When Dems lose like this, we spend a lot of time trying to understand GOP voters, so we can meet them where they are and maybe recalibrate where we missed, but do we ever stop to understand progressives? Here’s a take on progressives from a Xennial white guy in Southern California:
Progressives care deeply about rights—not just ours, but everyone’s. And since we know that all sides are motivated by fear, the fear that drives most progressives is the fear of losing those rights. Rights feel fundamental and we might take for granted that they’ll always be here, but for most of U.S. history, they weren’t universal. Black people were once considered property, women couldn’t vote, and until surprisingly recently, some basic things like opening a bank account required your husband’s approval.
The fear that motivates us? Waking up one day and seeing rights stripped away, making people unequal again, regressing. Moving backwards. Humans have this amazing capacity to put ourselves in others’ shoes. Imagine what it feels like to be told you don’t belong, can’t live where you do, love who you love or practice your faith. It’s a fear rooted in empathy and well-documented history.
That’s why the words matter. When a leader speaks, we listen for signals—subtle or loud—that they may strip rights away if they take power and get the chance. It triggers us, to use a word from a popular children’s book, because we know how fragile rights are and how quickly history can repeat.
If those words seem like a joke to you, like we shouldn’t take them seriously, then try understand that they are serious to us. Their purpose is to trigger, to scare. To stoke fear and anger. Even if they weren’t meant to be taken literally, it’s still what bullies do, not leaders.
So, if you see progressives sounding the alarm about authoritarianism and supremacy, know this: it’s not about partisanship. It’s about protecting the right to exist.