over the last 6 months i've been thinking a lot about the expectations we place upon celebrities to take part in activism; i think the best we can do is praise every "small good" and to condemn every "big bad"
i believe praising musicians and actors etc for making small good actions—such as praising Macklemore, The Weeknd, and Coldplay for actively educating themselves, speaking up for Palestine, and donating money to Palestinian fundraisers and charities—will encourage others to speak up, and hopefully pave the way for bigger and bigger action toward freeing Palestine
while it is obviously important to condemn people who actively and publicly support a genocidal state (a "big bad"), if we performatively condemn the "small bad" actions of a pro-Palestinian person with the same severity as we would treat an ex-IDF soldier, then we will turn celebrities away from engaging in activism at all.
e.g. an artist wearing a pro-Palestinian pin only to be lambasted for drinking a Starbucks coffee, a company that isn't on the BDS list and was only mentioned in the same breath as israel because the company sued its union for using the Starbucks logo in a letter speaking out against the zionist state. starbucks is very anti-union and has employed union-busting techniques like this in the past, but it hasn't had a store in Israel since 2001 and not a cent of the company's money is sent there, aside from money any zionist starbucks employee might send their of their own volition. i don't drink at Starbucks because it's anti-union, but to boycott it because of Palestine is performative and useless
praising "small good" actions is also more productive than condemning celebrities who haven't spoken out at all; a lot of these people could have spoken up by now if they'd wanted to, and focusing so much time and energy shouting at celebrities who just aren't interested or willing to listen is a waste of your time as an activist. you are effectively doing nothing, and it's better to actively do some small good than to actively do nothing. who knows, maybe praising people who do some good will convince others to forgo their silence, but you'll spin the wheels of the movement if you focus only on the silent
regardless, the actions of celebrities should only be a very small part of your activism; while it's great when celebrities speak out and we should encourage it, the actions and words of celebrities should not be the be-all and end-all of your focus as an activist. far too many of you only seem interested in Palestine as a trump card in "stan war" bullshit, where you hold a checklist of tenuous perceived wrongs above an artist's head which you can use to "win arguments" with stans of that artist. you are wasting your time and everyone else's time, and you don't genuinely care about genocide, you only care about how the image of an artist impacts the image of a stan of that artist and what that means for you
when it comes to overcoming a genocidal state we can't be puritanical about who we have on our "team". some people will do good and bad, and ultimately the good they do is more important for the movement as a whole. if we spend all our time criticising the small bad actions of people who are trying to do good, then we ourselves are doing no good for Palestine and are only trying to make ourselves look good. it's a waste of time that could be spent actually doing good on a grassroots level, where all successful movements start. praise small good, condemn big bad. Free Palestine