Forgive the repetitive messaging, but I want to reach as many folks as possible with the news that I can no longer justify staying on this platform. I'm now posting on Bluesky (bsky.app/profile/alfiekohn.bsky.social) and Mastodon (sciences.social/@alfiekohn). See you at one of those sites, I hope!
Alfie Kohn
Alfie Kohn (born October 15, 1957) is an American author and lecturer in the areas of education, parenting, and human behavior. He is a proponent of progressive education and has offered critiques of many traditional aspects of parenting, managing, and American society more generally, drawing in each case from social science research. More on Wikipedia
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Forgive the repetitive messaging, but I want to reach as many folks as possible with the news that I can no longer justify staying on this platform. I'm now posting on Bluesky (bsky.app/profile/alfiekohn.bsky.social) and Mastodon (sciences.social/@alfiekohn). See you at one of those sites, I hope!
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
This article was one of many final straws for me: newrepublic.com/article/188156/liberals-dump-musk-leave-t…. I'm still posting on education, parenting, & human behavior - but not on this site. You'll find me - and I hope you'll join me - at Mastodon (sciences.social/@alfiekohn) or Bluesky (bsky.app/profile/alfiekohn.bsky.social).
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Piling on...: www.truthdig.com/articles/the-case-for-abandoning-x/.
See you on Bluesky or Mastodon! -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
My conscience finally caught up with me. I can no longer justify supporting this Trump/Musk platform by posting on it. Please find me either at Mastodon (sciences.social/@alfiekohn) or Bluesky (bsky.app/profile/alfiekohn.bsky.social). And maybe ask your followers to join you on one of those sites!
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Friends, I've spent the last two years rationalizing that if we reasonable people huddle together over in this corner, we can ignore the fact that we're on a far-right propaganda platform.
But I can't do it any more, especially with the Trump-Musk regime preparing to take power.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
After 15 years, I can no longer justify staying here. Instead, I invite you to find me at Mastodon (sciences.social/@alfiekohn) or Bluesky (bsky.app/profile/alfiekohn.bsky.social), where I'll be posting with a clear conscience.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
If you share the concerns that finally led me - and, just in the last week or so, a wave of other educators, scholars, journalists, scientists, etc. - to stop supporting this site, I hope you'll consider making a similar announcement to your followers. See you on the other side!
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Someone going to start collecting these?
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
OK, maybe *I'm* going to collect them...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Fine. Since you insist, here's one more.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I'm guessing he plans to send Putin a gift basket
Matt McDermott
@mattmfm
Pretty wild that we just went through an election where a top foreign adversary aggressively tried to stop Democrats from voting — including calling in bomb threats to swing state polling locations — and there’s zero media interest in learning what Trump plans to do about that.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/5
Having read umpteen contradictory takes on Why Americans Supported Trump and What Harris Should Have Done, allow me to offer a few observations that argue for some humility:
A. One third of eligible voters stayed home. The electorate ≠the populace.Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/5
...when Trump does what he promised: when jobs done by immigrants go unfilled, tariffs prove massively inflationary, abortion (including medical) is outlawed nationwide, deregulation leads to more epidemics and food contamination, etc., etc.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
5/5
But how many Republicans will (1) wake up and angrily vote out the scoundrels (assuming that's still possible), (2) simply refuse to admit what and who caused these things, or (3) willingly put up with misery as long as life is even worse for nonwhite and LGBTQ people? -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Democratic erosion happens when pol. leaders gain enough control over parties & other institutions to neuter their restraining force but leave them intact enough, at least for awhile, to keep the opposition playing by the rules." Read esp. the last sec'n: www.nytimes.com/2024/10/29/magazine/democracy-elections-g…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
*sigh* Good thing I ordered an extra one of these in 2016
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Notice the ratio of news stories about the potential impact of Trump's victory on inflation and the deficit vs. the peril it poses to the very existence of immigrants and trans folks ... or to the survival of the rule of law and fair elections.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Summaries of what just happened by the NYT and the Onion
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Sondheim would like a word
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Huh.
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Ron Filipkowski
@RonFilipkowski
Now we face a challenge that other countries have faced in their history but we have not - a govt in the hands of an authoritarian madman & right-wing henchmen determined to dismantle our institutions, rule of law, constitutional norms, alliances, health care, economy & culture.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/5
We feared they would try to subvert the election. It's worse: They didn't need to.
We asked how, given his obvious unfitness & fascism, the election could be close. But it wasn't even close.
We deplored the injustice of the electoral college. But he won the popular vote, too.Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
5/5
I grieve particularly for our children, partly because the climate emergency will now escalate unchecked, but also because of what their country has become.
When you're ready to think about practical responses for resistance, here's a first pass: wagingnonviolence.org/2024/11/10-things-to-do-if-trump-wins/
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Maybe you already figured this out, but what just happened wasn't the kind of terrible event where we eventually recover from the shock, put the grief behind us, and get on with our lives. It was an announcement of unrelenting horrors ahead. We need to prepare for what's coming.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
It strains my imaginative capacities to the breaking point to understand how any woman - or even anyone who loves a woman - could consider voting for this malignant misogynist.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Qasim Rashid, Esq.
@QasimRashid
Watching MAGAs panic at the thought that women might vote opposite their husbands reminds me that after no fault divorce was legalized in 1970, female suicide rates dropped 20%
The "strong 1950s family unit" that GOP is nostalgic about ignores record high female suicide, suffocating DV, & 0 female financial autonomy.
GOP was always about control of women, and nothing about that has changed today.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
After I posted about my inability to understand how the sleazy guy who brags about abusing women could actually be favored over his (female) opponent by a majority of white women, I stumbled on this answer:
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Most Americans have only ever lived in a world where democracy was secure, where democracy was assumed. On Tuesday, we'll decide if we want to stay in that world or leave it behind." [more below]
- Jamelle Bouie (www.nytimes.com/2024/11/01/opinion/donald-trump-kamala-ha…) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I'll leave it to people who know a lot more about theology than I do to explain why this guy is the overwhelming favorite of -- indeed, revered as a cult figure by -- evangelical Christians.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
This alone should convince those w/concerns about KH to vote for her anyway: Trump wd not only end 100+ env. protectns but "dismantle the legal & scientific foundatns of the fed govt’s authority to regulate the environment, particularly on climate change": www.nytimes.com/2024/11/01/climate/trump-environment-elec…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The late Martin Haberman observed that the students most of us teach best - and the ones that selective schools are most eager to admit - are those who need us least.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
We'll be fine just as long as people devote as much effort to protect our country from an authoritarian cult as they did to create crazily elaborate Halloween lawn displays.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
From Barbara Kingsolver's novel Demon Copperhead, this observation about the rural poor of Appalachia: "Certain pitiful souls around here see whiteness as their last asset that hasn't been totaled or repossessed."
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
From Gary Shteyngart's novel Lake Success: Hard-scrabble, casually racist MAGA guys "had so little, but they would give up some of that 'little' to make sure [people of color] had less." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Three headlines and a cartoon
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Eli Cook
@Eli_B_Cook
Recent poll in Israel showed that 66% want Trump to win, 17% want Harris.
By 2020 results, this makes Israel Trumpier than:
Mississippi (57.5%)
Louisiana (58.5%)
South Dakota (61.8%)
Idaho (64%)
North Dakota (65.1%)
Oklahoma (65.4%)
Only West Virginia is more MAGA than Israel! -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Cartoon just published in Austria
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
100 MAGA lawsuits already filed to dispute the results if Trump loses. "The greatest threat to election integrity comes from Republicans who say they are concerned about election integrity." And there are loads of them - in Congress & swing-st. legisltrs: www.nytimes.com/2024/10/22/us/politics/election-2024-deni…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
A friend who somehow got on the Trump campaign mailing list couldn't believe anyone would fall for the absurdly condescending appeals promising to make each donor an Official MVP [Most Valuable Patriot].
Years ago, Continental Airlines introduced a little red rug that only...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
...elite members of their frequent flyer program could walk on when boarding their plane. I snorted when I saw this, figuring it would be gone in a week and rank as an all-time classic corporate debacle. Nope. It was so popular that every other airline quickly followed suit. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
I realized today that I've been struggling to reconcile a painful internal rift. On the one hand, I really want to reach across the divide, understand rather than condemn, figure out how to live peaceably with people who see things very differently than I do.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
But I also believe we must mobilize to defeat this reactionary force - characterized by breathtaking cruelty, depravity, & religious zealotry - a movement that invents its own warped reality, terrorizes those who are vulnerable, and is bent on uprooting Enlightenment values. -
Alfie Kohn reposted
Will Stancil
@whstancil
The Trump-Musk economic pitch of "we'll cause a depression but then afterwards everything will be better" is because they see the existence of nonwhite people as the fundamental problem with America. The solution is a bloody purge, after which a golden age will magically occur
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Mammas Don't Let Your Babies Grow Up to Be Elons
(Your periodic reminder that that it’s possible to be rich and famous without being a successful human being by any meaningful psychological or moral standard.)
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Lest you think the problem is limited to him and his site, though...
www.wired.com/story/facebook-militia-organizing-election/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Do you know people whose outrage over the Israeli slaughter of Palestinian civilians has led them to consider not voting for Harris (thereby making it more likely that Trump will win)? Consider sending them this 6-min. Bernie Sanders video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vf5MThSniiY
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I've written about doing good things for bad reasons in education: www.alfiekohn.org/article/do-this/. Here's a corporate analog: Companies support DEI not b/c it's right but just b/c it'll provide good P.R. So guess what happens when the right-wingers attack them? www.nytimes.com/2024/10/26/business/dealbook/dei-backlash…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
B-b-but if that's true, wouldn't it mean that all the advisers and pundits who have successfully persuaded Biden & Harris to redefine themselves as "tough on borders" are just getting them to endorse a slightly milder version of MAGA racism?
Mikel Jollett
@Mikel_Jollett
BOTH of these people were undocumented immigrants.
But Republicans don't care because they are white.
It has never been about "immigration." It has always been about skin color. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The '50s Red Scare allowed conservatives to attack liberal initiatives in the name of fighting Communism, though they did see the USSR "as a dystopian cautionary tale." Today, their counterparts cheer "the oppressive tactics of illiberal societies abroad": www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2024/11/texas-red-st…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Those bent on whitewashing history, banning LGBTQ-friendly literature, and otherwise imposing reactionary values know that a little intimidation goes a long way because educators then get busy "self-censoring, well beyond the most controversial books": slate.com/life/2024/09/banned-books-week-schools-censorsh…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Anticipatory obedience is a political tragedy."
- Timothy Snyder
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Speaking of self-censorship, this warning by Timothy Snyder also applies to newspaper owners afraid of antagonizing - and thereby acting as enablers of - an incoming vindictive authoritarian.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Another example: The new Trump biopic "The Apprentice" almost didn't get released because all the movie studios were afraid of angering Trump. "You don't think that will ever happen here," co-star Jeremy Strong told the NYT. "It's a dark harbinger that it even nearly happened."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Observation: Innocuous activities can sometimes expose an unexpected capacity for darkness in apparently lovely people. For example, gardening seems to transform perfectly pleasant folks into vicious bunny haters.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"So how would you rate this applicant on a scale of 1 to Donald?"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Aes🇺🇸
@AesPolitics1
I will never blame Kamala Harris for what Israel is doing to Gaza when Netanyahu has been in direct talks with Trump about not ending the war.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Domo Julio
@DapperDomo
To those who ask me how I can say free Palestine but still vote for Kamala.
My answer in short: -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
New research confirms that children are more likely to chase extrinsic goals like wealth & fame if they see their parents doing that: selfdeterminationtheory.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/20…. Our job is to warn kids about becoming addicted to A’s, dollars, & trophies, not to serve as enablers of those addictions
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Exactly right. And the chilling key phrase here is "mainstream Republican." Frank calls to install an authoritarian regardless of the election results - or to suppress the vote, or treat a Dem victory as illegitimate, per se - are no longer confined to neoNazis on the dark web.
Chris Murphy 🟧
@ChrisMurphyCT
It’s really important to understand the mainstream Republican goal - to make Donald Trump President whether or not he wins the election.
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Ryan Moulton
@moultano
Seeing big national newspapers decline to make a presidential endorsement because they don't want to risk Trump's retaliation if he wins is really dark. That's not something I ever expected to see in the United States.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Current events at the LA Times & WaPo remind us that many journalists are liberal but the people who own the papers? Not so much.
In 1972, the Cox chain forced its editors to endorse Nixon. One resigned; one took his name off the masthead & was fired.
@davidfolkenflik @Sulliview -
Alfie Kohn reposted
Jaime Harrison
@harrisonjaime
Yet another example of why Trump would be a Fascist dictator on Day 1.
Republicans in Congress are Feckless… they would stand on the sidelines and watch Trump do whatever he wants to undermine the constitution and the Rule of Law.
This is the #3 Republican in the House and he can’t find the words to condemn Trump’s praise for Hitler’s generals. If you are scared for our nation, you should be!
We need @KamalaHarris & @hakeemjeffries -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Buried in a study about child aggression is an interesting finding (that's confirmed by other research, incidentally): Narcissism is more likely to result from lack of parental warmth than from parental permissiveness: psycnet.apa.org/psycinfo/2015-13131-001/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
233 mental health experts: Trump's psychopathology is dangerous: www.psychopac.org/open-letter/.
23 Nobel economists: His agenda -->"higher prices, larger deficits, greater inequality”: www.cnbc.com/2024/10/23/nobel-prize-winning-economists-do….
Too bad MAGA is rooted in contempt for expertise (cf. publ health measures). -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The more truth there is in this observation, the more disheartening it is to acknowledge how many millions of Americans we're talking about here
Elie Mystal
@ElieNYC
Yup. I do not understand how nine years into this people still don’t get that Trump’s vileness is the thing that attracts the collection of racists and misogynists who have flocked to his banner.
The awful people feel Trump VALIDATES their awfulness.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Morning Joe
@Morning_Joe
.@AnandWrites: "It doesn't so much matter that Donald Trump is selling fascism. What really matters is that roughly half of Americans, including a clear majority of American men, are buying it." www.youtube.com/watch?v=zroZztr1bn4
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
More white women say they plan to vote for a guy who was found guilty of (and bragged about) sexual assault than for Harris.
This reminds me of a cross-cultural study showing that more women than men defend the practice of husbands hitting their wives: pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7508888/
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
BTW, that same study (of low- & middle-income countries) turned up a high correlation between support for wife-beating and for corporal punishment of children. This may be a useful reality check for those who find one of those practices appalling and the other one justified. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A researcher who discovered that the benefits of academically oriented pre-K classrooms quickly fade and even turn negative explains in simple language how that happens. Why a "scripted, academically focused curriculum" for young children makes no sense: dey.org/early-developmental-competencies-or-why-pre-k-doe…
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Jeff Alexander
@mgiant
One player will either win or lose and another player will either win or flip the table and pull a gun
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Beyond depressing that their polling indicates a contemptible attack on trans people will appeal to undecided voters, not just the religious bigots who comprise his base: www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2024/10/22/trump-republic…. Then again his numbers are actually ticking up as he melts down & goes full fascist.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From the archives: “What Parents Aren’t Asked in School Surveys - and Why.” How do conservative premises determine the questions that are (and aren't) asked about educational experiences? And what would a less-biased survey about, say, homework, look like? www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/parents-arent-asked-school-surveys/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Of all the risks posed by a second Trump term, this might be one of the most terrifying": www.theatlantic.com/books/archive/2024/10/donald-trump-is…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Huge new studies conducted in 30+ countries show compelling evidence of the psychological correlates of political beliefs. People inclined to exploit others (& to rationalize this w/ beliefs about inequality & need for dominance) are more often right-wing: psycnet.apa.org/record/2024-74059-001
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The giant PBMs are killing off local pharmacies: www.nytimes.com/2024/10/19/business/drugstores-closing-pb…. As someone who tries to patronize local shops (rather than Amazon), it took me much too long to switch my prescription from a giant drugstore chain to a neighborhood pharmacy, but I'm glad I finally did so.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
You know how some people are convinced that everything happens for a reason, that the universe is a sentient entity that cares about them personally? Maybe this is because, long ago, they misheard the lyrics to that Burt Bachrach song:
You see the sky?
The sky's in love with you. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Some blue staters act as if everyone in red states supports the right-wing policies in effect there & deserves what happens to them. So suppose Trump/Vance win & the authoritarian nightmare they promised begins. I imagine a European thinking, "Well, that's what they voted for..."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Learning should be seen as a qualitative change in a person's way of seeing, experiencing, understanding, conceptualizing something in the real world - rather than as a quantitative change in the amount of knowledge someone possesses."
-Paul Ramsden (Australian educator) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
And here's how he's spending his tens of millions...
Will Stancil
@whstancil
I don't think people realize the extent to which Elon Musk has taken over the entire election. Journalists have not caught up yet. Seemingly the ENTIRE field AND advertising operation of the GOP across many races and states is currently Musk-funded.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Rhetorical question: What does it say about this country that all three of these things can be true simultaneously?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Thomas Gordon: Parents who constantly criticize what their kids do or say "foster in these children a deep feeling that they are unacceptable as persons.”
That doesn’t change just because the parents say soothingly, “Oh, we love YOU, honey; we just hate almost everything you DO.” -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
cc Jack Smith
Ron Filipkowski
@RonFilipkowski
He says: “We didn’t have guns, the others had guns” on J6.
So “we” is Donald Trump and his insurrectionist mob.
“The others” is the police.
This was the President of the United States. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Prof. Lorrie Shepard, one of our leading assessment experts, summarizes the research on the effects of NCLB and observes that frequent state testing makes it impossible to assess (and thus promote) more meaningful learning.
See her answers to Qs 2 & 3: www.icontact-archive.com/archive?c=1748247&f=3100&s=3172&… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
We talk about "patriarchy," but this is the real thing: Christian nationalist bros with no use for democracy who think women's job is to defer to men & reproduce. Truly frightening: their influence on the guy who may well become VP - & therefore president: www.motherjones.com/politics/2024/09/theobros-jd-vance-ch…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"We want to fill our culture again with the Christian spirit, to burn out all the recent immoral development in...the arts & in the press...the poison of immorality which has entered into our whole life & culture as a result of liberal excess."
(Oh, wait. That was Hitler - 1933.) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
When students are bullied, the perpetrators aren't always other students: archive.learningforjustice.org/magazine/spring-2018/stati…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Read about the GOP's despicable anti-trans ads airing nonstop in swing states. Then read this study of trans kids being bullied: www.nytimes.com/2024/10/08/health/transgender-teenagers-c….
Talking about the latter w/o mentioning religious conservativism is like covering megahurricanes w/o mentioning fossil fuels. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Placing more emphasis on students' explanations requires teachers to relinquish some control over a lesson's direction. This can be a frightening prospect to a teacher who is unprepared to evaluate the validity of a novel idea that students propose."
-JW Stigler & HW Stevenson -
Alfie Kohn reposted
(((DeanObeidallah)))
@DeanObeidallah
Trump vowing this weekend to use US military to silence Democrats is the latest example of Trump embracing fascism. Most alarming part is if Trump were elected and did this, his base would cheer as Trump's forces beat or killed us. Please understand that www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/trump-suggests-hell-use-the…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Stanford study: Over the long term, bilingual / dual-immersion programs are more successful than English immersion for ELLs: storage.googleapis.com/gse-website-archive/cepa/cepa.stan…
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
NYTPitchbot
@DougJBalloon
Fascism has been on the rise in the United States as never before over the past eight years. Here is why we spent those eight years mostly writing articles about the dangers of wokeness at American universities.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Please rate us, review us, like us, friend us, bookmark us, retweet us, subscribe to our channel, sign up for our newsletter, listen to our podcast, and download our app so we can monitor your thoughts about us.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/4
What haunts me isn't just the terror that he might win, which means we wake up in a very different country. It's that the "oddly tinted compilation of psychiatric symptoms," as one commentator described him, is still - still! - viewed favorably by 43% of our fellow citizens.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
x.com/svdate/status/1845272844923441577.
I share liberal Twitter's outrage at the NYT et al. for consistently both-sidesing & euphemizing Trump. They should bluntly call out his fascism & racism. But would that change the race or does everyone already know? Half the country likes what it hears.
S.V. Dáte
@svdate
He's just openly talking Nazi talk now and 45-47 pct of the country is thinking, huh, he's making some good points.
Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/4
The GOP is now getting traction with repulsive anti-trans ads and hair-raising calls to round up immigrants. Why don't the Dems just denounce these obscenities? Because too many voters agree.
Even if we're spared the worst on Nov. 5, this is the country we live in now.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I no sooner hit "send" on that thread than I saw this piece, which I encourage you to read in its entirety, about the "dark, fictious world" in which so many Trump supporters live. It's one in which a democracy cannot survive: www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2024/10/hurricane-…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Chrome is about to start prohibiting some adblockers and privacy-protecting plugins. More reason to switch to another browser: www.techradar.com/pro/your-privacy-on-chrome-is-at-risk-h…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In some families (and perhaps cultures), parents conspicuously sacrifice everything for the child. But look closer: It's all to make the child a success in conventional terms so the parent looks good, not to meet the child's needs. The result can be psychologically debilitating.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
If you need me, I'll be in the library, moving Margaret Atwood's books to the nonfiction section
Jessica Valenti
@JessicaValenti
Please note that this football player was arrested for assaulting a fetus, not the woman carrying it.
I don't even know what to say anymore.
apnews.com/article/georgia-colbie-young-arrest-a7c7a5b9d7… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Sympathy for poor Floridians: They haven't even finished cleaning up from the devastation of Hurricane Chevron and now are about to be battered by Hurricane ExxonMobil.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In case, even for a second, you thought that maybe the MAGA folks who invoke "free speech" to defend their dangerous misinformation, hate, and incitements to violence were really committed to that principle across the board: www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/oct/09/republicans-crack…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"An outcome confirmed in hundreds of studies: students gain a much deeper understanding of science when they actively grapple with...questions than when they passively listen to answers": www.nature.com/articles/523272a
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
It's hardly news that Trump lies constantly. But now the entire GOP seems to be defined by a project of spewing ever more outrageous & dangerous falsehoods; it's central to their mission of locking down power even though most people oppose their policies: www.vanityfair.com/news/story/lying-is-loyalty-in-trumps-gop
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
An English teacher quoted in The Atlantic disputes its claim that kids can't read full books: They're "eminently capable of critically engaging in long form content, but are rightfully demanding a seat at the table where decisions about texts are made": cmsthomas.substack.com/p/the-atlantic-did-me-dirty
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Just embarrassing: Ed Week asks tchrs if kids in general are better or worse at something than 10 yrs ago. No data from back then. Then, based on the predictable result - most folks always insist things were better in the old days - it's published as fact: www.edweek.org/leadership/kids-are-getting-worse-at-makin…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Contrary to the media's framing of this sad anniversary, Oct. 7 was neither a beginning nor a cause but a deadly reaction to a 50+-year brutal, illegal occupation: www.nytimes.com/2023/11/14/opinion/israel-gaza-war-histor…. Just in the year before 10/7/23, Israel killed ~300 Palestinians: www.ochaopt.org/data/casualties
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Odd how the NYT headline writers always seem to forget this detail
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Bill Kristol
@BillKristol
I think I saw the dangers of demagogic populist nativism, bigotry, and grievance-mongering pretty early on.
I didn't focus enough on the extent to which oligarchic arrogance and entitlement would eagerly join forces with populist demagoguery in the assault on liberal democracy. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I'm not saying this guy I met an academic symposium is pretentious, but he refers to NPR's late-afternoon news program as "Ceteris Paribus."
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Lisa Snowden
@LisaESnowden
We don’t talk enough about the illegal immigrants who got here in the 1600s and almost immediately started human trafficking
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Study: Unlike citations based on traffic cameras, police ticketed Black drivers for speeding at a far higher rate than their representation among drivers on the road. Of course those data were collected way back when police racism was rampant, in...2020: www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2402547121
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Just Bill
@WilliamAder
Boss: Your quarterly report is riddled with errors.
Me: I was told there would be no fact checking. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The parents I really admire are those willing to keep asking themselves this question: "Is it possible that what I just did with my kids had more to do with my needs, my fears, and my own upbringing than with what’s really in their best interest?"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Some of the despicable lies and far-right conspiracies steadily emitted by this site's owner: www.nytimes.com/2024/09/27/technology/elon-musk-x-posts.h….
BTW, I cross-post daily on Mastodon: @alfiekohn@sciences.social. If a good share of folks here who share my interests moved there, I'd gladly become an ex-X'er. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 Numerical RATINGS are often misleading and counterproductive, but RANKINGS *never* make sense
because relative status is just about victory, not excellence. Now, new research shows that ranking in general leads to irrational decisions: psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037%2Fpspa0000289
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2 ...And it's really stupid to rank
* countries' ed. systems (see screenshot)
* high schls, esp. based on AP courses: www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2013/05/why-high-sch…
* students within a schl: www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/class-rank/
* colleges, as by USNWR: www.newyorker.com/magazine/2011/02/14/the-order-of-things
* hospitals: jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2786983 -
Alfie Kohn reposted
Matthew Gertz
@MattGertz
Pence is out and Vance is in because Pence defended the constitutional order and Vance would make a different choice.
Sam Stein
@samstein
A sampling of the pleas and persuasions Pence made to Trump to get him to acknowledge the truth of his election loss, from Jack Smith's new motion
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Another effect of relentless positivity: Even holding political beliefs constant, people keen to avoid negative feelings at all costs - "No conversations, books, or movies with any unpleasantness, please!" - are less likely to acknowledge systemic racism: psycnet.apa.org/record/2024-70752-001?doi=1
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Perpetual petulance: Does Vance's endless griping, like Trump's, just issue from his psychologically foundational self-pity, or does a campaign based on grievance represent a calculated strategy?
Interesting read: www.salon.com/2024/10/01/jd-vance-isnt-just-thin-skinned-… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
I keep reminding myself that no evidence showing that immigrants commit fewer crimes than the US-born will ever persuade racist xenophobes, just as no proof that a Democrat won an election will convince those who view progressive or nonwhite votes as inherently illegitimate.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
Here's an essay I wrote about how the same thing is true regarding certain beliefs about education and parenting: What may be presented as factual or predictive claims are often driven by ideology and thus cannot be dislodged with evidence: www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/unfalsifiable/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Today's tip for managers: "Doing performance evaluations well is like doing blood-letting well": goo.gl/R9C29x.
For more on this topic: www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1576752003/wwwalfiekohorg and www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0070580286/wwwalfiekohorg -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Dehumanizing the people they've displaced & colonized allows Israelis to murder them by the thousands - even while insisting that they themselves are (by definition) the real victims, no matter how blatant a distortion of reality & morality this requires: www.nytimes.com/2024/09/25/world/middleeast/west-bank-rai…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Never underestimate the durability of a demagogue with a captive base, a desperate will to keep going, and -perhaps most of all - a feeble & terrified opposition of spineless ciphers..."
Gift link to a remarkable account of Trump critics-turned-toadies: www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2024/10/trump-gop-su… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Why, as Lillian Weber once put it, do most kids "begin school as an exclamation point and a question mark [but then] leave as a plain period"?
My new Ed. Week commentary: "Less and Less Curious": www.alfiekohn.org/article/curiosity -
Alfie Kohn reposted
Alex Cole
@acnewsitics
Hello, President Biden, it's Ron! May I please have some socialism?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Just received another "Hey, our company discovered a 'data security incident' that compromised your information, but we'll salve our institutional guilt feelings by giving you a subscription to a credit monitoring service" letter. That's the second one this week alone.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Each fall since the '90s, I've written a commentary for Education Week's back page. This year's, just out, asks: If curiosity is so widely valued, why do so many classrooms almost seem designed to snuff it out?
"Less and Less Curious": www.alfiekohn.org/article/curiosity -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
According to a consortium of schools, U.S. News & World Report is now only the country's 4,879th best magazine.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Conservative columnist David French: Over the last 9 years, Republican voters "have moved from voting for Trump in spite of his transgressions to rejecting anyone who doesn't transgress. If you're not transgressive, you're suspicious. Decency...is seen as a rebuke of Trump."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Like other forms of control, the use of punishment often enrages whoever is on the receiving end. What history teaches us about nations echoes what psychology teaches us about individuals: Given a chance, those who feel like victims may eventually become victimizers.
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Laurence Tribe 🇺🇦 ⚖️
@tribelaw
The rabid “Send Them Back” chants Trump leads at his political rallies are sickening, unAmerican, downright disgraceful. He’s talking about people who are here legally. Raw racism. It’s Hitlerian. If you don’t vote for Harris, this is exactly what you’re enabling.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Somehow I find it kind of reassuring that people with such repellent political views so often turn out to be deeply unpleasant and unethical human beings as well (and vice versa).
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Exhibit B: www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/sep/24/project-2025-kevi…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
What does deep-thinking, inquiry-based learning look like in a (diverse) high schl? Show this ½-hr video about Urban Academy at a faculty meeting or prof dev session to help teachers in all subject areas move beyond pouring facts into passive students: vimeo.com/590281072
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
...And here are two more about the same school:
* "Looking for an Argument?" (social studies): vimeo.com/453359582
* "Back to the Books" (sparking a love of reading): www.youtube.com/watch?v=risQepkvyo4.
The contrast with traditional high school teaching in all 3 is breathtaking. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Today's "Doonesbury"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I don't know what thoughts drift into your brain at dawn, but I woke up this morning wondering when someone is going to publish a takedown of the hot-tub industry called "J'Accusi...!"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Apart from what it says about us that the election could be so close, notice the kinds of developments that are tilting it one way vs. the other.
Toward her: strong debate performance, Taylor Swift's endorsement, etc
Toward him: stuff like this (www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/sep/18/trump-election-ge…) and this:
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Similar divergence with abortion-rights measures that are coming up for a vote:
Proponents try to prevail by offering substantive arguments in favor.
Opponents use the power of the state "to keep these measures off the ballot or make them hard to pass" (per the NYT). -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I propose an update of Aristophanes' “Lysistrata” in which the appalled spouses and lovers of those planning to vote for Trump make it clear what the domestic cost will be.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
One requirement of good parenting is that, when you're at the end of your rope, you must somehow produce more rope.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
If you encounter a teacher or parent whose actions make you wince, perhaps you should say to yourself: "Wow, here's someone who has a lot to teach me...about how *not* to treat kids."
From the archives: “The Value of Negative Learning": www.alfiekohn.org/article/value-negative-learning/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Adam Serwer, always worth reading, puts the Trump/Vance racist lies about Haitian immigrants in perspective: www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/09/trumps-campaign…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Today's quiz: What does the deadly Boar's Head listeria outbreak share with last year's Silicon Valley Bank failure (www.theguardian.com/business/2023/mar/11/silicon-valley-b…)? And Norfolk Southern's train derailment (news.climate.columbia.edu/2023/02/20/the-ohio-toxic-train…)? And the Boeing 737 Max crashes (www.brookings.edu/articles/boeing-crisis-illustrates-risk…)?
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
...Oh, and also with Enron, Volkswagen, BP, Equifax, Takata....?
Imagine a world where media coverage of each such event explained the connection to deregulation and the underlying Reaganite "government bad, free enterprise good" premise. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A new, very large meta-analysis confirms the harmful effects across cultures of parental psychological control (use of guilt, threats, love withdrawal, conditional affection) as well as the benefits of supporting kids' autonomy: selfdeterminationtheory.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/20…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The late James Moffett suggested this slogan for elite, selective schools: "Send us winners and we'll make winners out of them!"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
As a boy, the psychoanalyst Erich Fromm recalled, "whenever someone told me he was a businessman I always felt a little embarrassed. I'd think: God, he must feel awful having to admit that he's not doing anything else with his life except earning money."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Conservatives who dismissed Harris as an idiot can't admit they were wrong b/c that would show why DEI efforts are necessary: "Plainly competent people are often wrongly assumed to be stupid b/c they're not white men, & denied opportunities as a result": www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/09/real-dei-candid…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Apparently the publisher of the audio version of my book Punished by Rewards is selling it for half its usual price until Oct. 11. And, no, that's not because they deleted every other word (although some of my magazine articles have been edited that way).
www.audiobooks.com/promotions/promotedBook/615911/punishe… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In case anyone who cares about evidence doesn't already know this: A new study proves that the reason firearm deaths (notably suicide) are so much higher in the U.S. than in other countries is the prevalence of guns here, not more mental health problems: journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.po…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Other signs of his pathology are obvious, but his exaggerated dichotomous worldview - no nuance; everything is either "like nobody has ever seen before" or "the worst in history" - is empirically associated with narcissism, Machiavellianism, & psychopathy: www.researchgate.net/profile/Bruno-Bonfa-Araujo/publicati…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3
Shift from asking “How should we measure the performance of students/teachers/schools?” to “How should we ASSESS…?” The first verb locks us into one particular, highly problematic form of assessment: the kind that reduces complex phenomena (e.g., understanding) to numbers.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3
It’s like the difference between asking “Whose car should we take to the park today?” vs. “How should we get to the park today?” The former excludes the possibility of walking, biking, public transit, etc., committing us to a single (problematic) type of transportation.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3
For more, read Jim Nehring on how rich assessment is “a more nuanced but less precise enterprise [than measurement] involving evidence, intelligence, conversation, and judgment" (www.edweek.org/policy-politics/opinion-we-must-teach-for-…). Or my own essay “Schooling Beyond Measure”: www.alfiekohn.org/article/schooling-beyond-measure/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Can't stop thinking about this Onion headline:
"Poll Finds Most Americans Would Swap Democracy For $100 Best Buy Gift Card" -
Alfie Kohn reposted
KSV
@KSVesq
While many of us are laughing at how genuinely deranged Trump sounds tonight (and boy does he) I just cannot shake the deeply unsettling feeling of knowing that nearly half of our country thinks he is fit to do *any* job let alone run this country.
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Robert Reich
@RBReich
Trump picked J.D. Vance to be his vice president because Vance has publicly said he’d do what Mike Pence refused to do — overturn democracy to place America under MAGA control.
Republicans against Trump
@RpsAgainstTrump
Q. Would you have certified the 2020 election?
JD Vance: No. “I would have asked the states to submit alternative slates of electors and ask the country to have a debate”
Disqualifying -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Legal scholar Lawrence Douglas: "Our Constitution does not secure the peaceful transition of power, but rather presupposes it."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
How often does “Explain your answer"/"Show your work” in math assessments just ask students to recite an algorithm rather than demonstrating real understanding? For that matter, how much of what preceded the assessment involved constructing meaning rather than mere memorization?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
After yet another conference was called with a misbehaving student & his parents & school staff, a NYC educator asked the principal when they would stop with the meetings already and just give him a detention. His principal replied, "When we decide to give up on him."
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
I'm always delighted to talk with such administrators and teachers - those who realize that euphemisms like "holding the student accountable" or imposing a "consequence" are just rationalizations for punishment. And that punishments, like rewards, only make things worse. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
a double abomination
Lydia Polgreen
@lpolgreen
There is something so deeply sinister about this completely manufactured fantasy of kids being given transition surgeries at school at a time when kids are quite literally being murdered at school.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Picking up on powerful resentments, hopes, and fears, [strongmen] present themselves as the vehicle for obtaining what is most wanted: territory, safety from racial others, securing male authority, or payback for exploitation by internal or external enemies."
- @ruthbenghiat -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Pretend you just emerged from a cave and knew nothing about the Republican party - its policies or candidates. All you know about it is its dedication to making it as difficult as possible for people to vote. How much of the rest could you infer? www.nytimes.com/2024/09/04/us/texas-voter-registration-pa…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Ditching my rubrics freed me up to make the kind of comments that could most help my students."
And in the absence of a rubric, this teacher adds, she now finds herself reading her students essays with genuine "curiosity about what [they] had to say": medium.com/@profhurley/why-i-threw-away-my-rubrics-323e51… -
Alfie Kohn reposted
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
One of those weeks where I'm just in disbelief that this election will be a nail-biter. Trump is so manifestly unfit for any office that I cannot imagine voting for him if you're paying attention at all. There's no case for him that doesn't come from a place of hate & resentment
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/7
Just published by 2 British literacy experts: Yet another evidence-based resource that debunks the misrepresentations of the "science of reading" campaign (& offers detailed teaching strategies): The Balancing Act by Dominic Wyse & Charlotte Hacking: www.amazon.com/Balancing-Act-Evidence-Based-Approach-Teac…Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/7
I've just added that book to a newly updated list of 10 key resources for understanding just how misleading SOR propaganda really is, according to the best theory, research, and practice. The 1st nine are recent; the last is my own early overview of the topic. Please share!
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/7
* RJ Tierney & PD Pearson, Fact-Checking the Science of Reading ('24); literacyresearchcommons.org
* D Wyse & A Hacking, Balancing Act ('24): www.amazon.com/Balancing-Act-Evidence-Based-Approach-Teac…
* D Reinking et al., "Legislating Phonics: Settled Science or Political Polemics?" ('23): journals.sagepub.com/doi/epub/10.1177/01614681231155688Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
6/7
* S Krashen, "Beginning Reading" ('19): languagemagazine.com/2019/04/17/beginning-reading/
* D Wyse & A Bradbury, "Reading Wars or Reading Reconciliation?" ('22): bera-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/re…
* C Compton-Lilly et al., "Stories Grounded in Decades of Research" ('23): ila.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/trtr.2258
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
7/7
* M Aukerman, "The Science of Reading & the Media" (series of 3 blog posts, '22): literacyresearchassociation.org/stories/the-science-of-re…
* A Kohn, "On Teaching Reading..." ('99): www.alfiekohn.org/article/reading/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Vance may have a misogyny problem. But I worry a lot more about his empathy problem." I see the writer's point (www.washingtonpost.com/style/power/2024/09/04/jd-vance-wo…), but I'm inclined to linger a bit longer on how Vance and other MAGA men really seem to regard women as little more than portable incubators.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A little disconcerted to receive this request from Beacon Press, an independent progressive publisher that I've worked with on a couple of my books. Thoughts?
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Ron Filipkowski
@RonFilipkowski
Rep. Mike Collins, who represents the district where the school shooting happened today in GA, was asked in 2022 if he favored ANY gun laws including red flag laws. The answer is no, he said God is the answer.
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Carl Quintanilla
@carlquintanilla
“.. By choosing to amplify disinformation and misogynist views, Musk .. is promoting radical content to the masses that might otherwise languish in the darkest corners of the internet.”
@CNN $TSLA www.cnn.com/2024/09/03/media/elon-musk-x-kamala-harris-tr… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I was recently reminded that, when my proposal for a book about altruism and empathy was being circulated to publishers, one editor turned it down on the grounds that the project sounded "too well-meaning to be engaging."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A study finds that people age 51+ are more than twice as likely as those under 30 to have met at least one close friend at work.
"Whether or not you believe that 'virtual commuting' is good for productivity, it is demonstrably bad for community building": www.nytimes.com/2024/08/27/magazine/loneliness-epidemic-c… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Hotel workers are on strike this weekend across the country. Some years ago, during another such (widely publicized) strike, a newspaper account described a guest crossing the picket line and apologetically explaining to a reporter, "I'm a liberal, but we had reservations."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The invisibility of class privilege protects "the privileged by letting people deny the unearned nature of their advantages." Recent research: When presented with evidence of their privilege, people "claim to have suffered more personal life hardships": ltaylorphillips.com/publications/Phillips_Lowery_2020JPSP…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
When voucher supporters target public schools, they're weakening something that serves as an anchor of local communities. But that's part of their plan because a shared secular, democratic institution is a threat to their theocratic vision.
Josh Cowen
@joshcowenMI
I note in The Privateers that closing public schools as community anchors is the entire point of school vouchers.
Betsy DeVos is on record lamenting public schools as centers of community—she wants churches there instead.
www.politico.com/video/2016/12/the-devoses-lament-that-pu… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Day after day of Israel's systematic targeting of a civilian population. Those who respond to this with rationalization, deflection, or indifference - or who label as "pro-Hamas" anyone who bears witness to Israel's crimes against humanity - have utterly lost their moral compass.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Has anyone else noticed that Trump and the young, white registered Republican who tried to shoot him seem to have something in common? Both appear to be less motivated by political beliefs than by a desperate thirst for attention.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From the archives: "Poor Teaching for Poor Children...in the Name of Reform," published in 2011: www.alfiekohn.org/article/poor/. What, if anything, do you think has changed from what I described back then?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A light-bulb moment for me was realizing that much of the talk about student "motivation" (how to boost it or why a given kid lacks it) is really code for talking about compliance: the extent to which students do whatever they're told without question.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I catch myself thinking, "If we can just put Harris over the top, we'll be OK." But read this interview about the far right's threats of violence & how the Dems are reluctant to take this seriously because it "runs counter to the whole 'joy' narrative": prospect.org/2024/08/28/2024-08-28-election-story-nobody-…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From "Why Professors Can't Teach" (washingtonmonthly.com/2024/08/25/why-professors-cant-teach/): The most comprehensive (10-yr, 732 instructors) study of the quality of college teaching (by Corbin Campbell; hep.gse.harvard.edu/9781682537923/great-college-teaching/) found that regional st. univs. > flagship st. institutions > private research univs.
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Josh Cowen
@joshcowenMI
With vouchers causing some of the largest academic losses on record, right-wing billionaires have turned to culture wars to make the case instead.
Early coverage of The Privateers @ajc @AJCGetSchooled
www.ajc.com/education/get-schooled/conservative-billionai… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I guess this is what comes of a determination to avoid being woke: www.psypost.org/surprisingly-strong-link-found-between-po…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Having kids read at night is certainly better than assigning worksheets, but I've lost count of the number of parents who have told me,"My child used to love reading until the teacher started requiring the kids to read x minutes every night. Now it's become a chore."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The #newyorktimes has officially become a parody of itself.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Interesting: A new study finds that the extent to which kids are connected to nature is determined less by whether they live in the city vs. the country than by their socioeconomic status: www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2024/08/240823120052.htm
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Article Titles Aren't Attracting Enough Readers:
Do Subtitles With Inane, Noncommittal Questions Hold the Answer?" -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"The past was alterable. The past never had been altered."
- George Orwell, 1984 -
Alfie Kohn reposted
Bill Kristol
@BillKristol
The Trump-Kennedy Pact occurs on the 85th anniversary of the signing of the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact between the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I'm uneasy about betting everything on vibes and memes - and, specifically, a shift from solemn and accurate warnings about how Trump would end democracy to a campaign of eye rolls about how he's just tiresome, pathetic, old, and weird.
If that's what it takes, though...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
But I do think "We're Not Going Back" is a shrewd slogan. It not only says "No more Trump" but turns the right's foundational reactionary nostalgia (for the days when straight white Christian men were accorded uncontested power and privilege) on its head: thomaszimmer.substack.com/p/moralizing-nostalgia-leads-to…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
DNC vs. RNC
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Ever notice how antivaxxers, election denalists, & their ilk pride themselves on hard-bitten skepticism, seeing through the conventional wisdom & doing their own "research" - yet they credulously lap up the most fanciful, preposterous conspiracy theories? www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/skepticism/
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
An example of skepticism being co-opted: Bills filed in many Republican states are justified as promoting critical thinking but actually seem intended to undermine science by implying that "accepted scientific theories are nothing more than conjecture": theconversation.com/politicians-step-up-attacks-on-the-te…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A new, large longitudinal study finds that having your baby sleep with you appears not to cause any long-term psychological problems once other variables are taken into account: www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14616734.2024.2380427
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Thoughtful critique of the Cass report, which gives the imprimatur of science to "reactionaries' war on trans young people" even though its call for more evidence is selective and based on the value judgment that transitioning should be discouraged: www.nytimes.com/2024/08/13/opinion/cass-report-trans-kids…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Upton Sinclair couldn't afford college tuition, but he noticed a rule that students who failed a course received no credit for it and had to take another course in its place (for which there was no charge). Sinclair got a free education by deliberately failing all his courses.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Came across this while leafing through an anthology of writings by pre-Socratics & Sophists:
"Some people don't live the life they have but thoroughly occupy themselves with plans, as if they had another life to live. And meanwhile time passes them by."
-Antiphon
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Somewhat less impressive, however, are the ancient Greeks' insights about the natural world:
"The sun is as broad as a human foot."
-Heraclitus -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Call me a dreamer, but when I graduate from college I want to devote my time and talents to making very rich people even richer - and, with a little luck, leave the world just a little bit worse than I found it.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Update: The mass delusion known as QAnon hasn't disappeared so much as it's spawned and empowered other "groomer narratives," paranoid conspiracies, and hatemongering that, thanks to the Republican party, are no longer on the dark fringes: www.motherjones.com/politics/2024/06/how-q-became-everyth…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Watching "Hollywood Squares" as a kid, I laughed at contestants too dumb to understand how tic-tac-toe worked. But Peter Marshall (1926-2024) offered a model of kindness & encouragement that I still think about: "OK, I might've picked Rose Marie to block, but this may work out!"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Today's tip: Complain about getting older only to your peers. Those who are younger than you won't really understand; those who are older will be unsympathetic.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Deb Meier once remarked, “If we deliberately tried to come up with a way to widen the achievement gap, we might just invent homework.”
In 2022, a qualitative study explored one mechanism by which the practice does in fact perpetuate inequities...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
Richer kids, whose advantages help them succeed w/ assignments, are then "seen by teachers as responsible, motivated, & capable." Conversely, kids who struggle w/HW because of fewer resources at home are blamed for lacking responsibility or motivation: files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1358254.pdf -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Yesterday we talked about the danger he poses to democracy and to humanity. Tomorrow we'll explore his psychopathology. But today let's just reflect once again on what a moron he is.
Acyn
@Acyn
Trump: Virtually 100% of the net job creation in the last year has gone to migrants In fact I've heard substantially more and actually beyond that number 100%. It’s a much higher number than that but the government has not caught up with that yet.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I'm periodically reminded that scholarship often seems to be valued in direct proportion to its inaccessibility. Here's Ibsen's dry irony from "Peer Gynt" (150 years ago): "He is a remarkably learned man: Almost all that he says is beyond understanding."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Well, THIS certainly has no disturbing historical precedents: www.heraldtribune.com/story/news/education/2024/08/15/new…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Andrew Solomon: Jonathan Haidt's "The Anxious Generation" offers a "reactionary...romanticization of the good old days" as well as sweeping, unwarranted absolutes (e.g., unsupervised play benefits all kids; social media explains everything that's wrong): archive.ph/2024.07.26-203438/https://www.the-tls.co.uk/po…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Dear Mr. Kohn:
I would love to have you as a speaker at my virtual conference! Naturally I'd expect you to do what you do for a living without any compensation, but please consider this request anyway because I'm a huge fan of your life-changing book (INSERT BOOK TITLE HERE)! -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Sorry to learn of the recent death of literacy scholar Linda Gambrell, coauthor of a study showing that children who were rewarded for reading lost interest in doing so. One exception: Those rewarded with a book remained as interested as those who didn’t get a reward at all.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
This is what now appears on the website of Trump's official campaign account.
Note that his favorables have been ticking *up* lately, as his lies & insults grow ever more feverish. He's now viewed positively (& is preferred to Harris) by ~42% of voters (> 2 of every 5 Americans). -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/6
The cost of attending "high-achieving" schls:
A research review shows that the "unrelenting pressures [in these schls] to accomplish ever more" & be the best --> anxiety & depression at a rate an astounding 6-7 times higher than average for that age: www.researchgate.net/publication/337098103_High-achieving…Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
5/6
And they offer similar cautions against boosting "internal locus of control" (these kids already overestimate the power of their own efforts) or teaching "mindfulness" (which emphasizes "solitary thinking rather than connecting with others") ...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
6/6
Finally, the researchers warn, if high school students are allowed (or, worse, encouraged) to take lots of AP courses, "it is unrealistic to think that teaching them coping skills will help them withstand the enormous pressure associated with incessantly high workloads." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Even outside of MAGAworld, many believe we overreacted to Covid. In reality, this new scientific paper calculates that 100s of 1000s of lives would have been saved if all states had imposed mask & vaccine mandates like those in the most restrictive states: jamanetwork.com/journals/jama-health-forum/fullarticle/28…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Attribution theory always struck me as unpersuasively binary, with life outcomes said to be due to either internal or external factors - and the former assumed to be preferable.
Theorists have finally acknowledged a 3rd option: *relational* attributions: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38206850/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I've been studying this subject for 40 years, yet I'm still amazed by the extent of social harm attributable to competition. There seems to be no limit to the damage that can be done, or the money wasted, just because of men panicking that someone may beat them at something.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In fact, I've argued that just such desperate competitiveness helps to explain Trump's psychopathology (and resulting authoritarian demagoguery): www.alfiekohn.org/article/trumped/
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Case in point: His desperate need to believe that he attracts the largest crowds led him to lie about his 2017 inauguration and, just today, to make the absurd (& easily debunked) claim that one of Harris's recent crowds didn't exist! ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/politics/2024/08/11/trump-kamala…
He's clearly unwell. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
3 regions of the world in various stages of sliding toward authoritarianism: India, Israel, and portions of Europe (notably Hungary but also rising far-right parties across the Continent).
The threat to democracy is fueled by religion in all 3, albeit different religions...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
It's authoritarianism wedded to Hindu, Jewish, & Christian nationalism, respectively. But notice that in all 3 places the primary victims (& scapegoats for the far right) are Muslim...within the country (India), in its occupied territories (Israel), or immigrants (Europe). -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Direct teaching of vocabulary is not as efficient as acquiring vocabulary via listening to stories, and the effect of direct instruction...fades more with time. The time dedicated to skill-bldg would have been better spent listening to stories & reading": www.sdkrashen.com/content/articles/2019_krashen_and_mason…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Speaking of vocabulary, here's a term that I just learned (from reading): "narcissistic mortification" -
The Shallow State
@OurShallowState
My BIG TAKEAWAY from Trump's absurd press conference is that he is finally undergoing something called NARCISSISTIC MORTIFICATION. We dusted off this Freudian term back in April during his criminal trial, and it's extra-relevant today.
Narcissistic Mortification is when a narcissist like Trump crosses over to a place where he sees visions of his own demise. A malignant narcissist who once held the loftiest of titles, cannot cope with this. Trump's fears have become "dread." He is very unhinged, yet uncomfortable in the feeling itself, because he knows he's partly responsible. Reality is being forced upon him, that's not of his making. He can't have that!
To put it in more psychological terms, narcissistic mortification is EXTREME fear experienced when one with a rigidly grandiose pathology sees his sense of self as exposed, defective or inferior. It was coined by Freud in his book Moses and Monotheism. It's described there as deep injuries to ego/self, triggered by one's own compulsiveness (unforced errors -- like suggesting Putin would only release prisoners to him which set him up for embarrassment, or choosing Vance as his running mate against his better judgment, which drives him crazy daily, or repeatedly attacking the popular Georgia Governor Kemp against his own interests, because he can't control himself).
THIS is where I think he is. He's become his own worst enemy, and this conflicts with his pathology of being unable to admit fault. It's a very severe and very dissonant conflict.
Malignant narcissists need their grandiosity. For them to become exposed and weakened, is narcissistic injury - that happens. BUT - for them to become weakened to the extent of being able to visualize their own demise and know it's partly due to their own frailties - frailties they spend a lifetime avoiding and denying - this is irreconcilable. For a malignant narcissist like Trump, it's hell.
Bringing it back to the press conference, it causes him to become even more sensitized ("that was a stupid question"), to become more easily triggered (especially about "crowd size" - the symbol of his fading grandiosity - which he rambled about excessively), to use even more projection ("America" is failing, "America" is in danger means HE is failing and HE is in danger), and it has made him physically haggard (he looked gaunt and hunched over, with stiffness in his facial muscles), and finally - got disoriented (the Willie Brown/Jerry Brown helicopter story being the most pronounced example from yesterday).
Look for him to be carefully coddled by aides. They may not know the psychological terminology, but they know he's slipping away.
Narcissistic mortification is a precursor to narcissistic collapse. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I'm no expert, but is there any chance that one solution to this puzzler (below left) might be developments like these (below right)?: thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/4806281-climate-cha…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The #2 on the GOP ticket isn't just weird, creepy, or snide toward childless women. He's endorsed blunt calls to replace democracy w/a reign of autocratic terror modeled on Franco & Pinochet. This horrifying embrace of violence is today's Republican party: www.nytimes.com/2024/08/05/opinion/jd-vance-fascism-unhum…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In 2020, Trump & his cronies didn't defend authoritarianism. They claimed to be preserving democracy because the Democrats had cheated. So what we're seeing now with Trump, Vance, et al. represents a chilling shift as they & their enablers begin to explicitly disavow democracy.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From the archives: Should educators use simpler language to describe what they do? Only when simpler language is adequate to convey the same idea, which isn't always the case.
My blog post: "'Eduspeak' Reconsidered" - www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/eduspeak/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
What Debbie Meier once said about schools and classrooms is true of workplaces and other realms as well: Democracy doesn’t mean that every issue has to be discussed, only that every issue has to be discussable.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
John Oliver's half-hour summary of where things stand in the Israeli-occupied West Bank is well worth a watch. And maybe worth forwarding to people who might benefit from an overview of the situation there: www.youtube.com/watch?v=NqK3_n6pdDY
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Tom Bonier
@tbonier
The contrast between the two presidential tickets just on the basis of their genuine human decency will be striking.
PatriotTakes 🇺🇸
@patriottakes
Here is Minnesota Governor Tim Walz signing a law guaranteeing all students receive a free breakfast and lunch no matter their household income.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Yet another study – this one especially strong because it followed students for 14 years – showing that holding at-risk kids back a year in elementary school (i.e.,making them repeat a grade) is very effective...at making sure they drop out of high school: asu.elsevierpure.com/en/publications/effect-of-early-grad…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Meanwhile, this is available on Amazon and apparently not intended ironically
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Go ahead - think of the most devastating and accurate possible epithet. Print up t-shirts and lawn signs that say "I'm voting for the rapist" (or "the racist" or "the malignant narcissist") and you'll sell out. These people are unacquainted with irony. Or shame.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Newly published paper in a psych journal (psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037%2Fpspi0000439) considers a possibility that apparently had never occurred to researchers: "Just as police may respond to civilians as threats, civilians may respond to the police as threats." How about that!
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"The ultimate person of conscience": www.nytimes.com/2024/08/01/us/politics/randy-kehler-dead.…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
To predict whether someone is authoritarian, ask what they value most in kids: obedience, respect for elders, good manners? Or curiosity, independence, considerateness? These 2 distinct sets of values are negatively correlated & predict opposed worldviews: www.karenstenner.com
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
You can always tell whose bombings, assassinations, and other war crimes the NY Times is covering just by its use of the passive voice.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I've been tracking this informally for years, and the consistency is jaw-dropping. Also, Palestinian children are never shot to death by Israeli soldiers; they die in "clashes."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
There are only 2 problems with using tests to assess learning: Right answers often don’t reflect real understanding, and wrong answers often don’t reflect the absence of understanding.
(Because the kind of learning tests are designed to assess isn't really about understanding.)
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
To be clear, this is true of teacher-designed tests as well as the standardized kind: www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/no-tests/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
If someone identifies with two different ethnic backgrounds because her mother comes from one and her father comes from the other, it's okay to ridicule her for that, right?
(Asking for a fiend.) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The late Michael Gerson put it very well: People who defend Trump "are attempting something extraordinary: to politically normalize abnormal psychology."
George Conway ⚖️🇺🇸
@gtconway3d
This is correct.
Trump will only get worse—his psychological decompensation will accelerate—as he becomes more desperate and his narcissistic injury accumulates.
@PsychoPAC24 -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Yet another reminder from literacy experts that a rich array of strategies (and goals!) for beginning readers, supported by solid theory and research, looks nothing like the sterile phonics-focused regimen demanded by "Science of Reading" partisans: www.researchgate.net/profile/Maren-Aukerman-2/publication…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Research generally fails to support the idea that kids must be taught certain basic facts or skills before they can actively construct conceptual understanding. So some traditionalists started using the term "foundational" to make their favored approach APPEAR more persuasive
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
Such rebranding is nothing new, of course. See also: "school choice" for privatization; "content-rich" for a bunch o' facts curriculum; and, most egregiously, "the Science of..." or "evidence-based" for a simplistic approach (of dubious benefit) to teaching reading or math.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The "idea that decoding instruction (e.g., learning to read) should precede teaching of other literate roles (e.g., reading to learn) has little basis in research"; in fact, "research shows that tchrs should foster multiple literate roles from the get-go": www.researchgate.net/profile/Maren-Aukerman-2/publication…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Like many others, I've cited evidence that punishment is counterproductive, that "working with" isn't just more humane but also more effective than "doing to."
Here's an ex. of how that works in practice: an administrator who rejects suspension/expulsion: www.abc.net.au/news/2020-08-23/school-suspensions-expulsi… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Yikes
The Tennessee Holler
@TheTNHoller
ROLLING STONE: “At least 70 pro-Trump conspiracists are election officials in key battleground counties — and they are poised to make a giant mess on Election Day…”
The ones who put the country first last time have been replaced. www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/trump-swi… -
Alfie Kohn reposted
Jackie Seidel, PhD
@JackieSeidel1
The more autonomy I offer students in undergrad & grad courses, the fewer rules & rubrics, the more astonishing their work is. Recent undergrad group research projects were all 🏆. Asked them why. They said "you asked us to do good work & gave us freedom to know for ourselves"
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Despite the proven benefits of autonomy support, the default from kindergarten to college is to tell students what they must do. A new study finds that giving students choices - e.g., whether to do harder assignments - yields greater effort & achievement: www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.ado6759
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Got an email from "your typical high school valedictorian, reduced to passivity as I crammed AP classes in the shopping cart of the mind" at the expense of "curiosity and creativity." He worries about grades hampering "real learning" in college.
Part of my response is below. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Doesn't much of the dispute on clearing homeless camps (in Calif. & elsewhere) really come down to whether the primary goal is to address the plight of people who don't have a place to live....as opposed to the inconvenience that their public presence poses for people who do?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Despite the proven benefits of autonomy support, the default from kindergarten to college is to tell students what they must do. A new study finds that giving students choices - e.g., whether to do harder assignments - yields greater effort & achievement: www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.ado6759
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Though book bans have been a familiar tactic in culture wars, today we’re witnessing an attack on libraries themselves as social institutions...[This benefits] those trying to move the US toward a less democratic, more authoritarian model of governance": www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/07/24/libraries-end-…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Interesting new research: Compared with people who just happen not to be religious, those who affirmatively embrace a secular identity are more likely to endorse core democratic values & freedom of expression as well as to reject conspiracy theories: www.psypost.org/secularists-revealed-as-a-unique-politica…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The "end game for the radical ideologues...working so diligently to privatize schooling...[is] to change the way we understand ourselves as a public, such that the very idea of a shared institution seems impossible."
-@Bisforberkshire & @Edu_Historian, www.educationwarsbook.com
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Privatizers want us to "settle for a parody of democratic self-government, in which market-based 'choices' are our highest aspiration...[and we are related to each other] only through voluntary market exchange."
- Derek Gottlieb (quoted in The Education Wars) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Thrilled to receive the 2024 National Humblebrag Award - in the category of Always Starts Boasts with "Thrilled to..."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Who's not going to save us: The last time ½ of whites voted Democratic in a presidential election was 60 years ago. (Avg. since then: 40%.) It's been almost as long (48 years) since ½ of men voted Democratic. And of course that's with white male candidates in all but 3 elections.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/6
It's widely known that Stanley Milgram convinced ordinary volunteers to deliver what they thought were painful electric shocks to other people when they were told to do so by an experimenter in a lab coat as part of a “teaching” exercise.
But contrary to popular belief...Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
5/6
It's more difficult to dehumanize someone who is palpably, undeniably human. Which is why psychologist Nicholas Humphrey once proposed that arms control negotiators be required to talk to each other in the nude.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
6/6
Coda: You may be interested in some background about another famous series of experiments whose actual findings (and whole purpose, for that matter) were very different from what we've been led to believe: Walter Mischel's "marshmallow studies": www.alfiekohn.org/article/smore-misrepresentation-research/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"A second Trump administration seems likely to bring what the Hungarian sociologist Balint Magyar has termed an 'autocratic breakthrough' - structural political change that is impossible to reverse by electoral means."
-M. Gessen -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In my experience, the best educators are less interested in "student achievement" than in students’ achievements.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Well, that didn't take long: www.raygunsite.com/collections/homepage-1/products/electi…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Okay, it's obviously still early, but I'm feeling maybe a wee bit encouraged: statuskuo.substack.com/p/a-whole-new-ball-game
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
And another thoughtful take: whatever.scalzi.com/2024/07/22/biden-harris-trump-and-2024/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Sitting in on a law school class on civil procedure offered fresh confirmation of a distinction I've been thinking and writing about for some time: "Academically rigorous" and "intellectually engaging" are two very different things. And, boy, do we overvalue the former.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
In case you didn't notice, I slipped in two distinctions there for the price of one:
1) rigorous ≠ engaging;
2) intellectual goals - and the corresponding teaching strategies - differ markedly from those that are merely academic. (This recognition can transform schooling.) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Whom the gods wish to punish they grant their wishes."
-Oscar Wilde -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Red states are
pro-liberty...unless you're pregnant
pro-life...with unrestricted access to weapons
pro-democracy...while trying to restrict voting
pro-parental rights...except for those trying to protect their LGBTQ kid
pro-business...until a company supports DEI practices
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
I found these contradictions perplexing and absurd until this tweet cleared it up for me: x.com/drvolts/status/1452369770670555144 -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Imagine that you read about this happening in, say, Uzbekistan
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3
Traditionalists use "feel-good" and “touchy-feely” as all-purpose epithets to disparage whatever seems suspiciously pleasurable.
In education, that includes authentic assessments (vs. tests & grades) and discovery-based learning (vs. memorizing facts).
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3
Evidence of the remarkable effectiveness of such practices is waved away: If something is enjoyable, that’s reason enough to deem it insufficiently rigorous. Make a case for a more engaging curriculum, or for bringing kids in on making decisions, and the huffy response...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3
...is that Life isn’t always going to be interesting (or responsive to kids’ preferences) - & students had better learn to deal with that fact. Apparently the goal isn't to promote critical thinking or excitement about learning; it's to prepare kids for later unpleasantness. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
During a commencement address, Bob Newhart noted that you don't have to be intelligent to be asked to give such a speech. "You just have to create that impression. This can usually be accomplished with a reference to Kafka - even if you've never read any of his - or her - works."
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
scary lawyerguy
@scarylawyerguy
There is chutzpah and then there is spending four years claiming you won an election you lost, having people literally go to jail in support of your lie and then claim you want to unify the country. All of which is only possible if the media helps you do it.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The dismaying results of this study of intellectual and emotional climate in 1,000 US elementary schools received scant attention when it was published a decade ago: pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2137172/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/6
Putting the Vance in GRIEVANCE:
a brief rumination on how the psychological underlies the political...Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
5/6
Rather than being repulsed by this attitude, millions of people actually resonate with it. Straight, white Christians, outraged that they no longer receive automatic deference (or have a monopoly on power), rely on thin-skinned narcissistic men to turn back the clock for them
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
6/6
Fascism, w/ its focused hatred of Others, promises people who see themselves as put-upon or left behind that they can be elevated through submission to Dear Leader, a pitch w/ religious overtones, as when Trump tells his worshippers that he's being persecuted for all of them. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
One response to those who use false-equivalence narratives about how our nation is "polarized" or "divided"
David Frum
@davidfrum
On July 11, I published an article disliked by strong Biden supporters. That prompted a flurry of emails threatening to cancel subscriptions to
@TheAtlantic
Today I offended Trump supporters - which got me a cascade of fantasies about sending my family to concentration camps. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A focus on increasing "rigor," "raising the bar," demanding "higher standards," etc. usually means teaching the same sorts of things in pretty much the same way, except now with fewer students being able to succeed.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From James Gilligan, psychiatrist and expert on violence:
“The most dangerous men on earth are those who are afraid they’re wimps." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Pre-Kool-Aid consumption
Angry Staffer
@Angry_Staffer
In light of what could be a VP JD Vance announcement, I think it’s worth remembering what he said a few years ago:
“I go back and forth between thinking Trump is a cynical asshole like Nixon who wouldn’t be that bad (and might even prove useful) or that he’s America’s Hitler.” -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Current conditions
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
NYTPitchbot
@DougJBalloon
I have always voted for the Democratic candidate for President, but this year I’ll be voting Republican because a Republican shooter tried to kill a Republican candidate who calls for violence against Democrats
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The pop-behaviorist canard that refuses to die is that an extrinsic inducement just provides a helpful jump-start: Once someone experiences the intrinsic value of reading, learning, helping, not smoking, being physically fit, etc., the reward can just be phased out...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Alas, the evidence, which I updated a few yrs ago (www.alfiekohn.org/punished-rewards/), shows this belief is naive. Introducing $, grades, food, praise, or other goodie for doing x promptly devalues x. The person being manipulated becomes even less likely to see it as valuable or appealing.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The reckoning of "the most violent person in contemporary US politics...should be with the orderly process of law, not w/ the bloodshed he rejoiced in when it befell others." But the GOP will exploit this act "to exonerate past crimes & empower new ones": www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/07/donald-trump-de…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Holy shit. If this is going on in New York, just imagine how many similar far-right paramilitary groups are being organized in red states. And if it's happening now, imagine what's coming under (an immunized) Trump 2.0: www.nytimes.com/2024/07/11/nyregion/bruce-blakeman-armed-…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
WashPost and CNN reporting that the shooter was registered to vote as a Republican
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Education's Project 2025? Fascinating 18-min. talk on how "Science of Reading" label ushers in a broader "Knowledge Matters" agenda: standardized "Core Knowledge" curriculum, direct instruction, right-wing cultural goals, & for-profit ed. companies: app.frame.io/reviews/8e3946bd-b011-4a67-af3b-bdbcaeaae488…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
One premise of this sweeping, Koch-funded initiative, as UWisc prof. Elena Aydarova explains: "If we just focus teachers on [mandated, standardized, fact-based] content, they will have no time to do anything else." More in her new article: www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/730991 -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
a-wards as-sem-bly n. An event, often held in an auditorium, that instantly transforms most people present into losers -- while simultaneously undermining the intrinsic motivation, self-confidence, and collaborative orientation of winners and losers alike
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/5
I've long been fascinated by things we regard as facts of life whose existence actually turns out to be entirely dependent on social context.
A few examples...Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/5
"Leisure" assumes that work is alienating or unfulfilling.
Treason is a terrible crime only if the interests of one's country take precedence over the interests of all humans.
Blasphemy has meaning only for those who believe in the existence of a deity who can be profaned.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
5/5
Finally, jaywalking is a meaningless concept in Boston, where I live, because there's simply no expectation that pedestrians should cross only at intersections.
[Add your own examples] -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
If unconditional love and genuine enthusiasm are present, praise isn’t necessary. If they’re absent, praise won’t help.
(A book-length explanation of the principles underlying, and the research supporting, this maxim: www.alfiekohn.org/unconditional-parenting-book/) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
And since this video was released, Speaker Johnson endorsed the plan to round up millions of Latinos, while Trump threatened to arrest Mark Zuckerberg and others
Mueller, She Wrote
@MuellerSheWrote
This is terrifying.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3
Definitive meta-analysis of research on student motivation published in 2021 that included nearly 250K kids. Clear confirmation of the benefits (for academic achievement & well-being) of intrinsic motivation + the harms of using rewards or punishments: selfdeterminationtheory.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/20…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3
The data clearly show "the potential costs of using external incentives & punishments (e.g., parents offering monetary rewards or teachers punishing bad behavior)." These controlling interventions undermine emotional health & don't even improve persistence or performance...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3
The authors add: "The pursuit of narrowly defined criteria of success in the form of test scores appears potentially harmful to students’ long-term development and educational success...[This] is particularly worrisome given [standardized testing's] worldwide pervasiveness." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A serious question: Is there *any* demand by religious reactionaries (in FL or TX) to distort or whitewash content that textbook publishers would refuse? Would they ever say, "We want your business, but no. We have some integrity and there are limits"? (www.orlandosentinel.com/2024/07/05/textbook-authors-told-…)
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Has medicine become too specialized? "Absolutely not!" says a friend of mine, a pediatric sinistropodiatric dermatologist, whose practice is limited to treating the skin on children's left feet.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Fixed it
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I was fascinated as a student to learn how W.R. Hearst used his papers not just to cover the news but to make policy - notably, to force a war with Cuba. I have a fresh understanding of how that works watching the NYT's open, relentless campaign to force Biden out of the race.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Having endured endless faculty meetings, I can't remember the last time anyone changed his mind as a result of reasoned discourse....The purpose of all academic discussion [seems to be] to provide the grounds for becoming further entrenched in our original positions."
-R. Russo -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"As the GOP became the party of coup denialism & unreconstructed Trump cultists, so too, finally, have the sober movement conservatives at the high court...Whatever braking mechanism once existed is now broken. We wake up this summer in a new gov't order": slate.com/news-and-politics/2024/07/supreme-court-maga-jo…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Priorities
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
We can promote helpfulness and other social values, but if they're taught in an environment where the primary emphasis is on obedience and following the rules, all may be lost.
Exhibit A: a man who recalled being “taught that my highest duty was to help those in need”...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
...but said he learned this lesson in the context of how important it was to “obey promptly the wishes and commands of my parents, teachers, and priests, and indeed of all adults….Whatever they said was always right.”
The speaker: Rudolf Höss, the commandant of Auschwitz. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/4
New: Another math expert explains why conceptual understanding is far more important than learning the "correct" steps & procedures. And why inquiry-based teaching works better than direct instruction to help kids develop that conceptual understanding: www.edsurge.com/news/2024-06-05-when-teaching-students-ma…Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/4
That findingwas replicated 25 yrs later: www.researchgate.net/profile/Bethany-Rittle-Johnson/publi…. Even w/older students, a 3rd study found, teaching procedures (or even just reminding students of them) - & evaluating students on whether they remember them- can undermine sense-making: www.researchgate.net/profile/Ji-Son/publication/350021438…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/4
In short, research suggests that explicit instruction focused on deriving right answers - even if it's marketed as the "science of math" - isn't merely less effective than helping kids to understand (& construct) mathematical principles. It can actually impede understanding. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Question from the NY Times, possible answer (published the same day) from the WashPost, based on CNN's new post-debate poll
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Andrew Lawrence
@ndrew_lawrence
if youre worried about the presidential immunity ruling, the good news is that it almost certainly wont apply to dem presidents
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Calls to teach kids self-discipline and "grit" always make me think of Annie Dillard's comment about writing: "You don't do it from will power; you do it from an abiding passion."
More generally, Einstein observed that "love is a better master than duty." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Read the whole thread
Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Today's decision was historic - as in Dred Scott, Plessy v Ferguson, Buck v Bell, Bush v Gore, Korematsu historic. Here's a gift link to a summary (by Adam Serwer) that you really should read: www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2024/07/supreme-cour…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A high school biology student of my acquaintance: "Apparently the way science works is if the results of your experiment aren't what you expected, it means you did the experiment wrong and have to get the data from the teacher."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Reviewing a recent hotel bill suggests that publishers have a lot to learn about how to set pricing for books. A hardcover should be advertised as "only $12!" - and only later would purchasers discover the addition of a $6 pagination fee, an $8 editing and indexing fee...
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"We never imagined that these leopards would eat OUR faces!" say countries whose entire economies are based on the production of face-eating leopards: www.nytimes.com/2024/06/27/world/middleeast/gulf-states-h…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
But he says stuff like this *forcefully*, and that's all that really matters, right?
Acyn
@Acyn
Trump: I say that the thing that's an existential threat is not global warming where the ocean will rise, maybe. And it may go down but may rise 1/8 of an inch in the next 497 years which gives you a little bit more waterfront property if you're lucky
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In case you were worried that the Court's destruction of reproductive rights, affirmative action, and the separation of church & state had distracted it from the task of protecting corporations (from regulations to safeguard workers, the environment, or consumers), you can relax.
scary lawyerguy
@scarylawyerguy
Any time an agency tries to adopt a regulation corporations don't like, they'll run to a Trump-appointed judge, who will substitute his/her own subjective judgment for that of experts and we'll wonder why there's lead in our water or seat belts are no longer required🙃
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Dave Troy
@davetroy
Some real talk: even if Biden had performed at 2012 levels last night, the SEC and Chevron SCOTUS decisions are sufficient to send American government into the stone age.
Project 2025's proscriptions are largely superfluous in the wake of those decisions. Decimating the civil service through executive order is of little consequence if the agencies themselves are unconstitutional. Project 2025 is, for the most part, a backup plan, Plan B; Plan A is the stuff that's already happened this week, and will have massive consequences no matter who becomes president.
Yes, it is possible that if an institutionalist president is elected, they can reshape the court in ways that eventually reverse these cases, but that realistically will take many years, if not decades.
The shockwaves from this week's events, culminating with the relatively less-consequential immunity decision on Monday, will be felt for the rest of our lives and likely into our childrens' dotage. Plan accordingly. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In a country where substance mattered more than appearance, where being low energy was regarded as less than ideal in a leader but compulsive, shameless, self-aggrandizing dishonesty was absolutely disqualifying, the conversation about that debate would be very different.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A simple strategy for raising a psychologically healthy, morally exemplary child: Think about Trump, then aim for the exact opposite: www.alfiekohn.org/article/untrump/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/5 Louisiana's mandate that public schools not only may but must display a Judeo-Christian document is many things: a contemptuous defiance of the 1st Amendment's establishment clause; a test of how much theocrats can get away with in their assault on our secular democracy...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I recently noted that the religious right (which effectively owns the GOP) is moving not only to proselytize in public schools but to eliminate abortion rights, IVF, LGBTQ rights (including marriage equality), & contraception. Well, it seems I missed one: www.theguardian.com/us-news/article/2024/jun/25/republica…
Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/5 BTW, the privileged status of the 10 Commandments is notable in its own right. Is this really the best we can do for moral guidance? #1 isn't even a commandment. Keep the Sabbath & Don't Covet are in the top 10, but genocide, slavery, child abuse, & rape don't make the list?
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
5/5 Indeed, such moral outrages are actually ENDORSED by the guys who came up w/ those commandments (during the Iron Age). The very next chap. in Exodus has instructions for trading slaves & selling daughters. But, hey, as long as they take 1 day off a week & obey their parents.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
What's so appalling is that conservatives no longer criticize how DEI initiatives are *implemented*; they now attack diversity, equity, & inclusion as *goals*: www.washingtonpost.com/business/2024/06/27/conservative-l….
In effect, they'd replace DEI with SIR: requirements for sameness, injustice, and rejection. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
There's a tie this week for the news story that most definitively demonstrates just how doomed we are.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 Whenever I talk about people spending their lives vainly attempting to live up to their parents' impossible expectations, I recall a story about the late Dr. Bernard Lown. A world-famous cardiologist, he co-founded Int'l Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2 ...IPPNW won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1985, and Lown treated his aged mother to a trip to Oslo so she could see him receive the honor. During the ovation as he walked to the stage to give his speech, she sighed sadly and murmured, "I always thought he'd win it for medicine."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Can we stop calling these people "pro-life" now?
Jill Filipovic
@JillFilipovic
The study found that the most significant driver of the increase in infant deaths was babies who died of congenital anomalies. In other words, women were forced by Texas law to have babies everyone knew would suffer and die.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Matthew Desmond observes that a typical reaction in many countries upon encountering a homeless person is to wonder how the state failed him, whereas Americans are more likely to wonder what poor decisions that individual made: www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/05/poverty-in-amer…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
It's hardly a new insight, of course. (Ryan's book about it is >50 years old.) But it helps to explain the US's anomalous lack of universal health care & other social supports. Maybe it's even related to our gun fetishism, huge prison pop., and unusual degree of religiosity. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
There is truly no moral bottom here. Anyone who pretends the two candidates are in any way comparable - or who doesn't do what is necessary to keep this vile demagogue from reclaiming power - shares responsibility for his depravity.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Early anthropologists debunked the myth that it's "just human nature" to compete, especially in times of scarcity. Some cultures with limited resources are indeed competitive, but others are cooperative, figuring that they can't afford to compete and must work together.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
Now a study of (typically testy) macaque monkeys finds that, after a hurricane eliminated most shade trees in their hot habitat, they widened their social network & became less aggressive & more tolerant - & stayed that way. Which helped them survive: www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adk0606 -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
By now, most people understand - from reports like #1 & #2, below - that climate change underlies more frequent & intense droughts, floods, & heat waves. But too few connect this to separate reports like those in #3.
Message: A vote for a Republican is a vote for more misery. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Every time I hear a politician sanctimoniously champion the interests of "hard-working families," I get a little closer to founding USPAL: the Unproductive Single People's Antidefamation League
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
What distinguishes a rational belief (however radical) from a cult-like conspiracy theory? Ask "What evidence would lead me to change my mind?" If you'd find a way to dismiss ANY disconfirming information or argument, you're in the company of election deniers, antivaxxers, et al.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Punished by Meta-Rewards
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
This 1996 article describes how even teachers whose practice is thoughtful and holistic feel obliged to switch to (far less effective & engaging) direct instruction when their principal drops by to evaluate them: www.ascd.org/el/articles/can-teacher-evaluation-reflect-h…. Still true today?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
While I'm angered by Biden's policy, I cannot fathom that anyone who's outraged over Israeli war crimes would consider not voting for him. Even if Gaza was the only voting issue (and lord knows it isn't), putting Trump back in the White House would be far worse for Palestinians.
Fubar🇨🇦
@Captain_Fubar
The fact that Netanyahu is so viscerally adamant about getting Biden out of the Whitehouse is something that should be ringing alarm bells for Americans who care about this conflict
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Q. When Republicans are in charge, what becomes of academic freedom?
A. www.tallahassee.com/story/news/politics/2024/06/14/florid… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I've long argued that efforts to control people (including kids) aren't just disrespectful; they're also counterproductive. I love this epigram by Herb Lovett that follows from that fact: "The more intrusive the procedure, the less empirical evidence there is to justify its use."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I'm no longer laughing off Trump & his sycophants' absurd references to Democrats (from moderately progressive to centrist) as Marxists/Communists. Historical precedents including European fascists & Latin American juntas show this is a deadly serious tactic to justify repression
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Fascinating study: Lower social-class university students (& other adults) do worse than their higher-class counterparts on a reasoning task only when they're led to focus on outperforming others. Competition, in other words, exacerbates social inequality: psycnet.apa.org/buy/2019-10560-001
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
You know those idiots who use the current weather to deny the reality of long-term global warming? I used to look forward to hearing a scientist set them straight, but now I just find such confrontations anti-climatic.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Science at its best is both bold (b/c it's "the belief in the ignorance of authority" - RFeynman) & humble (b/c it's not about discovering Truth but "an erratic stumble toward gradually diminished uncertainty" - Ed Yong). Paradoxically, both features trigger relig authoritarians.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Amazing how homework defenders get away with saying “Maybe there's no achievement benefit, but HW teaches self-discipline, responsibility, time mgmt...” In 20 years I've been unable to find a single study that supports this folk wisdom about HW's supposed nonacademic advantages.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In 2020, people took to the streets to protest police brutality....and were met with police brutality.
Just the other day, a FL school board banned a book about book banning.
They can destroy our democracy, but by god they can't take away our rueful appreciation of irony. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
When ed tech asks "How can we deliver content to students more efficiently?", we're discouraged from asking how to move beyond a content-delivery conception of learning. Or whether efficiency matters most. My 2023 Ed Week essay on "sneaky conservatism": www.alfiekohn.org/article/tech-conservatism/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The far-right parties and their leaders in Europe constitute a growing threat to democratic values and institutions. But Trump is worse: www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2024/06/europea…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I have boundless admiration for teachers who help kids read good books thoughtfully without turning it into a tedious structured exercise that pulls them out of the text and focuses them on monitoring their own reading skills.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
One teacher who used to have her students periodically “drop everything and read” their favorite books was asked whether she was still devoting class time to that purpose. She replied, “We haven’t done ANY reading since I had to start preparing the kids for the reading test.”
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Ted Sizer urged us to shadow a high school student for a full day or 2 to understand what it's really like to attend a traditional H.S. - & thus how urgent it is to rethink this model of schooling. One teacher did so & emerged shaken. An eye-opening read: authenticeducation.org/a-veteran-teacher-turned-coach-sha…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Here's Sizer's own one-paragraph summary of that experience from a student's perspective:
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
What matters isn’t how well a teacher holds students’ attention; it's whether a teacher knows enough about how learning happens to stop being the center of attention.
Or, as @ddmeyer puts it, great teachers are characterized less by being interesting than by being interested. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I'm pleased that five of my books can be listened to as well as looked at (www.alfiekohn.org/audiovideo/), but it may say something about how long I've been at this that the first of these audiobooks is available only on...cassette. (Sales for that one have, ah, lagged a bit lately.)
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A: A longterm brutal military occupation: www.nytimes.com/2023/11/14/opinion/israel-gaza-war-histor…
B: A savage attack by Hamas killing many civilians
C: A continuing assault by Israel killing 10x more civilians
If B explains C, then why doesn't A explain B?
And if A doesn't justify B, why would B justify C?
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I fear this is exactly right.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Also worth remembering that Israel killed 293 Palestinians in the year *before* last Oct. 7
(Source: www.ochaopt.org/data/casualties) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Even to talk about how Trump et al. are planning "revenge" on Democrats implies a kind of tit for tat, which is false. He was legitimately indicted, tried, and convicted under the rule of law. They're using that as a pretext for destroying their enemies: newrepublic.com/article/182480/trump-dr-phil-hannity-biza…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Given how many positive things can be flicked away just by calling them "woke," I guess it shouldn't be surprising that conservatives also rely on derogatory labels like ”fuzzy math” to dismiss more sophisticated teaching that emphasizes meaning over rote recall.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
When you think about it, it's just the flip side of the "Science of..." campaign to prop up traditionalist pedagogy - in combination, a diabolically effective framing that promotes a reactionary approach to education while putting progressive alternatives on the defensive. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
What matters isn't how involved parents are w/ their kids' education (such that we should urge either more, or less, involvement). The questions are HOW they're involved - and WHY. Effects differ depending on the type of, & reasons for, their involvement: sdtheory.s3.amazonaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/2015…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3 Vouchers undermine our secular democracy in 2 ways at once: They divert public $ to private entities (weakening the public sphere) & demolish the wall between church & state (since "the vast majority of the money is being directed to religious schls"): www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2024/06/03/tax-dollars-reli…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3 My sense is that a generation ago the main push came from the neoliberal, privatize-everything wing of the GOP, whereas today it's from the theocratic wing. Either way, the assault on public education, a cornerstone of a democratic society, is succeeding like never before.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3 The WaPo article notes that (a) the % of voucher $ going to religious schools exceeds even the high % of private schools that are religious, & (b) vouchers are just part of a broader move in red states "toward more govt-sponsored religion inside *public* schools." Chilling.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/3
Actually, in light of their history, I should have included a third major impetus for voucher plans. Beyond privatization and taxpayer-supported religion, "school choice" has also been driven by racism - specifically, resistance to integration: www.thedailybeast.com/segregation-academies-show-us-the-u… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Debate comprises a discrete set of skills: Successful debaters aren't necessarily those who have truth on their side or even more pertinent information. The same is true of taking standardized tests: They measure not just knowledge or thinking but test-taking ability...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
These things are widely seen as neutral, reliable indicators of truth & educational excellence, respectively. But you can be wrong & win a debate (or you can be right & lose). And you can be coached to beat a test - or, conversely, look dumb just b/c yr not a good test-taker -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Do you think that someone who has been convicted of a felony should be allowed to become president?" (purple bar = yes; red bar = no)
[Source: yougov.com/en-us/articles/49617-opinion-change-post-trump…] -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
A 2018 study showed that urging women to "tackle wkplace gender inequality by overcoming their own internal barriers" ("Lean In") -> endorsing "solutions that require women to change themselves as opposed to requiring companies or managemt to change": psycnet.apa.org/record/2018-63189-004
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
Now a new study confirms that such messaging may discourage women from protesting gender discrimination: www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2024/05/240528115015.htm
P.S. Minimizing structural barriers to focus on individuals - the "mindset" mindset - is similarly problematic w/ kids: www.alfiekohn.org/article/mindset/. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Descriptions of Hitler in Dean Haycock's book "Tyrannical Minds": obsessive declarations of his own greatness, lack of empathy, stunted personal relationships, histrionic speaking style, impulsive decisions & chaotic administrative style, promises to make Germany great again...
Bruce Bartlett
@BruceBartlett
People give me shit when I compare Trump and Hitler, but a serious scholar of German history has now done it. Stylistically and how they interact with their insane followers are very, very similar, he says. www.theguardian.com/us-news/article/2024/jun/03/donald-tr…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Now he claims he never said "Lock her up."
Psych explanatn: He's so far gone that he really believes anything he says is true just b/c he says it.
Political explanatn (via Anne Applebaum): "Sometimes the point isn’t to make people believe a lie—it’s to make people fear the liar." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
In my books I review research showing that rewards and punishments actively impede children's moral growth and other important outcomes. This study shows that traditional discipline is also counterproductive even when the goal is just compliance: www.researchgate.net/publication/318910439_Parental_auton…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
"The more [that] parents were observed as controlling when their toddlers were 2 years old, the less their toddlers complied wholeheartedly to their parents’ requests and prohibitions at 3.5 years old." Autonomy support, by contrast, promoted compliance. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Overturning Roe v. Wade: a detailed account of how the religious right "secretly led the country down a path that defied the will of [most] Americans." And ending legal abortion is just part of their "vision of what a modern Christian empire look[s] like": www.nytimes.com/2024/05/28/magazine/roe-v-wade-christian-…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"[Saddest of all is] the despairing man who is unconscious of being in despair"
-Kierkegaard -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Just putting this out there again...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
That he may be indicted for 4 separate clusters of serious offenses should lay bare the pattern, the scope & enormity of his criminality. But ~40% of voters live in an alternate reality where the more crimes he's held accountable for, the more it just shows he's being persecuted.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Possible grounds for appeal: The verdict wasn't from a jury of his peers since none of those jurors had incited an insurrection, tried to overturn an election, stolen national documents, or committed sexual assault.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The key to this authoritarian cult is unfalsifiability: NO revelation or set of facts will ever lead them to concede his guilt and unfitness for office. They'll abandon the rule of law rather than him. And now "they" refers not to a few far-right kooks but to one of our 2 parties
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A key distinction for parents/educators: teaching kids that hurting people (or lying) is wrong ... vs. teaching them WHY it's wrong. The latter is about reasons and values; the former is just about behavior, and the default reason to avoid a prohibited behavior is self-interest.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
As someone who tries to patronize local shops (rather than Amazon), including independent bookstores, I can't explain why it's taken me this long to switch my prescription from a giant drugstore chain to a neighborhood pharmacy, but I'm glad I finally did so. (It was effortless.)
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
ICYMI: Too often, the invocation of “science” to defend traditionalist education reflects an agenda based more on ideology than on solid data. My new blog post: "The Siren Song of 'Evidence-Based' Instruction": www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/evidence-based/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The same st that just classified mifepristone as a controlled dangerous substance is about to force publ schls to display the 10 Commdmts. The same sts that restrict voting & target LGBTQ folks are subsidizing parochial schls. And J6 was a religious event: ffrf.org/uploads/legal/Christian_Nationalism_and_the_Jan6…
Bill Kristol
@BillKristol
Q.: Has Bannon always had religious iconography behind him when he broadcasts?
The "Christian" element of today's anti-liberal Right seems more and more prominent. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3
Just before his death in 1952, Dewey reflected on how little of his vision had made it into schools, how the changes that did occur were merely "atmospheric" & hadn't "really penetrated the foundations of the ed'al instn," leaving its "fundamental authoritarianism" intact...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3
Other observers have agreed. Historian Ellen Lagemann put it this way: "One cannot understand the history of education in the United States during the 20th century unless one realizes that Edward L. Thorndike won and John Dewey lost"...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3
And this paradoxical insight from @DLabaree: "Dewey's undiminished prominence in the realm of educational ideas is a sign of his failure in changing America's schools," whereas many of the behaviorists are forgotten precisely because their ideas have triumphed." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
I commend to you a superb new book (available online for free) by literacy experts Rob Tierney & David Pearson: "Fact-Checking the Science of Reading." It provides a meticulously detailed, scrupulously fair-minded review of SoR claims: literacyresearchcommons.org
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
Attached you'll see a list of the specific SoR assertions, widely repeated as gospel these days, that are in some cases misleading or unsupported and in other cases simply false, which Tierney & Pearson patiently and politely dissect in light of the evidence. -
Alfie Kohn reposted
Josh Cowen
@joshcowenMI
In every state that’s expanded or passed “universal” vouchers, the share of voucher users becomes more white, while the population at-large becomes more diverse.
This is a direct result of new vouchers primarily going to kids already in private school.
Josh Cowen
@joshcowenMI
The real headline in the state’s report is that 67.5% of Indiana voucher users in 2023-24 had never been in Indiana public schools—up from 63.4% in 2022-23.
Nearly spot-on with every other state estimate of ~7/10 voucher users never having attended public school. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Parenting authors without rivalry: I'm sad to learn that my old friend Adele Faber has died. The coauthor of several wonderful books that popularized Haim Ginott's work, Adele was wryly funny and generous in supporting other authors who shared her vision of humane child-rearing.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I love my neighborhood
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Amazing to visit my alma mater and see all the buildings that weren't there before, reflecting the university's academic priorities: the gleaming new 15-story philosophy complex, the $200 million state-of-the-art history facility, the world-class center for sociology research...
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The more that parents' self-worth hinges on their kids' accomplishments, the more controlling they become & the more they want the kids to be rich, popular, attractive - as opposed to more meaningful goals (personal devlpmt, generosity, close relatnships): selfdeterminationtheory.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/20…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Sometimes invocations of "evidence" or "science" in education are used not to begin a discussion but to end one. My new essay: "The Siren Song of 'Evidence-Based' Instruction": www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/evidence-based/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
At best, the terms "evidence-based" & "the science of..." in education raise troubling questions. At worst, they're just slogans used by traditionalists & don't even signify real evidence.
My new blog post: "The Siren Song of 'Evidence-Based' Instruction": www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/evidence-based/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Calvin Trillin once insisted that he did poorly in math only because his teachers failed to realize that he intended many of his answers ironically.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 Jerome Bruner recalled a boy with exceptional calculation skills who proudly multiplied "2 large & ugly numbers on the board" on the 1st day of schl & announced "I know a lot of math." "He made no progress until he got over the idea that what was needed was hard computation."
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2 Such kids tend to be thrown for a loop in a classroom where the emphasis is on understanding rather than just producing right answers. Adults, too, who have succeeded with tradtl methods (and by tradtl criteria) are unnerved by environments where their status is put at risk.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"One ironical consequence of the drive for so-called higher standards in schools is that the children are too busy to think."
-John Holt (more than 60 years ago) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A horrifying dispatch from Israel: Polls show that the vast majority of ordinary Israelis actively support the slaughter in Gaza and oppose food & medical aid for civilians; a bumper sticker says "Finish them"; a popular song calls for Gaza to be "erased": www.nytimes.com/2024/05/16/opinion/israeli-palestine-psyc…
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
NYTPitchbot
@DougJBalloon
Biden pledged to be a president for all Americans. But by flying the American flag right-side up, he thumbs his nose at those who believe he stole the election via large-scale voter fraud in majority Black cities.
by Ginni Thomas and Martha-Ann Alito -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2:
A recent meta-analysis shows that minimizing control (supporting people's autonomy) promotes caring and generosity: www.researchgate.net/publication/355982043_Paths_to_the_l….
Two implications:
(1) When our needs are met, we're freed from being preoccupied with them and can be open to helping others...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2:
But if needs (including for autonomy) AREN'T met, they continue to reverberate, drowning out others’ cries of distress.
(2) Since rewards are just sugar-coated control, it's no wonder that other research shows that praising kids for helping makes them more self-centered. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I bristle whenever a skeptic is dismissed as "cynical." There's a huge difference. Skeptics think and doubt and, in so doing, affirm a vision of the way things ought to be. Cynics affirm nothing, take no action, and end up helping to perpetuate an objectionable status quo.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Many plutocrats are willing to let Trump destroy democracy in order to maximize their profits: www.nytimes.com/2024/05/15/business/wall-street-donors-tr…. But some also seem to be tilting toward Trump b/c they realize (as does Netanyahu) that he'd be far more supportive of Israel's ongoing war crimes than Biden.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
When teachers complained to Ted Sizer about a kid, he’d gently reframe by asking “What does this student need from you?”
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
This should be obvious, but judging by the claims of education traditionalists, it may bear repeating: Successful contestants on Jeopardy! may also happen to be highly intelligent, but we can't assume that's true just because they've managed to memorize a lot of information.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Research finds that putting children in competitive activities tends to reduce their generosity & empathy. (Makes sense when you consider the mindset required to try to beat others.) Someone summarized this by saying that caring tends to atrophy when the point is to win a trophy.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The Canadian educator and author Selma Wassermann once remarked that taking away children's right to make decisions because they've failed to make "responsible" choices is like taking away their right to read because they can't yet read well.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Pro tip: Make sure to insert a parenthetical in anything you write that begins with the ubiquitous phrase "pro tip."
Anti tip: Actually, don't. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/4 The defining feature of today's GOP is cruelty: denying aid to the needy, ending reproductive rts, attacking trans people, etc. Makes perfect sense that they're also vocal defenders of Israel's inconceivably savage siege of a civilian populatn that's killed 1000s of children
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/4 BTW, if an endless, brutal military occupation doesn't justify Hamas's slaughter of 1200 people on Oct. 7 (and it doesn't), then don't pretend that that act could justify Israel's slaughter of ~35,000 people or deliberately pushing 2 million souls to the edge of famine.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/4 Fueling such rationalizations (or claims that Israel is "defending itself") is dehumanization: You cannot defend the evil of bombing hospitals unless you believe a Palestinian life is worth less than an Israeli (or American) life.
Again, a perfect fit for Trumpian xenophobes -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Jerome Bruner reminded us that we want students to "experience success and failure not as reward and punishment but as information." This insight is so essential that I've come to call it Bruner's Law...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
Its immediate implication: Grades must be eliminated (not merely tweaked) since they're inevitably experienced by students as rewards and punishments. Beyond that, we should use Bruner's Law as the standard by which to decide whether other assessment practices make sense. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Research showing that [early] letter recognition predicts [later] rding success is based on children who learned letters thru natural literacy activities like having stories read to them. There is no evidence that memorizing the alphabet predicts later rding skill." -R Rothstein
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Reminder for teachers and parents: A society in which no one is willing to risk being called a troublemaker is a society in which power is certain to be abused.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The epigraph:
"Only extraordinary education is concerned with learning; most is concerned with achieving: and for young minds, these two are very nearly opposite."
-Marilyn French
The article that elucidates that distinction: www.alfiekohn.org/article/costs-overemphasizing-achievement/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"The more informal the learning environment, the greater the teacher's access to the learners' representations, understandings, and misunderstandings."
-Lilian Katz & Sylvia Chard -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Outside agitators
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In a speech he gave in 1917 ("Science as a Vocation"), the sociologist Max Weber summarized how American students seemed to regard each of their professors: "He sells me his knowledge and his methods for my father's money just as the greengrocer sells my mother cabbage."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The Methodist Church finally ended its ban on gay clergy, but only after (& because) a huge chunk of their homophobic members left the denomination. Is it more common these days that progress in a given group or area is due not to persuasion but to an exodus of those who resist?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"The Attack on Self-Esteem," a chapter from my book The Myth of the Spoiled Child, summarizes the research on that topic and offers a detailed rebuttal of conservative polemics about kids with "inflated" SE. It's now available in its entirety online: www.alfiekohn.org/article/self-esteem/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Inspirational slogans invariably reflect an individualistic worldview that ignores structural barriers. It's a hell of a lot harder to "turn the lemons that life gives you into lemonade" if you can't afford all the sugar that’s required.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Utterly damning: "A lot of the technology used in classrooms wasn't developed with students in mind. [Most of it is] 'created for commercial purposes,' [prof. of ed tech Mesut Duran] said, 'and then we decide how to use [it] in schools'": www.nytimes.com/2024/04/24/opinion/ed-tech-classroom.html…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Student protests reflect their "outrage over the tens of thousands of civilians killed in Gaza...and yet much of the media coverage of the protests themselves has obscured this reality." Worth a read: newrepublic.com/article/181107/college-protests-israel-ga…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
It's fair to question how "conservatism" and "creativity" were operationalized in this new study, but its finding of a negative (albeit very modest) correlation between the two phenomena across 28 different countries is interesting: www.psypost.org/study-links-conservatism-to-lower-creativ…
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Matthew Gertz
@MattGertz
Personally I think this sounds very bad. time.com/6972021/donald-trump-2024-election-interview/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/5 Bad teaching doesn't just happen. Nor is it usually due to defects in individual teachers. Rather, it is driven - indeed, practically demanded - by systemic factors.
For example...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/5 If students are under pressure to beat out their classmates for artificially scarce recognition, it's going to be hard for the teacher to figure out how their minds work. They'll be throwing her off by trying to impress her with how smart they are.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/5 If parents insist on the familiar sight of a teacher in front of the class presenting a conventional lesson, it's going to be hard for the teacher to grow past a model that impedes the promotion of active, engaged, enthusiastic learning.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/5 If a very specific curriculum is imposed on teachers, with requirements for what kids must know at each grade level, teachers are going to be permanently set on Play rather than Record (even though great teaching is, as Deb Meier notes, more about listening than talking).
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
5/5 If we allow legislators & school boards to make teachers "accountable" for producing higher test scores, you can bet students will receive an education completely out of step with the best thinking about how kids learn. The scores may rise even as the learning stagnates.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
As the president of this esteemed university, allow me to underscore our longstanding commitment to free expression before gracefully pivoting to an announcement that we will of course have the police arrest students who peacefully protest Israel's bombardment of Gaza civilians..
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 Important to understand that deskilling teachers is at the heart of Direct Instruction. Its pioneer, uber-behaviorist Sig Engelmann, said, "The teacher must be viewed as a consumer of instruction material." Also: "We don't give a damn about what the teacher thinks [or] feels"
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2 That behaviorist tradition goes back to Edward Thorndike, who thought all decisions about teaching should be made by experts & told his grad students to read about schls rather than visit them so as to maintain the "emotionally indifferent attitude of the scientific observer"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Whenever I start to miss academia, I remember that there was a time when I would have nodded solemnly along with those around me upon hearing Sartre's description of boxing as “a binary praxis of antagonistic reciprocity.”
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Know who loves these practical guides to being more disciplined w/our food shopping? The conglomerates raking in profits from their price hikes & shrinking package sizes: time.com/6269366/food-company-profits-make-groceries-expe…. (Just as oil cos. urge us to take individual responsibility for conserving energy.)
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Supr Court majority "evinced virtually no concern for our ability to continue holding free & fair elections that culminate in a peaceful transfer of power. They instead offered endless solicitude for the former president who fought that transfer of power": slate.com/news-and-politics/2024/04/supreme-court-immunit…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"It is what it is": learned helplessness in an impoverished community facing extreme climate change: www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2024/04/240423135210.htm. Not so different from shrugging about the GOP's assault on democracy, or surrendering one's privacy to Big Tech: a sense of normalcy purchased at any cost
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The #nytimes has helped me realize that the real victims of Israel's ongoing massacre of Palestinian civilians are the pro-Israel American college students who feel uncomfortable with protests on their campuses.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From the archives: "The Back-to-School-Night Speech We'd Like to Hear"- sort of a Cliff's Notes to progressive education in the form of a fictitious principal's informal remarks to parents: www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/back-to-school
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
New research confirms that believing in conspiracy theories is likely to generate a negative attitude toward vaccines (despite overwhelming evidence of their efficacy and safety), but, interestingly, it's even more likely to work the other way around: journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/19485506231181659
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A psychologist explaining why punishment backfires was interrupted by a skeptical teacher who had been assigned a kid with a police record. "I held him on a short leash to keep him out of trouble. And I know my strictness worked: Right after he left my class he was back in jail!"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
US share of the world's population: 4%
US share of the world's military spending: 37% (>183 of the other 193 countries combined)(www.sipri.org/sites/default/files/2024-04/2404_fs_milex_2…)
US share of weapons sales: 42% (www.statista.com/statistics/267131/market-share-of-the-le…)
US share of foreign military bases: 75-85% (www.overseasbases.net/fact-sheet.html) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Early-childhood expert Lilian Katz: "Intellectual dispositions may be weakened or even damaged by excessive and premature formal instruction": deyproject.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/dey-l…. (That all-important distinction between the intellectual & the merely academic applies to students of all ages.)
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Faced with people who are so myopic & absolutist as to equate Biden with Trump - and shrug off the urgency of stopping the GOP's authoritarian cult - I imagine them insisting that vegetarians are also no different from carnivores because both consume carbon-based forms of life.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From worst to best: curriculum designed by...
1) distant authorities
2) the teacher, well in advance
3) the teacher, for these particular students
4) the teacher, WITH these particular students -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Jonathan Haidt's latest book on kids recycles his earlier claims about overparenting (widely shared beliefs that I debunked in The Myth of the Spoiled Child: www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0807073881/wwwalfiekohorg) & adds an indictment of social media that may be on equally shaky ground: www.thedailybeast.com/the-coddling-of-the-american-parent
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Dems: Climate change is a serious threat. Immigrants and trans kids are human beings. Stop cops from shooting unarmed Blacks.
GOP: Distribute assault weapons to all white Christians. Install Trump as Pharaoh. Let embryos vote.
Media: We're so polarized! Extremists on both sides! -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
More evidence of spanking's harmful effects: A new longitudinal study of poorer countries confirms that corporal punishment leads to "lower levels of social-emotional competencies," including empathy, self-regulation, and healthy social interactions": www.psypost.org/longitudinal-study-provides-more-evidence…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Currently popular idiom that I could do without: "It's almost as if X!", which is a snarky way of saying, "X is obviously true, as even a moron like you should realize."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Alan Schoenfeld observed that very few exercises given to high school math students deserve to be called problems. In this classic article, he describes a geometry class that checks all the boxes for successful teaching...except it involves no real math: jwilson.coe.uga.edu/TiMER/Schoenfeld (1988) Good Teach Ba…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Trump’s conservative defenders are attempting something extraordinary: to politically normalize abnormal psychology. Their sycophancy enables a sickness" - and it's a sickness that may take down our country.
This 2017 column is even more relevant today: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/how-to-handle-an-unhinged… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A recent review of research confirms multiple benefits of "looping" - that is, having a teacher stay with a class of students for more than one year: www.edworkingpapers.com/ai22-590
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/7 Time for my periodic reminder about one of the most important educational research findings of the 20th century: the Eight-Year Study.
Back in the 1930s, 30 high schools around the U.S. turned traditional practice on its head, especially for college-bound students...Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
6/7 Many factors can explain why these remarkable findings were largely ignored and why high schools are still so traditional today. But now we know that it's not because students need, or even benefit from, those conventional practices in order to succeed in college...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
7/7 Want more? Track down the 5-vol. series "Adventure in American Ed." by various authors, esp. vol. 1 (W. Aiken, "The Story of the 8 Yr Study": archive.org/details/storyoftheeighty009637mbp); & vol. 4 (D. Chamberlin et al., "Did They Succeed in College?"). And this summary: files.ascd.org/staticfiles/ascd/pdf/journals/ed_lead/el_1….
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
One of the all-time great NYT letters to the editor
@karaswisher @doctorow -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
When a reward or punishment fails to produce the desired effect, we fault the specific rew/pun rather than the whole idea of behavior control. It's like when a new commodity doesn't bring lasting satisfaction: We look for something else to buy rather than questioning materialism.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3 Andrew Hacker pointed out that making all high schoolers take advanced math classes (which lacks academic justification) just creates "lifelong tracking" because those who can't hack these classes may be denied a diploma. (See his book The Math Myth: www.amazon.com/Math-Myth-Other-STEM-Delusions/dp/16209739….)
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3 Stanford's @JoBoaler (author of the excellent What's Math Got to Do With It?) has worked hard to challenge such pointless and inequitable curricular requirements, and now she's being attacked with anonymous accusations: www.youcubed.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/Boaler-Statem…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3 This appears to be another example of the striking overlap between reactionary views on education (a "bunch o' facts" curriculum, direct instruction, the deeply dishonest SOR campaign, behavior management, etc.) and anti-DEI & other right-wing political causes.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
People who fell for a grift used to get angry with the sleazeball who suckered them or with themselves for being a sap. With these folks, it's "Please, sir, may I have another" - or "May I keep funding your psychopathology and your assault on democracy?" - www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2024/04/14/truth-social…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Great to see a cooperative version of Scrabble (www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2024/apr/09/new-cooperat…), but I winced at the framing. Lots of us want to have fun w/o trying to beat others: www.alfiekohn.org/article/coop-games/. Doesn't mean we're "intimidated" by competition; actually, coop games are no less challenging.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The Onion: "In a statistical analysis comparing the U.S. to other industrialized nations, a new report released by McKinsey & Co. found that American children were severely behind in age...'There are too many American children who are 11 or 12 years old who should really be 17.'"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
A few highly rejective colleges that were test-optional during covid are now requiring the SAT/ACT again. Press coverage ignores the fact that the vast majority - ~2,000 schls - are still test-optional or won't even look at scores. Bad for the College Board; great for kids.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
As for claims that the SAT (1) predicts academic performance better than grades or (2) promotes diversity, read these 4 responses:
* www.newamerica.org/insights/a-fight-over-the-future-of-th…
* fairtest.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/TestOptionalRepor…
* jonboeckenstedt.net/2024/01/22/what-you-have-to-believe/
* Geiser & Atkinson's letter to the NYT: www.nytimes.com/2024/01/27/opinion/sat-tests.html -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I don't want to seem immodest, but I think my data-based criticisms of behaviorism and traditional pedagogy are really beginning to persuade all the sexbots that have chosen to follow my account.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
When, if ever, is it valid to invoke the paternalistic concept of "false consciousness," which holds that people can be misguided about what's in their own best interests - e.g., willing to renounce their autonomy/agency? This article has me pondering: www.washingtonpost.com/style/power/2024/04/10/tradwives-s…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The idea "that greatness comes from inner demons is the simplistic trope often used by those seeking to explain their bad behavior and casual cruelties."
-Kara Swisher -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Economists consistently misunderstand and distort education, but, lacking humility, crank out a ton of research and commentary on the subject. From the archives: "School Would Be Great If It Weren't for the Damn Kids": www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/school-great-werent-damn-kids/
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Related: a terrific 2022 critique of the "economic style of reasoning" that Emily Oster brings to decisions about education, parenting, & covid policy, the individualistic premises of which have endeared her to conservative activists and funders: proteanmag.com/2022/03/22/motivated-reasoning-emily-oster…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"At universities across the country, any criticism of Israel’s policies...or even pedagogy on the recent history of the land have emerged as perilous speech....What [many don't know] is that speech critical of Israel’s occupation...has long been censored": www.nytimes.com/2024/04/05/opinion/free-speech-academic-f…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Lest educational reactionaries try to rehabilitate the deeply dishonest - but, alas, hugely influential - "Nation at Risk" report, here are 3 (of many) critiques worth reading on its 40th anniversary:
- www.washingtonpost.com/education/2023/04/26/how-nationatr…
- radicalscholarship.com/2024/02/23/big-lies-of-education-a…
- www.huffpost.com/entry/were-a-nation-at-risk-hap_b_94519 -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Remind me - what time is today's eclipse?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"What gets tested gets taught"? Maybe, but it gets taught *badly* because the point is to raise scores rather than to promote thinking. And from a student's point of view, learning in order to do well on a test is a qualitatively different mindset from learning for its own sake.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Every time people refer to "communications" as "comms," or to "close of business" as "COB," I find myself wondering what they're planning to do with all the hundreds of hours they've presumably saved as a result of using those indispensable abbreviations.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3 After my conference talks, people come up to me & tell stories about a classrm or parenting experience. I used to assume they wanted my take on the incident, but I began to hold off offering any response other than sympathy until explicitly asked for it. Which rarely happens.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3 Obviously it doesn't make sense to offer an opinion to someone who isn't interested. What took me awhile to realize was that I was incorrectly inferring interest - and, more generally, that people often just want someone to listen to them (and, sometimes, to take their side).
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3 Related: School administrators often take me on tours of their school before I speak to the faculty. I can count on the fingers of one hand those who have asked for critical feedback of what I've seen (e.g., "How could our school be better?") The vast majority just brag.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Once you learn to speak Pig Latin, why not move on to Pig Latin Latin: “arpay-cay iem-day”
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
What parenting practice at age 3 makes it more likely that the child at age 5 will be disobedient, demanding, and mean? Permissiveness? Nope, guess again. It's spanking. Why? Because a kid "learns to be aggressive by being treated with aggression": www.researchgate.net/profile/Shawna-Lee-2/publication/431…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"One doesn't want to live as though each day may be his last when there is some chance that it may be only his next."
- John Barth (1930-2024) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"By defining reading as mastery of arbitrary skill sequences, pupils who read widely & with good comprehension may be undervalued, while pupils who perform well on isolated skill tests but who can't or don't care to read are lulled into complacency."
- the late Ken Goodman -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Lots of research shows that competition often leads people to act unethically. This study explains why, focusing on long-standing rivalries where more is at stake, psychologically speaking: w4.stern.nyu.edu/facdir/sworthen/kilduffpublications/amjw…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Industrialized extermination" with the help of AI.
Arnaud Bertrand
@RnaudBertrand
This is without a doubt one of the most important pieces of reporting on Gaza, and by far one of the most disturbing: www.972mag.com/lavender-ai-israeli-army-gaza/
All by Israeli journalist @yuval_abraham based on whistleblower accounts from within the IDF and intelligence agencies.
Israel has developed an AI called "Lavender" to generate kill lists, with almost no human verification to double check the targets selected by the machine: only a a “rubber stamp” check of about “20 seconds” just to make sure the AI target is male.
Moreover, the Israeli army "systematically attacked the targeted individuals while they were in their homes — usually at night while their whole families were present — rather than during the course of military activity". In fact Israel developed another automated system called “Where’s Daddy?” used "specifically to track the targeted individuals and carry out bombings when they had entered their family’s residences" 🤮
One of the intelligence officers who spoke to Abraham is quoted in the article: “We were not interested in killing [Hamas] operatives only when they were in a military building or engaged in a military activity. On the contrary, the IDF bombed them in homes without hesitation, as a first option. It’s much easier to bomb a family’s home. The system is built to look for them in these situations.”
In fact the article reveals a ratio, I think for the first time: "according to two of the sources, the army also decided during the first weeks of the war that, for every junior Hamas operative that Lavender marked, it was permissible to kill up to 15 or 20 civilians... The sources added that, in the event that the target was a senior Hamas official with the rank of battalion or brigade commander, the army on several occasions authorized the killing of more than 100 civilians in the assassination of a single commander."
A ratio of 20 civilians killed for one target works out to about 95% civilian deaths.
Please do read the whole article as it describes in details how the whole process works with the Lavender AI. It's industrialized extermination the likes of which we haven't seen since... you know when. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A "deeply divided nation"? No. Try a "decent nation under electoral assault from a violent seditionist minority": www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/archive/2024/04/supportin…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Calling attention to the vintage of our whines (i.e., how long our gripes have been fermenting): My take on the canards that morality & the quality of parenting & schools have declined: "Aggressive Nostalgia: The Dark Side of Pining for the Good Old Days": www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/aggressive-nostalgia/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
If a child skipped schl or “engaged in the mental truancy of mind-wandering, & [developed a] revulsion agst the subject, he was held to be at fault. No question was raised as to whether the trouble might lie in the subject-matter or the way in which it was offered.”
- Dewey, 1938 -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
If I had my way, every article in the popular press about research findings and recommended practices related to schooling would have to be accompanied by this caveat:
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
"Phrases such as 'higher achievement,' 'positive outcomes,' & 'better results' refer only to standardized test scores. These are poor indicators of intellectual proficiency and primarily measure socioeconomic status or the extent of students' training in test-taking skills." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Three of my favorite book titles:
- E.M. Cioran, "The Trouble with Being Born" [philosophy]
- Leslie Farber, "Lying, Despair, Jealousy, Envy, Sex, Suicide, Drugs, & the Good Life" [psychology]
- Lewis Frumkes, "How to Raise Your IQ by Eating Gifted Children" [humor (presumably)] -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Complaints about having to choose between Biden & Trump (as if they were remotely comparable), remind me of David Sedaris' analogy: Flight attendant asks, "Would you like the chicken...or the human feces w/broken glass in it?" Passenger replies, "Well, how is the chicken cooked?"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Kafka's last wish was for everything he wrote to be burned. Gabriel García Márquez told his sons to destroy his last novel. Me, I'm going the other way. "Kids," I'll whisper on my deathbed, "Dig out all those manuscripts in my desk and for god's sake get them published!"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
On Effective Altruism, longtermism, harmful side effects of GiveWell charities, the use of "expected value as a life hack for morality" (embraced by the felonious Sam Bankman-Fried), & self-congratulatory tech bros who say they get rich to save the poor: www.wired.com/story/deaths-of-effective-altruism/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From the archives: "Dewey, Piaget, and Frosted Mini Wheats" - a meditation on why sugarcoating is best avoided, both literally (in cereals) and figuratively (in education): www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/sugarcoating/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Another example of how a reality we take for granted may not be universal or inevitable: In some countries, (tuition-free) public universities are generally high-quality & prestigious, while (expensive) private universities are for those who couldn't get into a public institution
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Much as the violent Jan. 6 insurrectionists were aided by GOP politicians & lawyers who used other methods to keep Trump in office after he lost, so Israel's mass-killing of civilians is aided by a propaganda campaign to dismiss critics of its ongoing massacre as anti-Semitic.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"But are we subjecting kids to a sufficiently 'rigorous' education?" Responding to this myopic preoccupation, one Chicago mom helpfully suggested that we could measure rigor with "a value-added assessment of the quantity of tears children produce while doing their homework."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3
Standard studying methods like retrieval practice may help with rote recall, but a new pair of studies finds that, for more ambitious learning goals (like being able to create new questions), it's more effective for students to teach someone else: www.sarahshihuiwong.com/_files/ugd/8b1a2f_76e33cd7e068453…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3
1st, though, let's make sure our goal really is "meaningful learning...creating & discovering new knowledge, [not only] deriving answers to teachers' questions." Alas, enthusiasm over retrieval practice often equates learning with mere fact retention: www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/tests-really-help-students-learn-…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3
I'm reminded of the work some of us were doing long ago on the value of cooperative learning, with kids in pairs or small groups. The new studies confirm what was discovered back then: When done well, CL and peer tutoring benefit the tutor as well as the tutee. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The Onion: Kids explain how their woke schools are brainwashing them:
* "They're trying to convince me the slaves my ancestors owned were slaves"
* "My teachers make me feel guilty about bringing my gun to school"
* "I no longer feel any joy when people get killed by the police” -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3 A short essay about how our promiscuous use of diagnostic labels implies that just about everyone has a psychological disorder. We end up not only pigeonholing people but pathologizing a normal range of behavior: www.theguardian.com/books/2021/oct/18/the-big-idea-is-it-…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3 Here's a related (and, I think, thoughtful & balanced) reflection on "semantic creep": how the too-casual use of terms like "trauma," "abuse," and "gaslighting" - again, regularly applied to ordinary adversities - do a disservice to real victims: www.nytimes.com/2022/02/04/opinion/caleb-love-bombing-gas…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3 Update: The newest example of therapyspeak being used indiscriminately is applying "dysregulation" to anyone who gets upset: www.thecut.com/article/mental-health-managing-dysregulate….
(This may reflect a broader trend of biological reductionism, which I wrote about here: www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/brain-scan/.) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
To criticize grading mostly because extraneous stuff (like students' conduct) is factored into what should be only about academic performance is like walking into a cafeteria full of moldy food & objecting to the fact that potatoes are classified as a protein rather than a starch
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Let's hear it for the world leader in self-sufficiency, self-care, looking out for #1, personal empowerment, and minimizing collective responsibility in the name of individual liberty: www.apa.org/pubs/journals/releases/amp-amp0001322.pdf.
Bonus reading: www.psypost.org/mayo-clinic-study-links-social-isolation-… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The religious right's long-range plan is for the courts (& Republican legislatures) to do to birth control what they've done to abortion rights. Meanwhile, they're on social media, "sowing misinformation as a way to discourage the use of birth control": www.washingtonpost.com/health/2024/03/21/stopping-birth-c…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I just updated my recent critique of Cognitive Load Theory (www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/clt/) to cite this 2022 essay by British cognitive scientist @GuyClaxton, which I just stumbled on: www.guyclaxton.net/post/cognitive-load-theory-just-brain-….
Read the 1st few paragraphs here:
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Also see Claxton's new post: www.guyclaxton.net/post/the-sciences-of-learning-and-the-…. Experts, he says, realize that "there is no generally accepted core of knowledge that is 'the science of learning.'"
And this: "Relentless explicit teaching may well stunt the development" of curiosity, independence, etc. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Humility: "I'm unsettled by nontraditional gender and sexual identities, so I'm going to try to figure out what's going on with me that might explain that reaction."
Opposite of humility: "...so I'm going to condemn, ridicule, and persecute the people whom I find unsettling." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
This is...quite a chart.
(It's from a new Nature article by social epidemiologists called "Why the World Cannot Afford the Rich": idp.nature.com/transit?redirect_uri=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nat….) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 One underlying theme of all rewards and punishments is power: Those who have it use them to control those who don't. Another, less obvious premise is mistrust: To rely on bribes or threats is to assume the recipients will respond only to extrinsic inducements.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2 Note that defenders of behavior control also tend to demand direct, explicit instruction. Makes sense because that, too, is rooted in distrust - in this case, of kids as learners. This sour cynicism is then rationalized as realism; those who demur are dismissed as Romantics.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
If the Powers That Be decided to start making kids memorize the dictionary - in the name of "rigor," "college readiness," and a "content-rich curriculum" - we'd start to see workshops & apps called “Best Practices for Implementing the New Competency-Based Dictionary Assessments.”
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Are climate scientists so concerned about making sure we remain hopeful that they're being less than honest about how quickly things are actually going downhill and how remote the prospects are that the necessary steps will be taken? jonathonporritt.com/mainstream-climate-science-the-new-de…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
If you own a late-model car, it is quietly collecting detailed data about you and selling that data to other corporations and/or to your insurance company. Three important reads: * www.mozillafoundation.org/en/privacynotincluded/articles/…
* themarkup.org/the-breakdown/2022/07/27/who-is-collecting-…
* www.nytimes.com/2024/03/11/technology/carmakers-driver-tr… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"If religious instruction were not allowed until children had attained the age of reason, we would be living in a quite different world."
-Christopher Hitchens -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A researcher who discovered that the benefits of academically oriented pre-K classrooms quickly fade and even turn negative explains in simple language how that happens & why a "scripted, academically focused curriculum" for young children makes no sense: dey.org/early-developmental-competencies-or-why-pre-k-doe…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
- You're not rich and yet you graduated from a good college without crippling loans. How is that possible?
- Simple. Unlike These Kids Today, I took some responsibility! I made the decision to be born back when school was much more affordable. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Learning should be seen as a qualitative change in a person's way of seeing, experiencing, understanding, conceptualizing something in the real world - rather than as a quantitative change in the amount of knowledge someone possesses."
-Paul Ramsden (Australian educator) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 One of my favorite nature/nurture studies had people watch a video of a diapered baby. Those told that the baby was a boy were more likely to hear its crying as anger; those told it was a girl were more likely to hear the same sound as fear: www.yumpu.com/en/document/view/2169738/sex-differences-a-…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2 It's not just that we - notably parents - *treat* kids differently based on their biological sex, thereby shaping gender differences (which are often assumed to be inborn). It's that what we literally see and hear are, in part, constructions based on our gender stereotypes.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
An epiphany in the library led Terry Jones (of Monty Python fame) to ditch English lit grad school: "I suddenly thought, 'Why am I getting so emotionally outraged by what someone else has written about what someone else has written about what someone else originally wrote?'"
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A character in a Lorrie Moore story who, like Jones, attended grad school in English lit says, "I read Derrida. I read Lacan. I read 'Reading Lacan.' I read 'Reading "Reading Lacan"' - and that's when I applied to library school."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Have you noticed that more educators are using the word "assessments" when they just mean tests? Either they're euphemizing (like substituting "consequences" for "punishments") or they're inadvertently revealing their ignorance of other, better ways to assess than tests.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
For more: "Why the Best Teachers Don't Give Tests" - www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/no-tests/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
When someone says, "I don't want to interrupt...", that means he or she has decided to interrupt.
Similarly, I've come to realize, "Well, that sounds nice in theory..." actually means "I don't even like the theory." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
They're at it again: www.nytimes.com/2024/03/08/us/sat-online-digital-test-col…
After the last "major overhaul" of the SAT in 2002, I published this in the NY Times:
Revising is to SAT as
(a) reformulating is to Coke
(b) repackaging is to Beta-Max
(c) renaming is to Philip Morris
(d) repainting is to Pinto
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In its characteristically hard-hitting reporting, the only critical comment in the new NYT piece is a quote from someone who fears the reading passages are now too short. To dig deeper into what's wrong with the SAT itself, see this @FairTestOffice report: fairtest.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/TestOptionalRepor…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Any use of control - not just rewards & punishments but also simple coercion - can undermine subsequent intrinsic motivation. One of many examples: Requiring community service may reduce volunteering later, when kids have a choice: www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0272775713000848
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
This (ffrf.org/uploads/images/NYT-Wrath_of_God-24-Web.pdf) is exactly right: While media coverage of the Alabama Supreme Court ruling has focused almost exclusively on the threat to IVF availability, it - along with US Supreme Court decisions & legislation in GOP states - is chilling for a deeper reason.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
ICYMI - My new blog summarizes the extensive research confirming the benefits of progressive education, and it also debunks a concept used by traditionalists to disparage it: "Cognitive Load Theory: An Unpersuasive Attempt to Justify Direct Instruction": www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/clt/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A series of 3 useful posts (containing a ton of research citations) by literacy expert Maren Aukerman on how egregious media bias & ignorance have fueled the Science of Reading propaganda campaign:
literacyresearchassociation.org/stories/the-science-of-re…
literacyresearchassociation.org/stories/the-science-of-re…
literacyresearchassociation.org/stories/the-science-of-re…
Excerpts:
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The 2nd post explains why SOR advocates' attacks on "balanced literacy" & on what they call "three-cueing" are utterly misinformed.
Ironically, what's billed as science diminishes "the impact of real research on classroom practice, due in large part to lack of quality reporting" -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I used to assume I was a good teacher because I knew what I was talking about, I enjoyed what I was talking about, and I was a good talker. Only much later did I realize the problem was my assumption that teaching mostly involves talking (& my tendency to do way too much of it).
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
“Class participation” isn’t a single entity. As usual, we need to look beyond observable, quantifiable behavior: Is it real engagement (wondering aloud) or just an effort to impress the teacher? (Hint: If you're grading it, it's very likely to be the latter.)
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Too many educators, intimidated by the magic phrase "science of learning," swallow dubious claims by proponents of traditional teaching. My new blog post looks at one example: "Cognitive Load Theory: An Unpersuasive Attempt to Justify Direct Instruction" - www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/clt/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
My new blog post - "Cognitive Load Theory: An Unpersuasive Attempt to Justify Direct Instruction" - dissects another dubious effort to undermine progressive education by invoking the magic phrase "science of learning." (Warning: footnotes galore!)
www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/clt/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
What if, next to the "Like" button, there was a button that meant "Thanks for challenging me with something I didn't already believe to be true"?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Amazing coincidence: Statements by all 6 candidates for local office in my town suggest that every one of them will prioritize sound fiscal managementat at this pivotal moment & will also take a proactive role based on our shared values to develop a framework for sustainability!
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
“Little learning is retained when it is learned on command.”
-Jean Piaget -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Chomsky once began a book with the story of how Alexander the Great was reaming out a pirate for molesting the sea, and the pirate replied, "I do that with a little ship, so I'm called a thief; you molest the whole world with a huge navy, so you're called an emperor."
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
Now imagine a kid telling a traditional teacher, "If I threaten and intimidate kids who are weaker than I am in order to make them do whatever I want, it's called bullying. You do basically the same thing all the time, and it's called discipline or classroom management."
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A small study (eric.ed.gov?id=EJ450895) suggests that teachers’ classroom management strategies are predicted by their own childhood experiences. Those who punish students are more likely to have been punished themselves & discouraged from questioning parental authority.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Some parenting books promote “reflective listening” so kids know they’ve been heard but tend to oversell the technique, suggesting it has magical powers to produce instant results:
Child: "That is so unfair! You always do this to me! I hate you!!!" (bursts into tears)...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
... Parent: "Hmmm. It sounds like you think what I’ve proposed isn’t fair. That makes you feel angry, doesn’t it?"
Child: "Yes! (sniffs) But…well…I guess I can live with it. (pause) Gosh, thanks for taking the time to understand me! I feel all better now!" -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Autocrats warn that only their iron fist protects us from anarchy. (In this binary view, democracy isn't an option.) So, too, for classroom traditionalists/behaviorists, who justify bribe-&-threat control of kids by invoking the specter of chaos, as if that's the only alternative
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/6 Nuggets from Postman & Weingartner's classic book "Teaching as a Subversive Activity" (www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0385290098/wwwalfiekohorg), which I recently reread:
- Why do students almost never take notes on what other students say, no matter how insightful their comments are?Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
5/6
- Grades reflect *our* characteristics and behavior as much as the students'. If "you give the lowest grades to those students you least understand, then the problem is yours, not theirs. Each time you give a grade to a student, grade your own perception of that student."
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
6/6
- "The enthusiasm that community leaders show for an educational innovation is inversely related to its significance to learning." (Related: Ed tech just does "all the old school stuff better.")
- "All authorities get nervous when learning is conducted without a syllabus." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The word "sensitive" has two very different meanings: quick to take offense (easily hurt) vs. perceptive of others' feelings (empathic). It's fascinating to meet people who are very sensitive in the 1st sense but not in the 2nd - what a friend once described as needy porcupines.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Now accepting suggestions for possible updates to the sexist expression "separate the men from the boys" (referring to a particularly challenging situation). Currently I'm leaning toward "separate the periodontists from the general-practice dentists"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I once discussed the biological determinism lurking within "brain-based" ed. (www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/brain-scan/).
G. Coles adds that there are political implications to attributing the plight of low-income kids to poor self-control (executive functioning issues): www.counterpunch.org/2018/06/01/billionaires-want-poor-ch… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"We use caffeine to make up for a sleep deficit that is largely the result of using caffeine." -Michael Pollan
(Apt analogy for how traditional rewards-and-punishment discipline provokes kids into doing the very things that we then claim make such discipline necessary.) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The Bible-based Ala. Supreme Court decision that equates microscopic clumps of embryonic cells with "children" is hair-raising not just because it would eliminate IVF but because it reflects a march to theocracy that the U.S. Supreme Court may not block: threadreaderapp.com/thread/1760711870942695432.html
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
What does deep-thinking, inquiry-based learning look like in a (diverse) high schl? Show this ½-hr video about Urban Academy at a faculty meeting or prof dev session to help teachers in all subject areas move beyond force-feeding facts to passive students: vimeo.com/590281072
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Dancing in circles, kibbutzim, wars only because hostile neighbors forced them on us: That was what the typical American Jewish education taught us Israel was all about." Then @RickPerlstein learned about another foundational feature of Zionism's past & present. Worth a read.
moe tkacik
@moetkacik
rarely is an historian humble enough to admit he didn't know anything about the history of [topic] until the horror of [paradigm shifting event] inspired him to dig into its origins; @rickperlstein wields true humility & pulls off something profound here
prospect.org/world/2024-02-21-neglected-history-state-of-… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"I'll take TRADITIONAL EDUCATION for 200, please."
"And the answer is: 'A school assignment to list the major themes of each chapter in a classic novel'"
"Ah, what is, 'What's a reliable way to destroy students' interest in literature?'"
"Correct!" -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 Betteridge's Law holds that any headline ending in a question mark can be answered with "no."
A few of many examples from this past year:
* New Yorker 1/21: "Have We Already Been Visited by Aliens?"
* New Yorker 8/21: "Did Spacemen Build the Pyramids?"Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
More support for Betteridge's Law of Headlines in Dec.:
Boston Globe: "Decades of Climate Science Haven't Solved the Problem. Can the Royal Family?"
NY'er: "Should Local Police Departments Deploy Lethal Robots?"
Wash Post: "The UN Is Sending Ukrainians Aid in Crypto. Should It?"
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
And still more support for Betteridge's Law of headlines:
Wired, Dec. 2023: "Will Life Be Better in the Metaverse?"
Marketwatch, Feb. 2024: "Trump's limited-edition sneakers are already being listed for up to $45K on eBay, but can they hold their value?" -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
something something not from The Onion something something shifting Overton window something something frog in boiling water...
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From sociologist Robert Bellah et al., a timely observation (but a tough sell in a society that overvalues self-sufficiency):
"Education can never merely be for the sake of individual self-enhancement. It pulls us into the common world or it fails altogether." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Well, the results have been tabulated, and this year, once again, the most popular final paragraph in newspaper feature stories is
"'I guess we'll just have to wait and see,' he said." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A few examples of what you're agreeing to let those companies (Facebook, Amazon, Spotify, YouTube, Pinterest, etc.) do when you click on "I have read and agree to the Terms of Service" even though you really haven't: tosdr.org
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Tens of millions of Americans live in an alternate reality where the more of his crimes he's held accountable for, the more it just shows he's being persecuted.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/4 An impressive long-term study shows the harms of overly controlling parenting, remarkably connecting the perception of such control by one's parents at age 13 with relationship difficulties and lower educational attainment nearly two decades later: www.researchgate.net/publication/342213808_Perceived_Psyc…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/4 "Adolescents who perceive their parents to be psychologically controlling are likely to...steer away from close relationships [as adults, based on having learned that such relationships] are sources of stress and that closeness comes at a cost"...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/4 Also, "adolescents who experience manipulative pressure from parents are likely to avoid difficult situations rather than approach them, as they have likely acquired a more negative concept of themselves (i.e., as not...able to think for themselves)."
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/4 Side note: Don't confuse parents who manipulate kids (e.g., via conditional love, praise, guilt-induction) with those whom conservatives deride as overly indulgent ("helicopter parents"). Research on the former is far clearer and more damning: www.alfiekohn.org/article/hp/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
It's striking how many people fail to understand that quantified evaluations, such as standardized tests and rubrics, are no more objective than narratives & other qualitative appraisals. They just use numbers to conceal the subjective judgments that underpin them.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
NYer's new piece (www.newyorker.com/science/annals-of-medicine/the-argument…) asks if criticism of #aba has "gone too far" but offers no real reason to think it has. In all, I think the article's coverage of those criticisms will surprise readers who have never heard them & falsely assume ABA is "evidence-based."
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
NYTPitchbot
@DougJBalloon
At a weekend rally, Biden rambled for over an hour, sometimes repeating things he’d said earlier. At his own rally, Trump commanded the stage for an impressive 67 minutes, circling back to selected sentences and paragraphs to reiterate his point.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Linda Darling-Hammond: "If we taught babies to talk the way that most skills are taught in school, they would memorize lists of sounds in a predetermined order and practice them alone in a closet."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
My book "The Myth of the Spoiled Child" (www.alfiekohn.org/myth-spoiled-child/) challenged ideologically driven warnings about overparenting. Now new data confirm that greater parental involvement is typically neither detrimental for, nor unwelcome by, kids: www.nytimes.com/2024/02/09/upshot/parenting-young-adults-…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Of course I'd be watching the Puppy Bowl (www.discovery.com/shows/puppy-bowl) tonight anyway - and no, not just for the ASPCA PSAs. But it's exciting that the girlfriend of one of the Schnauzer wide-fetchers - a well-known barker in her own right - will be at the event.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A highly relatable observation from my friend Debbie Meier: “I live so much in a world that disagrees with me that sometimes I over-cling to people on my wavelength.”
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
What if teachers were subjected to the kind of rewards-based classroom-management system (including a behavior chart) that's commonly used to control students? This thread describes the eye-opening results of a brief, informal experiment: threadreaderapp.com/thread/1755986519376978189.html
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
Onion headline: "Elite Selective Hospital Only Accepts 9% of ICU Applicants."
But peel back the satire: In a humane and egalitarian society, maybe selectivity makes no more sense for an institution whose charge is to educate than it does for one whose charge is to cure...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
My essay on this, with special reference to private K-12 schools: www.alfiekohn.org/article/admit-deny/. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
So if I remember my Freudian theory, this means that Thomas skipped oral arguments and proceeded directly to phallic arguments
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Someone should write a book for kids called How to Handle Your Difficult Parents
Possible chapters: "The Behavioral Challenges of the Middle-Aged Brain," "How to Be Caring but Firm in Resisting a Controlling Parent," "When Mom or Dad's Self-Esteem Hinges on Your Accomplishments" -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
“This product helps improve your students’ reading scores, but it may make them hate reading forever.” Yong Zhao explains the disturbing side effects of many supposedly "evidence-based" educational policies.
Book: www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0807759058/wwwalfiekohorg.
Article: zhaolearning.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/SideEffectsPu… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 The entrance area that greets visitors to a typical American high school contains two things: evidence (in the form of trophies) that its students triumphed over students from other schools + plaques listing which of its students are better than others.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2 Suggested assignment (for administrators, teachers, and kids): Design a school lobby that reflects a commitment to collaboration and community rather than to sorting and triumphing.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3 Some of us never fell for the hype about "flipped" classrooms, which were hailed as innovative just because the time and place for traditional techniques was reversed, with mandatory lecture-based homework and practice problems at school.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3 Those who quickly realized the emperor actually had no new clothes (e.g., mmanderino.blogspot.com/2011/09/lecture-by-any-other-name…, theinnovativeeducator.blogspot.com/2012/12/why-flips-flop…) won't be shocked to see confirmation of flipping's reactionary premises as Sal Khan now enthuses about having bots teach kids: www.nytimes.com/2024/01/11/technology/ai-chatbots-khan-ed…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3 Khan reportedly was inspired by Neal Stephenson's sci-fi novel "The Diamond Age" in which a device monitors and analyzes students' voices and faces.
Jesus - we're in thrall to bros who, presented with dystopias, regard them as utopias. (Particularly if they're profitable.)
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The trouble with #ai's application to ed. recapitulates the trouble with dead-end ed. traditionalism more generally: It disempowers learners by "delivering" instruction & focuses on clearcut problems w/ right answers, says @Scratch inventor Mitch Resnick: mres.medium.com/ai-and-creative-learning-concerns-opportu…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
BTW, the gratuitous and rather creepy way that AI is designed not merely to perform its tasks but to try and simulate human qualities (which Resnick also mentions in his essay) reminds me of efforts to fashion vegetarian ingredients into something that resembles meat. Must we?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
True. And it's much the same story for the illiberalism and violent bigotry in India, Israel, and Indonesia - except a different religion animates the evil in each case.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I just figured out something that every other living human must have known: Hawaii Five-O presumably took its name (& that of the police force it featured) from the fact that Hawaii is the 50th state.
But why is this not a thing in every state, right on down to "Delaware Oh-One"? -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Chomsky once commented that US corporations are “as totalitarian an institution as humans have managed so far to contrive.” This seems particularly true of Big Tech, not only in how they're run but in the unconstrained power over us that they demand: www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2024/03/facebook-met…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Going into grad school: "I want to explore how people develop their political beliefs!"
Cut to: 8 years later, dissertation finally finished: "Belcher's Model of Sociopolitical Identity: The Case of Hungarian-American Adolescent Males in Wheeling, WV - 1924-1926" -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The great political divide (and moral litmus test): When you talk about immigration, do you think first about the human beings - desperate refugees who have uprooted and risked their lives to escape violence or immiseration? Or about how to fortify Our borders to keep Them out?
Andrew Lawrence
@ndrew_lawrence
express your horror at this now before the people who are going to defend it get out of church
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"You may not know what it feels like to be undocumented or unhoused or 14 years old & forced to carry a pregnancy to term; democracy, though - and basic decency - asks you to imagine the feeling. Trump, by contrast, absolves you of the need to try."
-Megan Garber -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Fascinating study of academic cheating shows that it's predicted by (the absence of) need fulfillment, which in turn reflects how kids are taught: goo.gl/dGDKQc. Of course this is inconvenient for adults who'd rather just blame & punish the students who cheat...
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Each generation experiences the fashion of the one immediately preceding it as the most radical antiaphrodisiac imaginable."
- Walter Benjamin -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Anthropologist and former college president Judith Shapiro once pointed out that the most compelling reason to get a good education is that it makes “the inside of your head an interesting place to spend the rest of your life."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Question from Levitsky & Ziblatt's book "How Democracies Die" that I can't stop thinking about: How many societies in all of human history have managed to be both multiracial and truly democratic?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 Can Trump's popularity be explained by the prevalence in our society of basic values that are extrinsic: power, fame, wealth, winning (www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/jan/29/donald-trum…)? These are values that he obviously exemplifies - and that bode poorly for mental health: www.alfiekohn.org/article/pursuit-affluence-high-price/.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2 Incidentally, earlier research confirmed that Republicans are more likely than Democrats to endorse these extrinsic values: onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1559-1816.2009.…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Rather than having kids write about their heroes, teachers could ask them to reflect on Brecht's remark: “Unhappy is the land that needs a hero.” (Or, from Ben Smith: "The alternative to heroes are strong institutions & a recognition that the people who work in them are human.")
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Unusual psych journal article documents "how the aims & practices that typify American corporate capitalism often conflict w/pursuits such as caring about the broader world, having close relationships w/others, and, for many people, feeling worthy & free": selfdeterminationtheory.org/SDT/documents/2007_KasserKann…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Does Applied Behavior Analysis basically amount to training children with autism as if they were pets? Hell no, replies a dog trainer: ABA is actually much worse than that - neuroclastic.com/is-aba-really-dog-training-for-children-…. (This may explain why it seems that autistic people uniformly detest it.)
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Mehdi Hasan
@mehdirhasan
Much more important than the 83 million dollar verdict is the recognition from a member of the U.S. judiciary that Trump and his supporters remain a violent threat to ordinary Americans.
erica orden
@eorden
Judge Kaplan, to jurors: "My advice to you is that you never disclose that you were on this jury."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
My favorite lyric by the folksinger Melanie, who died this week: "A thing is a phallic symbol if it's longer than it's wide." That line comes to mind whenever I come across another reductive pronouncement by a literary or cinematic critic.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In my bk Unconditional Parenting I challenged the belief that parents in dangerous neighborhoods must control & punish their kids to protect them: www.alfiekohn.org/article/discipline-and-race/. A recent study shows that such parenting is damaging even (or esp.) in such places: selfdeterminationtheory.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/20…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Yes, children facing racism and other perils may need more structure or closer monitoring, but that doesn't mean they benefit from controlling or authoritarian parenting. In fact, the chance for kids to participate in making decisions may be MOST important in tough areas.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
High, stable self-esteem confers sufficient comfort that you can learn from others, freely admit what you don't know and when you're wrong . By contrast, this is what desperate overcompensation for deep insecurity looks like: twitter.com/politvidchannel/status/1111011220495032320
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3 “When you watch a child who is focused on learning, & you let them know you’re watching, & you let them know your opinion as though your opinion matters, you just took that thing away from them. You just made it yours. Your smell is all over it now”: carolblack.org/the-gaze/
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3 “I watched an 18-month-old stacking blocks, completely absorbed. When she successfully stacked 3 blocks, I exclaimed, ‘Good job!’ She turned & looked at me with an expression that said, “Excuse me. Did somebody ask for your opinion?” Then she stopped playing with the blocks.”
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3 “Why is it clear to us that it's degrading and objectifying to measure and rank a girl’s physical body on a numeric scale, but we think it’s perfectly okay to measure and rank her mind that way?”
[Quotes are from this essay by @cblack_ : carolblack.org/the-gaze/] -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Inspiring words from what passes for a moderate in today's Republican party: Asked about building a wall, Nikki Haley replied, "I think we do whatever it takes to keep people out."
Say, maybe we can paste that on top of the Emma Lazarus poem on the Statue of Liberty... -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
How can some complain that students are "coddled" with safe spaces yet also complain that classrooms are so politicized that students don't dare to offer opinions?
1st, not the same students! 2nd, this conflates distinct meanings of safety. Great thread: hachyderm.io/@inthehands/111789225507625929 -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
He still has a bumper sticker on his car that says "VOTE NO ON #3!" even though he can no longer remember what #3 was.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Dissertations typically aren't graded; either they're acceptable or they're not. So @pdculbert_UBC wonders why we're so sure it makes sense to persist in grading what students do before that point: blogs.ubc.ca/teachingamongtrees/2021/10/30/why-dont-we-gr…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
With DeSantis quitting (new campaign slogan: "Eventually Back Down") and endorsing Trump, a shaky truce is fashioned by the two ideologically disparate wings of today's Republican party - the MAGA Christofascists and the MAGA-adjacent theocratic authoritarians.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
It's not just the assault on Diversity/Equity/Inclusion (DEI) initiatives that concerns me. It's the fact that they're being replaced with Sameness/Injustice/Rejection (SIR) requirements.
New evidence of the vile values behind the right-wing's assault: www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/01/20/us/dei-woke-clarem… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Christ! It's polarized b/c a large chunk of this country is now an authoritarian cult, determined to end our democracy & subjugate those who aren't straight, white, & Christian, while the rest of us are trying to stop them. Your "polarization" framing is a gift to the first group
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Related: a typically incisive @AdamSerwer essay on the Trump enablers - more respectable and therefore perhaps more dangerous than the Trump toadies - soberly assuring us that he's not really "a tyrant in waiting who poses an existential danger to the constitutional order"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Who benefits from the myth that anyone in our country can succeed w/enough effort, grit & a "growth mindset"? The answer should be obvious. But who's harmed by minimizing the impact of structural barriers? This study of students offers a disturbing answer: www.researchgate.net/publication/317776739_For_Better_or_…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Worth a (re-)read from 2016: "Data-driven instruction" greatly reduces time for meaningful learning. And, if that's not bad enough, it also stamps some kids as failures: www.ascd.org/el/articles/code-red-the-danger-of-data-driv…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
On today's menu for telling teachers how they have to teach: standardized differentiation and mandatory autonomy: www.mrfitz.com/strips.php?date=2024-01-14
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Podcast, shmodcast. Wouldn't you rather cook, drive, or walk while I read one of my audiobooks to you?
tantor.com/catalogsearch/result/?q=alfie+kohn: Unconditional Parenting, Punished by Rewards, Myth of the Spoiled Child
www.audiobooks.com/audiobook/the-homework-myth/355582: The Homework Myth
(If not, let's just forget I asked.) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Recipes online are often preceded by long leisurely lead-ins - e.g., "Back in Nebraska, MomMom loved to cook with smoked paprika...."
Solution: insert <cooked.wiki> in front of the recipe's URL (before <https:/>) and you get just the recipe, conveniently formatted! -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Surprising and mostly forgotten facts about Martin Luther King, Jr. and his “I Have a Dream” speech, courtesy of @garyyounge: www.thenation.com/article/archive/misremembering-i-have-d…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Has it ever occurred to you that “Jeopardy!” - with an exclamation point, no less – is an absurdly overheated name for a quiz show? How the hell are the contestants in any kind of jeopardy? I'm surprised "Wheel of Fortune" wasn't called "MORTAL PERIL!!"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Mel Brooks: "Being a kid was the best [time of my life, especially from] 4 or 5 to age 9. 'What happened at 9?' Homework. It took the joy of playing with my little friends away, and I didn’t have the freedom. I remember saying to myself, Uh-oh, they want something back."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
NYT: US & its allies struck multiple targets in Yemen.
Well, how could anyone object to that? After all, a target by definition is something meant to be hit or bombed. I'm curious: Are attacks by countries designated as our enemies also typically described as hitting "targets"? -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Even a first-class ticket on the Titanic is still a ticket on the Titanic."
When @zeynep said that, she was talking about pandemics and how our failure to provide vaccinations to poorer countries allows new variants to spread worldwide, but it also applies to the climate crisis. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
“Essay” comes from the French word meaning “to try.” But that spirit of tentativeness is crushed when essays are graded and the point isn't to explore but to snag an A.
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Mueller, She Wrote
@MuellerSheWrote
I have read every single court filing, pleading, and briefing filed by Trump in all four criminal cases and NOT ONE argues that he’s innocent.
In every single one he says he did it, but that he’s above the law. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2: A recent meta-analysis shows that minimizing control (supporting people's autonomy) promotes caring & generosity: psycnet.apa.org/record/2022-22515-003.
Two implications: (1) When our needs are met, we're freed from being preoccupied with them and can be open to helping others...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2: ...but if needs (including for autonomy) AREN'T met, they continue to reverberate, drowning out others’ cries of distress.
(2) Since rewards are just sugar-coated control, it's no wonder that other research shows that praising kids for helping makes them more self-centered. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I'm constantly struck by how common it is to judge colleges (and private K-12 schools) not by the quality of the education they offer but by the number of applicants they manage to avoid admitting. Say it with me: "Selectivity and quality are completely different things."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
One characteristic of extraordinary teachers is that they're not fazed by kids who challenge them; indeed, they welcome this. They're willing to reconsider what they've said, secure enough not to need to have the last word, & aware that arguing may help to sharpen kids' thinking.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Conservatves led by Ed Blum tried to sell their campaign to end affirmative action as a way of protecting Asian-Americans: www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2023-06-14/affirmative-acti….
Now the right is cynically framing their war on liberalism in higher ed. as a way of protecting Jews: www.nytimes.com/2024/01/05/us/politics/house-republicans-… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Regardless of their political party and views on other issues, the rule for all politicians (and businesspeople) is: If you talk about education, it must always be in the context of America's quest for economic supremacy.
More thoughts on the subject: www.alfiekohn.org/article/competitiveness/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Martin Hoffman, who specialized in research on altruism, offered a memorable rebuttal to dark views of human nature. He offered evidence that parents who want to raise a caring, empathic child actually don’t start from scratch. They already have “an ally within the child.”
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Study: College students asked to build something from a LEGO kit (with step-by-step directions) were subsequently less creative on a different task than those just asked to "build something." And they weren't even better at solving well-defined problems: www.researchgate.net/publication/279166869_The_Downstream…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The far right gloats after having forced out Harvard's Claudine Gay with a huge assist from the NYT & other media outlets. Provocateur Christopher Rufo admits the attack on her was really about ending DEI initiatives. And they're just getting started: donmoynihan.substack.com/p/the-campaign-to-remove-the-pre…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
BTW, to track how one of our two major parties began to embrace and normalize religious authoritarianism, watch when they stopped criticizing how DEI initiatives were implemented and instead, using the term "woke" as a sneer, attacked diversity, equity, and inclusion as *goals*.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Forces are gathering on the Right that see their political aspirations as something worth killing for," yet much of the media "omit the mounting potential for political violence from their political coverage." Unsettling essay from @rickperlstein: inthesetimes.com/article/far-right-mainstream-media-right…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Give 'em an inch and they'll take a mile" mostly describes the behavior of people who have hitherto been given only inches.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A new Penn. law took effect today that bans "the shackling and solitary confinement of pregnant incarcerated women, and full-body cavity searches of female inmates by male guards."
And stunned foreigners ask us: "What's it like living in a country where such a law is necessary?" -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3 When the late Dick Lewontin skewered human sociobiology (aka "evolutionary psychology") & other variants of biological determinism, his criticisms carried weight because of his unequaled expertise in evolutionary biology. He once took the time to explain to me what I...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3 ...like most people, had failed to understand: that "heritability" just measures how much genes account for *differences* in a population with respect to a trait, not the absolute level of genetic contribution (vs. nurture) to the trait - and why that distinction matters.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3 Lewontin was also my hero, & famous at Harvard, for neutralizing the effect of the grades he was forced to turn in. "All students who do the assignments will get a B+," he'd announce on the 1st day of each course. "So much for grades; now we talk & think only about biology."
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Monica Marks
@MonicaLMarks
A must-read by Oxford’s Avi Shlaim, who pulls precisely zero punches.
“The Palestinian people,” he writes, “are the only people living under military occupation who are expected to ensure the security of their occupier.”
“What is happening in Gaza is… Israeli state terrorism.”
Will Hutton
@williamnhutton
Avi Shlaim is one of the most high integrity Jewish intellectuals of his generation. This piece is a required read by all of us so torn by the events since October 7th www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/world/israel/64132/all-that-re…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
monocausotaxophilia: the love of finding single causes that explain everything.
(But does this sort of sweeping reductionism really explain why we're always getting into trouble? And would arguing that this is true be called metamonocausotaxophilia?) -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Hey, let's list our favorite clichés for rationalizing one's failure to speak out against harmful policies. I'll start: “Like it or not, this is reality." (Alternate version: "That train has left the station.”) Then there's “We need a seat at the table.” Your turn.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Today was the day I learned the name of Alabama's state treasurer, and nothing will ever be quite the same again.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/5 I once observed a teacher workshop that featured a self-conscious bit of community-building. The participants were divided into colors, and I watched the members of the red group try to carry out their assignment, which was to invent a logo and a slogan...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/5 This was supposed to model the process of creating "commonality," which these teachers would presumably go back and do with their students.
But why *should* any of these strangers have felt part of the group to which they were assigned? They didn't know each other yet...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/5 There was nothing of substance, no honest commonality, around which to create community. The earnest attempt to get consensus about whether they'd call themselves the Red Hot Chili Peppers led me to wonder why anyone should care....
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/5 Indeed, the participants weren't particularly responsive during the exercise, leading the facilitator to assume they were just shy or tired and in need of some artificial inducement to participate more energetically....
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
5/5 But the problem here wasn't with the attitudes of the individuals.
While it's crucial to foster community among students and also among faculty - in my book Beyond Discipline I offer ideas for how to do this - attempts to summon it out of thin air yield #pseudocommunity. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The late Charles Reich, author of The Greening of America, hiked 45 of the 46 high peaks of the Adirondacks, deliberately choosing not to do all of them because he said “It would be better to imagine what the 46th looked like.”
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
One reason that many kids seem to have trouble thinking for themselves is that they've learned the adults in their lives are none too pleased about their doing so.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
How should a committed Christian respond to "Happy holidays!"?
a) "Those of us going to heaven celebrate only one holiday this time of year. Care to guess which, Mr. Wokehead?"
b) "And I wish you a merry CHRISTMAS."
c) "Thanks! Same to you!
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2
How should a committed atheist respond to "Merry Christmas!"?
a) "There's absolutely no historical evidence that Jesus, assuming he existed, was born in December."
b) "And I wish you an enjoyable and reason-based winter solstice."
c) "Thanks! Same to you!" -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The holidays seem a fitting time to revisit the ancient art of satire. So, ICYMI (which, I just learned, does *not* mean It's Clear You're Mentally Ill), here's my parody of the corrections column published by a certain newspaper: www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/corrections/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
This study presents encouraging data showing that if leaders base their decisions on inaccurate information, they tend to lose their influence over followers. Unfortunately, the study was conducted only with pigeons: royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsbl.2016.0544
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Matt Duss
@mattduss
It’s funny hearing old folks blame TikTok for young people’s support for Palestinian rights, as if their own views weren’t shaped by decades of pro-Israel messaging. The young have access to a far greater range of views than you ever did, they can see what you refused to see.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Free speech in context: "We don't protest the war on Gaza because we have an abstract right to do so; we protest it b/c it's 1 of the great moral atrocities of our lifetime & the widespread refusal to admit this in America is an atrocity in its own right": nymag.com/intelligencer/article/free-speech-debate-free-p…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
No wonder American educators can't keep up with their counterparts in the UK & Australia. Over there, kids study maths; over here, we still have only one.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Resilience is a useful capability to have, sure, but efforts to promote it in kids often distract from efforts to identify and challenge harmful practices (or policies) that *require* resilience.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
How many children fail to get what they need, psychologically speaking, just because their parents are terrified that someone might regard them as insufficiently firm and "in control" - or guilty of helicopter parenting?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From @DwightGarner's latest book review in the NYT: "A summary of what is to come in the book...is the least felicitous type of introduction, for the same reason that 'as I will demonstrate later' are the worst 5 words in the English language, after 'brace for a water landing.'"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From the archives: "Progressive Labels for Regressive Practices: How Key Terms in Education Have Been Co-opted": www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/regressive/. (I'm looking at you, "formative assessment")
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
What educator David Page said many years ago about math is true across the disciplines: When kids give the wrong answer, they're often just answering a different question. And our challenge is to figure out what that question is.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Before checking the answer (worldpopulationreview.com/countries), see if you can name the 6 most populous countries in descending order. I confess I had reversed #1 and #2, and I didn't come up with more than one of those in positions #4 - 6.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Academic papers often begin w/comically broad, uncontroversial statemts. Actual ex. in Ed Psych Review: "Learning and instruction has [sic] undergone important changes during the last years." Same ritual in the natural scis ("Cells, while very small, are critical for survival")?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A Black mom speaks out against "no excuses" discipline, a "strict control...that mimics animal training": www.philasun.com/commentary/safe-but-silent/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Given their damaging effects, why are grades & standardized tests still so pervasive worldwide? @Edu_Historian & @ehutt1 cite the legacy of colonialism + neoliberalism's reduction of students to "human capital": economics as the sole reason for education - www.amazon.com/Off-Mark-Rankings-Undermine-Learning/dp/06…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Do not risk ruining the reading of stories by teaching children to focus on how they're processing them"
-Nancie Atwell, The Reading Zone -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The longstanding go-to source for research supporting the value of homeschooling is a man who believes the practice is Biblically mandated, and his data suffer from a fatal selection bias: unrepresentative kids who would have done well in any setting: www.washingtonpost.com/education/2023/12/11/brian-ray-hom…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Nice phrase buried in a book review: a reference to the grim consequences we face "as the climate changes and humans don't."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/5 I've long argued that making kids struggle to triumph over each other isn't harmless just because it's called a game: www.alfiekohn.org/article/coop-games/
Similarly, here's my annual reminder that lying to children doesn't magically become benign just because it's a holiday tradition...Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/5 The fact that my daughter understood it was all pretend didn’t dilute her joy one bit. The same is true of the endless imaginative games that all kids play: It’s enormous fun even though they know it’s make-believe.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
5/5 Why, then, at Christmastime, do so many adults assume children can’t enjoy the Santa myth unless it’s presented as literal truth? Given that it’s possible for kids to have fun without our having to deceive them, why not have the best of both worlds: gaiety and honesty?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Not all threats are existential.
Not all increases are exponential.
Not all fails are epic.
Not all motion pictures are major.
Not all openings are grand. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
It's the juxtaposition that's sickening: www.nytimes.com/interactive/2023/12/05/world/middleeast/g… with...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
And yet, in the U.S., it's criticizing this - not supporting it - that's far more likely to put your job or reputation at risk: www.theguardian.com/world/2023/dec/09/civilian-toll-israe…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
We're shocked upon running into classmates we haven't seen for decades because they look much older than we feel.
Related: We're more forgiving of our own missteps than others' (even when they cause harm) b/c we judge ourselves by our intentions but others only by their actions. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
New report: Policymakers across the political spectrum are becoming increasingly skeptical of standardized tests: www.politico.com/news/2023/12/06/standardized-testing-cha….
Activists need to drive home 3 arguments: tests are lousy indicators; test-prep kills real learning; and more authentic assessments exist. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From a novel by Susie Boyt:
"I allowed myself a moment of anger, but I didn't take myself up on the offer." -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
NYT recycles the conservative take on grade inflation, ominously warning that excellence is now in doubt at Yale because too many students get A's. So I'm reposting an op-ed I once published in the Times asking why excellence is seen as a scarce commodity: www.alfiekohn.org/article/excellence/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 In practice, “closing the achievement gap” rhetoric has become a conservative force, intensifying the least ambitious kinds of teaching for the have-nots, says Jal Mehta. He argues instead for equity as liberation: www.edweek.org/leadership/opinion-why-equity-has-been-a-c…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2 David Gribble, a UK educator, once observed that the kind of education that honors kids’ interests and helps them to think deeply about questions that matter is of course appropriate for affluent children. For disadvantaged children, on the other hand, it is....essential.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 "The fateful change from feeling merely unloved to feeling unlovable comes from the child's urgent need for good loving parents. He tries to maintain this image at any cost; if his parents do not treat him well, he assumes there must be something wrong with him."
-A. Angyal
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2 When you read that quote, were you thinking about yourself as the child of your parents, or as the parent of your children? Try switching to the other perspective.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Mindfulness training for kids: In 2016, a "carefully-controlled investigatn...showed no benefits for any measure, & indicated an adverse effect for some participants": www.scientificamerican.com/article/mindfulness-training-f…. Now a study of a different mindfulness prgm -->similar results: www.nationalelfservice.net/treatment/mindfulness/mindfuln…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
If issues like free will and responsibility seem too academic and abstract, let's bring it down to earth: Do the obvious psychopathologies of men like Trump and Musk - the fact that they're in the grips of serious personality disorders - mean that we're not allowed to hate them?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
If the goal of your civics curriculum is to instill patriotism, then it isn't education - it's indoctrination. Critical thinking isn't merely slighted; it's actively discouraged: www.nytimes.com/2023/11/30/us/republican-governors-civics….
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
When you think about it, that project reflects insecurity about what's being sold. Whitewashing - denying the foundational racism, ignoring the worldwide human cost of our empire - wouldn't be necessary if we thought kids would love their country even after knowing all the facts.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Axiom: The lower the status of the student population, the more traditional and teacher-centered the education they're likely to receive
Corollary: When this proves counterproductive, it will be assumed the problem is with the kids...prompting adults to double down on the control -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
In case you've been sleeping too well lately: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/11/30/trump-dictator…
(It's a long essay, but it's exceptionally well-reasoned and worth reading straight through to the end.) -
Alfie Kohn reposted
NYTPitchbot
@DougJBalloon
Whether it’s Rosalynn Carter saving the lives of millions around the world, or Henry Kissinger actively working to kill just as many, recently departed public figures on both sides will be remembered as impactful.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 A short essay about how our promiscuous use of diagnostic labels implies that just about everyone has a psychological disorder. We end up not only pigeonholing people but pathologizing a normal range of behavior: www.theguardian.com/books/2021/oct/18/the-big-idea-is-it-…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2 And here's a related reflection on "semantic creep": how the too-casual use of words like "trauma," "abuse," and "gaslighting" (which, again, are now freely applied to ordinary adversities) do a disservice to real victims: www.nytimes.com/2022/02/04/opinion/caleb-love-bombing-gas…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
From a satirical piece in the New Yorker about a parent's struggles
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Interesting study showing that kids who seem to learn faster probably just had earlier exposure to the same content - although, like so much research in the field, "learning" is limited to knowing the right answer or how to solve a well-defined problem: hechingerreport.org/proof-points-the-myth-of-the-quick-le…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Lots of research (that I reviewed in No Contest) shows that participating in competition undermines moral development & generosity, but one study also found that growing up with a competitive parent is enough to reduce a child's empathy - sort of like breathing secondhand smoke.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
An author or public figure whose work on topic X I love says something about topic Y that incenses me. Do I feel disappointed/betrayed and stop recommending that person's work? Or do I say, "Huh. If someone I respect takes that view, maybe I should rethink my own position on Y"?
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I don't think there's a single right answer here, but from what I can see, the latter response is not only extremely rare but doesn't even seem to occur to many people.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The sponsor of the new Stones tour pretty much says it all. (See the lower left of the ad.)
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Scene from an education conference I attended: school administrators at a fancy multi-course luncheon cheerfully comparing the number of free-or-reduced-lunch students in their respective districts
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Accusing lefty students of cancel culture distracts from the right's chilling use of state power to silence dissent. The latter increasingly overlaps with a move to shut down criticism of Israel's occupation by claiming it's pro-terrorist or antisemitic: www.nytimes.com/2023/11/20/us/arkansas-thrall-bds-antisem…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
It's not just that MAGA types tend to defend anything Israel does. It's that other powerful defenders of Israel, including free speech proponents, are making common cause with Trumpists and borrowing their harsh tactics to punish anyone who disagrees: www.webworm.co/biggesthypocrites/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"The Overselling of Gratitude": my seasonally relevant challenge, based on a talk I gave a few Thanksgivings ago: Always being positive makes no more sense than always being negative. (Also, who benefits when everyone is reminded to count their blessings?) www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/gratitude
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A series of studies finds that mindfulness meditation leaves people feeling at peace...about having harmed others. This reduces "their willingness to take 'prosocial' steps to remedy" what they did.
If it's all about *your* mental state, others may suffer: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34941333/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3 Years ago I argued that the bogeyman of "grade inflation" rests on dubious evidence, faulty logic, and reactionary values: www.alfiekohn.org/article/dangerous-myth-grade-inflation/.
Here's new testimony from an #ungrading teacher that the problem isn't grade inflation; it's GRADES: hechingerreport.org/teachers-voice-i-abandoned-grading-my…
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3 And here's another teacher who was delighted and "energized" once "the blinders had been removed" and he stopped trying to tweak the *way* he graded students (forget "standards-based" or "contract" grading) and finally stopped grading altogether: gradingforgrowth.com/p/why-i-no-longer-grade-my-college
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3 From a professor friend: Most "people from whom I hear complaints about grade inflation are teachers who get poor student evals.; they attribute others' high ratings to grade inflation...[and explain their own] poor ratings by claiming it's because they're tough graders."
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Slogan in search of an acronym:
Standardized Testing Undermines Pupils' Intellectual Development -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Older study that becomes ever more relevant: "While face to face communication sustains stable cooperation, computer-mediated communication makes cooperative agreements...extremely fragile, giving rise to waves of opportunistic behavior": www.researchgate.net/publication/24136462_Computer_Mediat…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
that time I took a break from writing about learning and human behavior in order to, um, write about a different kind of learning and human behavior: the curious, odious, hilarious world of online dating (with special attention to those of us over 40): www.alfiekohn.org/article/clickingforlove/
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Years ago I was chatting with Thomas Gordon (author of Parent Effectiveness Training) and he remarked, "Autocratic environments make people sick."
He was referring to control-based parenting, but now I can't help pondering the relevance of his comment for an entire nation. -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A question for parents who are impatient for their toddlers to walk sooner, use the potty already, do more on their own: A dozen years from now, will you still be pushing them to grow up faster? "Come ON! When are you gonna finally start driving and have sex?"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
It's the sanctimonious pretense of humility that gets me - www.nytimes.com/2023/11/12/us/politics/kelly-johnson-spea…:
1) What's less humble than believing your election was "divinely ordained"?
2) "Hate the sin, love the sinner"? The unmitigated arrogance of declaring that those you disapprove of ARE sinners! -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/3 Epiphany from Joan Goodman's book "When Slow Is Fast Enough": IEPs amount to "mandatory behaviorism." Their focus on specific, measurable behaviors "forces teachers to concentrate on narrow accomplishments, restrict free choice," & manipulate kids with extrinsic inducements.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/3 Behavioral specificity is required...and terribly damaging. "The more specific the goal," Goodman writes, "the more control must be exerted over the response, so only an extraordinarily ingenious teacher can be child-directed and flexible yet [still] conform to the IEP law."
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
3/3 This book helped me to see that sometimes the problem isn't with the tweakable *details* of a certain procedure or policy; rather, the policy itself may reflect hidden premises (in this case, a reductive Skinnerian worldview) and will invariably produce unwanted effects.
-
Alfie Kohn reposted
Radley Balko
@radleybalko
The guy who’s a coin flip to be the next president is using sort of language that has historically resulted in mass graves.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 When he taught H.S. history, Jim Nehring handed out several textbooks’ takes on the same historical event, each offering a different account in a tone of absolute certainty. Students learned more about the topic but they also came to question authoritative pronouncements.
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2 This is invaluable in everyday life, not just for teaching. I always try to read a few reviews of the same movie or multiple recipes for a given dish. Each time, I'm reminded that, had I read just one, I might have accepted its perspective or instruction as the Truth.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
20 yrs ago, I said the demand for educational "accountability" was "rooted in a top-down, ideologically driven contempt for public instns"; it "didn't start in living rms but in places like the Heritage Foundation."
Same applies now to Moms for Theocracy: curmudgucation.substack.com/p/the-real-moms-for-liberty-o… -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Another response by experts to dishonest "Science of Reading" claims. "To focus only on phonics is educational malpractice." It's not just a question of how MUCH phonics; reading instruction should be centered on "making sense" + tchg diff kids diff'ly : ila.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/trtr.2258
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 When older kids are forced to repeat a grade based on test scores, research finds "large private and social costs in terms of higher levels of long-run criminal convictions": www.nber.org/papers/w25384.
But this situation is actually even worse than it appears...
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
2/2: As Walt Haney & others have shown, no one even bothered to claim that the kids would benefit from being retained; the strategy was used en masse to artificially inflate test scores and give the impression that the school/district/state was making progress.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
I've posted studies refuting claims by the "Science of Reading" campaign as well as my own take on reading instruction (www.alfiekohn.org/article/reading/). Prefer to watch? Here's an engaging video on the folly of overemphasizing phonics skills (vs. real reading): youtu.be/wD4IRdeR0tE
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2
False assertions about the benefits of direct instruction, like the "Science of Reading" (and now, god help us, S of Math) campaign that egregiously misrepresents evidence about learning, remind us to be alert to exactly how research can be abused: www.alfiekohn.org/article/abusing-research/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/2 @plthomasEdD is right: "Most of a person’s acquisition of phonics, vocabulary, and knowledge comes from reading—not direct or systematic instruction": radicalscholarship.com/2023/04/18/beyond-reading-skills-p…. I can confirm that's what the research actually shows, notwithstanding SOR's false claims...
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
That he may be indicted for 4 separate clusters of serious offenses should lay bare the pattern, the scope & enormity of his criminality. But ~40% of voters live in an alternate reality where the more crimes he's held accountable for, the more it just shows he's being persecuted.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
An essential challenge for parents and teachers (and it *is* a challenge): to celebrate kids who have the gumption to question what they're told and, indeed, to help them become reflective rebels. Instead, too many adults prefer the “child of least resistance.”
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Just finished reading Adrian Hon's new book "You've Been Played" - a smart critique of gamification at work, at play, and at school. The last of these three focuses on that appalling, dystopian program used to manipulate kids called Class Dojo: www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1541600177/wwwalfiekohorg
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Numerical RATINGS are often misleading and counterproductive, but RANKINGS *never* make sense
because relative status is just about victory, not excellence. Now, new research shows that ranking in general leads to irrational decisions: psycnet.apa.org/doiLanding?doi=10.1037%2Fpspa0000289 -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
The Onion: "In a statistical analysis comparing the U.S. to other industrialized nations, a new report released by McKinsey & Co. found that American children were severely behind in age...'There are too many American children who are 11 or 12 years old who should really be 17.'"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
A thoughtful and balanced reflection on "semantic creep": how the too-casual use of words like "trauma," "abuse," and "gaslighting" (which are now freely applied to ordinary adversities) do a disservice to real victims: www.nytimes.com/2022/02/04/opinion/caleb-love-bombing-gas…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
As the late Tom Little pointed out in his book Loving Learning, the widely admired approach to education in Finland is very much like what progressive educators in the U.S. & elsewhere have been advocating for decades
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Can't stop thinking about this Onion headline:
"Poll Finds Most Americans Would Swap Democracy For $100 Best Buy Gift Card" -
Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Alas, the evidence, which I updated in 2018 (www.alfiekohn.org/punished-rewards/), shows this belief is naive. Introducing money, grades, food, or praise for doing x promptly devalues x so the person being manipulated with goodies becomes even less likely to see it as valuable or appealing.
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
You, too, can write education articles! Just pick 1 item from column A and 1 from column B:
"Can (chess, dancing, sketch comedy, meditation, video games, eating olives, gargling) improve students' (attendance, engagement, math scores, graduation rates)?" -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Key insight from @ruswalsh: Not only do kids who are learning to read have different needs & interests such that one instructional approach (like explicit phonics) doesn't fit all, but this is also true of kids who are having TROUBLE learning to read: is.gd/y0FlfP
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
If the Powers That Be decided to start making kids memorize the phone book - in the name of "rigor" and college readiness, of course - we'd start to see workshops & webinars (with apps) called “Best Practices for Implementing the New Competency-Based Phone Book Assessments”
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
5 essays, each reflecting informed skepticism about the concept of pandemic "learning loss":
by @palan57: www.forbes.com/sites/petergreene/2021/03/09/learning-loss…
by @RacheGabriel: www.washingtonpost.com/education/2021/03/10/what-learning…
by @raepica1: www.raepica.com/2020/08/learning-loss-in-early-childhood/
by John Ewing: www.forbes.com/sites/johnewing/2021/12/28/the-ridiculousn…
by me: www.alfiekohn.org/article/loss/ -
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Mind-boggling that policy makers are still defending the practice of forcing kids to repeat a grade. Decades of data show this is counterproductive in terms of their academic success, their psych'al well being, and the likelihood that they’ll eventually graduate. 3 examples...
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Tchrs who listen to kids’ conversations, observe their projects, & read their writing don't need to use tests. But this assumes kids have a chance to converse, design projects, & write. If they just listen to lecs & do wksheets, there’s not much authentic learning to BE assessed
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Please join me in signing this @FairTestOffice petition to suspend standardized testing for the rest of this academic year: actionnetwork.org/petitions/suspend-high-stakes-student-t…. And then let's work to end testing altogether (since the reasons for doing so go well beyond the constraints of the pandemic)
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
1/5 Many members of the fascist mob were comfortably middle class; quite a few were local GOP officeholders. And here's a fact about ALL the people who demanded that the results of the election be overturned so a dangerous demagogue could stay in power, who credulously accept...
Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
4/5 A thought experiment by @joelwestheimer comes to mind here: Imagine that you've been magically transported to a classroom somewhere in the world without knowing where. Can you tell just from the teaching whether you're in a democratic or a totalitarian country?
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Thomas Green (1927-2006), philosopher of education, said the best question for teachers to ask students in their final course evaluation is: "What did you used to put up with that you won't put up with anymore now that you've taken this course?"
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"Sorry, I'm Not Taking This Test": Settle in for a good (in fact, very good) read from pre-covid days: www.motherjones.com/politics/2015/08/opt-out-standardized…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Fascinating study on academic cheating shows that it's predicted by (absence of) need fulfillment, which in turn reflects how kids are taught: goo.gl/dGDKQc. Of course this is inconvenient for adults who'd rather just blame & punish students who cheat...
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Just posted - the more complete (unabridged) version of my recent NY Times op-ed, "Can Everyone Be Excellent?": www.alfiekohn.org/article/excellence
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Research shows that for qualitative feedback to help, it must replace grades. When students get a comment AND a grade, as Dylan William observed, the 1st thing they look at is the grade, and the 2nd thing they look at is…someone else’s grade
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
"As long as it's a high-quality test, it's fine to teach to it"? FALSE, says news study: hechingerreport.org/better-tests-dont-lead-better-teachin…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Too many educ profs "train [teachers] for the schools we have, whatever their flaws, rather than for the schools we should have" -Ted Sizer
-
Post not available here, view on X
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Keillor's essay: goo.gl/UCdF6f
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
Without grades, "my sole focus became the learning of each student & sharing my observations of that learning": www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/06/why-grades-…
-
Alfie Kohn
@alfiekohn
More teachers "who are convinced that teaching & learning can be better when we grade less" or not at all: medium.com/@hhschiaravalli/teachers-going-gradeless-50d62…




































































































































































