One of my favorite podcasts ever is a 2022 conversation between @add_hawk and @ezraklein. I'm thrilled to continue the conversation in the interviewer seat today.
@DialecticPod Ep. 36: C Thi. Nguyen - Measurement, Meaning, and Play
C. Thi Nguyen (@add_hawk) is a professor of philosophy focused on games, values, data, and metrics.
I visited him to discuss his new book, The Score: How to Stop Playing Someone Else's Game.
Thi is focused on a dilemma with scoring systems:
1) in games, they're are great: they allow game designers to sculpt the player's agency. By shaping goals, abilities, and obstacles, action becomes easy, even harmonious. The player can try on different roles, explore different values, and move "lightly between worlds"
2) in the real world, they flatten us: We've quantified our lives, and easily countable metrics produce what Thi calls "value capture." By obsessively measuring what matters, we only value what we can easily measure.
We went deep on the personal and societal implications of this:
- What are different types of agency? What is the shape of good values? What is the difference between recognition and perception?
- How can we be more playful, in and out of games? How can we find more beauty in process, not outcomes?
- How can we trust each other, scale progress, keep bad actors in check--all while not extracting nuance out of complex fields by relying too much on legible data?
- Are objectivity and truth the same thing? Is technology really value-neutral?
Available on all platforms below and here on X.
Timestamps:
0:00 - Opening Highlights
1:39 - Introduction to C. Thi Nguyen
5:13 - Thanks to Notion
6:31 - Start: What Does it Mean to Be Playful?
13:41 - Starting Local: Agency, Scoring Systems, and Games
23:36 - Value Capture: Incentives, Values, and the Collapse of Meaning
36:28 - What is the Shape of Good Values?
49:45 - Attention, Recognition vs. Perception, and Aesthetic Openness
58:46 - Process vs. Outcome, Striving Play vs. Achievement Play, Recipe vs. Dish
1:10:00 - Aesthetic Value & Autotelic Pursuits in Life
1:16:59 - Metrics, "Measure What Matters," and What We Miss
1:24:16 - Quantitative vs. Qualitative Ways of Knowing and Different Conceptions of Rules
1:38:01 - Scaling Trust, Data, Experts, and Legibility
1:54:37 - Objectivity & Truth, Value-Laden Technology & Decisions, and "Objectivity Laundering"
2:07:57 - Advice for Technologists: Ethics, Maps, Value-Neutrality, and Playfulness
2:18:52 - Closing Thanks to Notion
C. Thi Nguyen
C. Thi Nguyen (born 1977 or 1978) is an American philosopher and academic. Known for his work on the philosophy of games, he is a professor of philosophy at the University of Utah. More on Wikipedia
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Jackson Dahl
@jacksondahl
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
People will say things like, "This made my day" or week or whatever, but the WaPo review of my book... made me feel like I have not wasted my life.
penguinpress
@penguinpress
A five-star review for @add_hawk's book, THE SCORE, from @washingtonpost: "Brilliant and wildly original . . . THE SCORE is socially attentive, historically literate and imbued with sensual glee. It is exuberantly eclectic." On sale tomorrow!
www.washingtonpost.com/books/2026/01/08/score-c-thi-nguye… -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
penguinpress
@penguinpress
An incredible review by @FT for THE SCORE by @add_hawk:
“Like a latter-day Socrates ... [Nguyen] advocat[es] a kind of playful rebellion against rules and metrics. . . . I give this excellent book five stars.” www.ft.com/content/94463c8d-45e7-42e2-a247-af77f223e1e9 -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
The Royal Institute of Philosophy
@RIPhilo
🕹️ Does gamification lead us to prioritise what can be measured and monetised, over what is truly meaningful?
Philosopher and gamer @add_hawk explores this question in his forthcoming book, reviewed here in @guardian.
www.theguardian.com/books/2026/jan/06/the-score-by-c-thi-… -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The Nightmare Before Christmas as a meditation on cultural appropriation
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Sigal Samuel
@SigalSamuel
Congratulations to @add_hawk, one of the coolest philosophers around today, who's on the @voxdotcom
Future Perfect 50 list!!!! Read about his ideas on "value capture," optimization, & the limits of data. Then read about our other 49 brilliant honorees!
www.vox.com/future-perfect/386449/2024-future-perfect-50-… -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Joy Marie Clarkson
@joynessthebrave
Brat summer is out, attic wife autumn is in. We’re hissing at people. We’re withdrawing from society. We’re growing our hair below our waist. We’re setting fire to his curtains. We’re gaslighting his new side piece.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
吳偉雄
@jonlpan
from "Food assembly and the idea of a dish" by @add_hawk
objectionable.net/2015/10/19/food-assembly-and-the-idea-o…
Hyunsu Yim
@hyunsuinseoul
Ouch 👀
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Noah Garfinkel
@NoahGarfinkel
A key point missing in a lot of post debate analysis is that Trump’s claim about immigrants eating pets almost perfectly syncs up to the piano in the Peanuts theme song.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Kareem Carr
@kareem_carr
Infographics of this dataset have been kicking around on the internet for years. It is an insult to real scientists everywhere. For every 10 likes, I will post a new ridiculous fact about how fake and ridiculous this "data" is.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Jason Koebler
@jason_koebler
Beloved Apple blog TUAW was shut down in 2015, sold to private equity, then sold to a company in Hong Kong. It recently relaunched as an AI content farm using the stolen identities and bylines of its former human staff. A nightmare:
www.404media.co/a-beloved-tech-blog-tuaw-is-now-publishin… -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The example that helps me intuitively understand how LLMs "work, more than anything else: "naming artifacts":
It turns out, LLMs are systematically biased against anybody with the following names: Donald, Barack, Hillary, Bernie.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I learned this from @KathleenACreel and her AI ethics work on "the algorithmic monolith". Like when the majority of HR departments use a handful of resume-filtering algorithms for picking who to interview, which are all drawn from one original model.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This creates a distinctive new social harm: the possibility that you'll get shut out of *every* job search because your resume doesn't fit that one model.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
@KathleenACreel says: there are a bunch of different corporate products, but they're usually adaptations of one original model. Or even if they aren't, they're different models trained on the same base data set.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And she says there's a bunch of distinctive new LLM biases, like that naming artifact. Which is because LLMs are trained on the internet, and the internet is, like, 60% by weight Reddit. So resume algorithms are all systematically biased against anybody named Donald or Hillary.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And, she says, this is a tough problem to get out of, because it's hard to train different models on different data sets - because there's only one Internet.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
PS @KathleenACreel is a trained philosopher and software engineer who’s appointed as a prof in both phil and CS, and she has proposals for technical solutions to partially ameliorate these problems which are above my pay grade.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Kathleen Creel
@KathleenACreel
Thank you @add_hawk for this lovely thread! If people want to read more:
- name artifacts paper by @VeredShwartz, @rachelrudinger, & Tafjord: arxiv.org/abs/2004.03012
- our papers:
www.cambridge.org/core/journals/canadian-journal-of-philo…
arxiv.org/abs/2211.13972 arxiv.org/abs/2307.05862 arxiv.org/abs/2404.08592
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I learned this from @KathleenACreel and her AI ethics work on "the algorithmic monolith". Like when the majority of HR departments use a handful of resume-filtering algorithms for picking who to interview, which are all drawn from one original model.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Jordan
@jordanbhx
If you’ve ever wondered why we can’t build places that look like Italian hilltop towns, one of the reasons is Edwardian prudes.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Caroline Haskins
@car0linehaskins
New/exclusive:
African workers who moderate platforms like Instagram + train AI for places like OpenAI (often for >$2/hr) pub'ed an open letter to Biden.
They say US tech companies need to stop paying "modern day slavery" level wages & union busting:
www.wired.com/story/low-paid-humans-ai-biden-modern-day-s… -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Melanie Brusseler
@BrusselerMel
fantastic overview of the Red Lobster bankruptcy which is really an overview of the structural transformation of the fishing industry by @lukewgoldstein, where regulations to curb overfishing have led to corporate consolidation prospect.org/economy/2024-05-22-raiding-red-lobster/
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
The Philosopher
@philosopher1923
Today!
"Trust and Hostile Epistemology"
C. Thi Nguyen (@add_hawk) with Johnny Brennan
How can the individual, with their inadequate understanding, select which group to trust?
21st May, 7pm ET/9am (Wed.) AET
Free and all welcome!
Register: www.thephilosopher1923.org/events/trust-and-hostile-epist… -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Prem Thakker
@prem_thakker
Homeless person describes the most devastating thing they lost when the city swept away their stuff:
Charles Ornstein
@charlesornstein
ProPublica distributed notecards to homeless people in Albuquerque and asked them about objects they had lost when their encampments were hauled away. Here's what they said. www.propublica.org/article/albuquerque-homeless-encampments @nicolesantacruz
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My new public philosophy piece is out: "The Limits of Data"! It's about what data leaves out - about what gets systematically filtered out of the institutional process of data collection. 🧵:
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
So what enables the large-scale of data, and the easy agreeability of data, is that we've intentionally engineered out the high-context, highly nuanced bits. This is what enables data to travel between contexts.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Second thought from Bowker and Star:
Every data-collection effort requires a stable classification system, in the background. Every classification system represents a choice about the data buckets. And every choice of buckets leaves out some info, and emphasizes other info.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
For example, the US Census race categories emphasize the difference between "Asian" and "Latino", and forget the difference between "East Asian" and "South Asian".
These choices represent somebody's interests - but then we forget, and star thinking they're natural.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Their example: in the ICD-10, the classification manual for disease which is the backbone of worldwide mortality statistics, there is super high granularity for urban accidents, but incredibly low granularity for rural accidents.
It represents the interests of urban people.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Third thought, from Daston: institutions tend to want *mechanical procedures*. This means a procedure that can be executed by a replaceable worker.
You don't want a procedure that requires particular sensitivity or experience. You want rules anybody can follow.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
So if your data-collection procedure is supposed to scale, you want to target qualities that anybody can pick up. For example, the category of "good art" requires sensitivity to track. The category of "engagement hours" does not.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Mechanical procedures do get you a particular kind of objectivity. They make a certain individual bias impossible. But they also introduce another systematic bias - I bias towards what's easily and mechanically countable.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
"Transparency is Surveillance", about the essential tension between public transparency and expert sensitivity:
philpeople.org/profiles/c-thi-nguyen
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And "Value Capture", about the downsides of outsourcing your values to an institutional metric.
philpeople.org/profiles/c-thi-nguyen -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Phil Metzger
@DrPhiltill
Untrue. This does touch on something related that actually happened, which people have apparently distorted and used to prop up the dumb conspiracy theory. I will explain… 1/N
Mike Gorman
@mikexgorman
NASA deleted ALL the footage and telemetry data from the moon landing … this was an amazing #jre with Bart Sibrel
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
National Academies
@theNASEM
"Data is powerful but incomplete."
In a new @ISSUESinST essay, C. Thi Nguyen (@add_hawk) argues that #data is inherently limited, and that data users should learn how to interrogate and interpret it rather than simply treating it as objective: issues.org/limits-of-data-nguyen/ -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My current research on regulatory gaming leads me to have like zero trust for nutritional labeling, for a thousand examples like this:
██
@qweed
The reason they all have apple juice is it has one of the highest natural sugar ratios and that lets them market the juices as "no added sugar".
It may also help them dodge sugar tax, depending on the exact wording of the law.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
There’s an old legal theory slogan, something like: “Precise laws also let the bad man know exactly what he can get away with”, which seems to be the essence of market responses to nutritional labeling regulations.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Issues in Science and Technology
@ISSUESinST
Data is inherently limited, @add_hawk writes. “And these limitations aren’t accidents. They are built into the core of what data is. The methodology of data requires leaving out some of our more sensitive and dynamic ways of understanding the world.” Read: issues.org/limits-of-data-nguyen/
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Hey look, evil incentives summed up in a tweet.
Nikita Bier
@nikitabier
There is a deep misunderstanding of what “dating apps” are for—mostly because they’re called “dating apps”.
Modern dating apps are an entertainment product: a gallery of people in your area and someone will occasionally like your photos. This is all that needs to happen for the app to be successful. A relationship, or even meeting up, does not need to happen for the product to do well.
Anytime someone pitches me an app that they claim is a more effective way to find a partner, I just respond, “So that people use your app less?” -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This thread is 100% the rollercoaster ride of the year. Try to predict where it's going.
Kairo
@Kairo_Anatomika
So...Mammals normally store fat under the skin in an even layer, but camels evolved to pile fat in one spot, so the rest of their bodies can stay cool in the desert.
Why don't other desert animals do this?
Well, they do.... but for some reason, we never talk about them..... 🧵🧵 -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Some truly gorgeous notes here on neurodiversity, and learning to manage your oddball mind as a kind of relationship repair with yourself.
Visakan Veerasamy
@visakanv
are you also a fidgety boi? you may be interested in my draft notes for Constructive ADHD: docs.google.com/document/d/1ZDV-0WS8DrBDebF3fvUFj9aXQvLnw…
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
dr nipple slipple
@emilytilton_
🥳 @ms_brizzle and I have a new paper!
We argue that the socially dominant should *not* defer to the socially marginalized because deference prevents the socially dominant from developing the skills they need to really understand oppression
Link is here! philpapers.org/rec/TILSEA-2 -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Paul Schofield
@pschofie79
I’ve seen people post this. Easy to assume that this is explained my animosity toward those who are unhoused, but after reading a bit about it, to me it seems evil in a more banal sort of way (1)
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Kairo
@Kairo_Anatomika
So there’s this one tattoo design that’s pretty popular.
A wolf face on one side and a skull on the other side.
I love this tattoo design because the message behind it is just so unintentionally GREAT....🧵 -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
QC
@QiaochuYuan
> Betty, filled with spiritual radiance, said, ‘All the flowers are beautiful.’
> ‘Ah,’ said the teacher, blocking her, ‘but this flower is especially beautiful.’
> Betty rolled on the ground screaming, and it took a while to calm her.
Visakan Veerasamy
@visakanv
there's sth about the way people compare things that to me feels... unecological. like asking how does writing a book compare to having a child? both things are great in their own way and they each actually enrich the other. which cake ingredient do you prefer, eggs or flour?
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Talking with spouse about weird subtle flexes in different activities/hobbies and she said that a subtle gardener's flex is to be like, "This plant just showed up and I ignored it and now it's beautiful" and we decided this was a "zen flex" and I now I want more examples.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The best thing I’ve seen all year might be this clip of Elliot Smith awkwardly showing up on a kids-and-puppets morning talk show and the just… doing it.
Stereogum
@stereogum
This unearthed Elliott Smith appearance on the 1995 FX morning show 'Breakfast Time' is the most surreal thing you'll see today.
www.stereogum.com/2219287/watch-an-unearthed-elliott-smit…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The main paper I've been working on for the last 3 years is out: "Value Capture"! It's about the harms of taking on external metrics and rankings as your own core values.
The argument: you're outsourcing your values. It's fast, but then your values won't be tailored to you.🧵:
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
When you internalize a metric, you're taking a pre-fabricated value into your heart, letting it set your cares.
Like any other outsourcing, it's efficient. But that value isn't responsive or tailored to you. It's standardized.
And values are the worst thing to standardize.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Details. Consider "value capture". That's when:
1. Your values are rich and subtle or developing in that direction.
2. You enter a social context with a simplified, often quantified version.
3. The simplified version takes over your reasoning.Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Anyway, "Value Capture" is forthcoming from Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy. I archived the pre-print, free and online, here:
philpapers.org/go.pl?aid=NGUVCH
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Oh footnote: my "Transparency is Surveillance" paper - about how transparency metrics simultaneously undermine expertise AND reduce bias, and how it's all just a painful compromise - started as a footnote in "Value Capture."
That one's here:
philpapers.org/go.pl?aid=NGUTIS -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
In Neal Stephenson’s Fall, the event that changes everything isn’t super intelligent AI, but the open-source release of a language bot that could generate unlimited spam.
Anyway, that just happened.
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
For those who don't follow AI closely:
1) An open source model (free, anyone can download or modify) beats GPT-3.5
2) It has no safety guardrails
There are good things about this release, but also regulators, IT security experts, etc. should note the genie is out of the bottle.
Guillaume Lample @ NeurIPS 2024
@GuillaumeLample
Very excited to release our second model, Mixtral 8x7B, an open weight mixture of experts model.
Mixtral matches or outperforms Llama 2 70B and GPT3.5 on most benchmarks, and has the inference speed of a 12B dense model. It supports a context length of 32k tokens. (1/n)Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
In Stephenson’s Fall, the release of the perfect modifiable spam-bot lets spammers to flood every channel with infinite misinformation, and only people rich enough to afford really expensive filtering services had anything like real info.
I think about that a lot these days.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
If I remember right, the book stages the open-source release as a really understandable and at-the-time laudable act by a really well-intentioned person who wants to stop an authoritarian regime. And then the book timeskips forward to a wrecked misinformation hellscape.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
Folks, this isn't some sort of abstract worry about future harms. There are a bunch of immediate implications that people need to be aware of, for better and worse.
Like GPT-3.5 is really good spear phishing. arxiv.org/ftp/arxiv/papers/2305/2305.06972.pdf -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
For those who don't follow AI closely:
1) An open source model (free, anyone can download or modify) beats GPT-3.5
2) It has no safety guardrails
There are good things about this release, but also regulators, IT security experts, etc. should note the genie is out of the bottle.
Guillaume Lample @ NeurIPS 2024
@GuillaumeLample
Very excited to release our second model, Mixtral 8x7B, an open weight mixture of experts model.
Mixtral matches or outperforms Llama 2 70B and GPT3.5 on most benchmarks, and has the inference speed of a 12B dense model. It supports a context length of 32k tokens. (1/n) -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My 6yo has gotten into a simple iPad game in the tech tree/4x/Civilization-type expansion style, and I’m teaching him how tech trees and upgrade paths work, and I realized that this is my tribe’s cultural equivalent of the parental moment of teaching your kid to play baseball.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
He couldn’t understand how I knew things about a game I’d never played and I was trying to explain how many games I’ve played with a tech-tree/expansion logic and I was finally just like, “Look kid, Civilization was my Minecraft.”
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I mean seriously, how many movies show parents my age proudly teaching their kids to play catch, and how many show them teaching their kids to play Mario Kart and Smash and Zelda, and what do you think is actually happening more in reality?
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Trung Phan
@TrungTPhan
The iPhone camera uses computational photography, applying software to every snap.
This wild photo is an eery example: the subject tries on a wedding dress and each mirror shows her in a different pose.
Why? Apple insider says it’s a “mistake” in the computational photography pipeline:
➡️ “The iPhone camera doesn’t realize it was taking a photo of a mirror, so it treated the three versions of [UK actress Tessa Coates] as different people. Coates was moving when the photo was taken, so when the shutter was pressed, many differing images were captured in that instant. Apple's algorithm stitches the photos together, choosing the best versions for saturation, contrast, detail, and lack of blur.” ⬅️ -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Fascinating point about the relative clarity of laws: the .08% blood-alcohol line is very clear and usable to police with a device. But for normal people, it’s a very unclear criterion - they have to guess from approximate feel/consumption rate whether they are across the line.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I learned this from Seana Shiffrin’s article on the occasional virtues of legal fog:
harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-123/inducing-moral-deliber…
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Update: @HiPhiNation has just informed me that this is known as the Guidance Value vs. Process Value distinction in the philosophy of law. Guidance value is the value of a law to the citizen, process value is the value of the law to the enforcers.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
cinesthetic.
@TheCinesthetic
What’s the coolest photo of a director directing on set?
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Part of the psychology of being a philosopher is that the most thrilling thing that can happen to you is other lovely people devoted a huge chunk of time to proving that you’re totally wrong.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Enda Hargaden
@EndaHargaden
The Nobel Prize in Economics has been awarded to Claudia Goldin.
Most economists will immediately know why she won. This is a very quick thread, aimed at non-economists, explaining why her work on the the labour market outcomes of women has been awarded the Prize. -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Aaron Gwyn
@AmericanGwyn
Literary critic, Sam Bankman-Fried, on Shakespeare:
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
We're hiring in data ethics/AI ethics/philosophy of technology. With an emphasis on finding people who are equipped to teach to non-majors - esp. CS majors, engineers, etc.
I'm on the hiring committee, so feel free to shoot me any questions.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Here's the official ad:
utah.peopleadmin.com/postings/153492 -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
🦋🌸Gimme the Lute🌸🦋 סלע
@moontwerk
My daughter’s kindergarten homework reminded me to finish reading Games: Agency As Art by @add_hawk
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“Financial economists have observed that stock markets are—almost by necessity—sites of disagreement, because buyers and sellers in a given transaction are effectively expressing different opinions of the security being traded.”
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
From the incredible book Calculated Value by William Deringer. More on that book soon. He cites Hong and Stein, “Disagreement and the Stock Market” for this
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Blake Robbins
@blakeir
the best articulation for why games are such a powerful medium is from:
@add_hawk (on @ezraklein) —
Games: Agency as Art
overcast.fm/+oiPXNKQBw -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Holy… wha… wha? Uh, science people, is this…. right?
Jonatan Pallesen
@jonatanpallesen
Incredibly, the placebo effect is (mostly) not real.
It is a result of statistical confusion. Whenever you have a group with extreme values, they tend to exhibit regression to the mean. Eg. on average, sick people tend to become more healthy over time.
Thus if you give one group medicine, and one group placebo, the placebo group will also tend to get better over time, because of regression to the mean.
People have then misinterpreted this to think that it is the placebo pill that actively does this.
If you want to demonstrate a placebo effect, you have to construct a study where there are three groups:
• A. treatment
• B. placebo
• C. no treatment, no placebo
If B and C get different outcomes, that would demonstrate a placebo effect.
When this has been tried, mainly there has been no provable placebo effect. See the paper in the screenshot. (There is some evidence for an effect for pain, but this get's into a slightly different debate.)
The fact that the placebo effect is mainly not real, fortunately frees us from having to come up with convoluted explanations, as to why the placebo effect would work even when we tell the patient that it is a placebo, as in the quoted tweet. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Explained to the 6yo about how broadcast TV worked when I was his age: shows only showing at specific times and if you missed them that was it. He’s reacting like I said we used leeches for medicine.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Silja J.A. Talvi
@SiljaJATalvi
The hell that is known as solitary can never be “reformed.” It is torture, and it leaves psychic scars from which ppl never recover. Read this first-person essay @theappeal: theappeal.org/solitary-confinement-punishment-rules/
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Our Daily Nous post about our experiments with teaching philosophy through practical workshops - classes that are split between traditional lectures and workshops where students do something: make a game, learn to juggle, whatever. Upshot: it worked shockingly well. 🧵:
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I definitely had the experience of feeling like my philosophy education had tried to shut down my whole being, and here I was, teaching like one of the best classes of my life, and it required that I actually put my whole person - the weirdo games-lover - in the class.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Here's the post. Thanks to @DailyNousEditor for the opportunity!
dailynous.com/2023/07/18/do-the-thing-philosophy-teaching… -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Daily Nous / Justin Weinberg
@DailyNousEditor
Two philosophers, @CatSaintCroix and @add_hawk, made game days a part of their courses. They were uncertain what to expect, but it went well—really well. In this post, they discuss what they did and why it worked. dailynous.com/2023/07/18/do-the-thing-philosophy-teaching…
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Ben Norton
@BenjaminNorton
This story is crazy on multiple levels:
A mother in the US state of Nebraska faces years in prison because her teenage daughter unexpectedly got pregnant, so she got her abortion pills
But that's not all: Meta gave police their private Facebook messages!
jezebel.com/nebraska-mom-pleads-guilty-to-giving-abortion… -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Arvind Narayanan
@random_walker
I want to print and frame everything in this thread (and the paper thread quoted). Brilliant diagnosis of what's gone wrong in science — the whole mindset, not specific methods. Useful for science journalists too, as media perpetuates these misconceptions.
x.com/zerdeve/status/1677022283737739264 -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Paul Schofield
@pschofie79
Recently, people have noticed that members of the homeless population go to the bathroom, and that they need someplace to do it. That's . . . progress. There's talk about their needing a place to shower, too. But no one talks about their having space for sexual intimacy (1/11)
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My own theory is that the three perfect Wes Anderson movies - BR, Rushmore, and Royal Ts - were the ones co-written with Owen Wilson. And we haven’t noticed because people can’t imagine that Owen Wilson is actually, like, an important artist.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
But for me, at least, some of the warmth and soul which balanced out the formal perfection vanished after Owen Wilson stopped co-writing. Like, maybe it was one of those perfect balances - like Lennon/McCartney and Ice Cube/Dre - and the parts apart can’t quite get the perfect.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Like in Lennon/McCartney and Cube/Dre, there’s this balance between the rage/raw and the pop/perfect, and the marriage is amazing.
Anderson/Wilson gave us a balance of formal brilliance and human groundedness. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Never have I have experienced the unbridgeable gulf between cultures, then right now, trying to explain the concept of a “bro” to my parents-in-law.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The best advice I got in climbing: “For every 5 days of climbing, you get 3 decent days, 1 terrible day, and 1 great day. Don’t let the great day reset your expectations for the rest.”
This also applies to writing.Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“Instead, try hanging out at your inner edge where you’re pretty comfortable and just barely feel a stretch, until that feeling of stretch disappears. Then go a tiny bit deeper.”
This is basically the best advice for self management I ever learned.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
PS the inner edge advice is from Donna Farhi’s wonderful yoga book.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Just wrote a short blog of "Transparency is Surveillance". Core thought: Transparency and trust are deeply in tension. Transparency forces experts to explain themselves to non-experts - but much of expertise isn't explainable. So transparency undermines expertise.
🧵:Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Transparency has one blunt approach. It gets rid of implicit reasoning and intuition. And that's where bias lives and corruption thrives. But it's also where expert experience lives and special sensitivity thrives.
Transparency gets rid of it all.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The whole problem is that the world is too big for one brain. We have to trust each other to do things that we ourselves cannot understand. We have to make ourselves vulnerable when we trust experts, and they operate outside of our reasoning.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Here's the new 2k short blog post version of Transparency is Surveillance, hopefully teachable and stuff:
newworkinphilosophy.substack.com/p/c-thi-nguyen-universit…
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And here's the original version of Transparency is Surveillance:
philpapers.org/go.pl?aid=NGUTIS -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The 6yo found this YT channel called Hornet King, which is slow videos of a hornet removal specialist digging into walls to slowly reveal massive hornets’ nests. It’s weirdly, hypnotically satisfying. It’s like pimple popping videos, but for houses. It’s like danger ASMR.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Mel says she has the opposite of trypophobia because these make her feel weird-tingly but good. I suspect enjoying these videos requires that you have that trypophobia weird-tingle but interpret it as good, like spicy food but for honeycombs full of hornet pupae slowly revealing.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Here’s a good one: youtu.be/jAO2oAEr6Ro
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Reading beloved classics from fields and sub-fields outside of your own is a good way to get that intellectual high.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
If I could have one very low-grade superpower, it would be to hear the soundtrack music for the movie I’m in, so I’d have some kind of advance warning.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
New paper out: "Hostile Epistemology"!
The basic idea: we seem so willing to attribute the misinformation crisis and the "post-truth" world to bad people being stupid and lazy. An alternate explanation: it's the systematic exploitation of our cognitive vulnerabilities.🧵:Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This was supposed to be a big picture paper, setting a framework, and finding connections I was noticing in other stuff I was writing.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
It draws heavily on, and tries to put a big picture around, some earlier papers of mine.
One is "The Seductions of Clarity", about fake clarity and gaming our attention heuristic:
philpapers.org/go.pl?aid=NGUTSO-2
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Another is "Trust as an Unquestioning Attitude", about how limited beings need to take shortcut by dropping suspicion about some cognitive resources. And how vulnerable that leaves us.
philpapers.org/archive/NGUTAA.pdf
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Anyway, please forgive the big brush sloppiness of this thing. It was delivered as a keynote, intended to be an attempt to pull together all these threads on what I've been working on, that have been coalescing in my mind into a Big Thing.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Just read a wildly interesting article is a wildly interesting epic dive into "Kirk Drift": the "mass hallucination" that the Kirk of the original Star Trek series is a reckless, womanizing hothead.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
It is another object lesson that people de-contextualize the "Kirk was too drugged to consent" out of the cultural version of the story.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Massive, interesting, worth your time, and not just for Trek-heads. It's is more about cultural memory and masculinity than it is actually about Trek.
strangehorizons.com/non-fiction/columns/freshly-rememberd…Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My own experience is a small echo: I recently re-watched a TOS episode, and thought: "Wait, I thought Kirk was supposed to be a hot-head? He's, like, careful and thoughtful and really empathic with the crew." In a way, it's super sad.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Like, the Kirk/Spock pairing is actually, in the text, about two kinds of intelligence. Spock is the more science-y and explicitly logical one, and Kirk is the empathic, synthetic, humanely aware one. It's super sad that this gets re-written as "Spock smart, Kirk reckless."
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Of course egg companies are gaming our intuitive indicators about egg quality by feeding their birds paprika-heavy diets specifically to make the yolks look darker
Simon Sarris
@simonsarris
Darker yolks are usually better (rather, very light/weak yolks are usually worse) but know that Vital Farms is doping yolk color with marigold powder and paprika. They are very open about this. Especially compared to almost all the other brands.
Both these eggs are good. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Hey look it’s an entire AI ethics class topic in a tweet
Neeraj K. Agrawal
@NeerajKA
a mega influencer trained chatgpt4 on thousands of hours of her youtube content and is now selling access to it as a virtual gf for $1/ minute.
she's already made over 70k in a week decrypt.co/139633/snapchat-star-caryn-marjorie-ai-girlfri… -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“Virtue signaling” accuser, accuse thyself.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Agnes Callard
@AgnesCallard
My 🌃🦉🦉convo with @add_hawk, in which we discussed:
—whether games are art
—the dangers of gamification
—whether philosophers are assholes
youtu.be/iisrtoPD1JI -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This might seem funny because it’s directed at people you hate but if you take a second to think about all the other uses it’s pretty clear we’re about to enter the deception apocalypse.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Becoming more clear that @rinireg’s paper about it how the very existence deepfakes change the basic nature of what counts as evidence was prescient, and just the first drop in a torrent of the coming informational apocalypse.
philpapers.org/rec/RINDAT
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Also i saw some thread of somebody creating a ChatGPT plug in to automate lawsuits and cease and desist letters for spam callers and - also funny if you keep the target narrow, but if you think about every other possible malicious use of that tech…
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Daniel Hadas
@DanielHadas2
Inter alia, 'Moby-Dick' is a lament for a direct confrontation with nature which technology was erasing.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Daniel Hadas
@DanielHadas2
'Moby-Dick' was written after the invention of gun-powder-powered harpoons, but set before it.
This is not a small detail, but a key to the book. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I can’t find this thing that’s supposed to exist - a piece by Ta-Nahesi Coates that about why being a columnist/pundit is bad for you. Anybody know where it is? Very interested in the arc about how being a pundit wrecks your soul.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Aaron Bady
@zunguzungu
something about how Ta-Nehisi Coates was unquestionably the most well-known, respected, and liked pundits in the country, and he just decided to not be a pundit anymore
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Suggestion to multiply pleasure: put “cross the above item off my to-do list” on your to-do list.
Sasha Luccioni, PhD 🦋🌎✨🤗
@SashaMTL
The best part of having a todo list is crossing things off said todo list 🤓
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Really, the only unifying characteristic of analytic philosophers is a taste for recursive and/or self-referential jokes.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
New candidate for funniest scientific result of the year
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
The wisdom of the crowd works even if the crowd is totally drunk.
This study got undergrads intoxicated & found that while drunk individuals make a lot more errors, the consensus of groups of drunk people was as accurate as that of groups of sober people. core.ac.uk/download/pdf/42577847.pdf -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Would you be more interested in reading a paper about how making your values too explicit makes you more narrow-minded, or one about how keeping your values kinda vague leaves you more open?
(It's the same paper, trying to figure out a framing.) -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
New season of HiPhi Nation, one of the very best and deepest public philosophy things ever:
Hi-Phi Nation
@HiPhiNation
People are training AI to sound like loved ones who’ve
died. They say the AI isn’t just mimicking, it actually is their loved one. Some philosophers agree
it is possible, but grief experts are worried. Season 6 premiere is out today! hiphination.org/season-6-episodes/s6-episode-1-the-digita… -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Kirsty Sedgman
@KirstySedgman
I haven’t done a #theatreetiquette thread for a while, but for those who don’t know, my book The Reasonable Audience is all about ‘bad behaviour’ in theatres & how it gets policed.
This thread explains how we got here, and why I think we’re going to be seeing more of this. 🧵 -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Animation Obsessive
@ani_obsessive
Hayao Miyazaki's films are famous for their portrayal of running. In 1980, he wrote a guide to animating it.
Thanks to a translation by @kupobox, Miyazaki's running guide can now be enjoyed in full and in English. We explore its lessons today: animationobsessive.substack.com/p/hayao-miyazaki-on-running -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
A new symposium on my games stuff, out now in JESP! This one is super-meaningful me. I had two mentor-figures save my soul, when I was lost in the wasteland, about to drop out of the profession.
Now I got to have an argument with them, in print.🧵:
philpapers.org/rec/NGUGULPost not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
To respond to these criticisms, I have to build a whole new chunk of the theory - so there's new stuff in here. Here's my response:
philpapers.org/archive/NGUGUL.pdf
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And I can't say enough times: without these human beings telling me my stuff was interesting when the profession was giving me every opposite signal, I would have given up. Uncountable thanks to them, from the bottom of my heart.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Mel has introduced, for referring to certain public intellectuals, the term “uncritical race theorists.” You’re welcome.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Newton’s fourth law of thermodynamics: for every hot take, there is an opposite and worse hot take.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
We're hiring! We have a two-year postdoc in philosophy and the environment, climate justice, environmental applied ethics, or something in that space!
utah.peopleadmin.com/postings/145713 -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
A.J. Wendland
@aj_wendland
'What Good Is Philosophy? – A Benefit Conference for Ukraine' will be broadcast online beginning at 1:00pm ET on Friday, March 17th.
Please tune in and please give generously!
civic.ukma.edu.ua/benefit/ -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This is a crucial point in algorithmic ethics: that when many institutions use the same algorithm, it pulls decision-diversity out of the system.
Kathleen Creel
@KathleenACreel
Here’s an in-progress example: @Debbie_Hellman and I say in ‘The Algorithmic Leviathan’ that a person should not be systemically rejected by all decision makers arbitrarily, but that algorithmic monoculture makes systemic rejection possible (1/?) doi.org/10.1017/can.2022.3
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Also related: my private obsession with how we seem to be losing culinary diversity, as more and more people make the same Serious Eats/NYT/Epicurious recipe for something - whatever shows up at the top of the search.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Older example in a similar theme: Engines of Anxiety shows how the USN&WR law school rankings drive genuine diversity of missions out of law schools, as they all converge on optimizing their place in the same single ranking formula.
www.russellsage.org/engines-anxiety -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Overthink Podcast
@overthink_pod
In our latest podcast episode, we delve into the topic of Cultural Appropriation.
One of the texts discussed is C. Thi Nguyen & Matthew Strohl's article "Cultural appropriation and the intimacy of groups"
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6bUc634KFw -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Short story: I teamed up with some amazing philoso-teachers to produce a short, teachable version of my "How Twitter Gamifies Communication" piece. And it's packed with suggested teaching activities.
Longer story: 🧵
mit-serc.pubpub.org/pub/twitter-conversation/Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
So here it is: a short version of the Twitter and gamification material, optimized for teaching, with Meica and Susan's considerable tech ethics teaching experience deployed to give you their teaching ideas for the piece.
mit-serc.pubpub.org/pub/twitter-conversation/
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
AND: check out the rest of the SERC Case Studies, which are full of great, usable pieces.
computing.mit.edu/cross-cutting/social-and-ethical-respon… -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Bhaskar Mitra | ভাস্কর মিত্র
@UnderdogGeek
@MSFTResearchCam is hiring a #fate intern to explore potential ethical questions in using LLMs in enterprise. Looking for candidates from ML/NLP/HCI/other fields studying AI+people+society. Come work w/ Siân Lindley & me on this exciting & critical space!
careers.microsoft.com/us/en/job/1524034/Internship-Opport… -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Santa Fe Institute
@sfiscience
🧐 Take a step back: Are we even measuring the right things when we try to quantify the terms of better #governance? Or are we deluded by the clarity of #data into #thinking that we know what counts?
@psmaldino & @add_hawk join #complexitypodcast:
complexity.simplecast.com/episodes/101 -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Isabelle Baldwin 🌎🎞
@BelleNoelPhoto
Portraits famous photographers have taken of their partners (a thread):
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This is… the most interesting AI story I’ve heard?
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Also:
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Also:
Lucifer Severine, Citizen-Sodomite
@SpinyDykeLizard
This bot is so fucking cool
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I have a theory that the “systematized rule-bound magic” thing in fantasy novels has its roots in D&D, because you can’t give PCs some weird uncontrolled open-ended magic powers and still have it work as a constrained game.
Grunge no Hamster
@bbupton
The problem I have with magic systems is that once you systematize magic it doesn’t feel magical, it feels like science. I’m a bigger fan of magic OBJECTS that have a weird grab-bag of effects.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I might be influenced here by the foundational indie RPG designer Ron Edwards’ discussions in his game Sorcerer, which was trying to recreate the old weird pulp feel of a completely mythic incomprehensible magic.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
One of my absolute favorite classes to teach: Porter on standardized time.
So: before modern clocks, we often kept *diurnal time*. Like: there are 24 hours in the day. 6 AM = sunrise, 6 PM = sunset. This is a completely different way of keeping time.
🧵:Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Students at this point often freak out at this point. Sundial time seems to the primitive, insane, unusable. So I ask them to think about the advantages.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Here’s one: a given time has a particular relationship to light. For us, on clock time, sometimes “7 AM” is bright day, and sometimes it’s still dark as fuck. But in sundial time, 7 AM is always a decent bit after the sunrise.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Actually, Kern says before telegraphs, we didn’t strongly differentiate between time and space. When somebody asked you how far away something was, you’d say “Two days ride” or “half a day’s walk”. Telegraphs brought about a separation of our sense of time from distance.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Anyway, I just got to teach this class again, and it always turns out to be one of the most mindbending classes for the students. Who needs brains in vats when you have time standardization?
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
"Administrative man recognizes that the world he perceives is a drastically simplified model of the buzzing, blooming confusion that constitutes the real world. He is content with the gross simplification because he believes that the real world is mostly empty..."
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
"....that most of the facts of the real world have no great relevant to any particular situation he is facing and that most significant chains of causes and consequences are short and simple."
-Herbert Simon, quoted in Scott, Seeing Like a State. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
There's this quality I've been thinking about, call it "failure clarity". My fave example is climbing knots. The figure-eight not isn't the strongest possible knot, *but it's easy to see if you screwed it up*. When the process fails, the failure isn't hidden.
Thread:Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I'm sure there are many other examples of this, and this has to be other names for it in other fields. Any ideas, examples, suggestions?
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This is on my mind because I'm teaching a data and machine learning ethics class, and one of the lurking worries is whether we have this kind of failure clarity over machine learning,
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Growing up in an immigrant Viet household, certain American foods have always had this weird exotic aura. The most exotically Americana-signifying for me is the tuna melt (which I love). Maybe because it’s the absolute furthest you can get from the Viet aesthetic for fish.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I feel like an explorer braving the depths of the Midwest.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy
@OpenAccessJESP
Volume 23, issue 3 is now live at JESP! Come read Emanuela Ceva and Rossella de Bernardi, Aaron Finley, Stephen Morris, Frank Hindriks, and Frej Klem Thomsen, and our symposium on @add_hawk's Games and the Art of Agency, with Liz Camp and Elijah Millgram!
jesp.org/index.php/jesp/issue/view/70 -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
OK: here's a menswear writer arguing that the shift from blogs to instagram, on online-fashion world, has lead to a shift away from a more socially conscious and aesthetically careful fashion discourse, to one fixated on collecting, drops, and purchasing. How plausible is this?
derek guy
@dieworkwear
in the last 7 years, the online convo around menswear has radically shifted from blogs to Instagram. I feel the vacuum left behind by blogs has made a real impact. 15 years ago, menswear blogs pushed the message "buy less, buy better." they taught ppl how to spot quality
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I'm tempted, in part because I have a suspicion that Instagram has also capture the food world, and pushed us towards a world of crappy-tasting Instagrammable, like, donuts.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Oh wait I actually wrote up a blog post about the Instagram food effect once: schwitzsplinters.blogspot.com/2021/06/review-drift.html
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
6yo: “I’m gonna do a lot of science experiments at home! It’s a good thing my mommy is a scientist, so she can tell me if it’s safe or not! And my daddy is a philosopher, so he can tell me if it’s evil or not!”
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
On seeing me pull out my phone: “Are you putting me on Twitter?! Am I gonna be on TWITTER?! Sometimes daddy puts me on Twitter to share with other people how cool I am!”
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Great, absolutely brutal new paper on epistemic injustice from Gaile Pohlhaus. Guns-blazing attack on some current approaches to epistemic injustice. Accuses them of maintaining focus on healing the perpetuators of bias, while ignoring its victims.
www.academia.edu/67970429/Epistemic_Agency_Under_OppressionPost not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Full of careful, sharp observations as always from Pohlhaus. This strikes me as very teachable, and, in certain student populations, might hit like a molotov.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Also something in me thinks this would be well-paired with @lastpositivist's White Psychodrama, which accuses the American "culture wars" of centering white guilt, instead of focusing on fixing basic problems in material reality.
philarchive.org/archive/BRIWP -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
For weird reasons I love the advice column Ask a Manager. It’s like bureaucratic Am I the Asshole.
It just peaked with this post about whether making bear spray available to staff thereby mandates additional bear spray safety training.
www.askamanager.org/2023/01/my-employee-says-were-not-doi…
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I think my love for this comes half from my current research project on the nature of bureaucratic policy, and half from just raw personal bemusement at the lifestyle of “best practices”.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Mel says: “The police procedural and the mystery are two completely different genres. The procedural is a fantasy that systems work well and can make things better. The mystery is a fantasy that individuals are powerful enough to make things better by circumventing systems.”
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This followed after my showing her a few episodes of Reacher, which she dug, and her realizing that she always hated police procedurals and assumed that mysteries would be like that too, but that they were actually opposed in spirit.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Matthew Jordan
@mattyj612
Games: Agency as Art by @add_hawk took the glasses I use to look at the world, slapped them off my face, stomped on them until the lenses were grains of sand, then gave me new glasses I much prefer & never want to remove. An extraordinary book.
www.goodreads.com/review/show/5043770786?book_show_action… -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This is the review I’ve wanted for my entire life and never realized it. Gonna retire happy now.
Matthew Jordan
@mattyj612
Games: Agency as Art by @add_hawk took the glasses I use to look at the world, slapped them off my face, stomped on them until the lenses were grains of sand, then gave me new glasses I much prefer & never want to remove. An extraordinary book.
www.goodreads.com/review/show/5043770786?book_show_action… -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Mel is reading a history of Tolkien and CS Lewis’ friendship and its bitter end. She described it as: “One of them is going to turn out to be the bad art friend, but the mystery is who!”
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Also did you know that several times Tolkien gave Lewis the only copy of a new piece of Tolkien’s writing, and Lewis… lost it? More than once?
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Confession: every end-of-term, when it's grading time, I purposefully addict myself to a new video game and then make myself a bargain, like "Every three papers, you get to play a level."
When it works it's amazing, but it is truly a knife's edge.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I would say, on average, that when the technique is working, I play video games about 1/4 of the working day and end up grading 2x more papers over the day than just grading straight.
But once in a while the technique... backfires. -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Steven Levine
@Left_Hegelian
1. At my school, social justice imperatives were built directly into the mission statement of the school. Not as subsidiary goals of our main goals, teaching and research, but as the primary goals. Most, not all, faculty, well intentioned liberals, cheered or said nothing.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Utah's @eae_gamerU - a.k.a. the game design program - is hiring for *NINE NEW POSITIONS* right now.
The department is growing and in the midst of transforming into a center for academic study on games.
games.utah.edu/job-listings/Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This is a strictly EAE hire, so I'm not involved in the process at all. But I know people who are involved, so I'm happy to get answers for questions you have.
The jobs are 4 tenure-line, 5 career-line, which basically means renewable and potentially permanent positions.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I'm involved in this hire - it's strictly an EAE gig - but I know people who are running this thing, so I can pass on any questions.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Dr Dale Whelehan
@DrDaleford
🙌 THE 4 DAY WORK WEEK HAS HIT IRELAND WITH ASTONISHING RESULTS. 🙌
The Irish Findings are as follows:
• 100% of the companies involved are continuing with the 4-Day work week ➡
• 85% of companies which reported data on revenue reported growth in revenue 📈 (1/X) -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Robinson Meyer
@robinsonmeyer
have at long last and semi-involuntarily become a Housing Guy. every problem in america goes back to housing costs. the “decadence,” the cultural boredom, the sense that every “scene” is strip-mined before it can reach potential—housing, housing, housing. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/11/us-housing-gap-…
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Dr. Johnathan Flowers, Sword Bisexual
@shengokai
A bunch of twitter alternatives are like “we don’t have virality, we’re so much better!”
Yeah, you know who depends on virality? Activists. Social movements. All those things that have shifted the needle where rights and the struggles of others are concerned. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Just had my mind fully blown by an aesthetics talk on medieval Indian aesthetics by Cat Prueitt, about how cognition makes us free. Also about the deep difference between Western and South Asian ideas here.
Ok, explaining this might take a while. Here goes:Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
OK, says Cat, the background picture here comes from the view about Shiva. Roughly: Shiva is everything, coming to understand itself. Shiva is *the world thinking itself into being.* Which happens through a single unified thing separating itself into subjects and objects.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Shiva, says Cat, is supposed to be an artist, the creation of the world out of their own self an act of artistic play.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
More: James Reich saying the artistic act is supposed to mirror Shiva’s creation of the world by dividing up his oneness into objects:
The artist had a unified feeling. Then they divide it up into particulars in the artwork. Then the audience reassembles the unified feeling
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Oh crap forgot to tag @CatPrueitt
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Crazy interesting aesthetics talk #1:
@EvanCMalone about the paradox of rhinestone cowboy suits. The standard objections: why would country music, which cares about a kind of rural authenticity, embrace bedazzled suits?
His answer:
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Rhinestone suits are a deeper authenticity. It’s still a functional uniform for a job, just a different job. It’s there to be visible, to be spectacular. It’s giving the audience what they paid for, a show. It’s another working suit, for a different job.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
So much more in this awesome talk. God I love aesthetics conferences.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
It’s 10:30 am. I just caught a morning flight from Utah, now walking around Portland. Went into a men’s clothing shop and they handed me a free beer. I think I have literally never, ever experienced culture shock before this very moment.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Because speech is the act of bringing thought into the world
Hannah Kim
@thisishannahkim
My philosophy of language class covered speech act theory last week & we opened the discussion with Genesis 1:3. What's your theory on why a deity would *speak* things into existence instead of simply willing/thinking them into existence?
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
morg 📚
@wet_paint_books
there's a small subset of former incel fedora guys who, in lieu of becoming nazis, get really into fashion history and instead spend their time listening to benny goodman and measuring lapels and even finding a nice fashion history girl. it's heartwarming to see
blego triller moth
@legotrillermoth
2023 im getting on my “guy who dresses like this” shit
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
In the pre-class chatter I asked my students what the most perfectly mediocre show/movie/game/whatever was, and one student instantly shot up hand up and screamed “MAROON 5!” and the entire class burst out into spontaneous applause.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Another student said, “You’ve been waiting your entire life to answer that question haven’t you?” and the first student nodded with so much happiness that she had to put her head down on the table
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Zena Hitz
@zenahitz
Have you re-read @add_hawk 's "Teacher, Bureaucrat, Cop" recently? You should -- it's great!
dailynous.com/2022/08/09/teacher-bureaucrat-cop-guest-post/ -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Use pronouns do crime
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This is the single best story on Twitter. Read it.
Dr. Miah
@dst6n01
My mom & I just disagreed about something pivotal that happened TO ME 25 years ago
In the story I end up triumphant. We both agree on that.But,how I got there? She had a wholly different version
I said, that’s not what happened!, & suggested we trade stories
I gave my version -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Spouse’s Halloween display: two forms of Pumpkin Cannibalism. One adult pumpkin eating a pumpkin baby. Another pumpkin drinking a pumpkin spice latte.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Nick Kapur
@nick_kapur
"Person laid off from their job in the opening scene of a film"
デイリーポータルZ
@dailyportalz
洋画の冒頭でリストラされた人 #地味ハロウィン #地味ハロウィン2022 #dpz #会場より
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Nick Kapur
@nick_kapur
Mundane Halloween is back!
Japan does Halloween better than anyone, but best of all is the annual "mundane Halloween" contest sponsored by website @dailyportalz.
The point is to dress up as something super ordinary.
Here are some of my favorites from this year... -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
When the 5yo asked last month what the scariest thing was for me, I kind of wearily muttered, “Responsibilities.”
Now it is Halloween and he is being a creepy ghost, and sneaking up out of nowhere and whispering in my ear,“Responsibilitiessss”. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
A student brought this pink sparkle die to workshop day in my game design class. Another student saw it and declared, with joy in her voice, that it was totally barbiecore.
This is how the language grows, people. -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Liam Bright
@lastpositivist
Putting this all together my take is if an average academic turns up and does their job they will probably have left wing values but fail to pass them on, do research that left or not won't make a difference, *but* will successfully function as a cog in the credentialing machine.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Liam Bright
@lastpositivist
Fourth, we play credentialing roles in the great quasi-meritocracy. Companies and governments outsource initial screening and training functions to us, students generate elite camaraderie and solidarity, and our sorting gives a gloss of meritocratic legitimacy to the hierarchy.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Liam Bright
@lastpositivist
I've said before that I think that most academics doing similar jobs to me are *de facto* conservatives. A short thread on what I mean by this.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Olúfẹ́mi O. Táíwò
@OlufemiOTaiwo
"I suspect that the overwhelming concern with stability is in large part...an obsession born of fear of the loss
of democratic gains. Yet stability also threatens those who have not yet gained the value of what democratic life has to offer." - @rochellehd, Solidarity in Conflict -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Ok, is it plausible to say that heist movies are movies about perfect communication and rom-coms are movies about imperfect communication?
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Reading a review of some new Netflix rom-com, which said: this rom-com has that technological and cultural specificity, that you often find in rom-coms. And I was like: hell yeah, that's so true.
Small thread that is basically a ?:Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
More: action/heist movies tend to care *just* about the tech. Where rom-coms tend to care about the tech and the very culturally specific practices around it.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Oh found the original review:
www.vox.com/summer-movies/2018/6/29/17513562/set-it-up-re…Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Ok, is it plausible to say that heist movies are movies about perfect communication and rom-coms are movies about imperfect communication?
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Cardiff Philosophy
@cardiffphilos
Royal Institute of Philosophy Cardiff Annual Lecture 2022
– :: Value Collapse :: ––
:: –– C. Thi Nguyen –– ::
** Today! **
Monday 17th October, 8.30pm UK time
live on YouTube
youtu.be/zt03qjTyefU
Everyone is welcome!
@RIPhilo @add_hawk -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Dr. Samantha Hancox-Li
@perdricof
there's a style of policymaking i call "policy by morality play."
1: BAD THING is a problem
2: "we should make it illegal to do BAD THING!"
3: "and we'll make the BAD PEOPLE pay for it!"
problem solved, right? if housing policy has radicalized me on one thing, it's this: NO. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Please explain to me why I find this video terrifying to my very core?
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Next Monday, I'm giving the Royal Institute of Philosophy Cardiff Annual Lecture, via Youtube livestream.
It's about "Value Collapse" - exploring the possibility that making our values highly explicit and clear can deaden them.
www.cardiff.ac.uk/community/events/view/2672662-value-col…
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Abstract:
Something seems to go wrong when we take on, as our goals in life, some extremely explicit metric. As individuals, the metric might be making a lot of money, or getting the best grades, or getting into the top-ranked law school.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Organisations do something similar with profits, pageviews, or, in education, learning outcomes.
How can such metrics cause problems?Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The lecture will be 8:30 pm UK time, which is 1:30 pm Mountain Time. Thanks to @cardiffphilos for inviting me to lay this slab of weirdness upon the world!
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
PS forgot to say: this talk is supposed to be a public lecture, not just for the academic wonkety-wonks.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Scoop pumpkin out of the can with a graham cracker, followed with shots of whipped cream straight to the mouth, while telling yourself things are the same and you haven't lost the preciousness of your youth.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Scoop pumpkin out of the can with a graham cracker, followed with shots of whipped cream straight to the mouth, while telling yourself things are the same and you haven't lost the preciousness of your youth.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Washington State Dept. of Natural Resources
@waDNR
Made a motivational poster for spawning salmon😌
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Paul Bailey
@WAAMBMEDIC
Remains the greatest contribution to the toxicology literature *of all time*.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
A lot of the 5yo's moral concepts are pretty flexible. "Bad" can be good. Because bad guys are often cool. "Evil" can be fine, because Minecraft horror is evil and cool. But there is one normative rock: being "bully" is always the worst. That is morally non-negotiable.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The 5yo, walking out into the first crisp fall morning: “It’s cold! It’s because the Earth got a new version and it’s updating.”
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Most of the experience of feeling “stupid for not knowing anything” is actually the result of a hostile social gaming strategies by shitty people designed to make you feel exactly that.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Most of the experience of feeling “stupid for not knowing anything” is actually the result of a hostile social gaming strategies by shitty people designed to make you feel exactly that.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Story: I'm plugging in my laptop to the projector at the start of class. A student asks, "Hey professor, do you care which citation format we use?"
Another student points to the screen. "Look. He has 10,200 unread emails. Does he look like the kind of guy who would care?"
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Wow the best part is some people are reacting to this with “OMG how embarrassing for you” but I was like, “I feel seen.”
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Schwartz Reisman Institute
@TorontoSRI
🗓️ Join our next #sriseminarseries Wednesday September 21st for a talk by C. Thi Nguyen on the "essential tension" between trust and transparency.
💡 Talk title: “Transparency is surveillance”
🔗 Learn more and register: srinstitute.utoronto.ca/events-archive/seminar-2022-c-thi… -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Job alert: my neighbors in the Utah English department are hiring somebody who specializes in Video Game Narrative.
We seem to be forming a bad-ass cross-disciplinary game scholarship team....
joblist.mla.org/job-details/6203/assistant-professor/?por… -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Oxford Philosophy
@OUPPhilosophy
In this chapter, ‘How Twitter Gamifies Communication’ C. Thi Nguyen @add_hawk argues that Twitter makes conversation into something like a game, with scoring in likes and retweets. Free to read until 30 September within our #philosophyinfocus collection: academic.oup.com/book/39388/chapter/339074130
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
For some reason, so many of my kids' shows star the same trio:
3. A bashful boy, who is kind but fearful. Not the leader
2. A incredibly smart, resourceful girl who always gets it right. Never the leader
1. A brash, impetuous boy, who makes lots of mistakes. Always the leader
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Examples: PJ Masks, Chico Bon Bon, Spidey and His Amazing Friends, so many more.
One question: did this pattern start with the Harry Potter power trio, or is there an earlier source? -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Stupid aesthetic game: What would be the worst plausible media spinoff?
For fun, let’s define “worst” as the greatest gap between the quality of the source product and the spinoff.Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Our best “worst” candidate: an origin prequel series for Aragorn. It would be and hyper-serious and completely generic.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Somebody just tried to say a fully gender-flipped Knight Rider would be terrible, and they’re so deeply wrong. Imagine: Charlize Theron as the driver, Phoebe Waller-Bridge as the car. SOLD.
Alternate drivers: Dominique Tipper, Cardi B. The crucial thing is PWB as the car. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Is the the snooze button there so that your first act of the day can be one of luxury?
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The 5yo now refers to his sleeping bag as his “cuddle bag”.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
KC-10 Driver ✈️ 👨✈️ B-737 Wrangler
@MCCCANM
The pilot shortage is real & there are a lot of ideas about the cause.
The thread below is gaining enough attention that it may be worthwhile to dispel a few of the inaccuracies.
There are quite a few.
Ben Golus⚠️⭕
@bgolus
I was talking to my Dad about flight delays and staffing issues, and my dad pointed out a problem I'd missed entirely.
There are no new pilots. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Really tempted by the thought that self-report about personality is less telling than your choice of Super Smash character
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Yo, I'm doing an Author Meets Reader event on GAMES: AGENCY AS ART tomorrow, Sep 7, at 1 pm MT, at the @TannerHumCenter.
It'll be me in conversation with the lovely Alf Seegert, who teaches game narrative. There's a Zoom stream available:
humanities.utah.edu/news/why-play-games-thi-nguyen.php -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Among my favorite subtle-but-brilliant design touches: the Pentel GraphGear 1000 pencil’s pocket clip is also a spring-loaded binder clip, so you can use it to clip together loose papers or as a kind of bookmark. Design holiness.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I don’t have like stock in Pentel or anything. I just have been using this pencil for over 10 years on the daily and still take pleasure in its design.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I actually pulled this pencil out of my pocket on my design ethics class last year and passed it around as an example of thoughtful design, and my engineering students all freaked out at how... humanly integrated it was.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Mel (spouse): “When I was young I was into Star Trek for the cool space adventures. Now I’m watching for the management styles. Like Captain Pike genuinely listens to the differing views of his crew and then makes a decision. The real fantasy isn’t warp, it’s good leadership.”
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Yo, here's a public talk version of my "Transparency is Surveillance" stuff.
It's about the tension between trust and transparency. It's about the hidden costs of transparency: it can undermine expertise and sensitivity.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=8JEzXL5OXPI
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Transparency asks experts to explain themselves to non-experts. It asks people from a particular standpoint -- say members of an oppressed community -- to explain themselves to the public in general.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Longer thread on the original paper here:
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My new paper, "Transparency is Surveillance," is now out in PPR. It's about how transparency and trust are in profound tension. About how transparency weeds out corruption and bias AND undermines expertise and sensitivity, all in one fell swoop.
Thread:
philpapers.org/rec/NGUTIS
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This version was aimed at an interdisciplinary group of scientists and policy types. Thanks to the @sortecoevo gang for inviting me, and asking amazing questions.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Just got the greatest fortune cookie ever.
Currently considering cold-starting my intro ethics class next week by projecting this and just asking students to discuss and apply to their own lives.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This displaces my former favorite fortune cookie: “Put your trust in the will of the collective.” I am still, to this day, unsure of the degree to which that fortune cookie was kidding.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Update: the origin of this might be Polish, or maybe English?
quoteinvestigator.com/2022/04/26/snowflake/amp/ -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
OK, is this a good/bad teaching idea? The Accordion Paper Assignment. Multi-stage paper assignment.
1. Write a 4 sentence summary.
2. Write a 2 page outline.
3. Turn it into a 5 page paper.
4. Write the one page op-ed version.
5. Write it as a tweet.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Haven’t done it yet. Anybody done anything like this? Does this seem like a useful idea or a terrible one?
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Part of the thought is: how much of my (and many other people’s) work involves the skill of clearly condensing a complex thought or idea. And how I wasn’t taught that very much as a student.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The first 3 parts I already do, with students workshopping the pieces with each other as part of paper development.
The new idea is the condensation finale.
(More about the workshop here: objectionable.net/2015/09/24/the-workshop-sequence/ -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I have a complex love/hate relationship with the “look there’s a word for X in another culture” thing.
Like, I kinda feel like it’s a porny cheap thrill version of something deeper. But also I can’t help liking it. Always so tasty.Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I think I particularly love when I learn an aesthetic concept that crystallize some value. (Like the specific version of “wabi-sabi” that means the beauty of something work with loving use.)
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
*worn
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Sorry I’m probably just cranky because I made and spilled two coffees in a row.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Like: maybe some instances feel like they crystallize some network of subtle relationships - and other uses just few smug.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My post for Daily Nous. It's called "Teacher, Bureaucrat, Cop."
It's about three different roles of an instructor: the teacher educates, the bureaucrat evaluates, the cop enforces. These roles can conflict - and sometimes we have to choose.
dailynous.com/2022/08/09/teacher-bureaucrat-cop-guest-post/ -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My post for Daily Nous. It's called "Teacher, Bureaucrat, Cop."
It's about three different roles of an instructor: the teacher educates, the bureaucrat evaluates, the cop enforces. These roles can conflict - and sometimes we have to choose.
dailynous.com/2022/08/09/teacher-bureaucrat-cop-guest-post/Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Like: you could have move open-ended, fun final exam questions - which exercise student creativity, and offer a sense of joy in philosophical reflection - but at the cost of maximal fairness.
philosopherscocoon.typepad.com/blog/2018/12/unconventiona…
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This post partially inspired by watching all these professors march in the streets against cops - and then turn around in their own classroom and go full cop.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
A key moment for me was watching the degree to which some instructors went full surveillance during the pandemic online eras - embracing eye-ball tracking and everything. Catching cheaters, at the cost of a trusting educational environment.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And we have another decision point coming. With GPT-3, we'll have to choose again how hard surveillance we go. And something about the institutional culture of education makes it so easy to just reflexively go full bureaucrat and full cop, no matter what.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My spouse has discovered the most amazing parenting hack: whenever we have a roaring kid dance party going on but we need to put the kids to bed, all she has to do is put on Eric Clapton Unplugged. Party over.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Considering working out my anxieties in my class and starting my "contemporary ethical dilemmas" class with a discussion of Amazon's Roomba acquisition, and the potential surveillance implications.
Roomba gather a lot of data.
ron knox
@ronmknox
1. Hello. Amazon today announced it would pay $1.7 billion to acquire iRobot, the company behind the Roomba robotic vacuum.
It may be the most dangerous, threatening acquisition in the company's history. A thread.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Man, is there any reasonable micro-cut or public version of "The Age of Surveillance Capitalism" that could be usable in gen-ed intro to go with this?
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
emily
@emilyst
INTERVIEWER: can you describe the difference between reliability and resilience?
ME: hmm. well, Denny's is reliable, but Waffle House is resilient -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I think “Asian guy with a ponytail” picks out exactly 3 people in all of Salt Lake City, and it looks all of us are at this same climbing gym this morning.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
New paper out: "Playfulness Versus Epistemic Traps"!
Why is intellectual playfulness important? One possibility: exploring new belief systems *for fun* is an insurance policy - against being caught in a trap belief-system.
Thread:
philpapers.org/rec/NGUPVEPost not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
So I dig into the long literature on stuff about playfulness and irony and come up with an account of intellectual playfulness: that it's intellectual perspective shifting for its own sake. Or: it's playing around with ideas *for fun*.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Obviously, fun and play are valuable for their own sake. But this paper is chasing another possibility: that intellectual playfulness is also instrumentally useful, as a way to get to the truth.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Proposal: there are these things out there, we could call epistemic traps. They're belief systems that get you to ignore relevant contrary evidence - belief systems that are built to reinforce their grip on you. Like conspiracy theories and echo chambers.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The problem with these epistemic traps is that they're cleverly built to redirect your inquiries into the truth. They've jiggered your background beliefs, so your attempts to get out will just lead you back in.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
So normal investigation doesn't work. If you're trying to figure out what's true, using your background beliefs to set what's worth investigating and what's not worth investigating, and you're already in the grips of a trap belief system - you're screwed.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
They also had us do a super-cool thing where the various writers responded to each others chapters. For that, you'll have to find the actual book.
www.routledge.com/Social-Virtue-Epistemology/Alfano-Klein…
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Jesus, *in the long run*
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Have you ever read a book so interesting you thought you might die?
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
🔥 🔥 🔥
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
If you know Daston and Galison’s ultraclassic book, Objectivity, which tracks changing conceptions of objectivity over history, this is that, but for the concept of a rule.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The 5yo just destroyed a magnatile structure with a butter knife and referred to this act as “stabotage”.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Amazing example from @Ale1808’s talk:
Queuing - lining up - is a social technology that transforms a hard memory task into an easy perceptual task. Instead of having to *remember* the order of arrival, I just have to *look* at the line.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Queuing works by using social norms to transform *temporal* information into *spatial* information.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Just had a thought: queuing also transfers the work from, say, the shop-owner to the customers. This reminds me of stuff about the work of stillness that is imposed on students in creating a quiet classroom - and how that work is harder/unfriendly to some students.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
OK starting my next philosophy of art class with a discussion of the meaning, value, and purpose of the Polish LARPers role-playing as Americans on the 4th of July.
www.vice.com/amp/en/article/g5vpbx/poland-larp-america-ohio
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
New idea: starting a class discussion on cultural appropriation with Polish LARPers playing an American trailer park.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The 5 year old: “Ok, now I’m gonna learn you some PHILOSOPHY. Ready? <big dramatic gesture> The smallest thing... is the biggest thing. Got it? Now go tell all your philosophy friends this philosophy.”
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My life with philosophy, a timeline:
Age 20: “I want to understand the meaning of life, and the true foundation of ethics.”
Age 45: “My god, this account of the history of the standardization of the concept of a ‘boiling point’ is GRIPPING.”Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Hasok Chang, Inventing Temperature. A classic and justly so. You know who understands the real bitty gritty of the project of objectivity? It’s the goddamned philosophers of science.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I meant to say “nitty gritty” but you know what “bitty gritty” is even better.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
In the running for the greatest table in a philosophy book ever: different “fixed points” to standardize temperature against proposed and used by different scientists:
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Things I'm learning from keynote by MIT's David Kaiser:
A massive number of machine learning language AI's are trained on a public database of emails from Enron employees.
Enron as in the embezzling Texas oil-and-gas company.
The dataset is totally biased, but it's free.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The emails were made public literally as part of a fraud investigation.
The dataset is literally used as an example of study for systematic structural biases, but it's also used to train ML neural nets to understand language, because it's huge and un-copyrighted. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This is not just a one-off funny post. The replies turned into a full museum of tumblr’s inner funny voice and it’s magic.
Shawn Lenore | How to be a Werewolf comic
@shawnlenore
tumblr developed a humor style that I've never seen work elsewhere and I'm still losing my shit over this specifically
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Decision Space
@DecisionSpa
Hungry for a new perspective on games?
This week on Decision Space we had the pleasure of speaking to C. Thi Nguyen (@add_hawk) about his book Games: Agency As Art—a delicious, nourishing, and energizing book that will change how you think about games
www.decisionspacepodcast.com/episodes/episode-67 -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Carmen
@carmenleelau
I never had a morning or daily routine, so I wanted to explore making one since I don't work currently (nor am I looking for a job). Turns out the way is to ask my body what it wants at any given time, which I was never taught to do
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Nick Byrd, Ph.D.
@byrd_nick
I made up a thought experiment about algorithmic grading (GPAbot) that provoked great discussion in this semester’s final class (about risk prediction algorithms, recidivism, etc.).
Many students didn’t have much to say about algorithmic risk prediction until it got personal. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
OK, some further thoughts on "Are Grades Bullshit", after hearing responses:
The topic is not about whether *feedback* are bullshit. It's about whether *grading* is bullshit. The key difference is the reduction of a complex multi-dimensional set of evaluations to a single score.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
OK, tried out a new unit in my intro to philosophy class, and it is my new favorite unit: "Are Grades Bullshit?"
I have never seen intro students more intensely engaged, more edge-of-their-seat, and more mind-blown.
Thread:
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I spend a lot of the lesson having the students think about the content they get from, say, written evaluations of their work - which can discuss all the dimensions from carefulness to clarity to effort to intellectual honesty to curiosity...
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And comparing that to the content they get from having the overall summary in a "B", "A-", whatever. The point is not that education shouldn't have criticism and evaluations, it's about what we gain and lose from focusing so much effort onto that simple ranked score.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
In fact, my primary motivation as a teacher to ungrade is to get students to pay *more* attention to the qualitative evaluations. I find that when there is a grade, the students are so hyper-focused on the grade that most of them ignore all the other, more detailed evaluations.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
When I can ungrade *and* get the students to come to class and do the work (which is not always, but sometimes), I find they respond to the specific content of my evaluations more deeply, and their work gets better faster.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
OK, tried out a new unit in my intro to philosophy class, and it is my new favorite unit: "Are Grades Bullshit?"
I have never seen intro students more intensely engaged, more edge-of-their-seat, and more mind-blown.
Thread:Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This is basically a download of Scott's Seeing like a State, and Bowker and Star on standardization. A GPA is incredibly useful for large-scale management of students. (And useful for doing large-scale data collection about the general effectiveness of certain outcomes.)
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The larger point is to get them to reflect on the gap between the bureaucratic function of letter grades, and the real value of an education - whatever they think that is.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
For the folks asking if I've written on this topic: I have. Sorta.
Here's my paper "Transparency is Surveillance", which about the tension between trust and transparency, and how metrics narrow info. Also includes all my sources on metrics:
philpapers.org/go.pl?aid=NGUTIS
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Also the last chapters of my book on games are about the problems with real-world gamification - how it narrows values, and undermines our freedom of deliberation.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My book, GAMES: AGENCY IS ART is out! It's about:
How game designers sculpt agency.
How games let us record, transmit, and explore new forms of agency.
How real games make us more free.
How gamification undermines our freedom.Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
In fact, my primary motivation as a teacher to ungrade is to get students to pay *more* attention to the qualitative evaluations. I find that when there is a grade, the students are so hyper-focused on the grade that most of them ignore all the other, more detailed evaluations.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
When I can ungrade *and* get the students to come to class and do the work (which is not always, but sometimes), I find they respond to the specific content of my evaluations more deeply, and their work gets better faster.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I got to participate in a roundtable on @strohltopia's amazing new book, Why It's OK to Love Bad Movies.
If you want a hysterically funny philosophy book, that uses a profound love of Nic Cage and the Twilight movies to do real philosophy, THIS IS IT.
aestheticsforbirds.com/2022/04/14/so-bad-its-good-how-to-…Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Here's @strohltopia's book. It's carefully argued, real philosophy done in a publicly accessible way - and it is literally the funniest philosophy book I've ever read. His take on Batman & Robin alone is worth the $ of admission.
www.amazon.com/Why-Its-Love-Bad-Movies/dp/0367407655
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And thanks to @ArtFlockTweets and all the other roundtable members - @nickriggle, @juskhoo, @ehatmat, @lizscar11, and the rest, for making the discussion a fun time.
aestheticsforbirds.com/2022/04/14/so-bad-its-good-how-to-… -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Dan Kois
@dankois
Delighted to announce that my plane was showing THE LAST DUEL but the closed-captioning was from KNIVES OUT
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
curtis ''buick fucker'' wilcox
@birkmurkrow
I'M NOT SORRY BUT HOW THE FUCK ARE Y'ALL GONNA BAN PEOPLE LIVING TOGETHER. PEOPLE. LIVING. TOGETHER. im gonna throw up
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Migo
@JBW90
If you were Jesus, how would you have came out the tomb? Memes/Gifs only.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
One stab: if Greek tragedy is the expression of the worldview that things are fated and fixed, multiverse/alt self stories are an expression of a worldview of deep contingency in the shape of your life.
-
Ezra Klein
@ezraklein
Has anyone written a good piece on the rise of multiverse-fiction? Dark, Palm Springs, Everything Everywhere, the whole Marvel film-and-TV sequence we're in.
There were multiverse stories before, of course, but they seem unusually dominant now.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
One stab: if Greek tragedy is the expression of the worldview that things are fated and fixed, multiverse/alt self stories are an expression of a worldview of deep contingency in the shape of your life.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
manvir singh
@mnvrsngh
In the 1970s & 80s, anthropologists working in small-scale, non-industrial societies fastidiously noted down what people were doing throughout the day. I’ve been exploring the data & am struck by one of the most popular activities: doing nothing. [thread]
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Susanne Buecker
@BueckerSusanne
Just had the first in-person lecture with a 2nd semester cohort. 95% have never before been in a lecture hall. At the end of the lecture they waved goodbye - like in Zoom👋🥰
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Re-reading Bowker and Star's classic Sorting Things Out and this time really struck by their case study on the official coding of nursing work.
The main theme is of trade-offs. You get greater professional visibility of nursing work in exchange for intrusive standardization.Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Including humor, which is coded (5320) in the NIC as "Facilitating the patient to perceive, appreciate, and express what is funny, amusing, or ludicrous in order to establish relationships, relieve tension, release anger, facilitate learning, or cope with painful feelings."
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The creation of the NIC, they say, requires the standardization of categories of work from a vast body of very different, very intimate, and very variable communities of nursing.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
All of this in what has become one of my fave books:
mitpress.mit.edu/books/sorting-things-out
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
PS I'm teaching this book right now in Tech Ethics, because I think a some modern tech ethics breaks problems in algorithmic bias as a computing problem, where Bowker and Star makes clear the degree to which it is a development of problems associated with classification.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This is the worst a student has ever hurt me. I have given an in-class blue book exam.
Student: How are we getting our exams back?
Me: Uh... I'll just hand them back in class when they're ready?
Her: Oh cool, handing them back in class! I've seen that before, in movies! -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My spouse has just taught our 5 yo to stop saying “I don’t know” and instead say, “That’s classified”.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My spouse demands to know if, somewhere, there is a sex shop on some Main Street called “Horny on Main”. Because if there isn’t, apparently we’re quitting our jobs to start it.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Claire LM
@clairemclange
Through a family therapist's recommendation, my family introduced a behavior reward system. On reflection, this taught me that love and attention were conditional on metrics, not my relationships with family members. This system also placed me and my brothers as competitors (2/2)
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Claire LM
@clairemclange
Listening to C. Thi Nguyen talk on Ezra Klein’s podcast made me consider the ways I’ve been encultured to gamify my life and behaviors. My earliest memory of being taught to learn, move, and eat for the gain of points and rewards appears as early as 5 years old. (1/2)
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
James S Murphy
@James_S_Murphy
The paper by Columbia math professor Michael Thaddeus arguing that CU gamed the USNWR raankings is very much worth a read. www.math.columbia.edu/~thaddeus/ranking/investigation.html
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Professor Olga Chyzh
@olga_chyzh
If you’re hoping that Western sanctions will topple the regime in Russia, here is a thread on why they won’t. 1/n
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Ezra Klein
@ezraklein
Why there are so many more point systems dominating and deciding our lives today.
(From the fantastic conversation I got to have with @add_hawk)
www.nytimes.com/2022/02/25/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-c-t… -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I was on the @ezraklein show! About the glory of games, and the perversion of gamification.
Somebody will have to tell me how it was, because I don't have the nerve to listen to it right now.
www.nytimes.com/2022/02/25/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-c-t… -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Hella interesting thread about local knowledge vs. Big Data/institutional knowledge.
Mark Tenenholtz
@marktenenholtz
Zillow’s home buying business lost them $500,000,000, 25% of their stock value, and 25% of their workforce.
How did this happen to a company with so much data on housing prices?
Bad model evaluation.
Here’s the fatal error they made that you must avoid when deploying models🧵 -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Just came in the mail. There is now a whole issue of a journal devoted to people picking apart my book.
Told a relative about this and they were like, “I’m SO sorry, are you alright?” and I was like, “OMG lemme tell you something about academia...”
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
PS my reply to my commentators from this issue is archived free online here:
philpapers.org/rec/NGUTOO-2
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And the whole issue is online here, though sadly paywalled:
www.tandfonline.com/toc/rjps20/48/3?nav=tocList -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Just found a good place for Salvadorean empanadas in SLC. Pure joy is in my heart.
Salvadorean empanadas, if ya don’t know, are mashed plantains, stuffed with cream (or bean paste), and deep fried. The platonic form of which the Twinkie is the sad shadow.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I used to live in a Salvadorean neighborhood in LA and I missed this SO BAD.
For you SLCers, this is a Oaxacan/Salvadorean two-for-one: yelp.to/H6gIB4IuRnb -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I just farted and my 5yo jumped up from his game and screamed/sang:
“WHO LET THE TOOTS OUT?
WHO, WHO, WHO, WHO, WHO?” -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My 5yo calls doughnuts “sugar bagels”.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The road-service lady who came to fix my broken car battery had long bright green fingernails, then put on blue latex gloves, and the green fingernails slowly one-by-one busted through the latex , and it felt like some kind of magical blue-green handed fairy was magicking my car.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
She also had a tool wrap that she unrolled with this amazing mid-air flourishing flip, so, I’m thinking, definitely a magickal fairy from the realm of Techne.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And she had the same name as a famous feminist myth-rewriting novelist (who I’m not naming for privacy reasons of this mechanic-fairy) so, yeah.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Hot take: hard mode in Wordle is aesthetically worse. The most interesting decision in Wordle is when to burn a move on a word that doesn’t fit your given clues, to scan the decision space.
Hard mode Wordle is like chess with no sacrifices allowed.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The most interesting decisions in games for me are sometimes the ones in which there’s no clear optimal calculable best move, but the ones that require some deep value decision, some expression of weird self. Whether to make the sacrifice-move in Wordle is that.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Cristina Hartmann
@cmmhartmann
As a DeafBlind person, I feel torn about the trend of people describing their physical appearance during meetings for those who are blind/low vision.
I appreciate the effort to make things more accessible and inclusive. Truly & deeply, but--
1/ -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Wha... how... ummm... like, what kind of crossword design genius does it take to make this work?
ℳatt (matttomic.bsky.social)
@matttomic
Fun little trick in the Sunday New York Times crossword yesterday: the central theme clue was "The better of two sci-fi franchises", and regardless of whether you put Star Wars or Star Trek, the crossing clues worked
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Issa’s actual death-haiku, supposedly written with his dying breath:
a bath when you’re born
a bath when you die
how stupidPost not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
PS if you don't know, Issa is like the asshole-ironist of the great haikuists. Consider, for example, the following haiku:
All the time I pray to Buddha
I keep on
killing mosquitoes.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
All these from my beloved volume of Robert Hass' translatio of haiku. A few of them are online here:
www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/50983/selected-haiku-by-issa -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Parenting hot tip: you can sometimes get cheap bulk boxes of random legos at thrift stores. You can keep these hidden in the house and dole them out to sick bored kids stuck at home.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
OK, just had a peak teaching experience teaching Tufte's classic mega-rant, "The Cognitive Style of Powerpoint", in my Tech & Design Ethics class. It went SO GOOD and I kinda want to teach it in my intro ethics class now. And I get it way more deeply?
Thread/story:Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Anyway, in the class. We'd read Langdon Winner's classic, "Do Artifacts Have Politics?", which gets really interested in whether particular technologies drag in social structures.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Two of Winner's key examples: the existence of railroads asks for/encourages societies with standardized time and spatial measurements. The need for precise standardization in factories asks for the growth of authoritarian control schemes, that strongly punish minor deviations.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
PS this also had the ultra-peak moment of us all wondering why people tended towards bullet points on powerpoint, my firing up PPT onscreen, picking the first template, and finding bullet-points as the default, and the whole class screaming "OH SHIT ITS THE DEFAAAULT!"
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Also a reason to teach this in intro ethics, besides the more abstruse uses in thinking about tech ethics and agency scaffolding - it probably will be a clear win for critical thinking and communication in the world to get students to reflect on crappy powerpoints.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
DevDad || Infinity Girl 🏃♀️
@DevDad3030
This convo with @add_hawk and @adamconover on the philosophy of games is blowing my mind. A must listen for anybody who loves (or makes) games!
earwolf.com/episode/the-philosophy-of-games-with-c-thi-ng…
I especially love this quote. #gamedev -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Game: what is the dish, X, with the greatest difference in goodness between the real dish X, and an X smoothie.
First candidate: pizza.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My spouse advanced: fish and chips. But I’ve made nordic fish and potato soup and it’s delicious.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My spouse just entered: raw oysters
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Most fun thing I got to do this month: hang out with Adam Ruins Everything and talk about the philosophy of games. He did not, in fact, ruin me. It was basically pure delight.
Adam Conover
@adamconover
This week on Factually, philosopher @add_hawk joined me to explain how games transform personal agency into art. It's possibly the most comprehensive and compelling theory of games I've ever heard, and just a fascinating conversation. Take a listen! listen.earwolf.com/fact
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
For people heartbroken about the end of The Expanse , let me highly recommend two related series with deeply similar satisfactions. They are by Daniel Abraham, who happens to be half of the writing team behind the Expanse novels.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My two favorite series: one is The Long Price Quartet, which is basically heartbreaking. It's a series about a world in which magicians can capture *a concept* by writing the perfect poem about it, and then the concept incarnates as your... slave.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And you have total control over that concept, until you break some rules, in which case it disappears and that concept can never be captured again.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
It's fun, its zippy, but deep underneath - full of sharp political crap and sly observation. Very Expanse-like in many ways. It also has the best single long-burn metaphor in a fantasy series since Robin Hobb's amazing Liveship Traders mega-metaphor. Highly recommended.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And also, unlike Song of Fire and Ice... Abraham's The Dagger and the Coin is done.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
TFW when you finally realize that the now-17k word paper you're working on for 3 years on metrics and institutional values is an overworked tortured mess, and you have to burn the whole draft down and start anew.
Delete. Blank page, baby. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
In new weird career moments, the Wordle thread I dashed off while, honestly, on the toilet, kinda blew up and now is an @latimes op-ed. There's new stuff at the end, about how the artificial narrowness of games, in general, makes intimacy and near-telepathy more possible.
Los Angeles Times
@latimes
“As a professional philosopher of games, when my social media feed was flooded with incomprehensible, five by five, Wordle grids, I had to figure out why people were so obsessed with the game,” writes @add_hawk in a guest essay for @latimesopinion. www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2022-01-21/op-ed-wordle-gam…
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Also, I was on some podcasts and public radio shows to talk about Wordle. Two of these interviews involved the interviewing first marveling, for a whilet, about the bare fact that it was possible to be a professional philosopher of games.
You and me both, buddy.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And no, I don't understand why any of this is happening either.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
OK, so I was curious, and I played Wordle. And I have a theory about why it's so successful. The design is ingenious in a very particular way
This is a philosopher of games' theory of Wordle. A thread:
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The first experience a lot of people have of Wordle is: "wait, you just *guess*? But you quickly figure out you can construct your guesses to search the space of letter-possibility, and you probably want to do that thinking about letter-frequency.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
So the early experience is one of *agency expansion*. Like, you thought you had almost no agency, but you have way more than you thought.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This is getting re-tweeted outside of my usual circle, so I guess I should add: this line of thought is based on my own philosophical theory of games, which is that games are the art form that work in the artistic medium of agency itself. More here:
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My book, GAMES: AGENCY IS ART is out! It's about:
How game designers sculpt agency.
How games let us record, transmit, and explore new forms of agency.
How real games make us more free.
How gamification undermines our freedom.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Apparently because of this thread the book is sold out on Amazon?!? Oxford University Press still has some copies, and they told me they're trying to print more now...
global.oup.com/academic/product/games-9780190052089?cc=us…
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
More totally unexpected updates: this Wordle thread is now... an @latimes op-ed. The last bit is new material that's been on my mind: about how the artificial narrowness of games, in general, makes certain kinds of intimacy and near-telepathy possible.
Los Angeles Times
@latimes
“As a professional philosopher of games, when my social media feed was flooded with incomprehensible, five by five, Wordle grids, I had to figure out why people were so obsessed with the game,” writes @add_hawk in a guest essay for @latimesopinion. www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2022-01-21/op-ed-wordle-gam…
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Had a dream where we were setting up for a Western-themed tabletop RPG campaign and the rules asked us to pick a country song for every PC, NPC, place, and powerful item, and play it whenever they appeared in a scene, like a leitmotif... and... is this actually a good idea?
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Partially inspired by my spouse’s real-world insistence on finding the perfect theme/playlist music for every boardgame and RPG
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Hey! So, the coolest thing happened! The Journal of the Philosophy of Sport did a whole special issue symposium on my book, GAMES: AGENCY AS ART. Twelve critics came at me, and I got to reply. It was a delightful, nauseating, wonderful time.
Details:
www.tandfonline.com/toc/rjps20/48/3?nav=tocListPost not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And I get to reply!
(The fun part of a thing like this is, hey, you get to interact with really smart people about your work. The painful part is: OMG really smart people are ripping the hell out of my work and WTF do I say?!?)
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I put the pre-print of my reply here, for free online access, for those of you without institutional paywall access:
philpapers.org/archive/NGUTOO-2.pdfPost not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
That pressure got me to realize how underdeveloped my account was on that topic, and I developed a whole new chunk of the theory to talk about how the game-player slips between their enduring agency, and their in-game agency.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Thanks so much to J.S. Russell and Chris Yorke for putting together the issue and editing it, and to Paul Gaffney for hosting it at the JPS. This is a total, unbelievable honor.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Brain sufficiently tired that I was scanning my bookshelf for a specific book and then was like, “This is stupid, I should just do this the easy way”, and then tried to hit Ctrl-F in the air.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My book, GAMES: AGENCY IS ART is out! It's about:
How game designers sculpt agency.
How games let us record, transmit, and explore new forms of agency.
How real games make us more free.
How gamification undermines our freedom.Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And you can buy GAMES: AGENCY AS ART right here:
global.oup.com/academic/product/games-9780190052089?cc=us…
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
One more update to this thread: GAMES: AGENCY AS ART was awarded the American Philosophy Association's 2021 Book Prize.
I wrote a few thoughts and reax here:
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
So, the American Philosophy Association awarded the 2021 Book Prize to my book, GAMES: AGENCY AS ART. I am: shocked, elated, bemused, joyous, and more than a little bewildered.
I think I get to make, like, a little acceptance speech or something? So here it is: -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“If I was in marketing, I would advertise waffle makers as: “It is a Machine that Maximizes Surface Area.” And that is why I am not in marketing.”
-my spouse -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Katy Waldman
@xwaldie
Asked to upload proof of booster to my worker profile on the company site I accidentally uploaded the menu of Jinya's Ramen Bar and cannot delete it.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“We classify in order to forget.”
🔥 🔥 🔥 from Geoffrey Bowker, “Memory Practices in the Sciences”
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
A less pithy way to put it: classification makes certain aspects more easily retrievable and manipulator, while (giving permission?) to us to leave out and forget certain particulars
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Or, to put it more in lines with what I’ve been thinking - given cognitive limitation, we need to eliminate a lot of data. Classification provides a ready made and powerful and coordinated way to do this - but focuses our attention and in attention along *pre-established* lines.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The coolest thing I got to do: teach an "aesthetics and philosophy of play" class to game design students, where we threw aesthetic theory at them and they responded *with actual game designs*. It was unbearably delicious. And I need to do this theory/practice mix more.
Thread:Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Also, teaching this class for me was such a particular experience of feeling like my whole odd rambling path through life had led specifically to this place.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I never expected my ability to rattle of 10 subtly different reward mechanics in tabletop RPGs, and thoughts about their aesthetic implications, would ever matter in my professional life. But now it's, like, crucial.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
On a scale of 1-10, how much of a can of worms will I be opening up, if one of the first topics in my new "Intro to Philosophy through Contemporary Ethical Dilemmas" is: Are Grades Bullshit?
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Hannah Kim
@thisishannahkim
From a former student in intro to #philosophy
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
When all you have is the metaphor “When all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail”, everything looks like something’s looking like a nail to somebody with only a hammer.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Oxford Philosophy
@OUPPhilosophy
Congratulations to OUP author C. Thi Nguyen @add_hawk on winning the @apaphilosophy 2021 Book Prize. Take a closer look at the winning title, 'Games: Agency as Art' here: @APAEastern global.oup.com/academic/product/games-9780190052089?cc=us…
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Max Cotterill
@mcotteri
My younger sibling made an entire fake People magazine for a class lol
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The only thing getting me through this grading day is this hellishly delicious retuning, "Beat It but every note is C", which is somehow even more enjoyable and horrible than I could have even expected.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=OlbmRGvLExY
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I like it way more than a lot of other "but every note is" retunings... it's more deliriously off-kilterly alive. The "Eye of the Tiger (all vocals in E)" is funny once, but kind of a one-joke? But this Beat It just keeps giving.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
So, the American Philosophy Association awarded the 2021 Book Prize to my book, GAMES: AGENCY AS ART. I am: shocked, elated, bemused, joyous, and more than a little bewildered.
I think I get to make, like, a little acceptance speech or something? So here it is:Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Oh, if you're curious, here's an old tweet-thread about the book itself:
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My book, GAMES: AGENCY IS ART is out! It's about:
How game designers sculpt agency.
How games let us record, transmit, and explore new forms of agency.
How real games make us more free.
How gamification undermines our freedom.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And here's a pre-print of Chapter 1, free online still by the grace of @OUPPhilosophy:
philpapers.org/go.pl?id=NGUGAA&aid=NGUGAAv5 -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Vid Simoniti
@VidSimoniti
C Thi Nguyen @add_hawk will be giving the next Stapledon talk at @LiverpoolPhilos, 'What if Disagreeing About Art is the Whole Point?' This Thursday 3-5pm UK time. It's a good old fashioned Zoom, with everyone invited and a link here: www.liverpool.ac.uk/philosophy/events/stapledon-colloquiu…
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My new piece out in The Raven!
It's about how Twitter calls for intimate speech and then crushes that intimacy. About how Twitter rewards us for gambling on shared context - and then gives us the perfect tool to destroy that context.
Thread:
ravenmagazine.org/magazine/twitter-the-intimacy-machine/Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
PS I love this piece. Am I allowed to say that? It's my favorite thing I've written in years. A vague version of this idea was bouncing around in my head, and when I saw the Cohen connection, I leapt out of my bed and shouted something embarrassingly joyous.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
PS there's a factual error in the piece that's already been pointed out - Jeong wasn't fired, but people called for her to be fired, over her tweets. Getting it fixed now - thanks for those that caught it!
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The 5yo has just built this structure. We were urging the 2yo to crawl into it. Then the 5yo started frantically waving his stick and shouting, “It’s an art condition! That means: no entrance!”
It’s an art condition. That means: no entrance. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
OK I think I’m gonna start my new “Contemporary Ethical Dilemmas” class with: “Is Autotune ruining music?” and mine it to show the mess of social and political issues lurking underneath but also questions about the value of art and the meaning of life and I am so psyched.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And it’s straight up false that Autotune removes skill and difficulty but that’s another path to explore about the relationships of technology, constraints, and the role of recalcitrant media/tech in art.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“Why do children like being spun around and getting dizzy so much?” he said, as he sipped his third cocktail.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Background thought: Caillois has four basic categories of play - agon (competitive), mimesis (make-believe), alea (luck), and ilinx (vertigo). Ilinx gets the least discussion. He thinks it includes children’s games of spinning and swinging. But I kinda think: drinking games.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Pre-Xmas reminder: I keep a (excessive, and excessively annotated) list of my recommended boardgames right here:
objectionable.net/2020/12/07/board-games-so-many-recommen… -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The 5yo’s large Magnatile structure collapsed. He gave us a complex, histrionic tantrum - complete with hair rending, flailing, and fist pounding. For like five minutes. Then he jumped up, grinned, said, “Thanks for coming to my drama TED talk!” and went happily back to building.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Amazing piece from Meg Wallace, about her "circus and philosophy" course, where she mixes up practical circus arts days with philosophy days. Like: learning to juggle one day, and then next day discussing Aristotle on moral virtue as a craft and skill.
aestheticsforbirds.com/2021/12/02/circus-and-philosophy-t…
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I've been co-teaching with @JoseZagal a game design and game aesthetics course, where we mix up theory days with practical days - game-playing, game deconstruction, game invention - and I'm so convinced by this approach. But Meg's class is inspirational next-level.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
(Full disclosure: I commissioned and edited this piece. But my edits were mostly my saying "mor pix plz".)
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Ok am I gonna get fired if I teach a week in my “Contemporary Moral Dilemmas” class about pro and anti sentiments about autotune?
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
There sure are a lot of kids shows where the bad guys are a bunch of toys/pets/whatever who crave freedom and forment revolution with the language of “throwing off our oppressors” and this is supposed to be comical and then the good guys talk them back into subservience.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Tonight/this morning: a philosophical conversation about food.
(I’m def gonna y’all about how the narrow spotlight of Google search is eating away at the diversity of food culture by sending everybody to the same handful of recipes for each dish... )
Sarah Fine
@DrSJFine
Join us online @forumphilosophy 6pm UK Time, for a conversation about the social, political and philosophical dimensions of FOOD, with @add_hawk @OrRosenboim and Ahmed Sinno @migrateful. Co-sponsored by @ArupUK
blogs.lse.ac.uk/theforum/programme/food/
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Also: gonna talk about the weird narrowness of western food aesthetics, where taste and aroma rule supreme. Unlike, say, Chinese food aesthetics, where texture, feel in the body, and all that matter as much or more.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Pamela J. Hobart
@amelapay
past: your dog is the only dog in the universe to you. 11/10 Good Boy. valuable and perfect beyond measure.
present: -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Things I learned today: carp live in muddy water, so their *entire body* is covered in taste buds, so they can constantly taste the water in every direction.
They’re basically an entire gigantic swimming tongue. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
It’s 5 AM, and I’m reading a paper about the metaphysics of real estate. How did I get here.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Some love for my weirdest paper, "Transparency is Surveillance"! The philosophers of science don't think I totally screwed it up!
Sarah Wieten @sarahwieten.bsky.social
@SarahWieten
I often think transparency is a boring, tentative, ineffective, red-herring of a virtue for science.
I also think this article is very interesting:
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/phpr.12823
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
*at least two philosophers of science don't think I totally screwed it up.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
If you lack institutional access, the pre-print of "Transparency is Surveillance" is archived free online, right here:
philpapers.org/rec/NGUTIS -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Parenting fatigue level = “put the waffle back in the toaster but forgetting to remove it from the plastic kids plate” stage
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The funniest argument I have ever read is Augustine's theory of sexual shame in City of God. It somehow starts with a totally reasonable question ("Why is our nudity shameful?") and ends up someplace beyond gonzo... about the agility of our genitalia in Paradise. Thread:
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
So then Augustine says: whatever it was had to have *changed* about us when Adam and Eve fell, because our bodies weren't shameful beforehand. But our body shape didn't change, including the shape of our genitals. So what was it?
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Answer: our sexual parts aren't shameful in and of themselves. It is that they *display our weakness of the will* by *running out of our control* - along with the sexual passions behind them.
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
So, Augustine says, if we hadn't fell, we would have... and these are his words... have had as much direct control over our sexual members as an artisan does his hands.
And we will again, in Paradise.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This is from a chapter of City of God called "On the Justice of the Good Lord's Punishment for the First Man and Woman" or something like that. I found discovered it as a chapter in Solomon's Philosophy of Love and Sex reader, which is just full of great stuff.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
David Klion
@DavidKlion
We got sick of complaining about how broken higher education is. So we decided to do something about it. Announcing a new university dedicated to training female students to serve as powerful partners to the great houses while controlling their bloodlines to produce a superbeing.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My favorite brownies toe the line, and plays with the ambiguity, between fudge and cake. But this style of ultra-decadent brownies that go all the way into fudge: boring.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“OK, so the reason Proust is weird, is that Proust is slow-motion ADHD.”
-my high spouse -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
sadhominem.bsky.social
@sad_hominem
this is a really, really good paper that the good people of twitter should read. thank you and congrats for writing it @add_hawk philpapers.org/rec/NGUHTG
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“Can’t burn a bridge just to light my way.”
-Drake, and pretty much the paradigmatic Drake line -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“Yacht rock” is a natural kind.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I am so excited that the Analysis symposium on GAMES: AGENCY AS ART is now out, with some truly wondrous commentators! Tom Hurka, @QuillRKukla , and @alvanoe all provide rich, fascinating responses to the book. And I respond. All open access.
Thread:
academic.oup.com/analysis/issue/81/2Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
@QuillRKukla says that I don't attend to all the messy social reasons we play. I overemphasize this kind of pure, absorbed competitive play.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Kukla say: "People absolutely do play games for all sorts of reasons, and it would, indeed be a real dick move to just assume that everybody else was in it for a purely competitive experience."
Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Here's @alvanoe's argument that games aren't art, but preparation for work:
academic.oup.com/analysis/article/81/2/306/6338009
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And here's my responses to all of that stuff, and my desperate attempt to defend GAMES: AGENCY AS ART:
academic.oup.com/analysis/article/81/2/317/6352542 -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“Thanks for coming to my trick-or-treat TED Talk!”
- the 5 yo -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Hannah Kim
@thisishannahkim
📣 Jean-Paul Sartre's review of The Stranger totally misses the point! Or so I argue in this forthcoming article 🥳 I also show that life can be absurd in at least 2 diff ways... feeling doubly justified in my perpetual angst.
#academictwitter
#philosophytwitter -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Once in a while I re-read an old paper of mine, to like prep for a talk or something, and it's depressing. Like, I was so much better at philosophy back then! What happened to me?
And I have to remind myself: the author speaking in that paper is fake. A construct.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Like: here is a paper that you can read in an hour. It sounds like somebody quite clever talking for an hour. But that hour is the construct of this other, less clever person, spending months and years pouring on layer over layer of thinking. Fixing, incrementally improving.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And the result is this fake person talking, this constructed author, who is far more thoughtful, clear, and detailed than the actual author.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
As a grad student, I once complained about all my deadlines to one of my advisors, Calvin Normore. He replied: “Ah, but I have a different deadline order of magnitude. When you miss a deadline, you only ruin your OWN life.”
Anyway, it’s letter of recommendation season. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
One real effect of teleporter technology would be: any restaurant that got a write up in the NYT, or any scenic vista that got a write-up in a travel magazine, would instantly be ultra-mobbed forever.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I was on the Mindscape podcast and had a great convo about games and gamification, seductive clarity. Apparently, also, this is a big deal? Sorry @seanmcarroll, but I didn’t know, until I got floods of emails from friends saying “holy s$@& Thi, you’re on Mindscape!!!”
Sean Carroll
@seanmcarroll
Mindscape 169 | C. Thi Nguyen @add_hawk on Games, Art, Values, and Agency. A lot of ground is covered on this one! #mindscapepodcast
www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2021/10/18/169-c-thi… -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My greatest stupid aesthetic desire: to see the Wes Anderson remake of “2001: A Space Odyssey”.
Not sure if it’ll be good, but boy do I want to see it.Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Adrien Brody as Dave Bowman
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
OMG consider the profound aesthetic difference between these two possible versions:
1. Owen Wilson as Dave, Luke Wilson as HAL
2. Luke Wilson as Dave, Owen Wilson as HAL -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Mel: “The poignancy of prom is that it’s the last time you’re a child dressing up as an adult. After that, you’re just an incompetent adult.”
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Mel: “The poignancy of prom is that it’s the last time you’re a child dressing up as an adult. After that, you’re just an incompetent adult.”
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
It me.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I have discovered, in my life in Utah, that there is a direct correlation between how racist an area is, and how good the donuts are. Like, to the point where if a random dude in a truck flips me off for no reason, I immediately start craving donuts.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
I've started to act on this correlation, to much success. Like if I get out of the car and feel like people giving me the evil racial stare-down, I'll be like, "Let's get the fuck out of this town, but first, let's stop at that donut shop."
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Mel is making screen-print t-shirts for the family and asked the 4.5 year old what he wanted. He wants a t-shirt that says: “Danger is everywhere! The sickness is coming!”
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“Tactical ASMR”: potent.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Retweeting for the phrase “cringe register”, which is delicious.
Andy Matuschak
@andy_matuschak
The history of the hashtag is so wild: an ad-hoc folk invention, made official, but now can rarely be used without falling into one of several cringe registers.
Is its fate a necessary consequence of its structure, or an accident that could have been otherwise? -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My new strategy of reverse-aesthetic-leveraging:
I am trying to back up my "coffee not daily, but only when you REALLY need it" policy by stocking only incredibly awful coffee in the house. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Twenty years ago, my soul was saved by Anne Lamott’s Bird by Bird, a “creative writing manual” that is actually profound therapy for the soul. Everything about how what we think from the outside are “leaps of genius” are actually shitty first drafts followed by years of work.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Also, the profound insights about how you manage your recalcitrant soul by knowing how to nudge it. Like: not just sitting down to an empty page waiting for fresh words to flow, but having little stupid warm up activities to get yourself in the mood...
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Aesthetics for Birds
@ArtFlockTweets
T or F? 👀
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Cecily Whiteley
@cecilymwhiteley
do I genuinely want to die or is it just because I accidentally replied all to an email chain
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Lakota Man
@LakotaMan1
Pre-colonization Glass Gem Corn, Indigenous to North America, regrown by a Cherokee farmer in Oklahoma. This particular corn is a mix of ancient Pawnee, Osage and Cherokee varieties.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Shahid Kamal Ahmad
@shahidkamal
Foreshadowing alert: His example inspired and moulded me. Decades later when I was the speaker at an industry event, I got to thank him as he sat in the audience, unaware of the profound effect he had had on my life.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Shahid Kamal Ahmad
@shahidkamal
Think about this. He was Virgin Games’ MD and he had taken the time to hand write a detailed note full of marketing savvy and compassion to a 17-year-old boy.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Shahid Kamal Ahmad
@shahidkamal
"What's wrong?"
They've turned it down"
"What, the new one?"
"Yes, the new one"
"Well get up, and make another one"
To this day, the greatest advice I've ever received.
Part 2 continues here tomorrow if you're interested. -
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Rosemary Mosco (Bird And Moon Comics)
@RosemaryMosco
I just saw a Greater Back-backed Gull paddle up to a resting Bonaparte’s Gull, grab it, and eat it (!). I mentioned the sighting to a nearby ornithologist and he nodded and said “ah yeah that’s Dave”
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The greatest manifesto of all time: the Mold Manifesto Against Rationalism in Architecture.
"Any modern architecture in which the straight line or the geometric circle have been employed for only a second – and were it only in spirit – must be rejected."
www.hundertwasser.at/english/texts/philo_verschimmelungsm…Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
When rust sets in on a razor blade, when a wall starts to get mouldy, when moss grows in a corner of a room, rounding its geometric angles, we should be glad because, together with the microbes and fungi, life is moving into the house... "
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
"...and through this process we can more consciously become witnesses of architectural changes from which we have much to learn."
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
And on the third week of classes, on my 5-hours-of-lecturing Tuesdays - after complaining volubly about the gradually increasing stinkiness of my mask - this genius just figured out that he could *put on a fresh mask* mid-day.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The profound relief of having your computer get reformatted by the tech people and then spending 3 days thinking your backups failed to backup and you had lost 2 months of work. And then discovering that your backups did work, you just had to click a little weird hidden box.
-
C Thi Nguyen reposted
Emily Galvin-Almanza
@GalvinAlmanza
So one single narcotics detective has finally been caught testilying, and now hundreds of cases are in question. I want to tell you about my personal experience with this fool, and about how the scale of impact here is much, much bigger than it seems. www.nytimes.com/2021/04/06/nyregion/brooklyn-criminal-con…
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“Dirtbag medievalism is buying a deck of tarot cards and an incense burner shaped like a dragon at Spenser Gifts, because you’re fifteen and you’re already at the mall and Katie’s mom isn’t coming to pick you up until 3:30.”
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“It’s not that he’s evil, but he’s basic enough that he does evil thing.” -a friend describing an ex
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“I got 99 problems, but a lich ain’t one.”
-Melissa interrupting a friend’s story about their D&D campaign -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
“Would you shut up / I can’t hear myself drink.” -ye
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Melissa: “Do you think there’s any porno yet that’s used the line ‘Ceci n'est pas une pipe’?”
My spouse, y’all. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
OK today’s writing task involves generating examples of a philosophical point by taking classic poems and then wrecking them with minor linguistic changes and it is the most fun I’ve had in months.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My new paper, "Transparency is Surveillance," is now out in PPR. It's about how transparency and trust are in profound tension. About how transparency weeds out corruption and bias AND undermines expertise and sensitivity, all in one fell swoop.
Thread:
philpapers.org/rec/NGUTIS -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
New piece out in BR! It's "Polarization or Propaganda?" In which I stage a cage-match between two stories of WTF is going on:
1. Symmetrical polarization, i.e.: "Our society is so polarized and divided.
2. Propaganda, i.e.: "Fox News is BS."
Thread:
bostonreview.net/politics-philosophy-religion/c-thi-nguye… -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
One of the best pieces of advice I ever got, delivered by a wise person while I was fuming over a parking ticket:
"3% of your income is for mistakes. If it's too much over, you're too sloppy. If it's too much under, you're sweating the smalls stuff too much." -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
If you're looking for some weird aesthetic exploration to fight off the COVID boredom blues, can I recommend: avant-garde perfume. No, really. First:
1. Not all perfume is cloying mall crap. There's world of indie, experimental weird-ass perfume.
2. It's cheap.
Thread:Post not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Every time I teach aesthetics (except this year), I always ask my students if they think perfume can be real art. 90% say no. Then I bring in a few of these, let them try them, and they are almost all instantly convinced. I've had people cry from some of the nostalgic scents.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
My name is pronounced “tea”.
Have just discovered that, when I have my first sip of tea and say, “mmm, this is good tea”, my 4yo has been thinking that I am praising myself, each morning, for being a good boy. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
The more I think about it, the more weird it is to subscribe to the following discourse norms:
1. Anybody has a right to raise any question without significant cognitive investigation.
2. All people must put serious thought into answering any raised questions. -
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
This tweet is funny, but also kind of profound? Something about.... thinking that something is just a small problem in the design/tech, when really it is a deep problem in reality.
math prof
@mathematicsprof
Quote by a forest ranger at Yosemite National Park on why it is hard to design the perfect garbage bin to keep bears from breaking into it: “There is considerable overlap between the intelligence of the smartest bears and the dumbest tourists.”
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Update: one of my TA's followed up my "Bullshit" lecture with an entire section on one question: "Is this class bullshit?" Apparently, the class gleefully piled on with good arguments why it was bullshit. Then collectively realized that they had just demonstrated that it wasn't.
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Just had a lifetime peak teaching experience with my first trial go at putting Frankfurt's "On Bullshit" in my intro ethics class. Students are first laughing at the fact that we're analyzing "bullshit", and then laughing at how astonishingly profound the conversation goes.
-
C Thi Nguyen
@add_hawk
Just had a lifetime peak teaching experience with my first trial go at putting Frankfurt's "On Bullshit" in my intro ethics class. Students are first laughing at the fact that we're analyzing "bullshit", and then laughing at how astonishingly profound the conversation goes.
















































































