Moldaver wants someone to address "elephant in the room": #twu says its viability on the line. But if individual graduates can get in anyway, what's the problem? #scc Pratte: all we're saying is, we're not there yet.
Carissima Mathen
Carissima Mathen is a Canadian judge. She was appointed a judge of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice on May 1, 2024. More on Wikipedia
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Pratte throwing the "tolerance" arg back at #twu, tying it to fundamental duty of law societies. #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Pratte now going after BCCA analysis at para 188 which talks about "discomfort". LS entitled to refuse to accredit schools that shut out people of different views. Totally appropriate in a multi-cultural society. #twu
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Cote: Cov exclude lots of people. Pratte: and it's entitled to do that as a private institution. But it cant' seek state endorsement of its program through accreditation. #twu
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Karakatsanis: #twu explicit that it does not exclude anyone; just requires agreement. Also, does it matter that Covenant extends beyond campus? #scc Pratte: other believers/non believers are *not* welcome to sign Covenant.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Rowe asks whethere #lsuc has basically shut the door on religiously-based law schools. Pratte: having a law school based on those beliefs not so impt as to overcome other considerations. Now invoking SL. #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Hm....Pratte invoking "obligatory" practices now. No evidence that religion requires studying law with only co-religionists. #twu #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Brown: aren't we not supposed to be analysing the tie to religion? Isn't the degree of tie out of bounds? #twu #scc Pratte says it's inherent in 2nd step of 2a; AND he cites Ktunaxa.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
CJ: What is this was a Mormon group w/ Cov against alcohol consumption. Same arg? Pratte: question is whether LS could sanction such a policy. CJ: but would there be a breach of 2a? #twu #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Karakatsanis: is #twu imposing rel belief, or rel practice? Pratte: uncontradicted evidence that people with different beliefs cannot sign Cov. #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
CJ wants to know how #twu is forcing its beliefs. Pratte: requiring signing of Cov as condition of entry. Brown: this seems broader than what you need - 2a doesn't include forcing *law society* to enforce the belief. Pratte grabs lifeline. #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
CJ wants articulation of s.2a framework. Pratte: sincerity is fine. Degree of impairment trivial b/c it is the impact of the freedom on others that is at issue. Even if it is protected, it's at the "outer perimeter" of 2a. #twu
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Pratte: even if *no graduate* was admissible, that would be a minimal impairment, b/c they are not being treated differently from any one else (b/c they could attend an accredited law school) #twu
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Brown: so....if applicant is *admitted* in another province, would mobility agreement apply? Pratte pushes back against hypothetical; LS would have to decide on a process #twu
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Pratte: Running an accredited law school comes with responsibilities, which aren't mitigated by private status of that school. #twu #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Impact of admissions policy on non-believers exceeds protection of 2a. Cote: but they're not bound by the Charter, nor the BC hr code. #twu #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Pratte goes for a definitional limit under 2a in this case. "Putting my cards on the table." #scc #twu Cites Big M: Charter can't protect forcing beliefs on others.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Pratte realizes he never articulated his 4 points: jurisdiction; infringement; balancing; Dore "recipe". #scc #twu
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Pratte: exactly what are we balancing here? #twu's claim that it is being denied access to practice b/c of religion is inflated. #scc Rowe: are you claiming there is no infringement?
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Pratte make a reverse delegation argument. Rowe: are you saying such an admissions framework (by LS) would be illegal, or just bad policy? #twu
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Pratte: tuition not as clear a violation of human rights code. #twu #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Brown: so, are *all* admissions criteria reviewable? What about socio-economic conditions - prohibitive tuition? #twu #scc Pratte: that's not our case. (heh).
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Pratte: if #lsuc could not itself adopt discriminatory policies in its own law school, how could it accredit a law school that did? #twu #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
CJ: whatever the LS's power to impose educational stds, has to be directed at eventual provisions of legal services in ON (and not, presumably, broader considerations of equality/discrim). #scc #twu
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
CJ: isn't 4.1 conditioned on consideration of purpose to "provide legal services"? Seems narrower than what you're arguing for. #twu #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Back to #twu. Pratte now facing some questions by Rowe/CJ around scope of statutory authority. #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Think I'm getting throttled. Tweeting also at @cmathenalt. #scc #twu
-
Carissima Mathen reposted
Adam Dodek
@ADodek
Former child actor says being a law professor is like improv theater www.abajournal.com/news/article/former_child_actor_says_b…
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
K: so, can amend s6? ON: as long as you keep 3 of 9 judges from Quebec
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
K: you're saying its not SCAct that has been consitutionalized but #scc's essential characteristics? ON Yes
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
ON: could Parl abolish #scc? Feds didn't answer that but it's the inevitable conclusion of their arg
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
ON: must interpret s101 of CA1982 in light of unwritten constitutional; word "maintain" in that section must be read in present context
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
(As @adodek just told me, longer this goes on, more this case gets intertwined with Senate Ref. Result? 6 months or so)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
(I suppose the idea is that you're not tied to current legn in terms of drinking what is protected)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
(Can I be honest? This seems like a bit of an academic frolic.)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Abella: don't see how Part V is irrelevant, esp since you're now invoking 1982 ON: we don't say Part V has nothing to do with it
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
ON: note that UK PC could not be abolished by Parl #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
ON: basically, use Living Tree without actually mentioning it (a joke); constitution evolves from 1867
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Chief: until 1949 SCC was not final court; law shaped by UK. S 101 long precedes that, so how does your arg work?
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Cromw: so ss 5 and 6 reflect but do not mandate the extent of that protection? ON yes
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
If true, then oblig includes charact'cs that are essential Abella: place of Sup Ct Act? ON: composition incl 3 QC judges is protected
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Const arch requires maintenance of #scc as general court for appeal, absent amendment
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Protection for #scc flows from constitutional architecture, not any specific provision.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
2nd question re decl. provisions. Agree with QC that aspects of #scc have been consitutionalized, BUT independent of current Part V
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Ontario represented by former Osgoode Dean Patrick Monahan.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Left to speak: Ontario (60); Galati (15); Constitutional Rights (15); possible reply by Feds
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Sorry for dual accounts - twitter app behaving very badly.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Hearing to restart momentarily.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
QC now going to the "tense" issue in use of "has been", "from among"...#nadon #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
LeBel: lawyer in example; to maintain membership in bar, have to meet certain criteria
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
QC going back to tangible, concrete an contemporaneous link; possible in those circs; not possible is exp is 25 years ago
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
QC: based on hypotheses: LeBel: when I was appointed to CA my colleagues had been at war
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Moldaver: can you answer question about continuity of 10 yr period; seems impt for section 5
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
LeBel: seem to be talking more about political wisdom of apptmt; Que: can't challenge on individual qualities of person
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
QC: could go back quite far in time to find that cxn; Wagner correctly pinpointed earlier re: broader milieu
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Wagner: say we support args; person has worked several years in QC; no challenge; other bio (sounds like Lamer?)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
AG: yes, but we're interpreting s6 in light of underlying purpose
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
LeBel: the person remains member of Quebec bar? A: yes of course LeBel: but aren't you adding to the text?
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
QC uses example of Quebec-trained lawyer who moves to Vcvr (hey sounds familiar!); can this person be eligible under s6?
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Wagner: asks whether 10 yrs must continuous period? Nadon met neither requirement under s6
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
QC: taking on tangible, concrete and contemporaneous links; not in the Act, but interpretive theory; respect. S6
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
QC going to pre-Confed arrangements and expectations re judges
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Que: S6 does not supplant s5, but supplements them #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
QC tries to dispatch arg that s.6 permits appt of brand new call: 10 yrs is minimum for anyone.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Quebec now moving to Q1.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
QC taking opportunity to remind #scc that the optics of this reference (seeking advice while telling Court) are v odd
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
LeBel wants to know whether previous case of Canada Bread has any application here QC: can't rely on them to avoid constitutionality
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
QC's position on constitutionality takes declaratory provs out of Parl toolkit #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
QC pointing out that AG Canada's stated position that s.41(d) is anticipatory of actual entrenchment/means nothing is unaccaptable
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Que: 41(d) clearly applies to SCC; meant to protect it #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
QC: must read Part V s.41(d) ask in light of that agreement
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Que notes that in 1982 no agreement on fed institutions; but agreement reached in 1981 re amending #scc (8 provs incl Que)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Chief: suppose people decide that retirement age should be 70 not 75. Covered? A: No position. We believe that 5 and 6 are entrenched.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
LeBel: what does "composition" mean?
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Now, AG Quebec, who has 60 mins. Deal with Q2 (declaratory provisions); Quebec argues that s.6 has become entrenched #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Grammond argues that excluding FCC and prov judges is the negative absurd result.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Gr argues for absurd results both negative and positive; trust PM not to appoint clearly unqualified judges
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
(What this arg is ignoring is that you can absolutely choose a bright line to achieve an "intangible" goal)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Grammond now raising specter of endless judicial review of appts #nadon #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Gr now discussing negative impact on Quebec-trained lawyer and judges living outside the province #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
(I'm sorry - and seeking direct appt of provincial ct judges is NOT wishful thinking?)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Grammond argues that relying in less technical crit reflects wishful thinking re appointments #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Gr uses debates at the time to argue that he only concern was civil law knowledge #nadon #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Gr: what is objective of s6? Opposite side relies on cxn; establishing a hierarchy of judges. #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Gr: Why wasn't SCA amended? Mostly, never had a crisis; counting on constitutional reform then underway which mostly dealt with declarations
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Moldaver: back to reality; if Nadon went back to Quebec bar, he only needs one day? Grammond: that's the implication of other side #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Karakstanis: must the ten year be a continuous period? Grammond: no
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Abella: could the intention be broader: current cxn to Quebc legal environment? Gr: no, nothing in debates to support that #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Abella: you want us to ignore the specificity of the language and look at intention? Grammond thinks you still can rely on "has been"
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Grammond: Parl concerned to maintain prov connection: simply mentioned courts in Quebec at the time #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Abella: how do you explain different language for judges from Quebec? Grammond: different legal tradition Abella: doesn't SAY that #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Interv prov judges rely heavily on other statues dealing with appts of judges to divorce distinction between being a judge/bar membership
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Grammond cautions that evaluating apptees is a political decision #nadon SCC
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Aaand we're back with Ottawa Civil Law Dean Sebastien Grammond repr'g prov court judges and three retired FCC judges #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Morning recess.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Moldaver gamely asking in French about Part V
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
LeBel: could Parl amend Act to remove requirement that appt eyes be lawyers?
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Canada's bottom line appears to be that broader con law questions not squarely before the Court #nadon #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Canada arguing: what possible harm could arise from departing from contemporaneous connection? (That doesn't answer leg intent tho)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
K's first question: if legislator wants "contemporaneous connection" to legal profession, doesn't THAT matter to your interpretation?
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
(One thing people dont like to talk about is practice, eg that no FCC judge apptd under s6) nor prov judges under either section)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Canada hedges; LeBel having none of it
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Canada trying to tie this to s.101 of CA1867 Wagner: if Parl can amend SCAct under that section, can it abograte the court? #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Canada is frankly confusing me here
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Tee hee
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Canada says question relates to Parl authority under s.101 (they're determined to avoid s.52 and Part V amendment issues)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Feds don't thnk constitutional question is as broad as other parties argue; not before you. LeBel not buying it: what is before us?
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
LeBel: if we answer Q1 differently, what does that mean for declaratory provision? Can: then have to go to jurisdiction (const'ality)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
If you agree with us on Q1 (ss 5 and 6) have always meant that, becomes simpler
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Canada now moving on to Question 2: declaratory provisions (which means govt tells court HOW to interpret) #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Canada relies on massive exclusion of "qualified candidates". Frankly, we're talking about such a rarified pool, never found that convincing
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Canada relying on strict technical expertise, not the cultural/legitimacy argument that I make, and that Wagner posed earlier #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Canada now taking on Quebec: its basic argument is currency of membership is required to ensure that civil tradition is maintained #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
There are more probing questions than I might have expected. Pleasantly surprised. #nadon #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Cromwell: s5 potentially includes lawyers/judges regardless of currency; s6 may not. Canada relying on s6's use of word "the judges" #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Crowmell: why can't section 5 set out, say, four eligible groups for appt while section 6 only sets out two? #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Feds arguing that ss5 and 6 is the focus; LeBel points out that it IS about composition, albeit in exceptional circs #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Wagner going back to ad hoc judges question; this was amended in 2002 only for Fed Ct judges NOT representing Quebec #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Can arguing that the real import for Quebec seats was concern for civil law expertise, not two sets of qualifications
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Cromwell presses. "I don't have an answer for that" Can saying it just wasn't considered when s30 was amended #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Don't think this long historical treatise answers question of why s.30 continued to distinguish between s5 and 6 as late as 2002 #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Can going to historical precedents: s 30 created in specific circumstances long past when ad hoc judges were actually used
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Can: no real amendments to ss 5 and 6 LeBel: what about section 30? ( which does mention Fed Ct ad hoc judges BUT not for Quebec)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Chief: how do you explain the lack of inclusion of Federal Ct judges over all this time?
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Abella doesn't seem to buying that s.6 adds so little to s.5 of SCA #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Abella: can't decide this based on worth of Fed Ct judges (THANK YOU). #scc #nadon #thisisnotpersonal
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Liked that LeBel turned absurdity issue on its head: Can's arg means you could be appointed if you were a disbarred judge #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Wagner: aside from technical legal training, is there not something more to being a "Quebec" judge? #scc #nadon
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Aargh - wifi foes. Anyway, glad to see judges asking tough questions, including now by Wagner: regardless of words, what about purpose
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Lunch! Sadly real life intervenes for me. Will follow up later.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Term limits: always discussed as component of method of selection, companion to, for example, election. Agree with Court of Appeal here.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Wagner: what about other minorities; how does living tree accommodate them within PartV? A: obligation would be non-justifiable
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
So why mention Queen but not Senate in s41? Historical issues then current. Abolition never seriously considered.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Bicameralism is not by chance, it defines most federal states as essential governance?
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
It is not a leap to say that those institutions central to amending, mentioned within in, are captured within 41(e)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Abolition by 7-50 would allow it despite objections of 3 original partners constituting majority of Senate seats.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
In 1980, Feds made specific choice to put off Senate reform, not part of Patriation package
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Senate has evolved into body that protects minority interests
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Thus s42 has prohibitive aspects, putting certain things out of Parl's reach
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Senate has advanced interests of francophones
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
What are the interests of francophones? Significant. Elections would not work, specially when they are dispersed
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Three historical points; participants assumed continued existence of the senate; parl given limited power to amend Senate; scope of s42
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Citing #scc decn in Prosper: comment that living tree cannot transform essential meaning of the document. Can't uproot "tree" altogether!
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Now, about conflict between original intent and living tree; need to consider all sources
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Second, obligation to consult minorities (admittedly more political than legal)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Two points: if Amending affects minorities, need greater consensus, at least 7-50
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Now, #uottawa civil law dean Sebastien Grammond representing Francophone/Acadiab intervener group!
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Nunavut adopts amending amending formula argument, requires unanimity in respect of the Senate
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Charter was agreed to by provs because of amending formula.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Nunavut homeland of an Ab people, vast prop of nation's land mass
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
(You know, lots of mention of Patriation didn't need unanimity, No mention of consequence of Quebec's refusal to future of federation.)
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Nunavut references minority rights which has gotten scant mention so far here at #scc
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Chief: this is all interesting but none of it happened.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Nunavut invokes proposed CA 1987 (Meech Lake) , which repealed s42 and folded everything into s41
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Basic point: We have achieved or been close to unanimity before
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Nunavut now invoking unanimity in 1982, oops I meant 1992. LeBel: what about referendum? A: not in Part V. Laughter.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Nunavut going to explanatory notes of s44. (Parl alone) which talks about narrow nature and other provs which protect "fed-prov balance"
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Nunavut agrees with ON, Que, NS, NB, PEI et cetera.
-
Carissima Mathen
@cmathenalt
Just got throttled! NWT finishes up with another pitch for consultation. Now up, Nunavut. #scc #senca