Three days to go! See later post in thread for registration details
⭐️ The next Ethics of Argumentation talk will be “Against ‘Reason Supremacism’ in Democratic Politics” by Catarina Dutilh Novaes (@cdutilhnovaes), January 10th, 1 PM ET/6 PM GMT
Politicians, athletes, journalists, NGOs, companies... They all use corporation-owned social networks to communicate with us. Citizens shouldn't have to hand over their data to companies to read content published by public entities. Public Feeds changes that by making posts of popular accounts freely available. Read more.
Catarina Dutilh Novaes is a Brazilian and Dutch philosopher whose research concerns the formalization of argumentation and reasoning in the history of logic and the philosophy of logic. She is a professor at Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam in the Netherlands, and a professorial fellow at the Arché philosophical research centre of the University of St Andrews in Scotland. More on Wikipedia
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Three days to go! See later post in thread for registration details
⭐️ The next Ethics of Argumentation talk will be “Against ‘Reason Supremacism’ in Democratic Politics” by Catarina Dutilh Novaes (@cdutilhnovaes), January 10th, 1 PM ET/6 PM GMT
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
@sconinxphil and I invite you to our workshop on Technological Niche Disruptions at @VUamsterdam, December 5+6, 2024. With @cdutilhnovaes, Ivar Kolvoort,Richard Heersmink, Stella Hao, Regina Fabry @HopsterJeroen, Erik Rietveld, Shiyanthi Thavapalan sites.google.com/view/tend-project/events
Entrevista que fiz sobre teorias da conspiração (eu prefiro o termo 'crenças conspiratórias') com o Caio do @UGeneralista Argumento que é essencial se levar em consideração também conspirações reais para uma abordagem epistemológica do tema.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=T8y5ZtyNX3U
Depois de ter gravado essa entrevista, fiquei conhecendo o trabalho do Paolo Demuru @demurup sobre o assunto, muito bom!
Ilustríssima Conversa 🎧 | Conspirações seduzem por oferecer encanto em mundo individualista, diz Paolo Demuru (@demurup).
Em entrevista a @eduardosombini, pesquisador defende que esquerda aposte em discursos baseados na esperança para quebrar feitiço da extrema direita.
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
It’s fun in philosophy when you come to a debate confident that you understand something, and then someone else shows you how wrong you are. If you want to change your understanding of the epistemic challenges posed by conspiracy theories, read Catarina’s paper!
My paper on conspiratorial beliefs is now online: 'How conspiratorial beliefs spread, and how real conspiracies are covered up' #openaccess One of my motivations for writing this paper was to take the existence of real conspiracies seriously. Abstract 👇
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0020174X.2024.2375770
My paper on conspiratorial beliefs is now online: 'How conspiratorial beliefs spread, and how real conspiracies are covered up' #openaccess One of my motivations for writing this paper was to take the existence of real conspiracies seriously. Abstract 👇
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0020174X.2024.2375770
->conspirators do not want to become widely known. A pessimistic implication of my analysis seems to be that we are simply not well-equipped to distinguish, on principled grounds, conspiratorial beliefs that merit further investigation from those that do not. END
The paper engages extensively with the work of @NeilLevy10 @add_hawk Possibly of interest to @joshuadipaolo @QCassam @Wiglet1981
@danwilliamsphil the paper I presented in Valencia, you are thanked in a footnote.
This research may be of interest to @mariannaspring, who's doing great work on conspiracies and disinformation.
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Today is #ketikoti ("The Chain is Broken"), anniversary of the formal abolishment of slavery in the former Dutch colonies in 1863 (de facto in 1873).
The Netherlands still has much work to do to deal with its colonial/slavery past, which makes #ketikoti particularly significant!
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
The Masterclass in the Philosophy of Mathematical Practices 2024 @VUBrussel @vubclps
with Catarina Dutilh Novaes (VU Amsterdam) @cdutilhnovaes
starts today!
Looking forward to the dynamic and interactive sessions by our keynote and the many lovely talks by young scholars.
This has been out for a year already, but it's one of the best 'true crime' pieces I've ever read. It's humane, touching, funny, insightful, all at once. Highly recommended!
In 2015, my mother fell in love online with an American soldier who was, in fact, a Nigerian romance scammer.
Seven years later, I travelled to Lagos to search for him, immersing myself in the world of "Yahoo Boys."
magazine.atavist.com/the-romance-scammer-on-my-sofa-niger…
The amazing @MMTalbi, PhD candidate at our project @erc_sea, has a new article out! "The epistemic import of narratives" She argues that narratives can help foster common ground in situations of epistemic (& other) diversity.
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02691728.2024.235651…
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Filosofische analyse van allerlei morele, politieke en epistemische kwesties rond de Capitoolbestorming, met o.a. @cdutilhnovaes, @ridderjeroen, Naomi Kloosterboer en ondergetekende.
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Had a great time at the SEA closing conference this week @VUamsterdam, w/ @Ale1808 @Natalan @cdutilhnovaes @DavidLudwigWUR @a_nonamename & many others. A diverse group of people, diverse points of view, #onlineaccessible! All under Marx's watchful eyes
Philosophers of mathematical practice, join us in Brussels!
Only two days left to apply for the Masterclass in the Philosophy of Mathematical Practices 2024
with Catarina Dutilh Novaes (VU Amsterdam) @cdutilhnovaes
sites.google.com/view/mc-pmp-brussels-2024/
A great chance for young scholars to present their work in a friendly environment.
The philosophers of mathematical practice in Brussels are hosting a masterclass/workshop with/on my work at the end of June, with a Call for Abstracts for early career researchers (250 words, deadline May 2) 👇
sites.google.com/view/mc-pmp-brussels-2024
The full program for our conference on the social epistemology of argumentation at VU Amsterdam is now online! The conference will be hybrid, registration through the site 👇
(We still have some spots available in-person attendance as well.)
sites.google.com/view/seaconference/home?authuser=0
Muchas gracias @Eritorresto 😊
💜💜De nuestra serie de 2022, ERIKA TORRES💜💜
En este video Erika (@Eritorresto) nos habla de base cognitiva y social de los lenguajes formales (y razonamiento deductivo), y nos invita a leer el trabajo de Catarina Dutilh Novaes (@cdutilhnovaes).
www.youtube.com/watch?v=MA0Zn_c9Or0&list=PLg9kJiXBR875zNf…
Pacific APA goers! Our symposium on 'The Foucauldian Mind' will happen on Friday morning, with a stellar line-up 🤩 Come join us in Portland!
(Very annoyingly, it wasn't possible to add the names of my co-authors to the official program, but they will be there!)
This is the full version of the poster, somehow the previous one was missing the final line.
Very cool new book just dropped, and still available for free download, so go get it!
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
And what a keynote by Catarina Dutilh-Novaes @cdutilhnovaes on mistakes in mathematical proofs! Such an intriguing topic! This is a must-watch. youtu.be/xIkh4vi0uNc
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Full program online for our Workshop Perspectives on Scientific Error | 29 Feb, 1 and 2 March 2024! Program: docs.google.com/document/d/19sSFn7ea8KpfKjh6Ewp_AT0ZvudpP… Keynotes by @siminevazire @JudithterSchure @ianhussey @cdutilhnovaes
Registration (only 10 seats left): www.eventbrite.nl/e/workshop-perspectives-on-scientific-e…
Next week I'll be in Berlin, giving a talk on conspiratorial beliefs on Wednesday January 17th (coincidentally, my PhD defense anniversary!). It's open to all, more info on when and where here 👇
www.philosophie.hu-berlin.de/de/oeffentliche_vortraege
The special issue of the Midwest Studies in Philosophy on genealogy of belief is now available, and it looks fab ✨ My own #openaccess paper there is about genealogical anxiety 👇
www.pdcnet.org/msp/content/msp_2023_0047_0103_0133
I'll be in Oslo this week to give a talk to the GoodAttention group led by @watzl_sebastian. The talk can be followed on zoom too, details below 👇 The topic is attentional networks in the three-tiered model of epistemic exchange that I've been developing.
www.hf.uio.no/ifikk/english/research/projects/goodattenti…
Two more days to submit an abstract for our conference at the end of April in Amsterdam!
⚡Call for Papers: Social Epistemology of argumentation ⚡ (Pls re-share!)
All good things come to an end... Our @ERC_Research
project 'Social Epistemology of Argumentation' is wrapping up & we're hosting a conference to close it in style. Details👇
philevents.org/event/show/116290
Let's talk pop culture!
Which series do you like best, The Wire or The Sopranos? They are both amazing, but currently The Wire has my preference, for its nuanced treatment of deep social issues.
Discuss 😀
Interestingly, my partner likes The Sopranos better, so this is a conversation I have with him sometimes. Fun to see what others think!
🚨 Call for Papers for a Topoi Collection 🚨
'Social Epistemology of Argumentation'
Parallel to our @erc_sea closing conference, we'll also edit a Collection at Topoi, which is open to all (not only to speakers at the conference).
Deadline: Aug. 31 2024
link.springer.com/collections/ieigacecbd
The Call for Abstracts of the conference 👇
philevents.org/event/show/116294
Very nice CfP for a collection in Topoi @SpringerPhil, edited by @DoctorSpurt @SuttonProfessor & Giovanna Colombetti: 'Scaffolding Bad: Varieties of Situated Cognitive Harm'.
I'll try to submit something myself 😊
link.springer.com/collections/aadfbjhfec
"Treatments of situated and extended cognition and affect tend to be optimistic and apolitical, focusing mostly on the benefits of external cognitive resources for an individual user... Recent work has suggested that 4E thinking should recant its ‘Dogma of Harmony’"
YES to that!
I now have a profile at the other place 🔵☀️, same handle as here. Find me there if you're there too!
⚡Call for Papers: Social Epistemology of argumentation ⚡ (Pls re-share!)
All good things come to an end... Our @ERC_Research
project 'Social Epistemology of Argumentation' is wrapping up & we're hosting a conference to close it in style. Details👇
philevents.org/event/show/116290
*Social epistemology of science and academia
*Social epistemology of argumentation as viewed from the perspective of feminist, decolonial, queer philosophy and disabilities studies
*The role of trust in argumentation
Funding is available for scholars who require additional financial support (see submission form).
Sponsors: @ERC_Research, journal Topoi @SpringerPhil
Organizers: Solmu Anttila, Merel Talbi, Natalie Ashton, Catarina Dutilh Novaes
I have a new paper out, 'Should We Be Genealogically Anxious? From Anxiety to Epistemic Agency and Critical Resistance'. I'll paste the abstract below, and a link to an #openaccess version of it.
www.pdcnet.org/msp/content/msp_2023_0999_10_31_42
->is significantly curtailed. I present a model of belief-forming processes that highlights how networks of attention and trust/distrust influence these processes. The model suggests that, while there is a lot happening beyond our control that shapes what we come to believe,->
->we still retain some degree of agency to the extent that we can rewire our networks of attention and trust/distrust. I conclude that, surprisingly, genealogical anxiety may in fact increase agency insofar as it may encourage critical resistance./END
I'll be speaking at this awesome conference next Friday (9.00 CET); my talk will be titled 'Argumentative Injustice Revisited' (joint work with @solmuanttila). It will be on zoom, so anyone can join! Contact the organizer @philtaufiq for details 😊
The 11th ICNP will address issues on epistemic justice and feature four invited speakers: Prof Catarina Novaes (@cdutilhnovaes ); Prof Amandine Catala (@amandine_catala ); Dr Saraswati Putri (@sarasdewi ); and Agus Wahyudi, PhD (Kepala PSP UGM)
(My connections with philosophers in Africa are still quite patchy, need to work on that!)
There's lots of great work being done in many places; now that so many events are online, there's really no reason not to be more geographically inclusive in our philosophical dealings.
Here's the abstract of my talk 👇
Prof Catarina Novaes, the winner of the 2022 Lakatos Award, will construct epistemic/argumentative injustice within a model of epistemic exchange that she has been developing in her recent work.
One of the best assessments of the current situation in Israel and Gaza that I’ve come across lately.
Absolutely masterful interview on Gaza of Dominique De Villepin, former Prime Minister of France, who famously led France's opposition to the Iraq war and who, IMHO is the best diplomat the West has produced in decades.
This is so important, so incredibly well argued, that I decided to translate it in full:
"Hamas has set a trap for us, and this trap is one of maximum horror, of maximum cruelty. And so there's a risk of an escalation in militarism, of more military interventions, as if we could with armies solve a problem as serious as the Palestinian question.
There's also a second major trap, which is that of Occidentalism. We find ourselves trapped, with Israel, in this western bloc which today is being challenged by most of the international community.
[Presenter: What is Occidentalism?]
Occidentalism is the idea that the West, which for 5 centuries managed the world's affairs, will be able to quietly continue to do so. And we can clearly see, even in the debates of the French political class, that there is the idea that, faced with what is currently happening in the Middle East, we must continue the fight even more, towards what might resemble a religious or a civilizational war. That is to say, to isolate ourselves even more on the international stage.
This is not the way, especially since there's a third trap, which is that of moralism. And here we have in a way the proof, through what is happening in Ukraine and what is happening in the Middle East, of this double standard that is denounced everywhere in the world, including in recent weeks when I travel to Africa, the Middle East, or Latin America. The criticism is always the same: look at how civilian populations are treated in Gaza, you denounce what happened in Ukraine, and you are very timid in the face of the tragedy unfolding in Gaza.
Consider international law, the second criticism that is made by the global south. We sanction Russia when it aggresses Ukraine, we sanction Russia when it doesn't respect the resolutions of the United Nations, and it's been 70 years that the resolutions of the United Nations have been voted in vain and that Israel doesn't respect them.
[Presenter: Do you believe that the Westerners are currently guilty of hubris?]
Westerners must open their eyes to the extent of the historical drama unfolding before us to find the right answers.
[Presenter: What is the historical drama? I mean, we're talking about the tragedy of October 7th first and foremost, right?]
Of course, there are these horrors happening, but the way to respond to them is crucial. Are we going to kill the future by finding the wrong answers...
[Presenter: Kill the future?]
Kill the future, yes! Why?
[Presenter: But who is killing whom?]
You are in a game of causes and effects. Faced with the tragedy of history, one cannot take this 'chain of causality' analytical grid, simply because if you do you can't escape from it. Once we understand that there is a trap, once we realize that behind this trap there has also been a change in the Middle East regarding the Palestinian issue... The situation today is profoundly different [from what it was in the past]. The Palestinian cause was a political and secular cause. Today we are faced with an Islamist cause, led by Hamas. Obviously, this kind of cause is absolute and allows no form of negotiation. On the Israeli side, there has also been a development. Zionism was secular and political, championed by Theodor Herzl in the late 19th century. It has largely become messianic, biblical today. This means that they too do not want to compromise, and everything that the far-right Israeli government does, continuing to encourage colonization, obviously makes things worse, including since October 7th. So in this context, understand that we are already in this region facing a problem that seems profoundly insoluble.
Added to this is the hardening of states. Diplomatically, look at the statements of the King of Jordan, they are not the same as six months ago. Look at the statements of Erdogan in Turkey.
[Presenter: Precisely, these are extremely harsh statements...]
Extremely worrying. Why? Because if the Palestinian cause, the Palestinian issue, hasn't been brought to the forefront, hasn't been put on stage [for a while], and if most of the youth today in Europe have often never even heard of it, it remains for the Arab peoples the mother of all battles. All the progress made towards an attempt to stabilize the Middle East, where one could believe...
[Presenter: Yes, but whose fault is it? I have a hard time following you, is it Hamas's fault?]
But Ms. Malherbe, I am trained as a diplomat. The question of fault will be addressed by historians and philosophers.
[Presenter: But you can't remain neutral, it's difficult, it's complicated, isn't it?]
I am not neutral, I am in action. I am simply telling you that every day that passes, we can ensure that this horrific cycle stops... that's why I speak of a trap and that's why it's so important to know what response we are going to give. We stand alone before history today. And we do not treat this new world the way we currently do, knowing that today we are no longer in a position of strength, we are not able to manage on our own, as the world's policemen.
[Presenter: So what do we do?]
Exactly, what should we do? This is where it is essential not to cut off anyone on the international stage.
[Presenter: Including the Russians?]
Everyone.
[Presenter: Everyone? Should we ask the Russians for help?]
I'm not saying we should ask the Russians for help. I'm saying: if the Russians can contribute by calming some factions in this region, then it will be a step in the right direction.
[Presenter: How can we proportionally respond to barbarism? It's no longer army against army.]
But listen, Appolline de Malherbe, the civilian populations that are dying in Gaza, don't they exist? So because horror was committed on one side, horror must be committed on the other?
[Presenter: Do we indeed need to equate the two?]
No, it's you who are doing that. I'm not saying I equate the faults. I try to take into account what a large part of humanity thinks. There is certainly a realistic objective to pursue, which is to eradicate the Hamas leaders who committed this horror. And not to confuse the Palestinians with Hamas, that's a realistic goal.
The second thing is a targeted response. Let's define realistic political objectives. And the third thing is a combined response. Because there is no effective use of force without a political strategy. We are not in 1973 or in 1967. There are things no army in the world knows how to do, which is to win in an asymmetrical battle against terrorists. The war on terror has never been won anywhere. And it instead triggers extremely dramatic misdeeds, cycles, and escalations. If America lost in Afghanistan, if America lost in Iraq, if we lost in the Sahel, it's because it's a battle that can't be won simply, it's not like you have a hammer that strikes a nail and the problem is solved. So we need to mobilize the international community, get out of this Western entrapment in which we are.
[Presenter: But when Emmanuel Macron talks about an international coalition…]
Yes, and what was the response?
[Presenter: None.]
Exactly. We need a political perspective, and this is challenging because the two-state solution has been removed from the Israeli political and diplomatic program. Israel needs to understand that for a country with a territory of 20,000 square kilometers, a population of 9 million inhabitants, facing 1.5 billion people... Peoples have never forgotten that the Palestinian cause and the injustice done to the Palestinians was a significant source of mobilization. We must consider this situation, and I believe it is essential to help Israel, to guide... some say impose, but I think it's better to convince, to move in this direction. The challenge is that there is no interlocutor today, neither on the Israeli side nor the Palestinian side. We need to bring out interlocutors.
[Presenter: It's not for us to choose who will be the leaders of Palestine.]
The Israeli policy over recent years did not necessarily want to cultivate a Palestinian leadership... Many are in prison, and Israel's interest - because I repeat: it was not in their program or in Israel's interest at the time, or so they thought - was instead to divide the Palestinians and ensure that the Palestinian question fades. This Palestinian question will not fade. And so we must address it and find an answer. This is where we need courage. The use of force is a dead end. The moral condemnation of what Hamas did - and there's no "but" in my words regarding the moral condemnation of this horror - must not prevent us from moving forward politically and diplomatically in an enlightened manner. The law of retaliation is a never-ending cycle.
[Presenter: The "eye for an eye, tooth for tooth".]
Yes. That's why the political response must be defended by us. Israel has a right to self-defense, but this right cannot be indiscriminate vengeance. And there cannot be collective responsibility of the Palestinian people for the actions of a terrorist minority from Hamas.
When you get into this cycle of finding faults, one side's memories clash with the other's. Some will juxtapose Israel's memories with the memories of the Nakba, the 1948 catastrophe, which is a disaster that the Palestinians still experience every day. So you can't break these cycles. We must have the strength, of course, to understand and denounce what happened, and from this standpoint, there's no doubt about our position. But we must also have the courage, and that's what diplomacy is... diplomacy is about being able to believe that there is light at the end of the tunnel. And that's the cunning of history; when you're at the bottom, something can happen that gives hope. After the 1973 war, who would have thought that before the end of the decade, Egypt would sign a peace treaty with Israel?
The debate shouldn't be about rhetoric or word choice. The debate today is about action; we must act. And when you think about action, there are two options. Either it's war, war, war. Or it's about trying to move towards peace, and I'll say it again, it's in Israel's interest. It's in Israel's interest!"
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Looking forward to this, both the event and being in Valencia 💃
Our first in-person workshop on “Varieties of Misinformation” is coming up. Check the program out and join us if you are around!
Looking forward to this, both the event and being in Valencia 💃
Our first in-person workshop on “Varieties of Misinformation” is coming up. Check the program out and join us if you are around!
On my way to Paris now! It looks like nothing will stand between me and this lecture now. See you tomorrow, Collège de France! 🇫🇷
Last year I had to cancel my presentation at the Collège de France due to a covid infection. Fortunately, I get another chance this year! It will be on October 16th at 14.00, all welcome 😊
www.college-de-france.fr/fr/agenda/seminaire/la-philosoph…
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
I’d say you are allowed to fight fire with fire because it’s a unfair policy! For instance, you could simplify titles, remove issue numbers, pages, volume editors, city of publisher, etc… and reintroduce them at proofing stage, when they’ll ask you why they are missing 😏
As a 'synthetic philosopher', word limits are really bad for me... I want to cite *all the things*, drawing from all kinds of different fields, but then my papers end up with rather long bibliographies. Here's a plea for word counts NOT to include bibliographies! 🥴
In case anyone is wondering, here's what I understand by 'synthetic philosophy' (with eternal gratitude to @nescio13 for introducing me to the term!).
dailynous.com/2023/05/30/a-plea-for-synthetic-philosophy-…
Current dilemma: paper should be max 10k (special issue instructions), main text (including footnotes) is 9k, bibliography is 2k 🥴
Sounds like a typical quantificational ambiguity. The generic "violent resistance is justified" can be read as "*some* violent resistance is justified" or as "*all* violent resistance is justified". Seems pretty obvious that the reasonable reading should be the existential one.
Seems some people infer something along the lines of "violent resistance is justified"; <some particular thing> was violent resistance; hence <some particular thing>is justified. This is very very bad reasoning, and disagreeing with it does not mean denying the first premise.
And if *some* violent resistance is justified (which I think is a plausible claim), the next question is, what distinguishes justified from unjustified violent resistance? It's consistent to both support Palestine & deplore the Israeli gov. policies AND condem the Hamas methods.
I deleted my post on Sen, as apparently he is alive and kicking 👇
Friends, thanks for your concern but it’s fake news: Baba is totally fine. We just spent a wonderful week together w/ family in Cambridge—his hug as strong as always last night when we said bye! He is teaching 2 courses a week at Harvard, working on his gender book—busy as ever!
Symposium bij @_knaw op 16 november: Democratie, protest en propaganda - De vele gezichten van democratische dialogen. De sprekers zijn @MaartjeJanse (Leiden) @marijemartijn (VU), Frans Willem Korsten (Leiden) en ikzelf (VU).
Allen welkom!
www.knaw.nl/bijeenkomsten/democratie-protest-en-propagand…
Last year I had to cancel my presentation at the Collège de France due to a covid infection. Fortunately, I get another chance this year! It will be on October 16th at 14.00, all welcome 😊
www.college-de-france.fr/fr/agenda/seminaire/la-philosoph…
Save the Humanities at Australian Catholic University - Sign the Petition! www.change.org/p/save-the-humanities-at-australian-cathol… via @Change
The lack of strategic vision (not to speak of the sheer cruelty of these plans) is shocking. The reputational damage is huge: no Humanities academic anywhere in the world will ever take ACU seriously anymore.
Btw this case is getting lots of attention among philosophers bc the affected faculty at Dianoia are people w stellar international reputation. But the callousness of admin folks just deciding on ppl's future on a whim is very widespread & equally despicable for less famous ppl.
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
O caçador redimido: a história de um peão que ganhava a vida caçando onças-pintadas no Pantanal e, arrependido, trabalha hoje na preservação da espécie. "De bicho papão das onças, me transformei em protetor delas." piaui.folha.uol.com.br/o-cacador-redimido/
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
I am honoured to have been elected as President of the European Society of Analytic Philosophy (ESAP) for the period 2023-2026. I will try to do my best to promote Analytic Philosophy in Europe.
Find here the information about ESAP
analyticphilosophy.eu
🚨 HEEEEEELLLLP!!! 🚨
My iPhone froze! 😳 📱 The usual way of reseting is not working (pressing the side buttons simultaneously).
Any other ideas on how to get it going again? TIA 😅
UPDATE: Fixed!! 🥳 Thanks to tip by @sethadelman below 🙏🙏
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Exposición de algunas ideas sobre la filosofía científica o sintética, por parte de @cdutilhnovaes.
Os mencioné este texto hace días. Estuve en el mini-curso que Dutilh hizo sobre filosofía sintética, estas ideas ya las comentó ahí
Yo las compro todas :)
t.ly/96Pyk
Happy to be able to finally confirm that I'll be going to Valencia and deliver my lecture in person! I'll be talking about how conspiracy theories spread AND hide.
Call for Abstracts 🔊
Workshop: Varieties of Misinformation.
Date: 26-27 October 2023.
Confirmed speakers:
@cdutilhnovaes
Jessica Keiser
@Plural_truth
@Ale1808
@Nefvil
@danwilliamsphil
More info 👇👇
vlclab.blogs.uv.es/event/workshop-varieties-of-misinforma…
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Just sent out delegate packs for the "Functional Hypotheses..." conference @NottsPhilosophy 14-15 Sep. But there is still time to register! Details here: nott.ac/functionalhypotheses. Looking forward to the sessions. @m_j_hannon @matthieu_queloz @cdutilhnovaes @prescottcouch
The @erc_sea team will all be in Vienna for ECAP next week, and we'll be presenting our symposium 'Political Epistemology of Argumentation' on Thursday morning (rather early 🙄). Do show up if that's your jam! @solmuanttila @MMTalbi @Natalan @hugormota
Panel discussion at the end of the symposium--or alternatively, police lineup of the usual suspects 😆 @hugormota @Natalan @solmuanttila @MMTalbi
(Thanks to @celinehenne for the pic.)
Excellent news that Timmermans will be the candidate to PM for the Labour/Green cooperation at the upcoming elections in the Netherlands!
It's hard to think of a better candidate at this point in time @PvdA @groenlinks
Klimaatcrisis, wooncrisis, ongelijkheid: de uitdagingen waar NL voor staat zijn groot. Maar we kunnen het aan, mits we ons zelfvertrouwen, het vertrouwen in elkaar en het vertrouwen in de overheid herontdekken en invullen. Het moet en het kan.
Samen doen, dan komt het goed. 1/2
Very nice thread on my book 'The Dialogical Roots of Deduction' 😊
Wonderful new book just dropped 🤩
Daniele is currently one of my favorite philosophical interlocutors, well-versed in multiple philosophical traditions & with an unusually sharp philosophical mind. So this book is bound to be a tour de force (not only for Foucault scholarship!)
Thrilled to have you onboard, @loehrgui 🤩 much fun will be had!
I am excited to announce that, as of today, I am an Assistant Professor (TT) at @VUamsterdam. I'll be working with @cdutilhnovaes on many things including AI and conceptual engineering. I am extremely grateful to be given this opportunity because... 1/3
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Catarina @cdutilhnovaes leading us through Dialogical Roots of Deduction 😊
In Buenos Aires for CLMPST! Who else is here? My first talk is tomorrow at 14.30 (History of Logic track) & my second talk on Tuesday at 12.00 (Mathematics, Modality and Knowledge Symposium). With 15 parallel sessions, the attention economy is fierce :D clmpst2023.dc.uba.ar
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/mila.12471 I am more than excited to share this fun little @esdit_nl paper on conceptual engineering and Predictive Processing I wrote with @cmichelphil To my knowledge the first CE paper published in Mind and Language. Open Access 1/2
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Prof Catarina Novaes, the winner of the 2022 Lakatos Award, will construct epistemic/argumentative injustice within a model of epistemic exchange that she has been developing in her recent work.
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
The 11th ICNP will address issues on epistemic justice and feature four invited speakers: Prof Catarina Novaes (@cdutilhnovaes ); Prof Amandine Catala (@amandine_catala ); Dr Saraswati Putri (@sarasdewi ); and Agus Wahyudi, PhD (Kepala PSP UGM)
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
"Functional Hypotheses and the Engaged Point of View". Free two-day conference 14th-15th September 2023. w/ @cdutilhnovaes, @matthieu_queloz, @prescottcouch, @m_j_hannon and others. Details: philevents.org/event/show/111430. @UoNArts @NottsPhilosophy @UoNHumanities.
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
The latest special issue of The Philosophical Quarterly on the work of Katherine Hawley is dedicated to her memory. The issue features works by Alexander Bird, Miranda Fricker, Elizabeth Barnes, and more: academic.oup.com/pq/issue/73/3 @StAndrewsPhil
Huge congrats to Michela, who takes the relay baton from me as the winner of the Lakatos Award 2023 🥳 An amazing book, very richly deserved!
Comecei a acompanhar o trabalho da Rosana desde que vi meu ídolo prof. Paulo Arantes falando muito bem dele em uma entrevista (vou postar o link abaixo).
Nos 'conhecemos' pelo Twitter, e hoje finalmente pessoalmente 🤩 O começo de uma colaboração frutífera, espero!
Encontro lindo com a @cdutilhnovaes em Leiden. Muitas perspectivas futuras de colaboração conjuntas
Lovely meeting with my @ERC_Research Brazilian fellow @cdutilhnovaes - wonderful walk in Leiden and exciting collaboration prospects.
Thank you so much Cata :)
Entrevista com Paulo Arantes: www.youtube.com/watch?v=FNqGWOiphU8&t=4s
'Dele' = do trabalho da Rosana, não é erro de concordância não 😄
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Encontro lindo com a @cdutilhnovaes em Leiden. Muitas perspectivas futuras de colaboração conjuntas
Lovely meeting with my @ERC_Research Brazilian fellow @cdutilhnovaes - wonderful walk in Leiden and exciting collaboration prospects.
Thank you so much Cata :)
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
"Wrong opinions...gradually yield to...argument".
–J.S. Mill
@cdutilhnovaes's 2023 @Aristotweets paper "partially vindicate[s] Mill" with 3 tiers of necessary (not sufficient) conditions of whether we, for instance, "reflectively...engage [an] argument".
doi.org/10.1093/arisoc/aoad006
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
“ChatGPT is a waste of time” — Piek Vossen vumagazine.vu.nl/professor-piek-vossen-chatgpt-is-a-waste…
Does anyone know the exact origin of the saying "Whenever there is oppression, there is resistance"?
I see it variously attributed to the Black Liberation Army activist Assata Shakur, Irish republican sympathizers, and the Chinese Communist party 😳
Hello new followers 👋 I've had a surge of new followers prompted by my new Stanford Encyclopedia entry, thanks for your interest 🙂 Here's a 🧵 with links to my recent work on argument and argumentation. 1/n
Another output from the SEA project, #openaccess
My critical notice on @RobertTalisse's 'Overdoing Democracy' is now online #openaccess. I argue that, while there is much to like in the book, it is not sufficiently critical towards some of the basic assumptions of deliberative conceptions of democracy.
www.pdcnet.org/jpr/content/jpr_2021_0999_10_20_181
My paper with @SilvinaIv on dialogical public engagement in science, which applies some of the core SEA project findings specifically to the science-society interface:
Hurray! My paper with @SilvinaIv on public engagement in science is now online #openaccess 🥳
We both put a lot of work into this paper, so it's good to see it out in the world 😃 Another output of the @erc_sea project
I'll post the abstract below 👇
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13194-022-00480-y
And another one, this time a paper at the intersection between meta-philosophy and argumentation theory.
New paper of mine hot off the press #openaccess. It's called 'Two Types of Refutation in Philosophical Argumentation'; it's the 1st paper I wrote after a hiatus from writing due to care obligations. So it's special ❤️ Abstract 👇
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10503-022-09583-5
A key paper for the overall project, published at the Proceedings of @Aristotweets: 'Can arguments change minds?'
My paper in the Proceedings of @Aristotweets is now online! #openaccess The title is 'Can arguments change minds?' Abstract 👇
academic.oup.com/aristotelian/advance-article/doi/10.1093…
My commentary on @NeilLevy10's book 'Bad Beliefs'.
Very happy that my commentary on @NeilLevy10 's book 'Bad Beliefs' is finally published in @JournalPHP! (There were some complications to ensure #openaccess publication, solved thanks to the indefatigable @lisabortolotti!) Abstract 👇
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09515089.2023.2174845
My paper in the Proceedings of @Aristotweets is now online! #openaccess The title is 'Can arguments change minds?' Abstract 👇
academic.oup.com/aristotelian/advance-article/doi/10.1093…
To address this issue, we must take into account the broader contexts in which arguments occur, in particular the propagation of messages across networks of attention, and the choices that epistemic agents must make between alternative potential sources of content ->
-> and information, which are very much influenced by perceptions of reliability and trustworthiness. Arguments can change minds, but only under conducive, favourable socio-epistemic conditions. /END
And more good news for philosophy at @VUamsterdam! @RikPeels will be University Research Chair at the Faculty of Religion and Theology @VU_FRT 🥳
NIEUWS: Het College van Bestuur @VUamsterdam benoemt per 1 september 2023 godsdienstfilosoof @RikPeels tot hoogleraar Analytische en interdisciplinaire godsdienstfilosofie op de University Research Chair (URC) @VU_FRT. vu.nl/nl/nieuws/2023/rik-peels-benoemd-als-hoogleraar-op-…
Awesome news! Jeroen will be our next University Research Chair 🥳
📣 Fijn professioneel nieuws! Per 1 sept. word ik op de Fac Geesteswetenschappen @VU_FGW @VUamsterdam benoemd tot University Research Chair hoogleraar politieke epistemologie – oftewel filosofie van kennis in de samenleving. Blij en vereerd. 🎉 vu.nl/nl/nieuws/2023/jeroen-de-ridder-benoemd-tot-urc-hoo…
(Now in English!)
There's been much discussion over the past week about a proposal that minister @RHDijkgraaf would have made about the % of English-taught courses at NL universities. Now it seems that the media coverage is based on a *misunderstanding*.
www.utoday.nl/news/73010/misverstanden-rond-engelstalig-o…
The @volkskrant stated that per the 2025-2026 academic year, a maximum of one third of the courses in BA programs can be taught in another language. But the minister was referring to programs that are accredited as *Dutch language programs* - >
- > but offer (too?) many courses in English. This does not apply to programs accredited as English language programs.
"Meanwhile, media coverage is creating its own reality. All kinds of people and institutions are reacting to a plan that doesn't actually exist."
Er is veel discussie geweest de afgelopen week over een voorstel dat minister @RHDijkgraaf zou hebben gedaan over de % van Engelstalige vakken in Nederlandse universiteiten. Nu lijkt erop dat de berichtgeving in kranten op een *misverstand* gebaseerd is.
www.utoday.nl/news/73010/misverstanden-rond-engelstalig-o…
Op de @volkskrant stond dat met ingang van het collegejaar 2025-2026 maximaal eenderde van de vakken tijdens een opleiding in de bachelorfase in een andere taal gegeven mag worden.
Maar de minister had over opleidingen die geaccrediteerd zijn als *Nederlandstalig* ->
-> maar (te?) veel vakken in het Engels bieden. Voor de opleidingen die geaccrediteerd zijn als Engelstalig geldt dit niet.
"Intussen creëert de berichtgeving in de media een eigen werkelijkheid. Allerlei mensen en instellingen reageren op een plan dat er eigenlijk niet is."
Absolutely stunning concert by @djavanoficial yesterday in Utrecht! The public was singing along with almost every song. It was amazing 🤩
O show quase todo foi assim, todo mundo cantando junto 😍
@nescio13 you would have loved it!
TURNÊ D, A SETLIST DE MILHÕES! Ouça aqui: open.spotify.com/playlist/5OftORnDKX5AjC7GXvVivV
O show quase todo foi assim, todo mundo cantando junto 😍
At this cool workshop in Utrecht today. Fun to be doing some philosophy of logic again, back to my roots 😊
@olehjortland Just referred to your PhD thesis when asking a question to Pilar 😄 'Old' but still topical!
Huge congrats to my marvelous daughter @chromarieca who just heard that she passed her high school exams 🥳
And now on to new adventures: after the summer she will start at @UvA_Amsterdam 🤩❤️
This gif is appropriate as it's literally my reaction 😁 I'm a very enthusiastic celebrater haha... And naturally she is going to the OTHER university, she doesn't want to be taught by her mom's colleagues. Right she is!
In case anyone familiar with Dutch traditions is wondering: no, we did not hang her back pack with the Dutch flag outside our house... We're not in favor of nationalistic symbolism 😆
The Phil Quarterly special issue dedicated to the unforgettable @HawleyKatherine is now available, with a bunch of cool-looking papers on topics that Katherine worked on, in particular trust and distrust.
academic.oup.com/pq/issue/73/3
⚠️ WORK IN PROGRESS ⚠️
Working on a paper on irrelevant influences on belief and their epistemological implications. The title is 'Should we be genealogically anxious? Contingency and agency in belief-forming processes'
Which are your favorite papers on the topic? Mine so far 👇
This one by my friend Yuval Avnur and co-author Dion Scott-Kakures bring interests and desire into the picture
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/phpe.12060
Anyway, these are the papers that have inspired me so far, I welcome further suggestions! I'm sure there's stuff I've missed so far 😆
Self-referential loops 😆 this thread has the abstract for this paper, posting here for completeness.
I now have an abstract for this paper, it's progress 😆 I'll post it below👇👇👇 (omitting references for brevity)
⚠️ WORK IN PROGRESS ⚠️
Working on a paper on irrelevant influences on belief and their epistemological implications. The title is 'Should we be genealogically anxious? Contingency and agency in belief-forming processes'
Which are your favorite papers on the topic? Mine so far 👇
I now have an abstract for this paper, it's progress 😆 I'll post it below👇👇👇 (omitting references for brevity)
⚠️ WORK IN PROGRESS ⚠️
Working on a paper on irrelevant influences on belief and their epistemological implications. The title is 'Should we be genealogically anxious? Contingency and agency in belief-forming processes'
Which are your favorite papers on the topic? Mine so far 👇
But the model suggests that, while there is a lot going on beyond our control that significantly shapes what we come to believe, we still retain a certain degree of agency to the extent that we are able to rewire our circuits of attention and trust/distrust. /END
@RikPeels This was the question you asked me at the Conspiracy Theories conference 😊 Potentially of interest to @JuulDuetz & @NeilLevy10 too
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Exploring the intricacies of refutation and counterexamples in philosophical inquiries in a paper by Catarina Dutilh Novaes @cdutilhnovaes. Our ARGr discussion led by Martín Pereira.
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Call for Abstracts 🔊
Workshop: Varieties of Misinformation.
Date: 26-27 October 2023.
Confirmed speakers:
@cdutilhnovaes
Jessica Keiser
@Plural_truth
@Ale1808
@Nefvil
@danwilliamsphil
More info 👇👇
vlclab.blogs.uv.es/event/workshop-varieties-of-misinforma…
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Very excited for this!!
Organized by @p_expressivism and with support from @Aristotweets, The Analysis Trust, and @UniofNottingham.
W/ @cdutilhnovaes, @matthieu_queloz, @prescottcouch, and others!
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
The 11th ICNP will address epistemic (in)justice and will have @cdutilhnovaes and @amandine_catala as guest speakers. The CfA will appear soon. Prepare your abstract.
This one is next on my to-read list! @danwilliamsphil has consistently been saying excellent things on the complicated relations between cognition and culture (and politics), so I expect this piece to be similarly insightful.
Is misinformation a dangerous virus? Are we living through an infodemic? Is there a vaccine for misinformation? In this review of Sander van der Linden's (@Sander_vdLinden) new book 'Foolproof', I argue that the answer to these questions is "no". A thread:
www.bostonreview.net/articles/the-fake-news-about-fake-news/
I'll be giving a talk in Düsseldorf next Wednesday on the (ir)rationality of propaganda. I *think* it's open to all, so do show up if you happen to be in the area and are interested in propaganda 😉 Details 👇
www.philosophie.hhu.de/en/contact-and-services/events/dat…
Some tweeps will recall that I was thinking 'out loud' on propaganda a few months ago. This will be my first talk on the topic, but the corresponding paper is ready and I'm happy to share the draft if anyone is interested.
They made a nice poster 😆
And one more! This paper by @mkrishnamurthyX looks awesome, I can't wait to read it ☺️ (MLK and the civil rights movement have been an intense interest of mine in recent years.)
x.com/mkrishnamurthyX/status/1661752473319505920
Since many people have expressed interest in seeing the full paper that this talk was based on, here's its current draft 👇
drive.google.com/file/d/1FnslfMlWFUm5ujXlTUvJy5nu_HlBM5G3…
REAL CONSPIRACIES?
As I make my slides for the conspiracy theories conference starting tomorrow at @VU_FGW, I wonder: what are the best examples of conspiratorial beliefs that eventually proved to be true/well-founded?
Curious to see what y'all think!
conspiracytheoryconference.weebly.com/program.html
Btw, as the saying goes, the fact that you're paranoid does not mean you're not being followed...
Correction: it's actually a quote from Heller's book Catch-22, and the exact formulation is "Just because you’re paranoid doesn’t mean they aren’t after you."
How many years since I last wrote a blog post? 🤔 But here it is, prompted by Justin's kind invitation to write a guest post for @DailyNousEditor. In the post, I talk about the methodology of 'synthetic philosophy'.
The first in the summer series of guest posts at Daily Nous was published this morning: “A Plea for Synthetic Philosophy” by @cdutilhnovaes dailynous.com/2023/05/30/a-plea-for-synthetic-philosophy-…
For the younglings here who are too young to remember, once upon a time I was a prolific blogger myself. My last post for NewAPPS was written almost 7 years ago 👇
www.newappsblog.com/catarina-dutilh-novaes/
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
WORKSHOP
"Logic: Norms and Forms"
Utrecht, June 16, 2023, philevents.org/event/show/110637.
Speakers: @cdutilhnovaes, Sabina Domínguez Parrado, Pilar Terrés Villalonga, Evelina Lissoni, Rachel Boddy, Robin Martinot, et al.
I'll be speaking (remotely, alas) at the workshop 'Analysis: History & Metaphilosophy' at @ArchePhilosophy @StAndrewsPhil this Friday. My talk is titled 'Analytic and Synthetic Philosophy'. Abstract 👇
www.st-andrews.ac.uk/arche/event/workshop-on-analysis/
In this talk, I reflect on two complementary ways of doing philosophy: by means of analysis and by means of synthesis. I understand synthetic philosophy as “a style of philosophy that brings together insights, knowledge, and arguments from the special sciences with the aim to ->
-> offer a coherent account of complex systems and connect these to a wider culture or other philosophical projects (or both)." (Schliesser, 2019) @nescio13 I discuss two strands within early analytic philosophy, namely Russelian 'scientific philosophy' & Moorean 'common sense ->
-> philosophy', and argue that synthetic philosophy thus understood emerges naturally from so-called scientific philosophy and from a revisionary conception of analysis, which now falls under the heading of 'conceptual engineering'.
Interesting study 👇
Study finds "a complex relationship between the increasing use of private messaging for political participation and the spread of misinformation largely left unchecked in these spaces."
Explaining beliefs in electoral misinformation: misinforeview.hks.harvard.edu/article/explaining-beliefs-…
by @patyrossini @camilambpp @antoniskalog via @MisinfoReview #scienceupfirst
My PhD Merel dazzling the world with her cool research 🤩 Go follow her, she promises she'll give Twitter a real go haha...
Had a blast at @UAntwerpen for the MA-class on City Living, by the fantastic @QuillRKukla - it was lovely to talk! Also had the pleasure of meeting @lopezcanterop, Martha Claeys, Lara Schrijver, Kristien Hens and many others. Thank you so much @KatrienSchaubr for having me!🙏
PhD *student*, I mean! I'm so dazzled myself that I forgot to include the 'student' part haha...
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
I took the opportunity of the workshop celebrating Catarina Dutilh Novaes's @cdutilhnovaes excellent Lakatos-award winning 'Dialogical Roots of Deduction' to revisit my Lakatosian roots. www.youtube.com/watch?v=bKejEHr67Rg
This was good, especially for a Germany entry #eurovision2023
Cloudy with a chance of blood and glitter ✨☂️🤘 #eurovision
True! Finland so far the most #eurovision act so far 🤩
FINLAND!!! Finally, the type of batshit content we’re all here for. Glorious 😂 👏🏻🔥 🇫🇮 #eurovision
I very much enjoyed reading this essay by philosopher Justin Smith (no longer on twitter it seems) on his experience with psychedelic substances. It is personal, poignant and philosophically sophisticated at the same time.
www.wired.com/story/this-is-a-philosopher-on-drugs/
Cool research! I wonder, who are the neo-ordinary language philosophers? (Never been a fan of OLP much...)
For the ordinary language philosophy nerds:
@jdporterlive and I have a new paper using DH methods to find as many OLP papers as we could building on @bweatherson's topic model of philosophy journals. We argue OLP didn't die in the 1970s...
philpapers.org/rec/PORAQH
Check out the upcoming conference on philosophy of conspiracy theories at @VU_FGW, organized by M R.X. Dentith & @JuulDuetz. I'll be giving a talk titled 'How conspiracy theories spread or hide: attention and trust in belief-forming processes'. Abstract 👇
conspiracytheoryconference.weebly.com
In his book Bad Beliefs, @NeilLevy10 defines bad beliefs as widespread beliefs that are at odds with expert consensus and/or widely available scientific evidence, such as climate change denialism and vaccine skepticism. Some prominent conspiracy theories such as QAnon would be->
->extreme cases of bad beliefs. While it is easy to dismiss these beliefs as wholly irrational, Levy argues that those who come to hold bad beliefs do so through roughly the same belief-forming mechanisms as those who come to hold ‘good’ beliefs (primarily through deference).
->hidden from public scrutiny (thus being removed from the relevant attention networks), and dissenting voices and whistleblowers are openly discredited by means of, among others, character assassination.
\END
The gamified engagement that conspiracy theories invite is also noted by @add_hawk in a few places, and @NeilLevy10 in a recent paper 👇
ora.ox.ac.uk/objects/uuid:a662b53e-ce00-43dc-b901-af0077a…
Oh no! 😰 One of the most inspiring philosophers of the last decades...
RIP Ian Hacking.
Feb 18 1936 - May 10 2023
A very bright light has gone out.
Another great loss for Brazil today 😰 RIP @davidmirandario
www.theguardian.com/world/2023/may/09/david-miranda-dead-…
RIP Rita Lee @RitaLee_real , the most rock&roll Brazilian woman ever born 😰
www.youtube.com/watch?v=JJhKbpjfXnQ
Internationally, she is perhaps best known as one of the members of awesome psychedelic band Os Mutantes
www.youtube.com/watch?v=9yaN_sN0-7U
Obituary at @guardian
www.theguardian.com/music/2023/may/09/rita-lee-dead-brazi…
📚 CASE STUDIES IN PHILOSOPHY 📚
Philosophers, what are your favorite discussions on the use of case studies in philosophy? I'm looking for *methodological* discussions. I know there is some of that relative to history and philosophy of science, but what about more generally?
Tagging some people who may have ideas on this @motimizra @nescio13 @ExpertiseUnder @SabinaLeonelli
One cool example from philosophy of science is this paper by Hasok Chang: link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-94-007-1745-9_8
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Many thanks to @cdutilhnovaes for her fantastic #lselakatosaward Lecture last week on 'The Dialogical Roots of Deduction'. In case you missed the lecture, you can watch the recording online at: www.youtube.com/watch?v=CtuPHreauz8
Here's a conversation that @JulianBaggini kindly hosted between the inimitable @myishacherry and myself.
It was the first time that Myisha and I got to chat in real time, after years of social media interactions, and we had a blast 🤩
www.julianbaggini.com/how-to-think-like-a-philosopher-ep7/
We discuss the role of anger in thinking and debating, and the need to defer to others in an epistemic community.
Some people who may enjoy this convo: @NeilLevy10 @danwilliamsphil @AWorsnip
It was a blast! Thanks to all of those who made it possible 😊 @LSEPhilosophy
Delighted to welcome @cdutilhnovaes to @LSEPhilosophy #lselive event tonight discussing her #lselakatosaward winning book #thedialogicalrootsofdeduction lse.ac.uk/events
Hasok Chang's speech at the reception.
My slide with thanks to those who contributed in various ways for the book to be written and to the Lakatos Award celebrations @NWONieuws @ERC_Research @RohanFrench @GaskinHilary @wtgowers @JDHamkins @chromarieca @sophievgelder
What I’ll be doing today 🥳
The presentation can be watched live on youtube: www.youtube.com/watch?v=CtuPHreauz8
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
🗓️Tomorrow! #lselakatosaward Lecture & Expert Workshop
✏️Expert Workshop: 2 May, 1.30pm-5.00pm, LAK2.06, Lakatos Building: www.lse.ac.uk/philosophy/events/lakatos-award-expert-work… - Hybrid event!
🗣️Award Lecture by @cdutilhnovaes: 2 May, 6.00pm, Hong Kong Theatre: www.lse.ac.uk/Events/2023/05/202305021800/deduction - Hybrid event!
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Third, Catarina Dutilh Novaes (@cdutilhnovaes) highlights the centrality of relations of #attention and #trust in belief-forming processes
doi.org/10.1080/09515089.2023.2174845
#vol36issue4 4/9
Info about the workshop before my Lakatos lecture now available 👇 Next Tuesday!
🗓️ Save the date! #lselakatosaward Lecture and Expert Workshop
✏️ Expert Workshop: 2 May, 1.30pm-5.00pm, LAK2.06, Lakatos Building: www.lse.ac.uk/philosophy/events/lakatos-award-expert-work…
🗣️ Award Lecture by @cdutilhnovaes: 2 May, 6.00pm, Hong Kong Theatre, Clement House: www.lse.ac.uk/philosophy/events/lakatos-award-lecture-by-…
If you don't want to hear about the Lakatos events of next week, you may consider muting me for a few days 🙃
I recorded this interview with Ricardo a few months ago. It was fun, hope it will be fun to listen to as well ☺️
New episode (773), with Dr. Catarina Dutilh Novaes (@cdutilhnovaes): Argumentation, Reason, and Disinformation. #philosophy #misinformation #reasoning #science
YouTube: youtu.be/mQL819vCthc
Podcast: creators.spotify.com
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
🚨 NO AR 🚨
No II Dia Carol Blasio pela Diversidade na Lógica (2023) iniciamos uma campanha de compartilhamento de materias didátdicos de lógica e disciplinas afins. Os primeiros resultados já estão no site da SBL, vamos conferir?
sbl.org.br/pmwiki.php/Main/Ensino
#teachinglogic
Wonderful piece by Paul Griffiths, one of the most distinguished philosophers of biology currently in activity. Mandatory reading for anyone interested in the philosophical-political implications of biological sex differences for gender categories.
aeon.co/essays/the-existence-of-biological-sex-is-no-cons…
Kinda relevant for the controversy du jour over at @DailyNousEditor
🔥 New paper alert 🔥
Groundbreaking paper by Colin Rittberg @vavimproject on 'cranks' and epistemic exclusion in mathematics is out!
IMO this is Colin's most significant result from his period as a Marie Curie post-doc at @VU_FGW. Abstract 👇
academic.oup.com/philmat/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.…
I argue that workload-management concerns justify the exclusion of these outsiders from mathematical knowledge-making practices. My discussion reveals three insights. There are reasons other than incorrect mathematical argument that justify exclusions from mathematical practices.
There are instances in which mathematicians are justified in rejecting even correct mathematical arguments. Finally, the way mathematicians spot mathematical crankery does not support the pejorative connotations of the ‘crank’ terminology.
🤩 In less than two weeks from now 🤩
🤔 Join Catarina Dutilh Novaes (@cdutilhnovaes) for a lecture on her #lselaktosaward winning book, The Dialogical Roots of Deduction, bringing perspective from philosophy, history, psychology & cognitive science, and mathematical practice.
@LSEPhilosophy
www.lse.ac.uk/Events/2023/05/202305021800/deduction
Looking forward!
Next Monday, we have @cdutilhnovaes asking 'Can Arguments Change Minds?' Senate House, 6pm! Hope to see many of you there. Find details and draft paper here: www.aristoteliansociety.org.uk/the-2022-23-programme/cata…
I debated a lot with myself on which format to use for this talk (read paper out loud, use slides), and eventually settled on a handout (a format I have not used for a while). We'll see how it goes...
The audio of the lecture is now available online. The accompanying handout is also available via this link 👇
www.aristoteliansociety.org.uk/the-2022-23-programme/cata…
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
There will also be a workshop in the afternoon preceding my evening lecture, with @wtgowers @mjinglis @mary_leng Kevin Scharp and Wesley Wrigley. So far this is all I know about it 👇"More info coming soon."
⏳ Join Catarina Dutilh Novaes (@cdutilhnovaes) for a lecture on her #lselaktosaward winning book, The Dialogical Roots of Deduction, bringing perspective from philosophy, history, psychology & cognitive science, and mathematical practice.
@LSEPhilosophy
www.lse.ac.uk/Events/2023/05/202305021800/deduction
There will also be a workshop in the afternoon preceding my evening lecture, with @wtgowers @mjinglis @mary_leng Kevin Scharp and Wesley Wrigley. So far this is all I know about it 👇"More info coming soon."
This is starting tomorrow! Making the slides as we speak 😅
I made a meme!
@nescio13 you can borrow it 😆
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
⏳ Join Catarina Dutilh Novaes (@cdutilhnovaes) for a lecture on her #lselaktosaward winning book, The Dialogical Roots of Deduction, bringing perspective from philosophy, history, psychology & cognitive science, and mathematical practice.
@LSEPhilosophy
www.lse.ac.uk/Events/2023/05/202305021800/deduction
APA karaoke, a tradition!
I had covid a few weeks ago, so this was the right time for karaoke 😁
Here is the announcement for my Lakatos Award public lecture on 'The Dialogical Roots of Deduction' at @LSEPhilosophy on May 2nd 6pm.
In the afternoon , there will also be a workshop on the book, with speakers @wtgowers @mary_leng @mjinglis & Wes Wrigley
www.lse.ac.uk/Events/2023/05/202305021800/deduction
There's also the Author-meets-Critics session on the book at the Pacific APA coming up in less than 2 weeks from now.
For those who will be at the Pacific APA, the Author-meets-Critics session on my book 'The Dialogical Roots of Deduction' will take place on Thursday morning. Critics include @sutrasandstuff and @JDHamkins. Looking forward to my first major conference since the before-times!
Another heads-up for Brazilian music lovers in NL! @djavanoficial is coming to town in June 🤩 One of my all-time favorite singers, exciting!
www.tivolivredenburg.nl/agenda/djavan-16-06-2023/
Shocking! There is a grand total of *four* mentions to Paulo Freire in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy 😱 I know he tends to be ignored by (analytic) philosophers, but that's really staggering. 'Pedagogy of the Oppressed' is the 3rd most cited ->
blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2016/05/12/what-ar…
And you might think, well, it's education, not philosophy, so no wonder it's not widely cited in a philosophy encyclopedia. But that's just a misconception of Freire's work, which is philosophical through & through. In essence, it's a philosophy of the human condition.
UPDATE: I missed one mention to Freire in the SEP entry on scientific pluralism by @DavidLudwigWUR & Stéphaie Rufy 👇
We also cite him in our SEP "scientific pluralism" article! Someone sneakily as a classic post-positivist philosopher of science - and he should be recognized as a classic here even if he is not. plato.stanford.edu/entries/scientific-pluralism/
Come be our colleague at @VUamsterdam ! TT position in philosophy of science / research integrity / meta-science.
We’re hiring! The Philosophy Dept at @VU_FGW @VUamsterdam is looking for an Assistant Professor of Philosophy with expertise in philosophy of science / research integrity / meta-science. More info through link below, apply until April 9, 2023. werkenbij.vu.nl/ad/assistant-professor-in-philosophy-of-s…
TIP: I'm reading the entry on Imre Lakatos at the Stanford Encyclopedia, and finding it a delight to read! It's not something often said about encyclopedia entries, but this one is really well written.
plato.stanford.edu/entries/lakatos/
@BrendanLarvor do you share my enthusiasm? (Obviously, I'm not a Lakatos scholar so I can't attest to the accuracy of every claim.)
Team @erc_sea will be in Vienna for ECAP! We'll be there with our symposium 'Political Epistemology of Argumentation'. Speakers: @natalan @solmuanttila
@hugormota Merel Talbi & myself. Should be fun 🤩
analyticphilosophy.eu/ecap-11/
Huge congrats Lara! Your work on the epistemic significance of emotions is ground-breaking 🤩 it was a pleasure and an honor to be your supervisor 🎊
Yesterday, I successfully defended my PhD and passed with no corrections 🥳🎉 Thanks again to my amazing supervisors @jlsnedegar and @cdutilhnovaes, and my examiners @Ale1808 and Sandy Goldberg for their thoughtful comments and the stimulating discussion we had yesterday 😄
I just signed this letter in support of Susanne Täuber, who has been fired from her tenured position as associate professor at @univgroningen. Without getting into details, let me just say that, as a former Rosalind Franklin Fellow, I recognize much of ->
openletter.earth/reinstate-susanne-tauber-protect-social-…
-> what she describes in her article on equal opportunity schemes 👇, and how the RFF program has been conducted at @univgroningen. Lots of good intentions, but issues with implementation at faculty level (RFF is a university-level program).
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/joms.12516
I agree with much of what @nescio13 says here 👇
Door het ontslag van Susanne Täuber moeten we concluderen dat de *academische vrijheid* in Nederland slecht beschermd is omdat het (i) onder de vrijheid van meningsuiting valt, en (ii) die voor alle werknemers op de werkvloer begrensd is. 🧵
@dijkgraag @AObtweets
1/
This was so much fun! Thanks in particular to @mmmccabe1 and Fiona Leigh for the warm welcome ♥️ @sophievgelder and I had a great time 😃
Next Monday, we have @cdutilhnovaes asking 'Can Arguments Change Minds?' Senate House, 6pm! Hope to see many of you there. Find details and draft paper here: www.aristoteliansociety.org.uk/the-2022-23-programme/cata…
@HistPhilosophy we spoke fondly of you over dinner 🤩
Also of @consequently!
Very happy that my commentary on @NeilLevy10 's book 'Bad Beliefs' is finally published in @JournalPHP! (There were some complications to ensure #openaccess publication, solved thanks to the indefatigable @lisabortolotti!) Abstract 👇
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09515089.2023.2174845
-> provide higher-order evidence. I also argue that Levy’s account fails to sufficiently address the issue of strategic actors who have incentives to pollute epistemic environments for their benefit, and more generally the power struggles, incentives, and competing interests ->
that characterize human sociality. Levy’s attempted reduction of the political to the epistemic ultimately fails, but his account of social and cultural cues as higher-order evidence offers an insightful perspective on epistemic social structures. /END
🚨Brazilian music lovers in the Netherlands alert🚨
Caetano Veloso @caetanoveloso will be performing in Amsterdam in September! Just bought my tickets 🤩
carre.nl/voorstelling/caetano-veloso
In April I'll be teaching a (online) Masterclass on synthetic philosophy at @ArchePhilosophy, which is open to non-St Andrews research postgrads as well. Details 👇
@nescio13 you'll be pleased to hear 😃
I'm thinking of writing a paper arguing that there isn't really an essential difference between so-called rational argumentation and propaganda, contra people like Plato, S. Stebbing & J. Stanley (although Jason's position is more complicated). Here's my argument 👇
Btw here's a paper I wrote a while back but which still captures my preferred notion of propaganda, which is neutral rather than pejorative.
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/ejop.12411
@rbnmckenna86 @nathanballan have been thinking about these issues as well, I think.
UPDATE: paper is coming along smoothly, I should have a full draft by next week.
🚨 Cool new paper alert! 🚨
This paper addresses empirically an important question in the debates on the beauty of mathematics: are aesthetic judgments by mathematicians convergent, or is beauty in the eyes of the beholder? @FennerTanswell et al. find a lot of agreement.
Btw I wrote a paper on the beauty of mathematical proofs some years ago, for a volume edited by @andrewaberdein & @mjinglis 👇
www.bloomsburycollections.com/book/advances-in-experiment…
Aaaand she strikes again! Second high-profile publication by Julia, who is only in her second year as a PhD student at @VU_FGW 🤩 She's my go-to person for all my conspiracy theory-related questions. (Btw, watch this space as soon I'll be giving a go at the topic myself 😃)
New publication! 😁
What does it mean for a conspiracy theory to be a ‘theory’?
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02691728.2023.2172697
For those who will be at the Pacific APA, the Author-meets-Critics session on my book 'The Dialogical Roots of Deduction' will take place on Thursday morning. Critics include @sutrasandstuff and @JDHamkins. Looking forward to my first major conference since the before-times!
Interessant symposium over ChatGPT bij @_knaw, alle welkom! (zie link)
"ChatGPT produceert op afroep zeeën van tekst die menselijk aandoen. Is dat een vloek of een zegen? Voor wie, en waarom?"
Sprekers: @wzuidema, Hannah van Binsbergen & @GijsbersVictor.
www.knaw.nl/bijeenkomsten/waar-blijft-de-mens-chatgpt-en-…
I'm giving a presentation to the Aristotelian Society in a month from now; friends in London, it would be great to catch up!
Question for those who have given or attended such talks: what's the format? Do people actually *read* their papers out loud?
www.aristoteliansociety.org.uk/the-2022-23-programme/cata…
@nescio13 will you be in town then? March 6th.
This 🧵 explains the ChatGPT architecture very well, and clarifies why its output is quite often complete bullocks: it is primarily a bulls**t generator.
Why does chatGPT make up fake academic papers?
By now, we know that the chatbot notoriously invents fake academic references. E.g. its answer to the most cited economics paper is completely made-up (see image).
But why? And how does it make them? A THREAD (1/n) 🧵
For ex., this is what ChatGPT replied when I asked which books were written by Catarina Dutilh Novaes. All if them either don't exist or were not written by me, and those that I did write are not on the list. As well put by my daughter, these are books I *could* have written...
So it gives halfway plausible/coherent replies (which is exactly what one would expect given its architecture), but it has no commitment to the truthfulness of statements--a bulls**t generator indeed...
Excellent 🧶
I've been seeing some posts from well-intentioned faculty about eliminating all deadlines in their classes. I study #executivefunction, #stress and #mentalhealth in college #students, and I'm here to tell you this will hurt the students you are trying to help. . . 1/buckle up
An impressive example of a leader who governs to serve her people, not for personal benefit or to satisfy a thirst for power.
Upon concluding she can no longer fulfill this role properly (after handling many difficult situations in past years), she simply quits.
Jacinda Ardern resigns: ‘I no longer have enough in the tank’ www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-64327224
What a contrast with some other political leaders who cling on to power no matter what--looking at you, @MinPres #rutte!
(And many even worse examples of course, in particular those who refuse to accept democratic outcomes and so threaten basic democratic institutions.)
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
What are the similarities and differences between the recently attempted coup in Brazil and the Jan 6 attack on the U.S. capitol?
@OliverStuenkel explains:
This was an amazing interview on the thought of Martin Luther King! I have a profound fascination for the concept and practice of non-violent resistance, and this conversation addresses many of its complexities.
Really enjoyed this conversation on #mlk with the generous @ezraklein
A 'Letter to the editor' published in the journal Cognitive Science arguing for interactionist approaches in the cognitive sciences, based on the stance that interaction co-constitutes cognition, instead of still dominant single-mindedness approaches.
My contribution to the drafting of the letter was modest; but I wholeheartedly endorse all of its content, so I was thrilled to be one of the signatories.
Here's a direct link to the letter #openaccess onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cogs.13230
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Jair Bolsonaro supporters storm Brazil’s presidential palace and supreme court www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/08/jair-bolsonaro-supp…
Very important book edited by @SanderVerhaegh & Jeanne Peijnenburg (dear former colleagues at @wijsbegeerte).
In recent years I've been including Susan Stebbing in my (very short) course on the history of analytic philosophy, to great student satisfaction btw.
And the book is #openaccess!
Update: unfortunately, the book is actually not Open Access.
Democracy in Brazil came out stronger after 4 years of being battered and destroyed from within. Lula has a tall order ahead of him, as Bolsonaro left the country in shambles. But Lula is focusing on the right priorities so far: eradication of hunger & environment.
Hoje começamos uma nova etapa na história do Brasil.
📸: @ricardostuckert
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
I helped Pelé write a book in 2014, and got a brief glimpse into his unusual life. I wrote about it here for AQ
I’ll miss him a lot. RIP
www.americasquarterly.org/article/pele-was-a-genius-at-mo…
Do I know anyone with good graphic design skills to help me with an important PowerPoint presentation? Nothing super complicated, but it needs to look good/professional/slick, which is not one of my skills--to put it mildly 😆 (Talking about paid work of course.)
Pls RT!
Update: many people have replied here offering help, thank you! I’m a bit overwhelmed by all the responses actually 😆 I’ll be going offline soon for today, but will look into all responses tomorrow. Thanks again!
Update: I found the person for this job, thanks to all who replied. I appreciate all the contacts; who knows, maybe we'll get to collaborate at some later stage?
I have a fireplace in the house I moved to in 2016, which wasn't & never will be used (by me at least). I've known for many years that wood burning is bad for me, giving me asthma attacks when e.g. visiting people. Now it's scientifically clear that it's literarily poison.
How I became a major polluter, by getting my home heating disastrously wrong. My column.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/dec/27/wood-burnin…
Maybe in some places and for some people, it's the only option to stay warm inside (the UK is so so bad at heating houses!). But here where I live in the Netherlands, fireplaces are a rich person's hobby, used for 'atmosphere' rather than for heating. It should really stop!
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Brazil's far-right faithfuls are not giving up - BBC News www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-64094197
This paper seems really important for the whole epistemic injustice research program, and more generally for analytic political epistemology.
One underlying assumption in much of this literature is that knowledge & power can be neatly separated, while Foucault shows they can't.
My PhD student @solmuanttila is working precisely on incorporating this Foucauldian insight into analytic political epistemology. Here is a recent piece by Solmu showcasing some of their work 👇
psyche.co/ideas/on-the-moral-responsibility-to-be-an-info…
"In 2022, we lived through a relative rarity in recent memory: a decent year for democracy."
But as the article itself notes, there is no room for complacency: democracy remains a volatile, vulnerable system, especially as it can be destroyed from within.
www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2022/12/19/23453073/2022-…
Moreover, as the case of Brazil has shown, even if democracy eventually prevailed in this year's election, the years of Bolsonaro government have left the country in disarray (politically, financially, ecologically).
Congrats Lara! 🥳 It's been a pleasure working with you as your (second/third?) supervisor 🙂 The thesis looks great, it makes an important contribution to the debate on the epistemic significance of affective experiences. Now on to the next adventure!
I'm extremely proud to announce that I've submitted my PhD thesis titled 'Affective Experience as a Source of Knowledge' for examination today. This has been 3 years and 3 months in the making. Time to celebrate! 🥳🥳🥳
Nice post by @Helenreflects! Helen and I experienced the glory days of philosophy blogging together at NewAPPS. We then both moved shop first to FB then to Twitter, and now it looks like a new phase in philosophical online presence is about to start (TikTok videos maybe?).
The thing is that each of these platforms, as Helen describes, offers diff. affordances, and so every time we need to learn how to navigate the new environment and find ways to better communicate with others (as for me at least the main purpose of social media is communication).
I'm now trying to learn how to navigate Ma***don, which seems to have its own etiquette and also some interesting affordances (such as different privacy settings for each post, like FB). So far Ma***don seems less focussed on the dopamine kicks of every like & re-share.
This looks like a very cool paper! I've recently re-watched the documentary 'Behind the Curve' on flat-earthers (it's back on Netflix), which offers a very clear illustration of how #dyor can really lead people astray, even when they (try to) follow scientific methods.
In a new article w/ @JaredCelniker & @daviddunning6, we examine a commonplace slogan: #dyor. We spell out the slogan’s diverse meanings, its connection to conspiracy theorists (and Descartes), and argue that improving inquiry calls for greater humility.
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02691728.2022.2146469
I just applied for a Mastodon account in the server created by @RHoogstraat , akademienl.social. This place is quickly becoming unmanageable (in different senses of the term!). My handle will be the same as here, cdutilhnovaes.
The long awaited English version of my #mastodon 🧵!
Now that the big migration to #mastodon 🦣 has started, I thought it wise to make our own server.
Behold: akademienl.social, #akademienl.
Is this really necessary and will I need to transfer? Read on and find out. 1/n
As soon as it's approved I'll add links to my work on argumentation and free speech, seems there's much confusion on the topic going around 🤨
The account is on! Link on my Twitter profile now.
"No contexto das periferias platinar os cabelos tem a ver com celebração, brincadeira e beleza."
"Para a branquitude, um preto vaidoso é perigoso, eles sabem disso. Apontar e reprimir a vaidade preta é um sistema programado de manutenção de poder."
Exato!
www.uol.com.br/esporte/colunas/campo-livre/2022/12/14/max…
"Criticaram até as danças que os caras faziam para comemorar. Em que mais na vida desses caras - em sua maioria, pretos, de origem humilde - a galera branca vai querer dar palpite?"
Wonderful new book 🤩
Congratulations to Marcin Lewinski and Mark Aakhus on their new book, which explores the complexity of #argumentation in today’s #digitalsociety and shows how to analyse and manage disagreements among multiple positions, players and places
Worrisome developments in Brazil: pro-Bolsonaro partisans torch cars and buses following ratification of Lula’s election victory.
www.theguardian.com/world/2022/dec/13/bolsonaro-supporter…
Situation is even more worrisome in Peru. As @BrazilBrian puts it, dangerous times in South America.
Latin America is rarely placid but seems to be going through one of its periods of convulsion right now. Far left protests blocking airports and roads in Peru after Castillo’s failed self-coup, Bolsonaro supporters setting bus & cars on fire after Lula victory certified…
Incidentally, I'm reading this piece by E. Anderson right now, as we'll discuss it at the weekly @erc_sea seminar, which addresses precisely how populism gives rise to epistemic bubbles and the delegitimization of democratic institutions.
academic.oup.com/book/39301/chapter-abstract/338888946
EPISTEMIC vs. COGNITIVE
These are 2 terms that philosophers use more or less interchangeably, but not completely. My sense is that 'cognitive' is broader & 'epistemic' is a sub-category of 'cognitive'.
Is there a more precise way to differentiate the epistemic from the cognitive?
Wow, lots of responses, thanks all! I was at an inaugural lecture this afternoon, so I've been offline for a few hours. I'll look into every reaction carefully, thanks 😄
One of the best moments of this WC: Mondric consoling Rodrygo after he missed a penalty (they are very close at Real Madrid). #boycottqatar2022
Gestazo enorme de Luka Modric con Rodrygo después de que este fallara su penalti y Brasil cayera eliminada ante Croacia.
"Vas a volver más fuerte. Te quiero'
Capitán
*Modric, of course 🤦♀️
Win-win for me: if Brazil is kicked out, it will be easier to #boycottqatar2022 . If Brazil wins, then Brazil wins 🤪🇧🇷
So it's #boycottqatar2022 then...
I'm in this conversation right now, looking forward to learning much!
The last one standing 😆😷 Masking at conferences I mean, though I wasn't the only one (two or three others).
And yes, great talk Stephanie! It was a pleasure to chair yours and the other lightning talks 🤩 so much innovative, creative work being done by these young scholars!
LENGHT OF PROMOTION LETTERS?
Paging colleagues in North America! On average, how long should a letter be in support of someone who is seeking promotion to full professor? I'm thinking 2 pages is ok, does that sound right?
(Adding pic to grab attention 😬)
😩 the pain! A great game for Brazil, but I'm not watching 😩 #boycottqatar2022 #staystrong
Brazil take a four-goal lead into the break 👏
#fifaworldcup | #qatar2022
I'll be speaking at the 'COGITO New Directions in Epistemology 2022' event next Wednesday, commenting on J. Lackey's forthcoming book 'Criminal Epistemic Injustice'. My talk will be titled 'Criminal epistemic injustice: a feature, not a bug'.
Sadly, I won't be physically in Glasgow, it's going to be good old Zoom again 😄 @jasonintrator hope to catch you there!
CORRECTION: The title of Jennifer's book is 'Criminal TESTIMONIAL injustice'.
Pedantic philosophical question: can you say you are boycotting something (say, #boycottworldcup2022) if you never cared much about the thing in the first place? Seems like caring is a presupposition to boycott (a bit like first being a smoker to then stop smoking).
Discuss! 😆
De zoveelste getalenteerde jonge wetenschapper (geen toeval, 1 vrouw) die de academische wereld verlaat, nadat ze zich heeft ingezet om de omstandigheden voor studenten en docenten/onderzoekers te verbeteren. Wat een verlies voor ons, maar wat een wijze beslissing voor haar zelf.
Filosoof @fleurjongepier heeft de academische wereld verlaten. Op haar website schrijft ze "met boosheid, ontgoocheling, en grote opluchting." Ik ben dit jaar niet op de uni dus misschien mis ik e.e.a. Maar ik hoor hier niets over. Het zal wsch gaan zoals het al eerder ging:
Ga je goed @fleurjongepier! Wij zullen je missen, maar groot gelijk heb je om elders je geluk te zoeken, in omgevingen die meer respect en waardering tonen voor basale menselijke waarden. Met je veel talenten zal je sowieso overal schitteren ✨
Interview with @CasMudde, who on top of everything has excellent taste when it comes to football, as revealed by the jersey he's wearing 😄⚽️
Does anyone know why Germany is not currently recommending a 2nd booster (with updated bivalent vaccine) for the general population? (Only for those over 60, vulnerable, health workers etc.)
www.rki.de/DE/Content/Infekt/Impfen/ImpfungenAZ/COVID-19/…
Germany has been very proactive on the vaccination front before, but now it seems to have changed course. Other countries, including the Netherlands and USA, are now recommending a 2nd updated booster to everyone over 12. So what's up with Germany? @derafeynman
@bosmana thoughts?
ECAP11 coming up! It will take place in Vienna, with a bunch of excellent invited speakers, including @mariabaghramian @BenceNanay
CfP is out 👉analyticphilosophy.eu/ecap-11/
It’s already the 11th ECAP! See you in Vienna 21-25/8/2023
The European Society for Analytic Philosophy (ESAP) invites contributed papers and proposals for symposia to be presented at the 11th European Congress of Analytic Philosophy.
analyticphilosophy.eu/ecap-11/
Brazil is now playing against Serbia, and I realize this is the very first WC Brazil game that I miss in my entire conscious life 😫 #boycotqatar2022 #thanksfornothingfifa
Well, I'm glad that at least the hero of the game was Richarlison @richarlison97, who (unlike most others in the squad-looking at you, Neymar!) has an excellent track record on political positions, including speaking out against homophobia 🏳️🌈
x.com/realfutebolnews/status/1595895548187676672
@richarlison97: 'For a modicum of dignity and equality for all the Brazilians who were not as lucky as me.'
🚨 JOB ALERT 🚨
Come work with us! We're advertising an Assistant Professor in Logic and Philosophy of AI position at @VUamsterdam @VU_FGW
I'll be in the search committee, prospective candidates can get in touch with me for further details.
Please RT!
werkenbij.vu.nl/ad/assistant-professor-in-logic-and-philo…
@LIncurvati can you spread the word among the ILLC community please?
The ERC Starting Grants 2022 #ercstg have been announced. I spotted 3 philosophical projects (maybe I missed others).
👇
Rafal Stepien, 'The Ethics of Empty Beliefs: Chinese Buddhist Philosophy in the ‘Period of Disunity’' (Austrian Academy of Sciences)
erc.europa.eu/news-events/news/starting-grants-2022-call-…
Graziana Ciola @GrazianaCiola, 'The Impossible and the Imaginable: Late-Medieval Semantics of Impossibility and the Roots of Complex Mathematics' (Radboud University Nijmegen)
(Each project receives max. EUR 1,5 million)
Congrats to the three luck birds 🥳
@DailyNousEditor Keeping you in the loop!
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Ugh did it have to be Saudi Arabia though
True bravery! The Iranian people have been displaying unspeakable acts of bravery over the last months. Their plight seems far from over (the brutal regime has given no sign of relenting), but one can only hope that eventually basic human rights will prevail in Iran 🇮🇷
Better video from @NatalieAmiri shows more clearly the refusal of Iran #teammelli to sing national anthem of Islamic regime
I’m in #boycottqatar2022 mood but now rooting for Iran!
Media disabled... The video can still be seen here 👇
Breaking: Iran national football club stand mournfully and refuse to sing national anthem of clerical regime during first match against England at World Cup 2022 in act of protest against Khamenei henchmen’s violence x.com/MMomenfam/status/1594676861640278016/video/1
I see 'goodbye' tweets going around, as the chances of Twitter ceasing to exist very soon are quite real. FWIW, I think it is/was a brilliant platform! Over here I connected with way more people than in other social media platforms, both academics & the public. #riptwitter
I've had the occasional Twitter spat, but by and large my experience has been of constructive engagement. The 🧵function is quite suitable to convey thoughts and research results, something I've experienced both when writing 🧵s & when consuming them.
I haven't created a Mastodon account yet (sorry @RHoogstraat!). I'm worried that Mastodon will give rise to siloed communities, whereas what I appreciated here on Twitter was precisely the wider range of interlocutors. But we'll see, maybe Mastodon will have to happen for me...
✨Paging epistemologists✨
What are your favorite recent pieces on higher-order evidence? I'm familiar w the earlier literature, but there's been a recent explosion on the topic that I have not kept up with. There's a new SEP entry, it's a good start!
plato.stanford.edu/entries/higher-order-evidence/
As @AWorsnip pointed out in his review of the book, Neil does not engage that much with some relevant recent discussions in 'mainstream' epistemology. I agree with Alex that it's important to draw these connections, which I will try to do a bit in my piece
Here's my review of @NeilLevy10's new book. In this book Levy argues for a radical and surprising claim: that climate change deniers, anti-vaxxers, etc. are (typically) rational in believing as they do. I am not convinced. (1/3)
ndpr.nd.edu/reviews/bad-beliefs-why-they-happen-to-good-p…
@AWorsnip if I remember correctly, you were pressing me on how exactly attention and trust are (or count as) HOE, when I gave my talk (online, sadly) at the workshop organized by Yuval, right? Well the question has been on my mind since 😄
As the good Brazilian that I am, I ❤️ World Cups normally. I really kinda stop my life every 4 years to be completely absorbed by it, following as many games as I can (not only the ones of the teams I support).
But not this year... #boycottwc2022
www.theguardian.com/football/2022/nov/15/gay-qataris-phys…
While the FIFA has been corrupt since immemorial times, and World Cups usually involve a fair amount of bad politics (eg Argentina in 1978), this time too many lines have been crossed. (Admittedly, I should have considered boycotting the WC2018 in Russia already.)
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
The program for the 3rd Annual Political Epistemology Network Conference looks amazing! In Amsterdam on Dec 7-8, 2022. Organized by @ridderjeroen, @solmuanttila, @cdutilhnovaes, and @ThirzaLagewaard. www.politicalepistemologynetwork.com/3nd-annual-pen-confe…
I'm on day 9 after onset of symptoms (1st positive test 6 days ago), and my rapid tests are still bright red 🔴 What should I conclude? Should I still isolate, am I still contagious? How common is it? (Been symptom-free since Sunday.)
1st timer with covid here, so clueless 🤷♀️
My covid was not the worst, but not a walk in the park either. After feeling ok for two days, I had a bit of a rebound and developed sinusitis. On Friday I started antibiotics & now feel much better (rested full time over the weekend). The 4 doses of vaccine certainly helped!
Now I hope that I won't have long-lasting symptoms. My worry about covid has always been primarily long covid (post-covid syndrome), not the acute phase of the infection itself. So fingers crossed 🤞 Will continue to take it easy and avoid over-stretching.
This looks awesome! I've always been puzzled by the (presumed) high level of consensus in mathematics. Hoping to find some answers in these papers 🙂
The first contributions to the Axiomathes special issue on disagreement in mathematics #disinmath @DenizSarikaya and @VaViM are guest editing are now online.
But Colin is using the wrong handle to tag *himself* in the tweet 😆 his handle is @vavimproject
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
In het @parool van 12 november jl. schrijft @NWONieuws voorzitter @MarcelLevi dat er risico is op uitholling van het woord 'veiligheid', veroorzaakt door mogelijke melders die potentieel klachten zouden kunnen gaan indienen 'als je even je zin niet krijgt', 1/6
Just listened again (for like the 5th time!) to one of my favorite episodes of @HiPhiNation, 'Cover me softly'. It talks about the history and philosophy of cover songs, focusing primarily on 'Killing me softly'. Public philosophy at its best 🤩✨
hiphination.org/complete-season-two-episodes/s2-episode-5…
😞
Malheureusement, @cdutilhnovaes est covidée, et donc son séminaire dans ma série au Collège de France, qui devait être donné lundi à 14 heures, a dû être annulé. J'espère qu'elle pourra venir l'année prochaine!
Quick reminder that I'm speaking at the Collège de France next Monday, the talk is titled 'A Dialogical Account of Proofs in Mathematical Practice' and is open to all.
www.college-de-france.fr/agenda/seminaire/la-philosophie-…
@dansperber Will you be around perhaps?
I just cancelled my trip to Paris 😞 I'm still not fit to travel, still recovering from covid, so it wouldn't be a good idea neither for me nor for those around me.
Maybe I'll still give the talk via video connection, but not sure yet.
I just cancelled my trip to Paris 😞 I'm still not fit to travel, still recovering from covid, so it wouldn't be a good idea neither for me nor for those around me.
Maybe I'll still give the talk via video connection, but not sure yet.
Quick reminder that I'm speaking at the Collège de France next Monday, the talk is titled 'A Dialogical Account of Proofs in Mathematical Practice' and is open to all.
www.college-de-france.fr/agenda/seminaire/la-philosophie-…
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
🚨PAPER ALERT🚨
@cdutilhnovaes, "Two Types of Refutation in Philosophical Argumentation," Argumentation volume 36, pages 493–510 (2022)
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10503-022-09583-5
🚨OPEN ACCESS🚨
Very poignant piece on academic nomads 👇
"It feels exciting at the beginning, privileged even; being able to move to different countries, meet with people from different backgrounds, get to know different cultures… It is all shiny and bright, until it is not."
But even after 23 years not living in Brazil, I miss having friends and family nearby every day. When I chose to stay in NL at age 24, I did not realize how much I'd be losing/missing out on; it felt 'exciting'.
True, it's been great career-wise, but at a huge emotional cost.
My unsolicited advice to early-career folks out there: an academic career can be great (I still love it!), but the personal costs can be very high and may not be worth it. Don't necessarily go for that super shiny position on the other side of the globe if you have options nearby
This week there were several road blocks in Brazil by Bolsonaristas 'protesting' against the election results. Very serious situation, thankfully suitably addressed by the authorities.
HOWEVER, from it emerged a funny new character: the truck patriot!
www.showmetech.com.br/en/os-melhores-memes-do-patriota-do…
The episode gave rise to an outpour of hilarious memes, a selection of which can be enjoyed through this thread 👇
x.com/niklas_franzen/status/1588998119601360896
To be clear, this was a very grave situation in many respects, not least because the truck patriot's stunt was very dangerous for himself and for others.
But the line between the tragic and the farcical is sometimes very thin, and this is one such case...
This parody video is a gem, but you need to understand Portuguese and know more about the context to get it.
So @DailyNousEditor has a post now on the current commotion related to a paper published in Studia Logica which then turned out to contain a fatal mistake and is not retracted (sort of). The post cites a tweet of mine, so let me offer some clarifications.
dailynous.com/2022/11/02/logic-journal-retracts-two-artic…
Philosophers of math practice have been moving away from an overly idealized account of how math works, emphasizing the deeply social & human nature of the enterprise. My comments here were intended to dispel some misunderstandings about math practice that are still widespread.
And for readers wanting to know more about how practices of math proofs really work, what about checking out the final chapter of my monograph 'The Dialogical Roots of Deduction'? 😆
www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/dialogical-roots-of-dedu…
Colin Rittberg @vavim is now working on a paper on cranks in math, which argues that it's reasonable for the community as a whole not to spend significant time and energy on their purported results, despite the occasional outsider who does groundbreaking work (eg Ramanujan).
In sum, it's puzzling that a presumed 'insider' did not follow the informal 'rules of the game', ie did not circulate his (presumed) groundbreaking results before sending them off to a journal, as is common practice in math.
Either way, the editorial process failed badly.
The right handle is @vavimproject !
Very interesting article offering an insightful discussion of what Brazil did better than the US (lessons learned!) to avoid contestation of election results.
It also describes how justice @alexandre has been very hands-on with regulation of online speech.
A week after the election, here’s my take: Brazil did well.
And perhaps the U.S. could even learn something.
Shared with a @nytimes gift link, so it’s free to read:
www.nytimes.com/2022/11/05/world/americas/brazil-election…
His interventions have effectively mitigated the spread of mis/disinformation online, but also open a precedent for potential overreach in regulating online speech.
(As @DavidNemer cited in the article, I'm "cautiously in favor" of justice @alexandre's approach.)
This is a lovely tribute to Sarah ❤️ My interactions with her were not as frequent as Simona's, but I recognize the feeling of sheer joy and awe that ensued from being around her, her kindness & wit. Her philosophical influence will endure for many years to come!
A tribute of mine to Sarah Broadie. My mentor, friend, guide and inspiration. dailynous.com/2022/11/03/no-limit-to-goodness-remembering…
The day after: Brazil wakes up after the most nerve-wrecking presidential election since the return of democracy in 1980s. A little over half of the country is ecstatic and relieved that the nightmare is over. But is it? Will Bolsonaro concede? Will the transition be peaceful?
So my sense is that there is not enough institutional support for sustained contestation of Lula's victory. This is a significant disanalogy wrt to Trump's situation, as he still commanded significant support in the Republican party.
But as long as Bolsonaro remains silent, the suspense remains...
That is, contesting the results of the presidential election would entail also contesting results favorable to Bolsonaro's allies. For example, the state of São Paulo, the richest and most populous state in the country, elected a former Bolsonaro minister & close ally as governor
UPDATE: Things are getting rocky now, with many road blocks all over the country. Access to the international airport in São Paulo was blocked last night. As long as Bolsonaro stays quiet, some of his die-hard supporters feel emboldened to disrupt.
Bolsonaro supporters were never going to lose quietly, and there were hundreds of these roadblock protests overnight. Many truckers participating which conjures up memories of 2018 crisis (& Canada more recently). Courts ordering roads to be cleared. President still silent.
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Obrigada, Brasil! ✊💜
As urnas falaram. Venceu a democracia e a verdade. Viva o povo brasileiro! Meus parabéns, presidente @LulaOficial. A hora é de comemorar porque amanhã vai ser outro dia.
🥳😭 crying happy tears!
Breaking News: Brazil has ousted President Jair Bolsonaro, rebuking the far-right incumbent and electing Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, a former leftist leader known as Lula. www.nytimes.com/live/2022/10/30/world/brazil-presidential…
Track of the year! Trending on Spotify: "It's time for Jair to go away" (Ja-ir embora)
@jasonintrator @CasMudde for you to sing along 😄
Can’t wait to see this book out, it will be a paradigm-changing event!
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
O seu voto vai mudar a vida de milhões de brasileiros. Vote 13 por você e por todos nós! @Gabriel_Ba
para o #brasildaesperança #equipelula
OMG exactly this 😵💫 (And let me add that I do love cats very much, but somehow the love does not transfer over to libertarians...)
H/T @locuta
Btw this is my cat Shadow watching me do pilates. I always feel very judged 😆
😭 this is so emotional 🥹 Socrates was my childhood hero, and Raí is, as we say in Portuguese, tudo de bom (everything good)! The L gesture with his fingers at the end is to signal his support for @LulaOficial, to protect democracy in Brazil & elsewhere 🇧🇷
Raï, Socrates' brother is on stage for the Socrates Awards with @peaceandsport 🥰
#ballondor
@CasMudde have you seen this? 😭
For additional background, here’s what I wrote on the occasion of Socrates’ passing, some 11 years ago. www.newappsblog.com/2011/12/sócrates-making-political-his…
Prompted by an invitation to comment on J. Lackey's forthcoming book 'Criminal Epistemic Justice', I'm re-reading this excellent paper by Tommy Curry, which IMO clearly shows the limitations of Fricker's original analysis of 'To Kill a Mocking Bird'.
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/josp.12193
Actually @DrTJC is on twitter, I thought he had quit but still here.
Also, re-reading my thread I notice that I haven't said anything about the role of Tom's disability (one of his arms is incapacitated) for Curry's argument, which is however very important (with reference to, among others, @biopoliticalph).
Great interview with @JustinCaouette by @CliffordSosis! Justin has had such an interesting trajectory in life, coming from a working-class background and a rocky youth to become an academic in philosophy. It speaks volumes agains academia tho that he->
www.whatisitliketobeaphilosopher.com
-> still does not have a permanent position, thus ending up with temporary appointments at multiple places and a huge teaching load...
Interview includes fun mention of our encounter with a grizzly bear during our (otherwise wonderful) hike climbing Mount Yamnuska!
Pic of the hike, bear not included!
HYBRID CARS
What's the current status of hybrid cars regarding environmental impact? I'm considering buying a new car, and for various reasons going fully electric would not be practical yet. Is a hybrid a worthy alternative?
And if yes, which models/brands should I consider?
@simonfriederich you strike me as someone who may have views on this 😄
Brief voor de booster binnen! (Als griepprik-groeper) Net op tijd, ik had voor de zekerheid al een afspraak gemaakt voor 13 oktober 😆 Nu gegarandeerd dat ik over minder dan 48 de prik krijg, met de brief 🥳 FYI
@locuta
#booster #herhaalprik
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Foucault helped me accept the tragedy that is life, while showing that we retain a small amount of agency; and that resistance is worth it even when we are faced with powers way beyond our control.
Foucault helped me accept the tragedy that is life, while showing that we retain a small amount of agency; and that resistance is worth it even when we are faced with powers way beyond our control.
Today I’ve been keeping a human being alive for 18 years 🥳 (+ 9 belly months) Happy b-day @chromarieca, you make us proud every day ❤️
Never mind that I won’t see her today 😭 she’s in Rome on a school trip.
GIF courtesy of @pabllovittar 🤩 (If you don't know Pabllo, you should!)
That was fun, thanks for inviting me @loehrgui 😊
@cdutilhnovaes talking about trust and the internet in my session on conceptual engineering at the @esdit_nl conference in #leiden :)
This is definitely a high point in my career: giving a lecture at the Collège de France! My late father, an indefatigable francophile, would have been very proud 🤩
It's on November 14th & open to all, so maybe I'll see some Parisian friends there?
college-de-france.fr/agenda/seminaire/la-philosophie-de-l…
Of course, my father would have been *even prouder* if I delivered the presentation in French... We (Tim and I) considered the possibility, but then for various reasons eventually went with English instead.
It seems that the link in my original tweet is not working. This one is working for me: www.college-de-france.fr/agenda/seminaire/la-philosophie-…
Now preparing my presentation for the @esdit_nl conference coming up later this week. Somehow I am not listed on their website as a speaker, but I'll be speaking at Track 10, dedicated to conceptual engineering.
www.esdit.nl/event/esdit2022-international-conference/
It will be the first time that I'll speak in public on the Internet cognitive ecosystems material. I've recently submitted a grant application to work on this, so if @NWO_SSH gives me the money then there will be a lot more on this stuff in coming years 😃
Anyway, looking forward to the conference, which will include some awesome people such as @shaslang @DavidLudwigWUR @mgIS44C @add_hawk (sadly only via video) @rinireg (in person?). Thanks for the invite @loehrgui !
This is a crucial day not only for Brazilian democracy but for the resilience of democracy as a political system worldwide. Bolsonaro will follow the Trump playbook & reject unfavorable results; there is real risk of turmoil the coming weeks. www.theguardian.com/world/2022/oct/02/polls-put-lula-on-b…
Lula still had an advantage of 5% over Bolsonaro (much smaller than predicted by polls), and still has a better change of winning at the runoff in 4 weeks from now. But it will be much tighter and rockier than many of us had hoped for.
Vamos la
Lula will win today’s vote by about 4
But big story is — We’ll have a runoff, and it will be COMPETITIVE
Lula still slight favorite to win I think
But close margin will put strain on Brazil’s democracy
And make governing tough for whoever wins
Nightmare scenario for many
Here's an interview (in Portuguese, but google translate is your friend!) with @pablo_ortellado on the huge discrepancies between what the polls were predicting and the results. (@nescio13 possibly of interest to you.)
www.bbc.com/portuguese/brasil-63112606
Flying back home from Rome. It’s just so puzzling, virtually everyone maskless at airport 😱 Maybe 1 in 20? In Italy, which did enforce masks more than most places, and now that the dominant covid variants are even more contagious than before… People gave up, clearly 😩
I mean 1 in 20 is wearing a mask, certainly not more!
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Marcin Lewinski and Catarina Dutilh Novaes speaking on The many-to-many model an #argumentation and trust in online conversations #ecarome2022 @cdutilhnovaes
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
"Can arguments change minds?" An important question opens the plenary talk by @cdutilhnovaes #eca2022 #rome #argumentation
On my way to Rome for ECA! I defied the chaos at @Schiphol, went very quickly through security (Ski Priority helps...). Now with *lots* of time to kill, and so finally catching up on emails 😇 (What else does one do at this ungodly hour while waiting for a flight?)
Here's the program for ECA by the way, looks amazing! Two of my PhD students will be presenting papers, @solmuanttila & @hugormota. Well done, two!
ecargument.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/programmeECA202…
This is going to be groundbreaking! The main argument clearly shows that patriarchy is bad for *everyone*: even the Real Men on Top live in constant fear of losing their status & in order to keep this status must suppress great chunks of their emotional lives. Sad all around...
This is why the strands of feminism that I most identify with are the ones that reject the zero-sum conception of a 'battle of the sexes'. The great majority of men suffer greatly under patriarchy too, even if perhaps in different ways.
This way of framing the issue also has a strategic advantage: if men can be convinced that they too will be better off with less (or no!) patriarchy, then it will be easier to enlist them for feminist causes.
Here's a relevant thread by @RDembroff on how it sucks to be a man.
x.com/RDembroff/status/1437408111338340352
🚨 Awesome new paper alert! 🚨 'Epistemic Bunkers' just dropped.
"Exclusionary social epistemic structures are often constructed to offer their members safety, either actual or perceived. Recognising this allows us to develop better strategies to mitigate their negative effects."
It is publication day!
Sometimes people don't like hanging out intellectually with other people because it isn't safe. Or it feels unsafe.
That's the paper.
You can read the whole thing here for free (because open access)!
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02691728.2022.2122756
The general point aligns quite well with what I've been saying about the role of trust in argumentation. In many situations, it is in fact *rational* not to trust arguments/claims coming from sources that you have reason to believe do not act benevolently.
informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic/article/view/6328
In our piece for @BostonReview, @SilvinaIv and I developed this point specifically with respect to vaccine hesitancy.
bostonreview.net/articles/the-inflated-promise-of-science…
Conference season is starting for me! This week, my first work-related trip since January 2020: off to Rome for the European Conference on Argumentation. My talk is titled 'Can arguments change minds?', abstract here 👇
ecargument.org?page_id=1305
The week after, I'll be at a Lorenz Center workshop on algorithmic technology for democracy, organized by @davidegrote and colleagues.
www.lorentzcenter.nl/home.html
Finally, in the last week of October I'll be in Rio 😎, for the conference of the Brazilian Society for Analytic Philosophy, again talking about if, and if so how, arguments can change minds.
www.fil.puc-rio.br/vii-brazilian-society-for-analytic-phi…
Power to the people of Iran! 👊 Such amazing displays of bravery, especially the women who take off their headscarfs defying more than 4 decades of patriarchal oppression. We all watch you in awe! #iranprotests2022
Mahsa Amini’s death could be the spark that ignites Iran around women’s rights www.theguardian.com/global-development/2022/sep/23/mahsa-…
The one study that will have no issues whatsoever recruiting participants 😸
I’m a UBC doctoral candidate seeking study participants for my dissertation research on human-feline relationships in the home. If you are interested in participating or learning more about the study, please visit tellmeaboutyourcat.wordpress.com.
🐱Please share widely!🐱
Some (unsolicited) thoughts on the paper by @hanno_sauer claiming that we "should read only new philosophy and ignore all the old stuff"--aka on the irrelevance of the history of philosophy to 'real' philosophy. (Disclaimer: haven't read the full paper.)
x.com/hanno_sauer/status/1572170574486712322
(The link above has the wrong abstract for my chapter! It's not about Derrida 😃 It is though about Nietzsche and Foucault. Here's a link with a scanned PDF of the chapter.)
www.taylorfrancis.com/chapters/edit/10.4324/9781315766621…
More recently, I argued that conceptual genealogy is really useful for projects of conceptual engineering.
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0020174X.2020.1860122
Oh no, wrong link! Here it is 👇
drive.google.com/file/d/0BwBB5W78Z2I3Wk1PQkRwWDRzbjA/view…
For those who have read this far, thanks for indulging me in this satisfying navel-gazing experience 😆 I used my own work to substantiate my rejection of Sauer's claim because it's obviously the work I know best.
But the research of many other colleagues provide good examples of fruitful synergy between history of philosophy & 'real' philosophy-- @jehsmith & @nescio13 are two obvious examples. Please feel free to mention other such examples in comments!
Julia is a 2nd year PhD student at @VUamsterdam already doing significant work on the epistemology of conspiracy theories (& an informal member of @erc_sea). Congrats Julia 🥳 The paper looks great!
My first publication in the social epistemology of conspiracy theories :)
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10670-022-00620-z (open access)
🔉 Network epistemology 🔉
What are your favorite papers/chapters on network epistemology? Considering running a graduate seminar on the topic. I have some ideas, but maybe I'm missing some key sources. Bonus for not-overly technical papers!
(Pic from a paper by @KevinZollman)
The papers that are already on my radar are by @KevinZollman (of course) @cailinmeister @moral_psych , you may have know of other people doing interesting work on the topic 🙂
Sigh 😒 This is why most of us think long and hard before coming forward with testimonies of gender-related problematic behavior...
x.com/5minsphilosophy/status/1572171516334440448
Followers, please don't pile on this account, I quote-tweeted it simply because it is illustrative of a general attitude towards these kinds of testimonies. It's a small account, for all I know they are genuinely trying to have a good-faith debate here.
Dealing with a relentless person here 🤨
Grant application submitted! #aleaiactaest #bringonthebooze
This is appalling 😩 I know the colleague in question to be a very dedicated scholar and teacher, which makes it particularly bad.
(I'm very happy that my own employer @VUamsterdam has been much more accommodating towards my needs and special circumstances.)
And yes, it's the second time that I retweet @QuillRKukla today, don't see any problem with that if they say things that need to be said!
Yes, this needs to be said, sadly. A great mind for sure, with tremendous influence for philosophy and logic, but also a person who often engaged in very problematic behavior, towards women in particular.
I’ve had first-hand experience of said problematic behavior, so it’s not just hearsay for me.
Thanks for saying it, @QuillRKukla
I just came across this wonderful piece by my former colleague Charlotte Knowles at @wijsbegeerte (she used to be on twitter, but I can't find her handle now) on the complicated relations between philosophy & the maternal. Some excerpts below 👇
philarchive.org/rec/KNOPAT-4
The video of the lecture is available on youtube. It starts in Dutch with an introduction by the Dean, but the rest is in English, including laudatio by the awesome @marijemartijn !
www.youtube.com/watch?v=xqjjbx4hr50&list=PL_QTqA31F3wgzbN…
And Charlotte's handle is @charknowlez, go follow her for more exciting ideas 🤩
Very cool special issue on Genealogy, edited by @DanieLorenzini, including papers by @matthieu_queloz @GuyLongworth, and Daniele himself.
academic.oup.com/monist/issue/105/4
Amazing new book just dropped 🤩
New paper of mine hot off the press #openaccess. It's called 'Two Types of Refutation in Philosophical Argumentation'; it's the 1st paper I wrote after a hiatus from writing due to care obligations. So it's special ❤️ Abstract 👇
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10503-022-09583-5
->philosophical refutation can give rise to philosophical theorizing that is overly focused on hairsplitting disputes, thus becoming alienated from the relevant human experiences. Insofar as philosophical inquiry treads the fine line between questioning the obvious while still->
->seeking to say something significant about human experiences, perhaps a certain amount of what Lakatos describes as ‘monster-barring’—a rejection of overly fanciful, artificial putative counterexamples—has its place in philosophical argumentation./END
Proud to be a new member of the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences! 🥳 @_knaw
De 22 nieuwe KNAW-leden zijn geïnstalleerd! 🎉
De installatiebijeenkomst is terug te kijken via YouTube: youtu.be/8MXAQqXq3dk
Lees meer over de nieuwe leden: www.knaw.nl/nieuws/knaw-kiest-22-nieuwe-leden
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
It is commonly assumed that anti-science sentiment stems primarily from ignorance. But the “knowledge deficit” model of science communication suffers from deficiencies of its own, including a lack of #democracy, observe @cdutilhnovaes and @SilvinaIv. bostonreview.net/articles/the-inflated-promise-of-science…
✨Paging Amsterdam friends!✨
I'd like to have a nice but uncomplicated dinner with the fam after my @_knaw installation on Monday, where can we go? Close to Nieuwmarkt, with a good offer of vegetarian options. Suggestions? TIA!
@nescio13 Sorry, have to bug you again!
This is so incredibly sad! Cecile was such a valuable voice in public debates on health and science. I never met her personally, but I very much appreciated interacting with her on Twitter and reading her columns. Such a huge loss...
Cecile passed away on September 8th 2022. She embraced life untill the end. We will never forget her.
She had just recently come back to the Netherlands, her home country, to start a new chapter in her career and life. And then, bam! Hit by a horrible, merciless illness 😢
A very personal update:
Last month, I remigrated to NL, full of energy, but physically exhausted. I blamed the move, but learned last Friday that I have acute leukemia.
Here I am, 5 days later, in an isolation room, waiting for chemo. I feel strong but know hard times are ahead.
A very cool new paper by my former PhD student @jobdegrefte-incidentally, published exactly 5 years after his PhD defense. It's about the Persistent Interlocutor, the person who does not cease to question her opponent’s premises. Abstract 👇
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10503-022-09578-2
In this paper, I argue that these views all fail to accurately account for the epistemic relevance of the PI. I then briefly present an account that aims to do better in this regard, based on the modal notion of safety.
On the account proposed, the PI does not violate epistemic or dialectical norms. Rather, her behaviour tends to be epistemically perverse in the sense that it wastes cognitive resources. Perhaps surprisingly, this defect turns out not to be unique to the PI.
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Decaan Agneta Fischer van FMG aan de UvA heeft op ons verzoek tot rectificatie van de ad hominems in haar column richting @rensbod @IngridRobeyns en mijzelf gereageerd. Deze zijn nu verwijderd. Daarmee is de kous voor ons af.
Very happy to be part of the 2023-23 program of the Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society. My talk will be on March 6th 2023. I'm in great company, check out the amazing program 🤩 www.aristoteliansociety.org.uk/the-2022-23-programme/
Here's what @SilvinaIv and I wrote for @BostonReview on why and how the 'deficit model' of science education fails.
"The knowledge deficit model fails because it views public trust and acceptance of science primarily as an epistemic problem—a matter of too little knowledge."
We can’t simply teach our way out of anti-science sentiment. Building public trust is as much about power as about knowledge.
bostonreview.net/articles/the-inflated-promise-of-science…
Some of the people we refer to in our piece: @NaomiOreskes @goldenbergmaya1 @CT_Bergstrom @HawleyKatherine
Possibly of interest to @Jopinie (convo we had more than 1 year ago led to this eventually!)
And here's the more 'academic' (aka boring) paper by @SilvinaIv and me which provided some of the material for our BR piece 👇
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13194-022-00480-y
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Oops we did it again!
@cdutilhnovaes and I wrote this ⤵️
If you feel like reading about science education, trust, and vulnerability, here it is:
We can’t simply teach our way out of anti-science sentiment. Building public trust is as much about power as about knowledge.
bostonreview.net/articles/the-inflated-promise-of-science…
Haha thanks! This piece is from almost 6 years ago, but I’m still quite pleased with it 😊 plus, what are 6 years when compared to 6 centuries…
"Medieval ...Logical textbooks [had] chapters on fallacies, on consequence, on the logical structure and meaning of propositions"
100s of editions later, people still copyrighting those chapters! 🤣
More seriously, I am learning lots from @cdutilhnovaes: aeon.co/essays/the-rise-and-fall-and-rise-of-logic
🥳🥳 and now here’s to hoping that the updated vaccines will be the ones available for the booster round in the fall here in NL @MinVWS
Ein Quantensprung im Kampf gegen die Pandemie. Endlich gibt es auch Impfstoffe gegen Omicron Varianten. Damit ist ein deutlich besserer Schutz für den Herbst zu erwarten. Jeder sollte jetzt bestehende Impflücken schließen. www.spiegel.de/wissenschaft/medizin/ema-gibt-angepasste-o…
More generally, @Karl_Lauterbach is my go-to source when it comes to pandemic-related information in continental Europe. Even for those who don't read German it's worth following him, as the 'translate tweet' function works very well!
PEJORATIVE VS. NEUTRAL CONCEPTIONS OF IDEOLOGY
(Thoughts prompted by marking a thesis on gender ideology.) In the literature on ideology, pejorative conceptions of ideology are much more pervasive than alternatives. Here are some useful sources on the very concept of ideology 👇
T. Eagleton, Ideology: An introduction (1991)
www.versobooks.com/books/233-ideology
Shelby, T. (2003). Ideology, racism, and critical social theory. Philosophical Forum, 34(2), 153– 188. doi.org/10.1111/1467-9191.00132
Rather, the point seems to be primarily *ontological*: it is impossible (for humans at least) to exist outside of an ideological system. The very idea of an ideology-free state is itself an ideology 🥴
(Ok, sorry for the cheap philosophical trick, but it's kinda true!)
@jasonintrator speaking of ideology 😆
✨Professional news: as of tomorrow, I'll become one of the Associate Editors for Analysis (the journal)✨
I'm looking forward to this new challenge, and proud to be part of such a distinguished, historical institution!
academic.oup.com/analysis/issue
I had taken a break from intensive editorial work since I left Synthese 2 years ago, after 7,5 years of back-to-back positions (RSL, Thought, Synthese).
I of course already have my hands full with professional & family commitments (who doesn't?), but I felt it was time to->
->put the editorial skills that I acquired over the years to use again. (I've been an area editor for @dailySEP for 3 years now, but that's a different, lighter kind of work.)
At least the Analysis papers are short, so it should be easier to find referees, right? 😅
My paperback copies have arrived 😊
The book can now be purchased with a 20% discount with promo code PHIL3222 at checkout! www.cambridge.org/nl/academic/subjects/philosophy/logic/d…
And here's a bit more background on how the book came about, since it looks like there are way more people interested than I had anticipated 😃
Thanks all for the positive reactions to ‘The Dialogical Roots of Deduction’ receiving the Lakatos Award! @LSEPhilosophy
I wanted to say more on how the book came about; it’s been many years of hard work, which makes the recognition even more rewarding.
More good news! 🥳 My book 'The Dialogical Roots of Deduction' just won the 2022 Lakatos Award 😱
I'm absolutely delighted and elated, also because Lakatos' thought has influenced me a lot when working on the book 🙂
Champagne time! 🍾🥂
www.lse.ac.uk/philosophy/blog/2022/05/19/catarina-dutilh-…
Yesterday I (foolishly?) chose 'I want it that way' to sing at karaoke for the 1st time.
It's admittedly catchy (& easy to sing), but holy shit, the lyrics make no sense whatsoever 😆
Obviously, I wasn't the first to notice this 👇, but still shocked!
www.popdust.com/backstreet-boys-i-want-it-that-way-lyrics…
One explanation is that pop-mogul Max Martin, one of the composers, had quite patchy English at the time (exhibit B, Britney's 'One more time' and its apparent apology of domestic violence).
Btw I talked about my passion for karaoke last year, in this article by @KustawBessems at @volkskrant (in Dutch) which includes short video with collective rendition of 'I will survive'.
www.volkskrant.nl/kijkverder/v/2021/de-aantrekkingskracht…
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Come and join us in Amsterdam in December for some political epistemology! Keynotes by @ms_brizzle, @AidanMcGlynn, and @jana_bacevic, organization by @ThirzaLagewaard, @solmuanttila, @cdutilhnovaes, @m_j_hannon, and myself! Info and call for abstracts below.
We're organizing the 3rd annual political epistemology conference in Amsterdam this December and we're very happy that Briana Toole, @AidanMcGlynn and @jana_bacevic will be our keynotes. Check out our CFA (the deadline is approaching)! www.politicalepistemologynetwork.com/3nd-annual-pen-confe…
I can hardly believe it myself, but after more than 3 years I'll finally be able to go to Brazil again! 🥳 I
t will be mostly to see friends and family, but if all goes well I'll also attend the conference of the Brazilian Society for Analytic Philosophy.
sites.google.com/view/sbfa-sbpha/vi-congresso/próxima-con…
Looking forward already to catching up with Brazilian colleagues whom I have not seen in far too long... @filosofemas will you be there? The program doesn't seem to be online yet.
My talk will be titled 'Can arguments change minds?'
Abstract: Can arguments change minds? Philosophers like to think that they can: by engaging in the (presumably rational) process of carefully considering reasons in favor or against a given position or view, we should update->
->persuasive it will be for a given person. In a nutshell: arguments may well be able to change minds, but only under conducive, favorable socio-epistemic conditions. In this presentation, I turn to a three-tiered model of epistemic exchange that I’ve been developing over the->
->past years to (hopefully) shed light on the mechanisms involved in these processes and the conditions under which arguments can change minds./END
Working on a piece with @SilvinaIv for @BostonReview, edited by @mlordlordm, on the 'Knowledge Deficit Model' of science communication. It's shaping up nicely 🙂 Teaser below 👇
In the end, the knowledge deficit model fails because it views public trust and acceptance of science primarily as an epistemic problem—a matter of too little knowledge. What we need instead are approaches that respect equally important moral and political factors in shaping->
->the relationship between science and society. Social trust in science must be earned and cultivated, and this process depends as much on power as on knowledge.
My fabulous, brave daughter @sophievgelder has now turned her passion for sewing into a small business 🤩 She mostly makes handbags with all kinds of funky cloths, but she's happy to take on other projects. Check her out 👇 (on Instagram)
www.instagram.com/tasjesbysoof/
Wishing you a speedy recovery, @Karl_Lauterbach! Good thing you had access to Paxlovid. Here in the Netherlands, it’s unfortunately still not available…
Die letzten 4 Tage. Langsam geht es aufwärts. Aber COVID ist keine Kleinigkeit. Trotz 4 Impfungen und Paxlovid hatte ich stärkere Symptome als erwartet. Danke für die guten Wünsche. Hoffe, die Genesung ist bald komplett.
O prazer foi meu! O primeiro de muitos encontros 😊
'The Dialogical Roots of Deduction' is coming out in paperback, and can be purchased with a 20% discount. Go grab it! 😃
For the old school folks who still like physical books 😆
THE (SOCIAL) EPISTEMOLOGY OF ATTENTION?
In recent years there has been much work on attention in various fields (e.g., the attention economy). Cognitive science & philosophy of mind have been paying attention to attention (😆).
But what about epistemologists?
-> *instead of* to something else. What you zoom into, i.e. what becomes salient to you, will obviously be very relevant for your belief formation processes. Presumably, we have some degree of control over our attention processes, but the environment also plays a huge role.
As I mentioned at some point in this conversation, what I have in mind is in the ballpark of what is known as the frame problem in AI. All the time, we're curating what to pay attention to and what not, even if we're not aware of it. plato.stanford.edu/entries/frame-problem/
Coincidentally, my paper with @SilvinaIv just appeared, where we discuss atention (among other things), specifically wrt science-society interface. We use a 3-tiered model of epistemic exchange to public engagement, where attention is one of the tiers.
Hurray! My paper with @SilvinaIv on public engagement in science is now online #openaccess 🥳
We both put a lot of work into this paper, so it's good to see it out in the world 😃 Another output of the @erc_sea project
I'll post the abstract below 👇
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13194-022-00480-y
Further details on the 3-tiered model can be found in my paper 'The Role of Trust in Argumentation' 👇
informallogic.ca/index.php/informal_logic/article/view/6328
Hurray! My paper with @SilvinaIv on public engagement in science is now online #openaccess 🥳
We both put a lot of work into this paper, so it's good to see it out in the world 😃 Another output of the @erc_sea project
I'll post the abstract below 👇
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13194-022-00480-y
-> on a three-tiered model of epistemic exchange. As a case study, we discuss the phenomenon of vaccine hesitancy, arguably a result of suboptimal public engagement, and show how the proposed model can shed new light on the problem. \END
Possibly of interest to @goldenbergmaya1 @DavidLudwigWUR @APotochnik @aydinonat @caglar_dede
Thanks for the plug to my inaugural lecture, @bryankam! (From 2019, available on youtube and also in text form, link to text in Bryan's next tweet.)
'The human factor: doing philosophy in a messy world by asking inconvenient questions'
Here's the oratie 😊 which is brilliant
www.youtube.com/watch?v=xqjjbx4hr50&list=PL_QTqA31F3wgzbN…
I'm Catarina, I'm nothing but a monster of conventional pedantry 😆 (Imagine how that sounds in French...) It came from a history teacher in high school 🥴
Very interesting 🧵 Fascinating to read that John Stuart Mill was already talking about transgenerational solidarity, quite ahead of this time!
In What We Owe the Future, I advocate for concern about future people. Recently, I found out that John Stuart Mill got there over 200 years before me. And it turns out, weirdly, that we both thought a lot about coal.
WITCH HUNT!
Something I came across recently and seems really interesting in terms of the impact of technologies (desirable and less desirable consequences) is that the whole ugliness of witch hunt & witch trials were set in motion because of the advent of the printing press 😵💫
So we have an early example of how a technological innovation which is widely seen as transformative in the 'positive' sense, the printing press, also had less desirable consequences. Cognitive technologies can also ‘backfire’ in that they may bring about unwanted outcomes.
I first heard about 'Malleus Maleficarum' at the very beginning of the splendid BBC podcast 'The coming storm', which I cannot recommend enough!
www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/brand/m001324r
I really like this pic, taken by my wonderful daughter @sophievgelder during our fabulous walk through the dunes of Noordwijk yesterday ☀️
I realize this looks more like a post for Instagram than for Twitter 😆
Although now that Instagram wants to become wannabe TikTok, maybe there's a niche for Twitter to occupy? 😄
Just started reading this book, and loving it already! I'll post some quotes below so people can see if it's of interest to them.
mitpress.mit.edu/books/how-artifacts-afford
"Because values are not neutral and tend to reinforce power and status structures, technologies are often infused with the politics of the powerful. ...if left unchecked, technologies will arc toward privilege and normality."
"The bad news is that this means technologies will, by default, reflect and reinforce existing inequalities. The good news is that the default is neither necessary nor inevitable."
Possibly of interest to @DavidNemer @Natalan
This paper looks awesome! It's actually quite weird that there should be only one (correct) way to respond to evidence (which seems like a tacit assumption in much of epistemology), especially since different epistemic desiderata are often in tension with one another.
Why do people interact with evidence in so many different ways, and what does that tell us about the structure of cognition? My paper on epistemic styles, now out out, gives a new answer. (Full paper here: philpapers.org/rec/FLOES-3) 🧵
I haven't read the paper yet, but it seems to me that it develops a very promising new avenue to think about different, equally 'correct' and internally coherent ways to respond to evidence. Might even be that the same person will adopt different styles in diff. circumstances.
✨Paging Amsterdam friends✨
My 15-yo daughter and I want to spend an afternoon wandering around at the Jordaan tomorrow. She's interested in street art, thrift shops, vegetarian/vegan food.
What should we do/see? Where should we eat? (Outdoors sitting much preferred!)
TIA!
Thanks everyone for the tips, we had a great time 😎 here at the Noordermarkt (brand new glasses for me btw!)
If anyone is interested, we did this walking tour 👇 www.wanderlustingk.com/travel-blog/jordaan-walking-tour
HAWLEY ON TRUST & SOCIAL POWER
I'm working on a piece on trust in science (with @SilvinaIv), for which we are consulting the chapter on trust in the The Routledge Handbook of Epistemic Injustice by the wonderful and much missed Katherine Hawley.
www.taylorfrancis.com/chapters/edit/10.4324/9781315212043…
"Where there is social power, there is the potential for injustice, and there are many ways of linking discussions of trust and distrust with discussions of injustice.”
Btw, my piece with Silvia should appear in the Boston Review in due course.
I thought this time the ‘rona really got me (headache and fatigue since yesterday), but PCR just came back negative, phew 😅 On Sunday I was at the mega @ladygaga concert, wearing a good 😷 always except for some sips of water. So I was worried 🥴
The crowd 😵💫 @chromarieca and I were among the very few people masked.
Btw I’m still a ‘rona virgin and intend to stay that way for as long as possible 🤞
Is #paxlovid überhaupt beschikbaar in Nederland? Ik kan daar geen informatie over vinden 😒 Ik vermoed van niet, aangezien de laissez-faire houding van dit land tegenover deze nare ziekte 😩
Voor de duidelijkheid: ik ben niet positief getest of zo, ik vroeg me alleen af, handig om het alvast te weten.
Amazing new book edited by the unstoppable @nescio13 🤩
I am thrilled *Neglected Classics of Philosophy: volume 2* (@OUPPhilosophy, 2022) has appeared now. As you can see from the table of contents, it has a stellar line up by folk who gave me terrific papers. I have tagged some of the contributors; feel free to add more if you can.
🚨 Cool paper alert 🚨
Colin Rittberg, now running a Marie Skłodowska-Curie project @vavimproject @VUamsterdam, has just published an awesome paper w mathematician E. Hunsicker: 'On the Epistemological Relevance of Social Power and Justice in Mathematics'
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10516-022-09629-z
And in more cool publications by smart people who work with me (lucky me!), @solmuanttila has just published an insightful book review of Avia Pasternak’s 'Responsible Citizens, Irresponsible States: Should Citizens Pay for Their States’ Wrongdoings?'
ejpe.org/journal/article/view/685
Since many people indicated interest in the paper, here is the current draft of 'Two types of refutation in philosophical refutation' 👇
drive.google.com/file/d/1QJEsSCbnT8Q1R3AL-_qHZOeVPus2gxrj…
Just finished a paper titled 'Two types of refutation in philosophical argumentation', at the intersection between argumentation theory & phil. methodology.
It's the 1st paper I wrote after a long hiatus due to care obligations, so it's a special paper to me 🙂 Abstract below👇
Just finished a paper titled 'Two types of refutation in philosophical argumentation', at the intersection between argumentation theory & phil. methodology.
It's the 1st paper I wrote after a long hiatus due to care obligations, so it's a special paper to me 🙂 Abstract below👇
Oh, and if all goes well, it will appear in the journal Argumentation soon-ish. I'm happy to share the pre-print version before that, if anyone is interested.
Since a number of people mentioned they would be interested in checking out the paper, I uploaded its current version (which may not be the very final one) here 👇
drive.google.com/file/d/1QJEsSCbnT8Q1R3AL-_qHZOeVPus2gxrj…
Looking forward to this already! (🤞for no serious travel disruptions) Buenos Aires is an amazing city, DLMPST conferences are always fun, great team of organizers, brilliant line-up of invited speakers 🤩 So plenty of reasons to submit your papers 😊
The invited speakers of @clmpst2023 in Buenos Aires (July 2023) will include
María Caamaño, Matteo Colombo, David Danks, Yasuo Deguchi, John Dupré, Catarina Dutilh Novaes @cdutilhnovaes , Juliet Floyd, Maya Goldenberg, @goldenbergmaya1 , Erich Grädel, ... 1/3
Quick plug to a paper in Phil Compass by the amazing Dunja Šešelja, on formal models of scientific interactions drawing on network epistemology in particular. Essential reading for anyone interested in the dynamics of scientific knowledge production! 🤩
compass.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/phc3.12855
Yep, that's the bullshit we've had to put up with since the beginning of the pandemic here in NL 🇳🇱, coming from governmental institutions 😩
I still wear FFP2's whenever indoors with non-family members. People think I'm insane, I just say I have asthma & thus extra-careful...
I'm quite astonished at this exchange between a member of public at @rivm - the NL public health agency - on being asked where they can get high quality FFP2 masks, and which ones to buy! Aren't public health agencies supposed to be promoting public health not undermining it?
Awesome book, and fully #openaccess!
Hey @AgnesCallard, do you have your ideas on the roles of refutation in philosophy in print somewhere? I know you've given talks & interviews on this 👇, but cannot find a written-up version of it. (Asking for myself as I'm writing a paper on the topic!)
dailynous.com/2018/04/11/usefulness-refutation-philosophy/
Look what I found prominently displayed at a bookshop in Düsseldorf 🤩 @parenthesis_in
Also this! @RebeccaBuxton
And of course gazillions of books by Richard David Precht, philosopher/public intellectual whom Germans seem to love but is basically unknown elsewhere (I think?).
Today is #ketikoti ("The Chain is Broken"), anniversary of the formal abolishment of slavery in the former Dutch colonies in 1863 (de facto in 1873).
The Netherlands still has much work to do to deal with its colonial/slavery past, which makes #ketikoti particularly significant!
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
"Hi, I'm Catarina. I have very sensible things to say/write about Aristotle for someone who does not read ancient Greek."
Introduce yourself with the wildest feedback you’ve ever received.
I’ll go first:
“Hi I’m Amy. I’m too ambitious 🤝”
"Hi, I'm Catarina. I have very sensible things to say/write about Aristotle for someone who does not read ancient Greek."
Introduce yourself with the wildest feedback you’ve ever received.
I’ll go first:
“Hi I’m Amy. I’m too ambitious 🤝”
There are two strands of views on the epistemic effects of being a member of a disadvantaged group.
On the one hand, standpoint theorists & others posit that the experience oppression may confer epistemic superiority. On the other hand, the concepts of hermeneutical injustice->
->(Fricker) and double consciousness (Du Bois) indicate that being oppressed also entails epistemic disadvantages for the oppressed.
(Both strands have good Marxist credentials btw.) I've always found this tension puzzling. Are there already articles/books this tension?
(Thinking about this issue as I read/comment on @_RaniaAli's BA thesis!)
We're sooooo excited to have you join the @erc_sea team, Natalie 🤩 Much fun will be had for sure!
The end of an era 🥲 @mgIS44C has done an *amazing* job running this online seminar for 5 semesters 🙏
I’ll be there to say goodbye im style today, with none other than Kevin Scharp as the final speaker 🤩
*CONCEPTUAL ENGINEERING ONLINE SEMINAR*
Join us for our final lecture (June 28) at 4-6pm CEST (GMT+2): All are most welcome!
@KevinScharp (St Andrews): "Replacing Philosophy"
More info 👇👇👇
#conceptualengineering @UZH_ch + @ArchePhilosophy + @StAndrewsPhil
Lovely thread by @Helenreflects with suggestions on how to amplify academic work on social media in an efficient but also ethical way (giving credit to teams & junior co-authors, ensuring open access to content etc.).
Estarei no Happy Hour Filosófico do Fernando Costa Mattos na quarta que vem, 16.30 horário de Brasília. Vou falar do meu livro 'The Dialogical Roots of Deduction'. A conversa pode ser seguida pelo canal do Happy Hour no youtube, e permanecerá disponível no mesmo depois.
Link para o canal: www.youtube.com/c/fcmattos1974
This is starting tomorrow! I'm sad that I won't be there in person, but the whole thing will be live-streamed, and these are all stellar talks you don't want to miss 🤩 Open to all for online participation. My talk is titled “Can Arguments Change Minds?”, 2pm UK time.
Very excited for this ‘breakthrough’ workshop, long in the making - next weekend! Details and registration link here: www.st-andrews.ac.uk/philevents/event/epistemic-breakthro…
Thanks to @adametinson and @jlsnedegar for organizing such an awesome event!
What a cool idea for a paper! To look at group activity in escape rooms to investigate social dynamics of cooperation. (Haven’t read the full paper yet.)
Our paper about the anatomy of social dynamics in escape rooms has just been published with @SpringerNature in @SciReports.
w/@san_chowdhary @DavidDeritei @fede7j
Read, share, and enjoy. :) www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-13929-0.epdf?sharing_t…
Two of the most courageous journalists currently in activity, fierce defenders of democracy 📢
The great @mariaressa speaking at the Deutsche Welle Global Media Forum : "If you don't have integrity of facts, how can you have integrity of elections?"
SHOULD I STAY OR SHOULD I GO?
I'm due to go to Scotland this Wednesday, for my 1st work trip since covid. I was excited to go (awesome workshop!), but now I'm having second thoughts...
There is a new covid wave raging through the UK, & I really can't ->
news.sky.com/story/covid-19-infections-rise-by-nearly-hal…
-> afford a covid infection right now: there are some very important (positive!) things going on re the situation of prolonged illness in my family, I need to stay healthy for that.
So it just doesn't seem worth taking the risk ☹️ Even if I mask during flight & at workshop, ->
-> there are still the meals and other moments where wearing a mask becomes impossible. If I go, I know I'll be stressing out about this the whole time 🫤
What would you do in my situation, wise tweeps? (I can still join the workshop online at least, for the record.)
@msteenhagen as someone who follows the whole covid situation closely, what do you think?
I decided to stay...
I decided to stay... Just canceled flight, hotel etc. I'm also hearing of many people who got infected at the big epistemology conference last week in Glasgow, which was a decisive factor for me. Sad as it is, maybe it's not yet time for large in-person conferences 😞
SHOULD I STAY OR SHOULD I GO?
I'm due to go to Scotland this Wednesday, for my 1st work trip since covid. I was excited to go (awesome workshop!), but now I'm having second thoughts...
There is a new covid wave raging through the UK, & I really can't ->
news.sky.com/story/covid-19-infections-rise-by-nearly-hal…
I decided to stay... Just canceled flight, hotel etc. I'm also hearing of many people who got infected at the big epistemology conference last week in Glasgow, which was a decisive factor for me. Sad as it is, maybe it's not yet time for large in-person conferences 😞
SHOULD I STAY OR SHOULD I GO?
I'm due to go to Scotland this Wednesday, for my 1st work trip since covid. I was excited to go (awesome workshop!), but now I'm having second thoughts...
There is a new covid wave raging through the UK, & I really can't ->
news.sky.com/story/covid-19-infections-rise-by-nearly-hal…
Muito triste e chocada com a notícia da morte de Luís Fernandes dos Santos Nascimento, professor de filosofia na UFSCar, de um infarto fulminante. (Luís foi meu namorado nos meus últimos anos de faculdade no Departamento de Filosofia da USP, em 1997/98.) anpof.org/comunicacoes/notas-e-comunicados/nota-de-faleci…
Escrevi sobre ele com mais detalhes no Facebook:
www.facebook.com/catarina.dutilhnovaes/posts/283866332961…
Aqui sua apresentação no happy hour filosófico de Fernando Costa Mattos:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=jteUnlwG93s&t=766s
Father’s Day is always difficult for me; my father died 24 years ago. He loved me to pieces, but being his kid was hard due to his chronic depression & associated alcoholism. But he was also a wonderful, caring person who deserves to be celebrated. Here's him w me on his lap 👇
Here's one song he loved, which we listened to yesterday: 'O Ciume' by @caetanoveloso.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=5ipg14pGCLY
And here's a bit more info on his book (abstract), for those who can read Portuguese 👇
www.fnac.pt/O-Tempo-e-a-Ordem-Sobre-a-Homeopatia-Ricardo-…
Waroom zie ik deze man steeds in mijn timeline nu? Ik volg hem niet, en maar 2 mensen die ik volg volgen hem. Hij zit de hele tijd heel gevaarlijke dingen aan het verspreiden. Zo zie je hoe weinige controle wij hebben over waar onze aandacht naartoe gaat.
Net zoals dat de hittegolf geen golf was, maar slechts twee warmere dagen betrof, is de ‘groei van de groei’ qua corona’besmettingen’ ook er alweer uit. Het was een golfje. Niet meer. Niet minder. Daar lijkt het stevig op.
Ik kan hem muten uiteraard, maar mijn punt is, waroom krijgt hij opeens zo veel visibiliteit? Waarom wordt hij zo gepusht door de algoritmen?
Ik bedoel, hij *is* de hele tijd heel gevaarlijke dingen aan het verspreiden.
I haven't posted about the pandemic for a while, not because 'it's over', but out of despair, esp. given the complete lack of long-term plans from the Dutch government.
This became again apparent at yesterday's debate of MPs with healthcare minister:
nos.nl/artikel/2432942-brede-kritiek-in-tweede-kamer-op-c…
The gist of it is that the different sectors in society-schools, restaurants, businesses-need to figure out for themselves how to deal w the virus. Everyone fending for themselves thus 😵💫 MP's, even those in coalition parties, were (rightly) outraged.
But nothing will change...
I am envious of our next-door neighbors who have @Karl_Lauterbach as their minister of health! Lauterbach is very keenly aware of the dangers ahead, in particular concerning the long-term effects of long covid.
Not a good sign: belongings of @domphillips and Bruno Pereira found in the jungle, but no signs of them 😞
Update again: the bodies have not been found after all.
www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jun/14/brazil-embassy-dom-…
Live-tweeting of our workshop on @NeilLevy10's book 'Bad Beliefs' by the incomparable @lisabortolotti!
The #badbeliefsfest has started! @NeilLevy10 is offering a brief presentation of the book.
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
My brilliant PhD student @solmuanttila wrote an insightful piece for @aeonmag 🤩
"Solutions to our misinformation epidemic are effective when they are structural and address the problem at its roots."
Even if we accept that citizens are not primarily causally responsible for our poor information environments, it could be argued that they nonetheless have a remedial responsibility to mend them | Psyche Ideas psyche.co/ideas/on-the-moral-responsibility-to-be-an-info…
My brilliant PhD student @solmuanttila wrote an insightful piece for @aeonmag 🤩
"Solutions to our misinformation epidemic are effective when they are structural and address the problem at its roots."
Even if we accept that citizens are not primarily causally responsible for our poor information environments, it could be argued that they nonetheless have a remedial responsibility to mend them | Psyche Ideas psyche.co/ideas/on-the-moral-responsibility-to-be-an-info…
My slides are ready! My talk is titled ‘Attention and trust as higher-order evidence’.
Bad beliefs. @NeilLevy10 @cdutilhnovaes @danwilliamsphil @stephen_gadsby & @lisabortolotti discuss Neil Levy's recent book exploring why good people can hold bad beliefs & how they can become more responsive to evidence.
15 June 1-4:30pm Join in here: www.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/event/bad-beliefs-why-they-h…
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Bad beliefs. @NeilLevy10 @cdutilhnovaes @danwilliamsphil @stephen_gadsby & @lisabortolotti discuss Neil Levy's recent book exploring why good people can hold bad beliefs & how they can become more responsive to evidence.
15 June 1-4:30pm Join in here: www.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/event/bad-beliefs-why-they-h…
Opportunity to work with the amazing @CatherineDVries !
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
If you haven't heard the latest @BBCFreeThinking yet: @amiasrinivasan talks about her sex book, and then I join her, @cdutilhnovaes and @drchrisharding to talk about Nietzschean/Foucauldian genealogy
www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0017m63
How does one reply to the objection 'This is not philosophy'? 😁
To be honest, I haven't been getting this objection as much as before (this experience is from more than 10 years ago); it appears that doing empirically-informed philosophy has become much more mainstream.
Final paragraph of my 2012 monograph:
Final paragraph of my 2012 monograph:
Very worrisome indeed! There's a long history of defenders of indigenous rights and the environment in the Amazon being killed (such as Chico Mendes in 1988), so this looks quite suspicious.
This is going to be fun!
Next week (the 15th) there will be an online symposium on @NeilLevy10's *fantastic* recent book, "Bad Beliefs." I will be contributing, along with the brilliant @cdutilhnovaes @lisabortolotti & @stephen_gadsby.
Register at link below!
www.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/event/bad-beliefs-why-they-h…
I'm now back to writing papers (after a hiatus due to care obligations). Yay for writing papers again 🥳 loving it 😊
And what I'm loving *even more* is writing papers with Zotero! OMG Zotero, where have you been all my life? 😍 Cannot recommend it enough!
www.zotero.org
@ariannabetti I should have listened to you long ago 😆
The interview is now available online 👇
www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0017m63
This was a fun conversation with @amiasrinivasan & @chrisschuringa on philosophical genealogy, feminism and much more. It will air tonight on @BBCFreeThinking & will be available online afterwards via their site.
Tonight on @BBCFreeThinking…! @amiasrinivasan on #therighttosex. @chrisschuringa & @cdutilhnovaes on #genealogy. And how to talk about controversial topics by getting philosophical rather than geting angry. www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0017m63
This was a fun conversation with @amiasrinivasan & @chrisschuringa on philosophical genealogy, feminism and much more. It will air tonight on @BBCFreeThinking & will be available online afterwards via their site.
Tonight on @BBCFreeThinking…! @amiasrinivasan on #therighttosex. @chrisschuringa & @cdutilhnovaes on #genealogy. And how to talk about controversial topics by getting philosophical rather than geting angry. www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0017m63
Thanks @drchrisharding and @ilov77 for hosting it!
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Quick reminder that the deadline to apply for this position at our @erc_sea project is fast approaching, June 1st!
🚨 Job alert 🚨
2-year post-doc position in our project @erc_sea on political argumentation!
Full details on the position & how to apply through the link; deadline for application is June 1st.
Come work with us! @VU_FGW
(Please RT)
werkenbij.vu.nl/ad/postdoc-position-in-political-argument…
My first in-person conference post-you-know-what!
As of today, glad to have 3 fun days of expressing things in Amsterdam! @EXPRESS_project with @mtchrisman Lwenn Bussière @eganaegana, Imogen Dickie, @cdutilhnovaes @LIncurvati Julian Schlöder, Christine Tiefensee, Rachel Rudolph, Jack Woods, Mat Simpson and myself
In my talk, I'll be addressing a challenge by @consequently to my dialogical account of deduction.
So poignant and beautiful... To all 'curly-haired' kids out there: you're perfect just as you are 🏳️🌈
florida high school class president zander moricz was told by his school that they would cut his microphone if he said “gay” in his grad speech, so he replaced gay with “having curly hair.” i am in awe
Looks like an awesome paper!
Question for the math-minded: does Euler's conjecture for polyhedra run in both directions?
It says that if a solid is a polyhedron, then it satisfies formula V - E + F = 2. Does it also say that, if it satisfies the formula, then it must be a polyhedron?
plus.maths.org/content/eulers-polyhedron-formula
@FennerTanswell and @BrendanLarvor may have ideas, having thought a lot about Lakatos and proofs and refutations!
✨Cool online event coming up!✨
On June 15th we get together to discuss @NeilLevy10's awesome book 'Bad Beliefs'.
Discussants are @danwilliamsphil, @stephen_gadsby, @lisabortolotti & myself. All welcome, registration through link below.
(Please RT!)
www.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/event/bad-beliefs-why-they-h…
Thanks all for the positive reactions to ‘The Dialogical Roots of Deduction’ receiving the Lakatos Award! @LSEPhilosophy
I wanted to say more on how the book came about; it’s been many years of hard work, which makes the recognition even more rewarding.
More good news! 🥳 My book 'The Dialogical Roots of Deduction' just won the 2022 Lakatos Award 😱
I'm absolutely delighted and elated, also because Lakatos' thought has influenced me a lot when working on the book 🙂
Champagne time! 🍾🥂
www.lse.ac.uk/philosophy/blog/2022/05/19/catarina-dutilh-…
(Ok, this is sounding like a cheesy Oscar speech now 😆)
I’ll post below some materials related to the book such as reviews, interviews, and talks I gave presenting the book. I hope now more people will want to read it! Btw, paperback edition is coming out this year, it seems 😃
Podcast with interview with @RobertTalisse over at @NewBooksNetwork
newbooksnetwork.com/the-dialogical-roots-of-deduction
A talk where I present an overview of the book.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=0IOhYneseiM&t=2s
I thought the Preface was #openaccess via the @CambridgeUP site, but apparently it's not... So I uploaded a pre-print version of it here 👇 It offers a general overview of the book, and includes Acknowledgements, which everyone loves to read of course...
drive.google.com/file/d/16pcedFpAgQKnWo7ANb576g3hRrRJerM4…
Quick reminder that the deadline to apply for this position at our @erc_sea project is fast approaching, June 1st!
🚨 Job alert 🚨
2-year post-doc position in our project @erc_sea on political argumentation!
Full details on the position & how to apply through the link; deadline for application is June 1st.
Come work with us! @VU_FGW
(Please RT)
werkenbij.vu.nl/ad/postdoc-position-in-political-argument…
More good news! 🥳 My book 'The Dialogical Roots of Deduction' just won the 2022 Lakatos Award 😱
I'm absolutely delighted and elated, also because Lakatos' thought has influenced me a lot when working on the book 🙂
Champagne time! 🍾🥂
www.lse.ac.uk/philosophy/blog/2022/05/19/catarina-dutilh-…
The @LSEPhilosophy announcement:
#lse is pleased to announce the winner of the 2022 Lakatos Award, which goes to Catarina Dutilh Novaes (@cdutilhnovaes) for her book The Dialogical Roots of Deduction (@CambridgeUP, 2020).
Awesome @DUALIPA concert at Ziggo Dome tonight! My very first post-pandemic concert 🤩 I felt fine in my FFP3 😷😆 (needless to say, mine was the only mask being worn…)
Looking cool sporting my FFP3 😎😷
Looking forward! Not sure yet if I'll be able to attend the conference in person, but if not I'll be an active zoom participant 🙂
I'm often in agreement with @CT_Bergstrom, but here I think he's oversimplifying things. A focus on increasing scientific literacy in schools, in particular the social dimension of science, is surely welcome but will *not* significantly address the problem of disinformation.
In sum, I'm all for increasing scientific literacy through school education, in particular the social processes that lead to production of scientific knowledge. But this is not going to fundamentally address the issue of disinformation, as the problem is mostly moral/political.
I have a paper under review with @SilvinaIv on these issues, hoping it will see the light of day soon!
🚨Paging epistemologists!🚨
I vaguely recall a paper on Gettier cases and such like that was structured around 'exhibits' A, B etc. I can't recall the author nor the title. Does this ring a bell with anyone?
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
THIS IS #eurovision WE DON'T NEED SLOW SONGS. WE NEED WEIRDNESS AND UPBEAT CHAOS. IF WE WANTED TO BE SAD WE WOULD JUST WATCH THE NEWS.
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
🚨 Job alert 🚨
2-year post-doc position in our project @erc_sea on political argumentation!
Full details on the position & how to apply through the link; deadline for application is June 1st.
Come work with us! @VU_FGW
(Please RT)
werkenbij.vu.nl/ad/postdoc-position-in-political-argument…
Prof. Catarina Dutilh Novaes reposted
Sonja Smets and Catarina Dutilh Novaes have been selected as new members of the KNAW, the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences.
Many congratulations!
knaw.nl/nl/actueel/nieuws/knaw-kiest-22-nieuwe-leden
Happy to be able to finally share the news that I’ve been selected to become a member of the Royal Netherlands Academy of Arts and Sciences 🥳 It is a huge honor to receive this recognition!
Wij hebben 22 nieuwe leden gekozen! Zij zijn geselecteerd op basis van hun hoogwaardige wetenschappelijke prestaties. Van harte gefeliciteerd! Lees meer: www.knaw.nl/nieuwe-leden-2022
And there's more good news coming soon, watch this space! (Vaguetweeting, I know; it will be officially announced in a few days, I'm told.)
The @VUamsterdam announcement in English: vu.nl/en/news/2022/roberta-croce-and-catarina-dutilh-nova…
Looking forward to this, it will be my first in-person conference since the before-times (I'll be 😷 indoors), thanks @LIncurvati for getting me out of the house 😆 My talk will be titled 'Rejection and the dialogical roots of deduction'.
Registration is now open for the EXPRESS Conference on Expressivist Approaches to Meaning, which will take place in Amsterdam and online from the 25th to the 27th of May. Information on how to register is available on the conference webpage.
inferentialexpressivism.com/events/conference/
🚨 Job alert 🚨
2-year post-doc position in our project @erc_sea on political argumentation!
Full details on the position & how to apply through the link; deadline for application is June 1st.
Come work with us! @VU_FGW
(Please RT)
werkenbij.vu.nl/ad/postdoc-position-in-political-argument…
Another obvious one: @Plural_truth on knowing more but understanding less on the Internet.
wwnorton.com/books/The-Internet-of-Us/
My critical notice on @RobertTalisse's 'Overdoing Democracy' is now online #openaccess. I argue that, while there is much to like in the book, it is not sufficiently critical towards some of the basic assumptions of deliberative conceptions of democracy.
www.pdcnet.org/jpr/content/jpr_2021_0999_10_20_181