Thanx Michael!
Out today, one of the sanest books I've read on what to eat and why: Food Sense | Book by Christopher Gardner | Official Publisher Page | Simon & Schuster www.simonandschuster.com/books/Food-Sense/Christopher-Gar…
Politicians, athletes, journalists, NGOs, companies... They all use corporation-owned social networks to communicate with us. Citizens shouldn't have to hand over their data to companies to read content published by public entities. Public Feeds changes that by making posts of popular accounts freely available. Read more.
Christopher David Gardner (born July 13, 1959) is an American nutrition researcher. He is the director of nutrition studies at the Stanford Prevention Research Center and the Rehnborg Farquhar Professor of Medicine at Stanford University. More on Wikipedia
Thanx Michael!
Out today, one of the sanest books I've read on what to eat and why: Food Sense | Book by Christopher Gardner | Official Publisher Page | Simon & Schuster www.simonandschuster.com/books/Food-Sense/Christopher-Gar…
Christopher Gardner reposted
Out today, one of the sanest books I've read on what to eat and why: Food Sense | Book by Christopher Gardner | Official Publisher Page | Simon & Schuster www.simonandschuster.com/books/Food-Sense/Christopher-Gar…
Thanx Gil!
Just finished reading "Food Sense; What to Eat and Why", the new book by @GardnerPhD
Covers decades of nutrition discoveries, what we know and what we don´t, and finishes with very practical advice (including a number of delicious healthy recipes)
Sorely needed!
Must-read @bmj_latest editorial by @marionnestle on new Dietary Guidelines
When transparency + scientific consensus take a backseat, public health is at risk. How policy is made and communicated matters, especially when it shapes the health of millions.
www.bmj.com/content/392/bmj.s143.full
Consensus & Confusion
While the '25–'30 Dietary Guidelines repeat familiar messages like eat more veggies & fruits, they also overemphasize protein, downplay fiber, muddy guidance on processed foods, and send mixed messages on saturated fat.
My take:
med.stanford.edu/nutrition/news/press/2025_2030_Dietary_G…
Major milestone in gut microbiome science!
Using data from 34K+ stool samples, ZOE developed the first global, evidence-based measure of gut microbiome health. WOW!
Now published in Nature.
zoe.com/learn/new-microbiome-breakthrough
Food Summit
Two weeks ago, nearly 300 researchers & change makers came together for the '25 @Stanford Food Summit. It was a day of connection, inspiring keynotes, and action-driven discussions on building healthier, more sustainable food systems.
Videos: www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLkotywnoJchAKD3F0WmLli7uXm…
UPFs in Schools
Join me + other school food experts on Sept 17 @ 1 pm ET for “Reducing Ultra-Processed Meals: The Next Chapter in School Food” - the second webinar in the three-part Healthy School Food for Thought series hosted by @ChefAnnFnd. Register: www.chefannfoundation.org/school-food-for-thought-webinar…
MAHA Report
The new report gets some things right - better diets,
⬆️activity, ⬇️exposure to chemicals. But ignoring solid science in favor of “whim & whimsy” (like deep-frying in beef tallow) won’t improve children’s health. Evidence-based nutrition will
www.cnn.com/2025/09/10/health/maha-report-children-health…
Big news! 🎉 We’re teaming up with Eat Real to transform school food!
With support from Ardmore Institute of Health, this first-of-its-kind study will examine how healthy meals impact student performance, well-being & eating habits.
Learn more 👉 eatreal.org/stanford-x-eat-real-admore-institue-of-health…
Culinary Medicine - yum!
Big congrats to friend & colleague @ChefInMedicine.
She just launched an online resource to help people eat healthier AND cook delicious food. It’s 100% FREE to everyone thanks to @ACLifeMed. It's impressive! I hope you’ll check it out!
Now Serving: ACLM’s Free Culinary Medicine Program! 🍎
8 modules, 15 hrs of demos & recipes, plus resources to bring plant-predominant cooking to patients. Self-paced & skill-building for clinicians.
@ChefInMedicine
🔗 connect.lifestylemedicine.org/culinarymedicineeducation/home
#culinarymedicine #foodasmedicine
#schoolfoodreimagined
We’ve got something exciting cooking with Eat Real Certified…and it’s about the future of school meals. Stay tuned for the big reveal this Thursday!
Just published!
Congrats to lead authors, Dalia Perelman & Elisa Caffrey, on publishing "Unpacking Food Fermentation" in Advances in Nutrition.
They explore what we know (and don’t) about fermented foods & why clearer definitions & research matter.
🔗 pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12056253/
Beans, Peas and Lentils
Good for your health, your budget, and the environment, as engagingly revealed by @anahadoconnor
www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2025/07/02/beans-healthy-…
🎉Emmy-Nominated!
“You Are What You Eat: A Twin Experiment” — the @netflix docuseries featuring our @stanford Twins Study — is up for an Emmy in the Outstanding Lifestyle Program category! What a powerful nod to science communication and good research.
🌱🍓Farm to Table Camp
For the 14th year, we're partnering w/ @SantaClaraUSD on their 11-acre farm in Sunnyvale, CA. Kids garden, cook, & learn where food comes from. We're thrilled to support the district's new greenhouse w/ help from @ardmore_health.
www.svvoice.com/new-greenhouse-at-scusd-farm-offers-uniqu…
IGNITE Firefighters' Health Study
We’re fired up to partner with @SFFDPIO + sffcpf.org on a groundbreaking study asking: Can a whole-food, plant-based diet help reduce cancer risk in firefighters? Big questions, bold science, and more exciting updates to come soon!
A big thank you to @hubermanlab for having me on to talk all things food & health—popular diets, protein myths, gut health, food allergies & more. Grateful to have had the opportunity to share evidence-based nutrition insights.
The new Huberman Lab episode is out: How Different Diets Impact Your Health | Dr. Christopher Gardner (@GardnerPhD)
The full episode is available on 𝕏, YouTube, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and all podcast platforms.
(0:00) Christopher Gardner
(2:32) Is there a Best Diet?, Individual Needs, Geography & Diet, Lactose
(11:02) Sponsors: Eight Sleep & Mateina
(13:49) Raw Milk, Lactose Intolerance
(20:33) Wheat Allergies, Gluten Intolerance; Celiac Disease
(25:12) Processed Foods, Food Dyes, Research Outcomes, NOVA Classification, GRAS
(33:44) Processed Foods, Economic & Time Considerations, US vs European Products
(39:59) Food Industry Funding, Investigator Influence, Equipoise, Transparency
(50:10) Sponsors: AG1 & BetterHelp
(53:11) Industry Funding, National Institute of Health (NIH)
(56:41) Whole Food, Plant-Based Diet; Diet Comparison, DIETFITS, A TO Z Study
(1:10:24) Nutrition Naming, Omnivore, Meat, Animal Feeding Operations (CAFO)
(1:17:14) Transforming American Diet; Taste, Health & Environment
(1:22:26) Sponsor: LMNT
(1:23:43) Food Preparation, Chefs, Improve School Food
(1:29:54) Scalability, Mega-Farms, Small Farm & Farmer Loss
(1:34:25) Protein Requirements, Dietary Protein Recommendations, Standard Deviations
(1:45:33) Protein & Storage
(1:52:12) Plants & Complete Proteins?, Legumes, Bioavailability
(2:01:58) Sponsor: Levels
(2:03:17) Beyond Meat, Impossible Meat, Ingredients, Sourcing Meat, Salt
(2:09:18) Vegan vs Omnivore Diet, Twin Study, Cardiometabolic Markers, Genes, Microbiome
(2:20:24) Health Science Communication, DEXA; “Protein Flip” Diet; Food Patterns, Caloric Intake
(2:31:29) Microbiome, Inflammation, Fiber, Tool: Low-Sugar, Fermented Food
(2:45:32) Acknowledgements
(2:47:55) Zero-Cost Support, YouTube, Spotify & Apple Follow & Reviews, Sponsors, YouTube Feedback, Protocols Book, Social Media, Neural Network Newsletter
Incudes paid partnerships.
My amaZING colleague, Sally Duplantier, hosts an exceptional #wellnesswednesday this week with brain health expert Dr. Annie Fenn. Together, they will explore why blood glucose control is essential to reduce the risk of dementia. Free & Recorded. Register: us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_96n8JPsxTj2pomkrNZ5j-g
New Publication: FeFiFo-MOMS Methods
Our latest publication outlines our FeFiFo-MOMS study design, paving the way for future research on how diet during pregnancy impacts the microbiomes of mom & baby—an area still not well understood.
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1551714425…
Unapologetic Deliciousness Talk
This is my 2nd attempt to give this talk in Vallejo, CA @ Touro University. The first attempt on Dec 5, 2024 coincided w/ a California earthquake & automatic tsunami warning that led to evacuating campus, including me.
😱🌊
(there was no tsunami)
Excited to Present at #ciahkhl
For 20+ years, the Healthy Kitchens, Healthy Lives conference has united healthcare and culinary arts to improve access to healthy, affordable food.
See you there?
Learn more at www.healthykitchens.org/schedule
Believe Science, Not Hype
RFK Jr. & influencers call seed oils "poison," but research shows they can be part of a healthy diet. The real issue? Misinformation. As @neiltyson says, “Science is true, whether or not you believe in it.”
My @MSNBC op-ed: www.msnbc.com/opinion/msnbc-opinion/rfk-jr-seed-oils-bad-…
Nutrition Consensus over Controversy
Nutrition topics can feel like a battleground in the media, but with the right context, there’s actually more consensus than controversy. I unpack this and clear up confusion during a recent Mayo Clinic podcast.
🎤: www.youtube.com/watch?v=RU_3e8bxvVwee
Healthy New Year Webinar
Excited to join Wellness Wednesday on Jan 15 at 11 AM PT. I’ll share insights on what to eat (and avoid) for better health, plus tackle nutrition misinformation and how diet info can get 'ultra-processed.'
Register here: us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_sj-X_9aETZeUYudACYN3qg
Dietary Guidelines
After 2 years, 421 pages, and countless hours, the 2025 Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee submitted its recommendations.
I spoke with @StanfordMedicine “Scope" about the science, politics, and equity shaping what’s on our plates.
scopeblog.stanford.edu/2024/12/19/dietary-guidelines-nutr…
US News & World Report - Best Diets
@usnews has just released the #bestdiets ratings for 2025. I am honored to be on the panel reviewing these diets.
I offered my expertise in evaluating each of the rated diets in different categories.
health.usnews.com/best-diet
Big news for beans🌱
As part of the '25 US Dietary Advisory Committee, we recommended putting beans, peas, & lentils at the top of MyPlate's protein section instead of meat.
Why? They have protein, fiber, and no saturated fat.
Small swap, big impact!
www.cnn.com/2024/12/12/health/beans-lentils-nutrition-adv…
Health/Nutrition Science Communication
Honored to present at #standom Grand Rounds!
I shared the highs, lows, and lessons from blending rigorous science with pop culture when our Twins study hit @Netflix.
Interested in science communication? This talk was made for you! 🎤
Catch up with the latest recording of #standom's recent Medical Grand Rounds presentation, "Communicating What to Eat – To Netflix or Not," with Stanford Prevention Research Center's @GardnerPhD. www.youtube.com/watch?v=1IfpZhM_o4o
How Diet-Health Misinformation Gets Ultraprocessed:
Exposing Hidden Agendas and Distorted Narratives
Honored to be part of this discussion.
My talk will be:
Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee: Industry Influence?
Spoiler alert: I'm very IMPRESSED with DGAC process!
Stanford Medical Grand Rounds
This was fun!
Weds Dec 11th I got to present at MGR.
8-9 am
"Communicating What to Eat: To Netflix of Not"
It will be recorded and available later for those who couldn't be there in person.
Healthier food for kids is a bipartisan issue!
Today's edition of Food Politics from @marionnestle suggests that fixing food for kids is something agreed on by both sides of the aisle.
www.foodpolitics.com/2024/12/the-maha-saga-continues-sena…
Dr Professor Dean Ms Marathon
My AMAZING wife, @DrMichelsonPhD, just finished her 18th marathon in Honolulu this morning.
Awesome finishing time.
Looks fresh as a daisy?!
Crazy
🏃🏻♀️🏅
Plant-Protein & Heart Health
New research: Eating more plant protein may cut heart disease risk. The key isn't just protein—it's the fiber & lower saturated fat in plant-based options vs. animal proteins.
Prioritize fiber & cut sat fat for heart health
www.healthline.com/health-news/higher-ratio-plant-protein…
Fighting Nutrition Misinformation
Join me at @TrueHealthINIT’s online symposium, "How Diet-Health Misinformation Gets Ultraprocessed" on 12/11. Let’s tackle nutrition misinformation & share solutions for a healthier future.
🔗 Agenda + Registration: thi.today/11dec
Giving Thanks
Great day of family, friends, and delicious food yesterday. All four of our boys are home this weekend.
So much to be thankful for….
….including leftovers! 😋
Stanford Food Summit 2024
Pictures and videos are available from our Nov 1st event. Keynote by Doerr School of Sustainability Dean Arun Majumdar, and expert panels on Food and Sustainability and Food is Medicine.
Brief write up on the event 👇
med.stanford.edu/foodsummit/news.html
Brilliant study design - @KevinH_PhD
Great write-up @LaMotteSandee @CNN
"Hall and his team ...[are] testing diets with 80% of calories from ultraprocessed foods that are low in energy density and relatively low in hyperpalatable foods."
www.cnn.com/2024/11/22/health/ultraprocessed-food-us-diet…
Who's responsible for chemical additives in food?
Thx @anahadoconnor
"In many cases, it’s not the FDA that decides if chemical additives are safe to use in food. Instead, it’s the companies that make and sell the products that contain them."
washingtonpost.com/wellness/2024/11/22/food-additives-gra…
I’ve joined the BlueSky community!
Excited to connect and share more about nutrition science and food systems over there too. Find me at @cgardnerphd—see you on the other side! 🥗
We MUST rely on science
Nutrition is complicated
Food additives, ultra-processed foods, & their health impacts are topics of ongoing debate. But when it comes to reshaping America's food system we MUST rely on evidence-based science solutions.
www.wbur.org/onpoint/2024/11/21/vaccines-fluoride-rfk-pub…
#aha2024
And so goes another @American_Heart annual meeting. Thanx Chicago! Good friends. Good Science. Good food. So-so weather 🌥️☂️but still beautiful lake and skyline for a run or two.
Easily Intimidated…
…by powerfully brilliant women.
@chanders4 & @OdomsYoung were awesome in our #foodismedicine panel at #aha2024. Then look who we ran into just as we finished up…@fstanfordmd.
Nutrition and Public Health champions!
#aha24 – Food Is Medicine
Moderated GREAT panel w/ Kristina Peterson on Food Is Medicine this morning. @Chanders4 @kevin_volpp @OdomsYoung @SethABerkowitz & Dariush Mozaffarian - inspiring, brilliant.
Thx @American_Heart for pilot $$ to help shape future of this initiative!
#aha24 - Health Science Communication
Excited to share my experience working with @Netflix to elevate the reach and impact of the @Stanford vegan vs. omnivore twin study at #aha24’s “From Lab to Living Room: Partnering With the Media” session.
Plant-Based Symposium
Excited to be at @calpolypomona for the Plant-Based Food and Nutrition Symposium to discuss the health benefits of plant-based vs. animal-based diets with fellow experts. Looking forward to exploring ways to promote nutritious, sustainable choices!
Seed Oil Sanity
Thx @alicegcallahan for bringing some sanity to this topic. Important perspectives from Harris/@n3doc, Lichtenstein (Tufts), & Decker (UMass Amherst).
With what/instead of what?
With UPF - not good
Instead of butter/lard - better
www.nytimes.com/2024/11/09/well/eat/seed-oil-effects.html
#lm2024 - Lifestyle Medicine
Thrilled to have presented a morning plenary in Orlando with @ChefInMedicine (the recent President-Elect of the American College of Lifestyle Medicine).
Last night's conference opener by @thedanbuettner was fantastic.
Hello from Australia
Happy to be in Sydney this week, and giving two talks at this meeting.
One on Diet and the Microbiome (Wednesday), and a Plenary Session on Weight Loss Diets (Friday).
Christopher Gardner reposted
I am excited to be participating at Stanford Food Summit 2024 on Friday, November 1 at the Arrillaga Alumni Center as a speaker on the "Exploring Fermented Foods" panel.
Event registration: med.stanford.edu/foodsummit.html
Poster applications accepted until 10/14 forms.gle/MxWXwSgNJqy5MsKC6
Plant Based Meat
Nice coverage @anahadoconnor
Better for environment & animal rights/welfare than red meat
Healthy?
Not dichotomous
HealthIER than what?
Healthier than red meat
Intended to replace red meat
Not intended to replace beans/peas/lentils.
www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2024/10/08/plant-based-bu…
Food Systems Courses
Fantastic publication that first defines "Food Systems" courses, and then provides an overview of where these types of courses can be found in a subset of Land-Grant US universities.
Charlie Hoffs led this incredible work.
www.frontiersin.org/journals/sustainable-food-systems/art…
New ACLM President-Elect
Congrats to dear friend & colleague Dr. Michelle Hauser, @ChefInMedicine, @ACLifeMed’s new President-Elect! Excited for updated Culinary Medicine Curriculum & increased access to lifestyle medicine for underserved patients!
surgery.stanford.edu/news2/Hauser-ACLM-pres-elect.html
Attention Seed Oil Conspiracy Theorists
Recent @Join_Zoe podcast from @saraheeberry is a gem.
Scientific expert
She's done seminal RCTs on seed oil & impacts on human health
4 myths addressed
Evidenced based science!
Don't fear seed oils!
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/zoe-science-nutrition/id161…
Seed Oils: Friend, Not Foe!
Don't fear seed oils. They're rich in omega-6 fatty acids, which support heart health. Focus on cutting ultra-processed foods, not these healthy fats. My take with @American_Heart: www.heart.org/en/news/2024/08/20/theres-no-reason-to-avoi…
🌱Farm to Table Camp🌱
In partnership w/ @SantaClaraUSD, we're teaching students where their food comes from + researching the best ways to inspire healthy eating habits at Farm to Table Camp. Check out this article in the @Stanford Report to learn more.
news.stanford.edu/stories/2024/08/stanford-researchers-an…
Looking forward to collaborating on some diet X microbiome research with you @DrAlanDesmond
Whoever said “never meet your heroes” obviously never met @DrNealBarnard or @GardnerPhD Absolute legends in the field of human nutrition.
Native American Nutrition
This evening Dr. Valerie Blue Bird Jernigan gave an inspiring presentation at #icnm2024 on the impactful research she is doing on food sovereignty through her Center for Indigenous Health Research & Policy at Oklahoma State.
Standing Ovation @ close 👏
#icnm2024 Conference
Excited to speak at the International Conference on Nutrition in Medicine in Washington, D.C., about building consensus in health science communication around plant-based diets. Looking forward to bringing clarity and collaboration to the table!
Join healthcare professionals in Washington, D.C., for the 12th annual International Conference on Nutrition in Medicine! #icnm2024
Register here: www.pcrm.org/icnmv
Should you go vegan?
Our @Stanford twins study joins decades of research showing a plant-based diet is healthier long term, but that doesn’t mean you have to vegan. What’s more important is adding more plant-based foods to your diet. Catch my latest podcast w/ @SlatePodcasts.
Do you need to go vegan?🥬
Today on Well, Now: an interview with @GardnerPhD, lead researcher of the Stanford "twin study" that follows 22 sets of identical twins, one eating an omnivore diet and the other vegan, for 8 weeks.
🎧Listen now: slate.com/podcasts/well-now/2024/08/netflix-twin-study-do…
Congrats Sarah!
Well deserved.
And so much more to come!!!
Some exciting personal news….I’ve been promoted to Professor at KCL 🚀
The culmination of 25 yrs academic research, >35 RCTs, 10s of millions of £s grant funding, 1000s of BSc & MSc lectures/ projects, 100s manuscripts, PhD students & more….
But my kids are keeping me real 👇🏻😂
Big shoes to fill with the legendary Bob Harrington moving on.
Euan's feet are appropriately large! (metaphorically)
Congrats.
Lucky us!
We are thrilled to announce our new Chair of the Stanford Department of Medicine, Dr. Euan Ashley @euanashley . We have a great future ahead!!! Dr. Ashley becomes Chair Sept 18th, 2024.
Is Organic Worth the Higher Price?
EXCELLENT summary of the MANY issues relevant to what may seem like a straight-forward question.
Answer isn't yes or no - but, IT DEPENDS
Thank you @susan_shain for this practical, insightful and concise overview.
www.nytimes.com/2024/07/01/climate/organic-food.html?unlo…
Brilliant and effective nutrition study review.
Simon, this is fantastic! Powerfully effective.
@Biolayne, the challenges were credibly and respectfully presented. Will be interested to learn of your responses.
I discussed some of these views, in the below twitter post, in my latest episode of The Proof.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=qC3Euh8Ghbs
It was an honor to join the graduation festivities and hear from all the fantastic mentors as they shared insights and did a little roasting of their brilliant fellows. An inspiring evening!
A fun night celebrating our graduating fellows. Thank you @GardnerPhD for sharing your journey with us. Fortunate that we get to welcome @margaretzhou @SiddPradeep Andrew Li, Chiraag Kulkarni as faculty
Good luck to all. We are proud of you @Stanford_GI
Staying at the TWA hotel at JFK
Just finished up another great annual Menus of Change conference @CIACulinary #moc2024
Great people
Great food
Great inspiration for unapologetically delicious plant-forward initiatives
Headed home EARLY 7 am
First time ever in TWA hotel
Excellent choice for interim GI chief!!!
Congrats!!
Foreshadowed a new chapter for both mother & son…
As we wish @WRayKimMD good luck on his new adventure @MayoClinic, I’m honored to be selected to lead @Stanford_GI as Interim Chief to continue our mission of excellence in patient care, education, research & community
Diet Quality and Resilience
Congratulations Dr. Springfield-Trice on another important publication.
"Diet quality may be positively associated with resilience at all stages of adulthood."
file:///Users/cgardner/Downloads/nutrients-16-01724.pdf
Sounds like a fantastic opportunity!
An exciting postdoctoral position in my group!
Dietary profiles, health risk from chronic diseases, and dynamics of life-course health
jobs.inrae.fr/en/ot-21966
Health Matters-Food is Medicine
Fantastic talk about Food is Medicine by #drtamikokatsumoto, clinician specializing in Rheumatology & Oncology @StanfordMed.
If you aren’t here already, come now to Stanford for #healthmatters2024.
Choose a more whole food plant based diet.
Excellent and helpful follow-up by @saraheeberry on the recently published RCT on personalized nutrition
One more....please read the full paper to see what we did and didn't set out to answer and our discussion of the many limitations.
Choosing the right study design is dependent on the question the researchers set out to test; not what others might think we should have tested!
Ultraprocessed Foods
Very helpful balanced coverage in @nytimes by @alicegcallahan.
Thoughtful insights from @KevinH_PhD @maya_vadiveloo Dr Josiemer Mattei at @HarvardChanSPH and several others.
www.nytimes.com/2024/05/06/well/eat/ultraprocessed-foods-…
🌟 Job opening - Gardner lab 🌟
Diet Assessor for 3 exciting studies 🍎 Fixed-term 9-month role in PST time zone 🕒 Must have nutrition knowledge, NDSR experience preferred 📋 Bilingual in Spanish a plus. Remote work considered; hybrid preferred. Apply: stanford.io/3wvXJpK
Agreed. That is along the lines of how I would propose we start the interaction!
I’m sure there are more than three.
I would like them to find at least three things they agree on.
I’m all in!
Thank you both for thinking of me?
Loved having the opportunity to respond to some of the comments and apparent confusion about the Twins vegan vs omnivore study vs. the Netflix docuseries.
Simon, as always, you’re a master at getting to the proof of the truth!
Thanx for elevating science communication. 👍👨🔬👩🔬🍓
Out tomorrow. My episode with @GardnerPhD @Stanford @StanfordMed
Dr. Will Bulsiewicz - FREE webinar
“Fiber Fueled: The Power of Fiber to Transform Our Lives.” Science & practical advice about the importance of plants for overall health
May 8 at 11 am PT (also recorded). Hosted by the amaZING Sally Duplantier. Register: us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_Yp-vcHyqTWqiKbJK4JqgLQ
Great work Patrick. Love the heat map
Thrilled to share the first paper of my PhD, published in @NutrtnResrch. We discussed sustainable and healthy diet (SHD) conceptions and the factors influencing sustainable dietary behaviours within the university setting and beyond 🎯
🧵(1/7)
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0271531724000368
Dr. Ron Krauss - Livermore Lab @ UC Berkeley. I'm not sure he directly studied cooking oils & the parameters you are interested in. He was one of the original investigators that identified LDL particle size as an independent risk factor for CVD.
1996👇
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8782636/
Anyone know the domain specific expert scientists here? Cc @deirdre_tobias @GardnerPhD @NutritionMadeS3 @drmatthewnagra @PlantChompers @KCKlatt
The initial thought was….identical twins instead of a crossover.
Interesting thought experiment and statistical question to come up with a design that would test whether that is comparable. 🤔
Why not do a crossover trial with a washout?
Twins & Netflix
Thrilled to be featured in the @UCBerkeley Wellness Letter! As a member of the editorial board & a PhD alum, this recognition is an honor. Check out the interview to learn about our twins research and how it all came together on @netflix
www.wellnessletteronline.com/eat_well/twins-they-are-what…
Apologies….i would agree vegans eat lower proportion of protein.
What I was referring to at the time was a set of studies I was looking at that include low-fat vs low-carb, and keto vs Mediterranean, where the protein intake was much more similar than different. Strikingly.
I've heard Christopher say on your show that people tend to eat to roughly the same protein level, something like 17% of calories. But these vegans ate to 13%, no? And the omnivores ate to 20%. I wonder how he thinks about that.
I always enjoy my conversations with Simon Hill of the @theproof. Can’t wait for this episode to drop in a few weeks!
Today I sat down with @GardnerPhD to discuss the Omnivore/Vegan twin experiment. We had a blast (as usual) 🔥🔥🧨🧨
We discussed the ins and outs of the trial and critiques from @BioLayne @PeterAttiaMD @bigfatsurprise Tro and Mark Hyman.
Few new things I learned 💡:
1 - It's been said by some the omnivore diet wasn't a healthy omnivorous diet. From baseline to 8 weeks the subejcts eating an omnivore diet increased their animal protein, vegetable, eggs, meat, fish and poultry consumption... and decreased their consumption of refined grains and added sugars. Isn't this what most of the above people would recommend? Their fibre intake even went up (slightly) to 22g per day (above the national average). Total carbs went down from 43% of calories to 38% of calories (a significant reduction). Also their Healthy Eating Index (HEI) score went up significantly compared to baseline. The study was in fact designed to make sure it was a healthy vegan diet versus a healthy omnivorous diet.
2 - After considering some of the critiques I noticed a huge double standard from some of the folks mentioned above. Nothing personal - I often agree with some of their views but there's a giant double standard that I haven't seen them or others talking about. You'll have to tune in for that.
3 - Dexa scans were not part of the study. The documentary did them for fun - but as @GardnerPhD states, they didnt have the funds to do Dexa scans for all subjects, so there is no data that can be analysed. What's mentioned in the docuemntary about DEXA scans and body comp is not science. Dr Gardner had no say in what the documentary looked like.
There's many more takeaways. It'll be on YouTube in a couple of weeks. Subscribe below 👇
www.youtube.com/c/TheProofWithSimonHill
The Science behind benefits (human & planetary) of reduced meat consumption in US
In 2022 I had the honor of delivering 35 min keynote to @American_Heart. It wasn't recorded, but I created a recording (StanfordNutrition YouTube channel)
Data: 3:45-13:45
www.youtube.com/watch?v=V36nzfPUcnk&t=1862s
Meat Lobby Delighted
As described in @Guardian today, FAO's Global Roadmap following #cop28 disturbingly failed to specify reduced meat consumption in high consuming countries like US.
The science is there
Political will not so much
Much work to be done
www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/apr/08/us-meat-lobby…
Meat Lobby Delighted
As described in @Guardian today, FAO's Global Roadmap following #cop28 disturbingly failed to specify reduced meat consumption in high consuming countries like US.
The science is there
Political will not so much
Much work to be done
www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/apr/08/us-meat-lobby…
Addressing critics - Wow!
The @netflix hit, “You Are What You Eat: A Twin Experiment,” features our research & caused the internet to go wild. @PlantChompers dives into our findings, shutting down critics in a fabulously entertaining and informative way.
youtu.be/t24BCuXIlZI
Food Lab Talk
Big thanks to Michiel Bakker of @google for inviting me to join Food Lab Talk to chat about using storytelling to inspire change and the concept of “stealth nutrition.”
Hope you’ll check it out!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4ue3ucSF6g
ANZOS Conference
I’m excited to be heading to New South Wales in Australia this October to join #anzos2024 as a Plenary Speaker. Looking forward to sharing nutrition insights with @ANZOS_Society and engaging in thought-provoking discussions around health.
🌟 Exciting News! 🌟 @GardnerPhD joins #anzos2024 as a Plenary Speaker! 🎤 Renowned expert in #nutritionalscience, his insights will be thought-provoking. Join us in Sydney, Oct 16-18, for stimulating discussions! www.anzos.com/anzos-annual-meeting
#letstalkaboutobesity 📊🔬🎉
Coming soon on Instagram.
Just started using that platform recently. I recently uploaded a recipe for wheat berry salad.
@cgardnerphd
@GardnerPhD Can you share the recipe you made at the beginning of episode 1 of #youarewhatyoueat? It looks like tempeh and veggies with some amazing marinade! 🔥
Dairy vs plant milk
Very clever @anahadoconnor & @asteckelberg
Game modifications:
For Dairy, skim wouldn't have lost point for sat fat
For Plant, unsweetened wouldn't have lost point for sugar
Allergies/Intolerance: Tie? 🤔
Dairy > soy & nut
www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/interactive/2024/dairy-vs…
Modest correction.
In the JAMA 2007 publication of A TO Z, the only significant 12-month BMI pairwise comparison was between Atkins and Zone (the two low-carb diets).
You have to look at the superscripts to find out which diets were significantly different from one another.
IN 2007 @GardnerPhD (who describes himself as "mostly vegan") put calorie restriction to the test and found it did worse than a diet that did not include calorie counting. That diet was... the Atkins diet.
AHA EpiLifestyle 2024 Chicago
The opening session today for @American_Heart annual council meetings of Epidemiology & Lifestyle councils featured Prez @Joseph_C_Wu.
Thanx Joe for joining us in Chicago for #ahaepilifestyle2024 & for the Health Care X Food initiative shout out!
Everyone got the same amount.
The amount was determined to be that required by the person estimated to have the highest caloric need.
Nutrient data in tables reflect what participants reported eating.
So, if they didn’t eat the same proportion of each jar, this was captured.
I have q. Did everyone get the same amount of food in each jar, or was it different for each participant? How was the calorie content determined to be sufficient for all participants?
Nutrition study design explained
Did provide more than enuf calories.
Did instruct to eat to satiety.
Each jar had different item.
COLLECTIVELY the jars provided appropriate nutrient distribution.
Not so if you ate all of some jars and none of others.
See next post…..
Just finished listening to your AJCN podcast re: KetoMed study. I'm curious why you would tell people how much of each "jar" to eat if this was supposed to be an ad libitum study? Isn't that a contridiction? Why not just provide more than enough so subjects can eat to satiety?
So, to follow the prescribed diet pattern, & eat to satiety, participants were instructed to eat the same proportion of each jar…by the end of the week.
Eating all of every jar, or 1/2, or 75% of every jar, would result in adhering to intended macronutrient DISTRIBUTION
Helps?
Vegan Twins Study
Thank you @metronewspaper & @E_Borelli1 for covering the @Netflix docuseries “You Are What You Eat: A Twin Experiment,” & how there can be more consensus than controversy in nutrition if we’re willing to have open conversations.
www.metrosiliconvalley.com/are-plant-based-vegan-diets-he…
Plant protein
Thanks @AubreyNPR for including me in this story. All needed protein and nutrients needed can come from a plant-based diet w/ a little planning. Lentils, chickpeas, other beans, whole-grains & nuts & seed can provide plenty of protein
www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2024/03/03/1234460368/r…
Ketogenic diet
Science reporter @DewanPandora covers the Keto Diet for @Newsweek , and provides input from several nutrition professionals. Thanx for including my input and perspectives Pandora.
www.newsweek.com/what-scientists-say-keto-diet-1873233
Celebrating Book Contract
Friday nite my wife & I celebrated getting a book contract for "Chews Wisely" (or whatever publishers decide for title)
Unapologetically delicious 5-course prix fixe whole food plant based dining extravaganza experience @ Little Saint, Healdsburg. Yum!
20th HKHL Huge Success
Once again the HKHL conference was sold out this year-for it's 20th session! ~500 physicians & health professionals attended. The mastermind of it all, Dr. David Eisenberg has done it again!👏
I was honored to give a plenary talk on nutrition controversies
~30 years later
Dr @KurtRibisl & I started a postdoc fellowship together @ Stanford in 1993. Now he's Professor/Chair of Health Behavior @UNCpublichealth & returned 2/8 to give Grand Rounds
As postdocs, we played ultimate frisbee weekly🥏Before his talk we hurled a bit of disc
More plants, less meat
(in US, where fiber intake is so low, and meat intake is so high)
Thanx @CarrieDennett
Appreciate the practical approach to this, and agree.
Should you change your eating habits based on a Netflix ‘documentary’? www.seattletimes.com/life/wellness/should-you-change-your… via @seattletimes
Chews Wisely
Thrilled to be giving a Stanford webinar at noon today (pacific time) for the Healthy Living program.
This is a bit of a preview of a book I'm working on.
Title evolution:
1st: It Depends
2nd: Discerning Eater
Current: Chews Wisely
Next: ?
events.stanford.edu/event/chews_wisely_-_finally_figuring…
📚 Our study published in @JAMANetworkOpen comparing omnivore vs vegan diets in identical twins hit top 1% of research published (in similar time frame) in @altmetric – the ultimate visibility score! 🚀 So proud of the impact our research is having on people & the planet. 🌍 🌱
Appreciate you stating what could have been obvious but maybe wasn't.
Gratefully, Christopher
Wellness Wednesday Podcast
Join me for my #wellnesswednesday talk with the amaZING Sally Duplantier on Jan 10th. Learn whether organic foods are worth the cost, if eggs increase blood serum cholesterol, and if GMOs are the Frankenfoods we think they are!
us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_1iEAQJmWTQeJ11yvmnvYTg
Omnivore vs Vegan Diet Study Among Identical Twins
Study was fun to design & run - thrilled it was published in @JAMANetworkOpen 👇
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2812392
Certainly a new & unique experience to have the conduct & findings featured on Netflix!
#3 since released on 1/1/24 🎥🤣
Happy New Year!
Very impressive!
Also recently tested my visceral fat
Vegan vs Omnivore diet among Identical Twins
Study published last month in @JAMANetworkOpen
January 1st 2024 the study will be featured in @Netflix docuseries
Trailer today
www.youtube.com/watch?v=oygkWmXyOaM
4 episode docu-series tomorrow 🎥
Happy New Year🎉
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2812392
Omnivore vs Vegan Diet Study - Identical Twins
Cardiometabolic outcomes, 8 wks, 22 pairs of twins
The countdown is moving...3, 2, 1 days until release 🎉🥳
Study published in @JAMANetworkOpen
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2812392
Trailer to @netflix documentary 👇
www.youtube.com/watch?v=oygkWmXyOaM
We’ll done again @PlantChompers
Damn this is solid - a must watch! @PlantChompers
Peter Attia's Longevity Book Outlive: The BEST or WORST longevity book? youtu.be/VWeg3l3RBIM via @YouTube
Vegan vs Omnivore Diet Study in Identical Twins
Manuscript ➡️Netflix docuseries 🤯
You may have seen the publication in @JAMANetworkopen
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2812392
Starting January 1st you can see the @Netflix version!
Appearing...
@timspector
@marionnestle
@NimaiDelgado
🤣
That's right... Young Scientist Award... 😂
Nutrition Assessment - always a challenge
For those of you who aren't involved in running interventions & collecting diet data...
It is the norm that people under-report.
It happens: under-report, over-report, forget, lie (other?)
Self-report has challenges
Do does domiciling
What absolutely intrigues and fascinates me is that this was an *ad libitum* diet. How did these people manage to apparently unknowingly/voluntarily keep their enerygy intake so low? That looks like a philosopher's stone to me. I am green with envy. Really!
Greatly appreciate this!
This means a great deal to me @DoctorTro as I try to avoid unnecessary disagreement when there is room for greater consensus & more civility
Plenty of room for healthy disagreement and discussion
Respectfully,
Onward!
Christopher
In this tweet thread, Gardner explains why the discrepancies in sugar, processed carbs, refined grains and calories were noted in the Vegan Twin Study
I appreciate his explanation and I apologize for my quick judgement on it.
On this specific matter I was wrong.
Nutrition Research - Access your Inner Geek
Tweetorial
This is a great catch & observation by @stathitriadis who went into Supplemental materials to look at diet data.
Points out calorie intake for vegans was lower than omnivores & asked why not matched?
Nuanced 🧵
Read on...
Why weren't calories matched? Vegan arm had ~200 less calories per day.
Nutrition Research - Access your Inner Geek
Tweetorial
This is a great catch & observation by @stathitriadis who went into Supplemental materials to look at diet data.
Points out calorie intake for vegans was lower than omnivores & asked why not matched?
Nuanced 🧵
Read on...
Why weren't calories matched? Vegan arm had ~200 less calories per day.
Isocaloric vs Ad Libitum in Feeding Studies
The data reported during "Food Delivery" period was ~200 kcal lower for Vegan vs Omnivore.
Design flaw?
Consider...
There is a critical difference between food "delivered" & food "consumed"
"Delivered food" was MATCHED for calories
Delivered does not mean consumed
If we had recruited ducks & were studying Foie Gras we would have been more likely to equate "delivered" w/ "consumed"
Or maybe rats or mice?
But humans who join our research studies, despite good intentions, don't eat everything we deliver.
KetoMed study - adherence to food delivery
In 2021 we published an "adherence" paper for our KetoMed study. It also had "food delivered" & "self provided" phases
If participants had eaten everything delivered, adherence scores should have all been "10/10" in food delivery phase
KetoMed - Adherence study
Why didn't they eat it all?
When they joined the study they were told what to expect.
They were expected to eat ONLY delivered food for 4 weeks.
But some of them couldn't maintain that
Interestingly they honestly reported that!
(1 wk of food below) 🤣
During food delivery phase (cross-over study) participants reported eating fewer calories on Well Formulated Ketogenic Diet vs Mediterranean-Plus
Despite having same # of calories delivered
Why?
I assume at least partly because WFKD is more restrictive
Design flaw?
Real life?
Back to concern of @stathitriadis who noticed that REPORTED calorie intake was lower for those assigned to Vegan vs Omnivore for "food delivery" phase.
I believe he is concerned it is a study design flaw.
To clarify, kcals DELIVERED were matched.
But kcal CONSUMED were not.
Vegan diets are very restrictive.
I assume those on the vegan diet might have been hungry for some fish or eggs or yogurt or meat. But those were restricted. They weren't hungry for more veggies & beans.
Same for Keto? Restrictive.
Maybe hungry for bread, but not for more fat.
Helpful methodological explanation?
Hoping this helps.
Just cuz it is a feeding study, w/ same kcal delivered, doesn't mean calories consumed will be isocaloric
Thoughts?
Comments?
KetoMed study
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35641199/
Adherence paper (@TheGuyititian)
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33802709/
Diet QUALITY matters
In #dietfits weight loss for Low-Fat vs Low-Carb was not different
Both designed to be "healthy"
Lentils vs lollipops are both Low-fat
Fatty fish/avocados/nuts vs Keto cookies are all Low-Carb
Don't forget healthy/quality part
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0002916523662355
Diet QUALITY matters
Paper out today in @AJCNutrition
Excellent secondary analysis of #dietfits by @ChefInMedicine @TheGuyititian & others
"Results of this analysis support the combination of dietary adherence and HIGH-QUALITY diets for weight loss"
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0002916523662355
Vegan vs Omnivore - Twins study
So excited our study of identical twins comparing vegan and omnivore diets is making a splash! Check out this super fun video by Lisa Kim of @StanfordMed to see which diet – and twin – fared better. #nutrition #research
youtu.be/IvXo-RQGdls
If you want to cover this I’m sure it will all be clarified! 🤣
Please help the people on both polar ends of this understand that the answer is somewhere in the middle, and there is no one diet for everyone.
Just one study, answering a narrow question asked in a specific way.
vegan vs omnivore study in TWINS!!
I´m sure this won't cause ANY bickering AT ALL on social media 🤣🤣
calling it right now:
veganJoe146- "this proves everyone should be vegan"
meatySam38- "this study is useless garbage"
Vegan vs Omnivore diet - in IDENTICAL TWINS
Our study is out today!
Huge shout out to entire study team!
Especially co-first authors @TheGuyititian & @catepward
OMG...twins are so much fun to work with!
Stay tuned for Netflix docuseries! Jan2024
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2812392
Twin research indicates a vegan diet improves cardiovascular health
Thanx @emilymoskal_ @StanfordMed
A Stanford Medicine-led trial of identical twins comparing vegan and omnivore diets found that a vegan diet improves overall cardiovascular health.
med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2023/11/twin-diet-vegan-ca…
Vegan vs Omnivore diet - in IDENTICAL TWINS
Our study is out today!
Huge shout out to entire study team!
Especially co-first authors @TheGuyititian & @catepward
OMG...twins are so much fun to work with!
Stay tuned for Netflix docuseries! Jan2024
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2812392
Vegetables vs Fruits?
Thx @CarrieDennett for finding our 2019 pub. @botaniculture, @ChefInMedicine, and I had a blast writing this
It's a bit tongue in cheek
Byline: "Veggies squash fruits"
Many food puns!
Mostly, Americans don't eat enuf of either!
www.seattletimes.com/life/wellness/which-is-better-for-yo…
Ultraprocessed foods
Interesting new publication from #epic group from @TheLancet
Overall UPF again associated w/ adverse events
Animal-based products & ASB+SSB most strongly
Breads & cereals & plant-based alternatives trending toward protection
www.thelancet.com/journals/lanepe/article/PIIS2666-7762(2…
How Climate Change Is Affecting Our Health
This Salon hosted by @JeanneRosn59233 should be great
So are all the talks at www.soulfoodsalon.com
The incomparable @LisaPatelMD is Exec Director of @docsforclimate & Clinical Associate Professor & Pediatric Hospitalist at Stanford
For the meat arm of the study, we did go through a vendor in the Bay Area who specializes in organic, pasture-raised, regenerative farmed, meats. That is what we paid for.
Diet Quality Matters
Congrats to @ChefInMedicine for insightful secondary analysis of #dietfits
"Results of this analysis support the combination of dietary adherence & HIGH-QUALITY diets for weight loss"
There is more to Low-Carb & Low-Fat than "low"!
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0002916523662355
Bone Health and Diet
Join my AmaZING colleague, Sally Duplantier, to take a deep dive into the many nutrients that contribute to bone health. Free & Recorded. Learn more: myzinglife.com/upcoming-programs-2023/nutrition-and-bone-…
Clock changes for ~4 months
The switch back is March 12th...so 4 months and a week
Does that mean after 4 months, you are going to change your clock for 2 months so it isn't correct when the time switches back? 🤣
Your right, there was no need for that. 🤦♂️
Celebrating with you
Wishing a happy The Clock in My Car Will Be Wrong for Six Months Day to all who celebrate.
Happy to take on whatever moniker suggested, knucklehead or otherwise, for my absolute respect for @TamarHaspel. After hundreds of interactions, I find her understanding of nutrition science top notch
Relentless seeker of truth, w/ only the best intentions for communicating this
Here's a talk I gave at a science conference, referencing corporate documents, that touched on @tamarhaspel, who @mikegrunwald says reads zillions of scientific studies.
CORPORATE INFLUENCE IN FOOD SCIENCE AND POLICY: More Monsanto documents, more Tamar Haspel problems medium.com/@thackerpd/corporate-influence-in-food-science…
cc: @MarcJBrooker @Paul_Anater @GardnerPhD @KyraBattaglia57 @RosaMolinero @Kate_H_Taylor @KNordinBeato @MelissaMcCart
Powerful Op-Ed by @JerryMande
"Only by redirecting the agency’s [NIH] focus & adequately funding nutrition science can we hope to address America’s diet-related disease crisis and alleviate the burden it imposes on our society. The time to act is now!"
thehill.com/opinion/healthcare/4277664-the-national-insti…
No Nonsense Nutrition
"I’m going to sum up 10 things I’m persuaded are true. Some are important, a few are trivial and all meet with staunch disagreement every time I air them."
Nutrition science rarely has all the evidence needed for definitive answers.
Listen to Tamar 👏
This month marks my 10-year anniversary as a @WashingtonPost columnist.
To celebrate, I wrote about 10 things I'd love to be able to convince you of.
And here they are, in one convenient 🧵
www.washingtonpost.com/food/2023/11/01/food-truths-gmos-d…
"Reauthorization of the Farm Bill represents a critical opportunity to improve food systems & health in the US while also mitigating climate change...
health professional associations, & public health groups should consider engaging more substantively"
www-nejm-org.laneproxy.stanford.edu/doi/10.1056/NEJMp2307…
Protein
Much to unpack here
Why not do this trial in HUMANS, not mice🤔
"To examine possibility that exercise can protect against detrimental effects of high-protein diet, researchers used progressive resistance-based strength training program in mice"
scitechdaily.com/scientists-shed-new-light-on-the-protein…
Unapologetic Deliciousness
The trifecta of opportunity is available @nytimes @nytimeswell ....
Great taste, human health, planetary health.
The path....more plant-based recipes, from culinarians and cultures all around the world.
"If America runs on Dunkin'....we're F*cked"
Pumpkin Swirl Frozen Coffee
If you get the large with SKIM MILK (obviously for the health conscious consumer), it is "only" 880 calories (with 185 grams of sugar - 185 X 4 = 740 calories)
Happy Halloween! 🎃
www.dunkindonuts.com/content/dam/dd/pdf/nutrition.pdf
#mcurc2023
Getting started with unapologetically delicious breakfast at day 2 of the Menus of Change University Research Collaborative’s 10th annual meeting @Stanford
#mcurc2023
Menus of Change University Research Collaborative presentation by the Equitable Harvest Black Farmers Initiative.
Conversation with Stanford Food Institute and Farms To Grow
Farm-to-Institution procurement guide. 👏
#mcurc2023
Menus of Change University Research Collaborative session on Sustainability. A 2030 goal set in 2019 was to lower GHG emissions 25% in Univ dining menus.
Jackie Bertoldo says after 4 years, 24% reduction achieved across ~30 schools!
New 2030 goal is 40% reduction!!
#mcurc2023
The 10th annual Menus of Change University Research Collaborative has begun @Stanford
Hiring study coordinator
We have a pair of exciting nutrition studies ongoing & are looking to hire a new study coordinator. Would need to be located in Stanford area
If this isn't for you but you know of someone who would be interested, please share.
careersearch.stanford.edu/jobs/study-coordinator-23152?et…
Food is Medicine
Honored to have been part of the writing group for this important review.
This Presidential Advisory reviews landscape for FIM practice & research, suggests potential approaches to close gaps in field
Concludes with a call to action
professional.heart.org/en/science-news/food-is-medicine
Fantastic group of co-authors, including:
@kevin_volpp @HeartBobH @DrLaPrincess @RobertoCA @JulieGervis @MitchElkind @chanders4
Protein Rant
And yet another opportunity to share my protein rant.🤯
All plant foods have all 20 amino acids.
Relatively easy to get all the protein you need from plants.
Scrabble analogy!
This time with Chuck Carroll on the Exam Room Podcast - 20 min
www.google.com/search?q=Exam+room+christopher+gardnber
#mcurc23
The Menus of Change University Research Collaborative celebrates its TENTH anniversary Oct 2-4.
This year the annual all member meeting returns to the Stanford campus.
Unapologetic deliciousness, tied to
Human Health
Environmental Sustainability
and more...
Yum & Yay
Christopher Gardner reposted
Science stuff is not all that 'cool' if your just looking for 'likes' and 'views'. But if nutrition is your thing, especially 'protein' after been told to eat it like it's going out of fashion then this interview with @GardnerPhD is a good watch >> www.youtube.com/watch?v=DMwf_9wqWY0
The AMAZING Hannah Ritchie rocks this Ted talk on sustainability.
Powerfully data driven, optimistic, and inspiring.
Thank you for all you do @_HannahRitchie 🤯
www.ted.com/talks/hannah_ritchie_are_we_the_last_generati…
Job opening - Communications Director
Nutrition Studies Research Group
Stanford Medicine (Gardner Lab)
We have posted a 100% effort position for a communications director. Looking forward to finding who is out there that can join us!
careersearch.stanford.edu/jobs/pbdi-communications-direct…
Christopher Gardner reposted
We believe in the right to healthy food for all people. Nutrition security is our priority—for people to have equitable and stable availability, access, affordability, and utilization of foods and beverages that promote well-being and prevent and treat disease. #foodismedicine
Nutrition misinformation
This is fascinating and engaging.
Thank you @PlantChompers
Took a close look at how nutrition misinformation spreads, using an example of what seemed like a very informed lecture from a very popular scientist. Checking references can be shocking. 😵💫
youtu.be/nnyzuY-Xwe4
Let the wild rumpus begin! Shake ‘em up Dale. Congratulations!
Nutrition - Slowing aging
Two of my favorite people, Sally Duplantier & Jeanne Rosner, team up for the Sept. 6 SOUL Food Salon. Learn how lifestyle choices, including nutrition, can slow down cellular aging.
Register here to attend live - Woodside, CA
www.soulfoodsalon.com/events
As @TamarHaspel says, you wrote the book on it !! ❤️
I’m quoted in it!
Calories in/Calories out
Great piece on this today from @TamarHaspel
The real disagreement isn’t over whether this is true; it’s whether the effect is large enough to make a difference in weight loss.
www.washingtonpost.com/food/2023/08/23/calories-in-calori…
Calories in/Calories out
Great piece on this today from @TamarHaspel
The real disagreement isn’t over whether this is true; it’s whether the effect is large enough to make a difference in weight loss.
www.washingtonpost.com/food/2023/08/23/calories-in-calori…
Farm to Table Camp - Collaboration between @StanfordDeptMed and Santa Clara Unified School District.
This was our 12th summer!
Stanford students Isabella de Vlieger @isaglabella & Jack Thorell engaged & educated ~100 kids this summer on the 11-acre Farm at Peterson Middle School
It's a joy to see Stanford researchers working with young minds who are hungry for knowledge! Check out these colorful shots of the team teaching kids about healthy eating habits at the @SantaClaraUSD Farm!
@StanfordMed @StanfordHealth
Rich Roll podcast - We also covered:
Personalized nutrition & finding a sustainable diet for long-term success
What makes a rigorous scientific study?
What defines a healthy microbiome?
www.richroll.com/podcast/christopher-gardner-774/
Postdoctoral Research Fellows
Applications are NOW OPEN for the Stanford Postdoctoral Recruitment Initiative in Sciences & Medicine (PRISM)! We invite all graduate students, & especially those from backgrounds underrepresented within academia, to apply.
postdocs.stanford.edu/PRISM
RichRoll podcast: We covered
What we know & don’t know about diet, weight loss, obesity, diabetes, heart & metabolic health;
Diet wars: plant-based vs carnivore vs Mediterranean & low-fat vs low carb
Protein requirements & common misconceptions
& more
www.richroll.com/podcast/christopher-gardner-774/
Nutrition and Brain Health - Upcoming Webinar
What role do nutrition and other lifestyle choices play in keeping your brain healthy? Find out in a Stanford webinar with my amaZING colleague, Sally Duplantier. August 17 @ 12 noon (also recorded). stanford.io/3YC5DHx
Great fun doing this podcast with the legendary Rich Roll and team!
Director of Nutrition Studies at @Stanford Prevention Research Center & Professor @StanfordMed, @GardnerPhD is a legend in evidence-based nutrition research
Bottom line: despite diet tribalism there is more consensus that you think.
🧵 /1
www.richroll.com/podcast/christopher-gardner-774/
Christopher Gardner reposted
Director of Nutrition Studies at @Stanford Prevention Research Center & Professor @StanfordMed, @GardnerPhD is a legend in evidence-based nutrition research
Bottom line: despite diet tribalism there is more consensus that you think.
🧵 /1
www.richroll.com/podcast/christopher-gardner-774/
I didn't articulate my point well in the meeting.
I was frustrated the session was unnecessarily one sided: "...there are flaws w/ NOVA...so many flaws that it might do more harm than good...sooo much work to be done..."
I think we need more new strategies. Let's build on NOVA!
In a possibly sarcastic summary of an apparently unbalanced ultra-processed foods session at #nutrition2023, @GardnerPhD quipped, “It’s amazing how easy it was to take down ultra-processed foods”. I guess I’m wasting my time on our new RCT given that UPFs aren’t a thing anymore😜
Is the evidence to support #ultraprocessedfood recommendations solid? Or insufficient? Separating passions from objective science is a challenge on this one. The buzz on this at #nutrition2023 is hard to miss.
conscienhealth.org/2023/07/nutrition-2023-will-guidelines…
Christopher Gardner reposted
In a possibly sarcastic summary of an apparently unbalanced ultra-processed foods session at #nutrition2023, @GardnerPhD quipped, “It’s amazing how easy it was to take down ultra-processed foods”. I guess I’m wasting my time on our new RCT given that UPFs aren’t a thing anymore😜
Is the evidence to support #ultraprocessedfood recommendations solid? Or insufficient? Separating passions from objective science is a challenge on this one. The buzz on this at #nutrition2023 is hard to miss.
conscienhealth.org/2023/07/nutrition-2023-will-guidelines…
#asn2023 meet-ups
She tweets, she trains/coaches, she publishes, and now I’ve learned she farms!
Another highlight of the Boston Nutrition conference was meeting Twitter Nutrition maven @NanciGuestRDPhD in person
Meeting a legend, in person #asn2023
After many e-mails and a dual/dueling(?)/mostly-agreeing debate(?) on Simon Hill’s @theproof podcast, I finally got to meet the man, the legend, @mackinprof in person. #bucketlist
Diversity Equity and Inclusion #asn2023
Great morning session on the Battle to End Food Insecurity.
Excellent presentations by @DrBleich, @OdomsYoung and Dr Rafael Pérez-Escamilla
Huge opportunity now to move forward on #foodismedicine according to Sara Bleich
Christopher Gardner reposted
Agree. The UPF approach may be ideal for identifying all potentially risky thing the food industry do when optimizing for profit.
Lower nutrient (higher margins) and more addictive (more revenue) foods result. The exact mechanisms are as yet unknown so "UPF" yes/no may be the best we have?
UPFs may have many false positives, though, and it's too binary.
I believe we need a better approach and we're creating one with input from many experts, based on satiety per calorie.
Let me know if you're ever up for a 15 min chat @GardnerPhD. I'd love to pick your brain and show you what we have.
Plant-based Proteins for Sustainable Diets #asn2023
Thrilled to be on the panel will be presenting today on Plant protein and sustainability.
Joined by the eminent Drs. Privat, Boom and Bloem
Ultra Processed Foods - #asn2023
Excellent talks by Drs. Jones, Mattes & O'Connor!
Overall message was: UPF too confusing, too soon, more data needed
I'm wondering "instead of what?"
5-a-day?
⬇️ sugar/salt/fat?
⬆️ nutrient dense?
I'm interested in trying something different
Energy and Macronutrient Metabolism #asn2023 #boston
Excited to be tonight's speaker at the Energy & Macronutrient Metabolism Research Interest Section event.
7:30-8:30 pm
Location: Constitution A
Low-Fat, Low-Carb, Mediterranean, Ketogenic and more
19th anniversary with my AMAZING wife, @DrMichelsonPhD
Hmmmm….got a year to think of something for #20.
🤔
Another soberingly dead-on perspective from @TamarHaspel
Love the tennis/Serena analogy.
Bristled at the 4% blame assigned to scientists, but I'll take it.
Thanx for the 7% (more than 4%) assigned to media. 🤣
Agreed, that wasn't usually you.
www.washingtonpost.com/food/2023/06/29/obesity-blame-food…
Harvesting home grown potatoes!
Extraordinary spouse, @DrMichelsonPhD (not a Gardner, get it?) grew them in the backyard!
Despite warnings from Dr. Willett, we'll be thoroughly enjoying these tonight.🤣
Potatoes? With what, instead of what?🤔
Topping possibilities endless!😋
Videos available from Stanford Food Summit
www.youtube.com/c/StanfordNutrition
Earlier this year we held campus wide event that drew ~200 attendees from across all 7 schools.
Recorded sessions (~hour each) included:
Plant Based Diet Initiative
Food is/as Medicine
Microbiome
Blue Food
Great session at #ada2023
What fun and what a great honor joining Nutrition Science superstars @KevinH_PhD and Barbara Rolls for our Saturday morning symposium:“Beyond Calories In, Calories Out”
Great insights!
Great science!
Beyond Calories - Am Diab Assoc Session
Looking forward to an engaging and informative session with stellar colleagues Saturday morning in San Diego.
@KevinH_PhD
Barbara Rolls
Saturday morning at #ada2023: Delve into the nuances of diet makeup in diabetes care. Read a preview in ADA Meeting News: www.adameetingnews.org/experts-to-delve-into-the-nuances-… @gardnerphd
Plant-forward suggests mostly plants, but not necessarily exclusively plants…room for some animal-sourced foods.
What does it mean
Lunch at Menus of Change #ciamoc
Unapologetically delicious and plant-forward lunch at the conference today.
Ultra-Processed Food - What is and isn't? Decision tree
The helpful decision tree was the excellent work of lead author on the commentary, the amazing @maya_vadiveloo
Menus of Change - 2023
Thrilled to be here @CIACulinary in Hyde Park, NY / beautiful Hudson Valley for the 2023 #ciamoc
CIA has a new mascot! Meet Sting! 🤣🐝
Awesome Father’s Day!!
Had a great Dad’s day with 2 of our 4 boys. Tough to get all 4 in one place at the same time these days. Happy to get calls from the others. Still lovin’ fatherhood. ❤️
Brilliant François et al.
Rather than a single number, greatly appreciate that you provided ranges in all cases.
The TYPES of plant foods & animal foods play an important role in the projections.
As always, it will also depend on the context of ‘with what’ & ‘instead of what’
Comments welcome if you have time. @GardnerPhD @NutritionMadeS3 @mario_kratz @KevinH_PhD @DrDavidKatz @NanciGuestRDPhD @NicholasDCarter @DBelardoMD @vanvlietphd @theproof @mackinprof @AndreaGlennR @AuneDagfinn and all…
The Proof - In person!
I’ve had the pleasure of joining study-design-obsessed Simon Hill on his podcast several times now - @theproof. This time we met in person. Not photoshopped.😱 I joined him at his LA studio. We covered everything about nutrition!
Can’t wait for episode!
Wrapping up an unparalleled legacy of accomplishments, productivity, growth and impact.
Thanx @HeartBobH
You will be missed!
Many thanks to the many friends and colleagues who have reached out to me today. After 11 wonderful years @StanfordDeptMed @StanfordMed @StanfordHealth Rhonda and I look forward to heading back east for this incredible opportunity @WeillCornell @Cornell More in days ahead!
American Heart Association - fall 2023 conference abstract submissions
ICYMI #aha23 is accepting abstract submissions until June 8. Don't miss this opportunity to have your work published in @CircAHA and discussed by global thought leaders. Submit today @ scientificsessions.org
Stanford Food as Medicine event
Health Matters event at Stanford was huge success last weekend. Congrats to organizers! Thx to attendees.
Honored to join luminaries @GutBugs2 & @ChefInMedicine about diet & the microbiome, & unapologetic deliciousness
scopeblog.stanford.edu/2023/05/25/scientists-talk-aging-m…
Brain Healthy Eating
This looks like it is gunna be GREAT. 🧠
What role does diet play in brain health? Join Annie Fenn, MD, for a free #wellnesswednesday webinar on Brain Healthy Eating: Food vs. Supplement. May 24 @ 11 am PT (also recorded). us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_gascwMvnR4Sp5iY-uFLOyQ
Many published, several underway, and hundreds more to design, submit, conduct, analyze, and publish. Hopefully they will all be finished by…..well, actually…it is an ongoing process.
Many RCT’s will NEVER be done (cost, duration, other feasibility issues)
Not only was this @MarionNestle 's pic, but my son was torn btwn whether graduation ceremony was the highlight of the day, or having his picture taken by, & talking w/, a living legend & one of his all time heroes! 🤩
Thx Marion, for making both of our days!
It was a great day!
That’s my photo! Congratulations!
Proud Father
My oldest son, Colin, @CGardner_2, graduated from the NYU program in Food Studies today. Ceremony was held in Radio City Music Hall. 🤩
So proud!!
Newly minted Food Waste Warrior!
Now with a master’s degree!
Proud Father
My oldest son, Colin, @CGardner_2, graduated from the NYU program in Food Studies today. Ceremony was held in Radio City Music Hall. 🤩
So proud!!
Newly minted Food Waste Warrior!
Now with a master’s degree!
Point well taken
Chris - perhaps write a letter to the editor refuting the claims within the article, rather than tweeting out a disparagement of the authors' transparency? If anything, we should encourage the disclosure of potential conflicts of interest.
Misleading article title
Call it what it is
"Dairy foods, such as milk, cheese, and yogurt, are underconsumed nutrient-dense foods that often fall in the cross-hairs of reductionist nutrition strategies..."
Author disclosures
All authors employed by the National Dairy Council
Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee
2nd in person meeting of DGAC this week.
Committee members are a pleasure to work with - thoughtful, critical, informed group.
HHS/USDA staff supporting the effort are an incredible resource! Wow!
2-year process is off to a great start!
Point well taken
And Ginny, I'm a big fan of yours.
I suspect we agree more than you think.
Just hard to convey in the limited number of characters in Twitter.
Some other day, not today, I'll respond at greater length.
Until then, below is our article on protein:
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30726996/
I'm a big fan of Christopher and his work but I disagree with him on this. I can't assume that a lack of overt protein deficiency means everything is fine.
Shift to more plant-based diet
JAMA Network Viewpoint
"Ultimately, the greatest benefit lies in incremental changes toward increasing unprocessed plant-based food consumption..."
"Physicians can play an important role as advocates for such change."
jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2804889
EAR and RDA are population-based approaches for nutrient needs - not intended for individuals.
Iron - good objective clinical measures, common deficiency.
Calcium - more complicated due to long-term health outcomes, hard to study
Protein - Controversial. But IMO, not a concern
For Protein....
In the US, protein deficiency is rare
I've often asked at medical conferences how many clinicians have veg*ns among patients.
Most raise their hands.
I then ask how many have ever treated a patient for protein deficiency.
After 10 years of asking, none so far.
For Calcium...
Blood levels useless - homeostasis maintained at expense of drawing Calcium from bones.
Osteoporosis is common, but chronic, not acute.
Bone mineral density is helpful, but expensive, and not sensitive to acute dietary change.
Calcium AI got updated to RDA in 2011
Let's start with iron
Clinically, there are a variety of objective measures for iron status
Hemoglobin
Transferrin
Serum Ferritin
& more
Regardless of what someone reports for intake, iron deficiency anemia is common, & easily diagnosed.
Relatively acute onset & acute resolution.
Technically, by definition, 50% of population requires <EAR.
And typically people under report intake (overestimates deficiency?)
Unfortunately we don’t have feasible, accurate, objective metrics for meeting protein intake.
Should be something like maintaining skeletal muscle
Excellent. Congrats MP, and Thanx! 🙏
Final version now available online www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S10870792230004…
Role of carbohydrate quality and quantity on sleep. Need to evaluate carbohydrate to protein ratio; timing of carbohydrate intake relative to sleep for optimal sleep quality.
Lucky UCI!!
Popular Diet Patterns Scientific Statement @American_Heart
👍 DASH, Med, Veg
👎 Paleo & Keto
for aligning w/ AHA Guidelines
Honored to chair 🤩 writing group incl
@maya_vadiveloo
@kspetersen9
@chanders4
@dramitkhera
@cindyluzy
@joshuajosephmd
www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/CIR.0000000000001146
Authors included Drs. Linda Van Horn, Sparkle Springfield & Shawyntee Mayo
Addressed "as intended" vs. "as followed".
ALL diet patterns can be followed in more or less healthy way depending on choices.
All 10 diets promote
⬆️veggies, whole foods
⬇️added sugars & refined grains
Congrats @SeanPaulSpencer
So we’ll deserved!
Gifted physician and researcher!
Woot woot! 👏
Congratulations @SeanPaulSpencer @Stanford_GI @StanfordDeptMed on receiving an @AmerGastroAssn Research Award 🏆
Proud of you!🥳🎊🍾👏🏻
#microbiome #ibs #food #plantbased
@LabSonnenburg @GardnerPhD @WRayKimMD
The key is the pomegranate molasses 😋. Could also add pom seeds just before serving. I usually triple the recipe (=1 med butternut squash, 1 large eggplant or 3 Asian eggplant, 3 8-oz pckgs of tempeh). I mix the glaze w/ squash-eggplant-tempeh in a bowl, then put on baking sheet
Outed (by myself) for my junk food teenage past
Transition started with getting dumped by a vegetarian girlfriend. 💔
Journey to more aspirational and unapologetically delicious food choices chronicled by @American_Heart
www.heart.org/en/news/2023/04/17/this-food-expert-aspires…
Podcasting this 3/22 on Personalized Nutrition
Can't wait to join the incomparable @DuplantierSally once again for another session of amaZING Wellness Wednesday.
Is Personalized Nutrition ready for Prime Time?
Free & Recorded, but you have to register.
us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_n76uZg2mSqSNaqvieW8OWg
Hurray! More honors for Marion!
Thanks so much. Feels like a huge honor!
#epilifestyle23
@StanfordDeptMed postdoctoral research fellows @catepward (Dr Cate Ward) and @TheGuyititian (Dr Matt Landry) dazzled the audience at the NHLBI session with their scientific expertise and fantastic communication skills!
Dr Cate Ward, @catepward did a great job presenting her poster on the TwiNS study at the #epilifestyle23 @American_Heart conference in Boston!
Wow! #epilifestyle23
Opening keynote of the @American_Heart meeting in Boston today was a powerhouse/trifecta of speakers!
Implementation science and moving from policies to action!
These docs rock!
Crystal Wiley Cené, MD, MPH, FAHA
Josiemer Mattei, PhD, MPH
Sara Bleich, PhD
Honored to be selected for the Lyman award.
LOVE interacting with @Stanford alums! Engaged and critical audiences every time.
today.stanfordmedicine.org/member/post/christopher-gardne…
Webinar - Keto vs. Med Study
Is a #keto or #med diet healthier for controlling blood sugar and weight? Learn the results of a recent Stanford clinical trial in a free webinar with Dr. Matthew Landry. Feb. 22nd at 11 am PT (also recorded). us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_Da92wlHnQsmYbmIy2Lni8A
If you ever lose your current job, it’s good to know you’ll have a back-up career! 🤣
Great coverage Allison. Loved the alternate perspectives you covered.
The FDA should hire you for communication training. 🤣
Is #chocolate good for your heart?
Cocoa maker petitioned the @US_FDA to allow health claims on labels .
Here's what the agency concluded. @morningedition
www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2023/02/12/1156044919/c… @GardnerPhD @BrighamWomens @BarryCallebaut @madrechocolate @WorldCocoa @FCIA_org
Unapologetically Delicious!!
Great Ask-Me-Anything on food/cooking/health covered in the Stanford SCOPE blog today.
Rock star physician/Chef Dr. Michelle Hauser, @ChefInMedicine shares wisdom and tips
scopeblog.stanford.edu/2023/02/07/ask-me-anything-diets-c…
It is
Somebody kows if this course is available in Spanish?
If everyone listens to @TamarHaspel, I'll be out of a job running weight loss diet studies 🤣
"What we know is absolutely dwarfed by what we don’t know"
"It’s not a knowing problem...It’s a doing problem, and only you know what to do"
& more pearls...
www.washingtonpost.com/food/2023/01/23/weight-loss-diets-…
Thx Sharon!
I recommend several sources, rather than a textbook.
1. Nutrition Action Healthletter (CSPI)
2. Berkeley Wellness Letter
3. Harvard Nutrition Source
First two have annual subscription rates (very reasonable).
There are others. Start with these three.
Eat well, be well
Hi - I’m not an aspiring doctor or nutritionist. Therefore, I’m betting the tuition for your eight week online mini-course isn’t financially prudent for me. Any suggestions where I can best learn more about nutrition science - a great textbook, for example? Thank you!
Nutrition Myths
Great work @SophieEganM putting this together!
My contribution was STOP OBSESSING ABOUT PROTEIN. All plant foods have all 20 amino acids
Honored to join luminaries like #sarahbleich, @Dmozaffarian, @KatMerrigan, #frankhu & @marionnestle
www.nytimes.com/2023/01/19/well/eat/nutrition-myths.html
Thx Ruth Ann! ❤️
Congrats!
Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee (DGAC)
Thrilled and honored to be selected for the 2025 DGAC.
Looks like an incredible set of colleagues to work with for the next 2 years in preparing for updating the US Dietary Guidelines for Americans.
National Institute of Nutrition
Absolutely with you on this one @JerryMande. We need something independent of the FDA and USDA.
Help start a movement. Please share this call to action. Our food should be delicious, affordable, convenient, and not make us sick. Help us tell @FDAfood @USDAFoodSafety @USDANutrition @DrCaliff_FDA @SecVilsack @POTUS it's time to act. @Nourish_Science
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/01/15/food-is-making…
Christopher Gardner reposted
Here's a fairer example of Food Compass which clearly shows it is a decent system and would improve upon the current US diet. It would promote consumption of fruits, vegetables, legumes, nuts, seeds, whole grains, seafood, and yogurt, and limit consumption of junk foods.
Influencer 🤣
Adding "influencer" to my biosketch.
www.nextavenue.org/christopher-gardner-on-human-nutrition…
Amino acids
Data from USDA on amino acids, across many food groups.
All plant foods contain all 20 amino acids, including all 9 essential amino acids.
The proportions are much more similar than most people had assumed.
Science. Data.
See our paper:
academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/77/4/197/5307079
I’m actually dead. It’s my little secret.
Very effective Simon
Fact check: @jordanbpeterson on the dietary guidelines, carbohydrates and obesity
Precision Nutrition: Ready for Prime Time?
Not yet
But making progress
Honored to give Medicine Grand Rounds @StanfordDeptMed
Need more data. Our studies + @Join_Zoe, NIH Nutrition for Precision Health, +?
Will still need to work on Foundational Diet (Whole Food Plant Based)
Our recent #standom Grand Rounds recording, "Precision Nutrition: Ready for Prime Time?," with Stanford Prevention Research Center's @GardnerPhD, is now available. www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZYWvhRqRIU
Happy to hear that you’ve finished your experiment. Looking forward to your insights. But mostly just happy you can go back to whole foods.
Congrats @deirdre_tobias
Sweat equity and persistence paid off 🥹 long-time passion project is finally funded! Thank you @AmDiabetesAssn!
So excited to work with Drs. @LajousMartin & Dalia Stern on cutting-edge causal inference methods for nutritional epidemiology and T2D prevention.
More to come...
SWAP-MEAT Athlete study published!
Congrats Aubrey Roberts, lead author 🤩
3 arms: 2X/day - meat/alt-meat/vegan
3-way X-over, 4wks/arm
2 groups: runners, resistance trainers
No significant diffs in:
Running for runners
Lifting for resistance trainers
rdcu.be/cZQqS
Milk
Nutritious (compared to what?)
Instead of what?
With what?
For what/who?
Context!
Nice overview from Sandee LaMotte
In our house we have three types: 🤣
Whole milk for teenage boys
Oat milk (unswtnd) for @profmichelson
Soy milk (unswtnd) for me.
edition.cnn.com/2022/11/15/health/best-milk-for-planet-an…
Appreciate your bewilderment.
But one typical bagel was/is 4 serv of grain
Serving size not intuitive
The specific guideline was 6-11 servings (not “up to 11”)
mypyramid.gov was intended to clarify that 11 servings was for large active people & 6 for small inactive
Mediterranean Diet - more than the food...an important component of this is the accompanying lifestyle, which is often overlooked
www.inverse.com/mind-body/mediterranean-diet-secret-science
Congratulations @Charlie_Hoffs and the entire Unbox team!
Thank you for all you do!
And the winners are.......
Dr. Matthew Landry and Dr. Sophia Hua split this year's Ethan Sims Young Investigator Award at the 2022 annual meeting of The Obesity Society #obesityweek22.
Congrats!!
🏆
Hope you get home OK, and soon.
I'm in a rough travel situation. But all I can think about is how blessed I am.
My kids are fine, as my wife is home.
I'll get reimbursed, but if I didn't, I'd still be OK.
Lost items can be replaced.
I truly feel for those who had the exact same issues without these buffers.
Thanx again Hannah!
Question….for the beef burger, is that the sodium level before or after typical seasoning?
Macro nutritional + salt profile of meats and meat substitutes.
Meats in blue. Meat substitutes in yellow.
Very helpful @_HannahRitchie, thanx!
As you note below, some of the micronutrients below for plant-based milks are added/fortified, which is why they are so uniform across the different types.
Cow milk is also typically fortified, with Vit’s A & D.
Since this came up yesterday, I made a quick chart of the nutrition of dairy & plant-based milks 🐄🥜
➙ Soy milk is a good source of protein; other plant-based milks aren't
➙ Plant-based milks have fewer calories & sat fat.
➙ Plant-based milks can have micronutrients added
Fantastic presentation!
Important insights for clinicians and researchers.
Weight loss diets tend to work for ~6 months, and then weight loss plateaus.
Switching diets at that point doesn’t appear to kick start renewed weight loss.
Help patients focus on maintenance!
Dr Matthew Landry
Finalist for the Ethan Sims Young Investigator Award Competition
…getting ready to present his cutting edge research on “Diet Fatigue?” at #obesityweek22 in San Diego.
@TheGuyititian is on the job market. Rock star nutrition scientist! 🤩
This is gonna be good!
Brilliantly thoughtful and thought provoking!
This eater/journalist knows and grows her food!
Thank you @TamarHaspel
www.washingtonpost.com/food/2022/11/01/plant-foods-climate/
The AmaZING Sally Duplantier is hosting a free webinar with Dr. Anna Lembke, author of the NY Times best-seller Dopamine Nation on Nov 2 (also recorded). Learn how to deal with overconsumption in a world filled with high-reward, high-dopamine stimuli. myzinglife.com/upcoming-programs-2022/the-battle-with-com…
Meat 🧵
These 2 adjacent stories on NYT front page today
Intentional?
Bolsonaro ousted (under his watch policies promoted Brazilian rain forest destruction for increasing cattle production)
Detailed full page story on 💰 ties of Dr Frank Mitloehner @GHGGuru to US meat industry
And this from @PaulHawken and Dr. Jonathan Foley @GlobalEcoGuy
It isn't just the EAT Lancet report....there is a great deal of consensus about red meat and exceeding planetary boundaries...not just for GHG, but also for land use, water use, eutrophication (nitrogen, phosphorous) and decreasing biodiversity. In top scientific journals
Last year during COP 26, the importance of reducing methane emissions was highlighted, but the topic of reducing red meat consumption was not only avoided but dismissed!
US consumption influences global consumption
We DO need to reduce the amount of meat consumed in the US!
AND...Thank you @HirokoTabuchi for today's investigative journalism.
www.nytimes.com/2022/10/31/climate/frank-mitloehner-uc-da…
Meat 🧵
These 2 stories adjacent on NYT front page today
Intentional?
Bolsonaro ousted (under his watch policies promoted Brazilian rain forest destruction for increasing cattle production)
Detailed full page story on 💰 ties of Frank Mitloehner @GHGGuru to US meat industry
Mitloehner - a professor in cooperative extension in Department of Animal Science at UC Davis - has a history of challenging statements about the important role/threat of excessive red meat consumption in some countries.
As @matthewhayek from NYU states in the NYT article:
Low-Carb Lowers HbA1c
Lots to like
HbA1c ⬇️ w/ Low-Carb
Compared to: Usual Diet (?!)
Calories & weight: LC << UD
Carbs cut in 1/2 in LC
Added sugars ⬇️⬇️, fiber maintained!! 👍
% fat & protein ⬆️
But grams fat & protein up only modestly
(continued)
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/articlepdf/27977…
I'm always interested in "instead of what". Here participants cut carbs in half (mostly refined grain & added sugars) & DIDN'T replace them w/ (much) fat or protein
Is that low CALORIE diet sustainable? 🤔
Replace low quality carb foods w/ foods of ⬆️ quality carbs OR/AND fats
Mistakes were made 🤣
How #standom's @GardnerPhD took an unconventional path from skiing, surfing & biking in far-flung places to studying #foodsustainability & #nutrition at @StanfordMed --> stan.md/3SnfCvI
Washout duration in a crossover
Sounds good in principle.
What if the endpoint is a blood lipid, or TMAO, or an inflammatory marker?
Do you draw blood & do assessments daily, for every participant, waiting for them to return to baseline? 😱
That obviously wouldn't be feasible.
Eliminating the washout doesn't save money.
That's not the issue.
My issue is....how long?
1 day, 1 week, 2 weeks, 4 weeks, 8 weeks?
Does everyone return to baseline?
No. Never all at once.
If they do, they return to baseline after DIFFERENT amounts of time.
Waiting for our third no-washout crossover to be published. Once we have three, we'll cite them all, and come up with a methodological paper and address this.
Sure...@AJCNutrition is an obvious choice. 🤣
I’m not a fan of washouts. Just finished our third crossover study without a washout. Looked for literature on this, didn’t find much. Thinking of writing a paper on pros and cons of washouts.
"Practically Healthy"
Covered many of our nutrition studies
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/eating-for-optimal-health-d…
Below is teaser video (1 min) of above audio podcast (1 hour) I got to do w/ the wonderful Dr Melina Jampolis, @PHbyDrMelina creator of Practically Healthy podcast
www.dropbox.com/s/lhp4hgst75jjhrg/Dr. Christopher Gardner…
Plant based meat alternatives - Research talk
Looking forward to presenting our findings from the SWAP-MEAT study in this talk today, Thurs Oct 20
Study With Appetizing Plantfood - Meat Eating Alternative Trial: SWAP-MEAT
academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/112/5/1188/5890315
What is the effect of eating plant-based meat instead of animal meat on cardiovascular risk factors? Join Thursday's Science of Alt Protein seminar where Dr. Christopher Gardner will speak about his trial that sought to answer this question. Register 👉 gfi.org/event/the-science-of-alt-protein-plant-based-meat…
Mistakes were made 🤣
I've been outed. My career as a nutrition scientist is the result of a series of unexpected & often unintended shifts.
It all started with a philosophy major @colgateuniv, and getting dumped by a vegetarian girlfriend.
scopeblog.stanford.edu/2022/10/11/unconventional-paths-bo…
Statistical power
Rock star colleagues, Drs @BaiocchiMike & #michaelakiernan put together this awesome overview, complete w/ analogy, & visualization
Bonus Tip: effective pragmatic strategies for design & conduct of sufficiently powered trials, w/out increasing sample size 😱
Do you work with trainees or collaborators who may be in the dark about the importance of statistical power? A new and fun analogy illuminates what they need to know! @BaiocchiMike doi.org/10.1093/aje/kwac019
Did you dance to Tiny Dancer!?
What lies beyond the yellow brick road?
Volleyball mom in the morning. Dancing with @eltonofficial for date night. #farewellyellowbrickroad
#bestlife ❤️🧡💛💚💙💜
Menus of Change University Research Collaborative (#mcurc22)
HUGE shout out to dynamic duo @AllisonRighter & @SophieEganM, co-directors of the 8th annual #mcurc conference held @ U of North Texas
Chefs
Operators
Academics
Administrators
Great food
Great research
11th year of Vegan cafe on Texas campus!
Here in Denton, TX at the 8th annual Menus of Change University Research Collaborative #mcurc2022 annual conference.
Chef Cris Williams runs the wildly popular Mean Greens Café
Go University of North Texas!
Non-milk whey…..Why!?🤦♂️
Non-milk whey? So vegan-friendly...
One of the #whconfhungerhealth accomplishments was getting @marionnestle together with @Vidarreal3! Love it!
I’ve admired @marionnestle since I met her over 20 years ago. Improving the health of the nation. @WhiteHouse #whconfhungerhealth #whcnfsn22 #hunger #nutrition #health
Intellectually interesting
But Simon, rest assured, I won’t be stealing this idea for my next grant proposal.
Recruitment would be challenging…
“Looking for study participants to help us find out which is worse for humans…bad fat or bad sugar. Plz lend us your livers!”🤣
On a calorie for calorie basis, when saturated fat is put head to head with fructose isocalorically what is worse for liver fat accumulation?
Basically a high sat fat diet (low fructose) VS a high fructose diet (low sat fat) matched for calories.
Anyone seen a study like this?
Spectacular!
#watertownway thank you for making my homecoming spectacular. I am honored and amazed at all the wonderful ways you found to honor me.
More options needed
1. Muscular but short life
2. Muscular and long life
3. Long life, but miserable
4. Long life, lived vibrantly
5. All the years you have, lived to their fullest
6. Other
Now, let’s go to the evidence based literature…
Uh oh, no such studies available😱
To build muscles or live longer? What’s the goal here?
Congrats to this great team!
🥹 Floored, honored, SO grateful!
Colleagues and I @MassGenBrigham @HarvardChanSPH were just awarded a U01 by @theNCI to investigate mechanisms of obesity & cancer.
The best part of this program is the collaborations it builds across the funded centers. I cannot wait to begin!
Simon & Stu the conversation we just had was such a pleasure. @mackinprof I’m so respectful & appreciative of your perspective from an exercise science lens. @theproof, love your relentless pursuit of practical, actionable, evidence based nutrition truths.
Much to agree on!
Great episode with @GardnerPhD and @mackinprof on protein.
- Is the RDA an optimal intake?
- Does the average adult consume enough protein?
- What does 'optimal' mean?
- Defining protein 'quality'
- Protein and satiety
and plenty more along the way
Out soon
Visiting Sis in Vermont
My bright & brilliant sister Lisa lives in Norwich, VT. She & her husband Dave live in a beautiful rustic New England home w/ a barn, critters, a huge garden & on 10 acres. I think our entire house AND property in California would fit insider her house😱
Morning run around Boston Commons
Last week at home in California we hit 100+ degrees on multiple days.
Thursday morning, after visiting colleagues at Tufts, went for a run around Boston Commons & the Public Garden.....65 degrees?!?! Beautiful day! Got to say hi to George W.
It is fantastic that that you’ve set this up so we can switch up the denominator. 👍🙏
Tried this.
In general, the trends of animal foods vs plant foods don’t change much.
Animal sourced foods contribute more than plant to domains of planetary boundaries.
Another question I always get is "isn't it better to compare on the basis of protein, or calories, rather than kilograms?"
You can switch these units in our explorer here: ourworldindata.org/explorers/food-footprints
Gershoff Lecture at Tufts
Very excited about giving the annual Gershoff lecture at Tufts later today.
Title: Choose your own Food and Nutrition Adventure: Exhilarating, Boring, or Terrifying
🤣
Honored to be inaugural speaker - Case Western
Thx to the eminent Dr. Sanjay Rajagopalan, Director of Cardiovascular Research Institute at Case Western, @CWRU, for inviting me to be the inaugural speaker for the newly created UH CINEMA speaker series (9-9-22).
Great audience!
There's a new Dr. Gardner in the family!
Sooooo proud!
Dr Jackson Gardner gave his exit seminar for doctoral degree yesterday at UCSF (Cancer Biology).
Rocked it!
Great turnout of mentors, colleagues, friends & family
Now go get a job! 🤣
(He has one - Bain Consulting)
AHA Career Development Award - pointers?
My postdoc @TheGuyititian is seeking some perspective from folks who have submitted an AHA Career Development Award.
Anyone submit one recently and would be willing to chat and share some tips/pointers with him?
There she goes again!
My better half, @profmichelson, has another piece today in @washingtonpost on GOTV - Get Out The Vote.
#savingdemocracy
College students have been voting at record rates. Why? www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/08/30/college-studen…
Great to have rock star 🤩 @TheGuyititian join me on this great interaction with the incomparable @KCKlatt.
BTW… @TheGuyititian is on the job market, after 2 years and DOZENS of publications during his @Stanford postdoc fellowship.
Nutrition Scientist seeks faculty position!
New 'AJCN In Press' just dropped! @kcklatt chats with @GardnerPhD & @TheGuyititian about their recently published #keto vs Med Diet RCT. @nutritionorg #nutrition #metabolism
Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/5XhQNJAFslKwfKi1lOGyKj
Apple:
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ajcn-in-press/id1537760483
Google:
podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5ibHVicnJ5LmNv…
Civil nutrition discourse
Tamar, love this 🧵, and love the shout out to @davidludwigmd for his always civil discourse.
Here are two predictions made by CIM:
1. You will burn more calories with a low-carb diet, compared to a regular-carb diet with the same number of calories.
2. The regular-carb diet will make you hungrier, and drive you to eat more, than the low-carb diet.
Back atcha Dr Aronica. Your input into the design, analysis, and reporting of the trial provided an essential perspective.
Much more to come with the additional papers and studies we are working on together!
Onward!
Thanks @bschermd! I hope my perspective on the #ketomedstudy provided more context and helped people focus on the bottom line: Food can be medicine for #bloodglucose management.
I feel privileged to work with @GardnerPhD and his wonderful team #stanfordmedicine
Our editorial is out today on the paper by Li et al that presents an approach to assess red meat consumption through a blood marker metabolite score
Interesting idea 👇
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35754192/
Is this the direction diet assessment should be moving? 🤔
academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/116/2/295/6613359
Great work by @maya_vadiveloo and @TheGuyititian on the Editorial for @AJCNutrition
Which wasn’t intentional, correct?
You were mistaken about the due date and didn’t realize it until after you hit “submit”🤔😱
Wise commentary @marionnestle
"We cannot expect single interventions to prevent population-based weight gain on their own, but they might help some people—& might help even more people if combined simultaneously w/ other interventions"
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle…
@JAMAInternalMed
Celebrating last day of Farm to Table Camp - 2022
Kids love farm veggies & cooking!
Thanx rock star @Stanford summer camp counselors/field researchers
@sarah_darmstadt
Justin Donohugh
Julie Keipp
Thanx Santa Clara School District camp directors:
Natacha Costa
Carter Stain
Here’s a video peak of camp (~2015) - a 2 min clip from @PBS documentary (In Defense of Food, @MichaelPollan) from @KikimMedia
Check out & subscribe to YouTube Channel for other @GardnerPhD videos
👇
www.youtube.com/c/StanfordNutrition
Alternative Protein Education @Stanford
Great @GoodFoodInst blog about student initiated class on Alt Protein, led by Stanford rock stars 🤩
@ChloeRaygoza
Ellie Fajer
Hannah Huddleston
Gianna Dugan
Made possible by faculty support from
@DavidBLobell
gfi.org/blog/rethinking-meat-helping-students-find-their-…
This is a BRILLIANT overview of Personalized Nutrition by @saraheeberry
Congrats on the Silver Medal Award.
Sooooo well deserved!
Personalised nutrition (PN) – Friend or Foe?
A huge honour to receive the Silver Medal award from @NutritionSoc for my research on PN.
Like it or loathe it PN is here to stay - so how can we do it well?
A thread (13) below summarising my perspective & Silver Medal Lecture:
Well-deserved! Congratulations Rachael!!
Honored & Thrilled - New Role w/ AHA
This month I start my 2 year stint as chair of Nutrition Committee @American_Heart (Lifestyle Council)
Thanx @anne_thorndike for past 2 years of great leadership
Welcome @maya_vadiveloo to vice chair role!
& committee members...
Go team!
Greatly appreciate your call out of the challenges and limitations of human nutrition intervention trials! Thanx @MPStOngePhD / Marie-Pierre!
Elegant study & superb example of honest reporting of challenges/limitations intrinsic to dealing with humans!
Keto-Med Study: Meds
Last Friday, our #ketomedstudy was published in @AJCNutrition.
academic.oup.com/ajcn/article-lookup/doi/10.1093/ajcn/nqa…
We have already tweeted about main results, nutrients, & LDL-size.
Here we discuss the approach that was taken with medications: protocol and statistical analysis
🧵
Metformin & Sulfonylureas
Of the 33 study participants included in the primary analyses, 18 were taking Metformin, & 8 were taking Sulfonylureas.
There were no changes for Metformin during the study.
For Sulfonylureas, a specific protocol differed by diet phase (next).
Sensitivity analyses
4 of our study participants used a different dose of sulfonylurea medication on WFKD vs Med-Plus.
We conducted pre-planned sensitivity analyses to address many possible study design issues, this was one of them. Here is what is reported in our main paper:
Sensitivity analyses
As stated above, these sensitivity analyses (many are provided in the paper) had low power due to the small sample size, and their results should be interpreted with caution.
#ketomedstudy: Nutrient Diffs
In our study we collected a lot of dietary data, primarily to characterize diets & report adherence
In supplemental tables we reported changes in NUTRIENTS on each diet phase
In this 🧵we share the nutrient changes
academic.oup.com/ajcn/article-lookup/doi/10.1093/ajcn/nqa…
Self-Provided Period
Supplement Table 10 from paper
Vitamins, minerals and fiber
Baseline
End of Self-Provided (week #12)
Absolute Standardized Differences (effect sizes) between diets for change from baseline.
~0.2 = small diff
~0.5 = moderate diff
~0.8 = large diff
Self-Provided Period
Change from baseline indicated at least a moderate effect size (>0.5) that favored:
Med-Plus (4) (in blue)
Folate, Vit C, Magnesium, & fiber
WFKD (0)
(See RDA’s, far right, for reference)
Coverage of our #ketomedstudy by Sandee LaMotte @CNN, with input from Drs. Walter Willett, Frank Hu and @sjoshimd
www.cnn.com/2022/07/08/health/keto-mediterranean-diet-sho…
Keto-Med Study: LDL size
Our study published today in @AJCNutrition examined several secondary clinical measures: fasting LDL-C, HDL-C, TG, glucose, insulin, ALT & weight
Most significant diffs:
LDL-C better for Med
TG better for Keto
🧵 LDL-size
academic.oup.com/ajcn/article-lookup/doi/10.1093/ajcn/nqa…
As covered in 2017 American Heart Association Presidential Advisory, subsection titled "LDL sizes"
Conclusion: "...this sparse set of
findings suggests replacement of saturated w/
mono- or polyunsaturated fat reduces the
concentration all sizes of LDL."
www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/cir.0000000000000510
In our conclusion, we expressed concern over elevated LDL-C.
We acknowledge that concomitant drop in TG suggests mitigation of some of that concern.
But I still consider a drop in BOTH LDL-C and TG to be a better clinical outcome (Med-Plus).
To be continued….
Keto-Med Study – Main results
Thrilled our paper was accepted by @AJCNutrition.
Online version released today.
Open Access – free for all
Brief overview here 🧵
(Separate tweets will be sent out to address likely questions/comments, see end of 🧵)
academic.oup.com/ajcn/article-lookup/doi/10.1093/ajcn/nqa…
Keto-Med – Weight change
In Phase I (first 12 wks), WFKD weight loss was greater than Med-Plus
But from week #16 on, weight loss was similar and maintained through week #36, regardless of diet order
...and maintained out to week #36 👏
Keto-Med – Follow-up adherence
12-weeks after completing both diet phases (week #36), sustainability/maintenance of Keto (WFKD) was lower than for Med-Plus
Keto-Med – Comments/concerns
In separate tweets we will address several anticipated comments/criticisms
-Medication changes
-Nutrient intake differences
-LDL-C increase w/ TG decrease
-CGM data
Open to additional commentary/suggestions
Most importantly, ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
How rewarding and fun to work with
👏TEAM AWESOME👏
Including:
@TheGuyititian
@dalita
@LuciaAronica
@anniechang215
@sunkimmd
Holiday weekend reading
Thank you @TamarHaspel!
Delightful
Insightful
Engaging
Entertaining
Educational
Fun and Funny
And makes me really want to meet Kevin! 🤣
Justice Elena Kagan writing the dissent...
“The Court appoints itself — instead of Congress or the expert agency — the decisionmaker on climate policy. I cannot think of many things more frightening.”
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/06/30/supreme-court-…
"...the editors of the New England Journal of Medicine strongly condemn the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision".
"...reversal of Roe v. Wade serves American families poorly, putting their health, safety, finances, and futures at risk."
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMe2208288
Deriving and validating scores based on plasma metabolites for types of meat consumption
C Li et al did this 👇
doi.org/10.1093/ajcn/nqac143
Phenom colleagues @maya_vadiveloo & @TheGuyititian
& I wrote an invited @AJCNutrition editorial.
Whadya think?
academic.oup.com/ajcn/advance-article/doi/10.1093/ajcn/nq…
Bucket list, or time to retire now? 🤣
This is ... ahem ... my first academic journal citation.
I have arrived.
jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/article-abs…
Happy Father's Day!
Hope all you fathers had a great day yesterday.
Three (of 4) sons made FD dinner: Tofu and Green Beans with Chili Crisps, and Spicy Mango Wraps (nut paste, mangos, jicama, bell peppers & carrots) in red cabbage leaves.
It's good to be a father!
Thanx sons!
Gastronomically Orgasmic
Bento box lunch today at the 2022 Menus of Change Conference in Hyde Park, NY @CIACulinary was incredible. Ate unapologetically delicious creations overlooking a pond/fountain/waterfall on their beautiful campus.
Great speakers. Great content
#moc2022
Powerful challenge by @Dmozaffarian to reconsider assumptions about root causes of the obesity epidemic.
Suggests solutions should/need not address what we (falsely?) assume to be causes. 🤯
Food production & consumption: shift to healthy planet focus?!
academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/115/6/1445/6572830
At the #ada2022 session today on “How Plant-Based should people with diabetes go?” Lauren Plunkett - author and dietitian (RDN, CDES) - wants our new favorite “F” word to be Fiber. 🤣
Plant-based diets for Diabetes
Live tweeting from #ada2022
Dr. Qi Sun is defining what TYPES of plant based diets are good for diabetes…..differentiating “healthy” from “unhealthy” plant based foods.
Dr. Kim Williams is starting his #ada2022 presentation now in #nola
Plant-based diets for Diabetes
Seats still available. Room 355
Just How Plant-Based Should People with Diabetes Go?
That's the title of our 4 pm panel today for #ada2022 in #nola.
@cardio10s (Dr. Kim Williams)
-Mechanisms underlying
Dr. Qi Sun
-The Case for
Lauren Plunkett, RDN, CDES - book author
-Tips & Strategies
Me
-Protein issues
Personalized Nutrition
Free Community Event @StanfordMed
Looking forward to leading off Health Matters talks, Sat morning, May 14, 10 am PT
👇
med.stanford.edu/health-matters.html
Can’t join in person? Register to join livestream. Broadcasting Health Talks live.
👇
www.eventleaf.com/e/stanford-healthmatters
Stanford Food Inno - TODAY
Thrilled to be giving the opening Keynote on "Food and Sustainability" @Stanford, for the Food Innovation conference.
👇
www.foodinno.org
Incredible lineup of speakers today, including:
@segal_eran
@RobertLustigMD
@SeanPaulSpencer
more....
...more fabulous speakers for today's conference....
Almost instant gratification….
Prior to #dietfits we did a pilot study with n=60 to develop our “limbo/titrate/quality approach to healthy low carb and healthy low fat. It was a crossover!!
We published the first phase as a parallel design pilot study.
About to submit X-over!
Hey, @GardnerPhD, want to do a DIETFITS followup that has a cross-over halfway through? 😀
Nutrition Security
Proud & honored to be vice-chair of writing group for this @American_Heart policy statement out in @CircAHA today
👇
www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/CIR.0000000000001072
🤩writing group:
#drannethorndike (chair)
@HilarySeligman
#drmarleneschwartz
@AmyYaroch
#drkendraivy
& more
More 🤩 co-authors:
#drkatherinebishopkendrick
#drstephaniescarmo
#drcareejacksoncotwright
#draldringomez
Happy Mother's Day!!
3 out of 4 sons were home for a fabulous Mother's Day Dinner extravaganza. New York was a bit far to travel from this year for our oldest, @CGardner_2, but Melissa and Colin connected earlier in the day.
Whatta woman!
Magnificent MOM!
Protein Quality Criteria
In our 2019 Perspective in Adv Nutr
"Public Health Case for Modernizing the Definition of Protein Quality"
@DrDavidKatz, myself & others propose:
Bioavailability
Amino Acid Distribution
AND
Overall food quality
Environment
👇
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6743844/
Food Truths Webinar - Weds April 27
Looking forward to a healthy discussion about the type of diet that is simultaneously healthy for people & for the planet.
I'm honored to be a panelist for this discussion moderated by @DrDavidKatz
Join here: 👇
us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_hLLzgMW_RwOBRQhhdUifeg
This is gonna be GREAT!
How the Microbiome Affects your Health & Ways to Optimise it- with Drs. ... youtu.be/-dfHUc04XyU via @YouTube
Cc:
@GutBugs2 @StanfordMed @GardnerPhD
Nutrition Myths & More
Dr @ruthadewuyamd is an amazing moderator. We cranked through:
Stealth Nutrition
Is a calorie always a calorie?
Teaching Kitchen for Med Students
Farm to Table summer camp
Unapologetic Deliciousness
& more
🎙️Stream now medcast.stanford.edu
Episode 39
NEJM - Time Restricted Eating
Brief critique 🧵
Solid design, conduct & reporting for question asked.
Wuzzit the right question?
They ask "After imposing & achieving 25% calorie restriction, is it additionally useful to ADD TRE?"
It was not.
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2114833
More...
I find TRE "interesting" - intuitively appealing, but also a bit frightening.
Appealing - TRE approach is simple to understand &, for some, easy to follow
Frightening - Seems to be little concern about QUALITY of food being consumed. Eat whatever you want, in this window.
Most studies answer one question, & lead to many more. I'd like to see:
a.
TRE only vs.
Calorie Restriction (CR) only
b.
CR only vs.
TRE only vs.
QUALITY only (e.g. #dietfits - no prescribed energy restriction)
c. Combinations (none of 3 above in "b" are mutually exclusive)
Here is @ginakolata closing out her @NYTimes coverage
www.nytimes.com/2022/04/20/health/time-restricted-diets.html
of the new Time Restricted Eating study publication in @NEJM this week
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2114833
With a classic closing quote from @ethanjweiss
🤣🤣🤣
Wondering what @ethanjweiss thinks of baseline eating window of new NEJM paper on TRE?
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2114833
I'm thinking starting at baseline of 10-1/2 hours & going to 8 hours is a modest change (too modest to have an impact?).
Is study in China generalizable to U.S.?
Nutrition Study Recruitment
Need IDENTICAL TWINS in California Bay Area (San Fran/San Jose)
Randomized trial - Vegan vs Omnivorous diet
4 wks food delivery
4 wks you are on your own for food.
You get microbiome & blood results.
2-3 wks left to join 👇
med.stanford.edu/nutrition/research/current-studies/twins…
Tonight, today, or this morning…
It will be morning or mid day for anyone in the Americas.
10 am Pacific time for me, @GardnerPhD, @StanfordMed 🤣
Looking forward to it. 👍😎
Food & Sustainability
On March 2nd I had the honor of presenting a Keynote to open up #epilifestyle22 annual council meeting of @American_Heart Assoc. in Chicago.
It was not recorded.
I went ahead & made a recording 👇
www.youtube.com/watch?v=V36nzfPUcnk
35 min (or 17-1/2 @ 2X speed)🤣
What diet is best for YOU?
Had a blast discussing nutrition science & some of the opportunities & challenges around "personalized nutrition" w/ the engaging @KZelmanRD who's been a leader in communicating nutrition science for many years! @TrueHealthINIT
www.truehealthinitiative.org/christopher-gardnerpersonali…
Altered reports and recommendations
Similar to the 2015 Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee recommending a shift to plant-based diets...
health.gov/sites/default/files/2019-09/Scientific-Report-…
...but this never making it into 2015 Dietary Guidelines after Sec'ty of USDA nixing it.
www.wsj.com/articles/BL-WB-53714
One detail: The initial IPCC report summary recommended that consumers shift to plant-based diets and reduce their intake of meat, according to a draft seen by Reuters.
But the final version instead recommended balanced diets that include sustainably produced animal products.
Followed by the Trump administration, for the first time in its history, limiting the scope of the 2020 DGAC to predetermined topics (i.e., don't talk about connections between food and the environment).
WTF?! 🤯
www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/08/30/how-trump-admi…
Amazing writing group!
...diet consisting predominantly of fruits, vegetables, legumes, nuts, seeds, plant protein & fatty fish...
...while reducing consumption of foods with saturated fat, dietary cholesterol, salt, refined grain, & ultra-processed food intake
Thx @DBelardoMD
This weekend at #acc22 it was such an honor to present on nutrition & share our new paper "Practical, Evidence-Based Approaches to Nutritional Modifications to Reduce Atherosclerotic Cardiovascular Disease: An ASPC Clinical Practice Statement" www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S26666677220001…
Satellite imagery shows the Amazon rainforest is being destroyed at a frightening pace, largely driven by making room for cattle grazing and growing feed for livestock.
Join the @TrueHealthINIT and take this challenge.
Could you avoid beef for one week?
What if the survival of the Amazon rainforest depended on it?
As consumers we have the power to influence the demand. Use your voice, vote with your food dollar and take the #nobeefweek Challenge this April 18th - 24th 🌱
Oh Tamar......🤣
Oooh! Oooh! Can you get a third with the position that we don't have a clue and also have no way to figure it out?
Great Protein Debate?
BTW...congrats on Canada & World Cup!
⚽️🏅
As I work on my end of proposal, I want to be sure we agree on what we disagree on. 🤣
I think we agree more than disagree.
Here are my main points:
(is there enuf there to disagree on @mackinprof ?) 🤔
Perhaps a "Great Debate" worth of @AJCNutrition? Dr. Gardiner argues the RDA is sufficient and everyone's getting enough. Me: the RDA is an underestimate, many are getting enough, but not all 😉what do you say? @deirdre_tobias and @davidludwigmd perhaps you can convince the EIC?
Same here....will work on it. 👍
Will do!
I’m in! 👍😎
@davidludwigmd ?
@deirdre_tobias ?
Perhaps a "Great Debate" worth of @AJCNutrition? Dr. Gardiner argues the RDA is sufficient and everyone's getting enough. Me: the RDA is an underestimate, many are getting enough, but not all 😉what do you say? @deirdre_tobias and @davidludwigmd perhaps you can convince the EIC?
Great thread @mackinprof.
Thanx for the citations.
Between minimal requirement and optimal intake of protein, as is true for many nutrients, which we don’t know! But, there are multiple lines of evidence showing that even the RDA is inadequate; so, perhaps time to stop using it as kind of bar to reach or intake to target? 11/12
Agreeing on two counts
1-Protein in animal foods has dist'n of amino acids MORE similar to human needs than plant food
2-Animal protein MORE bioavailable
Key question: HOW MUCH MORE?
Answer: Not so much
Plant protein quality is higher & more biovailable than most people think
The biggest flaw in your argument is that you belive the protein quality ( i.e. bioavailability) of meat is the same as vegetables. Biology is way more complicated than the math formula..
👍
"the IAAO, which suggests an optimum about 50% higher, ranging from 0.93g (EAR) or 1.2g (RDA) for moderately active adults to about 2g (RDA), or even more, for heavy athletes."
From multiple papers I have, most mod active adults ALREADY get >1.2g, & most heavy athletes get >2.0
Take a look at this page with some of the IAAO studies and corresponding recommendations :
anthropogoniques.com/protein-quantitative-requirement/
Great question.
If we submit grant proposal, do you wanna be co-author/investigator? 🤣
Let's say 2,400 Kcal/day is quality diet (sure we could come to relative consensus), I don't think the last 100 Kcal would make a diff.
& I think response would differ by individual.
I think they should, and I think most do.
But more importantly, I think a vegan diet (more specifically, WFPD) has many benefits (weight management, chronic diseases) that outweigh concerns about protein intake.
Sure.
Simple version.
Don’t worry about protein.
Eat a whole food plant based diet with reasonable variety and minimal junk food.
Not rocket science.
EAR for adults = 0.66 g/kg body weight/ day
RDA = 0.8
Doesn’t change above age 18.
Many believe RDA should be higher for “older” adults
Proposed 1.0 g/kg/day
Where can I find the EAR and RDA for different age groups (or, for mine, 35 year old woman)
PROTEIN MATH GAME
I believe most people who have access to a reasonably diverse diet get ⬆️⬆️ protein than the RDA, especially athletes.
Do you?
Simple math
How much do you weigh?
Doubly-labeled water
% Protein in diet
@mackinprof – please check my math
Wanna play?
Example of elite/extreme athletes, caloric intake, & protein intake.
@TRotto53 was the TA for my Human Nutrition class at Stanford back in 2015 and 2016. He was also on the Stanford football team that went to the Rose Bowl in 2016.
At that Kcal level, easy to go >2.0 g/kg/day
Back to @ScepticalDoctor & vegans.
Let's say they only get 12.5% protein (I assume higher, but let's go with that).
& they are maintaining weight, at least 2,000 kcal (doubly-labeled water)
2,000 X 12.5% = 62.5 g protein
~150 lbs (68 kg)
=0.92 g/kg
>RDA
>>EAR
Protein math
Thanx for this resource!
apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/43411/WHO_TRS_93…
The World Health Organization says we should get 0.66 g/kg per day of protein. Which is 45 grams per day for a 150 pound person. And vegans eat around 70 grams per day. (I believe strict vegetarian means vegan in this study).
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6893534/
I've been trying to take lessons from you Deedee!
I just wanted to say that I’m super proud of you for developing such a solid GIF game, Dr Gardner.
Great question. I don’t know of anyone who has addressed that one yet.
The original studies from >50 years ago were intense. Had to wear hazmat-like suit all day, collect sloughed off skin, poop and pee….anything w/ nitrogen leaving the body - nitrogen balance studies.
Additional question - does RDA differ at all if one is eating a plant-exclusive diet based on minimally or unprocessed plant foods?
I’ve seen people question the original nitrogen balance studies.
Cc @mackinprof
Agreed, and we DON’T want that.
That is why RDA’s were targeted at maintaining lean mass.
Weight lost for #dietfits was greater at 6m than for #atoz, and better sustained. But in #dietfits, rather than reading popular weight loss diet books (as we did in #atoz), we emphasized choosing a HEALTHY low-fat and a HEALTHY low-carb.
Below is from supplement table, JAMA 2018
Here are #atoz results for weight loss.
Largely maintained, although weight was coming back on fastest for Atkins group, which had lost the most weight at 6 months
Sensible, and practical question.
WFPB diets should easily provide enuf protein to maintain nitrogen balance.
For more info than I have been able to provide today, consider:
@NimaiDelgado
@F_Mariotti_FR
@Drgarthdavis (Protein-aholic book)
It is relevant because of the pervasive MYTH that plant foods are MISSING (as in, completely) some of the 9 essential amino acids and therefore to obtain all of the AA's you need you would HAVE TO eat animal foods.
Why is this AA profile relevant here? Chicken has like 7-10x more protein per serving than brown rice.
There is the relevant issue of "limiting" amino acids in plant foods relative to animal foods. But they aren't missing.
Grains have a low proportion of lysine
Legumes have a low proportion of methionine/cysteine
But this only matters if your overall protein intake is very low.
Vegans eat the least protein.
That doesn't mean they don't eat enough protein.
The RDA does not reflect individual requirement.
Here is a brief RDA tweetorial.
>50 years ago, individual protein requirements were assessed in rigorous studies.
Requirements ranged...
Vegetarians should have no trouble meeting and exceeding their individual requirement.
Vegans need to be more conscious, but should not have a problem provided they have access to a reasonably diverse diet.
Even vegan body builders?
Ask @NimaiDelgado
vegnews.com/2017/6/vegan-bodybuilders-win-32-medals-at-20…
There is an important follow-up question.
When the RDA was established, what metric was being used for "requirement"?
Longevity?
Prevention of cancer or heart disease?
Nope.
Maintaining lean muscle mass.
Is that minimal, or optimal?
That will have to wait for another day.
??
No causal inferences we’re made.
To what are you referring?
The point being made was that across multiple observations from multiple studies, protein intake remained remarkably constant despite attempts to change it, or in the face of large shifts in fat and carbs.
That’s all
All plant foods contain all 20 amino acids AND all 9 essential amino acids.
High vs. Low Protein
A few wks ago, @ScepticalDoctor & @theproof brought up this ??. I was too busy @ the time, & it's a tough topic - limited base of quality evidence to draw from.
Got more time now.
Time for a protein tweetorial?
For starters, how high is "high"?
g? %?
The real reviewers agreed that 15% vs. 25% was an appropriate choice.
That was what they tried to implement
Design is one thing.
Implementation is another.
Adherence can be challenging in human studies.
At the end of 2 years, whadya think the ACTUAL protein intake levels were?
According to the extensive dietary assessment methods they used, the actual difference at the end of 2 years was JUST 20% vs. 21%
At that level of differentiation, they actually couldn’t test their hypothesis as to whether “low” vs. “high” was better for weight loss.
Agreed?
And just a few weeks ago, @sguyunet shared the impressive graphic from USDA ERS data showing that while fat and carb intake underwent notable changes from 1909-2006, protein intake levels were stunningly stable.
So here is my “avoid-the-real-question” response to @scepticalDoctor and @theproof regarding low vs. high protein.
Moot point: In general, people consume very similar amounts of protein
MOST people don’t/can’t achieve & SUSTAIN meaningfully diff levels of protein
Feedback?
Ethical drawbacks of sustainable meat choices
An thoughtful and thought provoking piece published in #science yesterday by my friend and colleague Dr. Maya Mathur from @StanfordMed
www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abo2535
Is he recommending protein restriction for general population, or vegans?
In our 2019 paper, we modeled 25% decrease in protein, and 25% shift from animal to plant protein, for GENERAL POPULATION
Trying to maximize health & lower GHG emissions & H2O use
doi.org/10.1093/nutrit/nuy073
Healthy diet➡️metabolic benefits
Recent trial finds more berries, veggies, fish, whole grains, low fat dairy, & rapeseed oil ➡️ metabolic benefits
Predictable. What's new?
Authors say unique contribution is finding benefits w/o weight loss
🤔 Disagree
www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/nordic-diet-may-improve…
#cantthankyouenough
3 yrs ago I met @Charlie_Hoffs & Benji Reade Malagueno as @Stanford frosh. They helped w/ new HumBio14 class: Connections btwn Food & Environment
Then they helped LEAD class for 5 more quarters!
Celebrated w/THANK YOU dinner we made together
Recipes follow
GREEN SALAD W/ WHATEVER WAS IN THE FRIDGE
Mixed greens
Red bell pepper
Carrots
Celery
Radishes
Garbanzo beans
Greek olives
Avocado
Cashews
Flaming Fig dressing (Tuscan Olive Oil [cayenne, garlic oil, basil oil] w/ Mission Fig Balsamic Vinegar (Palo Alto Farmers Market, Big Paw)
Wash down with homemade Mango-Raspberry Kombucha
Early Gray
Coconut Oolong
Pan-Fried Sencha Green
Ferment with SCOBY for 1 week
Finished with mango & raspberry
Ferment for another week
Inspired by @GutBugs2 and @LabSonnenburg
Sigh....#wfpb Nirvana
Unapologetically Delicious
Thanks! I was hoping responses would include new sources to consider.
I’ll compare Friends of the Earth Report with Oxfam report to try to understand reasons for differences.
🙏
It Depends - Coffee vs Tea
I'm working on a book. One of the chapters will be Coffee vs Tea.
Thought it would be fun to preview some of the content. I'll try turning this into a Tweetorial. (17 in 🧵)
Several polls, several fun facts.
Are you a coffee or a tea drinker?
A 2017 meta-analysis in BMJ concludes coffee is probably healthy.
There is obviously a dose issue.
The conclusion is 3-4 cups/day is optimal.
RCT's lacking.
Who's gonna agree to be randomized to drink it or avoid it for several decades?!
Not me.
Don't hold your breath for RCT.
A 2019 meta-analysis in Mol Nutr Food Res concludes tea is probably healthy.
There's obviously a dose issue
Conclusion is 2-3 cups/d is optimal
RCT's lacking
Who's gonna agree to be randomized to drink it or avoid it for several decades?!
Not me.
Don't hold your breath for RCT
Possibly helping with the eco-warrior claims and issues, there are various labels used for coffees and teas.
In the book I discuss a bit about verification, use, and cost.
16/17
For final conclusion you'll have to buy the book (if I ever finish writing it). 🤦♂️
Is Coffee or Tea "Better"?
IT DEPENDS!
With what?
Instead of what?
What dose?
Purpose of the book is to show that controversial nutrition topics are much less so after considering proper CONTEXT.
They were wearing CGM’s.
This was the 1st study we used them for; we listed CGM data as exploratory. One of our reviewer’s held us to downplaying findings due to exploratory nature.
Revise and resubmit is under review. 🤞
Coauthor @sunkimmd may do separate secondary CGM paper
Hey @GardnerPhD
1) were they wearing CGMs
2) where are the results
Thanks in advance clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT03810378
Amazon deforestation: Record high destruction of trees in January
www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-60333422
"Strong global demand for agricultural commodities such as beef and soy beans is fueling...illegal clearances"
Take action!
Join #nobeefweek
nobeefweek.org
Share w/ wild abandon
Shout out to @bfrist @JeromeAdamsMD & @JerryMande
for call out to FDA Commissioner Califf to put the "F" back in FDA.
"...FDA uses just 7% of its food-related budget to protect Americans from processed-food driven chronic illnesses"
www.statnews.com/2022/03/14/commissioner-califf-needs-to-… via @statnews
GREAT HUGE NEWS for ending Hunger in America.
Related - It will be very timely when a paper led by Dr. Anne Thorndike comes out from the American Heart Association on "Nutrition Security".
Be on the lookout. 👀
Should be out soon.
HUGE NEWS: The government funding package @POTUS Biden signed into law today includes $2,500,000 I secured to make a White House conference on Food, Nutrition, Health & Hunger a reality!
This is a transformational moment in our movement to #endhungernow.
I recommend you decline.
In 2019 she debated @DrDavidKatz.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=1qDYl4zHmAg
I found it very frustrating.
She misrepresented the science multiple times.
I tweeted ~10 inaccuracies coming from her (6-6-19).
If you do it, arrange for a panel to provide instant fact checking.
I've had several messages in the past week asking me to moderate a debate between @sguyenet and @bigfatsurprise.
Would you like to listen to (or watch) this?
Seeking Academic Cardiologist
Assistant Professor Level
Stanford
Interested candidates should submit a curriculum vitae and statement of research interests, and the names of three references, to Dr. Christopher Gardner, Search Committee Chair at facultyapplication.stanford.edu
Thanx Stephan!
Thought you might be interested in this @GardnerPhD
This is based on the same data as above.
There are some assumptions underlying this, one of which is that the jump in reported fat intake between 1999 and 2000 should be treated as an artifact & removed.
Yes @TamarHaspel, you are right!
I'm close to finishing the book (been saying that for a while🤦♂️).
Mock cover below
Finished:
Intro
GMO
Organic
Cholesterol
Sugar vs Substitutes
Protein: Animal vs Plant
Coffee vs Tea
What do I eat?
One chapter to go:
Milk: Dairy vs Alt-Dairy
"It depends," amirite?
Hard to pick which is most interesting here
-protein constant for a century (slight increase lately)
-carbs 1,400 in 1910, 1,100 in 1970, back to 1,400 in 2000
-fats relatively steady increase from <800 to >1,000
Painfully obvious, there was NEVER a LOW-FAT period.
(continued)
Since there's so much interest in this, I'm also posting the graph of absolute macro intakes below.
Data are from the USDA ERS, adjusted for loss at a rate of 28.8%. I also removed an artifact in the fat reporting data that causes an abrupt jump in 2000.
www.ers.usda.gov/data-products/food-availability-per-capi…
Percent vs grams
Btwn 1980 & 2000, grams of fat intake ⬆️slightly, grams of carb intake went from ~1,100 kcal ➡️ >1,400 kcal/day 😱
Total kcal ⬆️
% fat ⬇️, grams fat ⬆️
% carbs ⬆️, grams carbs ⬆️⬆️
"Low-Fat" 1980's messaging did not ➡️ ⬇️ fat,
but did ➡️ ⬆️carbs
(continued)
Since 2,000, the elephant in the room has been pastries! (or, to be more specific, refined grains, added sugars, mocha-frappa-crappa-cino, etc).
US Diet
~10% high quality carbs
~10% animal protein
~5% plant protein
~10% each, sat fat, mono, poly
>40% low quality carbs!! 😱
Must be a meeting in Portlandia?
#wcps22 mentoring lunch
This is brilliant Tamar. Thank you! 🙏❤️
What should you eat?
For human health?
For planetary health?
For animal welfare?
Food is all trade-offs, all the time. Might be good for you, bad for the planet. Or good for the planet, bad for the animal.
Here are 8 trade-offs in a handy dandy 🧵
Not controlled
Not matched
Would you control &/or match?
Meats have no carbs.
To match, need to add carbs to the meat phase.
➡️no longer just a meat containing omnivorous diet, but one w/ extra carbs
You’d have to add protein (powder?) to vegan.
Izat what you want to compare?
Are macronutrients controlled?
It is all clear now! 🤣
This is the "low-fat diet" that supposedly caused the US obesity epidemic
Yes, 6 orders, 4 participants in each order.
And the four in each order were
1 woman runner
1 woman resistance trainer
1 man runner
1 man resistance trainer
22 of 24 completed all 3 phases
Very interesting.
Did you randomise the order of the diets too?
I can imagine the cumulative effect of each diet depending on the order applied may be a confounder.
The question we were asking was the one you framed @NanciGuestRDPhD
Study completed, almost ready to submit:
12 runners, 12 resistance trainers.
Ave ~5 yrs continuous recreational workouts
12 women, 12 men
3 diets, 4 wks each, X-over
2 servings/day of:
-meat
-plant-based meat
-vegan (legumes/nuts/grains)
Performance outcomes
Coming soon!
Study completed, almost ready to submit:
12 runners, 12 resistance trainers.
Ave ~5 yrs continuous recreational workouts
12 women, 12 men
3 diets, 4 wks each, X-over
2 servings/day of:
-meat
-plant-based meat
-vegan (legumes/nuts/grains)
Performance outcomes
Coming soon!
Complementary proteins are moot if total protein consumption is substantially higher than RDA, which it usually is, even for vegetarians.
Ultraprocessed
Dr. Alice Lichtenstein gave the Kritchevsky lecture this morning @ the AHA #epilifestyle22 in Chicago. Great content.
One of her points that has come up again & again at this meeting is confusion re: definition of "ultra-processed".
Hot Topic - to be continued
Christopher Gardner reposted
Food Sustainability & Environmental Health
#epilifestyle22
Thrilled to be giving Keynote at this year's Am Heart Epi/Lifestyle council meeting in Chicago
IN-PERSON. LIVE. 🤯
This was the last academic conference I attended before all live conferences stopped in March 2020! 🤯
Farewell Jane Brody.
Jane joined the NY Times as a health and science writer in 1965 (when I was 6 years old). The Personal Health column has been running since 1976 - 46 year run! Wow!
It's been an informative ride! Thanks! 🤔👏🙏♥️
www.nytimes.com/2022/02/21/well/health-advice-diet-smokin…
Lucky attendees! @GutBugs2 (Justin Sonnenburg) will surely dazzle you with microbiotic insights and wisdom!
Join us for the 4th annual Harvard Chan Microbiome in Public Health Center Symposium on May 16, 2022! The symposium is VIRTUAL, registration is FREE, and our speaker lineup is AWESOME! Please RT - more info, registration, and abstract submission here: hcmph.sph.harvard.edu/hcmph-symposium/
Hannah has these as per kg of food, AND per 100 G protein, AND per 1,000 kcal. That is part of the elegance and usefulness of her work. I’m sure there can be a rationale for each one. Different units for different purposes. She’s got it covered.
Thanx again @_HannahRitchie
Do you think kgs is the correct measure for assessing food impacts @GardnerPhD? If so would you be able to say why?
Great sharing of these incredible Our World In Data resources from @_HannahRitchie. Many of these are interactive. Sources are cited.
Thanx @NanciGuestRDPhD
Food Sustainability & Environmental Health
#epilifestyle22
Thrilled to be giving Keynote at this year's Am Heart Epi/Lifestyle council meeting in Chicago
IN-PERSON. LIVE. 🤯
This was the last academic conference I attended before all live conferences stopped in March 2020! 🤯
This...today 👇
This should be good!
@DrDavidKatz
@drmaggarwal
@heartcuredoc
& Cole Adam RD (@the.eco.dietitian)
Registration here: 👇
us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_w0kHioEvTzOW9SirqqGR4w
More webinars listed on the main website here: 👇
www.dietid.com/foodtruthswebinar
Diet & Microbiome
Always great to talk w/ @Plant_proof about hot topics in nutrition.
This time, I had the privilege of joining the brilliant master of microbiology, author of "the Good Gut", and fabulous fermenter, Dr Justin Sonnenburg, aka @GutBugs2 from @LabSonnenburg
We are on the edge of our seats @SeanPaulSpencer waiting for the microbial illumination that will start in ~1 hour
Izit the bugs or the brine?!
Or both?
Izit the fiber or the fermented foods!?
Or both?
Is it delicious? YES! In your hands it is!
I'm excited to present at the @CIACulinary Healthy Kitchens, Healthy Lives conference today about using diet to promote gut microbiome health #ciahkhl.
🔑 = Fiber+Fermented foods help gut bugs thrive 🥑🍇 🥛🥗
👩🍳🧑🍳 & 👨⚕️👩⚕️cooking & learning together
@LabSonnenburg @Stanford_GI
This should be good!
@DrDavidKatz
@drmaggarwal
@heartcuredoc
& Cole Adam RD (@the.eco.dietitian)
Registration here: 👇
us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_w0kHioEvTzOW9SirqqGR4w
More webinars listed on the main website here: 👇
www.dietid.com/foodtruthswebinar
Protein Rant
This Thursday I get another chance to replay my Protein Rant for ~500 physicians coming to Napa for #hkhl22
Scientific/clinical talks interchange w/ cooking demos & hands-on activities
Lecture-Chop-Season-Cook-Taste...Repeat 🔃
Stop obsessing about protein
👍@maya_vadiveloo et al
"...importance of advances toward progressing field of dietary assessment & discusses application of food purchasing data, data analytics, alternative dietary quality metrics, & -omics technology in population & clinical medicine.
academic.oup.com/advances/advance-article/doi/10.1093/adv…
AHA Conference
Join me at #epilifestyle22 for breakthrough science on food sustainability, the environment and cardiovascular health! Register before 2/1 to receive early bird pricing: professional.heart.org/en/meetings/epi-lifestyle
Courageous, inspiring and informative. Wishing you a speedy recovery, and a long and meaningful life
Food/Ag and Climate Change
Fantastic panel presentation today on connections between food and climate change at the 2022 Plant Futures Symposium #plantfutures2022
Great perspectives and data from:
@matthewhayek (NYU)
@JRanganathanWRI (WRI)
Peter Newton (U Colorado, Boulder)
Looks very well insulated 🤣
I'm recording the audiobook for TO BOLDLY GROW this week.
Welcome to my sound studio.
Yes!
SCUSD/Stanford Farm-to-Table camp is on again for summer 2022!
Registration here: 👇
www.santaclarausd.org/site/Default.aspx?PageType=3&Domain…
(actually, that may be for 2021)
Try here:
(408) 423-3500
foodandfarmcamp@scusd.net
Cost: ~$350/$450 for a week
(look for updates)
Some scholarships available
Are you doing this again? Cost? I’ve got kids that need this!
#fatherson
Took 16 year old son & his friend to Tahoe for 3-day weekend. Blue skies and mid-40's. Surprisingly short lift lines. Hardly any traffic. 🤔🤷♂️
Josh did some gnar shredding (see Urban Dictionary). I just skiied. 🥱
Pic is top of Sugar Bowl.
Thank you weather gods. 🙏
#microbiome
Last week the amaZing @DuplantierSally hosted me on Wellness Wednesday, by Zing, to talk about the microbiome work I've been doing w/ @GutBugs2 @LabSonnenburg and @Join_ZOE
View the ~45 minute talk 👇
www.youtube.com/watch?v=wr6iGDjsOHA
& subscribe 👇
myzinglife.com/about-wellness-wednesdays
Throwin’ name shade Dr Michelson? Uppity academic wife. 🤣
For more context were you going to mention the up and coming Dr Jackson Gardner, and @CGardner_2 ?
Geez. Away on weekend trip with the 16 year old Michelson son and look what happens!?
Taking my almost 14yo to get a piercing tomorrow and the place requires your last name on your photo ID to match that of your kid. No problem; the kids have my last name, not their dad's. #fightthepatriarchy
One of the ways I kicked off the new year was to talk about "diets" w/ Jonathan Wolf on the Zoe podcast.
I'm all in for moving toward a "healthier diet".
But if we're talking about a specific "diet" that you go "on", and later go "off", I'm opposed.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=HtKlDR5S_aE
Fiber is adversely or inversely associated? 🤣
Izit the same? 🤔
Secondary, observational analyses of PREVIEW trial (3 yr, n=1279)
Glycemic load associated with:
👉hunger
👉desire to eat something sweet
👉weight gain
(fiber adversely associated)
"which provides support for the carbohydrate-insulin model of obesity"
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S02615614210054…
Stanford Study Recruitment (SF/Bay Area)
Looking to enroll ~130 pregnant women btwn now & June 2022. Enroll 1st trimester.
MOMS
Maternal &
Offspring
Microbiome
Study
Mom & baby will get microbiome & immune profile results
Determine eligibility 👇
studypages.com/s/diet-and-microbiome-study-in-pregnant-mo…
Christopher Gardner reposted
Thank you @TomColeOK04 for recognizing the bipartisan support for a @WhiteHouse conference on food, nutrition, hunger & health. Momentum is building on both sides of the Capitol. RT to ask @POTUS Biden to say yes to a national conference so we can #endhungernow!
Did you know that only 43/295 public policies affecting food donation prioritize nutrition? New @CSPI report in collab w/ @LernerCenterJHU, Policy Approaches to Healthier Food Banking, recommends policy reforms to increase #healthierfoodbanking donations: cspinet.org/resource/policy-approaches-healthier-food-ban…
🤣
Ladies and gentleman - after years of a government led search party dedicated to locating the missing essential amino acids in plants the project has been defunded.
“All plants contain all essential amino acids. They were never missing” reported a government official.
Whole Food Plant Based Thanksgiving
So great to celebrate TG with family and friends.
Thanx @nytfood for the Sidesgiving set of menus. Collectively we made 9 of the dishes (2 remotely, @CGardner2 in NY).
Unapologetically delicious!
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/11/08/dining/vegetarian-…
All vaccinated
Many boostered
Thanks were given for:
Family
Friends
Pets
Vaccines
Creativity
Democracy
"...this [AHA] statement thoroughly supersedes 2020-25 DGA (DietGuidlnsAmer), which—because they say nothing about ultra-processed foods, differential protein sources, sustainability, or... countering societal determinants of poor diets—were out of date the instant they appeared"
The American Heart Association’s new and groundbreaking dietary guidelines www.foodpolitics.com/2021/11/american-heart-association-i…
Angelika, we are thrilled to have you enrolled in the course!
Tomorrow is a big day!
I've been waiting for this course for more than a year!🥰
After 17 yrs teaching Human Nutrition I collaborated with @Stanford & @GetSmarter to create on-line Nutrition Science course
8 wk course, 8-10 hrs/wk
Guidelines/Evidence/Carbs/Fats/Proteins/Calories/Vit’s/Min’s/Controversies/+
Plz share w/ wild abandon
www.getsmarter.com/products/stanford-nutrition-science-on…
Food & Inequality in America
Just published: How the Other Half Eats
Doctorate in Sociology & Postdoc in CVD Prevention (both @Stanford) Dr. Priya-Fielding Singh (now Assis Prof at Univ. Utah - Dept Family & Consumer Studies) has published her groundbreaking dissertation work.
This is brilliant work by @priyafsingh, and a captivating and impactful read.
She conducted 160 interviews w/ parents & kids; Black, Latinx, Asian, white and multiracial.
Her empathy and insights are riveting and educational.
You can also find her excellent work in her pubs!
Kids can cook! & when they do➡️more likely to eat veggies
@stanfordhumbio rock star Isabelle Crary (now @UWMedicine ) conducted field research @ Stanford-SCUSD Food & Farm Camp
#drnicoleardoin 👍🤩 co-author @soc_ecology_lab
👇
doi.org/10.1016/j.jneb.2021.08.009
video link - next tweet
Here’s ~2 min clip taken at Stanford-SCUSD Summer Food and Farm Camp - from @PBS
documentary (In Defense of Food,
@MichaelPollan) produced by @KikimMedia
Veggie Pizza Day 😋
(This & more at @GardnerPhD YouTube channel)
👇
www.youtube.com/channel/UCym4hh_CggCXw7VTcA4RYMA
#ace2
Congrats to @CauwNi (Nicholas Cauwenberghs) & a fantastic team of co-authors.
Officially out today.
Secondary analysis of #dietfits
"Our findings may improve the risk stratification, prevention, and management of cardiometabolic complications."
doi.org/10.1093/ajcn/nqab243
Christopher Gardner reposted
Just up: new faculty search @TuftsNutrition, tenure-track any rank, for work on food and nutrition equity.
We're looking to expand research, teaching and impact in any field addressing disparities related to agriculture, food systems and health.
Details: apply.interfolio.com/98250
#cop26
"Americans can eat meat while cutting global heating, says agriculture secretary" www.theguardian.com/environment/2021/nov/06/americans-can…
Given the ongoing global meeting, perspective is critical here (OECD-FAO 2021). Can/should Americans eat MUCH more meat than the rest of the world?
Whyizat?
Simon, I think:
Start w/ achieving "low-carb" by eliminating low-quality carb FOODS (added sugars, refined grains). >40% of US energy. 😱
Replace as much as possible w/ veggies.
AFTER that hlthy low-fat or hlthy low-carb FOODS is likely similar for health, on AVERAGE
continued
My only wish here was that they gave constructive information to help people who do choose a low carb diet, to do it in a more heart healthy way than most people are (i.e choose plant over animal fats more often to get ApoB/LDL down).
Wonder what @GardnerPhD thinks?
...after maximizing veggies (which don't contribute much to calories), I think some individuals will be happier & do better w/ ⬆️ legumes, fruits & whole intact grains, while others w/⬆️ avo's, nuts & seeds, fatty fish, whole fat yogurt.
Still others with ALL the above (Med)
We are hoping to design & test more diet pattern studies that get beyond standard health parameters, & dive deeper into acceptability (personal, cultural, TASTE) and SATIETY (my take is that satiety is very personal, and heterogeneous, & major factor in maintaining diet changes)
Nutrition Twitter - Insulin Resistance
For the on-line Nutrition class I developed with @Stanford_CHE and @2Uinc...
👇
online.stanford.edu/courses/som-xche0001-nutrition-science
...we created a ~5 min video describing insulin resistance
Whadya think? Open to suggestions.
👇
www.youtube.com/watch?v=U1cr14xffrk
Lancet Planetary Health - Springmann et al model costs of dietary shifts aligned w/ environmental sustainability
"A fuller accounting of the costs of diets would make healthy and sustainable diets the least costly option in most countries in the future."
doi.org/10.1016/S2542-5196(21)00251-5
Are reprints available🤔
How much?
👍😎👏
I asked @Sinceregrace to create me something that captures the Brain Gut connection.
This masterpiece now on my wall. Who needs a zoom background when I now have this? 🔥❤️
Ultra-processed foods review
Congrats to the dynamic duo of postdocs - Dr. Anthony Crimarco & @TheGuyititian (Dr. Matt Landry)!
Here's an insightful (invited) review just published in Current Obesity Reports
Open Access
Share with wild abandon
rdcu.be/czZl3
Respectfully pushing back.
Nothing works for everyone & everything works for someone.
I'm confident a metric like this is what some people are looking for to help guide them, & it will help some people.
If it doesn't help, don't use it.
Question it. Improve it. Don't trash it.
Rankings like this imply that we can determine with great specificity the health implications of particular foods.
We can't.
The implication, that healthful eating is super-sciency and the province of experts, is hugely disempowering.
sites.tufts.edu/foodcompass/
Happy 50th birthday CSPI!
I've been receiving & reading the Nutrition Action Health Letter for 30 years.
I recommend the Health Letter and CSPI to anyone who asks me what to read and how to stay current on nutrition and health topics.
Stay strong! Stay impactful! Thank you 👏
Watch and share: @CSPI is celebrating 50 years of fighting for a safer, more equitable food system. Learn more about our accomplishments and ambitious agenda for the future: www.youtube.com/watch?v=GPxDsX1yKPI #cspi50
Discussion of Plant-Based Meat Alternatives vs Animal Meat & CVD Risk Reduction
Looking forward to presenting w/ Penny Kris-Etherton (pre-recorded) & then taking questions (live).
Monday 10/18 @eatrightFNCE
12:30-1:30 PT
1:30-2:30 MT
2:30-3:30 CT
3:30-4:30 ET
Join us! 👋🎙️
#dietfits fiber paper
Congrats @botaniculture Lisa Offringa on new publication today!
www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/13/10/3625/pdf
Yes, higher total fiber for Hlthy-Low Fat (HLF) vs Hlthy Low-Carb (HLC)
But looking at specific fiber sources is interesting
HLC better for ⬆️veggies, nuts & avos
Anahad, aren't you on paternity leave now? Hopefully this was written before Isabella was born?
Great article! Great quotes from @GutBugs2 & others. Yes @Join_ZOE's PREDICT studies generating interesting data!
But beware getting ahead of the science😱
www.nytimes.com/2021/10/13/well/live/microbiome-test.html
Thx Tamar, & kumbaya.
I agree, enthusiastically.
Thx for including 3 points beyond nutrients & metabolism:
#2 - Telling people to achieve a caloric deficit isn’t effective
#5 - Be kind, support everyone at every weight
(#6) - Nastiness doesn’t make this better
👏
Sounds pretty sensible to me👍
Congratulations @Dmozaffarian et al!
Looking forward to finding ways to use this new tool.
Connect the dots - Methane
This from @lisaelaineh today in @CivilEats
civileats.com/2021/10/06/methane-from-agriculture-is-a-bi…
"A large proportion of that reduction could come from farming differently, shifting to lower-meat diets, & wasting less."
Connected to this NYT article today
www.nytimes.com/2021/10/11/climate/methane-global-climate…
In general I am not a fan of dairy.
However, I found this article fascinating.
Milk on tap!?
Quotes from some Rwandans who drink 3 liters/day!
After the horrors of genocide, this is part of their nutritional solution, with a strong social component.
www.nytimes.com/2021/10/09/world/africa/rwanda-milk-bars.…
Curious to hear from nutrition twitter about other populations with high dairy intake that is not confounded by high intake of dairy desserts w/ added sugars (ice cream, whipped cream).
Scandinavian
Masai
Other?
US Dairy intake includes high sugar, ⬆️mocha-frappa-crapucinno
Extracting energy? I've never heard anyone suggest this as a benefit of microbiome fermenting fiber?
As w/ many nutrients & foods, optimal is btwn too little & too much.
Pro:
Satiety
LDL-C lowering
Slows glucose release
Bowel health
Anti-nutritive - please list (yes, some)
Humans can *maybe* extract ~5% of their energy needs by fermenting fiber, yet vegans love to push it as if it was the key to health - and never mention its anti-nutritive properties
#scamfartists
Wonderful job hosting the Eat-Move-Think podcast @LeslieBeckRD 👏
Always great fun to join up with the incomparable Dr. Justin Sonnenburg @GutBugs2 @LabSonnenburg to talk about our FeFiFo study (FErmented & FIber-rich FOods) published in Cell last August
www.cell.com/cell/pdf/S0092-8674(21)00754-6.pdf
Loved this Eat Move Think episode from @LeslieBeckRD, @GardnerPhD and @LabSonnenburg. Thanks so much for the time! Looking forward to making my own kombucha!
Wonderful job hosting the Eat-Move-Think podcast @LeslieBeckRD 👏
Always great fun to join up with the incomparable Dr. Justin Sonnenburg @GutBugs2 @LabSonnenburg to talk about our FeFiFo study (FErmented & FIber-rich FOods) published in Cell last August
www.cell.com/cell/pdf/S0092-8674(21)00754-6.pdf
Loved this Eat Move Think episode from @LeslieBeckRD, @GardnerPhD and @LabSonnenburg. Thanks so much for the time! Looking forward to making my own kombucha!
Simon, congrats & thx. This is an insightful & well organized examination & critical assessment of the main arguments being made by pro-sat-fat'ers
Another perspective to add. In the US, the sat fat contribution of cheese, desserts & chicken dishes
>red meat
Can others confirm?
Another great study out of @segal_eran lab. Med vs Personalized (algorithm - PPT) diet for glucose control.
Although: Med diet was 42%:35% carb:fat; PPT was 20%:56%
I'd like to see 20% carb in both diets, one w/ & one w/o algorithm & personalization
care.diabetesjournals.org/content/44/9/1980
Authors specifically state addressing this:
"Meal carb content explained only 25% of variability in glycemic response"
Inherent measurement error in diet assessment likely a factor.
Looking forward to a new study w/ & w/o PPT algorithm, w/ diets matched for carb (total & type)
2nd phase of this low-carb vs low-fat study is clever!
Keep in mind, not eligible for phase 2 until >=10% weight loss.
What diet reliably produced weight loss in n=164?
Run-In diet 45% carb, 35% fat, 25% protein: HYPOCALORIC
So...calories count?! 😱
academic.oup.com/ajcn/advance-article/doi/10.1093/ajcn/nq…
20 nearly 8 minute miles!! 🤪
⚡️👍
Sodium reduction
Reducing sodium in the food supply can prevent thousands of cardiovascular disease-related deaths annually. Please, @SecBecerra and @DrWoodcockFDA, release the sodium reduction guidelines!
Personal & Planetary Health intersect!
50th anniversary UPDATED edition of @fmlappe 's Diet for a Small Planet is out. Visionary! Still relevant & important today. Your ongoing vibrancy & prolific career are a testament to the personal benefits of all this.
Awesome Frankie!👏❤️
I must have misunderstood. From your previous tweet I thought you were suggesting leveraging the lower glycemic fruits, and I was asking which specific fruits (other than berries) you were referring to. But, none of your examples are fruits.
So, no fruits other than berries?
Want vitamin C?
✅Eat a green pepper🌶
❌Not an orange🍊
Want potassium?
✅Eat zucchini 🥒
❌Not a banana 🍌
Want fiber?
✅eat green leafy🥬
Not potatoes/carrot🥔🥕
🚨We can apply the principles of CIM to our holy fruits/vegetables & reduce calories & carbs!
Win, win, win
I’ll bite. Agreed that it is rare to find something in nutrition that works for every patient.
I like the idea of leveraging lower glycemic fruits.
What specific fruits would you recommend, beyond berries?
🍏🍌🍐🍍🥝🍑🍉
Are we counting tomatoes & avocados as fruits? 🤔
🥑🍅
This is the problem, given the unique benefits of ketosis and carbohydrate restriction, REPLACING processed carbs with "high-quality carbs" may not be an ideal worth striving for in every patient
Furthermore, we could leverage fiber from EVEN lower glycemic vegetables & fruit
Rather than debating EBM vs CIM, priority is replacing >40% of US kcal from low-quality carbs w/
High quality carbs (beans/fruits/whole grains)–YES
High quality unsaturated fats (nuts/seeds/avo’s/fatty fish)–YES
Combo’s of both–YES
More protein?–No need, all above have protein
I truly think @DavidLudwigMD et al design & conduct elegant studies. @ACJNutrition perspective on carb-insulin model is provocative.
Our #dietfits results don’t support CIM.
jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2673150
Yet, broad agreement – ⬇️⬇️⬇️ added sugars & refined grains (>40% of US kcal)
Perspective published in @AJCNutrition argues the root causes of the #obesity epidemic are more related to what we eat rather than how much we eat. Read the summary and access the #openaccess article: nutrition.org/scientists-claim-that-overeating-is-not-the… @davidludwigmd
Rather than debating EBM vs CIM, priority is replacing >40% of US kcal from low-quality carbs w/
High quality carbs (beans/fruits/whole grains)–YES
High quality unsaturated fats (nuts/seeds/avo’s/fatty fish)–YES
Combo’s of both–YES
More protein?–No need, all above have protein
Nutrition Media - heroes
Hurray for this recognition given to some of the best health writers out there. Thank you all for your insightful and helpful coverage of what can be challenging and controversial topics in food and nutrition.
😎👍👏🎉🥳
Booyah!
We are SO excited to announce our first annual REAHL Awardees, who combat dangerous and misleading health misinformation with skilled, nuanced reporting. Congratulations to @juliaoftoronto @jameshamblin @tamarhaspel @lamottesandee @aubreynpr and Jane Brody of @nytimes
Fermented food follow-up
Thx @taraparkerpope & @nytimes for great practical follow-up to our recent Cell paper on fermented food w/ positive immune function effects
Lots of great fermented food insights from microbiome wiz Justin Sonnenburg @GutBugs2
www.nytimes.com/article/fermented-foods-dos-facts.html
Lots of thoughts. Too many for tweet.
Eggs will be one of chapters in my upcoming book : “It depends”
How many?
With what?
Instead of what?
Battery cages?
Cage-free?
Organic?
Pasture-raised?
Cholesterol metabolism?
Omega-3?
White vs yolk?
Environment?
Animal rights & welfare?
Nutrition Science Twitter
Difference of differences
In today's post @marionnestle raises concerns about a prunes study.
Here's another. In a 3-arm RCT, the correct analysis tests for diff's BETWEEN groups. The analyses for this were WITHIN groups.
C'mon reviewers & editors?!
Industry-funded study of the week: prunes, this time www.foodpolitics.com/2021/08/industry-funded-study-of-the…
A few odd findings regarding dose:
HDL-C, IL-6, & TNF-alpha improvements were reported for mod. dose but not high dose.
It's puzzling that ~5 prunes/d would confer benefits but ~10 prunes/d would not.
Plateau of effect at a higher dose would be one thing, but no effect?
Finally, 100 g/day would be >200 Kcal/d. Authors report no dietary differences between arms. If weight didn't change, what was displaced by 100 g/day of prunes?
@marionnestle got it right. At end of day, all veg & fruit have benefits. Eat as wide a variety as possible.
Had fun discussing A Foundational Diet on @Plant_proof podcast. It's available on my new YouTube channel where we've collected my #nutrition talks over the years. Please take a look, subscribe & turn on notifications to keep up to date!
www.youtube.com/channel/UCym4hh_CggCXw7VTcA4RYMA?cbrd=1&u…
Here's a peek 👇
Food & Nutrition Twitter
Legumes drive me nuts (#1 of 6)
5 polls, 1 figure
Peanuts are legumes, but I suspect most people would say they're a type of nut.
(?botanically they’re legumes, but culinarily they’re nuts?)
If you were asked to classify a peanut, which would you pick?
Legumes drive me nuts (#5 of 6)
A “Plant-based diet” is often defined by a list that usually includes some combination of:
Vegetables
Fruits
Nuts (& Seeds)
Grains
…and LEGUMES or BEANS
Which term do/would YOU use when specifying a plant-based diet:
Legumes drive me nuts (#6 of 6)
Here is a diagram of the relationship between all things leguminous
I found ~20 diagrams, and they are all consistently the same, so I am assuming this is accurate.
(botanists…feel free to correct me)
Now I know.
But how long will I remember?
We’ll deserved @euanashley! Hoping there will be some precision nutrition collaboration in your future! 🤔
#standom's @euanashley has been appointed the Roger W. & Joelle G. Burnell Professor of Genomics & Precision Health. Please join us in congratulating him! shc.is/2W1nPP3
Fe - Fermented
Fi - Fiber-rich
Fo - Food (as in real, whole, foods, not supplements)
Credit goes to @GutBugs2 for coming up with that that one. 🤣
#fefifo ... 🤔 can you give me a clue?🙏
Fermented?, Fi...???, Fo...???🤯
Avocado toast recipe
1/2 Haas avocado, ripe, mashed onto toast
Favorite bread….mine is Vital Vittles (Sesame Millet). Toasted
Kimchi from Wise Goat at Palo Alto Farmers Market (Sunday, California Ave)
I don’t make my own kimchi….yet
Optional: Sriracha hot sauce
😋
Recipe?
Final product of wine is NOT a source of live bacteria.
Same for beer.
But Kombucha is easier to make than you might think.
You can experiment w/ different types of teas, & different flavors added after primary fermentation (berries, juice extracts, spices).
Got SCOBY?
Wine is indeed produced through fermentation. Although I’m not sure if the final product contains any live cultures. I suspect @GardnerPhD might know the answer. Any thoughts?
SCOBY - Symbiotic Culture Of Bacteria and Yeast
Prolific Op-Ed publisher, Stanford sociologist, & now Univ Utah prof of Family & Consumer Studies @priyafsingh has a new piece in @WashingtonPost.
Insightful perspectives on universal school meal programs impact
Her new book "How the Other Half Eats" will be out in November! 👏
Fermented Food & Microbiome
Thx @anahadoconnor for great coverage of #fefifo study @nytimes
👇
www.nytimes.com/2021/08/13/well/eat/yogurt-kimchi-kombuch…
How do I include fermented food?
This week I made my ~57th batch of kombucha (pomegranate/black cherry)
Breakfast this morning - avocado toast w/ kimchi
😋
Fermented Food & Microbiome
Thx @anahadoconnor for great coverage of #fefifo study @nytimes
Cell paper here:
👇
authors.elsevier.com/c/1dOdeL7PXe~ww
Such an honor & pleasure working w/ @LabSonnenburg on this, particularly lead authors
@wastyk & @GabiFragiadakis
www.nytimes.com/2021/08/13/well/eat/yogurt-kimchi-kombuch…
Congrats to @CauwNi et al.
Excellent repurposing of stored #dietfits blood samples to examine sACE2.
Conclusion. Our findings may improve the risk stratification, prevention, and management of cardiometabolic and COVID-19-related complications.
academic.oup.com/ajcn/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.109…
1/5
Celebrating 10th Anniversary of Stanford/SCUSD Farm-to-Table Camp! 👩🌾👨🌾🍅🥬🥕🍑
Here’s 2 min clip from @PBS documentary (In Defense of Food, @MichaelPollan) from @KikimMedia
(check out & subscribe to YouTube Channel for other @GardnerPhD videos) 👇
www.youtube.com/channel/UCym4hh_CggCXw7VTcA4RYMA
4/5
Special thx to crew that got us through re-opening of camp (w/ COVID restrictions):
Natacha Costa
Sajeemas (Mint) Pasakdee
Farmer Dave Tuttle
& Rishika Rawat (camper for 7 yrs, counselor-in-training for 2 yrs, & this year full counselor!)
+ Stanford students Tatum & Isabelle
5/5
Greatest thanks of all to Erin Bird (now Dr. Erin Bird), who took on role of camp director from 2012-2018 after graduating from the Masters in Education program at Stanford, & went on to get a PhD at UC Davis
Your legacy continues!
She has starring role in documentary clip!
Christopher Gardner reposted
I'm no fig aficionado...
But when @mmerschel requested an interview for @American_Heart I confessed my fig fetish - fresh figs frequently at the farmers market, when I can. Dried all year. Mostly mission, but crave calmyrna.
Who else is a fan of figs?
www.heart.org/en/news/2021/08/05/are-figs-good-for-you-ge…
Foundational Diet
Had a blast in interview w/ Simon Hill of @Plant_proof podcast fame discussing Low-Fat vs Low-Carb in context of our @StanfordMed #atoz & #dietfits studies
We discussed broad agreement on:
⬆️veggies, whole foods
⬇️ added sugars, refined grains, ultraprocessed
Respectfully, pushing back. I'm well aware of sdLDL (see JAMA 1996). I'm still convinced by totality of evidence that LDL-C ➡️⬆️CHD, and SFA raises LDL-C.
sdLDL can help explain some of the heterogeneity among individuals w/ same total LDL-C. Doesn't exonerate SFA
What you got wrong is perpetuating the myth that SFA is harmful via ⬆️ LDL. You failed to cover sdLDL vs lbLDL in relation to diet & CHD, which is covered by these experts:
doi.org/10.1016/j.jacc.2020.05.077
and in our paper, which = a rebuttal to yours:
DOI:10.1097/MED.0000000000000568
Food, Nutrition & Brain Health
Last Wed, 7/21/21 the amaZING @DuplantierSally hosted another fab Wellness Wednesday event, joining forces w/ @AnnieFennMD (Chef/MD) to cover Sally's recently published paper, and Annie's delish recipes.
An hour well spent!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=dJFzkpO8WL8
And here is the link to our paper, published in @Nutrients_MDPI June 2021
Open Access
www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/13/7/2264
1/6
Our review on Low Carb Diets is out today in Curr Obes Reports @SpringerNature
Work led by @StanfordMed rock-star postdocs @TheGuyititian & Dr Anthony Crimarco
A few highlights shared in this thread...
Whadya think we got right? Wrong?
Open Access
rdcu.be/cpN7s
5/6
Body weight alone is a crude measure that fails to capture potentially important differences in lean-mass, fat-mass, and body water
Benefits for glycemic control need to be balanced w/ impacts on non-glycemic outcomes such as LDL-cholesterol, the microbiome, & inflammation
6/6
We conclude: Mostly unsettled, not resolved.
We end our review with suggestions for future studies that could help address the challenges in this field.
Trying to help make this less controversial, more settled.
Whadya think?
Open Access
rdcu.be/cpN7s
🤣👰♀️🤵♂️
Happy Anniversary! I would have paid to watch you crash the wedding
For 17th anniversary (July 17th), @profmichelson & I went to Mtn Terrace where we had outdoor wedding, dancing & volleyball in 2004. Couldn't get in for dinner-wedding in progress!🤣
I kinda wanted to sneak in & wish newlyweds they'd be as deliriously happy as we are together!💞
Great comment @Plant_proof / Simon. That is on our list of follow-up questions.
Great study! What about looking at increase unique plants in the diet rather than a focus on absolute grams? Different types of prebiotics ---> different microbes?
Diet-Microbiome
Informative write up from @StanfordMed (thx Janelle Weaver) of our #fefifostudy out today in Cell.
"The findings paint a nuanced picture of the influence of diet on gut microbes and immune status."
Nice shout out to generous donors. 🙏
med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2021/07/fermented-food-die…
INTERESTING finding in our CELL paper
Microbial diversity ⬆️ in Fermented food group, ➡️ consistent ⬇️ in >dozen inflammatory markers
Similar for those in Fiber group w/ ⬆️ baseline diversity. But for those w/ ⬇️ baseline diversity ➡️ adverse(?) reaction
authors.elsevier.com/c/1dOdeL7PXe~ww
#fefifostudy
Bonus info: Only a small portion of the increase in microbial diversity in the High Fermented Food group was attributable to the bugs identified from the fermented foods. 🤔
Diversity increase largely due to species NOT in the fermented foods. Hmmm...
#fefifostudy
An obvious follow-up question...what if we START those with ⬇️fiber & ⬇️microbial diversity on fermented foods, & THEN increase their fiber?
Submitted to NIH (& 4 other R01's)...so far, no NIH success.
Thankful to many generous donors supporting our research. 🙏
#fefifostudy SHOUT OUTS
@LabSonnenburg
For interrogation & characterization of baseline microbiota & diet change response
Stanford Human Immune Monitoring Core - immune profiling
Diet whisperer @dalita & the data collection team @GardnerPhD
Trifecta!
authors.elsevier.com/a/1dOdeL7PXe~ww
#fefifostudy is out today in Cell!
Fe = FErmented Food (yogurt, kimchi, sauerkraut, kefir, kombucha)
Fi = FIber rich Food (veggies, beans, grains, fruits)
Fo - FOod
Characterized microbiome
Immune profiling outcomes
Some unexpected/interesting findings
authors.elsevier.com/a/1dOdeL7PXe~ww
Context, context, context.
Alt-meats have been criticized for being high sat fat & sodium - bad for LDL-cholesterol & BP - “if you switch, maybe good for environment but bad for your health.”
Our study suggests better for TMAO & LDL-C, didn’t adversely affect BP.
Context
My friend @GardnerPhD did a study looking at eating fake meat vs. real meat and found some advantage to the fake stuff.
BUT you'd have to eat a lot of it to make any difference.
I don't think the difference is big enough to be meaningful IRL.
academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/112/5/1188/5890315?login=true
Back atcha with respect, & admiration, but strong disagreement. Provided the magnitude of change in diet is “meaningful” (we can discuss), there is great investigative insight to be gained from looking at the CHANGE in outcome in response to the CHANGE in diet.
Continued…
I say this with love:
Free-living diet/lifestyle intervention trials are observational cohorts with lipstick on.
Meaningful comparisons group are important.
Equipoise is important.
Achieving and assessing adherence is important.
If the question is “should I choose A vs. B?”, free-living lifestyle trials offer additional important insights…more than lipstick.
Radiating wisdom and serenity. That’s what retirement should look like. Congrats!
Insightful article in Wash Post by my better half today, @profmichelson. Her recent experiments and two of her books (w/ valued co-author @brianfharrison) elaborate on the positive significance of Carl Nassib’s actions. Great wrap up for Pride Month 2021! 🏳️🌈
By coming out, Carl Nassib likely improved NFL fans’ attitudes toward gay men. Here’s how we know.
In today's @monkeycageblog, by me & @brianfharrison
#footballisgay
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/07/01/by-coming-out-…
Brilliant question. I’m on the edge of my seat waiting to learn if anyone can provide any examples.
My assumption is….no.
But I would love to be proven wrong on this one. 🤔
What is an example where GRADE was used for an environmental or behavioral exposure, in which the certainty was rated high?
And imagining you were able to leap ahead and have this in your back pocket (or framed and on your wall), at this point do you think you would prefer....
Teaching?
Research?
Combination? (what proportion for each)
Industry?
Other?
Contemplating a PhD...
What a trajectory!
@DuplantierSally takes on-line Stanford Nutrition class.
online.stanford.edu/courses/som-xche0001-nutrition-science
Then gets into USC masters program in Gerontology.
For internship, writes critical review on Neuroprotective Diets.
Which got published today!
www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/13/7/2264
👏👏👏
1/10
Yaass!!
Manuscript comes out in <2 weeks in CELL
Title: Gut-Microbiota-Targeted Diets Modulate Human Immune Status
We call it: Fe-Fi-Fo
FErmented & FIber-rich FOods study
Collaborative effort btwn @LabSonnenburg & @GardnerPhD nutrition group
Here are a few design teasers…
6/10
If you were us, what SOURCES of "increased fermented foods" would you have proposed?
7/10
We picked:
FIBER
Dose: +20 g/d
Sources: All plant foods
FERMENTED FOODS
Dose: +6 servings/d
Sources: All (Yogurt, kefir, kombucha, sauerkraut, kimchi)
9/10
ADHERENCE
Here's how we did for the high fermented food group
(Note: the dotted line represents the fermented food intake for the Increased Fiber group)
10/10
Whadya think of our targets?
Whadya think of our adherence?
We'll share more design & conduct insights next week.
On-line manuscript projected publication: July 6th
Team Awesome:
@wastyk
@GabiFragiadakis
@dalita
@GardnerPhD
@GutBugs2
@LabSonnenburg
More below
Just out.
We addressed 3 issues that come up in nutrition controversies. If these were addressed more often, more effectively ➡️ fewer controversies.
Kudos to fab co-authors
@EcoDocTush
@cyberRD
Dr. Adam Bernstein
& to @DrDavidKatz & @TrueHealthINIT
doi.org/10.1177/08901171211016191d
3 factors:
1. Instead of what?
Eggs - yes/no?
Instead of sugary cereal, or whole oats?
2. In what context?
Higher fiber - yes/no?
How high is baseline diet?
From whole foods, or supps?
3. For what?
Fish - yes/no?
Human health? Environment? Animal welfare?
Consider:
"Hierarchies of Evidence Applied to Lifestyle Medicine (HEALM)...based on specific contributions of diverse research methods to understanding lifetime effects of health behaviors."
@DrDavidKatz
@JEFielding_MD
LWGreen (UCSF)
WWillett (Harvard)
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6701153/
GRADE, developed for both RCTs and observational studies, is based on over 30 peer-reviewed guidance articles (BMJ, JCE) and is endorsed by the Cochrane Nutrition group. One common grading system across medicine and allied health makes sense to me. See: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32367118/
Agreed, not just nutrition - lifestyle/behavior topics similarly challenging
How many willing research participants out there in the Twitterverse ready to be RANDOMIZED for 5-XX years to ALWAYS or NEVER:
Run X miles/wk
Sleep for < or > X hrs/nite
Eat red meat
Dose & duration?
“Fields have tried & improved”
Twitter doesn’t lend itself to complete explanations, but???
While they may have improved, there’ll never be a definitive RCT for:
*Drinking alcohol tried it - terminated, debacle
*Red meat
*Lettuce & lentils
Each would require multiple RCTs
Agreed, nutrition shouldn’t have different standards for evidence.
But nutrition experts are better equipped to address importance of:
*Dose
*Source
*Substitution (instead of what?)
*Adherence (was it assessed? taken into account in analyses?)
*Baseline diet (change from)
*Other
If nutrition is not your primary field of study I can understand how you might hold that opinion.
If nutrition is your primary field of study, as it is mine, the emphasis on RCT’s w/ hard outcomes is highly problematic - those studies r rarely feasible. @deirdre_tobias explained
GRADE, developed for both RCTs and observational studies, is based on over 30 peer-reviewed guidance articles (BMJ, JCE) and is endorsed by the Cochrane Nutrition group. One common grading system across medicine and allied health makes sense to me. See: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32367118/
Brilliant!!
🌽🐄 If someone shares a chart of the carbon footprint of foods people ask for it:
– by protein
– by calorie
– land, water or other.
We have these but spread across different charts.
Tried to fix this. You can now switch between them all in one place👇
ourworldindata.org/environmental-impacts-of-food
Nutrition rock star in the making. Keep your 👀 on him!
Really looking forward to our @nutritionorg panel session tomorrow at Nutrition Live Online 2021 on the topic of Precision Nutrition with an all-star line-up:
@KCKlatt
@KevinH_PhD
@deirdre_tobias
Spoiler alert: Hype AND Hope
Yes. Context matters.
Overall, LDL-C was higher in the DIETFITS study for the Healthy Low-Carb group relative to the Healthy Lo-Fat group. But that was more likely due to higher saturated fat and lower fiber intake, than it was to the higher dietary cholesterol.
In this study, people were actively losing weight and on a healthy low carb diet. I have also seen clinically plenty of people with cholesterol increase on a low carb diet when not losing weight. There are also different types of low carb diets-some much healthier than others.
Many excellent points made here by @deirdre_tobias et al.
"...the infeasibility of conducting large long-term randomized trials for most dietary and lifestyle factors renders the current GRADE criteria inadequate for these exposures."
academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/113/6/1385/6272430
New secondary analysis of DIETFITS
What happens to LDL-C in Healthy Low-Carb group over 12m in context of dietary cholesterol change?
Highest tertile diet chol. chg ⬆️~400 mg/day ➡️total ~650 mg/d 😱
Diet choles. change not correlated w/ LDL-C change
mdpi.com/1138350
Keep in mind, largest proportion of increase due to ⬆️ eggs.
That was likely in context of breakfast for most participants.
Instead of what?
For many, instead of sugary breakfast cereals, white toast, jam/jelly - high simple carbs.
In a weight loss study
Context matters
Awesome team!!
Lead author Monica Vergara
@ChefInMedicine
@LuciaAronica
Joe Rigdon
Priya Fielding-Singh
Cindy Shih
Had a blast in this interview w/ @DrTomRifai & @TrueHealthINIT
We talked hummus, working w/chefs @CIALeadership, challenges of doing nutrition science studies, strategies for doing better studies, I ranted about protein & plug the Protein Flip, & more.
👇
www.truehealthinitiative.org/news2019/christopher-gardner…
Just out...
Stats wiz & newly minted @StanfordMed faculty member @_MMathur led rigorous meta-analysis looking at behavioral interventions focusing on animal welfare designed to decrease meat consumption
w/
@TomRobinsonMD
@JacobPeacock1
👇
doi.org/10.1016/j.appet.2021.105277
Trending in college dining halls
Powerful, impacting the next generation of eaters
"The Culinary Institute of America is promoting 'plant-forward' menus. Dozens of colleges, including Harvard and Stanford, are shifting toward “climate-friendly” meals."
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-14/is-beef-the-ne…
Whayda think "Sustainable Diets" means for CVD prevention/management?
Coming at this from several angles in Curr Athero Rep, Stanford postdocs Andrea M, @TheGuyititian, & Anthony C, & visiting researcher @BladierClaire provide thoughtful perspectives.
👇
rdcu.be/ckmqo
Curious or confused about plant-based milks?
@DawnMacKeen put together a summary of 6 of most popular w/ feedback from @davidludwigmd @eatfitrun J Haven (USDA), M Lott (Duke), A Lichtenstein (Tufts), E McDonald (U Chicago), & P Kris-Etherton (Penn State)
www.nytimes.com/2021/05/10/style/are-plant-milks-good-for…
Beware the Chocolate Peppermint Stick Soymilk, that has "25 grams of sugar — 2.5 times the amount in one original glazed doughnut from Krispy Kreme."
Oh my?! 😱
Great video from the Planetary Health Alliance, and Dr. Sam Myers of Harvard.
"We know what to do. Will we do it?"
www.youtube.com/watch?v=9cZ0zBSJz_g
Thx for calling out these numbers @reshmashahmd
"Ninety-seven percent of Americans meet their daily protein requirements, but only 4% of Americans meet their daily fiber requirements. I’ve never treated a patient for protein deficiency."
bewell.stanford.edu/plant-based-diet/
Huzzah on the book, & booyah!
Can I pre-order yet? 🤔
Rudderless & adrift?
As it should be.
I have no doubt that good trouble is around the corner for you.
Hmmm....I’m starting to fantasize a bit about the opportunity to be rudderless & adrift for a while....🤔💭
I turned in my book manuscript to my editor @mhowry and now I feel strangely rudderless and adrift.
If you missed it, this was recorded and will be available through @myDietID
Great honor and good fun sharing the Zoom screen with @DrDavidKatz and Drs Jenkins and Snetselaar
Join us! PROTEIN AND BEYOND: CONSIDERATIONS FOR DISEASE REDUCTION AND PLANETARY HEALTH - Food Truths Webinar — via @myDietID www.dietid.com/foodtruthswebinar
Not sure why this resurfaced in 2021, but this overview of our 2018 DIETFITS weight loss diet trial was my personal favorite of all the coverage we got for the study.
(and we got a lot of coverage, Altmetric score > 4,000)
Huge kudos @Examinecom
Fair, thorough, insightful
Excellent study by @gardnerphd, with our analysis here: examine.com/nutrition/low-fat-vs-low-carb-for-weight-loss/
Looking forward to joining @DrDavidKatz & Drs Linda Snetselaar and David Jenkins for our discussion Wednesday, 4/28, 9 am PT / 12 noon ET:
PROTEIN AND BEYOND: Considerations for Disease Reduction and Planetary Health
Time for some protein myth bustin'
us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_xpe5EKyLQMSKtb_D67rX5A
#ketomedstudy wk #10
Participants monitored ketones wkly for 12 wks using home monitor kits. We had venipuncture values at wks 0, 4 & 12.
Health educator in study found some participants who were apparently doing very well w/ diet couldn't get in ketosis.
Surprised?
Expected?
2/X
These results are from the Adherence paper that we published in advance of the main trial results.
Here is the link to the full adherence paper
👇
www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/13/3/967/htm
3/3
Maybe one more week of discussing design issues.
Main results still to come (under review soon)
Anything else you would like to know about study design or implementation issues?
@TheGuyititian
@LuciaAronica
@Dalita
@SunKimMD
@BladierClaire
@GardnerPhD
“...people who care about the climate need to get serious about holding Big Meat and Big Dairy accountable, just as they’ve been trying to do for years with Big Oil.”
I've frequently been told that my focus on food systems & land use is a 'distraction' from taking on oil and gas, who are indeed contributing the most to climate change, and are the real (subtext: only) bad actors. But it turns out... www.vox.com/future-perfect/22379909/big-meat-companies-sp…
Christopher Gardner reposted
Congratulations to Dr. David Maron for this well deserved recognition of the ISCHEMIA Trial! I feel so lucky to have him as my mentor in preventive cardiology since I arrived @StanfordDeptMed! cc: @joshuawknowles @FaRodriguezMD @AshishSarraju
medicine.stanford.edu/news/current-news/standard-news/isc…
This will be an important component of the effort to establish #nutritionsecurity for all
Wow.
Lucky Dept F&CS to have landed you!!
Congrats!!!
🎉🍾🥂🎶💥
Another study finds protein supplementation does NOT improve muscle mass & strength
Resistance training improves muscle mass & strength
But this trial doesn't have a matched arm w/ RT & w/o protein supp
Can anyone point me to a good trial that does?
academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/113/4/790/6132000
🎶🎵🎹🎸🎤
@NIHDirector plays guitar AND piano AND sings a rendition of “Here Comes the Sun” with COVID-recovery modified lyrics & praise for NIH employees!
💜💚❤️
"Eat less, waste none, try to source it from grass"
Practical, intelligible, actionable, helpful.
Greatly appreciated @GlobalEcoGuy
#ketomedstudy Week #9
1/7
Last week we presented cool adherence graphics, and announced release of our Adherence paper!
👇
www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/13/3/967/htm
We have a bit more to share on design of our study.
Here's a brief thread with SATISFACTION metrics, and a poll....
6/7
Sorry...kinda trick question.
They preferred whichever diet they got first (A #3).
But in both cases, they lost the most weight on whichever diet they started first (A #4)
Weight mostly stable in 2nd phase.
We think that explains it 🕵️
7/7
That's this week's insight into our design, conduct, adherence.
Any thoughts? Questions?
Next week we'll share levels of blood ketones while in the Keto phase
@TheGuyititian
@LuciaAronica
@Dalita
@SunKimMD
@BladierClaire
@GardnerPhD
Amar,
Maybe.
But you haven’t met Dalia Perelman, MS, RD, diet whisperer! @dalita
She supported the participants throughout the study.
Sure, they could have been resistant to her loving and supportive efforts.
But they certainly became more literate during the study.
1/18
#ketomedstudy
Adherence/Design paper is published!
👇
www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/13/3/967/pdf
Over the last 7 weeks we have released a weekly tweet thread on various design aspects.
This week we will share some of the incredible graphics developed by @Guyititian, Matt Landry, PhD, RD
9/18
Previous graphic captures a lot of info!
But it's missing some details you might be interested in
In this one, X-axis runs from 0-10 on the left AND the right.
To left is Keto adherence (blue), to right is Med (gold) adherence, for each person, at each time point...
10/18
…separated into those with prediabetes on top, and T2D below.
And within each of those categories, participants who did Keto first are above, and Med first are below (see text circled in red).
Those details weren’t captured in the line graphs.
So….. (next tweet)
17/18
A: Recommendation both diets had in common was restrict added sugar & refined grain, & include non-starchy vegetables. Hi points for BOTH Keto & Med
Eat some, but not a lot, of beans, fruits & grains
That would get you intermediate points for BOTH Keto & Med
18/18
Hope you appreciated graphics
These were highlights of Adherence/Design paper
Huzzah Matt Landry, @TheGuyititian
Main results still to come (under review soon)
Still more to share about this paper next week
@LuciaAronica
@Dalita
@SunKimMD
@BladierClaire
@GardnerPhD
Marie-Pierre, good question.
This was a crossover study
Everyone got a chance to do both diets
Randomized to order
We do have a supplemental set of graphics that presents the follow-up separately, by order. Diffs were negligible.
For main paper, all combined in follow-up
Curious: why follow-up diet data not presented separately by diet assignment? Did groups continue to be different or both regressed back to baseline levels?
Video of my talk with @DuplantierSally (#ketomedstudy) is now available on my new #nutrition YouTube channel where we've collected my talks into one easy to navigate location! Please take a look, subscribe, and turn on notifications to keep up to date!
www.youtube.com/channel/UCym4hh_CggCXw7VTcA4RYMA?cbrd=1&u…
Microbiome & Diet
In helpful article written for @American_Heart I shared my thoughts and observations w/ writer @MichelleHiskey from research studies we've conducted with dynamic @StanfordMed duo, Drs. Justin and Erica Sonnenburg - @GutBugs2
👇
www.heart.org/en/news/2021/03/24/as-fermented-foods-rise-…
An astute observation (as usual) from @TamarHaspel
Given that reducing added sugars and refined grains (the major source of carbs in the US diet) was a recommendation for BOTH diet patterns, this raised adherence scores for BOTH.
Next week...cool adherence graphics!
For those following along, here's @GardnerPhD's latest thread on his keto vs. Mediterranean diet study.
2 things I think are interesting:
When left to choose, participants go more Med than keto.
BUT
Decrease in calories from baseline is mainly from cutting carbs.
1/14
#ketomedstudy
For 6 weeks we have been sharing tweet threads about the DESIGN of our recently completed RCT comparing a Ketogenic vs. Mediteranean diet among adults with T2D or prediabetes.
Ready to start sharing RESULTS regarding ADHERENCE data.
Today…diet data!
👏
1/14
#ketomedstudy
For 6 weeks we have been sharing tweet threads about the DESIGN of our recently completed RCT comparing a Ketogenic vs. Mediteranean diet among adults with T2D or prediabetes.
Ready to start sharing RESULTS regarding ADHERENCE data.
Today…diet data!
👏
7/14
Participants instructed to include non-starchy veggies in both diet phases
Beans, fruits, grains:
WFKD – avoid
Med-Plus - include
Fiber changes as expected in Food Delivery phase
Recidivism in Self-Provided phase
Follow-up - Fiber similar to baseline (Sigh... 😞)
8/14
Which of the carbohydrate metrics do you think is most important for health in general, and glucose control more specifically?
13/14
Protein was not an important focus of the study
But here it is
Food Delivery:
Shift to more animal less plant for WFKD
Shift to less animal more plant for Med-Plus
Self-Provided:
Some recidivism (slippage)
Follow-up:
Similar to Med-Plus self-provided phase
14/14
See ya next week for ADHERENCE RESULTS!!
Awesome graphics by Dr. Matt Landry 👍😎👏
@TheGuyititian
Also, hoping to share published ADHERENCE paper by then!
@LuciaAronica
@Dalita
@SunKimMD
@BladierClaire
@GardnerPhD
Time to review DRI's.
RDA's tend to be presented as single number, but typically involve range of optimal intake, w/ wide range for safety.
⬆️ & ⬇️ that range is marginal risk of deficiency & toxicity.
No need to seek out low nutritional quality to avoid exceeding RDA. 🤪
Looking forward to discussing nutrition and human behavior in our recently completed Ketogenic vs. Mediterranean Diet study with @DuplantierSally.
This Wednesday, March 24, 11-11:45 am PT
👇
myzinglife.com/upcoming-programs-2021/the-healthier-diet-…
So proud of my son!
@ColinGa33124354 who moved to join the NYU Food Studies masters program.
There’s a new Food Waste warrior in town. Woot, woot!
What, another null finding with Vit D3 supplementation!?
Who could have seen that coming? 😱
To their credit, in this trial they conducted a separate analysis among the subset determined to be deficient.
But still no significant benefit.
jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2776738
1/7
#ketomedstudy Week #6
This is ADHERENCE SCORE metric week. How’d we do it? 🤔
For those of you who haven’t seen any of this yet, over the past 5 wks, every Saturday morning (PT) we’ve shared some design details of our recently completed Keto vs. Med Study
Follow thread
8/9
We believe our adherence scores appropriately reflect optimal Keto & Med diets AND the instructions/recommendations provided to our study participants.
Whadya think our manuscript reviewers will say?
(remember – no consensus on adherence metrics)
Novel/tailored scores:
9/9
See ya next week for more about study design and adherence assessments for #ketomedstudy
Teaser: Next week bee-yoo-tee-full graphics of macros, carb types (sugar, fiber), fat types, protein types
@TheGuyititian
@LuciaAronica
@Dalita
@SunKimMD
@BladierClaire
@GardnerPhD
Well that was fun!
In a conversation w/ @DeepakChopra we talked about nutrition & the possibility of an Int'l Academy of Nutritional Psychiatry
Some of this builds on an interest in rewilding the planet (Resurrecting the Planetary Microbiome)
👇👇👇👇
youtu.be/ONe6a49dfvI
#ketomedstudy
Week #5
1/5
For past 4 wks, we've been sharing study design details of forthcoming Keto vs Mediterranean Study
This week, we want to share the 36-wk time point & get your thoughts.
Poll on next post in thread - vote on time point you think is most interesting 🤔
4/5
Participants tried both diets for 12 wks each.
Mastered them with support of @Dalita (diet whisperer, MS, RD, CDE)
Watched their glucose results on CGM (Dexcom) on both diets
Then 12 wks with no staff support or contact!
Doncha wanna know what they're eating?
Week #36 😱
5/5
See ya next week, when we share our definitions of "adherence" to WFKD, and Med-Plus
@TheGuyititian
@LuciaAronica
@Dalita
@SunKimMD
@BladierClaire
@GardnerPhD
(Teaser - Design & Adherence paper accepted today!
🍾🥂 Will share when published. Still working on main paper)
Look who just landed a position @CSPI as Communications Associate on the policy communications team! 🤩
Rock-star undergrad & Stanford advisee @tia_schwab graduated & now has her dream job. & @CSPI has a gifted writer & relentless sustainable food systems fighter! 🦸♀️
So proud!
1/7
#ketomedstudy Week #4
This week we’ll share study endpoints, and inclusion criteria
For those of you who haven’t seen any of this yet, over the past 3 weeks, every Saturday morning (PT) we’ve shared some design details of our recently completed Keto vs. Med Study
6/7
Teaser for next week:
We’ll discuss/describe our exploratory time point:
12 weeks AFTER the 24 weeks of the crossover (12 weeks on each diet).
7/7
See ya next week for more about study design and adherence assessments for #ketomedstudy
@TheGuyititian
@LuciaAronica
@Dalita
@BladierClaire
@SunKimMD
@GardnerPhD
1/17
#ketomedstudy Week #3 – Crossover design, with no washout
We used a crossover design
With no washout period between phases. 😱
This thread covers pros and cons
Questions/opinions to ask of Twitterverse
(Warning: this thread's a bit long...complex...for study design geeks)
11/17
WE PROPOSE:
Despite challenges with carryover effects, there can be value in doing crossover studies in nutrition studies that involve:
a.Weight loss
b.Microbiome
c.Other challenging but important topics? – please comment
12/17
WE SUGGEST
Altho washout periods appear intuitively important, for nutrition studies that involve weight loss, microbiome change, (other?) it would be impossible to choose ONE washout duration that would work for everyone.
& tailored washout duration would be a nightmare.
16/17
DAMMIT! Didn’t expect order effect
Wait a sec…
Very interesting?!
Maybe plant meat 1st (when participants were ~vegetarian) changed microbiome, so that getting red meat 2nd didn’t produce TMAO?
Microbiome analysis in process
Might have missed this if we had a washout?!
17/17
Appreciate feedback: Diet study Xovers & pros/cons of washouts when studies have carryover effects (eg weight loss, microbiome)
Never do ‘em?
Too late, we did!
See ya next wk – study outcomes, inclusion/exclusion
@TheGuyititian
@LuciaAronica
@Dalita
@SunKimMD
@GardnerPhD
Drat...forgot to add pic to #4/10 for #ketomedstudy week #2 Tweetorial
Here are pix of home delivery boxes of research food, and what a week's worth of jars looked like.
Med-Plus above right, WFKD below right
Thanx @gomethodology
1/10
#ketomedstudy Week #2
Balance of rigor & generalizability
We LOVE & appreciate the great work of @KevinH_PhD
Domiciled participants (incarcerated?)🤣
Metabolic ward
Feeding studies
⬆️rigor 👍
We lean toward free-living studies
⬆️ generalizability
Try to maximize rigor
2/10
Our design was a crossover
with 12-wk phases
4 wks of food delivery (for immediate ⬆️adherence, ⬆️rigor)
8 wks of “self-provided” (for greater generalizability)
A health educator (MS, RD, CDE) was available throughout
At least weekly contact, more as needed
3/10
Food Delivery
Maximize initial adherence 👍
Guarantee initial adherence? No
What kcal level to deliver? 🤔
Tailor this, by week, by participant??
That'd be a nightmare 😱
No prescribed kcal restriction
Ad libitum
What to do?
Worked with great partner
@GoMethodology
9/10
We picked 4 wks food delivery (too late to change now)
For data geeks who got this far…
Here's Table 3 from Adherence paper (under review)
On ave, they ate ~½ of what we provided, for all jars
As...
Designed...
Delivered...
Consumed…ad libitum (until satiated)
Get it?
10/10
See ya next week for installment #3 of #ketomedstudy 👋
We're thinkin'..... a discussion about cross-over pros & cons, including NO WASHOUT!! 😱
@TheGuyititian
@LuciaAronica
@Dalita
@SunKimMD
@GardnerPhD
et. al.
Love, love, LOVE your work addressing finding synergies between conservation and livelihood❣️
👏👍
1/9
Just completed trial
Keto vs Mediterranean
Just submitted Design & Adherence paper PRIOR to main results paper
While waiting for reviews & decision…
~10 weekly mini-threads - #ketomedstudy
⬆️design understanding &
⬆️twitter civility?🙏
Week #1
Main study question
8/9
The study wasn’t perfect. 🤷🏼♂️
We had to make modifications because of Covid.😪
We’ll talk about some of that.
We want to see what the Twitterverse thinks of our definitions of adherence, our scoring criteria, the level of adherence we got, and more. 🤔
9/9
See ya next week for installment #2 of #ketomedstudy
@TheGuyititian
@LuciaAronica
@Dalita
@SunKimMD
@GardnerPhD
I was pleased to have the opportunity to provide a “short course” on nutrition science to the SCCR group.
In this case, “short course” meant “2-hour video with 275 slides. 😱
Not just any 275 slides...my finest 275! 🏆🥇
Didn’t realize they’d put it on YouTube!
Cool 👍😎
We recently invited @GardnerPhd to provide viewers with a foundational overview of the types of #studydesign that are used in #nutritionscience - ecological studies, case-control, cohort & randomized #clinicaltrials. www.youtube.com/watch?v=VfQtq4YTPso
Diet PATTERN studies r challenging - defining, achieving adherence, ASSESSING adherence
journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0890117120960580d
Study below defines patterns in terms of foods
Tables 2&3 report nutrients
Adherence diffs? Probly
Equipoise? No
Strawman comparison? Perhaps
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/07315724.2020.1869625
Clarifications:
If adherence to diet "A" is different than adherence to "B", ➡️ problematic for conclusions of effects of "A" vs "B"
Equipoise - If following "A" vs "B" is harder, this impacts interpretation
Strawman - Designing comparison diet that is predicted to do worse
Wurtz, @EricRimm & others from @HarvardChanSPH published a paper on implications for risk of T2D of reducing red meat & replacing with other protein sources in @AJCNutrition
academic.oup.com/ajcn/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.109…
I was invited to write an editorial. Whadya think?
academic.oup.com/ajcn/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.109…
Nice overview on dairy by @SophNaama
My take:
If u have hlthy WFPB diet, +/- milk won't matter much.
Milk is better than soda
Whole fat vs skim?
The @NEJM paper by @davidludwigmd & Walter Willett she cites is a great resource.
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMra1903547
www.discovermagazine.com/health/is-milk-bad-for-you-heres…
This is very reassuring.
Great choice President Biden!
I feel more hopeful already @DavidAKesslerMD
Biden Picks Former F.D.A. Chief to Lead Federal Vaccine Efforts www.nytimes.com/2021/01/15/health/covid-vaccine-kessler.html
Annual USN&WR diet rankings are out.
Increased # of diets to 39! 😱
This year I got to participate in the scoring.
Behind the scene process is interesting.
Lotsa challenges for rating diets w/o good data.
Website offers lotsa ways to sort diets.
Enjoy
health.usnews.com/best-diet/best-diets-overall?src=usn_tw
Again?
When 2015 DG ignored DG Advisory Committee's 2015 report (e.g. environment) I ended up citing the DGAC report more than the Guidelines.
2020 DG ignoring DGAC sugar and alcohol rec's?
Looks like I'll continue citing DGAC instead of DGA.
www.nytimes.com/2020/12/29/health/dietary-guidelines-alco…
Congrats @MPStOngePhD for 👍 coverage by @anahadoconnor of your impactful research on diet <-> sleep! 👏
Great practical messages for helping us sleep easier & better, which will help us w/ better dietary choices, which will help us sleep better...
www.nytimes.com/2020/12/10/well/eat/sleep-foods-diet.html
👍Make Sec of Ag -> Sec Food & Well Being
"With just one cabinet appointment, President-elect Joe Biden could tackle economic inequality, the rural/urban divide, climate change, the growing mistrust of science, systemic racism and even the coronavirus."
www.nytimes.com/2020/12/03/opinion/usda-agriculture-secre…
Giving outdoor thanx to:
Grampa - Cranberry delight
Alicia (sis-in-law) - Brussels sprouts/grapes/pecans
& gluten-free biscuits
Beloved @profmichelson - Root veg/chickpeas/dried
apricots w/cashew cream
& red curry kuri squash soup
And from me - Sweet potatoes w/ pecans
Yum!!!
Unapologetically delicious!
Cooking Demo filming today for Healthy Kitchens, Healthy Lives: Plant-forward Plate Strategies in the Relentless Pursuit of Deliciousness. Join the virtual conference Feb 3-5, 2021 #ciahkhl #chefinmedicine #plantforward #plantbased #delicious #culinarymedicine
From @RolineNL et al @AJCNutrition
Achieving GHGE targets while maintaining hlthy eating pattern in Netherlands
Reduce: beef, pork, poultry, cheese, butter, & snacks
Increase: Legumes, fish/shellfish, peanuts, tree nuts, vegetables, soy foods/drinks
academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/112/5/1338/5885179
Congrats @LuciaAronica et al
Sex Diffs examined in weight loss & adherence for Hlthy Low-Fat (HLF) vs Hlthy Low-Carb (HLC) for DIETFITS
Men-HLC lost more weight (& adipose & lean) than Men-HLF
Women less adherent to HLC than HLF, but similar weight loss
rdcu.be/caMwf
SWAP-MEAT study now officially out @AJCNutrition
Editorial by @chanders4 & R Bradley
Agreed:
"...results should not be interpreted as “plant-based
alternatives lower TMAO” but rather as “plant-based alternative may lower TMAO relative to eating meat.”
doi.org/10.1093/ajcn/nqaa253
Thank you America 🇺🇸
Joe and Kamala!!
Certainly enjoyed working on this editorial piece regarding nutrition study design with a trio of postdoc co-author rock stars: @priyafsingh @TheGuyititian and Dr. Anthony Crimarco.
journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0890117120960580d
Nutrition Study Design Issues: Diet A vs B
Clearly DEFINE diet criteria
Report ADHERENCE (despite given challenges) - critical for interpretation
Avoid STRAW MAN comparison
These steps will help resolve some apparent conflicting findings of Diet A vs B
journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0890117120960580d
The #foodchoicesgame is here.
Pick a country (from 4 options).
Pick a character (many options).
Make some food choices.
The game will scale your choices and calculate impact.
As questions come up, many answers have been prepared for you.
Eye-opening 👀
www.greenbrownblue.com/food-choices-for-a-healthy-planet/
🌍Want a playful interactive learning experience on how to take action for the planet through #food?
🧐 Expert answers on some complex questions of food system sustainability?
The #foodchoicesgame launched Friday on #worldfoodday has got you covered! www.greenbrownblue.com/food-choices-for-a-healthy-planet/
Wait, I think you forgot to include one study. 😱
Actually, nope, there it is. Go back to your movie. 👏
Welp, it's been about two months of non-stop work. But here it is. Low carb diets and health. ~200 studies across ~50 biomarkers, stratified by carbohydrate intake, duration, and weight loss.
I'm going to go get a bottle of Kahlua and watch a movie. 🥂🍿
thenutrivore.blogspot.com/2020/10/low-carbohydrate-diets-…
Got my ballot in the mail today.
Voted.
Going back out tomorrow.
#voteearly
Sonnenburg-Gardner labs report latest collaboration (pre-print)
Diet intervention➡️microbiome➡️immune fx
Rock stars @wastyk & @GabiFragiadakis from @GutBugs2 lab led brilliant analysis & interpretation
Fe-Fi-Fo study (Fe-rmented, Fi-ber, Fo-ods)
Feedback?
biorxiv.org/cgi/content/short/2020.09.30.321448v1
~40 gen'ly hlthy adults randomized to:
⬆️ daily fiber, or fermented food, for 10 wks (4 to ramp up, 6 to maintain)
Parallel design
Fiber ⬆️ from ~20 to ~40g/d
Fermented ⬆️ from ~0 to ~5-6 servings/d
Consistent ⬇️ in inflamm. markers for Fermented
Hi-Fiber results more nuanced
White flour flavored sugar?
www.independent.ie/irish-news/courts/sandwiches-in-subway…
We're so lucky to have you!
Loving our collaborations...looking forward to more!
12 yrs ago today, started my 1st day @Stanford_GI. What an amazing journey of personal & professional growth often spurred by the countless stumbles & falls.
Grateful to my family by🩸&❤️who were there to help & my kids who only know one way of life #workingmom #womeninmedicine
Christopher Gardner reposted
I want to hear from dieters.
Studies are full of people who go on a diet, lose weight, and then regain.
I have done this. If you have, too, I want to hear your story. What happened?
I'm writing about how we can make this stop.
DMs open.
RTs appreciated.
Very excited that our study came out today in @AJCNutrition
Study With Appetizing Plantfood - Meat Eating Alternative Trial
SWAP-MEAT
med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2020/08/plant-based-meat-v…
After 17 yrs teaching Human Nutrition I collaborated with @Stanford & @GetSmarter to create on-line Nutrition Science course
8 wk course, 8-10 hrs/wk
Guidelines/Evidence/Carbs/Fats/Proteins/Calories/Vit’s/Min’s/Controversies/+
Plz share w/ wild abandon
www.getsmarter.com/products/stanford-nutrition-science-on…