Trump’s own populism has been destructive in all sorts of ways. But Vance is promising populism uber alles. What does the mob say? Whatever it is, do it.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jd-vances-alienation-tour/
Commentary (magazine)
Commentary is a conservative American magazine on religion, Judaism, Israel, politics, and social and cultural issues. Founded by the American Jewish Committee in 1945 under Elliot E. Cohen, who served as editor from 1945 to 1959, Commentary magazine developed into the leading post-World War II journal of Jewish affairs. It strove to construct a new American Jewish identity while processing the events of the Holocaust, the formation of the State of Israel, and the Cold War. Norman Podhoretz edited the magazine from 1960 to 1995. His son, John Podhoretz, is the current editor. More on Wikipedia
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Trump said to Xi, 'I think as long as you and I are in charge of things, we will never have a problem.' As if the U.S. and the Communist slave-labor state are equal partners in leading a free global order."--from today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
November 19, @jpodhoretz recommends Watch How You Go by Rachel Ain
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
A similar gender-segregation trend has developed in the podcast world, with men the dominant audience for shows like The Joe Rogan Experience and This Past Weekend with Theo Von, and women forming the core audience (90 percent of listeners by some estimates) of shows like Call Her Daddy.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/online-gender… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This is Mamdani's first real action, unilateral mayoral action, to enshrine protest politics as the norm."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=XO4QG8pIOfY -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss the trilateral meeting in China with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin and what results we might expect Trump to deliver on Ukraine and Taiwan, the farce at the National Book Awards and the grim realities of the publishing industry, Abdul El-Sayed’s view of what Israel should be, a new poll reported by Axios shows strong support for Israel on the right, and the emergence of the leading republican candidates for 2028.
Plus, John recommends Rachel’s Ain’s Watch How You Go.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/try-lateral/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
A book that frames our current crisis primarily as a failure of dialogue is treating it as a communications problem awaiting better listeners.
www.commentary.org/articles/rabbiabraham/polarized-americ… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
My latest on El-Sayed's impossibly dim--but surprisingly revealing--comments about Israel's "faith" and "culture" www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/el-sayed-comes-clean/
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"How big was Nvidia's business using this backdoor through Southeast Asia? How reliant was the actual company on this?"
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=PBAij4pm6DU -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Post-election, El-Sayed’s denial of the Jewish right to self-determination has only gotten clearer.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/el-sayed-comes-clean/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We can only hope that the Rubio Doctrine is embraced in time for the West to ensure its future.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/marco-rubio-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Likud Party is not a prize easily won.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/succession-israel-style/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We welcome back stranded traveller @elianayjohnson to discuss the New York Times list of 10 days that changed the world, and which days we would have chosen instead, as well as Trump’s China trip on the backdrop of Ukraine destroying the Kerch bridge in Crimea and the emerging potential magnitude of the Nvidia scandal, the ongoing fight over neocons and “forever wars,” and Seth recommends the Shane MacGowen tribute album 20 Century Paddy.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/the-chips-are-down/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
For all Jacobson’s wit and verbal virtuosity, it was hard to imagine him making even remotely entertaining hay with our current discontents.
I could not have been more wrong.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-foreman/howl-october… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This isn't our fight. This is the Israeli electorate's fight."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=BFhsIPCivN0 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We may be seeing this dystopian future unfurling before us in real time at the present."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=XO4QG8pIOfY -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The ICC insists on its own legal immunity for actions taken in the legitimate pursuit of its court duties. It’s a perfectly reasonable argument if you imagine the ICC as a real court, rather than an NGO-like world body designed to evade basic principles of justice and sovereignty.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/israeli-hostage-families-b… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"As of this morning’s podcast, I was still leaning toward a combination of coincidence and incompetence. But soon afterward, there came news of Apple outages and the National Security Agency’s highly classified NSANet internal-communications network going down."--from today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Whether in Gaza, Lebanon, or Syria—though IDF operations in Syria are of a different sort than those relating to the October 7 war—the Israelis should decide where it is safe for them to stop and draw lines. They must also decide for themselves when those lines must be adjusted based on the illegal conduct of the other armies.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-uks-lies-about-green-l… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It could have been otherwise. Israel has agency, so it could have stopped partway. Much of its leadership wanted it to. That would have been agency of another kind.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/choice-to-act/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The party does seem to want to cut its nose off to spite its face."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=U-n2BlJs1pg -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
I understand the good faith behind statements like the following, we should do our best to avoid them:
“Clearly, people are entitled to express their opinions about policies of the Israeli government, but that’s not a reason to boycott Jewish-owned businesses.” -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @jpodhoretz, @AbeGreenwald, and @SethAMandel discuss the recent spat of outages including Microsoft Outlook, banks, and airlines, and whether we should trust administration officials who claim there is no cause for concern.
Plus, Zohran Mamdani disbands the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, will the quieter moderate democrats control the direction of the party over the flashier, fringe radical ones, and JD Vance’s ongoing strawman arguments on neocons and Iran.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/down-and-outage/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Turning to global perceptions of Israel, he relates a conversation he had over lunch with Yitzhak Rabin, then the prime minister. “The Arabs have succeeded in winning worldwide public support,” Bellow warns.
www.commentary.org/articles/bret-stephens/jerusalem-and-b… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Elissa Slotkin’s appeasement of the anti-Semites in her party isn’t brand new, but the truth is that her standing among Michigan’s Jews would have survived most of it intact, or only partially diminished. Her backing of Abdul El-Sayed, who rationalized an attempted massacre of Jewish children in Michigan, campaigned with a virulently anti-Semitic influencer, and blamed Jews for a rise in the price of eggs and bananas was entirely indefensible from a moral standpoint.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-fallout-from-slotkins-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"A loathing of Israel and a loathing of the United States is the ticket to entry into the DSA."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=BFhsIPCivN0 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If, as the saying goes, politics is downstream from culture, then we all knew this was coming. The parade of actors, artists, and musicians ritually pledging allegiance to the blood libel of genocide has, if anything, only gotten more intense, as if folks are afraid of being left out of all the Jew-baiting fun.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/woke-2-palestine-boogaloo/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Hasan is not just an Islamic supremacist but what the British call a “chancer,” an opportunist who exploits other people in underhanded ways to advance his own agenda.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/mehdi-hasan-th… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
November 16, @jpodhoretz recommends All in Your Head by Fredrick deBoer
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The December issue of Commentary is now available.
We analyze the repudiation of Trump’s GOP, NatCon’s betrayal of conservatism, the Palestine omnicause, the sociopathy of Elizabeth Holmes, the achievement of You Can See Everything, and much more.
With contributions from @NoahCRothman, @LekhtNaya, @srodan, @SpencerGuard, @NancyRomm, @jkirchick, @JSchanzer, @Claremch, @bstewart1776.
Read on at commentary.org and subscribe at commentary.org/subscribe. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Palestine lobby’s central plan is: Assume a Palestine.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/first-assume-a-palestine/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Next month, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear his case, Grand v. City of University Heights, Ohio, on December 9, 2026.
www.commentary.org/articles/edward-blum/jews-denied-right… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Nancy Rommelmann
@NancyRomm
Cover girl (thanks @jpodhoretz)! Does my decades-long dealings with sociopaths give me special insights into Elizabeth Holmes' manipulatory methods? Read the December issue of @Commentary and find out
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
“The Evil of NAZA,” my analysis of the outrageous claims and inferences pushed in the documentary Naza in @Commentary Magazine’s December 2026 issue. I try not to be surprised by the misinformation and disinformation that have been pushed about Israel’s operations in Gaza, but this film goes beyond anything I’ve seen yet. It tries to take good military practices and uses psychological tactics to convince a naive viewer that they are bad. Actually, the film barely touches on collateral damage and artificial intelligence, using those as launching points to demonize all IDF soldiers, the Israeli government, and all Israeli citizens with accusations of colonization, apartheid, genocide, and more. It directly calls Israeli citizens the new version of Germans during Nazi operations.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-spencer/naza-sensational… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: On this episode, recorded Sunday night, November 15th, we discuss the wave of newly-elected antisemites, and the complacency of some on the left regarding the possibility of their radicalism finding its way into law considering the horseshoe effect and their like-minded colleagues on the right.
Plus, the renewed signs of the Iranian arena heating up and whether Trump will pursue further action despite the war’s unpopularity, the public airing of the divisions within the Trump cabinet over the Nvidia export controls scandal, Marco Rubio’s political future, and the collapse of trust in authority after the nationwide air traffic system failure. @jpodhoretz also recommends Fredrik DeBoer’s All in Your Head.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/china-cabinet/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Who is the American government? Come January, the U.S. will have a Democratic Congress and a Republican White House. Many of the articles offering advice to the Israeli opposition are thinking solely about the former, not the latter. But a new premier cannot afford to alienate President Trump.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/does-eisenkot-know-which-a… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Congress does not have explicit oversight power. It doesn't have explicit subpoena power."
Watch the full episode joined by Adam J. White of AEI: www.youtube.com/watch?v=U-n2BlJs1pg -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Three years after October 7, Israelis continue to wonder how it was that their leaders so easily deluded themselves with the conceptzia.
www.commentary.org/articles/gil-troy/american-jews-break-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This is the fifth major Chinese subversion case in the past decade."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=neEjp01pQ_s -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
So Iraq, Afghanistan, and Iran—wars we won that didn’t take “forever.”
www.commentary.org/articles/abe-greenwald/forever-war-is-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This gender divide in content creation and consumption has had significant cultural consequences.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/online-gender… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Commitment and courage are among the most important qualities that anyone can possess."
Read our full Reader Commentary:
www.commentary.org/articles/reader-letters/reader-comment… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"It's Obama idiocy on steroids."
Watch the full episode with @jschanzer: www.youtube.com/watch?v=EBjPIDA4Puo -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"We have no choice but to win the AI race against China (and others). But if that means moving so quickly and with such careless players in key positions that China gets our secrets, what are we really doing?"--from today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
These cases raise difficult questions about agency and responsibility, both for the woman charged (Clancy) and the woman bringing civil charges (the “Jane Doe” in the Cornell case). Also notable is how swiftly the gender divide emerged in both cases. In the media and online, men and women are not only arguing about the facts in each case; they seem to be living in completely different moral universes.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/online-gender… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Noah Rothman
@NoahCRothman
I had the privilege of co-authoring @commentary’s post-mortem on 2026 with @jpodhoretz – an attempt at a comprehensive look at a comprehensive rebuke of Donald Trump’s GOP. www.commentary.org/articles/noah-rothman/voters-repudiate…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Hegseth has been metaphorically dropping high-level senior officers out of a helicopter."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLW_wzveOAs -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If the only professional avenue for people who cross this bridge from poverty into elite higher education is in chronicling their cultural alienation, what on earth has been accomplished?
www.commentary.org/articles/naomi-schaefer-riley/all-that… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @AEI's Adam White joins us today to discuss the White House counsel warning democrats against investigations of the Trump administration that may involve “criminality” and the historical context of congressional oversight, and Chris Van Hollen’s efforts to prevent Chuck Schumer from becoming Senate Majority Leader.
Plus, a look at the silver linings of the Trump administration.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/good-luck-chuck/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The AI boom is getting increasingly controversial, unpopular and worrisome to the American people."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=neEjp01pQ_s -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Chevalier helped found Columbia University Apartheid Divest (CUAD). When Hamas launched its war against Israel by massacring over a thousand innocents on October 7, 2023, Chevalier responded by attending a rally the next day that celebrated the slaughter. From there, she jumped into her alma mater’s anti-Semitic activism.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/welcome-to-congress-univer… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Vance himself has contributed mightily to the anti-Israel fever that he now blames for GOP losses."--from today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Interestingly, another individual to make this point was…Marco Rubio.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/marco-rubio-… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Hey, it had to happen. Vance has spent a good year sucking up to media figures who’ve orchestrated a right-wing revolt against the Trump administration." --from today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
JD Vance is a figure of ridicule among America's enemies, but especially in Tehran. His demotion was necessary and inevitable. My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/vance-lost-his-iran-talks-…
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
November 12, @continetti recommends Jews vs. Rome by @barrystrauss
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Many of the voters who backed Slotkin voted against El-Sayed.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/self-respect-is-obligatory/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Everything noxious about Hasan—his deception, his moral equivocation, his whataboutery —is on display in this post.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/mehdi-hasan-th… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @continetti joins us to discuss Jensen Huang’s resignation from Nvidia after further infidelity allegations were uncovered, its economic and geopolitical implications, and whether the scandal is much larger than anyone realized considering other Chinese efforts to undermine the American AI sector.
Plus, Trump takes Vance off the foreign policy beat, White House counsel Will Scharf’s warning to democrats, and Matt recommends Jews vs. Rome by Barry Strauss.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/huang-the-dog/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
@jschanzer: "You have about 10 weeks for Donald Trump to have whatever freedom of action he has before it expires."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=EBjPIDA4Puo -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Every moment of action contributed to an astonishing victory.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/choice-to-act/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are joined by @FDD's @JSchanzer from Jerusalem on this Veteran’s Day to discuss President Trump’s announcement that the Iran war is “effectively over” and whether that is the last word on the conflict, the failed attempt to impeach Pete Hegseth, and the ramifications of JD Vance’s vision for the region and the future of the country.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/the-jdpoa/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Stanley Zabar, 1932-2026 www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/stanley-zabar-1932-2026/
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Look at what the Jews and their allies did in Philadelphia, repeat it, grow it, and don’t stop. Show up everywhere. Outnumber the scum and get in their faces. Above all, be brave. Don’t steer clear of targeted businesses or neighborhoods or shuls. Don’t change your life one bit to accommodate the thugs." --from today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Her refusal to let anti-Semitism become partisan property is the most valuable quality of the book.
www.commentary.org/articles/rabbiabraham/polarized-americ… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"That's a pretty telling indicator that maybe you want to go to the polls and pull your lever for the other guy and not the party in power."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=GLW_wzveOAs -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The virtue of telling people to recognize something and then build it is that you don’t have to think about any of the details. What are the borders of this recognized state? If you told a developer to build a house on a specific block but refused to delineate the relevant property lines, how might that work out? Not well.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/first-assume-a-palestine/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
But Draxler’s predicament is not just a question of fear and the reasons for it. He is dealing with overwhelming disillusionment.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-foreman/howl-october… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"He's going to do whatever he can to try to collect as many heads on a pike as he can.
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=6V-f7t5UfkE -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Contributing editor @EliLake is back to discuss Trump’s 60 Minutes interview with Ross Douthat, the merits of the articles of impeachment against Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, the appointment of Stephen Miller as White House Chief of Staff, the counter protestors at the antisemitic Philadelphia bike protest, and the Chinese honeypotting of Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang.
Plus, John recommends I Play Rocky.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/trump-cant-douthat/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"While it’s true that Trump likes to back winners abroad, he has built his political career on the resentments of losers at home." --from today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
And here we come to the weirdest part of this book, which has gone unremarked thus far in its interestingly hostile reception: His examples do not represent the views he wants them to.
www.commentary.org/articles/david-wolpe/anti-zionism-jewi… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
My latest on how the Israeli elections are their own version of Likudnik Succession: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/succession-israel-style/
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If you're the CEO of America in competition with the CEO of China, first order of business on day one: buy Israel."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast with special guest @ambdermer: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sj5N9U6tSZ4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
No matter who’s head of government, the head of the Likud Party will be the same person who has held that position since 2005: Benjamin Netanyahu.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/succession-israel-style/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The stakes in this case reach well beyond one Ohio suburb.
www.commentary.org/articles/edward-blum/jews-denied-right… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @jpodhoretz is joined by 2026 Commentary roastee, former Israeli ambassador to the US @AmbDermer, to discuss the state of affairs for Israel in the current moment, the prospects of an anti-American US president, and the massive drawbacks of America rolling back its relationship with Israel due to the rising tide of anti-America and anti-Israel hatred in academia and politics.
Plus, a breakdown of the coalition building efforts in Israel after Gadi Eisenkot was tasked with forming a new government, and how might that government differ from the Netanyahu government.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/state-of-the-jews/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Ford administration, along with prominent commentators who speak for it, are growing weary of what they see as Jerusalem’s recalcitrance in the face of American diplomatic maneuvers, leading Israelis to fret constantly about whether their only true ally is about to turn on them.
www.commentary.org/articles/bret-stephens/jerusalem-and-b… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The Republican party is 80% supportive of Israel. That's your party."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=6V-f7t5UfkE -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Not only are our forever wars over, but the United States won them. Abroad.
Domestically—no.
www.commentary.org/articles/abe-greenwald/forever-war-is-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There's this idea that it doesn't matter how things are done. All that matters is the ideology."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=J4njMs5jV7I -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
No one doubts that Netanyahu has moved on from the conceptzia itself. That cannot readily be said of many American Jewish organizations and prominent American Jewish individuals.
www.commentary.org/articles/gil-troy/american-jews-break-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
For years now, the creative community has worried that artificial intelligence will write our scripts, direct our movies, and generally suck the soul out of the business. I share the worry. But almost nobody has asked the obvious question, which is whether the machines might be better suited to the other side of the building.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/ai-replacing-showbiz… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This gender divide in content creation and consumption has had significant cultural consequences.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/online-gender… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Trump lost Hispanic voters by five points in 2024. Republicans are on track to lose them by 27 points in 2026."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=8DcVvjXGp34 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Change came fast. Her application to transfer to a few four-year colleges was in part a response to these events.
www.commentary.org/articles/naomi-schaefer-riley/all-that… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The reason I identify Hasan as “nominally left-wing” is because while he has become one of the most influential commentators on the American left, he spends very little time drawing attention to the sorts of issues that have traditionally engrossed American leftists.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are joined by our Washington commentary columnist @jkirchick to discuss the rising tide against Jews on both sides of the political spectrum and JD Vance pinning republican problems on the relationship with Israel despite polling data to the contrary, and hanging his hopes on the radical podcast sphere of influence.
Plus, can democrats build a case against Trump that could convince senate republicans to convict, or will they focus on flashier moves to satiate their more radical base?
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/advance-notice/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
November 5, @EliLake recommends Haley Stevens
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"He is now going to run simultaneously as Trump's heir and Trump's chief critic."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=J4njMs5jV7I -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Capra’s most richly rewarded film was It Happened One Night (1934), the storyline of which was pretty much a genre all its own in the 1930s.
www.commentary.org/articles/bruce-bawer/frank-capra-filmm… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This is the problem that Republicans have from coast to coast. Many of their voters are happy to let them suffer."
Watch the full episode, featuring @ChrisStirewalt: www.youtube.com/watch?v=yB-icvwjlXw -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
His design was to take 250 Gilad Shalits and use them to break Israel’s heart and Israel’s spirit. The attack and the hostage-taking would trigger his allies north of Israel, Hezbollah, to act as well and bring about an uprising among Palestinians on the West Bank and perhaps Arab citizens living inside Israel itself. And then, perhaps, this sponsor, the great regional power in Tehran, would deliver the final blow.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/choice-to-act/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Contributing editor @EliLake is back to discuss the election postmortems and the Republican recriminations after their stunning defeat, how big a part did the Iran war play in voter dissatisfaction with the GOP, and the factional dispute within the right and its impact on JD Vance’s chances in 2028.
Plus, how can Jews respond to these negative trends?
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/the-blame-game-4/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Trump was elected because of the inflation, and he has not solved the inflation."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=8DcVvjXGp34 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Kwall is less interested in cataloguing division than in overcoming it.
www.commentary.org/articles/rabbiabraham/polarized-americ… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There is a recurring historical pattern in which the zenith of Jewish thriving becomes the precipice for Jewish existence.
www.commentary.org/articles/bret-stephens/jerusalem-and-b… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Anti-Semitic campaigns used to require some effort, some commitment. Now online Jew-baiting and blacklisting are moving into their Jetsons era, a futuristic digital playground. If you thought anti-Semites were ignorant before, just wait till they fully indulge their laziest instincts.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/training-a-i-to-be-anti-zi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In Europe and the U.S., far-left critics of Israel “are not overtly anti-Semitic” but discuss the country using “the Marxist-Leninist categories: finance capital, colonialism, and imperialism.”
www.commentary.org/articles/bret-stephens/jerusalem-and-b… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Jewish self-respect nearly stopped El-Sayed in the primaries and made him a much weaker candidate in the general.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/self-respect-is-obligatory/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"You can be extraordinarily hostile to the media and they will stay on your side as your cheerleaders no matter what."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ZplSDx2PIk -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Matthew Continetti
@continetti
Today's episode @commentary: Democrats ride a blue wave. Plus, I make a recommendation. www.commentary.org/noam-blum/wave-goodbye/
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @continetti is back to discuss the massive GOP wipeout in the midterm elections, analyze the causes for the historic loss, look ahead to the next two years in Washington, and drill down on individual race results across the country.
Plus, Matt recommends Fodor’s Florida Travel guide.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/wave-goodbye/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
November 3, @elianayjohnson recommends The Questions Adam Hamawy Won't Answer by @powellAtlantic
www.theatlantic.com/politics/2026/11/adam-hamawy-congress… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The stickers, which were first distributed in the 1980s, are primarily virtue-signaling devices—pre-internet advocacy emojis."--from today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The real point is to plant the idea that Americans are going hungry because of the Jews.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-semitic-ad-inspir… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
@ChrisStirewalt: "Convenience voting, a 30-year trend, is pernicious and bad for the country."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=yB-icvwjlXw -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
And here we come to the weirdest part of this book, which has gone unremarked thus far in its interestingly hostile reception: His examples do not represent the views he wants them to.
www.commentary.org/articles/david-wolpe/anti-zionism-jewi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Before World War II, Warsaw was home for nearly 20 years to a Yiddish theater museum. How is there not a proper brick-and-mortar Yiddish theater museum in New York today? There’s an idea for Gov. Hochul.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/who-are-jewish-museums-for/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The combination of confusion, frustration, fear, despair, and rage that has tormented Jacobson in the days and months after October 7 (he told an interviewer that the aftermath of the massacre turned him half mad, that he could not sleep and found himself shouting at the television, the radio, and the newspapers) has brought out the best in him. Howl combines his novelistic and essayistic gifts in a bitterly funny, savagely perceptive satire, overflowing with diamond-sharp epigrams.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-foreman/howl-october… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Once you conclude that your fellow citizens are complicit in a genocide, anything is possible."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-B-cgfHjfA -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israelis tend to be security-minded, and those seeking security know that they cannot get it by letting Palestinian negotiators endlessly drag them along a process with no end point.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/israelis-took-no-for-an-an… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s election day and we are joined by our friend @ChrisStirewalt to discuss the seemingly impending blue wave and all the ways in which Trump contributed to the expected loss of the senate, whether the polls might be historically wrong, Haley Stevens’ statement on her endorsement of Mike Rogers, Ross Douthat’s excellent interviewing skills, and a look ahead to the potential democratic nominee in 2028.
Plus, Trump’s statement on an agreement to end military aid to Israel and how it might undercut candidates who ran on ending it legislatively, and the crew recommends Michael Powell’s @TheAtlantic article on Adam Hamawy.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/wave-watch/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
Haley Stevens offered "a beautiful real-world illustration of Midge Decter’s wonderful insight: 'There comes a time when you need to join the side you’re on.' Realizing that she was already on the side of decency, Stevens felt morally obliged to 'join' that side."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There's an attempt to gaslight people into thinking that Haley Stevens is unstable."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ZplSDx2PIk -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To which city, then, is America indebted—Jerusalem or Athens? The answer, of course, is both.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/marco-rubio-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
So: As it stands, Bibi hasn’t been defeated.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-bibi-opposition-c… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The city convened an online YouTube session on March 4, 2021, attended by more than 100 residents, during which Grand’s religious practices were openly disparaged. “I am not Jewish, and I do not want our neighborhood labeled as Jewish,” said one of his neighbors.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The amount of effort the media puts into obscuring what it knows to be the truth is astounding. All for the transparent purpose of helping to elect a progressive anti-Semite.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/democrats-day-of-rage/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
November 2, @jpodhoretz and @AbeGreenwald recommend Great Performances: Jimmy Webb
www.pbs.org/video/jimmy-webb-american-songwriter-gi3uf8/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
They still killed Israelis, but they were prevented from killing many more by the checkpoint. Thank God for checkpoints—temporary and permanent ones alike.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/terror-and-vindication-in-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are joined by @JNS_org's @RuthieBlum from Tel Aviv to discuss tomorrow’s impending midterm election and the hoopla in Michigan over Haley Stevens endorsing Mike Rogers and the ridiculous reactions from democrats.
Plus, Israel’s elections are over, and now the process of coalition-building begins with Avigdor Lieberman refusing to serve with Netanyahu, thus all but ensuring another round of elections.
Finally, what the future holds for Trump with regards to Iran and the prospects of facing a democratic majority in the House and Senate, and @jpodhoretz and @AbeGreenwald recommend the PBS Great Performances episode on the songwriter Jimmy Webb.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/even-stevens/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Just about every part of Israel's economy is overregulated, overcentralized, and overtaxed, with the exception of the tech economy."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=s-B-cgfHjfA -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It has indeed been a disillusioning period, since many of the institutions American Jews both shaped and venerated over the past century have been the choreographers of today’s anti-Semitic, anti-Zionist mania—from the universities to the media to the publishing houses to the art world to Hollywood and the Democratic Party.
www.commentary.org/articles/gil-troy/american-jews-break-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In 2001, according to the Pew Research Center, 55 percent of American adults were using the internet. Five years earlier, the figure had been just 22 percent. The online world was becoming the American world. And as it did, it started transforming our relationship not only to information but to reality itself.
www.commentary.org/articles/abe-greenwald/forever-war-is-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The issue is the Democratic party just says Israel now and what they really mean is Jews."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=uCIOICfCUZ0 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It would be nice to see the Adam Brody types of the world display a bit of self-respect here and there.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/revenge-of-the-bubbes/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We have become expert at detecting the moral failures of the opposing camp while developing elaborate explanations for the failures of our own.
www.commentary.org/articles/rabbiabraham/polarized-americ… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If you're the left, at a certain point here, you have to realize that you just don't have the demographic numbers."
Watch the full episode with @benshapiro: www.youtube.com/watch?v=zs8uZp7e990 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In the entertainment industry, the budget line item for executive compensation has ballooned beyond rational efficiency.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/ai-replacing-showbiz… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It would be an interesting experiment to have a UN secretary-general who has some desire to see actual improvement in the Middle East.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/secretary-general-lana-nus… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If Moser’s anti-Zionist poster boy doesn’t want Israel to be destroyed, is he really an effective representative of anti-Zionist views, which at the very least are dedicated to the ending of the Jewish state?
www.commentary.org/articles/david-wolpe/anti-zionism-jewi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“Nowhere in my pictures,” boasted Capra in 1941, “will you find defeat or futility.”
www.commentary.org/articles/bruce-bawer/frank-capra-filmm… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“Referring specifically to Gaza, he stated: ‘A young person’s opposition to the Gaza genocide and scrutiny of the Israeli government are not, in themselves, antisemitic.’”
This is highly revealing.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/once-again-the-teachers-un… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Matthew Continetti
@continetti
Fantastic episode today @commentary with special guest @dansenor on Israel's election; the Michigan Senate race; and the U.S. midterms. Plus, I recommend ways to remember Patrick Stewart.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/sub-parliament/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are joined by @dansenor and @continetti to discuss the final vote totals in Israel’s elections and the prospects of forming a new government, and how will potential new coalitions deal with Israel’s geopolitical challenges?
Plus, the issue of rising antisemitism in the leadup to the midterms, the problem with polling rural conservatives, Haley Stevens’ message to Abdul El-Sayed, and Matt honors the late Patrick Stewart by recommending the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode The Inner Light and his general body of work.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/sub-parliament/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There's another element of this that bothers me, which is the idea that you're voting for the party and not the man."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=uCIOICfCUZ0 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"'Discreet' acts of genocide . . . I don't even know what those are."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=dYFIuxb6Vts -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Anti-Semitic campaigns used to require some effort, some commitment. Now online Jew-baiting and blacklisting are moving into their Jetsons era, a futuristic digital playground. If you thought anti-Semites were ignorant before, just wait till they fully indulge their laziest instincts.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/training-a-i-to-be-anti-zi… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"When a new cause bubbles up, the potential activist asks himself what’s in it for him. Consciously or not, he works out a few things: Will this make me look good? Will I be more accepted by others? Will my conscience be soothed? Will it raise my status or increase my power? And, maybe most important, will it be cost-free or even fun?"--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Suspicion, anxiety, hostility, and fear are experiences described by another woman from a previous century who also wrote about a woman-only space, albeit one far more menacing than Woolf’s imagined room of one’s own.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/online-gender… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Things didn’t work out quite as he expected. When he told his classmates where he was from, “the news was received much like the gift of a wounded bird—gorgeous and vulnerable and not long for this world.” He goes on: “I’m so sorry, I heard more than once. You’re so lucky you made it out, I heard as well.” He was pitied and isolated. By the time he had graduated, he didn’t belong in the world of Leech Lake—or the world of Princeton.
www.commentary.org/articles/naomi-schaefer-riley/all-that… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The other day, a Palestinian appeared to be caught on video trying to kill Knesset candidate Fleur Hassan by throwing a football-sized jagged rock through her car window while she and others were driving through Judea and Samaria.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/pyromania-from-paris-to-pa… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Contributing editor @EliLake joins us today to correct the record on Jon Lovett’s comments on Michigan Jews and Abdul El-Sayed, and discuss the larger implications of centering Israel in US politics and the different flavors of antisemitism on the left and right as both parties struggle with their own cohorts in the approach to the midterms.
Is there any cause for optimism going forward, or do even darker days lie ahead?
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/the-antisemitism-horseshoe/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Is this moment one that calls for Holocaust memorials or is there some better way to meet the challenge? Perhaps now would be a great time to build a memorial or a museum to some element of Jewish vibrancy. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/who-are-jewish-museums-for/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
@officialbenshapiro: "The thing for Americans and people outside Israel to understand . . . Israeli elections are not about you."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=zs8uZp7e990 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"People are talking themselves into supporting an obviously unfit candidate just to stop Republicans."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_aMoIKEyno -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Rubio is following in Churchill’s footsteps.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/marco-rubio-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
As it stands, Bibi hasn’t been defeated. In Israeli politics, that means it’s time for the opposition to see if they can go around Bibi instead of through him.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-bibi-opposition-c… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There are freedom-loving Muslims around the world who would make fine American citizens. Mehdi Hasan fails the test.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/mehdi-hasan-th… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @benshapiro joins us today to discuss the results of the Israeli election, where the anti-Bibi coalition underperformed and likely denied Eisenkot the prime ministership. Can Netanyahu form a new type of coalition or rely on Smotrich, Ben Gvir, and the ultra orthodox parties, and what might another round of elections look like if he can’t?
Plus, the election results as viewed through the prism of American politics, and @jpodhoretz recommends the movie Confession.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/coalition-building/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
October 27, @jpodhoretz recommends The Cheesecake Factory
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"They hate it because it is because it exists and that none of the policies will actually change."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=dYFIuxb6Vts -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We should not blame Zelensky for refusing to allow his country to be overrun, destroyed, and erased from the map.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-zelensky-can-learn-fr… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The sub-Rothian sexual humor that marred some of his earlier work has been burned away by fury and sorrow, even as familiar Jacobsonian tropes and themes—a nebbish protagonist, a half-mad brother, a mysterious mother, a tolerant shiksa wife, an errant daughter, treacherous colleagues—remain present. But here they serve a greater purpose.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-foreman/howl-october… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Does it require an astonishing level of innumeracy and economic ignorance to believe that when the U.S. gives Israel vouchers to buy weapons from American manufacturers—thus expanding American jobs and American manufacturing—it’s somehow taking eggs and bananas out of the mouths of theoretical Abdul El-Sayed voters?
Yes, it does.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-semitic-ad-inspir… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
All was going according to plan—until the Houthis struck the main airport in Riyadh, killing over a dozen and injuring hundreds and forcing flight cancellations.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-high-cost-of-saudi-pride/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Every moment of action contributed to an astonishing victory.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/choice-to-act/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: The Israeli election is in full swing with the highest turnout in 50 years. What will this mean for the Arab parties, Netanyahu’s chances of survival, and will an Eisenkot victory expose American leftists who claim to only be anti-Bibi?
Plus, the midterms loom large with the Michigan race seemingly tied and reports that early voting turnout in the state is down.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/let-it-bibi/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Barrack was laying the groundwork for a partial American retreat from its responsibilities in the Middle East. But he did so at a time that once again raises the familiar question: On what planet does Tom Barrack currently reside?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-planet-is-tom-barrack… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Up until now, her response to anybody who asked that question was, 'You're a bigot. What an absurd question. How dare you?'"
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=_3NQQwqkEJI -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Not everyone is comfortable risking the Hamasniks’ backlash or one of Javier Bardem’s blacklists to defend the Jews from the latest blood libel. But those who are comfortable doing so unapologetically have lately been, like Feldshuh, straight-talking Jewish women of bubbe-ish vintage.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/revenge-of-the-bubbes/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"He's not going to apologize. He's not going to say he did anything wrong."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_aMoIKEyno -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Wouldn’t a self-respecting journalist resent El-Sayed’s brazenly lying to her?
"Yes, a self-respecting journalist would."--From today's newsletter -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
October 26, @jpodhoretz strongly recommends The Imaginary Invalid
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In Europe and the U.S., far-left critics of Israel “are not overtly anti-Semitic” but discuss the country using “the Marxist-Leninist categories: finance capital, colonialism, and imperialism.”
www.commentary.org/articles/bret-stephens/jerusalem-and-b… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israelis tend to be security-minded, and those seeking security know that they cannot get it by letting Palestinian negotiators endlessly drag them along a process with no end point. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/israelis-took-no-for-an-an… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If Western Europeans are going to adopt the keffiyeh as the modern symbol of woke capitalism, I suppose it’s only fair that the pro-Palestinian movement hijacks the remembrance poppy.
Though there is one telling difference: The keffiyeh symbolizes violence, the poppy longs for peace.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-revolution-will-be-acc… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
So Iraq, Afghanistan, and Iran—wars we won that didn’t take “forever.” But here’s the thing: America has been fighting a forever war for the past quarter century. We’ve just misidentified it. It’s the culture.
www.commentary.org/articles/abe-greenwald/forever-war-is-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are back on this Monday to discuss tomorrow’s Israeli election and next week’s midterm election in the US, and whether other international electoral trends will come into play in both after Lula’s victory in the Brazilian election, and a series of violent riots in European cities.
Plus, the comments by Obama and Elissa Slotkin, Abdul El-Sayed’s confrontation with Bret Baier, Ilhan Omar’s new ad, fake polling firms, the Young Turks recycle their old antisemitic ad, and @jpodhoretz recommends The Imaginary Invalid on Broadway.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/electoral-collage/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Their immigrants from Somalia who came took the Minnesota taxpayer for a sucker."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=_3NQQwqkEJI -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The bureaucratic runaround that Toras Chaim endured is what the city of University Heights is hoping to impose on Grand and his Jewish neighbors.
www.commentary.org/articles/edward-blum/jews-denied-right… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There are hunter-killer drones, kamikaze drones, mine-laying drones, mine-detecting drones, even “dragon drones” equipped with flamethrowers that bring a touch of Game of Thrones to the conversation. Uncrewed machines dominate virtually every strategic and tactical operation and scenario in the conflict. According to the Institute for the Study of War, uncrewed ground vehicles (UGVs) and airborne drones account for up to 90 percent of military activity in “hot” combat zones like Pokrovsk.
www.commentary.org/articles/arthur-herman/ukraine-drones-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Indeed, as more and more American Jews have internalized the mass mania demonizing Benjamin Netanyahu, they have also seemed to sour on Zionism, implicitly joining those who place the onus on Israel for the burgeoning anti-Semitism worldwide.
www.commentary.org/articles/gil-troy/american-jews-break-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
When a political figure emerges as a harsh critic of Israel, there is an instinctive circling of wagons around him, even when he don’t exactly radiate good faith.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/anti-semites-waste-so-much… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The American people believe Russia is their enemy and the American people are sympathetic with Ukraine."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=8EOY-n61bHc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The trajectory of New York DSA co-chair Gustavo Gordillo is an almost too perfect example.
www.commentary.org/articles/jesse-arm/dsa-religion-substi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Why would they think he had control over U.S. foreign policy? Perhaps because he indicated that he had precisely those powers when he threatened to J. Edgar Hoover the NYPD on Bibi Netanyahu.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/you-hate-to-see-it/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"It's not the Democratic party in Minnesota. It's the Democratic Farmer Labor Party and the farmers and the laborers have switched sides."
Watch the full episode featuring @SteveKornacki: www.youtube.com/watch?v=qkDJXZmZNQc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Harvard professor Cass Sunstein is a liberal, not a progressive, but he has come to make a first-principles case for a robust conception of the separation of powers.
www.commentary.org/articles/tal-fortgang/separation-of-po… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The war with Hezbollah, including the “Grim Beeper” operation and the air strikes that killed longtime leader Hassan Nasrallah a year after the Hamas invasion, is described in terrific detail.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/israel-war-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
No one forced the Palestinians to reject a hundred years’ worth of peace deals. No one is forcing them now to reject self-government. And no one is forcing them to follow a national strategy of murdering civilians. But so long as they are, Israel must defend innocent life.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/terror-and-vindication-in-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In an era of widespread ignorance of and dismissiveness toward the subject of warfare, this emphasis on the utility of force, or the threat of force, is refreshing. Cohen’s call for “a new look at the problem of strategic thought and action” is especially timely because the concept of “strategy” has been promiscuously abused of late, and the word itself, as he sagely warns, “is in danger of losing its meaning.”
www.commentary.org/articles/brian-stewart/strategist-war-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Why does the tantrum of a mopey Marxist mediocrity matter to the big picture?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/sally-rooneys-self-boycott… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
By setting this scene in a war zone, Oppenheim also allows us to remember that the Kaddish—a faithful declaration and prayer for the further sanctification of God’s name—reflects not only the memory of those who have passed but faith in the face of mortality itself.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss the posthumous exposé on Lindsay Graham’s sexuality by The Young Turks, as well as Ilhan Omar’s legal troubles and the questions on her identity and immigration status breaking through after years of being dismissed as a racist conspiracy theory.
Plus, the Free Beacon exposes anti-Israel activists’ “olive harvest” racket in the West Bank after Brad Lander’s latest stunt, the backfiring of Vivek Ramaswamy’s inflammatory ad, and @jpodhoretz recommends the comedian Yohay Sponder’s Genesis tour.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/nightmare-on-elmi-street/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Progressive education theory increasingly sees political instruction as more important than helping children build knowledge and skills. And so the UK’s largest such union has flatly rejected the recommendation that they facilitate a reduction in anti-Semitism. @SethAMandel
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Welcome to the Middle East and have a nice day."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=8EOY-n61bHc -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The truth is often disturbing but always necessary. Its revelation brings reality back into focus. I appreciate such moments."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
America has been fighting a forever war for the past quarter century. We’ve just misidentified it. It’s the culture. And unlike the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and Iran, there’s no reason to believe that this one will ever end.
www.commentary.org/articles/abe-greenwald/forever-war-is-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Lana Nusseibeh is, like any potential UN honcho, a lacerating critic of Israel’s stewardship over Judea and Samaria, which the Palestinians call by its modern Jordanian moniker the West Bank. But thanks to the Abraham Accords, she also represents the framework of normalization with and recognition of Israel. That gives her an unusual level of credibility on both sides. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/secretary-general-lana-nus… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
October 22, @continetti recommends The Strategist by Eliot A. Cohen
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There is no single settlement or law that can solve these challenges.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/meta-settleme… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"You can't vote for Amy Acton according to Amy Acton's mother."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qej-cm-N0h8 -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Matthew Continetti
@continetti
Great discussion today @commentary with special guest star @JSchanzer on Iran, Ukraine, and the Michigan Senate race. Plus, I make a recommendation.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/brink-and-mortars/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friends @continetti of the @WSJ and @JSchanzer of @FDD join us today to discuss Saudi Arabia’s Houthi bind, the possibility of the entire region being dragged into the conflict, the controversy over the shutdown of Starshield, which limited Ukraine’s ability to strike Russia, and the possibility of renewed Israeli/American offensives on Iran.
Plus, more election talk, and Matt recommends The Strategist by Eliot A. Cohen.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/brink-and-mortars/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If you believed that Israel was committing genocide, that it was creating a famine in Gaza, killing journalists and medical workers wantonly, and many other discredited conspiracies, you have been fully abandoned by Hamas.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/hamas-joins-the-zionist-ha… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
As more and more American Jews have internalized the mass mania demonizing Benjamin Netanyahu, they have also seemed to sour on Zionism, implicitly joining those who place the onus on Israel for the burgeoning anti-Semitism worldwide.
What kinds of people keep siding with their sworn enemies?
www.commentary.org/articles/gil-troy/american-jews-break-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Western civilization no longer bows down to physical idols, but we undoubtedly place products, people, and even nature itself on a pedestal and offer them worshipful praise that blinds us to their shortcomings.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-rosen/rabbi-schlanger… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
October 21, @jpodhoretz once again recommends Slow Horses
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The joke in the newsroom, acceptable only because its subject’s monstrousness was unquestionable, went as follows: What were Robert Maxwell’s last words? Rose-blub.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-riedel/ill-tell-ya-wh… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Brad Lander’s stunt was reminiscent of the self-humiliation ritual performed by Democratic Rep. Ro Khanna. In July, Khanna’s vehicle was temporarily stopped by the IDF in a military zone. Khanna had been trying to provoke settler violence, failed, and his companion released video showing that Khanna’s story about being detained was a fairytale.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/pyromania-from-paris-to-pa… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
As of this writing, Russia is losing eight troops for every one Ukrainian fatality, according to the Center for Strategic and International Studies, and Russian troop deaths now stand at more than 450,000, with total casualties as high as 1.4 million.
www.commentary.org/articles/irina-velitskaya/russia-ukrai… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Palestinianism is just a reflection of 'I hate the West, I hate my my society and I want to burn it down.'"
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=vaXYJxrHYiU -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: NBC news analyst @SteveKornacki joins us today to discuss his “Kornacki Cam” and election night coverage, and to offer his predictions and historical perspective on some key races for house, senate, and governor.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/candy-kornacki/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The main point is that Obama has Jimmy Carter Syndrome. Carter held two beliefs about Israeli-Palestinian peace: first, that Israel doesn’t want it; second, that ultimately a peace deal is about Jimmy Carter, not Israel or the Palestinians. So he spent much of his long post-presidency crusading against the Jewish state.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/obamas-grudge/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This is a major crisis for Macron's leadership."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qej-cm-N0h8 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The U.S. is at war with Iran. Perhaps members of the administration would reject that terminology in order to preserve the president’s freedom of action regarding congressional oversight, but it is the reality of the situation. Some of Iran’s militias regularly fire on U.S. positions from outside Iran, killing Americans. Is it Barrack’s position that these militias aren’t America’s problem?
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-planet-is-tom-barrack… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"There’s a stronger response to El-Sayed’s 'Why are you asking me?' jiu-jitsu, and it goes like this:"--Today's newsletter in full.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What can Zelensky do to mitigate the risk that the president’s volatile mood swings pose to Ukraine? @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-zelensky-can-learn-fr… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Yuppies were paid handsomely for their abuse and found themselves with gobs of disposable income, which they disposed of in two ways that shifted the cultural and geographic landscape of New York: food and real estate.
www.commentary.org/articles/rick-marin/yuppies-conquered-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To most Americans, the proposition that natal males ought to be able to participate in girls’ athletics is one of those things that is so foolish as to require no explanation.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/seth-moulton-d… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Donald Trump backs down when he faces political blowback . . . we've seen it over and over again."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=1-JQwP6nibA -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Macron is not a victim. Did he really expect Abbas to hold elections when he said he would?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/palestine-is-canceled/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss Vivek Ramaswamy’s new anti-Amy Acton ad in the Ohio gubernatorial race starring Acton’s mother and the injection of intra-family conflict into politics, as well as the ongoing unrest in France and Italy, Benny Gantz withdrawing from the Israeli elections, Pete Hegseth’s unannounced visit to Israel, JD Vance’s foreign endorsement hypocrisy, and the prospects of an attack on Iran prior to the elections.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/family-dramaswamy/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Riots in which some hoist the Palestinian flag around monuments while others deface symbols of France such as the bust of Marianne produce a curious inversion. One can’t help but remember that these folks are the most likely to accuse Jews of dual loyalty. @SethAMandel
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The culture war just morphs and changes and shifts and takes on new topics, but it's the same fight."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=vaXYJxrHYiU -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The November issue of Commentary is now available.
Why liberal Jews need to reject the left, why the culture war is never-ending, and more.
With contributions from @AbeGreenwald, @jkirchick, @NaomiSRiley, @rcbl, @jpodhoretz.
Read on at commentary.org and subscribe at commentary.org/subscribe. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Here’s the Hollywood happy ending: An independent distributor called Ketchup Entertainment—a name I did not make up—bought the film for $50 million, released it at the end of August, and the movie became an end-of-summer hit. The Ketchup Entertainment team executed a perfect one-two: They released a big success into theaters, and they proved that studio executives and their financial predictions are almost always wrong.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/coyote-vs-acme-warne… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Saudis are currently treating their Houthi problem as an episode of Ted Lasso, hoping it can be solved by the mysterious appearance of a natural-born striker. And while the world would be a better place with more Ted Lassos in it, we’re not quite there yet. @SethAMandel
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
PRIZE identifies the five distinct ways Jews experience and express their identity.
www.commentary.org/articles/jeffrey-lax/fighting-anti-sem… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Contributing editor @EliLake is back on this Monday to discuss the upheaval in France and the influence of Palestinianism and the “globalize the intifada” movement and how this will impact the upcoming French elections, as well as the warning signs to America with the rise of radical left-wing candidates.
Plus, Eli recommends Merle Haggard’s Mama Tried, and @jpodhoretz recommends Ken Burns’ country music documentary.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/gallicize-the-intifada/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Recognizing one’s full rights as a citizen is a way of buying an umbrella. When it rains, you’ve already got it.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/superstorm-abdul-has-convi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Populist demagoguery has consequences? Who’da thunk it?
Not Mamdani, the Chosen One.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/you-hate-to-see-it/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"What is Ukraine doing? It's fighting for its national sovereignty like no other nation in Europe in this century."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=1-JQwP6nibA -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Polanski has been in the news a fair amount lately. On his watch, the Greens have transitioned from being a slightly quirky patch of left-wingers to being an openly anti-Semitic gang of aspiring authoritarians.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/britains-jews-get-a-much-n… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Every poll shows that the Democratic brand is still extremely unpopular."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=D1BM6pUAc3I -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Conversations with My Rabbi transcends its putative genre, and not just because one of its authors believed so deeply in his values that he actually died defending them.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-rosen/rabbi-schlanger… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If we had a clear view of how the system as a whole is meant to operate—taking seriously the role of states and the strictly delineated assignments of each federal branch—we could try to deduce the principles that tell us whether government is acting consistently with, or in violation of, our sacrosanct constitutional principles.
www.commentary.org/articles/tal-fortgang/separation-of-po… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It is a nonsense complaint. It is also silly because Israelis are the last people who need this lecture.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-bad-faith-policing-of-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Look at the Somali fraudsters in Minnesota who when folks started asking questions about what they were doing, they filed a lawsuit alleging racial discrimination"
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=P_xN7l-L8zQ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Netanyahu’s achievements, with and without the input of the war room, are hard to deny. But the fact that the October 7 attacks occurred on his watch cannot be ignored. As the authors rightly note, “The buck must stop with the prime minister.”
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/israel-war-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
I visited the old art deco News building the other day (the paper abandoned it in 1995 for some dump, now gone, in what is today Hudson Yards). The lobby is landmarked, so the marvelous rotating globe is still there, as are all sorts of weather-related gizmos that once upon a time could probably have told you about the barometric pressure in Burma.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-riedel/ill-tell-ya-wh… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Francesca Albanese, the U.S.-sanctioned unofficial Hamas mouthpiece with a UN badge, has finally crossed J Street’s line. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/anti-semites-waste-so-much… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“Traitor, traitor, come on out, you sold all your people out,” the street fascists in the crowd chanted.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/american-jews-are-fulfilli… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @NoahCRothman joins us today to discuss the counterintuitive republican competitiveness in bluer states while floundering in historically easier races, particularly in Texas, where James Talarico seems poised to win the democrats’ first statewide race since 1994.
Plus, the Trump administration’s disgraceful treatment of Ukraine and its incoherent strategy on the war, the turn against Indian Americans, and @jpodhoretz recommends You Can See Everything.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/talarico-suave/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
I wrote about *why* Sally Rooney would stage an elaborate self-boycott after Britain refused to censor her. Crazy only gets crazier www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/sally-rooneys-self-boycott…
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Audiences didn’t want to see Hasan’s execution, and it would have been showbiz malpractice not to listen to them." --From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
October 15, @continetti recommends Henry and Clara by Thomas Mallon
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The one thing that she would have done differently than Joe Biden is she would have been harsher on Israel earlier."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=D1BM6pUAc3I -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
For sounding the alarm about that grave impending danger, and for throwing a floodlight on how a formidable strategy can protect a fragile world order, Eliot Cohen has done us an extraordinary service with The Strategist.
www.commentary.org/articles/brian-stewart/strategist-war-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Sally Rooney, a devotee of the anti-Jewish boycott movement, has gone out of her way to express unambiguous anti-Semitism rather than try to hide behind “criticism of Israel.” @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/sally-rooneys-self-boycott… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Unless you are a Democrat or a liberal, you are going to have to be preparing yourself for hard realities. . ."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=DK7HMnyEdmw -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Still, this settlement is better understood as a small step in the right direction rather than a significant victory for people who would like to see a broader reckoning for social media companies.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/meta-settleme… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To stay or to leave? That’s the stark choice that John Podhoretz poses to American Jews facing an unprecedented onslaught of anti-Israel and anti-Semitic animosity....
Read the rest of our readers' comments:
www.commentary.org/articles/reader-letters/reader-comment… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @continetti is back on this Thursday to discuss John Ossoff’s surprise declaration that he won’t run for president before the end of his term, who will end up as the democratic nominee in 2028, and how will the Judaism of certain potential candidates impact their chances?
Plus, Obama’s awful ahistorical Belfast speech, Abdul El-Sayed’s terrible response to reports of his family’s Muslim Brotherhood associations, NYC’s comptroller refusing to buy Israel bonds in violation of his campaign promise, Mamdani gaining new haters in the anti-Israel crowd, and Matt recommends Thomas Mallon’s Henry and Clara.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/fallow-field/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Obama has Jimmy Carter Syndrome. Carter held two beliefs about Israeli-Palestinian peace: first, that Israel doesn’t want it; second, that ultimately a peace deal is about Jimmy Carter, not Israel or the Palestinians. So he spent much of his long post-presidency crusading against the Jewish state. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/obamas-grudge/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Omar's congressional staff helped to get her birth date changed in our public records after she was elected to Congress in 2018."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=P_xN7l-L8zQ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The left knows only how to take offense, and Shane Gillis doesn’t owe anyone an apology. But it’s hard to say that a joke is “just a joke,” if it’s also something else: a deliberate taunt."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Though Moulton claimed that his break with AIPAC was “a long time coming,” it could not have been that long considering how he had spent the previous months seeking its endorsement. Moulton was responding to the anti-Israel sentiment that has overtaken the Democratic Party since October 7, and he figured that contributing to the AIPAC-bashing would be an easy way to signal his antipathy to the Jewish state.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/seth-moulton-d… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The proper reaction to finding out that Gaza has a population growth above the global average—even now—is to rejoice. But if all you wanted was to accuse Israel of “genocide,” you will either ignore such news or show visible disappointment. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/why-did-people-believe-gaz… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
October 14, @jpodhoretz recommends the show Cupertino
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"31% of Trump's own supporters now disapprove of him."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mi2zoGoygX4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Wednesday, and we are still immersed in pre-election news with the New York and Oregon gubernatorial debates, as well as new details on the Ilhan Omar raid and reports on the discrepancy of her age.
Plus, the White House gets a new press secretary, the ongoing legal case against Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu, and @jpodhoretz recommends the new show Cupertino.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/the-age-of-omar/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
So as anti-Semitism, often expressed as anti-Zionism, increased, British Jews chose the path of peoplehood and communal solidarity despite the dangers inherent in doing so.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jewish-resilience-since-oc… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
October 13, @jpodhoretz recommends D: Heavy Water by Neal Stephenson
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In a world in which we must suffer the fatuous fulminations of Mark Ruffalo and Hannah Einbinder, this actor’s cameo carried a profundity that defied its brevity.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/idan-amedi-f… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Why have you not just answered the question? Why do you keep kicking this can down the road?"
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=DK7HMnyEdmw -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The world is spinning more rapidly than ever, and poor benighted Russia is barely hanging on.
www.commentary.org/articles/irina-velitskaya/russia-ukrai… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In Gaza, the Hamas narrative is dead. It lives on only in the zombie newsrooms of the U.S. and Europe. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/hamas-joins-the-zionist-ha… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"When you hear these races are moving to toss-up, it tells you nothing."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nd2JQX3HRyo -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: With the midterms three weeks away, Abdul El-Sayed’s liabilities are starting to make an impact, particularly due to his inability to respond to some of the worst allegations against him. Will his complacency from the primary run into the harsh reality of a general election?
Plus, James Talarico’s extended absence, the New York gubernatorial race, Kimberly Guilfoyle being asked to resign as ambassador to Greece, and @jpodhoretz recommends Neal Stephenson’s D: Heavy Water.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/lansing-the-boil/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
October 12, @jpodhoretz recommends We Want to Believe by Adam Kirsch
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Every aspect of her public identity has been fraudulent."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mi2zoGoygX4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The UK’s descent into anti-Zionist madness has always been just a few steps ahead of the Democratic Party’s leftward drift.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-return-of-zionism-is-r… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
When Mamdani and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, among others, denounced the October 8 rally attended by Chevalier, it was not exactly earth-shattering even if it was nice to see. But the anti-Zionist advocacy of those very same, highly influential Democratic Party figures over the course of the war put that denunciation in a different light. It turned out there was very little these electeds would object to. Celebrating the deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust would at least mean these figures were capable of doing the absolute minimum.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-people-who-celebrate-o… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This is America. It’s a free election. Do what you want. Yet because El-Sayed is a Democrat, some of these voters treat him like a wayward relative: Maybe this time he’ll clean up his act!
El-Sayed’s debate performance last week against Mike Rogers finally appears to be breaking the spell. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/superstorm-abdul-has-convi… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Now that the Palestinian Authority has dropped the elections that were a key reason France recognized their ‘state,’ I have a modest proposal for how Paris can pressure Ramallah to get back on track: try BDS! www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/palestine-is-canceled/
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"It would be too dramatic to call any of this a crisis for El-Sayed at the moment, but he’s just not showing anything like clear frontrunner momentum."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Jewish people have survived millennia through the clarity of self-understanding. In this moment of resurgent anti-Semitism, PRIZE offers precisely that clarity: a map for courts, a mirror for identity, and a bulwark against erasure.
www.commentary.org/articles/jeffrey-lax/fighting-anti-sem… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are back on this Columbus Day to discuss Trump’s newest turn against Zelensky and the nonexistent energy ceasefire between Russia and Ukraine, as well as Abdul El-Sayed’s Muslim Brotherhood connection.
Plus, the potential merits of the DHS raid on the home of rep. Ilhan Omar, the Saudi stubbornness and incompetence in their war against the Houthis, and John recommends Adam Kirsch’s We Want to Believe.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/pop-goes-the-diesel/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
NAZA provides anonymous and unverified claims that have been picked apart by experts who have gone on the record.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-media-blackout-on-isra… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Gazans, having seen their invasion of Israel ultimately fail, are indeed being pragmatic by expressing their openness to a different strategy.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/fox-butterfield-of-arabia/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The New York Times poll last week said they made 235,000 calls and got 8,000 responses. How do you construct an electorate out of that?"
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nd2JQX3HRyo -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The true masters of this new form of warfare are the Ukrainians, in part because it’s the only way they can confront an enemy with more soldiers, more weapons, and more resources—and survive.
www.commentary.org/articles/arthur-herman/ukraine-drones-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The U.S. is committed to protecting vessels as they sail through the strait, but the U.S. has also lately not been firing back at those who are attacking the ships.
What gives?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/behold-the-military-solution/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
A community can produce an army. DSA chapters train members to canvass, raise small dollars, run meetings, master ballot rules, and endure the tedium of local politics.
www.commentary.org/articles/jesse-arm/dsa-religion-substi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In a world in which we must suffer the fatuous fulminations of Mark Ruffalo and Hannah Einbinder, this actor’s cameo carried a profundity that defied its brevity. And in a season of the Jewish calendar in which we ask for life, Amedi reminds us of what a blessing it is to be alive, and to live a Jewish life today.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/idan-amedi-f… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Saudis see their contribution to the regional war as Being Saudi Arabia. It’s like when a guest asks you what they can bring to dinner and you say, “Just bring yourself.” The Saudis are here to hang out. Provide emotional support.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-fence-sitting-saudis/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We're not learning to live with Hamas. We're not managing a relationship with Hamas. We are going to wipe out Hamas."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=8wb4i5GTok8 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Rather than accepting that organized violence is a permanent feature of mankind, Cohen argues that the West has embraced a Kantian vision of permanent peace.
www.commentary.org/articles/brian-stewart/strategist-war-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israeli artists are following the usual pattern of working through a national tragedy: first come the documentary films, then the memoirs, and then the dramas and novels. And at each step of the way, Israelis have been hindered, stymied, or delayed by the harassment of those who don’t want citizens of the Jewish state to be humanized in the arts. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-bad-faith-policing-of-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If Ellison keeps his promise, there will soon be a shelf of weird, specific comedies that got to exist because the combined company was large enough to absorb the risk but not too large to take the risk in the first place.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/coyote-vs-acme-warne… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @continetti joins us on this Friday to discuss polling averages one month before the midterm elections, and whether polling errors in the primaries will rear their heads again in the general election.
Plus, the Michigan debate between Mike Rogers and Abdul El-Sayed, the disgraceful Navi Pillay wins the Nobel Peace Prize, and Matt recommends the podcast “The Plot Thickens.”
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/error-correction/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"People are celebrating this act of so-called resistance that 20 years ago would have been inconceivable and I'd venture impossible."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=8wb4i5GTok8 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Even before the Green Party officially endorsed anti-Semitism, its members were talking about Jews as if they were in a Munich beer hall a century ago. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/britains-jews-get-a-much-n… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In the long term, this settlement will likely benefit the company because it might serve as a form of regulatory-capture-by-lawsuit.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/meta-settleme… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“Traitor, traitor, come on out, you sold all your people out,” the street fascists in the crowd chanted.
Too sadistic for the Jews, not sadistic enough for the Palestinians—this poor guy just can’t please anybody. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/american-jews-are-fulfilli… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There's been a valorization over the last 10, 15 years of the idea that protest is the highest form of democratic expression."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=rcpZAsO0lwc -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
My latest on why it was so important to see American Jews stand up to Mamdani and speak for their own values and their own security www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/american-jews-are-fulfilli…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Despite not being able to admit that in many ways greed was in fact good, Yuppies is kind of a nostalgic hang. But now, as American Psycho’s Patrick Bateman used to say when he was ready to be done with something, “I have to return some videotapes.”
www.commentary.org/articles/rick-marin/yuppies-conquered-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israelis are often scolded for the psychological effect the conflict has on Palestinian children. They are, the world lectures, radicalizing a new generation of Palestinians. But the Palestinians, who have refused to end the conflict and thus are inflicting this reality on their own children, are rarely criticized for supposedly radicalizing a younger generation of Israelis.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/parenting-under-fire/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @jpodhoretz introduces a rebroadcast of our first show after the October 7th attacks, featuring @dansenor, @AbeGreenwald, Christine Rosen, and @continetti.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/revisiting-the-day-after/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Notable from @FalkOphir on the first two calls to come in to Bibi after the 10/7 slaughter: Biden’s “How can I help” vs Macron’s diplomacy gobbledygook www.wsj.com/opinion/what-i-saw-on-oct-7-leadership-and-is…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It should go without saying that everything that happens to a person can be attributed to only two general phenomena: things the person does (or doesn’t do) that are in his control and things that are outside of his control. The course of civilization is the progressive exertion of the force of the former over the latter.
www.commentary.org/articles/irina-velitskaya/russia-ukrai… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
American Jews’ patriotism doesn’t waver just because they increase their connection to their faith or community. But anti-Semites’ belief in Jews’ Americanness—or Britishness, or Francité—does take a hit when the Jews are in the news. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jewish-resilience-since-oc… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
“The changes Obama wrought in American political culture were large and lasting. He made it possible for someone like El-Sayed to get to where he is today.”—From today’s newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There's just no moral framework for how to conduct oneself on a college campus that's coming from leaders anywhere."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=vXOwqvJLh4E -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
I didn’t know it at the time, but I was catching the tail end of the Daily News’ supremacy. Five years later, I left for the New York Post, which, reinvigorated by Rupert Murdoch, had become the city’s most influential tabloid.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-riedel/ill-tell-ya-wh… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We're showing the world . . . don't f with us. We have our enemies wired and penetrated."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=t424RmQc7vI -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @dansenor joins us from Israel on this third anniversary of the October 7th attacks to revisit the initial reactions to the horrors and discuss the downstream consequences of instant anti-Israel responses, the contrast between the atmosphere in Israel and in American Jewish communities, and what the way forward might look like.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/three-years-on/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It’s curious enough that an anti-Israel group is part of the mayor’s apparent anti-Semitism plan, but the story gets curiouser. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-people-who-celebrate-o… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
October 6, @jpodhoretz recommends East of Eden by John Steinbeck
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"People think the way to be heard is to pitch tents in the middle of a college campus and to intimidate their fellow students, as opposed to cast votes."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=rcpZAsO0lwc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
For questioning the transgender movement’s holy grail, Moulton reaped the whirlwind. His campaign manager resigned in protest.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/seth-moulton-d… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
For someone who has written a whole book about the importance of separationism, Sunstein goes remarkably soft in defending the division of power.
www.commentary.org/articles/tal-fortgang/separation-of-po… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"That's the world of the anti-Israel movement . . . it doesn't care who the prime minister is."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=QUuu55bsW0c -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss the data points that seem to contradict predictions of a major democratic sweep in the midterms, the political unrest in France and England, the increased sociopolitical capital of protesting and rioting in an age of diminishing reasons to protest and riot, Obama campaigning with Abdul El-Sayed, Brett McGurk’s new book pouring cold water on Clinton-era revisionism, and @jpodhoretz recommends John Steinbeck’s East of Eden.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/protest-contest/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
I wrote about how we now have several on-the-record Israelis who have direct knowledge of the NAZA-related systems explaining what the movie got wrong--but they're only in Jewish and Israeli publications, b/c mainstream pubs are in blackout mode: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-media-blackout-on-isra…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To the Jews, history’s great survivors, the whole world may often seem like a very narrow bridge, but the Jewish people keep making it to the other side of that bridge. Israel’s enemies have been trying to destroy it since the rebirth of Jewish sovereignty in 1948, but that means Israelis have come to know victory, because they are still here.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-musicality-of-jewish-s… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Major general-interest news outlets have folded in on themselves and become very large versions of the single-perspective, ideologically driven websites they once decried. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-media-blackout-on-isra… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"For Kathy Hochul to appoint her as the special prosecutor in this case is an act of insanity."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=vXOwqvJLh4E -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"You will not mitigate the potential damage of AI by trying to shape its soul—because it has no soul."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This imprecision is not merely tactical. It reflects a deeper failure to articulate a fundamental truth: Jews are a people whose identity encompasses religion, ethnicity, ancestry, culture, and a profound—often faith-inflected—connection to the Land of Israel and its people.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The UK’s descent into anti-Zionist madness has always been just a few steps ahead of the Democratic Party’s leftward drift. Now the Democrats’ own Corbynites are many, and the moderates willing to oppose them are few. That means that the deeper the Democrats are pulled into this vortex, the more difficult it will be to pull them out of it. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-return-of-zionism-is-r… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“We had a shared goal,” Goldstein writes in a preface she hastily revised after Schlanger’s stunning murder. “We wanted to offer something radically hopeful: a window into Jewish thought that is compassionate, relevant, and powerful. A body of work that would resonate across time and cultures. A way of seeing the world that has sustained a people through exile, trauma, miracles, and rebirth.”
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-rosen/rabbi-schlanger… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The fact that every facet of the “genocide” accusation against Israel has fallen apart, along with the disintegration of numerous other false claims, raises a serious concern.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/as-the-hamas-narrative-dis… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss the story of the Cornell 7 and the controversy surrounding accounts of the events and aftermath of the incident, the potential for bias in the appointment of Letitia James as special prosecutor, as well as the general degradation of academia.
Plus, England’s Green Party further descends into antisemitism, and New York City ends its relationship with a far left synagogue. We end with Seth’s recommendation of the PBS miniseries Trespasses.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/hard-cornell/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"You can't turn the Israeli society into a political fantasy, you have to deal with what it is."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=QUuu55bsW0c -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
As the Hudson Institute’s Can Kasapoğlu has written, “Ukraine’s wartime technological transformation has been driven by the state and a dense ecosystem of private technology firms, start-ups, volunteer engineers, and Western commercial partners.”
www.commentary.org/articles/arthur-herman/ukraine-drones-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Britain thus joins Qatar and Turkey as the 21st century’s most important hosts of Hamas.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/how-the-uk-became-a-destab… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
For now, however, history continues to unfold in real time. Netanyahu’s achievements, with and without the input of the war room, are hard to deny. But the fact that the October 7 attacks occurred on his watch cannot be ignored. As the authors rightly note, “The buck must stop with the prime minister.”
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/israel-war-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The average poll error now in aggregate in elections is three points. And that's almost always in favor of the Democrats."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=EoQr9ZeN9mU -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
No one has benefited more from that infrastructure than Zohran Mamdani.
www.commentary.org/articles/jesse-arm/dsa-religion-substi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It’s a gut punch. Sinwar plainly understood the darker side of humanity better than those of us who expected a baseline level of decency from the public. He was right and we were wrong, and that will always sting.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/israeli-arabs-and-the-norm… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Clearly the idea of an Iranian escalation is out there . . . "
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=IfGMpP_XMEU -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If Ellison keeps his promise, there will soon be a shelf of weird, specific comedies that got to exist because the combined company was large enough to absorb the risk but not too large to take the risk in the first place. But Ellison might simply end up owning the latest studio to fall off the tightrope, and the guys at Ketchup will have another shot at picking up dead projects and making some real money.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/coyote-vs-acme-warne… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The country’s collective hangover from social media’s impact on our relationships, our politics, and our civic culture is finally here.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/meta-settleme… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Despite not being able to admit that in many ways greed was in fact good, Yuppies is kind of a nostalgic hang. But now, as American Psycho’s Patrick Bateman used to say when he was ready to be done with something, “I have to return some videotapes.”
www.commentary.org/articles/rick-marin/yuppies-conquered-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What to make of this? If you know Netanyahu, you will not be surprised by any of this. But if you are part of the Western media and academic and NGO complex, you will be confused. After all, the belief in the West is that Bibi is a warmonger and an aggressive right-wing ideologue staunchly opposed to peace.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/bibis-caution-and-the-octo… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There are, in fact, military solutions to military problems. Sometimes there are only military solutions to military problems. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/behold-the-military-solution/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The 1970s were brutal years for New York City, and no paper captured the mayhem, crime, and despair better than the News.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-riedel/ill-tell-ya-wh… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Friday, and we are back to discuss marking a full year without any rockets or missiles fired into Israel from the Gaza Strip and how this relates to the fierce opposition to Netanyahu in Israel as the election approaches, and how this can be viewed through the prism of Israeli political history.
Plus, Israel’s connection to thwarting the terrorist attack on an American airbase in the UK on the backdrop of British politicians ratcheting up their anti-Israel rhetoric and policies.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/rocketless/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
But Conversations with My Rabbi transcends its putative genre, and not just because one of its authors believed so deeply in his values that he actually died defending them.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-rosen/rabbi-schlanger… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"How many times is this going to happen for people to wise up? Nothing is private. Nothing is off the record."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=EoQr9ZeN9mU -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It would have been a decent gesture to allow Israel to pick up the passengers rather than ask them to get right back on a Flydubai plane.
But Mohammad bin Salman doesn’t do gestures, even in an emergency. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-fence-sitting-saudis/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The drug satisfies the tedious and ceaseless hunger that is now a part of me—a hunger that the drug created in the first place. If it also makes me calmer or more focused, that’s only because I don’t have to worry about when I’m getting my next fix."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Abe has a full description of the fascinating back-and-forth that followed, in which El-Sayed resolutely refused to back the people seeking democracy and who have been massacred in the streets for their activism.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-democracy-candida… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israelis are often scolded for the psychological effect the conflict has on Palestinian children. They are, the world lectures, radicalizing a new generation of Palestinians. But the Palestinians, who have refused to end the conflict and thus are inflicting this reality on their own children, are rarely criticized for supposedly radicalizing a younger generation of Israelis. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/parenting-under-fire/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The United States government should have the power and authority to deport enemies of the United States."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6rKJ6eTfy0 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Harvard professor Cass Sunstein is a liberal, not a progressive, but he has come to make a first-principles case for a robust conception of the separation of powers.
www.commentary.org/articles/tal-fortgang/separation-of-po… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are back on this Thursday to discuss the tight polling of likely voters in Michigan and whether this is considered good news in the current polling atmosphere, Troy Jackson’s comments on Jewish Mainers, Ken Paxton’s leaked comments on the midterm convention, and Anthropic’s Dario Amodei’s comments on AI personhood and rights.
Plus, @elianayjohnson recommends The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/poll-dancing/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The unspeakable evil didn’t end there. Months into the war, as negative public sentiment over the death toll of the war continued to mount, with an estimated 30,000 killed, Hamas officials sought to double down. “We have the Israelis right where we want them,” read one Hamas leader’s message reviewed by Kaufman and the Wall Street Journal.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/israel-war-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Here we have an attempted hijacking . . . clearly there's going to be some relationship to Iran."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=IfGMpP_XMEU -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Today I wrote about the musicality of Jewish survival: Why the returning Israeli passengers sang what they sang, why certain songs have become Israeli anthems of hope and resilience post-Oct. 7, and the deeper meaning of it all www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-musicality-of-jewish-s…
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Yes, much of the West’s unhinged rage toward Israel can be traced back to anti-Semitism. But there’s another factor at work. Israel shames the rest of the developed world."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
September 30, @continetti recommends To Jerusalem and Back by Saul Bellow
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In an era of widespread ignorance of and dismissiveness toward the subject of warfare, this emphasis on the utility of force, or the threat of force, is refreshing.
www.commentary.org/articles/brian-stewart/strategist-war-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @continetti is back to discuss breaking news of a thwarted 9/11-style attack on a flight from Dubai to Tel-Aviv and the heroism of the passengers who averted disaster, and how this ties to recent terrorism stories coming out of the UK, and to Iranian grand strategy.
Plus, Senator Eric Schmitt embarrassing sports gaffe during the Jack Smith hearing, and Matt recommends the reissue of Saul Bellow’s To Jerusalem and Back.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/rushing-the-cockpit/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If I were the Iranians, I would be afraid of Israeli action."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=WOa1P7DXvtM -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
September 29, @jpodhoretz recommends Season 2 of MobLand
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In a world in which we must suffer the fatuous fulminations of Mark Ruffalo and Hannah Einbinder, this actor’s cameo carried a profundity that defied its brevity. And in a season of the Jewish calendar in which we ask for life, Amedi reminds us of what a blessing it is to be alive, and to live a Jewish life today.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/idan-amedi-f… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Future Republicans will not be afraid to say we're going to toss people out of the country if they are America-hating."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6rKJ6eTfy0 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Historically, Americans have been unusually enthusiastic about technological innovation. Decades of decline in trust in government and our institutions, plus the behavior of many Big Tech companies, have squandered some of that enthusiasm. The Meta settlement should be understood as part of that story, as well as an expression of concern about the likely impacts of many new technologies.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/meta-settleme… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
As of this writing, Russia is losing eight troops for every one Ukrainian fatality, according to the Center for Strategic and International Studies, and Russian troop deaths now stand at more than 450,000, with total casualties as high as 1.4 million.
www.commentary.org/articles/irina-velitskaya/russia-ukrai… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Contributing Editor @EliLake is back to discuss his review of Mahmoud Khalil’s new book and debate whether the efforts to deport him were unwise.
Plus, the Trump administration moves to block EV adoption and reinstate Title IX rules that were revoked under Biden, how America can right the ship on education, the strange polling numbers in Ohio, and @jpodhoretz recommends season 2 of Mobland.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/mahmoudy-blues/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
A self-governing people must inhabit a shared reality. The villainous portrayal of Israel during the war was exactly backwards. Can these folks join the rest of us here, where the truth lives? @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/as-the-hamas-narrative-dis… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Palestinian identity is the golden ticket in the West at the moment.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/check-your-palestine-privi… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"It’s virtuous to be on the side of the truth, and therefore we like to believe that it’s also advantageous in a fight. Even better, we have faith that “the truth will out” somehow on its own. But in most battles, the truth alone is a poor weapon."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Britain's refusal until recently to proscribe Iranian terror proxies has led to the UK's status as a threat to the destabilization of Western Europe. My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/how-the-uk-became-a-destab…
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
September 28, @jpodhoretz recommends True Detective by Max Allan Collins
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"You had your chance. You blew it. You refused to open the straight of Hormuz."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=WOa1P7DXvtM -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"People talk about Israel as if it's the last country to have been formed in history or something."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdD8twq3Xy0 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The level of sloppiness in that story made it very clear that this was not a “documentarian” whose work could be trusted without extensive re-reporting.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/naza-is-a-jump-the-shark-m… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Britain thus joins Qatar and Turkey as the 21st century’s most important hosts of Hamas. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/how-the-uk-became-a-destab… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Monday, and we’re back to discuss Sunkist reversing their decision to cancel the Bar Mitzvah favorite fruit gems, the Hormuz crisis coming to a head, and the foiled terrorist attack in Britain with suspected ties to Iran.
Plus, impending doom for Republicans in November’s polling numbers over the war, the economy, and data centers, and @jpodhoretz recommends True Detective by Max Allan Collins.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/slouching-towards-november/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Given the ideological U-turns Moulton had to perform just to mount a credible challenge to Markey, and the slim chances of his winning regardless, one wonders why he didn’t opt to keep his safe House seat.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/seth-moulton-d… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In an era of widespread ignorance of and dismissiveness toward the subject of warfare, this emphasis on the utility of force, or the threat of force, is refreshing.
www.commentary.org/articles/brian-stewart/strategist-war-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
PRIZE captures this complexity without forcing Jews into a single box or tying identity to any particular Israeli government policy.
www.commentary.org/articles/jeffrey-lax/fighting-anti-sem… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The people of Israel are not listening to you because when it comes to their survival, they have no choice
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=VdD8twq3Xy0 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Both Ukraine and Russia have learned that uncrewed systems—drones—have a much larger, even indispensable role to play on the modern battlefield than the limited role they played in America’s recent conflicts, as either intelligence and reconnaissance platforms or for whack-a-mole precision strikes in remote places like Afghanistan.
www.commentary.org/articles/arthur-herman/ukraine-drones-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Early alignment among them was key to helping Israel rebound from the shock of Hamas’s initial success. But that alignment didn’t last. The positions of Netanyahu, Gallant, and Gantz began to shift in the face of American pressure to reduce the intensity of the war, international pressure to end the war, and new threats from across the war’s seven fronts.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/israel-war-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"These are simple-minded people who are desperately in need of living a simple-minded life and they want the rest of us to live"
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=uuUhRo9Mhzs -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Members who derive that much from a movement will give much in return. That helps explain why the DSA’s political influence exceeds its raw numbers.
www.commentary.org/articles/jesse-arm/dsa-religion-substi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
El-Sayed carries a torch for authoritarians the world over. And he has been more than clear: His core voters in Michigan do as well.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-democracy-candida… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
First rule: Don’t let anti-Semites take something away from you. If you, personally, consider yourself a Zionist, and if you, personally, see Zionism as a noble part of your own identity, then that’s the term you should use.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-z-word/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If Ellison keeps his promise, there will soon be a shelf of weird, specific comedies that got to exist because the combined company was large enough to absorb the risk but not too large to take the risk in the first place.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/coyote-vs-acme-warne… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
September 25, @SethAMandel recommends Barman of the Ritz and @jpodhoretz recommends The World at Night
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"To talk of anti-Semitism in terms of bubbles is to use a metaphor, and I’ve become increasingly convinced that thinking metaphorically about the topic may do more harm than good. Anti-Semitism seems to resist metaphor altogether."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Despite not being able to admit that in many ways greed was in fact good, Yuppies is kind of a nostalgic hang. But now, as American Psycho’s Patrick Bateman used to say when he was ready to be done with something, “I have to return some videotapes.”
www.commentary.org/articles/rick-marin/yuppies-conquered-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This is how Jews have always lived in the face of death, and this is how Jews will continue to live. Kaddish will continue to be said; Jews will continue to gather to say it; and in the process, they will reflect the faith, loyalty, and love of centuries past.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Our Secret Service is protecting the president of Iran whom we should be killing."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=MVdRp9gNbYk -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In counting mentions of a particular country, that country’s home-based publications are excluded—this is a study of how the rest of the world covers Israel and other states. Likewise, foreign-based outlets that primarily cover Israel-related topics are also excluded.
The study looked at the past 10 years. In nine of those 10 years, Israel was the most-talked-about subject. The exception was 2022, the year Russia invaded Ukraine.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/laying-bare-the-medias-man… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We already knew that Israel wanted peace and Gaza wanted war. We just didn’t know how badly Netanyahu’s government wanted peace. Badly enough, it turns out, to risk Israel’s immediate security. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/bibis-caution-and-the-octo… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The joke in the newsroom, acceptable only because its subject’s monstrousness was unquestionable, went as follows: What were Robert Maxwell’s last words? Rose-blub.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-riedel/ill-tell-ya-wh… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To be an anti-Zionist now, at this moment, is to be, by definition, the adherent of a violent ideology. It is to be an enemy of peace. To pretend otherwise is to be the defensive coordinator of a football team while claiming to be “personally anti-tackling.”
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Friday, and after a brief opening discussion about records, we turn to discuss Benjamin Netanyahu’s UNGA speech, Macron’s embarrassing flub, the ongoing efforts to find some resolution to the Iran war, the upcoming Israeli elections, the lowlife antisemitism of actor Wallace Shawn.
Plus, @SethAMandel recommends The Barman of the Ritz, and @jpodhoretz recommends The World at Night.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/un-mitigated-disaster/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
According to eyewitnesses, the last thing that Rabbi Eli Schlanger did before a jihadist gunned him down at Sydney’s fabled Bondi Beach last December was to try to talk the killer down.
Read on: www.commentary.org/articles/michael-rosen/rabbi-schlanger… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Why couldn’t he follow Mamdani’s lead here? Because, at the end of the day, Mamdani is a socialist and not an Islamist, whereas El-Sayed is an Islamist and not a socialist. And Islamists don’t care about Muslims. They care about advancing Islamism, which happens to be the Iranian regime’s chief aim."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
El-Sayed's alarming enthusiasm for authoritarianism and contempt for democracy www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-democracy-candida…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The population in Gaza is now larger than it was on October 7th."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=uuUhRo9Mhzs -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In other words, this has nothing to do with a temporary increase in “settler violence” over the past year. Norway has merely been waiting for a good pretext to hit Israel, and now it has found one.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/norways-boycott-law-is-an-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Harvard professor Cass Sunstein is a liberal, not a progressive, but he has come to make a first-principles case for a robust conception of the separation of powers.
www.commentary.org/articles/tal-fortgang/separation-of-po… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
At 8:12 a.m., Al-Muhtadi told an associate on a phone call to ‘get ready,’ that the ‘borders are open,’ and that other individuals were passing by in a Toyota pickup truck, apparently to join the invasion.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-gazans-who-thought-oct… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Yahya Sinwar, Mohammed Deif, and much of the world thought Arabs couldn't be patriotic citizens of a Jewish state. From Oct. 7 to this election, Israeli Arabs are proving them wrong. My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/israeli-arabs-and-the-norm…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Netanyahu’s achievements, with and without the input of the war room, are hard to deny. But the fact that the October 7 attacks occurred on his watch cannot be ignored. As the authors rightly note, “The buck must stop with the prime minister.”
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/israel-war-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss Benjamin Netanyahu’s speech to the UNGA after the son of Israel’s ambassador to the US was seriously injured in a terrorist attack, news that the Israeli film NAZA will be released for free online, the fight over the word genocide, and Israel’s “damned if you do, damned if you don’t” trap.
Plus, new polling data in key senatorial races, and @jpodhoretz recommends season 6 of Slow Horses.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/genocide-hustle/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Matthew Continetti
@continetti
Today's episode @Commentary: The Paramount-Warner Bros. deal; Trump and Iran at the UN; feckless Europe; and I make a recommendation.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/mergers-and-inquisitions-2/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"She is interested in racial politics and using education as a battering ram to recreate American society"
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=0OUaz3x9Fgg -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
September 23, @continetti recommends Wait Till Next Year by William Goldman and Mike Lupica
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
After Sheeran decolonized his tour and liberated his fans from Macklemore’s occupation, Macklemore responded exactly as expected: He and his fans and his defenders pretended he was being fired for simply supporting Palestinian rights.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-stiffening-spines-of-a… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Palestinian identity is the golden ticket in the West at the moment. Palestine is the omnicause—the one issue everyone must dedicate themselves to at the expense of all others. In the Democratic Party, the Palestinian omnicause is the only litmus test for political participation. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/check-your-palestine-privi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Rather than accepting that organized violence is a permanent feature of mankind, Cohen argues that the West has embraced a Kantian vision of permanent peace.
www.commentary.org/articles/brian-stewart/strategist-war-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @continetti joins us on this Wednesday to discuss football being back, as well as Rob Bonta’s failure to stop the Paramount-WB merger, how it connects to the pro-Palestine movement, and what the future of news media might look like.
Plus, the Iranian president speaks at the UNGA despite being at war with the host country, Trump’s speech, the Saudi-Houthi war, and Matt recommends Wait Till Next Year by Mike Lupica and William Goldman, and John also recommends William Goldman’s The Season.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/mergers-and-inquisitions-2/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Due to technical issues outside our control, we’ll be posting today’s podcast audio to our website later than usual. In the meantime, you can still tune into today’s episode by visiting our YouTube channel. Link to the latest episode is below:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=MVdRp9gNbYk -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In a world in which we must suffer the fatuous fulminations of Mark Ruffalo and Hannah Einbinder, this actor’s cameo carried a profundity that defied its brevity.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/idan-amedi-f… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Over the course of the last 40 years, schooling is now twice as bad as it was in 1983."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=0OUaz3x9Fgg -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Trump said that Mamdani has 'great potential' to be a 'great mayor.' He does? Well, that sure takes some of the sting out of Republican claims that the DSA and everyone in its orbit is a mortal threat to the country." --From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It won’t be a single stone that fells any one of the tech giants, nor should it be the goal of the government or trial lawyers to seek their downfall.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/meta-settleme… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Russia is losing eight troops for every one Ukrainian fatality.
www.commentary.org/articles/irina-velitskaya/russia-ukrai… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are back to gloat about Commentary’s non-susceptibility to current online media monetization trends in the age of broken search and ubiquitous AI, as well as to discuss the widely shared New York Times piece by Nikole Hannah-Jones on the failure of her daughter’s public schooling, and Trump’s newest idea for the DC memorial arch.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/learning-nothing/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Why would Israel need a system to calculate the collateral damage of a near-term strike before it’s approved? There are three possibilities. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/naza-is-a-jump-the-shark-m… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
I was not shocked that he gets attacked viciously and publicly on social media by the likes of professional anti-Zionist Mehdi Hasan or by the legion of twitter trolls and frauds who put “historian” in their bio. But still, the level of anger and hate he has been subjected to startled me.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/how-hamas-apologists-suppr… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The realist delusion is the idea that there are perfectly and equally rational motivations for things."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=movArTKjNYY -
Commentary Magazine reposted
James Kirchick
@jkirchick
My October @Commentary column is about the cravenness of @sethmoulton, a once promising Massachusetts Democrat who decided to sacrifice his reputation for independent-thinking to earn the support of progressives—and lost both.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/seth-moulton-d… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Arthur Herman
@ArthurLHerman
What can the US learn from Ukraine about winning a future drone war? Answer: many of the same lessons we learned, and forgot, during WW2.
My latest @Commentary explains:
www.commentary.org/articles/arthur-herman/ukraine-drones-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The reason the gay-rights movement was so successful was that it convinced the American people that granting gays and lesbians legal equality would not infringe on their own rights. Nor did it propose a fundamental rejection of reality itself. The transgender movement, by contrast, is unsatisfied with freedom and demands control—over the education system, journalism, the medical profession, the entertainment industry, the English language, and much else.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/seth-moulton-d… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
My own litigation against CUNY provides a powerful demonstration of PRIZE’s effectiveness in practice.
www.commentary.org/articles/jeffrey-lax/fighting-anti-sem… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To argue that Israel is now occupying land by a third claimant, one that never had sovereignty over that land, is just ahistorical nonsense.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/kaja-kallas-mangles-history/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Trump's strength was keeping enemies off balance, but now allies don't know what to make of him."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=movArTKjNYY -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What would prevent the sanctions from going into force? Apparently nothing. What would cause Burnham to rescind them once in force? No one knows.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-is-the-endgame/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We can start by taking a closer look at what’s happening in the unfriendly skies over Ukraine.
www.commentary.org/articles/arthur-herman/ukraine-drones-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Capitalism is neither sinless nor a complete moral order. Mammon is, indeed, a false god.
But so is politics.
www.commentary.org/articles/jesse-arm/dsa-religion-substi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Piker said . . . pound for pound, America is worse than al-Qaeda and that . . . America deserved 9/11.
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=B13dyflgfvoThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Hanson calls the second Trump term “the most dramatic political comeback in American presidential history.”
www.commentary.org/articles/tevi-troy/trump-regime-change… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Complaint Department on X continues to rail against the movie, and its denizens are made even more red-fog furious by its staggering success. But they are also miffed—and here I share their irritation—by the way it has been used by some in the show business community as a vindication of more inclusive “race-blind” casting.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/odyssey-lupita-nyong… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Democratic candidates for the House and Senate have been campaigning with Hasan Piker, who said America deserved 9/11.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/bin-ladens-heirs/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
She finds commonalities with the past in other unexpected ways. “Nazis were, among other things, edgelords, in it for the laughs,” Horn writes, noting that the sadism of the Third Reich’s supporters is rarely mentioned in educational materials. Then she quotes Romi Gonen, who was held hostage by Hamas terrorists for two years, describing one of her captors as “having the best time of his life” while sexually assaulting her.
www.commentary.org/articles/harkov-lahav/dara-horn-final-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
For young people whose jobs feel precarious or pointless, or whose expensive educations have not produced the lives they expected, or whose families and religious institutions no longer provide a thick sense of belonging—or a combination of two or all three—the DSA is the answer to a prayer. Perhaps literally. @Jesse_Leg
www.commentary.org/articles/jesse-arm/dsa-religion-substi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Abdul El-Sayed is a slick candidate, but . . . he's the person Republicans wanted to run against."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=HTVXBRNatxc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Khomeini and his adherents also wished to reduce, not expand, political freedom.
www.commentary.org/articles/joshua-muravchik/stolen-revol… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The self-cannibalizing nature of the international community’s obsession with Israel is surpassed only by its sense of entitlement.
Countries like Norway claim to govern only that which takes place in Norway—and also some Jews in the Middle East because it disapproves of their street address. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/norways-boycott-law-is-an-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
9/11 education ought to be mandatory, and young Americans should learn not only the Big Ideas around this earthshattering event but what happened on that day itself at the granular level.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/schools-should-teach-the-9… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our old friend @NoahCRothman is back this Friday to discuss Trump’s latest attempts to pacify Putin on the backdrop of reports that Russia might attack NATO countries, and how the business incentive strategy has proven unsuccessful time and time again.
Plus, the dangers of mistaken presumptions on the motivation of immigrants from Muslim countries, the controversy over Indian students at the University of Texas after comments from Republican candidate Bo French, and Noah’s latest article, The Future of Woke.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/groundhog-deal/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What’s So Great About the Great Books? is not an argument for changing school curricula. Kanakia argues that since college constitutes such a short amount of time and there are so few classes at stake, it needn’t be the focus of our attention.
www.commentary.org/articles/naomi-schaefer-riley/great-bo… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Piker is never challenged in any platform for all of the reprehensible, disgusting, anti-semitic, anti-American things he says."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=B13dyflgfvo -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Should Jews stop using the 'Z' word? www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-z-word/
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
September 17, @continetti recommends Mind vs. Machine
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The Taliban’s growing good fortune is directly tied to the West’s growing accommodation with Israel’s jihadist enemies. Once Hamas terrorists earned the admiration of all those twisted Western minds, the die was cast."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In peacetime (such as it is), the Muslim world ensures Israel’s negative coverage continues. When a conflict breaks out, which is often, everyone else jumps in with their own negative coverage. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/laying-bare-the-medias-man… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
While her subject is the settling of the West by white homesteaders, there is no callousness in Wilder’s portrayal of non-whites. True, 19th-century fears and hostility toward Native Americans are aired—including the noxious phrase “the only good Indian is a dead Indian,” uttered by a character whom Pa, the hero of the series, immediately discounts. Wilder has Pa tell Laura that if the Indians were left alone, they would be a peaceful people. Laura herself reflects that had she been a Native American, she would have fought whites like her family rather than give up the glorious prairie.
www.commentary.org/articles/clare-mchugh/laura-ingalls-wi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“Free play of thought” is precisely what collectivist Stalinism was designed to abort. Socialist realist literature frequently told the story of how a dedicated but naive Communist learns to overcome his “spontaneity”—his individual ideas—and instead embraces “consciousness,” the infallible direction of the Party, which possesses the scientific laws of history.
www.commentary.org/articles/gary-morson/vasily-grossman-u… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The AfD won enough seats in local elections to put it within spitting distance of an outright majority in the Saxony-Anhalt government. Although Saxony-Anhalt is only one of 16 German states, and not a particularly populous one, state governments have much control over what goes on in the classroom.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-war-on-germanys-cultur… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Thursday, and our friend @continetti is back to discuss Hasan Piker’s Axios interview and his comments on 9/11 and Al-Qaeda, and how this might impact Abdul El-Sayed and the Michigan senate race.
Plus, a review of battleground state polling, the Fed raises interest rates in defiance of Trump, the Saudi-Houthi war, the fight over the Kennedy Center, and Matt recommends the book Mind vs. Machine.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/head-on-a-piker/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Muhtadi and his friends appeared giddy with excitement and plotted to join the massacre and its attendant looting, as many Gazans did. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-gazans-who-thought-oct… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"What he wants here is to use public funds to celebrate himself, and that's creepy."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=HTVXBRNatxc -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
What Anti-Zionists Learned from Segregationists www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-anti-zionists-learned…
My latest on how identifying oneself as an anti-Zionist is a fairly embarrassing self-incrimination rather than a clever sidestep. -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Not that long ago, the late Abe Foxman and others would describe Israel as 'the Jew among the nations.'... But while the modern State of Israel became the chief target for anti-Semites around the world, the Jews of the West (most clearly in the U.S.) were treated much better than the Jewish state. That is, until October 7, 2023. Since then, you might say, the Jew has become the Israel among the people."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Media guilds are horrified that their dominance of our cultural voice in news gathering is being challenged."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=1MoYoBdYdDY -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The October issue of Commentary is now available.
This issue explores the rising influence of the DSA, Ukraine and the future of warfare, how to fight and defeat anti-Semitism in court, and much more.
With contributions from @Jesse_Leg, @ArthurLHerman, @JSchanzer, @CUNY_Prof, @IVelitskaya, @jkirchick.
Read on at commentary.org and subscribe at commentary.org/subscribe. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To be an anti-Zionist now, at this moment, is to be, by definition, the adherent of a violent ideology. It is to be an enemy of peace. To pretend otherwise is to be the defensive coordinator of a football team while claiming to be “personally anti-tackling.” @SethAMandel
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Allow me to close this essay—disquisition? diatribe? sustained groan?—with a toast. May all who have read it attain the age of 90 and as far beyond as seems to give them more pleasure than pain. May they end their days on neither a bang nor a whimper but a quiet smile in recognition of the boundless complexity of life.
www.commentary.org/articles/joseph-epstein/turning-ninety/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Andy Burnham has decided to begin his term as prime minister by fundamentally reshaping Britain’s relationship with Israel. For the worse.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/when-every-jew-in-the-worl… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"AI is out on the leading edge of massive, rapid, unsettling change. In the public imagination, it blurs the very line between the distressing but known present and the completely uncertain future."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss Trump holding the Kennedy Center hostage, the tightening senatorial races in Ohio, Texas, Michigan, and elsewhere, JD Vance’s ongoing descent into Tucker Carlsonian thought, and our producer @neontaster joins us to discuss the controversy over Macklemore being removed from the Ed Sheeran tour.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/mackleless/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Bartov’s latest book, Israel: What Went Wrong?, released in April, is an example of that problem. Anyone, and certainly a scholar who makes the grave accusation of genocide, faces a heavy burden of providing evidence and causal reasoning. Yet Bartov does not provide a single footnote to support his claims, nor does he bother addressing the evidence and arguments that would challenge them.
www.commentary.org/articles/jeffrey-herf/omer-bartov-hist… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"It's voters who deadlock democracy. The trend toward divided government and preference for divided government is absolutely clear."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=QoVh9qR3tnQ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We're choking their economy off. We are getting oil through the strait."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=1MoYoBdYdDY -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Today, an elite group from Ghana has decided to pick up where the Nigerian philanthropist left off.
www.commentary.org/articles/ebenezer-obadare/africa-repar… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Jordan’s occupation went unrecognized by the entire world. Well, not the entire world: Pakistan and the UK accepted Jordan’s land-grab at the time.
And that, in fact, makes the story much more interesting, especially for a British Sky News journalist who doesn’t know the history.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-invention-of-the-west-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Were Macklemore’s dream to come true, millions of Jews would be murdered and the rest banished from their homes. Many Jews did not find this charming, but Macklemore’s core audience ate it up. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-stiffening-spines-of-a… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Saudi–Israeli normalization suddenly reemerged as a possibility due to the surprising response of the Kingdom to the Hamas attacks of October 7. In an astonishing development, Saudi Arabia quietly supported Israel’s war in Gaza, and the Biden administration believed a diplomatic breakthrough was a real possibility.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/saudi-arabi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss the New York Times reporting on the mystery surrounding the condition of Iranian Ayatollah Mojtaba Khamenei and whether he is even still alive, the Saudi war against the Houthis, and the Russia-Ukraine connection.
Plus, 60 Minutes returns under the leadership of Bari Weiss, and democratic megadonor control of media outlets.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/bye-atollah/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We in the West were a people who had lost our sense of purpose."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=O1BF0wFi-ZY -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
For the Arab enemies of Israel, the Jews cannot be assimilated or even subjugated; they believe the Jews must be killed and driven out of the land entirely. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/kaja-kallas-mangles-history/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Do not give in to the temptation to hide . . . it is the only way to stand up against the horde."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=QoVh9qR3tnQ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The version of performative masculinity on the populist right is best represented by Secretary Hegseth’s efforts on social media.
Read more: www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/performative-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The pro-Israel community is happy to meet peace-loving Palestinians. Why do self-styled pro-Palestinian advocates want to convince everyone to ignore the moderates? @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/how-hamas-apologists-suppr… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Maybe one day, decades from now, long after the war has receded from public memory, we’ll finally find out who was right.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/are-we-winning-or-losing-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @ChrisStirewalt joins us to discuss the midterm republican convention and what effect it might have on the midterm elections, the controversy surrounding Indian-Americans and immigrant integration, the call from AI leaders for a technological slowdown and the nebulous dangers of innovation.
Plus, the crew recommends the Hulu show Furious.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/conventional-wisdom-2/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"But when they went in numbers into the lanes of the city, with their swords drawn, they slew those whom they overtook without mercy; and set fire to the houses whither the Jews were fled, and burnt every soul in them…and made the whole city run down with blood, to such a degree indeed, that the fire of many of the houses was quenched with these men’s blood."
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/israel-burnt… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"You actually have a faction of the American left that sees itself in a solidarity with Hamas."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=O1BF0wFi-ZY -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If Donald Trump is “a poor person’s idea of a rich person”—vulgar in his gaudiness, or the Monopoly Man made real—then Graham Platner is a rich person’s idea of a poor person.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/morris-katz-gr… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The case highlights just how absurd the legal movement to withhold rights from Jews has become: Call someone a “Jew-worker,” and successfully claim you were just being “anti-Zionist.”
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/el-sayed-and-the-anti-anti… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
These blanket judgments are wrong.
They are heavily colored by the American experience in Iraq and Afghanistan, almost as if “GWOT” was just another name for those wars.
www.commentary.org/articles/tod-lindberg/global-war-on-te… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Trump looks at what the Democrats have long done, what Biden has done, and sort of amplifies it in the mirror for him."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=OM2xUqrzbXI -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Why is Andy Burnham instituting discriminatory policies against Jews while making Palestinian lives harder? Because he has been convinced by the “settler violence” narrative. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/when-every-jew-in-the-worl… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Beyond politics, boasts about testosterone and expressions of extreme male braggadocio suggest a broader misunderstanding about cultural signifiers of masculinity.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/performative-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
With the return from Babylon, a new Jerusalem arose: but the scars remained. This is itself a symbol of the Jewish capacity for memory; but it is also something else. The Ninth of Av is also a reminder of the fragility of Jewish history. To build a city over these burnt sycamore beams of Jewish homes was a way of reminding those Jews that Jewish homes could burn again.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/israel-burnt… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
A Germany serious about guarding against any return to its 20th-century extremes, then, would stay as far away from anti-Zionism as is humanly possible. One cannot be vigilant in one’s anti-Nazism while also dabbling in anti-Zionism. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-war-on-germanys-cultur… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The left doesn't care about indiscretions or violations when it's committed by those on the left."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX7WBbbGDeg -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The U.S. will continue to win its wars against theocratic savages. Our real weakness is that a significant portion of the American people have a problem with winning—so much so that we take our hard-earned victories and place them at the feet of the monsters we’ve defeated."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In July 2021, the Middle East expert Mohammed Soliman wrote of “an Indo-Abrahamic alliance on the rise.” This alliance was marked by the Abraham Accords as well as a growing harmonization of interests between India, Israel, and the United Arab Emirates—spurred in part by dissonance between the UAE and Pakistan and a sense that Turkey’s ambitions to become a leading power in the region had to be countered. The result, Soliman noted, was “an unlikely and unprecedented…transregional order.”
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/saudi-arabi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The 9/11 ideology of bin Ladenism is marked by pride in butchery. Its adherents do not think that when they carry out attacks, they are undertaking a necessary evil. The carnage itself is what they celebrate, death for its own sake. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/bin-ladens-heirs/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Britain’s abstention is interesting when you consider that, back in 1993, 63 members of the UK Parliament had supported a motion that “welcomed” the Abuja Proclamation issued that year.
www.commentary.org/articles/ebenezer-obadare/africa-repar… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Contributing editor @EliLake joins us on this Friday to discuss the current geopolitical reality through the prism of the 25th anniversary of the September 11 attacks and the Global War on Terror.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/25-years-later/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Now that the gala has been canceled, and voices inside the Met are speaking out, we must ask: How did a group of Jewish elite envoys get it so wrong?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-galliano-affair-and-th… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Social media has essentially created not a public square but a global square. And the messages are the third-worldist messages."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=OM2xUqrzbXI -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Younger Americans have no memory of that day, and what they are missing out on, aside from the terror and the grief and the anger, is the way the civilian response filled one with a deep sense of gratitude for the cosmic gift of being an American.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/schools-should-teach-the-9… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israel has repeatedly offered the two-state solution only to be rejected every time by Palestinian leadership, so this puts Israel in a bind. The Israeli government cannot make the Palestinian government want a state. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-is-the-endgame/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
September 10, @continetti recommends the book In The War Room
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The hope of terrorists in 2001 was to frighten people. After October 7th, something else has happened."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=q7BT9ZG7QoY -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
A core element of Bartov’s polemic, and an important reason why it has struck a chord in the intellectual world, is his claim that Israel misuses the memory of the Holocaust, and that this misused memory has itself become a justification for its unjust, indeed evil, policies. He writes: “Since the Hamas massacre was constantly portrayed as genocidal and Hamas described in Israeli media as a Nazi organization … the lessons learned from the Holocaust” called for the war in Gaza to “be implemented as an unavoidably ruthless measure to prevent the repetition of another Auschwitz.”
He writes as if the genocidal essence of the attack of October 7 had not already been described in excruciating detail in numerous accounts in the press.
www.commentary.org/articles/jeffrey-herf/omer-bartov-hist… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
So one is left with the final contradiction: not wanting to die but finding life emotionally painful.
www.commentary.org/articles/joseph-epstein/turning-ninety/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Americans live in a state of hopeless confusion about what we stand for."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=iX7WBbbGDeg -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It seems a stretch to believe that Hamas would be demilitarizing faster and fully were it not for Israeli strikes on munitions depots. But Mladenov is also trying to convince Hamas to stop deploying its forces in ways meant to intimidate Gazan civilians, and in return Hamas is asking for the IDF strikes to stop. Mladenov appears inclined to support those terms.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-capture-of-hamass-secu… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Unlike other journalists, who played it safe, Grossman went to the most dangerous places to interview soldiers under fire. He produced 49 articles about the war, from its first days after the Nazis broke their peace pact with the Soviets and took city after city in an overwhelming onslaught, all the way to the fall of Berlin. Early in the war, his editor gave him two months off to write The People Immortal. Taken together, the novel and articles offer a remarkably powerful portrait of the war as Russians experienced it—and as Jews suffered it.
www.commentary.org/articles/gary-morson/vasily-grossman-u… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Wilder, who was born in 1867, drew upon memories of her hardscrabble girlhood during which she traveled via covered wagon from Wisconsin to Kansas to Minnesota and finally South Dakota, with her three sisters and her parents. The character of Charles Ingalls, Pa, is one of the great masculine figures of American fiction—a man who can’t bear to live too close to other people, and who, with enormous energy and constant good cheer (plus a dose of recklessness), kept hauling his family to new places, promising that this time they would find prosperity. His wife Caroline, Ma, is a woman of gentle, wise forbearance, capable of making a comfortable home anywhere, even in a dirt dugout, as she does in On the Banks of Plum Creek, novel number four. Feisty, impulsive, brown-haired Laura feels herself not as pretty or as good as her obedient and blonde older sister, Mary. But both girls are called upon to help their parents as they confront the untamed wilderness. There’s no room for complaining in this life, which demands immense courage, faith, and hard work.
www.commentary.org/articles/clare-mchugh/laura-ingalls-wi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
And that is the real value in her comments: The easy thing to do—the empty act with zero consequences—is to pile on Israel. Nothing takes less courage than being a Mark Ruffalo or a Javier Bardem—or, in this case, Gerard McCarthy.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/maureen-lipmans-appropriat… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israel doesn’t want these wars and doesn’t want anybody displaced and out of school. Its enemies, however, want that to happen to everybody.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/a-landmark-first-day-of-sc… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"People in their own heads blame the United States for the condition of the world that 9/11 caused than the attackers."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=q7BT9ZG7QoY -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“My contention is that if the politics are unimpeachably good, then the book cannot be beautiful,” she writes. “Moral complexity and aesthetic beauty are, to my mind, inextricably intertwined.” Over the course of almost two decades, she has engaged in a project to read these important works and to see them as part of her own inheritance—not as a trans woman or someone whose parents are South Asian or someone who is on the political left, but as a human being. It wouldn’t be a bad thing if she persuaded more Americans to do the same.
www.commentary.org/articles/naomi-schaefer-riley/great-bo… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today, we look back on the attacks of 9/11, the country’s evolving response, and how we began to lose the thread. To what extent did the media’s decision not to air footage of the attacks turn 9/11 into an abstraction? Give a listen.
www.commentary.org/abe-greenwald/remembering-9-11/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
U.S. laws have been countering this violation of American sovereignty for half a century. One would think El-Sayed and his fellow America Firsters on either side of the aisle would support U.S. companies under attack from authoritarian states. @SethAMandel
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
The Invention of the West Bank
My latest on how a very recent colonial term came to be used instead of the indigenous Jewish name. 'West Bank' is convenient--I sometimes use it too--but Huckabee is correct to use real names and refuse to pretend: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-invention-of-the-west-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
A dark tone was set almost immediately after the fall of the shah, as the victorious revolutionaries carried out a wave of executions of figures associated with the old regime, most of whom had surrendered peacefully. At the same time, the new rulers fell to fighting among themselves for control.
www.commentary.org/articles/joshua-muravchik/stolen-revol… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If you do not know what a blood libel is, perhaps you should exhibit just a little humility before telling Jews what anti-semitism is."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=tkmR8itiFQw -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In her miserable comments over the weekend, Nessel counseled silence and self-erasure. But those who think they can hide behind their silence should know that the rest of us hear that silence just as clearly as we hear those calling for our destruction.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-deafening-silence-of-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The broader strategy of the domestic hate campaign against Israel has been to try to prevent Israel from really going for the knockout blows."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=tkmR8itiFQw -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
After the speech, Nessel gave JTA the following comment: “I think it’s so easy for people to lash out at what they perceive are direct attacks on their faith, on their cultural beliefs, on their historical ancestry. It’s very easy for people to be mad and to say, ‘I reject that.’ I just hope that people will consider that there are many other factors at play.”
In other words: Democratic Party anti-Semitism is real, but her fellow Jews should suck it up and, if necessary, offer themselves as human sacrifices to their pursuers.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/dana-nessel-suggests-jewis… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
One clear message here is that to Trump, constant warfare, with allies and enemies alike, is a feature, not a bug. He does not save up political capital for a fight. He pressures institutions, processes, and players at every juncture. And he wants his people to do the same.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Final Solution to the Jewish Question fails to do what its title promises. But it’s stirring to see how Horn ties the challenges Jews face today to thousands of years of Jewish history. She describes Jewish civilization as a love story, beginning with God and Abraham and continuing with the Jewish people’s love for one another through the ages. The ancestors of every single Jewish person alive today made the choice again and again to stand against the majority, even when facing mortal peril, and stay Jewish. That love and courage is, ultimately, Horn’s answer to the hatred we face once again.
www.commentary.org/articles/harkov-lahav/dara-horn-final-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It was made clear many times over that if the Jews wanted to live, they needed sovereignty in at least part of the land the British had designated as a national Jewish home. Partition went through, but the Arabs rejected it and attempted to kill the Jews anyway.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The good news is that the audience—the group that actually gets final casting approval—has never believed that about anything. It doesn’t read the call sheet as a manifesto. It doesn’t know what a call sheet is. It walked into a movie retelling an ancient story about a soldier trying to get home, looked at the woman playing Helen on the screen, and asked the only casting question that matters: Would you start a war over her?
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/odyssey-lupita-nyong… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
But the crucial question is not whether there is a common good for virtually every political philosophy that claims to pursue one. The question is who has the authority to define it when free citizens disagree. Madison understood that people would hold competing conceptions of justice and flourishing, which is why the Constitution was designed to channel disagreement through representative institutions rather than empower a small class of rulers to impose its preferred vision.
Read all our reader's comments: www.commentary.org/articles/reader-letters/reader-comment… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If the Democratic party says there is no voter fraud, don't sell people a bill of goods. Everybody knows that's not true."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Cp3hhTOunE -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Victor Davis Hanson’s The Counter Revolution takes a very different approach. Drawing on his training as a classics scholar, Hanson views Trump through a sympathetic historian’s lens. He cites no inside sources. He is interested in showing how, in his view, Trump’s combative methods helped fuel his comeback.
www.commentary.org/articles/tevi-troy/trump-regime-change… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It was that “shock factor” that attracted Parra, who told the Post that he likes “the edginess” but “didn’t think it was edgy enough.”
That, in a nutshell, is the GOP’s juvenility problem.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/mike-collins-and-the-gops-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The DSA appeals to educated business class young types, not lunch pailers on the job."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=JoFJmDsMW5A -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
A dark tone was set almost immediately after the fall of the shah, as the victorious revolutionaries carried out a wave of executions of figures associated with the old regime, most of whom had surrendered peacefully. At the same time, the new rulers fell to fighting among themselves for control.
www.commentary.org/articles/joshua-muravchik/stolen-revol… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Horn’s other solution does not so much solve anti-Semitism as it seeks to empower Jews to embrace their heritage and their nationhood.
www.commentary.org/articles/harkov-lahav/dara-horn-final-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today, we begin by considering the significance of Israel’s destruction of Hezbollah’s tunnels in southern Lebanon before moving on to the dismantling of Anna Wintour’s John Galliano Met Gala.
When a public figure makes an anti-Semitic remark, who is supposed to reach out to whom, and how? Give a listen.
www.commentary.org/abe-greenwald/met-his-match/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
But why—if we must learn about the past—should we learn only from white, male authors of the past?
www.commentary.org/articles/naomi-schaefer-riley/great-bo… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It seems as though the U.S. military is, as is sometimes said in chess, “ahead in pieces.” But there’s a reason that, in chess, “ahead in pieces” is the closest you’re going to get to an answer from either player when you ask who is winning. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/are-we-winning-or-losing-t… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
I have narrowed it down to two possibilities: we are either winning the Iran war or losing the Iran war.
My latest on the whiplash and weirdness of trying to figure out where this is all going, and whether anybody actually knows: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/are-we-winning-or-losing-t… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
September 3, @continetti recommends The Bottom of the Harbor by Joseph Mitchell
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"In the midterms there's often a Democratic skew and the polling has been terrible this year."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Cp3hhTOunE -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In truth, it hardly matters. Political correctness couldn’t kill the enthusiasm for Wilder’s work, and the ALA censure meant nothing.
www.commentary.org/articles/clare-mchugh/laura-ingalls-wi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Now that the gala has been canceled, and voices inside the Met are speaking out, we must ask: How did a group of Jewish elite envoys get it so wrong? @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-galliano-affair-and-th… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Who now speaks for the Jews? www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-galliano-affair-and-th…
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The question that we should be asking is not whether a technological innovation is in itself virtuous or destructive. We need rather to ask the following: What, knowing what we do about human beings and human nature, are the most likely outcomes of introducing or distributing a particular piece of technology to the public in a given place at a given time? In other words, realistically speaking and on balance, how do you think this is going to go?"--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
So one is left with the final contradiction: not wanting to die but finding life emotionally painful. One solution may be religion.
www.commentary.org/articles/joseph-epstein/turning-ninety/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Given the bad polls, close polls, prediction markets, and double Dan Sullivans, perhaps the midterms are a jump ball.
We also discuss Hakeem Jeffries’s transformation from leader to follower. Give a listen.
www.commentary.org/abe-greenwald/midterm-madness/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Gaza Board of Peace currently has two running differences of opinion with Israel. The first is over the definition of Hamas’s “disarmament.” Mladenov would like there to be some wiggle room, Israel wants actual full disarmament, no tricks. @SethAMandel
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
September 2, @jpodhoretz recommends American Classic
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"[El-Sayed] would do what he could to leave the 7 million plus Jewish people in Israel defenseless against terrorist attacks on their population."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=opJKPtzVqbc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The demonstrations you see in the streets are by people who have the time and money to just hang out and yell at people."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=JoFJmDsMW5A -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The central argument of the book is as follows: Immediately after the October 7 Hamas assault on Israel, which he describes inadequately and laconically, “Israel declared its intention and then engaged in an attempt to destroy the Palestinian people living in Gaza, in whole or in part, as such, thereby reaching the high bar of the Genocide Convention.” The evidence for this claim is angry—and selectively quoted—statements about the inhumanity of the Hamas killers on October 7 made by Israeli leaders, but Bartov cannot offer any official statement by the prime minister or official government spokesman that it intends to “destroy the Palestinian people,” because there were no such statements. Israel declared war to defeat Hamas, a fact Bartov represses.
www.commentary.org/articles/jeffrey-herf/omer-bartov-hist… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Much of her industry sided against Israel in its defensive war against Hamas and many have now simply made themselves opponents of Israel’s existence. The wider arts world has done the same, abandoning artistic freedom and free speech for a crackdown on Hamas’s vocal critics. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/maureen-lipmans-appropriat… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Seth Moulton got wiped out by Ed Markey in last night’s Democratic primary for Senate in Massachusetts.
We discuss how Moulton, and other Democrats, have struggled to seem authentic amid their party’s lurch to the left.
And what does the DSA mean by “working class”? Give a listen.
www.commentary.org/abe-greenwald/moulton-point/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Stalin is supposed to have observed that one death is a tragedy but a million is a statistic. The artistic problem facing Grossman was the same that confronted Solzhenitsyn in his descriptions of the Gulag: how to reveal the horror behind the numbers.
www.commentary.org/articles/gary-morson/vasily-grossman-u… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The mayor of New York City is on record as downplaying the significance of 9/11 and highlighting the evils done by America."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=opJKPtzVqbc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This is a sign of the resilience of the Israeli people. For all the setbacks Israelis endured—and the school system is still struggling with numerous lingering problems—they are determined to resume a sense of normalcy in any way they can. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/a-landmark-first-day-of-sc… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The US government is not supposed to be an economic player in a private market."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=xh6p3UiTURM -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
All of Piker’s caveman anti-Semitism is being done for the benefit of Abdul El-Sayed, the angry Jew-baiting Democratic candidate for Senate in Baby Gap t-shirts who also fears Piker’s disapproval.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/fears-of-a-clown/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
All things considered, Ghana’s leadership of the reparations campaign is an extension of its heritage diplomacy.
www.commentary.org/articles/ebenezer-obadare/africa-repar… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Although campus anti-Semitism exploded after the Hamas attacks, silence was the response practiced by many in positions of authority. And that silence was arguably just as shocking as the Hamasnik calls for Jewish blood that rang out from America’s elite university campuses. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-deafening-silence-of-t… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Incel gamers moldering away in their parents’ basements 'turned on' their screens and 'dropped out' of society every bit as much as the acid-eating hippies had a half-century earlier. And they 'tuned in' to an endless array of angry, populist right-wing streamers from their own generation."--from the newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
At the moment, Israel is trying is to keep Hezbollah’s forces from getting too close to the border. Distance is the best defense against tethered drones for now.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-war-on-a-string/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"It's shocking the way that they've never come up against real world opinion or dissent on their issue."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zkb3CzpAVtA -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In other words, as a resurrection of Jerusalem was occurring, a choice was made to leave a charred, scarred remnant of the Jerusalem that was. Or as the reporter Amit Segal put it, “When Jerusalem’s residents returned from the Babylonian exile…they left the ruins deliberately in place, laying the new city over the scars of the old.”
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/israel-burnt… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today, we devote the podcast to Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel’s shameful suggestion that Jewish security and survival may have to be sacrificed for the good of humanity. Give a listen.
www.commentary.org/abe-greenwald/whats-danas-deal/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Why would anyone who supports Palestinian sovereignty oppose the creation of a Palestinian state? Because they oppose the continued existence of the Jewish state. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/explaining-el-sayeds-posit… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Trump wanted to escape the consequences of the aborted war and his responsibility to win it—and he let the Iranians know. That was all it took."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"It's literally a Jewish purge of the sitting Jewish members of Congress and it's going to be even more terrifying."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=xh6p3UiTURM -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
They prayed. What followed was an Arab campaign of incitement and then the pogroms, enabled by the British, during which more than a hundred Jews were murdered.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/blaming-the-jews-for-the-1… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
But the problems raised by the current war loom large. The inability of the United States to secure a victory, let alone defend the skies over Saudi Arabia, has left Riyadh in a perpetual state of doubt. The Turks, Egyptians, and Pakistanis continue to offer an alternative. Only a decisive American victory and an Iranian defeat can put IMEC back on track and pave the way for a new regional order.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/saudi-arabi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
At a gathering of Jewish Democrats this weekend, Dana Nessel made an astounding concession to the harassers that ensured the Jew-baiting will continue unabated.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/dana-nessel-suggests-jewis… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: The economic war on Iran seems to be working, and the U.S. has resumed targeted strikes.
Does this combination of tactics at last add up to a winning strategy?
Plus, DEI at the University of California, Berkeley’s law journal and anti-Semites on the attack. Give a listen.
www.commentary.org/abe-greenwald/getting-iran-right/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Real masculinity doesn’t preen or flex. It just shows up. It does what is needed. It demonstrates the steady virtues of strength and leadership and personal responsibility and courage. It protects and defends.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/performative-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Feminists are out supporting Lindsey Clancy, but Natalie Harp's committed this terrible crime of being a loyal employee of Donald Trump."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zkb3CzpAVtA -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Katz, Moraff, Fan, and a host of other progressive activists and influencers stuck with Platner through to the bitter end.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/morris-katz-gr… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Hanson calls the second Trump term “the most dramatic political comeback in American presidential history.” He argues that it was Trump’s critics and enemies who drove many Americans to feel that the forces at work against Trump were far more dangerous than Trump himself. As a result, while the detailed and grubby stories of
Regime Change make for a more gripping read, Hanson’s more provocative perspective will provide future generations with a deeper understanding of why Trump managed to return to the White House to begin with.
www.commentary.org/articles/tevi-troy/trump-regime-change… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Horn’s great strength is her ability to make the unspeakable horrors of the Jewish past more accessible to a contemporary audience. I finished the book days before Tisha B’Av, when Jews fast in memory of the destruction of the Temples in Jerusalem, and I found one comparison she offers deeply chilling. The Tisha B’Av service includes the martyrology—a series of texts recounting the murders of Jews from the time of the Roman Empire through the Holocaust. The central texts concern 10 sages who were tortured by the Romans; they flayed one rabbi’s face and wrapped another rabbi in a Torah scroll and burned him in it. The Romans brought the rabbis to their grisly fates in a stadium full of onlookers, “an ancient version of livestreaming murder,” Horn writes. In just these few words, Horn ties Rabbi Akiva and his colleagues to Hamas’s massacre of Israelis in their homes.
www.commentary.org/articles/harkov-lahav/dara-horn-final-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The necessity of destroying the Islamic State was obvious. But the challenge was greater due to Obama’s unnecessary withdrawal from Iraq and then his reluctance to provide adequate resources to make good on his new pledge to “degrade and destroy” the caliphate.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Helen of Troy has one function in the story: to be a woman men will cross an ocean and burn a city for. She has to be exotic and arresting. Remember whose daughter Helen is. Her mother was Leda; her father was Zeus pretending to be a swan. Helen arrived in an egg. She is not supposed to look like the pretty girl from your high school. She is supposed to look like an exotic, otherworldly, ravishing prize.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/odyssey-lupita-nyong… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"School systems have to take those 10 million iPads that they bought and throw them in the garbage can."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4CeBFcC0so -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What’s So Great About the Great Books? is in part a personal and in part a philosophical account of why she finds the mostly Western canon so compelling, and why she has spent the past 17 years reading through as many of these works as she can. A novelist and author of a blog called Woman of Letters, Kanakia does occupy herself with the question of what constitutes a list of the Great Books, but she does not want to spend a lot of time defending each book’s addition or subtraction. Instead, she points readers to Clifton Fadiman’s Lifetime Reading Plan (1960), which consists of 268 works from The Epic of Gilgamesh to The Adventures of Augie March.
www.commentary.org/articles/naomi-schaefer-riley/great-bo… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"She's praying that the president of the United States is guided by God and that God helps him lead more effectively."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3jVehmwsZw -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What now? Stolen Revolution leaves us with contradictory lessons. On the one hand, we see how relentlessly Iranians have struggled to reform or rid themselves of the Islamic Republic. On the other hand, we see how difficult that has proven to be. Tragically, while ordinary dictators like Egypt’s Hosni Mubarak or Iran’s shah are often toppled, totalitarian or extremely repressive dictatorships are exceedingly difficult to oust. Mussolini and Hitler were unchallenged until their countries were badly losing the war that the dictators had dragged them into. Communism had never been overthrown until Mikhail Gorbachev toppled the Soviet system and its empire from above. What about Iran’s rulers? Is the Mossad’s optimism well-founded? Or will Trump’s decision to cut his losses leave the clerics and the Revolutionary Guards in power for years to come?
www.commentary.org/articles/joshua-muravchik/stolen-revol… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
But the West ought to be able to walk and chew gum at the same time. There’s no reason to be unbothered by Erdogan’s adventurism. And yet, we apparently are.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/turkeys-imperial-fantasies… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Republican Party has an absurd number of young staffers and potential staffers indulging in the right-wing “ironic Nazi” social trend. And toxic feeder streams pollute the whole river. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/mike-collins-and-the-gops-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Of course, subjecting all building in Judea and Samaria to final-status agreement would make a whole lot of Palestinian construction invalid. But we know that’s not what the Europeans are proposing; they simply want there to be more housing restrictions on Jews than on non-Jews.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There is perhaps no greater testament to the genius of novelist Laura Ingalls Wilder, and the enduring power of her stories for children, than the desire of the hall monitors of American cultural life—librarians and academics, plus their eager acolytes in Hollywood—to admonish and correct her.
www.commentary.org/articles/clare-mchugh/laura-ingalls-wi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It’s important to note here that anti-Semites in New York or Michigan aren’t any less pathetic than the anti-Semites in Florida. These people are losers across the board who are looking to scapegoat Jews because they need an excuse for their own failings. It’s just that, whatever the combination of reasons, this level of self-pity and delusion doesn’t seem to play as well in Florida.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/florida-curbs-the-anti-zio… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Friday, and we are here to discuss Trump’s latest stunt with the renaming of Lake Ontario, the story of Natalie Harp, the ongoing controversy over the Lindsay Clancy murder trial and the modern popularity of transgressive ideas, and @jpodhoretz recommends Coyote vs. Acme.
www.commentary.org/abe-greenwald/whats-in-a-name-5/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
August 27, @continetti recommends Free Creations of the Human Mind
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
So one is left with the final contradiction: not wanting to die but finding life emotionally painful. One solution may be religion. With the aid of true religion and its confident belief in the afterlife, one might even welcome death and its rewards in Heaven. Many Catholics do. But the afterlife is more complicated for Jews, as comes through in the old story of the village idiot in the shtetl of Frampol, who is given the job of awaiting the arrival of the Messiah at the village gates and told that, while the pay is low, the work is steady.
www.commentary.org/articles/joseph-epstein/turning-ninety/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Deterrence by disclosure . . . was nonsense because Putin himself gave this crazy speech justifying the fact that he was going to invade."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=q4CeBFcC0so -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We can't lose the tech war to China."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=JHRkfhvyDQk -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Russian experience shows that totalitarians will go as far as they can unless they are stopped, and so what really matters is whether the liberals and progressives who may not share their views are willing to oppose them. What really scares me is how rare such opposition still is.
www.commentary.org/articles/gary-morson/vasily-grossman-u… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If someone attacks Jewish children in the street, I don’t care what they’re angry about. It’s entirely irrelevant. Every single instance of anti-Semitism is inexcusable.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/a-swedish-palestinian-lawm… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we are joined by our friends @EliLake and @continetti to discuss CIA Director John Ratcliffe’s trip to Russia, the interconnectivity of Ukraine and Iran, and the American delusion regarding warfare.
Plus, will Meta’s massive settlement on child safety actually produce results, the growing controversy in democratic circles regarding leftist streamer Hasan Piker, and Matt recommends Free Creations of the Human Mind.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/off-a-cliffe/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Bartov’s tome is likely to contribute to the ongoing effort to make hatred of Israel respectable in the faculty lounge, the editorial office, the think tank, and in many political parties. Its lack of scholarly distinction will not diminish its contribution to the global campaign to undermine the legitimacy of the state of Israel.
www.commentary.org/articles/jeffrey-herf/omer-bartov-hist… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
@rcbl: "Everything that's really important about her in the eternal sense is available to us every minute of the day."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3jVehmwsZw -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The earth of Israel contains what outlasted the destruction by the Jordanians of the 20th century and by the Romans of the first century: One mikveh separated by another, separated by soot and ash and thousands of years of conquest.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/israel-burnt… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"DEI is delegitimizing itself every day with these stories."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=zi-I2ewjGb8 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Before we consider the merits of the case for “reparatory justice,” it is important to understand why Ghana is leading the contemporary campaign. In 1957, Ghana became the first sub-Saharan African nation to gain formal independence, and it has always seen itself as a “beacon” for the complete liberation and unification of Africa. Its first president, Kwame Nkrumah, set this conviction in stone with his statement that Ghana’s independence “is meaningless unless it is linked up with the total liberation of Africa.” If, for Nkrumah, Ghana’s independence meant nothing without freedom for all of Africa, similarly, African independence meant little unless understood as an aspect of liberation for black people everywhere, especially in the United States. That’s where Nkrumah, who had attended the University of Pennsylvania in the early 1940s, had gotten a taste of what life was like for the average Negro of that era.
www.commentary.org/articles/ebenezer-obadare/africa-repar… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
So the new Iran is not content with blocking one major commercial waterway; it wants to choke every artery it can reach.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/meet-irans-new-thugocracy/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Commentary’s Hollywood Commentary columnist @rcbl joins us today to discuss the passing of the legendary Dolly Parton, her status as a consensus figure in American culture, and her amazing and storied life.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/goodbye-dolly/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"I just can't believe how much experts get it wrong."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=JHRkfhvyDQk -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
So we’ve determined whom the party’s powers-that-be are afraid of: a Twitch streamer. And we’ve determined what they are afraid of: mean tweets from Piker or his fans. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/fears-of-a-clown/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The tale of the president and his loyal aide makes Trump look better than any story I’ve ever read about him."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The events that followed produced lessons in three problems that have held back the government’s attempts to restore the civil rights of America’s Jewish college students:
1. The ideological opposition to combating anti-Semitism among career bureaucrats.
2. Those same bureaucrats’ resentment at being told to apply civil-rights law, specifically Title VI, to Jews.
3. The Trump administration’s aversion to process norms.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/democrats-take-aim-at-the-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
These four Sunni powers have undeniably forged an important alliance. But they lack a coherent strategy.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/saudi-arabi… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss how American politicians are dealing with the hot button topic of data centers and how opposition to them is the latest manifestation of tech anxiety, as well as the increasingly larger part AI plays in our daily lives.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/data-driven/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
On the right, supporters of a thoroughly populist GOP have embraced some of the worst aspects of the so-called manosphere, including, too often, its misogyny.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/performative-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This is Trojan horsery, that they are pretending to be something that they're not, and then take power."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=TfZwLimbVHQ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The lesson of October 7 was that everything Hamas does is to test Israel’s defenses. Inaction, too, is a test. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-war-on-a-string/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The ironies are so thick that you cannot there's no way even to like get to the bottom of it."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=zi-I2ewjGb8 -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
How the media paints Israel as evil--and then superimposes that portrait on all of Jewish history. My latest on a psychotically deranged Guardian article blaming the Jews for the 1929 pogroms: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/blaming-the-jews-for-the-1…
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
August 24, @jpodhoretz recommends The Testament of Ann Lee
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The purpose of Holocaust education is education. The purpose of the work being done by Raz Segal, Briahna Joy Gray and the Democratic Socialists of America is the opposite of education. Let’s help society stop confusing the two.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-plague-of-and-genocide… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Platner called Moraff, the consultant who introduced him to Katz, a “mad scientist with politics.” It’s a fitting phrase for this new cohort of progressive operatives, whose experiments can yield unintended results.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/morris-katz-gr… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
By the broadest and most important indicator, then, one must ask: If this is failure, what would success have looked like?
www.commentary.org/articles/tod-lindberg/global-war-on-te… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We’re back from break to discuss Karen Attiah’s reinstatement at the Washington Post and the absurdity of forced employment in the opinion journalism space, as well as the troubling online support for Luigi Mangione, Lindsay Clancy, and Jason Arday.
Plus, Abdul El-Sayed attempts to soften his image on American Jews while accepting money from CAIR, and @jpodhoretz recommends The Testament of Ann Lee.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/parasocial-media/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Israel's amazing intelligence services have supplied us with completely invaluable information."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=TfZwLimbVHQ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“This is how we often talked: two women applying their makeup, sharing the small conspiracies of our days,” she writes.
www.commentary.org/articles/nancy-rommelmann/motherhood-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To President Joe Biden, however, those years of higher prices meant companies were “ripping off” the American people, not recovering the outlays that make future medicines possible. In 2022, he signed the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), which, among other things, empowers Medicare to impose price limits on selected smallmolecule drugs nine years after FDA clearance. Small-molecule drugs are the traditional pills and tablets patients take regularly. Relatively cheap to manufacture, store, and administer, they are the affordable workhorses used to treat chronic ailments at scale—think blood pressure medicines and statins.
www.commentary.org/articles/mworonof/american-biotech-ced… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Of course, if Hamas were truly committed to disarming, this meeting could have been a quick WhatsApp text. Kushner doesn’t need the jetlag just for empty words. And there is evidence Kushner’s impervious-to-carbonation demeanor is starting to give way to annoyance.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"[Trump]'s trying to get stuff done that he can get done by himself without having to worry about the courts or the Congress."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=adgJv65XQfs -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We sent him a script, he said yes, we haggled on a fee, we had a deal. And now he was saying, essentially, the deal was off. But those words have a legal meaning, too. They meant that we could fire him for cause, without a complicated and generous settlement.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The story and popularity of “God Bless America,” I said, reflected America’s penchant for prayer, and it also reminded us, at a time when Jew-hatred was festering, that “anti-Semitism is utterly un-American.” The crowd cheered that assertion. And then, as I left the gathering, I kept encountering attendees who expressed their appreciation for my words. They were Christians who had come to pray at the Capitol, and they went out of their way to thank the rabbi for his message, to embrace him as a Jew—and as a fellow American.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/us-independe… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Ossoff is a skillful campaigner. Whether he is a man of substance as well remains to be seen. On that count, Morris is skeptical.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jon-ossoff-josh-shapiro-an… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Ottoman Empire stood for the better part of a millennium, but it would not be missed.
Except by the likes of Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who seems to think of the lost empire the way Vladimir Putin yearns for the Soviet Union. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/turkeys-imperial-fantasies… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"MBS has dragged the country into this century and he deserves an enormous amount of credit."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=3prTufvZUZ8 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
With a nod to the Magna Carta and its utility in promoting the rights of Englishmen, the principles of the Founding of the United States as a rights-regarding republic were the real-world instantiation of liberal democracy.
www.commentary.org/articles/tod-lindberg/great-powers-ret… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What Levy preserved for the United States was an indelible part of its birthright. He began with the statue.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-auslin/jews-declarati… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
As investigations like this continue, we’ll get a look at who feels the same way—and who knew exactly what they were involved with all along.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/investigating-chinas-role-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Are European leaders suggesting that Israel must relinquish E1? Or is their position that E1 should be subject to final-status negotiations before anyone lives there? The latter is coherent, at least. The former is not on the table and has never been on the table, including in the proposals that these European governments have supported. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/map-quest/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s time for another mailbag episode. Our producer @neontaster joins us to answer questions on the U.S.-Israel alliance, post-Bibi Israel, the funniest moments in politics, our favorite museums, and more.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/weve-got-mail/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In one fell swoop, Simona Mohamsson schooled nearly the entire Western world. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/a-swedish-palestinian-lawm… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The Republican party is his party now. There's no question about that . . ."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=adgJv65XQfs -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The most controversial part of the book is its final chapter, which brings the story to the present day. Opinions about the founders of the modern era, whether corporate or political, are extraordinarily contentious. Herman’s choice to label Donald Trump as a present-day founder will certainly be deemed as partisan, but he makes a case. Trump is connected to previous founders by his origins—despite his immense wealth and cultural cachet, still a political outsider—and his willingness to break the status quo in pursuit of an original vision. Still, it is unclear just what Trump can be said to have founded, or innovated, besides his own career. Had Herman more deeply explored the potential downsides of the “founder” in American history, including with characters like Woodrow Wilson, Trump’s inclusion might be more broadly palatable.
www.commentary.org/articles/mike-cote/founders-fire-1776-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Nixon actually told the Times that “practically speaking, [AGI] will achieve the outcomes that many religions claim their deities would be able to achieve.” Another executive agreed: “People are matter-of-factly saying that they are looking to build a machine God. . . . They are not saying that ironically or in jest.”
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/ai-anthropic-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"[Trump] sort of proved that the consultant class in politics are completely worthless, right?"
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=-4_kmKXxJAI -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Culture really does seem to matter, and the anti-Zionist activists had a worse go on both sides of the aisle in Florida’s major races. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/florida-curbs-the-anti-zio… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The most prominent American socialists who call for the U.S.’s destruction tend also to be among the most blessed by American liberty and the free market."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The Saudis are snubbing Israel and the United States."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=3prTufvZUZ8 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There are, as it turns out, plenty of words in Arabic for concepts such as “compassion” and “sympathy” and “empathy.” And needless to say, Arabs demonstrate these qualities in practice every day throughout the Arab world, and not least in the many thousands of Arab-Israeli physicians and nurses in Israel, who demonstrate care and compassion in their treatment of Jewish, Christian, and Muslim patients alike.
www.commentary.org/articles/irina-velitskaya/hell-russia-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Consider the lengths to which Miller and his colleagues at the Bulwark have gone to downplay, if not deny, the extremism of the Democratic Party’s burgeoning progressive left. In April, the publication ran a piece entitled “How Big Is the Democrats’ ‘Big Tent?’” One center-left activist quoted in the article argued it was getting too big: “If people really are arguing that the price of winning is becoming like a bigoted misogynist like Hasan Piker, then I’ll take not winning,” said Jonathan Cowan.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/partisanship-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Like clockwork, Jamie Raskin, the Maryland congressman and ranking Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee, took the baton handed to him by Van Erem and promised retribution for Trump officials. He called the anti-Semitism investigations a “frame-up operation” and threatened to push changes to the Civil Rights Act itself. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/democrats-take-aim-at-the-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"It took the Patriot Act and the Homeland Security Act to make that possible. Before then, there was a wall between the agencies."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=PxlL13ptNew -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Campus anti-Semitism is coming from the institutions themselves.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-replacement-of-educati… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @FDD’s @JSchanzer joins us on this week-long series of interviews for our upcoming September print issue to discuss his article on the two paths that lie before Saudi Arabia—a pro-American route, and a darker alternative.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/riyadh-politik/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Testing the West’s defenses this way is typical behavior from the wider China-led bloc. The Iranians, for example, use proxies to prod the good guys and look for weaknesses.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/we-are-being-tested/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
The problem with Holocaust and Genocide Studies is "and Genocide Studies." My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-plague-of-and-genocide…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"These people don't really have their finger on the pulse of what the American working class wants."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast joined by @jkirchick: www.youtube.com/watch?v=-4_kmKXxJAIThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Crabapple’s book is sprinkled with solecisms. Anyone with an elementary knowledge of Jewish history, or history of the 19th and 20th century, will be astonished to read the following: “The Great War began with the inevitability of a Grecian play.”
www.commentary.org/articles/david-wolpe/jewish-bund-molly… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"He hates football, fireworks, bacon, and dogs. You got a pretty fertile field of otherness there."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vex9vx7OgdA -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The ultimate statement of the meteor-like impact of the Revolution, however, was reserved for the British-born propagandist Thomas Paine, who wrote in January 1776 that the Revolution offered Americans “every opportunity and every encouragement…to form the noblest, purest constitution on the face of the earth.” Even more, “We have in our power to begin the world over again. A situation, similar to the present, hath not happened since the days of Noah until now. The birthday of a new world is at hand.”
www.commentary.org/articles/allen-guelzo/american-revolut… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The new Iran is not content with blocking one major commercial waterway; it wants to choke every artery it can reach. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/meet-irans-new-thugocracy/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Meet Iran's New Thugocracy
Today I look at the restructured Iranian government, which has now basically reconstituted itself as an IRGC state rather than a state with an IRGC. Here's what that means, with specifics: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/meet-irans-new-thugocracy/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There is of course much irony in the fact that, before 1948, “Palestinian from the pre-1948 borders” would have meant Jews, especially during the portion of the Mandate when Arabs in the Holy Land still considered themselves part of a Syrian polity.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/how-israeli-came-to-mean-j… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Khanna’s answer to how Israel could have negotiated a non-Hamas Gaza is that Israel should have negotiated with Hamas.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-great-dumbing-down-of-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our Washington Commentary Columnist @jkirchick joins us on this week-long series of interviews for our upcoming September print issue.
We welcome Jamie to our line of commentary columnists and discuss his piece on the progressive consultant class bubble. -
Commentary Magazine reposted
FDD
@FDD
The Saudis are key to the success of IMEC. But more important, between their vast financial resources and religious influence in the wider Muslim world, they are the key to regional stability, explains @JSchanzer in @Commentary: www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/saudi-arabi…
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Jonathan Schanzer
@JSchanzer
From my latest in @Commentary: www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/saudi-arabi…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There was not a comparable attack following up on the US homeland of this degree and severity of 9/11 . . . this is a quite remarkable achievement."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=PxlL13ptNew -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Punishments for plagiarism differ in different realms. For scholars, they can be serious. In The Little Book of Plagiarism, Posner cites the case of Julius Kirshner, the University of Chicago historian, who published under his own name a book review written by one of his graduate students and was penalized by the university by not being permitted to teach graduate students for the next five years.
www.commentary.org/articles/joseph-epstein/plagiarism-wri… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The September issue of Commentary is now available.
This issue covers the Global War on Terror, performative masculinity, Saudi Arabia at a crossroads, the rise of the next generation of progressive political operatives, and more.
With contributions from @todlindberg, @jkirchick, @jschanzer, @JeffreyHerf, Gary Saul Morson, @NaomiSRiley, @TeviTroy, @rcbl.
Read on at commentary.org and subscribe at commentary.org/subscribe. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It is indeed a landmark in American history, but often forgotten is that Washington wrote an earlier letter to the Jews of Savannah, because of course the Jews couldn’t all agree on getting together and sending Washington one letter. So they ended up sending him three letters, and Washington is probably wondering why these fellows keep sending me letters. But he responded to every one of these. There’s like around 2,000 Jews in America at this point, John. They send three letters. His response to the Savannah letter, in June 1790, uses language that I think is as important, though much less well known.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/history-americ… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
No one thinks Hamas is committed to peace. No one. Not even Steve Witkoff. But people are impatient. And—this part’s important—most observers don’t really care what happens to the Israelis and the Gazans. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/hamas-disarmament-is-the-o… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Indeed, a larger lesson of this whole post-October 7 environment on campus is that all over the country, young Jews are teaching their elders what it actually means to speak truth to power and show some spine. If courage is contagious, perhaps they will have a few more allies in the future.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jewish-students-regain-fre… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Hudson Institute Senior Fellow @todlindberg joins us on this week-long series of interviews for our upcoming September print issue to discuss his cover story on the War on Terror and the global changes in the quarter century since the September 11 attacks.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Why is it so important for DSA types to hold to such an embarrassingly false claim?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/why-dsa-leaders-dont-know-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"How many times a minority group has been told to fix what's wrong with it instead of protecting the group?"
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vex9vx7OgdA -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The People’s Forum, a pro-Chinese Communist Party propaganda outfit, was a key player in the pro-Hamas astroturf campaign across the U.S. and Western Europe after October 7, 2023.
And it now finds itself under increased congressional scrutiny for its role in the China-Russia-Iran bid to destabilize the West. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/investigating-chinas-role-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The worldview is love of country, which leads to a set of ideas about how to protect it, nurture it.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/america-jews-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There is always the chance that Trump will reject the piracy deal. If he doesn’t, pretty soon the world’s shipping lanes will belong to whoever has the most suicide drones.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/legalized-piracy-in-the-st… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The real benefit of heads-on-sticks is that when the rest of the team realizes that the head really is on a stick, that it isn’t about to come back to life, they feel emboldened to reveal just what a jerk the guy was all along. When I walked onto the soundstage the morning after firing Evil Unnamed Get, I was greeted with—I am not kidding—a standing ovation from the rest of the cast. Turned out, they hated him too. I don’t expect Bari and Nick got anything remotely like that response, and my guess is that it’s going to be a very chilly place to work for the next few months.
Until they succeed. Which I fervently hope they do, because then maybe it won’t be just a head on a stick for CBS News but for television news in general.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/scott-pelley-cbs-fir… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“I’m sorry I couldn’t save you,” the mother whispers. “I’m so sorry I couldn’t save you, my darling girl.”
www.commentary.org/articles/nancy-rommelmann/motherhood-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Democratic Socialist America is its own party, and the leading figure in the insurgency in the United States for the last 10 years is Bernie Sanders."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=tvsGd5DRI-M -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The “enterprising spirit” Tocqueville recognized is Herman’s “founder’s fire,” and it has indeed characterized the history and people of the United States ever since. If we make the choice to maintain that Promethean fire and continue to create and empower the risk-seeking visionaries who have made America into the exceptional nation it is, that ongoing triumph for liberty will continue. And that is well worth remembering as we celebrate the 250th anniversary of our founding.
www.commentary.org/articles/mike-cote/founders-fire-1776-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Levy was a trailblazer in sparking Jewish civic philanthropy, giving to the nation as much as if not more than far-better-known Jews later gave to the sciences, finance, and education. What Levy preserved for the United States was an indelible part of its birthright. He began with the statue.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-auslin/jews-declarati… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
I've been trying to figure out why David Axelrod said what he said on Tuesday night after Abdul El-Sayed squeaked by Haley Stevens in the Michigan Democratic Senate primary.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/why-david-axelrod-smeared-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Experiencing the many thousands who had come to pray—and who immediately cheered a condemnation of Jew-hate—was, for me, a moment that I will remember on this Fourth of July as I stand in synagogue on the Sabbath and pray once more that this country experiences a defeat of anti-Semitism in this land—and that God continues to bless America.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/us-independe… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It’s a race-war camp, in other words. An indoctrination station for children to learn to see Jews as the proper targets of violence. Welcome to Britain!
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/palestinian-radicalization… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The return of great powers adversarial to the United States doesn’t change that. It just makes the challenge of upholding those principles harder. That’s where American power once again comes to the foreground. It has always been the backdrop.
www.commentary.org/articles/tod-lindberg/great-powers-ret… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Friday, and we close out the week by discussing the tendency of leftist candidates to publicly put down favorite American pastimes and places and how this could impact Abdul El-Sayed’s political ambitions.
Plus, the antisemitism reckoning at Haverford College, the dismissal of the antisemitism case against Harvard, and Duke’s racial admissions discrimination. Also, @elianayjohnson recommends the Netflix documentary Mourinho.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/non-campus-mentis/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Posner notes, rightly, that creativity is not the same as originality. One can be the former without being the latter.
www.commentary.org/articles/joseph-epstein/plagiarism-wri… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Nixon actually told the Times that “practically speaking, [AGI] will achieve the outcomes that many religions claim their deities would be able to achieve.” Another executive agreed: “People are matter-of-factly saying that they are looking to build a machine God. . . . They are not saying that ironically or in jest.”
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/ai-anthropic-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Why on earth any American would want our House of Representatives to resemble the UN General Assembly is an eternal mystery to me."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=tvsGd5DRI-M -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
August 13, @continetti recommends No Middle Name by Lee Child
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"She has said that her proximity to whiteness makes her uncomfortable and mentioned that she has a half-white child."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=0bj0FXSXKzQ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What a difference seven years makes. Today, Miller and many others in the conservative “Never Trump” space are no longer homeless. Like many one-time political operatives, Miller now fashions himself a political analyst, and he has made himself a home at the Bulwark, a news and opinion website, alongside several other ex-Republican strategists. While it occasionally offers criticism of left-wing excesses, the Bulwark is a highly partisan outlet whose overriding purpose is to generate enthusiasm for Democrats and loathing of Republicans.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/partisanship-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Instead of providing a serious history of this fascinating if minor blip in Jewish history, the author follows the Bundists off their suicidal cliff in 2026, more than a hundred years after the party was dissolved.
www.commentary.org/articles/david-wolpe/jewish-bund-molly… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @continetti is back to discuss recent primary results and the artificial differences between so-called establishment and insurgent nominees, and how muddying these lines allows socialism to infiltrate mainstream democratic circles.
Plus, the debate surrounding “woke 1” and what a post-Trump right might look like, and Matt recommends Lee Child’s No Middle Name.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/backdoor-socialism/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Mike Coté
@ratlpolicy
And if you want to know more about that malignant antisemitic conspiracy theory & how it is becoming mainstream on the progressive left, you can read my essay on the topic for @Commentary:
www.commentary.org/articles/mike-cote/anti-zionists-mains… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Abdul El-Sayed’s contempt for his fellow Democrats was a feature, not a bug. And now it has been vindicated more than even El-Sayed could possibly have expected.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/democrats-lived-down-to-el… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"It’s now clear that the fiercest elements have indeed come out on top. The revolution is no longer dominated by the ideas of featherweight academics such as Ibram X. Kendi and Robin DiAngelo. All that redemptive white fragility and anti-racism and intersectionality was sundered in a flash after October 7, 2023. A few bestselling authors didn’t stand a chance against the Marxist-jihadist alliance that swooped in with its genocidal chants and terrorist regalia. Woke 2, if we’re going to call it that, is in the hands of Communists and Islamists."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The proliferation of pro-terrorism lessons is one of the more disturbing patterns in American higher education. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-replacement-of-educati… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"New York magazine has just implicitly endorsed the elimination of the state of Israel because there's this land mass."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=0bj0FXSXKzQ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
On more than one occasion, I witnessed Stephan reel out of our cabin to our outhouse or nearby doghouse to vomit, and then come back to drink the rest of the wine. Other times, he would drain bottles of cheap, alcohol-based colognes called Troynoy and Shipr that he’d “borrowed” from my grandfather. (One reviewer of Shipr online averred that Russia “had some of the best-smelling bums and alcoholics!”)
www.commentary.org/articles/irina-velitskaya/hell-russia-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
A Russian bomb was planted at a German airport near a Ukrainian jet. If the implications are true, then that would mean Russia has taken its active war against Ukraine into German territory and planted a bomb in a NATO country. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/we-are-being-tested/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This is what we used to unironically call “virtue signaling.” It’s just a shame we can’t see the signal through the fog.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-smug-of-war/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are back to discuss the fallout of Francesca Hong’s loss in the Wisconsin gubernatorial primary and what another stunning polling error that radically favored far left candidates tells us about upcoming races.
Plus, Trump endorsements no longer guarantee victory to republican primary candidates, the controversy surrounding the security incident involving Air Force One in Ankara, and John recommends James Ellroy’s Red Sheet.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/poll-vaulting/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
For obvious reasons, the United States simply cannot do that.
So what can be done instead? Well, the PA could stop supporting terrorism.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-palestinian-authority-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This man is galactically unserious, and his prospective candidacy itself is an insult to the American people. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-great-dumbing-down-of-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Winning the war would have all sorts of ancillary benefits . . . but losing is the end of everything."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=TdId6VPe9JM -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
A person modifying Syrian cooking and calling it Palestinian and then telling a Jew he may not also cook the dish is reminiscent of the line from the Princess Bride in which Vizzini accuses the Man in Black of “trying to kidnap what I’ve rightfully stolen.” @SethAMandel
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israel’s advocates often correctly point out that the Jewish state has made concessions when it believes it has strong U.S. support. Israel’s critics routinely misunderstand this.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/israel-and-the-midterms/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s primary day in Wisconsin, and Francesca Hong is in the spotlight with her history of terrible comments and social media posts, AOC hand-waves “woke 1” and announces IVF treatments, and New York Magazine’s antisemitism-infused ode to Middle Eastern food and culture in NYC.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/hong-out-to-dry/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Piker isn’t anywhere near the outermost fringe of El-Sayed’s political and social circle. In fact, El-Sayed is much closer to jihadist terror organizations than Piker is. So why are we talking about Piker?" From the newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We don’t have anything more to learn from John Galliano. Honor him, don’t honor him—let the fashion world follow its exuberant heart wherever it leads it, so long as the Jews aren’t props in the show.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-galliano-question/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
And what’s important to emphasize is that what marked the dawn of Jewish equality was not merely a granting of equal rights in the way that, say, Jews were offered equal rights in post-revolutionary France. What was unique here is that the Jews felt simultaneously comfortable with being fully American while bringing their Jewishness with them into the public square. And when they felt that wasn’t available—for example, when certain states, because of test oaths requiring legislators to state their fealty to Christianity, barred Jews from serving in the legislature—the Jews protested as Jews and as Americans. They cited both their equal rights as Jews, but also the fact that they had served in the Revolution and taken part in the Founding of the United States. And so we find not just equality granted to the Jews, but equality granted to them as Jews. That is at the heart of the uniqueness of the American Jewish story.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/history-americ… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The more you read it is not really a plan to disarm Hamas since it will literally take a decade to disarm Hamas."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=TdId6VPe9JM -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The Iranian leadership doesn't give a s*** about the Iranian people . . . they're mass murderers, they are religious fanatics."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=_zdrgJEF2Wk -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The demand for ingenuity persists. Researchers have identified more than 10,000 rare diseases; it’s estimated that fewer than 10 percent have approved treatments. Over two-thirds of American adults suffer from chronic illness; cancer touches roughly 2 in 5 Americans over their lifetime; more than 7 million Americans have Alzheimer’s.
www.commentary.org/articles/mworonof/american-biotech-ced… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are back to discuss the never ending cycle of the Iran war and the forming regional alliances in the wake of an American power vacuum, as well as the president’s polling and the looming electoral disaster in the midterms.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/no-way-out/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
No one who paints swastikas on Jews cares about what the Israeli government does or does not believe.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-semitic-hounding-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
He was an artist who became a businessman, and he was helped along his way by businessmen who made their fortunes by transmitting popular art.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/america-jews-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The Democratic Party is already a lost cause for you and the values you allegedly say you believe."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=_zdrgJEF2Wk -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There is only one solution for a mother who has lost a child, and that is to mother. And so it is, when Crittenden and Frum meet their first grandchild, a little girl named Abigail— Frum watches Crittenden nuzzle and coo her.
www.commentary.org/articles/nancy-rommelmann/motherhood-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
On a recent call with donors, El-Sayed salivated at the possibility that he could, once in office, put Democratic Sen. John Fetterman’s head “on a pike.” Fetterman was not a random choice. He is one of a dwindling number of Democrats who haven’t turned against Israel out of fear of the Gaza Left’s radical politics and violent organizing.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/el-sayeds-war-on-democrats/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Is this general assessment really the best way to understand our current state of global affairs as we enter a post–post–Cold War era? It understates two important aspects of the situation in which we find ourselves. The first is the extent to which U.S. power shaped events in the aftermath of the Cold War. The second is the role of values in shaping global politics now.
www.commentary.org/articles/tod-lindberg/great-powers-ret… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Among those “great men,” no one towered in international esteem above George Washington.
www.commentary.org/articles/allen-guelzo/american-revolut… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"They now have the luxury of imagining that the world of the Islamic radical is not anything that they need to worry about."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ef-xpF8PhuE -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Crabapple is clear-eyed about how horrible life was in Eastern Europe and how deep the prejudice against Jews. She writes powerfully about the monstrousness of the pogroms. On page 160, she writes, “It didn’t matter who one was, or what he believed. Everyone killed Jews. Everyone raped Jews, burned their houses, threw them out of trains. When Jews tried to form self-defense units, they were outnumbered, and the sight of Jews with weapons only provoked their attackers more.… Everyone agreed they had it coming.”
But with lunatic inconsistency on the very same page, she writes approvingly of a Bundist who “found Zionist ambitions ridiculous.” Because “for the Bund, the fight for Jewish life was in Poland.”
The degree of cognitive dissonance required to write both of these paragraphs is almost beyond belief. Between 1918 and 1921, Crabapple notes, more than 200,000 Jews were murdered. Everyone hated and killed us, but God forbid we should try to leave. And this, of course, is all before the Shoah, which clinched once and forever the urgency of a place of Jewish refuge.
www.commentary.org/articles/david-wolpe/jewish-bund-molly… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"It is a referendum about whether the American experiment is flawed, irredeemably so."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ef-xpF8PhuE -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Palestinian youth-radicalization camps in the UK highlight the West's role in growing extremism www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/palestinian-radicalization…
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Like the internet itself, socialism and anti-Semitism are primarily virtual... at their cores, they both suppose notional worlds that mirror only the surface appearance of the real one."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
August 7, @jpodhoretz recommends the film Tony
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The chapters on American businessmen, entrepreneurs, and innovators are excellent, showcasing how this founding impulse has been of immense benefit to all Americans through the inventions and companies that are omnipresent in our daily lives. The book treats these oft-maligned figures—men like John D. Rockefeller, Thomas Edison, Charles Schwab, Cornelius Vanderbilt, and James Hill—as the indispensable individuals they were. In an era where men who murder business leaders in cold blood are fêted for the act, Herman’s approach is itself almost radical, and much needed.
www.commentary.org/articles/mike-cote/founders-fire-1776-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Hackney had been governed by a Labour majority for two decades, but the Greens won local elections in May by a mile. They might expand their control of councils as they concentrate on winning locally. Or they might flame out when the public realizes that petty tantrums are all the party is interested in. It’s an interesting experiment in how far the worst people in politics can get on anti-Semitism alone.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/petty-for-palestine/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
From a very early age—12 or so—Stephan was a severe alcoholic. He would drink vodka when he could get ahold of it, but more often, he would drink homemade wine made by my mother from grapes Stephan and I had filched from a nearby vineyard. She stored the wine in a 10-liter pitcher on our makeshift kitchen table, and he would drink half of it; my mother didn’t notice and didn’t care. (Drinking five liters of wine at one sitting may seem like an exaggeration; unfortunately, it was not.)
www.commentary.org/articles/irina-velitskaya/hell-russia-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Truth is, advertising property for sale to foreign buyers is a normal thing to do. Less normal is to characterize only the Jewish purchases as an invasion and occupation.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/how-israelis-are-being-sca… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Unconscious plagiarism entails committing plagiarism without being aware one is doing so. Mark Twain, Helen Keller, and Vladimir Nabokov serve as notable examples of unconscious plagiarism. In the case of Nabokov, Kreuz adduces a story with the same subject as Lolita, an older man transfixed by a female child, that Nabokov read when a young man in Berlin. He discovers another story the Russian had to have read, this one with the actual title “Lolita,” and still other stories by Salvador Dalí that likely unconsciously influenced the writing of Lolita. Finally, at his death, Nabokov left behind an unfinished novel, translated, edited, and published by his son Dimitri, also about a middle-aged man and a nymphet, which shows among other things Vladimir Nabokov’s obsession with the subject.
www.commentary.org/articles/joseph-epstein/plagiarism-wri… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Contributing editor @elilake is back to discuss Chuck Schumer’s promotion of Abdul El-Sayed despite styling himself the Guardian of Jews, and the folly of attempting to appease those who hate you.
Plus, President Trump’s hard-to-believe declaration that the Strait of Hormuz is open and the prospect of a terrible Iran deal on the backdrop of negative economic numbers, and John recommends the Anthony Bourdain biopic Tony.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/frogs-electing-scorpions/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
David Axelrod tends to carry himself as a calm elder statesman, a sort of wise campaign guru. He is unusual in his seeming preference for civility in politics. And yet there he was on Tuesday night accusing American Jews of being agents for Israel and suggesting American Jewish campaign donations are tainted. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/why-david-axelrod-smeared-… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Revolutionary ideas, however ruinous, are always superficially compelling. Perhaps the best way to go after a radical opponent, then, is to get a jump on offering a compelling vision of your own that competes with the dark one he’s peddling."
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Jewish books are being rejected very explicitly by publishing houses on the grounds that Jewish content will create controversies."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=X8oKvFfnJCY -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Cutting NIH funding attacked the front end of the channel. At the same time, Washington was busy squeezing the back end as well.
Most biotech start-ups aren’t financed on the assumption that they’ll become the next Genentech. They’re funded on the belief that scientific success will lead to licensing deals, partnerships, or acquisitions by larger players. Destabilize this path and the logic of early-stage investment collapses.
www.commentary.org/articles/mworonof/american-biotech-ced… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Iran has no right to interfere in Hormuz traffic. It is holding the global economy hostage, and much of the “free” world seems to want Trump to just pay the ransom. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/legalized-piracy-in-the-st… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Hamas should disarm. That’s the deal. So if Hamas isn’t really going to disarm, how are the Qataris and Steve Witkoff’s team and the restrainers in the administration going to make it look like Hamas is willing to disarm?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-wile-e-coyote-plan-for… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"96% of the DSA are white college graduates."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=BsCTLgKdNl4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Levy was a trailblazer in sparking Jewish civic philanthropy, giving to the nation as much as if not more than far-better-known Jews later gave to the sciences, finance, and education. What Levy preserved for the United States was an indelible part of its birthright. He began with the statue.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-auslin/jews-declarati… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @NoahCRothman joins us today to share in our crushing morosity over recent election news, and whether the rise of terrorism-friendly politics and academia are the result of the decisive win in the War on Terror.
What strategies might work in countering candidates like Abdul El-Sayed and Francesca Hong and the intersection of Marxism and Islamism?
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/pyrrhic-victories/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
States that gave Ukraine enough aid to survive the early war years were wholly vindicated and now friendship with Ukraine was an investment with serious returns.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/you-are-going-to-want-ukra… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"In the year of America’s Semiquincentennial and the 25th anniversary of 9/11, we are being called upon to fight for our country once again. This strikes me as propitious. Patriotism is not supposed to be an exercise in nostalgia but a persistent expression of love for country and a commitment to its vigilant defense." From the newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This polling may have been a psyop to kill enthusiasm for Stevens, to get her voters to stay home."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=X8oKvFfnJCY -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The prayer asking for the removal of British wrath had not received the answer for which the worshippers had hoped—but the America for which they had prayed pro-vided a sign of the providence for which they had hoped. And the way in which they expressed their patriotism, in a Judaic fashion, portended the way in which they would be able to do so throughout American history.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/us-independe… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Abdul El-Sayed bet on spinelessness and partisanship, and he was right. Now they line up to bend the knee.
The Democrats lived down to his opinion of them. My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/democrats-lived-down-to-el… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It exacts a cost to exaggerating Israel’s crimes, even if that “cost” is minimal. Once “genocide” is seen even by Israel’s staunch critics as a way to derail the debate, a reality-based conversation might finally be possible.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/israel-take-heart-there-is… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"What is the deep state? [Trump] is the deep state."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=BsCTLgKdNl4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This would be a telling criticism, save for the fact that it also applies to AI industry insiders like Nixon—who also don’t understand what this thing is or what they are doing. They admit as much. And yet Nixon and his ilk remain confident of their secular and superior mission. Indeed, as the Times noted, “he and his peers saw AI as an alternative [to religion] that was more real and far more powerful.”
Nixon actually told the Times that “practically speaking, [AGI] will achieve the outcomes that many religions claim their deities would be able to achieve.” Another executive agreed: “People are matter-of-factly saying that they are looking to build a machine God. . . . They are not saying that ironically or in jest.”
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/ai-anthropic-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss Abdul El-Sayed’s tiny margin of victory in Michigan in contrast to polls that predicted a landslide, as well as the sorry state of the Democratic establishment and what these results tell us about the November election.
Plus, the remarkable story out of the UK regarding fabulist Cambridge Professor Jason Arday, which grew out of a report on supposed plagiarism in his work, and Simon & Schuster’s shame in publishing antisemitic author Susan Abulhawa.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/abduly-noted/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The unpredictability has become utterly predictable at this point. And Iran is not stupid. They know this game."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast, joined by @JoshKraushaar: www.youtube.com/watch?v=4vCST72kN9E -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Money is fungible, and whether the Open Society Foundations were funding protesters vilifying two Jewish business executives (Zuckerberg and Sandberg) with a hoary anti-Semitic trope directly or via cut-outs is immaterial. Gaspard’s deflection of factual information concerning his boss as the product of “tactics out of Putin’s playbook” and his imputation of bigotry to Facebook and Definers were emblematic of left-wing defenses of Soros—conservative criticism of whom, no matter how legitimate, they have long mechanically labeled as anti-Semitic. (Indeed, conservative criticism of Soros is one of the few things liberals can unanimously agree is anti-Semitic.)
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/partisanship-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"[DeSantis] just didn't show he has the skills to be a party unifier."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bp6_JLV8avA -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The only people at risk of plummeting to their doom are the prime minister and everyone who works for him or travels with him. And Micheal Martin is reportedly willing to take that chance.
That’s what it means to be truly committed to hating the one and only Jewish state. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-smug-of-war/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Man cannot live by genocide potato chips alone. Yet that is all much of the media and most of academia are feeding their audiences.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-israel-side-has-a… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This new understanding of politics remained only a thought experiment in European capitals. Even in Locke’s England, where the powers of the king had been slowly but markedly circumscribed by Parliament throughout the 17th century, Parliament itself was still top-heavy with nobility, the landed gentry, and the senior clergy of the Church of England. In Britain’s North American colonies, by contrast, Locke and the other great political questioners of what later became known as the Enlightenment—Montesquieu, Beccaria, Adam Smith—were read with very different eyes, not as the providers of thought experiments but as men who were describing the colonies’ own creation.
www.commentary.org/articles/allen-guelzo/american-revolut… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss Trump’s ire with Jeanine Pirro for dismissing charges of vandalism of the reflecting pool after the prosecution fell apart, which dovetails with the almost comic nature of his ongoing flip-flop on Iran strikes.
Plus, Abdul El-Sayed’s probable win in the Michigan primary vote and the increased marginalization of Jews in the democratic party, the antisemitic hate crime spike in New York, and how this year’s MET Gala reflects these trends.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/pirro-pressure/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Anybody watching progressive activism over the past couple of years knew exactly what the goal of this display was: to bully Jewish Democratic politicians out of the party’s public gatherings. And now it seems to have worked. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-semitic-hounding-… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Thick walls of rank idiocy are growing ever higher in all directions. But if you look closely, the comparison with Idiocracy breaks down in an important way. That movie takes place in a world where average human intelligence has plunged dramatically. That’s not this world. We haven’t devolved at the genetic level. So if we can’t even blame our biology, what’s our excuse?"--From the newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"It starts at the very far-left district, but because there hasn't been a sustained push back from party leaders, it just grows."
Watch the full episode with @JoshKraushaar: www.youtube.com/watch?v=4vCST72kN9E -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
They had literally incepted a nation. And there is only one other incepted nation that we know of, the nation of Israel, or the Israelites, or the Hebrew people, incepted into being with the very first covenant with Abraham.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/history-americ… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Is it really a good idea, some wondered, to fully resurrect the Galliano Phoenix right at this moment? @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-galliano-question/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"How likely is it that Trump will declare an emergency of some kind as an excuse to alter or cancel the 2028 election?"
Watch our responses to reader comments: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bp6_JLV8avA -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Indeed, they loved her so much that their odes to her helped solidify America’s image of itself.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/america-jews-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Jewish Insider’s @JoshKraushaar joins us on this busy news Monday to discuss Trump’s latest walkback of an attack on Iranian infrastructure, the collapse of the Reflecting Pool vandalism prosecution, the worrisome midterm poll numbers and the rise of increasingly radical left wing candidates, and another global wave of antisemitic incidents.
Plus, John recommends City of Angels at the Ogunquit Playhouse in Ogunquit, Maine.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/tehran-taco/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In taking this step, the UN made the destruction of historic sites (one in Lebanon and one in Judea and Samaria) far more likely. It’s clear now that, somehow, the world is going to need to protect historic sites from the United Nations.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-un-would-rather-histor… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are joined by our producer @neontaster to answer some of your questions: From our favorite essayists to 2028 predictions and much more.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/mailbag-friday/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There was an organized effort to deflect attention from the long history of American researchers and American funding going to the lab."
Watch the full episode featuring @jamesbmeigs: www.youtube.com/watch?v=HCd01WY9vdk -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
True to form, President Biden failed to see the unintended consequences of his policies.
www.commentary.org/articles/mworonof/american-biotech-ced… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“If Mamdani cannot acknowledge this painful history, he cannot adequately defend the Jewish community of New York — and therefore, his vows to do so lack any true meaning.”
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/are-new-yorkers-tiring-of-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“This is how we often talked: two women applying their makeup, sharing the small conspiracies of our days . . .”
www.commentary.org/articles/nancy-rommelmann/motherhood-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We got completely blindsided in that they did it through politics. They came through leftist American politics."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pn60DIVlBoM -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Simms declines to propound a definition of a great power. Rather, he offers a set of “characteristics with which they are associated, historically and today.”
www.commentary.org/articles/tod-lindberg/great-powers-ret… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
I was, of course, aware of plagiarism but failed to comprehend the extent of the phenomenon. Roger Kreuz, author of Strikingly Similar: Plagiarism and Appropriation from Chaucer to Chatbots, a recent book on the subject, claims to have found so much of it in researching his book that, as he writes, “I must confess that this odyssey has dented my faith in human nature.”
www.commentary.org/articles/joseph-epstein/plagiarism-wri… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Such joint-defense programs are normal, but Israel’s critics are incapable of matching that normalcy. Instead, they have created a very strange talking point that the bill would “merge” the two countries’ militaries.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/aocs-latest-dual-loyalty-h… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The officials didn't want to talk about it. They pretended it like wasn't happening for a long time."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast, joined by @jamesbmeigs: www.youtube.com/watch?v=HCd01WY9vdk -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Opinions about the founders of the modern era, whether corporate or political, are extraordinarily contentious. Herman’s choice to label Donald Trump as a present-day founder will certainly be deemed as partisan, but he makes a case.
www.commentary.org/articles/mike-cote/founders-fire-1776-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The tell is that in 2020 Rubin could claim to be working from the inside of the progressive movement to influence it in a better direction; in 2026 he has to go public with his concerns because there is no place for him on the inside.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/an-action-plan-for-democra… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
A decade after Levy’s death, another American Jew took center stage in efforts to preserve the Declaration’s past and bring it closer to the people. Born in 1833, Colonel Frank Marx Etting was a Philadelphian, a Civil War officer whose ancestors had fought in the Revolutionary War, and a relative of the first Jewish U.S. official, the aforementioned Reuben Etting.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-auslin/jews-declarati… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This is an indictment of President Trump. This is an indictment of Trump under COVID . . . his effectively abdication allowed Fauci to become powerful."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pn60DIVlBoM -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Experiencing the many thousands who had come to pray—and who immediately cheered a condemnation of Jew-hate—was, for me, a moment that I will remember on this Fourth of July as I stand in synagogue on the Sabbath and pray once more that this country experiences a defeat of anti-Semitism in this land—and that God continues to bless America.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/us-independe… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
That’s because there are two kinds of lies Mamdani leveled in his Two Minutes Hate. One includes the provably false accusations of specific behavior—for example, the long-debunked calumny that Israel engaged in the “targeting of neonatal hospitals and maternity care centers” and deliberately starved Palestinians.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/why-mamdani-tries-to-erase… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"A strong Ukraine helps Trump reduce America's involvement in the NATO alliance."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=5jptJmbeomc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Hackney had been governed by a Labour majority for two decades, but the Greens won local elections in May by a mile. They might expand their control of councils as they concentrate on winning locally. Or they might flame out when the public realizes that petty tantrums are all the party is interested in. It’s an interesting experiment in how far the worst people in politics can get on anti-Semitism alone.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/petty-for-palestine/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Instead of providing a serious history of this fascinating if minor blip in Jewish history, the author follows the Bundists off their suicidal cliff in 2026, more than a hundred years after the party was dissolved.
www.commentary.org/articles/david-wolpe/jewish-bund-molly… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This cover up of Biden's incapacity will be among the most irresponsible uses of power."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=5jptJmbeomc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
States that gave Ukraine enough aid to survive the early war years were wholly vindicated and now friendship with Ukraine was an investment with serious returns.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/you-are-going-to-want-ukra… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There are distinct layers of Hell, and there is a deeper layer even than the one on the battlefields of Ukraine and in the prisons and mental institutions of Russia.
That deeper layer of Hell exists today in Iran, Southern Lebanon, and Gaza.
www.commentary.org/articles/irina-velitskaya/hell-russia-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Man cannot live by genocide potato chips alone. Yet that is all much of the media and most of academia are feeding their audiences.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-israel-side-has-a… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What a difference seven years makes. Today, Miller and many others in the conservative “Never Trump” space are no longer homeless. Like many one-time political operatives, Miller now fashions himself a political analyst, and he has made himself a home at the Bulwark, a news and opinion website, alongside several other ex-Republican strategists. While it occasionally offers criticism of left-wing excesses, the Bulwark is a highly partisan outlet whose overriding purpose is to generate enthusiasm for Democrats and loathing of Republicans.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/partisanship-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The bedrock of the United States is the political participation of the citizenry in the process of self-governance."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=LT2ONTW6uhg -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Nixon actually told the Times that “practically speaking, [AGI] will achieve the outcomes that many religions claim their deities would be able to achieve.” Another executive agreed: “People are matter-of-factly saying that they are looking to build a machine God. . . . They are not saying that ironically or in jest.”
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/ai-anthropic-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It’s easy to pass around a list of Israel’s “victims.” It’s much harder to fact-check that list and reveal the truth about whether Israel actually is putting so many journalists in danger. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-israel-side-has-a… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
For the sake of the U.S. and Lebanon both, the president still needs to find a path to victory over Iran.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/trump-welcomes-lebanon-to-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Organizations are now preaching to ordinary citizens that it is their moral obligation to harass Israelis."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=g-wE9jan0Ps -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @continetti is back to discuss today’s oval office meetings with president Zelensky and Prime Minister Netanyahu and the increased focus on the Iranian facility in Pickaxe Mountain, as well as how technology has shifted the modern battlefield.
Plus, the Haley Stevens-Abdul El-Sayed debate pits the establishment against populist enthusiasm, the release of Anthony Fauci’s diaries and Biden’s interview with Robert Hurr, and Matt recommends The Oxford History of the French Revolution.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/cherry-pickaxe/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
But by the time we get to the years immediately before the Founding, Jews are fully members of their societies, which can be found first and foremost in the fact that a huge majority of the Jews in America, though a small group to be sure, were patriots and felt as invested in that cause as their fellow colonists at that.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/history-americ… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
My latest on some evidence that, whatever their opinions on the Middle East, New Yorkers would appreciate it if their mayor would grow up www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/are-new-yorkers-tiring-of-…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Mamdani can either be mayor of all New Yorkers or he can rant and rave about the supposed evils of the world’s one Jewish state and its supporters. The two are mutually exclusive. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/are-new-yorkers-tiring-of-… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The plan is to make people so miserable that they’ll accede to the DSA’s agenda against their will. In other words, compulsion."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"What we have now is an all-out effort by the media to sell us, as they did with Kamala, the hope and joy of Troy Jackson."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=LT2ONTW6uhg -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The decision to raze the Temple to the ground has been understood by some historians as a strategic move as much as it was an expression of barbarism. Rome’s battlefield successes against Jewish rebels couldn’t demoralize the Jews or weaken their dedication. But the religious aspect of the Jewish civilization was deeply connected to the Temple. Perhaps total physical destruction would finally cause this spiritual people to disintegrate, as it would have for so many other ancient tribes and peoples?
We know that didn’t work either, of course. The miracle of Jewish continuity has no equal. Historically, it doesn’t really make sense. Even a day as bleak as the ninth of Av can remind us of that if we keep digging.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/a-new-discovery-and-an-old… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“The memory of Washington,” added the British political commentator Leslie Grove Jones in 1827, “will outlive the history of all the other great captains, whether of antient or of modern times, in the proportion that his virtues exceeded their military deeds.” And why? Because “every act of his was for the benefit of his fellow-citizens; he lived but for his country and the advantage of mankind.”
www.commentary.org/articles/allen-guelzo/american-revolut… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
The UN would rather Hezbollah dig tunnels and shoot rockets at Beaufort than it be in Israeli hands. It also moved to enable the further looting and destruction at an ancient Jewish historical site: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-un-would-rather-histor…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The UN has turned UNESCO into an agency of destruction. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-un-would-rather-histor… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Monday, and we are back to discuss the pivot to Troy Jackson after Graham Platner’s implosion in Maine and the familiar pattern of adoring media coverage for a struggling democrat, as well as Governor Gretchen Whitmer throwing her lot in with Haley Stevens in Michigan.
Plus, a full resumption of hostilities in Iran once again does not materialize and the issue of stockpile shortages is brought into the spotlight, and 9/11 victim families want Mamdani out of the memorial ceremony.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/sellin-of-troy/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The person who is stimulating the feeling of being terrorized in New York among Jews is the city's mayor. We are in uncharted territory."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=g-wE9jan0Ps -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The worldview is love of country, which leads to a set of ideas about how to protect it, nurture it. Where American patriotism differs from love of country everywhere else—and it seems clear most people have the initial inclination to love the place in which they were born—is precisely that it does not require having been born here, or having deep roots here. The overwhelming majority of Jews in the United States descend from ancestors who came to these shores only five generations ago. And yet, Jews with no roots whatever came here and came to love America with a passion almost as great as Donne’s for his lady fair.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/america-jews-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This is the proper response to anti-Zionist lawfare. It is worthy of contempt, of a public dressing-down. That is no less true when the person trying to abuse the legal system is the mayor of a major city. In fact, the opposite is true. The public ought to be aghast.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Experiencing the many thousands who had come to pray—and who immediately cheered a condemnation of Jew-hate—was, for me, a moment that I will remember on this Fourth of July as I stand in synagogue on the Sabbath and pray once more that this country experiences a defeat of anti-Semitism in this land—and that God continues to bless America.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/us-independe… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The Democratic Party is becoming openly hostile to Israel and therefore fostering an undercurrent of anti-Semitism."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=4nUtP4EplFE -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The “end of history” afficionados, meanwhile, may have believed convergence around democratic capitalism to be inevitable. But it was the power of the United States that protected democratic capitalism and gave others something to converge on—or not, were they determined not to, as was the case with China and Russia. Perhaps one could say that some states want to be market-based, rights-regarding democracies, and others don’t. During the Cold War, the United States was the power that upheld the security of these states—that is, the West—against the Communist challenge. The power of the United States continued uninterrupted through the post–Cold War era as the self-conscious supervisor of global order. Without it, the “end of history” would never have had a chance.
www.commentary.org/articles/tod-lindberg/great-powers-ret… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In other words, if the U.S. was going to tie Israel’s hands on the global market, it was at least going to ensure some kind of durable aid system that wouldn’t leave Israel weaker for its alliance with the U.S.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-blank-check-myth/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The patriotic Levy considered Thomas Jefferson “one of the greatest men in history,” as he wrote in an 1832 letter (quoted in Marc Leepson’s excellent book, Saving Monticello). It was Jefferson’s fight for religious freedom that particularly inspired him.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-auslin/jews-declarati… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If we make the choice to maintain that Promethean fire and continue to create and empower the risk-seeking visionaries who have made America into the exceptional nation it is, that ongoing triumph for liberty will continue. And that is well worth remembering as we celebrate the 250th anniversary of our founding.
www.commentary.org/articles/mike-cote/founders-fire-1776-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If we just continue on this pace, the regime's wheels are gonna start to fall off the bus."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=4nUtP4EplFE -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The Democratic base, while hating the Democratic Party, hates Donald Trump and Republicans more."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=sHTMNIDE5YoThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
I think Jeffries clearly means well here. But let’s remember that the reason this discussion is back in the news today is because yesterday half his party voted against treating Israel as an ally.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/has-hakeem-jeffries-met-de… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Stephan’s parting words to me were, “Russia is a s—t nation, a nation of physical and moral invalids. They will always betray you. I wish I could move to America. It’s a great nation—I love America! Please promise me you will never come back here.”
www.commentary.org/articles/irina-velitskaya/hell-russia-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This is why some Catholic observers found the encyclical too accommodationist in its approach, particularly in its understanding of AI as merely another technological enhancement. Matthew Walther, editor of the Lamp, noted in the New York Times, “Despite voicing concerns about the dangers that AI poses to humanity, the encyclical nonetheless seems to envision a world in which it is simply a tool, rather than an evil that all people should reject.”
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/ai-anthropic-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
No aid, no joint projects—they just want the alliance of democracies to fail. Russian and Qatari propaganda outlets have echoed their claims because they, too, want the alliance of democracies to fail. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/aocs-latest-dual-loyalty-h… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss the creeping danger to Jews and Israelis everywhere after yesterday’s stabbing in New York City and reports that the stabber shouted “Allah Akbar,” as well as how Zohran Mamdani’s minimal response contrasts with sterner comments from other officials.
Plus, the Jews who lend legitimacy to those who hate them.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/a-stabbing-in-new-york/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
July 23, @continetti recommends The Boroughs
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The more the U.S. chastised Israel, the more brazenly the regime escalated. By the time Vance got around to airing his conspiracy theories, Iran was back to menacing the Strait of Hormuz at will. The two developments were hardly unrelated."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This is an actual blood libel."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=nE8YFfLdoucThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Nakba, of course, is the foundational myth of Palestinism, the idea that the modern miracle of Jewish history was in truth a catastrophic crime against the Arabs. “Born of another people’s violent dispossession, Israel had yoked itself into an ever worsening cycle of repression and resistance,” she tells us were the thoughts of the surviving Bundists. They knew that the new nation’s “own violence would poison it, and the cancer would metastasize, until there was nothing else left.”
www.commentary.org/articles/david-wolpe/jewish-bund-molly… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Democratic Party itself, Vindman said, has bred “impunity” for anti-Semites and thereby only encouraged more of it to come. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/an-action-plan-for-democra… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The DSA relies on the politics of fear, and a few Democrats aren’t cowing to it.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/fear-itself/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In politics, when there is a mass coordinated campaign to sell a lie, that lie has a specific purpose. We would do well to get used to asking ourselves what might be the purpose of the lies we come across. The purpose of the “genocide” lie is clear if you just listen long enough to the people spreading it. The reason they falsely accuse Israel of genocide is that they want to justify violence against Israelis.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/lies-and-the-language-of-v… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This is the problem when one’s priority is maintaining the approval of a political faction; so important is it to prove one’s partisan bona fides that you enter an escalatory spiral. One day you’re excommunicating someone as an anti-Semite for criticizing the activities of a politically active Jewish billionaire, the next you’re defending a guy with an SS tattoo. the Bulwark and Crooked are what I call “operative media,” in that they are media institutions populated not by journalists but political operatives posing as them.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/partisanship-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we are joined by @WSJ's @continetti and @FDD’s @JSchanzer to speculate on Trump’s new strategy in Iran after the resumption of strikes last week and Iran and the Houthis teaming up to choke the straits of Hormuz and Bab Al-Mandab, as well as the emerging Saudi nuclear deal.
Plus, Vance support slips in favor of Marco Rubio, a check in on the polls in the leadup to the midterm, and Matt recommends The Burroughs.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/dire-straits/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Of course, there is the strong possibility that Trump doesn’t mind—just as he doesn’t mind scratching Qatar’s back when he should be sending them stern warnings. In February, Trump announced that countries that trade with Iran would be subject to a tariff. “So far, however, the US has not applied such tariffs to Pakistan — a decision one Pakistani source speculated could be thanks to President Donald Trump’s fondness for Pakistan’s leaders.”
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/pakistans-double-dealing/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In 1776, the Western world still understood human societies as hierarchies, enforced by authority. From classical times, both the physical and political universe had been understood as an orderly and logical stacking of things and people, arranged according to a kind of moral pedigree.
www.commentary.org/articles/allen-guelzo/american-revolut… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It has been a 24-hour period of unprecedented and slickly produced taxpayer-funded Hamas propaganda and anti-Jewish incitement from the elected leader of the most Jewish American city. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/why-mamdani-tries-to-erase… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Give a listen.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/book-em-mamdanno/
John Podhoretz
@jpodhoretz
Today's @Commentary podcast descends to levels of crushing morosity seldom heard or seen in the annals of morosity. It'll be out soon. Get your Klonopin ready.
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
John Podhoretz
@jpodhoretz
Today's @Commentary podcast descends to levels of crushing morosity seldom heard or seen in the annals of morosity. It'll be out soon. Get your Klonopin ready.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If we can't fight a 3-month war without draining our material, then we shouldn't have fought it, then we shouldn't have gone to war."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=QzJYDwCErgIThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Does the influence of other writers, writers better than oneself, constitute yet another form of plagiarism? If so, then perhaps almost all writing is essentially plagiarism. In which case, I say, don’t evade your eyes, just plagiarize. As Tom Lehrer put it.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There is a tenacity to the Jews’ connection to their homeland. The extent of the destruction on the ninth of Av six centuries later, when the Second Temple was razed and the Jews sent into exile, was more evidence of this tenacity. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/a-new-discovery-and-an-old… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"What most Americans under 50 “know” about socialism is that it’s a well-meaning system of governance that may or may not work, in part or in whole, in the United States. They also know that the prominent socialists they see on their screens can be entertaining like Bernie Sanders, attractive like AOC, or superficially charming like Mamdani. But evil? Come on."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Trump, the master of branding, is going to brand Lebanon as part of the Western alliance through sheer force of will, if necessary. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/trump-welcomes-lebanon-to-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @ChrisStirewalt joins us to discuss the evidence that a democratic wave in November is not a done deal, the ever-increasing uncertainty surrounding Iran amid reports that centrifuges were moved into the fortified Pickaxe Mountain facility, and the scapegoating of Israel in an attempt to take heat off of Trump.
Plus, new revelations about Abdul El-Sayed’s half sister in the Free Beacon, and the creeping danger of left wing violence.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/breaking-the-wave/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Do foreign officials need police protection from the mayor of New York City? Does Mamdani have a list of global politicians he openly fantasizes about assaulting? Or is it just the guy governing the world’s only Jewish state? @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-normalizing-of-mamdani… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The more radical the Democratic candidate or elected official, the more slick, measured, or downright elusive he tries to sound in selling his ideas."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Patriotism is not an idea. It is an emotion that alchemizes into a worldview.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/america-jews-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Wokism is, at its root, an effort to reverse the status of success and failure. America has been overwhelmingly successful. In 1976, that was seen as a virtue; in the woke America of 2026, it has become a crime."
www.commentary.org/articles/reader-letters/reader-comment… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Normalization is humanization. Many people are upset by the humanization of Jews, especially those from the Jewish state. But this dehumanization has a strategic purpose: It is very easy to find out what Israelis really think, and so if you want to dehumanize them you must ban contact with them outside of those whom you know will express a pre-approved line of thought.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/have-you-considered-talkin… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The “blank check” talking point is meant to deceive the public and keep voters ignorant of a wealth of details about the U.S.-Israel relationship. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-blank-check-myth/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Monday, and we’re back to discuss Iran striking US positions in Jordan and Iraq, the downplaying of American casualties and stockpile depletion, and the realization that intimidation tactics are not bearing fruit.
Plus, Abdul El-Sayed’s interview with Jake Tapper, Zohran Mamdani flirting with attempting to arrest Netanyahu, and John strongly recommends The Odyssey.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/the-liminal-war/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There are vulnerabilities in the system that China has been actively working to gather information."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=YX2UzVZ5B54This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The United States of America doesn’t accept fatwas or the threats of them from authoritarian regimes. But if some member states are threatening to “arrest”—the correct word would be “kidnap”—U.S. officials because of their fealty to the ICC, then one of those two entities would need to be dismantled. And it is easier to dismantle a fake court than a real nation-state.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/rubios-reclamation-of-amer… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This stuff of life is what—slowly, slowly—has Crittenden turning her face to those who are still here, to her two other children, to Miranda’s friends. She arranges a party at Miranda’s finally opened apartment, a last time to gather there, to talk, to cry, to drink all the wine and, for Crittenden, alone at the end of the night, never to abandon her child.
www.commentary.org/articles/nancy-rommelmann/motherhood-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Gaspard’s deflection of factual information concerning his boss as the product of “tactics out of Putin’s playbook” and his imputation of bigotry to Facebook and Definers were emblematic of left-wing defenses of Soros—conservative criticism of whom, no matter how legitimate, they have long mechanically labeled as anti-Semitic.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/partisanship-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
How quickly the Democratic Party has changed. In 2020, Joe Biden claimed his decision to run for president was influenced by the horrible scene of white nationalists marching in Charlottesville, one of whom killed a woman. Six years later, Khanna made himself a national figure by defending a Nazi-inked mercenary accused of repeated violence against women.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/how-israel-should-handle-p… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There are distinct layers of Hell, and there is a deeper layer even than the one on the battlefields of Ukraine and in the prisons and mental institutions of Russia.
That deeper layer of Hell exists today in Iran, Southern Lebanon, and Gaza.
www.commentary.org/articles/irina-velitskaya/hell-russia-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
When people ask me about my most favorite moments in show business, I always mention that delicious and richly satisfying phone call.
We recast the role with an excellent though non-get actor and the show was ordered and it ran for a few weeks in a terrible time slot and we were quickly cancelled, and yes had we somehow made it work with the original actor, we probably would have had a better time slot and a better chance of staying on the air, but sometimes you just have to pick up the phone and fire the bastard. Heads-on-sticks, in other words. It’s not a terrible HR move, to be honest.
And no, I won’t tell you who it was. Who knows? I may need a get at some point, and maybe he’s mellowed.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/scott-pelley-cbs-fir… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Faced with this reality, a prudent government would take care not to damage the engine of progress. Instead, Washington spent the past several years distorting prices, limiting the upside of success, and obstructing innovation.
www.commentary.org/articles/mworonof/american-biotech-ced… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To progressives, the logical endpoint of their rhetoric about the evils of the Jewish state is violence against the Jewish state, and Ro Khanna can’t pretend otherwise without getting himself called out for the contradiction. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/lies-and-the-language-of-v… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Crabapple’s book is sprinkled with solecisms. Anyone with an elementary knowledge of Jewish history, or history of the 19th and 20th century, will be astonished to read the following: “The Great War began with the inevitability of a Grecian play.”
www.commentary.org/articles/david-wolpe/jewish-bund-molly… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @NoahCRothman is back to discuss President Trump’s Thursday night speech about Chinese efforts to interfere with American elections and the notable absence of Iran and the resumption of the war from the remarks.
Plus, Washington democrat Adam Smith admits that he flipped his vote on aid to Israel due to threats and intimidation from the left, Marco Rubio’s speech on left-wing violence, and John recommends Dangerous, Dirty, Violent and Young.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/speech-pathology/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Hakeem Jeffries said something very good and very decent and very wise—which is why it’ll be the first thing rejected by his party’s base. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/has-hakeem-jeffries-met-de… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
July 16, @jpodhoretz pre-recommends Promise Me America by Joe Biden
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"If we’re now weighing Vance’s anti-Israel conspiracism against the Hamas fandom of the left, we’ve already taken a dark turn that threatens the whole national project."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This is, in part, why the “decolonization” discourse is not abstract. Jewish indigeneity in the Holy Land is not in dispute. So why do progressives and academics cling to an obvious lie?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-increasingly-strident-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Just now, the great subject for commencement speeches is artificial intelligence, but it, too, will doubtless soon be worn out and devolve into elevated platitudes.
www.commentary.org/articles/joseph-epstein/plagiarism-wri… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Etting installed a “first class fire-proof safe” in Independence Hall to protect the document and then enlisted George W. Childs, publisher of the Philadelphia Public Ledger and a close friend of Ulysses S. Grant, to sway the president. His plan worked.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-auslin/jews-declarati… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Hamasnik intimidation campaigns have already done a number on lawmakers in the UK, who have changed rules and votes to avoid threats on them and their family. That the same subversion of democracy is happening in the U.S. is not shocking. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/fear-itself/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Contributing editor @EliLake is back to discuss the newest round of bad news – JD Vance joining Joe Rogan for a conspiracy fueled podcast, 103 democrats joining Thomas Massie to vote to cut off aid to Israel, and Ro Khanna’s DropSite interview trying to capitalize on his West Bank stunt.
Plus, John ironically recommends Joe Biden’s upcoming memoir Promise Me, America.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/israel-on-the-brain/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If half the Muslim American population of the United States actively supports a movement to kill my people, they are my enemy."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tag2ELTClzU -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Here’s the thing: If you genuinely believe the terrorists’ narrative about apartheid, genocidal Zionists, and the righteous Palestinian resistance, then Scahill has the more “logical” argument. If you buy into an insane premise, you will necessarily arrive at an equally insane conclusion."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
They were Christians who had come to pray at the Capitol, and they went out of their way to thank the rabbi for his message, to embrace him as a Jew—and as a fellow American.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/us-independe… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Walther is correct that AI is not merely a tool. It is something else we can’t quite describe. A hammer cannot build a house for you, but an AI can draft a plausible version of a story or “compose” something that sounds like music.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/ai-anthropic-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What are Iranian oil carriers doing in Pakistan?
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/pakistans-double-dealing/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: The president is due to give a primetime address to the nation on Thursday the 16th. We give him advice on what he should talk about.
We also talk about the mysterious affluence of Michigan senatorial candidate Abdul El-Sayed and his fondness for expensive watches.
And we wonder at New York State going Luddite when it comes to AI and data centers.
www.commentary.org/john-podhoretz/what-trump-should-say-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There is no ceasefire. We are back in a shooting war with Iran. It’s a war."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=W60hVHM7WpYThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Food that made it into the strip under Israel’s supervision is rotting. Hamas should disarm, abide by the agreement, and allow the process to work as designed.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/gaza-apparently-has-more-f… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"It felt virtuous to point out that the vast majority of Muslims in America were not extremists or even remotely sympathetic to jihadist terrorism. Repeating this mantra made us feel like open-minded citizens in a wonderfully welcoming nation. And it had the additional benefit of being true."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Overall, Egypt’s management of the border crossing suggests a desire on Cairo’s part to maximize death and suffering on the Gaza side of the border.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/political-football/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Uneasy observers like Spain’s ambassador to France in 1783, Pedro Pablo Abarca de Bolea, the count of Aranda, were also convinced that the American Revolution signaled the fall of aristocratic dominoes around the Atlantic world, although that was not a result they welcomed. “The independence of the English colonies…is for me a source of pain and fear,” Aranda reported to Spain’s King Carlos III.
www.commentary.org/articles/allen-guelzo/american-revolut… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Normalization is humanization. Many people are upset by the humanization of Jews, especially those from the Jewish state. But this dehumanization has a strategic purpose. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/have-you-considered-talkin… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
July 14, @jpodhoretz recommends The Extinction of Experience by Christine Rose
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Inouye felt a strong affinity for the Jewish community—even once reportedly considering converting—in part because, serving after Pearl Harbor, he understood what it was like to be mistrusted by his fellow Americans just because of who he was.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/when-did-liberals-forget-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss the United States officially being back at war with Iran and the resumption of the American blockade in order to open the Strait of Hormuz, the new revelations surrounding Michigan senatorial candidate Abdul El-Sayed, and John recommends Christine Rosen’s The Extinction of Experience.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/war-of-fog/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"America and Israel just demonstrated the ability to take out your leadership without invading your country."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=MRptyvt4ghwThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
On dismantling the ICC, which absolutely brought this on itself www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/rubios-reclamation-of-amer…
Incidentally, a bonus would be to open space for the type of impermanent tribunals that once existed with some success. ICC not only option, not by a mile. -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The U.S. has fought itself into a perverse Goldilocks zone where we won just enough and lost just enough to prevent our leaving."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Indeed, they loved her so much that their odes to her helped solidify America’s image of itself. Irving Berlin, born Izzy Baline in Ukraine, wrote “God Bless America.”
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/america-jews-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
That’s not some angry voter shouting at candidates on the campaign trail. That’s a member of Congress.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-democrats-trickle-down… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Ro Khanna won't be the last progressive to make a bad-faith pilgrimage to Judea & Samaria to try to provoke a confrontation. But he will almost certainly be the least knowledgeable and clumsiest. His faceplant shouldn't make Israel complacent. My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/how-israel-should-handle-p…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To my knowledge, even in the colonies before the rise of the nascent United States, Jews were remarkably welcomed.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/history-americ… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israel should not assume Khanna will be the last Democrat to launch a political campaign in Judea and Samaria, nor will Khanna be the last to make his campaign explicitly about punishing the Jewish state. But the next one to do so might be less blockheaded, less ignorant of the environment and its history. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/how-israel-should-handle-p… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Monday, and we are back to discuss the waves of airstrikes against Iran over the weekend and what the US might do next, the legacy of Senator Lindsey Graham, who passed suddenly over the weekend, and Abdul El-Sayed’s race in Michigan.
Plus, Seth recommends Maggie Stiefvater’s The Listeners, and John recommends What Happens at Night by Peter Cameron.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/iran-heats-up/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The common theme is the fantasy that you can squeeze the supply side without changing behavior. You can’t. Drug development is not exempt from the laws of economics.
www.commentary.org/articles/mworonof/american-biotech-ced… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Experiencing the many thousands who had come to pray—and who immediately cheered a condemnation of Jew-hate—was, for me, a moment that I will remember on this Fourth of July as I stand in synagogue on the Sabbath and pray once more that this country experiences a defeat of anti-Semitism in this land—and that God continues to bless America.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/us-independe… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Jewish indigeneity in the Holy Land is not in dispute. So why do progressives and academics cling to an obvious lie? Why spend so much time and energy and resources pushing the idea that Jews are colonizers in their own land, when it is the equivalent of evangelizing the idea that the earth is flat? @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-increasingly-strident-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Friday, and contributing editor @EliLake joins us to discuss whether we are at war with Iran again, and how can Trump reconcile his desire for a deal with Iranian intransigence?
Plus, the evil conspiracy theories surrounding Charlie Kirk reach a fever pitch during his trial, and John recommends the new film Gale Daughtry and the Celebrity Sex Pass.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/memorandum-mori/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Today I explored how it is that American liberals and American Jews became so alienated from each other, not just ideologically but on a level that feels weirdly personal.
When Did Liberals Forget that Jews Are Patriots? www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/when-did-liberals-forget-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"It makes perfect sense why the Democrats are better organized than the Republicans - because they actually have institutional cores that control money, power, and organizational strength."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=D57mt3bQlqwThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
July 9, @continetti recommends The Hero Returns by Richard Brookhiser 🧵 1/2
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The problem is that “anti-Semite” and “Jew-hater” don’t begin to cover the complicated array of adversaries, enemies, and troublemakers we face. It’s almost certainly true, in fact, that most Americans who’ve turned against Israel to one degree or another in the past three years do not hate Jews."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Qatar gets something else out of this, too. It appears that, absent a sudden showing of spine from the Trump administration, the near-term future of the Strait of Hormuz will include either partial blockades or an Iranian toll-collection system.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/did-qatar-win-the-u-s-iran… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Gaza has a government, and that government has failed spectacularly to fulfill its obligations. So here we are, with Israel and NGOs filling the roles for which Hamas should be responsible. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/gaza-apparently-has-more-f… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
That world of hierarchy and authority began to crack in the 1600s, as the scientific discoveries of Galileo and Isaac Newton overthrew the old notion of a physical universe governed by moral qualities of superiority and inferiority.
www.commentary.org/articles/allen-guelzo/american-revolut… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Inouye felt a strong affinity for the Jewish community—even once reportedly considering converting—in part because, serving after Pearl Harbor, he understood what it was like to be mistrusted by his fellow Americans just because of who he was. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/when-did-liberals-forget-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Instead of providing a serious history of this fascinating if minor blip in Jewish history, the author follows the Bundists off their suicidal cliff in 2026, more than a hundred years after the party was dissolved.
www.commentary.org/articles/david-wolpe/jewish-bund-molly… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Hugh Hewitt
@hughhewitt
Headline of the day from @Commentary podcast:
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-commentary-magazine-pod… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @continetti is back to discuss Graham Platner suspending his campaign with an angry 11-minute video diatribe, and whether his cratering poll numbers played a part in democrats’ willingness to cut him loose.
Plus, Iran’s overreach leads to a resumption of hostilities in the region, Rahm Emmanuel’s hallucinatory speech in Israel and the upcoming Israeli elections, and Matt recommends Richard Brookhiser’s The Hero Returns: Lafayette and the Legacy of Revolution.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/platline/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"It is the explicit effort to turn vices into virtues and to say no - we like him because he's flawed and imperfect."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=SFSMrm6jzzcThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Allowing anti-Zionist radicals to hijack human-rights groups has left genuine humanitarianism and genuine justice hobbled. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/karim-khan-and-the-perils-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This is the problem when one’s priority is maintaining the approval of a political faction; so important is it to prove one’s partisan bona fides that you enter an escalatory spiral.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/partisanship-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The letter to the Jews of Savannah is theological. Washington is actually saying that, in contrast to much of your history in Christendom, where many depicted you as rejected by God, we see you as the opposite. Your story is an inspiration for our story. You are a covenantal people, and we see ourselves as a covenantal people. The two letters have to be taken together in tandem, because only when you look at both do you truly appreciate why Jews were so warmly welcomed.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/history-americ… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
During the Cold War, the United States was the power that upheld the security of these states—that is, the West—against the Communist challenge. The power of the United States continued uninterrupted through the post–Cold War era as the self-conscious supervisor of global order. Without it, the “end of history” would never have had a chance.
www.commentary.org/articles/tod-lindberg/great-powers-ret… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If you want to believe that Iran and Russia launched these wars over legitimate grievances that have yet to be addressed by the always-somehow-at-fault West, you have been living now for several years in an alternate reality. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/trump-faces-reality-on-ukr… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In his stand-up routine, Stanhope goes on to explain the context of his “I hate the Jews” joke. He had noticed that Mel Gibson got a ton of attention for simply hating the Jews. Stanhope resented this, because Gibson didn’t need all that free publicity. “I need press. I hate the Jews. Give me press,” Stanhope joked.
I doubt he expected that line to someday be one political party’s electoral strategy, but here we are.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-electoral-value-of-ant… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The kinds of things that would be a slam-dunker in America 5 years ago may no longer have that kind of impact."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=CX2EiUhcXncThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @jpodhoretz is joined by author Nicholas Lemann to discuss his new memoir Returning and the story of the American Jewish immigrant family.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/coming-to-america/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The reason the Egyptian soccer coach’s remarks were popular among “journalists” is that to the rest of the world, “Palestine” is a tool for anti-Jewish agitation. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/political-football/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Every protester wearing Hamas gear or waving a Hamas flag is implicitly going to bat for the jihadist subjugation of females. Compared to the left’s terrorist heroes, Platner is a piker." From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“The physical attachment to our child begins at conception,” Crittenden writes. “Scientists have discovered that fetal cells migrate during pregnancy, taking up residence in the mother’s brain and organs—a phenomenon known as fetal microchimerism. These cells can remain in the mother for as long as she lives.… I find this infinitely comforting: Even after death, Miranda literally remains alive within me, her cells woven through my brain and blood.”
www.commentary.org/articles/nancy-rommelmann/motherhood-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What happens when a strain of bigotry so completely overtakes a political movement that its elected representatives believe the same things as their most extreme voters?
This is what threatens to become of the Democratic Party—and the warning is coming from Democrats themselves. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-democrats-trickle-down… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss the latest explosive allegations against Graham Platner, leading to a string of endorsement withdrawals and a likely withdrawal from the Maine senate race, and how the New York Times tried to bury serious charges against Platner in their June story.
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
YUStrausCenter
@YUStrausCenter
In 1776, the Shearith Israel congregation joined a Continental Congress fast day, reciting Hebrew psalms. In @Commentary, Rabbi Dr. Meir Soloveichik connects that story to our present moment, 250 years later. www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/us-independe…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
When Zohran Mamdani raged against Jewish donors as “monsters,” even his erstwhile defenders were uncomfortable with the level of malice he was demonstrating. But his lack of empathy is visible too.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/anti-zionism-and-the-end-o… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Rahm Emanuel is testing a presidential campaign, but he sounds like someone applying for an internship at the Brookings Institution. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/rahm-emanuel-loves-the-nin… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Whether Mamdani’s anti-American agenda proves to be broadly popular, he knows that the Democratic Party is betting that it will be. The game now is to show his institutional allies exactly what he expects of them and to remake the party entirely."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The “enterprising spirit” Tocqueville recognized is Herman’s “founder’s fire,” and it has indeed characterized the history and people of the United States ever since. If we make the choice to maintain that Promethean fire and continue to create and empower the risk-seeking visionaries who have made America into the exceptional nation it is, that ongoing triumph for liberty will continue. And that is well worth remembering as we celebrate the 250th anniversary of our founding.
www.commentary.org/articles/mike-cote/founders-fire-1776-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The real benefit of heads-on-sticks is that when the rest of the team realizes that the head really is on a stick, that it isn’t about to come back to life, they feel emboldened to reveal just what a jerk the guy was all along.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/scott-pelley-cbs-fir… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are back to discuss the July 4th weekend and the Great America Fair, the upcoming democratic primary election in Michigan between Abdul El-Sayed and Haley Stevens, the new Free Beacon poll on republican primary voters, and The NYT editorial on standardized testing for college admissions.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/project-haley-mary/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Mallory McMorrow was a driver without a lane. Her cynical decision to jump on the anti-Israel "genocide" bandwagon was a transparent play for the same voters she would later repel by criticizing Hasan Piker's anti-Semitism. My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/gone-mcmorrow/
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Without the efforts of Uriah Phillips Levy and Frank Etting, significant parts of the history of the Declaration of Independence might have been lost.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-auslin/jews-declarati… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In this 250th anniversary year, there is still evidence that Fisch and Lincoln and Roosevelt were not wrong, and that the example of the American Revolution still exerts a hopeful force on the minds of people around the world.
www.commentary.org/articles/allen-guelzo/american-revolut… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"In America, if we see among some a hostility to the Jewish state and Jewish people on the progressive left or among what is called the woke right, it’s because they hate the covenantal nature of America. This is an anti-American movement."
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/history-americ… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Never again would the Declaration be brought so directly to the people or placed in what was almost a living historical tableau.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-auslin/jews-declarati… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Most telling of all was the fact that the initial claim was that Al-Basma was the most damaged structure in the area, supposedly proving that it was therefore intentionally targeted. But wire photos show that, right next to the clinic, a multi-story building had been left with a gaping hole, which, as Aizenberg notes, means that building and not the fertility clinic was almost certainly the target of any strike.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-uns-war-crimes-recycli… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Mamdani taught future DSA candidates how to make their New York campaigns all about Israel. “We have to make clear that when the boot of the NYPD is on your neck, it’s been laced by the IDF,” Mamdani told a DSA gathering.
To say his disciples understood the assignment is an understatement.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-new-democrats-and-the-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @jpodhoretz is joined by Professor Ruth Wisse for a discussion on her book If I Am Not for Myself: The Liberal Betrayal of the Jews, the challenges Jews face in an era of converging hatreds, and the need for American Jews to leverage their position in society for their own self-defense.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/how-to-save-the-jewish-people/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Ansari is a politician. She wants to win, and she will do or say whatever it takes to remain in her position of political power and privilege.
Now that Ansari has gotten what she needed from the Jews, she has moved on to greener pastures.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jewish-voters-hopes-for-mo… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Yassamin Ansari’s betrayal represents Jewish voters’ quandary when it comes to Democratic Party primaries and the search for moderates www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jewish-voters-hopes-for-mo…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This is eminent common sense given that we believe in free political speech."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bdkt8aCEtLsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Society initially pays more for a drug so that it exists at all. After that, it pays far less for a very long time. A modest cadre of temporarily pricey therapies underwrites decades of inexpensive medicine. That’s not a flaw in the system. It is the system.
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Genes are so impenetrably sophisticated that one is forced to discuss their function in terms of design whether or not one acknowledges a designer. They contain instructions—in the form of a symbolic, digital code—for assembling amino acids into proteins. And when I say the code is symbolic, I’m not overstating things. It’s a language made up of combinations of nucleotides that aren’t even chemically related to the amino acids they specify."--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
July 1, @continetti recommends Ironwood by Michael Connelly
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What does one terrible and futile war, and one man’s horrible experiences in it, have to do with another, and very different, war in the Middle East?
The answer lies in the notion that some depths of depravity are deeper than others.
www.commentary.org/articles/irina-velitskaya/hell-russia-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It’s becoming clear that Qatar bet on Iran and, by extension, October 7. And right now it looks like they made the right bet. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/did-qatar-win-the-u-s-iran… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Matthew Continetti
@continetti
Today's episode @commentary: The socialist wave; Trump's presidential fortune; Nina Totenberg's big mistake; and gratitude for America. Plus I make a recommendation. www.commentary.org/noam-blum/the-blues-go-red/
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What we’re witnessing is the electoral value of anti-Semitism for progressive candidates. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-electoral-value-of-ant… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @continetti is back to discuss the wave of democratic incumbent losses to insurgent DSA candidates and the party establishment’s lack of pushback, and what this could mean for the next democratic administration.
Plus, the revelation that Trump has made $2 billion as president, Nina Totenberg’s false announcement of Justice Alito’s retirement, and Matt recommends Michael Connelly’s Ironwood.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/the-blues-go-red/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Robert Doar
@RobertDoar
No legal expert and Supreme Court watcher has been more perceptive in commenting on the proceedings of the Court than AEI’s Adam White.
Here he joined the @Commentary podcast to discuss the end of the Supreme Court term. www.aei.org/multimedia/scotus-bog/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Experiencing the many thousands who had come to pray—and who immediately cheered a condemnation of Jew-hate—was, for me, a moment that I will remember on this Fourth of July as I stand in synagogue on the Sabbath and pray once more that this country experiences a defeat of anti-Semitism in this land—and that God continues to bless America.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/us-independe… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In 2012, the Democratic Socialists of America had 6,500 members. In February 2026, their numbers had swelled to 100,000, and my guess is that by the end of this year there will be, at minimum, half a million people who officially affiliate with the DSA. It is the story in American politics now. And it is the threat to American Jewry now. Sound the claxons. This is, by any definition, an existential emergency.
www.commentary.org/john-podhoretz/were-in-a-waking-nightm… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"He facilitates the oppression and cruelty by translating the florid war cries of radicals into establishment shorthand."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
While plagiarism is not a crime, for those caught at it, it is a disgrace.
www.commentary.org/articles/joseph-epstein/plagiarism-wri… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Walther is correct that AI is not merely a tool. It is something else we can’t quite describe.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/ai-anthropic-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Why don’t Western activists want to see Palestinians freed from their oppressors? @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/anti-zionism-and-the-end-o… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we are joined by @AEI's Adam White to try and make sense of the Supreme Court decisions striking down President Trump’s executive order on Birthright Citizenship, upholding state bans on transgender athletes, and overturning limits on political party-coordinated spending.
Plus, we celebrate Mel Brooks on his 100th birthday.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/scotus-bog/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
Just learned that "Klu Klux" is a phonetic bastardization of a Greek word (Kluklos) that means "circle." They sure Klu Kluxed Wiener on Friday.
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"We’re long past pointing out that gay and trans anti-Israel activists would be killed on the spot were they to sashay around Gaza in gold lamé shorts—keffiyehs notwithstanding.... What we’re dealing with here is the queer Klan. Their Jew-hatred has swallowed up all other activist concerns."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
My post on how it wasn’t the Hamas and PIJ obits that spurred CPJ to act but the work of writers and researchers like @GabrielEpsteinX, @Aizenberg55, @EFischberger and others, plus reporting by @FreeBeacon that made it un-ignorable.
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
CPJ deliberately ignores all the actual journalism that has gone into holding it accountable for its misrepresentations. For an organization called the Committee to Protect Journalists, that’s not a great sign. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/is-it-too-late-to-save-the… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
CPJ deliberately ignores all the actual journalism that has gone into holding it accountable for its misrepresentations. For an organization called the Committee to Protect Journalists, that’s not a great sign. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/is-it-too-late-to-save-the… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If there were still a way to turn his career into something good and decent, he would ask himself some hard questions about what he has become. That nobody expects him to do that is perhaps the saddest comment of all on New York’s mayor.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/mamdani-and-the-monsters/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This is reflective of just the hatred, extremism, just vile radicalism of the DSA activist class in New York City."
Watch and subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=H60MaPgnGWYThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Technologists may speak of progress for “humanity,” but for a long time now they have viewed ordinary human beings as stumbling blocks to it when measured against what the machines can do.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/ai-anthropic-… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Two deals: one predicated on American decline, the other on American strength. Vance and Rubio's assignments represent competing visions of the country they hope to lead. My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/two-deals-two-competing-vi…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss the ongoing fallout from DSA candidate victories in NY primary elections and the shifting lines of acceptability in political discourse, the video of Scott Wiener being harassed at a pride event in San Francisco and the rise of the all-obliterating omnicause.
Plus, putting to bed the leftist fantasy about the impending end of Israel, and John recommends Darcy O’Brien’s A Way of Life, Like Any Other.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/impurity-tests/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The strangest part of the administration’s 180 is the way it first debunked an Obama-era talking point and then embraced it
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/trump-owns-this-iran-deal/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @jewishinsider Editor-in-Chief @JoshKraushaar joins us to discuss the radicalism and antisemitism festering in New York’s DSA circles, and the piling up of scandals that would have doomed political careers in the past.
How did we get to this point, and how will both parties approach this trend in the lead up to the midterm elections?
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/new-york-old-hatred/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
True to form, President Biden failed to see the unintended consequences of his policies. L.E.K. Consulting estimates that the IRA reduces the meaningful exclusivity period of selected drugs by more than five years on average. Reducing the period changes neither risk nor development cost; it just lowers expected return. And because the lion’s share of lifetime revenue often arrives in the latter years of the window, lopping off the back third lowers expected return considerably.
www.commentary.org/articles/mworonof/american-biotech-ced… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We are living in a time of Idiocracy-style institutional embarrassment. Democracy, as you may have heard, dies in darkness.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-uns-war-crimes-recycli… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
The latest 'genocide' report at the UN is just a recycling of already-debunked claims twisted into an attempt to conjure 'intent.' There is real suffering in Gaza, and the report is a politicized disservice to that suffering. My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-uns-war-crimes-recycli…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @NoahCRothman joins us today to discuss the demographics of New York’s primary election results, and how voting for socialists is an expression of perpetual childhood.
Plus, the ongoing breakdown of relations between President Trump and the republican senate caucus, and a check-in on the situation in the Middle East.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/peter-pan-socialism/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
American Jews need to stop with the apologizing.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/stop-throat-clearing/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
John Podhoretz
@jpodhoretz
My take on last night and the two decades preceding it that led to it.
www.commentary.org/john-podhoretz/were-in-a-waking-nightm… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
How the DSA remade itself as an anti-Zionist org and then began remaking the Democratic Party www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-new-democrats-and-the-…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Many of the voters who say they now support “socialism” are clearly not planning on seizing the means of production and setting up gulags, so we have that going for us. Instead, they now associate the word “socialism” with scapegoating the Jews. And they like the sound of that. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-new-democrats-and-the-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Contributing editor @EliLake and FDD’s @JSchanzer join us today to mourn New York City in the wake of the string of radical left candidate victories in the democratic primaries.
Plus, the latest on the Iran MOU and Israel’s impossible position with regards to Hezbollah. -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
"Zohran Mamdani demanded that we take him as he is, did not trim his sails, stuck with what he believed in, and has trumped the Squad in charting an ever-more radical path for one of the two major political parties in the United States."
key @jpodhoretz www.commentary.org/john-podhoretz/were-in-a-waking-nightm… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Muslim anti-Zionist mayor of America’s most Jewish city sponsored three candidates for Congress, two in primary races against sitting left-wing incumbents, and pretty much secured for them the Democratic Party nominations in their districts. @jpodhoretz
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Before October 7, 2023, Israel might have been willing and able to show the kind of restraint that Trump wants it to now. But the lesson of October 7 was that emerging threats are imminent threats. And Hezbollah’s activity makes that threat very real. @SethAMandel
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss the antisemitic shooting in Montreal, and the controversy involving Dan Goldman and a Brooklyn coffee shop.
Plus, Dan Schueftan, chairman of the National Security Studies Center at the University of Haifa, speaks on the current regional and international state of Israel, and the struggle to ensure the continuity of the Jewish way of life.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/enemies-on-all-sides/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It should be easy to understand the unease of American Jews who hear the country’s most prominent mayor and a would-be mass murderer talk about us the same way. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/mamdani-and-the-monsters/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The administration will continue to say that Israel has the right to defend itself from Hezbollah’s cease-fire violations. But it doesn’t really mean it. And it doesn’t believe in Lebanon’s right to defend itself from Iran.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/trump-is-demanding-israel-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We are amid a significant shift in the cultural messaging around parenthood, and we can’t throw shame or money at the problem if we hope to solve it. A growing number of people in younger generations have decided that having children simply isn’t worth it. Why?
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If you look at the eight years of the Obama presidency . . . he changed the trajectory of America toward decline."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=uihc8zEyox4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Ambassador Deek concluded his 2014 speech with the following reflection: “The reason my family succeeded in life, and the reason I’m standing in front of you today as an Israeli diplomat and not a Palestinian refugee from Lebanon, is because my grandfather had the courage to take a decision that was unthinkable to others.”
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/israel-georg… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There is good reason to suspect the Parthenon was unusual among temples in that “for Pericles the motivation behind temple building was not primarily religious but political.”
www.commentary.org/articles/spencer-klavan/hubris-pericle… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"When the missiles come raining down on you, there will be no Israeli defense technology to protect you. That's the rules."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=O8ASuCkNCV8 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Palestine Action ruling will still be appealed to the UK Supreme Court. But the court cannot change the facts as the judges laid them out above. And by trying to equate terrorism with free speech and civil protest, the West’s various Hamasnik groups and their defenders continue to undermine both.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/yes-its-terrorism/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Jesus said, “Turn the other cheek,” “Love your enemy.” Jesus said, “The meek shall inherit the earth.” In every Catholic church, Jesus appears as a victim on a crucifix—not a soldier, not a conqueror. Muhammad was a general. His hijra to Medina in 622 C.E. was not a retreat from a fallen world but the founding of a polity. Within a decade of his death, Islamic armies had taken Arabia, Persia, and the Levant. The religion was born in victory and has never fully forgotten what victory felt like.
www.commentary.org/articles/zohar-atkins/martyrdom-islam-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Alito added that “Nino also changed the tenor of our proceedings. Oral argument became a contact sport.”
www.commentary.org/articles/adam-white/scalia-supreme-cou… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
On the Democratic side, we have officially entered a campaign season in which literally every primary race is centered on Israel and the Jews. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/scapegoat-season/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The administration deserves credit for following through on its vow—as expressed in the National Security Strategy—to tackle “resurgent Islamist terrorist activity in parts of Africa.”
www.commentary.org/articles/ebenezer-obadare/trump-counte… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This has now become an economic enrichment device for the Iranian regime and a humiliation for the United States."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=4rGP6ZkxFVw -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss reports on issues with the Iran MOU and the cancellation of JD Vance’s trip to Switzerland, ostensibly over ongoing hostilities between Israel and Hezbollah, and the scapegoating of Israel, Zionists, and neocons.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/lebanon-sequitur/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Who has established deterrence at the end of this war? Iran has established deterrence against the United States."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=uihc8zEyox4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Russell Calloway is the proprietor of his own small but tony publishing house, thanks to a rich friend who staked him in some earlier novel and who plays a minor role in this book as one of Russell’s super-rich wine bros. Mrs. Calloway is some sort of socialite (attended Miss Porter’s school, etc.) with the requisite charitable leanings and eating disorder. We meet them at a 35th wedding anniversary party for his best friend. While the first lines are less grabby than his Bright Lights opener, they’re striking for how they pay direct homage to his first book.
www.commentary.org/articles/rick-marin/jay-mcinerney-see-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The consequences have been predictable. Legislative inactivity has been accompanied by a steady expansion of executive power. Today, the United States is engaged in a war against Iran—marked by the use of cruise missiles and precision-guided munitions and the deployment of three carrier groups to the Middle East. Yet President Trump has not sought congressional authorization, and Congress has made little meaningful effort to force the issue. The conclusion is hard to avoid: Many members appear content to be relieved of their constitutional responsibility to declare war.
www.commentary.org/articles/jay-lefkowitz/last-branch-sta… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The strangest part of the administration’s 180 is the way it first debunked an Obama-era talking point and then embraced it. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/trump-owns-this-iran-deal/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Trump Owns This Iran Deal
Why blaming Obama and lashing out at 'neocons' falls flat. My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/trump-owns-this-iran-deal/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @continetti is back to discuss the inauguration of the Obama presidential center in Chicago and president Obama’s legacy.
Plus, the ongoing unfolding Iran disaster with the signing of the MOU and Trump’s press conference, Israel’s precarious position in Lebanon, and Matt recommends The Infinity Machine.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/mullah-moolah/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Under what set of understandings of how relationships between nations work does one party unilaterally decide what a sovereign ally must do?"
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=4rGP6ZkxFVw -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"If the regime refused to conduct detailed and credible negotiations about ending its nuclear program today, it’s certainly not going to feel more pressured to do so 60 days into its second life as the country that beat America."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It is a hallmark of anti-Semitic movements throughout the ages to find Jews to do their dirty work for them. The UK Green Party is merely following European historical precedent. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/prostrators-for-palestine/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To be clear right off the bat: No one in this case is being punished for protesting. They are being indicted for behavior they knew fell into the category of federal criminal conspiracy.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-we-learned-from-the-f… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Now we know how to get any Democratic Party PAC to reveal its donors. Just accuse them of being Zionists and they’ll go to any length to make clear their PAC is of pure blood. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jews-on-the-brain/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Serious criminal accusations against Israel are not random. They are indications that Israel’s enemies have been found to have engaged in monstrous behavior that will soon be made public. It didn’t seem possible for Hamas’s defenders and enablers to be even further discredited, but here we are. Pay attention to the when, and you’ll figure out the why.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-psychological-projecti… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Brad Lander Isn’t Selling Us Out. He’s Giving Us Away.
My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/brad-lander-isnt-selling-u… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If these letters had excised all the specific anti-Israel fertilizer and just left the parts about artistic freedom and cancel culture, would they still get all those names to sign on? What about if Nadav Lapid had written a different sort of film, with a different political or ideological message? Or if he wasn’t living in self-imposed exile in France because of his distaste for his homeland?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jewish-artists-shouldnt-se… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss the media blitz to sell the Iran MOU despite refusing to release its contents, as well as the contents of the agreement that were published in the media.
Plus, Trump torpedoes Jay Clayton’s nomination for DNI, JD Vance’s appearance on Megyn Kelly, and the elections in Georgia and DC, a new FBI investigation of Gavin Newsom, and John recommends The Furious.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/whats-in-the-mou/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Just being a caustic critic of Israel isn’t enough to be inducted into this fraternity. If you don’t embrace Holocaust revisionism that makes Jews into the villain of their own story, you can’t sit at the intifada lunch table. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/brad-lander-isnt-selling-u… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The Iranians are now lying to our face rather than through intermediaries."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=O8ASuCkNCV8 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The world's attitude should be, if [Iran] even jokes about shutting it down, we'll bury them."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=3HvgtO_VGCQ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The July/August double issue of Commentary is now available.
This issue celebrates America’s 250th anniversary, the political operatives fueling the “Never Trump” movement, the state of biotech, the false humility of Silicon Valley’s AI surge, and more.
With contributions from @jpodhoretz, @jkirchick, @RabbiWolpe, @ratlpolicy, @NancyRomm, @rcbl.
Read on at commentary.org and subscribe at commentary.org/subscribe. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The analogy the book really offers is about the accommodation of evil—and in our day, not of those to the right to Trump, but of the liberal establishment to the unambiguous political violence being embraced by their fellow progressives.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/effingers-oppe… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Rarely does a Democrat mention Israel these days without a perfunctory jab at the country’s leader.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/most-democrats… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The contrast between Trump’s aversion to tackling serious matters and his enthusiasm for ridiculous ones becomes deeply unsettling. He stops being what some of us hoped he was—a strangely resolute man with off-putting eccentricities—and snaps back to being what he is: an untethered, slapdash populist."--From today's newsltter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There are three things we went into this war for—none of those has been achieved."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=3HvgtO_VGCQ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"You may think that the cost of victory in Iraq and Afghanistan was too high—and you may very well be right. But don’t tell me that our current surrender to the Iranian regime was worth tens of billions of taxpayer dollars (with billions more soon to come) and the lives of 15 American service members. If we wanted to tell Iran (and the world) that it finally won its near-50-year battle with the U.S., we could have done that for free."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Trump’s Iran deal forces Israel and Lebanon to violate their obligations and promises to Trump under the last two agreements.
There are two Trumps, they’re both president at the same time, and they can’t agree on anything. My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/trump-is-demanding-israel-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The fact is, Israel is abiding by its “internationally recognized borders,” and anyone who says otherwise isn’t engaging in honest debate. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/israels-internationally-re… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It was a covenantal conviction—the conviction that Britain’s fate and the fate of the Jewish people were bound together in a moral order that transcended any particular government or generation.
www.commentary.org/articles/mike-burke/britain-jews-betra… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"I think the worst part about this deal . . . is that this is a deal of US military surrender."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=AAkPQ6v5twQ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Contributing editor @EliLake is back to discuss the MOU with Iran, which has seemed to receive universal condemnation from everyone except vice president JD Vance, who is engaged in a widespread media tour to sell a deal whose details remain unknown.
Plus, the indictments of Pro-Palestinian activists at the University of Michigan for their campaign of threats and intimidation.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/vance-macabre/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This emerging Iran deal appears to require Israel and Lebanon to violate their own previous obligations, made at the behest of President Trump. Perhaps this is one problem with an addiction to negotiated cease-fires: You start to lose track of the details. @SethAMandel
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If you are Jewish, you are part of the Jewish nation. That can get confusing for people in the post-1948 world in which there is a Jewish nation-state. But in the century before that year, debates among major Zionist and non-Zionist thinkers took for granted that the Jews were a nation deserving of some measure of autonomy, no matter where they were in the world.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-the-israel-day-parade… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
No genocidal regime in history has ever investigated its own soldiers, expressly warned civilians of impending attacks, or spent hundreds of millions of dollars on humanitarian aid—all steps that Israel alone has taken.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-rosen/israel-on-trial… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Cerf relished his TV fame. In one amusing story, he was dining at the home of the Connecticut writer Eleanor Clark, wife of Robert Penn Warren. Cerf asked Clark, who disdained television, if he could watch his appearance on What’s My Line. Clark considered Cerf’s willingness to absent himself from a dinner party, as well as his interest in watching himself on TV, “disgusting.” Regardless, she told Cerf of a nearby home that had a television. Cerf set out in the snow, found the house, and knocked on the door. A woman answered and exclaimed, “It’s Bennett Cerf! I’m watching you!”
www.commentary.org/articles/tevi-troy/random-house-bennet… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
No matter which way the ruling ultimately goes, the case has managed to reveal the fundamental nature of the networks of post-October 7 anti-Zionist activism. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/yes-its-terrorism/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The ceasefire is a farce. The state of war exists between Iran and its neighbors. The president has turned into a clown."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=AAkPQ6v5twQ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @FDD’s @JSchanzer is back to discuss President Trump’s terrible Iran deal and the ongoing uncertainty about its details, as well as America’s position in the world in the aftermath of such a deal.
Plus, the Bidens attempt a comeback, and Jay Clayton’s nomination for DNI.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/my-kingdom-for-a-deal/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There will be no pivot to Asia if the president doesn’t want one. There can be no rebalancing if instead of great power competition the president wants to see FDR-style spheres of influence.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/did-trump-just-telegraph-h… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There is no point before, during, or after negotiations for cease-fires or nuclear deals at which Jews are not at that moment being targeted for murder somewhere by Iran. When that war is over, we can talk of peace.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/how-irans-global-war-works… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We're a next-generation military power fighting a last-generation military power."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Su2xD0Bz8dcThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The most interesting aspects of the book involve Cerf’s intermittent brilliance as an editor and acquirer. He challenged Geisel to use fewer and fewer words, leading to the triumph of Green Eggs and Ham, which uses only 50. He promised Ayn Rand that he would let her publish her books without being censored by the liberal staff at Random House, a promise he ultimately could not keep when she sought to write a book in 1963 accusing John F. Kennedy of being a fascist.
www.commentary.org/articles/tevi-troy/random-house-bennet… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Whereas “colonists don’t speak the land’s language, practice its religion, or share any of its cultural heritage,” contemporary Jewish Israelis unambiguously perform all three and even share common DNA with their ancestors in the Levant.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-rosen/israel-on-trial… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
On the other hand, as Stuttard observes, there is good reason to suspect the Parthenon was unusual among temples in that “for Pericles the motivation behind temple building was not primarily religious but political.” Athens’s foremost statesman was part of a daring intellectual vanguard that routinely questioned the logic of traditional Greek myth.
www.commentary.org/articles/spencer-klavan/hubris-pericle… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We are entering a very dangerous moment just in terms of terrorist threats."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Su2xD0Bz8dc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Even so, a committed observer of the Court like Isgur acknowledges that “the cracks are starting to show.”
www.commentary.org/articles/jay-lefkowitz/last-branch-sta… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Even Lander was horrified by the October 8 rally, as was literally any person on earth with a shred of humanity.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-bottomless-pit-of-prog… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Scalia estate’s restrictions on releasing these files are justified. For justices to have candid discussions with each other, and with their clerks, their memos and files need to be kept secret long after a case is decided. But that means for the purposes of an account like Rosen’s, the deepest views of his subject are simply unavailable to us.
www.commentary.org/articles/adam-white/scalia-supreme-cou… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The wife’s middle name is “Makepeace,” McInerney’s not-so-subtle way of letting us know he wants this to be viewed as a social novel à la William Makepeace Thackeray’s Vanity Fair, only this one capturing the chaotic moment in American/New York life that featured Covid, George Floyd, Bill DeBlasio…
www.commentary.org/articles/rick-marin/jay-mcinerney-see-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Friday, and time to discuss yet another round of “is there a deal with Iran?” after reports on the latest proposal that put a halt to a planned attack on Kharg Island. How much longer can this situation persist?
Plus, Jodi Kantor defends Graham Platner and lays MeToo to rest.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/stall-tales/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There is no clear solution outside of defeating Iran and opening the waterways. But if and when that happens, at least, it’ll almost surely be the last time such an effort is necessary.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/why-the-hormuz-crisis-coul… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The people who told you there was something there were shown the files and forced to say 'oops, there's nothing there'."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=qtRMCNJED6k -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
A federal complaint on the indictments of a pro-Hamas vandals ring exposes how our political culture is coming entirely unglued www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-we-learned-from-the-f…
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
June 11, @continetti recommends the documentary Earth, Wind & Fire (To be Celestial vs. That's the Weight of the World
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The left can make a tactical peace with cops and whiteness and biological reality. But anti-Semitism is too powerful an organizing tool to throw away. You can’t give up the Jewish villain."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It is important to see beyond any doubt that every Hamas-worshiping tentifada activist knows exactly he’s doing. There’s no “youthful innocence” here. No one’s just getting carried away.
@SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-we-learned-from-the-f… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The question now becomes: Will this satisfy all those who claim that American subsidy is the problem with Israel aid? Or will they find other reasons to bash the plan and move the goalposts in their continuing quest to undo America’s alliances?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/u-s-military-aid-to-israel… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
J Street is free to lobby for downgrading the alliance and weakening both the U.S. and Israel. I wouldn’t expect anything different, because that is what the organization does. And therefore that is what the organization is. I’d rather they be honest about their own motivations, but they shouldn’t begrudge the honesty of their critics.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/j-street-vindicates-its-cr… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Every religion has martyrs. What distinguishes the modern suicide bomber is not the willingness to die. It is the mechanism: The death is made to cause other deaths. The martyr’s body becomes the weapon. Dying and killing are fused into a single transaction.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The American military has to refrain from sounding pleading."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=qtRMCNJED6k -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Serious criminal accusations against Israel are not random. They are indications that Israel’s enemies have been found to have engaged in monstrous behavior that will soon be made public. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-psychological-projecti… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @continetti is back to discuss the central theory of Trump’s second term, as well as the resumption of strikes on Iran and the threat to take Kharg Island. Is this a negotiating tactic, or have the Iranians finally pushed Trump too far?
Plus, the expiration of FISA, the launch of the World Cup, the historic Knicks game, the inflation numbers, and Matt recommends the documentary Earth, Wind & Fire (To Be Celestial vs That’s the Weight of the World).
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/drive-my-kharg/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In another good omen, U.S. intervention has also been welcomed by other segments of the Nigerian society, including major media outlets, which have embraced it as “a fitting but long overdue diplomatic signal to all terrorism merchants, sponsors, and foot soldiers in Nigeria that their days are numbered.”
www.commentary.org/articles/ebenezer-obadare/trump-counte… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The optimal outcome here is regime change."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=7CqWgA5n1OU -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israel took South Lebanon from Hezbollah, not the Lebanese army. Hezbollah is an Iranian occupation force. Why isn’t Iran’s occupation of South Lebanon viewed as a threat to France? Because when he talks about “invasions of our allies’ territory,” the ally is apparently imperial Iran.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-threat-of-jean-luc-mel… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Does Natalie Portman, born in Jerusalem, agree that Jews are interlopers in the Holy Land? @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jewish-artists-shouldnt-se… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"I can't imagine anything worse than taking the biggest gamble of your presidency and bringing it to an inconclusive result."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=B79eNno-GxI -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss Trump’s ongoing pendulum swings on Iran and the contrast between his statements and American action, as well as revelations from Jonathan Swan and Maggie Haberman’s upcoming book on the Trump admin’s reaction to the Epstein scandal.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Indeed, one might say that this act is so unhistoric, we do not know to this day the name of the person who performed it. Yet that act is also, in a sense, profoundly linked to a newsworthy event of the last month.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/israel-georg… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Does Natalie Portman believe Israel is a colonialist state? Does Nadav Lapid really believe that if you take the ideological messaging in his work seriously you *shouldn't* boycott Israelis--including Nadav Lapid?
Jews, stop begging for table scraps: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jewish-artists-shouldnt-se… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"There are a lot of variations on the 'hate has no place…' line. Elected officials use it all the time. Racism or anti-Semitism, they tell us, 'has no home' in this city or that state or even in the country. There is no line of stock political rhetoric more enraging than this empty declaration. In fact, I hate it." From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Why is the big Jewish event each year specifically an 'Israel Day?'
Because a celebration of Israel *is* a celebration of Jewish peoplehood, of the Jewish nation--not just the Jewish nation-state. Americans need to rediscover Jewish nationhood: -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This is where the postliberals have their own form of the “hasn’t truly been tried” myth. Instead of admitting that centralized, religious autocracy inevitably leads to all sorts of intended and unintended consequences—of which there is adequate proof—postliberals seem to believe that real religious autocracy, or real postliberalism/integralism, hasn’t been tried yet. But the truth is it has been tried and the results left much to be desired.
www.commentary.org/articles/josh-appel/postliberals-orban… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What anti-Semites so hated about Bettauer’s book and the movie was, of course, the idea that Jews add so much to society that their absence can be catastrophic economically and culturally. There is no reason any modern country should have to learn this lesson for itself.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The message to the Islamic Republic is that what happens in Lebanon stays in Lebanon. Iran doesn't get a vote."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=7CqWgA5n1OU -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Why, some wonder, does the big show of pride in Jewish life and culture have to be a specifically “Israel” event? Why don’t we instead have a Jewish parade? @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-the-israel-day-parade… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There's a rot around Platner that the people who have put themselves in a position to defend him have absorbed."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=7E98-zRV8EM -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What’s more concerning is the collapse in support among average Democratic voters. Until recently, American support for Israel was a bipartisan affair, with Democrats and liberals often outshining Republicans and conservatives in their affinity for the Jewish state. Harry Truman, John F. Kennedy, and Lyndon Baines Johnson were stalwart supporters of Israel; so too was Bill Clinton. Apportioning culpability for the rupture between Democrats and Israel is therefore a bit like asking which came first, the chicken or the egg.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/most-democrats… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Any belief that Iran can be merely contained while leaving its threats intact is shortsighted in the extreme. The entire region was blown open by October 7, which was the work of one of Iran’s militias, Hamas. The fact that Iran is asking to preserve the ability to have its proxies repeat the conflagration is proof that the choice before Trump is war now, in which the U.S. has a distinct advantage, or war later, when the enemy has rearmed. The president should choose wisely.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-iran-is-really-asking… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We must understand raising children as a welcome moral obligation that connects us to the future and that contributes to the health of society, as something more meaningful than the decision to live in the city or the suburbs, or which kind of car to buy.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @FDD’s @JSchanzer is back to discuss yesterday’s chain of events involving Hezbollah, Israel, and Iran, and the stream of contradictory media reports and remarks from admin officials.
Plus, more on the miscalculations in conducting the war and what the endgame might look like, and a check in on Graham Platner.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/multipolar-disorder/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"What an ideological bubble [Scott Pelley] lives in."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=B79eNno-GxI -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter.
www.commentary.org/newsletter
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"I don’t mean, nor do I believe, that Trump is senile. I mean, rather, that the elliptical rhetorical style that he likes to call “the weave” is now nothing more than a nonsensical haze. It’s just a blur of wishful thinking." --From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There will be no pivot to Asia if the president doesn’t want one. There can be no rebalancing if instead of great power competition the president wants to see FDR-style spheres of influence. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/did-trump-just-telegraph-h… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Rejecting Platner was supposed to be the absolute least that was expected of them. Platner wasn’t supposed to be the “country over party” test because it was too easy to mean anything. You weren’t supposed to deserve credit for rejecting Nazi iconography.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-easiest-test-youve-eve… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss Israel’s retaliatory strikes on Iran and reports that Trump had instructed Netanyahu to not respond to the Iranian missile salvo.
Was Israel’s response indicative of a smoke screen or something more serious, and how does it relate to reports that the Pentagon is concerned about a rising espionage threat from Israel?
Plus, Scott Pelley’s post-firing media tour, and Seth recommends Legends on Netflix.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/plan-bibi/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Iran has declared a war that is permanent. That means that while the forgivably war-weary can try to forget about the conflicts each time a cease-fire is reached, Jews cannot. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/how-irans-global-war-works… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The analogy the book really offers is about the accommodation of evil—and in our day, not of those to the right to Trump, but of the liberal establishment to the unambiguous political violence being embraced by their fellow progressives.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/effingers-oppe… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
When the deterioration becomes impossible to ignore, when it spills over into bloodshed, it reaches for words—and words, in the hands of this governing class, are where the response begins and ends.
www.commentary.org/articles/mike-burke/britain-jews-betra… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"That is increasingly the tactic of the Democrat party: 'You have to vote for this guy, or else you're not part of the righteous people.'"
Watch the full episode joined by @liel: www.youtube.com/watch?v=7E98-zRV8EM -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
While Cerf was an influential character and perhaps more responsible than anyone for the rise of the modern publishing house, he has a more complicated legacy than one would think.
www.commentary.org/articles/tevi-troy/random-house-bennet… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Against this backdrop of decades-long material and technical support, the recent troop deployment is not so much a shift in strategy as it is a powerful signal to the Nigerian government that the administration is determined to back up its threat to intervene militarily.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The story of Taryn Thomas’s recovery from the intellectual isolation of pro-Palestinian activism provides a handy guide for anyone interested.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-cliffsnotes-guide-to-a… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"When you start encroaching on the private rights of others, we don't take that lying down in the United States."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrTxhYtajh4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
I’ve been watching a lot of Modern Family lately, in clips and fragments, scrolling through my feed. I suppose that means I’m telling the algorithm—and, by extension, the studios—that I wish they’d do Modern Family again.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/spoilers-memes-moder… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
When the job gets harder, it still must be done. Obligations are not for easy times only.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/heed-this-rabbis-words/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Ambassador Deek concluded his 2014 speech with the following reflection: “The reason my family succeeded in life, and the reason I’m standing in front of you today as an Israeli diplomat and not a Palestinian refugee from Lebanon, is because my grandfather had the courage to take a decision that was unthinkable to others.”
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/israel-georg… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Spencer Pratt has really taken the world by storm with his viral ads and his common-sense campaign against homelessness and crime."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=-rXDvyaR8fM -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There is a key belief animating blood-and-soil extremists like Chevalier: that it doesn’t matter what a Palestinian does to a Jew; there is no line and no sin. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-bottomless-pit-of-prog… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
You would think something that is true 100 percent of the time is a pretty good bet. But there’s a very simple reason people still do not want Israel to do what brings peace 100 percent of the time: Israel’s critics, including much of the world’s media, don’t want peace.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Roy Altman rebuts the allegation that Israel has prevented the establishment of a Palestinian state. To do this, Altman chronicles the six instances in which Palestinian leadership expressly rejected internationally brokered partitions and permanent resolutions to the conflict.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Judaism and early Christianity were born under empires. Egypt. Babylon. Rome. Their primary theological challenge was not how to win but how to remain elect while being crushed. The answer was transcendence through suffering.
www.commentary.org/articles/zohar-atkins/martyrdom-islam-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @tabletmag’s @liel joins us to discuss the newest allegations against Graham Platner published by the New York Times and the paper’s misconduct in handling the story, and how politics supplanting culture in America has led to the current state.
Plus, a look back at the worst moments for public health officials during COVID.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/pu-pu-platner/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The threat of long-term Strait closure has materialized, which makes it real, which makes it something that cannot be repeated. Market forces will mobilize alternatives. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/why-the-hormuz-crisis-coul… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Why this Hormuz crisis might also be the last: A look at the ways the global markets are adjusting to blunt a future Iranian threat www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/why-the-hormuz-crisis-coul…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"I cannot imagine that you would choose anywhere but the United States to be born."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrTxhYtajh4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Internalizing fear means forfeiting freedom. As Jews, we are the world’s foremost ambassadors of liberty. We have a responsibility to act like it.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/a-plea-to-jews-dont-do-the… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Downtown LA is now basically one giant 25-acre homeless shelter . . . and no one is doing anything."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=fIqIrodI7fs -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
You can support ending aid to Israel for various reasons. J Street’s problem with U.S. aid to Israel is the “Israel” part, not the “aid” part. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/j-street-vindicates-its-cr… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The biggest shift, however, is the acceptance of the idea that having children is merely one among many viable choices available if one is to live a flourishing adult life.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/young-couples… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Contributing editor @EliLake is back to help us beat back the crushing morosity with an extra long show all about how America is actually a great country that affords infinite opportunities for those who wish to thrive there.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/america-is-great-actually/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Jean-Luc Melenchon, the powerful leader of the French left and prospective presidential candidate in the next national elections, has a history of voicing his inner anti-Semitic thoughts. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-threat-of-jean-luc-mel… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Do I still maintain that Trump did the civilized world a tremendous favor by leveling Iran’s nuclear program? Absolutely. But it must now be acknowledged that his dithering, if it continues, will introduce a whole new danger."--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"A literal al-Qaeda supporter named Adam Hamawy has won the Democratic primary."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=-rXDvyaR8fM -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The traditional story about the Athenians is that they managed to withstand Persia’s assault through the courage of their convictions.
www.commentary.org/articles/spencer-klavan/hubris-pericle… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
At the start of his legal career, Scalia told a friend, “I will be sent to Washington, and then I will rise.”
www.commentary.org/articles/adam-white/scalia-supreme-cou… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There has always been a portion of the far left that’s implacably hostile to Israel.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/most-democrats… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @continetti is back to discuss Adam Hamawy’s victory in the NJ democratic primary and what it means for other extremist democrats on the ballot, the various California races.
Plus, the slog of war continues with more uncertainty and indecisiveness in the Iran war, and Bill Pulte’s appointment as acting DNI.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/hamawy-wowee/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Figures like Tucker Carlson and Marjorie Taylor Greene continue to dishonestly frame the aid issue as a cudgel against Israel and against Trump. Eliminating this talking point without eliminating the aid, then, has given Trump reason to pursue a restructuring under his own watch. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/u-s-military-aid-to-israel… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The judiciary hasn't escaped the broader polarization of American politics. Its prestige has suffered as a result.
www.commentary.org/articles/jay-lefkowitz/last-branch-sta… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Food shortages, economic stagnation, corruption, and repression are inherent to collective ownership and centralized social planning. The failure to grasp such basic cause and effect is due to the romanticization of Communist utopia and the demonization of democratic capitalism.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The left doesn't care about norms. Socialists don't care; they just want power."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=I22V39InzgI -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Why is Trump yelling at Bibi [Netanyahu]? Why is he not saying, 'Alright, you know what? You're my leverage.'"
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=fIqIrodI7fsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
But because Scalia’s triumph is now so obvious, it is all the harder to imagine how daunting—how implausible—such a victory might have seemed in 1986, when Scalia joined the court.
www.commentary.org/articles/adam-white/scalia-supreme-cou… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
You can rearrange the pieces all you want, but in the end Israelis are going to support taking out the threats they face.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-democrats-and-america… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @FDD’s @JSchanzer is back to discuss a litany of bad news: a disputed report on an aggressive phone call between president Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu over Israel’s planned offensive on Beirut, the regional obstacles to a resolution in Iran, and the multi-pronged approach necessary to achieve it.
Plus, the California primary vote, and John recommends Obsession.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/the-ceasefire-war/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It turns out the real “Jewish Problem” is not having enough Jews. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/cities-without-jews/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The book’s concluding section is about a man who is sent to a concentration camp. Remember, his book was written and concludes…in 1933.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/effingers-oppe… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Trump got rolled today by the Iranians. My latest: www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-iran-is-really-asking…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We have three powers in Lebanon: Israel, Lebanon, and Iran. Only two of those are arguing for a permanent right to control the country: Lebanon and Iran. So which of those two has a stronger case to control Lebanon? @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-iran-is-really-asking… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The whole concept of a ceasefire in modern warfare is absurd."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=T_g4W5zJV0A -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If we can't use our military out of fear that one person will be taken and used as a bargaining chip, then our military is useless."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=I22V39InzgI -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To deface Churchill’s statue is not to deface a monument. It is to deface Britain itself—its greatest hero, its defining moral struggle, and the covenant that struggle sealed.
www.commentary.org/articles/mike-burke/britain-jews-betra… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The restaurant, by the way, is called Condrieu, which sounds like a villain out of The Three Musketeers but is in fact an obscure French wine that Jay McInerney knows about and you don’t.
www.commentary.org/articles/rick-marin/jay-mcinerney-see-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Progressives have made Platner the hero of the hour, a living idol and a human litmus test. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-easiest-test-youve-eve… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Contributing editor @EliLake joins us today to discuss Iran pulling out of talks with the US over Israel’s expanding offensive in Lebanon, the American fear of utilizing ground troops, and Trump’s only way out of the deadlock.
Plus, Graham Platner’s latest controversy and the aggressive attempts to tamp it down.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/maine-squeeze/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We're living in a world that is creeping perilously close to antinomianism about our own laws."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=T_g4W5zJV0A -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Auchincloss’s choice of zeroing in on the Nazi tattoo is a fascinating one. Had he denounced Platner for sexism or racism, the pushback from pro-Platner Dems might have been more muted. But calling rank anti-Semitism disqualifying is a threat to an entire group of up-and-coming progressives.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-platner-has-done-to-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Islam proves itself by winning. Judaism proves itself by surviving. These are different epistemologies, and they produce entirely different martyrologies.
www.commentary.org/articles/zohar-atkins/martyrdom-islam-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
As the public has come to see the Court more as a political actor, scrutiny of the justices has intensified.
www.commentary.org/articles/jay-lefkowitz/last-branch-sta… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This is not merely a story of one journalist behaving unconscionably. It’s a story of Western institutional collapse and the dreary remnants that rise from the rubble to perpetuate all the evil things its predecessors got away with.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-enormous-blast-radius-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We are amid a significant shift in the cultural messaging around parenthood, and we can’t throw shame or money at the problem if we hope to solve it. A growing number of people in younger generations have decided that having children simply isn’t worth it. Why?
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The team decided that they were going to protect Biden so that they could maintain their hands on the levers of power."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=s4w32-cfIic -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The great irony is that this biography of one of the best-known of all American editors could have benefited from Bennett Cerf himself trimming it down.
www.commentary.org/articles/tevi-troy/random-house-bennet… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
We have no idea who this Jew was, but his own action gave the Deek family a future.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/israel-georg… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We are getting very close to the Democratic party's line being that it is okay to be anti-Semitic."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=mJIgDNPnzSk -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Whether American counterterrorism efforts in Nigeria succeed or fail will depend to some extent on the reception accorded U.S. personnel—something that, for its part, will ultimately boil down to public perception of the mission.
www.commentary.org/articles/ebenezer-obadare/trump-counte… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The way forward isn’t to argue that having children will make you happy (even though it often does). It is to acknowledge that sacrifice, responsibility, and love are what make fully formed people, and that parenthood is one way (although not the only way) of becoming such a person.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/young-couples… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
He also refutes the “adverse possession” offshoot of the colonization charge, i.e., the assertion that the Jews left Israel centuries ago and thus cannot object to others occupying it in the meantime. In fact, the Jewish people resided there continuously, and, in any event, this doctrine “doesn’t grant the adverse possessors true title to the property in situations where, as here, they took the property illegally by force,” as Arab Muslims did in the seventh century.
www.commentary.org/articles/michael-rosen/israel-on-trial… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The story of Taryn Thomas’s recovery from the intellectual isolation of pro-Palestinian activism provides a handy guide for anyone interested. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-cliffsnotes-guide-to-a… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Friday, and we are back to discuss reports that Iran has used the ongoing ceasefire to extract missiles and launchers from destroyed sites and how losing countries can exploit breaks in fighting to their advantage, as well as Trump’s anti-weaponization fund and his other corrupt practices.
Plus, John recommends Faulkner’s Light in August.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/the-ceasefire-two-step/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Teaching, leadership, education—these are what saved Judaism after the destruction of the Second Temple and the ensuing exile. We argue endlessly about what our rabbis say and do and mean, but it is largely thanks to this system that we have something to argue about at all. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/heed-this-rabbis-words/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Rubio is an American dream candidate and Vance is an 'the American dream has died' candidate."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=s4w32-cfIic -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Is there a word for nostalgia for something that’s too recent? The New York we’re reliving here was only six years ago.
www.commentary.org/articles/rick-marin/jay-mcinerney-see-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Jabotinsky is talking about building the institutions of a Jewish state. But he might as well also be talking about America. Should Jews be ashamed of all that has been built with “Jewish money?”
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/on-jewish-money-in-america… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Jewish blood comes at a cost. Those who kill Israelis will be hunted down and given earthly justice.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/hunting-the-terrorists-of-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There are foreign billionaires who are basically funding the American left and creating a surge of unprecedented strength."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=BI95WqjuEzw -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What’s the lesson for those who don’t want to see permanent war in the Middle East? The obvious conclusion is that the two forces of disruption—Iran and Hezbollah—need to be defeated. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/thank-you-for-the-hezbolla… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The failure of one effort to cauterize a suppurating wound ends up seven years later with an entire party in a state of sepsis—one of the two major political parties in the most important country on earth. @jpodhoretz
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/effingers-oppe… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Every time someone clips a scene and posts it, every time it gets shared and memed and set to a different soundtrack, that’s a market signal.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-long/spoilers-memes-moder… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss Jill Biden’s comments on her reaction to her husband’s disastrous debate performance and how they differ from her public statements at the time, and how this could help Kamala Harris in 2028.
Plus, the rise of Marco Rubio and what direction will the Republican Party take, and another check-in on the Iran ceasefire.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/a-jillion-little-pieces/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"For much of the Republican grassroots, scandal or controversy is actually a sign that you're fighting liberals and liberalism."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=mJIgDNPnzSk -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Our friend @continetti is back to discuss John Cornyn’s loss to Ken Paxton in the Texas primary and the republican chances to defeat James Talarico, the Park Slope coop voting to boycott Israeli products, New Jersey candidate Adam Hamawy’s terrorism ties, and the cultivation of anti-Israel sentiment in American society.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/paxton-americana/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Starmer has put the UK on a path to a bleak future.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-doom-loop-of-uk-anti-s… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To deface Churchill’s statue is not to deface a monument. It is to deface Britain itself—its greatest hero, its defining moral struggle, and the covenant that struggle sealed. There is no figure in British history whose claim to that title is more complete: no dukedom accepted, no comfort sought, no negotiation considered when every counsel of prudence pointed toward it. @Mike_Burke_UK
www.commentary.org/articles/mike-burke/britain-jews-betra… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
It’s possible to read this story in two ways. First, that the Athenians made a number of strategic mistakes and let their democratic institutions fall into disarray, or second, that they committed a series of offenses against heaven and were punished for them.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The Iranians are not agreeing to negotiate our victory at the negotiating table."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=BI95WqjuEzw -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There has always been a portion of the far left that’s implacably hostile to Israel.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/most-democrats… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Even two high-powered progressives on the outs can come together for a certain cause: Graham Platner and his Nazi tattoo. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-platner-has-done-to-t… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Jews were invited to describe the state of anti-Semitism in Australia, and simply by doing so they are then made to demonstrate the state of anti-Semitism in Australia in real time. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/a-plea-to-jews-dont-do-the… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
He is fighting for and alongside and with Jews. So anyone who, after all this time, continues to look at Donald Trump and see Hitler—well, that person can go straight to hell.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/effingers-oppe… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: We are back to discuss the long weekend’s rollercoaster news cycle regarding a forming peace deal with Iran that has yet to materialize, culminating in American strikes on Iranian assets in the Strait of Hormuz.
Plus, the leveraging of social media for political advertising, and John recommends the movie Tuner.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/on-again-off-again/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
You can rearrange the pieces all you want, but in the end Israelis are going to support taking out the threats they face. That means resolution, not cease-fire, in both Lebanon and Iran. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/what-democrats-and-america… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
One needs only to reference the New York Times or the scandal Kristof’s claims have kicked off, and voila: Lots of people in establishment media spaces are suddenly talking about imaginary Israeli monster dogs. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-enormous-blast-radius-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“There’s an orgy of antisemitism, an absolute, shameless orgy of antisemitism, overtaking the west,” Nemes declares.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-truth-about-the-entert… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In crucial early cases, Scalia was the lone dissenter. Even Scalia’s friend, Chief Justice William Rehnquist, who as a non–chief justice in the 1970s earned a reputation as the “Lone Ranger” for his punchy conservative solo dissents, was now sometimes writing or joining the majority opinions that Scalia criticized.
www.commentary.org/articles/adam-white/scalia-supreme-cou… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israel would like this to be rectified. The Arabs would not.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/rashida-tlaibs-nakba-denial/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
This is the architecture of deep, systemic betrayal. It is the same habit that is administering out of existence the last purpose-built synagogue of the East End of London.
www.commentary.org/articles/mike-burke/britain-jews-betra… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Given how many scandals were actually real, the false stories seemed entirely plausible. Even today, it is hard to sort out myth from reality, both of which had terrible consequences. Beevor has good reason to insist that Rasputin was not the empress’s lover, but what are we to make of a letter she sent him that read:
www.commentary.org/articles/gary-morson/rasputin-romanovs… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
That regional instability? Been funded and enabled for years by Qatar.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/dont-cry-for-qatar/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Jim Lovell took up the reading: “And God called the light Day, and the darkness he called Night. And the evening and the morning were the first day.” And with so many looking at an image of both the land and water that made up earthly existence, Frank Borman read that “God called the dry land Earth; and the gathering together of the waters called He Seas: and God saw that it was good.” He then concluded: “And from the crew of Apollo 8, we close with good night, good luck, a Merry Christmas—and God bless all of you, all of you on the good Earth.”
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/artemis-ii-h… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"All presidents have this kind of power . . . just others haven't exercised it as nakedly, as Trump exercises power in an incredibly naked fashion."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=sIoA6fz5Dzo -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Ahmadinejad becoming an Israeli asset . . . that is so mind-blowing that it goes beyond all reckoning."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ad2a7fBPYps -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Greene’s reputation among liberals suddenly began to change. “There was once a great president that the American people loved,” she wrote on June 24, two days after the launch of Operation Midnight Hammer. “He opposed Israel’s nuclear program. And then he was assassinated. I am for peace. I oppose war, including wars Israel wages. Should I feel that my life is in danger now too?” Greene apparently wasn’t all that afraid of being the target of an Israeli assassination attempt, because a few months later she was insinuating that Jeffrey Epstein was a Mossad agent.
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/far-right-far-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Political violence has crossed from being an occasional thing to something with which we are all too commonly familiar."
Watch the full episode featuring @NoahCRothman: www.youtube.com/watch?v=KZxfgmHi-TY -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
If Jewish Democrats aren’t going to resist having extremist anti-Semites representing their party, then virtually no one will.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/can-jewish-democrats-still… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Finally, it came down to this. The girl said, “It sounds like you want me to dumb down my writing so that you can believe a student wrote it.”
www.commentary.org/articles/orson-scott-card/artificial-i… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Abbas wants to be the model for future Arab moderates. His fellow Arab politicians don’t want to let him. This election will reveal who wins that battle.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-future-of-moderate-isr… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
People like Piker are not without power in this world, especially when their views are amplified.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/antisemitism-h… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If the blowback is coming already from the blockade, send the planes in and finish the job because the interest is piling up. Just get it done."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ad2a7fBPYps -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
No character in the book is more memorable than the family’s youngest member, Lily. She figures prominently in five stories, and her impending bat mitzvah prompts in her father the thoughts that give the book its title. With his ex-wife sitting next to him and Heather, the woman carrying his child, standing beside his chanting daughter—Heather is also Lily’s bat mitzvah tutor—Richard is haunted by the idea that his daughter’s haftarah passage from Isaiah is directed at him. It asks: “Can you cast off the wife of your youth?”
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-franciosi/allegra-goodman… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"The circumstances of the 2024 election were so comprehensively disastrous for the Democrats that a traditional political autopsy seems superfluous. It’s like trying to find the cause of death after someone’s entire house fell in on him. The self-evident cause is utter defenselessness against a sweeping catastrophe."
--from today's newsletter. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
What came forth from Gaza that day was a nightmare with few parallels in modern human history.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-laughing-monsters/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Those who consider themselves anti-Zionists are admitting they have a problem. They define their lives and their work and their play around opposition to a certain national population. Anti-Zionism is by definition an obsession, an antisocial affliction, a psychological condition.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-zionist-affliction/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Those who kill Israelis will be hunted down and given earthly justice. No one is allowed to get away with doing what these Palestinians did on October 7. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/hunting-the-terrorists-of-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
As America approaches its 250th birthday, I feel less anticipation than melancholy. Civic rituals are now parsed as partisan signals.
www.commentary.org/articles/robert-pondiscio/america-250-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Thursday, and our friend @continetti is back to discuss the ongoing fight over funding for the White House ballroom and the never-ending Iran ceasefire.
Plus, Matt recommends the documentary Marty, Life is Short, and John recommends the Broadway play Becky Shaw. -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
On 'Jewish Money'--and the attempt to shame Americans out of the political process by denigrating their work. www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/on-jewish-money-in-america…
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
Democrats were terribly distraught at the prospect of a white-supremacist, anti-Semitic takeover of our beautiful country. So distraught that nine years later, their chief strategy is attacking Jews, Jewish money, and Israel—and criticizing the Republican Party for failing to tolerate anti-Semitism.--from today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The message now is that the right is too cowardly to be bigoted. If you want to be bigoted, get over here. We'll show you how to hate Jews implicitly."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=sIoA6fz5Dzo -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Anything Jewish, whether related to Israel or not, is a trigger for anti-Semites. Western societies just happen to be at a place now where there’s always someone triggered by Jews being Jews. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-doom-loop-of-uk-anti-s… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"When he cast that vote for impeachment, he was crossing a line in Trump’s mind that you can’t uncross."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=j-DQf1VnzEo -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
While the world very clearly needs to be reminded as often as possible what the Palestinians of Gaza did on October 7, this time it should be presented with no universality. Hamas and its supporters all over the world have already tried to appropriate Israel’s suffering, as usual, by graverobbing the memory of the Holocaust.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/putting-october-7-on-trial/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Whereas Williams keeps a tight eye on the city, Thompson’s need for villainy has her widening the lens, starting with a subtitle that pins the “rebirth of white rage” on “the Reagan eighties.”
www.commentary.org/articles/nancy-rommelmann/bernie-goetz… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The attempt to make Jews in America self-conscious about their money is a smart tactic, because it hides its true target: Jewish inclusion in society.
And so American Jews should know what’s at stake for Jews and for America. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/on-jewish-money-in-america… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss Thomas Massie’s loss in the Kentucky primary and Trump prioritizing loyalty at the potential cost of election defeats.
Plus, actor Javier Bardem and director Laszlo Nemes trading comments on being pro-Palestinian in entertainment, the Islamic Center shooting in San Diego, and what it will take to rout out the disease of antisemitism.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/massie-exodus/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
There’s a default liberal assumption that whatever the extreme left’s tactics, the radicals deserve some grace because at least they’re trying to push things in the right direction. And because they’re trying to make things “better,” they can’t really be as bad as people are saying. That sentiment hardens into liberal denial.--From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
A very happy pub day to @NoahCRothman! Read this book! www.amazon.com/Blood-Progress-Century-Left-Wing-Violence/…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israel and the United States certainly won the conventional war from Day One, flying sortie after sortie into Iran with the confidence that only air superiority can offer. But the regime countered by launching an asymmetric economic war that soon had even some initial supporters of the war questioning its wisdom. With the short-lived cease-fire in early April having come to its conclusion after six days, Trump’s task is to end that economic war on favorable terms so that he can credibly declare victory not only on the battlefield but also in rendering harmless the enemy’s economic weaponry.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/us-victory-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Serious allegations—and there are few allegations more serious than the ones being alleged here—deserve heaps of evidence and careful scrutiny. The report delivered by the Israeli commission is a model of such investigation. The Times’s rumor mill is the opposite.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The desire for “real life” interactions is notable enough that McKinsey & Co. published a report this year about the growth of the “in-person experiences market,” with consumer research showing that Gen Z is far more likely to visit “immersive experiences” at museums and pop-up exhibits.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/gen-z-hungers… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Usually, what Nemes calls the “overclass of Hollywood” loves to portray itself as some courageous institution. But occasionally a smug buffoon like Javier Bardem will be so giddy with self-righteousness that he’ll reveal the truth. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-truth-about-the-entert… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In such a moral universe, the fact that individuals had the capacity to choose good or evil, life or death, was simply irrelevant.
www.commentary.org/articles/tal-fortgang/in-gods-image-we… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @NRO’s @NoahCRothman is back to celebrate the publication of his new book Blood and Progress and to discuss the press-credentialed Luigi Mangione fans outside his court proceedings and the underlying philosophy behind left wing support for violence.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Qatar contributes to any misery one might find in the Middle East but none of the progress. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/dont-cry-for-qatar/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Trump isn't a long game player, but he's marinated in the idea that it's good America wins, and these commies lose."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=1CkpEsU8Hgc -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
Much of what many Americans lament today was put in place by the Obama administration. It was 2008, not 2016, when the modern presidency became a cult of personality. And it was when party narrative first made a bid to overtake reality itself.--From today's newsletter
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"What if the story is that the ceasefire actually was bad for Trump’s poll numbers? Because the war is not over, but the war is not going on."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=j-DQf1VnzEo -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Is a root level of genuine patriotism a precondition for participation in our politics in 2026? The answer is unclear. But the fact that it is even in question is a poor sign for the health of a republic—which depends first and foremost on a pre-rational commitment to love of our shared political project.
www.commentary.org/articles/charles-fain-lehman/anti-amer… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The June issue of Commentary is now available.
This issue explores the betrayal of Britain’s Jews, how the Dems really feel about Israel, a mission of noble purpose in Nigeria, and much more.
With contributions from @Mike_Burke_UK, @jpodhoretz, @jkirchick, @ZoharAtkins, @SpencerKlavan, @michaelmrosen, @TeviTroy, and @rcbl.
Read on at commentary.org and subscribe at commentary.org/subscribe. -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
Rashida Tlaib's Nakba Denial
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/rashida-tlaibs-nakba-denial/
My latest on the self-sabotage of pro-Palestinian maximalists. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
As is always the case, an ideology that puts Israel’s harm first puts Palestinian welfare lower on the list, if it makes the list at all. And thus we have this year’s nakba resolution, a bizarre document that undercuts supposed “pro-Palestinian” advocacy. @SethAMandel
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To be for the people today, it is necessary to be like the people.
www.commentary.org/articles/clare-mchugh/queen-elizabeth-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Lammy and Starmer whipped up public anger at the Jews, and then they bent over backwards to appease the violent extremists to whom the government meekly ceded the streets.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jews-and-boos/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Monday, and we are joined by our friend @dansenor to discuss the looming election in Israel and the prospects of an Israeli government without Bibi Netanyahu, the signs that hostility might resume in Iran in light of ongoing Iranian intransigence, and Senator Bill Cassidy’s loss in the Louisiana primary.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/bye-bye-bibi/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"One of the world's most enduring communist regimes is about to collapse . . . 5 months, and Cuba's done.
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=1CkpEsU8Hgc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The draft was this great leveler . . . it had enormous virtues for the kind of social cohesion that we lack today."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=rBuRX_h3wVcThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
One person who did not pay, at least at first, was Goetz. “Gun tucked into his pants, he sprinted southbound down the tunnel, splashing through puddles as rats scurried away . . . ”
www.commentary.org/articles/nancy-rommelmann/bernie-goetz… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The “Jews who care” were the ones Abe Foxman, the most important and probably the most beloved American Jewish communal leader of his day, spoke for.
www.commentary.org/john-podhoretz/abe-foxman-1940-2026/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Against that background, the biblical claim that every person bears the divine image was an intellectual rupture and spurred an ethical upheaval. People were no longer avatars of a local deity, or symbols of a particular interest such as love or war, or mere representatives of the tribe into which they were born. They were animate manifestations of divinity itself and therefore “unique and irreplaceable,” to use Persico’s phrase. Justice would have to be done accordingly—in a way that corresponded to each individual’s capacity as a free agent.
www.commentary.org/articles/tal-fortgang/in-gods-image-we… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Though the queen voluntarily began paying income tax and capital gains tax in 1993, King Charles paid no inheritance tax—40 percent in the UK—on the fortune he inherited from his mother. Also, the royal household is currently exempted from Freedom of Information Act regulations, and Prince William has refused to reveal how much tax he pays on his sprawling Duchy of Cornwall holdings. “A period of painful disclosure lies ahead,” the Independent intoned in February.
www.commentary.org/articles/clare-mchugh/queen-elizabeth-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“Those whom God would destroy he first makes mad,” wrote Euripides. When a dynasty is to be ended, God makes them corrupt and stupid as well.
www.commentary.org/articles/gary-morson/rasputin-romanovs… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The views of the intelligence community are treated like infallible expert views when they're in fact totally fallible opinions."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=1rY7VcZMC-4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The anti-Zionist activists who started or popularized the rumors have made clear that there is no evidence in their favor.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/journalism-succumbs-to-its… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Like her earlier integrated collection, The Family Markowitz (1996), the book contains stories that can stand on their own. But 'This Is Not About Us' is a richer and more mature work both stylistically and thematically. Where the stories in the 1996 volume advance in a predictable, mostly linear fashion, those in her latest compose a beautiful mosaic, one that invites and rewards engagements with patterns established by individual characters.
www.commentary.org/articles/rob-franciosi/allegra-goodman… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Now that you mention it, I have noticed a distinct lack of nuance when it comes to differentiating between Zionists and the “good Jews.” As protesters wave Hezbollah flags, yell “we support Hamas,” and call Jews at a synagogue “pedophiles,” I worry about the lack of nuance, too.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The time it has taken Democratic Jewish figures to come around to the need to fight anti-Semitism within their own tent has left them forever playing catchup. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/can-jewish-democrats-still… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Friday, and contributing editor @EliLake is back to discuss the historical context of the Trump-Xi summit, the false air of permanence that surrounds authoritarian regimes, are Trump’s potential geopolitical successes worth his domestic policy issues, and Eli recommends Whiplash.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/the-summit-of-all-fears/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The @Commentary podcast audio today is delayed because of a server glitch. You might see it in your podcast feed but then when you click on it you may encounter a message that says it’s unavailable. We're working on it. It is, however, available on our YouTube channel if you just can’t take it! And, hey, subscribe to the channel to support us while you’re there. Visit: youtube.com/@commentarypodcast
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The episode is now live. If you still can't get it to play, try refreshing your podcast app.
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
What sticks with you about the video- and photo-documented Hamas sexual violence is 1) the amount of posthumous abuse and 2) the demonic laughter of the monsters trying to disfigure the genitalia of their many, many, many victims.
We live in dark times. www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-laughing-monsters/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Commentary Recommends
@CommentaryRec
May 14, @continetti recommends Biloxi Blues and @jpodhoretz recommends The Sunshine Boys
-
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"It's not a secret that America is in the throes of a major trust crisis. But that’s really half the story. Americans are at once militantly untrusting and hopelessly credulous. It all depends on whether the story they’re told supports or undermines their position." From today's newsletter.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Mansour Abbas's pragmatism is aimed at giving Israeli Arabs more of a role in national policymaking. He sees himself as a problem-solver and not a revolutionary. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-future-of-moderate-isr… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We are the energy fossil fuel superpower, and now we've added to our power Venezuela."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=rBuRX_h3wVc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"We are the energy fossil fuel superpower, and now we've added to our power Venezuela."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=rBuRX_h3wVc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The promotion of open debate and thoughtful nuance might be what truly offends the progressive Georgetown students the most.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/a-tale-of-two-commencement… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Trump likes to be unpredictable, but in war our allies need to be able to rely on us. Balancing the element of surprise with reliability to our friends is tricky business, and the administration failed to find that balance here. Hopefully the lesson has been learned.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The coddled “anti-colonialists” on university campuses have proved willing and able to defend any act, no matter how depraved, so long as it is for the cause. But even they cannot muster a defense of a rapist’s glee or a torturer’s joy. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-laughing-monsters/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"American targeting and Israeli targeting have achieved a level of almost supernatural accuracy."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=1rY7VcZMC-4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In these early stages of AI experimentation, the focus is on how it seems able to provide written and imagistic material indistinguishable from the work that can be produced by human hands and minds.
www.commentary.org/articles/orson-scott-card/artificial-i… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @continetti is back to discuss President Trump’s summit with Xi Jinping and the topics of Taiwan, Iran, EVs, and AI.
Plus, JD Vance’s Maine visit on the backdrop of Marco Rubio’s rising favorables, the importance of winning the Iran war to republican chances in 2028, and Matt recommends the movie Biloxi Blues.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/he-said-xi-said/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"You're not talking about some extremist leftist publication, you're talking about the Israeli mainstream . . . these are people who would rather slander our soldiers than see Netanyahu as prime minister."
Watch the full episode featuring @RuthieBlum of @JNS_org: -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israel and the United States certainly won the conventional war from Day One, flying sortie after sortie into Iran with the confidence that only air superiority can offer. But the regime countered by launching an asymmetric economic war that soon had even some initial supporters of the war questioning its wisdom. With the short-lived cease-fire in early April having come to its conclusion after six days, Trump’s task is to end that economic war on favorable terms so that he can credibly declare victory not only on the battlefield but also in rendering harmless the enemy’s economic weaponry.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/us-victory-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Here we have the reasons for hope and despair in one sentence. On the one hand, apparently British society needs to be told that the rule of law applies even if you don’t like the victim of a crime. On the other, at least someone in the judicial system is willing to say as much.
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
That’s why stores like IKEA and Target now sell vintage-looking handset telephones (which connect via Bluetooth to your mobile phone) to replicate the experience of talking on an old-fashioned land line. Brian Fass, a.k.a. “The Polaroid Guy,” has seen his business boom thanks to his Gen Z customers. He camps out in New York’s Central Park and for $20 will take a Polaroid picture of you. “It’s just so authentic,” one 19-year-old told the New York Post. “It’s nice to have a picture, a physical picture, rather than something on your phone,” a 23-year-old observed.
www.commentary.org/articles/christine-rosen/gen-z-hungers… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If I had to trade that for moving the embassy to Jerusalem and bombing Iran's nuclear program, I would take that trade."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_wjJEcxk-8 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
There is almost nothing in the world quite as campy as the Eurovision song contest, but instead of getting into character and enjoying the shtick, Europeans are whining year-round about the participation of Israelis. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-anti-zionist-affliction/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss an intelligence assessment cited by the New York Times claiming Iran’s military capabilities were not substantially damaged by the war, Thomas Massie’s primary woes, and the risks of a major American party centering its identity on antisemitism.
Plus, John remembers Abe Foxman.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/is-iran-still-strong/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The broadcast of Apollo 8 can be seen on YouTube. In an age when much of our contemporary culture is devoid of, or even hostile to, biblical themes, and when members of the “woke right” seek to sever any tie between Christians and the Hebraic tradition, the words of Apollo’s astronauts remind us of what was, undeniably, a profoundly American moment.
www.commentary.org/articles/meir-soloveichik/artemis-ii-h… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Abe Greenwald
@AbeGreenwald
"Accusing Jews of committing impossible crimes is the oldest, most primitive category of anti-Semitic propaganda. It takes us out of the realm of the human, no matter where we are on this planet."
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If you need a lesson in what the big lie is and how it works, we have it here in the pages of the New York Times."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=yGM2NWvFGmAThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Now the terrorists captured alive on October 7 will have their day in court for the whole world to see. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/putting-october-7-on-trial/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Israel did not invade a place called “Palestine” and take its land. It fought a defensive war against Jordan and won. “Palestinian land” is a concept of the future—if the Palestinians want it.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-palestinian-land-myth/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Reject the premise of every intifadist’s yammering. Reject the whataboutism. Most of all, reject the idea that the truth is in the middle. Hamasniks should never be coddled.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/lets-stop-pretending-that-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To the anti-Zionist collective, the truth is to be avoided like the plague, and therefore what is rewarded is not evidence but creativity and imagination. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-end-of-our-illusions/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
People like Piker are not without power in this world, especially when their views are amplified. As a voice in the most influential opinion precinct in the Western world, Klein is a gigantic megaphone. He represents what are now deemed acceptable views and, in so doing, advances those views from the acceptable to the respectable.
www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/antisemitism-h… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Mamdani himself seemed to get a boost during his campaign after he refused to denounce a slogan calling for the ethnic cleansing of Jews from the Middle East. Ocasio-Cortez’s obsession with anti-Jewish conspiracy theories hasn’t cost her anything. The aforementioned Ilhan Omar is holding her own. And Platner, to whom establishment and elected Democrats have flocked, is soaring.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/progressive-radicals-face-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The reason Iran doesn't yet have an operable nuclear weapon is because Israel has assassinated its nuclear scientists."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=z-2Cs5eMiMI -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @JNS_org’s @RuthieBlum joins us today to discuss three New York Times articles that point to a disturbing trend with regards to the paper’s coverage of Israel – Israel’s absence from a list of New York’s best restaurants, a piece on supposed Israeli manipulation of the Eurovision Song Contest, and Nicholas Kristof’s piece alleging Israel trained dogs to rape Palestinians.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/antisemitic-times/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The government’s responsibility here is not only to act but to stop stoking the anti-Zionist fires that incite some of the violence in the first place. Yet all it can manage are the occasional half-apologetic platitudes of what is and isn’t “acceptable” or representative of the real Britain. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/jews-and-boos/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"This blockade is costing the regime something like $430 million a day. And it's going to get worse."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_wjJEcxk-8 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
As you might expect, liberals once detested Greene (who resigned from Congress in January). The onetime owner of a CrossFit franchise, she was the target of constant derision and ridicule, an easily mockable personification of the die-hard MAGA voter. Five years ago, congressional Democrats voted to expel her for her previous expressions of support for political violence. In 2024, a routine hearing of the House Oversight Committee descended into farce when Greene alleged that Democratic Representative Jasmine Crockett, possibly the only member of Congress as obnoxious as Greene, was wearing “fake eyelashes.” Crockett responded by telling Greene that she had a “bleach-blonde, bad-built, butch body.”
www.commentary.org/articles/james-kirchick/far-right-far-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
He saw his mission and obligation in the defense of Jews against the scourge of anti-Semitism. If that anti-Semitism came from the right, he attacked it. If it came from the left, he attacked it. If it came from white people, he attacked it. If it came from black people, he attacked it. If it was hidden inside anti-Zionism, he attacked it. If it was hidden in conversations about rapacious capitalists, he attacked it. He was utterly consistent. His mission was his mission and he pursued it unfailingly.
@jpodhoretz
www.commentary.org/john-podhoretz/abe-foxman-1940-2026/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Bicentennial didn’t just teach me America’s history, it cemented me to it. Without fully realizing it, I was becoming a citizen, and an invested one.
www.commentary.org/articles/robert-pondiscio/america-250-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Democratic voters seem eager to reward their representatives for growing ever more vicious in their criticism of Amerikkka.
www.commentary.org/articles/charles-fain-lehman/anti-amer… -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Jonathan Schanzer
@JSchanzer
On The @Commentary Magazine Podcast w/ @jpodhoretz, I discussed how the rules-based international order we created is holding us back in Iran.
📺 Full episode here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgYlT-rkrHwThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
We talked about the passing of Abe Foxman on today's podcast. As discussed, among his many admirable qualities was his refusal to put ideology or partisanship above his mission: the survival of the Jewish people. May his memory be a blessing, truly. Give a listen:
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Monday, and @FDD’s @JSchanzer is back to discuss another confusing weekend in the Iran war with the trading of proposals for a deal, Senator Mark Kelly’s statement on the depletion of US munitions, the controversy over Trump’s gold statue at Doral, and the passing of longtime ADL director Abe Foxman.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/deal-or-no-deal-2/ -
Commentary Magazine reposted
Seth Mandel
@SethAMandel
The destruction of Western journalism was an inside job www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/journalism-succumbs-to-its…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Will Western journalism ever recover from its alliance with the machinery of Hamas propaganda?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/journalism-succumbs-to-its… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The West must wake up to the reality that its civic institutions have been heavily colonized by terror-linked zombie NGOs before those institutions have all been hollowed out and there’s nothing left to save.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-chilling-truth-behind-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: It’s Monday, and @FDD’s @JSchanzer is back to discuss another confusing weekend in the Iran war with the trading of proposals for a deal, Senator Mark Kelly’s statement on the depletion of US munitions, the controversy over Trump’s gold statue at Doral, and the passing of longtime ADL director Abe Foxman.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/deal-or-no-deal-2/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"If the US doesn't try to take out monsters now and then, that's the end of the world guaranteed."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=z-2Cs5eMiMI -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
She’s a fictional creation. She isn’t real. But the very thought of a Jane, the possibility of a Jane in the real world, has become perhaps the consuming obsession, for good or ill, of the present moment.
www.commentary.org/articles/orson-scott-card/artificial-i… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To suggest that Herzog is some kind of populist warmongering provocateur is as wrong as wrong can be. That is why these scholars and students of history should have been skeptical right off the bat. Instead, they have joined in sloppy character slander of the president of the Jewish state. It is a poor way to emerge from the shelves and stacks into the harsh light of the world, where the Jewish people will need them to be far more discerning.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/infighting-over-israel-at-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Trump doesn’t just want to win on both the conventional and asymmetric fronts. He wants a full Iranian surrender.
www.commentary.org/articles/jonathan-schanzer/us-victory-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
To be sure, the Bicentennial was also relentlessly commercial—and not always in flattering ways. Much of it was kitschy, crass, and transparently designed to separate Americans from their money. 7UP issued 50 state-themed soda cans designed to be collected and stacked to create a portrait of Uncle Sam. Fast-food chains sold commemorative glassware. Airlines painted their planes red, white, and blue. Commemorative coins, stamps, mugs, plates, and souvenirs flooded American homes. The commercialization didn’t ennoble the moment—but it didn’t poison it, either.
www.commentary.org/articles/robert-pondiscio/america-250-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The only way to ensure the perpetual opening of the Strait of Hormuz is regime change in Iran."
Watch the full episode at the link in bio. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Trump is struggling with the system that he inherited . . . he doesn't know how to escalate in ways that won't harm us."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgYlT-rkrHw -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The anti-Israel movement on campus has targeted not just Hillels but kosher restaurants and Chabad Houses and synagogues—there is no real attempt anymore to hide their true mission, which is to target Jews simply for being Jews. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-chilling-truth-behind-… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we are joined by @RoyKAltman to discuss his new book, Israel on Trial, which addresses claims against Israel from a legal standpoint.
Plus, the indictments against Anthony Fauci’s deputy and James Comey.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/judging-israel/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: @CharlesFLehman of the @ManhattanInst joins us this Friday to discuss the New York Times interview with Hasan Piker and Jia Tolentino and his lead article in Commentary’s May issue, Anti-Americanism Is a Disease.
www.commentary.org/noam-blum/robbin-hood/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The May issue of Commentary is now available.
This issue explores the rise of anti-Americanism on both the Left and Right, the significance of America’s 250th anniversary, the mainstreaming of Hasan Piker, the unfounded fear of AI, and much more.
With contributions from @CharlesFLehman, @rpondiscio, @jpodhoretz, @jkirchick, @JSchanzer, @orsonscottcard, @NancyRomm, @tal_fortgang.
Read on at commentary.org and subscribe at commentary.org/subscribe. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: Today we discuss 2028 democratic hopefuls Gavin Newsom and Ruben Gallego ratcheting up their anti-Israel rhetoric.
@JNS_org’s @RuthieBlum then joins us from Tel-Aviv to discuss the reality of bomb shelters and life under the shadow of Iranian attacks and the battle for American public opinion.
Plus, John recommends the movie Sovereign.
www.commentary.org/nblumcommentary-org/courting-anti-zion… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Outside of Fox, every other news programming on offer is interchangeable. That is the problem."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=ydRCp9OvSyA -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"Israel is doing the regime change. We’re there to take out the ballistic missiles and nuclear program."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkHOjrQjaz4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
EMERGENCY POD: War With Iran
We are joined by @FDD’s @JSchanzer and @JNS_org’s @RuthieBlum from Tel-Aviv to discuss the Israeli and American attacks on Iran, the news that Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei was killed, and what this means for the future of the country and the region. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The public’s willingness to believe the worst about Jews is not new, and it’s not an accident. Those who have participated in the “genocide” Big Lie have not made an honest mistake. A mistake, perhaps—but not an honest one.
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/hamas-debunks-the-genocide… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Norman Podhoretz we all know and admire made it because of his love of the written word, the sheer power of his mind, and, most important, his undaunted courage for standing against the prevailing wisdom, especially among the intelligentsia.
www.commentary.org/articles/roger-hertog/norman-podhoretz… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The story of a friendship, from soup to nuts, is told in those eloquent, rueful sentences, in their images and feeling, with all hints of sentimentality dashed at the end by a perfect kicker.
www.commentary.org/articles/andrew-ferguson/norman-podhor… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The challenge with AI isn't just the potential of existential risk . . . but understanding what we choose to remain human in doing."
Watch the full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=YBbnNQCn9Cc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
@jpodhoretz remembers Norman Podhoretz and his enduring patriotism. www.commentary.org/articles/john-podhoretz/norman-podhore…
-
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"There are more people living in Gaza at the end of 2026 than there were on October 6, 2023. That’s some genocide."
Watch & subscribe to the Commentary Magazine Podcast: www.youtube.com/watch?v=qB4DBM3gxp4 -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The February issue of Commentary is now available.
This issue honors the life and legacy of Norman Podhoretz, explores society’s current state of moral and political apathy, Trump and Venezuela, the NVIDIA deal, and much more.
With contributions from former U.S. Special Representative for Venezuela Elliott Abrams, @jpodhoretz, @todlindberg, @dpletka, @slsatel, and @NaomiSRiley.
Read on at commentary.org and subscribe at commentary.org/subscribe. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Sunstein’s confusion extends beyond personal liberty to economic freedom.
www.commentary.org/articles/mworonof/on-liberalism-cass-s… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Although the anti-Israel activist world was hoping for mass starvation, those of us who aren’t monsters are very happy that there was no famine in Gaza. Pay attention to those who dispute this and those who show their disappointment. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/closing-the-book-on-genoci… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
LISTEN: COMMENTARY contributing editor @JSchanzer joins the podcast to discuss his innovative plan for Israel to stop playing Hamas’s game and bring the war in Gaza to a victorious end.
www.commentary.org/abe-greenwald/a-fresh-approach-to-gaza/ -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The launch of the GHF should have been treated as a major step toward ending the war and prioritizing the wellbeing of Gazans over that of Hamas. Instead, the fact that GHF excluded Hamas was treated as a drawback. @SethAMandel
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/the-medias-war-on-the-gaza… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Think of it this way: In all the wars of the past two centuries—the First and Second World Wars, Korea and Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan, Ukraine—there has never been a case in which civilians were absolutely forbidden to flee the battlefields. Until Gaza.
www.commentary.org/articles/elliott-abrams/nobody-wants-g… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Chris Stirewalt joins the podcast today to discuss Donald Trump’s efforts to dominate the news and whether they are simply his way or a canny strategy to advance his interests. @ChrisStirewalt
www.commentary.org/john-podhoretz/why-is-trump-still-hold… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The February issue of Commentary is now available.
Featuring @NoahCRothman, @continetti, @NaomiSRiley, Wilfred M. McClay, examining left-wing political violence, America's exceptional democracy, the tradwife trend, and much more.
Read and subscribe at commentary.org. -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Host of the must-watch The Hill Sunday show, @ChrisStirewalt, joins us to discuss how polls work at this late date and whether they do, what poll herding is, and whether we can trust the data we’re seeing.
www.commentary.org/john-podhoretz/the-stirewalt-closing-a… -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
In Morning After the Revolution, "@NellieBowles funny and sobering takedown of the 'New Progressive' movement is also an account of her own disillusionment with said movement."
Read Rick Marin's full review 👉 lttr.ai/AUMYZ
#progressives #woke #newyorktimes -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"As @johanknorberg highlights, economic freedom is inherently valuable, constituting an end in itself. The essential feature of capitalism is that it enables people to interact voluntarily."
Read the full review of The Capitalist Manifesto 👉 lttr.ai/ATNmc -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The Capitalist Manifesto: Why the Global Free Market Will Save the World by @johanknorberg "makes the definitive case for capitalism and repudiates common arguments offered against the system."
Read more 👉 lttr.ai/AQPEW -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
"The need for a full-throated defense of free markets has increased. @johanknorberg meets this need with his most recent book, The Capitalist Manifesto: Why the Global Free Market Will Save the World."
Read more 👉 lttr.ai/AQxoD
#capitalism #economy #freemarkets -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
“Ewen Montagu took special pride in outwitting Hitler in light of his family’s background. 'Joy of joys to anyone, and particularly a Jew, the satisfaction of knowing they had directly and specifically fooled that monster,' he once wrote.”
@MedvedSHOW👉 lttr.ai/yyxx -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
@MedvedSHOW remembers the real Ewen Montagu.
Read more ▸ lttr.ai/ys5f
#history #wwii #british #jews #operationmincemeat -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
With everything else going on in the world, the human-rights movement—now fully aligned with the boycott, divest, and sanction (BDS) movement—still places Israel at the top of the international human-rights agenda.
Read more from @danilewitzesq 👉 lttr.ai/v1bu -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The unmistakable yearning for good-bad-old-days may help lead the Academy to establish a more coherent connection this year between the best of Hollywood's present work and the still resonant echoes of its glorious past.
Read more from @MedvedSHOW: lttr.ai/t2Pu -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
The First Limbaughs
@MedvedSHOW reviews @PMatzko's The Radio Right
👉 lttr.ai/kt9w
#conservative #radio #history #rushlimbaugh #carlmcintire -
Commentary Magazine
@Commentary
Can Trump Come Back?
By @MedvedSHOW 👉 lttr.ai/g9Nx
#presidents #ushistory #donaldtrump


























































































































