You don’t happen to have any door knocking needs this weekend? Asking for a friend obviously.
Craig Renney
Craig Renney (born 1979) is a New Zealand economist and politician. He was the Labour Party candidate in Wellington Bays for the 2026 general election. Based on preliminary results, he has won the electorate, but the results may change with the final vote count expected for 27 November. More on Wikipedia
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Delighted to be at Dr. Ayesha Verrall’s campaign launch today. Ayesha is an MP will get things done for Wellington, and knows how to represent everyone in our City. We have 84 days until we can get rid of this one term government, and start looking after people again.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Delighted to stand with @NZPSA and Deb, who works for Nurse Maude. She is one of 250 care workers on strike today, because their employer wants to cut sick leave, and has offered no pay deal. Deb & other care workers deserve decent pay, decent conditions, and our total support.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Get where you're going for less with Labour. $20 a week is the most you'll pay for public transport. This package would save a typical 2-commuter household nearly $2,500 a year in Wellington Bays/Rongotai. No paperwork, just real cost of living support for you and your family
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Labour stands with public servants, public service unions, and the services we all need. 167 days to make this a one-term government and turn New Zealand around
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
With more rain coming for Wellington, please look out for each other over the next few days. Stay safe, stay out of flood water, & follow emergency services advice.
Have a look at the WREMO & Wellington City Council websites:
www.facebook.com/WREMOnz/
www.facebook.com/wellingtoncitycouncil/ -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Child poverty data from Stats NZ out today. All political parties except Act agreed to the Child Poverty Reduction Act 2018, creating legally mandated targets for child poverty reduction. Right now, we are missing even the looser targets the government has set. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Material poverty is particularly bad for tamariki Maori (25.1%) and Pacific children (31%). Material poverty is nearly double the rate for disabled children (26.9%) as against 14.3% for the general population. None of these indicators is improving fast enough.
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This is what happens if you cut the minimum wage in real terms year after year. This is what happens if you spend more time kicking people out of housing rather than building it. This is what happens when you care more about cruise ship passengers than Kiwis.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We need to do better than this. For years we made bipartisan progress on tackling something that really matters. Children's futures are blighted by child poverty - something beyond their control. There can be fewer things more fundamental to the purpose of government than this.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Prices for basics are rising again at a rate much faster than wages, new data from Stats NZ shows. 70% of workers got a pay rise less than 3% last year and 44% got no pay rise at all. Food prices rose 4.6% overall, with the price of white bread rising 58% this year. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
For households on the lowest incomes, annual inflation is 3.4%. For pensioners, its 3.8%. For the richest its 1.2%. The minimum wage goes up by less than inflation for 3 consecutive years in 26. That laser-like focus on the cost of living seems to be pointing at the wrong people
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If you think that life is getting harder, not easier, you aren't alone. Record numbers of people want work and can't get it. Highest unemployment in 10 years. More cuts signalled at the Budget in front of us. Do you feel back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I’m here at the release of the Salvation Army State of the Nation for 2026. It’s a portrait of the problems facing Aotearoa, and how we are doing in tackling them. Many of the problems we face have worsened over the past two years. A 🧵
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
On nearly every measure our measures of the labour market have fallen. The numbers of people needing help just getting the basics has increased. It’s getting harder - especially if you are poor - just to get by
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The number of children living in poverty is growing and troublingly, the number of children living in material poverty has now reached 156,600. The number of children referred for possible child abuse or neglect requiring further action increased 13% this year to 44,532
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Drug consumption has rocketed over the past two years. Meth use has nearly doubled during that time. Support for people affected by drug abuse needs more support given this weight of consumption.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Charm Skinner, who works for the Salvation Army, reminded us that “in all this data, these are the real lived experiences of whānau”. We have choices ahead at the next election, about how to tackle these problems. Recent decisions have taken us here. Let’s make better choices.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
New unemployment data from Stats NZ today, showing the impact of an economy that isn't working. An additional 5,000 people became unemployed during the quarter, rising to levels last seen in 2015. 164,000 people are now unemployed, up 39,000 in just 2 years. A🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There has been a fall in filled jobs in 11 of 16 sectors over the past two years. This includes manufacturing, construction, IT & telecoms, professional, scientific, technical & admin. Forestry & mining. Wholesale Trade. The fall in employment has been broad-based.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If there is a recovery going on in the economy, it's not happening for working people. The cost of living is rising again. Work is harder to find. A tax cut doesn't help you if you don't have work. We need a real plan from the government, not another slogan.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Stats NZ has put Household Living Price Index data - showing how the cost of living is affecting different households. The cost of living has nearly stalled if you have a high income (1.2%). The poorest have a household inflation rate (3.4%) nearly 3 times the rate of the richest
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Pensioners face an even higher rate of inflation at 3.8% annual change. Maybe not the right time for Treasury to be examining whether to be means-testing the Winter Energy Payment is it?
www.nzherald.co.nz/business/economy/treasury-boss-iain-re…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This data shows once again the uneven choices getting "back on track". Tax cuts tilted to those with higher incomes and higher assets. Wages stalling, and higher price rises for the poorest. Everything we do in economics is a choice. Let’s choose better than this.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
@BarbEdmondsMana today in FEC asked why GDP for 2026 keeps falling. The data from Treasury is clear - forecasts have fallen at every update year - down $14.4bn in just 2 years. Perhaps insanity really is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
But as the Minister of Finance told us, we shouldn't take unemployment personally. So is it working for the Crown accounts? Er no - the OBEGAL deficit forecast for 25/26 has increased at every update. Turns out that totally unfunded tax cuts can be quite expensive!
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Mark it in your calendar - Budget is on 28 May. If things get a tiny bit better then, it's only because in 2 short years they got so much worse. Cuts to essential public services. Record out-migration of Kiwis. Failing child poverty. Let's make this a one-term government.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data released by Stats NZ today shows that the cost of living rose at its fastest rate for 18 months. Prices rose for 80% of items in the CPI basket, meaning growth in prices was broad-based. Minimum wage workers are now facing a 3rd year of real terms cuts in wages. A thread
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
68% of workers across the economy are facing another year of real terms pay cuts under this government. When last measured, annual household inflation was running 2.7 times faster for the lowest income New Zealanders, than for the highest income earners
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
RBNZ had annual inflation forecast at 2.7% this quarter, & Treasury forecast at 2.9%. This comfortably beat both estimates. The worry is RBNZ & TSY are basing their economic forecasts on big falls in inflation from here. There is little in this data to support that assumption
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Workers need wage increases, not tax cuts for tobacco companies, landlords, and big businesses. The government should settle its pay disputes so that essential workers don't see their pay fall. If the economy is improving, but working people aren’t feeling any relief.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Prime Minister spent longer managing his Spotify Playlists than writing that speech. Nothing new, nothing to help manage growing unemployment, more cuts signaled to government investment. That wasn't a State of the Nation - it was asking people to forget the past two years.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I have had a look at these economic 'green shoots' ahead of the Prime Minister's State of the Nation Speech on Monday.
The data tells us that we have spent two years regressing. Let’s not make it another 4 years by following the same plan.
More at: craigrenney.substack.com/p/the-recovery-you-want-has-been… -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
NBR reports the Min. of Finance saying a "Stronger economy will help the Government’s books". www.nbr.co.nz/politics/stronger-economy-will-help-the-gov…
The chart (from @labourcartel) might explain the government's current situation. Something happened in late 2023 and things have got worse since. -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data released today shows that for all the talk of green shoots, the economy hasn’t grown at all in 2 years. Unemployment is up, & the cost of living is still rising for middle and low-income New Zealanders. The GDP increase today simply balances out the fall previously. A Thread
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The economy is flatlining, and claims of 2025 being the year of growth aren't being realised. Growth is in unemployment, & numbers of New Zealanders leaving the country. September per capita GDP has fallen for 2 years - $1,593 worse than it was at the start of this government
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This data shows there is no plan to deliver growth. The government is looking at more cuts at the next Budget. We have record numbers of Kiwis on benefits. Its time for a different economic approach - before working people and their families face another year of drift and decline
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
In the house today, Nicola Willis said that in my recent book I thought the debt limit for the government should be 80-90% of GDP. As is clear in the book - that is the Treasury's position, not mine. See P.14 of www.treasury.govt.nz/sites/default/files/2022-05/guide-an…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The book states:
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
At no point in time in the book do I give a debt to GDP limit recommendation - I just point out the Treasury analysis and other interpretations. Could @NicolaWillisMP please correct the record?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
HYEFU shows that the OBEGAL deficit is no longer in the same postcode as the National Party Fiscal Plan. We never get close to the surplus being promised - to the tune of -$48bn across the period to 2027/28
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
HYEFU data today showed that unemployment is forecast to stay much higher than forecast by Treasury at the last election. There will be 76,000 more people on jobseekers by 2027. Wages going up by less every year than forecast at the last election.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Just catching up with the HYEFU data today - but the data looks grim pretty much across the board. One data point stood out to me - the economy will be cumulatively $28.3bn smaller at the next election than predicted by Treasury at the last election.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Congratulations to @Unions_Welly on the opening of the ‘front door to the union movement’ - resource centre and community & union organising space in Wellington Trades Hall. Come and talk to the lovely people here on Vivian Street about worker rights and organising.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Today the government announced that the minimum wage will rise by 2% in April 2026. On current forecasts this will represent the 3rd successive year in which minimum wage workers will face a real terms cut in pay. Over the past 3 years full time workers are $4,184 worse off. A 🧵
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Using Reserve Bank CPI data & forecasts, the full time minimum wage should be $51,519 a year in April. It will instead be $49,816 - $1,703 less. The chart below shows how the minimum wage has lagged inflation every year of this government. Each one of those changes is a choice
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Minister Van Velden claims in her press release that "This new rate will benefit around 122,500 working New Zealanders". Currently those workers are losing money not benefitting. The government will pay more in benefits and welfare as well, so taxpayers lose too.
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Minister says that it's been a "tough time to do business". She should try being on the minimum wage after 3 years of real term cuts. Also can she have a word with the Minister of Finance and stop making it a more difficult time to be in business please?
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Government's actions show it's committed to making working people pay the price of its economic decisions. Jobs are down and the economy is smaller than at the election. No cost of living relief for those on low incomes. Do you feel back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data out today on the economy ahead of the GDP reading next week. It’s a mixed bag – Profits up for firms but not wages. Some sectors seeing growth, but parts of the private sector are smaller than at the election. This isn’t broad-based growth - we’ve just stopped falling. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Young people are bearing the brunt of the poor economy. There are 59,427 fewer 15-29 year olds filling jobs than 2 years ago. The fastest growth in employment is for those aged 65+ (up by 6.7%.) This reflects the fact that increasing numbers of older are working to make ends meet
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
So some bits of the economy are growing – Great! But sales are behind Sept 2023 in real terms. Profits are up, but wages are down in real terms. Jobs are disappearing. GDP will likely rise next week, but workers aren’t seeing any benefit. They don't feel back on track yet.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Here at a packed meeting at the Basin Reserve to talk about the SH1 changes. At $3.8bn it’s a lot money - and NZTA is talking about tolling, a regional fuel levy, and a levy on your rates. We need a solution to traffic, but Wellington also needs a fair deal.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
NZTA put out a very redacted report on the proposed changes to SH1. What it shows is that the likely cost of the package will be borne by Wellingtonians, regardless of whether they use the roads. Wellington does need new infrastructure, but it also needs a fair deal. A🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The amount that the toll would charge, how, & when, is all redacted. We also have no idea how much traffic will be moved from the tolled road to ‘free’ roads meaning that some neighbourhoods will likely have huge new volumes of traffic that their roads were never designed to take
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We can’t pretend that Wellington doesn’t need investment & new transport infrastructure. People are sat in their cars in traffic today and they need a solution. Wellington needs to grow, but it also needs a fair deal - not this half-baked plan. Wellingtonians deserve better.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Is the government so broke that it will allow "at least three years of ageing Interislander ferries plying the notorious stretch of water with no viable rescue vessel if things go wrong"? www.thepost.co.nz/nz-news/360897749/government-confirms-c… 1/3
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
"The minister also noted most recorded boating incidents happened outside of Cook Strait". Yep - Just like a few days ago when the existing tug towed an oil and chemical tanker off the coast of Stewart Island back to the mainland 2/3 www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/573216/stricken-oil-and-chemi…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Kaitiaki, The Connemara, and the Aratere have all lost power, been grounded, and had to be towed back into port since 2023. New ferries aren't here until 2029 - and the risk is more than just ferries - its every cargo vessel. All to save $9m. Are we back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I’m delighted to announce I'm standing as the Labour candidate in Wellington Bays/Rongotai in 2026. I'm thrilled to fight for better jobs, housing, and health services in our community. Look in the bio to donate, volunteer, and help us deliver a better government next year.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Minimum Wage increased 1.5% this year. Data today from Stats NZ shows annual increases of:
- Food prices up 4.7%
- Fruit up 11%
- Beef up 17.4%, Lamb up 32.2%
- Bread up 11.4%
- Cheese up 14.8%
- Eggs up 16.2%
- Electricity up 11.8%
Laser focussed on the cost of living -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Good News Alert 🚨
@EtuUnion and @workersfirstnz unions won their case in the Supreme Court against Uber - meaning the court found some workers to be employees rather than contractors. Opening the door to more workers being able to claim their rights!
www.courtsofnz.govt.nz/assets/cases/2025/2025-NZSC-162.pdf -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Migration data from Stats NZ today with 72,700 New Zealand citizens leaving in the year to Sept 2025 – one every 7 minutes & 22 seconds. It’s improved marginally, but its way behind where it should be on Treasury forecasts. That creates a $1bn tax gap against forecast. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Where are they going to? 58% of migrant departures of New Zealand citizens went to Australia. Going to a country with Fair Pay Agreements, a growing economy, low energy prices, and a capital gains taxation system. For some reason that doesn’t seem to so be unpopular.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
So while there is a tiny improvement in the data , we still have a record annual outflow of NZ Citizens for a September month. Young people are taking with them all the skills, talent, and investment we as New Zealanders have provided. Are we back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
A quick note to those believing we are doing better than forecast at the election:
Blue line is jobseeker forecast at PREFU
Orange line is Budget 25 forecast
Green line - MSD actual data.
18,000 more people on Jobseekers than forecast this year & getting worse at every update -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
In episode 27 of Locked Out with Craig Renney, we take a look at the recent labour market data, and look at what’s happening with unemployment, underemployment, and wages. Who is losing, and is anyone winning right now? Hint - it's unlikely to be you. www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0Exfr63T_4&list=PLKzyMX9pCGMvQ6O…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Thanks Minister - you and the other National Party accounts retweeting this have got the message that there is the highest number of unemployed people since 1994 out to an extra 30,000 views and rising. Real wage cuts. 39k fewer full time jobs. Well done! 👍
Simeon Brown
@SimeonBrownMP
Is this the same person?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Unemployment reached a 9 year of 5.3%. The labour market took another turn for the worse - unemployment growing, underemployment growing, fewer hours being worked, and wages are not keeping up with inflation. This data is another sign the economy is not working. A thread
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Wages are falling behind the cost of living, and the government’s response is to cut the real value of the minimum wage, and ask essential workers like Doctors, Nurses, Teachers, & Fire Fighters to take another real pay cut. Its dangerously out of touch with the reality right now
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This government promised to get the economy back on track, & tackle the cost of living. On both measures its failing. Working New Zealanders & their families are hurting – and the promised recovery keeps being pushed back. New Zealand needs a plan – not promises of green shoots
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
On Morning Report today Ingrid said "Should we say green shoots?" in response to a tiny lift in MBIE job ads. Anything that shows a better labour market should be welcomed - but is that really what's going on? The honest answer is not really - job ads are down 30% in 2 years. A🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
With 400,000 people wanting more work and not being able to get it - small shifts in job ads won't cut it. There are 36,309 more people on Jobseeker over the past two years (217,818 in Sep 2025), and the only plan is to take it away from 18/19 year olds.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Tomorrow we get labour market data. Expect some people to point to the job ad data as a sign that the 'worst is behind us'. It's not - not for the hundreds of thousands of New Zealanders needing work. We aren't 'back on track' and this data doesn't change that.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Filled jobs out this week - and the number of filled jobs went up - Whoop! That's great news. Only 45,692 jobs to go until we are back to where we were at the election.
Something happened in November 2023, and jobs started to fall.... -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The CTU is releasing the latest policy on its programme for the next election - a New Deal for Workers. Fair Pay Agreements. Preventing workers from being forced to be contractors, when they are really employees. Simplifying access to
Unions. More at: union.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2025/10/RIAT-ER-policy-Oc… -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Labour is proposing to create a Capital Gain Tax on property - excluding farms and the family home. That income will help make GP visits free for the majority of people. Is that a better policy than continuing tax-free profits on say someone's seventh property? Absolutely. A🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The proposed CGT doesn't apply to Kiwisaver investments - meaning savers will be more incentivised to save for the long-run rather than for short-term gain. Over time income from a CGT builds - meaning more money to support health as the population ages and has higher needs.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Is the proposed CGT perfect? No - no taxation system anywhere in the world is perfect. Would the proposed CGT improve the current situation in NZ? Categorically. There is a huge job needed to repair the damage of National's reckless and unfunded tax giveaways.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I never thought that I would see the day when the Public Service Commission was used as an attack arm of the government. National Party polling must be telling them how popular the strikes are, and how unpopular they are. They are afraid. www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/576537/public-service-commis…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Nicola Willis “I always take pause to celebrate that since our government came to office inflation has returned to normal levels”. The cost of living increased 3% when wages are up 2.4%. The government’s laser-like focus on the cost of living should have gone to Specsavers. A🧵
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The prices of things that New Zealanders can’t avoid is rising quickly, putting more stress on already overstretched budgets. Electricity prices are up 11.3%. Gas prices up 15%. Fruit and veg prices up 7.5%. Contents insurance up 9.3%. Going to the GP costs 10.3% more.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Rents are still rising faster than wage inflation (2.6% vs 2.4%) –often the biggest cost working families face. Cuts to government investment, esp. water infrastructure, has helped drive higher rates. Electricity prices are rising at the fastest rate since the late 1980’s
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
At a time when the government is taking away jobseeker benefits from 18- & 19-year-olds, Stats NZ recorded a 22.6% increase in the cost of tertiary education. The government has halved support for apprentices. It is another symbol of a government that is out of touch
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Both public and private sector wage inflation is rising by less than 3%. All workers are now falling behind. Government proposed pay deals would almost certainly make that worse. Workers shouldn’t see living standards fall even further than they have under this government.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Episode 25 of Locked Out with Craig Renney looks at the singularly most idiotic policy launched yet by the government. Visible from space levels of moronic. Have watch now 😄
youtu.be/8aTWMV6ULIc -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
GOOD NEWS ALERT 🚨
Today the government relented to pressure from the Living Wage Movement and retained the requirement for contracted workers to be paid at least the Living Wage rate in Government Contracts. Around 5,000 workers will likely benefit from this decisionPost not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It’s clear that someone around the Cabinet Table could see that cutting the wages of some of the lowest paid workers in the country is not a way to build a more prosperous economy, and we should thank them. More of their voice is needed to prevent other harmful reform.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The decision is a demonstration of the organising power of trade unions, charities, NGO's and the wider Living Wage movement. We should celebrate their victory and the lasting good it will achieve for thousands of households in New Zealand.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Reserve Bank has cut the official cash rate by 0.5%. That sounds great. But banks only cut interest rates that much when the economy is in trouble - and not when things are going well. This cut is a sign of economic weakness, not strength. A 😄🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There is also a risk that in the short run we will be driving higher inflation. A lower OCR means a lower NZ$. That likely means higher petrol prices and higher imported food, energy, and goods pricing. That will put further pressure on inflation- likely to breach 3% soon.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Overall, this cut signals how far we have fallen. Remember that we were supposed to have recovered by now and growth was supposed to have returned. It hasn’t, the policy mix of the government likely makes growth harder. Back on track? More like off the rails.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Sometimes a policy is so stupid it makes you question the very fabric of reality. Decisions so fabulously, almost wantonly dumb, you wonder if we actually live in a simulation. Welcome to the world of removing Jobseeker Support for 18- and 19-year-olds. craigrenney.substack.com/p/a-small-wrinkle-in-the-jobseeker
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The government has announced that 18/19 year olds, who live in a household where the parents earn $65,529 or more can't claim jobseekers. If both parents work 27 hours on the minimum wage - $634 a week - they will be expected to now financially support their adult offspring.
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The government has a target to reduce the number of people on jobseekers by 50k. I assume that they have announced that they will not be making that target by simply reducing the number of people who can access it? Or like child poverty stats will they cheat their way to a win?
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This is a policy with no basis in any analysis. It's designed to look tough. It actually makes them look thoughtless and out of touch. Its arbitrary, mean, and simply designed to disguise the fact that the government is failing young people. Is this being back on track?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
20 Economists have penned an open letter to the Prime Minister and Minister of Finance - asking for change. The contents and signatories to the letter are at: craigrenney.substack.com/p/open-letter-to-prime-minister-and
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Ministers reply to our letter - and further reporting is here: www.thepost.co.nz/nz-news/360842383/not-sound-economics-2…
-
Craig Renney reposted
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The CTU has today released its report on electricity in New Zealand. We are calling for electricity generators to be brought back into public ownership - and to recognise electricity for what it really is - a public utility not just a source of profit. 🧵 www.reimagineaotearoa.nz/publicly_owned_electricity
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If generators chose to invest their returns in new generation, rather than profit, that would help lower electricity costs. We need to make sure that vulnerable people can afford to put the heating on when they need it – not just when the electricity market says it’s okay.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The CTU is calling on political parties to support communities, and support the economy, by adopting this policy. We need to stop making the same mistake - in believing that more market-based solutions will solve a problem created by the electricity market itself.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Monthly employment data - and there are 4,814 more jobs than this time last month! Whoop. Only 42,746 to go to get us to where we were at the last election. 62 jobs lost every single day of this government - one roughly every 23 minutes. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We broke the 20,000 barrier for construction, with 21,043 fewer filled jobs since the election. Retail (down 13,952) Manufacturing (down 11,566) Accom & Food (down 10,793). Professional, Scientific, and Technical (down 9,304).
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This is a set of data that some might use to suggest 'green shoots' in the economy. It simply serves to show far we have fallen. At the current rate of growth it will take us until the next election to gain back all the jobs lost since the election. Are we back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
#nzpol with @NZHerald's Mood of the Boardroom showing that even NZ’s executive suite prefer Barbara Edmonds over Nicola Willis, we ask why is the New Zealand economy so bad, and what needs to change to improve it? Watch Locked Out ep:23 now youtu.be/5HnB64l16co
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Do we have to do this all the time?
www.beehive.govt.nz/release/20-million-boost-ed-staffing
It’s not new funding. “the initiative will be funded from Health New Zealand’s baseline”. So it’s actually being cut from somewhere else.
We already underfunded the health system at the Budget. This is a further cutPost not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Importantly, the Minister states “Hospitals will be able to recruit additional doctors, nurses, and support staff” with this money. I’m assuming that will only be on nine month contracts as that is all the funding that is available. Is that really solving the problem?
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Rather than pretend $20m is going to make any difference (it represents 0.06% of health funding), the Minister could recognise the government underfunded health to begin with. He could pay nurses and doctors properly - rather than fight them.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This is not good policy, nor targeted spending. It’s just a press release trying to distract people from the very real problems in health. Our health system needs real solutions and real funding - to support health workers. Not more spin.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Big turnout for the Women’s Day of Action for pay equity. Billions of dollars have been stolen from low-paid female dominated workforces. This government can find huge tax cuts for tobacco companies, landlords, and big businesses - but not fair pay. That must change.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Locked Out has had a look at the recent GDP numbers.
Guess what? They’re not great, and there is no plan to make it work.
Have a watch now: youtu.be/RQgR2S6aaTI -
Craig Renney reposted
edward miller
@labourcartel
The year ended June 2025 shows record exports to the US, up 79 percent since 2021. Willis’ contractionary fiscal policies - not the trump tariffs - are crashing the economy.
henry cooke
@henrycooke
Nicola Willis: Economy had 'stuffing knocked out of it' by US tariffs
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Just spent all morning at the NZNO conference, talking with Nurses and medical professionals about how the health service is fairing (hint - not well).
Have I missed anything? -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Minimum Wage increased 1.5% this year. Data from Stats NZ shows
- Food prices up 5%
- Fruit & Veg up 8.9%
- Meat up 9.4%
- Bread up 9.5% (white sliced up 41.7%)
- Cheese up 14.3%
- Milk up 15%
- Electricity up 11.4%
Laser focussed on the cost of living
www.stats.govt.nz/information-releases/selected-price-ind… -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data released by Statistics New Zealand shows that the labour market is even more bleak than feared, with the loss of more than 10,000 jobs in just three months. The data shows that there are more than 50,000 fewer jobs than in December 2023. A 🧵www.stats.govt.nz/information-releases/business-employmen…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Outside of one COVID-affected quarter, filled jobs rose consistently from June 19 to December 2023. Now we have had 5 quarters - 15 months - where filled jobs have fallen further every quarter. This data represents a further slump in the labour market
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The government has no plan to manage this crisis. More job losses are being announced every day, and the government does not seem to recognise the growing scale of the challenge. Thousands of working people and their families are paying the price. Do you feel back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The National Party are at it again. The source of this data is kpi.nz - not official data. A Thread…
NZ National Party
@NZNationalParty
National looks after victims, not criminals.
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The NZ Police make the “Note: Burglary victimisations are classified to property rather than the resident and have been excluded from the data” so that isn’t in alongside a wide range of other offences. Again not all crime.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Not included:
- Homicide & Related Offences
- Dangerous or Negligent Acts endangering persons
- Fraud
- Property Damage & Environmental Pollution
- Public Order Offences
- Traffic & Vehicle Regulatory Offences
- Some Prohibited and Regulated Weapons & Explosive DevicesPost not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
For the purposes of clarity - I’m not having a go at kpi.nz - I have no idea who they are, who funds them, or what they are trying to do. You can make your own assessment by looking at thefacts.nz/who/ which is the parent website for this data
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
But once again - this is serious stuff. This is not the first time that National have done this. Crime data is an important issue, and we should using data carefully here. We all want a better understanding of how to tackle it. This just makes it harder to achieve.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Big turn out tonight at the Living Wage Election Forum Event. The Living Wage right now puts an extra $172 a week into the pay packet of a full time worker. Dignity at work comes from decent pay for everyone - not from tax cuts.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Amazon’s investment in Auckland being announced today by the government “is not new money being pledged, nor new jobs being created. Nor even new data centres being built”.
But apart from that it’s totally new.
Thomas Manch
@thomas_manch_
All may not be what it seems with the big hurrah of an Amazon Web Services announcement this morning. This from @the_postnz’s business team this morning: www.thepost.co.nz/business/360809627/luxon-re-announces-a…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Nicky:
- no boats
- no new supermarkets
- no-one getting $250 a fortnight
- no debt reduction
- no jobs
- no pay equity
- no child poverty reduction
- no Central Bank Bosses left
- no hope
The quiet whispers of leadership must be getting louder -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Monthly jobs rose this month – great! Except we have 36,734 fewer jobs than at the election. There are 17,573 fewer jobs than this time last year. Total wages have fallen 4% in real terms. If the current economic plan is working – its not working for working people. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Many economists are saying that the worst is over. That’s like saying we fell off a cliff, and we have at least stopped falling. It just shows us how far we have to climb. And for many – the fall hasn’t stopped. The response of the government has been to watch people fall.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The unemployment rate in New Zealand is 5.2%. 400,000 people are underutilised – the highest on record. Unemployment is 4.2% in Oz, and it has a growing economy - unlike NZ. We are losing a New Zealander every 7 minutes and 24 seconds. New Zealand is hurting and its not working.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Looking at the past few forecasts from RBNZ, and a pattern emerges. GDP. Employment. Residential investment. The recovery from the 2024 recession keeps being delayed.
More at: craigrenney.substack.com/p/on-the-cusp-nearly-there-all-the -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
In 2022 we were second. Source: www.economicsandpeace.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/GPI-….
If it doesn’t happen by accident - does that mean they made it deliberately worse?
NZ National Party
@NZNationalParty
New Zealand has been rated the 3rd safest country in the world. That doesn’t happen by accident. It’s the result of backing our Police, cracking down on gangs, and restoring law and order.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Retail trade data out today. The Govts economic strategy right now hinges on interest rate cuts turning up as increased spending. Retail sales are coming back - its just painfully slow. They are still behind where they were at the election
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
That big fall in hardware, building, and garden supplies is hard to square with the reports that home improvements are having a moment. This data, the building consent data, and the labour market data all still point to a very soft construction market www.thepost.co.nz/nz-news/360797183/home-renovation-boom-…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
During this period since the election, we have had 225 basis points knocked off the OCR. We have had billions of dollars of wildly misdirected tax cuts financed largely by borrowing. If this prescription was to have worked it should be working by now.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Instead, it is another sign of an economy probably bumping along the floor. An economy that's had the confidence knocked out of it. Every region except for Otago has seen real terms falls in retail spending since the election. Wellington is down 6% & Auckland 5% in real terms
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We will get employment and business data out later this week which will give us a sense of whether there might be better things ahead. Income and consumer confidence data is out too. It feels like spring in Wellington at the moment - but change isn't yet in the air in the economy
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I've reviewed the new Treasury Long Term Insights Briefing. Like shoulder pads & telethons, the Treasury thinks the 80s are back in style for fiscal policy. I'm not sure - let's actively shape our future economy, rather than passively watch it shape us. craigrenney.substack.com/p/shoulder-pads-telethons-and-fi…
-
Craig Renney reposted
New Zealand Council of Trade Unions
@NZ_CTU
🚨MEDIA RELEASE: Workers paying the price in weak economy. 🚨
1/8 New data released by Stats NZ shows that unemployment has increased to 5.2%, meaning that there are 158,000 people unemployed in NZ, and that wages aren’t keeping up with rising costs says CTU economist @CLRenney -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Unemployment data released by Statistics New Zealand today shows an increase to 5.2%. There are now 158,000 people unemployed in New Zealand, up 28% since the government took office. There is no plan to help, and the data shows even deep problems ahead. A 🧵
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There were 2.5m fewer hours worked than last year, and 8.5m fewer hours worked this year than at change in government. That’s over a million fewer days at work on an average 8-hour day. The Quarterly Employment Survey shows 34,600 fewer filled jobs than December 2023
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
51% of workers got a pay rise less than inflation, and 64% of people got a pay rise less than 3%. The majority of workers are now seeing their pay shrink in real terms on their base pay. 43% of workers saw no increase in wages according to the Labour Cost Index.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Underemployment continues to be a real problem. 130,000 people want more hours and can’t get them. The number of people underutilised – a broader measure of spare capacity including all those wanting work or more hours – broke the 400,000 barrier for the 1st time in NZ's history
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There were 15,000 fewer 15-24 year olds in employment than last year. Māori unemployment is 10%, Pacific Peoples unemployment is 12.1%. The number of people employed fell in 9 out 12 regions, with a fall of 23,100 people employed in Auckland since last year.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This data, together with anticipated weaker GDP data, suggests that the economy is in a difficult place and now needs support – not cuts. Unemployment is higher in New Zealand than in the UK (4.5%) the USA (4.2%) and Australia (4.2%). It’s higher than the OECD Average (4.9%)
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This data shows that New Zealand needs a different economic plan. Workers are paying the price for the government's policies, and the government has the wrong priorities when tax breaks come before employment support. Do you feel back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Nurses and health care workers are out campaigning today for safe staffing, decent contracts, and a properly funded public health system. They support you when you and your family need help the most. Support them today.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data from Stats NZ today demonstrates how far we have fallen in the labour market. Between June 2019 and June 2023, we put on 225,000 new jobs. Since then, we have lost 31,216 jobs. A job lost every 34 minutes. A thread
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The real pain is being felt by young people. Over the past year, 20,149 fewer jobs are being filled by 15-24 year olds. Even those aged 25 to 29 are suffering, as there are 9,921 fewer jobs for them. It’s no wonder so many young people are looking at leaving the country right now
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Jobs fell in Auckland (-16,114 since June 2023). Wellington (down 8,438). Manawatu-Whanganui (down 2,776). Hawkes Bay (down 1,341). N'land (down 1,153). Taranaki (down 1,040). Waikato (down 725). Nelson (down 693). Canterbury put on 1,666 jobs – against 29,620 between 19 & 23.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Since 2023 the number of filled jobs in manufacturing is down 10,283. Construction down 16,603. Professional, Scientific and Technical Services down 9,411. Administrative and Support Services down 10,812. Retail trade down 7,915. Accommodation and Food Services down 5,855.
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Since the election there has been no plan to deal with growing unemployment - simply a 'hope' that falling interest rates would spark house prices again. More sanctions on beneficiaries - tick. Removing jobseeker for 18+19 year olds - tick. Actual action? nil.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It's clear from the data the government's plan isn't working for working people. We are losing a New Zealand citizen overseas every 7 minutes and 24 seconds. We have huge infrastructure needs and ghost money announcements. Do you feel back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Delighted to be invited to hear @MaxRashbrooke deliver the first IDEA report into welfare and the role that active labour market programmes can play. With rising unemployment this is an urgent and necessary area of research. The full report is at: www.ideainstitute.nz/projects-the-pipeline-of-potential
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Standing with workers affected by the theft of pay equity, handing over a petition of more than 93,000 signatures. It’s been 53 years since the Equal Pay Act and this government is taking us backwards not forwards. Join your union and make this a one-term government.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The CTU is closing signatures at 8am tomorrow morning on our Pay Equity Petition. If you have signed - thank you. If you haven't - don't wait any longer and sign right now. 330,000 workers affected by the theft of pay equity have already waited too long.
www.together.org.nz/fbt_for_pay_equity -
Craig Renney reposted
New Zealand Council of Trade Unions
@NZ_CTU
We're almost ready to take our petition to Parliament. Let's get it to 100,000—tell your friends, tell your whānau, and spread the word. Join us as we fight back together for working women.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data released by Statistics New Zealand today shows that the Consumer Price Index rose to 2.7%. This marks the 3rd straight quarter in which annual inflation increased, up from 2.2% in December 2024. The data underneath this figure suggests some troubles ahead. A🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
With rising unemployment and a rising cost of living for low-income families, the government should have a plan to tackle these concerns. But rents are rising faster than inflation, despite $bns in tax breaks. Food prices rising at 4.2% despite the focus on supermkt competition.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Inflation in Aus is 2.1% - here its 2.7% with lower wages. Unemployment and beneficiary numbers are up. A NZ citizen migrates away every 7 mins and 24 sec. Ministers stand around in high-viz jackets and tell us about stuff that's already happened. Do you feel back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I had a great chat with Nathalie Jacques from NZNO about the problems facing Nurses and the health system in Aotearoa, busting some of the myths being thrown around. We also look at the current GDP forecasts from the Reserve Bank. Have a listen at:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMw0yUK5ydM -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It's not often that I am given to bouts of optimism, such is the curse of being an Economist. But a look back at New Zealand's history is giving me pause for thought. My latest substack on what 1931 can tell us about today is available at: craigrenney.substack.com/p/its-not-1931-but-it-feels-like-it
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I have had a look at the FamilyBoost Changes - and who they really benefit.
All the details at: craigrenney.substack.com/p/familyboost-for-some-more-than… -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There have been a slew of recent indicators telling us that there is real pain in the labour market right now. I have a look at what the latest data is telling us at:
craigrenney.substack.com/p/the-labour-market-isnt-working -
Craig Renney reposted
New Zealand Council of Trade Unions
@NZ_CTU
...other action that [van Velden] also includes in the category of “partial strikes” includes things like teachers refusing to take extracurricular activities and sports, which is voluntary, wearing union T-shirts and “working to rule”.
www.thepost.co.nz/business/360736055/employers-once-more-… -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Episode 11 of Locked out with Craig Renney is out - I had a great conversation with @_chloeswarbrick
looking at the Green Party Fiscal Strategy which was released last week.
Check it out now: www.youtube.com/watch?v=3I6T_6ISAXo -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data released by Stats New Zealand today shows that the economy grew on a quarterly basis by 0.8% but fell on an annual basis by 1.1%. The economy is about the same size it was in March 2023 tells you that we have had almost zero (0.3%) economic growth over the past 2 years. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The lack of business confidence in the economy is present in the business investment data. Business investment fell this year. Non-residential building investment fell 2.9%. Transport equipment fell 6%. Households are feeling it - purchase of durable goods lower in December 2023.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This data shows how far we fell last year in economic terms. Growth in GDP this quarter is welcome – but the economy is still smaller than at the election in real terms. Recent data shows the economy struggling, and there is a real danger that we see slow, no, or negative growth
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It’s time for the Government to realise its economic plan isn’t working. There are 23,000 more people on Jobseekers. 48% of workers in NZ got a pay cut in real terms last year. Business & consumer confidence are at levels associated with recessions.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
One quarter of data shouldn’t blind the government of the need for change. There is an urgent need to invest in New Zealand. The economy is in the doldrums. We should be using every lever right now to makes sure the warmth of any growth reaches working people
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Minimum Wage increased 1.5% this year. Data just released by Stats NZ shows:
- Food Prices up 4.4.%
- Beef up 16.2%. Lamb up 20.3%
- Cheese up 17.3%. Milk up 13.7%
- Electricity up 8.7%. Gas up 15.4%
- Rent up 2.8%
Laser focussed on the cost of living
www.stats.govt.nz/information-releases/selected-price-ind… -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Business NZ looks at the state of the economy through two measures – PMI (Performance of Manufacturing Index) and PSI (Performance of Services Index). If they score above 50 – the sectors are growing. Data today shows them at 47.5 and 44. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If GDP grows this week – great. But timelier data shows its likely to be a high water mark. Our current growth driver, exports, will be impacted by the current global turmoil . The OECD is forecasting annual GDP growth of just 0.8% for NZ in 2025. www.oecd.org/en/about/news/press-releases/2025/06/global-…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I’ve produced a preview of the GDP numbers on Thursday in my Substack. There is now a wealth of data from employment, to services, to welfare, and to manufacturing telling us that all is not well. Have a look now.
craigrenney.substack.com/p/gdp-preview-look-out-the-window -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Migration data came out today. It’s down at levels not seen – outside of COVID – since January 2014 when we were climbing out of the GFC. Migration added 21,300 people to NZ in April 25. It was 95k in April 24. A thread...
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
74,230 people migrated from New Zealand last year who were aged between 15-39. That's the highest number since 2001. It beats the previous peak in 2012 when we had the Christchurch sequence (69k). Young people appear to be voting with their feet.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Until we get a better economic plan – one that doesn’t stem from a false belief that we can cut our way to prosperity, its difficult to see this trend changing significantly. It's time we invested in New Zealand and make it an attractive place to life - not just a place to leave.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Delighted to talk with @GaryPayinda about the Budget for Episode 8 of Locked Out. Talking about what it means for Health in New Zealand, and what life is like on the frontline of our health services. Find us at:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=P_GPXNJKg1E&list=PLKzyMX9pCGMvQ6O… -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The CTU has released a report today looking at the Budget, and what it means for working people across New Zealand. Find all the details of what the government intends to buy after stealing $12.8bn from low-paid workers at: union.org.nz/a-workers-analysis-of-budget-2025/
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Ep.7 of Locked Out with Craig Renney is out now. We talk with disability advocate @nickruane about how government decisions in the Budget will affect 850,000 people with disabilities in NZ. We also take a first look at the Budget spending decisions.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=VJxTOOZ-fNs -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
During the last election campaign – you might have heard the phrase “It’s time to get the county back on track” uttered once or twice.
How do you feel that is going? Do you feel back on track yet?
There are some numbers in the Budget that back-up your concerns. A 🧵Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We are nearly halfway through this term of office – Mr. Peters notwithstanding. If we were truly back on track, would we feel as justifiably angry as many of us feel today?
If we are to truly get "back on track" we might – just might – need to change the driver instead.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There is so much more to examine about this Budget, and over the next few weeks we will delve into the key issues to show what it really means for working people in Aotearoa. craigrenney.substack.com/p/the-reverse-robin-hood-budget takes a look at the first set of issues. Have a look now.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Today’s Budget takes $12.8bn from low-income, female dominated workforces to prop up the governments failed economic policies. It's a Reverse Robin Hood Budget that steals from working people. This is a Budget that isn’t working for working people. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Budgets are about choices. Tax cuts for large firms, cuts to pay for low-income workers. Falling capital investment, while investing in more money for private schools. Taking money from 18 and 19 year olds, while investing nothing on climate change for their future.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Working people will be paying the price for decisions made by Ministers. The government had a choice at this Budget - and it chose the wrong choices for New Zealand. We shows the need to make different choices at the next election.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It has been a week!
- Tuesday 13th. Locked out of Budget 25 Briefing alongside other NGO analysts without reason
- Wednesday 14th. Told that I couldn't attend as a journalist for #bhn despite having NZ Media Council accreditation (See Blindfish Media below).
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
- Wednesday 14th. Blindfish Media could send someone else "If you would like to send an alternative representative from your organisation, we will consider this decision further".
- Wednesday Night - Reports filter through that other analysts now have been allowed in. Not CTUPost not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Thank you to everyone who has helped and supported the CTU and I to attend the lock-up. I know its a tiny thing, but it makes such a huge difference to us that we can be there asking questions and understanding what the Budget means for working people.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
In particular, can I thank @patbrittenden @JordNZ @EricCrampton for your support and solidarity. It's probably the only time you will find us all in the same room agreeing. Its wild that just asking to be allowed into a room to read economic projections should be this hard.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
At 5pm yesterday, the Treasury informed the New Zealand Council of Trade Unions Te Kauae Kaimahi (NZCTU) it has been barred from attending the Budget lock-up on 22 May. This is the first time the CTU has been prevented from attending a Budget lock-up in living memory
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Last week the government made the decision to unilaterally end the 33 pay equity claims under negotiation and make it harder to lodge claims in the future. It is unsurprising that it doesn’t want working people to understand the impacts of its Budget decisions this year.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There is still time for this decision to be reversed. There is no capacity concern, nor are the CTU a security risk. Providing access will only support transparency, and more informed public debate on issues important to all New Zealanders.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Pay Equity changes need clear and honest answers from this government. The hundreds of thousands of workers whose lives will be affected by this decision should expect nothing less. A list of currently unanswered questions is here: craigrenney.substack.com/p/pay-equity-questions-yet-to-be…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If you haven’t done so already, join more than 50,000 people and sign the pay equity petition www.together.org.nz/fbt_for_pay_equity
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Not providing answers to these questions would suggest that the government has something to hide - or that it hasn’t done the basic level of due diligence that would be expected of any competent Minister holding a warrant. We deserve better.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The fourth episode of Locked Out is now available - looking at housing with Bernard Hickey. Find us on youtube, spotify, apple, or wherever you get your podcasts.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=FRMEquMT0_c&list=PLKzyMX9pCGMvQ6O… -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Unemployment data released today by Statistics New Zealand shows ongoing weakness in the labour market, with falling employment, falling hours of work, and nearly half of all workers getting a pay rise less than inflation. A 🧵
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
While the unemployment rate number stayed at 5.1%, the number of people working full-time fell by 45,000 while the number working part-time increased by 25,000. People can’t find all the work they need to get by. There are now nearly 3 million fewer hours worked in the economy
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There are now 37,000 more unemployed people that at the last election. Māori unemployment is now at 10.5%. Pacific Peoples unemployment is at 10.8%. Unemployment in Auckland is 6.4%. Employment fell in manufacturing, construction, retail, education, and health care
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Without changes to the government’s economic approach, things will likely get worse. In 2022 New Zealand was sixth in the OECD rankings for unemployment. We are now 18th. Unemployment is lower in Australia, UK & the US. Budget forecasts this month will likely see this get worse
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Failing to tackle this problem will just lead to years of costs in the future. Yet the only plan from our government is to make workers poorer, strip away their existing rights, and entrench inequalities. This is a choice. We can and should choose something different.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The pay equity decision today – just before Mothers Day – takes employment law back decades. It will likely impact the earnings of hundreds of thousands of women, often working in some of the most poorly paid work. It will cost us all in the long-run. A 🧵www.beehive.govt.nz/release/changes-improve-pay-equity-pr…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Making it less attractive to work in the industries which will be affected by this decision, will make it harder to recruit. Care, Nursing, Teaching. That makes it more expensive to provide those services. We are simply passing on the costs to the future, rather than solving them
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This government has cut the minimum wage in real terms - twice. We are cutting living wage protections. Cutting sick leave. Child poverty is rising. Is this seriously the only plan for the economy? How many people need to be impoverished for this government to feel wealthy?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Wasn’t going to have a drink this weekend but the Australian Election might push me to it. Two elections in a week - both looking likely to keep the right in opposition. Winning bigly some might say.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If the operating allowance has been halved - that’s a sign of real stress on the Budget. That’s not enough money to pay for cost pressures just in the health service - nevermind anything else. This Budget will now be paid for with cuts.
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
So when child poverty rises as a consequence of this - which it will - that’s a choice. When there is less help available for kids with extra needs at your kids school - that’s a choice. When we can’t tackle climate change- that’s a choice. This governments choice. Actively made.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
You can’t complain about spending too much money after giving it all away in a tax cut. We borrowed $12bn for the last tax cut, and now the Minister of Finance is complaining about borrowing! Make it make sense!
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Episode 2 of Locked Out is now available 😀 - looking at the minimum wage after two years of below inflation increases by this government. We also examine the $8,944 a year loss facing workers who might lose the Living Wage due to government proposals. podcasts.apple.com/nz/podcast/locked-out-with-craig-renne…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Thanks to everyone who gives it a listen, and many thanks to everyone who makes this possible - especially all my friends at #bhn. If you have any numbers or claims you want us to investigate - we are always on the lookout for things to investigate!
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Correct Substack link attached! substack.com/home/post/p-161941416
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Locked Out with Craig Renney was the top ranked NZ news podcast today on Apple! Thank you to everyone who has supported the podcast and helped make it possible. If you haven’t caught it yet - you can download it at podcasts.apple.com/nz/podcast/locked-out-with-craig-renne…. P.S. Mike Hoskings was eighth.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data released by Stats NZ today showed that inflation was 2.5% for the year to March 2025 rising from 2.2% in December last year. The prices of things that you can’t avoid are rising faster than others – meaning inflation is rising faster for those on low incomes. A thread…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
With 46% of workers receiving a pay rise less than inflation last year, it also shows that many working people are still doing it really tough. Unemployment is still rising, with tens of thousands of more people on Jobseekers Support. It is clearly not workers who are benefitting
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This data is another piece of evidence about who is winning and losing in the economy. The poorest working people are facing higher costs they can’t avoid – but with less money to pay. That needs to change.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The first episode of Locked Out with Craig Renney is…unlocked! I sat down with @labourcartel to talk about energy markets and missing data from the government m.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLKzyMX9pCGMvQ6OMZi4FXx9COoVq…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We will be putting out this podcast weekly - so we are on the hunt for numbers you might have heard that make you go….”hmmmn, is that right?” Ask us - and we will investigate!
-
Craig Renney reposted
Big Hairy Network
@bighairynetwork
First episode of Locked Out with Craig Renney drops tomorrow morning on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and YouTube with a conversation around electricity prices.
Dis you know that there was a period last year when every dollar you paid for electricity had 92c profit for the provider? -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Huge new package announced for defence yesterday. $12bn over the next four years – about the same as NZ spends in total on the police. $9bn of the $12bn is new. Quick question…where does the money come from? A 🧵www.beehive.govt.nz/release/multi-billion-dollar-defence-…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
So it might come from capital spending? Well we have $14.5bn in capex available over the period. Great! Great that is if you don’t like building any new roads, hospitals, schools, or perhaps a ferry or two. For the next 4 years.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Also, capital spending has to be on capital items. Much of what is described in the review appears to be operating items ($1bn for enterprise software for example). You can’t turn that into capex. See "capital allowance"
www.treasury.govt.nz/publications/guidance/glossaryPost not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The government should be clear about how it intends to pay for new spending on defence. What will go if it is to come from cuts. We don't have $9bn or $12bn spare right now - and if we did - is this what we would spend it on? This is a choice. Kiwis should be told how it adds up
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If you like this sort of analysis - you might like the 'Locked Out with Craig Renney' podcast starting this month. Looking at the numbers and asking where they come from and what they really mean. More details will be coming soon www.youtube.com/DOCNZStudios
-
Craig Renney reposted
New Zealand Council of Trade Unions
@NZ_CTU
When we fight back, we win.
#fightbacktogether #marangaake -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
GDP Data released today shows a quarterly 0.7% increase – whoop! Growth again! But that growth needs to be put into some context. We are still worse off than we were a year ago. Many economic signals are still heading in the wrong direction. A Thread
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
While any economic growth is welcome, this data further demonstrates the compelling need for an actual economic plan, not just a few slogans. One based upon growing both public and private investment. One based upon growing wages and household incomes
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Many might celebrate this economic signal, but that one note needs to be put in context. Unemployment is up. Child Poverty is up. Homelessness appears to be rising. Our economic challenges are still very much here and worse than they were a year ago.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Has the chat about PPPs left you confused? You're not alone. There is no official definition, they are filled with acronyms & confusing diagrams. It's almost as if they dont want you to know. Find a bluffer's guide to PPPs and their use at: craigrenney.substack.com/p/when-should-you-use-a-ppp-a-bl….
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The draft decision to remove the Living Wage from cleaners, caterers, and security guards by the Minister of Finance will hurt real people. People we rely on every day to deliver public services. But it will also hurt us as taxpayers. Let's look at the story of 'Amy'...🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If the company employs 150 workers, that would be an extra $1.34m in their pockets annually. For the same work, doing the same thing, delivering the same output. If you think that prices will come down I have a bridge to sell you. It will simply be scooped up as extra profit.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Nicola Willis said that this was about "getting rid of rules that make it really difficult for some firms to even apply for a government contract". How does paying the Living Wage make it harder - surely it makes it easier? www.rnz.co.nz/national/programmes/morningreport/audio/201…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Please visit the consultation webpage at: www.mbie.govt.nz/have-your-say/government-procurement-rul…
and let the government know that you don't agree with this. This can't be the way that we grow the New Zealand economy.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If you are stuck on what to say - just quote the maiden speech to Parliament of Christopher Luxon "We need to work smarter, not harder". The government needs to think harder. Think smarter than making Amy and the taxpayer poorer, while profits go higher. www.scoop.co.nz/stories/PA2103/S00191/christopher-luxon-m…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
New draft government procurement guidelines would remove wage protections for thousands of low-paid workers in New Zealand - taking away the gains they have made from the Living Wage. Why? A 🧵 www.beehive.govt.nz/release/going-growth-new-procurement-…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The LW is $27.80 an hour. Dropping to minimum wage would mean losing $186 a week for a full time worker - or $9,672 a year. How will that benefit anyone? It just means more child poverty, higher welfare payments, and more income insecurity. Is this really how we "go for growth"?
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This is the same logic that brought back 90 day trials, ended Fair Pay Agreements, reduced sick leave, and stopped work on modern slavery. Rather than make New Zealand more competitive, we squeeze workers harder. Please take the time to tell the government that this has to stop.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
A week of many announcements in health. But not much detail or action on the issues that matter. Even less real new funding - exactly $0 this week. The only thinkings growing in health are need and insults. More at craigrenney.substack.com/p/not-in-rude-health-just-rude
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Its 80 days to the Budget. Too early for an analysis of what is possibly going on? Absolutely not. I'm surprised I held out this long. More at: craigrenney.substack.com/p/your-early-guide-to-the-2025-b…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I’ve taken the liberty of offering some advice on Special Economic Zones. And why we need a wide conversation on industrial policy in New Zealand. Take a look at: craigrenney.substack.com/p/special-economic-zones-special-or
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Is there a more appropriate term for “gaslighting” when it’s done via the electricity market? Asking for 5.2 million friends.
edward miller
@labourcartel
When we accused gentailers of excessive dividends and underinvestment in 2022, Mike Fuge retorted. Now it’s 2025 and Fuge says underinvestment is causing price increases…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I saw the below and thought that's a heck of a claim. So let's examine how National got here. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Ministerial PR states “There were 24,000 fewer victims over the year ending October 2024, compared to June 2024”. Is this a typo, as the year in question would include 8 months under both ‘years’? Is the release saying that in four months the number of crimes fell by 24,000?
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
What is clear is the data available from NZ police itself (www.police.govt.nz/about-us/publications-statistics/data-…). This is actual 'police data'.
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
What has dropped are the number of police - which are down 561 from its peak of 10,700 in June 2023. It's now 10,139 - fewer than when National took office and miles away from the target of 10,711.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We should be really careful when we use terms like 'police data', or when we link data on prison populations and crime. Crime is a terrible thing and we all want less of it. The public conversation about crime and its solutions deserves better than this.
-
Craig Renney reposted
Fleur Fitzsimons
@FleurFitzsimons
Facts
1. Defence Force disestablised 200 civilians roles
2. Defence lost 144 civilians through voluntary redundancy to save $
3. Civilians are critical - they certify military equipment is safe to fly and do security at bases
4. Plans to cut flu vaccine at Defence to save $
Nicola Willis
@NicolaWillisMP
Facts:
1) We increased funding for defence in our first Budget.
2) We will continue to increase funding for defence in every Budget we deliver.
Our Government knows that strengthening defence capability is vital to protecting our national interests: New Zealand’s economic prosperity depends on it.
Hon Judith Collins KC
@JudithCollinsKC
I’m finding it slightly weird to have to defend allegations that our government cut defence spending last year. We didn’t. Defence received an extra $571 million in the 2024 budget.
What commentators don’t seem to realise is that, having already paid for the new Hercules, we didn’t need to pay for them a second time.
It’s just like a car. Pay once! So we didn’t get the same capital funding for Hercules since we’d already paid for them.
That $571 million included a $163 million in extra remuneration for our uniform personnel.
I am looking forward to our new fully funded Defence Capability plan which will show the commitment needed. -
Craig Renney reposted
Jim Stanford
@JimboStanford
I've been a 'union economist' my whole career, so I can't overstate how honoured I'll be Friday to receive a lifetime membership from the Australian Education Union @AEUfederal for research showing the economic & social benefits of public education. /2
-
Craig Renney reposted
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Child poverty costs us morally, economically, and socially. It is corrosive to all that is good. Our children deserve security from the ills of poverty, and we can deliver that. We had an agreement to get there once. We can do it again. craigrenney.substack.com/p/its-a-sin-child-poverty-in-aot…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Child poverty costs us morally, economically, and socially. It is corrosive to all that is good. Our children deserve security from the ills of poverty, and we can deliver that. We had an agreement to get there once. We can do it again. craigrenney.substack.com/p/its-a-sin-child-poverty-in-aot…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Stats NZ measures child poverty on three measures – before housing costs, after housing costs, and material poverty. All three central estimates of poverty rose last year. This is the second year in a row in which the data is heading in the wrong direction. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There is no plan to help these families living in poverty, only the threat of more sanctions for households already facing hardship. Child Poverty is a prison that holds too many children in New Zealand back.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Unless we tackle this problem now New Zealand will be paying for this over generations. The government has urgently produced a strategy for its economic growth plan, it doesn’t seem as if it shares the same sense of urgency for child poverty.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
A few thoughts on the MPS today - its painting a picture of a soggy economy for New Zealand. We have to actively choose something better. craigrenney.substack.com/p/banking-on-the-future
-
Craig Renney reposted
Fleur Fitzsimons
@FleurFitzsimons
The PSA filed legal action this week against the cuts at Health New Zealand Te Whatu Ora which aim to stop the health cuts and stop the job losses in their tracks.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
18,447kms from the town I grew up in, but Wellington is my home. Today was a good day…you know the rest.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The government came to office saying its’ plan was to get New Zealand ‘back on track’. When that slogan failed, we now have a slogan saying we need to ‘go for growth’. New Zealand needs an actual plan – not another slogan.
craigrenney.substack.com/p/planning-to-fail -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Luxon dreams of development. Sadly, he has the wrong end of the stick. Development happens when you have a skilled & healthy workforce, and great public infrastructure. That doesn’t happen because you held a meeting with canapés for wealthy investors. craigrenney.substack.com/p/luxon-dreams-of-development
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
A quick note about the latest labour market data, and how not to appear out of touch. substack.com/inbox/post/156780072
-
Craig Renney reposted
edward miller
@labourcartel
Minister Van Velden says she prefers to meet with workers directly, rarely making time to meet with the @NZ_CTU, which represents 360,000 workers across the country. How many workers do they FSU and Red Unions represent? newsroom.co.nz/2025/02/04/van-velden-turns-down-union-mee…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Unemployment data today. It crossed the 5% barrier to 5.1%, with 33,000 more people out of work than last year. employment fell in Aotearoa at its fastest rate since the GFC. There is a real and growing problem in the labour market. A thread
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Wage increases are slowing. Nearly half (46%) of working people got a pay rise less than CPI. With the minimum wage rising by only 1.5% in April this trend will continue. With part-time work growing, but full-time work falling, maintaining incomes is going to be difficult
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Right now there is no plan for the economy. No plan for the labour market. The economy is in sharp recession. Unemployment is rising. It’s time for a plan for New Zealand. We're losing record numbers of people overseas, and without that these numbers would likely have been worse
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There has been a lot of talk all of a sudden about how corporate tax needs to be cut. Only the evidence doesn't support that view. More, including unexpected Wizard of Oz references at: craigrenney.substack.com/p/dont-follow-the-yellow-brick-road
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The government announced new sanctions for those on Jobseekers. Why? A look at the evidence suggests that they do little to help. Might they be about demonising the poor instead? A 🧵www.beehive.govt.nz/release/new-benefit-sanctions-traffic…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The UK act forced people to look for work “taking at least three steps each week”. Again the evidence suggests that “the best estimate of the ‘average’ treatment effect on search activity is very close to zero”.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This is a policy designed not to improve the lives of beneficiaries, their families, working people, or the communities they live in. It's not going to help the economy or businesses doing it tough. It's designed as a media talking point ahead of a bad news day. We can do better.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We work some of the longest hours in the OECD. On average we work 100 hours a year longer than Australians. 251 hours more than French workers. Both are more productive. This is lazy thinking - we need to work smarter not longer. www.oecd.org/en/data/indicators/hours-worked.html
Kelly Eckhold
@kellyenz
We won’t boost productivity growth if we only work 4.25 days a week.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Revisions to the costings for the Treaty Principles Bill have calculated due to the record number of submissions provided to the Justice Select Committee. Originally we forecast that $4.1m would be needed - but that was before 343,000 physical and digital submissions. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Many of these costs could be managed. The Sponsor of the Bill (David Seymour) could immediately withdraw the bill. Or, the Leader of the National Party could make it clear to the Chair of the Justice Select Committee that no more work or energy is to be expanded on this Bill.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The coalition agreement between National & Act states “Introduce a Treaty Principles Bill based on existing ACT policy and support it to a Select Committee as soon as practicable”. That has been delivered. Any further expenses associated with this Bill are a choice for National
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
“My conviction that this country needs to go for growth”
Liz Truss - www.gov.uk/government/speeches/pm-press-conference-openin…
“we have to go for growth”
Christopher Luxon - www.beehive.govt.nz/speech/state-nation-2025
🥬 -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Inflation data provided by Statistics New Zealand today surprised some by remaining at 2.2%, defying those expecting a further fall in inflation. Prices continued to rise at 2.2% annually the same as September 2024. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
That decision makes no economic sense – and there is still time for it to be changed – and it should be. This will be the second year in a row of below inflation increases. Deliberate choices made by this government that simply penalises those on low incomes.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The prices of things that the government has no control over are falling – notably fuel. The price of things that the government has more control over are rising more quickly than general inflation. Do you feel back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There have been a few stories this week about the jobs market - in particular the Westpac-McDermott Miller Employment Confidence Index. That rose rose by 2.4 points the December quarter - which is good news. Only once you get below that its not great. A 🧵www.westpac.co.nz/assets/Business/tools-rates-fees/docume…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
So yes - Westpac is right - overall the index did improve. Its at almost the same spot on the index (91.6 vs 91.4) as 6 months ago - which was its lowest level since 2020. That's not really a cause for celebration! library.westpaciq.com.au/content/dam/public/westpaciq/sec…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If people aren't confident in their employment, they don't spend. Business don't invest if there isn't demand. If government isn't investing this compounds the problem. Round and round we go - hoping for interest rate cuts to come to our rescue. There is no plan - just hope
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Stats NZ produced three new sets of data today - showing the headwinds facing the economy. Housing consents, employment data, and business numbers. All three show declines. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The numbers of new dwellings consented in the year ended November 2024 (compared with November 2023) were:
13,905 in Auckland (down 12 %)
2,836 in Waikato (down 21 %)
1,839 in Wellington (down 33 %)
5,009 in rest of North Island (down 7.0 %)
6,502 in Canterbury (down 9.2 %)
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
All in all its bleak set of numbers today. It's clear that the recent GDP data isnt lying. Still no plan from the government, except more cuts. How much longer do we have to accept our current approach isn't working for working people ?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Welcome to more "vibes based analysis" on 90 day trials from the EMA. Zero hard data provided within this oped supports the use of 90 day trials, nor is their any mention of their potential misuse. What does the real evidence say? A 🧵 www.nzherald.co.nz/business/have-90-day-employment-trials…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
90 days didn't help "beneficiaries, jobseeker beneficiaries, non-workers, recent migrants, youths under 25 years old, Māori or Pasifika under 25, or education leavers. This result holds both over the economy as a whole, and in the high-use industries" www.motu.nz/assets/Documents/our-work/population-and-labo…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Perhaps then the policy supports people into temporary work? “The policy seems not to have substantially increased short-term hiring”. So no increase in employment. No increase in work for marginalised workers. No increase in short-term hiring. Who does benefit from this policy?
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We should reject such vibes based analysis, found here and in areas like sick leave & holidays act reform. In cutting the minimum wage in real terms. In cutting welfare payments. In cutting public sector roles. In cutting child poverty targets, climate action, and in Te Tiriti
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
With grim economic news likely set to continue, we will see more of this "vibes based analysis" in the near future - as those who endorse the government's current policies look for any support they can find. New Zealand isn't back on track yet - according to the evidence
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Happy Hogmanay! I hope that 2025 is all you desire it to be. May the New Year bring peace and prosperity for you and your family. Slàinte mhath.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Its the last Sunday before Christmas, so as a special treat to myself I thought that I would look over the last 3 sets of Economic and Fiscal Updates from the Government. That gives us a sense of change over time, and if the government's current approach is working. A looong 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The good news is that it doesn't have to be this way. Much of the increase in borrowing is to pay for tax cuts, that haven't helped the economy or the accounts. New cuts to spending and public services will simply make things worse. It didn't work last year and won't work now
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Things will get better in the long-run, and the govt will try to claim that as proof its policies worked when it occurs. We shouldn't let them off. Thousands of families will be harmed by this government unless things change. More children in poverty. It's time to change track.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data released by Statistics New Zealand today showed a significant slowdown in the economy over the past six months, with GDP falling by 1% in September, and 1.1%. We now have a real growth emergency in New Zealand. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This isn’t a wake-up call for the government, it’s an alarm. Excluding COVID lockdowns, this is the fastest fall in Production GDP over six months since June 1991. The economy isn’t back on track, its derailed
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Government spending has fallen at the fastest rate since 1992 and the Budgets of Ruth Richardson. We have just had a Budget where the government’s fiscal plans have clearly been shown to have failed. Unemployment is rising fast – and will likely rise more.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The economy is now showing the impact of the government’s policies – it’s been in office for a year. It’s clear that it’s time for a new approach – before the New Zealand economy suffers any longer.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Just filmed a pop-up Hoon with @bernardchickey for the Kākā on the HUEFU.More at: thekaka.substack.com/p/willis-austerity-strategy-just-isn…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Minister of Finance and the Treasury released its Half Year Economic and Fiscal Update today, and with it – its ‘plan’ for the Budget in 2025 in the Budget Policy Statement. The indicators show very clearly that it’s not working for anyone. A long thread (apologies)
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Other countries around the world are seeing growth, yet New Zealand is not. That lack of growth in turn delivers poorer fiscal outcomes, and less public investment. That in turn requires bigger cuts to balance the books. Round and round we go.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The quote "When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do, sir?" is often attributed to the economist John Maynard Keynes. The current governments policies are making the problem worse, and the books today show that problem writ large. It should change its mind.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It’s no wonder they didn’t want me in. Shocker.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Another year, another real terms Minimum Wage cut. The government has decided to increase the Minimum Wage by 1.5% - when inflation is forecast by the Reserve Bank to be 2%. Full time Minimum Wage Workers will be $235.04 a year worse off. A 🧵 www.nzherald.co.nz/business/minimum-wage-rate-to-go-up-by…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Last year the Minimum Wage rose 2%, when inflation was 4%. To keep up just with inflation over the past two years, it should be $24.08. Minimum Wage Workers are now $23.20 a week worse off in real terms from the two decisions of this government. That's $1,206.40 a year.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
At a time when rents are rising at 4%, when insurance is rising at 13%, and when support for public transport and free prescriptions were withdrawn - this is another blow to low income households. 61% of children in poverty live in households with work - this will make it worse
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Your annual tax cut from budget.govt.nz/taxcalculator/ is $732 if you are in full time work - so you are now $474 a year worse off even after tax changes. We can't find money for some of the poorest households - yet we can find $3bn in tax cuts for landlords. Are we back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Today the CTU sent an open letter to the Treasury asking them to reconsider their decision to bar access to financial briefings. Democracy & public scrutiny aren't supported by locking social partners like CTU & non-financial institutions from the lock-up union.org.nz/nzctu-open-letter-to-treasury-on-undue-restr…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
On a personal note, I have been genuinely touched by the support I have received on this issue from those with whom I would normally disagree. I won't embarrass them by naming names - but they have been better friends to me than I think I might have been in their shoes. Thank you
-
Craig Renney reposted
edward miller
@labourcartel
1/17 A new report from @CICTAR_Tax @350nz and Common Grace Aotearoa warns that a dry winter in 2025 could enable NZ's largest gas user, Methanex, to push up gas and electricity prices, which could destroy jobs and livelihoods. See: cictar.org/all-research/methanexit
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Do you want to know what a loss of hope looks like? This is the percentage increase in the number of people migrating away from NZ since the election. The 131,100 migrant departures in the October 2024 year are, provisionally, the highest on record for an annual period
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Why are young people leaving? Unemployment is rising - 24,600 fewer 15-30 years olds in work than at the election. Recent rent rises are the fastest in the Consumer Price Index history . Wages aren't rising - & the Minimum Wage cut in real terms. Public services being cut...
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
They are leaving because there is no plan. Nothing to spur economic growth, or new jobs, or new hope. Places like Ruapehu or Tokoroa, facing significant job losses without any government support. Taking away support for apprenticeships - not adding. Are we back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
No Plan, No Idea, No Ferries. Today’s announcement by the Minister of Finance means we don't know:
- where replacement ferries are coming from
- how much they will cost
- who will pay for them
- how the port infrastructure will be delivered,
- the fiscal or economic impact
A 🧵Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Workers on the Cook Strait ferries, service users, and New Zealanders all deserve better than this. This is a plan to have a plan. The ferries are reaching the end of their service life, yet we have been given another working group and another delay instead of clarity
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The previous contract should never have been cancelled and all New Zealanders are going to pay for the current indecision. Later, smaller ferries, likely run by a private company. Higher costs of freight - which means higher shop prices. A poorer service. Is this back on track?
-
Craig Renney reposted
Eric Crampton
@EricCrampton
This is wrong and bad.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
How is your day going? I’ve just been declined access to the @nztreasury HYEFU lock-up. Apparently that’s because the CTU didn’t meet their criteria. Our 27 Unions & more than 320,000 workers don’t need to know about the govt books or the economy? Open & transparent government 🤷
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
How is your day going? I’ve just been declined access to the @nztreasury HYEFU lock-up. Apparently that’s because the CTU didn’t meet their criteria. Our 27 Unions & more than 320,000 workers don’t need to know about the govt books or the economy? Open & transparent government 🤷
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Todays announcement by RBNZ shows that the economy will remain weak going into 2025, and that unemployment will continue to climb. The forecasts show employment is likely to remain below 2023 levels until Dec 2025 – while the labour force grows 28,000 during that period. a 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Unemployment is forecast to remain elevated until the end of 2025. The forecast never sees it returning to the rates seen in 2023. Without a plan to reduce it, we are choosing a permanently higher unemployment rate. It’s no wonder many Kiwis are emigrating overseas on this data
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Many people will celebrate the fall in interest rates, and the hope that this will bring future relief. This data shows that the labour market is in for the long-haul. Lower future employment. Higher future unemployment. Lower business investment. It's time for a different track.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It takes a lot to get 15 Economists to agree on anything - so the fact that we have all signed up to this letter is a clear sign of the danger we are in. Having promised to get the country back, we are needlessly exacerbating the current recession. A 🧵 img.scoop.co.nz/media/pdfs/2411/Economists_letter_to_PM_L…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There is a direct conflict between current fiscal policy and the aspiration to double exports. Aotearoa's historical reliance on volume commodity growth & low-value exports requires structural change- which will need significant investment. We haven't doubled exports in 10 years
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Given the urgency of the situation, we need urgent change. Continuing on the current course is simply guaranteeing misery for some with little reward. We are now one year into this government and economically we are firmly off-track. We need a plan - not more cuts and drift.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Unemployment data out today - it rose to 4.8%. Many people might be trying to tell you that's better than expected - and so things are okay. A closer look at the data shows otherwise. There are 29,000 more people unemployed since this government took office. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Unemployment didn’t hit 5%, but the underlying data shows the labour market is as weak as people fear. There have been layoffs at sites across New Zealand which won’t register yet in this data. The only plan for Kiwis appears to be welfare sanctions that won’t help.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Workers deserve to know what this government is going to do to create good, sustainable work. What it's going to do to help - not just what it's going to cut. We can't simply hope that the housing market stirs back into life and hope . New Zealand needs a better economic plan now
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Forgive a personal tweet. After destroying coalfield communities, the government then stole miners pensions. It’s only taken 30 years to put right. Congratulations to the miners on their campaign, and to @UKLabour for putting it right. www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2024/oct/31/former-miners-cel…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Monthly employment data released today by Statistics New Zealand showed our continuing labour market weakness, and particularly challenging conditions for young working people. Both wages and jobs are suffering right now. A 🧵www.stats.govt.nz/information-releases/employment-indicat…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This data shows that the labour market needs a plan – one that focusses on helping people into good, long-term work. Yet the government is doing the opposite – making work more insecure, taking away essential investment, and it has no employment plan except more sanctions
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There are things we could be doing to manage the pain being felt for working people right now. Schools, hospitals, housing, transport all need new investment. But the government is choosing not to deliver them. Its choosing unemployment instead.
-
Craig Renney reposted
Fleur Fitzsimons
@FleurFitzsimons
Huge crowd today in Wellington at our meeting to resist and oppose this Government’s destructive agenda.
Unions will keep this opposition up every day between now and the next election. This Government is dangerous and divisive and must be stopped. -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Today we stood up and fought back against a government that is destroying workers rights, and taking Aotearoa backwards. 740(ish) days to change this government and its anti-worker agenda.
-
Craig Renney reposted
New Zealand Council of Trade Unions
@NZ_CTU
The loss of 600 jobs will be devastating for Timaru and South Canterbury. It is unacceptable that there has been absolutely no help for the affected workers even though the Government has known since last month that this was likely to happen. union.org.nz/government-must-support-workers-following-sm…
-
Craig Renney reposted
Kieran McAnulty MP
@Kieran_McAnulty
Tough day at the office? Join a union
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data from by Stats NZ today shows inflation slowed to 2.2% annually, reflecting lower petrol prices and a weaker economy. petrol prices fell 8% & vegetable prices fell 18% annually. These reflect softer global demand, and a return to normal harvests after Cyclone Gabrielle. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
One of the biggest drivers of the fall in inflation was the reduction in early childhood costs associated with the new family boost payment. More than half of all eligible households aren’t claiming it – meaning its unlikely to be translating into families’ pockets for many
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Lower inflation is good news if it doesn’t come at a cost of much higher unemployment, which every forecast tells us will occur. With inflation now back on target, Government has no reason to not invest in making sure that unemployment doesn’t happen. Anything else is a choice.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
For the true Fiscal Policy Tifosi - The Financial Statements of Government were released today. They show that the government is choosing pain over a plan, with economic drift the key takeaway from the numbers. A thread...🧵
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This government has been in charge for most of the period this set of books covers. Spending and debt continues to grow - Net Core Crown Debt increased by $20bn, with revenue from taxation also rising by $8bn. The OBEGAL deficit increased $3.4bn last year alone, to $12.9bn.
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Spending on welfare has increased by 8%, with Jobseeker Support expenses rising by 17%. Unemployment is expected to rise significantly in the future, meaning that welfare expenses will be higher in the future. An extra 47,000 people are out of work this year alone
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Government has set aside $500m for the Cook Straight Ferry (iREX) Costs, which is only the cost of the works abandoned to date. It doesn’t include the cost of cancelling the contract, nor the cost of purchasing the replacement ferries . Its likely facing a $bn bill for that.
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Government’s fiscal strategy needs to change. Government debt is low by international standards, and there is no shortage of projects to invest in. These would improve employment and economic outcomes – both of which will benefit working people.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Government is still wedded to plan that will see unemployment rise, see public and private investment fall, and see cuts every year to public services. It’s time for a better plan.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
. @dbseymour on #qanda today you said that Fair Pay Agreements had a "Scathing negative opinion from the International Labour Organisation". Can you tell me where this opinion is? The ILO has been asked to comment once on FPA's. A Thread... www.youtube.com/watch?v=FSW4GJE26Rk
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The ILO discussed FPA's because of a complaint by Business NZ. The findings are here. The Committee simply asked the Government to keep working with social partners while developing the legislation, essentially giving FPA's the ILO seal of approval normlex.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f?p=NORMLEXPUB:13100:0::NO…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
FPAs are currently being considered by the incoming Labour Government in the UK "We will start by establishing a new Fair Pay Agreement in the adult social care sector". Can you point them to the ILO scathing review? labour.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/MakeWorkPay.pdf
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Fair Pay Agreements were designed to give workers a voice and opportunity to bargain. To improve health & safety. To lift productivity & wages. All things seen overseas where these deals are common - including Australia. Things your government is systematically stripping away.
-
Craig Renney reposted
Rachel Brooking (she/her)
@BrookingRachel
National campaigned on a very specific Dunedin Hospital rebuild. They did not campaign on a vague fit for purpose promise that Shane Reti is now referring to. A potential retrofit, new site, or fewer floors is a huge backtrack. And a disgrace. 🏥
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It's been 52 years since the signing of the Equal Pay Act - and analysis released by the CTU shows that its going to take until 2055 to reach gender pay equality across New Zealand. But the story for women is much worse than that. A thread...
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This year the mean gender pay gap is 8.9% - this is down from 9.8% last year. But if we compare European men to all women the pay gap is 14.4% - and it got worse last year, up from 13.9%. During COVID progress went backwards
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If we forecast the changes since 2008 for the overall gender pay gap, then it will take a further 31 years (2055) until we close the gap - 83 years since the Equal Pay Act. Closing the gap to European males will take until 2067, or 95 years since the Equal Pay Act.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Progress has been painfully slow. But it got a bit faster thanks to recent pay equity deals. Closing the Pay Equity Unit in government will slow that down, as will not maintaining existing pay equity deals. Lifting the minimum wage by less than inflation hurts women more as well
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We can make estimates of the missing wages for women if they were to achieve parity in wages today - or $3.73 an hour. For a full-time worker (at 40 hours a week) this represents $149.20 a week, or $7,758 a year. This generating an annual loss in wages to women of $7.2bn per year
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
For Wahine Maori this is October 14th. For Asian women it's October 21st. For women overall against European men this is November 8th. There is no justification for perpetuating inequality by failing to act to raise women’s pay
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There are no good reasons why this pay gap exists, and recent policy announcements will make closing this harder.A downturn and rising unemployment will compound this issue. It is clearly untenable for the gender pay gap to continue to exist until 2055. Action is needed today.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I was going to write something about this - but Lilly has put it far more eloquently and accurately than I could. If we care about productivity, delivery, capability, or cost - this is a bad idea.
Lilly Leadbeater
@mintyhiggins
Hoo boy, this is a bad idea. Objectively this is such a conservative and dated approach to ways of working that will backfire on the public service and we the public will pay the price
Let me give you the reasons it’s not a good idea 🧵 www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/528779/watch-nicola-willis-d… -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
. @Amelia__Wade has a great story about the scale of cuts required if the government is to achieve its spending targets. I thought that I might add a little more information to that article. A 🧵 www.waikatotimes.co.nz/politics/350423568/why-scale-gover…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
People have been told that public sector pay is growing fast, and is out of control. In fact, public sector pay on average hasn't recovered from the COVID cost of living crisis. That's mainly because of the 2021 Workforce Policy Statement, where pay was held for many.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The wage bill for government hasn't grown significantly for a long time - its actually grown in line with the economy. According to Treasury data, public service pay as a % of GDP has been the same since 2002. Even with COVID, Cyclones, Earthquakes, and everything else
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Nor are there large amounts of new public sector staff - despite what some may claim. The public sector has grown at the same rate as the workforce. Since 1999, the proportion of the workforce in the public sector has remained the same - at 20%. It was higher under Jim Bolger!
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Pay isn't rising more quickly than the private sector - over time its rising at the same rate. The Stats NZ Quarterly Employment Survey shows public and private sector pay essentially mirroring each other since 2002. Public sector pay actually lags private since 2021
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
All this background is important because the 2024 Workforce Policy Statement is trying to tackle a problem that only exists because the government has chosen to give around $15bn in tax cuts mainly to landlords and higher income earners. www.publicservice.govt.nz/assets/DirectoryFile/Government…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
When that says "Ensure that all workforce costs, including the outcomes of remuneration reviews and collective bargaining are affordable within an agency’s baseline" - it means every increase must come from cuts somewhere else. No $$$ to pay for changes even for population growth
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
And those cuts are huge. If pay increases in line with average change since 2002, that means finding $5.5bn a year in cuts for four years. If we take the 5 years after the GFC, that means cuts of $3.5bn. Expected cuts at the last budget were just $1.6bn. budget.govt.nz/budget/pdfs/summary-initiatives/b24-sum-in…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
These cuts apply to teachers, police, health workers, customs, firefighters, social workers, defence, universities, and everyone else in the public sector. These are exactly the front line workers you were promised would be protected under this government. www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2024/04/prime-minister-ch…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
And let us not think that this is a cost free decision - something that won't affect you if you work in the private sector. These are workers with skills that are in demand globally. The wait time in A&E won't get shorter if there are no staff www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/525072/people-leave-new-zeala…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We don't need to be here. There is no public sector pay crisis, nor a crisis of overemployment in the sector. The actual crisis is one of systematic underinvestment, and cuts will make this worse. We are manufacturing a crisis to manufacture tax cuts. Are we back on track yet?
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data released by Stats NZ today showed that the size of the economy fell -0.2% in the June Quarter. GDP in June was smaller than June 2023 – meaning no real growth in the economy for at least a year. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Every other country highlighted by Stats NZ saw growth in Jun 2024. Oz, Canada, China, EU, Japan, UK & US. None of these are proposing the economic and fiscal approach being delivered in New Zealand. We are at risk of making a bad situation worse
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
With jobs being lost across Aotearoa, and falling GDP, this is the time to rethink what we are doing. Softer growth and lower interest rates will feed through to lower tax revenues, putting the governments books further at risk
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There are things the government could be doing to make sure that the economy returns to growth, and that the recovery benefits all New Zealanders. We have an energy crisis costing jobs rights now. Building sites are lying idle and workers heading overseas
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Rebuilding Aotearoa now will help with the recovery and make growth less inflationary when it returns. It’s time to change economic track, and build great jobs and a better economy. The cuts right now aren't working for anyone.
-
Craig Renney reposted
Rachel Brooking (she/her)
@BrookingRachel
👀Minister Reti just said Dunedin Hospital build will be “phased” and sounded like it would not be a vertical build - module builds mentioned. Hansard to come. Exceptionally concerning. 🏥 #dunedin @odtnews @southernscoop
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Calculations from CTU show the government will waste millions of dollars taking the already failed Treaty Principles Bill forward. The process is estimated to cost $4.15m, enough to pay for around 40 nurses. The same amount that Wairarapa Hospital is currently short. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There is still time to save some of the costs associated with this failed bill – but only if actors like the Prime Minister acts now. This would not only save money, it would also signal to the public that they shouldn’t waste their time on this bill. Everyone would be better off
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
More details here. This is a waste - like Bootcamps, Charter Schools, tobacco excise changes, and the canning of the IREX project. There is a repeated pattern of not understanding real costs or what they mean. www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/527744/extremely-conservativ…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Energy data released last night by the Electricity Authority shows that big generators made big margins in their generation activities - $119m in one week alone. $512m over six weeks - equivalent to $4.4bn annually. That profit comes at a cost. A 🧵 public.tableau.com/app/profile/electricity.authority/viz/…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
To put that $4.4bn into context, that is more than we spent last year on secondary education ($3.7bn). Hundreds of jobs have been lost as New Zealand electricity becomes the most expensive in the developed world www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/524692/human-cost-of-energy-c…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This increase in price is not because of unexpected demand. It's because electricity generation didn't increase while profits did. In our report with @labourcartel @FIRST_Union @350nz We showed a decade of lost investment while dividends rose to new highs union.org.nz/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/Generating-Scarci…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
MBIE electricity generation shows this best. In 2023 NZ generated 43,000 GWH of electricity - the same as in 2010. Our population increased by 888,000 during this time and Nominal GDP doubled. Yet no new electricity. The market has failed year after year.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Wholesale energy prices rose 900% from August last year. Future prices for electricity are still well above (more than double) their long-term average - this pain isn't going away anytime soon. How many more jobs have to be lost before we do something about it?
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Mercury has just announced that its profits are up 159% from last year. Contact Energy profits up 85%. Yet about 110,000 households are living in energy poverty. The data is for 2022 as the new govt has stopped collecting this information. Wonder why? www.mbie.govt.nz/about/news/new-analysis-shows-110000-hou…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This is what happens when a market is given all of the wrong incentives. Profit maximisation has led to a lack of investment. Renewable energy could be the driving force behind growth in a more sustainable economy but the market is holding it back. When that happens we should act
-
Craig Renney reposted
edward miller
@labourcartel
Re-upping this: from 2016 to 2020, gentailer dividends were more than four times the level of capital investment into new generating capacity. High energy prices have nothing to do with offshore gas and everything to do with privatisation and a decade of lost investment.
-
Craig Renney reposted
Max Rashbrooke
@MaxRashbrooke
My @TheSpinoffTV latest looks at the data on what happened last time National cracked down on beneficiaries. Spoiler alert: it wasn't great. thespinoff.co.nz/politics/15-08-2024/what-happened-last-t…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Reserve Bank cut the Official Cash Rate by 0.25% to 5.25% today. The Bank cited “a broad range of indicators suggesting the economy is contracting faster than anticipated” leading the Reserve Bank to forecast inflation to fall to 2.3% in September this year. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
With GDP falling, demand falling, employment falling, and average wages forecast to rise in real terms by just 0.2% over the next year (instead of 1.7% in June 2023) this is a really worrying set of forecasts. It's now possible to see why the Bank chose to cut.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
But it looks like the damage has been done - and government policy is making this worse. Inflation will be in the target band inside the next 6 weeks - but cuts to government investment continue for more than a year. It's time to change track.
-
Craig Renney reposted
Big Hairy Network
@bighairynetwork
#bhn It's an active choice by National for the unemployment rate to rise higher than it needs to, different decisions would lead to different outcomes #nzpol @CLRenney
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Unemployment Data released by Statistics New Zealand shows the unemployment rate accelerating to 4.6%, and worrying labour market trends that should spur the government into action. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Right now the government should be taking urgent action to get ahead of what could become a much deeper crisis. GDP is likely to fall again. Planned Cuts to infrastructure and other spending by government will make that already grim situation worse
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There is an urgent need for an economic plan to tackle these issues, help keep New Zealanders in work, and to support those who lose their jobs during these difficult times. Right now there is no plan.
-
Craig Renney reposted
Camilla Belich MP
National is not the party for workers. Here are 8 reasons why www.labour.org.nz/workers_under_national
Christopher Luxon
@chrisluxonmp
National is the for party for workers, for law and order, and for rural NZ. We are the party that rebuilds the economy so we have more money for health and education.
That's what brings us together for our 88th annual conference this weekend, and it's what guides us in Government. -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
New welfare data is out, and the numbers aren't great. Those in receipt of income support has increased significantly over the past year. Worryingly, sanctions have also risen materially. Taking a dive into the numbers reveals some odd details. A 🧵
www.msd.govt.nz/about-msd-and-our-work/publications-resou…Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This big increase in sanctions comes at a time when labour market pressures are growing - fewer job openings, and growing unemployment, and more people chasing each job. It seems like an odd time to take a punitive approach rather than one centred on families needs.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Finally, we should listen to the experts on the Welfare Expert Advisory Group who said there was "little evidence in support of using obligations and sanctions (as in the current system) to change behaviour; rather, there is research indicating that they compound social harm".
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data released by Stats NZ shows that annual inflation was 3.3%, falling by nearly half from a year ago. This data is weaker than expected – highlighting problems in the wider economy, supporting other data which suggests we might be heading back into falls in economic output”. 🧵
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The falls in information were driven by reductions in the price of food, particularly fruit and vegetables. There were falls in the price of furniture, IT, household appliances, and second-hand vehicles. This data suggests a lack of demand in the economy and consumer confidence.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Rents continue to increase rapidly – up 4.8% annually. The fastest rate of growth for at least 17 years. Rates increased 9.8%. Insurance prices increased 14%, led by property (24%) and car insurance (24%). Petrol prices up 14.7%. These are costs that are very difficult to avoid.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This data will be welcomed by those looking for interest rates to fall. But they also suggest that economic growth is stalling, and action is needed now to support employment and household incomes. Cuts in investment at the Budget are likely to exacerbate this problem further.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Before the government claims credit for this, the cuts in the Budget haven't happened yet. The general falls in inflation have also been predicted for a while. Inflation is still hurting as prices that people can't avoid are still rising. The medicine isn't working.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It’s hard to put in words what the UK election means to me. I was born in 1979 when Thatcher came to office. My first vote was the Blair election of 1997. I came to NZ because of the Cameron austerity programme. The result today is a chance to turn the page on that history.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Today, @NZ_CTU and 18 organisations have released an open letter asking the Government to follow Australia and ban the use, supply and manufacture of engineered stone products. Silicosis is a debilitating disease with no cure. A ban will save lives. union.org.nz/19-organisations-send-brooke-van-velden-open…
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Occupational disease is the biggest killer of workers in NZ. Work-related health issues kill between 750 and 900 workers each year - 17 workers a week. Every 15 minutes a worker is injured at work so badly they require more than a week away from work. data.worksafe.govt.nz
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Banning the use, supply and manufacture of engineered stone products, is the right thing to do. Each generation has to confront materials that were once thought safe - like asbestos, lead, and PCBs. Alternatives to engineered stone are readily
available. We can stop this today. -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Minister of Employment Relations launched a new front on workplace conditions. If implemented it would be arguably the biggest threat to workers' core rights for a generation. Its consulting on if you should be allowed to call yourself an employee. A🧵 www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/520467/government-pushes-ahe…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Employment Relations Act 2000 states a court can determine whether you are an employee. That gives you access to holidays, sick leave, pay equity, the Minimum Wage, ACC, health and safety, and Kiwisaver. If you are an employee, you get all of these benefits. If not, you don’t
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Minister is considering making the contract you signed at the beginning of your employment more important than your actual work today. Right now, you can go to court. That's what UBER drivers have been doing so successfully here @FIRST_Union www.rnz.co.nz/news/business/477319/court-deems-uber-drive…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
ACT policy is “amend the Employment Relations Act so that contractors who have explicitly signed up for a contracting arrangement can’t challenge their employment status in court”. If you signed a contracting arrangement you would be stuck on it forever. www.act.org.nz/freedom-to-contract
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If you want to see what that looks like in New Zealand, look no further than our Postal Service. It's talking about firing around 700 Posties, and then rehiring them as self-employed contractors. They would lose their current benefits to do the same job www.newshub.co.nz/home/politics/2024/03/union-takes-fight…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Some might say this is okay – where workers have freely signed up to an agreement. That ignores the thousands of cases where workers are exploited. With a rising unemployment rate and cost of living that power imbalance will lead to abuse. We have our current law for a reason.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Many might think that this won't affect them. Sadly, economics dictates the race to the bottom inevitably occurs. Rogue bosses are freed to push costs down, make profits, and win business. Competitive pressures push more workers into involuntary contracting. We are all worse off.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This is just the latest example of the government reducing the security that workers have. 90 day trials return. Removing sick leave. Real terms cuts in minimum wages. We're not building an economy based on good work & productivity but on the back of low pay and poor conditions
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
New Zealand already has one of the most liberal, flexible regimes in the developed world when it comes to work. If adopted, this would likely lead to widespread exploitation. There is no economic, social, or regulatory case for change. We shouldn’t head backward like this.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
In 2023 MUNZ said "The upgrade of the ferries is not an option for New Zealand...failure to modernise this essential infrastructure leaves NZ exposed to further delays, service outages, expense for industry, & serious safety issues for crew & passengers" union.org.nz/cutting-ferry-investment-to-subsidise-proper…🧵
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The grounding of the Aratere is a warning about the current state of the Interislander service. New Zealand has now found itself lucky twice with the Interislander. In 2023, the Kaitaki lost all power with more than 800 passengers on board. Now the Aratere is stranded in Picton
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
$15bn of cargo is carried annually by Interislander, 4% of our GDP. It transports 800k passengers a year. Its central to our economic resilience. Yet government has recently ditched funding for coastal shipping, and losing the Aratere puts more us at risk newsroom.co.nz/2024/03/18/coastal-shipping-plans-continue…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
These are aging ships that require more intensive repair and maintenance – as we discovered last year when the Kaiarahi service was canceled for days. It's time they were replaced with safe & efficient ferries. It's in everyone’s interest that the service is seaworthy
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The decision to cancel the replacement ferries should be urgently reviewed in light of the developments overnight. The replacement ships from Korea could have been here from next year. There is no date for their replacement now. transporttalk.co.nz/news/govt-axes-interislander-ferry-re…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This is a symbol of the direction of this Government. We can’t get power to Northland. A key ferry service is grounded. Yet investment by government in infrastructure will fall every year under the new Budget. The priorities of this Government are all wrong.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Finally, this should not provide an excuse for government to privatise the service. Ministers should rule this out right now. Privately run utilities are no guarantee of service - just google "Thames Water". We all benefit from a well-run service - we just have to invest in it
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
GDP data out today shows the economy grew by just 0.2% annually - showing stalled growth and weak demand. On a per capita basis, GDP fell by 2.4%. There has now been 6 successive quarters of per capita decline, the worst since the GFC. The growth figure is camouflaging weakness.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Business investment fell 0.5% overall, led by a decline in plant, machinery and equipment. Households annual consumption of durable and non-durable goods fell 2.6%. This is a very weak set of accounts. Annual GDP growth is worse than Oz, Canada, EU, US, and OECD average of 1.7%
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Countries that have invested in their productive capacity – such as the US – have seen much stronger and more sustained growth. Now should be the time that we invest in Aotearoa. Growth is being held back by a lack of investment, both by the government and the private sector.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There is no confidence in the economic management of this country because there is no plan for anything except a tax cut, and reducing government investment in areas such as housing, research and development, and climate change. That is showing through this data.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Ed Miller @labourcartel and I have a piece up on one of the underreported cuts in the Budget - $47m being taken away from Bus Drivers. Not to support public transport, but to support tax relief for Landlords. Something to think about when the bus is late. www.thepress.co.nz/nz-news/350313432/budget-slash-risks-a…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
. @cjsbishop in your interview on www.youtube.com/watch?v=2JEi1nplmUM you ask people to read the ‘discussion document’ on proposed holiday & sick leave changes. Can you tell us where that is? According to MBIE there won’t be any documents available to the public until September
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
MBIE state “In September 2024 MBIE will send consultation participants the exposure draft of the Bill” - that’s here www.mbie.govt.nz/business-and-employment/employment-and-s…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Where and when will this discussion document be made public? You state that you will be “seeking the feedback”. But the government is running a “targeted consultation” process - not involving the public. So how do they respond?
-
Craig Renney reposted
edward miller
@labourcartel
Do you remember when we *solved* the bustatrophe by - reads notes - moderately improving working conditions? Well we’re bringing it back! Nicola Willis’ budget hacks out $47m over next 4 yrs assigned for penal rates and split shifts. Do these people have any idea how cities work
-
Craig Renney reposted
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Joe Biden said, “Don’t tell me what you value, show me your budget and I’ll tell you what you value”. This Budget shows the values of this Government - ideological wants before real need. This Budget fails the most important test going, will it help deliver a better Aotearoa. A🧵
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Nicola Willis said that her tax package would not “require any additional borrowing”. Treasury says the government will now borrow an extra $17.1bn by 2028. Tax cuts cost nearly $10bn. Without cuts, borrowing would be lower. Future taxpayers are going to pay for tax cuts today
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
That might be okay if tax cuts were going to those with the highest needs. A couple on Superannuation ($4.30 a week) will get around a tenth of the tax cut being promised to a couple earning $300,000 ($40.09 a week). Only tiny numbers of people will get the full $250 a fortnight
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It would be easy to blame this Budget on malice – to frame the Government as being simply indifferent. That would be the wrong. Rather, what this Budget demonstrates is that the current Government places its political survival over the very real investment needs of the country.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Government is squeezing the cost of school meals while giving landlords $3bn in tax reductions. This is despite the Minister of Finance admitting today that it won’t do anything for rising rents. Everything in this Budget is a choice. The Government has chosen the wrong approach.
-
Craig Renney reposted
Kieran McAnulty MP
@Kieran_McAnulty
I don’t trust the National Party on housing, but I was still shocked to see reports tonight that they’re going to scrap the First Home Grant.
Throughout our time in Govt they pushed us to expand the grant. Now it’s gone to pay for tax cuts.
Hypocrites, plain and simple. -
Craig Renney reposted
Wellington Phoenix 🔥
@WgtnPhoenixFC
OMG ASDKJSNFKSLDF:ag;skrljgvkfwdhvlfk
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I’m standing with some workers affected by the ending of support for the pay equity unit. Which is everyone. This will mean it will become harder and more expensive to make sure that people are being paid fairly.
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
According to the PSA this is the third time that National has cut support for pay equity services - 1990, 2009, and 2024. There are still 25 pay equity claims outstanding - this will save nothing, it simply makes the cost of settling these claims harder and more expensive.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It staggers belief that this is something this government is going to cut. They may claim they support pay equity, but their actions say otherwise. New Zealand should proud of the progress made to date - we should all fight to make sure that support for pay equity continues
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Unemployment data today from Stats NZ today shows a rise from 3.4% in March 2023 to 4.3% in March 2024. That's an extra 31,000 people unemployed - with the data showing the fastest rises for women, kaimahi Māori, and Pacific Peoples. The time to act is now. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We shouldn't accept that job losses and families being thrown into poverty are the right way to manage the economy. Add to this real-term cuts to the minimum wage and cuts to welfare, and there are all the ingredients needed for worker exploitation and increasing child poverty.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Govt has a chance to act before unemployment rises further - to help make sure workers and their whānau don’t bear the costs of their changes. This should be a wake-up call. Unemployment is rising, but there is no plan to deal with the increase in those who will need help.
-
Craig Renney reposted
Jenée Tibshraeny
@JeneeTibshraeny
Productivity is failing to fire - is red tape or the nature of what we produce in NZ to blame?
The economists I spoke to (Dave Heatley & @CLRenney) shared differing views on the causes and solutions.
www.nzherald.co.nz/business/productivity-fails-to-fire-wh… -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Data today shows headline CPI inflation at 4%, in line with market expectations, and continuing the fall begun in March 2023. It also shows inflation at twice the increase in the Minimum Wage, taking money out of the pockets of those with the least. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Pricing for goods that in the past have generated inflation such as food are now much more subdued. Vegetable prices have fallen nearly 15% annually according to this report, and groceries rose by less than headline inflation
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
However, petrol prices rose by 12% from last year. This is a worry as petrol rises tend to lead future inflation. The faster we can transition to an electric vehicle fleet, and high-quality accessible public transport, the better. Which sadly is the opposite of what we are doing
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Inflation is still higher in New Zealand than it is in other comparable countries such as Australia or the USA, where economic and employment growth is also stronger on the back of strong infrastructure spending, government investment, and higher wages.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Prices in New Zealand are instead responding to pressures such as population growth and climate change. The absence of both a plan and investment from government in these areas suggests an absence of action on future price rises. It's time we had a plan - not just a cut.
-
Craig Renney reposted
Barbara Edmonds
@BarbEdmondsMana
After months and months of gaslighting NZ’s debt level, the Minister of Finance has finally confirmed they will be borrowing more. They wouldn’t need to borrow more if they hadn’t promised tax cuts.
-
Craig Renney reposted
New Zealand Council of Trade Unions
@NZ_CTU
If the PM really cared about working people, he wouldn’t be getting rid of jobs, he wouldn’t have cut the minimum wage, and he wouldn’t have scrapped Fair Pay Agreements, which would have lifted the pay of hundreds of thousands of low-income workers. www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/unions-slam-prime-ministers-comment…
-
Craig Renney reposted
Hayden Donnell
@HaydenDonnell
Amazing Australia can provide such better quality of life when it has unaffordable and economically destructive policies like Fair Pay Agreements, capital gains taxes, an income tax-free threshold, 45% tax on income over $190k, and a higher minimum wage www.stuff.co.nz/nz-news/350235186/life-infinitely-better-…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
April 1st usually sees the usual array of people who think that it’s funny to trick you. I don’t usually expect governments to join in, but this year has seen the Coalition Government provide an example with the Minimum Wage increase of 2%. Only this isn’t a joke. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It's important to understand that this isn’t an accident. The government has made a choice. Its chosen to set the Minimum Wage at a level that will make people poorer in real terms. Its chosen to make tackling child poverty harder. Its choice won’t tackle inflation or save jobs.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It’s difficult to come to any other conclusion from this analysis that this government is out of touch with the realities of workers on the Minimum Wage. Low-income and vulnerable workers need to be protected from changes such as this. We all pay for failing to make work pay.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The coalition government has released its Budget Policy Statement today, which is supposed to provide guidance and certainty around the forthcoming Budget. Sadly, both of these are in short supply. It reads like 8 pages of excuses for not doing your homework. A thread 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
After fearmongering for so long about our debt position, the BPS now accepts that our debt levels are within the bounds of “prudence on debt sustainability". Yet somehow our priority is cutting debt further - meaning lower investment in the future.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The worsening economic forecasts set out by the Treasury were expected. Inflation is falling more quickly than expected, caused by unemployment rising and growth stalling. Now is the time for Government to act responsibly by investing in NZ and raising its productive future.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
However, the government appears to be acting pro-cyclically – cutting investment and spending at a time when the economy is in the doldrums. This document shows that the government has no plan for sustainably growing the economy or creating good jobs
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There is no economic case made within this document for tax cuts, particularly tax cuts for higher-income earners or landlords. There is nothing to meet the demands of a growing population with higher needs. Instead, it’s a return to the rhetoric that saw mould in hospital walls
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
New Zealanders who read the Budget Policy Statement will find it short of information and short of ideas. It’s not surprising that analysts weren’t allowed to access the government lock-up for this information release, as they would have found little to say. Kiwis deserve better.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
GDP numbers show that the economy shrank into a technical recession, declining by -0.1% in the December 2023 quarter, following a -0.3% decline in September. We shouldn't overinterpret one quarter of data - but it does point to some wider concerns. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This data should act as a wake-up call about our economic direction. Those countries with an active economic plan based on investment – like the US – are seeing strong economic growth. This government is heading in the opposite direction, and delivering more economic insecurity
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Central government expenditure in New Zealand fell 2.2% on average across the past year, so excuses about government spending shouldn’t hold any weight. This is not the time for cuts, it’s the time for investment that will benefit all New Zealanders – not just a select few.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Please note the date.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The CTU has costed Nationals election spending plans because it continues not to. union.org.nz/billions-missing-to-deliver-national-party-p… The analysis shows that there is a $3.3bn to $5.2bn gap in their spending plans
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The fiscal gap of $5.6bn currently identified is very likely an underestimate. Climate change funding is supposed to provide $2.4bn for tax cuts. That's now in doubt - with the Climate Commission calling ETS revenue "not a reliable source of income" www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/climate-change-commission-…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The good news is that none of this needs to happen. It's all a choice for this government. We can choose to invest in New Zealand - not in landlords. We can choose to maintain essential services. Budgets are about values - you show your values with your choices.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Changes to taxation for landlords have blown out in cost and might have taken the Government's tax plans with them. At the election, the National party claimed that the return of interest deductibility would cost $2.1bn. Now we discover it's going to cost nearly $800m more. A🧵
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This Government appears to have its priorities all wrong. It is committed to fattening the wallets of landlords, but it won’t commit to feeding hungry children in schools. There is no economic evidence that shows this tax cut will lead to lower rents www.treasury.govt.nz/publications/jp/what-drives-rents-ne…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Oh hugely. It’s really important that we encourage new building. I would maintain and improve quality standards on property - but liberalise hugely the density and location restrictions.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I might be tempted to go further and seek incentives like GST reductions on brownfield development or mixed-use building types, as a means of delivering regional economic development
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This will likely mean deeper cuts to public services to pay for this plan. That in turn will impact every community around New Zealand. These are huge sums of $ that could be invested - instead, it's going to inflate the housing market and force first-home buyers to the sidelines
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
It’s not too late to change. The Government should withdraw this bill and first explain to New Zealanders why nearly $3bn needs to be spent this way, instead of rebuilding the 350 schools that have been paused. It’s time to change track and invest in New Zealand, not landlords.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The CTU has launched the "Investing in a Growing Population" report. It examines our population using a range of forecasts & shows that there is up to a $20bn investment gap if it continues to grow at current rates - before the government's planned cuts.🧵
union.org.nz/public-investment-in-new-zealand-fails-to-me…Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Government could use the money that it is currently proposing to give to landlords and higher-income earners to help close the gap. Budgets are about values, and this Government still has time to show that it cares about New Zealand’s growing population and its growing needs
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Importantly, nothing in this analysis should place any blame on migrants for this. Our economy and society are stronger because of immigration. Many of our essential public services and private firms would struggle to function if migrants did not come to New Zealand.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Child Poverty released today shows that after years of falling child poverty numbers, the number of children estimated to be living in poverty increased on all three of the measures. After years of progress on child poverty we are now going backwards. A thread...
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This data is likely to get worse as a consequence of the governments programme. Unemployment is forecast to rise, and needs will get higher. This government must show that it a deliverable plan to reduce child poverty that puts their welfare first – ahead of anything else.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
If we fail to do tackle child poverty, then we are condemning thousands of children to the worst start in life. If social investment means anything to this government then it needs to act now. Simply saying that reducing inflation solves this isn't enough - children need help now
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
So saddened to hear of the death of Fa’anānā Efeso Collins today, a champion of the Living Wage and worker rights. In his maiden speech to parliament, Efeso said "I’ve come to this House to help. Helping is a deliberate act". He helped. union.org.nz/nzctu-statement-on-faanana-efeso-collins/
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Grant Robertson was not only my boss. He was a friend and source of inspiration. His workrate was phenomenal, & capacity to understand enormous. Thankfully for me he was also patient, and a thoroughly decent human. I will miss hearing him in Parliament. Otago is lucky to have him
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Some thoughts ($) on the minimum wage change. Post the election, one commentator said this was an "anti-woke" government. Right now it isn't leading a war on woke - its prosecuting a war on the broke. One committed to removing security from New Zealanders
www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/minimum-wage-increase-ignores-the-r…
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
We should keep investing in essential public services. We should make sure welfare changes don’t push more children into poverty. We should set the minimum wage at the Living Wage, a level calculated by experts. We should do better. Sign the petition at
www.together.org.nz/stop_minimum_wage_cutsand -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The decision today by to government to cut the Minimum Wage in real terms is a sign of what the government thinks about workers. Inflation is currently 4.7%, and a 2% increase means real terms cuts for the lowest income workers across New Zealand. A 🧵
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The proposal wasn’t even supported by MBIE officials, who recommended a 4% increase, rather than a 2% increase. That’s an annual difference of $944.32. If the minimum wage had kept up with inflation, that would have been a $1,274 difference annually – or $24.52 a week.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
These losses dwarf the tax changes that the government is proposing – meaning those workers will be worse off in real terms even after any tax changes. The government is also proposing to increase welfare payments by less than in the past, and cut investment in public services.
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
This is a government that doesn’t seem to know how difficult life is for the poorest New Zealanders. How are workers meant to keep up with rising food and rent costs if the government is cutting their wages in real terms?
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Taking money away from hundreds of thousands of workers during a cost-of-living crisis defies understanding, and is poor economics. The government should do the right thing and deliver a minimum wage that doesn’t see New Zealand workers fall further behind.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
James Shaw was consistently one of the most thoughtful, decent, and insightful MP's that I have had the honour of working with. Parliament will be a poorer place without him there. Thank you @jamespeshaw for your tireless efforts in making Aotearoa a better place.
Green Party NZ
@NZGreens
After eight historic years leading the Green Party, James Shaw has announced he is resigning as co-leader. A new co-leader will be announced on 10th March.
Thank you for everything, James. -
Craig Renney reposted
New Zealand Council of Trade Unions
@NZ_CTU
CTU President Richard Wagstaff is calling on Minister Brooke van Velden for a total ban on engineered stone to protect workers’ health. Exposure to the silica dust from cutting engineered stone can cause the fatal lung disease silicosis. This needs to be addressed urgently.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Inflation fell to a two-year low of 4.7% today. If we measure what has been happening over the past three months inflation is now back at the Reserve Bank target rate. But these high-level numbers hide some really interesting things going on underneath. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Inflation has now fallen from 7.2% to 4.7% without significant cuts to government spending, and on a quarterly basis is now within the the target range. Inflation doesn’t appear to have been driven by government spending in any significant way.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Promises to reduce current inflation by cutting public spending should therefore be treated with a high degree of caution. Instead, those cuts will simply hurt service services, with negative economic benefit overall. Cuts in essential services cost us all in the long-run.
-
Craig Renney reposted
Phil Quin
@philquin
Co-host @CLRenney and I sat down with the brilliant @drayeshaverrall for the first episode of Behind the Cycle, a new podcast on NZ politics from a Labour perspective. Full episode drops tomorrow.
Never fear, Dr. Verrall lets rip on Smokefree walkback & its enabler, Shane Reti. -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Mini-Budget today. Despite the Incoming Government calling for clarity on existing spending, the mini-Budget today does not provide any analysis of the tax cut or spending programme of the incoming Government. It's very thin - it's basically 10 pages of press release. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The government is claiming that it is cutting $1.5bn of spending annually. Of that is third are savings commitments made by the previous government. A further $0.4bn aren't cuts - it's a spending transfer to early childcare support. So only $0.6bn of the $1.5bn is new.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
$1bn of the savings come from Let's Get Wellington Moving, and from cuts to the Climate Emergency Response Fund - through the National Land Transport Fund. That's money coming from fuel taxes to pay for tax cuts. It's simply robbing Peter to pay Paul.
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
There appears to still be a debate within government about when key planks of the tax cut package will be delivered. Nothing in this package helps with the cost of living today for workers across Aotearoa. New Zealanders have to wait to find out what the plan is.
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The Minister of Finance said that she knew how much was going to be cut from each department. She said she knew what the tax plan was. Yet she hasn't chosen to share that with New Zealand. The Government should be making this clear today.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The CTU has taken a look at the costs of the Cook Strait Ferry upgrade (sometimes called the IReX Project). It's a huge deal, with a huge price tag. The recent decision by the Coalition Government to end it however should be viewed against the other decisions they have made. A 🧵
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
National was elected to ‘get our country back on track’ – yet it's going to derail a transport link between the North & South Islands, carrying $14bn of freight and 850k people each year. It's an example of the Government knowing the cost of something but not its real value
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
I have had a quick go at costing the current coalition negotiation, and the options open to NZ First and the National Party. it’s not an easy task that is ahead of them, and they face some tough decision. A thread…
www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/craig-renney-difficult-tax-choices-… -
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
@labourcartel and I have a piece in the Spinoff on the need for industry bargaining in NZ. It’s a big part of the solution to our productivity problem. National should think carefully before removing something that would deliver such long-term benefits. thespinoff.co.nz/politics/24-10-2023/if-luxon-wants-to-cu…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
New analysis by NZCTU has revealed that New Zealanders under the age of 44 would face an effective ‘Pension Tax’ if National brings in its reform of the superannuation age from 65 to 67 in the next term. The tax is much greater than the value of Nationals tax cut proposals. A 🧵
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
New Zealand Council of Trade Unions analysis has revealed that a select group of landlords would be made tax-cut millionaires if National Party landlord tax breaks are delivered. At the same time 350,000 people, including the disabled, risk seeing their incomes cut. A thread 🧵
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
According to the Cambridge Dictionary, a plan is "a method for doing or achieving something". National's 100-point economic plan has lots of things in it - but that's not the same thing as being a plan. And some of the elements could do with more thought. A short 🧵
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Stu, this is not the insult you believe it is. One day I hope to be as educated, erudite, and eloquent as @SiouxsieW. New Zealand is lucky to have her here.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The CTU has costed Nationals election spending plans because it continues not to. union.org.nz/billions-missing-to-deliver-national-party-p… The analysis shows that there is a $3.3bn to $5.2bn gap in their spending plans
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Off to talk to colleagues here about Fair Pay Agreements, and why they make such an important and positive difference to workers and workplaces. New Zealand is once again leading the way.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The CTU has costed Nationals Tax Package because it consistently refuses to. The clear take-away from $bns in tax cuts is that it is geared to those on the very highest incomes, with more than 2m New Zealanders getting $2.15 a week or less. A thread...
Post not available here, view on X
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Tax cuts are about priorities. National has chosen to prioritise giving a huge tax cut to the already wealthy. If we had $11bn available - is that the very best plan for it? Even if you like tax cuts, you could design a package that was much fairer than this for low incomes
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
National says it will pay for its plan with cuts - which at this size is barely credible. But look at who is winning from the package - very high-income earners and landlords. Everyone else will face degraded public services when they need them.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
NZ Company profit levels are up 26.2% last year. Genesis energy profit up 600%, Mercury Energy up 233%. Banking profits up to record levels. Supermarkets made $1m in excess profits a day. I support @NZGreens in examining a windfall tax & investing in a better economy for everyone
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
The poverty of right-wing economic analysis leads to the poverty of their solutions. Some thoughts from me 👉🏻 www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/craig-renney-falling-wages-is-a-rig…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Inflation at 7.3% hurts everyone - but not everyone equally. Petrol prices up 32.5% annually. Rent is up 4.3%. Food increased by 6.5%. These are costs that can’t be avoided and so will eat into the budgets of those with the least ability to pay.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
ACT does know that this is actually an advert for FPAs right?www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/128595633/transtasman-w…
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Labour Day commemorates the struggle for an eight-hour working day, first won in New Zealand in 1840. It was first celebrated in 1890. It’s not surprising that National wants to get rid of a long-standing public holiday that celebrates workers’ rights.
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Luxon seems determined to undermine what little economic credibility National has left. Cutting investment in the critical public services to pay for a tax cut for the highest income New Zealanders would be an act of economic self-harm. CTU view here: news.fuseworksmedia.com/5df50f2a-d740-437d-adc7-c73fdfe04a9a
-
Craig Renney
@CLRenney
Luxon has just said that "people don't want more platitudes from the podium". Whilst giving a speech (from behind a podium) that gave no:
- timetable
- policy details
- analysis
- understanding of who will bear the cost of change



























































































