I have barely used X for months, and Elon Musk’s latest attempts to destabilise my country are the final straw. I’m closing my account - and only wish I had succeeded in persuading @UKParliament and its committees to do the same. See you where skies are blue?
David Anderson, Baron Anderson of Ipswich
David William Kinloch Anderson, Baron Anderson of Ipswich, (born 5 July 1961) is a British barrister and life peer, who was the Independent Reviewer of Terrorism Legislation in the United Kingdom between 2011 and 2017. On 8 June 2018 it was announced that he would be introduced to the House of Lords as a cross-bench (non-party) working peer. On the same day he was appointed a Knight Commander of the Order of the British Empire (KBE), for services to national security and civil liberties, in the Queen's 2018 Birthday Honours. More on Wikipedia
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My successor as Independent Prevent Commissioner is Tim Jacques. I welcome him warmly to the post and wish him every success in helping improve Prevent and hold it to account. Announcement below.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The job is part time, and I hope Tim will be able to continue his good work as CEO of the Vault Youth Zone in Preston: www.vaultyouthzone.org
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A new offence of planning a mass attack/killing, without the need to prove a defined ideology? My take was on this morning’s Today prog, from 0715 (link below).
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Commented on the thoughtful and sensible Southport Inquiry report to BBC News. More from me on ITV evening news at 1830/2200.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My letter to the Security Minister, marking the end of my tenure as Interim Independent Prevent Commissioner, was published on the IPC's website this morning: www.gov.uk/government/publications/commissioners-end-of-t…. I will remain in post until Tuesday 14th April.
-
David Anderson reposted
Rajiv Shah
@RajivShah90
Thanks to @ShabanaMahmood for putting Article 3 on the agenda for this meeting
Art 3 prohibits deportations to countries where there is a risk of torture, cruel, inhumane or degrading treatment.
Here are 4 reasons why it needs to be reformed
Council of Europe
@coe
Happening now: Ministers from Council of Europe member states are engaging in discussions on how to uphold the European Convention on Human Rights while addressing migration challenges across the continent.
www.coe.int/en/web/portal/-/council-of-europe-ministers-t… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
What's going on in Strasbourg today - and how is it relevant to the case for continued UK membership of the European Convention on Human Rights? Updated text of my lecture this week in Stormont is below.
-
David Anderson reposted
Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission
@NIHRC
🟣Today we launched our 2025 Annual Human Rights Statement - read it here: nihrc.org/publication/detail/annual-statement-2025
A big thank you to our keynote speaker
Lord Anderson of Ipswich @bricksilk for his thought-provoking address.
You can watch the recording of the event here: www.youtube.com/live/NLD3sMIs7nI
#as2025 @NIHRF -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My title: “ECHR - the view from London and Strasbourg”. Free!
Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission
@NIHRC
Register now! The @NIHRC Annual Human Rights Statement 2025 Launch is taking place on Monday 8 December from 12.30pm - 2pm, as part of @NIHRF.
The keynote address will be delivered by Lord Anderson of Ipswich KBE KC (@bricksilk).
Find out more and register to watch the livestream here: www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/annual-human-rights-statement-2025… -
David Anderson reposted
Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission
@NIHRC
Register now! The @NIHRC Annual Human Rights Statement 2025 Launch is taking place on Monday 8 December from 12.30pm - 2pm, as part of @NIHRF.
The keynote address will be delivered by Lord Anderson of Ipswich KBE KC (@bricksilk).
Find out more and register to watch the livestream here: www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/annual-human-rights-statement-2025… -
David Anderson reposted
Colm O'Cinneide
@colmocinneide
Deferential position vis social welfare regulation facing an Art 14 ECHR challenge re-emphasised, along with limits of the S. 3 HRA interpretative obligation.
The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom
@UKSupremeCourt
Judgment has been handed down today in the matter of R (on the application of Jwanczuk) (Respondent) v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions (Appellant) UKSC 2023/0152: www.supremecourt.uk/cases/uksc-2023-0152
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
“ The rule of law: holding the line against tyranny and anarchy” – published at midnight by @UKHouseofLords Constitutional Committee (link below)
-
David Anderson reposted
Blavatnik School of Government
@BlavatnikSchool
EVENT: Prevent and Counter-Extremism in the UK
📆 20 Nov, 5pm GMT
Lord David Anderson will reflect on what Prevent has achieved, where it has struggled, and how the UK’s extremism landscape has shifted in recent years.
Register👇
www.bsg.ox.ac.uk/events/prevent-and-counter-extremism-uk -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Interested in #prevent? @Channel4 News was given exclusive access to its inner workings, including an intervention provider and a “channel panel”. The result was a 10-minute film shown on tonight‘s news (below). Strongly recommended.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
www.channel4.com/programmes/channel-4-news (from 29:30)
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Prevent stats published today www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/prevent-referrals-far…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Full figures here www.gov.uk/government/statistics/individuals-referred-to-…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My report of July 2025 www.gov.uk/government/publications/lessons-for-prevent
-
David Anderson reposted
Special Envoy Steve Witkoff
@SEPeaceMissions
I would like to acknowledge the vital role of the United Kingdom in assisting and coordinating efforts that have led us to this historic day in Israel. In particular, I want to recognize the incredible input and tireless efforts of National Security Advisor Jonathan Powell.
-
David Anderson reposted
Jesse Norman
@Jesse_Norman
The full legal advice from David Wolfson KC @DXW_KC on the ECHR has just been published. www.conservatives.com/wolfson-final-report
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Immigration accounts for only around 1.5% of the Strasbourg caselaw. I argue here that the ECtHR has had, on balance, a positive influence on UK national security. www.daqc.co.uk/2024/11/28/national-security-and-human-rig…
-
David Anderson reposted
Lord (David) Alton
@DavidAltonHL
The attack on Manchester’s Jewish community is an attack on all who believe in British freedom of religion or belief. We mourn those murdered; pray for healing of the wounded; and protection for those targeted by hate and violence. No one attending a British synagogue, temple, mosque or church should have to be in fear of their life.
-
David Anderson reposted
Daniel Finkelstein
@Dannythefink
Today I spent three hours outside my synagogue providing security. It was cold and (save for the excellent company of one of my best friends) a bit boring but tragically it obviously wasn’t a waste of time.
-
David Anderson reposted
Andrew Defty
@adefty
It's too early to know and investigations will quite properly follow into what was and was not known about the Manchester attacker. It is the first seminar of my intelligence module tomorrow and I'll be starting with this from @bricksilk following a previous attack in Manchester
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Among a number of brilliant speeches in HL, Baroness Prentis’s (14:21:00 - against) and Lord Pannick’s (14:54:45 - for) were incredibly powerful, in completely different ways. Watch them, you will not regret it! parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/308df98e-6c71-4829-b6b6-d0c… #asssteddyingbill
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And on a “lighter” note …
Calgie
@christiancalgie
Mitchell and Webb’s take on assisted dying
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Strongly recommended
Sam Freedman
@Samfr
New post just out:
"The route to chaotic authoritarianism"
On why Reform's deportation plans would have consequences well beyond asylum, that could change Britain forever.
(£/free trial)
open.substack.com/pub/samf/p/the-route-to-chaotic-authori… -
David Anderson reposted
Nikki da Costa
@nmdacosta
Strongly critical report from the Lords Constitution Committee on Leadbeater's Bill. The second such report from a Lords' Committe this week. 10 conclusions of note:
1. "Degree of deliberation, assessment and scrutiny is...significantly less than we would expect to see for an equivalent government bill. This is especially concerning given the subject matter of the Bill."
2. ""There is no reason for the usual scrutiny role of the House to be constrained...Given that this Bill is a private members’ bill and that it deals with a morally significant subject, close and detailed scrutiny by both Houses is particularly important."
3. Rejects Charlie Falconer's and Esther Rantzen's attempts to reduce the role of the Lords: "It is constitutionally appropriate for the House to scrutinise the Bill and, if so minded, vote to amend, or reject it"
4. Endorses Delegated Powers Committee's report. Particularly concerned by Clause 41 (power to set up a service) that there is "no indication of the shape or substance of the regulatory regime that is intended...Instead, they give Ministers almost unlimited powers to legislate in that area by statutory instrument.”. Clause 41 is "highly skeletal. It should be replaced with greater detail on the face of the Bill."
5. Clause 43 - the 'so called' advertising ban and public education campaign clause - "the power provided for in clause 43 is broad and gives the Government significant discretion over an important matter. The House should include further detail on the face of the Bill, particularly in relation to the exceptions included in or anticipated by this provision."
6. Clause 44 deals with 'events' doctors should notify the Commissioner of. "The purpose of clause 44, as well as the nature of the specified information to which it is intended to refer, is unclear. This detail should be provided for on the face of the Bill."
7. In general, provision in clauses 47–50 for monitoring and review of the Act lacks detail.
8. "We draw the attention of the House to the lack of detail about the proposed Disability Advisory Body contained in clause 48. There should be greater detail on the face of the Bill about its constitution and functions."
9. "The codes of practice provided for in clause 39 are examples of disguised legislation—they purport to be non-binding but may be treated by those subject to them as directive. It is also not clear what they will contain. The House should consider whether this is appropriate, or whether the guidance to be contained in these codes of practice is more fully provided for on the face of the Bill."
10. "Clause 40 requires the Secretary of State to issue guidance “relating to the operation of the Act”, without any associated parliamentary process...The duty on the Secretary of State is very broadly framed. It is not clear what the purpose of the power is, nor is it clear at whom the guidance will be targeted or what its intended scope will be....The House should consider whether the delegation of this broad power is necessary. If it is considered necessary, the House should provide greater detail on the face of the Bill what the intended guidance is for and to whom it might be directed." -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
HL Constitution Committee report on Assisted Dying Bill: we noted some serious reservations. publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld5901/ldselect/ldconst/177…
-
David Anderson reposted
Julien Burcher
@Dowellenough
*But I would have thought that it would not take much, looking around the world at the moment, to see how dangerous it is to have a law which can be used by Governments of any kind to do almost anything that they want to* Lord Deben
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Labour and Conservatives unite to ask for powers that would allow a Reform government to inflict the most extreme measures imaginable on mainstream, law-abiding visa-holders - without even needing to trouble Parliament. The mind boggles. /2
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
20 years ago, Parliament anxiously debated whether suspected terrorists could be tagged, curfewed and confined. In 2025, government asks us to allow such powers, and more, to be used without safeguards on any temporary visa-holder: tourist, student, spouse of UK citizen ... /1
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Labour and Conservatives unite to ask for powers that would allow a Reform government to inflict the most extreme measures imaginable on mainstream, law-abiding visa-holders - without even needing to trouble Parliament. The mind boggles. /2
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This government would not abuse such powers, they (no doubt rightly) tell us - but the supply of "good chaps" may not be endless. Now more than ever, it is Parliament's job to ensure that oppressive powers are no broader than they need to be, and subject to proper safeguards. /3
David Anderson
@bricksilk
You can read tonight's debate here hansard.parliament.uk/search/MemberContributions?house=Lo… /4
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
You can now read the debate in Hansard. hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2025-0.... /3
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Former DPP Ken Macdonald has already broken ranks on the Refugee Convention, and I am sure politicians of all parties will be considering these kinds of options. I would like to see further informed commentary from immigration specialists and others.
Derrick Wyatt's Law and Policy Blog
@BlogWyatt
derrickwyatt.substack.com/publish/post/172171976
The Refugee Convention blurs the distinction between legal migrants and illegal migrants. For millions of UK voters, that distinction is paramount. Review of the Refugee Convention by Labour would signal serious intent, both at home and abroad. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Parliament and the Rule of Law: the text of my keynote address to the ALBA conference last month is now on my website (link in next post).
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Interviewed by Andrew Marr on #prevent this evening on LBC from 16 to 25 minutes in. He was certainly well prepared. www.google.com/gasearch?q=lbc marr
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Prevent missed chance to treat Southport killer, says review www.bbc.com/news/articles/c74zy014x84o
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
“Lessons for #prevent” now published www.gov.uk/government/publications/lessons-for-prevent
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My report "Lessons for Prevent" will be published on Wednesday, probably late morning. My terms of reference ask me to look at the Prevent histories of the killers of Sir David Amess and the Southport girls, and draw any conclusions for the future of Prevent.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Accompanying written ministerial statement here questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-statements/det…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My report "Lessons for Prevent" will be published on Wednesday, probably late morning. My terms of reference ask me to look at the Prevent histories of the killers of Sir David Amess and the Southport girls, and draw any conclusions for the future of Prevent.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Terms of Reference here www.gov.uk/government/publications/independent-prevent-co….
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My evidence on #prevent to @CommonsHomeAffs yesterday is here, starting after the break at 15:44 parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/e549469b-9b1b-4b4d-9b8d-6c2….
-
David Anderson reposted
Home Affairs Committee
@CommonsHomeAffs
Watch live on Tuesday 15th July from 2.30pm as we hold the first session on our inquiry into new forms of extremism.
We will examine new and emerging forms of extremism in the UK.
Watch on Parliament Live 🟢
[1/2] -
David Anderson reposted
The Crisis Room Podcast
@CrisisRoomPod
🚨New episode out now!🚨
As the Home Secretary brands Palestine Action a terrorist group, @AmberRuddUK, @MarkUrban01 and @Mpolymer ask what is at stake for protest rights?
Plus, @bricksilk joins The Crisis Room to discuss tackling radicalisation.
#palestineaction -
David Anderson reposted
Akua Reindorf KC
@akuareindorf
There are several concerning legal inaccuracies in this piece by barrister Sam Fowles about yesterday’s landmark #supremecourt decision in For Women Scotland v The Scottish Ministers 🧵⬇️
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/apr/16/supreme-cou… -
David Anderson reposted
Mark Elliott
@ProfMarkElliott
New post | Could it happen here? Peter Hennessy and Andrew Blick on the ultimate ‘what if’ constitutional question publiclawforeveryone.com/2025/03/04/could-it-happen-here-…
-
David Anderson reposted
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
It has taken Trump to put UK back at the heart of European security, where it belongs.
Mujtaba Rahman
@Mij_Europe
🇪🇺🇬🇧 Through my first set of meetings in Brussels. The praise for @Keir_Starmer is overwhelming: “What he has managed to do is not just good for him. It's good for all of us. Absolutely top notch. This is the UK at its best. The UK we have always admired.”
-
David Anderson reposted
Adam Tomkins
We at Glasgow law school are looking for an admin lawyer to join our wonderful public law team. A great job in a fab team—and a rare opportunity. Interested? Then join us! www.jobs.ac.uk/job/DMA933/lecturer-senior-lecturer-in-adm…
-
David Anderson reposted
Alan Woodward
@ProfWoodward
This shows how badly the Trump administration have taken the UK govt asking Apple to circumvent ADP. dw-wp-production.imgix.net/2025/02/DNI-Wyden-Biggs-Respon…
-
David Anderson reposted
Sky News
@SkyNews
'Today I am appointing Lord David Anderson KC as an interim prevent commissioner to start work immediately'
Home Secretary Yvette Cooper adds that there will also be a review of Prevent thresholds.
news.sky.com/story/politics-latest-pm-insists-uk-us-speci…
📺 Sky 501, Virgin 602, Freeview 233 and YouTubeThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Early career lawyer or law student anywhere in the world, seeking human rights fieldwork abroad? You can apply for an Anthony Lester fellowship here: humanrights.bard.edu/lester-fellowship/
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
National Security and Human Rights: full corrected text of last night's Denning Society Lecture is now on my website. Link follows below.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Thank you, @commonslibrary. When are you coming over?
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Property (Digital Assets &c) Bill Special Public Bill Committee first live evidence session on this link from 1 pm today: www.parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/....
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Could constitutional principles (civil service, delegated legislation, watchdogs) usefully be put into statute? Ministers Pat McFadden and Nick Thomas-Symonds answered me in @HLConstitution from 11:23:25 to 11:35:05 yesterday (no transcript yet): parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/f1e39fa4-5ec2-42d7-8296-615….
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
UK competition for ECtHR Judge is being rerun – not enough candidates of sufficient quality! I applaud the emphasis on “ability to master unfamiliar areas of law“: the Court needs first-rate, impartial judges more than it does human rights activists. judicialappointments.gov.uk/applications...
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Perhaps @JoshuaRozenberg will tell us what is going on…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Here’s a guide to the procedure, for anyone who might be tempted assembly.coe.int/LifeRay/CDH/Pdf/GuideRoleQualification-E….
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A proud day for Inter Mediate, the conflict resolution charity I have the honour to chair. As Jonathan Powell returns to his country’s service, we welcome Claire Hajaj as our new Executive Director.
www.inter-mediate.org -
David Anderson reposted
ComputerWeekly
@ComputerWeekly
Lords shoplifting inquiry calls for facial recognition laws www.computerweekly.com/news/366615259/Lords-shoplifting-i…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Great appointment - and just in time for next week’s investment summit. She joins James Timpson and Patrick Vallance in an increasingly impressive Lords ministerial team.
FT UK Politics
@ftukpolitics
Ex-Darktrace head Poppy Gustafsson named UK investment minister www.ft.com/content/a08b1b32-4bc9-44ce-b7af-b70dda0e187f
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The deed is done. Thank you @downingcollege.
Downing College
@downingcollege
Downing College is delighted to announce the appointment of five new Honorary Fellows: @DharshiniDavid, @bricksilk, Ravindra Gupta, Sir Andrew Popplewell and Professor Mike Lean.
Read more about our new Honorary Fellows here: www.dow.cam.ac.uk/news/downing-appoints-five-new-honorary…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And @downingcollege, you have lots of friends on @bluesky who would be glad to see you there …
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
💯🐢🐢🐢
PoliticsHome
@politicshome
✉️ The IPPR advises Keir Starmer to “be the Tortoise to the last government’s Hare” on passing bills
🗑️ “This approach to law-making is a tremendous waste of parliamentary time and resources at best and littered with harmful side-effects at worst."
www.politicshome.com/news/article/ippr-dont-rush-passing-… -
David Anderson reposted
Middle Temple
@middletemple
Following his new book 'Downward Spiral', John Bowers KC will be in conversation with Sir Rupert Jackson on standards in public life. Join us on 14 October, book your tickets here - www.middletemple.org.uk/civicrm/event/info?reset=1&id=41960
-
David Anderson reposted
Dominic Grieve
@dominicgrieve_
The way the ECHR is applied may at times irritate and as in all human affairs no court will always be perfect in its reasoning and decisions. But the ECHR has done immense good throughout Europe. Precisely because it is a " living instrument", it has been able to promote human rights. We take for granted today that illegitimate children should not suffer discrimination and that homosexual relationships should not be criminalised. But delivering these reforms is just some of the good work of the ECHR. As Churchill saw, it's drafting and promotion has been one of the great achievements of UK soft power for the common good of all.
At the end of his video, Jenrick gratuitously offers an irrelevant image which is intended, I infer, to show an immigrant gloating over money he is getting. The only purpose of this is to stir up hatred against immigrants. That is why we need the ECHR. It is also why he is showing himself entirely unfit for office. -
David Anderson reposted
UCL European Institute
@UCL_EI
Another year of showcasing UCL’s European expertise & enhancing its reach through exchange with partners, from dancers to diplomats.
Thank you to our collaborators @UCL and beyond. www.ucl.ac.uk/european-institute/news/2024/sep/european-i…
@PietEeckhout @bricksilk @ukstaiger @ShackletonLucy Claudia Sternberg -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The House of Lords Constitution Committee published our latest report on devolution today, expertly summarised here by Stephen Tierney, our legal adviser: ukconstitutionallaw.org/2024/09/27/s...
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Prof Tierney makes this excellent point: though not formally representative of the nations and regions, the House of Lords has long operated in practice as an effective “devolution watchdog”.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
How “noble and gallant Lords”, working with lawyers, blocked the proposed immunity from war crimes in the Overseas Operations Act 2021 www.daqc.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/22/2022/11/The-Lo…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
(As explained just now by @dominicgrieve_ on @BBCr4today)
-
David Anderson reposted
Susan Hawley
@susanpjhawley
Excellent piece by @_peterriddell @ConUnit_UCL - “it is no longer sufficient or credible to believe you are the good guys” - important call for swift and meaningful action on strengthening UK standards regime to restore trust in politics. constitution-unit.com/2024/09/20/government-standards-the…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Family visas: consultation launched www.gov.uk/government/calls-for-evidence/family-visa-fina…
-
David Anderson reposted
Independent Reviewer
@terrorwatchdog
Interesting - and tribute to Parliamentary scrutiny of draft Bill in 2023 - that Martyn’s Law introduced into Parliament today [Terrorism (Protection of Premises) Bill] is markedly different from original proposals…/1
-
David Anderson reposted
Lord Norton of Louth
@LordNortonLouth
My House of Lords (Peerage Nominations) Bill received its formal First Reading today bills.parliament.uk/bills/3770
-
David Anderson reposted
Theresa May
@theresa_may
It was a privilege to be introduced to the @UKHouseofLords today. I look forward to continuing to contribute to the work of Parliament and public life over the years ahead.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I will be posting mostly as bricksilk.bsky.social from now on. A large and interesting crowd, a familiar user interface and a platform set up for democratic debate (as explained in this podcast) were the clinchers. I loved Twitter, but don’t expect to be here for much longer.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Wise Brazilians
Sam Freedman
@Samfr
Brazil twitter just moved wholesale to Bluesky due to the battle there between Musk and the government. (You can see the smaller bump from the UK after the riots last month for contrast).
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Congratulations to the excellent Catherine Smith KC, for whom I once spoke at @JUSTICEhq Scotland and once at @JohnSmithCentre, on her appointment as a Law Officer and peer. I look forward to our debates. www.gov.uk/government/n...
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I’ve set up as bricksilk.bsky.social, and have been amazed to see how many legal, political, media and natsec types are already there. Join me?
-
David Anderson reposted
David Gauke
@DavidGauke
Trump backing Tories should watch and reflect on this.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson reposted
Matthew Scott
@Barristerblog
A welcome & necessary tour de force from @BarristerSecret debunking the widely believed nonsense that "right wing" rioters are being treated differently from those involved in other riots. thesecretbarrister.com/2024/08/14/two-tier-justice-cuttin…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A reminder of #athelstaneford in deepest Suffolk this afternoon
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
No sunstroke here, but a thoughtful piece. Highlights the undesirable and constitutionally questionable role allotted by the major parties to their members in choosing a new leader when a PM resigns in office.
Tom Hickman
@TomRHickman
What rules govern appointment of ministers? What about choosing a prime minister? Sun lounger constitutional law from me in the @LRB www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v46/n16/tom-hickman/short-cuts
-
David Anderson reposted
Nick Lowles
@lowles_nick
As suspected, yesterday’s protests outside law firms and migrant help centres were designed to wind up, generate fear and waste time and resources. Very few anti-immigrant protesters turned up anywhere, and many saw none.
If that was the strategy then it badly backfired. Thousands came out on the streets in a huge expression of solidarity and anti-racism. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This from a genuine expert on our prison system is well worth a listen – starts 14.30 minutes in www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0021qjf?partner=uk.co.bbc&orig….
Ian Acheson 🇬🇧☘️
@NotThatBigIan
I've just been on @BBCPM talking about the differences in our prison capability 2011 vs 2024. I was also able to reiterate a wider point made better by @bricksilk earlier. We must not give thuggery & common criminality the respectability of any ideology. They aren't terrorists.
-
David Anderson reposted
Lords Constitution Committee
@HLConstitution
On 29th July, the @UKHouseofLords approved a motion to re-appoint @HLConstitution for the new Parliament.
Find out more about our work on our website: committees.parliament.uk/committee/172/constitution-commi… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
From 2220 www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/live:bbc_radio_fourfm?partner=u….
Tl:dr Be very cautious about charging rioters with terrorism – (1) there are plenty of other powerful tools in the box (2) terror charges will raise the emotional temperature, and focus attention on motivation rather than simple criminality.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I’ll be discussing this subject on @BBCRadio4 at around 2215 tonight.
Guardian politics
@GdnPolitics
Far-right violence should be treated as terrorism, says former police chief www.theguardian.com/politics/article/2024/aug/05/far-righ…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Revised link here www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0021qd1 (from 2220)
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I’ll be discussing this subject on @BBCRadio4 at around 2215 tonight.
Guardian politics
@GdnPolitics
Far-right violence should be treated as terrorism, says former police chief www.theguardian.com/politics/article/2024/aug/05/far-righ…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This is England
Alex O'Leary
@alexoljourno
“We are not going to let them divide us”
Heartwarming scenes in #middlesbrough this morning as the community rallies together after the shocking disorder yesterday -
David Anderson reposted
Hannah Al-Othman
@HannahAlOthman
Just wanted to share quickly how lovely yesterday felt in Southport; a total contrast to the night before. 🧵
The mosque and people’s garden walls were rebuilt by builders and bricklayers volunteering their time and labour: -
David Anderson reposted
UCL Constitution Unit
@ConUnit_UCL
With the parliamentary recess now underway, you may be looking for some summer reading.
Go no further, says @bricksilk, than the final report from our Democracy in the UK after Brexit project!
If you are already on the beach, you can read it now 👉 www.ucl.ac.uk/constitution-unit/research-areas/deliberati…. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Interesting thread on Lords vs Commons scrutiny of EU affairs
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
Just reminding you @anandMenon1 that the European Affairs Committee @UKHouseofLords re-constituted yesterday will continue to scrutinise EU documents. It is not just civil servants! @LordsEUCom
-
David Anderson reposted
Sophia Psarra
@SophiaPsarra
Our book with @ukstaiger + Claudia Sternberg is shortlisted for the Colvin Prize by the @TheSAHGB .The Colvin Prize is awarded annually to an outstanding work of reference that relates to the field of architectural history, broadly conceived. @UCLpress www.uclpress.co.uk/products/223069
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
It was an excellent debate, sharpened by Lord Robertson’s presence throughout. Well worth a read.
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
The foreign policy debate @UKHouseofLords on 25/7 was interesting on the Defence Review, being led by our own Lord George Robertson. In his speech👇he noted it w’d be more difficult than the one he did as Defence Sec in 1998, given that../ hansard.parliament.uk/lords/2024-07-25/debates/F82A2EE0-9…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
⬅️
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Something to ponder: how to achieve Teazel-like levels of engagement for my usual worthy tweets on legislative amendment?? 🥱🤔
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Proud to be able to celebrate a family success, however unlikely it seemed
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
So that’s what it was! But what makes the balloon rise? www.edf.fr/en/giving-paris-2024-the-energy-to-shine/paris…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Something to ponder: how to achieve Teazel-like levels of engagement for my usual worthy tweets on legislative amendment?? 🥱🤔
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Proud to be able to celebrate a family success, however unlikely it seemed
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Proud to be able to celebrate a family success, however unlikely it seemed
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Teazel (and her brother) says thanks for all the likes
-
David Anderson reposted
Spotlight on Corruption
@EndCorruptionUK
While the new govt has a packed agenda, as our ED @susanpjhawley argues in a recent piece, political integrity reforms are not a nice to have that can come later. They are essential to delivering the government’s full agenda and winning back public trust.
www.spotlightcorruption.org/thin-gruel-for-anti-corruptio… -
David Anderson reposted
Spotlight on Corruption
@EndCorruptionUK
How can the new govt tackle the political integrity deficit in the UK? Yesterday, @bricksilk set out 5 things it should do to improve ethical governance in the UK. While we agree with them all, 3 stand out for us:
1⃣ Give key ethics regulators legal standingThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The public longs for ethical governance - and @ConUnit_UCL, @instituteforgov, @EndCorruptionUK, @TransparencyUK, @JUSTICEhq, @Law_Commission, @CommonsPACAC and others have made the tools that government needs to do the job. My speech recognises this: hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-07-23/debates/BC575765-A…. /1
David Anderson
@bricksilk
King’s Speech debate in @UKHouseofLords gets on to constitutional matters today - from about 3.30pm parliamentlive.tv/Lords. Speaker list here: www.lordswhips.org.uk/speakers-lists.
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Some of my thoughts are set out at greater length here. /end
David Anderson
@bricksilk
… and this lecture www.daqc.co.uk/2023/12/01/writing-a-constitution/, a revised version of which will be published in Public Law in October. /4
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I have just been promised a letter from the Minister responding to the five points I made last night - will post it here when received.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
King’s Speech debate in @UKHouseofLords gets on to constitutional matters today - from about 3.30pm parliamentlive.tv/Lords. Speaker list here: www.lordswhips.org.uk/speakers-lists.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Sorry speaking order is here www.lordswhips.org.uk/todays-lists
-
David Anderson reposted
London Live
@LondonLive
Islamist preacher Anjem Choudary has been found guilty of directing a terrorist organisation and encouraging support for it through online meetings.
Following a trial at Woolwich Crown Court, he was convicted on Tuesday of taking a “caretaker role” in directing Al-Muhajiroun (ALM).
Prosecutors said Choudary directed the terrorist organisation for a significant period of time from 2014 onwards and also encouraged support for the group by addressing online meetings of the Islamic Thinkers Society (ITS).
He gave lectures to the New York-based ITS, which prosecutors said was “the same” as ALM.
ITS was infiltrated by undercover law enforcement officers in the US, who were present at online lectures in 2022 and 2023, held over the Element messenger platform.
ALM was proscribed as a terror organisation in the UK in 2010, though it was said in court that the group has continued to exist under various names.
The conviction followed investigations by the Metropolitan Police, the New York Police Department (NYPD) in the US, and the Royal Canadian Mounted Police.
Prosecutor Tom Little KC, opening the trial at Woolwich Crown Court on June 13, said that Choudary had a “warped and twisted mindset”.
Omar Bakri Muhammad, who founded ALM, was in prison in Lebanon between 2014 and March 2023, and Choudary stepped in and “filled the void”, Mr Little said.
Choudary, who was convicted of supporting the so-called Islamic State in 2016, denied inviting support to ALM through lectures to ITS because the group “didn’t exist”.
He said during the trial that ALM was disbanded in 2004 because founder Muhammad had a shift in ideology.
Khaled Hussein, 29, whom prosecutors said was a “follower and dedicated supporter” of Choudary, was also found guilty of membership of ALM.
Choudary was arrested in east London on 17 July 2023 while Hussein, from Edmonton in Canada, was detained at Heathrow Airport having arrived on a flight the same day.
Choudary was convicted of directing a terrorist organisation and addressing meetings to encourage support for a proscribed organisation.
They will be sentenced on July 30 at the same court. -
David Anderson reposted
Susan Hawley
@susanpjhawley
An important letter from @bricksilk in the @FT about the need for a legislative underpinning for the regulators of ethical standards of politicians. Statutory footing is - as @PublicStandards found - the only sure way to secure their true independence.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My letter in today’s @FT: our King’s Speech debate on constitutional affairs is on Tuesday.
www.ft.com/products -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My letter in today’s @FT: our King’s Speech debate on constitutional affairs is on Tuesday.
www.ft.com/productsPost not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
… and this lecture www.daqc.co.uk/2023/12/01/writing-a-constitution/, a revised version of which will be published in Public Law in October. /4
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Text of today’s letter here /5
-
David Anderson reposted
John Peet
@JohnGPeet
Where might UK-EU relations be under a Labour government? My take in a new CER essay:
www.cer.eu/publications/archive/essay/2024/where-might-uk… -
David Anderson reposted
Keiran O'Neill
@KeiranON
A lot happened yesterday but this quote from John Reid in the Lords is a belter 😂
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This🧵recalls the time and effort expended by so many over the past few years in identifying and resisting threats to the rule of law. If as predicted we are in for a quieter time on the legal/constitutional front, I look forward to finding something more constructive to do.
-
David Anderson reposted
Robert Harris
@Robert___Harris
The contrast between this and the “lock her up”, “build the gallows” state of US politics makes one proud of Britain, for all its problems
Antonello Guerrera
@antoguerrera
Il primo ministro, il leader dell’opposizione e i loro vice che, nonostante divisioni, divergenze e attacchi reciproci, scherzano e chiacchierano amichevolmente prima del Discorso del Re in Parlamento.
Un Paese e una democrazia sani: il Regno Unito 🇬🇧❤️👑 -
David Anderson reposted
Dominic Grieve
@dominicgrieve_
I have finally decided to get on X.
There is a new era in politics and much of importance to be debated, particularly in respect of our relationship with our European neighbours.
Please do follow. -
David Anderson reposted
Tim Durrant
@timd_IFG
Warm words in the King's speech about service in government, and the importance of standards in parliament, but as far as I could tell no commitment to legislation on ethics and integrity?
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
"The Article 267 reference procedure constitutes an important "judicial dialogue" between the CJEU and the national courts but it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that the dialogue here has been rather one-sided": Collins J in Irish Supreme Court. www.bailii.org/ie/cases/IESC/2024/2024IESC22unapprovedCol… /1
David Anderson
@bricksilk
(Quote from para 97: I agree). See also his reference to my evidence in Dwyer on the irreplaceable benefits of mobile location data in investigating serious crime (para 64). Hogan J dissented. Interesting prelude to the SCt judgment in Dwyer, expected later this month. /2
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
As the other VVIPs went in for half-time refreshment last night, one man stood alone: Viktor Orban. amp.theguardian.com/news/2018/jan/11/viktor-orban-hungary…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Berlin
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
David Anderson
@bricksilk
What a night – next time, England.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And may the best team win, particularly if representing England.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Happy 70th birthday to my old client #uefa, and thanks for letting me and my #itfc badge get so close to the Euros Cup.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Checkpoint Charlie has improved since 1988, when as a young EU stagiaire I first crossed here into an alien world. In troubled times, let’s not forget how far we have come.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Profoundly affected by Daniel Libeskind’s @jmberlin and Holocaust Tower - as were others whom #euro2024 has brought to #berlin.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This pigeon seems to like it too.
-
David Anderson reposted
David Torrance
@davidtorrance
Colleagues in the House of Lords Library have produced this excellent briefing on the potential constitutional aspects of next week’s King’s Speech: lordslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/lln-2024-0028/
-
David Anderson reposted
Spotlight on Corruption
@EndCorruptionUK
👏 We strongly welcome Prime Minister @Keir_Starmer’s @10DowningStreet commitment to beef up the powers of the Independent Adviser on Ministers’ Interests by allowing them to initiate their own investigations, as reflected in Labour’s manifesto.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c4ng8l9klrvo -
David Anderson reposted
DJ Musgrove
@DJMusgrove
If I landed a job running a medium-sized country, I too would insist on my first week including a global summit so I can be statesmanlike, and my national men's sports team suddenly becoming world-beating. In my second week, I'd demand that the sun come out
-
David Anderson reposted
Diana Barran
@dianabarran
As my time as a minister has now ended, I wanted to acknowledge what an extraordinary privilege it is to serve in government and how grateful I am to have had the opportunity.
For me, there are three main reasons that make this so special. 1/13 -
David Anderson reposted
Hannah White
@DrHannahWhite
Good to hear @Keir_Starmer say his first remarks to Cabinet were to establish the standards he expects of them, and that he has had an early meeting with Sir Laurie Magnus - the PM’s adviser on ministerial interests - in line with our recommendations www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/press-release/seven-ste…
-
David Anderson reposted
Krishnan Guru-Murthy
@krishgm
Watch this it’s fascinating - I asked James Timpson what he’d do about prisons and sentencing if he was in charge. He believes only a third of prisoners in jail should definitely be there. He’s now in charge of prisons (but not sentencing).
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson reposted
Benjamin Tallis 🇺🇦
@bctallis
10 Points on UK Elections.
Including on:
- democratic merits of Britain’s First Past the Post (FPTP) electoral system
- vote share vs seats
- right/ left shift
- delivery & safeguarding democracy
1. At first glance it looks crazy that Labour would achieve such a crushing victory with such a mid share of the total vote.
BUT
2. Key to UK elections is ⭐️voter efficiency ⭐️(getting the most seats per vote) - Starmer’s Labour absolutely nailed it [while Corbyn’s totally failed to]
3. To do this you need to appeal broadly, across a lot of different constituencies (you have to get more votes than any other party in each of those locations- and all of them are trying to do that)
4. That requires a strong, non-toxic, flexible and transferable brand, a broadly appealing offer & good local candidates.
5. You cannot rely on heartlands alone to deliver you victory - you have to reach out and convince others of your Programme, credibility & competence - a real strength of FPTP.
6. The local connection (all MPs are directly, locally elected & accountable) is FPTP’s other great democratic strength.
7. FPTP also generally delivers majority governments which have a better chance of delivering on a strong clear Programme (not guaranteed of course) but looking at past listlessness [merkel era] & current infighting & coalition govt failure in eg Germany one can see the benefit. Given delivery is a key issue that drives satisfaction or discontent with democracy itself, this is important - & it’s something Starmer has prioritized. Now he has to deliver on delivery.
8. Some claim there has been a rightward shift. This is not credible given Tory+Reform are down 5.5% on last time in total & Lab-Lib-Green are up 6.4%. Actually the right shifted further right (to reform) but the Centre strengthened.
[even if reform casts a nasty shadow]
9. Which brings us to another merit of FPTP. Extreme parties start, by definition, as having fringe appeal to small numbers of people in any given area. FPTP helps keeps it that way - whereas PR/ list systems link them up across different areas, helping them gain publicity and credibility and translating that into positions of power - as we can see happening in France, Germany & elsewhere
10. It is not undemocratic to say you don’t want anti-democratic & extremist parties to succeed via the ballot box (b/c they will destroy our democracies). FPTP may be better at ensuring this doesn’t happen - need for broad appeal outside heartlands (need to win the Centre), locally connected & accountable MPs, Majority governments have possibility to implement & deliver, doesn’t amplify extremes.
So please bear this in mind before jumping on the total vote-share/ seat share disparity & condemning then UK system!
- there are downsides too of course & many merits to PR/ lists … but let’s assess these properly in relation to FPTP.
#ukelection2024 #ukelections2024 -
David Anderson reposted
Hannah White
@DrHannahWhite
With two seats to declare we already have the most female parliament ever - 40% of MPs are now women! Fantastic news!
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Chamberlain J has with his usual clarity dismissed the @Policy_Exchange heresy that #ecthr r34 interim rulings are not binding in international law, while confirming that Parliament may (however regrettably) choose to allow Ministers to act contrary to international law.
-
David Anderson reposted
PARLY
@PARLYapp
The official opposition has to shadow each Commons minister (usually 95), provide MPs to sit on select committees and bill committees as well as two Deputy Speakers and members of the panel of chairs (Labour provided 19 in the last parliament). And whips, obviously.
-
David Anderson reposted
David Robson
@d_a_robson
🚨 Important info for anyone who wants to vote in the UK general election ⬇️
Lewis Goodall
@lewis_goodall
Remember, if you don't have a form of voter ID you have until 5pm *TODAY* to apply for one via this link, in order to vote on 4th July.
Don't lose your right to vote because you don't have the right ID. Share far and wide. www.gov.uk/apply-for-photo-id-voter-authority-certificate -
David Anderson reposted
Peter Riddell
@_peterriddell
Yes -not only could a new PM make a big difference but this could happen quickly via a revised Ministerial Code snd new guidance to the regulators. But leadership from the top is crucial as and when allegations of wrongdoing occur - as they inevitably will.
-
David Anderson reposted
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
100% agree with these excellent proposals. This is a subject where clear leadership from the new PM would make a big difference. Legislation would help but the example set from the top will be the crucial thing.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
How to restore trust in the political class - proud to be among the signatories of this letter in today’s @thetimes www.thetimes.com/article/e5cd8302-7ff5-4f1b-af7e-14546b20…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Seven changes for a better constitution: this morning’s letter is the subject of @d_a_t_green’s excellent blog. emptycity.substack.com/p/seven-changes-for-a-better-const…
-
David Anderson reposted
Joanna Cherry KC
@joannaccherry
What an excellent letter. I endorse its sentiments and its asks. If re-elected I would support legislating for the 7 key changes it sets out to restore integrity & rebuild trust in politics & our public institutions. It might also address policy capture.
Hannah White
@DrHannahWhite
Our letter to @thetimes today… calling for a reset of ethics in government 👇
-
David Anderson reposted
Jim Pickard 🐋
@PickardJE
excellent take-down of the correct - but misleading - Brexiteer claim that the UK has jumped from 7th to 4th biggest exporter in the world
Ed Conway
@EdConwaySky
However here's some (very) important context.
It's not like the UK has only JUST hit fourth spot. In fact, it was in 4th place in 2020. And in 2015, 2014 and 2013.
Actually if you look at the modal average of our position in the past decade it was... fourth. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
How to restore trust in the political class - proud to be among the signatories of this letter in today’s @thetimes www.thetimes.com/article/e5cd8302-7ff5-4f1b-af7e-14546b20…
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
These are cheap and effective ways of sorting what former Clerk to the Commons Lord Lisvane, debating our constitution, called “expensive noises coming from the engine”.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Nerdy though they might seem, they are my top priorities. Without them, and the trust they will help to promote, more far-reaching reforms to our constitutional arrangements will fare no better than water poured into a leaky bucket. /end
-
David Anderson reposted
UCL Constitution Unit
@ConUnit_UCL
The three organisations behind today's statement on ethics in government are represented on the 1pm opening panel at the Constitution Unit conference today.
You can still register to attend the session with @_peterriddell, @timd_IFG and Dominic Grieve 👉www.ucl.ac.uk/constitution-unit/events/2024/jun/constitut… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
From zombie fungi to radical mycology, this “compost heap of questions and fascinations” intrigues and delights. Thank you @MerlinSheldrake (and @PeterRSGray for the loan).
-
David Anderson reposted
Jeremy Vine | Here, on Tiktok, Insta & Facebook
@theJeremyVine
The “here is a full list of candidates in this seat” moment is just absolute gold in Chesterfield 1984
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I agree with @DrHannahWhite, adding that a supermajority would deplete the talent pool from which shadow ministers are taken, further reducing the quality of scrutiny in @HouseofCommons. Not a problem in @UKHouseofLords, but scrutiny should not be left to the unelected House.
Robert Saunders
@redhistorian
The UK has "one of the most executive-dominated parliaments in the world. Curiously, this is a fact that has not appeared to bother the Conservatives for the past 14 years".
Excellent piece by @DrHannahWhite, on why a "supermajority" is not the problem. www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/comment/conservatives-s… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This proud and rather traditionally-minded 2018 recipient of an honour thinks it’s high time this happened. How about it, @UKLabour? www.excellencenotempire.co.uk.
#ExcellenceNotEmpire
@ExcellenceNotE1
Congrats to everyone awarded an honour in the Kings Birthday List today. If you believe we need an honours system we can all be proud of please support our campaign. A simple name change can make Honours the celebration of excellence we want it to be #excellencenotempire
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Appealing to the big guns @LadyBasildon @HayteratLords
-
David Anderson reposted
UCL Constitution Unit
@ConUnit_UCL
The Constitution Unit Conference 2024 is just over a week away!
Our third panel will see Kate O'Regan discuss the rule of law with Lord (Jonathan) Sumption, Baroness (Shami) Chakrabarti @CaseForDefence and @SirJJKC.
Book now 👉 ucl.ac.uk/constitution-unit/events/2024/jun/constitutiona…. -
David Anderson reposted
Daniel Bruce
@DanielJBruce
#labourmanifesto makes some meaty commitments to restore #integrity in politics, confirming an Independent Ethics Commission among other measures. Collectively a high bar if well implemented – similar measures long called for by @TransparencyUK & others www.transparency.org.uk/publications/briefing-parliamenta…
-
David Anderson reposted
Independent Reviewer
@terrorwatchdog
Latest Terror Stats to y/e March 2024. Children are breaking records again. Impact of Israel/Gaza protests also showing…/1
-
David Anderson reposted
Dan Neidle
@DanNeidle
This is a good question. Here's the answer:
John Lewis
@JohnLewisEU
Can someone please explain to me, in a way that would make sense to a toddler, why I'm taxed more for my labour than a millionaire is taxed for their investments?
-
David Anderson reposted
Arnaud Bertrand
@RnaudBertrand
These have undoubtedly been the wildest 72 hours in French politics in my lifetime. Pretty incredible stuff.
A 🧵 -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I endorse this message (and hope for the same from other parties)
Transparency International UK
@TransparencyUK
✨ MANIFESTO WATCH ✨
The @LibDems have just released their 2024 manifesto – the first one of the General Election campaign.
We welcome the commitments to transparency and political integrity in their plans.
Here’s our summary of their key points ⤵️
🧵(1/6) -
David Anderson reposted
Samantha Asumadu
@SamanthaAsumadu
Here is @neill_bob outgoing chair of the Justice Select commitee on the green benches commemorating Lord Simon Brown's work in the other place on the last day of parliament. #ippscandal
Samantha Asumadu
@SamanthaAsumadu
I kinda wish people knew a bit more about what the Lords do. Especially in the last few years of Tory government. They have been/tried to be a bulwark against creeping fascism. Lord Simon Brown who died last year at 86 is a case study of exactly the type you want in the Lords.
-
David Anderson reposted
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
"The 1944 Victoria Cross roll of honour includes Sikh, Muslim and Hindu soldiers – a reminder that events that year shaped our world then, and the society we share today" - `King Charles III speaking at the D-Day commemorations in Portsmouth today
www.royal.uk/news-and-activity/2024-06-05/a-speech-by-the… -
David Anderson reposted
Frederick Cowell
@fredacowell
Shades of Hirst v UK in 2011, Lautsi v Italy in 2009 and others. The q is given the nature of climate change claims and their ever increasing importance, whether backlash to these cases becomes a different species altogether.
Evelyne Schmid @evelyneschmid.bsky.social
@SchmidEvelyne
The Swiss Upper Chamber today adopted a declaration opposing the Swiss climate judgment (Klimaseniorinnen v 🇨🇭), accusing the ECtHR as "unduly activist" and indicating that no further steps should be taken. @EI_Network This is a new low for the rule of law and foreign policy.
-
David Anderson reposted
Damien Lewis
@authordlewis
This is fabulous. Sterling stuff @usabmc We must cherish the last, for their numbers grow ever smaller ...🙏🙏🙏
ABMC
@usabmc
.@USArmy #wwii Veteran Dennis Boldt landed on #utahbeach in 1944. Today he walked through the Normandy American Cemetery with cast members from Band of Brothers & paused to meet soldiers from the 207th Military Intelligence Brigade. #dday80 @US_EUCOM @USArmyEURAF @walkamongheroes
-
David Anderson reposted
John Fitzpatrick
@johnmfitzp
He’s only a relaxed communicator if allowed to waffle on. But when challenged properly watch the colour drain from his face…
-
David Anderson reposted
Alex Thomas
@AlexGAThomas
In our latest @instituteforgov podcast I do my best public service assessment of the @michaelgove governing method and why it worked (20 mins in)
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/inside-briefing-with-instit… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Fun for all the family #scarfolk
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Long-delayed government response to the Ouseley Report is here: assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/6655c2d4d470e3279d…. They have accepted some but not all of its recommendations: I would be interested to see the reaction of @AMcC_KC and the other special advocates.
Joshua Rozenberg
@JoshuaRozenberg
Secret courts in crisis
Most special advocates will not accept new work in closed civil proceedings
New piece for my Substack subscribers: rozenberg.substack.com/p/secret-courts-in-crisis -
David Anderson reposted
John Peet
@JohnGPeet
A very pragmatic sensible thread. One for @Keir_Starmer to ponder. This story is not over yet!
David Lidington
@DLidington
I agree with @GavinBarwell about the future trend in UK opinion. Even now, we've had 2 yrs of polls showing c 60% now believe with hindsight that Brexit has harmed the country. But I'm more cautious about likelihood of rejoining -at least any time soon. Several reasons:🧵 1/12
-
David Anderson reposted
Bruno Tertrais
@BrunoTertrais
I'm trying to let personal emotions away when commenting on international affairs, but this is goosebumps material. If you don't know what the EU is about - this is what it is about.
Ani Chkhikvadze
@achkhikvadze
European anthem at the demonstration
-
David Anderson reposted
Nick Macpherson
@nickmacpherson2
Until this announcement, I was unpersuaded 16-17 year olds should get the vote. Now, I regard it as essential. #strangetimes
BBC News - Conservatives plan to bring back mandatory national service
www.bbc.com/news/articles/cpddxy9r4mdo -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
“Such a constitutionally unorthodox measure as this Bill should only be contemplated if … there exists no feasible alternative that would be as swift and comprehensive in its effect as the Bill itself.”
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Sad that neither the Arbitration Bill nor the Litigation Funding (Enforcement) Bill made it through wash-up. Both would have been positive for parties to litigation and for UK Legal plc. But on the plus side, we will shortly have the Pet Abduction Act 2024 ... #democracy
-
David Anderson reposted
Joshua Rozenberg
@JoshuaRozenberg
Remembering Simon Brown
The debt we owe to those who led the way
New piece, free to read: rozenberg.substack.com/p/remembering-simon-brown -
David Anderson reposted
Matt Purvis
@HLLibResearch
Lords business tomorrow
- Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Bill – Consideration of Commons Amendment
- Post Office (Horizon System) Offences Bill – Committee and Remaining Stages
- Victims and Prisoners Bill – Third Reading
- Media Bill – Report and Third Reading -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The last (2010) wash-up was described as 'a squalid stitch-up’, a ‘rather sad and tawdry affair’, and as showing a ‘brazen disregard for Parliament’. Report here.
John Curtis
@JohnHoCLibrary
Last two wash-ups (2005 & 2010) were also over two days. 14 bills received Royal Assent during wash-up in 2005 & 17 in 2010. More about how it works in our paper here researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/RP11-18/R…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Useful up-to-date @commonslibrary guide to the period of pre-election sensitivity formerly known as Purdah: researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/SN05262/S…. Over-caution should be avoided, as I wrote two elections ago: www.daqc.co.uk/2017/06/06/purdah-lifting-the-veil/.
-
David Anderson reposted
Hansard Society
@HansardSociety
⬇️ Our Director on what to look out for on the legislative front if the febrile speculation is right and the calling of a general election is imminent.
Ruth Fox
@RuthFox01
🧵If a General Election is called there will have to be a legislative 'wash-up' - a process known as a squalid stitch up or a pragmatic solution for parliamentary business depending on your point view! 1/
-
David Anderson reposted
David Gauke
@DavidGauke
Lots of rumours and speculation. Everyone on tenterhooks. What will Kieran McKenna do?
-
David Anderson reposted
Fabian Picardo
@FabianPicardo
I am sorry to say that @Jacob_Rees_Mogg clearly has not even started to understand the complexity of the issues that arise for #gibraltar as a result of #brexit. BRITISH is what Gibraltar is and will always be. BRITISH is what I and all my fellow Gibraltarians are and will always be. It is cheap and wrong for anyone to suggest we would ever consider our BRITISH nationality, heritage and birthright an "inconvenience". We are negotiating for fluid travel, immigration and trade arrangements, not sovereignty. Happy to brief Mr Rees-Mogg if he really has the remotest interest...
Jacob Rees-Mogg
@Jacob_Rees_Mogg
Clearly Fabian Picardo, the Chief Minister, no longer wants the inconvenience to Gibraltar of being British so he must want it to be Spanish.
mol.im/a/13441311 -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Quiet wisdom from @lib_thinks on our modest expectations of the state and the “sense of wear and tear on a thinning social fabric”:
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Link here
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/bfbe0950-6299-457e-96be-8201bc… -
David Anderson reposted
Bingham Centre for the Rule of Law
@BinghamCentre
Last week the Independent Commission on UK Public Health Emergency Powers published its final report, after 18 months intensive work.
The Bingham Centre acted as the Commission’s secretariat throughout.
Read the final report here ➡️binghamcentre.biicl.org/documents/2185_icukphep_final_rep… -
David Anderson reposted
Derrick Wyatt's Law and Policy Blog
@BlogWyatt
Brexit border checks to cost nearly £5bn and have no clear timetable for completion, says National Audit Office
I KNOW we can't turn the clock back, and I KNOW we all need to move on
But what a waste it has all been.
www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/brexit-border-cont… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Improving legislative scrutiny without the ermine: ideas from Scotland
Murdo Fraser MSP
@murdo_fraser
The Scottish parliament isn’t working. I am proposing how to fix it www.thetimes.co.uk/article/the-scottish-parliament-isnt-w…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The full paper is here www.reformscotland.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/A-bluep…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Expensive noises from the constitutional engine, and how to mend it: my comment piece in today’s @thetimes
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/bf42d5bd-1a73-4b0a-82a1-169d25…Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Of course there are political risks attached to moving in this area, as @katyballs points out today, also in @thetimes:
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/d69401e4-c2f2-4c30-ba13-a3d932…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
But the downsides of doing nothing are of a different order: disillusionment, corrosive cynicism and the weakening of faith in our democracy.
-
David Anderson reposted
Steve Peers
@StevePeers
Analysis of the Northern Ireland High Court judgment disapplying part of the Illegal Migration Act for breach of the Windsor Framework, by @CRGMurray
eulawanalysis.blogspot.com/2024/05/were-all-trying-to-fin… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I’ll be writing more on this next week @scottishlegal www.scottishlegal.com/articles/lord-anderson-moots-offenc…
-
David Anderson reposted
Alex Thomas
@AlexGAThomas
Thank you Baroness Drake and @HLConstitution for giving my NPC credentials a much-needed boost in a Lords debate yesterday
-
David Anderson reposted
UCL Constitution Unit
@ConUnit_UCL
It's great to see @bricksilk mention our Director Meg Russell's work in this @LordSpeaker podcast.
Find out more about her House of Lords research👉 www.ucl.ac.uk/constitution-unit/research-areas/parliament….
And read her latest report on Lords reform with @instituteforgov/@BennettInst👉 www.ucl.ac.uk/constitution-unit/news/2023/mar/launch-new-…. -
David Anderson reposted
Aileen McHarg @AileenMcHarg@mastodon.scot
@AileenMcHarg
This includes the father of my children, many of my colleagues, former students, friends and neighbours. All hardworking British taxpayers.
Dame Andrea Jenkyns DBE 🇬🇧
@andreajenkyns
The loopholes are clear, and the consequences are felt by every hardworking British taxpayer. Enough is enough.
-
David Anderson reposted
Joshua Rozenberg
@JoshuaRozenberg
A day in the law
Migration, corruption, transparency and two failures
New post, free to read: rozenberg.substack.com/p/a-day-in-the-law -
David Anderson reposted
Ian Acheson 🇬🇧☘️
@NotThatBigIan
HMP Wandsworth: A thread
Chief Inspector Charlie Taylor has cut short an unannounced inspection of this prison to issue an Urgent Notification to ministers about conditions there. This is his Red Flag warning of a prison in serious danger. The Governor resigned yesterday. 1/ -
David Anderson reposted
Derrick Wyatt's Law and Policy Blog
@BlogWyatt
"What..we've lost by leaving [the EU] is the influence on global standards...You think of the standards that govern mobile phones throughout the world. They were developed by the EU..
..the real loss for us is no longer being at the table when those decisions are made.." 👍👍
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Proud to be the latest addition to @LordSpeaker’s corner (a kind of Desert Island Discs without the music): the earlier episodes can also be found here and are of extraordinary quality. www.parliament.uk/business/news/2023/february-2023/lord-s…
-
David Anderson reposted
Spotlight on Corruption
@EndCorruptionUK
In this fascinating episode of @LordSpeaker’s Corner, @bricksilk explains that “standards in public life is the thing you have to fix first” & discusses his PMB, which would put key standards regulators into legislation as recommended by @PublicStandards.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=qUHvPkLGzsY&list=PLilBYVf0P9aZDem… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Proud to be the latest addition to @LordSpeaker’s corner (a kind of Desert Island Discs without the music): the earlier episodes can also be found here and are of extraordinary quality. www.parliament.uk/business/news/2023/february-2023/lord-s…
-
David Anderson reposted
David Wolfson
@DXW_KC
Another interesting discussion in the @LordSpeaker series: @bricksilk on law, politics and how his success in the Factortame case might (very much inter alia) have led to Brexit … podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/house-of-lords-podcast/id15…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Closed material proceedings have a place in civil justice - but only if the special advocates who are key to the system are properly resourced and supported. They are right to step back if the government fails to do this.
-
David Anderson reposted
The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom
@UKSupremeCourt
Lord Reed has had his proposal to enable overseas judges to sit on the JCPC approved by the government.
The Court and the Ministry of Justice are now working on detailed arrangements to welcome judges from JCPC served countries, subject to the approval of His Majesty the King. -
David Anderson reposted
The House magazine
@TheHouseMag
"The title ‘Lord’ or ‘Lady’ gives its bearers an exaggerated sense of self-importance"
✍️ Lord Parekh
www.politicshome.com/thehouse/article/its-time-radical-lo… -
David Anderson reposted
Joshua Rozenberg
@JoshuaRozenberg
Rwanda hearing next month
Ministers acknowledge potential breach of international law
New post, free to read: rozenberg.substack.com/p/rwanda-hearing-next-month -
David Anderson reposted
Iraq Football Podcast
@IraqFootballPod
🚨 𝐎𝐅𝐅𝐈𝐂𝐈𝐀𝐋 🚨
𝐀𝐥𝐢 𝐀𝐥-𝐇𝐚𝐦𝐚𝐝𝐢 𝐦𝐚𝐤𝐞𝐬 𝐡𝐢𝐬𝐭𝐨𝐫𝐲 𝐭𝐨 𝐛𝐞𝐜𝐨𝐦𝐞 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐟𝐢𝐫𝐬𝐭 𝐞𝐯𝐞𝐫 𝐈𝐫𝐚𝐪𝐢 𝐩𝐥𝐚𝐲𝐞𝐫 𝐭𝐨 𝐛𝐞 𝐩𝐫𝐨𝐦𝐨𝐭𝐞𝐝 𝐭𝐨 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐏𝐫𝐞𝐦𝐢𝐞𝐫 𝐋𝐞𝐚𝐠𝐮𝐞!
#itfc 🔵⚪️ -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
An informative evidence session, notably on the role of @UKSupremeCourt and Privy Council as “global courts”, and on the effect of leaving the Palace of Westminster (which did not prompt greater activism, but did expose the top court’s work to a far wider audience).
Lords Constitution Committee
@HLConstitution
Today we are holding our annual evidence session with the President and Deputy President of the @UKSupremeCourt, Lord Reed of Allermuir and Lord Hodge
📷Watch live: parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/ed42d005-5180-47dd-93a5-1ce…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Lord Reed observed that the development of JR (1980s) and human rights law (2000s) by the Judicial Cttee of HL was at least as dramatic as anything @UKSupremeCourt has done - but went largely unnoticed by the public because its profile was so low.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
*1960s
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Lots more of interest, e.g. on the relative caseloads of @UKSupremeCourt and Privy Council, the latter predominating in 2022/23. Transcript should follow in a few days.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
More here
James Lee
@jamessflee
Interesting reflections from Lord Reed PSC - asked what the greatest challenge the Supreme Court has faced in its 15 years has been the greater visibility and transparency, which it has embraced, but this has heightened awareness of the Court's work
Lords Constitution Committee
@HLConstitution
Today we are holding our annual evidence session with the President and Deputy President of the @UKSupremeCourt, Lord Reed of Allermuir and Lord Hodge
📷Watch live: parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/ed42d005-5180-47dd-93a5-1ce… -
David Anderson reposted
James Lee
@jamessflee
Interesting reflections from Lord Reed PSC - asked what the greatest challenge the Supreme Court has faced in its 15 years has been the greater visibility and transparency, which it has embraced, but this has heightened awareness of the Court's work
Lords Constitution Committee
@HLConstitution
Today we are holding our annual evidence session with the President and Deputy President of the @UKSupremeCourt, Lord Reed of Allermuir and Lord Hodge
📷Watch live: parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/ed42d005-5180-47dd-93a5-1ce… -
David Anderson reposted
Williamrt
@Williamrt
New - DWP anti-fraud measures will allow monitoring of bank accounts of landlords, carers and parents www.computerweekly.com/news/366582876/DWP-anti-fraud-meas… via @computerweekly #surveillance #fraud #dpib #dataprotection #benefits @bricksilk
-
David Anderson reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
"The reauthorization of Section 702 through H.R. 7888 represents a major win for national security hawks and the Biden administration. But any enthusiasm may be short lived."
Preston Marquis on FISA Section 702 reauthorization www.lawfaremedia.org/article/fisa-section-702-reauthorize… -
David Anderson reposted
Statute Law Society
@law_statute
👋📺Check out our past lectures in 2023 ( Lord Anderson @bricksilk, Professor Christopher McCrudden..) and our 2024 Lecture Series so far (Professor David Howarth and Justice David Goddard) vimeo.com/showcase/statute-law-society
-
David Anderson reposted
Lords European Affairs Committee
@LordsEUCom
Tomorrow (30 April, 4pm) we will continue our inquiry into UK-EU data adequacy with a session focusing on law enforcement.
We will hear from Dr Nora Ni Loideain (@NoraNiLoideain) and Martin Kelly (former Home Office official).
📺Watch live: committees.parliament.uk/event/21067/formal-meeting-oral-… -
David Anderson reposted
Lucy Kellaway
@lucykellaway
‘Almost beyond belief’: axing of UK teacher recruitment scheme will worsen crisis, say critics www.theguardian.com/education/2024/apr/28/axing-uk-teache…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
May also help explain the attraction of the UK to migrants?
Giles Wilkes
@Gilesyb
Astonishing chart from @jburnmurdoch- www.ft.com/content/c6bb7307-484c-4076-a0f3-fc2aeb0b6112?s… The UK is brilliant at handling immigration, relatively.
Could be a huge strength in the decades ahead -
David Anderson reposted
Hacked Off
@hackinginquiry
Yes, @thetimes totally misses the point. @HackedOffHugh made clear it is not about the financial outcome. It is about seeing @TheSun face accountability at trial over the most serious allegations of illegality.
-
David Anderson reposted
Cleo Davies
@CleoDavies2
The 🇫🇷 press have all (including all local press) covered the story of adoption of 🇬🇧 controversial Bill to send asylum seekers to Rwanda…. Here is a 🧵 of the coverage 1/7
Alex Taylor
@AlexTaylorNews
"The airplanes of shame" 👇
Tomorrow's @libe
Scathing editorial ...
"a symbol of moral bankruptcy"
"unreal, absurd and unworthy"
"the abyss from which the Tories lie to the British"
"The saddest thing is Britons don't massively take to the streets to say how awful this law is" -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Putting #rwandabill in context: my interview for ABC’s @RadioNational Breakfast in Australia www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/radionational-breakfast/uk…
-
David Anderson reposted
House of Lords
@UKHouseofLords
From 3.15pm, #houseoflords considers @HouseofCommons changes to the #investigatorypowersbill.
➡️ Learn more and watch online from at the link in our bio -
David Anderson reposted
Esther Bintliff
@estherbintliff
“You can’t make a country safe just by saying it’s safe,” @bricksilk tells @MarkLandler & @_StephenCastle, as Rishi Sunak finally pushes through his "Safety of Rwanda bill" through parliament.
www.nytimes.com/2024/04/22/world/europe/uk-rwanda-deporta… -
David Anderson reposted
Farrukh
@implausibleblog
Lord Anderson of Ipswich (Crossbench), "We are in the end game now"
"The benefits of the Rwanda bill remain to be seen"
"It's costs will be measured not only in money but in principles debased"
"Disregard for our international committmments"
"Avoiding statutory protections for the vulnerable"
"And the removal of judicial scrutiny over the core issue over the safety of Rwanda"
"We are concerned over the safety of Rwanda both in the present and in the future. This bill is honest about neither"
(At 6-45) "The Rwanda bill is a legal fiction that makes the law look like an ass, and those who make it, asses"This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson reposted
Ruth Fox
@RuthFox01
This degree of media attention on parliamentary ping-pong for a Bill is unusual. So important to stress that it is a standard, normal part of the legislative scrutiny process. What is unusual (historically, tho not in recent years) is the Govt's intransigent attitude to amdts.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I’m quoted here on #rwandabill and double insistence. This “post-truth”Bill asks Parliament to declare that Rwanda is safe (which it isn’t, yet) and will always be safe (which is obviously unknowable). I expect to be involved (in Lord Hope’s absence) in the final stages tomorrow.
PoliticsHome
@politicshome
📝 Rishi Sunak’s Rwanda Bill will be back in front of MPs on Monday, as parliamentary ping-pong has pushed the process into another week
www.politicshome.com/news/article/house-of-lords-rwanda-b…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
On the “will of the people”, some interesting information here from @britishfuture.
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
On the Rwanda bill amendment that the Lords have felt most strongly about, there is 75% public support and 15% opposition for the amendment proposed.
This was the amendment with the broadest cross-party public support.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
More background here
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My remarks on this theme to @BBCr4today this morning are here, from 0810 (2h10m in) www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m001y861
-
David Anderson reposted
Eleanor Sharpston now @akulith.bsky.social
@akulith
I probably wouldn’t agree with Lord Sumption on every other issue; but I think that he nails the political importance of the EU against the background of European history very elegantly. And small nations acting together within the EU can end up with a surprisingly strong voice.
BremainInSpain
@BremainInSpain
From the Spectator! 😳 In defence of the EU
‘The overriding factor is that the EU has made statehood economically viable for small nations, even if they have only a weak voice in Brussels. The Union is repairing the broken continent after a century of war and ideological division. For all the grumbling, few want to leave. Serbia, Montenegro, North Macedonia, Albania and Bosnia-Herzegovina and Ukraine are queuing up to join’ www.spectator.co.uk/article/in-defence-of-the-eu/ -
David Anderson reposted
Spotlight on Corruption
@EndCorruptionUK
👇As ACOBA is back in the news, here's a re-up of @susanpjhawley's blog on the Business Appointment Rules from yesterday:
www.spotlightcorruption.org/britains-revolving-door-rules…
Emilio Casalicchio
@e_casalicchio
Boris Johnson skips the rules and doesn't want to be transparent about it latest ...
assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/66214c26be5f81890e… -
David Anderson reposted
Transparency International UK
@TransparencyUK
🗣️ "the rules no longer have relevance in the modern world and are unenforceable to applicants determined to ignore them."
Strong words from Lord Pickles on the latest breach of ACOBA rules and Boris Johnson's failure to disclose hedge fund links.
www.ft.com/content/ece2996d-10dd-44c0-a62f-94f774f10977 -
David Anderson reposted
Peter Foster
@pmdfoster
🚨🇬🇧🇪🇺🚨Labour says it has “no plans” for doing a youth mobility deal with EU — says it is “synonymous with free movement” (it isn’t)
…but another poor sign for those hoping Labour will be brave on EU. /1
Via @ft
www.ft.com/content/feb93c52-b8ca-4137-ba27-2f15b5af85bd?s… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Best news of the week www.theguardian.com/politics/2024/apr/18/brussels-propose…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
There are 37 of these trade envoys: www.gov.uk/government/news/prime-ministers-trade-envoy-pr…. Has any assessment ever been made of their utility? Though unpaid, the jobs must be coveted: are they an informal way of extending the government’s payroll vote? @instituteforgov
The Guardian
@guardian
Mark Menzies suspended from role as unpaid trade envoy to Colombia, says No 10 – UK politics live www.theguardian.com/politics/live/2024/apr/18/rwanda-bill…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
We debate this on Monday 22 April
Williamrt
@Williamrt
Lords to challenge controversial DWP benefits bank account surveillance powers www.computerweekly.com/news/366581392/Lords-to-challenge-… via @computerweekly #surveillance #benefits @DWP @MaeveSherlock @bricksilk @silkiecarlo
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Who would have thought it? Emotional resonance in this Moldovan commercial video, recorded in Norwegian: www.youtube.com/watch?v=vBUekC1C_-w. Takk, @edwardlucas #europe
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
More on #rwandabill coming up from me, on @TimesRadio just after 0830 this morning
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Good to see @RobertBuckland standing up for what he believes. Next round of ping pong starts soon in @UKHouseofLords, with likely votes on monitoring and Afghans, though double insistence does not seem to be in our repertoire of shots this time around.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Peston
@itvpeston
.@Peston: Why were you the only Conservative MP to rebel?
@RobertBuckland: I have long felt if we are going to deem Rwanda a safe country, let’s make sure the facts meet the law
Former Justice Sec on why he voted in favour of the Lord's amendments to the Rwanda Bill
#peston -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
#rwandabill ping pong latest: victory for Lord Hope’s monitoring amendment by 245-208: majority of 37 as against yesterday’s 39. Normally margins reduce as the Bill proceeds: this is a big one.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And victory for Lord Browne’s Afghan amendment by 247-195 - against, almost the same as last night
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Crossbenchers broke 46-1 for Hope and 42-1 for Browne. No rebels against any of the main party whips.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Acute and timely analysis: the Investigatory Powers Amendment Bill returns to @UKHouseofLords on 23 April. But unless Labour's position has changed, we are unlikely to see "conflict of interest" built into the Bill as a reason for the PM's role in the triple lock to be delegated.
Colin Murray
@CRGMurray
Worth a read from @PaulFScott on the issue of intercepting parliamentarians' communications - an issue that keeps raising its head (especially around the multiple recent alarms over foreign agent interference):
ukconstitutionallaw.org/2024/04/17/paul-f-scott-spying-on… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My remarks on this theme to @BBCr4today this morning are here, from 0810 (2h10m in) www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m001y861
-
David Anderson reposted
Guy Herbert
@guy_herbert
Lord Hope: "Surprisingly, no provision is made anywhere in the Bill for what should happen if the facts change and everyone can see that Rwanda is no longer safe."
[30 years this month since the Rwandan genocide: 800,000 people in 100 days, which is something of a record. - GH]
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Four more @UKHouseofLords defeats for the government tonight on #rwandabill, by margins of 17 to 57 votes. This speech by Lord Hope, ex-Deputy President of @UKSupremeCourt, well expresses the idiocy of what we are being asked to do hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-04-16/debates/1DEECB02-A…. /1
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Four more @UKHouseofLords defeats for the government tonight on #rwandabill, by margins of 17 to 57 votes. This speech by Lord Hope, ex-Deputy President of @UKSupremeCourt, well expresses the idiocy of what we are being asked to do hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-04-16/debates/1DEECB02-A…. /1
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Bumped from @BBCr4today tomorrow so thought I would get this off my chest now … /end
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Stop press – reprieved by @BBCr4today (perhaps they read X) - should be on around 0710.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
0810
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Now rescheduled to talk about #rwandabill and double insistence at 0810 on @BBCr4today.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Four more @UKHouseofLords defeats for the government tonight on #rwandabill, by margins of 17 to 57 votes. This speech by Lord Hope, ex-Deputy President of @UKSupremeCourt, well expresses the idiocy of what we are being asked to do hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-04-16/debates/1DEECB02-A…. /1
-
David Anderson reposted
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
I was proud to vote in favour of the amendments passed this evening. There is an overwhelming case for the Gov’t to give some ground especially on the two amendments cited by @bricksilk. First, that Afghans who risked their lives working for UK armed forces should be exempt 1/2
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Four more @UKHouseofLords defeats for the government tonight on #rwandabill, by margins of 17 to 57 votes. This speech by Lord Hope, ex-Deputy President of @UKSupremeCourt, well expresses the idiocy of what we are being asked to do hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-04-16/debates/1DEECB02-A…. /1
-
David Anderson reposted
British Future
@britishfuture
As Parliament debates the 'Safety of Rwanda' Bill again this week, a reminder of our @focaldataHQ polling, which found that the majority of the public support almost all of the Lords' amendments.
www.britishfuture.org/public-backs-lords-in-clash-with-go… -
David Anderson reposted
PoliticsHome
@politicshome
🔎 Dr Hannah White, director at @instituteforgov, noted that lately the "Commons has been spending less time" on legislation, while peers in the House of Lords "see it as their job" to get into the details
www.politicshome.com/news/article/house-of-lords-scrutiny… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Climate change has provoked judicial activism across the world, from India to the Netherlands and - today - Strasbourg hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng{%22itemid%22:[%22001-233206%22]}. www.lse.ac.uk/research/research-for-the-world/sustainabil…. /1
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
But read Judge Eicke (UK)'s dissenting opinion: "I fear that in this judgment the majority has gone beyond what it is legitimate and permissible for this Court to do and, unfortunately, in doing so, may well have achieved exactly the opposite effect to what was intended." /3
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I fear he may be right. /4
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Quite right
Transparency International UK
@TransparencyUK
📣 NEW REPORT 📣
We need to reform the House of Lords!
Our research found almost 1 in 4 party nominations were political donors – handing over £58 million since 2013.
This is damaging public trust and bringing the Lords into disrepute.
Read more ➡️ www.transparency.org.uk/seats-sale-new-research-reveals-w… -
David Anderson reposted
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
As readouts of calls with leaders of friendly countries go, this is quite something. The Netanyahu Government's conduct of the war in Gaza is doing serious damage to Israel's relationships even with its closest friends
-
David Anderson reposted
António Guterres
@antonioguterres
The devastating Israeli airstrikes that killed @WCKitchen personnel yesterday bring the number of aid workers killed in this conflict to 196 – including more than 175 members of our own @UN staff.
This is unconscionable. -
David Anderson reposted
Ipswich Town
@IpswichTown
ghterghpeagoherwghubfreguhgreukhafegruhb
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A quota reserved for hereditaries is utterly indefensible. But some have proved their excellence and should not be excluded from a reformed, more meritocratic system of fixed-term appointments to @UKHouseofLords. www.ft.com/products
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
If you read nothing else today …
Simon Knott
@TheSimonKnott
The story of the Ipswich Underground Railway is well-known today. But when the story was first published #otd in 2007 it aroused great interest, appearing in the press and on local radio, and perhaps inspiring a generation of amateur urban archaeologists: www.simonknott.co.uk/ipswichunderground.htm
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Simon Knott
@TheSimonKnott
Thank you for your indulgence, and particular thanks to those who played along. The Great Ipswich Underground Hoax started as an April Fool's joke in 2007 on Flickr. I take full responsibility, although it was with the advice and suggestions of a number of other local flickrers that it was all drawn together.
The Train Operating Company ONE, which ran East Anglia's trains at the time, very kindly helped by reporting the thing as truth, lock stock and barrel, in its in-flight magazine, which gave it a certain amount of traction. When I was the sofa guest on @lesleydolphin's afternoon show on @BBCSuffolk that week, mainly talking about Suffolk churches, she also asked me about the Underground, and we both managed to keep a straight face.
Of course, it couldn't last, so I was pleased when @Geates exposed it in the gentlest way in the @ipswichstar24 (👇). However, the website remained up, and over the years I hope that some people have got a small amount of pleasure from it.
I was particularly grateful to people who contacted me with further evidence of the system, most of all to one particular person who claimed they broke into one of the surviving stations, which at the time was disused. They made their way down to the cellars and took photos, which they sent to me. As they quite rightly said, the vaulted roofs look as if they were once part of a tunnel. I still don't know if they were spoofing me, which is just as it should be.
Incidentally, the site works better on a desktop than on a phone, because an account of each individual building appears under the photo without having to look for it.
Simon Knott
@TheSimonKnott
The story of the Ipswich Underground Railway is well-known today. But when the story was first published #otd in 2007 it aroused great interest, appearing in the press and on local radio, and perhaps inspiring a generation of amateur urban archaeologists: www.simonknott.co.uk/ipswichunderground.htm
-
David Anderson reposted
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
The government will have to decide that approx 99% of 2023 and 2024 arrivals are exempt from the duty to remove (having promised to remove 100% of those who arrived after 7th March 2023). You can see why they would like to avoid a pre-election decision if they possibly could
Lizzie Dearden
@lizziedearden
Exclusive: Rishi Sunak’s small boats law has been given a “red” risk rating by the Home Office as civil servants wait for ministers to make decisions on how asylum seekers will be treated
A key question is who will be exempt from the new “duty to remove”
inews.co.uk/news/politics/sunak-small-boats-plan-stalled-… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Happy Easter!
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Interim Measures from the European Court of Human Rights: amended Rule 39 and Practice Direction published today hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng-press?i=00…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Commentary by @JoshuaRozenberg open.substack.com/pub/rozenberg/p/strasbourg-tightens-rul…
-
David Anderson reposted
Derrick Wyatt's Law and Policy Blog
@BlogWyatt
The International Court of Justice has ordered Israel to allow unimpeded access of food aid into Gaza, where sections of the population are facing imminent starvation, in a significant legal rebuke to Israel’s claim it is not blocking aid deliveries.
www.theguardian.com/world/2024/mar/28/famine-is-setting-i… -
David Anderson reposted
The News Agents
@TheNewsAgents
“Be careful what you wish for, there's a reason people around the world watch moments from PMQs - it’s unusual."
Q&A: Is PMQs is fit for purpose? 🤔
👉 global-player.onelink.me/Br0x/TNANewEpisode
@maitlis | @jonsopel | @lewis_goodallThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson reposted
Ben Riley-Smith
@benrileysmith
The government has quietly slipped out new honours just before the Easter break. An eye-catcher in there:
Tory donor Mohamed Mansour, who gave a whopping £5m to the party last year, is handed a knighthood. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
John Brownlee was my form teacher at @edinburghacad in 1968-69, when I was 7-8 years old. I recognise some of the behaviour described and though I was not as badly marked by it as many others, am glad to see that justice has been done in this way. www.copfs.gov.uk/about-copfs/news/edinburgh-teacher-found…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Thanks to the 42 who gave evidence, and sorry I didn’t join you.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A classy tribute to a class act
Alex Chalk KC
@AlexChalkChelt
Yesterday marked the final episode of @JoshuaRozenberg’s Law in Action which he has used to shine a light on our justice system.
I enjoyed sitting down to chat with him last year after my appointment as Lord Chancellor and wish him all the best. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The insights of a lifetime, compellingly communicated and focused on the future of our country, our species and our planet. Worth an hour of anyone’s time.
Martin Rees
@LordMartinRees
the Lord Speaker is doing a series of wide-ranging interviews with members of the House of Lords.
This is my contribution
www.youtube.com/watch?v=L6NJTEiGb1E -
David Anderson reposted
IPCO
@IPCOffice
We have published our 2022 Annual Report, which covers the use and oversight of covert investigatory powers by UK public authorities:
www.ipco.org.uk/news/report-published-on-oversight-and-us… -
David Anderson reposted
The News Agents
@TheNewsAgents
"Putin has been working with the Taliban - a sworn enemy of ISIS."
Prof. of Global History, Peter Frankopan on why ISIS-K targeted Moscow, calling it a 'recruitment drive' for the terror organisation.
@maitlis | @jonsopel
👉 global-player.onelink.me/Br0x/TNANewEpisode -
David Anderson reposted
Ben Bloch
@realBenBloch
🚨 France raises its terror alert to its highest level tonight after a security and defence council meeting, convened by Macron.
France’s PM says this decision is due to the ISIS attack in Moscow and “threats facing our country”.
Gabriel Attal
@GabrielAttal
À la suite de l’attentat de Moscou, un Conseil de Défense et de Sécurité nationale a été réuni ce soir à l’Elysée par le Président de la République.
Compte tenu de la revendication de l’attentat par l’état islamique et des menaces qui pèsent sur notre pays, nous avons décidé de rehausser la posture Vigipirate à son niveau le plus élevé : urgence attentat. -
David Anderson reposted
ThinkingWest
@thinkingwest
"Since it is so likely that children will meet cruel enemies, let them at least have heard of brave knights and heroic courage."
C.S. Lewis -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The new rules for controlling media ownership by "foreign powers" have been published today, in the form of government amendments to #dmbill: bills.parliament.uk/publications/54855/documents/4610. Comments?
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Shocking.
Annette Dittert
@annettedittert
At the request of so many of my followers here: This is my short film on how social inequality and poverty have reached unprecedented levels in Britain, now with English subtitles. Tx a lot for all your comments and the extraordinary feedback this had !
www.youtube.com/watch?v=gj2WgG2CDPU&t=1s -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Impressively candid from @JohnnyMercerUK. To my mind it vindicates those (led by George Robertson and “noble and gallant lords”) who opposed in @UKHouseofLords - with limited success - attempts to give those on overseas operations immunity from prosecution #oobill.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Here’s the hard-won exclusion in the Overseas Operations Act 2021 for war crimes and others within the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2021/23/schedule/1/enacted
-
David Anderson reposted
Kate McCann
@KateEMcCann
Bringing back next week means 3 line whip = MPs have to be back in Commons for long slog. They're cross, early break helps calm everyone down (in theory). But second reason? Delay means Gov can 'blame' Labour/Lords for blocking & pushes moment it's passed closer to May... 2/
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
UK shamed here by the excellent Siofra O’Leary, outgoing President of the European Court of Human Rights. For all the good work done by @UKHouseofLords last night, repeal of #rwandabill cl5, a blow to the heart of ECtHR interim measures, was not even on the agenda.
Ed Bates
@EdBatesECHR
In a recent speech,* President of the @ECHR_CEDH cites major challenges facing the ECHR system today. She highlights the problem that some stats see the ECHR as for others not themselves...
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This is what I had to say about the issue in Parliament: www.theyworkforyou.com/lords/?id=2024-02-19b.470.1
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Vote on former Supreme Court Justice Lord Hope’s first amendment (which I signed previously) passed by a significantly bigger majority of 55, with his fellow crossbenchers breaking 71-10 and Ken Clarke viting against the government.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
First vote carried 271-228
David Anderson
@bricksilk
7 @UKHouseofLords votes on #rwandabill expected tonight: bills.parliament.uk/publications/54768/documents/4596
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
No votes, sadly, on my amendments to allow decision-makers to consider evidence that Rwanda is not safe. So on to the Chakrabarti amendment providing for judicial remedies …
David Anderson
@bricksilk
… which passed by 30 votes. Smaller majority, but a much more ambitious rule of law amendment.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
First vote carried 271-228
David Anderson
@bricksilk
7 @UKHouseofLords votes on #rwandabill expected tonight: bills.parliament.uk/publications/54768/documents/4596
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Rigorous party discipline on both sides. Crossbenchers (light grey) broke 57-16 so effectively produced the majority.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
(Con 204, Lab +LD 199)
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
7 @UKHouseofLords votes on #rwandabill expected tonight: bills.parliament.uk/publications/54768/documents/4596
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Destroying the system from the inside …
Sam Macrory
@sammacrory
Brilliant from @DrHannahWhite on Simon Case’s men-only Garrick Club membership:
‘Simon Case’s professed selfless motive for joining the Garrick will sound bizarre to the 284,000 women of the civil service who it would bar from membership’
amp.theguardian.com/politics/2024/mar/19/uks-top-civil-se… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Key insight from the LCJ: the moral courage of our judges has traditionally been forged when they were advocates in difficult circumstances. A flourishing self-employed Bar is a key to judicial independence, as a Royal Commission (which would be welcome) will surely agree. /1
Joshua Rozenberg
@JoshuaRozenberg
Top judge seeks evidence
Lady chief justice says scrutiny could improve criminal justice system
New post, free to read: rozenberg.substack.com/p/top-judge-seeks-evidencePost not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
An expert on the human brain once explained it to me in terms of neural pathways: habits of independent thought learned before 50 are never abandoned - likewise, habits of obedience to authority. /3
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I’m glad we have an LCJ who not only understands this so well, but is fully committed to evidence-based reform of our criminal justice system. Bring it on. /4
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Here are the “reasons” of @HouseofCommons for rejecting my amendments to #rwandabill. They require credible evidence to be ignored, taking us all for fools. But with majorities of c. 70 in the elected House, and @RobertBuckland the only Tory rebel, hard choices lie ahead.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Good sense from @instituteforgov
Institute for Government
@instituteforgov
Rishi Sunak should not disregard Lords scrutiny of his Rwanda bill www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/comment/rishi-sunak-dis…
-
David Anderson reposted
Institute for Government
@instituteforgov
Rishi Sunak should not disregard Lords scrutiny of his Rwanda bill www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/comment/rishi-sunak-dis…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
These suggestions could make a real contribution to restoring trust in our democracy. constitution-unit.com/2024/03/19/constitutional-watchdogs…
-
David Anderson reposted
UK Parliament Human Rights Committee
@HumanRightsCtte
We're scrutinising the Government's proposals on extremism on Wednesday 20 March at 2.15pm.
We'll hear from:
- Sara Khan @CohesionReview
- Ruth Ehrlich @ruth_ehrlich, @libertyhq
- Joshua Rozenberg @JoshuaRozenberg
Find out more: committees.parliament.uk/event/21049/formal-meeting-oral-… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A remarkable read, including on the role of education in fostering integration in UK. These figures are particularly striking.
Sam Freedman
@Samfr
New post just out
With the PM talking of "mob rule" and columnists saying we're too diverse - I thought I'd take a look at what the data said...
"The truth about integration"
(Free to read)
open.substack.com/pub/samf/p/the-truth-about-integration?… -
David Anderson reposted
Richard Albert
@RichardAlbert
🌍 Ten most difficult constitutions to amend, listed alphabetically, along with one notable cause for the difficulty of amending each.
-
David Anderson reposted
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
As the Rwanda Safety Bill returns to the Commons, what do the public think of the Lords amendments?
New @focaldataHQ research for @britishfuture finds strong and broad public support for the proposed changes to the bill
www.britishfuture.org/public-backs-lords-in-clash-with-go… -
David Anderson reposted
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
The free flow of data between 🇬🇧🇪🇺is vital for businesses and for law enforcement. At the moment it is enabled by a data adequacy decision by the EU. But this expires in 2025. How are things working now? What would be the implications of losing data adequacy? Evidence please!
Lords European Affairs Committee
@LordsEUCom
🆕We have launched an inquiry into data adequacy and its implications for the UK-EU relationship.
📖Read more and have your say! (deadline for written submissions: 3 May 2024)
committees.parliament.uk/committee/516/european-affairs-c… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Interview on extremism here www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/show/20240314-26578/2024-03-14, from 7 minutes in.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Just recorded a much longer interview on all this (and @OppenheimerFilm) with @mariellaf1 @TimesRadio - airing after 1pm.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And a good piece in @thetimes on the same theme, from Matthew Parris
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/deba27d6-6003-48d2-ba6a-ae52b3… -
David Anderson reposted
IPCO
@IPCOffice
We are currently seeking to recruit a Chief Inspector.
To find out more and apply, please visit Civil Service Jobs: www.civilservicejobs.service.gov.uk/csr/jobs.cgi?jcode=19… -
David Anderson reposted
Catherine Barnard
@CSBarnard24
Gosh. This is striking. Note UK declined to make observations. curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2024-03/…
-
David Anderson reposted
Mariella Frostrup
@mariellaf1
Ready for brain food this lunchtime? 1-3pm @TimesRadio
1.08pm Extremism @bricksilk + @GreenpeaceUK
1.15pm Racism row @TrevorPTweets
1.20pm Cancer treatment @CR_UK
1.35pm Brave new world @cyberbaines
1.40pm Life & Times Tom Priestly
1.50pm OTG in Nigeria @TheValentineBen -
David Anderson reposted
Mariella Frostrup
@mariellaf1
So interesting to talk you about extremism and the spectre of McCarthyism @TimesRadio
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Just recorded a much longer interview on all this (and @OppenheimerFilm) with @mariellaf1 @TimesRadio - airing after 1pm.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Just recorded a much longer interview on all this (and @OppenheimerFilm) with @mariellaf1 @TimesRadio - airing after 1pm.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Very small parts! Democracy is not a suicide pact. But there are issues on process, scrutiny, challenge, monitoring (surveillance?) and defining precisely what is prohibited: expansion of the policy is mooted, and the law of unintended consequences looms large.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I think parts of the pre-record I have just done will go out before the 0810 interview.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Due to speak about the new extremism definition on @BBCr4today in the morning, time tbc
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/332ec007-262a-491f-9d06-5d2070…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I made the point on @BBCr4today that the characterisation as extremism of intolerant ideologies which negate fundamental rights of others is likely to appeal to both sides of the trans debate: there will be a challenge in keeping even this narrower definition focussed.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I think parts of the pre-record I have just done will go out before the 0810 interview.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Due to speak about the new extremism definition on @BBCr4today in the morning, time tbc
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/332ec007-262a-491f-9d06-5d2070… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Due to speak about the new extremism definition on @BBCr4today in the morning, time tbc
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/332ec007-262a-491f-9d06-5d2070… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Debating (and if necessary voting on) this tomorrow in @UKHouseofLords: the detail is negotiable, but the principle is that foreign governments should not be able to take control of news media organisations in the UK. #digitalmarketsbill
David Anderson
@bricksilk
More here www.spectator.co.uk/article/peers-back-vote-on-foreign-st…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Looks like good news may be on the way …
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/a31a4284-437b-4267-9487-f5a03d… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Deprivation of citizenship leading to statelessness: 2014 power still not used, and will be reviewed after first use: answer to my written question here: members.parliament.uk/member/4705/writtenquestions
David Anderson
@bricksilk
-
David Anderson reposted
Gavin Phillipson
@Prof_Phillipson
Such a significant mark of fully-deserved distinction: congratulations and the very best of luck in the process to @colmocinneide
UCL Faculty of Laws
@UCLLaws
Professor Colm O'Cinneide, Professor of Constitutional and Human Rights Law at @UCLLaws, has been nominated For election as a Judge of the European Court of Human Rights @colmocinneide tinyurl.com/yc8mn9xu
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And member of the Rwanda Monitoring Committee under the U.K.-Rwanda Treaty
Lords Committee on Justice and Home Affairs
@LordsJHACom
At 10:30 am, the Committee will hear oral evidence from Hon. Alexander Downer AC @AIexandernDoner, author of An Independent Review of Border Force.
📺Watch live:
parliamentlive.tv/event/index/8c051569-2f38-49aa-bba0-650… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My written question to the FCDO about this has been (sort of) answered.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Can Russian state assets be confiscated to support the reconstruction of Ukraine? Philippa Webb @KCL_Law reviews the options for @Europarl_EN - and finds some potentially workable options. www.europarl.europa.eu/thinktank/en/document/EPRS_STU(202… via @Europarl_EN
-
David Anderson reposted
Colin Murray
@CRGMurray
When anyone says investigating the legacy of the NI conflict is expensive, a reminder from the Kenova report why doing so matters. We're looking to live in a liberal democracy, in which the state is responsible for upholding rights even amid conflict:
www.kenova.co.uk/Kenova Report 2024 Digital version - FIN… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The Security Minister notes that #rwandabill had "a hell of a scrubbing" in @UKHouseofLords. But detailed, public, on-the-ground scrutiny both in UK and in Rwanda is needed for informed judgements on whether Rwanda is safe and the policy effective.
BBC Radio 4 Today
@BBCr4today
Security Minister Tom Tugendhat responds to sacked immigration chief David Neal's revelations on The Today Podcast that there will be no independent oversight of the government's Rwanda policy if he's not replaced.
#r4today -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Full of admiration for these people. They are right on all counts. www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-68526577
-
David Anderson reposted
Will Gompertz
@Will_Gompertz
Let’s explore the Breakfast Room at the @soanemuseum, a space John Soane built to celebrate the ‘poetry of architecture’. I think it’s the perfect distillation of everything that makes Soane fascinating as an artist, collector and human!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A huge debt is owed to John Boutcher and his team for his thorough and even-handed Kenova interim report. Some conclusions here.
Police Service NI
@PoliceServiceNI
Operation Kenova Interim Report published.
Further information and full report here: www.psni.police.uk/latest-news/operation-kenova-interim-r… -
David Anderson reposted
Steve Peers
@StevePeers
Using the Windsor Framework to disapply an Act of Parliament
Analysis of a recent judgment, by @governmentalite and @CRGMurray eulawanalysis.blogspot.com/2024/03/the-dillon-judgment-di… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Labour, #rwandabill, political power and the constitution: characteristically acute contribution from @IanDunt to the @sundersays / @RuthFox01 debate (flagged here x.com/bricksilk/status/1764954524555399657).
Ian Dunt
@IanDunt
For an assortment of political and strategic reasons, Labour is about to give way on Rwanda. They are going to buckle at the last minute. And the tragic fact is that every one of those reasons is wrong.
iandunt.substack.com/p/rwanda-were-in-the-endgame-now -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A shout out on #iwd2024 for this engaging new book by @satisfactory20: the untold story of Parliament's working women www.thehistorypress.co.uk/publication/necessary-women/978…. Available in the Parliament Shop and in all good offline and online stores.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Five more big victories in #rwandabill debates today, to add to Monday’s haul. We had a debate on the proposed new cl5 power for Ministers to disregard r39 interim measures from the ECtHR. My first contribution is here: hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-03-06/debates/4475C1E4-2… /1
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This exchange indicated that the government accepts - through clenched teeth - that compliance with r39 measures is required by international law, save where it is impossible - … /2
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The letter has arrived!
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I had sympathy with the argument made by Ken Clarke that with a more aggressive strategy from @UKLabour, we could have hung on to more of these gains. But the politics dictated otherwise. We did what we could, and will continue to do so. /7
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Some highlights on @BBCRadio4 last night, from 12-18 minutes in www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m001wy05?partner=uk.co.bbc&orig… /8
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Long evidence session in @HLConstitution yesterday morning with devolution experts Philip Rycroft and Professor Jim Gallagher: you can watch here (no transcript yet) www.parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/3704d930-e4a4-4590-8ba0….
-
David Anderson reposted
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
If you are a young 🇬🇧 or 🇫🇷 professional interested in understanding the other country better and creating a network of friendships helping to keep the UK-France entente going for another generation, then please apply! It is a very special opportunity.
FrancoBritishCouncil
@francobritish
Two days left to apply for our prestigious Young Leaders programme 2024. Information about the programme and application process is available here: francobritish.org/en/young-leaders/
Deadline to apply: Friday 8th March at 23.59 GMT. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Wisdom, as always, from @sundersays on this tricky subject
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
Times letter today. On the government proposing to redefine "extremism" (again) in a General Election year. A useful policy will require cross-party consensus, rather than a party political "dividing line"
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/times-letters-discord-over-new… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Can hardly believe what the German Ambassador has just said on @BBCr4today. No apology called for because a “secure line” was used – over hotel Internet!
-
David Anderson reposted
UCL European Institute
@UCL_EI
Proud to be launching our new book @UCLpress tonight:
Parliament Buildings: The architecture of politics in Europe
Edited by @SophiaPsarra, @ukstaiger & Claudia Sternberg
W/ respondents @bricksilk, @satisfactory20 & Níall McLaughlin @BartlettARchUCL
rb.gy/o3j0kh -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Contrasting threads from @sundersays and @RuthFox01 on @UKLabour's current approach to government bills in @UKHouseofLords.
Ruth Fox
@RuthFox01
🧵@DArcyTiP & I have been discussing this for weeks on a the @HansardSociety podcast Parliament Matters. But there's another strand to Labour's thinking on this. If Lab wins GE it will not have a majority in the Lords. It has nearly 100 fewer Peers than the Cons. 1/
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Better news overnight - it looks as though there may be movement on the very particular issue of Afghans who assisted British forces, championed by Lord Browne of Ladyton and senior military figures in @UKHouseofLords: inews.co.uk/news/politics/afghan-veterans-who-fought-with…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A nominally successful but still frustrating fifth day on #rwandabill was summed up tonight by former head of the diplomatic service, Lord Kerr. The government hears us, sustains huge defeats, but (unusually in our system) shows no real signs of actually listening.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Reflecting on yesterday’s debates, from 0736 www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/live:bbc_radio_scotland_fm?part…
Gary Robertson
@BBCGaryR
Rwanda bill: Government suffers five defeats in House of Lords.
We'll speak to cross-bench peer Lord Anderson of Ipswich @bricksilk
#bbcgms 0735
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-68473525 -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Five huge majorities in @UKHouseofLords today to amend #rwandabill, with more votes likely on Wednesday (Afghans, children, victims of slavery, clause 4, backlog). My rule of law amendments, supported by Ken Clarke and others, went through by 87 and 91 votes - others by 100+.
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
Starting voting @UKHouseofLords on the Rwanda Bill. First vote amends Para 1 of the Bill (setting out its purpose). It inserts the requirement that removals to Rwanda can only take place in ‘full compliance with domestic and international law’. Carried by large majority 274/142
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Reported here amp.theguardian.com/world/2024/mar/04/lords-pass-five-ame…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A nominally successful but still frustrating fifth day on #rwandabill was summed up tonight by former head of the diplomatic service, Lord Kerr. The government hears us, sustains huge defeats, but (unusually in our system) shows no real signs of actually listening.
-
David Anderson reposted
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
The House of Lords has voted by 274 votes to 172, a majority of 102, to amend the Rwanda Safety Bill, by adding that it should “maintain full compliance with domestic and international law.”
(The government opposed this amendment).
votes.parliament.uk/votes/lords/division/3088 -
David Anderson reposted
Matt Purvis
@HLLibResearch
The 100+ results are probably the biggest margins of govt defeat since peers returned to in-person voting in the lobbies in 2022.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Five huge majorities in @UKHouseofLords today to amend #rwandabill, with more votes likely on Wednesday (Afghans, children, victims of slavery, clause 4, backlog). My rule of law amendments, supported by Ken Clarke and others, went through by 87 and 91 votes - others by 100+.
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
Starting voting @UKHouseofLords on the Rwanda Bill. First vote amends Para 1 of the Bill (setting out its purpose). It inserts the requirement that removals to Rwanda can only take place in ‘full compliance with domestic and international law’. Carried by large majority 274/142
-
David Anderson reposted
Tom Hickman
@TomRHickman
Listening to the excellent @RestIsPolitics @RoryStewartUK @campbellclaret on the Begum case has brought home to me just how much confusion there is about the deprivation of citizenship power. Here are 7 important facts about the power, starting with some common misconceptions :…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Interview here, starting at 08:10 www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/live:bbc_radio_fourfm?partner=u…
BBC Radio 4 Today
@BBCr4today
The Rwanda bill is set to come under more scrutiny as the House of Lords debates and votes on amendments this week.
Crossbench peer Lord Anderson tells @MishalHusain he has concerns the bill is 'constitutionally inappropriate' and 'jeopardises the rule of law'.
#r4today -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Will be talking about #rwandabill on @BBCr4today at 0810 today
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
"Just because extremism is a word does not mean that it is a useful legal concept": my reflections from 2019 on this once again topical subject. www.daqc.co.uk/2019/03/20/extremism-and-the-law/
-
David Anderson reposted
Miqdaad Versi
@miqdaad
When we discuss a future extremism strategy, it is valuable to use the 15 point test that the former Independent Reviewer of Terrorism Legislation @bricksilk identified.
It seems the current @terrorwatchdog has some similar areas of scepticism.
terrorismlegislationreviewer.independent.gov.uk/wp-conten…
Rich Preston
@RichPreston
Rishi Sunak says Britain must face-down "extremists" who are trying to undermine democracy, and that a robust new framework is needed to deal with the issue. But Jonathan Hall KC, the Independent Reviewer of State Threats Legislation, says 'extremism' is very hard to define
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson reposted
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
I would suggest reading the Intelligence and Security Committee 2022 report, the MI5 annual update of the terrorism threat, and the government response to the Prevent Review for answers to your questions about the extreme right-wing terrorism threat
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Some stimulating themes in this book – e.g. the European project as a vehicle first for imperial consolidation (here), and later for “imperial amnesia”.
Hans Kundnani
@hanskundnani
My book #eurowhiteness comes out in August. Pre-order it here: geni.us/hAtEWeb
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
All fair comments, though habits of tolerance, applicable more widely, are surely acquired even from integration limited to Europe. The EU may reflect nationalist prejudices, but it doesn’t intensify them – rather the reverse.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Anyway, it’s a good read – and all in less than 200 pages.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Keller brilliantly captures the essence of @UKHouseofLords, from its many absurdities (though, as he points out, the US too has “a satire-worthy democracy”) to the debates “like graduate seminars in which everyone has done their homework”.
Prospect
@prospect_uk
Opulent leather benches. A gilded throne. An immense red pillow.
It’s easy to caricature the Lords, says former NYT editor Bill Keller. But we shouldn’t:
www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/politics/65033/house-of-lords-… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Makes sense to me
IPCO
@IPCOffice
We have published an update on our website following the merger of the Investigatory Powers Commissioner’s Office and the Office for Communications Data Authorisations:
www.ipco.org.uk/news/sir-brian-leveson-announces-the-merg… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Applications for UK judge to the European Court of Human Rights – Judicial Appointments Commission judicialappointments.gov.uk/applications-for-uk-judge-to-…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This is a significant judgment, not just for #nitroublesbill but for #rwandabill where there also potential breaches of #niprotocol Art 2 that could result in the partial disapplication of the eventual Act. /1
David Anderson
@bricksilk
These concerns were raised by @NIHRC nihrc.org/publication/detail/nihrc-advice-on-the-safety-o… and in @UKHouseofLords (including by me: www.theyworkforyou.com/lords/?id=2024-02-12b.99.2 ). The NI courts are likely to have to rule on them, as in yesterday's judgment on #nitroublesbill. /2
David Anderson
@bricksilk
If the Bill is not substantially amended and those concerns are upheld in the courts, it will demonstrate that EU law has no truck with the legal fiction that Rwanda is irrebuttably safe - and has a surer hold on the rule of law than our own government and Parliament. /3
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Looking forward to speaking next Tuesday at the launch of this fascinating inter-disciplinary book on parliamentary architecture in Europe (already downloable for free) www.ucl.ac.uk/european-institute/events/2024/mar/parliame… @UCL_EI
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
First oral witness was the always interesting @ciaranmartinoxf, speaking to us on Wednesday from Australia where it was Thursday www.parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/4b45f63c-d6cd-4205-86ea….
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Relations between UK and devolved administrations is the subject of @HLConstitution’s next report: call for evidence published today committees.parliament.uk/call-for-evidence/3350/
-
David Anderson reposted
Matt Purvis
@HLLibResearch
2nd reading of the Media Bill takes place in the Lords later on today. Lord Forsyth has tabled “but this House regrets that the bill does not make provision concerning the ownership and control by foreign governments of newspapers in the United Kingdom”. lordslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/lln-2024-0006/
-
David Anderson reposted
Independent Reviewer
@terrorwatchdog
Today, formal response by gov to my annual report (Terrorism Acts in 2021): 6 recommendations accepted, one partially accepted, one rejected, plus acceptance of recommendation on 'Ernest Moret' review, as follows.../1
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Can Russian state assets be confiscated to support the reconstruction of Ukraine? Philippa Webb @KCL_Law reviews the options for @Europarl_EN - and finds some potentially workable options. www.europarl.europa.eu/thinktank/en/document/EPRS_STU(202… via @Europarl_EN
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Let's see what our government makes of it - I've asked this WQ questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/deta…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I have signed this important amendment, on which (if not accepted by government) @UKHouseofLords is likely to vote on 11 or 13 March. Further piece from @FraserNelson here: www.spectator.co.uk/article/lords-amendment-could-thwart-…
Tina Stowell
@tinastowell
.@Telegraph report on the amendment I’ve tabled to the Digital Markets & Competition Bill, which would prevent foreign govts buying UK news organisations without explicit approval of Parliament.
www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2024/02/26/lords-seek-powers…
Here is text of amendment -
David Anderson reposted
Peter Foster
@pmdfoster
A story that should concern leaves and remainers equally. Thread later.
Giles Wilkes
@Gilesyb
"How UK regulators are missing a chance to make the best of Brexit" - www.ft.com/products Excellent via @pmdfoster
One of the many ironies of Brexit may end up being that any eventual benefits rely on non-Brexiteer politicians with a greater belief in state capacity -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Relations between UK and devolved administrations is the subject of @HLConstitution’s next report: call for evidence published today committees.parliament.uk/call-for-evidence/3350/
-
David Anderson reposted
Paul Seaward
@pseaward1
Deeply dismayed to hear of the death of Lord Cormack: a great supporter of @Histparl of which he was chairman (never chair) for 15 years. The passing of an era. @LordNortonLouth
-
David Anderson reposted
Timothy Garton Ash
@fromTGA
Sometimes debating skills honed at @UniofOxford can be put to *really* good purpose. This 4- minute history lesson to Russia by @radeksikorski is one for the ages…
Kancelaria Premiera
@PremierRP
Minister @MSZ_RP @sikorskiradek podczas wczorajszego wystąpienia w #onz o prezentacji rosyjskiego ambasadora: Kijów nie jest klientem Zachodu. Kijów walczy o niezależność, a Ukraina ma demokratycznie wybrany rząd i nie jest zbrodniczym reżimem. To Rosja próbowała eksterminować Ukrainę i to nie pierwszy raz. Historia pokazuje, że często to Rosja była agresorem, a nie ofiarą.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson reposted
Rory Stewart
@RoryStewartUK
This idea that “London is in the grip of Islamists” is deluded and it’s awful - an obsession that thrives among a bizarre and dangerous coalition. No conservative MP should ever be spouting this stuff.
Adam Bienkov
@AdamBienkov
Conservative MP Lee Anderson tells GB News that he thinks Sadiq Khan has "given our capital city away" to Islamists, who are "his mates".
"Islamists have got control of Khan and they’ve got control of London," he says. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
🤩
-
David Anderson reposted
Hannah White
@DrHannahWhite
Last night’s events in the Commons reinforce many of the themes I explored in my book - Held in Contempt - about the need for parliamentary reform - impenetrable procedure, government dominance of the Commons’ agenda, introspection and loss of trust… manchesteruniversitypress.co.uk/9781526156693/
-
David Anderson reposted
The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom
@UKSupremeCourt
Applications are now open for Judicial Assistants to join us for the 2024/25 legal year:
🗓️Closing date 31st March
🖥️Online information event 5th March
🎓Minimum requirements of a 2:1 degree with 2 years of legal study and research.
Apply online: www.supremecourt.uk/about/ja-recruitment.html -
David Anderson reposted
UKCLA
@ukcla
Raffael N. Fasel: Ouster Clauses and the Silent Constitutional Crisis ukconstitutionallaw.org?p=13464
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
UK bill to send asylum seekers to Rwanda ‘undercuts human rights’: UN rights chief news.un.org/en/story/2024/02/1146662
-
David Anderson reposted
Gordon Corera
@gordoncorera
An online site run by a major cyber criminal gang appears to have been taken over by law enforcement.
On Monday evening, a message appeared on their site saying it was "under the control of the National Crime Agency of the UK"
www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-68344987 -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Why Ministers who act as they say they will under #rwandabill cl5 will be breaching international law, now in print thanks to the night owls of Hansard: hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-02-19/debates/767CA9FE-A…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Ministers seek parliamentary approval in #rwandabill cl5 to ignore interim measures from the #ecthr. @UKHouseofLords debate is here, from 20:39:45 parliamentlive.tv/event/index/8a2641ab-975d-4634-b232-3dd…. I explain why this is unlawful at 21:48:00, and pose (unanswered) questions to the Minister at 22:31:15.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Tearing the fabric of international law - and why we should be ashamed to do so
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The simple question that the Minister (the Advocate General, Scottish Law Officer) was extraordinarily reluctant to answer hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-02-19/debates/767CA9FE-A…. I’ll hope for more clarity in his letter.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Ministers seek parliamentary approval in #rwandabill cl5 to ignore interim measures from the #ecthr. @UKHouseofLords debate is here, from 20:39:45 parliamentlive.tv/event/index/8a2641ab-975d-4634-b232-3dd…. I explain why this is unlawful at 21:48:00, and pose (unanswered) questions to the Minister at 22:31:15.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The essential work of the Chief Inspector has been hobbled by the late publication of reports at least since Theresa May’s time as Home Secretary. Non-publication of 13 consecutive reports, followed by non-appointment to the post, looks like a new and cynical low point.
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
The Chief Inspector of Immigration will leave his post in March - with the Home Office having not published his last 13 reports in the last 12 months. Home Office decision not to renew & intend to take 6-9 months to recruit, so the role is vacant for most of an election year
-
David Anderson reposted
Andrew Defty
@adefty
British former spy chiefs say UK intelligence structure needs a shakeup therecord.media/british-former-spy-chiefs-shakeup @TheRecord_Media
-
David Anderson reposted
Matt Purvis
@HLLibResearch
The Economic Activity of Public Bodies (Overseas Matters) Bill would prevent public authorities from participating in or expressing support for boycott, divestment and sanctions campaigns.
Impartial briefing below 👇
lordslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/lln-2024-0003/ -
David Anderson reposted
Colin Murray
@CRGMurray
Lots going on in this new leave for JR in regard to the application of Article 2 of the Protocol to the Illegal Migration Act. Worth noting how insistent the UK Govt have become that immigration law applies the same way across the UK:
www.bailii.org/nie/cases/NIHC/KB/2024/75.html -
David Anderson reposted
Aileen Kavanagh
@AileenFKavanagh
This from Lord Sales @UKSupremeCourt (2022) @PL_PublicLaw 527 on different conceptions of the separation of powers, with the UK conception based on the relationships between the different institutions in the constitutional scheme.
-
David Anderson reposted
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
@bricksilk nails it. Clause 2 of the Rwanda Bill ‘asserts to be true what first the Supreme Court and then our International Agreements Committee have found to be false, and then to protect that false assertion from rational challenge by decision-makers or in the courts’.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Some superb debates on #rwandabill in @UKHouseofLords today. This is how I opened the debate on the attempt in clause 2 to exclude evidence contradicting the assertion that Rwanda is safe, come what may … hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-02-14/debates/DF3D4002-2…
-
David Anderson reposted
JUSTICE
@JUSTICEhq
Thanks to @bricksilk for an excellent speech and for leading on these rule of law amendments to Clause 2 which we have been supporting.
Pleased there was support from across the House on the importance of full scrutiny of the safety of Rwanda by our domestic courts. #rwandabill
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Some superb debates on #rwandabill in @UKHouseofLords today. This is how I opened the debate on the attempt in clause 2 to exclude evidence contradicting the assertion that Rwanda is safe, come what may … hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-02-14/debates/DF3D4002-2…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The debate can be viewed here (from 13:48): Lords Clarke, Deben and Hoffmann - all speaking without a paper in sight - provided my personal highlights. parliamentlive.tv/event/index/d24b687d-1066-425a-b013-997…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Some superb debates on #rwandabill in @UKHouseofLords today. This is how I opened the debate on the attempt in clause 2 to exclude evidence contradicting the assertion that Rwanda is safe, come what may … hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-02-14/debates/DF3D4002-2…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Some superb debates on #rwandabill in @UKHouseofLords today. This is how I opened the debate on the attempt in clause 2 to exclude evidence contradicting the assertion that Rwanda is safe, come what may … hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-02-14/debates/DF3D4002-2…
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Before that came an expert and moving debate on the treatment of victims of trafficking and Afghans who worked with British forces. hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-02-14/debates/DF3D4002-2…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
@UKLabour have made it clear that they wish neither to block nor delay the Bill - they have the votes to stop either of these outcomes. Those are strong political constraints - but though the Bill will not be wrecked, we must do what we can to improve it.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The moment of truth in yesterday’s @UKHouseofLords Rwanda debate (after 6.15 pm). The government asks us to declare that Rwanda IS safe but had to accept that the necessary safeguards are not in place – and could give us no timescale or meaningful details on progress.
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Much to say on the last point - this from @TomRHickman is interesting.
Tom Hickman
@TomRHickman
According to The Telegraph the Attorney General and Solicitor General have in the recent past advised that there is ‘no respectable argument’ that interim measures are not binding on the Uk. This may help to explain an oddity of the Bill …
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And this from @SirJJKC
-
David Anderson reposted
Gideon Rachman
@gideonrachman
A former president of Mongolia weighs in
ELBEGDORJ Tsakhia Mongol
@elbegdorj
After Putin’s talk. I found Mongolian historic map. Don’t worry. We are a peaceful and free nation🌏
-
David Anderson reposted
Joanna Cherry KC
@joannaccherry
Full report of JCHR @HumanRightsCtte on #rwanda bill published today at link below. We condemn it as fundamentally incompatible with the U.K.‘s international #humanrights obligations. I’ll be on @TimesRadio to discuss at 845am. . committees.parliament.uk/publications/43292/documents/215…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
As the “input legitimacy” of @UKHouseofLords plumbs new depths, yesterday’s wise, thoughtful and unfashionably frank debate on the Conversion Therapy Bill shows its remarkable “output legitimacy”. hansard.parliament.uk/lords/2024-02-09/debates/DB690A34-D…
-
David Anderson reposted
Mr Memory
@AmIRightSir
13 new peerages announced (8 Conservative, 4 Labour, 1 Plaid Cymru): www.gov.uk/government/news/political-peerages-2024
-
David Anderson reposted
Lords Constitution Committee
@HLConstitution
📢We have published our report on the #safetyofrwandabill
"We reiterate that where domestic and international law diverge, the duty reflected in the Ministerial Code to comply with international law remains."
📜You can read the report here: committees.parliament.uk/publications/43291/documents/215… -
David Anderson reposted
Bennett Institute for Public Policy
@BennettInst
🗎In a new guest paper, @ciaranmartinoxf analyses the current state of the UK Union, analyses the competing visions for the UK’s future, & looks at which strategies & levers of government can be used to further each of the competing visions. ⬇️
www.bennettinstitute.cam.ac.uk/publications/contested-vis… -
David Anderson reposted
John Peet
@JohnGPeet
I have recently spent some time in Berlin, Brussels and Paris trying to find out how the EU might greet a prime minister Keir Starmer. Here are a few conclusions. 1/
-
David Anderson reposted
Colm O'Cinneide
@colmocinneide
I'm coming late to it, but this article by @PaulFScott on Lord Diplock and his extra-judicial work in the national security domain is absolutely top-tier legal research. onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1468-2230.12856
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Duly regretted (by 175-159). Check out Lord Hayward’s excellent speech when it appears in Hansard - unanswered by the Minister.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
We have a chance on Tuesday to “regret” (but not to block) this attempt to dictate policy to @ElectoralCommUK, the neutral umpire of the democratic game. Useful explainer as always from @HLLibResearch. lordslibrary.parliament.uk/the-governments-strategy-and-p…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Good news
Independent Reviewer
@terrorwatchdog
I've been appointed Independent Reviewer of State Threats Legislation, which I will do alongside my existing terrorism reviewer role. I will use this twitter account for both.../1
-
David Anderson reposted
Matt Purvis
@HLLibResearch
The Haunted House on the Thames: Behind the Scenes in the House of Lords www.spiegel.de/international/europe/haunted-house-on-the-… via @derspiegel
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
We have a chance on Tuesday to “regret” (but not to block) this attempt to dictate policy to @ElectoralCommUK, the neutral umpire of the democratic game. Useful explainer as always from @HLLibResearch. lordslibrary.parliament.uk/the-governments-strategy-and-p…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
“Of course” the government respects interim measures of the ICJ. Yet where the ECtHR is concerned, it seeks to pick and choose.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
How can clause 5 of the Rwanda Bill be consistent with the ministerial duty to defend judicial independence in s3 of the Constitutional Reform Act 2005? @TomRHickman @Prof_Phillipson @BinghamCentre?
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Excellent initiative and product - manifesto-writers please take note.
-
David Anderson reposted
Anne Applebaum
@anneapplebaum
Seems like a waste of time, or worse, for Congress to make social media CEOs *apologize* for harming people if you aren't going to get serious and regulate them.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
“The real danger of terrorism … is not so much in what it inflicts as in what it provokes.” So true.
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/a-fresh-wave-of-muslim-militan… -
David Anderson reposted
Derrick Wyatt's Law and Policy Blog
@BlogWyatt
"Flattering as it may be for some of us to be treated as infallible, to cast Parliament as decision-maker in this changeable and fact-specific context is fraught with constitutional danger."
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I am critical of #rwandabill, but the elected House passed it unamended and we owe them the courtesy of careful scrutiny. My 4-minute speech on the Bill is here: hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-01-29/debates/BCBA2022-F…
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
Liberal Democrat motion to decline a second reading to Rwanda Safety Bill fails in Lords by 86 votes to 206. 8 Labour peers and 5 crossbench peers voted for the 'fatal motion'. votes.parliament.uk/votes/lords/division/3079
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
In which I accord @LibDemLords a licence to annoy: parliamentlive.tv/event/index/b196def6-6ee5-4377-be04-5ea…… (from 15:25:55). Not quite what I meant to say, but they didn't seem to mind.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I am critical of #rwandabill, but the elected House passed it unamended and we owe them the courtesy of careful scrutiny. My 4-minute speech on the Bill is here: hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-01-29/debates/BCBA2022-F…
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
Liberal Democrat motion to decline a second reading to Rwanda Safety Bill fails in Lords by 86 votes to 206. 8 Labour peers and 5 crossbench peers voted for the 'fatal motion'. votes.parliament.uk/votes/lords/division/3079
-
David Anderson reposted
Lords Committee on Justice and Home Affairs
@LordsJHACom
On Saturday, we published our letter on Live Facial Recognition (LFR) Technology ⬇️
Read more here: committees.parliament.uk/committee/519/justice-and-home-a… @UKHouseofLords
Lords Committee on Justice and Home Affairs
@LordsJHACom
📢We’ve published our letter to the Home Secretary on Live Facial Recognition (LFR) Technology.
📜Read the letter and the conclusions and recommendations in full in the appendix here: committees.parliament.uk/publications/43080/documents/214…
➡️More on the Committee’s work here: committees.parliament.uk/committee/519/justice-and-home-a… -
David Anderson reposted
Alexander Horne
@AlexanderHorne1
Delighted to see that @CommonsPACAC has released its new report on parliamentary scrutiny of international agreements in the 21st century this morning👇
committees.parliament.uk/publications/43077/documents/214…
(Short 🧵) 1/6 -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I had not realised the extent to which US intelligence and its oversight are among his targets. Anyone got more detail?
-
David Anderson reposted
Philip Leach
@PhilipLeach5
An important reminder from @JoelleGrogan & @alicedonald that states cannot invoke domestic law to avoid international obligations
The UK’s ECHR record: how common are Rule 39 orders and how often is the UK found to have violated rights? ukandeu.ac.uk/explainers/the-uks-echr-record-how-common-a… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Should PMs have a veto over the interception of their own communications by MI5? I started a @UKHouseofLords debate on this at 1750: interesting interventions also from Lord Carlile, Lord Evans (ex-DG MI5), and others parliamentlive.tv parliamentlive.tv/event/index/1beb330f-ebb5-46f4-ac04-f04….
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The #ipabill provides for others to approve wiretaps and hacks, including of the PM’s own messages, but only when the PM is ill or without secure communications.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Written record of the debate now published: hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-01-23/debates/8A611116-1…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Personalities aside and as a once fervent nat (until the age of 11), I would welcome this. @UKHouseofLords debates on Scotland would benefit from speakers who favour independence – just as we gain from the presence of the Greens and Plaid Cymru. www.thetimes.co.uk/article/ian-blackford-why-snp-should-s…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Always room for hedgehog-hunters too …
Nick Lester
@nickolester
A vexed @UKHouseofLords clerk has to deal with a mobile phone going off during the introduction of the Bishop of Hereford. The senior cleric is a one-time atheist whose hobbies include riding his motorbike and looking for hedgehogs
-
David Anderson reposted
PACE_Legal
@PACE_LegalHR
Congratulations to Lord Richard Keen (United Kingdom, EC/DA) on being elected the Chairperson of @PACE_News Committee on Legal Affairs and Human Rights!
@UKHouseofLords @Conservatives -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
We are getting close to a vote in @UKHouseofLords on whether the ratification of the U.K.-Rwanda Treaty should be delayed until its protections have been implemented. My speech is here: hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2024-01-22/debates/92EF95E2-A….
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Motion carried votes.parliament.uk/votes/lords/division/3077
David Anderson
@bricksilk
If it is indeed a trap, it is a largely toothless one. Important profile-building though for @HLIntAgreements, which does an important job with few powers.
Alexander Horne
@AlexanderHorne1
Following the debate on the Rwanda treaty this afternoon, Peers have now voted in favour of Lord Goldsmiths’s motion (214-171). In my view, they have sprung a clever trap on the Government…
-
David Anderson reposted
Brigid Fowler
@Brigid_Fowler
1st Gov #reul report just published - link here www.gov.uk/government/publications/retained-eu-law-reul-p…
Brigid Fowler
@Brigid_Fowler
1st Gov report on status of retained EU law is coming on Mon (22/1), exactly hitting the deadline under the #reul Act @Usherwood @CSBarnard24
-
David Anderson reposted
Arabella @arabellalaw.bsky.social
@Arabella_Law
Excellent report out today on treaty scrutiny, full of expertise and practical proposals.
Particularly timely given today's @UKHouseofLords debate on whether the UK-Rwanda treaty should be ratified, which shows the strengths and weaknesses of the current system.
Alexander Horne
@AlexanderHorne1
Today marks the end of a year long research project with the excellent @hhesterm looking at parliamentary scrutiny of treaties in the United Kingsom (short 🧵) 1/6
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Every word of this from @martinwolf_ is true, sadly. www.ft.com/products
-
David Anderson reposted
Brigid Fowler
@Brigid_Fowler
#rwandabill 2nd Reading in the Lords confirmed for Mon 29 Jan in updated version of Gov Whips' future business paper published this afternoon
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Learn with the Lords: Question Time - January 2024. If this is as good to view as it was fun to make, it will be brilliant. youtu.be/GpA_9OUX5V4 75 min via @YouTube
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
We in @HLConstitution have relied for the first time (I think) in this report on the notion of “disguised legislation”, identified by #dpprc in its 2021 report “Democracy Denied” @ConUnit_UCL @HansardSociety @instituteforgov
Lords Constitution Committee
@HLConstitution
📢We have published our report on the #victimsandprisonersbill
📜You can read the report here: committees.parliament.uk/publications/42955/documents/213…
Committee stage is scheduled to begin on Wednesday 24 January -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Sensible recommendation from @HLIntAgreements that the UK-Rwanda Treaty not be ratified until it has been properly implemented. My evidence about monitoring a similar treaty with Jordan is referred to. committees.parliament.uk/work/8091/ukrwanda-asylum-agreem…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
UNHCR assessment of the UK-Rwanda treaty is here www.ein.org.uk/news/unhcr-finds-new-uk-rwanda-treaty-and-…
-
David Anderson reposted
Kate McCann
@KateEMcCann
Such a 'sorry, WHAT' moment from our chat with Jonathan Hall KC yesterday - he explains how easy it was for him to create an Osama Bin Laden chatbot which then spouted terrorist propaganda back at him. He created it to prove how easy it is for AI to be utilised by terror groups👇🏼
Times Radio
@TimesRadio
"I created an Osama bin Laden chat bot, and I should say that I've since deleted it."
The UK should do more on AI inspired terrorism says @terrorwatchdog and tells @KateEMcCann how he was able to make an Osama Bin Laden chatbot online.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson reposted
Independent Reviewer
@terrorwatchdog
Some points on today’s proposed terror proscription of Hizb ut-Tahrir (HUT)…/1
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
“The start of 2024 here in the UK is like the start of 1914. Everything carries on as normal with little understanding of how easily complacent assumptions can fall apart.” Awful clarity from @NickCohen4 on what Trump Mk II could mean for Europe. nickcohen.substack.com/p/it-will-take-a-missile-hitting-the
-
David Anderson reposted
Robert Saunders
@redhistorian
The Commons Home Affairs Committee - whose membership stretches from Diane Abbott to Lee Anderson - calls for parliament to debate ratification of the UK-Rwanda treaty.
That's clearly right - but it's an absurdity that Parliament has to ask government for time to debate this.
Arabella @arabellalaw.bsky.social
@Arabella_Law
@CommonsHomeAffs calls for full debate on whether the UK-Rwanda treaty should be ratified
If granted, would be the *first ever* substantive debate under CRAG treaty procedures.
committees.parliament.uk/publications/42852/documents/213… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Bravo
Arabella @arabellalaw.bsky.social
@Arabella_Law
@CommonsHomeAffs calls for full debate on whether the UK-Rwanda treaty should be ratified
If granted, would be the *first ever* substantive debate under CRAG treaty procedures.
committees.parliament.uk/publications/42852/documents/213… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Indeed so! What a pleasure it was to welcome @PedroSerranoEU to the Advisory Board of @UCL_EI last night.
Sabina Ciofu
@SabinaCiofu
The car of the EU Ambassador to the UK has quite the statement number plate.
-
David Anderson reposted
Elisabeth Kendall
@Dr_E_Kendall
Out today @EngelsbergIdeas: I have written an explainer on #yemen's Houthis & the Red Sea attacks
▪️Who are the #houthis & what do they want?
▪️What is the link to #israel-#gaza?
▪️What is #iran's role?
▪️Can they be reined in?
▪️How likely is all-out war?
engelsbergideas.com/essays/the-houthis-forgotten-war-goes… -
David Anderson reposted
Spotlight on Corruption
@EndCorruptionUK
@bricksilk’s Bill would be a good first step to proper independent standards regulation. But as with Labour’s Integrity & Ethics Commission it needs to be accompanied by a range of reforms to upgrade ethical standards in public life.
See our options paper:
www.spotlightcorruption.org/report/what-could-a-uk-integr… -
David Anderson reposted
Spotlight on Corruption
@EndCorruptionUK
The Integrity and Ethics bill introduced by @bricksilk would put in place several key @PublicStandards recommendations. @RichardNewby3 called for the govt to bring the Bill forward soon and implement several other key reforms including on lobbying transparency.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Lawyer or law student early in your career, looking for fieldwork in human rights 2024/25? Have a look at this amazing opportunity, just launched: www.bard.edu/news/releases/pr/fstory.php?id=19794.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
For clarity, applications are welcomed from anywhere in the world.
-
David Anderson reposted
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
Sun has been briefed that government claims it could deport 100 people to Rwanda "within hours" of Royal Assent. Whether true (or not) the claim should certainly concentrate minds in Commons *and Lords* over the stakes of getting a "Rwanda Safety Bill" right.
("Bomb-proof" - ?)
Harry Cole
@MrHarryCole
🗞️NEW: The Tories need to pick a better candidate for Mayor of London
The age at which voters switch from Labour to Tory is now 65 - housing Budget urgently needed
And 100 "bomb-proof" migrants already identified for first Rwanda flight - if MPs back it
www.thesun.co.uk/news/25334063/sadiq-khan-mayoral-electio… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Congratulations @joannaccherry
UK Parliament Human Rights Committee
@HumanRightsCtte
At this week’s Committee meeting, Joanna Cherry MP was elected by members as our new Chair.
You can read more about the Committee’s work here: committees.parliament.uk/committee/93/human-rights-joint-… -
David Anderson reposted
Middle Temple
@middletemple
Over several decades the late Master Igor Judge assembled a collection of 15th century documents which he generously gave to the Inn. A selection of these have been displayed in the Middle Temple Library where they can be viewed during Library opening hours throughout January.
-
David Anderson reposted
UCL European Institute
@UCL_EI
Struggling to remember what year it is? No better time to peruse our activities and achievements from 2022-23, published today and available here: www.ucl.ac.uk/european-institute/news/2024/jan/european-i…
-
David Anderson reposted
UCL European Institute
@UCL_EI
We are delighted to announce that EU Ambassador to the UK, HE @PedroSerranoEU, has joined the @UCL_EI Advisory Board, as of January 2024
Find out more: www.ucl.ac.uk/european-institute/news/2024/jan/eu-ambassa…
With comment from @PedroSerranoEU, Chair of the Advisory Board @bricksilk & EI Director @ukstaiger -
David Anderson reposted
Michael Crick
@MichaelLCrick
Lessons from postmasters' scandal for all non-executive directors - NEDs 1/3:
1. Ask tougher questions of management - recognise they may have reasons to avoid the truth;
2. Don't simply read board papers, attend meetings & ask a question or two - that's the easy, lazy way;
Michael Crick
@MichaelLCrick
There are 10s of 1000s of non-executive directors (NEDs) in all sorts of bodies across public sector, as well as in public companies. There are huge lessons for all NEDs from the postmasters scandal (and scandal is too small a word).
-
David Anderson reposted
Michael Crick
@MichaelLCrick
There are 10s of 1000s of non-executive directors (NEDs) in all sorts of bodies across public sector, as well as in public companies. There are huge lessons for all NEDs from the postmasters scandal (and scandal is too small a word).
-
David Anderson reposted
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
IPSO Editors Code review decides not to cover discrimination against groups @pressgazette
Few people know of the IPSO Editors Code's "Goebbels problem". Ipso discrim clause would not curb anything Der Sturmer published re Jews as a group. (Only if attack a named Jewish person) -
David Anderson reposted
IPCO
@IPCOffice
We are currently recruiting for Legal Advisers.
To find out more and apply, please visit Civil Service Jobs: www.civilservicejobs.service.gov.uk/csr/index.cgi?SID=b3d… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The transcript of my evidence to @HLIntAgreements on the UK-Rwanda Treaty is now online: committees.parliament.uk/event/20129/formal-meeting-oral-…. tl;dr - actions matter more than words, and changing a culture takes time.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Rwanda Treaty - today’s evidence to @HLIntAgreements can be viewed here www.parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/92176eeb-0105-4c89-b980…
-
David Anderson reposted
John Simpson
@JohnSimpsonNews
I’m a proud holder of a CBE, for reporting on the first Gulf War. But the letters stand for ‘Commander of the Order of the British Empire’ — something which has long ceased to exist. With a new head of state and a new year, is it time to rename the Order ‘British Excellence’?
-
David Anderson reposted
Robert Saunders
@redhistorian
Another reminder that the transfer of power to unelected party members has been profoundly anti-democratic.
The power to appoint Prime Ministers and Leaders of the Opposition has been turned into a subscriber benefit for a wholly unrepresentative & unaccountable group of people.
Christopher Hope📝
@christopherhope
This is very interesting, not least for any future Tory party leadership contest …
Over half of @ConHome’s panel of Conservative Party members now watch GB News | Conservative Home conservativehome.com/2024/01/01/over-half-our-panel-of-co… -
David Anderson reposted
BETA
@BETAUK
Good news for school trips between
🇫🇷 & 🇬🇧from today French students @education_gouv will be able to make school trips to the UK with their identity card, and students from third countries will no longer need a visa.
www.gov.uk/guidance/visit-the-uk-as-part-of-a-french-scho…
French Embassy UK🇫🇷🇪🇺
@FranceintheUK
Bonne nouvelle pour les voyages scolaires entre 🇫🇷 & 🇬🇧! À partir d’aujourd’hui, nos élèves @education_gouv 🇫🇷 & 🇪🇺 pourront effectuer leurs voyages scolaires avec leur carte d’identité, et nos élèves de pays tiers n’auront plus besoin de visa.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
3,5,10,13 made me think.
Gurwinder
@G_S_Bhogal
In 2023 I learned hundreds of useful concepts.
Here are 20 of the best, to equip you for 2024: -
David Anderson reposted
Charles Grant
@CER_Grant
RIP Jacques Delors. I got to know him when researching 'Delors: Inside the House that Jacques Built' (1994). A decent, modest man. How many politicians would turn down the chance to run for president of France, when they had a good chance of winning, as he did in 1994? /1
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
In darkness, hope - Happy Christmas from the Outer Isles to Suffolk and beyond
Pete Savin
@pete_savin
One of my favourite winter poems by Laurie Lee
No night could be darker than this night, No cold so cold, As the blood snaps like a wire, And the heart's sap stills, And the year seems defeated. O never again, it seems, can green things run, Or sky birds fly, Or the grass exhale its humming breath Powdered with pimpernels, From this dark lung of winter. Yet here are lessons for the final mile Of pilgim kings; The mile still left when all have reached Their tether's end: that mile Where the Child lies hid For see, beneath the hand, the earth already Warms and glows; For men with shepherd's eyes there are Signs in the dark, the turning stars, The lamb's returning time. Out of this utter death he's born again, His birth our saviour; From terror's equinox he climbs and grows, Drawing his finger's light across our blood – The sun of heaven, and the son of god. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Half an hour of rare constitutional wisdom from “the chauffeur who married into the family … high priest of Parliament” Lord Lisvane, expertly interviewed by @DArcyTiP and @RuthFox01.
Hansard Society
@HansardSociety
Are there constraints on parliamentary sovereignty? In the latest episode of Parliament Matters, former Clerk of the House of Commons and now crossbench Peer, Lord Lisvane, explains what parliamentary sovereignty means.
🎧Listen to a clip here and the full episode below. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A rare balanced article on facial recognition technology and its regulation #cjbill #fr - one for 2024 no doubt www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/dec/24/facial-reco…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
More here
-
David Anderson reposted
The Bar Council
@thebarcouncil
Nick Vineall KC, Moira Smyth KC, & @RoddyQC respond to the @Telegraph front page 'Starmer helped free dangerous prisoners' -"The idea that barristers (or advocates) should somehow be associated with the causes of those whom they represent is misconceived." www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/2023/12/22/letters-the-danger…
-
David Anderson reposted
David Aaronovitch
@DAaronovitch
This is what happens when you discover that a policy you thought would affect one distant group of people turns out to also affect your friends and relatives
Matt Dathan
@matt_dathan
NEW: Big climb down just slipped out without any fanfare by the Home Office on its plans to reduce immigration
Minimum income threshold needed to bring foreign spouses to UK will only rise to £29,000 initially. No timeline for it to be raised to £38,700
www.gov.uk/government/publications/legal-migration-statem… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
That’s more like it – but will it affect those who are already here?
Matt Dathan
@matt_dathan
NEW: Big climb down just slipped out without any fanfare by the Home Office on its plans to reduce immigration
Minimum income threshold needed to bring foreign spouses to UK will only rise to £29,000 initially. No timeline for it to be raised to £38,700
www.gov.uk/government/publications/legal-migration-statem… -
David Anderson reposted
Jeremy Ogilvie-Harris
@JOgilvieHarris
Important Supreme Court decision about the extent to which alleged torts committed by the UK security and intelligence forces against an individual rendered and detained without trial outside of the UK can be subject to the law of England and Wales.
www.supremecourt.uk/cases/docs/uksc-2022-0083-judgment.pdf
The Supreme Court of the United Kingdom
@UKSupremeCourt
Judgment has been handed down today in the matter of Zubaydah (Respondent) v Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office and others (Appellants) UKSC 2022/0083: www.supremecourt.uk/cases/uksc-2022-0083.html
-
David Anderson reposted
CAJ
@CAJNi
Ireland will take Interstate case against legacy act
www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2023/1220/1423066-ireland-uk-case/ -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Can't wait to see the full-length film!
Global Research Network on Parliaments and People
@GRNPP1
Ever wondered how Sheffield’s political culture would look to two anthropologists from Ethiopia?
Well wonder no longer, because here’s an EXCLUSIVE TRAILER for the Ethnographic film - Mugut: The Wheels of Democracy - by @MGabrehiwot and @tesfahunhailu vimeo.com/893519912 -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Also on a cross-disciplinary theme, anyone with £1.08 to spare who is seeking a @UKHouseofLords-themed Christmas present still has time to buy @_Emma_Crewe's engaging anthropological study of our manners and rituals www.amazon.co.uk/Lords-Parliament-Manners-Rituals-Politic….
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This short comparative film (featuring me in a 2020-vintage lockdown headset) www.parliamentbuildings.org.uk/video/inside-parliament-th… is a taster for Sophia Psarra and @UCL_EI's fascinating cross-disciplinary study of how democracies shape, and are shaped by, their parliament buildings www.hansardsociety.org.uk/blog/parliament-buildings-the-a….
-
David Anderson reposted
House of Lords International Agreements Committee
@HLIntAgreements
📺WATCH LIVE: International Agreements Committee takes evidence from Home Secretary @JamesCleverly on UK-Rwanda asylum treaty: parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/0abcd88f-1488-47aa-8df8-b63…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
If this means assessment of suitability by HOLAC and an end to hereditary elections, it would be a very good start.
The House magazine
@TheHouseMag
'We should be honest about what we can achieve on Lords reform'
The Baroness Smith interview
www.politicshome.com/thehouse/article/baroness-smith-we-h… -
David Anderson reposted
Lords Constitution Committee
@HLConstitution
📢Today we have published our letter to Simon Hoare, Minister for Local Government, on voter ID
We consider how implementation of the new policy might be improved to minimise negative effects on the ability of the electorate to cast their vote.
👇
committees.parliament.uk/committee/172/constitution-commi… -
David Anderson reposted
House of Lords International Agreements Committee
@HLIntAgreements
🚨TODAY: The International Agreements Committee takes evidence from the Home Secretary on the UK-Rwanda asylum treaty. 📺Watch live from 5pm: www.parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/0abcd88f-1488-47aa-8df8…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Rwanda Treaty - today’s evidence to @HLIntAgreements can be viewed here www.parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/92176eeb-0105-4c89-b980…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Now complete with Explanatory Notes bills.parliament.uk/publications/53363/documents/4162 - for which special thanks to George Havenhand and @EndCorruptionUK.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My Public Service (Integrity and Ethics) Bill gives sharper teeth to the regulation of ministerial conduct bills.parliament.uk/bills/3332. It was 23rd in the PMB ballot and will be given its 1st reading on 7th December, with a 2nd reading debate likely if there is no early election.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Great initiative www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-suffolk-67693821.amp
-
David Anderson reposted
Mark Elliott
@ProfMarkElliott
What exquisite timing.
The Royal Family
@RoyalFamily
The King has visited the Royal Courts of Justice to celebrate the work of the judiciary and its commitment to the rule of law.
-
David Anderson reposted
Kaja Kallas
@kajakallas
The Estonian delegation congratulates the people of #ukraine, #moldova and #georgia for landmark decisions by #euco.
It is a historic day for all of us. -
David Anderson reposted
Shoaib M Khan
@ShoaibMKhan
Next week, the Lords International Agreements Committee will take oral evidence as part of its inquiry into the UK-Rwanda asylum Agreement.
18 Dec: @bricksilk and @konstadinides give evidence.
19 Dec: @JamesCleverly gives evidence.
committees.parliament.uk/work/8091/ukrwanda-asylum-agreem… -
David Anderson reposted
David Gauke
@DavidGauke
My piece for @NewStatesman on the Rwanda Bill and the Tory centrists - the tactical case for acquiescing but the strategic risks of allowing the party to be driven further to the extremes. www.newstatesman.com/comment/2023/12/rwanda-bill-right-wi…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Look forward to giving evidence Monday on the UK-Rwanda Treaty to @HLIntAgreements. I examined the similar subject of deportation with assurances in this 2017 report www.gov.uk/government/publications/deportation-with-assur….
Sunder Katwala
@sundersays
Lords International Agreement Conmittee to scrutinise the Rwanda Treaty. Has it dealt with the Supreme Court's concerns about Rwanda being unsafe?
committees.parliament.uk/committee/448/international-agre… -
David Anderson reposted
Jeanine de Roy van Zuijdewijn
@JeanineRvz
Dutch terrorism threat level raised from 3 to 4 (out of 5) : substantial. The jihadist threat in particular has increased, due to 1) the Hamas attacks and ensuing conflict in Gaza, 2) Quran desecrations in European countries, 3) calls to perpetrate attacks by jihadist groups.
Pieter-Jaap Aalbersberg NCTV
@PJAalbersberg
Het dreigingsniveau in Nederland is verhoogd van 3 (aanzienlijk) naar 4 (substantieel): de kans op een aanslag is reëel. De terroristische dreiging is het afgelopen half jaar verder toegenomen. Zie de afbeelding, klik op de link of lees hier verder www.nctv.nl/onderwerpen/dtn (1/6)
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I am quoted in this @nytimes piece on Rwanda www.nytimes.com/2023/12/12/world/europe/sunak-rwanda-asyl…
-
David Anderson reposted
Transparency International UK
@TransparencyUK
🧵 Today @Keir_Starmer pledged he would:
🧹 "clean up politics"
🔨 "crack down on cronyism"
⚖️ make sure "nobody will be above the law"
x.com/BBCPolitics/status/1734528934736253061
Our research shows that if he wants to succeed, these are the areas he should focus on... 1/6
BBC Politics
@BBCPolitics
"We'll need to clean up politics"
Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer pledges a "total crackdown on cronyism" and adds "nobody will be above the law in a Britain that I lead"
www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-politics-67689442 -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A reminder
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The Ministerial Code still mandates compliance with international law, despite a change to its wording, as the Court of Appeal confirmed in 2018: amp.theguardian.com/law/2018/aug/01/appeal-court-rules-th…
-
David Anderson reposted
Tom Hickman
@TomRHickman
Government statement on legal issues raised by Rwanda is Safe Bill. Three observations:
www.gov.uk/government/publications/safety-of-rwanda-asylu… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Committee day 1 on the Investigatory Powers (Amendment) Bill today: hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2023-12-11/debates/AC2BC51B-0… lots of low-key scrutiny, not much drama (unless you count the “starboard knee” gag).
Nick Lester
@nickolester
Former navy chief Lord West of Spithead tells @UKHouseofLords he has 'a brand new starboard knee', which is still a bit wobbly. A minister later expresses hope the peer remains on 'an even keel'
-
David Anderson reposted
Bingham Centre for the Rule of Law
@BinghamCentre
The central purpose of the #rwanda deportations Bill is contrary to #ruleoflaw, @BinghamCentre's preliminary analysis finds. Read our report: binghamcentre.biicl.org/publications/safety-of-rwanda-asy…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A brilliant analysis by @TomRHickman, spelling out the failure of the UK-Rwanda Treaty to address the failings identified by the Supreme Court. /1 www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/publication/prime-minis…
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The notion that flights could be sent to Rwanda in the spring, consistently with the ruling of @UKSupremeCourt, may therefore lack realism ... /3
David Anderson
@bricksilk
… even before factoring in the possibilities explained by @TomRHickman of individual challenges, interim measures and a possible declaration of incompatibility under s4 HRA. /4
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Hurray! Next stop Germany?
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
Good news for school visits from France! Home Office are finally amending the rules to allow children aged 18 and under, studying at a school in France, to visit the UK on an organised educational trip without the usual passport or visa requirements. 1/2 questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-statements/det…
-
David Anderson reposted
Mark Elliott
@ProfMarkElliott
For a court directly to refuse to apply the Rwanda legislation, or any other Act of Parliament, would be fraught with danger and seems highly unlikely. But to suggest that such a possibility is outside the realms of established constitutional thought goes too far. (10/10)
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Pressure growing? www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/dec/10/fury-grows-over-t…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Time to think again. Non-Brits facing spousal visa renewal (particularly with very young children) will be expelled by this despicable plan, which confounds their expectations on marriage and whose cruelty would have been exposed by proper consultation. www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/foreign-spouse-mig…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Pressure having effect?
CJ McKinney
@mckinneytweets
The government now says it has not made up its mind about whether the £38,700 income requirement for British citizens/permanent residents to sponsor a spouse or partner to live here will apply to couples extending visas, as well as new arrivals homeofficemedia.blog.gov.uk/2023/12/08/reducing-net-migra…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
"As the ancient philosopher Heraclitus told us, 'you cannot step into the same river twice': neither you nor the river would be the same." www.ft.com/content/9c2df35f-555a-4c34-84e6-93e125d6c410 via @ft
-
David Anderson reposted
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
This is a major demonstration of the EU’s norm-setting power. The UK showed with the AI regulation conference it’s convening power, but that is not the same as having the economic heft to turn ideas into regulations which have some prospect of shaping how the technology develops.
Steve Peers
@StevePeers
Summary of the EU Artificial Intelligence Act just agreed #aiact
www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20231206IPR1569… -
David Anderson reposted
Rose Zussman
@rose_zussman
Very good news that this has been brought back by @bricksilk
Lord Anderson's private member's bill would enshrine public standards bodies and the codes they oversee in law. The government should lend it their support.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My private member’s bill had its first reading yesterday (a formal stage but it gets us going). Explanatory notes should be published soon. bills.parliament.uk/bills/3552/stages
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My private member’s bill had its first reading yesterday (a formal stage but it gets us going). Explanatory notes should be published soon. bills.parliament.uk/bills/3552/stages
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Investigatory Powers (Amendment) Bill: it is good to have these draft excerpts from codes of practice before us in advance of debates in committee starting Monday. www.gov.uk/government/publications/investigatory-powers-a…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The PM’s letter to Robert Jenrick seems to confirm that it was not his but RWANDA’s concern for OUR international law obligations that prevented the Bill from going even further. Shameful if true.
Paul Brand
@PaulBrandITV
NEW: In what reads like a fairly tetchy letter, Sunak has accused Jenrick of a "fundamental misunderstanding".
He insists migration bill "will work" and going any further would lose Rwandan support.
"No point in passing a law that would leave us with nowhere to send people to."
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And if not true, shamefully weak.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Adam Boulton
@adamboultonTABB
Quite a headline!
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
All the pain for no gain – 🧵 with my thoughts on #rwandabill, excessively strong meat even for @ChatGPTapp
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The Government seeks to use Parliament as a shield by attributing to it both the competence to decide that Rwanda is a safe country, and the ability to act “unaffected by international law”. In reality it has neither: smoke and mirrors, as @ProfMarkElliott says. #rwandabill /1
Joshua Rozenberg
@JoshuaRozenberg
A triumph of hope over experience
The Safety of Rwanda Bill sounds tough — but can it deliver?
New post, free to read: rozenberg.substack.com/p/a-triumph-of-hope-over-experience -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The Government seeks to use Parliament as a shield by attributing to it both the competence to decide that Rwanda is a safe country, and the ability to act “unaffected by international law”. In reality it has neither: smoke and mirrors, as @ProfMarkElliott says. #rwandabill /1
Joshua Rozenberg
@JoshuaRozenberg
A triumph of hope over experience
The Safety of Rwanda Bill sounds tough — but can it deliver?
New post, free to read: rozenberg.substack.com/p/a-triumph-of-hope-over-experiencePost not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
That is relevant context for this comment from @JoshuaRozenberg, in which he notes that @Michael4MDNP rather than @VictoriaPrentis chose to sign the Bill. /5
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The AG @VictoriaPrentis has been a significant voice for sanity in government and for a law-abiding UK on the international plane. If there is a way for her to reconcile this misbegotten Bill with her conscience - and only she can know that - I rather hope she will take it. /6
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
“Brexit is the origin of this, but the split now is much worse – between those who believe in the rule of law and those who do not.” Dominic Grieve on @BBCNewsnight.
-
David Anderson reposted
Mark Elliott
@ProfMarkElliott
The rule of law is widely understood to include respect for international law. For reasons explained in my recent post, the Rwanda Bill is likely incompatible with the UK's treaty obligations. Hence the Lord Chancellor should be considering his position. publiclawforeveryone.com/2023/12/06/the-rwanda-bill-and-i…
Matthew
@MWHoyle19
The rule of law remains in place and the judiciary remain independent, and the policy remains a bad one.
All these things can be true. -
David Anderson reposted
David Gauke
@DavidGauke
When it comes to upholding international law, the Rwandan Government is a restraining force on the UK Government. I think that should be a clue that something is awry.
Anushka Asthana
@AnushkaAsthana
A govt source says - “We’ve just published a hardcore bill. It’s as far as it cd have been without walking away completely from international law which the Rwandans said they wouldn’t want. So we’ve gone to the max. Further and we wouldn’t have a Rwanda partnership.”
-
David Anderson reposted
Paul Brand
@PaulBrandITV
BREAKING: Rwanda government threatens to pull out of the deal if it does not adhere to international law.
Hugely problematic - and potentially humiliating - for govt if its partner country decides the deal is too toxic.
Statement below 👇 -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
We heard evidence on voter photo ID in @HLConstitution today from the new Elections Minister, Simon Hoare MP www.parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/a240457b-e5c9-4477-b6a4…. My questions start at 13:10:45 about the process (recommended by @ElectoralCommUK) for considering additional forms of photo ID (railcards &c).
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Time to think again. Non-Brits facing spousal visa renewal (particularly with very young children) will be expelled by this despicable plan, which confounds their expectations on marriage and whose cruelty would have been exposed by proper consultation. www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/foreign-spouse-mig…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Here's just one example: x.com/CostumedVole/status/1732335441599250534
-
David Anderson reposted
Sam Macrory
@sammacrory
So how would parliament be involved in this new asylum treaty with Rwanda and how much chance for scrutiny is there?
@aliceolilly @instituteforgov has the answers
www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/explainer/rwanda-scheme…
BBC News (UK)
@BBCNews
New Rwanda asylum treaty deals with Supreme Court concerns, says James Cleverly www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-67627696
-
David Anderson reposted
Dr. Dan Lomas
@Sandbagger_01
👀 Latest annual report of the Intelligence and Security Committee of Parliament has landed.
🔗isc.independent.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/ISC-Ann… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The long-standing convention against retired judges returning to private practice is alive and well, according to @MoJGovUK in today’s answer to my two written questions members.parliament.uk/member/4705/writtenquestions @BYMYong
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Sheer beauty yesterday - in Ipswich, where else?
James Dart
@James_Dart
Wes Burns bringing the trivela for Ipswich. Ridiculous goal
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Think about this - 156 PAGES of new law without pre-legislative or Commons scrutiny. @UKHouseofLords will do its best as always but this sort of behaviour treats Parliament with contempt … /1
Hansard Society
@HansardSociety
Earlier this week Govt added 156 pages of amendments to the Data Protection & Digital Info Bill at Report Stage—ie *after* detailed Committee Stage scrutiny. Is this familiar habit turning the Commons into a rubber-stamp?
⏯️ youtu.be/KUNzsxX4b6I
✅ pod.fo/parliamentmatters
✂️⤵️
David Anderson
@bricksilk
… particularly when, as @HansardSociety reports, the government rejected a recommittal motion that would have allowed @HouseofCommons to look at the Bill in the time available before Christmas. /2
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This is one of the abuses I identified in last week’s lecture (para 52): www.daqc.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/22/2023/12/Writin…. It is becoming a habit and we must be able to do better. /3
-
David Anderson reposted
Tom Hickman
@TomRHickman
So, what about the Supreme Court’s Rwanda ruling? What next?
First, the ruling.
The SC delivered an emphatic decision that UK asylum seekers sent to Rwanda will face a real risk of being sent back to their countries of origin. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Last night's lecture "Writing a Constitution" is free for all to read here www.daqc.co.uk/2023/12/01/writing-a-constitution/
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Not forgetting @IanDunt @gavinesler
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And @Dr_W_E_Bulmer who is quoted at length (omitted because I couldn’t remember his handle)
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Praise from a mentor is the best kind. Follow him!
Derrick Wyatt's Law and Policy Blog
@BlogWyatt
Anybody with an interest in our Constitution should read this excellent lecture. It identifies weaknesses in the status quo, and offers 3 options for improvement: restatement, renewal and revolution. Judicial override of statutes is given short shrift. A reformer's blueprint.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Last night's lecture "Writing a Constitution" is free for all to read here www.daqc.co.uk/2023/12/01/writing-a-constitution/
-
David Anderson reposted
Spotlight on Corruption
@EndCorruptionUK
🔥These really important comments on the importance of improving the regulation of standards in public life in @bricksilk's Lord Renton lecture for @StatuteLawSoc caught our eye this morning 👇. We couldn't agree more 👏
h/t to @JoshuaRozenberg's essential blog on S*bstack -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
“Writing a Constitution” (restatement, renewal, revolution): my lecture last night to @StatuteLawSoc at @ucl has been published and reviewed by @JoshuaRozenberg, with Alison Young’s exciting new book, under the title Where the Power Lies: rozenberg.substack.com?r=9bgl3
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The fruits of diplomacy (h/t @Mij_Europe)
-
David Anderson reposted
Sima Kotecha
@sima_kotecha
Worth noting the brilliant original journalism #newsnight has produced over the last year. A tribute to the whole team and its investigative specialists
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Nicosia today - the buffer zone
-
David Anderson reposted
Peter Foster
@pmdfoster
Spot the difference. Brilliant @ft visual data piece on Xi Jinping’s erasing of Muslim culture in China 🥶
ig.ft.com/china-mosques/ -
David Anderson reposted
Joshua Rozenberg
@JoshuaRozenberg
Chalk announces limited IPP reform
Released prisoners will have their licences ended sooner
New post, free to read: rozenberg.substack.com/p/chalk-announces-limited-ipp-reform -
David Anderson reposted
Tim Durrant
@timd_IFG
This is a great tool from @TransparencyUK - just a shame it's necessary and that the government doesn't make this information more easily findable itself
-
David Anderson reposted
Alex Thomas
@AlexGAThomas
This is a fantastic job - one you can really make your own
Come and work with superb colleagues (and me). If you think you’d be good at the job then apply. If you’re not quite sure then apply too - we’d love to hear from you
Institute for Government
@instituteforgov
Do you have experience of policy making in government or the wider public sector?
We are looking for an Associate Director or Programme Director to lead our work on improving policy making in the UK.
Applications close on Monday 18 December at 11:00 www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/about-us/careers/curren… -
David Anderson reposted
Seamus Heaney
@HeaneyDaily
Hope is not optimism, which expects things to turn out well, but something rooted in the conviction that there is good worth working for.
-
David Anderson reposted
Independent Reviewer
@terrorwatchdog
Today I've published my report on terrorism and the recent protests
-
David Anderson reposted
Shoaib M Khan
@ShoaibMKhan
Our second wonderful panel - @bricksilk, @WomaninHavana, @RazaHusainQC and Baroness Chakrabarti. A delightful, fascinating discussion.
-
David Anderson reposted
Nick Macpherson
@nickmacpherson2
Credit to Mr Hunt though for funding national insurance cut by raising income tax. Turns practice of last 40 years on its head. Benefits workers and young at expense of rentiers, capitalists and pensioners.
Paul Johnson
@PJTheEconomist
When is a tax cut not a tax cut?
This chart from OBR shows tax as a per cent of GDP still peaks at same level as projected in March - a record 37.7% of GDP.
OBR: "the tax burden is forecast to reach a post-war high of 37.7 per cent of GDP in 2028-29" -
David Anderson reposted
Matthew Scott
@Barristerblog
Sensible and knowledgeable thread on why so few people are arrested at protests and demonstration.
Matt Ashby
@LessCrime
Why don’t police arrest many people at protests, even when lots of people are breaking the law?
A 🧵 to explain …
(If you’d like to tell me I’m wrong, please read the whole thread first! 🙏)
Photo: flic.kr/p/6ceVY4 -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Just 12 of us spoke at second reading of the Investigatory Powers (Amendment) Bill this afternoon in @UKHouseofLords. My speech in support is here hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2023-11-20/debates/F933A59A-E… #ip(A)Bill. /1
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Here is my independent appraisal of the Bill’s main features, published in June: www.gov.uk/government/news/lord-anderson-publishes-review…. A couple of colleagues described it as readable – high praise in my book. /2
-
David Anderson reposted
Shoaib M Khan
@ShoaibMKhan
This event with a former ECtHR president, @bricksilk, @conorgearty, @RazaHusainQC, @WomaninHavana, @andrew_cutting, @JacquiMckenzie6 and others is this week.
Sold out. But join Eventbrite waiting list to attend online and spaces will be made available.
www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/hrla-anniversary-event-tickets-716… -
David Anderson reposted
David Gauke
@DavidGauke
Defeat in court on the Rwanda policy is no reason to abandon the rule of law. My piece for @ConHome. conservativehome.com/2023/11/20/david-gauke-defeat-in-cou…
-
David Anderson reposted
Hansard Society
@HansardSociety
🎧 In the latest episode of Parliament Matters:
Listen to Lord Anderson (@bricksilk), crossbench Peer and member of the @HLConstitution Committee, speak about the prospect of the Lords rejecting the Government’s #rwandaplan legislation.
Click to listen [from 24m:38s] 👇 -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
For any lover of the Hebrides who is in London on 12 December there is a free showing of a truly beautiful film about the life and work of my friend, the sculptor Steve Dilworth, followed by Q&A. Worth anyone's time! Register here www.swedenborg.org.uk/events/stuff-the-world-is-made-of/
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Also starring @RobGMacfarlane and - without giving away any secrets about the Whalebone Box - @middletemple.
-
David Anderson reposted
Adam Tucker
@AdamJTucker
So is "an ouster clause protecting extra-judicial executions" an impossible/outlandish example? Or a plausible one?
(Asking for a friend writing about ousters and trying to avoid impossible silly examples) -
David Anderson reposted
Jeff King
@jeff_a_king
Having considered the PM's statement on responding to the Rwanda judgment with a treaty and emergency legislation, a few thoughts on how Parliament might respond below - prompted by @Prof_Phillipson 's thread - long thread:
Gavin Phillipson
@Prof_Phillipson
So plan B from press conference: elevate UK's MoU with Rwanda to a treaty with specific safeguards, then introduce emergency legislation to have Parlt put in primary legislation that Rwanda is to be treated as a safe country. Quick 🧵@IanDunt @woodstockjag @JoshuaRozenberg
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Thanks for the opportunity. I talk about Rwanda and my Public Service (Ethics and Integrity) Bill from 25 minutes in.
Hansard Society
@HansardSociety
🎧 NEW episode of Parliament Matters in your podcast feeds now!… A huge thank you to this week's special guests, @twocitiesnickie & @bricksilk, who gave us some fascinating insights into the Private Members' Bill process & more.
✅ Listen & subscribe:
pod.fo/e/202bd0. -
David Anderson reposted
Matthew Scott
@Barristerblog
"Legal challenges to detention must be excluded to avoid burdening the courts." Just one extraordinary sentence amidst a series of disgraceful proposals from would be Conservative leader Suella Braverman. digitaleditions.telegraph.co.uk/data/1518/reader/reader.h…
-
David Anderson reposted
Sam Macrory
@sammacrory
After the Supreme Court verdict, what is Rishi Sunak's new Rwanda plan?
What problems could it face?
Will "flights will be heading off in the spring, as planned?"
This essential explainer by @SirJJKC for @instituteforgov is required reading:
www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/comment/supreme-court-r… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I favour reform of @UKHouseofLords, including to limit its numbers. But @richardmarcj is right to warn against excessive shrinkage of a Chamber whose real selling point – its expertise – derives from the fact that many of its (unsalaried) members do other things as well.
Richard Johnson
@richardmarcj
If you had a smaller House of Lords, it would be much harder for these professionals to be peers because the demands to be full- rather than part-time legislators would be so much greater. And what a loss that would be.
As I wrote in my recent evidence:
committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/124445/pdf/ -
David Anderson reposted
CJ McKinney
@mckinneytweets
I expect this does reflect the forthcoming new treaty: the existing agreement envisages people with no right to stay in Rwanda being removed (para 10.4).
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Rwandan Govt rep said on #wato today that nobody sent by the UK to Rwanda will be sent elsewhere: if refugee status is refused, they will be granted leave to remain. (1) Was this a sneak peek at the new Treaty? (2) If credible, could this assurance meet @UKSupremeCourt concerns?
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Rwandan Govt rep said on #wato today that nobody sent by the UK to Rwanda will be sent elsewhere: if refugee status is refused, they will be granted leave to remain. (1) Was this a sneak peek at the new Treaty? (2) If credible, could this assurance meet @UKSupremeCourt concerns?
David Anderson
@bricksilk
(3) If yes to both, why is urgent legislation needed? (4) Was there any hint of this during argument in Supreme Court?
-
David Anderson reposted
Hansard Society
@HansardSociety
Parliament Matters in action w/ today's special guests @bricksilk on the #rwandaplan & @twocitiesnickie on her Private Members' Bill for #pedicab licensing.
❓Still time to send your Qs before we hit the studio:
airtable.com/app0ruz4vOFIs5FpG/shrHD4fneQ3autELT
✅ Subscribe here:
podfollow.com/parliamentmatters
Ruth Fox
@RuthFox01
Just popped out with @DArcyTiP to see @bricksilk in his legal chambers to talk about the Rwanda case & his new Private Members' Bill for our next episode of Parliament Matters which will be out tomorrow wherever you get your podcasts.
-
David Anderson reposted
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Is it really sought to use Parliament to bar our own courts from conducting the factual assessments that the law requires where human lives and safety are at stake? /5
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Correct. If a binding Treaty can correct the defects found by the Supreme Court (as Theresa May achieved with Jordan in the Abu Qatada case), the Rwanda scheme is free to proceed legally. /1
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Is it really sought to use Parliament to bar our own courts from conducting the factual assessments that the law requires where human lives and safety are at stake? /5
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I would be surprised if our Law Officers, who are good lawyers and decent human beings, have signed off on such a scheme. If they have (and we wait to see the Bill), then surely Parliament should not agree to be complicit in it. /6
-
David Anderson reposted
Matt Purvis
@HLLibResearch
The briefing looks at the Investigatory Powers (Amendment) Bill’s provisions, as well as providing background to the investigatory powers regime and recent reviews by the Home Office and Lord Anderson @bricksilk lordslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/lln-2023-0042/
-
David Anderson reposted
Gavin Barwell
@GavinBarwell
It appears Conservative MPs no longer have to believe in the rule of law. What has happened to the party I devoted nearly 30 years of my life to? Utterly depressing
-
David Anderson reposted
Matt Purvis
@HLLibResearch
Lords front bench changes 1/3
- Lord Benyon as a Minister of State jointly in the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office and the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs
- Earl of Minto as a Minister of State in the Ministry of Defence
www.gov.uk/government/news/ministerial-appointments-novem… -
David Anderson reposted
The House magazine
@TheHouseMag
"He cared deeply about the work of the Lords, and all who made it possible. In return he commanded attention and affection, right across the House, to an extent that can only be described as unique."
🕊️ Tribute to Lord Judge by Lord Kinnoull & @bricksilk
www.politicshome.com/thehouse/article/tribute-lord-judge-… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My tribute to Lord Judge - an extraordinary advocate, judge, leader and mentor - was published today in @TheHouseMag: www.politicshome.com/thehouse/article/tribute-lord-judge-…. RIP Igor.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This is truly terrible news. Igor was not only a superb judge but one of the most principled, kind and influential members of @UKHouseofLords.
-
David Anderson reposted
Shoaib M Khan
@ShoaibMKhan
Wonderful @HumanRightsLawA event with a former ECtHR president, Geoffrey @BindmansLLP, @bricksilk, @conorgearty, @RazaHusainQC, @WomaninHavana, @YasmineAhmed001, @andrew_cutting, @JacquiMckenzie6, @Rene_Cassin & others.
Online too.
3pm on 23 November.
www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/hrla-anniversary-event-tickets-716… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
One for @Scotlandteam to ponder? 😉 I wouldn't rule out tightening the law on glorifying terrorism, but getting it right is far from simple as the government, and Parliament, discovered in 2006. www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/nov/13/plan-to-tighten-…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The European Court of Human Rights has provisionally adopted amendments to rule 39 of its Rules of Court (interim measures). Now out for consultation.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
‘Bugles calling for them from sad shires’ - Remembrance Sunday in Christchurch Park Ipswich, observed by several thousand people.
-
David Anderson reposted
GCHQ
@GCHQ
These words will be read at Remembrance Services today as we honour those who served and sacrificed to protect our country and way of life.
Discover the origins of the Kohima Epitaph
www.gchq.gov.uk/information/when-you-go-home
#lestweforget #wewillrememberthem
#remembrancesunday -
David Anderson reposted
Sayeeda Warsi
@SayeedaWarsi
Today I remember those that fought for the freedoms we enjoy today
People of different backgrounds, race, ethnicity and all faiths and none
I remember my paternal and maternal grandfathers and my great uncle who fought for King and country
Lest we forget -
David Anderson reposted
Metropolitan Police
@metpoliceuk
Today's policing operation is now drawing to a close.
Officers worked tirelessly to keep London safe, making at least 126 arrests in the face of significant violence. Sadly, nine officers were injured.
Assistant Commissioner Matt Twist's statement gives an overview of events. -
David Anderson reposted
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
Still trying to clarify who governs Gaza when the fighting stops. Netanyahu has said Israel would keep overall security responsibility at least for transition. I asked Lord Ahmed in the Lords yesterday. He spoke of ensuring Palestinian oversight supported by moderate Arabs. 1/
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This is truly terrible news. Igor was not only a superb judge but one of the most principled, kind and influential members of @UKHouseofLords.
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And as we begin our debate on the King’s Speech, here is his contribution to last year’s version: www.theyworkforyou.com/search/?pid=14138&pop=1 /5
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
By sheer moral force, when lockdown made it hard to arrange these things, he led @UKHouseofLords in removing the shabby “limited and specific” EU Treaty breach from the #imbill: www.theyworkforyou.com/lords/?id=2020-11-09b.855.4. It never came back. /6
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Subtle or direct as the case required, we must learn to accept that he has led us to the barricades for the last time. RIP Igor, judge and parliamentarian without compare. /7
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And finally … today’s Parliamentary tributes are here: hansard.parliament.uk/lords/2023-11-09/debates/9C00CCA7-3…. That of Lord True, Lord Privy Seal, is particularly fine.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My Public Service (Integrity and Ethics) Bill gives sharper teeth to the regulation of ministerial conduct bills.parliament.uk/bills/3332. It was 23rd in the PMB ballot and will be given its 1st reading on 7th December, with a 2nd reading debate likely if there is no early election.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
With the help of @EndCorruptionUK I have added explanatory notes to the Bill (which finished too far down last year’s ballot to secure a debate). The notes will be published at 1st reading on 7 Dec.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Full list of the lucky 25:
-
David Anderson reposted
Peter Ricketts
@LordRickettsP
A 🧵on ceasefires. In my experience, 3 elements are normally needed. Readiness by both sides to stop fighting (on conditions). A broker to negotiate a deal. And int supervision to give confidence that both sides will respect the terms. Gaza conflict is not at this point yet 1/6
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
She’s right - this was superb. Just two nights to go. Thank you, @red_rose_chain.
Libby Purves
@lib_thinks
Sometimes the first five-star play for ages, immaculate and powerful, turns up in a studio theatre in Ipswich. THE UNGODLY is remarkable in power, humanity and subtlety. Rvw up, theatrecat.com
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And speaking of witch hunts …
Amanda Craig
@AmandaPCraig
This is appalling. Many of us who publically support @j_kRowling_ have had professional problems and bullying, but this poor nurse @preta_6 is an especially awful case of persecution. unherd.com/thepost/legal-ordeal-continues-for-nurse-who-b…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Congratulations to those elected to @CIJ_ICJ. Glad to see that the excellent @clevelandICJ made it.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I very much agree
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Credit to tough and independent police chiefs like Mark Rowley and Neil Basu, both of whom I have been privileged to work with. No one should be using the Cenotaph/Palestine issue to divide us from each other or fan the flames of hatred.
Danny Shaw
@DannyShawNews
This is the “end of operational independence in policing” - says Neil Basu, ex-Met Assistant Commissioner, about the pressure the Govt is exerting on @metpoliceuk to ban Saturday’s march.
Basu says Govt is “on the verge” of behaving unconstitutionally.
Interviewed on @LBC -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The Investigatory Powers (Amendment) Bill (a “Lords starter” announced in yesterday’s King’s Speech) had its 1st reading today www.gov.uk/government/publications/investigatory-powers-a…. /1
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Much of it (though not, in particular, the Part 4 provisions on Notices, which fell outside my remit) is based on my report of April 2023, published in June www.gov.uk/government/news/lord-anderson-publishes-review…. /2
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I have not yet had a chance to examine the text of the Bill: but early indications are that my recommendations have been broadly accepted. /3
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Fresh off the press … the Bill has landed bills.parliament.uk/bills/3508/publications #ipabill /6
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Graham Smith
@Cyberleagle
30 pages of genuinely informative exposition preface the Explanatory Notes for the Investigatory Powers (Amendment) Bill. bills.parliament.uk/publications/52906/documents/3980
-
David Anderson reposted
Michael Gove
@michaelgove
A very sad loss. A truly great man
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This is truly terrible news. Igor was not only a superb judge but one of the most principled, kind and influential members of @UKHouseofLords.
-
David Anderson reposted
Andrew Defty
@adefty
Notes on the proposed Investigatory Powers (Amendment) Bill from today’s #kingsspeech assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/654a21952f045e0012…
-
David Anderson reposted
Tom Hickman
@TomRHickman
Professor Young is an excellent appointment - superb lawyer and great ambassador for public law. Big loss for Cambridge though and it’s students, at least for 5 years.
CrimeLine
@CrimeLineLaw
The Lord Chancellor has approved the appointment of Professor Alison Young as the Law Commissioner for Public Law and the Law in Wales.
-
David Anderson reposted
Steve Peers
@StevePeers
Government plans to redefine "extremism"
www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/nov/04/plans-to-redefine… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Legal London: Lincoln’s Inn this afternoon
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This German Green politician speaks for 10 minutes with courage and clarity on anti-semitism, Israel and Palestine, with translation into English, Hebrew and Arabic. A welcome glimpse of grown-up politics.
Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Energie
@BMWE_
It's almost four weeks since the horrific terrorist attack on #israel. A lot has happened, the public debate has become heated and confused. Find thoughts from Vice-Chancellor Robert #habeck in the video, putting the events in context. 📣With English, Hebrew and Arabic subtitles.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This looks like being essential for anyone with an interest in the workings of @UKParliament
Hansard Society
@HansardSociety
🚨 Introducing: Parliament Matters – A new podcast about the institution at the heart of our democracy, co-hosted by @DArcyTiP & @RuthFox01.
🎧 Tune-in to the preview trailer below…
✅ And subscribe here to get the first episode when it lands on 10 Nov: podfollow.com/parliamentmatters -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Hurray! And congratulations to @pmdfoster whose thorough reporting on this issue has helped keep up the pressure on government over the past couple of years. www.ft.com/content/b3172c61-3fbe-4acb-9cc6-798fdb9c175b
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Things have certainly come on since 2022, when post-Brexit dogma required our closest neighbours’ children to be treated as though they were security threats from the other side of the world: www.theyworkforyou.com/lords/?id=2022-02-02a.895.0&s=spea….
David Anderson
@bricksilk
.@LordRickettsP put it well, as he often does.
-
David Anderson reposted
UCL Global Engagement
@UCL_Global
Congratulations to @UCL European Institute, which earlier this month was awarded its third consecutive Jean Monnet Centre of Excellence grant by the @EU_Commission.
The grant consolidates @UCL_EI as a focal point of competence on EU affairs.
www.ucl.ac.uk/european-institute/news/2023/oct/european-i… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The Rowley/Khan report on hateful extremism, part of the background to this morning's COBRA meeting, is here. www.gov.uk/government/news/commission-for-countering-extr… /1
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
More dangerous is the proposal for a new framework to deal with extremism: we should not criminalise people, or put them under surveillance or suspicion, for something as vague as "helping to create a climate conducive to hate crime/terrorism/violence" (Report 5.34-40). /3
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Sorry to be bumped this morning by @BBCr4today, where I was looking forward to discussing these difficult issues with Sara Khan. (But listeners were not short-changed: @LordRickettsP on the lessons from Lebanon 1982 was superb!) /4
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A judicial report has identified important repairs needed to the closed material procedure under #jsa2013. The principled resignation of @AMcC_KC must prompt @MoJGovUK to act, after far too long a delay. ukhumanrightsblog.com/2023/10/30/the-special-advocate-not…
-
David Anderson reposted
Justin Sherin
@wychstreet
Judi Dench was on Graham Norton last night to push her new book about her life and work with Shakespeare. After making the point we quote Shakespeare daily without knowing it, this happened:
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I like her forthright approach - and agree with her completely about this.
Guardian politics
@GdnPolitics
Peers need more vetting, says new head of House of Lords appointments www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/oct/26/peers-need-more-…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Spot-on, @IanDunt. Pity the poor police who would have to decide whether adherents of Oswald Mosley or Geert Wilders (also inspirations for the NZ mosque shooter) were “creating a climate conducive to terrorism/hate/violence”.
Ian Dunt
@IanDunt
Creating new laws to stop ‘jihad’ protestors will set a dangerous precedent for free speech inews.co.uk/opinion/new-laws-jihad-protestors-precedent-f…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Echoes of the problematic “legal but harmful” provisions of the Online Safety Bill, dropped save in relation to children.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Also in the frame?
@eliothiggins.bsky.social
@EliotHiggins
Heavy recorded the Twitter likes of alleged mass shooter Robert Card, from his now suspended Twitter account, which includes @TuckerCarlson @DonaldJTrumpJr @DineshDSouza @elonmusk @SpeakerMcCarthy @catturd2 @jordanbpeterson
heavy.com/news/robert-card-x-twitter-politics/This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson reposted
Independent Reviewer
@terrorwatchdog
Today I submitted my latest annual report on terrorism legislation (themed around Travel to Terror Zones) to government. I look forward to its publication in due course.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Anyone commenting on events in Gaza could read this with advantage. It’s a reliable expert account of the legal constraints on military action, where they are clear and where they are disputed. /1
Just Security
@just_security
Expert Guidance: Law of Armed Conflict in the Israel-Hamas War
By
- Co-editor-in-chief @rgoodlaw
- Michael Meier, recently served as senior civilian adviser to U.S. Army Judge Advocate General
- Co-editor-in-chief @bridgewriter
www.justsecurity.org/89489/expert-guidance-law-of-armed-c…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The issue of international jurisdiction over war crimes, touched on at the end of the piece, is of topical relevance for the U.K. I’ll be discussing later today with @REDRESSTrust and @ClooneyFDN in @UKHouseofLords. /2
David Anderson
@bricksilk
For a much shorter guide to the applicable international law, including these specific warnings to Israel, see the letter from eight distinguished Jewish lawyers (including a former president of the UK Supreme Court) in today’s @FT on.ft.com/48WVeLg. /3
David Anderson
@bricksilk
See also this speech by Lord Verdirame, perhaps the most expert international lawyer currently sitting in @UKHouseofLords: hansard.parliament.uk/lords/2023-10-24/debates/17465F6F-4…
-
David Anderson reposted
Mujtaba Rahman
@Mij_Europe
Macron today attempted a perilous balancing act in a conflict which threatens to overturn all balance & proportion. After talks in Jslum with Israeli PM Netanyahu, Macron called for a western coalition to defeat Hamas but also a “decisive” relaunch of Palestinian peace process 1/
-
David Anderson reposted
UCL European Institute
@UCL_EI
“I’m off to draw some London into my lungs. “
Pavel Vilikovský
Venture out and join us to celebrate the launch of our exhibition - Lost & Found: Mapping European Literary London.
TODAY, 5:30pm. In the UCL South Cloisters.
#europeanliterarylondon
www.ucl.ac.uk/european-institute/events/2023/oct/launch-e… -
David Anderson reposted
Rob Linham
@radinden
So here you go... (all?) 81 cases involving an interpretation under section 3 of the Human Rights Act 1998: www.gov.uk/government/publications/cases-involving-an-int… (🧵7/7 and out)
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Thanks Ian! I’ll be talking about this on my @GBNEWS debut with @Jacob_Rees_Mogg after 8pm tonight.
Ian Dunt
@IanDunt
Incidentally the longer these ideas around new anti-extremism/terror laws float around, the more important it is to follow @bricksilk
-
David Anderson reposted
Gabriel Tan
@finishedloading
SIAC holds that Begum principles also apply to challenges to deprivation of citizenship/exclusion where non-conducive decision is based on involvement in serious and organised crime, and therefore are not only confined to national security cases.
siac.decisions.tribunals.gov.uk/Documents/D5, D6 & D7 - O… -
David Anderson reposted
Lords Constitution Committee
@HLConstitution
📢Today we have published our report 'Permanent secretaries: their appointment and removal'
We consider the degree of ministerial involvement in these processes, and whether there exists a desire to appoint politically sympathetic candidates.
👇
publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld5803/ldselect/ldconst/258… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
“To guard against the improper removal of senior civil servants, formal departure processes should be set out in writing.” @HLConstitution report on the appointment and dismissal of permanent secretaries published today. committees.parliament.uk/publications/41636/documents/206…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
By describing our better qualities, the King encourages us to show them. This is leadership: we are lucky to have him.
The Royal Family
@RoyalFamily
The King has reflected on the shared values inherent in our society during a speech at Mansion House in the City of London.
Head to our website to read the speech in full: royal.uk/mansion-house -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A small but remarkably effective organisation - recommended!
Spotlight on Corruption
@EndCorruptionUK
⏱️The deadline for this great role is midnight on Sunday. If you're a legal researcher with great writing skills and a passion to help fight corruption, don't miss this opportunity! Apply using the @CharityJob link in the post below ⬇️.
-
Joshua Rozenberg
@JoshuaRozenberg
Lady Justice Simler will join the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom as a Justice on 14 November 2023, it was announced today.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Congratulations to her (interviewed here in 2022) www.counselmagazine.co.uk/articles/strength-in-diversity-….
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Scholars’ Dinner at @middletemple tonight, to honour 84 bright and super-diverse entrants to the Bar. Of my table companions, four were dentist, actor, journalist, judge’s clerk: the fifth works full time at Greggs to finance her studies. Infinite respect, good luck to them all.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Thank you, Giles Coren www.thetimes.co.uk/article/people-tell-me-i-need-to-take-…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Parliament, #brexit and "prophetic democracy": a clear narrative account by @redhistorian of how the 2016 referendum affected - at least for a time - the UK's fundamental constitutional balance.
Institut für Zeitgeschichte München−Berlin
@Leibniz_IfZ
Out now: The recording of @redhistorian's talk "Democracy in Crisis: Brexit and the British Constitution, 2016–19". A brilliant lecture on the causes of the #brexit controversy and its legacy for democratic thought and practice in the UK.
@DAADCamHub
www.youtube.com/watch?v=lYpqh83dQkE
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I would like to think that orthodoxy was restored by the Supreme Court in Miller 2 - but that may be an excessively law-focussed view.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A useful summary of international law on proportionality in armed conflict. Unsurprisingly, the application of the test is highly fact-dependent.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Some horrible antisemitic incidents are logged here. Sadly, even in normal times, @CST_UK volunteers are needed to protect Jewish schools and synagogues. cst.org.uk/news/blog/2023/10/11/antisemitic-incidents-inc…
-
David Anderson reposted
Alex Thomas
@AlexGAThomas
Worth a read of this 🧵 on Labour’s plans for an Ethics and Integrity Commission
IfG events
@ifgevents
Starting now at #lab23: How will Labour's proposed Ethics and Integrity Commission work?
With @NiaGriffithMP @Debbie_abrahams @duncanhames @susanpjhawley @breeallegretti & @timd_IFG chaired by @DrHannahWhite
Room 26 ACC, with @TransparencyUK & @EndCorruptionUK -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
👏👏
-
David Anderson reposted
Shayan Sardarizadeh
@Shayan86
Thread: Online misinformation is rampant following the escalation of violence between Israel and Hamas today.
This video of a tower block in Gaza being hit by a missile is from May 2021, not today. It was captured live during a BBC Arabic broadcast at the time. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
As judicial scrutiny of the Rwanda MOU continues, worth remembering that Parliamentary scrutiny was excluded. This is what @HLIntAgreements had to say:
Alexander Horne
@AlexanderHorne1
As @JoshuaRozenberg notes, the case concerning the legality of removals under the Government’s Rwanda asylum partnership is before the Supreme Court this week. (Short 🧵) /
-
David Anderson reposted
Edward Lucas
@edwardlucas
Cracking Times leader today
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/ff1b0e44-660f-11ee-a4e7-0fb10a… -
David Anderson reposted
JUSTICE
@JUSTICEhq
A lively end to this year's JUSTICE Human Rights Conference, with a robust debate on human rights and party manifestos.
Chaired by @IStephanieBoyc1, and featuring @bricksilk, @robertbuckland, @GreenJennyJones, @LordCFalconer and The Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames KC. #jhrc23 -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Thanks @warwickpolsoc for a cracking session on Remaking the Constitution, full of good questions and debate. Subsequent speakers are in for a treat!
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The mills of (secret) justice grind exceeding slow. #jsa2013 s13 required this report to be completed as soon as reasonably practicable after June 2018. But it was only commissioned in 2021 - and we won’t even hear what @MoJGovUK proposes to do about it until 2024! /1
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Having started, researched and written his lengthy report within the calendar year 2021, he is the one actor in this sorry drama who cannot be accused of undue delay. /4
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Does anyone know of a longer delay in commissioning and responding to a report required by Act of Parliament @JoshuaRozenberg @d_a_t_green? This one should have been commissioned in 2018, published and responded to in 2019. /5
David Anderson
@bricksilk
These are cases in which the government seeks to rely on secret intelligence, in closed proceedings, without disclosing it to the other party. Given the potential for injustice, a five-year delay in learning the lessons of 2013-18 is a serious matter indeed. /6 end
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Balanced appraisal of the NI Troubles Bill (as improved during its parliamentary passage) by the distinguished human rights expert Brice Dickson sluggerotoole.com/2023/09/25/is-the-legacy-and-reconcilia…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I'm with @JMPSimor on this: an excellent piece, enriched by first-hand experience. www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/ideas/law/63339/lord-sumption-…
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
That the “living instrument” doctrine so deplored by detractors of the ECtHR is standard in courts adjudicating on constitutional rights – including our own Privy Council www.jcpc.uk/cases/docs/jcpc-2021-0064-judgment.pdf.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
And that in a Europe threatened by war, hateful prejudice, attacks on independent institutions and the dilution of democracy, the supranational adjudication and enforcement of individual rights is a vital asset which if carelessly handled, will be fatally diminished.
-
David Anderson reposted
JUSTICE
@JUSTICEhq
Join our Board! We are looking for four new Board members to share their expertise and guidance.
If you are committed to the fair administration of justice, and would like to sit on the Board of a small but effective charity, visit our website:
justice.org.uk/about-us/careers -
David Anderson reposted
Guardian politics
@GdnPolitics
Braverman’s claim about ethnicity of UK child grooming gangs was false, regulator rules www.theguardian.com/politics/2023/sep/28/braverman-ethnic…
-
David Anderson reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
Today, the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board released a report on Section 702 of FISA that examines how it is being used and provides recommendations aimed at protecting privacy and civil liberties. Read the report, from Caleb Benjamin. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-privacy-and-civil-libert…
-
David Anderson reposted
GCHQ
@GCHQ
A summer internship working in UK intelligence?
Be it in MI5, SIS or GCHQ, bring your unique mindset to our teams, piece together intelligence and identify possible threats. With training from the start, you’ll gain new skills & develop your abilities.
ad.doubleclick.net/ddm/clk/566833851;376303683;t -
Joanna Hardy-Susskind
@Joanna__Hardy
Another IPP sentence, still wrecking lives, a decade after they were abolished.
www.itv.com/news/tyne-tees/2023-09-21/prisoner-released-a…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
We regularly debate IPPs in @UKHouseofLords: www.theyworkforyou.com/lords/?id=2022-10-13a.891.0. Let us hope that @AlexChalkChelt will grasp the nettle and correct this manifest injustice, acutely analysed here in July by @JoshuaRozenberg rozenberg.substack.com/p/chalk-considering-limited-ipp-re….
-
David Anderson reposted
Joanna Hardy-Susskind
@Joanna__Hardy
Another IPP sentence, still wrecking lives, a decade after they were abolished.
www.itv.com/news/tyne-tees/2023-09-21/prisoner-released-a… -
David Anderson reposted
Dr Catherine Haddon
@cath_haddon
Recommendation for unambiguous source of constitutional advice and warning (Parl committee, external body to review, strong unit in Cab Office and clear role for Cab Sec)
Partic apt after @bbclaurak revelation yesterday that officials considered mobilising THE QUEEN. -
David Anderson reposted
Matt Purvis
@HLLibResearch
"we recommend that the UK parliament should establish a new [joint] Parliamentary Committee on the Constitution (PCC), with membership drawn from both Houses of Parliament, aligning more comfortably with the principle of parliamentary sovereignty"
Hannah White
@DrHannahWhite
Delighted today to be launching the final report of the @instituteforgov @BennettInst Review of the UK Constitution in which we argue that we need to strengthen checks and balances and reform the way we approach constitutional change… www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/publication/final-repor…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This is a truly impressive piece of work, whose evolution I was privileged to observe from my place on the Advisory Board. On the parliamentary side it has some bold and thoughtful ideas for @CommonsPACAC and @HLConstitution, which I hope will be widely discussed.
Hannah White
@DrHannahWhite
Delighted today to be launching the final report of the @instituteforgov @BennettInst Review of the UK Constitution in which we argue that we need to strengthen checks and balances and reform the way we approach constitutional change… www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/publication/final-repor…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Politics then and now: some depressing truths in @adwooldridge’s arresting polemic www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2023-09-15/theresa-may…. How can the incentives operating on public servants be better aligned with the public good?
-
David Anderson reposted
Institute for Government
@instituteforgov
What will the next general election mean for the UK constitution?
Don't miss our event at the IfG and @BennettInst conference on the future of the UK constitution on Tuesday 19 September, 12:15.
With @cath_haddon @aliceolilly @jacknewmanHE @AkashPaun www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/event/future-uk-constit… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Two rejections of govt amendments this evening on nutrient neutrality - the first of them (by 203-156) on its over-broad Henry VIII clause. My speech is here: hansard.parliament.uk/search/MemberContributions?house=Lo…. As they were introduced so late to @UKHouseofLords, they cannot now be restored in the Commons.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Despite John Gummer’s (Lord Deben’s) brilliant rallying call (worth a watch on parliamentlive tv) only 3 Conservatives rebelled votes.parliament.uk/votes/lords/division/3046.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Nutrients debate @UKHouseofLords in full swing - science, politics and constitutional law. #levellingupbill #nutrientsneutrality #henryviii
Ruth Chambers
@ruthmchambers
📺 One of the most hotly awaited debates of the year has started in @UKHouseofLords on govt plans to scrap water pollution laws in important nature sites.
Expect lots of focus on our river health crisis, broken govt promises and lack of consultation.
www.parliamentlive.tv/Event/Index/b2efa2b3-ac1a-4615-850d… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Indeed - looks like votes (including on this staggeringly broad delegated power) will come late tomorrow or possibly on Monday.
Richard Benwell
@RSBenwell
Parliamentarians from all parties are worried, including the Delegated Powers Committee. It says the Henry VIII power to amend #nutrientneutrality laws "should not form part of the bill". @bricksilk & other eminent legal minds are concerned at this agregation of executive power.
-
David Anderson reposted
Adam Vaughan
@adamvaughan_uk
The head of the National Trust and other green leaders have said that the planned scrapping of protection for rivers would amount to the “most significant unwinding of environmental law for decades” www.thetimes.co.uk/article/national-trust-head-warns-agai… #nutrientneutrality
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Untreated sewage discharges: @OfficeforEP stirs things up www.theoep.org.uk/news/oep-identifies-possible-failures-c…
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Summarised here www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-66778409
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
This report on #martynslaw committees.parliament.uk/publications/41090/documents/201…, using the expert evidence of @terrorwatchdog and others, shows the value of parliamentary pre-legislative scrutiny. It should happen more: preventing errors in advance is easier than reversing them in @UKHouseofLords.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I hope @TomTugendhat, who has signalled a welcome degree of flexibility, will react positively to these recommendations of @CommonsHomeAffs.
-
David Anderson reposted
Hannah White
@DrHannahWhite
My latest for @FT on the tricky problems surrounding Labour’s policy on @UKHouseofLords reform… 👇
on.ft.com/489hPUw -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The Delegated Powers Committee of @UKHouseofLords has today condemned the Henry VIII clause on nutrient neutrality that the government is seeking to put into #levellingupbill at the last minute: committees.parliament.uk/publications/41347/documents/203…. I will be seeking to remove it from the Bill on Wednesday.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Hoping for support from the cross-benches and @rosaltmann @IanDuncanHMG @SueHayman1 @kateparminter @GreenJennyJones @GreenAllianceUK!
-
David Anderson reposted
EJIL: Talk!
@ejiltalk
Are judges with non-renewable terms more independent and impartial? @helgasteensig & Quemy find that, after the ECtHR's tenure rules amendment, judges with non-renewable terms write more separate opinions and criticize their appointing state more often.
academic.oup.com/ejil/advance-article-abstract/doi/10.109… -
David Anderson reposted
David Lidington
@DLidington
Not often you can say this about an obituary, but this is the funniest thing you'll read today: a celebration of a gloriously eccentric life www.thetimes.co.uk/article/dbb20ffa-4c17-11ee-98c9-759fff…
-
David Anderson reposted
Gavin Hales
@gmhales
Police use of firearms in England and Wales in the year to March 2023. There were 10 incidents where a firearm was discharged out of 18,395 firearms operations (0.05%). #useofforce
www.gov.uk/government/statistics/police-use-of-firearms-s… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Inside Elon Musk’s Twitter takeover
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/cb2a1701-b5f4-428f-bfee-1929c3… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Good to see @OfficeforEP holding government to account
The Office for Environmental Protection
@OfficeforEP
We are clear - the proposed changes to the Levelling Up Bill amount to a regression in environmental law. Transparency over this is important. The latest exchange of letters with Government on this can be found here: www.theoep.org.uk/report/proposed-changes-laws-developmen…
-
David Anderson reposted
UCL Faculty of Laws
@UCLLaws
Professor @TomRHickman (Professor of Public Law at UCL Laws) has written an article for the London Review of Books on the ECHR and the Rwanda deportation scheme www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v45/n17/tom-hickman/short-cuts
-
David Anderson reposted
JUSTICE
@JUSTICEhq
This year's JUSTICE Human Rights Conference closing debate will be chaired by @IStephanieBoyc1, and features @bricksilk, @RobertBuckland, @LordCFalconer, @GreenJennyJones and The Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames KC.
Don't miss it - book your ticket today!
justice.org.uk/events/justice-human-rights-conference-2023 -
David Anderson reposted
Dave Throup
@DaveThroup
An important test for the new(ish) OEP whose core function is to hold Government to account on environmental protection matters.
Reading between the lines they’re, rightly, livid!
They’re also clear the bonkers proposals are a regression in environmental protection.
The Office for Environmental Protection
@OfficeforEP
Proposed changes to the Levelling-up and Regeneration Bill will reduce the level of environmental protection provided for in law and amount to a regression, the OEP is warning. Find out more: www.theoep.org.uk/report/proposed-changes-laws-developmen…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Trying to get my head around the proposed new Schedule 13 to the Levelling Up Bill. Can it really be as bad as it looks @ruthmchambers @IanDuncanHMG?
Dave Throup
@DaveThroup
The proposed nutrient neutrality amendment is simply staggering
2 says LAs must assume new houses will have no impact on protected rivers
3 tells them not to check
4 tells them to ignore anything that says otherwise
No MP in their right mind could vote for this?! -
David Anderson reposted
David Aaronovitch
@DAaronovitch
Oops. Someone has just lost the love of the birding community
-
David Anderson reposted
T.M.C. Asser Instituut
@TMCAsser
In a new interview, @tom_renard (@ICCT_TheHague) shares his insights into the recent developments in #extremism and #terrorism, their connection to the COVID crisis, and the various challenges in creating effective #counterterrorism measures
Read it here: www.asser.nl/about-the-asser-institute/news/interview-cou… -
David Anderson reposted
UnHerd
@unherd
‘Why write about the Hundred Years War?’ | Jonathan Sumption reflects on 43 years of scholarship: unherd.com/2023/08/modern-europe-was-born-on-the-battlefi…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Oh dear. I feel a writtten question coming on.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Deligjted to endorse this multi-disciplinary study of parliament buildings in Europe. To paraphrase Churchill, they both reflect and influence our democracies. Thanks to @UCL_EI @ukstaiger for introducing me to the project. www.uclpress.co.uk/products/223070
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Talking of sculpture, this is the Pilane Skulpturpark in Tjorn, W Sweden (pictured, magic from Ai Weiwei, Tony Cragg, Jaume Plensa, Hans Gethlin)
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Lovely piece on hidden art. It tells how the Whalebone Box, crafted by Harris sculptor Steve Dilworth www.pangolinlondon.com/artists/34-steve-dilworth/works/, found its place in @middletemple library, between the Molyneux Globes middletemplar.org.uk/the-terrestrial-molyneux-globe-in-li…. www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2023/aug/16/deliberately…
-
David Anderson reposted
Derrick Wyatt's Law and Policy Blog
@BlogWyatt
"Bringing the Strasbourg Court’s jurisdiction over the UK to an end would strengthen parliamentary democracy.."
Checks and balances on the democratic process can strengthen it too, if the overall package is supported by the public.
unherd.com/2023/08/the-case-for-leaving-the-echr/ -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
GCHQ’s Chief Data Scientist has written a piece on the applications of large language models for the intelligence community. cetas.turing.ac.uk/publications/large-language-models-and…
-
David Anderson reposted
David Lidington
@DLidington
Only this May, PM attended Council of Europe summit #reykjavik & with other heads of state & govt signed declaration expressing "deep & abiding commitment" to ECHR & Ct of Human Rts and "binding obligation" to respect judgments of the Court. h/t @patricklohlein
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Quite right
Lee David Evans
@LeeDavidEvansUK
The Times offered a scathing commentary on the idea of constituency associations (i.e. party members) having a role in the selection of a new Conservative leader to replace Macmillan.
11th October 1963, page 13 -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Lord (Simon) Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood - Treasury Devil, @UKSupremeCourt Justice and exemplary cross-bench peer - has died. On retiring this spring from @UKHouseofLords he told friends he had one summer left - luckily, an Ashes summer! RIP and I hope he enjoyed the cricket.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
His many fine qualities included humanity, independence of mind and humour. The first two were evident in his campaign against #ipps and his last speech, on #imbill, which was both thoughtful and brave: www.theyworkforyou.com/lords/?id=2023-05-10a.1805.0. /2
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I have many good memories of arguing cases before him – “not invariably with success”, as he recalled in response to my rather earnest maiden speech, “but that was probably our fault, and not his …” /3
David Anderson
@bricksilk
His memoirs – Playing off the Roof, Second Helpings and Last Scrapings - are equally amusing, and a good deal more readable than most of their genre. /4
David Anderson
@bricksilk
He showed that it is possible to live a life of public service - and to enjoy every moment of it. It was a privilege to know him. /5
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood obituary
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/76352d0c-1e8a-11ee-97d4-772627… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Just in time for last two days of line-by-line @UKHouseofLords scrutiny, @HumanRightsCtte has published a lengthy and critical report on #imbill committees.parliament.uk/publications/40298/documents/196….
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Congratulations to @AlexChalkChelt, whose careers in law and parliament have qualified him well to perform the Lord Chancellor’s duty of upholding the rule of law.
Sky News
@SkyNews
BREAKING: Alex Chalk to replace Dominic Raab as justice secretary
@BethRigby has the latest
Live updates here 👉 qrcode.skynews.com/skynews/politicshub
qrcode.skynews.com/skynews/home
📺 Sky 501, Virgin 602, Freeview 233 and YouTubeThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Scary last-sentence challenge from @CamCavendish via @FT. Lawyers, sci-fi visionaries and others still have a few days to respond to my consultation www.daqc.co.uk/2023/02/09/investigatory-powers-act-review/. /1 on.ft.com/3ycNwvC
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
“Because we are free to deplete our environment and trash our workplace and consumer protections, it is of the utmost importance that we do so (and by regulation, so that Parliament can neither amend nor reject our plans).” x.com/jacob_rees_mogg/status/1611805773180571650 #reulbill
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Interviewed this evening by @EvanHD @BBCRadio4 PM on the removal of citizenship, from 47.50-52.50 www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m001329g
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Just attended an online Covid briefing with Sir Patrick Vallance, Chris Whitty &c. Only MPs and peers - almost 450 of us. Questions were uniformly concise, courteous, pertinent, well-informed and non-political: better on each count than we usually hear at press conferences. /1
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
The Ministerial Code still mandates compliance with international law, despite a change to its wording, as the Court of Appeal confirmed in 2018: amp.theguardian.com/law/2018/aug/01/appeal-court-rules-th…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Last night’s debate is now in Hansard - my contribution is here hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2020-06-15/debates/852C6EE6-D….
David Anderson
@bricksilk
"We are more likely to respect both rules and guidance if we are treated as grown-ups, capable of distinguishing between the two." My speech this evening in a spirited (and absurdly overdue) @UKHouseofLords debate on the 12 May Lockdown Regulations: parliamentlive.tv/event/index/dce36087-1731-4a92-9c2b-289…. /1
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
"We are more likely to respect both rules and guidance if we are treated as grown-ups, capable of distinguishing between the two." My speech this evening in a spirited (and absurdly overdue) @UKHouseofLords debate on the 12 May Lockdown Regulations: parliamentlive.tv/event/index/dce36087-1731-4a92-9c2b-289…. /1
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
I don’t claim to be a great cross-examiner - most of the best are at the criminal Bar - but the efforts of the journos so far are lame in the extreme. One question at a time, keep it specific!
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Intelligent, resourceful, driven and widely respected: from what I have observed over several years, Ken McCallum is the obvious choice to lead #mi5 both operationally and in its dealings with Government. Best of luck to him, and to them. www.mi5.gov.uk/news/new-director-general-of-mi5-appointed
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My "private notice" (urgent) question on the Russia Report issue has been selected, and there will be a 10-minute session on it in @UKHouseofLords shortly after 3pm today.
David Anderson
@bricksilk
As a former intelligence reviewer I agree with @DominicGrieve and @LordRickettsP. HMG sadly has form for withholding info from the ISC (below: hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2019-09-09/debates/314D293A-D…). Non-release of a declassified report on Russian election interference looks cynical and will feed suspicion.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
As a former intelligence reviewer I agree with @DominicGrieve and @LordRickettsP. HMG sadly has form for withholding info from the ISC (below: hansard.parliament.uk/Lords/2019-09-09/debates/314D293A-D…). Non-release of a declassified report on Russian election interference looks cynical and will feed suspicion.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Matthew Parris has left the Conservative Party www.thetimes.co.uk/article/im-leaving-the-tories-and-voti… (£)
-
Post not available here, view on X
David Anderson
@bricksilk
We fought hard to get the independent review and I would encourage all those with relevant experience to engage with it.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Whatever the truth behind this www.thetimes.co.uk/article/cf1c17d6-bbac-11e9-a968-3aae19… (£) - the comments attributed to a “senior Home Office official” are certainly troubling - it underlines the importance of the independent review of #prevent whose details are to be announced tomorrow.
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Govt’s silence on facial recognition reported in @thetimes today (£) www.thetimes.co.uk/article/spy-technology-ministers-must-… @surcamcom
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Facial recognition: when will the Surveillance Camera Code of Practice be updated, as undertaken to @surcamcom?
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Facial recognition: when will the Surveillance Camera Code of Practice be updated, as undertaken to @surcamcom?
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Looking forward to discussing this film (in which I appear briefly) at its BAFTA premiere on Thursday
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/5f408e14-7409-11e9-ae5e-b136d5… -
David Anderson
@bricksilk
A man who knows what he is talking about: @NotThatBigIan’s foreword to @csjthinktank’s new prison manifesto medium.com/csj-criminal-justice/control-order-hope-forewo…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Tuesday's HC debate on my intelligence-handling report. Dominic Grieve indicates likely focus of Intelligence and Security Committee scrutiny. hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2017-12-05/debates/859F234B…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
My report on intelligence handling prior to the terrorist attacks has just been published: www.daqc.co.uk/2017/12/05/report-mi5-police-intelligence-….
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Counter extremism bill could be 'very dangerous', says watchdog www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/counter-extremism…
-
David Anderson
@bricksilk
Report of my Bulk Powers Review now published: terrorismlegislationreviewer.independent.gov.uk/bulk-powe…























































































































































































































































































