Ninety three today. I'm not about to start tweeting again, but look forward to the fascinating politics of the coming year.
David Butler (psephologist)
Sir David Edgeworth Butler (17 October 1924 – 8 November 2022) was an English political scientist who specialised in psephology, the study of elections. He has been described as "the father of modern election science". More on Wikipedia
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Learning to tweet at 92 has been fun. But my musings should now be confined to elections, so I am signing off . . . until next year?
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
I have enjoyed my flirtation with Tweeting – and thank you for all the feedback. It’s wonderful to rediscover one is never too old to learn.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Parliament emerges "weak and unstable" after the snap election.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Wilson ran a minority govt for 8 months in 74. It's hard to see a May govt lasting any longer now.
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Unlike 74 though, this time the Opposition will probably want a new vote.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Significantly more variation in swing this time both by region and amount than in any post-war election.
-
Sir David Butler reposted
Matt Goodwin
@GoodwinMJ
**In the betting markets Jeremy Corbyn is now favourite to be the next Prime Minister of Britain**
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
15 Seats declared. Still none changed hands. Unusual. Can't last of course.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
No one yet pledging to eat their hat on the back of the exit poll.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Higher youth turnout in Sunderland may hint at explaining Labour strength generally.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Exit polls do not take in the last hour or more of real voting.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Health warning about TV exit poll: 2015 and 92 both underestimated Conservative support
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
If net poll forecasts of a 7-8% Tory lead are accurate, one would certainly expect an increased majority
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The first 10 seats called usually give an accurate steer to the final outcome.
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
If there's an overall swing towards the Conservatives, their victory becomes v probable.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Rain can play a part - but it’s small. Lab voters go to polls later, so evening showers potentially hurt Lab more.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The polls have moved a great deal over the past two weeks. When people ask me for a prediction, I have to say I know that I don’t know.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The Con lead varies from 12 – 1%. The polls are likely to converge, but if they don’t some pollsters will be embarrassed.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
There have been successful post-election fraud prosecutions, but I cannot recall a 20th century candidate being charged during the campaign.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The last MPs to lose their seats because of false election expenses were Berwick-on-Tweed and Oxford in 1922 and 1923 respectively.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
A new politics? In five days 12k followers provoked by a few non-partisan quotes.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Two weeks ago polls pointed to a huge Conservative landslide. Now highly respected pollster Peter Kellner can envisage a hung parliament.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Polls have a mixed record but they have never moved or disagreed so much as now. There’s a week to go but someone will be embarrassed.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Winston Churchill is easily the most widely-travelled MP when it comes to labels, standing on seven party tickets 1899 - 1959.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Leader approval ratings are less important than many think. One study says a 4% change in leader rating only moves voting intention by 1%.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Successful campaign slogans? 'Labour Isn't Working' (1979) vs 'Strong and Stable' (2017)
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The polls currently have combined Lab/Con vote at 80%. The last time they shared so much was 81% in 1979, but at 65% in 2010; 67% in 2015
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Voters are more volatile: the proportion switching parties between elections rose from 15% in 1960s to 43% in 2015.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
As leader approval rating gap narrows, remember voters thought Callaghan would be a better PM than Thatcher in 79, but Cons still won well.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
If Callaghan considered bad weather when ducking an autumn 78 poll in favour of spring 79, it backfired thanks to the winter of discontent.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Traditional thinking says polling day rain hurts Labour, but if Heath banked on Feb snow in 74 it didn't work and Wilson won that October.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Boundary changes muddy the waters, but a third of British seats have only ever been represented by one party.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Oh, if anyone wants to see the full Newsnight interview . . . www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b08rzp9k/newsnight-26052017
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
As I said last night on Newsnight, the movement in the polls over this campaign is bigger than in any election I've covered since 1945.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Andrew Bonar Law was born in Canada. He was prime minister for six months in 1922-23 before resigning due to ill-health in May.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Britain has only had one prime minister born outside the British Isles. Who was he? (Answers later this evening.)
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Nick Clegg was the only post-war Lib leader to serve in Gov, but under him his party never gained a by-election and fell from 63 to 8 seats.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The last prime minister to die in office was Lord Palmerston in 1865 although Campbell-Bannerman died 19 days after resigning in 1908.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Who was the last prime minister to die in office?
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Checking my tweets on the Mid-Wales (Brecon &Radnor) campaign trail with LibDem William Powell
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Direct tv debates between election principals began in US in 1960. Only happened once here (2010). Cameron stopped this in 2015.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
This year we have barely seen party leader press conferences. They were the prime campaign staple from 59 to 2005.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Comparing opponents to extremists generally doesn't work well in the UK - Churchill's 'socialist gestapo' speech in 45 backfired badly.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Leaflets and posters always feature strongly in elections. Do they work? Maybe, but more by boosting activist morale than by swaying voters.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Consulting the Oracle
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The highest winning vote over my career was Con’s 50% in 55; the lowest Lab’s 35% in 2005. In 1951 Lab lost with 50% to Con victorious 49%.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Tightest 4-way seat since full franchise: Invn'ss Nairn & Loch'ber '92: LD 26.0, Lab 25.1, SNP 24.7, Con 22.6%. Gap between 1 and 4 - 1,741
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
In 1950 both Churchill and Attlee gave a speech in all Britain's great cities. Wilson was the last to try to do the same in 74.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Congratulations to those that worked out Theresa May is the only serving PM to represent a Berkshire seat.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
In the 20 general election campaigns I've followed, I can't remember a U-turn on this scale - or much that could be called a U-turn at all.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Only one Prime Minister has represented a Berkshire seat while in office - which one? (Answers in time for journey home from work.)
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
From 1924 to 2010, no MP was ousted for election fraud. Action could be pending in one 2015 case.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Tightest 3-way seat since full franchise: Caith & Sutherl'd '45. Con 33.5%, Lab 33.4%, Lib 33.1%. Con maj 6 over Lab and 61 votes over Lib
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Democratic casualties: 2010 saw the most candidates (4150) and the most lost deposits (1893). Nearly £1 million raised for the Treasury.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The nationalisation of campaigns is fairly new. The first manifesto was issued in 1834, but until 50s most local candidates ignored HQs.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Defence rarely swings elections. 1951 Mirror rallying headline: "Who's finger on the trigger?" didn't help Attlee beat Churchill.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Politicians worry about the student vote in some constituencies, but until 1950 graduates of Britain’s universities elected their own MPs.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
WW1 soldiers cast Britain's first postal votes 99 years ago. By 2015, one in five votes were postal. For many the campaign ends today.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Thanks to @sethfarsides for pointing out '79 was last time voters felt the losing party’s leader would make the better PM
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Until 1926 ministers had to resign on appointment and fight a by-election. The last to fail to be reelected was in 1922.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Congratulations to those that spotted Palmerston, Wellington, Canning and Melbourne were all MPs for the dual-constituency of Newport, IoW.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The highest post-war turnout was 84% (in 1950), the lowest was 59% (2001). It was 66% in 2015.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Four MPs from one British seat went on to become PM. Where was the seat and who were they? (Answers here later.)
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
From 1885 to 1950 there was a seat called Liverpool Everton. One of its MPs was Frank Hornby, founder of Hornby Trains, Meccano & Dinky toys
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The voting age dropped from 21 to 18 for the 70 election. Further reductions have since failed, but 16s voted in the 2014 Scots Referendum
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
From 45 – 64 elections were as like to be in autumn as spring/summer. Since Oct 64 there has only been one autumn election (Oct 74).
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The last general election not on a Thurs was Tues 27 October 31. By-elections were sometimes on Tues or Weds until 70s.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
In 1950 there were 9 candidates who went on to be PM - Attlee, Churchill, Eden, Macmillan, Home, Wilson, Heath, Callaghan & Thatcher.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The best Cons vote was 50% in ‘55 (31% in 97). Worst Lab 28% in ’83 (49% in ’51). Current polls put Con on 48% and Lab around 30%.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
BBC's Peter Barnes says today's polls put Lab (30%) and Con (48%) - nearly 80% together. It was last 78% in 92 and last over 80% in 79.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
The Libs re-emerged as a Parliamentary force in 1966, but the Westminster breakthrough was 46 MPs in 1997, 62 in 2005 - in 2015 it fell to 8
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
1983 is always seen as a Tory high-water mark. True, Thatcher emerged with a 144 majority, but her Cons only actually gained 39 seats.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Political swing has become much more complex. In the 50s votes were 95% Con or Lab: no Nats or UKIP and Libs were negligible until 64's 11%.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Do campaigns matter? The striking examples are 1959 and 1992. Lab started well in both, but the Tories pulled irons out of the fire to win.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
1970 is the only election where economic figures were clearly important. Just before the poll they went sour: surprise win for Tories.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Landslides are rare. In 45 and 97 Labour gained 239 and 145 seats (mainly from Con). In 1970 the Tories won 77 (mainly from Lab).
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
1970: England holders, knocked out of World Cup 4 days before polling. Labour just beaten. Might Wilson have won 4 days earlier?
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Twists of fate rarely affect elections, but Kruschev fell just too late for Home. Instead economically-strong Wilson won by five in 1964.
-
Sir David Butler
@SirDavidButler
Contrary to some beliefs, the polls have a good record. 1992 was the exception when they put Labour ahead by about 7%. The Tories won by 7%.

