When will we recognize the necessity of electoral reform to protect against tyranny? electionlawblog.org?p=153958
Edward B. Foley
Edward B. Foley, also known as Ned Foley, is an American lawyer, law professor, election law scholar, and former Ohio Solicitor General. He is the theorist of the blue shift, a phenomenon in American politics in which in-person votes overstate overall percentage of votes for the Republican Party (whose color is red), while provisional votes, which are counted after election day, tend to overstate overall percentage of votes for the Democratic Party (whose color is blue). When the provisional votes are counted after the election, there is often a shift in totals toward the Democrat, or blue, candidate. More on Wikipedia
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Condorcet Voting and the Cornyn-Paxton Race open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/condorcet-voting-and…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
A cleaner, edited version of this paper is now available on SSRN; in reading it over, I think it's one of my more significant contributions:
“The Real Preference of Voters”: Madison’s Idea of a Top-Three Election and The Present Necessity of Reform @SSRN papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5097563 -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Just in time for March Madness: Bracket Voting.
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/bracket-voting?r=lrx… -
Ned Foley reposted
Law & Democracy
@lawdemocracypod
Aligning Election Law and Polarization with Professor Richard Pildes of ... youtu.be/l87BjrmddEc via @YouTube
@RickPildes
@GaughanAnthonyJ
@Nedfoley
@OhioStateLJ
#election2024 -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The Senate Has Surrendered Its Constitutional Responsibilities open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/the-senate-has-surre…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Everyone concerned about the rule of law in the US right now should read this by @DebPearlstein : "The Law Is Not Fully Trump’s Yet"
www.nytimes.com/2025/01/30/opinion/trump-law-control-auth… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Keep Condorcet in Consideration as an Electoral Reform Option: It’s wrong to argue that Condorcet Voting should be rejected entirely and everywhere.
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/keep-condorcet-in-co… -
Ned Foley reposted
Princeton P*LAW
Democracy: A Journal of Ideas published an essay that draws upon the fellowship research of P*LAW Crane Faculty Fellow @Nedfoley .
Read the full piece here 🔗: democracyjournal.org/arguments/should-we-be-saying-presid…
#plaw #lawatprincetonThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
More evidence that nation’s Madisonian system, with its separation of powers, is in trouble: substack.com/@nedfoley/note/c-87824849?r=lrx2b
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Don’t Treat Trump as a Condorcet Winner. Post-inauguration, there continue to be misunderstandings of the election.
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/dont-treat-trump-as-… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Some thoughts on the current condition of Madisonian democracy that some might find useful as part of an effort to understand how the country arrived to where it is today: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5097563 (long version) & edwardbfoley.substack.com/p/the-real-preference-of-the-vo… (short version)
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Did America's electorate vote for taking back the Panama Canal? To understand why our two-party electoral system leads to misinterpreting the extent of the mandate from a popular vote victory, here's an explanation: electionlawblog.org?p=148245
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"Should We Be Saying 'President Haley'?": The correct way to understand Trump’s popular vote victory is to understand that it represents a mandate to the extent, but only to the extent, that Nikki Haley would be pursuing the same agenda. open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/should-we-be-saying-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Should We Be Saying “President Haley”? electionlawblog.org?p=148245
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If our electoral system worked, it would be President Haley: democracyjournal.org/arguments/should-we-be-saying-presid…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“The Real Preference of the Voters”: in this essay I discuss Madison's letter that's essential to understand if we are to repair our currently broken Madisonian democracy. Discovering the significance of this letter has been gratifying scholarly work. open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/the-real-preference-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I've posted "'The Real Preference of the Voters': Madison's Idea of a Top-Three Election and The Present Necessity of Reform" (forthcoming Wisc L Rev), discussing a letter written by Madison the significance of which has not been previously appreciated. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5097563
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Is PR the panacea? Proportional representation isn't reform that would work for Senate and presidential elections, both of which need reforming as much as House of Representatives elections. open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/is-pr-the-panacea?r=…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Is PR the panacea? electionlawblog.org?p=148151
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The threat of being primaried isn't purely ideological; it's about enforcing loyalty to the leader of the MAGA party: "Trump threatens primary against Texas conservative Chip Roy" thehill.com/homenews/campaign/5049317-donald-trump-chip-r…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
A key quote from this: "You sit down with Republican senators and one thing that comes through—they are absolutely terrified of a primary challenge."
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I've really enjoyed my year so far as a Crane Fellow in Law & Public Policy at Princeton. Can't believe 1st semester is over already. I encourage others to apply for this fellowship for lots of reasons (too many to list; Princeton is great). Deadline 1/1: plaw.law.princeton.edu/opportunities/crane-fellowship-law…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Really looking forward to this event tomorrow, and the book it discusses, which has been 3+ years in the making (it's possible to participate both online and in person): www.aei.org/events/electoral-reform-in-the-united-states-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Very honored to be co-editors with @LarryDiamond & @RickPildes on this new book--and to work with all the authors of its chapters: @leedrutman, Rob Boatright, Frances Lee, @raylaraja, all of whom will be discussing the book at this event on Tuesday: www.aei.org/events/electoral-reform-in-the-united-states-….
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Just received the advance copy of the book that we will be discussing on Tuesday, as detailed here: www.aei.org/events/electoral-reform-in-the-united-states-…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
Book launch next week at AEI for our book, Electoral Reform In the US: Proposals for Combatting Polarization and Extremism. My co-editors are @LarryDiamond and @Nedfoley.
With contributions from more than 30 expert political scientists, law professors, and others. A link to the event is in the reply.
@nyulaw -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Book event in DC & online: “Electoral Reform in the United States: Proposals for Combating Polarization and Extremism” electionlawblog.org?p=147499
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Trump’s Nominees Confirm the Need for Electoral Reform open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/trumps-nominees-conf…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
As @RickPildes says, @MattGrossmann's data is key. It's why a Condorcet Voting system is necessary; otherwise, a MAGA candidate can be closer to the median voter than the Democrat. But the electorate would have preferred a third candidate between those 2: edwardbfoley.substack.com/p/the-case-for-condorcet-voting-is
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
Whether voters' perceptions are correct or not, this data from MI shows that voters perceived Harris as further to the left of Biden, to the left of the D's successful Senate candidate, and further from the median voter's ideological location than was DJT.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The media should not overstate the important of Trump to his own victory. Given Biden's unpopularity, transferred to Harris because she is his VP, other GOP candidates would've won and with higher margins. For more: edwardbfoley.substack.com/p/the-case-for-condorcet-voting-is
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"The Case for Condorcet Voting Is Clear": this essay explains the need for the type of electoral reform that will actually elect the kind of candidate a majority of Americans would prefer to either major-party nominee; it's how best to protect democracy. open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/the-case-for-condorc…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Julie Tsirkin
@news_jul
PA’s Cambria County extended voting until 10pm today due to technical issues with machines >>
Carter Walker
@ByCarterWalker
Voting has been extended in Cambria County
-
Ned Foley reposted
MIT Election Lab
@MITelectionlab
A provisional ballot is a fail-safe measure intended to provide protection for voters when there are questions about their registration status on Election Day. How do these ballots work? Here's our explainer on it: electionlab.mit.edu/research/provisional-ballots
-
Ned Foley reposted
Cameron Joseph
@cam_joseph
@Nedfoley on the Electoral Count Reform Act: "The whole approach of ECRA is to basically say that the rule of law controls the outcome, and that politicians can’t subvert the outcome just because they don’t like it."
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"Any Other Republican Would Be Running Away With This" www.nytimes.com/2024/11/04/opinion/trump-harris-inflation… The truth of the above headline for @nytopinion essay by @mattyglesias is why I stress the need for electoral reform that would let voters elect their most preferred candidate: edwardbfoley.substack.com/p/the-ongoing-relevance-of-elec…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The Ongoing Relevance of Electoral Reform: Whatever the outcome of this year's presidential election, there will be the continuing need to adopt major structural reform of the nation's electoral system. open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/the-ongoing-relevanc…
-
Ned Foley reposted
The Road to Now
@Road_To_Now
🎙Edward Foley @Nedfoley explains the origins of the electoral college, how and why the 12th Amendment changed the process for electing Presidents, and the concerns that led Congress to codify the procedure for counting electors’ votes in 1887.
▶️ rtnpod.me/listen -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Everyone should read @RickPildes on the electoral reform measures on the ballot in various states this year. Tuesday is a major moment in the effort at electoral reform to make American democracy better reflect what a majority of voters want: open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/rick-pildes-on-the-i…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
One Electoral Method is Inferior to Others When Voters Are Deeply Divided open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/one-electoral-method…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Electing a Single Winner When the Electorate is Divided in Multiple Ways open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/electing-a-single-wi…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Check out the new "Law and Democracy" podcast: @lawanddemocracypod
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/law-and-democracy-po… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The Possibility of Majority Winners When Politics is Multidimensional open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/the-possibility-of-m…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Why Majority-Preferred Candidates Should Win Single-Seat Elections open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/why-majority-preferr…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"The State of Election System Reform in 2024" open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/the-state-of-electio…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“The State of Election System Reform in 2024” electionlawblog.org?p=145857
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Webinar: “The State of Election System Reform in 2024” open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/webinar-the-state-of…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Jason Willick
@jawillick
Really persuasive debunking of the "Seal Team Six" scenario under the Roberts immunity framework. From @Nedfoley
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/don-t-overread-the-court-s-i… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Agree. Convergence Voting is for statewide offices, like governor or US senator: ssrn.com/abstract=4488662. My Self-Districting plan, for US House & state legislative elections, would create multi-party electoral competition to represent various groups:
ssrn.com/abstract=4328642
Magnus Jonsson
@jmagnusj
Convergence voting seems fine for executive elections.
For representative elections I’d like to see a greater role for (multiple) parties representing many varied interests. -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"Fusion or Super-Fusion?: What Institutional Reform Would Most Depolarize Politics?" This essay compares 2 proposals to address the ills of America's current electoral system. You decide, after reading its analysis, which one states like Ohio should pick: open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/fusion-or-super-fusi…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
So pleased that @johncfortier1 & @VotingGuy are devoting an episode of their Voting Booth podcast to this event:
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"Ballot Battles" book event: I think this will be a really great conversation on an important topic at a crucial time. open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/ballot-battles-book-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"Ballot Battles" book event: I think this will be a really great conversation on an important topic at a crucial time. open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/ballot-battles-book-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Really looking forward to this event. The new edition of Ballot Ballots brings the history of disputed elections in the US up-to-date by including a discussion of 2020 and revising the book in light of that fight. Understanding this history is necessary preparation for this year.
John C. Fortier
@johncfortier1
Join @VotingGuy and @johncfortier1 in person or virtually for a live audience Voting Booth podcast at @AEI July 15 10 am
@Nedfoley to discuss new edition of Ballot Battles book
www.aei.org/events/ballot-battles-a-book-event-and-live-p… -
Ned Foley reposted
John C. Fortier
@johncfortier1
Join @VotingGuy and @johncfortier1 in person or virtually for a live audience Voting Booth podcast at @AEI July 15 10 am
@Nedfoley to discuss new edition of Ballot Battles book
www.aei.org/events/ballot-battles-a-book-event-and-live-p… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Happy Fourth of July! If you'd like to read today something related to the current electoral process unfolding in our democracy, here's one piece (among the zillions available): "If Harris replaces Biden, who should run with Harris?" open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/if-harris-replaces-b…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Presidential Immunity and Partisan Primaries open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/presidential-immunit…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Given that the first round of the French legislative elections are today, I thought it might be useful to recirculate this essay: "France's 'snap' legislative elections are a warning" open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/frances-snap-legisla…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Princeton P*LAW
Congrats to incoming P*LAW Fellow @Nedfoley on the publication of the latest edition of his essential book, Ballot Battles: The History of Disputed Elections in the United States.
Couldn’t be more timely…
global.oup.com/academic/product/ballot-battles-9780197775… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Reminder: Wednesday webinar on electoral reform electionlawblog.org?p=143998
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
France's "snap" legislative elections are a warning open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/frances-snap-legisla…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
New edition of BALLOT BATTLES open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/new-edition-of-ballo…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I'm very pleased to be part of this webinar that Election Law at Ohio State is hosting: open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/webinar-on-structura…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Top-3 Voting: Video Version open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/top-3-voting-video-v…
-
Ned Foley reposted
MarianWCates
@CatesMw
An oldie but still very relevant @thedispatch pod: How Do You Solve A Problem Like Primaries. Very interesting. @whignewtons interviews @Nedfoley & @NickTroiano, who are specialists in this area. open.spotify.com/episode/4nBdufEOeGxo4nSjB2eeky
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Self-Districting Solves the Problem of the Supreme Court’s South Carolina Case: If voters can choose the legislative districts they are in, then there is no need for courts to grapple with the problem of how states handle the role of race in districting. open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/self-districting-sol…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Washington Post Opinions
@PostOpinions
"Traditional Republican senators are becoming extinct," @Nedfoley writes.
If former senators William Cohen, John Danforth and Alan Simpson need evidence from outside the Senate, Nikki Haley proved this point. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/05/21/reforming-repu… -
Ned Foley reposted
Nick Troiano
@NickTroiano
Huge! Congrats to South Dakota!
South Dakota Open Primaries
@sdopenprimaries
We made the ballot!!! South Dakota voters will be voting on top two open primaries in November. #southdakota #openprimaries #letusvote #sdpol
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
As a regular viewer (and big fan) of the PBS NewsHour, I'm very pleased to have had this opportunity:
PBS News
@NewsHour
The legal fallout from alleged efforts to overturn the results of the 2020 presidential election continued in Arizona.
Rudy Giuliani and 11 other allies of former President Trump pleaded not guilty to charges that include conspiracy, fraud and forgery.
@Nedfoley explains.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Democrats and “Traditional” Republicans Must Unite This Year open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/democrats-and-tradit…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"Virtue and Institutions," an essay on why civic virtue isn't enough and we must adopt institutional change to protect democracy (as Rick Pildes argues) and to bring our Madisonian system back into equilibrium.
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/virtue-and-instituti… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Reflections on Oral Argument in the Trump Immunity Case electionlawblog.org?p=142734
-
Ned Foley reposted
Jeff Jenkins
@jaj7d
We need some new congressional (party) theory. We’ve needed this for a while. Maybe existing theories can be tweaked, but here’s where some meaningful work can be done. www.politico.com/live-updates/2024/04/17/congress/all-eye…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Nicholas Stephanopoulos
@ProfNickStephan
I wrote this blog post on the Third Circuit's county line ruling. It's a big deal legally, not just politically!
It limits parties' ability to organize primaries however they want. It recognizes a policy's disparate electoral effects as a severe burden.
electionlawblog.org?p=142526 -
Ned Foley reposted
Florida Law Review
@FloridaLawRev
Today is the day! Zoom registration is still open via the following link: linktr.ee/FLRSymposium
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Changing the Rules in order to Win: Nebraska shows why reforming the procedures for presidential elections is so urgently needed.
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/changing-the-rules-i… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Important:
Nick Troiano
@NickTroiano
When voters are given the freedom to vote for any candidate in every election, regardless of party… they exercise it!
A great analysis on the impact of primary reform in Alaska via @Sightline:
alaskabeacon.com/2024/04/03/nonpartisan-open-primaries-le… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
To Work in Ohio, Alaska's "Final Four" Electoral System Needs Modification open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/to-work-in-ohio-alas…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Charles Stewart III
@cstewartiii
The Elections Performance Index has just been updated to reflect the 2022 election. Check it out. @MITelectionlab elections.mit.edu
-
Ned Foley reposted
The Ohio State University Moritz College of Law
@OhioStateLaw
Our @OSU_Law faculty presented at the Junior Scholars Conference at @NUSL! From #constitutionallaw to #intellectualproperty, they showcased their expertise and in-progress scholarly work. Great job to Assistant Professors @BridgetDooling, Blaine Saito, and Rebecca Wolitz!
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Great conversation:
John C. Fortier
@johncfortier1
@Nedfoley joins the Voting Booth podcast on #trumpvanderson decision. @VotingGuy @derektmuller @rickhasen @ElectionLawBlog
open.spotify.com/show/3fNciamtofkcbpjQotD4BJ -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Ohio Should Embrace Common Ground Democracy: Ohio’s U.S. Senate race this year, as in 2022, illustrates how the current electoral system causes the defeat of the candidate whom a majority of voters prefer to each other candidate in the race.
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/ohio-should-embrace-… -
Ned Foley reposted
Elections Research Center
@ElectionsCenter
Did you miss our latest event? Election experts @Nedfoley, Alice Miller, @RachelOrey, @MindySRomero, and @bcburden discussed the challenges of administering the 2024 Election and possible solutions. Hear what they had to say in our panel recording ⬇
📽 youtu.be/nJS0dwjnBW0 -
Ned Foley reposted
Hyemin
@hyeminjhan
"How did the Court leave the nation—and Congress—in such uncertainty over this crucial question?"
@Nedfoley on ambiguities left by SCOTUS's Trump disqualification decision and what that could mean for Congress's joint session on Jan. 6, 2025: www.lawfaremedia.org/article/can-congress-disqualify-trum… -
Ned Foley reposted
Make Elections Fair AZ
@MakeAZFair
"One of the most promising—and exciting—efforts at electoral reform in the United States right now is underway in Arizona. It needs to be more widely known—and supported—around the country as well as in its own state." He's talking about @MakeAZFair! 😊Thank you for the kind words @Nedfoley!
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Everyone interested in improving democracy in the US should spread the word about this important electoral reform effort underway in Arizona:
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/arizonas-especially-… -
Ned Foley reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
What does the Supreme Court’s ruling in Trump v. Anderson mean for Congress’s ability to disqualify Trump?
@Nedfoley analyzes two possible interpretations of the Supreme Court's dueling opinions in Trump v. Anderson. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/can-congress-disqualify-trum… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Everyone interested in improving democracy in the US should spread the word about this important electoral reform effort underway in Arizona:
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/arizonas-especially-… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Too bad this article doesn’t mention that electoral reform would have enabled Sinema to run a competitive centrist campaign in a 3-way Senate race, rather than having to drop out & leave her supporters feeling without a home in a polarized 2-party race: substack.com/profile/36574499-edward-b-foley/note/c-51534…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This was a great discussion. I was very glad to be a part of it.
Lawfare
@lawfare
On Mar 4, SCOTUS ruled that states cannot disqualify Donald Trump from appearing on the presidential ballot under the 14th Amd.
On today's Lawfare Podcast, @qjurecic spoke with @rparloff, @Nedfoley, and @GerardNMagliocc to make sense of the Court’s ruling. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-lawfare-podcast-unpackin… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
More evidence why “Common Ground Democracy” electoral reform is needed, to avoid the “primary problem” (@NickTroiano) & solve the governance crisis in Congress (@RickPildes); in red districts it matters which kind of Republican wins: www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2024/03/06/super-tuesday-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Super Tuesday Was Not So Super for November’s Voters: The consequences of the nation’s two-party system is vividly on display with the elimination of Kyrsten Sinema and Nikki Haley from their respective races. open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/super-tuesday-was-no…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Super Tuesday Was Not So Super for November’s Voters electionlawblog.org?p=141863
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I highly recommend listening to Chuck Todd’s podcast with Nick Troiano; they discuss Nick’s important new book “The Primary Solution,” and among other valuable points Nick makes is that partisan primaries actually hurt political parties:
substack.com/profile/36574499-edward-b-foley/note/c-50736718 -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If you read one thing about the structural problem afflicting American elections, including an explanation of the institutional reform most likely to remedy the problem, make it this new analysis. A Must-Read Analysis of Why U.S. Elections Aren't Working:
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/a-must-read-analysis… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Happy President's Day! Here's an idea to improve the process of presidential elections and to enable a majority of Americans to elect the candidate they most prefer:
edwardbfoley.substack.com/p/a-top-3-presidential-election… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Happy President's Day! Just in time for the holiday, I've drafted a new essay applying the Top-3 electoral system that Eric Maskin & I have advocated for congressional elections to presidential elections as well:
electionlawblog.org?p=141516 -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
A Top-3 Presidential Election System open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/a-top-3-presidential…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Check out this article: www.cnn.com/2024/02/13/politics/supreme-courts-easy-out-o…
-
Ned Foley reposted
James Carroll
@JamesCarrollRK
America's problematic first-past-the-post voting system was devised in the Middle Ages. There are now many superior modern alternatives that state legislatures can easily implement. Here's one:
www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/top-three-election-s…
@Nedfoley @ProSyn
www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/top-three-election-s… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Here's a cure for the dysfunctional Congress, which is incapable of legislating on behalf of the public because the voting system used to elect its members produces hyper-polarization rather than accurate representation of the electorate's preferences:
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/a-top-three-version-… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The justices seem ready to leave the issue of Donald Trump’s eligibility up to Congress. Here’s why they shouldn’t. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/02/supreme-court-c…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Project Syndicate
@ProSyn
With "top-three" voting, Trumpists like @JDVance1 would not be able to exploit a flawed system to oust popular incumbents like @senrobportman, write @Nedfoley and Eric S. Maskin. www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/top-three-election-s…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The justices seem ready to leave the issue of Donald Trump’s eligibility up to Congress. Here’s why they shouldn’t. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2024/02/supreme-court-c…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Project Syndicate
@ProSyn
Ranked-choice voting has gradually been gaining more attention, and for good reason. But a "top-three" system is even better, @Nedfoley and Eric S. Maskin explain. www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/top-three-election-s…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“How to Depolarize American Politics” electionlawblog.org?p=141323
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Eric Maskin and I have co-authored this column describing a simple electoral system to combat partisan polarization: @ProSyn prosyn.org/Lprv3gm
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Conversation on Colorado Case electionlawblog.org?p=141178
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Collapse of Border Bill Proves Need for Electoral Reform open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/collapse-of-border-b…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Susan R. Johnson | ThrivingAmidstChaos! + WBB fan
@srjohnson007
Great explanation of the meaning and significance of the D.C. Circuit's decision. The law matters. Read it!
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Quick note on D.C. Circuit’s rejection of Trump’s immunity claim electionlawblog.org?p=141130
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Quick note on D.C. Circuit’s rejection of Trump’s immunity claim electionlawblog.org?p=141130
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Trump’s reply brief is inconsistent with the original history relating to enforcement of the Fourteenth Amendment's disqualification provision. electionlawblog.org?p=141103
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/2 In addition to all the good arguments made by @WilliamBaude & Michael Paulsen about why the argument that section 3 is undemocratic is unsound, there is the additional point that because of how partisan primaries distort electoral choice, disqualifying Trump would enable ...
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
The Objection that Enforcing Section Three is "Undemocratic" reason.com/volokh/2024/02/03/the-objection-that-enforcing…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/2 ... a majority of general election voters to elect the candidate whom, according to the polls, they most prefer: edwardbfoley.substack.com/p/disqualifying-trump-might-enable
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The concluding chapter to the new edition of BALLOT BATTLES contains a new section assessing the implications of Trump's attack on the outcome of the 2020 election in relationship to the rest of the nation's historical experience with disputes over election outcomes:
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The new chapter of BALLOT BATTLES delivers a mixed verdict on Mike Pence (there are several more paragraphs of analysis on Pence's role between December 14 and January 6 following this one):
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I'm very pleased to be proofreading the page proofs for the second edition of BALLOT BATTLES, coming out later this year, including an all-new chapter on post-2016 events:
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
New amicus brief in SCOTUS case on Trump &s3 is relevant to issue discussed by @chucktodd & @rickhasen: what if ineligible candidate whom states lets on the ballot wins? The brief seems to argue that Congress must let this person serve. Is this right?:
electionlawblog.org?p=141040 -
Ned Foley reposted
James Carroll
@JamesCarrollRK
Here's an interesting idea for presidential elections that is familiar to many Americans, intuitive, and wouldn't require a constitutional amendment to implement.
edwardbfoley.substack.com/p/presidential-elections-surviv…
@Nedfoley
edwardbfoley.substack.com/p/presidential-elections-surviv… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
As this year’s presidential elections develops, which is heading to the Biden-Trump rematch that most Americans don’t want, we should be thinking imaginatively of better ways to elect a president. Here's one idea to consider, based on a familiar format:
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/presidential-electio… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Presidential Elections, "Survivor"-style: Could the format of a television show solve the problem of partisan polarization and avoid presidential elections being a match between two candidates most voters would prefer not to be in contention? For more:
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/presidential-electio… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Presidential Elections, “Survivor”-style electionlawblog.org?p=141014
-
Ned Foley reposted
Univ. of Arizona Law
@uarizonalaw
ICYMI: The Rehnquist Center will host a special lecture "Trump's Eligibility for Reelection: What Will the Supreme Court Decide?" a conversation between Professors @Nedfoley and Andrew Coan on February 5.
Register ▶️ law.arizona.edu/news/2024/01/professor-edward-b-foley-dis… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
More confirmation of the need for the media to educate the public on the need for electoral reform: “No Labels director doubles down on 3rd-party ticket after New Hampshire” electionlawblog.org?p=140941
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I'm looking forward to this!
Univ. of Arizona Law
@uarizonalaw
EVENT: The Rehnquist Center will host a special lecture "Trump's Eligibility for Reelection: What Will the Supreme Court Decide?" a conversation between Professors @Nedfoley and Andrew Coan on February 5.
Register ▶️ law.arizona.edu/news/2024/01/professor-edward-b-foley-dis… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This analysis holds up after the NH results: Haley is "a third-party candidate stuck in a two-party system." Whether Haley or someone else is No Label's nominee, assuming No Labels does run a ticket, that looms as the most important factor in November. open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/haleys-campaign-demo…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If you've read all the stories saying that the GOP primary is over because Haley can't win, perhaps you agree it would be nice if those stories would point out that her inability to win is a function of the existing electoral system, not her unpopularity:
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/haleys-campaign-demo… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I hope as part of covering the NH primary over the next few days, the media can devote some attention to this key point: "Haley’s Campaign Demonstrates the Need for Electoral Reform"; the third-party race she's running can't work in a two-party system.
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/haleys-campaign-demo… -
Ned Foley reposted
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
#elb: “Haley’s Campaign Demonstrates the Need for Electoral Reform” electionlawblog.org?p=140844
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"Nothing could be more obvious watching Nikki Haley run against Donald Trump in the week between the Iowa caucuses and the New Hampshire primary: she’s a third-party candidate stuck in a two-party system." For more, read:
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/haleys-campaign-demo… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
New "Common Ground Democracy" column by @nedfoley: Haley’s Campaign Demonstrates the Need for Electoral Reform--She can’t win in the current system although she’s the candidate a majority of America’s voters would prefer to either Biden or Trump.
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/haleys-campaign-demo… -
Ned Foley reposted
Juliya
@Grace469818
Cheers to Michael Kimberly and Charles Seidell! 🌟👏 Pro bono superheroes fighting the good fight! 🦸♂️✨ You guys deserve a cape and a sidekick named Justice! 🦸♀️🌈
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Aboslutely!!!
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
Shout out to Michael Kimberly and Charles Seidell of the McDermott firm for their excellent pro bono work on this brief.
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
Ned Foley-Ben Ginsberg-Rick Hasen Amicus Brief Warns SCOTUS of Political Instability, Potential Violence, and Voter Disenfranchisement If It Avoids Deciding Merits in Trump Disqualification Case electionlawblog.org?p=140813
-
Ned Foley reposted
David Becker
@beckerdavidj
This an outstanding, comprehensive brief from election law experts @rickhasen, @Nedfoley, and Ben Ginsberg making the key argument that SCOTUS can and must resolve the question of Trump's qualification to serve as POTUS, one way or the other, on the merits, ASAP.
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
Ned Foley-Ben Ginsberg-Rick Hasen Amicus Brief Warns SCOTUS of Political Instability, Potential Violence, and Voter Disenfranchisement If It Avoids Deciding Merits in Trump Disqualification Case electionlawblog.org?p=140813
-
Ned Foley reposted
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
#elb: Ned Foley-Ben Ginsberg-Rick Hasen Amicus Brief Warns SCOTUS of Political Instability, Potential Violence, and Voter Disenfranchisement If It Avoids Deciding Merits in Trump Disqualification Case electionlawblog.org?p=140813
-
Ned Foley reposted
Nick Riccardi
@NickRiccardi
Provocative historical thought experiment by @Nedfoley that becomes highly relevant with Trump's 14th Amendment case at SCOTUS papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4695953
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Some history that's germane to the pending SCOTUS case from Colorado on whether or not Trump is constitutionally disqualified to serve as president again: "1868 and 2024: The Relevance of the Past to the Present" electionlawblog.org?p=140786
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I think this is an appropriate message for MLK Day: Don’t Despair—Mobilize for Institutional Change open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/dont-despairmobilize…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Don’t Despair—Mobilize for Institutional Change electionlawblog.org?p=140767
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Don’t Despair—Mobilize for Institutional Change. Even smart scholars think nothing can be done to solve the problem of polarization, but they’re unduly pessimistic: there are institutional reforms that would work if we muster the will to adopt them.
open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/dont-despairmobilize… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
5 ways the Supreme Court may try to defuse its newest Trump bomb www.politico.com/news/2024/01/08/trump-supreme-court-ball… via @politico
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is fantastic news. @RickPildes is indeed the leading intellectual trailblazer of our election law field. For all of us who have been so influenced by Ely's Democracy and Distrust & related work, this recognition is especially meaningful & appropriate. Many congratulations!!!
Nicholas Stephanopoulos
@ProfNickStephan
I’m delighted to see the most important and influential election law scholar recognized for his pathbreaking contributions to the field.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
As we continue to learn details of 1/6, we should make sure we learn the lesson of that terrible day: it's necessary to adopt structural reforms of the electoral process so that a minority party cannot prevail and then use its power to repudiate elections
edwardbfoley.substack.com/p/learning-the-lesson-of-january-6
Jonathan Karl
@jonkarl
Big exclusive coming this morning on @ThisWeekABC on what our sources say Trump’s inner circle, including Dan Scavino, has told federal investigators about Trump’s “unsettling” behavior inside the White House on Jan 6.
@KFaulders and I will discuss with @GStephanopoulos on This Week. -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Learning the Lesson of January 6: there is the need for structural reform that will enable the will of the majority to prevail in elections, rather than the will of a minority faction that is willing to overturn elections that they lose: electionlawblog.org?p=140652
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Learning the Lesson of January 6: Hopefully, after this year's elections, America will get another chance to adopt the structural reforms necessary to assure that elections produce the results that a majority of voters want. open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/learning-the-lesson-…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Susan R. Johnson | ThrivingAmidstChaos! + WBB fan
@srjohnson007
Jamie is right! And, you can transform the idea into a New Year's project: Go through all your lists, and delete, delete, delete. I've been doing it this week, and it is very energizing!
Jamie Miles
@JamoeMills
My first thoughts when being productive is a rhyme:
"The easiest task to complete?
The one you can delete." -
Ned Foley reposted
Kyle Cheney
@kyledcheney
BREAKING: The Supreme Court has agreed to consider Colorado’s decision to deem Trump ineligible to run under the Constitution’s insurrection clause.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Merits issues versus procedural issues in Trump’s cert petition electionlawblog.org?p=140604
-
Ned Foley reposted
The Ohio State University Moritz College of Law
@OhioStateLaw
Prof. Ned Foley, director of election law at #ohiostatelaw, shares insights on the Supreme Court's potential moves following the unprecedented Colorado ruling disqualifying Trump from the 2024 Colorado ballot.
#electionlaw #election2024
video.snapstream.net/Play/HTOZvvQJTCElE8mzaiTPP?accessTok… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This point is absolutely key, which is why the #primaryproblem will be one of the main issues of focus in Common Ground Democracy, edwardbfoley.substack.com. Please subscribe (it's free) if you'd like to follow its discussion of this and related topics concerning democratic choice.
Ross Sherman
@rossbsherman
Important context when discussing the "success" of election deniers from @NickRiccardi: "Election deniers have been able to make gains in one area — offices where they simply have to win a Republican primary." #primaryproblem apnews.com/article/democracy-threats-trump-2024-election-…
-
Ned Foley reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
An underappreciated observation from @nedfoley:
Disqualifying Trump Might Enable Americans to Elect the Candidate They Most Prefer open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/disqualifying-trump-… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"[T]he election should be decided by the voters," said @TheView host @sarahaines. True but incomplete. Elections are path-dependent: outcome depends on the rules. Disqualifying Trump might let Nov. voters elect who they want more: edwardbfoley.substack.com/p/disqualifying-trump-might-enable
thehill.com/homenews/campaign/4385869-view-host-says-trum… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"We’re just opposed to her taking away the rights of the voters to be able to choose the leader that they want to vote for or not,” Maine's GOP chair said about Trump case. But this argument misses the point, as explained here:
edwardbfoley.substack.com/p/disqualifying-trump-might-enable
thehill.com/homenews/campaign/4385987-cnn-anchor-gop-gues… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Democracy & Disqualification: Disqualifying Trump Might Enable Americans to Elect the Candidate They Most Prefer; voters in November might prefer to elect a Republican, like Haley, who can't beat Trump in the GOP primary. Democracy is path-dependent:
electionlawblog.org?p=140546 -
Ned Foley reposted
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
#elb: Democracy and Disqualification electionlawblog.org?p=140546
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Disqualifying Trump Might Enable Americans to Elect the Candidate They Most Prefer--Voters in November might prefer to elect a Republican, like Haley, who can't beat Trump in the GOP primary:
edwardbfoley.substack.com?r=lrx2b -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
SCOTUS Should Say Now if Trump Can Serve Again (so the issue doesn’t return to Congress after the election) electionlawblog.org?p=140514
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
At 'Common Ground Democracy' I've got a new column on why it's better for the Court to decide now the issue of Trump's eligibility to be president again, rather than leaving the issue open for Congress to consider after the election if he wins: open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/the-court-should-dec…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The Court Should Decide Now if Trump Can Serve Again open.substack.com/pub/edwardbfoley/p/the-court-should-dec…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Please check it out and subscribe: Common Ground Democracy electionlawblog.org?p=140504
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
With the imminent arrival of 2024, I've started a Substack: Common Ground Democracy. Please subscribe (it's free). I hope you enjoy its content, as it explores ways to improve elections to maximize the consent of the governed (see "About" page for more): edwardbfoley.substack.com?r=lrx2b
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Yes, this a key point. Partisan primaries are the biggest single problem affecting the nation’s electoral system, causing misalignment (to use @ProfNickStephan’s term) between the electorate’s preferences and the results of elections. This type of reform should be a top priority.
Nick Troiano
@NickTroiano
Boebert got into office by primarying a GOP incumbent. Now she’ll likely stay in office by moving to a district where the primary is the only contest that matters.
Hence why CO should adopt an all-candidate/nonpartisan primary and empower a true majority of voters to decide. -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The point about Obama is important and, unfortunately, often overlooked in the context of discussions about 14th Amendment disqualification.
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
I get claims that the 14th Amendment disqualification case is anti-democratic, but I think it's really more about the weakness of the argument than it being anti-democratic per se. If the Constitution didn't place limits on who could run, Obama would run again—and likely win.
-
Ned Foley reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
I get claims that the 14th Amendment disqualification case is anti-democratic, but I think it's really more about the weakness of the argument than it being anti-democratic per se. If the Constitution didn't place limits on who could run, Obama would run again—and likely win.
-
Ned Foley reposted
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
@demchiefexecpod has its first 3 Season 2 episodes up: On the electoral college (with Alex Keyssar and @Nedfoley), political polling (with @geoffgarin and @WhitAyres), and candidate selection (with Elaine Kamarck and @RickPildes, with a preview below). Enjoy!
-
Ned Foley reposted
The Ohio State University Moritz College of Law
@OhioStateLaw
Excited to announce Terri L. Enns' Investiture as the James W. Shocknessy Professor of Law! Terri's dedication to student growth in the Legislation Clinic and contributions to the legal field inspire us all. Congratulations, Terri! #ohiostatelaw #moritzlawstars
-
Ned Foley reposted
MIT Election Lab
@MITelectionlab
Today we are delighted to launch SEVEN new white papers assessing the current state of knowledge and practice in seven key areas of election administration. Find it all at electionlab.mit.edu/research/projects/mapping-election-sc…
electionline
@electionline
In the newser this week, new resources from @MITelectionlab's Mapping Election Administration and Election Science initiative. That, plus so much more election news and info: electionline.org/electionline-weekly/2023/10-26/
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Great metaphor from @_justinlevitt_ in a valuable summary of this case from @miwine: '“It’s not in the center of the strike zone, but it’s not a wild pitch, either,” he said. “The context in this is everything.”'
www.nytimes.com/2023/10/26/us/voter-fraud-trial-georgia.h… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Very useful summary of pending cases on this extremely important issue, by @patrickdmarley www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/10/27/trump-14th-ame…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The election of "MAGA Mike" as Speaker of the House proves the need to eliminate partisan primaries, as I explain here: electionlawblog.org?p=139371. Arizona's CD2 illustrates this: MAGA winner of GOP primary blocks voters in November from electing non-MAGA Republican they'd prefer:
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
A Simple Cure for House Chaos electionlawblog.org?p=139008
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is a great piece by @rickhasen. Spot on in my view. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/09/supreme-court-n…
-
Ned Foley reposted
-
Ned Foley reposted
AEI Economics
@AEIecon
In a forthcoming paper in @IllinoisLR, @AEI’s @scganz, with @WisconsinLaw's Nathan Atkinson and @nedfoley of @OSU_Law, research the extent to which Instant Runoff Voting can fall short in mitigating the problem of political polarization.
Read below⬇️
www.aei.org/research-products/journal-publication/beyond-… -
Ned Foley reposted
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If states adopted laws awarding statewide office (including presidential electors) to candidates supported by actual majorities—e.g., through runoffs or ranked-choice voting—3d parties could offer voters a range of platforms to support w/o causing minority rule. H/t @Nedfoley
-
Ned Foley reposted
MS NOW Reports
@MSNOW_Reports
“The key point is timing. This needs to be resolved before the election. Not afterwards. If he ends up on the ballot in November of next year…I think it would be a real constitutional crisis,” says @Nedfoley on legal theories about Trump's eligibility to run for president.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Ned Foley reposted
Michael Smerconish
@smerconish
Two law professors contend Donald Trump is ineligible to run for president due to the 14th amendment. Law Professor Edward Foley says, though legally difficult to determine, "it's essential to do this before the election, rather than afterwards." www.cnn.com/videos/politics/2023/08/19/smr-trump-ineligib…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I like the new title of this piece; it captures where the focus should be: "Forget the Trump trials. He might already be ineligible for 2024." www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/08/15/trump-ineligib… Even if Trump is convicted on the new Georgia charges, he could still be president unless disqualified this way:
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
One state can make the Supreme Court decide if Trump can be president www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/08/15/trump-ineligib…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Yes indeed!!!
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
Fantastic news for USC and for you. Congratulations!
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
These were my great-great-grandparents as well (mother's mother's mother's parents): www.nytimes.com/2023/06/21/us/wendy-stockton-rush-titanic…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Given today's consternation over DOJ's delay in pursuing 1/6 charges against Trump, electionlawblog.org?p=136938, it's worth recalling that Congress could have required DOJ to pursue disqualification of Trump under 14th Amendment, sec.3, as I urged on 10/14/21: electionlawblog.org?p=125256
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Given all the discussion about whether DOJ should prosecute Trump and for what, the historical comparison of Trump to the indictment and disqualification of Lincoln's 1860 opponent is worth considering: "John C. Breckinridge and … Donald J. Trump" electionlawblog.org?p=136950
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Today's SCOTUS ruling in Allen v. Milligan, Alabama's redistricting case, is a hugely important development, for both the Voting Rights Act and SCOTUS more broadly. It shows that Roberts & Kavanaugh are open to moderation in some key cases, whereas 4 others to their right aren't.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Great recognition for a great colleague:
Patti Zettler
@pzettler
I'm *beyond* honored to be named a 2023 @OhioState Early Career Distinguished Scholar.
HUGE thx to @OSU_Law, @OSULawDEPC & @OSUCCC_James, my colleagues & all my fantastic collaborators. Too much gratitude for tweet thread (at least for my capabilities on a Fri PM!) -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I'm very pleased and honored to be a co-author with Nate Atkinson and Scott Ganz on this new paper: “Beyond the Spoiler Effect: Can Ranked Choice Voting Solve the Problem of Political Polarization?” electionlawblog.org?p=135548
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I'm thrilled and honored to receive this support for work on how majority rule fits within America's constitutional system of judicially protected fundamental rights, federalism, and separation of powers, and how innovations in majority-winner elections can improve this fit.
GuggenheimFoundation
@GuggFellows
Congratulations to our 2023 Fellows in the Social Sciences! In their work, these scholars addressing topics like long Covid, majority rule in America, and reproductive rights. Read more at www.gf.org. #guggfellows2023
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I've posted on SSRN a paper entitled "Total Vote Runoff: A Majority-Maximizing Form of Ranked Choice Voting," ssrn.com/abstract=4328946, to be published by the University of New Hampshire Law Review, where it was presented at a symposium.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I've posted on SSRN this paper: SELF-DISTRICTING: The Ultimate Antidote to Gerrymandering, forthcoming Kentucky Law Journal. Here's the link: ssrn.com/abstract=4328642
-
Ned Foley reposted
Charles Stewart III
@cstewartiii
Here's Day # 3 analysis from @jaj7d and me on the speakership election, reflecting on the contest's historical context. We focus on plurality election, with a mention of secret balloting. Let's see what today brings on the House floor. broadstreet.blog/2023/01/05/back-to-the-future-day-3/
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Sinema easily would be among top 4 in Alaska-type nonpartisan primary. But would she win the instant runoff against both a D & R? She likely would be the Condorcet winner, so it might matter whether or not Arizona's version of RCV was Condorcet-compliant (like Total Vote Runoff).
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
If AZ had the Top-4 primary, RCV general election -- as in AK -- would Sen. Sinema still be a D? She might have concluded she could not survive a D primary but I assume she can get to the general election via signatures as an I.
@Rob_Richie @Nedfoley @leedrutman -
Ned Foley reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
Join us tonight (5PM East Coast) to hear @nedfoley @derektmuller @s_r_anders discuss Moore v. Harper.
x.com/i/spaces/1ynKOampWOEJR -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I concur with @RuthMarcus: "Trump’s call for suspending the Constitution is too dangerous to ignore." One point: his inability to suspend the Constitution if he's reelected depends on the Court's power to constrain a rogue president. See Nixon Tapes Case.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/12/04/ruth-marcus-do… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Pursuing election law from a nonpartisan belief that electoral competition should be fair to all candidates & parties, & arguing that opposition to Trump is nonpartisan because of his distinctive threat to constitutional democracy, I note his proof of this
www.nytimes.com/2022/12/04/us/politics/trump-constitution… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
6 minutes in, this interview has an inadequate response to Trump's call to suspend the Constitution. History shows that constitutions can't always protect themselves against elected leaders determined to negate the rule of law and to rule instead by fiat. abcnews.go.com/ThisWeek/video/trump-lot-things-itll-happe…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Useful analysis: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/11/18/gerrymandering…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Useful: “Why the AP hasn't called the Arizona governor's race | AP News” apnews.com/article/2022-midterm-elections-arizona-governo…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Make sure you read the final paragraph of this smart @ezraklein column (which provides the foundation for why after the midterms we continue to need to reform primary elections, because of how they exacerbate the combined effect of 3 trends he identifies): www.nytimes.com/2022/11/12/opinion/election-midterm-patte…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The ticket-splitting numbers at the end of this article are particularly interesting (and potentially important):
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/11/13/us/politics/senate… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Very smart analysis from @Yascha_Mounk www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/11/midterm-electio…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
PA: “RNC to challenge provisional ballots” electionlawblog.org?p=133021 Unless I'm missing something, one or the other ballot should count (obviously not both). It would be wrong to disqualify both ballots just because a mailed ballot with a fixable technical problem arrived on time.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I agree with @rickhasen here: "Thoughts on Last Night: A Step Back from the Precipice on Election Denialism and a Slightly Rosier Forecast for a Free and Fair Election in 2024" electionlawblog.org?p=133007
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“The math doesn’t add up” (as one candidate conceding defeat put it) is a succinct expression of election realism, which is the opposite of election denialism. The more we return to the acceptance of this basic point, the better off we are. www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/11/09/election-denie…
-
Ned Foley reposted
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
4 called Senate races were MAGA v DEM: NH, NC, OH, PA. They split 2-2: NH & PA for DEM; NC & OH for MAGA. Difference? NH & PA lean blue; NC & OH red. So red states are MAGA states unless electoral reform would show red-state voters preferring non-MAGA Republicans to win even more
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Will control of House of Representatives turn on uncertain, or even disputed, seats from California? I hope we don't need to relearn the lessons of the "Broad Seal War," where electing the new Speaker after the 1838 elections was held up because of fighting over several NJ seats.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
MAGA candidate beats Democrat here, like OH but unlike NH. So 2-1 for MAGA v Dem. But would non-MAGA Republican, Pat McCrory, who lost GOP primary in NC, also have won tonight? If so, can we say voters wanted MAGA candidates? Maybe non-MAGA Republicans would've won all 3 races?
NBC News
@NBCNews
BREAKING: Republican Ted Budd wins U.S. Senate race in North Carolina, NBC News projects. nbcnews.to/3WL4bBm
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Here's a race, opposite to NH, where a MAGA Republican defeats the Democrat. Would a non-MAGA Republican, like Matt Dolan, also have won? Or Portman, if he had run for reelection? Trump may claim victory, but maybe a non-Trump Republican would have won just as easily or even more
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is an example of a MAGA candidate who won the GOP primary losing the general election. Unclear whether or not the non-MAGA Republican, Chuck Morse, who was narrowly defeated in the GOP primary, would have done any better. Will other races, like Arizona governor, be similar?
Norah O'Donnell 🇺🇸
@NorahODonnell
MAJOR RACE CALL: Sen. Maggie Hassan wins in New Hampshire
-
Ned Foley reposted
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
Interesting
Kira Lerner
@kira_lerner
Arizona Republicans Kari Lake and Blake Masters, along with the Republican National Committee and the National Republican Senatorial Committee, filed a lawsuit late Tuesday against Maricopa County demanding that polling places remain open until 10 p.m. www.azmirror.com/2022/11/08/republicans-sue-for-extended-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"When can you expect results? Will some contests drag on for days, like the 2020 presidential election did? When will we know who won the Senate? I talked with a few experts about what to expect from this year’s Election Day," @mimbsy writes: www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/11/election-result…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The plan to save America by killing the partisan primary www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/23412858/nevada-question-… via @voxdotcom
-
Ned Foley reposted
MIT Election Lab
@MITelectionlab
Team MEDSL is ready to dive into the data from this #electionday! We’ll be here gathering as much as we can so we can continue to bring you nonpartisan, data-driven analysis in the days and weeks to come!
-
Ned Foley reposted
Stephen Richer
@stephen_richer
STATEMENT.
-
Ned Foley reposted
Josh Douglas
@JoshuaADouglas
Polling hours extended by 2 hours in a county in PA (which includes Wilkes-Barre).
Under federal law, ballots cast during these 2 extra hours must be provisional ballots.
John Kruzel
@johnkruzel
Judge extends voting hours in Luzerne County, Pennsylvania, after paper shortage thehill.com/homenews/campaign/3725562-judge-extends-votin…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Virginia Kase Solomon
@KaseVirginia
To be clear, elections aren’t certified on Election Day. It takes days and sometimes weeks to count all the votes. #electionresults
-
Ned Foley reposted
John Kruzel
@johnkruzel
Judge extends voting hours in Luzerne County, Pennsylvania, after paper shortage thehill.com/homenews/campaign/3725562-judge-extends-votin…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Josh Douglas
@JoshuaADouglas
Your regular PSA that Election Night results aren't a thing--at least legally.
Any vote totals tonight are *unofficial."
Vote totals "changing" is normal--it means they are counting ALL ballots.
Will Doran
@will_doran
We'll know tonight who probably won most #ncpol races. But if there are a couple that are too close to call, it could be days before we know.
This isn't some conspiracy theory. The state simply needs time to count all the votes before declaring who won. www.newsobserver.com/news/politics-government/election/ar… -
Ned Foley reposted
Maricopa County
@maricopacounty
.@maricopavote has identified the solution for the tabulation issues at about 60 Vote Centers. County technicians have changed the printer settings, which seems to have resolved this issue. It appears some of the printers were not producing dark enough timing marks on ballots. 1/
-
Ned Foley reposted
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
Based on conversations with people doing voter-protection work, we are so far not seeing significant problems with poll workers, poll watchers, challenges to voters, or similar problems at polling places. A few isolated incidents.
Still the end of the day rush to get through. -
Ned Foley reposted
Nick Corasaniti
@NYTnickc
A few days for PA results -->
David Catanese
@davecatanese
“We will not have unofficial results in Pennsylvania on Election Night and that’s a fact,” Leigh Chapman, Pennsylvania’s acting secretary of state, told @McClatchyDC in an interview.
“We’re expecting at least a few days for results to be final.”
www.mcclatchydc.com/news/politics-government/article26789… -
Ned Foley reposted
Jonathan Tamari
@JonathanTamari
Worth remembering: PAs GOP primary went through a lengthy recount and the winner wasn't decided until nearly 3 weeks later.
Both R candidates, including Oz, abided by that procedure and one sued to get more mail ballots counted -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“Philly vote count for 2022 midterm elections will be slower for poll book reconciliation” important development www.inquirer.com/politics/election/philadelphia-election-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“Fetterman sues over mail-in ballots | The Hill”. This is one to watch thehill.com/homenews/campaign/3724626-fetterman-sues-over…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"10th anniversary of “blue shift” research": when will enough voters who support candidates of both parties understand and accept the validity of 'blue shift' ballots, so that conspiracy theories about these valid votes won't undermine trust in elections? electionlawblog.org?p=132950
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Of all the takeaways from this piece, this one may be the most important. The new Alaska system in its current form is a major improvement from regular primaries plus plurality-winner general elections, as I've written elsewhere. But it's possible to make this reform even better:
Washington Post Opinions
@PostOpinions
The lesson of Alaska’s special election is not to abandon ranked-choice voting, as some have misguidedly charged, but instead to improve it, write @NedFoley and Eric S. Maskin. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/11/01/alaska-final-f…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is key data:
Charles Stewart III
@cstewartiii
Using election return data from 2020, here are graphs that show the % of the eventual vote that was reported, by state, in the 1st 6 hrs after polls closed & the deviation from Biden's final 2-party share at that time. More details in the thread.
-
Ned Foley reposted
Washington Post Opinions
@PostOpinions
The lesson of Alaska’s special election is not to abandon ranked-choice voting, as some have misguidedly charged, but instead to improve it, write @NedFoley and Eric S. Maskin. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/11/01/alaska-final-f…
-
Ned Foley reposted
The Ohio State University Moritz College of Law
@OhioStateLaw
Professor @Nedfoley was recently on @WOSUAllSides with Ann Fisher discussing the pros and cons of rank-choice voting. #osulaw
news.wosu.org/show/all-sides-with-ann-fisher/2022-11-02/t… -
Ned Foley reposted
Washington Post Opinions
@PostOpinions
By tweaking this rule, Alaska’s system would become more palatable to Republicans and Democrats alike, and more likely to be adopted across the country, @NedFoley and Eric S. Maskin write: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/11/01/alaska-final-f…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
very much enjoyed being part of this conversation!
All Sides
@WOSUAllSides
Voters in two states rank candidates in order of their preference, but some would like that to change. We look at the pros and cons of rank-choice voting with @Nedfoley, @WisconsinLaw's and @DebTheOtis. Listen at 10 a.m. wosu.pm/3UksRP2
-
Ned Foley reposted
All Sides
@WOSUAllSides
Voters in two states rank candidates in order of their preference, but some would like that to change. We look at the pros and cons of rank-choice voting with @Nedfoley, @WisconsinLaw's and @DebTheOtis. Listen at 10 a.m. wosu.pm/3UksRP2
-
Ned Foley reposted
Kaleb Nyquist
@KalebNyquist
I've been an outspoken advocate of #rankedchoice & #approvalvoting this year (see op-eds thefulcrum.us/Elections/Voting/faith-and-voting & therevelator.org/reform-elections-sustainable-future/).
This new "Total Vote Runoff" proposal combines strengths from both: the preference-signaling of RCV & the consensus-building of Approval.
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Eric Maskin, Nobel laureate & Harvard economist, and I propose a small but powerful tweak to Ranked Choice Voting, called Total Vote Runoff, that would improve the "instant runoff" method used in RCV systems like Alaska's. It makes RCV more majoritarian.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/11/01/alaska-final-f… -
Ned Foley reposted
Nicholas Stephanopoulos
@ProfNickStephan
Total Vote Runoff is a great way to fix the biggest problem with instant-runoff voting -- its failure to identify the Condorcet winner in some cases -- while keeping IRV ballots exactly the same for voters.
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Eric Maskin, Nobel laureate & Harvard economist, and I propose a small but powerful tweak to Ranked Choice Voting, called Total Vote Runoff, that would improve the "instant runoff" method used in RCV systems like Alaska's. It makes RCV more majoritarian.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/11/01/alaska-final-f… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Eric Maskin, Nobel laureate & Harvard economist, and I propose a small but powerful tweak to Ranked Choice Voting, called Total Vote Runoff, that would improve the "instant runoff" method used in RCV systems like Alaska's. It makes RCV more majoritarian.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/11/01/alaska-final-f… -
Ned Foley reposted
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
2. "By law," Muller argues, Congress contemplated redistricting that might be done by state courts as remedies.
If the Court accepts this view, it would mean that state courts can enforce state constitutional provisions as applied to congressional redistricting. -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If Pennsylvania used Alaska's electoral system, the choice now wouldn't just be Fetterman v. Oz, but also would include McCormick & Lamb.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Liz Cheney: ‘If Donald Trump Is The Nominee Of The Republican Party, The Party Will Shatter’ electionlawblog.org?p=132585
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
How to return to normal electoral competition? electionlawblog.org?p=132578
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I'm delighted to be participating in this symposium and looking forward this afternoon to presenting a new paper on electoral system reform.
Kyle C. Kopko
@KyleKopko
Happening today at 9AM - @UNHLaw Symposium on Contemporary Issues in Election Law. Fantastic lineup of speakers. @Nedfoley @EllenLWeintraub @derektmuller @eugenemazo @CERVASJ @SamWangPhD @megancarpenter and more! To register to view online, click here: unh.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_EeTiFY7LSYygwMvSOcGGzg
-
Ned Foley reposted
Kyle C. Kopko
@KyleKopko
Happening today at 9AM - @UNHLaw Symposium on Contemporary Issues in Election Law. Fantastic lineup of speakers. @Nedfoley @EllenLWeintraub @derektmuller @eugenemazo @CERVASJ @SamWangPhD @megancarpenter and more! To register to view online, click here: unh.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_EeTiFY7LSYygwMvSOcGGzg
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Executive privilege doesn't apply to Pence's role on Jan.6 or Trump's talk about it; neither involves an Art.II function. This key point gets lost in media coverage of Trump's privilege claim.Trump's effort to overturn election isn't in scope of privilege.
www.nytimes.com/2022/09/30/us/politics/trump-executive-pr… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
A note of dissent to this @DLeonhardt & @Nate_Cohn analysis: gerrymandering isn't just about D-R balance; there's also the problem of too many safe seats, exacerbated by partisan primaries. The resulting Ds &Rs, even if near 50-50, may be more polarized.
www.nytimes.com/2022/09/30/briefing/gerrymandering-maps-d… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Some good news on prospects for ECA reform in the Senate: www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/09/27/mcconnell-schu…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"The most promising strategy for avoiding an overturned election, many scholars say, involves a broad ideological coalition that isolates election deniers." Count me among this group. It's why I think bipartisan ECA reform remains Job One until complete.
www.nytimes.com/2022/09/17/us/american-democracy-threats.…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
It's also why, since after 1/6/21, I've urged a majority-winner rule for congressional elections. The most effective way to build "a broad ideological coalition that isolates election deniers" is a majority-winner rule, letting states choose specific form:
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/05/why-congress-s… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I'm very much looking forward to this webinar that my Election Law at Ohio State colleagues have organized; it's on the results of Alaska's special election using Ranked Choice Voting. They've recruited a great panel. Here's how to register: moritzlaw.osu.edu/alaskas-first-ranked-choice-voting-elec…
-
Ned Foley reposted
History Behind News Program & Podcast
@HistBehindNews
Disputing outcome of the 2020 presidential election continues to play a major role in #gop politics.
So to better understand the history of election disputes, I spoke with @Nedfoley of @OhioState.
Listen to trailer: creators.spotify.com/pod/profile/history-behind-news/epis…
#midterms2022 #2020election -
Ned Foley reposted
History Behind News Program & Podcast
@HistBehindNews
1876 was a frightening year!
America almost exploded into a 2nd civil war... over a presidential election dispute!
As anger over #election2020 continues, this week
@Nedfoley explains the history of U.S. election disputes.
Stay tuned. Get highlights: creators.spotify.com/pod/profile/history-behind-news/ -
Ned Foley reposted
Bob Zadek
@rzadek
This week I continue my series on the @ConstitutionCtr Restoring the Guardrails of #democracy project featuring @Nedfoley presenting the #progressiveteam ideas for safeguarding our democracy. LIVE AT 8AM bobzadek.com/live
-
Ned Foley reposted
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
Good to see support for RCV in this Henry Olsen column. Olsen is a conservative who recognizes the value of electing candidates capable of generating majority support.www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/08/18/murkowski-alas…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
For the reasons stated in this @ElectionLawBlog post electionlawblog.org?p=131434, I hope @LeaderMcConnell reads @henryolsenEPPC's new column on Alaska's Ranked-Choice Voting system. It shows why McConnell & Democrats should do a deal to adopt electoral reform: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/08/18/murkowski-alas…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“Round robin” versus “instant runoff”: Begich coming in third behind Palin highlights the significance of this distinction. I'll be looking for full results to see whether a different candidate wins depending on which type of Ranked Choice Voting is used. electionlawblog.org?p=131387
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This @AaronBlake piece supports the argument I've made since 2 months after the Jan 6 insurrection on "Why Congress should require its members to be elected by a majority of votes"; recent events strengthen the argument (for more: electionlawblog.org?p=131384).
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/08/16/gop-impeachmen… -
Ned Foley reposted
Jason Willick
@jawillick
Keep coming back to these wise words from @Nedfoley. Antithetical to the Twitter Law mindset, but often political problems have no legal solution.
electionlawblog.org?p=129937 -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Very glad to see @nytopinion strongly condemn this "repugnant" as well as "risky" strategy, which undercuts efforts to "rebuild a strong center-right party that will step up to protect democratic norms, an alternative the United States desperately needs": www.nytimes.com/2022/08/03/opinion/meijer-trump-candidate…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
It's important to realize that the problematic nature of partisan primaries followed by plurality-winner general elections enables this anti-democratic strategy. If Alaska's new top-4 & RCV or Round-Robin Voting (see go.osu.edu/terrp) were used, this tactic couldn't work.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
100% agree with @rickhasen: “Democracy cannot be sustained by just having one party believing in it and helping to purge the other party of democracy-supporting members.” As I've said before, this isn't just risky strategy; it undermines democracy itself.
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/08/03/democrats-face… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
@rickhasen's point here is why it's essential for Congress to revise the Electoral Count Act. As he acknowledges, the state legislature's claim that it has Article II power to negate the state's popular vote would be incorrect (and this is so separate from the SCOTUS case on...1/
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
The independent state legislature doctrine is complicated, and the argument is that a state legislature could *claim* the doctrine lets it overturn the will of the people. Kevin McCarthy could agree and the courts might not intervene to stop it during electoral college count. 9/x
Post not available here, view on X
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
...accept the state legislature's claim even though it's incorrect. The decision of a joint session of Congress under the 12th Amendment likely can't be reviewed in court. Thus, it's essential for ECA reform to make clear that Congress doesn't count electoral votes based on a 3/
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
...state legislature's incorrect Article II claim (which would be contrary to a judicially validated count of the state's popular vote). The current ECA doesn't protect against this risk. The bipartisan Electoral Count Reform Act if adopted would. That's why it's a must-pass law.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
My article “Requiring Majority Winners for Congressional Elections: Harnessing Federalism to Combat Extremism” (part of AALS "Rebuilding Democracy & the Rule of Law" conference) is now published. Here's why this reform should be a top electoral priority: electionlawblog.org?p=131092
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
It's categorically inappropriate to promote anti-democratic candidates in the hope of having an easier-to-beat opponent. One should hope for an opponent who shares a belief in democracy but offers a different policy vision, so voters can pick between them.
www.axios.com/2022/07/27/jan-6-committee-democrat-meddlin… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I called for a stand-alone anti-gerrymandering Act of Congress as "job one" in February of 2021: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/02/04/congress-end-p…
Steve Bergin 🌎
@conservcacao
And when will a pure Anti-gerrymandering Act get brought to the Senate? No one understands what was in HR.1, gerrymandering needs to be taken on as single issue.
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I renewed my call for a stand-alone anti-gerrymandering Act of Congress in August 2021: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/08/09/house-represen… That didn't happen unfortunately. But now is the time to pass the Electoral Count Reform Act & return to the issue of anti-gerrymandering legislation after ECRA passes.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This morning's news on the topic of Electoral Count Act reform should include the important @lawfareblog piece by Bob Bauer & @jacklgoldsmith posted last night, as noted here: electionlawblog.org?p=130965
Dave Clarke
@davecclarke
The Senate will hold a hearing Aug. 3 on @SenatorCollins and @Sen_JoeManchin's bill to update the Electoral Count Act. But two leading Democratic lawyers, @marceelias and @NormEisen, raised concerns about the text.
@theodoricmeyer @LACaldwellDC @tobiaraji www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/07/25/why-two-democr… -
Ned Foley reposted
Matthew A. Seligman
@Matt_Seligman
(As I was drafting this thread, I see @Nedfoley has made similar points on @ElectionLawBlog: electionlawblog.org?p=130928.)
-
Ned Foley reposted
AYMAN
@AymanMSNBC
“Do you think we should abolish the Electoral College?” @AymanM asks election law expert @Nedfoley.
“Yes,” he says. “But in the meantime, we have to fix the flaws that are in front of us.” Watch: -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If you'd like the latest analysis on ECA reform, here's this, which builds on what @derektmuller wrote earlier today (linked at beginning): electionlawblog.org?p=130928
-
Ned Foley reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
Today’s timely Lawfare Podcast:
@Nedfoley and @genevievenadeau join @S_R_Anders to discuss what the new legislative reforms of the Electoral Count Act intend to change, what elements would remain unchanged, and how likely the reforms are to become law. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-lawfare-podcast/id49889… -
Ned Foley reposted
AYMAN
@AymanMSNBC
A bipartisan group of senators want to reform the Electoral Count Act in the aftermath of January 6th. But do the proposed changes go far enough?
Election law expert @Nedfoley joins @AymanM tonight to weigh in — watch their convo on @MSNBConPeacock! -
Ned Foley reposted
Election Law Blog
@ElectionLawBlog
#elb: “Electoral Count Act reform won’t save our republic. But it could help preserve it.” electionlawblog.org?p=130899
-
Ned Foley reposted
Matthew A. Seligman
@Matt_Seligman
I echo @Nedfoley’s view he expressed on @ElectionLawBlog. We are in full agreement that, in his words: “this is not a close call; the 2024 presidential election would be in a far better position if the new bill, rather than the existing ECA, is in effect.”
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
And this note of it: electionlawblog.org?p=130894
Matthew A. Seligman
@Matt_Seligman
Me in @Slate on why the newly-announced bipartisan Electoral Count Reform Act just might be able to save American democracy.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
And this note of it: electionlawblog.org?p=130894
Matthew A. Seligman
@Matt_Seligman
Me in @Slate on why the newly-announced bipartisan Electoral Count Reform Act just might be able to save American democracy.
-
Ned Foley reposted
Bipartisan Policy Center
@BPC_Bipartisan
Don't miss our Twitter Spaces today at 12 p.m. ET!
@LisaDNews will moderate a conversation between @Nedfoley, @kevinrkosar, and @ThorningMichael.
x.com/i/spaces/1yNGaYNODMWGj -
Ned Foley reposted
Bipartisan Policy Center
@BPC_Bipartisan
Tap that "set reminder" button to join our Twitter Spaces tomorrow at 12 p.m. ET as @LisaDNews of @NewsHour moderates a conversation between:
🎙️ @Nedfoley (@OhioState)
🎙️ @kevinrkosar (@aei)
🎙️ @ThorningMichael (BPC)
x.com/i/spaces/1yNGaYNODMWGj -
Ned Foley reposted
Matthew A. Seligman
@Matt_Seligman
I spoke with @ThePlumLineGS:
“'This proposal effectively constrains both state officials and Congress to count the true electors,' legal scholar Matthew Seligman, an expert on the ECA, tells us."
.
@GregTSargent
We did a close read of the new ECA reform bill:
*Bars states from appointing electors in defiance of their own laws
*If states ignore, judicial review kicks in and Cong must count right electors
Key: It stops subversion of electors at state level. More:
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/07/20/new-proposal-p… -
Ned Foley reposted
Election Law Blog
@ElectionLawBlog
#elb: “A bill to prevent Trump’s attempted coup is finally ready — and must pass.” electionlawblog.org?p=130874
-
Ned Foley reposted
Election Law Blog
@ElectionLawBlog
#elb: “The new proposal to prevent a future coup is surprisingly good” electionlawblog.org?p=130876
-
Ned Foley reposted
Kyle Cheney
@kyledcheney
NOTABLE: The Electoral Count Act reform proposed by the bipartisan Senate group resolves a thorny question about the total number of electors required to win the presidency, if some electors are disqualified.
The denominator gets lowered from 538 to reflect the new total. -
Ned Foley reposted
Election Law Blog
@ElectionLawBlog
#elb: Why Congress should swiftly enact the Senate’s bipartisan ECA reform bill electionlawblog.org?p=130870
-
Ned Foley reposted
gronke
@gronke
Like many, I hope this reform of the Electoral Count Act happens, and when a history is written of this time, I hope that @Nedfoley’s contributions are in the history books. There are many others who will deserve credit, but Ned has been so important.
www.nytimes.com/2022/07/20/us/politics/electoral-count-ac… -
Ned Foley reposted
Matthew A. Seligman
@Matt_Seligman
The ISLD does not, however, give state legislatures a carte blanche to steal a presidential election. Fin.
-
Ned Foley reposted
Matthew A. Seligman
@Matt_Seligman
But--and here's the important part--it *does not mean* that the state legislature can set the "manner" of appointing electors unconstrained by *federal* law. And two sources of federal law in particular are relevant: Article II, sec. 1, cl. 4 and the Equal Protection Clause.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Looking forward to this!
Ilya Somin
@IlyaSomin
Tune in tonight at 7 PM eastern to watch team leaders @ConLawWarrior, @whignewtons, and @Nedfoley talk about their reports, with @ConstitutionCtr President Jeffrey Rosen. constitutioncenter.org/calendar/restoring-the-guardrails-…
-
Ned Foley reposted
The Ohio State University Moritz College of Law
@OhioStateLaw
Professor @Nedfoley was recently interviewed by the @NewYorker discussing the January 6 insurrection and what the committee has revealed as far as key vulnerabilities in the electoral process. www.newyorker.com/news/q-and-a/the-gap-in-the-constitutio…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Patrick F. Gleason
@PatrickFGleason
"If there is ever going to be a successful coup, it will be committed by Congress itself because Congress holds the power to declare the winner of the Presidential election."
Deft analysis and what's needed to protect democracy by #election law expert @Nedfoley
The New Yorker
@NewYorker
“As long as we have an Electoral College under our Constitution, we have a lot of vulnerabilities,” an election-law expert says. nyer.cm/n6X20ju
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
In response to question: SCOTUS might review application of statute enforcing 14th Amendment's disqualification clause, but SCOTUS could also review legal validity of criminal prosecution of Trump (under 18 USC 371, for example). Enacting a new 14th Amend law is less vulnerable.
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
With all the discussion on whether the Jan. 6 hearings will cause DOJ to prosecute Trump, there needs to be more consideration of invoking the 14th Amendment's disqualification clause to authorize DOJ to bring a civil suit to bar Trump from office again: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/06/23/there-better-o…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Also, even a criminal conviction (unless under 18 USC 2383 for insurrection) would not officially bar Trump from running in 2024. Only disqualification under a new statute enforcing section 3 of 14 Amendment would have legal effect of making Trump ineligible to hold office again.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
To my mind, this suggestion (though well-intentioned) shows how messed-up our existing electoral system is. It argues that voters should act contrary to the system's basic premises because otherwise "your vote doesn't matter"; a new system would be better. electionlawblog.org?p=130176
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Does Today’s Second Amendment Decision Affect the First Amendment and thus Election Law? electionlawblog.org?p=130174
-
Ned Foley reposted
Washington Post Opinions
@PostOpinions
There is a better option to keep Trump out of office than prosecution, @NedFoley writes
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/06/23/there-better-o… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
With all the discussion on whether the Jan. 6 hearings will cause DOJ to prosecute Trump, there needs to be more consideration of invoking the 14th Amendment's disqualification clause to authorize DOJ to bring a civil suit to bar Trump from office again: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/06/23/there-better-o…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Pam Fessler
@pamelafessler
This turned out to be a really good discussion last week with @larryrjacobs @Nedfoley and @KevinJreformers.
I know...so many vulnerabilities. We try to end on an UP note! youtu.be/M5si7HhICvM via @YouTube -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
extremely well-argued essay by @jacklgoldsmith:
www.nytimes.com/2022/06/20/opinion/trump-merrick-garland-… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is disturbing, especially after the January 6 Committee hearings last week that demolished the predicate for this claim: "Texas Republicans Approve Far-Right Platform Declaring Biden’s Election Illegitimate" www.nytimes.com/2022/06/19/us/politics/texas-republicans-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"Trump campaign documents give inside look at fake-elector plan" www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/06/20/trump-document…
-
Ned Foley reposted
PBS SoCal (KOCE)
@PBSSoCal
Need a tl;dr on Day 3 of Jan 6 Committee testimony? @NewsHour/ @JudyWoodruff x Garrett M. Graff (@vermontgmg) x @Nedfoley have you covered! www.pbssocal.org/shows/newshour/clip/the-january-6th-hear…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Should Congress change the body that determines disability for 25th Amendment purposes? Are there 60 votes in the Senate to consider this?
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/06/16/25th-amendment… -
Ned Foley reposted
National Constitution Center
@ConstitutionCtr
How can we prevent another January 6?
On this week’s #wtppodcast, @judgeluttig, @nedfoley, Sarah Isgur (@whignewtons), and Clark Neily (@ConLawWarrior) consider ways to strengthen American constitutional and democratic institutions against future threats. -
Ned Foley reposted
Pam Fessler
@pamelafessler
After today's J6 committee hearing, I'm especially interested in what these panelists @Nedfoley @larryrjacobs and @KevinJreformers have to say!
PSQ
@PSQuarterly
VIRTUAL EVENT | America’s Vulnerable Elections, June 16 @ 7:30 p.m. ET
Register to hear @Nedfoley, @larryrjacobs, @KevinJreformers, and @pamelafessler discuss elections in an era of hyperpartisanship. Organized by the Network for Responsible Public Policy. -
Ned Foley reposted
Amy Howe
@AHoweBlogger
Looking ahead to 2022-23 term, #scotus released its October calendar today. Justices kick off the new term on October 3 with Clean Water Act Case, will hear Alabama voting rights case on October 4.
-
Ned Foley reposted
Pam Fessler
@pamelafessler
America's Vulnerable Elections, couldn't be more timely. Join the discussion Thursday night, 7:30 ET with three of the smartest people on the topic @Nedfoley @larryrjacobs and Kevin Johnson @ERN_Reformers. Hosted by Network for Responsible Public Policy.
www.nfrpp.org/event/americas-vulnerable-elections/ -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Ben Ginsberg: “the simple fact is that the Trump campaign did not make its case” (discussing the campaign's litigation of election results in multiple states). Ginsberg also contrasted 2020 as not being close in the way that Bush v Gore 20 years earlier was.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Stepien on Election Night said it was "far too early" to call the election.
www.nytimes.com/live/2022/06/13/us/jan-6-hearings-trump/1… -
Ned Foley reposted
Pam Fessler
@pamelafessler
"The big lie was also a big ripoff." -- Zoe Lofgren
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This ELB post on today's hearing, electionlawblog.org?p=129891, has been updated to include this development:
Ryan Nobles
@ryanobles
BREAKING: The 1/6 Committee just announced Bill Stepien will NOT appear due to a “family emergency”. His counsel will appear instead and make a statement.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Today’s 1/6 Committee Hearing in Historical Context: why Trump's bad faith challenge to his 2020 loss differs from previous disputed elections. electionlawblog.org?p=129891
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Very cogent @jbouie piece. For more majority rule & democracy, see also electionlawblog.org?p=129707 www.nytimes.com/2022/06/03/opinion/majority-rule-democrac…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The Constitution and Condorcet: Democracy Protection through Electoral Reform electionlawblog.org?p=129707
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Sometimes a conversation really clicks: "The Dispatch Podcast on the Problem with Primaries" electionlawblog.org?p=129660
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This was a really great conversation with @whignewtons & @NickTroiano on why primary elections aren't working and how we can fix them: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/how-do-you-solve-a-problem-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Misreading: the point of the article cited was to warn what could go wrong if Trump falsely claimed to have won the election when he hadn't. Also, once courts had rejected all Trump's claims, there was no basis for any effort to subvert the result on 1/6 under any view of the ECA
Adam Ambrogi
@AdamAmbrogi
This memo and craven logic behind it is worth folks' time to read. It's looking for crazy loopholes that allow variation for what's always been done, for the purposes of taking power away fr the people. Outrageous. Silver Lining: at least they're reading @Nedfoley 's work...
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
A Case Study in the Failure of Democracy in America electionlawblog.org?p=129567
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
democracyjournal.org/magazine/reforming-the-electoral-cou… Hopefully, this essay will help encourage Congress to get Electoral Count Act reform across the finish line this year. It needs to happen before 2024, and this is the year to do it, because after the midterms the politics are likely to be even harder.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Raffensperger defeating Hice in GOP primary for Georgia Secretary of State is very good news for all who care about upholding election results based on the will of the voters & thus ending the kind of election denialism Trump has caused with his "Big Lie": www.nytimes.com/live/2022/05/24/us/election-georgia-prima…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Chris Cooper
@chriscooperwcu
This looks like a terrific webinar (2 words I rarely say together): @Nedfoley @dawnbvaughan @ProfGuyCharles & Sunshine Hillygus on what the #ncsen race tells us about the future of the 2 party system.
#ncpol
mailchi.mp/osu/jun-1-webinar-nc-senate-race -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
thehill.com/news/house/3497838-cheney-warns-of-threat-we-…. We should never tire of hearing words like @Liz_Cheney standing up for peaceful transfer of power based on democratic elections pursuant to the rule of law.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Relying on @CarnegieEndow report by @jlynnmccoy, @Yascha_Mounk in @TheAtlantic argues, as has @leedrutman, for institutional reform to redress "The Doom Spiral of Pernicious Polarization.” What institutional reform would be best? We need more work on this:
electionlawblog.org?p=129423 -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Very glad to talk with @AliVelshi about the need for Congress to revise the Electoral Count Act now, before the midterms. The bipartisan effort in the Senate must get across the finish line! Both sides should support this deal, as either side could exploit the flawed law in 2024.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Some good news from Georgia–and a caveat electionlawblog.org?p=129409
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Important development:
Jonathan Lai 🙊 賴柏羽
@Elaijuh
Breaking: A federal appeals court just ruled that undated mail ballots from last November be counted in Lehigh County.
The impact could be immediate — by affecting counties’ decisions on whether to count or reject undated mail ballots *this* election.
www.inquirer.com/politics/election/undated-mail-ballots-p… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I missed this valuable story from a few days ago; very helpful discussion on why alleged misdeeds were in fact lawful under Georgia law: www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/05/17/georgia-electi…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Opinion | How our system of primary elections could destroy democracy www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/05/19/primary-electi…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Excellent review of important book. www.theatlantic.com/books/archive/2022/05/this-will-not-p…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Two first thoughts on PA’s GOP Senate primary electionlawblog.org?p=129362
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Important @henryolsenEPPC column, especially about plurality winners of multi-candidate primaries www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/05/17/republicans-ma…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The upcoming GOP gubernatorial primary in Nebraska, like Ohio's GOP primaries just completed, is a reason to consider this:
Eliminating plurality-winner primaries? electionlawblog.org?p=129189 -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
One of Ohio's House races in yesterday's primary illustrates how the current system can produce results contrary to what the voters overall most want. That's bad enough in a democracy, but when the winners embrace the "Big Lie" it's even more dangerous:
electionlawblog.org?p=129145 -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Given that democracy requires "loser's consent," it's nice to see tonight losing candidates quickly conceding defeat, rather than claiming election was stolen. Worth remembering that the same voting & counting procedures used today will be used again in November. It's trustworthy
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Think if Ohio's Senate race in November were the top 4 from today's primary regardless of party (Vance, Mandel, Dolan & Ryan), like in Alaska, & ranked-choice ballots were used; & what if Round-Robin Voting was the way to pick the winner from the ballots?: electionlawblog.org?p=129124
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This conversation between @Yascha_Mounk & @JonHaidt was well worth it, especially: 1) tweaks to Twitter; 2) other structural reforms to improve social discourse and governance; & 3) personal behaviors to enhance civility.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/why-do-we-always-think-were… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is happening in a statewide race, not a gerrymandered district. Would it occur if Ohio used a Ranked-Choice Voting system with a nonpartisan primary, like Alaska's? Under current conditions, a party primary incentivizes extremism. Other systems don't. www.nytimes.com/2022/04/30/us/politics/ohio-senate-primar…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If Ohio used a nonpartisan "round-robin" primary to pick two candidates for general election (see go.osu.edu/terrp for details on "round-robin" voting), who would be the top 2 finalists? Most likely Ryan & Dolan? Not Vance, Mandel (the polarizers)?
www.politico.com/news/2022/04/29/trump-says-matt-dolan-is… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Highlighting @henryolsenEPPC's important new anti-gerrymandering column & exploring its potential implications, including a possible bipartisan deal to permit state experimentation with PR for Congress: "Conservative Case for Proportional Representation" electionlawblog.org?p=129056
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Will there be a “spoiler” in 2024? electionlawblog.org?p=128960
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/x I'm perplexed by today's federal court order in Ohio's redistricting case. Yes, a federal court can enjoin a state from holding a primary election with a map that violates the federal Constitution. But a federal court has no power to require a state... electionlawblog.org?p=128858
Post not available here, view on X
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
3/x...given the Ohio Supreme Court's view that this map violates the state constitution. I don't think there would be any federal-law basis to overturn that state court order, if it were issued. When it comes to the general election, the issue seems trickier because there must...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
4/x...a valid map for that. But because at issue now is only state legislative seats, and not congressional seats, there's no federal-law requirement that the general election must be on a specific date in November. To be sure, state law sets a date for the general election in...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
5/x...these races, but again that's state (not federal) law. If the Ohio Supreme Court held that it had power under Ohio law to adjust this date in order to having the election using maps that comply with the state constitution, I see no federal-law reason to object. The cases...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
6/x...cited by today's majority opinion seem inapposite. Some concern congressional elections, where federal-law deadlines apply. Others, like Griffin v. Burns, involve negating ballots of some (not all) votes in an election that occurred, not whether to hold a primary election.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I'm confident @FrankLaRose wouldn't be shifting his message if Ohio had Alaska's new "top 4" nonpartisan primary system. In that case, LaRose would simply need to earn 1 of 4 spots on the Nov. ballot & thus would target his message to the median Nov. voter apnews.com/article/2022-midterm-elections-elections-ohio-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This podcast is a "must listen" for those concerned with the task of restoring sufficient trust in elections, so that democracy US is sustainable. As Ginsberg & Longwell acknowledge, it will be a challenge to recreate adequate levels of trust among GOP voters, but it's essential.
Sarah Longwell
@SarahLongwell25
Roughly 70% of Republicans believe the 2020 election was stolen. We asked Trump voters why they’re so sure the election was rigged. And conservative election lawyer Ben Ginsberg and I talk about what it will take to restore faith in our elections. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-focus-group-with-sarah-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The most telling line of Judge Carter's opinion, in my judgment, is Eastman's acknowledgment of being partisan & unprincipled: that he wouldn't want VP Harris, or VP Gore, to have the same power he wanted Pence to exercise (see p.39). No good faith at all. electionlawblog.org?p=128463
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
There's been recent discussion on whether SCOTUS will rollback the Anderson-Burdick test for protecting voters from excessively onerous voting rules (see @derektmuller at electionlawblog.org?p=127766), but these facts suggest a worthy claim of unjustified disenfranchisement to pursue.
Zach Despart
@zachdespart
Harris County's elections office told me today they'd flagged *30%* of mail ballots for rejection because of the stricter ID rules set by the Legislature. Voters, who are mostly elderly, have 6 days to fix or ballots won't count.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/ This is the most significant development to date on the proposition that the perpetration of the Big Lie (the willfully dishonest claim that Biden did not validly win the 2020 election) was a criminal conspiracy in violation of 18 USC 371. The evidence in support of this claim
Kyle Cheney
@kyledcheney
BREAKING: The Jan. 6 select committee says it believes Donald Trump violated multiple laws in his quest to overturn the 2020 election — including obstruction of Congress and defrauding the United States.
storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cacd.841840/…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/ includes detailed multiple times Trump was told by high-level US officials & his own campaign staff that there was no basis to assert the election was stolen. Given this, any organized effort to undo the outcome based on the Big Lie would be in reckless disregard of the truth
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
'“The election was not ‘stolen,’”Barr writes. “Trump lost it.”...In more detail than previously shared, Barr describes how he marshaled [DOJ &] FBI to explore various fraud claims. And in each instance, they could find no evidence to support those claims'
www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2022/02/27/barr-… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I had the privilege of visiting Kyiv in 1990. I was struck by blue & yellow everywhere, including women dyeing their hair to be both colors. Seeing this Ukrainian pride shortly before the fall of the Soviet Union is useful context for watching the same spirit resist Russia now.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"On visits to congressional districts, [McCarthy] said, it was clear to him that the right-wing lawmakers were merely doing what the voters who sent them to Washington wanted."If those districts hadn't been gerrymandered, would their voters want the same?
www.nytimes.com/2022/02/24/us/politics/kevin-mcarthy-spea… -
Ned Foley reposted
Charles Stewart III
@cstewartiii
This report from Columbia World Projects has good thoughts about building partnerships between academics and elex officials to improve Amer. elections. I've advocated many of these ideas for years. This report is a great step forward. worldprojects.columbia.edu/news-media/report-universities…
-
Ned Foley reposted
National Constitution Center
@ConstitutionCtr
On this week’s #liveatncc, listen to experts @Charlescwcooke, @Nedfoley, Michael T. Morley, and @Dawn_teele discuss proposals to protect the integrity of the American election process.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If Wyoming adopted Alaska's new system, it could avoid this issue: all of the state's voters could decide in November which candidate they prefer (and the state's Republican party could exercise its First Amendment right to express its own preference).
www.politico.com/news/2022/02/17/trump-moves-to-close-off… -
Ned Foley reposted
Darrel Rowland
@darreldrowland
BREAKING: Ohio Supreme Court gives state redistricting commission 5 days to show cause "as to why the commission and its members should not be found in contempt for failure to comply with the Court’s Feb. 7 order"
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
What would this race look like if Wyoming used Alaska's new electoral system? Not clear that result would be different, but it might be: Cheney more likely to do better in RCV general election than in GOP primary (where Trump/McCarthy have more power).
thehill.com/homenews/campaign/594838-mccarthy-endorses-ch… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Walter was unfailingly the most courteous and kindest, also perceptive, person whom I've had the privilege of knowing as a lawyer. Each year I teach my students about his brilliant litigating based on knowing the need to see the world through others' eyes. www.washingtonpost.com/obituaries/2022/02/17/walter-delli…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Interesting overview of GOP midterm primaries:
www.politico.com/news/2022/02/17/primaries-redefining-pos… There still would be the battle between Trump & non-Trump factions if Alaska's new system were used elsewhere, BUT this fight would be settled by general-election voters, not primary voters: a big difference? -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
What would Missouri's US Senate race look like if the state used Alaska's new electoral system (in which top 4 candidates in nonpartisan primary advance to the general election, to be chosen by Ranked Choice Voting)? I think it would be different than now: www.politico.com/news/2022/02/16/missouri-senate-poll-ala…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
How would these candidates behave if they were running in a race with Alaska's new electoral system (where they just want to finish among the top 4 in a nonpartisan primary), rather than in a party primary? I think it would be quite different; don't you?
thehill.com/homenews/campaign/594589-republicans-spurned-… -
Ned Foley reposted
LarryDiamond
@LarryDiamond
Excellent piece by NYU Law Professor Rick Pildes explaining why RCV is the reform we need to depolarize our politics and liberate members of Congress to compromise. More Places Should Do What Alaska Did to Its Elections www.nytimes.com/2022/02/15/opinion/alaska-elections-ranke…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If Ohio used Alaska's new electoral system, what would Mandel's chances be? Also, would Mandel have moved so far to the right if there was no partisan primary to win? Politicians adjust their messaging to the specific electoral system in which they compete www.nytimes.com/2022/02/15/us/josh-mandel-ohio-trump.html
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Another story about which to ask: what would this race be like if Alaska's new electoral system were in place here? www.politico.com/news/2022/02/15/conor-lamb-senate-penn-0…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Rick Pildes makes the key point on why other states should adopt Alaska's new electoral system (or a variation on same approach): "in our era, one of the highest priorities in election reform must be reducing the influence of extremism in our politics."
www.nytimes.com/2022/02/15/opinion/alaska-elections-ranke… -
Ned Foley reposted
National Constitution Center
@ConstitutionCtr
Join @ConstitutionCtr & @SNFAgoraJHU to explore proposals to protect the integrity of the American election process. Experts @charlescwcooke, @Nedfoley, Michael T. Morley, & @dawn_teele discuss.
Register for #americastownhall on Feb. 15 at 7 p.m. ET: constitutioncenter.org/calendar/election-integrity-and-vo… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/2 Ohio's Senate race would be interesting test of Alaska's new electoral system. It might have produced a different campaign, including different candidates. Maybe even Portman would've run, not having to win a Trumpian GOP primary. On the other hand...
thehill.com/homenews/campaign/593951-josh-mandel-tests-oh…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/2 Instant Runoff Voting method to identify Nov winner might yield same result as existing system given very high level of voter polarization. Thus, Ohio would be a good place for testing other versions of Ranked Choice Voting than IRV. One option is BTR: go.osu.edu/ppw
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Here's another story to read with this question in mind: how different would it be if Alaska's new electoral system were used elsewhere? In Arizona, Ducey's view of the race might differ if he only had to earn one of 4 top spots in a nonpartisan primary...
www.nytimes.com/2022/02/13/us/mcconnell-trump-primaries-m…Post not available here, view on X
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Re Alaska specifically: @jmartNYT is a top reporter, but this phrase is misleading: "If [Murkowski] wins her primary, it will show..." Under Alaska's new system, she's not in a position to "win" the primary, but only get one of the 4 tickets to the November ballot. But given...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
...that the rest of sentence quotes McConnell, the error about Alaska may have been his, not @jmartNYT's. Bottom-line: there needs to be much better understanding of, and reporting on, Alaska's new system and its potential national implications. For more: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/02/10/alaska-ranked-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is an important new analysis of a major problem by @srl www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2022/feb/12/us… For a solution, it could be unlawful for a state's House seats on average to be less competitive than statewide races, absent mapmaker's valid redistricting justification: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/08/09/house-represen…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Another reason to think about Alaska's new electoral system: electionlawblog.org?p=127619. If NY used it, would Schumer be as worried about protecting his left flank from possible AOC primary challenge? (Don't think so.) For more analysis of Alaska's system: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/02/10/alaska-ranked-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Another way to state the point: if Ohio used Alaska's new electoral system, the incentives and pressures that LaRose and other Republicans would face would be entirely different. They wouldn't need to "ride the Trump train" (as @rickhasen) says in order to survive the GOP primary
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
@rickhasen asks: "What Has Happened to Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose? Once a Sensible [GOP] Voice on Election Administration, He’s Now Starting to Ride the Trump Train" electionlawblog.org?p=127569
This problem won't get fixed without structural reform: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/02/10/alaska-ranked-… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
@rickhasen asks: "What Has Happened to Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose? Once a Sensible [GOP] Voice on Election Administration, He’s Now Starting to Ride the Trump Train" electionlawblog.org?p=127569
This problem won't get fixed without structural reform: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/02/10/alaska-ranked-… -
Ned Foley reposted
Washington Post Opinions
@PostOpinions
From @NedFoley: Can Alaska save democracy? www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/02/10/alaska-ranked-…
-
Ned Foley reposted
David Becker
@beckerdavidj
"[ERIC] helps identify duplicate registrations," AL SOS John Merrill said. "It helps identify dual participation in elections. That's a concern [and] there's no other way that any state in the union can do that independently of ERIC."
www.npr.org/2022/02/09/1076529761/right-wing-conspiracies… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Can the difference between McConnell & McCarthy on this be attributable entirely to the fact that the House is gerrymandered whereas the Senate is not?
"GOP tensions flare over Jan. 6 attack" thehill.com/homenews/senate/593406-gop-tensions-flare-ove… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I haven't agreed with @ProfNickStephan on everything recently (for example, here on partisan gerrymandering: electionlawblog.org?p=127353), but this column is right on the money as far as I'm concerned: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/02/08/supreme-court-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Rick Pildes helpfully amplifies the point I made in my correction: electionlawblog.org?p=127506
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Correction: before Shelby County, preclearance wouldn't stop a map just for vote dilution violating VRA s2; instead, VRA s5 preclearance blocked only "retrogressive" maps. Still, it seems that yesterday's application of Purcell is significant, especially without preclearance. 1/2
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Is it fair to say that the combo of Purcell & no preclearance is a procedural double-whammy? Before Shelby County, Alabama couldn't use a new map w/o DOJ or fed court approval. Now, Alabama gets to sneak through new map w/o chance for fed court disapproval if map violates VRA s2.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Correction: before Shelby County, preclearance wouldn't stop a map just for vote dilution violating VRA s2; instead, VRA s5 preclearance blocked only "retrogressive" maps. Still, it seems that yesterday's application of Purcell is significant, especially without preclearance. 1/2
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Is it fair to say that the combo of Purcell & no preclearance is a procedural double-whammy? Before Shelby County, Alabama couldn't use a new map w/o DOJ or fed court approval. Now, Alabama gets to sneak through new map w/o chance for fed court disapproval if map violates VRA s2.
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Indeed, is it possible that yesterday's version of Purcell is even more consequential than Shelby County precisely 'cause it prevents blocking new maps violating VRAs2, which has nationwide applicability & is supposed to be the basic protection of equal electoral opportunity? 2/2
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
In Election Law class today, we discussed how the current state of redistricting law seems especially chaotic, arbitrary, and in urgent need of major revision (which Congress has failed to provide because of the filibuster). That was before today's ruling: www.nytimes.com/2022/02/07/us/politics/supreme-court-alab…
-
Post not available here, view on X
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Is it fair to say that the combo of Purcell & no preclearance is a procedural double-whammy? Before Shelby County, Alabama couldn't use a new map w/o DOJ or fed court approval. Now, Alabama gets to sneak through new map w/o chance for fed court disapproval if map violates VRA s2.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/2 Is this the first time SCOTUS has applied Purcell to a redistricting case rather than an election administration one? I can't recall a previous example & to my mind the equities differ. The majority here misjudges the equities in my view because ...
www.nytimes.com/2022/02/07/us/politics/supreme-court-alab…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/2 plaintiffs sued immediately after adoption of new map & district court acted with appropriate speed. To prevent a preliminary injunction here, as SCOTUS stay does, is to let state use a VRA-violating map with impunity for at least one congressional election. That seems wrong.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This episode of Bulwark podcast is one of the best I've heard; even better is its announcement that @saletan will joining @sykescharlie every Monday, thereby promising more of the same.
"Will Saletan: It's Easy to Become an Authoritarian" www.thebulwark.com/podcast-episode/will-saletan-its-easy-… @BulwarkOnline -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This Ohio Senate race is indeed significant for Trump's role in the GOP primary & @DavidFrum offers interesting angle on it. One note: Glenn & Metzenbaum served together, after Glenn beat Metzenbaum in 1974 primary & Metzenbaum won OH's other seat in 1976. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/02/bernie-moreno-r…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Agreeing with Rick Pildes that uncompetitive districts facilitate extremism, electionlawblog.org?p=127471, it's possible to measure how uncompetitive a state's districts are & to require a state to justify districts less competitive than the state as a whole: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/08/09/house-represen…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
For those who saw this tweet & wondered about the technical term "Condorcet winner", here's an explanation of the idea without the jargon: electionlawblog.org?p=127452 The key point is that current plurality-winner system blocks majority preference & Trump exploits this perilous flaw.
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/2 As GOP abandons democracy, ask: how many Trump-backed candidates in GOP primaries would be the "Condorcet winner" in an all-candidate nonpartisan election, meaning the candidate who can defeat all others one-on-one? Then ask: how many Trump-backed ... www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2022/02/03/rnc-cheney-trump…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
There is no reason why round-robin voting should be any more vulnerable to legal challenge than instant runoffs: both are just different mathematical ways to calculate the majority-preferred candidate using the same Ranked Choice Voting ballots containing the same voter rankings.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Interesting details here: www.nytimes.com/2022/02/05/business/trump-fox-news.html
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/2 As GOP abandons democracy, ask: how many Trump-backed candidates in GOP primaries would be the "Condorcet winner" in an all-candidate nonpartisan election, meaning the candidate who can defeat all others one-on-one? Then ask: how many Trump-backed ... www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2022/02/03/rnc-cheney-trump…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/2 candidates can win GOP primary & defeat Democrat in Nov? To the extent latter is larger than former, current system enables Trump-backed candidates to prevail despite not being majority-preferred (Condorcet) candidate. To save democracy from Trump, this problem must be fixed.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I agree with @rickhasen's diagnosis, but what's the cure? Rick seems to say those who aren't in GOP have to watch as bystanders while they fight it out. I believe we are all responsible for the rules that limit general-election options to only candidates who win party primaries.
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
Today's RNC censure and Pence speech clarified that the Republican Party is at a crossroads. Back in the early 2010s, I wrote at a Drake Law symposium on the tea party/establishment split, and eventually saw the Tea Party breaking off from Rs. That was backwards /1
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is a great idea for Cheney's midterm but doesn't solve the structural problem nationwide. electionlawblog.org?p=127437 Alaska has a new system that may let Murkowski survive Trump's attack, but what about non-Trump GOPers elsewhere? electionlawblog.org?p=127426
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/02/04/liz-cheney-can… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Which is why figuring out what electoral reform will safeguard healthy two-party (or multi-party) competition must be the highest priority: electionlawblog.org?p=127437
Can't Stop Twinkling...Still 💚💕
@ProfTolson
Probably not in any meaningful way (2/2,304)
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“As Part of Electoral Count Act Reform, Liberals Should Learn to Love Bush v. Gore” electionlawblog.org?p=127422
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I agree with @derektmuller that this post is very valuable. The ineligibility of a winning presidential candidate to serve should cause the winning vice presidential candidate to become acting president under the 20th Amendment, not the losing candidate to be declared the winner.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Alexa says there is no primary in Ohio this year. But I'm pretty confident that's incorrect. www.ohiosos.gov/elections/voters/current-voting-schedule/…
Miranda Cox
@TheMirandaCox
Election Day in Ohio is three months away, but Alexa denies it.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Matching GOP gerrymanders with counter-gerrymanders of their own is surely not the way for Democrats to liberate a future Speaker McCarthy from control of a candidate Trump seeking to subvert his way back into the White House. electionlawblog.org?p=127353
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I agree with @rickhasen: ballot-box stuffing is worse than gerrymandering. But we shouldn't discount the anti-democratic evil of gerrymandering. If Democrats in NY distort districts to negate voter choice, that subverts self-government. It doesn't fix GOP gerrymanders elsewhere.
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
In my view, the problem with Ned's analogy is that ballot box stuffing is clearly illegal and partisan gerrymandering, at least as a constitutional matter, is not (or at least courts won't do anything about it). Gerrymandering also requires judgment about what goes too far.
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
3 points in response to @rickhasen on this: 1) supporters of LBJ in 1948 backed ballot-box stuffing because the other side did it; same need to avoid unilateral disarmament argument--when is it not ok to fight fire with fire in democracy? 2) if you are going to justify evil to...
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
Here's a provocative @Nedfoley post on Dems' supporting partisan gerrymandering. I don't agree with this one, given that it would represent a kind of unilateral disarmament that Dems cannot afford in the name of high principle.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
3 points in response to @rickhasen on this: 1) supporters of LBJ in 1948 backed ballot-box stuffing because the other side did it; same need to avoid unilateral disarmament argument--when is it not ok to fight fire with fire in democracy? 2) if you are going to justify evil to...
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
Here's a provocative @Nedfoley post on Dems' supporting partisan gerrymandering. I don't agree with this one, given that it would represent a kind of unilateral disarmament that Dems cannot afford in the name of high principle.
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
... to fight evil, you need a very firm moral compass; Raskin's "we have to do everything we can" is too cavalier; what's unacceptable means even given the save-democracy goal? 3) my main point is the broader one about the Democratic Party's electoral reform mistakes in 2021,...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
...which has caused the current predicament of believing gerrymandering is justified to save democracy. The whole HR1 approach was "what's good for Democrats is good for democracy." Democrats need to reorient their approach & build democracy-protection that survives midterm loss.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I missed this editorial initially. Worth reading. How do we get the 70% of GOP voters who believe Trump’s Big Lie to accept this truth? “A conservative group finds that in Wisconsin…there’s no evidence of fraud that would have changed the [2020] result.” www.wsj.com/articles/the-best-summary-of-the-2020-electio…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Pence lacked power to either (1) reject electors appointed by state law or (2) send electoral votes back to states for redo.Once appointed electors have met & voted, their appointment can't be undone. That's the basis on which the 1876 election was settled
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/02/01/trump-says-con… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I agree with the need for this kind of statute, as noted in this #elb post: electionlawblog.org?p=127315
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/02/01/bar-insurrecti… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
New WaPo op-ed on need for Section 3 statute electionlawblog.org?p=127319
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Nicely done editorial on this important subject: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/interactive/2022/gerryman…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Amplifying my agreement with @henryolsenEPPC in this #elb post: electionlawblog.org?p=127296
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/01/31/mike-pence-thi… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Some of us worried about this before Nov 2020: blog.harvardlawreview.org/a-november-nightmare-part-i-wha… Thank goodness it never happened & thus courts weren’t required to enjoin it. Also, by 12/18 the electors had met; under Art II no longer constitutional to undo appointment of electors. www.nytimes.com/2022/01/31/us/politics/donald-trump-elect…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I agree with @henryolsenEPPC on this: "Sooner or later, someone with stature has to take the lie head on." There's no other way to overcome the Electoral McCarthyism that Trump has perpetrated. My only disagreement: Pence should have done this long ago.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/01/31/mike-pence-thi… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
It's entirely consistent to think BOTH that Pence had no such authority (as I wrote on 1/5/2021 www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/01/05/pence-cannot-i…) AND ALSO that the Electoral Count Act should be clarified on this crucial point (as I wrote over a month earlier on 12/1/2020 www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/12/01/congress-must-…).
Maggie Haberman
@maggieNYT
Pence is speaking the night before Trump in NOLA at the Rnc
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Agreeing with @rickhasen, I've been publicly critical of some litigation decisions Elias made in recent years, viewing them unduly aggressive with counterproductive consequences. Looking forward, I also think it essential not to miss the opportunity to revise Electoral Count Act.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If Ohio had Alaska's new electoral system ("top 4" nonpartisan primary, with RCV in general election), the campaign would be entirely different. What's happening now is because of the existing electoral system, which incentivizes extremism to win primary. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/01/28/jd-vance-ohio-…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Charles Stewart III
@cstewartiii
This is troubling. All Philly gains when experienced Republicans with a demonstrated track record for integrity are part of the city's election leadership. www.inquirer.com/politics/clout/philadelphia-progressives…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Election Law Blog
@ElectionLawBlog
#elb: “Schumer gives Electoral Count Act group breathing room” electionlawblog.org?p=127187
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“Schumer gives Electoral Count Act group breathing room” electionlawblog.org?p=127187
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Another race for which this question is relevant: what if Alaska’s new electoral system applied here? DeWine surely would finish among top 4 in nonpartisan primary. What about the RCV general election? Would dynamics of campaign be different? If so, how? www.politico.com/news/2022/01/25/trump-ohio-governorship-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Kuttner's analysis is severely mistaken: there isn't going to be "federal takeover" of election admin & well-crafted ECA reform can thwart election subversion by both Congress & states (see new Lawfare podcast).
"Kuttner...Against Stand-Alone [ECA] Reform" electionlawblog.org?p=127100 -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Lawfare podcast on ECA reform electionlawblog.org?p=127098
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Excellent @danbalz analysis of a disconcerting development. Wouldn't it be better to pursue statistically sound measures for bipartisan risk-limiting audits, to verify accuracy & integrity of vote tallies?
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/01/22/sundaytake-ele… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I essentially agree with @beckerdavidj here, although I think we need to be a bit more precise in defining the standard for evaluating when certified election results should, or should not, be considered valid exercises of voter choice. See electionlawblog.org?p=126818 & links there.
David Becker
@beckerdavidj
“All elections are legitimate outside of extraordinary circumstances where a court raises questions about the integrity of the election. The threat is real, but until that happens, elections are legitimate and the winners take office. Period." www.cbsnews.com/news/voting-rights-electoral-count-act-ne…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Election Law Blog
@ElectionLawBlog
#elb: “Opinion: When Biden imitates Trump, he is on a dangerous path” electionlawblog.org?p=127088
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is a superb column by @jameshohmann. I agree with it 100%. "When Biden imitates Trump, he is on a dangerous path" www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/01/21/biden-press-co…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Charles Stewart III
@cstewartiii
ICYMI, the Election Science, Reform, and Administration conference is seeking proposals for the summer conference. Propose a paper, or at the very least, plan to attend. pages.charlotte.edu/martha-kropf/election-science-confere…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is another example of the question I plan to ask a lot this year: would it be different if the new Alaska electoral system applied here as well? @rickhasen raises "primary electoral pressures" to explain this; they wouldn't exist in the Alaska system electionlawblog.org?p=127068
-
Ned Foley reposted
Election Law Blog
@ElectionLawBlog
#elb: “McCarthy open to Electoral Count Act reform” electionlawblog.org?p=127062
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Significant development: "McCarthy open to Electoral Count Act reform" www.politico.com/news/2022/01/20/mccarthy-electoral-count… via @politico
-
Ned Foley reposted
Election Law Blog
@ElectionLawBlog
#elb: “As Giuliani coordinated plan for Trump electoral votes in states Biden won, some electors balked” electionlawblog.org?p=127052
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I agree with @rickhasen on this, for reasons I've discussed previously on this topic, including electionlawblog.org?p=126818. It's essential to have a standard by which to judge if an election's outcome doesn't qualify as voters' choice, including because they couldn't cast a ballot.
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
President Biden’s Should Clarify His Remarks on Election Legitimacy and the 2022 Elections. But Even The Troubling Aspects of What He Said Are Nowhere Nearly as Bad as What Trump Repeatedly Has Said About Election Legitimacy electionlawblog.org?p=127041
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Given Biden's comments, also this: "How to tell if an election result is valid?" electionlawblog.org?p=126818, which has links to deeper dives on the topic, including a law review article with an analysis of historical and theoretical considerations relevant to this crucial question.
Grace Panetta
@grace_panetta
Reupping my feature on what a messy contested election in 2022 could look like in light of Biden's comments yesterday suggesting the 2022 elections could be "illegitimate" if voting rights bills (which failed in the Senate just hours later) didn't pass www.businessinsider.com/midterms-could-see-ugly-disputes-…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Charles Stewart III
@cstewartiii
This story is a reminder that red states aren't the only ones where pre-pandemic voting laws are lapsing, thus reducing voter options. www.newstimes.com/news/article/COVID-cannot-be-used-for-a…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Heading towards this year's midterm elections & looking ahead to 2024, there may be no question more important than "How to tell if an election result is valid? (electionlawblog.org?p=126818). It's worth thinking about this analytically in light of this news:
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/01/19/offered-chance… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Alaska Supreme Court upholds electoral reform electionlawblog.org?p=127025
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Important ruling on Ranked Choice Voting.
Matt Acuña Buxton
@mattbuxton
NEWS: The Alaska Supreme Court has issued an order UPHOLDING the slate of election reforms—ranked voting, non-partisan primaries, Gov./Lt. Gov. tickets—approved by voters in 2020, clearing the way for this year's elections.
#akleg #akelect -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
It's necessary to resolve this issue, as it applies to Trump, before the 2024 election (including primaries) begins; otherwise, it's not fair to voters, as discussed here: electionlawblog.org?p=125256
"How Jan. 6 Gave the 14th Amendment New Life" www.nytimes.com/2022/01/19/us/politics/jan-6-attack-14th-… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is a important case. See electionlawblog.org?p=126992
Gavel Alaska
@GavelAlaska
In addition to legislative coverage today, we're live at 1:30 with Alaska Supreme Court hearing oral arguments in a case concerning Alaska's new voting method. Watch here: www.ktoo.org/gavel/video/2022011000/scott-a-kohlhaas-the-…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Grace Panetta
@grace_panetta
"If you think about what kind of election crisis might happen in November of 2022, in front of my mind is the possibility of a genuine fight over the outcome of one of the competitive US Senate races," @Nedfoley said at a recent @ElectionTask event www.businessinsider.com/midterms-could-see-ugly-disputes-…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Grace Panetta
@grace_panetta
Top Senate Republicans don't seem to be sweating too much over that possibility. But as @Nedfoley's "Ballot Battles" recounts in detail, the Senate's track record of resolving election disputes in the 20th century is...not exactly encouraging www.businessinsider.com/midterms-could-see-ugly-disputes-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"Electoral act reform picks up growing bipartisan support" www.axios.com/electoral-reform-bipartisan-support-0b1ffd0…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Michael McGough
@MichaelMcGough3
Is less more on election reform? www.latimes.com/politics/story/2022-01-16/time-to-start-o…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“Time to start over on voting rights and election security” electionlawblog.org?p=126964
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Time to start over on voting rights and election security www.latimes.com/politics/story/2022-01-16/time-to-start-o…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Sam refuses to support Elon's hate-filled platform
@MsSamAdams
@Nedfoley I just read your 2019 paper, Preparing for a Disputed Presidential Election.
One question: Will you pick my lottery numbers?
I thought I was reading an election autopsy until I saw the "fill in the blank" Democrat. Incredible! -
Ned Foley reposted
Matthew A. Seligman
@Matt_Seligman
The unavoidable task in ECA reform, then, is a project in relative risk assessment.
-
Ned Foley reposted
Matthew A. Seligman
@Matt_Seligman
The staff report shares that guiding principle, as do others who have written on this like @Nedfoley, @rickhasen, @lessig, @michaelmorley11, Rick Pildes, Michael McConnell, and more.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I was honored to be part of this conversation. I think it was very constructive and worth a listen, if you are interested in protecting the integrity of the electoral process.
National Constitution Center
@ConstitutionCtr
On this week’s #wtppodcast, @OhioState’s @Nedfoley and @CapitalLaw’s Brad Smith (@CommishSmith) dive into the history of the Electoral Count Act and discuss proposals for reforming it with host @RosenJeffrey.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“The Case for Reforming the Electoral Count Act” electionlawblog.org?p=126935
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Rick Pildes provides a very helpful overview of the important House staff report released yesterday: "Analysis of the House Committee’s Proposals for Electoral Count Act Reform" electionlawblog.org?p=126922
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“Chairperson Lofgren Releases Staff Report On The Electoral Count Act” electionlawblog.org?p=126909
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Paging @michaelmorley11: new section 3411 relates to your ssrn.com/abstract=3694839 & cites the LBJ Ballot Box 13 case, as well as the 2018 Fifth Circuit case, Keyes v Gunn, which you write about.
Also, @rickhasen @ProfNickStephan, have you seen anyone list all the new provisions? -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Useful analysis by @Nate_Cohn, but one note: "if state officials invalidated or overturned the result of a free and fair election without violating state laws," this would still violate federal Equal Protection, which fed courts would have duty to remedy. www.nytimes.com/2022/01/12/us/politics/biden-voting-right…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
How to guarantee the right to cast a ballot? electionlawblog.org?p=126888
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Great job by @rickhasen with @smerconish summarizing the case why right now combatting the risk of election subversion, including reform of Electoral Count Act, is top priority & why ECA reform must be bipartisan. Yes we must protect casting ballots, but focus on greater risk now
Michael Smerconish
@smerconish
ENCORE: Welcoming @rickhasen back to @SXMPOTUS @SIRIUSXM to discuss: www.nytimes.com/2022/01/07/opinion/trump-democracy-voting…
-
Ned Foley reposted
The New Republic
@newrepublic
“It’s just a dense morass of verbiage that is very hard to understand, which is dangerous because the role that it’s supposed to play is to provide clarity.”
— @Nedfoley on an 1887 law that still governs aspects of the electoral count:
newrepublic.com/article/164989/bipartisan-reform-electora… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I share @ProfNickStephan's concern, but courts will constrain rogue state actors trying to distort tally of ballots: Bush v Gore. Bigger concern is state legislatures attempting to appoint electors directly, after popular vote already held & counted. Only ECA reform can fix that.
Nicholas Stephanopoulos
@ProfNickStephan
I'm very concerned about state legislatures, too! A worry about ECA reform is that it stops congressional hijinks but doesn't do anything about state-level election subversion.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
ECA reform & Article II electionlawblog.org?p=126876
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
McConnell: Rounds 'told the truth' about 2020 election thehill.com/homenews/senate/589309-mcconnell-rounds-told-…
Good for McConnell to defend Rounds, the truth, and acceptance of his party’s defeat (which is essential for a democracy to function). -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
My fear: voters will be able to cast ballots, courts will insist the ballots be counted correctly, but Congress (controlled by partisans) will nullify the results (as some members tried on 1/6/21) & SCOTUS on Political Question grounds won't stop Congress. electionlawblog.org?p=126847
Renuka Rayasam
@renurayasam
Tonight I wrote about the democracy crisis Biden didn’t address w/ help from @Nedfoley and @nyulaw’s Richard Pildes www.politico.com/newsletters/politico-nightly/2022/01/11/… via @politico
-
Ned Foley reposted
Renuka Rayasam
@renurayasam
Tonight I wrote about the democracy crisis Biden didn’t address w/ help from @Nedfoley and @nyulaw’s Richard Pildes www.politico.com/newsletters/politico-nightly/2022/01/11/… via @politico
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If McConnell approves an ECA reform bill, we have to hope a GOP House on 1/6/2025 wouldn't nix it. It's key to consider the role of the House & Speaker under 12th & 20th Amendments, & try to lock in ECA reform now with greatest chance of restraining a rogue GOP House on 1/6/2025.
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
If---miraculously---10 Republican Senators agreed to vote for ECA reform, how many Republicans would vote for such reform in the House?
If the number is very low (as I suspect it would be), is that bipartisan enough?
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Details reported by @ThePlumLineGS are interesting. The piece ends by suggesting a filibuster carve-out for ECA reform. That won't work for technical reasons explained here (and in the linked piece): electionlawblog.org?p=126847. ECA reform must be bipartisan.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/01/11/new-proposal-e… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Details reported by @ThePlumLineGS are interesting. The piece ends by suggesting a filibuster carve-out for ECA reform. That won't work for technical reasons explained here (and in the linked piece): electionlawblog.org?p=126847. ECA reform must be bipartisan.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/01/11/new-proposal-e… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Always essential to read @derektmuller on this topic!
-
Ned Foley reposted
Election Law Blog
@ElectionLawBlog
#elb: WaPo “Factchecker” on “Jim Crow 2.0” Senate debate electionlawblog.org?p=126861
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
WaPo “Factchecker” on “Jim Crow 2.0” Senate debate electionlawblog.org?p=126861
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
We need more GOP leaders to speak up for electoral honesty like this: “if we’re being honest, there was no evidence of widespread fraud that would have altered the results of the election.” thehill.com/homenews/senate/589092-rounds-doesnt-back-dow…
-
Ned Foley reposted
LarryDiamond
@LarryDiamond
As @Nedfoley argues here, reform of the antiquated and impossibly vague Electoral Count Act "is essential whether or not Democrats are able to achieve their other voting rights goals." Democrats should seize the opportunity now for bipartisan action.
www.acslaw.org/expertforum/reforming-the-electoral-count-… As -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
ECA reform must be bipartisan electionlawblog.org?p=126847
-
Ned Foley reposted
Nick Troiano
@NickTroiano
"I’m even more convinced than I was a year ago that if we are going to solve the Big Lie problem, we must solve the 'Primary Problem.'" - @Nedfoley 💯
electionlawblog.org?p=126731 -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Just think if this Alabama Senate election used Alaska’s new procedures (top 4 in nonpartisan primary go to general election with RCV). The race would be very different (with Trump’s role diminished). thehill.com/homenews/campaign/588827-alabama-gop-gears-fo…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Election Law Blog
@ElectionLawBlog
#elb: “The Bad Deal Democrats Should Take; Electoral-count reform is a narrow fix, insufficient for the many problems in the voting system—but it’s better than nothing at all.” electionlawblog.org?p=126831
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Best line in this book review: “'Dude, I voted for the same guy you did. I’m just telling you it wasn’t stolen; these ballots weren’t illegally cast.'” Goal for future elections: creating conditions that will enable this kind of thing to be said repeatedly
www.nytimes.com/2022/01/04/books/review/the-steal-mark-bo… -
Ned Foley reposted
Election Law Blog
@ElectionLawBlog
#elb: “Democracy is on the brink of disaster. For voters, it’s politics as usual.” electionlawblog.org?p=126812
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
@rickhasen and I are on the same page here about steps to prevent election subversion (losers declared winners) being Job One of democracy protection at this moment. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/01/mcconnell-elect…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Barton Gellman
@bartongellman
Video and transcript of a really good discussion with
@tnyCloseRead @Nedfoley and @LilyMasonPhD on democracy at @CFR_org is now posted. www.cfr.org/event/renewing-america-series-growing-divide-… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Superb essay by @rickhasen Let’s hope it can be a blueprint for safeguarding elections in this perilous period, which remains dominated by the corrosive effects of Trump’s Big Lie about 2020. www.nytimes.com/2022/01/07/opinion/trump-democracy-voting…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
It's crucial to resolve the issue of Trump's eligibility to hold office again BEFORE the 2024 campaign starts; otherwise, it's unfair to voters & could lead to a crisis on 1/6/25 if Dems in Congress refuse to accept his win (see: electionlawblog.org?p=125256).
thehill.com/policy/national-security/588489-democrats-qui… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/ This from @peterbakernyt is key: "Those who speak against him are purged, and his endorsement is the most coveted asset in almost any Republican primary." If election law scholars were MDs, this would be the diagnosis of the disease afflicting democracy
www.nytimes.com/2022/01/06/us/politics/jan-6-capitol-riot…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/ So what's the cure for this disease? It must include structural reform of the electoral process that prevents Trump from controlling which GOP candidates get on the Nov ballot for general-election voters to pick. For more on this (& links to even more): electionlawblog.org?p=126731
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The fact that Dems are able to counter-gerrymander does not, in my view, make gerrymandering any less anti-democratic (small-d). It's still partisan distortion of districts.
“Surprise: Democrats dodged a gerrymandering fiasco. A top analyst explains why.” electionlawblog.org?p=126711 -
Ned Foley reposted
All Sides
@WOSUAllSides
Tomorrow marks one year since a pro-Trump mob marched on the U.S. Capitol.
We take a look at what happened that day and what is being done to ensure it never happens again w/ @Rho_Co, @kyledcheney, & @Nedfoley. Listen live at 10 a.m.
wosu.pm/3eUEzxm -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I'm delighted to be able to collaborate with my three co-authors on this bipartisan basis for reforming the Electoral Count Act: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/01/04/congress-fix-e…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Very helpful chart from my colleague @chris_j_walker; check out the whole piece from which it comes!
Chris Walker
@chris_j_walker
Our toolkit is summarized in the following table from the draft paper (ssrn.com/abstract=3941605):
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/4 @ruleandruin @AlexKeyssar & David Kennedy's contributions stand out for me among this impressive collection: www.politico.com/news/magazine/2021/12/29/how-will-the-hi…
Post not available here, view on X
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
3/3 @AlexKeyssar rightly emphasizes the danger that "one of the two major American political parties had abandoned the principle of majority rule and devoted itself to durably gaining, or retaining, power with the support of only a minority of the electorate."
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
4/4 David Kennedy captures the mood of the moment, observing: "To a striking degree, Americans had become distrustful people, with scant confidence in their institutions and waning trust in each other."
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Must-Read essay by Rick Pildes on the difficult condition Western democracies, including the US, are in. Institutional reform is needed to address this. A majority-winner rule & especially Round-Robin Voting might help; worth trying go.osu.edu/mwr
www.nytimes.com/2021/12/29/opinion/democracy-fragmentatio… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Key is to adjudicate before 2024 whether Trump is disqualified to serve again, as discussed here: electionlawblog.org?p=125256. It would be better for DOJ to do this in a civil suit authorized by Congress; criminal prosecution is fallback if Congress won't act.
www.nytimes.com/2021/12/23/opinion/trump-capitol-riot-jan… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Where does the urgent work of democracy protection stand at the end of 2021 as a result of what Democrats in Congress have done this year? (& if it's completely stalled with no forward moment in sight, is it time for a strategic rethink to avoid failure?) electionlawblog.org?p=126453
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I agree with @rickhasen that this is an important, & frightening, year-end summary of where things stand on this most crucial of issues: the fate of self-government in the US. Must-Listen at NPR: “The clear and present danger of Trump’s enduring ‘Big Lie'” electionlawblog.org?p=126466
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Could bipartisan democracy-protection have worked? Could it still? electionlawblog.org?p=126453
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Yes, there are Republicans who oppose sensible efforts to protect democracy. But the Democratic Party's go-it-alone strategy hasn't worked. Dems should've tried to forge deal with McConnell for reforms to protect GOP from Trump, like majority-winner rule: go.osu.edu/mwr.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This sums up my thinking why 2021 was a missed opportunity for the kind of electoral reform necessary to safeguard democracy from the ongoing threat that Trump presents. Spoiler alert: Democrats barked up the wrong tree; should’ve chased structural reform. electionlawblog.org?p=126436
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Trump’s primary power electionlawblog.org?p=126436
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“As the GOP sheds its moderates, a whirlwind approaches” electionlawblog.org?p=126418
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“Republicans Should Help Reform the Electoral Count Act “ electionlawblog.org?p=126392 I agree with Rick Pildes on this.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
NPV effort in Michigan won’t affect 2024 election electionlawblog.org?p=126357
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Some Electoral College math electionlawblog.org?p=126333
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
What @Edsall describes is why I advocate "round-robin voting" (see go.osu.edu/terrp) & especially a majority-winner rule for congressional elections (see go.osu.edu/mwr). US democracy is NOT "past the point of no return" if we can do this.
www.nytimes.com/2021/12/15/opinion/republicans-democracy-… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Electoral College changes before 2024? electionlawblog.org?p=126310
-
Ned Foley reposted
Chris Elmendorf
@CSElmendorf
Everyone freaked out by @DLeonhardt's terrifying synopsis of the antidemocratic movement must read @Nedfoley's brilliant new paper making case for round-robin primary elections.
I can't think of a more timely & important law review article. Ever. 1/n
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3890246 -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Plurality versus Majority electionlawblog.org?p=126250
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If you're concerned about election subversion & see David Perdue as a prime example of this risk, you should think about the idea of "round robin voting" as an antidote to this risk. For more, see this explanation & link to paper: electionlawblog.org?p=126211
www.axios.com/david-perdue-georgia-2020-election-certific… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
David Perdue and Round-Robin Voting electionlawblog.org?p=126211
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Why would executive privilege cover talk between Trump & Meadows about electoral votes, when a president has no official role in Congress's receipt & counting of electoral votes, but is interested solely as a candidate (no different than a non-incumbent)?
www.nytimes.com/2021/12/08/us/politics/mark-meadows-conte… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Tournament Elections with Round-Robin Primaries (published version) electionlawblog.org?p=126205
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Key point from this new analysis (echoing previous pieces observing the same dangerous development for democracy): "the number of competitive House districts — which has been on the decline for several decades now — is on track to hit a new low." 53eig.ht/3ocafUo
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The loss of competitive districts–and maybe democracy electionlawblog.org?p=125905
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Loss of competitive districts is very worrisome. It makes elections seem pointless: why bother to vote if outcome is foreordained? Incumbents cater to extremes in their base, making governance harder. Goal becomes power for its own sake, not public good. www.politico.com/news/2021/11/19/kiss-your-swing-district…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Very useful: www.politico.com/news/2021/10/28/virginia-vote-count-gove…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
How best to safeguard democracy? Two conflicting views on recent display. electionlawblog.org?p=125285
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
What democracy-protection measures can overcome the filibuster obstacle one way or another? One idea (electionlawblog.org?p=125256) is a law to enforce 14th Amendment's sec. 3, so it doesn't become an issue on 1/6/2025 (when filibuster doesn't apply). Doable?
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/biden-democracy-eroding/2… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Talk of Trump running in 2024 assumes he’s eligible to serve if reelected. He’s not, or at least there’s a strong argument he isn’t. In fairness to voters, this ought to be resolved in court before voters cast their ballots in 2024—not on Jan 6, 2025. See electionlawblog.org?p=125256
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment and January 6, 2025: the need for legislation now electionlawblog.org?p=125256
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Don’t miss @danbalz on Wisconsin: www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/10/08/wisconsin-pola…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“The imminent impact of redistricting: sharper partisan elbows, less compromise by both sides in the House” www.washingtonpost.com/politics/redistricting-partisanshi…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Maybe Trump isn't any more successful on 1/6/2025 than 1/6/2021, but it's still important to prepare for the risk that he might be. There are specific steps Congress can & should take to reduce this risk, including reform of inadequate Electoral Count Act. www.nytimes.com/2021/10/05/opinion/trump-2024.html
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
What's evidence Liz Cheney won't vote for bill to protect vote-counting or reform of Electoral Count Act? Key @rickhasen point: "considering voting rights issues separately from anti-subversion issues increases chance for bipartisan compromise on latter." www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/09/29/stolen-election…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I agree with @rickhasen that an anti-subversion bill should get some GOP votes, even if filibuster reform is needed. A Democrats-only bill risks increasing Big Lie 2.0 claims that could cause the kind of election subversion the bill is meant to stop.
www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/09/29/stolen-election… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Opinion | The three fixes Congress should make to save democracy www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/09/28/three-fixes-co…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Election Law Blog
@ElectionLawBlog
#elb: Now Available: Full Video of the “Election Subversion: Is American Democracy in Danger?” Conference Held Sept. 24 by UCI Law’s Fair Elections and Free Speech Center electionlawblog.org?p=124864
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The advantage of a simple majority-winner rule enacted by Congress is that it permits states to choose which majority-winner system they want. Those that, like you, prefer IRV can have that. But if ranked-choice ballots are too novel for some states, they can choose CA-like top-2
James Joyner
@DrJJoyner
I hate the California system, which gives parties even less control. But am very much in favor of IRV or even old-style runoffs.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Different ways to have a majority-winner rule: CA's top-2 system, Ranked Choice Voting as in Maine or Alaska, St. Louis approval voting, or new Round-Robin Voting. All better than plurality-winner elections. go.osu.edu/mwr go.osu.edu/terrp go.osu.edu/mwwp
James Joyner
@DrJJoyner
How would we manage ballot access in such a system? Why bother to run in primaries at all, considering the expense?
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Liz Cheney wouldn't have to win the GOP primary if Congress required general-election winners to get a majority, not plurality, of votes. Then, she could run in the general without worrying about primary. A majority-winner rule would safeguard democracy.
thehill.com/homenews/campaign/573882-cheney-allies-flock-… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I agree with @rickhasen on this: "I thought that Democrats wasted months on the For the People Act,” “The Democrats’ answer … is ‘Well, the Democrats just have to win elections.’ There needs to be a plan B to that.” www.politico.com/news/magazine/2021/09/26/trump-politics-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This essay should convince everyone, if they weren't convinced already, of the importance of the topic of today's conference, on the risk of election subversion, organized by @rickhasen (electionlawblog.org?p=124779)
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/09/23/robert-kagan-c… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This story explains the reason for today's conference on the risk of election subversion (electionlawblog.org?p=124779)
www.vice.com/en/article/g5gawj/trump-endorsing-candidates… -
Ned Foley reposted
Cameron Joseph
@cam_joseph
Election law experts are alarmed.
“There is a serious risk that if big lie candidates like Jody Hice and others who embrace the big lie can gain power at the state level and in Congress they will use that power to perpetuate big lie 2.0 on January 6, 2025,” said @Nedfoley. -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This essay makes a powerful case. I don’t agree with every detail, but I do share the basic concern, sense of urgency, and belief that the solution requires a coalition of pro-democracy Republicans and Democrats. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/09/23/robert-kagan-c…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Washington Post Opinions
@PostOpinions
Senate Democrats are making a tactical mistake by including same-day registration in their compromise voting rights bill, @NedFoley writes www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/09/20/is-same-day-vo…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Great piece by Charles Lane, especially because it cites Arrow's Theorem. "It's complicated," Lane rightly writes about designing democratic electoral procedures. Still, some procedures are better than others. Plurality-winner elections are bad for USA now www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/09/21/canadas-non-ty…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
It's worth reading the last line of this article. Spoiler alert: Trump campaign had no evidence that election wasn't stolen, and thus thought it okay to assert, without any evidence, that it was stolen. The Big Lie seems built on this flimsiest of grounds. www.nytimes.com/2021/09/21/us/politics/trump-dominion-vot…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is important point if accurate. I'm not sure I know what the votes would be on 1/6/2025. It depends on a lot of specific factors, which we can't know now. If Hayes-Tilden dispute remains relevant, partisan dynamics involved in an all-out fight to control outcome are complex.
b_pet
@Greenspan_
Every single R in the House will pull the the trigger? I doubt it. A third or whatever would vote with the Dems, just as they did in 2020. It’s sad that it’s only a third, but there is no hypothetical majority for stealing a pres election. Voters in those states would flip out.
-
Ned Foley reposted
Jonathan H. Adler
@jadler1969
The Eastman Memo—Poor Lawyering for a Disreputable Cause reason.com/volokh/2021/09/21/the-eastman-memo-poor-lawyer… via @reason @VolokhC
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Initial Reaction to Eastman Memo electionlawblog.org?p=124705
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Succinct summary of the "electoral McCarthyism" conditions currently at work; how they affect not just the past, but potentially the future (unless and until this collective reality-denialism of "electoral McCarthyism" ends): www.politico.com/news/2021/09/20/election-fraud-conspirac… via @politico
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Freedom to Vote bill & democracy-protection electionlawblog.org?p=124697
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Opinion | Is same-day voter registration good? Yes. Is it essential? Probably not. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/09/20/is-same-day-vo…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
What’s best way to avoid Congress on 1/6/2025 negating valid victory for Dem prez nominee? It’s reducing the chances “Big Lie” candidates like Mo Brooks & Josh Mandel win seats in Congress even though majority of November voters would prefer non-“Big Lie” GOP candidates, but …
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
… Nov. voters can’t vote for non-“Big Lie” GOP candidates because “Big Lie” candidates win GOP primary. How to solve this? By having all Nov. voters choose between “Big Lie” & non-“Big Lie” GOP opponents and requiring Nov. winner to get majority not just plurality. This lets …
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
…non-“Big Lie” GOP candidates show that 1-on-1 majority of all Nov. voters prefer them to plurality-getting “Big Lie” opponents (because Nov. voters who like Dem candidates most prefer non-“Big Lie” to “Big Lie” GOP alternatives).This is how best to protect 2024 from Big Lie 2.0
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Sen. Klobuchar, like others for the Freedom to Vote bill, are equating democracy-protection with making it as easy as possible to cast a ballot. They aren’t exactly the same. Thinking they are risks failing to do what’s essential to avoid losing democracy. www.msnbc.com/the-sunday-show/watch/sen-klobuchar-breaks-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Possible election reforms fall into 4 groups: (1) help avoid election subversion & don't harm voting rights; (2) make it easier to vote but don't help avoid election subversion; (3) make it easier to vote at risk of more election subversion & aren't essential for voting rights...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
...(4) increase risk of election subversion but essential for voting rights. In my view, given current threat, (1) is essential; also (4) despite risk, but only if it's true that without (4) there's no more voting rights. (3) is mistake right now given threat; wish it weren't...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
(2) is risky as legislative priority insofar as it crowds out (1) & (4). My fear is Dems in Congress are at risk of pursuing (2) at expense of making sure to do (1). I also fear Dems are pursuing (3) in mistaken belief they are pursuing (4). Upshot worse for anti-subversion goal?
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Federalism answer to @ProfNickStephan: Congress shouldn't require approval voting, Borda count, etc. But Congress should enact majority-winner rule to end plurality-winner elections, letting states pick which majority-winner system. go.osu.edu/mwr go.osu.edu/mwwp
Nicholas Stephanopoulos
@ProfNickStephan
Or if Ohio had proportional representation, or a jungle primary, or approval voting, or a Borda count . . . But it's hard to criticize the FTVA for not mandating these things when the political support for them isn't there (and when the FTVA does *so* many other good things).
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If Ohio had Round-Robin Voting, go.osu.edu/terrp (paper) & go.osu.edu/rrv (video), Gonzalez wouldn't have to win a Trump-dominated GOP primary. Instead he could've proven that he'd beat one-on-one BOTH a Trump-backed opponent & a Democrat.
www.politico.com/news/2021/09/17/gonzalez-trump-effect-51… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If GOP moderates want to solve this problem, they'd join with Dems to enact a majority-winner rule (see go.osu.edu/mwr). This would enable Liz Cheney, etc., to win in November even if can't win GOP primary & wouldn't be November plurality winner.
www.politico.com/news/2021/09/17/gonzalez-trump-effect-51… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If Ohio had Round-Robin Voting, go.osu.edu/terrp (paper) & go.osu.edu/rrv (video), Gonzalez wouldn't have to win a Trump-dominated GOP primary. Instead he could've proven that he'd beat one-on-one BOTH a Trump-backed opponent & a Democrat.
www.politico.com/news/2021/09/17/gonzalez-trump-effect-51… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"Never Trumpers sink into gloom as Gonzalez bows out." There are remedies for this: a majority-winner rule & specifically Round-Robin Voting (form of ranked-choice voting). See my 2 most recent papers: go.osu.edu/ebfssrn Also: electionlawblog.org?p=124641
thehill.com/homenews/the-memo/572838-the-memo-never-trump… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
A majority-winner rule for general elections would redress this: “House GOP Conference will almost certainly be more Trumpy after the 2022 midterms as critics like Gonzalez head for the exits and Trump acolytes win primary races, a then general elections.” thehill.com/homenews/campaign/572798-emboldened-trump-tak…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Democracy Protection Requires More than Voting Rights electionlawblog.org?p=124660
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is why I prioritize a majority-winner rule; plurality-winner elections cause this danger. Protecting casting & counting ballots is not enough a remedy. “‘Incredibly dangerous’: Trump is trying to get Big Lie promoters chosen to run the 2024 election” electionlawblog.org?p=124649
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Some good news on the Electoral McCarthyism front: "Youngkin breaks with Trump on whether Democrats will cheat in the Virginia governor's race"; also: "both candidates said they would accept the other as the legitimately elected governor if the other won." thehill.com/homenews/campaign/572697-youngkin-breaks-with…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The “Portman problem” is now also the “Gonzales problem” electionlawblog.org?p=124641
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
What I call "the Portman problem"--as in this #elb post today: electionlawblog.org?p=124633 --could also be called the "Gonzales problem," especially after this news: www.nytimes.com/2021/09/16/us/politics/anthony-gonzalez-o… If this problem is to be solved, it's by the majority-winner rule I describe in the blog post.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Here are my further thoughts in light of @ed_kilgore's response to my #elb blog: electionlawblog.org?p=124633
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
In which @ed_kilgore responds to @Nedfoley's #elb blog post on whether Democrats should go it alone on election reform: nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/09/democrats-surrendering-on…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Democrats, democracy, and “the Portman problem” electionlawblog.org?p=124633
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Freedom to Vote Act and Same-Day Registration? electionlawblog.org?p=124561
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This says new bill requires same-day registration. True? Didn’t see that in other reports. Any publicly available copy of bill or official summary? Thanks. www.npr.org/2021/09/14/1036812609/senate-democrats-offer-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
How best to end “Electoral McCarthyism”? electionlawblog.org?p=124540
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The problem of "electoral McCarthyism" seems to be growing and spreading. We are going to need to figure out a way to end this, as we ended the "Red Scare" version of McCarthyism, or else we'll be incapable of government by democratic elections. www.nytimes.com/2021/09/12/us/politics/gop-voter-fraud-ca…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
GOOD NEWS: @derektmuller updates previous post “Texas enacted SB 598, which includes a paper audit requirement and a risk-limiting audit” electionlawblog.org?p=124433. This is very positive as way to verify vote counts.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Thanks to @derektmuller for pointing out: "The disappearance of a paper ballot requirement in Texas’s SB 1" electionlawblog.org?p=124390 As he says, this is a particularly pernicious development: paper ballots, or paper records of electronic ballots, is what enables a verifiable audit
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
We need to pay attention to chain-of-custody, paper trails (or paper ballots), and other rules that assure verifiable election results--so that both parties can trust that their opponents have not wrongfully distorted vote tallies: www.nytimes.com/2021/09/01/us/politics/gop-us-election-se…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I've posted a new draft of "Tournament Elections with Round-Robin Primaries: A Sports Analogy for Election Reform": ssrn.com/abstract=3890246. For 2022 races with GOP primary fights between Trump & non-Trump candidates (like Liz Cheney's seat), what would happen if TERRP were used?
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Federal judge in Michigan orders pro-Trump lawyers disciplined over lawsuit seeking to overturn 2020 election www.washingtonpost.com/politics/federal-judge-in-michigan…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
A useful heads-up: www.politico.com/news/2021/08/19/arizona-audit-elections-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Newsom recall lawsuit electionlawblog.org?p=124129
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Useful overview: "On The Trail: Census kicks off a wild redistricting cycle" thehill.com/homenews/campaign/567781-on-the-trail-census-…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Dan Balz
@danbalz
BREAKING: Texas Senate passes bill with new voting restrictions after a Democrat filibustered for 15 hours to try to stop the measure
By @EvaRuth @eliseviebeck
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/texas-senate-voting-bill/… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I want to acknowledge @Redistrict as the source for the point about Texas (that redistricting will have bigger effect than changes to rules for casting ballots): x.com/Redistrict/status/1414952280877674499
www.nytimes.com/2021/08/11/us/politics/census-redistricti…
Dave Wasserman
@Redistrict
The truth is that redistricting is likely to have an infinitely bigger impact on TX’s political future than proposed restrictions on voting procedures (which may be born of ill intent but I see as having negligible partisan impact).
-
Ned Foley reposted
Nicholas Stephanopoulos
@ProfNickStephan
Does anyone have the text of the anti-gerrymandering bill that Schumer proposed early this morning (and Cruz blocked)? (Is there actual text?)
@StevenTDennis @grace_panetta @hugolowell -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/3 A September Senate vote is challenging for redistricting reform; with census data to be released tomorrow, states will start drawing maps. In theory, Congress could preempt those maps with a new federal law, assuming a way to overcome a filibuster, ... thehill.com/homenews/senate/567290-schumer-sets-september…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/3 ...but timing is tricky. There'd likely be litigation on whether the new law was too late to change maps for 2022 midterms. But the stakes are high enough to be worth the fight. Otherwise, gerrymandered maps may control composition of Congress. Also, one encouraging detail...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
3/3 ... in this Hill piece: Schumer floated stand-alone redistricting bill, separate from S1. This would be smart in September too; if Senate can convert to a "talking filibuster," it might be hard for GOP to sustain a defense over their desire to protect unfair gerrymandering.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Colorado Redistricting & Competitiveness electionlawblog.org?p=124004
-
Ned Foley reposted
Mike on the Mic🏴☠️🐉🗡🇺🇸
@mlatner
@Nedfoley with the sharp analysis. Our new book demonstrates that the consequences of gerrymandering through single-seat districts has deep social and political costs for the US www.cambridge.org/core/books/gerrymandering-the-states/27… www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/08/09/house-represen…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
House elections are unnecessarily uncompetitive electionlawblog.org?p=123994
-
Ned Foley reposted
Deb Otis
@DebTheOtis
Multi-member districts can disenfranchise voters if they're winner-take-all districts. But they don't have to be! MMDs with proportional ranked choice voting, like in the Fair Rep Act, will improve representation. www.fairvote.org/fair_rep_in_congress
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The House is supposed to represent the people. It doesn’t. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/08/09/house-represen…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Washington Post Opinions
@PostOpinions
Every lost life on Jan. 6 should be mourned. But the rioters on Jan. 6 were not heroes or martyrs, the Editorial Board writes www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/08/06/every-lost-lif…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Columbus Dispatch
@DispatchAlerts
Ohio is using a new process to draw state, congressional districts. Here's how it works www.dispatch.com/story/news/2021/08/06/ohio-redistricting…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Gerrymandering the Presidency Without a Coup electionlawblog.org?p=123907
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
It wasn’t just the mob. Government insiders tried to keep Trump in power, too. - The Washington Post www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/08/05/trump-doj-coup/
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
American voters largely united against partisan gerrymandering, polling shows - thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/566327-american-voters-l…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Redistricting battles kick off early as Democrats scramble to try to cut into GOP advantages www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021-redistricting-lawsui…
-
Ned Foley reposted
Jennifer Morrell
@votinggeek
Please download and read!!
✅ Chain of custody plays an important role in security & risk mitigation for ALL critical infrastructure sectors.
✅ Without secure chain of custody practices, systems & assets could be unknowingly accessed and manipulated by threat actors. @CISAgov
Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency
@CISAgov
Today, we released a new CISA Insights: Chain of Custody and Critical Infrastructure Systems, which helps critical infrastructure owners and operators understand how to secure chain of custody for their physical and digital assets.
Learn more: www.cisa.gov/publication/chain-custody-and-critical-infra… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Smart analysis with useful details: nymag.com/intelligencer/article/will-republicans-gerryman…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This piece by @davidfrum captures well why I'm worried about the honesty of vote-counting, and the acceptance of valid election results, in 2022 and especially 2024.
David Frum
@davidfrum
Last exit from Trump and Trumpism, my latest for @TheAtlantic
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Extremely worrisome: Threats of violence spark fear of election worker exodus - thehill.com/homenews/campaign/565722-threats-of-violence-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Manchin “can’t imagine” a filibuster exception for voting rights electionlawblog.org?p=123764
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Dan Balz on DOJ notes: more to learn electionlawblog.org?p=123762
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
House readies John Lewis bill electionlawblog.org?p=123760
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
No vacation w/o voting reform electionlawblog.org?p=123758
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
DOJ backs Congress in Trump tax return fight electionlawblog.org?p=123756
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Politico links to the DOJ notes electionlawblog.org?p=123754
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Trump didn’t fight release of DOJ notes electionlawblog.org?p=123752
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
DOJ took notes of Trump’s efforts to subvert 2020 result electionlawblog.org?p=123750
-
Ned Foley reposted
Grace Panetta
@grace_panetta
Clyburn says "there's tremendous support" in the Dem caucus for expanding Section 5 preclearance to all 50 states
-
Ned Foley reposted
Jonathan Lai 🙊 賴柏羽
@Elaijuh
Philly elections officials will vote today on updating their mail ballot envelopes to make the signature box and date line blue — so it stands out — and add arrows to them.
The goal: Get voters’ attention to minimize the number of unsigned and undated ballots they reject. -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
MyPillow’s CEO is at it again electionlawblog.org?p=123748
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Michigan Mess: Internecine War in GOP electionlawblog.org?p=123746
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Dems Attempt to Jumpstart S1 electionlawblog.org?p=123744
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
DOJ Task Force to Protect Election Workers electionlawblog.org?p=123740
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/6 Select Committee Still Planning Its Investigation electionlawblog.org?p=123729
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
New details on Trump’s efforts to get Acting AG Rosen to assist his election subversion efforts. electionlawblog.org?p=123727
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
A call for pro-democracy journalism electionlawblog.org?p=123723
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Arizona “audit” update: GOP go-between quits electionlawblog.org?p=123719
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Georgia may not be done revising its election laws electionlawblog.org?p=123717
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
S1 v2: Senate revisits electoral reform electionlawblog.org?p=123715
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
New DOJ warning on pseudo-audits & voting laws electionlawblog.org?p=123713
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Two excellent podcasts on yesterday’s 1/6 hearing electionlawblog.org?p=123707
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Imagine that there had been adequate security on 1/6 & riot quickly quashed without breach of Capitol. There still would be just as much threat to future elections from Trump's Big Lie & his current effort to create conditions that would permit negating vote tallies he dislikes.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
DOJ Refuses to Defend Rep. Brooks electionlawblog.org?p=123703
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/6/21 versus 1/6/25? electionlawblog.org?p=123701
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
January 6 Select Committee Gets Started; will it address the threat next time (as well as what happened this time)? electionlawblog.org?p=123697
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Breaking round-robin ties (in sports and voting) electionlawblog.org?p=123695
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Preview of select committee’s hearing electionlawblog.org?p=123691
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
NFRPP Discussion of S1/HR1 electionlawblog.org?p=123689
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
USA is undefeated after round robin in Olympic softball. In round-robin voting, a candidate who beats all others is called a "Condorcet winner"; but in Olympics, round-robin winner must play a 1-on-1 final match against round-robin runner-up; same here: ssrn.com/abstract=3890246
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The structure of Olympic competition in women's softball is similar to the proposed system of Tournament Elections with Robin-Robin Primaries ssrn.com/abstract=3890246: first a round-robin, followed by a 1-on-1 match between the top 2 from the round-robin. www.sportingnews.com/us/athletics/news/olympic-softball-2…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Panic setting in over new voting rules electionlawblog.org?p=123676
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Could you withstand the pressure? electionlawblog.org?p=123655
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The Big Lie and January 6 electionlawblog.org?p=123653
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
State-Districts Competitiveness Gap electionlawblog.org?p=123651
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Electoral McCarthyism on display electionlawblog.org?p=123647
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
If you like round-robin competition as the first stage of Olympic soccer, you should consider round-robin voting as the first stage of a tournament-style electoral system: ssrn.com/abstract=3890246
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“Accelerating Election Science” electionlawblog.org?p=123639
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
House hearing on election subversion electionlawblog.org?p=123637
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Trump’s efforts to “primary” Cheney electionlawblog.org?p=123630
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The latest on battle for electoral reform electionlawblog.org?p=123628
-
Ned Foley reposted
NFRPP
@nfrpp
Reminder: NFRPP July 22 Event Notice - For the People Act (HR.1/S.1) Unpacked mailchi.mp/b6523e46be69/nfrpp-event-notice-1688048
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
A positive bipartisan development electionlawblog.org?p=123626
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
We are not in Walter Cronkite’s world electionlawblog.org?p=123620
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Pew survey: views on voting electionlawblog.org?p=123618
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
House Hardball, part 2 electionlawblog.org?p=123614
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Will Pelosi add Kinzinger to the January 6 select committee? electionlawblog.org?p=123608
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Trump on tape about Jefferson & 1800 election electionlawblog.org?p=123605
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Collateral damage from ersatz audits electionlawblog.org?p=123603
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Brennan Center Updates Report electionlawblog.org?p=123599
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Nuanced Analysis of New Laws electionlawblog.org?p=123593
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Bloomberg Investigates Voter Fraud electionlawblog.org?p=123591
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“The Democracy Constitution” proposal electionlawblog.org?p=123589
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Can House hardball end gerrymandering? electionlawblog.org?p=123575
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
House terms are too short electionlawblog.org?p=123583
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
You can’t have elections without election officials electionlawblog.org?p=123573
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“21st Century Jim Crow” or Electoral McCarthyism? electionlawblog.org?p=123571
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Pelosi rejects Banks & Jordan for 1/6 committee electionlawblog.org?p=123569
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
DOJ Will Not Prosecute Trump Officials After IG Referred Findings of False Testimony on Census electionlawblog.org?p=123512 [the report linked to has been updated with a correction, which is now noted on #elb]
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Tournament Elections with Round-Robin Primaries electionlawblog.org?p=123555
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Congratulations to @rickhasen on this great news: electionlawblog.org?p=123550
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Report on the Georgia hearing; what’s next? electionlawblog.org?p=123546
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Effect of Primaries on Electoral Outcomes? electionlawblog.org?p=123516
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/2 First reference (that I heard) to redistricting & partisan gerrymandering in today's Senate Rules Committee hearing: the argument that GOP state legislatures are adopting restrictive voting laws in order to assure control of redistricting. ... electionlawblog.org?p=123502
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/2 ... If this correct, it underscores the need for Congress to enact a bill to combat partisan gerrymandering before the new maps get drawn for the 2022 midterms. Yes, Congress needs to tackle the topic of election subversion, but maps will be drawn before ballots (mis)counted.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Nick Stephanopoulos Speaks Out on Brnovich electionlawblog.org?p=123506
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
New Voting Laws Face Court Challenges Across the U.S. electionlawblog.org?p=123504
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Good morning. Georgia on my mind. electionlawblog.org?p=123502
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
J.D. Vance and the pressures of primaries electionlawblog.org?p=123283
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Nationwide preclearance for congressional elections electionlawblog.org?p=123269
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Opinion | How Congress should fix the Supreme Court’s damage to the Voting Rights Act www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/07/08/how-congress-s…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
this discussion between @rickhasen & @chrislhayes was excellent; covered all key points succinctly. worth searching for if you missed it
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
Tune in!
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
Looking forward to talking to @chrislhayes about voting rights and what's next on @allinwithchris @msnbc tonight around 5:15 pm PT/8:15 pm Et
-
Ned Foley reposted
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
Tune in!
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
Looking forward to talking to @chrislhayes about voting rights and what's next on @allinwithchris @msnbc tonight around 5:15 pm PT/8:15 pm Et
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This video is based on a paper presented on June 23 at conference host by the University of Wisconsin Law School's Research Initiative on State Democracy and to be published by the Wisconsin Law Review. law.wisc.edu/statedemocracy/
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
For a 15-minute video explaining Round-Robin Voting and comparing it to Instant Runoff Voting, as well as to California's "top two" system and to the common practice of party primaries followed by a plurality-winner general election, here's this: www.youtube.com/watch?v=TvvE-R55g8s
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Here's the clip discussing Round-Robin Voting on @Morning_Joe with @JoeNBC @morningmika & @JonLemire www.msnbc.com/morning-joe/watch/an-alternative-to-ranked-…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
For a 15-minute video explaining Round-Robin Voting and comparing it to Instant Runoff Voting, as well as to California's "top two" system and to the common practice of party primaries followed by a plurality-winner general election, here's this: www.youtube.com/watch?v=TvvE-R55g8s
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
How about VRA-type preclearance just for state rules on congressional elections? That way Congress wouldn't have to worry about Shelby County & issues of power under 14th & 15th Amendments. It would be legislating under clear Article I power over procedures for its own elections.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/ The filibuster doesn't need to "end"; it just needs to be reformed. @NormOrnstein has written a lot on flipping the filibuster burden so that the minority party must regularly produce 41 votes to block, rather than requiring majority part to produce 60 votes. That reform ...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/ in the context of debate over John Lewis VRA reform potentially could make a big difference (& in any event seems the most practical avenue to pursue, given where Manchin, Sinema & other Dems are right now on not ending the filibuster):
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/ I wonder whether Brnovich will affect dynamics on potential filibuster reform. Specifically, when John Lewis VRA reform bill reaches Senate floor & it's blocked by GOP, will Dems convert to "talking filibuster" that would require GOP to sustain 41 no votes on ongoing basis?
Mark Wylie
@Mark_Wylie001
But as long as the filibuster remains in place, Republicans will block any pro-democracy legislation, no matter how watered down it is.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/ I wonder whether Brnovich will affect dynamics on potential filibuster reform. Specifically, when John Lewis VRA reform bill reaches Senate floor & it's blocked by GOP, will Dems convert to "talking filibuster" that would require GOP to sustain 41 no votes on ongoing basis?
Mark Wylie
@Mark_Wylie001
But as long as the filibuster remains in place, Republicans will block any pro-democracy legislation, no matter how watered down it is.
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/ What will a sustained public debate on John Lewis bill be like if GOP is seen as wanting to block equal electoral opportunity for all Americans regardless of race? The filibuster dynamics in that context seems different than over S1, which was easy for GOP to demonize.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/ I don't want to minimize the risk that SCOTUS will invalidate VRA reform, just as it invalidated the old coverage formula in Shelby County. But SCOTUS has held that Congress has the power to enact a disparate impact statute against employment discrimination in Fitzpatrick
Post not available here, view on X
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
3/ worth having, most definitely. Also, there's separate congressional power under Article I, section 4, over congressional elections specifically. Congress could enact a disparate impact statute just for congressional elections and, unless states wanted a whole separate system
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
4/ for state elections, as a practical matter the disparate impact statute would apply to all election procedures. Similar point about redistricting: Congress could enact rules that SCOTUS must enforce for congressional elections; Rucho & Shelby County would be irrelevant on that
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The combo of Brnovich today & Rucho previously (on redistricting) seems a strong message that Congress is the only institution that can repair American democracy. SCOTUS is not going to be that institution, unless Congress enacts clear statutes that SCOTUS must enforce as the law
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Am I correct in thinking that, given Alito's opinion, a facially neutral rule of no drop boxes, would be okay because drop boxes were not a practice in 1982? Or would it depend at all on degree of racial effect of no drop box rule? Not entirely clear to me electionlawblog.org?p=123065
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Still reading but fact that Alito repeatedly calls dissent's disparate impact approach "radical" seems important IF Congress ever revised VRA to do this, along the lines of Title VII. Is use of term "radical" a sign that SCOTUS would hold it unconstitutional (like Shelby County)?
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
First thought (while still reading Alito op): If Congress had the votes to enact @ProfNickStephan's disparate impact standard (rejected by Court today), Congress could (like Title VII). Will that put pressure on Congress to include this in John Lewis bill? electionlawblog.org?p=123065
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
First thought (while still reading Alito op): If Congress had the votes to enact @ProfNickStephan's disparate impact standard (rejected by Court today), Congress could (like Title VII). Will that put pressure on Congress to include this in John Lewis bill? electionlawblog.org?p=123065
-
Ned Foley reposted
Miranda Cox
@TheMirandaCox
This shows more than one candidate eliminated per round. That's not how I understand ranked-choice voting. Can anyone explain? web.enrboenyc.us/rcv/024306_4.html #rcv @boenyc
-
Ned Foley reposted
NYC Board of Elections
@BOENYC
We are aware there is a discrepancy in the unofficial RCV round by round elimination report. We are working with our RCV technical staff to identify where the discrepancy occurred. We ask the public, elected officials and candidates to have patience.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I've posted revised draft of "Requiring Majority Winners for Congressional Elections," ssrn.com/abstract=3843029. Last 2 months have increased the need for this rule, as Trump accelerates revenge efforts to "primary" Republicans, like Liz Cheney, who refuse to embrace his Big Lie.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“Voting reform cannot die. The future of democracy is at stake.” www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/06/23/voting-reform-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“States across the country are dropping barriers to voting, widening a stark geographic divide in ballot access”. Very useful report www.washingtonpost.com/politics/voting-rights-expansion-s…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Valuable analysis from @Nate_Cohn www.nytimes.com/2021/06/23/us/politics/voting-rights-bill…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
What Should Congress Do to Tackle Election Subversion? electionlawblog.org?p=122769 I agree with @rickhasen on this
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Shouldn't priority be the problem of partisan gerrymandering, given need to solve that problem first, before new redistricting maps are drawn? Rules for casting & counting ballots can be tackled a bit later, but unless there's a ban on gerrymandering soon, midterms won't be fair.
Manu Raju
@mkraju
Lacking the votes on bill to rewrite election laws, Dems now planning a series of hearings to draw attention to the issue - with Senate Rules prepping a focus on Georgia and field hearing there. www.cnn.com/2021/06/22/politics/senate-democrats-next-ste…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“If Republicans block a compromise voting-rights bill, reform the filibuster” www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/if-republicans-block-a-co…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/2 Some GOP Senators are opposing Manchin's compromise in belief that, like S1, it requires states to create redistricting commissions. That's not how I read Manchin's gerrymandering provision. His computer models to ban gerrymanders could be enforced... www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/06/18/manchins-votin…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/2... by federal courts. Current federal law requires single-member districts. A well-written gerrymandering ban could operate like that. No need for Congress to require states to create new commissions. State legislatures still could draw maps consistently with new federal law.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Manchin's compromise is NOT a federal takeover of elections, as some GOP Senators claim. If it were, I'd oppose it. Like Manchin, I oppose the Dems' S1 because it's a federal takeover. But that's not true of Manchin's plan. It properly respects state power www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/06/18/manchins-votin…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/4 There's talk that Sen. Murkowski won't win in 2022 even with Instant Runoff Voting in Alaska. That's based on polling showing her with fewer first-choice votes than either the Trump-endorsed candidate or the Democrat. But Round-Robin Voting, which uses the same ranked-choice
Post not available here, view on X
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
3/4 This video shows how Round-Robin Voting differs from Instant Runoff Voting using the same ranked-choice ballots, with Round-Robin Voting finding the more majority-preferred candidate: youtu.be/m1iQJfjtI7g?t=2718 And the paper on which the video is based: ssrn.com/abstract=3843029
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
4/4 A key difference between Round-Robin Voting & Instant Runoff Voting is that Round-Robin Voting treats equally the full range of voter preferences, including extent to which voters don't want candidates to win, not privileging first-choice enthusiasm over other voter rankings.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This story illustrates why I argue, in my most recent @PostOpinions column, that Congress should act to protect the chain-of-custody of ballots. If Congress does that, then Congress can assure ballots will be counted honestly (at least for federal races). www.nytimes.com/2021/06/19/us/politics/georgia-republican…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Manchin’s voting rights compromise is great — except it doesn’t take on ‘election subversion’ www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/06/18/manchins-votin…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
well-said @rickhasen; @pamelafessler, we will all miss your regular voice; enjoy & all best wishes! "Pam Fessler, the Dean of Journalists Covering Voting Rights, is Retiring from NPR" electionlawblog.org?p=122682
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/2 My view of Manchin's compromise is essentially the same as @rickhasen's. What Manchin includes makes sense, but doesn't address need to protect COUNTING as well as CASTING votes. Getting GOP to accept honest counts must be highest priority right now. slate.com/news-and-politics/2021/06/democrats-should-take…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/2 Also, like HR1/S1, Manchin's plan doesn't address "primary problem," which must be cured to repair USA's broken electoral process (as explained here): www.uniteamerica.org/reports/the-primary-problem. Congress should enact simple "majority winner" rule as best way to do this: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/05/why-congress-s…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is an example of why I believe electoral reform should prioritize ways to increase likelihood that GOP will accept vote tallies in close races; HR1/S1 as currently drafted is not well-designed for that priority & should be redrafted with that goal: thehill.com/homenews/campaign/558697-majority-of-republic…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Round-Robin Voting avoids risk Sen. Murkowski doesn't survive Instant Runoff Voting, which @DLeonhardt & @Nate_Cohn discuss: www.nytimes.com/2021/06/16/briefing/a-guide-to-ranked-cho…. I compare Round-Robin and Instant Runoff use of same RCV ballots in video youtu.be/m1iQJfjtI7g?t=2718 & paper ssrn.com/abstract=3843029
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Opinion | How Joe Manchin could escape the trap he set for himself www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/06/11/how-joe-manchi…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
A sobering example of how fraught vote-counting in presidential elections can be & how the United States increasingly shares some of the same difficulties as other nations with presidential rather than parliamentary systems of government: www.nytimes.com/2021/06/10/world/americas/peru-election.html
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Terrifying: '“It seemed like we were descending into this third-world mentality,” said Barron, who has worked in elections for 22 years... “I never expected that out of this country.”' Also seems like USA is returning to 19th century electoral intimidation www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-trump-geo…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"Restricting participation in elections, & playing with district boundaries, both conduce to the election of more extreme politicians, who ... are more likely to regard elections as purely partisan competitions waged without regard to the public interest." www.nytimes.com/2021/06/04/opinion/voting-law-rights-cong…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Key new Bauer-Ginsberg project: bipartisan plan to protect election administrators. "No requirement of our electoral process ... is more critical than the commitment to nonpartisanship in the administration of our system for casting and counting ballots." www.nytimes.com/2021/06/04/opinion/republican-state-laws-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
For even more on how electoral reforms should be prioritized to counteract the threat of extremism, Rick Pildes has set forth a 4-pronged agenda (which I've previously characterized as essential reading and worth mentioning again in this context): www.nytimes.com/2021/02/25/opinion/elections-politics-ext…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/2 measures most likely to restore GOP to being a responsible right-of-center party in a system of well-functioning electoral competition. Thus, focus on gerrymandering & the pathology of partisan primaries, which skew GOP to anti-democracy extremes. See: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/05/27/democrats-are-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/2 The White House view, @RonBrownstein reports, is that Democrats must control Congress for democracy to be safe. That doesn't describe a healthy democracy, which requires each side to take turns as voters decide. This is why reform priorities should be
electionlawblog.org?p=122341
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/2 measures most likely to restore GOP to being a responsible right-of-center party in a system of well-functioning electoral competition. Thus, focus on gerrymandering & the pathology of partisan primaries, which skew GOP to anti-democracy extremes. See: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/05/27/democrats-are-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Opinion | Democrats are wasting time pursuing their dream elections reform bill. Here’s a better path. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/05/27/democrats-are-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This story illustrates why my current work is on different electoral systems. Candidates preferred by majority of general election voters can't win partisan primary. Outcomes defy what voters actually want. Reform is needed so voters' preferences prevail. apnews.com/article/politics-donald-trump-ohio-senate-elec…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
America's electoral rules don't need to exacerbate extremist views that are on the rise. Some electoral systems magnify extremist views among overall voter preferences; other electoral systems do not. Here's a 17-minute video on how 4 systems handle this: youtu.be/m1iQJfjtI7g?t=2718
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Opinion | Voter suppression is bad. But this tactic is even worse. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/voter-suppression-is-bad-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I was honored to be part of AALS conference Friday on Rebuilding Democracy. My talk, on why Congress should require a majority (not just plurality) of votes to win an election & how this counteracts extremism, starts at 45:10 and lasts 17 minutes here: www.aals.org/events/rebuilding-democracy/live-stream/
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
A really great piece by @rickhasen on why election subversion, not just vote suppression, deserves focus. I'd add only Hice "primarying" Raffensperger as another element of retaliation against honest vote-counting. Put primary reform on the "must do" list www.nytimes.com/2021/04/23/opinion/republicans-voting-us-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
'“Liz’s primary is absolutely the most symbolic race in the country right now,” said Julie Conway, executive director of VIEW PAC.' But instead of a party primary, there should be nonpartisan primary followed by a majority-winner rule in general election. www.nytimes.com/2021/04/22/magazine/liz-cheney-vs-maga.html
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Primary challenges, whether from right or left, are problematic for majority rule when followed by "plurality winner" elections. General elections should require a majority winner & let a primary's loser compete as an independent. Think Lisa Murkowski 2010 thehill.com/homenews/house/549644-liberal-advocacy-group-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I'm going to assign this important new piece for reading in my Election Law class: "Why Political Sectarianism Is a Growing Threat to American Democracy" www.nytimes.com/2021/04/19/us/democracy-gop-democrats-sec…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Want to dig deep this weekend into what ails our democracy & best to heal it? Check out part 2 of the conversation that @ProfTolson & I had with Rick Pildes on the latest episode of our Free & Fair podcast. Rick's ideas merit close & widespread attention: soundcloud.com/freeandfair/making-democracy-work-part-2
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Smart, important new piece from @Nate_Cohn "New Law, and the Risk of Election Subversion" www.nytimes.com/2021/04/06/upshot/georgia-election-law-ri…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Opinion | Democrats have a chance to expand voter access. But they’re focusing on the wrong bill. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/29/democrats-have…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
With Sen. Blunt & Portman not running, 2 podcasts in last 24 hours assume it's inevitable that GOP Senate caucus gets Trumpier; but it's "inevitable" only because of existing electoral rules: partisan primary followed by plurality-winner general election.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/05/why-congress-s… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Was listening to the Bulwark podcast & heard @SykesCharlie mention this piece; after reading it, happy to see it link (in penultimate paragraph) to my latest @PostOpinions column; we are thinking along parallel lines on this topic (a voting rights bill): morningshots.thebulwark.com/p/whats-wrong-with-hr-1
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Opinion | Saving voting rights is an emergency. Here’s a modest fix Republicans might support. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/08/saving-voting-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Given Senator Blunt's announcement that he's not running for reelection in 2022, should Missouri consider the possibility of using for the Senate election "approval voting", which St. Louis just used for its mayoral election (as discussed in this column)?: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/05/why-congress-s…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Given Senator Blunt's announcement today that he's not running for reelection in 2022, this piece from Friday is even more relevant; the example of Senator Portman being replaced in 2022 by a more extreme Republican from Ohio now applies to Missouri also: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/05/why-congress-s…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Very interesting and worthwhile discussion: "Primaries: What Are They Good For?" remnant.thedispatch.com/p/primaries-what-are-they-good-for
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The advantage of this approach is its federalism philosophy; it doesn't impose any single system on states, but instead lets them be "laboratories of democracy" as the Constitution intends. Still, a simple majority-winner rule would be significant reform: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/05/why-congress-s…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This idea is what I consider the top priority right now, because it's an electoral reform that's both potentially feasible in the short term and would do a lot of good: Opinion | Why Congress should require its members to be elected by a majority of votes: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/05/why-congress-s…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Opinion | Why Congress should require its members to be elected by a majority of votes www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/05/why-congress-s…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I'm especially pleased to share this episode of our "Free and Fair with Franita and Foley" podcast; @ProfTolson & I tackle what some consider the #1 electoral reform priority: reducing the polarization & extremism that's contrary to what voters really want soundcloud.com/freeandfair/the-problem-worth-solving
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
In 2017 I wrote this, on how Due Process contains an anti-retrogression principle that limits states from taking away previously granted voting rights; in light of all the proposed new state laws that would do just that, now's the time for another look:
lawreview.uchicago.edu/publication/due-process-fair-play-… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Rick Pildes has an absolute "must read" piece that sets forth an agenda of electoral reforms aimed at protecting American democracy from the ever-increasing, and alarmingly so, forces of polarization. Bookmark this, to keep track of efforts on this front. www.nytimes.com/2021/02/25/opinion/elections-politics-ext…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Comprehensive: www.washingtonpost.com/politics/election-claims-legal-san…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is going to be a very interesting race to watch from an election law perspective, concerning the relationship of the primary to the general election. How far right will the primary pull the GOP? "Former Ohio GOP chair Jane Timken launches Senate bid" thehill.com/homenews/campaign/539361-former-ohio-gop-chai…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Key point: "What many operatives fear, however, is that Trump becomes guided by his personal grievances as the midterm elections approach—perhaps by endorsing far-right GOP candidates in swing-state Senate races, clearing the way for Democratic victories." www.washingtonpost.com/powerpost/trump-mcconnell-clash-th…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"Trump’s statement will almost certainly aggravate the fight among Republicans over the party’s future after Trump’s presidency." What's the implications for 2022 (Ohio's US Senate election, for example) and then 2024? Can the GOP hold itself together? www.politico.com/news/2021/02/16/trump-attacks-mcconnell-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Ex-judge McConnell: "the use of the presidential office to keep power after losing an election is the gravest possible offense against our democratic constitutional order—one the authors of the Constitution specifically contemplated and sought to prevent." www.nytimes.com/2021/02/13/opinion/trump-impeachment-acqu…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Smart analysis: www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/02/impeachment-did…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
"How did White House process widespread reports Trump fanatics were planning violence on 1/6? How did Trump respond as he watched the riot unfold? What, if any, conversations took place between the White House & Pentagon about sending in National Guard?" www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/57-senators-got-it-right-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Well put: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/senate-republicans-suffer…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The counterargument would be that if McConnell had been able to secure enough GOP votes to reach 67 for conviction, he would have done that. If so, that means Trump has more power going forward than McConnell wants. Still, it's not as if Trump has free rein unopposed by McConnell
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
You can argue McConnell, as top elected GOP official, imposed his own disqualification penalty on Trump, against his running in 2024. True, it doesn't keep Trump off the ballot but as practical matter it stops Trump from being GOP nominee without tearing party apart. Significant.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
You can argue McConnell, as top elected GOP official, imposed his own disqualification penalty on Trump, against his running in 2024. True, it doesn't keep Trump off the ballot but as practical matter it stops Trump from being GOP nominee without tearing party apart. Significant.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Prior to the impeachment vote, I thought an acquittal would enhance Trump's personal political power as a potential candidate heading towards 2024. But my first impression after McConnell's speech, echoed by Portman, is that Trump is actually weakened as a potential candidate.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The Election Law Implications of Trump’s Acquittal electionlawblog.org?p=120848
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Portman takes essentially same jurisdictional view as McConnell, while similarly condemning Trump's conduct on the merits. Like McConnell's position, Portman's stance raises question of trying to reach 60 votes for statute to enforce section 3 of 14 Amend www.cleveland.com/open/2021/02/rob-portman-votes-to-acqui…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
what about James Kent?
Keith E. Whittington
@kewhittington
Joseph Story our nation's first great constitutional scholar? St. George Tucker would like a word.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Key point (also same as what McConnell said, despite their divergent votes on whether or not to convict, based on McConnell's view of the jurisdictional limit of the Senate):
Pat Toomey (US Sen. ret.)
@SenToomey
He urged the mob to march on the Capitol for the explicit purpose of preventing Congress and the Vice President from formally certifying the results of the presidential election. All of this to hold on to power despite having legitimately lost.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Given McConnell's speech, what's the chance for exploring possibility of 60 Senate votes for a statute that would enforce section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment? I'm personally skeptical of its applicability to Trump's conduct unless there's additional proof that he was part...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
...a seditious conspiracy that would bring him within the "engaged in insurrection" text of section 3. As awful as Trump's conduct was, as shown by the House managers, even incitement of insurrection is not the same as actually engaging in it. But maybe there will be an effort...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
...to invoke this provision & use it as a basis, other than impeachment, to bar Trump from running in 2024. It would need to be a statute requiring judicial adjudication of its applicability to Trump in order to avoid a bill of attainder problem.A censure vote wouldn't be enough.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
In light of Senator McConnell's invitation to consider President Trump's potential vulnerability to conventional criminal prosecution for his conduct in relationship to the January 6 insurrection, I'm retweeting this: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/01/14/can-trump-be-p…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Even though McConnell did not vote to convict, his speech is still a very important defense of free and fair elections and a thorough condemnation of Trump's attempt at electoral subversion.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
79% of Republicans still view Trump favorably even after Jan 6 riot; with other results of this survey (65% of Republicans believe there was "widespread voter fraud" in 2020 election) the upshot is Trump's voters exonerate him. What consequence for future? datawrapper.dwcdn.net/f8sgg/4/
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This new survey shows that two-thirds of Republicans believe that Biden's victory was "illegitimate"; more evidence, in other words, of the continuing consequences of Trump Team's Big Lie "stolen election" claim. datawrapper.dwcdn.net/Q0C7W/5/
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
'That afternoon Trump was determined to do “whatever it took” to stop the certification, according to a former senior administration official, and encouraged Giuliani to also call senators. “He was happy the results had been stopped,” the official said.' www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-tweet-pence-capitol…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Ben Franklin would like Liz Cheney here: youtu.be/MVukh_ZXW08 Franklin, we're told, said "A republic, if you can keep it" in response to what kind of government the Constitution created. Cheney's doing her best to preserve the Republic. She upholds self-government...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
...even when the voters choose leaders, like Biden, whose policies she opposes--because the highest priority under the Constitution is to let the electorate make the choice of how to be governed. Others in GOP don't see what Cheney clearly does, and the Republic may be in danger.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
For everyone who's hoping Congress adopts significant democracy-enhancing electoral reforms in the next couple of years, what's the backup plan if there's an unwillingness to negate the filibuster for this purpose? I've suggested focusing on gerrymandering as highest priority...
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
...What deal is possible to get 60 Senate votes for real anti-gerrymandering reform? That's the question I would focus on if eliminating the filibuster is not an option. I'd look to voter ID & vote-by-mail as items that might make a deal possible. See: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/02/04/congress-end-p…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The use of tort suits to redress the Big Lie seems potentially broader than just libel cases by voting machine makers. All victims of the Big Lie, including on Jan 6, might sue all the Big Lie's perpetrators? Incitement to violence as tort, not just crime? www.nytimes.com/2021/02/06/business/media/conservative-me…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Remember: Gabe Sterling, the Georgia election official, warned in a widely publicized press conference that someone will get "killed"; he was speaking specifically about the Big Lie claim of a stolen election. Thus, injuries caused by Big Lie were foreseen; relevant in tort suit.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
‘How do we save America?’ is the latest episode of "Free and Fair with Franita and Foley" (the first since Jan 6); an especially meaningful conversation with @ProfTolson on what now in light of what happened in the 2020 election including the Capitol siege soundcloud.com/freeandfair/how-do-we-save-america
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Opinion | Congress should make a deal to end partisan gerrymandering www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/02/04/congress-end-p…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Very useful charts (and data) to back up the comparison between the Gilded Age and today in terms of polarization and close presidential elections: 53eig.ht/3rb1p7N
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This essay is clarifying, but perhaps not in the way intended: its historical comparison, as I see it, suggests a night-&-day difference between now & then, making it much harder to marginalize Trumpism than John Birch Society. Trumpism isn't fringe in GOP www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/01/29/gop-john-birch-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Poll cited here: 72% of GOP voters, and 32% overall, believe that Biden didn't win "fair and square" but only "due to voter fraud"; this is evidence of lingering damage caused by the "stolen election" Big Lie. We need to consider how to undo this damage. www.nytimes.com/2021/01/30/us/politics/trump-republicans-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Useful analysis, especially Prof. Bowman on CJ Roberts at the end: Why John Roberts's absence from Senate trial isn't a surprise - thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/535977-why-john-robe…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“Chuck Coughlin, Republican consultant who worked with former governor Jan Brewer, is hoping to raise money for a statewide referendum that could impose nonpartisan primary elections in the state, draining power away from local Republican Party officials.” www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-republican-split/20…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Arizona is going to be an important "laboratory of democracy" over the next few years, and this idea is one to consider: @katherinegehl advocates a "final five" system similar to the "top four" system that Alaska just adopted. Does this oped show the idea gaining traction in AZ?
Katherine Gehl-Final Five Voting
@katherinegehl
"In Arizona, we cannot easily remedy all the systemic problems addressed in 'the politics industry' but we can do something about one core game changing issue – how we conduct our primaries." @TucsonStar tucson.com/opinion/local/tucson-attorney-si-schorr-we-nee…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
1/2 '“I don’t know want to tell my constituents you can’t vote for him, they’re grownups,” the lawmaker added.' That was my view after the Ukraine phone call. But after summoning the mob, as Liz Cheney put it, plus all the lying about a stolen election? thehill.com/homenews/senate/535343-gop-senators-say-only-…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
2/2 Also, the multiple Georgia phone calls trying to get officials there to change the vote totals. To protect democracy itself, it's necessary to recognize that Trump's behavior between November and January shows him to be a unique menace to conducting a free and fair election.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
As an election law prof, I have mixed emotions: relieved that, as our new president said, "democracy has prevailed" but still saddened by the attack two weeks ago. "Bruised but whole," Amanda Gorman put it. Let's hope, as she also said: "We will rebuild, reconcile, and recover."
-
Ned Foley reposted
Washington Post Opinions
@PostOpinions
Each day brings new — and chilling — evidence of an organized plot to derail the electoral count by force, writes @Nedfoley.
But was Trump himself a party to this seditious plot? www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/01/14/can-trump-be-p… -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Dealing with this problem, no matter how challenging, is an urgent priority. Much of the effort to undo the Big Lie must come from within the GOP: repetition & amplification of Liz Cheney's detailed & documented explanation why the election was not stolen. www.nytimes.com/2021/01/18/us/supporters-of-donald-trump.…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
There is much insightful analysis here by @bartongellman on Trump's attempt at "democracide"; one snippet: "What choice is there but rebellion against a pretender to the throne? Sedition, for Trump’s true believers, became the patriotic choice." So: undoing the Big Lie is urgent.
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
"The extremists are capable of bloodshed, but they cannot stop Joe Biden from taking office," @bartongellman writes. "Their resurgence is, however, a symptom of genuine danger to our constitutional order." on.theatln.tc/xPtv8pV
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This story raises important point: it's not enough to say Biden will be president due to process; it's necessary to acknowledge that the process yielded what voters actually chose. Sure there were some flaws (always are), but outcome is what voters wanted. www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/01/17/republicans-ca…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This jumped out to me from the new CBS poll: 51% of Republican respondents say that they will not consider Biden a "legitimate" president after he takes office. That's obviously troubling & much work is needed to redress this problem due to disinformation www.cbsnews.com/news/joe-biden-coronavirus-opinion-poll/
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
The comparable percentage from the Post-ABC poll is even worse: "7 in 10 Republicans say [Biden] was not legitimately elected." www.washingtonpost.com/politics/poll-biden-trump-republic…
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Pew has similar finding in recent poll: 40% of Trump voters think Trump "definitely" won, while 36% think he "probably" won--making 76% of Trump voters disbelieving the validity of Biden's election. This is dangerous: democracy requires accepting defeat. www.pewresearch.org/politics/2021/01/15/voters-reflection…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
As always, @danbalz is illuminating in his analysis: www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-leaves-behind-a-rep…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This deep-dive analysis of what, to me, is the most important issue confronting the future of electoral competition in the US is a certain must-read; the state-level details are significant, I think, as the internecine fight within GOP will play out there: www.nytimes.com/2021/01/16/us/politics/republicans-trump-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This story signals the long-term threat caused by the stolen election myth: "now they have been galvanized by the outgoing president’s false claims that the election was stolen from him"; the Capitol riot Jan. 6, I'm afraid, is not the end of this danger: www.nytimes.com/2021/01/16/us/capitol-attack-extremist-ha…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Details of what happened at the White House on Election Night; if accurate, it portrays a version of risk the election law community was focused on throughout 2020 (Trump's use of "blue shift") & raises question about importance of Fox News Arizona "call": www.axios.com/trump-election-premeditated-lie-ebaf4a1f-46…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is very sobering to read, particularly about efforts already underway to "primary" Republicans who are perceived to have abandoned Trump; it's a clear picture of GOP internal feud. "Abandon Trump? Deep in the G.O.P. Ranks, the MAGA Mind-Set Prevails" www.nytimes.com/2021/01/14/us/politics/trump-republicans.…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
I agree with @leedrutman on this:
Lee Drutman ⚙️🏛
@leedrutman
Democracy in America is going to depend on the triumph of the institutionalist center-right against the tear-it-all-down anti-institutionalist far-right. Stay tuned.
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Very important point from @leedrutman
Lee Drutman ⚙️🏛
@leedrutman
Only 13% of Americans describe themselves as "Trump supporters." In a proportional multiparty system, they would be a far-right party, with no chance of controlling government. www.ipsos.com/en-us/news-polls/unrest-capitol-election-ce…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“There’s a reason why Lisa Murkowski can threaten to leave the Republicans” @leedrutman will be important voice as the nation considers structural reforms to counteract the anti-democracy forces of associated with Trumpian wing of Republican Party. www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/01/09/theres-reason-…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Lawmakers who conspired with Capitol attackers in legal peril www.politico.com/news/2021/01/14/lawmakers-capitol-attack… via @politico
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Opinion | Prosecuting Trump for the Capitol riot will be difficult — but not impossible www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/01/14/can-trump-be-p…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This should be a timely discussion:
Election Law at Ohio State
@electionlawOSU
Register & join us tomorrow at 4pm (ET) for an expert panel discussion: 'Picking Up the Pieces of the 2020 Election'
u.osu.edu/electionlaw/events/picking-up-the-pieces-of-the… -
Ned Foley reposted
Jonathan Karl
@jonkarl
House Democrats intend to send the impeachment resolution to the Senate next week. There will be no delay, a source involved w deliberations on this tells me.
The question now is whether McConnell will bring the Senate back early; the senate is now scheduled to be back on 1/19. -
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
“I was not on the investigate-and-prosecute train before yesterday,” Kathleen Sullivan, ex-chairwoman of New Hampshire's Democratic Party, said. “However, undermining the very foundations of democracy and the Constitution is a crime that can’t be ignored.” www.nytimes.com/2021/01/09/us/politics/democrats-trump-cr…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This is an insightful account of the challenges that the Republican Party specifically, and thus the nation as a whole, will face as we endeavor to recover from what happened last Wednesday: www.nytimes.com/2021/01/09/us/politics/republican-party-t…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
As part of our partnership with @SCOTUSblog, Election Law at Ohio State (ELOSU) is tracking active Presidential Election Cases: go.osu.edu/pec. I'll tweet updates to the database as I'm able, but you can also follow updates from others on ELOSU team here: @electionlawOSU
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Everyone should read this story of Samuel Randall's pivotal role in the disputed 1876 Hayes-Tilden election, by my great podcasting partner @ProfTolson; an enduring, essential lesson: In the Messiest Contested Election, One Man Saved the System From Itself www.nytimes.com/2020/11/03/us/samuel-randall-1876-electio…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
This piece by @geoffreyvs of @538politics is one of the most significant I've seen on trying to estimate as precisely as possible what the magnitude of the "blue shift" might be in Pennsylvania this year. Everyone interested in this issue should read it: 53eig.ht/35LkowC
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Here's a piece on why all the pending election litigation is facing such stiff headwinds: claims based on old non-originalist precedents are meeting resistance from new judges who embrace originalist jurisprudence. A new Voting Rights Amendment is needed. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/10/19/does-the-const…
-
Ned Foley
@Nedfoley
Today I discussed the history in these 2 books with Ohio Association of Election Officials. I appreciate the opportunity & great discussion, with focus on need to wait beyond Election Night returns for full official results. (And I must say the two books look good side-by-side!)





































































































