I’ve been saying it for 10 months: Hamas is deeply hated in Gaza! While the IDF’s statements, evidence, and allegations should always be taken with a pinch of salt & skepticism, it’s hard to imagine why they’d manufacture fake documents that confirm Hamas’s declining popularity and support among the Palestinian population of the coastal enclave. Part of the Gaza war ethos has been centered on the premise that “they’re all Hamas” and that Palestinians in the Strip “all support the terror group” and must, therefore, be punished. The polls that I’ve long called fraudulent and completely inaccurate/unrepresentative have been an anchor for the dehumanization of the Palestinian people in Gaza, justifying their murder by associating them all with Hamas. The IDF, the security establishment, and the government in Israel have long relied on @KShikaki PSPSR polls to assess Palestinian public opinion and develop policies and strategies accordingly. I don’t see any benefit for Israel to manufacture documents that undermine the claims of most “pro-Israel” talking points about “Gaza is Hamas”, “there are no innocent civilians in Gaza”, “Gazans need to be deradicalized”, “there is no hope for Gaza”, and “they still support Hamas despite all the death and destruction.”
Still, you don’t need the IDF’s documents, real or fake, to prove that Hamas has directly and indirectly manipulated public opinion to manufacture the perception of widespread support and popularity. Any actual Palestinian who knows Gazans, not imbeciles in the Western world or fools in the diaspora who continue to praise Hamas, would have told you exactly what I’ve been saying for months. Hamas’s popularity is in the toilet, and the group is intensely hated, despised, and unliked by the majority of the population. This was true before October 7, and especially so after the attack, which triggered the most destructive disaster in Palestinian history.
I’ve said time and again, with complete conviction, that these polls defy logic and basic common sense: how could a population, no matter the supposed brainwashing and radicalization, keep cheering on the very group (Hamas) that has held them hostage for 17 years, made them live in miserable conditions, and brought unprecedented death and annihilation upon them? I’ve said repeatedly that my views are held by numerous Palestinians in Gaza, who despise Hamas and hope it’ll never control their lives again, but they’re afraid to share their honest opinions, lest they be killed, attacked, called traitors/Zionists/sellouts/shills, or seem as if they’re supportive of Israeli actions. Imagine living under an Islamist militant dictatorship in an undemocratic, illiberal society; you’re not going to share what you really think to a pollster when asked about Hamas, Israel, or October 7.
The findings today decimate the narrative of two extreme camps: the “pro-Israel” hardliners who used the polls’ results to demonize Palestinians in Gaza and justify their slaughter; and the “pro-Palestine” fools who are praising and cheering on Hamas in the Western world because they think the group represents organic and sincere Palestinian “resistance” and freedom fighting. I’ve been regularly and incessantly disputing the polls’ results in Gaza and how misrepresentative they are, only to be mocked, ridiculed, ignored, or scoffed at by journalists, activists, government officials, and social media warriors. But it’s not too late to re-assess.