Hmm. There are two errors in this, and also the new 15% limit is way too low. And finally this is an unintentional call for communism.
(1) First error. This charge isn’t for “overhead”. It does include overhead, but it also includes “General & Administrative” costs. For example, there are two types of people who work on government contracts. (A) Those who do the technical part of the work. Their labor is counted as a “direct cost”. (B) Those who do all the other types of work for the contract, including management, safety, security, contracts management, accounting, project management, etc. It is all real work that has to be done for the contract to be successful, and the people who do that work all need to get paid or the university/company would lose money on the contract and therefore would choose to stop doing any work for the government. It is such a high rate because a lot of people do real work on contracts.
(2) Second error. A 60% indirect rate does not mean that 60% of the money is being siphoned off for indirect costs, but only 37.5%. That’s because 100% of the direct costs get charged, plus another 60% to cover the indirect costs, so the total charge is 160% of the direct costs. 60% divided by 160% is 37.5%. So 37.5% of the total payment is being siphoned off to cover the indirect costs, or about 1/3.
Is 37.5% more reasonable than 60%? Yes, and it is all audited by the government for every university and every company line-by-line to make sure all the indirect cost charges are real work being done and are all justified. Could the government run a much tighter ship during these audits and demand that indirect costs come way down? Maybe so, but 15% seems way, way too low. Which is the third point.
(3) According to Grok, this isn’t just universities. Large companies also charge 40% to 60% for their indirect rate. I don’t know what SpaceX charges for its indirect costs, but it isn’t building rockets for the government as charity, so they aren’t going to give away the indirect labor to the government for free.
Since indirect costs are real costs, they have to be built into the price or the universities/companies would lose money doing research for the government so they would choose to stop doing research for the government. Does the United States want universities and companies to do research or not? If yes, then we have to pay the total of the real costs, both direct and indirect. I think 15% is way too low. Maybe 40% is a good number to make universities try to shoot for instead of 60%. The goal here is to get the most research we can out of the tax money. Offering to pay much less than the real costs will result in less research from US universities, not more. Which brings us to the fourth point.
(4) Final point: whether universities have big endowments or not is irrelevant. That’s like saying the government shouldn’t pay SpaceX the full cost on its contracts because Elon already has a lot of money. We don’t pay based on what people have, but on the value of their work. Pay is the motive to do the work in capitalism. By saying pay should scale with what you already have, Elon is unintentionally calling for communism: “from each according to their ability; to each according to their need.” The problem is that communism doesn’t work. If we want good research, we have to pay for it regardless whether the universities are rich or poor.
Can you believe that universities with tens of billions in endowments were siphoning off 60% of research award money for “overhead”?
What a ripoff!