New Florida law restricts First Amendment rights online | @gygonzalez
Similar laws in Arkansas, Ohio, and Utah have hit constitutional roadblocks. Expect the same for Floridaās unconstitutional law.
The Florida legislature has once again chosen to limit its citizensā free speech rights ā this time by passingĀ House Bill 3, which severely restricts Floridiansā access to websites and content on the internet.
HB 3 bans most minors from having accounts on social media platforms and forces others to get parental consent.
The bill also requires adult websites which contain material āharmful to minorsā to conduct age verification on every user ā not just minors ā who visit such sites.
HB 3 has many similarities with prior Florida bill HB 1, which the legislature passed earlier this session. Gov. Ron DeSantis vetoed HB 1 ā just as FIREĀ urged due to its blatant First Amendment problems ā but ultimatelyĀ struck a deal with the legislature to pass HB 3, which contains the sameĀ constitutional defects.
Today, despite FIREās warnings, Gov. DeSantis signed HB 3. Other states must avoid Floridaās example and reject similar unconstitutional legislation.
Social media bans and parental consent:
HB 3 prohibits people under 14 years old from having social media accounts and requires 15- and 14-year-olds to obtain parental consent in order to obtain an account.
This flies in the face of the First Amendment and decades of Supreme Court law holding that minors have strong free speech rights.Ā
As Justice Lewis Powell wrote inĀ Erznoznik v. Jacksonville, āminors are entitled to a significant measure of First Amendment protection, and only in relatively narrow and well-defined circumstances may government bar public dissemination of protected materials to them.ā
Just as the First Amendment bars the government from banning adults from communicating online, or banning children from reading newspapers without a parentās consent, it bars the government from imposing these kinds of regulations on young peopleās use of social media.
The Supreme Court illustrated this principle inĀ Brown v. Entertainment Merchants Association, the latest in a long line of cases explaining the governmentās limited authority to regulate minorsā access to speech. InĀ Brown, the Court invalidated a California law that prohibited selling violent video games to purchasers under age 18, even though the law effectively allowed minors to access such games with a parent's consent. As Justice Antonin Scalia wrote for the majority, the government does not have āa free-floating power to restrict the ideas to which children may be exposed.ā
Justice Scalia went on to note that although parents have āthe power to control what their children hear and say,ā a governmental prohibition doesnāt āenforce parental authority over childrenās speech.ā Instead, such a prohibition āimpose[s] governmental authorityā over it. In other words, the fact that a parent can regulate their childās speech does not mean the First Amendment allows the government to do so as well.
Eroding anonymous speech on social media:
Florida HB 3 also burdens the right of kids and adults to speak anonymously on social media.
By banning social media accounts for users under 13, or under 16 without parental consent, the bill requires both teens and parents to reveal their identities to verify their relationship and the parentās consent. In doing so, the provision eliminates anonymity for everyone ā adultsĀ and minors.
The bill also requires platforms to terminate accounts belonging to someone under the age limits, or whom the platform ātreats or categorizesā as belonging to someone under the age limits, and gives them 90 days to āeffectively dispute the termination.ā The bill doesnāt say what is required to āeffectively dispute the termination,ā but itās not technically possible to verify oneās age without handing over personally identifying information to someone. As such, adult account holders whose accounts are flagged for termination will need to dispense with their anonymity in order to maintain their accounts.
This implicates First Amendment protection of the right to anonymous speech. During the countryās founding, anonymous pamphlets advocated breaking away from England, and then for ratification of the Constitution. In keeping with that legacy,Ā numerous court cases have invalidated laws and ordinances that required speakers and/or those who listen to or view speech to identify themselves. As the Supreme CourtĀ explained: āThe decision in favor of anonymity may be motivated by fear of economic or official retaliation, by concern about social ostracism, or merely by a desire to preserve as much of oneās privacy as possible.ā
HB 3 breaks with this important precedent, eliminating free speech protection that Floridians, like all Americans, have long enjoyed.
Similar laws in other states have hit constitutional roadblocks
FIRE warns that these kinds of restrictions on social media will not survive judicial scrutiny, and courts have invalidated on First Amendment grounds provisions similar to HB 3 in other states. A federal court in Arkansas issued aĀ preliminary injunction blocking a state law requiring age verification for access to online content and requiring parental permission for minors to have social media accounts. And an Ohio federal courtĀ did the same to a state law requiring parental consent for people under 16 to have social media accounts.
In January, faced with aĀ lawsuit from FIRE and others challenging a state law that required age-verification for social media users, Utah passed legislation to push back the lawās effective date, thenĀ repealed it and passed a replacement law. Yet while the new statute substantially modified the initial restrictions, it still imposes problematic limits on minorsā social media accounts.
Eliminating anonymous access to adult material:
HB 3 also raises constitutional issues in requiring all users to submit to age verification in order to access sites that distribute content deemed āharmful to minorsā if more than one-third of the content meets the billās definition of that term.
But the billās definition of āharmfulā encompasses content that the First Amendment protects. While the government may restrict some speech to minors that cannot be restricted to adults, this authority is very narrow, and even when trying to serve a legitimate interest like protecting children, it cannot burden adultsā speech more than is absolutely necessary to achieve its goal.
Courts have thus consistently invalidated laws like HB 3 that prohibit access to online content absent age verification, due largely to the burden verification imposes on all users, not only minors. InĀ Reno v. ACLU, the Supreme Court invalidated provisions of the Communications Decency Act that criminalized distribution of āindecentā or āpatently offensiveā material on the internet if it could be viewed by a minor. The law allowed sites to avoid liability if they used age verification or took āgood faith, reasonable, effective, and appropriate actions" to restrict minorsā access, but the Court held the CDA suppressed āa large amount of speech that adults have a constitutional right to receive.ā It thus ultimately held the CDA provisions unconstitutional, because Congress could have used less restrictive means to limit minorsā access to this content.
Not long afterĀ Reno, the Court considered the constitutionality of the Child Online Protection Act, which restricted content āharmful to minorsā using a definition nearly identical to that in HB 3. As inĀ Reno, COPA included a provision that allowed adult content distributors to avoid conviction if they restricted minorsā access through measures like requiring a credit card, a ādigital certificate that verifies age,ā or āany other reasonable measures that are feasible under available technology.ā
Lower courts preliminarily blocked COPA on the grounds it was unlikely to be the least restrictive way of preventing minors from accessing adult content online. On review, the Supreme Court inĀ Ashcroft v. ACLU agreed with the lower courts, holding the government was unlikely to be able to show the age verification provision was āthe least restrictive means among available, effective alternativesā to serve Congressās goal. The Court noted Congressās promotion of parentsā use of voluntary filtering technology may be a less restrictive means that would allow āadults without children [to] gain access to speech they have a right to see without having to identify themselves or provide their credit card information.ā
HB 3ās age verification requirement will fare similarly in court.
Bottom line:
We are disappointed that Gov. DeSantis signed this unconstitutional legislation. HB 3 will place substantial restrictions on Floridiansā access to protected speech online.
We urge the states currently considering bills similar to HB 3 to respect the First Amendment rights of their citizens and avoid wasting resources defending an unconstitutional law in court.
Protecting children is a laudable goal, but enacting futile and unconstitutional legislation does not protect anyone.