Our story is linked below — but first the facts as we understand them.🧵
- in 1996 Keir bought a field, the famous donkey field, for £20,000
- in 2022, he sold it at a price of £295,000
- He did not declare ownership for several years while an MP, a breach of the rules for which he apologised
- When asked to explain, in a previously unnoticed comment, he told the parliamentary authorities:
"I immediately gifted the land to my parents for as long as they should live but I did not transfer the legal title - that remained with me."
- To a normal reader, these words would not have any significance beyond their natural meaning
- @DanNeidle said it is in fact specific language that refers to the creation of a trust
- We spoke to a leading KC who agreed with this view
- Under such a trust - a life interest or interest in possession trust - Starmer technically remained owner even as his parents had a claim to the land throughout their lives
- Per s54(1) of the Inheritance Tax Act - in force at all points - such a trust guarantees that, upon death of the beneficiary, the property returns to the settlor - Starmer
- The legislation explicitly says the property shall not be into "account" in determining the value of the estate of the deceased person
- In other words, by creating the trust, Starmer guaranteed that, whatever its eventual value, and however much the commuter belt land rose to, it would be excluded from the estate of his parents, of which he was beneficiary.
- The smaller the estate, the less inheritance tax payable. At the time he bought the land, in 1996, inheritance tax allowances were far lower than they are today - making it easier for a person's estate to cross the threshold into paying the tax and creating an even greater incentive to reduce the size of an estate
- Starmer says he structure the purchase with anything in mind other than helping his parents.
- We have repeatedly asked why, then, he could not have pursued the two simplest options: giving them the field - or retaining it but letting them use it. That is not a question which No10 would answer.
- Fast forward to 2018: Starmer's father's estate upon death had a gross value of £460k and a net value of £375k.
Had the field been included, Starmer, as executor, would have needed to get it valued within a year and submit details to HMRC as part of wider inheritance tax admin - a precursor to getting probate
- As the field did not form part of the estate, this did not happen
- It is impossible to say what its value would have been at the time. It could have been higher, it could have been lower, but let's take its eventual sale price of £295k (the relevant share of the £3230k for which he sold the field and an adjacent strip belonging to his father) in 2022. In that scenario, the net value of the estate grows to £670k
- That sum easily eclipses the basic IHT allowance, and it exceeds the combined basic allowance and the residence nil band rate which would have been available to his father. It falls short of the combined size of his father's estate and his mother's allowances, which, to the extent they were unused, could have been unused
- In other words, while no one can say exactly what the estate would have been, there are scenarios where it could have plausibly tipped the estate into an IHT liability and scenarios where it plausibly could have had no ultimate effect. For the sake of fairness Starmer says such a structure made "no difference" to the estate's eventual liability
- Of course, upon the purchase, the PM could not have known what the actual eventual implications would be - the value of the land, the size of his parents estates, and the allowance available to them upon death, were all known unknowns.
- All that is know is that the arrangement put the field outside the domain of IHT - then, as it is now, set at 40%
- We went to No10 months ago with a number of queries. the PM has demanded transparency and railed against legal tax avoidance - saying the money better spent on the NHS - but he would not answer Qs in detail.
- He spent a day with top KC in Downing St but then simply said all taxes were paid.
- We went back with Qs about the trust weeks ago - a list of clear, fair inquiries, with plenty of time to answer, and none assuming any wrongdoing or bad faith. But the PM will only go as far as saying, whatever the arrangement was, he paid all his taxes, and did not have tax in mind in creating it.
- That is where we are left after some expert detective work from @DanNeidle and my impressive colleagues @ManuMidolo and @venetiamenzies. Take a look below...
Did Keir Starmer give land to his parents via a trust, guaranteeing their estate, of which he was beneficiary, would never pay inheritance tax on its eventual value?
Legal experts say yes.
Curiously No10 will not answer - despite having a list of straightforward questions for weeks and Starmer retaining a leading tax KC following our original approach.
@DanNeidle, @manumidolo, @venetiamenzies and I have done our detective work regardless. Read the Sunday Times and Tax Policy Associates tomorrow to find out more!