ChatGPT Translation:
SPIEGEL: Professor Allison, Donald Trump has promised to end the war in Ukraine as quickly as possible. Will he succeed?
Allison: Yes, I believe this terrible war will soon come to an end. In fact, I would bet that we will have a ceasefire within the next six months.
SPIEGEL: How is that supposed to happen?
Allison: With the help of a powerful partner: China. Trump has shown that he thinks highly of Chinese President Xi Jinping and hopes for his assistance. After meeting Zelensky and Macron at the reopening of Notre Dame Cathedral, he tweeted: “China can help.” Since then, Trump and Xi have spoken on the phone several times. According to media reports, there have also been phone calls between Trump and Putin as well as Xi and Putin. To me, it looks as though the puzzle pieces are coming together.
SPIEGEL: What does that picture look like?
Allison: An end to the war on the battlefield in the form of a pause in fighting and possibly even a formal armistice. The United States and China will tell each party to the conflict: “Enough.” The fighting will end roughly along the current front line, maybe with slight adjustments. Because the US and China are working together on this solution, the parties can hope that it won’t just be a brief interruption. That is especially important for Ukraine, which fears that Putin could use a ceasefire to prepare for the next phase of the war. China’s role as a guarantor of the ceasefire could be very significant.
SPIEGEL: Why should the Ukrainians agree to such a deal?
Allison: Because they have no other choice. Trump has already made it very clear to Ukrainian President Zelensky that he wants this war to end now. Trump believes that this war would never have happened if he had been president, because he would never have toyed with the idea of bringing Ukraine into NATO. And he has made it clear that he will no longer cover the costs of the war. Trump has repeatedly emphasized that far too many people have already died in Ukraine, that the longer the war continues, the more Ukraine will lose, and that Ukraine therefore will not be in a better position for a deal a year from now than it is today.
SPIEGEL: Trump’s predecessor Joe Biden had a mantra: “Nothing about Ukraine without Ukraine.”
Allison: Trump sees it differently. When American interests are at stake, he always says, “America First.” From the beginning, he has made it clear that he doesn’t care whether the war ends along today’s front lines or 100 kilometers closer to Kyiv. He wonders, “Why should someone like Zelensky decide on my interests?” The international order and human rights are not big concepts in his vocabulary. To him, there are strong powers and weak powers, and the weak have to submit to the strong because they have no alternative. He is an old-school realist.
SPIEGEL: That’s reminiscent of the time before World War II, when European great powers decided the fate of their neighbors at will. Are we headed for another catastrophe?
Allison: I don’t find that analogy helpful. From the start of the war, realists have argued that Ukraine would lose more lives and territory the longer the war lasted. Six months after Putin’s invasion and the Ukrainian counteroffensive, then Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Mark Milley advocated that the US take a leading role in negotiating a ceasefire. If the war had ended last year, Ukraine would be better off today. And if we wait another year, it will be in an even worse position than now.
SPIEGEL: Still, wouldn’t such a peace send a dangerous message to Russia that borders can indeed be changed if one is brazen enough?
Allison: Maybe, but in my view people overestimate the importance of that message. Whether Vladimir Putin attacks Latvia, Poland, or Germany next isn’t really determined by how the war in Ukraine ends. What deters Putin is the deterrent posture of other states. Deterrence is the product of capability multiplied by credibility. If Europeans and Americans in NATO expand their military capabilities—and if the promise to respond to an attack on one state as if it were an attack on all is credible—then, in my opinion, the probability that Putin will invade a NATO country is nearly zero.
SPIEGEL: So in the end it’s all about the number of soldiers, tanks, or drones?
Allison: No. As I said, you have to multiply capability by credibility. If Trump were to say that NATO’s obligation to assist no longer applies to Latvia, Poland, or Germany, then the whole chessboard would look very different.
SPIEGEL: Trump demands that NATO countries spend five percent of their GDP on defense and threatens to leave NATO.
Allison: That’s how Trump makes deals: he starts with a maximum demand and might end up settling for three percent.
SPIEGEL: Can you haggle over the security of the Western world like a used car?
Allison: Trump’s negotiating tactic is to begin with an extreme demand. He wants the other side to feel uneasy. That gives him the chance to get an even better deal. Trump is a brilliant showman who combines facts, fiction, and his imagination in a unique way. He is a calculated provocateur who says shocking things to shake things up, even creating a bit of chaos. From his perspective, that gives the more powerful party an opportunity to push through its interests. Most of us think, “You can’t say that!” But that’s part of his method. Remember his campaign against Kamala Harris?
SPIEGEL: Of course.
Allison: Can you recall a single memorable quote from her campaign?
SPIEGEL: Not off the top of my head.
Allison: It’s the same for many people in America. But everyone remembers Trump’s tirades against “Sleepy Joe” or “Crooked Hillary.” Immigrants become “invaders” who allegedly even ate our dogs and cats. It’s certainly unorthodox. But regardless of what we think of his tactics, and whatever else Trump may or may not be, he managed the greatest comeback in American history. My advice would be to view him as a phenomenon. To quote a good piece of advice from investor Peter Thiel: you shouldn’t take him literally, but you do have to take him seriously.
SPIEGEL: Does Trump really mean it when he threatens to withdraw from NATO?
Allison: I don’t think so. But he sees the other NATO members as free riders, and he has a point. Compared to Russia, Europe has four times the population and twelve times the GDP. But it doesn’t have the necessary military capabilities to defend itself, and it isn’t united. So there is some truth to Trump’s criticism. But there is something he overlooks.
SPIEGEL: What is that?
Allison: The US allies in Europe and Japan pay less for defense than they should, but together with the United Nations they form the foundations of the US-led international order. That order has allowed us to live for the past 79 years without a war between great powers. The architects of this system had experienced firsthand what happened to the world in the first half of the 20th century, when a rivalry between great powers led to World War I. After a short respite, this great-power poker led to World War II. That made these wise men think and led to the creation of a new system to prevent a third world war. I believe these statesmen were right. I’m grateful for that.
SPIEGEL: What do we learn from this?
Allison: Only thanks to the international order has the West experienced the longest period of peace in human history. A fantastic success! If people now say, “You should pay more” or “I should pay more,” it’s like arguing over how to split the restaurant bill. We should be glad that there was dinner for us all in the first place. I hope Trump does not overlook that.
SPIEGEL: How should Germany and other Europeans respond to Trump’s threats?
Allison: Tony Blair gave some wise advice about this at the World Economic Forum in Davos. He said, “Those who don’t change will be subject to the changes of others.” Germany has to change. The next federal government should not only work for more growth to improve people’s lives; it should also expand Germany’s military capabilities. But Europe’s problems run even deeper.
SPIEGEL: In what sense?
Allison: I love Europe and European culture. But Donald Trump is right when he complains about inefficiency in Europe; you need only read Mario Draghi’s report on the EU’s lack of competitiveness. Europe needs to become more efficient and more capable of defense. Far-sighted Europeans have realized that Europe needs radical change. Smart leaders could even use Trump’s demands to push through far-reaching reforms.
SPIEGEL: Who or what could stop Donald Trump?
Allison: Even Trump cannot override the laws of gravity. Right now the hopes are enormous; many people want to believe he will fulfill the promise of a golden American era. Yet some of the measures he’s calling for have the opposite effect. You cannot reduce the deficit with large tax cuts. And if you impose tariffs on goods from China or the EU, that tends to drive inflation higher. Rising inflation and higher interest rates aren’t good for the stock market. All of that can backfire.
SPIEGEL: And then?
Allison: Then, in two years, the next congressional elections will come around. I believe in American democracy.