Vampire bats aren’t just drinking blood. They’re sampling viruses too
New evidence shows they were infected with H5N1 after feeding on marine animals with bird flu
Bats in Egypt are also susceptible to a related strain of another bird flu virus, H9N2
www.sciencenews.org/article/vampire-bats-bird-flu-h5n1-virus
Jane Qiu
Jane Qiu (Chinese: 邱瑾; pinyin: Qiū Jǐn) is an independent science journalist based in Beijing, primarily focusing on geoscience and the environment. More on Wikipedia
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jammer
@acrossthemersey
Scientists in Peru found over a dozen vampire bats with H5N1 antibodies after likely feeding on sick and dying marine animals, calling it very worrisome and a step closer to spreading among people.
www.sciencenews.org/article/vampire-bats-bird-flu-h5n1-virus -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I’ve started posting on Bluesky from this account: @janeqiu.bsky.social
Please connect me there. Together, let’s help build a better world there. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
Epidemiologists & virologists estimate a 77% likelihood that covid began with a spillover from nature, like the emergence of SARS, HIV, Ebola, flu & other epidemics.
90% predict the next pandemic will stem from a natural zoonotic event.
Details: gcrinstitute.org/papers/069_covid-origin.pdf -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Siri Carpenter
@SiriCarpenter
I had the pleasure of visiting the SHERP program @nyu_journalism recently & got peek at this gorgeous, meticulously reported project: @Scienceline for Kids! Congrats to @EllynLapointe, @alicesun_nature, and the rest of the #sherpies! scienceline.org/scienceline-kids/
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
KSJ at MIT
@KSJatMIT
Local, local, local!
Know of any US science journalists doing excellent work at the local or regional level? Tell them to submit their work for the McElheny Award -
ksj.mit.edu/mcelheny-award/
Submissions close January 31, 2024.
Sally James
@jamesian
Many of you who follow me are #science #journalists. Please enter this contest! $10K. Glory. Local, local, local.
#scicomm #sciwri23 @nswa
@KSJatMIT
Click link for details. ksj.mit.edu/mcelheny-award/submission-guidelines/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Céline Gounder, MD, ScM, FIDSA 🇺🇦
@celinegounder
1/ Ohio is reporting an outbreak of pediatric pneumonia cases.
This is similar to the "white lung syndrome" (aka ARDS) that is being seen in Europe & China.
THIS IS NOT DUE TO A NOVEL PATHOGEN CAUSING A NEW PANDEMIC.
on @CBSEveningNews @CBSNews with @noraodonnell & @megoliverThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
friendly boar 🐗
@FriendlyBoar
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Sarah Wild
@sarahemilywild
My first piece in @ObserverUK : Where did they all go? How Homo sapiens became the last human species left
www.theguardian.com/science/2023/nov/18/where-did-other-h… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Chris Stringer
@ChrisStringer65
‘Humanity will be faced with either cooperating in the face of those crises or competing. And what we see from Neanderthals and H sapiens is that the groups that cooperated better were the ones that got through’ www.theguardian.com/science/2023/nov/18/where-did-other-h…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Alice C Hughes
@AliceCHughes
Good data is key to good decisions
Errors in data, spatial, temporal& taxonomic inconsistencies,biases & gaps hinder effective decision making
The redlist needs to evolve to better reflect species ranges + risks
The RL should be A not THE species indicator
www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/nov/22/iucn-red-list… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Royal Society
@royalsociety
Breathless takes us inside the frantic international effort to understand and control the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus, like peering over the shoulders of the brilliant scientists who led the chase. Author David Quammen tells us why it's so important to trust in the scientific process:
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Peter Aldhous
@paldhous
ICYMI: tipsheet from investigative reporting session at #sciwri23. Thanks @betsyladyzhets and @priyanka_runwal for organizing and fellow panelists @stephaniemlee @lisalsong @NicholasFlorko
docs.google.com/document/d/1PHy6DNOMB5pJsgRGEqnK80MB7fL07… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
eileen chengyin chow
@chowleen
This is the light of autumn; it has turned on us.
Surely it is a privilege to approach the end
still believing in something.
- Louise Glück, "October"
#everynightapoem #fragment -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
eileen chengyin chow
@chowleen
I wanted to stay as I was
still as the world is never still,
not in midsummer but the moment before
the first flower forms, the moment
nothing is as yet past—
-Louise Glück, "The Doorway"
(1943 - October 13, 2023) safe travels
#everynightapoem -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
GO GREEN
@ECOWARRIORSS
Since 1990, 420 million hectares of forest lost as a result of human activity including land clearing for agricultural farming logging
We Lose 10 Million Hectares of Forest Every Single Year
Deforestation Contributes about 4.8 Billion Tonnes of C02 A Year
earth.org/deforestation-facts/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Tom Zeller Jr.
@tomzellerjr
We are living in troubled times and the competition for attention and emotional space is stiff. Still, I'd like to invite you to visit a truly masterful piece of journalism of a different sort, with some thoughts on why I think it's important. 1/14 🧵
undark.org/2023/10/09/rsv-vaccine-children-trials/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The TLS
@TheTLS
'Rather refreshingly, Mitchell says that to get a clear picture of free will, 'humans are the absolute worst place to start.'
Philip Ball (@philipcball) on the quest to determine whether humanity has the freedom to choose
www.the-tls.co.uk/articles/determined-robert-sapolsky-fre… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jo Marchant
@JoMarchant
First text from inside intact Herculaneum scrolls! And they’ll have more very soon… My piece for @Nature - most exciting story I’ve worked on in a long time www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-03212-1
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Deborah Blum
@deborahblum
I just signed the @AuthorsGuild's Open Letter to Generative AI Leaders calling on them to compensate writers fairly for the use of copyrighted materials in their AI programs. Sign here: actionnetwork.org/petitions/authors-guild-open-letter-to-…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Zahra Hirji
@Zhirji28
It was fun talking to @elaberwarren for this @Open_Notebook story on tips for prepping & conducting interviews. Always come prepared with questions, but be ready to ask follow-ups on the spot. You might just get your best quote or anecdote that way!
www.theopennotebook.com/2023/09/26/the-art-of-crafting-ef… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Emily Laber-Warren
@elaberwarren
Thanks to @Open_Notebook editors @thekibosch @RachelZamzow @SiriCarpenter for helping make this story vivid and concise. And to my interviewees! @anilananth @Zhirji28 @Rehabamohsen @jefftollef @lxin2014 It was a very meta experience to interview journalists about interviewing!
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
You don’t know what a person has to say until you speak with them, so how do you know what to ask? Well, here is how, from @elaberwarren, with @anilananth, @zhirji28 and others. www.theopennotebook.com/2023/09/26/the-art-of-crafting-ef…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Prof. Dr. Hasan Ünal
@hasanunal1920
The US has always been the champion of making foreign policy mistakes but each & every mistake it has made has led to a catastrophe for several nations in the world
Arnaud Bertrand
@RnaudBertrand
This is incredible. This is Graham Allison, the Founding Dean of the Harvard Kennedy School of Government - who taught generations of US leaders - and former Assistant Secretary of Defense.
Here is what he says on the "rules-based order": "We say we're the exceptional nation. What does that mean? That means we make the rules and you're supposed to obey the rules. But we don't obey the rules. So we say we're for the rules-based order. Excuse me the rules-based order was the basis with which we invaded Iraq? I don't think so. That we occupied Afghanistan? I don't think so. The US has made a lot of mistakes of unnecessary wars." -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
KSJ at MIT
@KSJatMIT
Congratulations to our Associate Director @AshleyTheSmart, winner of the 2023 NASW Science in Society Longform Narratives Category for his article “A Field at a crossroads: Genetics and Racial Mythmaking”
race.undark.org/articles/a-field-at-a-crossroads-genetics… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
KSJ at MIT
@KSJatMIT
Congratulations to 2023-2024 KSJ Fellow @Kakape, winner of the 2023 NASW Science in Society Commentary Category for his article “We Can Fight Monkeypox Without Hysteria or Homophobia” www.nytimes.com/2022/08/04/opinion/monkeypox-communicatio…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Ashley Smart
@ashleythesmart
Shout out to the entire @undarkmag team, to @big_data_kane, @smjyoti, @jonathan_moens, @duylinhtu, @CharlesMBlow, Melba Newsome, @kgpnyc, and Maria Baranova, and to my co-pilot Angela Saini. We did good work yall.
Tom Zeller Jr.
@tomzellerjr
I'm just so proud of @undarkmag and @ashleythesmart. Thanks to @ONA for recognizing this work, and congrats to all of the #ona23 nominees and winners.
If you haven't explored race.undark.org, you're missing out on some powerful #journalism. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Tom Zeller Jr.
@tomzellerjr
I'm just so proud of @undarkmag and @ashleythesmart. Thanks to @ONA for recognizing this work, and congrats to all of the #ona23 nominees and winners.
If you haven't explored race.undark.org, you're missing out on some powerful #journalism. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Online News Association
@ONA
The 2023 ONA Community Award recognizes @SiriCarpenter for her work leading The Open Notebook, a nonprofit organization on a mission to help journalists improve their skills in covering science, health, technology and the environment. awards.journalists.org/entries/siri-carpenter/
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Ashley Smart
@ashleythesmart
Congrats, @SiriCarpenter! Couldn't imagine a more deserving winner!
Online News Association
@ONA
The 2023 ONA Community Award recognizes @SiriCarpenter for her work leading The Open Notebook, a nonprofit organization on a mission to help journalists improve their skills in covering science, health, technology and the environment. awards.journalists.org/entries/siri-carpenter/
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Kai Kupferschmidt
@kakape
So sad to hear that @MohammedY has died. Mohammed passionately believed in and bravely defended the role of science journalism in society and he was simply a lovely and kind person full of joy. This from Toulouse in 2018 has always stuck in my memory…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Deborah Blum
@deborahblum
This is just so impossibly sad. A good man and a science journalist who made a real difference gone way too soon. cen.acs.org/people/obituaries/CEN-editor-in-chief-Mohamme… via @cenmag
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Timothy Caulfield
@CaulfieldTim
Journalism Is a Public Good and Should Be Publicly Funded www.scientificamerican.com/article/journalism-is-a-public… via @sciam cc @carlyweeks @picardonhealth
The disastrous effects of less good journalism: "a steady supply of misinformation, often masquerading as legitimate news..."
#scienceupfirst -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Hank Greely
@HankGreelyLSJU
REALLY nice write up of the Earth BioGenome project by @SilverJacket: www.newyorker.com/science/elements/the-race-to-save-the-w…
Deals w/both science & ethics, including indigenous peoples' issues.
To me, project isn't so much racing the clock but wanting to get a baseline of just what's here, now. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Yangyang Cheng
@yangyang_cheng
For @WIRED, I write about the ethnicization of espionage in the US as a distinct Chinese threat: like how terrorism is racialized as Muslim after 9/11, it's rooted in centuries-old racism and weaponized to expand state power and advance special interests.
www.wired.com/story/china-espionage-tiktok-spying-nationa… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Marion Koopmans, publications: https://pure.eur.nl
@MarionKoopmans
While we see discussions about investing billions in response to outbreaks, we continue to have a blind spot for early warning and prevention focussed initiatives. Read the worrisome downfall of PROMED. Of course things should not depend on a single person www.science.org/content/article/long-running-promed-email…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
Journalists have helped propagate ableism by using language that casts disability as abnormal and socially unacceptable. #diversevoices www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/27/eradicating-ableist-la…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
Covering gender-affirming care for trans youth?
✳️ Check your source affiliations
✳️ Don’t give false balance
✳️ Include the experiences of the people seeking the treatments you’re writing about.
More here for tips on better reporting. www.theopennotebook.com/2023/07/25/how-to-report-on-healt… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Merritt Turetsky
@queenofpeat
NEW PAPER ALERT! I am fortunate to have published a lot, but this permafrost paper and review is really special to me. Let me explain why. 1/
www.nature.com/articles/s43247-023-00886-3 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
SARS‑CoV‑2 (COVID-19)
@COVID19_disease
It has been confirmed that 38 cats died in South Korea due to avian influenza.
news.sbs.co.kr/news/endPage.do?news_id=N1007282384&plink=… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Sunday Long Read
@sundaylongread
So you say you want…a jungle wedding? @HighHip did—tying the knot at El Mirador, the ruins of a Mayan city—and discovered nothing says “I do” like a small blood sacrifice. A breezy, hilarious story stuffed full of cautionary tales. @DVNJr's pick: www.outsideonline.com/adventure-travel/essays/jungle-wedd…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
WWF
@WWF
Twitter's iconic bird isn't the only one disappearing.
👉 Today, one in eight bird species are at risk of extinction.
But we can save them and their habitats – benefiting people and nature across the globe. RT to spread the word! #twitterx #twitterlogo -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Alice C Hughes
@AliceCHughes
Great stuff, important work and really fun collaboration
We need more of this kind of work to really understand the dynamics that underlie the phylogeographic patterns of viruses
Spyros Lytras
@SpyrosLytras
Check out @jepekar chatting to @PeaseRoland about our recent preprint on the human SARS-CoVs evolutionary origins and phylogeography in @BBCScienceNews Science in Action www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct4sck
(Jonathan's bit start around 20:02) -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Mariana Lenharo
@marilenharo
Scientists whose first language is not English spend much longer to read and write papers in English and prepare for international conferences. @tatsuya_amano and colleagues worked to measure this invisible struggle. I wrote about their work for @Nature www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-02320-2
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Julia Rosen
@1juliarosen
Finally got around to reading this wonderful @Open_Notebook story on the ladder of abstraction, by @smjyoti, and was delighted to see that it opens with an example from the fabulous @DeborahNetburn.
Full of insightful writing advice, as always: www.theopennotebook.com/2023/05/30/using-the-ladder-of-ab… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Ade Adamson, MD MPP
@AdeAdamson
The @washingtonpost with more melanoma health disparities pornography replete with misleading statistics and false statements. I’m not sure who dropped the bag here, the journalist or the researchers/dermatologists. Probably both. THREAD 🧵👇🏾
The Washington Post
@washingtonpost
Melanoma is far more deadly in Black men, who may get skin cancer in unexpected places such as fingernails and the bottoms of their feet, according to a study of more than 205,000 cases. www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2023/07/11/melanoma-skin-…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Alice C Hughes
@AliceCHughes
Caves are amazing, upto 90% of species are undescribed, and a huge amount to learn
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-02155-x
-however also note these systems are at risk, mining rates are high in many tropical regions, and global aquifer depletion is also a risk -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Alice C Hughes
@AliceCHughes
Good to see more data on bat viruses and their dynamics as well as inter-relationships between bats and their viruses, especially coming from Yunnan province
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Gigi Gronvall
@ggronvall
It's great testimony @K_G_Andersen, but I am sorry this sorry spectacle is occurring, and that a Congressional committee is treating US scientists this way. So many people should be feeling ashamed for their behavior that led up to this moment, if shame were in their capacity.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Wonder of Science
@wonderofscience
The beautiful opalescent nudibranch (Hermissenda opalescens), one of the most colorful species of sea slug, filmed off the coast of California by Aron Sanchez-Baranda.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
David Steel
@SteelySeabirder
The incredible Gannets of the Bass Rock…what a place, what birds!
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jeremy Farrar
@JeremyFarrar
Another reason why regulators need to be ahead technological advances in order to preserve & facilitate positive impact & prevent abuse & protect us all. Anticipating technological developments so important rather than reacting by which time too late. www.telegraph.co.uk/money/consumer-affairs/scammers-ai-de…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
"From spilling all the secrets of kick-starting freelance to explanations about different scientific studies, (TON) covers the nitty gritty of doing science journalism."
A delightful interview between @SiriCarpenter and @septia_nurmala2 for @jyijournal. www.jyi.org/2023-may/the-life-of-science-journalist-turne… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Peter Yang
@petergyang
Here's a wild stat:
43% of white students admitted to Harvard are legacy, athletes, or related to donors or staff.
86% admit rate for athletes is insane. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Elen Shute
@LoneRangifer
I just don't have the words for this after an awful year spent in his lab. Not mentioned in the article, Adelaide was the 2nd uni from which he made an inelegant exit. Previously, Oxford. Has he really changed his ways, or will he just find new enablers?
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-02147-x -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Michael 英泉 Eisen
@mbeisen
I’ve learned from a decade on this app to not accept the superficial way things are presented here, especially when someone’s words are being used against them. And so I watched the whole session for context. And I’m glad I did. Because in context it’s way worse.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Alice C Hughes
@AliceCHughes
as a woman in science I have regularly been the only woman in meetings, 1 of 3 female PIs in my last job, the only tenured woman in the ecology&biodiversity dept in my present one
Discrimination, bias, & barriers are real-& they prevent the diversity of scientists we need -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Marion Koopmans, publications: https://pure.eur.nl
@MarionKoopmans
A committee that posts tweets about an inquiry with comments like “ get your popcorn out”, in my view is a committee that has failed before it started and is of ill faith. I do not see why scientists should subject themselves to such abusive behavior. Evaluations? Fine.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Uproot Project
@uproot_project
This article on @Open_Notebook has some great suggestions for how to remove ableist language from your reporting! www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/27/eradicating-ableist-la…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Robertson
@robertson_lab
Nice to see journalist @mehdirhasan following the science for SARS-CoV-2’s origin👍🏻& lack of evidence for it being a lab leak - ‘People who believe the novel coronavirus was the result of a lab experiment don't have any evidence to support their theory’ www.msnbc.com/the-mehdi-hasan-show/the-mehdi-hasan-show/c…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Declassified intel refutes the narratives that have been enthusiastically & relentlessly splashed across @WSJ @thetimes
But let’s not forget unique contribution of @propublica @VanityFair👇
Great piece by @PaulNuki @Telegraph: informative, fair & witty
www.telegraph.co.uk/global-health/science-and-disease/why…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Declassified intel refutes the narratives that have been enthusiastically & relentlessly splashed across @WSJ @thetimes
But let’s not forget unique contribution of @propublica @VanityFair👇
Great piece by @PaulNuki @Telegraph: informative, fair & witty
www.telegraph.co.uk/global-health/science-and-disease/why…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Kendall Powell
@KendallSciWrite
So excited to help usher this important piece by @rach_garr and @AlisonRBentley out into the light! If you are not a #womeninstem pls read and absorb and grow.
Don’t get mad, get equal: putting an end to misogyny in science www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-02101-x -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Subtle forms of misogyny can be daily trials for female scientists, chipping away their metal well-being and making them consider to quit science
Two scientists speak out about the soul-crushing ordeals they have to endure to survive in the still male-dominated world of science -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Disability is a normal,intrinsic & ubiquitous feature of human experience
Yet we live in a society that often associates it in negative contexts,thereby dehumanizing people w disability —a phenomenon termed ableism
Countering ableism language is the 1st step to counter ableism
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
A slip up during @MarionRenault’s reporting for this story exemplified the insidiousness of ableist language. With @AmandaMoMorris, @infamouslyshort, @emily_ladau, @EricMGarcia and many others. #diversevoices www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/27/eradicating-ableist-la…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Alice C Hughes
@AliceCHughes
Some astute comments from @sreetama on our recent piece on the lack of diversity and representation in high impact researchers in ecology and diversity, and how we can work to do better www.asianscientist.com/2023/06/in-the-lab/why-are-there-s…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Disability is a normal,intrinsic & ubiquitous feature of human experience
Yet we live in a society that often associates it in negative contexts,thereby dehumanizing people w disability —a phenomenon termed ableism
Countering ableism language is the 1st step to counter ableism
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
A slip up during @MarionRenault’s reporting for this story exemplified the insidiousness of ableist language. With @AmandaMoMorris, @infamouslyshort, @emily_ladau, @EricMGarcia and many others. #diversevoices www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/27/eradicating-ableist-la…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Subtle forms of misogyny can be daily trials for female scientists, chipping away their metal well-being and making them consider to quit science
Two scientists speak out about the soul-crushing ordeals they have to endure to survive in the still male-dominated world of science -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Mariana Lenharo
@marilenharo
25 years ago, neuroscientist Christof Koch bet philosopher @davidchalmers42 that the neural basis of consciousness would be clear by 2023. This Friday, Chalmers brought home a case of fine wine. I reported about this scientific wager for @Nature www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-02120-8
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You know how to spoil a good party, Eddie!
It’s hilarious!
It just shows how increasingly desperate and ridiculous @emilyakopp @USRightToKnow is getting.
Such is the sad reality of the clickbait economy of our time.
At what cost? -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Declassified intel serves as a reproach to news orgs that have bought into lab-leak theory despite utter lack of evidence,says @hiltzikm
“The saddest example” is claims in article by @propublica @VanityFair, which the intel report has debunked
Is it time to retract the story?
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
National Association of Science Writers (NASW)
@ScienceWriters
ICYMI: The @ScienceWriters @ScienceWriting national meeting is coming to Colorado this October, with virtual sessions preceding. Save the dates for #sciwri23—and tell a friend or colleague!
Bookmark Website: sciencewriters2023.org
Share CU News Release: www.colorado.edu/today/2023/03/14/nations-biggest-science… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
RSV wasn’t caused by vaccine research.
HIV didn’t emerge from polio vaccines.
Nobody knew flu was caused by a virus in 1918, much less leaked it from a vaccine lab.
Gain of function research has nothing to do with these pathogens.
This is the kind of wrong that kills people.
Rolling Stone
@RollingStone
RFK Jr. Claims ‘Vaccine Research’ Likely Responsible for HIV and the Spanish Flu
www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/rfk-kennedy-a… -
Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You know how to spoil a good party, Eddie!
It’s hilarious!
It just shows how increasingly desperate and ridiculous @emilyakopp @USRightToKnow is getting.
Such is the sad reality of the clickbait economy of our time.
At what cost? -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Declassified intel serves as a reproach to news orgs that have bought into lab-leak theory despite utter lack of evidence,says @hiltzikm
“The saddest example” is claims in article by @propublica @VanityFair, which the intel report has debunked
Is it time to retract the story?
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Silverman
@amysilvermanaz
Such an important, detailed and well done piece about the language around disability. Thank you @MarionRenault and @Open_Notebook
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
A slip up during @MarionRenault’s reporting for this story exemplified the insidiousness of ableist language. With @AmandaMoMorris, @infamouslyshort, @emily_ladau, @EricMGarcia and many others. #diversevoices www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/27/eradicating-ableist-la…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
“Ableism evaluates the worth of bodies and minds based on socially constructed criteria of normalcy, performance, and intelligence.” – @MarionRenault, with @kristingilger, @ricearosie, @sesmith, @wendyluwrites, @DisabilityStor1 and more. #diversevoices www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/27/eradicating-ableist-la…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Magdalena Skipper
@Magda_Skipper
Read it! It makes for uncomfortable reading; it’s important!
#womeninstem #womeninleadership -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Alice C Hughes
@AliceCHughes
Being a woman in academia is tough, at all stages
It does not get easier if you do become successful, you just face different challenges
We need to change this to ensure that the next generations of women do not continue to experience the same challenges
www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fenvs.2023.1211211/full -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Michael Hiltzik
@hiltzikm
Column: U.S. government debunks COVID lab-leak conspiracy theory, enraging conspiracy theorists www.latimes.com/business/story/2023-06-26/u-s-government-…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Scientist Koch lost a case of fine wine over 25-year bet with philosopher @davidchalmers42 that mystery of consciousness would be solved by 2023
Both are involved in ‘adversarial’ experiments to test hypotheses by getting rival scientists to collaborate
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-02120-8 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
.@Ankur_pali evokes Toni Morrison’s famous quote on rejecting the white gaze:
“I have spent my entire writing life trying to make sure that the white gaze was not the dominant one in any of my books.”
Excellent @Open_Notebook interview by @pratikmpawar
www.pbs.org/wnet/americanmasters/toni-morrison-on-writing… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“You should break free” from established media houses abroad about the form & techniques
“It’s the culture that informs writing and writing choices”
You should see things through the worldview of the people you meet, not the worldview that people in the West have
@Ankur_pali
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
In reporting his @FiftyTwoDotIn story, Off Balance, @Ankur_pali wanted to show the incremental process that defines science, showcasing a scientist’s quest and the patients living with hope for better understanding of their disease. www.theopennotebook.com/2022/07/05/ankur-paliwal-tells-th…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
Our summer fundraiser is in full swing! We need YOUR support to empower science writers worldwide. Help us reach our goal of 50 new donors and 25 new monthly recurring donors. If you're able, donate today! #sciencejournalism www.theopennotebook.com/donate
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
@ijbailey
It was just weeks ago that journalists who raised these types of issues were demeaned by other journalists as "emotional" "woke" "activists" who want to destroy journalistic standards, including at @nytimes. That's what's been so frustrating. 1/ www.nytimes.com/2023/05/16/us/politics/transgender-care-d…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Lucy Jakub
@LucyJakub
"A writer does not need to be just one kind of writer." I interviewed the one and only @DavidQuammen about his long career, from the book review to the science essay to "slogging through jungles with intrepid biologists." www.nybooks.com/online/2023/06/24/who-swims-with-the-scie…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Scientist Koch lost a case of fine wine over 25-year bet with philosopher @davidchalmers42 that mystery of consciousness would be solved by 2023
Both are involved in ‘adversarial’ experiments to test hypotheses by getting rival scientists to collaborate
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-02120-8 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Alice C Hughes
@AliceCHughes
Important to note, this is patently untrue and agriculture is pushing us towards tipping-points which will exacerbate climate change as well as being the main driver of global biodiversity loss
Amazingly being a billionaire does not mean ignoring facts is wise-see Titan sub CEO
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
Important to note that what happens on Earth’s surface (eg farming) has no meaningful impact on climate change.
Overwhelmingly, the risk of climate change is due to moving billions of tons of carbon from deep underground into the atmosphere.
Over time, if we keep doing this, the chemical makeup of our atmosphere will change enough to induce meaningful climate change. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“You should break free” from established media houses abroad about the form & techniques
“It’s the culture that informs writing and writing choices”
You should see things through the worldview of the people you meet, not the worldview that people in the West have
@Ankur_pali
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
In reporting his @FiftyTwoDotIn story, Off Balance, @Ankur_pali wanted to show the incremental process that defines science, showcasing a scientist’s quest and the patients living with hope for better understanding of their disease. www.theopennotebook.com/2022/07/05/ankur-paliwal-tells-th…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
.@Ankur_pali evokes Toni Morrison’s famous quote on rejecting the white gaze:
“I have spent my entire writing life trying to make sure that the white gaze was not the dominant one in any of my books.”
Excellent @Open_Notebook interview by @pratikmpawar
www.pbs.org/wnet/americanmasters/toni-morrison-on-writing… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Greg Tucker-Kellogg (gtuckerkellogg.bsky.social)
@gtuckerkellogg
The ODNI declassification makes clear that the Oct/Nov 222 @VanityFair/@propublica report by @KatherineEban and @jeffykao, in addition to relying on amateurish and flawed translations by a self-proclaimed CCP-whisperer, was also wrong about pretty much everything else.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
John Travis
@johnstravis
Whether you believe them or not, here are on the record denials from 2 of 3 WIV scientists anonymously accused of being the first COVID-19 patients and of sparking the pandemic. a @sciencecohen exclusive. www.science.org/content/article/ridiculous-says-chinese-s…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Alice C Hughes
@AliceCHughes
Science matters, data matters, not collecting data and conducting biosurveillance is flying blind
We cannot continue to target scientists,research is crucial to avoiding future pandemics
We cannot afford to close our eyes & pretend there are no risks by stopping critical research
Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic
@COVIDSelect
🚨SUBPOENA ALERT🚨
@COVIDSelect announces its FIRST subpoena for “Proximal Origins” author Kristian Andersen’s private communications with the paper's co-authors & related info on COVID-19 origins.
We are following the breadcrumbs of a COVID cover-up straight to the source! -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Julie Rehmeyer
@julierehmeyer
I love the way that @Open_Notebook is challenging me to see myself as a global citizen and to expand my conception of the science journalism community to the whole world, not just the West. www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/20/how-non-western-journa…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Local journalists are critical not only for empowering underserved local communities but providing underappreciated perspectives in international press
It’s indispensable in our understanding of the world, our relationship to each other & how to make the world a better place
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
“An understanding of the world only from the Western perspective is not only limited but extremely dangerous,” says @janeqiuchina in this article about how journalists from the Global South enriched coverage of COVID-19. www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/20/how-non-western-journa…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Local journalists are critical not only for empowering underserved local communities but providing underappreciated perspectives in international press
It’s indispensable in our understanding of the world, our relationship to each other & how to make the world a better place
National Association of Science Writers (NASW)
@ScienceWriters
Newsroom Mentors and Journalism Instructors: Teaching trainees how to expand, improve, and grow their reporting practices to include historically overlooked perspectives? Use our Diverse Voices collection—a @ScienceWriters @Open_Notebook collaboration: www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/20/how-non-western-journa…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Local journalists are critical not only for empowering underserved local communities but providing underappreciated perspectives in international press
It’s indispensable in our understanding of the world, our relationship to each other & how to make the world a better place
National Association of Science Writers (NASW)
@ScienceWriters
Newsroom Mentors and Journalism Instructors: Teaching trainees how to expand, improve, and grow their reporting practices to include historically overlooked perspectives? Use our Diverse Voices collection—a @ScienceWriters @Open_Notebook collaboration: www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/20/how-non-western-journa…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Local journalists are critical not only for empowering underserved local communities but providing underappreciated perspectives in international press
It’s indispensable in our understanding of the world, our relationship to each other & how to make the world a better place
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
“An understanding of the world only from the Western perspective is not only limited but extremely dangerous,” says @janeqiuchina in this article about how journalists from the Global South enriched coverage of COVID-19. www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/20/how-non-western-journa…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
An understanding of the world only from the Western perspective is not only limited but extremely dangerous
Local journalism is indispensable in our understanding of the world, our relationship to each other & how to make the world a better place
#diversevoices @ScienceWriters
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
Since the start of COVID-19, journalists who serve communities in the Global South have played a vital role in combating misinformation and myth, write @theplainjain and @Jennifer_Fact. www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/20/how-non-western-journa…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
An understanding of the world only from the Western perspective is not only limited but extremely dangerous
#diversevoices are indispensable in our understanding of the world, our relationship to each other & how to make the world a better place
By @theplainjain @Jennifer_Fact
National Association of Science Writers (NASW)
@ScienceWriters
Newsroom Mentors and Journalism Instructors: Teaching trainees how to expand, improve, and grow their reporting practices to include historically overlooked perspectives? Use our Diverse Voices collection—a @ScienceWriters @Open_Notebook collaboration: www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/20/how-non-western-journa…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
National Association of Science Writers (NASW)
@ScienceWriters
Newsroom Mentors and Journalism Instructors: Teaching trainees how to expand, improve, and grow their reporting practices to include historically overlooked perspectives? Use our Diverse Voices collection—a @ScienceWriters @Open_Notebook collaboration: www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/20/how-non-western-journa…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
Since the start of COVID-19, journalists who serve communities in the Global South have played a vital role in combating misinformation and myth, write @theplainjain and @Jennifer_Fact. www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/20/how-non-western-journa…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
“An understanding of the world only from the Western perspective is not only limited but extremely dangerous,” says @janeqiuchina in this article about how journalists from the Global South enriched coverage of COVID-19. www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/20/how-non-western-journa…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
An understanding of the world only from the Western perspective is not only limited but extremely dangerous
#diversevoices are indispensable in our understanding of the world, our relationship to each other & how to make the world a better place
By @theplainjain @Jennifer_Fact
National Association of Science Writers (NASW)
@ScienceWriters
Newsroom Mentors and Journalism Instructors: Teaching trainees how to expand, improve, and grow their reporting practices to include historically overlooked perspectives? Use our Diverse Voices collection—a @ScienceWriters @Open_Notebook collaboration: www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/20/how-non-western-journa…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
An understanding of the world only from the Western perspective is not only limited but extremely dangerous
Local journalism is indispensable in our understanding of the world, our relationship to each other & how to make the world a better place
#diversevoices @ScienceWriters
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
Since the start of COVID-19, journalists who serve communities in the Global South have played a vital role in combating misinformation and myth, write @theplainjain and @Jennifer_Fact. www.theopennotebook.com/2023/06/20/how-non-western-journa…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Thinking Is Power
@ThinkingPowers
7. However, science is not democratic: Achieving consensus in science is time-consuming and requires significant evidence and argumentation. The best explanation is the one that works the best, and has survived repeated attempts at disproof, not the one that’s most popular.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Thinking Is Power
@ThinkingPowers
6. Diverse communities are better able to find the “truth”: Communities with diverse perspectives, backgrounds, worldviews, etc. are better able to point out each other’s biases and blindspots, and are thus more likely to get closer to understanding reality.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Thinking Is Power
@ThinkingPowers
🧵Addressing common misconceptions about science
1. There is no single “scientific method”: The recipe-like “scientific method” presented in countless textbooks is at best an oversimplification and at worst…wrong. There are endless ways to collect and evaluate evidence. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“I think part of science, and part of critical thinking in general, is supposed to be a high level of comfort with uncertainty and unknowns. … This is a situation where there’s such intense interest that it becomes important to say, We don’t really know the answers.”
Marc Lipsitch
@mlipsitch
We’d be in a much better place if more scientists were as levelheaded as @jbloom_lab and all journalists as clear-thinking and -writing as @dwallacewells
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
I am all for smarter regulations on bio research. But the obsession seems to ignore the downpour of infectious agents hammering people every single day.
And filling my inbox. @ProMED_mail could be rebranded as, nature messes us up. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Alice C Hughes
@AliceCHughes
So often I hear arguments that "there are too many people" & that is driving biodiversity loss.What this fails to encapsulate is the disproportionate role of High-income economies and their per-capita consumption as THE major drivers,whilst exacerbating inequality+marginalisation
spencer 🦈
@Unpop_Science
When someone says, “boycott seafood,” and you respond with, “X million people rely on the ocean for protein,”
You are invoking the people that are being starved to suit your consumption interests as an excuse to perpetuate their exploitation. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“Science is not an unblemished search for the truth but rather a scrum of salesmanship full of competition, greed and harassment in which men have the upper hand.”
Excellent book review by @alexwitze @Nature of The Exceptions by @kzernike.
1/
go.nature.com/3KMFMHTPost not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“Even though the main events transpired decades ago, they remain remarkably relevant today given the sexism, racism and other injustices that still permeate academia.”
3/
Dr. Alice C Hughes
@AliceCHughes
Many women still face this, women frequently have to fight for the same resources as those automatically given to men, and whilst being expected to acheive as much, can still face other issues if they manage to
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Gender discrimination is only one form of bias in science.
Race, perspective, language skill, politics and other factors combine to amplify discrimination, so certain groups of people and certain theories are underrepresented, or even prejudiced against.
Buyers be aware.
4/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
eileen chengyin chow
@chowleen
Qing Ming Festival falls on April 5 this year.
Once again I find myself far from home and unable to sweep my loved ones’ tombs; so instead, sharing a small and most familiar poem.
#清明 #遙祭 #everynightapoem -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Sarah Kaplan
@sarahkaplan48
"Many people think, Oh, it’s a shame that journalism is no longer profitable, but we’re just gonna have to let it wither away. But this really should be seen as a political choice, not just an act of nature"
www.cjr.org/the_media_today/victor_pickard_qa.php -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Alice C Hughes
@AliceCHughes
Many women still face this, women frequently have to fight for the same resources as those automatically given to men, and whilst being expected to acheive as much, can still face other issues if they manage to
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Marion Koopmans, publications: https://pure.eur.nl
@MarionKoopmans
Further steps to reduce sales of wild animals for food in China. Fur farming allowed. Before the twitter sphere jumps on this: there is no fur market without people buying fur coats. considerwww.science.org/content/article/china-cracking-down-its-w…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
.@Laurie_Garrett alerted me that somebody has hacked her Twitter account, freezing her out completely
It seems they are using it to steal money from people in what looks like a scam computer sales op
Please spread this and demand that Twitter stop the hacker
#twitter @Twitter -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
dr Katarzyna Nowak
@katzyna
Splendid piece by @DavidQuammen, "We owe it to raccoon dogs...even if they did carry the coronavirus into the market, they weren’t there by choice...the vast commerce in wild animals that carried those miserable raccoon dogs to Wuhan goes far beyond China" www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/03/28/raccoon-dogs-c…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
eileen chengyin chow
@chowleen
秋瑾:秋風秋雨愁煞人
Qiu Jin - Autumn winds autumn rains rend one's soul
晏殊: 滿眼春愁説向誰
Yan Shu - To whom could I speak of all the heartbreak before my eyes this spring
(me: 春愁 更何堪
Spring grief is that much harder to bear) -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Journalist's Resource
@JournoResource
“’Breakthrough’ is the one that leaps out to me because there so rarely is a breakthrough,” says @deborahblum of @KSJatMIT.
“I and most of my science journalism friends want to go screaming down the street when we see that in a headline.”
journalistsresource.org/health/writing-headlines-health-r… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Matjaž Barborič
@BarboricLab
Great piece! It's a travesty, countering the collaborative spirit of science. The responsible folks at the NIH need to be held accountable over this. This is another excellent article on the topic published in @NewYorker of last year: www.newyorker.com/magazine/2022/03/21/have-chinese-spies-…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Hank Greely
@HankGreelyLSJU
/2 Here's the link, wh/I should have included initially. www.science.org/content/article/pall-suspicion-nihs-secre… HT/@pknoepfler
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Hank Greely
@HankGreelyLSJU
Chilling piece in @ScienceMagazine on the NIH's shameful role in "the China Initiative." Lots of ruined careers, looks like many weak or just wrong accusations, and apparently no due process. Many universities also should be ashamed. Great work, @jeffmervis.
Why did NIH do it? -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Prof Francois Balloux
@BallouxFrancois
We've updated our preprint on UK bat coronaviruses. A lot of additional work went into it and there are new results, some pretty unexpected and surprising.
1/
www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.01.17.524183v4.full.pdf -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD DSc(hon)
@PeterHotez
Exasperated with mainstream coverage of Covid origins. It’s clear our flagship newspapers learned nothing from the false equivalencies around phony vaccine-autism links 20 years and the damage that caused. Despite zero evidence they’re doing the same with GOF or lab leak nonsense
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Gigi Gronvall
@ggronvall
Still doesn’t matter— the majority of people could believe COVID came from aliens and it wouldn’t change the fact that there is little scientific support for that view. The important thing is to understand what actually happened—it is a scientific issue not a popularity contest.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
There is nothing comforting to see this speculation due to lack of understanding of science is still being used as poss evidence for lab leak
It’s one of the many reasons why story👇is widely discredited
It does get lower. The latest @propublica @VanityFair story is much worse -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed.Mice expressing hACE2 are a common tool for studying function of coronaviruses—even before covid
This is a good example of how journalists and intelligence analysts can come to a wrong conclusion when they don’t understand the relevant science
This has been a big problem -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Ashley Smart
@ashleythesmart
For the past 6+ months, we here at @KSJatMIT and @undarkmag have been working on a project that explores science's long, often-troubled relationship with race. Today, "Long Division: The Persistence of Race Science" finally sees the light of day. race.undark.org
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Thank you to everyone who attended this morning's awards ceremony at the #aaasmtg. Attendees can continue the celebration at a wine-and-cheese reception 2:30pm in the Expo Hall lounge.
Missed the event this afternoon? Watch a recording of the ceremony: youtu.be/ie-kGpwJKC4. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
“As a journalist and as a queer person, I've always been drawn to stories about underreported communities,” says Small Outlet Gold Award winner @Ankur_pali. For his winning story, he wanted to show “what it really means to live with and research a rare disease in India.”
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
eileen chengyin chow
@chowleen
A visual guide to spring flowers in East Asia. Clockwise from top right, in Japanese, Korean, Chinese Mandarin readings
梅 plum (ume/maehwa/mei)
杏 apricot (anzu/salgu/xing)
李 plum (sumomo/jadu/li)
桃 peach (momo/boksung-a/tao)
櫻 cherry (sakura/beotkkeot/ying)
🎨@mojacookie -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Joel Achenbach
@JoelAchenbach
SARS-CoV-2 origin: "this is such an explosive issue that incremental developments can generate big headlines." Proceed with caution www.washingtonpost.com/science/2023/02/28/covid-origin-ev…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed.
They are effectively saying:”Trust us. We are politicians.”
Numerous journalists have falled for it—over and over again.
In April 2020, Trump was the first person to say he had seen the evidence for lab leak.
Not a single thread has come out for nearly 3 years!
Stephen Goldstein
@stgoldst
Always a good idea to trust anonymous government intel sources (notice the first byline) www.nytimes.com/2002/09/08/world/threats-responses-iraqis…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Why care about factual accuracy when spin sells?
@CNN probably didn’t realise there were more than one lab in Wuhan
Does it care?
Please prove to me you do, @kaitlancollins, by apologizing and issuing a correction.
Accountability matters. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Sarah Scott Scire
@SarahScire
"It’s really difficult not to anthropomorphize—I struggle with this too—because it’s a very evocative way to explain it to audiences. But I do think we should strive to describe [AI] as a tool, rather than as a 'brain' or a companion of some kind." www.niemanlab.org/2023/02/meet-the-first-ever-artificial-…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
This comes as House Republicans gear up for US-China relations hearing. Members focused on Covid include those promoting disinformation like vaccines cause death, that masks harm children, etc.
So, yes, investigate a lab leak but consider context and actual, DISCLOSED evidence. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
Kind of weird to headline a conclusion as likely with the definition above, which is why I suppose WSJ didn't include that definition. @hiltzikm column here: www.latimes.com/business/story/2023-02-27/contrary-wsj-cl…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
Lab leak likely with "low confidence"? @hiltzikm dug up the IC official definition of "low confidence"
"Info’s credibility or plausibility is uncertain; Info is too fragmented or poorly corroborated to make solid analytical inferences; or reliability of sources is questionable" -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
DOE’s claim that lab leak most likely caused pandemic is partly based on new info about research of coronavirus conducted at Wuhan CDC before pandemic
What exactly was going at Wuhan CDC?
@ZCohenCNN @jeremyherb @NatashaBertrand @PamelaBrownCNN:
1/
www.cnn.com/2023/02/27/politics/intel-community-covid-ori…Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
How did @FilippaLentzos, biosecurity expert & proponent of lab leak, respond to DOE’s “low confidence” claim?
Low confidence level indicates solid analytical conclusions cannot be inferred from information or there are significant concerns w sources
10/
www.theguardian.com/world/2023/feb/27/how-seriously-shoul…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Clarification: this thread is in response to @CNN story👇saying that DOE’s assessment was partly based on new info on coronavirus research conducted at Wuhan CDC before pandemic
It’s important to get the record straight
It’s a matter of journalistic accountability
11/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Kai Kupferschmidt
@kakape
This is a great, balanced thread (as so often from @GidMK).
There are some serious issues with that cochrane review of masks and even more with how it has been presented. But this viral takedown thread of that study is full of mistakes and misunderstandings itself
Health Nerd
@GidMK
People are sharing this thread around a lot, and I have to say that it's extremely unfair and mostly incorrect when it comes to the specifics of the Cochrane review
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
josh fischman (now on Blue Sky)
@jfischman
WSJ hype: Energy Dept backs lab-leak hypothesis. Then admits in story "backs" means "low confidence." Low confidence means analysts question the credibility of the information. So much for WSJ. h/t @janeqiuchina
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed.
And “low confidence means that intelligent analysts question the credibility or plausibility of the information, or that they’re concerned about the sources”
Does such confidence justify DOE’s conclusion and the screaming “most likely” headlines? -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed.
And “low confidence means that intelligent analysts question the credibility or plausibility of the information, or that they’re concerned about the sources”
Does such confidence justify DOE’s conclusion and the screaming “most likely” headlines? -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thank you, Lauri! Yes, just very slightly…
Lauri Myllyvirta
@laurimyllyvirta
You two just made Twitter a slightly better place.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“Forgive” is too big a word in my book, Fansini!
Everybody makes mistakes. I’m ready to move on since you’ve apologized.
Twitter is probably not the best place to resolve disagreement, and people are often too quick to react to disagreement in an ill-judged way.
Fansini
@TheTropaion
Yes, that's the big downside of a platform like Twitter. Our better angels tend to get shoved aside. You're very kind to forgive me for my hurtful, poorly-reasoned comments.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I’d like to stress I block people only for one reason: the behaviour of the person in question has fallen below standards of acceptability
I don’t think insults have a place in public discourse
If anybody I’ve blocked is willing to apologise, I’d be happy to consider unblock.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks, Fansini! Apologies accepted
It’s not uncommon for people to blast insults when they don’t fully understand my work
I admire @flodebarre for her commitment to factual accuracy, which sets herself apart from many others who are too eager to cast evidence-light speculation
Fansini
@TheTropaion
Thank you, Jane. This is my apology. No caveat or excuses. What I said was wrong and - I don't doubt - hurtful. I recklessly said you were insinuating (indirectly) that COVID may have been in the U.S. prior to the Wuhan outbreak. I based that on your reference to the...
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I’d like to stress I block people only for one reason: the behaviour of the person in question has fallen below standards of acceptability
I don’t think insults have a place in public discourse
If anybody I’ve blocked is willing to apologise, I’d be happy to consider unblock.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks, Fansini! Apologies accepted
It’s not uncommon for people to blast insults when they don’t fully understand my work
I admire @flodebarre for her commitment to factual accuracy, which sets herself apart from many others who are too eager to cast evidence-light speculation -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks, Fansini! Apologies accepted
It’s not uncommon for people to blast insults when they don’t fully understand my work
I admire @flodebarre for her commitment to factual accuracy, which sets herself apart from many others who are too eager to cast evidence-light speculation
Fansini
@TheTropaion
Thank you, Jane. This is my apology. No caveat or excuses. What I said was wrong and - I don't doubt - hurtful. I recklessly said you were insinuating (indirectly) that COVID may have been in the U.S. prior to the Wuhan outbreak. I based that on your reference to the...
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I’m all ears if you want to apologize
I don’t mind good-faith challenge,but I won’t tolerate insult, and hence the block
My @techreview & @NatGeo stories have been untouched since publication
When *on earth* did I say covid may have originated in the US?
See relevant grafs👇
Fansini
@TheTropaion
Still, though, I have to admit that's shaky ground on which to cast aspersions on Jane Qiu's motives. I owe her an apology. She blocked me so, if you don't mind, Flo, could you let her know?
Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks, Fansini! Apologies accepted
It’s not uncommon for people to blast insults when they don’t fully understand my work
I admire @flodebarre for her commitment to factual accuracy, which sets herself apart from many others who are too eager to cast evidence-light speculation -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Two interviews? Please get your facts right, Michael!
I logged > 40 hours of reporting during a cumulative 6-week stay in Wuhan that spanned 14 months. I talked to different people in the team. I checked their versions of the story against each other.
1/
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
Just because there were no “minders” around during the two interviews/flattering profiles a reporter did with Shi does not necessarily mean the “Bat Woman” was free to tell everything she knew or the truth. #journalism 101. @sciam @laurahelmuth @marynmck @techreview
Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
My interaction with Shi and her team members was no different from my interaction with any other research groups in China and other parts of the world in nearly two decades of my journalism career.
3/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I also talked to over 40 experts from diverse perspectives and expertise globally
I took into account of not only what they said but their agenda and the role of power, money and where they sat in the institutional hierarchy
I’m never someone who quote sources uncritically.
4/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The story has received praises from top journalists (some below are Pulitzer-winning)👇
Are these journalists serious enough for you, Michael?
You are a journalist with questionable judgment & conduct. You got kicked out by @ScienceWriters for your unacceptable behaviour.
10/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Here’s a free journalism lesson for you, Michael!👇
Transcending subjective biases is the only way to prevent journalism from descending into a sorrowful state in which it does little more than reinforce stereotypes, confirm preconceived ideas, & rehash existing narratives
11/
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
While objectivity “has long been regarded as one of the sacred tenets of journalism,” writes 2016 AAAS Kavli Award-winner @janeqiuchina, “our relationship with it is a tortured one.” Read her story on journalistic objectivity and the origins of COVID-19: sjawards.aaas.org/news/journalistic-objectivity-and-origi….
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Laurie Garrett
@Laurie_Garrett
It amazes me that Chinese-speaking PhD @janeqiuchina keeps having to defend her on-the-ground reporting from #wuhan regarding the origins of #sarscov2 from critics that can't speak Chinese, many have never been to China, and cast suspicion on her precisely because she has.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Two interviews? Please get your facts right, Michael!
I logged > 40 hours of reporting during a cumulative 6-week stay in Wuhan that spanned 14 months. I talked to different people in the team. I checked their versions of the story against each other.
1/
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
Just because there were no “minders” around during the two interviews/flattering profiles a reporter did with Shi does not necessarily mean the “Bat Woman” was free to tell everything she knew or the truth. #journalism 101. @sciam @laurahelmuth @marynmck @techreview
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s false.
You have absolutely no expertise in Chinese language or translation (or China for that matter).
Please stop cherry-picking or twisting things to suit your narrative.
You are doing the world a disservice.
Stop it!
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
The spelling I used is a very common Western transliteration btw
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Seriously? How credulous and out of touch you seem to be, Michale!
We have enough people with no first-hand info second-guessing what might or might not be happening to Shi
I wouldn’t trust the interpretation of Shi’s circumstance by someone who can’t even spell her name right
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
This Slack exchange, obtained by @USRightToKnow, suggests any reporter who claims to have had “unfettered access” to Shi Zhengli of Wuhan Inst Virology could be fooling themselves. Shi was/is clearly under duress from the Chinese govt. @janeqiuchina usrtk.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/Baric_Slack_EDDec202…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Erik Karlsson
@E_A_Karlsson
Enhanced surveillance in both domestic and wild birds is critical across South America. Aside from domestic poultry, A/H5 2.3.4.4b in South America will also likely affect entire populations of already vulnerable wild bird species. #avianinfluenza #chile www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2023.02.01.526205v1
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
ABSW
@absw
The struggle for objectivity in science journalism. @janeqiuchina shared her experience with Angela Saini at our latest event. With thanks to @SorrellDominic for covering the story for our website www.absw.org.uk/articles/the-struggle-for-objectivity-jan…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dominic Sorrell
@SorrellDominic
Some really interesting insights from @janeqiuchina and Angela Saini with @absw last week. Objectivity, particularly in science journalism, is considered the gold standard, but is it truly possible? Read more here:
www.absw.org.uk/articles/the-struggle-for-objectivity-jan… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Sarah Kaplan
@sarahkaplan48
It's telling that this effort was coordinated not by Fred Ryan or anyone in Post management, but by laid-off employees whose commitment to the work didn't end with their jobs.
We, the workers, are the heart and soul of The Washington Post. This newspaper is nothing without us.
Sarah Kaplan
@sarahkaplan48
Last month the Washington Post ended publication of its award-winning magazine and laid off its brilliant, irreplaceable staff.
Today, on their last day at their jobs, magazine employees & @PostGuild members are bringing the magazine archives to @librarycongress for posterity. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Kashif Pirzada, MD
@KashPrime
He was dying as he wrote this thread, as his lungs steadily shut down. This is happening to thousands of people a week in America but we are becoming ghoulishly indifferent to the suffering happening here. RIP @gregfoley2002
Greg Foley
@gregfoley2002
Short thread on Covid and respiratory support.
There are numerous grifters, and serious academics, out there who seem to think if the fatality stats are not that bad, then Covid is no big deal. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
How can you find your “go-to-people”? Always good for comment or fact-checking, who might also share new stories and tips? @KatherineJWu talked to @A_AbdoolKarim, @janeqiuchina, @bylenasun, @dvergano, @umairfan and @katie_thomas for this guide. www.theopennotebook.com/2023/01/10/building-a-roster-of-g…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Ankur Paliwal
@Ankur_pali
For months I collected data about the representation of Dalit, Adivasi and OBC students and researchers at various levels of academia in some of the elite universities in India.
The results were stark. That story for @Nature in 6 charts.
🧵1/n
www.nature.com/immersive/d41586-023-00015-2/index.html -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Pulitzer Center
@pulitzercenter
#pulitzerstaffpicks Copy Editor Assistant Alex Waddell chose the Pulitzer-supported story, "Meet the Scientist at the Center of the Covid Lab Leak Controversy" by grantee @janeqiuchina for @techreview.
See the full list 👉 pulitzercenter.org/stories/2022-year-stories -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
From @KatherineJWu, with @janeqiuchina, @bylenasun, @umairfan and others, here’s how to “build relationships with sources purposefully and compassionately” while “maintaining the boundaries that keep reporting objective.” www.theopennotebook.com/2023/01/10/building-a-roster-of-g…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Ashish K. Jha, MD, MPH Archived
@AshishKJha46
Good morning
Over the holidays, you may have heard about Omicron XBB.1.5
It went from 4% of sequences to 40% in just a few weeks
That’s a stunning increase
So what does it mean? Will it cause a wave of serious illness and death?
Here's what we know, don't know
🧵 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Caitlin Rivers
@cmyeaton
New from me and @dr_kkjetelina: High or very high levels of flu activity across the nation. Any hope that flu season was slowing down evaporated with this week’s update. In other words, this flu season is shaping up to be a big one.
caitlinrivers.substack.com/p/high-or-very-high-levels-of-… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
Public health hasn't failed us. Libertarianism, a "you-do-you" ethos, has allowed US life expectancy to plummet, writes @gregggonsalves.
I long this definition of "real liberty" from a Supreme Court justice in 1905...
www.thenation.com/article/society/public-health-covid-pan… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Esther Wei-Yun Landhuis
@elandhuis
As a scientist turned journalist, I've always struggled with the rampant cherry-picking in journalism...picking which topics to cover, whose voices to center, which examples to use. I love how @janeqiuchina reframes "journalistic objectivity" as a method of understanding. ICYMI👇
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Hear 2016 AAAS Kavli Award-winner @janeqiuchina speak at tomorrow’s #sciwri22 opening plenary, and read her reflections on journalistic objectivity here: sjawards.aaas.org/news/journalistic-objectivity-and-origi….
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Alex O'Brien
@obrientweet
@absw hosts many FREE member-only events to help journalists become better at their jobs. Join us for the next one: "Who is objective? Science reporting on the political frontlines" @janeqiuchina will be in discussion with Angela Saini. Tickets here > www.absw.org.uk/events/who-is-objective-science-reporting…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
There are many things wrong about this piece from @jeffykao @propublica & @KatherineEban @vanityfair. @janeqiuchina did a nice job compiling them in this thread.
Again, interesting omission to not mention this was funded by a multimillion dollar grant from SBF’s foundation.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
FQxI Physics
@FQXi
Congratulations @janeqiuchina!This is a long read, but well worth the time investment. Hugely deserved award.
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
In a deeply reported @techreview story on the controversy over the origins of the SARS-CoV-2 virus, Beijing-based Science Reporting – In-Depth Silver Award winner @janeqiuchina gained unparalleled access to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. sjawards.aaas.org/news/2022-aaas-kavli-science-journalism… #aaaskavli2022
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“If science is progress then there is not going to be progress if the fruits of science are not widely distributed to people”.
@amymaxmen’s fabulous talk on inequality and emerging infectious diseases.
Nowhere is safe until everywhere is safe.
YouTube: m.youtube.com/watch?v=0ZI643rEPVs
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Public health effects related to inequality are “huge problems and they’re not simple to solve,” said @CFR_org Murrow Press Fellow @amymaxmen in her AAAS Kavli Fall Lecture series talk at @UCBerkeley. Read about the lecture here: sjawards.aaas.org/news/aaas-kavli-lecture-amy-maxmen-ineq….
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jessica McDonald
@jjmcdona
Congrats to @janeqiuchina on the well-deserved win!
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
In a deeply reported @techreview story on the controversy over the origins of the SARS-CoV-2 virus, Beijing-based Science Reporting – In-Depth Silver Award winner @janeqiuchina gained unparalleled access to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. sjawards.aaas.org/news/2022-aaas-kavli-science-journalism… #aaaskavli2022
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
In a deeply reported @techreview story on the controversy over the origins of the SARS-CoV-2 virus, Beijing-based Science Reporting – In-Depth Silver Award winner @janeqiuchina gained unparalleled access to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. sjawards.aaas.org/news/2022-aaas-kavli-science-journalism… #aaaskavli2022
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Public health effects related to inequality are “huge problems and they’re not simple to solve,” said @CFR_org Murrow Press Fellow @amymaxmen in her AAAS Kavli Fall Lecture series talk at @UCBerkeley. Read about the lecture here: sjawards.aaas.org/news/aaas-kavli-lecture-amy-maxmen-ineq….
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Helen Branswell 🇨🇦
@HelenBranswell
Terrific story on "state fair flu" — how #flu viruses that circulate in pigs evolve and move about, and the risks they pose to people, by @sciencecohen.
www.science.org/content/article/thwart-next-pandemic-swie… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Thomas Levenson, Zṓiarchos
@TomLevenson
Seconded. @janeqiuchina has been doing great work on the lab leak conspiracy nonsense. And taking often vicious grief for doing so. The piece linked below is excellent.
(And yeah–that Vanity Fair/Pro Publica debacle is well past the 3-day-old-fish stage & not getting better.)
MIT School of Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences
@MIT_SHASS
Warmest congratulations to Jane Qui / @janeqiuchina, former fellow of our @KSJatMIT program, on receiving the Silver Kavli Award for In-Depth Science Reporting! Her winning story appears in @techreview www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
MIT School of Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences
@MIT_SHASS
Warmest congratulations to Jane Qui / @janeqiuchina, former fellow of our @KSJatMIT program, on receiving the Silver Kavli Award for In-Depth Science Reporting! Her winning story appears in @techreview www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
@janeqiuchina worked on this story for almost 2 years. This recognition of her tremendous efforts is richly deserved. Congratulations, Jane!
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Roland Pease
@PeaseRoland
Massive congratulations to @janeqiuchina on this award for her superb and diligent reporting.
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Congratulations to “Science Reporting – In-Depth” Silver Award winner @janeqiuchina. sjawards.aaas.org/news/2022-aaas-kavli-science-journalism… #aaaskavli2022
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Greg Tucker-Kellogg (gtuckerkellogg.bsky.social)
@gtuckerkellogg
Congratulations @janeqiuchina, on this well-deserved award. Your work has been invaluable.
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Congratulations to “Science Reporting – In-Depth” Silver Award winner @janeqiuchina. sjawards.aaas.org/news/2022-aaas-kavli-science-journalism… #aaaskavli2022
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Michael Worobey
@MichaelWorobey
Wonderful, @janeqiuchina -- congratulations!
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Rose Rimler
@rosenrimler
Congrats @KendraWrites! Congrats @janeqiuchina, it was lovely meeting you in Memphis (briefly, on the bus!) and big congrats to all the other winners this year. Well done 🏆
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Congratulations to the 2022 winners of the international AAAS Kavli Science Journalism Awards! Read about this year's winners here: sjawards.aaas.org/news/2022-aaas-kavli-science-journalism… #aaaskavli2022
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Martin Enserink
@martinenserink
Big congrats to the winners of the @AAASKavli Science Journalism Awards, including @Ankur_pali for a piece on a rare genetic disease in India and @janeqiuchina for her story on "bat woman" Shi Zhengli (+ many others.) sjawards.aaas.org/news/2022-aaas-kavli-science-journalism…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Benjamin Mateus, MD
@BenjaminMateus7
Congratulations to Dr. Al-Aly and colleagues on this major report highlighting the dangers of COVID reinfection!
@zalaly @janeqiuchina @MeetJess
@DrEricDing @EricTopol @NatureMedicine @EnemyInAState
@sri_srikrishna
www.wsws.org/en/articles/2022/11/10/covi-n10.html -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Richard Van Noorden
@Richvn
Great journalism in this year's winners of the @AAASKavli , including @KendraWrites, @Ankur_pali, @janeqiuchina, @LoisParshley, and many more sjawards.aaas.org/news/2022-aaas-kavli-science-journalism…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Niall Firth
@niallfirth
Not one but TWO winners in this year's AAAS Kavli awards! Congrats to @KendraWrites and @janeqiuchina and their excellent @techreview editors. sjawards.aaas.org/news/2022-aaas-kavli-science-journalism…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Congratulations to “Science Reporting – In-Depth” Silver Award winner @janeqiuchina. sjawards.aaas.org/news/2022-aaas-kavli-science-journalism… #aaaskavli2022
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Nieman Storyboard
@niemanstory
In a piece on cat tooth-brushing, @TheAtlantic science reporter @KatherineJWu has made a mini-beat out of wondering about the unanswered questions to everyday life
niemanstoryboard.org/stories/how-curiosity-about-cats-ins… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
As a long-term member of @absw—which was absolutely instrumental in helping launch my career and is a continuing source of inspiration—I’m super proud that my article for @AAASKavli on journalistic objectivity has been selected as its monthly showcase.
www.absw.org.uk/articles/absw-monthly-showcase -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed. Even Nobel Prize winners can be wrong, too! Remember the “smoking gun” statement?
Yes, sources’ track record is important
What’s more important, in my view, is to examine whether any claim is backed up by evidence and the priors & assumptions, which are often neglected -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
CASW
@ScienceWriting
Or on YouTube youtu.be/ZjdgrTNw8xI
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
CASW
@ScienceWriting
#sciwri22 virtual attendees: You can now watch video of the Memphis #covidorigins plenary in the meeting app. Urgent debate over journalists' role in an internationally politicized, science-based, high-stakes controversy. Apologies for audio glitches (captions help)
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Anne Huang
@drannehuang
Thoroughly enjoyed listening to this @ScienceWriting #sciwri22 panel on media coverage of SARS-CoV-2 origin. youtu.be/ZjdgrTNw8xI
Moderated by @deborahblum, featuring Ben Hurlbut***(really insightful), @sciencecohen, @KatherineEban, and @janeqiuchina.
CASW
@ScienceWriting
#sciwri22 virtual attendees: You can now watch video of the Memphis #covidorigins plenary in the meeting app. Urgent debate over journalists' role in an internationally politicized, science-based, high-stakes controversy. Apologies for audio glitches (captions help)
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Greg Tucker-Kellogg (gtuckerkellogg.bsky.social)
@gtuckerkellogg
Oh, the Great Firewall is really a thing, but so are VPNs, and plenty of Chinese tweet without Xi's approval.
That said, if you read Chinese, you should easily see that @janeqiuchina is correct that the @propublica/@VanityFair translations are wrong, and wrong in one direction -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
My goodness!
Do you know how many Chinese people in China use VPN for all sorts of purposes?
If you think the use of VPN requires government sanction, then your insight into China is close to zero.
And so you really have no basis to judge whether I can be trusted.
Period.
x 45k
@dr_handler
Disqualified.
If a tweet must be sent through a VPN with Xi's approval, it does not deserve serious attention. Period.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
At the @ScienceWriting panel, I also warned against the danger of joining dots we are not supposed to be joining
In the latest @VanityFair @propublica story👇, they not only took existing dots out of context but also invented dots that do not exist through bad translation -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
At the @ScienceWriting panel, I also warned against the danger of joining dots we are not supposed to be joining
In the latest @VanityFair @propublica story👇, they not only took existing dots out of context but also invented dots that do not exist through bad translation -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Absolute! Can’t agree more
This is also how science should be done
I was a scientist before & so I appreciate the importance of critically examining original data/materials and priors/assumptions of methodologies & associated caveats
This should be how we approach everything
Dr. Anne Huang
@drannehuang
Agree with the importance of critical thinking — critically assess the original data & materials that form the evidence base for the conclusion.
Not only is it relevant for good journalism, it should be foundational to modern medicine and public health policy as well. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The lack of critical thinking is single most important reason underlying shoddy journalism
We should always critically assess what we are told by examining the original data & materials and if claim is backed up by evidence—regardless who the source is or his claimed expertise
Dr. Anne Huang
@drannehuang
Given researcher Toy Reid’s professional experience as a fluent China specialist and a political officer for 🇺🇸 State Dept, I would defer to his translation and interpretation of CCP Politburo speech personally.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
As a long-term member of @absw—which was absolutely instrumental in helping launch my career and is a continuing source of inspiration—I’m super proud that my article for @AAASKavli on journalistic objectivity has been selected as its monthly showcase.
www.absw.org.uk/articles/absw-monthly-showcase -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Alex Heard
@alexheard
National Park visitors are licking toads to get high again! www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-adventure/environment/natio…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Kelly 🧶 Tyrrell
@kellyperil
There is a lot to unpack here, and if you care about journalism, you should spend the time. @janeqiuchina does the difficult and vulnerable work of diving into issues of parachute journalism, journalistic objectivity and the critical role journalism plays in democracy.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Saugat Bo 🐸
@saugat_optimist
In case you missed a highly insightful plenary discussion at Science Writers22 about the COVID-19 origin story, here is a brief highlight of the session ft. @janeqiuchina, @sciencecohen, J. Benjamin Hurlbut, @KatherineEban moderated by @deborahblum.
casw.org/news/we-are-not-yet-done-with-covid-19s-origin-j… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
@threadreaderapp unroll
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You might want to read this media-criticism article for @AAASKavli about keeping biases in check and upholding journalistic objectivity.
Perhaps you might learn something.
Please do better next time. Please do much better. Thanks!
27/
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Hear 2016 AAAS Kavli Award-winner @janeqiuchina speak at tomorrow’s #sciwri22 opening plenary, and read her reflections on journalistic objectivity here: sjawards.aaas.org/news/journalistic-objectivity-and-origi….
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
PS. Could you please provide the link to the 2018 Zhangjiajie report?
The link associated with “2011”, which is linked to a 2019 dispatch right now, is obviously not the correct one. Please provide the correct one.
Many thanks!
26/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
So,stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence,honest errors or bad faith?
You tell me. You answer will determine whether @propublica—or journalism in general—deserve to be trusted
@VanityFair,it’s said,is a lost cause—about which I’m agnostic
25/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
They say journalism is what makes democracy work
We should all ask ourselves: Have we helped to make democracy work?
Or have we helped perpetuate stereotypes and existing narratives, exacerbate mistrust and polarization, and make the world a more dangerous place?
24/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
In China, the press is a tool of propaganda for advancing political gains.
I had thought media organizations in the US, especially the likes of @propublica, were categorically different.
Please, prove to me that I was right.
23/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I’d think the documents you cite in the story are the ones that help make the strongest case
I’m open to the possibility that you might have other documents that can help make similar arguments.
If so, then please bring them along, and let them subject to public scrutiny.
22/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
In response to @hiltzikm, you blamed problems on vagueness of Chinese language
Many scientists, journalists (incl fierce critics of China), native Chinese speakers,supporters of natural origins or lab leak think it’s a matter of honesty, integrity & due diligence—or lack of
21/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
If documents are not interpreted in correct context—scientific, political & cultural—then they could be subject to abuse and we risk joining dots we’re not supposed to be joining.
I should add if you get translation wrong, then you might be inventing dots that do not exist.
20/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
In the opening plenary of @ScienceWriting #sciwri22 on 22 Oct👇–organized by @sciencecohen and myself and moderated by @deborahblum—I warned against the limitation and danger of documents-based approaches.
casw.org/news/media-coverage-of-sars-cov-2s-origin/
19/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Please similar critiques👇by @dakekang & @BeijingPalmer about glaring errors & glaring omissions that put in question the narrative—and the motivation/integrity of the sources/writers/outlets
Both are fierce critics of China
Please also see article by @hiltzikm @latimes👇
18/
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
LA Times on the ProPublica/Vanity Fair expose: “The article is based heavily on Chinese-language documents that appear to have been mistranslated…
It also takes as gospel a report by a rump group of Republican congressional staff”
By @hiltzikm
www.latimes.com/business/story/2022-11-01/column-propubli… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
(2) Senate report regards procurements of equipments as signs that WIV struggled to maintain key biosafety capabilities.
(3) Patent applications of inventions to counter corrosion of equipments are also seem as signs that the biosafety labs are not up for scratch.
17/
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
Here, WIV procured a vaporized hydrogen peroxide system to disinfect air coming from the lab. They even explain why they procured it: it’s less corrosive than an alternative. It’s an example of proactively upgrading critical equipment, not evidence of biosafety failure.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
7️⃣ You consider the following as evidence for biosafety breaches at WIV, but you are wrong.
(1) During a safety training in Nov 2019, WIV officials outlined several safety issues identified in the past year that he hoped would be addressed to prevent potential consequences
16/
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
There are multiple levels where biosafety protocols are implemented: all the way from individual (appropriate PPE & proper training) to the facility design & infrastructure (negative pressure, HEPA filters, waste disposal) to administrative (operational procedures, security).
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
(c)In 2019,China was drafting/deliberating its first biosecurity law & there was a national campaign to improve workplace safety (including biosafety)
There is no indication the remarks by Xi & other senior officials on safety importance were specifically geared towards WIV
15/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You have obviously missed the crucial contexts below:
(a) People in China often invoke Xi’s remarks to underscore the importance of the matter in question
(b) There had been anti-corruption campaigns for years, and so (1) and (2) above👆took place within that context
14/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
(4) Oct: a senior official argued before Congress’ standing committee for the importance of biosecurity law that was being deliberated.
I admire your imagination that joined all those dots—some real and other imagined.
But you imagined wrong.
13/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
(3) 19 Nov: safety training at WIV, attended by CAS biosafety official Ji Changzheng, who invoked Xi Jiping’s general comments on safety issues.
You interpret this as Xi issuing specific instructions for WIV to address biosafety breaches.
12/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
6️⃣ You story also speculates that “emergence response activity”, listed below, was triggered by biosafety breach at WIV:
(1) 3 Sept:WIV meeting about an upcoming internal audit to evaluate political discipline issues
(2) 11 Sept:Central Inspection Patrol Group visiting CAS
11/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Wrong translation by VF/PP👇: Every time a biosafety lapse has/had happened, Party members have/had rushed to the front lines.
There’s no equivalent of “would” or “could” in Chinese, and so grasping hypotheticals can be very challenging for non-native speakers.
9/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
(2) Referencing an “accident” that you say mentioned in the 12 Nov dispatch
This resulted from confusion of actual & hypothetical events
The sentence starting with “每当这时” = Every time a potential risky situation rises, Party members would rush to the frontlines
8/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
5️⃣ A key element of your narrative is: there was a biosafety crisis at WIV in late 2019
This is false
The misunderstanding resulted from mistranslations
Your evidence for the “crisis” includes:
(1) Uncovering of “hidden safety danger”, which results from mistranslation 👇
7/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
3️⃣ Glaring error
Your story mentions “hidden danger” 4 times,& uses them as evidence that major biosafety accidents took place at WIV before covid & had been covered up
They are mistranslated from “安全隐患” (potential, not actual, safety danger)👇
cn.linkedin.com/pulse/隐患的哪种英文表达更合理-norisk-safety-technology
4/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Other native speakers and professional translators of Chinese language raised similar issues👇
Another factual error: the 12 Nov dispatch was actually a republication of a post published on 30 Aug of the same year
This further messes up your narrative
10/
Dake Kang
@dakekang
The Wuhan Institute of Virology notice cited in the @VanityFair/@propublica is actually a repost of a piece published Aug 30 in 科苑党建, a publication by the party-building group of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (which is in charge of the WIV).
kydj.sciencenet.cn/content.aspx?id=3844 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
4️⃣ You misrepresented @WHO SAGO report by portraying the two theories as equally likely, a mistake called false equivalence
They are not
At SAGO press briefing,I asked which scenario was mostly likely
Answer:“the strongest evidence is still around a zoonotic transmission”
6/
Jon Cohen
@sciencecohen
From ‘open minded’ to ‘underwhelming,’ mixed reactions greet latest COVID-19 origin report www.science.org/content/article/open-minded-underwhelming…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
More on “安全隐患”: it’s one of the most mistranslated Chinese terms
This article👇explains the literal translation of “隐” to “hidden” is not correct because 隐患 refers to potential, rather than actual, danger.
There is no ambiguity here.
cn.linkedin.com/pulse/隐患的哪种英文表达更合理-norisk-safety-technology
5/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
3️⃣ Glaring error
Your story mentions “hidden danger” 4 times,& uses them as evidence that major biosafety accidents took place at WIV before covid & had been covered up
They are mistranslated from “安全隐患” (potential, not actual, safety danger)👇
cn.linkedin.com/pulse/隐患的哪种英文表达更合理-norisk-safety-technology
4/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
2️⃣ Glaring error
Your story says:on 24 Feb 2020 Zhou became the 1st in the world to apply for a patent for CoV2 vaccine
It’s wrong: half dozen Western companies applied earlier.H/T @flodebarre
By your logic,isn’t that even more scientifically & technologically impossible?
3/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
1️⃣ Glaring error in the tense regarding “the 3 nos” and glaring omission of “the 3 haves”
The dispatch you cited was about officials gloating about how they had started from “the 3 nos”, overcome obstacles, and achieved “the 3 haves”, which was noted in the GOP report👇
2/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi @KatherineEban @jeffykao @VanityFair @propublica:
Your article contains at least 1 glaring error & 1 glaring omission
Citing two documents published in June & Sept 2019👇,you say they lamented the BSL-4 lab as having the problem of “the 3 ‘nos’”
You got the tense wrong
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Sarah Wild
@sarahemilywild
Wow. This is a rather long list of important questions.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Henri Mourant 🌱
@henri_mourant
I recommend reading these threads the see the massive issues with those stories:
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
SidonieW
@SidonieWinfield
@propublica @VanityFair set a correction or retraction. Our nation and our journalism are only as strong as when we admit our mistakes and try to fix them. Covering up only makes you look weak.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Bob Morris, MD, PhD
@rdmorris
Misinformation vs disinformation is an interesting question. I see 3 levels.
Flawed information- you thought was correct but learn is not
Misinformation - you continue to propagate after learning it is false
Disinformation- you know it is false and intentionally propagate -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Happy889123
@HAPPY889123
Thank you so much for this🧵Dr. Qiu.
Takes time to explain to this level of details.
This is at once informative and educational. You have done Science and Public Health a service.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Laurie Garrett
@Laurie_Garrett
There's a cottage industry is tearing apart the @ProPublica + @VanityFair "expose" of the origins of #sarscov2 -- so many reports on the inaccuracies & failures in the story, it seems hard to imagine more. But @janeqiuchina is a Chinese-speaking writer, & this thread is intense.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Gigi Gronvall
@ggronvall
Why not share those documents? One of the benefits of sharing is that you can benefit from expertise. There have been numerous factual and translation errors already found in the piece (which should lead to its retraction) as described in this thread:
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Gigi Gronvall
@ggronvall
The @VanityFair/@propublica story on COVID-19 origins doesn't bother to address what is already known and published about the origin of SARS-CoV-2, and whether/how its main inference about a lab origin could possibly be correct in light of these published findings.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Zhihua Chen
@zhihuachen
Comprehensive summary of the massive issues in the @propublica /@VanityFair report on senate minority report on covid origins by @janeqiuchina 31/+
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
PaperclipAI
@xiruxi
When does this shoddy train wreck get retracted? Shameful to see ProPublica involved in this debacle.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Lindsay Beyerstein
@beyerstein
Must-read thread from @janeqiuchina, who’s a scientist, a native speaker of Mandarin, and one of the top journos on the covid origins beat:
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
A comprehensive summary of everything that went wrong with the recent @VanityFair/@propublica article on the Burr report about SARS-CoV-2 origins.
It’s unbelievable that this article hasn’t been withdrawn. Makes me wonder: at what point does misinformation become disinformation?
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Zhihua Chen
@zhihuachen
@propublica @VanityFair Stop hiding behind claims of party speak vagueness when your false translations and false interpretations are simple and fundamental and clear for everyone to see. Don’t engage in sophistry to cover up your mistakes! 😤😖
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Laura Spinney
@lfspinney
Nice ⬇️ People are part of ecology too. Zoonotic spillover has been accelerating for at least 1/2 a century. Farming - a globalised industry - is one culprit (witness devastating #birdflu outbreak), and the proliferation of biosecure labs - in part - a response. 1/2
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Thread Reader App
@threadreaderapp
Saluti, the unroll you asked for: threadreaderapp.com/thread/1589098167051911169.html Enjoy :) 🤖
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence, honest errors or bad faith?
Summary of glaring errors & omissions & lack of insight of science in story by @KatherineEban @jeffykao
@tracyweber @SteveEngelberg @propublica @radhikajones @VanityFair
1/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
1️⃣ Glaring error in the tense regarding “the 3 nos” and glaring omission of “the 3 haves”
The dispatch you cited was about officials gloating about how they had started from “the 3 nos”, overcome obstacles, and achieved “the 3 haves”, which was noted in the GOP report👇
2/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi @KatherineEban @jeffykao @VanityFair @propublica:
Your article contains at least 1 glaring error & 1 glaring omission
Citing two documents published in June & Sept 2019👇,you say they lamented the BSL-4 lab as having the problem of “the 3 ‘nos’”
You got the tense wrong
1/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
2️⃣ Glaring error
Your story says:on 24 Feb 2020 Zhou became the 1st in the world to apply for a patent for CoV2 vaccine
It’s wrong: half dozen Western companies applied earlier.H/T @flodebarre
By your logic,isn’t that even more scientifically & technologically impossible?
3/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
3️⃣ Glaring error
Your story mentions “hidden danger” 4 times,& uses them as evidence that major biosafety accidents took place at WIV before covid & had been covered up
They are mistranslated from “安全隐患” (potential, not actual, safety danger)👇
cn.linkedin.com/pulse/隐患的哪种英文表达更合理-norisk-safety-technology
4/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
More on “安全隐患”: it’s one of the most mistranslated Chinese terms
This article👇explains the literal translation of “隐” to “hidden” is not correct because 隐患 refers to potential, rather than actual, danger.
There is no ambiguity here.
cn.linkedin.com/pulse/隐患的哪种英文表达更合理-norisk-safety-technology
5/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
4️⃣ You misrepresented @WHO SAGO report by portraying the two theories as equally likely, a mistake called false equivalence
They are not
At SAGO press briefing,I asked which scenario was mostly likely
Answer:“the strongest evidence is still around a zoonotic transmission”
6/
Jon Cohen
@sciencecohen
From ‘open minded’ to ‘underwhelming,’ mixed reactions greet latest COVID-19 origin report www.science.org/content/article/open-minded-underwhelming…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
5️⃣ A key element of your narrative is: there was a biosafety crisis at WIV in late 2019
This is false
The misunderstanding resulted from mistranslations
Your evidence for the “crisis” includes:
(1) Uncovering of “hidden safety danger”, which results from mistranslation 👇
7/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
3️⃣ Glaring error
Your story mentions “hidden danger” 4 times,& uses them as evidence that major biosafety accidents took place at WIV before covid & had been covered up
They are mistranslated from “安全隐患” (potential, not actual, safety danger)👇
cn.linkedin.com/pulse/隐患的哪种英文表达更合理-norisk-safety-technology
4/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
(2) Referencing an “accident” that you say mentioned in the 12 Nov dispatch
This resulted from confusion of actual & hypothetical events
The sentence starting with “每当这时” = Every time a potential risky situation rises, Party members would rush to the frontlines
8/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Wrong translation by VF/PP👇: Every time a biosafety lapse has/had happened, Party members have/had rushed to the front lines.
There’s no equivalent of “would” or “could” in Chinese, and so grasping hypotheticals can be very challenging for non-native speakers.
9/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Other native speakers and professional translators of Chinese language raised similar issues👇
Another factual error: the 12 Nov dispatch was actually a republication of a post published on 30 Aug of the same year
This further messes up your narrative
10/
Dake Kang
@dakekang
The Wuhan Institute of Virology notice cited in the @VanityFair/@propublica is actually a repost of a piece published Aug 30 in 科苑党建, a publication by the party-building group of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (which is in charge of the WIV).
kydj.sciencenet.cn/content.aspx?id=3844
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
6️⃣ You story also speculates that “emergence response activity”, listed below, was triggered by biosafety breach at WIV:
(1) 3 Sept:WIV meeting about an upcoming internal audit to evaluate political discipline issues
(2) 11 Sept:Central Inspection Patrol Group visiting CAS
11/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
(3) 19 Nov: safety training at WIV, attended by CAS biosafety official Ji Changzheng, who invoked Xi Jiping’s general comments on safety issues.
You interpret this as Xi issuing specific instructions for WIV to address biosafety breaches.
12/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
(4) Oct: a senior official argued before Congress’ standing committee for the importance of biosecurity law that was being deliberated.
I admire your imagination that joined all those dots—some real and other imagined.
But you imagined wrong.
13/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You have obviously missed the crucial contexts below:
(a) People in China often invoke Xi’s remarks to underscore the importance of the matter in question
(b) There had been anti-corruption campaigns for years, and so (1) and (2) above👆took place within that context
14/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
(c)In 2019,China was drafting/deliberating its first biosecurity law & there was a national campaign to improve workplace safety (including biosafety)
There is no indication the remarks by Xi & other senior officials on safety importance were specifically geared towards WIV
15/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
7️⃣ You consider the following as evidence for biosafety breaches at WIV, but you are wrong.
(1) During a safety training in Nov 2019, WIV officials outlined several safety issues identified in the past year that he hoped would be addressed to prevent potential consequences
16/
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
There are multiple levels where biosafety protocols are implemented: all the way from individual (appropriate PPE & proper training) to the facility design & infrastructure (negative pressure, HEPA filters, waste disposal) to administrative (operational procedures, security).
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
(2) Senate report regards procurements of equipments as signs that WIV struggled to maintain key biosafety capabilities.
(3) Patent applications of inventions to counter corrosion of equipments are also seem as signs that the biosafety labs are not up for scratch.
17/
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
Here, WIV procured a vaporized hydrogen peroxide system to disinfect air coming from the lab. They even explain why they procured it: it’s less corrosive than an alternative. It’s an example of proactively upgrading critical equipment, not evidence of biosafety failure.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Please similar critiques👇by @dakekang & @BeijingPalmer about glaring errors & glaring omissions that put in question the narrative—and the motivation/integrity of the sources/writers/outlets
Both are fierce critics of China
Please also see article by @hiltzikm @latimes👇
18/
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
LA Times on the ProPublica/Vanity Fair expose: “The article is based heavily on Chinese-language documents that appear to have been mistranslated…
It also takes as gospel a report by a rump group of Republican congressional staff”
By @hiltzikm
www.latimes.com/business/story/2022-11-01/column-propubli…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
In the opening plenary of @ScienceWriting #sciwri22 on 22 Oct👇–organized by @sciencecohen and myself and moderated by @deborahblum—I warned against the limitation and danger of documents-based approaches.
casw.org/news/media-coverage-of-sars-cov-2s-origin/
19/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
If documents are not interpreted in correct context—scientific, political & cultural—then they could be subject to abuse and we risk joining dots we’re not supposed to be joining.
I should add if you get translation wrong, then you might be inventing dots that do not exist.
20/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
In response to @hiltzikm, you blamed problems on vagueness of Chinese language
Many scientists, journalists (incl fierce critics of China), native Chinese speakers,supporters of natural origins or lab leak think it’s a matter of honesty, integrity & due diligence—or lack of
21/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I’d think the documents you cite in the story are the ones that help make the strongest case
I’m open to the possibility that you might have other documents that can help make similar arguments.
If so, then please bring them along, and let them subject to public scrutiny.
22/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
In China, the press is a tool of propaganda for advancing political gains.
I had thought media organizations in the US, especially the likes of @propublica, were categorically different.
Please, prove to me that I was right.
23/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
They say journalism is what makes democracy work
We should all ask ourselves: Have we helped to make democracy work?
Or have we helped perpetuate stereotypes and existing narratives, exacerbate mistrust and polarization, and make the world a more dangerous place?
24/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
So,stunning scoop or train wreck?
A matter of mistranslation?
Incompetence,honest errors or bad faith?
You tell me. You answer will determine whether @propublica—or journalism in general—deserve to be trusted
@VanityFair,it’s said,is a lost cause—about which I’m agnostic
25/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
PS. Could you please provide the link to the 2018 Zhangjiajie report?
The link associated with “2011”, which is linked to a 2019 dispatch right now, is obviously not the correct one. Please provide the correct one.
Many thanks!
26/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You might want to read this media-criticism article for @AAASKavli about keeping biases in check and upholding journalistic objectivity.
Perhaps you might learn something.
Please do better next time. Please do much better. Thanks!
27/
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Hear 2016 AAAS Kavli Award-winner @janeqiuchina speak at tomorrow’s #sciwri22 opening plenary, and read her reflections on journalistic objectivity here: sjawards.aaas.org/news/journalistic-objectivity-and-origi….
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
@threadreaderapp unroll
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Correct: using correct cell lines is critical, which was trial and error in early days of coronavirus research
Two other limiting factors:
1. Prevalence: % of samples that contain🦠
2.🦠concentrations in samples
Bats harbour lots of 🦠, but often at very low concentrations
Steve Massey
@stevenemassey
I doubt the host material has much influence on virus isolation
More important is the ability of the virus to bind primate ACE2 efficiently if using green monkey (Vero) cells to isolate - which explains why they had difficulties previously isolating SARS1r CoVs (they used Vero) -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Correct: using correct cell lines is critical, which was trial and error in early days of coronavirus research
Two other limiting factors:
1. Prevalence: % of samples that contain🦠
2.🦠concentrations in samples
Bats harbour lots of 🦠, but often at very low concentrations
Steve Massey
@stevenemassey
You'll find it's rather easy to isolate SARS2r CoVs in Vero cells - this is because their RBDs efficiently bind primate ACE2
SARS2, GX/P2V and BANAL-236 have all been isolated with ease, probably for this reason. It would not have been difficult for WIV to isolate such a virus -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
We need to be precise with language
Nobody had a live🦠that was a close relative of SARS-CoV-2 before covid
And so nobody could have experimented on relatives of SARS-CoV-2 before covid
Wuhan team had over a dozen live🦠closely related to SARS-CoV-1👇
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c…
zeynep tufekci
@zeynep
Also we didn’t get a totally random novel virus, we got one related to the one we have been poking around and experimenting on for the past decade, fearing it may launch a pandemic, in a city with such labs. That’s not proof! Could be a coincidence. But can’t calculate this imo.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Matt Schrader
@Matt_Schrader_
The translation is bad, to the point that it was pretty obviously not checked with a native speaker or even a skilled non native translator
Matt Schrader
@Matt_Schrader_
Yeah, toy screwed up (I was a mandarin to English translator in a former life). As @zhihuachen points out, the key phrase 每当这时 ("every time this happens") is not referring to 操作失误 ("operational failures") but to the act of working with the test tubes, where...
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Alan Wong
@alanwong
Stunning how Toy Reid of South Carolina, who clearly has a gift for languages, could decipher Chinese official documents that a native Mandarin speaker "can't really follow" www.vanityfair.com/news/2022/10/covid-origins-investigati…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
David Gorski, MD, PhD
@gorskon
When outlets like @propublica and @VanityFair report conspiracy theories as fact, they contribute to the spread of disinformation. They are accomplices.
Michael Hiltzik
@hiltzikm
Column: ProPublica and Vanity Fair are pushing the COVID lab-leak theory, but their exposé is a train wreck www.latimes.com/business/story/2022-11-01/column-propubli…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“If science is progress then there is not going to be progress if the fruits of science are not widely distributed to people”.
@amymaxmen’s fabulous talk on inequality and emerging infectious diseases.
Nowhere is safe until everywhere is safe.
YouTube: m.youtube.com/watch?v=0ZI643rEPVs
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
Bay Area folks! I'm speaking at @UCBerkley this Thurs eve, about why scientists & science reporters must dig deeper into inequality. Let's address the "peculiar indifference" described by WEB DuBois 120 yrs ago.
@KavliFoundation
🧵stories I'll blab about:
www.eventbrite.com/e/inequality-as-a-frontier-for-science… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It was not @joshrogin’s first offence👇
@washingtonpost:Is it not imperative for op-ed to abide to the same standards of factual accuracy?Is it acceptable for sources to make baseless accusations,hiding behind anonymity?
Democracy dies in darkness.Lies make darkness even darker -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It was not @joshrogin’s first offence👇
@washingtonpost:Is it not imperative for op-ed to abide to the same standards of factual accuracy?Is it acceptable for sources to make baseless accusations,hiding behind anonymity?
Democracy dies in darkness.Lies make darkness even darker -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
Bay Area folks! I'm speaking at @UCBerkley this Thurs eve, about why scientists & science reporters must dig deeper into inequality. Let's address the "peculiar indifference" described by WEB DuBois 120 yrs ago.
@KavliFoundation
🧵stories I'll blab about:
www.eventbrite.com/e/inequality-as-a-frontier-for-science… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Deborah Blum
@deborahblum
Fascinating discussion with on the Covid origin story and coverage with @sciencecohen @janeqiuchina @KatherineEban and science historian Ben Hurlbut. Moderated by me at the NASW/CASW meeting.
Jon Cohen
@sciencecohen
Many thanks to @rosreid, @amberldance, @yashastone, @dvergano, @ScienceWriters and everyone else who put together this recording of the CASW panel on media coverage of the pandemic. Rough audio only for first 12 1/2 minutes but then clean audio/video.
casw.org/news/media-coverage-of-sars-cov-2s-origin/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jon Cohen
@sciencecohen
Many thanks to @rosreid, @amberldance, @yashastone, @dvergano, @ScienceWriters and everyone else who put together this recording of the CASW panel on media coverage of the pandemic. Rough audio only for first 12 1/2 minutes but then clean audio/video.
casw.org/news/media-coverage-of-sars-cov-2s-origin/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
Sad to hear that in the midst of an escalating Ebola outbreak in Uganda, clinics are short-staffed, lack PPE, and health-workers aren't adequately protected or paid.
Grim update @newhumanitarian www.thenewhumanitarian.org/news/2022/11/01/Rising-Ebola-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s telling—and shocking—how clueless Washburne is on the subject matter
An important part of journalists’ job is to critically evaluate the credibility of our sources rather than running with whatever sensational stuff that is out there
I’m sure @natashaloder would agree
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
If one gives everybody’s scientific claims equal weight without critically evaluating their expertise on the topic or the underling evidence, she is committing false equivalence, and the result will inevitably be uncritical he-said/she-said reporting
Objectivity vs neutrality👇
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Hear 2016 AAAS Kavli Award-winner @janeqiuchina speak at tomorrow’s #sciwri22 opening plenary, and read her reflections on journalistic objectivity here: sjawards.aaas.org/news/journalistic-objectivity-and-origi….
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
If one thinks the fact that all research has flaws is enough justification to report any preprints,then she obviously doesn’t understand not all flaws are the same
Some are fatal,making the coverage irresponsible, and others are trivial
The onus is on us to make sound judgement -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jeremy Konyndyk
@JeremyKonyndyk
Core problem is this: there's no real evidence for lab origin, but due to China's obfuscation, it can't be definitively refuted either. So it become a sort of Rorschach test that hinges on your priors.
Chris Hayes
@chrislhayes
I don't have any special insight or expertise, but have been pretty persuaded by the pushback to the piece.
Michael Hiltzik
@hiltzikm
Column: ProPublica and Vanity Fair are pushing the COVID lab-leak theory, but their exposé is a train wreck www.latimes.com/business/story/2022-11-01/column-propubli…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Natasha Loder
@natashaloder
Interesting thread challenging parts of the Vanity Fair/ProPublica piece
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi @KatherineEban @jeffykao @VanityFair @propublica:
Your article contains at least 1 glaring error & 1 glaring omission
Citing two documents published in June & Sept 2019👇,you say they lamented the BSL-4 lab as having the problem of “the 3 ‘nos’”
You got the tense wrong
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Patrick Adams @jpatadams.bsky.social
@jpatadams
And just a remarkable degree of arrogance given the evidence they were surely aware of going into this.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed. That makes the story of @KatherineEban @jeffykao @VanityFair @propublica even more draw-dropping
It’s a matter of honesty, competence and due diligence—or lack of
Please do not let your prejudice and crave for scoops colour your judgement
It’s a new low for journalism -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Peter Daszak
@PeterDaszak
Incredibly spot-on reporting by @hiltzikm “Others have questioned Reid’s claim to have read “between the lines” of Chinese dispatches. “One should get the lines themselves correct first,” observed @zhihuachen Chen, a China-born data scientist.
Michael Hiltzik
@hiltzikm
Column: ProPublica and Vanity Fair are pushing the COVID lab-leak theory, but their exposé is a train wreck www.latimes.com/business/story/2022-11-01/column-propubli…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
LA Times on the ProPublica/Vanity Fair expose: “The article is based heavily on Chinese-language documents that appear to have been mistranslated…
It also takes as gospel a report by a rump group of Republican congressional staff”
By @hiltzikm
www.latimes.com/business/story/2022-11-01/column-propubli… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Michael Hiltzik
@hiltzikm
Column: ProPublica and Vanity Fair are pushing the COVID lab-leak theory, but their exposé is a train wreck www.latimes.com/business/story/2022-11-01/column-propubli…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed. For majority of Chinese living & breathing Party talks for decades, it’s in their blood to know how to read between the line, understand the context and recognize the pattern
For non-natives, yes, it’s much more tricky & challenging, and one’d need to consult the experts
Greg Tucker-Kellogg (gtuckerkellogg.bsky.social)
@gtuckerkellogg
Gilles, do you think that Chinese natives and professionals who have grown up in, been educated in, and worked in environments where interpreting Party language is a specialised but widespread skill don't know what they are doing?
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
Jane is a native speaker. But yes, I hope @propublica looks into this issue with other native speakers. Note that @janeqiuchina isn't the only person to raise issues with the misinterpretation of Chinese documents. eg @zhihuachen
Zhihua Chen
@zhihuachen
Issues with the senate minority report on covid origins and the latest vanity fair/prorepublica piece that covers it.
Two issues.
1) Bad translation of a sentence in a Nov 12 WIV news release.
2) Bad interpretation of events leading to the Nov 17 safety training at WIV. 1/n -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jiahao Chen @NeurIPS
@acidflask
The amount of whitemansplaining @janeqiuchina is facing is insane. I thought this was a misreading of context, but no, it really is as clear cut as misreading the predicate of a conditional as a claim that the predicate is true. At least from the memos shared
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Speciality?If you are a native Mandarin speaker,it’s a piece of cake and doesn’t require special training
As someone who doesn’t speak fluent Mandarin,please show some humility rather than telling native speakers what they do/do not know about their own language
Thanks, Gilles! -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
PCSTNetwork
@PCSTNetwork
"Having biases is part of being human. The biases that end up compromising journalism standards are those that are unrecognized, unacknowledged, and unexamined."
So many great quotes in this story -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You meant the tabloid press? Or did you miss the joke?
Oh, I forgot you seem to be in short supply of a sense of humor (as well as humility)
Gilles Demaneuf
@gdemaneuf
Thanks God we have real journalists in the UK to keep us informed.
You seem to have missed that. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
If I tell Stuart:
- He doesn’t know how to read between the lines of speeches of his PM & MPs and related context/pattern
- He should read a Chinese translation/analysis of the speeches done by Chinese before he’d understand what’s going on in UK
I wonder what he would say/feel -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed. Hubris is the word.
Here is a hubristic Westerner telling us native Mandarine speakers that we can get better at decoding Party talks if we read more often their English translation!
Wow!
Life, indeed, is stranger than fiction.
Happy889123
@HAPPY889123
The hubris of non-native Chinese speaker or Chinese-illiterate western reporters (if you can't read can't write you are illiterate - see Kate Winslet in movie The Reader) is legend.
I've had such characters tell me Chinese is a piece of cake b/c they learned PinYin in 2 weeks.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Speciality?If you are a native Mandarin speaker,it’s a piece of cake and doesn’t require special training
As someone who doesn’t speak fluent Mandarin,please show some humility rather than telling native speakers what they do/do not know about their own language
Thanks, Gilles! -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Happy889123
@HAPPY889123
The hubris of non-native Chinese speaker or Chinese-illiterate western reporters (if you can't read can't write you are illiterate - see Kate Winslet in movie The Reader) is legend.
I've had such characters tell me Chinese is a piece of cake b/c they learned PinYin in 2 weeks.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Speciality?If you are a native Mandarin speaker,it’s a piece of cake and doesn’t require special training
As someone who doesn’t speak fluent Mandarin,please show some humility rather than telling native speakers what they do/do not know about their own language
Thanks, Gilles! -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Wow!
You think native Madarine speakers in China can learn something from the (not always good) English translation of Party talks when we can readily access the original Chinese version from within China?
I’m simply lost for words!
You seem to be in short supply of humility
Gilles Demaneuf
@gdemaneuf
You should read this more often (if you can access it from China):
www.ccpwatch.org/weekly-report-1 -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Speciality?If you are a native Mandarin speaker,it’s a piece of cake and doesn’t require special training
As someone who doesn’t speak fluent Mandarin,please show some humility rather than telling native speakers what they do/do not know about their own language
Thanks, Gilles! -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Sean Upton-McLaughlin
@SeanUM_China
The "secret language" of Chinese officialdom that native Mandarin speakers can't follow, but don't worry here's another white, male, "#china expert" to explain everything.
Except for the part where he got it completely wrong. 😂😂😂
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s rather unbelievable for native Mandarin speakers like myself to read the passage👇 in your article saying even we “cannot really follow” the so-called “party speak”.
It’s absurd and arrogant beyond belief.
One cannot make this up.
8/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The absurdity is simply beyond belief
Stunning ‘scoop’ of @KatherineEban & @jeffykao that CCP is not at all secretive or lacking transparency
It has all its dirty laundry out in the open—only if you can understand Party code language that few native Chinese speakers can follow -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed. That makes the story of @KatherineEban @jeffykao @VanityFair @propublica even more draw-dropping
It’s a matter of honesty, competence and due diligence—or lack of
Please do not let your prejudice and crave for scoops colour your judgement
It’s a new low for journalism -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Ben Smith
@semaforben
.@maxwelltani scoop: ProPublica scrambles to check translation in COVID origin story www.semafor.com/article/10/31/2022/pro-publica-scrambles-…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Please see similar critiques by @dakekang & @BeijingPalmer about serious errors & omissions that put in question the narrative—and the motivation/integrity of the sources/writers/outlets
Both have been fierce critics of China
twitter.com/beijingpalmer/status/1587068708844871680?amp;…
twitter.com/dakekang/status/1586943461818867712?amp;t=bKS…
1/
Paul D. Thacker
@thackerpd
Jane Qiu is now alleging that @propublica mistranslated a Chinese document ("got the tense wrong"). This is being amplified by other science writers.
Of interest: China state-affiliated media first began floating this allegation shortly after @propublica published.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Dear Paul
Please be rigorous with facts and stop shamelessly spreading mis/disinformation about me.
You’ve been making baseless assumptions about someone you don’t know and have absolutely no idea of. Stop it!
2/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Please see similar critiques by @dakekang and @BeijingPalmer about serious errors & omissions that put in question the narrative—and the motivation/integrity of the sources/writers/outlets.
Both are fierce critics of China.
twitter.com/beijingpalmer/status/1587068708844871680?amp;…
twitter.com/dakekang/status/1586943461818867712?amp;t=bKS…
Eric Feigl-Ding
@DrEricDing
FYI—That lab leak article in @propublica / @VanityFair seems to have maybe mistranslated the Mandarin Chinese document about the Wuhan lab. They maybe messed up the tense of the sentence. I’m gonna vet this further— but good to read meantime and hold for further deliberation.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi @KatherineEban @jeffykao @VanityFair @propublica:
Your article contains at least 1 glaring error & 1 glaring omission
Citing two documents published in June & Sept 2019👇,you say they lamented the BSL-4 lab as having the problem of “the 3 ‘nos’”
You got the tense wrong
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I wish you were at opening plenary of @CASW #sciwri22,where I talked about why journalists’ personal leaning shouldn’t affect how the story is covered & how to keep biases in check to achieve our ideal of journalistic objectivity
My essay for @AAASKavli: sjawards.aaas.org/news/journalistic-objectivity-and-origi…
Chris Shaver
@ChrisShaver64
Hi Jane! You’ve had unprecedented access to #wiv. Where do you think the SARS-CoV-2 virus came from?
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Prof Francois Balloux
@BallouxFrancois
I spent more time on the distribution of type IIS restriction sites in SARS-CoV-2, and revised my views. The distribution of the sites can be explained by extensive genetic recombination between viral lineage and does not provide evidence for a lab-origin for SARS-CoV-2.
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Kai Kupferschmidt
@kakape
Whatever you think of the original tweets, I admire the willingness to admit to a mistake here and change one‘s mind publically and I think Twitter is a better place the more people are able to do this…
Prof Francois Balloux
@BallouxFrancois
I spent more time on the distribution of type IIS restriction sites in SARS-CoV-2, and revised my views. The distribution of the sites can be explained by extensive genetic recombination between viral lineage and does not provide evidence for a lab-origin for SARS-CoV-2.
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Greg Tucker-Kellogg (gtuckerkellogg.bsky.social)
@gtuckerkellogg
Absolutely amazing. What an embarrassing spectacle that @VanityFair/@propublica piece is turning out to be.
Dake Kang
@dakekang
The Wuhan Institute of Virology notice cited in the @VanityFair/@propublica is actually a repost of a piece published Aug 30 in 科苑党建, a publication by the party-building group of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (which is in charge of the WIV).
kydj.sciencenet.cn/content.aspx?id=3844 -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I’m not the only person to have raised serious issues about the @propublica @VanityFair story by @jeffykao @KatherineEban
Please, eg, see the threads👇 by @dakekang and @BeijingPalmer
Both are fierce critics of China. Neither is zoonotic origins proponent as far as I’m aware of -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Gigi Gronvall
@ggronvall
Fascinating conversation w @DavidQuammen about his new book which I can’t wait to read! It was also a super cool surprise to hear him bring up my @SurvivalEditors paper! @profvrr www.microbe.tv/twiv/twiv-948/
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dake Kang
@dakekang
As others have pointed out, there's serious factual issues with this piece, including misleading translations of key quotes.
I want to point out one more issue: The contents of the WIV biosafety notice was written in *August*, NOT November. That overturns the narrative...
VANITY FAIR
@VanityFair
Breaking: A new Senate report concludes that SARS-CoV-2—the virus that causes COVID-19—likely resulted from “a research-related incident.” The report includes evidence of alarming biosecurity issues at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. vntyfr.com/F6VtO8r
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
The recent @propublica piece appears to rely on a misinterpretation of Chinese documents stating that the Wuhan lab went from not meeting standards, **to meeting them**, according to @janeqiuchina.
This is in addition to scientists saying they've been taken out of context.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi @KatherineEban @jeffykao @VanityFair @propublica:
Your article contains at least 1 glaring error & 1 glaring omission
Citing two documents published in June & Sept 2019👇,you say they lamented the BSL-4 lab as having the problem of “the 3 ‘nos’”
You got the tense wrong
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Monkeytime
@tmorman
Have you seen the Chinese speakers who have pointed out the mistranslations that form the basis of some of the strongest claims in the article?
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi @KatherineEban @jeffykao @VanityFair @propublica:
Your article contains at least 1 glaring error & 1 glaring omission
Citing two documents published in June & Sept 2019👇,you say they lamented the BSL-4 lab as having the problem of “the 3 ‘nos’”
You got the tense wrong
1/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi @KatherineEban @jeffykao @VanityFair @propublica:
Your article contains at least 1 glaring error & 1 glaring omission
Citing two documents published in June & Sept 2019👇,you say they lamented the BSL-4 lab as having the problem of “the 3 ‘nos’”
You got the tense wrong
1/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s rather unbelievable for native Mandarin speakers like myself to read the passage👇 in your article saying even we “cannot really follow” the so-called “party speak”.
It’s absurd and arrogant beyond belief.
One cannot make this up.
8/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Or did you invent your own lexicon, so you could ‘interpret’ the Chinese-language documents in ways that suit your agenda and narrative?
Please do the honorable thing: Please correct the glaring error and fix the glaring omission.
9/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You might want to read this media-criticism article for @AAASKavli about keeping biases in check and upholding journalistic objectivity.
Perhaps you might learn something.
Please do better next time. Please do much better. Thanks!
10/
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Hear 2016 AAAS Kavli Award-winner @janeqiuchina speak at tomorrow’s #sciwri22 opening plenary, and read her reflections on journalistic objectivity here: sjawards.aaas.org/news/journalistic-objectivity-and-origi….
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
What’s your definition of “promotion”, Paul?
Would journalists be promoting @K_G_Andersen just because they cite his work & scientific assessment?
You are being sloppy with facts again: Could you please give me one example in which I’ve cited Kristian in my articles?
Paul D. Thacker
@thackerpd
Journalists cannot forget that #scicomm writers like @carlzimmer @amymaxmen @janeqiuchina & @sciencecohen promoted this guy and his behavior relentlessly over the pandemic.
And their editors and outlets enabled all of this. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jon Cohen
@sciencecohen
Anyone record #casw panel on media and pandemic
origin coverage? Please DM me. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
World Federation of Science Journalists
@WFSJ
Journalistic Objectivity and the Origins of COVID-19: A Dispatch From the Front Lines
By Jane Qiu (@janeqiuchina)
#china
pulitzercenter.org/node/28109 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
World Federation of Science Journalists
@WFSJ
Journalistic Objectivity and the Origins of COVID-19: A Dispatch From the Front Lines
By Jane Qiu (@janeqiuchina)
#china
pulitzercenter.org/node/28109 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
World Federation of Science Journalists
@WFSJ
Journalistic Objectivity and the Origins of COVID-19: A Dispatch From the Front Lines
By Jane Qiu (@janeqiuchina)
#china
pulitzercenter.org/node/28109 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Lauren Quinn
@lquinn_phd
Discussion of how to do better with investigative reporting in science journalism. @sciencecohen says he loves FOIA, leaks. But you have to look at *everything* with a critical eye. “If your mother says she loves you, check it out.” Obtain but verify. #covidorigins #sciwri22
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Alice Fleerackers
@FleerackersA
"We have to be careful that we are not joining dots that we are not supposed to be joining"
—@janeqiuchina on the dangers of speculation and the importance of solid evidence in investigative reporting
#sciwri22 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Lauren Quinn
@lquinn_phd
@janeqiuchina Invited herself to give a talk at Wuhan lab on #scicomm. Used the talk to explain her approach, what she expected from the scientists, how they could help her. Great move to help her get unprecedented access. #covidorigins #sciwri22
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Lauren Quinn
@lquinn_phd
@janeqiuchina says there's a lack of critical thinking in the #sciwri community; we often simply regurgitate what we’re told by scientists. We're not assessing scientists’, safety experts’, politicians’ biases critically enough. #covidorigins #sciwri22
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Alice Fleerackers
@FleerackersA
"We focus a lot on fact-checking... [but] less on context," stresses @janeqiuchina.
"We can get the facts right but the story wrong" when we work this way
#sciwri22 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Alice Fleerackers
@FleerackersA
“Objectivity is not about [how] we don’t have personal biases…. It’s a method of understanding—that we could take different perspectives in a story despite our own personal leaning”
—@janeqiuchina on the always controversial idea of "objectivity" in journalism
#sciwri22 -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks, Anna!
Just a wee clarification: I meant that my interaction with the scientists at the Wuhan lab—40 hours, 6 institutions visits, 6 weeks in Wuhan, over 14 months—was no different from any other research teams I visited in other parts of China and world. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Kelly 🧶 Tyrrell
@kellyperil
An important point from @janeqiuchina: "Document-based research is powerful, but the approach is powerful only if those emails and documents are correctly interpreted in the correct context. Can be used as a tool to advance certain narratives and agendas." #covidorigins #sciwri22
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
CASW
@ScienceWriting
Kicking off in-person #memphis #sciwri22 TOMORROW Saturday 10/22 at 8:45 AM CDT:
Join panelists @janeqiuchina @sciencecohen @KatherineEban and J. Benjamin Hurlbut for the opening plenary on coverage of #covidorigins -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Hear 2016 AAAS Kavli Award-winner @janeqiuchina speak at tomorrow’s #sciwri22 opening plenary, and read her reflections on journalistic objectivity here: sjawards.aaas.org/news/journalistic-objectivity-and-origi….
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
The Open Notebook
@Open_Notebook
.@janeqiuchina implores science journalists to be mindful of cultural contexts. @jane_c_hu covered this well in this piece: "Sensitivity reading can help illuminate the truth by avoiding harmful stereotypes or mischaracterizations." #sciwri22 #covidorigins www.theopennotebook.com/2020/01/21/gut-check-working-with…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jon Cohen
@sciencecohen
If you don't follow @yangyang_cheng, your loss.
"Every act of rebellion, however spectacular or humble, is a reclamation of the self and a love letter to a stranger."
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/oct/25/xi-jinping-… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Anna Funk 🌻
@DrAnnaFunk
Science writers need to make sure we're not just regurgitating what we're told — need strong critical thinking and evaluation of the evidence @janeqiuchina #sciwri22
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Pulitzer Center
@pulitzercenter
“As most journalists are aware, we can get all the facts correct but the story wrong.” For @AAASKavli, grantee @janeqiuchina reflects on the limits of objectivity and the influence of bias while reporting on competing theories of COVID-19’s origins. pulitzercenter.org/stories/journalistic-objectivity-and-o…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
International Women's Media Foundation
@IWMF
As Asian elephants wander past protected areas seeking food and space, they leave long-term safety, putting themselves and other people in harm's way.
Read the story by #iwmfgrantee @janeqiuchina for @Nature: www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-03318-y -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Kelly 🧶 Tyrrell
@kellyperil
Here is @janeqiuchina's #covidorigins story for @techreview, which is the most memorable story I have read this year. #sciwri22 www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
Read 2016 AAAS Kavli Award-winner @janeqiuchina on journalistic objectivity and the origins of #covid19: sjawards.aaas.org/news/journalistic-objectivity-and-origi….
#sciwri2022 attendees can see her speak during the program's opening plenary on Saturday morning. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A new study @BritishEcolSoc shows Asian elephants spent most of their time outside protected areas, putting them & people in harm’s way
I am eternally grateful for the support of @IWMF’s Fund for Women Journalists for the reporting of this @nature story.
go.nature.com/3VGk6AA -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Protected areas might not contain suitable habitat for Asian elephants, which prefer forest edge & areas of regrowth.
This means we need to take into consideration nuances of elephant habitat needs & preferences & better manage human-elephant conflict.
econ.st/3gp5gyd -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
AAAS Kavli Awards
@AAASKavli
While objectivity “has long been regarded as one of the sacred tenets of journalism,” writes 2016 AAAS Kavli Award-winner @janeqiuchina, “our relationship with it is a tortured one.” Read her story on journalistic objectivity and the origins of COVID-19: sjawards.aaas.org/news/journalistic-objectivity-and-origi….
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A new study @BritishEcolSoc shows Asian elephants spent most of their time outside protected areas, putting them & people in harm’s way
I am eternally grateful for the support of @IWMF’s Fund for Women Journalists for the reporting of this @nature story.
go.nature.com/3VGk6AA -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You have misunderstood me: nobody said BtCoV4991 was the code for a sample
As everybody knows, 4991 was the sample ID
BtCoV4991 was the code for an (initially) partial virus sequence before the virus was properly named
There are numerous such codes for partial virus sequences
Steve Massey
@stevenemassey
'BtCoV4991' is hardly the name of a sample - it is a name of a virus
'BtCoV' stands for 'Bat Coronavirus' -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I guess you’ve missed a crucial “don’t” in your tweet👇
Science is messy and there are often inconsistencies in peer-reviewed papers, let alone graduate thesis
But they can easily become evidence for coverups if you are conspiracy-minded. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It was a code given to many *partial* virus sequences (often only a couple of hundred bases) based on the ID of the samples from which the pathogen had derived (which has subsequently been referred to).
It’s just a much easier way to archive them than naming them individually.
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
Please take a look at a 2019 thesis from the WIV. The virus was still called Ra4991.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I wonder what your definition of “prioritized” is
All of the 9 Mojiang sequences are distant cousins of SARS-CoV-1
Now we also know that, with the exception of RaTG13, the other 8 sequences are also distant cousins of SARS-CoV-2
None of them was deemed important before covid.
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
This would've been the true story:
Miners fell severely ill with a suspected SARSrCoV in 2012. WIV including other prominent labs went to that mine looking for bat CoVs. By 2015 WIV found at least 9 of these SARS2-like viruses and had prioritized these for study. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s a code given to many *virus* sequences (often only a couple of hundred bases) based on the ID of the samples from which the pathogen had derived.
It’s just a much easier way to archive them than naming them individually.
The sample ID is 4991 and contains no “Cov”.
Pete Aphid
@AphidPete
Why would a sample ID contain "Cov" before anyone has identified a coronavirus present in it? It might include the sample type, location and date, e.g. RA for R. affinis, TG for Tongguan and 13 for 2013.
Your claim makes no sense. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“Forced a correction”?Please do not confuse addendum with corrigendum.They are categorically different
Another thing you seem to be confused about:BtCov4991 is not a name. It’s a label that refers to the ID of the sample that contained the virus
RaTG13 is the name of the virus
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
This forced a correction to be made in Nature by the WIV in late 2020. This is not what I would call transparency.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“Forced a correction”?Please do not confuse addendum with corrigendum.They are categorically different
Another thing you seem to be confused about:BtCov4991 is not a name. It’s a label that refers to the ID of the sample that contained the virus
RaTG13 is the name of the virus
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
This forced a correction to be made in Nature by the WIV in late 2020. This is not what I would call transparency.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Pulitzer Center
@pulitzercenter
When and where exactly did COVID-19 start? Heated debates surrounding the origins of the virus are still ongoing in the third year of the COVID-19 pandemic.
For @NatGeo, grantee @janeqiuchina investigates the elusive role of China's wet markets. pulitzercenter.org/stories/debate-deepens-over-wuhan-wet-… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Pulitzer Center
@pulitzercenter
The Huanan wet market in Wuhan, China, has been off limits since January 1, 2020. As the world enters the third year of the COVID-19 pandemic, the precise origins of the virus remain hotly contested. Grantee @janeqiuchina investigates for @NatGeo. pulitzercenter.org/stories/debate-deepens-over-wuhan-wet-…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
There is no “my” interpretation
People I talked to are unconvinced of *your* interpretation for reasons I listed below and in other tweets
Your lack of rigor in scientific reasoning and understanding of China is demonstrable
The sales of live mammals at Huanan was well known.
Michael Standaert
@mstandaert
Or your "interpretation" ... perhaps a better word choice than opinion. The importance of those still stands in my interpretation. Particularly since authorities took the notice down after I asked about the fines.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
There is no “my” interpretation
People I talked to are unconvinced of *your* interpretation for reasons I listed below and in other tweets
Your lack of rigor in scientific reasoning and understanding of China is demonstrable
The sales of live mammals at Huanan was well known.
Michael Standaert
@mstandaert
Or your "interpretation" ... perhaps a better word choice than opinion. The importance of those still stands in my interpretation. Particularly since authorities took the notice down after I asked about the fines.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I didn’t say “Westerners couldn’t possibly understand”. I have great Western friends who understand China perfectly well
I was saying @mstandaert & others like him didn’t understand China’s behaviour because of their poor understanding of how China works and their Western gaze.
scott ferguson
@scotub
Jane, you’re the 1 saying that obvious shared behavior cannot be viewed as obvious shared behavior. You are instead suggesting that these shared behaviors are actually just cultural differences that “Westerners” couldn’t possibly understand. By invoking common humanity, I call BS
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Incidentally, I’d suggest you take a crash course so you could have a better and more sophisticated understanding of what common humanity really entails.
Invoking common humanity in this context is totally inappropriate. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Please do not conflate culture differences with common humanity.
Have you ever heard about the idea of a Western gaze?
scott ferguson
@scotub
China works in such strange and mysterious ways. Viewing their actions through even the most general lens of a shared common humanity might make you confused. The Chinese people defy such logic. This according to Jane Qiu.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s not about opinions. It should never be about opinions.
It’s about following the evidence. It’s about being rigorous about the presentation and the interpretation of evidence.
It’s also about vetting the alleged evidence against the original data.
1/
Michael Standaert
@mstandaert
You're welcome to your opinion of course, but I think they're important for the reasons stated above. Have you tried talking to Jin in person or by phone? I have his number if you want it. He also should be out at Sijimei market from what I understand.
Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The other 4 business records involved sales of livestock & aquatic products, and were last confirmed in 2014
Sci Rep paper had established illegal wildlife sales at Huanan
None of 6 records is evidence that any of the vendors had sold live mammals relevant to covid origins
3/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Any rigorous person would not infer that because the two vendors illegally sold live porcupines in May 2019, then it follows that they must have sold live mammals in late 2019 and caused the pandemic
That would be a speculation that cannot be justified by existing evidence.
4/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Most business records that have been dug out are vastly outdated.None shows those vendors at Huanan had license to sell live wildlife
The three vendors fined for illegal selling live mammals in 2019 concerned only porcupines
The interpretation of those records is sloppy at best
Michael Standaert
@mstandaert
Those records are important because they're another piece of evidence about live wildlife sales at Huanan before the outbreak, and two of the three owned stalls where environmental samples were found. Have you tried to speak with any of those three stall operators?
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The busts happened in early 2018. The sentencing was announced in July 2019, involving two smugglers selling 3 pangolins in total.
Such details are important.
Without such details and context, to say that there were busts prior to the outbreak is misleading.
1/
Michael Standaert
@mstandaert
Not necessarily. There's at least one farm near WH with a license to "breed" [ie have at the farm] pangolin. There were also busts for smuggling pangolin prior to the outbreak out in Lichuan, Enshi prefecture, Hubei. news.sina.com.cn/c/2019-08-09/doc-ihytcitm8047805.shtml
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
One should never take anything on paper in China on face value. People often used such “registration” of wildlife breeding as a disguise for poaching or smuggling.
It’s critical to understand the bigger context to truly understated the significance of what’s on paper.
2/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Most of business records that have been dug out are outdated.None shows those vendors at Huanan had license to sell live wildlife
The three vendors fined for illegal selling live mammals in 2019 concerned only porcupines
The interpretation of those records is sloppy at best
3/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I’d like to stress there are lots of incorrect information on Chinese internet, including government websites
Chinese media often lack rigor and factual accuracy
Please do not take information you see on the internet on face value or use it without independent verificaiton
4/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I did not say you were technically wrong
Indeed,“two months” is prior, so is “two years” or “a decade”— which, of course, has entirely different implications
Which was why I stressed that such details and contexts were critical
We need to adhere to the highest level of rigor
Michael Standaert
@mstandaert
Of course. I didn't mean like days or weeks etc. ... all of that information is in the stories I posted about those busts. I've noted before that this occurred in 2018. That's still "prior to the outbreak" ...
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Nobody said hospitals in Wuhan were overwhelmed in Jan 2020 because of flu.
They were overwhelmed because of covid and because people (understandably) panicked.
Emergency hospitals were built also because of covid, not flu.
quisp
@quisp1965
I've worked a lot of bad flu years and hospitals don't get overwhelmed like we saw of videos in January. Emergency hospital was being built Jan 21st. This shows worse flu previous year. Those flu were probably Covid.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I do have the obligation to point out that some people, like yourself, don’t understand critical aspects of the science involved and/or misunderstand a poorly-worded tweet—especially if those are the basis of their theory on covid origins.
It’s my job to counter misinformation. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Your command *of* English (not “on”,BTW) might not be as good as you think it is
Neither is your grasp of the science involved
You didn’t understand the differrence between symptom-onset dates & reporting dates.Neither did you understand how 30 cases in Dec 2019 were diagnosed -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Please show me the @stgoldst tweet that, according to you, says Shi knew about covid before 9 Dec 2019?
I haven’t been following tweets lately, but I’d be surprised if that’s what Stephen said or meant. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
There is no indication covid was widespread in Wuhan in late 2019
Who said Shi Zhengli knew about a new virus epidemic before Nipah conference on 9 Dec 2019? Please show me the tweet.
There was a really bad flu season in 2019-2020. Perhaps that was what Shi was talking about? -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
About 30 cases of atypical pneumonia were clinically diagnosed in different hospitals across Wuhan.Some hospitals sent samples to sequencing companies
No PCR or serology covid tests were available in 2019
PCR tests were not available until 10 Jan 2020👇
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmoa2001316 -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
There have been lots of misreporting about the 174 cases in the media and academic journals.
It resulted from a confusion between symptom-onset dates and reporting dates.
WHO reports said there were 174 cases in Wuhan with symptom-onset dates in December 2019.
1/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
About 30 cases—out of 174 with symptom-onset dates in Dec 2019—were reported/diagnosed in 2019
The first cluster was officially reported by Xinhua Hospital on 27 Dec 2019. Central Hospital had similar cases at same time or slightly earlier but didn’t realise significance
2/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
New Scientist
@newscientist
Companies are increasingly looking to engender loyalty by tapping into our evolved need to belong. But the emotional costs of bonding sessions and other techniques can be high and the sense of belonging false, warns @jonathnrgoodman
www.newscientist.com/article/mg25533960-300-beware-the-ri… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Shall I do your homework for you? A few random examples:
www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.336.6079.288
go.nature.com/3PW185n
go.nature.com/3bw3aub
go.nature.com/3bvAL7A
go.nature.com/3vCUDwg
Once again,please don’t jump to conclusion about things you know nothing about.That’s called prejudice
Rob Ricket
@RicketRob
Land slides in Nepal, grasslands in Tibet, water shortages in the Indus River, searching Tibet for the oldest climate records. Mmmm, what exactly does any of these stories have to do with industrial pollution endemic to China?
How about all those coal fired plants in China? -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Please don’t jump to conclusions about things you know nothing about.
I’ve written numerous articles critical of China’s environmental issues in China—published in Nature, Science and elsewhere—for which I’ve won @AAASKavli, @absw, and Asian Environmental Journalism Award
Rob Ricket
@RicketRob
Beijing must have a boot firmly planted on her neck, or she would be writing about the environmental issues inside China.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed, no debunking at all
@MichaelWorobey Science papers have made extremely valuable contribution to origins debate, doubly so given data rarity
It’s perfectly normal for scientists not agreeing with each other on certain aspects of a study. This does not discredit the work -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The preprints could have worded better, I agree.
It’s part of the purpose of the peer-review process to make submissions more rigorous—in terms of both wording and scientific arguments
I also agree that the published versions are a great improvement. So peer review has worked.
MJ Allen
@MJnanostretch
I thought the preprint was indeed dubious due to wildly oversold claims that were unethically promoted across media, whereas revisions in the peer-reviewed pub used appropriate language and balanced findings against shortcomings of the data.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“Dubious” is too much a pejorative terms to use in the given context, in my view.
If scientific disagreements make a paper dubious, then that can be said about all scientific papers.
There is no single scientific paper upon which everybody agrees about everything in it. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
In science,we need to distinguish three things:
- Data
- Interpretation of data
- Speculation
Some scientists do not agree with some aspects of the methodologies & interpretation of data of the @MichaelWorobey Science papers
It’s perfectly normal & does not discredit the work -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I actually don’t agree with you on that
@MichaelWorobey Science papers have made extremely valuable contribution to origins debate, doubly so given data rarity
It’s normal for scientists not agreeing with each other on certain aspects of a study. This doesn’t mean it’s dubious -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s interesting you also think zoonotic spillover is most likely, the most productive & realistic angle to pursue
That’s the consensus I meant after talking to dozens scientists of diverse disciplines & perspectives
We also need to step up lab biosafety governance & oversight
MJ Allen
@MJnanostretch
Re:"vast majority", were they all from the zoo crew? How many 5, 10, 20? Scientific poll? I also agree zoo spillover most likely, is that the consensus you're speaking of? Because that is not to say that a research-related origin is off the table. Right?
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Please be precise when quote my story: the language is “alternative spillover scenarios are consistent”, not non-zoonotic scenarios
So it’s where spillover happened that is controversial, not that covid emerged as a result of zoonotic spillover👇
Critical take is not debunking -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Minor clarification to avoid ambiguity: the *vast majority* of scientists I talked to agreed zoonotic spillover was the cause of the emergence of covid.
It’s a clear & unambiguous scientific consensus.
I don’t think we can find a single scientific theory that has no dissenters -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Many thanks, Pierre, my favorite PhD pal! You are the person on Twitter Land who knows me the best and for the longest time.
Gosh, I miss Scotland! Those happy memories of Garscube Estate, ceilidh dancing, and monro walking!
Hope all is well with you and your family!
Bio-Therapeutics Lab Malta
@lab_psw
I have known Jane Qiu for a very long time and i know her as a dedicated scientist keen to get to the bottom of things and to inform. I would never imagine her the puppet of a regime. She has the journalistic credentials to not risk that. Thanks for your reporting Jane.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A critical take on two new papers in @ScienceMagazine: while most experts agree that covid-19 was caused by zoonotic spillover,some are unconvinced it happened at Huanan market
Pinpointing the site of spillover “has important policy implications” @NatGeo
www.nationalgeographic.com -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Bio-Therapeutics Lab Malta
@lab_psw
I have known Jane Qiu for a very long time and i know her as a dedicated scientist keen to get to the bottom of things and to inform. I would never imagine her the puppet of a regime. She has the journalistic credentials to not risk that. Thanks for your reporting Jane.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A critical take on two new papers in @ScienceMagazine: while most experts agree that covid-19 was caused by zoonotic spillover,some are unconvinced it happened at Huanan market
Pinpointing the site of spillover “has important policy implications” @NatGeo
www.nationalgeographic.com -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You know little about me and my circumstance.
Yes, there is serious lack of press freedom in China. But I only write for UK/US outlets.
And yes, I’m writing as a free agent—much freer than you as I’m not bound by the shackles that are your glaring ignorance of your ignorance.
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
Jane would have a lot more credibility if she acknowledged the severe limitations on reporters working in China (both foreign/domestic journalists) instead of pretending she is somehow a free agent; so would those who publish her work. Is she an apologist for the regime?
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
This potently demonstrates your leaning, bias and prejudice, and the fact you don’t let your blaring ignorance get in the way when you express opinions about something you don’t know or understand, including the editorial process that goes into this story.
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
3/ Might as well get it all out. Jane also seems to think she is a totally free and independent journalist working out of China, an authoritarian country that routinely throws reporters in jail. A combination of naïveté and arrogance might explain this delusion.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
This potently demonstrates your leaning, bias and prejudice, and the fact you don’t let your blaring ignorance get in the way when you express opinions about something you don’t know or understand, including the editorial process that goes into this story.
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
3/ Might as well get it all out. Jane also seems to think she is a totally free and independent journalist working out of China, an authoritarian country that routinely throws reporters in jail. A combination of naïveté and arrogance might explain this delusion.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Have you consider the possibility you incorrectly judged me & my work from a lens strongly coloured by your personal leaning on orgins debate?
@NatGeo has no influence on main thrust of the story
The editing is about structure, clarity & length (1000 words were edited out)
1/
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
@janeqiuchina’s latest piece on Covid origins in @NatGeo is more balanced than any of her previous reporting. Not sure if she has been sobered by criticisms of her work (perhaps not likely) or if the NatGeo editors insisted on a more evenhanded approach.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I haven’t changed.Neither has my journalistic process
If you understand how I work👇,you’d agree there really is nothing baffling about my latest @NatGeo story
We should all try not to let our personal leaning affect our professional judgement on this extremely toxic debate
2/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I don’t have an agenda to push. I follow the evidence. I talk to many scientists of diverse disciplines and perspectives.
I try to steer away from people who have an axe to grind or a vested interest or those who might be too close to the authors of the papers I cover.
3/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s incredibly difficult to remain level-headed when it comes to intense controversies.We are all humans
We should be extremely vigilant not to let the extreme toxicity of the covid-origins debate distort our perspectives or colour our vision
Let’s all try to rise above it
3/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I’m glad to hear you agree that there is not enough evidence to reach a consensus regarding “where, when, how and which animals were involved in zoonosis”
In other words, spillover might or might not have happened at the market
I appreciate your perspective and open-mindedness -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks, Philipp! I’m glad to hear you were not saying that I created false equivalence in my @NatGeo story
I can’t agree with you more regarding “the tyranny of the majority” & believe that a lone scientist can be right even if everybody else disagrees
1/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
There is overwhelming consensus with climate change, which was not achieved after a single study
To force a consensus when there isn’t one—regarding spillover site (let me be clear: there is consensus regarding zoonotic spillover as the cause of covid)—is likely to backfire.
5/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I do hope you don’t mind me using QT. I really like it as QT makes it clearer what I’m responding to.
My small number of followers means that there is a slim chance of causing a dunking-on effect.
In any case, I have no intention to offend. Thank you for your attention.
6/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I’d like to clarify that I wasn’t saying only when we find an animal at market infected with a progenitor of SARS-CoV-2 could we conclude spillover happened there
It’s more about the preponderance of evidence not strong enough to convince some scientists that was the case.
1/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Neither paper concludes spillover took place at Hunan. It’s an interpretation that some disagree👇
You’d really need the two jumps to be true, which is controversial👇
Regarding Fig 4: association & correlation does not mean causation. Gao’s data might shed more light on this
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The bottom line is: the majority of scientists I talked to agree *multiple lines* of evidence point to:
(1) Pandemic exploded out of Huanan
(2) Emergence of covid was caused by zoonotic spillover associated with wildlife trade
These are the conclusions of your market paper
2/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
But they don’t think evidence presented by *a single study* is convincing enough to support the theory that spillover happened at market,especially other research groups using different approaches have come to diff conclusions of how pandemic started
More skeptical voices👇
3/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
What other evidence might move the needle? Two examples
(1) If samples collected by Gao’s team yield an animal virus closely related to human SARS-CoV-2
(2) If research using different methodologies comes to the same conclusion that there were two separate introductions
5/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
PS. I do hope you don’t mind me using QT here. I want to make sure it’s clear what I’m responding to
My small number of followers means that there is a slim chance of causing a dunking-on effect
In any case, I have no intention to offend. And I thank you for your attention.
6/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi Philipp Thanks again for the critiques.
I just wanted to stress that “false equivalence” is a special terminology that describes a journalism practice in which two sides of a debate are presented as equally valid even though there is overwhelming evidence for one of them
1/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Logically speaking,however,that doesn’t necessarily mean the two-jumps theory is correct
Both papers could be wrong even though one is superior
Please be careful in the future when you accuse a journalist of committing an offense of false equivalence. It’s no trivial matter
7/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Finally, I share your enthusiasm for the debate on covid-19’s origins.
I appreciate your contribution in the Twitter Land and beyond.
I look forward to engaging with you again about the topic in the future.
Thank you, Philipp, for your attention!
8/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi Moreno I’m not sure what you meant by “line-ups” or “journalists have their own ideas”
I wonder if this might reflect lack of understanding of journalism, which can cause confusion and make a toxic debate even more toxic.
Please let me explain my journalistic processes.
1/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I don’t have an agenda to push. I follow the evidence. I talk to many scientists of diverse disciplines and perspectives.
I try to steer away from people who have an axe to grind or a vested interest or those who might be too close to the authors of the papers I cover.
3/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
If one puts aside controversial two-jumps theory, alternative spillover scenarios are consistent with correlations reported in the market paper.
This is not to say spillover did not happen at Huanan. It’s just that there aren’t enough evidence to form a scientific consensus.
8/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
What other evidence might move the needle? Two examples:
(1) If samples collected by Gao’s team yield an animal virus closely related to human SARS-CoV-2
(2) If research using different methodologies comes to the same conclusion that there were two separate introductions
9/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Katherine Eban
@KatherineEban
A nuanced, detailed look by @janeqiuchina at continued questions surrounding the market origin hypothesis of #sarscov2: www.nationalgeographic.co.uk/science-and-technology/2022/…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
@scipak_es
"Origen de la COVID-19: ¿Cómo influyó el mercado de animales de Wuhan?" – via @janeqiuchina, @NatGeo_la www.nationalgeographicla.com/ciencia/2022/07/origen-de-la…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I used QT with all my replies to everybody. It’s nothing personal or has the intention to dunk on anybody. (I didn’t even know QTing has a dunking-on effect.)
Well, that’s something I learned today. Will definitely be careful with QT-sensitive folks in the future.
Andrew Tan
@andrewtanyongyi
And @janeqiuchina was totally courteous in her QT conversation with me. I admit I do think she has here somewhat "dunked on" @stgoldst (as he perceived), even if it was unintended.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Many thanks,Andrew! I just heard about QT today and realised this is regarded as an offensive tactic used by lab leak proponents
I normally reply to the original thread and then again by QT so that it’s easier to see what I’m responding
Glad that you don’t find this offensive!
Andrew Tan
@andrewtanyongyi
I've had a great conversation with @janeqiuchina where she QTed all my replies, which I found very unusual, but I'm not famous, and so unlikely 🤞 to get piled on. I think @sciencecohen uses similar QT technique. It may be different when QTing virologists who've been harrassed.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A critical take on two new papers in @ScienceMagazine: while most experts agree that covid-19 was caused by zoonotic spillover,some are unconvinced it happened at Huanan market
Pinpointing the site of spillover “has important policy implications” @NatGeo
www.nationalgeographic.comPost not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s true we don’t have all the answers and may never know for sure where COVID-19 came from—not unlike many other emerging infectious diseases
But we know enough to know that wildlife farming in China continues to pose a grave threat to global public health,says @edwardcholmes
Jamie Metzl
@JamieMetzl
Well-written and fair article by @janeqiuchina on #covid19 origins. Given that we still don’t know how the pandemic began, however, it would have been better for her to include a section on the danger of laboratory incidents. www.nationalgeographic.co.uk/science-and-technology/2022/…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Let’s not forget it’s difficult science,especially when working with limited data
So hat off to @MichaelWorobey @K_G_Andersen & Joel Wertheim for their leadership
It’s natural not everybody agrees. It’s part of the scientific process.Disagreement is what drives science forward
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks for the critiques, which are always welcome!
Mentioning different lines of investigation that come to different conclusions does not necessarily implies they are of equal merits.
The point is there are enough uncertainties to leave the debate on spillover site open.
1/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Neither paper concludes spillover took place at Hunan. It’s an interpretation that some disagree👇
You’d really need the two jumps to be true, which is controversial👇
Regarding Fig 4: association & correlation does not mean causation. Gao’s data might shed more light on this -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The majority of scientists I talked to agree overwhelming evidence—including latest Science papers—suggests that covid-19 emerged as a result of zoonotic spillover associated with wildlife trade at Huanan market
The question is where the virus jumped from an animal to a human.
Jamie Metzl
@JamieMetzl
Is @janeqiuchina the Captain Renault of the #covid19 origins conversation? Kudos to her for making clear what should be obvious to every credible journalist: the pandemic origins question remains fully open and both the lab and non-lab-related hypotheses remain viable."
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Your Science paper didn’t say spillover took place at Hunan because the evidence could not have led to that conclusion
It’s in the discussion of Pekar paper,which you said is irrelevant,that cites spillover at Huanan as the most probable explanation
Your case rests on two jumps
Stephen Goldstein
@stgoldst
That’s not the point - it’s that the evidence in the epicenter paper points to zoonosis and Huanan. Within the context of the paper they are inseparable.
I didn’t mention the Pekar paper, it’s not relevant to my point. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Have any other possible spillover locations—farms, warehouses (for keeping wildlife), & transportation chains—been studied?
I was aware you are a co-author of the epicenter paper
No offense, but I also suspect you don’t have the technical expertise to assess the two-jump paper
Stephen Goldstein
@stgoldst
That’s fine if someone thinks the case isn’t closed. But there is no evidence *for* zoonosis that implicates any location *other* than the Huanan market. This is clear in the Science paper, of which I am an author.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s true we don’t have all the answers and may never know for sure where COVID-19 came from—not unlike many other emerging infectious diseases
But we know enough to know that wildlife farming in China continues to pose a grave threat to global public health,says @edwardcholmes
Jamie Metzl
@JamieMetzl
Well-written and fair article by @janeqiuchina on #covid19 origins. Given that we still don’t know how the pandemic began, however, it would have been better for her to include a section on the danger of laboratory incidents. www.nationalgeographic.co.uk/science-and-technology/2022/…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
National Geographic
@NatGeo
As the world enters the third year of the COVID-19 pandemic, the precise origins of the virus and the role of the Huanan market in kickstarting the outbreak remain hotly contested on.natgeo.com/3vkf9Sj
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks for the critiques, which are always welcome!
Mentioning different lines of investigation that come to different conclusions does not necessarily implies they are of equal merits.
The point is there are enough uncertainties to leave the debate on spillover site open.
1/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The bottom line is much of the results in Science papers remain open to interpretation, and many scientists are yet to be convinced of the two jumps or the market being the spillover site
Some of the authors agree that the case is not closed yet. So let’s keep an open mind.
5/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Take home message of my @NatGeo story: while most experts agree covid-19 was most likely caused by zoonotic spillover, some are unconvinced that it happened at Huanan market.
Pinpointing the site of spillover “has important policy implications”.
6/
www.nationalgeographic.com -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks for highlighting my @NatGeo story on @ScienceMagazine papers
A better summary:while most experts agree covid was caused by zoonotic spillover,many are unconvinced of two jumps or market being the spillover site
Pinpointing spillover site has important policy implications
David Beard
@dabeard
Two new studies point to that Wuhan "wet market" as the springboard of the progenitor of #covid19, with at least 2 animal-to-human jumps of the virus. www.nationalgeographic.com/newsletters/article/new-clues-… @NatGeo @janeqiuchina
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Antonio Regalado
@antonioregalado
When reporter in a China wet market asked about yewei (“wild taste”), the vendors became stone-faced.
“Don’t mention that word,” one told me. “It’s not allowed anymore.”
But large-scale wildlife farming persists.
www.nationalgeographic.co.uk/science-and-technology/2022/… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Roland Pease
@PeaseRoland
Highly recommended reading. @janeqiuchina digests the two new Science (previously preprinted) studies on COVID origins, and sets them in much needed context
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A critical take on two new papers in @ScienceMagazine: while most experts agree that covid-19 was caused by zoonotic spillover, some are unconvinced it happened at Huanan
Pinpointing the site of spillover “has important policy implications”. @NatGeo
on.natgeo.com/3S4xOeF -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A critical take on two new papers in @ScienceMagazine: while most experts agree that covid-19 was caused by zoonotic spillover, some are unconvinced it happened at Huanan
Pinpointing the site of spillover “has important policy implications”. @NatGeo
on.natgeo.com/3S4xOeF -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A world within a world, infinitely. Enchanting and fascinating!
Vaskange
@Vaskange
The original video of my artwork here.
Stay tuned, to discover more infinite stories!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Not everybody knows how to read a science paper, esp those, like @JamieMetzl, who don’t understand how science works
The “preponderance” quote was from the intro of the paper. It’s the starting point of the study, not its conclusion. To present it as the conclusion is misleading
Jamie Metzl
@JamieMetzl
This new @ScienceMagazine article 100% clear "the observation that the preponderance of early cases were linked to the Huanan market does not establish that the pandemic originated there." The question of #covid19 origins remains fully open. www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abp8715
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
Except for an underestimated-but-at-least-9/11-level death toll every week. That’s still way more than seasonal flu.
We can’t prevent every COVID death but we still can reduce the risk significantly.
Unfortunately our policies aren’t reducing risk, so congrats are unwarranted.
Leana Wen, M.D.
@DrLeanaWen
"We are at a point that we can prevent nearly every Covid death in America." --@AshishKJha46 at White House briefing.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Can’t recommend more this amazing book, which is set to be the Bible for science journalism. Loved its global perspective.
I’ve already benefited enormously from reading a few chapters on topics related to my current work.
Hat off to @deborahblum @ashleythesmart @tomzellerjr
CASW
@ScienceWriting
A TACTICAL GUIDE TO SCIENCE JOURNALISM fm @OxUniPress is out. With 12 CASW-affiliated authors incl @HelenBranswell @apoorva_nyc @azeen @SciWriAlicia @cgseife & Rich Stone @TangledBankHHMI you can't go wrong! Sample their insights here. casw.org/news/casw-contributors-share-tips-in-tactical-gu…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Hank Greely
@HankGreelyLSJU
Hey, @newscientist - DON'T call human neural organoids "mini-brains." They are brain tissue but not organized at all like miniature brains. Calling them mini-brains is misleading—and may scare people. See www.newscientist.com/article/mg25533962-300-what-lab-grow… See this @theNASEM report: nap.nationalacademies.org/read/26078/chapter/1
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
Scientists teared up when I interviewed them for this #abortion story on research post #roe, and so did I.
(1) It's about studying predicted rises in maternal deaths & injury, a rise in health disparities, a rise of over-criminalization of Black people... www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-01947-x -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Hank Greely
@HankGreelyLSJU
Having read Jane's work over the years, especially her work on the He Jiankui affair, I have seen no reason to think she's a CCP apologist.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Hank Greely
@HankGreelyLSJU
By @janeqiuchina in @techreview on Shi Zhengli, "the bat lady" of the Wuhan Institute of Virology. www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… Long but powerful piece. I found the last few paragraphs, about Shi's disillusionment w/the West, very sad.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
🚨My latest: An in-depth feature tackling global vaccine inequality🧵
1/ This is bigger than Covid. It’s about unsafe policies & practices ensuring that profit & power stays in the Global North.
It’s about what needs to change.
#longreads #covidvaccine www.nature.com/immersive/d41586-022-01898-3/index.html -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
NEW: unfortunately it’s time for another international Covid update, as the BA.5 Omicron lineage (and BA.4 to a lesser extent) sends not only cases but also hospitalisations climbing around the world, from South Africa, to Portugal, the UK, Israel and now the US 📈
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
David Gorski, MD, PhD
@gorskon
Ugh. Paul Thacker? Seriously? ABSW's standards for good investigative journalism need some work. His story was poorly sourced, and he didn't support his allegations with evidence. sciencebasedmedicine.org/what-the-heck-happened-to-the-bmj/
ABSW
@absw
Find out which of the finalists @CrispinDowler, @AkshatRathi or Paul Thacker will win the Steve Connor Award for Investigative Science Journalism at the Awards Ceremony: www.absw.org.uk/events/absw-2022-awards-ceremony
#abswawards -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Rodrigo Pérez Ortega
@rpocisv
It's been a while since I've had such a thoughtful, honest, and deep interview. I'm glad I recently had a chance to talk to @pbaJackson about many things, but especially about a way forward studying how structural racism impacts health. Here's out chat: www.science.org/content/article/capture-racism-s-impact-h…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It was an honor to share with colleagues in UK/Austria my reporting of lab leak controversy for @techreview, funded by @pulitzercenter, in which I discussed the importance of vetting biases & challenges of fighting misinformation.
Thanks @ChemistryKit @faljournalism for invite!
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Emma Elobeid (she/her)
@emmaelobeid
What a privilege to listen to @janeqiuchina describe her journalistic process behind this incredibly nuanced story on the origins of Covid-19. Thanks @faljournalism for organising!
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Kai Kupferschmidt
@kakape
And I hope everyone hears this loud and clear:
“If you see an unusual rash illness or you see something that looks to you like a sexually transmitted disease in terms of it, looks like syphilis, looks like herpes, we probably need to be thinking about testing for monkeypox”. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Kai Kupferschmidt
@kakape
“What we think that this indicates is that there are likely multiple introductions out of Nigeria at points in the recent past, and there are likely additional transmission events occurring globally”.
Great story as always, from @HelenBranswell
www.statnews.com/2022/06/03/genetic-data-indicate-at-leas… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Helen Branswell 🇨🇦
@HelenBranswell
BREAKING: US #monkeypox sequence data suggest there are at least 2 concurrent outbreaks going on globally, @CDCgov says. It suggests the virus may have a foothold in places that haven't been identified & has been spreading longer than recognized. www.statnews.com/2022/06/03/genetic-data-indicate-at-leas…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
I'm glad that WHO nods to the racism inherent in Monkeypox coverage. But to be clearer, she might have said that this is the reality of white people only caring about white people.
Kai Kupferschmidt
@kakape
1000s of suspected monkeypox cases and 66 deaths reported in Africa this year alone, she says. “We have to acknowledge the fact that this virus has been circulating for decades, and we now have attention to this. This unfortunately is the sad reality of the world that we live in"
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
643 confirmed monkeypox cases in 26 countries have been reported to @WHO, with possibly many more suspect cases, says @mvankerkhove.
Human-to-human transmission might have been going on for quite some time before the first case was identified.
twitter.com/kakape/status/1532327123863601158 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Christophe Fraser Group
@ChristoPhraser
One to read carefully. Analysis of genomes in current monkeypox outbreak, by @AineToole & Andrew Rambaut. Suggests that this outbreak has been going for a while, and the mutations are the result of innate host mechanisms that limit virus replication.
virological.org/t/initial-observations-about-putative-apo… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
It must be comforting to believe that if we just stop studying pathogens they’ll go away. But viruses don’t cease to exist because we ignore them.
Virus emergence is a complex problem & requires complex solutions, all of which begin with taking it seriously & not neglecting it. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
Since I’m seeing a whole lot of increasingly wild claims about the origin of the current monkeypox outbreak, here’s a couple facts despite the many unknowns:
✔️Monkeypox is not smallpox. They are different viruses.
✔️Neither one was created in a lab. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
“SARS-CoV-2 is rapidly mutating & recombining, & more variants…are on the horizon. The world is still barely vaccinated, & even in wealthy countries like the US, resources are inequitably distributed. It absolutely ain’t over. And this is no time to drop the ball.” 🎯
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Does a lobster feel pain when you pop it in a pot?
The UK government asked scientists to find out and the answer is yes.
@ConversationUK
theconversation.com/octopus-crabs-and-lobsters-feel-pain-… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Crabs, lobsters, and lobsters demonstrate clear signs of emotions, including pain and anxiety-like behaviour
A new UK law will recognize them as sentient beings, subject them to similar animal welfare consideration as mammals
@horton_official @guardian
www.theguardian.com/world/2022/apr/25/crabs--lobsters-may… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Myth busted: Pedigree is not destiny!
A sweeping study published in @ScienceMagazine comparing the behaviour and ancestry of more than 18,000 dogs shows that breed does not predict behavior or temperament
@FKreier @Nature
go.nature.com/3knDSzn -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
‘Jurassic Park effect’: ancient DNA research illustrates the symbiosis between media and ‘celebrity science’.
“Funding, top-tier papers and ‘impact’ are good for careers, but are they good for science?”
go.nature.com/3vR5Skg -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Myth busted: Pedigree is not destiny!
A sweeping study published in @ScienceMagazine comparing the behaviour and ancestry of more than 18,000 dogs shows that breed does not predict behavior or temperament
@FKreier @Nature
go.nature.com/3knDSzn -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jon Cohen
@sciencecohen
Fascinating @carlzimmer story about @wormmaps team's machine learning to suss out potential viral threats.
www.nytimes.com/2022/04/27/science/pandemic-viruses-machi… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Crabs, lobsters, and lobsters demonstrate clear signs of emotions, including pain and anxiety-like behaviour
A new UK law will recognize them as sentient beings, subject them to similar animal welfare consideration as mammals
@horton_official @guardian
www.theguardian.com/world/2022/apr/25/crabs--lobsters-may…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Does a lobster feel pain when you pop it in a pot?
The UK government asked scientists to find out and the answer is yes.
@ConversationUK
theconversation.com/octopus-crabs-and-lobsters-feel-pain-… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social
@BillHanage
A very interesting thread from an expert in mental health and how the pandemic has impacted it. The upshot is it has, but nowhere near as much as some suggest, and of course the causal relations driving these observations are not known
Tyler Black, MD
@tylerblack32
📣"Well-being during the pandemic"📣
A data-driven thread designed to *demonstrate the reality* about the moral panic of well-being during the pandemic.
If you want to know what the data shows, read on. Bring an open mind and read carefully. I've put a lot of work into it.
/1 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Emily Feng 冯哲芸
@EmilyZFeng
Who's in those PPE suits, enforcing lockdowns and testing millions? @AowenCao and I began digging. Turns out, much of the "dabai" muscle behind China's zero covid are migrant workers, roaming from lockdown to lockdown for temporary gigs.
www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2022/04/20/1093578978/m… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
In report you mentioned👇,“isolates” refers to genomic sequences. We all know there was no natural isolate of SHC014
All 15 bat viruses are published in @Nature, J Virol, @PLOSPathogens 👇
Imprecise in language? Yes
Liar? Not based on this incorrect argument of yours at least -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Marion Koopmans, publications: https://pure.eur.nl
@MarionKoopmans
Tweetorial by @DebbyvanRiel about neurological complications of COVID19 👇🏻
Debby van Riel
@DebbyvanRiel
Challenged by @MarionKoopmans, to write a thread about on our recent paper “The neuroinvasiveness, neurotropism and neurovirulence of SARS-CoV-2” for the general public.
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8890977/pdf/main.pdf
So here I go...👇👇 -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Contexts & framing are just as important as facts. Every fact & statement must be understood in the right context
Different types of work of the same virus entrails totally different levels of risk
There is big difference btw growing “a dozen” & “hundreds” of live bat CoVs
1/
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
Is Ralph Baric, a top coronavirus expert, correct about the dangers of culturing numerous unknown viruses at BL2, or is he not?
www.technologyreview.com/2021/06/29/1027290/gain-of-funct…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The contexts and framing matter!
I laid out in my @techreview story the biosafety standards for working with bat coronaviruses at Wuhan lab (that is,molecular/culture work in BSL2 cabinets and animal work in BSL3), the context of evaluation,and why they need to be revised👇
2/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I’m not trying to convince anybody. My job is to present diverse perspectives
I don’t think you cay say for sure whether people who accuse Shi of lying are racists or not
To say that nobody can exercise their agency in an authoritarian regime is to diminish our humanity -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Many journos have to endure online abuse and harassment that are beyond legitimate scrutiny of their work.
If you are a journo and have had such experiences, please help study this worsening epidemic by taking part in this survey, so we could find ways to better deal with it.
Global Reporting Centre
@GlobalRepCentre
Journalists around the world are regularly targeted w/ campaigns aimed at discrediting them & undermining reporting. If you’re a journalist, please fill out @GlobalRepCentre & @pressfreedom’s confidential survey to help us better understand this threat. ubc.ca1.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_eXlr3GmyggQ8hUO
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Shi has identified ~220 bat CoVs that are closely related to SARS1 (which was the focus). We’re talking about (mostly partial) sequences, not live viruses
It’s notoriously difficult to isolate live viruses out of bat samples 👇
All detailed in my story: www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c…
Roland Pease
@PeaseRoland
I'll defer to @janeqiuchina who is more on top of the details, but the 180 identifications noted in the PREEMPT doc refer to RNA detections (in my understanding), not whole viruses .
It's a bit like police saying they've caught 180 crooks when all they have are 180 fingerprints. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Please be rigorous when communicating science to public,@Ayjchan
This sentence “working with 100s of new airborne viruses in BSL2” is misleading
1️⃣ Different types of work have different BSL considerations. PCR tests (covid tests for bats) have lowest risk & is fine in BSL2
1/
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
Point taken that many virologists do not like the BL2-to-dentist's office comparison.
But does this mean they still think working with 100s of new airborne viruses in BL2 is wise?
This research is still ongoing with SARS, MERS, ebola, nipah-like viruses.This post is unavailable. See it on X.Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The 3,300-word story is poorly reported: @rowanjacobsen cited few primary sources, only one (Baric) is a virologist. (Shi gave only short email replies)
This is extremely inadequate for a complex science story like this, especially of which the journalist has no expertise.
7/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
7️⃣ Getting the contexts & the framing right is just as important as getting the facts right. The key is extensive reporting. (I talked to ~40 sources for the story👇, many not cited.)
There is no short cut to it. Second-hand reporting simply won’t do & should be minimised.
8/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A masterclass by @edyong209: How to conduct interviews with empathy?
Interviews are about learning something new, people’s experiences & emotions
There are ways of asking hard questions that respect the person you’re talking to.
@KimhCross @niemanstory
niemanstoryboard.org/stories/how-a-top-explanatory-report… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunningly and exquisitely beautiful! Wow!
The anatomy of literally how we feel: a sensory neuron visualized by using florescent dyes that bind to different proteins on the cell.
#neuroscience by P. Diaz, H/T @slava__bobrov -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Lions may have roamed in Europe, possibly for thousands of years before being driven to extinction by humans ~3,200 yrs ago, casting a whole different light on the art and mythology in Bronze Age Greece
Fascinating story by @katarinazimmer @SAPIENS_org
www.sapiens.org/archaeology/lions-europe/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
India is cutting large swaths of forests for development projects, claiming that new plantation will make up for the loss
This is missing forest for the trees. Monocultures of fast-growing trees cannot replace natural forests
@AtharParvaiz @TRF_Stories
tmsnrt.rs/3v1EGQm -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Photographer @laurendecicca talks to @NewsfromScience photo editor @billdouthitt about invading moths and obstructing elephants as she tried to document virus-sampling trip in Thailand, along with @sciencecohen
👇Pic by Jon, who was shooting the shooter
www.science.org/content/blog-post/focusing-bats -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
How the covid surge in Shanghai has affected scientists?
“Every day I walk about 3,000 steps just by circling my home dozens of times.”
The lockdown is a misfortune for the city, but for sociologists, “it’s a huge social experiment.”
@yvaineye @Nature
go.nature.com/3ECkd7O -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
How to stay alive and keep science alive in Ukraine? #scienceforukraine
Many institutions have lent a helping hand, but much more and longer-term solutions are needed
Deeply reported by @katarinazimmer @TheScientistLLC
www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/amid-the-terror-of-war… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
India’s mega projects to develop renewable energy are exempt from environmental impact assessments required for major infrastructure projects
They are destroying environment & people’s livelihood. Hardly green or sustainable.
@AtharParvaiz @TRF_Stories
tmsnrt.rs/3rCUV4r -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A masterclass by @edyong209: How to conduct interviews with empathy?
Interviews are about learning something new, people’s experiences & emotions
There are ways of asking hard questions that respect the person you’re talking to.
@KimhCross @niemanstory
niemanstoryboard.org/stories/how-a-top-explanatory-report… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Stunningly and exquisitely beautiful! Wow!
The anatomy of literally how we feel: a sensory neuron visualized by using florescent dyes that bind to different proteins on the cell.
#neuroscience by P. Diaz, H/T @slava__bobrov -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Lions may have roamed in Europe, possibly for thousands of years before being driven to extinction by humans ~3,200 yrs ago, casting a whole different light on the art and mythology in Bronze Age Greece
Fascinating story by @katarinazimmer @SAPIENS_org
www.sapiens.org/archaeology/lions-europe/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
This was in response to Dr. @janeqiuchina’s queries about why said influencer is uncritically repeating the assertion by one of her fellow agenda-driven leakers-in-arms that BSL2 containment is akin to a “dentist’s office” (it’s not).
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Virologists have discredited the analogy by @R_H_Ebright who is not a virologist
Please do not uncritically cite the wrong comparison
BSL2 involves working in cabinets with air filtration and under negative pressure to keep pathogens inside. No dentist work in such cabinets
1/
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
Some scientists have tried to explain what BL2 is like to non-scientists. @R_H_Ebright has compared it to a dentist's office.
But I think you need to have worked at BL2 to know exactly how inappropriate it is for handling airborne SARS-like viruses. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Marion Koopmans, publications: https://pure.eur.nl
@MarionKoopmans
An outbreak of rabies in South Africa. North-South collaboration . Rabies is a 100% lethal zoonotic virus, unfortunately still a big problem in many parts of the world www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.202…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
India is cutting large swaths of forests for development projects, claiming that new plantation will make up for the loss
This is missing forest for the trees. Monocultures of fast-growing trees cannot replace natural forests
@AtharParvaiz @TRF_Stories
tmsnrt.rs/3v1EGQm -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Photographer @laurendecicca talks to @NewsfromScience photo editor @billdouthitt about invading moths and obstructing elephants as she tried to document virus-sampling trip in Thailand, along with @sciencecohen
👇Pic by Jon, who was shooting the shooter
www.science.org/content/blog-post/focusing-bats -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
How the covid surge in Shanghai has affected scientists?
“Every day I walk about 3,000 steps just by circling my home dozens of times.”
The lockdown is a misfortune for the city, but for sociologists, “it’s a huge social experiment.”
@yvaineye @Nature
go.nature.com/3ECkd7O -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
How to stay alive and keep science alive in Ukraine? #scienceforukraine
Many institutions have lent a helping hand, but much more and longer-term solutions are needed
Deeply reported by @katarinazimmer @TheScientistLLC
www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/amid-the-terror-of-war… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
India’s mega projects to develop renewable energy are exempt from environmental impact assessments required for major infrastructure projects
They are destroying environment & people’s livelihood. Hardly green or sustainable.
@AtharParvaiz @TRF_Stories
tmsnrt.rs/3rCUV4r -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed. It’s not about arguing over a comparison people don’t like
The comparison is wrong and misleads the public, includ yourself, about what BSL2 entails
It’s a piece of misinformation that needs to debunked. People who are spreading it, like @Ayjchan, need to be called out
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
It is wrong, misleading, and betrays your total lack of knowledge about biosafety practices to characterize BSL2 containment as "unsafe" for "human-infective" pathogens. BSL2 is appropriate for many, including some arguably GOF work with known respiratory viral pathogens.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
All the virologists I talked to in US, Europe, Australia and Singapore said that growing viruses designated as BSL2 agents is invariably carried out in BSL2 cabinets
This is also explicitly required by the biosafety committee at the Wuhan lab for growing bat coronaviruses👇
4/
Richard H. Ebright
@R_H_Ebright
The only mandated requirements for BSL-2 are lock on door, screens on windows, uncarpeted floor, sturdy furniture, sink, eyewash, availability of device for sterilization/decontamination, and availability of gown, glasses, and gloves; cdc.gov/labs/pdf/CDC-BiosafetymicrobiologicalBiomedicalLa…).
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Many virologists, including @R_H_Ebright and @angie_rasmussen, are advocating global reevaluation of biosafety standards for animal viruses with unknown risks
“The pandemic has changed that risk-benefit equation,” says Rasmussen
My @techreview story: twitter.com/janeqiuchina/status/1491445332089384960
3/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s not uncommon for labs worldwide to culture uncharacterized animal viruses in BSL2 facilities.
In US, some contagious animal CoVs that can infect human cells in a petri dish, including deadly pig viruses originated in bats, are—like Shi’s viruses—designated BSL-2 agents.
2/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Virologists have discredited the analogy by @R_H_Ebright who is not a virologist
Please do not uncritically cite the wrong comparison
BSL2 involves working in cabinets with air filtration and under negative pressure to keep pathogens inside. No dentist work in such cabinets
1/
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
Some scientists have tried to explain what BL2 is like to non-scientists. @R_H_Ebright has compared it to a dentist's office.
But I think you need to have worked at BL2 to know exactly how inappropriate it is for handling airborne SARS-like viruses. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Before pandemic,Shi’s team had worked with only the following live bat viruses,all close relatives of SARS1: twitter.com/janeqiuchina/status/1491445332089384960
- 3 natural isolates
- 3 synthesized from genomic sequences
- a dozen chimeras using as the backbone bat viruses that were close relatives of SARS1 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
This breathtaking book is bound to be the bible for science journalists worldwide. It covers general principles & many beats with a global perspective
Love the title of the epilogue by @tomzellerjr: Stay curious and question everything
That’s what science journalism is about!
KSJ at MIT
@KSJatMIT
Looking for practical advice and insights from the world’s best science writers? Check out “A Tactical Guide to Science Journalism” edited by @KSJatMIT's @deborahblum @ashleythesmart @tomzellerjr. Take a look at what’s inside:🧵
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The media is to blame to some extent. Many journalists writing about this have no science background or insight of China & had written little about neither pre-covid
There are also lots of second-hand reporting, so journalists are merely repeating rumors masquerading as evidence
PaperclipAI
@xiruxi
Cites an opinion, calls it a fact. Then calls it evidence.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It was considered as appropriate based on what scientists knew then👇
Science is a process. As the science of bat viruses evolves, so will biosafety oversight
We don’t know the origins of many infectious diseases, but this shouldn’t stop us from strengthening biosafety measures
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
And I’ll add the link to the Wikipedia page on biosafety levels. This links to all the major regulatory bodies (in US, it’s CDC) that defines them. Note that prior to this pandemic, BSL2 *was* considered appropriate by the regulators for bat CoVs.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biosafety_level -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Really helpful diagram about different levels of biosafety measures. H/T @angie_rasmussen
www.cdc.gov/cpr/infographics/biosafety.htm -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks, @JacquiB! I dream about going to the magical Madeline Island and getting another dose of badly needed craft talk and inspiration
Hopefully summer 2023: www.madelineartschool.com/product/crafting-the-true-story…
My latest @techreview story would not be possible without the Tucson workshop in winter desert
Jacqui Banaszynski
@JacquiB
Would love to see you on magical Madeline. I owe you a response to your messages. Miss you, and thrilled by the work you're doing.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks, @JacquiB! I dream about going to the magical Madeline Island and getting another dose of badly needed craft talk and inspiration
Hopefully summer 2023: www.madelineartschool.com/product/crafting-the-true-story…
My latest @techreview story would not be possible without the Tucson workshop in winter desert -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed. It’s not about arguing over a comparison people don’t like
The comparison is wrong and misleads the public, includ yourself, about what BSL2 entails
It’s a piece of misinformation that needs to debunked. People who are spreading it, like @Ayjchan, need to be called out
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
It is wrong, misleading, and betrays your total lack of knowledge about biosafety practices to characterize BSL2 containment as "unsafe" for "human-infective" pathogens. BSL2 is appropriate for many, including some arguably GOF work with known respiratory viral pathogens.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jon Cohen
@sciencecohen
A Q&A by @NewsfromScience photo editor @billdouthitt with terrific photographer @laurendecicca, who shot story sampling bats in Thailand for viruses. I like to shoot shooters I work with and glad to flip tables with my shots dressing up her story!
www.science.org/content/blog-post/focusing-bats -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I have discussed this at length in my @techreview story and in my previous tweets.
Please do your homework first before you challenge anybody, especially when you talk outside of your expertise and insight
The story in question: twitter.com/janeqiuchina/status/1491445332089384960
MJ Allen
@MJnanostretch
@janeqiuchina I'm spreading false rumors that SZL worked at BSL-2? because bamboozled by non-expert opinion pieces? Gross. Is this SZL& batcovs at BSL-2 or not?: "All experiments using live virus was conducted under biosafety level 2 (BSL2) conditions."
journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/JVI.03079-15
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The media is to blame to some extent. Many journalists writing about this have no science background or insight of China & had written little about neither pre-covid
There are also lots of second-hand reporting, so journalists are merely repeating rumors masquerading as evidence
PaperclipAI
@xiruxi
Cites an opinion, calls it a fact. Then calls it evidence.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks, @JacquiB! I dream about going to the magical Madeline Island and getting another dose of badly needed craft talk and inspiration
Hopefully summer 2023: www.madelineartschool.com/product/crafting-the-true-story…
My latest @techreview story would not be possible without the Tucson workshop in winter desert
Jacqui Banaszynski
@JacquiB
Would love to see you on magical Madeline. I owe you a response to your messages. Miss you, and thrilled by the work you're doing.
-
Jacqui Banaszynski
@JacquiB
Would love to see you on magical Madeline. I owe you a response to your messages. Miss you, and thrilled by the work you're doing.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks, @JacquiB! I dream about going to the magical Madeline Island and getting another dose of badly needed craft talk and inspiration
Hopefully summer 2023: www.madelineartschool.com/product/crafting-the-true-story…
My latest @techreview story would not be possible without the Tucson workshop in winter desert -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Really helpful diagram about different levels of biosafety measures. H/T @angie_rasmussen
www.cdc.gov/cpr/infographics/biosafety.htm -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It was considered as appropriate based on what scientists knew then👇
Science is a process. As the science of bat viruses evolves, so will biosafety oversight
We don’t know the origins of many infectious diseases, but this shouldn’t stop us from strengthening biosafety measures
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
And I’ll add the link to the Wikipedia page on biosafety levels. This links to all the major regulatory bodies (in US, it’s CDC) that defines them. Note that prior to this pandemic, BSL2 *was* considered appropriate by the regulators for bat CoVs.
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biosafety_level -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The media is to blame to some extent. Many journalists writing about this have no science background or insight of China & had written little about neither pre-covid
There are also lots of second-hand reporting, so journalists are merely repeating rumors masquerading as evidence
PaperclipAI
@xiruxi
Cites an opinion, calls it a fact. Then calls it evidence.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
This breathtaking book is bound to be the bible for science journalists worldwide. It covers general principles & many beats with a global perspective
Love the title of the epilogue by @tomzellerjr: Stay curious and question everything
That’s what science journalism is about!
KSJ at MIT
@KSJatMIT
Looking for practical advice and insights from the world’s best science writers? Check out “A Tactical Guide to Science Journalism” edited by @KSJatMIT's @deborahblum @ashleythesmart @tomzellerjr. Take a look at what’s inside:🧵
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
KSJ at MIT
@KSJatMIT
Looking for practical advice and insights from the world’s best science writers? Check out “A Tactical Guide to Science Journalism” edited by @KSJatMIT's @deborahblum @ashleythesmart @tomzellerjr. Take a look at what’s inside:🧵
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Please do not make assumptions about an area of complexity science for which you have demonstrated a total lack of basic understanding.
No, zoonotic theory doesn’t imply that you get a pandemic—or even an epidemic or an outbreak—when you put “2 sick animals in the same place”.
Bob Apposite
@BobApposite
Keep in mind, though, the "zoonotic" theory implies it's not "challenging" at all.
It implies that simply combining 2 sick animals in the same space can make it ... -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You are incorrect. The list above entails lots of work. Much of it has been published, or publicized in conferences. Some are indeed ongoing and/or in the process of writing up.
Science is a slow and incremental process, especially when involving animal experiments in BSL3.
BiotechObserver
@BiotechObserver
That must be the most unproductive research lab in human history.
But even the miniscule list you just produced (from where? Who knows) was not publicly shared!!!!! -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Contexts matter!
In the context we are discussing, the biosafety committee at the Wuhan institute explicitly required that the culturing of bat coronaviruses be done in BSL2 cabinets, not a dentist’s office👇
My @techreview story: twitter.com/janeqiuchina/status/1491445332089384960
g∘f : X → Z
@pseudorandompi
Do BSL2 requirements mandate the use of BSCs for all or even any specimens or samples? Or is the use of BSCs optional at BSL2 labs?
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Indeed. In light of the pandemic, scientists, including virologists, are working towards raising the biosafety standards. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.
Science is a process. So are governance and oversight of science.
Please see the following tweets in the thread 👇
Louis R Nemzer
@BiophysicsFL
The question shouldn't be "was this a good analogy?".
The question should be "were the safety protocols sufficient?" -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
This is an important point. The people complaining about biosafety and containment rarely have relevant expertise.
No competent virologist would ever work with a potential human pathogen in a “dentist’s office” without a biosafety cabinet.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Virologists have discredited the analogy by @R_H_Ebright who is not a virologist
Please do not uncritically cite the wrong comparison
BSL2 involves working in cabinets with air filtration and under negative pressure to keep pathogens inside. No dentist work in such cabinets
1/
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
Some scientists have tried to explain what BL2 is like to non-scientists. @R_H_Ebright has compared it to a dentist's office.
But I think you need to have worked at BL2 to know exactly how inappropriate it is for handling airborne SARS-like viruses. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Virologists have discredited the analogy by @R_H_Ebright who is not a virologist
Please do not uncritically cite the wrong comparison
BSL2 involves working in cabinets with air filtration and under negative pressure to keep pathogens inside. No dentist work in such cabinets
1/
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
Some scientists have tried to explain what BL2 is like to non-scientists. @R_H_Ebright has compared it to a dentist's office.
But I think you need to have worked at BL2 to know exactly how inappropriate it is for handling airborne SARS-like viruses.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s not uncommon for labs worldwide to culture uncharacterized animal viruses in BSL2 facilities.
In US, some contagious animal CoVs that can infect human cells in a petri dish, including deadly pig viruses originated in bats, are—like Shi’s viruses—designated BSL-2 agents.
2/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Many virologists, including @R_H_Ebright and @angie_rasmussen, are advocating global reevaluation of biosafety standards for animal viruses with unknown risks
“The pandemic has changed that risk-benefit equation,” says Rasmussen
My @techreview story: twitter.com/janeqiuchina/status/1491445332089384960
3/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
All the virologists I talked to in US, Europe, Australia and Singapore said that growing viruses designated as BSL2 agents is invariably carried out in BSL2 cabinets
This is also explicitly required by the biosafety committee at the Wuhan lab for growing bat coronaviruses👇
4/
Richard H. Ebright
@R_H_Ebright
The only mandated requirements for BSL-2 are lock on door, screens on windows, uncarpeted floor, sturdy furniture, sink, eyewash, availability of device for sterilization/decontamination, and availability of gown, glasses, and gloves; cdc.gov/labs/pdf/CDC-BiosafetymicrobiologicalBiomedicalLa…).
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
SiggyRose
@SiggyRose1
In Germany, teaching the Holocaust is mandatory. It includes visits to concentration camp, museums, etc. They don’t shy away from their own ugly history. Yet the kids aren’t damaged; they’re strengthened, matured, humbled. US needs to do same re slavery. Not that complicated.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I was a mol biologist and regularly worked in BSL2 cabinets.
@Ayjchan was also a mol biologist. The question is: Is she dishonest (if she does know the difference) or is she incompetent (if she doesn’t)?
How about @rowanjacobsen who uncritically quoted it in @techreview story? -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Ehsan Masood
@EhsanMasood
Huge congrats to @nature colleague @amymaxmen - and a link to her long-read on a century of research that shows how discrimination, low wages, limited labour protections, a lack of affordable housing and education -- all contribute to disease: www.nature.com/immersive/d41586-021-00943-x/index.html
nature
@Nature
Congratulations to Nature's @amymaxmen for an honourable mention at the @NIHCMfoundation awards for her piece on the deadly toll of inequality. Read the full article here: go.nature.com/3xGaxry
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s not a matter of choice. The team, for instance, didn’t manage to isolate SHC014 virus. They only had its genomic sequence. So synthesizing was the only option
If they had the virus, then it would be much easier just to cut and swap.
It’s really hard to get virus from bats
Andrew Tan
@andrewtanyongyi
So why isn't it easier to synthesize as in the Nat Med 2015, than the cloning technique in Shi's swapping PLoS pathogens? Can't one just order the desired spike sequence from a company?
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Cloning is a generic term regardless whether you have to resort to synthetic biology or not
In 2015 Nat Med paper, the spike sequence of SCH014 was synthesized and then cloned into a SARS-CoV clone
Sequencing is routinely used for confirmation at each step before moving forward
Andrew Tan
@andrewtanyongyi
Ah, ok, if the swapping was done by cloning of an existing virus, then it may not be used to introduce an fcs. I'd assumed they'd synthesized DNA sequences of the novel spikes.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I was trying to give Andrew a sense how big the spike protein is.
When we say swapping, it’s obviously swapping by cloning, and sequencing is always used to confirm you are getting what you think you are getting before moving forward. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You have totally misunderstood
Before covid, Shi had worked with only the following live bat viruses. All were close relatives of SARS1 & none could have caused the pandemic: twitter.com/janeqiuchina/status/1491445332089384960
- 3 natural isolates
- 3 synthesized from genomic sequences
- a dozen chimeras
Wick 🥃
@imUrB00gieman
Even the nay sayers admit the facts.
“Leaning from BARIC, Shi swapped spike of WIV1 with that from newly identified sequences of bat CoVs”
COVID WAS MANUFACTURED IN THE WUHAN INSTITUTE of VIROLOGY… 😡😡😡 -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You understanding is incorrect. The spike consists of 1,200 or so amino acids. When Shi swapped the spike of WIV1 with that of SCH014, we are talking about the swapping of the entire 1,200 amino acids.
Nothing within the spike would change. No FCS could be introduced this way.
Andrew Tan
@andrewtanyongyi
If I understand swapping spikes means you can put a quite arbitrary spike sequence in the WIV1 backbone. Suppose you have a spike where there is SLLRSTSQSI, if you replace the whole spike with another spike where that sequence is instead SLLRRSRRSI, you'd have introduced an fcs.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
As I said, FCS is part of the spike. It lies between S1 and S2 subdomains.
You can’t introduce an FCS by swapping the entire spikes, like what Shi did, that do not have it.
Conversely, you don’t need to swap spikes to insert an FCS.
Andrew Tan
@andrewtanyongyi
Why can't you introduce an fcs by swapping spikes?
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
As someone who was a molecular biologist for a decade, I don’t find that surprising.
First, Shi was a new kid on the block in 2013 when she started to conveive viral genetics experiments—after the team had isolated the first bat CoV—whereas Baric had done that for decades.
1/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
That was lots of work already, especially the animal experiments
Most people don’t realise how interesting & important SCH014 results are: a virus that is so similar to SARS1 but might be causing disease in a totally different way, and existing drugs and vaccines don’t work
4/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Example of SHC014: a fascinating 🦇 virus that Shi discovered a decade ago in Yunnan at the birthplace of the original SARS virus.
It’s 95% identical to SARS virus, but its spike is totally different. Pseudoviruses coated with the SHC014 spikes couldn’t enter human cells.
25/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s important to figure out how SCH014 makes animals sick and what factors other than spikes are crucial for determining a virus’s emergent potential
Those were Shi’s preoccupation before pandemic. So, no, I’m not surprised FCS didn’t top her agenda
5/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Conclusions:spikes are not the only factor that determines if a virus can make an animal sick
We can’t asses emergent potential of viruses using only pseudovirus assays or predictions based on genomic sequences & molecular modeling
We need live viruses & use genetics tools
32/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Before pandemic,Shi’s team had worked with only the following live bat viruses,all close relatives of SARS1: twitter.com/janeqiuchina/status/1491445332089384960
- 3 natural isolates
- 3 synthesized from genomic sequences
- a dozen chimeras using as the backbone bat viruses that were close relatives of SARS1 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Slava Bobrov
@slava__bobrov
Brain cell forming new connections:
#neuroscience -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Slava Bobrov
@slava__bobrov
Cell division step by step:
#biology -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Slava Bobrov
@slava__bobrov
Brain cells in two different micro-compartments are trying to connect with each other:
#neuroscience -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Slava Bobrov
@slava__bobrov
Neurons in the hippocampus are shown using the brainbow technique:
#neuroscience by G. Dunn -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Richard Van Noorden
@Richvn
I was curious about two surveys on COVID-19 scientists' experiences of harassment. @nature and @NewsfromScience asked different pop'ns, hence different %s. But both suggest scientists more frequently in news-media are more likely to report harassment (1/2)
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-00936-4 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jason Hickel
@jasonhickel
3. Finally, capitalism is notable for precluding democratic decision-making. Even in countries that prize political democracy, democratic principles are rarely allowed to operate in the sphere of production, where decisions are made overwhelmingly by those who control capital.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jason Hickel
@jasonhickel
The result is that decisions about what to produce, for what purposes, for whose benefit, and under what conditions are generally made in the narrow interests of the capitalist class (workers, the people actually *doing* the production, rarely get a voice at all).
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jason Hickel
@jasonhickel
It is worth pondering how our production priorities (and our treatment of labour and nature) might be different under conditions of economic democracy. Existing evidence suggests that democratic conditions lead to less exploitation, more equality, and more care for ecology.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Clue to ageing?
Despite different lifespans, mammals of all sizes have the same no. of mutations, ~3,200, at the end of their lives
Mice have 800 mutations a yr & live only four years. Dogs have 249 annual mutations, lion 160, giraffe 99, and humans 47
www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-61045950 -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Climate change might have influenced early human migration—and possibly contributed to the emergence of modern-day human species around 300,000 years ago.
“This is another brick in the wall to support the role of climate in shaping human ancestry.”
go.nature.com/3xAOX7L -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Stewart Brand
@stewartbrand
Markoff's WHOLE EARTH book "briefly noted" in the New Yorker.
(It's a good feature--200 short recommendations every year.)
www.newyorker.com/magazine/2022/04/25/whole-earth-the-gen… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Scientists under attack: 38% of researches reported harassment, from personal insults, attacks on their competence & integrity, to death threats—often related to covid origins. Deeply reported by @cathleenogrady
Survey data: www.science.org/pb-assets/science.abq1755/wos_analysis-16…
1/
www.science.org/content/article/overwhelmed-hate-covid-19…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Who are the abusers?Those who see scientists as bad people who must be stopped for the good of the world
Those who monetize attention and have, say, a book to sell
Finally, pundits, politicians & commentators, who know fights drive visibility & lead to more followers+impact
2/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
By encouraging public communication, academic institutions are exposing researchers to a hostile environment. But most regard this as a personal problem and haven’t invested the resources to protect them
👇Organizations that offer help & resources for victims of online abuse
3/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Battling against powerful & persuasive misinformation during covid is a Sisyphean task, says @CT_Bergstrom
Misinformation is a symptom of social ills. The real disease is polarization and a political system and societal climate that rewards it. @kakape
www.science.org/content/article/studying-fighting-misinfo… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Important question posed by @sciencecohen: Can discovering viruses in the wild help prevent the next pandemic?
Global Virome Project aims to find all the viruses in the wild, at a cost of >US$4 billion.
Not everybody agrees it’s good value for money.
www.science.org/content/article/hunt-new-viruses-bat-trap…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
While discovering new viruses could shed light on their evolution,some scientists doubt its value in pandemic prediction because viruses are extremely diverse and ephemeral
Targeted surveillance at animal-human interface might be much more cost-effective
go.nature.com/3KSHFjz -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
Once again I am compelled to remind you that bidirectional zooanthroponotic transmission (animals to humans to animals to humans and so on) is more common than we think it is.
Just because we aren’t looking closely enough doesn’t mean it’s not happening.
www.freep.com/story/news/health/2022/04/17/michigan-covid… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
Because SARS-CoV-2 is an infectious virus, that means that your actions can impact & cause harm to others. So the key to travelling during the pandemic is to make sure you have lots of options. Choose the options that keep both yourself & those around you as safe as possible.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
2. I feel comfortable travelling in part because I know my own risk level (and my spouse, who is coming with) & we don't live with anyone at high risk (elderly, immunocompromised, etc). YMMV but it's important to assess risk of your household, not just what you can tolerate.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
This doesn’t have to be as hard as some make it out to be. Risk reduction is additive and by layering on as many precautions as possible, I can significantly reduce the likelihood of exposure and infection. I will do that as I resume getting back out into the world.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
Lots of anecdotes about people getting COVID at in-person conferences. I went to one last week in Boston and next week am going to one in Portugal. Both require negative testing for international travel.
Here’s how I plan to not get COVID. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Timothy Caulfield
@CaulfieldTim
People Are Willing to Excuse Lies, Misinformation That ‘Might’ Come True theswaddle.com/people-are-willing-to-excuse-lies-misinfor… @Saumya_Kalia
"Trend was more prominent when false statement fit with individual political views."
Study: "more inclined to share falsehood on social media..." by @BA_Helgason et al -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi Paul Which part of “I asked several scientists the questions and got the same answer” & “it’s a collective decision” among myself & editors at @techreview “it’s not important part of the story” that you don’t understand?
I’d suggest you work on your inadequate literacy skills
Paul Sykes
@PaulPsykes
The FCS is not an important part of the story? Which scientists said that? Let me guess - the authors of proximal origins. COI anyone ? This is why science journalists are not taken seriously - they avoid tough questions and just advance the zoonatic narrative blindly
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi Adrian Please bear in mind that what appears in the published story is only a small part of my research. It’s similar to academic papers
I did ask the question and talked to my editors at @techreview about it. It’s a collective decision it’s not an important part of the story
Adrian J
@humblesci
Another opportunity missed by @janeqiuchina was to ask Shi why she did not mention a novel fcs in the SARS-CoV-2 genome in Zhou et al. Not plausible that she 'missed noticing it' as this site would be a key section of the genome to review
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You should stop making assumptions about things you have no first-hand information of:covid’s origins, China and me
I asked several scientists the question and got the same answer. I told my editors at @techreview. It’s a collective decision it’s not important part of the story
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
These are questions to which there are no government-approved answers a journalist based in China can hope to publish and still maintain their personal safety.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I don’t want to engage with you on this because of your unethical and unprofessional behaviour.
I did ask several scientists the question and got the same answer. I told my editors at @techreview in writing. It’s a collective decision it’s not an important part of the story.
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
So @janeqiuchina didn’t want to answer my question whether she asked Shi Zhengli about proposed experiments in a 2018 DARPA proposal to insert furin cleavage sites into SARS-like viruses, in her recent profile of Shi in @techreview, and whether those experiments…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You are wrong again. You should stop making assumptions about things you have no deep insight of: covid’s origins, China and me
Shi did not seek permission from Chinese authorities. She’s deeply unhappy about the way they have dealt with the issues. She was exercising her agency
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
One thing we can be pretty sure of: Shi Zhengli had to get permission from Chinese authorities to give this extended interview to @janeqiuchina. That means authorities must have considered Jane to be the right reporter to do the story, and if so, the question is why…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Fascinating golden tortoise beetle, a native American species
Its color changes—from reddish-brown with black spots to brilliant, mirror-like gold, earning it the nickname "goldbug"—through development, during mating, and during times of disturbance (eg, when touched by a human)
Amazing Nature
@AmazingNature00
The Golden Tortoise. Awesome Nature
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Deborah Blum
@deborahblum
Take a bow, everyone. These terrific fact-checking workshops do @KSJatMIT proud every time!
Brooke Borel
@brookeborel
Big thanks to our speakers @Plwolter @J_Roberts8 @ashleythesmart and @bradscriber, our 20 facilitators, everyone at @ScicommX (especially @SaadLotfey) for running an amazing show, and @deborahblum and @htpotter for the support.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Brooke Borel
@brookeborel
It was nice to see some of you for @KSJatMIT's fact-checking workshop today! Glad my voice held up. We plan to have more workshops later this year, so follow KSJ's social media account and check the website for updates: ksjfactcheck.org/workshops/
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You sympathy is misplaced. You’re making incorrect assertion about my situation of which you have absolutely no idea
You peddled misinformation on AIDS origins. You’re long-term climate change denier, and widely discredited in UK.Anyone engaging with you should bear this in mind
Matt Ridley
@mattwridley
Yes, @janeqiuchina deserves our sympathy. She is in an impossible situation, unable to ask the right questions or expect true answers without fear of serious consequences for her safety. I hope the editors who publish her work bear this in mind.
Alina Chan
@Ayjchan
These are questions to which there are no government-approved answers a journalist based in China can hope to publish and still maintain their personal safety.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
This is an excellent point. Some top scientists have contributed to misinformation.
But good journalists don’t simply regurgitate what we are told. We need to critically vet the scientific validity of the assertions and potential bias—without which we can be easily manipulated.
Andrew Tan
@andrewtanyongyi
Perhaps one can't blame the journalists too much. Bloom is a top scientist. It's too bad he's spread nonsense on some issues. Unfortunately, some top scientists have contributed misinformation in this pandemic - Baltimore, Montagnier, co-authors of the Bloom et al Science letter.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
What you meant was you find it hard to be polite to people who write articles not in line with your preferred narrative
Engaging in smearing campaign against someone you don’t agree with is unethical & unprofessional
This is my last word before you learn how to behave properly
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
Jane, I find it very difficult to be polite to someone I do not consider to be honest. So I will let other, more polite colleagues ask you the same question, and hope that you will answer them. Otherwise it would appear you are trying to avoid the question.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Richard Sever
@cshperspectives
"The pandemic has given rise to a class of influencers [with] a veneer of credibility...who build conspiracy theories...almost without exception, the[y] feel they have been wronged in some way” www.nytimes.com/2022/04/03/technology/robert-malone-covid…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi Michael You have made the following baseless assertion about me.
“@janeqiuchina spent hours with the Wuhan Institute of Virology’s “bat woman” and didn’t ask the question.”
Please delete the original tweet and apologize to me. Then I might tell you what I know.
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
So you did ask her? Then what’s the answer? It’s a very important question.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Hi Michael What’s the basis for the assertion of yours below? Please do correct me if I’m wrong, but I don’t recall you ever asked me.
“@janeqiuchina spent hours with the Wuhan Institute of Virology’s “bat woman” and didn’t ask the question.”
@mbalter — investigations and commentary
@mbalter
@Ayjchan has asked this question over and over again with no response. @janeqiuchina spent hours with the Wuhan Institute of Virology’s “bat woman” and didn’t ask the question. Peter Daszak is rarely asked. UNC’s Ralph Baric refuses to answer any questions at all. Why?
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
New fossils suggest our species arrived in Europe 54,000 yrs ago, 12,000 yrs earlier than thought. They might have mingled—and mated with—Neanderthals for a much longer time than we thought before Neanderthals went extinct 40,000 yrs ago. @BBCPallab
www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-60305218 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Magdalena Skipper
@Magda_Skipper
Companies are marketing polygenic risk scores as part of IVF well ahead of a full understanding of the potential benefits or dangers www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-00787-z
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
What did we learn from giving people #sarscov2?
The 1st challenge study report 🆕 @NatureMedicine
www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01780-9
—Viral load is not correlated w/ symptoms
—Shedding occurs at high levels irrespective of symptoms
—Rapid antigen tests are extremely useful
and much more -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Slava Bobrov
@slava__bobrov
Hungry microorganism attacks and eats a single cell:
#biology -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
MicrobesInfect
@MicrobesInfect
A genomic analysis suggests that there are probably dozens of unknown species of horseshoe bats in southeast Asia, some of which could host new viruses.
Study suggests ~40% of horseshoe bats in the region have yet to be formally described.
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-00776-2 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Sarah Kaplan
@sarahkaplan48
Salmon travel deep into the Pacific. As it warms, many ‘don’t come back.’ Now @NOAA scientists are scouring nearly a million square miles of ocean, with researchers from Canada and Russia, to find out why. By @partlowj www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2022/03/28/sal… #climate
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Carl Bovis
@CarlBovisNature
Egrets.... I've had a few...
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Slava Bobrov
@slava__bobrov
Single-celled Lacrymaria olor attacks another cell:
#biology -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“To live with the coronavirus, we cannot be blind to its movements.”
“…governments are shutting their eyes to the danger. If this trend continues, the new normal is going to look a lot like the false comfort of ignorance.” @Nature
go.nature.com/3NkPlgi -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Marion Koopmans, publications: https://pure.eur.nl
@MarionKoopmans
Interesting perspective from ecologists on virus emergence, drawing a paralel with biological invasion science www.cell.com/action/showPdf?pii=S0169-5347(20)30134-8
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Maria Van Kerkhove
@mvankerkhove
What happens when we allow the virus to circulate at such an intense level.👇The virus continues to evolve and more variants are expected. Recombinants are also expected… as we have been explaining for a very long time.
Vaccines AND, not vaccines only
#covid19 @WHO @DrTedros
World Health Organization (WHO)
@WHO
What happens when #covid19 variants combine? Dr @mvankerkhove explains ⬇️
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Ed Yong is not here
@edyong209
🚨I wrote a short piece about the COVID funding collapse--the latest example of the panic-neglect cycle that public health people have bemoaned for decades, and that's now spinning at frankly absurd speed *in the middle of a pandemic*. 1/
www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2022/03/congress-covid… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I just joined Science Writing News Roundup's membership on @buymeacoffee! 🎉
Science Writing News Roundup is a newsletter for people interested in science writing. It’s a great service for science writers worldwide!
You can join here — www.buymeacoffee.com/sciencewriting -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Matt Shipman
@ShipLives
Science writers!
* Are you grappling with a challenge other sci writers may relate to?
* Did you learn something others may benefit from?
* Are there issues you think sci writers could/should address or explore?
Submit a proposal for @ScienceWriters 2022!
sciencewriters2022.org -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Thomas Levenson, Zṓiarchos
@TomLevenson
I am very glad that I’m away from campus this term.
This is a shockingly bad policy response
Kate Darling
@grok_
MIT no longer has a mask requirement. Our research group discussed whether to keep masks on for indoor meetings so that everyone feels comfortable attending. Today, an email from the Vice Chancellor says that’s not allowed.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Amy Maxmen, PhD
@amymaxmen
Just so we're clear, CDC's unmasking policy shifts public health decisions from them to various bosses, who mainly have no infectious disease background.
Kate Darling
@grok_
MIT no longer has a mask requirement. Our research group discussed whether to keep masks on for indoor meetings so that everyone feels comfortable attending. Today, an email from the Vice Chancellor says that’s not allowed.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
MIT Technology Review
@techreview
We may never know if covid-19 came from a lab. But now scientists at the Wuhan Institute of Virology tell their side of the story. www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Camille Bromley
@chameauleon
"Competition, prizes and awards are part of a patriarchal construct that destroys love and creativity." 💖 Ocean Vuong 💖 thecreativeindependent.com/people/2017-05-16-ocean-vuong-…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Tara Haelle #ReadBannedBooks
@tarahaelle
“If you want a strong universal immunization program that people can count on, you have to have a vibrant safety net, and the safety net is about to collapse.” —Renee Gentry
I've reported this story for 4+ months. It's important. Please read and share.
www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/why-is-it-so-h… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Tara Haelle #ReadBannedBooks
@tarahaelle
If you read my National Geographic article on vaccine injury & compensation, I've just published a (very, very lengthy) companion piece in Medium, sharing what had to be cut (for length) from the Nat Geo piece & a little bit about the reporting process.
tarahaelle.medium.com/its-time-to-open-pandora-s-box-for-… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
David Gorski, MD, PhD
@gorskon
From @tarahaelle, an important piece and more evidence that, contrary to what antivaxxers claim, vaccine advocates do recognize that on rare occasions vaccines can cause harm and we seek to acknowledge the harm and compensate it when it does. www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/why-is-it-so-h…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“Much of the distorted science…was shaped by the values of a certain kind of man. To change that, she insists, we need more diverse scientists: “a mixture of sexes, sexualities, genders, skin colours, classes, cultures, abilities and ages”.” By @josiegz
www.theguardian.com/books/2022/mar/11/bitch-by-lucy-cooke… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
NEW: I’m not sure people appreciate quite how bad the Covid situation is in Hong Kong, nor what might be around the corner.
First, an astonishing chart.
After keeping Covid at bay for two years, Omicron has hit HK and New Zealand, but the outcomes could not be more different. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Patrick deHahn
@patrickdehahn
Finally got to read this by @janeqiuchina, and wow. Incredible.
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Tara Haelle #ReadBannedBooks
@tarahaelle
The best kind of journalism is when it’s all shades of gray and the journalist takes the time to examine each of those shades.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The story is not about providing answers. You’ll have to make up your own minds. It’s for sophisticated readers open to new perspectives & appreciate the world in 50 shades of grey.
It’s about how this deeply entrenched controversy has come about & how we can move forward
4/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Marc Owen Jones
@marcowenjones
This is an incredible read.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Katya Zimmer
@katarinazimmer
If you haven't yet, you *have* to read this incredible reporting by @janeqiuchina 🦇🦇
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Katherine J. Wu, Ph.D.
@KatherineJWu
It took so long to raise awareness about long COVID—with the U.S.'s new focus on severe disease, is it about to slip away from us again?
I wrote about long COVID's unknowns, and why we need to push on them more than ever.
www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2022/03/long-covid-ris… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
⚠️It’s speculation masquerading as evidence that I take issue with, not speculation per se.
The problem arises when Twitter influencers conflate evidence with speculation and spin an elaborate tale based on incorrect assumptions—which is then amplified by credulous journalists.
Jamie Metzl
@JamieMetzl
Nasty and unfair Twitter messages like this should be avoided. ALL articles & studies re #covid19 origins contain an element of speculation because the Chinese government has engaged in a massive cover-up preventing sufficient access to relevant records, data and personnel.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Antonio Regalado
@antonioregalado
THE Malik Peiris of Hong Kong who identified the original SARS virus in 2003.
Everyone watching Hong Kong spike in covid-19 cases...perhaps as a prelude to mainland allowing virus in.
Roland Pease
@PeaseRoland
For two years, Hong Kong maintained an impressive grip on COVID - a total of only 213 deaths until the start of February - then case rates went off scale.
For Science in Action, I've been talking to @HKUniversity's Malik Peiris about what's changed. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Exactly! It does not appear to be Vicount Ridley’s strength to get facts straight. This is just the latest example.
One must wonder: How many similar such examples of getting things mixed up in his books?
@Ayjchan -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
This is shockingly rich coming from someone who doesn’t understand the nuance and the intricacies of the science surrounding COVID-19’s origins and has written a problematic, discredited story on lab leak for @VanityFair that conflates evidence and speculation.
Katherine Eban
@KatherineEban
I wrote in defense of @janequichina when her article on Shi Zhengli 1st pubbed. But this defensiveness/ condescension a v. bad look when critical facts are at stake. WIV removed its online database in Sept 2019 as Peter Daszak confirmed. @techreview needs to issue a correction.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The story—vetted by two top US fact checkers and repeatedly by half a dozen TR editors—is watertight and contains no mistake.
You have no first-hand information and have no idea what are in those databases
You need to understand the difference between evidence and speculation.
Gilles Demaneuf
@gdemaneuf
@janeqiuchina could you, as asked before, correct the wrong date that was mentioned in your piece for the main database going offline?
Somehow, despite me giving you the full details and all the records, you invented a February 20 date that better fits the narrative.
@techreview -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Please don’t be presumptuous about where I got my information from. Thanks!
Second-hand reporting—in which people do journalism and write books based on rumors and unverified information—is a root cause of misinformation.
My story doesn’t entail such questionable practice. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thanks for your advice, Paul! But please don’t insult the pigs. They are decent and smart animals.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I can see that has touched a nerve.
I suspect stressing the difference between evidence and speculation—which is absolutely crucial for the origins debate—makes uncomfortable reading for someone who has written a book based on speculation and unverified information.
@Ayjchan
Matt Ridley
@mattwridley
Can you show us the independent documentary evidence of the database closing on 20 February 2020, which the fact checkers presumably were shown?
Otherwise, to paraphrase your patronising tweet, "you need to understand the difference between evidence and assertion".
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The story—vetted by two top US fact checkers and repeatedly by half a dozen TR editors—is watertight and contains no mistake.
You have no first-hand information and have no idea what are in those databases
You need to understand the difference between evidence and speculation.
Gilles Demaneuf
@gdemaneuf
@janeqiuchina could you, as asked before, correct the wrong date that was mentioned in your piece for the main database going offline?
Somehow, despite me giving you the full details and all the records, you invented a February 20 date that better fits the narrative.
@techreview -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s incorrect. At the very minimum, fact checkers vet the accuracy of hard facts.
Good fact checkers also check if there is anything wrong with the nuance, the context, and the framing.
In some cases, they conduct independent interviews with sources quoted in the story. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The story—vetted by two top US fact checkers and repeatedly by half a dozen TR editors—is watertight and contains no mistake.
You have no first-hand information and have no idea what are in those databases
You need to understand the difference between evidence and speculation.
Gilles Demaneuf
@gdemaneuf
@janeqiuchina could you, as asked before, correct the wrong date that was mentioned in your piece for the main database going offline?
Somehow, despite me giving you the full details and all the records, you invented a February 20 date that better fits the narrative.
@techreview -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Hank Greely
@HankGreelyLSJU
David Bennett, the "pig heart transplant patient", died. www.cnn.com/2022/03/09/health/pig-heart-transplant-death/… I hope that his experiment bears good fruit, for others though it did not do so (for long) for him. Made it for two months w/what sounds like some decent quality of life—but never out of the hospital
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Ron Rosenbaum
@RonRosenbaum1
I met the brilliant Jane Qiu when we were both on a Cambridge (UK) fellowship. She is a geat and devoted reporter and researcher.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Lesley Evans Ogden
@ljevanso
Fascinating long read by @janeqiuchina
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
3-min @BBCWorld video of civilians fleeing Russian invasion—the parents,the toddlers,the elderly,the disabled, and the pets (including puppies)—and their bravery, dignity and anger. @BowenBBC
“She was as dignified as a woman striding to the park”
😭😭
www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-europe-60641873 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
george church
@geochurch
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
There are critical diaglogues to be had about preprints on #originofcovid & its coverage
But to attribute ill intent to honest, albeit imperfect, efforts, and to compare the scientists & journos to Elizabeth Holmes is disgraceful
Quotes👇from story by @antonioregalado
@Ayjchan -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
There are critical diaglogues to be had about preprints on #originofcovid & its coverage
But to attribute ill intent to honest, albeit imperfect, efforts, and to compare the scientists & journos to Elizabeth Holmes is disgraceful
Quotes👇from story by @antonioregalado
@Ayjchan -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
B. Duygu Özpolat, Ph.D.
@biyolokum
Fascinating read.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
3-min @BBCWorld video of civilians fleeing Russian invasion—the parents,the toddlers,the elderly,the disabled, and the pets (including puppies)—and their bravery, dignity and anger. @BowenBBC
“She was as dignified as a woman striding to the park”
😭😭
www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-europe-60641873 -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
3-min video of civilians fleeing the Russian invasion—the toddlers, the elderly, the disabled, and the pets (including puppies)—and their bravery, dignity and anger.
“She was as dignified as a woman striding to the park.”
😭😭
www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-europe-60641873 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Tom Cheshire
@Chesh
A death rate now far higher than the darkest days of pandemic in UK
Nathan Ruser
@Nrg8000
In the last week, more people have died of COVID in Hong Kong, a city of 7mil people, than in India, a subcontinent with 1.4bil people.
Hong Kong is being hit by the virus right now worse than anywhere in the world has so far during this pandemic. -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
There are critical diaglogues to be had about preprints on #originofcovid & its coverage
But to attribute ill intent to honest, albeit imperfect, efforts, and to compare the scientists & journos to Elizabeth Holmes is disgraceful
Quotes👇from story by @antonioregalado
@Ayjchan -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
There are critical diaglogues to be had about preprints on #originofcovid & its coverage
But to attribute ill intent to honest, albeit imperfect, efforts, and to compare the scientists & journos to Elizabeth Holmes is disgraceful
Quotes👇from story by @antonioregalado
@Ayjchan -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Yes, yes, I’d second your recommendation highly. I went to the workshop three years ago. Learned so much from @JacquiB. Learned so much from fellow participants
I miss the deep blue desert sky and the gigantic cactuses
I’d love to go to the workshop on Madeline Island one day. -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
eileen chengyin chow
@chowleen
Insects have startled awake
for days —
Now, this moment,
frogs join in song.
If one could just bask in
moon and breeze —
And not fuss over duties of
court and home.
驚蟄已數日 聞蛙初此時
能如喜風月 不必問官私
Zhao Fan 趙蕃 (1143-1229)
#everynightapoem #節氣 #mytranslation -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Polina M. Pompliano
@polinapompliano
Shi Zhengli has spent years at the Wuhan Institute of Virology researching coronaviruses that live in bats. Her work has come under fire as the world tries to understand where COVID-19 came from. (@janeqiuchina)
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Meg seanchaibeag
@seanchaibeag
ICYMI, this is a brilliant thread about Covid, bat viruses, what goes on in a viral research lab, etc. The article upthread is excellent too.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A long story,a long🧵:@techreview
5️⃣ How should work on viruses of🦇origins be regulated?
6️⃣ How did a @washingtonpost op-ed launch lab leak claims?
7️⃣ What happens when mistrust is left unchecked?
8️⃣ How have the past two years marked China’s🦇woman?
Bonus: trip to a🦇cave
3/ -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
This new thread contains 62 tweets: threadreaderapp.com/thread/1491445332089384960.html
I’m having troubles adding more. There may be a bug on Twitter. But it’s at least an improvement and covers all the article content.
Thank you again for your interest.
🇺🇸🌻🇺🇦#🟦 Annabeth Krasnov Amerine 🇺🇦🌻🇺🇸
@WarmGingerTea
Thanks! I didn’t see anything beyond 44 even before I used Thread Reader. This is what I get when I go through the thread even this morning — responses start.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Thread Reader App
@threadreaderapp
Hi! here is your unroll: threadreaderapp.com/thread/1491445332089384960.html See you soon. 🤖
-
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c…Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A long story,a long🧵:@techreview
5️⃣ How should work on viruses of🦇origins be regulated?
6️⃣ How did a @washingtonpost op-ed launch lab leak claims?
7️⃣ What happens when mistrust is left unchecked?
8️⃣ How have the past two years marked China’s🦇woman?
Bonus: trip to a🦇cave
3/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
The story is not about providing answers. You’ll have to make up your own minds. It’s for sophisticated readers open to new perspectives & appreciate the world in 50 shades of grey.
It’s about how this deeply entrenched controversy has come about & how we can move forward
4/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Example of SHC014: a fascinating 🦇 virus that Shi discovered a decade ago in Yunnan at the birthplace of the original SARS virus.
It’s 95% identical to SARS virus, but its spike is totally different. Pseudoviruses coated with the SHC014 spikes couldn’t enter human cells.
25/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Conclusions:spikes are not the only factor that determines if a virus can make an animal sick
We can’t asses emergent potential of viruses using only pseudovirus assays or predictions based on genomic sequences & molecular modeling
We need live viruses & use genetics tools
32/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
What did the cables really say?
Lack of trained workers could “impede research”, but “opens up even more opportunities for expert change”, noting Wuhan lab’s ability “to undertake productive research despite limitations.”
foia.state.gov/Search/Results.aspx?searchText=&beginDate=…
44/
www.washingtonpost.com/context/read-the-state-department-…Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Shi finds such allegations “baseless and appalling”:“If that’s what they think,then there is nothing we can do to convince them otherwise”
Some in the West agree:“I’m quite distressed by people throwing this kind of extremely serious allegations around,” says Nancy Connell
48/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
But to be fair to those who don’t trust Chinese institutions, China’s questionable credibility and curious missteps haven’t helped:
- Massive coverup during SARS
- Obfuscation about early covid cases
- Ministry rules: scientists have to seek approval to publish covid work
49/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
I have no affiliation with any Chinese institutions.I don’t write or publish Chinese-language articles in China
I only write in English & publish in top UK/US outlets.I’m totally independent and have been under no constraint while researching & writing Covid-related stories
68/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
A big thank you to all the researchers who kindly helped me understand the nuance & complexity of the subject matter. Many are not quoted in the story
Thank you @kkakaes for recognizing the potential of my rambling pitch, a superb first edit & feedback on later drafts
🌸🌸
69/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Thank you @AmyNordrum for helping me prepare for online abuse & harassment
I’m also eternally indebted to many friends & colleagues who guided & encouraged me behind the scene—especially through difficult patches and moments of despair—on this incredible journey
🌸🌸
73/FinitoPost not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Solution? Long-term surveillance of wildlife,farmed animals,people who live close to wildlife & work in animal trade
“It can help strengthen capacity building in neglected rural regions. It should be a concerned global effort,”says Fabian Leendertz
We need to work together
54/
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
But Chinese scientists are increasingly wary of international collaboration.
Trained in France, Shi cherishes critical thinking, independent-mindedness, and not following the crowd: “I used to admire the West. I used to think it was a just and meritocratic society.”
55/Post not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“This story by former @KSJatMIT fellow and acclaimed science writer @janeqiuchina is fascinating. But it's also meticulous, fair-minded, insightful - and wholly worth your time”
— Deborah Blum: Pulitzer-winning journalist and director of
@KSJatMIT
twitter.com/janeqiuchina/status/1491445332089384960
61/
Deborah Blum
@deborahblum
This story by former @KSJatMIT fellow and acclaimed science writer @janeqiuchina is fascinating. But it's also meticulous, fair-minded, insightful - and wholly worth your time.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
“I am jealous of @janeqiuchina. She has written the masterpiece I wish I'd been able to do. This is an absolute must-read.”
— Laurie Garrett: Pulitzer-winning journalist, author of The Coming Plague: Newly Emerging Diseases in a World Out of Balance
twitter.com/janeqiuchina/status/1491445332089384960
62/
Laurie Garrett
@Laurie_Garrett
I am jealous of @janeqiuchina . She has written the masterpiece I wish I'd been able to do. This is an absolute must-read. Her 40 hrs of interviews w/much-maligned Shi Zhengli of the Wuhan Inst of Virology on the origins of #sarscov2 & other research.
MORE
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c…
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Testing-3
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Testing-4
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
siewlynwrites
@slwong_writes
A deep dive into the Chinese virologist at the Wuhan Institute of Virology who linked Covid to bats. It shines a light on the human behaviours - including research- that could cause pandemics. #covid19 #science
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Yes, something very strange has happened.
Have you managed see beyond tweet No.44 now? If you click that tweet (link below), it should allow you to see tweets No. 45-73.
x.com/janeqiuchina/status/1499411733034590208
Thank you for your interested.
🇺🇸🌻🇺🇦#🟦 Annabeth Krasnov Amerine 🇺🇦🌻🇺🇸
@WarmGingerTea
Thanks! I didn’t see anything beyond 44 even before I used Thread Reader. This is what I get when I go through the thread even this morning — responses start.
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Liz Highleyman
@LizHighleyman
A fascinating story from @janeqiuchina...
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Hank Greely
@HankGreelyLSJU
Excellent thread, but the article is even better.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Something strange happens to my 73-point thread
Thread Roll stops at No.44,but if you click the tweet (twitter.com/janeqiuchina/status/1499411733034590208),it will take you towards the end
Please let me know if anybody knows what’s going on
Or should I be worried?Are Twitter and CCP trying to censor me?
Thread Reader App
@threadreaderapp
Namaste, the unroll you asked for: threadreaderapp.com/thread/1491445332089384960.html Share this if you think it's interesting. 🤖
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
MIT Technology Review
@techreview
Shi Zhengli has spent years at the Wuhan Institute of Virology researching coronaviruses that live in bats. Her work has come under fire as the world tries to understand where covid-19 came from. www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c…
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Pulitzer Center
@pulitzercenter
Grantee @janeqiuchina was interviewed by @bbcworldservice for her recent story on Shi Zhengli, China's "bat woman" who studies coronaviruses at Wuhan Institute of Technology. Listen to the conversation on Science in Action: www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct1l50
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Kendall Powell
@KendallSciWrite
This is a tour de force by @janeqiuchina in @techreview. Long read, but well worth it for how it lays out the science, the arguments and the personalities.
Meet the scientist at the center of the covid lab leak controversy www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
World Federation of Science Journalists
@WFSJ
Meet the scientist at the center of the covid lab leak controversy
By Jane Qiu (@janeqiuchina @techreview)
#china
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Thomas Levenson, Zṓiarchos
@TomLevenson
Good story.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
John W. Farrell
@JohnWFarrell
Great feature in the latest Technology Review by my T-C colleague @janeqiuchina with her thread below.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Marion Koopmans, publications: https://pure.eur.nl
@MarionKoopmans
interesting perspective, based on doing hours of interviews with staff of Wuhan institute of virology. Sounds very similar to what the WHO team discussed
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
World Federation of Science Journalists
@WFSJ
Meet the scientist at the center of the covid lab leak controversy
By Jane Qiu (@janeqiuchina @techreview)
#china
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Emily Feng 冯哲芸
@EmilyZFeng
Clear-eyed, science-based, and worth a careful read.
Unfortunate that later Chinese government cover-ups of the Huanan market created understandable suspicion about Covid-19's origins, suspicion which seems to have fallen unfairly on the Wuhan Virology Institute.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Tara Haelle #ReadBannedBooks
@tarahaelle
I haven’t read this yet — it’s 10K words from 14 months of reporting — but I can’t wait to read it this weekend. Just a glance tells me this story is the perfect intersection of science, investigative journalism, and the messiness of being human. Kudos to @janeqiuchina!
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Charles Arthur
@charlesarthur
Excellent article on a topic we can’t stop worrying away at. And/or a thread to digest it by.
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
You are a microbiologist. How would we know you have not been secretly working on a programme related to pandemic viruses?
How would we know you are not hiding something related to covid origins?
Why should we trust you based on what you are telling us? -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Do you have unpublished work? If you do, is it because you are hiding it out of malicious intent?
Or is it because you are in the process of writing some data up and for the rest, you simply don’t know how the data are coming together to make a paper yet?
It’s ongoing science -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
It’s spelled out clearly in my article and my thread
- 3 virus isolates
- 3 synthetic viruses from genomic sequences
- A dozen or so chimeras using bat viruses closely related to SARS-CoV-1 as the backbone, only a handful of which can infect humans cells
twitter.com/janeqiuchina/status/1491445332089384960 -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Roland Pease
@PeaseRoland
Interview with @edwardcholmes re new papers on origins of COVID, Wuhan, Huanan market, now available online
www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w3ct1l53
Roland Pease
@PeaseRoland
Just recorded an extended interview with co-author @edwardcholmes on these two new origins paper, and a third by China CDC's George Gao. Eddie was on last week's Science in Action talking about related work on the scale of threat from zoonotic viruses.
See www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w3ct1l52 -
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
That’s great,James! I applied to attend the workshop and just got an email from @KSJatMIT telling me that I’ve been accepted. How wonderful you will facilitate it.Really look forward to it!
I want to learn more and get better at it.There is under-appreciation of its importance
James Gaines
@the_jmgaines
(By the way, shameless plug, but if you're interested in how to fact-check or what writers should know before getting fact-checked, I'll be a facilitator at @KSJatMIT 's upcoming workshop on April 8th!)
-
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Jane Qiu, PhD reposted
James Gaines
@the_jmgaines
If you haven't read this yet, you really should. I helped fact-check!
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
Meet China’s bat woman: She’s spent 18 years studying coronaviruses. She’s traced both SARS and covid to bats. Did she cause the pandemic? Is she the victim of a witch hunt? I spent 14 months trying to find answers. Join me in Wuhan and at a bat cave. 1/n
www.technologyreview.com/2022/02/09/1044985/shi-zhengli-c… -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Jane Qiu, PhD
@janeqiuchina
While Huanan definitely has played a critical role in kickstarting the pandemic, it could be animal-to-human or human-to-human transmission. @Biol4Ever says that a contaminated lab member might have lived near Huanan or went there and caused superspreading. 9/







































































































































































































































