We don't have an AI problem folks. And I'm about to rattle some cages. And yes, I used AI to assist in this piece. But I assure you every thought is mine and as intended.
You see, every election cycle, every technological breakthrough, and every economic proposal shows up carrying the same promise. This one will finally fix us.
Our politicians promise better policy. Technologists promise greater innovation. Economists promise more prosperity. Now the people building artificial intelligence promise abundance, automation, and maybe a check in the mail so nobody has to worry about earning a living again.
We are the wealthiest, best educated, longest living, most connected human beings who have ever existed. A teenager with a phone can find more information in an afternoon than a brilliant scientist could assemble in 1985.
But by most of the measures that track whether people are actually doing well, we’re going backward.
Incidence of anxiety and depression continue to climb. Loneliness has gotten bad enough that public health officials started calling it an epidemic. Trust in institutions, all of them, keeps eroding. Politics has become a form of tribalism, where the other side isn’t mistaken, they’re evil. Basic courtesy has worn thin. We built a culture that treats comfort as a right and responsibility as an imposition someone else should have handled.
You can see it in small things. People board airplanes in pajamas now. I don’t bring that up because sleepwear is destroying civilization. I bring it up because a generation ago there was a shared, unspoken sense that showing up in public meant showing up for other people, and that sense evaporated without anyone voting on it.
So we pursue more money, better tools, more information, more access, and less of whatever it is that makes life feel worth living.
What if we’re trying to solve the wrong problem?
Open a newspaper or turn on the evening anchorman.
You’ll find a discouraging pattern. Almost everyone treats our troubles as political, technological, educational, or economic. After all, we can right the ship by fixing the policy, ship the newest product, reform the schools or grow the economy.
But what if those solutions, no matter how beneficial any of them might end up being, are actually just symptoms of a deeper problem?
I’m not a wise old sage. Perhaps I will be one day, but for now I’ve just got my 62 years of experience to go on.
I’ve come to believe the deeper trouble is the condition of the human heart. Put aside spirituality and philosophy for a moment. Let’s just see it as a diagnosis that explains what's happening better than the alternatives do.
Consider what technology actually does and doesn’t do. It doesn’t install character. It amplifies whatever is already sitting inside the person. Give a generous man more resources and you get more generosity. Give a cruel one the same resources and you get more cruelty, faster, to more people, with better targeting.
AI will not make humanity wiser. It simply hands human beings more capable tools. A machine can be brilliant and still have nothing to say about whether a thing should be done. That question was never something that a computation was designed to solve.
That’s why there is a giant chasm between intelligence and wisdom. I know plenty of incredibly smart people, if we are measuring with degrees or IQ. Some of those people have the discernment and common sense of a brick.
Here’s the difference.
Intelligence answers: can we?
Wisdom asks: should we?
Just about every serious catastrophe of the last century never asked the second question. Social media didn’t invent envy, vanity, or mob behavior. It found them, fed them, and put them on display for all to see. By the same token, AI isn’t creating human nature. It’s magnifying it, and it’s magnifying it at a scale we’ve never had to reckon with before.
-> The trust problem is a heart problem <-
The clearest recent proof runs straight through the pandemic, and I want to walk through it carefully, because it’s the place where people stop reading and start defending. Regardless of where you stand, I encourage you to let down your guard and be open to what might be an alternative take.
Some things dismissed as fringe in 2020 have aged better than the dismissals. The lab leak hypothesis got people banned from platforms; it’s now an assessment held by the FBI and based on recent testimony I’ll soon address, completely accurate.
Prolonged school closures were defended as settled wisdom, and the learning loss data has been absolutely brutal on our children. Fauci testified in 2024 that the six foot distancing rule “sort of just appeared” without solid evidence behind it. Pharmaceutical companies made tens of billions of dollars on products the government required, recommended, or heavily promoted, which doesn’t make the products worthless but does explain why people got suspicious. And a long parade of officials who wrote the rules were photographed breaking them, at dinners, at salons, at parties, unmasked and undistanced, while the rest of us skipped funerals.
Recently, Senator Rand Paul released more than a thousand pages of Anthony Fauci’s private diaries from 2019 through 2022. Paul’s reading is that Fauci’s private notes and his public statements tell two different stories, particularly on origins. Fauci’s team disputes that, arguing the entries show a scientist’s understanding evolving in real time, which is a fair thing for a scientist’s notes to show. On July 29th, Fauci sat before the Senate Homeland Security Committee and invoked the Fifth Amendment 111 times.
I’m not going to tell you what that proves about the virus. That’s not why I bring up this example.
I also want to resist the victory lap, though I am pleased with the choices I personally made under extreme
pressure to go against my own better judgment. The people who said the vaccines would kill millions by 2022 were wrong. Masking did nothing but cut us off from seeing each others’ faces. Lockdowns destroyed countless businesses and careers. And sadly, an unprecedented number of young, healthy athletes, have suddenly died from myocarditis. But being right about one thing doesn’t hand anybody a track record, and a broken clock is still right two times each day.
Institutions asked for trust while behaving in ways that made trusting them irrational. They demanded compliance and then exempted themselves. They called honest questions dangerous and then, years later, asked the questions themselves. They confused defending the truth with defending their own standing, which is a very old confusion and a predictably human one. We have the receipts for this and it’s not up for debate.
That’s not a policy failure. It’s pride, self-protection, and the deep reluctance to say “I was wrong” in front of people who watched you be certain.
And the bias runs in every direction
Now for the harder part, and the part most people writing about this are scared to discuss.
The same defect operates in the people who were right.
Cognitive bias isn’t a condition afflicting the other tribe. It’s our standard operating system. We take in evidence that flatters what we already believe and discount evidence that costs us something. Being vindicated once tends to make that worse, not better, because now you’ve got proof you’re the kind of person who sees clearly.
I know this because I’ve done it in embarrassing ways myself.
In 1994 I was publishing a software review ezine on floppy disks. Actual 3.5” disks, coded as a self-executing program and distributed by hand. One of my volunteer reviewers suggested we put the reviews on something called the World Wide Web. I had been on BBBes since 1980 and myriad online services over the year. Yet I had no clue what the web was, and I dismissed his suggestion as a fringe idea. I ignored the single most consequential technology of my adult life because it didn’t fit the picture I already had of how things worked.
Nothing about my intelligence caused that. My information wasn’t the problem either. My prior understanding was the problem, and my confidence protected it.
If you can hold both of those thoughts at once, that the institutions failed in ways that were predictable and human, and that your own certainty is running on the same machinery that failed them, you’re closer to wisdom than you may know. If you can only hold the first one, you’ve just switched tribes.
Here's the thing that gets to the core of my thesis. A society needs a standard it didn’t invent.
This is where I think the modern way we approach solutions hits the wall again and again. And again, some of you will find my opinion in opposition to yours. It’s fine. People can think differently. Those with open minds will at least consider my proposition. It wasn't until I was 24 that I realized my framework for the world wasn't logical. 38 years later, the change I made in how I viewed the world has only solidified.
I believe civilizations require a moral framework that sits outside individual preference. Not because people are stupid, but because when two people disagree, something has to be able to settle it besides volume.
Replace objective moral truth with personal truth, and disagreements become structurally unresolvable. Your truth and my truth collide, and there’s no higher court, so the only remaining tiebreakers are power, money, and social pressure. Sound familiar? Turn on YouTube and watch any public argument. After a time it usually stops being an argument about what’s right and becomes a contest over who gets to define the terms.
I opted for a Christian worldview in my mid-twenties, and have written about that choice publicly before, so I’ve no problem putting my cards on the table about what that framework actually claims.
Christianity doesn’t teach that people are fundamentally good and occasionally slip. It teaches that people are fallen and in need of redemption. No one likes to hear that about themselves, and it’s the reason a lot of people reject it out of hand.
But look at what it predicts. It predicts that human beings will pursue self interest, power, pleasure, and autonomy unless something transforms them from the inside. It predicts that better education, more wealth, and stronger technology will make people more capable without making them better. It predicts that the ones who gain authority will be tempted to protect it at the cost of the truth.
You don’t have to accept the theology to notice that the predictions keep landing.
America is now, by any reasonable measure, a post-Christian culture. That transition took decades, and I want to be careful about how I describe it.
I don’t believe that taking prayer and Bible reading out of public schools caused our social problems. That treats one court decision as the hinge of history. It’s better understood as a symbolic marker inside a much larger movement away from any transcendent moral authority. Plenty of other forces did the heavy lifting: the reshaping of the family, mass media, consumerism, mobility, globalization, and eventually social platforms that made every person the editor of their own reality.
The consequence of moving God out of the center isn’t that people stop believing in anything. It’s that every individual and every institution ends up defining morality on its own authority. Which produces exactly the confusion we’re living in now, about truth, about identity, about purpose, and about what a human life is worth.
That last one is the one that cuts the deepest. And if I haven’t rattled your cage yet, this one ought to do it. Not for the sake of rattling, but for the shared exercise of seeking wisdom and truth, no matter the cost.
If a unique human life begins at conception, then abortion is one of the defining moral questions of our era, and the number of them is not something a society can wave off. That’s my conviction, and I hold it because of what I believe about where human worth comes from.
I also think it’s worth being precise about where the disagreement actually lives. Very few people dispute that something biologically human and genetically distinct exists after conception. The argument is about personhood and moral status, about when a human organism becomes a someone with claims on the rest of us. That’s largely a philosophical and theological question, with a scientific consensus already agreeing that human life begins at conception.
If human worth is conferred by capability, or viability, or by whether someone else wants you, then it’s negotiable, and the negotiation never stops at the unborn. If it’s intrinsic, granted by God and not by us, then it isn’t ours to adjust. Those two starting points can’t both be true, and almost every downstream fight about human dignity traces back to which one you picked.
The consequences of treating human life at any stage as disposable is seen in the current trial of Lindsay Clancy, the woman who is currently on trial for brutally murdering her own three children.
There are now people out there who are standing behind this monster who deserves life in prison at the very least. Those of us with common sense know it. It makes you wonder how twisted someone's thinking has to become in order to believe otherwise. But several generations of discounting the value of human life leads to natural consequences. So here we are.
The pattern is remarkably consistent.
The printing press. Radio. Television. The internet. Social media. Artificial intelligence.
Every one of them changed civilization. The printing press cracked open literacy and also supercharged religious warfare. Radio educated millions and also handed dictators a direct line into the living room. The internet gave everyone a library and a megaphone, and we mostly used the megaphone.
Not a single one of them changed the human heart.
There’s no reason to think this one will. AI will cure diseases and write symphonies and eliminate categories of work, and it will also produce fraud, manipulation, and weapons at a scale that we’ve never seen before. Same tool. Same species. Different outcomes depending entirely on who’s holding it and what they love.
We don’t have an AI problem.
We don’t primarily have a political problem.
We don’t primarily have an economic problem.
We have a human problem. And from where I sit, that human problem is spiritual at its root.
None of this means the rest of what we do is pointless.
Politics matters. Education matters. Technology matters. Economic opportunity matters enormously to the person who doesn’t have any.
But run the list of things a society actually needs from its members and notice that no institution can manufacture a single one.
Wisdom.
Virtue.
Humility.
Self-control.
Forgiveness.
Courage.
Love.
No policy produces those. No curriculum installs them.
No model, however capable, can hand them to you. They’re formed inside people, slowly, usually through some combination of suffering, relationship, and submission to something above yourself. It’s the least scalable process in existence, and it’s the only one that has ever fixed anything.
Which leaves us in an odd position. We’re pouring extraordinary resources into making our tools smarter, and comparatively nothing into making ourselves better, and then acting surprised when capability keeps outrunning character.
The future won’t ultimately be determined by how intelligent our machines become.
It’ll be determined by whether human beings become wiser than the tools we create.