Glasman and Hinder in Paris
John Milbank
Alasdair John Milbank (born 23 October 1952) is a British theologian and philosopher. He is professor emeritus of Religion, Politics and Ethics at the University of Nottingham, where he is also president of the Centre of Theology and Philosophy and the Centre for Social Renewal. Milbank has previously taught at Lancaster University, University of Cambridge, and University of Virginia, where he held the Frances Myers Ball Chair of Philosophical Theology. While at Cambridge as a Reader, he was also fellow of Peterhouse. More on Wikipedia
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Cumbria recalled
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Am in Paris to speak at this.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Dame Sarah is saving the Church from the mistrust of the Welby years www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/18/sarah-mullally-is-sav…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Glory be!
Marcus Walker
@WalkerMarcus
A very interesting article by @BijanOmrani. It seems @ArchbishopSarah’s staggeringly pro-parish speech and pro-local agenda has been heard…
www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/c03717b0cf842d23 -
john milbank reposted
Phillips P. OBrien
@PhillipsPOBrien
The best indication that Ukraine is hurting Russia is that US officials are criticizing Ukrainian strategy.
If the gang that lost a war to Iran in a few months and regularly sucks up to Putin, is trying to get Ukraine to change strategy, you know Ukraine is ok the right road. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘the gender war is a misrecognition of class war.’ (Tony Chamas)
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘The politics of individual behavioral modification, which the phantom of patriarchy sustains and encourages, is precisely the politics that capital prefers:it keeps the population focused on interpersonal conduct while the structural conditions of exploitation remain untouched.’
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Emmanuel Todd has shown how the West was never totally patriarchal compared with Eurasia. And that its greater focus on the nuclear family, allowance of bilateral inheritance etc were in fact semi-survivals of the pre-agricultural. So much for any notions of universal progress!
Post not available here, view on X
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
As Todd also insists, all the serious work of abolishing the (always weaker) patriarchal dimension of the West was complete by 1950. In this light the sexual revolution and second wave feminism look ambiguous: to a degree they could be seen as male pushback against this abolition
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
There is no gender pay gap, only the comparative disadvantage suffered by women after the birth of the first child. What is needed to address this and for much more important reasons is a new allowance of the unity of work and family life.
-
john milbank reposted
Marcus Walker
@WalkerMarcus
This such good news - and so exciting! If you thought that people coming to faith - adults wanting to be baptised and confirmed - was a city-only phenomenon (and I’ve heard that often) then @gerrylynch will disabuse you of that thoroughly!
Gerry Lynch
@gerrylynch
My interview on the growing number of adult baptisms in the @ChurchofEngland with Sarah Montague on @BBCRadio4's lunchtime news magazine, The World at One. #quietrevival
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
But the ideas of the Catholic co-founders of the EEC were significantly different from those of Monnet.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Anglesey: a study in greys
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Did Marx and Engels talk of themselves as being ‘on the left’? The answer is of course no.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Christmas is not ‘coming’ until we get to Advent. For now ignore the tinsel and relish the falling leaves.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The new safe routes may not be safe for Britain at all.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A precise indictment. We now have concept creep around ‘grooming’ and confusion of the unseemly with the criminal. Above all a situation where almost no one can be sure that a current sexual interaction will not later be deemed worthy of condemnation.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Consent as the only moral standard naturally conflates sin with crime. And forces us to understand other natural moral revulsions as supposed disgust at the lack of consent. The latter must then be ever more tightly defined and the realm of the criminal expanded. New Puritanism.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This would be an appalling development. Taking us yet further on a course against nature. Gay marriage has profoundly disturbed human norms.
Politics UK
@PolitlcsUK
🚨 NEW: The Government has confirmed it's considering introducing a "staggered" age of consent
It would make relationships between adults and 16 and 17-year-olds illegal
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Fortunately we have now stopped persecuting gay people. But are now going to decide that a man who has sex with a 17 year old boy is a rapist?!
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
And how on earth would one protect adults from teenagers convincingly pretending to be far older than they are? Again, having been deceived renders you a rapist?!
-
john milbank reposted
Politics UK
@PolitlcsUK
🚨 NEW: The Government has confirmed it's considering introducing a "staggered" age of consent
It would make relationships between adults and 16 and 17-year-olds illegal -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Totally agree. The great Athelstan, founder of England, anticipator of a united Britain.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The threat to Southwell Minster.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A recent interview with me, mainly about universalism.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Unbelievable tosh. ‘Progressives’ are now people who deny the reality of daily working-class experience…Of course rightwing populism is not the answer, but populists and progressivists merely spawn each other. The real answer is left conservatism, traditionalist socialism.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Surely the former head of Nvidia is a Chinese spy himself?!
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Good for Malawi! Let’s hope other African countries join it in giving a more balanced account of the history of slavery.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘If the past is not to bind us, where can duty lie?’ (George Eliot, The Mill on the Floss). It is at once a religious and yet a post-religious sentiment. The wise high church vicar in the novel only half agrees: he sees the equal claims of the future in the light of eternity.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
George Eliot’s profound social conservatism was actually connected to her agnosticism one can surely argue. But she was a superlative novelist, significant admired by Proust, Woolf and Lawrence.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I like best her earlier rural, rooted novels. The Mill on the Floss is astoundingly hybrid: touches of legend, of myth, of epic, of tragedy, of melodrama, of sensation novel yet a sustained adult sense that there is scarcely any good choice that does not also do damage.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘Moral judgments must remain false and hollow, unless they are checked and enlightened by a perpetual reference to the special circumstances that mark the individual lot.’ (George Eliot, The Mill on the Floss)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The triumph of smother nature
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
To think that we have wasted so much human history falsely supposing that one needed two and not just one shampooings at every hair-wash!
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Allister Heath seriously doesn’t see that the cult of celebrity (which he accurately denounces) is part and parcel of the ‘society of the spectacle’ that is of course a manifestation of capitalism. Quite incredible.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Fortunately within Labour opposition to this mad and dangerous bill is growing.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Stupefying.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Isolation
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Nothing more confirms the truth of historicism…and historical relativity is now much speeded up.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yes Europe must act to save Ukraine.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
If we deny to women, even young women, sexual agency, then we actually *encourage* nasty male predators to imagine that they are easy prey. This dialectic seems lost upon progressivists who have thereby actually abandoned serious feminism.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
When we traverse a house from within, we have also traversed this very same distance without, albeit virtually.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
American aesthetic at its finest. Old Ford Mustang
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
British Gothic 299
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Have I really got this right? You can be involved in a consensual drunken threesome, make no protests at the time but later realise you were traumatised by a particular phase you hadn’t precisely consented to. It’s ‘out of date’ not to be totally sure this is full scale rape…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I am assured by ‘the vaginal fantasy book club’ that they are interested in studying Trinitarian Ontologies Vol 2. At this point I realise I’m simply out of my depth in this current era.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Lind at his incredible best. He is giving a *genuinely* postliberal analysis here, trashing both Rightwing neoliberal myths of capital shortage and ‘Leftwing’ neoliberal myths of skills shortage. Both are in hoc to a sacrificing of real national wellbeing to spurious ‘growth’.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
No. And again no. It is Europe alone that is on the side of humanity now. Just about. But for that reason it has to defend itself and work out how to combine humanism with a sane use of developing technology.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
We need laws against this and on capital flight. Urgently.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Autumn water
-
john milbank reposted
Alexandra Wilson
@amwilson_opera
A. N. Wilson in today's Times: "whenever we hear [the King] speak, demonstrating that he is well-informed and well-read, it is an uncomfortable reminder that almost none of the cabinet or the shadow cabinet are capable of expressing themselves without cliché...
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Autumn canal (Oxford) by Richard Milbank
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
British Gothic 298: north of Jericho (by Richard Milbank).
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The East Midlanders are still rather like this in an updated way (even if George Eliot was partly projecting the West Midlands upon them. From The Mill on the Floss. (The Floss is the Trent.)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
From George Eliot, The Mill on the Floss. She states here (surely knowingly) the post-Romantic aporia of the novel. If character is not wholly destiny, then every plot is arbitrary and what can be its general significance?
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This time of year always falls as the suddenly sinister: the early dark, the bangs and crackles, the screech owls joining in. It is so full of foreboding.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Besides the memory of the fallen dead.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Good to see that there are several sensible Labour MP’s.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The government’s dreadful abolition of VAT relief is partly responsible for the plight of Southwell Minster. How can it justify placing our greatest physical cultural legacy (mediaeval churches) in such peril? @SaveTheParish
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Museums get this tax relief!
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
We have gone from putting those guilty of ‘sodomy’ into jail to putting people trying to dissuade people from sodomy (*and* from mutilating their bodies) into jail — for five years! Thereby one oppressive horror succeeds another. The wise will pause to consider the implications…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The best post midterm piece by far. In terms of decadent corporatism China and Russia put the state first. By putting money first Trump has severely weakened the US. The republicans won’t break with this priority and the democrats may sell out to anti-western Islamism etc.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The US is likely to lose control of the Near East and its oil resources. Europe may not be able to save Ukraine. Meanwhile, China advances.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
(Looks as if John Gray has left the New Statesman for UnHerd. The NS continues to degenerate into shallow progressivism that fails to understand our present moment.)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The decadent blurring of sexual difference by Bowie etc has proved extremely dangerous for women.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Burnham is correct and cunning not to ignore the little things that actually matter. But he surely knows he has to tackle the big very soon or not at all.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Monumental languor remembered
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The modern ‘master builder’ window in the parish church of Steeple Bumpstead in Essex.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Bérulle said: as the human nature is only personified by the Son and not by the Father or the Spirit, whereas all three persons personify the divine nature, therefore the unity of human nature to the Son is more intimate than that of the divine nature to persons of the Trinity.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Why indeed.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank reposted
Daniel Inman
@ddinman
Who would have thought Eamon Duffy’s Stripping of the Altars would have been the 8th most borrowed book in the London Library in the past 20 years. No impact metric for that, I suppose
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A key problem for populism is that once in power it transpires that it has no real programme to carry through.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Outside Cambridge
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The tree mountain
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It perfectly encapsulates how populism has been captured by continuing neoliberalism.
James Noyes
@jranoyes
It is striking that the only politicians to call for lower taxes on the high street gambling industry are now essentially from the nationalist Right. Yet looking at the comments on his post, Lowe’s own supporters are unanimously in favour of *reducing* the industry’s presence in white, working class communities.
I remember when the @BetGameCouncil promoted this same culture war narrative about the working class during Michael Dugher’s disastrous tenure. This was not just irresponsible (as I wrote back then in an article for the Critic — thecritic.co.uk/dont-let-the-bookies-cry-for-freedom-fool… ) — but also misguided, as it assumes that British working class communities deserve nothing better than high street wastelands of vape shops, kebab shops, Turkish barbers and arcades.
Lowe talks about Great Yarmouth, where he is the MP. I know Yarmouth well, as my parents live nearby. He talks about the arcades and the local economy. But Rupert Lowe is not from Norfolk, he doesn’t know the town from back when it had a proper maritime economy, he doesn’t know how most Norfolk people hate the degradation and despondency that has taken hold of Yarmouth and other towns in the county. He might be the current MP, parachuted in because of current political circumstances, but he seems to have no positive or transformative vision for the community. And when it comes to the high street, his own supporters can see this lack of vision — and reject it.
Rupert Lowe MP
@RupertLowe10
Gambling is not evil, and a Restore Britain Government will reduce taxes on the industry.
Adults should be free to make their own choices about how they spend their own money - a wild thing for a political party to say, I know.
Britain has a successful gambling industry that supports local economies all over the country.
In my constituency alone we have horse racing, a greyhound stadium, plenty of arcades and more.
We should be encouraging responsible operators to thrive, not taxing them into dust.
Problem gambling is an issue and should be properly addressed. But punishing an entire industry, costing thousands of jobs, for the actions of a very small number is not the answer.
Restore Britain will back British gambling. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Dark and light
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Arches
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Wonderful. Few people visit Ireland without encountering the preternatural. ‘Knockers’ once visited us on the Dingle. Friends of mine once directly witnessed an unmistakeable leprechaun simply walking along the road. It was entirely prosaic but he suddenly vanished to nowhere.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank reposted
Jonathan Hinder MP
@Jonathan_Hinder
Reindustrialise Britain.
More meaningful work. Fewer bulls**t jobs.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
john milbank reposted
Eric Kaufmann
@epkaufm
52% of midterm voters say support for trans rights has gone too far vs. 26% saying not far enough.
Progressives should not take the result as an endorsement of their views. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
How Lindsey Graham Lost the Midterms www.compactmag.com/article/how-lindsey-graham-lost-the-mi…
-
john milbank reposted
James Noyes
@jranoyes
It is striking that the only politicians to call for lower taxes on the high street gambling industry are now essentially from the nationalist Right. Yet looking at the comments on his post, Lowe’s own supporters are unanimously in favour of *reducing* the industry’s presence in white, working class communities.
I remember when the @BetGameCouncil promoted this same culture war narrative about the working class during Michael Dugher’s disastrous tenure. This was not just irresponsible (as I wrote back then in an article for the Critic — thecritic.co.uk/dont-let-the-bookies-cry-for-freedom-fool… ) — but also misguided, as it assumes that British working class communities deserve nothing better than high street wastelands of vape shops, kebab shops, Turkish barbers and arcades.
Lowe talks about Great Yarmouth, where he is the MP. I know Yarmouth well, as my parents live nearby. He talks about the arcades and the local economy. But Rupert Lowe is not from Norfolk, he doesn’t know the town from back when it had a proper maritime economy, he doesn’t know how most Norfolk people hate the degradation and despondency that has taken hold of Yarmouth and other towns in the county. He might be the current MP, parachuted in because of current political circumstances, but he seems to have no positive or transformative vision for the community. And when it comes to the high street, his own supporters can see this lack of vision — and reject it.
Rupert Lowe MP
@RupertLowe10
Gambling is not evil, and a Restore Britain Government will reduce taxes on the industry.
Adults should be free to make their own choices about how they spend their own money - a wild thing for a political party to say, I know.
Britain has a successful gambling industry that supports local economies all over the country.
In my constituency alone we have horse racing, a greyhound stadium, plenty of arcades and more.
We should be encouraging responsible operators to thrive, not taxing them into dust.
Problem gambling is an issue and should be properly addressed. But punishing an entire industry, costing thousands of jobs, for the actions of a very small number is not the answer.
Restore Britain will back British gambling. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
No! the end of the Pax Americana means that European countries need to render more real again their former empires as more cooperative ‘commonwealth’ empires with real networks of fair trading etc. Otherwise Europe itself will be swamped.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I don’t think we are unpopular with the peoples of commonwealth countries. Just the reverse. It is only their corrupt woke leaders who are in hoc to global capitalism. We can restore Commonwealth bonds by breaking with all of this in terms of alternative shared economic norms.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
And a Britain neither within the EU or the Commonwealth would be still more perilously isolated! Postliberalism doesn’t mean a cult of the isolated sovereign nation (that’s Hobbes and so liberal!) but pluralism and federalism within and without. (Like Althusius)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
According to Pierre Bérulle, the Son is more perfectly separated from the Father than the Creation is separated from the Father. This is rigorous orthodoxy: only the Son is perfect self-standing product of God, so only the Son is the perfect expression of love as non-egotistical
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
That does not deny perfect substantive relationality and reciprocity but affirms it. We only have pure relation to and reciprocity with a genuinely equal other.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
What a nasty sneering tone about both Pico and de Lubac! Who gives a F how much Mediaeval Latin you know! You still miss the crucial historical and textual points: Lubac rightly sees now Pico is more truly trad than Cajetan and how Bérulle has a real Renaissance Platonic strand.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
As for your caricature of what ressourcement means, simply hang your silly young pseudo-learned head in shame.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
And as for your prudery concerning the bold young Pico, would *you* just let your mistress languish in the hands of some rich old fart? You really don’t grasp the faith at all.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Totally right.
North Yorkshire
@visitnorthyork
Once a culture is gone, it doesn't come back.
The pubs, the dialect, the village traditions, the slower pace of life, none of it exists by accident and none of it is guaranteed to still be here in another generation.
It survives because people choose to keep it alive.
Worth remembering, before it's too late 🥰 -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Eric Coates Dam Busters March (just heard on Radio 3) is so incredibly Elgarian, with an added Big Band Swing. As if to advertise musically that WW 2 was just round 2 of the great conflict against German militarism: lilting swagger defeating mere consolidated might.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Compromise with Putin is illusion yet defeating him may be extremely difficult and appallingly costly for Ukraine. The extreme dilemma is real. Yet I can’t help feeling that the only sane if grim course is to try to defeat him.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It is more obvious that Christianity favours something like socialism than that it favours democracy or rights. Witness the very conservative Bossuet’s great sermon on poverty: Christ came as much to deliver the poor from the oppressive rich as to deliver all of us from our sins.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
One could ask: how does the new inter-age conflict interact with class conflict? Well the more late capitalism has tilted towards rents and finance, the more it favours age and the fixed over youth and creative productivity. Only the children of the rich continue to do well.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Ireland depends on heavily taxing operations not even primarily based in Ireland and even so it struggles to renew its infrastructure. Despite apparent national wealth the economic problems of Irish youth are as bad or worse than elsewhere.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This Dutch person (who has apparently had novels published at the age of 13 and a half…) must surely know that the king cannot decide to do such a thing on his own. And the thing is foolish: Badenoch (sorry to say) is right to ask why demands now and belatedly?
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Foolish because we cannot say sorry for our ancestors, even if we repent of their ways. And yes as Kemi says the demands for reparations come now because of global economic crisis hitting poorer countries worse. She might note this is because of decades of neoliberalism…
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
In that perspective one can say that the global south is not suffering now because of past slavery but of more recent specifically economic western neocolonialism in league with corrupt local rulers. Their slavery focus is therefore both hypocritical and distracting.
-
john milbank reposted
Richard Chapman
@SelsdonChapman
The Telegraph are in danger of jumping the gun. We still await clarification on the Government's policy intention here (& key is what is defined as charitable).
-
john milbank reposted
Marcus Walker
@WalkerMarcus
Churches are at the heart of £55bn of social value, using the Treasury’s own Green Book analysis. This is because priests live in the heart of their community, in homes that are often at the centre of community activity. Labour is going to drive the Vicar out of their community.
-
john milbank reposted
Marcus Walker
@WalkerMarcus
It really seems as if Labour is trying to break the Church. Hot on the heels of charging a punitive extra 20% for all repairs to listed places of worship now they’re going to hit parishes with backbreaking extra taxes on vicarages
www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/47fa8c2455f9a618 -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Today the far right is linked to excessive philo-semitism and the far ‘left’ to excessive philo-Islamism. So the path to sanity includes our re-insistence on the exceeding of the Jewish law by the Incarnation and refusal of the claimed Islamic universal law as displacing that.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Malebranche thought that ‘wasted’ or refused grace obeys a general law, like ‘wasted’ rain falling into the sea because of the general laws of motion. But rain falling into the sea fulfils many crucial functions! Premodern views of grace chime better with current views of nature.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Despite the ignorant dismissal of the 68 generation French postmodernists and their heirs by the youthful Christian Right, it is remarkable that they all took theology much more seriously than earlier leftist intellectuals. Badiou and Agamben especially notable here.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
With all of them and especially Badiou one feels a sense that while the void, the party and the therapist have replaced God, Church and confessor they see the replacement almost as development. It’s as if all this is just waiting to be re-reverted in a subsequent generation.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A wild Lacanian reading of the already wild Oratorian philosopher. But the reading is also theological, mathematical and communist all at once. Entirely enjoyable and stimulating. Worth 90% of most theology books for the theologian, despite certain lacunae re history of ideas.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It is the twin of Badiou’s brilliant reading of Pascal in Being and Event. He admires Malebranche for his ingenuity and its implications, but emphatically prefers Pascal and his lineage. Quite right.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Happy All Saints’ Day to all.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The only alternative to the Zionist Right is for Israel to shift to greater pluralism. Judaism can still be ‘the established religion’ on an English model.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Strengthening the Commonwealth as an economic union of mutual assistance is the right way forward in helping our ex-colonies. Not reparations. Brown and Burnham are right.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A fair piece of reporting which concludes @SaveTheParish now in the ascendancy. But the picture of evangelicals serving the marginalised outside parishes is off. Anglo-Catholic parish missions to the poor in inner cities vastly more important. Evangelicals mainly more bourgeois.
Post not available here, view on X
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Today @SaveTheParish is incredibly far from trying to save a ‘bucolic’ model and knows that parish boundaries etc have to shift. Many of the parishes threatened with closure or liturgically alien colonisation by middle class charismatics are inner city, poor and sometimes black.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Meanwhile, trying to rescue also rural parishes is radical, not reactionary. The countryside like the seaside is part of the now neglected margins. Upholding the parish is eg ensuring that carless old ladies don’t have impossibly long bus rides to get to church services.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Thanks for your analysis which suggests that 51% minimum of the Synod now backs the @SaveTheParish position! Its focus on the entire cure of souls rather than particular issues like sexuality etc is the reverse of eccentric - as you imply. It’s instead a call back to Christianity
Tim Wyatt
@tswyatt
I've started a newsletter! It's called The Critical Friend and the first edition is arriving tomorrow morning. It will be a weekly email about the church - what it's doing right, what's going wrong, & what might happen next - from a churchgoing journalist: tswyatt.substack.com/p/coming-soon
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
What has been done to Christa Pike over decades is a monstrous crime in itself. As sustained cruelty it surely exceeds in evil the crime of her momentary action as a mistreated and disturbed 18 year old.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Liberals just cannot abandon their illusions. All the factors that boost populism remain fully in place.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
One idea for supporting historic church buildings might be to set up something like a national trust equivalent for them. Perhaps we need a royal commission that could conclude to such an intention and the ways to achieve it? @SaveTheParish
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This is Jenny Sinclair’s brilliant lecture on Christianity and the Common Good that she gave recently in (the beleaguered) Southwell Minster. It’s in effect the clearest short introduction to postliberalism that one could hope for.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The sky in the river
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Healey budget makes absolutely no sense unless there is going to be an election before long?
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The banning of conversion therapy (even with respect to homosexuality and even if you think such therapy a huge mistake) is simply totalitarian.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This seriously plays down the ways in which Canada is truly more European than the US. It is at once more communitarian and more truly diverse, with much more ‘liberal’ approaches to welfare and punishment.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The left must break with cultural progressivism if it is to return to dominance. Thinking otherwise will prove illusory.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yes — surely local government should decide and spend on money raised on local taxes, not decide and spend on money from national taxes using powers delegated to it (to mayors more specifically) by central government? This huge novel anomaly was stealthily included in the budget.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
One resonates
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Whatever your politics you should be appalled by the creeping sell-out of the open and public purpose of the British Library.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Tree and wire
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
British Gothic 297. (A bit Appalachian.)
-
john milbank reposted
Andrew Davison
@AP_Davison
Southwell Minster may need to close, unable to afford building repairs. Many people can’t afford extra giving, but if you can, please consider supporting it, not least for the sake of the ‘Leaves of Southwell’: some of the greatest 13th C’s stone carving. southwellminster.churchsuite.com/donate/fund/qx2ayo61
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
British Gothic 288: Southwell Minster
-
john milbank reposted
James Noyes
@jranoyes
It is an outrage that the CofE leadership’s vanity Project Spire continues to pledge tens of millions of pounds to a misguided and historically-dubious reparations fund, when the actual living and historic fabric of the church is falling apart because of lack of funds. Southwell is the canary in the coal mine. Everything must be done, including by the state if necessary, to preserve England’s ancient ecclesiastical buildings and the parish life within them.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Southwell is now the worst case amongst cathedrals but others will soon follow. A precedent now needs setting in relation to Southwell: a financial rescue plan involving both Church and secular sources. Our architectural, cultural and social besides religious legacy is at stake.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Go ghosts and fairies exist? *Only* ghosts and fairies exist. Everything we see is a haunted by the virtuality of the past. Everything we think involves the constant intrusion of creatures of the world of the imagination.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Southwell is now the worst case amongst cathedrals but others will soon follow. A precedent now needs setting in relation to Southwell: a financial rescue plan involving both Church and secular sources. Our architectural, cultural and social besides religious legacy is at stake.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The excellent new Dean has unearthed a mess that preceded him — a combination of answerable incompetence plus decay that is inevitable, given the current lack of public support for our ancient and magnificent church buildings that are central to our patrimony.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Few realise that England and Wales have the most extensive collection of mediaeval churches in Europe. Something that ought to have world heritage status.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I’m no expert but from my reading of Jane Grigson this sounds like a misrepresentation of 18thC English cuisine. What of the Salamagundis and sustained meat with fruit dishes? It was a sophisticated cuisine, admired on the Continent, not all this jolly beef business?
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
In fact English food went downhill first either the cruder tastes of the Victorians and then second the interwar loss of domestic service and turning already to convenience foods. Postwar there was yes a turning to France etc but also eventually a revival of better English food.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Grigson, the Lake District hotel-restaurants etc.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Why is TV convinced that the interior of every church is always ablaze with candlelight?! It’s become an absurd visual cliché.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Splendidly argued heresy that a serious Left should not simply reject.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It’s time to colonize Haiti spectator.com/article/its-time-to-colonize-haiti/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It’s time to colonize Haiti spectator.com/article/its-time-to-colonize-haiti/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Northumberland recalled
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Solutions are entirely derived from problems. (Deleuze is right about this).
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Problematic is also geometric construction. The total reversal of priority that places problemata above theoremata is clearly implied by Trinitarian Ontology, since in the Trinity the eternal Logos is itself expressed/constructed. The Christian shift beyond even Proclus.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Great pro Jefferson piece in this.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Lula Won—‘Lulismo’ Didn’t www.compactmag.com/article/lula-won-lulismo-didnt/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Seriously awful.
Joshua Knapp
@havingaknapp
Went to Lincoln for confession. Afterwards, newly shriven and perky, I went to visit the cathedral. It’s wonderful.
Unfortunately, a band was loudly tuning up for tonight’s ‘ABBA By Candlelight.’ Couldn’t really think, let alone pray. And it cost thirteen quid to get in.
I know it costs loads of money, money, money to maintain a cathedral (let alone pay all those slavery reparations) and the CofE performs a valuable public service by keeping them open, but even so…
Thank you for the (choral) music CofE but knowing me, knowing you, I’ll take a chance on the pub instead.
‘A serious house on serious earth, it is’ writes Larkin in Church Going. Not in Lincoln it’s not.
ABBA by bloody candlelight! -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The U.K. needs more tax revenue (we are not comparatively over-taxed at all) but can only really achieve that via considerable tax reform.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The forests are saved!
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Autumn corner
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Absorbing and immensely scholarly book. Some things in French grail romances have only Irish parallels. They must have come says JC via Wales from lost Welsh sources influenced by Ireland. But then…these sources might just have contained Welsh versions of shared Celtic tropes?
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Another problem with this text, unlike Carey’s amazing A Single Ray of the Sun, is an apparent reluctance to assume that medieval writers of romances consciously saw pagan Celtic sources topologically in relation to Christian truths. It is not a Celtic or Catholic either/or.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I also just do not see why the grail maidens carrying the sacred vessels and their contents needs to be seen as violating liturgical norms, given the allegorical and fictional mode.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Typologically should read.
-
john milbank reposted
Phil💙
@phil0073
#3hillsroundbarrows. A #bronzeage #tumuli near #woodford & #greataddington,#northamptonshire. Pleased to be able photo as so much from these ancient times is lost in the #midlands & #anglia.More of this site soon.#philonabike #weekendwander #fridayfields #ancientways #clouds
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Hard to imagine anything further from the truth than this. In fact the 19thC era of ‘free trade’ itself fomented the era of national imperial conflict. Today individualistic neoliberalism has already given dialectical rise to an analogous upshot that could easily lead to WW 3.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
After the great fire London became an essentially Baroque city. Despite 18thC classicism the later Victorians restored a baroque profusion of mutated Continental and native styles in a glorious jumble of varied but combining massivity. It is very unlike Paris in this regard.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
In this way London is also far more generally ornamental, fanciful and brazen than the gothic or classical restraint of the rest of England.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
James Graham’s fantastic Keynes play ‘The Standard of Living’ at Haymarket. The reviews do scant justice to Graham and production’s skill in weaving together disparate themes and miss the main reflexive point: Keynes is theatre because his anti-economics makes ‘acting’ primary.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The whole thing brings out the essential Ruskinianism of Keynes’s vision and his subordination of economising itself to art and to life. What a little man Hayek was by comparison — as the play comically brings out. It also satirises the Bloomsburyites as prim prudes after all.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
London arcade
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Deep London
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Surely exaggerations and biases here? Much social democracy remains in the Nordic countries (despite reprehensible neoliberalism) and the threat from Russia is not dreamed by America.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Could Vance realise that leaning into Catholic Social Teaching (with a superior grasp of its implications for immigration than that of the Vatican!) now makes political sense for the next presidential election?
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Overseas national empires kept Europe afloat, but Dante has proved right in the longterm: her lack of political unity renders her vulnerable. This is why, despite the horrors of the EU we must not give up on unity. Rapprochement between the Pope and British monarchy a good sign
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It is more important to be critical than to be ‘left’. It’s notable that Žižek is now saying this in his openness to ‘post left’ insights.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Manchester City Football was founded by an Anglican Church, St Mark’s Gorton,for the benefit of working-class people. Now it is controlled by foreign Muslim big money. We need a postliberal politics and philosophy that grasps the implications of this historical shift.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Postliberal politics seeks at one to show that the Right’s support of capitalism cannot be conservative and that the left’s opposition to all modes of hierarchy and suspicion of tradition and virtue is not really compatible with ‘socialism’ or associationism.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Private capitalist ownership means making maximum short-term profits from assets which in consequence decay as assets. Capitalism then moves on (though to less and less) leaving the rest of us with corrupted water, unaffordable homes and corrupted football clubs. ‘Conservative’?!
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Asset Class by Hettie O’Brien | Book review | Peter Geoghegan www.the-tls.com/politics-by-region/british-politics/the-a…
-
john milbank reposted
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Asset Class by Hettie O’Brien | Book review | Peter Geoghegan www.the-tls.com/politics-by-region/british-politics/the-a…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Asset Class by Hettie O’Brien | Book review | Peter Geoghegan www.the-tls.com/politics-by-region/british-politics/the-a…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
In my maddest moments I imagine a grand Franco-British alliance where we jointly agree to default on all our debts and start again with a post-capitalist, post-left, postliberal corporatist-socialist order, linked to our former vast empires. But is this thought so completely mad?
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Why are we so complacent about all this? We just don’t want to tell ourselves that the way we live is destroying the viability of life itself.
Tom Holland
@holland_tom
Put that on the banknote
Queen Natalie 👑
@TheNorfolkLion
Britain had about 30 million hedgehogs in the 1950s; we've got under 875,000 today. The population has dropped by about 97%. Shocking.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The darkening year
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Intervals
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
But also unlikely to work, as Brendan Simms rightly argues here.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Dorset drama recalled
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Agree: the end of history is (so far) very real after all. Western cultural trash has won. Disagree: 1. it’s not true late classical culture was ‘pluralist’ in any comparable way. 2. ‘Plural communitarianism’ is negligible compared to the alienating collapse of association. For
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
that reason I will persist in my postliberal struggle against the liberal triumph. This finality of trash negates the human will to reproduce itself, as Sloterdijk argues. It is already part of the metacrisis of liberalism. So the end is not secure and not really the end.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This is what happens when you abandon the faith. Official ‘Irishness’ is now just globalised liberalism. The real thing survives better in the north…
Europa.com
@europa
🇮🇪 The Irish state has published an advert discouraging grandparents from hugging their grandchildren, as part of a campaign designed to promote "consent".
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Cunliffe more plausible than Tombs (in same issue) on this issue: plenty of mobs in British history and further back revolutions as well. We cannot be as certain as Tombs that relatively recent British political stability will survive current circumstances.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Despite an initial insistence on ‘different’ causes of rioting across Europe, the writer eventually declares that indeed a disadvantaged generation and a crisis of state provision (in the face of sluggish growth one could add) is a common factor.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
No arguments here at all. Why is it better to import gas than use our own? The former is worse for global warming. Aiming to reduce our current energy efficiency and costs by using our fossil resources for now (we’re using fossil fuels anyway) doesn’t negate longterm greening.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
We can’t risk our wellbeing and security in the face of China and Russia for the sake of an absolutely tiny contribution to the restriction of global warming. Especially when we are well on track to an eventual almost exclusive reliance on renewables.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The spread of evangelical Protestantism in Latin America is a catastrophe. This creed (the real ‘dualistic Gnosticism’ unknown to most actual gnostics) loathes the divine creation and revels only in (un)atoning blood. Catholics complicit in this need to think hard again.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
As usual as regards his accurate critique, Monbiot is entirely right. Capitalism is hard-wired to ‘using-up’ nature and would rather destroy nature entirely than call itself into question.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Scruton read Foucault etc and thought: this relativism must be opposed in the name of truth and tradition! I read Foucault etc and thought: this relativising of enlightenment truth could be bent towards asserting the greater truth of tradition…
Post not available here, view on X
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Scruton read Foucault etc and thought: this everything being uncertain is dangerous frogggie nonsense! I read Foucault etc and thought: this rigorous insistence on the elusiveness of meaning points to a Platonic view that we participate truth as eternal only in fragments.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Scruton’s response to Foucault etc was to retreat to a soft Kantian humanism. My response to Foucault etc was much more in the line of Coleridge’s very Schellingian rendering of Kant: an attempt to resurrect a Romantic Christian Platonism taking full account of nature and poesis
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Scruton’s ruling out of an after life on the basis of a Kantian account of causality was more Kantian than Kant, who of course didn’t rule it out on that basis.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
British Gothic 296
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This looks grave
Carlo Martin
@Liberfach0
🚨🇮🇹 | URGENTE: La ciudad de Bologna en Italia, quedó totalmente DEVASTADA durante esta madrugada por las protestas SALVAJES de izquierdistas radicales e inmigrantes, quienes han destruido calles, vandalizado vehículos y saqueado locales. El centro turístico es un infierno total
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Written on the cusp of the legalisation of gay marriage. I feel my reasoning against it has been borne out by developments since (including transmania) and which I somewhat anticipated. Note that when I wrote it 70% of Brits opposed gay marriage! What do they really think now?
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Of course my wider perspectives here will likely please virtually no one. That’s a strong indicator that they are right…They are right.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This book surely vindicates distributists: modern modes of private property are based upon the suppression of older modes of more dispersed and more sacral ownership. State and private capital are equally guilty of such seizure.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Interesting argument.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Why the Muslim World Fell Behind www.compactmag.com/article/why-the-muslim-world-fell-behind/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
High debt plus over-extended welfare needs besides legitimate infrastructural and educational ones that are now barely affordable by the state. Exacerbated by immigration tensions. This lurks behind the French riots, but Britain has exactly the same problem.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Bleak Truth Behind France’s Riots www.compactmag.com/article/the-bleak-truth-behind-frances…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Bleak Truth Behind France’s Riots www.compactmag.com/article/the-bleak-truth-behind-frances…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Why the Muslim World Fell Behind www.compactmag.com/article/why-the-muslim-world-fell-behind/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Important:
James Noyes
@jranoyes
Some words on the French riots and streaming platforms.
Much is being written about the social and ethnic background of the people currently looting and vandalising French cities. Less is said about the technology being used to organise, coordinate and broadcast the disorder: specifically, the live streaming functions on Snapchat and TikTok, the use of Snap Map to identify police and geolocate flashpoints, and illegal content / hashtags which are inadequately moderated by the platforms.
These Very Large Online Platforms, which are already poorly regulated and undertaxed, are playing a direct role in the scenes of violence and disorder that we are witnessing across French and European cities. Yet legislation exists which is designed to deal with this: namely, the Digital Services Act, which contains clauses that cover crisis protocols, risk assessment and the mitigation of illegal content and threats to public wellbeing.
The legislation exists, the threat of significant fines exists, yet still these tech companies fail to do what is necessary to prevent their platforms from being used to promote crime and civil disorder. Snapchat, which is very popular among French youth, is especially problematic in this respect. It is imperative that the French government looks again at the option of serious sanction against both Snapchat and TikTok, as it did during the riots of 2023.
A first concrete step should be a review of the Snap Map function, including “Ghost mode”, and its role during the recent riots. If it is demonstrated that these geolocation functions have been used to organise and coordinate looting, they should be limited in the EU using provisions within the Digital Services Act. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Cathedral sunset
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
View from the top 3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
View from the top 2
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
View from the top 1
-
john milbank reposted
Donald Tusk
@donaldtusk
Polska nie powtórzy błędów innych europejskich państw, nie będzie też za nie płacić. Twardo bronimy granicy przed nielegalną migracją, mamy własną politykę azylową (nie przyjmujemy wniosków), deportujemy tych, którzy łamią polskie prawo. W kwestii bezpieczeństwa będziemy bezwzględni. To usłyszeli ode mnie liderzy Europy w Brukseli.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The prominence of safeguarding pamphlets on pews in churches is really objectionable. As if that were somehow the major Christian message and concern!
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The left has been wrong to see high educational standards as right wing. But the right wing is wrong to see them as right wing.
Post not available here, view on X
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Courses.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The whole dodgy Ralston College thing. We are now in dire need of purified academic institutions not fighting one side of the culture war or the other, not hijacked by either wokery or MAGA.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
There are lots of nice young Christians attracted to the Right because the Left has become so rotted by ultra-liberalism and hatred of high culture and the western
legacy. Yet it is still a mistake. They ignore the deeper liberalism of capitalist economics and nationalism. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yes I agree
John Duffield
@jfwduffield
Complete & utter nonsense. Western museums are a good thing. They have discovered & preserved cultural artefacts that developing countries were unable to do so themselves. Ethnic minority politicians are playing with fire with these grievance ridden tantrums.
Chatham House
@ChathamHouse
"The British Museum is the largest depository of stolen goods known to man."
Lord Paul Boateng (@UKHouseofLords) on the British Museum and the return of the Ethiopian Tabots, Benin Bronzes and Ashanti gold.
Watch the event in full: www.chathamhouse.org/events/all/standard-event/reckoning-…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Biden betrayed Ukraine earlier and for the same reason as Trump has done.
-
john milbank reposted
Ben Goldsmith
@BenGoldsmith
Speak to any hard-bitten older farmer around me in Somerset, or anywhere in Britain, and they will tell you that they grew up among fields teeming with corncrakes, grass snakes, hares, hedges full of yellowhammers and other songbirds, car windscreens splattered with bugs after the shortest summer drive, nearly all now gone. 98% of wildflowers, gone. Huge shoals of herring, cod, and other fish in the sea, a distant memory. Across almost every indicator, the losses during just one human lifetime have been catastrophic. The data is all there, as are the anecdotes. Britain is among the most nature-depleted countries on earth.
Francis Buner
@fbuner
We are not the most nature depleted country. That's just a myth. We are one of the most human altered countries, i.e. one with the least amount of truly wild places. Our biodiversity is actually quite high for a small country, partly as a result of human intervention.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Adrian Pabst on different postliberalisms.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Towards Haymarket
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Countryside near Broadmoor by Richard Dadd
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Grief by Richard Dadd
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Robin Hood by Richard Dadd
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Dadd’s masterpiece illustrating A midsummer night’s dream: ‘The fairy feller’s master stroke’
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Columbine by Richard Dadd
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Fairy Hour by Richard Dadd. She looks noble and enormous until you take in the grasses above her head.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Victorians often exercised far more humanity in relation to mentally deranged murderers than several American states and indeed other states do today. The likewise psychotic Mary Lamb killed her parents but her brother Charles was allowed to care for her.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Puck by the great Victorian painter Richard Dadd
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Construction
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Cavendish parish church
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Cavendish village green (Suffolk)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Overheard in a Suffolk pub today: ‘Oi ‘allus know the name of the cow whose milk Oi’m drinking.’
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Justice does not override any natural good is the derivation.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Inside Cavendish parish church
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The core of a really paradoxical but coherent postliberal politics would be a combination of Marx’s desire to abolish economic classes with de Maistre’s view that it is actually impossible to abolish estates (in the deepest sense) or corporations beneath the level of the state.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Thus even ‘workers’ control’ would not abolish the functions of ideas-making and architectonic organisation and defence that tend inevitably to become specialisations and in some sense lineages.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
And to be quite clear I am hugely in favour of economic democracy. (It is just that no sane or workable democracy is ever pure.)
Post not available here, view on X
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Thus socialism requires notions of the objectively good and of virtue outside what people want. Capitalism is not basically a different mode of arbitrary power as kings held in the past. For at least kings claimed to pursue just order, capitalism pursues only abstract capacity.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This is why (roughly) one has to add Ruskin to Marx.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Burnham must stay left to stay in power.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
We have insanely put low consumer prices before supporting native industry.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘we know of no despot in history who ever decreed that his subjects smile on cue — yet that is routine in customer service today.’ (Mike Beggs et al)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Britannia stands firm
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I’m very anti Reform but watching the big ‘exposure’ of their candidates on ITV just now made one realise just how deluded the left-liberal mainstream, still are in thinking this will ‘shock’ people away from the party.
Post not available here, view on X
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
They’ll simply watch and conclude that the establishment has betrayed them. Similarly when Robert Peston says ‘we have had fifty years of unlearning racism’ he will be seen as not registering that in that period totally unprecedented levels of immigration have shifted our culture
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yes in many positive ways but also in many ways that have caused problems and left too many of the older and even the more recent indigenous feeling marginalised. Like the Danish SDP we have to recognise this and now mitigate these dangers or Reform will eventually win.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
So long as you cannot find the right home, it is best to stay on the road.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The low but undulating East Anglian countryside gives you the uncanny effect of living in the sky.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Although it wants to say the opposite, this article tends to support the Weimar parallel after all.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Coming up soon.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Completely incoherent. The canon was assembled (and several times reassembled) by the Church. Your view of the Bible is like the rather crazed Islamic view of the Koran or the Mormon view of their book, whatever it’s called. You don’t possess a Christian outlook.
The Christian Statesman
@ChrisStatesman
Not true, death penalty is biblical, Catholicism has so much un- and anti-biblical accretions.
Someone pointed out though that the execution by firing squad was deserved to important men of rank, this terrorist should be hanged instead. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Round the bend
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Labour is in a fix. They feel they need a mandate to borrow and raise taxes sensibly. But they need to do it now (sensible cuts to disability etc are not enough) or they will plunge into trouble and it will be too late. They should forget ‘promises’, plead crisis and do it now.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Completely. Whereas it is clear that Paul saw the OT and paganism as rather similarly confined.
Both sides of the Tweed
@Dr_W_E_Bulmer
When I say that (most) American evangelicals have constructed a syncretic 'Americanity' that rejects Christian ethics, this is what I mean. There is no real reckoning with how the resurrection transforms our understanding of justice. It is stuck in a pre-Christian worldview.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
One can see that past circumstances may have made execution necessary as summary justice. But one should see this as tragic exception that doesn’t stop such killing as killing being bad. In this sense it is actually *not* unlike war or early abortion in the face of rape etc.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Respect for life should be absolute, but just *because* respect for life means respect for the living there can be instances of justified killing. Not capital punishment though and not euthanasia (even if ‘allowing to die’ is an unavoidable grey area).
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Albion, stand forth!
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I’m shocked that Nottingham University is closing its music dept. Music is one of the key liberal arts and you cannot be a real university without it. Yet Nottingham is supposed to be one of the top 20 in the UK and used to be within the top 10. But this self-damage not unique.
-
john milbank reposted
Nick Spencer
@theosnick
The new @Theosthinktank report ‘Beyond “Christian nationalism”: Measuring attitudes to Christianity and Britishness today’ is published today!
www.theosthinktank.co.uk/research/2026/10/10/beyond-chris… -
john milbank reposted
Giles MacDonogh
@GilesMacDonogh
Now, the lying is over. Donald is free to be what he always wanted to be and to sing it loudly to the world. He, and by extension the government of the United States of America, is Vladimir Putin’s friend and partner. He will help Putin, protect Putin, and do what he can to get
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The French dialectic of formalism and anarchy. Absolutely.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Vietnam destroyed the US as a republic.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Manx faerie recalled
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A classic Alfa Spider
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Berlin Gothic 2
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
(This is Fichte by the way)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
There he lies
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
In ‘The Forsaken Merman’ Arnold retained a Coleridgean power of imagination. It is so much more interesting than ‘On Dover Beach’.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
RIP Arthur Gibson — an old friend from Cambridge who encouraged me in several ways. See his forward to my first poetry book, The Mercurial Wood.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Too many Catholics, even in Europe, tend to bend Francis and Leo’s ideas in too rightwing a direction. On the other hand too many lefter Catholics reduce CST to an impossible attempt just to restore postwar social democracy. Can’t be done and anyway it was still too liberal.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
That’s to say not sufficiently seeking to overcome capitalism and too addicted to subjectivist notion of human rights. (Maritain very inadequate here.)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
That awful female Irish neoliberal ‘selling’ voice they use on Ryanair and in adverts for ‘softness’! Its distortion of the Irish lilt sums up everything that has gone wrong with the Republic. Keynes predicted it was too small to achieve a self-sufficient resistance to capitalism
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Phew! I’m back in clearer island skies with floating clouds, away from those louring Asian masses of blanketing grey.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I recall Egypt in the Seventies. Barely a headscarf in sight, never mind a veil. Nothing in Islam absolutely commands the headscarf so it’s impossible not to see its mass wearing as a fairly deliberate statement of dividing difference. A discrete cross is nothing like that.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
How the Omni-Cause Swallowed Amnesty International www.compactmag.com/article/how-the-omni-cause-swallowed-a…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Very soon the heirs of the Nazis are likely to take power in Germany and this time they’ll likely be abetted by the heirs of the Maurrasians in France. They’ll do a deal with Russia. The US will be sort of on their side. The UK will then stand far more alone than in the Thirties.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Somehow we have to reach again for our greatness and deal with this.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
After a brief trip to Brandenburg I’d say that Prussian efficiency is a thing of the past, but Prussian authoritarianism very much alive and in fact reviving.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Death is always at an infinite distance from life, even in its last instance.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Berlin gothic
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Foreign powers should not control British sports clubs.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
In Berlin at the Common Good Foundation conference I’m just massively encouraged by the numbers of dynamic young people here from all over the world doing practical associationist things and thinking them through. They reject both individualism and divisive nationalism.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It is evidence that genuine postliberalism (mainly of the left but also of the more moderate, organicist right) is seriously gaining traction. Catholics, Protestants, Jews and secular people are all involved. No doubt people of other faiths also.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Conference is actually run by Our Common Home. It is about ecology and the common good. Really exceptional so far.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Thank God and let’s hope the Greens now decline — or recover their original mission.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Increasingly we face a dreadful shift towards an extreme Right defined by ultra-Zionism and an extreme Left covertly or openly allied with Islamism. Only a different postliberal, associationist ‘centre’ may be able to save us from this double danger. Crucial moderate Israelis win
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Although part of the new Right is itself drifting into anti-Semitism and philo-Islamism. The entire Christian legacy that is the parent of true personalism and solidarism is now profoundly threatened. Let’s recall that the Crusades were initially a defensive operation.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
We must hope and pray that the American people (and remember that some American states were pioneers in ending the death penalty) reject this descent into an almost unprecedented barbarism. The only place for the unspeakably vulgar and nasty Hesgeth is (a quite pleasant) jail.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
But if the US continues this slide into sick cruelty the UK along with the Commonwealth and in alliance with the EU must steer a new and boldly independent course.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Lowlands loch recalled
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Sometimes when one hears the ‘thoughts’ of people who were once high up in government, one realises it is no wonder we are so f*cked…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This ignores the strong ‘joining’ dimension of the Scandi soc dem ethos. Danes join more clubs than any where else in Europe. How this relates to admitted individualising tendencies I by no means fully understand. Nonetheless the point about weak redistribution is interesting.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
There Is No ‘Nordic Model’ www.compactmag.com/article/there-is-no-nordic-model/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
There Is No ‘Nordic Model’ www.compactmag.com/article/there-is-no-nordic-model/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It is weak association that is the main cause of the declining birth-rate. Only associationism (ie Socialism!) can reverse this. But probably only religious revival can revive association.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Everything that the deranged ultra-liberal Allister Heath believes is the very opposite of core historical Toryism. Dr Johnson weeps.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Unlike Jesus. Suspicion of money is near the core of his message. There can be no arguments on this point. It is possible to be a Tory and a Christian, but not to be a Hayekian and a Christian.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Will Brett and Adrian Pabst open the Berlin conference.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Here in Berlin
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Just heard from someone that the justified anger of French schoolchildren may nonetheless be exacerbated by the banning of smart phones in French schools. Without this comfort zone they have to confront harsh immediate reality.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Berlin always strikes me as bleak and Asian. I miss the jolly Rhine and Bavaria snd mystical Swabia, folkloric Schwarzwald and the Romantic Baltic to the west. I still worry about Prussia.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Off to Berlin to participate in the Common Good ecology conference.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Ascending
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yes Badenoch’s ideas are just awful and show zero understanding of the present time. With apologies to some friends she is neither Burkean nor Scrutonian (Scruton no Hayekian), but more dogmatically Thatcherite than Thatcher — who might have realised this was a different moment.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
She is still shackled! These barbaric Wild Western areas really aren’t Christian at all. It’s just a shame Britain now lacks the military power to take them all back within the Commonwealth…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A difference between Marx’s atheist and Polanyi’s Christian Socialism is that Marx saw the economic as always foundational, whereas for Polanyi only capitalism had made it so by disembedding the economic from the social. So Polanyi was more rigorously historicist and globalist.
-
john milbank reposted
Mark Lambert
@sitsio
I think one of the most moving corners of Norwich Cathedral is the altar of Our Lady of Walsingham & it is a reminder that Walsingham was never merely a remote Norfolk shrine. Medieval East Anglia was crossed by pilgrims making their way to England’s Nazareth, where the Holy House was founded in 1061. So Norwich itself stood within that landscape of pilgrimage. Today the connection is tangible again: the modern Walsingham Way begins at Norwich Cathedral and winds 37 miles through the Norfolk countryside to the shrine. There is something wonderfully fitting, therefore, about finding Our Lady here in Norwich. The Reformation destroyed the original shrine and attempted to erase the devotion that surrounded it, yet centuries later, in this great medieval cathedral, once itself a Benedictine monastery, the Mother of God is still honoured under the title Our Lady of Walsingham...England’s Nazareth endured.
Our Lady of Walsingham, pray for England. 🙏 -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
For once, well done the Mogg.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Neoliberalism plus debt Keynesianism. Degradation of public institutions. The response of the school pupils (I refuse to say students!) and police is highly French, but the basic situation is shared across both sides of the channel.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The view that the British empire was ethically superior to other European overseas empires is now held in derision. Yet it was the view of the decidedly radical economist Keynes and the immensely critical novelist Conrad. Both in positions to know what they were talking about.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
RIP Jeffrey Archer - one of many Grantchester legends from Chaucer onwards.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The liberal and standard Marxist view that history is a total horror show nonetheless tending towards some sort of utopia is somehow not convincing…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Premodernity really was pursuing ethical alongside material ends in politics and economics. Not that the ethical ends were always the right ones! But idea this pursuit was just ideological disguise projects back our modern disembedding of politico-economic from the ethical.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Thus the cynical view of the premodern shared by the vast majority of historians is in fact naïveté. The only non-naive approach is taken by historians who read eg Ancient Greek history as if the gods etc were real. (For Schelling there was a sense in which they were real.)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The only validity for the ‘sociological’ is 1. The importance of the synchronic and 2. The reality that all human societies within the natural and animal and geographic-ecological order are specifically ‘human social’ in comparable ways.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
But there can be no ‘sociology’ as foundational either in collective or individualist terms (Durkheim or Weber). Only in the (non)foundationalist sense that all society is reciprocal gift-exchange and (re)production in both space and time. Sociology-History (Mauss).
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Even though I disagree with big things in this book it is astonishing and likely to leave no reader where he was. It favours space, exchange, geography and Kant, not time, production, history and Hegel, while still seeing nature as eastern flow that western ‘building’ can’t stop.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A very important thing about is it’s Maussian view of socialism as expanded gift-exchange. Moreover KK reads all the axial religions and philosophies as opening to this ‘return’ of primitive reciprocity. His mode of Marxism is then less anti-religious.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
But maybe his biggest mistake (besides a false duality of exchange and production) is to see exchange as still diubdatiobslly material and economic. Exchange is also spiritual and so ‘religious’. Indeed economy itself is also spiritual. And production! (Materialism is old hat.)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Let’s hope the current ludicrous version of the Green Party is sunk by the members’ monstrous embrace of antisemitism. I just watched them prance around like overgrown children. Such types need to stay well away from public life.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Philippe Buchez, the 19thC Catholic socialist and pioneer of cooperatives somewhat in advance of Proudhon, rarely revives his due in socialist history. Via Ludlow and Maurice he was the really key if hidden influence (besides Ruskin) on British Christian socialism.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Unlike Proudhon or Marx, Buchez was happy to combine voluntary with state encouraged associationism. In fact maybe this mix is characteristic of Christian socialism? By contrast secular socialism has to absolutise either the will of the people or the immanent reason of the state.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘socialism in the strict sense (associationism) is not a continuation of the French Revolution: this socialism was actually born as a rejection of that revolution.’ (Kojin Karatani — eminent Japanese Marxist.)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Indeed Restore is now treacherous. Let’s not dignify this with an ‘ironically so’.
Adrian Pabst
@AdrianPabst1
The radical right are fusing nativist politics with libertarian economics, invoking @JMilei who wants to reclaim the Falklands from the UK with the tacit support of @realDonaldTrump -- perfidious alliances against Albion
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
An incredible number of mistakes are down to premature judgement. It’s not really avoidable, yet one should try to minimise it.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Well as a Fifties child I’m still a Start-Rite man, appalled by Thatcher’s destruction of community!
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
And the expanded bourgeoisie is really an increasingly proletarianised middle-class.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A language is most fundamentally a fiction.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Isn’t time to tell ourselves that soccer has got way too important and needs somehow to be drained of its big money? Ideally it should return to mainly local boys and girls in local teams paid only somewhat more (given that players retire young) than the average income.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
As an incorrigible boomer I confess my boredom with revived narrative history. I just wildly prefer the history of structures, of ideas and the longue durée. Events matter but I see the decisive contingencies as huge and mysterious, even if most manifested by single individuals.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
After the age of fags and booze came the era of choc in 4 stages: 1. A treat of Cadbury’s on Friday evening; 2. A treat of Thornton’s on Friday and Cadbury’s every evening; 3. Belgian/Lindt once a week, Thornton’s every evening. 4. Single Source once a week, Lindt every evening.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Of course the final era 5 of single source every evening is more or less upon us.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This excellent 2015 book seems to be underread. No other work I know so integrates economics with ecology and world history, thereby somewhat redefining how we should deal with ecological crisis now. A blend of modified Marxism and Lewis Mumford.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Genuine Christian ‘transhumanism’. Rightly understood, the notion of ‘progress’ is the child of Christianity.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
We Must Become Gods www.compactmag.com/article/we-must-become-gods/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
We Must Become Gods www.compactmag.com/article/we-must-become-gods/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It remains a fantastic 7-page read, full of oft-quoted brilliant sentences. In this short diatribe Keynes denounced at once both liberal globalisation and pure economic nationalism. He proposed instead ‘regional’ systematic cooperation, as did Polanyi. Totally relevant to today.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
All the new research on Keynes shows 1. He wanted full socialism in the end, not a ‘saved’ capitalism. 2. He was much influenced by Ruskin. 3. Though not religious he was close to Xn socialism and advocated an ethical not materialist socialism, concerned for ecology and beauty.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The fact that Keynes offered in effect a ‘virtue’ approach to economics under the influence of G. E. Moore’s mode of ethical Platonism is another reason to doubt whether the too rationalistic Macintyre had Moore right. His ‘emotional’ recognition of the good was NOT subjectivism.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Burnham continues so far not to run away from tricky problems. Disability claims are far too high and we need many more young people in work.
-
john milbank reposted
Tony Annett
@tonyannett
The Pope Francis effect.
Ryan Burge 📊
@ryanburge
Just 17% of Gen Z Catholics say that they are politically conservative.
That's half the rate of Millennial Catholics.
Among Gen Z evangelicals, 46% say that they are politically conservative. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Trent turns
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Self portrait with blue door
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Astonishingly silly. Anti-statism has not given us growth. The latter needs good infrastructure, health and governance plus local pride. To these Burnham proposes to add an industrial and investment policy — for growth. Though no doubt he needs to break with ‘fiscal rules’ here.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The hysterical AH actually admits that his mythical English ‘conservative individualism’ has never commanded even 50% of votes. And anyway many of those Tories NOT individualists. The conflation of Burnham with Blair here as regards constitutional shifts is also completely wrong.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
France like Britain needs real socialism but it is senseless for socialists to ally with Russian neo-fascists.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
In the end, governments do not have to ‘pay for things’. This misunderstands the relationship of money to power, which Keynes analysed still more radically (contra Lapavistas here) than Marx. And govts DO successfully ‘back winners’. Post 1945 Attlee ignored 250% national debt!
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
September fortress
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Newark corner
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Quite apart from its reasonably bold and candid content, it is a very good sign that Burnham wrote his conference speech almost entirely by himself.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Some US States remain places of grotesque horror. The death penalty is completely unjustifiable. Humans can legitimately punish within the limits of life. But to take life away exceeds our remit and is itself murder. The inflicters of the death penalty are themselves murderers.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Antioch recalled
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I don’t get this. Surely it is only the owners, not players, managers and fans who should be punished?
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yes — perhaps only religion can restore the associational spirit on which the Left relies.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Fine article on a fine-sounding book.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Burnham had postponed a lot of his radical shifts till after the next election, perhaps calculating (rightly or not) he truly needs a mandate for them. But three years is a long time: I wonder if he is reserving the possibility of going earlier if he can plead a (likely) crisis.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
In 1945 Karl Polanyi prophesied an American ‘reactionary’ attempt to institute global free trade and predicted disaster for GB if she subordinated herself to this. Yet he suggested that facing the resultant crisis at last Disraeli’s English ‘two nations’ might combine. Burnham?
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The number of ‘no reply’ messages from authorities in our lives continues to pile up. Sometimes this means once cannot challenge false statements. It cannot be good.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It is not that Burnham’s Labour pines for the Seventies (or Fifties) but that the Tories and Reform are stuck in the Eighties and Blair is stuck in the Nineties. Neoliberalism was only a historical phase that has now mutated and is in crisis.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yes there is a problem about funding of the NHS and future NCS. But the Continental systems are seriously inequitable and some people more or less left out. Is there a way to combine universal provision with a greater mutual insurance dimension? I don’t know. Wish there was.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Cathected tax stream plus much stricter hierarchisation of medical problems and ‘problems’?
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Reduce our old people’s money in order to pay Britain’s creditors?! This defeatism is conservatism?! Stupefying. It is indeed Burnham who is the patriot — and the unionist.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Suffolk deserves better than this. Fortunately I’m moving there fairly soon! Labour tradition has always had the aesthetic at its very heart. Ruskin was the most read author of the first Labour MP’s. It was Labour who protected the countryside and walking (to pubs!) after 1945.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yes but…Burnham has significantly put foreign affairs under someone arguably left of himself. This might suggest a global anti neoliberal and anti American neocon push. The ways in which Trump might both like and hate this will have to be cunningly negotiated.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yes Burnham has broken with domestic neoliberalism, at least aspirationally. But — to modify OJ — in doing so he is *as much* leaning in to the ‘Blue Labour’ perspective of the red wall margins as he is leaning into the ‘progressive’ faction in the blue wall suburbs and towns.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Thereby Andy has - so far - squared a certain circle.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Our fantasy that we might have pure democracy prevents us from pursuing much *more* democracy. That would mean continuous local participation and assent in symbiosis with the consulting of the wise and supple architectonic, attentive guidance by rulers at all levels.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Wonderful that Thatcher has finally been denounced. She did the opposite of restore British greatness, as has become ever clearer over time.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I just hope that Burnham has the strategy right and would not have been better to risk overriding mandates and scrap the triple lock now, set up social care system now, circumvent the artificial ‘fiscal rules’ now etc. But I wish him only success.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It is tremendous that Andy Burnham spoke openly of the common good and of the UK as a commonwealth. His Catholic background came through here.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Exposes the rationalist myth of ‘the tragedy of the commons’ invoked both for privatisation and state control of shared resources. In reality communities find ways to ensure that individual priorities do not destroy the commons. And in reality there is real group consciousness.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Middle England dream
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Warning to farmers; protecting walkers
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Happy Michaelmas to all
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A sign that Burnham could now hold the crucial centre ground.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
At the minimum this is a vast improvement over Starmer, even if Burnham may need to be still bolder and in faster time to ward off Farage.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yes the left cannot win on the grounds of ideological liberalism — but does this author quite see the need to embrace a politics of teleological and shared flourishing? Does she in the end sound unable to break with the idea primacy of (negative) freedom?
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Essential: highly intelligent and stylishly written. Even left nationalism is not the full answer because the nation state is neither small enough for real popular participation, nor big enough for international cooperation, especially needed with regard to ecological crisis.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Kunkel is only weak I think with regard to its advocacy of open borders for migration contra the Danish SDP. But even here he indicates a dilemma: large scale immigration appears necessary in relation to falling birth rates that don’t look to be realistically reversible.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Boundary (recalled)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Steps recalled
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Man Reviving Left Antisemitism www.compactmag.com/article/the-man-reviving-left-antisemi…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Thomas Hardy was far less merely agnostic than George Eliot, by whose rural tales he was influenced.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I love GM Hopkins — and yet, as a Scotist he had little sense of ascending analogy. His Scotism was part of a quite rigid neo-scholasticism as comes through in his prose writings. In his poetry alone does his overwhelming sense of disclosive particularity allow things to ‘speak’.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank reposted
Mark Lambert
@sitsio
This is BIG.
Pope Leo has just told the bishops of France that laïcité does NOT mean Christianity should retreat from public life and that the answer to France’s secularisation is the public evangelisation of Jesus Christ.
Speaking at Lourdes this morning, Leo insisted that the Church has “every right to be heard in the public square” and possesses, by her very nature, a “prophetic authority”. Then he became remarkably explicit, he told the bishops to defend the Church’s freedom: “to evangelize, to educate about true freedom, and to worship publicly, so that charity may be exercised visibly in the name of Jesus Christ.” Read that again in the context of modern France. The state may be secular. The Church emphatically is not.
Laïcité cannot mean that Catholicism is permitted to survive only as private spirituality, safely contained behind church doors and forbidden from attempting to convert, educate or influence the culture around it.
And Leo went further, he told French Catholics to “reclaim their heritage of faith”. Christianity, in other words, is not some foreign intrusion into French society. Leo reminded the bishops that the Church helped build France, profoundly shaping its culture, art, education and understanding of the human person. So what should the Church do now that France has become one of the most secularised societies in Europe? Leo’s answer could hardly be clearer: “There is only one ‘roadmap,’ which is always the same: to make Jesus Christ known and loved, authentically, passionately, again and again.” That's a really powerful sentence!
And then at Mass in Lourdes the language became even stronger. “Today, not tomorrow,” Leo said, is the time to repent. He recalled Our Lady’s words to Bernadette:
“Penance! Penance! Penance!” And, in a France currently wrestling with profound questions about assisted dying, he warned against attempts “to redefine the value of human life in illness, suffering and old age”.
There are still subjects I want to hear Leo address more directly: abortion, euthanasia, marriage, demographic decline, Islam and the enormous challenge of integration. But the direction of this visit is now unmistakable: reclaim France’s Christian inheritance, defend the Church’s place in public life, call people to repentance and proclaim Christ without embarrassment. Not a strategy for managing Christianity’s decline, a roadmap for reversing it. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
After Church coffee in urban middle England. Typically impressive Anglo-Catholics sustaining ritual, warmth, music and prayer. Mainly elderly but noone has given up and young people are now joining them at the other end of the age spectrum. Such things deserve full CofE support.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Beautifully proportioned late Victorian church architecture: the interior of St Mark’s Mansfield.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
When I emerge from Mass on Sundays I always have an obscure but acute sense that the surrounding streets have been blessed and somehow washed clean into an ordinary radiance.
-
john milbank reposted
James Noyes
@jranoyes
I have long said this. Those small-minded Westminster commentators who obsess about the French Revolution and symbolic secularism demonstrate that they know very little about the actual country. France is a deeply Catholic country in both a cultural and social sense, especially in the vast and empty countryside, where the teachings of the Church still define the lives of families and communities. It is no surprise at all to see this outpouring of support for the Pope in Paris this weekend.
Henri d'Anselme
@Henri_d_Anselme
C'est le monde entier qui vient de se prendre une claque au stade France !
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Donald Sassoon in @NewLeftReview is wrong to lump Blue Labour with the Labour Right. It is an explicitly socialist and anti-capitalist tendency in the ethical socialist tradition much indebted to Polanyi and sometimes Marx. Its moderate social conservatism is in this lineage.
Blue Labour
@blue_labour
Great discussion about Blue Labour, immigration, identity politics, and the need for a new economic model with @Jonathan_Hinder
labourlist.org/2026/09/inside-blue-labour-labour-tribes-p…
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
As @Jonathan_Hinder indicates, excessive immigration is down to ultra-capitalist labour arbitrage. Opposing it is socialist as opposed to libertarian. Equally, as he says, controlling borders is a prerequisite of democratic control that needs a defined area for its exercise.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
In Victorian England organised football barely existed. Cricket was the main outdoor game and it was played also in the winter and even on ice. And by all classes. See the new book 1864: the Year that changed cricket. (Most crucially overarm replaced underarm bowling.)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Are ADHD and Autism over-diagnosed with quite severe socio-economic consequences? Why is this an especially British thing?
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Guess what periodical refers to Andrew not Andy Burnham? New Left Review of course! Only highbrow Marxists it seems sustain formality these days — in the radical aristocratic trad of Perry Anderson.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The left habitually (disastrously?) neglects two opposite seeming problems: 1. The supposed state representatives of the people acting in their own, not the people’s interests; 2. the people themselves preferring the debased. Yet this is a single neglect of the question of virtue
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This is partly why Macintyre, himself on the far left, matters so much. Yet curiously he neglected the specifically political dimension of virtue, as I argued in ‘On Left Integralism’.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Essential reading — even if several claims remain debatable. A very thorough and concise book.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The U.K. needs to switch from too much indirect taxation hitting the poorer to higher taxation of wealth, as on the Continent.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
One gasps at what Allister Heath thinks life is all about: bigger cars, bigger houses, bigger junk food in horrible humid heat. He should leave for Florida now. Yet even he has to mention in passing the flip-side of the US which is dire poverty and much semi-poverty above that.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Heath also fails to mention that manufacturing growth in the American SW is not just helped by low taxes (though those benefit only some) but also post neoliberal Trumpian protection, systematic inshoring reducing supply chains and state provision of infrastructure/education.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Not to mention huge American debt and power of the dollar in the background. European countries simply could not become Florida, even if they were insane enough to want to.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Public Benefit companies can often be superior to outright nationalisation: profit is involved, but subordinated to social purpose. Regulatory structures can ensure that failing to produce the latter results in lower returns and salaries.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Grand New Films About Charles de Gaulle www.compactmag.com/article/dont-miss-the-grand-new-films-…
-
john milbank reposted
Sebastian Milbank
@SebMilbank
This quote is very funny for anyone who has actually read Martin's rambling, incoherent books which at no stage whatsoever engage seriously with any questions of political economy and are in fact a crude pastiche and mishmash of eras, cultures and attitudes.
allie rose
@dreamfyrefairy
His mind 😍😍😍
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Alfa and farmhouse
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Old Alfa GT. note very small front triangle and no numberplate to the side!
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Coxwold parish church
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Medieval glass in Coxwold parish church
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Coxwold tombs
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Unusual circular altar rail in Coxwold parish church (erected around 1780 to deal with problem of huge encroaching tombs on either side!)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Monument to Sterne in Coxwold, where he was ‘perpetual curate’.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Lawrence Sterne’s village: Coxwold in the North Riding of Yorkshire.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Sacred wheels
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
One of many grisly medieval ghost stories recorded by the monks of Byland Abbey
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Byland Abbey, North Riding of Yorkshire
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
We are only faced with resurgent fascism because liberalism has already drifted in a fascistic direction — especially with regard to monetary corporate power.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Nazism is not a species of the genus Fascism. The two political philosophies, though both sinister, are extremely different and only in some ways akin.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It would be better if most commercial popular culture were eradicated. If only serious (including entertaining) stuff was available, people would watch and listen to that.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Bonkers. It’s not Frances Yates’s scholarly and High Anglican view of these things and repeats much that is unfounded. No doubt there was some dark sorcery but all of the best and often Catholic scholarship (Antoine Faivre etc) points to a more positive take on the ‘esoteric’.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘Occultism’ is really a later, 19thC phenomenon. Renaissance natural magic and theurgy was an integral aspect of engagement with Neoplatonism and Hermeticism that was nothing new for Xty, though now intensified. Whether some did bad Goedelic stuff with demons is controverted.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Elizabeth I no more toyed with alchemy etc (though she did) than many a Catholic monarch of this period — and prior to Trent a very Platonic and ‘enchanted’ Catholic reform was on the cards. People should really try to get more academically up to speed on this whole area.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
What Owen Jones says here is true. Complacent ultra-capitalism encouraging the unproductive, and false assumption of military supremacy, *fomenting* Islamism, along with ‘emergency’ suppression of decency have wrecked the west. But one could add the *link* of all this to wokery!
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Postliberals think economic ultra-liberalism and cultural ultra-liberalism are connected. Current populism is a sad fascistic-tending rejection of both, plus legal ‘proceduralism’, favouring authoritarian control on all fronts with inconsistency as to how it views neoliberalism.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Ruthless calm is ethically superior to moral frenzy.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Could it be that Britain is simultaneously moving Left and returning to global leadership, even halting its long retreat from empire? It seems too much to hope but all the same…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
As we wreck nature and expel ourselves from her embrace we can see how the supratemporal event of the Fall is still happening now. And that outside Eden is still lingering Eden. But outside Eden altogether, outside nature, where will we be? Where will anything be?
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Scotland has the highest drug usage in Europe and it just got worse, yet the Church of Scotland has decided to shut up shop. Only a parochial system can deal with this sort of social malaise. @SaveTheParish
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Justice is a primary social imperative. Consent to justice is only a secondary imperative.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Happy Equinox to all this evening.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Truth About Indian Americans www.compactmag.com/article/the-truth-about-indian-americans/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The British legacy is a key part of what enabled great writers like CLR James and Derek Walcott to forge a new, more independent Caribbean legacy. Suppressing that can only weaken Caribbean cohesion and cultural reach.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Is there anything more ghastly than the Lib Dems? Cultural wokery plus Thatcherite economics. The great Jo Grimond would surely now back the continuing SDP.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The clichéd idea of the north tends to allude to industrialised Pennine valleys where smoke and mist mingle in a gritty mirk. It’s then a shock to arrive in York and the vast varied countryside north of this region, for in a way it reverts to ‘southern’ gentility in its own mode.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
More Marvell and Sterne than Brontë country! Though even the latter is largely rural.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I tried in honour of once having lived in the East Riding of Yorkshire to read Winifred Holtby South Riding (really about the East Riding) but found it unreadable. George Eliot she is not, so the Midlands win there. But I recall the TV adaptation of SR being good.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yorkshire people are much more forthcoming and responsive to humour, irony and sharp remarks than are East Midlanders — solid folks as they are.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I doubt if a nostalgic revival of 20thC anti-racism is proportionate to our 21stC problems. Interesting that a focus of this nostalgia should be Nottinghamshire which atypically retains a white predominance. It is not Leicester or Birmingham!
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
www.theguardian.com/type/video tone/comment
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
www.theguardian.com/type/video tone/comment
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yorkshire breakfast: fried bread, not hash browns. No baked beans. Echt English.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Guildhall, York
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yorkshire Gothic
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yorkshire moorland September
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The old Queen in her York Minster niche
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
No one should be ordained priest without some solid knowledge of philosophy besides theology. How can they possibly perform their ‘clerical’ task otherwise? This is more needed today than before, because almost everyone is influenced by pop philosophy in some sense or other.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
What could be more perfect than York on a late September morning? Where I am now.
Post not available here, view on X
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
York streets are retaining their integrity, albeit updated (trendy cheese shops etc) better than Oxford or Cambridge)
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Given the collapse of theology and humanities in universities, York Minster should establish a full scale Cathedral School (in the medieval sense), with perhaps in collaboration with one of the universities.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Everyone who was at the Zermatt Future of Europe Summit, and others, this is Benjamin Britten’s Alpine Suite for three recorders, composed and first performed (by Britten’s touring party) in Zermatt.
This post is unavailable. See it on X.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A member of his holiday party injured her leg; they were hotel-bound but had their recorders with them, so this resulted.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Do everyone listen. It is playful, inventive and charming. Modernist Baroque.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Do listen!
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Scottish and Welsh home rule would work far better without nationalist parties. So far it is mainly them who have screwed it up. Eg the tragic decline in Scottish education.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I agree. The CofE faces a parallel choice. At the same time we have to be extremely careful of *some* young people embracing religion to a degree as part of a far right nationalist agenda. Whatever our own politics what is genuine in their return to Xty has to be sifted out.
Mark Lambert
@sitsio
Ces chiffres sont vertigineux. Quelles que soient les explications que l'on puisse avancer, sécularisation, démographie, histoire particulière de la France, la chute du nombre de prêtres, de paroisses et de baptêmes depuis 1980 nous oblige à reconnaître une réalité assez simple : quelque chose n'a manifestement pas fonctionné.
Et pourtant, au moment même où les statistiques institutionnelles semblent catastrophiques, un phénomène beaucoup plus encourageant apparaît.
Des milliers d'adultes demandent aujourd'hui le baptême en France, avec une présence particulièrement frappante des jeunes. Les pèlerinages attirent des foules considérables et le catholicisme traditionnel manifeste lui aussi une vitalité remarquable auprès d'une nouvelle génération.
Il faudrait peut-être prendre cela très au sérieux.
La question pour Léon XIV, lors de sa visite en France, ne devrait donc pas être seulement de savoir comment gérer le déclin, mais où l'Église grandit réellement, qui vient à elle, et ce que ces nouveaux catholiques recherchent.
Car je me demande si beaucoup de jeunes ne cherchent pas précisément ce que l'Église a parfois hésité à leur offrir : la transcendance, la beauté, l'appartenance, une exigence morale, une identité clairement catholique et, par-dessus tout, une rencontre avec le Christ.
Ils connaissent déjà parfaitement la modernité séculière. Ils vivent en son sein.
Ce qu'ils semblent chercher dans l'Église est quelque chose qu'elle seule peut leur donner.
La France fut appelée « la fille aînée de l'Église ». Ces statistiques racontent l'histoire d'un effondrement extraordinaire. Mais cette nouvelle génération de catholiques français pourrait bien raconter le commencement d'une histoire beaucoup plus encourageante.
La question est de savoir si l'Église institutionnelle est prête à les écouter. press.vatican.va/content/salastampa/en/bollettino/pubblic… -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Imagine the furore if I wrote equivalently ‘white men are brave, witty and romantic.’
-
john milbank reposted
Adrian Pabst
@AdrianPabst1
Can Reform UK pursue a politics of disruption when the voters it seeks to mobilise want greater security?
Jason Cowley in @thetimes
Why Reform is pinning hopes on voters who hardly ever turn up
www.thetimes.com/article/cd390391-3041-471a-ba01-86ad2ed2… -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Moth emergency! Have to do a eulogy at a funeral tomorrow but find all my dark suits have been eaten! Crisis logistics now being put into place.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Diana fiasco does not justify Harry’s hypocritical behaviour (career-banking on his birth while denouncing his own family) and it is appalling that Earl Spencer is now supporting this. What is his and Harry’s endgame? Dethrone Charles and William, else destroy the monarchy?
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This is horrific and Europe must not go down this road.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Excessive immigration has been a mistake, as even left politicians seem to have secretly known but feared to stop in fear of being branded racist. But repatriation (save of illegal migrants who then commit crimes) is bound to be cruel and to result in general social repression.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A druggy Muslim gay parody of western and asian art (yes the art is fairly skilful) is only ‘a challenge to the west’ (or to the historic east) if we grant it more prominence than it merits.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The same goes for Muslim ‘socialist’ politics that is actually far too wedded to crazy woke projects like disbanding the police and systematic reparations. How are we to understand such things as anything other than an attempt to undermine western order?
-
john milbank reposted
Sebastian Milbank
@SebMilbank
Scotland really pulled off an incredible trick of being the vanguard of British imperialism for 400 years then going decolonial small bean mode at the very last minute.
Cú Chullain
@paddyb53
As the end of the 'United Kingdom' draws near and England pleads with Scotland, Wales and the 6 occupied counties in Ireland to stay, never forget it was England that invaded our three countries, tried to ban our languages and murdered millions of our people....just saying....
-
john milbank reposted
Sebastian Milbank
@SebMilbank
For this reason I'm a Christian and Tory Socialist - I am suspicious of the big Fabian state, but keen on great public control of the economy, but ideally by means of direct shareholding, mutualism, and a stronger worker or small businessman
-
john milbank reposted
Sebastian Milbank
@SebMilbank
Worth noting that the most virulent suppression of Gaelic culture was primarily imposed by *Lowland Scots* not the big bad Anglo. I'm challenging Scots nats to learn the absolute basics of their own history
𝖙𝖗𝖎𝖘 🏴
@treasonoustris
I feel like all the English cunts who tell Welsh, Scottish and Irish people that we're larping victimhood forget that they literally outlawed each of our respective languages to the point you'd be beaten in school for saying "aye" instead of "yes"
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Mourning the Matterhorn
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
An absurd article that totally ignores the clear correlation between the decline of stable marriage and the extreme drop in the number of births. Quite regardless of its irresponsibility: being legitimate may no longer matter in law, but it seriously matters in reality.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Interesting — though class is more crossed by both culture and relation to State than this allows? Eg aren’t a lot of liberal-left professionals in reality in some sort of managerial role within the public sector. (Lasch, Piccone ‘new class’ needed more analytic attention here)
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
And one can be serving capitalist interests by serving the state that is inherently linked to capitalism even when one is in denial about that.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yesterday from Swiss train
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The AI risk is not of a fantasised superman destroying us, but of human narcissistic ‘supermen’ like Musk extending their oligarchic domination. In the face of this we have to ask ‘what makes us human?’ Can universal emancipation be after all linked to a neo-corporatism of role?
Adrian Pabst
@AdrianPabst1
Face aux risques de l’IA, il faut méditer l’essai de Slavoy Žižek @Slavojiek dans @Grand_Continent – le paradoxe
« la croissance explosive de l’intelligence artificielle, qui nous contrôle précisément au moment où nous nous percevons comme libres »
legrandcontinent.eu/fr/dimanches/le-pire-scenario-nest-pa… -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I completely agree. No two European countries are as deeply similar (for reasons listed) as Britain and France. Today they are natural allies and a renewed entente cordiale is crucial for the whole world. Vive La France! says this Britisher.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Wisdom presided over Athens, but Rome was led forth by Beauty.
-
john milbank reposted
Adrian Pabst
@AdrianPabst1
"He has become a tribune of disaffected working-class and lower-middle-class voters. Even if he resigned tomorrow, the anti-liberal forces he has unlocked will continue to shape British politics [...] There is no turning back"
www.thetimes.com/article/8e5872dc-aac8-4179-9500-74873925… -
john milbank reposted
Adrian Pabst
@AdrianPabst1
Face aux risques de l’IA, il faut méditer l’essai de Slavoy Žižek @Slavojiek dans @Grand_Continent – le paradoxe
« la croissance explosive de l’intelligence artificielle, qui nous contrôle précisément au moment où nous nous percevons comme libres »
legrandcontinent.eu/fr/dimanches/le-pire-scenario-nest-pa… -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Rémi Brague in Zermatt: ‘Christianity is blamed for imposing strict moral rules, yet these are the same almost banal but necessary moral rules embraced by most human cultures. The rejection of them is the rejection of civilisation, not just Christianity’. (Roughly)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Sanity from WH
Will Hutton
@williamnhutton
Jim Ratcliffe has lost confidence in the world’s 3rd largest innovation economy with two fifths of Europes high growth young companies. Ignorant and ill-informed this tax exile deserves no air time www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm0463619r1no
-
john milbank reposted
Marcus Walker
@WalkerMarcus
It was really interesting to be put through my paces by the @ChurchTimes and have the opportunity to explore the underlying theology of what we’re doing in Save the Parish.
Church Times
@ChurchTimes
This week on our podcast, Stephen Cherry sat down with @WalkerMarcus to discuss the Save the Parish campaign. Tune in now to learn more about the thinking behind the campaign.
Out now on our website or on your favourite podcast platform.
➡️ www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2026/18-september/audio-vi… -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘On the Sublime’
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
In Zermatt
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Matterhorn
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Just heard a disgusting tirade in Zermatt from Ulrich Schlueer a far right AdF friendly Swiss politician. He wants a German-Russian alliance to ‘renew’ Europe. In reality it would be an authoritarian alliance against the Catholic, Humanist and constitutional European legacy.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘The Magic Mountain’
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Rémi Brague later clarified his view on the ultimate fate of Sarah Mullaly: ‘she will be in the very lowest cuticle of hell: that of the traitors, along with Cassius, Brutus and Judas’.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Circle should read, not cuticle
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I had an interesting interaction in Zermatt with the highly insightful and learned Rémi Brague that was sort of (but I caricature) Anglican integralism vs French Catholic care of Republican laicité.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Here in Zermatt, a former minister under Mitterrand is pointing out that the shape of Europe after the war was the work of the USSR and then the US. There was never any *independent* project of European unity even with the EU. That is only being perforce considered *now*.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
He adds that the elites must listen to the people as regards the inherent link of sovereignty to popular control, the importance of restricting immigration and stopping completely illegal immigration and pretend asylum seekers (maybe 90%).
Post not available here, view on X
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Vedrine says that Europe beyond the EU must now create a way to defend itself and that this effort is ‘unthinkable’ without the U.K. But also that the U.K. must rearm more rapidly.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Vedrine also says that French govts of the recent past, including those on the Left, all *knew* that they needed severely to restrict immigration, but failed to do so out of fear of the bien-pensant left liberal press that could have ensured they lost the next election…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Hard to imagine the mix of politics, philosophy and Christian theology, that is rolled out here in Zermatt with perfect naturalness, happening back in the UK.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Lots of Euro anger with Mullaly in Zermatt. Rémi Brague, one of Europe’s top philosophers, asked ‘which special new circle of Dante’s hell would be reserved for her?’ A bossy nurse out of her depth. Putting her where she is was institutional cruelty, as with Jason Arday.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Matterhorn emerges
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Below the Matterhorn
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The event I am currently at
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘Europe must return to its core as demanded by Jan Patocka: the commitment to reason as something not mainly human (and so tyrannical) but rather divine and free, concrete and therefore incomprehensible. Incarnate reason.’ (Bertrand Vergely in Zermatt — again I summarise.)
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘The real encounter with transcendence is neither submission nor permissiveness. It is something in a certain sense interior and ‘discreet’ in the sense of Baltazar Gracian’. (Bertrand Vergely in Zermatt — I summarise).
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘Did Christ dream? Do we continue to dream Christ?’ Bertrand Vergely in Zermatt.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Ties are very modern. Previously male neck attire was less self-strangling. And people had less self-strangled, more Romantic thoughts.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Yawn. This one has been around for years.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Train through Switzerland
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
View from my hotel window in Zermatt
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
I want one!
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
In Zermatt Emmanuel Tourpe called for a new politics of love and friendship.
-
john milbank reposted
Ryan Haecker
@RyanHaecker
Seven years ago, I hosted, with a team of PhD students, the New Trinitarian Ontologies conference at the University of Cambridge. @Cambridge_Uni @DivinityCam @Peterhouse_Cam
With 33 speakers and over 300 delegates from around the world, it was the largest philosophical theology conference held at Cambridge in living memory.
Along with @johnmilbank3, @jdlyonhart, and many others, I am proud of what we accomplished, and the work that continues with @MasperoGiulio, @philipgonzales8, @EduardFiedler, and many others to promote speculative explorations of the Trinity.
New Trinitarian Ontologies
@NTOntologies
Seven years ago, we hosted the 2019 New Trinitarian Ontologies conference at the University of Cambridge.
Watch the proceedings here:
youtu.be/7tMaZAIhemw -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Failure to see that the de-ethicisation of politics and economics lies at the core of modernity causes both liberals and Marxists to read pre-modern history in an entirely cynical way, as if its assumptions of an ethical politics and economics were a sham. C.Dawson an antidote.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Sylvie Perez is rightly arguing here in Zermatt that unnatural deviations from nature (eg in relation to human birth) are parodies of our supernatural transcendence of nature.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Is Lambeth simply located on a different planet?
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
‘Kant’s morality was not a question of good and evil but of freedom (spontaneous self-determination)…In the absence of this kind of morality there can be no communism’. (K. Karatani). But this is why Kant is unethical and nihilistic and Marxism is still liberalism.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It’s now pretty clear that liberalism
Is anti sex. -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Let’s hope water is taken back into real public control.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Am supping in the bar of an elegant Parisian hotel, but having to listen to some ghastly brash English woman talking awful business-stuff in a loud voice with the odd bit of foul language thrown-in. Definitely sticking to French for the evening.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
En route for Zermatt in the Swiss Alps tomorrow via TGV for a conference on The Crisis of Europe.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
We lack an analysis of why the grotesque is now so celebrated and not in any redemptive mode. Rather, in the name of a sort of sham anti-aesthetic democracy, seeking to dethrone beauty as the last trace of the divine amongst us. Eg the current Boots TV commercial.
-
john milbank reposted
James Noyes
@jranoyes
Definitely agree. One of the books that most marked me as a young man. Carr is also an interesting character. His series of County Maps of England published by the Quince Tree Press after the war is captivating and full of unusual detail. I have one of the original maps of Norfolk from that series, signed by Carr and stamped, which I inherited from my grandfather.
Nicholas Boys Smith
@boys_nicholas
I strongly agree. I read it by chance about 10 years and keep meaning to re-read it. This feels like a prompt !
Dominic Sandbrook
@dcsandbrook
Today on @bookclubpodhq Tabitha and I explore a truly beautiful novel, J. L. Carr's A MONTH IN THE COUNTRY.
The memory of the Great War, the English countryside, art, love, loss - this is such a moving book. Everybody should read it.
🏴 linktr.ee/thebookclub -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
So will the left now realise that from 1789 anti-colonialism is an American capitalist strategy that favours its own counter-empire? There never has or will be a world without empire: a nationalist fantasy on both left and far-right. The issue is always craft a juster empire.
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Behind MAGA’s Anti-Colonial Turn www.compactmag.com/article/behind-magas-anti-colonial-turn/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Behind MAGA’s Anti-Colonial Turn www.compactmag.com/article/behind-magas-anti-colonial-turn/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The advice here is keep Chinese investment under state not market control, as Spain does, if Germany wants to ward off the AfD.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Tasks of humanist creative thinking that can supposedly be automated aren’t tasks of humanist critical thinking. It’s amazing how many journos have ‘tech brain’.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Adam Kuper is surely right that something approximating the nuclear family embedded within kinship structures that are biological besides symbolic is well-nigh universal and not a ‘western construct’. His view fits an overcoming of nature-culture dualism.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Labour will not be threatened by the Piddington factor if the Right-wing vote is split between Tories and Reform, as is not unlikely. Burnham wisely calculates that Paddington won’t vote Labour anyway. And they may balk at Reform hint of thuggery as Kemi gets tougher on migrants
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This well-hyped book is certainly worth a read and it is very short. Bottom line: the collapse of civil association favours the authoritarian right and the left can only recover by restoring institutional association. But author knows his suggestions for doing that are forlorn.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Shared with you by a Times subscriber.
Enjoy this article for free.
www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/enemy-is-iran… -
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Great article by Allison Pearson. Extremely thorough. It is though worth mentioning that the @savetheparish Windsor report was written by Alison Milbank who is absolutely not a Tory! The concerns Pearson so brilliantly expresses entirely transcend secular right vs left.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The Windsor report shows that clergy shortage in the CofE is considerably down to policy failure in many dimensions. Some bishops concede this, openly or tacitly; the ones denying it are reduced to marginal carping and spluttering. The wind is in the sails of @SaveTheParish
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Important report from @savetheparish
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Important report from @savetheparish
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Forget the Celtic Tiger, Ireland is now a freeloading Celtic Cuckoo www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/08/19/ireland-cuckoo-econom…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Cambridge professor loses key ally from letter of support www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/08/03/cambridge-professor-a…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
There is no inherent connection between empiricism and materialism.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
It has and this is awful. Quite terrifying for academics in this country. www.spiked-online.com/2026/04/30/the-high-court-has-rewar…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
British Gothic 288: Southwell Minster
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
This is really grave. Thiel was totally in with Epstein; Mandelson likely helped negotiate the huge involvement of Palantir in our defence industry. A surveillance company run by a man opposed to democracy, welfare and the political state as such!
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Mandelson’s links with US tech firm Palantir must be fully exposed, campaigners warn - The Guardian apple.news/ALotsbsLZTvyUGVxWNyp5Bg
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Mandelson’s links with US tech firm Palantir must be fully exposed, campaigners warn - The Guardian apple.news/ALotsbsLZTvyUGVxWNyp5Bg
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Agree or disagree, whether you are left or right, Benanav’s 90 page NLR two-parter is, along with Brenner, the cleverest analysis of where we are now and how to escape. Non-dogmatically he mixes Marx, Keynes, Polanyi and even Hayek to produce something seriously different.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The crisis of our universities is a crisis for our cities in terms of knock-on effects. Nottingham especially relies economically to some degree on its two (up till now at least) high-ranking universities. I hope the vice-chancellors are meeting with city elders to devise a plan.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Southwell Minster on Corpus Christi
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Of course Francis is open to criticism on various fronts, but in the end American Catholics opposed to him and his official writings were against him because of his strong opposition to an unqualified capitalist economic global order.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
From America with Love | Sebastian Milbank | The Critic Magazine thecritic.co.uk/from-america-with-love/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Apocalyptic Reaganism thecritic.co.uk/apocalyptic-reaganism/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
How will 2025 turn out? The life of Jimmy Carter offers an unexpected clue | Jonathan Freedland www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2025/jan/03/2025-jimmy-…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The first quarter of this century is over. It has been pretty awful. Unless we move in a sensible and coherent postliberal direction, the next quarter will be a global nightmare.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Absolutely massive thanks to all who participated in the Corpus Christi Cambridge 2024 Postliberalism Conference: to speakers, audience, sponsors. There was truly serious, convivial political debate without partisan rancour. The Centre for Social Renewal is profoundly grateful.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
The tragedy is that the good economic things Biden did were still nothing like enough in the face of 40 years of wage stagnation.
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
Don’t idolise Roger Scruton | Sebastian Milbank | The Critic Magazine thecritic.co.uk/dont-idolise-roger-scruton/
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
A new essay by me in The Hedgehog Review hedgehogreview.com/issues/theological-variations/articles…
-
john milbank
@johnmilbank3
There is no 'Enlightenment music' only 'Baroque music' and that should tell us a very great deal. The Baroque was a bigger reality.































































































































