Let’s end this debate.
Full disclosure, I’m one of the many art collectors scrambling to work directly with Joe (Quitely’s rep, yes, this is coming directly from Quitely) to try and acquire this piece of comic’s history.
I think this All-Star Superman trade cover not only says it all, it ends the conversation. When Grant and Vin wrapped their acclaimed run, Vin drew one final image—crystallizing their story and Superman forever. This image.
I’ll start this rant by saying I’m endlessly fascinated by how stories re-manifest across time and cultures—the same structures wearing different skins. It’s as if they are these invisible, eternal monoliths that exist outside of space and time, just waiting to be uncovered and repainted. That brings me to this little essay about All-Star Superman—aka 2D Jesus.
Thousands of creators have worked on both Batman and Superman over the decades—sculpting them, refining them, nudging them closer and closer to what I’d argue are their final forms.
Batman, in The Dark Knight Returns by Frank Miller: the most grounded man of grounded men. Untrusting of everything. Prepared to take down his own friends if needed. Hopeless in a bleak world. Literally operating in the dark. A completely material existence as Bruce Wayne. Entirely mortal. The godless man.
Superman, in All-Star Superman: the pure symbol of hope. Powered by the sun (the light). Coming from above. Essentially a god living humbly as a man—who knows his time on Earth is limited. Who doesn’t leave until even the man who schemed to kill him is saved. He leaves behind not just strength, but his example of goodness. His message of hope. His way.
This All-Star Superman cover—especially when placed next to DKR #2—makes the contrast clear. It’s like 70+ years of mythology were funneled through two Franks: inky grit from Frank Miller, graphite grace from Frank Quitely. Bookending these icons. Elevating them to their ultimate forms.
What blows my mind is this: how do we instinctively—and sometimes unconsciously—just know when Batman is acting like Batman? Or when Superman is being Superman? We all feel it. We all know it. Separately, and somehow collectively. And that’s wild to me.
And it’s not just the thousands of creators—it’s the millions of fans, too. Readers supported the versions and runs they loved most, telling editors and publishers what resonated through their buying power. They helped turn story arcs into evergreen myth. Together, fans and creators co-sculpted these characters into what they are now.
Miller deconstructed Batman into his gritty, inky essence. Morrison and Quitely crystallized Superman into his final, divine form—and Frank Quitely actually had the balls to just draw it with this definitive final cover. This image reminds me of those Jesus-on-a-plate pictures hanging in your grandma’s kitchen. And I love that.
Lastly, I’m calling The Dark Knight Returns and All-Star Superman the bookends of these characters. Not because they’re everyone’s favorite versions—though for many, they are. My claim is this: whatever your favorite version of Batman or Superman is… it probably lives somewhere between these two books, and these two images. These are the myths—actualized, fully formed.
Batman’s bookend by Frank Miller sold for almost 500k at auction 11-12 years back, and the comic art market has only went into the stratosphere since then.
Superman’s bookend by Frank Quitely is being offered directly from the artist for 50k today. Tell me again how this is a rip off.
@BritComicsArt
They are asking for $50,000 for this pencil piece used as the cover and trade of ALL STAR SUPERMAN - art by Frank Quietly. Would love to hear your opinion.