A Tale of Two Legal Fees: Double Standards and Questionable Accountability.
The recent revelation that Sierra Leone is being sued by U.S. law firm Jenner & Block for an outstanding balance of $8.1 million, following a $3.6 million payment, starkly contrasts with its previous stance on legal fees paid under the former administration. This discrepancy highlights a troubling pattern of double standards that undermines public trust and good governance.
In 2018, the government established a commission of inquiry (COI) to investigate professional fees paid during the tenure of former President Ernest Bai Koroma. The inquiry, chaired by Honourable Justice Biobelle Georgewill, scrutinized a $270,000 payment for defending the case Sam Sumana v. Attorney General & Victor Foh before the Supreme Court. The commission deemed this payment "exorbitant" and labeled it a "subterfuge to launder money." Consequently, prominent legal figures, including Franklyn Bai Kargbo, Agibola Emmanuel Manly-Spain, and the law firm Basma & Macaulay, were held liable by the COI to refund two-thirds of the sum to the Consolidated Revenue Fund, with recommendations for potential prosecution which was accepted by the government under the administration of the former Attorney General Dr. Priscilla Schwatz.
However, the current government now finds itself entangled in a legal dispute with Jenner & Block over unpaid fees exceeding $8 million. The firm was retained in 2019 to represent Sierra Leone in a dispute against Gerald International Ltd., which threatened the country with potential damages of $1.8 billion. While Sierra Leone has already paid $3.6 million, it now disputes the validity of an alleged oral contract for further payments, claiming the firm has not sufficiently substantiated its claims.
Although the COI decision was subsequently reversed on appeal, this glaring double standard raises serious questions about the motives behind the 2018 inquiry.Was it a genuine pursuit of accountability, or a politically motivated witch hunt? Moreover, if the government deemed $270,000 an “exorbitant sum” and “subterfuge to launder money." how can it justify $3.6 million dollars already paid? And in the event Jenner & Block wins their claim for the balance sum of $8.1 million dollars how can it further justify a potential payment exceeding $11 million to an international law firm? In light of the apparent contradictions and the fact that the decision against our senior colleagues Franklyn Bai Kargbo, Agibola Emmanuel Manly-Spain, and the law firm Basma & Macaulay, has been reversed on appeal, will the new AG be a breath of fresh air at the justice department, start to heal some of the wounds and embark on a damage repair exercise by at the very least tendering to them a public apology for and on behalf of the state?