Tao has discovered, in the flavor of his particular world, the wages of Outputism.
x.com/MattPirkowski/status/1721683937800618478
I feel like the people criticizing this letter have not really taken the time to read it
Tao is not saying that AI should not be used for math
In fact, I think that he is an advocate for using AI to support math research
What he is saying is that there is a problem with the big AI companies racing to check off as true or false big famous problems because the approach they are taking is not advancing human understanding
The goal of math is not to simply check off as true or false a list of things, but rather to increase human understanding of human thought
And right now, while I guess it’s sort of interesting to know the answers to these problems, human understanding is not really being advanced and the things that were valuable about math in the first place are getting lost
This is a very thoughtful point and it is not simply “gatekeeping” or whatever

































































































































































