religionnews.com/2026/06/02/pope-leo-begins-to-update-jus… @RNS
religionnews.com/2026/05/22/what-memorial-day-once-meant-… @RNS
Politicians, athletes, journalists, NGOs, companies... They all use corporation-owned social networks to communicate with us. Citizens shouldn't have to hand over their data to companies to read content published by public entities. Public Feeds changes that by making posts of popular accounts freely available. Read more.
Mark Silk is an American academic. He is Professor of Religion in Public Life at Trinity College, where he also serves as the Director the Leonard E. Greenberg Center for the Study of Religion in Public Life. In addition, Silk is a Contributing Editor of the Religion News Service, specializing in Spiritual Politics. More on Wikipedia
Of course Mauser is an amoral jerk. religionnews.com/2026/01/05/marty-supreme-is-a-classic-am… @RNS
The real purpose of Trump's Xmas day bombing of Nigeria: religionnews.com/2025/12/29/our-age-of-religious-politics/ @RNS
The VP's Christian American creed. religionnews.com/2025/12/22/jd-vance-includes-the-unspeak… @RNS
Why not teach about the impact of religion on American history? religionnews.com/2025/11/28/ohios-charlie-kirk-education-… @RNS
Christian nationalism nixes the Judeo-Christian tradition: religionnews.com/2025/11/18/on-the-right-judeo-christian-… @RNS
Trump goes full Catholic: religionnews.com/2025/11/10/president-trumps-saintly-mess… @RNS
American Jewish anxiety, to the left and to the right: religionnews.com/2025/11/06/the-greater-worry-mamdani-or-… @RNS
Demonic possession from The Exorcist back to the Middle Ages...Happy Halloween! religionnews.com/2025/10/31/scary-demons-only-if-you-harb… @RNS
Oklahoma's Christian nationalist culture war: religionnews.com/2025/10/29/in-walters-wake-oklahoma-push… @RNS
Ramaswamy's Hinduism v. TPUSA: religionnews.com/2025/10/17/give-ramaswamy-an-a-on-his-ch… @RNS
A cautionary note from the Bible's least attractive prophet: religionnews.com/2025/10/09/the-prophet-jonahs-lesson-for… @RNS
Love v. Hate at the Kirk memorial service: religionnews.com/2025/09/26/charlie-kirks-memorial-servic… @RNS
When the right pushes back against the left's criticism of "thoughts and prayers": religionnews.com/2025/09/22/when-liberals-decry-thoughts-… @RNS
MAGA has found its Horst Wessel: religionnews.com/2025/09/16/charlie-kirk-is-fast-becoming… @RNS
Trump v. Kaine re: the Declaration's god-given rights: religionnews.com/2025/09/11/trump-versus-kaine-on-god-giv… @RNS
Rabbis' criticism of Israel's devastation of Gaza falls short of Netanyahu: religionnews.com/2025/08/26/rabbis-criticize-israeli-gove… @RNS
Why you should read the Texas judge's Ten Commandments injunction: religionnews.com/2025/08/21/texas-judge-enjoyably-enjoins…. (Spoiler alert: it a hoot.) @RNS
When religious needs to be limited: religionnews.com/2025/08/20/scotus-supported-parents-righ… @RNS
Euthanasia on the march in Canada: religionnews.com/2025/08/15/why-has-canada-embraced-eutha… @RNS
Does the arc of the moral universe really bend toward justice? religionnews.com/2025/07/31/what-the-story-of-the-charles… @RNS
There's a new religion jurisprudence in town: religionnews.com/2025/07/28/the-supreme-courts-radical-re… @RNS
How Washington State botched a child protection law: religionnews.com/2025/07/25/how-to-botch-a-children-prote… @RNS
No, Virginia. Trump's IRS didn't kill of the Johnson Amendment: religionnews.com/2025/07/21/the-trump-irs-keeps-the-johns… @RNS
When do you think public school students should be permitted to opt out: religionnews.com/2025/06/30/a-quiz-on-the-supreme-courts-… @RNS
On the morality of bombing Iran: religionnews.com/2025/06/23/was-it-moral-to-bomb-iran/ @RNS
Pope Leo's reviving the papal vacation at Castel Gandolfo. Here's something for him to do: religionnews.com/2025/06/18/the-new-popes-going-on-vacati… @RNS
The conservative evangelical charged with assassination in Minnesota is a radical leftist? Uh, no. religionnews.com/2025/06/16/how-not-to-deal-with-the-assa… @RNS
Madison wouldn't have approved of the Oklahoma religious charter school either: religionnews.com/2025/05/23/the-establishment-clause-live… @RNS
Pat on the back to the American Jewish Committee for working with ed groups to condemn 1) campus antisemitism and 2) Trump administration's campaign against same: religionnews.com/2025/05/20/its-possible-to-criticize-cam… @RNS
Pope Leo XIV v. Right-wing "Americanism": religionnews.com/2025/05/09/whats-in-the-new-popes-name-a… @RNS
Criticism of the late pope is traditional. Will it make a difference? religionnews.com/2025/05/06/criticism-of-the-late-pope-is… @RNS
How fundamentalism has shaped American Catholicism: religionnews.com/2025/04/29/the-fundamentalist-strain-in-… @RNS
Trump's hateful Easter message: religionnews.com/2025/04/21/we-should-be-shocked-by-trump… @RNS
How satanic is Trump? AI answers: religionnews.com/2025/04/18/trump-and-satan-the-ai-analysis/ @RNS
Moses was a stranger in a strange land. Now us: religionnews.com/2025/04/15/when-america-becomes-a-strang… @RNS
Yeshiva U. sows confusion with decision to allow LGBTQ club — maybe on purpose: religionnews.com/2025/04/01/yeshiva-university-accepts-an… @RNS
The movement to place the 10 Commandments in classrooms is winning some, losing others — and may well succeed in Scotus: religionnews.com/2025/03/27/why-not-post-the-ten-commandm…. @RNS
A fight of biblical proportions in Oklahoma schools: religionnews.com/2025/03/18/in-oklahoma-a-fight-of-biblic… @RNS
When trolling columns gets out of hand: religionnews.com/2025/03/06/trolls-gotta-troll-but-there-… @RNS
Trump DOJ doesn't like a federal judge asking one of its attorneys WWJD. WTF? religionnews.com/2025/02/28/should-a-judge-be-censured-fo… @RNS
Catholic bishops right to sue Trump administration for disgracefully suspending funds committed by Congress to pay for refugee settlement services: religionnews.com/2025/02/24/catholic-bishops-sue-trump-ad… @RNS
Criticize the late Chabad rebbe at your peril, a case in point: religionnews.com/2025/02/21/criticize-the-late-chabad-reb… @RNS
Trump's new-old Faith Center is the latest if hardly the greatest chapter in the saga of George W. Bush's faith-based initiative: religionnews.com/2025/02/13/the-white-house-has-a-faith-o… @RNS
Idaho legislature's anti-ssm "memorial" is performative MAGA cosplay: religionnews.com/2025/01/31/idaho-goes-after-same-sex-mar… @RNS
Trump's religious opposition is rising: religionnews.com/2025/01/28/the-gathering-force-of-trumps… @RNS
Running down the clergy who did and didn't pray at Trump's inauguration: religionnews.com/2025/01/22/all-the-presidents-clergy/ @RNS
Next time around, should Democrats play the religion card like they did in 2006? Meh-be: religionnews.com/2025/01/02/should-the-democrats-re-embra… @RNS
Jimmy Carter's most consequential legacy: the religious right: religionnews.com/2024/12/30/how-jimmy-carter-created-the-… @RNS
Last I checked, little Denmark is a member of NATO, which would be obliged to defend Greenland if it is attacked. Of course, if the the U.S. leaves NATO...
Trump’s former Ambassador to Denmark Carla Sands:
“The idea that little Denmark, which can’t even defend its own territory can defend Greenland, is preposterous…I think that what President Trump is suggesting [to buy Greenland] is a common-sense solution”x.com/Ronxyz00/status/1872647183578845492/video/1
The Hanukkah story isn't what you think it is. It's darker...and more relevant to today: religionnews.com/2024/12/24/the-real-hanukkah-story-and-w… @RNS
When an Ohio teacher was punished for having gender-nonconforming books in her classroom, she sued in federal court: religionnews.com/2024/12/13/when-a-public-schoolteacher-i… @RNS
Explaining the yawning gap between religious elites and public opinion on assisted suicide: religionnews.com/2024/12/04/religious-elites-oppose-assis…
@rns.org
Texas makes public education great again...for religion: religionnews.com/2024/11/26/texas-makes-public-education-… @RNS
Anti-abortion extremism has created an unbridgeable divide between the pro-life movement and the American public: religionnews.com/2024/11/21/the-abortion-divide-has-becom… @RNS
His prayer? "Thank Heaven for little girls."
I don't know what Matt Gaetz believes, but he certainly likes to run in evangelical circles and speak in evangelical language. currentpub.com/2024/11/19/is-matt-gaetz-an-evangelical/
So what's the likelihood that Trump threw Gaetz a bone because he was about to be kicked out of the House, knowing that the Senate won't confirm him?
Mark Silk reposted
Dems are like, “we take institutions seriously so we’ll nominate Merrick Garland who will be meticulous and slow so no one will ever suspect him of political bias” and GOP is like “LOL MATT GAETZ AS AG”
A Christian Zionist will be representing the US in Israel: religionnews.com/2024/11/13/a-christian-zionist-will-be-o… @RNS
Hegseth, Gabbard & Gaetz will make US a banana peel republic.
How religious demography and religious values behaved in the election. Spoiler alert: not so well. religionnews.com/2024/11/07/did-religion-matter-in-the-el… @RNS
It was Cujo.
Authoritarian movements are religious movements...around the world and in the U.S.: religionnews.com/2024/10/31/authoritarian-movements-are-r… @RNS
I wonder how he'd respond to a comedian who said, "I don’t know if you guys heard this, but there’s literally a steaming mountain of garbage in the middle of the country right now. Yeah. I think it’s called Appalachia."
Vance: I have heard about the joke… Maybe it's a stupid, racist joke.. Maybe it is not. But we have to stop getting so offended at every little thing can a United States of America. I’m so over it
This suggests otherwise: www.as-coa.org/articles/chart-how-us-latinos-voted-2020-p….
Harris is doing best in PA with Latinos of all the swing states.
PA had huge Latino rightward shifts in 2020 & 2022 meaning there was a lot of Democratic crossovers to Republicans. That existing registration history suggests they can also be brought back.
Trump's Madison Square Rally harks back to Blaine's "Rum, Romanism, and Rebellion" NYC rally of 1884: religionnews.com/2024/10/28/trumps-rally-harks-back-to-th… @RNS
Mark Silk reposted
In which case, all of us should retweet!
NYT tweeted this to its 55 million followers and it has under 500 retweets - presumably suppressed due to the link out. “John Kelly, Donald Trump’s longest-serving chief of staff, said Trump met the definition of a fascist and would try to govern like a dictator if elected”
Transportation, communication, health care...
Time for straight talk. Trump is a perpetrator of evil. religionnews.com/2024/10/15/donald-trump-perpetrator-of-e… @RNS
Mark Silk reposted
Just seeing this - fantastic
Musk keeps deleting this video. I wonder why?
x.com/MA_Joyful_Again/status/1830267661428912582/video/1
Anti-Zionist antisemitism is not your grandfather's antisemitism. How come: religionnews.com/2024/10/07/what-makes-anti-zionist-antis… @RNS
The God Gap abides...but is going to require new metrics: religionnews.com/2024/10/01/the-god-gap-abides-up-to-a-po… @RNS
What up with the candidates' religious commitments? Political reporters should be asking: religionnews.com/2024/09/25/who-cares-about-the-religion-… @RNS
Nice little voting bloc you've got here. It would be a shame if something happened to it.
Conventional wisdom: Americans think national economy bad because they're suffering. Today's WaPo poll: PA voters say their personal financial situation is good (60%-37%) but nation's economy is bad (66%-33%). What gives?
How the GOP has turned away from religion: religionnews.com/2024/09/18/the-declining-significance-of… @RNS
If Haitian immigrants could walk off with the country's Canada geese, the country would owe them a vote of thanks — and immediate citizenship.
This is true. Geese will f*** you up.
Trump got played again. A second debate (MSW: "He did better than last time") would do Harris no good. Now they get to call him chicken.
Damn. Full beta cuck. “no mas, no mas”.
Trump shows me some love. Kinda. religionnews.com/2024/09/09/trump-shows-me-the-love/ @RNS
Trump's Arlington affair harks back to Bill Clinton — up to a point: religionnews.com/2024/09/03/trumps-arlington-affair-harks… @RNS
The GOP's 2024 Religious Platform versus the Democrats' Religious Platform: religionnews.com/2024/08/28/platform-religion-gop-versus-… @RNS
That's not how John Green defined the God gap. Strictly speaking it was (is) the partisan divide among frequent worship attenders — a 20% split in favor of Republicans from 2000 on; i.e. 60% voting GOP and 40% Democratic. In most elections a gap larger than the gender gap.
The 'God Gap' is the concept that Democrats have left religion more quickly than the Republicans.
Atheist/Agnostic Belief in 1988 vs 2022:
Dem: 5% -> 20%
Rep: 4% -> 6%
Never attend in 1972 vs 2022:
D: 9% -> 37%
R: 8% -> 23%
Nones in 1972 vs 2022:
D: 4% -> 33%
R: 3% -> 14%
The religious conflict of the election is Republican restorationism versus Democratic futurism: religionnews.com/2024/08/15/the-competing-faiths-of-the-2… @RNS
"The bikers you will always have with you..."
Would Jesus park in a bike lane? For Philadelphia churches, it’s a real question religionnews.com/2024/08/13/would-jesus-park-in-a-bike-la… via @RNS
And speaking of ads, how about billboards with nothing more than the latest Time cover:
"All the pressure is on Trump now. Can he come back? Can he respond? Can he prove, contra @gtconway3d’s brilliant ads, that he is not a pathetic psychopath?"
From @mtomasky: newrepublic.com/article/184754/donald-trump-freaked-out-h…
A teabag.
Part of the Citgo sign
The astonishing abandonment of its abortion plank by the GOP: religionnews.com/2024/08/09/the-gop-ducks-the-abortion-is… @RNS
Trump's questioning of Kamala Harris's Black identity has deep Judeo-Christian roots: religionnews.com/2024/08/07/trumps-questioning-of-kamala-… @RNS
There are a lot of "Republicans for Harris" sprouting up. Are there any "Democrats for Trump"? Just asking.
The religion of opposing climate change action: religionnews.com/2024/07/31/the-religion-of-opposing-gove… @RNS
They're changing the spelling of their name to "D"SA IC.
You've got to be fucking kidding me.
Biden's decision to withdraw undergirded American civil religion. The MAGA response, not so much: religionnews.com/2024/07/24/bidens-exit-evokes-the-crisis… @RNS
Not sure this is true. I'd like to see a quote from a framer to that effect. The regime of checks and balances (up to impeachment) were designed to enable the republic to endure when presidents lack the character and honor to put duty head of self-interest.
The framers of our Constitution knew that our republic would endure only if our presidents have the character and honor to put duty ahead of self interest. President Biden deserves our gratitude for his decades of service to our nation and for his courageous decision today.
Josh Hawey's Christian nationalism is old-time civil religion, weaponized: religionnews.com/2024/07/16/hawleys-christian-nationalism… @RNS
Those Columbia deans deserved to be removed. But what does the university do next? religionnews.com/2024/07/09/those-columbia-deans-deserved… @RNS
Making every public school teacher teach from the Bible in Oklahoma...for "historical context": religionnews.com/2024/06/28/teaching-the-bible-in-oklahoma/ @RNS
Louisiana's 10 Commandents' law is only pretextually about American legal history: religionnews.com/2024/06/25/louisianas-ten-commandments-l… @RNS
Louisiana's new 10 Commandments law is at odds with its own legal heritage: religionnews.com/2024/06/21/louisiana-mandates-the-ten-co… @RNS
I suspect the Vatican wanted to send a signal to Francis' many assailants that there are limits, whether they support this fringe nutter or not. In other words, this is not about Viganò-ism as about those who attack the pope as heretical and question the authority of Vatican II.
A few random thoughts here FWIW:
My first reaction was why give this guy any oxygen? He is such a fringe nutter he's like QAnon election deniers on steroids. Francis has for years, and wisely, ignored him--which in itself puts the lie to Francis as a "dictator pope." 1/8
Tatum talked about God. A lot.
The @celtics were an interfaith team -- Brown, the Finals MVP, is Muslim. Mazzula is Catholic. Jrue Holliday, who has a Bible verse tattoo, is likely Protestant (but not sure what denomination)
Roberts v. Alito on polarization, plus the secret history of Martha-Ann Alito's upside-down flag display: religionnews.com/2024/06/14/roberts-and-alito-are-polariz… @RNS
Reasonable Expectations
Soften a classic book title:
One Hundred Years of Intermittent Socializing
The Uncomfortable Lightness of Being
Soften a classic book title:
One Hundred Years of Intermittent Socializing
As I Lay in Hospice Care
Soften a classic book title:
One Hundred Years of Intermittent Socializing
Not that weird, when you understand it's accompanied by info that the U.S. provided support for the lab. The conspiracy theory thus insinuates responsibility for the pandemic on the part of malevolent forces in the U.S. government; i.e. the culpability of the Deep State.
Louisiana is about to require the Ten Commandments in every public school classroom. Madison wouldn't have approved: religionnews.com/2024/05/31/would-madison-have-been-ok-wi… @RNS
Here's how the GOP should put the IHRA antisemitism definition into effect: religionnews.com/2024/05/10/ok-gop-lets-put-that-antisemi… @RNS
In hyper-capitalist America, train tracks are privately owned whereas in Europe they do socialism. Ergo, in Europe they have high-speed rail everywhere while we are only beginning to get it off the ground: www.dot.nv.gov/projects-programs/transportation-projects/…
In hyper-capitalist Europe, airports are mostly privately owned whereas in the United States we do socialism with the minor exceptions of New Haven and San Juan.
reason.org/privatization-report/2024-aviation/
Jewish agita over campus antisemitism is excessive: religionnews.com/2024/05/08/antisemitism-when-israel-is-o… @RNS
I.e. Four strikes and you're...in.
Merchan sounds like he's done with merely fining Trump.
"... Because this is now the tenth time that this Court has found [Trump] in criminal contempt, spanning three separate motions, it is apparent that monetary fines have not and will not suffice to deter Defendant from violating this Court's lawful orders."
"... if appropriate and warranted, future violations of its lawful orders will be punishable by incarceration."
www.nycourts.gov/LegacyPDFS/press/PDFs/DOcontempt_5-6-24F…
Arizona is the latest example of the pro-life movement's political overreach coming back to haunt it: religionnews.com/2024/05/03/the-pro-life-movement-in-poli… @RNS
One of Newt's few redeeming features is that he loves animals. (He's always taken his name to heart.)
In 2012, Newt Gingrich released an attack ad that criticized Mitt Romney for putting his dog on the roof of his car. Asked what he thinks of Kristi Noem shooting her puppy dead, he tells me it’s, “Totally crazy and appalling.”
An antisemitic Jan. 6 insurrectionist gets the book thrown at him: religionnews.com/2024/04/25/a-january-6-antisemite-is-sen… @RNS
The Archdiocese of Baltimore plans to radically downsize the parishes and shutter most of the churches in the city of Baltimore. What's next? religionnews.com/2024/04/18/whats-to-be-done-with-baltimo… @RNS
Indiana appeals court declares its support for a religious right to abortion: religionnews.com/2024/04/09/how-allowing-abortion-for-sec… @RNS
The Wisconsin Supreme Court bats down the latest right-wing exercise in spiritual libertarianism: religionnews.com/2024/04/03/spiritual-libertarianism-swat… @RNS
Remembering Joe Lieberman's religiously promiscuous campaign for vice president: religionnews.com/2024/03/28/joe-liebermans-religiously-pr… @RNS
The country is less religiously identified and committed, but these numbers are problematic. We know from careful studies that actual weekly attendance in 2000 was in the mid-20s; i.e. people way over reported how often they attended worship. They may be doing less of that now.
The US has become a strikingly less religious country over the course of my adult life.
Texas A.G. Paxton's commitment to religious liberty does not extend to protecting a Catholic nonprofit's right to provide services to migrants and and refugees: religionnews.com/2024/03/26/texas-attorney-general-hates-… @RNS
Trump say Jews who vote Democratic hate Israel and their religion. Do Christians who vote Republican hate America and THEIR religion? religionnews.com/2024/03/20/do-christians-who-vote-republ… @RNS
Alabama's new IVF law defines embryonic personhood down: religionnews.com/2024/03/13/alabamas-ivf-protection-law-l… @RNS
Biden (up to a point) restores religious liberty protections for social service beneficiaries that Trump took away: religionnews.com/2024/03/06/biden-restores-faith-based-in… @RNS
Alito's privileging of religion hits the jury pool: religionnews.com/2024/02/29/alito-argues-that-religious-b… @RNS
The Alabama IVF is lousy law with theocratic religious filigree: religionnews.com/2024/02/26/alabama-ivf-decision-is-bad-l… @RNS
A call for international Christian leaders to denounce the Russian Orthodox Church's complicity in Putin's war on Ukraine: religionnews.com/2024/02/22/a-call-for-christian-leaders-… @RNS It's long overdue.
Uh, that's "qui tacet consentire," Jim.
The latest from MAGA-land; I believe Bishop Barron has had this man on his "Word on Fire" program a few times (or vice versa). It'd be interesting if His Grace has any "comment" here (qui tacit consentire).
This assumes that those who advocate such values are ipso facto Christian nationalists. I'd argue, to the contrary, that many of them aren't. But as Christian nationalism has intensified for a minority of Americans, more oppose positions increasingly associated with it.
In 2007, 55% of folks said that the govt should advocate Christian values.
In 2021, that dropped to 38%
In 2007, 69% thought that the govt should allow the display of religious symbols.
In 2021, it dropped to 50%.
Pretty clear that Christian Nationalism has faded.
Super Bowl religion ads were the opposite of MAGA religiosity: religionnews.com/2024/02/13/super-bowl-religion-ads-are-a… @RNS
According to Abbot and Costello, no one's on first.
It’s sad that so many voters feel that no one cares about them
How the Trump disqualification case is shaking up American civil religion: religionnews.com/2024/02/06/trump-disqualification-case-s… @RNS
In his new book, Tim Alberta channels his inner pastor and preaches against white evangelicals' MAGA sins.
Great news for Biden.
Me too!
Gettysburg would have been the perfect place to recall June 6 on its third anniversary. Why Biden chose to kick off his campaign 100 miles to the east: religionnews.com/2024/01/08/why-didnt-president-biden-kic…. @RNS
What Christian moral theology has to say about Trump's eligibility for office under the 14th Amendment: religionnews.com/2024/01/02/what-christian-moral-theology… @RNS
Would it have made any difference to God if Adam and Eve had actually said they were sorry for eating of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil? And here's the answer: religionnews.com/2023/12/28/suppose-adam-and-eve-had-said…
@RNS
Would it have made any difference to God if Adam and Eve had actually said they were sorry for eating of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil? @RNS
The answer is yes.
"Until now, Trump’s Republican rivals have shown themselves too scared to fight and too weak to win," @davidfrum writes. "The question ahead: Are they too scared and too weak even when the win is presented to them by the courts?" www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/12/colorado-court-…
How Zionism became religious for American Jews, making anti-Zionism anti-Judaism: religionnews.com/2023/12/19/how-anti-zionism-became-anti-… @RNS
Spirituality, like religion, is in decline in America. Why didn't Pew report what it found? religionnews.com/2023/12/11/americans-are-becoming-less-s… @RNS
The University of Bologna, the first university, was not invented by the Catholic Church but by groups of students who hired teachers from the city's educational institutions to teach them various subjects. Also, there were hospitals in ancient Rome in the 1st century BCE.
The Catholic Church invented the hospital, nursing, the university, and is still the most important force in defense of the poor and sick around the world.
Angels we have smelled on high
Sweetly smoking o'er the plains...
Another kind of fragrant offering:
"A massive marijuana grow operation was found inside a Tennessee church after a weeks-long investigation … neighbors of the church complained about a smell coming from the church, according to the sheriff’s office."
ktvz.com/cnn-regional/2023/12/03/massive-marijuana-grow-o…
Despite what Hindu Nationalists say, banning discrimination on the basis of caste is not anti-Hindu; cf. the latest federal court decision out of CA: religionnews.com/2023/11/29/hindu-nationalists-notwithsta… @RNS
Another part is that the clientele of liberal arts colleges know that knowledge of the humanities (history, art history, music, literature, religion, philosophy) is no longer necessary to be a respectable member of the upper middle class.
I think a big part of the "crisis" in the liberal arts comes down to the fact that the people who teach these classes no longer want to do what society wants them to do and expound on the greatness of our civilization.
www.slowboring.com/p/thankful-mailbag
American news coverage of the Gaza war is no more biased than Israeli news coverage — but a bit more hopeful: religionnews.com/2023/11/21/is-american-media-coverage-of… @RNS
Simply put, it was easier for young single 18th-century women in New England to have sex than to become a church member.
"Nostalgia is the enemy of history."
In Colonial America - one third of all women gave birth to their first child less than 9 months after getting married.
Meanwhile, 20% of New Englanders had a religious affiliation.
Finke and Stark, Churching of America.
Clearly there are earthly grievances (though earthly does not equal secular, esp. in this place), but Hamas' religious motivation is usually left out of most characterizations of the organization.
Sam Harris says that the Israel-Hamas war is a battle between "civilization and savagery" - and that Palestinian terrorism is motivated solely by radical Islam, not any earthly grievance.
Which shows that atheists aren't immune to fundamentalist thinking
nymag.com/intelligencer/2023/11/sam-harriss-fairy-tale-ac…
How Bishop Strickland went out of his way to get removed from office: religionnews.com/2023/11/13/an-american-catholic-bishop-g… @RNS
The increasingly hard line on abortion of evangelical Christianity is what's upset the Republican applecart: religionnews.com/2023/11/09/the-christian-hard-line-on-ab… @RNS
With any luck.
Sure. OK. God gave Mike Johnson the speaker's gavel.
And the American people will take it away from him.
Going to Dubai for COP 28, Pope Francis has something new to say about anthropocentrism v. ecocentrism: religionnews.com/2023/11/03/pope-francis-sets-the-table-f… @RNS
Mike Johnson may not be the Christian nationalist bogeyman of liberal imagining. But he should read his Bible better: religionnews.com/2023/10/30/the-movement-activist-who-is-… @RNS
Arguing that expelling Santos would set a bad precedent, this piece by WaPo's congressional bureau chief manages to ignore the actual precedent set by the expulsion of Adam Clayton Powell in 1967: www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/10/28/george-santos-…
The last time I saw Hair was in 1967 — the original production at Joseph Papp's Public Theater in downtown Manhattan. Seemed pretty innocuous to me then...
An SBC leader is coming to Chicago to speak at the Atheneum Theater in a couple weeks. Brought back memories -- last time I was there was in 1996 to see a revival of Hair www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1996-08-02-9608020350-…
Holy war is a good recipe for evil, especially when coupled with irredentism: religionnews.com/2023/10/24/the-evil-of-holy-wars/ @RNS
Jordan's colleagues should be quoting from the Gospel of Kenny Rogers. He clearly doesn't know when to fold 'em.
This comes after Jordan’s colleagues invoked Esther earlier this week.
Just a whole lotta Bible verses thrown around the House amid this speaker fight.
So GOP reps blame Dems for not supporting McCarthy but refuse to partner with Dems for temp Speaker McHenry. Well played, guys!
I'd say that the Gaetz division aims to force an alliance between "institutionalist" GOP members and Democrats in order to get the former primaried and defeated in 2024.
The "whole situation" (just as plausibly the result of the invasion by 5 Arab armies of the newly declared state of Israel in 1948) is not what matters. What matters (as far as the destruction of the hospital is concerned) is that Hamas murdered 1400 Israeli civilians on Oct. 7.
Noah hits the nail on the head: newrepublic.com/article/176337/israel-palestine-universit…
Mark Silk reposted
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-10-09/ty-article/.premiu…
Religious liberty has become a go-to right for everyone, thanks to Scotus: religionnews.com/2023/09/27/religious-liberty-is-becoming…. @RNS
Once upon a time there was The Americanism Heresy in the Catholic Church. The bishop-led opposition to Pope Francis is The New Americanism Heresy: religionnews.com/2023/09/20/the-new-americanism-heresy/ @RNS
Aren't there just two seasons of #thebear?
So the real reason Meadows et al. want the trial moved to federal court is that they don't want to be on TV.
#breaking: A Fulton County judge on Thursday said that all court proceedings in the election interference case against former President Donald Trump and 18 co-defendants will be live streamed and televised. www.ajc.com/politics/fulton-judge-says-trump-court-procee…
GOP presidential wannabes caught between a rock and a hard place on abortion: religionnews.com/2023/08/25/debate-outlined-gop-president… @RNS
"The museum did not say how many objects were taken... But it said that the missing, stolen or damaged pieces included 'gold jewelry and gems of semiprecious stones and glass' dating from as far back as the 15th century B.C."
The British Museum has lost its charms.
The Ohio referendum told us what historians of the subject have long known: Given the choice, Americans will opt for making abortion available: religionnews.com/2023/08/14/ohio-shows-that-people-want-a… @RNS
Appeals court turns thumbs up on Connecticut's elimination of religious exemptions for unvaccinated schoolkids. Will SCOTUS do the same? religionnews.com/2023/08/10/will-the-supreme-court-take-u… @RNS
Respondeo: The Religious Right started out semi-Christian, in the sense (let's say) that the Crusades were semi-Christian or pogroms were semi-Christian. Over the past half-century semi- has shifted toward post-.
Sed contra: The Religious Right was always post-religious, or, more properly, post-Christian. Trump is the natural outcome.
Trump's latest indictment works hard to show that the former president knew that he had lost the election. This raises the moral/epistemological conundrum of Trump's relationship to the truth: religionnews.com/2023/08/02/indicting-trumps-gospel-of-tr… @RNS
www.politico.com/magazine/story/2019/01/09/why-horse-race…
Right on, Jack.
Ron DeSantis' evangelical costume is just the latest in a long tradition of GOP presidential candidates' religious disguises: religionnews.com/2023/07/25/the-religious-evasiveness-of-… @RNS
www.bostonglobe.com/2023/07/24/metro/research-harvard-eco…
I'm shocked, shocked...
I'd say it's now a hermeneutic of hostility.
Sounds just like the Christians of the 4th Century: from embrace of universal religious tolerance to bringing the hammer down.
At the exact time when religious liberty is enjoying a historic winning streak at the Supreme Court, a cohort of Christians has decided that liberty isn’t enough. It's power--even more than freedom--that they crave: www.nytimes.com/2023/07/09/opinion/christian-right.html
Mark Silk reposted
At the exact time when religious liberty is enjoying a historic winning streak at the Supreme Court, a cohort of Christians has decided that liberty isn’t enough. It's power--even more than freedom--that they crave: www.nytimes.com/2023/07/09/opinion/christian-right.html
Saint Francis was right.
Pope Francis was right
Last week SCOTUS rectified an error on religious rights. Liberals should be happy: religionnews.com/2023/07/05/scotus-corrects-one-old-mista… @RNS
If Hunter Biden's deal is, in Trump's characterization, "no crime, no case," perhaps Orange-is-the-New-Orange will see fit to negotiate his own plea deal to avoid "Election Interference!"
dailycaller.com/2023/06/20/trump-election-interference-re…
I'm afraid, Jim, that faith in Trump is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.
You would think Republicans would listen to AG Bill Barr and realize Trump is guilty.
Trying to think who the most blessed and loved person in early modernity was...
"in late modernity." Gotta love Cornel West.
On the contrary, it sees totally in character. Classic Trump. Cf. The phone call to Raffensperger.
Politics aside, it just seems out of character for Trump to do something as reckless and sloppy as what’s alleged in this indictment.
Like the guy or not, I don’t care, but you have to admit something doesn’t fit here.
How Pat Robertson's church-based politicking turned white evangelicals into the GOP base: religionnews.com/2023/06/10/how-pat-robertson-made-white-… @RNS
Why did Trump work so hard to keep the docs? This transcript suggests that it was at least in part to be able to rebut (or pretend to rebut) assertions about his behavior as president.
Wow. New scoop from @cnn has the actual tape transcript of Trump, rifling through secret docs to try to rebut my 6/21 @newyorker story on Mark Milley and his concerns about Trump wanting to hit Iran:
www.cnn.com/2023/06/09/politics/trump-tape-didnt-declassi…
What to do about Utah county that removed the Bible from elementary and middle-school library shelves? religionnews.com/2023/06/07/utah-county-protects-children… @RNS
Putin's Patsies
Caption this.
The future of religion in America as the old ascription regime is replaced by a new regime of choice: religionnews.com/2023/06/01/the-future-of-religion-in-ame… @RNS
Texas will soon be hiring religious chaplains in its public schools. Who cares if it's an establishment of religion? religionnews.com/2023/05/30/chaplains-in-the-texas-public… @RNS
Still, I readily concede that lawyers have a firmer grasp of ethics rules than us mere mortals.
So the following, discussing the 1978 Ethics in Government Act (which requires all government officials to report annually “all gifts" above a certain amount not from a relative) is complete bullshit? www.brookings.edu/articles/justice-thomas-gift-reporting-…
So the following, discussing the 1978 Ethics in Government Act (which requires all government officials to report annually “all gifts" above a certain amount not from a relative) is complete bullshit? www.brookings.edu/articles/justice-thomas-gift-reporting-…
Who's she gonna believe — the Texas House or her cheatin' husband?
Ken Paxton always wanted to be a politician. His wife wanted to be a musician.
But now that he’s been impeached, she’s the one holding the future of the Paxton political dynasty in her hands.
More on the “pistol packin mama whose husband sues Obama”:
www.texastribune.org/2023/05/28/texas-angela-paxton/
Apparently the technical definition of "bullshit" is hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of undeclared gifts of real estate, private school tuition, and travel junkets. Though I'm not sure Judge Luttig would go along: www.politico.com/f/?id=00000187-d9a8-d5cb-a7a7-ddea09530000
Wow. Texas House Republicans show themselves to have more integrity in re: Paxton than U.S. House Republicans in re: Clarence Thomas.
PAXTON IS IMPEACHED, 121-23.
Because they believe Paxton's actions constitute impeachable offenses. The will of the voters cannot be considered preemptive inoculation against impeachment, regardless of what voters are presumed to know.
Whether or not you’re persuaded, Cruz makes a compelling argument: TX voters knew Ken Paxton’s problems and re-elected him anyway, so why is the TX House trying to undo the will of the voters?
Religion in America does not prosper in the wake of disease. As the Great Flu Pandemic went, so goes COVID-19. religionnews.com/2023/05/17/covid-19-and-the-decline-of-r… @RNS
Demittere divinum.
Errare humanum est!
The correct Latin is the passive infinitive "tractari" not "tractaro." NCR got it wrong.
A different paradigm for the exercise of episcopal power 'Quod omnes tangit ab omnibus tractaro debet' [Whatever concerns all must be considered by all]." Francis' synod reforms show voices of Catholic laity can no longer be ignored www.ncronline.org/node/242861 via @NCRonline
The correct Latin is the passive infinitive "tractari" not "tractaro." NCR got it wrong.
A different paradigm for the exercise of episcopal power 'Quod omnes tangit ab omnibus tractaro debet' [Whatever concerns all must be considered by all]." Francis' synod reforms show voices of Catholic laity can no longer be ignored www.ncronline.org/node/242861 via @NCRonline
Agreed. It's been that way for months. What's the explanation?
Quiz: George Soros is discovered to have taken Elena Kagan on expensive vacations and paid for her mother's house and her nephew's private schooling. Jim Jordan would 1) denounce the report; 2) dismiss it as no biggie; or 3) begin impeachment proceedings.
Nope, the guys who wrote the Constitution were not more about protecting religion from the state than protecting the state from religion: religionnews.com/2023/05/05/no-the-framers-were-not-more-… @RNS
Don't your charts show a very small decline among non-white evangelicals?
There is no religious tradition where a smaller percentage say that they are evangelical in 2022 compared to 2008.
There's been a (small but) noticeable rise in born-again:
Catholics
LDS
Jews
Muslims
And a huge jump in evangelical (Russian/Eastern) Orthodox Christians.
Which underscores Jefferson's metaphor.
The Establishment Clause tells Congress to butt out: don't establish religion federally, let the states do as they choose. Nothing in your article suggests framers were more concerned to protect religious authority. "No religious Test" suggests otherwise.
What statements of the framers indicate an interest in protecting religious authority from political authority?
No "separation of church and state" in the Constitution? Don't be silly: religionnews.com/2023/04/28/yes-virginia-the-constitution… @RNS
A must-read for Democrats and the Democrat-Adjacent.
Sorry to report that Biden is being challenged by a crazy Kennedy with blood on his hands. Please subscribe--free or paid.
oldgoats.substack.com/p/rfk-jr-pedigreed-menace
Supreme Court's current religion case harks back to the big 19th-century fight over Sunday mail delivery: religionnews.com/2023/04/20/religious-zealots-go-postal-a… @RNS
And who can forget Homer's amazing epic poem about the Gamecock War.
Since blue checks are gonna vanish, might as well go old-school Twitter and pick a fight over nothing.
In that tradition: "USC" should be understood to refer to the University of South Carolina, not that other school in California.
The South Carolina school is bigger and older.
I'm not so sure. Only 1% of self-identified atheists say they believe in God (with doubts).
I think that all three of them are a social identity (that's my bias a social scientist).
But, the data backs that up.
Only 65% of self-ID'ed atheists express an atheist belief in God.
Only 37% of agnostics actually have an agnostic belief about God.
What about the other way? That is, do self-identified Jewish atheists count as Nones or as Jews? Put another way, is "None" the larger self-identification category within which people identify as atheist, agnostic, or nothing in particular?
I think that all three of them are a social identity (that's my bias a social scientist).
But, the data backs that up.
Only 65% of self-ID'ed atheists express an atheist belief in God.
Only 37% of agnostics actually have an agnostic belief about God.
According to your data, Ryan, all Nones self-identify as either atheist, agnostic, or nothing in particular, right? The categories don't seem fully comparable, the first two having to do with belief, the last with social identity.
I think that most nones will vote for Democrats in the near future.
But, I also don't believe the nones would look at all like a coherent voting bloc in a Democratic primary.
Atheists prefer a Bernie type. Nothing in particulars look for a moderate.
That's a big difference.
Cheap at twice the price. Of course, John Harvard got the whole shebang for less than half the price (in today's dollars) plus a bunch of books.
How American politics has become positively medieval (in the crusader/jihadi sense): religionnews.com/2023/04/10/american-politics-has-become-… @RNS
You're welcome, Chaz. Keep me posted.
Coincidence or not, I'm sure it appealed to his sense of his own importance.
It is interesting that after his exile from Harvard, Father Feeney landed in Harvard.
The professor acted with respect, decency and an appreciation of religious differences. The issue is whether the administration simply kowtowed to a student's claim to have been disrespected. It did.
Miller defended the decision not to renew the professor’s contract, saying, “respect, decency, & appreciation of religious & other differences should supersede academic freedom.” Hamline U. president to retire following Islamic art controversy religionnews.com/2023/04/03/hamline-university-president-… via @RNS
So former presidents are above the law because if they're not above the law all former presidents will be prosecuted.
Blue check: Gone.
Why Florida's got to get the Bible out of public schools: religionnews.com/2023/03/31/why-florida-needs-to-keep-the… @RNS
It turns out ChatGPT embraces the Golden Rule: religionnews.com/2023/03/28/chatgpt-embraces-the-golden-r… @RNS
Or unless they want to help their trans kid.
No, Elise. The Republican Party isn’t the “party of parents.” It’s the party that wants to force a 10-year-old rape victim to become a parent.
I say backwards.
I know of no data re: consensus. I'm just talking about myself.
Interesting. Is there a consensus view on these two decisions?
I'm not baffled why Putin invaded Ukraine nor why Bush invaded Iraq. That both invasions were mendacious, stupid, and contrary to national self-interest doesn't make them hard to understand.
Self-righteous will do.
Is there a word to describe the attitude of a person who regards his or her opinions as so obviously correct--and so profoundly enlightened--that they may not legitimately be challenged or questioned, and that only hate or bigotry can explain others' holding different beliefs?
When he accused Cardinal McElroy of heresy, Bishop Paprocki was accusing Pope Francis of the same: religionnews.com/2023/03/09/in-accusing-cardinal-mcelroy-… @RNS
Nah, that's just bullshit rhetoric.
I thought you were going to say, "A second yellow."
And what would result in a red card?
Probably will do more good in the world than all the philanthropy of the Lilly Endowment. I say this as a beneficiary of the latter.
Eli Lilly & Co. is capping out-of-pocket costs for insulin at $35 a month, following a public plea from President Biden for lower prices of the diabetes treatment for all Americans. abcnews.go.com/Business/eli-lilly-cuts-insulin-prices-70-…
Whatever else one thinks of her, in my book she had the best characterization of Trump to date: neither cause nor symptom of the GOP's condition but rather an "opportunistic infection."
As Marianne Williamson prepares another White House bid, a look back at her first presidential campaign back in 2020.
“The lack of a vibrant spiritual conversation is to the detriment of American democracy … spirituality means the path of the heart.” religionnews.com/2019/04/12/the-spiritual-politics-of-pre…
Roald Dahl's stories are too nasty to be bowdlerized: religionnews.com/2023/02/28/roald-dahl-doesnt-deserve-to-… @RNS
Of course they won't.
Many US bishops have said that Catholic politicians who don't follow church teachings, especially on life issues, should be denied Communion. Will they call for @GovRonDeSantis to be denied Communion? Church teaching is that the death penalty is "inadmissible."
Some Democrats do, including white pols. Take Rep. Joe Courtney. His voting record is as liberal as they come. In 2022 he won by 18 pts in his D+2 district of eastern CT. Did I mention that my son Abe was his campaign manager?
I think Joe may have a valid point
David French's advocacy of the classical liberal principles of the First Amendment is needed. Two cheers for the NYT for hiring him: religionnews.com/2023/02/24/two-cheers-for-david-french/ @RNS
The majority has begun to act on abortion, at some peril to GOP candidates, so the latter have changed their messaging to trans issues.
On abortion, as on gun-safety laws, a clear but determined minority is dictating to the clear but acquiescent majority, and it will continue to do so until that majority decides it must act.
Giving up ChatGPT for Lent?
His Grace is branching out in his list of topics to be condemned. Happy Lent!
You can't even keep your mouth shut when the President of the United States is giving the State of the Union Address.
So insulting!
seriously?
It'll be called Project Mendacium.
NEWS- James O'Keefe told Project Veritas staff this morning that he would start a rival group and accused internal adversaries of "ruining our reputation in front of supporters and donors and leaking confidential information and fabricating stories" www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/02/20/james-okeefe-e…
And should that happen, America would be better off.
I doubt it will happen to Fox, but to the contrary, a media outlet that, let's say, consistently libeled public figures according the Sullivan standard would deserve to be penalized into oblivion by the courts.
I doubt it will happen to Fox, but to the contrary, a media outlet that, let's say, consistently libeled public figures according the Sullivan standard would deserve to be penalized into oblivion by the courts.
Civil religious language is sometimes the same as Christian nationalist language. It's important not to mistake the former for the latter: religionnews.com/2023/02/13/christian-nationalism-overlap… @RNS
"Entitlement reform" = cutting Social Security and Medicare. Say it and keep saying it. And ask people if they support taxing the rich to keep Social Security and Medicare as they are. And keep asking.
Woke-ism Is Winding Down
compactmag.com
MAGA-ism is not.
Orban?
Modi yes, LePen no.
I'd have thought the real analogy was with the immature teenager who refuses to raise enough money to pay for what he buys.
The prophet who resented the hell out of their penance.
Cultured meat is kosher, says Israel's Ashkenazi chief rabbi. It's also eco-kosher: religionnews.com/2023/02/06/is-cultured-meat-the-kosher-w… @RNS
On skates?
See #3: www.mentalfloss.com/article/55243/8-creative-interpretati….
I'd put it at #1.
I’ve never heard anyone make that comparison
Homosexuality would appear to be on the table for the upcoming Catholic Synod on Synodality: religionnews.com/2023/01/30/the-catholic-churchs-upcoming… @RNS
Why not Catholics? It's a movie about Purgatory.
A quick crowdsource: looking for Buddhist folks / scholars to talk with about Groundhog Day the movie
When Kissinger got his Harvard Ph.D., all male teachers were identified as, and addressed as "Mr.," whether they had a Ph.D. or not. When he was secretary of state, Kissinger (perhaps jokingly) asked to be addressed as "Excellency."
I someone missed it when @megynkelly trashed Henry Kissinger for insisting he be called "Dr. Kissinger." And you wouldn't argue that his PhD is a bigger deal because it's from Harvard, would you?
Evangelical leaders' new lukewarmness toward Trump explained: religionnews.com/2023/01/25/how-come-evangelical-leaders-… @RNS
Thanks, Michael.
You did a great job writing this up, Mark.
Biden undoes Trump who undid Obama who undid Bush re: faith-based initiative regs: religionnews.com/2023/01/18/biden-administration-moves-to… @RNS
Who else would adopt Trump's own standard of loyalty?
A quiz to help college administrators and DEI personnel from screwing up the way they did at Hamline University: religionnews.com/2023/01/11/who-says-you-cant-show-studen… @RNS
Interesting indeed, up to and including his throwing his brother and sister-in-law under the bus for, he alleges, giving him the idea of wearing he Nazi uniform. Keeping faith with great great uncle Edward VIII?
Before the Civil War. In the South.
Those could be fatal questions. Just saying.
That leaves some, um, critical questions. Are you in greater danger of dying if you’re in critical condition? Is critical condition declared based on specific vital signs?
I didn't think so.
Renewing my request that reporters covering injuries explain exactly what “critical condition” means and how it differs from “serious condition.” Bonus question: Do all doctors/hospitals define these terms in the same way?
Clearly, Mike, critically is more serious than seriously but less serious than fatally. Satisfied?
Renewing my request that reporters covering injuries explain exactly what “critical condition” means and how it differs from “serious condition.” Bonus question: Do all doctors/hospitals define these terms in the same way?
Present company included?
There’s a special crown of righteousness reserved for anyone who shows up at the 8 am service on New Year’s Day.
What was wrong about Pope Benedict's put-down of Islam? Hint: not just theological ignorance. religionnews.com/2022/12/31/what-pope-benedict-got-wrong-… @RNS
Well, west of I-495.
Everything west of Newton is “western” Mass, though, right?
Even by 12th century standards, Becket's position was problematic.
Imagine if a contemporary American Catholic bishop argued that priests who committed crimes should be tried only in church courts.
Is there a difference between "embellishing" and "making up out of whole cloth"? I think so.
I think Santos is a total embarrassment and has no place in public life. But a lot of folks on this site dinging him seem to have forgotten how much both the current president and his predecessor “embellished” about their accomplishments.
But bear in mind, this vote didn't matter, and she knew it.
Santos is the Madison Cawthorn of the next Congress. House GOP keeping it classy.
Will Santos be the first member of Congress to have falsely claimed to be gay to get elected?
The defrocking of Frank Pavone is the latest chapter in the story of fundamentalist Catholicism: religionnews.com/2022/12/27/frank-pavone-leonard-feeney-a… @RNS
When it comes to charging Trump and his circle (Stone, Bannon, et al.) with insurrection, Chapter 6 of the 1/6 Committee's final report makes it clear that there were three concentric circles of awareness of what was to happen on Jan. 6.
As one of the latter, Lucas Denney, wrote, "Trump speaking to us around 11 am then we march to the capital and after that we have special plans that I can’t say right now over Facebook."
What the Committee didn't obtain was first-hand testimony on those special plans and who was aware of them. If DOJ has such testimony, or succeeds in getting it, then the full conspiracy will be exposed and the case for insurrection will be all but open and shut.
Thanks for reminding us of your iconic denunciation, Tim.
Lord Haw-Haw
Westbrook Pegler.
Does that mean the Hoover Institution will no longer describe itself thusly? "Seeking to improve the human condition by advancing ideas that promote economic opportunity and prosperity, while securing and safeguarding peace for America and all mankind."
The decline of the little church = the rise of the mini-church, right?
Wrote last year about the rise of the mini-church
religionnews.com/2021/11/16/why-the-minichurch-is-the-lat…
DFT's forthcoming reality tv show: "Orange is the New Orange."
According to the Legionaries, it's Marcial.
Marshall or martial ?
LDS Church supports Respect for Marriage Act. USCCB opposes it. How come: religionnews.com/2022/12/12/why-the-lds-and-catholic-chur… @RNS
A judge makes clear by current first amendment law permits a religious right to get an abortion: religionnews.com/2022/12/07/indiana-judge-backs-a-religio… @RNS
Totally!
"Even the most well-intentioned statements on women in the Church bear the unmistakable hint of the male CEO who calls his female secretary 'the real boss' and sincerely believes it’s a compliment." — @SusanBReynolds1
www.commonwealmagazine.org/women-church-synod-francis-cat…
Exactly which of the Constitution's "rules, regulations, and articles" would Trump have terminated, and who does he think will terminate them?
Lindsey Graham. Of course.
BREAKING: 36 MAGA Republican senators just voted NO on the Respect for Marriage Act. You read that right. In 2022, the majority of the Republican Party is AGAINST protecting the right to marriage for LGBTQ and interracial couples.
What took Jewish right-wingers so long to bail on Trump: religionnews.com/2022/11/29/right-wing-jews-bail-on-trump/ @RNS
Trump is Palinizing himself. Like her, he's becoming a faded caricature of himself. He will meet her fate.
So how about providing Ukraine with air defense technology?
#israel has transferred intelligence dossiers to dozens of countries and international organizations regarding Iranian arms exports to #russia in recent week, with the goal of mobilizing more countries in the world to exert pressure on #iran
m.jpost.com/international/article-723386/amp
"I've never supported Dems. Didn't vote for Hillary in 16. Didn't vote for Biden in 20. But the closest I ever get to supporting them is when I'm watching the people who most oppose them. In this sense I suspect Fox is an unintended get out the vote operation for Dems." So what?
I’ve never supported Trump. Didn’t vote for him in 16. Didn’t vote for him in 20. But the closest I ever get to supporting him is when I’m watching the people who most oppose him. In this sense I suspect MSNBC is an unintended get out the vote operation for Republicans.
Because they would rather take their chances in the general for opposing SSM than risk being primaried for supporting it.
Republicans suffered the worst midterm performance for a party out of power in decades because they were viewed by Americans as too extreme. Then, in the very next vote - to protect same-sex marriage - 75% of the Republican conference voted against it.
Zero lessons learned.
Two cheers for the late Michael Gerson: religionnews.com/2022/11/17/two-cheers-for-michael-gerson/. @RNS
In typography, agate is very small print. It minimizes the attention paid.
If Walker loses in Georgia, Trump 24 collapses. One-liners about GOP rivals won't help. All he has to keep him in the public eye will be bad legal news.
Sadly, they delivered all that in agate.
We’re delivering historic results for the American people.
Quiz: Name 2 GOP House members who might be interested in switching parties when the next Congress convenes.
Call me bad, but I'm going to miss Twitter.
I doubt a single GOP representative would vote for her, nor would the Squad and the Squad-adjacent.
Cheney as speaker is not a crazy idea and would be great for the country. One need not be an elected member of Congress to be speaker. Getting 3 or 4 Republicans to vote with Democrats for Cheney would be very difficult but not impossible with good deal-cutting.
Academia is the best when a journalist calls you out of the blue and you get to pontificate in public.
Journalism is the best when you can call a professor out of the blue and they are super helpful
1. In the face of once-in-a-generation inflation, and a president with approval in the low 40s, not so much. 2. And how about a demonstration of the weakness of American society?
Let's be real. TWhen the opposition is organized around doing nothing to help human beings, runs lunatics, and abandons the basic pretense of commitment to democracy, and the result is a tie, this is a demonstration of the weakness of the Democratic Party, not its health.
Abortion enabled the Dems to keep the red wave at bay: religionnews.com/2022/11/09/abortion-was-no-dud-for-democ… @RNS
Call it Daytripping.
I love that Dorothy Day will help many working women and men get to and from their jobs. Also, for so many people she really was a lifesaver.
Religious liberty defeats fetal personhood in Indiana: religionnews.com/2022/11/04/a-legal-victory-for-religious… @RNS
What they mean is: "They refuse to talk about what we talk about the way we talk about it."
"We can't talk about the thing we constantly talk about" is a regular theme of right-wing infotainment.
Diderot and Montesquieu did have children. Thomas Aquinas not so much. So what?
Locke never had children. Neither did Descartes, Hobbes, Spinoza, or Kant. Rousseau had children but gave them all up for adoption. In other words, Enlightenment rationalism was the construction of men who had no real experience of family life or what it takes to make it work.
Props to Bolsonaro supporters for accepting the will of the people. Trump supporters take note. www.theguardian.com/world/2022/oct/31/brazil-election-bol…
Is antisemitism still the third rail of prejudice in America? Up to a point. religionnews.com/2022/10/28/is-antisemitism-still-the-thi… @RNS
Yes! They should put their money where I have.
Will Scotus recognize a religious right to abortion? We'll find out from the Indiana RFRA case: religionnews.com/2022/10/26/will-there-be-a-religious-rig… @RNS
Among other things, the 1/6 committee's subpoena of Trump amounts to a bill of indictment. Yo, DOJ! www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/read-trump-su…
Sukkot: Mother of Jewish holidays. Hosannah! religionnews.com/2022/10/14/sukkot-mother-of-jewish-holid… @RNS
Agreed. But how come Leahy didn't get his colleagues to make the same inquiries? WTF?
Incredible.
By all means! I only wish she'd actually been able to do it.
This is one of the great quotes in American history. May our children and their children and their children's children read all about it in their textbooks.
It's hard to avoid the conclusion that the Secret Service was complicit in the coup attempt. The question: Who managed to persuade Trump not to go to the Capitol Jan. 6?
Props to Tim Ryan for saying, "Ohio needs and ass-kicker, not an ass-kisser." The problem is, most Republicans want elected officials who kiss Trump's ass. thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/3682621-ryan-slams-v…
Yes, completely normal.
As for voting for him, these days GOP voters expect senators to be servants of Trump(ism), not leaders in their own right. So a Herschel Walker would fit right in with the rest of the bowing and scraping GOP congressional crowd.
After the Herschel Walker affair, what is there left to say about Georgia's white evangelicals? religionnews.com/2022/10/07/the-herschel-walker-case-beli… @RNS
As many as needed.
Tiblisehnsucht.
There should be a German word for waking up and missing Tbilisi.
First prize: expedited Russian citizenship. Second prize: immediate Russian citizenship.
4405/
If the Scotus today dealt with free exercise cases the way the way Scotus 50 years did, we'd be much better off—and so would free exercise: religionnews.com/2022/09/30/the-hasidic-educational-stand… @RNS
Shows how little ideology per se matters. The West remains the enemy, Russia remains the victimized bearer of a message of salvation for the rest of the world. Plus ça change...
18 October: I'll be talking @Pushkin_House
about Russia's ideological 180 from the "Godless communism" of the Soviet era to presenting its war on Ukraine as a spiritual struggle with the "godless" west. www.pushkinhouse.org/events/propaganda-wars-roland-elliot…
Here's betting the NY State's commitment to holding Hasidic schools to account ends up in Scotus, with Scotus finding for the Hasids: religionnews.com/2022/09/25/holding-hasidic-schools-to-ac…. @RNS
"Hi, Y'all! God here."
A sincere question. If God had to reveal himself to a race of non-binary aliens (let’s just assume that they exist), how would he do it?
Basil the Great is turning over in his grave.
Unadulterated evil.
With apologies to Henry IV, Part I:
Putin: "I can call up soldiers from the vasty steppe."
Zelensky: "Why, so can I, or so can any man; But will they come, when you do call for them?”
When I hear the word "transparency," I reach for my pistol.
They always say they want "transparency." And often then things get more restricted.
Very droll.
QTing without comment
Sure they've been actively courted by the GOP, but my point is that these are simply the stable cohort of white Christian Republicans. With the departure of white Christian Dems, they now make up a larger share of the white Christian population.
Think about cause. I’m dubious that religion is an independent variable here. Religiosity is declining rapidly in white America. Maybe these are aging, alienated, middle- & working class whites in flyover states who are actively courted by one party & not by the other.
I'm guessing the salute derives from evangelical worship and serves in part to signal the religious character of the rally. Call it the Christian Nationalist Salute.
This Trump rally finger salute is curious. Some on Twitter are calling it a QAnon salute, with 1 finger for "Where we go 1," and Trump is playing a pro-Q song as he talks. I've never seen this happen before, though, so if it's a Q thing it's new.
this is one of the most bizarre things I've seen at a Trump rally. All it is missing is passing around Kool-Aid right after.
Nowhere did the white Christian share of the general population grow. Meanwhile, the white Christian GOP vote has stayed constant. So what explains the growth of the Republican share of white Christian communities is disaffiliation on the part of their Democratic members.
This is the share of white Christians who ID as Republicans between 2008 and 2021.
States were Republican % has increased 5% or more
AR, DE, ID, IN, IA, KY, ME, MI, MO, MT, NE, NM, NC, ND, OH, OK, PA, TN, UT, VT, WA, WV, WI
Biggest movers:
UT (+35)
AR (+21)
ND (+20)
WV (+18)
And what about Cardinal O'Malley of Boston or Bishop Da Cunha of Fall River, whose diocese includes Martha's Vineyard?
Shame on @FlaCathBps for their silence about the cruelty of Governor DeSantis toward vulnerable migrant families.
Scotus gives LGBTQ club at Yeshiva U. a lease on life, but I wouldn't bet on its longevity: religionnews.com/2022/09/15/yeshiva-university-is-forced-…. @RNS
Should have been titled, "Breaking Wind."
ICYMI: My review of Jared Kushner's book, "Breaking History: A White House Memoir"
foreignpolicy.com/2022/09/11/breaking-history-jared-kushn…
Kushner imagines that he was charting a new course in U.S.-Middle East policy, but it was just the same old same old.
In the case of the Roman Empire it took a millennium. Cf. Gibbon.
1) It's important to have a longer timeline. Empires generally don't collapse overnight. It may take decades or even centuries for a collapse to fully play out.
2) Toxic nationalism is a destructive force, and all nationalism, no matter how enlightened, has toxic seeds.
Lindsey Graham says his anti-abortion bill will hurt Dems "when they try to explain to some reasonable person why it’s OK to be more like Iran and less like France on abortion.” Last year Iran effectively banned abortion: news.un.org/en/story/2021/11/1105922. Huh?
The Constitution is silent on many things that get legislated. Graham's bill would simply be statutory—like RFRA, for example.
One thing about Graham's 15-week national abortion puzzles me: Didn't the Dobbs ruling (well, Alito) specifically say that such a ban would not be possible because the Constitution is "silent" on abortion one way or the other?
Putin fiddled while Russia was burned.
Chaos at the front, fireworks at home.
Me and @Andrew__Roth on the mood in Moscow. www.theguardian.com/world/2022/sep/12/moscows-narrative-o…
Put another way, they were Enlightenment intellectuals who retained a belief in original sin.
Has anyone every written a book on the ne're-do-well relatives of presidents—Billy Carter, Roger Clinton, Hunter Biden, etc. If not, maybe they...shouldn't.
This looks to be a pretty thorough, even-handed look at the contents of - and backstory to - Hunter Biden's infamous laptop. Bottom line?
Hunter's a real mess, but there's no clear proof of almost any "fact" in the whole damn story: nym.ag/3d6agXb
I'm surprised that this did not attract more attention when it came out four years ago.
This unredacted transcript is damning. There will be some major revisions of the Graham legacy.
Make sure Rod Dreher's there too.
I honestly cannot fathom the moral bankruptcy of Americans who have been openly rooting for Putin's success and the destruction of Ukraine.
And yes, @TuckerCarlson, you are high on that list.
Mark Silk reposted
This is not aging well.
Agreed. Though I think there's something specific going on in this case, as in osmotic absorption of the PR efforts of the British royalty with the English public.
Agree, Mark. My 10ct analysis is that it’s another manifestation of contemporary America’s cult of celebrity.
I second this emotion. But I'd question the "still." The evidence of yearning for hereditary privilege in the early Republic is weak and limited. The popularity of the British royalty in the U.S. is latter-day thing.
Richard Stengel, former Under Secretary of State for Obama, does not mince words:
"Why are American news networks dedicating all of this time to Queen Elizabeth's funeral? … There's a weakness in the American character that still yearns for that era of hereditary privilege."
Trump: The Grift that Keeps on Grifting: www.nytimes.com/2022/09/08/us/politics/trump-save-america…
Nope. This is astonishing.
I've obviously seen lots of religious liberty claims related to LGBTQ issues but I can't recall seeing anything like this, related to the ACA or HIV treatment. Anyone remember otherwise?
To understand Evangelicalism's Trumpism, you need to go back to the Faustian bargain the Christian Right made in 1980: religionnews.com/2022/09/06/the-christian-rights-original… @RNS
How the Almighty is no economist and what Shmita and the Lord's Prayer have to do with Biden's student loan forgiveness: religionnews.com/2022/08/30/comparing-bidens-student-debt…
Interesting that Rasmussen's latest polls show a 10-point swing in Biden's favorability, with 538's adjustment actually putting Biden's approval rating a point ahead of his disapproval, 48%-47%: projects.fivethirtyeight.com/biden-approval-rating/?cid=r….
This assumes "religiously devout" equals religion being very important. There's good evidence that religion is important to some non-attending (i.e. non-devout) conservatives solely as an identity marker. So the gap between the groups may be smaller.
About 2/3 of politically conservative Protestants and Catholics say that religion is very important to them.
It's 40% of liberal Christians.
I just don't see how the statement, "Liberal Christians are just as religiously devout as conservatives" is empirically true.
The explanation, I think, is that the (mostly white) journalists are thinking only about white people.
I keep seeing journalists and columnists seemingly unable to avoid repeating the Democrats-are-coastal-elites whereas Trumpists-are-Middle-Americans trope. But maybe also mention this fact? In 2022 Biden won voters under $100k ~ 56%-43%. Trump won voters over $100k ~ 54%-43%.
On the nose.
We have two parties.
One is anti-democracy, anti-truth, and anti-rule of law.
The other is sometimes inept and foolish, with some fringe illiberal elements--but basically committed to the institutions and norms of liberal democracy and a free society.
It's not a tough choice.
Option 1(a): DOJ tells judge Trump objects. Trump says his lawyers made him object even thought he personally would like to see the warrant released.
Sounds like an admission of guilt to me. I'm guessing that the files have to do with intelligence information on Iran's nuclear program, given that he was focused on attacking Iran as late as Jan. 3, 2021 (see www.newyorker.com/magazine/2022/08/15/inside-the-war-betw…).
Trump doesn't sound like a guilty narcissistic sociopath at all here. Not one bit.
I plead giggly.
Hypocrisy get no better than this.
August 17: "Can't testify. The dog ate my homework."
Breaking: Fulton Judge McBurney says he’ll order Rudy Giuliani to appear before the special grand jury on Aug. 17. (Giuliani was initially scheduled to testify today but said he couldn’t fly down because of a medical procedure.) 1/ #gapol
Four legs good, two legs better.
Republicans are out here explicitly complaining about living in a country with civil equality and the rule of law, it’s deranged.
What Indiana's new abortion law has to say about the impact of the Kansas pro-choice vote: religionnews.com/2022/08/08/was-kansas-a-wake-up-moment-f… @RNS
Time to give the much maligned Chuck Schumer major props. He's managed to get more done with the slimmest of majorities than any Senate Majority Leader in history.
The Greek Orthodox Archbishop of America is a liberal! religionnews.com/2022/07/26/uh-oh-the-greek-orthodox-arch… @RNS
How about Europe sends those Magyar tribes back to Central Asia?
Orbán talking again in stark extremist terms about “race mixing” and great replacement. With @floragaramvolgy www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jul/24/viktor-orban-agains…
Mark Silk reposted
Orbán talking again in stark extremist terms about “race mixing” and great replacement. With @floragaramvolgy www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jul/24/viktor-orban-agains…
Trump's position on the afternoon of January 6: If I can't be at the Capitol egging them on I'll make sure to do nothing that holds them back, from calling in law enforcement to telling them to cease and desist.
The Webb telescope give creationists a chance to strut their stuff: religionnews.com/2022/07/21/the-webb-telescope-vs-young-e…. @RNS
I've a feeling we're not in Jersey any more.
holy shit watch and retweet this ad
The tirade is shocking to be sure, but I wonder what the numbers actually are.
Kind of a world war in Ukraine. The Axis: Russia, Belarus, China, Syria, and Iran with fellow travelers Nicaragua, Cuba, India, Serbia, and Hungary.
www.amazon.com/Robert-Penn-Warren-Joseph-Blotner/dp/03945…
Anyone know a good recent (say, post-1990) biography of Robert Penn Warren? A friend (@shauncasey57) and I were wondering about this the other day... Hey @MatthewSitman do you know? Anyone?
That Trump helped incite the insurrection is clear. We need more evidence for his participation in the seditious conspiracy. I expect the 1/6 Committee has some.
In preparation for today's Jan. 6 committee hearing, a reminder that Trump's "will be wild" tweet on Dec. 19, 2020 clearly set in motion what would happen, as was apparent at the time.
I did. It is.
"no religious test for office" = separation of church and state
"no law respecting an establishment of religion" = separation of church and state. Thomas Jefferson, who was not involved in its drafting, thought the Constitution established a "wall of separation."
Charlie Kirk: "There is no separation of church and state. It's a fabrication. It's a fiction. It's not in the Constitution. It's made up by secular humanists"
Looking at abortion as a rights conflict: religionnews.com/2022/07/06/when-it-comes-to-abortion-no-… @RNS
Hutchinson's testimony has shifted the pertinent legal question from whether Trump incited the Capitol insurrection to whether he was part of a conspiracy that planned it. The answer appears to be: Yes he was.
Fine recap. Let's recall, in addition, that the permit for the 1/6 rally stated there would be no march to the Capitol. But Trump knew such a march would happen. "They can march to the Capitol from here," he reportedly said, demanding his armed people be let into the rally.
The Orange Monster in an orange jumpsuit has gone from liberal fantasy to genuine possibility.
My Day Six recap and analysis:
oldgoats.substack.com/p/cassidy-hutchinsons-bombshells-day
The ruling establishes a standard of judgment for Establishment Clause cases that could permit teacher-led prayer in public schools. That's why there's a prayer-in-schools argument.
This is a lie and you know it. This ruling allows an individual the right to private prayer outside of their duties. Meaning, the coach cannot pray with the team officially, but he has the right to pray and others are allowed to join him. This is not a prayer in schools argument.
The Establishment Clause gets a conservative make-over — in the public schools. religionnews.com/2022/06/28/teacher-led-prayer-is-back-in… @RNS
The Supreme Court gooses up the culture war: religionnews.com/2022/06/25/a-good-week-for-the-culture-war/. @RNS
Was Jesus ever sexually aroused? The late theologian who thought so: religionnews.com/2022/06/22/the-theological-ethicist-who-…. @RNS
So are we to assume that the Texas GOP considers heterosexuality a normal lifestyle choice?
Homosexuality is not an "abnormal lifestyle choice." It is the way that God created a part of the human race. LGBTQ people are beloved children of God who are, in many places, at risk of violence. As with all marginalized people, God is by their side, even if the Texas GOP isn't
Mark Silk reposted
Trump is not impaired. He’s just a rich asshole who believes what he wants because he can. For heaven’s sake, don’t make that a reason not to put him on trial, writes @TimothyNoah1.
newrepublic.com/article/166864/trump-mental-state-delusional
That's pretty much Rousseau's argument for civil religion at the end of the Social Contract. Nor was he alone. Most European thinkers bought it, contra Pierre Bayle. Americans not so much, though Tocqueville thought we were its exemplar.
Since Reagan became president, abortions have only bumped up when a Republican is president, have declined more when a Democrat is president. Coincidence?
The usual explanation would be CYA. Something more ominous? Enquiring minds want to know.
And why is the Capitol Police chief whitewashing this?
Actually, I'd give some thought to getting rid of the politics comments too. Cf sometime WaPo politico, now NYT columnist Tom Edsall's column in today's NYT: www.nytimes.com/2022/06/15/opinion/social-media-polarizat…
I don't entirely disagree. I encourage readers to reach out to the Post with feedback helpcenter.washingtonpost.com/hc/en-us/articles/360002940…
The old barroom saw—no talking about religion or politics—half applies. And yet, WaPo allows comments on politics stories.
Readers ask me regularly why religion reporters' stories on The @washingtonpost don't allow comments. It's because so many comments on religion -- and other topics -- violate community standards. We're hoping to find a solution soon
Is the U.S. Constitution informed by "a Judeo-Christian value system"? religionnews.com/2022/06/15/how-judeo-christian-is-the-u-… @RNS
Devastating as yesterday's 1/6 hearing was, I can help seeing DeSantis, Cruz, Hawley, Cotton and the other 2024 GOP presidential wannabes licking their lips as the Dems do their dirty work for them.
Trump's speech didn't incite the Proud Boys, it incited the normies at his rally to march to the Capitol and follow them in. IMHO the evidence will ultimately show that he knew (via his people—Giuliani, Powell, etc.) what the Proud Boys were up to as part of the coup.
Interesting...the Proud Boys moved toward the Capitol before the speech. That is the first time I have heard that. It raises the issue: how could Trump's speech "incite" them to go to the Capitol if they were already there?
Is American conservatism de-Christianizing? I don't think so. religionnews.com/2022/06/08/is-the-religious-right-defunct/ @RNS
The big take-away from Tuesday's primary is that the middle prevailed, in both parties.
For the record, a question that begins "Aren't you..." is an accusation. But fwiw I wouldn't oppose a process for deciding whether to permit a late-term abortion, under the old Roe viability criterion.
I asked, as opposed to alleged that, if you were on absolutist on abortion, opposing any and all restrictions on abortion.
You denied it. So which restrictions, if any, do you favor?
Answer my question. Where did you get that idea?
Okay, so which restrictions do you favor?
I don't oppose any and all restrictions on abortion. Where did you get that idea?
Aren't you an "absolutist" on abortion, meaning you oppose any and all restrictions and support the public financing of it?
I urge everyone to watch "Servant of the People"—3 seasons on Netflix (with subtitles). It provides a kind of insight into the situation in Ukraine, and Zelenskyy himself, that is unavailable anywhere else in English. It's also pretty damn funny.
On the 101st day of this war, he is still in his office, in Kyiv >>>
What I'd like to know is who tipped off Short. I bet the 1/6 committee knows, and that we'll soon find out.
If Belarus sends troops into Ukraine, does NATO? Should it? If it shouldn't, why not?
From COVID-19 to Uvalde, pastoring a megachurch just became too much for my "friend" the court evangelical: religionnews.com/2022/05/31/my-court-evangelical-throws-i… @RNS
Bat Mitzvah speech ad lib: "Today we are a man and a woman."
If we get a chance to find out, that'll be the silver lining.
I don’t think Thomas would vote to overturn Loving. Just my hunch
Did the SBC learn from the Catholic abuse crisis? Not hardly: religionnews.com/2022/05/25/comparing-the-southern-baptis… @RNS
Ergo, no anti-abortion laws, right?
You cannot legislate away evil.
So no anti-abortion laws, Lauren?
I don't think people appreciate that Republicans don't care about having good or valid arguments for their positions - the mere appearance of having an argument suffices. Boebert's absurd claim undermines all laws. But it justifies doing nothing about gun violence, so it's enough
You cannot legislate away evil.
Similarly, when he was in the White House there was a policy agenda. Now it's all vengeance all the time.
NEW: When Trump was in White House, there was an it-takes-a-village process to keep him on track w endorsements. Now, he’s resisted any structure for endorsements and has been on vengeance tour that voters mostly don’t share. @MichaelCBender and me www.nytimes.com/2022/05/25/us/politics/trump-perdue-georg…
True, but as Wasserman points out, they also voted for Raffensperger. Lesson: Even GA's MAGA faithful care more about beating Dems than re-litigating 2020.
Agreed. But where does that leave Trump vis-a-vis the other Georgia races?
I think this victory-lap by Kemp and Pence is their way of rubbing Trump's nose in it. #gapol
Moral autarky: Kirill advocates a Benedict Option for Russia. interfax-religion.com?act=news&div=16552.
"Ohio GOP Senate nominee J.D. Vance hit Democratic opponent Rep. Tim Ryan for 'pushing billions in foreign aid while the communities he serves in Congress have been decimated.'” So is J.D. supporting billions in infrastructure spending? Of course not.
I second this emotion.
Biden needs to use his bully pulpit as president to directly, explicitly take on the Great Replacement theory, by name, as well as those who spread it. Drag it out from the shadows of Fox News and put it in the national spotlight for all to see its ugliness and its consequences.
During the Trump administration, there were 60 U.S. military fatalities. In 15 of the 48 months in question, there were no fatalities.
Why Rod Dreher would prefer Putin and Patriarch Kirill getting their way in Ukraine to the alternative: religionnews.com/2022/05/12/drehers-war-part-2/ @RNS
Because when you've got EWTN and CNA, why would you need anything else?
Wait, what? Why?
Religious liberty claims are about to go up against anti-abortion laws: religionnews.com/2022/05/03/abortion-restrictions-v-relig… @RNS
About time. When the other side ups the arms race, you've got to saddle up.
NEW: Biden, elected on a vow to ease the political divide, has long avoided America's culture wars.
Now he's in the middle of one with huge implications — for his presidency and the country.
“It’s one more tempest among many."
w/ @cmsub
www.latimes.com/politics/story/2022-05-03/biden-reacts-to…
Positively Rowlellian.
Amazing choice of literary reference.
NYT calls Tucker Carlson an "indifferent" student and doesn't mention where he went to college. It was Trinity, in Hartford, and "indifferent" is, shall we say, an understatement. www.nytimes.com/2022/04/30/us/tucker-carlson-gop-republic…
Where does Rod Dreher, America's best-known Orthodox Christian scribbler, stand on the war in Ukraine? First of two columns: religionnews.com/2022/04/30/drehers-war-part-1-rod-dreher…. @RNS
Which is also to say, twice as many Nones as Catholics, 12% more Nones than Protestants, barely half Christians.
I use this graph when I give talks to let people know just how small a lot of religious groups are. Yet, the average American is fascinated by them.
1 in 100 Americans are LDS.
There's a Real Housewives of Salt Lake City. Its population is 200k.
Tulsa, OK is twice the size.
Will Scotus let high school coaches pray with their players on the 50 yard-line? Let's hope not. religionnews.com/2022/04/27/how-much-leeway-should-the-su… @RNS
It's all well and good to take Georgia Republicans choosing Kemp over Perdue as evidence of Trump's endorsement weakness. But I'd say it's more they see Kemp as their best chance to beat Abrams: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/04/26/trump-sycophan….
In 2017, Macron beat Le Pen 66-34. When all the votes are counted, he will beat her about 58-42 this time around. Given his lack of popularity, I'd say reports of the demise of France's political center have been exaggerated.
What articles like this always leave out is the issue of self-determination. Do Ukrainians get a vote?
www.cnn.com/2022/04/20/opinions/sachs-ukraine-negotiation…
House GOP turns a no-brainer into an insult to an iconic Florida judge: religionnews.com/2022/04/18/house-republicans-dishonor-an…. @RNS
The same thing that happened when Christians went from embracing religious tolerance in the early 4th century to embracing religious repression in the late 4th century: power.
For 20 years, the conservative movement litigated against speech codes about race and sex and zealously defended corporate speech. Now? The GOP proposes speech codes about race and sex and tries to regulate corporate speech. What happened? www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/04/republican-dont…
Check out Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address.
The Case of the Praying Football Coach. Scotus seizes opportunity to weaken the Establishment Clause: religionnews.com/2022/04/06/can-a-public-high-school-coac… @RNS
Better: The Orbanidict Option.
Call it the Orbanict Option.
Rod has traded in his Benedict Option for a Magyar Bromance.
Rod Dreher says that America has “few champions” like Viktor Orban, but Florida governor Ron DeSantis gives him “hope” currentpub.com/2022/04/05/rod-dreher-says-that-america-ha…
Call it the Orbanict Option.
Rod has traded in his Benedict Option for a Magyar Bromance.
Rod Dreher says that America has “few champions” like Viktor Orban, but Florida governor Ron DeSantis gives him “hope” currentpub.com/2022/04/05/rod-dreher-says-that-america-ha…
Rod has traded in his Benedict Option for a Magyar Bromance.
Rod Dreher says that America has “few champions” like Viktor Orban, but Florida governor Ron DeSantis gives him “hope” currentpub.com/2022/04/05/rod-dreher-says-that-america-ha…
Justinian lived in a world where he could get away with it.
As one student observed, what's the difference between Justinian saying that "God has returned Carthage to the empire" from Putin saying that he is doing God's bidding in Ukraine.
Wait a minute. What about the New Deal? What about the Civil Rights Movement?
It will be interesting to see if Trump endorses Palin. He has always kept her at arms length b/c she as vp candidate invented him as a presidential candidate. Misogyny has kept us from calling Trump Palinesque.
WAPO says Pope Francis "implicitly criticized" Putin for Ukraine war. (www.politico.eu/article/pope-lashes-out-at-potentate-puti…). NYT says he "inched closer" to doing so (www.nytimes.com/2022/04/02/world/europe/pope-francis-russ…). No. He blamed "some potentate, sadly caught up in anachronistic claims of nationalist interests." That's explicit.
God forbid we reduce the profits of Eli Lilly, Novo Nordisk and Sanofi.
What in God’s name is the possible counterargument for NOT capping the price of insulin?!
I looked up your church and gotta say it sounds like quite the place. Not sure how the Church of England would process the St. Joan name, but more power to you.
What a great Ukrainian Byzantinist prophesied about the current situation: religionnews.com/2022/03/31/my-ukrainian-teacher/ @RNS
What a great Ukrainian Byzantinist prophesied about the current situation: religionnews.com/2022/03/31/my-ukrainian-teacher/ @RNS
I have no doubt that Volodymyr Zelenskyy, professional actor and comedian that he is, is as obsessed with "the slap" as we are.
M
Biden may have committed a gaffe when he said “This man cannot remain in power.” Certainly the walk-back from the White House suggests this was the case. But I would rather have a president who isn’t afraid to call out Putin for his war crimes than one who toadies up to him.
Me too.
Hey hey,
Ho ho,
Butcher Putin's got to go!
It was a perfect Kinsleyan gaffe. Of course Putin's got to go. Sooner or later. Rothkopf's got it right.
In re: Orban. Dreher v. Niemöller: "First they came for the Ukrainians, and I did not speak out because I was not a Ukrainian..."
www.theamericanconservative.com/dreher/
Let's assume Ginni Thomas was violating no law in asking Meadows to "release the Kraken." Does that render her immune from criticism as the spouse of a Supreme Court justice?
One of the goals of Trump's various allies was to try to get the election settled by the Supreme Court, which Trump has been vocal about.
Striking that self-reported weekly-plus attendance by evangelicals has shrunk by over 40% since 2008. To be sure, the increase in evangelical self-identification by those who would not have identified as evangelicals in 2008 should be taken into account.
In 2008, 16% of self-identified evangelicals attended church seldom or never.
In 2021, it was 29%.
The % who attended church less than once a month was 29% in 2008. Now, it's 42%.
Now, less than half of self-identified evangelicals are weekly attenders. It was 59% in 2021.
Rather than New Right, I propose calling them the New Nativists. The New Right was a movement of the 1970s and 1980s.
Many thanks to @DamonLinker for a thoughtful response to my New Right piece. Damon's insistence on seeing these underlying tendencies as grouped together under anti-liberalism is important:
Time to get Brooks under oath before the House Select Committee.
ALERT: In new statement, Rep Mo Brooks (R-AL) says:
"President Trump asked me to rescind the 2020 elections, immediately remove Joe Biden from the White House, immediately put President Trump back in the White House, and hold a new special election for the presidency... "
Bringing the anathammer down!
“Any Patriarch or Bishop who supports Russia’s actions is a heretic and has nothing to do with Orthodoxy,” said Metropolitan Ioseb of the Patriarchate of Georgia
#orthodox_times
orthodoxtimes.com/metropolitan-of-the-georgian-church-any…
Pentecost?
OK, but my question remains: What's the third church service Graham attends each year? Easter, Christmas and... ?
I'd love to see a Clarence Thomas opinion on this one.
Sen. Mike Braun R-IN told home-state reporters today that the U.S. Supreme Court should again allow individual states to decide if interracial marriage should be legal - just like he wants states to individually decide if abortion should be legal.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=HYrNIkR0ByA&t=142s
The lamestream media evidently now includes National Review: www.nationalreview.com/2022/03/senator-hawleys-disingenuo…
It’s sickening how the lamestream media is trying to discredit viable reports that Joe Biden’s Supreme Court nominee was soft on sentencing pedophiles.
The American people need to know the truth.
www.foxnews.com/media/senator-hawley-calls-abc-gotcha-que…
Fair enough.
1. As someone who has studied Russian Orthodoxy for most of my academic career, I’m focused on how we miss the mark by simply calling Putin’s war a holy war, just as we miss the point if we label Putin as a fake Christian based on particular categories of belief.
Here's the difference between us. Many people, including me, would say that the Crusades were an unholy use of religion — or, more charitably, a misunderstanding of a divine calling. In my book, that doesn't mean they weren't Holy Wars. In your book, apparently it does.
Putin is not answering a divine calling through his warfare. That would be a holy war. He’s doing the opposite. This is an unholy use of religion + political philosophy to wipe out both a country, to claim it as part of his nation, and to fracture democracy.
Holy War Adjacent?
Agreed. To understand their ambitions means looking at the connections of contemporary nationalisms globally and the relationship between church and state historically in Russia. It may not be a holy war, but it is a nostalgic imperial production for Kirill and Putin.
Here's the difference between us. Many people, including me, would say that the Crusades were an unholy use of religion — or, more charitably, a misunderstanding of a divine calling. In my book, that doesn't mean they weren't Holy Wars. In your book, apparently it does.
Putin is not answering a divine calling through his warfare. That would be a holy war. He’s doing the opposite. This is an unholy use of religion + political philosophy to wipe out both a country, to claim it as part of his nation, and to fracture democracy.
Holy War Adjacent?
Agreed. To understand their ambitions means looking at the connections of contemporary nationalisms globally and the relationship between church and state historically in Russia. It may not be a holy war, but it is a nostalgic imperial production for Kirill and Putin.
Abandon all hope ye who enter here. But hey, maybe hope's overrated.
So, Twitter followers, I just realized there are more than 5,000 of you. I know many journalists have tons more than that, but I do not really tweet. Someone at NCR's home office tweets out my columns. Is it time to start tweeting?????
Holy War Adjacent?
Agreed. To understand their ambitions means looking at the connections of contemporary nationalisms globally and the relationship between church and state historically in Russia. It may not be a holy war, but it is a nostalgic imperial production for Kirill and Putin.
OK, not a Holy War. But the parallelism between Putin's and Kirill's respective hegemonic ambitions — the alliance between the geo-political and the theo-political — makes the religious dimensions of the war more significant than the usual "Gott mit uns" nationalism.
Absolutely. There are religious dimensions to this geopolitical war. There are also philosophical dimensions (traditionalism, fascism, etc). Still not a holy war.
And yet there are religious dimensions to the conflict, not least the political religion of Russki Mir (the Russian Nation).
I’ll say it again: This is not a holy war. Labeling it as such is sloppy journalism/academic research.
And yet there are religious dimensions to the conflict, not least the political religion of Russki Mir (the Russian Nation).
I’ll say it again: This is not a holy war. Labeling it as such is sloppy journalism/academic research.
The war in Ukraine is likely to extrude Russia from the global religious right: religionnews.com/2022/03/21/franklin-graham-russia-and-th… @RNS
Stalin ordered kulaks to be "liquidated as a class." Putin appears to be ordering Ukrainians to be liquidated as a people.
Well then, I stand corrected. Good for you and good for them.
I'm not saying they LIKED it, but they gritted their teeth and accepted it.
If I'm not mistaken, Jay, you were cancelled by your superiors at the paper for opposing the war — or, to be precise, your antiwar opinions were cancelled. Correct?
I went on a bit of a Tweet rant about this topic, and the posts got out of sequence. So I'm reposting it here in the correct, numbered order.
Yes, Virginia, there is a religious war in Ukraine.
Join us today at 2pmEST for a discussion on religion, geopolitics, and the Russia-Ukraine war.
This will feature @directorsilk, Elizabeth Prodromou of @FletcherSchool, and Rev. John Burgess of @pghseminary. www.eventbrite.com/e/putins-war-and-the-fracturing-of-fai…
What, no Russian sanctions on Trump for sending all those Javelins to Ukraine?
What's with the smirk? Is that meant to take the edge off his literal demonization of the United State?
Side note: Religion has become a significant element of Fuentes’ America First movement —> religionnews.com/2022/01/26/for-right-wing-extremists-a-r…
I'm not so sure about that.
extraordinary move would be for pms of poland, czech rep, and slovenia to stay in kyiv
there’s no way russia risks direct attack on leaders of 3 nato states
And then there this:
Good question. This is a process. The question is how long it takes.
Thanks! In short, the word is getting out.
I like to see some reporting on whether what's going on in Ukraine is beginning to seep into the consciousness of ordinary Russians.
To bad that didn't make it into the Atlantic article.
Saudi Arabia puts 81 to death in its largest mass execution religionnews.com/2022/03/14/saudi-arabia-puts-81-to-death… via @RNS
Don't like pacifism or just war theory? Orthodox Christianity offers a third way: religionnews.com/2022/03/14/ukraine-offers-a-middle-path-… @RNS
A Democrat with a Republican House that didn't want to fund any of his priorities, just he wouldn't cut the taxes they wanted to. Just for the record.
From the end of history to the end of Putin's Russia.
All faculty or all LDS faculty? Or are there no LDS faculty?
What do you think prompted BYU's new push to make sure all faculty have a current temple recommend? And what about those questions for new hires?
www.sltrib.com/religion/2022/03/10/new-employment-policy/
State Dept. trying to get NATO planes to Ukraine. Pentagon saying no way. Uh, does the White House have a position?
If that's a joke, it's not very funny.
White Bible-believing Christians confront climate change on small islands in the Pacific and the Caribbean: religionnews.com/2022/03/07/making-religious-sense-of-cli… @RNS
Better to visit the sun and ask it pump out more rays. On second thought, maybe not.
NOPE.
NOPE NOPE NOPE NOPE NOPE.
El Lago Ness Monstruo.
March 6, 1922: The plesiosaur, a sea-dwelling, long-necked beast believed to have gone extinct 66 million years ago, apparently still lives, says the head of the Buenos Aires zoo. A British visitor claimed to have seen a lake monster resembling a plesiosaur in Patagonia.
Basically the foreign policy equivalent of drinking bleach for Covid.
No matter how stupid you think Trump is he always shows that he’s even more stupid than you thought.
Nuclear weapons notwithstanding, is there a point where NATO is compelled to intervene directly?
Putin's military "strategy" seems to be just total destruction of Ukraine, including slaughtering of innocent civilians. Just appalling. He must someday be held accountable.
This puts him right up there with Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson after 9/11.
Russian Orthodox Patriarch Kirill unsurprisingly endorsing Putin’s narrative on Ukraine in a sermon today. According to him the West essentially organises genocide campaigns against countries that refuse to stage gay parades 🤯
When you've got the world's current hero repeatedly asking for a no-fly zone over his country, you've got to ask U.S. policymakers why not. The question is pressing, not (necessarily) the course of action.
Or as Tacitus put it, in words he puts into the mouth of a leader of the Britons facing Roman conquerers, "To ravage, to slaughter, to usurp under false titles, they call empire, and where they make a desert, they call it peace."
With the indiscriminate bombardment of Kharkiv, a mostly Russian-speaking city, Putin's strategy becomes clear: Murder as many people as possible. Then take possession of the ruins.
I'm no big fan of just war theory, but in my moral lexicon, military aggression is evil, self-defense is legitimate, and while killing even in a war of self-defense is a bad thing, it may be necessary.
Offering Putin asylum in Israel?
🔴BREAKING: Prime Minister Naftali Bennett is reportedly in Moscow for talks with Russian president Vladimir Putin.
#israel | #russia
www.jpost.com/breaking-news/article-700416
There certainly are very right-wing bishops who may be considered Putin-adjacent.
Uh-oh, you're rite.
On the Francis left, there's an ingrained pacifism that is reluctant to support any fighting. On the anti-Francis left, there some pro-Putinism. Nevertheless, where's the active support for their co-religionists, the Eastern Right Catholics?
You're wrong. You're thinking of Pope John XXIII's removal of the adjective "perfidis" (unbelieving) from the Good Friday prayer for the Jews in 1959.
Am I right that the RC Church stopped calling us Jews Christ killers only as late as 1963, when I was 16?
The present guy can't catch a break.
I hear from so many people who say it’s a really good thing that NATO and the West has been so strong & unified in their response but then refuse to give Biden ANY credit for that strong & unified response.
Is the invasion of Ukraine a religious crusade? Kind of. religionnews.com/2022/02/28/religious-nationalism-and-the… @RNS
Trump runs into the White House bomb shelter when peaceful demonstrators show up. Zelensky goes and has coffee with the troops when the Russians invade. All you need know.
Maybe not all of his mind, soul question above my pay grade.
Yeah Rod you haven't lost your mind and your soul.
Desantis is the only wannabe with significant support now, so you could be right. But he's got his finger in the wind. I'm not sure that's going to work.
So which putative candidates have strongly denounced Putin?
That data is from 2020 though. I'd like to see comparable data from a survey done now. I'll bet the rankings would be different.
Strong support for using the US military to protect an ally that is being attacked by a foreign nation.
75% of White evangelicals and mainline are in favor.
66% of atheists and agnostics.
Hindus (43%), Orthodox (41%), and Muslims (23%) are the least supportive.
Does Newt want us to put boots on the ground in Ukraine?
The Biden Administration talks and Putin acts. This is such a clear replay of Chamberlain trying to deal with Hitler that it is more than a little frightening. Putin is pushing day by day and has no fear of NATO because he has no fear of the United States or its President.
Which is why it would be better to call Christian nationalism in the U.S. "Christian Americanism."
How the Christian Right embraced Christian Nationalism, Part 2: religionnews.com/2022/02/22/from-new-christian-right-to-c… @RNS
Or keep telling their story until they become winners.
Actually, a lot of history is written by losers. It's what they do.
Let's hear it for the GQP (Great Quisling Party)!
How Christian Americanism became the political religion of the GOP: religionnews.com/2022/02/22/from-new-christian-right-to-c… @RNS
How the Christian Right embraced Christian Nationalism, Part 1: religionnews.com/2022/02/21/from-new-christian-right-to-c…
It's Christians of color — the religious cohort that most stands to benefit from a higher minimum wage — who support it most. It's white Christians (Mormons included) — the most conservative religious cohort —who support it least.
"Do you favor or oppose raising the minimum wage to $15/hour?"
There's majority support for this proposal. Even among white evangelicals at 55%!
Something else noteworthy: usually atheists are the furthest left on policy. Not here. It's non-white Christians.
He doesn't have a sexual license.
"Priceless" understates it.
Priceless rant about Boris Johnson. www.nytimes.com/2022/02/04/opinion/boris-johnson-party-sc…
Someone is drafting this shit for Trump. Who?
Trump as unhinged as ever, along with his “automatic conveyor belt” interpretation of the 12th Amendment.
Anyway: More evidence below that Trump *intended* to overturn a legitimate election. So where is the DOJ at this point?
Who says we can't enjoy a little schadenfreude at the expense of our enemies? Not the Bible: religionnews.com/2022/02/04/cant-we-enjoy-the-suffering-o…. @RNS
If pro-Israel evangelicals want to bring young evangelicals back into the fold they should tell their Israeli friends to clean up their act: religionnews.com/2022/01/31/what-to-do-about-young-evange…. @RNS
I suspect she's worried about Josh Mandel's lasers.
Sad and pathetic. There’s nothing he wouldn’t say or do for a taste of power
On the hypocrisy of religious freedom zealotry: religionnews.com/2022/01/20/when-religious-freedom-is-for…
@RNS
Of course, his lawyers argued that he should be allowed to conduct in-person worship against county Covid rules on religious freedom grounds.
Social scientists have long called these people Nones, because they say they identify with no religion. There have been studies of them by social scientists. They are a rather fuzzy group, but that's not to say they have been inadequately theorized.
He should be going to celebrate Mass at the Australian Open.
Scandalous.
So basically, among Millennials equal numbers of Nones and Christians, among Gen Z more Nones than Christians. As opposed to four times as many Christians as Nones in the Silent Generation.
1 = Protestant
2 = Catholic
3-8 = Other World Religions
9 = Atheist
10 = Agnostic
11 = Nothing in particular
All Others chose "something else" and free responded in a textbox.
He's intellectually consistent, now backing the filibuster as a way to restore Jim Crow.
This is a terrific speech by McConnell denouncing the filibuster as a Jim Crow relic, and it's a shame he abandoned this sensible position.
Why the push for Jewish institutions to adopt the IHRA antisemitism definition? Its value is open to question: religionnews.com/2022/01/13/to-define-or-not-to-define-an… @RNS
What are "all others"? Refused to answer? Non-world religions?
71% of the Silent Generation is Protestant or Catholic.
63% of Boomers
53% of Gen X
42% of Millennials
37% of Gen Z
18% of the Silent Generation are nones.
25% of Boomers
35% of Gen X
43% of Millennials
45% of Gen Z
There are clearly more nones in Gen Z than Cath/Prot.
Nice crack. Also untrue and silly.
This is why we need alternative formulations to red v. blue, as in: religionnews.com/2022/01/05/anti-vaxism-as-esoteric-relig….
The gravitational pull of two-handed journalism can be observed across distances as short as a single sentence. www.nytimes.com/2022/01/06/us/politics/jan-6-capitol-riot…
Anti-vax is the latest American esoteric religion. We've got a bunch these days: religionnews.com/2022/01/05/anti-vaxism-as-esoteric-relig…
@RNS
Why the best model for understanding American politics today is the Protestant Reformation: religionnews.com/2021/12/28/the-trumpist-reformation-is-u…
@RNS
How about the courts treat religious liberty claims the way the military treats conscientious objector applications? religionnews.com/2021/12/21/lets-treat-religious-liberty-… @RNS
A long haul, Carol Ann, but better late than never. Thanks for hanging in there.
This chapter began at a conference at the Leonard E. Greenberg Center for the Study of Religion in Public Life at Trinity College. Thanks for seeing it through @directorsilk @Chris_G_White -- Metaphysical Religion and Spirituality: A Measured Approach - scholar.google.com/scholar_share?url=https://link.springe…
An odd choice. I would have thought religious studies departments were the ones to replace.
Gorsuch's religious maximalism on NY's vaccine mandate loses, but shows what's wrong with Scotus' free exercise jurisprudence: religionnews.com/2021/12/17/supreme-court-religious-liber… @RNS
Tis the season to be wary. Gift-giving is dangerous to your moral health: religionnews.com/2021/12/13/gift-giving-is-perilous-micro… @RNS
Tis the season to be wary. Gift-giving is dangerous to your moral heath: religionnews.com/2021/12/13/gift-giving-is-perilous-micro… @RNS
How is it blasphemy if "they" comes to be used as the third person singular in standard English, just as centuries ago "you" (the second person plural) took the place of "thee" and "thou" as the second person singular?
Jesus called God "father" it is beyond the shadow of doubt that it's a man, a single entity. Referring to God as "they" is blasphemy.
Mark Silk reposted
Bigotry and cowardice in the GOP www.ncronline.org/news/opinion/bigotry-and-cowardice-gop
Lauren Boebert's Islamophobic standup routine was good old-fashioned fascist comedy: religionnews.com/2021/11/30/lauren-boebert-does-islamopho… @RNS
Agreed. Madison himself would have done more to protect the state from religion, but states like CT and MA wanted to keep their standing orders.
The Founders who led on this issue (Jefferson/Madison) as well as their evangelical supporters made it clear that mixing corrupted both. The restrictions went both ways.
A look at the founding makes clear that the U.S. also wanted to shield the state from religious involvement. What is "no religious test for office" if not that?
"The United States, in guaranteeing freedom of religion, sought to shield religion from state involvement. France, in guaranteeing freedom of religion, sought to shield the state from religious involvement. This distinction has consequences." currentpub.com/2021/11/23/on-french-secularism/
The "one religion" in Mike Flynn's "one nation under God" is not Christianity. It's Judeo-Christianity: religionnews.com/2021/11/22/is-josh-mandel-the-christian-…. @RNS
How Maimonides would have reacted to Dennis Prager's anti-vax screeds: religionnews.com/2021/11/12/what-would-maimonides-say-abo…
@RNS
Apparently my little jeu d'esprit (religionnews.com/2021/09/29/why-our-preferred-pronoun-for…) on the pronouns of God has succeeded as a fundraising ploy for a small Baptist church. Ah, Their will be done!
The CBMW called out the small Texas Baptist congregation in a post criticizing gender-neutral pronouns, *even though the church's current stance still uses "himself" for God*.
The saga has resulted in $15K in donations for FBC Elm Mott.
You've got to see Jason Berry's new film on New Orleans jazz funerals: religionnews.com/2021/11/05/new-film-offers-a-portrait-of… @RNS
I'm afraid ambition has led many a man to humiliate himself.
If David Perdue runs for governor, he would become Trump's knife in Brian Kemp's back, Trump's poison poured into Kemp's chalice. I don't understand how a man would humiliate himself to serve such a role.
georgiarecorder.com/2021/11/04/bookman-gops-trump-lite-vi… #gapol
Decline of Western Civilization: Once there was physics and metaphysics. Thank you, Aristotle. Then there was data and metadata. Thank you, Philip Bagley. Now there's Facebook and MetaFacebook. Thank you, Mark Zuckerberg.
Many years ago, in a universe far far away, when Beardsley Ruml resigned as dean of social sciences at U. of Chicago to become chairman of Macy's, U. of C. President Robert Hutchins cracked, "He's giving up ideas for notions." Ideas have now become notions.
Religious liberty quiz show RNS readers closer to Madison and Jefferson than to today's religious liberty enthusiasts: religionnews.com/2021/10/25/a-religious-liberty-quiz-show…
@RNS
And we're super excited to give it to you.
How far should religious liberty go? Here'a quiz that let's you decide: religionnews.com/2021/10/14/your-religious-liberty-quiz/ @RNS
So let's see what he told the lawyers and what the lawyers told him.
Floyd tried to limit the scope of an investigation into how the EC treated abuse survivors- putting him at odds with local churches. He defended his decisions in resigning
religionnews.com/2021/10/14/ronnie-floyd-resigns-from-sbc…
What do you think about religious liberty? Take the quiz: religionnews.com/2021/10/14/your-religious-liberty-quiz/. @RNS
Upset that English pronoun evolution means calling God "They"? Why you shouldn't be: religionnews.com/2021/10/04/why-calling-god-they-shouldnt…. @RNS
What's a museum?
He seems genuinely puzzled to find himself in a museum.
The top down model isn't going to cut it when settling Afghan evacuees in America: religionnews.com/2021/09/27/meeting-the-challenge-of-rese… @RNS
Less power to him. To start celebrating Halloween before the Fall equinox is as bad as putting up Christmas decorations before Thanksgiving.
Pretty sure I just saw a kid trick-or-treating. And you know what? More power to him.
Don't like today's leadership style? Jonah's the model: religionnews.com/2021/09/20/a-prophet-for-our-time/ @RNS
Cotton Mather would not have been shocked at news of an atheist chief of chaplains at Harvard. Nor should we be. religionnews.com/2021/09/13/why-shouldnt-harvard-have-an-… @RNS
That's assuming it's particular provisions he cares about, as opposed to calling attention to himself.
As a sometime medievalist, I say your missus is correct. In the history of the West, far more in the way of barbarism can be found in Ancient Rome and post-medieval Europe.
The fundamentalist who created the template for conservatism today: religionnews.com/2021/08/23/the-fundamentalist-who-create… @RNS
Why Jews should support Ben and Jerry's decision to withdraw from the West Bank: religionnews.com/2021/08/16/why-jews-should-support-ben-a…
@RNS
America replaces redemption with fulfillment, cf. Cuomo, Climate Change, My Pillow Guy: religionnews.com/2021/08/11/when-redemption-fails-cuomo-l… @RNS
It's called the Harvey Weinstein two-step.
NEW: In public, Cuomo cast himself as an advocate of women. In private, women say, he was harassing them at the same time.
By @michaelscherer @jdawsey1
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/cuomo-sexual-harassment/2…
Politics not law explains the filing of anti-vax religious lawsuits in time of Covid: religionnews.com/2021/08/06/why-file-frivolous-religious-… @RNS
Be a moron.
Eric Metaxas: Don’t get vaccinated. Be a rebel. currentpub.com/2021/07/28/eric-metaxas-dont-get-vaccinate…
"Stop the Steal" = American Civil Sedevacantism. Say what? See here: religionnews.com/2021/07/28/running-on-stop-the-steal-the…. @RNS
Yeah, yeah. By the way, Rick. What did you think of Alito's concurrence in Fulton?
Of course that's not what public education means. Unless you're Humpty Dumpty.
Because it's a scam to undermine public education.
Opinion | Why are unions and Democrats so opposed to giving poor children a choice in schooling? www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/07/08/save-dc-privat… @PostOpinions
"White evangelicals" numerically, politically in decline: religionnews.com/2021/07/14/white-evangelicals-in-numeric… @RNS @PRRIpoll
Are they calling 'em golden gophers?
The exemplary Baptist roots of Robert's Rules: religionnews.com/2021/07/09/the-baptist-insight-of-the-ma…
@RNS
And presumably think they're a good thing.
Share agreeing with, "Religions are usually a barrier to equality between women and men" in 2018.
Evangelicals: 26%
Mainline: 20%
Black Prot: 32%
Catholics: 19%
Other Faith: 22%
Nones: 40%
Evangelicals are more aware of barriers created by faith than Catholics or Mainline!
Pew election survey suggests American political polarization should have declined in 2020. It didn't. Why? Religion. religionnews.com/2021/07/02/americans-are-as-divided-as-e… @RNS
Hamilton might have — on his better days: www.denofgeek.com/movies/alexander-hamilton-real-history-….
Would the Founding Fathers support critical race theory? www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/06/30/would-founding…
Ah, that fibbing, backtracking conference of Catholic bishops: religionnews.com/2021/06/29/catholic-bishops-put-eucharis… @RNS
Or he was consciously making a homoerotic crack at Trump's expense.
Sheesh. My only question is: Is he a Carlson-like cynic or has he actually drunk the Trumpian Kool-Aid?
Of course, the federal RFRA was intended not as a statutory remedy but as an instruction to the Court on constitutional adjudication. Which the Court summarily rejected in Boerne.
I expect there was. Whether that affected the positions of Sotomayor, Kagan, and Breyer is hard to say.
I know there's a quibble about whether or not RFRA simply reinstated the court's pre-Smith jurisprudence. But RFRA does provide deference to free exercise, and after Hobby Lobby I think there was some rethinking about RFRA on the left.
Hobby Lobby was a RFRA (statutory) decision. Is Barrett critical of it? Could be but hard to say.
How influential was the Hobby Lobby decision in that reappraisal?
Do you?
Scotus puts Scalia's notorious religious free exercise decision (Smith) on life support. It's time to pull the plug: religionnews.com/2021/06/21/scotus-puts-scalias-smith-dec…. @RNS
But some of those bishops are simply going to say, "Don't let the door hit you on the way out."
The German bishops are the other side of the same coin — a subject for another column.
what if you wrote this piece with the German bishops in mind and in reality?
“The idea that very direct warnings and guidance from the Vatican would simply be seen as an advisory opinion was not part of my experience,” John Carr
The fracas over a Eucharistic document aimed at pro-choice pols like Joe Biden points to the end of the era of popes as oracles of God: religionnews.com/2021/06/16/the-end-of-the-oracular-papacy/. @RNS
If you think it’s a coincidence that two accusatory letters from Russell Moore were leaked just before the Southern Baptist Convention convenes in Nashville, Tennessee, next week, I’ve got a big granite mountain east of Atlanta to sell you. religionnews.com/2021/06/09/the-bubbas-that-be-in-the-sbc/ @RNS
Why were @drmoore's letters leaked when they were? To sink the candidacy of Patterson-ite candidate Mike Stone at next week's Southern Baptist Convention in Nashville: religionnews.com/2021/06/09/the-bubbas-that-be-in-the-sbc/. @RNS
The wages of Marjorie Taylor Green: Hat store owner apologizes for anti-vax Star of David patches. religionnews.com/2021/05/31/hat-store-owner-apologizes-fo… @RNS
The GOP's religion is not Christianity (or Christian Nationalism) but Trumpianity, and here's a Scripture for it to canonize: religionnews.com/2021/05/26/the-true-republican-religion/. @RNS
A more congenial gig than going back to Southern, I presume.
Russell Moore, Baptist ethicist and Trump critic, to leave ERLC for Christianity Today religionnews.com/2021/05/18/russell-moore-baptist-ethicis… via @RNS
Katie brings the hammer down. Ouch!
Big Pharma says they need to charge astronomical prices to pay for research and development. Yet, the amount they spend on manipulating the market to enrich shareholders completely eclipses what's spent on R&D. Today, I confronted a CEO about the industry's lies, with visuals ⤵️
Fool Al once, shame on you. Al embraces your foolishness, shame on him.
Critics of critical race theory in the Southern Baptist Convention have turned to an atheist hoaxer - rather than Christian schools - to learn about CRT
religionnews.com/2021/05/18/james-lindsay-southern-baptis…
You're correct, Phil.
So, overall, polarization among religious groups has decreased since 2008, with the significant exceptions being atheists, agnostics and non-white evangelicals, who have become more liberal, more Democratic.
Interesting to see that a lot of Christian groups are less conservative/Rep. in 2020 vs 2008. LDS moved pretty significantly toward the center.
Big shifts among the smaller trads, though.
Buddhists, Hindus, Muslims all shifted away from the Democrats.
Black Prots did, too.
He appears to have done two and a half points better with younger evangelicals than Clinton — but of course there were significant third-party opportunities in 2016.
Joe Biden was going to win back some white evangelicals, right?
He may have done 1 point better among younger evangelicals than Obama.
But, he did about five points worse among white evangelicals over the age of 40 than Obama did. And no better than Clinton in 2016.
New Pew survey shows American Jews increasingly divided by religion and politics: religionnews.com/2021/05/14/the-growing-jewish-divide/ @RNS
Got it. All good!
Sure, but who said anything about truth? Trump is the GOP's existential crisis.
Byron Donalds (R-FL) after Cheney vote: “Let me posit to you this, if you had a member of the Democratic leadership who said they don’t believe in climate change anymore, would they stay in leadership? I don’t think so.” Trump, in other words is the GOP's existential crisis.
I can't think of anyone in the PRO-Francis wing of the US hierarchy (with the semi-exception of +McElroy) who has publicly denounced the anti-Catholic insanity of the anti-Francisistas.
Say what you want about today's GOP, at least they have Liz Cheney denouncing the Big Lie.
I can't think of anyone in the anti-Francis wing of the US hierarchy who has denounced the anti-Catholic insanity of their party.
So proportion of Mainline college grads remains constant, while evidence of shrinkage among Mainline no college. Thanks!
Very interesting, Ryan. Can you say what the proportions of Mainliners in each group are over that time period?
The folks in the pews of Mainline Protestant churches are not liberals.
There's actually fairly compelling evidence that Mainliners without a college degree are becoming more Republican.
While those w/a college degree are fairly evenly split among Democrats and Republicans.
The American remedies for too much corporate power are 1) anti-trust breakup; and 2) government regulation. In Facebook's case, both are in order. Which is not to say what the rules should be on de-platforming, defamation etc.
Will Scotus uphold the right of states to require school children to be vaccinated even if their parents claim a free exercise right not to vaccinate them? A challenge to CT's new law may be the test case: religionnews.com/2021/05/04/connecticuts-religious-anti-v…. @RNS
Ultimately, Snow White is about the lover's liberation of the beloved from the toxic control of the beloved's jealous parent.
So is the willful flouting of pandemic restrictions.
Biden on the stampede in Israel:
"The loss of life among worshipers practicing their faith is heartbreaking."
With four exceptions (Alaska, Idaho, Montana and Wyoming), every "no religion" state voted for Biden. With two exceptions (Virginia and Georgia), every "Protestant" state voted for Trump.
The most popular religion in each state in 2020.
No Religion - 25 states
Protestant - 22 states
Catholic - 2 states (New Jersey and Rhode Island)
LDS - 1 state (Utah)
And 100% of historians believe history should...be studied.
“84% of Republicans believe history should celebrate our nation’s past, while 70% of Democrats think history should question it” currentpub.com/2021/04/30/84-of-republicans-believe-histo…
Still, Ivy League meritocrats all, no?
I expect you'll be telling your students that, Phil.
I don't think it was ideological. It did express a political philosophy, about which it was pretty explicit. Government = us. It's called democracy.
Politico: Biden’s speech was ideological without sounding ideological currentpub.com/2021/04/29/politico-bidens-speech-was-ideo…
Wondering why the opposition to Biden's climate agenda has been so flaccid? White evangelicals are losing their climate skepticism: religionnews.com/2021/04/28/evangelicals-are-losing-their…. @RNS
In other words, Trumpian = Conservative. A new low for the American conservative tradition.
Most religious groups perceive that there's little distance between Trump and the GOP.
White evangelicals are the *only* group to see Trump to the right of the GOP (stat sig.)
And white evangelicals see both Biden and the Dems as more liberal than any other religious group.
So it turns out the GOP IS willing to limit religious exemptions.
BREAKING: The Virginia GOP will not allow religious Jews who cannot travel due to Shabbat to participate in its convention. There were 38 votes in favor of providing a religious exemption, 28 against, and 3 abstentions. The motion needed 75% in favor to pass.
Too late for that.
lord please give me the strength not to make a snarky post about this earnest pitchfork earth day article
Hey, Rick. How come you haven't yet answered my simple question: Do you favor Employment Division v. Smith's denial of free exercise claims against neutral, generally applicable law?
No such concessions can be made, because the resentment is ineluctable. Cf. Nietzschean ressentiment, which in Robert Solomon's interpretation "arises out of the frustrated desire to take revenge for one's wounded self-esteem."
I feel that I've read a version of this argument a hundred times and I'm still not sure what concessions the "elite" are supposed to make to ease the resentment of people in the so-called Heartland. www.americanpurpose.com/articles/the-bitter-heartland/
I for the most part agree, though Hispanics who consider themselves Indios could identify as "American Indian." Also, FWIW, "other Pacific islander" could be taken as a non-American indigenous category, and might even include Filipinos.
No, we're not becoming a majority-minority country; or, as religion goes, so goes race: religionnews.com/2021/04/19/racial-identity-follows-in-th…. @RNS
Bring back the witenagemot!
The Anglo-Saxon caucus? currentpub.com/2021/04/17/the-anglo-saxon-caucus/
The Consistory is going to have to look into this.
Jerry, Sr. is turning over in his grave. Ted Cruz, who groveled for Jerry, Jr.'s endorsement in 2016, is smiling.
Liberty University has sued Jerry Falwell Jr. for $10 million, accusing its former president and chancellor of breach of contract and fiduciary duty. The suit lands just as the school's board of trustees arrives in Lynchburg for its semiannual meeting. www.nytimes.com/2021/04/16/us/jerry-falwell-jr-liberty-un…
I prefer Marianne Williamson's "Trump is an opportunistic infection." The infection has now spread through the entire GOP body politic.
Trump is gone, and Republican Senators are doing white genocide talking points. Trump was a symptom, not a cause.
Shouldn't he have said "communicating grace"?
“The Eucharist is infrastructure for sanctifying grace.”
Simple question: Do you favor Smith's denial of free exercise claims against neutral, generally applicable law?
I've got no problem with bona fide comparability—in-home and in-home in this case. I'd actually prefer pre-Smith strict scrutiny. IMHO Court now playing fast and loose with Smith, Babalu Aye.
Scotus just neutered Scalia on religious liberty: religionnews.com/2021/04/12/how-scotus-is-restoring-relig… @RNS
Eastern Time.
I have a lunch meeting at noon and a class at 2. Will try to catch what I can, thanks.
Mark, you're invited to join us on our virtual religious freedom event via Zoom - link below. I'd also be happy to share notable quotes from Gov. Jared Polis (D) and other speakers following the event. us02web.zoom.us/j/81996432481
Given huge attendance decline in the general population, the more significant change may be the embrace of "evangelical" by non-evangelicals (i.e. mainline Protestants, Catholics, Jews...). Under the circumstances attendance of bona fide evangelicals may have declined less.
Two things. I'd bad at math. The decline of weekly attenders is actually down nine points, not eleven.
And, I've written about this in more depth with older data here:
religioninpublic.blog/2020/12/10/so-why-is-evangelicalism…
Question for Cruz & Co.: When a church seeks to prevent open carry in its sanctuary, what prevails, 1st Amendment religious liberty or 2nd Amendment right to bear arms?
And, as I recall, you were vilified as traitors at the time and, in certain cases, forced by editors to stop writing in that vein.
20 years later, it's interesting to see some conservatives come around to the viewpoint that a relative handful of us liberals dared to express at the time, that our invasion of Iraq and talk of a "Pax Americana" constituted the worst foreign policy mistake in US history.
Theory: Mia Farrow is the Alma Maria Mahler Gropius Werfel of her time.
And I'll bet some of those non-denominational churches are SBC churches in disguise.
But, here's what most notable about this.
Among the people that leave the SBC, almost all of them end up in non-denominational churches. Very few change religious traditions entirely.
Cf. Might the Church not be better served by having fewer -- but better -- Catholics
Kind of like someone giving water to voters on line, according to Georgia.
In other words, even as Trump increased his (the GOP candidate's) share of the Catholic vote, Biden increased the Democratic candidate's share by slightly more. I'm guessing that white Catholics trended to Biden, non-white to Trump. Right?
All Catholic in 2016:
Trump: 48.9%
Clinton: 46.8%
Third Party: 4.2%
All Catholic in 2020:
Trump: 50.2%
Biden: 48.4%
Third Party: 1.3%
Third party went down 2.9 points. Biden got 1.6 of that. Trump got 1.3.
So throw out the exits. By your numbers, Trump increased his share of the Catholic vote by about 3 pts. What are the aggregate totals?
We should really stop relying on exit polls.
I don't think I've ever seen a peer reviewed article in political science that relied entirely on exit polls.
@rp_griffin from Nationscape lays out some excellent evidence of their flaws here:
www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2020/11/11/lessons-2020-el…
By your calculations, in 2020 Trump did 1 pt. better with white Catholics and 4 pts. better with non-white Catholics than in 2016. Exit polls show him winning the Catholic vote by 4 pts. in 2016 and losing it by 5 pts. in 2020. What gives?
The religious groups where Trump did better in 2020 vs. 2016.
Non-White Catholics: +4%
Mormons: +11%
Where he did worse:
Atheist: -3%
Agnostic: -6%
Nothing in Particular: -4%
Biden didn't take Trump votes, he took third party votes. That's the religion story.
How the hollowing out of American religion turned the GOP away from democracy: religionnews.com/2021/04/05/the-hollowing-out-of-american…. @RNS
Eulaliaaa!
4 books that changed me!
Coca Cola should announce that its executives will be providing bottled drinks to citizens lined up to vote free of charge, daring the State of Georgia to arrest them.
But where was Moose?
Rooting for Boris and Natasha on this episode.
What's the sample size for the small groups: Hindus, Orthodox in particular?
Hindu gender gap the biggest. The Kamala factor?
I do. Pretty big gender gaps for a lot of traditions.
6 pts for white evangelicals, 10 pts for non-white.
11 pts for mainline.
10 pts for white Catholic, 8 for non-white.
10 pts for Black Prot.
18 pts for Orthodox.
10 pts for agnostics
No gap for LDS, though.
Hindu gender gap the biggest. The Kamala factor?
I do. Pretty big gender gaps for a lot of traditions.
6 pts for white evangelicals, 10 pts for non-white.
11 pts for mainline.
10 pts for white Catholic, 8 for non-white.
10 pts for Black Prot.
18 pts for Orthodox.
10 pts for agnostics
No gap for LDS, though.
Not sure about unique but always open to information.
@directorsilk Could a Denver interfaith event be a sign of increasing ideological diversity in the pursuit of religious freedom? Where even a blue-state Dem governor feels welcome? We think so, and we'd love to share more information if this feels unique to you.
Cool, but where are Cupich and O'Malley and Gregory?
The statement "God is on Your Side" has been signed by 13 US Bishops and almost 100 Catholic religious orders, schools and institutions. I'm proud that my own religious order has extended a word of compassion to this community. AMDG. tylerclementi.org/catholicbishopsstatement/
Is the Equality Act a big threat to religious freedom? No. religionnews.com/2021/03/25/why-the-equality-act-is-no-bi…. @RNS
For sure. And in most cases it's nothing more than a meme, part of a hoary tradition of turning the founders into devout Christians. Understanding that, I suggest calling out the principles. E.g. What about conservative neo-monarchism?
I'm semi-serious. There are Judeo-Christian principles regarding rebellion (e.g. Romans 13), slavery, women's rights, care for the poor, the role of religion (viz. theocracy), etc. Sure, the "Christian" principles are sometimes at odds with the "Judeo" ones. Let's do it!
Could someone please enumerate the Judeo-Christian principles on which America's founding was based? Just asking.
Could someone please enumerate the Judeo-Christian principles on which America's founding was based? Just asking.
In Atlanta shootings, Evangelical purity culture meets Christian cancel culture: @RNS
Christianity is under assault = young people are leaving it in droves. #riseofthenones
It’s a white grievance party now. Very dangerous place for a political party to be.
I disagree. They just like Islamophobes.
Just got a dunning letter from Donald Trump, Jr. that says: "The do-nothing Democrats will stop at nothing to destroy my father’s legacy and turn America into a socialist nightmare. We can’t let that happen, Fellow Conservative." Sound like they're do-something Dems, no?
How about: Dayenu Feinstein, enough already. Kind of a Pesach meme.
Does anyone have a meme of a wretched elderly super rich incrementalist bat trying to uphold a racist institution or something like that? asking for a friend
Gold standard yes, but less accurate than non-in-person surveys where social desirability bias comes in. So GSS numbers on nones and church attendance will now be 1) more accurate; and 2) more in line with other surveys. Right?
This is going to be a big story in how we measure religion.
The GSS is our gold standard, dating back to 1972. It's always been in person, but went phone/online in 2020.
The nones are going to surge and church attendance is going to decline. Largely because of survey technique
Has anyone proposed democratizing the Catholic Church by getting rid of chancel culture? Just asking.
Why are Republican Hindus such outliers (i.e. just over one-third Trumpist)? Is it because such a high proportion of them are well educated?
If I were to guess how Republicans would split in a Trump vs. Non-Trump fracture, here's my best guess of how it would go down among religious groups.
72% of white Catholics/Evangelicals are MAGA, but just 56% of LDS.
Will the Vatican succeed in holding back the tide on same-sex unions? Don't bet on it. religionnews.com/2021/03/15/the-vatican-tries-to-hold-bac… @RNS
It's a climate apocalypse updating of the Dr. Strangelove solution to the nuclear apocalypse: we the powerful survive, you the powerless don't.
crypto bro ecofascist nihilism is a new one but not a surprising one
To be sure. Leibovitz, however, just writes "from the Deep South."
Yo, NYT! Time to stop referring to Jon Ossoff as 1st Jewish Senator from Deep South (www.nytimes.com/2021/03/13/us/politics/georgia-republican…). Distinction belongs to Judah P. Benjamin, U.S. senator from LA 1853-61 (then AG, Sec of State CSA). @MarkLeibovich
Yo, NYT! Time to stop referring to Jon Ossoff as 1st Jewish Senator from Deep South (www.nytimes.com/2021/03/13/us/politics/georgia-republican…). Distinction belongs to Judah P. Benjamin, U.S. senator from LA 1853-61 (then AG, Sec of State CSA). @MarkLeibovich
I'm trying to remember which state the CDC is in.
Some state has to be last.
It doesn't have to be Georgia. #gapol
So this is what it takes to get Republicans to stop superspreader events.
The age-old xenophobic trope of foreigners bringing disease into the United States is still being used after Americans spent a full year infecting each other with COVID-19
Past time to take the next one.
Read the latest "#dabruemet: 20 Years Later" essay by @directorsilk (@trinitycollege) on @AmRelJournal: "Dabru Emet: A Small Step Forward"
#thread 1/4
From Borat to Swan, interviewers with foreign accents have a leg up when it comes to American interviewees.
Among the absolute best
Now that the GOP has decided it loves Dr. Seuss, will it embrace his environmentalism? The Lorax is not holding his breath.
We're now faced with the Religion of Trump's Lost Cause: religionnews.com/2021/03/05/the-religion-of-trumps-lost-c… @RNS
On the other hand, after Biden's remarks about the governors of Texas and Mississippi yesterday, I'm worried about the reaction of the NRA (Neanderthal Rights Association).
dad gets it
why aren't more people talking about the word civilized? It draws an invidious distinction between people who live in cities (good) and those who don't (bad). Also, what about gauche and sinister, which denigrate the left-handed among us?
why aren’t more people talking about the word barbaric? It is a pejorative used to other non-Roman/Greek ppl (xenophobic) and is also anti-beard (hotphobic) 😤
why aren't more people talking about the word civilized? It draws an invidious distinction between people who live in cities (good) and those who don't (bad). Also, what about gauche and sinister, which denigrate the left-handed among us?
why aren’t more people talking about the word barbaric? It is a pejorative used to other non-Roman/Greek ppl (xenophobic) and is also anti-beard (hotphobic) 😤
The question is: Who is best situated to squeeze the Pentagon officials for answers. I'm saying DOJ. And Garland says this investigation will be his top priority. Fasten your seatbelts.
Those memos were clearly written as part of the planning and preparations for Jan. 6, in anticipation of Jan. 6. The way they chose to prepare was to stress the ways the NG could NOT respond, rather than to plan for how it could.
Curious, no?
No it doesn't. Whatever one things of the legitimacy of his position, his Catholicism is no mere outward veneer.
Actually reveals that Biden is using Catholicism as a outward veneer
From Mario Cuomo to Joe Biden: the pro-life/pro-choice Catholic politician: religionnews.com/2021/02/27/being-pro-choice-doesnt-neces…. @RNS
Why Biden's position on abortion doesn't necessarily make him a bad Catholic: religionnews.com/2021/02/27/being-pro-choice-doesnt-neces… @RNS
And Lindsay is more "submissive." www.newsweek.com/lindsey-graham-trump-more-dominant-gop-m…
Potato Head (he, she, they, his, hers, theirs).
But what about Mrs. Potato Head? How do we differentiate?
In fairness, Potato Head was always so high-handed and needlessly formal, insisting children call him “Mr.” Potato Head, like he was Sir Elton John or something.
As the old crack went, she was just a poor girl from Argentina, but she had her ways and means.
Their recommendation will be for Democrats to put their absentee ballots under their MyPillows and wait for the good fairy to take them away to be counted.
And I shall call it: "My Pillow Conservatism."
But of course.
will my followers interact with this tweet?
no no no
👇 👇 👇
Reading it where?
reading this sentence: “as psychopolitical bourgeois pathologies go, this must count as one of the more remarkable” 🥴
I guess if climate denial is part of your belief system, the point is to demonstrate that the nominee doesn't share your belief system.
What's the point of asking a nominee for attorney general (or the Supreme Court) about personal beliefs regarding climate change.
Up to a point, perhaps. But a far larger proportion of the Orthodox vote GOP.
Bob Wuthnow's restructuring thesis in action?
Holy shit. 13.6% of Orthodox Jews identify as born-again/evangelical!
The share of 55 religious traditions that identify as born-again/evangelical.
Non-denominationals and charismatics top the list.
Notable:
More Mormons identify as evangelical than Episcopalians.
41% of Buddhists
24% of Orthodox
Hi-res/zoomable: ibb.co/VmzCx7m
Fine account of the rise and fall of the Bozocracy.
2/17/21: Trump Plaza and Hotel is imploded. Rush Limbaugh kicks the bucket. What's the Trifecta?
No.
Thesis: Islamofascism
Antithesis: Islamoleftism
Synthesis: Christian Nationalism
Wehner writes, "For nearly a half-decade, Republicans became accustomed to saying one thing and thinking another." I'd say they'd become accustomed to doing that for a lot longer — at least since 1994, when the Gingrich-led GOP gained control of the House.
Worth a read. Personally, I favor the “own the libs” motivation for backing Trump. And a significant percentage have been brainwashed by lying rightwing media. www.nytimes.com/2021/02/14/opinion/trump-impeachment-tria…
It's not an op-ed, John. It's an unsigned editorial — the considered opinion of the editorial board, speaking on behalf of the paper.
The *Kansas City Star* publishes a scathing op-ed on Sen. Josh Hawley’s vote to acquit Trump thewayofimprovement.com/2021/02/15/the-kansas-city-star-p…
Yes, Paula White was named to oversee the Initiative. But did it ever have a staff? I never heard of anyone who actually worked there, or that it ever did anything. @melissarogers @jackmjenkins
Under Trump, the WH faith office went largely unstaffed until 2019 when Paula White oversaw the Faith & Opportunity Initiative. Before then, much of Trump’s religious outreach involved informal meetings with a core group of unofficial evangelical advisers. religionnews.com/2021/02/14/biden-to-sign-executive-order…
Been there, Jack. Done that: religionnews.com/2021/01/08/the-desecration-of-the-house/ and religionnews.com/2021/01/21/the-civil-religious-cleansing…, to say nothing of www.jstor.org/stable/40005932?seq=1. @RNS
1. There is a whole dissertation waiting to be written about the multiple references to the U.S. Senate chamber as “sacred” — including *by* insurrectionists, who then proceeded to, according to House managers and other lawmakers, “desecrate” it — over the past month.
Witnesses to call: Pence, Milley, the two sergeants-at-arms, McCarthy, Wray...
Why not subpoena Mike Pence?
To understand what's going on in Myanmar, you need to understand the Burmese concept of hpoun (spiritual power) and how it works politically. Here's the skinny: religionnews.com/2021/02/13/democratic-values-are-pushing…. @RNS
Yep, It's the only way he thinks he can get the good ol' boys to think he's one of them.
You seven-year-old Oedipus, you! "My Mother the Car" is the greatest example of Pop Freudianism in the history of American culture! How Burns got away with it is an eternal mystery. RIP.
So it turns out that Herman Melville's Great American Novel must be reread as cli-fi, with Ahab an obsessed carbon sequesterer. Call it Moby Sink. www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/2019/12/natures-soluti…
Excellent op-ed in The Hill!
It's time to turn climate emergency rhetoric into action. @POTUS should declare climate a national emergency and then really treat it like one. @climatepsych and I look at Biden's COVID strategy as a model in @thehill. @earlblumenauer @AOC @SenSanders thehill.com/opinion/energy-environment/537993-five-things…
Mark Silk reposted
It's time to turn climate emergency rhetoric into action. @POTUS should declare climate a national emergency and then really treat it like one. @climatepsych and I look at Biden's COVID strategy as a model in @thehill. @earlblumenauer @AOC @SenSanders thehill.com/opinion/energy-environment/537993-five-things…
Maybe Baby Jesus?
“Maybe Jesus.” #sweetjesus
Wow. Just got an email from the RNC asking me to take their 2021 GOP Platform Survey. Kind of a tabula rasa, since there was no 2020 GOP Platform. First question has two choices for self-identification: Republican or Socialist. Check it out: gop.com/2021-republican-platform.
But this isn't a criminal trial, it's a civil proceeding, where pleading the fifth is ordinarily not allowed.
No reason why he can't be compelled, although he could invoke his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination.
Quelle shitshow if he actually shows up!
Indeed, the letter warns Trump that should he refuse to testify, his refusal "supports a strong adverse inference regarding your actions (and inactions) on January 6, 2021."
I wonder if they have first-hand testimony about Trump's reaction watching the attack from the WH.
Cf. Lucky Jim: "this strangely neglected topic..."
But then how will chapter 1 of literally every Ph.D. dissertation begin?
Belief in a big Watergate conspiracy was just a theory until it wasn't.
All 37 of them.
Just talked to a reporter from a French newspaper. He wants to talk to evangelicals who voted for Trump in 2016, but voted for Biden in 2020. Any takers? Private message me and I can get you in touch with him.
Since being crucified by Twitter and disappearing from Washington, Trump has occulted himself. His acolytes await his return "in some form." Some claim to speak with him. He may appear to others. Is his second coming imminent? Who can say?
Interesting that today's National Prayer Breakfast featured participation from past presidents Jimmy Carter, George W. Bush, Bill Clinton, and Barack Obama…
…But not Trump.
Republican denunciation of QAnon is sooo 2020.
Despite denouncing QAnon months ago, Kevin McCarthy now says, "I don’t even know what it is" www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2021/02/04/mccarthy-qanon-m…
The Jewish establishment needs to get off its butt and push for action on climate change: religionnews.com/2021/02/03/jewish-leaders-need-to-step-u…. @RNS
At least they proclaim their sedevacantism. It's time for other trads to do the same — or to be named and claimed, in this outsider's view.
Icons of Catholic Trumpism:
I suggest that the Dems say they'll accept the deal if 1) the GOP caucus censures Greene; and 2) she apologizes for her actions. Won't never happen.
Kevin McCarthy is trying to cut a deal with House Democrats over the fate of Marjorie Taylor Greene, but so far the Dems aren't buying.
Perhaps more importantly, this thread should be read as Greene herself rejecting McCarthy's request to act sane. So there's that. #gapol
Props to the Post for solid coverage of this effort, notwithstanding that it's owned by Amazon boss Jeff Bezos.
More like a deranged In The Loop spinoff, I'd say: www.imdb.com/title/tt1226774/
Any sign of GOP cooperation is newsworthy even if it's faux cooperation.
So if his team believes that he's not the ex-president, that means it's constitutional to impeach him, according to their lights, right?
Trump team has apparently backtracked from calling him the "Former President" to using the title "45th President." I find that ominous and terrifying
If those bishops actually want to work on the climate change and the refugee crisis, that is.
Though @POTUS is only the second Catholic U.S. #president ever, many bishops aren't sold on him. @ThomasReeseSJ suggests a list of issues that Biden and the bishops can work together on, from climate change to the refugee crisis.
religionnews.com/2021/01/29/can-catholic-bishops-work-wit…
And: Will the House managers have answers to impart in 10 days?
Back to the Watergate mantra: "What did Trump know and when did he know it?" Plus: "What did his people know and when did THEY know it?"
Back to the Watergate mantra: "What did Trump know and when did he know it?" Plus: "What did his people know and when did THEY know it?"
Um, I meant: "As in, let's say, when MBS said "off with his head" with respect to Jamal Khashoggi.
I believe the term is, in fact, "literally." As in, let's say, when MBS said "off with his aid" about
"Pulling out the stops"! Is there a term for using a metaphor when it is literally accurate? (See the postal service slogan "We deliver.")
I believe the term is, in fact, "literally." As in, let's say, when MBS said "off with his aid" about
"Pulling out the stops"! Is there a term for using a metaphor when it is literally accurate? (See the postal service slogan "We deliver.")
Not the greatest and most effective since Jeff Davis?
Alabama GOP wants to pass a resolution declaring Trump “one of the greatest and most effective Presidents in the 245-year history of this Republic.” thewayofimprovement.com/2021/01/28/alabama-gop-wants-to-p…
Steve King was not immune. He was deprived of his committee assignments in 2019 and defeated in the Republican primary last year. Tolerance of the likes of Taylor and Boebert is the measure of where the House GOP has come in two years.
Why are people like Mitt Romney, Bob Corker and Liz Cheney "Republican In Name Only," thus eligible for purging, while nutcases like Marjorie Taylor Greene, Lauren Boebert, etc., are members in good standing?
Why are far-right extremists immune to the RINO treatment?
See chapters 87 and 88.
When I visited the Museum of the Confederacy in NOLA 30 years ago there was a crown of thorns identified as having been woven for Davis by no less than Pope Pius IX. Not so. It was woven by Davis' wife.
The trail of the White Christian Persecution Complex leads to unsurprising places.
Moby Fuckin' Dick
Sure. Just the way we continue to talk about a project being "out of steam."
When all vehicles are electric, will people still talk about a project "running out of gas"?
Moral Majority, Inc. had state organizations, but so far as I know it didn't operate at the congregational level, the way Robertson and Reed's CC did with its voter guides. I'd say the networks in the 70s were among activists, and largely ad hoc. But it's worth exploring.
That's interesting. And I wonder also about the stronger networks of congregations on the right? Do we know anything about that? (And much of org on right goes back well before 89, with Moral Majority etc; Worthen's APOSTLES OF REASON has some good stuff on this in 80s I think).
Worth recalling that her Dad, when he was governor, was notable for supporting state benefits for undocumented immigrants: www.ontheissues.org/celeb/Mike_Huckabee_Immigration.htm
The right also has a structural advantage, in that, among whites, its people tend to belong to congregations that are more politically homogeneous than those on the left. Since the Christian Coalition was created in 1989, the right has been able to use congregations to organize.
Yes obviously. But it’s not an either/or. The religious left has had this “they’ve out-organized us” theory of the case since at least 2004, and Jim Wallis’s GOD’S POLITICS, so I suspect something else is going on as well.
Thanks for the clarifications. Of course, what you've measured is point of view, or ideological stance. Gauging activism would require another approach.
That's a fair summary.
Not ideological reasons. The religious right has been organizing support for over four decades, support connected directly as well as indirectly with one of the major political parties. They's got the know-how.
I wonder also if there are ideological reasons why this religious right is better at organization than this religious left. That won’t be visible for at least a decade more, I bet.
Religious right certainly has had bigger, better funded, louder organizations since it arose at the end of the 1970s.
Isn't it also that the thing called the "religious right" is institutionally/politically quite different from the population identified here as the "religious left"? The former seems more organized, the latter more individualized. Fair?
So: religious right 3x bigger than religious left with a weekly screen; 2.5x with a monthly screen. Plus a modest decline on the right and possibly a little growth on the left. OK?
I made a mess of all this, but hopefully cleaned it up here.
So for weekly attenders, the religious left and religious right are essentially the same size. Bumped up to monthly or more, the religious right is twice as big. Right?
Then what are the criteria for identifying the religious left?
So the religious right is twice as large as the religious left, but evidently shrinking. Is the religious left growing?
That did not apply to the civil rights movement. It was seen as a religious triumph by the mainstream. White Southern religious folks saw it as not as a capitulation to culture but as a sacrifice of the church's "spirituality."
Good point!
In other words, the religious left is punching above its weight but it doesn't weigh much. So what does the religious right weigh, Ryan?
.@PaulDjupe and I quantified the religious left.
They are most politically active religious group in America today.
They are also fairly small at ~6% of the population.
Made up of lots of Catholics and Mainline Protestants.
And racially diverse.
More:
religioninpublic.blog/2020/01/08/the-religious-left-is-sm…
But for release of the tape of Trump's phone call with Raffensperger, I think it would have.
This secret plot between Donald Trump and a top DOJ official to overthrow Georgia's election results is really something, and it came oh so close to fruition. Mind-boggling. #gapol
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/22/us/politics/jeffrey-clark-trum…
We should have been just like the economists who forecast the Great Recession, and the political scientists who predicted the election of Donald Trump.
Hawley's fist brandishing is evidence. But of what, exactly? Complicity? Encouragement? Seeking a photo op?
Cruz and Hawley have a lot to answer for in their role as US senator, but unless Whitehouse knows something the rest of us do not, there is no evidence to link them to the assault on the Capitol itself.
Let's stay within the world of facts.
I suppose the only way to achieve unity on these terms is to say that there are very fine people on both sides.
The only people whom Biden called "white supremacists, racists and nativists" were white supremacists, racists and nativists.
You're the one asserting that's a significant portion of the American public, and you may be right.
Turnabout's fair play. Right on, John!
Great piece by @directorsilk!
Lest I be the only one calling for the revival of American civil religion -- the national verse through which unity can be pursued.
www.nbcnews.com/think/opinion/biden-s-inaugural-speech-ca…
Biden Inaugural pulls out all the stops on the American Civil Religion organ: religionnews.com/2021/01/21/the-civil-religious-cleansing…. @RNS
Classic good cop/bad cop play with GOP. Biden as good cop: We can do this nicely or I'm going to have to turn it over to that guy.
Does Biden support doing away with the filibuster? Psaki doesn't answer yes or no, says his preference is to work with members of Congress.
A confession that that's the Republican base, I'd say.
When Joe Biden condemns "a rise of political extremism, white supremacy, domestic terrorism," and Republicans then complain that they're being attacked, that's pretty much of a confession on their part, right?
I guess that's what's known as faith in things unseen.
Tennessee pastor Greg Locke is not giving up on his claim that former President Trump won the election
x.com/pastorlocke/status/1351938902437867523
I'd say that the desecrated Capitol has now been reconsecrated.
Uh-oh. Trump Withdrawal setting in.
A definite ouch moment for Al Mohler, no?
Former SBC president Fred Luter announced Tuesday his intent to nominate Mobile, Ala.,-area pastor Ed Litton for SBC president at the 2021 SBC Annual meeting in Nashville in June.
Litton is the third announced candidate.
www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/litton-to-be-n…
Who am I to judge?
The end of the line for the most overtly pro-Christian presidency in American history: religionnews.com/2021/01/19/trumps-pro-christian-presidency/. @RNS
Walt ("I contain multitudes") Whitman (he, hers, them).
More shockingly, Pew's latest on public attitudes to Trump has no religious categories: file:///Users/msilk%201/Downloads/PP_2021.01.15_biden-trump-views_REPORT%20(1).pdf.
Pew!!!
Because, unfortunately, Wapo/ABC polling never includes religion categories — despite WaPo's serious commitment to religion reporting. Yo, WaPo! How about it?
This is fascinating but also *how are there not religion breaks for this poll?!* www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-poll-post-abc/2021/…
Because, unfortunately, Wapo/ABC polling never includes religion categories — despite WaPo's serious commitment to religion reporting. Yo, WaPo! How about it?
This is fascinating but also *how are there not religion breaks for this poll?!* www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trump-poll-post-abc/2021/…
Right. Yes and No.
I think you mean that the anwers appear to be Yes and No.
The answers would appear to be No and No. They see themselves as Crusaders with an ideology of "Deus Vult" (a right wing chatroom meme). Theirs is the the Christianity of the Church Militant, "Gott Mit Uns," and "Onward Christian Soldiers." To say nothing of the Inquisition.
....especially given the surfeit of Christian signs and symbols brandished by so many rioters--terrorists--that day. And here I mean violence against individuals. Did they forget Jesus's way of nonviolence? Did they see no parallels to the mob violence that Jesus faced?
Plus, of course, Ballarmine served as Galileo's adjudicator.
Jesuits have been in outer space a long time, so yeah:
www.americamagazine.org/politics-society/2019/07/12/why-a…
Right. I hear the next probe is to be named Bellarmine.
NASA stole a march on the Vatican space program by naming an early probe after Galileo. Nice that the Holy See is catching up.
Ah, a papist plot. Back just when we need it.
Works for me.
I am always impressed with the way we pluck ancient heresies to confirm our contemporary priors.
The Gnostics have been taking a lot of heat, though no one knows what they are. Now Pelagius.
Honestly Marcionism seems more apropos for the anti-Semitic Capitol Hill Mob.
I would refer you to Leonard Cohen's most famous song.
moral philosophers what’s the take on how to react to the death of persons who have done extraordinary harm
If such investors would even buy that debt. Maybe at a penny on the dollar.
I hope that Deutsche Bank, if it can, sells all of its Trump debt to aggressive and litigious vulture investors who will pursue collection relentlessly.
In a word, Semi-Pelagians, eh, David?
If Republicans tried to be half-decent Pelagians they'd be better Christians than they are now.
It's time for Collins, Romney, Murkowski, Toomey, and Sasse to say they will become an independent caucus outside the GOP if McConnell doesn't find a way to take up impeachment this week. And then, when he doesn't, do so.
Has there been a single sign of repentance from a Republican senator or representative? Just asking.
"Many of my Republican colleagues are now calling for healing and for us to come together. I'll tell you that there can only be reconciliation with repentance." -- Sen. Chris Coons
Mark Silk reposted
My message to my fellow Americans and friends around the world following this week's attack on the Capitol.
A quick and clear impeachment and conviction, with strong support from Republican legislators, would lower the temperature and calm the waters imho.
Many thanks, Ryan. A wonderful resource!
I built a dashboard to explore the partisanship, political ideology, and age distribution of 85 different religious traditions from 2008 to 2019.
You can also filter by white vs. non-white (or all races).
The sample size is listed at the bottom
ryanburge.shinyapps.io/cces_pid/
Imagine if Congress had gone ahead and amended the Defense bill to repeal Section 230 and the ousters had happened just a month ago?
In one of myriad ironies, the repeal of Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act that has been demanded repeatedly by Trump and others would make Twitter responsible for the consequences of Trump's statements and thus forced his ouster a long, long time ago.
If Trump (no @realDonaldTrump any more) had gotten his way on Section 230, his Twitter ban would be the equivalent of the NYT saying it would never again print a letter or op-ed of his, right?
Thanks, Victor!
Thank you for this read, Mark!!
The greatest sacrilege lay not in what was done to and in the Capitol but in the fact that it had been incited by the president of the United States himself: religionnews.com/2021/01/08/the-desecration-of-the-house/ @RNS
Trumportunists.
We need a term for people who opposed Trump before he gained power, supported him while he had it, and now oppose him again that he's losing it. "Never-Always-Never Trumpers?"
Yes it is. I'm just not sure I agree.
That is still quite a quote "the worst mistake of my life."
I believe, @franklingraham, that your niece is talking about you: www.facebook.com/FranklinGraham/posts/4026339264088891.
When leaders constantly point the finger & condemn non stop but “call us to prayer”once the finger points back they are using prayer as a manipulative tool for their own agenda. It dilutes the powerful practice of prayer to their followers. Its manipulative,transparent & gross.
Let's not forget that Clarence Thomas would not be on SCOTUS w/o Danforth. A decent man with seriously flawed judgment.
JACK DANFORTH to @tonymess, in an interview today about his endorsements of Josh Hawley: "Supporting Josh and trying so hard to get him elected to the Senate was the worst mistake I ever made in my life." www.stltoday.com/news/local/columns/tony-messenger/messen…