Scrapping the two-child benefit cap is irresponsible and unfair.
I outlined why in the @thetimes last week 👇🏻
The UK is in the grip of a cost-of-living crisis, and families across the country are working harder than ever, tightening their belts and making tough choices every day just to make ends meet.
In this climate, politicians owe the public honesty – not empty promises and reckless spending. That is why the two-child benefit cap must stay. It is not just a responsible policy; it is fundamentally a fair one.
While Labour’s two Deputy Leadership hopefuls, Bridget Phillipson and Lucy Powell, roll the pitch for scrapping the two-child benefit cap, without a plan to pay for it, Reform have already pledged to scrap it if they ever get a chance.
Both Labour and Reform are veering to the left on welfare - it falls to the Conservatives to stand up for hard-working taxpayers and call for the country to live within its means.
When this cap was introduced by the Conservatives in 2017, it was based on a simple, common-sense principle: working families do not receive a sudden income boost when they have more children. They plan around what they can afford. It is only right that the benefits system reflects that same principle.
We have a compassionate system that supports those in need, but welfare must be a safety net, not a blank cheque. Why should taxpayers, many of whom cannot afford large families themselves, be expected to pick up the bill for others who choose to have more children than they can support?
The fiscal reality is stark. Our national debt has ballooned, and Labour is already spending over £100 billion a year on debt interest alone - double our defence budget. Scrapping the two-child benefit cap is not a minor tweak; it comes with a significant cost of £3.5bn. If Labour do this, they will be handing out money they simply don’t have. They are borrowing to fund welfare, and that is not sustainable or responsible.
Labour's position on this is defined by chaos and indecision. Before the election, Keir Starmer pledged to keep the cap. Yet, following Labour’s botched welfare reforms, his u-turn on winter fuel, the Chancellor’s economic mismanagement, and a string of scandals, Sir Keir is a lame duck Prime Minister – and he appears to be folding under political pressure from senior figures, as well as backbenchers, within his party. The contest for the deputy leadership has only sharpened the divisions, with several contenders signalling they would push to scrap the cap, regardless of the cost or the consequences.
Keeping the two-child cap is not just about money. It is about core values: fairness, responsibility, and acknowledging the tough decisions that working families make every single day. While we must do more to support work and reduce poverty, scrapping a policy that protects economic credibility, and rewards responsibility would be a significant step backwards. The public deserves the truth, not a race to promise what we cannot afford. Britain must live within its means.