#sexindustryarticles
How the left gets prostitution wrong
logosjournal.com/article/how-the-left-gets-prostitution-w…
"Leftists who come to support prostitution often frame their position in terms of “listening to sex workers,” the implication being that women in prostitution universally desire decriminalization.[10] However, it is obvious that women in prostitution are not a monolithic whole possessing a singular opinion. Many women, both currently in the industry and formerly prostituted, oppose the legalization or decriminalization of prostitution.[11] Recently, I interviewed Chelsea, a woman working in one of New Zealand’s many legal brothels. “The brothels still work the same way they did when it was illegal,” she told me. “We get the worst of both worlds.”[12]
According to her, decriminalization has been an abject failure. Laws mandating condom use are rarely enforced and women who refuse to let men ejaculate on or inside them struggle to find clients. Should a man harass, abuse, or assault a woman, management can refuse to give out the offender’s name, making prosecution impossible. Chelsea is herself a supporter of the Nordic model, saying, “If we had the Nordic Model, I’d call the cops on all of them the second I get my money, before they get to rape me. If I called cops under [decriminalization] they would say, Did you accept the money? If say yes, they say, boom, consensual.” This perspective is not unique among prostituted women; however, it is a voice that Leftists often refuse to hear.
Moreover, Leftists have traditionally understood that discussions of public opinion, far from functioning as a free and equal “marketplace of ideas,” tend to reflect and reinforce the ideology of the powerful. Those who are most likely to align with the dominant narrative are given greater access to culturally sanctioned methods of expression. Traumatized indigenous women being sold for sex on South Dakota oil fields and middle-class white escorts may both be equally capable of communicating their experiences with prostitution on an individual level, but to argue that those experiences will be equally represented to the public through the media infrastructure is both naive and in conflict with traditional Leftist analysis. Inside a system that privileges the voices most likely to validate power, “listening to sex workers” often means uncritically accepting the public statements of a small minority of women in prostitution – most of whom are likely to be white, middle-class, young, and able-bodied.
But even if we were able to objectively gather the opinions of every prostituted woman, a larger issue still remains: Many, if not all, of the systems of exploitation Leftists unequivocally oppose would be vindicated in a popular vote of the exploited themselves. The increasingly conservative Republican Party, for example, finds firm support from the white American working class,[13] while the majority of Americans in general report a positive view of capitalism.[14] Yet few, if any, Leftists would argue that these general trends in opinion are enough reason to abandon support for socialism so as to best align with the self-reported policy demands of the proletariat. Nor are Leftists routinely criticized for speaking over, disregarding, or otherwise betraying the working class when advocating for socialism, despite many members of that very working class holding to the belief that socialism is a dangerous and destructive ideology.
Leftists have long understood, following Marx, that one’s worldview is shaped by the dominate ideology, which develops in relation to specific structures of power in society.[15] It is not surprising that those who upon whom an exploitative economic and political system rests may develop a social consciousness that obscures, ignores, or even validates those systems.
While the issue of “false consciousness” and the root of social understanding is a complex topic that exists beyond the scope of this essay, it is worth contrasting the general Leftist position on capitalism with the specific defense provided for prostitution. “Listen to workers” is not a common slogan for anti-capitalists, likely because most anti-capitalists are aware that the political ideology crafted solely from workers’ self-reports would often carry strong conservative or neoliberal influence that contradicts the Leftist position. The primacy of individual self-reporting as a basis for political theory is widely rejected in cases other than prostitution, where the dominate ideology reflected in that self-reporting happens to coincide with the predetermined position of many Leftists who desire a robust sex industry.
Leftism as an ideology is incompatible with the idea that self-reported policy demands are the only acceptable base for one’s politics. Many of the laws universally seen by Leftists as victories – among them, legislation against child labor and the creation of the minimum wage – are not even settled issues among the working class in America. Unskilled laborers often accept employment at less-than-legal wage out of desperation, while families often exist in such poverty as to make the employment of their children a necessary decision. There is little doubt that Leftists would not “listen” to child laborers and those working for five dollars an hour, should those workers ask for their employment to be legalized. Yet it becomes difficult to see how common Leftist justifications for prostitution decriminalization would not decriminalize these practices as well.
Leftist defenses of prostitution are awash in these unintended implications for other exploitative industries. For example, many on the Left argue that without decriminalization, women in prostitution are unable to claim health benefits and other labor protections. But this is also the case with those who work illegally for less than minimum wage. While the Fair Labor Standards Act[16] is technically designed to allow all employees to request worker’s compensation and overtime pay, under-the-table workers (especially immigrants, young adults, and unskilled laborers) are often unable to claim these benefits as a result of their gray legal position.
In response to this, it could be said that lowering or abolishing the minimum wage would allow these workers to come out from the shadows and claim FLSA protections, much as decriminalizing prostitution is said to do the same. Yet very few Leftists would argue that the abolition of wage laws is an acceptable way to ensure workers’ safety, even if the removal of those wage laws would allow them to claim protections afforded to others.
Leftists similarly claim that legislation against men who purchase sex deprives women in prostitution of their livelihoods and may, in some extreme versions of this argument, lead to homelessness, starvation, and death. It should be noted beforehand that this claim seems to contradict the equally popular Leftist notion that prostitution is most often a voluntary choice made by a woman, free from coercion or desperation.linking the abolition of prostitution with starvation and death, defenders of decriminalization implicitly acknowledge that working in the sex industry is often a last barrier between a woman and crushing poverty. This objection also fails to align with the common Leftist claim that laws aimed to curb prostitution are ineffective, as their ability to prevent women’s employment would be evidence of the sex industry’s successful reduction."