CANCEL CULTURE
I was scheduled to teach my signature course, The Laws of War, at Brooklyn College in the upcoming Spring semester. The class was the first in the Political Science department to be closed out (fully enrolled). Last week I was informed that Dean Philip Napoli abruptly cancelled the course. If you wish to register your opinion of his action, you can reach him and Brooklyn College’s president here:
Dean Philip Napoli
pnapoli@brooklyn.cuny.edu
718.951.3136
President Michele Anderson
bcpresident@brooklyn.cuny.edu
718.951.5671
Norman Finkelstein
Norman Gary Finkelstein ( FING-kəl-steen; born December 8, 1953) is an American political scientist and activist. His primary fields of research are the politics of the Holocaust and the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. More on Wikipedia
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein and Chris Hedges
www.youtube.com/watch?v=cCUQG4cOMLo -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
“With Security Council Resolution 2803, the UN handed the deed for Gaza to a retarded ape [Trump]. Gaza is his. Only thing that comes close is when King Leopold was given the deed to the Congo.”
New @apoliticalorg interview @normfinkelstein youtu.be/80Rpbrd0QjM…
Matt Kennard
@kennardmatt
“With Security Council Resolution 2803, the UN handed the deed for Gaza to a retarded ape [Trump]. Gaza is his. Only thing that comes close is when King Leopold was given the deed to the Congo.”
New @apoliticalorg interview w/ Norman Finkelstein live now: youtu.be/80Rpbrd0QjMThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
How the Intl. Community Sold Out Gaza & Killed Itself in the Process (w/ Norm Finkelstein) | TCHR www.normanfinkelstein.com/how-the-intl-community-sold-out…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein: How the Intl. Community Sold Out Gaza & Killed Itself in the Process youtu.be/cCUQG4cOMLo
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
BLACKMAIL!
How Catholic Health/PEP Strong-Arms Its Physicians into Submission
Note to readers: This is the second installment in a series on Catholic Health/PEP’s criminal activities. For the first installment, go to:
Our country is being destroyed right beneath our noses in broad daylight.
By corporate greed.
By ruthless bloodsuckers.
Once upon a time only the most vulnerable among us fell victim to these vultures.
But nowadays even physicians are being devoured by thisinsatiable maw.
Dr. Rudolph Baldeo—a penniless immigrant from Guyana who realized the American Dream—was subject to relentless abuse and harassment by his employer, Catholic Health/Progressive Emergency Physicians (PEP).
Dr. Baldeo was a revered and beloved pediatrician at Good Samaritan hospital.
He was held in awe for his magic touch with children.
The nurses would greet him with a broad smile.
But then, Catholic Health/PEP decided to junk Dr. Baldeoafter a quarter century of devoted service just as he was turning 60.
Dr. Baldeo was abruptly terminated without written notice.
This was a brazen breach of the Catholic Health/PEP contract.
After an external investigation, Christopher Raio (a.k.a. “The Fellatio King”) of Catholic Health/PEP conceded that the hospital was in the wrong.
It was then stipulated that Dr. Baldeo’s employment wouldcontinue until November 2026.
However, Raio and his hospital sidekick, Cornelia Muntean, threatened Dr. Baldeo: if his resignation wasn’t submitted by the end of August, he would never again find employment.
When Dr. Baldeo stood his ground rather than succumb to this naked blackmail, Raio concocted an absurd pretext to fire Dr. Baldeo.
It was alleged that Dr. Baldeo didn’t say “excuse me” to the hospital registrar before alerting her that she wascommitting an egregious error.
I spoke to PEP counsel Bronwyn Pepple.
I repeatedly interrogated Pepple: Did you speak to the hospital registrar to ascertain what happened?
If Pepple refused to reply, wasn’t that because she knew Dr. Baldeo was framed?
Catholic Health/PEP alleges that it fired Dr. Baldeo for not saying “excuse me” to the registrar.
But it retained Dr. Raio even as he indulged in fellatio with his subordinate in the hospital parking lot!
Is this Catholic Health or Catholic Crooks?
To be continued
If you want to stop the corporate vultures and take back our country, then express your outrage at this gross injustice by writing Catholic Health/PEP:
James O’Brien
James.Obrien@chsli.org,James.Obrien@chsli.org
Bronwyn Pepple
bpepple@williamsweese.com
Christopher Raio
christopher.raio@pephealth.net
Cornelia Munteam
cornelia.muntean@chsli.org
Andrew Sama
andrew.sama@pephealth.net
Jennifer Brown
jennifer.brown@pephealth.net
Cathy Cahill
Cathy.Cahill@chsli.org
Justin Lundbye
Justin.Lundbye@chsli.org
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
IS CATHOLIC HEALTH GENERAL COUNSEL JAMES O’BRIEN A BRAZEN LIAR?
There are Causes and there are causes: upper-case “C” such as a genocide and lower-case “c” such as a worker unjustly sacked.
Herewith is a small “c” story. However, it is illustrative of what has become of our country when a medical doctor is treated as if he were an undocumented worker by a depraved medical system.
The dramatis personae include a lecher, a shyster, and a gaggle of nondescript, gray-on-gray bureaucrats, on the one hand, and a devoted and beloved pediatrician, on the other. If this story sounds Dickensian, that’s because it is: pristine Evil versus pristine Good.
Rudolph Baldeo came to the U.S. penniless from Guyana. When he took my course in political theory at Hunter College 35 years ago, Rudolph was a shipping clerk by day and a biology major by night. A brilliant student, one semester he took six science courses with ten labs and earned straight A’s.
Rudolph eventually won a full scholarship to Columbia University towards a PhD in biology but decided instead to pursue a medical career.
In sum, Rudolph’s life trajectory traced the proverbial American Dream.
For a quarter century, Dr. Baldeo invested his professional life in Pediatrics ER (Emergency Room) at Good Samaritan Hospital. He was loved and respected by his colleagues, staff, and patients alike.
Good Sam is owned by Catholic Health Long Island. Its subcontractor at the hospital is Progressive Emergency Physicians (PEP) headed by Dr. Raio. Raio’s claim to fame is that he was caught in an act of fellatio with his subordinate (and mistress) in the hospital parking lot.
One day, out of the blue, the Fellatio King decided to terminate Dr. Baldeo. It was speculated by hospital staff that Catholic Health/PEP was “getting rid of the dinosaurs” (Dr. Baldeo will turn 60 this year) and that Raio wanted to open up a spot for his golfing buddy.
Dr. Baldeo proved faithful in the wholeness of his being to Good Sam. It treated him in return as if disposable trash to be deposited in the gutter.
He was the perfect victim: diminutive stature, soft-spoken, and dark-skinned. It was just assumed that he would go quietly into the night.
But he wouldn’t. Dr. Baldeo decided to fight back.
I myself contacted Catholic Health General Counsel James O’Brien. O’Brien threatened me with a libel suit if I revealed all the sordid and squalid goings-on at the hospital: it was credibly reported that Good Sam overbilled Medicare/Medicaid patients and underreported child sexual abuse allegations.
Then O’Brien did something even more brazen: he purported in a letter to me that “Dr. Baldeo was not employed by the Hospital at any point.”
But Dr. Baldeo received multiple “Catholic Health Reappointment Approval” letters that “approved your application for reappointment as a member of the Medical Staff” in the “Department/Division” of “Pediatric Emergency Medicine” as an “Attending.”
How could Catholic Health at one and the same time “reappoint” Dr. Baldeo as a “member of the Medical staff” at Good Samaritan Hospital as an “Attending”—yet not be Dr. Baldeo’s employer?!
It is a sorry day indeed for our country when a major medical establishment carries on like a Las Vegas fly-by-night craps joint.
To be continued
If you would like to express your outrage at this gross injustice, you can contact these individuals at Catholic Health/PEP:
James O’Brien
James.Obrien@chsli.org,James.Obrien@chsli.org
Bronwyn Pepple
bpepple@williamsweese.com
Christopher Raio
christopher.raio@pephealth.net
Cornelia Munteam
cornelia.muntean@chsli.org
Andrew Sama
andrew.sama@pephealth.net
Jennifer Brown
jennifer.brown@pephealth.net
Cathy Cahill
Cathy.Cahill@chsli.org
Justin Lundbye
Justin.Lundbye@chsli.org -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Emperor of #gaza: Norman Finkelstein: #netanyahu DESTROYED Global Order - With #trump's Help
youtu.be/r0qpbAT2AiY -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Katie Halper
@kthalps
Urgent Action: Third States Must Intervene to Stop Israel’s Mass Starvation and Intensified Genocidal Attacks on Gaza www.alhaq.org/advocacy/27977.html
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
IS CATHOLIC HEALTH GENERAL COUNSEL JAMES O’BRIEN A BRAZEN LIAR?
There are Causes and there are causes: upper-case “C” such as a genocide and lower-case “c” such as a worker unjustly sacked.
Herewith is a small “c” story. However, it is illustrative of what has become of our country when a medical doctor is treated as if he were an undocumented worker by a depraved medical system.
The dramatis personae include a lecher, a shyster, and a gaggle of nondescript, gray-on-gray bureaucrats, on the one hand, and a devoted and beloved pediatrician, on the other. If this story sounds Dickensian, that’s because it is: pristine Evil versus pristine Good.
Rudolph Baldeo came to the U.S. penniless from Guyana. When he took my course in political theory at Hunter College 35 years ago, Rudolph was a shipping clerk by day and a biology major by night. A brilliant student, one semester he took six science courses with ten labs and earned straight A’s.
Rudolph eventually won a full scholarship to Columbia University towards a PhD in biology but decided instead to pursue a medical career.
In sum, Rudolph’s life trajectory traced the proverbial American Dream.
For a quarter century, Dr. Baldeo invested his professional life in Pediatrics ER (Emergency Room) at Good Samaritan Hospital. He was loved and respected by his colleagues, staff, and patients alike.
Good Sam is owned by Catholic Health Long Island. Its subcontractor at the hospital is Progressive Emergency Physicians (PEP) headed by Dr. Raio. Raio’s claim to fame is that he was caught in an act of fellatio with his subordinate (and mistress) in the hospital parking lot.
One day, out of the blue, the Fellatio King decided to terminate Dr. Baldeo. It was speculated by hospital staff that Catholic Health/PEP was “getting rid of the dinosaurs” (Dr. Baldeo will turn 60 this year) and that Raio wanted to open up a spot for his golfing buddy.
Dr. Baldeo proved faithful in the wholeness of his being to Good Sam. It treated him in return as if disposable trash to be deposited in the gutter.
He was the perfect victim: diminutive stature, soft-spoken, and dark-skinned. It was just assumed that he would go quietly into the night.
But he wouldn’t. Dr. Baldeo decided to fight back.
I myself contacted Catholic Health General Counsel James O’Brien. O’Brien threatened me with a libel suit if I revealed all the sordid and squalid goings-on at the hospital: it was credibly reported that Good Sam overbilled Medicare/Medicaid patients and underreported child sexual abuse allegations.
Then O’Brien did something even more brazen: he purported in a letter to me that “Dr. Baldeo was not employed by the Hospital at any point.”
But Dr. Baldeo received multiple “Catholic Health Reappointment Approval” letters that “approved your application for reappointment as a member of the Medical Staff” in the “Department/Division” of “Pediatric Emergency Medicine” as an “Attending.”
How could Catholic Health at one and the same time “reappoint” Dr. Baldeo as a “member of the Medical staff” at Good Samaritan Hospital as an “Attending”—yet not be Dr. Baldeo’s employer?!
It is a sorry day indeed for our country when a major medical establishment carries on like a Las Vegas fly-by-night craps joint.
To be continued
If you would like to express your outrage at this gross injustice, you can contact these individuals at Catholic Health/PEP:
James O’Brien
James.Obrien@chsli.org,James.Obrien@chsli.org
Bronwyn Pepple
bpepple@williamsweese.com
Christopher Raio
christopher.raio@pephealth.net
Cornelia Munteam
cornelia.muntean@chsli.org
Andrew Sama
andrew.sama@pephealth.net
Jennifer Brown
jennifer.brown@pephealth.net
Cathy Cahill
Cathy.Cahill@chsli.org
Justin Lundbye
Justin.Lundbye@chsli.org -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Finkelstein, Dr. Cornel West, Richard Wolff, Robinson Erhardt
Full interview: www.youtube.com/watch?v=HFc5by8F2S0&t=1514s -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A Correspondent Comments on my book GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS. www.normanfinkelstein.com/a-correspondent-comments-on-my-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
With Oliver Eagleton on latest episode of Tribune In Conversation: Telling the Truth about Gaza
Tribune
@tribunemagazine
Norman Finkelstein joins Oliver Eagleton for the latest episode of Tribune In Conversation.
Finkelstein exposes the lies that have enabled the genocide in Gaza and analyses the British government's shift on Palestine.
Watch now: youtu.be/tLFpaP3l7l0 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
PROTECTING RIGHTS, PLAYING POLITICS
Former UN High Commissioner for Human Right Navi Pillay was awarded this year’s Nobel Peace Prize. The choice was widely praised in the human rights community. Pillay headed the UN Commission of Inquiry investigating crimes perpetrated by Hamas and Israel on October 7 2023 and thereafter. The quality of the Commission’s work was mixed. I analyze the Commission’s multiple reports at length in my new book, Gaza’s Gravediggers: An Inquiry in Corruption in High Places. Excerpted below is the Commission’s disingenuous findings on the Hamas rape allegations.
The “Patten mission” refers to a prior report by Pramila Patten, who was Secretary-General Guterres's Special Representative for Sexual Violence in Conflict. Patten purported that “there are reasonable grounds to believe” that Hamas committed sexual violence “including rape and gang rape” on October 7. By her own admission, Patten adduced zero material evidence to substantiate her spectacular allegations.
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/protecting-rights-playin… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What We Can Do:
October 10th at 2 p.m. at the Freedom Park in #athens
www.instagram.com/reel/DeGqwftssWe/
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
WHY THE IHRA'S DEFINITION OF ANTI-SEMITISM DOESN'T WORK
@NormFinkelstein on @TuckerCarlson, promoting his new book, Gaza's Gravediggers -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Focusing on the United Nations, the perversion of international law, @NormFinkelstein produces an indictment of those who abused their authority to whitewash an unfolding horror.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
"Norman knows what he is talking about. It is urgent and just that the Palestinians have their own State after the Gaza genocide, that they finally enjoy the realization of the right to self-determination."
Review of GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS in @CovertActionMag by @normfinkelstein -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein’s Gaza’s Gravediggers is a Tour de Force normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/norman-finkelsteins-gaza…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Aaron Maté
@aaronjmate
At the UN for The Hague Group meeting with the man who exposed Gaza’s Gravediggers. @normfinkelstein @orbooks
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Aaron Maté
@aaronjmate
.@Casablancas_J meets @normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Hen "How Dare You Call Me a State Propagandist!" Mazzig
forward.com/israel/412206/did-this-pro-israel-superstar-w… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/liar-liar-pants-on-fire-…
Liar, Liar, Pants on Fire: Hen Mazzig -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
BIRMINGHAM, 18 September
www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/birmingham-the-world-after-gaza-wi…
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
LONDON, 17 September
Tickets 👇
www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/london-the-world-after-gaza-with-p…
NORMAN FINKELSTEIN UK TOUR – SEPTEMBER 2026 www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-uk-tour-sept… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
LONDON, 17 September
Tickets 👇
www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/london-the-world-after-gaza-with-p…
NORMAN FINKELSTEIN UK TOUR – SEPTEMBER 2026 www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-uk-tour-sept… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
NORMAN FINKELSTEIN UK TOUR – SEPTEMBER 2026 www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-uk-tour-sept…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Tucker Carlson: Norman Finkelstein Reveals Shocking Discoveries While Researching History of Israel’s Gaza Obsession www.normanfinkelstein.com/tucker-carlson-norman-finkelste…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein with Tucker Carlson on Gaza genocide youtu.be/Jmv2h1WYnNo
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Tucker Carlson
@TuckerCarlson
Norman Finkelstein has been telling the truth about Gaza longer than anyone else in academia. Naturally the media have dismissed him as an antisemite or ignored him completely.
0:00 The Gaza Concentration Camp
11:37 The Military and Intel Operations Focused on Destroying Gaza
14:05 Evidence of Israel's Genocide in Gaza
27:58 The Attacks Against Anyone Who Criticizes Israel
46:29 Israel's Targeting of Children, Medics, and Journalists
52:04 The Corruption of Benjamin Netanyahu and Denying Jewish Americans Entry
55:41 Has Finkelstein Faced Backlash in the US for Speaking Out?
59:39 Propaganda in the Classroom
1:11:34 Why They Kicked Finkelstein Out of Hunter College
1:25:50 Is Finkelstein Bitter About the Consequences He's Faced?
1:31:07 Are These Reports About Hamas Accurate?
1:45:31 Will Anyone Be Held Accountable for These Actions?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Gaza's Gravediggers youtu.be/n5k1aNvQNlc
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Gaza’s Gravediggers: An Inquiry into Corruption in High Places
@orbooks
orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Gaza Gravediggers: An Inquiry into Corruption in High Places www.normanfinkelstein.com/gaza-gravediggers/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Gaza Gravediggers
An Inquiry into Corruption in High Places
@orbooks
orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
In Praise of the Houthis www.normanfinkelstein.com/in-praise-of-the-houthis/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
In Praise of the Houthis
From Norman Finkelstein's new book, Gaza's Gravediggers:
The genocidal Israeli juggernaut proved unstoppable. But it wasn’t for a want of trying. It behooves the chronicler to memorialize the noble few who, albeit in futility, stood on principle and put themselves at considerable risk to stop the killing machine. When Hezbollah opened a second front mainly targeting military installations in the north of Israel, and the Houthis blocked international shipping lanes in solidarity with the forlorn people of Gaza, the “enlightened” West reacted in shock and indignation: How dare they intrude, What business is it of theirs? But wasn’t it this enlightened opinion that not so long ago promulgated the doctrine of “R2P”—“Responsibility to Protect”? In essence, R2P denoted that, when established institutions fail to stop genocide and cognate crimes, then other entities must step in to fill the void. In the 1930s, when the enlightened West abandoned the Spanish Republic, international brigades of volunteers went there to fight the nascent forces of fascist barbarism. They covered themselves with glory. (Fully three thousand Americans joined the Abraham Lincoln Brigade, more than a third of them Jewish.) This time around, Fate appointed the Party of God and the Houthis. The Houthis possessed intimate knowledge of exalted Western values, on the one hand, and Gaza’s martyrdom, on the other. The US had enabled Saudi Arabia’s blockade of Yemen that left nearly one hundred thousand children dead and gone. Rousseau famously observed that the most—indeed, only— truly civilizing impulse in human beings is not reason but the natural, inborn capacity for pity, and that the more society “progresses,” the more refined its rational faculty, the more its natural capacity for pity is stifled. Who, in a decent world, would not choose one dagger-in-hand Houthi risking life and limb in defense of defenseless Gaza over ten thousand Harvard-educated, elegantly coiffed Antony Blinkens adroitly lubricating the gears of Israel’s murder machine?
See also this video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=miIAl65-uJo -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A Letter to Readers normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/a-letter-to-readers?r=nvni
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Gaza's Gravediggers by Norman Finkelstein published this week... and is a seething indictment of the officials responsible for Israel's genocide against Gaza
Here's @normfinkelstein on Hasan Piker talking about the book, which is available to buy here: orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Gaza’s Gravediggers
An Inquiry into Corruption in High Places
NORMAN G. FINKELSTEIN
orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/ -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
NORMAN'S BEST...
Gaza's Gravediggers publishes TODAY
@normfinkelstein's most damning work yet, a devastating exposé of international duplicity and complicity in the Gaza genocide.
Buy direct, this one shouldn't line Amazon's pockets.
orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
GIVING VOMIT A BAD NAME normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/giving-vomit-a-bad-name?…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
NEW REVIEW BY TALAL HANGARI OF GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/new-review-by-talal-hang…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
NEW REVIEW BY TALAL HANGARI OF GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/new-review-by-talal-hang…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
India & Global Left
@Indiagloballeft
Did Hamas rape on October 7? @normfinkelstein responds youtu.be/37iC7uz4I6g via @YouTube
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
@normfinkelstein with @hasanthehun talking about Norman's newest book GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/
www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEbtSbMcQCg -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
"Finkelstein writes that the book 'was written to expose lies and restore truth.' GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS does considerably more than that. It is not merely a chronicle of Israel's destruction of Gaza, but an examination of the institutional architecture that rendered that destruction politically and legally sustainable"
@The_NewArab review of @normfinkelstein newest book
Get your copy orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/
www.newarab.com/features/who-enabled-israels-genocide-nor… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The New Arab Book Club- Gaza's Gravediggers: Norman Finkelstein's dissection of the institutions that enabled Israel's genocide www.normanfinkelstein.com/gazas-gravediggers-norman-finke…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS IS FINALLY ABOUT TO START SHIPPING
You've waited patiently. You've emailed us. You've asked where it is. This week, Norman Finkelstein's new book finally begins shipping.
Last chance to pre-order and save 15%: orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/ @normfinkelstein -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
GAZA GRAVEDIGGERS: Great review from the comrades www.normanfinkelstein.com/gaza-gravediggers-great-review-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
*Physicians for Human Rights Israel Warns of Imminent Danger to Dr. Hussam Abu Safiya's Life* www.normanfinkelstein.com/physicians-for-human-rights-isr…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
FIRST REVIEW OF GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS! (He clearly read the book so I can't complain) www.normanfinkelstein.com/first-review-of-gazas-gravedigg…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
TARGETING CHILDREN IN THE HEAD AND CHEST www.normanfinkelstein.com/targeting-children-in-the-head-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
May 29, 2026 - Speak Truth, Build Power: An Evening of Resistance with Norman Finkelstein www.normanfinkelstein.com/may-29-2026-speak-truth-build-p…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Piers Morgan Uncensored: "DISGUSTING!" Gaza Flotilla Detainees on Israel 'Abuse' | Norman Finkelstein on 'Nazi' Post
In May 2018, Palestinians in Gaza organized a peaceful protest “March of Return” in order to break the illegal siege of Gaza. The IDF responded by brutal killing of civilians. Israeli snipers were targeting the peaceful protesters killing children, paramedics, women, amputees and civilian men. The IDF spokesperson tweeted on May 22, 2018:
“The mask has been pulled off : Hamas is Iran, Iran is Hamas! The terror along the security fence is an Iranian mission”
Norman Finkelstein responded to the above tweet by a post with the title:
“The mask has been pulled off: Israelis are Nazis, Nazis are Israelis. The assassins along the concentration camp fence target children for goofs.”
www.normanfinkelstein.com/piers-morgan-uncensored-disgust… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
"DISGUSTING!" Gaza Flotilla Detainees on Israel 'Abuse' | Norman Finkelstein on "Nazi" Post youtu.be/w3zqO-zK0Zw
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norm posted in 2018 in response to the IDF post "The mask has been pulled off Hamas is Iran, Iran is Hamas"
www.normanfinkelstein.com/the-mask-has-been-pulled-off-is…
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
"DISGUSTING!" Gaza Flotilla Detainees on Israel 'Abuse' | Norman Finkelstein on "Nazi" Post youtu.be/w3zqO-zK0Zw
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein on the Insane Racism of Israeli Society and the Plan to Erase Gaza @normfinkelstein youtu.be/dy9ObUMEvZA
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
My two indefatigable editors who saved Gaza's Gravediggers from a premature death
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Lost Tribe of Israel Celebrates the Queen of Winger's Birthday at Coney Island's Posh Anti-Zio-Nazi Pavillion
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Former ICC Chief Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda: Profile in Courage or Outsized Crook? www.normanfinkelstein.com/former-icc-chief-prosecutor-fat…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein: Palestinians Tried EVERYTHING before October 7th - A Slave's Case for Resistance www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-palestinians…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein: Palestinians Tried EVERYTHING before October 7th - A Slave's Case for Resistance
youtu.be/e_wcyGPMDh0 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
He Who Lives by the Sword, Will Die by the Sword (May the Force be with them!) www.normanfinkelstein.com/he-who-lives-by-the-sword-will-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The sinister plot behind the far-right's shift on Israel | Norman Finkelstein interview www.normanfinkelstein.com/the-sinister-plot-behind-the-fa…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein Speaks in the People's Republic of Minneapolis (A truly inspiring place) www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-speaks-in-th…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
THE LAST CLASS (May the force be with them!) www.normanfinkelstein.com/the-last-class-may-the-force-be…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
The sinister plot behind the far-right's shift on Israel | Norman Finkel... youtu.be/BtTDUeL7vy4
@normfinkelstein -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norm Finkelstein RESPONDS To Tucker Saying Trump Israel's "Slave" www.normanfinkelstein.com/norm-finkelstein-responds-to-tu…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Bad Faith: Tucker and Candace Owens Are HIJACKING Anti-Zionism (w/ Norm Finkelstein) youtu.be/lTuXAiwvJhw via @YouTube
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein: Israel will lose aad the resistance will prevail.
@normfinkelstein youtu.be/qtgbwpCrTgY -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
40 minutes: Bashar Lakkis with Norman Finkelstein and the war on Iran www.normanfinkelstein.com/40-minutes-bashar-lakkis-with-n…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
40 minutes: Bashar Lakkis with Norman Finkelstein on the war of Iran. youtu.be/K2XrmC5VfhY
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Audible version of Gaza: An Inquest Into Its Martyrdom www.normanfinkelstein.com/the-audible-version-of-gaza-an-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
From a Friend in Iran (Part 5) www.normanfinkelstein.com/from-a-friend-in-iran-part-5/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein thinks Trump is too humiliated to attack Iran again | UNAPOLOGETIC www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-thinks-trump…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
The Katie Halper Show
@KatieHalperShow
@normfinkelstein returns to the program & gives us a story on his time in Lebanon with Hezbollah fighters/ tour guide before reacting to Israel/Iran/US crisis
live rn:
www.youtube.com/live/6idTiFpktB8This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein thinks Trump is too humiliated to attack Iran again
@normfinkelstein youtu.be/4eg3yiYeQxc -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Letter from an Iranian friend (Part 4) www.normanfinkelstein.com/letter-from-an-iranian-friend-p…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
From an Iranian Friend (Part 3) www.normanfinkelstein.com/from-an-iranian-friend-part-3/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
From a friend in Iran (Part 2) www.normanfinkelstein.com/from-a-friend-in-iran-part-2/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
From a friend in Iran (Part 1) www.normanfinkelstein.com/from-a-friend-in-iran-part-1/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What We Can Do!
chuffed.org/project/172378-emergency-relief-for-palestini… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What We Can Do: Emergency relief for Palestinians in Lebanon www.normanfinkelstein.com/emergency-relief-for-palestinia…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein: Trump, Netanyahu, Putin, and the War in Iran www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-trump-netany…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein: Trump, Netanyahu, Putin, and the War in Iran youtu.be/PBWnC90buHk
@normfinkelstein -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
MY CLASS, OUR FUTURE www.normanfinkelstein.com/my-class-our-future/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Really excellent. Unimpeachable with clearly sourced evidence.
SourcedPress
@SourcedPress
“I ask you now: do not stop speaking about Gaza. Do not let the world look away. Keep fighting, keep telling our stories—until Palestine is free.”
— Hossam Shabat, killed by Israeli forces, March 24, 2025
sourced.press/a/killing-gaza-witnesses/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
“BRAZEN Aggression!” Norman Finkelstein vs Jonathan Conricus On Israel-Lebanon Operation + Iran War www.normanfinkelstein.com/brazen-aggression-norman-finkel…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
With the IRGC and Hezbollah Go the Heroes!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=EiP6U1qwcSc -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
"BRAZEN Aggression!" Norman Finkelstein on Israel-Lebanon operation & on Iran war. @normfinkelstein
youtu.be/YNcyU4YSp3w -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein: Why the Israel-US attack on Iran is NOT another Iraq war. youtu.be/-jNggeDPv0o
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
India & Global Left
@Indiagloballeft
.@normfinkelstein argues that while the Iraq invasion in 2003 primarily reflected US strategic interests, the current escalation with Iran is driven largely by the interests of Israel, with the United States playing a supporting role. youtu.be/-jNggeDPv0o via @YouTube
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
March 13 and March 14 Iftar with Norman Finkelstein: Fundraising for Famine Relief and Medical Aid for Gaza www.normanfinkelstein.com/march-13-and-march-14-iftar-wit…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
18th Palestine Convention | Gaza is the World youtu.be/ZitFErqIfX0
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finklestein on Gaza & Trump's Board of Peace
@normfinkelstein youtu.be/ZitFErqIfX0 -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
☀️👀
@zei_squirrel
Harvard professor Robert Trivers tried to get Jeffrey Epstein in touch with Norman Finkelstein. Instead of accepting, Norman sent a reply calling Alan Dershowitz a pedophile rapist and saying Trivers should be ashamed for defending them, and both should be strangled instead
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein joined Upscrolled. You can follow him here.
@realUpScrolled
share.upscrolled.com/en/user/1b511bf1-47a5-46cf-8e82-bc63… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Chris Hedges
@ChrisLynnHedges
Did China and Russia betray Gaza at the UN Security Council? Or were more forces at play? @NormFinkelstein reckons with the geopolitical context of Trump's atrocious Gaza peace plan. www.youtube.com/watch?v=ryWqT29j5JQ
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Deconstructing Trump's 'Peace' Plan for Gaza (w/ Norman Finkelstein) | The Chris Hedges Report www.normanfinkelstein.com/deconstructing-trumps-peace-pla…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein with Mohammad Obaid on Almashhad Media www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-with-mohamma…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein and Mouin Rabbani Debate Palestine, Geopolitics & the Far Right www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-and-mouin-ra…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
‘Gaza Is Over, It’s Gone. There’s Nothing Left' | Aaron Bastani meets Norman Finkelstein www.normanfinkelstein.com/gaza-is-over-its-gone-theres-no…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein EXPOSES Israel’s DARKEST SECRET www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-exposes-isra…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
محمد أبوعبيد
@mobeid
المفكر الأمريكي نورمان فينكلستين في "50 دقيقة" الذي أعده وأقدمه على قناة المشهد:
"لم تعد ورقة الهولوكوست فعالة مع الجيل الجديد"
American scholar Norman Finkelstein, speaking on “50 Minutes”, a program produced and hosted by me on Al Mashhad TV:
“With the younger generation, the Holocaust card no longer works.”
@normfinkelstein -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein with Mohammad Obaid on Almashhad Media
@normfinkelstein
@mobeid
youtu.be/sS8iLSM9Jus -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein @normfinkelstein on @novaramedia
youtu.be/RO-Lor_yndM -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Get your copy of Norman's new book, Gaza's Gravediggers, here: orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Watch now: @normfinkelstein on @DoubleDownNews
Pre-order Gaza's Gravediggers here: orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/
Double Down News
@DoubleDownNews
Norman Finkelstein EXPOSES Israel’s DARKEST SECRET @normfinkelstein
www.doubledown.news/watch/2025/december/12/norman-finkels… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Double Down News: Norman Finkelstein EXPOSES Israel's DARK SIDE youtu.be/NyYl6_N1FZw
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Double Down News
@DoubleDownNews
Norman Finkelstein EXPOSES Israel’s DARKEST SECRET @normfinkelstein
www.doubledown.news/watch/2025/december/12/norman-finkels… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The UN Security Council Declares War on Gaza, by Norman G. Finkelstein
[Below is the conclusion to Norman Finkelstein’s new book entitled GAZA’S GRAVEDIGGERS: An Inquiry into Corruption in High Places, published by OR Books: orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/]
On 17 November 2025, the UN Security Council passed, by 13 votes to zero with two abstentions, a milestone resolution imposing a ceasefire in Gaza and charting a path forward based on “President Donald J. Trump’s Comprehensive Plan to End the Gaza Conflict.”[1] The resolution was simultaneously a revelation of moral insolvency and a declaration of war against Gaza. By proclaiming international law null and void, the Security Council proclaimed itself null and void. Vis-à-vis Gaza, the Council transmuted into a criminal conspiracy. The Council and Gaza having been thrust into the antechamber of the state of nature, mutual relations between them reverted to being regulated by the laws of nature, whereby the Council members that “declared war . . . may be destroyed as a lion or a tyger, one of those wild savage beasts, with whom men can have no society nor security.”[2] The people of Gaza suffer no obligation to obey this grotesque resolution; on the contrary, the Council, by virtue of it, “becomes dangerous to mankind” and “every man upon this score, by the right he hath to preserve mankind in general, may restrain, or where it is necessary, destroy things noxious to them.”[3] The Council didn’t just issue Gaza a death warrant; it also issued its own.
A UN resolution, even one just calling for an immediate ceasefire, is typically set off by a painstaking preamble “Recalling,” “Reaffirming,” “Emphasizing,” “Reiterating,” etc., the parameters and particularities of the relevant law defined by UN organs.[4] This new resolution, which prescribed not only the terms of a ceasefire but also a roadmap for resolving the Israel-Palestine conflict writ large, emerged ex nihilo, inscribed on a tabula rasa. According to entrenched law, ratified by the International Court of Justice (ICJ), Gaza constituted, alongside the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, “Occupied Palestinian Territory”; “As an occupying Power, Israel must refrain from . . . imped[ing] the Palestinian people from exercising its right to self-determination, including its inalienable right to territorial integrity over the entirety of the Occupied Palestinian Territory”; “Israel’s continued presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory is illegal. . . . Consequently, Israel has an obligation to bring an end to its presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory as rapidly as possible.”[5] This robust and enduring legal consensus crystallized after protracted deliberations spanning almost eight decades among multiple UN organs and was anchored in fundamental norms of international law: the prohibition on the acquisition of territory by war and the right of peoples to self-determination. The new UN resolution deposited this comprehensive legal framework into the dumpster. All that survived was a pathetic fragment “noting prior relevant Security Council resolutions relating to the situation in the Middle East, including the Palestinian question” (emphasis in original).[6] What’s more, the resolution left Gaza’s legal status suspended in juridical limbo. Nowhere did the resolution so much as hint that Gaza was part of Occupied Palestinian Territory, let alone that it was illegally occupied territory, that it is the Palestinian people’s inalienable right to exercise self-determination in the entirety of this Palestinian territory, and that Israel must withdraw from it “as rapidly as possible.” Shorn of any public standing, left dangling by a thread in a juridical void, Gaza was reduced by the Security Council in one fell swoop to the extralegal status of—in the idiom of the European conquest of Africa—res nullius (“thing of nobody”).
The resolution divided into three mandates: a Board of Peace (BoP), an International Stabilization Force (ISF), a political roadmap:
Board of Peace. The resolution authorized “the establishment of the Board of Peace (BoP) as a transitional administration with international legal personality that will set the framework, and coordinate funding for, the redevelopment of Gaza.” The resolution fell silent on the modalities of the BoP—how it would be constituted, who would sit on it. . . —except for one crucial detail. Its first operative paragraph “[e]ndorses” without caveat the Trump Plan (annexed to the resolution) and “calls on all parties to implement it in its entirety” (emphases in original). The Trump Plan in turn resolved that the BoP—surprise! surprise!—“will be headed and chaired by President Donald J. Trump.” Lest any doubt lingered on this score, the US representative asserted right after the Security Council vote that “the Board of Peace, which will be led by President Trump, remains the cornerstone of our effort.” In their subsequent remarks, not one Council member voting in favor of the resolution registered any objection.[7] The resolution didn’t hold the Board accountable to the UN or any other entity; except that it “requests” that the Board submit a biannual progress report to the Security Council, it made no provision whatsoever for external oversight (emphasis in original). The wonder was that it didn’t include in an annex the formal transference of deed to The Trump Organization. Provoking widespread consternation, President Trump boasted in early 2025 that “[t]he U.S. will take over the Gaza Strip” and “[w]e’ll own it.”[8] If, in Trump world, we denotes me—l’etat, c’est moi—then his words proved prescient: courtesy of the Security Council, Gaza now figured as one more property in his portfolio. Will his next move be, per the board game Monopoly, to build houses and hotels in his fantasy Riviera on the Mediterranean? The BoP was a throwback to the Berlin Conference of 1884–85 when the Great Powers handed title over the Congo to the International Association of the Congo created and controlled by one of Europe’s richest men, King Leopold II of Belgium. He was then declared the Congo’s sole owner: “It was a personal state, the property of one capitalist of genius, the King-Sovereign.”[9] Leopold had pledged to “open to civilization the only part of our globe where it has yet to penetrate, to pierce the darkness which envelops whole populations.” In the shadows of his “crusade worthy of this century of progress,” Leopold presided over a lucrative sideline in the ivory and rubber trade in which he worked to death as many as 15 million Congolese. It was an auspicious precedent, and the Security Council passed the baton to a deserving heir: didn’t Trump possess in abundance the apposite “international legal personality”—of a criminally deranged megalomaniac?
The resolution charged the BoP with coordinating both humanitarian aid and reconstruction. Neither will come to pass. A 2025 ICJ advisory opinion found that the United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) was the only humanitarian organization in Gaza technically competent to provide aid at scale, and that Israel must cooperate with it.[10] However, falsely alleging that UNRWA was riddled with Hamas members who diverted aid, Israel has fought tooth and nail to discredit and dismantle it. The original US draft of the new Security Council resolution sustained Israel’s spurious allegations as it allowed that “any organization found to have misused aid would be ineligible to provide continued or future assistance—a provision that was perceived to target the UN Relief and Works Agency.”[11] So brazen was this frontal attack on the ICJ opinion that the US was forced to tone it down, but the adopted text still incorporated language—the BoP was charged with “ensuring such aid is used solely for peaceful uses and not diverted by armed groups”—that Israel could exploit so as to refuse cooperation with the only relief agency able to meet Gaza’s humanitarian needs. To judge by its track record going back decades, Israel won’t admit more than a “humanitarian minimum” of aid, if that much and probably a lot less. The days of weaponizing starvation as a method of warfare won’t be over until and unless the Gaza “question” has been “solved.”[12] The reconstruction of Gaza won’t happen because it can’t happen and because Israel won’t let it happen. Just clearing out the more than 60 million tons of rubble intermixed with toxic substances and unexploded ordnance—not to mention, dead bodies—would take more than 15 years, while actual rebuilding could take as many as eight decades.[13] And, anyhow, Israel won’t allow it. It didn’t expend more than two years turning Gaza into a moonscape so as to make it uninhabitable, only to abruptly reverse course, clasp hands with the people of Gaza, intone om, chant Give Peace a Chance, sing Kumbaya, and, like the Seven Dwarfs, merrily heigh-ho, heigh-ho while rehabilitating Gaza’s pulverized infrastructure. Israel will no doubt justify a ban on entry of cement and steel by reinvoking the specious pretext that Hamas might redirect them to build tunnels. The Security Council resolution provided no external oversight mechanism and so no one can compel either the BoP or Israel—not that the powers-that-be give a damn—to cooperate with UNRWA or admit reconstruction material.[14] The almost certain outcome of the new resolution will be that Gaza returns to the status quo ante 7 October—its inhabitants forgotten by the outside world, left to languish and die in a concentration camp—with the crucial difference that Gaza itself is no more. The Palestinians of Gaza have been left with the two options signaled by Israel when it embarked on the genocide: stay and die, or flee.[15] Israel gave its all to induce a stampede; now it will have to settle for a trickle. The intermittent ceasefire in place, Israel’s final solution has entered a new, no less lethal albeit less visible, phase.[16] Greenlighting it, the Security Council stands in the dock of history as an accessory to genocide.
International Stabilization Force. The resolution authorized the establishment of a “temporary International Stabilization Force (ISF),” the charge of which was to “stabilize the security environment in Gaza by ensuring the process of demilitarizing the Gaza Strip.” The ISF was to operate in “close consultation and cooperation” with Egypt and Israel. It must be conceded that the resolution recruited a pair of virtuosos at pacification: Egyptian strongman Abdel Fattah el-Sisi seized power in a military coup that climaxed “in one of the world’s largest killings of demonstrators in a single day in recent history,”[17] while Israel had invested the previous two years in comprehensively stabilizing Gaza by erasing it. Although emphatic that Gaza must be disarmed “us[ing] all necessary measures,” the resolution was conspicuously mute as to why it must be. The reason for this silence wasn’t hard to find. If Gaza had to be demilitarized because of the 7 October massacre, then the obvious question arose: After committing a genocide that killed incomparably more innocents, didn’t Israel also need to be demilitarized? Judging by the resolution’s content (or the lack thereof), Israel’s conduct was as virginally pure as the white sheet of paper upon which the resolution was inscribed. Its criminal blockade and periodic hi-tech killing sprees before 7 October[18] and the genocide that ensued after 7 October vanished from the UN annals. Only barbaric Gaza needed to be civilized, at gunpoint.[19] For all the horror of 7 October, the fact also remained that a people under occupation wasn’t legally debarred from armed resistance. International law prohibits use of military force “by an administering power to suppress widespread popular insurrection in a self-determination unit,” while “the use of force by a non-State entity in exercise of a right of self-determination is legally neutral, that is, not regulated by international law at all.”[20] An occupied people must obey the laws of war but, all the same, it retains the prerogative to violently resist a violent occupation. The Security Council resolution thus triply breached international law: it punished the lesser but not the greater violator of international humanitarian law; it granted Israel a right to suppress armed resistance not granted other occupiers; it denied Gazans a right to armed resistance not denied other people living under occupation.
Political Roadmap. The resolution stated that the BoP would cede sovereign power over Gaza only when “the Palestinian Authority (PA) has satisfactorily completed its reform program,” and that “[a]fter the PA reform program is faithfully carried out and Gaza redevelopment has advanced, the conditions may finally be in place for a credible pathway to Palestinian self-determination and statehood.” By making Palestinian self-determination and statehood conditional, the UN regressed to the League of Nations era. In the League mandates system instituted after World War I, former colonies of the defeated Central Powers, allegedly “not yet able to stand by themselves under the strenuous conditions of the modern world,” were placed under the “tutelage” of “advanced nations” until they demonstrated the fitness to be independent. After World War II, the twin principles of decolonization and self-determination seized center stage at the UN (the League’s successor). The self-serving paternalistic conceit, incorporated in the League Covenant, that “non-self-governing territories” required a tutelary period before attaining independence was scrapped. Instead, the seminal 1960 UN General Assembly resolution, “Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples” (1514), asserted that “inadequacy of political, economic, social or educational preparedness should never serve as a pretext for delaying independence.” The new Council resolution annulled 65 years of UN practice.
The resolution didn’t specify objective benchmarks to assess whether or not the PA “has satisfactorily completed its reform program,” while “Gaza redevelopment” will almost certainly and at minimum take decades. What’s more, even if the PA “satisfactorily completed” and “faithfully carried out” reforms, and even if Gaza redevelopment was sufficiently advanced, the prospect of Palestinian self-determination and statehood would still be indeterminate: meeting these criteria “may”—or may not—advance the political process, and even if it did, the Palestinian people would still only be on a “pathway” to statehood—i.e., not yet there. That outcome would be held in abeyance pending “a dialogue between Israel and the Palestinians to agree on a political horizon for peaceful and prosperous coexistence.” In other words, were Palestinians to meet all the—nebulous—demands put on them, they still could not exercise their “inalienable right” to self-determination and statehood even in the distant future until and unless Israel agreed to it. The resolution further stated that “the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) will withdraw from the Gaza Strip based on standards, milestones, and timeframes linked to demilitarization that will be agreed between the IDF, ISF, the guarantors [?], and the United States, save for a security perimeter presence that will remain until Gaza is properly secure from any resurgent terror threat” (emphasis added). That is, the resolution endowed Israel with veto power over both the exercise of Palestinian self-determination and any withdrawal of Israeli forces from Gaza, thus ensuring that neither would ever come to pass.
A multitude of UN resolutions as well as ICJ opinions had variously and cumulatively found that Palestinians constituted a “people”; that the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, and the Gaza Strip, constituted “Occupied Palestinian Territory” (OPT); that the Palestinian people possessed an “inalienable right” to self-determination and statehood in the “entirety” of the OPT; that Israel’s occupation of the OPT was “illegal”; and that Israel was legally obliged to withdraw from the OPT “as rapidly as possible.” The political roadmap laid out in the resolution eviscerated the massive UN record on the Israel-Palestine conflict that was assembled over many decades with near-unanimous agreement. By signing onto resolution 2803 (2025), the Security Council committed suicide. The ultimate irony was that the supreme political organ of the UN immolated itself in order to placate a gangster juggernaut in Washington that heaped only scorn on the organization, to the point of sabotaging by defunding it; and, even as the Trump administration successfully extorted—at the behest of its, albeit scaled down, gangster doppelganger in Tel Aviv—this criminal resolution, it would not be deterred from its crazed crusade, in which no mode of coercion was out of bounds, to crush (or neuter) the UN and anything else that stood in its path. The hunger increases with each bite. Is prostrate Gaza now safely in the rear-view mirror of the Arab/Muslim states—Algeria, Egypt, Indonesia, Jordan, Pakistan, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Palestine, Türkiye, United Arab Emirates—that lined up with Big and Little Moloch, or is it a morbid signpost of their own futures?
***
The original purpose of this book was therapeutic: to isolate, so as to enable the UN to excise, pockets of corruption that, albeit rare but nonetheless egregious and pernicious, tainted its record on the Gaza genocide. The UN did not halt the enormity that befell Gaza but overwhelmingly did not abet it either. Until now. The new resolution has directly implicated the Security Council itself in the ongoing genocide. It has also condemned the tormented and tortured people of Gaza, or those not killed off, to eternal martyrdom. “The fish stinks first from the head.” It’s only a matter of time before the corruption in the Security Council spreads throughout the UN system. An epoch has passed. The silently raised hands ratifying the resolution sounded its death knell. Going forward, the cause of Justice will have to be reconstituted on a new foundation. It must be said without recoiling—for it is the Truth—but also being cognizant of the gravity of the verdict that: After 17 November 2025, the UN is a rotting corpse.
______
[1] “UN Security Council Resolution 2803 (2025)” (17 November 2025, S/RES/2803; docs.un.org/en/S/RES/2803(2025)). Russia and China abstained. The prime impetus behind President Trump’s initiative sprang not from the “Gaza conflict” per se but elsewhere. If he was to seal his long-coveted “deal of the century” formally incorporating Saudi Arabia within the US-Israeli sphere of influence (à la the Abraham Accords), then the Saudis needed the fig leaf of a “ceasefire” to placate Arab public opinion. Hardly had the ink dried on the UN resolution before the Saudi crown prince received a royal reception at the White House.
[2] John Locke, Second Treatise of Government (1690), para. 11.
[3] Ibid., para. 8.
[4] See, e.g., “United States of America: Draft resolution” (25 October 2023, S/2023/792; docs.un.org/en/S/2023/792), and “Russian Federation, Sudan and Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela: Draft resolution” (25 October 2023, S/2023/795; docs.un.org/en/S/2023/795).
[5] See Chapter 3 of this book.
[6] It also made desultory reference to unspecified “international legal principles,” “international law, including international humanitarian law.”
[7] United Nations Security Council, 10046th Meeting, “The Situation in the Middle East, including the Palestinian Question” (17 November 2025; digitallibrary.un.org/record/4093696?ln=en&v=pdf).
[8] Dave Lawler and Barak Ravid, “Trump Claims U.S. Will ‘Take Over’ Gaza and Turn It into New ‘Riviera,’” Axios (4 February 2025; www.axios.com/2025/02/05/trump-gaza-takeover-palestinians…).
[9] Thomas Pakenham, The Scramble for Africa: The white man’s conquest of the dark continent from 1876 to 1912 (New York: 1991), passim (“personal state” at p. 588).
[10] See Chapter 3 of this book.
[11] Security Council Report, “The Middle East, including the Palestinian Question: Vote on a draft resolution to authorize an International Stabilization Force in Gaza” (16 November 2025; www.securitycouncilreport.org/whatsinblue/2025/11/the-mid…).
[12] See the Prologue of this book and Norman G. Finkelstein, Gaza: An inquest into its martyrdom (Oakland: 2018), p. 33n57.
[13] See Prologue of this book, and Paul Brown et al., “‘Worse than Starting from Scratch’: How big is the task of rebuilding Gaza?” BBC (15 October 2025; www.bbc.com/news/articles/cr5e4ee9r13o).
[14] The alarm has of late been sounded that Gaza will be partitioned into a security “Green Zone” comprising more than half of Gaza, where reconstruction will be permitted for returning Gazans, versus a “Red Zone” comprising the bulk of Gaza’s population, where reconstruction will be barred until Hamas is disarmed. If for a disheartening reason, such fears are unfounded: there won’t be reconstruction anywhere in Gaza. Israel will either annex the security perimeter or turn it into a buffer zone. In either case, it won’t allow for reconstruction except perhaps for a handful of Potemkin villages that will house the “hewers of wood, drawers of water”—i.e., coolie labor—as well as armed Gazans collaborating with Israel. The last thing Israel wants in any areas under its control is more Arabs; ideally, they would be Arab-rein. See Sari Bashi, “Gaza: The threat of partition,” New York Review of Books (23 November 2025); Dov Lieber and Summer Said, “US Pushes a Hamas-Free ‘Green Zone’ in Gaza,” Wall Street Journal (21 November 2025); Jonathan Whittall, “How the US-Israeli ‘Peace Plan’ Will Partition Gaza,” Al Jazeera (22 November 2025; www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2025/11/22/how-the-us-israeli-…); Emma Graham-Harrison, “US Military Planning for Divided Gaza with ‘Green Zone’ Secured by International and Israeli Troops,” Guardian (14 November 2025).
[15] See Prologue of this book.
[16] Amnesty International, “Post-Ceasefire: Israel’s genocide in the Occupied Gaza Strip continues” (27 November 2025; www.amnesty.org/en/documents/mde15/0527/2025/en/).
[17] Human Rights Watch, All According to Plan: The Rab’a massacre and mass killings of protesters in Egypt (12 August 2014; www.hrw.org/report/2014/08/12/all-according-plan/raba-mas…).
[18] See Prologue of this book.
[19] Whereas several States (US, UK, France, Greece, Panama) supporting the resolution condemned Hamas in statements right after the vote was taken, except for a single sentence by Algeria, not one State supporting the resolution uttered one word of criticism of Israeli actions after 7 October.
[20] James Crawford, The Creation of States in International Law, second edition (Oxford: 2006), pp. 135–37, 147. See also Heather A. Wilson, International Law and the Use of Force by National Liberation Movements (Oxford: 1988), pp. 135–36 (“[the law] is still not agreed upon” as to the right of national liberation movements to use force, although “the trend . . . since 1960 . . . has been toward the extension of the authority to use force to national liberation movements,” while “the use of force to deny the free exercise of a people’s right to self-determination is contrary to the principles of international law”); A. Rigo Sureda, The Evolution of the Right of Self-Determination: A study of United Nations practice (Leiden: 1973), pp. 331, 343–44, 354 (“The fact that the Security Council has never expressly condemned the guerrilla activities of the Palestinians can be interpreted as an implied recognition of their right to recover at least the territories from which they were displaced in the June 1967 hostilities, and to do so by the use of force if necessary”); Finkelstein, Gaza: An inquest, pp. 140–41. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Happy Birthday Professor Norman. A video dedicated to you from the UK tour team, Usman, Aamer and Sana. Wishing you many happy returns. may you continue to be the voice of truth!! www.normanfinkelstein.com/happy-birthday-professor/
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein : The end of International Law
@normfinkelstein youtu.be/UrPTSduHI5I -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
PROFESSOR CHOMSKY
I have been asked to comment on allegations of a “relationship” between Professor Chomsky and Jeffrey Epstein. It is an incontrovertible fact that Professor Chomsky met and corresponded with everyone. He didn’t discriminate; that was his modus operandi. That disposes of the bulk of the accusations leveled against Professor Chomsky. However, a portion of the allegations do puzzle: for example, a mysterious undated, unsigned, and unaddressed letter that Professor Chomsky supposedly wrote in support of Epstein. Most of the letter does not sound at all like him. How this letter came to be is, at this point, anyone’s guess. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sarah Wilkinson
@swilkinsonbc
The israelis have committed countless violations of the “ceasefire”, slaughtering 318 ppl, including many children, since the truce began www.middleeasteye.net/live/live-israel-dropped-153-tonnes…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein at Panteion University of Athens - November 12, 2025 youtu.be/pGkZQiZ2iFM
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein at Panteion University of Athens - November 12, 2025 youtu.be/pGkZQiZ2iFM
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Sana Kassem has been Norman Finkelstein's comrade and social media manager for over a decade. She lived through the siege of Beirut in 1982 and ended up a chemistry teacher in Athens. Here's a talk she recently gave chronicling her family's history.
@SanaImmTarek -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sarah Wilkinson
@swilkinsonbc
If you lock 2 million people in a concentration camp, don’t react with shock when it backfires, says Norman Finklestein @SanaImmTarek
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
November 12, Norman Finkelstein in Athens (photos and articles) www.normanfinkelstein.com/november-12-norman-finkelstein-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
12 Nov | 19:00 An Evening with Norman Finkelstein at Panteion University in Athens www.normanfinkelstein.com/12-nov-1900-an-evening-with-nor…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
November 13-16: Join Professor Norman Finkelstein in the UK! Book Your Tickets www.normanfinkelstein.com/november-13-16-join-professor-n…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
November 12 2025: Norman Finkelstein in Athens, Greece - Gaza, How did we get there and where are we going! www.normanfinkelstein.com/november-13-2025-norman-finkels…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Candace Owens x Norman Finkelstein youtu.be/5g0IC1ZlcIg
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Strange Happenings at the Oxford Union
Norman Finkelstein will not be attending the Oxford Union debate on November 13 due to inexplicable wild irregularities in its announced structure. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
‘DENYING Aid For Hamas’ Crimes!’ IDF Attacks Gaza Days Into Truce | With Norman Finkelstein @normfinkelstein
youtu.be/Ri2kPD3-W6Q -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
This is an invaluable project, brilliantly executed.
SourcedPress
@SourcedPress
We’re making the ebook and audiobook free for everyone. The genocide and the occupation are funded with our money and backed by our governments — we all have a right to know what’s being done in our name.
sourced.press/book/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein at ICPC | The Cost of Truth and the Struggle for Justice in Palestine in Paterson, NJ (Photos and Videos) @muslimcityfest www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-at-icpc-the-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Of Slaves and Stooges, and Yellow Ribbons
Both my parents died 30 years ago in 1995, my Father on January 21, my Mother on October 19 (yesterday). In my book, I'll Burn That Bridge When I Get to It, I included a brief remembrance of them. Here's what I wrote:
“Traitors!”
Except for my Mother and Father, every member of both my parents’ families was exterminated during the war. From as far back as I can remember, our home was saturated with politics. On Sunday mornings, seated around the breakfast table, we divided up among the five of us the sections of the New York Times while, later in the day, we sat around the television set watching Meet the Press, hosted by the redoubt able Lawrence Spivak. But politics wasn’t just intellectualizing words. When the nightly news flashed war images from Vietnam, my Mother would abruptly avert her gaze, hold her hand up to shield her eyes, and say: “Tell me when it’s over.” My parents stayed faithful to their decidedly unpopular political beliefs until their last breaths. They reserved their harshest epithet for those who betrayed their principles for earthly reward. “Traitors!” they would mutter, with a mixture of disdain and disgust. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein at ICPC | The Cost of Truth and the Struggle for Justice in Palestine
@normfinkelstein
youtu.be/RNyAbRPQhaI -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein on Gaza Ceasefire and Trump's Peace plan www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-on-gaza-ceas…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
نورمان فينكلستين.. الأميركي المتمرد | هامش جاد Norman Finkelstein...The American Rebel www.normanfinkelstein.com/نورمان-فينكلستين-الأميركي-المتم…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
نورمان فينكلستين.. الأميركي المتمرد | هامش جاد
Norman Finkelstein...The American Rebel
@normfinkelstein
@Jad_Ghosn
youtu.be/yQl24f5sIbU -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein at UMass: Gaza, Truth & the Battle for Free Speech www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-at-umass-gaz…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Briahna Joy Gray
@briebriejoy
Starting soon:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=KsSc3yRY_OQ -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
India & Global Left
@Indiagloballeft
UN Confirms Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza—Norman Finkelstein Breaks... youtu.be/Pze8aFh8yFc @normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein at UMass: Gaza, Truth & the Battle for Fr... youtu.be/zFoHXuhq9mU
@normfinkelstein -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
BREAKING STORY
In her first X post since becoming head of CBS news, Bari Weiss launches campaign to defend Van Jones: UNCLE TOM LIVES MATTER! -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
2 Years On: Has the Resistance Won? With Dr Norman Finkelstein
youtu.be/5L8fgGF80wI -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
NEWS FLASH:
Bari Weiss hires Van Jones to head up CBS News Schvartze Department. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Question That the Whole World is Asking:
When Van Jones f***s his mistress, does he wear the yellow ribbon? -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Why is Van Jones wearing a pimp's blazer when he's so obviously a high-price call girl?
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
TWO YEARS AFTER OCTOBER 7: Interviews with Norman Finkelstein www.normanfinkelstein.com/two-years-after-october-7-inter…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein: Trump plan has no connection to reality in Gaza www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-trump-plan-h…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Gaza’s obliteration has been paved by US-Israeli peace proposals | Norman Finkelstein | UNAPOLOGETIC www.normanfinkelstein.com/gazas-obliteration-has-been-pav…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein: Trump plan has no connection to reality in Gaza aje.io/bdntsp via @AJEnglish
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Full episode: Norman Finkelstein Exposes Israel’s SECRET PLAN for Gaza |
@normfinkelstein
youtu.be/t2uiNJPxAek -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A Comment on the New UN Report on Gaza
I devote a chapter of my forthcoming book, Gaza’s Gravediggers, to the point that describing the situation in Gaza as a “war” rather than a “genocide” egregiously distorts what is happening there. In a postscript to this chapter, reprinted below, I comment on the new UN report that found Israel is committing genocide in Gaza.
In September 2025, the Independent International Commission of Inquiry released a new report in which it found that Israel was committing genocide in Gaza.[1] It reached this conclusion after extensively documenting (from UN sources and respected human rights organizations) that Israel had willfully committed acts defined by Article II of the 1948 Genocide Convention—Killing members of the group; Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part; Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group—“with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such.”[2] The report explicitly addressed Israel’s contention that it was engaged in a “war of self-defense” against Hamas.[3] It found that, on the contrary, if not this or that “discrete” or “individual” incident but, instead, the “totality” or “overall factual situation” of the Israeli assault was scrutinized[4]—the absolute number of Gazans, and proportion of civilians versus combatants, killed and injured; [5] the systematic targeting of civilians along evacuation routes and in safe zones;[6] the systematic targeting of homes, vital infrastructure, and healthcare facilities (as well as medical personnel);[7] the systematic denial of basic necessities (food, water, fuel, electricity, medicine) to the civilian population and use of “starvation as a method of warfare”;[8] the systematic targeting of children, including “toddlers,” in the head and chest,[9] as well as the targeting of Gaza’s only IVF (in vitro fertilization) clinic;[10] the systematic targeting of cultural, educational, and religious sites;[11] the systematic resort to sexual and gender-based violence, including “many cases of rape”;[12] etc.—then it was impossible to reconcile the “overall factual situation” with a defensive “war” against Hamas. The report thus eschewed the terminology of the laws of war. There was, for example, no mention of “disproportionate” attacks anywhere in it. A disproportionate attack presupposes that a legitimate military site was targeted but an excessive number of civilians were killed. The report found, however, that, overwhelmingly, it was Gaza’s civilian population and infrastructure that was targeted. Indeed, the massive death and destruction was proportionate to Israel’s genocidal goal. Further to this point, the report only occasionally paused to examine an Israeli claim that it was targeting Hamas in this or that attack:[13] in the grand scheme of things, beside the magnitude of death and destruction visited on Gaza, the lethal incidents in which a Hamas militant might have been present amounted to a trifle and an irrelevance.[14] The report’s upshot was that the quantity (gross numbers) and quality (selection of targets) of the Israeli attack couldn’t be squared with the paradigm of a war: “[T]here was no military necessity to justify the pattern of conduct.”[15] It was palpably not Hamas but the entirety of Gaza’s population that was being targeted; indeed, the “war” aspect of the hostilities was, all told, a fiction.[16] The body of this chapter expounded that the laws of war and genocide frameworks are mutually antithetical. The Commission’s latest report confirmed this: as it concluded that Israel was committing a genocide in Gaza, it dispensed with the language and investigative modus operandi of a “war” situation.
To clinch its case that Israel was committing genocide in Gaza, the Commission had to demonstrate not only that Israel willfully committed acts listed in Article II of the Convention, but also that the “intent” behind Israel’s commission of these acts was to physically destroy the Gazan population. The report found that from right after 7 October forward, senior Israeli officials repeatedly uttered genocidal statements;[17] that the Israeli security forces dispatched to Gaza understood these to be genocidal orders, weren’t subject to “any genuine investigations or prosecutions” for committing acts prohibited by the Convention, and that, on the contrary, Israeli officials were “encouraging , permitting and authorizing such criminal behavior to continue”;[18] that Israel’s genocidal intent could reasonably be inferred from the quantity and quality of the criminal acts committed by Israeli forces.[19] The report thus concludes that “Israeli political and military leaders possess the specific intent to commit genocide against Palestinians in Gaza, based on their statements and the pattern of conduct of those under their command since 7 October 2023.”[20] A slightly more nuanced analysis would perhaps read like this:
Israel intentionally committed acts that perforce resulted in the destruction of the Gazan population. The inevitable massive death and destruction that Israel visited on Gaza traced back to primal vengeance, [21] Israel’s perceived need to restore the Arab world’s fear of it, [22] and its determination to “solve” the Gaza Question once and for all—an historical opportunity long coveted and then miraculously gifted on 7 October, that Israel was dead-set on exploiting, come what may, to the hilt. The genocide commenced immediately after Hamas’s attack—the initial public statements by senior Israeli officials perfectly, indeed eerily, foreshadowed what would unfold in the next two years—but it was necessarily calibrated to take account of the response abroad. If Israel didn’t outright nuke Gaza, that’s because, functioning as Israel must within the constraints, albeit feeble, imposed by the vicissitudes of international public opinion, it couldn’t. But even as Israel’s overarching objective was not to annihilate but rather to ethnically cleanse Gazans, [23] it was also prepared to kill off as many civilians and pulverize as much infrastructure as was politically feasible in order to “persuade” the population to leave or “persuade” the international community to take it in. This is not idle speculation, it’s a fait accompli: Israel has already committed genocide in Gaza. Absent external political constraints, and if Gazans prove unwilling or unable to leave, then Israel, its leadership as well as Israeli Jewish society en masse—this was a national project—won’t recoil at totally annihilating Gaza’s population. Far from it. If need be, Israel won’t just be “intent to destroy, in whole or in part,” Gaza’s population, it will be positively gleeful and relish the prospect. Whereas Heinrich Himmler, cognizant at some level of his criminality, feigned anguish in his infamous Posen speech at the onerous burden placed by History on the shoulders of Germany to rid the world of the Jews, Israeli security forces danced the hora and then flaunted their foul deeds on social media. It was the giddiness of a child, magnifying glass in hand, burning ants.
____________________________________
1 Legal Analysis of the Conduct of Israel in Gaza Pursuant to the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, Conference Room Paper of the Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel (16 September 2025, A/HRC/60/CRP.3; www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/documents/hrbodies/hrco…).
2 The Commission did not find evidence of a fifth act defined by Article II of “forcibly transferring children of the group to another group” (Legal Analysis, para. 16).
3 Ibid., para. 177.
4 Ibid., paras. 144, 158, 160, 254.
5 Ibid., paras. 180-86; see also ibid., paras. 48, 50. A classified Israeli intelligence report found that 83 percent of Gazans killed were civilians (ibid., paras. 21, 180).
6 Ibid., para. 182; see also ibid., paras. 49, 58-59.
7 Ibid., paras. 187, 204-8; see also ibid., paras. 87-90, 93-106. A military expert stated that “Israel is dropping [more bombs] in less than a week than what the United States was dropping in Afghanistan in a year, in a much smaller, much more densely populated area” (ibid., para. 22).
8 Ibid., paras. 190-203; see also ibid., paras. 48, 85-86, 96, 100, 104, 110-126. The report noted that “The denial of entry for special infant milk, resulting in the starvation of new-born and young infants, is especially powerful evidence of an intention to destroy the population” (ibid., para. 190).
9 Ibid., 214-19; see also ibid., paras. 28, 30, 32, 46, 56 (“toddlers” at paras. 28, 215). The report observed that “The targeting of children is relevant to infer the genocidal intent of the Israeli authorities because … the extensive and deliberate targeting of Palestinian children shows that the military operations were not conducted solely to defeat Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups, nor can they legitimately contribute to the other stated goals of defending the state of Israel and securing the release of Israeli hostages (ibid., para. 218). On a related note, the Commissioner General of UNRWA stated that “10 children lost one or both legs in the war every day,” and another UN organization reported that “Gaza is home to the largest cohort of child amputees in modern history” (ibid., paras. 53, 214).
10 Ibid., para. 207; see also ibid., paras. 57, 79, 151-54.
11 Ibid., paras. 188-89; see also ibid., paras. 91-92, 146.
12 Ibid., paras. 209-213; see also ibid., paras. 65-71 (“many cases” at para. 66), 73, 80. The report states that “the nature and scale of these acts [of sexual and gender-based violence] do not support and cannot justify Israel’s claims that its military operations were conducted in self-defense, to defeat Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups, or to secure the release of Israeli hostages” (ibid., para. 212).
13 Ibid., paras. 35-44, 95, 103, 118, 185. Incidentally, in just one single instance did the Israeli alibi hold up, if only in part.
14 Israel’s critics fixated on to its use of AI to liquidate alleged Hamas militants as they returned home, killing many family members. See Yuval Abraham, “‘Lavender’: The AI machine directing Israel’s bombing in Gaza,” +972 Magazine (3 April 2024). But this too was largely an irrelevance and a distraction: long before AI came along, Israel routinely killed many civilians as it targeted alleged Hamas militants in densely populated civilian neighborhoods; of the more than 200,000 Gazan homes damaged or destroyed since 7 October, it’s implausible that AI was implicated in more than a tiny fraction of the attacks; harping on the use of AI to track down alleged Hamas militants obscured the crux that, overwhelmingly, Israel wasn’t even targeting Hamas but instead the entire civilian population. The criminality wasn’t that Israel committed disproportionate attacks, in which an excessive number of civilians were killed when targeting Hamas, but that it was committing genocide as it targeted not Hamas but the Gazan people.
15 Legal Analysis, para. 179.
16 One indicative juxtaposition is that, during the period March-August 2025, 50 Israelis versus 12,000 Gazans, 11,000 of them civilians, were killed. A global ratio of 1:240 or combatant ratio of 1:20 betokens at minimum a slaughter or extermination not a war. The figure of Hamas militants killed can itself be misleading: most of them almost certainly died not on the battlefield but alongside Gazan civilians in the course of Israel’s genocidal assault. For the numerical data, see International Crisis Group, The World’s Shame in Gaza (2 September 2025), and ACLED (Armed Conflict Location and Event Data), “Gaza after Two Years” (17 September 2025).
17 Legal Analysis, paras. 221-33; see also paras. 162-176.
18 Ibid., paras. 163, 184, 232, 237, 242.
19 “Considering the evidence in totality, the Commission has found that Israeli authorities were aware of the high probability that their military operations, the imposition of a total siege, including the blocking of humanitarian aid in Gaza, and the destruction of housing and of health systems and facilities would lead to the physical destruction of Palestinians, in whole or in part in Gaza. Importantly, in relation to the blocking of humanitarian aid, Israeli authorities were put on notice by the International Court of Justice, the Security Council and various human rights experts and groups. . . . The Commission therefore finds that Israeli authorities knowingly and deliberately inflicted such conditions of life to bring about the destruction of Palestinians in Gaza”; “[T]he Commission finds that genocidal intent was the only reasonable inference that could be drawn based on the pattern of conduct of the Israeli authorities” (ibid., paras. 144, 220).
20 Ibid., para. 238.
21 “[V]engeance is a great value. There is vengeance for what they did to us. . . . [I]n 100 years they will know that you don’t mess with the Jews”—senior Israeli security forces officer (ibid, para. 173).
22 “The fact that 50,000 have already been killed in Gaza is necessary and required for future generations. . . . They need a Nakba from time to time to feel the price”—head of Israel’s Military Intelligence (ibid., para. 175).
23 The report mistakenly infers that Israel’s intention was to “trap Palestinians in Gaza, creating such conditions that would prohibit them from escaping and ultimately lead to their destruction” (ibid., para. 201).
orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/ -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
American Muslims for Palestine
@AMPalestine
🚨 We’re excited to announce that @normfinkelstein will speak at our 18th Palestine Convention.
🗣️ Meet Our Speaker:
Norman G Finkelstein received his PhD from the Princeton University Politics Department in 1987 and taught for many years. He has written many books, including The Holocaust Industry: Reflections on the Exploitation of Jewish Suffering and Gaza: An Inquest into Its Martyrdom. In 2020, he was ranked the fifth most influential political scientist in the world for the years 2000-2020.
🎟 Join Dr. Norman at this year’s Palestine Convention during Thanksgiving weekend at the Tinley Park Convention Center. Book your tickets today @ palestineconvention.org -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Saturday Oct 4th - Muslim City Fest: Gala for Gaza www.normanfinkelstein.com/saturday-oct-4th-muslim-city-fe…
@muslimcityfest -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
To Jamie Stern-Weiner, Friend and Comrade, Protege and Collaborator. May you live to see the Promised Land!
@jsternweiner www.normanfinkelstein.com/to-jamie-stern-weiner-friend-an… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Why I Am Still a Communist! www.normanfinkelstein.com/why-i-am-still-a-communist/
Here’s the translation of the speech of one of the dockworker’s leaders in Genoa, before the departure of the ships of the Global Sumud Flotilla.
“I want this to be clear to everyone — really to everyone: around mid-September these boats will arrive near the coast of Gaza, close to the critical zone. If we lose contact with our boats, with our comrades, even for just twenty minutes, we will block all of Europe. I’ve written it down so I won’t forget it. Together with our union, together with all the dockworkers who stand with us, together with the whole city of Genoa… from this region 13–14 thousand containers leave every year for Israel, not a single nail will leave anymore. We will launch an international strike, we will block the roads, we will block the schools, we will block everything. Our young women and men must come back without a scratch, and all this cargo, which belongs to the people and is going to the people, must reach its destination, down to the very last box. That’s all I have to say.”
Paolo Mossetti
@paolomossetti
Here's the translation of the speech of one of the dockworker's leaders in Genoa, before the departure of the ships of the Global Sumud Flotilla.
“I want this to be clear to everyone -- really to everyone: around mid-September these boats will arrive near the coast of Gaza, close to the critical zone. If we lose contact with our boats, with our comrades, even for just twenty minutes, we will block all of Europe. I’ve written it down so I won’t forget it. Together with our union, together with all the dockworkers who stand with us, together with the whole city of Genoa… from this region 13–14 thousand containers leave every year for Israel, not a single nail will leave anymore.
We will launch an international strike, we will block the roads, we will block the schools, we will block everything. Our young women and men must come back without a scratch, and all this cargo, which belongs to the people and is going to the people, must reach its destination, down to the very last box. That's all I have to say.” -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
May the people of Gaza yet beat back the Nazi hordes: "Let their blood spill and soak in the dirt"
youtu.be/7MQ-SC9bmp4 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Maryla Husyt Finkelstein: The only “fault” of Palestinians is being born on their land… they are innocent and show tremendous patience. www.normanfinkelstein.com/maryla-husyt-finkelstein-the-on…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
No doubt Guterres came under terrific pressure. And yet again, he capitulated. Was it cowardice, careerism—or maybe blackmail? It’s anyone’s guess. What’s certain is that by omitting Israel from the Annex, Guterres disgraced himself and his office. He inflicted yet another blow on the UN by rewarding Israel’s obstructionism: wasn’t the take-away in Tel Aviv that it could get its way even as it sabotaged the UN’s system of accountability?
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Did Secretary-General Guterres Betray Gaza and the UN to Appease Israel? open.substack.com/pub/normanfinkelstein/p/did-secretary-g…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
But beyond all else, Guterres betrayed, in its moment of truth and death agony, Gaza. He might not be the first and most certainly won’t be the last but, all the same, among those—albeit diminishing few—who still believe in Truth and Justice, he now carries and will henceforth carry forever the mark of Cain.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Did Secretary-General Guterres Betray Gaza and the UN to Appease Israel? open.substack.com/pub/normanfinkelstein/p/did-secretary-g…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Did Secretary-General Guterres Betray Gaza and the UN to Appease Israel? open.substack.com/pub/normanfinkelstein/p/did-secretary-g…
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
@antonioguterres @NaviPillay1 @UNLazzarini @Alfreddezayas @FranceskAlbs
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Mouin Rabbani "On Anas al-Sharif"
@MouinRabbani open.substack.com/pub/mouinrabbani/p/on-anas-al-sharif -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
In conversation with Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein youtu.be/T8KXQBsyCDY -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
This @SourcedPress series meticulously examines Israel's long record of killing journalists with impunity. Every source document is provided with annotations.
SourcedPress
@SourcedPress
Decades of Israeli forces killing journalists with impunity (Part I). Full piece — complete with fact-checking pages — in 🧵
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein in Conversation with Cornel West and Nadine Strossen | Free Speech and Gaza www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-in-conversat…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Get a copy orbooks.com/catalog/ill-burn-that-bridge-when-i-get-to-it/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
In conversation with Cornel West and Nadine Strossen for the launch of I'LL BURN THAT BRIDGE WHEN I GET TO IT
@orbooks
www.youtube.com/live/yBaGqy9h0eE -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Watch @normfinkelstein in conversation with @CornelWest and Nadine Strossen — talking cancel culture, free speech & Gaza, live-streamed from our event at @POWERHOUSEArena last night.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=yBaGqy9h0eE&t=9495s -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Watch the recording and get a copy of I’LL BURN THAT BRIDGE WHEN I GET TO IT
Cornel West
@CornelWest
Today 7pm Brooklyn, NY.
Live-streaming on YouTube
www.youtube.com/live/yBaGqy9h0eE
@normfinkelstein @orbooks -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Cornel West
@CornelWest
Today 7pm Brooklyn, NY.
Live-streaming on YouTube
www.youtube.com/live/yBaGqy9h0eE
@normfinkelstein @orbooks -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
JULY 17 at 7:00 p.m. Dr. Cornel West, Norman Finkelstein, and Nadine Strossen in conversation on cancel culture, free speech and Gaza
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
JULY 17 Dr. Cornel West, Norman Finkelstein, and Nadine Strossen in conversation on cancel culture, free speech and Gaza www.normanfinkelstein.com/july-17-dr-cornel-west-norman-f…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Tomorrow July 17th at 7:00 p.m.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Don't forget to get your ticket
@orbooks
powerhouse-books.ticketleap.com/finkelstein-strossen-west… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Don't forget to get your ticket
@orbooks
powerhouse-books.ticketleap.com/finkelstein-strossen-west… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein's new book: Gaza's Gravediggers-An Inquiry into Corruption in High Places
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS, exposing international duplicity and complicity in the Gaza genocide. Pre-order now at 15% off orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
From the forensic fearless Finkelstein: GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS, exposing international duplicity and complicity in the Gaza genocide. Pre-order now at 15% off orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/ @normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
OR Books
@orbooks
From the forensic fearless Finkelstein: GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS, exposing international duplicity and complicity in the Gaza genocide. Pre-order now at 15% off orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/ @normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
OR Books
@orbooks
From the forensic fearless Finkelstein: GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS, exposing international duplicity and complicity in the Gaza genocide. Pre-order now at 15% off orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/ @normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
OR Books
@orbooks
From the forensic fearless Finkelstein: GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS, exposing international duplicity and complicity in the Gaza genocide. Pre-order now at 15% off orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/ @normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS, exposing international duplicity and complicity in the Gaza genocide. Pre-order now at 15% off orbooks.com/catalog/gazas-gravediggers/…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Al Arabiya English: ‘Declare Middle East A NUCLEAR FREE Zone’ - Norman Finkelstein On Iran Vs Israel, Gaza And Trump www.normanfinkelstein.com/al-arabiya-english-declare-midd…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Al Arabiya English: ‘Declare Middle East A NUCLEAR FREE Zone’ - Norman Finkelstein On Iran Vs Israel, Gaza And Trump www.normanfinkelstein.com/al-arabiya-english-declare-midd…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
JamieSW
@jsternweiner
"It's not possible to appease or placate these people because it has nothing whatever to do with antisemitism."
www.youtube.com/watch?v=iiyU07XqaQE&list=PLoCKbJgrDISI_AX… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
JamieSW
@jsternweiner
Back when British pro-Israel groups were issuing ultimatums to Jeremy Corbyn, just like US pro-Israel groups are now issuing ultimatums to Zohran Mamdani, @normfinkelstein gave some sage advice: ¡NO PASARAN!
JamieSW
@jsternweiner
Should Labour capitulate to external pressure and adopt the full IHRA document? Norman Finkelstein says: ¡No pasaran! www.youtube.com/watch?v=iB91kQs0c-4&list=PLoCKbJgrDISI_AX…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
orbooks.com/catalog/ill-burn-that-bridge-when-i-get-to-it/
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
How do you judge a book? By its cover? By its author? By its content? OR BY ITS INDEX?
@orbooksThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein: Zohran Mamdani Has Struck A Winning BLOW Against The Israel Lobby www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-zohran-mamda…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
JULY 17 Dr. Cornel West, Norman Finkelstein, and Nadine Strossen in conversation on cancel culture, free speech and Gaza www.normanfinkelstein.com/july-17-dr-cornel-west-norman-f…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
I NEVER PROMISED YOU A ROSE GARDEN www.normanfinkelstein.com/i-never-promised-you-a-rose-gar…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein on Israel, Zohran Mamdani and the coming class war | The Big Picture- Middle East Eye www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-on-israel-zo…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein: Israel, Zohran Mamdani and the coming class war. youtu.be/JADy940qXHY
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein in conversation with Dr. Cornel West and Nadine Strossen at Power House Arena (Brooklyn, NY)
Ticket required. Hope to see you there!
Can't make it in person? Join the livestream.
www.youtube.com/live/yBaGqy9h0eE
@orbooks -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
JULY 17 Dr. Cornel West, Norman Finkelstein, and Nadine Strossen in conversation on cancel culture, free speech and Gaza @POWERHOUSEArena
@CornelWest @normfinkelstein
Get your ticket powerhousearena.com/events/finkelstein-west/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
How do you judge a book? By its cover? By its author? By its content? OR BY ITS INDEX?
@orbooksThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
@normfinkelstein on his new book I'LL BURN THAT BRIDGE WHEN I GET TO IT for @AJEnglish www.youtube.com/watch?v=XP7Nzwm-kQ4
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
ISRAEL ATTACKS IRAN (POSTED 19 APRIL 2024)
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/samson-and-cassandra
SAMSON AND CASSANDRA
My Mother once told me the story of an emaciated woman in the Warsaw Ghetto who would wail from her window sill that all the Jews in the ghetto would be killed. She came to be called Cassandra, after the prophetess of doom in Greek mythology. Everyone just assumed that she was mad. My Mother speculated in retrospect that somehow she had become privy to the truth: Jews weren’t being “relocated” in the East; they were being transported to their deaths.
I have hesitated thus far to sound the alarm. But at the risk of being thought mad, it must, as an act of political responsibility, be said out loud: Israel is hurling toward the precipice and dragging the rest of the world with it.
A rational analysis of the current predicament must begin with this bedrock fact: Israel is a crazy state. Not a “bad actor.” Not a “rogue” regime. A crazy state. The full range of Israeli elite opinion, itself reflective of Israeli society at large (which overwhelmingly supports the genocidal war in Gaza; only a handful of Israelis have refused to serve), spans a mere flea’s hop:
AT ONE POLE stand “crackpot realists,” of whom sociologist C. Wright Mills wrote in the American context: “they have come to believe that there ... is no other solution but war, even when they sense that war can be a solution to nothing ... they still believe that ‘winning’ means something, although they never tell us what.” (1) Professor Benny Morris is cut squarely from this mold. He is urbane, educated, secular—and a crackpot. He once even “proved” that Israeli Jews couldn’t coexist with barbarian Palestinians by inter alia mustering stats on how many more road accidents Palestinians got into! (2) Morris exhorts the US to join in an attack on Iran and then rattles the threat that if Washington doesn’t rise to the occasion, Israel will go it alone by nuking Iran. He must be cognizant as he breezily proffers such counsel that an attack would not only incinerate tens of millions of Iranians—he reckons they have it coming—but also trigger a terminal retaliation. Hezbollah alone is alleged to possess 150,000 missiles. It’s a circuitous auto-da-fé. That prospect, however, doesn’t appear to faze Morris one bit.
AT THE OTHER POLE stand full-blown crazies—or those just one step short of this threshold. “The greatest danger facing Israel right now,” Noam Chomsky presciently observed already four decades ago, “is the ‘collective version’ of Samson’s revenge against the Philistines—‘Let me perish with the Philistines’—as he brought down the Temple in ruins.” The Samson clones ensconced in Jerusalem have either already gone mad—“we shall kill and bury the Gentiles around us while we ourselves shall die with them”—or pretend to “go crazy” so as to terrify enemies and allies alike into submission. Feigned lunacy, be it noted, easily transmutes into the real thing as the imaginary phantoms one repeatedly conjures seep into the psyche’s inner chambers. The upshot is that this madness, real or contrived, “renders rational calculations ... questionable” as Israel “may behave in the manner of what have sometimes been called ‘crazy states.’” (3) A report in yesterday’s paper fleshes out in real time this Israeli propensity to unhinged outbursts: when one senior Israeli official counseled caution, if only in the immediate term, after Iran’s symbolic retaliation, a far-right cabinet minister demanded on the contrary that Israel go “crazy.” (4)
*
The April 14 speech at the Security Council emergency session by Israel’s representative, Gilad Erdan, brought home just how lunatic Israel has become. Presenting a master class in—if nothing else—proximate projection, Erdan was seemingly persuaded to the bone of his being that “the Islamic regime of today is ... no different than Adolf Hitler’s Third Reich.... Just like the Nazi regime, the Ayatollah regime sows death and destruction everywhere.... For years, the world has watched the rise of this Shite Islamist Reich, yet just like during the rise of Nazism, the world has been silent”; that “Iran’s hegemonic ambitions of global domination must be stopped before it drives the world to a point of no return, to a regional war that can escalate to a world war”; that Iran was “barreling towards nuclear capabilities ... its breakout time to produce an arsenal of nuclear weapons is now weeks, mere weeks.” If the world didn’t rein in Iran, then Israel had no recourse except to bear this crushing burden on its own of stopping Hitler’s Third Reich: “We are being fired upon from all fronts, from every border. We are surrounded by Iran’s terror proxies.... All of the terror groups attacking Israel are tentacles of the same Shiite octopus, the Iranian octopus. So, I ask you, and be honest with yourselves, what would you do? What would you do if you were in Israel’s shoes? How would you react if your existence was threatened every single day? Israel cannot settle for inaction. We will defend our future.” Holding up his iPad to display an image of Israel allegedly intercepting an Iranian drone over al-Aqsa mosque, Erdan even claimed for Israel the mantle of the true guardian of Islam’s holy sites—“look at this video that shows how Israel intercepts Iranian drones above the Temple Mount and al-Aqsa mosque”—against the defilers of them in Teheran. The tonal register of his rhetorical delivery was as if a defiant accusation, Who dares doubt me?! “In every speech and in countless letters,” Erdan further recalled, “I rang the warning bell regarding Iran.” He got right that the bell must be sounded; but he got wrong from whence the madness emanates. Medice, cura te ipsum. If Erdan represents even half of the Israeli state and society—the fraction is arguably much higher—a catastrophe looms. True, Israeli leaders have in the past uttered certifiable lunacies. It is sufficient to recall Prime Minister Netanyahu holding up a Loony Tunes-like cartoon of the Iranian bomb at the UN and his pronouncement that it was not Hitler but the Palestinian Mufti of Jerusalem who masterminded the Final Solution. Indeed, already as far back as the 1978 Camp David negotiations, President Carter mused about Israel’s head of state, “It’s becoming clearer that the rationality of [Menachem] Begin is in doubt.” (5) All the same, a civilizational leap backwards separates the Israel that once was from what it has become. Israel’s UN representative at the time of the 1967 (“Six-Day”) war, Abba Eban, could serially prevaricate—albeit with consummate eloquence, as befitted the triple-first graduate of Cambridge—without batting an eyelash. But still, it was possible to rationally parse his propositions (as I once endeavored) to prove them wrong. (6) It is no more possible to parse Erdan’s speech than a psychopath’s rant.
*
It might be urged upon Iran to tread lightly so as not to agitate the lunatic in the room. But alas, that is not, in my opinion, a viable option. The documentary record demonstrates that, once Israel has fixed a country in its crosshairs, nothing short of abject submission will bring it to desist. If the “enemy” power resists initial provocation, Israel will keep escalating with another and another provocation until it proves politically untenable for the targeted entity to passively absorb further blows. That’s what happened when Israel targeted Egypt’s Gamel Abdel Nasser in the early 1950s. (7) (It was feared by Israeli Prime Minister Ben-Gurion that the “radical nationalist” Egyptian president might one day preside over a modern state able to check Israel’s regional ambitions.) That’s what happened when Israel targeted the Palestine Liberation Organization in Lebanon in the early 1980s. (8) (It was feared by Israeli Prime Minister Begin that the PLO’s “peace offensive”—the Palestinians supported but Israelis opposed a two-state settlement—would bring international pressure on Israel to withdraw from the West Bank.) That’s what happened in 2002 during the second intifada when Israel carried out targeted assassinations of Palestinian leaders. (9) (It was feared by Prime Minister Sharon that the Palestinians would stop armed attacks in exchange for a negotiated ceasefire.) That’s what happened in 2008 when Israel broke a ceasefire with Hamas in order to launch Operation Cast Lead. (10) (It was feared by Israeli Prime Minister Olmert that Hamas would gain international legitimacy as it moderated its political program.) The lamentable truth is that, short of national suicide, Iran cannot exercise the option of inaction: Israel will almost certainly keep ratcheting up the provocations until Teheran has no choice but to respond. It wouldn’t surprise were Israel to assassinate Ayatollah Khamenei then (wink, wink) deny it.
*
The Israeli government has ever been on the alert to exploit opportunities in order to implement its preconceived plans. In 1989, during the Tiananmen Square massacre, Benjamin Netanyahu urged his government to exploit this media distraction by carrying out a mass expulsion of Palestinians in the West Bank. On November 4, 2008, when the United States elected its first Black president, Prime Minister Olmert exploited this media distraction by breaking the ceasefire with Hamas. On July 17, 2014, when a Malaysian airliner flying over Ukraine was downed, Prime Minister Netanyahu exploited this media distraction by launching the murderous ground invasion of Gaza in Operation Protective Edge. The pretexts of October 7 and now Iran’s “retaliation” present the lunatics in Jerusalem with an unprecedented opportunity to rid Israel of the triple challenge to its regional domination: by destroying Gaza, Hezbollah, and Iran; the “fog” of such an explosion would also enable Israel’s ethnic cleansing of the West Bank. If it is hoped that a sane cabal among the Israeli leadership will crystallize to stop this headlong lurch over the precipice, then it must be said that the odds are against it. Hitler’s biographer, Ian Kershaw, observed that, if it took so long for coup plans to hatch against the Fuhrer, it was because of “a deep sense of obedience to authority and service to the state,” the belief that it was “not merely wrong, but despicable and treacherous to undermine one’s own country in war,” and “even as the military disasters mounted and ultimate catastrophe beckoned, the fanatical backing for Hitler had by no means evaporated and continued, if as a minority taste, to show remarkable resilience and strength.”(11) It’s hard not to notice cognate factors at play in elite Israeli circles. On the last point, whereas Netanyahu’s critics have been writing his political obituary for years, he too keeps bouncing back notwithstanding his missteps. Why? Because Israelis see their reflection in him. Indeed, Netanyahu IS Israel: an obnoxious, narcissistic Jewish supremacist for whom only Jews reckon in God’s grand design. It must, finally, be acknowledged that not all Israeli fears are unfounded—the wish is by now widespread that Israel vanish from the map while its capacity has diminished to terrorize its neighbors into submission. But, for the most part, it is a corner that Israel has boxed itself into. Before October 7 Hamas had gestured toward a two-state settlement while Iran consistently voted with the UN General Assembly majority in support of the two-state consensus. Israel rebuffed it.
Will Prime Minister Netanyahu resist the irresistible temptation to cut the Gordian regional knot or, like Samson, will he bring down the Temple—the rest of us—with him? Cassandra would probably say: All bets are off! -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein: Have identity politics changed the course of pro-Palestine protests? | Centre Stage Al Jazeera English www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-have-identit…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
‘This Is The FINAL SOLUTION To The Gaza Question’: Norman Finkelstein CLASHES With Israeli General www.normanfinkelstein.com/this-is-the-final-solution-to-t…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein: Have identity politics changed the course of pro-Palestine protests? aje.io/fwegk6 via @AJEnglish
@normfinkelstein -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein: The Final Solution for the "Gaza Question" youtu.be/VrvaDE53GIU
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
I NEVER PROMISED YOU A ROSE GARDEN
OR Books
@orbooks
Brace yourselves! Are you in the index of @normfinkelstein's new book?
Few in its pages come out alive....
mcusercontent.com/6180a1909cdc59a9df25c1a94/files/ab48c0a… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
India & Global Left
@Indiagloballeft
Finkelstein EXPOSES Israel's Hidden Agenda on Piers Morgan youtu.be/aWRH2Budx1k via @YouTube
@normfinkelstein -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein EXPOSES Israel's Hidden Agenda on Piers Morgan youtu.be/aWRH2Budx1k
@Indiagloballeft -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
SURPRISE!
During an appearance last week on Piers Morgan Uncensored, I stated the following about the proposed “humanitarian” distribution centers in Gaza:
“The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation will set up two or three distribution points in the south of Gaza, and then everybody from the north and middle of Gaza would have to go to the South in order to get food or water or medicine. And then, when everybody is congregated in the south, what do you think is going to happen? There are going to be the massacres. You know what Israel is going to say: ‘There was rioting at the food distribution centers. The IDF felt afraid, and then it started to fire.’”
(www.youtube.com/watch?v=R4jN7IEYNOs&t=2239s, start at 35:04)
What did the NY Times report this morning after yet another large-scale IDF massacre at a distribution center that killed at least 27?
“In the latest violence on Tuesday, the Israeli military said the troops fired near ‘a few’ people who had strayed from the designated route to the site and who did not respond to warning shots. The statement called them ‘suspects’ and said they had ‘posed a
threat’ to soldiers.”
It was as surprising as Dracula sucking the blood of his victims. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Benny Morris, Psychopathic Liar (Part 4)
Several months ago I was supposed to debate Israeli ex-historian Benny Morris at the Oxford Union. At the last minute the ex-historian stipulated that he would only participate in the debate if former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert was also invited. The Union then approached Mr. Olmert but, according to the Union, Olmert “firmly declined to participate if you [i.e., Norman Finkelstein] were part of the debate. Despite multiple discussions, his position remained unchanged, which subsequently led to Benny Morris withdrawing as well” (x.com/normfinkelstein/status/1863481580397731842?lang=en).
Poor Mr Morris, he’s now the last rat left on the sinking ship. His buddy Olmert just jumped off.
A few days ago I debated the ex-historian on Piers Morgan Uncensored. True to demented form, he was adamant that, except for the occasional rotten apple, Israel only targets Hamas in Gaza
(www.youtube.com/watch?v=R4jN7IEYNOs&t=2116s).
But the next day Olmert weighed in: “What we are doing in Gaza now is a war of devastation: indiscriminate, limitless, cruel and criminal killing of civilians. It’s the result of government policy – knowingly, evilly, maliciously, irresponsibly dictated” (Haaretz, “Enough is Enough: Israel is Committing War Crimes,” 27 May 2025).
The next time we debate at Oxford, I suppose the ex-historian can always lean on Mr Borrelli VermiNcelli. www.youtube.com/watch?v=fOZ-MySzAac
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Cowardly Lions
I was invited to participate in a debate at the Oxford Union on November 28, 2024 that included Israeli professor Benny Morris. I was subsequently informed by the Union that, after agreeing to attend, Professor Morris stipulated that he would only participate in the debate if former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert was also invited. The Union then approached Mr. Olmert but, according to the Union, Olmert “firmly declined to participate if you [i.e., Norman Finkelstein] were part of the debate. Despite multiple discussions, his position remained unchanged, which subsequently led to Benny Morris withdrawing as well.” It does give pause just how pusillanimous Israel’s chief historian and former Prime Minister are—and how powerful is the weapon of Truth. The Opposition to the motion no longer included a qualified scholar (the Union replaced Morris with a certifiable psychopath) so I withdrew from the debate. I suppose things could have turned out worse: Morris and Olmert might have booby-trapped my pager.
P.S. Morris is now complaining that the decision to cancel a lecture by him in Germany on account of his deranged anti-Palestinian statements was “sheer cowardice.” I wonder how he would describe his decision not to publicly debate me at Oxford unless Olmert was there to protect him? -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Benny Morris, Psychopathic Liar (Part 3)
I recently debated Israeli ex-historian Benny Morris on Piers Morgan Uncensored. I noted that the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation [GHF] was setting up distribution centers in southern Gaza. The objective is obvious: forcing Gazans to relocate in the South in order to obtain food, water, and medicine. Once crammed in that tiny space, it would be the prelude to their mass expulsion into Egypt. I cited in particular an article in the British Financial Times. (It has been reported elsewhere that one distribution center would be located in central Gaza.) Taking strong exception, the ex-historian purported that Israel’s benign goal was to “supply the Palestinian population in three centers, not just in the south but also in the north with humanitarian aid.”
youtube.com/watch?v=R4jN7IEYNOs&t=1310s… (Start at 34:00)
Here’s what the Financial Times wrote: “The UN and other agencies have refused to participate [in the GHF], arguing that by setting up just a handful of mass distribution centers—mostly clustered in southern Gaza—GHF will force hungry Palestinians to the region bordering Egypt. Bezalel Smotrich, the far-right Israeli finance minister, has described the recent IDF operation as a means to ultimately expel Gazans from the territory and ‘change the course of history.’” (“THE LITTLE-KNOWN GROUP POISED TO TAKE OVER GAZA’S AID,” 21 May 2025) -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Benny Morris, Psychopathic Liar (Part 2)
I recently debated Israeli ex-historian Benny Morris on PIERS MORGAN UNCENSORED. A Palestinian doctor interviewed by Morgan before the debate stated that “I still have many of my colleagues from Nasser hospital who have been kidnapped since the beginning of the war. These doctors have never come back,” and referenced one doctor who “disappeared” and has been reportedly “tortured in Israeli jails.” Visibly outraged, the ex-historian called the doctor “a total Hamas propagandist,” and went on to assert that the allegation that “lots of doctors have been abducted and disappeared [in Gaza] is total nonsense. I know of one or two cases of doctors who have been taken to an Israeli detention center. What happened to them afterwards, I don’t know. I don’t think they have been killed. They have been under arrest for whatever reason.”
www.youtube.com/watch?v=R4jN7IEYNOs&t=1310s
(Start at 14: 50)
Here is what HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH reported already back in August 2024:
“Israeli forces have arbitrarily detained Palestinian healthcare workers in Gaza since hostilities began in October 2023, deported them to detention facilities in Israel, and allegedly tortured and ill-treated them…. Released doctors, nurses and paramedics described … their mistreatment in Israeli custody, including humiliation, beatings, forced stress positions, prolonged cuffing and blindfolding, and denial of medical care. They also reported torture, including rape and sexual abuse by Israeli forces, denial of medical care, and poor detention conditions for the general detainee population…. The Gaza Health Ministry reported that Israeli forces have detained at least 310 Palestinian healthcare workers since October 7. Healthcare Workers Watch-Palestine, a nongovernmental organization, documented 259 detentions of healthcare workers and collected 31 accounts describing torture and other abuses by Israeli authorities, including the use of stress positions, deprivation of adequate food and water, threats of sexual violence and rape, and degrading treatment.” (ISRAEL: PALESTINIAN HEALTHCARE WORKERS TORTURED)
A detailed PHYSICIANS FOR HUMAN RIGHTS-ISRAEL (PHRI) report published three months ago in February 2025 confirmed HRW’s findings. It observed, inter alia, that “healthcare workers in Gaza were subjected to enforced disappearance, leaving their whereabouts, conditions, and fates unknown,” and it further found that “among those who were killed are at least four Palestinian medical workers from Gaza: Dr. Adnan Al Bursh, Dr. Iyad Al Rantisi, Dr. Ziad Al Dalou, and paramedic Hamdan Abu Anaba.” (UNLAWFULLY
DETAINED, TORTURED AND STARVED: THE PLIGHT OF GAZA’S MEDICAL WORKERS IN ISRAELI CUSTODY)
It appears the ex-historian confused who was the “total propagandist.” -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Benny Morris, Psychopathic Liar (Part 2) www.normanfinkelstein.com/benny-morris-psychopathic-liar-…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
@normfinkelstein on the moral dilemma of free speech and academic freedom
Watch the full video on our YouTube and get the book through the link in our bio! youtu.be/r33012Xg6k0 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Israel Derangement Syndrome
JamieSW
@jsternweiner
First the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (@TheIHRA) enabled Israel's genocide by helping smear valid criticism of Israel as antisemitic.
Now @TheIHRA plays host to straight-up genocidal incitement and genocide denial from a wanted fugitive: -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
JamieSW
@jsternweiner
First the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (@TheIHRA) enabled Israel's genocide by helping smear valid criticism of Israel as antisemitic.
Now @TheIHRA plays host to straight-up genocidal incitement and genocide denial from a wanted fugitive: -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Benny Morris, Psychopathic Liar (Part 1) www.normanfinkelstein.com/benny-morris-psychopathic-liar/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Santa's Wish List
The EU's top diplomat, Kaja Kallas, and the EU Commission President, Ursula van der Leyen (aka The Nazi Princess), have been Israel's biggest cheerleaders during its genocide in Gaza. Yesterday, they came out deploring it. I was so touched by this bold act of principle that I purchased a gift on Amazon for each of them. I do hope they're a snug fit.
To the Nazi Princess:
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
To Kaja Kallas,
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Free Speech, Moral Dilemmas, Academic Freedom and "Woke": Norman Finkelstein and Briahna Joy Gray www.normanfinkelstein.com/free-speech-moral-dilemmas-acad…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Speaking Truth to Power and the Encampments: Norman Finkelstein and Briahna Joy Gray www.normanfinkelstein.com/speaking-truth-to-power-and-the…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Live on Ave C: Norman Finklestein & Briahna Joy Gray Debate: Were The "Anti Woke" Left WRONG? www.normanfinkelstein.com/live-on-ave-c-norman-finklestei…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein: Trump, Israel, Gaza, and the Criminalization of Dissent youtu.be/zxsx8LXEcoc
@normfinkelstein -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Watch OR Books author @normfinkelstein in conversation with host of @BadFaithPod @briebriejoy for the launch of I'LL BURN THAT BRIDGE WHEN I GET TO IT publishing June 24, 2025 www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y3SldRLSd6c&t=4638s
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Briahna Joy Gray
@briebriejoy
You can watch in full here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y3SldRLSd6c
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Katie Halper
@kthalps
Briahna Joy Gray @briebriejoy interviews Norman Finkelstein @normfinkelstein at @orbooks about his book “I’ll Burn that Bridge When I Get to it.” orbooks.com/catalog/ill-burn-that-bridge-when-i-get-to-it/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Comrades! The Red Flag Will Triumph! www.normanfinkelstein.com/comrades-the-red-flag-will-triu…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: Until several weeks ago I was unfamiliar with the neo-conservative polemicist Douglas Murray. In my defense, I had also not previously heard of the comedian Dave Smith. Why their 10 April debate has generated so much comment and discussion remains something of a mystery. Presumably this has at least as much to do with it being hosted by Joe Rogan, the most popular English-language podcaster, as with the substance of the exchange itself.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Chris Hedges: Israel's Solution to the GAZA QUESTION (w/ Norman Finkelstein) www.normanfinkelstein.com/chris-hedges-israels-solution-t…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
When Boeing Backfired www.normanfinkelstein.com/when-boeing-backfired/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
I’ll Burn That Bridge When I Get To It
Heretical Thoughts on Identity Politics, Cancel Culture, and Academic Freedom
NORMAN X. FINKELSTEIN
NEW EXPANDED EDITION
America’s most canceled intellectual presents a scorching defence of free thought and a devastating indictment of a left that has lost its way.
—Noam Chomsky
“Badly needed, and done with Finkelstein’s usual verve and precision.”
—Alice Walker
“There is no one like him today … [an] incredible warrior for truth and justice.”
—Cornel West
“Like his magisterial work on Gaza, this book is both brilliant and brave.”
—Debra Winger
“Norman reaches into the bushes, grabs less rigorous analyses, and shakes them until the chaff shows. I may not always agree, but I require his view for a full accounting.”
@orbooks
orbooks.com/cart.php?suggest=8a62d4b0-4a94-48d6-87dd-dc10… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
From OR Books @orbooks
FROM THE KING OF BRIGHTON BEACH
orbooks.com/catalog/ill-burn-that-bridge-when-i-get-to-it/ -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
The latest from @normfinkelstein, I’ll Burn That Bridge When I Get To It: Heretical Thoughts on Identity Politics, Cancel Culture, and Academic Freedom.
Pre-order now!
orbooks.com/catalog/ill-burn-that-bridge-when-i-get-to-it/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein has just completed a new book manuscript entitled GAZA'S GRAVEDIGGERS: An Inquiry into Corruption in High Places. It demonstrates that, since 7 October 2023, key figures in the international community have facilitated the genocide in Gaza by shamelessly lying on Israel's behalf. The book concludes that "It is imperative that they be held accountable for this egregious abuse of power." Finkelstein would welcome the submission of a COVER DESIGN for the book. Below are photos of the key figures analyzed and indicted in Finkelstein's book.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Emptying Gaza (w/ Norman Finkelstein) | The Chris Hedges Report www.normanfinkelstein.com/emptying-gaza-w-norman-finkelst…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A GROUP OF US WENT TO SEE THE INSPIRING DOCUMENTARY, THE ENCAMPMENTS, LAST NIGHT AT LINCOLN CENTER IN MANHATTAN. I STRONGLY RECOMMEND IT. www.normanfinkelstein.com/a-group-of-us-went-to-see-the-i…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein EXPOSES Senator Chuck Schumer's Book youtu.be/wbtNwn9JYj8
@Indiagloballeft -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
"This is Hossam’s team, and we are sharing his final message" www.normanfinkelstein.com/this-is-hossams-team-and-we-are…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Senator Schumer: Shakespeare or Schmaltz? www.normanfinkelstein.com/senator-schumer-shakespeare-or-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Senator Schumer: Shakespeare or Schmaltz?
The other day I suffered the ordeal of reading Senator Chuck Schumer's awful little book, ANTI-SEMITISM IN AMERICA: A WARNING. Such an original subject! Until Mr. Schumer came along, no Jew had published a book on alleged rising anti-Semitism in the US since the last ... 48 hours. At one point, Mr Schumer recalls meditating on his remote relatives who were exterminated during the Nazi holocaust: "Sometimes as a kid, I tried to picture them, those-long-distant Schumers, living half a world away and half a lifetime ago. Did they look like me? What kind of food did they eat? Did they ride their bikes on the weekend like I did? Who were their friends, neighbors, school crushes? Did they like to dance? If so, to what music?" Above my piano hang photos of my late Mother's family: her mother, father, and two siblings. (No photos of my late Father's family survived the war.) I know nothing about them. It was a taboo subject in my home. But, somehow, I don't recall ever wondering, Did my Mother's mother ride her bike on the weekend? Schumer credits his co-author for bringing "poetry to my thoughts." Is this Shakespeare or schmaltz? -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Letter from Columbia student Ranjani Srinivasan after fleeing the United States to Canada www.normanfinkelstein.com/letter-from-columbia-student-ra…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein on Donald Trump and the genocide in Gaza | A Busboys ... www.youtube.com/live/wo41zgyLCKI
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What We Can Do
Demand the Immediate Release of Palestinian Student Activist Mahmoud Khalil from DHS detention www.normanfinkelstein.com/demand-the-immediate-release-of… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Palestine, Israel, History & Gaza ft. Norman Finkelstein | Know Time 108 www.normanfinkelstein.com/palestine-israel-history-gaza-f…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Nader Hashemi
@naderalihashemi
This Sunday in DC.
My conversation with Norman Finkelstein -- the world's leading authority on Gaza
@normfinkelstein @MouinRabbani -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Palestine, Israel, History & Gaza ft. Norman Finkelstein | Know Time 108 youtu.be/RDQWby8XqGI via @YouTube
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
BREAKING: DHS Detains Lead Negotiator of Columbia Gaza Solidarity Encampment After Online Campaign by Pro-Israel Groups
www.dropsitenews.com/p/dhs-detains-columbia-university-st… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein on Trump, Mossad Conspiracies in Israel, and the Dying Left www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-in-trump-mos…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein on Trump, Mossad Conspiracies in Israel, and the dying left. youtu.be/k0PfzWbxuIQ
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
@normfinkelstein Norman Finkelstein on AlMayadeen talking about Sayyed Nasrallah @AlMayadeenNews youtu.be/muaEq5CDvf0
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Down in Palestine ...Κατω Στην Παλαιστινη by the Greek Band "Monkey Man Cdj Reeko" www.normanfinkelstein.com/down-in-palestine-κατω-στην-παλ…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein Calls for a Mass Protest Movement www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-calls-for-a-…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
"Israel's Masterplan....to Ethnically Cleanse Gaza" - Norman Finkelstein/ Unapologetic www.normanfinkelstein.com/israels-masterplan-to-ethnicall…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Malfeasance at the International Court of Justice - Mouin Rabbani Interviews Norman Finkelstein www.normanfinkelstein.com/malfeasance-at-the-internationa…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
TOMORROW AT 7 PM EST: Join us on Monday, 3 February for a conversation with @MouinRabbani and @normfinkelstein about recent revelations that Judge Julia Sebutinde, President of the International Court of Justice, extensively plagiarized Israel apologists in a dissenting opinion to a major ruling by the Court. This episode of Connections will discuss Finkelstein’s recently-concluded research into Judge Sebutinde’s professional integrity, and his conclusion that she is serving as an agent of a foreign power.
"Connections Episode 99: Malfeasance at the International Court of Justice with Norman Finkelstein (3 February)"
jadaliyya.com/Details/46493 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein on Genocide in Gaza and Free Speech www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-on-genocide-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein: Israel Succeeded In Making Gaza Unlivable | Full Interview www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-israel-succe…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Jadaliyya Connections Episode 99: Malfeasance at the International Court of Justice with Norman Finkelstein (3 February) www.normanfinkelstein.com/jadaliyya-connections-episode-9…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
"Join us on Monday, 3 February for a conversation with @MouinRabbani and @normfinkelstein about recent revelations that Judge Julia Sebutinde, President of the International Court of Justice, extensively plagiarized Israel apologists in a dissenting opinion to a major ruling by the Court. This episode of Connections will discuss Finkelstein’s recently-concluded research into Judge Sebutinde’s professional integrity, and his conclusion that she is serving as an agent of a foreign power.
"Connections Episode 99: Malfeasance at the International Court of Justice with Norman Finkelstein (3 February)"
www.jadaliyya.com/Details/46493 -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Al Arabiya English
@AlArabiya_Eng
"Israel's primary aim the past 15 months has been to make Gaza unlivable."
@normfinkelstein warns that #gaza has been made “literally unlivable,” leaving its people with no choice but to stay and die or find a way to leave—potentially with #israel’s facilitation. #gntThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Al Arabiya English
@AlArabiya_Eng
Political scientist Norman Finkelstein says #us President #trump’s meeting with #israeli Prime Minister #netanyahu signals a disregard for international law and a willingness to give Israel a free hand in #gaza. #gnt
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Al Arabiya English
@AlArabiya_Eng
"Elon Musk probably can't find Israel on a map"
@normfinkelstein critiques the fixation on flamboyant personalities like @elonmusk, emphasizing that #us foreign policy remains driven by institutional investments and the exertion of maximal force, not personal connections. #gntThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Al Arabiya English
@AlArabiya_Eng
Political Scientist Norman Finkelstein discusses #netanyahu's meeting with #trump, highlighting the message it sends to #palestinians and the possible future of their statehood under the new administration. #gnt
Watch the full interview here: youtu.be/aiWvgAwYvp0 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
NEW BOOK REVEALS
ICJ PRESIDENT JULIA SEBUTINDE GUILTY OF WHOLESALE PLAGIARISM
ONLY BRIBERY OR BLACKMAIL CAN EXPLAIN SEBUTINDE’S WHITEWASHING OF ISRAEL
News broke yesterday of plagiarism by president of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) Julia Sebutinde.
In July last year, the ICJ issued an advisory opinion that found Israel’s decades-long occupation of Palestinian territories to be “unlawful.”
Judge Sebutinde issued a dissenting opinion in support of Israel that subverted the overwhelming international legal consensus.
A report in Middle East Eye points to three instances in Justice Sebutinde’s dissent where the ICJ president appears to have lifted sentences directly from a paper by a key official in the administration of George W. Bush.
In fact, as explosive new findings by renowned Middle East researcher and analyst Norman Finkelstein demonstrate, the problem with Sebutinde’s judgment runs much deeper.
Finkelstein documents that no less than 32% of Sebutinde’s dissenting opinion has been directly lifted from publications by notorious apologists for Israel.
But that’s just the tip of the iceberg. Finkelstein sets out, in painstaking detail, why the anomalies, errors, and legal contortions in Sebutinde’s dissent could have only resulted from either bribery or blackmail by the Israeli government.
The problem with Judge Sebutinde, according to Finkelstein’s research, is not just that she’s an unprofessional judge but that the president of the highest judicial body in the world is in thrall to a foreign power.
The full details of Finkelstein’s allegations against Sebutinde appear in a forthcoming book, Gaza’s Gravediggers: An inquiry into corruption in high places, copies of which will be available from OR Books in June 2025.
Finkelstein received his doctorate from the Princeton University Department of Politics and has established himself, after decades of groundbreaking research, as the world's leading “forensic scholar.”
Among those whose falsehoods have been exposed by his research are Joan Peters, Daniel Goldhagen, Alan Dershowitz, Jeffrey Goldberg, and Benny Morris.
Professor John Dugard, who served on the UN’s International Law Commission, has described Finkelstein as “probably the most serious scholar on the conflict in the Middle East.”
For more information about Norman Finkelstein’s exposé of ICJ president Julia Sebutinde and to interview him, please contact publicity@orbooks.com
@orbooks -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein: Keynote Address at the Gala for Gaza
Organized by: Muslim City Fest
Location: Bensalem, PA.
Date: 1/18/2025
youtu.be/1YcWuObe0h8
@muslimcityfest -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
It might seem that I've been Missing in Action, but I continue to do my best, non-stop, for the Cause. I am hopeless but that's beside the point: the wise Confucius was once described as "one who knows it’s hopeless, but keeps trying anyway.” Here are two wonderful renditions of a timeless song (by the great Pete Seeger) about the horrors of war and the dignity in the refusal to go along with it. Marlene Dietrich was German, but she denounced the Nazi atrocities during World War 2 and publicly sided with the Allies. The Germans never forgave her, but in the hearts of free men and women, she will forever be honored. Would that today's Germans learn the real meaning of moral courage. The new college semester is just beginning. Hopefully, it will be marked by a new surge of courage as young people wrest back the right to free speech and defy university officials who, in return for a few gold coins, are colluding with Israel's genocide. Free Speech/Free Gaza
www.youtube.com/watch?v=kveooWmqqr8
www.youtube.com/watch?v=AybZIw8BRIM -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Audible version of Gaza: An Inquest Into Its Martyrdom is now available. Narrated and produced by @voicemta, it brings the book’s detailed examination to life. The audiobook is also available on Everand, Spotify, and 36+ platforms.
🎧 Listen here: www.audible.com/pd/Gaza-Audiobook/B0DQQG9M5H?source_code=… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein on the ceasefire agreement. youtu.be/sJ4SMY2UNW4
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What we can do
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
On the occasion of the declared ceasefire taking effect on Sunday after 460 days of horrific genocide, a call for a candle vigil on Sat 18 at 6:00 p.m. at Syntagma square to honor all the martyrs in Gaza and praying for the healing of the whole of Gaza and its injured people.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Finkelstein request:
If you already read my book, I ACCUSE!, and have time to do fact-checking on the new postscript to the book, kindly contact me at NormFinkelstein@gmail.com -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
India & Global Left
@Indiagloballeft
Our latest long-format discussion with Norman Finkelstein is now live. Must watch!
youtu.be/o_BtoZETnEc
@normfinkelstein @SanaImmTarek -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein with India &Global Left: Is Gaza really Gone?
Coming soon @IndiaGlobalLeft
@normfinkelstein youtu.be/4EFPYAZbqBQ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Coming up with @Indiagloballeft
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein with India &Global Left: Is Gaza really Gone?
Coming soon @IndiaGlobalLeft
@normfinkelstein youtu.be/4EFPYAZbqBQ -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
BREAKING: A statement from Dr. Hussam Abu Safiyeh’s family.
They are asking everyone to please share this message 🙏🏽
Sulaiman Ahmed
@ShaykhSulaiman
BREAKING: A statement from Dr. Hussam Abu Safiyeh’s family.
They are asking everyone to please share this message 🙏🏽
“Peace be upon you and God’s mercy and blessings.
We are the family of Dr. Hussam Abu Safiyeh. It is no secret to anyone the great efforts the doctor has made since the beginning of the war to support the sole health system for the residents of northern Gaza—your families, loved ones, and relatives. His last known effort was after the military operation on northern Gaza, following an 84-day siege during which they endured the harshest trials, hunger, oppression, bombardment, and threats. Despite all of this, he continued to work for the sake of the patients. He even lost his beloved son, our son Ibrahim, and he himself sustained a severe injury. To this day, our father is still affected by that injury.
We do not know the fate of our father. We urge you to act, to apply media pressure, and to amplify calls for action through reports and advocacy to pressure the occupation forces to release him as soon as possible. Currently, our father is suffering from the severe cold, and many of you have heard from eyewitnesses who were released about how he was forced to remove his clothes, including his medical coat, and was used as a human shield.
We call upon every living conscience, every organization, and every international institution to act immediately.
Please note that we hold foreign citizenship.” -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein: If we do nothing, it will get worse. youtu.be/yfukDzdTOuY
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Syria: Fractured but Hopeful - A Think Piece by Dhul Aslayn www.normanfinkelstein.com/syria-fractured-but-hopeful-a-t…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Who would ever have thunk that Finkelstein and Dershowitz would co-star in a musical?!
www.tiktok.com/@compassionfatiguesongs/video/745163547112…
youtu.be/l1rZP5V04RM -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
I received this message in my inbox today. If any group is taking any action, I would want to join.
A message to the world from North Gaza
Northern Gaza is being destroyed and the last landmark of life there (Kamal Adwan Hospital) is being subjected to heavy bombardment and its patients and medical staff are starving.
The occupation has destroyed all the necessities of life. There is no food, water, ambulance services, or civil defense, and the bombing has been ongoing for about 80 days.
What is the world waiting for
x.com/HossamShabat/status/1870585909714006297
حسام شبات
@HossamShabat
أكتب لكم #النداء_الاخير
رسالة للعالم من شمال غزة
شمال غزة يباد وآخر معلم للحياة فيه (مستشفى كمال عدوان) يتعرض للقصف المكثف ويجوع مرضاه وطاقمه الطبي..
كل مقومات الحياة أعدمها الاحتلال فلا طعام أو ماء أو خدمات إسعاف أو دفاع مدني والقصف متواصل منذ نحو 80 يوما..
*ماذا ينتظر العالم؟ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Spring courses with Norman Finkelstein at Brooklyn College:
POLS 3120: Constitutional Law (3 Credits)
Overview: This course will focus on landmark U.S. Supreme Court decisions on race, sex, and privacy.
POLS 3240: International Law (3 Credits)
Overview: This course will focus on the laws of war--what is and what isn't legally permissible in an armed conflict.
normanfinkelstein.com/spring-classes-with-professor-finke… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Spring courses with Norman Finkelstein at Brooklyn College
www.normanfinkelstein.com/spring-classes-with-professor-f… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Spring Classes with Professor Finkelstein www.normanfinkelstein.com/spring-classes-with-professor-f…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Deborah Maccoby on Refaat Alareer www.normanfinkelstein.com/deborah-maccoby-on-refaat-alareer/
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Buy Refaat's book here orbooks.com/catalog/if-i-must-die/ 🪁🇵🇸
Drop Site
@DropSiteNews
Pledge to buy Refaat’s book (which we have nothing to do with) on Dec 10 and help it become a bestseller. Together, we can honor his life and show we are not looking away. Sign the pledge to buy the book Tuesday and share this with everyone you know: actionnetwork.org/forms/refaat-alareer/
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Buy Refaat's book here orbooks.com/catalog/if-i-must-die/ 🪁🇵🇸
Drop Site
@DropSiteNews
December 6 marks a year since Palestinian poet Refaat Alareer was killed in an airstrike, leaving behind words that still soar. On Dec 10, his book If I Must Die will be released. Let's make it a best seller.
Buy it that day to honor his dream of hope and justice. Let it fly like a kite. Let it be a tale. @ryangrim:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Announcing:
GAZA’S GRAVEDIGGERS, a new book from Norman Finkelstein.
Sign up here to be notified when the book is available to order:
orbooks.com/news/gazas-gravediggers-announcing-a-major-ne… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
OR Books is pleased to announce a new book by Norman Finkelstein, the world’s leading authority on Gaza.
In the new book, Gaza’s Gravediggers: An Inquiry into Corruption in High Places, Finkelstein trains his critical eye on the most influential arguments defending Israel’s genocide and systematically dismantles them.
In the process, he exposes how a United Nations special representative lent credence to an Israeli smear campaign, how judges on the world’s highest court perverted the law in Israel’s defence, and how even Israel’s severe critics colluded in misrepresenting genocide as a war.
The book’s purpose, Finkelstein writes, is to put officials in the highest places on notice:
“You cannot mangle Truth and traduce Justice with impunity. You cannot go your merry way after besmirching your calling and betraying your mandate. It will not be forgotten, it will no longer be business as usual, if you choose to do the Devil’s work.” orbooks.com/news/gazas-gravediggers-announcing-a-major-ne…
@orbooks -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein Visiting Student Encampment at Cambridge University. Most are women. It was deeply moving and inspiring. May the Force be with them.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
“Gaza Is NO MORE” Norman Finkelstein vs Fleur Hassan | www.normanfinkelstein.com/gaza-is-no-more-norman-finkelst…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Dr. Norman Finkelstein | International Law, The U.S. & Israel's Weaknesses www.normanfinkelstein.com/dr-norman-finkelstein-internati…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Khalil Hamada's Audio Message from Gaza www.normanfinkelstein.com/khalil-hamadas-audio-message-fr…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Memories of the British Speaking Tour www.normanfinkelstein.com/memories-of-the-british-speakin…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Cowardly Lions
I was invited to participate in a debate at the Oxford Union on November 28, 2024 that included Israeli professor Benny Morris. I was subsequently informed by the Union that, after agreeing to attend, Professor Morris stipulated that he would only participate in the debate if former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Olmert was also invited. The Union then approached Mr. Olmert but, according to the Union, Olmert “firmly declined to participate if you [i.e., Norman Finkelstein] were part of the debate. Despite multiple discussions, his position remained unchanged, which subsequently led to Benny Morris withdrawing as well.” It does give pause just how pusillanimous Israel’s chief historian and former Prime Minister are—and how powerful is the weapon of Truth. The Opposition to the motion no longer included a qualified scholar (the Union replaced Morris with a certifiable psychopath) so I withdrew from the debate. I suppose things could have turned out worse: Morris and Olmert might have booby-trapped my pager.
P.S. Morris is now complaining that the decision to cancel a lecture by him in Germany on account of his deranged anti-Palestinian statements was “sheer cowardice.” I wonder how he would describe his decision not to publicly debate me at Oxford unless Olmert was there to protect him? -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein's social media and email are currently being updated. He can be reached via his social media and email AFTER December 3, 2024.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: Encounter with the Thought Police (Remarks delivered at the Fletcher School's Fares Center for Eastern Mediterranean Studies)
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The UK tour
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Hussain “Hoz” Shafiei
@HussainShafiei
Proffessor @normfinkelstein deconstructs and interviewee with a young man that is claiming that he suffers antisemitism and he shows him the exact opposite is the case in the United States of America if anything Jewish people have advantageous rights.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
📣 Get the new expanded edition of @normfinkelstein's incendiary work I'LL BURN THAT BRIDGE WHEN I GET TO IT: Heretical Thoughts on Identity Politics, Cancel Culture, and Academic Freedom. Pre-order now to get 15% off 👇
orbooks.com/catalog/ill-burn-that-bridge-when-i-get-to-it/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein- Trump’s intrusive demons and Israel’s ‘enlightened cause’ www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-trumps-intru…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein on Hizb -o-llah and The Responsibility to Protect youtu.be/7-3AFRE57qU
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Mouin Rabbani- 10 November: Thugs and Hooligans www.normanfinkelstein.com/mouin-rabbani-10-november-thugs…
@MouinRabbani -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Watch live at 3:30 p.m EST:
Norman Finkelstein predicted Trump would win when the "experts" said he'd lose. Listen!! youtu.be/e1aOQVUH8hI
@Indiagloballeft -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein on the war on Gaza and Lebanon at a Muslim Global Peace and Unity Conference in London youtu.be/u7Ikp_3hYSs
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
This is Mahasin Alkhateeb. She was an entrepreneur and a freelance graphic and motion designer.
Mahasin was an example of a successful and creative young independent woman. She took care of her family and her visually impaired siblings, she was the breadwinner of all of them.
Mahasin was martyred yesterday in the bombing of Jabalia.
www.normanfinkelstein.com/here-is-the-fate-of-the-woman-i…
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Audio of Jew in Warsaw Ghetto during the Final Solution www.normanfinkelstein.com/audio-of-jew-in-warsaw-ghetto-d…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
"Here is the fate of the woman I sent you a recording of... I'm broken today - the one you likened to the Warsaw Ghetto voice" www.normanfinkelstein.com/here-is-the-fate-of-the-woman-i…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
المقابلة | الأكاديمي والباحث الأمريكي نورمان فنكلشتاين.. يهودي يتصدى للص... youtu.be/a1nUsDX2G7U via @YouTube
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
المقابلة | الأكاديمي والباحث الأمريكي نورمان فنكلشتاين.. يهودي يتصدى للص... youtu.be/NeNaDtJv4TI via @YouTube
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein's gmail will be upgraded October 17-20. He will not have access to his account. Do not email him until October 21, 2024.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
المقابلة | الأكاديمي والباحث الأمريكي نورمان فنكلشتاين.. يهودي يتصدى للص... youtu.be/NeNaDtJv4TI
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Audio of Jew in Warsaw Ghetto during the Final Solution www.normanfinkelstein.com/audio-of-jew-in-warsaw-ghetto-d…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A Guest Commentary www.normanfinkelstein.com/a-guest-commentary/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
“Israel's FAVOURITE Cheerleader!” Oct 7 One Year On | Norman Finkelstein & Naftali Bennett www.normanfinkelstein.com/israels-favourite-cheerleader-o…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Palestine Talks | Norman Finkelstein
youtu.be/LCF04lvUUd0 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
FINKELSTEIN ON GAZA-WHAT HAPPENED, WHERE WE STAND, WHAT'S NEXT? www.normanfinkelstein.com/finkelstein-on-gaza-what-happen…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein & Mouin Rabbani react to Lebanon Attack, Iran retaliation & Nasrallah's death
youtu.be/ZWphDTn1oVc -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
To the Party of Sayyed Nasrallah-- May The Force Be with You! www.normanfinkelstein.com/to-the-party-of-sayyed-nasralla…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
To the Party of Sayyed Nasrallah--
May The Force Be with You!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=LYIJ2r3AeiM -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
ANOTHER CORRECTION to Glenn Greenwald interview.
Hezbollah stated that it fired 8,000 projectiles at Israel during the 2006 war. Israel stated that it was closer to 4,000. On the last day of the war, Hezbollah fired 250 rockets at Israel, which was the largest number that it fired on any single day of the 33-day war. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
IMPORTANT CORRECTIONS
After the Glenn Greenwald interview was posted, two errors were brought to my attention:
(1) There is no publicly reliable figure for the number of Gazans who have fled. The best estimates are not 300,000-500,000 as I stated, but 150,000-200,000.
(2) Israel does post its casualty figures and there is no reason to doubt their accuracy. I should have said that, unlike in previous conflicts, there is no public recognition of these numbers, which don't bear out that it is fighting a "war" in Gaza. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein on Lebanon www.normanfinkelstein.com/new-israel-u-s-war-with-profess…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Finkelstein on Lebanon.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
New Israel/U.S. War With Professor Norman Finkelstein www.normanfinkelstein.com/new-israel-u-s-war-with-profess…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
New Israel/U.S. War With Professor Norman Finkelstein www.normanfinkelstein.com/new-israel-u-s-war-with-profess…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Security State Endorses Kamala; Zelensky & Shapiro Campaign in PA; New Israel/U.S. War With Professor Norman Finkelstein | SYSTEM UPDATE #339
Interview with Norman Finkelstein starts at 57:00
rumble.com/v5g2qmb-system-update-show-339.html -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A Poem by Ahmed Hamadi www.normanfinkelstein.com/a-poem-by-ahmed-hamadi/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A Jailed Bird’s Plaint by Ahmed Hamadi www.normanfinkelstein.com/a-jailed-birds-plaint-by-ahmed-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
SHBAIR AND BIGG: WHORES OF GENOCIDE www.normanfinkelstein.com/shbair-and-bigg-whores-of-genoc…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
SHBAIR AND BIGG: WHORES OF GENOCIDE
Israel is ever attuned to the US news cycle. It has predictably escalated its genocide in Gaza as the Kamala Harris candidacy replaced Gaza as the top news story. The past few weeks have been particularly gruesome: another day, another massacre of innocents. The New York Times plays its assigned role. Desperate to appease its reader base of billionaire Jewish supremacists on the Upper East Side in Manhattan, the Times keeps churning out the Israeli propaganda. Here’s one of its wretched headlines today (10 September 2024):
“Unwilling to Be Militants’ Human Shields, Some Gazans Turn Gunmen Away From Shelters”
Midway into this harrowing article on Hamas perfidy, the reader who gets this far comes across this line: “It was not possible to confirm whether armed or unarmed militants stay in the school shelters.” In other words, the whole thing is fabricated out of whole cloth. The authors of this article are identified as Bilal Shbair and Matthew Mpoke Bigg. Let there be no mistake: these two “persons of color” are complicit in genocide. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein and Benny Morris on @piersmorgan
youtu.be/IVjVDPle6a4 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Finkelstein on Sinwar's Elevation
youtu.be/d_TVBJgxqC4 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein on Israel/Palestine youtu.be/laTJsfObva8
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
NORMAN FINKELSTEIN: Zionism, Israeli society, Gaza, Genocide, Kamala Harris and debate with Destiny youtu.be/GCqQhobrnC0
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Substantive interview with Norman Finkelstein:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=laTJsfObva8 -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Arab and Muslim Techies, I need your help! (Also Christian and Jewish techies!)
I need assistance in tracking down PLAGIARIZED sections of a document that I am analyzing for a book on Gaza, to be published in October. I am certain the alleged author of the document did not write the document, but I don't know enough about modern web technologies to track down the actual author. If you are skillful at this sort of thing, kindly contact me at my email address:
NormFinkelstein@gmail.com.
Thank you in advance. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
20 July 2024: Polio and the Destruction of Gaza’s Health Infrastructure
By Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
This past week, poliovirus was detected in sewage samples in the Gaza Strip. According to the World Health Organization (WHO) polio (poliomyelitis) is a “highly infectious disease” that “invades the nervous system and can cause total paralysis in a matter of hours”.
Like so much else in the Gaza Strip these days, polio according to the WHO “mainly affects children under 5 years of age” but can infect “anyone of any age who is unvaccinated”. Furthermore, “One in 200 infections leads to irreversible paralysis (usually in the legs). Among those paralyzed, 5-10% die when their breathing muscles become immobilized”.
Israel and its apologists can be expected to blame Hamas for this state of affairs, with canards about the Gaza health authorities prioritizing the construction of tunnels over inoculating those under their rule, dirty Arabs, and the like. The fact of the matter is that not only is polio not endemic in the Gaza Strip, it was eradicated from the territory several decades ago. The achievement was publicly touted by none other than Ted Tulchinksy, who from 1978-1994 served as the Coordinator for Health in the West Bank and Gaza Strip within Israel’s Ministry of Health. His testimony is significant because during his tenure Tulchinsky supervised the health departments of the military governments Israel established in each of the West Bank and Gaza Strip in 1967.
Writing on the website of the US National Institutes of Health (NIH) in 2011, Tulchinsky writes that during the 1970s polio epidemics periodically erupted in Israel and the Palestinian territories it was in the process of annexing, and “despite high levels of [vaccination] coverage” in the Gaza Strip in particular, on account of its degraded sanitary infrastructure.
Tulchinsky recounts that in 1978 Israel consulted with Natan Goldblum and Joseph Melnick, two noted epidemiologists from Baylor University, to develop more effective anti-polio strategies. Their recommendation, to increase the four doses traditionally given to infants during their first year with an additional three of a different variety, was pioneered in the Gaza Strip. It proved so effective that the disease was eradicated from the territory within a few short years. Tulchinsky does not say so, but it seems likely that as with so much else the Gaza Strip here too functioned as a human laboratory for new Israeli methods. Indeed, the Goldblum-Melnick vaccination sequence was according to Tulchinsky “dubbed the Gaza system” and subsequently applied within Israel to quell a polio outbreak of its own in 1988. “As a result of this episode”, Tulchinsky wrote, “Israel adopted the Gaza system, and total eradication of polio was rapidly achieved”.
It is unclear how polio has suddenly re-appeared in the Gaza Strip. What is beyond doubt is how it’s spreading. Israel has systematically destroyed the Gaza Strip’s health, sanitary, water treatment, and power infrastructure, particularly since October 2023, leading to the collapse of systems that were already precarious. Contaminated water, untreated sewage, and uncollected garbage, particularly when paired with the severe overcrowding resulting from Israel’s genocidal campaign and repeated forced displacement of the civilian population, represent ideal conditions for its spread.
In the words of United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, speaking last December:
The people of Gaza are being told to move like human pinballs – ricocheting between ever-smaller slivers of the south, without any of the basics of survival … Conditions in shelters are overcrowded and unsanitary. People nurse open wounds. Hundreds of people stand in line for hours to use one shower or toilet … wearing clothes they have not changed for two months.
Such conditions have also created a breeding ground for other infectious diseases. As of 30 June, the WHO reported nearly a million cases of acute respiratory infection (affecting almost half the population), over half a million cases of diarrhea (including nearly 200,000 cases of “acute watery diarrhea”), and over 100,000 cases of acute jaundice (suggesting hepatitis is widespread), and so on. The WHO notes these figures “should be interpreted with caution, due to delayed and incomplete data reporting”. As the summer intensifies, there have also been multiple warnings of a cholera outbreak.
With few and limited exceptions, Israel is preventing the entry of fuel, vaccines, medical supplies, and potable water into the Gaza Strip. As Israel’s Minister of Defense, Yoav Gallant, publicly announced on 8 October, “We are imposing a complete siege on Gaza. There will be no electricity, no food, no water, no fuel. Everything will be closed”.
There was more to this policy of collective sadism than revenge. Giora Eiland is a retired major-general who previously served as head of Israel’s National Security Council and is an advisor to its current government. He also publishes a regular column in the Israeli newspaper Yedioth Ahronoth. Writing on 29 October, he urged Israel to inflict “not only destruction in Gaza City, but a humanitarian disaster and absolute governmental chaos … [O]nly that outcome – the complete destruction of all systems in Gaza and desperate distress”, would in his view bring about victory. On 19 November he exhorted the government to continue its siege on the Gaza Strip, emphasizing that “severe epidemics in the southern Gaza Strip will bring victory closer and will reduce the number of IDF casualties.” The enthusiastic identification of an entire society as a military target, and the determination to inflict maximum levels of suffering to compensate for Israel’s military failures, has been a common refrain among Israel’s senior political and military leaders.
Central to this campaign has been the eradication of Gaza’s health infrastructure. The WHO speaks of the “continued dismantling of the health system”. In late May Doctors Without Borders (MSF) put it thus: “In the last seven months the healthcare system in the Gaza Strip has been systematically dismantled. According to OCHA [The United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs] 24 hospitals are now out of service, while 493 health workers have been killed”. By 12 July the WHO reported 746 health workers killed, 967 injured, and 128 still incarcerated. Israel flunkies will no doubt denounce each and every one of them as Hamas, and claim the numerous ambulances bombed to smithereens were camouflaged rocket launchers.
Attention has primarily focused on the challenges Gaza’s disintegrating Palestinian medical facilities and their overworked and under-resourced staff confront in dealing with the overwhelming number of casualties resulting from Israel’s genocidal campaign. The accounts of young children enduring amputations without anaesthetics and severe burns without pain management, of patients dying because of the unavailability of basic medical supplies like disinfectants, have become all too common. But the crisis also goes much deeper. Regular health care, for example for cancer patients or those who suffer a stroke, diabetics requiring insulin, a child or grandparent with a broken bone, and the like, has also all but disappeared. Mark Perlmutter and Feroze Sidhwa, two US surgeons who recently volunteered at a hospital in the Gaza Strip, provide a particularly harrowing account of their experience. It is, unfortunately, just one of very many such testimonials.
At the beginning of July Rasha Khatib, Martin McKee, and Salim Yusuf published a letter in the prestigious British medical journal The Lancet in which they note that “Armed conflicts have indirect health implications beyond the direct harm from violence”, with “destroyed health-care infrastructure” prominently noted as a factor. The authors observe that “In recent conflicts, such indirect deaths range from three to 15 times the number of direct deaths”. Based on current conditions in the Gaza Strip the authors, “applying a conservative estimate of four indirect deaths per one direct death”, find it “not implausible to estimate that up to 1860,000 or even more deaths could be attributable to the current conflict in Gaza”, and note that this amounts to “7-9% of the population in the Gaza Strip”. That’s a lot of Pallywood for the Defamation League and other Israel flunkies to explain away.
Accounts of the destruction of the Palestinian health infrastructure typically focus on Israel’s destruction of Al-Shifa Hospital, the largest medical complex in the Gaza Strip that was razed and burned to the ground by the most moral army since the Ku Klux Klan after none of its pretexts for attacking the complex were substantiated.
Before Al-Shifa there was the 17 October mass casualty bombing of Al-Ahli Arab Hospital, also known as Al-Ahli Baptist Hospital. Established in 1882, it is the only Christian hospital in the Gaza Strip and is managed by the Anglican Diocese of Jerusalem. Along with other hospitals, it also became a refuge of choice for civilians desperate for safe haven.
Three days earlier, on 14 October, Human Rights Watch reported that “an artillery projectile struck the hospital’s diagnostic cancer treatment center”. Based on details of the shell, it concluded that “Israel is the only party to the [Gaza] conflict known to possess and use the artillery that fires this type of munition”.
Over the course of the next three days the hospital’s director and staff received numerous direct Israeli warnings and threats, demanding they evacuate the premises. (Needless to say, they refused and continued to treat their patients). In the immediate aftermath of the 17 October bombing, Israel put out several and often contradictory accounts, before eventually settling on two points: the casualty figures were vastly exaggerated and, more importantly, were caused not by Israeli fire but an errant Palestinian projectile.
As so often Israel’s purpose in rejecting culpability and blaming its victims is not to convince its audience so much as to confuse it. If journalists, Human Rights Watch, and others conclude they cannot clearly establish responsibility and must await a full and proper investigation when conditions permit, it is mission accomplished.
In this particular case the ruse worked beyond expectations. Although the Anglican Diocese of Jerusalem pointed the finger squarely at Israel, the Archbishop of Canterbury and senior cleric of the Anglican Church, Justin Welby, shamelessly denounced accusations that Israel was responsible as a “blood libel”. “Don’t assume it’s Israel”, he stated. “You have no proof”.
For good measure Welby professed total ignorance on the numbers killed and injured, stating, “I’ve heard so many different figures”. Ever the knave, US President and soon-to-be-former-nominee Joe Biden rushed to blame the Palestinians. Speaking in Israel, the same individual who claimed to have viewed non-existent images of beheaded infants on 7 October stated, “Based on what I’ve seen, it appears it was done by the other team, and not you”. The resulting outrage contributed to the abrupt cancellation of his scheduled conclave with an assortment of Arab client regimes in Amman several days later. Like these past several weeks, even his closest allies couldn’t stomach being associated with him.
The most comprehensive investigation I have come across to date has been conducted by Maher Arar, who has produced two extraordinarily detailed technical reports to demonstrate not only that it was an Israeli projectile that hit Al-Ahli Hospital, but that any other theory is inconsistent with the available evidence. While I found his reasoning entirely convincing, I’m not sufficiently technically proficient – to put it mildly – to rebut any challenges to his technical conclusions. I do however know enough to confidently dismiss any detractors who do not call for an immediate, comprehensive, independent international investigation and refuse to condemn Israel for refusing one.
Maher Arrar makes the important point that Israel attacked Al-Ahli Hospital not despite its prominent international connections, but because of them. It was a test case. If it succeeded, and it could get the likes of Welby, the BBC, and Western governments to play along, that would send an unmistakable signal that every single Palestinian hospital was fair game and could be attacked with impunity. And that’s precisely what has happened. A fundamental principle of the laws of war that has survived for centuries if not millenia lies buried in the rubble of Gaza’s hospitals. It no longer exists, and the horrific consequences will – already do – reverberate far beyond the Gaza Strip.
In the words of noted Palestinian-British surgeon Ghassan Abu-Sitta, who was at Al-Ahli Hospital the night of the attack:
This incident served as a litmus test for what was to come: Israel’s full war on Gaza’s healthcare infrastructure. After Al-Ahli was hit, and no one was held to account, the domino pieces began to fall rapidly. Hospitals were targeted one after the other. It became obvious that the attacks were systemic.
Several months ago, I had the pleasure of meeting Dr Chandra Hassan in Chicago. A dedicated medical professional and humanitarian, he had volunteered at Nasser Hospital in Khan Yunis for some time during the current genocide, and has remained in regular contact with Palestinian colleagues.
During our conversation I asked him if he had what he thought the underlying purpose of Israel’s systematic destruction of the Palestinian health infrastructure. He responded – and here I paraphrase – that hospitals have a special sanctity and form the ultimate refuge and source of hope for people in crisis. They expect to have, and need the confidence they can have, access to a hospital and its staff should they or their loved ones require it, and refuge within its premises should this prove necessary. Remove that confidence, that hope, and replace it with the fear generated by the knowledge it is no longer there, that you will be left to your own devices when you most need hope and help, and you are well on your way to ensuring the disintegration of a society. Sounds about right.
ENDS -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: This past week, poliovirus was detected in sewage samples in the Gaza Strip. According to the World Health Organization (WHO) polio (poliomyelitis) is a “highly infectious disease” that “invades the nervous system and can cause total paralysis in a matter of hours”.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Arab and Muslim Techies, I need your help! (Also Christian and Jewish techies!)
I need assistance in tracking down PLAGIARIZED sections of a document that I am analyzing for a book on Gaza, to be published in October. I am certain the alleged author of the document did not write the document, but I don't know enough about modern web technologies to track down the actual author. If you are skillful at this sort of thing, kindly contact me at my email address:
NormFinkelstein@gmail.com.
Thank you in advance. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
We Demand an Immediate Cessation of all Bigotries and Lies Regrading Palestine on all Greek Public Mass Media
Sign the Petition! www.change.org/p/απαιτουμε-να-παψει-η-ερτ-τη-διασπορα-ψευ… via @Change -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What we can do!
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
We Demand an Immediate Cessation of all Bigotries and Lies Regrading Palestine on all Greek Public Mass Media
ΑΠΑΙΤΟΥΜΕ ΝΑ ΠΑΨΕΙ Η ΕΡΤ ΤΗ ΔΙΑΣΠΟΡΑ ΨΕΥΔΩΝ ΚΑΙ ΜΙΣΑΛΛΟΔΟΞΙΑΣ ΣΕ ΣΧΕΣΗ ΜΕ ΤΗΝ ΠΑΛΑΙΣΤΙΝΗ - Sign the Petition! www.change.org/p/απαιτουμε-να-παψει-η-ερτ-τη-διασπορα-ψευ… via @Change -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Gaza: An Inquest into its Martyrdom is now also an audiobook available across several platforms and eventually audible.
Credit for narration goes to @voicemta, an independent producer who wanted to make the source material more accessible and support the author's work.
Link to spotify: open.spotify.com/show/3dulLPD95PlwFLR7gblciH -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Gaza: An Inquest into its Martyrdom is now also an audiobook available across several platforms and eventually audible.
Credit for narration goes to @voicemta, an independent producer who wanted to make the source material more accessible and support the author's work.
Link to spotify: open.spotify.com/show/3dulLPD95PlwFLR7gblciH -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein at the NYC launch of DELUGE: GAZA AND ISRAEL FROM CRISIS TO CATACLYSM. DELUGE is now available as an audiobook, exclusively from OR Books: orbooks.com/catalog/ordio/
@orbooks @jsternweiner
OR Books
@orbooks
Norman Finkelstein at the NYC launch of DELUGE: GAZA AND ISRAEL FROM CRISIS TO CATACLYSM. DELUGE is now available as an audiobook, exclusively from OR Books: orbooks.com/catalog/ordio/
@normfinkelstein -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Clare Daly
@ClareDalyIRL
Good to see that Deluge, edited by @jsternweiner, which includes my chapter on how @vonderleyen abused her position to offer the EU's support to Israel's war crimes in Gaza - is now an audiobook available exclusively from @orbooks
👉orbooks.com/deluge-audiobook/ -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Use the code ORDIO10 at checkout for a 10% discount 🎧
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
DELUGE (AUDIOBOOK)
Gaza and Israel from Crisis to Cataclysm
Edited by JAMIE STERN-WEINER
Now available in audio form, this groundbreaking book provides an initial taking-stock from leading Palestinian, Israeli, and international authorities orbooks.com/deluge-audiobook/ -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
DELUGE (AUDIOBOOK)
Gaza and Israel from Crisis to Cataclysm
Edited by JAMIE STERN-WEINER
Now available in audio form, this groundbreaking book provides an initial taking-stock from leading Palestinian, Israeli, and international authorities orbooks.com/deluge-audiobook/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A young man from Gaza named Ahmed Hamada sent me these portraits and inscribed them: "From Gaza with love, And we love life" He also sent a picture of himself.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
NEWS FLASH
At a hastily called news conference, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen stunned a packed room of reporters: "It is an outrage to call me a Nazi. Sieg Heil!" After lowering her outstretched arm, The Nazi Princess rushed out of the room in a huff. (www.euronews.com/my-europe/2024/03/29/no-ursula-von-der-l…) -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
LONDON COMRADES: The "Deluge" book on Gaza -- featuring chapters by @MouinRabbani and @ClareDalyMEP among others -- is launching in Bethnal Green on June 25th.
Book your free ticket here:
www.outsavvy.com/event/20623/deluge-london-book-launch -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
"Brave to highlight what is known but less often said" DELUGE: GAZA AND ISRAEL FROM CRISIS TO CATACLYSM reviewed in @M_Star_Online
morningstaronline.co.uk/article/understanding-israel-war-…
@jsternweiner @MouinRabbani @normfinkelstein Get your copy or listen to the new audiobook orbooks.com/catalog/deluge/ -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein on the legal and public challenges to Israel youtu.be/ZxulOWe7rlA
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
I just learnt that the inimitable Clare Daly @ClareDalyMEP was not reelected to the European Parliament. It's a disappointment--but NOT a defeat. In fact, each "defeat" is a necessary stepping-stone on the road to victory:
"What does the entire history of socialism and of all modern revolutions show us? The first spark of class struggle in Europe, the revolt of the silk weavers in Lyon in 1831, ended with a heavy defeat; the Chartist movement in Britain ended in defeat; the uprising of the Parisian proletariat in the June days of 1848 ended with a crushing defeat; and the Paris commune ended with a terrible defeat. The whole road of socialism – so far as revolutionary struggles are concerned – is paved with nothing but thunderous defeats. Yet, at the same time, history marches inexorably, step by step, toward final victory! Where would we be today without those “defeats,” from which we draw historical experience, understanding, power and idealism? Today, as we advance into the final battle of the proletarian class war, we stand on the foundation of those very defeats; and we cannot do without any of them, because each one contributes to our strength and understanding." (Rosa Luxemburg, "Order Reigns in Berlin")
Two clenched fists (and a rose) to Red Clare!
www.youtube.com/watch?v=D-00DfluoNU -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
"Currently the only book on the invasion and genocide in Gaza" read Abraham Edward's review of DELUGE medium.com/@abrahamedwards/review-jamie-stern-weiners-del… @jsternweiner @MouinRabbani @normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein with India & Global Left: Discussion of his book on Gaza, Israel, Palestine, A... youtu.be/yPBAcXTB3OQ
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
An Oasis of Sanity in a Desert of Wokeness
I filled out today the US Census Bureau "American Community Survey." Question 3 reads:
What is Person's sex? Male Female Mark ONE box.
Not "gender", but SEX. Only TWO choices. You can choose only ONE box. It seems no one at the Census Bureau has read Judith Butler. Lucky them. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Mouin Rabbani, Briahna Joy Gray, and Norman Finkelstein come together to talk about the latest revelations from the Guardian and the status of accountability on Israel. Conversation happening here: www.youtube.com/live/fsO-XDdXARU
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Tonight at 5:30 PM (ET), Norman Finkelstein, Mouin Rabbani and Briahna Joy Gray will discuss the latest developments with the ICJ genocide case and the ICC indictments as well as the new bombshell report regarding Israel's attempts to threaten the former ICC prosecutor.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
THE BLIMP AND THE GALLOWS (29 May 2024)
Jeffrey Goldberg began his career as an accessory to torturing Palestinian detainees in an Israeli prison. He then moved on to greener pastures as Prime Minister Netanyahu’s stenographer in the US media, where, inter alia, he lobbied at the behest of Israel’s generals for a US attack on Iran. (Goldberg called it journalism.) He was simultaneously Obama’s favorite Court Jew, as each intuitively grasped that the other, although posing as deeply principled, was an opportunistic slimebucket. When Jews began souring on Israel as it aligned with Donald Trump, Goldberg checked out of Hotel Zion. Instead, the new Atlantic editor-in-chief went woke (alongside the Democratic Party) as he promoted on-the-make Black hipsters like Ta-Nehisi Coates (or “T”, as chill Jeff called him) and Ibram X. Kendi (whose dreads place-held for thought). Since October 7, a coterie of Upper East Side Jewish supremacist billionaires has been calling in its chips. The time is now—no ifs, ands or buts—to circle the wagons around the Jewish supremacist state. Or else. The endowment-conscious Ivy Leagues quickly got the message and so, it seems, has Goldberg. This circumcised blimp is ever cognizant of which side his bread is being buttered. In 2003 Atlantic published an article “proving” that 12-year-old Mohammed al-Dura was killed not by Israel but by Palestinians. Now Goldberg has published an article containing this pearl of wisdom per Gaza: “It is possible to kill children legally.” True enough. And Julius Streicher discovered at Nuremberg that it’s also possible to kill editors legally. Here’s wishing you a swinging future, Jeff. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Introducing Dr. Cornel West at a Harlem Rally in Support of His Presidential Campaign. Pictures by Abdalla Hassan.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
CONSPIRACIES DO HAPPEN
The British Guardian reported today that Israeli secret services were blackmailing former ICC Chief Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda. Already four years ago I wrote a full book documenting Bensouda’s disgraceful record of whitewashing Israel.
It was perfectly obvious at the time that extra-legal pressures were being exerted on Bensouda. Indeed, I stated in the very last sentence of my book that Israel was bringing “to bear every squalid and sordid instrument in its arsenal” against the ICC. It was also obvious that extra-legal pressures were exerted on Richard Goldstone to recant his milestone report on Israeli crimes in Gaza, even as “Goldstone’s secret will perhaps never be revealed” (from my book Gaza: An Inquest into Its Martyrdom). It is also my considered opinion that ICC Judge Peter Kovacs was subject to extra-legal pressures or enticements and current ICJ Vice-President Julia Sebutinde has been subject to extra-legal pressures or enticements by Israel. At the very least, Israel has assisted their whitewashing endeavors. (The flagrant, shameful and shameless lie that former ICJ president Joan Donaghue uttered on BBC last month—she purported that the ICJ did not find that Israel was “plausibly” committing genocide in Gaza--was morally debased but almost certainly traced back to careerism and opportunism, not Israeli dirty tricks.) One of the redemptive aspects of the current horrible moment is that a lot of the dirt is finally coming out. It was, for example, always assumed, but couldn’t be proven, that a class of Jewish supremacist billionaires acting at Israel’s behest were exerting financial pressures on academia. The machinations of the Ackmans, Krafts, Sternlichts et al. have now been exposed. If the Harvard Corporation wouldn’t let the 13 anti-genocide students attend graduation, was it not because “he who pays the piper calls the tune”? -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Wednesday 5/29 at 5:30 p.m. Eastern Time
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein and Mouin Rabbani are going to have a discussion on the ICJ and ICC cases on 'twitter spaces' on Wednesday 5/29 at 5:30 PM (eastern).
@normfinkelstein @MouinRabbani -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
"Everybody Knows": A song dedicated to Gaza youtu.be/8o_0Yj9SqK4 via @YouTube
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
THE WINNER IS...
A thousand thanks for your submissions to the lyrics contest. The concert artist, Christine Bovill, synthesized her version from the lyrics submitted by Chayim Lowen, Deborah Maccoby, and Tom Shaw. Here’s the final version:
youtu.be/8o_0Yj9SqK4
We will post on this Twitter (X) your renditions of the song (solo or choir). Just send the video to NormFinkelstein@gmail.com You can use Ms. Bovill’s version; Lowen, Maccoby, or Shaw’s version; or mix-and-match your own version.
EVERYBODY KNOWS
By Chayim Lowen
Everybody knows the death toll’s growing
Everybody’s lines in the sand are gone
Everybody sees the grass you’re mowing
In that morning-jog-by-a-marathon
Everywhere live-streamed suffering
The ICJ can’t do a thing
That's how it goes
Everybody knows
Everybody knows that the truth is leaking
Everybody knows that the media lied
Everybody knows what you’ve been seeking
Your goal was “transfer”, now it’s genocide!
Everybody talkin’ Hamas rockets
While Arab leaders are in US pockets
But up Yemen rose!
And everybody knows.
Everybody’s screaming “Antisemite!
Terrorist! Self-hating Jew!”
Everybody cares ‘bout 2 million lives
Oh, give or take a child or two
Everybody knows who’s footing the bill
But there are so many medics you just have to kill
With missiles and drones
Everybody knows
Everybody knows, everybody knows
That's how it goes
Everybody knows
Everybody knows, everybody knows
That's how it goes
Everybody knows
And everybody knows ‘bout the Samson option
Everybody knows you want WWIII
Everybody knows that this wild destruction
Is your deterrence capacity.
Everybody reads: stage 5 starvation
Genocide Joe’s at the ice cream station
But UNRWA you loathe
And everybody knows
And everybody knows that a change is comin’
Everybody knows it is student-led
Everybody sees the state repression
It’s “ceasefire now!” or we’ll all be dead
Everybody knows it starts at Hind’s Hall
Brick by brick, this apartheid will fall
Though progress is slow
Which everybody knows
And everybody knows that you're in trouble
Everybody knows what you've put us through
You’ve turned half of Gaza into rubble,
Now attacking Lebanon too.
Everybody knows it's nearing an end
All lunatic states, they follow a trend
And so it goes
Everybody knows
Everybody knows, everybody knows
That's how it goes
Everybody knows
Everybody knows, everybody knows
That's how it goes
Everybody knows
---
EVERYBODY KNOWS
By Deborah Maccoby
Everybody knows if you make a prison,
Everybody rolled in a tiny space,
Regularly kill them and block provision,
Everything’ll blow up in your face.
Everybody knows if you make a cage,
One day they’ll break that cage in rage.
That’s how it goes,
Everybody knows.
Everybody knows that kids are dying
Every day in Gaza’s killing fields.
Everybody knows that Israel’s lying.
Nobody is buying “human shields”.
No-one’s buying “anti-Jewish hate”;
Everybody sees in the Israeli State
Those who deal the blows,
And everybody knows.
Everybody knows that there’s mass starvation.
Everybody knows; they really do.
Everybody knows the real situation.
Nobody can say “I never knew”.
Everybody sees this genocide
On rolling news on screens worldwide,
And prime time shows.
Everybody knows.
Everybody knows
Everybody knows
That’s how it goes,
And everybody knows
Everybody knows
Everybody knows
That’s how it goes,
And everybody knows
Everybody knows through their media feeders,
Everybody scrolls through their Instagram.
Everybody’s worried among our leaders;
Everyone pretends to give a damn.
Every leader knows that there’s elections;
That’s why they’re raising some objections.
It’s just a pose,
And everybody knows.
Everybody fears that the conflict’s spreading,
Everybody fears that we’re going to hell,
Everybody fears we’re being led to Armageddon
By a lunatic state called Isra-el.
Everybody knows that the system’s fried;
Old Joe’s enabling genocide,
Reaching new lows,
And everybody knows.
And everybody knows that we’re all in trouble,
And everybody knows the only hope is in the youth
Who rise against Gaza’s and our system’s rubble,
In the name of justice and truth.
Everybody knows things are falling apart,
And the only hope is a change of heart.
As the movement grows,
Everybody knows.
Everybody knows
Everybody knows
That’s how it goes
Everybody knows
Everybody knows
Everybody knows
Everybody knows
That’s how it goes
Everybody knows
---
EVERYBODY KNOWS
By Tom Shaw
Everybody knows the guns were loaded
Everybody knows the crosshairs locked
Everybody knows the war ain’t over
Everybody knows that peace is blocked
Everybody knows the fight was fixed
But they still had to try save their kids
That’s how it goes
Everybody knows
Everybody knows their knees have bullets
Everybody knows the Iron Dome.
Everybody’s got that lonely feeling
Like their fathers when you took their homes.
Everybody asking for forgiveness
Everybody knows they’ll be in Heaven
Where a meadow grows
Everybody knows
Everybody knows you shot the babies
Everybody knows you make sure to
Everybody knows it ain’t about faith
But media won’t tell the truth
Everybody knows you’ve been discreet
For there were politicians you just had to meet
To buy their clothes
And everybody knows
Everybody knows
Everybody knows
That’s how it goes
Everybody knows
Everybody knows
Everybody knows
That’s how it goes
Everybody knows
Everybody knows it’s now or never
Everybody knows the end is due
Everybody knows you’ll fire forever
And the line of Netanyahu
Everybody knows you’ve all gone rotten
Sleepy Joe still funds the rockets
Though his people oppose
And everybody knows
Everybody knows there’s justice coming
Everybody knows it’s moving fast
Everybody knows the guilty men and women
Will be put behind the bars at last
Everybody knows that when it’s time
You’ll be weighed against the bombs you dropped
That will disclose
What everybody knows
And everybody knows you’ve been trouble
Everybody knows you’re losing grip
From the bloody corpses in the West Bank
To the beaches of the Gaza Strip
Everybody knows it’s coming apart
Take one last look at the children’s hearts
Before your blows
That everybody knows
Everybody knows
Everybody knows
That’s how it goes
Everybody knows
Everybody knows
Everybody knows
That’s how it goes
Everybody knows
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
CONTEST!!!
Who can come up with the best GAZA lyrics to go with this song? I will post the best submission sung by the original concert artist, Christine Bovill, on my social media, crediting the winner.
Send lyrics to normfinkelstein@gmail.comThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
NORMAN FINKELSTEIN:
I ACCUSE!
Norman Finklestein’s book casts a
forensic eye over the functioning of the
International Criminal Court’s treatment
of Israel. @normfinkelstein
orbooks.com/catalog/i-accuse/ -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein BLASTS "International Caucasian Court," Netanyahu Arrest Warrant Not Enough. youtu.be/75oar3KIz3U
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Put Dr. West on the Ballot! 👇
Let’s get Dr. Cornel West on the presidential ballot in New York! Only a few days left. Check out this link to see how you can collect petition signatures:
docs.google.com/document/d/1bXJw33-I3ZigyoiCkaUVoHXk5hxl5…
Download the New York ballot-access petition here: drive.google.com/file/d/1gM8BWYWKMMbOufzcT3hs35_weYUCW3el…
Get involved in securing ballot-access for Dr. Cornel West’s presidential campaign:
www.cornelwest2024.com
www.cornelwest2024.com/lwevents -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein Introduces Dr. Cornel West at a Harlem Rally in Support of His Presidential Campaign. Pictures by Abdalla Hassan.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
The whole Interview: Israel/Palestine: Asking The Questions No One Else Will - Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
youtu.be/vQMdUeEX4PI
Lord Bebo
@MyLordBebo
🇺🇸🇮🇱 Norman Finkelstein paints the picture of the current situation in Gaza.
Watch …This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
“The insinuation that Jewish donors secretly plotted to influence government operations is an all too familiar antisemitic trope that the Washington Post should be ashamed to ask about, let alone normalize in print” -- From a 3,000-word article in today's Washington Post ("Business titans privately urged NYC mayor to use police on Columbia protesters, chats show") documenting how a cabal of billionaire Jewish supremacists have plotted to crush academic freedom and freedom of speech in our country in order to abet the Jewish Supremacist State's genocide in Gaza. AM YISRAEL CHAI! SIEG HEIL!
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
INTERVIEW: Norman Finkelstein | The sickness of capitalism, Israel's war in Gaza & German complicity www.normanfinkelstein.com/interview-norman-finkelstein-th…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Genocide in Gaza? Why isn't the world doing anything to stop Israel? —Norman Finkelstein www.normanfinkelstein.com/genocide-in-gaza-why-isnt-the-w…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein Interviews with Piers Morgan (Five videos) www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-interviews-w…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
INTERVIEW: Norman Finkelstein | The sickness of capitalism, Israel's war in Gaza & German complicity
@normfinkelstein www.normanfinkelstein.com/interview-norman-finkelstein-th… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
CONTEST!!!
Who can come up with the best GAZA lyrics to go with this song? I will post the best submission sung by the original concert artist, Christine Bovill, on my social media, crediting the winner.
Send lyrics to normfinkelstein@gmail.comThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The dead can't be brought back to life. But it's still possible to save the living. President Biden announced today that he won’t supply certain weapons if Israel attacks Rafah. Even if this policy shift saves only one life: still, that one life might be your own. IT WAS PRIMARILY THE STUDENT DEMONSTRATIONS THAT FORCED THIS CHANGE. Let it weigh heavily on the conscience of every university president contemplating the expulsion of these students: YOU ARE PUNISHING YOUNG PEOPLE WHO HAVE SAVED LIVES THAT, BUT FOR THE GRACE OF GOD, MIGHT HAVE BEEN YOUR OWN.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Cornel West
@CornelWest
Norman Finkelstein Endorses Cornel West for President 2024
I deeply thank my dear brother and comrade Norman Finkelstein for his endorsement! He is one of the most erudite and courageous scholars alive! ~Cornel West
@normfinkelstein
#truthjusticelove
#cornelwest2024 -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Al Mayadeen English
@MayadeenEnglish
Norman Finkelstein, political scientist and activist, discusses the systematic usage of antisemitisim as a pretext to suppress the students' protest against the Israeli genocide in American universities.
#gazasolidarityencampmentThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Al Mayadeen English
@MayadeenEnglish
American political scientist and activist Norman Finkelstein explains the differences between today's protests in American universities across the #us and anti-war protests in the US during the #vietnam War.
@normfinkelsteinThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
"It is testament to the majesty of these young people that they have risked their futures for the sake of a poor, powerless people halfway around the world in order to uphold that sacred principle that every life is worthy and the murder of none shall pass in silence.'
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Today marks a historic occasion. By seizing control of Hamilton Hall, students at Columbia University have anchored in historical memory the nexus between the horrors inflicted in Vietnam that was the hallmark of my generation with the horrors inflicted in Gaza that is the hallmark of the new generation. It is testament to the majesty of these young people that they have risked their futures for the sake of a poor, powerless people halfway around the world in order to uphold that sacred principle that every life is worthy and the murder of none shall pass in silence. As Abraham Lincoln famously quoted, "The judgments of the Lord are true and righteous altogether." The right of the people of Gaza to live is an eternal truth. May the young soldiers in Hamilton Hall be honored and blessed for not countenancing, come what may, its extinguishment.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Today marks a historic occasion. By seizing control of Hamilton Hall, students at Columbia University have anchored in historical memory the nexus between the horrors inflicted in Vietnam that was the hallmark of my generation with the horrors inflicted in Gaza that is the hallmark of the new generation. It is testament to the majesty of these young people that they have risked their futures for the sake of a poor, powerless people halfway around the world in order to uphold that sacred principle that every life is worthy and the murder of none shall pass in silence. As Abraham Lincoln famously quoted, "The judgments of the Lord are true and righteous altogether." The right of the people of Gaza to live is an eternal truth. May the young soldiers in Hamilton Hall be honored and blessed for not countenancing, come what may, its extinguishment.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
"A Brief History of Palestine" by the one and only Norman Finkelstein @normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein on Israel Palestine youtu.be/gu4OMmoo5mw -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Don't Lecture the People of Gaza! They tried nonviolence: "The Great March of Return" that began on March 30, 2018. What Happened? Israeli snipers along the perimeter fence day after day shot them dead, and the world stayed silent. May God bless the people of Gaza! This video was posted six years ago today.
youtu.be/gup3tx8ngx0 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Benny Morris: They Had It Coming (April 22, 2024)
In a new article, Israeli historian-turned-state-propagandist Benny Morris chastises the hypocrisy of Recep Tayyip Erdogan: the Turkish president deplores Israel’s “genocide” in Gaza yet denies the atrocities that Muslim Turks committed against Greeks, Armenians, Assyrians, and Kurds circa the early 20th century. (He also takes note of Erdogan’s current “cultural repression” of Turkish Kurds and the bloody war he has been waging against Kurdish armed forces in neighboring countries.) (“Erdogan’s Hypocrisy,” 22 April 2024*) No doubt, such rank hypocrisy deserves condemnation. It is no less true, however, that a public personality’s denial of a past genocide pales in moral culpability beside denial in the face of an ongoing genocide, when openly expressing outrage at an infamy in progress can literally be a matter of life and death for the victims. Consider this case in point. Mouin Rabbani and I recently participated in a debate** during which Professor Morris cavalierly denied the imminence of mass famine in Gaza and Israel’s hand in engineering it. Here’s the official transcript:
Benny Morris—There’s no genocide.
Norman Finkelstein— … half of whom are children… Yeah, according to the most current UN reports, as of today-
Benny Morris—There’s no genocide.
Norman Finkelstein—… one quarter of the population of Gaza-
Benny Morris—Is starving.
Norman Finkelstein— That means 500,000 children-
Benny Morris—Are starving,
Norman Finkelstein— … are on the verge of famine.
Benny Morris—They keep saying on the verge of. Steven Bonnell: On the verge of. Didn’t you quote that they said it was unlivable?
Benny Morris—I have not seen one Palestinian die of starvation in these last four months. Not one.
Mouin Rabbani—There have been documented cases.
Benny Morris—They are always on the verge. They’re on the verge.
Mouin Rabbani—have been documented cases.
Benny Morris—I haven’t seen any.
Steven Bonnell—Yesterday Al Jazeera said six, and the day before that they said two, so those are the two.
Benny Morris—That number probably dies in Israel of starvation also.
Mouin Rabbani—I don’t think there’s famine in Israel.
Norman Finkelstein—You’re so laid back, so blasé.
Benny Morris—There isn’t. There isn’t in the Gaza Strip either. It’s something which is produced for the Western-
Norman Finkelstein—“I haven’t seen any starving children yet.”
Mouin Rabbani— There are infants dying due to a engineered lack of access to food and nutrition.
Benny Morris—I don’t think it’s engineered, I think that if the Hamas stopped shooting perhaps, or-
Norman Finkelstein—Unfortunately, most-
Mouin Rabbani—As I said, engineered.
Norman Finkelstein—I think Human Rights Watch called it using starvation as a weapon. That’s called engineering.
Today, B’Tselem (Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories) issued a report, “Manufacturing Famine: Israel is Committing the War Crime of Starvation in the Gaza Strip,” that confirms what has already been widely documented. It finds that “for months, Israel has been committing the crime of starvation under international law in the Gaza Strip.” It further finds that, under the terms of the Rome Statute, Israel is culpable of the “war crime” of “starvation,” as it has intentionally (mens rea) engineered a famine (actus reus) in Gaza:
“[F]or many months, Israel has prevented the required scope of humanitarian relief, including food and medicines, from entering the Gaza Strip and particularly northern Gaza. The destruction that Israel sowed during the fighting has all but obliterated the ability to locally grow food or source it for production. Given these circumstances, the population’s diet relies almost entirely on outside aid, which is controlled by Israel. ... Israel is failing to meet its obligations ... by not allowing sufficient aid to enter the Gaza Strip and by failing to guarantee the safe arrival of the aid to its destination, even in areas it says are under its control.”
“Israel’s intent to use starvation in order to gain a military advantage is reflected in statements made by senior politicians and military commanders, that denying residents food and water is part of Israel’s methods of warfare in the Gaza Strip. For example, Minister of Defense Yoav Gallant, a member of the war cabinet, which is the highest forum directing Israel’s policy in its war in Gaza, explicitly stated that denying food and water is part of the fighting: ‘We are imposing a full siege on Gaza City. There is no electricity, no food, no water, no fuel. Everything is closed. We are fighting beasts and we are acting accordingly.’ Minister of National Security Itamar Ben Gvir tied efforts to release the Israeli hostages to preventing humanitarian aid from entering Gaza: ‘As long as Hamas refuses to release the hostages it is holding, the only thing that should enter Gaza is hundreds of tons of Air Force explosives, and not a gram of humanitarian relief.’ Foreign Minister Yisrael Katz said: ‘For years, we’ve given Gaza electricity, water and fuel. Instead of thanking us, they sent thousands of beasts to butcher, rape and kidnap babies, women and elderly people. That is why we decided to stop the supply of water, electricity and fuel, and now their local power plant has collapsed and there’s no electricity in Gaza. We will continue to tighten the siege until the threat that Hamas poses to Israel and to the world is removed. The past will not be the future.’”
It should finally be noted that decriers of the South African genocide application to the International Court of Justice have alleged that the case mounted by South Africa was defective as it didn’t prove criminal intent to commit genocide. For example, it’s purported that Prime Minister Netanyahu’s allusions to “Amalek” were distorted. Thus Morris: “The prime minister didn’t say genocide.” Here, however, is B’Tselem’s gloss:
“‘The current war against the Hamas murderers is another chapter in the story of our national resilience through the generations. Remember what Amalek did to you.’ That is what Binyamin Netanyahu wrote in a message to Israeli soldiers on 3 November 2023, in a dog whistle that anyone who has gone through Israel’s education system will recognize as meaning a response to an attack in a way that would obliterate any memory of that nation, women and children included. When the fight against Hamas is compared to the war against Amalek, the conclusion is clear: The order is to wipe out Gaza.”
In other words, “the conclusion is clear” that Netanyahu’s Amalek allusion evidences criminal intent to commit genocide. But according to Morris, even if Netanyahu did target Gaza’s civilian population for annihilation, that wouldn’t quite constitute genocide as these noncombatants aren’t innocent: “Gaza’s civilian population ... is largely sympathetic to Hamas’s actions and goals, which include the destruction of Israel. In going after the Hamas units, the IDF inevitably killed many non-combatants. They died in a war initiated by Hamas.” That is, standing not just before but also behind Hamas, Gazan civilians have it coming if they’re wiped out. Doesn’t only a flea’s hop separate Morris’s palliation of Israeli genocide from a full-blown apologia for it? If Erdogan is a genocide denier, then Morris is his doppelganger.
*quillette.com/2024/04/22/erdogan-the-hypocrite-turkey-isr…
**lexfridman.com/israel-palestine-debate-transcript/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Arabic Translation of "Samson and Cassandra"
Translator: Aiman Haddad
شمشون وكاساندرا (16 نيسان/ أبريل 2024)
أخبرتني والدتي يوماً ما قصة امرأة ضامرة في غيتو وارسو كانت تنوح من نافذة زنزانتها بأن جميع اليهود في الغيتو سيُقتلون. وباتت تُلقّب بكاساندرا، على اسم نبيّة المصير القاتم في الأساطير اليونانية. وافترض الجميع أنها مجنونة. وتأملَتْ والدتي في الأمر لاحقاً وقالت إن تلك المرأة استشرفت الحقيقة بطريقة ما: فلم يكن ما يجري هو "إعادة توطين" لليهود في شرق أوروبا؛ بل كانوا يُنقلون لمواجهة الموت.
لقد بقيتُ متردداً لغاية الآن في قرع جرس الإنذار. لكني أجد لزاماً عليّ، ومن دافع المسؤولية السياسية، ورغم الخطر بأنني سأُدعى مجنوناً، أن أقول علناً: إسرائيل تندفع نحو الهاوية وتجر بقية العالم معها.
يجب أن يبدأ أي تحليل عقلاني للمأزق الحالي بالحقيقة الثابتة التالية: إسرائيل هي دولة مجنونة، وليست مجرد "جهة فاعلة سيئة"، أو نظام "عاصٍ"، بل دولة مجنونة. إن الطيف الكامل لآراء النخبة الإسرائيلية، والتي تعكس الآراء السائدة في المجتمع الإسرائيلي بمجمله (الذي يدعم بأغلبية كاسحة حرب الإبادة الجماعية في غزة؛ فلم يرفض الخدمة العسكرية سوى حفنة من الإسرائيليين)، لا يتسع أكثر من أنملة:
فعلى أحد قطبي هذا الطيف يقف "الواقعيون المخبولون"، الذين كتب عنهم عالم الاجتماع سي. رايت ميلز في السياق الأمريكي: "لقد باتوا يعتقدون بأنه ليس هناك ... حل آخر سوى الحرب، حتى عندما يشعرون بأن الحرب لن تحل شيئاً ... وهم ما زالوا يعتقدون بأن ’الانتصار‘ يعني شيئاً، رغم أنهم لم يخبرونا قط ما يعنيه".[1] ينتمي البروفيسور بيني موريس تماماً إلى هذه الطينة، فهو دمث، ومتعلم، وعلماني—ومخبول. حتى أنه "أثبت" في إحدى المرات بأن الإسرائيليين اليهود لا يمكن أن يتعايشوا مع الفلسطينيين البرابرة بناء على مجموعة من الإحصاءات من بينها العدد الأكبر من حوادث السيارات التي يتسبب فيها الفلسطينيون![2] ويحث موريس الولايات المتحدة أن تنضم إلى إسرائيل في مهاجمة إيران، وبعد ذلك يتوعد بأنه إذا لم تكن الولايات المتحدة على قدر هذه المسؤولية، فستقوم إسرائيل بالمهمة لوحدها وتهاجم إيران بالأسلحة النووية. لا بد أنه يدرك إذ يعرض مبتهجاً مثل هذه المشورة بأن مثل هذا الهجوم لن يؤدي فقط إلى حرق عشرات ملايين الإيرانيين—وهو يعتقد أنهم يستحقون هذا المصير—بل سيثير أيضاً انتقاماً فتاكاً. فحزب الله اللبناني لوحده يملك، حسب المزاعم، 150,000 صاروخ. ويشبه الأمر حكم إعدام متبادل، لكن لا يبدو أن هذه الآفاق تثبط همة موريس ولو قليلاً.
وعلى القطب الآخر من الطيف يقف مجانين بلغوا آخر مصاف الجنون—أو أولئك الذين على بعد خطوة واحدة من تلك العتبة. وكان تشومسكي قد علّق بما يشبه النبوءة قبل أربعة عقود، "إن الخطر الأكبر الذي يواجه إسرائيل اليوم هو ’النسخة الجماعية‘ من انتقام شمشون من الفلسطينيين—’لتمت نفسي مع الفلسطينيين‘—إذ هدم المعبد على رؤوس من فيه". أما المُستنسَخون الحاليون عن شمشون ممن يتحصنون في القدس فإما بلغوا مبلغ الجنون—"يجب أن نقتل الأغراب [الأمم غير اليهودية] من حولنا وندفنهم بينما نموت نحن معهم"—أو إنهم يتظاهرون "بالجنون" لإثارة الهلع في قلوب أعدائهم وحلفائهم على حدٍ سواء ليخضعوا لهم. يجب الإشارة إلى أن الجنون الزائف قد يتحول بسهولة إلى جنون حقيقي إذ تأخذ الأشباح المتخيلة التي يستحضرها المرء تتسرب إلى أعماق عقله. والنتيجة هي أن هذا الجنوب، سواء أكان حقيقياً أم
مختلقاً، "يجعل الحسابات العقلانية ... أمراً مشكوكاً فيه" إذ أن إسرائيل "قد تتصرف بأسلوب ما أُطلق عليه أحياناً ’الدول المجنونة‘".[3] وثمة تقرير في صحيفة يوم أمس يبين في الوقت الحقيقي هذه النزعة الإسرائيلية من الهياج المعتوه: فعندما نصح مسؤول إسرائيلي رفيع بوجوب توخي الحذر، وإن يكون على المدى القصير فقط، بعد الانتقام الإيراني الرمزي، طالب وزير من اليمين المتطرف، على العكس من ذلك، أن تتصرف إسرائيل "بجنون".[4]
*
عقد مجلس الأمن الدولي جلسة طارئة في 14 نيسان/ أبريل تحدث فيها ممثل إسرائيل، جلعاد إردان، ويبين ما قاله مدى الجنون الذي يحيق بإسرائيل. ويمثل ما طرحه إردان—إذا كان خالياً من أي قيمة أخرى—درساً في الإسقاط التقريبي للدوافع الذاتية على الآخرين، فقد بدا مقتنعاً قناعة تامة بالإسقاط الذي تفوه به "أن النظام الإسلامي الموجود اليوم هو .... غير مختلف عن الرايخ الثالث الذي أقامه هتلر ... ومثل النظام النازي تماماً، يبذر نظام آية الله الموت والدمار في كل مكان ... فمنذ سنوات، ظل العالم يشاهد صعود هذا الرايخ الإسلامي الشيعي، تماماً مثل ما حدث أثناء صعود النازية، وظل العالم صامتاً"؛ وأنه "يجب إيقاف الطموحات الإيرانية بالهيمنة على العالم قبل أن تدفع العالم إلى نقطة اللاعودة، وإلى حرب إقليمية يمكن أن تتصاعد إلى حرب عالمية"؛ وأن إيران "تنطلق بسرعة نحو تكوين قدرات نووية ... وبات الوقت اللازم لها حالياً لإنتاج ترسانة من الأسلحة النووية أسابيع فقط، مجرد أسابيع". وإذا لم يكبح العالم جماح إيران، فليس أمام إسرائيل حينها سوى تحمل هذا العبء الهائل لوحدها لإيقاف الرايخ الثالث لهتلر: "نحن نواجه إطلاق نيران من جميع الجبهات، ومن جميع الحدود، ونحن محاطون بعملاء الإرهاب الإيراني ... وجميع الجماعات الإرهابية التي تهاجم إسرائيل هي أذرع للأخطبوط الشيعي نفسه. لذا فإنني أسألكم، وأرجو أن تكونوا صادقين مع أنفسكم، ما الذي كنتم ستفعلونه لو كنتم مكاننا؟ وما الذي كنتم ستفعلونه لو كنتم تواجهون الظرف الذي تواجهه إسرائيل؟ وكيف ستستجيبون إذا كان وجودكم مهدداً في كل يوم؟ لا يمكن لإسرائيل أن تقف ساكنة، ونحن سندافع عن مستقبلنا". ورفع إردان جهازه اللوحي الإلكتروني الذي يُظهر صورة زعم أنها تبيّن اعتراض إسرائيل لمسيرات إيرانية فوق المسجد الأقصى، وادعى لإسرائيل عباءة الحامي الحقيقي للأماكن الإسلامية المقدسة من الذين دنسوها من طهران—"انظروا إلى مقطع الفيديو هذا الذي يُظهر كيف اعترضت إسرائيل مسيرات إيرانية فوق جبل الهيكل والمسجد الأقصى". وكانت النبرة التي تبناها في خطابه وكأنه يوجه اتهاماً متحدياً، من يجرؤ على الشك بما أقوله؟! واستذكر إردان، "في كل خطاب ألقيه وفي رسائل لا حصر لها، قرعت جرس الإنذار بخصوص إيران". لقد كان محقاً في قرع جرس الإنذار؛ ولكنه أخطأ في تعيين المكان الذي ينبثق منه الجنون. أيها الطبيب، اشفِ نفسك [باللاتينية في الأصل]. وإذا كان إردان يمثل ولو نصف دولة إسرائيل والمجتمع الإسرائيلي—ويمكن إقامة حجة بأن النسبة أكبر بكثير من ذلك—فثمة كارثة تلوح بالأفق. ومن الصحيح أن القادة الإسرائيليين أعربوا سابقاً عن تصريحات مخبولة تماماً، ويكفي هنا أن نتذكر رئيس الوزراء نتنياهو عندما حمل رسماً سخيفاً في الأمم المتحدة يصور قنبلة إيرانية نووية، وتصريحه بأن هتلر لم يكن العقل المدبر وراء الحل النهائي [بإبادة اليهود] بل مفتي القدس الفلسطيني. وفي الواقع منذ مفاوضات كامب ديفيد في عام 1978 تأمّل الرئيس كارتر بشأن رئيس دولة إسرائيل وقال، "لقد بات من الأوضح أن عقلانية [مناحيم] بيغن هي في موضع شك".[5] مع ذلك ثمة قفزة حضارية إلى الخلف تفصل بين ما كانت عليه إسرائيل يوماً ما عمّا باتت عليه حالياً. فقد كان بوسع
ممثل إسرائيل في الأمم المتحدة في وقت حرب عام 1967 ("الأيام الستة")، إيبا إيبان، أن يراوغ مرة تلو المرة دون أن يرف له جفن، وإن يكن ببلاغة بارعة كما يليق بخريج متفوق من جامعة كامبريدج. ولكن كان من الممكن تحليل طروحاته لإثبات خطئها (كما سعى كاتب هذه السطور للقيام بذلك سابقاً).[6] أما إمكانية تحليل خطاب إردان فليست أفضل من إمكانية تحليل تبرّمات شخص مضطرب عقلياً.
*
قد يرغب المرء أن يحث إيران على التصرف بحذر كي لا تثير الدولة المجنونة، لكن ذلك، وللأسف، ليس خياراً ممكناً، حسبما أرى. فالسجل الوثائقي يوضح أنه عندما تستهدف إسرائيل بلداً ما، فما من شيء يدفعها للكف عما تنوي عليه سوى الخضوع التام من قبل البلد المستهدف. وإذا قاومت القوة "العدوة" الاستفزازات الأولية، ستواصل إسرائيل التصعيد باستفزاز إثر الآخر حتى يصبح من غير الممكن سياسياً للكيان المستهدف امتصاص المزيد من اللطمات. فذلك هو ما حدث عندما استهدفت إسرائيل مصر في عهد جمال عبد الناصر في بدايات عقد الخمسينيات من القرن العشرين.[7] (كان رئيس الوزراء الإسرائيلي آنذاك، ديفيد بن غوريون، يخشى من أن الرئيس المصري "القومي الراديكالي" قد يصبح يوماً ما حاكماً لدولة عصرية قادرة على لجم الطموحات الإقليمية لإسرائيل). وهذا ما جرى أيضاً عندما استهدفت إسرائيل منظمة التحرير الفلسطينية في لبنان في بدايات عقد الثمانينيات من القرن العشرين.[8] (كان رئيس الوزراء الإسرائيلي آنذاك، مناحيم بيغن، يخشى من أن "هجوم السلام" الذي انتهجته منظمة التحرير الفلسطينية—إذ دعم الفلسطينيون تسوية على أساس حل الدولتين فيما رفضتها إسرائيل—سيتسبب بفرض ضغوطات دولية على إسرائيل للانسحاب من الضفة الغربية). وهذا ما جرى أيضاً في عام 2002 أثناء الانتفاضة الثانية عندما نفذت إسرائيل عمليات اغتيال مستهدفة ضد القادة الفلسطينيين.[9] (كان رئيس الوزراء الإسرائيلي آنذاك، أريئيل شارون، يخشى من أن الفلسطينيين سيوقفون الهجمات المسلحة مقابل التوصل إلى وقف لإطلاق النار عبر التفاوض). وهذا ما جرى أيضاً في عام 2008 عندما خرقت إسرائيل اتفاق وقف إطلاق النار مع حركة حماس من أجل إطلاق ’عملية الرصاص المصبوب‘.[10] (كان رئيس الوزراء الإسرائيلي آنذاك، إيهود أولمرت، يخشى من أن حماس ستكتسب شرعية دولية إذ عكفت على إضفاء الاعتدال على برنامجها السياسي). والحقيقة المؤسفة هي أنه، فيما عدا ارتكاب الانتحار الوطني، لا يتوفر لإيران أي خيار آخر للإحجام عن المواجهة: فمن المحتم تقريباً أن إسرائيل ستواصل تصعيد استفزازاتها حتى لا يبقى أي خيار لطهران سوى الرد. ولن يكون أمراً مفاجئاً أن تغتال إسرائيل آية الله خامينئي ثم تنكر قيامها بذلك مع إصدار تلميحات هنا وهناك بأنها فعلت ذلك.
*
لقد ظلت الحكومة الإسرائيلية متيقظة دائماً لاستغلال الفرص من أجل تنفيذ خططها المعدة مسبقاً. ففي عام 1989، أثناء مذبحة ميدان تيانانمين، حث بنيامين نتنياهو حكومته لاستغلال انشغال وسائل الإعلام بهذا الأمر وتنفيذ طرد جماعي للفلسطينيين من الضفة الغربية. وفي 4 تشرين الثاني/ نوفمبر 2008، عندما انتخبت الولايات المتحدة أول رئيس أسود البشرة في تاريخها، استغل رئيس الوزراء أولمرت الانشغال
الإعلامي بهذا الأمر ليخرق اتفاق وقف إطلاق النار مع حركة حماس. وفي 17 تموز/ يوليو 2014، عندما أُسقطت طائرة ماليزية مدنية فوق أوكرانيا، استغل رئيس الوزراء نتنياهو انشغال وسائل الإعلام بهذا الأمر بأن شن اجتياحاً برياً فتاكاً في غزة خلال عملية الدرع الواقي. وثمة فرصة غير مسبوقة للمجانين في القدس لتخليص إسرائيل من تحدي ثلاثي لسيطرتها الإقليمية، وهي فرصة وفرتها ذريعة 7 تشرين الأول/ أكتوبر، والآن "الانتقام" الإيراني: وذلك لتدمير غزة، وحزب الله، وإيران؛ وستتمكن إسرائيل أيضاً وسط "ضباب" مثل هذا الانفجار من تنفيذ تطهير عرقي في الضفة الغربية. وإذا كان ثمة أمل بأن عصبة من الأشخاص في القيادة الإسرائيلية ستتبلور لإيقاف الاندفاع نحو الهاوية، فلا بد من القول إن فرص حدوث ذلك ضئيلة. وكان كاتب سيرة هتلر، إيان كيرشو، قد أشار إلى أن سبب مرور وقت طويل قبل إعداد خطط انقلاب ضد الفوهرر هي وجود "شعور عميق بطاعة السلطة وخدمة الدولة" اعتقاداً بأنه "ليس خطأ فقط، بل خسة وخيانة أن يعمل المرء على تقويض بلده أثناء حرب"، و "حتى مع تعاظم الكوارث العسكرية واقتراب وقوع الكارثة المطلقة، لم يتبخر التأييد المتعصب لهتلر بأي حال من الأحول، بل استمر وإن يكن على شكل توجه من قبل أقلية من الناس، وذلك رغبة منهم بإظهار قوة ذاتية مذهلة وقدرة على التحمل".[11] من الصعب ألا نلاحظ عوامل مشابهة قيد العمل حالياً في أوساط النخبة الإسرائيلية. وبخصوص هذه النقطة الأخيرة، بينما ظل ناقدو نتنياهو يبشرون بنهايته السياسية منذ سنوات، فقد ظل ينهض من جديد على الرغم من عثراته. لماذا؟ لأن الإسرائيليين يرون انعكاسهم فيه. بل إن نتنياهو هو إسرائيل: شخص بغيض وأناني ومناصر لفكرة تفوق اليهود على سائر الأعراق، ولا يرى أي اعتبار سوى لليهود في الترتيب الإلهي العام لشؤون الدنيا. يجب الإقرار، أخيراً، بأن ليس كل ما يخشاه الإسرائيليون لا أساس له—فثمة رغبة واسعة النطاق الآن بأن تختفي إسرائيل عن الخريطة، بينما تضاءلت قدرتها على بث الرعب في قلوب جيرانها لإخضاعهم. ولكن إسرائيل تتحمل الوزر الأكبر عن حشر نفسها في هذا الموقف. فقبل 7 كانون الأول/ أكتوبر، أومأت حماس نحو قبولها بالتسوية على أساس إقامة دولتين، كما ظلت إيران تصوت باستمرار مع غالبية أعضاء الجمعية العامة للأمم المتحدة دعماً للإجماع الدولي حول حل النزاع على أساس إقامة دولتين. ولكن إسرائيل رفضت ذلك.
هل سيقاوم رئيس الوزراء نتنياهو الإغراء الذي لا يُقاوم بحل العقدة الإقليمية المستعصية باستخدام القوة الغاشمة وجر العالم لما لا تُحمد عقباه، أم سيقوم، مثل شمشون، بهدم المعبد على رأس كل من فيه ويدمرنا ويدمر نفسه؟ ربما كانت كاساندرا ستقول: كل شيء ممكن!
المراجع:
[1] ميلز، ’أسباب الحرب العالمية الثالثة‘.
[2] موريس، ’دولة واحدة، دولتان‘.
[3] تشومسكي، ’المثلث الرهيب‘. أسهب الصحفي الاستقصائي سيمور هيرش لاحقاً بشأن الرؤى التي أعرب عنها تشومسكي بخصوص خيار شمشون.
[4] صحيفة ’نيويورك تايمز‘، 15 نيسان/ أبريل 2024.
[5] كارتر، ’مذكرات البيت الأبيض‘.
[6] فنكلستين، ’الحقيقة والخيال في النزاع الإسرائيلي-الفلسطيني‘.
[7] بيني موريس، ’الحروب الحدودية‘.
[8] روبرت فيسك، ’ويل لأمة‘.
[9] نورمان فنكلستين، ’ما يفوق الوقاحة‘.
[10] نورمان فنكلستين، ’غزة‘.
[11] كيرشو، ’هتلر، 1936-1945‘. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Dr. Finkelstein speaking to students at Columbia University on Friday, April 19. He will be giving a formal presentation at Columbia's SIPA school on Monday, April 22.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Palestine Talks | Norman Finkelstein youtu.be/AOdRk7Wptjg
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
"The full range of Israeli elite opinion, itself reflective of Israeli society at large (which overwhelmingly supports the genocidal war in Gaza; only a handful of Israelis have refused to serve), spans a mere flea’s hop"
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
SAMSON AND CASSANDRA (April 16, 2024)
My Mother once told me the story of an emaciated woman in the Warsaw Ghetto who would wail from her window sill that all the Jews in the ghetto would be killed. She came to be called Cassandra, after the prophetess of doom in Greek mythology. Everyone just assumed that she was mad. My Mother speculated in retrospect that somehow she had become privy to the truth: Jews weren’t being “relocated” in the East; they were being transported to their deaths.
I have hesitated thus far to sound the alarm. But at the risk of being thought mad, it must, as an act of political responsibility, be said out loud: Israel is hurling toward the precipice and dragging the rest of the world with it.
A rational analysis of the current predicament must begin with this bedrock fact: Israel is a crazy state. Not a “bad actor.” Not a “rogue” regime. A crazy state. The full range of Israeli elite opinion, itself reflective of Israeli society at large (which overwhelmingly supports the genocidal war in Gaza; only a handful of Israelis have refused to serve), spans a mere flea’s hop:
AT ONE POLE stand “crackpot realists,” of whom sociologist C. Wright Mills wrote in the American context: “they have come to believe that there ... is no other solution but war, even when they sense that war can be a solution to nothing ... they still believe that ‘winning’ means something, although they never tell us what.” (1) Professor Benny Morris is cut squarely from this mold. He is urbane, educated, secular—and a crackpot. He once even “proved” that Israeli Jews couldn’t coexist with barbarian Palestinians by inter alia mustering stats on how many more road accidents Palestinians got into! (2) Morris exhorts the US to join in an attack on Iran and then rattles the threat that if Washington doesn’t rise to the occasion, Israel will go it alone by nuking Iran. He must be cognizant as he breezily proffers such counsel that an attack would not only incinerate tens of millions of Iranians—he reckons they have it coming—but also trigger a terminal retaliation. Hezbollah alone is alleged to possess 150,000 missiles. It’s a circuitous auto-da-fé. That prospect, however, doesn’t appear to faze Morris one bit.
AT THE OTHER POLE stand full-blown crazies—or those just one step short of this threshold. “The greatest danger facing Israel right now,” Noam Chomsky presciently observed already four decades ago, “is the ‘collective version’ of Samson’s revenge against the Philistines—‘Let me perish with the Philistines’—as he brought down the Temple in ruins.” The Samson clones ensconced in Jerusalem have either already gone mad—“we shall kill and bury the Gentiles around us while we ourselves shall die with them”—or pretend to “go crazy” so as to terrify enemies and allies alike into submission. Feigned lunacy, be it noted, easily transmutes into the real thing as the imaginary phantoms one repeatedly conjures seep into the psyche’s inner chambers. The upshot is that this madness, real or contrived, “renders rational calculations ... questionable” as Israel “may behave in the manner of what have sometimes been called ‘crazy states.’” (3) A report in yesterday’s paper fleshes out in real time this Israeli propensity to unhinged outbursts: when one senior Israeli official counseled caution, if only in the immediate term, after Iran’s symbolic retaliation, a far-right cabinet minister demanded on the contrary that Israel go “crazy.” (4)
*
The April 14 speech at the Security Council emergency session by Israel’s representative, Gilad Erdan, brought home just how lunatic Israel has become. Presenting a master class in—if nothing else—proximate projection, Erdan was seemingly persuaded to the bone of his being that “the Islamic regime of today is ... no different than Adolf Hitler’s Third Reich.... Just like the Nazi regime, the Ayatollah regime sows death and destruction everywhere.... For years, the world has watched the rise of this Shite Islamist Reich, yet just like during the rise of Nazism, the world has been silent”; that “Iran’s hegemonic ambitions of global domination must be stopped before it drives the world to a point of no return, to a regional war that can escalate to a world war”; that Iran was “barreling towards nuclear capabilities ... its breakout time to produce an arsenal of nuclear weapons is now weeks, mere weeks.” If the world didn’t rein in Iran, then Israel had no recourse except to bear this crushing burden on its own of stopping Hitler’s Third Reich: “We are being fired upon from all fronts, from every border. We are surrounded by Iran’s terror proxies.... All of the terror groups attacking Israel are tentacles of the same Shiite octopus, the Iranian octopus. So, I ask you, and be honest with yourselves, what would you do? What would you do if you were in Israel’s shoes? How would you react if your existence was threatened every single day? Israel cannot settle for inaction. We will defend our future.” Holding up his iPad to display an image of Israel allegedly intercepting an Iranian drone over al-Aqsa mosque, Erdan even claimed for Israel the mantle of the true guardian of Islam’s holy sites—“look at this video that shows how Israel intercepts Iranian drones above the Temple Mount and al-Aqsa mosque”—against the defilers of them in Teheran. The tonal register of his rhetorical delivery was as if a defiant accusation, Who dares doubt me?! “In every speech and in countless letters,” Erdan further recalled, “I rang the warning bell regarding Iran.” He got right that the bell must be sounded; but he got wrong from whence the madness emanates. Medice, cura te ipsum. If Erdan represents even half of the Israeli state and society—the fraction is arguably much higher—a catastrophe looms. True, Israeli leaders have in the past uttered certifiable lunacies. It is sufficient to recall Prime Minister Netanyahu holding up a Loony Tunes-like cartoon of the Iranian bomb at the UN and his pronouncement that it was not Hitler but the Palestinian Mufti of Jerusalem who masterminded the Final Solution. Indeed, already as far back as the 1978 Camp David negotiations, President Carter mused about Israel’s head of state, “It’s becoming clearer that the rationality of [Menachem] Begin is in doubt.” (5) All the same, a civilizational leap backwards separates the Israel that once was from what it has become. Israel’s UN representative at the time of the 1967 (“Six-Day”) war, Abba Eban, could serially prevaricate—albeit with consummate eloquence, as befitted the triple-first graduate of Cambridge—without batting an eyelash. But still, it was possible to rationally parse his propositions (as I once endeavored) to prove them wrong. (6) It is no more possible to parse Erdan’s speech than a psychopath’s rant.
*
It might be urged upon Iran to tread lightly so as not to agitate the lunatic in the room. But alas, that is not, in my opinion, a viable option. The documentary record demonstrates that, once Israel has fixed a country in its crosshairs, nothing short of abject submission will bring it to desist. If the “enemy” power resists initial provocation, Israel will keep escalating with another and another provocation until it proves politically untenable for the targeted entity to passively absorb further blows. That’s what happened when Israel targeted Egypt’s Gamel Abdel Nasser in the early 1950s. (7) (It was feared by Israeli Prime Minister Ben-Gurion that the “radical nationalist” Egyptian president might one day preside over a modern state able to check Israel’s regional ambitions.) That’s what happened when Israel targeted the Palestine Liberation Organization in Lebanon in the early 1980s. (8) (It was feared by Israeli Prime Minister Begin that the PLO’s “peace offensive”—the Palestinians supported but Israelis opposed a two-state settlement—would bring international pressure on Israel to withdraw from the West Bank.) That’s what happened in 2002 during the second intifada when Israel carried out targeted assassinations of Palestinian leaders. (9) (It was feared by Prime Minister Sharon that the Palestinians would stop armed attacks in exchange for a negotiated ceasefire.) That’s what happened in 2008 when Israel broke a ceasefire with Hamas in order to launch Operation Cast Lead. (10) (It was feared by Israeli Prime Minister Olmert that Hamas would gain international legitimacy as it moderated its political program.) The lamentable truth is that, short of national suicide, Iran cannot exercise the option of inaction: Israel will almost certainly keep ratcheting up the provocations until Teheran has no choice but to respond. It wouldn’t surprise were Israel to assassinate Ayatollah Khamenei then (wink, wink) deny it.
*
The Israeli government has ever been on the alert to exploit opportunities in order to implement its preconceived plans. In 1989, during the Tiananmen Square massacre, Benjamin Netanyahu urged his government to exploit this media distraction by carrying out a mass expulsion of Palestinians in the West Bank. On November 4, 2008, when the United States elected its first Black president, Prime Minister Olmert exploited this media distraction by breaking the ceasefire with Hamas. On July 17, 2014, when a Malaysian airliner flying over Ukraine was downed, Prime Minister Netanyahu exploited this media distraction by launching the murderous ground invasion of Gaza in Operation Protective Edge. The pretexts of October 7 and now Iran’s “retaliation” present the lunatics in Jerusalem with an unprecedented opportunity to rid Israel of the triple challenge to its regional domination: by destroying Gaza, Hezbollah, and Iran; the “fog” of such an explosion would also enable Israel’s ethnic cleansing of the West Bank. If it is hoped that a sane cabal among the Israeli leadership will crystallize to stop this headlong lurch over the precipice, then it must be said that the odds are against it. Hitler’s biographer, Ian Kershaw, observed that, if it took so long for coup plans to hatch against the Fuhrer, it was because of “a deep sense of obedience to authority and service to the state,” the belief that it was “not merely wrong, but despicable and treacherous to undermine one’s own country in war,” and “even as the military disasters mounted and ultimate catastrophe beckoned, the fanatical backing for Hitler had by no means evaporated and continued, if as a minority taste, to show remarkable resilience and strength.”(11) It’s hard not to notice cognate factors at play in elite Israeli circles. On the last point, whereas Netanyahu’s critics have been writing his political obituary for years, he too keeps bouncing back notwithstanding his missteps. Why? Because Israelis see their reflection in him. Indeed, Netanyahu IS Israel: an obnoxious, narcissistic Jewish supremacist for whom only Jews reckon in God’s grand design. It must, finally, be acknowledged that not all Israeli fears are unfounded—the wish is by now widespread that Israel vanish from the map while its capacity has diminished to terrorize its neighbors into submission. But, for the most part, it is a corner that Israel has boxed itself into. Before October 7 Hamas had gestured toward a two-state settlement while Iran consistently voted with the UN General Assembly majority in support of the two-state consensus. Israel rebuffed it.
Will Prime Minister Netanyahu resist the irresistible temptation to cut the Gordian regional knot or, like Samson, will he bring down the Temple—the rest of us—with him? Cassandra would probably say: All bets are off!
References
1. Mills, Causes of World War III.
2. Morris, One State, Two States.
3. Chomsky, Fateful Triangle. Investigative journalist Seymour Hersh later elaborated on Chomsky’s insights in The Samson Option.
4. New York Times, April 15, 2024.
5. Carter, White House Diary.
6. Finkelstein, Image and Reality of the Israel-Palestine Conflict
7. Benny Morris, Border Wars.
8. Robert Fisk, Pity the Nation.
9. Norman Finkelstein, Beyond Chutzpah.
10. Norman Finkelstein, Gaza.
11. Kershaw, Hitler, 1936-1945: Nemesis. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
SAMSON AND CASSANDRA (April 16, 2024)
My Mother once told me the story of an emaciated woman in the Warsaw Ghetto who would wail from her window sill that all the Jews in the ghetto would be killed. She came to be called Cassandra, after the prophetess of doom in Greek mythology. Everyone just assumed that she was mad. My Mother speculated in retrospect that somehow she had become privy to the truth: Jews weren’t being “relocated” in the East; they were being transported to their deaths.
I have hesitated thus far to sound the alarm. But at the risk of being thought mad, it must, as an act of political responsibility, be said out loud: Israel is hurling toward the precipice and dragging the rest of the world with it.
A rational analysis of the current predicament must begin with this bedrock fact: Israel is a crazy state. Not a “bad actor.” Not a “rogue” regime. A crazy state. The full range of Israeli elite opinion, itself reflective of Israeli society at large (which overwhelmingly supports the genocidal war in Gaza; only a handful of Israelis have refused to serve), spans a mere flea’s hop:
AT ONE POLE stand “crackpot realists,” of whom sociologist C. Wright Mills wrote in the American context: “they have come to believe that there ... is no other solution but war, even when they sense that war can be a solution to nothing ... they still believe that ‘winning’ means something, although they never tell us what.” (1) Professor Benny Morris is cut squarely from this mold. He is urbane, educated, secular—and a crackpot. He once even “proved” that Israeli Jews couldn’t coexist with barbarian Palestinians by inter alia mustering stats on how many more road accidents Palestinians got into! (2) Morris exhorts the US to join in an attack on Iran and then rattles the threat that if Washington doesn’t rise to the occasion, Israel will go it alone by nuking Iran. He must be cognizant as he breezily proffers such counsel that an attack would not only incinerate tens of millions of Iranians—he reckons they have it coming—but also trigger a terminal retaliation. Hezbollah alone is alleged to possess 150,000 missiles. It’s a circuitous auto-da-fé. That prospect, however, doesn’t appear to faze Morris one bit.
AT THE OTHER POLE stand full-blown crazies—or those just one step short of this threshold. “The greatest danger facing Israel right now,” Noam Chomsky presciently observed already four decades ago, “is the ‘collective version’ of Samson’s revenge against the Philistines—‘Let me perish with the Philistines’—as he brought down the Temple in ruins.” The Samson clones ensconced in Jerusalem have either already gone mad—“we shall kill and bury the Gentiles around us while we ourselves shall die with them”—or pretend to “go crazy” so as to terrify enemies and allies alike into submission. Feigned lunacy, be it noted, easily transmutes into the real thing as the imaginary phantoms one repeatedly conjures seep into the psyche’s inner chambers. The upshot is that this madness, real or contrived, “renders rational calculations ... questionable” as Israel “may behave in the manner of what have sometimes been called ‘crazy states.’” (3) A report in yesterday’s paper fleshes out in real time this Israeli propensity to unhinged outbursts: when one senior Israeli official counseled caution, if only in the immediate term, after Iran’s symbolic retaliation, a far-right cabinet minister demanded on the contrary that Israel go “crazy.” (4)
*
The April 14 speech at the Security Council emergency session by Israel’s representative, Gilad Erdan, brought home just how lunatic Israel has become. Presenting a master class in—if nothing else—proximate projection, Erdan was seemingly persuaded to the bone of his being that “the Islamic regime of today is ... no different than Adolf Hitler’s Third Reich.... Just like the Nazi regime, the Ayatollah regime sows death and destruction everywhere.... For years, the world has watched the rise of this Shite Islamist Reich, yet just like during the rise of Nazism, the world has been silent”; that “Iran’s hegemonic ambitions of global domination must be stopped before it drives the world to a point of no return, to a regional war that can escalate to a world war”; that Iran was “barreling towards nuclear capabilities ... its breakout time to produce an arsenal of nuclear weapons is now weeks, mere weeks.” If the world didn’t rein in Iran, then Israel had no recourse except to bear this crushing burden on its own of stopping Hitler’s Third Reich: “We are being fired upon from all fronts, from every border. We are surrounded by Iran’s terror proxies.... All of the terror groups attacking Israel are tentacles of the same Shiite octopus, the Iranian octopus. So, I ask you, and be honest with yourselves, what would you do? What would you do if you were in Israel’s shoes? How would you react if your existence was threatened every single day? Israel cannot settle for inaction. We will defend our future.” Holding up his iPad to display an image of Israel allegedly intercepting an Iranian drone over al-Aqsa mosque, Erdan even claimed for Israel the mantle of the true guardian of Islam’s holy sites—“look at this video that shows how Israel intercepts Iranian drones above the Temple Mount and al-Aqsa mosque”—against the defilers of them in Teheran. The tonal register of his rhetorical delivery was as if a defiant accusation, Who dares doubt me?! “In every speech and in countless letters,” Erdan further recalled, “I rang the warning bell regarding Iran.” He got right that the bell must be sounded; but he got wrong from whence the madness emanates. Medice, cura te ipsum. If Erdan represents even half of the Israeli state and society—the fraction is arguably much higher—a catastrophe looms. True, Israeli leaders have in the past uttered certifiable lunacies. It is sufficient to recall Prime Minister Netanyahu holding up a Loony Tunes-like cartoon of the Iranian bomb at the UN and his pronouncement that it was not Hitler but the Palestinian Mufti of Jerusalem who masterminded the Final Solution. Indeed, already as far back as the 1978 Camp David negotiations, President Carter mused about Israel’s head of state, “It’s becoming clearer that the rationality of [Menachem] Begin is in doubt.” (5) All the same, a civilizational leap backwards separates the Israel that once was from what it has become. Israel’s UN representative at the time of the 1967 (“Six-Day”) war, Abba Eban, could serially prevaricate—albeit with consummate eloquence, as befitted the triple-first graduate of Cambridge—without batting an eyelash. But still, it was possible to rationally parse his propositions (as I once endeavored) to prove them wrong. (6) It is no more possible to parse Erdan’s speech than a psychopath’s rant.
*
It might be urged upon Iran to tread lightly so as not to agitate the lunatic in the room. But alas, that is not, in my opinion, a viable option. The documentary record demonstrates that, once Israel has fixed a country in its crosshairs, nothing short of abject submission will bring it to desist. If the “enemy” power resists initial provocation, Israel will keep escalating with another and another provocation until it proves politically untenable for the targeted entity to passively absorb further blows. That’s what happened when Israel targeted Egypt’s Gamel Abdel Nasser in the early 1950s. (7) (It was feared by Israeli Prime Minister Ben-Gurion that the “radical nationalist” Egyptian president might one day preside over a modern state able to check Israel’s regional ambitions.) That’s what happened when Israel targeted the Palestine Liberation Organization in Lebanon in the early 1980s. (8) (It was feared by Israeli Prime Minister Begin that the PLO’s “peace offensive”—the Palestinians supported but Israelis opposed a two-state settlement—would bring international pressure on Israel to withdraw from the West Bank.) That’s what happened in 2002 during the second intifada when Israel carried out targeted assassinations of Palestinian leaders. (9) (It was feared by Prime Minister Sharon that the Palestinians would stop armed attacks in exchange for a negotiated ceasefire.) That’s what happened in 2008 when Israel broke a ceasefire with Hamas in order to launch Operation Cast Lead. (10) (It was feared by Israeli Prime Minister Olmert that Hamas would gain international legitimacy as it moderated its political program.) The lamentable truth is that, short of national suicide, Iran cannot exercise the option of inaction: Israel will almost certainly keep ratcheting up the provocations until Teheran has no choice but to respond. It wouldn’t surprise were Israel to assassinate Ayatollah Khamenei then (wink, wink) deny it.
*
The Israeli government has ever been on the alert to exploit opportunities in order to implement its preconceived plans. In 1989, during the Tiananmen Square massacre, Benjamin Netanyahu urged his government to exploit this media distraction by carrying out a mass expulsion of Palestinians in the West Bank. On November 4, 2008, when the United States elected its first Black president, Prime Minister Olmert exploited this media distraction by breaking the ceasefire with Hamas. On July 17, 2014, when a Malaysian airliner flying over Ukraine was downed, Prime Minister Netanyahu exploited this media distraction by launching the murderous ground invasion of Gaza in Operation Protective Edge. The pretexts of October 7 and now Iran’s “retaliation” present the lunatics in Jerusalem with an unprecedented opportunity to rid Israel of the triple challenge to its regional domination: by destroying Gaza, Hezbollah, and Iran; the “fog” of such an explosion would also enable Israel’s ethnic cleansing of the West Bank. If it is hoped that a sane cabal among the Israeli leadership will crystallize to stop this headlong lurch over the precipice, then it must be said that the odds are against it. Hitler’s biographer, Ian Kershaw, observed that, if it took so long for coup plans to hatch against the Fuhrer, it was because of “a deep sense of obedience to authority and service to the state,” the belief that it was “not merely wrong, but despicable and treacherous to undermine one’s own country in war,” and “even as the military disasters mounted and ultimate catastrophe beckoned, the fanatical backing for Hitler had by no means evaporated and continued, if as a minority taste, to show remarkable resilience and strength.”(11) It’s hard not to notice cognate factors at play in elite Israeli circles. On the last point, whereas Netanyahu’s critics have been writing his political obituary for years, he too keeps bouncing back notwithstanding his missteps. Why? Because Israelis see their reflection in him. Indeed, Netanyahu IS Israel: an obnoxious, narcissistic Jewish supremacist for whom only Jews reckon in God’s grand design. It must, finally, be acknowledged that not all Israeli fears are unfounded—the wish is by now widespread that Israel vanish from the map while its capacity has diminished to terrorize its neighbors into submission. But, for the most part, it is a corner that Israel has boxed itself into. Before October 7 Hamas had gestured toward a two-state settlement while Iran consistently voted with the UN General Assembly majority in support of the two-state consensus. Israel rebuffed it.
Will Prime Minister Netanyahu resist the irresistible temptation to cut the Gordian regional knot or, like Samson, will he bring down the Temple—the rest of us—with him? Cassandra would probably say: All bets are off!
References
1. Mills, Causes of World War III.
2. Morris, One State, Two States.
3. Chomsky, Fateful Triangle. Investigative journalist Seymour Hersh later elaborated on Chomsky’s insights in The Samson Option.
4. New York Times, April 15, 2024.
5. Carter, White House Diary.
6. Finkelstein, Image and Reality of the Israel-Palestine Conflict
7. Benny Morris, Border Wars.
8. Robert Fisk, Pity the Nation.
9. Norman Finkelstein, Beyond Chutzpah.
10. Norman Finkelstein, Gaza.
11. Kershaw, Hitler, 1936-1945: Nemesis. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
WHEN IT’S OKAY TO NUKE A COUNTRY open.substack.com/pub/normanfinkelstein/p/when-its-okay-t…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
WHEN IT’S OKAY TO NUKE A COUNTRY (April 12, 2024)
Historian Benny Morris supports Prime Minister Netanyahu’s resolve to attack Rafah (“Israel’s Security Depends on Rafah,” NY Times, 11 April 2024). Normally home to 280,000 Gazans, Rafah now also contains 1.2 million internal refugees swept into the city during Israel’s massive ethnic cleansing the past six months. It’s probably the most densely populated spot on God’s earth. In a disingenuous wordplay, Morris designates these 1.5 million Gazans a “human shield.” This locution denotes the involuntary conscription by an armed force of civilians to protect itself. But Hamas didn’t conscript these forsaken souls as shields; it was Israel that drove them there while now purporting that it must kill them to get at Hamas. Morris’s article is couched in this propagandistic idiom. He still refers to the casualty figures as based on the “Hamas-controlled Gaza Health Ministry” even as independent professional studies have confirmed these figures, and they are almost certainly an underestimate. He states that the current 33,000 figure “includes the more than 12,000 Hamas fighters the Israeli military claims to have killed these past six months.” In fact, the casualty figures Israel alleged in its previous “operations”—dutifully repeated by Morris in his books—wildly differed from the findings of human rights groups, while Israel has bandied about a mass of wildly discrepant figures of militants killed during the past six months. The IDF hasn’t even a clue how many Hamas combatants have been killed: it’s almost certain that most militants have fallen victim anonymously alongside civilians in the course of Israel’s deliberately indiscriminate terror assault on Gazan society; there have only been a handful of “battles” where Hamas corpses can ultimately be counted while, judging by previous Israeli operations—in which its “crazy” and “insane” firepower overwhelmed Hamas fighters and thus they rarely made it to actual combat—there cannot have been many Hamas battlefield corpses in the latest round to add up; the IDF doesn’t usually enter the Hamas tunnels it discovers but just explodes the shafts; Israel routinely classifies any dead adult male it stumbles upon during its “operations” as a Hamas “terrorist.” Meanwhile, Israel’s prime minister recently avowed that the IDF has killed only one civilian for every Hamas militant it killed. Does Morris believe this?
Morris justified an Israeli assault on the grounds that Rafah is the last stronghold of Hamas in Gaza; that an “expansive Hamas tunnel system” lies beneath Rafah; and that the “Hamas battalions” numbering “thousands of its fighters” ensconced in these tunnels must be “obliterated.” How does he know all this? Yes, Israel alleges that Hamas has built 450 miles of tunnels beneath Gaza. But that figure exceeds in length the famed sprawling, ramified New York City subway system (430 miles of tunnels), and, if true, every 1,200 hundred feet along minuscule Gaza’s 5-mile-long width, there is yet another 25-mile-long tunnel stretching its full length. Is that credible? It’s also anyone’s guess whether “Hamas battalions” are hiding in Rafah. Just a few months ago Israel alleged that Hamas’s command-and-control center lurked beneath al-Shifa hospital. Then it alleged that Hamas’s leaders had fled to Khan Younis. And on and on. Even as each claim proved to be false, they did nonetheless serve as a useful pretext to pulverize the infrastructure of another parcel of land as Israel proceeded to make Gaza uninhabitable. It seems that—with an assist from Morris—that fate now awaits Rafah.
Morris’s admonition that Hamas must suffer total defeat places him squarely within the consensus of Israeli politics. But the Israeli political spectrum is off the spectrum. There’s no center let alone left in Israeli politics: there’s only a right, a far right, and an ultra right. On the US political spectrum Morris’s opinion is echoed in a new publication by the neocon Jewish Institute for National Security of America: Hamas must be “effectively destroyed”; Israel must inflict a “visible and overwhelming defeat of Hamas.” (JINSA, “The Day After: A Plan for Gaza,” March 2024) The lead authors of this report are John Hannah, Elliott Abrams, and Lewis Libby. This trio was last heard from when they played crucial roles in the George W. Bush administration’s decision to unseat Saddam. So if you’re curious where Morris is coming from, think of the—crazed—mindset that brought us Iraq.
Morris anticipates that if the attack on Rafah goes ahead, “the additional civilian casualties and the attendant further disruption of humanitarian aid ... will ratchet up condemnation of Israel’s conduct by its Western allies, led by the United States.” Notice his one and only concern is that the assault won’t go over well in the West. A just-released report by the respected International Crisis Group observes that Israel’s “stated goals of destroying Hamas and toppling the government” cannot be reconciled with “saving what remains of Gaza and preventing mass death from starvation and disease.” It’s one or the other. The report concludes that “The goal of toppling Hamas cannot justify abetting a famine that could claim tens of thousands of lives.” (“Stopping Famine in Gaza,” April 2024) But the moral dilemma of pursuing an assault that could result in a hecatomb doesn’t even register for Morris. His moral calculus only reckons the diplomatic fallout. Here again, he is an Everyman Israeli.
Professor Morris was once a serious historian. Like everyone else, he had his biases, but his books were replete with rich archival findings. But, per the generality of Israelis, he has in recent decades become so consumed by hatred and contempt of Palestinians, so given to bile-filled rants, that not a word he says can any longer be trusted. (I publicly challenged Morris during a debate to answer my stringent parsing of his recent scholarly output. Morris agreed—but then abruptly, albeit predictably, backed out after reading my analysis.) He has exploited his deserved past reputation to disseminate Israeli state propaganda. Like the JINSA neocons, he has been repeatedly exhorting the US to join Israel in an attack on Iran. What’s more, he has even rattled the threat that, if Israel has to go it alone, it will have no recourse except to nuke Iran:
“Realistic leaders in Washington and Jerusalem cannot allow Teheran to have the Bomb. And, in the coming months or year, must do what is necessary to halt and destroy the Iranian nuclear project. And if this involves a protracted, conventional air assault on the Iranian nuclear facilities—then so be it. The Iranians will have brought that assault on their own heads. And, if conventional weapons cannot do the job—and if Israel is forced to go the course alone, it is doubtful that its conventional capabilities will be sufficient to destroy the Iranian nuclear project. Then non-conventional weaponry will have to be used to stymie the project. And many innocent Iranians will die. But the Iranians will have brought this upon themselves by bringing to power and leaving in power a leadership that will have forced Israelis to do what was necessary in order to survive.” (“A Second Holocaust?: The threat to Israel” (2 May 2008; www.mideastfreedomforum.org/de/node/66)
It’s a most intriguing proposition. If the Iranian people elected their current government, then, if they are wiped out in a nuclear attack, “they will have brought this upon themselves.” Doesn’t it then follow that, if the Israeli people elected their current genocidal government—indeed, according to polls, overwhelmingly support the genocide—then “they will have brought this upon themselves” if ...? -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Bassam Haddad
@4Bassam
The top Israeli historian is just like Israel. Shameful and embarrassing …. and murderous.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
WHEN IT’S OKAY TO NUKE A COUNTRY (April 12, 2024)
Historian Benny Morris supports Prime Minister Netanyahu’s resolve to attack Rafah (“Israel’s Security Depends on Rafah,” NY Times, 11 April 2024). Normally home to 280,000 Gazans, Rafah now also contains 1.2 million internal refugees swept into the city during Israel’s massive ethnic cleansing the past six months. It’s probably the most densely populated spot on God’s earth. In a disingenuous wordplay, Morris designates these 1.5 million Gazans a “human shield.” This locution denotes the involuntary conscription by an armed force of civilians to protect itself. But Hamas didn’t conscript these forsaken souls as shields; it was Israel that drove them there while now purporting that it must kill them to get at Hamas. Morris’s article is couched in this propagandistic idiom. He still refers to the casualty figures as based on the “Hamas-controlled Gaza Health Ministry” even as independent professional studies have confirmed these figures, and they are almost certainly an underestimate. He states that the current 33,000 figure “includes the more than 12,000 Hamas fighters the Israeli military claims to have killed these past six months.” In fact, the casualty figures Israel alleged in its previous “operations”—dutifully repeated by Morris in his books—wildly differed from the findings of human rights groups, while Israel has bandied about a mass of wildly discrepant figures of militants killed during the past six months. The IDF hasn’t even a clue how many Hamas combatants have been killed: it’s almost certain that most militants have fallen victim anonymously alongside civilians in the course of Israel’s deliberately indiscriminate terror assault on Gazan society; there have only been a handful of “battles” where Hamas corpses can ultimately be counted while, judging by previous Israeli operations—in which its “crazy” and “insane” firepower overwhelmed Hamas fighters and thus they rarely made it to actual combat—there cannot have been many Hamas battlefield corpses in the latest round to add up; the IDF doesn’t usually enter the Hamas tunnels it discovers but just explodes the shafts; Israel routinely classifies any dead adult male it stumbles upon during its “operations” as a Hamas “terrorist.” Meanwhile, Israel’s prime minister recently avowed that the IDF has killed only one civilian for every Hamas militant it killed. Does Morris believe this?
Morris justified an Israeli assault on the grounds that Rafah is the last stronghold of Hamas in Gaza; that an “expansive Hamas tunnel system” lies beneath Rafah; and that the “Hamas battalions” numbering “thousands of its fighters” ensconced in these tunnels must be “obliterated.” How does he know all this? Yes, Israel alleges that Hamas has built 450 miles of tunnels beneath Gaza. But that figure exceeds in length the famed sprawling, ramified New York City subway system (430 miles of tunnels), and, if true, every 1,200 hundred feet along minuscule Gaza’s 5-mile-long width, there is yet another 25-mile-long tunnel stretching its full length. Is that credible? It’s also anyone’s guess whether “Hamas battalions” are hiding in Rafah. Just a few months ago Israel alleged that Hamas’s command-and-control center lurked beneath al-Shifa hospital. Then it alleged that Hamas’s leaders had fled to Khan Younis. And on and on. Even as each claim proved to be false, they did nonetheless serve as a useful pretext to pulverize the infrastructure of another parcel of land as Israel proceeded to make Gaza uninhabitable. It seems that—with an assist from Morris—that fate now awaits Rafah.
Morris’s admonition that Hamas must suffer total defeat places him squarely within the consensus of Israeli politics. But the Israeli political spectrum is off the spectrum. There’s no center let alone left in Israeli politics: there’s only a right, a far right, and an ultra right. On the US political spectrum Morris’s opinion is echoed in a new publication by the neocon Jewish Institute for National Security of America: Hamas must be “effectively destroyed”; Israel must inflict a “visible and overwhelming defeat of Hamas.” (JINSA, “The Day After: A Plan for Gaza,” March 2024) The lead authors of this report are John Hannah, Elliott Abrams, and Lewis Libby. This trio was last heard from when they played crucial roles in the George W. Bush administration’s decision to unseat Saddam. So if you’re curious where Morris is coming from, think of the—crazed—mindset that brought us Iraq.
Morris anticipates that if the attack on Rafah goes ahead, “the additional civilian casualties and the attendant further disruption of humanitarian aid ... will ratchet up condemnation of Israel’s conduct by its Western allies, led by the United States.” Notice his one and only concern is that the assault won’t go over well in the West. A just-released report by the respected International Crisis Group observes that Israel’s “stated goals of destroying Hamas and toppling the government” cannot be reconciled with “saving what remains of Gaza and preventing mass death from starvation and disease.” It’s one or the other. The report concludes that “The goal of toppling Hamas cannot justify abetting a famine that could claim tens of thousands of lives.” (“Stopping Famine in Gaza,” April 2024) But the moral dilemma of pursuing an assault that could result in a hecatomb doesn’t even register for Morris. His moral calculus only reckons the diplomatic fallout. Here again, he is an Everyman Israeli.
Professor Morris was once a serious historian. Like everyone else, he had his biases, but his books were replete with rich archival findings. But, per the generality of Israelis, he has in recent decades become so consumed by hatred and contempt of Palestinians, so given to bile-filled rants, that not a word he says can any longer be trusted. (I publicly challenged Morris during a debate to answer my stringent parsing of his recent scholarly output. Morris agreed—but then abruptly, albeit predictably, backed out after reading my analysis.) He has exploited his deserved past reputation to disseminate Israeli state propaganda. Like the JINSA neocons, he has been repeatedly exhorting the US to join Israel in an attack on Iran. What’s more, he has even rattled the threat that, if Israel has to go it alone, it will have no recourse except to nuke Iran:
“Realistic leaders in Washington and Jerusalem cannot allow Teheran to have the Bomb. And, in the coming months or year, must do what is necessary to halt and destroy the Iranian nuclear project. And if this involves a protracted, conventional air assault on the Iranian nuclear facilities—then so be it. The Iranians will have brought that assault on their own heads. And, if conventional weapons cannot do the job—and if Israel is forced to go the course alone, it is doubtful that its conventional capabilities will be sufficient to destroy the Iranian nuclear project. Then non-conventional weaponry will have to be used to stymie the project. And many innocent Iranians will die. But the Iranians will have brought this upon themselves by bringing to power and leaving in power a leadership that will have forced Israelis to do what was necessary in order to survive.” (“A Second Holocaust?: The threat to Israel” (2 May 2008; www.mideastfreedomforum.org/de/node/66)
It’s a most intriguing proposition. If the Iranian people elected their current government, then, if they are wiped out in a nuclear attack, “they will have brought this upon themselves.” Doesn’t it then follow that, if the Israeli people elected their current genocidal government—indeed, according to polls, overwhelmingly support the genocide—then “they will have brought this upon themselves” if ...? -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein signed and endorsed the petition:
"Everything and anything must now be tried to prevent the lunatic Israeli state from hurling Humanity over the precipice into oblivion."
Norman Finkelstein
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
#athens with its history and legacy can only stand for justice, and not be complicit in an unfolding genocide.
We call for the cancelation of the event at the Olympia Theatre sponsored by the genocidal state of Israel.
Please sign and share
www.change.org/p/να-ακυρωθει-οριστικα-η-υπο-την-αιγιδα-τη… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
WHEN IT’S OKAY TO NUKE A COUNTRY (April 12, 2024)
Historian Benny Morris supports Prime Minister Netanyahu’s resolve to attack Rafah (“Israel’s Security Depends on Rafah,” NY Times, 11 April 2024). Normally home to 280,000 Gazans, Rafah now also contains 1.2 million internal refugees swept into the city during Israel’s massive ethnic cleansing the past six months. It’s probably the most densely populated spot on God’s earth. In a disingenuous wordplay, Morris designates these 1.5 million Gazans a “human shield.” This locution denotes the involuntary conscription by an armed force of civilians to protect itself. But Hamas didn’t conscript these forsaken souls as shields; it was Israel that drove them there while now purporting that it must kill them to get at Hamas. Morris’s article is couched in this propagandistic idiom. He still refers to the casualty figures as based on the “Hamas-controlled Gaza Health Ministry” even as independent professional studies have confirmed these figures, and they are almost certainly an underestimate. He states that the current 33,000 figure “includes the more than 12,000 Hamas fighters the Israeli military claims to have killed these past six months.” In fact, the casualty figures Israel alleged in its previous “operations”—dutifully repeated by Morris in his books—wildly differed from the findings of human rights groups, while Israel has bandied about a mass of wildly discrepant figures of militants killed during the past six months. The IDF hasn’t even a clue how many Hamas combatants have been killed: it’s almost certain that most militants have fallen victim anonymously alongside civilians in the course of Israel’s deliberately indiscriminate terror assault on Gazan society; there have only been a handful of “battles” where Hamas corpses can ultimately be counted while, judging by previous Israeli operations—in which its “crazy” and “insane” firepower overwhelmed Hamas fighters and thus they rarely made it to actual combat—there cannot have been many Hamas battlefield corpses in the latest round to add up; the IDF doesn’t usually enter the Hamas tunnels it discovers but just explodes the shafts; Israel routinely classifies any dead adult male it stumbles upon during its “operations” as a Hamas “terrorist.” Meanwhile, Israel’s prime minister recently avowed that the IDF has killed only one civilian for every Hamas militant it killed. Does Morris believe this?
Morris justified an Israeli assault on the grounds that Rafah is the last stronghold of Hamas in Gaza; that an “expansive Hamas tunnel system” lies beneath Rafah; and that the “Hamas battalions” numbering “thousands of its fighters” ensconced in these tunnels must be “obliterated.” How does he know all this? Yes, Israel alleges that Hamas has built 450 miles of tunnels beneath Gaza. But that figure exceeds in length the famed sprawling, ramified New York City subway system (430 miles of tunnels), and, if true, every 1,200 hundred feet along minuscule Gaza’s 5-mile-long width, there is yet another 25-mile-long tunnel stretching its full length. Is that credible? It’s also anyone’s guess whether “Hamas battalions” are hiding in Rafah. Just a few months ago Israel alleged that Hamas’s command-and-control center lurked beneath al-Shifa hospital. Then it alleged that Hamas’s leaders had fled to Khan Younis. And on and on. Even as each claim proved to be false, they did nonetheless serve as a useful pretext to pulverize the infrastructure of another parcel of land as Israel proceeded to make Gaza uninhabitable. It seems that—with an assist from Morris—that fate now awaits Rafah.
Morris’s admonition that Hamas must suffer total defeat places him squarely within the consensus of Israeli politics. But the Israeli political spectrum is off the spectrum. There’s no center let alone left in Israeli politics: there’s only a right, a far right, and an ultra right. On the US political spectrum Morris’s opinion is echoed in a new publication by the neocon Jewish Institute for National Security of America: Hamas must be “effectively destroyed”; Israel must inflict a “visible and overwhelming defeat of Hamas.” (JINSA, “The Day After: A Plan for Gaza,” March 2024) The lead authors of this report are John Hannah, Elliott Abrams, and Lewis Libby. This trio was last heard from when they played crucial roles in the George W. Bush administration’s decision to unseat Saddam. So if you’re curious where Morris is coming from, think of the—crazed—mindset that brought us Iraq.
Morris anticipates that if the attack on Rafah goes ahead, “the additional civilian casualties and the attendant further disruption of humanitarian aid ... will ratchet up condemnation of Israel’s conduct by its Western allies, led by the United States.” Notice his one and only concern is that the assault won’t go over well in the West. A just-released report by the respected International Crisis Group observes that Israel’s “stated goals of destroying Hamas and toppling the government” cannot be reconciled with “saving what remains of Gaza and preventing mass death from starvation and disease.” It’s one or the other. The report concludes that “The goal of toppling Hamas cannot justify abetting a famine that could claim tens of thousands of lives.” (“Stopping Famine in Gaza,” April 2024) But the moral dilemma of pursuing an assault that could result in a hecatomb doesn’t even register for Morris. His moral calculus only reckons the diplomatic fallout. Here again, he is an Everyman Israeli.
Professor Morris was once a serious historian. Like everyone else, he had his biases, but his books were replete with rich archival findings. But, per the generality of Israelis, he has in recent decades become so consumed by hatred and contempt of Palestinians, so given to bile-filled rants, that not a word he says can any longer be trusted. (I publicly challenged Morris during a debate to answer my stringent parsing of his recent scholarly output. Morris agreed—but then abruptly, albeit predictably, backed out after reading my analysis.) He has exploited his deserved past reputation to disseminate Israeli state propaganda. Like the JINSA neocons, he has been repeatedly exhorting the US to join Israel in an attack on Iran. What’s more, he has even rattled the threat that, if Israel has to go it alone, it will have no recourse except to nuke Iran:
“Realistic leaders in Washington and Jerusalem cannot allow Teheran to have the Bomb. And, in the coming months or year, must do what is necessary to halt and destroy the Iranian nuclear project. And if this involves a protracted, conventional air assault on the Iranian nuclear facilities—then so be it. The Iranians will have brought that assault on their own heads. And, if conventional weapons cannot do the job—and if Israel is forced to go the course alone, it is doubtful that its conventional capabilities will be sufficient to destroy the Iranian nuclear project. Then non-conventional weaponry will have to be used to stymie the project. And many innocent Iranians will die. But the Iranians will have brought this upon themselves by bringing to power and leaving in power a leadership that will have forced Israelis to do what was necessary in order to survive.” (“A Second Holocaust?: The threat to Israel” (2 May 2008; www.mideastfreedomforum.org/de/node/66)
It’s a most intriguing proposition. If the Iranian people elected their current government, then, if they are wiped out in a nuclear attack, “they will have brought this upon themselves.” Doesn’t it then follow that, if the Israeli people elected their current genocidal government—indeed, according to polls, overwhelmingly support the genocide—then “they will have brought this upon themselves” if ...? -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
JamieSW
@jsternweiner
TONIGHT, 6.45pm ET / 11.45pm BST.
Norman Finkelstein (@normfinkelstein)
Mouin Rabbani (@MouinRabbani)
Colter Louwerse (@ColterL)
and Slavoj Zizek
debate and discuss the catastrophe in Gaza.
Livestream if you're not in New York:
mailchi.mp/orbooks/deluge-launch -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
JamieSW
@jsternweiner
Bill Ackman's proposals for Gaza are as original as his wife's PhD
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
“THE INSIPID FLATNESS OF OUR PRESENT BOURGEOISIE IS TO BE MEASURED BY THE ALTITUDE OF ITS ‘GREAT INTELLECTS’” (Karl Marx, CAPITAL)
The last time billionaire Bill Ackman was heard from, he perpetrated the most brazen assault on academic freedom in our country’s history. He engineered a coup that toppled Harvard president Claudine Gay by publicly threatening to withhold megabucks in alumni contributions if the Board of Trustees did not dismiss her. What was Gay’s crime? She was insufficiently repressive of student outrage at Israel’s genocide in Gaza. It is not, however, as if Ackman is a Zionist. Social critic Irving Howe once quipped that, if you have enough money to purchase a one-way ticket to Israel but don’t, then you’re not a Zionist. So no, Ackman is not a lover of Zion. Rather, he’s a typical Jewish supremacist. The notion that a Jew—or, in the case at hand, the Jewish State—can be anything less than the paragon of virtue amounts to a blood libel. When Ackman’s coup plans began to falter, he went after Gay for plagiarism. But, alas, Yahweh proved to be a mischievous God. It was miraculously revealed that Ackman’s wife had herself plagiarized in her doctoral dissertation. The difference was that Gay lifted passages from scholarly publications, whereas Ackman’s wife plagiarized Wikipedia. In a world replete with ironic coincidences that almost make one a believer, it appears that Ackman’s wife was channeling Mr. VermiNcelli, or vice versa.
In any event, Ackman is back. Now that the Gaza genocide that he facilitated is getting a bad rap, Ackman’s decided to cover his pig’s feet with the philanthropist’s white gloves. He’s touting enlightened “high-level thoughts on a potential solution to Gaza.” Except as an articulation of his infinite self-regard, it’s hard to make out what exactly makes his insipid banalities “high-level.” The essence of his supposed genius comes down to two steps. (1) Rebuild Gaza as a “model city” with “modern infrastructure.” Open any book on the so-called peace process and you’ll come across the same tired cliché of turning Gaza into the Singapore of the Middle East. “Imagine if Hamas had just a 2 percent interest in building Gaza,” peace process macher Dennis Ross pontificated a few months ago, “they could have turned Gaza into Singapore." (2) The hitch in this plan is, of course, political: Gazans want to control their own fate, while Ackman wants them to be “governed by a consortium of Gulf states.” To square this circle, Ackman proposes a “high level” solution: defeat Hamas. How original. In his words, “Civilians in Rafah are moved to a refugee camp safe zone built in the Negev desert adjoining Gaza,” so that “the IDF destroys Hamas.” Setting aside that this scenario is as fantastical as his Emerald City over the rainbow, it also prompts this heretical thought: If Hamas must be destroyed because it killed 1,200 Israelis including 36 children on October 7, shouldn’t the population of Israel also be moved to a refugee safe zone built in the Negev desert so that Hamas can destroy Israel’s genocidal government and army that have murdered to date 32,000 Gazans including 13,000 children?
Ackman requests constructive criticism. Here’s mine: Stop making a fool of yourself by defending your wife’s plagiarism and marketing your drivel as “high-level thoughts.” -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Guess Who Israel is Starving (An old friend just back from Gaza)
Nancy Mansour saying goodbye to the children of Nuseirat Refugee Camp #2 after a day's workshops @ The Camp Breakerz Crew Dance school. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
"Ackman requests constructive criticism. Here’s mine: Stop making a fool of yourself by defending your wife’s plagiarism and marketing your drivel as “high-level thoughts.”"
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
“THE INSIPID FLATNESS OF OUR PRESENT BOURGEOISIE IS TO BE MEASURED BY THE ALTITUDE OF ITS ‘GREAT INTELLECTS’” (Karl Marx, CAPITAL)
The last time billionaire Bill Ackman was heard from, he perpetrated the most brazen assault on academic freedom in our country’s history. He engineered a coup that toppled Harvard president Claudine Gay by publicly threatening to withhold megabucks in alumni contributions if the Board of Trustees did not dismiss her. What was Gay’s crime? She was insufficiently repressive of student outrage at Israel’s genocide in Gaza. It is not, however, as if Ackman is a Zionist. Social critic Irving Howe once quipped that, if you have enough money to purchase a one-way ticket to Israel but don’t, then you’re not a Zionist. So no, Ackman is not a lover of Zion. Rather, he’s a typical Jewish supremacist. The notion that a Jew—or, in the case at hand, the Jewish State—can be anything less than the paragon of virtue amounts to a blood libel. When Ackman’s coup plans began to falter, he went after Gay for plagiarism. But, alas, Yahweh proved to be a mischievous God. It was miraculously revealed that Ackman’s wife had herself plagiarized in her doctoral dissertation. The difference was that Gay lifted passages from scholarly publications, whereas Ackman’s wife plagiarized Wikipedia. In a world replete with ironic coincidences that almost make one a believer, it appears that Ackman’s wife was channeling Mr. VermiNcelli, or vice versa.
In any event, Ackman is back. Now that the Gaza genocide that he facilitated is getting a bad rap, Ackman’s decided to cover his pig’s feet with the philanthropist’s white gloves. He’s touting enlightened “high-level thoughts on a potential solution to Gaza.” Except as an articulation of his infinite self-regard, it’s hard to make out what exactly makes his insipid banalities “high-level.” The essence of his supposed genius comes down to two steps. (1) Rebuild Gaza as a “model city” with “modern infrastructure.” Open any book on the so-called peace process and you’ll come across the same tired cliché of turning Gaza into the Singapore of the Middle East. “Imagine if Hamas had just a 2 percent interest in building Gaza,” peace process macher Dennis Ross pontificated a few months ago, “they could have turned Gaza into Singapore." (2) The hitch in this plan is, of course, political: Gazans want to control their own fate, while Ackman wants them to be “governed by a consortium of Gulf states.” To square this circle, Ackman proposes a “high level” solution: defeat Hamas. How original. In his words, “Civilians in Rafah are moved to a refugee camp safe zone built in the Negev desert adjoining Gaza,” so that “the IDF destroys Hamas.” Setting aside that this scenario is as fantastical as his Emerald City over the rainbow, it also prompts this heretical thought: If Hamas must be destroyed because it killed 1,200 Israelis including 36 children on October 7, shouldn’t the population of Israel also be moved to a refugee safe zone built in the Negev desert so that Hamas can destroy Israel’s genocidal government and army that have murdered to date 32,000 Gazans including 13,000 children?
Ackman requests constructive criticism. Here’s mine: Stop making a fool of yourself by defending your wife’s plagiarism and marketing your drivel as “high-level thoughts.” -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
“THE INSIPID FLATNESS OF OUR PRESENT BOURGEOISIE IS TO BE MEASURED BY THE ALTITUDE OF ITS ‘GREAT INTELLECTS’” (Karl Marx, CAPITAL)
The last time billionaire Bill Ackman was heard from, he perpetrated the most brazen assault on academic freedom in our country’s history. He engineered a coup that toppled Harvard president Claudine Gay by publicly threatening to withhold megabucks in alumni contributions if the Board of Trustees did not dismiss her. What was Gay’s crime? She was insufficiently repressive of student outrage at Israel’s genocide in Gaza. It is not, however, as if Ackman is a Zionist. Social critic Irving Howe once quipped that, if you have enough money to purchase a one-way ticket to Israel but don’t, then you’re not a Zionist. So no, Ackman is not a lover of Zion. Rather, he’s a typical Jewish supremacist. The notion that a Jew—or, in the case at hand, the Jewish State—can be anything less than the paragon of virtue amounts to a blood libel. When Ackman’s coup plans began to falter, he went after Gay for plagiarism. But, alas, Yahweh proved to be a mischievous God. It was miraculously revealed that Ackman’s wife had herself plagiarized in her doctoral dissertation. The difference was that Gay lifted passages from scholarly publications, whereas Ackman’s wife plagiarized Wikipedia. In a world replete with ironic coincidences that almost make one a believer, it appears that Ackman’s wife was channeling Mr. VermiNcelli, or vice versa.
In any event, Ackman is back. Now that the Gaza genocide that he facilitated is getting a bad rap, Ackman’s decided to cover his pig’s feet with the philanthropist’s white gloves. He’s touting enlightened “high-level thoughts on a potential solution to Gaza.” Except as an articulation of his infinite self-regard, it’s hard to make out what exactly makes his insipid banalities “high-level.” The essence of his supposed genius comes down to two steps. (1) Rebuild Gaza as a “model city” with “modern infrastructure.” Open any book on the so-called peace process and you’ll come across the same tired cliché of turning Gaza into the Singapore of the Middle East. “Imagine if Hamas had just a 2 percent interest in building Gaza,” peace process macher Dennis Ross pontificated a few months ago, “they could have turned Gaza into Singapore." (2) The hitch in this plan is, of course, political: Gazans want to control their own fate, while Ackman wants them to be “governed by a consortium of Gulf states.” To square this circle, Ackman proposes a “high level” solution: defeat Hamas. How original. In his words, “Civilians in Rafah are moved to a refugee camp safe zone built in the Negev desert adjoining Gaza,” so that “the IDF destroys Hamas.” Setting aside that this scenario is as fantastical as his Emerald City over the rainbow, it also prompts this heretical thought: If Hamas must be destroyed because it killed 1,200 Israelis including 36 children on October 7, shouldn’t the population of Israel also be moved to a refugee safe zone built in the Negev desert so that Hamas can destroy Israel’s genocidal government and army that have murdered to date 32,000 Gazans including 13,000 children?
Ackman requests constructive criticism. Here’s mine: Stop making a fool of yourself by defending your wife’s plagiarism and marketing your drivel as “high-level thoughts.” -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
ISRAEL’S MORAL DILEMMA (April 5, 2024)
This morning the New York Times reported the findings of the IDF “investigation” into the WCK killings: “grave mistake ... errors in decision-making.” It’s a mystery why the Times ran this redundant story. It had already determined what happened yesterday BEFORE the “investigation”: “mistakes and misjudgments.” How did the Times know this ahead of the “investigation”? The IDF told it so before the “investigation.” The Times reporters covering today’s story are named Aaron Boxerman and Adam Ragson. Both of them previously worked in Jerusalem for the Israeli propaganda rag sheet, Times of Israel. Theirs must have been a most smooth transition from Israel’s Jerusalem disinformation bureau to Israel’s New York disinformation bureau. Still, wouldn’t a cost-cutting expert recommend that the Times just reprint IDF press releases without the intermediary of “reporters”?
The IDF fired on the second and third cars in the WCK caravan after survivors of the first targeted assassination sought refuge in them. Targeting the survivors of an initial attack is IDF standard operating procedure; one of the tricks of the (satanic) trade. Here are a couple of typical examples from Operation Protective Edge (2014):
A MULTIPLE DRONE-MISSILE ATTACK wounded nine civilians, including three children, in the vicinity of a mosque. Another drone missile targeted an ambulance just as it headed back to the hospital loaded with several of the wounded, incinerating eight people, including the three children, two medics, and a volunteer. Yet another drone-missile attack targeted a second ambulance that arrived belatedly on the scene. A witness recalled, “What we saw was really horrible. The ambulance looked like a tree branch that was completely charred. The bodies had no parts—no legs, no hands—they were severely burned.” (Amnesty International, “Black Friday”)
*
THE ROOF OF A HOME WAS HIT by high-explosive mortar shells that killed eight family members, including seven children aged between three and nine, who were playing there, and their grandfather aged seventy. Israel purported that the attack was in response to an “anti-tank missile” and a “burst of mortar” fired from the neighborhood that injured one soldier. The IDF then fired “another round of shells” ten minutes later “just as three ambulances and the paramedics arrived at the scene,” which also hit “many of the people who had gathered around the [family] house to try and help survivors.” A UN investigation headed by a New York State judge quoted a journalist eyewitness who was “stunned” by the “apparent targeting of ambulances and journalists who had rushed to provide assistance to the injured and cover the incident.” It further noted that eyewitness accounts “are corroborated by two video recordings,” one of which showed a “dying cameraman continuing to film, and the ambulances being hit by a rocket.” As a result of the second round of shelling, 23 persons were killed and 178 others injured. (“Report of the Detailed Findings of the Independent Committee of Inquiry”)
*
The Times reports that, on account of the “errors” in the WCK massacre, two officers would be dismissed from their positions and three others would suffer a “reprimand.”
Although naive observers were appalled at such leniency, this was by Israeli standards actually a harsh punishment. During Operation Cast Lead (2008-9), Israel killed 1,400 Gazans, up to 80 percent of whom were civilians and 350 children. Human Rights organizations documented massive war crimes committed by the IDF. How did Israel punish the perpetrators? A handful of soldiers suffered disciplinary sanctions such as an officer who was “severely reprimanded,” while the harshest sentence meted out was a seven-and-a-half-month prison term to a soldier who had stolen a credit card. During their attack on a humanitarian convoy of vessels headed towards Gaza (2010), Israeli commandos killed 10 unarmed passengers aboard the flagship Mavi Marmara. The punishment? A corporal was sentenced to five months in prison for stealing a laptop computer, two camera lenses, and a compass. During Operation Protective Edge, Israel killed 2,200 Gazans, of whom 70 percent were civilians and 550 children. “I can say without hesitation,” Gaza specialist Sara Roy of Harvard University observed, “that I have never seen the kind of human, physical, and psychological destruction that I see there today.” The punishment? Three Israeli soldiers were indicted for stealing $600 from a Palestinian home.
Truth be told, Israel confronts an excruciating dilemma. It is a war crime to deliberately target or indiscriminately attack a civilian or civilian object. The World Bank’s “Gaza Strip Interim Damage Assessment” (March 2024) reports that since October 7 Israel has, among other things, damaged or destroyed 290,820 housing units (of which 76% were totally destroyed), and as a result “more than 1.08 million people will not be able to return to their homes.” It has killed more than 31,000 Gazans (of whom 70% are women and children) and wounded 75,000 others. The objective of the Israeli assault has been to, once and for all, solve the Gaza “problem.” It has carried out a deliberately indiscriminate assault targeting Gaza’s entire civilian population and infrastructure. If this or that killed Gazan proves to be a militant or this or that destroyed housing unit stands above a tunnel, it amounts to little more than the margin of error in the totality of this onslaught. Here, then, is Israel’s moral dilemma: were it to prosecute every war criminal in its ranks, there wouldn’t be anyone left to finish the job in Gaza. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Interview with Al Jazeera on the War on Gaza youtu.be/ELNr_ro97MI
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein on Gaza: The US could have stopped Israel on day one ... youtu.be/ELNr_ro97MI
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Kiko's Freethinker's Forum: "“All These Arab Countries Want to See Israel Destroy Hamas": Norman Finkelstein Explains"
youtu.be/GmkNcAq6gLE
@KikoFreethinker -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Kiko's Freethinker's Forum-Episode 109: Norman Finkelstein talks Identity Politics, Middle East, Chuck Schumer and Cornel West
youtu.be/YoTxmdfyIA4
@KikoFreethinker -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
STARVE OR LEAVE
Let’s cut to the chase: of course Israel deliberately targeted the WCK relief convoy. Not only do all the material facts point to this conclusion. There also aren’t any grounds to doubt it; the heavy burden of proof falls on Israel to demonstrate that it was not a premeditated strike. On October 8, 2023, Israel announced a total blockade of Gaza: no food, fuel, water, or electricity would be allowed in. The rationale behind this order was laid out by former Israeli National Security Council head Giora Eiland: “Israel should not allow any economic assistance. The people should be told that they have two choices: to stay and to starve, or to leave.” For the next two weeks, Israel blocked the entry of any aid into Gaza. Flagrant mass murder not being a good look, President Biden counseled Prime Minister Netanyahu to lighten up a bit. Israel tweaked its murder plan so as to pass muster with its enablers in Washington. But it did not alter the essence of its game-plan. Human Rights Watch documented in December that Israel was “using starvation of civilians as a method of warfare.” Normally reticent senior international and humanitarian officials have in recent weeks openly charged that “Starvation is used as a weapon of war. Israel is provoking famine." (Josop Borrell, EU foreign policy chief) If—as everyone seems to agree—Israel’s declared objective is to starve Gaza’s civilian population, then: HOW COULD IT NOT PLUG THE HOLES IN ITS MURDER PLAN BY TARGETING INTERNATIONAL RELIEF ORGANIZATIONS? And in fact it’s mission accomplished: international aid operations in Gaza have largely ceased “as a result of recent attacks on humanitarian workers by the IDF.” (“Letter to the White House and National Security Council,” April 4, 2024) But it might be wondered: Wasn’t it foolhardy for Israel to risk international opprobrium? Not at all. Israel has targeted by various metrics an historically unprecedented number of hospitals, medics, journalists, and aid workers; it has killed an unprecedented number of women and children. It is ever testing the limits of the permissible. So far, it’s successfully crossed every downward threshold into barbarism with impunity. It’s impossible to predict in advance which story will be picked up by the fickle international media and which story will just get passing notice. The latest atrocity could just as easily have been subsumed in a paragraph on the inside pages under the title “Aid workers killed in Gaza.” The only error Israel might have—it’s too soon to tell—committed was anticipating that it would get another free pass. Indeed, Israel’s news bureau in the US, the New York Times, is already spinning the story to exonerate Israel: “botched operation ... mistakes and misjudgments ... accidental killing.” (“Back-to-Back Israeli Strikes Show Tragic Gaps in Choosing Targets,” April 4, 2024) It’s also being said that it’s not senior Israeli officials but on the contrary IDF field commanders and soldiers who are out of control, or that Israel’s resort to AI is behind the hecatomb in Gaza. That’s all bullshit. During its periodic “mowing-the-lawn” hi-tech murder sprees in Gaza (Operation Cast Lead, Operation Protective Edge), Israel has always used DISCRIMINATELY INDISCRIMINATE firepower to terrorize Gaza’s civilian population into submission. The nub of the problem is neither disciplinary nor technical. It’s Israel’s murder plan: to make Gaza unlivable and to force its people to decide—starve or leave. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What We Can Do: Sign and Share www.normanfinkelstein.com/what-we-can-do-sign-and-share-2/
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
#athens with its history and legacy can only stand for justice, and not be complicit in an unfolding genocide.
We call for the cancelation of the event at the Olympia Theatre sponsored by the genocidal state of Israel.
Please sign and share
www.change.org/p/να-ακυρωθει-οριστικα-η-υπο-την-αιγιδα-τη… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What we can do: Sign and share
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
A call to cancel the musical ensembles of the Cultural, Sports and Youth Organization of the Municipality of Athens (OPANDA) at the Olympia Theatre, scheduled for the 29th of April 2024 and sponsored by the genocidal state of Israel
Please sign and share www.change.org/p/να-ακυρωθει-οριστικα-η-υπο-την-αιγιδα-τη… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Wed April 10 at 6:45 p.m. ET. You can sign up to OR BOOKS mailing list to join the livestream of the event.
www.youtube.com/channel/UC__1QtA3JaDPQRkT9vxxfuw/live
@orbooks @MouinRabbani @jsternweiner
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
To sign up to OR Books mailing list: mailchi.mp/orbooks/deluge-launch
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Mr. VermiNcelli once Read a Book!
(April Fool's) -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
The Palestine Center
@PalestineCenter
If you missed our conversation with @normfinkelstein on the Great March of Return and the persistent neglect and dismissal of the urgent calls to end the blockade of Gaza, moderated by @JehadAbusalim, you can watch it here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=wE72pwKTRYk
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Join us online April 10 at 6:45pm ET for Deluge: Gaza and Israel From Crisis to Cataclysm a conversation featuring @normfinkelstein @jsternweiner @Slavojiek @MouinRabbani @raziaiqbal @ColterL by signing up for our mailing list: mailchi.mp/orbooks/deluge-launch
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Five Guys Posing with the Joe Biden Look-Alike at Madame Tussauds Wax Museum
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
GENUS IMBECILUS BORRELIS
In a recent debate moderated by Lex Fridman, a nullity seated beside Professor Benny Morris expounded on the nuances of the Genocide Convention: “I think it’s called dolus specialis, it’s the most important part of genocide, which is proving it is a highly special intent to commit genocide.” This writer innocuously and uncontroversially interjected: “That’s mens rea.” Which was to say that the crux of the Genocide Convention is proving intent or mens rea (from the Latin for “guilty mind”) to commit genocide. Thus commenced a saga that has by now polluted cyberspace. Like a baby that won’t let go of its rattle, the misbegotten intruder obstinately purports, and his weird cult mindlessly repeats after him, that reference to mens rea instead of dolus specialis reveals complete ignorance of the Genocide Convention. It happens that yesterday the International Court of Justice issued a new statement pertaining to South Africa’s application charging Israel with genocide. The Israeli judge on the Court, former president of the Israeli Supreme Court Aharon Barak, dissented from the majority opinion. Among other things, Barak had this to say: “The Court’s lack of reasoning is concerning with regard to the issue of INTENT. South Africa made no reference to INTENT in its request for the modification of provisional measures, although IT IS THE KEY REQUIREMENT IN CASES OF GENOCIDE.” (my emphases) In other words, proving “intent” (mens rea) is the crux of the Genocide Convention. It would appear that Barak too is ignorant of international law. Darn, if only we had taken a crash course at Wiki U. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
The Palestine Center
@PalestineCenter
How the World Failed Gaza: The Great March of Return Six Years On x.com/i/broadcasts/1BRJjPWrpaQKw
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
“YOU CAN RUN BUT YOU CAN’T HIDE” (boxer Joe Louis)
The Lex Fridman Debate
In a recent debate* moderated by Lex Fridman, I challenged Professor Benny Morris to answer my detailed book chapter on his scholarship (“History by Subtraction,” in my book Knowing Too Much). The point at issue was simple and straightforward: Morris has repudiated his original historical conclusions without demonstrating why his old evidence was wrong or even acknowledging his dramatic reversal. For example, Morris originally stated that “the fear of territorial displacement and dispossession was to be the chief motor of Arab antagonism to Zionism” and, further, that this Arab fear was rationally based: “transfer was inevitable and inbuilt into Zionism—because it sought to transform a land which was ‘Arab’ into a ‘Jewish’ state and a Jewish state could not have arisen without a major displacement of Arab population.” In other words, if Palestinian Arabs opposed Zionism, it was because the Zionists intended to expel them. Morris adduced a wealth of primary sources to sustain this contention. But he has now done a volte-face. He purports that transfer “had not been part of the original Zionist ideology,” and it was only later adopted by the Zionist movement in reaction to “expulsionist or terroristic violence by the Arabs.” Expulsion has inexplicably metamorphosed from an “inevitable and inbuilt” tenet of Zionism into a reaction “triggered” by expulsionist Arab threats and assaults. The root cause of the conflict was no longer the rational Arab fear of Zionist expulsion but, on the contrary, an irrational Arab hatred of Jews. Morris thus displaced the moral onus of the conflict from Zionist expulsion to Arab expulsion. It’s hard to conceive a more drastic revision. A historian is of course within his right to reconsider his prior conclusions. But Morris doesn’t provide a shred of evidence that his original conclusions were wrong; he doesn’t even acknowledge that he has diametrically reversed himself. Indeed, his current rightwing opinions amount to a negation of his very own scholarship. In the debate Morris clearly stated that he would accept my challenge (2:37:13). Alas, he recently informed me that he wouldn’t be responding. I cannot say I was altogether surprised. Discretion, after all, is the better part of valor. Herewith my reply to Professor Morris’s abrupt change of heart:
“I am in receipt of your curt reply: ‘I'm afraid the tone of the chapter precludes a serious dialogue.’ You can obviously exercise the option of establishing at the outset that you find the tone of my critique objectionable, even outrageous, yet still proceed to answer the substantive points at issue. The great sociologist Raul Hilberg—he was, incidentally, a rightwing Republican and fastidious in his professional comportment—had this to say during my abortive tenure bid: ‘leaving aside the question of style—and here, I agree that it’s not my style either—the substance of the matter is most important here, particularly because Finkelstein, when he published this book [The Holocaust Industry], was alone. It takes an enormous amount of academic courage to speak the truth when no one else is out there to support him.’ I would further submit that you yourself are not exactly renowned as a paragon of academic civility. In response to my close parsing of your book on the Palestinian refugee question, here’s how you described me and my scholarship in an academic journal: ‘forever a purveyor of Jewish malice,’ ‘palpable nonsense,’ ‘dishonesty of a high order,’ ‘dishonest and reprehensible point,’ ‘trickery,’ ‘twisted, distorted, and hoodwinked,’ ‘spurious, twisted scholarship,’ etc. (Oddly, you concluded by deploring my lack of ‘civilized academic argumentation.’) I have nonetheless, and unhesitatingly, acknowledged the indispensability of your scholarship. I did not exploit your adjectival frenzy as a pretext to evade engaging your work. Quite the contrary. I plunged into your oeuvre, read and reread it, before proceeding to critique it. I should hope that you will reconsider your decision. Millions of viewers of the Lex Fridman debate heard you commit yourself to answering me, and many—not least myself—look forward with great curiosity to your learned response. It would be most regrettable if your failure to stand by your word is construed as an act of intellectual cowardice—to wit, you couldn’t coherently answer my substantive claim that you have reversed your original scholarly findings without adducing any new evidence.”
*lexfridman.com/israel-palestine-debate-transcript/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
March 31 at 5:00 p.m. Norman Finkelstein on the ongoing genocide in Gaza with Krystal Ball.
@krystalball -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Wed April 10 at 6:45 p.m. A conversation marking the publication of Deluge: Gaza and Israel from Crisis to Cataclysm with Norman Finkelstein, Mouin Rabbani, Slavoj Žižek, Jamie Stern-Weiner and Colter Louwerse. The discussion will be moderated by Razia Iqbal.
@jsternweiner @MouinRabbani @orbooks -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
The Palestine Center
@PalestineCenter
Join us tomorrow at 12pm EST for a conversation with @normfinkelstein on the persistent disregard of the urgent calls to end the #gaza blockade such as the March or Return, and how years of international inaction and complicity have culminated in the current disaster in Gaza, moderated by @JehadAbusalim.
🗓️ Friday, March 29 | 12:00 PM EST
thejerusalemfund.org/2024/03/how-the-world-failed-gaza-th… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
“TWO OR THREE QUOTES THAT YOU USE TO PUSH PEOPLE AROUND”
In a recent debate, someone seated next to Professor Benny Morris lectured me on the impossibility that Israel systematically breaches the laws of war. It was stated that Israel only approved and launched precision attacks directed at legitimate military targets:
“I think that it’s important that when we talk about military strikes or we talk about things especially involving bombings or drone attacks, these are things that are signed off by multiple different layers of command, by multiple people involved in an operation, including intelligence gathering, including weaponeering, and they also have typically lawyers involved.” (from the official transcript)
It was further stated that the whole of my contrary evidence comprises “two or three quotes that you use to push people around.”
In 2014 Israel launched Operation Protective Edge against Gaza. Peter Maurer, president of the International Committee of the Red Cross, observed after touring the ravaged Strip, “I’ve never seen such massive destruction ever before.” According to the vagrant seated next to Professor Morris, “I think Protective Edge was 2014, but I’m just saying that the coordination in the military is pretty tight.” Was this destruction then the result of “pretty tight” precision attacks directed at military targets? An unimpeachable source definitively answers this question. Eyewitness accounts by Israeli combatants were compiled in a large dossier by Breaking the Silence, an Israeli non-governmental organization comprising former Israeli soldiers (“This is How We Fought in Gaza,” 2014). None of the hundreds of testimonies collected by this organization over more than a decade has ever been proven false, and all of them were approved for publication by the IDF censor. The leadership of Breaking the Silence is not conventionally leftist—it does not support the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement, opposes criminal prosecution of Israeli officers, and prudently fudges its own findings—while most of the soldier-witnesses themselves do not even appear contrite. Here’s a tiny sample of the “pretty tight” precision attacks directed exclusively at military targets:
“Shooting to kill. This is combat in an urban area, we’re in a war zone. The saying was: ‘There’s no such thing there as a person who is uninvolved.’ In that situation, anyone there is involved.”
*
“People who look at you from the window of a house that is in your designated area—they, to put it mildly, won’t look anymore.”
*
“The inclination is to avoid taking risks—rather to destroy everything we come across.”
*
“The assumption being that the moment we went into Gaza, anyone who dared poke his head out was a terrorist. . . , you are allowed to open fire.”
*
“The idea was, if you spot something—shoot. . . . Whether it posed a threat or not wasn’t a question, and that makes sense to me. If you shoot someone in Gaza it’s cool, no big deal. . . . They made it clear that there were no uninvolved civilians.”
*
“When we left after the operation, it was just a barren stretch of desert. . . . We spoke about it a lot amongst ourselves, the guys from the company, how crazy the amount of damage we did there was. I quote: ‘Listen man, it’s crazy what went on in there,’ ‘Listen man, we really messed them up,’ ‘Fuck, check it out, there’s nothing at all left . . . , it’s nothing but desert now, that’s crazy.’”
*
“I remember that the level of destruction looked insane to me.”
*
“The formal rules of engagement—I don’t know if for all soldiers—were, ‘Anything still there is as good as dead. Anything you see moving in the neighborhoods you’re in is not supposed to be there. The Palestinian civilians know they are not supposed to be there. Therefore whoever you see there, you kill.’ The commander [gave the order] ‘Anything you see in the neighborhoods you’re in, anything within a reasonable distance, say between zero and 200 meters—is dead on the spot. No authorization needed.’ . . . The working assumption states—and I want to stress that this is a quote of sorts: that anyone located in an IDF area, in areas the IDF took over—is not [considered] a civilian. That is the working assumption. We entered Gaza with that in mind, with an insane amount of firepower.”
*
“The instruction was: ‘Anyone you identify in the area—you shoot.’”
*
“It all looked like a science fiction movie . . . serious levels of destruction everywhere. . . . Everything was really in ruins. And non-stop fire all the time.”
*
“The instructions are to shoot right away. Whoever you spot—be they armed or unarmed, no matter what. The instructions are very clear. Any person you run into, that you see with your eyes—shoot to kill. It’s an explicit instruction.”
*
“I remember it, all the tanks were standing in a row, and I personally asked my commander: ‘Where are we firing at?’ He told me: ‘Pick wherever you feel like it.’”
*
“Before the entrance on foot to Gaza, a crazy amount of artillery was fired at the entire area. . . . Before a tank makes any movement it fires, every time. Those guys were trigger happy, totally crazy. Those were their orders, I’m certain of it, there’s no chance anybody would just go around shooting like that.”
*
“The explosions’ effects cause major amounts of damage, but that doesn’t interest anyone. ‘Use it, use it, explosives can’t be taken back,’ the platoon commander says, ‘I don’t want to leave explosives on me.’”
*
“I don’t really remember what was discussed in terms of formal instructions before we entered, and after we entered nobody really cared about the formal instructions anyway. That’s what we knew. Every tank commander knew, and even the simple soldiers knew,
that if something turns out to be not OK, they can say they saw something suspicious. They’ve got backup. They won’t ever be tried.”
*
“Our view was of the center of the Strip. Let’s say it was a real fireworks display. From a distance it looked pretty cool. . . . If you looked through a night vision scope you saw crazy wreckage, it was a real trip.”
*
“You’re shooting at anything that moves—and also at what isn’t moving, crazy amounts. . . . It also becomes a bit like a computer game, totally cool and real.”
*
“There were no rules of engagement. If you see anyone in that area, that person is a terrorist.”
*
“They went in just to destroy stuff. Just to purposely destroy stuff.”
*
“The rules of engagement were very, very lax. I wouldn’t say that they shot anything that moved—but they didn’t request authorization to fire either. There was no such thing as requesting authorization. Just fire.”
*
“That’s how it was, really—every tank just firing whatever it wanted to. And during the offensive, no one shot at us—not before it, not during it, and not after it. I remember that when we started withdrawing with the tanks, I looked toward the neighborhood, and I could simply see an entire neighborhood up in flames, like in the movies. Columns of smoke everywhere, the neighborhood in pieces, houses on the ground, and like, people were living there, but nobody had fired at us yet. We were firing purposelessly.”
*
“It was total destruction in there—the photos on line are child’s play compared to what we saw there in reality. . . . I never saw anything like it.”
*
“We were firing purposelessly all day long. Hamas was nowhere to be seen. . . . And the rules of engagement were pretty easy-going—I was shocked when I first heard them.”
*
“Everything is a suspicious spot. This is Gaza, you’re firing at everything.”
*
“They explained what you do if you see a civilian. They explained that that’s the way it is in combat. It was shoot to kill immediately if you see stuff. . . . Really, they did say, ‘If you see someone—shoot him.’”
*
“If it looks like a man, shoot. It was simple: You’re in a motherfucking combat zone. A few hours before you went in the whole area was bombed, if there’s anyone there who doesn’t clearly look innocent, you apparently need to shoot that person.”
*
“The unfathomable number of dead on one of the sides, the unimaginable level of destruction, the way militant cells and people were regarded as targets and not as living beings—that’s something that troubles me.”
*
“It’s destruction on a whole other level. . . . We just couldn’t believe it.”
*
“The briefing on rules of engagement was [to open first at], ‘Anything you think you should [open fire at]. . . . Anyone you spot that you can be positive is not the IDF.’ The only emphasis regarding rules of engagement was to make sure you weren’t firing at IDF forces, but other than that, ‘Any person you see.’ From the very start they told us, ‘Shoot to kill.’”
*
“The air force carries out an insane amount of strikes in Gaza during an operation like ‘Protective Edge.’”
*
“Shells are being fired all the time. Even if we aren’t actually going to enter: shells, shells, shells. A suspicious structure, an open area, a field, a place where a tunnel shaft could be—fire, fire, fire.”
***
If “these are things that are signed off by multiple different layers of command, by multiple people involved in an operation, including intelligence gathering, including weaponeering, and they also have typically lawyers involved,” if “the coordination in the military is pretty tight”—then, doesn’t that, on the contrary, PROVE that Israel has premeditatedly, systematically and egregiously breached the laws of war?
***
The collection fittingly concludes with this testimony:
“You leave Gaza and the most obvious question is, ‘Did you kill anybody?’ What can you do—even if you’ll meet the most left-wing girl in the world, eventually she’ll start thinking, ‘Did you ever kill somebody, or not.’ And what can you do about it, most people in our society consider that to be a badge of honor. So everybody wants to come out of there with that feeling of satisfaction.” -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein on Gaza youtu.be/N3uHqW4eezc
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
The book emerged from a conviction that understanding the significance and causes of 7 October, as well as the genocidal Israeli offensive that followed, had to begin by placing them in historical context.
New Texts Out Now with Jamie Stern-Weiner (ed.):
www.jadaliyya.com/Details/45855/Jamie-Stern-Weiner,-ed,-D… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
LEX FRIDMAN ASKS: DOES ISRAEL TARGET CIVILIANS?
In the course of a recent debate, moderator Lex Fridman posed the question, “Do you think there is a policy, top down from the IDF to target civilians?” (from the official transcript). Both Mouin Rabbani and I answered in the affirmative. Someone seated next to Professor Morris indignantly retorted that the notion of “a whole apparatus that tries to murder” was a “ridiculous argument.” To settle this matter, leaving not a smidgen of doubt, I recalled Gaza’s Great March of Return that began in March 2018. A distinguished independent international Commission of inquiry afterwards investigated these protests and produced a voluminous report running to fully 250 single-spaced pages (from which I will be quoting). The report states that at its inception the protests “could be characterized as a genuine popular festive event, with tens of thousands of people ... gathering around traditional activities, concerts, barbecues, cultural activities and sports games.” When Israel perpetrated a large scale massacre six weeks later on May 14, “anger over [the] killings and injuries drove groups of youths to engage in more violent actions.”
How did Israel respond to the overwhelmingly peaceful protesters as they gathered on March 30 and for weeks thereafter engaged in nonviolent demonstrations? It assembled along the perimeter of Gaza, according to Israeli officials, “specially trained snipers, in order to ensure accurate and measured use” of live ammunition. The IDF subsequently stated that “nothing was carried out uncontrolled; everything was accurate and measured, and we know where every bullet landed,” while then-Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman stated that “Israeli soldiers did what was necessary. I think all our soldiers deserve a medal.” The Commission of inquiry found that “demonstrators who were hundreds of meters away from the Israeli forces and visibly engaged in civilian activities were intentionally shot. Journalists and health workers who were clearly marked as such were shot, as were children, women, and persons with disabilities;” it also found “reasonable grounds to believe that the Israeli security forces killed and maimed Palestinian demonstrators who did not pose an imminent threat of death or serious injury to others when they were shot.” A large portion of the report documents in detail “emblematic” killings and injuries inflicted by Israel’s precision snipers. Herewith a tiny sample of these typical incidents as described by the Commission:
Mohammad Obeid, a 24-year-old footballer for the Al Salah Sports Club…, took out his telephone and began recording a “selfie” video. An Israeli Security Forces sniper shot him in the right side of his right leg as he filmed himself approximately 150 meters from the separation fence. The bullet passed through his right leg and hit his left leg just above the knee, shattering the base of his femur.… He was standing alone. The area was quiet and calm, there was no shooting from the Israeli side, no tear gas, no stone throwing from the Palestinian side, no one had set fire to tires.… Mohammad was speaking calmly and filming himself when the ISF sniper shot him.
Yousef Kronz was a 19-year-old student journalist when he attended the demonstration.…He wore a blue “PRESS” vest and carried his photography equipment, including a camera and a tripod. He sat cross-legged on top of a sand dune to take photographs of the demonstrators, at least 800 meters from the separation fence. After approximately 40 minutes…, as he stood up, the ISF shot him with two bullets in immediate succession which hit him in the right knee and the left knee.… Yousef’s right leg was later amputated.
Abed Hawajri was a 41-year-old man…. The ISF shot him in the abdomen.… Abed was standing near the back of a crowd when shot, with nothing in his hands…, approximately 150 meters from the fence. He was taken to the hospital and died the same day.
A 16-year-old boy climbed onto high ground … approximately 300 meters from the separation fence. He was distributing sandwiches to demonstrators. The ISF then shot him in the face with a single bullet, which entered his nose and exited his skull. As a result of his injuries, he had a fractured jaw, is deaf in one ear and is unable to taste or smell.
Naji Abu Hojayeer was a 25-year-old mechanic…. An ISF soldier … shot him in the abdomen…. He died the same day.… Naji was standing 300 meters from the separation fence when he was shot. He was wrapped in a Palestinian flag, surrounded by hundreds of people.
Mohammad Ajouri, a 17-year-old … member of the Palestinian Athletics Organization…handed out onions and water to protestors to relieve symptoms of teargas inhalation. When he was approximately 300 meters away from the fence, ISF soldiers shot Mohammad in the back of his right leg. Doctors had to amputate his leg as a result.
Jihad Abu Jamous was a 30-year-old man…. ISF soldiers shot him in the head with live ammunition when he was approximately 250 to 300 meters from the fence. He died immediately.
Alaa Dali is a 21-year-old cyclist for the Palestinian Cycling Team. He had earned a slot to participate in the Asian Games in the summer of 2018.… An ISF sniper shot him in his right leg … as he stood alone watching the demonstration approximately 300 meters from the separation fence … while wearing his cycling gear and holding his bicycle. The nearest demonstrator was approximately 15 meters in front of him.… Doctors amputated Alaa’s leg above the knee in order to save his life.
Ali Khafajah was a university student…. ISF soldiers shot him in the head with live ammunition…. Ali was talking on his phone while standing in a crowd about 150 meters from the separation fence when he was shot.… He died at the hospital.
The ISF shot 14-year-old Mohammad Ayoub … in the head…. Mohammad was at least 200 meters from the separation fence when the ISF shot him.
The ISF shot 14-year-old Haytham Jamal in the abdomen. He was killed with a single shot as he stood in a crowd watching the ISF fire tear gas at another group of demonstrators.
Majdi Al Satari was an 11-year-old child…. He was shot in the head by live ammunition by an ISF sharpshooter while attending the protest…. Majdi died of severe brain lacerations ….Majdi was shot while standing … about 100 meters away from the security fence.
ISF soldiers shot 16-year-old Ahmad Abu Tyoor in the thigh as he danced a traditional Palestinian dance alone with his hands in the air, around 10-15 meters from the separation fence. The bullet severed his femoral artery and he died of his wounds the following day.
The ISF shot 11-year-old Nasser Mosabeh in the back of the head…. Nasser had been helping his two volunteer paramedic sisters treating injured people…. When the victim was shot, he was under a tree, 250 meters from the fence…. The bullet entered the right side of his head behind his ear and parts of his skull and brain were found close to his body.
Musa Abu Hassainen was a 35-year-old Civil Defense paramedic. ISF soldiers killed him with a shot to the chest … while he was wearing a high-visibility Civil Defense vest.… He was approximately 250-300 meters from the fence when ISF soldiers shot him.
Abed Abdullah Al Qotati was a 22-year-old volunteer paramedic…. ISF soldiers shot him in the chest in Rafah … as he was tending to an injured demonstrator near the separation fence. Abdullah was wearing a white paramedic jacket and carrying a red first-aid kit when the ISF soldiers shot him.… He died of bleeding and lacerations to his thoracic organs.
Tarek Loubani is a Canadian-Palestinian physician.… The ISF shot him as he stood among a group of paramedics wearing his hospital uniform. He was shot with one bullet that passed through both legs. Visibility was clear. There were no demonstrators near the group of medics and there was no shooting from the ISF either immediately before or after he was shot.
The ISF shot a 24-year-old freelance photojournalist … in the abdomen with live ammunition. He was standing with his back to the separation fence, around 300 meters away. When he was shot he was taking a break from photographing along with two other photojournalists from international news agencies. He was wearing a blue vest marked “PRESS” and the bullet entered his mid-section just below the vest.
The ISF shot 30-year-old journalist Yasser Murtaja with live ammunition in the lower abdomen as he covered the demonstration site…. Yasser was wearing a dark blue bulletproof vest clearly marked with the word “PRESS,” and a blue helmet.… He was standing approximately 300 meters from the separation fence, behind a large group of demonstrators. Visibility was good, and there were no other shots fired in the vicinity at the time. The gunshot hit him in the abdomen…, and [he] died of his injuries the following morning.
The ISF killed Ahmed Abu Hussein, a 24-year-old journalist…. Publicly available video footage of Ahmed’s shooting ... clearly shows him standing still taking photographs of demonstrators…. At the moment he was shot, Abu Hussein was approximately 250-300 meters from the fence. He was clearly marked as a journalist, wearing a blue helmet and a blue vest marked “PRESS.”
Fadi Abu Salmi was a 29-year-old double amputee…. The ISF shot him in the chest…. He died immediately. The ISF shot him … as he sat in his wheelchair under a tree approximately 250-300 meters from the separation fence with two friends.
Ahmad Abu Aqel was 24 years old…. He walked with crutches…. He sat down alone on a small sand hill … approximately 150 meters from the separation fence … with his back towards the fence. The ISF shot him in the back of the head…. He died the same day.
***
The wonder is that in the here and now it can still be doubted that Israel targets civilians: Haven’t the UN, senior public officials, humanitarian organizations, and human rights groups explicitly and unequivocally denounced Israel for using starvation “as a weapon of war. Israel is provoking famine” (EU foreign policy chief Josep Borrell)? -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
LEX FRIDMAN ASKS: DOES ISRAEL TARGET CIVILIANS?
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/publish/post/142894132 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Kiko's Freethinker's Forum Episode 109: Norman Finkelstein talks Identity Politics, Middle East, Chuck Schumer and Cornel West www.normanfinkelstein.com/kikos-freethinkers-forum-episod…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein on Genocide in Gaza | A Busboys and Poets Program www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-on-genocide-…
@krystalball -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein on Genocide in Gaza | A Busboys and Poets Program www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-on-genocide-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Mar 31, 2024 5:00 pm
Location: 14th & V
2021 14th St NW, Washington, District of Columbia, 20009 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
James Elder, UNICEF spokesperson, 22 March:
> “The depth of the horror surpasses our ability to describe it… As soon as you drive through the north, you get that universal gesture of hunger of people putting their hands to their mouths. A lot of children, women with very gaunt faces. In [the city of] Khan Younis, there is utter annihilation. I’ve not seen that level of devastation in 20 years with the UN. People’s coping capacity in the north has been smashed and in the south it is hanging by a thread" -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
The Palestine Center
@PalestineCenter
Join us next week for a conversation with @normfinkelstein on the persistent disregard of the urgent calls to end the #gaza blockade such as the March or Return, and how years of international inaction and complicity have culminated in the current disaster in Gaza, moderated by @JehadAbusalim.
🗓️ Friday, March 29 | 12:00 PM EST
Register here: us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_rvIMyUcmRwOmsl9L85-frg -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
MORON SPECIALIS
I have been challenged on one—and only one—point in the Lex Fridman debate. Here is the relevant excerpt from the official transcript. I have filled in the legal term that I used and placed it in upper case:
STEVEN BONNELL (03:17:58) I don’t know if you used the phrase dolus specialis, that the intentional part of genocide-
MOUIN RABBANI (03:17:58) I don’t know that term.
STEVEN BONNELL (03:18:35) I think it’s called dolus specialis, it’s the most important part of genocide, which is proving it is a highly special intent to commit genocide. It’s possible that Israel could-
NORMAN FINKELSTEIN (03:18:43) That’s MENS REA 03:18:43].
STEVEN BONNELL (03:18:46) Yes, I understand the state of mind, but for genocide, it’s called dolus specialis. It’s a highly special intent. Did you read the case?
NORMAN FINKELSTEIN (03:18:47) Yeah.
STEVEN BONNELL (03:18:54) It is a highly special intent [inaudible 03:18:56]-
MENS REA (criminal intent, from the Latin for “guilty mind”) denotes the legal principle at stake while DOLUS SPECIALIS (criminal intent to commit genocide) denotes one application of it. Here is an example of this usage from the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda:
“In considering whether a perpetrator had the requisite mens rea, regard must be had to his mode of participation in the given crime. Under the Bisesero Indictment, Elizaphan Ntakirutimana was convicted of aiding and abetting genocide while Gérard Ntakirutimana was convicted of committing genocide. The requisite mens rea for aiding and abetting genocide is the accomplice’s knowledge of the genocidal intent of the principal perpetrators. From the evidence, the Trial Chamber found that the attackers in Bisesero had the specific genocidal intent. Furthermore, in the view of the Appëals Chamber, it is clear that Elizaphan Ntakirutimana knew of this intent. The Trial Chamber found that Elizaphan Ntakirutimana was present during several attacks on refugees in Bisesero, including situations where the armed attackers sang: ‘Exterminate t .... Let them; look for them everywhere; kill them; and ... exterminate them’, while chasing and killing Tutsis. It is from this, as well as from Iris transporting the armed attackers and directing them toward fleeing Tutsi refugees that the Trial Chamber found that Elizaphan Ntaldrutimana had the requisite intent to commit genocide, convicting him of aiding and abetting genocide. In the view of the Appeals Chamber, it is not necessary to consider whether the Trial Chamber correctly concluded that Elizaphan Ntakirutimana had the specific intent to commit genocide, given that it convicted him not of committing that crime, but rather of aiding and abetting genocide, a mode of criminal participation which does not require the specific intent. The Appeals Chamber finds that Elizaphan Ntakirutimana knew of the genocidal intent of the attackers whom he aided and abetted in the perpetration of genocide in Bisesero and, therefore, that he possessed the requisite mens rea for that crime.” (ucr.irmct.org/LegalRef/CMSDocStore/Public/English/Judgeme…)
Did these distinguished judges err by referring to mens rea and not dolus specialis? I was stating the obvious that the critical point of contention in a genocide case is proving criminal INTENT (“That’s mens rea”), and of course everyone in the room understood that the threshold under the Genocide Convention is proving criminal INTENT to commit genocide. Speaking of fantastic morons, I wonder how Mr. Vermicelli is doing. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
"Indispensable... a tour de force" - @normfinkelstein
"Eye-opening, compelling, required reading" - @kthalps
"First-rate analysis... a truly important antidote" - @MearsheimerJ
"Comprehensive and compassionate" - @CornelWest
Learn more at the link below! -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
I will be speaking on SATURDAY, MARCH 16 at GRAND ARMY PLAZA library. They put me at 11:30 pm (yes, 11:30 AT NIGHT!) in the basement. I suppose it could have been worse: 3:00 am in the broom closet. Whoever is sleepwalking at that hour, head on over. Here's the announcement:
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
UN Special Representative Pramila Patten states in her report that her mission viewed fully 5,000 photographs and 50 hours of footage of the October 7 attack supplied to her by the Israeli government and available in open sources. This digital evidence, from every conceivable angle and by every conceivable electronic device (bodycams, dashcams, individual cellphones, CCTV, and traffic surveillance cameras) DIDN'T YIELD ONE SINGLE IMAGE OF SEXUAL VIOLENCE. The report also states that it COULDN'T LOCATE ANY FORENSIC EVIDENCE of sexual violence. The report also states that it was UNABLE TO MEET A SINGLE SURVIVOR of sexual violence on October 7. What does Patten then conclude? "There are reasonable grounds to believe that multiple incidents of rape, including gang rape, occurred." Isn't it time for UN Secretary-General Guterres to appoint a Special Representative to investigate Pramila Patten?
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
UN "Special Representative" Pramila Patten told the Security Council that there is "clear and convincing" evidence that Israeli hostages were raped, and that there are "reasonable grounds to believe" that hostages are still being raped. These are SHOCKING BAREFACED LIES transparently designed to justify Israel's ongoing genocide. Will any UN official summon the courage to publicly challenge her?
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Arabic Translation of “PRAMILA PATTEN’S RAPE FANTASIES: A Critical Analysis of the UN Report on Sexual Violence during the 7 October Attack” – تخيّلات براميلا باتن بخصوص عمليات الاغتصاب: تحليل نقدي لتقرير الأمم المتحدة بشأن العنف الجنسي أثناء هجوم 7 تشرين الأول/ أكتوبر
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein on Substack:
PRAMILA PATTEN’S RAPE FANTASIES open.substack.com/pub/normanfinkelstein/p/pramila-pattens… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Patten will be speaking today (Monday) on her report:
www.timesofisrael.com/un-security-council-to-meet-monday-…
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
PRAMILA PATTEN’S RAPE FANTASIES: A Critical Analysis of the UN Report on Sexual Violence during the 7 October Attack www.normanfinkelstein.com/pramila-pattens-rape-fantasies-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Patten will be speaking today (Monday) on her report:
www.timesofisrael.com/un-security-council-to-meet-monday-…
Here's my analysis to her report:
PRAMILA PATTEN’S RAPE FANTASIES: A Critical Analysis of the UN Report on Sexual Violence during the 7 October Attack www.normanfinkelstein.com/pramila-pattens-rape-fantasies-… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Pramila Patten will be speaking at the UN Security Council today on her Sexual Violence "report." It's impossible to know whether Patten is incompetent or cynical (or both). What's certain is that her "report" is rubbish. Here's my analysis:
PRAMILA PATTEN’S RAPE FANTASIES: A Critical Analysis of the UN Report on Sexual Violence during the 7 October Attack www.normanfinkelstein.com/pramila-pattens-rape-fantasies-… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Did Pramila Patten Concoct a Fraud?
Coming Monday, March 11, 2024
Norman Finkelstein on "PRAMILA PATTEN’S RAPE FANTASIES: A Critical Analysis of the UN Report on Sexual Violence during the 7 October Attack." -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein on Biden and the Nazi princess, Ursula von der Leyen. youtu.be/d2dX9BPN0oI
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Surprise Biden Announcement in State of the Union Address:
"The US will supply the Starship Enterprise with 1,000,000 Morton pot pies and Captain Kirk will beam them down. The starship's phaser banks will be set at medium warm to heat the pot pies on the ground. We consider this the most practical solution to the famine conditions in Gaza." -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The other day I participated in a debate with Israeli professor Benny Morris and That Thing Called Destiny. They mocked the notion that Gaza was verging on famine.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Coming Monday, March 11
Norman Finkelstein on "PRAMILA PATTEN’S RAPE FANTASIES: A Critical Analysis of the UN Report on Sexual Violence during the 7 October Attack" -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Coming Monday, March 11
Norman Finkelstein on "PRAMILA PATTEN’S RAPE FANTASIES: A Critical Analysis of the UN Report on Sexual Violence during the 7 October Attack" -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The rally is today!
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
US aiddrops on Gaza
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
The one and only Mouin Rabbani on the US airdropped.
mediaview.aljazeera.com/video/CliOs6WoFc -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
ALL OUT FOR GAZA! Hope to see you at Washington Square on March 2.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Tomorrow, Thursday Feb 29, Norman Finkelstein and Mouin Rabbani will square off against Benny Morris and Steven Bonnell (Destiny) over the Gaza conflict: a defining issue of our time.
You can watch the debate on Lex Fridman's YouTube channel.
As preparation for the debate, you can download a free chapter from Finkelstein's masterpiece, Knowing Too Much, where he meticulously critiques Morris. Join the mailing list of OR Books and get the free chapter delivered to your inbox.
@orbooks
orbooks.com/news/norman-fi…
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Maher Arar
@ArarMaher
"Who Attacked Al-Ahli Hospital on Oct 17, 2023".
Investigation by @ararmaher
1- Summary:
ararmaher.wordpress.com/2024/02/21/who-commited-the-massa……
2- Full:
ararmaher.wordpress.com/2024/02/13/how-the-media-misled-t…….
Video below shows an animated bomb drop on Al-Ahli Hospital. Read full investigation for more details. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Ghassan Abu Sitta, Chair of Conflict Medicine AUB
@GhassanAbuSitt1
No Israeli journalists were killed in 2023. Morally bankrupt whitewashing. The inability of western journalist to feel any kind of solidarity or kinship with Palestinian journalist shows how deep-seated white supremacy is within this profession.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
"After Israel launched the attack [on Gaza] at the end of 2008 and proceeded to obliterate everything in sight, Morris promptly published an op-ed in the New York Times pushing all the right buttons (“many Israelis feel that the walls . . . are closing in . . . much as they felt in early June 1967”) and praising “Israel’s highly efficient air assault” on Gaza. Meanwhile, as Israel keeps endeavoring to recruit Washington for an assault on Iran, Morris continues to make the rounds in the West repeatedly warning, Cassandra-like, that if the Americans do not launch a conventional attack Israel would be compelled and justified in launching a nuclear strike to prevent a “second Holocaust.”"
You can download this chapter, HISTORY BY SUBTRACTION, from Finkelstein's masterpiece, Knowing Too Much, where he meticulously critiques Morris. Join OR BOOKS @orbooks mailing list and get the free chapter delivered to your inbox.
orbooks.com/news/norman-finkelstein-takes-on-israels-grea… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
@normfinkelstein and @MouinRabbani take on Israel's leading historian over the Gaza conflict.
Hosted by @lexfridman
Get ready by reading Finkelstein's brilliant debunking of Morris, sent to your inbox free of charge when you join our mailing list: -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
"Morris also repeatedly alleged that during the 1982 Lebanon war Israel was “reluctant to harm civilians,” sought to “avoid casualties on both sides,” and “took care not to harm Lebanese and Palestinian civilians." From Finkelstein's book Knowing too Much.
As preparation for the debate with Benny Morris on Feb 29, you can download a free chapter from Finkelstein's Knowing Too Much, where he meticulously critiques Morris. Join OR Books mailing list and get the free chapter delivered to your inbox.
@orbooks
orbooks.com/news/norman-finkelstein-takes-on-israels-grea…
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
During the Israeli invasion of Beirut in 1982, Israel has used vacuum bombs killing hundreds of civilians. In one building in Beirut,Aker building, there was a massacre where more than 40 families displaced from Dbayyeh Palestinian refugee camps were killed.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Where is the Middle East headed after Oct 7 and the US role. With Norman Finkelstein, Vijay and Jeffrey Sachs
@normfinkelstein youtu.be/JO8ROnCvR0M -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
I was in Beirut during the 1982 Israeli invasion of Lebanon. One one day the bombing was very brutal that the rescue workers were unable to extract all bodies in the next day. 500 people killed/wounded, 600 homes destroyed. This was already after the PLO agreed to leave Beirut.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Morris repeatedly alleged that during the 1982 Lebanon war
Israel was “reluctant to harm civilians,” sought to “avoid casualties on both
sides,” and “took care not to harm Lebanese and Palestinian civilians.” ...
Whereas Morris alleged that “Israel tried to pinpoint military tar-
gets” during the siege of Beirut, Robert Fisk in his classic eyewitness ac-
count Pity the Nation reported: “To call the gunfire indiscriminate was an understatement. It would also have been a lie. The Israeli bombardment of
4 August was, we realized, later, discriminate. It targeted every civilian area,
every institution in west Beirut—hospitals, schools, apartments, shops,
newspaper offices, hotels, the prime minister’s office and the parks. Incredibly, the Israeli shells even blew part of the roof off the city’s synagogue.”
The chapter on Morris can be downloaded for free from OR Books @orbooks
orbooks.com/news/norman-finkelstein-takes-on-israels-grea… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
orbooks.com/news/norman-finkelstein-takes-on-israels-grea…
@orbooks
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Morris has contributed the expulsion of my parents to their "Islamic expulsionist Judeophobia". "The indigenous population of a country has metamorphosed into expulsionists" because they resisted expulsion. To read more, download Finkelstein chapter on Benny Morris from OR books
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Morris has contributed the expulsion of my parents to their "Islamic expulsionist Judeophobia". "The indigenous population of a country has metamorphosed into expulsionists" because they resisted expulsion. To read more, download Finkelstein chapter on Benny Morris from OR books
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
My parents were brutally expelled from Palestine in 1948. They lived the rest of their lives as Palestinian refugees. Benny Morris has a different story to tell. Read Norman Finkelstein chapter on Benny Morris. You can download it for free from OR Books
orbooks.com/news/norman-finkelstein-takes-on-israels-grea… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
As preparation for the debate between Norman Finkelstein and Benny Morris, you can download a free chapter from Finkelstein's masterpiece, Knowing Too Much, where Finkelstein meticulously critiques Morris. Join OR BOOKS @orbooks mailing list and get the free chapter delivered to your inbox.
orbooks.com/news/norman-fi… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
On Feb 29, Norman Finkelstein and Mouin Rabbani will square off against Benny Morris and Steven Bonnell (Destiny) over the Gaza conflict: a defining issue of our time.
You can watch the debate on Lex Fridman's YouTube channel.
As preparation for the debate, you can download a free chapter from Finkelstein's masterpiece, Knowing Too Much, where he meticulously critiques Morris. Join the mailing list of OR Books and get the free chapter delivered to your inbox.
@orbooks
orbooks.com/news/norman-fi… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
What is UNRWA? UNRWA came into existence after the first attempt to implement a two-state settlement in 1948 ended in catastrophe.
Read more about this history in @MouinRabbani's ongoing post analyzing the war on Gaza:
www.jadaliyya.com/Details/45557/Ongoing-Quick-Thoughts-on… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
"Once an industrious clerk, the new Morris has metamorphosed into a raging kook. In all fairness to him, it is of course arguable that Morris has honestly come to reconsider his former conclusions on the basis of new evidence;
to discover that, however deficient their scholarship, the conclusions of the
old historians were right after all. The problem is that Morris does not ad-
duce new evidence to support his return to the old orthodoxy, but rather
whites out the findings of his own pioneering research. This genre might be
called doing history not by accretion but by subtraction."
You can download the whole chapter, History by Subtraction, from OR books @orbooks
orbooks.com/news/norman-finkelstein-takes-on-israels-grea… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Old Morris vs New Morris: You can download for free the chapter on Benny Morris, History by Subtraction, from Finkelstein's book Knowing Too Much from OR Books @orbooks. Reading the chapter is a good preparation for the debate
on Feb 29 between Norman Finkelstein and Mouin Rabbani against Benny Morris and Steven Bonnell (Destiny) over the Gaza conflict: a defining issue of our time.
You can watch the debate on Lex Fridman's YouTube channel.
Join OR books mailing list and get the free chapter delivered to your inbox.
@orbooks
orbooks.com/news/norman-finkelstein-takes-on-israels-grea… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Next week, on Feb 29, Norman Finkelstein and Mouin Rabbani will square off against Benny Morris and Steven Bonnell (Destiny) over the Gaza conflict: a defining issue of our time.
You can watch the debate on Lex Fridman's YouTube channel.
As preparation for the debate, you can download a free chapter from Finkelstein's masterpiece, Knowing Too Much, where he meticulously critiques Morris. Join our mailing list and get the free chapter delivered to your inbox.
@orbooks
orbooks.com/news/norman-finkelstein-takes-on-israels-grea… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
As preparation for the debate between Norman Finkelstein and Benny Morris, you can download a free chapter from Finkelstein's masterpiece, Knowing Too Much, where he meticulously critiques Morris. Join OR BOOKS @orbooks mailing list and get the free chapter delivered to your inbox.
orbooks.com/news/norman-finkelstein-takes-on-israels-grea… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein takes on Israel's greatest historian: Benny Morris - OR Books @orbooks
Prepare for THE GREAT DEBATE by reading Norman Finkelstein's detailed critique of Benny Morris. To obtain a FREE EBOOK COPY, just click this link:
orbooks.com/news/norman-finkelstein-takes-on-israels-grea… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Feb 29: Norman Finkelstein and Mouin Rabbani will square off against Benny Morris and Steven Bonnell (Destiny) over the Gaza conflict: a defining issue of our time. You can watch the debate on Lex Fridman's YouTube channel
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Prepare for THE GREAT DEBATE by reading Norman Finkelstein's detailed critique of Benny Morris. To obtain a FREE EBOOK COPY, just click this link:
orbooks.com/news/norman-finkelstein-takes-on-israels-grea… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Benny Morris is Israel's leading historian.
@normfinkelstein and @MouinRabbani its most brilliant critics.
They're debating the conflict in one week, hosted by @LexFridman.
We published Finkelstein’s meticulous critique of Morris. Join our mailing list for your free copy: -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
US now genocidesplaining its veto...
HE
@hasmikegian
4th US veto on Gaza ceasefire. UK abstention. 13 in favour.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
nor have an inkling that they are entitled to any rights. Rather, it is only because such ideas are being implanted into their unthinking heads by UNRWA that they call themselves refugees and insist they have rights vis-à-vis Israel. No UNRWA, no Palestine refugee question.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
UNRWA’s role, with certain exceptions, is limited to the provision of services to Palestine refugees registered with the Agency within its areas of operations, whether they live within these camps or outside them.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: What is UNRWA (Part I)? The United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Middle East, commonly known by the acronym UNRWA, is the UN agency that currently provides humanitarian relief and services to Palestinian refugees in Jordan, Syria, Lebanon,
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: My comments to the Annual Palestine Forum in Doha earlier today: I’ve been asked to speak on the topic of “Hamas in the Aftermath of the War on Gaza”. It’s a topic that makes a number of assumptions: that this war will have a defined ending and aftermath;
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Yesterday the NY Times ran yet another ridiculous article based on "anonymous Israeli sources" alleging that the IDF attacked al-Shifa hospital because of Hamas tunnels beneath it. (1)
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
It couldn't but be wondered why now, three months after the fact and after so much other fake Times news about al-Shifa? The answer wasn't long in coming. Today the IDF invaded Nasser hospital, housing 9,000 refugees, on the grounds that Hamas was using it. (2)
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Will the NY Times win a special Oscar for "Best Supporting Role in Israel's Genocide"? (3)
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A world-historic confrontation is now unfolding as South Africa exhorts the ICJ to deliver an emergency ruling on the imminent genocide in Rafah. 1/2
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
It's South Africa demanding an equal place under the sun for the world's colored peoples versus Israel holding fast to a sacrosanct principle of the Jewish States, "Schwarzes need not apply." 2/2
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Warsaw-Rafah: Scurrying Cockroaches www.normanfinkelstein.com/cockroaches/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
COCKROACHES www.normanfinkelstein.com/cockroaches/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
ACCORDING TO ANONYMOUS ISRAELI OFFICIALS www.normanfinkelstein.com/according-to-anonymous-israeli-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
As the number of Hamas "terrorists" allegedly working in UNRWA plummets, the Times' Patrick Kingsley was overheard singing this:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0SkWCCWrF8 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Hail Patrick Kingsley, Starver of Children! www.normanfinkelstein.com/hail-patrick-kingsley-starver-o…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
STOP THE PRESSES! The New York Times has discovered that the Israeli Mongol hordes are systematically destroying civilian infrastructure in Gaza ("Israel's Controlled Demolitions are Razing Neighborhoods in Gaza," 01 February 2024). www.normanfinkelstein.com/stop-the-presses-the-new-york-t…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
ANOTHER DAY, ANOTHER PATRICK KINGSLEY “SCOOP” www.normanfinkelstein.com/66606-2/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
SIMPLE TRUTHS www.normanfinkelstein.com/simple-truths/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
ANOTHER DAY, ANOTHER PATRICK KINGSLEY “SCOOP”:
(1/)Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
That a humungous Hamas moonbeam hidden in an UNRWA toilet bowl targeted Holocaust survivor Elie Wiesel’s gravesite; and that, on Hamas orders, UNRWA has blocked distribution of puberty blockers.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
In the face of this avalanche of revelations, it boggles the mind why Kingsley squandered precious Times space on the ICJ genocide opinion.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
SIMPLE TRUTHS: Behind the contrived hysteria at UNRWA lurks Western fury at the ICJ decision; If Israel is plausibly guilty of genocide, then the “enlightened” West stands guilty of complicity in genocide; (1/)
Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
And the Houthis!, who don't stop their ears and blind their eyes to the agonized cries in Gaza, but—moved by the natural faculty of pity, and lacking the gift of "reason" to rationalize away this pity—have instead thrown down the gauntlet to the barbarous West.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
No business as usual—No commerce, No trade—while Gaza is crucified!
“Men would never have been anything but monsters, if nature had not given them pity to aid their reason.” (Rousseau) -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Julie Sebutinde www.normanfinkelstein.com/julie-sebutinde/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Patrick Kingsley: Whore of War Par Excellence www.normanfinkelstein.com/patrick-kingsley-whore-of-war-p…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
IMBECILE ALERT!
I posted this morning that, even if Hamas members implicated in the October 7 attack worked for UNRWA, all it would prove was that Hamas members had day jobs. Not even Israel purports that UNRWA was privy to their alleged membership.(1)
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
My commonplace observation evoked outrage: It's our taxpayer money that's financing UNRWA! If a former IDF member studying at an American university committed war crimes in Gaza----which, more often than not, is the case--should the university be defunded? (2)
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Why does it outrage to fund a humanitarian organization that, unbeknownst to it, might have had Hamas militants on its staff, but it's not an outrage to fund a State that, according to the International Court of Justice, is plausibly committing genocide?(3)
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Ghassan Abu Sitta, Chair of Conflict Medicine AUB
@GhassanAbuSitt1
Defunding UNRWA in the midst of the carnage constitutes "complicity" in genocide.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Stop the Presses! Hamas Militants Have Day Jobs!
Let’s assume the horrible, awful, godforsaken worst: several of the 3,000 Hamas militants involved in the October 7 attack worked in UNRWA. Others no doubt worked in hospitals, bakeries, banks, and schools. (1/3)Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The sadistic Western powers—led by the U.S. and including Germany, Japan, Canada, Netherlands, Britain, Australia, Austria, and Finland—have now suspended aid to the starving people of Gaza. (4)
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
One hopes the great Houthi people, while carrying out their humanitarian mission, will take special note of ships from these countries.(5)
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Patrick Kingsley: NY Times Ace Sleuth
As the IDF closed in on al-Shifa hospital, Patrick Kingsley kept peddling Israeli disinformation that it was a Hamas command-and-control center. (1)Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Israeli evidence of Hamas phone intercepts in the past proved to be forgeries. Kingsley doesn’t mention any of Israel’s prior disinformation campaigns--unsurprisingly, as he was Israel's chief conduit. (4)
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What prevents Israel from just releasing these “text messages” and “phone intercepts”? The only purpose of Kingsley’s sleuthing is to contrive “evidence” in the absence—so far—of evidence.(5)
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
My thoughts on this proposed debate below
Lex Fridman
@lexfridman
I would like to host an Israel-Palestine debate, and to do it well: 3-5+ hours, in-person, focused on exploring ideas & history, with empathy, rigor, and respect. Please suggest people who could represent each side. Reply below and/or vote in this form: form.jotform.com/lexfridman/israel-palestine-debate
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein and Craig Mokhiber Explain ICJ Genocide Decision on Israel www.youtube.com/live/Kj7mqGVg554
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Live with Restream x.com/i/broadcasts/1rmxPMERWNVKN
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Live with Restream x.com/i/broadcasts/1jMKgmlyqbkJL
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein will be going live shortly. Sorry for the delay. we are having some technical difficulties. Please tune in in few minutes to hear his comments on the upcoming ICJ decision.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Tune in today, Thursday Jan 25 at 10:30 a.m. ET to Twitter Go Live with Norman Finkelstein to hear his comments on ICJ.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Tune in today, Thursday Jan 25 at 10:30 a.m. ET to Twitter Go Live with Norman Finkelstein to hear his comments on ICJ.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
The Katie Halper Show
@KatieHalperShow
“It’s 84 pages & extremely impressive. Even someone like myself who thought i knew everything , I learned from it” - @normfinkelstein on ICJ South African hearing
with @normfinkelstein x @briebriejoy x @krystalball x @MouinRabbani
live rn-
www.youtube.com/live/EmEsv9g7eI8 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Obstacle to Peace youtu.be/-_pMXQZ8LxQ via @YouTube
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norm Finkelstein & Mouin Rabbani BREAK DOWN Israeli Genocide Case w/Bria... youtube.com/live/EmEsv9g7eI8
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
On January 16, 2024, the New York Times ran a major investigative story based on alleged new revelations about Hamas tunnels and relying entirely on official Israeli sources. It reported "details and new information about the tunnels ... the scope, depth and quality of the tunnels built by Hamas have astonished [Israelis]. .. . The Israeli military now believes there are far more tunnels under Gaza.... Senior Israeli defense officials, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss intelligence matters, are currently estimating the network is between 350 and 450 miles .... there are close to 5,700 separate shafts leading down to the tunnels." But already on January 12, in its oral argument at the International Court of Justice, Israel matter-of-factly recited these "intelligence" secrets that supposedly "astonished" them:
"Hamas ... has built an extensive warren of underground tunnels for its leaders and fighters, several hundred miles in length, throughout the Strip, with thousands of access points and terrorist hubs located in homes, mosques, United Nations facilities, schools and perhaps most shockingly hospitals."
So what was the point of the Times article except to recycle Israeli propaganda as a major Times "scoop"--and provide Israel with an alibi for its genocidal assault on Gaza? -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Will Patrick Kingsley's Extraordinary Revelation in Today's New York Times Win Him a Pulitzer?
"Speaking on condition of strict anonymity, a senior Israeli official informed the Times that 'the Prime Minister of the State of Israel is Benjamin Netanyahu.'" -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Katie Halper
@kthalps
MONDAY at 8pm EST the Katie Halper Show joins forces with @krystalball & @briebriejoy to host a discussion with @normfinkelstein & @MouinRabbani on South Africa's genocide case against Israel at the International Court of Justice (ICJ). Tune in here www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmEsv9g7eI8
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
According to the Daily Mail, in his court papers filing for divorce, Michael Haley alleges that, while he was on duty in Iraq, wife Nikki Haley was having an affair with one "Hottie Houthi." Speaking on condition of anonymity,. "Hottie Houthi" told Patrick Kingsley of the N.Y. Times, "We only had one tryst in a Hamas tunnel beneath the Eiffel Tower. It was very romantic." Speaking on condition of anonymity, Prime Minister Netanyahu told Kingsley, "Nikki Haley and Hottie Houthi are both goys. Israel is the Nation-State of the Jewish People. We don't give a flying f*** what they do or where they do it." Speaking on condition of anonymity, Kingsley then asked the Prime Minister, "But what if the transgender person fighting with the IDF in Gaza had an affair with Hottie Houthi?" Speaking on condition of anonymity, Netanyahu responded...
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
As Valentine's Day approaches, here are four t-shirt ideas for your loved one:
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
If There Were a Pulitzer Prize for Yentas...
The N.Y. Times' Isabel Kershner reported today from northern Gaza. Widely acclaimed as the "Yenta Queen" of journalists, Kershner states that it was a “dark wasteland ... Buildings ... were flattened into layers of concrete. We saw no people, only a few dogs.” But she doesn’t say why it was a wasteland, who flattened the buildings, or why it was empty. She dutifully quotes one female officer: “The military ‘does everything’ to try to avoid civilian casualties and lamented the destruction of so many homes. But it was Hamas, she said, that turned Gaza into a war zone.” Why bother to mention Israel has indiscriminately bombed Gaza with an intensity not witnessed even during the Allied bombing of Dresden? Kershner proudly proclaims that the Israeli military wasn’t permitted to screen her coverage beforehand. But why would they bother? Himmler didn't screen Julius Streicher's coverage either. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Happy Days Are Here Again!
Even as Gaza heads toward mass famine, the New York Times manages to bring cheery news by Isabel Kershner. The only qualifications of this “reporter” – apart from taking excellent dictation from Israel hasbara (propaganda) officials – are that she makes excellent chicken broth and won a Jerusalem Mah Jong tournament. Kershner reports that female soldiers now get to kill women and children in Gaza and that – brace yourself! – this novelty has won the “respect” of “Druze and Bedouin Muslim men.” (“Israeli Women Fight on Frontline in Gaza, A First,” 19 January 2024) And then Kershner throws in this inspirational tidbit: “at least one transgender soldier has fought on the front in Gaza.” Truly, Israel is a democracy: every Jew gets to commit genocide. Let’s hope and pray that the day is not long in coming when female Israelis cross that ultimate threshold of equality: they, too, can pull the plug on incubators. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
NY Times: The Worst Is Over
I read today in the Guardian that international humanitarian “officials said they strongly suspected that ‘pockets of famine’ existed in northern Gaza.” But then I read in today’s Times a semi-upbeat article on northern Gaza titled “Some residents say they can walk through war-ravaged Gaza City more freely.” In other words, the worst is over; no need to indict Israel for genocide. The story’s byline reads: “Adam Ragson and Aaron Boxerman reporting from Jerusalem.” (Ragson used to work for the Jerusalem Post and Boxerman for the Times of Israel; both propaganda rags.) Sitting in a Jerusalem café, sipping a latte, they obviously know better than aid agencies in Gaza what the situation is, or they just decided that walking freely was more significant than facing famine. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
WHORE OF WAR
New York Times correspondent Patrick Kingsley reports that Hamas has built up to 450 miles of tunnels in Gaza. He knows this because Israeli officials told him. FACT: The total tunnel length of New York City’s famous sprawling, ramified subway system is 443 miles. FACT: If the Israeli figure is true, then, every 1,250 feet of Gaza along its width, there is another 25-mile-long tunnel stretching across its length. Kingsley didn’t consult a single engineer on the plausibility of this Israeli claim. He knows that Hamas tunnels are Israel’s prime alibi to escape the charge of genocide at the ICJ: if Israel is carpet bombing Gaza, that’s because Hamas tunnels are literally everywhere. If Kingsley is not a whore of war, who is? -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Marc - Jewish and I support #Free Palestine 🇵🇸
@mco_dev
I wrote a poem today.
mco.dev/the-american-way/ -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
OFFSPRING OF A SCHMATTE?
Israel persists in its mujrderous assault on hospitals. The latest target is Nasser Medical Center in Khan Younis. It's not a pretty sight as Israel terrorizes thousands of refugees seeking shelter there. So Adam Ragson, propagandist for the Jerusalem Post and now the New York Times, rushes to Israel’s rescue. He says that "Israel has accused Hamas of using hospitals for military purposes" (“As Fighting Intensifies in Southern Gaza, Thousands Flee Hospital Refuge,” 17 January 2024). He might have further reported--God forbid!--that Human Rights Watch had not “seen any information that would justify attacks on Gaza hospitals.” Instead Ragson then states: "The raid on Al-Shifa [hospital] revealed a stone-and-concrete tunnel shaft below the hospital." It's a wonder to behold: History rewritten before the ink has even dried! Here's what actually happened. Israel proclaimed far and wide that al-Shifa medical complex contained a vast, sprawling, Hamas command-and-control center. It disseminated flashy visuals displaying the exact location of the command-and-control center. The Times reported that it had in its possession a photograph of the hospital door connecting with the command-and-control center. But when the IDF invaded al-Shifa (it ransacked the pediatric ward), it spent a week in the hospital complex allegedly searching for the command-and-control center. What happened to the magical door? Finally, eureka!, it found a tunnel. A tunnel that not Hamas but -- according to former Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak -- ISRAEL had built when it occupied Gaza. But the IDF wouldn't let reporters into the tunnel. First, it said that the shaft was booby-trapped. Poor Israel, even as it created the miracle of miracles, Iron Dome missile interceptor, it still can't figure out how to deactivate a booby-trap. Then it said that reporters couldn't enter the tunnel because of a "Hamas blast door." Oh, Israel can demolish 350,000 homes in Gaza—which, we’re told, were booby-trapped—but it doesn’t yet know how to blow open a blast door. The IDF then announced that it found another tunnel on the other side of the blast door. Indeed, it even discovered two flush toilets. (It didn't say whether there was two-ply or four-ply toilet paper.) What, pray tell, was going on? Israel of course knew beforehand that there was no Hamas command-and-control center in al-Shifa. So it stalled for time, drip-feeding news to the willfully gullible media, until the cameras shifted away from al-Shifa. When the first ceasefire negotiations began and all attention was riveted on them, Israel declared mission accomplished and then quickly BLEW UP THE TUNNEL before outside experts could examine it. A subsequent investigation based on IDF videos by the Washington Post found no evidence that the tunnel was being used by Hamas; no evidence that hospital buildings in the al-Shifa complex were connected to the tunnel; and no evidence that the tunnel could be accessed from inside hospital wards. But Ragson manages to adduce this revolting episode as proof-positive that Hamas uses hospitals for military purposes. The evocative Yiddish word for rag is schmatte. Indeed, what is this reporter if not the Son of a Schmatte? -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
New York Times chief stenographer Patrick Kingsley reports that, according to a senior Israeli official who spoke on condition of anonymity, "Hamas has constructed 10 gazillion miles of tunnels, some of which go so deep as to reach the orthodox Jewish Chabad center in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, endangering Jews everywhere!" When a skeptic queried the authenticity of this report and wondered why Kingsley didn't consult any Gaza engineers on its plausibility, Kingsley angrily retorted: "It's hard enough taking dictation from the IDF."
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
After Wandering 40 Days and Forty Nights in Hamas Tunnels, the N.Y. Times' Patrick Kingsley and Ronen Bergman Discover the Location of the Holy of Holies of Hamas Tunnel System:
www.curbed.com/2024/01/secret-tunnel-synagogue-lubavitch-… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
NY Times' Patrick Kingsley Admits Error in Story on Hamas Tunnels
"I confused a Hamas tunnel with my partner Ronen Bergman's anal cavity. As luck would have it, I was warned in advance that it was booby-trapped so I didn't enter it." -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
NY Times' Patrick Kingsley and Ronen Bergman Discover Hamas Tunnel That Leads To...
www.youtube.com/watch?v=NJmVstWoG3E -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A Historic First! Finkelstein on American television
To my recollection, this is the FIRST time I have ever been interviewed on American television. A public thank you to the reporter, Jim Morelli, for his personal courage and professional accuracy.
www.boston25news.com/news/local/gaza-expert-predicts-poli… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
N.Y. Times' Patrick Kingsley and Ronen Bergman: Call-Girls on a Mission
Israel was accused of committing genocide by South Africa at the Hague. Israel blamed the mass destruction and mass death in Gaza on Hamas: in particular, its tunnel network. Today, lo and behold, the NY Times runs a long article on Hamas's vast tunnel network. Imagine: what a coincidence! The article, which alleges that there were more tunnels in Gaza than grains of sand in the Sahara, is based entirely on Israeli government claims. These intrepid reporters seem blissfully unaware that Israel has been touting these deluxe tunnels for two decades already. After each of its hi-tech massacres in Gaza, it ascribes the death and destruction to these tunnels. So as to leave no doubt that the purpose of this article is to exonerate Israel of the charge of genocide, it states: "Every strategic goal of Israel in Gaza is now linked to wiping out the tunnels." Oh, is that why Israel has killed an unprecedented number of journalists, doctors, and UN personnel; is that why it assassinated Christian women taking refuge in a church; is that why it murdered civilians carrying white flags: to wipe out the tunnels? While Mr Kingsley and Mr Bergman are pretending to be reporters -- not call girls -- might they ask their Israeli interlocutors this question: What happened to the vast, sprawling Hamas command-and-control center under al-Shifa hospital? Oh, excuse me, I forgot: the IDF did prove there was a flush toilet under al-Shifa. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Houthis: Lawbreakers or Law Enforcers?
From the 2005 World Summit Outcome Document:
Each individual State has the responsibility to protect its populations from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity. This responsibility entails the prevention of such crimes, including their incitement, through appropriate and necessary means. We accept that responsibility and will act in accordance with it. The international community should, as appropriate, encourage and help States to exercise this responsibility and support the United Nations in establishing an early warning capability.
Israel is carrying out a genocide in Gaza. The U.S. is the chief enabler of this genocide. The Houthis have targeted U.S. ships. The Houthis say they acted “in defense of the Palestinian people in Gaza, who are being exposed, until this moment, to the most horrific type of massacres by the Zionist entity.” Aren't the Houthis fulfilling their international "responsibility" to prevent genocide? -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
د. فينكلشتاين يكشف أسباب اختيار قاضي الدفاع عن إسرائيل youtube.com/watch?v=dMYgFzapOSs
5qqTnkoJs- -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
UN Secretary-General Gutteres' Latest Statement on Gaza: Not bad, but still cowardly www.normanfinkelstein.com/un-secretary-general-gutteres-l…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
UN Secretary-General Gutteres' Latest Statement on Gaza: Not bad, but still cowardly
The Secretary-General denounces Hamas by name for October 7. He then goes on to describe the approaching famine conditions in Gaza. (1)Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Second, he calls for a ceasefire-which is one of the provisional measures that the ICJ can call for. Third, he says at the very end that the situation in Gaza cannot be allowed to continue. (4)
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Those statements should all work in favor of the South African case.(5) www.youtube.com/watch?v=JJut6xVk0zM
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Neri Oxman Tells THE VIEW Why She Plagiarized www.normanfinkelstein.com/neri-oxman-tells-the-view-why-s…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norm Finkelstein REVEALS Genocide Case Strengths and Weaknesses www.normanfinkelstein.com/norm-finkelstein-reveals-genoci…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
On the final segment of #icj analysis with @MouinRabbani, @normfinkelstein discussed the the lasting resentment South Africa feels towards Israel, and the ways this has played into the ICJ proceedings.
#icjanalysis #finkelsteinrabbaniseries
www.youtube.com/watch?v=UvnO6XkP88Y&t=932s -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Connections Podcast Episodes with Norman Finkelstein, South Africa Charges Israel with Genocide (Four Parts) www.normanfinkelstein.com/connections-podcast-the-four-ep…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
Yesterday @normfinkelstein & @MouinRabbani concluded their 4-part series by providing summary & next steps of South Africa's charge of #genocide against #israel.
#icjanalysis #finkelsteinrabbaniseries
www.youtube.com/watch?v=UvnO6XkP88Y&t=2358s -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
Norman Finkelstein on judges at #icj acting in the interest of their states.
@normfinkelstein and @MouinRabbani concluded their series summarizing South Africa's #genocide case against #israel at the ICJ. #icjanalysis #finkelsteinrabbaniseries
www.youtube.com/watch?v=UvnO6XkP88Y&t=932s -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norm Finkelstein REVEALS Genocide Case Strengths and Weaknesses youtu.be/D3LDa6M-tpo
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
For tomorrow’s @jadaliyya Connections episode with @normfinkelstein on the ICJ genocide hearings, we will be taking questions. Feel free to post them here, and we'll address as many as we can!
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
Part 3 is live now with @normfinkelstein and @MouinRabbani
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
Connections Podcast Episode 87 with Norman Finkelstein, South Africa Charges Israel with Genocide at the ICJ, A 4-Part Series, Hosted by Mouin Rabbani x.com/i/broadcasts/1lPKqbDlkElGb
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Connections Podcast Episode 86 with Norman Finkelstein, South Africa Cha... youtube.com/live/-QM70gyT5ck
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
"It's very important now for the public to be focused on the ICJ case, and for the people on the court to know we are watching you. If you do nothing, you are going to completely discredit the rule of law." @normfinkelstein in conversation with @MouinRabbani.
Tune in today for the second part of the 4-part series with Norman Finkelstein & Mouin Rabbani at 8pm ET, in which they will analyze today's South Africa arguments at #icj.
#icjanalysis #finkelsteinrabbaniseriesThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
I just completed the first of four special episodes of Connections with @normfinkelstein regarding the ICJ genocide case that will commence on 11 January. Thanks to Norman for a great discussion. We will review the South African submission Thursday 8pm US EST
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
Connections Podcast Episode 85 - South Africa Charges Israel with Genocide at the ICJ, A 4-Part Series. Mouin Rabbani Interviews Norman Finkelstein x.com/i/broadcasts/1vOxwjDmnLRJB
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Connections Podcast Episode 85 - South Africa Charges Israel with Genocide at the ICJ, A 4-Part Series. Mouin Rabbani Interviews Norman Finkelstein (Part 1-Preview) fb.watch/pv_wkaHbqD/ via @FacebookWatch
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
For Connections @mouinrabbani @normfinkelstein will discuss the ICJ public hearings on South Africa's genocide case against Israel.
"Connections Episode 85: South Africa Charges Israel with Genocide at the ICJ with Norman Finkelstein (A 4-Part Series)"
www.jadaliyya.com/Details/45698 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Connections Episode 85: South Africa Charges Israel with Genocide at the ICJ with Norman Finkelstein (a 4-Part Series) www.jadaliyya.com/Details/45698 via @jadaliyya
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Connections Episode 85: South Africa Charges Israel with Genocide at the ICJ with Norman Finkelstein (a 4-Part Series) www.normanfinkelstein.com/connections-episode-85-south-af…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
News Flash: Terrorist Attack Foiled! www.normanfinkelstein.com/news-flash-terrorist-attack-foi…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
News Flash: Terrorist Attack Foiled!
Israel just dropped a two-ton bomb on the Hague during the ICJ hearing on Israel's genocide in Gaza. The Israeli government stated: "There was a Hamas command-and-control center in a Hamas tunnel beneath the Court chamber. Two top Hamas terrorists were ensconced in the tunnel. The six members of the South African delegation and seven judges killed in the pinpoint Israeli strike were also Hamas." The New York Times' Isabel Kershner and Ronen Bergman confirmed the existence of the tunnel. "We even saw a flush toilet!" Patrick Kingsley expressed some skepticism: "I should think only five of the judges were Hamas." In an interview with Piers Morgan, noted philosopher Jordan Peterson stated that Iran built the tunnel, while Sam Harris warned the Dutch to beware of Muslim babies strapped with explosives. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Jadaliyya
@jadaliyya
Jadaliyya co-editor,@MouinRabbani, and Norman Finkelstein @normfinkelstein will provide commentary on historic Gaza Genocide case at International Court of Justice. Stay tuned for details.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Shakespeare on Ackman
"Hell hath no fury like a billionaire Jewish supremacist thwarted"--William Shakespeare -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Ackman: Jews don't plagiarize; only schwarzes do www.normanfinkelstein.com/ackman-jews-dont-plagiarize-onl…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Ackman: Jews don't plagiarize; only schwarzes do! Jewish billionaire William Ackman was angry that Harvard students opposed genocide in Gaza. He was angry that Harvard president Claudine Gay didn't suppress the students' First Amendment right to speech and assembly. He then demanded that Gay be ousted because she supposedly committed plagiarism. Gay was ousted. When a Jewish billionaire says that the Black president of Harvard must go, she goes. But then it was discovered that Ackman's wife, an Israeli-born former lieutenant in the Israeli air force, committed plagiarism. Ackman is now hopping mad. Only schwarzes are supposed to be punished for plagiarism. Ackman is now threatening to expose plagiarism among faculty at MIT (where his plagiarizing wife taught). I for one am relieved that Ackman didn't order his wife to drop 2,000-pound bombs on MIT.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
How Harvard and the Times Collude to Protect Dershowitz www.normanfinkelstein.com/how-harvard-and-the-times-collu…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein SLAMS ‘Deranged’ Israeli Psychotherapist www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-slams-derang…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Finkelstein and Rabbani on the Genocide case at ICJ www.normanfinkelstein.com/finkelstein-and-rabbani-on-the-…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein and Mouin Rabbani to provide commentary on historic Gaza Genocide case at International Court of Justice. Stay tuned for details.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Wanted for Genocide www.normanfinkelstein.com/wanted-for-genocide/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein: Israel’s Genocide Defenders ‘Live in Jewish Supremacist Bubble” www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-israels-geno…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein: Israel’s Genocide Defenders ‘Live in Jewish Supremac... youtube.com/watch?v=Vu3jxj1tXAs
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein EVISCERATES Alan Dershowitz Over Lying, Hypocrisy & Plagiarism www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-eviscerates-…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Katie Halper
@kthalps
“Billionaire thugs” forced Harvard president Claudine Gay to step down. - @normfinkelstein youtu.be/aZqFN54jI5g
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein Discusses Palestine, the Harvard Controversy, and Attacks on Academic Freedom!!! www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-discusses-pa…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein On Gaza, Jamal Mohamad on Rabbi Shmuley and "Free Palestine" www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-on-gaza-jama…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
In The Bleak Midwinter (Song for Gaza) www.normanfinkelstein.com/in-the-bleak-midwinter-song-for…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Katie Halper
@kthalps
.@normfinkelstein calls the (forced) resignation of Harvard president Claudine Gay “end of academic freedom… if billionaire criminal class can determine the president, they can determine every facet of university life.” Calls for her & reinstatement. www.youtube.com/live/d0nBKrgIN8U
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein On Gaza, Jamal Mohamad on Rabbi Shmuley and "Free Palestine" www.normanfinkelstein.com/norman-finkelstein-on-gaza-jama…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
CLOSING DOWN MY SUBSTACK ACCOUNT
open.substack.com/pub/normanfinkelstein/p/closing-down-my… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Sam Harris et al.: Moral Dilemma
Sam Harris, Ben Shapiro, Jordan Peterson, and Bill Maher will debate this moral dilemma at the 92nd Street Y:
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
If the children of Gazan, qua Muslims, are "rigged to explode" (Sam Harris), should they be rescued from or left to die under the rubble?
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: The Israeli correspondent Barak Ravid had an interesting article in Axios on 29 December. The article in question, about a recent phone call between Biden and Netanyahu,
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Ghassan Abu Sittah Children’s Fund www.normanfinkelstein.com/the-ghassan-abu-sittah-children…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What we an do!
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
The Ghassan Abu Sittah Children’s Fund www.normanfinkelstein.com/the-ghassan-abu-sittah-children…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Sam Harris: Rational Man
www.normanfinkelstein.com/sam-harris-rational-man/ -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
form DOT jotform DOT com/233430448529155
POWER MOVE for PALESTINE! SHOW BIDEN HE IS LOSING VOTES BY MAKING A SOLEMN PLEDGE!
We, the people, pledge NOT to vote for President Biden in Nov 2024 because he has failed to call for permanent ceasefire stance in Gaza.
This decision is IRREVOCABLE.
It is a commitment to a symbolic early vote as a registered voter, to support pro-Palestinian representatives and therefore NOT vote for Biden in November 2024.
Step 1) Take the Pledge Now at tinyurl DOT com/powermoveforpalestine
Step 2) If your state allows party preference selection:
Re-register and change to 'No Party Preference' at VOTE DOT GOV
to show the democrats/republicans they are losing members! -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
form DOT jotform DOT com/233430448529155
POWER MOVE for PALESTINE! SHOW BIDEN HE IS LOSING VOTES BY MAKING A SOLEMN PLEDGE!
We, the people, pledge NOT to vote for President Biden in Nov 2024 because he has failed to call for permanent ceasefire stance in Gaza.
This decision is IRREVOCABLE.
It is a commitment to a symbolic early vote as a registered voter, to support pro-Palestinian representatives and therefore NOT vote for Biden in November 2024.
Step 1) Take the Pledge Now at tinyurl DOT com/powermoveforpalestine
Step 2) If your state allows party preference selection:
Re-register and change to 'No Party Preference' at VOTE DOT GOV
to show the democrats/republicans they are losing members! -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: Senior Israeli leaders, including Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu, are again publicly advocating the ethnic cleansing of the Gaza Strip. Their proposals are being presented as voluntary emigration schemes,
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
open.substack.com/pub/normanfinkelstein/p/sam-harris-sava…
Norman Finkelstein on SAM HARRIS: SAVANT IDIOT. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/fighting-amalek-in-gaza-…
Fighting Amalek in Gaza: What Israelis Say and Western Media Ignore
[Updated 26 December 2023] -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norm Finkelstein UNLEASHED: Bibi, RFK Jr, Bill Maher youtube.com/watch?v=7tI595leq4U
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Song for Gaza. With lead soprano @fink_deborah & too many contributors to list on this particular website
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
In the Bleak Midwinter (Join us in song!)
open.substack.com/pub/normanfinkelstein/p/in-the-bleak-mi… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Bill Maher: "I just love Crispy Critters for breakfast." Ha, Ha, Ha, Ha, Ha.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Hanging Out with Bill Maher
Last night I had a dream. Like MLK’s dream, it was about Justice. But it wasn’t about white supremacy. It was about Jewish supremacy. It was about Bill Maher. He was in a courtroom. Like Julius Streicher at Nuremberg, he was being prosecuted for his diabolical lies and disgusting jokes as a people was being martyred—systematically murdered and starved; their homes and hospitals methodically destroyed. The verdict was pronounced. I woke up with a bittersweet smile. No one can bring back the dead but, at least, Justice was done. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norm Finkelstein SHREDS Bill Maher's Israel Defense youtube.com/watch?v=wxcrqkwQYmE
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Ben Shapiro's Final Solution:
"If you believe that the Jewish state has a right to exist, then you must allow Israel to transfer the Palestinians and the Israeli-Arabs from Judea, Samaria, Gaza and Israel proper. It's an ugly solution, but it is the only solution." (Ben Shapiro, 2003) He went on to say that, if Israelis don't openly avow this goal, it's "because they are afraid that if they expel the Arabs, they will be called Nazis." It seems that Israelis are no longer afraid. Indeed, senior Israeli officials have called for wiping out "Amalek" and making Gaza "uninhabitable." Is it okay, Mr. Shapiro, to now call them Nazis?
web.archive.org/web/20150220130431/http://townhall.com/co… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
While listening to his audience explode in guffaws as Bill Maher declared victory over the terrorized people of Gaza, I was reminded of another hilarious monologue:
"One thing I should like to say on this day which may be memorable for others as well as for us Germans: In the course of my life I have very often been a prophet, and have usually been ridiculed for it. During the time of my struggle for power it was in the first instance the Jewish race which only received my prophecies with laughter when I said that I would one day take over the leadership of the State, and with it that of the whole nation, and that I would then among many other things settle the Jewish problem. Their laughter was uproarious, but I think that for some time now they have been laughing on the other side of their face. Today I will once more be a prophet: If the international Jewish financiers in and outside Europe should succeed in plunging the nations once more into a world war, then the result will not be the Bolshevization of the earth, and thus the victory of Jewry, but the annihilation of the Jewish race in Europe!"
Wasn't Hitler a real gas, Mr. Maher? -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Bill Maher: "You are a defeated people! Sieg Heil!"
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Bill Maher: In Search of a Nun
An undergraduate at Harvard rang me up yesterday. He's trying to organize a debate on Gaza. The problem is, no faculty at Harvard is willing to debate me. Imagine!Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Lately, Mr. Maher has been wowing his loser audience with his sweeping knowledge of the rise and fall of empires.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Gee whiz, Mr. Maher, if you know so much, debating me should be like shooting fish in a barrel. So, why not invite me on your program? If things get too rough, you can always steal a page from your heroic IDF and use a nun as a human shield.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Posted on Bill Maher's Instagram Page:
You lost! We won! Get used to it! Ha, ha, ha, ha, ha. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Bill Maher, the Cabaret Comic
Bill Maher is a throwback to the third-rate Berlin cabaret comics who mocked the Jews: “Isn’t it time those smelly Jews in Warsaw finally take a SHOWER?” (Wink! Wink! Ha! Ha!)
youtu.be/KP-CRXROorwPost not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
And the last time someone boasted that it’s here to stay, the thousand-year Reich lay in ashes after 12 years.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Sources:
1) www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-67670679
2) www.hrw.org/news/2023/12/18/israel-starvation-used-weapon…
3) www.ochaopt.org/content/hostilities-gaza-strip-and-israel…
4) www.hrw.org/news/2023/11/14/gaza-unlawful-israeli-hospita…
5)www.theguardian.com/world/2023/dec/05/un-martin-griffiths… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A new title from @orbooks, by @jsternweiner
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
ASSASSINS
The media reported today in shock that Israeli snipers killed two Christian women inside a church in Gaza. But is that news? Israeli snipers routinely kill unarmed civilians. Here's a sample of unarmed Palestinian civilians killed by "specially trained" Israeli snipers during the overwhelmingly nonviolent Great March of Return in 2018. (Compiled by an Independent International Commission of Inquiry)
documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G19/085/50/PDF/G190… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Unlikely Feminists
According to this morning's New York Times, "a U.S. official said publicly that Hamas reneged on an agreement to release all female hostages. A Hamas official said it considered some of the remaining female hostages to be soldiers."
Wouldn't feminists agree that, if you're a soldier, you should be treated as such, and not be patronized on account of your sex? -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
JamieSW
@jsternweiner
"The crucial context and record of the unfolding crimes against Gaza. It's unlikely to be surpassed anytime soon" - Norman Finkelstein (@normfinkelstein)
DELUGE: Gaza and Israel from Crisis to Cataclysm is now available for pre-order:
www.orbooks.com/catalog/deluge/ -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sabby Sabs
@SabbySabs2
🚨 How do you feel about Marianne Williamson & RFK position on Israel & Gaza?
"Marianne has no idea what she's talking about. I really wish Marianne Williamson would just shut up!" - Norm
PREMIERES AT 6PM ET
youtu.be/1X7QRAaSVfM -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: The 15 December killing of three Israeli captives in the Gaza Strip by the Israeli military is significant in several respects.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Human Rights Watch reported already as far back as two decades ago (2002) that tanks in The Most Moral Army in the World ran down a wheelchair-bound Palestinian hoisting a white flag:
"Fifty-seven-year-old Kamal Zghair, a wheelchair-bound man who was shot and then run over by IDF tanks on April 10 as he was moving in his wheelchair equipped with a white flag down a major road in Jenin"
www.hrw.org/news/2002/05/02/israel/occupied-territories-j… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
There's shock that Israel killed three civilians -- as it turned out, Israelis who had been taken hostage -- carrying white flags. But killing civilians carrying white flags is standard operating procedure of the SS (Satanic State).
See www.hrw.org/report/2009/08/13/white-flag-deaths/killings-… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Russell Brand
@rustyrockets
"this is standard operating procedure for Israel" @normfinkelstein and I discussed the depth of the conflicts' history and how to understand both sides in order to ferret out the truth
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Russell Brand
@rustyrockets
Don't miss our conversation STREAMING NOW, join 16,000 others in the LIVE chat🔥 rumble.com/v41e4hp-why-oct-7th-really-happened-norman-fin…
Russell Brand
@rustyrockets
🎙️@normfinkelstein expresses his views on the importance of opposition to genocide
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: The following translation of a witness statement from the Gaza Strip was produced by a volunteer with the Palestinian Journalist Syndicate. It is provided here because it is an account that according to the translator “we find to be highly credible”.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
open.substack.com/pub/normanfinkelstein/p/fighting-amalek…
Fighting Amalek in Gaza: What Israelis Say and Western Media Ignore
Updated 14 December 2023 -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein vs Alan Dershowitz On Israel-Palestine War With Piers... youtube.com/watch?v=uHqs15gOv4k
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Censored Men
@CensoredMen
🇵🇸🇮🇱 Wow, Prof. Norman Finkelstein being brilliant once again 👏
The amount of respect I have for this man is indescribable.
Thank you Piers for giving him a good amount of time also.
"Israel has been waging a war of genocide in Gaza."
@piersmorgan | @normfinkelsteinThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: On Monday Israel’s Defense Minister, Yoav Gallant, stated that Hamas’s military force, the Martyr Izz-al-Din al-Qassam Brigades as well as the Jerusalem Battalions of Islamic Jihad (PIJ) were on the verge of collapse.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Alan Dershowitz says that Harvard president Claudine Gay should not have been hired in the first place because "her scholarship has now been questioned and challenged." His opinion should be given its due.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
After all, who is more qualified than Mr Dershowitz to render expert judgment on scholarly malfeasance?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=reibkTRZ4oI -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Cornel West
@CornelWest
I deeply enjoyed this serious intellectual dialogue with my dear brother Norman Finkelstein! This is part 1/3 videos to come. @normfinkelstein
youtu.be/1_-cq3SnVEQ -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: More on visa bans. It seems the new fad among Western governments is to denounce settler violence and adopt measures against individual settlers. Following the US, the European Union and United Kingdom are now also considering the nuclear option:
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
IS HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH COVERING UP ISRAEL'S GENOCIDE IN GAZA?
On November 26, 2023, Human Rights Watch released its “Findings on October 17 al-Ahli Hospital Explosion.” www.hrw.org/news/2023/11/26/gaza-findings-october-17-al-a….
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The findings effectively exonerated Israel of culpability for the massive death toll at the hospital. On November 29, I sent a list of skeptical queries to Omar Shakir, Director of Israel and Palestine Affairs at HRW.
Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
In a subsequent email to Mr Shakir, I offered to correct any errors he found in my text that is now posted on my Substack. normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/is-human-rights-watch-co…
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
He didn’t respond. Mr Shakir should either respond to my queries, call on HRW to issue a correction, or resign. Otherwise, he is complicit in Israel's genocide.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A Plea to Students at University of Pennsylvania
Don't give up your right to think! Demand President Magill's reinstatement! -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Jewish billionaire class has declared war on our nation's universities: Either you support Israel's genocidal war or we will destroy you!
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Jewish billionaire class has declared: WE WILL DESTROY ANY STUDENT, FACULTY, OR ADMINSTRATOR WHO DENIES ISRAEL'S RIGHT TO COMMIT GENOCIDE!
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Students Must Unite and Fight
The Jewish billionaire class wants to control thought on college campuses. The students must reply: Our right to think is not for sale! Keep your dirty money and get the f*** out of here! -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A reign of terror has descended upon college campuses. The Jewish billionaire class wants to stop students from opposing genocide. The burning question now is: Will the students stop these rabid Jewish supremacists?
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Jewish billionaire class must be stopped. The student body at University of Pennsylvania must boycott classes from Day One of the Spring semester until and unless President Magill is reinstated.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Otherwise, academic freedom is dead and a gang of rabid Jewish supremacists will henceforth be deciding what can and can't be said on a college campus.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Israel has been waging a unique war of extermination in Gaza. By openly, blatantly and flagrantly targeting Gaza's hospitals, it has crossed a negative threshold of barbarism.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Jewish billionaire class is now targeting every college student, faculty, and administrator opposed to such barbarism. These rabid Jewish supremacists must be stopped.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Judging by its headlines, the New York Times is of the opinion that students chanting "From the river to the Sea, Palestine will be free" pose a more lethal threat to civilization than Israel's stated policy of extinguishing all sentient life in Gaza.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Make no mistake about it. In order to stifle dissent from Israel's genocidal war in Gaza, the Jewish billionaire class has launched the most concerted assault on academic freedom in the history of our country.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
If the presidents at Ivy League universities are not safe from the wrath of these Jewish supremacists, then no one is, and academic freedom is dead.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Isn't it easy to imagine Mark Regev doing experiments on twins?
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/deborah-maccoby-tutors-b…
Deborah Maccoby Tutors Bar Mitzvah Boy Benny Shapiro on Jewish History -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_-cq3SnVEQ With @CornelWest
The Marathon Interview, Part One: Race -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
I was approached today for comment by a reporter working on an article for Deutsche Welle. My response:
Thank you for your message and questions. I do recall our previous contact.
Under normal circumstances I would be happy to respond to your questions. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
From the Bowels of Hell, the Satanic Hordes Strike Again
I read in the morning paper that Israel is now obliterating the "terrorist hotbed" of Shuja'iya. It is among the most densely populated neighborhoods in Gaza.Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
An IDF eyewitness testimony recalled, "The artillery corps and the air force really cleaned that place up." By the operation's end, Shuja'iya was systematically razed to the ground.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Satanic hordes have now returned to destroy it again. If there is a God, they will be buried alive in their own rubble.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Israel's Humiliation and Overcompensation
youtube.com/shorts/PaogE0BHtVY -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: Regarding International Criminal Court (ICC) Prosecutor Karim Khan, there is an interesting personal dimension to his story. Karim Khan, although a British citizen, is the grandson of the distinguished Pakistani diplomat and jurist Muhammad Zafarullah Khan (1893-1985).
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
After watching US Ambassador to the UN Robert Wood raise his hand in support of Israel's genocide, I was reminded of a fine passage in W. E. B. Du Bois' biography of John Brown.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
In the course of "Bloody Kansas," when a mini civil war would decide whether Kansas entered the Union a free or slave state, John Brown's people seized five of "the dogs" who terrorized the free-staters:
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
JOHN BROWN RAISED HIS HAND AND AT THE SIGNAL THE VICTIMS WERE HACKED TO DEATH WITH BROADSWORDS.
Glory Hallelujah!, Mr. Wood. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
If any substantial group is planning a sit-in action to close down the GENOCIDE ENABLERS at the U.S. Mission to the U.N., count me present. I would gladly be the first of 1,000 persons to get arrested.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
There Are Real Opportunities Now (Biden's in Trouble)
youtu.be/qdLyAnmHsXE -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Events of October 7th Are Still Hazy
youtube.com/shorts/i6CV1rNHW7U -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Cornel West and Norman Finkelstein Live in New York! youtube.com/live/bhGkoLeOUIo
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Biden is under pressure
youtube.com/shorts/hdyTiABDKwM -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
open.substack.com/pub/normanfinkelstein/p/fighting-amalek…
Fighting Amalek in Gaza: What Israelis Say and Western Media Ignore
[Last update: 6 December 2023] -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: On 5 December, the United States announced “a new visa restrictions policy targeting individuals and their family members involved in or meaningfully contributing to actions that undermine peace, security, and stability in the West Bank.”
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Councillor asks library to disinvite controversial author www.thestar.com/news/gta/toronto-city-councillor-asks-lib…
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein Discusses Israel's War on Gaza and Living Conditions ... youtube.com/live/q0Af0j5vSlQ
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What is Israel's Goal? And How Do We Achieve a Ceasefire?
youtu.be/bQLTKBtYLVM -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Deadly Weekend In Gaza, Norman Finkelstein Interview | #novaralive youtube.com/watch?v=6G14d8l5oN0
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: The verdict is in. The US, as could have been predicted even before the recent Israeli-Palestinian truce came into force, has blamed Hamas for its collapse. (More accurately, the truce expired because no agreement was reached by the parties on its extension or renewal).
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: To understand why International Criminal Court (ICC) Prosecutor Karim Khan’s conduct regarding “The Situation in Palestine” is so scandalous and should disqualify him from office, a little background is necessary.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: In contrast to most military operations, Yemeni attacks on Red Sea shipping don’t need to hit their target in order to achieve their objective. The Bab Al-Mandab (“Gate of Lamentation”) strait is a very narrow maritime chokepoint,
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
THREAD:
Can Human Rights Watch Be Trusted?
The Biden administration rushed to second Israel’s allegation that Hamas was responsible for the al-Ahli hospital massacre.Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
But when asked whether it would allow HRW to view the evidence from the site, Hamas replied: “Yes 100%.”
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
How does HRW report this response? It released its findings without scrutinizing this physical evidence that it itself deemed critical, and then refused to publicly acknowledge that Hamas had “100%” agreed to let HRW examine the physical evidence.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: Did Israel create Hamas, and did Netanyahu empower it to rule the Gaza Strip? Since the 7 October attacks in Israel, many critics of Israeli policy, and of Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu in particular,
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The inexecrable, bootlicking, sadistic Samantha Power (Obama loved her "crinkly" eyes) just described Biden as a "humanitarian desk officer from the beginning" of the Gaza genocide.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
It seems this dim bulb borrowed from but mis-rendered the description of Eichmann: "desk murderer."
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Human Rights Watch’s Bad Faith
In its preliminary report on the al-Ahli hospital massacre, HRW observes that neither Israel nor Hamas has previously carried out satisfactory criminal investigations, and it calls for an international “independent investigation” into the hospitalPost not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What's yet more wretched, HRW castigated Hamas for concealing critical evidence whereas Hamas stated that “Yes 100%” it would let HRW look at the evidence.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Sources:
1) www.hrw.org/news/2023/11/26/gaza-findings-october-17-al-a…
2) documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G19/085/50/PDF/G190… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/mouin-rabbani-a-post-cea…
Mouin Rabbani: A Post-Ceasefire Analysis -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: Israel’s war on the Gaza Strip has resumed in full force. The intensity of its bombing and shelling is as intense as before the truce, perhaps even more so. Israel will however find it difficult to continue this campaign for another 50 days.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Tina Tyrell took this photograph yesterday at my home away from home, Coney Island beach.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Cornel West
@CornelWest
I will be in conversation with my dear brother the courageous scholar @normfinkelstein on Dec. 7th @ 5pm at the Comedy Cellar.
Very limited capacity, but we hope to see you there! TICKETS @ www.cornelwest2024.com/comedycellar -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
New York Times Twitter Obit on Kissinger
Henry Kissinger died at age 100. He was reportedly very old when he died. He had a thick German accent that won him early tenure at Harvard. He wrote many learned tomes.Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
He was a popular dinner guest among the rich and famous. He regaled gatherings with his bon mots. At a Hamptons soiree, he told Saudi Arabia’s Muhammed bin Salman, “I hear you ground the bones of that Washington Post reporter to dust. I would have just crushed them.”
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The crowd laughed appreciatively. Human rights crusader Samantha Power posted on Twitter after news of his death, “I learnt everything I know about human rights from Dr. Kissinger.” There are unconfirmed rumors that Kissinger killed millions of people.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
IS HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH A MASSACRE MINIMIZER?
Human Rights Watch has stated in the past that Gaza Ministry of Health casualty figures are generally reliable.
www.hrw.org/news/2023/11/26/gaza-findings-october-17-al-a….Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
HRW says that it issued its report after "reaching the requisite degree of confidence in our findings." Yet, it passed up the opportunity extended by Hamas to examine the crime scene.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
It must be a first for a criminal investigative body to forgo an on-the-spot inspection before issuing its findings. HRW castigated Hamas for suppressing critical evidence in its possession. Yet, Hamas stated that "Yes 100%" it would let HRW examine this evidence.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
For all I know, everything HRW wrote in its report will eventually be confirmed. But HRW manifestly did not take basic steps to ascertain the truth before issuing its incendiary report.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
IS HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH LYING?
Human Rights Watch, in a preliminary report on the al-Ahli hospital massacre, devoted 24 lines to describing in minute detail how Hamas was suppressing critical evidence on the incident.
www.hrw.org/news/2023/11/26/gaza-findings-october-17-al-a… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: As predicted, no sooner did Antony Blinken arrive in the region than hostilities erupted again. The first killings, numbering in the dozens, resulting from Israeli air raids and artillery barrages throughout the Gaza Strip have already been reported.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
IS HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH LYING?
Human Rights Watch, in a preliminary report on the al-Ahli hospital massacre, devoted 24 lines to describing in minute detail how Hamas was suppressing critical evidence on the incident.
www.hrw.org/news/2023/11/26/gaza-findings-october-17-al-a…
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Yet, Hamas has stated that it would provide full access to HRW regarding the evidence it has collected and has invited HRW to conduct a full, impartial, and independent investigation. HRW has refused to post a correction.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/mouin-rabbani-the-hamas-…
Mouin Rabbani: The “Hamas-ISIS" line has become untenable -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Apart from the obvious that he was a monster, my only strong memory of Henry Kissinger is that I lost all respect for Zsa Zsa Gabor when she dated him
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: About a week ago the US and Israeli suddenly stopped comparing Hamas to ISIS. The term “Hamas-ISIS” had become de rigueur among Israeli officials in their public statements,
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
MEMORY: Piers Morgan, Norman Finkelstein, and Amira Hass
youtu.be/QYVCIz6JM7o -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
www.youtube.com/watch?v=kdqQEkUnWp0
The Death of a Palestinian Hero Child (Part 1)
(Radio Documentary done by a correspondent) -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Is Ben Shapiro Joshing about Joshua—or Is He Just a Jerk? Part 2 of a series by Deborah Maccoby
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/is-ben-shapiro-joshing-a… -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: The relationship between Zionism and anti-Semitism is often misunderstood, and just as often deliberately distorted.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Get it now at 30% off: www.orbooks.com/catalog/catalog/method-and-madness/
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What Should We Do After There's a Ceasefire? youtu.be/U27BEorRPos
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/mouin-rabbani-israel-has…
Mouin Rabbani: Israel has lost the plot -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: On 7 October Israel vowed to destroy Hamas. To eradicate it as an organization. To neuter it as a military force, political movement, and governing entity. More recently Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu, in true mob boss style,
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
open.substack.com/pub/normanfinkelstein/p/mouin-rabbani-t…
Mouin Rabbani: Thoughts on the Truce -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
THREAD: It is difficult to predict whether or not the Israeli-Palestinian truce will be extended beyond its expiration on the morning of 29 November, or for that matter whether it will even last until then.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
Thread: Since 1917 it has been a consistent principle of Western policy that Palestinians have no right to self-defence. There isn’t a single exception on record. Most recently, several Western governments characterised a number of settler pogroms in the West Bank as “terrorism”,
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman On Gaza: “They have the right to hate the people who destroyed their lives”
youtu.be/8HOdvfss_cc -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
OR Books
@orbooks
Does Hamas serve the interests of Palestinian liberation?
@normfinkelstein in conversation with @aaronjmate, LIVE ON AVE C. Watch the full video here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MCJajUbzXo
#gaza #freepalestine #normanfinkelstein #aaronmate #liveonavenuec #orbooks -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
Thread: Israel has repeatedly denounced Hamas as Nazis. It has now concluded yet another agreement with the Palestinian movement. If we accept Israel’s characterisation of Hamas, this means it is negotiating with Nazis. Sound strange? Not really.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Mouin Rabbani
@MouinRabbani
Thread: What has happened to Israeli hasbara (“explaining”, i.e. propaganda)? Others may disagree but it used to be professional, sophisticated, intelligent, and effective.
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Piers Morgan Uncensored
@PiersUncensored
Dr Norman Finkelstein tells Piers Morgan he saw he had 'humanity' when he watched him judge Susan Boyle on Britain's Got Talent - before comparing the singer to the people of Gaza.
@normfinkelstein | @piersmorgan | @TalkTV | #pmuThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Dr. ʾUstādh ʾAbū Saūce, PhD
@IbnSauce
Dr Norman Finkelstein responds to “Palestinians rejected a peace deal in the year 2000”
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
“Liar!” Norm Finkelstein DISMANTLES Hillary Israel Spin
www.youtube.com/watch?v=H4PckPdApIY on @BreakingPointsN -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Piers Morgan Uncensored
@PiersUncensored
Piers Morgan asks controversial Jewish scholar Norman Finkelstein if he condemns Hamas.
@normfinkelstein | @piersmorgan | @TalkTV | #pmuThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Censored Men
@CensoredMen
🇵🇸🇮🇱 Piers Morgan asks professor @normfinkelstein how he thinks his parents, who were both Holocaust survivors, would’ve reacted to October 7th.
“They [his parents] had the right to hate the people that destroyed their lives, and the people of Gaza have the right to hate the people who destroyed their lives.”
@piersmorgan | @PiersUncensoredThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Norman Finkelstein vs Piers Morgan tonight. This would be the show not to be missed!! substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/6984c2… (1920×1080) substackcdn.com/image/fetch/f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progres…
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Piers Morgan Uncensored
@PiersUncensored
You asked, we delivered.
Dr Norman Finkelstein joins Piers Morgan live on tonight's show to discuss the latest in the Israel-Hamas conflict.
@normfinkelstein | @piersmorgan | @TalkTV | #pmu -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A Photo from Ursula von der Leyne's Family Album
"My Sweet Granny Didn't Wash Her Hand for a Month after This Precious Occasion" -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
A Simple Picture of Gaza
youtu.be/v-GK1lKmexE -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
"It must be remembered that between August 3 and August 26 2014 when the ceasefire was reached, Israel escalated its murderous attacks, so it will almost certainly be a bestial denouement." Norman Finkelstein
#gazagenocide #gazaceasefirenow
@NormFinkelstein -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
European Commission president Dr. Ursula von der Leyen denounces ceasefire:
"How will I be able to continue my experiments on dead babies?" -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Regarding the hostage deal between Israel and Hamas, the Times reports that "Hostages likely won’t be released until Thursday at the earliest, to allow time for Israeli judges to review potential legal challenges to the prisoner release, according to Israeli officials."
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
It is reported that famed attorney Alan Dershowitz will petition the Israel High Court demanding that, as part of the deal, his pool privileges be restored at Martha's Vineyard.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Overheard by person seated next to Ben Shapiro on Amtrak speaking into his iPhone
"Mommy, he called me stupid."
"Don't cry, Benny. You'll always be a Jewish genius to me." -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Denying he's a stupid slimy coward, Ben Shapiro debates Gaza against not one but two opponents:
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Israel Built Them But Now Can't Find Them
Former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak just told Christiane Amanpour that the Hamas "bunkers under al-Shifa hospital were originally built by Israeli constructors." Okaaaaaaaaaaaaay. But then, why can't the IDF now find them?
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
These Israelis can't be Jewish. The things they say are just too stupid.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=cVG7duZ-u2U -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Ben Shapiro Agrees to Debate Gaza against...
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
My first night off since October 7. Dinner yesterday with John Mearsheimer.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Jewish billionaire class is amassing a war chest in order to shield Israel on the web by "getting ahead of the narrative" on Gaza. Here's an idea: if "getting ahead of the narrative" is their goal, they should post this picture everywhere under GAZA:
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein deconstructs Ben Shapiro and challenges him to debate
www.youtube.com/watch?v=eF4ez-iHIyU -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
www.instagram.com/normanfinkelsteinofficial/
The Norman Finkelstein IG has been created for anyone who favors that platform! -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
www.instagram.com/normanfinkelsteinofficial/
The Norman Finkelstein IG has been created for anyone who favors that platform! -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Nazi Princess
Ursala von der Leyen, a German citizen, is president of the European Commission. She has of late lustily embraced Israel’s genocidal war in Gaza.Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
It’s so easy to imagine von der Leyen as a commandant, crisp Nazi uniform, whip in one hand, a German shepherd on her other side, strutting through Maidanek, torturing to death Jews in her path.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Let us hope and pray that the Nazi Princess meets Ryan's fate.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
By Deborah Maccoby ... NOT TO BE MISSED.
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/biblical-brainiac-ben-sh… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
THREAD:
Natural Superiority of Women?
Brainy hunk Jordan Peterson was interviewed by Piers Morgan about Gaza. He confidently stated that “This is a last ditch attempt by the Iranian mullahs to use the Islam against Jews story to prop up their own dismal reign.Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Peterson wondered why the 1947 UN Partition Resolution awarded Jews 56% of Palestine if they only comprised one-third of the population, while Owens wondered what Israel stood to gain by committing a genocide in broad daylight.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
When I juxtaposed in my mind Jordan and Mikhaila, Top Gun and Candace, a book I read as an undergraduate came to mind, Ashley Montagu’s "The Natural Superiority of Women."
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/fighting-amalek-in-gaza-…
Advisor to Israel’s Defence Minister: "SEVERE EPIDEMICS IN THE SOUTH OF THE GAZA STRIP WILL BRING VICTORY CLOSER" -
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
How Norman got to his position on the conflict #ceasefirenow #palestine ... youtube.com/shorts/kNnGGqSMaxU
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Senator Schumer erupts in rage after reading in Times that there were "32 babies in extremely critical condition remaining" at Al-Shifa Hospital. "I just don't get it," Schumer fumed, "Didn't I say STRANGLE them?" Schumer's father was an exterminator.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Small wonder he is so upset.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
IDF "Searching" for Hamas Command-and-Control Center under al-Shifa Hospital
www.youtube.com/watch?v=pSj2h34ZrmY -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
IDF Concedes Error!
An IDF spokesperson just acknowledged that the tunnel under al-Shifa doesn't lead to Munchkinland. Au contraire! It leads here:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=9rpuHN00M4A -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Finkelstein Twitter Exclusive!
The NY Times Reports:
"At Al-Shifa Hospital, Israeli troops discovered a shaft on Friday night and were scouring the underground area it led to, Admiral Hagari said. The military said it plans to release images and video from that operation."
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
An IDF source requesting anonymity has provided this Twitter account with the video revealing where the tunnel leads:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_jqOpDCXY0 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Genocide with Amalek: Norman Finkelstein @normfinkelstein youtube.com/shorts/fiG9J8oYCbI
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Booby Journalists
Israel has shown journalists a hole in the ground at al-Shifa hospital. Is it a tunnel shaft? The jury is still out because—the Times credulously reports—the IDF “fearing booby traps, had not ventured down the shaft at the hospital.” (17 November)
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Most strange. It designed the “miracle” of Iron Dome to deflect incoming missiles, but it can’t figure out how to deactivate a booby-trap. Here’s an idea. It can always rely on an old trick of the trade.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Whenever it used to fear a booby-trap, the brave IDF conscripted Palestinians—including children—to march ahead of them as human shields.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
In any event, have no fear: it’s certain that Israel will figure out how to deactivate the booby-trap—after it finishes constructing the tunnel.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Devil’s Eiland
A headline on the front page of the NY Times poses the question, “Is Israel’s Military Strategy to Eradicate Hamas Working?” It goes on to state that the “military strategy at the heart of the ground invasion” is to “eradicate Hamas and free roughly 240 hostages.”Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
“Israel should not allow any economic assistance. The people should be told that they have two choices; to stay and to starve, or to leave.”
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
But No! No!, a thousand times No! Israel’s goal is to “eradicate Hamas.”
[For full references, see
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/fighting-amalek-in-gaza-…] -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Fighting Amalek in Gaza: What Israelis Say and Western Media Ignore
UPDATED: NOVEMBER 18th
normanfinkelstein.substack.com/p/fighting-amalek-in-gaza-… -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Sana
@SanaImmTarek
Israel vs. Palestine with Norman Finkelstein youtube.com/watch?v=te1y7ahp2LQ
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
I was supposed to debate a person named "Destiny" this evening at 6:00 pm. He agreed that Briahna Joy Gray would moderate the debate. Ms. Gray accepted. I provided Mr. "Destiny" with references so as to help him along in the debate.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
He called my scholarship "atrocious" so I anxiously awaited this challenge. But then Mr "Destiny" disappeared. I guess this debate wasn't our -- you guessed it -- destiny.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
-
Norman Finkelstein reposted
Candace Owens Podcast
@CandaceOwensPod
Israel vs. Palestine with Norman Finkelstein
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
rumble.com/v3wd8ng-israel-vs.-palestine-with-norman-finke… With @RealCandaceO
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Job Well Done, Patrick Kingsley
The NY Times' Patrick Kingsley dutifully promoted the Hamas "command-and-control center" hoax to justify Israel's denial of fuel to al-Shifa.
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Here are the fruits of his labor: four premature babies are dead and another five are expected to die due to the lack of fuel and oxygen for the incubators.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Evidence Is In!
The New York Times states today that Israel has justified the killing of 11,000 people in Gaza "in part by Hamas’s decision to hide its military fortifications and command centers inside civilian infrastructure like Al-Shifa."Post not available here, view on X
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
But Col. Elad Tsury, commander of Israel’s Seventh Brigade, said Israeli forces, fearing booby traps, had not ventured down the shaft at the hospital, Al-Shifa. He said it had been discovered earlier in the day under a pile of sand on the northern perimeter of the complex."
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
In other words, as of now. 11,000 people in Gaza were killed "in part" because of a hole in the ground.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Never to Forgive! Never to Forget!
Israel -- and the Biden administration -- justified the suffocation of infants in al-Shifa incubators by asserting that a ramified Hamas command-and-control center was located beneath the hospital (see Israel's image below).
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
How did this sprawling command-and-control center vanish?
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
It is now 24 hours since Israel invaded al-Shifa hospital. No sprawling Hamas command-and-control center. No arms caches in the tunnels. No secret passageways. No nothing except: DEAD BABIES IN INCUBATORS WITHOUT FUEL.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
THREAD:
Let the Circus Begin!
Patrick Kingsley of The Times reports:
"In a video filmed at Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City, a military spokesman, Lt. Col. Jonathan Conricus, showed about 10 guns, ammunition, -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
NEWS FLASH: IDF Discovers Saddam's WMD Hidden in al-Shifa Basement. An IDF spokesman stated: "It's clearly labeled in black-and-white: SADDAM'S WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION."
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
It is reported that Israel is about to invade al-Shifa. Don't be surprised if it finds copies of Mein Kampf in the incubators.
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
If I re-enroll in college as a freshman, will Ben Shapiro then agree to debate me?
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Most Magnificent Sight on God's Earth (Organized by Jews)
Jewish Voice for Peace
@jvplive
⚠️ HAPPENING NOW AT NYC'S GRAND CENTRAL STATION: THOUSANDS OF JEWS AND ALLIES HOLD AN EMERGENCY SIT-IN, DEMANDING A CEASEFIRE IN GAZA. WE'RE TAKING OVER THE GRAND CONCOURSE. WE'RE REFUSING TO ALLOW A GENOCIDE BE CARRIED OUT IN OUR NAMES. CEASEFIRE NOW! NEVER AGAIN FOR ANYONE! ⚠️
-
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
The Hospital Bombing: What is the US Afraid of?
It’s so simple to resolve the mystery of which side committed the atrocity:
(1) Gaza is a tiny place. US intelligence was intensively monitoring the area. Why doesn’t the US simply publish its satellite imagery? -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
Norman Finkelstein's book, GAZA: An Inquest into Its Martyrdom, is now #1 on Amazon's Middle East bestseller books
www.amazon.com/gp/bestsellers/books/684269011 -
Norman Finkelstein
@normfinkelstein
What the Nazis Did to the Warsaw Ghetto after Jews Dared Resist the Nazi Ubermenschen





























































































































