American citizen Wilmer Chavarria was reentering the country from a trip to visit family in Nicaragua.
As Wilmer prepared to walk past the final CBP agent, he was stopped. Wilmer was surprised, but he knew he had done nothing wrong and tried to remain calm. Surely, this mistake would be rectified shortly.
He and his husband were led to the backroom meant for additional screening, where they were met by a woman in plainclothes. She led Wilmer deeper into the building, leaving his husband behind to wait.
Wilmer was ushered into a cold, windowless room where a mix of federal agents—some in uniforms, some in plainclothes—rotated through, towering over him and subjecting him to hostile lines of questioning. Never once was he told why he was there. This continued for over four hours, but without a clock in the room, Wilmer had no concept of time.
Even though they made no formal accusations, his interrogators demanded that he hand over his electronic devices—which included his personal phone and his work tablet and laptop—and all his passwords. Wilmer knew his Fourth Amendment rights and refused. The agents continued their intimidation tactics to break Wilmer down.
“They said they were going to taint my record so that I could never get a job again. They were going to refer me to the FBI because I had something to hide. They were telling me out loud that they would destroy my life if I didn’t do what they were asking me to do,” Wilmer remembers.
At one point, he capitulated and handed over his devices but still refused to give his passwords. He repeatedly asked to speak to an attorney but was denied and told that he had no Fourth Amendment rights.
Eventually, the agents’ tactics worked. Willmer was physically and mentally exhausted and he just wanted to go home.
Wilmer finally gave up and allowed them to access his phone and computer.
American citizens should not have to hand over access to their electronic devices to reenter the country. That's why we're suing to defend Wilmer's Fourth Amendment rights.