Does this seem like a real person to you? Or some LLM?
Could Elon be boosting numbers and engagement by using bot accounts, as Ashley Maddison did? But even better, maybe he is creating bots that pretend to be people who were once on twitter and have left?
Paul Romer
Paul Michael Romer (born November 7, 1955) is an American economist and policy entrepreneur who is a Seidner University Professor in Finance at Boston College. Romer is best known as the former Chief Economist of the World Bank and for co-receiving the 2018 Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences (shared with William Nordhaus) for his work in endogenous growth theory. He also coined the term "mathiness," which he describes as misuse of mathematics in economic research. More on Wikipedia
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
FYI: You are following a fake account that pretends to be me.
@shantelle39729
@DonteJarvi61177
@LorenAdler
@george70209387
@ray_mclaug21770
@D_K_M242962
@MichaBeverl
@GraceMetoy71410
@VeryShineLuAr
@nicke_charl
@LucjaCeres
@ClareQuiro45366
@aswoboda
@Fran4Dunedin
@AsaMadden45581 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
FYI: You are being followed by a fake account that pretends to be me. Fake handle: @paulmromers Tipoff: the "s" at the end
@jeannine3161 @ForrestShryock @ChildrenNeedUs_ @Noahpinion @nealkwatra @shlorenzen @DavidNAKinney -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
FYI: You are being followed by a fake account that pretends to be me. Fake handle: @paulmromers Tipoff: the "s" at the end
@coco_dachs @_tryke @Yeeprs1 @mimilewissabin @PTReid684 @Fran4NZ @AleVentu1998 @BenGera9 @kinsako87 @AdamTherneau @russ_conser @aswoboda @FredHeitman -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
FYI: You are following a fake account that pretends to be me. Fake handle: @paulmromers Tipoff: the "s" at the end
@davidpiegaro
@gmamlet
@Alfonsomonterod
@HHIDavidson
@oblivious_dude
@hayleycbbrown
@hpwaltha
@wutrain -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
FYI: You are following a fake account that pretends to be me. Fake handle: @paulmromers Tipoff: the "s" at the end
@Yeeprs1
@Fran4NZ
@Charles81177138
@AsaMadden45581
@Andi_llb
@anchari
@DercioDeAssis
@Valio_ch
@tveitdal
@mircea_epure
@bse_barcelona
@bsm_upf
@Dviddles -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
FYI: You are following a fake account that pretends to be me. Fake handle: @paulmromers Tipoff: the "s" at the end
@SEASolicitorCJS
@LucjaCeres
@Jonthn_Wheatley
@FT
@TomaszUrbas
@shlorenzen
@Sderivet
@vis.social
@ClareQuiro45366
@MerviHangasm
@aswoboda
@NEOS
@dbroockman -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Another indication of the sad state of X/Twitter: Someone using the handle
@paulmromers (notice the "s" at the end)
is pretending to be me, reposting many of my old posts. Don't be fooled.
Better yet, don't use X/Twitter. I stopped last year and it's been great. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
While I'm here ...
There is one important story that I found when I came back after a month:
See also:
x.com/lydiadepillis/status/1598781874834444293
Lydia DePillis
@lydiadepillis
Important paper here from the @BostonFed finds that 44% of the rise in labor force exits among prime aged U.S. men from 1980-2019 is driven by a decline in *relative* wages for non-college educated white guys: www.bostonfed.org/publications/research-department-workin…
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Stop doom scrolling on twitter.
Read some good news:
paulromer.net/inflation/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Winding down twitter, moving to my blog:
On Sequoia Capital's fawning portrait of Sam Bankman-Fried (SBF), the collapse of his financial empire (FTX), and the central role the Sequoia portrait assigns to effective altruism (EA) in this saga.
EA-FTX-SBF
paulromer.net/ea-ftx-sbf/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Winding down twitter and moving to my blog:
Looting as the Endgame of the Entirely Predictable Crypto Collapse
paulromer.net/looting-redux/ -
Paul Romer reposted
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I’m good.
Twitter Verified is a sham. It is in no way a solution to the pervasive identity problems on this and all other digital platforms.
I don’t want a check for me. I want someone to come up with a trustworthy solution that is open to every real person. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
To everyone who wondered why I never wanted a Blue Check from twitter, is it easier now to understand?
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Healthy Davis Together: Creating a Model for Community Control of COVID-19
American Journal of Public Health
ajph.aphapublications.org/doi/10.2105/AJPH.2022.306880 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Well who'd a thunk:
Turns out that frequent testing did in fact reduce deaths from covid:
www.politico.com/news/magazine/2022/09/25/the-city-that-s…
Revealing, and very damning, article by @vcolliver -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Here we go:
If Offit truly cares about the cost versus benefit of a vax, why hasn't he done a cost-benefit analysis?
Why does a journalist quote him without demanding numbers?
Good science relies on quantification, not hunches and hand-wringing.
www.science.org/content/article/omicron-booster-shots-are… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I couldn't agree more with @zeynep.
I can say it more bluntly:
The noise that some well known scientists injected into the public discussion about vaccines killed a lot of people In the US. And is still killing them.
1/2
www.nytimes.com/2022/09/15/opinion/covid-booster-shot.html
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Don't let yourself or those you love be collateral damage from negative-attention-getting behavior.
2/2 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
New story on still under-reported and under-appreciated fact about US labor market -- fewer people are at work.
www.nytimes.com/2022/09/12/business/economy/labor-partici…
As @lydiadepillis notes, covid and above age 55 could be part of the story.
But only part. See US v Canada for prime age workers.
1/n
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Canada should be suffering from the same post covid reduction in labor supply. US lags far behind among workers between ages of 25-54.
Same when comparing US to other countries:
2/n
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The international comparisons suggest something specific to US that affects workers at all ages.
It also suggests that employment in the US has been on a downward trend behind ups and downs of recessions and recoveries since late 1990s.
3/n -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Economic update:
One month ago I showed data on the increase in inflation in many countries and predictions that it would fall.
x.com/paulmromer/status/1548072556095086595
So far, those predictions have been correct. PCE inflation gauge that Fed uses shows US prices fell slightly in July.
1/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Inflation in the US looks similar to inflation in peer countries
https:paulromer.net/current_recovery
1/3Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Moreover, wage inequality continues to go down -- wages are growing faster in bottom quarter of wage dist than in top quarter.
We have not seen this much progress since the tight labor market of the 1990s.
3/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
But the fraction of adults w a job is lower in the US compared to what it was in the past and to other countries. See e.g. the difference for both men and women in US vs. Canada.
So crucial that wages continue to increase for workers w least attachment to labor market.
4/4 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Congrats to the team at the WSJ for making sure their article on the letter from NARA documenting the sensitivity of the classified info recovered from Mar-a-Lago in Jan 2020 included a link to the actual letter.
@JanNWolfe, @learyreports @sgurman
www.wsj.com/articles/letter-to-trump-lawyer-highlights-na… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Politico reruns quote from Rep Stewart:
www.politico.com/news/2022/08/23/national-archives-letter…
Why? News that Trump kept had even more "special access program" materials.
- FBI inventory for docs recovered on Aug 8
- Letter from Nat. Archives leaked today by Team Trump about docs recovered back in Jan 2022
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Rep. Chris Stewart (R-Utah), a member of the Intelligence Committee, commenting on today's news about Trump:
www.politico.com/news/2022/08/12/gop-contorts-itself-in-d…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
You can find the letter from NARA (National Archives and Records Administration) here:
www.archives.gov/files/foia/wall-letter-to-evan-corcoran-…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From the first page of the letter
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Or you can read the letter here:
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/08/23/us/politics/nation… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Helpful background from @gcaw on the legal implications of nuclear secrets.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/08/trump-fbi-raid-… -
Paul Romer reposted
Noah Giansiracusa
@ProfNoahGian
Wrote op-ed w/ Nobel Prize winning economist @paulmromer in which we explore the power of mathematical functions (and mathematical thinking) to provide a clear debunking of AI sentience and to reveal what's been largely missing from the debate. 🧵 1/14 www.barrons.com/articles/ai-artificial-intelligence-googl…
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Rep. Chris Stewart (R-Utah), a member of the Intelligence Committee, commenting on today's news about Trump:
www.politico.com/news/2022/08/12/gop-contorts-itself-in-d… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Inflation in the US looks similar to inflation in peer countries
https:paulromer.net/current_recovery
1/3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The prime age employment Rate in the US has still not recovered and lags far behind the rate in peer countries
paulromer.net/current_recovery/
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The good news is that wages are increasing faster for those with the lowest employment rate
paulromer.net/current_recovery/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From my conversation today with @DavidWestin:
The secret success of Biden's economic policy. Wage inequality is shrinking -- wages for workers at the bottom are growing faster.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Graph from
www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2022-06-08/us-income-ineq…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
But from the same article -- the US still has a long way to go to reduce wage inequality:
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Of course, the hero behind the success of Biden's policy is @SecYellen.
Her work on nominal wage rigidity tells you exactly why the only way to get a reduction in wage inequality is to have an increase in the rate of growth of average wages.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"But wait!
Didn't fresh-water macro-economists show that they could just assume away nominal wage rigidities and produce coherent theories that come out they way they want them to?"
Yes, but a fact beats a theory every time.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Recent facts about wage rigidity:
scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/simonquach/file…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I refer to the graph of wage growth at 2:50 in this video:
www.bloomberg.com/news/videos/2022-06-09/current-inflatio… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
This is a nice example of why I've stopped allowing replies.
People who should know better tweet out so much that is plainly wrong.
An inflation adjustment would make zero difference to a measure of relative wages!
Domenico De Giorgio, EU. Capre Diem (not a typo).
@degiorgiod
I'd inflation adjust tho.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From my conversation today with @DavidWestin:
The secret success of Biden's economic policy. Wage inequality is shrinking -- wages for workers at the bottom are growing faster. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Back in the naive 1990s, when I was trying to characterize the link between technology and economic growth, I didn't think about the possibility that a nation's tech sector might specialize in new opportunities for grift.
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-02-16/who-won-the-me… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Journalist falls for stunt by MTG, who fakes confusion about gazpacho and Gestapo.
A perfect demonstration that negative attention-getting behavior works.
Hugo Lowell
@hugolowell
New: House Republican Marjorie Taylor Greene is railing against Pelosi’s “gazpacho police” — intending to refer to the Nazi Gestapo, itself a nonsense comparison, but instead referring to a cold tomato soup.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
See also
SwiftOnSecurity
@SwiftOnSecurity
YouTube content creators noticed that making minor errors got them more user interaction, so they started misspelling things on purpose in videos because the algorithm rewards engagement of any kind.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Please:
@hugolowell, 110k followers
@jdawsey1, 325k
@maggieNYT, 1.7 million
Consider the possibility that MTG is punking you and that you are rewarding her with the attention she craves.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If MTG was looking for more attention, she hit the jackpot with gazpacho:
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/02/a-raid-by-nancy… -
Paul Romer reposted
Natalie E. Dean, PhD
@nataliexdean
With re-infections, breakthroughs, & home testing, the reported numbers are only getting more complex to interpret. Waste water surveillance is a fantastic tool, but it doesn’t tell us who is getting infected. Here, I write about the benefits of random sampling for surveillance.
nature
@Nature
It's time to change how we track COVID-19 infections, says biostatistician @nataliexdean go.nature.com/3HAmC3S
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
100,000 deaths (to date) in US from the Omicron wave.
A death rate that is twice as high as in our peers.
@DLeonhardt asks the obvious question: Why has the US done so badly? We have so many professors in the health sciences?
Exactly.
David Leonhardt
@DLeonhardt
Why does the U.S. trail so many other countries in getting booster shots into arms? There are multiple answers. But I think an important one is the communication flaws of our public-health bureaucracy. 🧵 www.nytimes.com/2022/02/07/briefing/boosters-us-covid-omi…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Chart (from very good thread by @jburnmurdoch) reinforces Leonhardt's point that the recent problem in the US is not simply vaccine refusniks.
The crushing blow in US was failing to get everyone who got 2 shots to trade up to 3.
Booster rebels have to be prime suspects.
2/3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
R Proctor showed how big tobacco held off regulation of cigarettes for decades.
www.ucpress.edu/book/9780520270169/golden-holocaust
All it took was patient repetition: "The sensible policy is to do nothing until all uncertainty is resolved." And academics willing to keep generating noise.
Voila!
3/3 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Why Lisa Cook is a better nominee for the Board of Governors of the Fed than John Cochrane would be -- or than I would be.
paulromer.net/lisa-cook/
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
See also the article by @ctorresreporter
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-02-02/first-black-wo…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
For more on the background on the history of the paper by Lisa that I described and to have a chance to hear her speak for herself, check out:
www.npr.org/2020/06/11/875445743/story-of-a-paper
by @CardiffGarcia and @svaneksmith
www.npr.org/2020/06/12/876097416/patent-racism
by @duffinkaren and @mdc -
Paul Romer reposted
Colby Smith
@colbyLsmith
Lisa Cook, who would be the first black woman on the Fed's board of governors, faces a rocky confirmation despite widespread praise from fellow economists and policymakers www.ft.com/content/33bb8e9c-ca6d-4e81-8af0-5f59727f5655 @FT
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If this was the first report on a newly discovered virus, I don't think the headline would be,
"No Worries, New Virus Could Have Been More Severe"
Aaron Richterman, MD
@AaronRichterman
A few days old (years in omicron-time), but the Norwegian x-mas party outbreak report is instructive:
-81/110 (74%) attack rate w 89% vaccinated x 2 => high
-median incubation period 3 days (IQR 3-4) => short
-80/81 (99%) symptomatic => high
www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.202… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
A very clear explanation about how easy it is to mislead by reporting data from the most recent couple of days.
In a comparison with values from 6 days ago, results for yesterday are always going to be lower. It will always look like we are past the peak.
Just An Ordinary Bloke
@Unusual_Times
I'm going to briefly explain why you should take any specimen date case number less than five days old with a pinch of salt because it is likely incomplete.
So for example people quoting numbers for the 16th December today on the 21st December are telling the truth (ish). -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Will the booster rebels try to organize another mob attack on vaccines?
I wonder how many extra deaths we will see in the US because of the effect that the last one had on the take up of boosters in the US.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Taking note, to date Israel has called the shots, with the data to back it up, exceptionally well
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Official confirmation of the report from @MadsAlbertsen85 that the Danish gov't has hit the limit of its capacity to process samples.
Statens Serum Institut
@SSI_dk
Dear Jukka
We are only showing data until the 15th in the reports where we compare Omicron with other variants because the variant PCR analysis right now is delayed, because of the number of tests vs. the capacity. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
We will know a lot more when we see data on hospitalizations in one week from now in the UK.
There are two important lags that we will have to account for:
1. from infection to hospitalization
see discussion by @chrischirp
1/2
Prof. Christina Pagel - @chrischirp.bsky.social
@chrischirp
THREAD on cases, hospital admissions and why so many scientists & NHS leaders are worried.
Case study of London - and what is behind the alarm!
1/10
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
2. Cases will initially be concentrated among young people because of differential patterns of socialization, then move to older age groups.
Colin Davis
@ProfColinDavis
If we look at the age breakdown we see a similar pattern to other places -- the big increase over the last week (red line vs. blue line) has been among young(ish) adults. I think this is largely due to greater socialising in these age groups.
-
Paul Romer reposted
Mads Albertsen
@MadsAlbertsen85
Unfortunately, It’s just the test system that cant keep up with the massive influx of samples.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Not clear that omicron wave in UK really is slowing. Testing capacity may have big effects.
Colin Davis
@ProfColinDavis
Over 15K omicron cases reported today, which is the highest yet, though below the trend line again. This might indicate a slowing of growth (one would expect changes to behaviour to have had some effect), but it's harder to draw solid conclusions as testing hits capacity limits.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
On the basis of a careful look at the SA data, @michaelzlin argues case that the hospitalization rate from omicron is about 1/3 of the rate for delta and that age distribution of omicron cases does not explain this reduction.
Michael Lin, MD PhD 🧬
@michaelzlin
Finally, what we've been waiting for: age-controlled data on Omicron severity, courtesy SA health ministry.
Across all ages, deaths among hospitalized pts are 2/3 lower in Omicron wave.
If more mild cases are admitted, this # goes down, but doesn't seem likely that's the reason
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Even if this turns out to be true, it seems likely that the total number of cases and infections will be substantially more than 3X times larger than for previous waves.
So the takeaway is still that the coming wave is likely to be worse than any we've seen so far.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
But I do not know how to reconcile the SA evidence with this evidence from UK that likelihood of hospitalization with omicron is no different from delta.
@chrischirp is there an update for these data?
Prof. Christina Pagel - @chrischirp.bsky.social
@chrischirp
Hosp admissions by primary diagnosis show increase in *both* admissions for Covid and more incidental admissions (e.g. trauma or caught covid while in hospital for something else).
This is consistent with no evidence that Omicron milder.
Critical care already v busy. 13/18 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Omicron's rapid spread very likely the result of shorter generation interval (time between infections) bc of a shorter incubation period.
www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/12/omicron-incub… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Signs that young people are the vanguard in the new omicron wave.
Colin Davis
@ProfColinDavis
Thread got unravelled ...
Colin Davis
@ProfColinDavis
If we look at the age breakdown we see a similar pattern to other places -- the big increase over the last week (red line vs. blue line) has been among young(ish) adults. I think this is largely due to greater socialising in these age groups.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Limits on test capacity may be affecting reported results from Denmark.
Mads Albertsen
@MadsAlbertsen85
#omicron update from Denmark. I'm stopping to report the daily increase of #omicron in Denmark. It has been dominant from the 16th of December, but the test systems can not keep up anymore. See yesterday's tweet.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Data on the growth rate of omicron in CT - doubles every 3.5 days ~ exponential growth rate of 20%.
-
Paul Romer reposted
Adam Kucharski
@adamjkucharski
Any writer who claims 'UK models always overestimate COVID numbers' is either lazy or trying to mislead their readers. A few illustrations... 1/
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Better late than never.
Better some than none.
Gaurav Venkataraman
@gaurav_ven
Congratulations to everyone who has been tirelessly pushing for this in the USA (@michaelmina_lab, @paulmromer + others). Hope it's enough, in time.
www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/dec/21/biden-to-announce… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
In rough terms, the US now has 130k daily cases and a case-fatality rate of 1%.
If you are have a strong view about the omicron wave, what are your best estimates:
a) When does US will hit 1 million daily cases?
b) What fraction of those million cases will end in death? -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
There is tons of material like this on his feed and he thinks that what @mugecevik says backs him up.
I doubt that he would ever conclude that from anything @mlipsitch writes.
2/2
Michael Openshaw
@mopenshaw
Still figure I'll catch Omicron somewhere along the line, even vaxxed & recovered from a breakthrough. Yeah, I'm absolutely TERRIFIED 🙄of getting- tiredness, a scratchy throat & a headache for a day or two, which is what 99.9+% of the cases are.
Ignore the panic porn, folks. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
This is what it sounds like when a right wing crazy gets his "science" from Muge Cevik.
1/2
Michael Openshaw
@mopenshaw
Also, you MIGHT want to read up on the significantly different PATHOLOGY of Omicron, with infected cells almost exclusively bronchial, not lung tissue itself. (1st career was medical microbiology, 2nd data analysis; read 160+ papers over 20 months.)
Muge Cevik
@mugecevik
In this ex vivo study (press release), Michael Chan, Malik Peiris & John Nicholls et al. @hkumed show that at 24h after infection Omicron replicated ~70x faster than Delta in bronchus. Interestingly, it replicated ~10x less efficiently in the lung tissue. www.med.hku.hk/en/news/press/20211215-omicron-sars-cov-2-…/
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
This is what it sounds like when a serious scientist discusses the severity of omicron.
Marc Lipsitch
@mlipsitch
the following thread is purely my personal opinion as a @CCDD_HSPH @HarvardEpi epidemiologist. I would welcome feedback though I am trying to take some breaks so don't promise to reply. Thanks in advance to anyone who provides critique or further info
-
Paul Romer reposted
Nafnlaus 🇮🇸🇺🇦
@enn_nafnlaus
Lastly, before the last wave, around 40% of SA had had a previous infection, but at the start of this wave over 70% had; and a quarter of SA was fully vaccinated, particularly the high risk.
TL/DR: You cannot compare variant severity by such naive methods. You must do studies. -
Paul Romer reposted
Nafnlaus 🇮🇸🇺🇦
@enn_nafnlaus
Furthermore, the wave has been on average much younger (image) - the age difference *on its own* would imply 1/3rd the rate of hospitalizations. And growth has been much steeper, which creates a stronger time bias in the hospitalization/mortality pictures.
-
Paul Romer reposted
Nafnlaus 🇮🇸🇺🇦
@enn_nafnlaus
Gary, the latest Imperial College report - in agreement with the Danish report earlier in the week - shows the same severity as Delta. Furthermore, it shows protection from past infection is down to a mere 19%, gutting the "herd immunity through infection" hypothesis.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The problem with the people pretending to be health professions while selling the "omicron is less severe" snake oil is that they are frauds chasing likes and clicks.
The serious people with credibility are saying something very different.
Michael Baym
@baym
If you think the US isn’t also about to hit its highest caseload by far of the pandemic, it’s pure wishful thinking.
Even if it’s meaningfully less severe, there will be major nationwide disruptions from the sheer number of people sick simultaneously -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
www.washingtonpost.com/health/2021/12/19/fauci-warns-omic…
But the experts feeding the "it's not severe" bubble are not worried. They will move on to a new scam new scam. After all, they haven't suffered any reputational harm for spinning up the claim that "boosters are bad." -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More persuasive skepticism about whether SA data are actually reassuring.
"TL/DR: it's far too soon to be assessing this wave's severity."
Nafnlaus 🇮🇸🇺🇦
@enn_nafnlaus
Now let's align hospital admissions (red again) with the first wave. What does that look like?
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The NYC vanguard.
Patri̶c̶k̶ Hipp
@thehipp
Bartender here: the rest of you are fucked in about two weeks.
-
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Today's report on Omicron (vs yesterday)
Hospitalizations increased from 85 to 104
Deaths increased from 7 to 12 -
Paul Romer reposted
Tom Wenseleers
@TWenseleers
Still - if the lower 95% conf interval is 40% less severe that already excludes 2 or 3x less severe...
-
Paul Romer reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
If you have symptoms of COVID-19, for example a dry cough, I advise that you do not go testify to Congress about how masks are unnecessary while maskless.
Ron Filipkowski
@RonFilipkowski
After testifying for over 3 hours in a Senate hearing where he suggested masks may not be necessary on flights, Southwest CEO Gary Kelly tested positive for covid. Sitting with him were CEOs of Delta, United, American, and Pres of Flight Attend. Here he is.
-
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Dr Fearnley's warning
x.com/fearnley_k/status/1472273232216707074 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More very preliminary evidence from UK that there is no reduction in severity for Omicron.
Prof. Christina Pagel - @chrischirp.bsky.social
@chrischirp
Hosp admissions by primary diagnosis show increase in *both* admissions for Covid and more incidental admissions (e.g. trauma or caught covid while in hospital for something else).
This is consistent with no evidence that Omicron milder.
Critical care already v busy. 13/18 -
Paul Romer reposted
Richard Splett 💎
@therealsplett2
If you read this thread he says his prediction is a minimum of 3000/day and a bunch of people who base their information on their gut feel instead of data say it will be "way less" than that. So that's pretty useful. If he just said "above 3000" no one would complain.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I guess I forgot to include the mandatory trigger warning.
Sorry kids, get ready for bad news: There is this thing called uncertainty.
And there are people called scientists for whom it is a required part of their job to recognize it and quantify it. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
And this point is so obvious and has been said so many times that I find it astonishing that it needs repeating, but it does.
My only amendment would be to say that he may be understating the risk. I see nothing that rules out a surge in the US death rate well above 2000/day.
Dr. Tom Frieden
@DrTomFrieden
Even if Omicron is less severe, unless it’s LOTS less severe, it could double the current already-high US death rate to 2,000/day or more by mid-February. There’s a major risk that hospitals will be overwhelmed in the next two months. 9/
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
As an update, my current estimate is a surge in US death rates from omicron that peaks in the range of 3,000 to 30,000 per day.
Previous peak was 3,300. So burden on medical care system very likely to be worse than during all previous waves.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
To estimate US deaths from omicron, use models from UK, scale by 5 = the ratio of populations
Result: Peak US deaths per day:
3,000 - 30,000
Previous US peak: 3,300 per day
And UK estimates assume tight restrictions that US will not implement.
www.gov.uk/government/publications/spi-m-o-consensus-stat… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
To estimate US deaths from omicron, use models from UK, scale by 5 = the ratio of populations
Result: Peak US deaths per day:
3,000 - 30,000
Previous US peak: 3,300 per day
And UK estimates assume tight restrictions that US will not implement.
www.gov.uk/government/publications/spi-m-o-consensus-stat… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Another reminder that all the breathless speculation about Omicron being less severe was a stupid waste of scarce time and attention.
Bob Wachter
@Bob_Wachter
7) Even if Omicron proves to be less severe, don't get lulled: it's unlikely to be massively less severe. If (let’s say) Omcrn is 30% less severe but cases go up 5-10x (both plausible), that’s still awful, w/ far more hospitalizations & deaths than comparable Delta surge.(12/25)
-
Paul Romer reposted
Stewart Brand
@stewartbrand
Even the Covid survivors of the ICU are traumatized and permanently impaired—in most cases—by what happens in there.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
This is important, genuinely good news.
If you want a rational basis for optimism that there is a way to limit the harm being done by the pandemic, read Eric's (free) substack post about Paxlovid:
erictopol.substack.com/p/why-paxlovid-is-a-just-in-time-b…
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Until now, we’ve fully relied on immunity to counter the virus. With Omicron and further 🦠evolution, it’s time to make this anti-Covid pill a priority. I would enact the Defense Production Act to get pills made at scale and not rely on one company
-
Paul Romer reposted
François Falep
@FFalep40
This is a very clear explanation of this paradoxal conclusion. This is frightening
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Actually, you shouldn't take it from me.
Get your information from someone
1) who knows this area
2) who has a track record of being right: @famulare_mike
x.com/famulare_mike/status/1472019186633248773
🥥 #NeverTrump
@InKamalaWeTrust
#omicron is very likely not (much) less severe.
Don't take it from me, take it from a Nobel Prize laureate 👇
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Faster growth gives negative bias to naive estimate of omicron severity. Using recent rates of growth from @trvrb and @twenseleers, the bias is by an order of magnitude.
This graph gives a qualitative explanation. Blog post calculates the numbers.
paulromer.net/grow-severity-confound/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
A much needed dose of realism from @DrTomFrieden
If you are still telling yourself that "omicron probably won't be that bad because it will be milder," read the entire thread with an open mind.
What if he is right?
Dr. Tom Frieden
@DrTomFrieden
Bottom line: Omicron is still Covid, it’s still capable of doing damage to your body. And it’s still capable of overwhelming our health systems. It’s shaping up to be a hard winter. Get vaccinated and boosted ASAP. 10/
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
This thread poses a troubling question:
Why is it that "twitter/newspaper science" keeps going viral with speculation that is untethered from fact.
e.g.:
- "Boosters might be bad"
- "Omicron might be mild"
...
What incentives drive this?
How can we prevent it?
Mike Famulare
@famulare_mike
The uncertainty around individual-level severity of #omicron is shrinking. & what we're learning is, sadly, predictably, boring.
tl;dr: Omicron is probably about as severe as delta, or every other VOC. "Mild" is all but ruled out.
2 years & many "experts" have learned nothing -
Paul Romer reposted
Nafnlaus 🇮🇸🇺🇦
@enn_nafnlaus
Why do people always keep looking at the most recent week, which is ***incomplete data***? Even ***previous weeks*** continue growing over time as data continues to be updated.
And re: cases: at ~31% test positivity, South Africa's testing capacity is clearly saturated. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Here is an example that is subject to the bias that @enn_nafnlaus flagged and that I tried to explain as clearly as I could in my blog post.
Graphs like this can convey a falsely positive impression even with caveats in the body of the article.
1/N
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
They also published in-hospital mortality by age, which show a similar pattern.
Key point: all of these data are for patients no longer in hospital, so it’s a like-for-like comparison across waves, not biased by Omicron having patients whose outcomes are yet to be determined.Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
2. If you wait, you will be trying to get a booster when there is mad rush of others all trying to do the same.
11/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
3. When the wave hits, it could be so big that even if omicron infections are less severe, the medical system is still overwhelmed.
It may be impossible to find a health care prof. who can treat accident victims, heart attacks, ... much less take time to give you a vax.
12/12 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Faster growth gives negative bias to naive estimate of omicron severity. Using recent rates of growth from @trvrb and @twenseleers, the bias is by an order of magnitude.
This graph gives a qualitative explanation. Blog post calculates the numbers.
paulromer.net/grow-severity-confound/
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More reason to be skeptical of claims that "the evidence shows that omicron is less severe."
Tom Wenseleers
@TWenseleers
Big caveat: new Imperial College report suggests breakthrough infections with Omicron in the UK are no less severe than those with Delta. My advice: just get your booster! www.imperial.ac.uk/news/232698/modelling-suggests-rapid-s… x.com/mroliverbarnes/status/1471838015907631108 x.com/AllamanSeb/status/1471856185494192129
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If anything, the rate of growth I used for omicron is too low, so my estimate of the bias in any ratio of some lagged outcome today to infections today is too low.
@trvrb reported a doubling time of 2.3 for UK. @kallmemeg reports less than 2.
Meaghan Kall has moved to Bluesky
@kallmemeg
GROWTH RATES
Now less than 2 day doubling time
Closer to 1.5 days in the north 😱 growing very fast indeed
(North East, North West, Yorkshire & Humber)
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Do you have any calculations that correct for the bias that a faster rate of growth for omicron induces in any ratio of lagged outcomes to current infections?
BTW, ht to @enn_nafnlaus for raising this issue -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
After turning a poorly informed advisory panel into a pitchforks and torches mob that depressed the take up of boosters and thereby doomed thousand to needless deaths, Philip R. Krause wonders why the FDA has stopped relying on advisory panels.
www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/12/16/vaccines-fda-cd… -
Paul Romer reposted
Billy Quilty
@BQuilty
A demo of how fast you can turn positive:
Yesterday morning, yesterday lunchtime, yesterday evening, this morning.
Do LFTs *just* before meeting up. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
In case you have any doubt about whether long covid should be a concern ...
Rowland Manthorpe
@rowlsmanthorpe
Don’t like putting personal things on Twitter, but I’ve just logged on after a while and found a load of DMs asking why I’ve disappeared, which is… a good question
If you haven’t seen me recently it’s because I’ve got a nasty case of long covid. Eight months and counting :( -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Why you want to use rapid tests on yourself frequently:
If you don't know who among your friends and family is the careless/selfish jerk who will infect everyone else, it's you. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
A helpful explainer by @trvrb on how things could play out in the competition between omicron and delta.
Trevor Bedford
@trvrb
It seems that the common assumption has been that Omicron will displace Delta, just as Delta displaced Alpha, Beta, Gamma, etc... before it. This may well be the case, but it's by no means definite. 1/15
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
When I talk about "carpet bombing" an area with rapid tests, from now on I'll be sure to remember to mention liquor stores too.
ht @nataliexdean
If everybody just followed her, I wouldn't have to do these retweets. :- )
Same for @EricTopol
Isaac Bogoch
@BogochIsaac
Nova Scotia continues to lead the way with free community-based #covid19 rapid tests.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Simulations of omicron risk in the UK quantify benefits of boosters.
For hospitalizations and deaths, dashed line is peak in Jan 2021.
0% booster take-up=>
3-4x worse for hosp's
2-3x worse for deaths
99% boosters =>
comparable hosp's
fewer deaths
cmmid.github.io/topics/covid19/omicron-england.html
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Here is a link to a thread that discusses these results:
Dr Rosanna C Barnard (she/her)
@BarnardResearch
The B.1.1.529 SARS-CoV-2 variant was first reported on 24th November 2021, and 2 days later @WHO designated it #omicron. Since then we (me @_nickdavies @cap1024 @markjit and John Edmunds) have worked to understand potential consequences for England. 🧵 [cmmid.github.io/topics/covid19/omicron-england.html]
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The response by @trvrb to a question about what to do:
And of course, encourage people now to get the boosters that are available now.
Remind them that it takes a couple of weeks for protection to kick in. If they wait for the wave, it might be too late to help.
Trevor Bedford
@trvrb
Lockdowns or other severe NPIs should be a last resort. But some immediate options:
1. Omicron-specific booster approved ASAP
2. Approve a larger gamut of RDTs and supplement pricing
3. Increase manufacturing and distribution of N95s
4. Ramp testing to get antivirals early -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Omicron update from @trvrb:
Fast growth in South Africa -- doubling time of 3.0 days [80% CI 2.4-4.6 days] -- and an "epidemic growth rate" in the UK -- r = 0.32, corresponding to a doubling time of 2.2 days [80% CI 1.8-3.0 days]
Trevor Bedford
@trvrb
We've seen exceptionally rapid spread of Omicron in South Africa. Although we should expect this rapid spread to follow in other geographies, we've mostly lacked data to confirm this until recently. 1/21
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
When historians look back at US management of the pandemic, they will probably highlight as our biggest mistake failing to take full advantage of boosters.
The tool was there, cost little, and was supported by both Dems and key Republican governors.
How did this happen?
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
The overwhelming evidence for 3rd shot boosters *before* Omicron, reinforced by new data for benefit vs Omicron
1. The randomized trial of 3 shots vs 2 shots + placebo, 95% efficacy for preventing symptomatic infections across all age 16+ groups (N=10,125)
www.cdc.gov/vaccines/acip/meetings/downloads/slides-2021-… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Thanks to the Nobel Foundation for hosting a great conversation with Kevin Casas and a group of bright young people who are devoting themselves to protecting and enhancing democracy.
Kevin Casas
@KevinCasasZ
Today at 14.00hr (CET) I'll take part in the Nobel Week Dialogue on "The City of the Future," organized by @NobelPrize. I'm honored to share the conversation with Nobel Laureates @paulmromer & @francesarnold, as well as the wonderful fellows of the @iythinktank. Join us! ⬇️
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
We now can be sure that boosters do not merely prevent infections; they save lives.
x.com/paulmromer/status/1468706832348860421
Last summer, it was already clear that this was very likely.
The tweets that precede this one document just part of evidence available then and in early fall.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Rebels are going to try claim that their opposition to boosters was correct until omicron unexpectedly arrived on the scene.
This paper demonstrates to the contrary that boosters saved lives of people who would have died from delta if they had stayed pat with 2 doses of Pfizer. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From Aug. 24
A blog post of mine
paulromer.net/infrequent-events-and-proxy-indicators/
Was based on a paper that was posted on Aug. 21.
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.08.06.21261707v3 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From Sept. 27:
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
The 2 FDA scientists knew the @NEJM data for >1.1 million Israelis age 60+ w/booster restoration of vaccine effectiveness, but wrote "currently available evidence does not show the need for widespread use of booster vaccination " @TheLancet
There are 70 million Americans age ≥60 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From Sept. 28
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
"The [booster] data themselves weren’t in contention. Rather, nearly the entire debate centered on broader value judgments....."
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/09/28/covid-booster-… by @DrLeanaWen @PostOpinions -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From Oct 1:
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
A hospital Delta outbreak starting with a Covid patient, infects 41 other: patients, staff (wearing masks), and family, of whom 39 (96%) were fully vaccinated but > 5 months out. Transmission between health care workers
www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.202… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From Oct 1:
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Inconvenient truth #3: T cell response
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From Oct 7:
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
These 3rd shot data are compelling.
Beyond protection vs deaths in age 60+ (graph), vs severe illness in younger age groups
But those biased against the usefulness of boosters will continue to put them aside, while over time the gradient of benefit will augment. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From Oct 14:
Leana Wen, M.D.
@DrLeanaWen
Dramatic results from Israel, as presented at FDA advisory committee meeting: Boosters reduce severe disease in all age groups.
Note that severe disease is defined slightly different (it's not just hospitalization/death, but physiological values as explained in this chart). -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The new article in the NEJM confirms indications we've had for months.
From Oct 17:
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Until now, the only clinical proof of booster shot effectiveness came from Israel with Pfizer. New data from the UK, in the 1st group (half) boosted age 80+, w/ multiple vaccines, showing benefit vs hospitalization
by @tomhcalver @thesundaytimes www.thetimes.co.uk/article/covid-booster-uptake-among-the… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
We had the data in hand to see the value of the boosters:
From Oct 18
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Graph of the waning effectiveness of the 3 vaccines over time
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From Sept. 14
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
. @EricTopol and @ashishkjha
The Lancet critique of boosters says decision "should be evidence-based and consider the benefits and risks for individuals and society"
But it contains not even one sentence claiming that risks exceed benefits.
1/n
www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(2… -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
P.S. There are not many interventions in medicine that reduce mortality by 90%
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Obvious 2 months ago:
1. The rebels would kill people by slowing take-up of boosters.
2. Their claims had no basis in logic or fact.
3. Most scientists would look away and say nothing.
4. As truth emerged, the legitimacy of all science would suffer.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Unfortunately, the attack on boosters is just the latest in a series of cases overreach that have seriously damaged the credibility of the entire community of science.
paulromer.net/overreach-credibility/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Rebels are going to try claim that their opposition to boosters was correct until omicron unexpectedly arrived on the scene.
This paper demonstrates to the contrary that boosters saved lives of people who would have died from delta if they had stayed pat with 2 doses of Pfizer. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
FYI, I'm happy to respond to questions about testing.
But my favorite of the 4 is from @TWenseleers -- allow tweaked mRNA vaxs with no additional testing for efficacy or safety.
Some will be hesitant. Fine. Let them wait and watch. I'm in.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
2. Radically speed up the approval process for versions of the existing vaccines that are tweaked to track new variants.
x.com/TWenseleers/status/1467966274554970112
x.com/TWenseleers/status/1467879651540361231
2/N -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The reason that I think tests do offer 10x - 100x return is that they help us get out of **and prevent another** episode of job loss like this.
Of course, cost wouldn't be so high if we had policy like Germany. But we don't and won't. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
For what it's worth, the cost-benefit on deaths alone is not overwhelming.
Take current state of the pandemic. We might stop 1000 deaths per d with 100 million at home tests per d. If tests cost $10, you are looking at $1 m per life saved. Worth it but not a 100x return.
1/2 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Just to be clear, the 4 things I described were 4 **new** things.
x.com/paulmromer/status/1468232752969486344
We should, of course, keep doing things that are working.
EVERYONE should be OPTIMALLY vaccinated, which in the absence of a prior infection, means 3 doses of the mRNA vaccines.
1/2
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Four things we could be doing to limit the health and economic cost of the ongoing pandemic:
1) Develop a new universal coronavirus vaccine
x.com/EricTopol/status/1468231398511235076
1/4
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
I still don't understand why we are not going all out for a pan-sarbecovrus vaccine
www.politico.com/newsletters/playbook/2021/12/07/bidens-w… by @RyanLizza @politico w/ @brucegelin
Our @nature paper in February www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-00340-4
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
And it means no more of this:
x.com/KhoaVuUmn/status/1467601777474392064
ht @Noahpinion
Khoa Vu
@KhoaVuUmn
Public health experts' communication about the vaccine booster be like
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Re 4 things we can do:
I understand the wish/hope that we could simply "change the minds of people who disagree ..."
But as a practical matter, I don't see how to make progress this way.
We live in a democracy. We should be looking for measures that can attract broad support. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Four things we could be doing to limit the health and economic cost of the ongoing pandemic:
1) Develop a new universal coronavirus vaccine
x.com/EricTopol/status/1468231398511235076
1/4
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
I still don't understand why we are not going all out for a pan-sarbecovrus vaccine
www.politico.com/newsletters/playbook/2021/12/07/bidens-w… by @RyanLizza @politico w/ @brucegelin
Our @nature paper in February www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-00340-4
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
2. Radically speed up the approval process for versions of the existing vaccines that are tweaked to track new variants.
x.com/TWenseleers/status/1467966274554970112
x.com/TWenseleers/status/1467879651540361231
2/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
3. Invest in better air quality, starting in schools.
x.com/j_g_allen/status/1426240715491737607
3/4
Joseph Allen
@j_g_allen
SCHOOLS. It's not too late, not too expensive, not too hard to improve air quality.
Target 4-6 clean air changes per hour thru any combo of ventilation+filtration, in this order:
1. More outdoor air (windows, HVAC...)
2. Better filters (MERV13)
3. Portable air cleaners w/ HEPA
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
4. And yes, dramatically scale up our capacity for testing, the NPI that voters want.
Antigen testing every 3 days (A3) could prevent ~65% of all infections. PCR testing (e.g. via www.salivadirect.org ) every 3 days could prevent 70%.
www.pnas.org/content/118/49/e2111477118 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Re approvals by MHRA (UK) and FDA (US) for new antivirals.
Michael Lin, MD PhD 🧬
@michaelzlin
First results of mAb testing on omicron: looks good for sotrovimab. GSK and Vir say no loss of activity v compared to previous strains www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/gsk-s…
-
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Perhaps the safest thing to conclude at this point is that there's no signal for Omicron causing more severe disease than Delta. The case for milder should be viewed as tentative, admixed with hope, amidst many other worrisome signs /8
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Crucial point that keeps getting lost - infection is costly even if patient does not die.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Not much has been said of Omicron's potential to induce #longcovid, but with such high transmission levels that is certainly a concern, as even mild cases can be associated with prolonged disability /7
-
Paul Romer reposted
zeynep tufekci
@zeynep
Another thread on the risk of sublethal mutagenesis (on the virus, not the human!) from molnupiravir:
Michael Lin, MD PhD 🧬
@michaelzlin
In conclusion, it would be highly irresponsible to approve molnupiravir unless the possibility of sublethal accelerated viral mutagenesis is thoroughly addressed and satisfactorily rejected, especially within the target population of patients at risk of hospitalization.
-
Paul Romer reposted
Tom Wenseleers
@TWenseleers
And for those who say "but not a single person died from Omicron". Well, that's not quite correct: the "it's mild" Tshwane report found that of 166 Covid-positive patients admitted to this 1 hospital in the last 2 weeks, 9 died of Covid & 5 out of 33 admissions aged over 60 died.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More on why FDA should deny EUA for molnupiravir, the new antiviral from Merck.
Dr. Dale Wen
@dale_wen
Especially an old drug is shown to be more effective and safer. clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT04668950
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
And now, God help us, Fauci falls into the severity trap.
x.com/AP/status/1467617414217093122
Just like Girior, he distracts and confuses by focusing attention on the probability of serious disease **conditional on infection.**
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Giroir spouting nonsense.
If a software update made self-driving cars crash into 70% more pedestrians, no honest person would say that “this isn't more dangerous because the probability of death in each crash is unchanged."
1/N
www.politico.com/news/2020/12/20/covid-19-variant-mutatio…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Suppose best case that compared to δ, half as many people infected with ο end up dying. Woohoo, right?
But suppose that omicron will infect 10-100 times more people because it can target the 150 million in US who have already been infected.
This math is not difficult.
2/2 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
One of the things I've learned about policy work is that one has to be patient and poised to act.
Even if an argument is logically coherent and consistent with the facts, one has to watch and wait for an opening when people are receptive and able to understand it.
1/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Are we ready to deliver?
If not, there will be no one to blame but ourselves.
5/5
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
PS: Because I do not understand the way that the NYTimes combines multiple articles into a single web page, the link I gave above shows an irrelevant picture and headline.
On my third try, I think this will be the right one.
www.nytimes.com/live/2021/12/04/world/omicron-variant-cov…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
UPDATE: A look at the data suggests that this connection: omicron -> more vaxes is implausible.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I looked at the data on vaccinations and now think that the NYTimes claim that they increased in part because of omicron is not credible.
Vaxes are up starting in the last week of Oct.
No sign of interest in "omicron" or "new variant" or "mutation" until Nov 25. -
Paul Romer reposted
Savannah Bee
@SavannahBee13
I can tell you the new variant gave two of my family members the kick in the butt they needed to go get their boosters.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I looked at the data on vaccinations and now think that the NYTimes claim that they increased in part because of omicron is not credible.
Vaxes are up starting in the last week of Oct.
No sign of interest in "omicron" or "new variant" or "mutation" until Nov 25.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The discussion about omicron might still encourage a bump up in vaccinations, but if so, it is too soon to see this effect.
Data for last 10 days are complicated by Thanksgiving holiday.
2/2
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Lones, FYI, I reposted, this time with the right google trends graph.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Never mind, it looks like you go have the right one. Best, P
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you are feeling overwhelmed by all the detail, here is a new summary of the conclusions reached by one of the scientists working to understand the behavior of omicron, @TWenseleers, along with his recommendation about what to do in response:
1/2
Tom Wenseleers
@TWenseleers
That Omicron is an immune escape variant, that breaks through immunity caused by prior infection and/or vaccination. And that people getting a booster asap is the best protection for now, at least until specifically adapted vaccines might be brought onto the market later on.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Tom is at the pessimistic end of the spectrum among the thoughtful people describing what we know about omicron, but his interpretation is entirely plausible.
If you want a little more detail, see his added text here:
2/2
Tom Wenseleers
@TWenseleers
Short summary below. R0 probably 1.3x higher than Delta, ie 8.5 & 4-5x higher immune escape & reinfection risk than with Delta.
Tom Wenseleers
@TWenseleers
That Omicron is an immune escape variant, that breaks through immunity caused by prior infection and/or vaccination. And that people getting a booster asap is the best protection for now, at least until specifically adapted vaccines might be brought onto the market later on.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
For a less pessimistic take, see the analysis I flagged by @trvrb
x.com/paulmromer/status/1466827973437411333
He includes data on absolute rate of growth bc sequencing data can bias up relative rate of growth of omicron v delta.
@C_Althaus seems to be in the middle:
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Another thread on the fast spread of omicron, by @C_Althaus.
Key observation:
"Hence, it is likely that almost everyone in South Africa has been infected with #sarscov2 and developed partial immunity against reinfection."
x.com/C_Althaus/status/1464922681585897478 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
We need to be careful not to over interpret the degree to which it is "good news" that lots of children and young people are getting infected w omicron in SA.
The percentage is lower but young people are still hospitalized. Some die.
ht @sheldonchang
1/2
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Prof. Mathivha, Head of ICU at hospital in SA:
"Yes we do get a lot of women testing positive being asymptomatic, but now we are starting to see a significant number presenting with symptomatology and this is worrying." -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The problem now is that "insane" noise has had a real effect. Look at how low the booster numbers are in the US for people w age > 75.
The only comfort is that many of them may show up as single dosers because they were willing to lie to get a booster.
1/2
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
With such low uptake of 3rd shots (boosters) in the US, especially in high-risk age groups, as compared with England, the outlook to deal with Delta, no less Omicron, is poor
www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2021/12/03/how-prepared-…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
But even if you treat all the single dosers as people who got boosters, the US is still way behind the UK in terms of the number of people in the 50 and over age groups who are boosted.
So US will have more infections in the > 50 group.
2/3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
And I do not believe all the sophistry and evasive reassurances about "two walls" models that were used to imply that an increase in infections among old people will not have *ANY* downstream effect.
None of the additional infected will be hospitalized?
None will die?
3/4 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"Insane" seems about right to me.
Tom Wenseleers
@TWenseleers
Arguing against boosters and vaccines is pretty insane. In SA only 24% was vaccinated and their natural immunity cost them 230 000 lives and selected for an immune escape variant all the same. Now things can start all over again not just for SA but the whole world...
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I still cannot believe that the rebels said "Yes, boosters will prevent infections. Yes this reduces the effective reproduction number. But we don't care. 'Let them get sick!'"
If the rebels don't want to prevent infections or reduce R, does that mean they oppose masks too?
Tom Wenseleers
@TWenseleers
Absolutely, booster like there is no tomorrow! But the growth rate advantage would suggest that the protection one would then get would still only roughly be equivalent to that of a badly waned vaccine.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More evidence that sensible people are "seriously worried."
It is good that they are speaking up. Because of their emphasis on the facts, the message is getting out.
Demand for vaccines is already way up.
www.nytimes.com/live/2021/12/04/world/omicron-variant-covid
Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social
@BillHanage
A little over a week since it was announced it is already clear that Omicron is really serious. Some important pieces of evidence have begun to coalesce. While the worst outcomes still seem unlikely, what we have is quite bad enough to be going on with, a thread, with nuance 1/n
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
SA data suggests that omicron is relatively good at evading the immune defense from previous infection.
In UK, a hint (small numbers) that omicron is also not bad at infecting people who are 2x vax'd:
In UK:
Not vaxed / vaxed ~ 1/3
Infected by ο:
Not vaxed / vaxed = 6/14
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
The Table from the new UK Omicron report today for their first 22 cases by vaccination status. Small numbers but confirmed by many cases elsewhere for some extent of immune evasion to vaccination, aligns with reinfection signal
assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/syste… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More on MA
Michael Lin, MD PhD 🧬
@michaelzlin
As expected the Thanksgiving holiday was followed by a spike of cases. The below graph is from Massachusetts.
Massachusetts is among the best vaccinated states so it will be interesting to see if a spike in hospitalizations follows in the next 2 weeks or not. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Remarkable data on wastewater testing for Covid in MA along with corresponding data on cases, hospitalizations and deaths, from @j_g_allen.
Start with the last (most recent) tweet in this thread and work backwards.
Joseph Allen
@j_g_allen
Boston wastewater through 12/2
-post-Thanksgiving bump and clear now off plateau, matching peak last winter
-moment of truth for vaccines (key determinants of hosp/death = age and vax status)
>65: 92% fully vaxxed (99% 1-dose)
>18: 82% (97% 1-dose)
(Note: fig on rt is MA)
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
One more booster rebel who now recognizes that the data don't support the rebel position.
-
Paul Romer reposted
Jeremy Chrysler
@jeremychrysler
at least in some places in SA, increase in hospitalization appears to be trending younger as well. Don't know much about age distribution of vaccines but this is odd looking data.
Jeremy Chrysler
@jeremychrysler
Good find here and another data point to be aware of. Hospital admissions are trending younger in the 4th wave in SA according to this data.
Source is 30 min into this video: youtu.be/FFNM7h0h3B4?t=1840 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Early evidence pointing to fast growth of omicron in UK.
Jeffrey Barrett
@jcbarret
So my main take-away is that growth looks fast in a country with immunity mostly from vaccines, rather than previous infection (and with a big ongoing Delta wave). We'll know a lot more soon, but this is not reassuring.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Another thread on the fast spread of omicron, by @C_Althaus.
Key observation:
"Hence, it is likely that almost everyone in South Africa has been infected with #sarscov2 and developed partial immunity against reinfection."
x.com/C_Althaus/status/1464922681585897478 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Omicron is spreading very rapidly.
Why?
@TWenseleers favors R0 ~ 8.
@trvrb R0 < 6.5 (the R0 of delta). Perhaps as low as 2, w relative growth advantage because previous infection offers much less protection against infection by ο.
Either way, outlook looks darker.
1/4Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If @trvrb is right, US faces a huge increase in susceptibles.
He notes that just because most previously infected are susceptible to o, it could still be that vaxed are protected.
Even so, > 30% of US pop is relying on previous infection for protection from delta.
3/4
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
@TWenseleers:
x.com/TWenseleers/status/1466501989500653568
@trvrb:
x.com/trvrb/status/1466076761427304453
Also @AdamJKucharski
1) on the two alternatives:
x.com/AdamJKucharski/status/1359193937907449863
2) caution from last yr.: A higher value of R0 is very dangerous, as delta subsequently showed:
x.com/AdamJKucharski/status/1343567425107881986
4/4
Adam Kucharski
@adamjkucharski
Why a SARS-CoV-2 variant that's 50% more transmissible would in general be a much bigger problem than a variant that's 50% more deadly. A short thread... 1/
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
My dyslexia bites again.
In my thread last night, I got the handle for Trevor Bedford wrong. The correct handle is @trvrb
The link to his thread is ok. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The anti-booster rebels who slowed the take up of booster shots are killing people; just as anti-vaxers are killing people.
And remember, someone who claimed to be a scientist published the fraudulent paper that got the anti-vax movement going - yes, also in The Lancet.
Michael Lin, MD PhD 🧬
@michaelzlin
In this thread from June, I pushed for boosting J&Jers. (As we know, they can now, but only after dying at higher rates than Pfizer and Moderna.)
I also laid out medium and worst-case scenarios. Both came true unfortunately.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Here is a very helpful follow up by @trvrb today with more analysis of Omicron, in particular on the two distinct dimensions that will matter -- transmissibility and immune escape.
Trevor Bedford
@trvrb
Following up here with speculative estimates of the rate of spread of Omicron and a stab at how to apportion this rapid rate of spread between intrinsic transmissibility and immune escape. 1/18
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
A good example of the type of contribution that @trvrb makes regularly, in this case with an initial assessment of Omicron.
Trevor Bedford
@trvrb
There have been a number of overview threads on the emerging variant designated as @PangoNetwork lineage B.1.1.529, @nextstrain clade 21K and @WHO Variant of Concern Omicron. I'm not going to attempt to be comprehensive here, but will highlight a few aspects of the data. 1/16
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
See also this appreciation by @trvrb of the thread by @michaelzlin that I just retweeted.
These two people show that high integrity scientific communication that pays attention to the details *is* possible on twitter.
Trevor Bedford
@trvrb
Thank you for your persistence on this issue. Yet again, prioritizing messaging for intended outcome ("vaccines are highly efficacious, please _everyone_ get vaccinated") rather than scientific accuracy has backfired.
-
Paul Romer reposted
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
The anti-booster movement is just very weird and bad.
It's just an antivax movement by another name.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Same as it ever was.
In reprise of their flagrantly unscientific, anti-democratic advocacy against boosters, Krause and Gruber are back with more incoherent arguments against a strategy for limiting infections that people in the US actually support.
www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/11/29/booster-shots-u… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Same as it ever was.
In reprise of their flagrantly unscientific, anti-democratic advocacy against boosters, Krause and Gruber are back with more incoherent arguments against a strategy for limiting infections that people in the US actually support.
www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/11/29/booster-shots-u…Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Stupidity and mendacity by people who claim to be scientists can do real harm -- and not just to the legitimacy of science. Because of the efforts of the booster rebels, more people in US will get sick; more will die.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
The US markedly lags many countries with boosters, in part because of poor messaging, and lack of priority to get *all* adults with fully restored vaccine effectiveness.
Would help vs Omicron, too. Boosters induce a striking increase in level & breadth of neutralizing antibodies.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Kamala Harris
@KamalaHarris
The best protection against the Omicron variant for yourself, your neighbors, and your family is getting fully vaccinated—and getting a booster shot.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Same as it ever was.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
The US markedly lags many countries with boosters, in part because of poor messaging, and lack of priority to get *all* adults with fully restored vaccine effectiveness.
Would help vs Omicron, too. Boosters induce a striking increase in level & breadth of neutralizing antibodies. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Same as it ever was.
Josh Marshall
@joshtpm
Worth noting that Biden White House has been full booster for months and got lots of criticism from clinicians saying the science wasn’t in yet or that vaccines aren’t for infections but to keep you out of the hospital.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
The US markedly lags many countries with boosters, in part because of poor messaging, and lack of priority to get *all* adults with fully restored vaccine effectiveness.
Would help vs Omicron, too. Boosters induce a striking increase in level & breadth of neutralizing antibodies. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Same as it ever was.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I just finished a 4-week twitter vacation. Highly recommended.
- I was happier and more productive.
- I could have stayed away for a day or a year. As far as I can tell, I didn't miss anything.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=5IsSpAOD6K8 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I'm proud to be married to someone (the reviewer of this book) who insists on the truth and refuses to go along with lazy lies promulgated as part of a political campaign -- even when the people involved have been dead for centuries.
www.nytimes.com/2021/10/29/books/review/in-the-shadow-of-…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
For a factually accurate and intellectually provocative portrait of the life and times of Marie Antoinette, see Caroline's tour de force:
www.amazon.com/Queen-Fashion-Marie-Antoinette-Revolution/… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
A timeline of the events documented in the WilmerHale investigation into the manipulation of data for the Doing Business report.
paulromer.net/georgieva-imf/
The apt conclusion summarized by @JustinSandefur: -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The sad state of play:
Even the action that Ms. Georgieva admits that she took -- "I would tell staff to check, double-check, triple-check" -- data points that were inconvenient, is an admission of intent to commit scientific fraud. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Thoughtful reaction to the IMF Board's decision to back Ms. Georgieva from @JustinSandefur and Ioannis Kessides.
www.wsj.com/articles/embattled-imf-chief-to-stay-followin… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From someone who knows what it means to live a life of integrity in science -- a message that the IMF Board and Ms. Georgieva might want to contemplate:
There is such a thing as truth.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/10/07/francis-collin… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
On Bloomberg today:
"Romer Calls Allegations Against IMF's Georgieva 'Embarrassing'"
www.bloomberg.com/news/videos/2021-10-11/romer-calls-alle…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you are looking for a backgrounder on the scandal that is engulfing both the World Bank and the IMF, @JustinSandefur 's post from several days ago does not mince words.
www.cgdev.org/blog/data-manipulation-scandal-could-topple… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
World Bank's investigation into manipulation of country ranks for *Doing Business* report -- triggered by an internal whistle-blower -- leaves IMF Board w few good options.
From @Jonthn_Wheatley at the FT:
"Divisions over Georgieva’s fate to overshadow IMF annual meeting" -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Summary of the recent data for vaccine effectiveness vs symptomatic infections. At 2 months, this was well over 90% for mRNA vaccines, but by 4-6+ months has declined to between 44-70%.
All ages.
Data for Pfizer, Moderna, and AZ /2 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Apparently, aggrieved booster rebels are still angry about being told that the administration will ignore their advice.
They still do not see how far out of line -- arrogant on politics, clueless on costs and benefits -- they were.
1/N
www.politico.com/news/2021/10/06/biden-covid-experts-boos…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
.@DrLeanaWen has been particularly clear about the arrogance and the cluelessness of the rebel position.
"If we choose to, we can deny boosters to many who want them, including health care workers. We are like gods. Let them get sick. "
2/N
www.politico.com/news/2021/09/30/biden-officials-covid-bo…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Meanwhile, the weight of sensible scientific opinion continues to move against them.
3/3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The absurdity of the position adopted by the anti-booster rebels becomes ever more evident:
www.politico.eu/article/eu-regulator-backs-pfizer-vaccine… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Widows?
So much to absorb from testimony yesterday by @FrancesHaugen.
But one burned like a signal flare in a night fight:
Facebook has learned to target widows because it is easy to suck them into a high engagement vortex of misinformation.
apnews.com/article/facebook-frances-haugen-congress-testi… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Important observation, by
Janan Ganesh.
Despite all the complaining, ...
- his words: "people want to be led."
- my translation, "people want a government that does its job."
Likely to be especially important force in the wake of crisis.
www.ft.com/content/20a7d614-3153-45e2-bde8-55a1cc032f6b -
Paul Romer reposted
Michael Lin, MD PhD 🧬
@michaelzlin
Meanwhile 561 children have died of COVID-19 in the US since the epidemic began
(174 ages 0-4, 387 ages 5-18 per data.cdc.gov/NCHS/Provisional-COVID-19-Deaths-Focus-on-Ag…)
Colin Davis
@ProfColinDavis
In September 2021 there were 328,472 cases of COVID in u-19s in England. This will add thousands (probably tens of thousands) of #longcovidkids. Just under half (48%) of those cases were in 10-14 year olds, who we neglected to vaccinate. Nine children died.
#publichealthscandal -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The absurdity of the position adopted by the anti-booster rebels becomes ever more evident:
www.politico.eu/article/eu-regulator-backs-pfizer-vaccine… -
Paul Romer reposted
Robert H Frank
@econnaturalist
The tax on digital advertising advocated by @paulmromer would be one of the best responses to the abuses of the targeted ad model:
www.nytimes.com/2021/02/11/business/social-media-facebook…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Pushing this thread, which was a reply to Frances Haugen, up to the top.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
One person with integrity and courage can make a difference!
Re a tax on digital advertising, some think it is radical bc it would force a change in the business model: ads -> subscriptions
In fact, it is conservative bc it is the only way to restore integrity and save FB
1/N -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Pushing this thread, which was a reply to Frances Haugen, up to the top.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
One person with integrity and courage can make a difference!
Re a tax on digital advertising, some think it is radical bc it would force a change in the business model: ads -> subscriptions
In fact, it is conservative bc it is the only way to restore integrity and save FB
1/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
In case you do not know who Frances Haugen is and what she has done:
www.wsj.com/articles/facebook-whistleblower-frances-hauge… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Postscript on digital ad tax:
adtax.paulromer.net
has specifics about tax rates and taxes that specific firms might pay.
The system outlined there would collect tax from only 4 firms.
Rest?
Twitter - $0
NYTimes - $0
Verizon -$0
Hulu - $0
Yelp - $0
Reddit - $0
...
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
It is so easy to tailor a progressive tax on corporate revenue to limit the advantages of giant incumbents without encumbering small firms and new entrants, it is surprising that it has received so little consideration.
-
Frances Haugen
@FrancesHaugen
I believe that we can do better.
Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
One person with integrity and courage can make a difference!
Re a tax on digital advertising, some think it is radical bc it would force a change in the business model: ads -> subscriptions
In fact, it is conservative bc it is the only way to restore integrity and save FB
1/N -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
a notable quote
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Here's the spot-on tweet by @pbleic that triggered the follow-up pledge of allegiance to vaccines that I cited in my previous tweet.
If you think I am being critical of @pbleic, you are not reading carefully.
**He** is not the problem.
ht @michaelzlin and @EricTopol
Paul Bleicher
@pbleic
Nosocomial outbreak in Israel in a 96% vaccinated environment. Attack rate was 10.6% for staff and 23.7% for patients. I continue to rail against the oft repeated misstatement that breakthrough infections are "rare" or that vaccinated people don't transmit COVID.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
After defending the truth, why does someone sensible like @pbleic feel the need to recite the pledge of allegiance to vaccines?
Because so many supposed scientists have actually gone tribal:
"If you criticize us for misleading people, you are not with us. You are with them."
Paul Bleicher
@pbleic
Let me be clear. I am a total and complete advocate of COVID vaccination. It protects amazingly well against hospitalizations and death. Everyone should be vaccinated, who can be. That being said, we need to not be afraid to tell people that vaccinated people may get COVID.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"Let them get sick"
That's the response, worthy of Marie Antoinette, from academic rebels who don't want the public to have the option to get boosters.
Fauci clearly understands how arrogant, not to mention politically foolhardy, the rebels are being.
www.politico.com/news/2021/09/30/biden-officials-covid-bo… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Unfortunately, the attack on boosters is just the latest in a series of cases overreach that have seriously damaged the credibility of the entire community of science.
paulromer.net/overreach-credibility/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
As @DrLeanaWen writes, opposition to boosters was a shocking case of overreach by members of the scientific community.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/09/28/covid-booster-… -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
A change in leadership at @US_FDA's Office of Vaccines Research and Review. This was necessitated by the resignation of the 2 FDA scientists who also led a strident opposition to use of 3rd shots www.nytimes.com/2021/09/27/us/politics/fda-vaccine-regula… by @noahweiland
-
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Why are symptomatic post-vaccination covid infections, without hospitalization (H), important?
—they can be severe, on the brink of H
—they can result in #longcovid
—they can transmit to others
—they were the primary endpoint of the vaccine clinical trials for efficacy -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I'll try to say this w no snark.
Leaks complaining about long hours by a few senior officials who are unhappy about having a leader willing to take charge, could do enormous damage to the reputation of the many truly dedicated employees of the CDC.
www.politico.com/news/2021/09/24/burnout-fatigue-cdc-pand… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More evidence that people stop thinking when they use the word "need."
tombreur.wordpress.com/2021/09/22/simpson-strikes-again-a… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Government official does her job.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Re CDC ACIP.
Sigh.
Michael Lin, MD PhD 🧬
@michaelzlin
You only need to listen for a few minutes to realize 9 on the committee were extremely disconnected from reality. "no data on the need" "want to learn more about the risks" etc
As one more grounded panelist said, this is the most studied disease and the most studied vaccine ever -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More on why I fear resistance to booster shots by WHO / public health types will, in retrospect, look just like:
1. Recommendation against masks
2. Denial about evidence of airborne transmission
3. Denial about spread by people with no symptoms
paulromer.net/dice-walls-boosters/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I've worked out some implications of tweets by @jburnmurdoch on dice vs two-walls model.
I've never before seen a model presented in a tweet, but the two-walls tweet nails it -- captures the essence; precise enough to surface its logical inconsistency
paulromer.net/dice-walls-boosters/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"Success in the 21st century will require building upon the bi-partisan infrastructure deal that has passed the Senate."
www.axios.com/biden-economic-plan-nobel-laureates-8b75c69… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Perhaps time to re-frame the question about why the quantity of tests in the US is so low:
Q: Why is the average price of a test in the US so high?
A: A powerful duopoly protects billions of dollars in excess profits by limiting entry into testing.
www.nytimes.com/2021/09/21/briefing/rapid-testing-covid-u… -
Paul Romer reposted
ACEMAXX ANALYTICS
@acemaxx
IMF chief says that claims she inflated #china data at @WorldBank are “not true” – Yet @paulmromer says country rankings published in “Doing Business” report could be easily manipulated – " @KGeorgieva stripped me of all administrative authority " @faznet www.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/manipulation-der-weltbank-…
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
When Kristalina Georgieva was the CEO of the World Bank, working under President Jim Kim, Simeon Djankov was her consigliere and fixer. Everything he did was on her behalf.
1/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The statements and actions of Mr. Djankov that are documented in the audit report just released by the WB are a direct reflection of Ms. Georgieva's character and leadership style.
thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/84a922cc9273b7b120d49ad3b9e9…
2/2 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
How are booster opponents avoiding a finding that efficacy is falling?
Same way a pharma company avoids finding negative side effects:
Focus on rare events and small subgroups so it's impossible to get results that are statistically significant.
paulromer.net/burden-of-proof-games/ -
Paul Romer reposted
Heather Scott
@heatherscottafp
@paulmromer reveals more damaging comments about @KGeorgieva in interview with @AFP news.yahoo.com/nobel-laureate-romer-decries-lack-02174052…
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Perhaps it is also easier to understand why I decided to get myself fired as Chief Economist rather than to keep working in a position where I reported to Kristalina Georgieva:
freakonomics.com/podcast/pima-paul-romer/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Re announcement today from World Bank
Perhaps it is more clear now why I encouraged the new World Bank President back in 2019 to outsource its entire research function.
"Diplomacy and science cannot both thrive under the same roof."
paulromer.net/ft_oped/ -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Today England started giving 3rd shots for all healthcare workers, age >50, and clinically vulnerable individuals who are 6 months out from their 2nd dose, irrespective of what vaccine they received.
While the US fights about whether boosters are needed at all. Brilliant. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More from the NEJM article:
After day 14 post-booster, people in the booster group are about 1/10 as likely to get infected as those not in the booster group. But little difference for days 1-14, so this is not just a difference between the groups.
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2114255 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you read the FDA staff report, read this article from the New England Journal of Medicine next.
If you don't want to read, @EricTopol pulls out the table that captures the key results.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Circling back on the "let me be clear" initial post of this thread
Here are the published @NEJM data today on 3rd shot impact for over 1.1 million Israelis age 60 or older, > 12 days out:
A 19.5-fold reduction in severe illness
nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa2114255 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The report issued today by FDA staff:
www.fda.gov/media/152176/download -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
See Section 5, pages 46-49, of this submission by Pfizer to the FDA for an illustration of what a discussion of benefits and risks for boosters looks like.
Notice that it relies on facts that can be, and should be, verified by others.
www.fda.gov/media/152161/download -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
.@jburnmurdoch provides a useful discussion of the new evidence from Israel about boosters.
He has done an admirable job of covering this complicated topic.
I hope he will consider a suggestion about how to write about these issues more clearly.
1/N
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
Now onto the broader discussion:
• We can clearly see that not everyone needs a booster. For most under-65s, and even some healthy over-65s, protection is still holding up very well
• But for those with serious underlying health conditions, boosters could make a big differencePost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
In general, "need" and "appropriate" are a signal that an argument is leaving the scientific realm of "true" and "false" and transitioning into the realm of advocacy or preaching characterized by "should" and "ought."
7/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
There is an important role for advocacy and preaching in social and political life.
But we will make faster progress in both our understanding of the facts of science and in the evolution of our moral principles if we don't pretend that advocacy is science or vice versa.
8/N -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I pointed to the dishonesty of the argument in the Lancet piece even if you accept its assertions of fact.
Michael Lin shows that the dishonesty also extends to their presentation of the facts.
Michael Lin, MD PhD 🧬
@michaelzlin
1) The news has been reporting on this "expert" editorial opposing boosters.
Just read it. Shocked that anyone would use pre-Delta studies to argue against boosters now.
Plus blatant data destruction that I'll try to explain.
A complete Lancet fail.
www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(2… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
. @EricTopol and @ashishkjha
The Lancet critique of boosters says decision "should be evidence-based and consider the benefits and risks for individuals and society"
But it contains not even one sentence claiming that risks exceed benefits.
1/n
www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(2…Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
They merely pile up assertions about uncertainty and implicit claims about the benefits of waiting without ever admitting that there are in fact costs associated with waiting.
11/n
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The paper is yet another embarrassment.
It is advocacy that pretends to be science.
It discredits everyone who tries to uphold the standards of scientific integrity.
12/nPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Unfortunately because the effect of the paper will be to further undermine the legitimacy and authority that the authors claim for scientists.
15/n
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If scientists and scientific journals are willing to use the misleading rhetorical tricks that we expect from lawyers and lobbyists, why should anybody give more credibility to what scientists have to say?
16/n -
Paul Romer reposted
Michael Mina
@michaelmina_lab
In UK, any household can get a **7-pack** of rapid tests every day for free…
An incredible example of what taking a true public health approach with regard to #covid19 testing looks like. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
It is not hard to understand and accept these two simple facts:
1. Vaccines work
2. They would work even better with a 3rd dose (which as @Bob_Wachter says, conveys its benefits w minimal risk and cost)
People who don't understand just aren't trying
Bob Wachter
@Bob_Wachter
Thx, Eric. We need to grapple with 2 mutually compatible facts at once: vaccines remain highly effective vs cases (& especially severe cases), AND effectiveness has fallen, placing vulnerable folks at ⬆ risk – which likely can be rectified (at very low risk/cost) with a booster.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Better late than never.
www.whitehouse.gov/covidplan/ -
Paul Romer reposted
Elizabeth Stuart
@Lizstuartdc
I am more and more convinced we need to dramatically increase access + affordability of at-home rapid antigen #covid19 tests.
We are a long way from that, though; in my experience many people don't even know such tests exist. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Once again, @drgiroir leaves us puzzled about whether he is intentionally dishonest or is, in fact, the village idiot.
Remember when he assured the public that just because a variant spreads faster, that doesn't make it more dangerous?
Tatiana Prowell, MD
@tmprowell
This is wrong & will unfortunately be misunderstood & misused. Imagine "#sarscov2 infection-->natural immunity" as an investigational product. If that product had amazing efficacy but such poor safety that it killed >600K+ Americans, it would never have seen the light of day. 1/X
-
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Large outbreaks in US schools
Why aren't rapid home antigen tests being freely supplied for all kids, staff to be done on a frequent basis to help prevent outbreaks as has been achieved in multiple other countries? -
Paul Romer reposted
Ashish K. Jha
@ashishkjha
It is absolutely possible to safely have in-person schools
But you can't just wing it
You need to
1. Vaccinate adults
2. Ventilate classrooms
3. Test folks weekly
4. Wear masks indoors
If adults acted responsibly
Kids could be safe in classrooms
Lets not fail our kids again -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
New paper with analysis of data from Israel on changes over time in protection offered by the Pfizer vaccine.
As others have noted, results are consistent with other studies that have been published: 1/n
Ofra Amir
@ofraam
A new pre-print of a study showing a detailed analysis of waning immunity in Israel: technionmail-my.sharepoint.com/:b:/g/personal/yairgo_tech…
TL/DR: infection rate and severe disease rates both significantly increase with vaccine age (thread)
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
As I suggested in my blog posts:
1. Using effectiveness instead of relative risk tends to bias down perceptions of magnitude of change.
paulromer.net/implicit-bias-effectiveness/
2. Confidence intervals are larger for severe disease relative to infections
paulromer.net/infrequent-events-and-proxy-indicators/
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
So we have several papers, agreement on the facts, but polarization of responses into into "glass is half full" versus "glass is half empty."
Policymakers are considering very important choices about boosters.
Time when both sides should strive for clarity in communication. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Why the Mayo Clinic study found a significant reduction in effectiveness of vaccines against infections but not against hospitalization.
Things that happen less often are more likely to get lost in the noise.
paulromer.net/infrequent-events-and-proxy-indicators/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
“Who cares whether the probability of breakthrough infections is increasing? We only care about preventing severe disease.”
<==>
“Who cares that the canary died? We only care about saving the lives of miners.”
paulromer.net/infections-are-the-canary-in-the-coal-mine/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
“Who cares whether the probability of breakthrough infections is increasing? We only care about preventing serious disease.”
<==>
“Who cares that the canary died? We only care about saving the lives of miners.”
paulromer.net/infections-are-the-canary-in-the-coal-mine/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The Implicit Bias of Vaccine Effectiveness
paulromer.net/implicit-bias-effectiveness/ -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
That was a year ago.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The coda to the testing tragedy:
"Maker of Popular Covid Test Told Factory to Destroy Inventory"
www.nytimes.com/2021/08/20/us/abbott-covid-tests.html -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I guess you could say that @paulkrugman 's position is that endogenous growth may work in practice:
www.nytimes.com/2021/08/17/opinion/us-obama-renewable-ene…
... but it will never work in theory:
krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/08/18/the-new-growth-fizzle/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Clear thread on the 4 forces that will drive R toward 1.
His second --
"B. Cross-protective immunity from infection with earlier variant"
-- is big. CDC says 120 million in the US were infected by May 2021.
Of course, infected + vax is even better!
www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burden.html
Adam Kucharski
@adamjkucharski
In discussions of future COVID dynamics and potential for ‘herd immunity’, need to remember there are four main routes to immunity that can reduce Delta transmission - even though coverage often focuses on just one or two of them. A quick thread... 1/
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
In calling for boosters, @EricTopol was once again ahead of the pack.
He saw the links between bits of evidence pointing to two drivers of current trends:
- the mRNA vaccines are less effective against delta
- high initial protection wanes with elapsed time post vaccination
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Last week I mentioned there was more to the US Delta breakthrough infections and hospitalizations (H) than apparent via the CDC website and other sources. Since then the @nytimes looked into it
www.nytimes.com/2021/08/17/health/covid-vaccinated-infect…
Still looking for all US (H) data...... -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
What a difference to have leaders who accept the facts and act.
"Biden administration to announce most Americans will need coronavirus booster shots"
www.washingtonpost.com/health/2021/08/16/booster-shot-cor… -
Paul Romer reposted
Kadee Russ
@Kadee_Russ
Yes but what about TESTING??? Research shows that asympromatic testing 1-2x/week prevents outbreaks, can keep kids safer. All they have to do is spit. @michaelmina_lab @paulmromer www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/08/15/delta-is-comin…
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Exactly!
Jeremy Chrysler
@jeremychrysler
Every person who gets a booster will help reduce Rt as well. If 20% of population would get one quickly, it could mean 7-8% net reduction in Rt, which might well be enough to tip under 1 in many places. Shots are there. Very little reason not to do this IMO.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The paternalism of medical establishment is undermining its credibility.
1. "Two doses of a mRNA vaccine offer huge net benefits."
2. "Someone like Romer who wants a third dose as a booster should not be allowed to have one bc ..."
Why exactly? Net benefit might be negative? -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I agree w @ericTopol:
- vaxes are amazing!
- everyone should get them!
BUT ... we have to admit the truth -- their effectiveness against **infection** falls somewhat over time.
Having two vaxes is great. A third after 4-6 months is even better.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
For the sake of science, pls listen to @EricTopol on truth-telling.
Every time experts tried to suppress the truth, it has been an absolute disaster.
Remember:
- "masks don't work"?
- "presymptomatic"?
- "droplets not aerosols'?
More people died.
Scientists lost legitimacy.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
There needs to be truth-telling about the reduced protection of mRNA vaccines vs symptomatic Delta infections.
It was 95% pre-Delta.
Many are claiming it's still ~80%.
It isn't.
50-60% is best estimate from all sources (not US, since we don't have the data) -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
For the sake of science, pls listen to @EricTopol on truth-telling.
Every time experts tried to suppress the truth, it has been an absolute disaster.
Remember:
- "masks don't work"?
- "presymptomatic"?
- "droplets not aerosols'?
More people died.
Scientists lost legitimacy.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
There needs to be truth-telling about the reduced protection of mRNA vaccines vs symptomatic Delta infections.
It was 95% pre-Delta.
Many are claiming it's still ~80%.
It isn't.
50-60% is best estimate from all sources (not US, since we don't have the data) -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If they are feeling alarmed, maybe they should think about doing something.
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/virus-surge-democrats-mid…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
And just to be clear, "doing something" means "doing something to further reduce the spread of the virus."
It does not mean finding someone else to blame. -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
May 2020
Rapid antigen tests validated
February 2021
"Biden has proposed spending $50 billion to vastly expand rapid testing as part of his push to return most K-8 students to classes within his first 100 days"
apnews.com/article/joe-biden-pandemics-coronavirus-pandem… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
There are 2 levels to flying blind in the Delta wave.
One is the CDC's void of data 👇
The other is our testing, << 1/2 of 3rd wave, w/
very poor availability
A no show: home rapid antigen tests, which should be freely provided to every household to help safely open schools -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The suggestion by many observers --
@EricTopol
@ashishkjha
@ScottGottliebMD
@MeaganCFitz
-- is that test and isolate will limit the spread of delta.
Why isn't the Biden team pushing this?
Especially in hot spots and as a way to get children safely back in school?
Ashish K. Jha
@ashishkjha
My kids' schools open in a month
Have been talking to school leaders (unions, superintendents) across the US about how to keep schools safe
We have 5 tools
And if we use some combination of them, we can get all kids back to school safely, full-time
So what are they?
Thread -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Yes!
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Yes!
Dr. Meagan Fitzpatrick
@MeaganCFitz
Delta doubles attack rate, so puts schools at higher attack rates despite previous successful mitigation. Schools should mentally move themselves down a mitigation level when assessing their risk -- and add probably add MORE mitigation (perhaps testing?) to compensate.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The fight against covid has suffered from Lincoln's Civil War problem -- generals who waffle and hesitate.
The FDA needs a leader who will act.
@ZekeEmanuel has the confidence to reason, weigh evidence, then decide.
www.politico.com/news/2021/08/06/fda-commissioner-search-… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Testing is not the only additional measure that we could be taking. We could also invest in cleaner indoor air:
Nice article about the work on the value of clearer air and ways to get it: @j_g_allen
www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/08/scientist-says-cleaning-i… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Why hasn't admin acted on this?
Tests will slow the virus.
Compared to mask mandates, they do not anger people.
People who are vax hesitant will get tested.
Where besides E. Topol are voices from medicine & pub health?
On all sides -- no explanation; passive silence.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
It's August 2021, where are the rapid antigen tests that should have been supplied for free for every household to accurately screen for infectiousness—which is what really matters? The tests that were ready here in May 2020. www.wsj.com/articles/demand-for-covid-19-tests-and-wait-t… @sharonterlep @Brabbott42
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Given that Facebook's former head of elections integrity ops for political ads says that FB intentionally harmed our democracy, it is no surprise that they are trying to stop academics for discovering exactly what they are doing with their political ads.
www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-08-03/facebook-disab… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Simple, clear assertions by Facebook's former global head of elections integrity ops for political ads, @YaelEisenstat, who refused to let FB buy her silence:
"I believed they had made intentional decisions that harmed our democracy."
www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2021/08/03/facebook-nondis… -
Paul Romer reposted
Mirimus
@Mirimus
Pasadena Health Director recommends weekly COVID-19 testing amongst rising infection rates
#covid #health #pasadena #backtoschool2021
www.pasadenanow.com/main/pasadena-health-director-recomme… -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Current US test positivity is 8%; we have not seen >20% levels anytime since the 3rd wave, but now Alabama 22%, Oklahoma 22%, Mississippi 20%, Florida 19% and 20 states in double digits. And grossly under-testing in face of Delta's spread.
coronavirus.jhu.edu/testing/individual-states
@CovidActNow -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Sometimes it seems as if public health experts are Facebook / Youtube addicts who care only about another chance to provoke the public so they can respond with arrogance and condescension.
Shouldn't the focus be on measures the public will adopt?
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Quote from @AliHMokdad (Wapo) displays astonishing ignorance and/or pigheadedness.
Also: letting people who are infected self-isolate will substantially reduce transmission. We should be carpet bombing outbreaks with free tests.
x.com/EricTopol/status/1420934644480954371
x.com/KittyKicksAss/status/1420961674228498434 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I support a "get vaxed or get tested" mandate; but not measures that needlessly provoke people who are all torqued up about masks.
If there is a way to reduce transmission that won't trigger the same backlash as a mask mandate, wouldn't it at least be worth a try? -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Free, rapid testing is the only measure for decreasing transmission that people **want** -- even Republicans, covid-deniers, vaccine-hesitant, ...
Compare pushback against mandates in NYC vs cooperation with testing in similar group in NJ.
www.politico.com/states/new-jersey/story/2020/10/30/a-tal… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
It is not hard to scale up testing.
Other countries are doing it. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Quote from @AliHMokdad (Wapo) displays astonishing ignorance and/or pigheadedness.
Also: letting people who are infected self-isolate will substantially reduce transmission. We should be carpet bombing outbreaks with free tests.
x.com/EricTopol/status/1420934644480954371
x.com/KittyKicksAss/status/1420961674228498434 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
What if billions of young people suffer new harm.
Evidence in hand => 3 to 1 odds that a specific new vector is the cause.
Wait and study? Or act now to limit lifelong harm?
@JonHaidt & @jean_twenge:
The vector is ad-based social media.
www.nytimes.com/2021/07/31/opinion/smartphone-iphone-soci…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Even if you do not think that ad-tech giants are destroying democracy;
if you have children (or grandchildren) and care about the lives they will live;
you should support action now to limit the harm.
No family acting alone can stop the harm social media is doing to children.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
This is a public health emergency.
The expected harm per child is not as bad as dying. But could be worse than long covid.
If you had to choose for your child between a life limited by
a) chronic fatigue; or
b) stunted emotional development
which would you pick? -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
What's dispiriting is that even leaders in the field of public health refused to take the math seriously.
It was as if they thought their job was to preach and moralize, not to follow logic and evidence.
If you think I'm exaggerating ...
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
My point is not that we should be more or less pessimistic. It is that I have no idea what the authors meant when they wrote:
"More important, we may not need to achieve that goal [herd immunity] in order to escape the pandemic."
www.nytimes.com/2021/05/28/opinion/herd-immunity-covid-us… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
And about the unions that represent federal employees.
If they want to draw a line in the sand and refuse to follow a policy that protects the nation, maybe it's time for a repeat of the firing of the air traffic controllers.
"Get vaxed or get tested.
Or get fired." -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The stomach churning fact is that we should have known there would be a summer wave of covid.
It was predictable as early as January 2021.
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/28/opinion/new-covid-strain.html
x.com/paulmromer/status/1355047477397893122
1/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
On Thursday, @EzraKlein published an important column with discouraging news: the new variants of the corona virus will make it far more difficult to end the pandemic and return to life as we knew it in 2019.
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/28/opinion/new-covid-strain.html
1/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
.. instead of making test and isolate the priority -- targeting the unvaccinated and locations with many of them -- we are instead back in the trap of discussions about mask mandates and activity restrictions.
And now we don't even have the excuse that there are no tests.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The cost benefit analysis and the political calculus are both decisive:
- The policy should be "get vaxed or get tested" -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
19% of breakthrough infections (e.g. infections of people who were fully vaxed) had signs of long covid at 6 weeks.
What does long covid entail?
"some of the patients with lingering symptoms had severe fatigue."
@EricTopol:
x.com/EricTopol/status/1420516224291663875
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
3. 7 of 36 (19% ) of BTIs had "persistent symptoms" > 6 weeks. Table below
An indicator for the potential of #longcovid in BTIs in a few of these people at > 6 weeks, but that's a very limited and early time for assessment. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Follow up to @matthewherper
Why the cost of long covid dominates cost/benefit calc re booster shot:
19% Long covid w breakthrough infections -- Small sample, lots more to learn. But sheesh, why run the risk? I'll pay for a booster now.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
3. 7 of 36 (19% ) of BTIs had "persistent symptoms" > 6 weeks. Table below
An indicator for the potential of #longcovid in BTIs in a few of these people at > 6 weeks, but that's a very limited and early time for assessment. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
As A Garber and I said 16 months ago, T&I (test and isolate) slows spread of virus with minimal restrictions:
www.nytimes.com/2020/03/23/opinion/coronavirus-depression…
- For the willing, vaxes now are better
- For the unwilling, T&I will work without any new burden on the willing, who already did their share -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Both countries have >92% Delta prevalence and have similar vaccination rates (~49-51% fully vaccinated, total pop). Denmark is on the descent. They rely heavily on free, frequent rapid antigen tests. The US is a no show on these.
@OurWorldInData -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Bot Blocking or Twitter as Whack-a-Mole
Here's a good candidate:
- Joined in 2018
- Two tweets
- Zero followers
But hey, a good looking photo. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"Big Tech Backlash Brewing, Nobel Laureate Romer Says"
"... big tech firms are 'causing the problems we're seeing with vaccine hesitancy' and expects a regulatory response from the U.S. government."
www.bloomberg.com/news/videos/2021-07-26/big-tech-backlas… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
There are better responses than either:
1. "You are stupid and defiant."
2. "Let's explore your feelings about vaccines, mind control, and DNA hijacking."
By rewarding attention-getting behavior with attention, these both reinforce anti-social behavior.
Michael Kruse
@michaelkruse
Considering unvaccinated people "'defiant' or 'stupid' ... is probably not helpful," says @ASlavitt. "... we probably ought to try to understand that group of people better if we really want to bring them into the dialogue and participation process." view.newsletters.cnn.com/messages/16272694385715673eb1dad…
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Wise counsel from @ZekeEmanuel
Ignore negative-attention-getting-behavior. It's just cheap talk.
E.g.: Medical staff at Houston Methodist, got lots of media attention by opposing a vaccine mandate. But after it was imposed 97 percent of them complied.
www.washingtonpost.com/health/2021/07/26/mandatory-vaccin…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
if we just ignore their noise about vaccines, they'll move on:
- Flat earth didn't take.
- Blood drinking pedophiles is tired.
- Space lasers ???
But we can count on the disinformation-for-hire specialists to craft some new rant for them.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"For-hire disinformation ... is growing more sophisticated as practitioners iterate and learn. Experts say it is becoming more common in every part of the world, " 2/4
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"The Delta Variant Is the Symptom of a Bigger Threat: Vaccine Refusal" by @apoorva_nyc
Agreed. But vaccine refusal is itself a symptom of an even bigger threat:
www.nytimes.com/2021/07/25/world/europe/disinformation-so… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Social platforms are destroying the most important legacy of the enlightenment - shared reality.
"... newcomers eventually reached the same conclusion as Russian operatives ... Disinformation performs especially well on social platforms." 1/4
www.nytimes.com/2021/07/25/world/europe/disinformation-so…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"For-hire disinformation ... is growing more sophisticated as practitioners iterate and learn. Experts say it is becoming more common in every part of the world, " 2/4
Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"The result is an accelerating rise in polarizing conspiracies, phony citizen groups and fabricated public sentiment, deteriorating our shared reality beyond even the depths of recent years." 4/4
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The entire article by @Max_Fisher deserves a careful read.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Governors on the front lines in R states are not coddling the vaccine hesitant. They say what's true.
Gov of AR:
" someone said ... Call it a bioweapon. And they talk about mind control," Hutchinson said. "Well, those are obviously erroneous." 1/4Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Gov of AL:
"Ivey went on to describe the shots as 'safe' and 'effective,' saying: 'The data proves that it works. [It] doesn’t cost you anything. It saves lives.'" 3/4
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Gov of AL:
“Folks [are] supposed to have common sense. But it’s time to start blaming the unvaccinated folks, not the regular folks. It’s the unvaccinated folks that are letting us down.” 4/4
www.politico.com/news/2021/07/23/alabama-governor-covid-v… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Scientists have zero tolerance for snowflakes.
Facts beat theories; feelings aren't even considered.
Harsh, yes, but it delivers:
- longer lives;
- cleaner air;
- an ozone hole that isn't getting bigger;
...
@ThePlumLineGS on the new blizzard:
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/07/23/have-trump-vot… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Among all the ventures spawned by the emergence of the web, there is one unambiguous success - Wikipedia.
In the fight to defend truth, @noUpside encourages the CDC to learn from an approach that has worked.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/07/cdc-should-be-m… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The point that @mattyglesias gets is that although a tax on the ad-tech giants is far from a perfect solution, it may be our best chance to save democracy -- and not just in the US. All over the world.
Read about my dinner in Chile:
adtax.paulromer.net -
Paul Romer reposted
Alex Thompson
@AlexThomp
Reporter: "What's your message to platforms like Facebook?"
President Biden: "They're killing people. The only pandemic we have is among the unvaccinated and they’re killing people” -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
How does this relate to the US?
2-dose vaccination for AZ or Pfizer vs Delta >90% effectiveness vs hospitalization
Adults %
UK 2-dose 67.5
US 2-dose 59.3
States w/ very low vaccination already showing the signs, inc MO, AR, NV, LA (<-today) -
Paul Romer reposted
WBC24
@WBC24News
NEW: Florida reports 8,225 new coronavirus cases, the biggest one-day increase since April 13
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The obvious, underreported math shows that we are due for another wave of covid infections:
x.com/AdamJKucharski/status/1415587167863283713
The new wave is now upon us:
x.com/EricTopol/status/1415677526689517568
It is time reset public expectations.
We may be done with the pandemic, but it is not done with us.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Parallel lines suggest replication is in the works.
Also seen with deaths. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you are a committed believer in American exceptionalism and the world-beating performance of the US labor market, it's a bit of a comedown to have to settle for:
"Better than Italy!"
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Note on the data:
- I pulled the data from the OECD.
- Only the US, Canada, and Australia provide monthly data, so for comparability, this figure uses quarterly data.
- Today, the most recent observation for monthly data is May 2021; for quarterly is Q1 2021. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Jobs lost since Feb 2020 makes the US look bad enough, but fails to capture the reality that the US has been steadily falling behind.
This measure is the % of people between the ages of 25-54 who have a job; so population aging and retirement are not relevant.
1/2Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
What's worrisome is the combination of:
- a US job market that is more responsive on the downside to shocks; and
- recoveries that are NOT faster.
The combined effect is that the US working age employment rate keeps ratcheting down when other countries show it can go up.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Sorry for the low quality of the graphs in this thread. (Grrr ...)
Better versions here: -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
. @ellawinthrop made the right choice in showing where the US is on the path to economic recovery
- ignore the unemployment rate
- focus on the enormous number of jobs lost and the achingly slow process of creating new ones
www.nytimes.com/2021/07/02/business/economy/june-2021-job… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
.@EricTopol is so right that one has to wonder what has gotten into the leadership at the FDA.
www.nytimes.com/2021/07/01/opinion/fda-vaccines-full-appr… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
News yesterday confirms my warning that courts will not stop the harm done by ad-tech giants; and that it may be wishful thinking to believe that new antitrust law will make any difference.
Alternative legislative approach:
adtax.paulromer.net
www.nytimes.com/2021/06/28/technology/facebook-ftc-lawsui… -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
The lack of full licensure by @US_FDA for vaccines, despite having had 7 months to do plant inspections and review the BLA applications iteratively as they were submitted by sections, is holding us back in a major way. Yes, a BFD.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
. @GibMetcalf @AlexMasPton
"33 Nobel Laureates in Economics and 20 other prominent economists write in defense of Andreu Mas-Colell"
elpais.com/espana/2021-06-22/en-apoyo-a-andreu-mas-colell… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Trump banned? Not if he pays.
"...a joint venture between Trump’s Save America leadership PAC and his Make America Great Again PAC, has spent $3,506 on Facebook ads promoting Trump’s upcoming rally outside Cleveland, Ohio and calling for donations ... "
www.politico.com/news/2021/06/21/trump-fundraising-arm-ad… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Remember the lumber panic?
It was last month.
May 5: ‘Pure panic’: Lumber prices up a staggering 280% as builders scramble for supply
fortune.com/2021/05/05/lumber-prices-chart-2021-may-price…
June 15: Lumber Prices Are Falling Fast, Turning Hoarders Into Sellers
www.wsj.com/articles/lumber-prices-are-falling-fast-turni… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
This reply tells you everything you need to know about why I follow @nataliexdean
When most people encounter something puzzling, they just shrug and move on. "Nobody else seems to care, so why should I."
Natalie asks.
Natalie E. Dean, PhD
@nataliexdean
Heads up, why would this app need permission to follow, unfollow, mute snd block accounts for you? Permissions are overly broad so be sure it’s not a scam.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
My favorite title for an article:
"Statisticians are Fairly Robust Estimators of Location" (JASA 1977)
It's a reminder that:
- There are people behind every claim
- Some are more reliable than others
- In deciding *what* to trust, it pays to decide first *whom* to trust -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I do know and respect Alex's father Andreu Mas-Collel.
It shocks the conscience to hear of a penalty for actions not specified.
And one that far exceeds anything that could be justified to deter official misconduct.
It sounds not like justice, but politics by other means.
Gilbert Metcalf
@GibMetcalf
This strikes me as a situation where a letter headed by Nobel Laureate economists and signed by many economists could have an impact by drawing attention to Andreu’s situation. I would certainly sign on. @paulkrugman @paulmromer @Pmilgrom @R_Thaler @JeanTirole
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Looks like we already have the answer to the question that I posed here
https:adtax.paulromer.net
about whether Facebook would use its control over digital political ads to "influence public debate about an urgent policy question."
signal.org/blog/the-instagram-ads-you-will-never-see/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Two NYT pieces assess the future course of pandemic
www.nytimes.com/2021/05/28/opinion/herd-immunity-covid-us…
www.nytimes.com/2021/05/28/opinion/covid-vaccine-variants…
One is incoherent, preachy, incomplete, and reassuring without justification.
The other is coherent, clear, and suggests concern.
Guess which is by med/health professionals?Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
My point is not that we should be more or less pessimistic. It is that I have no idea what the authors meant when they wrote:
"More important, we may not need to achieve that goal [herd immunity] in order to escape the pandemic."
www.nytimes.com/2021/05/28/opinion/herd-immunity-covid-us… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
There is a 3rd NYT article about the problem posed by health care workers who are not vax'd.
It argues for persuading them to get vax'd without forcing them.
I do not agree, but it is a clear, coherent contribution to the policy debate.
www.nytimes.com/2021/05/28/opinion/vaccine-hesitancy-heal… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Politicians who thrive on the dark side love Facebook targeting
Misogyny -> men
Racism against Blacks -> Hispanics; and vice versa
Racism against Asians -> Blacks and Hispanics
Antisemitism to some, support for Bibi to others ...
We can stop this.
adtax.paulromer.net -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Why the time might be right for action against the ad-tech giants - bipartisan consensus about the size and **influence** of major corporations.
For one suggestion about a truly effective move to reduce this influence:
adtax.paulromer.net -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
With a progressive tax on digital advertising, this is what the average tax rate could look like as a function of 2021 estimate revenue.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
My conversation with Wharton Biz Daily on the threat to democracy and the state of the economy
x.com/WhartonBizDaily/status/1395710971033829377 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
How my perception of the tech industry and economics has evolved over the last couple of decades:
www.nytimes.com/2021/05/20/technology/tech-antitrust-paul… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
And now for something completely different ... protecting democracy:
adtax.paulromer.net -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
As I have argued from start of the pandemic, there are lots of ways to reduce both the cost of a test and the time from sample to result.
And as I've argued for my entire career, naysayers always underestimate the potential for speeding up the rate of technological change.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Forget 30 minutes. I like this 1 second covid test
avs.scitation.org/doi/10.1116/6.0001060
Cheap, disposable cartridge, saliva. Looks promising.
@UF @UFMSE @UFWertheim -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
New paper shows that "screen and isolate" works.
It is a strategy for suppressing the spread of the virus that is far less costly than lockdown because it restricts activity for a small fraction of the pop instead of restricting everyone.
science.sciencemag.org/content/372/6542/635
1/2
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Confirms J Peto's argument that the right response to a +ive test result is to isolate entire household.
Even with a few false +ives, far fewer people are restricted than under measures that apply to everyone. E.g. far more children can be in school.
royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rsos.200915 -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
The UK achieved containment of covid. But that's not enough. They are pursuing crushing it with free, rapid home tests, unlike the US
www.wsj.com/articles/as-covid-19-testing-moves-center-sta… @wsj_douglasj w/ @michaelmina_lab and @ggronvall -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
When the folks at Facebook say that letting customers make a choice is anti-competitive, I don't think what they mean by "anti-competitive" is the same as what I think it means.
From a funny and informative video for WSJ by @JoannaStern:
www.wsj.com/video/series/joanna-stern-personal-technology… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
One more sign about the problems the US health care system faces because of its reliance on an increasingly predatory private sector.
www.politico.com/news/2021/04/03/pharmacy-covid-vaccine-c… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you are skeptical about whether misogyny is part of what is causing the attack on the refreshingly honest communication strategy @RWalensky has adopted, see this use below of the "women are too emotional" trope.
Locksley Fletcher
@LocksleyFletchr
She allows her emotions to infect her communications (and decisions). That immediately makes many listeners skeptical. We need facts, not emotions.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I do not know her and have zero inside information, but it is obvious that she made a conscious decision to show some emotional transparency in her briefing on the impending surge, in the hope that she could connect with the skeptics and deniers:
www.cnn.com/videos/health/2021/03/29/cdc-walensky-warning…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Oh no! The pedantry police are pounding at my door.
I'm sorry, I'm sorry.
"Although there is evidence to suggest intentionality, scientists do not know if @RWalensky did or did not make a conscious decision to show some emotional transparency in her briefing." -
Paul Romer reposted
Na Sirf Musiqi 🧡
@nasirfmusiqi
Great study on reduction in household risk of HCW vaccination too! www.publichealthscotland.scot/news/2021/march/covid-19-va…
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
So what does the field evidence show?
1. Days 13-24 post first injection w Pfizer, risk of becoming infected falls by 50%.
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.01.27.21250612v1
1/6Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Sounds to me a lot like the question of whether I can say that I will not be hit by a meteor this afternoon.
I do say things like this when I am trying to communicate clear on urgent issues.
If you want the pedantry police to lock me up, give them a call.
5/6
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
What I find breathtaking is the assertion that Walensky is doing a worse job of communicating the steps the nation has to take.
Her statements have been far more honest almost everything her predecessor, Giroir, even Fauci have said.
But hey, she's not one of the guys.
6/6 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Image is a headline from web front page of the NYTimes. No news, just clickbait for anti-vaxers. Takes gullible to a story that is feeding a hazing ritual.
Compare w what @EricTopol, a real scientist, has to say about what the evidence actually shows:
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Not exactly. You can be vaccinated and carry the virus (carrier). But if the viral load is so low you can't transmit (not a transmitter) spread is blocked and we move onto the pandemic exit ramp.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More from @ericTopol here:
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
New @NatureMedicine: The concern about asymptomatic transmission addressed in nearly 5,000 people after 1st dose of mRNA vaccine (~2 -5 wks). Viral load markedly reduced (high Ct). Supports vaccine effect for blocking or strongly reducing chance of spread
www.nature.com/articles/s41591-021-01316-7 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Image is a headline from web front page of the NYTimes. No news, just clickbait for anti-vaxers. Takes gullible to a story that is feeding a hazing ritual.
Compare w what @EricTopol, a real scientist, has to say about what the evidence actually shows:
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Not exactly. You can be vaccinated and carry the virus (carrier). But if the viral load is so low you can't transmit (not a transmitter) spread is blocked and we move onto the pandemic exit ramp.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The attack on @RWalensky over a triviality adds to growing body of evidence of misogyny among scientific and media elites that's subtle but pervasive.
www.nytimes.com/2021/04/01/health/coronavirus-vaccine-wal…
1/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
And NYTimes quotes Redfield, who was pinned down at a news conference, saying, in effect, "reasonable people can differ."
But those stern academic scolds? ...
9/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"And come on Paul, why you gotta be harshing on Giroir and Redfield? They are pretty good guys."
Yep. **guys**
10/10
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Correction: "NYTimes quotes Fauci, who was ..."
-
Paul Romer reposted
Ezra Klein
@ezraklein
So this is a BFD. @US_FDA has (finally!) approved some cheap, rapid, at-home COVID tests, to be sold over the counter with no prescription.
And CDC announced a huge rapid testing pilot program.
Hope @michaelmina_lab is pouring the nice whiskey tonight.
www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/coronavirus-c… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you did not read the Jan 28 column by @ezraklein on the risk of a new surge, or if you read it and were skeptical, this would be a good time to read it or read it again.
The new surge has arrived.
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/28/opinion/new-covid-strain.html -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Summary of my take on Birx, Fauci, and quitting:
1. Wapo is obviously correct that Birx and Fauci were "complicit in a narrative to downplay the threat".
www.washingtonpost.com/health/2021/03/29/trump-officials-…
On Fauci, see also:
x.com/paulmromer/status/1372001886614740993
1/3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
A good look back at the 1 year mark, by @dwallacewells
nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/03/how-the-west-lost-covid-1…
Telling story about Fauci: He was reassuring the public that the virus was "low risk" after Trump had told Woodward that "This is deadly stuff. You just breathe the air and that's how it's passed."Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
3. But like @mattbai, I think that Birx made the wrong choice. It would have been better for the country had she quit sooner.
My point: It would have been far better for her to have quit earlier; same for all others in these horrible positions.
3/3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
4. All too often, people in these positions try to play fourth-quarter football in a desperate attempt at accomplishing something truly meaningful, something that will lead to recognition
They underestimate the satisfaction of integrity and the anguish of regret and shame
4/3 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Terrific bit of empathetic analysis by @mattbai.
I would add to it a complementary point that @SteveDLevitt has made for years: people are too slow to make a change.
Quitting sooner would have been better for the nation AND better for Birxs.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2021/03/30/deborah-birxs-… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"They were all complicit in a narrative to downplay the threat because they felt that’s what Trump wanted,” said former senior Trump administration official. “They manipulated their statements to please Trump..."
"www.washingtonpost.com/health/2021/03/29/trump-officials-… -
Paul Romer reposted
David Wallace-Wells
@dwallacewells
“A misplaced belief in U.S. exceptionalism by experts led to narrow-minded, rigid thinking that hindered the ability of U.S. public health leaders to respond effectively.” (1/2) foreignpolicy.com/2021/03/18/us-exceptionalism-covid-19-d…
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Finally.
"The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention issued expansive new recommendations on coronavirus testing Wednesday in an effort shift the role of testing from diagnostic tool to screening and prevention."
www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2021/03/17/coronavirus-covi…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Yes, but as @umairirfan makes clear in his article in Vox, we need to be clear about what the use case is for testing.
- We do not need more clinical diagnostic testing.
- We do need more tests devoted to disease surveillance and screening.
www.vox.com/22321794/covid-19-testing-test-vaccine-corona… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The epitaph for the amazing contribution made by @yayitsrob, @alexismadrigal and the team at the Covid Tracking project.
Required bc of the void left by a failure by the gov't that is simply beyond comprehension.
www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/03/americas-coro… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
A good look back at the 1 year mark, by @dwallacewells
nymag.com/intelligencer/2021/03/how-the-west-lost-covid-1…
Telling story about Fauci: He was reassuring the public that the virus was "low risk" after Trump had told Woodward that "This is deadly stuff. You just breathe the air and that's how it's passed."Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Yes, but as @umairirfan makes clear in his article in Vox, we need to be clear about what the use case is for testing.
- We do not need more clinical diagnostic testing.
- We do need more tests devoted to disease surveillance and screening.
www.vox.com/22321794/covid-19-testing-test-vaccine-corona… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Why the stimulus bill is not enough.
We have a very long way to go to get back to where the labor market was at the end of Clinton's term.
Notice, btw, the good performance after Clinton raised taxes and the weak / nonexistent effect of the Bush and Trump tax cuts. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"Why mass testing for Covid-19 still matters"
www.vox.com/22321794/covid-19-testing-test-vaccine-corona… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
On Thursday, @EzraKlein published an important column with discouraging news: the new variants of the corona virus will make it far more difficult to end the pandemic and return to life as we knew it in 2019.
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/28/opinion/new-covid-strain.html
1/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I do not want to raise undo alarm, and I'm having trouble coming up with realistic scenarios that do not involve hundreds of thousands of additional deaths in 2021.
4/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I can reinforce one of Ezra's points: it is extremely important that we speed up the pace of vaccinations to 3m shots per day. But as I explain below, even this will leave us in a very dangerous position this summer, one that will probably force us to do even more.
5/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If we can sustain the pace of 3m per day, it looks like testing everyone once every two weeks would leave us with an buffer that keeps us well away from 1.0. Testing at this frequency would reduce the effective R by roughly 20% (that is, by a factor of 0.8.)
16/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If we can only do 1.5m shots per day, we might need to test people more frequently -- once a week. This would reduce the effective R by a factor of 0.5, which should be enough to get us through the summer and fall without a new wave of infection and death.
17/17 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The update on B.1.1.7 from Denmark:
"Cases involving the variant are increasing 70 percent a week in Denmark, despite a strict lockdown, according to Denmark’s State Serum Institute, a government agency that tracks diseases and advises health policy."
www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/uk-variant-covid-denm… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The facts are now indisputable. B.1.1.7 is extremely dangerous.
So when Girior said that "We don't know that it's more dangerous” — either he was lying, was incapable of thinking straight, or both.
www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/uk-variant-covid-denm…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Giroir spouting nonsense.
If a software update made self-driving cars crash into 70% more pedestrians, no honest person would say that “this isn't more dangerous because the probability of death in each crash is unchanged."
1/N
www.politico.com/news/2020/12/20/covid-19-variant-mutatio… -
Paul Romer reposted
R. Scott Love
@TheScottLove
@YaleSPH @awyllie13 @robbysikka so why isn't saliva-based testing the predominate approach yet or is it? @michaelmina_lab @paulmromer @RickABright @ASlavitt
Prof. Akiko Iwasaki
@VirusesImmunity
URT virus is key to transmission, but LRT is key to severe #covid19. Saliva appears to be better at capturing the critical viral source driving severe disease.
This was once again an amazing collaboration with the Yale IMPACT team 🙏🏼 Led by @SilvaJ_C 💪🏼 (end) -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Meanwhile … because of a catastrophic policy failure, the pandemic continues to rage in the US, needlessly.
Transcript here of a discussion with Michael Mina and me on the test strategy that we should still be rolling out, even as we vaccinate.
www.heritage.org/sites/default/files/2021-01/HL1319.pdf
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Video available here:
www.heritage.org/public-health/event/virtual-event-rapid-… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Me in conversation with Steve Levitt.
People I (Mostly) Admire
@MostlyAdmiring
“It's the non-rivalry or shareability of discoveries that not only makes them a driver of growth, but also explains why there's so much benefit from connecting with other people.” — @paulmromer in conversation with @StevenDLevitt. Listen here: freak.ws/38s1gXf
-
Paul Romer reposted
Jake Sherman
@JakeSherman
A lot of anger on the Dem Caucus call that 75-year-old @RepBonnie got Covid after being in a room with maskless Republicans. BWC is a cancer survivor.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Justice Dept. Pursues at Least 150 Suspects in Capitol Riot
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/11/us/politics/capitol-riot-justi… -
Paul Romer reposted
John McCormack
@McCormackJohn
15 cops attacked at the Capitol were hospitalized. www.nytimes.com/2021/01/11/us/capitol-mob-violence-police…
-
Paul Romer reposted
The New York Times
@nytimes
Videos show pro-Trump rioters pulling three officers down a set of stairs during a violent attempt to breach the U.S. Capitol last Wednesday. Our Visual Investigations team looks at how the assault happened.
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/11/us/capitol-mob-violence-police… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Impeachment after leaving office by @MichaelGerhard8
"It should accordingly go without saying that if an impeachment begins when an individual is in office, the process may surely continue after they resign or otherwise depart."
www.justsecurity.org/74107/the-constitutions-option-for-i… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
It makes good sense to impeach and convict Trump after he is out of office.
This would open up a safe way to expose him to a wrongful death lawsuit WITHOUT creating a precendent that would let Giuliani file endless nuisance lawsuits against Pres Biden.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
.@jacklgoldsmith: A precendent we could live with?
1. Congress impeaches & convicts fmr. pres. for X.
2. Courts rule that this shows X was not an official act.
3. Fmr. pres. is then subject to lawsuits, maybe criminal prosecution, but only for X.
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/11/us/politics/trump-legal-jeopar… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Is Trump responsible?
“There’s no question the president formed the mob,” Representative Liz Cheney, Republican of Wyoming, told Fox News. “The president incited the mob. The president addressed the mob. He lit the flame.”
1/2
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/11/us/politics/trump-legal-jeopar…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Even former Attorney General Barr … has interpreted [Trump’s] conduct as “orchestrating a mob to pressure Congress,” calling Mr. Trump’s actions “inexcusable” and “a betrayal of his office and supporters.”
Pressure was illegal and caused a death. 2/2
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/11/us/politics/trump-legal-jeopar… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
.@jacklgoldsmith: A precendent we could live with?
1. Congress impeaches & convicts fmr. pres. for X.
2. Courts rule that this shows X was not an official act.
3. Fmr. pres. is then subject to lawsuits, maybe criminal prosecution, but only for X.
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/11/us/politics/trump-legal-jeopar…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
There is a reasonable chance that Trump would be personally liable if the estate of Officer Sicknick brings a civil suit for wrongful death.
All that is needed for this lawsuit to be heard is some basis for a court to conclude that the speech was not an official act. 2/3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
3/3
Melanie Zanona
@MZanona
NEWS: McCarthy tells Republicans on a call just now that Trump told him he does bear some responsibility for the Capitol riots, per source.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
.@charlie_savage notes the most incriminating part of Trump’s speech. Says he told Pence he’d need courage to face what would happen if Pence accepted Biden’s win. Same for R’s in Congress.
On cue, rioters show up at Capitol chanting “Hang Mike Pence!"
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/10/us/trump-speech-riot.html?sear… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
WHAT WE HAVE LOST
A colleague and I concluded that we need to have a plan for what we will do if terrorists are attacking the nation’s capital during the first lecture of our new course, which is scheduled to start at 2 pm on Weds. Jan 20. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I wish more R politicians understood @StevenDLevitt ’s point:
"I’m a firm believer there should be a lot more quitting.”
Looking back, were the petty jobs they clung to really worth the humiliation and moral degradation of submitting to a sociopath?
People I (Mostly) Admire
@MostlyAdmiring
For many economists there is no greater inspiration than @paulmromer, who redefined the discipline and maintained a passion for introducing new ideas to debates. @StevenDLevitt finds out what makes Romer a “quitter” and why you can’t manufacture big ideas. freak.ws/38s1gXf
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
By calling me a “serial quitter”, @StevenDLevitt conveys both
1. An important fact:
- There are always other paths.
2. And my guiding principle:
- If continuing on my current path would violate my beliefs about right and wrong, I switch paths.
People I (Mostly) Admire
@MostlyAdmiring
For many economists there is no greater inspiration than @paulmromer, who redefined the discipline and maintained a passion for introducing new ideas to debates. @StevenDLevitt finds out what makes Romer a “quitter” and why you can’t manufacture big ideas. freak.ws/38s1gXf
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Background on the hooligan carrying the podium.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Here’s the pic again
-
Paul Romer reposted
Ben Rhodes
@brhodes
Putin didn't want sanctions relief. He wanted this.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Political hooligans.
Ryan Lizza
@RyanLizza
Via Getty, one the rioters steals a podium from the Capitol
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you want to understand mob violence, you really should read Among the Thugs by Bill Buford.
For some people, there is nothing like the high of being part of a riot. (Retweeted to fix spelling of author’s name.) -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you want to understand mob violence, you really should read Among the Thugs by Bill Bufford.
For some people, there is nothing like the high of being part of a riot. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Press release by the FDA creates alarm on basis of no new information.
What is going on?
FDA is threatening Curative bc Congress is not using its tests in the excessively narrow way specified in FDA’s EUA: Test ONLY people who have symptoms. 1/N
www.fda.gov/medical-devices/safety-communications/risk-fa…Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Faced with a new strain of the virus that spreads more easily, the minimum safe program to protect the Congress is test
- EVERYONE who comes into the building
- at least TWICE a week.
5/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Given the cost to the nation of more infections and more deaths of elected officials, the cost-effective measure would be to test
- EVERYONE who comes into the Capitol
- EVERY DAY
6/6 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Trump’s reaction to the worst cyber security breach ever is still “Not my problem” + Bart Simpson defense:
“Russians didn’t do it.”
“Nobody saw the Russians do it.”
“There’s no way you can prove anything.”
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Seems clear that this is will be the worst security breach ever.
After 2 days, NYTimes is already saying biggest breach in "more than two decades.” And we are only beginning to understand the implications.
Meanwhile. Trump?
“Not my problem.”
www.nytimes.com/2020/12/17/us/politics/russia-cyber-hack-… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
And one final reason to put not just 2020 but all four of the miserable Trump years behind us:
Re worst security breach ever — Microsoft now says that Russian hackers were able to explore its source code repositories.
www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/microsoft-russia… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Recall @DrLenaWen on administration officials who followed a playbook “to confuse and obfuscate” re testing in US.
Recall how Giroir (@HHS_ASH) dismissed new variant by saying “we do not know that it’s more dangerous”.
More proof that no one should trust anything he says.
Aris Katzourakis
@ArisKatzourakis
Absolutely essential reading. This is the most definitive analysis yet showing substantive and significant increased transmission for the variant of concern.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Dr. Lena Wen
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From @DrLeanaWen
The vaccine rollout is giving me flashbacks to the administration’s testing debacle.
… Instead of admitting that there wasn’t enough testing, administration officials followed a playbook to confuse and obfuscate
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/12/29/covid-19-vacci…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Giroir on the new variant of concern
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Giroir spouting nonsense.
If a software update made self-driving cars crash into 70% more pedestrians, no honest person would say that “this isn't more dangerous because the probability of death in each crash is unchanged."
1/N
www.politico.com/news/2020/12/20/covid-19-variant-mutatio… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Better late than never.
“This pandemic is real and it’s taken too many of our loved ones,” Louisiana House Speaker Clay Schexnayder (R) said in a Facebook post on Wednesday.
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/congressman-luke-letlow-d… -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From @DrLeanaWen
The vaccine rollout is giving me flashbacks to the administration’s testing debacle.
… Instead of admitting that there wasn’t enough testing, administration officials followed a playbook to confuse and obfuscate
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/12/29/covid-19-vacci… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From @DrLeanaWen
The vaccine rollout is giving me flashbacks to the administration’s testing debacle.
… Instead of admitting that there wasn’t enough testing, administration officials followed a playbook to confuse and obfuscate
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/12/29/covid-19-vacci… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Re the new VOC — variant of concern — of the virus that is causing so much concern:
A useful update thread from a leader in the relevant discipline, epidemiology.
Bill Hanage @BillHanage.bsky.social
@BillHanage
Very interesting preprint on epidemiology of B.1.1.7 (or the 'Variant of concern' - VOC) in SE England. Have not fully digested but there are some important take homes 1/n cmmid.github.io/topics/covid19/reports/uk-novel-variant/2…
-
Paul Romer reposted
Aaron Ruby 💥
@aruby_
$10-$15 plus overhead per person is expensive for a pooled test.
Pooled SalivaDirect tests should be much cheaper.
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.09.02.20183830v1
x.com/NathanGrubaugh/status/1319974568593821696 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Reason to be cheerful!
The Biden team is putting together a plan for fighting the pandemic and for opening schools that makes good sense.
Such a welcome change.
www.politico.com/news/2020/12/23/biden-frequent-testing-r…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
As usual, just ignore the defensive nonsense from Giroir — @HHS_ASH — to the effect that we don’t need to make any changes because the current approach is working so well.
He seems not to have noticed that children are not actually in school.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The country owes a huge debt to @rajshah and the team at the Rockefeller Foundation for patiently doing the preparation and planning that will let the new adminstration implement this quickly.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Update from the Guardian on the new strain w the N501Y mutation:
"Scientists are very confident that the new variant is more transmissible than older ones.”
www.theguardian.com/world/2020/dec/23/what-do-we-know-abo… -
Paul Romer reposted
The Idle Archer
@archer_idle
“Knowing more is better than knowing less.” @paulmromer
www.govexec.com/technology/2020/11/did-trump-delay-arriva… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you are coming in late, the background on the new mutation in the UK is the presentation by Erik Volk at the COG-UK Showcase event on Dec. 16.
Starts at about 2:37. One of several presentations available here:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=G3CT9N89L-c -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
.@brucetempleton
You asked: What if the new mutation is 70% more infectious?
We should do what we should have done from the beginning — test and isolate.
1/3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
As @michaelmina_lab has been saying, now we have the rapid antigen tests so test-and-isolate can identify and isolate people while they are early in their infection.
The only things holding us back are obstinacy, hubris, and a failure of collective rationality.
2/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
At best, cutting off travel to/from UK buys a little time.
We need to assume that this mutation is already in every country, or will be soon.
And we need to do the math and accept the reality that a higher fraction of pop has to be vaccinated to halt spread of the virus
3/3 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you want to see how Eric Volz and co-authors analyzed a previous mutation (D614G) that increased the infectiousness by a factor that they estimate to have been about 1.3, see their published paper in Cell:
www.cell.com/cell/fulltext/S0092-8674(20)31537-3 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Giroir spouting nonsense.
If a software update made self-driving cars crash into 70% more pedestrians, no honest person would say that “this isn't more dangerous because the probability of death in each crash is unchanged."
1/N
www.politico.com/news/2020/12/20/covid-19-variant-mutatio…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
What he means when he says that "we do not know that it’s more dangerous” is that there is no indication that the new lineage causes more severe disease.
But there are clear indications that the lineage (right side) with the new mutation spreads much faster than its ancestors.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Yes, yes, there is every reason to expect that the existing vaccines will protect people from this lineage.
But you’d have to be an idiot to think that a 1.7 x increase in infectiousness is of no concern when we are many months away from having most people vaccinated.
3/3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
And yes, yes, the current estimate of 1.7 x increase could turn out to be 1.4 x or 1.1x.
But it is equally likely that it will turn out to be 2.0 x or 2.3 x.
So "wait and see" makes sense only if you think that being behind the curve has been working out great.
4/3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
You tell me. Is this a model or is it data?
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Other nations in Europe are cutting travel links with the UK. So who are you going to believe? Them, or the US gang that can’t shoot straight or give a straight answer?
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
At this link, the House topline summary of the new emergency relief bill.
We had to wait through 9 months of needless suffering and death; but finally, $54 b (out of $887 b) in new spending to limit the spread of the virus (see attached graphic.)
context-cdn.washingtonpost.com/notes/prod/default/documen….
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Broken link!
Twitter is mangling it by deleting a required period at the end.
- so manually add the period at the end of the link or
- search for “Emergency Relief Package Topline Summary” or
- find the link “Read the summary …” in this article:
www.washingtonpost.com/us-policy/2020/12/20/stimulus-cong… -
Paul Romer reposted
Ravi Rannan-Eliya
@ravirannaneliya
Failure to invest enough in testing is not just a 🇺🇸problem, it's global. We have COVAX for vaccines, but nothing comparable for testing. But we need both to control this through 2021, & surely both if we ever want to kill this virus.
@michaelmina_lab @IlonaKickbusch @paulmromer
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
UPDATE WSJ — there may be some funds for testing:
"And lawmakers agreed to increase the amount of money aimed at combating the virus, adding $30 billion for the procurement and distribution of a vaccine, as well as $22 billion for testing and tracing.”
www.wsj.com/articles/congress-races-to-approve-virus-reli… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
It will take many monthts to vaccinate 70-80% of pop.
And the "virus will probably be able to generate vaccine escape mutants.”
www.bbc.com/news/health-55388846
So it would be foolish beyond belief to slack off now and fail to invest more in our capacity to test.
C-A-G
@C_A_G0101
It's not the outbreak peaking up at 220k per day, but just the testing capacity which is getting overwhelmed (positivity rate is still rising) !!!
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More detail from separate article from Wapo:
- $20 billion for the purchase of vaccines
- $8 billion for vaccine distribution
- $20 billion to assist states with testing
www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/12/20/stimulus-packa… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
UPDATE WSJ — there may be some funds for testing:
"And lawmakers agreed to increase the amount of money aimed at combating the virus, adding $30 billion for the procurement and distribution of a vaccine, as well as $22 billion for testing and tracing.”
www.wsj.com/articles/congress-races-to-approve-virus-reli… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Wapo has same general info as Axios and NYTimes, but does say “$20 billion for vaccine distribution”
So no new funds for testing?
Is the Congress even going to ask the admin to finally spend the $9 b it allocated back in Apr that Trump never spent?
www.washingtonpost.com/us-policy/2020/12/20/stimulus-cong… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Apparently Axios also had trouble finding anyone who knew anything about spending on testing and vaccines.
www.axios.com/stimulus-checks-congress-deal-33e713ae-501e… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Apparently, NYTimes could not find anybody who knew about spending for testing, vaccines ...
But woohoo!
- $600 checks
- Extended ui benefits
- $284 b - PPP
- $15 b - performance venues
- $82 b - schools and universities
- $7 b - broadband
...
www.nytimes.com/2020/12/20/us/politics/congress-stimulus-… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
It is not a surprise that the President of the United States does not care about protecting the nation from attacks by Russia.
But it is not normal.
Dustin Volz
@dnvolz
Minutes before this tweet landed I heard Trump was telling aides he thinks the SolarWinds hack and Russia attribution is a hoax.
And then he just tweeted it out. -
Paul Romer reposted
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
But whatabout…
“We have the most sophisticated financial system that supports the best tech firms in the world, so we will use the market to protect us.”
From @mattoyeah:
"Little-known SolarWinds gets scrutiny over hack, stock sales"
www.washingtonpost.com/national/little-known-solarwinds-g…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Why would anybody buy when private equity firms like Silver Lake and Thomo Bravo are suddenly hot to sell?
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Seems clear that this is will be the worst security breach ever.
After 2 days, NYTimes is already saying biggest breach in "more than two decades.” And we are only beginning to understand the implications.
Meanwhile. Trump?
“Not my problem.”
www.nytimes.com/2020/12/17/us/politics/russia-cyber-hack-… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Worst cyber breach ever?
1. US gov’t agencies — Treasury, HHS, DoD, NSA — used software that started installing a backdoor 9 months ago. Little detail from them
2. Cyberdefense firm FireEye is public, so it had to disclose extent of its penetration
www.reuters.com/article/us-global-cyber/u-s-homeland-secu… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I’ve said it before, but it is worth repeating.
The best book to read to understand this type of behavior is Among the Thugs by Bill Buford.
www.washingtonpost.com/local/public-safety/proud-boys-pro… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
In US, those who have never had covid-19 have prob of infection of about 0.2% per day.
For previosly infected, the prob of reinfection is less than 0.000002% per day.
To stop the spread of the virus, the priority is to vaccinate first those who have not yet been infected. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Setbacks for Sanofi and AstraZenica + failure to buy more from Pfizer => US may exhaust its supply of approved vaccines in Q1 of 2021 at level of pop immunity that lets virus keep spreading during Q2.
So very important not to waste doses on people w neutralizing antibodies.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
The mRNA vaccines will be in short supply for months. ~60 million Americans have now been infected.
>3 million more per week
If we could rapidly and accurately test for #sarscov2 neutralizing antibodies, and defer these + folks, we could get to population immunity levels faster. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
How to get to the socially optimal take up of vaccinations, by
@jasonrileywsj
www.wsj.com/articles/the-best-herd-immunity-money-can-buy…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"But a 2015 study conducted by economists at Swarthmore College found that offering people a $30 reward was enough to increase vaccination rates by 12 percentage points."
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Of course, economists can come up with a model which shows that paying people to get vaccinated yields fewer vaccinations (or for that matter, pretty much anything they want to show.)
But the data from the Swathmore study otherwise:
www.swarthmore.edu/sites/default/files/assets/documents/u… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Link to the web version of today’s Morning Newsletter by @DLeonhardt which looks at the contribution testing could still play in the fight to contain the pandemic.
Quoting me: “There’s clear evidence that test-and-isolate works ...”
www.nytimes.com/2020/12/10/briefing/facebook-covid-deaths… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From The Morning Newsletter:
www.nytimes.com/newsletters/morning-briefing -
Paul Romer reposted
Carl Quintanilla
@carlquintanilla
A new UCLA/Harvard working paper finds that a broad, federally funded program to test asymptomatic Americans — every 4, 7, 14 or 30 days — would generate more than enough GDP growth to offset the cost.
(h/t @jeffbaileychgo @uclaanderson @nberpubs)
anderson-review.ucla.edu/covid-testing-payback/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
In Liverpool, gov’t in UK finally shows that it is willing to try a different strategy to fight the pandemic — one based on the type of expanded system of testing that many of us have called for.
www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/liverpool-mass-testin…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Hard to make any sense at all of complaints by critics, e.g. that this is an “unethical” use of public funds.
Their confidence — that they already know all the answers, know that this program will fail, know that gov’t will learn nothing by trying — seems hard to justify. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"One, to get closer, walked down the steps, but the crowd hissed and chanted—the first chant, a crude fuck-off-press chant—and I thought that the photographer would be set upon. The anger surprised me—spontaneous and unanimous.”
4/4 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Among the Thugs, p. 290
"This phase of the crowd—this happy, happy phase—lasted for about four minutes. During these minutes, everyone, myself included, felt the pleasure of belonging, not unlike the pleasure of being liked or loved.”
1/4
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"There was another pleasure at work as well, one derived from power, even though the power had not been exercised, even though it was only the potential of power: the power of a crowd that had taken over a city.”
2/4
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"The next stage—the first lawless stage—also happened quickly,
Six or seven photographers had clustered on the steps of a hotel, shooting as the crowd approached.”
3/4 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
A frightening, yet plausible, analysis of the dynamic that has engulfed the US:
"Mao’s Lesson for Trump’s America
Beware of leaders willing to set their own country on fire.”
1/2
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/11/mao-zedongs-les…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
To understand the side of human nature that a leader can exploit to set off a wave of destruction, the best book to read is Bill Buford’s first person account of mass violence by soccer hooligans:
Among The Thugs
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Among_the_Thugs -
Paul Romer reposted
Michael Mina
@michaelmina_lab
IMPORTANT point on Rapid #covid19 tests:
They're the ONLY solution available that people actually WANT!
Ppl do not WANT:
• Social Distancing
• Masks
• Lockdowns
But WISH they had rapid tests!
This difference should not be overlooked in planning!
time.com/5912705/covid-19-stop-spread-christmas/ -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
In the legend of the woman attacked repeatedly on the street, you know how it is the witness who does nothing that torments us?
For me, ADM Giroir will forever be the guy in the second story window, smoking a cigarette, watching her get stabbed to death.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
In an interview full of Barr-class evasion, Giroir slips and says something true:
“There are physical manufacturing impediments that can't be fixed overnight. A lot of them could be fixed over weeks.”
You’ve been working on this for what, 9 months?
www.npr.org/2020/11/19/936783698/man-in-charge-of-coronav… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Yep.
He never gets around to that $9 billion Congress allocated for testing back in April that he has been holding onto in, I don’t know, maybe the petty cash box? -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
In an interview full of Barr-class evasion, Giroir slips and says something true:
“There are physical manufacturing impediments that can't be fixed overnight. A lot of them could be fixed over weeks.”
You’ve been working on this for what, 9 months?
www.npr.org/2020/11/19/936783698/man-in-charge-of-coronav… -
Paul Romer reposted
Sahil Kapur
@sahilkapur
NEWS: Republican @SenToomey says @realDonaldTrump has “exhausted all plausible legal options” and tells him to “accept the outcome of the election and facilitate the presidential transition process.” He congratulates “President-elect Biden and Vice President-elect Kamala Harris.”
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
An amazing accomplishment!
The team at Yale has done more to get testing up to where it is now. And they did it by figuring out how to work with / work around the FDA.
Anne Wyllie
@awyllie13
40 labs in 21 states* 💦
It certainly hasn't been easy, but proud to be part of such an incredibly hard working team.
ocr.yale.edu/news/yale-team-leads-national-rollout-cost-f… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Courage and integrity survive, outside the beltway:
'Former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, … criticized Atlas over his recent tweet [calling for people to rise up], calling it “offensive and well beyond the boundaries of what is appropriate ....'
sanfrancisco.cbslocal.com/2020/11/20/dr-scott-atlas-stanf… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
My translation of the Fed's statement re termination of emergency lending programs:
“In an unconscionable display of naked hypocrisy, Sec. Mnuchin has deprived the incoming administration of tools that he deemed helpful and appropriate — until his team lost the election.” -
Paul Romer reposted
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Here's how you do it. Outbreak, no lockdown. Virus squashed.
A taxi driver, a nursing assistant. Traces to 2 loading dock workers getting a CT scan.
10.9 million tests at 4090 testing sites. 10 others infectees found, isolated.
Done.
New @NEJM www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2032361?query=featured… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Univ. of Illinois UC has about 57 thousand students and staff.
It looks like they are testing about 70 thousand people per week, hence testing everyone roughly once a week.
If we extend this to the US as a whole, this would mean testing about 50 million people per day.
1/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
(And boy, were people mad at me when I said test 20 million per day.)
At $10 per test, this would mean $500 million per day.
To sustain this for 3 months and get the rate of infection way down, this would cost about 90 * $500 million or $45 billion.
2/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If the infection rate comes down in the entire US as it did at UIUC, this $45 billion expenditure would save tens of thousands of lives.
And it would cost far less than the $1-2 trillion loss that a 4-6 week shutdown would impose.
3/3 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Maybe we should just subcontract-out the testing program for the entire US to UIUC.
But of course, it will have to wait until after Jan 20 when Trump is no longer able to kill every effort to use tests to stop the spread of the pandemic.
The Idle Archer
@archer_idle
"2% of all the tests that happen in the country today will be by the Univ of Illinois. 'Fast & frequent' is the unofficial motto for the university's testing strategy."
abcnews.go.com/US/inside-university-illinois-massive-covi…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you think that there is no evidence that a strategy of test and isolate can work, check out today’s numbers for the Univ. of Illinois Urbana-Champaign.
That is not a typo: 7-day positivity rate of 0.36%.
Compare with WY where it now exceeds 50%.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Yes, America, there is a state with a 62.9% test positivity, the 3rd highest new cases per capita in the world, and a rapidly rising death rate
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you think that there is no evidence that a strategy of test and isolate can work, check out today’s numbers for the Univ. of Illinois Urbana-Champaign.
That is not a typo: 7-day positivity rate of 0.36%.
Compare with WY where it now exceeds 50%.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Yes, America, there is a state with a 62.9% test positivity, the 3rd highest new cases per capita in the world, and a rapidly rising death rate
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
New article by @olgakhazan points to the fundamental divide on use of testing to contain the pandemic:
1) The “ignorance is bliss” camp, which includes M. Osterholm and the FDA
2) The many sensible people who understand that
knowledge > ignorance
www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/11/can-you-test… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From StatNews
Fauci said he raised the idea of mass testing early in the U.S. response, but that his message was not heeded.
“Deep down, perhaps I should’ve been much more vocal ... we really absolutely gotta do that,” Fauci said.
www.statnews.com/2020/11/17/fauci-more-vocal-covid-19-tes…
Ht @JadePinkSameera -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Trump will be out of power but the well is poisoned.
The public healthg militants happy to ride roughshod over the concerns of voters will get lots of attention from flashy fights with the crazy trumpkins.
There may be no oxygen left for reason and facts re test and isolate. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Prospects now? Bleak.
Co-head of Biden’s advisory panel had to do damage control on the Sunday news shows — “lockdow is a last resort”
As a response to another panel member who was being chicken little and calling for immediate lockdown.
1/N
Ken Chiu
@kjw_chiu
Any indications of how Biden will approach this? Is the public health community more receptive now?
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
This meant that Christmas came early for Fox News and Republicans. They have been trying for weeks to tag the Biden administration with “lockdown” without much success.
2/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
But over the weekend it was
"Biden advisor calls for 4-6 week lockdown”
with damage control that meant co-chair says
“only as a last resort.”
Fox News had all it needed to make the charge of “threat to freedom, theat to economy” stick.
www.foxnews.com/media/laura-ingraham-joe-biden-globalist-… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More on the limits on testing
@michaelmina_lab @davidaxelrod
There were many other hurdles that stood in the way of more testing.
The FDA was the most obvious.
See e.g. my blog post on this:
paulromer.net/fda_perpetual_process_machine/
1/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
There was also a bunch of nonsense about whether we could afford to do more tests.
See e.g. Michael’s paper with Jim Stock or my blog posts on this:
paulromer.net/if-tests-were-sodas/
paulromer.net/cost_of_tests/
2/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
There was oppostion to more testing by public health types that was stubborn to the point of being irrational in scholarly discussions and dishonest in public discourse.
See e.g. CIDRAP on “Smart Testing":
www.cidrap.umn.edu/sites/default/files/public/downloads/c…
3/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The Congress allocated $25 billion for testing back in Apr.
But because of Trump’s opposition, the federal gov’t never even spent the $9 billion that it was supposed to allocate to testing.
In the end, the opposition would have faded were it not for Trump.
6/6
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
PS: Armchair theorists should stop wasting time with idle speculation about a “Peltzman” effect e.g. compensation.
The effect can go either way: You get a negative but you hear about peers who test +
At U of WI, net effect of testing was to make students *more* careful -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Re this conversataion between @michaelmina_lab and @davidaxelrod
I spent the last 8 months working on this qn. The answer is simple.
Trump decided in February that it would be advantageous politically to keep the number confirmed cases to a minimum.
Michael Mina
@michaelmina_lab
.@davidaxelrod - want to give me a call/DM to discuss this.
This is the best option we have now to control the virus w/out total lockdowns. And we had it many months ago. Still no action - we need voices like you to help. Congress is stuck, FDA is stuck, everyone stalled.Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Go back and watch the TV interview in which he says that he wants to force US citizens to stay offshore in miserable conditions on the Princecess Grand so that their cases don’t count as cases in the US.
3/N
www.nbcnews.com/video/trump-prefers-coronavirus-quarantin…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
In the documentary “Out of Control” K. Sebelius, former HHS Secty, says that that interview of Trump, back in March was when she realized that Trump was committed to a strategy of suppressing information about the virus, at the expense of our ability to limit its spread.
4/4 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I am a big believer in talking to people from other disciplines. To illustrate, I’ll tell a story about a brief coinversation with @CT_Bergstrom that was literally one of the of high points of my entire career.
1/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
To me, there is something deeply satisfying about being able to capture an insight into the unity of nature. Of course, this is closely related to the “unreasonable effectiveness of math” and the power of abstractions that strip away the context and reveal the commonalities
6/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Someday I will have to try to publish the paper I was working on then. For complicated reasons, I haven’t done so yet. Norms are a sensitive topic. Sometimes, it’s best to wait for the right time.
But I will forever be grateful to Carl for insight he gave me.
7/7 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I’ve learned a huge amount from my conversations with Carl (who I knew from before this year.) And I’ve gotten to know many other people via twitter. I learned a lot from @mlipsitch just by reading one of his papers.
Sometimes we disagree. The goal is to learn, not to make nice. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The urgent demands for a mandatory government lockdown show experts at their worst - clueless yet condescending.
The wise, humane advice from @zeynep is the best antidote:
For the sake of the people you love, it is time to hunkerdown - voluntarily.
www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/11/lock-yourself-… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
As someone reminds me, today is the due date for the bet with @paulsolman that I made on @NewsHour back on May 14:
- that in 6 months, the US would be testing 20 million people per day for SARS-CoV-2.
No doubt about it - I lost.
1/N
cgs203
@cgs203
On 5/14/20, @paulmromer bet @paulsolman we'd be at 20M coronavirus tests/day by now. See coronavirus.jhu.edu/testing/individual-states. Looks like @paulsolman wins but we all lose. @NewsHour #covid19
Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I was right that if we did not scale up testing to at least this level, we’d end upw with some horrible combination of a delayed recovery and far too many unnecessary deaths. And far too many other harms, including long covid.
3/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The critics who turned out to be right said that at the rate 20 mpd (million per day) test and isolate alone would not be enough to allow full return to normal activity with R below 1.
But 20 mpd would have saved many lives and many livelihoods. And we could wear masks too
4/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
My mistake: underestimating Trump’s skill as a liar.
He persuades by doggedly repeating his lies and manipulating numbers to justify them.
Trying to slow testing and lower the confirmed case count might have been his best shot at a 2nd term.
He did get 73 million votes
6/6
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
PS: Just made my dontation to American Exchange Project, which is not just Paul Solman’s favorite charity, but one he helped found.
$500 + cc processing fee
donorbox.org/american-exchange-project -
Paul Romer reposted
Joshua Gans
@joshgans
.@paulmromer bet on the wrong country. He should have bet on Slovakia.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"Brett Giroir, assistant secretary at Health and Human Services, oversaw distribution of Covid-19 testing equipment to nursing homes, much of which is going unused.”
It is not credible that so many tests were wasted merely because Giroir was incompetent.
www.wsj.com/articles/many-nursing-homes-shun-free-covid-1… -
Paul Romer reposted
Andrew Ross Sorkin
@andrewrsorkin
There’s been a lot of emotions and analysis about Biden’s projected win this morning. But of everything I’ve watched, this struck me as the most raw and honest moment...
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you are a CA voter and have not already voted, you still have a chance to support the limits that Prop 24 places on the firms responsible for surveillance capitalism.
CPRA Resource Center
@YesOn24
Vote YES for #privacy, vote YES for #prop24! www.caprivacy.org/consumer-and-privacy-advocates-support-…
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Many people have resisted the forces of darkness, despite the long odds, bc the stakes were so high.
@erictopol ’s success validates these individual efforts. Many assumed the FDA was helpless but Eric got it back on the job.
An enormous win.
www.vanityfair.com/news/2020/10/trumps-vaccine-rush-vs-th… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If the people who ran the NBA can understand a simple cost-benefit calculation, why do so many others seem not to?
My quote below in @bzcohen ’s strory in the WSJ:
www.wsj.com/articles/covid-sports-season-lessons-pandemic… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Lessons @bzcohen draws from successful reopening by sports teams:
"Testing is crucial. Professional leagues were unanimous in deciding that more testing was better"
"Air is more dangerous than surfaces”
Assume that some people will "break rules”
www.wsj.com/articles/covid-sports-season-lessons-pandemic… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The GDP report is encouraging but the labor market still shows signs of deep distress.
New claims for unemployment (under the traditional insurance program) continue at levels that are higher than at any point during the financial crisis.
Today - 750k
Peak in 2009 - 660k -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
People who want schools to open have good intentions, but this does not give them license to mischaracterize the evidence.
Children do contribute to the spread of SARS-CoV-2
Saying they don’t is just as bad as saying that masks do not work
We need open schools w frequent tests
Dr Zoë Hyde
@DrZoeHyde
My paper on #covid19, children, and schools is now published, with new material added.
"We can no longer afford to overlook the role children play in transmission if we hope to contain the virus."
Precautions must be put in place in schools. #auspol
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.5694/mja2.50823 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Worth the read. Scroll down to find Haseltine:
"My recommendation is make (tests) universally available to every household, and if somebody in the household is positive … [make isolation possible] by paying them to stay home -- the whole family -- for 14 days.”
William Haseltine
@WmHaseltine
Why don't we all have Covid-19 tests in our medicine cabinets yet? From the President on down, most of the official leadership has been deeply misguided. They have focused first on treatment and not on prevention.
www.cnn.com/2020/10/21/health/covid-19-treatment-progress… -
Paul Romer reposted
Michael Mina
@michaelmina_lab
#salivadirect on the other hand (as one example) has made a strong concerted (and so far successful) effort to drop prices and raise awareness that these exorbitant prices need not exist
Not surprising - they are not-for-profit and doing what’s right
@awyllie13 @NathanGrubaugh -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Facebook is threatening to sue @LauraEdelson2 for checking the accuracy of FB's voluntary reports on political ads.
Maybe Laura should use the response @ProjectLincoln is drafting to the letter threatening a law suit on behalf of Jared and Ivanka.
George Conway ⚖️🇺🇸
@gtconway3d
draft legal response letter
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"As Covid-19 Sweeps Europe, One Country Tries to Test the Entire Population”
Also at:
www.wsj.com/articles/as-covid-sweeps-europe-one-country-t…
JonFSchwartz
@JonFSchwartz
This is excellent. Every school should do this. And here’s an example of an entire country that plans to test everyone: apple.news/AXp2WKdxMSgy-JDSxGOPO0w
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Re the misinformation about how high schools are not involved in the spread of the virus, the facts say “No."
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Graphs from today with data showing how successful the U of Illinois testing program has been.
If U of I can do this, why can’t we extend to every high school in the US?
Live dashboard here:
go.illinois.edu/COVIDTestingData -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"Because testing-related challenges pose a serious threat to the viability of school reopening plans, we believe that increasing routine screening using rapid tests in schools ... most urgent national priorities.”
From:
@MichelleM_Mello
@YasminRafiei
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMp2028209 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Evidence in favor of immunity post infection to be sure.
But also damning evidence against make-believe models where herd immunity is reached at 20%, 25%, …
attack rate of 85% => 104/122 people on board tested positive
www.nytimes.com/2020/10/20/magazine/covid-natural-experim…
jcm.asm.org/content/58/11/e02107-20 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
To understand how Trump single-handedly paralyzed such agencies as the CDC and the FDA — agencies that had been able to do their job under Obama — read @mashagessen on:
The Coronavirus and the Kursk Submarine Disaster
www.newyorker.com/news/our-columnists/the-coronavirus-and… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Follow up homework assignment re: Totally Under Control documentary:
a) When did the CDC ship its test with the superfluous, contaminated N3 assay?
1/3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
b) When did the FDA say that it was legal for a laboratory to use the working assays from its test — the N1 and N2 assays which were sufficient for identifying SAR-CoV-2 — and just ignore the nonspecific N3 assay?
2/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
c) How long do you think it would have taken an official in S. Korea to respond to a crisis of this magnitude?
3/3 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Reporters I quote in my thread on Totally Under Control:
Caroline Chen
@CarolineYLChen
Victoria Kim
@vicjkim
Michael D. Shear
@shearm
Michael caught covid bacause of Trump’s WH outbreak. I hope he is OK.
One cannot overstate how much we owe them and their peers. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From Totally Under Control:
Caroline Chen
Healthcare Reporter
ProPublica
"Because South Korea had already started ramping up diagnostic test production, they were able to seek out every member of this church in Daegu and get them tested."
Feb 2020
1/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Narrator:
"On Jan 27, South Korean health officials summoned representatives from from twenty medical companies to put in place a national testing program. "
8/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
There is one person, a single deeply flawed man, who has singlehandedly stopped the US from mounting the kind of effective response to the virus that we saw in South Korea.
13/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
His response to the pandemic is exactly what you would predict from someone whose core business competence was accounting fraud, excess leverage, and default.
"Manipulate the numers."
14/14 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Totally Under Control
Watch this documentary:
- if you care about the pandemic;
- If you care about the future of this country;
- if you can bear to be reminded of the immense tragedy caused by one deeply flawed man.
Viewing options follow
1/5Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Totally Under Control
Apple:
trailers.apple.com/trailers/independent/totally-under-con…
4/5
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Totally Under Control
Amazon:
www.amazon.com/Totally-Under-Control-Alex-Gibney/dp/B08L5…
5/5 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
A clear explanation by @mlipsitch & @nataliexdean of the detailed information about the effects of a vaccine that we won’t get unless gov’t provides sufficient funding.
For any candidate vaccine, this info could mean the difference betwee a tiny vs a huge public health benefit
Science Magazine
@ScienceMagazine
Having reliable evidence on direct & indirect protection #covid19 candidate vaccines provide can help plan how to use approved vaccines in a coordinated way, write @mlipsitch & @nataliexdean in this #scimagperspective. science.sciencemag.org/cgi/doi/10.1126/science.abe5938
-
Paul Romer reposted
Anne Watkins Stahlfeld
@AnneStahlfeld
Spending the majority of the past few months testing nearly 3800 @NBA saliva samples with @XtinaHarden was well worth it to support SalivaDirect and the impact it could have on public health. Check out our updated preprint and a useful thread here 🏀
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Mass Testing: China Doubles Down on Its Covid-19 Control Plan
"Mass testing has become a major part of how the Chinese government plans to eradicate coronavirus and keep the economy on track."
www.wsj.com/video/mass-testing-china-doubles-down-on-its-… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"Singapore is preparing to launch a rapid coronavirus antigen testing plan for people seeking to attend large-scale gatherings such as weddings, sporting events … conferences,"
"Only people who produce a negative result will be allowed to attend"
www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2020/10/20/coronavirus-covi… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The unspent $9 billion was allocated back in April — 6 months ago:
"Birx and Fauci … have urged the government to use unspent money Congress allocated for testing — which amounts to $9 billion, according to a Democratic Senate appropriations aide …”
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/trumps-den-of-dissent-ins… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Contact Tracing in US @laeeth
There is an excellent article by @britsham and @bylenasun on how the Sturgis motorcycle rally is spreading Covid-19 in the mid-western US.
Contact tracing was not the main focus, but it show why it is so much harder here.
www.washingtonpost.com/health/2020/10/17/sturgis-rally-sp… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More on why the FT presentation of the data undermines the position I have taken — and why I still hold that position.
1. The successes from the FT presentation (China, S. Korea) clearly relied on a combination of testing and contact tracing to control the pandemic.
1/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
7. Evidence that experts persuasion is failing:
- Backlash against economic experts in the Brexit vote.
- Growth of the anti-vax movement despite unified expert exhortation re value of vaccines.
- In this pandemic, masks as political statement.
7/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
8. Reasonable people can disagree about why experts lost their legitimacy and how we might recover.
But in the next 6 - 12 months, there is no reason to expect a dramatic change.
To save lives and livelihoods, It is a fact that the we experts must work around.
8/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I hope we have a new administration that succeeds.
I am terrified that frustrated experts will send it on a kamikaze mission that gives expert exhortation the force of law.
Claim 4: This use of the law will not restore expert legitimacy and might destroy our democracy
15/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Claim 5: Experts are not entitled to legitimacy. We always had to earn it. Now, we have to earn it back.
16/16 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I want to be clear that the reason why I am impressed with the FT presentation of the data is *not* because it supports all of the positions I have taken.
It presents data that supports testing, which I have supported.
But … 1/2
ig.ft.com/coronavirus-global-data/
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
But …
the FT does not cite tests for all 10 m people in Wuhan, Qingdao; says contact tracing was most important in China’s success.
My larger point: contact tracing will not work in the US.
My point here: I trust the FT for an unbiased summary of the facts.
2/2 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The FT has done an amazing job of collecting, distilling, and presenting data about the pandemic.
As far as I can tell, this presentation is unbiased and comprehensive. There is no cherry picking.
And no paywall!
Journalism at its very best, in service of the greater good.
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
NEW: today we've published the culmination of a weeks-long @ftdata team effort, summarising everything data has shown us about the virus over the year so far, from Wuhan to the autumn resurgence ig.ft.com/coronavirus-global-data/
Free to read, with a wealth of #dataviz on the key trends. -
Paul Romer reposted
Natalie E. Dean, PhD
@nataliexdean
“When you start seeking out and testing asymptomatic people, you are destroying the workforce.” A very problematic sentence. The goal of asymptomatic testing is to protect others in the workforce from getting infected.
Stephanie M. Lee
@stephaniemlee
this article doesn't spell it out, but Atlas's insistence on only testing the "vulnerable" is key to the Great Barrington Declaration. www.nytimes.com/2020/10/16/business/white-house-coronavir…
see this op-ed by two of its authors, "The Case Against COVID Tests for the Young and Healthy": www.wsj.com/amp/articles/the-case-against-covid-tests-for… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More from @jimtankersley, @noahweiland and @escochrane, reporting in the NYTimes about my interaction with Scott Atlas.
My email here:
paulromer.net/email_to_atlas/
www.nytimes.com/2020/10/16/business/white-house-coronavir… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
How one uinversity-affiliated lab provided the tests that kept students safe throughout the Northeast.
With a little more funding from US Gov’t labs like Broad could be keep school children and teachers safe too.
www.wsj.com/articles/how-a-pioneering-covid-testing-lab-h… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
On 9/21, at the request of an intermediary, I made a last ditch attempt to explain the value of testing to WH advisor Scott Atlas.
Predictably, it had no effect. He was already dead set on chasing herd immunity
Email:
paulromer.net/email_to_atlas/
NYTimes:
www.nytimes.com/live/2020/10/16/world/covid-coronavirus -
Paul Romer reposted
luluandmika
@siruiiiz
People in Qingdao are working and hanging out as usual. The government set up testing sites almost block by block. Each time ten samples are collected in one device and if test positive they are called back to test a second time. Those leaving for other cities are quarantined tho
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
To @CT_Bergstrom, @mlipsitch and others whom I respect:
- I agree that the GB plan for surrender appeals to a WH that would like a justification for having done nothing.
I agree that adopting the GB plan would be a horrible mistake.
But …
1/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
They need to ask, “what might actually work?”
And they need to be honest about what they are suggesting. And explain it clearly.
10/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I’ve read over and over that “opening up slowly” is part of their plan, but given what I know about the dynamics of the spread of this or any virus, I have no idea what “slowly” means or why it might matter.
11/NPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If test and isolate can protect professors at Harvard, why can’t it protect public school teachers?
If it can protect basketball players, why can’t it protect meatpackers?
14/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If the government in China can afford to test every resident in a city, why can’t the government here do the in the US?
15/N -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
But what is the right response to the vaccuum created by no strategy?
Articulate a clear strategy > lazy plan for surrender.
Repeating a curve metaphor and suggesting that “you can just leave things to us experts” — this is not the same as articulating a clear strategy
Jay B. Varkey
@jaybvarkey
1. The “Great Barrington Declaration” is an important reminder that”Herd Immunity” is NOT a strategy—it is the natural result of a LACK of a strategy and associated with unacceptable morbidity and mortality. @IDSAInfo & @HIVMA speak for me www.idsociety.org/news--publications-new/articles/2020/he…
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Pay attention to #2 from Dr. Hollander
Such experts as @mlipsitch @RWalensky @CarlosdelRio7 @gregggonsalves are trying to do the right thing, but have totally failed to answer questions like the one this MD asks
Do exactly what? For how long?
A curve metaphor is not an answer
Buzz Hollander MD
@buzzhollandermd
My general policy is to "agree w/ what Lipsitch says;"
but 2 counter-points valid here:
1) unfair to assume past failures to protect nursing homes project forward - daily rapid testing might do this.
2) pls tell us the better alternative that could *realistically* happen in US. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Doesn’t sound like China is going to sign up for the “Great Barrington” plan for surrendering to the virus.
Wouldn’t it be refreshing to live in a country where everybody understands that it is the government’s job to do whatever it takes to protect public health?
The Associated Press
@AP
ASIA TODAY: Chinese health authorities will test all 9 million people in the eastern city of Qingdao for the coronavirus this week after nine cases linked to a hospital were found, the government announces. apne.ws/3a6cFhe
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
And now for something completely different …
Opaque proprietary security hardware makes computers less secure.
Again.
Sigh.
"Apple's T2 custom secure boot chip is not only insecure, it cannot be fixed without replacing the silicon”
www.theregister.com/2020/10/08/apple_t2_security_chip/
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From theReg:
"Compromising the T2 doesn't dissolve macOS FileVault2 disk encryption but it would allow someone to install a keylogger to obtain the encryption key or to attempt to crack the key using a brute-force attack.” -
Paul Romer reposted
JonFSchwartz
@JonFSchwartz
At this point I don’t think there is any doubt that Trump understands. He is executing a conscious strategy which he thinks will maximize his chances of electoral victory. It may be a fatally flawed strategy, but it’s deliberate.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Like he said …
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Hammill is being too polite. WH understands.
Trump washonest when he said he does not want more tests bc:
more testing =>
more confirmed cases.
Trump based his career on manipulating the numbers to mislead.
Dishonesty is the core competency of this administration.
Drew Hammill
@Drew_Hammill
One major area of disagreement continues to be that the White House lacks an understanding of the need for a national strategic testing plan. The Speaker believes we must reopen our economy & schools safely & soon, & scientists agree we must have a strategic testing plan. (2/3)
-
Paul Romer reposted
Ron Davison
@iamrondavison
One quick stat.
Last 3 years of Obama's admin, avg monthly job creation at 225k.
First (best) 3 years of Trump's admin, avg monthly job creation at 185k. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
.@jcollingridgeST asked me if there was any truth to the claim that “Trump’s economy was the greatest ever”?
I said, “No."
Behind paywall, so I’ve attached the calclulations I did for him on GDP growth during recent business cycle expansions.
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/has-donald-trumps-handling-of-… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Yes, you are right. I missed that one.
And the video of Bob and his wife at Paul’s door really is worth a look. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Very cool that Bob Wilson got the prize along with one of his students — a first AFAIK.
Bob’s track record in mentoring prize winning PhD students at the Stanford Business School is unprecented.
- Al Roth
- Bengt Holmstrom
- and today, Paul Milgrom. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
David has a paper w cost-benefit analysis that I need to read.
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3627273
He reports the same difficulty in getting people to think in terms of costs and benefits that I encountered.
BTW, in 1st sentence, I’m pretty sure that what he means by “it” is lockdown.
David Manheim
@davidmanheim
We showed that it was both unnecessary, and expensive, but we've had as little success as you have at convincing people that massively scaling up testing and tracing is far less expensive than allowing resurgence.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
2. Academics, especially the epi-modelers, need to own their share of the responsibility for this failure
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Recycling my harsh, but in retrospect, accurate alarm about the harm that the epi-modelers were doing by taking seriously a policy of cycling lockdown on and off.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Scientists are observationally equivalent to madmen and fools when they dismiss cycles of tests that deliver benefits that are orders of magnitude larger than what they cost;
and endorse instead cycles of lockdown that look like this: -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
To recap my many tweets from today:
1. The public policy response to the pandemic has been a massive tragic failure 1/2
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
What went wrong:
"But rather than replacing harsh lockdown measures with a functioning testing and tracing strategy, switching from quarantining the population to only quarantining those who had been exposed to the virus, the UK lifted restrictions …”
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/oct/10/continual-l… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
What matters at high levels of prevalence like the ones we now face is to
- test, and
- isolate.
Tracing is optional; nice to have but not essential. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
But to be fair, there were economists (@neelkashkari) who aligned themselves the public health types who relentlessly opposed more testing (@mtosterholm) and pushed lockdown as the only feasible policy response.
See e.g.
www.nytimes.com/2020/08/07/opinion/coronavirus-lockdown-u… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Here is the paper from Imperial College from Mar 2020 that does the same type of analysis. My other figure was from Science Mag but based on the original figure from the paper, attatached here. 1/N
www.imperial.ac.uk/media/imperial-college/medicine/mrc-gi…Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Bottom of page 14:
"A minimum policy for effective suppression is therefore population-wide social distancing combined with home isolation of cases and school and university closure.”
4/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Then in the next sentence (in a new paragraph):
"To avoid a rebound in transmission, these policies will need to be maintained until large stocks of
vaccine are available to immunise the population – which could be 18 months or more.”
5/N=5 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Recycling my harsh, but in retrospect, accurate alarm about the harm that the epi-modelers were doing by taking seriously a policy of cycling lockdown on and off.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Scientists are observationally equivalent to madmen and fools when they dismiss cycles of tests that deliver benefits that are orders of magnitude larger than what they cost;
and endorse instead cycles of lockdown that look like this:Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Maybe those who jumped on @NoahRFeldman owe him an apology.
He was right. There was a serious disagreement between the epi modelers and at leasst this economist.
Moreover, looking back, it seems clear that they deserved to be criticized.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Maybe I missed it. Were there other members of the epi modeling community back then who spoke up and said how absurd this type of analysis really was?
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
And from April, my reaction to a paper from the team at Imperial College.
Please take a look at the the entire thread.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
So here is the question for the epidemiologists and public health officials:
If you had $100 billion to spend right now, can you suggest a way to save the same number of lives that does not involve recurring flareups and lockdowns: -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Very clear analysis by @devisridhar
Applies equally well to the US.
This was easy to anticipate, at least as far back as Mar 2020. See e.g.
www.nytimes.com/2020/03/23/opinion/coronavirus-depression…
And the epi modelers are partly to blame. Remember those papers on cycling lockdown on and off? -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"For the government, the purpose of lockdown seemed to be simply that: lock the country down and hope the problem would go away. But lockdown itself doesn’t fundamentally change the virus or its trajectory. It just buys us time.“
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/oct/10/continual-l… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
What went wrong:
"But rather than replacing harsh lockdown measures with a functioning testing and tracing strategy, switching from quarantining the population to only quarantining those who had been exposed to the virus, the UK lifted restrictions …”
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/oct/10/continual-l… -
Paul Romer reposted
Joel Cawley
@jcawley01
In the past two yrs, I’ve had two separate people, both of whom are quite intelligent, assert that the root cause of US problems is the enlightenment. Both rely heavily on FoxNews. That *is* what this election represents.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you are still resisting:
- Knowing more > Knowing less,
Maybe this will help:
- Knowledge > Ignorance
1/2
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The battle for the future of the greatest achievements in human history — the enlightenment and the scientific revolution — now pits those with the courage to keep pursuing knowledge against and those who want to retreat and cower in ignorance.
It’s time to take sides. 2/2 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
When the communiction channel is noisy, the most reliable way to convey an idea is to keep sending reinforcing variations until it gets through.
The implication of Tim’s two final points has not yet gotten through:
Knowing more > Knowing less
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Corrolary 1: If you believe (as I do) in the social value of policies that encourage everyone to wear a mask,
Knowing more > Knowing less
Corralary 2: If you do not believe in the social value of such policies,
Knowing more > Knowing less -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
This week's cover of Bloomberg Business Week:
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"The country is flying blind into what could be the darkest winter in modern history."
We can pay attention now to the inadequacies of our national testing strategy that @RickABright identifies or doomscroll later when it is too late to do anything.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/rick-bright-trump-coronav… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
“...the White House has seemed determined to slow down testing and not test people who might have asymptomatic infections.”
A diagnosis of the fundamental failure of this adminstration, by @RickABright, who saw the problem from the inside.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/rick-bright-trump-coronav… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Jay Bhattacharya and Martin Kulldorff apparently used the stupid arguments in their Sept 3 WSJ oped to fish for suckers.
Looks like they caught some.
#greatbarringtondeclaration
www.wsj.com/articles/the-case-against-covid-tests-for-the… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Key virus spreading events in the last 10 days:
1. Rose Garden Scotus
2. Debate prep
3. Gold Star
Next?
Peter Walker
@PeterJ_Walker
Gold Star event highlighted...there are so many more people in that room, but the beginning of the tracking looks worrisome.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Reminder of long delay between exposure and positive test--especially for less sensitive antigen tests
If WH had been using Saliva Direct test from @awyllie13 team at Yale, it might have
- caught infections sooner
- limited the extent of the outbreak
asm.org/Articles/2020/August/What-is-the-COVID-19-SalivaD…
Hallie Jackson
@HallieJackson
NEW: Stephen Miller has tested positive for COVID, per senior administration official. Adds Miller has been working remotely for last 5 days, testing negative every day through yesterday, and is in quarantine after a positive test today.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Why I gave up on the prospect of Congressional action to encourage testing.
The WH will not let it happen. It will continue to refuse to spend on an effective testing program.
There is support for testing among R senators, but Trump has paralyzed them. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Not often that I get to retweet something about a song by the Grateful Dead.
Lyrics by the incomparable Robert Hunter.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"Went to see the captain, strangest I could find
Laid my proposition down, laid it on the line
I won't slave for beggar's pay, likewise gold and jewels
But I would slave to learn the way to sink your ship of fools" -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
‘Doomed to fail’: Why a $4
trillion bailout couldn’t revive
the American economy
By @PeterWhoriskey and colleagues at Wapo.
Provides the foundation for the discussion we urgently need about how to recover.
This crisis is not over. Not even close.
www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/business/coronavirus… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
World’s wrongest man sets new record; demonstrably wrong in just under 3 hours.
Oct 2, 3:31 pm
nymag.com/intelligencer/2020/10/larry-kudlow-trump-corona…
Oct 2, 6:30 pm
Trump is taken to Walter Reed -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
DeSantis decides to increase the current death rate in FL from a level that will cause 39,000 FL deaths per year.
Been here before. FL opened up in summer. What happened?
Compare w MD, a state w an R governor who is not ready and willing to kill.
www.politico.com/states/florida/whiteboard/2020/09/25/des…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
To get 39,000 deaths per year at current daily rate of ~ 5 per million, multiply:
5 deaths per day per million people
x
365 days per year
x
21.5 million residents of FL -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
This is what I had in mind when I wrote about the big, quick supply response that we could harness by putting existing lab infrastructure to work doing centralized testing. There is more where this came from.
Congrats to @awyllie13 and @NathanGrubaugh
Yale Ventures
@Yale_Ventures
@Yale's pleased to announce the 1st labs designated to provide theSalivaDirect™ COVID-19 test. Special thanks to our partners throughout this process: @nba @AccessMED @Hennepin @Mirimus Major congrats to @NathanGrubaugh @awyllie13
news.yale.edu/2020/09/24/yale-designates-labs-three-state…
#innovation #biotech -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Oped against testing by J. Bhattacharya and M. Kulldorff shows either that
a) they are stupid;
b) they think that readers of the WSJ editorial page are stupid;
c) or both.
Their argument against testing: There exists an unreasonable answer to an irrelevant question. Really? -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you want to connect with someone who is opposed to wearing a mask
@LisaRosenbaum17 has some wise and kind suggestions.
But does this scale? Can this approach influence the outcome of an election on which the fate of the nation depends … ?
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMms2027985 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Re the talented Mr. Atlas.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Much needed clarity from the Editor in Chief of Science Magazine:
“But now, a U.S. president has deliberately lied about science in a way that was imminently dangerous to human health and directly led to widespread deaths of Americans."
science.sciencemag.org/content/369/6510/1409?rss=1
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More from Holden Throp, Editor in Chief of Science Magazine:
Trumps lies were just the beginning:
"It also meant silencing health officials who tried to tell the truth.” Nancy Messonnier (NCIRD) "was right and Trump knew it. But he shut her down.”
science.sciencemag.org/content/369/6510/1409?rss=1 -
Paul Romer reposted
andrew dallos
@adallos
13 Nobel Prize-winning economists back Biden www.axios.com/joe-biden-nobel-prize-economists-endorsemen…
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
In an email thread with John Cochrane, I tried to summarize briefly what I think we know about testing as a response to the pandemic. He asked if he could post it. Link below.
I did not cite the literature so apologies to all who contributed to this understanding.
Social Finance, David Hirshleifer
@4misceldah
Lucid email by @paulmromer on testing and isolating
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
People with integrity at the FDA and at the CDC will soon be looking back on their failure to act with the same mix of regret and shame that the members of Mueller’s team now express.
“We could have made a difference."
www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/09/andrew-weiss… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Same to staff scientists at the FDA as for those at the CDC.
Where is the courage? Where are the public protests? The work stoppages? The resignations?
This is the last chance to avoid being damned forevcer as a colaborator.
Eric Topol
@EricTopol
Just what we needed in a pandemic. The @HHSgov is at war with the @US_FDA and, for all intents and purposes, has taken over. @SecAzar is at @realDonaldTrump's command. Watch out, folks.
www.nytimes.com/2020/09/19/health/azar-hhs-fda.html?searc… @BySheilaKaplan -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Where is the outrage from staff at the CDC? Where are the resignations?
Being a scientist is like being a pilot. Most of the time it is an easy job. But there are times when it takes all the courage and integrity one can muster to do the job well.
This is one of those times. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Multiply this terrible loss by 200,000 to get a sense for the magnitude of the tragedy that we’ve experienced so far in the US.
And it is far from over. Many more losses to come. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Retweeting my appreciation for the rare moral conviction of @OliviaTroye.
Cross in photo from Ash Wednesday:
x.com/paulmromer/status/1306772363581759493
Courage:
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
So perhaps it should not come as a surprise that she alone had the courage to speak out about the evil they all witnessed.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Revealing detail:
Look at the photo at 0:05-8 in the video. It must have been taken on Ash Wednesday. Ms. Troye has a cross on her forehead. She apparently had no qualms about being the only person in the room displaying her relgious conviction.
www.youtube.com/embed/f0j6adNroo4
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
So perhaps it should not come as a surprise that she alone had the courage to speak out about the evil they all witnessed.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you think your job is hard, listen to what it was like to work every day to save lives and watch as one man stymies your efforts and carries out his plan to gaslight his way out of the pandemic, at the cost of many tens of thousands of needless deaths.
Republican Accountability
@AccountableGOP
NEW AD: @OliviaTroye was @VP's lead staffer on COVID-19. She put her heart & soul into the job.
After a while she couldn't look herself in the mirror because no matter what she did, the President would undermine it and make Americans less safe.
Now she's a GOP voter for Biden.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From interview w Ms Troye:
"Sadly, the surprise here is not that Trump acted so callously in the midst of a pandemic but that so many senior government officials know that this is happening and are doing nothing to stop it.”
www.newyorker.com/news/letter-from-trumps-washington/it-w… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
RETRACTION:
I was wrong to write on Aug. 25 that the new CDC guidance on testing was “madness.”
x.com/paulmromer/status/1298422945400971266
There is, in fact, a rational explanation. The WH was using the CDC website to distribute unvetted political propaganda.
www.nytimes.com/2020/09/17/health/coronavirus-testing-cdc…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
This is madness.
C.D.C. Now Says People Without Covid-19 Symptoms Do Not Need Testing
www.nytimes.com/2020/08/25/health/covid-19-testing-cdc.html
Why does leadershop at the CDC provide no explanation?
Why did they refer questions about the change to HHS?
Are they now just puppets? -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Next, @DouthatNYT will say that Trump is actually doing OK bc Lat America is the baseline & using public health funds to create a slush fund for a deranged, Russian-compromised bully who admits to stealing from the blind happens all the time in Hondouras.
www.nytimes.com/2020/09/05/opinion/sunday/covid-19-trump.… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Amazing. No one could make up stuff like this.
Caputo admits that he was caught stealing from someone who was blind.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Hard to believe that it could, but the Caputo fiasco gets worse.
"Dr. Redfield … was ordered by the White House … to transfer $300 million from [CDC] budget for a public relations campaign … that Mr. Caputo said he was tasked with overseeing.” 1/N
www.nytimes.com/2020/09/16/world/covid-19-coronavirus.htmlPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
So we know who was beind the scheme to muzzle the professionals at the CDC and take some of its resources so they could be used by a deranged flack who is compromised by Russians and a close associate of a convicted felon … 2/3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
… a convicted felon who says that if Trump loses the election, that would be justification for him to use force to take over the nation. 3/3
wallstreetrebel.com/wsr/articles/convicted_felon_roger_st… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Figures it was Facebook.
'Michael R. Caputo, the assistant secretary of health apologized … for a Facebook outburst in which he accused federal scientists working on the pandemic of “sedition” and warned of coming violence from left-wing “hit squads.”'
www.nytimes.com/2020/09/15/world/covid-coronavirus.html
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
"In other fallout, McMaster University in Canada issued a statement on Monday distancing itself from Dr. Alexander, whom Mr. Caputo hailed to his Facebook followers as a “genius.” He did receive a doctorate from the university, but is not on the faculty."
www.nytimes.com/2020/09/15/world/covid-coronavirus.html
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Think about how delusional these two people would have to have been to think that they could tell the scientists at the CDC what to say and write.
Or how corrupt.
Or how delusional and corrupt. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Mnuchin has apparently endorsed new Bipartisan Stimulus Plan, which allocates $100 billion for testing, contact tracing and other health initiatives.
But no matter what’s in a bill Congress passes, the Trump administration will simply refuse to spend any money on testing. 1/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
There is no indication that the administration has spent the $9 billion allocated for testing to HHS back in Apr. in the PPP - HCE act.
Recall that in Aug WH used this unspent $9 billion to justify reducing proposal by Senate R’s to spend $25 billion on testing down to $16. 2/N
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
You cannot underestimate how determined this administration is to mislead voters about the facts of the pandemic.
Trump has been very clear. He wants to reduce testing to reduce confirmed cases.
He is smart enough to know that this will kill people.
He does not care. 3/3 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Turns out that M. Caputo, the HHS flack w no medical training charged with muzzling the CDC, is out of his mind.
Even he admits that his “mental health has failed.”
But his job is secure.
“muzzling":
www.nytimes.com/2020/09/12/us/politics/trump-coronavirus-…
"out of his mind":
www.nytimes.com/2020/09/14/us/politics/caputo-virus.htmlPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
More on CDC from @germanrlopez
"President Donald Trump and his administration are actively trying to undermine and corrupt the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the country’s premier public health agency, in the middle of the Covid-19 pandemic"
www.vox.com/future-perfect/21436459/cdc-trump-mmrw-covid-…
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Figures.
"Mr. Caputo’s remarks also dovetailed … with those of Roger J. Stone Jr., a longtime confidant of both Mr. Caputo and Mr. Trump”
"Mr. Caputo ...had once lived in Russia, had worked for Russian politicians and was contacted by a Russian ..."
www.nytimes.com/2020/09/14/us/politics/caputo-virus.html -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Yes, the final clause — “provided we use the information wisely” — is essential.
Economists understand that most people can learn to use information reasonably. Not everyone. Not perfectly. Most. Reasonably.
People who work in public health seem not to recognize this point.
Tim Harford
@TimHarford
Yes!
Seeing a lot of confusion about this.
If you treat an innaccurate test as though it is perfect, you have a BIG problem.
But if you treat an innaccurate test as though it is innaccurate, you can still learn a lot from it.
Bayesians understand this!
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The point that cannot be repeated often enough:
"Fast, cheap tests don’t need to be perfect to help contain the virus. They don’t even need to be nearly perfect. Cheap and quick is enough — provided we use the information wisely."
www.ft.com/content/059684da-b180-409b-865f-d7283c7407b3 -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If you are surprised by @byHeatherLong takedown of the strong Trump economy, it shows that his lies work.
Everyone “knows” that he lies, but with repetition, they shift perceptions.
So of course he thought he could lie his way out of the pandemic.
www.washingtonpost.com/business/2020/09/05/trump-obama-ec… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
From @TimHarford, who gets it exactly right:
"...we undervalue data. … But data, even noisy data, about who is infectious is information that could save both livelihoods, and lives.”
www.ft.com/content/059684da-b180-409b-865f-d7283c7407b3
Tim Harford
@TimHarford
My column this morning ventures into science fiction: what if everyone who was infectious glowed orange like the children in the Ready Brek ads?
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The point that cannot be repeated often enough:
"Fast, cheap tests don’t need to be perfect to help contain the virus. They don’t even need to be nearly perfect. Cheap and quick is enough — provided we use the information wisely."
www.ft.com/content/059684da-b180-409b-865f-d7283c7407b3
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
QN: “Would you like some extraordinarily valuable information?”
ANS: From public health officials:
“If we expert, have monopoly control of this information, of course.
But if you are proposing that everyone have it, no way. We’ll stick with ignorance. They might misuse it.” -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Today’s release shows that new claims for unemployment — under the traditional and new PUA programs — increased for the fifth week in a row.
I can’t believe that I have to say this, but when 1.6 million people file for UI in a single week, the labor market is not in good shape.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Under no other President has the labor market ever been as bad as it is now. Still. And getting worse.
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Agreement with my critique of collabo journalism as exemplified by @DouthatNYT ’s column which tries to gaslight readers into thinking that the United States is in the middle of the pack.
Matt
@matt_seden
Great thread.
This kind of semi-literate apologia for Trump's incompetence and recklessness in publications that still enjoy a good degree of trust and a wide readership is very harmful and needs calling out clearly and precisely at every turn. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
It is strikiing how much of his reputation for journalistic integrity @DouthatNYT was willing to trade away for a chance to claim that Trump’s pandemic response was mediocre. 1/N
www.nytimes.com/2020/09/05/opinion/sunday/covid-19-trump.…Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Oh, wait. Joke’s on me. He slipped in the qualifier that “Of the five most populous countries in Western Europe …” before his claim about German exceptionalism.
So he gets an AG Barr award for exceptional dissimulation. Woohoo. @CT_Bergstrom will have a field day.
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Oh and then, you’ll love this doozy.
"But actually both Spain and France have seen late-summer infection waves that have brought them above or close to our infection rate.”
But see the data on deaths for this week.
Even AG Barr wouldn’t go that far. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Supported isolation has to be part of the solution.
The economics are simple. The cost is low because the duration is short and the fraction of the population that needs to be in isolation is so small.
Even now, in uncontrolled US is only ~ 1%.
www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2020/04/30/coronavirus-tes… -
Paul Romer reposted
Stefan Ruijsenaars
@stefan_arrr
Small business revenue has been trending down for the last 4 weeks too
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The data on unemployment claims demonstrate the damage that the pandemic continues to do to the economy.
Total new claims for unemployment persist at at levels that are historically unprecedented.
And they have been trending up for the last 4 weeks.
www.nytimes.com/2020/09/03/business/economy/unemployment-… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
The best and most up-to-date- reporting on our national testing disaster, by @Atul_Gawande
Title reveals the take away, but what matters are the details about what we have to do to get more testing. 1/N
www.newyorker.com/science/medical-dispatch/we-can-solve-t…Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
8. "On Election Day, we’ll have a chance to turn out a President who has sacrificed tens of thousands of American lives—and undermined essential government institutions—to serve his own desires."
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
9. "[O]ur best chance for long, flourishing lives in the future requires that we build the foundations of our public health now."
-
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
This is madness.
C.D.C. Now Says People Without Covid-19 Symptoms Do Not Need Testing
www.nytimes.com/2020/08/25/health/covid-19-testing-cdc.html
Why does leadershop at the CDC provide no explanation?
Why did they refer questions about the change to HHS?
Are they now just puppets? -
Post not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
I’m good.
Twitter Verified is a sham. It is in no way a solution to the pervasive identity problems on this and all other digital platforms.
I don’t want a check for me. I want someone to come up with a trustworthy solution that is open to every real person. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
17. Remote learning is harming students from poor families to a much greater extent than students from affluent families 17/18
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Scientists are observationally equivalent to madmen and fools when they dismiss cycles of tests that deliver benefits that are orders of magnitude larger than what they cost;
and endorse instead cycles of lockdown that look like this: -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
So here is the question for the epidemiologists and public health officials:
If you had $100 billion to spend right now, can you suggest a way to save the same number of lives that does not involve recurring flareups and lockdowns: -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
If policy makers are stuck with frequent, long periods of lockdown, it will kill business and consumer confidence. No one can plan. No one will invest. We lose many $trillions.
If we spent $100 billion on testing, can contain the virus with no lockdowns.
Sounds cheap to me. -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Signs of progress:
"Atypical Illness Levels for New York City, NY and surrounding areas. As of March 29, 2020."
www.kinsahealth.co/early-social-distancing-measures-reduc… -
Paul Romer
@paulmromer
Thoughts about open source (Jupyter) vs proprietary software (Mathematica) prompted by the Somers article:
paulromer.net/jupyter-mathematica-and-the-future-of-the-r…

























































































































































































































