This assertion from Yglesias is quite damning -- for Yglesias. He is claiming it is "basic reality" that Elizabeth Warren is "an electoral underperformer" and that anybody who doesn't understand that shouldn't be trusted to understand more complicated things. But he appears not to understand the numbers himself.
He often points out (rightly) that Kamala Harris outperformed Warren in 2024 in Mass. That's true overall. You could note that Warren ran no ads and didn't campaign, so that explains the difference, but it's actually much worse than that for Yglesias. If you look at where the votes were spread out, what you find is that Harris significantly overperformed Warren in the wealthiest, most-educated parts of Massachusetts, while Warren outperformed Harris in the working class areas.
So if you think the way for Democrats to win nationally is to keep running up the score with people who read Yglesias' newsletter, then by all means, don't listen to Warren and definitely follow Matt's advice into the arms of Kamala.
But if you think Democrats need to do better in working class areas where people don't have advanced degrees, the candidate who does well there is actually Warren.
I'm going to assume in the spirit of good faith that Matt has never looked at the numbers beyond the state level. (Matt, is that right?) Once he sees them, I think he'll have to correct his analysis. It is basic reality that in areas that demographically and educationally look more like the rest of the country, Warren outperformed Harris. That doesn't mean he has to like her or her ideas, but he has to confront them head on, and drop this false claim that she is an underperformer.
Let's take a look at about a dozen towns and cities that tell the real story: