The AHSAA should have an intent and goal of encouraging true competition and maintaining competitive balance in all divisions of sports.
Competitive balance requires allowing all teams to move up or down in classification because when a team like the Asbury Rams goes 0-20 over two consecutive seasons, they need to be moved down. And when a team like Mars Hills wins a state championship, they need to be moved up at least one classification level, which would have happened.
It is also unfair to young, up-and-coming teams in Marshall County, such as Douglas High School, to be placed in a region with teams like Clay Chalkville, which just won the state championship. It is yet another fundamental flaw in the AHSAA’s new system and demonstrates that its decision was certainly not rooted in the best interests of the student athletes they are supposed to serve.
Losing 60 private school teams in the playoff regions creates unintended consequences and raises a hint of chaos.
To demonstrate the discrepancy in sizes of schools in the regions, let’s look at my home county of Marshall. Douglas, Boaz, and Arab high schools have 524, 534, and 548 students respectively, and are all zoned 5A, but the AHSAA now expects them to compete with some schools that have more than double the student populations. They are now assigned to compete against the defending 6A State Champion Clay Chalkville High School, which has 952 students. Other schools in similar position are East Limestone, Scottsboro, Ramsay, St. Clair County, and Elberta, with an average of 525 students each.
There are obviously countless similar situations across the state.
It is an unfair, unsportsmanlike, uncompetitive flaw that is a direct result of eliminating private schools from these groups, and once again, it does an incredible disservice to the student athletes that the AHSAA is supposed to serve and support.
The AHSAA’s imperious plan also results in the loss of gate revenues due to long road commutes, the abolishing of historic football rivalries, and other serious issues. The loss of gate revenues is especially crucial in small towns and counties that desperately need the money to fund their programs.
A school like Lee-Scott will now have to travel 3 hours to get to games, and Cullman, which is the only North Alabama team in its region, will have to travel over an hour to compete against Birmingham teams it has never traditionally played as most of its rivalries have been abolished.
Removing more than 60 teams will Increase transportation costs, create huge disruptions in academic and work weeks, and create logistical nightmares for schools, families, and, most importantly, students. Regional games that are up to three hours away are inconvenient, unnecessary, and impractical, especially when other regional opponents could be much closer.
Parents and grandparents will lose additional hours of work time in order to attend games, and those who cannot take time from their jobs will miss games altogether. The purpose of school is to get a good education, and sports do teach many life lessons, but it is difficult to learn when the schedule forced by the AHSAA’s decision makes missing missing class more likely.
It is yet another failure of the AHSAA to consider the needs and well-being of the student athletes they are supposed to serve.
Even worse, the new system has the potential to create more “super teams” among both private and public schools, which worsens the problem that the AHSAA claims it is trying to solve.
Student athletes will be drawn to the programs with the most money, which will be the city school system programs and private school programs that have more resources to provide coaches, facilities, and equipment.