Excited to announce that @GovKathyHochul, @USCTO47, and @coeff_giving's @mattsclancy will be keynoting at Abundance 2026, produced by @TheBTI and @NiskanenCenter.
More keynotes and speakers TBA!
abundancedc.org
Breakthrough Institute
The Breakthrough Institute is an environmental research center located in Berkeley, California. Founded in 2007 by Michael Shellenberger and Ted Nordhaus, the institute is aligned with ecomodernist philosophy. The Institute advocates for an embrace of modernization and technological development (including nuclear power and carbon capture) in order to address environmental challenges. Proposing urbanization, agricultural intensification, nuclear power, aquaculture, and desalination as processes with a potential to reduce human demands on the environment, allowing more room for non-human species. More on Wikipedia
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Over the years, U.S. farm output has risen faster than environmental impacts and resource use. Our new Sustainable Intensification Tracker, built by @danrejto, shows how, across land, nitrogen, water, herbicides, soil erosion, and climate.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/s… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
New @TheBTI website just dropped.
thebreakthrough.org -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
74% of NEPA court decisions went against the challenging party.
75% of those suits came from NGOs.
NEPA is a tool for proceduralist delay, not blocking projects environmentalists don't like.
@TheBTI analysis:
navigatingnepa.com -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The X-energy construction permit is the first permit issued for a multi-module advanced reactor, for a pebble-bed reactor, and also for a reactor that is supposed to refuel while operating."
Subscribe to Nuclear Notes today: www.nuclearnotes.org/p/another-advanced-reactor-gets-perm… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Abundance is ascendent, vibrant, and cross-partisan.
But we haven't fully reckoned with AI, and we don't know what the upcoming open presidential primaries portend for our young movement.
My latest @TheBTI:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/abundance-between-2026-and-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Lauren Teixeira
@lrntex
Honored to be on a panel next Monday alongside @MichaelWWara and @CleanPowerDave about CA wildfire resilience. I imagine we will discuss, among other things, the possible impacts of the Jane Kim win. It’s open to the public - come thru!
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Abundance 2026, which I’m producing, takes place in DC next month.
So I wrote about five unsettled arguments for the abundance movement to reckon with as we process the 2026 midterms and prepare for 2028.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/abundance-between-2026-and-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“As of this writing, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) is on the cusp of passage, culminating years of energy abundance advocacy.”
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/abundance-between-2026-and-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"I believe significant progress towards the abundance agenda is possible regardless of either the setting of the thermostat or the occupant of the White House. But the exact nature of that progress is certainly contingent on political trajectories."
The latest from @atrembath: -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
The @NRCgov issued a construction permit to Long Mott Energy for the @xenergynuclear plant at the DOW plant in Texas. This is an important milestone for the ARDP projects. thebreakthrough.org/press/release-nrc-issues-construction…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Environmental groups, from the silent to the supportive, are reckoning with the reality... that permitting reform is good for developers, consumers, the environment, and the climate."
Read @atrembath's latest: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/on-anti-baaja-bullshit -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"For far too long, the environmental movement has been dominated by a culture of “no” ... Imagine what the movement might be able to accomplish if activists shifted toward a mindset of trying to get to “yes”"
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/10/31/permitting-ref… -
Breakthrough reposted
Niskanen Center
@NiskanenCenter
High housing costs, slow energy projects, and aging infrastructure reflect a common challenge: America needs to build more, but policies and regulations often stand in the way.
Abundance is about changing those policies that constrain supply and make building harder than it needs to be.
Abundance DC brings that debate to Washington, D.C., Dec. 10–11, with @TheBTI.
Press info: abundancedc.org/press/ -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Before the Simon-Ehrlich bet, there was Bill Nordhaus.
Before McKibben and Hansen and Gore and net-zero, there was Bill Nordhaus.
A lovely eulogy from Bill’s nephew @TedNordhaus.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-original-environmental-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"A functioning insurance market is one of California’s most important climate-resilience tools. The state cannot afford to break the one it is only just starting to rebuild."
The latest from @lrntex: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/natural-disaster-insurance-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Thank you Uncle Bill, for all that you did for the world, and for me. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-original-environmental-…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
A recurring argument by environmental lobbyists has been that permitting reform like BAAJA will unleash US LNG exports whose emissions outweigh any clean energy benefits. Our new analysis reexamines a prominent “study” by Symons Public Affairs that made similar claims about the Energy Permitting Reform Act of 2024—its results depended on absurdly pessimistic assumptions, which slash estimates by 55-80% when varied.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Many permitting critics have little interest in the full range of policy outcomes—but rather only in results that provide cover for their preferred arguments."
The latest from @wang_seaver @RyanAlimento and @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-faulty-logic-at-the-hea… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Once again for those in the back. The mainstream green groups were never going to be part of the abundance coalition that was going to get serious about building a clean energy future. A lot of people were upset at me when I said this at the first Abundance Conference but everything that has happened since has pretty well proved my point, starting with the protest immediately after my speech and culminating with the full court press by the movement to kill permitting reform.
Christy Goldfuss
@christygoldfuss
There is a need for compromise, but it’s frustrating to see the bill’s cheerleaders refuse to acknowledge any flaws that may result from that compromise. I’m going to go out on a limb and say that you can recognize the climate benefits of the permitting bill and still point out concerns.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Properly implemented, information from DOE and DOW experience can help reduce duplication and improve NRC review focus as prototypes and military-deployed reactors enter the commercial space."
Read more in the latest Nuclear Notes: www.nuclearnotes.org/p/separated-at-birth-nrc-and-doe-con… -
Breakthrough reposted
Niskanen Center
@NiskanenCenter
Press applications are now open for Abundance 2026, taking place December 10–11 in Washington, D.C. As the U.S. confronts persistent challenges in housing, energy infrastructure, and public project delivery, the conference will convene leaders across sectors and political perspectives to examine reforms that could shape the country’s ability to build and deliver at scale.
Apply for press access: abundancedc.org/press/ -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The bill does not solve all the problems that mineral supply chains face. But BAAJA fixes a broken permitting system that needlessly raises the cost, risk, and time it takes to develop mines and build processing plants."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/critical-mineral-policy-nee… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
The era of the climate hawk is over.
Whitehouse and Heinrich are crafting a new climate policy agenda for a new era.
McKibben and Huffman are stuck in the past.
Adam Jentleson
@AJentleson
If BAAJA passes over Podesta’s opposition it will mark the end of one era and the beginning of another.
If not… it’s still just a matter of time. -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Stay ahead of the curve: listen to @TheBTI before the conventional wisdom catches up in a decade or so.
New York Post
@nypost
Paper straws worse for the environment than plastic ones, says study nypost.com/2026/10/26/lifestyle/paper-straws-worse-for-th…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"BAAJA fixes a broken permitting system that needlessly raises the cost, risk, and time it takes to develop mines and build processing plants."
via @TheBTI's @PeterCookBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/critical-mineral-policy-nee… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The bill does not solve all the problems that mineral supply chains face. But BAAJA fixes a broken permitting system that needlessly raises the cost, risk, and time it takes to develop mines and build processing plants."
The latest from @PeterCookBTI:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/critical-mineral-policy-nee… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Can BAAJA Save the Environment?
@JeremiahDJohns interviews @TheBTI's Marc Levitt.
cnliberalism.org/posts/can-baaja-save-the-environmen-ft-m… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“Tech companies, which have pledged to cut their carbon footprints as they build hyperscale data centers, are backing technologies that are far more ambitious, and far different from what the utilities are accustomed to operating.”
www.nuclearnotes.org/p/two-steps-forward-for-advanced-nuc… -
Breakthrough reposted
New Liberals
@CNLiberalism
Can BAAJA help save the environment?
@TheBTI's Marc Levitt joins @JeremiahDJohns to talk about what's in the new bill, how it makes building clean energy easier, and why permitting reform is so important to reaching our climate goals.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/can-baaja-save-the-environm… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Relative to the scale of wind, solar, and battery capacity waiting in interconnection queues, the volume of projects currently “slow-walked or stalled” by the Trump administration is small.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/permitting-reform-unlocks-m… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
I genuinely hope that @fervoenergy is correct here and the short seller is wrong. But @heatmap_news publishing what is basically an extended debunking of what the short seller is claiming here is a marked contrast to how Heatmap and other clean tech media treat similar stories about next generation nuclear, where every short position and dip in share prices is treated as proof that its all a gigantic bubble built on hype while the founders, unlike Latimer, are framed not as climate heroes but tech bros and con men.
Maybe Fervo will succeed and advanced nuclear will fail. But the double standard is noticeable and reflects I think, the latent anti-nuclearism that has been baked into environmental and energy discourse for a several generations and that is so normalized that many well-meaning and "not anti-nuclear" people are completely unaware of it.
I see this across many related domains. I can't tell you how many times over the last decade I've heard philanthropists and program officers proudly proclaiming that they are making big investments under the banner of clean energy abundance, underresourced climate strategies and technologies, or effective altruism who then proceed to explain that while they are making big philanthropic commitments to geothermal, carbon capture, carbon removal, geoengineering, and similar, they aren't investing in nuclear because nuclear is already covered.
This notion is laughable. Even today, a decade and a half after we launched the pro-nuclear movement, there is a pittance of philanthropic money going into nuclear compared with any of the above technologies. But making big philanthropic bets on nuclear is considered to be gauche, a fool's errand, or just not something that environmentally or climate concerned philanthropists do.
At this point I don't think any of this is going to change. Environmentalism is the secular religion of the western, post-industrial, knowledge class and it comes with a particular imaginary about the future. As I wrote a few years ago:
"At the heart of modern environmental identity and consciousness is an imaginary and utopian future, easily recognizable in contemporary iconography, of bucolic landscapes with low density housing in the foreground, agricultural lands teeming with wildlife and dotted with windmills and solar panels in the middle ground, and magnificent mountains, wilderness, and wild rivers in the background. Somewhere in this world there are cities and lithium mines, factories and sewage treatment plants. But they are literally not in the picture."
It is remarkable that even today, carbon capture and removal, enhanced geothermal sprawling across vast landscapes to frack hot water from deep below the earth's surface, and spraying sulfur particles into the upper atmosphere are all more welcome amendments to that imaginary than dense, land and material efficient, always on nuclear energy. If nuclear succeeds it will do so in spite of climate-industrial complex, and its many pragmatic and abundance-ish offshoots, not because of it.
heatmap.news/energy/fervo-short-seller-report -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
In case you missed it from last week: a new data-based report from my team provides a one-stop, mineral-by-mineral primer on which critical minerals have low potential for production from mine waste tailings, and which minerals (a very limited set), possess higher potential.
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
Despite hype, reprocessing of mine tailings is generally unlikely to yield economic production of critical minerals.
Shown here: global mine site sample data for antimony, gallium, lithium, and tin. Economic ranges in blue.
It’s rare for a single report to put an end to a bad policy idea, but I’m hopeful this tour de force from my colleague @PeterCookBTI does just that. Policymakers should not misinterpret mine tailings as a meaningful solution for critical minerals security. 🧵 -
Breakthrough reposted
John Stossel
@JohnStossel
Trump has ordered regulators to fast-track new nuclear plants.
Democratic senators call that dangerous.
“That's just a bunch of crap," says Ray Rothrock of @TheBTI, "They're afraid of something they don't need to be afraid of.”
My video below covers some of their fears:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Breakthrough reposted
Shawn Regan
@Shawn_Regan
Great piece by @EmilyJane_Bass for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/two-permitting-bills-are-be… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"There is growing scientific consensus that removing flammable fuels with thinning and prescribed fire projects can bring down the severity of wildfires. But federal efforts have barely made a dent."
The latest from @EmilyJane_Bass: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/two-permitting-bills-are-be… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
Despite hype, reprocessing of mine tailings is generally unlikely to yield economic production of critical minerals.
Shown here: global mine site sample data for antimony, gallium, lithium, and tin. Economic ranges in blue.
It’s rare for a single report to put an end to a bad policy idea, but I’m hopeful this tour de force from my colleague @PeterCookBTI does just that. Policymakers should not misinterpret mine tailings as a meaningful solution for critical minerals security. 🧵 -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Pleased to say @TheBTI is a signatory in this effort:
Isaiah Menning
@IsaiahMenning
Down with the invasive mosquitoes and ticks.
Proud to lead a coalition letter to @EPA today recommending pro-innovation reforms for advanced pest control tech, from gene drives to Wolbachia, along with my @JoinFAI colleagues @ZacharyGraves, @maxbodach, and @banksianr. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The studies simply do not prove anything about cancer incidence."
Read @thebti's @Dr_A_Stein and @econpragmatist excerpted in the Wall Street Journal: www.wsj.com/opinion/notable-quotable-does-costco-cause-ca… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The clean energy benefits of permitting reform to the United States over the coming decades far outweigh whatever remaining influence Donald Trump has on the country’s energy system in his last two years in office."
New from @wang_seaver:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/permitting-reform-unlocks-m… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"To the extent law and policy impose penalties on emitters, those penalties need to be legislated, not litigated, and they need to be prospective, not retroactive."
New from @atrembath and @3lizabethMcC: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-limits-of-climate-attri… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) creates a clear and credible path to building the infrastructure we need to decarbonize our electricity sector and stabilize prices."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-unmistakable-need-for-b… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Climate change is real and is having impacts. But "the determination by the climate movement and its allies to reduce the issue to a manichean struggle to save lives by reducing fossil fuel use" has undermined straightforward measures to improve public health outcomes associated with climate change and pollution.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The climate issue has always been a politics taker, not a politics maker—the sort of issue that benefits or suffers from various shifts in political fortune but does not determine them."
@TedNordhaus reflects on climate politics in the Summer of 2026: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/about-last-summer -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“An amazing takedown from @econpragmatist and @Dr_A_Stein.”
@ATabarrok on @TheBTI’s debunking of recent nuclear-and-cancer research.
marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/10/does-co… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
A recent series of papers suggested that nuclear power plants are responsible for more than 100 thousand cancers. Using their method, every landmark we tested causes cancer,
-
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
@TheBTI published a comprehensive methodological debunking of the Harvard "nuclear plants cause cancer" study today.
Props to my nuclear team colleagues @Dr_A_Stein and @econpragmatist.
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
BREAKING: Costco, major league baseball stadiums, and Harvard cause hundreds of thousands of cancer deaths every year.
Not really. But @econpragmatist and @Dr_A_Stein reanalysis of @HarvardChanSPH study on cancer deaths and proximity to nuclear power plants shows that you can use the exact same methodology and data to reach this conclusion.
File this study under lies, damn lies, and statistics... -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
BREAKING: Costco, major league baseball stadiums, and Harvard cause hundreds of thousands of cancer deaths every year.
Not really. But @econpragmatist and @Dr_A_Stein reanalysis of @HarvardChanSPH study on cancer deaths and proximity to nuclear power plants shows that you can use the exact same methodology and data to reach this conclusion.
File this study under lies, damn lies, and statistics... -
Breakthrough reposted
Deric Tilson
@econpragmatist
We spent months replicating papers that claimed an association between cancer and nuclear power plants. After expanding the analysis to non-nuclear landmarks, we couldn’t find a negative result. Everything caused cancer, from baseball stadiums to state capitals.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Sophisticated statistics can produce extremely precise nonsense when the design fails to identify the causal mechanism."
Read @econpragmatist and @Dr_A_Stein's critique of recent studies claiming to show that nuclear plants were associated with higher cancer risks for nearby communities.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/things-that-apparently-caus… -
Breakthrough reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
For decades, the NRC created overly burdensome regs and was a major hurdle for the nuclear industry. There was a lot of deserved criticism from advocates. But new commissioners and legislation in 2019 and 2024 catalyzed reforms. Today it's much more constructive for the industry.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
NEW paper from @thebti's @wang_seaver @PeterCookBTI and @RyanAlimento et al. projects the fast growing demand for energy transition critical minerals in South + Southeast Asia. driven by both demand for electric vehicles (cars + two-wheelers) and power sector development.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Learn more from @wang_seaver below:
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
My team and co-authors published a new paper today in Environmental Research Letters @IOPenvironment: "Future Energy Transition Mineral Demands and Barriers for South and Southeast Asia."
Key Finding 1: South Asia and ASEAN become major drivers of energy transition mineral demand. Under announced climate pledges, critical mineral demand in clean tech deployed across South and Southeast Asia may surpass that of a rapidly-decarbonizing United States, as early as the mid-2030s. 🧵 -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
My team and co-authors published a new paper today in Environmental Research Letters @IOPenvironment: "Future Energy Transition Mineral Demands and Barriers for South and Southeast Asia."
Key Finding 1: South Asia and ASEAN become major drivers of energy transition mineral demand. Under announced climate pledges, critical mineral demand in clean tech deployed across South and Southeast Asia may surpass that of a rapidly-decarbonizing United States, as early as the mid-2030s. 🧵 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Clinch River is an important signal toward efficient reviews becoming routine rather than the exception"
Read the latest in Nuclear Notes: www.nuclearnotes.org/p/the-nrc-issues-its-first-smr-const… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 is a true, heroic breakthrough for permitting reform that opens the door to a new era of climate policy, infrastructure deployment, and long-term price stabilization.”
thebreakthrough.org/press/release-breakthrough-institute-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"It would be little exaggeration to say that, over 20 years, federal greenhouse emissions regulations have accomplished nothing in the real world."
The latest from @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-federal-regulations-fai… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
As we wrote earlier this year, “passing durable, bipartisan permitting reform is a response to the Administration’s energy policies, not a surrender to them. Democrats would be cutting off their nose to spite their face by balking at this opportunity.”
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/trumps-war-on-renewable…
Joshua Siegel
@SiegelScribe
BREAKING: A senior Dem aide tells me the permitting deal is ON HOLD after staff re-read the text this am and found that language addressing five offshore wind projects Trump had attempted to stop "had changed substantially from the language that was originally negotiated."
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The future is uncertain and messy. That is not a reason to hogtie innovation in advance; uncertainty provides reason to preserve the freedom to experiment, build, compete, and learn."
Read @econpragmatist:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/dont-let-temporary-bans-bec… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Democrats and Republicans have spent twenty years arguing over emissions regulations that have never had, and likely never will have, any meaningful effect.
My latest @thedispatch:
thedispatch.com/newsletter/dispatch-energy/epa-endangerme… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Smith
@alexjmssmith
The U.S. hit peak beef in 1976. Health, convenience, and cheap chicken drew consumers away from it. Yet, steaks, bbq, and burgers remain key to American diets and global beef consumption is on the rise.
@billmckibben is wrong that high prices mean the end is near for beef. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Energy and consumption transitions rarely look like one technology neatly replacing another. They are messy and partial, with incumbents sticking around far longer than advocates expect. We should be skeptical of McKibben’s tidy story."
@alexjmssmith responds to @billmckibben:
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
You can read the piece here: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/beef-its-still-whats-for-di…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Moratoria should be a temporary and rarely used tool, not a hammer that treats every new innovation, idea, and piece of infrastructure as a nail."
Read the latest from @econpragmatist:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/dont-let-temporary-bans-bec… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Despite alarmism from Mother Jones, glyphosate use in California and the rest of our National Forests is vanishingly small, has minimal environmental impacts relative to alternatives, and is crucial to conducting the forest management projects needed to mitigate wildfire risk and protect ecosystems from invasive species."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-glyphosate-panic-comes-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
100% predictable that @NRDC support for permitting reform was always limited to potemkin permitting reform. When it comes down to real permitting reform that might allow anyone to build at scale, they and the rest of the green groups were always going to be scorched earth.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
As we @TheBTI wrote over the course of this year, Democrats’ permitting priorities are reasonable, but not worth killing an overall deal over.
“Passing durable, bipartisan permitting reform is a response to the Administration’s energy policies, not a surrender to them.“
Joshua Siegel
@SiegelScribe
NEW in ME: Time running short on pre-elex permitting reform deal. Thune wants answers today. POTUS was briefed and gave his blessing for his team and Rs to cut a deal. But Trump admin's attacks on wind, along w/ transmission are among outstanding issues
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Georgia Power said it spent $3.53 billion in interest on its portion of Vogtle 3 & 4, and it owned only 46 percent of the project, meaning that interest costs approached 20 percent of its expense."
The latest from @MattLWald:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/what-rising-interest-rates-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Lot of people were outraged when I predicted this possibility right before the 2024 election...
Josiah Neeley 🇺🇸
@jneeley78
Trump is a climate hero.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Despite the alarmism from Mother Jones, glyphosate use in California and the rest of our National Forests is vanishingly small... and is crucial to conducting the forest management projects needed to mitigate wildfire risk and protect ecosystems from invasive species."
From @EmilyJane_Bass:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-glyphosate-panic-comes-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"By DOE’s own model, all five sites passed the safety test with large margins. What the ranking actually adjudicated, under guidelines that required safety to carry the greater weight, was a pair of unmeasured construction estimates. A decision made on cost is a decision not made on safety."
Read the latest from @Dr_A_Stein:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/amer… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The comments implicitly carry the idea that reforming the rules means increasing nuclear risk. In fact, the changes pave the way for a generation of nuclear technology that is inherently safer."
Read the latest Nuclear Notes: www.nuclearnotes.org/p/some-state-attorney-generals-are -
Breakthrough reposted
Richard Morrison
@RichardMorrison
My guest for Episode 191 of @freethe_economy is @wang_seaver of @TheBTI. We talk about rare earth elements, China’s export controls, permitting reform, friend-shoring, and where to find tomorrow’s supply of critical minerals: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tbp8hTigJJs (2/3)
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“Climate hushing” is not a defeat for decarbonization and climate policy, but a return to the quieter, bipartisan, technology-and-abundance politics that actually has a track record of emissions reductions.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/climate-policy-is-getting-q… -
Breakthrough reposted
Bay Area Council
@BayAreaCouncil
"AI and the build-out of data centers may offer a generational opportunity to clean up our electricity grid, improve water quality and water-use efficiency, and accelerate technologies to lighten the burden we impose on the planet." Great piece from @TedNordhaus @TheBTI
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"AI and the build-out of data centers may offer a generational opportunity to clean up our electricity grid, improve water quality and water-use efficiency, and accelerate technologies to lighten the burden we impose on the planet."
www.wsj.com/opinion/protect-the-earthbuild-more-data-cent… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"Whatever you think about AI, the future of the planet will be determined not by a short-term blip in domestic carbon emissions from data centers...but by how quickly the world develops clean technologies."
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"The massive data center build-out may prove to be the critical platform for commercializing clean, reliable, low-carbon electricity-generation technology that the world will need to tackle climate change."
My latest @WSJopinion. -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
Quoted, giving some pragmatism that will be viewed as negativity. But it is true and has been experienced time after time. Even if a project pencils out perfectly, decision-makers might say no due to perception of risk. Some will need earlier and smaller wins to gain confidence
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"In an era when voters are laser-focused on cost-of-living concerns and emerging challenges like artificial intelligence, climate hushing may well be the thing that saves the climate."
Read @atrembath in @TheArgumentMag:
www.theargumentmag.com/p/we-wont-stop-climate-change-by-t… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
A really important new banger piece from @RyanAlimento for @TheBTI on grid-enhancing technologies (GETs). Let's dive right into the technical insights.🧵
First, dynamic line ratings don't always increase rated capacity--sometimes they decrease it. In this example from Ohio, more accurate ratings actually decreased the line's rating relative to its static rating (black straight line), because this line is shielded by vegetation and actually experiences less wind cooling than the static rating accounted for.
So dynamic line ratings should not be thought of as *synonymous* with increased headroom. But they *do* provide better information for safe and efficient grid operation regardless of the direction they point in. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Results from a few case studies and a more nuanced explanation of how GETs work can help policymakers and non-technical members of the public appreciate GETs for what they are: innovations that deserve policy support as tools for grid modernization, not as “non-wires alternatives” to transmission lines."
Read the latest from @RyanAlimento:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/software-wont-expand-the-el… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Everyone—from Markey to Mamdani, from Sunrise to @leahstokes—is climate hushing.
And that’s fine, because pitched partisan fights are bad for durable energy and infrastructure policy.
My latest @TheArgumentMag:
www.theargumentmag.com/p/we-wont-stop-climate-change-by-t… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"The massive data center build-out may prove to be the critical platform for commercializing clean, reliable, low-carbon electricity-generation technology that the world will need to tackle climate change."
My latest @WSJopinion. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"AI and the build-out of data centers may offer a generational opportunity to clean up our electricity grid, improve water quality and water-use efficiency, and accelerate technologies to lighten the burden we impose on the planet."
Latest from @TedNordhaus in @WSJ: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Wildfire liability and ineffectual mitigation are driving electricity rates up in California. The solution: liability reform, insurance market correction, and catastrophe fund capitalization.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/rewiring-risk -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @ClearPathAction to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Human activity and land management decisions exert enough influence to complicate the narrative that climate change will always lead to a net increase in wildfire activity."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/climate-change-alone-doesnt… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"Human activity and land management decisions exert enough influence to complicate the narrative that climate change will always lead to a net increase in wildfire activity."
via @TheBTI's @EmilyJane_Bass
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/climate-change-alone-doesnt… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Climate change is worsening an important driver of wildfire: fire weather. But fire weather is not synonymous with wildfire outcomes. Human land use decisions, accumulating fuel loads, and fire suppression policies play a huge role in transforming how easily fire spreads across the landscape."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/climate-change-alone-doesnt… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Modernizing the grid in a time of rising demand will be more costly for many years before those efforts start saving Americans money. Those expenditures represent an investment in a better future that may reduce energy bills in a decade, not tomorrow."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/home-upgrades-cant-power-da… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Every transformer runs on a core made of GOES, from the large power transformers that carry over 90% of the nation’s electricity to the 60 to 80 million distribution transformers feeding energy to homes and businesses.
But the U.S. can't make it right.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/america-makes-the-wrong-ste… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @PERCtweets to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Due to a peculiarity in the state’s constitution, California's electricity utilities are incentivized to pay for a huge amount of wildfire prevention."
@thebti's @lrntex joins @robinsonmeyer on Shift Key for @heatmap_news.
heatmap.news/podcast/shift-key-s3-e64-lauren-teixeira -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Governor Newsom recently opted to not support the 20 year extension of Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power Plant, California's last remaining nuclear plant, despite growing support from across the State and recent approval from the NRC.
Learn more from Nuclear Notes: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with Abundance Network to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
California's electricity bills have risen by 70-80% since 2018, due, in large part, to utility wildfire mitigation and the State's insurance approach.
A new report from @lrntex explains how to bring down electricity bills make CA more wildfire resilient: thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/rewiring-risk -
Breakthrough reposted
Fred Stafford
@fredstaffordcs
New short post on the National Anchor Power Program I proposed in my recent essay for @TheBTI. Though I'd framed it as serving hyperscaler load, any high load factor industry would be well suited too. Here I give some history on that idea. 1/ www.publicpowerreview.org/p/national-anchor-power-going-b…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with Welcoming Neighbors Network to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
Large infrastructure projects don't fail because of a single bottleneck. They fail because approval is stratified across independent layers, with different definitions of risk, and non-substitutable approvals.
My new report explains why solving one often just moves the problem. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
New @thebti report from @Dr_A_Stein: When big infrastructure projects fail, its because no single actor controls the outcome, and every single approval -- from investors, regulators, local communities, etc -- must align at once. (1/8)
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/stakeholder-stratification
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The dominant account of failed infrastructure projects explains cost overruns through agent-level failure: optimistic planners, promoters gaming approval. But this framework has a limited scope. (2/8)
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The challenges of a distributed decision system is the better frame. Legal, commercial, financial, technical, political and social approvals are non-fungible. A project that has satisfied every condition but one is not "almost finished." (3/8)
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
This is because "risk" is not a shared idea. A construction delay is a safety-schedule concern for regulators, a cost-of-capital exposure for lenders, and a counterparty question for buyers. Each stakeholder has a different conception of the problem and the risk involved. (4/8)
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
This is why "better communication" does not fix stakeholder conflicts. A community worried about fairness and trust isn't evaluating the same thing as a regulator modeling radiological risk. They're entirely different problems with entirely different solutions. (5/8)
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
To add to this problem, mitigating one "risk" often means increasing another "risk." Government loan guarantees turn financing risk into political risk. (6/8)
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The implication of this is that single-domain interventions don't resolve the problems. They relocate the binding constraint. For example, federal cost protection for nuclear addresses PUC risk aversion, but the overruns came from delivery and supply-chain, not regulation. (7/8)
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Hyperscalers are learning this in real time. PPAs solve commercial risk but not interconnection, transmission, or siting. Solving this coordination problem is the challenge for any infrastructure project going forward. (8/8)
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/stakeholder-stratification -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Partisan tension combined with the Trump administration's preference for unilateral action have paralyzed this Congress, leaving it unable to advance its own proposals—let alone forge them into a coherent national critical minerals strategy."
New from @PeterCookBTI and @wang_seaver:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/does-congress-even-have… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with Students for Abundance to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Congrats to @TheBTI's @lrntex and @RyanAlimento for their inclusion in @rootsofprogress's excellent writing fellowship!
Roots of Progress Institute
@rootsofprogress
41 outstanding progress intellectuals joined the 2026 Blog-Building Intensive Program. x.com/i/article/2087956500652445696
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Every transformer on the grid runs on a core made of grain-oriented electrical steel (GOES). GOES prices doubled from 2020 to 2024, but there is only 1 GOES plant in the U.S. and it makes an inferior product.
New from @RyanAlimento:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/america-makes-the-wrong-ste… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
We have written a new primer on prospects and challenges facing value-added mineral beneficiation opportunities in the Indian states of Andhra Pradesh and Jharkhand, at the request of and in collaboration with @Swaniti and the Meridian Collective.
Our analysis focuses on rare earths and titanium from heavy mineral sands in Andhra Pradesh, and on lithium, byproduct gallium and rare earths, aluminum, copper, and iron in Jharkhand. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"These pilot reactors, Groves included, are remarkable for having reached initial criticality in less than a year since groundbreaking. But, the initial demonstration still leaves these developers with huge tasks ahead."
www.nuclearnotes.org/p/another-criticality -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Modernizing the grid in a time of rising demand will be more costly for many years before those efforts start saving Americans money. Those expenditures represent an investment in a better future that may reduce energy bills in a decade, not tomorrow."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/home-upgrades-cant-power-da… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"As modern humans have destroyed, detached, and otherwise decoupled from dependence and impact on the natural world, we have become structurally better off as a species while less connected to most other species."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/decoupling-syndrome -
Breakthrough reposted
Dan Rejto 🇺🇸🌎🍴
@danrejto
Engineering the genome of insects is emerging as the next wave of pest control whether for screwworm, mosquitos or even ticks. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/bioengineering-the-ultimate…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @PubEnterprise to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org: -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Gene drives, baby.
New from my colleague @danrejto @TheBTI.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/bioengineering-the-ultimate… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The return of the New World screwworm has brought with it an old lesson. Pest control doesn’t have to involve spreading a poison and hoping it reaches the target. Sometimes the best insecticide for the job is one that hatches and flies away, leaving little trace and no descendants."
Read the latest from @danrejto: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/bioengineering-the-ultimate… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
Critical minerals recovery from materials "thrown away" in mine tailings and waste rock has generated a lot of enthusiasm in advocacy and policy circles as an alternative to new mining. Our new analysis led by @PeterCookBTI strives to set more realistic expectations.
Concentrations are often low and well below the range of concentrations typically handled at operating mines and mills. With waste material samples clustering near typical Earth crustal abundance, even assuming innovation has made recovery economically viable at such concentrations, one might as well feed rocks and dirt from any hill in the Rockies into the processing plant. There's nothing particularly special about targeting tailings at that point. 🧵 -
Breakthrough reposted
Fred Stafford
@fredstaffordcs
Part 2 is up at @TheBTI. Part 1 argued fed transmission earns public trust only when anchored to a public resource w/ tangible public benefit, & found the model in the Pacific Intertie. Here's how that template applies to today as a concrete policy program, in a new 🧵. 1/
Fred Stafford
@fredstaffordcs
On Friday @TheBTI posted the first of my new two-part essay on public power and transmission expansion. Part 1 is critique and a highlight of what worked historically with public power. Part 2 puts it together into a proposal. Here’s a 🧵 for the first. 1/ www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-public-power-anchor
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Today’s progressive demands should similarly anchor new interregional transmission to new generation resources for clear public benefit. Now what’s needed is a resource that’s not limited to the last drops of untapped hydropower; one that offers direct benefit to receiving utilities and to the public, as clean, firm power; one that locals love and that can be deployed as an anchor in public power systems across the nation.
America has one resource that fits the bill: nuclear power."
Read @fredstaffordcs for @thebti: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-public-power-anchor-par… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"A system designed to protect public health should distinguish meaningful risk reduction from requirements that consume resources without producing a commensurate safety benefit."
Read the new whitepaper from @thebti's PJ Seel: thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/why-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
From Westinghouse's upcoming IPO to a new technology to pull uranium out of seawater, read what's happening in the nuclear industry and why it matters in Nuclear Notes.
www.nuclearnotes.org/p/a-gigantic-nuclear-ipo-is-coming -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The U.S. cannot rely solely on uncertain recovery pathways that may never materialize or that may only meet a small fraction of national demands. Waste recovery must therefore expand in parallel with policies to support new conventional mining."
Read the policy brief from @PeterCookBTI and @wang_seaver: thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/u-s-critical-mineral-se… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“Environmentalism…erred in connecting our tactile and complex ecophilia to a more global, flattening policy agenda demarcated by global average surface temperature and parts per million.”
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/decoupling-syndrome -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @employamerica to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The proper balance of attention towards home upgrades and the grid at a system level is ultimately simple. Policymakers should cut through red tape to make home upgrades more accessible for Americans that want them while focusing on channeling utility and data center developer capital investments into the shared infrastructure that supports long-term electricity system resiliency and national economic growth."
Read @wang_seaver @RyanAlimento and @atrembath on the limits of home upgrades (electrification and rooftop solar) for responding to electricity demand growth.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/home-upgrades-cant-power-da… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“Environmentalism…erred in connecting our tactile and complex ecophilia to a more global, flattening policy agenda demarcated by global average surface temperature and parts per million.”
My latest for The Ecomodernist:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/decoupling-syndrome -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @ACC_National to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Most Americans, and increasingly most humans, simply don’t need, for their immediate health and well-being, to be aware of local wildlife counts, or wild fish harvests. To the extent these empirics show up meaningfully in the typical person’s live experiences, it’s through many layers of social and technological mediation."
Read the latest from @atrembath for @thebti:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/decoupling-syndrome -
Breakthrough reposted
Fred Stafford
@fredstaffordcs
On Friday @TheBTI posted the first of my new two-part essay on public power and transmission expansion. Part 1 is critique and a highlight of what worked historically with public power. Part 2 puts it together into a proposal. Here’s a 🧵 for the first. 1/ www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-public-power-anchor
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
For every earth-shattering revelation published in the mainstream media, there’s a @TheBTI essay published over a decade prior.
Garett Jones
@GarettJones
Past peak woke
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @EPIConservation to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org: -
Breakthrough reposted
Fred Stafford
@fredstaffordcs
Back in BTI's journal w/ 1st of 2-part essay on what advocates for federal transmission expansion get wrong, w/ history lesson on post-New Deal public power system we ought to learn from but is rarely mentioned. Part 2 will be my concrete program proposal.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"For a federal authority to be trusted with any of this, our vision of public power transmission expansion must be anchored instead to public resources with tangible public benefit—clean, firm power owned and operated at cost that puts people to work. It’ll have to play ball with utilities, too."
Read the first part of @fredstaffordcs's 2-part essay on a new vision for public power and transmission: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-public-power-anchor -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
A bold and important guest essay by fredstafford responds to our TheBTI piece from earlier this year on the federal transmission reform problem. In the first of a two-part series, he points to the Pacific Intertie long-distance transmission project as inspiration for a different model for federally-led transmission infrastructure development. 🧵
I must admit I did not previously know about the Pacific Intertie’s high voltage direct current component—”an HVDC line carrying 1,440 MW across 846 miles—the first HVDC transmission line in the United States and still the longest.”
The below photo is a section of the line running through Washoe County, Nevada: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"For a federal authority to be trusted with any of this, our vision of public power transmission expansion must be anchored instead to public resources with tangible public benefit—clean, firm power owned and operated at cost that puts people to work. It’ll have to play ball with utilities, too."
Read the first part of @fredstaffordcs's 2-part essay on a new vision for public power and transmission: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-public-power-anchor -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The DOE selected Utah, Tennessee, Oklahoma, Louisiana, and Idaho as potential host states for their "Nuclear Lifecycle Innovation Campus" program to build out nuclear fuel reprocessing facilities and other activities across the nuclear supply chain.
To learn more, read Nuclear Notes, our weekly newsletter on what's happening in the nuclear industry, and why it matters:
www.nuclearnotes.org/p/spent-nuclear-fuel-a-hot-potato-looks -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @InclsvAbundance to convene the researches, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
California electricity rates have risen 70-80% since 2018, driven in large part by utilities paying for wildfire mitigation and insurance costs. California policy has effectively turned ratepayers into the de facto insurance fund for the wildfire problem.
Read @lrntex's report for the fix: thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/rewiring-risk -
Breakthrough reposted
Fred Stafford
@fredstaffordcs
Damning rebuttal to a Rewiring America report that will surely be seen as a magic solution.👇
Ryan Alimento
@RyanAlimento
Recent reports from @rewiringamerica argue against new power plants and transmission, since their model (built on factually incorrect assumptions) finds heat pumps and DERs can serve data centers & energy affordability, instead. Here are the most egregious issues: 🧵
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @JoinFAI to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org: -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
New piece by myself + @RyanAlimento @atrembath calls out two recent @rewiringamerica reports overhyping home electrification upgrades (roof solar, home batteries, heat pumps, etc) as the key to accommodating growing U.S. data center power demand and energy affordability.🧵
The methodology is simply bad--like the solar output calculation hidden in the appendices assuming a perfectly south-facing solar array for all houses theoretically suitable for rooftop solar nationwide. -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
We wrote about @rewiringamerica’s home retrofit maximalism, which makes erroneous modeling assumptions to argue against bulk electric power supply investments and for policies that will make housing more expensive.
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
New piece by myself + @RyanAlimento @atrembath calls out two recent @rewiringamerica reports overhyping home electrification upgrades (roof solar, home batteries, heat pumps, etc) as the key to accommodating growing U.S. data center power demand and energy affordability.🧵
The methodology is simply bad--like the solar output calculation hidden in the appendices assuming a perfectly south-facing solar array for all houses theoretically suitable for rooftop solar nationwide. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Policymakers should cut through red tape to make home upgrades more accessible for Americans that want them while focusing on channeling utility and data center developer capital investments into the shared infrastructure that supports long-term electricity system resiliency and national economic growth."
Read the latest from @wang_seaver @RyanAlimento and @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/home-upgrades-cant-power-da… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @IFP to convene the researchers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org -
Breakthrough reposted
Shawn Regan
@Shawn_Regan
We're still not doing enough fuel treatments.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Congress has already demonstrated that it is willing to invest billions in reducing wildfire risk. The next question is whether federal agencies can convert those dollars into completed fuel treatments on the ground."
New from @EmilyJane_Bass, www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/wildfire-mitigation-has-pea…: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Congress has already demonstrated that it is willing to invest billions in reducing wildfire risk. The next question is whether federal agencies can convert those dollars into completed fuel treatments on the ground."
New from @EmilyJane_Bass, www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/wildfire-mitigation-has-pea…: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Earlier this week, the Trump administration signed a nuclear megadeal with Saudi Arabia, that would see US export reactors, and would eventually allow Saudi Arabia to enrich their own uranium.
Learn more about the deal and why it matters from Nuclear Notes: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @yimbyaction to convene the researchers, policymakers, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org: -
Breakthrough reposted
Lauren Teixeira
@lrntex
My report on California’s intertwined wildfire, electricity unaffordability and home insurance crises is out TODAY! I hope you take a peek but if you just want the greatest hits, here is the liability crisis in eleven charts (THREAD):
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
California's electricity bills have risen 70-80% since 2018, in large part due to utility wildfire mitigatin and the state's insurance approach.
A new report from @thebti's @lrntex explains how to bring down electricity bills and increase wildfire resilience:Post not available here, view on X
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Strict liability also hides the true cost of living in fire country. CA Proposition 103 blocks actuarial pricing while subrogation quietly shifts insurers' losses onto electricity bills.
The FAIR Plan (the State-run insurer of last resort) has nearly quadrupled since 2018, while private insurers are dropping out of California.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The fix is four reforms that must move together:
- Replace strict liability with a fault-based standard
- A managed insurance-market transition fro high-risk owners
- A state catastrophe reinsurance backstop
- Fund fuels management through taxpayers, not electricity rates.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
California can keep bills climbing indefinitely, or the State can rebalance liability and bring down both its wildfire exposure and the cost of bearing it.
Read the full report here:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/rewiring-risk
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
And listen to a discussion between @lrntex and @eric_biber about the report and findings here: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/rewiring-risk
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Wildfire liability and ineffectual mitigation are driving electricity rates up in California. The solution: liability reform, insurance market correction, and catastrophe fund capitalization.
New research from @TheBTI's @lrntex. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Electricity bills in California have risen by 70-80% since 2018, in large part due to utility wildfire mitigation and the state's insurance approach.
A new report from @lrntex lays out the problem, and what it will take to fix it. Read here: thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/rewiring-risk -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Observers still describe permitting negotiations as Democrats "trading" NEPA/CWA/NHPA reforms for Republican concessions on transmission and interconnection.
But as @TheBTI's proposals make clear, statutory reforms are a worthwhile pursuit on the merits. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"While the EU’s NGT reforms and the US’s potential overhaul are steps in the right direction, true modernization demands that all genetically engineered products—gene-edited and transgenic alike—be treated the same as conventionally bred crops."
The latest from @EmilyJane_Bass: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @InnovateEconomy to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Congress designed the National Historic Preservation Act in an era of breakneck federal infrastructure development. Now America struggles to build.
New from @TheBTI's Marc Levitt and @3lizabethMcC: how to fix Section 106 for the transmission lines and pipelines we actually need. 🧵
thebreakthrough.org/issues/environmental-regulatory-refor…
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Section 106 works fine for routine projects. It scales poorly for large, multi-state transmission lines and pipelines.
For a thousand-mile line, coordination burdens grow dramatically as the project crosses multiple jurisdictions, sovereigns, and hundreds of miles. The report identified three structural sources of friction:
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Sequencing and path dependency: meaningful tribal consultation often occurs after major routing decisions have already hardened, leaving tribes in a reactive position when options are limited.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Fragmented information and coordination: responsibility is distributed across agencies, tribes, preservation officers, applicants, and courts, each operating under different authorities and timelines.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Scale mismatch: coordination burdens grow dramatically as projects cross multiple jurisdictions, sovereigns, and hundreds of miles.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The consequences are concrete. For example, federal NHPA authority covered only about 37 miles of a 1,168-mile route for the Dakota Access Pipeline, but reviewed it as around 200 separate "crossings."
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
To fix this issue, the report proposes earlier engagement paired with clearer closure. Require corridor-level screening before a preferred route is selected, then give agencies statutory safe harbors and procedural certainty in return.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Done right, these reforms preserve meaningful consultation while aligning Section 106 with the infrastructure needs of the twenty-first century.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Explore the NHPA process and Marc and Elizabeth's finidngs here, which includes a detailed process map of how NHPA works: modernizingpreservation.com/home.html
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
And you can read the full report here: thebreakthrough.org/issues/environmental-regulatory-refor…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Elizabeth McCarthy
@3lizabethMcC
Large transmission lines and pipelines have to clear a historic-preservation review that wasn't designed for projects of their size.
Our new @TheBTI report shows how to fix that —without gutting tribal consultation. Site to explore it below. 🧵 -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
For a new @TheBTI policy proposal, we mapped the compliance process for Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act:
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Read Marc Levitt and @3lizabethMcC’s “Modernizing Preservation: Fixing the National Historic Preservation Act for Linear Infrastructure.”
New @TheBTI:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/environmental-regulatory-refor… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The National Historic Preservation Act Section 106 functions for routine projects, but it scales poorly for large, multi-state transmission lines, pipelines, and other linear infrastructure.
The current system ends up failing everyone: tribes get consulted after routes harden, agencies face unclear standards and litigation, developers hit late-stage uncertainty after major investments. A better design helps all three.
Read the new report from @thebti's Marc Levitt and @3lizabethMcC:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/environmental-regulatory-refor… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @metroabundance to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Poor households need safe, reliable, and affordable energy now. Where grids are reliable and power is affordable, cooking can be done with electric cookstoves. But until those options are broadly available, rejecting liquefied petroleum gas can leave families dependent on fuels that are more dangerous for health and often worse for local forests."
The latest from the Ecomodernist:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/a-practical-climate-test-cl… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Read and subscribe to Nuclear Notes, our weekly newsletter that explains what's happening in the world of nuclear power, and why it matters.
www.nuclearnotes.org/p/keeping-nuclear-cool-in-texas -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @ClearPathAction to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org: -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"There is hubris on both sides of that divide. The climate movement remains far too confident that catastrophic framings of the issue will not only result in climate action but the sort of climate action that the movement has in mind. Geoengineering advocacy, meanwhile, simply assumes a level of technocratic competence that is nowhere to be found."
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Once you decide that human control of the climate is desirable, not a sin against nature, the desire to geoengineer becomes hard to resist."
Read @TedNordhaus's latest, on Solar Geoengineering: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-i-oppose-solar-geoengin… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The Reactor Pilot Program delivered four criticality events by the July 4th deadline.
@Aalonomics @valaratomics @AntaresNuclear and @DeployableE all successfully built and powered prototypes that will give them critical information as they build towards commercial reactors.
Read @Dr_A_Stein and @stoohill13's breakdown of the Reactor Pilot Program and what the milestone means for U.S. nuclear: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/from-paper-to-real-life-rea… -
Breakthrough reposted
John Stossel
@JohnStossel
Trump has ordered regulators to fast-track new nuclear plants.
Democratic senators call that dangerous.
“That's just a bunch of crap," says Ray Rothrock of @TheBTI, "They're afraid of something they don't need to be afraid of.”
My video below covers some of their fears:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Breakthrough reposted
Lauren Teixeira
@lrntex
I'll bite! "Natural Disaster Insurance for All" is decidedly not the answer! Such a program would be wasteful, duplicative and ineffective in achieving wildfire risk reduction. (THREAD)
Kainoa Lowman
@klowmn
Property insurers are fleeing California due to wildfire risk. Could "Natural Disaster Insurance for All" be the answer?
I spoke with the candidate winning over voters with this idea—and with her critics—for @monthly.
washingtonmonthly.com/2026/07/13/jane-kim-california-home… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @PERCtweets to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
There is now more than 70 GW of planned new nuclear capacity in the United States. Hyperscaler projects account for about 45% of that.
If even a fraction of this proposed capacity is deployed, it would mark a historic turnaround for the U.S. nuclear industry. -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
Thanks to fast-growing electricity demand, especially from AI data centers, the pipeline for new nuclear energy is rapidly growing. There is 74GW of planned new nuclear reactor capacity in the United States. Hyperscalers account for about 45% of the matrix of orderbooks.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Over 70 gigawatts of nuclear in the pipeline, most of it for non-light water reactors, and mostly for hyperscalers and data centers.
New analysis from @TheBTI’s @joyjiang1997: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with Abundance Network to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"That much of America’s roadways, bridges, and buildings are more than 50 years old means that they are aging, not historic."
But, according to the National Historic Preservation Act, all of those 50+ year old sites require review when the Federal Government wants to make improvements.
Reforming NHPA is fundamental to building the next generation of American infrastructure.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/everything-is-becoming-hist… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Using the epithet “climate husher” is an attempt to bring the era of the climate hawk back into being.
It won’t work.
My latest:
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Climate hushing reflects a reaction to the very real material developments that have occurred since climate change came to occupy such a prominent place in Democrats’ issue prioritization."
Read the latest from @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-climate-hushing-is-comi… -
Breakthrough reposted
Steffan Szumowski
@UnoMasReactor
Nuclear Notes has some of the best insight on current industry stories and updates
Skipping their newsletter puts you behind the curve for staying at pace with the nuclear renaissance
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Read and subscribe to Nuclear Notes, our weekly newsletter that explains what's happening in the world of nuclear power, and why it matters.
www.nuclearnotes.org/p/the-odd-couple-uranium-and-silicon -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Read and subscribe to Nuclear Notes, our weekly newsletter that explains what's happening in the world of nuclear power, and why it matters.
www.nuclearnotes.org/p/the-odd-couple-uranium-and-silicon -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with the Welcoming Neighbors Network to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Climate hushing reflects a reaction to the very real material developments that have occurred since climate change came to occupy such a prominent place in Democrats’ issue prioritization."
Read the latest from @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-climate-hushing-is-comi… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with Students for Abundance to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"More money won’t fix process design flaws; we need to rethink how much these regulations are helping to preserve our cultural identity and how much they’re impairing efforts to build a better future."
Read @3lizabethMcC: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/everything-is-becoming-hist… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
As producers of Abundance 2026, @thebti is proud to partner with @PubEnterprise to convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The Reactor Pilot Program was not meant to produce commercial nuclear plants by the Fourth of July. It was meant to help restore a missing process in nuclear innovation: building, testing, learning, and improving before moving to commercial scale."
www.nuclearnotes.org/p/the-reactor-pilot-program-meets-the -
Breakthrough reposted
Jordan Bramble
@jordanbramble
Really appreciate how pragmatic @TheBTI has been in their analysis of the DOE program. These are incredible milestones provided they are advancing towards real commercial deployment of viable systems.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The more important question is whether the Reactor Pilot Program helped the United States rebuild a practical innovation cycle for nuclear energy."
Read @Dr_A_Stein and @stoohill13 on what achieving the July 4 criticality deadline really means: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/from-paper-to-real-life-rea… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Did you hear that Valar, Antares, and Deployable went critical this month?
@TheBTI's @Dr_A_Stein and @stoohill13 break it down at The Ecomodernist:
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The more important question is whether the Reactor Pilot Program helped the United States rebuild a practical innovation cycle for nuclear energy."
Read @Dr_A_Stein and @stoohill13 on what achieving the July 4 criticality deadline really means: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/from-paper-to-real-life-rea… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
We @thebti are proud to co-produce Abundance 2026 alongside @NiskanenCenter where we will convene the researchers, policymakers, entrepreneurs, and civic leaders shaping America's growth.
Learn more at abundancedc.org. -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
From Paper to Real-Life Reactors: The Holistic View of the Reactor Pilot Program
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The more important question is whether the Reactor Pilot Program helped the United States rebuild a practical innovation cycle for nuclear energy."
Read @Dr_A_Stein and @stoohill13 on what achieving the July 4 criticality deadline really means: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/from-paper-to-real-life-rea… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Visualize and understand the geography of America's nuclear future with a new interactive map created by @joyjiang1997 and @Dr_A_Stein:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/mapp… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The World Bank announced on Monday that it will sunset its 45% climate finance target.
It's about time. The target distorted the Bank's mission and skewed its funding away from poverty reduction.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/its-time-for-the-world-bank… -
Breakthrough reposted
Lauren Teixeira
@lrntex
Me and @danrejto are, once again, asking CA to reconsider a climate program that makes gas more expensive while *at best* doing nothing for climate
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The LCFS adds nearly 20 cents per gallon of gas and even more to diesel, but delivers little discernable benefit to Californians."
Read the latest from @danrejto and @lrntex:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/californias-hidden-gas-tax-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The LCFS adds nearly 20 cents per gallon of gas and even more to diesel, but delivers little discernable benefit to Californians."
Read the latest from @danrejto and @lrntex:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/californias-hidden-gas-tax-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The idea is to build up the supply chain for reactor vessels, steam generators, reactor coolant pumps, and other big parts, and to lower the cost of those components by encouraging suppliers to tool up to build multiple copies."
Read and subscribe to Nuclear Notes (link below)
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Check it out here: nuclearnotes.substack.com/p/us-will-finance-hardware-for-ten
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Intensive animal agriculture has lower emissions, uses less land, and has more room for welfare improvement than its regenerative or pastured alternatives.
You can't defend industrial food without defending industrial meat.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/you-cant-defend-industrial-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Why does China dominate titanium, rare earths, and battery-grade nickel? Cheap debt.
The higher the upfront CAPEX per ton, the smaller the West's share of global production.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-capex-challenge-is-key-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
If you want to accelerate AP1000 builds, this is the path that leads down the cost curve. DOE loan guarantees, order in bulk to reduce total cost, build in pairs, use the few existing sites, order ahead to start long-lead item manufacture.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
For more than a decade, development dollars were diverted from health, agriculture, and infrastructure to "climate" with little appreciable impact on emissions.
It's beyond time for the World Bank to reconsider its climate targets: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/its-time-for-the-world-bank… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Scrapping the 45 percent target will enable the World Bank to focus on investments in agriculture, energy, and infrastructure, to meet the needs of households and businesses, and help poor countries deliver much-needed services."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/its-time-for-the-world-bank… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"How quickly the United States can deploy a new generation of advanced nuclear reactors will depend in large part on whether the NRC can license them efficiently and at scale."
Subscribe to Nuclear Notes (Link below):
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Subscribe here: nuclearnotes.substack.com/p/how-to-make-the-numbers-work-for
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Unfortunately for its critics, industrial meat production is the only way to produce enough meat and dairy products without accelerating the deforestation of wild lands or driving up food prices."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/you-cant-defend-industrial-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The higher the capital expenditure (CAPEX) per ton of annual metal output, the smaller the share of global production of that metal by advanced economies other than Russia or China."
The way to fix that imbalance: low-cost debt.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-capex-challenge-is-key-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
The relative lack of new critical minerals processing in high-income countries stems from a high capital cost feedback. High capital costs depress internal rate of return, disincentivizing projects. Growing lack of plant development experience and technical know-how, over decades, worsens the CAPEX problem. 🧵
We find a rough decreasing relationship between metallurgical plant CAPEX/ton and the share of global production ex-China and ex-Russia.
The most powerful policy solution is low-cost debt finance.
New guest piece for @TheBTI from Matt Helligg—a metallurgical industry engineer—myself, and @RyanAlimento. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Subscribe to Nuclear Notes, a weekly breakdown of what's happening in nuclear industry, technology, and policy.
nuclearnotes.substack.com -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"With changes, Part 57 can become a durable and effective licensing framework because it is more focused, not because it is less rigorous."
Read @thebti's comment on NRC Part 57: thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/part… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"@TheBTI urges the NRC to make clear that Part 57's central purpose is high-volume licensing, not a technology category, and to ensure its eligibility criteria, security requirements, environmental review, and emergency planning are calibrated to demonstrated risk and administrable at scale."
All 110 pages of our public comment on the NRC's proposed Part 57 rule for licensing micro and factory fabricated reactors.👇 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"For all the talk of feedbacks in the climate system, we’re not very good at thinking about, much less modeling, feedbacks in our socio-economic systems."
Read @TedNordhaus's latest: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/rich-world-poor-world -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Antares Nuclear's Mark-0 became the first under the DOE Reactor Pilot Program to achieve criticality ahead of the July 4 deadline.
Learn what the prototype actually means, and what it does not: nuclearnotes.substack.com/p/a-big-step-for-small-reactors -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Thanks to @DC_Hartman and @MichaelGiberso3 for responding to @TheBTI essay on use of transmission reform as a pathway to stealth electricity deregulation. Very happy to have this debate and to engage different perspectives on this question. We are all better for it.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Better transmission policy improves service to customers in vertically integrated territories, restructured markets, and hybrid models alike."
Read @MichaelGiberso3 and @DC_Hartman's response to @thebti's "Stealth Deregulation" argument: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/a-defense-of-utility-deregu…
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Read @TedNordhaus @wang_seaver and @RyanAlimento's original argument here: thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/dont-let-stealth-deregu…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
Today we're publishing a response by @MichaelGiberso3 and @DC_Hartman, "A Defense of Utility Deregulation," which pushes back against our earlier piece by @TedNordhaus, @RyanAlimento and myself ("Don’t Let Stealth Deregulation Sink Permitting Reform")
Have always been proud of how @TheBTI's commitment to upfront public debate--surfacing competing views in tension that otherwise simmer unresolved beneath polite professional interactions--can advance discussion. This exchange is the latest expression of that philosophy in action, and certainly won't be the last!
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/a-defense-of-utility-deregu… -
Breakthrough reposted
Michael Giberson
@MichaelGiberso3
Breakthrough posted an article a few weeks back asserting that permitting reform was a kind of "stealth deregulation." @DC_Hartman and I disagreed with the piece on several points. Breakthrough published our response at The Ecomodernist via Substack. (Short🧵; link in next.)
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Smith
@alexjmssmith
I have been thinking a lot about the politics of meat lately, thanks, in large part, to @jan_dutkiewicz and @gnrosenberg's new book Feed the People. My take: industrial meat is here to stay, we need to embrace it and improve it: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/you-cant-defend-industrial-…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"If technologically advanced, large-scale, highly capitalized production provide the solutions to the problems caused by agriculture in general, why would they not also provide the solutions to the problems caused by animal agriculture in particular?"
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/you-cant-defend-industrial-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
⚛️ Nuclear Newsletter Announcement ⚛️
Subscribe to NUCLEAR NOTES, @TheBTI’s new weekly newsletter on the latest news in nuclear policy, politics, and industrial development.
nuclearnotes.substack.com -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Antares Nuclear hit initial criticality on June 4 at Idaho National Lab. We explain what this means and why this matters in the first issue of Nuclear Notes on Substack.
You can subscribe for new issues every Thursday (link in comments):
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Read and subscribe here: nuclearnotes.substack.com/p/a-big-step-for-small-reactors
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Without data on denials, timelines, conditions, project types, and agency practices, Congress cannot know which reform would solve the problem."
Read Marc Levitt and @3lizabethMcC on the data challenges to reforming Clean Water Act Section 401:thebreakthrough.org/issues/environmental-regulatory-refor… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
We are very excited to be partnering with @NiskanenCenter to co-host Abundance 2026, along with a growing coalition of partners.
Save the date! -
Breakthrough reposted
David Wallace-Wells
@dwallacewells
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"For all the talk of feedbacks in the climate system, we’re not very good at thinking about, much less modeling, feedbacks in our socio-economic systems."
RCP 8.5, IPAT, and Climate Impacts Reconsidered. My latest @TheBTI The Ecomodernist. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"I have increasingly come to the view that human societies will be more resilient to climate extremes in a rich world with 5C of warming than a poor world with 2C of warming. But neither of these futures is particularly likely."
Read @TedNordhaus: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/rich-world-poor-world -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Nuclear energy is Japan’s way out of the Hobson’s choice between continuing its heavy dependence on imported fossil fuels and mortgaging its energy future to China."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/caught-between-hormuz-and-a… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Thrilled to announce Abundance 2026!
Produced by @TheBTI and @NiskanenCenter with our growing coalition of partners in the abundance movement.
December 10-11 in Washington, DC. Stay tuned for more info... -
Breakthrough reposted
Elizabeth McCarthy
@3lizabethMcC
Stop vibes-based policymaking. The Clean Water Act's 401 certification process is a mess, and almost nobody can tell you exactly how or why.
Real reform starts with understanding how a law failed and what it cost us, not just with the urge to change it.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Without data on denials, timelines, conditions, project types, and agency practices, Congress cannot know which reform would solve the problem."
Read Marc Levitt and @3lizabethMcC on the data challenges to reforming Clean Water Act Section 401:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/environmental-regulatory-refor… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Last week, Antares Nuclear announced that its Mark-0 reactor reached criticality as part of the Department of Energy's Reactor Pilot Program.
This is a big step forward, and a welcome early success for a program with plenty of potential: thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/maki… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Without data on denials, timelines, conditions, project types, and agency practices, Congress cannot know which reform would solve the problem."
Read Marc Levitt and @3lizabethMcC on the data challenges to reforming Clean Water Act Section 401:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/environmental-regulatory-refor… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The DOE Reactor Pilot Program "can establish a model for how the U.S. develops, tests, and validates new nuclear technologies—proving that America can once again build nuclear reactors the way Ford builds trucks: by learning and iterating."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/building-nuclear-reactors-t… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Genetic engineering could give American chestnut trees disease resistance and restore the keystone species to Eastern forests... and assisted reproduction technology could rescue the Northern white rhinoceros from the brink of extinction."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/biotechnology-is-a-powerful… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
The @AntaresNuclear reactor is the first reactor in the DOE reactor pilot program to reach criticality. This is a milestone!
Jordan Bramble
@jordanbramble
Antares Mark-0 has achieved initial criticality! ⚛️
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“Secular progressives’ attempts to displace ancient anthropocentric theology with ecocentric climate scientism failed. Something new is happening now.”
Read @atrembath: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/magnifica-anthropocene -
Breakthrough reposted
Matt Huber
@Matthuber78
By relentlessly trying to block industrial development, the climate mvmt has been antagonizing the very industrial workers we need to build new energy infrastructure for a generation! It's not working!
Please read @Leigh_Phillips's classic piece on this. thebreakthrough.org/journal/no-15-winter-2022/unions-labo… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"After a decade plus of haltingly slow approvals, nuclear generation is now back up to over 9% of Japan’s electricity. That’s still a far cry from close to 30% prior to Fukushima."
Read @TedNordhaus's latest: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/caught-between-hormuz-and-a… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"Nuclear energy is Japan’s way out of the Hobson’s choice between continuing its heavy dependence on imported fossil fuels and mortgaging its energy future to China."
New @TheBTI The Ecomodernist on Japan's difficult energy choices. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
We're quickly approaching the July 4 deadline to achieve criticality in three prototype advanced reactors under the DoE Pilot Program.
If the program succeeds, it could establish a model for how the U.S. develops and validates new nuclear technologies. thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/maki… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Every $ the US invests in public agricultural research returns $20 in social value.
So, naturally, USDA R&D funding has declined by 1/3 since the early 2000s, a trend that will continue under the proposed Farm Bill. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/public-agricultural-researc… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Climate hawks simultaneously tied their fate to a phantasmic permanent Democratic majority and made demands upon it that hastened its decline."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-era-of-the-climate-hawk… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"EA seems to grapple very seriously with the human condition. Environmentalism... is dismissive, taking for granted that humans are merely upright apes. And it’s in EA’s and environmentalism’s respective reactions to the Pope that this contrast becomes stark."
Read @atrembath:
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Read the post here: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/magnifica-anthropocene
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“Secular progressives’ attempts to displace ancient anthropocentric theology with ecocentric climate scientism failed. Something new is happening now.”
My reaction to Pope Leo’s AI encyclical @TheBTI: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Every aluminum smelter in the world runs on a process invented in 1886. Every ton of ammonia is made by a process invented in 1913.
Heavy industry doesn't get disrupted often. It's important to look at cases of when it does: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/what-drives-innovation-in-h… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
There are 7 genetically engineered foods available for purchase in the United States.
This is not because the technology doesn't exist, but because regulatory oversight is so slow and costly it disincentivizes new product development.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/u… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The United States needs a regulatory system that protects health and safety in a way that is credible, predictable, timely, and proportionate with actual risk."
Read or watch @Dr_A_Stein's testimony before Senate EPW last week: thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/nrc-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
One year ago this week, Trump signed four executive orders aimed at building out America's nuclear resurgence.
We @thebti assessed the EOs the day after they were signed, most of what we flagged remains true today: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/can-trump-expedite-a-nuclea… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
One of Australia's first high-pressure acid leaching plants exhausted the entire available supply of sulfuric acid in Western Australia.
The story of how a process invented during WWII finally commercialized — 80 years later — in Indonesia: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/what-drives-innovation-in-h… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Congress has already provided substantial direction to modernize the NRC through legislation, and the NRC has begun to make visible progress. But modernization will ultimately be judged by implementation."
Read @Dr_A_Stein testimony to Senate EPW: thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/nrc-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“Successful NRC modernization will be measured by whether the United States has created a regulatory system capable of enabling the safe deployment of nuclear technology.”
From @TheBTI’s @Dr_A_Stein’s testimony before the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works. -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
A titanic, thought-provoking new piece from my colleague @RyanAlimento on technology transitions in industrial metallurgy--a sector where new processes are born and commercialized only on rare occasions.
Ryan dives into the origins of the rotary kiln electric furnace (RKEF) route for nickel pig iron (NPI), and the high-pressure acid leaching (HPAL) for producing battery-grade nickel and cobalt compounds from nickel ores, key factors in Indonesia's ascendance as a major nickel refiner. 🧵
Below shows a satellite imagery time lapse Ryan made of Obi Island Industrial Park (North Maluku, Indonesia) from Dec. 2015 to Mar. 2026 -
Breakthrough reposted
Ryan Alimento
@RyanAlimento
New from me w/ @theBTI
Disruptive innovation in heavy industry is exceedingly rare; we still smelt aluminum and make ammonia using 100+ y/o processes. To reindustrialize, decarbonize, and grow the economy, we must formally study what drives innovation in heavy industry 🧵 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Earth MRI is key for stimulating private sector investment in the U.S. and identifying prospective new deposits that can help change the nation's position in the global resource picture.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/congress-should-fund-th… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Without empirical process knowledge, risk-tolerant capital, secure demand, and abundant infrastructure, even early-stage technologies with tremendous promise may continue to fall short of their commercial ambitions."
Read @RyanAlimento: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/what-drives-innovation-in-h… -
Breakthrough reposted
Deric Tilson
@econpragmatist
Senate Environment and Public Works Subcommittee meeting this morning. Patrick White @cleanaircatf, @NiconomistLoris from C3, and @Dr_A_Stein @TheBTI providing testimony.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Rescuing elemental functions of NEPA now requires doing what the statute never did: guaranteeing meaningful public participation while constraining the litigation dynamics that threaten development."
thebreakthrough.org/issues/environmental-regulatory-refor… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The U.S. Critical Minerals list now has 60 entries. And it keeps growing.
The goal over the next decade can't be to add more. It should be to take minerals off.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/the-critical-minerals-p… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"But with the benefit of hindsight, it’s clear that the IRA was not the beginning of something but the end of it. The political, economic, and cultural conditions that allowed for climate hawks’ advances over the last decade simply no longer hold."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-era-of-the-climate-hawk… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The Democratic Party is broken precisely because its educated base and powerful donor class have demanded that it move the climate issue to the center of its core political value proposition whether or not the average voter much cares about the problem."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/who-killed-the-liberal-patriot -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
In the 1960s, US electricity demand grew 8% annually. Transmission tripled in a decade.
Today, interconnection takes six or more years. To understand the challenge facing the American grid, we need to understand its history.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-the-grid-is-lagging-beh… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The House will vote on year-round E15 on Wednesday.
Supporters frame it as "energy independence." But, in reality, it's a policy that puts 1/3 of US corn into fuel tanks, raises food prices, and drives cropland expansion.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/biofuel-policy-is-failing-c… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"If Washington wants a more productive and more competitive farm sector, it should rebuild agricultural research around the problems farmers actually face."
Read @danrejto's latest for @thebti: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/public-agricultural-researc… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
60 minerals are now on the U.S. Critical Minerals list.
The goal of federal policy should be to remove minerals from that list, not keep adding to it.
Learn about how to make critical mineral policy work: thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/the-critical-minerals-p… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The environmental movement may be the wealthiest social movement in human history. It funds NGOs, academia, and Democratic PACs.
That's one reason climate dissent is costly: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/who-killed-the-liberal-patriot -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission isn't too cautious. It's structurally broken.
@Dr_A_Stein on why a regulator built to optimize one objective (Safety), struggles to regulate when it's required to weigh nuclear's benefits to society: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-nrcs-problem-isnt-cauti… -
Breakthrough reposted
Russ Greene
@GreenPlusAnE
Left wing elites cling harder to climate orthodoxy than to any other belief, including gender, race and immigration.
Why?
1. Appeals to “the science”
2. $$$$
I would add: it’s an effective excuse for global governance, the real telos of elite leftism. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The most polarized input to agriculture, Glyphosate, has delivered net environmental benefits.
It displaced more toxic herbicides. It made no-till farming possible. And it led to declines in erosion, fuel use, and even emissions.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/glyphosates-environmental-b… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
The Liberal Patriot published contentious takes on DEI, immigration, trans issues, Gaza, and more.
But it was when they challenged Democratic climate orthodoxy that they always got in trouble.
@TedNordhaus and I explain the death of The Liberal Patriot (link below). -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"When environmental leaders and donors say that a particular set of facts is unhelpful, what they mean is not just that it is unhelpful to their advocacy objectives but also that it is immaterial to their broader truth."
Read @atrembath and @TedNordhaus: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/who-killed-the-liberal-patriot -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The IRA was not the beginning of something but the end of it."
With the growing focus on energy affordability and security, it's even more important today to understand @atrembath's argument from last march: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-era-of-the-climate-hawk… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The biggest challenge the nuclear sector faces today is from within.
Read @TedNordhaus on five key "pro-nuclear, but" myths: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/five-pro-nuclear-but-myths -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The NRC's new proposed Part 57 licensing pathway does something new: it tries to match regulatory burden to actual risk.
Read @Dr_A_Stein on what it gets right, and what still needs work: thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/part… -
Breakthrough reposted
Steffan Szumowski
@UnoMasReactor
If you’re trying to understand Part 57 and the impact it will have on microreactor licensing and deployment, then you should be reading this! 👇
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The NRC’s proposed new licensing framework, called Part 57, tests whether nuclear regulation can do something it often says it wants to do: match regulatory burden to actual risk."
Read @Dr_A_Stein for @thebti:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/part… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
Licensing microreactors and other low-consequence reactors took a major step. The NRC published a new proposed framework, called Part 57. I outline some of the major provisions here. The rule is open for public comment for the next 45 days. thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/part…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The NRC’s proposed new licensing framework, called Part 57, tests whether nuclear regulation can do something it often says it wants to do: match regulatory burden to actual risk."
Read @Dr_A_Stein for @thebti:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/part… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Climatic conditions and a build up of hazardous fuels are primary drivers of this year’s worrying start. But, Trump may be fanning the flames."
Read @EmilyJane_Bass: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/trumps-reorganization-adds-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Climate activists keep warning that US crop yields are falling.
USDA's latest forecast: record-high corn and soybean yields for 2025.
But yield growth is slowing due to steady declines in public ag R&D. That must change: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/are-us-crop-yields-declining -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
40 years ago, anti-nuclear voices warned the next reactor accident would prove the industry too dangerous.
Since then, we've learned containment works. Some still won't admit it.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-public-confidence-game -
Breakthrough reposted
Peter Cook
@PeterCookBTI
Excited to share an op-ed by @wang_seaver and myself in @heatmap_news on the state of play of critical mineral policy in Congress
The gist: Democratic policymakers need to get more sophisticated with their critical mineral strategy
heatmap.news/ideas/democrats-critical-minerals -
Breakthrough reposted
Isaiah Menning
@IsaiahMenning
Humility in the use of technology and love for neighbor and the Creation also show up on the dominion ecology of PROJECT HAIL MARY.
In @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-dominion-ecology-of-pro… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Diablo Canyon 2045!
@TheBTI is proud to join a coalition of partners dedicated to extending operations at California's last nuclear plant through 2045.
diablocanyon2045.com -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Every $1 of public ag R&D returns about $20 in social value. And yet, USDA R&D funding has fallen by a third since 2000.
As the Farm Bill heads to a House floor vote, the research title has the highest return, and the smallest political constituency: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/agricultural-research-needs… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
New from myself & @PeterCookBTI in @heatmap_news
“Democrats must start alleviating national critical mineral constraints now, in the middle of a Trump presidency, to position the U.S. industrial base to produce impressive economic and technological results in 2028 and beyond.” -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Stronger congressional oversight and robust environmental and human rights safeguards are worthy Democratic goals, but advancing them requires that Congress do its job and legislate."
Read @wang_seaver and @PeterCookBTI in @heatmap_news: heatmap.news/ideas/democrats-critical-minerals -
Breakthrough reposted
Heatmap News
@heatmap_news
Democrats need a real critical minerals policy — beyond just opposing Trump, @wang_seaver
and @PeterCookBTI of
@TheBTI argue in an op-ed.
Read more:
heatmap.news/ideas/democrats-critical-minerals -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Banning glyphosate sounds clean. The reality is messier.
If glyphosate disappears, farmers don't switch to nothing. They switch back to older, more toxic herbicides. Harmful substitution is the real risk.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/04/25/roundup-isnt-h… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
SCOTUS heard oral arguments in Monsanto v. Durnell today, a case that could reshape glyphosate regulation.
Glyphosate isn't harmless, but it's better for farmers, people, and the environment than the alternatives.
Read @danrejto: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/04/25/roundup-isnt-h… -
Breakthrough reposted
Val Giddings
@prometheusgreen
Will Climate Change Really Take Away Our Breakfast? open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/will-clima… A Recent High-Profile Nature Paper Doesn’t Say What Its Authors Say it Does
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"The 'pro-nuclear but' camp is genuinely pro-nuclear but typically argues for policy and technology that represent little change from the status quo that has been responsible for a generation of decline and stagnation."
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The biggest challenge the nuclear sector faces today, in my view, comes from within."
Read @TedNordhaus on the key myths of the "pro-nuclear but..." crowd: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/five-pro-nuclear-but-myths -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Driving less harmful farming inputs off the market won’t make people safer or food healthier. Improving these tools will."
Read @danrejto's latest in the Washington Post: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/04/25/roundup-isnt-h… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The biggest challenge the nuclear sector faces today, in my view, comes from within."
Read @TedNordhaus on the key myths of the "pro-nuclear but..." crowd: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/five-pro-nuclear-but-myths -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"The “pro-nuclear but” camp is genuinely pro-nuclear but typically argues for policy and technology that represent little change from the status quo that has been responsible for a generation of decline and stagnation—reactors that no one has been willing to build and regulations that have stifled innovation."
New post @TheBTI The Ecomodernist. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The impulse is millenarian, not meliorist."
Read @TedNordhaus on the worldview underpinning contemporary climate politics, and why a more pragmatic environmentalism is both necessary and possible.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-i-stopped-being-a-clima… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Will climate change starve the world? Only if technological innovation completely stops.
Global cereal yields are up 215% since 1961 despite a degree of warming. Climate will produce headwinds, to be sure, but adaptation and innovation can persist.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/will-climate-change-really-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
In more than a decade we have not broken ground on a new commercial nuclear project and now we have two under way. www.wsj.com/business/energy-oil/americas-first-commercial…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
About a year ago, a common critique of physical warehousing of critical minerals was their ostensibly short shelf life--the worry that gallium or lithium would "go bad".
Our @TheBTI report to the contrary from last July can now be compared against an @IEA short analysis from a couple months ago that generally agree on the feasibility of physical stockpiling of most critical commodities in practice.
The @IEA is more pessimistic than we were on the reactivity and shelf life of the battery salts cobalt sulfate, manganese sulfate, and nickel sulfate. We are more pessimistic than they are on the ability to store rare earth metals, and we did not consider the ability to simply stockpile magnets (probably best stored as uncut magnet blocks, but this precludes protective nickel coating which poses a shelf life consideration).
But that's it--that's the extent of any differences in interpretation. We agreed on the vast majority of commodities covered in both publications. We agreed on a 6-month shelf life for lithium hydroxide that is much longer for lithium carbonate. Our organizations independently concurred that storage of most commodities is manageable. -
Breakthrough reposted
Peter Cook
@PeterCookBTI
We need to get more specific with our critical mineral strategy.
Thats why @TheBTI put together our report that maps out the best strategy for different commodities based on factors like supply chain gaps, geologic resources, and technical barriers 🧵
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/the-critical-minerals-p… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
We need nuclear energy to meet growing energy demand and reduce global greenhouse gas emissions.
But the Nuclear Regulatory Commission still lacks the decision architecture to consider nuclear energy's benefits to society:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-nrcs-problem-isnt-cauti… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The U.S. Critical Minerals list now has 60 entries. And it keeps growing.
The goal over the next decade can't be to add more. It should be to take minerals off.
A new @thebti report lays out how:Post not available here, view on X
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Or, consider molybdenum. The U.S. is a net exporter, but the American downstream supply chain for powder and oxide has withered.
Mining leadership is only part of the critical mineral story.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Critical mineral supply chain security can not be solved with any one policy. @wang_seaver @PeterCookBTI and @RyanAlimento show that it's dozens of different problems, with dozens of different solutions.
Learn more, read the report: thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/the-critical-minerals-p… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
If you have felt overwhelmed by questions over what the U.S. should do to alleviate its critical mineral supply vulnerabilities, this new publication from my @theBTI team is for you. We outline top mineral-by-mineral priorities for the U.S. to take action on. 🧵
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
It's Earth Day today. Here's some good news:
Despite 1.5C of warming over the last century, global mortality from climate and weather extremes has fallen by a factor of 25 or more on a per capita basis.
Read @TedNordhaus: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-i-stopped-being-a-clima… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
This April, @Securing_Energy is hosting senior industry and government leaders in D.C. to drive conversations on embracing energy abundance, rebuilding America’s industrial base, and securing critical supply chains.
Register for #safesummit2026: safesummit.org -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
California drivers have paid around $18B for biofuels under the Low Carbon Fuel Standard, but with no net emissions reduction.
Instead, the bio-diesel Californians were forced to pay for drove 1.7M hectares of forest loss in S.E. Asia:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/california-should-stop-forc… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
U.S. electricity demand is rising for the first time in ~30 years, and the grid can't keep up. Interconnection now takes 6+ years.
This isn't just an engineering problem, it's also a governance problem almost a century in the making:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-the-grid-is-lagging-beh… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
Just did a back-of-envelope this morning based on a global solarmaxxing scenario of 277 terawatts of solar capacity covering 6% of global land area, and I feel this still doesn't likely exhaust global silver or tin resources.
831,000 tons of silver assuming a future 3 mg/W
11 million tons of tin assuming 40 tons/GW
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
In a 2023 paper, I wrote that among minerals used in solar panels + wind farms, hard limits might only appear for tellurium, used in CdTe thin-film PV. A new paper suggests our 50 GW/yr tellurium limit was too pessimistic, giving a roadmap to 100 GW/yr.
I think they're right. -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Solar panels and wind turbines are cheap, and their fuel is free. So why are electricity prices rising?
My latest for @thedispatch:
thedispatch.com/newsletter/dispatch-energy/solar-wind-ren… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
Re-sharing this article. It is timely as the NRC is working through revising not only its regulations, but also internal processes. It would best serve the public if they considered not only what needs to be decided, but also how to make those decisions. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-nrcs-problem-isnt-cauti…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
China consumed 56% of all coal used globally in 2024. Coal still generates 59% of its electricity. New coal-powered smelters and petrochemical plants are being built right now.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/greenwashing-with-chinese-c… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Elon Musk says AI data centers will be in space within 30 months.
Meta's Llama 3 training saw 419 unplanned interruptions in 54 days—on Earth. Now add cosmic radiation, zero-gravity cooling, and tripled hardware redundancy.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/data-centers-wont-be-in-spa… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
California drivers a paying a premium to subsidize biofuels already mandated by the Federal Renewable Fuel Standard through the Low Carbon Fuel Standard.
Ironically, that may actually lower emissions from CA drivers. Read @danrejto and @lrntex:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/paying-extra-for-biofuels-t… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The real risk of AI is not that machines will make mistakes. It is that, as we grow accustomed to relying on them, we may become less likely to notice when they do."
Read @Dr_A_Stein:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/when-the-machine-is-usually… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
By volume & absolute magnitude of electricity consumption, aluminum deserves its reputation as "congealed electricity".
But from a electricity/ton perspective, aluminum is hardly the only congealed electricity commodity.
From my "The Aluminum Tech Stack" piece a few weeks ago: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The NRC’s final Part 53 rule is not perfect, but it is a real step forward.
@Dr_A_Stein and @stoohill13 break down the good, the bad, and the new, of the final rule:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/part… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Part 53 provides a better pathway for advanced reactor licensing, but does not go far enough to create certainty for advanced reactor developers or ensure that benefits to society are considered in reactor licensing."
Read @Dr_A_Stein and @stoohill13:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/part… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Elon Musk says that within 30 months, space will be the most economically compelling place for AI data centers.
He's wrong, explains, @RyanAlimento:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/data-centers-wont-be-in-spa… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Despite what you may hear, glyphosate delivers net environmental benefits, largely by displacing more toxic herbicides and enabling farming practices that reduce soil erosion, water and air pollution, energy use, and crop losses.
Read @danrejto:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/glyphosates-environmental-b… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
California's Low Carbon Fuel Standard program has a paradox: when it fails to incentivize new biofuels, it just overcharges drivers. When it succeeds, it pays to make emissions worse.
New from @danrejto and @lrntex:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/paying-extra-for-biofuels-t… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
After a series of judicial decisions and White House recissions, the NEPA that Democrats are defending no longer exists.
Dems need permitting reform legislation.
via @TheBTI’s Marc Levitt:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/environmental-regulatory-refor… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"NEPA’s defenders face a changed reality. The legal and institutional framework that once guaranteed meaningful public engagement has been dismantled. In its place is a system defined by discretion, inconsistency, and uncertainty."
thebreakthrough.org/issues/environmental-regulatory-refor… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Our environmental politics should reject Ehrlich’s lies. The human person is good. Our home is good. And technological ingenuity, inspired by nature, can elevate people and ecosystems by realizing the good of each."
Read @IsaiahMenning's review here:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-dominion-ecology-of-pro… -
Breakthrough reposted
Isaiah Menning
@IsaiahMenning
“Our environmental politics should reject Ehrlich’s lies.
The human person is good. Our home is good.
And technological ingenuity, inspired by nature, can elevate people and ecosystems by realizing the good of each.”
On Project Hail Mary in @TheBTI’s The Ecomodernist. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The MAHA movement's crusade against pesticides and processed foods sounds noble, but the science does not support their claims.
@EmilyJane_Bass did the fact-checking: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/mythbusting-mahas-claims-ab… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
USDA's own regulations are blocking agricultural innovation, even as farmers face the worst input crisis in years.
From @EmmaKovak : thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/u… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
China didn't build its clean tech dominance with clean energy. It used its last great wave of coal-fired heavy industry to master the upstream metallurgy that batteries, solar, and chips all depend on.
Read @wang_seaver's latest for @thebti: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-aluminum-tech-stack -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
China’s total installed flexible, dispatchable electricity generation capacity exceeds 1905 GW, including 1267 GW of coal power. In contrast, the country’s all-time peak electricity load record from July 2025 was 1506 GW. Significant new solar and wind additions must be understood in the context of a grid that has already overbuilt enough coal to kill God.
I talk about this and more in today’s new @DecoupleMedia podcast episode with @Dr_Keefer on the flip side of China’s green electrostate narrative. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Big tech has been announcing nuclear deals left and right. But there is a serious bottleneck for new nuclear: the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
We're tracking the regulatory pipeline here: thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/nrc-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Everyone's talking about the electrotech stack--batteries, PV, chips, drones--as the essence of 21st-century power. But China's dominance in all of them traces back to something mundane: 15 million tons of produced aluminum per year.
Read @wang_seaver:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-aluminum-tech-stack -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
In a new piece, I emphasize how the ability to build new upstream metallurgical and chemical plants is crucial to industrial competitiveness and the downstream ability to mass produce drones, batteries, or electric cars.
In other words, what if it’s all the aluminum tech stack? -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Selectively framing the future of industrial mastery around the most photogenic technologies risks ending up with an incomplete recipe."
Read @wang_seaver's latest for The Ecomodernist: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-aluminum-tech-stack -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Microsoft and NVIDIA announced last week that they are teaming up to build AI tools to improve nuclear energy.
AI can optimize for fuel loading, it can guide plant inspections, and much more.
Read @MattLWald's analysis from last 2024:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/artificial-intelligence-goe… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The claims in Lighthiser v. Trump misrepresent climate science, inflate what executive action can do to emissions, and ask courts to circumvent constitutional rights.
The lawsuit perverts both science and democracy in pursuit of a millenarian agenda.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/against-climate-lawfare -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"Despite these brutal efforts, India’s population growth did not slow down. Between 1971 and 1981, India’s population grew by roughly 24% from 548 million to 683 million people. And, yet, India never ran out of food."
@TheBTI Vijaya Ramachandran about why Paul Erlich was doubly wrong. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The Strait of Hormuz carried half the world's urea exports. It's now shut. This is global problem, but impending shortages are just adding on to the already deep fertilizer crisis in Africa.
Read @alexjmssmith and Vijaya Ramachandran from 2024:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-west-needs-to-come-to-g… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The apocalyptic scenario Paul Ehrlich predicted for India never came to pass. New seeds, fertilizer, irrigation, and human ingenuity provide more than enough food for the 1.4 billion people who live there."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/paul-ehrlich-was-wrong-abou… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Limits to Growth. Planetary Boundaries. Climate targets. These are arbitrary limits dressed up in the language of science to enforce a scarcity agenda.
Paul Ehrlich may be dead, but his intellectual project is not.
From @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-cruelty-is-the-point -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Having failed to mobilize sufficient public demand for sweeping action, the climate movement has turned to executive action and the courts.
Our new amicus brief in Lighthiser v. Trump challenges that strategy head-on.
From @TedNordhaus and @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/against-climate-lawfare -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Banning glyphosate without viable alternatives would likely increase tillage and revive more toxic herbicides, undermining decades of environmental progress.
The science doesn't support reflexive bans. It supports better innovation.
read @danrejto: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/glyphosates-environmental-b… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
The @NRCgov is working on a large volume of rulemakings. I created an NRC Rulemaking Tracker to help the public stay informed and engaged. It updates multiple times a day, and opportunities to submit public comments are highlighted. You can even download a pdf!
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The Iran war is creating exactly the kind of energy crisis that should force a bipartisan permitting deal in Congress.
But, permitting reform remains stuck-in-the-mud. A potential trade over a niche Clean Water Act provision could help:
Read: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-pawn-trade-that-could-u… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
I’m in @nytimes today on @DrKateMarvel resignation from NASA. I’m sorry to see her leave and the Trump administration is unfortunately throwing out the climate science baby with the politicized science bath water. But this is also chickens coming home to roost for activist scientists inside these federal agencies who have continually overegged the pudding and abused the privilege of conducting public science. www.nytimes.com/2026/03/25/climate/kate-marvel-nasa-resig…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The IPCC's most-cited worst-case scenario assumes a 6x increase in per-capita coal use by 2100. But coal use is expected to decline. How did an implausible forecast become the default "business as usual" for thousands of climate studies?
Read @atrembath: asteriskmag.com/issues/13/merchants-of-certainty -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“A successful climate science will ultimately be one that informs society, not one that bounds it.”
Thrilled to publish this essay in @asteriskmgzn’s new issue on science.
asteriskmag.com/issues/13/merchants-of-certainty -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Transmission reform needs to work not only for utilities and states that have liberalized their electricity markets but also for those that have not."
New from @TedNordhaus @RyanAlimento and @wang_seaver:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/dont-let-stealth-deregulati… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"Using transmission reform to force competition on states that have not signed up for liberalization is bad politics and bad policy."
New from me, @wang_seaver and @RyanAlimento @TheBTI.
cc @fredstaffordcs @Leigh_Phillips @Matthuber78 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Paul Ehrlich predicted hundreds of millions would starve to death. He inspired China's one-child policy. He described poor Indians as a screaming, defecating horde.
He was wrong about everything, but he never recanted.
Read @atrembath: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-cruelty-is-the-point -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Casey Means wants to be America's doctor. But her food agenda reads like the vaccine skeptic's playbook applied to farming: distrust regulators, fear synthetics, champion "natural" alternatives, all without evidence.
Read @EmilyJane_Bass in @AgriPulse: www.agri-pulse.com/articles/24411-opinion-casey-means-foo… -
Breakthrough reposted
Dr. Emma Kovak
@EmmaKovak
Have you ever heard that biotechnology or genetic modification is going to revolutionize agriculture — but wonder where all the supposed products are? Part of the problem is an inefficient regulatory system.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/u… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"Means is bringing the vaccine skeptic’s playbook to food: promoting distrust in regulators, voicing fear of synthetics, and advocating for 'natural' alternatives, all without evidence..."
via @TheBTI's @EmilyJane_Bass
www.agri-pulse.com/articles/24411-opinion-casey-means-foo… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Over the past 10 years, the average USDA review for transgenic crops took 600 days. The average cost to authorize a single new trait: $115 million.
That's why only 7 transgenic produce items have reached U.S. grocery store shelves.
Read @EmmaKovak:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/u… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Glyphosate accounts for ~50% of herbicide applied to U.S. wheat, but only 0.7% of the chronic hazard to mammals.
With the Farm Bill heading to the House floor and MAHA calling for a ban, the actual science matters.
Read @danrejto:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/glyphosates-environmental-b… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The IEA says were currently in the worst oil supply disruption in history.
Last time America faced an oil shock of this magnitude, Congress passed bipartisan energy legislation. It's harder today, but the opportunities are there.
Read: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-iran-war-underscores-th… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
We @TheBTI were critical when @youthvgov tried to get all federal energy policy declared unconstitutional during the Biden Admin.
Now we've filed an amicus brief in a similar suit against Trump.
Trying to enforce climate targets through judicial fiat is anti-democratic.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"While Lighthiser can be easily dismissed as an absurdist parody of an actionable legal theory, it is also a microcosm of sorts of the fundamental strategy pursued by the climate movement."
New from @TedNordhaus and @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/against-climate-lawfare -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"The court room, as opposed to the court of public opinion, requires a much higher standard for both evidence and argument. Wise climate and energy policy, whether pursued through the judicial, legislative, or executive branches, requires some basic fidelity to both climate science and techno-economic reality. This is as true for the climate movement as it is for the Trump administration."
Me and @atrembath on why @TheBTI filed an amicus brief in Lighthiser v Trump. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"While Lighthiser can be easily dismissed as an absurdist parody of an actionable legal theory, it is also a microcosm of sorts of the fundamental strategy pursued by the climate movement."
New from @TedNordhaus and @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/against-climate-lawfare -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
It’s easy to dunk on Paul Ehrlich, even on the occasion of his death, because of the horrifying cruelty of his rhetoric.
But there’s an inherent cruelty even in the kinder, gentler Malthusian scarcity agenda.
My latest for The Ecomodernist: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"And even if Ehrlich’s dehumanizing language and policy agenda have gone out of fashion, it’s still important to recognize the inherent cruelty in enforced Malthusian scarcity that persists in too much of environmental advocacy today."
Read @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-cruelty-is-the-point -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Republicans want limits on how states use Section 401 to block pipelines. Democrats want more transmission lines to decarbonize the electric grid. The trade could help get pipelines built while unlocking a path to a larger grid and lower emissions."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-pawn-trade-that-could-u… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
If you need pragmatic takes on radiation protection this morning (instead of hot takes), I have a few recommendations. Here is a thread of them.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Oil, gas, solar, and wind all have bright futures in the U.S. But responding to the looming global oil crisis will require expanding America’s energy technology and infrastructure frontiers."
Read @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-iran-war-underscores-th… -
Breakthrough reposted
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Despite a bad reputation, "glyphosate has delivered net environmental benefits, largely by displacing more toxic herbicides and enabling practices that reduce soil erosion, water and air pollution, energy use, and crop losses."
Read @danrejto:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/glyphosates-environmental-b… -
Breakthrough reposted
Jason Crawford
@jasoncrawford
“It’s time to resist the deceptive lure of a non-agrarian world in some imagined past or future dreamed up by countless elites. Instead, we might look to the story of humanity’s huge strides in using these tiny seeds to create food that sustains the lives of billions of people, that is fairly distributed and freely chosen, and that with its satisfying taste contributes to happiness.”
@rachellaudan, “With the Grain” (2018)
thebreakthrough.org/journal/no-9-summer-2018/with-the-grain -
Breakthrough reposted
Elizabeth McCarthy
@3lizabethMcC
America Needs Mining, Mining Needs Permitting Reform!
New post for @TheBTI from me, @PeterCookBTI and @wang_seaver
open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/mining-nee… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"As debates drag on, permitting bottlenecks threaten to push mining investment abroad."
New from @PeterCookBTI @3lizabethMcC and @wang_seaver:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/mining-needs-permitting-ref… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"Kamala definitely needs to start getting involved."
☝️ Democrats' plan the last time Congress had an opportunity to pass major federal permitting reform.
Let's stick the landing this time.
My latest @TheBTI: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Reform efforts should begin by recognizing that the current system is the product of institutional accumulation rather than a single flawed policy decision."
Read the new report for @thebti from PJ Seel: thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/deca… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Permitting reform: too big for Secret Congress deals, too complicated for partisan budget reconciliation.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Permitting reform should be one of the only remaining policy issues for which bipartisanship can prevail. If our legislature can’t do this, what can it do?"
Read the latest from @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/permitting-reform-or-die -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The danger is not that microplastics concerns will be studied too rigorously; rather, it is that misaligned incentives will keep selecting for the most alarming interpretation of uncertain findings."
New guest post from @JonEntine and @henryimiller:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-microplastics-panic -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
Two new papers claim nuclear plants increase cancer risk. That sounds alarming.
But they are not studies of radiation exposure. They are studies of geographic proximity and do not provide valid results. 🧵 -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
P-hacking to find spurious correlation between metric that doesn't measure exposure to radiation from nuclear plants and cancer, with no control group and a phony sensitivity test. @HarvardChanSPH and @NatureComms should be embarrassed. Once again, peer-review is broken.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"To establish that nuclear plants are increasing cancer risk, a study must show more than a map-based association... Neither study does this."
Read @econpragmatist and @Dr_A_Stein:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/two-new-papers-are-wrong-ab… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“Without RFS, corn and soy would be cheaper, and U.S. farmers would have even more of a competitive advantage internationally.”
@TheBTI's @danrejto in this @jamesbmeigs piece @CityJournal:
www.city-journal.org/article/food-prices-epa-renewable-fu… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
In which @atrembath and I clap back at @Noahpinion @ramez and other solarmaxxers.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"We are far more likely to succeed in building an abundant energy future if we pursue a broad portfolio of technologies and strategies rather than insisting fanatically upon a single technological solution."
Read @atrembath and @TedNordhaus:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/solar-and-nuclear-both-must… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Confirming Dr. Means risks advancing a vision of food and farming that is divorced from scientific evidence, dismissive of farmers’ livelihoods, and inconsistent with the goal of making healthy food affordable for every household."
Read @EmilyJane_Bass:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/surgeon-general-pick-deepen… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"There is no scientifically understood mechanism by which an electrical substation could cause the injuries that brought the Niners down."
New from PJ Seel for @thebti: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/no-a-substation-did-not-mak… -
Breakthrough reposted
Shawn Regan
@Shawn_Regan
Conservation today isn’t something that happens on its own. It must be *supplied*. It requires active work, and that work often faces supply-side barriers.
The same procedural gauntlets that slow housing or infrastructure projects also slow restoration projects.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"If conservation is primarily about stopping things from happening, then it will always sit counter to a movement that explicitly wants to build."
Read @Shawn_Regan for The Ecomodernist: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/can-abundance-include-nature -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“Thought experiments about bringing industrial development into the final frontier don’t obviate the need for investment, innovation, and, critically, regulatory reform for industries here on Earth.”
via @TheBTI’s @RyanAlimento -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Orbital data centers give an exciting vision of a future frontier for both compute and electricity production. But given the enormous technical hurdles, they are not a real solution for the AI industry today."
Read @RyanAlimento: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/data-centers-wont-be-in-spa… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"If conservation is primarily about stopping things from happening, then it will always sit counter to a movement that explicitly wants to build."
Read @Shawn_Regan for The Ecomodernist: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/can-abundance-include-nature -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
This tweet is totally misleading. We have known for a long time that most of CA's energy intensity advantage versus other states is due to climate, high energy prices, deindustrialization, and other behavioral factors. Energy efficiency is not the primary reason and BTM has almost nothing to do with it. So I asked ChatGPT to apply the famous "Deconstructing the Rosenfeld Curve" analysis, which first demonstrated this, to @mzjacobson chart and claim. Here's what it finds:🧵
-
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
Let’s be clear how much the frame on the aluminum “long green march” story in China has now shifted, from “renewables are cheaper than coal so China is now moving heavy industry to where renewables are!” to “I built a plant here to use cheap coal mined 8 miles down the road, and now the govt is making me buy renewables certificates for 30% of my power needs”
As I do think it’s useful for the climate folks and what I’ll call the "China futurist" folks in this convo to understand what these plants in Xinjiang + Inner Mongolia look like, I’m going to show each of them here while I lay out some thoughts. 🧵
Tianshan Aluminum, Xinjiang 44°25'N 86°04'E -
Breakthrough reposted
Elizabeth McCarthy
@3lizabethMcC
But this shows exactly why we need permitting reform — for the stability and certainty the sector has been missing. 4/4
More: For @TheBTI w/@atrembath and Marc Levitt www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/trumps-war-on-renewables-in… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Passing durable, bipartisan permitting reform is a response to the Administration’s energy policies, not a surrender to them. Democrats would be cutting off their nose to spite their face by balking at this opportunity."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/trumps-war-on-renewables-in… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
As luck would have it, 11 years ago *today* I wrote a post to Noah Smith calling for more humility in energy prognostications. Noah seems to have taken this as a challenge to do the precise opposite. In the mean time, @TheBTI has continued doing our work.
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
Remember: If you get your ideas about the future of energy from the Breakthrough Institute, you have only hurt your own portfolio.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The anti-nuclear movement is dead. The soft energy path is a fantasy. Fear of the unknown when it comes to nuclear energy and radiation may still be around, but new research suggests that it has substantially attenuated."
Read @TedNordhaus: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-public-confidence-game -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The Commission is operating with an institutional architecture designed to optimize a single objective—safety—while being asked to govern a system where multiple objectives now matter at the same time."
Read @Dr_A_Stein:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-nrcs-problem-isnt-cauti… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
The NRC isn’t unique. Most complex organizations are built to optimize one objective, then get stuck when they’re asked to govern several at once.
That failure mode shows up everywhere. -
Breakthrough reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Why does eco-misanthropy flourish in the West? Is it a relic of Christianity? Perhaps the answer is simpler: only rich, safe societies can afford to romanticise nature—and then hate humanity for disturbing an imaginary “natural harmony.” Essay for @TheBTI. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/is-green-misanthropy-a-uniq…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"It is modern people who romanticise nature, precisely because they no longer have to endure its daily hardships."
The incomparable @mboudry graces the pixels of The Ecomodernist: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"It is modern people who romanticise nature, precisely because they no longer have to endure its daily hardships. The more thoroughly we are buffered from the dangers of the natural world, the more estranged we become from it."
Read @mboudry:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/is-green-misanthropy-a-uniq… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"To harness fusion energy, meet new load growth, decarbonize the economy, or achieve any technological solution to a national goal, the United States needs to rebuild its industrial commons."
Read @RyanAlimento:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-fusion-power-tomorrow-n… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Revealing the limits and unintended consequences of environmental doomism won’t free us of its hold. The allure of the apocalyptic may be something that we can temper and redirect but never transcend."
A guest post from @dots_t on The Ecomodernist: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/after-revelatory-environmen… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
As @wang_seaver @joyjiang1997 @RyanAlimento cover in a @TheBTI paper released today, tariffs are not the solution for domestic aluminum production.
Cheap industrial electricity is much more important.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/a-crossroads-for-alumin…
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
HOW TARIFFS CAN "WORK" AND FAIL AT THE SAME TIME
Wrote about aluminum in today's Odd Lots newsletter -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
New white paper from colleagues and myself: Why did China come to dominate aluminum smelting? What does today’s aluminum production landscape look like in China, North America, and Europe, and what should the U.S.'s light metal strategy be going forward?
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"None of this will be cheap, but policymakers inclined to balk at market interventions must recognize large capital investments as the price of admission for rebuilding atrophied industry knowledge."
New from @wang_seaver @PeterCookBTI and @joyjiang1997:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/a-crossroads-for-alumin… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"By making agriculture a central pillar of a whole-of-government effort to scale the bioeconomy, Congress can usher in the innovation needed to secure the future of American agriculture over the long term."
Read @EmmaKovak and @EmilyJane_Bass:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/congress-punts-on-the-farm-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Dan Rejto 🇺🇸🌎🍴
@danrejto
A court ruling in favor of anti-GMO groups has slowed @USDA approval for some GMOs.
But USDA cut its review time for most biotechnology crops, including gene-edited ones, by more than 50% last year, shows this new @TheBTI analysis. thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/s… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Overall, even with the disruptive reversion to legacy regulations in late 2024, USDA has done an impressive job of quickly reinstating legacy systems and decreasing review times"
New from @EmmaKovak:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/s… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Climate watchdogmatism is not an ethics operation gone awry; it is, rather, the inevitable logic of the climate emergency."
Read @atrembath: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/who-watches-the-watchdogs -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"In the years leading up to the LA fires, California failed to adequately follow through on all of these. In the year since, it has made tentative progress, but it is still far from what is needed."
Read @lrntex: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-much-progress-has-calif… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Today’s legal gridlock serves no one. By taking up Monsanto Co. v. Durnell, the Supreme Court can provide a definitive ruling on whether federal law preempts state-law failure-to-warn claims."
Read @EmilyJane_Bass:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-clock-is-ticking-for-gl… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"If policymakers are serious about an “all-of-the-above” energy strategy, then protections cannot stop at oil and gas offshore leases. They must extend to every form of energy infrastructure authorized by the federal government."
Read: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/permitting-certainty-is-a-b… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Today @TheBTI proposed extending regulatory protections available to offshore oil & gas leases to all permitted projects.
No “permitting certainty” provision will be 100% bulletproof against a determined executive. But it’s better than doing nothing. -
Breakthrough reposted
Elizabeth McCarthy
@3lizabethMcC
Congress recognizes offshore energy projects need protection from political reversal, that logic shouldn’t stop there. All federal permits and authorizations deserve the same baseline stability.
Read Me & Marc Levitt’s permit certainty proposal for @TheBTI 👇 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"But the administration has also launched the most ambitious effort to commercialize new nuclear energy technology since the Eisenhower administration’s Atoms for Peace initiative."
Read @TedNordhaus:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/trumps-surprising-win-for-t… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
DOE’s $2.7B for uranium enrichment is necessary, but it won’t solve the HALEU problem.
The constraint was never technical capacity. It’s the absence of early, durable offtake. The U.S. can already produce HALEU at pilot scale.
New piece www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-billions-for-uranium-en… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"There has been much talk in recent years about the need for “climate moon shots”... The Trump administration’s effort to revitalize the U.S. nuclear sector is as close as we’ve seen to a moon shot."
My @PostOpinions essay today. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Producing limited quantities of HALEU for first-of-a-kind reactors, without firm, multi-reactor, multi-decade contracts, makes little economic sense. From an enricher’s perspective, that is not a bridge to a future market—it is a stranded-asset risk."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-billions-for-uranium-en… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"It is not enough to simply ignore the UN’s annual climate bacchanal as a pointless contrivance. It’s long past time to abolish it."
Read @TedNordhaus:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/defund-the-cops -
Breakthrough reposted
Lauren Teixeira
@lrntex
Today @danrejto and I tell the infuriating story of California’s Low Carbon Fuel Standard, a program that was supposed to decarbonize transportation but ended up forcing CA drivers to pay 18 billion dollars for biofuels that are worse for the climate than fossil fuels (THREAD):
-
Breakthrough reposted
Dan Rejto 🇺🇸🌎🍴
@danrejto
Here's a win-win: California could cut gas prices AND emissions by backing away from corn & soy-based biofuels.
Studies consistently show these lead to far more land conversion than the state projected. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/california-should-stop-forc… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"California policymakers must now decide whether to align the LCFS with the latest scientific evidence, or continue subsidizing fuels that worsen the very problem the program is meant to solve."
Read @danrejto and @lrntex:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/california-should-stop-forc… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The increasingly sharp division between Hochul and her environmentalist critics is a sign that Democrats will no longer simply outsource energy policy ideation and implementation to the climate movement."
Read @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/environmentalism-vs-afforda… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“This is very different to the last nuclear renaissance in the mid-2000s…We now have market conditions for rapid growth in the US nuclear fleet.”
@TheBTI’s @Dr_A_Stein in @FT
www.ft.com/content/9f6c4db1-559f-48e1-8c21-ac0bc1a1237c?a… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
With the return of nuclear energy to the public square and serious efforts among policymakers to commercialize a new generation of reactors in the United States and Europe, familiar claims about the risks of nuclear reactors have returned as well... repeat[ing] claims based upon decades-old studies and outdated science [that] ignore an enormous body of better and more recent data [and] defy contemporary scientific understandings of the health risks associated with low doses of ionizing radiation.
@TheBTI @Dr_A_Stein and @PeterJamesSeel in @BulletinAtomic. -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Smith
@alexjmssmith
From 2010 to 2014, one organization, Conservation Congress, filed at least 24 suits against U.S. Forest Service fire management programs in California through NEPA, the Endangered Species Act and other environmental laws.
New from me and @3lizabethMcC :
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-environmentalists-makin… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"A single breakthrough in a given mineral supply chain could take the U.S. from a position of scarcity to global dominance. National and economic security cannot risk forgoing these opportunities"
Read @PeterCookBTI: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/could-the-us-unlock-a-shale… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"This decade offers a generational opportunity to remake 50 years of environmental law and policy, to relaunch a globally competitive American nuclear industry, and to build a new ecomodernist politics of abundance for the 21st century."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/a-new-era -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“This decade offers a generational opportunity to remake 50 years of environmental law and policy, to relaunch a globally competitive American nuclear industry, and to build a new ecomodernist politics of abundance.”
@TedNordhaus and my latest: -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Read @3lizabethMcC and @alexjmssmith who name and shame @SierraClub, @CenterForBioDiv and other green groups, large and small, that are destroying western forests and ecosystems in the name of saving them. The spectacle of environmental groups dogmatically obstructing action necessary to protect public health and endangered species is old hat but still never fails to infuriate.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Elizabeth McCarthy
@3lizabethMcC
Wildfires are getting worse.
Environmental groups blame climate change, but their lawsuits block needed forest management.
With @alexjmssmith, we explain how the spotted owl fight helped burn down a forest, and what recent reforms do to prevent that from happening again. -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“During the period that about a sixth of California’s forests were going up in flames, one single group was busy suing the USFS 24 times.”
via @TheBTI’s @alexjmssmith and @3lizabethMcC
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The fact that U.S. environmental law can allow for such undemocratic processes and excesses is indicative of the system’s inability to rationally protect the environment."
Read @alexjmssmith and @3lizabethMcC: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-environmentalists-makin… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The fact that U.S. environmental law can allow for such undemocratic processes and excesses is indicative of the system’s inability to rationally protect the environment."
Read @alexjmssmith and @3lizabethMcC: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-environmentalists-makin… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
China is proving a green electrostate is key to being a 21st century economic superpower, or so goes the popular meme.
But this isn’t a remotely accurate characterization of the energy system beneath China’s industrial might. New by myself, @TedNordhaus + Vijaya Ramachandran🧵 -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"It is China’s non-carbon constrained energy-industrial model, not electric vehicles, solar panels, batteries, and heat pumps, that has rewritten the rules of the global game."
New from me, @wang_seaver, and Vijaya Ramachandran @TheBTI. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"China will likely continue to dominate the green technology sector. But its industrial economy will almost certainly remain powered and heated by coal and gas for decades."
Read @wang_seaver @TedNordhaus and Vijaya Ramachandran: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/greenwashing-with-chinese-c… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The NRC has never been fully independent from other parts of government; instead, it is built on layers of independence and oversight."
Read @Dr_A_Stein for @thebti: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/understanding-the-nrc-indep… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“They argued that polarization over energy projects ultimately undermines national climate objectives.”
Our letter from @TheBTI @ThirdWayEnergy @Inclsvabundance @employamerica featured in @politico Morning Energy: -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
NEW LETTER
@TheBTI @ThirdWayEnergy @Inclsvabundance and @employamerica applaud Gov Hochul’s approval of the NESE natural gas pipeline as a cost- and climate-smart decision. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"With all of those constraints, maritime propulsion is still an attractive target for replacement with nuclear; it’s a continuous load, now met with polluting fuel, in a major economic sector that is amenable to economies of scale."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/an-engineers-dream-a-lawyer… -
Breakthrough reposted
William Davison
@wdavison10
The recent COP summit tried to make progress towards the "Global goal on adaptation".
In this piece for @TheBTI, I argue that it would make far more sense to think of adaptation as something that's tied to economic development.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/climate-finance-is-everythi… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"No data exists today that the Diablo Canyon plant’s annual intake of less than one cubic mile of seawater has had any measurable impact on any adult fish population."
Read @wang_seaver:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-californias-coastal-com… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
A thing @mattyglesias gets at here is the way in which slogans and memes are a substitute for thinking.
It’s why we @TheBTI have been so fanatical about publishing argumentative essays, and why I feel even more urgency about writing long-form arguments in the age of LLMs. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Institutions need to continually renew themselves or they stagnate."
To that end, we are excited to announce that on January 1, @TedNordhaus will become President of @thebti, and @atrembath will be our new Executive Director.
Read the announcement: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/breaking-things-at-breakthr… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
10 years ago this month, we announced that Michael Shellenberger was leaving @TheBTI. Breakthrough has transformed significantly since then. Today I'm pleased to announce the next step in that evolution. On Jan. 1, @atrembath will become the executive director and I will move into a new role as President. Alex has been my peer and partner in building BTI over the last few years and its time to make that official.
I'm not retiring or stepping down my involvement, but its important to make room for new leadership and I will be looking to new projects and new directions for BTI. Keeping institutions like BTI vital ultimately requires that the older generation get out of the way. So today begins the process of getting out of the way. More here:👇www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/breaking-things-at-breakthr… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
We’re excited to announce that in January, @TheBTI founder @TedNordhaus will become President and I’ll become Executive Director.
It’s an honor I couldn’t have imagined when I started working here in 2011. Today it’s the only job I can imagine wanting. -
Breakthrough reposted
Dr. Emma Kovak
@EmmaKovak
Have you heard that U.S. crop yields are declining and our food supply is in danger from climate change? Good news: yields for staple crops like corn, wheat, soybeans, and potatoes are still increasing and show no signs of slowing down.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/a… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Downstate New York has unique energy supply constraints that leave them with energy that is often dirtier and less reliable than gas. Ignoring that reality at voters' expense would be costly to ratepayers.
Read:
Third Way Climate & Energy
@ThirdWayEnergy
Green groups were outraged at Governor Hochul’s decision to okay a new gas pipeline in New York. Missing from their backlash, though, was any acknowledgment of the state’s rising energy costs.
@jsfreed explains in @EMPIREREPORTNY why the Governor made the right call. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The evidence to date does not support the claim that key crop yields are facing a long-term trend that signals declining growth rates."
New from @EmmaKovak for @thebti:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/are-us-crop-yields-declining -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Ultimately, inking a civilian nuclear deal that would see the United States export reactor technology to Saudi Arabia would be a boon for a U.S. nuclear industry that has been dominated by Russia in the global export market."
New from @stoohill13:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/what-the-us-saudi-nuclear-d… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Climate advocates are still trying to get people more worried about climate change.
They should instead consider taking the public’s views seriously.
My latest @TheArgumentMag. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Permitting reform has never looked more plausible. But there remain significant substantive and political hurdles between introduced legislation and a successful, meaningful bipartisan deal."
New from @3lizabethMcC:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-fall-of-permitting-reform -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“Achieving cold criticality represents a milestone for Reactor Pilot Program participants and meets the goal outlined in the recent executive order. This is one step of many toward a functional commercial product.”
@Dr_A_Stein on the news from Valar: thebreakthrough.org/press/valar-atomics-achieves-first-cr… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“AIM for Scale should act as a catalyst and dealmaker, aligning fragmented efforts, mobilizing new resources, and ensuring that cost-effective innovations reach millions of farmers.”
New report from @thebti:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/a… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"In a sense, the climate movement—exemplified by the increasing bloat at the annual COP meetings—has overtaken development, and set its own rules for how developing nations must act."
A guest post from @wdavison10 for the Ecomodernist: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/climate-finance-is-everythi… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Growth, development, and technological change are both the source of and solution to environmental challenges. Environmental law must place itself in service of those processes in order to serve the environment."
Read @TedNordhaus: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/environmental-law-after-env… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Having spent the last 20 years or so convincing policymakers to prioritize climate change, climate hawks are now insisting that doing so need not come at the expense of other issues like public health. It’s magical thinking."
Read @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/of-course-prioritizing-clim… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Trustworthiness and reliability decrease when stakes are high and values are contested because, in those cases, knowledge generation is highly susceptible to cultural forces and thus motivated cognition."
Read @PatrickTBrown31 in the Ecomodernist: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/when-are-scientific-claims-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"To deploy clean energy and address climate change, America needs to end partisan warfare over energy deployment. We applaud Governor Hochul for taking a bold step in that direction."
Read our statement here: thebreakthrough.org/press/release-breakthrough-institute-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
If the US really wants to expand nuclear to 400GW nationwide by 2050, the US must secure enrichment ~5x-10x of current domestic capacity.
This new report explores the potential future US + global nuclear fuel supply chain needs, from uranium enrichment to mining.🧵 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
To meet anticipated future demands, the U.S. must increase uranium enrichment capacity five-to-tenfold by 2050.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/abundant-fuels-for-abun… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
Our new report explores the envelope of potential future US + global nuclear fuel supply chain needs, from uranium enrichment to mining.
If the US really wants to expand nuclear to 400GW nationwide by 2050, the US must secure enrichment ~5x-10x of current domestic capacity.🧵 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“The U.S. faces a dramatic shortage in uranium enrichment capacity, with current capacity only sufficient to cover 10% to 25% of projected annual needs in 2050.”
NEW @TheBTI report out today:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/abundant-fuels-for-abun… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Although the company has access to municipal potable and wastewater, as well as a groundwater lease with the university system, Stein said it is likely to face questions about water access from the NRC."
BTI's @Dr_A_Stein in the WSJ yesterday:www.wsj.com/business/energy-oil/rick-perrys-nuclear-ambit… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"But for all their talk of transforming American diets, MAHA leaders have proposed little to actually make healthy food more accessible."
Read @danrejto:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/seeds-of-abundance -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"In practice, the idea that China’s clean technology successes have uncovered a more hopeful recipe for climate salvation is wrong."
Read @wang_seaver's latest for The Ecomodernist:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/six-things-the-climate-move… -
Breakthrough reposted
Lauren Teixeira
@lrntex
GREAT NEWS!! No one will ever have to argue over which electricity generation sources are cheapest again because I have revealed some ***important nuances*** about electricity prices. (THREAD)
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The only thing that Texas’s success integrating renewables into the grid shows us is that renewables are a good option for Texas. But what is good for Texas is not necessarily good for New York."
Read @lrntex:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/do-renewables-lower-electri… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“Former EPA Official’s NEPA ‘Reboot’ Embraces AI, Clean Air Act Revisions”
InsideEPA on @TheBTI’s new proposal:
insideepa.com/remaking-epa-news/former-epa-official-s-nep… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
Reduce exposure to project cost risk by buying more. An order book will reduce costs through learning-by-doing, and is needed to justify investment in manufacturing infrastructure. But it can also significantly reduce the potential for an overrun. thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/orde…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Elizabeth McCarthy
@3lizabethMcC
It’s time to Reboot NEPA. Our proposal streamlines reviews and court challenges, upgrades public comment, and gives agencies AI tools for faster, smarter decisions.
Here are our 11 key reforms:
🧵 1/13 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
NEPA has become a litigation machine that delays critical projects, straying from its original purpose of informed planning and public engagement. After decades of inadequate reforms, the system is unstable and unpredictable.
A true reboot is needed.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/environmental-regulatory-refor… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
New from @TheBTI: Our plan to reboot NEPA.
1. Certainty in the judiciary and agencies.
2. Voice, not veto.
3. AI-driven modernization of NEPA procedure and documentation. -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
How China Raced Ahead of the U.S. on Nuclear Power.
As @joyjiang1997 @thebti notes, serial orders allow developers to refine construction, streamline licensing, simplify the supply chain, and reduce costs.
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/10/22/climate/china-us-n… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"By defanging NEPA in the short-term, the SPEED Act leaves open the possibility that future administrations will bring NEPA back from the dead and recreate the arduous environmental review drafting cycles that the SPEED Act aims to solve."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/beware-zombie-nepa -
Breakthrough reposted
Peter Cook
@PeterCookBTI
As the US debates how to secure critical minerals, some insist that we first must wholly reform mining before we embrace its role in decarbonization
@TheBTI argues how the stringent standards miners already follow make that attitude counterproductive
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/mining-is-not-what-it-used-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"But as the consensus shifted, the reaction among much of the climate science and advocacy community has not been to become less catastrophic. Rather, it has been to shift the locus of catastrophe from five to three degrees of warming.”
Read @TedNordhaus
www.thefp.com/p/i-thought-climate-change-would-end?hide_i… -
Breakthrough reposted
The Free Press
@TheFP
“I used to argue that if the world kept burning fossil fuels at current rates, catastrophe was virtually assured.
‘The heating of the earth,’ Michael Shellenberger and I wrote in our 2007 book, Break Through, ‘will cause the sea levels to rise and the Amazon to collapse and, according to scenarios commissioned by the Pentagon, will trigger a series of wars over the basic resources like food and water.’
I no longer believe this hyperbole.
At the time, I, like most climate experts, thought that business-as-usual emissions would lead to around five degrees of warming by the end of this century. That assumption was never plausible. It assumed high population growth, high economic growth, and slow technological change. But fertility rates have been falling, global economic growth slowing, and the global economy decarbonizing for decades.
Nor is there good reason to think that the combination of these three trends could possibly be sustained in concert. High economic growth is strongly associated with falling fertility rates. Technological change is the primary driver of long-term economic growth. A future with low rates of technological change is not consistent with high economic growth. And a future characterized by high rates of economic growth is not consistent with high rates of population growth.
As a result, most estimates of worst-case warming by the end of the century now suggest three degrees or less. But as the consensus has shifted, the reaction among much of the climate science and advocacy community has not been to become less catastrophic. Rather, it has been simply to shift the locus of catastrophe from five to three degrees of warming.” —@TedNordhaus -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Failing to recognize how mining practices and oversight have improved perpetuates needless resistance to new mines and inhibits the acquisition of the raw materials that supply modern society."
Read @PeterCookBTI and @wang_seaver: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/mining-is-not-what-it-used-… -
Breakthrough reposted
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Congress and the Administration are working together to steer American agriculture deeper into biofuels. If China’s retreat from U.S. soy and corn continues, the political pressure to continue to do so will only intensify."
Read @danrejto:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/burning-the-breadbasket -
Breakthrough reposted
Energy Switch
@theenergyswitch
We often hear that climate change is driving extreme weather. Our guests dug into the IPCC data for heat waves, storms, rainfall, and more. With @PatrickTBrown31, climate scientist from @TheBTI, and acclaimed environmental journalist @Revkin. Watch here: www.pbs.org/video/extreme-weather-part-1-qpm5je/
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"You don’t get that lost culture and community back without bringing poverty and precarity, provincialism, and patriarchy along for the ride."
Read @TedNordhaus :
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-best-things-in-life-are… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"China and the USA have dramatically different political economies, and what works in one place might not work in the other, but China’s success offers invaluable insights for the American nuclear industry to scale."
New analysis from @joyjiang1997: thebreakthrough.org/issues/nuclear-energy-innovation/what… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"I think there’s a huge gap between what you’d read in the IPCC Working Group 1 chapter on extreme weather and what you see in a lot of media."
Always read @PatrickTBrown31: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/24-questions-on-extreme-wea… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"As more variable renewable energy sources are being added to the grid, it is worth considering that our old systems for ensuring reliability might not be enough."
Read @econpragmatist breakdown of the Iberian Blackout: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/blackout -
Breakthrough reposted
Deric Tilson
@econpragmatist
In my latest @BTI, I take readers step-by-step through the Iberian Blackout and explore what it means for the US grid.
Renewables add extra complexity to grids. Our institutions and governance need to evolve to help mitigate new and unknown risks.
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Yes, a solar plant in Spain did initiate the cascading failures and feedback loops that caused the blackout on the Iberian peninsula. There are lessons here for how to make RE heavy grids less susceptible to this sort of failure, but learning them requires acknowledging that there is a vulnerability here. @econpramatist with a second by second explanation of what happened and what to do about it in The Ecomodernist.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Yes, a solar plant in Spain did initiate the cascading failures and feedback loops that caused the blackout on the Iberian peninsula. There are lessons here for how to make RE heavy grids less susceptible to this sort of failure, but learning them requires acknowledging that there is a vulnerability here. @econpramatist with a second by second explanation of what happened and what to do about it in The Ecomodernist.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
New piece from me weighs in on the important brewing debate over corporate Scope 2 clean electricity crediting (GHGP2).
I argue that it’s obviously better for clean energy innovation to require companies to buy hourly and regionally-matched clean power to make green claims. 🧵 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The greatest value to society from companies pledging various climate targets isn’t their narrow emissions goals but rather the larger innovation and commercialization for clean energy technologies that they stimulate."
Read @wang_seaver: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/its-time-to-raise-the-bar-f… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Like Goodall, I have one son. And partially because of people like her, I’ve dedicated my career to protecting the beauty of the Earth so that he and his children and many billions of future humans can enjoy, protect, and nurture it."
Read @atrembath:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/rest-in-primacy-jane-goodall -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"As national debates over the role of government in our food system continue, bipartisan support for sustained, robust research funding remains critical."
Read @EmilyJane_Bass on dodging the MAHA bullet: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/big-agriculture-dodged-a-bu… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"NEPA is, at least recently, less about environmental protection and more about preventing new construction."
@PCRossetti @thedispatch, citing @TheBTI's analysis. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Even though the structures of utilities and markets have changed over time, regulatory decisions made over 90 years ago are still affecting the decisions made today."
Read @econpragmatist's new piece for The Ecomodernist: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-the-grid-is-lagging-beh… -
Breakthrough reposted
Dr. Emma Kovak
@EmmaKovak
What do the American Chestnut tree, the black rat, and the northern white rhinoceros have in common? They're prime targets for conservation through biotech. The upcoming USDA and IUCN decisions are important determinants of biotech’s role in conservation.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/b… -
Breakthrough reposted
Isaiah Menning
@IsaiahMenning
An environmentalism of dominion
@EmmaKovak in @TheBTI
Dr. Emma Kovak
@EmmaKovak
What do the American Chestnut tree, the black rat, and the northern white rhinoceros have in common? They're prime targets for conservation through biotech. The upcoming USDA and IUCN decisions are important determinants of biotech’s role in conservation.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/b… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"If you want to know why the Left has largely abandoned faith that the industrial proletariat might lead the way to a revolutionary post-capitalist order, consider that about as many Americans today work in the non-profit sector as in manufacturing."
@alexjmssmith and me on Marx, ecology, and the Third Contradiction of Capitalism. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/karl-marx-ecomodernist -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Adopting the MAHA movement’s agricultural proposals at scale would undermine its goals, raising food prices, expanding agriculture’s land footprint, and worsening both environmental and human health."
Read @danrejto: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/maha-make-agriculture-harde… -
Breakthrough reposted
Elizabeth McCarthy
@3lizabethMcC
Permitting reform usually collapses on politics. But here’s a rare bipartisan fix Congress could actually pass - modernizing NEPA’s broken data systems. 🧵1/5
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Whether under the banner of abundance, liberalism, or leftism, the center-left will have no future so long as environmentalists retain substantial power within that coalition."
Read @TedNordhaus and @alexjmssmith: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/karl-marx-ecomodernist
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
You can read the full series here: thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/w…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
In which @alexjmssmith and I propose a third contradiction of capitalism.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"It’s long past time to give agencies the tools they need — an interoperable, government-wide platform for NEPA data and project management, supported by large language models."
Read @thebti's Marc Levitt and @3lizabethMcC in @heatmap_news:
heatmap.news/ideas/nepa-reform-data -
Breakthrough reposted
Heatmap News
@heatmap_news
"We can’t manage what we can’t measure."
@TheBTI's Marc Levitt and @3lizabethMcC explain why better data technology infrastructure is a surefire way to "future-proof NEPA."
heatmap.news/ideas/nepa-reform-data -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"Even truncated reviews would still be handicapped by broken systems. Fixing the technology infrastructure now is a way to future-proof NEPA."
@TheBTI's Marc Levitt and @3lizabethMcC @heatmap_news
heatmap.news/ideas/nepa-reform-data -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"All-of-the-above energy policy remains both the most robust approach to the wicked and highly differentiated nature of America’s electricity system and, demonstrably, the best political approach."
Read @TedNordhaus and @atrembath here:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/its-the-electricity-prices-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Quiet climate policy is dead, killed by the polarization of energy politics that’s occurred over the last ~decade.
But all-of-the-above energy policy can rise again.
@TedNordhaus and my latest for The Ecomodernist: -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"We were both struck during our week in DC for Abundance 2025 how hard it was for even moderate, Abundance-pilled Democratic politicians, despite the determination to pivot to electricity cost, to talk about energy and electricity without talking about climate change."
Me and @atrembath on the new the new politics of energy and climate. -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Every dollar invested in public agricultural R&D has generated $20 in returns, yet the Trump Admin is overhauling the USDA. @TheBTI's @EmilyJane_Bass and @scientistsorg's Irene Ngun offer a policy agenda to sustain federal ag innovation.
fas.org/publication/safeguarding-agricultural-research-ca… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Smith
@alexjmssmith
Did Karl Marx harbor secret environmentalist feelings? Did he reject his own historical materialism? Or should we take Marx at his own words?
Read Part II of @TedNordhaus and my series on Marx and environmentalism to find out: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/marxology-gone-wild -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"In an effort to reconcile Marx with environmentalism, O’Connor and Foster invented the new ecomarxist doctrine from whole cloth, first a second contradiction of capitalism, then an absolute law of environmental degradation."
Read here:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/marxology-gone-wild -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Now for something completely different...
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The old Marxist Left had a theory of the economy, how it produces surplus and value, and how both the quantity and quality of production changes as political economies evolve. The ecoleft has no such theory."
Read @TedNordhaus and @alexjmssmith: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-we-love-marx-and-hate-e… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"FDA can accelerate the availability of beneficial products, ensure that small and large developers alike are able to contribute to advances in biotechnology, and keep American innovation onshore."
New whitepaper from @EmmaKovak: thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/f… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Abundance is emergent. Abundance is bottom-up. We were not herded and orchestrated: we found each other."
@atrembath's talk from Abundance 2025: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/bottom-up-abundance -
Breakthrough reposted
The Giving Review
@GivingReview
www.liberalpatriot.com/p/the-trouble-with-catastrophe-pol…
On @TheLibPatriot podcast, Ruy Teixeira asks @TheBTI’s @TedNordhaus about climate catastrophists: “What drives these people to be so invested in this narrative and so impervious to any kind of feedback that might lead them to change their minds and their approach?”
Part of Nordhaus’ answer: “[T]he thing that I’m always stunned by and everyone’s like, oh, you know, there’s still this identity that the kind of climate movement and the environmental movement is this sort of scrappy underdog. I mean, it’s just the amount of money. I mean, it’s stunning. It’s stunning. … The Lilly School of Philanthropy at Indiana University estimated eight billion dollars a year in just U.S.-based climate philanthropy.
“And you have to understand that that is not like $8 billion in revenue that some company then goes and takes a very, very small part of that to spend on its lobbying and its public relations or whatever. That’s $8 billion for advocacy and communications and lobbying and all of it.” In D.C., “you walk you walk around this town and there’s entire huge buildings filled with people who do climate. And that’s what they do for their entire careers. And they will do it for their entire careers.
“And so there’s just huge professional incentives.” -
Breakthrough reposted
Elizabeth McCarthy
@3lizabethMcC
At our @TheBTI briefing of “The Procedural Hangover”, @SenatorHick nailed the takeaway: we build faster when we align self-interest across agencies, states, and communities. Grateful to panelists @glicksmanr @ceqalaw @matthewmailbox for a riveting discussion.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Snowmobile Abundance is where to go to find de-extinction, weather modification, solar radiation management, genetic engineering, novel ecosystems, and other advanced human methods for altering, and protecting, the natural environments we care about."
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/snowmobile-abundance -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"Environmentalists are more likely to try to ban these activities than to consider them just another way of communing with the natural world. But it’s not obvious to me why protected areas with dirt trails and agro-tourism on low-productivity farms are inherently more legitimate ways to consume nature than snowmobiling."
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Snowmobile Abundance: Like @RubenGallego and @mattyglesias’s “Big-Ass Truck Abundance” but for nature, another sub-variety of abundance to add to Steve Teles’s framework.
From my latest at The Ecomodernist: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The current moment should establish that when political leaders get truly serious about nuclear energy, it is possible to go much faster than has historically been the case in the US and most other countries."
Read @TedNordhaus:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/on-breaking-nuclear-things -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
You’ve heard @RogerPielk on the bad methods, analysis and peer review of Kotz et al. Here, @JessicaWeinkle unpacks the web of conflicts and stealth advocacy that produced and promoted this absurd analysis and convinced central banks to use it as basis for calculating climate related financial risks.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"When McKibben reports on climate change, he is essentially covering himself."
@TedNordhaus on the strange credulousness given to McKibben, at once the climate movement's chief architect and leading journalist, despite a penchant for misinformation.
www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/how-bill-mckibben-los… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Bill McKibben’s new book is an apologia for the widely discredited methane research of Robert Howarth.
As @hausfath wrote @TheBTI, neither should be taken seriously on the subject. -
Breakthrough reposted
The New Atlantis
@tnajournal
There is just one final, final, final, final chance to save the world, writes Bill McKibben in “Here Comes the Sun,” out this week.
After hearing this so many times, the book does read like the end of something — but not the world, writes @TedNordhaus: www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/how-bill-mckibben-los… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Abundance 2025 is just two weeks away! Thrilled for this event chaired by @ZacharyGraves @pahlkadot, emceed by @makosloff, and supported by so many amazing organizations.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"The far more interesting question that @tylerhnorris raises is not why my colleagues and I at Breakthrough have revised our priors about climate risk but why so many progressive environmentalists like Norris have not."
With shoutouts and arguments for @RogerPielkeJr @JesseJenkins @vsiv @hausfath @jritch @DanielRaimi @Peters_Glen. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Why do so many smart people, most trained as scientists, engineers, lawyers, or public policy experts, and all who will tell you, and I say this not ironically, that they “believe in science,” get the science of climate risk so badly wrong?"
@TedNordhaus for the Ecomodernist:
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
You can read the piece here: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-i-stopped-being-a-clima…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Trump adminstration subsidizing Chinese steel, silica, and solar panels with tax credits for metallurgical coal that is exported to China.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The shotgun approach of the Trump admin only risks wasting limited federal resources on an arbitrary list of pet commodities that are often non-issues. The taxpayer-funded metallurgical coal blunder serves as a prime example."
@PeterCookBTI for @thebti: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-trump-administration-ju… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The shotgun approach of the Trump admin only risks wasting limited federal resources on an arbitrary list of pet commodities that are often non-issues. The taxpayer-funded metallurgical coal blunder serves as a prime example."
@PeterCookBTI for @thebti: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-trump-administration-ju… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
My colleague @PeterCookBTI is too generous... 😛 @Earthjustice staff may have cribbed one of the better lines from an article Peter and I co-wrote without attribution.
I don't think Peter or I really care, but it does speak to the in-group, out-group dynamic among enviro NGOs.
Peter Cook
@PeterCookBTI
If imitation is the highest form of flattery, you can only imagine how honored I am that @SierraClub used a line from a @TheBTI article on critical minerals.
A citation would have been nice though....🧵 -
Breakthrough reposted
The Honest Broker
@RogerPielkeJr
If you read just one thing this week on the EPA Endangerment Finding, read this by @atrembath
Link in reply -
Breakthrough reposted
Peter Cook
@PeterCookBTI
If imitation is the highest form of flattery, you can only imagine how honored I am that @SierraClub used a line from a @TheBTI article on critical minerals.
A citation would have been nice though....🧵 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Agricultural research has been the engine of abundance that feeds a growing world population while reducing the environmental footprint of food production."
Agricultural Research Needs a Farmer-First Focus. @benjamin_goren
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/agricultural-research-needs… -
Breakthrough reposted
Jayson Lusk
@JaysonLusk
Agricultural Research Needs a Farmer-First Focus open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/agricultur…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"A century ago the argument was between preservationists and conservationists. Today, at least according to Mulvaney, the argument is between environmentalism and abundance."
From my latest @TheBTI: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Join us in just over an hour for a discussion with @MikeGrunwald and @p_lehner about the future of food, moderated by @jennysplitter. Register here: us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_vEwvJmfXRkqCHcmCdDHCng
-
Breakthrough reposted
Sentient
@Sentient_Media
📅TODAY
Sentient's @jennysplitter will be moderating a panel presented by @TheBTI, featuring @MikeGrunwald and @p_lehner, as they discuss their visions for the future of food.
Sign up below ⬇️
Sentient
@Sentient_Media
On July 30, join award-winning journalist and author @MikeGrunwald and @Earthjustice's @p_lehner in conversation about the future of food in this virtual webinar moderated by Sentient's Editor-in-Chief @jennysplitter and presented by @TheBTI.
RSVP: us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_vEwvJmfXRkqCHcmCdDHCng -
Breakthrough reposted
Michael Grunwald
@MikeGrunwald
Tune in today at 1pm ET - I’ll be talking about the future of food and farming with the leaders of @Earthjustice and @Sentient_Media. Maybe not the lineup you’d expect from a @TheBTI event, but the idea is to break out of our silos.
us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_vEwvJmfXRkqCHcmCdDHCng -
Breakthrough reposted
James Coleman
@EnergyLawProf
Really great resource- I was proud to help review it!
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
This work benefitted radically from input from our review board @nicholas_bagley @ceqalaw @ProfSchleich @ArnabDatta321 @EnergyLawProf @CSElmendorf.
Shoutout to Nick in particular for his work on the "procedure fetish" that inspired our title. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
If NEPA is to function as an effective tool for safeguarding the environment, policymakers and stakeholders alike must work to streamline the process so that it supports cleaner and more abundant energy and resources. Learn more: navigatingnepa.com
-
Breakthrough reposted
Elizabeth McCarthy
@3lizabethMcC
New report by me and @BTI:
The Procedural Hangover: How NEPA Litigation Obstructs Critical Projects
NEPA litigation reshapes the process. Agencies pad the record, reports get longer, timelines slip, and projects are not built. Hence, the procedural hangover. -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
⚙️ NEW MICROSITE JUST DROPPED ⚙️
Today @TheBTI launched navigatingnepa.com, featuring our analysis and open-source database of over 2000 District-level judicial NEPA opinions. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
NEPA is widely understood as an impediment to timely, orderly, and cost-effective infrastructure investment and deployment.
Explore how NEPA litigation is impacting clean energy, forest management, and much more with our new interactive website:
navigatingnepa.com -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
NEPA litigation imposes costly delays, bureaucratic gridlock, and government dysfunction, all yielding deleterious procedural effects on major beneficial infrastructure investments.
Read our new report: thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/the-procedural-hangover -
Breakthrough reposted
Volker Hahn 🇩🇪🇪🇺🇮🇱
@volkerhahn1
This is a lesson in misleading science communication, amplified by bad media reporting: “A Recent High-Profile Nature Paper Doesn’t Say What Its Authors Say it Does … It is harder to understand, however, why [the authors] portrayed the losses as …
substack.com/home/post/p-169002790 -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
Should a US national critical minerals reserve program act more like the National Defense Stockpile or more like the Strategic Petroleum Reserve? A major new report by my team does a deep dive into this question, looking at 15 minerals relevant to energy.
My thoughts🧵: -
Breakthrough reposted
Peter Cook
@PeterCookBTI
Building US critical mineral supply chains is hard enough - market volatility and export dumping only makes it harder
So Im excited to release @TheBTI 's report that maps 15 US mineral supply chains and which commodities would be best to stockpile under a strategic reserve 🧵 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
A strategic mineral reserve can be a good policy support to build markets and establishing clearinghouses, but physical stockpiles are likely not the answer to short-term critical mineral challenges.
Read @thebti's latest report: thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/taking-inventory-of-cri… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"If the development community is serious about combating hunger by funding fertilizer chemical plants local to SSA, they cannot continue to dogmatically discard petrochemical solutions without giving them serious consideration."
Read @RyanAlimento: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/sub-saharan-africa-cant-aff… -
Breakthrough reposted
Deric Tilson
@econpragmatist
Cost overruns are a huge source of concern for nuclear projects. We @TheBTI have just released ACTION, a proposal aimed at incentivizing nuclear builds to be completed on time and on budget. ACTION is forward-looking and proactively reduces project risk.
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
🏗️Trilled to finally introduce ACTION, to accelerate nuclear energy deployment. It is a milestone-based program to address the root causes of project risk for advanced nuclear energy projects.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"The government should create a milestone-based program for advanced nuclear energy projects that incrementally reduces interest rates through credit subsidies when project milestones are achieved on time."
Important new report @TheBTI:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/action -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Congress should create a milestone-based program for advanced nuclear energy projects that incrementally reduces interest rates through credit subsidies when project milestones are achieved on time."
Read @thebti's Nuclear Team new proposal here: thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/action -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Instead of an overhaul of the LNT model itself, focus should be on pragmatic policy and regulatory adjustments that leverage existing legal discretion."
Read @thebti's PJ Seel and @Dr_A_Stein new white paper on the future of the LNT model:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/drawing-the-line -
Breakthrough reposted
Peter Cook
@PeterCookBTI
The US has so far prioritized permitting reform to build more critical mineral mines
My latest @TheBTI article shows why we need to do more on exploration too
Remember: permitting is only one stage in developing a mine but even finding a deposit can take just as long! -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Reducing federal involvement in mineral exploration risks perpetuating long project lead times, decreasing the number of successful critical mineral mines, and misdirecting valuable private sector investment overseas."
@PeterCookBTI for @thetbti:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/fiscal-austerity-for-th… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
The Breakthrough Journal is now THE ECOMODERNIST.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
We are excited to announce that we are launching a new publication, The Ecomodernist.
Under the banner of The Ecomodernist, we will be publishing relevant analyses and essays that seek to build a new environmental paradigm. Read more here:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/b… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Sacrificing deregulatory goals in favor of short-term “wins” for downsizing the federal government is a mistake."
Read @EmilyJane_Bass on the risk workforce reduction at key federal agencies poses on the future of agricultural biotechnology:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/p… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Iran has enriched uranium far beyond what is necessary for either civilian energy or medical use, but has stayed short of the threshold of a weapon, creating public uncertainty."
Read @MattLWald's breakdown of Iran's nuclear program: thebreakthroughjournal.substack.com/p/irans-nuclear-activ… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Iran has enriched uranium far beyond what is necessary for either civilian energy or medical use, but has stayed short of the threshold of a weapon, creating public uncertainty."
@MattLWald breaks down Iran's nuclear program. Read here:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/irans-nuclear-activitie… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"For defenders of technocratic competence and skeptics, the coming years will be a test of whether an admin bent on radically reducing the regulatory and bureaucratic obstacles to deploying energy technology and infrastructure can deliver the goods."
@TedNordhaus for @thebti:
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Read the post here: thebreakthroughjournal.substack.com/p/state-power-without…
-
Breakthrough reposted
YIMBY Democrats for America 🇺🇸🗽
@YIMBYDems
New episode of Radio Abundance, starring @atrembath of @TheBTI!🎙️🇺🇸🗽
They've been in the Abundance game for 20 years, fighting for the planet and the environment. We discuss how to actually fight climate change and why nuclear energy is truly safe.
Links below!👇 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
By extending policy support to nascent energy technologies that would've been phased out by the "One Big Beautiful" Bill, the Senate reconcilation draft bill represents a major improvement.
Read @wang_seaver @RyanAlimento @atrembath on IRA reform in the reconciliation bill
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
You can find the piece here: thebreakthroughjournal.substack.com/p/a-lifeline-for-clea…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Peter Cook
@PeterCookBTI
@TheBTI, @wang_seaver, and I wrote more extensively on the Mining Regulatory Clarity Act if you want a deeper dive.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/can-the-mining-regulato… -
Breakthrough reposted
Peter Cook
@PeterCookBTI
Remember the Rosemont Copper project that has been tied up in all those permitting lawsuits since 2017?
Well, apparently the proposed One Big Beautiful Bill Act does not 🧵 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"A 'loser-pays' model could be crucial in shifting the burden away from public agencies and developers and placing it on litigants who weaponize uncertainty without prevailing in court."
Read @3lizabethMcC on alternatives to the NEPA reforms currently in Reconciliation:
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
You can read the post here: thebreakthroughjournal.substack.com/p/shifting-the-cost-o…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
The first in-depth reports to the Spanish government on the Iberian blackouts on April 28 have begun circulating this week. My sense of the summary is that grid oscillations and operator corrections caused overvoltages that triggered protection trips, with insufficient synchronous generators online that day and operating synchronous generators perhaps failing to control voltage as expected. Some renewable trips that possibly occurred within operable standards are under investigation. Overall seems possible there will be some responsibility to go all around.
Importantly, available inertia was sufficient, frequency change during the incident was not a problem at least until the cascading failure was unrecoverable. -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Very pleased to jointly endorse Commissioner David Wright for a new term @NRCgov with @GoodEnergyColl. In a moment of increasing partisanship at the NRC, we believe that Chair Wright is the best choice to turn down the temperature and sustain America's bipartisan commitment to nuclear regulatory modernization.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Dr. Emma Kovak
@EmmaKovak
Misleading framing in @Nature paper suggests global crop production will decrease by 2100. In fact, it only predicts that crop yields will grow more slowly than if climate change wasn’t happening, meaning they will very likely continue to grow. 🧵
doi.org/10.1038/s41586-025-09085-w -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"David Wright is the right man to accelerate the pace of regulatory reform and commercialization of advanced nuclear technology and to restore a modicum of bipartisanship" to the NRC.
Read @TedNordhaus and Erik Funkhouser (@GoodEnergyColl) statement on Wright's renomination. -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
The Breakthrough Institute @thebti and Good Energy Collective @GoodEnergyColl support the renomination of David Wright to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-wright-man-for-the-job
-
Breakthrough reposted
Dan Rejto 🇺🇸🌎🍴
@danrejto
Many think that eating local helps the climate. But exporting more U.S. beef, especially to China, could cut global emissions by millions of tons.
Why? American beef has a far lower carbon footprint than beef from Brazil and other major exporters.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-trump-can-quietly-cut-g… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
⚙️ ⚛️ 🚜 🌆 🚀 🌎
REGISTER NOW for Abundance 2025, taking place this September in Washington DC.
Early bird pricing ends soon!
⚙️ ⚛️ 🚜 🌆 🚀 🌎
www.abundancedc.org -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"As a growing number of countries seek to strike trade deals with the U.S., the Trump administration quietly has the opportunity to mark a win for both U.S. beef producers and global climate emissions."
Read @benjamin_goren on the climate comparative advantage of U.S. beef:
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
You can read the piece here: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-trump-can-quietly-cut-g…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Peter Cook
@PeterCookBTI
The ongoing budget discussions in Congress have proposed to eliminate the $7,500 tax credit on new electric vehicle sales and the $4,000 credit for used electric vehicles......🧵
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"The NRC remains critically in need of reform and modernization. But those efforts will almost certainly fail if the result is to return to the partisan polarization around nuclear energy that crippled the industry over the last generation." thebreakthrough.org/press/release-breakthrough-institute-…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Nuclear-grade concrete is 1.5x the price of regular concrete, and is one of the most used materials in nuclear construction.
@MattLWald breaks down a few examples of how some companies are trying to reduce costs by cutting out some concrete:
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
You can read the piece here: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/to-cut-nuclear-costs-cut-co…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Without guidance from Congress, legal uncertainty and ongoing changes to NEPA implementing regulations could stymie a core goal of NEPA reforms—providing the stable regulatory environment we need to build big things.
Read Marc Levitt's first piece for @thebti:
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
You can read the piece in full here: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-widening-vacuum-of-nepa…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"In a post-IRA, post-inflation world, regulatory reform is at the cutting edge of infrastructure, economic, and environmental policy."
Why I'm so excited to welcome Marc Levitt, @TheBTI's new Director of Environmental Regulatory Reform. -
Breakthrough reposted
Lauren Teixeira
@lrntex
California has always insisted that it is possible to pursue aggressive environmental policy without inflicting economic harm. An impending gasoline shortage and sky-high pump prices will refute this idea. In @TheBTI today I trace the factors leading up to this Icarian moment 🧵
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"For a long time, the state has sought to gaslight the public into believing California can have it all—pristine air, rapid emissions reductions and affordable energy."
According to @lrntex, high gas prices in California refutes this fantasy: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-california-regulated-it… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
California's mandated gasoline blend and low-carbon fuels standard have had their intended effect: raising the price of gasoline and forcing in-state refining capacity to consolidate and close. It's about to get worse, and Newsom/Democrats are panicking.
via @TheBTI's @lrntex -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
For year's, Gavin Newsom and other prominent California Democrats have blamed the state's high gas prices on oil company greed. Meanwhile, oil companies kept closing refineries and leaving the state because they couldn't make money due to the state's environmental regime. Now, CA's environmental and climate policy chickens are coming home to roost. Demand is outpacing supply with no obvious end in sight. Gas prices could spike to $8/gallon this year. New analysis @TheBTI from @lrntex.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"True NRC modernization would require the agency to adopt the standard set in the 1990 amendments to the Clean Air Act."
Read a new whitepaper from @Dr_A_Stein, @stoohill13, and @MattLWald for @thebti: thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/clarifying-the-limits-o… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
If you are interested in evidence-based recommendations on how to make effective and durable improvements to implement the recent executive orders and deploy nuclear energy, we have a series of publications on the way!
-
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
LNT and ALARA, two polarizing terms in nuclear energy. The NRC was tasked with reconsidering both the LNT radiation model and ALARA requirement by a recent executive order. But, many misunderstand what LNT and ALARA are, and what pragmatic evidence-based solutions are available
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The NRC must pursue regulatory approaches that reflect current scientific understanding, acknowledge uncertainty, and achieve more balanced risk management."
Read PJ Seel and @Dr_A_Stein for @thebti: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-to-regulate-radiation-e… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The USDA’s regulatory framework must take a scientifically-sound view of risk and not unnecessarily delay key innovations."
Read @EmmaKovak's piece for @TheBTI:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/trump-has-an-opportunity-to… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Folks insisting that IRA repeal will be the death of advanced nuclear need to account for the fact that Republicans might just make sure that tax credits for nuclear and other technologies they support survive. They may not do that the way that we @TheBTI have recommended. But the reality is that whether our way or this way👇, most of the tax credit money is in wind, solar, and consumer EV credits and Republicans can keep pretty much everything else and still cut most of the tax credit spending.
-
Breakthrough reposted
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Failure to acknowledge the need for fossil fuels for economic growth risks jeopardizing both African development and the clean energy transition at large."
@RyanAlimento @wang_seaver analyze the mineral industries of the DRC, Guinea, and Mozambique.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/sub-saharan-africa-needs-fo… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ryan Alimento
@RyanAlimento
First study from @wang_seaver and me in my time at @TheBTI. Technical analysis shows that sub-Saharan Africa needs fossil fuels to internalize the value of its critical mineral resources and advance development via chemical and metallurgical processing
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/sub-saharan-africa-needs-fo… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Partisanship begets partisanship. It only took five months of a Trump admin to prove wrong the Democrat's theory that green spending in red states would protect the IRA from future Republican cuts.
Read @TedNordhaus on the failure of the "Green Vortex":
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/after-the-green-vortex -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
If the Trump administration is serious about their stated goal of 400GW of nuclear capacity by 2050, then the four executive orders signed late last week are just the beginning.
@thebti's nuclear team weighs in:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/can-trump-expedite-a-nuclea… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
RFK Jr. and the MAHA movement continue to point to pesticide use, especially glyphosate, as a leading cause of chronic illness. This is a fundamental misunderstanding.
Read @EmilyJane_Bass's mythbusting here: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/mythbusting-maha-a-reality-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
The US needs a regulator that can license new reactors, and a government capable of enabling the industry to grow. These Executive Orders signal that the admin understands the value of nuclear and the role that the government must play in its resurgence.
thebreakthrough.org/press/release-four-nuclear-executive-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The current state of U.S. agricultural biotechnology regulation remains overly burdensome and fails to allocate resources based on the actual risks associated with genetically engineered organisms."
Read @EmmaKovak's new white paper for @thebti: thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/s… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"Continually adding to the critical minerals list in response to stakeholder lobbying only dilutes limited federal resources intended to prioritize minerals of greater concern."
via @wang_seaver @PeterCookBTI @TheBTI. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"It’s funny that everyone wants their mineral on the USGS critical mineral list when the goal of critical mineral policy should really be to remove them."
@PeterCookBTI and @wang_seaver on Trump's executive order declaring coal a "critical mineral."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/if-every-mineral-is-critica… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Would the nuclear industry would be better off without the Nuclear Regulatory Commission? Is the Trump administration's shake up of bureaucracy good for the industry? And what about spent fuel?
@Dr_A_Stein @MattLWald weigh in on 7 nuclear misconceptions
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/seven-more-things-you-thoug… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
Correcting seven misconceptions about building new nuclear energy. Some people are very entrenched on a few of these misconceptions. with @MattLWald www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/seven-more-things-you-thoug…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Nuclear winter would destroy civilization beyond repair within months or years. Yet unlike climate change, which has preoccupied activists for decades, it is largely ignored."
@TedNordhaus @mark_lynas on nuclear war and the climate for @washingtonpost
www.wsj.com/opinion/one-nuclear-war-can-ruin-the-whole-cl… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“The repeal of the existing tax credits would not ring the death knell for a nuclear resurgence, but it would remove the scaffolding supporting its construction.”
@Dr_A_Stein @econpragmatist break down how IRA rollbacks will affect the nuclear buildout
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/does-nuclear-energy-need-th… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"Denying poor countries financing to prevent them from developing with fossil fuels is equivalent to killing the village to save it, making poor people more vulnerable to climate extremes to prevent them from emitting greenhouse gases." Me and @vijramachandran in @ForeignPolicy.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Concentrating IRA cuts on the most mature sectors—solar, onshore wind, and EVs—would save almost as much money as the Ways & Means reconciliation text, without kneecapping critical emerging industries like nuclear, geothermal, AI, critical minerals, and hydrogen.
New @TheBTI: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Federal financial support is the rule, not the exception, in energy technology innovation."
@atrembath @wang_seaver @RyanAlimento critique the Republican's proposed reconciliation legislation for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/saving-money-without-underc… -
Breakthrough reposted
Zachary Bogue
@zackbogue
Wow. Terrific post from @TedNordhaus of the Breakthrough Institue (@TheBTI).
Phenomenal advice to climate philanthropists--so many good quotes that it wouldn't fit into one tweet! 1/6 -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"So you want to get into climate philanthropy?"
@TedNordhaus explains how to not set your money on fire — and actually help fix the climate — for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/dont-set-your-money-on-fire -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"If your benchmark for success is net-zero by 2050 or strategic impact in 2-3 years, you should just set your money on fire and heat your home with it."
My advice to new climate philanthropists @TheBTI -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Biofuels increase food prices; incentivize more agricultural land-use and risk deforestation and other environmental problems."
@danrejto on the risks of biofuel subsidies amidst ongoing debates on how best to support suffering U.S. farmers
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/biofuel-policy-is-failing-c… -
Breakthrough reposted
Deric Tilson
@econpragmatist
"Overly narrow or outdated environmental reviews delay or block the deployment of zero-emission nuclear infrastructure, undermining both climate goals and more direct environmental impacts...
That cannot continue."
My team's latest @TheBTI
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Environmental review is a critical safeguard, but the NRC can uphold environmental standards while modernizing the process to ensure it aligns with today’s energy imperatives."
@joyjiang1997 @spencertoohill & @econpragmatist for @thebti Journal: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/environmental-reviews-shoul… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Environmental review is a critical safeguard, but the NRC can uphold environmental standards while modernizing the process to ensure it aligns with today’s energy imperatives."
@joyjiang1997 @spencertoohill & @econpragmatist for @thebti Journal: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/environmental-reviews-shoul… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Wind and solar power contribute meaningfully to modern electric grids. But their benefits to the power system—modularity and low marginal costs—have to be balanced against their shortcomings."
@wang_seaver @atrembath on lessons from Spain's blackout
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/its-okay-to-notice-when… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Humans have been genetically engineering wolves for our purposes for tens of thousands of years. They’re called dogs."
@atrembath weighs in on the dire wolf controversy for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/courtesy-of-colossal-biosci… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
Trump’s new executive order to speed US permitting for seafloor mineral collection in international waters challenges the International Seabed Authority to put its act together--and finalize its alternative, multilaterally-governed mineral regulations.
New piece by me: 🧵 -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“A credible alternative regulatory framework must offer a viable path for seafloor mineral projects to move forward.”
via @wang_seaver www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/an-america-first-challenge-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The Trump administration’s seafloor minerals declaration must be understood as a call to action for international stakeholders to finalize the ISA mining code as quickly as possible."
@wang_seaver's warning to the international community for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/an-america-first-challenge-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Whether or not the US made any commitment to cut its emissions, it would become the world’s climate policeman."
@TedNordhaus writes on the sinister implications of the climate realism doctrine for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-worst-thing-about-the-c… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
I have a new essay out, about how Avocado Politics came to the Council on Foreign Relations. This was a really hard essay to write because the person who led @CFR_org's new Climate Realism project is a long-time colleague, Varun Sivaram, who I have great respect for.
As I note in the piece, I agree with much of the Climate Realism doctrine, including its clear eyed view on emissions, climate targets, and clean energy. I've published @vsiv in @TheBTI Journal. He's been a long time participant in the Breakthrough Dialogue. He even served on our board for a time. But I felt an obligation to speak out against the Climate Realism doctrine because of its exaggerated claims about climate risk, which result in the notion that developing world emissions represent an existential threat to the American homeland.
Varun, in some ways, is collateral damage. My real beef here is with CFR and the center-left political establishment, which allowed itself, over the last decade, to get captured by the climate movement. Climate Realism is simply the logical endpoint of the climate catastrophism that the climate movement has manufactured over the last several decades and that too many Democrats, progressives, and otherwise thoughtful people unthinkingly endorsed in the belief that turning up the volume on the "climate crisis" would create the political will necessary to rapidly accelerate the energy transition.
Varun has assured me that he is not proposing that the United States actually take military action to prevent emerging economies from emitting greenhouse gases, at least in the near term, and I take him at his word. But that is the logical conclusion of the catastrophism that informs not only Climate Realism but Democratic and center-left politics around climate change. If you really believed 2 or 3 degrees of warming to be civilization endangering, and that developing economy emissions are equivalent to "missiles" aimed at the American homeland that threaten the survival of American society, then bombing emerging economies back to the stone age would be a rational response.
In this sense, I'm quite grateful to Varun for making these entailments of the center-left's climate catastrophism more explicit. Because so many activists, journalists, Democratic politicians, and other thought leaders on the Left have so demonized any challenge to catastrophic climate framings as science denial, there hasn't been much debate on the Left about either what is actually particularly well established scientifically or the risks of overindexing on those exaggerated risks. This has allowed an endemic and lazy catastrophism to take hold, justified by poorly specified arguments about tail risks, planetary boundaries, and similar.
Varun's intent, was to open up a conversation about what the US might need to do to protect itself from these existential risks. But his contribution here is best viewed, in my opinion, as a provocation. It reminds us that there are real consequences when advocates and their scientific and political allies exaggerate threats in service of their political and ideological goals. Here's hoping that we can have a more open conversation on the Left about the many substantial risks of overstating climate risk. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The simple fact is that neither Democrats nor the Abundance movement can succeed unless they offer solutions for the great majority of Americans..."
@ceqalaw offers a critique of Klein and Thompson's new book, Abundance for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/abundance-for-who -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"It’s not too late for a nascent Abundance movement to acknowledge its urbanist bias. Failing to do so will prolong rather than repair the chasm of distrust the majority of Americans have for Democrats, the cities and states they run, and their policy choices."
Essential reading from Jennifer Hernandez @TheBTI -
Breakthrough reposted
Deric Tilson
@econpragmatist
@MattLWald and I discuss the recent "Clean Beautiful Coal" EO and how price expectations determine investments more than policy in our latest @BTI.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Trump’s executive orders are a bit like building new runways that the airports will need on the day that pigs fly."
@MattLWald and @econpragmatist on Trump's coal policy, the mechanics of the grid, and what it will take for nuclear to succeed
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-to-define-nuclear-success -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Trump’s executive orders are a bit like building new runways that the airports will need on the day that pigs fly."
@MattLWald and @econpragmatist on Trump's coal policy, the mechanics of the grid, and what it will take for nuclear to succeed
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-to-define-nuclear-success -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
ICYMI: We argue to phasing out eligibility for the IRA's tech-neutral tax credits after a given technology has achieved a measure of commercial maturity (namely, 5% grid penetration w/in a given NERC region).
-
Breakthrough reposted
Jennifer Pahlka
@pahlkadot
Incredibly honored to do this with @ZacharyGraves, the team at @TheBTI, and many others. So excited for Sept 4-5 in DC. Mark your calendars!
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
The estimable @pahlkadot and @ZacharyGraves will co-chair Abundance 2025.
mailchi.mp/7b6b4611ae14/cochairs] -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Until large reactor advocates come up with a serious plan to remake the power sector 'just build large light water reactors' will remain a slogan, not a serious political program."
@TedNordhaus on the pitfalls of nuclear advocacy for @TheBTI
thebreakthrough.org/articles/nuclear-underpants-gnomes?x-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Pegging the clean electricity tax credits to grid penetration instead of emissions is better technology policy and could save hundreds of billions of dollars.
New by @wang_seaver @RyanAlimento @TedNordhaus and me @TheBTI: -
Breakthrough reposted
AgFunder
@AgFunder
Blocking federal funding for R&D projects mentioning ‘climate change' 'greenhouse gas emissions' and related terms “would directly undermine US farmers’ competitiveness and long-term output,” warns a new report from environmental think tank The @TheBTI agfundernews.com/censoring-climate-in-ag-research-will-ba…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
One way or another, Republicans will almost certainly take a pound of flesh out of the IRA. In a new @TheBTI analysis, we find that tying clean tech subsidy phase out to grid penetration/market share instead of emissions goals can save close to a half billion dollars while preserving investment in early stage technologies such as advanced nuclear and geothermal.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Subsidy-driven technology policy is best when leveraged to maximize innovation, not to prop up already mature technologies.
Our proposal to reform the IRA prioritizes innovation while saving the federal government up to $421 billion.
Read here: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/technology-policy-not-emiss… -
Breakthrough reposted
Elaine Watson
@EWatsonWrites
"Indiscriminate cuts" to climate-related USDA funding will hurt farmers and weaken US agriculture, says @TheBTI "Many climate-related projects have clear productivity benefits for farmers." www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/stifling-agricultural-resea…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Dan Rejto 🇺🇸🌎🍴
@danrejto
A leaked memo suggests the Department of Agriculture wants to halt research mentioning "climate" and related terms. Our new analysis estimates that could affect over $400 million of funding across agencies. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/stifling-agricultural-resea…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"A blanket cut for all research projects with a climate component won’t just hinder climate progress—it would directly weaken the long-term viability of American farming."
@benjamin_goren @danrejto on the risks of Trump’s climate denial for agriculture
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/stifling-agricultural-resea… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Lasers can work with a smaller physical footprint – and smaller capital expense—because they handle more material than a centrifuge does."
@MattLWald explains why the Department of Energy should explore laser enrichment
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/will-laser-enrichment-be-th… -
Breakthrough reposted
Emily Bass
@EmilyJane_Bass
MAHA's narrow focus on pesticides, seed oils, UPFs is setting the movement's vision for the food system up to fail -- distracting from the chance to invest in real public health interventions, while making healthy foods less affordable and accessible. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/mythbusting-mahas-claims-ab…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Should Kennedy succeed in implementing his agenda, he risks making America's food supply less healthy and more expensive—undermining the MAHA Commission’s own objectives."
Read @EmilyJane_Bass on MAHA and RFK's dangerous myths.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/mythbusting-mahas-claims-ab… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Breakthrough is proud to cohost Abundance 2025 this September in Washington, DC, alongside our parters: @ACC_National @JoinFAI @scientistsorg @Inclsvabundance @IFP @metroabundance @NiskanenCenter @RSI @yimbyaction @Arnold_Ventures @ProgressChamber @open_phil @StandTogether @InnovateEconomy
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Now is the perfect time to contest, not to crystallize, the meaning and mission of abundance."
@atrembath reflects on abundance today vs. 2022, what's changed, what's endured, and revisits his and @TedNordhaus's essay from three years ago
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/abundance-and-its-discontents -
Breakthrough reposted
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
When @PatrickTBrown31 came to talk to me about the starting up a climate prediction market, I couldn't really muster up much of an argument against it. I'm incredibly proud of the work that he's done @TheBTI and was honored to stand with him in the wake of his criticisms of @Nature and other high profile journals. The production and dissemination of climate science is broken and continues to result in deep mischaracterizations of climate risk. But while it is easy to criticize, it is hard to build something better. So huge respect for Patrick's decision to go build something better.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Scaling up these prediction markets in the climate and energy sector will bring clarity that has often been lacking from both academic and private sector climate predictions."
@PatrickTBrown31 on his pivot to prediction markets for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/why-i-left-breakthrough-to-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“I have greatly appreciated the intellectual environment and believe that emphasizing the principles of Ecomodernism offers significant value to the energy and climate dialogue.”
@PatrickTBrown31 on leaving @TheBTI to work on prediction markets:
open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/why-i-left… -
Breakthrough reposted
John Dobken
@JohnDobken
Making the Case for #nuclear Energy in Virginia. Spencer Toohill with @TheBTI speaking at a workshop for policymakers and stakeholders in Lynchburg.
Strong agenda for the day! -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"As the demand for clean, reliable energy continues to grow, the NRC must streamline approaches that maintain regulatory efficiency while ensuring strong environmental protections."
Read @spencertoohill @joyjiang1997's comment on the NRC's new GEIS draft
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/strengthening-the-nrcs-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Preferring the private sector to run certain aspects of our economy is fine, but some things simply will not be done unless the public sector acts."
@MattLWald on how the government should function when it comes to uranium enrichment for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/dont-leave-uranium-enrichme… -
Breakthrough reposted
Bjorn Lomborg
@BjornLomborg
The proposed California Superfund to dubiously force fossil fuel companies to pay for LA fires
will only cover 0.2% of the cost
"because anthropogenic climate change simply remains a minor contributing factor in the frequency, intensity, and cost of natural disasters"
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Policy penalties on fossil fuel corporations will play a minor role at most in either accelerating decarbonization or financing societal resilience to extreme weather."
@atrembath @lrntex @PatrickTBrown31 on the California Climate Superfund Laws
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-much-does-big-oil-owe-c… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Since 2011, China has consistently consumed more coal than the rest of the world combined."
Vijaya Ramachandran & @wang_seaver caution against lauding China in the energy transition for @ForeignPolicy
foreignpolicy.com/2025/03/20/china-climate-emissions-rene… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"It is easy for the White House to kick things down. It is a lot harder to build awe-inspiring things that empower a nation to lead the world. Congress needs to step up."
@JessicaWeinkle's new piece explains why we need NOAA for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/gutting-noaa-is-a-bad-idea -
Breakthrough reposted
Jessica Weinkle
@JessicaWeinkle
Kerfuffle re: NOAA is a good opportunity for legislators to think critically and deliberately about how to best wrangle the agency into serving US needs and maritime interests
History on NOAA and contemporary areas of debate👇
Gutting NOAA is a Bad Idea www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/gutting-noaa-is-a-bad-idea?… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Policy penalties on fossil fuel corporations will play a minor role at most in either accelerating decarbonization or financing societal resilience to extreme weather."
@atrembath @lrntex @PatrickTBrown31 on the California Climate Superfund Laws
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-much-does-big-oil-owe-c… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
If California’s “climate Superfund” bill passes, large emitters collectively would be, hypothetically, liable for 0.2% of the damages from the LA fires.
New analysis by me @lrntex @PatrickTBrown31 @TheBTI: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-much-does-big-oil-owe-c… -
Breakthrough reposted
Emily Bass
@EmilyJane_Bass
To those farm state Senators that assumed RFK Jr. would leave ag policy to USDA... it's starting. 1/5
www.nytimes.com/2025/03/18/health/kennedy-bird-flu.html -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
On cue, egg prices start falling just as @TheBTI @benjamin_goren predicted.
Dan Rejto 🇺🇸🌎🍴
@danrejto
Bird flu is seasonal. This fall in prices was predictable. There were big declines early 2023 and 2024. Prices likely would have fallen regardless of federal policy as @benjamin_goren noted. Still, glad to see more efforts & funding to control bird flu. thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/w…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“Until now, with this study, there’s really been no rigorous analysis that combines these two pieces of the puzzle,” @danrejto in @washingtonpost's review of new study that reveals grass-fed beef does not have fewer emissions than conventional cattle.
www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2025/03/17/gra… -
Breakthrough reposted
Dan Rejto 🇺🇸🌎🍴
@danrejto
New study published today reaffirms that grass-fed beef in the US is not more climate-friendly than conventional beef. As I'm quoted, accounting for grass-fed's increased land use actually makes it significantly *less* climate-friendly. www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2025/03/17/gra…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
Lastly, @econpragmatist @MattLWald @Dr_A_Stein
described risks US-Canada tariffs could pose to affordability of electricity, to availability of clean power like 🇨🇦's hydro + nuclear, and to energy system reliability.
Superstar team, full stop. (END) 🧵
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/a-trade-war-threatens-y… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
Long ago I could promote all my @TheBTI colleagues' great work--now it's far harder to keep up. In one month our nuclear policy team has published eight amazing pieces.🧵
@Dr_A_Stein @kyledanish weighed on risks of legal challenge to the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission... -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The price impact of a trade war on consumers is not that some of the incoming electricity is more expensive; it’s that all the electricity is more."
@econpragmatist @MattLWald @Dr_A_Stein on the environmental and economic costs of the Trump trade war
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/a-trade-war-threatens-your-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Now that a court has recognized @michaelemann's proclivity for falsehoods and misinformation, fully endorsed by climate movement and philanthropy, and outlets like @nytimes. reupping two pieces on Mann and the many false and incendiary claims he has made about me and @TheBTI.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Shutting down Diablo Canyon would incentivize more natural gas or other fossil fuel generation, increasing greenhouse gas emissions, and undermining the state’s goal of achieving carbon neutrality."
@joyjiang1997 on the Diablo Canyon's license renewal
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/diablo-canyons-license-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Dan Rejto 🇺🇸🌎🍴
@danrejto
Over 300 groups, including @TheBTI, call for science, not misinformation, to guide the new MAHA Commission's efforts. Biotech & modern ag practices are important for sustainability. Banning safe, proven tech hurts farmers, consumers, and the environment. soygrowers.com/news-releases/food-ag-community-to-maha-co…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"This flurry of America First announcements were punctuated with abrupt and seemingly uncoordinated efforts to shrink the scientific workforce."
@EmilyJane_Bass on the contradictions and dangers of Trump's stance towards agricultural innovation
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/can-america-first-succeed-i… -
Breakthrough reposted
Jonah Messinger
@JonahMessinger
Great piece by @atrembath for @TheBTI
The Era of the Climate Hawk Is Over open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/the-era-of… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Environmental Justice communities swung more decisively towards Trump than non-EJ communities. New analysis from @atrembath and @lrntex @TheBTI.
The premise of Biden climate and EJ strategies was that delivering clean energy jobs and environmental benefits would assure that EJ communities turned out strongly for Democrats. But unsurprisingly, economic growth and energy prices mattered a lot more to those communities, especially since the Biden administration struggled to overcome its own procedural fetishes sufficiently to deliver the EJ goods. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"As temperatures warm and cases decline this summer, egg producers and consumers should find temporary relief, allowing the Trump administration to claim a win for the changing of the seasons."
@benjamin_goren on the politics of eggs for @TheBTI journal
substack.com/home/post/p-158807658?source=queue -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"The uncertain future of the public agricultural research workforce could slow the development and deployment of the type of new technologies that have provided consumers with increasingly affordable eggs for decades."
- @TheBTI's Benjamin Goren
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/who-will-take-credit-when-e… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Democratic messaging on inflation and egg prices risks handing Trump a big win. New @TheBTI from Ben Goran. open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/who-will-t…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
The Era of the Climate Hawk Is Over. New from @atrembath @TheBTI . open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/the-era-of…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
The Era of the Climate Hawks is Over.
Read more @TheBTI Journal:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-era-of-the-climate-hawk… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Well, it’s 2025 now, and decadence is dead"
@atrembath dives into the political atmosphere that built the climate hawk, and the current trends that have killed it
Read here: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-era-of-the-climate-hawk… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"We should not make our nuclear industry dependent on Russian exports. The clear solution is either tariffs or outright market restrictions."
@MattLWald explains the dangers of Trump's Russia friendly approach for the nuclear sector in @TheBTI journal
open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/a-place-wh… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Most of the concern about President Trump’s tariff strategy is that it will raise costs and reduce international trade, but in the case of nuclear fuel, the opposite may be true."
Read @MattLWald on the uranium industry for @thebti Journal.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/a-place-where-tariffs-would… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"Kennedy only became a problem for NRDC when he began trafficking misinformation and fraudulent science about the wrong topics. But Kennedy and MAHA were operating from the same playbook that the environmental movement invented a generation ago."
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"A system of rules that favors older technologies over newer, smarter ones is not what the industry needs, and not what Congress or the NRC itself wants."
@joyjiang1997 @spencertoohill on NRC's new rules under Part 53 and regulating advanced reactors
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/writing-rules-that-work… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Had Kennedy limited his misinformation, grandstanding to nuclear energy, pesticides, and GMOs, and his palling around to Vandana Shiva and not Rogan, he would still be a senior attorney at NRDC in good standing."
@TedNordhaus on RFK & environmentalism
substack.com/home/post/p-158407160?source=queue -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Voters were more comfortable with the earlier, narrower idea of environmental justice than the broadly ambitious one espoused by the Biden administration."
@lrntex @atrembath on why EJ communities largely swung towards Trump for @TheBTI journal
thebreakthrough.org/journal/no-20-spring-2024/environment… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
How Fossil Fuels Saved the Whales, Twice
@EdConwaySky is too quick to dismiss Nordhaus et al. Technology tends to beget effective regulation, not vice versa.
@JonahMessinger and my latest @TheBTI: -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The route to environmental conservation lies in improved technologies that are not merely better with respect to environmental metrics, but genuinely superior on techno-economic grounds."
@atrembath @JonahMessinger on substitution and sustainability
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-fossil-fuels-saved-the-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"By addressing stakeholder concerns and refining the rule, the NRC can create a regulatory environment that supports the safe and timely, and cost-effective deployment of reactors."
Read the new stakeholder consensus on revising Part 53 at @TheBTI
thebreakthrough.org/articles/stakeholder-consensus-on-pro… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Including exposure and vulnerability not just physical hazards, analyzing total risk not just additional risk, limiting publication bias, and attempting description instead of mobilization: @PatrickTBrown31 on how to fix the National Climate Assessment.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"So why was this version of the research more challenging to publish in a high-profile venue? I think the key difference lies in the framing."
@PatrickTBrown31 on the politics of scientific publishing and climate adaptation for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/do-climate-adaptation-strat… -
Breakthrough reposted
Matthew L. Wald
@MattLWald
We can’t insult #canada with tariff threats and then expect Ontario’s big public utility to take on the first-of-a-kind risk to build our small modular reactor design, the GE-Hitachi BWRX-300 #nuclear plant. My take: shorturl.at/C4mRb
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Tariffs could stifle the effort to build the 300-megawatt GE-Hitachi SMR, pushing Canadian utilities into using Canadian, rather than U.S. technology."
@MattLWald on the dangers of Trump's trade policy for the nuclear sector www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/tariffs-cant-help-an-intern… -
Breakthrough reposted
Dan Rejto 🇺🇸🌎🍴
@danrejto
Firings at the Department of Agriculture are affecting agricultural research, much of it in rural areas, that helps farmers be more efficient, sustainable, and reslient, explains my @TheBTI colleague @emilyjane_bass.
WIRED
@WIRED
The blanket firing of Department of Agriculture scientists has thrown a host of climate science and crop projects into chaos. www.wired.com/story/usda-layoffs-throw-climate-and-crop-p…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The industry is optimistic but has already put the brakes on several projects due to uncertainty. A rapidly changing landscape doesn’t encourage investment in an 80-year asset."
@Dr_A_Stein @spencertoohill on nuclear under the Trump administration
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/opportunities-and-uncertain… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“This approach of wide-swath firings throws the USDA and affiliated agricultural research enterprise into a world of uncertainty.”
- @TheBTI’s @emilyjane_bass www.wired.com/story/usda-layoffs-throw-climate-and-crop-p… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The NRC should revisit its proposal to ensure that it has established a metric for protection of health and safety that is consistent with the Clean Air Act."
Read @Dr_A_Stein @kyledanish's new white paper on the NRC's risk standards below
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/implications-for-nrc-co… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The National Climate Assessment could be recognized as valuable by both parties instead of merely reflecting the perspective of the party in office at the time of its creation."
@PatrickTBrown31's five recommendations for the NCA in @TheBTI journal
open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/recommenda… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Even though 1st Trump administration compensated US farmers, US trade war with China resulted in substantial long term loss of market share for US farmers. That's bad for US farmers, global agriculture, and environment. @alexjmssmith in @TheBTI Journal. open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/the-world-…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Smith
@alexjmssmith
It's been said that the NBA is "better" when the Knicks are good. In short, when the most popular teams are winning, everyone benefits.
In agricultural terms, the United States are the Knicks. When U.S. farms lead, we all benefit. Tariffs threaten that: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-world-is-better-when-am… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Clearly there is room for change in how American producers feed the U.S. and the world, but a trade war is not the way to make that change."
@alexjmssmith on Trump's tariff policy and its implications for U.S. food production for @TheBTI journal
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-world-is-better-when-am… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Reactor managers lose sleep over the possibility of needing a replacement part from a company that doesn’t exist anymore."
@MattLWald explores the potential of 3-D printing for the nuclear sector for @TheBTI journal
substack.com/home/post/p-156971944?source=queue&autoPlay=… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
As @nils_gilman observed in @TheBTI Journal, fittingly titled "The Coming Avocado Politics," a lot of radical environmental ideas will live more comfortably in this world, as opposed to utopian academic expressions of them, on the right, not the left. thebreakthrough.org/journal/no-12-winter-2020/avocado-pol…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Efforts to shift away from fossil fuels will need to be balanced with portfolios of energy sources that provide continuous, reliable energy for the modern digital economy."
@vijramachandran @juzel_lloyd @wang_seaver on data centers for @TheBTI journal
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/data-centers-emerging-econo… -
Breakthrough reposted
Macdonald-Laurier Institute
@MLInstitute
"#canada can strengthen the resilience of the global nuclear industry, ensure the pathway to a decarbonized world & reaffirm its position as a global energy powerhouse... the opportunity to act is now." - @juzel_lloyd | @TheBTI @AtlanticCouncil
macdonaldlaurier.ca/securing-the-nuclear-future-how-enhan… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"It’s time for Canada to leverage its strengths to redefine the global nuclear supply chain and establish a more secure, reliable future for the nuclear industry."
Read @juzel_lloyd's argument for securing Canadian enrichment capacity in @MLInstitute
macdonaldlaurier.ca/securing-the-nuclear-future-how-enhan… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
The IRA's clean energy spending ties deployment subsidies to emissions targets. This was never the point of the "make clean energy cheap" alternative to carbon pricing.
Thread: -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
In 2010 and 2012, @TheBTI would further build out the case for clean energy subsidy reform, "disciplining all incentives for technology deployment and adoption to a new framework that rewards innovation."
thebreakthrough.org/articles/postpartisan-power
thebreakthrough.org/articles/beyond-boom-and-bust-report-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Making clean energy cheap in unsubsidized terms remains the right approach today and, in our view, the only plausible way to assure US energy security or significant global decarbonization in the long term."
@TedNordhaus and @atrembath on IRA reform
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-case-for-ira-reform -
Breakthrough reposted
Science for Sustainable Agriculture
@SciSustAg
Productivity gains in beef production - by improving cattle nutrition, genetics, grassland management and new technologies like methane-reducing feed additives - can significantly reduce global emissions.
Cutting Beef Isn’t the Only Way thebreakthrough.org/articles/cutting-beef-isnt-the-only-way via @TheBTI -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"RFK's unscientific positions of health, food, and farming are reckless. If he does end up leading HHS, the consequences for the future of U.S. agriculture are real and worrying."
@EmilyJane_Bass analyzes what RFK's positions could mean for food security
thebreakthrough.org/articles/rfk-jr-is-exactly-who-we-sai… -
Breakthrough reposted
Emily Bass
@EmilyJane_Bass
"Having such a loose cannon in the administration may end up alienating both left-wing supporters of RFK Jr. and more conventional members of Trump’s cabinet, leaving Kennedy and his unusual organic coalition adrift once more." More from @TheBTI on RFK Jr:
www.wired.com/story/rfk-jrs-organic-crusade-has-sparked-a… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“Limiting use of genetically modified crops, or more strictly monitoring their existence in the food supply, is something that could create a chilling effect on agricultural production.”
@TheBTI’s @emilyjane_bass www.wired.com/story/rfk-jrs-organic-crusade-has-sparked-a… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"In the aftermath of the disaster, California has turned to rebuilding. Unfortunately, local policymakers have already demonstrated a clear preference to recreate existing vulnerabilities and housing shortages."
Read @JessicaWeinkle for @thebti Journal. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/a-climate-dumpster-fire -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Nuclear energy is prone to be misunderstood...it is one of the few technologies that is explicitly designed with the worst case in mind."
Read @MattLWald's case that nuclear is a Rorschach Test for @TheBTI journal
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/this-is-a-rorschach-test -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Reducing beef consumption can certainly help cut emissions, but improving beef production offers an equally—and often more—effective path for regions expecting demand growth."
@danrejto @benjamin_goren on reducing beef carbon footprints for @TheBTI
thebreakthrough.org/articles/cutting-beef-isnt-the-only-way -
Breakthrough reposted
Lauren Teixeira
@lrntex
Really enjoyed supporting my boss @PatrickTBrown31 on this important piece, which questions the empirical grounds for an increasingly ubiquitous claim that climate whiplash, a phenomenon that exacerbated the LA fires, is becoming more frequent thanks to AGW.
Patrick T. Brown
@PatrickTBrown31
“Los Angeles is burning, and accelerating hydroclimate whiplash is the key climate connection.”
That was the first line of the @UCLAUpdates press release on a recently-published Nature review paper by @Weather_West et al. This led to extensive global coverage of the fires through this “climate whiplash” lens.
In this analysis, I contend that there is a large gap between the impression conveyed by the coverage and the impression left from the observational data.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-much-did-increasing-cli… -
Breakthrough reposted
Jessica Weinkle
@JessicaWeinkle
Everything worth knowing about ‘climate whiplash’ 👇
by @PatrickTBrown31
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-much-did-increasing-cli… -
Breakthrough reposted
Patrick T. Brown
@PatrickTBrown31
Using our attributions methods (adapted from the study below), we calculate that climate change enhanced wildfire intensity over the LA area by 6% between January 7th-11th. This is assuming a 10% difference in wind speed.
Brown, P.T., Strenfel, S.J., Bagley, R.B., Clements, C.B. The Potential for Fuel Reduction to Reduce Wildfire Intensity in a Warming California (2025). Environmental Research Letters, iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/adab86
Remarkably, World Weather Attribution's just-released calculation also comes up with a 6% enhancement of the Fire Weather Index.
www.worldweatherattribution.org/climate-change-increased-…
Convergence of results using very different methodologies is evidence that we have some confidence in the order of magnitude of the effect. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Highlighting changes in 'event' frequency without reporting changes in 'event' magnitude is misleading, and it goes against one of the core recommendations of the National Academies of Sciences."
@PatrickTBrown31 on climate whiplash for @TheBTI journal
substack.com/home/post/p-156031075?source=queue -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
This is a huge win for nuclear and @TheBTI. Adam provided extensive evidence to the commission that the Office of General Counsel claims about NRC statutory authority had no basis in, and was in fact contravened by, statute.
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
The NRC revised its mission statement to include enabling civil nuclear technologies through efficient licensing for benefits to society and the environment. This update was mandated in the ADVANCE Act. Many said it was an unachievable goal.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Trump’s wind energy pause should be opposed for the same reasons as Biden’s LNG pause. Both seek to 'reassess' impacts ... in service of culture war pandering to influential constituencies"
@TedNordhaus @NikkiChiappa talk permitting reform for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/permitting-reform-for-me-an… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Landmark Fire Prevention and Protection Bill, The Fix Our Forests Act, Passes the House
Appreciate @RepScottPeters citing @NikkiChiappa's @TheBTI NEPA research:
scottpeters.house.gov/press-releases?ID=F1EA5803-55CB-4B7… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
“There’s no such thing as impact-free mining. There’s no such thing as energy without impacts either.”
I'm quoted today in @nytimes on lithium + Nevada. Meg Bernhard wrote a great piece, maybe not in the way the Center for Biological Diversity intended.🧵
www.nytimes.com/2025/01/24/magazine/nevada-lithium-mines.… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Commentators of all stripes readily invoke marine wildlife protection for their own purposes ... by spinning a whale slaughter narrative while ignoring far more impactful threats whales face."
@wang_seaver debates wind versus whale for @TheBTI journal
substack.com/home/post/p-155578652?source=queue -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“Two experts from @TheBTI…urged poor countries to quit the Paris Agreement. They described the agreement as overly focused on abstractions instead of practical concerns such as building the infrastructure needed to survive a hotter world.” www.huffpost.com/entry/trump-paris-climate_n_678e8350e4b0…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"After decades of climate politics that have grown increasingly polarized but have barely gained much... public support, perhaps climate advocates should be most welcoming of the kind of reset augured by Chris Wright’s realism."
@atrembath for @thebti:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/wright-is-right -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Climate catastrophism and green industrial policy are out. Energy dominance is in... But transforming the nation into a global energy superpower will require more than simply expanding oil and gas production."
@TedNordhaus and @atrembath in @WSJ:
www.wsj.com/opinion/the-partisan-path-to-u-s-energy-secur… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"While shifts in policy are inevitable in any democratic society, some level of policy consistency is crucial for efforts to develop secure domestic critical mineral supply chains."
@wang_seaver and @PeterCookBTI for @thebti Journal.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/washington-must-prioritize-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
New piece out from @PeterCookBTI + myself providing an overview of the National Critical Minerals Council Act and Critical Materials Future Act--two promising U.S. federal policy proposals for critical minerals that a new Congress could look to in 2025.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/revisiting-the-national… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
“By hamstringing technological advances and crucial inputs... he will make life harder for agricultural producers, decrease food production, and increase food prices for American consumers.”
Please join @theBTI in opposing confirmation of RFKJr to HHS. thebreakthrough.imgix.net/RFK-Jr.-Opposition-Letter_Final… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“Policymakers must recognize that strengthening critical mineral supply chains will require sustained, multifaceted support—or else risk failures, wasting federal resources.”
@PeterCookBTI & @wang_seaver review NCMCA and CMFA critical mineral policy
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/revisiting-the-national… -
Breakthrough reposted
Patrick T. Brown
@PatrickTBrown31
Do Climate Adaptation Strategies Get Enough Attention: The Case of Wildfires in California.
My talk at Columbia University last fall: youtu.be/ciupSLrNN84 -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
"Modeling by @TheBTI suggests that clearing brush — and thus eliminating fuel — can reduce the intensity of wildfires in the Los Angeles Basin even during extreme weather, @PatrickTBrown31 said."
www.latimes.com/environment/story/2025-01-13/could-brush-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Many are looking for a clear culprit to blame for this disaster, with climate change being one of the most popular. This disaster, however, is the result of a confluence of natural and human-caused factors."
@PatrickTBrown31 on the LA fires:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/causes-and-potential-soluti… -
Breakthrough reposted
Matthew L. Wald
@MattLWald
It’s so unlikely that it would be rejected as a Hollywood script: a nuclear reactor melts down and the President who comes to visit is a nuclear engineer. But he introduces himself as a peanut farmer. My take: shorturl.at/FGLUv
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"But in a twist that approaches the implausible, a reactor melted down and the president actually was a nuclear engineer—one of only two presidents who were engineers."
Read @MattLWald on Jimmy Carter's little-known nuclear legacy.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-nuclear-engineer-who-in… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"While not perfect, GFI 187B sets a reasonable standard and process for regulatory approval of food animals with IGAs such as gene edits."
@thebti analyst @benjamin_goren on updated FDA guidelines for genetic editing of livestock.
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/r… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Farm bill investments that enable agricultural research to catalyze the development and adoption of new technologies will prove crucial to maintaining American agricultural leadership on the global stage."
Read @EmilyJane_Bass on the farm bill in 2025: thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/l… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The climate media is made up of actors whose mission is to raise awareness of the negative impacts of climate change, and thus, there will be a tendency to selectively highlight studies where climate change is a larger driver"
Read @PatrickTBrown31: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/do-climate-attribution-stud… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The notion that international climate efforts would be a net positive for the social and economic development aspirations of poor countries has been a mirage."
Read @thebti's @vijramachandran and @TedNordhaus in @ForeignPolicy this morning: foreignpolicy.com/2025/01/06/trump-paris-agreement-climat… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
California has long fashioned itself a global climate leader, arguing that it has proven that it is possible to rapidly cut emissions while assuring prosperity for all in the 5th largest economy in the world. But in a new analysis and essay, @ceqalaw and @lrntex show that California's results don't match that story. Since CA passed its first in the nation climate law in 2006, Texas and Florida have both achieved similar rates of emissions reduction with faster and more equitable economic growth.
California's growth, moreover, has been driven by a handful of wealthy counties centered around Silicon Valley and has not filtered down to lower income and majority Black and Latino counties. By contrast, similar counties in TX and FL have grown faster than the national average and at similar or higher rates than high income and majority white counties.
In pursuit of faster emissions reductions, CA has saddled low income and working class residents with the highest energy prices in the country. Unsurprisingly, this has significantly contributed to a cost of living crisis that has disproportionately been borne by those in the bottom half of the income distribution and has driven rising inequality. Equally problematic, it has contributed to the exodus of manufacturing and other heavy industry from the state, which provide good jobs for those without four year college degrees.
There are two conclusions one can draw from this analysis. Either deeper emissions reductions, particularly outside the power sector, require slower and less equitable growth. Or California is doing it wrong. Obviously, we believe there is a better way. But that will require a reset in CA and well beyond of progressive techocratic climate policy and a less monomaniacal obsession with climate change and short/midterm emissions goals. -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
The siren song of COP and international climate deals for poor countries has been that in exchange for backing a global framework predicated on the notion that they would leapfrog fossil fuels and achieve modern living standards through an energy development path fundamentally different than every industrialized country on earth, rich nations would cut their emissions deeply and underwrite the higher cost of poor country development with clean technology. 30 years after the first COP, the rich world has serially failed to deliver on any of these promises while using global temperature and emissions target as a justification to blocking virtually all fossil fuel development in poor countries.
In a new essay in @ForeignPolicy, @vijramachandran and I argue that Trump's looming pull out of Paris Agreement offers poor nations an opportunity to do the same. The UNFCCC framework, in practice, represents the priorities of the West and the rich world, not the global poor, in whose name climate actions is constantly demanded. This is not the path to an equitable, just, and sustainable global future. Poor countries should cut their losses. foreignpolicy.com/2025/01/06/trump-paris-agreement-climat… -
Breakthrough reposted
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“Extraordinary growth rates in a handful of tech-centric counties have obscured the costs of the state’s climate regime.”
via @lrntex and @ceqalaw @TheBTI -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"California’s claims to climate leadership now depend upon demonstrating that it can cut its emissions while assuring that home ownership, an affordable cost of living, and good jobs are available to all."
@ceqalaw and @lrntex for @thebti Journal: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/time-to-reset-californias-c… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
For "something as complicated as a first-of-a-kind reactor, the endpoint isn’t when construction is finished, fuel is loaded, and operators achieve first criticality. It’s when the model becomes a commercial success."
@MattLWald for @thebti Journal: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-not-to-innovate -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Though US federal regulatory agencies have made some progress toward regulations for genetically engineered microbes in agriculture, there is still no clear pathway to market for these products."
@emmakovak on the regulatory pathway for GE microbes: thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/c… -
Breakthrough reposted
Matthew L. Wald
@MattLWald
The Canadians seem to have found a pathway to disposal: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/nuclear-waste-yes-in-or-und…
Brett Rampal
@Beazy_Rampezy
In 2022, the U.S. exceeded 90,000 tons of spent nuclear fuel in storage around this country.
This fuel is frozen in place b/c federal government has vacated its responsibility to move forward with a long term isolation strategy.
How many tons will it be before we do something? -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
My latest @theBTI Journal. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/has-there-really-never-been…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"Every advanced developed economy in the world has in fact undergone an energy transition and no longer meets its energy needs with biomass... the reason use biomass has increased is because a billion people, give or take, lack access to modern energy." www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/has-there-really-never-been…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"There is good news for everyone concerned about the spent nuclear fuel stranded at scores of sites around the United States"
@MattLWald analyzes recent progress in Canada's nuclear repository journey and what it bodes for the U.S. in @TheBTI journal
open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/nuclear-wa… -
Breakthrough reposted
Nick Schulz
@nickschulz
This @TedNordhaus piece is truly excellent @TheBTI www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/has-there-really-never-been…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The notion that the world has never undergone an energy transition and has simply added fossil fuels, along with a bit of nuclear and renewable energy, really misses the point."
@TedNordhaus discusses the transition (and its critics) for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/has-there-really-never-been… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Smith
@alexjmssmith
I have a new piece out this morning exploring RFK's vision for the food system, his influences (Vandana Shiva, for one), and what he could do at FDA to harm American agricultural abundance.
Give it a read here: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/can-rfk-kneecap-american-ag… -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
This @alexjmssmith essay on the consequences of RFKJr's vision for food and agriculture and @MikeGrunwald @nytopinion essay on factory farming are worth reading together. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/can-rfk-kneecap-american-ag…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Recently, @drvolts said “the climate movement could have owned abundance," a reference, I think, to climate hawks' affection for solar and EVs.
But abundance goes far beyond narrow sectarian techno-optimism. My latest:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/progressives-against-abundance -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Good @dwallacewells write up of @TheBTI @PatrickTBrown31 report on the massive cost of CA wildfires and massive benefits of fuel reduction. www.nytimes.com/live/2024/12/04/opinion/thepoint/californ…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Because of its vague meaning, policymakers who adopt the term “resilience” do so at risk of setting policy goals that are misunderstood, vague, or incompatible with other overriding objectives."
Read @JessicaWeinkle on "Resilience":
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-code-word-is-resilience -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“There is definitely an inherent tension and people in the agricultural community are hopeful Rollins will be a backstop to the RFK Jr. agenda."
@TheBTI's @EmilyJane_Bass in @WSJ:
www.wsj.com/politics/policy/trump-agriculture-pick-brooke… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Progressives like @drvolts, @rgunns, and @DylanGyauchL have come out against abundance, ostensibly because there's no constituency. It's classic projection. The Groups are reckoning w/ progressive electoral failures and their own dependence on philanthropy by dissembling.
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The climate movement could never have owned abundance because, at least so far, abundance offers something the climate movement never could."
@atrembath responds to abundance critics and the movement's place in policy for @TheBTI journal
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/progressives-against-abundance -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
I'm featured in @gbrumfiel @NPR All Things Considered this morning talking about nuclear and AI. Long story short, net-zero commitments X 24 hour clean energy matching don't leave many options for firm generation. www.npr.org/2024/12/09/nx-s1-5171063/artificial-intellige…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Peter Cook
@PeterCookBTI
China just announced critical mineral export restrictions — again
Now they specifically target the US for gallium, germanium, graphite, and antimony
@TheBTI gives this latest move context by reexamining the infamous 2010 China/Japan incident
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-should-we-interpret-chi… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
With Chinese policymakers imposing export restrictions on more critical materials (germanium, gallium, graphite…), our new piece looks back at the 2010 China-Japan rare earths episode and how export policies create tools useful for diplomatic leverage.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
The psychotic everythingism of The Groups is nowhere more obvious than over the issue of nuclear energy, which the League of Women Voters and AARP have, for some reason, lobbied against.
via @MattLWald
thebreakthrough.org/journal/no-20-spring-2024/these-organ… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"China can control market supply and international prices for a wide host of critical commodities with the stroke of a pen."
@wang_seaver, @PeterCookBTI & @lrntex discuss the implications of U.S.-China trade tensions for the energy transition
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-should-we-interpret-chi… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The extent of these organizations’ influence on energy policy isn’t clear, but they can gum up the works by entering the licensing and permitting processes at the federal and state level."
@MattLWald on anti-nuclear energy orgs for @TheBTI journal
thebreakthrough.org/journal/no-20-spring-2024/these-organ… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Too often in our industry, an unqualified man gets elevated before a qualified woman."
Read Brooke Morrison's guest essay on gender equity at the Nuclear Regulatory Commission for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/gender-equity-at-the-nrc-sh… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“We hope Brooke Rollins will be a force to defend against RFK Jr.’s vision, and instead lead a USDA that recognizes the value of technology-forward advances.”
- @TheBTI’s @emilyjane_bass sentientmedia.org/brooke-rollins-trumps-agricultural-secr… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The NRC has had the authority and mandate to consider benefits to society since its creation but has not fulfilled this mandate."
Read @Dr_A_Stein's white paper on the NRC's shortcomings, and recommendation for revision of its role for @TheBTI journal
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/considering-nuclear-ene… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
I penned some thoughts in this new piece on how the Republican trifecta will--and won't--define the trajectory of the US energy system.
What matters:
- Tariffs
- changes to IRA
- energy innovation
What won't:
- Paris exit
- EPA regulations, O&G policy
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-will-republican-governa… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"For the next four years and likely beyond, even the most ardent environmental advocates must recognize that technology, not regulation, will have to drive national momentum towards decarbonization."
@wang_seaver on the energy transition post-election:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/how-will-republican-governa… -
Breakthrough reposted
Patrick T. Brown
@PatrickTBrown31
In a 2nd Trump presidency, rather than doubling down on the misguided notion that science is an authority that can fully dictate policy, scientists should strive to delineate between strict scientific facts and their political preferences. 🧵
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The greatest gains may be achieved by improving animal health, which, counter to a common stereotype of policy solely focused on efficiency improvement, would also have a positive impact on animal welfare."
Read @benjamin_goren on beef and the climate
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/m… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"We can think globally and act locally, but in fact we should be thinking about local steps that will allow global action."
Read @MattLWald's case for U.S. nuclear exports in the @TheBTI journal
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/think-locally-act-globally -
Breakthrough reposted
Patrick T. Brown
@PatrickTBrown31
This is Part 2 of my two-part post defending economic productivity and capitalism for climate adaptation and mitigation.
It’s in response to the Degrowth push to dismantle capitalism and reduce and redistribute global wealth to solve climate change.
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Contrary to being a liability, economic productivity undergirded by private property, markets, and prices - is our primary asset"
Read @PatrickTBrown31's defense of productivity for climate mitigation and the clean energy transition
open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/defending-… -
Breakthrough reposted
Mariam Ibrahim
@MaryanEbrahim
Attending COP 29? Report from @TheBTI reveals a misallocation of #climatefinance by the World Bank & MDBs. In low & middle-income countries, only 37% of $60.9B spent in 2022 went to climate adaptation, while 63% went to mitigation. Learn more: thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/adaptation-finance-and-… 🌍 #cop29
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Contrary to being a liability, economic productivity undergirded by private property, markets, and prices - is our primary asset"
Read @PatrickTBrown31's defense of productivity for climate mitigation and the clean energy transition
open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/defending-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Environmental advocates need to grapple with the implications of crop yield tradeoffs in AV systems, even if the overall profitability of such systems is net positive."
@EmilyJane_Bass discusses the nuances of agrivoltaics for @thebti journal
thebreakthrough.org/articles/can-agrivoltaics-eliminate-l… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Last week’s election should put an end to the notion that Trump or his followers can be driven from the public square."
Read @TedNordhaus on last week's election, and American politics' new normal. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/we-have-never-been-normal -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“The exciting thing with CRISPR for gene editing is you can make changes exactly where you want them."
@TheBTI's @EmmaKovak in this @jtemple on gene editing for crops and livestock:
www.technologyreview.com/2024/11/02/1106579/how-a-breakth… -
Breakthrough reposted
Patrick T. Brown
@PatrickTBrown31
Our new @TheBTI report, led by @vijramachandran, contends that the World Bank & Multilateral Development Banks have misallocated #climatefinance in low & middle-income countries, with too much emphasis on climate change mitigation and not enough on climate adaptation. (In 2022, for example, only 37% of $60.9B spent went to adaptation, while 63% went to mitigation).
Check out the full report at:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/adaptation-finance-and-…
🌍 #cop29 #globaldev
The report has many important insights and recommendations, but I’ll highlight three that I was involved in.
1: Climate Change's impact on climate hazards is just one subset of the broader issue.
The risk of adverse consequences from weather and climate phenomena can be thought of as the interaction of three components: hazards (physical weather and climate phenomena such as wildfires, extreme temperatures, extreme precipitation, droughts, and hurricanes); exposure (people or assets in the path of hazards); and vulnerability (the propensity of people or assets to be adversely affected by the hazard).
Much of the discussion on climate change is focused on reducing greenhouse gas emissions to prevent further increases in certain hazards in the long term. However, an inordinate focus on hazard reduction without an attendant focus on exposure and vulnerability might increase the risk of overall negative climate impacts because the successes in hazard reduction could be offset by forgone progress on reduced vulnerability. Therefore, to reduce overall climate impact risk, it is important not to focus exclusively on reducing hazards via greenhouse gas mitigation when exposure and vulnerability are often much bigger and more direct levers that can be pulled.
2: When investing in climate adaptation, don't get unnecessarily distracted by climate change; rather, focus on facilitating continued increases in resilience against the climate generally.
There are broad areas that we know make society more resilient to climate extremes that result from both climate and climate change. For example, investments in flood management, demi-lunes and other rainwater harvesting techniques for land restoration, nutrient-dense crops, seed diversity including hybrid and native seeds, and reliable weather forecasting, can help farmers adapt to climate.
The baseline impact of a weather or climate hazard cannot be left out of decisions on how best to adapt to climate, and a projected long-term change in a hazard should not necessarily make it a priority in adaptation investment. The figure below illustrates this point.
Consider Hazard A, which is expected to become more destructive in the future, and Hazard B, which is not expected to become more damaging but has a larger current impact.
Adaptation investment for Hazard A completely negates its enhanced destructiveness in the future, which makes it appear to be a successful investment for climate change adaptation.
However, If we make an adaptation investment for Hazard A at the expense of Hazard B (simply because Hazard A is projected to change and Hazard B is projected to remain constant) we will be making a mistake. The return on investment for Hazard B ($5 billion per year) is larger than it is for Hazard A ($2 billion per year).
The point is that we should prioritize the adaptation actions that have the highest return on investment regardless of whether they are true climate change adaptations as opposed to actions that generally fortify systems against the climate.
3: Multilateral Development Banks should explicitly recognize and prioritize the role of abundant energy in adapting to climate.
All countries require a minimum level of continuous power to cope with extreme weather and climate events. Access to affordable, reliable energy is central to the proper functioning of farms, businesses, schools, and hospitals and for the operation of early warning systems in extreme weather or climate events. The World Bank has committed to providing electricity access to 300 million people in Africa by 2030. However, the Multilateral Development Banks should recognize the Modern Energy Minimum, which is defined as 1,000 kilowatt hours per person per year, and critically, they should not allow mitigation measures to undermine the achievement of sufficient and affordable energy in low- and lower-middle-income countries. -
Breakthrough reposted
Jessica Weinkle
@JessicaWeinkle
"The carbon offset industry treats the economic development of poor nations as a 'co-benefit' of a virtue signal marketing scheme"
Also, the indictment of C Quest Capital reads like a Grisham novel. I cover it below.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/is-an-equitable-carbon-offs… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The carbon offset industry treats the economic development of poor nations as a 'co-benefit' of a virtual signal marketing scheme"
@JessicaWeinkle singles out the elitism at the center of the C-Quest carbon offset scandal for @TheBTI journal
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/is-an-equitable-carbon-offs… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
A new report from @vijramachandran for @TheBTI reveals a misallocation of #climatefinance by the World Bank & MDBs. In low & middle-income countries, only 37% of $60.9B spent in 2022 went to climate adaptation
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/adaptation-finance-and-… 🌍 #cop29 #globaldev -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“If you are able to make clean energy cheaper, more modular, more reliable, the politics of transitioning become a whole lot easier. If all you can do is sacrifice that's a much harder politics.”
@ezraklein on #abundance for @TheBTI dialogue
www.youtube.com/watch?v=CXSjLFgn5ns -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"A number of energy analysts have questioned why firms like Google and Amazon have chosen to go the small reactor route"
@TedNordhaus & @Dr_A_Stein unpack why small reactors may be the future of nuclear energy for @TheBTI journal
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-case-for-small-reactors -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“Rather, now is the time for the climate community to more critically assess how clean energy options really fit into each country’s energy transition.”
@juzel_lloyd discusses clean energy transitions for @TheBTI journal
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/beyond-the-100-renewabl… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Neither Kamala Harris nor Donald Trump has said a lot about nuclear energy."
@MattLWald breaks down nuclear in the upcoming election for the @TheBTI journal
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/will-the-next-president-get… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The relationships between progressives and technology was breaking down”
@ezraklein explains what progressivism needs to rebuild in this excerpt from the @TheBTI Dialogue 2022
Catch this insightful clip from the archives www.youtube.com/watch?v=CXSjLFgn5ns -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"There are real trade-offs when it comes to decisions about agricultural land-use, but whether a tiny percentage of farmland becomes utility scale solar is not among them."
@EmilyJane_Bass debunks critiques of solar utility for @TheBTI journal
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/i… -
Breakthrough reposted
Dan Rejto 🇺🇸🌎🍴
@danrejto
🌱 Replacing a small share of chicken or pork consumption with meat-alternatives could cut prices for corn and soy, while displacing some beef would have minimal impact, our new research shows. 👇
-
Breakthrough reposted
Nikki Chiappa
@NikkiChiappa
In this installment agency staff and judges spent years debunking the ✨unhinged✨ claim that wind turbines cause cancer ⬇️
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"That NEPA can be so easily weaponized, by conspiratorial and pseudoscientific litigation, like those from BAD, underlines how badly we need permitting reform."
Read the newest NEPA nightmare in @NikkiChiappa's series: the story of Tule Wind
www.breakthroughjournal.org/publish/post/150622774?back=%… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"That NEPA can be so easily weaponized, by conspiratorial and pseudoscientific litigation, like those from BAD, underlines how badly we need permitting reform."
Read the newest NEPA nightmare in @NikkiChiappa's series: the story of Tule Wind
www.breakthroughjournal.org/publish/post/150622774?back=%… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The relationships between progressives and technology was breaking down”
@ezraklein explains what progressivism needs to rebuild in this excerpt from the @TheBTI Dialogue 2022
Catch this insightful clip from the archives
youtu.be/CXSjLFgn5ns -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Smith
@alexjmssmith
High productivity agriculture has enabled a reduction in land-use, emissions intensities, and prices for food in the United States. And yet, there is growing support for doing funky accounting to reverse that trend and make cheap food more expensive.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/cheap-food-is-the-only-option -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The advocates of 'true cost accounting' and other demand-side interventions in agriculture will continue to try to muddy the economics of cheap food."
@alexjmssmith critiques @nytimes' discussion of food prices for @TheBTI journal
substack.com/home/post/p-150416075?source=queue -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
I appreciate @OurWorldInData citing our study! The original source is available at thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/updated-mining-footprin…
Our World in Data
@OurWorldInData
Mining for coal is much more resource-intensive than renewables or nuclear power
Read about this and much more in today's Biweekly Digest: mailchi.mp/ourworldindata/biweekly-digest-2024-10-04 -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“The grid and the nation need a regulatory framework for energy abundance, not burdensome additionality rules.”
@smithtjosh and me @heatmap_news: heatmap.news/ideas/abundance-additionality-permitting-reform -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Many climate activists now insist that anyone who challenges any of the movement’s claims... is a science denier. That’s how people like me get branded as climate deniers and, ultimately, cockroaches."
@TedNordhaus on climate vitriol and dehumanization.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/will-the-climate-movement-i… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"It’s fine to add factories that make computer chips, but at some point the health of the infrastructure depends on deploying cement mixers, for highways, bridges, tunnels and runways."
@MattLWald on infrastructure and decarbonization:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/our-infrastructure-is-too-old -
Breakthrough reposted
Mark Lynas
@mark_lynas
This is one wing of the climate activist movement going pathological - trying to shut down legitimate discussions and police the boundaries of the conversation. It's performative, self-indulgent and anti-intellectual. @TheBTI @atrembath and @TedNordhaus pls continue your work.
Matthew C. Nisbet
@mcnisbet
I was at the #abundance meeting today when activists stormed the stage during a convo between @mattyglesias + @DKThomp - at a moment that paradoxically Thompson was describing the important contributions of the enviro movement across decades. The false claims by @climatedefiance about @TheBTI are a textbook example of how years of Mannichean climate wars thinking issues.org/new-climate-war-michael-mann-hulme-review/ and misinformation have done a grave disservice to young people. Their claim that a protestor was “ tackled” is also false as evident in the video. The two hotel staff members were trying their best to defuse the deeply erratic, hysterical behavior of the white male protestor shown in the video as his peers chanted down Yglesias, Johnson and others who were trying to engage them in a dialogue. I feel badly for the staff member who politely replied “Buddy I didn’t push you down.” FYI @Fisher_DanaR @Revkin
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Yesterday I gave a speech to the Abundance Movement arguing that they needed to keep the environmental movement out of the tent. A few minutes later, @ClimateDefiance showed up to prove my point. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/environmentalism-is-antithe…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The climate movement increasingly aims not simply to advocate for its own demands for radical action but to silence more moderate, pragmatic, and nuanced viewpoints."
Read @TedNordhaus on the incompatibility of enviromentalism and the abundance agenda.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/environmentalism-is-antithe… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The improvements in adaptation of the past decades are repeatable, but only if we understand them as success stories, and not denigrate them to sell a narrative that our society is collapsing under the weight of climate change."
Read @PatrickTBrown31:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/no-our-adaptation-to-global… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Are you still not subscribed to @TheBTI Journal? Folks, it's good.
www.breakthroughjournal.org -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
The death of baseload, the inevitability of wind/solar, corporate climate commitments, nuclear's reliance on regulated electricity markets—the MSFT/Three Mile Island deal upends decades of conventional wisdom.
@TedNordhaus and my latest:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-double-symbolism-of-the… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
It’s been obvious for a while that shutting down nuclear plants increases emissions.
It’s becoming increasingly obvious that we can’t persistently reduce emissions without new nuclear capacity.
@TedNordhaus and me the Three Mile Island news: www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-double-symbolism-of-the… -
Breakthrough reposted
Terrestrial Energy
@TerrestrialMSR
A Department of Energy report suggests that tripling nuclear power by 2050 is achievable, but only if we accelerate the deployment of advanced nuclear technologies, like the IMSR now.
#smr #gen4nuclear @TheBTI @GovNuclear
www.breakthroughenergy.org/newsroom/articles/new-nuclear-… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The Three Mile Island restart goes beyond the future of nuclear energy. It raises fundamental questions about the US electricity system and the plausible paths to decarbonize it."
@TedNordhaus @atrembath discuss energy infrastructure for @TheBTI
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-double-symbolism-of-the… -
Breakthrough reposted
Jessica Weinkle
@JessicaWeinkle
"the Three Mile Island reopening marks a remarkable turnabout in the trajectory of the US power sector, nuclear energy, and US decarbonization trends."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/the-double-symbolism-of-the…
@TheBTI -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
Next week! Abundance 2024 co-hosted by @TheBTI and @Inclsvabundance w/ @NiskanenCenter @JoinFAI @IFP and @scientistsorg.
www.abundanceconference.org -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Vermont’s vulnerability to flooding predates whatever influence anthropogenic climate change is having or will have on the state’s hydrology."
@JessicaWeinkle addresses the shortcomings of the Climate Superfund Act for @TheBTI journal
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/vermonts-fossil-fuel-shakedown -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“The idealization of peer review as the arbiter of good science is problematic for many reasons, but one is that it downplays the possibility that bad science can appear in the peer reviewed literature and good science outside of those outlets.”
The Honest Broker
@RogerPielkeJr
At THB
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"An energy transition is enmeshed with macroeconomy and constrained by infrastructure inertia. If Trump or Harris admin is characterized by major energy policy achievements or failures, unlikely to manifest until well after next president leaves office." www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/is-climate-really-on-the-ba…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"If the history of US and global decarbonization tells us anything, it is that the things that matter, with the benefit of hindsight, are rarely the things that most political actors in the present imagine."
@TedNordhaus on climate in the 2024 election:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/is-climate-really-on-the-ba… -
Breakthrough reposted
Adam Stein
@Dr_A_Stein
A short response to a recent article telling us all to move on from nuclear by @Noahpinion. No, the ship hasn't sailed.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/uninformed-nuclear-pessimism -
Breakthrough reposted
Kate Yoder
@katemyoder
A year ago, climate scientist @PatrickTBrown31 criticized his own wildfire study in Nature, causing an uproar. I kept wondering why he did it. I spent the summer talking to Patrick and those who know him, reviewing private emails, to get the inside scoop
grist.org/science/patrick-brown-profile-climate-scientist… -
Breakthrough reposted
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The New York Times is peddling in 'not in my backyard' implicit racism hidden behind a thin veneer of HPAI fear mongering."
@benjamin_goren exposes the bias in @nytimes reporting on live markets versus large-scale slaughterhouses for @TheBTI
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/d… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
“Then @PatrickTBrown31 said something I wasn’t expecting. Would I talk to his critics? He hoped I would, and helpfully name-dropped a couple of them.”
Excellent @katemyoder reflections on the “Brown Affair.” grist.org/science/patrick-brown-profile-climate-scientist… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Brown wanted the complicated truth, the full story in all its messiness — even in an article about him."
Read @katemyoder's wonderful profile of @theBTI's resident anti-Hero, @PatrickTBrown31, published in Grist today. grist.org/science/patrick-brown-profile-climate-scientist… -
Breakthrough reposted
Spin Boy
@Spinboydotcom
Arbitrary Decision Making Means More Stalled Mine Projects on Federal Lands thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/arbitrary-decision-maki… via @TheBTI
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The New York Times is peddling in 'not in my backyard' implicit racism hidden behind a thin veneer of HPAI fear mongering."
@benjamin_goren exposes the bias in @nytimes reporting on live markets versus large-scale slaughterhouses for @TheBTI
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/d… -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
Very proud to see our @TheBTI teams' work (on adding advanced nuclear to clean energy system models and on power plant material usage) cited in a couple places in the U.S. Dept of @ENERGY's latest updated liftoff report on advanced nuclear energy:
liftoff.energy.gov/advanced-nuclear/ -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"From an environmental and public health standpoint, which should also matter, nuclear wins in almost every category—health risk, CO2 emission, land use, mining impacts and critical minerals, and more."
@Dr_A_Stein on recent uninformed nuclear pessimism
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/uninformed-nuclear-pessimism -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"We are in the decade of nuclear renaissance, at least in terms of designing and planning. The 2030s could be a time of rapid deployment."
Read @MattLWald's new journal piece on nuclear energy (and common misconceptions) for @TheBTI
open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/seven-thin… -
Breakthrough reposted
Nikki Chiappa
@NikkiChiappa
Case 3 includes NIMBYs forcing a 5+ years NEPA analysis of a transmission line AFTER it was legally built. It's infuriating. Here're the highlights 🧵
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Agencies could prohibit mining not because it causes some impermissible damage, but because it is politically salient to do so."
@PeterCookBTI @wang_seaver comment on recent mining bills that threaten to shift permitting practices for the worse
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/arbitrary-decision-maki… -
Breakthrough reposted
Josh Smith
@smithtjosh
But I was told NEPA only stopped bad projects?
@NikkiChiappa is doing a great series you should pay attention to -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Climate change is, at its core, an industrial problem"
Don't miss @Matthuber78's call for unions to be centered in the environmental movement, at @TheBTI dialogue
www.youtube.com/watch?v=WHYWI2rcxno -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Excited to announce the #abundance coalition at the inaugural #abundance2024 Conference in D.C. Leaders in housing, energy, technology, and more are reimagining policy to build a better future through cross-sector collaboration. #inclusiveabundance
@Inclsvabundance -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"The most contentious NEPA challenges filed between 2013 and 2022, on average, delayed clean energy projects by nearly 4 years."
@NikkiChiappa explains how NEPA litigation delayed clean energy at Surry-Skiffes Creek-Whealton transmission line
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/nepa-vs-climate -
Breakthrough reposted
Seaver Wang
@wang_seaver
What quantities of minerals will the US need to decarbonize electricity/transport? If we want to both deploy clean tech at scale while reducing critical mineral import dependence we have much work to do.
My team’s new @TheBTI report does the math.🧵
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/metals-for-the-future -
Breakthrough reposted
Peter Cook
@PeterCookBTI
Pleased to announce the new @TheBTI report that estimates the minerals the US needs for decarbonization.
Clean energy needs a lot of minerals like copper and graphite. This report directs any policy efforts that try to secure those minerals to where they are needed most -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"If you want good unionized jobs, nuclear power plants employ 100s, whereas solar and wind are temporary installation jobs"
@robinsonmeyer and @Matthuber78 discuss the tension between unions, renewable energy, and environmentalism for @TheBTI
dialogue
www.youtube.com/watch?v=nVUVprZdlEk&t=4s -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
New letter from @TheBTI to @SenatorCarper and @SenCapito opposing the nomination of Matthew Marzano to @NRCgov. Neither his qualifications and background, nor his experience with @EPWCmte suggest he will be a champion for regulatory modernization. thebreakthrough.imgix.net/BTI-Letter-on-Matthew-Marzanos-…
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Without strong industrial policy and diplomacy, critical mineral demands will force policymakers to prioritize between deployment of advanced energy technologies and resilient supply chains.
New Report from @wang_seaver, @PeterCookBTI and @juzel_lloyd:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/metals-for-the-future -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Braver men than I have tried to get people to grapple with this parallel between constructed climate ignorance and constructed polling ignorance. But for many, the knowledge is just too uncomfortable."
Read @atrembath on comfy ignorance about climate:
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/comfy-ignorance -
Breakthrough reposted
Leon Simons 🌍
@LeonSimons8
Comparing people to cockroaches is the most crazy thing I've seen Mann do on 'social' media.
And that's after he spread defamatory lies about me from an antisemite to his 200,000 followers (which he didn't delete after learning it were lies).
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
This is totally normal…
-
Breakthrough reposted
Dan Rejto 🇺🇸🌎🍴
@danrejto
In a few months, ethanol & other biofuel producers may claim carbon reductions from farmers in their supply chain using climate-smart practices. While the aim is to cut emissions, the effort could raise emissions. I wrote about 4 reasons why & how to prevent it form backfiring:
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"Our message to the abundance movement is, "stop pretending that environmentalist are your allies. They're not. They're your enemies. Don't let the environmental blob into the tent. You can come in the tent but you have to stop being an environmentalist, because we're going to go build a new world and you're in the way."
Great conversation on the Bungacast w/@Leigh_Phillips and @bungacast, with shoutouts to @nils_gilman, @atrembath, and a headnod to @Eaterofsun's evergreen corrective that there is no "we." bungacast.podbean.com/e/439-we-can-create-our-own-environ… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"If the USDA doesn’t quantify the climate impact of farming practices in a accurate manner... they could underestimate the carbon footprint of biofuels and undermine clean fuel programs."
@danrejto reveals the risks of the USDA's biofuel initiative:
thebreakthrough.org/issues/food-agriculture-environment/c… -
Breakthrough reposted
Aufhebunga Bunga
@BungaCast
🚨 NEW EPISODE🚨
On "eco-modernism" with @TedNordhaus and @Leigh_Phillips on the 20th anniversary of "The Death of Environmentalism" and the 10th anniversary of "The Ecomodernist Manifesto." -
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
Finally, a note on why all this matters. The reason that @doctorvive has been so vociferous about her 500 citations and her former New Yorker factchecker is that her factual claims, about climate science, economics, and technology, are not incidental to her primary argument. They are necessary to sustain it. The core argument of her book is that the claims of the climate movement, about climate risk, the cost of climate change, and the solutions to it are refutable, hence people like me, who talk about the need for adaptation and innovation and insist upon an accurate representation of climate risk, the relationship between climate change and natural disasters, and similar are engaged in climate disinformation. So the demonstration here that many of her representations of the evidence around key issues are themselves inaccurate and misleading discredits the entire premise of the book.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Jonah Messinger
@JonahMessinger
Let it sink in folks. So butchering science and economics literatures, she evidently knows nothing or very little about, in an @OxUniPress book and getting several important things very very wrong shouldn’t lead one to question her book’s larger thesis. Quick question: why?
Jason Rylander 🌎☮️🕊️
@JasonRylander
A hit dog hollers? The book is about fossil fuel propaganda and their enablers. I’m not saying factual errors aren’t important. But they aren’t central to her thesis. The fact that you and Yglesias won’t engage her actual argument (and would rather take potshots) is telling.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Jonah Messinger
@JonahMessinger
Saying that @DoctorVive’s assertion that bioenergy w/ carbon capture & storage causes ionizing radiation is blatantly insane is not a nit pick. @rustneversleepz elucidated more than half a dozen egregious errors. You all have no epistemic standards and it shows.
Jason Rylander 🌎☮️🕊️
@JasonRylander
What's most notable to me in all this nit picking is that neither you nor BTI (no surprise there!) engage at all with @DoctorVive's actual thesis. In an odd way, these critiques are proving her point.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
ICYMI: @DoctorVive's book "asserts that the concepts of 'growth,' 'innovation,' and 'resilience' (among other things) are forms of fossil industry propaganda."
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/of-course-misinformation-is… -
Breakthrough reposted
CLEAR Center
@UCDavisCLEAR
Research on enteric methane is one of the cornerstones of our work. @UCDavisCLEAR along with @TheBTI, @Breakthrough, @sparkclimate, @CAFarmBureau & @calcattlemen recently met w/ @RepJimmyPanetta to discuss sustainability in livestock farming & ways to mitigate impact on #climate.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ryan Maue
@RyanWeather
Shocking to no one, a fact checker finds a recent highly publicized climate book by an activist author is full of sloppy errors and should not be taken seriously as scholarship.
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"I spent a decade fighting disinformation from climate science deniers, and it felt inconsistent to let the same slide based on which “side” it came from."
New guest essay by @rustneversleepz factchecking @doctorvive. Spoiler Alert: It doesn't go well.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/fact-checking-genevieve-gue… -
Breakthrough reposted
Alex Trembath
@atrembath
In her book @DoctorVive says that crop yields have fallen, that Robert Solow believed arable land is the key constraint on economic growth, that economic losses from anthropogenic extreme weather effects are a couple orders of magnitude greater than reality.
-
Breakthrough reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
"I spent a decade fighting disinformation from climate science deniers, and it felt inconsistent to let the same slide based on which “side” it came from."
New guest essay by @rustneversleepz factchecking @doctorvive. Spoiler Alert: It doesn't go well.
www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/fact-checking-genevieve-gue… -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"Guenther provides no reference whatsoever for this claim, which she apparently believes to be so self-evident that no reference is needed."
Read @rustneversleepz's fact check of Genevieve Guenther's "The Language of Climate Politics" for @TheBTI here www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/fact-checking-genevieve-gue… -
Breakthrough reposted
Matt Huber
@Matthuber78
This is my very short talk (8 min!) at @TheBTI this summer on how environmentalism is a class interest rooted in the professional class/PMC; separated from & often hostile towards the industrial workers we need to build the decarbonized future. youtu.be/WHYWI2rcxno
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“Environmentalism is a class interest bound for continued political failure unless we really start rethinking what and who environmentalism is for.”
Watch @Matthuber78's presentation on climate change, class, and workers for @TheBTI dialogue
www.youtube.com/watch?v=WHYWI2rcxno&t=154s -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"We cannot undo the Anthropocene Event outside of our own extinction."
@Leigh_Phillips distinguishes the Anthropocene as an Event versus an Epoch (and explains why it matters) for @TheBTI journal -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“But ultimately, the choice of how and where to protect nature will be a human one, driven not by what we have to do to survive, but what we want to do to thrive on an ecologically vibrant planet.”
Read @atrembath on why humanity should protect nature for @thebti Journal. -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
"America’s short-sighted neglect of its nuclear energy sector has also weakened our nation’s power and global influence relative to Russia’s authoritarian regime," argue BTI's @TedNordhaus and @ThirdWayTweet's @ValerieShen:
thehill.com/opinion/energy-environment/3488215-americas-n… -
Post not available here, view on X
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
(2) Plenary: Ecomodern Justice For a Multi-Polar World
Feat. @vijramachandran, @GlobalNamati's @VivekHMaru, @CGDev's @gyude_moore, & @berggruenInst's @nils_gilman
📅 Aug 5, 2021 (8:30am-9:45am PST)
thebreakthrough.org/articles/digital-dialogue-registration -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
This year's @BTI Dialogue theme is #ecomodernjustice, so we're asking what a new framework for #climate justice might look like in a multi-polar world?
Feat. @vijramachandran, @GlobalNamati's @VivekHMaru & @CGDev's @gyude_moore
Register here: thebreakthrough.org/articles/digital-dialogue-registration -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Our new interactive tool: tracking agricultural sustainability over time.
Find it here: thebreakthrough.org/issues/food/intensification-data-visual -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
We're very excited to have three of the world’s leading experts on oceans and aquatic life at @TheBTI Dialogue this year.
@9brandon moderating with @SylviaEarle, @AquariumPacific's Jerry Schubel, and @Revive_Restore's Ryan Phelan.
#wholeearthdiscipline -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
“Most things improve slowly.”
@AnnaGapminder
#powerofprogress -
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Peak farmland will occur when innovation allows us to stop the expansion of agricultural lands. wle.cgiar.org/thrive/2017/03/20/precision-agriculture-big… @linusblomqvist
-
Breakthrough
@TheBTI
Human progress quantified: @sapinker’s favorite recent scientific advancement www.edge.org/response-detail/26616 @Ecomodernism

































































































































































































































































































































































