The oddest intellectual position I have encountered over the last decade is the refusal of so many to believe that the current version of Pangram is incredibly good at avoiding false positives (i.e., flagging a human-written text of some length as AI-generated). It is not terribly hard to trick Pangram into false negatives (i.e., classifying an AI-generated text of some length as human-written) with “humanizing” tools and some careful editing. But the other way around? Nearly impossible.
For two weeks, I have been running experiments in many different situations for a new paper I will circulate tomorrow (and because, as an editor, I care a lot about the answer). Not in a single case did a human-written text of reasonable length score above 10% for AI generation. And, yes, many the texts I used (including mine!) are from ESL writers.
Frankly, the counterarguments I have read over the last week here on X (and the papers linked to “back them up”) are childish in the extreme.
If you think that false positives at Pangram are, as of November 16, 2026, a concern, you are lying to yourself.
Maarten Boudry
Maarten Boudry (born 15 August 1984) is a Belgian academic and skeptic. He has been a researcher in philosophy and moral sciences at Ghent University from 2006 until 2025. More on Wikipedia
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Jesús Fernández-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
That “genocide” has become an ossified dogma, and the g-word a loyalty test everyone must pass. Preferably with an explicit reference to the Holocaust, because that’s what it’s all about: accusing the Jews of precisely the crime of which they are the most famous victims, the very reason the term was coined.
~Conjecture Institute Senior Philosopher @mboudry 👇
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Geen Vlaamse tv-zender, krant of universiteit zou het vandaag in zijn hoofd halen om iemand als mij (of eender welke dissident) een platform te bieden over de “Gaza-genocide”. Iedere redactie weet dat de boel zou ontploffen.
In Nederland is de echokamer bijna even beklemmend, maar toch zijn daar nog een paar kiertjes. Dus schoof ik deze week aan bij De Joodse Wereld (@EOnl), samen met oud-parlementslid @roboudkerk, die uit de @PvdA stapte vanwege de demonisering van de enige Joodse staat ter wereld. We spraken over het g-woord en over het nieuwe boek van Joël Kotek (ULB), dat deze moderne bloedsmaad krachtig weerlegt.
Die “genocide” is een versteend dogma geworden, en het g-woord een loyauteitstest die iedereen moet afleggen. Liefst met een expliciete verwijzing naar de Holocaust, want daar draait het om: de Joden beschuldigen van precies de misdaad waarvan zij de beroemdste slachtoffers zijn, de reden zelf waarom de term werd gemunt.
Want als de Joden nu zélf een genocide op hun geweten zouden hebben, zou dat geen enorme opluchting zijn voor ons? Zou dat niet bewijzen dat ze even erg zijn als hun daders en iedereen die met hen collaboreerde? Zou de wereld dan niet weer quitte staan? (Excuseer mijn cynisme.)
In de kranten gaat de discussie alleen nog over wie de geloofsbelijdenis het vroegst aflegde en wie te lang aarzelde. Die laatsten moeten nu het boetekleed aantrekken. Zoals een bekende Jood ooit zei: zalig zij die niet gezien hebben en toch al geloven. Een tegensprekelijk debat is er nooit geweest. Het was van bij het begin een ritueel, een schuldbelijdenis, een credo. De argumenten waren altijd ridicuul en onlogisch (zie mijn essay voor Quillette, herwerkt tot voorwoord)
Het is de grootste leugen van onze tijd, een moderne versie van de bloedsmaad. Waarmee ik niet ontken dat veel mensen het oprecht in geloven, omdat ze het woord overal horen rondzingen en niet beter weten. En omdat het informatie-ecosysteem over de Gaza-oorlog zo compleet gecorrumpeerd is. Iedereen herhaalt het g-woord, en de ene ngo schrijft het over van de andere, in eindeloze rommelrapporten.
Enfoin, bedankt aan de Evangelische Omroep om deze rabiate atheïst uit te nodigen. Een klein mirakel. 😇 Ik was eigenlijk ziek, maar de redactie drong aan en ik wilde de kans niet laten schieten. Dus gedaan op adrenaline en paracetamol, en daarna een paar dagen in de touwen gelegen.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=FMCq3nzk4JQ -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
En dan uitgerekend door zo’n rommeldocumentaire: zonder één verifieerbare beschuldiging, zonder ernstig onderzoek, zonder weerwoord, en gebaseerd op anonieme getuigen van wie rang, leeftijd, eenheid en functie zelfs niet worden vermeld.
Gewoon een samenraapsel van vage anonieme getuigenissen en knullige tekeningen op bierviltjes, op basis van het eigen geheugen. Met een compleet gammele ‘argumentatie’ die zichzelf nota bene al in de titel tegenspreekt, en zonder het flauwste benul van militaire strategie.
Zie deze twee vernietigende kritieken:
substacktools.com/sharex/2deqC2O2
www.commentary.org/articles/john-spencer/naza-sensational…
En dát zorgt voor een bekering? Voor 25 minuten staande ovatie? Voor vijf sterren alom?
Redelijk verbijsterend. Maar de rationaliteit was in dit debat dan ook al lang zoek.
Ive Marx
@IveMarx
Ik moet bekennen dat ik het straf vind dat een academicus, een oud rector dan nog, zo van opinie verandert door één film. Je bent uiteindelijk geconditioneerd om je opinie op zo robuust mogelijke empirie te bouwen. Begrijpelijke menselijke reactie wel.
www.standaard.be/opinies/pijnlijk-dat-er-pas-geluisterd-w…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Zie onze eigen bespreking hier, met @ThomasRotthier als gewaardeerde tegenstem die het toch (deels) opnam voor NAZA. /2
www.youtube.com/watch?v=FfEeI1uWU0w -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Geen Vlaamse tv-zender, krant of universiteit zou het vandaag in zijn hoofd halen om iemand als mij (of eender welke dissident) een platform te bieden over de “Gaza-genocide”. Iedere redactie weet dat de boel zou ontploffen.
In Nederland is de echokamer bijna even beklemmend, maar toch zijn daar nog een paar kiertjes. Dus schoof ik deze week aan bij De Joodse Wereld (@EOnl), samen met oud-parlementslid @roboudkerk, die uit de @PvdA stapte vanwege de demonisering van de enige Joodse staat ter wereld. We spraken over het g-woord en over het nieuwe boek van Joël Kotek (ULB), dat deze moderne bloedsmaad krachtig weerlegt.
Die “genocide” is een versteend dogma geworden, en het g-woord een loyauteitstest die iedereen moet afleggen. Liefst met een expliciete verwijzing naar de Holocaust, want daar draait het om: de Joden beschuldigen van precies de misdaad waarvan zij de beroemdste slachtoffers zijn, de reden zelf waarom de term werd gemunt.
Want als de Joden nu zélf een genocide op hun geweten zouden hebben, zou dat geen enorme opluchting zijn voor ons? Zou dat niet bewijzen dat ze even erg zijn als hun daders en iedereen die met hen collaboreerde? Zou de wereld dan niet weer quitte staan? (Excuseer mijn cynisme.)
In de kranten gaat de discussie alleen nog over wie de geloofsbelijdenis het vroegst aflegde en wie te lang aarzelde. Die laatsten moeten nu het boetekleed aantrekken. Zoals een bekende Jood ooit zei: zalig zij die niet gezien hebben en toch al geloven. Een tegensprekelijk debat is er nooit geweest. Het was van bij het begin een ritueel, een schuldbelijdenis, een credo. De argumenten waren altijd ridicuul en onlogisch (zie mijn essay voor Quillette, herwerkt tot voorwoord)
Het is de grootste leugen van onze tijd, een moderne versie van de bloedsmaad. Waarmee ik niet ontken dat veel mensen het oprecht in geloven, omdat ze het woord overal horen rondzingen en niet beter weten. En omdat het informatie-ecosysteem over de Gaza-oorlog zo compleet gecorrumpeerd is. Iedereen herhaalt het g-woord, en de ene ngo schrijft het over van de andere, in eindeloze rommelrapporten.
Enfoin, bedankt aan de Evangelische Omroep om deze rabiate atheïst uit te nodigen. Een klein mirakel. 😇 Ik was eigenlijk ziek, maar de redactie drong aan en ik wilde de kans niet laten schieten. Dus gedaan op adrenaline en paracetamol, en daarna een paar dagen in de touwen gelegen.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=FMCq3nzk4JQ
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"In de kranten gaat de discussie alleen nog over wie de geloofsbelijdenis het vroegst aflegde en wie te lang aarzelde. Die laatsten moeten nu het boetekleed aantrekken."
QED
www.standaard.be/opinies/waarom-kreeg-ex-rector-rik-van-d… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Als dit een genocide is, dan is het de stomste, meest incompetente en bizarre genocide die ooit is uitgevoerd." www.youtube.com/watch?v=drJHWjESk30
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Pleegt Israël een genocide in Gaza? Een gesprek over een moderne bloedsmaad, naar aanleiding van het nieuwe boek van politicoloog en genocide-expert Joël Kotek (ULB), waarvoor ik het voorwoord schreef: uitgeverijprometheus.nl/boeken/genocide-en-gaza-paperback/
Interviewer: Rob Oudkerk. Uitgezonden op de Evangelische Omroep (@EOnl)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Michael Verstraeten
@MichaelVerstrae
Er was en is in Gaza geen genocide. Zij die dat beweren doen dat alleen om de Joden te pesten.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Een ex-woke docent
@EenExWokeDocent
Wat een zegen om wetenschapper Maarten Boudry het bloedlasterlijke genocideframe tegen Israël te horen betwisten in De Joodse Wereld. Wat wij momenteel in de samenleving zien, is niet anders te omschrijven dan als genocidegretigheid. Direct daaronder ligt mijns inziens een fenomeen dat sinds 1945 onze omgang met de Holocaust kenmerkt: gaschamberlighting.
Na 1945 kreeg de handvol terugkerende Joden geen warm welkom, maar een zeer kille ontvangst. Hun huizen waren bezet, hun bezit was gestolen en de ambtelijke machine die zo enthousiast had meegewerkt aan hun deportatie was nog altijd onvermurwbaar. Van de 140.000 Joden in Nederland waren er ruim 100.000 vermoord. Desondanks draaide het nationale narratief om het zogenaamd dappere Nederlandse verzet en wederopbouw. Het onvoorstelbare Joodse leed raakte compleet ondergesneeuwd. Pas in 1962 bijvoorbeeld werd de Hollandsche Schouwburg, van waaruit Joden massaal naar de vernietigingskampen werden afgevoerd, aangewezen als herdenkingsmonument.
Dit ongemak kunnen wij onmogelijk zien als onschuldig, net zo min als de grootschalige collaboratie van onze nabije voorouders. Het verhaal van het heldhaftige Nederland dat wij voorgeschoteld kregen, verdroeg slecht dat instanties meewerkten aan deportaties, landgenoten Joden verraadden en bijna iedereen wegkeek. De eigen rol onder ogen zien was veel pijnlijker dan hardop ‘nooit weer’ zeggen en dat ook daadwerkelijk menen.
Later kreeg de Holocaust erkenning, maar vrijwel direct werd deze erkenning in de blender van mensenrechten en algemene morele lessen gegooid. Heel vilein natuurlijk, want wanneer het universele het specifieke bewust verdringt, zoals hier, wordt het wegrelativeren van zelfs de meest ondenkbare duisternis een optie.
In Nederland werd de status van het ultieme slachtofferschap zo snel mogelijk uitbesteed aan nieuwe, actief binnengehaalde minderheden. De overgebleven Joden werd subtiel duidelijk gemaakt dat zij hun geschiedenis beschikbaar moesten stellen voor andermans doelen. Pure morele chantage: “Kijk, wij hebben geleerd van jullie uitroeiing! Kijk, wij halen zelfs ‘nieuwe Joden’ binnen!” Absurder en beledigender wordt het niet.
Gaschamberlighting noem ik specifiek deze omkering: Holocaustoverlevenden, hun nazaten en andere diaspora-Joden onder druk zetten om de geschiedenis van de genocide op hun families te verdunnen tot een universele, inwisselbare slachtofferidentiteit. Zo kon juist de Holocaustherinnering een moreel dwangmiddel tegen Joden zélf worden. Eventuele Joodse instemming werd vervolgens misbruikt om dat dwangmiddel extra gezag te geven.
Dit perfide fenomeen sluit aan bij Boudry’s analyse. Waarom is het niet genoeg om Israël te bekritiseren, op welke manier dan ook? Waarom die genocidegretigheid, die obsessieve genocide-de-la-Tourette? De ongemakkelijke hypothese: de beschuldiging van de Joodse staat kan voor Nederlanders een vorm van historische schuldverlichting zijn. Als de Joden van toen immers de daders van nu zouden worden, kunnen de nazaten van daders, collaborateurs en wegkijkers zichzelf moreel vereffend wanen.
De twee mechanismen houden elkaar perfect in stand. Genocidegretigheid maakt van de nazaten van slachtoffers symbolisch verdachten en gaschamberlighting verlangt dat Joden deze omkering bekrachtigen. Eerst werd hun specifieke leed weggedrukt, vervolgens geüniversaliseerd en nu, uit naam van die universele moraal, tegen Joden zélf ingezet.
Het beschamende is dat men telkens meent te mogen bepalen wat Joden wel of niet uit de eigen geschiedenis zouden moeten leren. Eerst moesten zij zwijgen over wat hun was aangedaan en nu moeten zij instemmen met wat hun geschiedenis volgens anderen betekent.
Laten we vechten voor betere tijden waarin mensen in staat zijn eerlijk te reflecteren op de geschiedenis en het slachtofferschap te laten bij degenen aan wie het daadwerkelijk toebehoort.
Link naar uitzending in onderstaande tweet. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib
@afalkhatib
A Hamas takeover of Belgium? The problem of Hamas's presence in Belgium has become so blatant that, after senior Hamas terror leader Khaled Abu Anza was killed in southern Gaza, a public mourning house was opened in Deurne, Antwerp [Belgium], on Saturday, November 14, from 2- 8 p.m. Out in the open. No fear, no restraint; they even highlighted the bus route for taking public transportation! A Gaza-based page publicly advertised a memorial for a senior Hamas figure in the heart of Belgium.
Where are the Belgian authorities, government, and security services? As I have documented before, friends of mine in Gaza were arrested, detained, interrogated, and tortured at the behest of Hamas members and money-laundering networks in Belgium. This is another glaring example. When will Belgium realize the extent of the catastrophe they are facing? -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Jesús Fernández-Villaverde
@JesusFerna7026
Every time I think European voters cannot be more in denial about pensions, they prove me wrong: they are even more in denial than in my worst nightmare.
The average French person believes there are 6.4 workers for every retiree. The real number is about 1.8.
François Valentin
@Valen10Francois
Really interesting (and worrying) polling on French pensions
The electorate estimates that for every pensioner we have 6 workers.
In reality it's 1.8/1... Even in 1960s we weren't close to 6/1.
Melenchon's supporters think its 13/1. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Ole Lehmann
@itsolelehmann
Norway now has more than 2,000 underwater AI laser robots shooting lice off its salmon
they're made by a company called Stingray, and they already guard more than 50 million salmon and trout 24/7
the reason is sea lice, tiny parasites that latch onto salmon and feed on them
as few as 11 can kill a small fish, and one pen can hold 150,000 salmon
the usual fix is pumping the fish out and blasting them with warm water or water jets to knock the lice off
but the handling is so rough that Norway's fish health report ranks it the top cause of death in full-grown farmed salmon
so instead, Stingray puts a robot inside the pen that hunts lice one at a time, all day:
> two cameras watch every salmon that swims past
> AI checks two frames to make sure it's really a louse
> then a green laser fires from up to 2 meters away
> the salmon's scales reflect the beam, so the fish swims off fine and the louse is dead
we now live in a world where AI lasers do pest control on your dinner lmao -
Maarten Boudry reposted
John Cleese
@JohnCleese
Here's another
Why don't Muslim women smoke pot ?
It's because they don't enjoy getting stoned
Any others ?
John Cleese
@JohnCleese
Here's a joke about Islam:
When are Muslim women allowed to walk ahead of the men ?
In mine fields
Oh! There'a a knock at the door...
The Free Speech Union
@SpeechUnion
🚨 TODAY IS THE DAY!
Stephen Gray is in court today to appeal his conviction under Section 127 of the Communications Act 2003 for posting a joke about Islam on Facebook.
Stephen is an FSU member and a retired police officer who gave 27 years of service to his community.
The joke was an image of a rasher of bacon beside a man in a turban, with the caption: “Fun facts about bacon! People who eat bacon have a lower chance of marrying a 9-year-old!”
It referred to the Prophet Muhammad’s marriage to Aisha, who was six at the time, and the consummation of the marriage when she was nine.
Stephen told the court that the post was satirical, but that he also hoped it would prompt serious debate about whether the marriage had helped make child marriage acceptable in parts of the Muslim world.
He was ordered to pay more than £1,000 in fines and costs, and now has a criminal record.
This is astonishing in a country that abolished blasphemy laws in 2008 — 18 years ago.
The Free Speech Union is proud to support Stephen, and we hope he wins his appeal today.
Please donate to Stephen’s crowdfunder and help us stop an Islamic blasphemy law from taking root in Britain 👇 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Bedankt! Morgen deel ik de video, nu even geveld door virus. 😉
GebandvanJ⭕🚫p @GebandvanJoop
Ontzettend goed gesproken in #dejoodsewereld, Maarten! Veel mensen zijn blij met jouw bijdrage die de enige rationele lijkt in de huidige massapsychose.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
Conspiracy theories may be the only theories that predict an absence of evidence in their favor.
If the plotters are powerful and smart, they’d cover their tracks, and even plant counterevidence.
CI Senior Philosopher @mboudry on why debunking often backfires.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maria Barth - van Beurden Cahn @mariavhaperen
Kijk de Joodse wereld van 12 november. Hè, hè, de Belgische filosoof, Maarten Boudry, die niet zwicht voor de waanzin van journalisten, politici, en andere weekdieren om Israël genocide aan te smeren.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Math Files
@Math_files
Show me a better opening sentence in textbook history than this one✍️
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Geen enkele Vlaamse tv-zender zou het vandaag in zijn hoofd halen om mij (of eender welke andere dissident) uit te nodigen voor een gesprek over de ‘Gaza-genocide’. Evenmin zou een Vlaamse krant het in haar hoofd halen om daarover een opiniestuk te publiceren, of een universiteit om hierover een tegensprekelijk debat te organiseren.
Ze zouden wel gek zijn! De ‘genocide’ in Gaza is immers een versteend dogma geworden, dat niet langer in vraag mag worden gesteld. Iedereen moet het g-woord prevelen als ideologische loyauteitstest, liefst met verwijzingen naar de Holocaust en de Nazi's. De enige discussie betreft nog wie de noodzakelijke geloofsbelijdenis wanneer aflegde. De ijverigen zijn trots dat ze daags na 7 oktober al het g-woord uitspraken, of zelfs jaren eerder al. Anderen die te lang aarzelden, moeten vandaag het boetekleed aantrekken.
In Nederland is het debat gelukkig nog een tikje ruimer dan bij ons. Dus schuif ik vanavond aan bij De Joodse Wereld van de Evangelische Omroep, voor een gesprek met oud-parlementslid @roboudkerk, die uit de @PvdA stapte vanwege de demonisering van de enige Joodse staat ter wereld. We spreken over het g-woord en het nieuwe boek van Joël Kotek (ULB), die deze moderne bloedsmaad krachtig weerlegt.
Bedankt aan @EOnl om deze rabiate atheïst uit te nodigen. Wellicht heeft er zich een klein mirakel voltrokken. 😇
www.eo.nl/tv/de-joodse-wereld -
Maarten Boudry reposted
ApoStructura
@ApoStructura
Reminder that the “datacenters use too much water” problem is fake.
Mary Pezzulo
@mary_pezzulo
Let me try and explain: a Krispy Kreme uses water to make doughnuts which can be eaten and coffee which can be drunken. The workers wash their hands so the food is sanitary and the customers use the bathroom. In a data center, all that water is wasted with no treats.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Noam Dworman
@noam_dworman
Did The New Yorker bend the source materials to fit the narrative? We asked Michael Walzer about this headline (clip).
Full interview below.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Histoire & Odyssée
@HistoireOdyssee
Vue aérienne saisissante des ravages de la Première Guerre mondiale dans les Flandres, près d'Ypres, en 1919. Un paysage encore profondément marqué par quatre années de combats.
Images d'époque colorisées.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Thomas Rotthier
@ThomasRotthier
Ik ging samen met @mboudry en Leentje en Geert van vzw JID naar de NAZA-documentaire kijken (over Israël-Gaza).
Nadien hadden we een nabespreking die je hier kan bekijken. www.youtube.com/watch?v=FfEeI1uWU0w&t=1s
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Vijf sterren voor NAZA? youtu.be/FfEeI1uWU0w
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Joren Vermeersch
@JorenVermeersc1
Iemand Tom Sauer al gehoord over de weigering van Lavrov om met de EU-delegatie te praten in Abu Dhabi? U weet wel: Tom 'Maar we prááten niet met Rusland. Prááát dan toch met Rusland!' Sauer?
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"De beste comedyvoorstelling ooit!" (@DeStandaard over Russell Brand in 2014)
"Brand verheft zelfreflectie tot sublieme comedy en blijft zichzelf heruitvinden. Vijf sterren!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (De Standaard in 2018)
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Remember when this guy was hailed as a Great Thinker by liberal elites, speaking "truth to power"?
In 2015, Russell Brand was voted the fourth most influential thinker alive by Prospect. His book Revolution was praised by a roster of @Guardian writers, with Owen Jones calling it “funny, full of charm, and engaging,” and Vonny Moyes “a dialogue we all need to be having.” Newspapers gushed over his shows as “the best comedy show ever,” claiming they “bear witness to profound insights into society.” Even academic journals described him as “an authentic anti-austerity spokesperson for the disenfranchised left.”
The truth is that Brand was always an obvious fraud—an unhinged conspiracist and narcissist who could pivot on a dime from left-wing posturing to right-wing nuttery. The political horseshoe incarnate.
And a sexual predator, of course.
Gadget
@Gadget440
During his interview with Piers Morgan, Russell Brand got increasingly defensive and didn't want to answer any questions.
Here are the final moments when he melted down:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Remember when this guy was hailed as a Great Thinker by liberal elites, speaking "truth to power"?
In 2015, Russell Brand was voted the fourth most influential thinker alive by Prospect. His book Revolution was praised by a roster of @Guardian writers, with Owen Jones calling it “funny, full of charm, and engaging,” and Vonny Moyes “a dialogue we all need to be having.” Newspapers gushed over his shows as “the best comedy show ever,” claiming they “bear witness to profound insights into society.” Even academic journals described him as “an authentic anti-austerity spokesperson for the disenfranchised left.”
The truth is that Brand was always an obvious fraud—an unhinged conspiracist and narcissist who could pivot on a dime from left-wing posturing to right-wing nuttery. The political horseshoe incarnate.
And a sexual predator, of course.
Gadget
@Gadget440
During his interview with Piers Morgan, Russell Brand got increasingly defensive and didn't want to answer any questions.
Here are the final moments when he melted down:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Vijf sterren voor NAZA? youtu.be/FfEeI1uWU0w
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Eric Fux @ericfux
"Journalistiek broddelwerk" vs. "Als je pro-Israël bent, negeer die getuigenissen niet zomaar"
Maarten Boudry, Thomas Rotthier en Geert Jacobs fileren de film NAZA, die volgens de filmmakers de Israëlische oorlogsvoering in Gaza aan de kaak stelt. In de documentaire getuigen anonieme klokkenluiders over het gebruik van AI-technieken. De film werd op het Filmfestival van Venetië in september onthaald op een 25 minuten lange staande ovatie. Bewijst de film dat het IDF bewust veel burgerslachtoffers wil maken, of net het tegendeel? www.benews.media/nl/post/vijf-sterren-voor-nazaThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Vijf sterren voor NAZA? youtu.be/FfEeI1uWU0w
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De Oekraïense pianiste Anna Fedorova speelt de stormachtige vierde beweging van Chopins 3de Sonate (Chopin had zelf een band met Oekraïne), in het Concertgebouw van Amsterdam. Geweldig concert, veel dank aan Protect Ukraine! 🇺🇦
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De Oekraïense pianiste Anna Fedorova speelt de stormachtige vierde beweging van Chopins 3de Sonate (Chopin had zelf een band met Oekraïne), in het Concertgebouw van Amsterdam. Geweldig concert, veel dank aan Protect Ukraine! 🇺🇦
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Garry Kasparov
@Kasparov63
It’s so disrespectful not to want to be invaded and murdered.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Trump accuses Zelenskyy of showing “great disrespect” to Russia
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A year ago, I published a long essay in @Quillette debunking the “Gaza genocide” calumny and exposing the disingenuousness of its proponents.
It was translated into French by the magazine @LePoint, as well as into Polish and German. And in my own language Dutch? Every single newspaper I pitched it to in Belgium and the Netherlands turned it down. No dissent on this question is tolerated in the Low Countries — not in the press, and certainly not at the university, where my rector declared that anyone questioning the genocide narrative was “crossing a line that should not be crossed”.
But I have finally found a way to publish at least part of the essay in Dutch: it will appear as the foreword to Genocide en Gaza, the Dutch translation of an excellent new book by political scientist and genocide expert Joël Kotek of @ULBruxelles.
Did I mention that this internationally renowned genocide scholar (fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joël_Kotek) happens to agree entirely with my thesis? Are you listening, rector De Sutter (who deleted her account @pdsutter)? -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Aan al deze klavierkrijgers:
Wacht tot jouw land eens wordt binnengevallen door een imperiale agressor die je familie vermoordt en je kinderen laat doodvriezen. Dan zullen we nog eens zien of je die schofterige onverschilligheid van verwende buitenstaanders uit veilige landen weet te appreciëren.
Niemand verplicht je om deze inzamelactie voor Oekraïne te steunen. Maar waarom moet je dan per se zulke hufterige reacties plaatsen? Hou dan gewoon je bek.
Als ik dit soort reacties lees, moet ik mezelf telkens opnieuw voorhouden: "Dit is niet representatief. De meeste mensen zijn niet zo. Alleen verstokte tankies en Poetin-apologeten voelen de aandrang om hierop te reageren."
whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Aan al deze klavierkrijgers:
Wacht tot jouw land eens wordt binnengevallen door een imperiale agressor die je familie vermoordt en je kinderen laat doodvriezen. Dan zullen we nog eens zien of je die schofterige onverschilligheid van verwende buitenstaanders uit veilige landen weet te appreciëren.
Niemand verplicht je om deze inzamelactie voor Oekraïne te steunen. Maar waarom moet je dan per se zulke hufterige reacties plaatsen? Hou dan gewoon je bek.
Als ik dit soort reacties lees, moet ik mezelf telkens opnieuw voorhouden: "Dit is niet representatief. De meeste mensen zijn niet zo. Alleen verstokte tankies en Poetin-apologeten voelen de aandrang om hierop te reageren."
whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Aizenberg
@Aizenberg55
There are now 110 Gazan "healthcare workers" who are confirmed Hamas & PIJ combatants, including 14 who worked at Shifa Hospital, corroborating its use as a Hamas strategic military base. No mainstream media outlet has covered these key admissions by Hamas & PIJ themselves.
Aizenberg
@Aizenberg55
110. Mahmoud Basem Ibrahim Al-Maqadma
Ambulance Driver, Deir Al-Balah
Hamas fighter
ID 404529042, Age 24
Killed 11/16/2023 - Deir Al-Balah -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Sam Bowman
@s8mb
One of my biggest life rules is to never, ever get in an argument with Kelsey Piper.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Andrew Fox
@Mr_Andrew_Fox
I’ve been playing around with May’s Hamas fatality lists today, because what else are Saturdays for?
Gaza’s recorded deaths are heavily concentrated among adult males. In the May 2026 dataset, which contains 72,835 deaths, men aged 18–45 account for 41.12% of those killed, whereas that age/gender group comprised 20.52% of the pre-war population. Their share of recorded deaths is almost exactly twice their population share.
Widening the bracket to males aged 15–45 produces much the same result. They represent 24.39% of the population and 45.68% of listed deaths: 33,268 fatalities against approximately the 17,762 deaths we would expect if deaths had followed the population’s age and sex distribution. Among men aged 25–34, the death share reaches 2.18 times the population benchmark; among those aged 35–45, it reaches 2.35 times.
The 14–18 age group also warrants examination because Hamas has a documented history of recruiting and training minors. The UN’s 2019 report verified the recruitment and use of a 17-year-old by Hamas’s al-Qassam Brigades. Its following annual report recorded Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad camps exposing children as young as 14 to military activities. Hamas itself has publicised children’s military training through its Telegram channel, including instruction in firearms and guerrilla warfare. This evidence requires us to consider under-18 combatants within the casualty figures.
The list contains 5,551 males aged 14–18, against approximately 4,661 under the population-proportional benchmark, a difference of 19%. That disparity is considerably smaller than the adult-male concentration. Of course, it does not mean every teenage boy killed was a fighter, but we cannot pretend that Hamas’s recruitment of children has no bearing on the analysis.
Across all ages, the Gaza list is 69.96% male and 30.04% female.
In Gaza, Hamas’s conduct is central to that examination. In the Henry Jackson Society report I co-authored with @Aizenberg, Hamas’s Human Shield Strategy in Gaza, we documented military infrastructure embedded within civilian neighbourhoods, including tunnel entrances inside homes and weapons stored in residential buildings. The report also examines Hamas’s instructions to civilians to ignore evacuation warnings. These practices placed civilians around military objectives and exploited the restrictions their presence imposed on Israeli attacks. Any account of civilian deaths that removes Hamas’s battlefield organisation from the explanation discards a central cause of civilian exposure to harm.
Israel’s civilian protection measures also form part of the record. OCHA estimated that approximately 50,000 people moved south through an Israeli military corridor on 8 November 2023 alone. It recorded danger and shelling around the route, as well as the extension of the corridor’s operating hours while people continued to leave. This establishes that organised evacuation operated on a substantial scale. The IDF has also published footage of strikes being aborted when civilians appeared. This evidence cannot be omitted from any judgement about Israeli intent.
Even NAZA, a film constructed around allegations against Israel’s conduct, describes intelligence personnel identifying Hamas targets and calculating anticipated civilian casualties. Its most sensational claim, concerning approval for an attack anticipating 500 civilian deaths, comes without any corroborating evidence. The film provides neither a named target nor enough detail to verify its accounts of the alleged high-casualty strikes. Those allegations remain completely unsubstantiated.
A collateral damage estimate belongs within a military targeting process. In its detailed response to the film, the IDF explains that preliminary estimates precede operational review, during which commanders can change the weapon, timing or scope of an attack, require further precautions, or refuse approval. An Israeli targeting source told me 50% of planned strikes in Gaza were aborted due to civilian presence by July 2024. The IDF also distinguishes thresholds requiring senior authorisation from permission to inflict a specified number of civilian deaths. By proving the existence of those calculations, NAZA establishes that anticipated civilian harm was being assessed.
When considered alongside Hamas’s human shield strategy and the evidence of Israeli civilian protection measures, the casualty patterns do not indicate a genocidal campaign. The concentration of deaths among adult males is consistent with substantial combatant losses in a war fought through civilian neighbourhoods. Evacuation arrangements and decisions to withhold fire further undermine any claim of an intention to destroy Gaza’s population. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit is nu al mijn favoriete donatie! 😅 Het spiegelbeeld hiervan kom ik ook vaak tegen: mensen die mij volop steunen i.v.m. het Midden-Oosten, maar mij een "complete lul" (dan wel complete idioot) vinden over Oekraïne. Oef, zo weet ik tenminste dat ik niet lijd aan "audience capture".🙃
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
€17.000 inmiddels om Oekraïne warm te houden! 😍🤑
whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De koppige weigering om na te denken over onze stijgende levensverwachting en de enorme medische mogelijkheden— beide ongezien in de geschiedenis — kan ons nog zuur opbreken.
Hoe «verbouwereerd» en «geschokt» we ook zijn: het is volkomen legitiem om stil te staan bij de miljoenen die we als samenleving uitgeven in de allerlaatste levensfase van een mensenleven om er nog enkele weken of maanden uit te «persen», vaak zonder dat de betrokkene daar zelf om heeft gevraagd.
Bijna elke arts en zorgverlener die ik ken, geeft (onder vier ogen) toe dat er aan het levenseinde vaak sprake is van absurd dure therapeutische hardnekkigheid, voor een marginale «winst».
Noch in Het Nieuwsblad («nog nooit zo verbouwereerd, huiveringwekkend»), noch in De Standaard («neomalthusiaans, onfris»), noch bij politici ("Nazi-idee" / "Hoe gestoord kan je zijn?”) lees ik enig serieus argument, maar vooral een weigering om erover na te denken: «Een samenleving die geen zorg kan dragen voor haar ouderen, is een arme samenleving.»
OK. Stel dat ons laatste levensjaar de samenleving evenveel kost als alle voorgaande levensjaren samen, voor een fractie van de levenskwaliteit. Geen bezwaar, want dit is ononderhandelbaar? En wat als het dubbel zoveel kost? Hoe onsmakelijk die vraag ook mag zijn, je zult toch ergens een grens moeten trekken. De medische technologie schrijdt immers steeds verder, en de vergrijzing die op ons afkomt ook. Dit gaat absoluut ten koste van jongere generaties.
Maar ik hoor dit allemaal liever van Louis CK, een komiek die zich pijnlijke waarheden kan veroorloven met gepaste overdrijving en karikaturen, dan van Roland Duchâtelet, die het met uitgestreken gezicht vermengt met een belachelijk voorkeursregime voor topvoetballers (de slechtst denkbare manier om dit debat te openen).😉
www.youtube.com/watch?v=O13O_jJ55oc -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Gerard Govers (@gerardgovers) is nog diplomatisch ("lang niet zeker"), maar zoals zijn draadje aantoont, wijst echt niéts erop dat gewone Amerikanen de afkeer van 'superrijken' delen die bij Bernie Sanders en andere progressieven zo leeft.
Gematigde kandidaten deden het overal beter (zie grafiek); de kandidaten die Bernie steunde, waren juist relatief zwakker. En de miljardairsbelasting werd zelfs in het progressieve Californië overtuigend weggestemd. Amerikanen ergeren zich aan eikels als Elon Musk, die hun macht misbruiken, en aan de corruptie van Trump, maar niet aan superrijken in het algemeen. Toen Elon Musk nog gewoon Tesla's maakte, vonden ze hem geweldig.
Na deze compleet bevooroordeelde intro van @destandaard, waarin Steven De Foer zijn eigen wensen voor werkelijkheid aanneemt, haak ik eigenlijk al af. (De Foer is één van de ergste gevallen in die krant).
Als de Democraten de toer van De Foer opgaan en zich inbeelden dat Amerikanen zitten te wachten op een haatcampagne tegen 'superrijken', zijn ze reddeloos verloren. De gemiddelde Amerikaan bewondert juist de superrijken.
Gerard Govers
@gerardgovers
Dat Bernie de weg heeft gewezen lijkt me lang niet zeker @destandaard , integendeel. Er zijn verschillende Amerikaanse commentatoren die *op basis van data* stellen dat de meest linkse democraten (gesteund door Sanders , het *minder* goed deden dan de meer gematigden. Hieronder een paar voorbeelden. De kiezer lust minder pap van extreme ideologieën dan we dikwijls schijnen te denken.
www.standaard.be/buitenland/bernie-sanders-wees-de-democr… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A year ago, I published a long essay in @Quillette debunking the “Gaza genocide” calumny and exposing the disingenuousness of its proponents.
It was translated into French by the magazine @LePoint, as well as into Polish and German. And in my own language Dutch? Every single newspaper I pitched it to in Belgium and the Netherlands turned it down. No dissent on this question is tolerated in the Low Countries — not in the press, and certainly not at the university, where my rector declared that anyone questioning the genocide narrative was “crossing a line that should not be crossed”.
But I have finally found a way to publish at least part of the essay in Dutch: it will appear as the foreword to Genocide en Gaza, the Dutch translation of an excellent new book by political scientist and genocide expert Joël Kotek of @ULBruxelles.
Did I mention that this internationally renowned genocide scholar (fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joël_Kotek) happens to agree entirely with my thesis? Are you listening, rector De Sutter (who deleted her account @pdsutter)? -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"It has become common to lament the public crisis of trust in science, experts, and institutions, but much of the decline in trust is deserved. When the public senses that researchers and academic journals are attempting to leverage their scientific authority to advance particular political goals, it ironically undermines that very authority." (@PatrickTBrown31)
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I haven't tweeted anything about the Gaza war for a while because I can barely contain my anger at the sheer dishonesty and irresponsibility of it all—it’s just not good for my blood pressure.
Every major element of the “Gaza genocide” blood libel has now collapsed, yet there has been zero accountability, zero corrections, and zero apologies. It was all just a gleeful exercise in Holocaust inversion: accusing the Jews of the very crime they suffered eight decades ago.
It was bullshit, and many of the people pushing it never believed their own bullshit anyway, as you could tell from their behavior throughout the war: substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx
The gravest crime imaginable has been cheapened and weaponized as a tool of political propaganda, fomenting violence against Jews and Israelis around the world. But nobody seems to care—and least of all the Western media.
Anyway, I can relate to @Mr_Andrew_Fox’s feelings:
“Sometimes I think I am not angry enough, but the scale of the problem is almost too huge to be angry at, collectively. Towering rage must be split into smaller rages at each of the component parts of the blood libel machine.
The whole sorry mess sickens me, and now the great indictment of Israel is coming apart, one revelation at a time. This fact is not being reported by a single damned one of the media outlets that have spent years screeching over the war in Gaza to the exclusion of almost all else. Famine, deliberate attacks on hospitals, the slaughter of journalists and children, and systematic obstruction of aid: each allegation was broadcast as settled fact and then used to prove genocidal intent. The same newsrooms and universities that thundered these charges have shown remarkably little interest in the evidence that now destroys each of these allegations.
It is incredible. There is no aspect of the genocide allegation that has not collapsed.”
/2
substacktools.com/sharex/M_6TYSPO -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
[No comment this time, I'm too exhausted screaming into the void, and my alma mater doesn't give a shit anyway]
Dear Maarten
I spoke with an acquaintance this weekend—she is a professor of political science at [XXX]. She had originally planned to pursue her PhD or post-doc at @UGent, but cancelled those plans due to the anti-Zionist/antisemitic climate. She comes from a Jewish family from [XXX], is progressive (in the true sense of the word), a feminist, and is married to another woman; they have a young daughter. She would fit the profile perfectly—were it not for the fact that she is Jewish and does not speak of "genocide."
She certainly feels isolated, does not dare to speak about her roots, and has little hope that things will change.
I am not sure if you are still collecting testimonies, but her experience is exactly like that of the other lecturers who have reached out to you.
****
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In 1933, Hitler purged Jews from German universities. An entire generation of brilliant Jewish scientists was lost to the country. Within a few years, Hitler had all but destroyed German academia, then the finest in the world.
In 2026, there are no direct expulsions of Jewish scientists. No, of course not! We’re civilized today. But no matter: universities have created such a hostile environment for Jews that many leave of their own accord.
As I have explicitly warned, Belgian universities are engaging in naked acts of ideological partisanship: they are boycotting the only Jewish state in the world for waging a defensive war; giving the blood libel of “genocide” their official stamp of approval; and awarding honorary doctorates to inveterate “antizionists” like @FranceskAlbs, who spreads constant lies about Israel and wouldn’t recognize antisemitism if it clobbered her over the head. And they do all of that under pressure from activists.
This sends a very clear signal to people who believe in Jewish self-determination and Israel’s right to exist: you don’t belong here. Get out. As the activists themselves like to put it: “This is a Zionist-free campus.”
Read this email I received from a Belgian Jewish physicist, and weep.
***
Dear Maarten,
I just wanted to send you an update, following my message to you from a year ago.
We have decided to leave Melbourne and move back to Belgium in March 2027. Until about six months ago, I had a fairly clear idea of what I wanted to do when I returned: find a position at a Belgian university that would allow me to combine teaching with developing and applying mathematical models in physics, mathematical biology, or another field. This is what I enjoy doing, and what I am trained to do. But given everything that has happened over the past few years, and in particular what I have been seeing across the academic world, I have increasingly moved away from that plan. I just don’t feel at home anymore in that world. What you have written about your own departure from academia feels very familiar to me.
My main frustration is not the fact that people at universities have opinions that differ from, or even strongly oppose, my own. That will be the case no matter where I work, and I think having one’s views discussed or even challenged is a great thing. What bothers me, rather, is universities adopting political positions as institutions. Individual academics having and expressing their political views is one thing. The university taking an institutional position is quite different. Two of the universities where I considered applying have recently awarded Francesca Albanese an honorary doctorate. I regard that as an institutional political statement, and one I cannot support.
I wholeheartedly hope the Palestinian people will one day have a state of their own, with full self-determination and the same opportunities in life that we all deserve. I hope that Israelis and Palestinians will ultimately be able to live peacefully and constructively alongside one another. But I experience much of what is presented today as pro-Palestinian activism not as an argument for that future, but as a rejection of Israel’s right to exist. I find it difficult to feel comfortable being part of an institution that, in my view, associates itself with positions of that kind.
More generally, I have little desire to be part of an academic environment in which I find myself constantly frustrated by what I experience as a very unequal treatment of Israel and Jews. Walking around campus and seeing posters everywhere about the so-called genocide in Gaza and calls for a boycott of Israel, while seeing virtually nothing about any other conflict in the world, as though this were the only or the worst conflict on earth, only reinforces that feeling.
I do not yet have a plan B for when I’m back home, but I’m sure I’ll figure something out. One of the main projects for the coming months will be to figure out what I want the next phase of my professional life to look like.
I continue to read your pieces with great interest. It helps to know that I am not alone in these frustrations. And when I am back in Belgium, I’d very much like to go and grab a coffee together.
Kind regards,
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
You really have to wonder why this Jewish scholar believes the climate at @UGent is anti-Zionist and antisemitic.🤔
Just take a look at this list of lectures on Palestine at UGent: every single one is slanted in a pro-Palestinian, anti-Zionist direction. All other perspectives are carefully excluded—yet they have the audacity to call this "dialogue."
No fewer than six lectures take the blood libel of "genocide" for granted—an obscene accusation for which there is not a shred of evidence (substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx).
And this year's new season kicks off with: "How and Why Israel Camouflaged Genocide in Gaza."
Meanwhile, UGent boycotts Israeli universities, continues collaboration with the anti-semitic Birzeit University in Palestine (which bars Israeli Jews from campus), and gives an honorary PhD to the execrable Francesca Albanese.
What a welcoming environment for Jewish and Israeli scholars!
(And here I am, commenting on it after all.) -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De koppige weigering om na te denken over onze stijgende levensverwachting en de enorme medische mogelijkheden— beide ongezien in de geschiedenis — kan ons nog zuur opbreken.
Hoe «verbouwereerd» en «geschokt» we ook zijn: het is volkomen legitiem om stil te staan bij de miljoenen die we als samenleving uitgeven in de allerlaatste levensfase van een mensenleven om er nog enkele weken of maanden uit te «persen», vaak zonder dat de betrokkene daar zelf om heeft gevraagd.
Bijna elke arts en zorgverlener die ik ken, geeft (onder vier ogen) toe dat er aan het levenseinde vaak sprake is van absurd dure therapeutische hardnekkigheid, voor een marginale «winst».
Noch in Het Nieuwsblad («nog nooit zo verbouwereerd, huiveringwekkend»), noch in De Standaard («neomalthusiaans, onfris»), noch bij politici ("Nazi-idee" / "Hoe gestoord kan je zijn?”) lees ik enig serieus argument, maar vooral een weigering om erover na te denken: «Een samenleving die geen zorg kan dragen voor haar ouderen, is een arme samenleving.»
OK. Stel dat ons laatste levensjaar de samenleving evenveel kost als alle voorgaande levensjaren samen, voor een fractie van de levenskwaliteit. Geen bezwaar, want dit is ononderhandelbaar? En wat als het dubbel zoveel kost? Hoe onsmakelijk die vraag ook mag zijn, je zult toch ergens een grens moeten trekken. De medische technologie schrijdt immers steeds verder, en de vergrijzing die op ons afkomt ook. Dit gaat absoluut ten koste van jongere generaties.
Maar ik hoor dit allemaal liever van Louis CK, een komiek die zich pijnlijke waarheden kan veroorloven met gepaste overdrijving en karikaturen, dan van Roland Duchâtelet, die het met uitgestreken gezicht vermengt met een belachelijk voorkeursregime voor topvoetballers (de slechtst denkbare manier om dit debat te openen).😉
www.youtube.com/watch?v=O13O_jJ55oc
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hier nog meer uit hetzelfde vaatje. 😜
youtu.be/8kzEg5cDEEc -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Gerard Govers (@gerardgovers) is nog diplomatisch ("lang niet zeker"), maar zoals zijn draadje aantoont, wijst echt niéts erop dat gewone Amerikanen de afkeer van 'superrijken' delen die bij Bernie Sanders en andere progressieven zo leeft.
Gematigde kandidaten deden het overal beter (zie grafiek); de kandidaten die Bernie steunde, waren juist relatief zwakker. En de miljardairsbelasting werd zelfs in het progressieve Californië overtuigend weggestemd. Amerikanen ergeren zich aan eikels als Elon Musk, die hun macht misbruiken, en aan de corruptie van Trump, maar niet aan superrijken in het algemeen. Toen Elon Musk nog gewoon Tesla's maakte, vonden ze hem geweldig.
Na deze compleet bevooroordeelde intro van @destandaard, waarin Steven De Foer zijn eigen wensen voor werkelijkheid aanneemt, haak ik eigenlijk al af. (De Foer is één van de ergste gevallen in die krant).
Als de Democraten de toer van De Foer opgaan en zich inbeelden dat Amerikanen zitten te wachten op een haatcampagne tegen 'superrijken', zijn ze reddeloos verloren. De gemiddelde Amerikaan bewondert juist de superrijken.
Gerard Govers
@gerardgovers
Dat Bernie de weg heeft gewezen lijkt me lang niet zeker @destandaard , integendeel. Er zijn verschillende Amerikaanse commentatoren die *op basis van data* stellen dat de meest linkse democraten (gesteund door Sanders , het *minder* goed deden dan de meer gematigden. Hieronder een paar voorbeelden. De kiezer lust minder pap van extreme ideologieën dan we dikwijls schijnen te denken.
www.standaard.be/buitenland/bernie-sanders-wees-de-democr… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dus ik overdrijf zogezegd wanneer ik zeg dat onze universiteiten gekaapt zijn door een eng-linkse ideologie?
Bekijk deze lijst van lezingen aan @UGent eens: ALLEMAAL pro-Palestijnse en anti-zionistische sprekers. Elke stem van de andere kant wordt zorgvuldig geweerd. Maar dat durven ze dan wel "dialoog" te noemen.
En maar liefst zes lezingen draaien rond de bloedsmaad van "genocide", een absurde beschuldiging zonder een spat bewijs (substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx).
Moet dit echt met belastinggeld? Organiseer deze agitprop in je eigen VZW, maar niet aan een publieke universiteit.
Dit jaar gaat het nieuwe seizoen van start met: "How and Why Israel Camouflaged Genocide in Gaza".
Onvoorstelbaar.
web.archive.org/web/20260228070154/https://www.middleeast… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"I have to confess that I sometimes feel embarrassed when I realize that my most viral posts (on X or even here on Substack) are about culture-war issues where far less is at stake. As a writer, it doesn’t take long to figure out that angry rants about woke craziness in academia, gender ideology or stupid European climate policy will receive far more clicks and likes than anything related to Ukraine."
This is unfortunatly borne out again by the viewer stats. 😆
If you have ever helped one of my culture-war posts go viral, I’d appreciate it if you checked this one out as well. Still, I'm already extremely happy with the €15K in donations! THANKS.🙏
whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"The two most prominent invitees were philosopher of science Maarten Boudry and Member of Parliament Sam van Rooy (Vlaams Belang)."
I implored the organizers to invite politicians from other parties, not just the radical-right @vlbelang. They tried their best, but couldn't find anyone willing to participate, not even from @MR_officiel or @de_NVA (though, to be fair, they're in the midst of a government crisis).
I don't mind sharing a stage with @SamvanRooy1, but it makes me uncomfortable that his is the only political party represented. My friend Joel Kotek from @ULBruxelles, an expert on antisemitism and genocide (for whose new book I just wrote a foreword), even cancelled his appearance because of Van Rooy's presence.
That's his call, and I respect it, though I think it's unfortunate. This is becoming a self-reinforcing dynamic: the more progressives and moderates abandon the only liberal democracy in the Middle East and even side with its enemies, the more right-wing parties rush to fill the vacuum. And the more Israelis and Jews accept the overtures of these far-right parties, the more they reinforce the association between being pro-Israel and being right-wing.
And then, when I show up at one of these events, my enemies triumphantly exclaim: "Aha! You're sharing a stage with Sam Van Rooy! You've finally shown your true colors!" Never mind that I loathe the far-right fanatics in the current Israeli government and want nothing more than to see Netanyahu gone (Van Rooy, by contrast, is a fan). But just as I'm pro-American despite Trump, I'm a Zionist despite Netanyahu.
The truth is that if politicians from other parties weren't such spineless cowards, pandering to the antisemites among their constituents, we wouldn't need people like @SamvanRooy1 to stand up for Israel.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Exact location shared with registered attendees before the event."
How awful that peaceful pro-Palestinian activists have to hide from murderous Zionists!
Just kidding, of course it's the other way around. It's always Jews and Israelis who have to hide, and deep down you know this. But you’ve just grown so accustomed to it that you no longer notice.
(I'll be speaking there. And don't fucking complain about Sam Van Rooy. If politicians from other parties were not such spineless cowards, we wouldn't need @SamvanRooy1 to stand up for Jews and Israel.)
why-israel-leuven.vercel.app -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is a stunningly good impersonation, and I say this as a fan of @DouglasKMurray. 😂
Tony Lapidus
@TonyLapidus
Douglas Murray reacts to the US midterms
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Keep Ukraine warm
I forgot to mention that you can dial the suggested fee for WhyDonate down to zero, if you like (or choose a smaller amount than the hefty 14%). Just drag that slider! Obviously, I want the lion's share of your donation to actually reach Ukraine and help keep its soldiers alive. By the way, look at that: we're already at 82% of our fundraising goal!
whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"The two most prominent invitees were philosopher of science Maarten Boudry and Member of Parliament Sam van Rooy (Vlaams Belang)."
I implored the organizers to invite politicians from other parties, not just the radical-right @vlbelang. They tried their best, but couldn't find anyone willing to participate, not even from @MR_officiel or @de_NVA (though, to be fair, they're in the midst of a government crisis).
I don't mind sharing a stage with @SamvanRooy1, but it makes me uncomfortable that his is the only political party represented. My friend Joel Kotek from @ULBruxelles, an expert on antisemitism and genocide (for whose new book I just wrote a foreword), even cancelled his appearance because of Van Rooy's presence.
That's his call, and I respect it, though I think it's unfortunate. This is becoming a self-reinforcing dynamic: the more progressives and moderates abandon the only liberal democracy in the Middle East and even side with its enemies, the more right-wing parties rush to fill the vacuum. And the more Israelis and Jews accept the overtures of these far-right parties, the more they reinforce the association between being pro-Israel and being right-wing.
And then, when I show up at one of these events, my enemies triumphantly exclaim: "Aha! You're sharing a stage with Sam Van Rooy! You've finally shown your true colors!" Never mind that I loathe the far-right fanatics in the current Israeli government and want nothing more than to see Netanyahu gone (Van Rooy, by contrast, is a fan). But just as I'm pro-American despite Trump, I'm a Zionist despite Netanyahu.
The truth is that if politicians from other parties weren't such spineless cowards, pandering to the antisemites among their constituents, we wouldn't need people like @SamvanRooy1 to stand up for Israel.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Exact location shared with registered attendees before the event."
How awful that peaceful pro-Palestinian activists have to hide from murderous Zionists!
Just kidding, of course it's the other way around. It's always Jews and Israelis who have to hide, and deep down you know this. But you’ve just grown so accustomed to it that you no longer notice.
(I'll be speaking there. And don't fucking complain about Sam Van Rooy. If politicians from other parties were not such spineless cowards, we wouldn't need @SamvanRooy1 to stand up for Jews and Israel.)
why-israel-leuven.vercel.app -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Tony Lapidus
@TonyLapidus
Douglas Murray reacts to the US midterms
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
If Europe had expanded nuclear energy rather than phase it out...it could have closed down all coal plants by now, slashed gas imports, and cut emissions by an additional ~21%.
Anti-nuclear greens have caused more harm to the climate than climate denialists.
~Conjecture Institute Senior Philosopher @mboudry -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The classic disingenuous wordplay: pretending that "antisemitism" doesn't target Jews because "Arabs are Semites too." And since she loves Arabs so much, how could she possibly be an antisemite? Does she even know that the term "antisemitism" was coined by Jew haters to have a more dignified and salonfähig term for "Jew hatred"?
This comes close on the heels of her ludicrous claim about "dogs trained in Europe to rape Palestinian prisoners."
Every time Albanese comes out with another piece of antisemitic nonsense, she further disgraces the three universities that saw fit to bestow an honorary PhD on her (@Ugent @UAntwerpen @vubrussel). Only @KU_Leuven rescued its reputation by abstaining. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський
@ZelenskyyUa
When Putin seized Crimea, both Europe and America were quite openly making calls, holding meetings, and sending signals to the Ukrainians who were in power at the time that there should be no escalation – let's just keep things friendly and leave things as they are for now. And we lost Crimea. After that, we lost part of Donbas. But the shooting in the east continued. There was no peace.
People think we were always helped. That is not true. Help started coming after the full-scale invasion, but that was after eight years of Russia occupying our territory. That is a long time to figure things out and understand that Putin has no intention of giving anything back to us.
At one point, some Europeans asked me: “Why do you think that if you withdraw from Donbas, he will go further?” And I answered: “Because at the beginning of the war, he wasn't seizing Donbas. He came to the capital. He seized parts of Zaporizhzhia and Kherson regions, Kherson itself, and Kharkiv region.” We have retaken a lot of territory, but he had seized different parts of our country. And now they want us to give them something because they are unable to seize it. We may have a smaller territory, less money, and fewer weapons, but we still have more dignity than many others. We will do everything we can to end this war, but it must end in a way that preserves our dignity.
From an interview with ZDF. (2/3) -
Maarten Boudry reposted
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Massimo
@Rainmaker1973
Ronald Reagan explains the USSR in one joke (1988)
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"I have to confess that I sometimes feel embarrassed when I realize that my most viral posts (on X or even here on Substack) are about culture-war issues where far less is at stake. As a writer, it doesn’t take long to figure out that angry rants about woke craziness in academia, gender ideology or stupid European climate policy will receive far more clicks and likes than anything related to Ukraine."
This is unfortunatly borne out again by the viewer stats. 😆
If you have ever helped one of my culture-war posts go viral, I’d appreciate it if you checked this one out as well. Still, I'm already extremely happy with the €15K in donations! THANKS.🙏
whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dus ik overdrijf zogezegd wanneer ik zeg dat onze universiteiten gekaapt zijn door een eng-linkse ideologie?
Bekijk deze lijst van lezingen aan @UGent eens: ALLEMAAL pro-Palestijnse en anti-zionistische sprekers. Elke stem van de andere kant wordt zorgvuldig geweerd. Maar dat durven ze dan wel "dialoog" te noemen.
En maar liefst zes lezingen draaien rond de bloedsmaad van "genocide", een absurde beschuldiging zonder een spat bewijs (substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx).
Moet dit echt met belastinggeld? Organiseer deze agitprop in je eigen VZW, maar niet aan een publieke universiteit.
Dit jaar gaat het nieuwe seizoen van start met: "How and Why Israel Camouflaged Genocide in Gaza".
Onvoorstelbaar.
web.archive.org/web/20260228070154/https://www.middleeast… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Belgian Friends of Israel
@BelgianFOI
Illuminating keynote address last night at @KU_Leuven, no less, by courageous intellectual @mboudry.
Why is Belgium the epicentre of anti-Israel propaganda, in the media, judiciary, politics, so-called civil society and particularly academia?
Few call it out. Dr. Boudry is one of the minority to have the integrity and resolve to do so.
One Belgian university Vice-Chancellor privately confided that what they called “Gaza mania” appears to be “a collective madness” exemplified by the fallacious claim that Israel is committing genocide.
Integrity comes at a cost. Massive respect to this man of principle. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"It turns out that normal Americans do exist — in great numbers, in fact. It’s possible to keep them divided with relentless partisanship. It’s possible to drive them to jaded apathy with relentless he-said-she-said accusations and manufactured scandals. It’s possible to get many of them to stay home on election nights, simply by ignoring their wishes for long enough. But if you push them hard enough — if you step on their face again and again, with corruption and mismanagement and disdain for their daily struggles — they will eventually bestir themselves and rise up and smack you down. They will remind you of who won the Second World War, and why."
substacktools.com/sharex/ZJ915_ax -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Seeds of Science
@science_seeds
Are the Brooms Multiplying Yet? — by Maarten Boudry (@mboudry)
"This is the Darwinian update of the apprentice’s predicament: every blow of the axe selects for brooms that are harder to destroy."
www.theseedsofscience.pub/p/are-the-brooms-multiplying-yet -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Heeft @Humo zich hier ooit voor geëxcuseerd? Is er iets van die klacht terechtgekomen?
Ik vind het werkelijk schokkend dat Kamagurka (@LucZeebroek), die ik nochtans hoog heb zitten, zoiets uit zijn pen kan schudden. Hij moet toch op de hoogte zijn van de lange geschiedenis van de middeleeuwse bloedsprookjes over Joden die het bloed van kinderen drinken, en van de mythe van ‘Joden als kindermoordenaars’.
Zie de voorbeelden hieronder. Een ‘cartoon’ van Joodse beulen die op bebloede kinderlijkjes inhakken, is niet alleen het smerigste, maar ook het luiste en minst originele dat je als cartoonist kunt bedenken.
Was het niet Kamagurka die (terecht) zijn vriend Herman Brusselmans berispte om diens column over ‘joden met een mes door de keel rammen’? Maar dit vind ik minstens even erg.
www.knack.be/nieuws/belgie/klacht-tegen-humo-wegens-antis…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Niet verwonderlijk dat @Humo ook het blad is dat walgelijke antisemitische "cartoons" als deze afdrukt, een moderne versie van het middeleeuwe bloedsprookje met als leugenachtige onderschrift: "Op 7 oktober 2023 viel Israël Gaza binnen." En natuurlijk kon je in hetzelfde blad ook columns lezen waarin de auteur fantaseert dat hij "elke Jood met een mes door de keel wil rammen".
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Mijn voorspelling is uitgekomen, met dank aan @Humo:😉
"Wedden dat jullie ook deze brief weigeren, net zoals mijn vorige over de kwestie?"
Dit is het zoveelste "progressieve" medium dat steeds meer werd gekaapt door een jonge generatie van regressief-linkse activisten (om het vagere woord "woke" maar te vermijden). Daar hoort vanzelfsprekend islamapologie bij, want dat heet vandaag "progressief" (zie mijn boek: uitgeverijprometheus.nl/boeken/verraad-aan-de-verlichting…).
Triest voor een blad dat ooit rebels, oneerbiedig en snoeihard voor de Katholieke Kerk was.
wnl.tv/2026/10/25/islamogauchisme-is-geen-complottheorie
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Waarom "islamogauchisme" geen complottheorie is
Is de toenadering tussen linkse en islamitische krachten in onze samenleving, soms aangeduid als islamogauchisme, niet meer dan een ‘complottheorie’, zoals Stefaan Werbrouck (@swerbrou) schrijft in @Humo? Als auteur van meerdere academische papers over complottheorieën kan ik stellen: dat is volstrekte onzin en een misbruik van de term.
Een echte complottheorie draait om een doelbewust, geheim en snood plan waarvoor geen hard bewijs bestaat, omdat de samenzweerders het zogezegd zorgvuldig verbergen. De toenadering tussen delen van links en de islam is echter voor iedereen zichtbaar en uitvoerig gedocumenteerd. Het is geen bewuste coördinatie achter de schermen, maar een toenadering die wordt gedreven door een gedeelde vijand (het Westen en het kapitalisme) en een fikse scheut naïviteit aan linkse kant.
Linkse academici, journalisten en intellectuelen doen al decennialang hun uiterste best om elke legitieme kritiek op de islam neer te sabelen als ‘islamofobie’. Dat perfide concept moet een geloofssysteem immuniseren tegen kritiek, en ze namen het letterlijk over van islamisten. Ze verloochenen hun eigen progressieve principes door een oogje dicht te knijpen voor homohaat, vrouwenhaat, eerwraak en geweld tegen afvalligen, zolang die maar uit islamitische hoek komen. Ze herhaalden ook uitentreuren de onzin dat jihadistisch terrorisme ‘niets met de islam te maken heeft’. Al jaren zijn er demonstraties en optredens waar radicaal-linkse en islamitische groepen samen optrekken, de laatste jaren vooral rond Palestina.
In mijn boek Het verraad aan de verlichting documenteer ik uitvoerig hoe moslims uitgroeiden tot de favoriete slachtoffergroep van links: een groep die nooit of te nimmer iets verkeerd kan doen.
De sympathie is overigens veel minder wederzijds. Islamisten profiteren van de naïviteit van links en staan zij aan zij met linkse activisten op de barricaden zolang ze een gemeenschappelijke vijand delen: het kapitalisme of het Westen. Maar zodra islamisten ergens de macht grijpen, zoals in Iran, Egypte, Libanon of Palestina, worden hun linkse medestanders brutaal aan de kant geschoven en onderdrukt.
Het hoeft dus niet te verbazen dat de rellen en plunderingen in Frankrijk werden uitgevoerd door een allegaartje van radicaal-linkse activisten en Noord-Afrikaanse moslims, en dat er overal Palestijnse vlaggen wapperden. Hier en daar werden zelfs leuzen gescandeerd als ‘Dood hen in naam van Allah!’ gescandeerd, en rapsongs gezongen die de terreuraanslag op de Bataclan verheerlijkten. Links drukt deze slang al decennialang tegen de borst.
De ironie wil dat Stefaan Werbrouck zelf een treffend voorbeeld van dat islamogauchisme is: een linkse rakker die in het ooit rebelse en vrijzinnige magazine @Humo onlangs de Koran in bescherming nam tegen de beschuldiging van vrouwenhaat, en die de overduidelijke verbanden tussen het islamitische geloof en homohaat wegwuift.
Kun je je voorstellen dat iemand in Humo in de bres springt voor de Jehova’s getuigen en de Bijbel tegen kritiek in bescherming neemt? Dat is precies het soort dubbele standaard waar de term islamogauchisme naar verwijst.
Dank voor de illustratie, @Humo. Wedden dat jullie ook deze brief weigeren, net zoals mijn vorige over de kwestie? -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The problem is that I don’t really understand what kind of mental state the phrase “I did not believe X, but I believed that I believed X” picks out. If that describes my mental state at the time, shouldn’t it be possible, at least in hindsight, to admit that I never believed in X? But that’s not what it feels like: I didn't just believe that I believed in heaven, I also believed in heaven.
Here is a mental state I do understand: “I really wanted to believe X at the time, and I had sort of persuaded myself that X, but deep down I didn’t really believe it. I just suppressed my doubts”. That's self-deception, and once the spell is broken, you can explain what was going on. But again, that is not what it feels like.
Let me tell you a creepy little story. When I was about six, I was playing at my grandmother’s house in the hallway, together with my little sister. It was a spiral staircase with a metal balustrade. My little sister got her head stuck between the V-shaped balusters and began to strangle herself as she tried to pull out. My grandmother heard the commotion and rushed over to free her. According to family lore, I just stood there unperturbed, and I said, “Don’t worry, sis, soon you’ll be up in heaven.”
My grandmother, who was very devout, loved telling this story. She found it amusing, one of those silly things children say. But hang on, I thought: you were the one who told me about this wonderful place where we all end up when we die. What exactly did I get wrong? How was I supposed to not take it seriously? I was almost jealous that my sister would get there first!
David Pinsof
@DavidPinsof
Thanks, Maarten. As for your personal past belief, is it at least possible that you merely believed that you believed heaven and hell were literal places? If pseudobeliefs feel like real beliefs from the inside, it may be impossible to tell from the inside if they're pseudo.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A great post by @DavidPinsof on a question I've been thinking about a lot, and on which my own views are still very much in flux: do people who profess to believe crazy things actually believe them? Or are they merely pretending for social reasons? Does anyone really believe in heaven and hell, deep down, or in 9/11 conspiracy theories, or in climate doom, or AI doom?
substacktools.com/sharex/-2PZSzLT
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
As for climate doomers, I agree that many of them are full of shit. You can glean as much from their behavior. A fortiori for AI doomers. /2 quillette.com/2024/03/18/are-climate-doomers-for-real/
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
But I've made the opposite argument when it comes to religious belief: crazy as it may sound, millions of people really do believe that shit, and they act accordingly. And we ignore this at our peril (think of jihadist beliefs about heavenly rewards in the afterlife).
Anecdotally, I used to be a religious believer myself, and I can tell you that I really believed heaven and hell were literal places. @DavidPinsof
/3
drive.google.com/file/d/0B_K-qtp6iiL1akU3am5HRUtFdVE/view…
David Pinsof
@DavidPinsof
Thanks, Maarten. As for your personal past belief, is it at least possible that you merely believed that you believed heaven and hell were literal places? If pseudobeliefs feel like real beliefs from the inside, it may be impossible to tell from the inside if they're pseudo.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The problem is that I don’t really understand what kind of mental state the phrase “I did not believe X, but I believed that I believed X” picks out. If that describes my mental state at the time, shouldn’t it be possible, at least in hindsight, to admit that I never believed in X? But that’s not what it feels like: I didn't just believe that I believed in heaven, I also believed in heaven.
Here is a mental state I do understand: “I really wanted to believe X at the time, and I had sort of persuaded myself that X, but deep down I didn’t really believe it. I just suppressed my doubts”. That's self-deception, and once the spell is broken, you can explain what was going on. But again, that is not what it feels like.
Let me tell you a creepy little story. When I was about six, I was playing at my grandmother’s house in the hallway, together with my little sister. It was a spiral staircase with a metal balustrade. My little sister got her head stuck between the V-shaped balusters and began to strangle herself as she tried to pull out. My grandmother heard the commotion and rushed over to free her. According to family lore, I just stood there unperturbed, and I said, “Don’t worry, sis, soon you’ll be up in heaven.”
My grandmother, who was very devout, loved telling this story. She found it amusing, one of those silly things children say. But hang on, I thought: you were the one who told me about this wonderful place where we all end up when we die. What exactly did I get wrong? How was I supposed to not take it seriously? I was almost jealous that my sister would get there first!
David Pinsof
@DavidPinsof
Thanks, Maarten. As for your personal past belief, is it at least possible that you merely believed that you believed heaven and hell were literal places? If pseudobeliefs feel like real beliefs from the inside, it may be impossible to tell from the inside if they're pseudo.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hou Oekraïne warm!
maartenboudry.be/2026/11/hou-oekraine-warm.html -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit opiniestuk werd geweigerd door zowel @destandaard als @demorgen, uiteraard (DM antwoordde wel, DS niet). Maar hier in ons tochtgat aan de Noordzee kon je wel ridicule "analyses" lezen over hoe de gewelddadige protesten allemaal de schuld waren van "neoliberalisme" en van Marine Le Pen.
Het verscheen wel bij @WNLVandaag in Nederland. En inmiddels ook Franse, Engelse en Poolse vertalingen.
Leve de Vlaamse kneuterigheid!
wnl.tv/2026/10/25/islamogauchisme-is-geen-complottheorie
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
L’islamo-gauchisme n’est pas une théorie du complot, c’est une histoire d’amour à sens unique
jonathas.org/lislamogauchisme-nest-pas-une-theorie-du-com…
via Postbro -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
L’islamo-gauchisme n’est pas une théorie du complot, c’est une histoire d’amour à sens unique
jonathas.org/lislamogauchisme-nest-pas-une-theorie-du-com…
via Postbro -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Institut Jonathas
@jonathasbel
Nous publions aujourd'hui l'analyse de @mboudry, philosophe et chercheur indépendant.
"L'islamogauchisme n'est pas une théorie du complot, c'est une histoire d'amour à sens unique", à lire sur le site de l'Institut Jonathas.
jonathas.org/lislamogauchisme-nest-pas-une-theorie-du-com… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Winter Is Coming for Ukraine
Putin wants to freeze the country into submission. Will you help me buy heaters for its soldiers?
I'm raising money for heaters, generators and power stations for soldiers in Ukrainian trenches. Almost €10,000 raised in a few days! Chip in or share here:
👉 whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What a thrilling story. I hope many Russian soldiers who still have a conscience will follow in his footsteps.
"Stupnikov is now facing off against the Russian brigade he left behind. His story has inspired others. One Russian drone pilot tossed a live grenade into his military barracks before sprinting across the front lines earlier this year. Another defector who aided Ukraine said he had wanted to beat Stupnikov’s record of 300 Russians dead. Karpenko’s informant pipeline has become a 24/7 operation, with longtime sources earning $4,000 a month."
archive.ph/WIgRE -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Richard Dawkins
@RichardDawkins
Hallelujah! Donald lame-Duck.
But let’s hope the Looney-Tunes left wing of the Democrat party can be reined in.
At the same time let’s hope Congress will find a way to bring Trump to justice, for his corrupt use of the presidency to enrich himself, for his criminal attempted coup when he lost the 2020 election, and for besmirching the dignity of the presidency. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Almost €13.000 in just a few days, amazing! 😍 Thanks a lot to everyone who already donated! whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The effect of our financial and material support to the Ukrainian army should not be measured only in terms of soldiers’ lives saved. For the rest of us in Europe, the war in Ukraine is also about averting a low-probability, high-impact event that many of us fail to appreciate. What if the Ukrainian front collapses and Russia manages to topple the democratically elected government in Kyiv? The consequences of such a scenario would be catastrophic for all of Europe.
The Russian army would suddenly be on the doorstep of NATO members Poland, Slovakia, Hungary and Romania, as well as Moldova. The largest European army, and the only one with battlefield experience in modern drone warfare, would be obliterated, and much of its drone industry and technical know-how would end up in Russian hands. Russia would conclude that Europe is feckless, having failed to prevent the obliteration of a friendly democracy, just as it failed to prevent the annexation of Crimea in 2014. And it would now have a free hand in the Baltic States, as the Institute for the Study of War wrote in a 2024 report:
"The risks of a Russian attack against NATO in the near future would rise dramatically if the US allows Russia to defeat Ukraine now, and the challenge of defending the Baltic States in particular could become almost insurmountable."
There might be even broader geopolitical consequences: quietly watching from a distance, China would likely conclude that the West is a paper tiger and that it can do as it pleases with Taiwan.
When Ukraine eventually sits down to negotiate peace with Russia—as it must, sooner or later—we need to ensure that it does so from the strongest possible position. Beyond the moral imperative of supporting a beleaguered democracy against imperial aggression, supporting the Ukrainian army is also in our enlightened self-interest.
substacktools.com/sharex/4G8UAaa8 -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Almost €13.000 in just a few days, amazing! 😍 Thanks a lot to everyone who already donated! whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The effect of our financial and material support to the Ukrainian army should not be measured only in terms of soldiers’ lives saved. For the rest of us in Europe, the war in Ukraine is also about averting a low-probability, high-impact event that many of us fail to appreciate. What if the Ukrainian front collapses and Russia manages to topple the democratically elected government in Kyiv? The consequences of such a scenario would be catastrophic for all of Europe.
The Russian army would suddenly be on the doorstep of NATO members Poland, Slovakia, Hungary and Romania, as well as Moldova. The largest European army, and the only one with battlefield experience in modern drone warfare, would be obliterated, and much of its drone industry and technical know-how would end up in Russian hands. Russia would conclude that Europe is feckless, having failed to prevent the obliteration of a friendly democracy, just as it failed to prevent the annexation of Crimea in 2014. And it would now have a free hand in the Baltic States, as the Institute for the Study of War wrote in a 2024 report:
"The risks of a Russian attack against NATO in the near future would rise dramatically if the US allows Russia to defeat Ukraine now, and the challenge of defending the Baltic States in particular could become almost insurmountable."
There might be even broader geopolitical consequences: quietly watching from a distance, China would likely conclude that the West is a paper tiger and that it can do as it pleases with Taiwan.
When Ukraine eventually sits down to negotiate peace with Russia—as it must, sooner or later—we need to ensure that it does so from the strongest possible position. Beyond the moral imperative of supporting a beleaguered democracy against imperial aggression, supporting the Ukrainian army is also in our enlightened self-interest.
substacktools.com/sharex/4G8UAaa8 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Jean-Luc Picard remains the single most compelling vision of progressive politics I am familiar with — secular, rational, compassionate, egalitarian; a believer in progress & abundance but also duty, hard work, and a constant battle for self-improvement and improving the world.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Jonah
@jonahelshout
Winter Is Coming for #ukraine.
#freezing Ukraine into #submission
In the coming months, however, the #russians plan to enlist another deadly ally: the brutal Ukrainian winters.
Maarten Boudry
maartenboudry.substack.com/p/winter-is-coming-for-ukraine…
maartenboudry.substack.com/p/winter-is-coming-for-ukraine… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Het moet gezegd: dit is een uitstekend stuk van @RubenBaetens. Was het allemaal zo simpel als sommige klimaatwetenschappers het voorstellen. Nogmaals blijkt dat de mensen die de meeste expertise hebben over klimaatopwarming niet de beste raadgevers zijn om het probleem op te lossen.
"Dat schouderophalen doet alsof de moeilijkste vraag van de hele transitie amper een detail is. Alsof iemand ergens één knop moet aanzetten en dat niet wil. Thiery noemt zichzelf een “oncoloog van de planeet”, maar ook een oncoloog kiest de behandeling niet alleen. En ze is zelden pijnloos."
"Investeerders in wind en zon wachten op meer elektrische vraag om hun prijs zeker te stellen. Wie wil elektrificeren, wacht op meer wind en zon om een lagere prijs zeker te stellen. En de netbeheerder wacht op wie het eerst beweegt, voor hij een dikkere kabel legt waarvan iemand de rekening moet betalen. Alle drie handelen ze verstandig en samen staan ze stil."
"Zelfs ‘goedkoop’ is minder eenvoudig dan het klinkt. Want leg als politicus maar eens uit waarom de technologie die steeds als ‘de goedkoopste’ verkocht wordt, toch twintig jaar overheidsgaranties nodig heeft." www.demorgen.be/meningen/wie-de-schouders-ophaalt-voor-he…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Precies. En dit is een nagel waarop ecomodernisten al jaren kloppen, @RubenBaetens. Dat narratief over de "goedkoopste energie ooit" creëert verwachtingen die je nooit kan waarmaken, omdat het helemala geen rekening houdt met weersafhankelijkheid, waardedeflatie, netaansluiting, etc.😉
"Zelfs ‘goedkoop’ is minder eenvoudig dan het klinkt. Want leg als politicus maar eens uit waarom de technologie die steeds als ‘de goedkoopste’ verkocht wordt, toch twintig jaar overheidsgaranties nodig heeft."
www.demorgen.be/meningen/wie-de-schouders-ophaalt-voor-he… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What a thrilling story. I hope many Russian soldiers who still have a conscience will follow in his footsteps.
"Stupnikov is now facing off against the Russian brigade he left behind. His story has inspired others. One Russian drone pilot tossed a live grenade into his military barracks before sprinting across the front lines earlier this year. Another defector who aided Ukraine said he had wanted to beat Stupnikov’s record of 300 Russians dead. Karpenko’s informant pipeline has become a 24/7 operation, with longtime sources earning $4,000 a month."
archive.ph/WIgRE -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The effect of our financial and material support to the Ukrainian army should not be measured only in terms of soldiers’ lives saved. For the rest of us in Europe, the war in Ukraine is also about averting a low-probability, high-impact event that many of us fail to appreciate. What if the Ukrainian front collapses and Russia manages to topple the democratically elected government in Kyiv? The consequences of such a scenario would be catastrophic for all of Europe.
The Russian army would suddenly be on the doorstep of NATO members Poland, Slovakia, Hungary and Romania, as well as Moldova. The largest European army, and the only one with battlefield experience in modern drone warfare, would be obliterated, and much of its drone industry and technical know-how would end up in Russian hands. Russia would conclude that Europe is feckless, having failed to prevent the obliteration of a friendly democracy, just as it failed to prevent the annexation of Crimea in 2014. And it would now have a free hand in the Baltic States, as the Institute for the Study of War wrote in a 2024 report:
"The risks of a Russian attack against NATO in the near future would rise dramatically if the US allows Russia to defeat Ukraine now, and the challenge of defending the Baltic States in particular could become almost insurmountable."
There might be even broader geopolitical consequences: quietly watching from a distance, China would likely conclude that the West is a paper tiger and that it can do as it pleases with Taiwan.
When Ukraine eventually sits down to negotiate peace with Russia—as it must, sooner or later—we need to ensure that it does so from the strongest possible position. Beyond the moral imperative of supporting a beleaguered democracy against imperial aggression, supporting the Ukrainian army is also in our enlightened self-interest.
substacktools.com/sharex/4G8UAaa8 -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Winter Is Coming for Ukraine
Putin wants to freeze the country into submission. Will you help me buy heaters for its soldiers?
I'm raising money for heaters, generators and power stations for soldiers in Ukrainian trenches. Almost €10,000 raised in a few days! Chip in or share here:
👉 whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Winter Is Coming for Ukraine
Putin wants to freeze the country into submission. Will you help me buy heaters for its soldiers?
substacktools.com/sharex/4G8UAaa8 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
If you end up with a situation in which a bunch of scientists tend to have the same blind spots, then the mechanism of peer review no longer works.
~Conjecture Institute Senior Philosopher @mboudry w/ @andrasbanethThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Aizenberg
@Aizenberg55
Gaza's story of the year remains ignored: Hamas & PIJ have admitted themselves that FIFTY-NINE of their combatants used the press vest as cover. Once, any Israeli claim that a "journalist" was a combatant was dismissed as propaganda. Now dozens of confirmed cases—still ignored.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
BBC News (World)
@BBCWorld
Supermarket freezers in Belgium and Sweden hit by cyber-attack www.bbc.com/news/articles/cq1kd1nee80eo
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Geert Noels
@GeertNoels
Wie vandaag de straat opgaat voor meer koopkracht, betoogde enkele jaren geleden nog voor degrowth.
Ze kregen wat ze vroegen. Alleen het verband zien ze niet. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Hans Koppies
@HansKoppies
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit is de meest verontrustende (en ook teleurstellende) zin uit het interview met de uitgejouwde Prof. Freddy Mortier (@Ugent):
"Mocht ik vooraf geweten hebben welke storm daaruit zou ontstaan, had ik die passage waarschijnlijk niet opgenomen. Dat geef ik zonder problemen toe."
Mortier had die passage juist wél moeten opnemen, zelfs en vooral als hij op voorhand wist dat ze controverse zou veroorzaken. Waarvoor dienen universiteiten anders? Decaan Gita Deneckere had sowieso al het dossier-Cofnas aangesneden. Maar zij vertolkte natuurlijk het Enige Moreel Correcte Standpunt.
Mortier was dus niet zozeer moedig, zoals ik aanvankelijk dacht. Hij had gewoon de gevolgen verkeerd ingeschat.
Kijk, jongens en meisjes, zo werkt sociale druk en zelfcensuur dus. Als de activisten maar agressief genoeg zijn, durft niemand nog zijn mond open te trekken en zijn werkelijke standpunt te delen.
Hetzelfde geldt voor Israël en transkwesties. Ik wéét dat sommige collega's het voor 100% met mij eens zijn, maar doodsbang zijn om daarvoor uit te komen.
Als universiteiten op deze manier doorgaan, verbreken ze het sociale contract. Dan moet hun financiering worden heroverwogen, of op zijn minst afhankelijk worden gemaakt van aantoonbare beterschap.
In een vrij land mag je ideologische madrassa's oprichten, maar dan niet met belastinggeld.
Verder trouwens een uitstekend en waardevol interview met Freddy Mortier over levenseinde.
demens.nu/nieuws/veel-mensen-denken-dat-hun-levenseinde-g…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hier de dynamiek beschreven: substacktools.com/sharex/vDKZRhgf
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"School studies in Belgium show that attitudes towards Jews and homosexuals are not only more negative among Muslim pupils, but also more negative among other pupils where the percentage of Muslim pupils is higher."
Het onderstaande bevestigt dus precies de hypothese die ik een tijdje geleden opperde, @mkeulemans: de intolerantie tegenover homo’s en Joden onder Moslims sijpelt ook door naar hun niet-islamitische leeftijdsgenoten: hoe meer moslims in de klas, hoe lager de homo-acceptatie bij de andere leerlingen.
Dit is ook logisch: waarom zouden jongeren wél vatbaar zijn voor sociale invloed door marginale manosphere-types op Instagram die ze nooit ontmoet hebben, maar níét door de reële sociale druk in hun eigen klas, waar je toch niet als het "homo-vriendje" (of erger) wil gezien worden?
Wordt het geen tijd om dat oordeel "aantoonbaar onjuist" in te trekken, Maarten?😉Zelfs voor de stijging van homohaat kan je dat niet hardmaken; het tegendeel van een indirecte invloed lijkt inmiddels best waarschijnlijk.
De hele analyse van Ruud Koopmans (@Ruud_Koop_mans) over de dynamieken van integratie en de vele rooskleurige illusies daarover is trouwens voortreffelijk en meer dan het lezen waard:
"Prejudices towards outgroups among certain groups of immigrants may moreover affect prosocial equilibria in the receiving society not only directly through their own attitudes and behaviors, but may also, through cultural transmission in the reverse direction, affect the attitudes of the rest of the population. This is especially likely to happen in contexts where immigrant shares are disproportionately high, as is the case nowadays in many school classes. School studies in Belgium show that attitudes towards Jews and homosexuals are not only more negative among Muslim pupils, but also more negative among other pupils where the percentage of Muslim pupils is higher.
A large-scale study across 867 classrooms in Germany, the United Kingdom, the Netherlands and Sweden showed that pupils' attitudes towards homosexuals are associated with the attitudes prevailing in classmates' parental countries of origin. Pupils in classrooms connected to more conservative origin-country cultures expressed less acceptance of homosexuality. The relationship appeared in all four countries and differed little between ethnic-majority and minority pupils."
bibliothek.wzb.eu/pdf/2026/vi26-103.pdf
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Beste Maarten (@mkeulemans),
Het verbaast me toch dat iemand als jij, die anders zo nuchter en onverschrokken tegen heilige huisjes schopt op andere domeinen (bv. klimaat en economie), dan toch zo goedgelovig bent zodra het over islam en migratie gaat. Is het een soort waterbedeffect, waarbij je verloren deugpunten op het ene terrein elders moet compenseren? Of misschien heb jij ook zo'n indruk van mij, maar dan andersom?😉
Maar even ernstig: het verband tussen islam en homohaat is overduidelijk en blijkt uit alle studies die rechtstreeks naar religie peilen, in plaats van naar een zeer onvolkomen proxy als "migratieachtergrond". Zie bovenal het onderzoek van @Ruud_Koopmans, maar er zijn ook andere studies hierover, die allemaal in dezelfde richting wijzen (er zijn er niet geweldig veel, want de meeste onderzoekers durven het verband met de islam met geen tang aan te raken).
Wereldwijd is ongeveer 85% van de moslims van mening dat homoseksualiteit moreel verwerpelijk is. 27% van de Britse moslims wil homoseksualiteit verbieden. De helft van de Turken in Duitsland beschouwt homoseksualiteit als een "ziekte". De helft van de Europese moslims wil geen homoseksuele mensen als vriend. En een kwart van de jonge moslims in België zegt dat geweld tegen homoseksuele mensen gerechtvaardigd is (JOP-monitor). Deze opvattingen volgen bovendien een voorspelbare gradiënt: hoe vromer, hoe intoleranter. Net zoals bij christenen overigens, maar de baselines bij islam ligt flink hoger.
Hoezo is het verband met islam en migratie dan "aantoonbaar onjuist" volgens deze studie? Ze gebruiken enkel de proxy "migratieachtergrond", en daarover enkele punten die vanzelfsprekend zouden moeten zijn: (1) niet iedereen met een migratieachtergrond is moslim; (2) niet iedereen zonder migratieachtergrond is géén moslim. Het hangt bovendien af van de gebruikte definitie van "migratieachtergrond" (doorgaans iets als: minstens één ouder die in het buitenland geboren is). Derde-generatiemigranten uit moslimlanden zijn dan volledig onzichtbaar in zo'n methodologie, net als blanke bekeerlingen. En daarmee laten we de afvalligen en liberale moslims nog buiten beschouwing.
En dan nog een laatste punt: als het aannemelijk is dat sociale besmetting van attitudes via de online "manosfeer" mogelijk is, waarom zou het dan ondenkbaar zijn dat enkele dominante jongeren in een klas met een agressief anti-LGBT-discours hun leeftijdsgenoten beïnvloeden? Dat er zo een breder anti-LGBT klimaat ontstaat? Is het dan zo vergezocht om hier een rol van de islam in te zien, gezien al het bovenstaande en de groei van de islam in onze contreien?
Ik heb de methodologie van deze studie niet uitgebreid bekeken, dus verlicht me als ik iets mis. Maar ik heb het onderwerp wel grondig bestudeerd en uitgezocht aan de hand van een zeer gelijkaardige studie hier in Vlaanderen. De politiek-correcte blindheid was daar niet te harden, en de denkfouten waren krek dezelfde.
substacktools.com/sharex/A9qupIBj
Maarten Keulemans
@mkeulemans
Natuurlijk weer de reflex: "Lagere homoacceptatie jongeren komt door MoSLiMs!!!" 🙄
Alleen is dat gewoon aantoonbaar onjuist.
Cijfers #trimbos: afname acceptatie zit overal, óók bij kinderen zónder migratieachtergrond. >> -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I just stumbled upon this gem from @slatestarcodex, written more than 12 years ago, about the curious phenomenon of in-group tribalism masquerading as humble self-criticism, which has fascinated me for a long time:
"So when members of the Blue Tribe decide to dedicate their entire life to yelling about how terrible the Red Tribe is, they make sure that instead of saying “the Red Tribe”, they say “America”, or “white people”, or “straight white men”. That way it’s humble self-criticism.
[...]
So when members of the Blue Tribe decide to dedicate their entire life to yelling about how terrible the Red Tribe is, they make sure that instead of saying “the Red Tribe”, they say “America”, or “white people”, or “straight white men”. That way it’s humble self-criticism."
I've previously discussed the linguistic crystallization of this phony humility: the self-excluding we, where the speaker implicates others while subtly exempting himself. Here on misanthropy:
"Much of this misanthropy may amount to posturing—a form of covert self-aggrandisement concealed behind the grammar of the “self-excluding we.” When flagellants declare that “we” are a cancer on the planet, they quietly exempt themselves and the environmentally enlightened."
Translation of the Elvis Presley story: "Except for me! Look at me showing so much care, racially sensitive person that I am! I'm not like the rest of 'us'!"
slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything-exc… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
For everyone who helped make some of my culture-war tweets go viral: please check this out as well, as it’s WAY more important! 😆As I wrote in @Quillette:
"If we can't support this brave nation fighting to be part of our civilisation, what’s the point of having such a civilisation in the first place?"
Slava Ukraini! 🇺🇦
whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Enkel vanuit een positie van kracht kan Oekraïne een vredesbestand uit de brand slepen. Wie Oekraïne steun ontzegt voordat Poetin akkoord is gegaan met een bestand, brengt vrede net verder weg. Dan herinnert Poetin zich meteen de veel grotere ambities die hij had toen hij Oekraïne op 24 februari 2022 binnenviel: het land zelf opnieuw onder Russische dominantie brengen. Dan stoomt het Russische leger door, desnoods nog jaren, tot heel Oekraïne veroverd is. Over de ruggen en lijken van miljoenen Oekraïense burgers."
Dit is elementaire speltheorie, maar dat gaat er bij sommige "vredesduiven" maar niet in.
Nog een geluk dat @JorenVermeersc1 voor @destandaard schrijft. 😉
www.standaard.be/opinies/het-is-niet-de-steun-aan-oekrane… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
UPDATE: The literary prize awarded by @themothmagazine to Jeffrey-Michael Kane for a story that turned out to be 100% AI-generated has now been withdrawn.
The official explanation reads:
"Jeffrey-Michael Kane has withdrawn his story ‘The Shoulder’ from The Moth Short Story Prize 2026, due to a misunderstanding of the terms and conditions."
themothmagazine.com/directory/2026-judged-by-wendy-erskine
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
It seems that literary magazine @themothmagazine has awarded its 1st prize to a short story that is 100% AI-generated, according to @Pangram: www.pangram.com/history/e3d1c545-4024-453b-8986-6ec8093c1…
I read the story. I ain't no literary critic, but it's kinda lame. It's superficially poetic and atmospheric, but on reflection it doesn't make much sense.
Here it is:
***
The Shoulder
By Jeffrey-Michael Kane
The first dead thing I ever saw that someone claimed was sleeping was a horse.
Not a whole horse. The back half was under a blue tarp behind the volunteer fire department in Nebo, and the front half was visible enough to make the lie unreasonable. Its eye had gone the colour of creek water. A man from the county stood smoking beside it while my aunt said to me quietly, don't stare if you can help it. Then louder, for everyone else: poor thing's exhausted.
Afterwards, for years, I thought exhaustion was a visible condition. I thought if you became tired enough your body would simply refuse further instruction.
The horse had gotten loose in a storm and stepped wrong on the shoulder where the road gave way. That was the official version. But mountain people have a second version for every story and sometimes a third one they keep for themselves. By supper the Ingles cashier was telling customers the horse had thrown itself into the ditch because animals know weather before people do. By Wednesday somebody at church said it'd been running from something up on Hoppis Ridge. By Friday the children had improved it into certainty.
There was a woman on the ridge road.
Not a ghost. Nobody said ghost. Ghosts belonged to stories imported from elsewhere, all chains and vengeance and Victorian grief. This woman was local. She wore a yellow raincoat and stood in the middle of the road after storms with one hand lifted like she was trying to remember whether she'd meant to wave or warn.
The first person to mention her to me was my cousin Dell, who lied with tremendous conviction.
"If you pass her and don't look in the mirror," he said, "she stays where she is."
"And if you do?"
He shrugged. "Then she rides home with you."
We were eleven and had just enough imagination to injure ourselves with it.
When I was eight or nine, before any of this, my mother had driven these same roads with her left hand open on the wheel and her right hand pointing things out. Goldfinches in the chicory. A buck no bigger than a kitchen dog. The field where her grandfather had cut hay until the tractor took his hand. She had a way of saying look without taking her eyes off the road, and I learned to look in the direction her voice tilted. By eleven I could find a kingfisher on a wire before she'd finished the word.
She sang Patsy Cline wrong her whole life. When I leaned in, I could almost taste the gravel in her voice. The second verse of Walkin' After Midnight she never could get right, didn't care, would not be corrected.
That autumn my mother started taking the long road back from Morganton after chemo because the curves kept her awake. She said the mountain roads required a conversation with the body that straight roads did not. The treatments made her sleep in fragments. Sometimes she'd wake at the kitchen table at two in the morning with both hands still around a cold cup of coffee like she'd only briefly stepped away from herself.
She wore a scarf even indoors by then. Not because she'd lost all her hair yet, but because she knew she would.
On Thursdays I went with her to treatment because my father worked swing shift at the furniture plant and my aunt had three boys already ruining her carpets. The cancer centre sat beside a dentist's office and smelled faintly of powdered soup. Women slept in recliners under crocheted blankets while televisions mounted near the ceiling explained weather systems no one intended to travel through.
Mama always carried a grocery sack with her Bible, peppermint candies and a little spiral notebook where she wrote down numbers.
Not prayers. Counts.
White blood cell count. Platelets. Temperature. Weight. Hours slept. Ounces of water. Number of times she'd thrown up that morning. She recorded herself the way men in flood country mark river heights on bridge pilings.
One Thursday coming home, rain came down so hard the road disappeared except where the headlights rebuilt it.
"You watching?" Mama asked.
"Watching what."
"The shoulder."
"For deer?"
"For people."
She said it flatly. Not teasing.
I watched.
Near the turnoff for Lake James, where the guardrail bent inward from an old collision, someone stood in the rain wearing yellow.
Not bright yellow. The exhausted yellow of newspaper left in a window.
My mother saw her too. I know she did because her hand tightened once on the wheel and then relaxed deliberately, finger by finger, like she was unclenching from prayer.
We passed the woman at thirty miles an hour.
She did not wave.
She stood with her face turned slightly towards us, patient as mail.
In the side mirror I saw only rain.
Mama drove another two miles. She did not speak. I did not ask her to.
At home she vomited blood into the sink while I stood behind her holding the scarf she'd taken off in the car. Afterwards she rinsed the basin clean before my father got home because illness in our family was treated as a kind of untidiness. Something to manage privately before guests arrived.
The woman in yellow stayed with me though.
I started watching roadsides after storms. I checked mirrors too quickly. I learned every reflector and mailbox between Marion and Glenwood so I could identify deviations instantly. If I could notice enough things in time, maybe nothing irreversible would happen.
By November my mother no longer drove herself to treatment.
By Christmas she had stopped writing numbers in the notebook.
I found it months later in the drawer beside the telephone. The last page held only four entries:
Temperature normal. Road clear. No woman tonight. Home safe.
I carried the notebook for years after she died. Through college. Through my first apartment in Asheville with windows that leaked cold air straight onto the mattress. Through the year I married someone who believed all fear could be reasoned with if you loved a person steadily enough.
Last October, driving home from visiting my aunt in Marion, I took the ridge road by mistake.
Or not by mistake.
Rain had just passed through. The trees were still dripping. Halfway around the bend near the old guardrail I saw someone ahead on the shoulder in a faded yellow coat.
Not standing.
Walking.
Head down against the weather.
I slowed almost to nothing.
For one impossible second I thought: Mama forgot something somewhere.
Then the woman turned enough for the headlights to catch her face and she was twenty years old at most, earbuds in, carrying a plastic grocery bag that bumped against her knee with every step.
A local girl. Wet. Alive.
She glanced at me politely as I passed.
In the mirror behind me, for just a moment, the road held two yellow figures instead of one. Then rain moved across the glass and took the other one with it.
www.themothmagazine.com/directory/2026-judged-by-wendy-er…This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
As a psychologist and therapist, Freud was a charlatan and a pseudoscientist. But when he ventured beyond the human mind and briefly escaped the grip of his own dogma, he could be quite perceptive. See books like The Future of an Illusion and Civilization and Its Discontents. Here he was right on the money.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Niet verwonderlijk dat @Humo ook het blad is dat walgelijke antisemitische "cartoons" als deze afdrukt, een moderne versie van het middeleeuwe bloedsprookje met als leugenachtige onderschrift: "Op 7 oktober 2023 viel Israël Gaza binnen." En natuurlijk kon je in hetzelfde blad ook columns lezen waarin de auteur fantaseert dat hij "elke Jood met een mes door de keel wil rammen".
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Mijn voorspelling is uitgekomen, met dank aan @Humo:😉
"Wedden dat jullie ook deze brief weigeren, net zoals mijn vorige over de kwestie?"
Dit is het zoveelste "progressieve" medium dat steeds meer werd gekaapt door een jonge generatie van regressief-linkse activisten (om het vagere woord "woke" maar te vermijden). Daar hoort vanzelfsprekend islamapologie bij, want dat heet vandaag "progressief" (zie mijn boek: uitgeverijprometheus.nl/boeken/verraad-aan-de-verlichting…).
Triest voor een blad dat ooit rebels, oneerbiedig en snoeihard voor de Katholieke Kerk was.
wnl.tv/2026/10/25/islamogauchisme-is-geen-complottheorie
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Waarom "islamogauchisme" geen complottheorie is
Is de toenadering tussen linkse en islamitische krachten in onze samenleving, soms aangeduid als islamogauchisme, niet meer dan een ‘complottheorie’, zoals Stefaan Werbrouck (@swerbrou) schrijft in @Humo? Als auteur van meerdere academische papers over complottheorieën kan ik stellen: dat is volstrekte onzin en een misbruik van de term.
Een echte complottheorie draait om een doelbewust, geheim en snood plan waarvoor geen hard bewijs bestaat, omdat de samenzweerders het zogezegd zorgvuldig verbergen. De toenadering tussen delen van links en de islam is echter voor iedereen zichtbaar en uitvoerig gedocumenteerd. Het is geen bewuste coördinatie achter de schermen, maar een toenadering die wordt gedreven door een gedeelde vijand (het Westen en het kapitalisme) en een fikse scheut naïviteit aan linkse kant.
Linkse academici, journalisten en intellectuelen doen al decennialang hun uiterste best om elke legitieme kritiek op de islam neer te sabelen als ‘islamofobie’. Dat perfide concept moet een geloofssysteem immuniseren tegen kritiek, en ze namen het letterlijk over van islamisten. Ze verloochenen hun eigen progressieve principes door een oogje dicht te knijpen voor homohaat, vrouwenhaat, eerwraak en geweld tegen afvalligen, zolang die maar uit islamitische hoek komen. Ze herhaalden ook uitentreuren de onzin dat jihadistisch terrorisme ‘niets met de islam te maken heeft’. Al jaren zijn er demonstraties en optredens waar radicaal-linkse en islamitische groepen samen optrekken, de laatste jaren vooral rond Palestina.
In mijn boek Het verraad aan de verlichting documenteer ik uitvoerig hoe moslims uitgroeiden tot de favoriete slachtoffergroep van links: een groep die nooit of te nimmer iets verkeerd kan doen.
De sympathie is overigens veel minder wederzijds. Islamisten profiteren van de naïviteit van links en staan zij aan zij met linkse activisten op de barricaden zolang ze een gemeenschappelijke vijand delen: het kapitalisme of het Westen. Maar zodra islamisten ergens de macht grijpen, zoals in Iran, Egypte, Libanon of Palestina, worden hun linkse medestanders brutaal aan de kant geschoven en onderdrukt.
Het hoeft dus niet te verbazen dat de rellen en plunderingen in Frankrijk werden uitgevoerd door een allegaartje van radicaal-linkse activisten en Noord-Afrikaanse moslims, en dat er overal Palestijnse vlaggen wapperden. Hier en daar werden zelfs leuzen gescandeerd als ‘Dood hen in naam van Allah!’ gescandeerd, en rapsongs gezongen die de terreuraanslag op de Bataclan verheerlijkten. Links drukt deze slang al decennialang tegen de borst.
De ironie wil dat Stefaan Werbrouck zelf een treffend voorbeeld van dat islamogauchisme is: een linkse rakker die in het ooit rebelse en vrijzinnige magazine @Humo onlangs de Koran in bescherming nam tegen de beschuldiging van vrouwenhaat, en die de overduidelijke verbanden tussen het islamitische geloof en homohaat wegwuift.
Kun je je voorstellen dat iemand in Humo in de bres springt voor de Jehova’s getuigen en de Bijbel tegen kritiek in bescherming neemt? Dat is precies het soort dubbele standaard waar de term islamogauchisme naar verwijst.
Dank voor de illustratie, @Humo. Wedden dat jullie ook deze brief weigeren, net zoals mijn vorige over de kwestie? -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Mijn voorspelling is uitgekomen, met dank aan @Humo:😉
"Wedden dat jullie ook deze brief weigeren, net zoals mijn vorige over de kwestie?"
Dit is het zoveelste "progressieve" medium dat steeds meer werd gekaapt door een jonge generatie van regressief-linkse activisten (om het vagere woord "woke" maar te vermijden). Daar hoort vanzelfsprekend islamapologie bij, want dat heet vandaag "progressief" (zie mijn boek: uitgeverijprometheus.nl/boeken/verraad-aan-de-verlichting…).
Triest voor een blad dat ooit rebels, oneerbiedig en snoeihard voor de Katholieke Kerk was.
wnl.tv/2026/10/25/islamogauchisme-is-geen-complottheorie
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Waarom "islamogauchisme" geen complottheorie is
Is de toenadering tussen linkse en islamitische krachten in onze samenleving, soms aangeduid als islamogauchisme, niet meer dan een ‘complottheorie’, zoals Stefaan Werbrouck (@swerbrou) schrijft in @Humo? Als auteur van meerdere academische papers over complottheorieën kan ik stellen: dat is volstrekte onzin en een misbruik van de term.
Een echte complottheorie draait om een doelbewust, geheim en snood plan waarvoor geen hard bewijs bestaat, omdat de samenzweerders het zogezegd zorgvuldig verbergen. De toenadering tussen delen van links en de islam is echter voor iedereen zichtbaar en uitvoerig gedocumenteerd. Het is geen bewuste coördinatie achter de schermen, maar een toenadering die wordt gedreven door een gedeelde vijand (het Westen en het kapitalisme) en een fikse scheut naïviteit aan linkse kant.
Linkse academici, journalisten en intellectuelen doen al decennialang hun uiterste best om elke legitieme kritiek op de islam neer te sabelen als ‘islamofobie’. Dat perfide concept moet een geloofssysteem immuniseren tegen kritiek, en ze namen het letterlijk over van islamisten. Ze verloochenen hun eigen progressieve principes door een oogje dicht te knijpen voor homohaat, vrouwenhaat, eerwraak en geweld tegen afvalligen, zolang die maar uit islamitische hoek komen. Ze herhaalden ook uitentreuren de onzin dat jihadistisch terrorisme ‘niets met de islam te maken heeft’. Al jaren zijn er demonstraties en optredens waar radicaal-linkse en islamitische groepen samen optrekken, de laatste jaren vooral rond Palestina.
In mijn boek Het verraad aan de verlichting documenteer ik uitvoerig hoe moslims uitgroeiden tot de favoriete slachtoffergroep van links: een groep die nooit of te nimmer iets verkeerd kan doen.
De sympathie is overigens veel minder wederzijds. Islamisten profiteren van de naïviteit van links en staan zij aan zij met linkse activisten op de barricaden zolang ze een gemeenschappelijke vijand delen: het kapitalisme of het Westen. Maar zodra islamisten ergens de macht grijpen, zoals in Iran, Egypte, Libanon of Palestina, worden hun linkse medestanders brutaal aan de kant geschoven en onderdrukt.
Het hoeft dus niet te verbazen dat de rellen en plunderingen in Frankrijk werden uitgevoerd door een allegaartje van radicaal-linkse activisten en Noord-Afrikaanse moslims, en dat er overal Palestijnse vlaggen wapperden. Hier en daar werden zelfs leuzen gescandeerd als ‘Dood hen in naam van Allah!’ gescandeerd, en rapsongs gezongen die de terreuraanslag op de Bataclan verheerlijkten. Links drukt deze slang al decennialang tegen de borst.
De ironie wil dat Stefaan Werbrouck zelf een treffend voorbeeld van dat islamogauchisme is: een linkse rakker die in het ooit rebelse en vrijzinnige magazine @Humo onlangs de Koran in bescherming nam tegen de beschuldiging van vrouwenhaat, en die de overduidelijke verbanden tussen het islamitische geloof en homohaat wegwuift.
Kun je je voorstellen dat iemand in Humo in de bres springt voor de Jehova’s getuigen en de Bijbel tegen kritiek in bescherming neemt? Dat is precies het soort dubbele standaard waar de term islamogauchisme naar verwijst.
Dank voor de illustratie, @Humo. Wedden dat jullie ook deze brief weigeren, net zoals mijn vorige over de kwestie? -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
So far, I've managed to thank every single donor individually. But please, keep flooding us with more donations until I can no longer keep up! 😀 We're already at €8,354 to help keep the Ukrainian army warm this winter. 🙏🇺🇦
whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In plaats van eindelijk eens een tegensprekelijk debat te organiseren over Israël, bijvoorbeeld met genocide-expert Prof. Joël Kotek van de ULB (zie zijn nieuwe boek), organiseert @destandaard dus een "debat" tussen twee anti-zionisten die het zo roerend eens zijn dat ze elkaar letterlijk knuffelen.
Nadat ze dus elke week een beaat interview doen met een andere anti-zionist, bij voorkeur een Jood. Dit is de lezers gewoon in hun gezicht uitlachen.
Zoals eerder gezegd: deze krant heeft totaal geen interesse meer in debat, enkel in kneuterige rondjes zelfbevlekking.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wij van WC-eend presenteren u een spannend debat tussen twee liefhebbers van WC-eend, die vurig pleiten voor nóg meer WC-eend. Dit na onze wekelijkse reeks van gesprekken met gepassioneerde voorstanders van WC-eend. @destandaard
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Mikael J. K. PETITJEAN @mjkp1973
Si "Israël n'est pas une démocratie et ne l'a jamais été", alors nous vivons tous dans un enfer dictatorial. Aux armes citoyens ! A quand la révolution antifasciste ? A quand nos lendemains qui chantent ? Ces gens vivent en plein "Cloud Cuckoo Land"... sans même les Beatles (LSD= Lucy in the Sky with Diamond). Vive @mboudry. Et je m'arrête là... @destandaard
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In plaats van eindelijk eens een tegensprekelijk debat te organiseren over Israël, bijvoorbeeld met genocide-expert Prof. Joël Kotek van de ULB (zie zijn nieuwe boek), organiseert @destandaard dus een "debat" tussen twee anti-zionisten die het zo roerend eens zijn dat ze elkaar letterlijk knuffelen.
Nadat ze dus elke week een beaat interview doen met een andere anti-zionist, bij voorkeur een Jood. Dit is de lezers gewoon in hun gezicht uitlachen.
Zoals eerder gezegd: deze krant heeft totaal geen interesse meer in debat, enkel in kneuterige rondjes zelfbevlekking.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wij van WC-eend presenteren u een spannend debat tussen twee liefhebbers van WC-eend, die vurig pleiten voor nóg meer WC-eend. Dit na onze wekelijkse reeks van gesprekken met gepassioneerde voorstanders van WC-eend. @destandaard
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
Demanding economic growth has become unfashionable among some people in Europe.
Instead they speak of a “cost of living crisis”.
But it’s really one and the same.
Economic growth means that incomes rise relative to prices.
Economic growth means that the things we need become more affordable. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wij van WC-eend presenteren u een spannend debat tussen twee liefhebbers van WC-eend, die vurig pleiten voor nóg meer WC-eend. Dit na onze wekelijkse reeks van gesprekken met gepassioneerde voorstanders van WC-eend. @destandaard
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In plaats van eindelijk eens een tegensprekelijk debat te organiseren over Israël, bijvoorbeeld met Prof. Joel Kotek van ULB (zie zijn nieuwe boek), organiseert @destandaard dus een "debat" tussen twee anti-zionisten die het zo roerend eens zijn dat ze elkaar letterlijk knuffelen.
Nadat ze dus elke week een beaat interview doen met een andere anti-zionist, bij voorkeur een Jood. Dit is de lezers gewoon in hun gezicht uitlachen.
Zoals eerder gezegd: deze krant heeft totaal geen interesse meer in debat, enkel in kneuterige rondjes zelfbevlekking.
/2
www.editions-hermann.fr/livre/le-genocide-a-l-epreuve-de-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Kathryn Paisner
@KathrynPaisner
Can you imagine the @washingtonpost publishing this article, today?
They should run it again, but they probably won’t, because they’re cowards. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Winter is coming. For Ukrainians, that means temperatures of –20°C or lower, Russian missiles targeting power grids and warehouses, and the very real prospect of freezing in the dark.
Unable to conquer more territory on the battlefield, Putin is now trying to freeze and starve an entire population into submission.
I traveled to Ukraine in September, which was a harrowing experience (read my account here in @Quillette: quillette.substack.com/p/an-army-of-yesterdays-civilians-…). A friend I made on the train to Kyiv, who was travelling with her nine-year-old daughter, recently texted me that Kyiv had endured a 13-hour power cut.
Generators are scarce and prohibitively expensive. And as for the soliders, many are spending the winter in freezing trenches and dugouts, with no reliable heating whatsoever.
With Trump now completely betraying Ukraine – and even praising Putin as a “humanitarian” – it's up to the rest of us to step up.
We're raising money to provide thousands of generators, portable power stations and diesel heaters. These aren't luxuries. They keep soldiers warm, power the drones and radios they depend on, and can literally save lives.
Want to be a real humanitarian? Here's your chance. Please donate today, and help keep Ukraine warm this winter:
👉 whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm
Slava Ukraini! 🇺🇦 -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Winter is coming. For Ukrainians, that means temperatures of –20°C or lower, Russian missiles targeting power grids and warehouses, and the very real prospect of freezing in the dark.
Unable to conquer more territory on the battlefield, Putin is now trying to freeze and starve an entire population into submission.
I traveled to Ukraine in September, which was a harrowing experience (read my account here in @Quillette: quillette.substack.com/p/an-army-of-yesterdays-civilians-…). A friend I made on the train to Kyiv, who was travelling with her nine-year-old daughter, recently texted me that Kyiv had endured a 13-hour power cut.
Generators are scarce and prohibitively expensive. And as for the soliders, many are spending the winter in freezing trenches and dugouts, with no reliable heating whatsoever.
With Trump now completely betraying Ukraine – and even praising Putin as a “humanitarian” – it's up to the rest of us to step up.
We're raising money to provide thousands of generators, portable power stations and diesel heaters. These aren't luxuries. They keep soldiers warm, power the drones and radios they depend on, and can literally save lives.
Want to be a real humanitarian? Here's your chance. Please donate today, and help keep Ukraine warm this winter:
👉 whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm
Slava Ukraini! 🇺🇦
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Donate here! whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
🇺🇦 Keeping Ukraine warm this winter 🇺🇦
Winter is coming, and for most of us, that means cozy evenings with family and friends. For Ukrainians, it means temperatures of minus 20 degrees or lower, and a Russian army attacking the power grid and warehouses. Putin couldn’t conquer any new territory, so now he wants to freeze people into submission. 🥶
I was in Ukraine in September. My friend Yana, whom I met on the train to Kyiv with her nine-year-old daughter, just texted me that Kyiv had endured a thirteen-hour power cut. ⚡ Generators are scarce and expensive. And the soldiers? They’re in trenches and dugouts with no heating at all.
With the U.S. now betraying Ukraine, even praising Putin as a “humanitarian,” it’s up to the rest of us to step up. ❤️
The Diel Foundation is raising money for thousands of generators, portable power stations and diesel heaters. They keep soldiers warm, and power the drones and radios that keep them alive. 🔌
Want to be a true humanitarian? Please donate today! 🙏
Last year, we raised over a million euros. Will you help us beat that? 💙💛
👉 whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warmThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wow, dat gaat hard! Gisterenavond pas gelanceerd, maar ze zitten al bijna aan €5.000, een kwart van het vooropgestelde doel. Donaties voor powerstations, dieselkachels en noodgeneratoren zijn nog steeds meer dan welkom! Laat het Oekraïense leger deze winter niet in de kou staan. 🇺🇦😉whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
For everyone who helped make some of my culture-war tweets go viral: please check this out as well, as it’s WAY more important! 😆As I wrote in @Quillette:
"If we can't support this brave nation fighting to be part of our civilisation, what’s the point of having such a civilisation in the first place?"
Slava Ukraini! 🇺🇦
whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Ted Nordhaus
@TedNordhaus
A giant is gone. news.yale.edu/2026/10/31/william-nordhaus-nobel-laureate-…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
🇺🇦 Hi everyone!
Winter is coming, and for most of us, that means cozy evenings with family and friends. For Ukrainians, it means temperatures of minus 20 degrees or lower, and a Russian army attacking the power grid and warehouses. Putin couldn’t conquer any new territory, so now he wants to freeze people into submission. 🥶
I was in Ukraine in September. My friend Yana, whom I met on the train to Kyiv with her nine-year-old daughter, just texted me that Kyiv had endured a thirteen-hour power cut. ⚡ Generators are scarce and expensive. And the soldiers? They’re in trenches and dugouts with no heating at all.
With the U.S. now betraying Ukraine, even praising Putin as a “humanitarian,” it’s up to the rest of us to step up. ❤️
The Diel Foundation is raising money for thousands of generators, portable power stations and diesel heaters. They keep soldiers warm, and power the drones and radios that keep them alive. 🔌
Want to be a true humanitarian? Please donate today! 🙏
Last year, we raised over a million euros. Will you help us beat that? 💙💛
👉 whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Is6UyYSgeVA -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Joël De Ceulaer
@jdceulaer
Doneer. Vandaag nog. 🔥
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
🇺🇦 Hi everyone!
Winter is coming, and for most of us, that means cozy evenings with family and friends. For Ukrainians, it means temperatures of minus 20 degrees or lower, and a Russian army attacking the power grid and warehouses. Putin couldn’t conquer any new territory, so now he wants to freeze people into submission. 🥶
I was in Ukraine in September. My friend Yana, whom I met on the train to Kyiv with her nine-year-old daughter, just texted me that Kyiv had endured a thirteen-hour power cut. ⚡ Generators are scarce and expensive. And the soldiers? They’re in trenches and dugouts with no heating at all.
With the U.S. now betraying Ukraine, even praising Putin as a “humanitarian,” it’s up to the rest of us to step up. ❤️
The Diel Foundation is raising money for thousands of generators, portable power stations and diesel heaters. They keep soldiers warm, and power the drones and radios that keep them alive. 🔌
Want to be a true humanitarian? Please donate today! 🙏
Last year, we raised over a million euros. Will you help us beat that? 💙💛
👉 whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Is6UyYSgeVA -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
🇺🇦 Keeping Ukraine warm this winter 🇺🇦
Winter is coming, and for most of us, that means cozy evenings with family and friends. For Ukrainians, it means temperatures of minus 20 degrees or lower, and a Russian army attacking the power grid and warehouses. Putin couldn’t conquer any new territory, so now he wants to freeze people into submission. 🥶
I was in Ukraine in September. My friend Yana, whom I met on the train to Kyiv with her nine-year-old daughter, just texted me that Kyiv had endured a thirteen-hour power cut. ⚡ Generators are scarce and expensive. And the soldiers? They’re in trenches and dugouts with no heating at all.
With the U.S. now betraying Ukraine, even praising Putin as a “humanitarian,” it’s up to the rest of us to step up. ❤️
The Diel Foundation is raising money for thousands of generators, portable power stations and diesel heaters. They keep soldiers warm, and power the drones and radios that keep them alive. 🔌
Want to be a true humanitarian? Please donate today! 🙏
Last year, we raised over a million euros. Will you help us beat that? 💙💛
👉 whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warmThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
🇺🇦 Hi everyone!
Winter is coming, and for most of us, that means cozy evenings with family and friends. For Ukrainians, it means temperatures of minus 20 degrees or lower, and a Russian army attacking the power grid and warehouses. Putin couldn’t conquer any new territory, so now he wants to freeze people into submission. 🥶
I was in Ukraine in September. My friend Yana, whom I met on the train to Kyiv with her nine-year-old daughter, just texted me that Kyiv had endured a thirteen-hour power cut. ⚡ Generators are scarce and expensive. And the soldiers? They’re in trenches and dugouts with no heating at all.
With the U.S. now betraying Ukraine, even praising Putin as a “humanitarian,” it’s up to the rest of us to step up. ❤️
The Diel Foundation is raising money for thousands of generators, portable power stations and diesel heaters. They keep soldiers warm, and power the drones and radios that keep them alive. 🔌
Want to be a true humanitarian? Please donate today! 🙏
Last year, we raised over a million euros. Will you help us beat that? 💙💛
👉 whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Is6UyYSgeVA -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
🇺🇦 Keeping Ukraine warm this winter – fundraiser 🇺🇦
Many of us are looking forward to winter, with its coziness, warmth and celebrations with loved ones – but Ukrainians are not. 🥶 Winters in Ukraine can be brutal, with temperatures dropping to -25 °C or lower, and the Russian army is preparing a winter offensive aimed squarely at the country’s energy infrastructure, warehouses and food distribution. Putin’s plan? To freeze and starve the Ukrainian population into submission, having failed to win on the battlefield.
When I visited Ukraine in September (see link below), the weather was still balmy and pleasant, yet many Ukrainians were dreading the months ahead. My friend Yana from the Heart Institute, whom I met on the train to Kyiv together with her nine-year-old daughter Eva, texted me last week that the city had just endured a 13-hour power cut. With generators scarce and expensive, she may have to move in with relatives in the west of the country, who at least have a wood stove. The soldiers defending their loved ones face the same cold, in trenches and dugouts, with not even a wood stove to retreat to.
And yet, this is precisely the moment U.S. special envoy Steve Witkoff has chosen to lavish praise on Vladimir Putin as a true “humanitarian,” and to blame Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky for the continuation of the war. It is a revolting strain of Newspeak that would leave even George Orwell gasping.
If the most powerful country on the planet betrays the Ukrainians and wants to force them to surrender, it is up to the rest of us to step up. If you want to be a humanitarian in the true sense of the word, here is a concrete way to keep Ukrainians warm. ❤️
🔌 The Diel Foundation is launching a winter campaign to help the Ukrainian army survive the winter. Our goal is to fund:
1,000 generators
1,000 portable power stations
1,000 diesel heaters
Together, they will keep soldiers warm, and also keep them alive, by powering life-saving drones, laptops and communication equipment. 🛡️
Last year, the Diel Foundation raised over €1,000,000 for Ukraine. Will you help us top that? 🙏
I chipped in €250 to kick things off! 💙💛
👉 whydonate.com/nl/fundraising/keeping-ukraine-warm
If you want to know more about this brave nation fighting for its survival, and for our own civilization, see the essay I wrote about my trip for @Quillette :
📖 quillette.substack.com/p/an-army-of-yesterdays-civilians-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Enkele weken geleden zag ik een uitvoering van Charles Gounods opera Faust, in een schitterend klassiek theater dat overal in Europa had kunnen staan. Alleen volgde ik het libretto stiekem op mijn telefoon, want het gezongen Frans was nauwelijks te verstaan en de boventiteling was alleen in het Oekraïens. Ik was in de Nationale Opera van Lviv, een prachtige stad vol pastelkleurige architectuur in het westen van Oekraïne.
Zonder het ontroerende volkslied vóór de ouverture, waarbij iedereen met de hand op de borst opstond, had je niet kunnen raden dat dit land in het vijfde jaar van een uitputtingsoorlog zit. Had de voorstelling een paar uur later plaatsgevonden, dan was ze onderbroken door een luchtalarm en hadden we de schuilkelder in gemoeten. Maar wij hadden geluk en konden genieten van drieënhalf uur ongestoord escapisme, tot de finale, waarin Fausts geliefde Marguerite sterft en ten hemel stijgt, terwijl hij zelf vol afgrijzen op de knieën zinkt.
Ook zonder luchtalarm was de oorlog nooit ver weg. In de opera trekt Marguerites broer naar het front, samen met zijn vriend Wagner – naamgenoot van Poetins huurlingenleger – en de duivel voorspelt dat beiden zullen sterven. Dan is er de hartstochtelijke uitbarsting van de stokoude Faust zelf, vroeg in de opera, waarin hij jaloers smacht naar de geneugten van de jonge jaren: ‘Ik wil jeugd! Geef mij genoegens, jonge minnaressen! Geef mij de kracht van machtige driften, de wilde orgieën van hart en zinnen! Gloeiende jeugd, ik wil je verlangens, je vervoering, je genot!’
Mefistofeles gunt hem de zalige zorgeloosheid van een tweede jeugd voor de bescheiden prijs van zijn ziel – een verleidelijk aanbod. De Faust in het Kremlin sloot een veel diabolischer pact: hij verpatste de eerste en enige jeugd van honderdduizenden jonge mannen – en in ruil waarvoor? De oude KGB-officier wordt 74, zijn gezondheid sukkelt en de tijd dringt. Smachten doet hij vooral naar persoonlijke roem, of wat daarvoor doorgaat in zijn koortsige verbeelding: de mystieke band met het Oekraïense volk herstellen, het machtige Russische rijk doen herrijzen, van Moskou een ‘Derde Rome’ maken dat de christelijke beschaving redt.
Het was Joris Luyendijk, onvermoeibaar pleitbezorger van de Oekraïense zaak, die me uitnodigde om met Protect Ukraine mee te reizen naar Lviv. Ik aarzelde aanvankelijk, want ik wilde niet de rampentoerist uithangen, of oorlog romantiseren, of doodvermoeide Oekraïners afleiden van hun existentiële strijd om het voortbestaan van hun land en cultuur. Het voelde ongepast om als West-Europeaan naar een actief oorlogsgebied te reizen, om na een paar dagen weer naar mijn behaaglijke, zorgeloze leven terug te keren. Maar Joris verzekerde me dat Oekraïners bezoek uit Europa enorm waarderen. Die dankbaarheid vond ik even onwaarschijnlijk als onverdiend, maar hij kreeg gelijk.
We bezochten een dronelab in een troosteloze Sovjetflat, waar twee grijnzende techneuten vertelden over hun wapenwedloop met Russische ingenieurs, met wie ze tot februari 2022 nog samenwerkten in een IT-bedrijf. In een opleidingscentrum voor rekruten zagen we grondrobots waarmee gewonde soldaten in veiligheid worden gebracht. (De Russen hebben die niet: ze laten hun kanonnenvlees liever op het slagveld liggen.) Een traumatherapeute legde uit hoe ze soldaten met posttraumatische stress behandelt, en kreeg een krop in de keel toen ze over haar eerste patiënt vertelde. (Ook traumatherapeuten hebben zelf een therapeut.) De directrice van het Oekraïense cultuurinstituut INDEX, Sasha Dovzhyk, nam ons mee naar het militaire kerkhof Veld van Mars, waar ze ons de graven toonde van jonge schrijvers en kunstenaars.
Na afloop van het programma met Protect Ukraine reisde ik op eigen houtje door naar Kyiv. Daar ontmoette ik Issac Luna, een Amerikaanse oud-marinier die zijn succesvolle carrière als consultant in Texas inruilde voor het Oekraïense front en daarover de aangrijpende memoires Reckoning Dreams and Fire schreef. Ik sprak er ook met een projectmanager van het Heart Institute, waar chirurgen na de invasie hun operatiekamer naar de schuilkelder verhuisden. Een Oekraïense vriendin vertelde me over de gewenning na jaren van onophoudelijke luchtalarmen en over het fatalisme en de doodsverachting die veel Oekraïners ervaren. Aan de Kyiv School of Economics gaf ik een voordracht over complottheorieën voor studenten (minstens 80 procent meisjes, om voor de hand liggende redenen), waarna ik een bezoek bracht aan Boetsja, zelf het brandpunt van enkele van de bizarste Russische complottheorieën.
Eén vraag bleef door mijn hoofd spoken: als mijn land morgen werd binnengevallen door het op één na sterkste leger ter wereld, zou ik dan bereid zijn mijn bestaan als schrijver op te geven en de wapens op te nemen? Of me aan te sluiten bij het verzet in bezet gebied? En u, beste lezer?
De meesten van ons geloven graag dat we de moed zouden bijeenrapen, mits gezond en van strijdbare leeftijd. Maar hoe je reageert als puntje bij paaltje komt, is lastig te voorspellen. Sasha Dovzhyk vertelde over wetenschappers, intellectuelen en kunstenaars die in februari 2022 tot de conclusie kwamen dat het zwaard soms toch machtiger is dan de pen. Een novice die zich voorbereidde op het priesterschap moest zijn kloosterorde toestemming vragen om Russen te doden.
De Oekraïense schrijver Artem Chapeye worstelt met die vraag in zijn korte maar krachtige boek Ordinary People Don’t Carry Machine Guns. Als levenslang pacifist – hij vertaalde zelfs Gandhi naar het Oekraïens – ontdekte hij op 24 februari 2022 dat de luxe van onbeproefde overtuigingen niet langer voor hem was weggelegd. ‘Abstract pacifisme is het privilege van mensen die niet voor een existentiële keuze staan en zich kunnen veroorloven te theoretiseren.’ Binnen enkele dagen stond hij in de rij bij een rekruteringscentrum. Toch is hij eerlijk genoeg om te beseffen dat zijn keuze niet in de sterren stond geschreven. Als hij op de dag van de grootschalige invasie toevallig in het buitenland was geweest, geeft hij toe, was hij waarschijnlijk niet teruggekeerd om de wapens op te nemen.
Als ik Oekraïners hoor spreken over hun onbevangen en vurige verlangen om vrij te zijn, om bij Europa en het Westen te horen, voel ik al snel enige schaamte voor alle verwende aanstellerij van de rest van ons, die vrede en veiligheid als vanzelfsprekend beschouwen. Ik hoop nooit voor het dilemma te komen dat Oekraïners in februari 2022 trof, maar mijn eigen overtuigingen over weerbaarheid, net als die van de meeste Europeanen, zijn nooit aan een vuurproef onderworpen.
De Oekraïners vragen ons niet eens om naast hen te komen vechten. Op enkele duizenden buitenlandse vrijwilligers na, zoals de oud-marinier Issac Luna, neemt niemand buiten Oekraïne spontaan de wapens op tegen de Russen. Het minste wat de rest van ons kan doen, is hen blijven steunen: financieel, militair en moreel. Als we dit dappere volk niet bijstaan, terwijl het vecht om bij onze beschaving te mogen horen, wat is dan het punt van zo’n beschaving?
Hier het volledige reisverslag voor @Quillette, in het Engels:
substacktools.com/sharex/roDtjbS0 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een leger van ‘burgers van gisteren’: Oekraïne en de strijd voor vrijheid (met fotoverslag) maartenboudry.be/2026/10/een-leger-van-burgers-van-gister…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Pretty shocking: the Berlin chief of the "Left Party", secretly admits to being terrified of the Hamas/PFLP goons among her support base.
Everyone who still insists that “islamogauchisme” is nothing but a far-right fever dream, on a par with the Nazi fantasy of Judeo-Bolshevism, is now part of the problem. If you refuse to see it, you're probably part of it.
This includes, unfortunately, virtually all of academia, including the 600 academics who signed that moronic letter in @lemondefr dismissing islamogauchism as a mere “conspiracy theory”.
In fact, there is now overwhelming evidence of a dangerous Red-Green alliance across the West, even if the degree of coordination and awareness varies considerably.
“Progressives” are betraying everything they once stood for to appease and mollify people who despise them—and exploit them purely for their own purposes.
Andrew Hammel
@AndrewHammel1
Elif Eralp, the Berlin chief of the "Left Party", which just came in first in the Berlin elections with 25% of the vote, accidentally sent an email to the German magazine "Der Spiegel" in which she consulted with her advisors.
In that email, she admitted that she was "afraid" of Ibrahim Ibrahim and his supporters. Ibrahim is a notorious supporter of Hamas and the PFLP. He and his supporters had supported the Left Party and Ibrahim appeared at the Left Party victory party in Berlin.
Eralp said she and her husband had been advised by local law enforcement to avoid critical commentary about organized crime groups and radical pro-Palestine factions in Berlin. These groups are a key part of the pro-Left-Party faction in Berlin.
Nobody was supposed to see these comments, but Eralp or someone on her team accidentally sent them to a journalist.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Voor de sport heb ik deze reactie op Dries Lesage nog eens als lezersbrief naar @destandaard gestuurd (zonder de sneer naar de media natuurlijk, maar puur op de inhoud, anders is het sowieso kansloos). Hier 50K keer bekeken, bij @destandaard geen enkele reactie.
Ook heb ik onlangs bij de redactie aangeboden om een stuk te schrijven over de rellen in Frankrijk, als reactie op Hendrik — ‘Het is de schuld van Marine Le Pen!’ — Vos. Opnieuw: geen enkele reactie.
In de plaats daarvan drukt De Standaard vandaag de elfendertigste tirade tegen Israël af. (Nog meer boycots graag! Zelfs als Netanyahu weg is! We gaan nog niet ver genoeg!) Voor wie publiceren ze dit in godsnaam nog? Wat voor maatschappelijk ‘debat’ is dit? Er komt toch nooit een tegengeluid in deze echokamer. Het zijn elke dag variaties op hetzelfde refrein: Israël = slecht, Amerika = slecht, neoliberalisme = slecht.
Zelfs bij @demorgen of @NRC lees je af en toe nog een tegengeluid, maar nergens is het zo erg als bij @destandaard (behalve bij hun columnisten, daar valt het nog mee). Wie in Vlaanderen nog een echt tegensprekelijk debat wil, is steeds meer aangewezen op sociale media.
Resultaat:
‘De Standaard ziet zijn bereik fors dalen met vijf procent.’
Moge hun marktaandeel nog verder wegzakken, wat mij betreft. (Mijn abonnement heb ik al lang opgezegd.) Jammer voor de goede journalisten die er werken, @dskarel, maar het is echt ondraaglijk geworden.
www.demorgen.be/nieuws/de-morgen-blijft-groeien-en-bereik…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit krijg je dus als je nooit meer tegenstemmen toelaat in de echokamer van media en academia over Israël: een aaneenschakeling van leugens en geschiedvervalsing, opgetekend door @DriesLesage. Met als toppunt:
"De Israëlische annexatie en kolonisatie sinds 1967 zijn even misdadig als de Russische bezetting in Oekraïne."
Oekraïne is al decennialang een soevereine, internationaal erkende staat, bovendien beschermd door het Boedapestmemorandum. Een Palestijnse staat bestaat echter niet en heeft nooit bestaan, omdat Palestijnse leiders elk voorstel tot de oprichting ervan hebben afgewezen: van de Peelcommissie in 1937 en het VN-partitieplan in 1947 tot de vredesvoorstellen van 2000 en 2008.
Het doel van de Arabische landen was altijd de vernietiging van de ene Joodse staat in het Midden-Oosten, niet de oprichting van een onafhankelijke Palestijnse staat. Toen Egypte en Jordanië na hun vernietigingsoorlog tegen Israël respectievelijk de betwiste gebieden in de regio (Gaza, Oost-Jeruzalem en de West Bank) bezetten, kraaide daar geen haan naar. Want dat was bezetting door andere Arabieren, niet door de verfoeide Joden.
Bovendien heeft Israël zich in 2005 vrijwillig en eenzijdig uit Gaza teruggetrokken en de Palestijnen de kans gegeven er zelf iets van te maken. Ze hebben zelfs hun eigen Israëlische burgers hardhandig verwijderd. Het exacte tegendeel dus van "landroof".
Het resultaat? Twintig jaar terreurbewind door Hamas, miljarden geïnvesteerd in de uitbouw van een militair tunnelnetwerk met menselijke schilden, en de voorbereiding van de slachtpartij van 7 oktober.
Is het een wonder dat de Israëli's niet langer een Palestijnse staat willen? Het zou gewoon suïcidaal zijn. De Palestijnen hebben zelf hun kansen op een staat verkwanseld, door hun starre eliminationisme en hun onophoudelijke terreur.
Het is werkelijk ongelofelijk dat deze man hoogleraar internationale politiek is. Maar hij is helaas niet de enige: hele universiteiten worden nu bevolkt door zulke types.
www.standaard.be/opinies/de-parallelle-werkelijkheid-van-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
w̸͕͂͂a̷͔̗͐t̴̙͗e̵̬̔̕r̴̰̓̊m̵͙͖̓̽a̵̢̗̓͒r̸̲̽ķ̷͔́͝
@anthrupad
Mythos talks about reading Finnegans Wake in a way that reveals how chadded to the max their brain is
“every pun resolves for me simultaneously” -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Enkele weken geleden zag ik een uitvoering van Charles Gounods opera Faust, in een schitterend klassiek theater dat overal in Europa had kunnen staan. Alleen volgde ik het libretto stiekem op mijn telefoon, want het gezongen Frans was nauwelijks te verstaan en de boventiteling was alleen in het Oekraïens. Ik was in de Nationale Opera van Lviv, een prachtige stad vol pastelkleurige architectuur in het westen van Oekraïne.
Zonder het ontroerende volkslied vóór de ouverture, waarbij iedereen met de hand op de borst opstond, had je niet kunnen raden dat dit land in het vijfde jaar van een uitputtingsoorlog zit. Had de voorstelling een paar uur later plaatsgevonden, dan was ze onderbroken door een luchtalarm en hadden we de schuilkelder in gemoeten. Maar wij hadden geluk en konden genieten van drieënhalf uur ongestoord escapisme, tot de finale, waarin Fausts geliefde Marguerite sterft en ten hemel stijgt, terwijl hij zelf vol afgrijzen op de knieën zinkt.
Ook zonder luchtalarm was de oorlog nooit ver weg. In de opera trekt Marguerites broer naar het front, samen met zijn vriend Wagner – naamgenoot van Poetins huurlingenleger – en de duivel voorspelt dat beiden zullen sterven. Dan is er de hartstochtelijke uitbarsting van de stokoude Faust zelf, vroeg in de opera, waarin hij jaloers smacht naar de geneugten van de jonge jaren: ‘Ik wil jeugd! Geef mij genoegens, jonge minnaressen! Geef mij de kracht van machtige driften, de wilde orgieën van hart en zinnen! Gloeiende jeugd, ik wil je verlangens, je vervoering, je genot!’
Mefistofeles gunt hem de zalige zorgeloosheid van een tweede jeugd voor de bescheiden prijs van zijn ziel – een verleidelijk aanbod. De Faust in het Kremlin sloot een veel diabolischer pact: hij verpatste de eerste en enige jeugd van honderdduizenden jonge mannen – en in ruil waarvoor? De oude KGB-officier wordt 74, zijn gezondheid sukkelt en de tijd dringt. Smachten doet hij vooral naar persoonlijke roem, of wat daarvoor doorgaat in zijn koortsige verbeelding: de mystieke band met het Oekraïense volk herstellen, het machtige Russische rijk doen herrijzen, van Moskou een ‘Derde Rome’ maken dat de christelijke beschaving redt.
Het was Joris Luyendijk, onvermoeibaar pleitbezorger van de Oekraïense zaak, die me uitnodigde om met Protect Ukraine mee te reizen naar Lviv. Ik aarzelde aanvankelijk, want ik wilde niet de rampentoerist uithangen, of oorlog romantiseren, of doodvermoeide Oekraïners afleiden van hun existentiële strijd om het voortbestaan van hun land en cultuur. Het voelde ongepast om als West-Europeaan naar een actief oorlogsgebied te reizen, om na een paar dagen weer naar mijn behaaglijke, zorgeloze leven terug te keren. Maar Joris verzekerde me dat Oekraïners bezoek uit Europa enorm waarderen. Die dankbaarheid vond ik even onwaarschijnlijk als onverdiend, maar hij kreeg gelijk.
We bezochten een dronelab in een troosteloze Sovjetflat, waar twee grijnzende techneuten vertelden over hun wapenwedloop met Russische ingenieurs, met wie ze tot februari 2022 nog samenwerkten in een IT-bedrijf. In een opleidingscentrum voor rekruten zagen we grondrobots waarmee gewonde soldaten in veiligheid worden gebracht. (De Russen hebben die niet: ze laten hun kanonnenvlees liever op het slagveld liggen.) Een traumatherapeute legde uit hoe ze soldaten met posttraumatische stress behandelt, en kreeg een krop in de keel toen ze over haar eerste patiënt vertelde. (Ook traumatherapeuten hebben zelf een therapeut.) De directrice van het Oekraïense cultuurinstituut INDEX, Sasha Dovzhyk, nam ons mee naar het militaire kerkhof Veld van Mars, waar ze ons de graven toonde van jonge schrijvers en kunstenaars.
Na afloop van het programma met Protect Ukraine reisde ik op eigen houtje door naar Kyiv. Daar ontmoette ik Issac Luna, een Amerikaanse oud-marinier die zijn succesvolle carrière als consultant in Texas inruilde voor het Oekraïense front en daarover de aangrijpende memoires Reckoning Dreams and Fire schreef. Ik sprak er ook met een projectmanager van het Heart Institute, waar chirurgen na de invasie hun operatiekamer naar de schuilkelder verhuisden. Een Oekraïense vriendin vertelde me over de gewenning na jaren van onophoudelijke luchtalarmen en over het fatalisme en de doodsverachting die veel Oekraïners ervaren. Aan de Kyiv School of Economics gaf ik een voordracht over complottheorieën voor studenten (minstens 80 procent meisjes, om voor de hand liggende redenen), waarna ik een bezoek bracht aan Boetsja, zelf het brandpunt van enkele van de bizarste Russische complottheorieën.
Eén vraag bleef door mijn hoofd spoken: als mijn land morgen werd binnengevallen door het op één na sterkste leger ter wereld, zou ik dan bereid zijn mijn bestaan als schrijver op te geven en de wapens op te nemen? Of me aan te sluiten bij het verzet in bezet gebied? En u, beste lezer?
De meesten van ons geloven graag dat we de moed zouden bijeenrapen, mits gezond en van strijdbare leeftijd. Maar hoe je reageert als puntje bij paaltje komt, is lastig te voorspellen. Sasha Dovzhyk vertelde over wetenschappers, intellectuelen en kunstenaars die in februari 2022 tot de conclusie kwamen dat het zwaard soms toch machtiger is dan de pen. Een novice die zich voorbereidde op het priesterschap moest zijn kloosterorde toestemming vragen om Russen te doden.
De Oekraïense schrijver Artem Chapeye worstelt met die vraag in zijn korte maar krachtige boek Ordinary People Don’t Carry Machine Guns. Als levenslang pacifist – hij vertaalde zelfs Gandhi naar het Oekraïens – ontdekte hij op 24 februari 2022 dat de luxe van onbeproefde overtuigingen niet langer voor hem was weggelegd. ‘Abstract pacifisme is het privilege van mensen die niet voor een existentiële keuze staan en zich kunnen veroorloven te theoretiseren.’ Binnen enkele dagen stond hij in de rij bij een rekruteringscentrum. Toch is hij eerlijk genoeg om te beseffen dat zijn keuze niet in de sterren stond geschreven. Als hij op de dag van de grootschalige invasie toevallig in het buitenland was geweest, geeft hij toe, was hij waarschijnlijk niet teruggekeerd om de wapens op te nemen.
Als ik Oekraïners hoor spreken over hun onbevangen en vurige verlangen om vrij te zijn, om bij Europa en het Westen te horen, voel ik al snel enige schaamte voor alle verwende aanstellerij van de rest van ons, die vrede en veiligheid als vanzelfsprekend beschouwen. Ik hoop nooit voor het dilemma te komen dat Oekraïners in februari 2022 trof, maar mijn eigen overtuigingen over weerbaarheid, net als die van de meeste Europeanen, zijn nooit aan een vuurproef onderworpen.
De Oekraïners vragen ons niet eens om naast hen te komen vechten. Op enkele duizenden buitenlandse vrijwilligers na, zoals de oud-marinier Issac Luna, neemt niemand buiten Oekraïne spontaan de wapens op tegen de Russen. Het minste wat de rest van ons kan doen, is hen blijven steunen: financieel, militair en moreel. Als we dit dappere volk niet bijstaan, terwijl het vecht om bij onze beschaving te mogen horen, wat is dan het punt van zo’n beschaving?
Hier het volledige reisverslag voor @Quillette, in het Engels:
substacktools.com/sharex/roDtjbS0
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hier met meer foto's: maartenboudry.be/2026/10/een-leger-van-burgers-van-gister…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een leger van ‘burgers van gisteren’: Oekraïne en de strijd voor vrijheid (met fotoverslag) maartenboudry.be/2026/10/een-leger-van-burgers-van-gister…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nog eentje uit die reeks, voor meer dan de helft door AI geschreven. Ach, je kan zeggen dat het nog meevalt, sommige columns van @vanranstmarc zijn tenslotte 100% AI. Maar voor een "schrijfwedstrijd" zou je toch verwachten dat er elementaire regels zijn over AI-gebruik, @dskarel? En dat dat even wordt getoetst?
Over de betrouwbaarheid van Pangram, zie VUB-studie: link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40979-026-00226-w
/3
www.pangram.com/history/08cc7f74-15d6-4154-9dc3-001334455… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Bij @destandaard besteden ze hun dagelijkse tirades tegen neoliberalisme nu uit aan "jong talent": een amper vier jaar oude chatbot.😉 Echt een kolfje naar de hand van ChatGPT, zo'n perfect voorspelbare en voorgekauwde slop over "de SchUld vAN nEoLIbeRalisMe". Move over, Paul Verhaeghe! www.pangram.com/history/8a2c55bd-673c-475a-a57b-15c0ac9b3…
Thomas Spaas
@thomas_spaas
Deze warboel van een column verdient het integraal gepost te worden.
Contradicties, vaagheden, taalfouten... Lees en huiver. Als dat tegenwoordig universitair niveau is, zijn we er nog slechter aan toe dan we dachten.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wat een jonge "talenten" daar bij @destandaard. 😅 Hier nog eentje uit de talentenjacht "De mening 2026'. www.pangram.com/history/39b407f6-af5c-456e-8ef5-549f09dac…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nog eentje uit die reeks, voor meer dan de helft door AI geschreven. Ach, je kan zeggen dat het nog meevalt, sommige columns van @vanranstmarc zijn tenslotte 100% AI. Maar voor een "schrijfwedstrijd" zou je toch verwachten dat er elementaire regels zijn over AI-gebruik, @dskarel? En dat dat even wordt getoetst?
Over de betrouwbaarheid van Pangram, zie VUB-studie: link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40979-026-00226-w
/3
www.pangram.com/history/08cc7f74-15d6-4154-9dc3-001334455… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Koert Debeuef (@koertdebeuf) is iemand die tien jaar geleden nog suste dat de moslimbroeders gewoon een soort "moslim republikeinen" waren, geheel en al democratisch en zeker geen religieuze fundamentalisten:
"De leidinggevende figuren van het Moslimbroederschap in Tunesië of Egypte die ik sprak, gaven me allemaal dezelfde boodschap: hun objectief in de politiek is de economie herstellen en de corruptie aanpakken. Ik heb daarbij niet één van hen zelfs maar de woorden ‘islam’ of ‘moslim’ in de mond horen nemen."
Hoe onvoorstelbaar blind moet je zijn om zoiets te schrijven? Bedenk dat de organisatie in talloze moslimlanden verboden is als terreurgroep, dat ze werd opgericht en gevormd door totalitaire fanatici als Hassan al-Banna en Sayyid Qutb, en dat Hamas ontstond uit de Egyptische tak van de moslimbroederschap.
In 2016 zei Debeuf ook dat er in Canada geen terreuraanslagen gepleegd worden "omdat zij staan voor openheid en multiculturalisme". Inmiddels is er een hele resem jihadi-terreuraanslagen in Canada.
Debeuf is geen idioot, hij heeft veel kennis over het Midden-Oosten. Je zag zelfs zelfs dat die kennis hem "in de weg zat" in @deafspraaktv: hij wist dat Jonath gelijk had op bepaalde punten, maar kon het niet over zijn lippen krijgen.
De enige overblijvende conclusie: Debeuf is een zuivere ideoloog die de islam in bescherming wil nemen en dus anti-Israël moet zijn.
@DoornaertMia
Thomas Rotthier
@ThomasRotthier
Dit vind ik nogal goedkoop, @DoornaertMia. Waarom zijn Koert Debeuf (prof. internationale politiek) en Meinie Nicolai (oud-AZG) 'ideologisch'?
Jonath Weinberger is een uitgesproken zioniste en verdedigster van Israëls oorlogspolitiek. Is dat dan niet ideologisch?
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Over @bsoenensvrt spreken we zelfs niet. Dat die man daar een knettergekke complottheorie verkondigde die het equivalent is van 9/11 Truthers ("Bush liet het doelbewust gebeuren om een excuus te hebben om Irak binnen te vallen!") is werkelijk ongehoord. De VRT liet het gewoon passeren, er kwam geen enkele kritische vraag. Ah ja, want het was anti-Israël.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Helemaal eens met @siegfriedbracke. In @deafspraak zag je vanavond één gewone Israëlische vrouw (de moedige @JonathW66041) die met enkele welgemikte zinnen (de enige die ze kon afmaken) de drie zogenaamde ‘experts’ omverblaast.
Zij hadden geen enkel zinnig antwoord op haar eenvoudige vragen over wat Israël dan wél had moeten doen na 7 oktober, en waarom hun mantra van een "tweestatenoplossing" na 7 oktober zou neerkomen op national suïcide.
Nog geen minuut ver in de uitzending had de gastvrouw het al over ‘genocidaal geweld’, waarmee de toon van vooringenomenheid meteen gezet was. De VRT koos daarmee meteen partij, en de hele uitzending bleef het vier tegen één.
Het gênantst van al was het optreden van het VRT-goudhaantje @bsoenensvrt, die idiote complottheorieën over 7 oktober lanceerde (alsof Netanyahu het ‘doelbewust’ had laten gebeuren) en maar wat stotterde over ‘de Nakba’ en Israëls vermeende ‘intentie’ om de hele Palestijnse bevolking uit te roeien — ondanks evacuaties, waarschuwingen voor militaire aanvallen, voedselhulp en poliovaccinaties.
Siegfried Bracke
@siegfriedbracke
De aflevering van @deafspraaktv van vandaag is echt de moeite waard: zelden zoveel onkunde en vooringenomenheid gezien. En nog opvallend: die ene joodse mevrouw heeft argumenten waarop de ‘experts’ geen zinnig weerwoord konden formuleren. Om te gieren als het niet zo treurig was.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Talia Yoseph
@taliaortati
Apparently 6 seconds is a long time for some men #fyp
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Pretty shocking: the Berlin chief of the "Left Party", secretly admits to being terrified of the Hamas/PFLP goons among her support base.
Everyone who still insists that “islamogauchisme” is nothing but a far-right fever dream, on a par with the Nazi fantasy of Judeo-Bolshevism, is now part of the problem. If you refuse to see it, you're probably part of it.
This includes, unfortunately, virtually all of academia, including the 600 academics who signed that moronic letter in @lemondefr dismissing islamogauchism as a mere “conspiracy theory”.
In fact, there is now overwhelming evidence of a dangerous Red-Green alliance across the West, even if the degree of coordination and awareness varies considerably.
“Progressives” are betraying everything they once stood for to appease and mollify people who despise them—and exploit them purely for their own purposes.
Andrew Hammel
@AndrewHammel1
Elif Eralp, the Berlin chief of the "Left Party", which just came in first in the Berlin elections with 25% of the vote, accidentally sent an email to the German magazine "Der Spiegel" in which she consulted with her advisors.
In that email, she admitted that she was "afraid" of Ibrahim Ibrahim and his supporters. Ibrahim is a notorious supporter of Hamas and the PFLP. He and his supporters had supported the Left Party and Ibrahim appeared at the Left Party victory party in Berlin.
Eralp said she and her husband had been advised by local law enforcement to avoid critical commentary about organized crime groups and radical pro-Palestine factions in Berlin. These groups are a key part of the pro-Left-Party faction in Berlin.
Nobody was supposed to see these comments, but Eralp or someone on her team accidentally sent them to a journalist.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
John Aziz
@aziz0nomics
One of the most insane videos I've seen.
American-Jewish comedian who describes himself as pro-Palestine is attacked at his show by a woman who believes all Jews are evil.
This antisemitic garbage has become totally normalised. Social media brain rot!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Tomas Pueyo
@tomaspueyo
This crazy article shows a hidden aspect of Islamo-Leftism: how, at some point, Leftist politicians are just too scared of Islamists and bow to them
DER SPIEGEL
@derspiegel
Elif Eralp möchte Regierende Bürgermeisterin Berlins werden. Doch in einem internen Vermerk zeigt die Linkenpolitikerin, dass sie sich vor Terrorsympathisanten mit Kontakten zur Hamas fürchtet. Kann so jemand für die Sicherheit in der Hauptstadt verantwortlich… Link in X-Bio.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Bart Nijman
@BartNijman
Onderstaande tweet van Boudry komt uit de heup, het hier gelinkte artikel bevat zijn academische onderbouwingen:
Islamo-Leftism Is Not a Conspiracy Theory maartenboudry.substack.com/p/islamo-leftism-is-not-a-cons…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
We will all soon know what it feels like to be Jewish. In France, they already do.
It will be our just deserts for having abandoned the Jews, ignored their warnings, turned against them, and even marched alongside their oppressors.
For three years, you useful idiots have been parading Palestinian flags, sporting keffiyehs, screaming “From the River to the Sea”, and recognizing a fictitious Palestinian state as a reward for Hamas’s October 7 massacre (looking at you, @EmmanuelMacron). You have boycotted the only Jewish state in the world, vilified the Jewish people’s right to self-determination (aka “Zionism”), and spread the “Gaza genocide” blood libel.
Did you really think that if you fed the crocodile enough Jewish flesh, it would eventually be satiated? All you have done is embolden the monster and whet its appetite.
So you were worried about “colonization”? Look around. The only thing being colonized here are our own Western cities. The Palestinian flag has become a victory banner, proudly waved amid the ruins of looted and vandalized historic buildings—a symbol of hatred for our civilization and everything it stands for.
It never ends with the Jews. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
If you don't believe me that the Palestinian flag has become the rallying banner for every enemy of the West, listen to the French poseur Jean Genet, who waxed lyrical about the beauty of SS uniforms, the Black Panthers, and Palestinian fedayeen. In 1974, he explained his love for the Palestinians thusly:
“Why the Palestinians? It was perfectly natural that I should be attracted not only to the most disadvantaged people but also to the one that most fully crystallizes hatred of the West.”
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Voor de sport heb ik deze reactie op Dries Lesage nog eens als lezersbrief naar @destandaard gestuurd (zonder de sneer naar de media natuurlijk, maar puur op de inhoud, anders is het sowieso kansloos). Hier 50K keer bekeken, bij @destandaard geen enkele reactie.
Ook heb ik onlangs bij de redactie aangeboden om een stuk te schrijven over de rellen in Frankrijk, als reactie op Hendrik — ‘Het is de schuld van Marine Le Pen!’ — Vos. Opnieuw: geen enkele reactie.
In de plaats daarvan drukt De Standaard vandaag de elfendertigste tirade tegen Israël af. (Nog meer boycots graag! Zelfs als Netanyahu weg is! We gaan nog niet ver genoeg!) Voor wie publiceren ze dit in godsnaam nog? Wat voor maatschappelijk ‘debat’ is dit? Er komt toch nooit een tegengeluid in deze echokamer. Het zijn elke dag variaties op hetzelfde refrein: Israël = slecht, Amerika = slecht, neoliberalisme = slecht.
Zelfs bij @demorgen of @NRC lees je af en toe nog een tegengeluid, maar nergens is het zo erg als bij @destandaard (behalve bij hun columnisten, daar valt het nog mee). Wie in Vlaanderen nog een echt tegensprekelijk debat wil, is steeds meer aangewezen op sociale media.
Resultaat:
‘De Standaard ziet zijn bereik fors dalen met vijf procent.’
Moge hun marktaandeel nog verder wegzakken, wat mij betreft. (Mijn abonnement heb ik al lang opgezegd.) Jammer voor de goede journalisten die er werken, @dskarel, maar het is echt ondraaglijk geworden.
www.demorgen.be/nieuws/de-morgen-blijft-groeien-en-bereik…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit krijg je dus als je nooit meer tegenstemmen toelaat in de echokamer van media en academia over Israël: een aaneenschakeling van leugens en geschiedvervalsing, opgetekend door @DriesLesage. Met als toppunt:
"De Israëlische annexatie en kolonisatie sinds 1967 zijn even misdadig als de Russische bezetting in Oekraïne."
Oekraïne is al decennialang een soevereine, internationaal erkende staat, bovendien beschermd door het Boedapestmemorandum. Een Palestijnse staat bestaat echter niet en heeft nooit bestaan, omdat Palestijnse leiders elk voorstel tot de oprichting ervan hebben afgewezen: van de Peelcommissie in 1937 en het VN-partitieplan in 1947 tot de vredesvoorstellen van 2000 en 2008.
Het doel van de Arabische landen was altijd de vernietiging van de ene Joodse staat in het Midden-Oosten, niet de oprichting van een onafhankelijke Palestijnse staat. Toen Egypte en Jordanië na hun vernietigingsoorlog tegen Israël respectievelijk de betwiste gebieden in de regio (Gaza, Oost-Jeruzalem en de West Bank) bezetten, kraaide daar geen haan naar. Want dat was bezetting door andere Arabieren, niet door de verfoeide Joden.
Bovendien heeft Israël zich in 2005 vrijwillig en eenzijdig uit Gaza teruggetrokken en de Palestijnen de kans gegeven er zelf iets van te maken. Ze hebben zelfs hun eigen Israëlische burgers hardhandig verwijderd. Het exacte tegendeel dus van "landroof".
Het resultaat? Twintig jaar terreurbewind door Hamas, miljarden geïnvesteerd in de uitbouw van een militair tunnelnetwerk met menselijke schilden, en de voorbereiding van de slachtpartij van 7 oktober.
Is het een wonder dat de Israëli's niet langer een Palestijnse staat willen? Het zou gewoon suïcidaal zijn. De Palestijnen hebben zelf hun kansen op een staat verkwanseld, door hun starre eliminationisme en hun onophoudelijke terreur.
Het is werkelijk ongelofelijk dat deze man hoogleraar internationale politiek is. Maar hij is helaas niet de enige: hele universiteiten worden nu bevolkt door zulke types.
www.standaard.be/opinies/de-parallelle-werkelijkheid-van-… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Uiteraard vindt @DriesLesage papers in toptijdschriften "compleet achterhaald". Want zonder die lastige criteria van internationale excellentie kunnen we mensen aanwerven op basis van hun ideologische gezindte: iedereen links, iedereen anti-zionistisch, anti-imperialistisch en antikoloniaal. Kan de geloofwaardigheid van onze universiteiten alleen maar ten goede komen! 👍
Het resultaat? Een echokamer vol ideologische prietpraat, zoals Lesage in @destandaard illustreerde. Nog los van het verwerpelijke idee om een orkestdirigent (!) omwille van zijn nationaliteit te onderwerpen aan een maoïstische struggle session en allerlei publieke stellingnames van hem te eisen.
x.com/mboudry/status/2115055356422308337
Dries Lesage
@DriesLesage
@wduyck heb je inhoudelijk iets te zeggen over mijn tekst en de Israëlische internationale misdaden? Neen dus. Ik heb de expertise, jij & Boudry niet. Jouw A1-fetisjisme is overigens compleet achterhaald. Hou jij je bezig met je brein. Of lees dit eerst: www.lannoo.com/nl-be/mens-maatschappij/conflict-en-samenw…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Islamogauchisme is geen complottheorie (plus videopodcast bij De Nieuwe Wereld over het verraad van links)
maartenboudry.be/2026/10/islamogauchisme-is-geen-complott…
via Postbro -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit krijg je dus als je nooit meer tegenstemmen toelaat in de echokamer van media en academia over Israël: een aaneenschakeling van leugens en geschiedvervalsing, opgetekend door @DriesLesage. Met als toppunt:
"De Israëlische annexatie en kolonisatie sinds 1967 zijn even misdadig als de Russische bezetting in Oekraïne."
Oekraïne is al decennialang een soevereine, internationaal erkende staat, bovendien beschermd door het Boedapestmemorandum. Een Palestijnse staat bestaat echter niet en heeft nooit bestaan, omdat Palestijnse leiders elk voorstel tot de oprichting ervan hebben afgewezen: van de Peelcommissie in 1937 en het VN-partitieplan in 1947 tot de vredesvoorstellen van 2000 en 2008.
Het doel van de Arabische landen was altijd de vernietiging van de ene Joodse staat in het Midden-Oosten, niet de oprichting van een onafhankelijke Palestijnse staat. Toen Egypte en Jordanië na hun vernietigingsoorlog tegen Israël respectievelijk de betwiste gebieden in de regio (Gaza, Oost-Jeruzalem en de West Bank) bezetten, kraaide daar geen haan naar. Want dat was bezetting door andere Arabieren, niet door de verfoeide Joden.
Bovendien heeft Israël zich in 2005 vrijwillig en eenzijdig uit Gaza teruggetrokken en de Palestijnen de kans gegeven er zelf iets van te maken. Ze hebben zelfs hun eigen Israëlische burgers hardhandig verwijderd. Het exacte tegendeel dus van "landroof".
Het resultaat? Twintig jaar terreurbewind door Hamas, miljarden geïnvesteerd in de uitbouw van een militair tunnelnetwerk met menselijke schilden, en de voorbereiding van de slachtpartij van 7 oktober.
Is het een wonder dat de Israëli's niet langer een Palestijnse staat willen? Het zou gewoon suïcidaal zijn. De Palestijnen hebben zelf hun kansen op een staat verkwanseld, door hun starre eliminationisme en hun onophoudelijke terreur.
Het is werkelijk ongelofelijk dat deze man hoogleraar internationale politiek is. Maar hij is helaas niet de enige: hele universiteiten worden nu bevolkt door zulke types.
www.standaard.be/opinies/de-parallelle-werkelijkheid-van-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Aizenberg
@Aizenberg55
Israel’s elections, where Arab citizens vote equally alongside Jews and all other Israelis, demolish the simplistic, fraudulent “apartheid” narrative. So the goalposts move: Why can’t Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank vote in Israeli elections? Apartheid!
Suddenly, Palestinians don’t want sovereignty or statehood anymore. Recognition of Palestine by the UK, France and dozens of other countries? Irrelevant. Palestine’s UN status? Irrelevant. The Palestinian Authority, President Abbas, Palestinian elections? Scrap them all!
What Palestinians REALLY want, apparently, is to be Israelis, governed by Israeli law and voting in Israeli elections. Forget Palestinian self-determination! At least for today.
It’s always the same. Whichever argument serves the immediate need to condemn Israel wins the day, no matter how contradictory or intellectually bankrupt. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Fania Oz-Salzberger 🇮🇱🕊️🟣 פניה עוז-זלצברגר
@faniaoz
Note that the genocide/apartheid crowd is rather quiet about the Israeli election drama.
For them, we are all genociders; so what’s all the political fuss about?
It’s also awkward that the Arab parties did exceptionally well and hold the key to coalition formation. Weird apartheid.
Disclaimer: racism still exists, of course. And the calamitous Gaza war was not the major election issue It should be. Israel is very far from perfect. But perhaps some things are finally moving in a better direction. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Voor de duidelijkheid: Prof. Wouter Duyck (@wduyck) heeft het over Prof. @DriesLesage, beiden @UGent. Ik heb Lesages CV niet bekeken, maar als dit klopt, rijst inderdaad de vraag: hoe kan je met zo'n flinterdun dossier in hemelsnaam professor worden? (Ik heb 6 keer zoveel A1-publicaties). En dan zulke agitprop-stukken vol historische onzin schrijven.
Wouter Duyck
@wduyck
Telkens je zo’n geval tegenkomt even academisch CV checken. Het resultaat is ALTIJD bingo. 8 A1 publicaties. In een vakdomein *internationale* politiek. Bij ons geraak je daarmee niet aan een post-doc. Laatste publicatie in 2020 (!). En dan schrijf je zo’n
opiniestukken -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Tomas Pueyo
@tomaspueyo
This person is challenged, so let’s help him understand, so others avoid the same pitfall
As we do that, you’ll see how this graph is much worse than it looks at first sight in 2 ways
When we talk about crime and immigration, the underlying question is:
Who should we let in?
A person that commits 20x more crime than the average native is very bad. Don’t get these people in.
Now, if you only have 10 of them, are they yet a national threat? No, they’re not.
Can they become one?
Surely, if you only let in people like them.
So by talking about the per capita, you’re raising the alarm.
Another way to say the same thing: if a woman finds herself alone at night in the subway, and she can choose between one wagon with a native and one with an afghan asylum seeker, which one should she choose? By far, she will be safer with the native.
Does it mean the majority of rapes are committed by Afghans? No! There are too few. Thankfully! If there were as many as natives, the rape rate would be 10-20x higher.
So yes, you’re more likely to be raped by a native because there are many more.
Now the types of rapes. Broadly there are 2: from ppl you know, and from ppl you don’t know.
I’d argue the rapes from ppl you don’t know are much scarier, because you have zero agency on them, because there are few choices you can make differently to avoid them, short of curtailing your daily life.
Meanwhile, you have some agency with partners: don’t start relationships with bad people, leave them, don’t contact them, call for help…
I assume the natives tend to commit more of this type of crime, whereas immigrants commit more rapes to strangers. Therefore not only are these immigrants more likely to commit rape, they’re also more likely to commit the worst type of rape—to strangers.
And when we have public debates on these things, public behavior is much more relevant than private behavior, so this type of rape is much more relevant to public debate than the more private one (even if both are relevant).
So yes, this graph is bad because it’s logarithmic and undersells the problem, but also because this blends both stranger and acquainted rape. If you only look at stranger rape, immigrants would likely be even worse.
And yet, also, as a woman you’re more likely to be raped by somebody who knows you, so beware
Thanos Angelopoulos
@Th_Angelopoulos
1/ The man most likely to rape a White British woman isn't on a small boat or an immigrant. He's her partner or her ex.
The graph by @TheEconomist is doing rounds, and @RestoreBritain , @reformparty_uk and the rest of the circus of the self-appointed protectors of White British women think that it proves their made up point: that White British women's biggest danger is immigrant men.
Well, data and facts say a different story, a story that the circus of the self-appointed protectors of White British women don't want normal people to know.
Here's the data. 🧵 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
Jason Arday no longer the most embarrassing Cambridge academic.
Jostein Hauge
@haugejostein
Under “dictator” Mao, life expectancy in China increased by 30 years, literacy rates went from 20% to 70%, steel output grew from 1 million to 23 million tons, 47 million hectares of land was taken from landlords and given to peasants, and China was unified under a strong central state and got nuclear weapons.
Despite his failures, it does not take a rocket scientist to understand why Mao is revered in China. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Islamo-Leftism Is Not a Conspiracy Theory
It’s an unrequited love affair
“The Red-Green alliance does not rest on covert coordination behind the scenes, but on ideological kinship, a shared enemy (Western civilization, modernity and capitalism) and a hefty dose of naivety on one side.”
“The bargain is straightforward: leftists coddle Muslims and give them preferential treatment, while Muslims respond by voting for left-wing parties.”
“What makes this love affair tragic is that it is mostly unrequited.”
“There may be ‘Queers for Palestine’, but there are no ‘Queers in Palestine’.” -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Despite a popular misonception, China didn't get rich through centralized, top-down control, but precisely the opposite: relentless experimentation and competition (between firms, between mayors, between governors).
"In the West, China’s success is often attributed to the central government’s willingness to pick winners and direct its economy from above. Many Westerners have concluded that a similar top-down approach is needed in their countries to create champions that can compete with China’s. But Beijing’s role is more akin to being a rulemaker in a great tournament. Subnational governments – provinces, cities, towns, villages – are responsible for around 85 percent of public expenditure, according to the IMF, the lion’s share of which is spent at city level."
“China’s mayors and provincial governors turn their cities into venture capital portfolios because of the system of incentives in which they operate. [ref 2] Each cadre (the party members and other officials who run the Chinese state) is scored by their superiors in a secret file built up over the course of their career. Prefecture-level party secretaries evaluate county chiefs, who in turn evaluate their juniors heading up townships, who evaluate village leaders, down to the lowest party member.”
Must read from @WorksInProgMag.
www.worksinprogress.news/p/how-china-became-rich?publicat… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Helemaal eens met @siegfriedbracke. In @deafspraak zag je vanavond één gewone Israëlische vrouw (de moedige @JonathW66041) die met enkele welgemikte zinnen (de enige die ze kon afmaken) de drie zogenaamde ‘experts’ omverblaast.
Zij hadden geen enkel zinnig antwoord op haar eenvoudige vragen over wat Israël dan wél had moeten doen na 7 oktober, en waarom hun mantra van een "tweestatenoplossing" na 7 oktober zou neerkomen op national suïcide.
Nog geen minuut ver in de uitzending had de gastvrouw het al over ‘genocidaal geweld’, waarmee de toon van vooringenomenheid meteen gezet was. De VRT koos daarmee meteen partij, en de hele uitzending bleef het vier tegen één.
Het gênantst van al was het optreden van het VRT-goudhaantje @bsoenensvrt, die idiote complottheorieën over 7 oktober lanceerde (alsof Netanyahu het ‘doelbewust’ had laten gebeuren) en maar wat stotterde over ‘de Nakba’ en Israëls vermeende ‘intentie’ om de hele Palestijnse bevolking uit te roeien — ondanks evacuaties, waarschuwingen voor militaire aanvallen, voedselhulp en poliovaccinaties.
Siegfried Bracke
@siegfriedbracke
De aflevering van @deafspraaktv van vandaag is echt de moeite waard: zelden zoveel onkunde en vooringenomenheid gezien. En nog opvallend: die ene joodse mevrouw heeft argumenten waarop de ‘experts’ geen zinnig weerwoord konden formuleren. Om te gieren als het niet zo treurig was.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Helemaal eens met @siegfriedbracke. In @deafspraak zag je vanavond één gewone Israëlische vrouw (de moedige @JonathW66041) die met enkele welgemikte zinnen (de enige die ze kon afmaken) de drie zogenaamde ‘experts’ omverblaast.
Zij hadden geen enkel zinnig antwoord op haar eenvoudige vragen over wat Israël dan wél had moeten doen na 7 oktober, en waarom hun mantra van een "tweestatenoplossing" na 7 oktober zou neerkomen op national suïcide.
Nog geen minuut ver in de uitzending had de gastvrouw het al over ‘genocidaal geweld’, waarmee de toon van vooringenomenheid meteen gezet was. De VRT koos daarmee meteen partij, en de hele uitzending bleef het vier tegen één.
Het gênantst van al was het optreden van het VRT-goudhaantje @bsoenensvrt, die idiote complottheorieën over 7 oktober lanceerde (alsof Netanyahu het ‘doelbewust’ had laten gebeuren) en maar wat stotterde over ‘de Nakba’ en Israëls vermeende ‘intentie’ om de hele Palestijnse bevolking uit te roeien — ondanks evacuaties, waarschuwingen voor militaire aanvallen, voedselhulp en poliovaccinaties.
Siegfried Bracke
@siegfriedbracke
De aflevering van @deafspraaktv van vandaag is echt de moeite waard: zelden zoveel onkunde en vooringenomenheid gezien. En nog opvallend: die ene joodse mevrouw heeft argumenten waarop de ‘experts’ geen zinnig weerwoord konden formuleren. Om te gieren als het niet zo treurig was.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit komt letterlijk uit het land dat een cordon sanitaire hanteert tegen een politieke partij die 20% van de kiezers vertegenwoordigt. Die kiezers staan dus evengoed “buitenspel”. Heerst er dan ook “apartheid” in België?
Het punt is dat Arabische en Palestijnse Israëli’s mogen stemmen, net als alle andere Israëli’s. Ze mogen politieke partijen oprichten en zich verkiesbaar stellen, net als iedereen. In Gaza en op de Westelijke Jordaanoever is dat al decennialang niet meer mogelijk, omdat terroristen en corrupte autocraten er de macht in handen hebben.
In Israël kunnen Arabische partijen zelfs mee bepalen wie er aan de macht komt en deel uitmaken van een regeringscoalitie, ongeacht wat Netanyahu daarvan vindt. In 2025 ontmoette ik Mansour Abbas, de leider van Ra’am, een Arabische islamistische partij. Zelfs hij benadrukte dat Israël een democratie is en géén apartheidsstaat: “Wij maken deel uit van Israël en zijn toegewijd aan ons staatsburgerschap.”
De hypocrisie is weer niet te harden.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Link vergeten: www.demorgen.be/nieuws/netanyahu-zet-israelische-arabiere…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
David Saranga
@DavidSaranga
An open letter to the Editor in Chief of @VTMNIEUWS :
“Criticism does not relieve a news organisation of its most basic responsibility: to present facts accurately, fully and in their proper context…
“We expect an unequivocal correction and an apology.
“Anyone reporting should start with the facts, even when those facts do not fit the editorial line…VTM NIEUWS viewers deserve better…”
You can read the entire letter in the thread:
David Saranga
@DavidSaranga
What kind of misleading headline is this, @VTMNIEUWS?
VTM’s headline claims that “7.5 million Palestinians have no vote” in its coverage of Israel’s elections.
Who exactly is included in that figure?
If it includes 2 million Israeli Arab citizens, the claim is wrong. They have the same voting rights as other Israeli citizens, run for office and serve in the Knesset.
If it includes 5 million Palestinians living in the West Bank and Gaza, they generally do not hold Israeli citizenship and therefore do not vote in Israeli national elections. Combining these populations under one sweeping headline misleads viewers.
A reminder: the last Palestinian parliamentary elections were in 2006. President Mahmoud Abbas has now postponed the November 2026 elections until September 2027, despite commitments to international partners. His promise to hold elections was among the commitments underpinning France’s recognition of a Palestinian state.
Recognition went ahead. The elections did not.
A report about democracy should begin by getting the electorate right. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Mikael J. K. PETITJEAN @mjkp1973
Merci @mboudry. Une partie du monde académique, particulièrement active dans les médias, a perdu tout sens de la nuance et parfois même celui des faits. Le conformisme idéologique et la réécriture de l'histoire prennent des proportions inquiétantes. Mais il y a plus grave encore dans cette tribune : depuis quand un chef d'orchestre doit-il rendre des comptes sur ses convictions politiques ? En vertu de quel principe devrait-il condamner tel gouvernement, employer telle qualification juridique ou souscrire à une interprétation particulière d'un conflit pour avoir le droit d'exercer son art ? Faudra-t-il bientôt imposer aux artistes des professions de foi idéologiques et des séances d'autocritique, comme aux heures les plus sombres de la Révolution culturelle ?
Le paradoxe est saisissant : un universitaire reproche à un artiste de ne pas adopter une position politique suffisamment conforme à ses propres convictions, alors que c'est précisément de l'universitaire que l'on est en droit d'attendre rigueur intellectuelle, honnêteté historique et distinction entre analyse scientifique et militantisme. Hélas, une thèse de doctorat et un poste de professeur n'ont jamais protégé contre le dogmatisme et les dérives sectaires.
L'université devrait être le dernier rempart contre les chambres d'écho idéologiques, et non leur principale caisse de résonance. Et la liberté artistique ne devrait jamais être conditionnée à la délivrance d'un certificat de conformité politique.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit krijg je dus als je nooit meer tegenstemmen toelaat in de echokamer van media en academia over Israël: een aaneenschakeling van leugens en geschiedvervalsing, opgetekend door @DriesLesage. Met als toppunt:
"De Israëlische annexatie en kolonisatie sinds 1967 zijn even misdadig als de Russische bezetting in Oekraïne."
Oekraïne is al decennialang een soevereine, internationaal erkende staat, bovendien beschermd door het Boedapestmemorandum. Een Palestijnse staat bestaat echter niet en heeft nooit bestaan, omdat Palestijnse leiders elk voorstel tot de oprichting ervan hebben afgewezen: van de Peelcommissie in 1937 en het VN-partitieplan in 1947 tot de vredesvoorstellen van 2000 en 2008.
Het doel van de Arabische landen was altijd de vernietiging van de ene Joodse staat in het Midden-Oosten, niet de oprichting van een onafhankelijke Palestijnse staat. Toen Egypte en Jordanië na hun vernietigingsoorlog tegen Israël respectievelijk de betwiste gebieden in de regio (Gaza, Oost-Jeruzalem en de West Bank) bezetten, kraaide daar geen haan naar. Want dat was bezetting door andere Arabieren, niet door de verfoeide Joden.
Bovendien heeft Israël zich in 2005 vrijwillig en eenzijdig uit Gaza teruggetrokken en de Palestijnen de kans gegeven er zelf iets van te maken. Ze hebben zelfs hun eigen Israëlische burgers hardhandig verwijderd. Het exacte tegendeel dus van "landroof".
Het resultaat? Twintig jaar terreurbewind door Hamas, miljarden geïnvesteerd in de uitbouw van een militair tunnelnetwerk met menselijke schilden, en de voorbereiding van de slachtpartij van 7 oktober.
Is het een wonder dat de Israëli's niet langer een Palestijnse staat willen? Het zou gewoon suïcidaal zijn. De Palestijnen hebben zelf hun kansen op een staat verkwanseld, door hun starre eliminationisme en hun onophoudelijke terreur.
Het is werkelijk ongelofelijk dat deze man hoogleraar internationale politiek is. Maar hij is helaas niet de enige: hele universiteiten worden nu bevolkt door zulke types.
www.standaard.be/opinies/de-parallelle-werkelijkheid-van-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Ella Ke
@EllaTravelsLove
Is there a single day when the Belgian media doesn’t lie about Israel and incite its citizens against the people of an entire country?
Today, democratic elections are being held in Israel. All Israeli citizens, Jews, Christians, Muslims, and members of other communities, are eligible to vote and enjoy equal voting rights at the ballot box.
As for the Palestinians in Judea and Samaria, they were supposed to hold elections this year. But the head of the Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas, canceled them once again, ensuring that the Palestinian Authority has gone 21 years without elections under its own leadership.
In Gaza, which is ruled by Hamas, there have been no elections for 20 years either. After the Palestinians in Gaza democratically elected Hamas, Hamas canceled elections and never allowed them to take place again.
The ones denying Palestinians the right to vote are their own leaders, not Israel.
And if you look across the Middle East, you will struggle to find a single Arab democracy. So this is entirely on brand.
Palestinians not having the right to vote has nothing to do with Israel.
But why tell the truth when you can lie and incite hatred against Israel instead?
This is the face of the Belgian media in 2026.
Apparently, some nations never change.
David Saranga
@DavidSaranga
According to @VTMNIEUWS:
“Elections in Israel: 7.5 million Palestinians have no vote.”
That’s like reporting:
“Elections in Belgium: 18 million Dutch people have no vote”
I explained it in Flemish (English subtitles)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
David Saranga
@DavidSaranga
What kind of misleading headline is this, @VTMNIEUWS?
VTM’s headline claims that “7.5 million Palestinians have no vote” in its coverage of Israel’s elections.
Who exactly is included in that figure?
If it includes 2 million Israeli Arab citizens, the claim is wrong. They have the same voting rights as other Israeli citizens, run for office and serve in the Knesset.
If it includes 5 million Palestinians living in the West Bank and Gaza, they generally do not hold Israeli citizenship and therefore do not vote in Israeli national elections. Combining these populations under one sweeping headline misleads viewers.
A reminder: the last Palestinian parliamentary elections were in 2006. President Mahmoud Abbas has now postponed the November 2026 elections until September 2027, despite commitments to international partners. His promise to hold elections was among the commitments underpinning France’s recognition of a Palestinian state.
Recognition went ahead. The elections did not.
A report about democracy should begin by getting the electorate right. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Het grote verschil met die andere oorlog (Gaza), @brunostruys en @simontibo02, is dat dissidenten als Tom Sauer tenminste nog aan bod komen in de media: hun opiniestukken worden gepubliceerd, ze worden uitgenodigd in praatprogramma's, ze krijgen interviews.
En dat vind ik goed, zelfs al ben ik het totaal oneens met Tom Sauer en andere Poetin-apologeten. Sauer krijgt in @demorgen zelfs een softbalinterview, gezellig samen met een andere Poetin-apologeet, zonder veel kritische vragen.
Over Israël en Gaza is de situatie veel zorgwekkender: daar komen dissidente stemmen letterlijk NOOIT meer aan bod. Ze worden zo stelselmatig doodgezwegen dat de argeloze lezer wellicht denkt dat ze niet eens bestaan. De weinige dissidenten die er wél zijn, durven zich vaak niet uit te spreken. Ze vrezen sociale en professionele repercussies en zelfs fysieke bedreigingen. Ik moest mijn vriendin beloven om niet langer over Israël te spreken op tv (geen zorgen: niemand is zo gek om mij uit te nodigen).
Bij mijn weten roept niemand op tot het ontslag van Tom Sauer, en heeft hij geen beveiliging nodig bij zijn lezingen. Er zijn geen Oekraïners die hem willen vermoorden of het zwijgen opleggen.
Waarom schrijven jullie dáár niet eens iets over, in plaats van over het relatief diverse Oekraïne-debat? De vraag stellen is ze beantwoorden.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nu ben ik echt benieuwd of ook maar één Vlaamse krant een interview zal doen met Joel Kotek. Hij is genocide-expert en professor aan @ULBruxelles en schreef meerdere boeken en artikels over de Holocaust en andere genocides. Nu brengt hij een nieuw boek uit (ook in het Nederlands) waarin hij de beschuldiging van genocide in Gaza fors en ondubbelzinnig tegenspreekt.
Al meer dan drie jaar laten Vlaamse kranten geen énkele expert aan het woord die niet meegaat in de genocide-onzin. Nooit een Jeffrey Herf, Norman Goda, Benny Morris, Steven Pinker, Fania Oz-Salzberger of John Spencer. Maar elke week wel een nieuwe anti-zionistische Jood die berouwvol komt biechten: “Ja, snik, het is genocide en apartheid en etnische zuivering en alles wat je nog wil horen van mij.”
Dit is een ongekend schuldig verzuim van de voltallige Vlaamse media, van @destandaard tot @demorgen, @tijd, @HLN_BE en @Nieuwsblad_be. In Nederland is het ook erg, maar daar heb je nog @telegraaf en heel af en toe een tegendraads opiniestuk in @nrc of @volkskrant. In Frankrijk heb je @LePoint, waar mijn essay over de bloedsmaad van genocide probleemloos verscheen (www.lepoint.fr/debats/israel-commet-un-genocide-a-gaza-un…), dat overal in ons taalgebied werd geweigerd. In Duitsland is het debat sowieso diverser en bestaat er absoluut geen consensus over de "genocide". Zelfs in @nytimes heb je Bret Stephens die al deze onzin krachtig tegenspreekt.
Maar het ergst van al is ons achterlijke tochtgat aan de Noordzee.
@RemyAmkreutz @dskarel -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit krijg je dus als je nooit meer tegenstemmen toelaat in de echokamer van media en academia over Israël: een aaneenschakeling van leugens en geschiedvervalsing, opgetekend door @DriesLesage. Met als toppunt:
"De Israëlische annexatie en kolonisatie sinds 1967 zijn even misdadig als de Russische bezetting in Oekraïne."
Oekraïne is al decennialang een soevereine, internationaal erkende staat, bovendien beschermd door het Boedapestmemorandum. Een Palestijnse staat bestaat echter niet en heeft nooit bestaan, omdat Palestijnse leiders elk voorstel tot de oprichting ervan hebben afgewezen: van de Peelcommissie in 1937 en het VN-partitieplan in 1947 tot de vredesvoorstellen van 2000 en 2008.
Het doel van de Arabische landen was altijd de vernietiging van de ene Joodse staat in het Midden-Oosten, niet de oprichting van een onafhankelijke Palestijnse staat. Toen Egypte en Jordanië na hun vernietigingsoorlog tegen Israël respectievelijk de betwiste gebieden in de regio (Gaza, Oost-Jeruzalem en de West Bank) bezetten, kraaide daar geen haan naar. Want dat was bezetting door andere Arabieren, niet door de verfoeide Joden.
Bovendien heeft Israël zich in 2005 vrijwillig en eenzijdig uit Gaza teruggetrokken en de Palestijnen de kans gegeven er zelf iets van te maken. Ze hebben zelfs hun eigen Israëlische burgers hardhandig verwijderd. Het exacte tegendeel dus van "landroof".
Het resultaat? Twintig jaar terreurbewind door Hamas, miljarden geïnvesteerd in de uitbouw van een militair tunnelnetwerk met menselijke schilden, en de voorbereiding van de slachtpartij van 7 oktober.
Is het een wonder dat de Israëli's niet langer een Palestijnse staat willen? Het zou gewoon suïcidaal zijn. De Palestijnen hebben zelf hun kansen op een staat verkwanseld, door hun starre eliminationisme en hun onophoudelijke terreur.
Het is werkelijk ongelofelijk dat deze man hoogleraar internationale politiek is. Maar hij is helaas niet de enige: hele universiteiten worden nu bevolkt door zulke types.
www.standaard.be/opinies/de-parallelle-werkelijkheid-van-… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In Belgium, you can condone and glorify terrorism with impunity (but only if it’s Islamic), even at our universities. But make a descriptive claim about racial differences in IQ, and you’ll be sued by a government agency and threatened with a prison sentence. Is this still a free country? Please abolish UNIA (Interfederal Center for Equal Opportunities), @Bart_DeWever.
"Threatening a scholar with a prison sentence silences the careful along with the clumsy, and it shuts down scientific inquiry. We can reject racism and assert that Nathan Cofnas is being treated shamefully. There is no trade-off. A university and a culture that fail to understand this have lost their way."
quillette.com/2026/10/22/prison-or-peer-review/ -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Jerry Coyne
@Evolutionistrue
A terrific piece by Maarten Boudry on Islamo-leftism, the unholy marriage of the extreme left and radical Islamism. It's coming for the West, as it is in France right now.
maartenboudry.substack.com/p/islamo-leftism-is-not-a-cons… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Matty Dread
@MattyDread
A very clever pun
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
At bottom, the Red-Green alliance stems from an accidental but deeply unfortunate association between religious faith and skin color.
Most Muslims in Europe are immigrants from North Africa and the Middle East, and therefore happen to have darker complexions. Nothing has warped the minds of progressives more than this stupid accident of history.
Out of colonial guilt and a misguided notion of “respect”, all kinds of evils are condoned. After all, who wants to be seen targeting an ethnic minority? Islamists have learned to exploit this fear of racism relentlessly, using it as a protective shield behind which to propagate their noxious ideology with impunity.
To make matters worse, genuine racists hide behind the cloak of Enlightenment values to make themselves appear more respectable. Because so few progressives have dared to criticize Islam, for fear of being branded racists, the far right has been free to monopolize the field. The result is a self-fulfilling prophecy: criticism of Islam is increasingly left to those who have no qualms about racism at all, because they are racists themselves.
But religions are not races, and ideas have no skin color. If we should be grateful to the white converts to Islam who joined the ranks of ISIS for anything, it is that they inadvertently exposed the absurdity of conflating Islam with ethnicity. Radical Islam has nothing to do with skin color. Anyone can embrace despicable ideas.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Despite a popular misonception, China didn't get rich through centralized, top-down control, but precisely the opposite: relentless experimentation and competition (between firms, between mayors, between governors).
"In the West, China’s success is often attributed to the central government’s willingness to pick winners and direct its economy from above. Many Westerners have concluded that a similar top-down approach is needed in their countries to create champions that can compete with China’s. But Beijing’s role is more akin to being a rulemaker in a great tournament. Subnational governments – provinces, cities, towns, villages – are responsible for around 85 percent of public expenditure, according to the IMF, the lion’s share of which is spent at city level."
“China’s mayors and provincial governors turn their cities into venture capital portfolios because of the system of incentives in which they operate. [ref 2] Each cadre (the party members and other officials who run the Chinese state) is scored by their superiors in a secret file built up over the course of their career. Prefecture-level party secretaries evaluate county chiefs, who in turn evaluate their juniors heading up townships, who evaluate village leaders, down to the lowest party member.”
Must read from @WorksInProgMag.
www.worksinprogress.news/p/how-china-became-rich?publicat… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Climate scientist: "The world is a Japanese warrior committing a slow harakiri. The knife is already in his belly, the blood is running down his body.'
I am, quite frankly, fed up with this. This kind of extreme fearmongering is not only scientifically unfounded; it is actively harmful. It breeds paralysis and defeatism, fuels mental health problems, and leads young people to decide against having children.
For a long time, I tried to maintain the utmost respect for climate scientists. But it’s time we confronted a paradox: experts are often not the best guides when it comes to assessing the dangers within their own field—and even less so when it comes to deciding which policies should address them.
The same goes for AI, where even the field’s pioneers are now recklessly speculating about their “p(doom)”—the probability of human extinction.
Years of specializing in a single domain can narrow your perspective until everything else pales in comparison. Climate change—or AI—becomes the existential threat to humanity, eclipsing every other danger we face.
Self-selection plays a role, too. If you choose to specialize in a field because you believe humanity’s future depends on it, you’re hardly a representative sample of people who think the threat is manageable, or that the real dangers lie elsewhere. Those people are less likely to pursue a career in climate science or AI safety in the first place.
And, I’m sorry to say, there’s also a certain narcissism inherent in this kind of doomsday rhetoric: the belief that the fate of the entire world hinges on your particular area of expertise. That you possess privileged knowledge and occupy a central role in humanity’s existential drama.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Today Is the Best Time To Be Born, Despite Climate Change
Economic growth will ensure an abundant future
substacktools.com/sharex/s-SRKDMp
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Original interview: www.humo.be/achter-het-nieuws/klimaatwetenschapper-wim-th…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
John Aziz
@aziz0nomics
1/ Russian imperialism
2/ Jihad
3/ Jihad
4/ Jihad
5/ Jihad
6/ Jihad
7/ Jihad + natural resource control
8/ Drug cartels
9/ Drug cartels
10/ Jihad
11/ Jihad + natural resource control
12/ Jihadis vs Zionists -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
It’s incredibly kind of you to illustrate my thesis about islamogauchism better than I ever could, @ThomasVanRiet2. When someone presents extensive evidence of the disturbing beliefs and attitudes held by millions of Muslims (on apostasy, homosexuality, gender equality, blasphemy), left-wing academics will immediately brand them as proto-Nazis.
Never forget: as a “progressive”, you provide cover for the most reactionary, dangerous, and violent ideology* on the planet — a latter-day Nazism whose adherents even draw on the very same antisemitic conspiracy texts. That, in a nutshell, is islamogauchism.
And don’t worry, @ThomasVanRiet2: you’ve posted far more hateful things about Israelis and Zionists here. Yet I’ll continue to defend your academic freedom.
*I mean Islamism or Islamic fundamentalism or whatever you want to call it, not Islam in general, as not all Muslims share the same violent and intolerant beliefs. But it's not a fringe position either, and often even represents a majority. Check the data I cited.
Thomas Van Riet
@ThomasVanRiet2
Imagine me writing posts like yours with muslim replaced by jew.
I'd risk loosing my job.
Islamophobia is todays antisemitism. You are the modern day equivalent of intellectuals in the 30s writing about "the jew problem".
On a day of intensified ethnic cleansing. Insane. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ik ben dit eigenlijk redelijk strontzat. Die paniekzaaierij is niet alleen totaal onwetenschappelijk, maar ook schadelijk. Ze leidt tot verlamming, defaitisme, psychische problemen en jongeren die besluiten geen kinderen meer te krijgen.
Ik heb lang geprobeerd het grootste respect op te brengen voor klimaatwetenschappers, maar het wordt tijd dat we oog krijgen voor deze paradox: vakspecialisten zijn vaak niet de beste raadgevers zijn als het gaat om de gevaren binnen hun eigen vakgebied. En al zeker niet als het gaat om beleid om die gevaren aan te pakken.
Dat geldt ook voor AI, waar zelfs de grondleggers inmiddels roekeloos speculeren over p(doom) en de uitroeiing van de mensheid.
Waarom? Als je je jarenlang specialiseert in één domein, kun je je zo blindstaren op je eigen tegel van de werkelijkheid dat al het andere bijzaak lijkt. Het klimaat — of AI — wordt dan dé existentiële bedreiging voor de mensheid, waarvoor al de rest moet wijken.
Zelfselectie speelt ook een rol: de reden waarom je je juist in dat domein specialiseert is misschien wel je denkt dat de toekomst van de mensheid ervan afhangt. Wie gelooft dat het allemaal wel meevalt of dat het gevaar elders ligt, zal geen carrière als klimaatwetenschapper ambiëren.
En (het spijt me) er zit ook een zeker narcisme in die doempraatjes: de gedachte dat de toekomst van de hele wereld afhangt van jouw kennisdomein.
Manuel Sintubin 🌎⛏️💚🇺🇦🇬🇱🇪🇺
@ManuelSintubin
Laten we vooral de jongeren hoop geven ...
#foutecommunicatie
#climatedisasterporn
@humo -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
I'm shocked that The Economist was willing to publish this!
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In the same category: while Belgians are fighting over whether to bring 13 traumatised Gazan students to our country, and the Dutch are fighting over whether one of their own did or did not glorify the October 7 massacre, our own wunderkind Laurent Simon is leaving Belgium and heading to Israel.
Although Laurent isn't Jewish, he’s a staunch Zionist and supporter of Israel. Because he’s not stupid, as you may have gleaned from the fact that he has two PhDs at age 16. Laurent wants to invent, innovate, and make the world a better place. And few countries are more dynamic and technologically advanced than Israel.
Meanwhile, our Belgian universities are boycotting @BarIlanU, which will host Laurent Simon, because some of their archeologists did some excavatations in the West Bank (I'm not making this up, check @UGent's report).
Nice brain trade, Low Countries!
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Despite fighting multiple wars of necessity, constant terrorist threats and huge internal divisions, Israel’s 🇮🇱 economy is growing so fast that it is set to overtake the Netherlands 🇳🇱 within 18 months, in GDP per capita.
Israelis are more innovative, their civil society is stronger, they have a stronger sense of national identity, and they have a real demographic future, because they still actually procreate (all European nations are below replacement level).
By many measures, even Muslim citizens are better integrated in Israel proper (not the West Bank) than in the Netherlands.
Yes, Israeli democracy is under threat, and the growing ultra-orthodox population poses serious porblems, but we'll see what the next election will bring (hopefully the end of the Netanyahu era).
Meanwhile, the Dutch government bans Israeli goods from the West Bank, universities have cut ties with Israeli partners, and the “progressive” @progressiefned backs further sanctions and an end to all military support, even for purely defensive purposes. Because who cares if Jews die under rockets attacks?
The Netherlands needs Israel more than the other way around.
Saul Sadka
@Saul_Sadka
UPDATE: Israel’s economy is growing so fast, it will leapfrog the Netherlands and Australia within the next 18 months, in time for it's 80th birthday—not by 2030, as predicted—to rank second only to the USA in GDP per capita of all nations with populations over 10 million.
Saul Sadka
@Saul_Sadka
Congratulations to Israel, which, despite the war and six weeks of economic shutdown in the spring, now has the 4th highest GDP per capita among states with over ten million people—behind only the USA, the Netherlands & Australia. It will likely leapfrog into 2nd place by 2030.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
*Simons
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ik ben dit eigenlijk redelijk strontzat. Die paniekzaaierij is niet alleen totaal onwetenschappelijk, maar ook schadelijk. Ze leidt tot verlamming, defaitisme, psychische problemen en jongeren die besluiten geen kinderen meer te krijgen.
Ik heb lang geprobeerd het grootste respect op te brengen voor klimaatwetenschappers, maar het wordt tijd dat we oog krijgen voor deze paradox: vakspecialisten zijn vaak niet de beste raadgevers zijn als het gaat om de gevaren binnen hun eigen vakgebied. En al zeker niet als het gaat om beleid om die gevaren aan te pakken.
Dat geldt ook voor AI, waar zelfs de grondleggers inmiddels roekeloos speculeren over p(doom) en de uitroeiing van de mensheid.
Waarom? Als je je jarenlang specialiseert in één domein, kun je je zo blindstaren op je eigen tegel van de werkelijkheid dat al het andere bijzaak lijkt. Het klimaat — of AI — wordt dan dé existentiële bedreiging voor de mensheid, waarvoor al de rest moet wijken.
Zelfselectie speelt ook een rol: de reden waarom je je juist in dat domein specialiseert is misschien wel je denkt dat de toekomst van de mensheid ervan afhangt. Wie gelooft dat het allemaal wel meevalt of dat het gevaar elders ligt, zal geen carrière als klimaatwetenschapper ambiëren.
En (het spijt me) er zit ook een zeker narcisme in die doempraatjes: de gedachte dat de toekomst van de hele wereld afhangt van jouw kennisdomein.
Manuel Sintubin 🌎⛏️💚🇺🇦🇬🇱🇪🇺
@ManuelSintubin
Laten we vooral de jongeren hoop geven ...
#foutecommunicatie
#climatedisasterporn
@humo
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
A conspiracy theory, in the pejorative sense, is an unproven and speculative hypothesis about a secret and sinister plot hatched by a relatively small group of people.
Typically, the very lack of hard evidence for the conspiracy is taken as proof that the conspirators are fiendishly clever and have covered their tracks.
In my academic work, I have dubbed such self-sealing theories the intellectual equivalent of a black hole: once you’ve dived in, it’s hard to claw your way back out.
The rapprochement between parts of the Left and Islam is none of these things...
The Red-Green alliance does not rest on covert coordination behind the scenes, but on ideological kinship, a shared enemy (Western civilization, modernity and capitalism) and a hefty dose of naivety on one side.
~Conjecture Institute Senior Philosopher @mboudry
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Islamo-Leftism Is Not a Conspiracy Theory
It’s an unrequited love affair
“The Red-Green alliance does not rest on covert coordination behind the scenes, but on ideological kinship, a shared enemy (Western civilization, modernity and capitalism) and a hefty dose of naivety on one side.”
“The bargain is straightforward: leftists coddle Muslims and give them preferential treatment, while Muslims respond by voting for left-wing parties.”
“What makes this love affair tragic is that it is mostly unrequited.”
“There may be ‘Queers for Palestine’, but there are no ‘Queers in Palestine’.” -
Maarten Boudry reposted
WNL Op Zondag
@WNLOpZondag
Volgens columniste @DoornaertMia komt het vernietigende geweld in Frankrijk voort uit het monsterverbond tussen extreemlinks en de islam. "De gevaarlijkste politicus is Jean-Luc Mélenchon, uiterst links en een bewonderaar van Fidel Castro. Hij zet op een roekeloze manier jongeren met een migratieafkomst op tegen het land waar ze leven." #wnl
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Despite fighting multiple wars of necessity, constant terrorist threats and huge internal divisions, Israel’s 🇮🇱 economy is growing so fast that it is set to overtake the Netherlands 🇳🇱 within 18 months, in GDP per capita.
Israelis are more innovative, their civil society is stronger, they have a stronger sense of national identity, and they have a real demographic future, because they still actually procreate (all European nations are below replacement level).
By many measures, even Muslim citizens are better integrated in Israel proper (not the West Bank) than in the Netherlands.
Yes, Israeli democracy is under threat, and the growing ultra-orthodox population poses serious porblems, but we'll see what the next election will bring (hopefully the end of the Netanyahu era).
Meanwhile, the Dutch government bans Israeli goods from the West Bank, universities have cut ties with Israeli partners, and the “progressive” @progressiefned backs further sanctions and an end to all military support, even for purely defensive purposes. Because who cares if Jews die under rockets attacks?
The Netherlands needs Israel more than the other way around.
Saul Sadka
@Saul_Sadka
UPDATE: Israel’s economy is growing so fast, it will leapfrog the Netherlands and Australia within the next 18 months, in time for it's 80th birthday—not by 2030, as predicted—to rank second only to the USA in GDP per capita of all nations with populations over 10 million.
Saul Sadka
@Saul_Sadka
Congratulations to Israel, which, despite the war and six weeks of economic shutdown in the spring, now has the 4th highest GDP per capita among states with over ten million people—behind only the USA, the Netherlands & Australia. It will likely leapfrog into 2nd place by 2030.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
David Saranga
@DavidSaranga
“There may be ‘Queers for Palestine’, but there are no ‘Queers in Palestine’.”
“The bargain is straightforward: leftists coddle Muslims and give them preferential treatment, while Muslims respond by voting for left-wing parties.”
A must read by @mboudry
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Islamo-Leftism Is Not a Conspiracy Theory
It’s an unrequited love affair
“The Red-Green alliance does not rest on covert coordination behind the scenes, but on ideological kinship, a shared enemy (Western civilization, modernity and capitalism) and a hefty dose of naivety on one side.”
“The bargain is straightforward: leftists coddle Muslims and give them preferential treatment, while Muslims respond by voting for left-wing parties.”
“What makes this love affair tragic is that it is mostly unrequited.”
“There may be ‘Queers for Palestine’, but there are no ‘Queers in Palestine’.” -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"De mensheid wordt bedreigd als nooit te voren: klimaat, geopolitiek, artificiële intelligentie". 🤯
Voor zoveel economische en historische ongeletterdheid moet je wel de hoofdredacteur van een "kwaliteitskrant" zijn.
Maar dan tegelijk schrijven dat "declinisme wordt aangeblazen door de sociale algoritmes" (www.standaard.be/opinies/bart-de-wever-hoeft-het-radeloze…). Het lijkt erop dat Karel Verhoeven (ik tag @dskarel ter wille van het open vizier) zelf in een konijnenpijp van doemporno zit (maar dan alleen linkse doemporno, natuurlijk nooit iets over migratie of islam of dalende geboortecijfers).
Het enige wat steil bergaf gaat, is het lezersbereik van zijn krant @destandaard:
"De Standaard ziet zijn bereik fors dalen met vijf procent."
Misschien zijn lezers de bekrompenheid en linkse ideologische kaping gewoon beu?
www.demorgen.be/nieuws/de-morgen-blijft-groeien-en-bereik…
Thomas Spaas
@thomas_spaas
Stel je voor dat je die krant elke dag leest, en ernstig neemt. Kan niet goed zijn voor de mentale gezondheid.
Ik deel dat doem-gevoel totaal niet. Ik betreur vooral dat perma-doomers zoals Karel Verhoeven hier het depri maatschappelijke klimaat bepalen, de Europese psychosfeer. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Islamogauchisme is geen complottheorie
"De sympathie is overigens veel minder wederzijds. Islamisten profiteren van de naïviteit van links en staan zij aan zij met linkse activisten op de barricaden zolang ze een gemeenschappelijke vijand delen. Maar zodra ze ergens de macht grijpen, zoals in Iran, Egypte, Libanon of Palestina, worden hun linkse medestanders brutaal aan de kant geschoven of zelfs geëxecuteerd. Er zijn wel ‘Queers for Palestine’, maar geen ‘Queers in Palestine’."
wnl.tv/2026/10/25/islamogauchisme-is-geen-complottheorie -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Islamo-Leftism Is Not a Conspiracy Theory
It’s an unrequited love affair
“The Red-Green alliance does not rest on covert coordination behind the scenes, but on ideological kinship, a shared enemy (Western civilization, modernity and capitalism) and a hefty dose of naivety on one side.”
“The bargain is straightforward: leftists coddle Muslims and give them preferential treatment, while Muslims respond by voting for left-wing parties.”
“What makes this love affair tragic is that it is mostly unrequited.”
“There may be ‘Queers for Palestine’, but there are no ‘Queers in Palestine’.”
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Islamo-Leftism Is Not a Conspiracy Theory
It’s an unrequited love affair
substacktools.com/sharex/A0yQ5KK7
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Like what you’ve read? Support independent thought by becoming a paid subscriber. Or support me here: buymeacoffee.com/maartenbou4 Thanks a lot! 🙏
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Mark Nelson
@energybants
Need a crumb of hope about Europe on a Saturday?
Belgium has gone from rapidly closing and destroying its entire nuclear fleet (half of its power before 2023) to quickly relicensing and returning a few of them to the grid.
PM @Bart_DeWever is trying to save as many as he can.
Martien Visser
@BM_Visser
België en @ENGIE_energie zijn erin geslaagd de kerncentrales Doel IV en Tihange III in een half jaar volledig te reviseren, alle veiligheidsprocedures te doorlopen en weer op te starten. Terwijl sluiting gepland was.
Dat is een applausje waard, vindt u niet?
#grafiekvandedag -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Yannick Bernier @ycbernier
« L'Alliance Rouge-Verte » n'est pas une théorie du complot — c'est une politique officielle. Le 19 juillet 2026, lors d’un appel Zoom du Sunday Morning Marxist Forum organisé par l’Institute for the Critical Social Studies (ICSS), la co-fondatrice de Samidoun, Charlotte Kates (du Liban, tout juste revenue des funérailles de l’ayatollah Ali Khamenei en Iran), appellait ouvertement à une alliance complète et nécessaire entre la Résistance islamiste et la gauche révolutionnaire occidentale.
À lire : « Islamo-Leftism Is Not a Conspiracy Theory » par Maarten Boudry
maartenboudry.substack.com/p/islamo-leftism-is-not-a-cons… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Andrea Speyerbach ☄️ 'Activist'
@ALSpeyerbach
Once again, Boudry is doing the work of journalists and academics combined in the time it takes to go grocery shopping. Ghent University fumbled a GOAT.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Islamo-Leftism Is Not a Conspiracy Theory
It’s an unrequited love affair
“The Red-Green alliance does not rest on covert coordination behind the scenes, but on ideological kinship, a shared enemy (Western civilization, modernity and capitalism) and a hefty dose of naivety on one side.”
“The bargain is straightforward: leftists coddle Muslims and give them preferential treatment, while Muslims respond by voting for left-wing parties.”
“What makes this love affair tragic is that it is mostly unrequited.”
“There may be ‘Queers for Palestine’, but there are no ‘Queers in Palestine’.” -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Crémieux
@cremieuxrecueil
This is just sad.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Jonah
@jonahelshout
‘’Is de #westerse Samenleving Kwaadaardig?''
Marlies Dekkers & #maarten #boudry over zijn breuk met de #universiteit #gent & het ideologische geklap van de academische wereld.
Hoe het progressieve vrijdenken is gekaapt door activistische groepen en woke dogma's,
mechanismen van groepsdenken en zelfcensuur,
& waarom de verlichting & rationaliteit vandaag de
dag onder zware druk staan.
youtu.be/oSfSiDqJo8Y -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
As Paris lectures Israel, riots leave its Jews fearing for their safety. www.jpost.com/opinion/article-912389
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Je zou eens moeten weten wie deze tweet allemaal liket. Sinds je hier op X in alle discretie een blijk van goedkeuring kan uitbrengen, wordt (voor mij) pas duidelijk hoe vals en kunstmatig de "consensus" over Israël en Gaza is. Maar prachtige kleren heeft die Keizer, hoor! Wat een garderobe! substacktools.com/sharex/QjW6L9_Y
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nu ben ik echt benieuwd of ook maar één Vlaamse krant een interview zal doen met Joel Kotek. Hij is genocide-expert en professor aan @ULBruxelles en schreef meerdere boeken en artikels over de Holocaust en andere genocides. Nu brengt hij een nieuw boek uit (ook in het Nederlands) waarin hij de beschuldiging van genocide in Gaza fors en ondubbelzinnig tegenspreekt.
Al meer dan drie jaar laten Vlaamse kranten geen énkele expert aan het woord die niet meegaat in de genocide-onzin. Nooit een Jeffrey Herf, Norman Goda, Benny Morris, Steven Pinker, Fania Oz-Salzberger of John Spencer. Maar elke week wel een nieuwe anti-zionistische Jood die berouwvol komt biechten: “Ja, snik, het is genocide en apartheid en etnische zuivering en alles wat je nog wil horen van mij.”
Dit is een ongekend schuldig verzuim van de voltallige Vlaamse media, van @destandaard tot @demorgen, @tijd, @HLN_BE en @Nieuwsblad_be. In Nederland is het ook erg, maar daar heb je nog @telegraaf en heel af en toe een tegendraads opiniestuk in @nrc of @volkskrant. In Frankrijk heb je @LePoint, waar mijn essay over de bloedsmaad van genocide probleemloos verscheen (www.lepoint.fr/debats/israel-commet-un-genocide-a-gaza-un…), dat overal in ons taalgebied werd geweigerd. In Duitsland is het debat sowieso diverser en bestaat er absoluut geen consensus over de "genocide". Zelfs in @nytimes heb je Bret Stephens die al deze onzin krachtig tegenspreekt.
Maar het ergst van al is ons achterlijke tochtgat aan de Noordzee.
@RemyAmkreutz @dskarel -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
As Paris lectures Israel, riots leave its Jews fearing for their safety. www.jpost.com/opinion/article-912389
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Je zou eens moeten weten wie deze tweet allemaal liket. Sinds je hier op X in alle discretie een blijk van goedkeuring kan uitbrengen, wordt (voor mij) pas duidelijk hoe vals en kunstmatig de "consensus" over Israël en Gaza is. Maar prachtige kleren heeft die Keizer, hoor! Wat een garderobe! substacktools.com/sharex/QjW6L9_Y
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nu ben ik echt benieuwd of ook maar één Vlaamse krant een interview zal doen met Joel Kotek. Hij is genocide-expert en professor aan @ULBruxelles en schreef meerdere boeken en artikels over de Holocaust en andere genocides. Nu brengt hij een nieuw boek uit (ook in het Nederlands) waarin hij de beschuldiging van genocide in Gaza fors en ondubbelzinnig tegenspreekt.
Al meer dan drie jaar laten Vlaamse kranten geen énkele expert aan het woord die niet meegaat in de genocide-onzin. Nooit een Jeffrey Herf, Norman Goda, Benny Morris, Steven Pinker, Fania Oz-Salzberger of John Spencer. Maar elke week wel een nieuwe anti-zionistische Jood die berouwvol komt biechten: “Ja, snik, het is genocide en apartheid en etnische zuivering en alles wat je nog wil horen van mij.”
Dit is een ongekend schuldig verzuim van de voltallige Vlaamse media, van @destandaard tot @demorgen, @tijd, @HLN_BE en @Nieuwsblad_be. In Nederland is het ook erg, maar daar heb je nog @telegraaf en heel af en toe een tegendraads opiniestuk in @nrc of @volkskrant. In Frankrijk heb je @LePoint, waar mijn essay over de bloedsmaad van genocide probleemloos verscheen (www.lepoint.fr/debats/israel-commet-un-genocide-a-gaza-un…), dat overal in ons taalgebied werd geweigerd. In Duitsland is het debat sowieso diverser en bestaat er absoluut geen consensus over de "genocide". Zelfs in @nytimes heb je Bret Stephens die al deze onzin krachtig tegenspreekt.
Maar het ergst van al is ons achterlijke tochtgat aan de Noordzee.
@RemyAmkreutz @dskarel -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
After the Second World War, Western academic institutions spawned one school after another to denounce or undermine Western civilisation.
Postmodernists like Michel Foucault and Jacques Derrida attacked the “logocentrism” of Western rationality and attempted to deconstruct the narrative of scientific and moral progress.
Followers of the Frankfurt School of Critical Theory wrote devastating critiques of the European Enlightenment.
Its delusional project to quantify, rationalise, and dominate the world, they claimed, had paved the way for National Socialism and the Holocaust.
Social constructivists exposed modern science as just one mythological narrative among many.
Science, they argued, did not so much reveal reality as construct its own reality—and an oppressive one at that. Postcolonial thinkers denounced Western civilisation for its colonialism and cultural imperialism.
~Conjecture Institute Senior Philosopher @mboudry in @Quillette (The Enlightenment's Gravediggers) -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is such a fantastic chart! Take your time and look carefully at both the X and Y axes. This should finally put to rest the naysayers’ claim that the decline in poverty is merely an artefact of choosing a particular poverty threshold. Let's celebrate the progress we have already achieved, and bring poverty all the way down to zero. Great work, @MaxCRoser.
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
How has global poverty changed in our lifetimes?
No matter what poverty line you choose, the share below it has declined globally. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nu ben ik echt benieuwd of ook maar één Vlaamse krant een interview zal doen met Joel Kotek. Hij is genocide-expert en professor aan @ULBruxelles en schreef meerdere boeken en artikels over de Holocaust en andere genocides. Nu brengt hij een nieuw boek uit (ook in het Nederlands) waarin hij de beschuldiging van genocide in Gaza fors en ondubbelzinnig tegenspreekt.
Al meer dan drie jaar laten Vlaamse kranten geen énkele expert aan het woord die niet meegaat in de genocide-onzin. Nooit een Jeffrey Herf, Norman Goda, Benny Morris, Steven Pinker, Fania Oz-Salzberger of John Spencer. Maar elke week wel een nieuwe anti-zionistische Jood die berouwvol komt biechten: “Ja, snik, het is genocide en apartheid en etnische zuivering en alles wat je nog wil horen van mij.”
Dit is een ongekend schuldig verzuim van de voltallige Vlaamse media, van @destandaard tot @demorgen, @tijd, @HLN_BE en @Nieuwsblad_be. In Nederland is het ook erg, maar daar heb je nog @telegraaf en heel af en toe een tegendraads opiniestuk in @nrc of @volkskrant. In Frankrijk heb je @LePoint, waar mijn essay over de bloedsmaad van genocide probleemloos verscheen (www.lepoint.fr/debats/israel-commet-un-genocide-a-gaza-un…), dat overal in ons taalgebied werd geweigerd. In Duitsland is het debat sowieso diverser en bestaat er absoluut geen consensus over de "genocide". Zelfs in @nytimes heb je Bret Stephens die al deze onzin krachtig tegenspreekt.
Maar het ergst van al is ons achterlijke tochtgat aan de Noordzee.
@RemyAmkreutz @dskarel
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Gaan we dit binnenkort in een Vlaamse "kwaliteitskrant" lezen? Joel Kotek zou echt incontournable moeten zijn, als Belgische wereldautoriteit en genocide-expert. Maar ik hou mijn adem niet in.
"Et il y a une jouissance particulière, perverse, à accuser les victimes de la Shoah du crime qu'elles ont subi, et ce dans un contexte de collaboration exacerbée. Comme le souligna dès 1978 le philosophe français Vladimir Jankélévitch : « Et si les Juifs étaient eux-mêmes des nazis ? Ce serait merveilleux. »"
www.21news.be/entretien-avec-joel-kotek-ulb-je-conteste-l… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Everything I don't like is genocide".
I didn't think a more absurd court case for "genocide" was possible, but here goes...
www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2026/10/22/bill-gates-kwam-niet-naar-le… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Waarom "islamogauchisme" geen complottheorie is
Is de toenadering tussen linkse en islamitische krachten in onze samenleving, soms aangeduid als islamogauchisme, niet meer dan een ‘complottheorie’, zoals Stefaan Werbrouck (@swerbrou) schrijft in @Humo? Als auteur van meerdere academische papers over complottheorieën kan ik stellen: dat is volstrekte onzin en een misbruik van de term.
Een echte complottheorie draait om een doelbewust, geheim en snood plan waarvoor geen hard bewijs bestaat, omdat de samenzweerders het zogezegd zorgvuldig verbergen. De toenadering tussen delen van links en de islam is echter voor iedereen zichtbaar en uitvoerig gedocumenteerd. Het is geen bewuste coördinatie achter de schermen, maar een toenadering die wordt gedreven door een gedeelde vijand (het Westen en het kapitalisme) en een fikse scheut naïviteit aan linkse kant.
Linkse academici, journalisten en intellectuelen doen al decennialang hun uiterste best om elke legitieme kritiek op de islam neer te sabelen als ‘islamofobie’. Dat perfide concept moet een geloofssysteem immuniseren tegen kritiek, en ze namen het letterlijk over van islamisten. Ze verloochenen hun eigen progressieve principes door een oogje dicht te knijpen voor homohaat, vrouwenhaat, eerwraak en geweld tegen afvalligen, zolang die maar uit islamitische hoek komen. Ze herhaalden ook uitentreuren de onzin dat jihadistisch terrorisme ‘niets met de islam te maken heeft’. Al jaren zijn er demonstraties en optredens waar radicaal-linkse en islamitische groepen samen optrekken, de laatste jaren vooral rond Palestina.
In mijn boek Het verraad aan de verlichting documenteer ik uitvoerig hoe moslims uitgroeiden tot de favoriete slachtoffergroep van links: een groep die nooit of te nimmer iets verkeerd kan doen.
De sympathie is overigens veel minder wederzijds. Islamisten profiteren van de naïviteit van links en staan zij aan zij met linkse activisten op de barricaden zolang ze een gemeenschappelijke vijand delen: het kapitalisme of het Westen. Maar zodra islamisten ergens de macht grijpen, zoals in Iran, Egypte, Libanon of Palestina, worden hun linkse medestanders brutaal aan de kant geschoven en onderdrukt.
Het hoeft dus niet te verbazen dat de rellen en plunderingen in Frankrijk werden uitgevoerd door een allegaartje van radicaal-linkse activisten en Noord-Afrikaanse moslims, en dat er overal Palestijnse vlaggen wapperden. Hier en daar werden zelfs leuzen gescandeerd als ‘Dood hen in naam van Allah!’ gescandeerd, en rapsongs gezongen die de terreuraanslag op de Bataclan verheerlijkten. Links drukt deze slang al decennialang tegen de borst.
De ironie wil dat Stefaan Werbrouck zelf een treffend voorbeeld van dat islamogauchisme is: een linkse rakker die in het ooit rebelse en vrijzinnige magazine @Humo onlangs de Koran in bescherming nam tegen de beschuldiging van vrouwenhaat, en die de overduidelijke verbanden tussen het islamitische geloof en homohaat wegwuift.
Kun je je voorstellen dat iemand in Humo in de bres springt voor de Jehova’s getuigen en de Bijbel tegen kritiek in bescherming neemt? Dat is precies het soort dubbele standaard waar de term islamogauchisme naar verwijst.
Dank voor de illustratie, @Humo. Wedden dat jullie ook deze brief weigeren, net zoals mijn vorige over de kwestie? -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
How has global poverty changed in our lifetimes?
No matter what poverty line you choose, the share below it has declined globally. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Moynihan's Law: The greater the number of complaints one hears about human rights violations in a country, the better those rights are protected in that country.
"It is a bitter moment for the Palestinian citizens of Israel who will go to the polls on Oct. 27. We are part of a national election in a state that is practicing the most devastating war, ethnic cleansing and violence against our people since the Nakba of 1948. [...] Being a Palestinian Israeli voter is a paradox: We are asked to participate in a political system that does not treat us as an equal part of that democracy."
archive.ph/412g4 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
With enormous gratitude, Conjecture Institute is pleased to welcome our first Platinum Donor!
Their anonymous gift has already helped us bring on @mboudry as our first Senior Philosopher and taken us past halfway to our 2027 budget.
Our plans for 2027 below👇 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
El Satori @ElSatori28
"Red-Green Alliance" is not a conspiracy theory — it's official policy. Samidoun coordinator Charlotte Kates (from Lebanon, fresh from the Ayatollah’s funeral in Iran) openly calls for a full necessary alliance between Islamist Resistance and the Western revolutionary left.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Wierd Duk ܦܝܪܬ ܕܘܟ
@wierdduk
Ik sprak met @FBBlackler - vermaard kenner van de politieke islam - nav. de Franse rellen. Zij waarschuwt: "Er vormt zich een extreem gewelddadige alliantie tussen jihadisten en rode revolutionairen. Een burgeroorlog kunnen we niet langer uitsluiten": www.telegraaf.nl/binnenland/kenner-politieke-islam-waarsc…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Waarom "islamogauchisme" geen complottheorie is
Is de toenadering tussen linkse en islamitische krachten in onze samenleving, soms aangeduid als islamogauchisme, niet meer dan een ‘complottheorie’, zoals Stefaan Werbrouck (@swerbrou) schrijft in @Humo? Als auteur van meerdere academische papers over complottheorieën kan ik stellen: dat is volstrekte onzin en een misbruik van de term.
Een echte complottheorie draait om een doelbewust, geheim en snood plan waarvoor geen hard bewijs bestaat, omdat de samenzweerders het zogezegd zorgvuldig verbergen. De toenadering tussen delen van links en de islam is echter voor iedereen zichtbaar en uitvoerig gedocumenteerd. Het is geen bewuste coördinatie achter de schermen, maar een toenadering die wordt gedreven door een gedeelde vijand (het Westen en het kapitalisme) en een fikse scheut naïviteit aan linkse kant.
Linkse academici, journalisten en intellectuelen doen al decennialang hun uiterste best om elke legitieme kritiek op de islam neer te sabelen als ‘islamofobie’. Dat perfide concept moet een geloofssysteem immuniseren tegen kritiek, en ze namen het letterlijk over van islamisten. Ze verloochenen hun eigen progressieve principes door een oogje dicht te knijpen voor homohaat, vrouwenhaat, eerwraak en geweld tegen afvalligen, zolang die maar uit islamitische hoek komen. Ze herhaalden ook uitentreuren de onzin dat jihadistisch terrorisme ‘niets met de islam te maken heeft’. Al jaren zijn er demonstraties en optredens waar radicaal-linkse en islamitische groepen samen optrekken, de laatste jaren vooral rond Palestina.
In mijn boek Het verraad aan de verlichting documenteer ik uitvoerig hoe moslims uitgroeiden tot de favoriete slachtoffergroep van links: een groep die nooit of te nimmer iets verkeerd kan doen.
De sympathie is overigens veel minder wederzijds. Islamisten profiteren van de naïviteit van links en staan zij aan zij met linkse activisten op de barricaden zolang ze een gemeenschappelijke vijand delen: het kapitalisme of het Westen. Maar zodra islamisten ergens de macht grijpen, zoals in Iran, Egypte, Libanon of Palestina, worden hun linkse medestanders brutaal aan de kant geschoven en onderdrukt.
Het hoeft dus niet te verbazen dat de rellen en plunderingen in Frankrijk werden uitgevoerd door een allegaartje van radicaal-linkse activisten en Noord-Afrikaanse moslims, en dat er overal Palestijnse vlaggen wapperden. Hier en daar werden zelfs leuzen gescandeerd als ‘Dood hen in naam van Allah!’ gescandeerd, en rapsongs gezongen die de terreuraanslag op de Bataclan verheerlijkten. Links drukt deze slang al decennialang tegen de borst.
De ironie wil dat Stefaan Werbrouck zelf een treffend voorbeeld van dat islamogauchisme is: een linkse rakker die in het ooit rebelse en vrijzinnige magazine @Humo onlangs de Koran in bescherming nam tegen de beschuldiging van vrouwenhaat, en die de overduidelijke verbanden tussen het islamitische geloof en homohaat wegwuift.
Kun je je voorstellen dat iemand in Humo in de bres springt voor de Jehova’s getuigen en de Bijbel tegen kritiek in bescherming neemt? Dat is precies het soort dubbele standaard waar de term islamogauchisme naar verwijst.
Dank voor de illustratie, @Humo. Wedden dat jullie ook deze brief weigeren, net zoals mijn vorige over de kwestie?
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit dus: www.humo.be/tv/toen-mia-doornaert-in-de-afspraak-haar-com…
En eerdere Koran-apologie van @swerbrou: www.humo.be/tv/filosoof-maarten-boudry-beschuldigde-bart-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
TheJewishAlly
@TheJewishAlly
Philosopher and author Maarten Boudry posted a powerful monologue on X about the riots in Europe: “Before long, we will all know what it feels like to be Jewish. Soon, we will all know what it feels like to be Jewish. In France, they already know. This will be the punishment we deserve for abandoning the Jews, ignoring their warnings, turning against them, and even marching alongside their oppressors.”
“For three years, you useful idiots have marched with Palestinian flags, worn keffiyehs, screamed ‘From the river to the sea,’ and recognized a fictitious Palestinian state as a reward for Hamas’s October 7 massacre (yes, I’m looking at you, Emmanuel Macron). You boycotted the world’s only Jewish state, demonized the Jewish people’s right to self-determination (known as ‘Zionism’), and spread the blood libel of ‘genocide in Gaza.’”
“Did you think that if you fed the crocodile enough Jewish flesh, it would eventually be satisfied? All you did was strengthen the monster and whet its appetite even more.”
“So you were worried about ‘colonialism’? Look around. The only things suffering from colonialism here are our Western cities. The Palestinian flag has become a flag of victory, proudly flown among the ruins of historic buildings that have been looted and vandalized, a symbol of hatred toward our culture and everything it represents. It never ends with the Jews...”
@ sinaiproject @mboudry -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Kate from Kharkiv
@BohuslavskaKate
Witkoff to Putin: "You talk so much about President Trump being a humanitarian. You are a humanitarian also, sir, and I salute that. I commend you, and I thank you again."
HE MURDERS BABIES! BABIES!!! In their strollers. He murders adults too, entire families. Every day. I can't believe I'm fucking watching this! -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Andrew Fox
@Mr_Andrew_Fox
Apartheid update
Irish Independent
@Independent_ie
Explainer: Arab voter turnout could make or break Netanyahu in Israeli election www.independent.ie/world-news/explainer-arab-voter-turnou…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Mitt Romney
@MittRomney
Churchill could have shortened WW2 by years if he had just “done a deal” with Hitler. George Washington could have done a deal to end the American Revolution. Zelenskyy is in good company.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Mark Nelson
@energybants
Proud to announce what we've been working on: Prosperity One.
Site control on 4 thousand acres of extraordinary land.
It includes ultra high voltage transmission, rail, and the mighty Ohio River, and a welcoming county, making for one of the best places for nuclear on earth. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nog zo'n pseudo-analyse over de Franse rellen, compleet losgezongen van de werkelijkheid, deze keer over die andere favoriete zondebok ter linkerflank: "neoliberalisme".
Dat terwijl het overheidsbeslag in Frankrijk meer dan 57% is (!) van het BNP, met een schuldratio van 115,6%. Stilaan het nieuwe Griekenland. En ze geven nu al meer uit aan onderwijs dan gemiddeld in Europa. Maar ja, "neoliberale besparingen" zijn het probleem.
Pure waanzin. Ik sla dit soort stukken steeds meer over, het is volkomen zinloos.
"Het vervangen van de neoliberale besparingslogica door een rechtvaardige herverdeling van welvaart en door de garantie dat er opnieuw zal worden geïnvesteerd in de domeinen die mensen sociale erkenning, bestaanszekerheid en lotsverbetering bieden, is de weg naar democratisch herstel."
www.demorgen.be/meningen/frankrijk-zit-geklemd-tussen-woe…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Academici en klassieke media lijken echt in een parallel universum te leven. Volgens deze ‘analyse’ zijn de massale plunderingen en brandstichtingen in Frankrijk — letterlijk onder Palestijnse vlaggen, met steun van antifa en Greta Thunberg, gepleegd door voornamelijk Noord-Afrikaanse jongeren — de schuld van… radicaal-rechts en Marine Le Pen. 🤯
Werkelijk verbijsterend. Doe geen moeite, @hendrikvos: Le Pen zal ook wel de verkiezingen winnen zónder uw nijvere inspanningen. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Mossadil Commentary
@MOSSADil
Israel has spent years trying to explain to the world what it has been dealing with. Maybe our most effective PR campaign was never going to come from Israel at all.
Maybe it’s this...👇 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Eric Anceau
@Eric_Anceau
Entre Lola-Fleur, jeune idéologue bourgeoise qui ne connaît rien de la vie mais donne des leçons à tout le monde et Jehmima née au Congo, arrivée en France à 5 ans, ayant vécu dans 10m2 et devenue cheffe d'entreprise, inutile de vous dire ma préférence !
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I love this Grand Theory by @etiennefd: “There are many kinds of gay people, but, fundamentally, only one kind of straight people.” Properly understood, and for good evolutionary reasons, I think he’s right. 😉 substacktools.com/sharex/YDJtkOc5
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I'm immensely proud to be the first Senior Philosopher at the Conjecture Institute! At @ConjectureInst, we're dedicated followers of Karl Popper and @DavidDeutschOxf, championing bold conjectures and ruthless refutations. They hired me in a heartbeat—but if I turn out to be wrong about something (or everything), they should kick me straight back out. As fallibilists, we learn from our mistakes! 😉
"Let our hypotheses die in our stead!"
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
Conjecture Institute is thrilled to welcome our first Senior Philosopher: @mboudry!
Dr. Boudry is a philosopher of science and first holder of the Etienne Vermeersch Chair of Critical Thinking at Ghent University.
He has published over 50 academic papers and co-edited two volumes: Science Unlimited? and Philosophy of Pseudoscience.
He has also written six trade books in Dutch on science and philosophy.
Boudry's book, The Betrayal of Enlightenment, will be published by @PitchstoneBooks.
He’s also a @rootsofprogress fellow and a regular contributor to @Quillette, @JoinPersuasion, @ConversationUS, @Independent, and @HumanProgress. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Masih Alinejad
@AlinejadMasih
Emotional moment two women blinded under Islamic regimes meeting each other for the first time.
Fahimeh is from Afghanistan. Her husband threw acid on her face because she was fighting for women's rights against the Taliban. As her face burned, he told her: now I have taken your eyes and your face, people will be scared of you, so I dare you to go out and talk to people.
I invited her to come on stage with me and talk directly to thousands of people in Poland.
She met Kosar, an Iranian woman who was blinded by the Islamic Republic during the Woman life Freedom uprising.
We are now together stepping into Jewish history in Poland, including Auschwitz, and understanding the connection between the Holocaust and the Islamic Republic’s massacre on 2026.
If any of you think it’s easy to live under Islamic republic or Taliban just listened to their stories.
These women are not fighting for themselves. They are fighting to protect democracy everywhere from the most dangerous cancer, which is called Islamism.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Hillary Clinton
@HillaryClinton
Ten years ago today.
In just the last few days: Trump made a deal for the U.S. to buy Russian diesel, an economic lifeline for Putin; he and Elon Musk blamed each other for an order that slowed down Starlink satellite connectivity over Ukraine, hampering the country's defenses during a devastating Russian attack; and Trump waived sanctions on Russia that Congress, led by his late friend Lindsey Graham, had pushed for.
Now, Putin has proposed a summit with Trump and Xi to decide Ukraine’s fate for them, bulldoze a century of international cooperation, and frame Russia as an equal to the U.S. and China.
We’ll see if Putin’s puppet continues to dance on his strings.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Love Animals❤️
@GuGi263
Keith Jarrett’s solo performance of “Over the Rainbow” in Tokyo in 1984 is widely regarded as one of the most outstanding and moving piano solo covers of all time. Rather than simply restating the familiar melody, the legendary pianist infused the piece with new life through his brilliant improvisation, refined harmonic structure, and profound emotional depth.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Noa Tishby
@noatishby
Last year I was attacked in Paris by a pro-Hamas hate mob. They were screaming “F*** Israel, F*** USA”. This hate and violence was spreading like wildfire.
And now, the same mob is waving the same flags and chanting the same chants while Paris burns.
This was never just about Israel. It was never just about Jews. This is a war on the West and the freedom and values we hold dear. I said it then and I’ll say it again: wake up. This has to be stopped.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Academici en klassieke media lijken echt in een parallel universum te leven. Volgens deze ‘analyse’ zijn de massale plunderingen en brandstichtingen in Frankrijk — letterlijk onder Palestijnse vlaggen, met steun van antifa en Greta Thunberg, gepleegd door voornamelijk Noord-Afrikaanse jongeren — de schuld van… radicaal-rechts en Marine Le Pen. 🤯
Werkelijk verbijsterend. Doe geen moeite, @hendrikvos: Le Pen zal ook wel de verkiezingen winnen zónder uw nijvere inspanningen. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What this assistant professor of religion at @haverfordedu has posted is simply unacceptable. It’s very unfortunate that he targeted “Jews” rather than “Zionists,” as he should have. Had he made that crucial distinction, there would be nothing to object to. Everything else is hunky-dory in academia, folks.
“The jews are angry because the world has woken up and realized Hitler was right all along.”
“Our society must be cleansed of the jewish filth.”
“The goyim have woken up, jew. Run. Flee. Leave.”
“Lower Merion will be cleansed of the jew filth.”
“We can make you into candles to celebrate the complete elimination of the jews.”
“What flavor would you like for the gas we will be using?”
“Go get fucked, fat jew pig.”
“Even a mild holocaust will put the American economy in a much better position. Deal with the jews first.”
freebeacon.substack.com/p/hitler-was-right-all-along-have… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Sam
@Sam_kuyp
It's great to have @mboudry, a deeply thoughtful and insightful writer, as part of CI.
I recently attended a wonderful talk he gave about his book The Betrayal of the Enlightenment. It was refreshing to hear a philosopher defend progress so unequivocally.
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
Conjecture Institute is thrilled to welcome our first Senior Philosopher: @mboudry!
Dr. Boudry is a philosopher of science and first holder of the Etienne Vermeersch Chair of Critical Thinking at Ghent University.
He has published over 50 academic papers and co-edited two volumes: Science Unlimited? and Philosophy of Pseudoscience.
He has also written six trade books in Dutch on science and philosophy.
Boudry's book, The Betrayal of Enlightenment, will be published by @PitchstoneBooks.
He’s also a @rootsofprogress fellow and a regular contributor to @Quillette, @JoinPersuasion, @ConversationUS, @Independent, and @HumanProgress. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
We will all soon know what it feels like to be Jewish. In France, they already do.
It will be our just deserts for having abandoned the Jews, ignored their warnings, turned against them, and even marched alongside their oppressors.
For three years, you useful idiots have been parading Palestinian flags, sporting keffiyehs, screaming “From the River to the Sea”, and recognizing a fictitious Palestinian state as a reward for Hamas’s October 7 massacre (looking at you, @EmmanuelMacron). You have boycotted the only Jewish state in the world, vilified the Jewish people’s right to self-determination (aka “Zionism”), and spread the “Gaza genocide” blood libel.
Did you really think that if you fed the crocodile enough Jewish flesh, it would eventually be satiated? All you have done is embolden the monster and whet its appetite.
So you were worried about “colonization”? Look around. The only thing being colonized here are our own Western cities. The Palestinian flag has become a victory banner, proudly waved amid the ruins of looted and vandalized historic buildings—a symbol of hatred for our civilization and everything it stands for.
It never ends with the Jews.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
One of the pictures below (top left) appears to have been AI-generated; the other three are real. I chose the images purely for illustrative purposes, but I should have checked them more carefully. My apologies!
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
We will all soon know what it feels like to be Jewish. In France, they already do.
It will be our just deserts for having abandoned the Jews, ignored their warnings, turned against them, and even marched alongside their oppressors.
For three years, you useful idiots have been parading Palestinian flags, sporting keffiyehs, screaming “From the River to the Sea”, and recognizing a fictitious Palestinian state as a reward for Hamas’s October 7 massacre (looking at you, @EmmanuelMacron). You have boycotted the only Jewish state in the world, vilified the Jewish people’s right to self-determination (aka “Zionism”), and spread the “Gaza genocide” blood libel.
Did you really think that if you fed the crocodile enough Jewish flesh, it would eventually be satiated? All you have done is embolden the monster and whet its appetite.
So you were worried about “colonization”? Look around. The only thing being colonized here are our own Western cities. The Palestinian flag has become a victory banner, proudly waved amid the ruins of looted and vandalized historic buildings—a symbol of hatred for our civilization and everything it stands for.
It never ends with the Jews. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Israël en français
@IsraelenFR
🇮🇱🔬 À 16 ans, il possède déjà deux doctorats. Et pour poursuivre ses recherches, il a choisi Israël !
Voici Laurent Simons, un jeune prodige belge au parcours scientifique exceptionnel.
À seulement 6 ans, il terminait l’école primaire. À 8 ans, ses études secondaires. À 11 ans, il obtenait sa licence universitaire, puis son master à 12 ans.
Aujourd’hui âgé de 16 ans, il est déjà titulaire de deux doctorats, en physique quantique et en sciences médicales. Son nom figure également parmi les auteurs d’une étude publiée en 2026 dans la prestigieuse revue scientifique Nature.
🎓 Sa prochaine étape ? Rejoindre les laboratoires de recherche de l’université Bar-Ilan, en Israël, pour poursuivre ses travaux scientifiques.
Un choix motivé par l’excellence de la recherche israélienne dans les domaines qui le passionnent.
💙 Une belle illustration du rayonnement international des universités israéliennes, qui continuent d’attirer des talents scientifiques exceptionnels venus du monde entier.
📸 Laurent Simons aux côtés de David Saranga, ambassadeur d’israël en Belgique
@DavidSaranga
@IsraelinBelgium -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
One of the pictures below (top left) appears to have been AI-generated; the other three are real. I chose the images purely for illustrative purposes, but I should have checked them more carefully. My apologies!
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
We will all soon know what it feels like to be Jewish. In France, they already do.
It will be our just deserts for having abandoned the Jews, ignored their warnings, turned against them, and even marched alongside their oppressors.
For three years, you useful idiots have been parading Palestinian flags, sporting keffiyehs, screaming “From the River to the Sea”, and recognizing a fictitious Palestinian state as a reward for Hamas’s October 7 massacre (looking at you, @EmmanuelMacron). You have boycotted the only Jewish state in the world, vilified the Jewish people’s right to self-determination (aka “Zionism”), and spread the “Gaza genocide” blood libel.
Did you really think that if you fed the crocodile enough Jewish flesh, it would eventually be satiated? All you have done is embolden the monster and whet its appetite.
So you were worried about “colonization”? Look around. The only thing being colonized here are our own Western cities. The Palestinian flag has become a victory banner, proudly waved amid the ruins of looted and vandalized historic buildings—a symbol of hatred for our civilization and everything it stands for.
It never ends with the Jews. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
Conjecture Institute is thrilled to welcome our first Senior Philosopher: @mboudry!
Dr. Boudry is a philosopher of science and first holder of the Etienne Vermeersch Chair of Critical Thinking at Ghent University.
He has published over 50 academic papers and co-edited two volumes: Science Unlimited? and Philosophy of Pseudoscience.
He has also written six trade books in Dutch on science and philosophy.
Boudry's book, The Betrayal of Enlightenment, will be published by @PitchstoneBooks.
He’s also a @rootsofprogress fellow and a regular contributor to @Quillette, @JoinPersuasion, @ConversationUS, @Independent, and @HumanProgress. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Pepel Klaasa
@pepel_klaasa
In a nutshell
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Bijzonder schadelijk dat het @_knaw de centrale waarde van "waarheidsvinding" in wetenschap steeds meer op het achterplan plaatst, ten voordele van vage begrippen als "eerlijkheid", "transparantie" en het onvermijdelijke "inclusie". Geloof je dat het zo'n vaart niet loopt? Lees dit onthullende stuk van @HofhuisSteije, waarin hij beleidsdocumenten van KNAW door de tijd heen vergelijkt. hofhuis.substack.com/p/wat-is-er-gebeurd-met-de-waarheids…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"A world in which the White House is allied to the Kremlin was, until now, the stuff of paranoid fiction. Manchurian candidates and red presidents were fantasies, dark tales that Americans told themselves, like ghost stories around a campfire. But this alliance now exists."
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The sheer stupidity of Western leaders like @EmmanuelMacron recognizing a fictitious state — with no agreed borders, no territorial integrity, no political cohesion, and no sovereignty — as a reward for a massive terrorist attack and decades of Palestinian rejectionism. While Israel is holding democratic elections, Palestinian leaders are cancelling theirs for the umpteenth time, reneging on their promise to France. And why not? France is weak anyway.
"In exchange for recognition of Palestinian statehood last year, Mr. Abbas had promised French President @EmmanuelMacron that he would hold elections in 2026 at last. Sometimes leaders and nations want to be lied to. [...] Weak at home, Mr. Macron touted this as a major breakthrough abroad. “In light of the commitments you have made,” he wrote, “France will proceed with the full recognition of Palestine.”"
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
We will all soon know what it feels like to be Jewish. In France, they already do.
It will be our just deserts for having abandoned the Jews, ignored their warnings, turned against them, and even marched alongside their oppressors.
For three years, you useful idiots have been parading Palestinian flags, sporting keffiyehs, screaming “From the River to the Sea”, and recognizing a fictitious Palestinian state as a reward for Hamas’s October 7 massacre (looking at you, @EmmanuelMacron). You have boycotted the only Jewish state in the world, vilified the Jewish people’s right to self-determination (aka “Zionism”), and spread the “Gaza genocide” blood libel.
Did you really think that if you fed the crocodile enough Jewish flesh, it would eventually be satiated? All you have done is embolden the monster and whet its appetite.
So you were worried about “colonization”? Look around. The only thing being colonized here are our own Western cities. The Palestinian flag has become a victory banner, proudly waved amid the ruins of looted and vandalized historic buildings—a symbol of hatred for our civilization and everything it stands for.
It never ends with the Jews. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The Palestinian flag is becoming a symbol of mindless destruction, looting, and wanton violence. How do those who (pretend to) care about the Palestinian cause feel about that? Most don't give a peep.
Meet John Aziz (@aziz0nomics), a lone dissenter who forcefully condemns the desecration of the Palestinian flag by people using it as a prop for criminality. Unlike them, he actually cares about Palestinians (he is one himself):
"As a Palestinian, I find it absolutely disgusting and unfair to see these people waving Palestinian flags while committing violent and criminal acts. Looting a Playstation 5 or a Louis Vuitton bag does nothing whatsoever to help Palestinians."
substacktools.com/sharex/-CAaKx-O -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What this assistant professor of religion at @haverfordedu has posted is simply unacceptable. It’s very unfortunate that he targeted “Jews” rather than “Zionists,” as he should have. Had he made that crucial distinction, there would be nothing to object to. Everything else is hunky-dory in academia, folks.
“The jews are angry because the world has woken up and realized Hitler was right all along.”
“Our society must be cleansed of the jewish filth.”
“The goyim have woken up, jew. Run. Flee. Leave.”
“Lower Merion will be cleansed of the jew filth.”
“We can make you into candles to celebrate the complete elimination of the jews.”
“What flavor would you like for the gas we will be using?”
“Go get fucked, fat jew pig.”
“Even a mild holocaust will put the American economy in a much better position. Deal with the jews first.”
freebeacon.substack.com/p/hitler-was-right-all-along-have… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Sebastian Kurz
@sebastiankurz
For more than a week, we have seen increasingly disturbing images from France and elsewhere in Europe: burning town halls, looted shops and brutal violence.
What has been portrayed as “student protests” increasingly resembles scenes from a civil war.
Behind the mob, there is an uncanny alliance: well-organised left-wing extremists and political Islam. Two movements that could hardly be more different - but united in their rejection of our free and open society.
Both are enemies of the Enlightenment. The far left likes to present itself as its guardian. Yet it marches side by side with those who reject freedom of speech and everything a liberal society stands for.
Beyond the violence itself, what is most shocking is the unwillingness to acknowledge what is happening, or even the apparent attempt to conceal the truth by many.
The violence we are witnessing has nothing to do with legitimate student protest. To me, these scenes reflect the consequences of nearly two decades of failed migration policy.
Unless we change course immediately, we risk seeing the same scenes soon in Berlin, Vienna and Munich.
For years, Hungary and other Central European countries have faced harsh criticism from their Western European neighbours over their approach to migration. Today, Budapest, Warsaw and Prague stand out as islands of calm.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
We will all soon know what it feels like to be Jewish. In France, they already do.
It will be our just deserts for having abandoned the Jews, ignored their warnings, turned against them, and even marched alongside their oppressors.
For three years, you useful idiots have been parading Palestinian flags, sporting keffiyehs, screaming “From the River to the Sea”, and recognizing a fictitious Palestinian state as a reward for Hamas’s October 7 massacre (looking at you, @EmmanuelMacron). You have boycotted the only Jewish state in the world, vilified the Jewish people’s right to self-determination (aka “Zionism”), and spread the “Gaza genocide” blood libel.
Did you really think that if you fed the crocodile enough Jewish flesh, it would eventually be satiated? All you have done is embolden the monster and whet its appetite.
So you were worried about “colonization”? Look around. The only thing being colonized here are our own Western cities. The Palestinian flag has become a victory banner, proudly waved amid the ruins of looted and vandalized historic buildings—a symbol of hatred for our civilization and everything it stands for.
It never ends with the Jews. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Donald Tusk
@donaldtusk
Polska nie powtórzy błędów innych europejskich państw, nie będzie też za nie płacić. Twardo bronimy granicy przed nielegalną migracją, mamy własną politykę azylową (nie przyjmujemy wniosków), deportujemy tych, którzy łamią polskie prawo. W kwestii bezpieczeństwa będziemy bezwzględni. To usłyszeli ode mnie liderzy Europy w Brukseli.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Shermin Amiri
@SherminAmiri
Is dit de faillietverklaring van het westerse integratiebeleid?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Simon Schama
@simon_schama
pretty much clinches it for le Pen
Eylon Levy
@EylonALevy
This looks more like an Islamist insurrection than a protest for nicer classrooms.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Every time I receive a message like this, my heart breaks. Within seconds, however, sadness gives way to immense anger at the cowardice of the political and intellectual elites who have allowed this rerun of the 1930s to happen.
Especially the “progressive” ones, who are blind to the resurgence of Jew-hatred just because its newest purveyors are (mostly) not white and not European. And yes, I'm sorry to say, that includes everyone who has given oxygen to the modern blood libel of “genocide”, a blatant form of Holocaust inversion.
This man is the grandson of a Holocaust survivor, a doctor who fears he may be the last generation of his family to live in Belgium. Meanwhile, we let in tens of thousands of Jew-haters who despise our civilization and contribute precisely nothing to it.
Remember: it won't end with the Jews. It never does.
***
Fri 9 Oct, 12:50 (6 days ago)
Dear Mr Boudry,
I’d like to thank you for your clarity of thought and for the many times you have spoken out against antisemitism that has become so pervasive in our democracies.
This is by no means a recent phenomenon, but I am deeply concerned about my future as a Jew in my own country, Belgium.
Throughout history, Jews have repeatedly been treated as foreigners in countries where they had lived long before those who eventually considered them as "foreigners". Jewish communities had existed for over a thousand years in Poland, Yemen and elsewhere. And what remains of them today? Barely a trace.
Today, I can no longer tell whether politicians from parties such as the PS, PTB, Ecolo and others make or endorse antisemitic statements out of sheer electoral calculation or because they genuinely believe in what they are saying.
What is democracy? Simply the majority + 1. Unfortunately, demographic trends do not favour Jews. And we must be able to say this without being labelled xenophobic: there is a deeply ingrained antisemitism among many of our fellow muslim citizens (cf testimonies among others of Ismaël Saidi).
My grandparents, who immigrated from Poland, were Belgian and proud to be so. My grandfather, an Auschwitz survivor, changed his name after the war because he no longer wanted a Polish-sounding name. He arrived in Belgium at the age of six months and graduated as a medical doctor from the Université Libre de Bruxelles, he was een « echte Brusseleir », deeply attached to Belgium, his country. And yet, today, I am afraid.
Do we, as Belgian Jews, still have a future here in Europe, in our own countries? Because yes, Belgium is my country. I am increasingly doubtful, and that saddens me profoundly. I am the third generation of Belgian Jewish doctors in my family, and perhaps the last one to live here in Brussels/Belgium.
I sincerely hope that you will succeed in convincing our fellow citizens who are not directly affected by antisemitism that “it starts with the Jews, it never ends with the Jews.”
Please accept my deepest respect and appreciation.
Dr [XXX],
Grandson of Holocaust survivors -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I can't believe The Free Press (@TheFP) published this atrocious piece denouncing Europe's "war fever":
"There is, I suspect, a hunger for existential purpose—for a great war that will return these mediocrities and their peoples to the heights of history and restore the epic dimension to everyday life. Russia and Putin, the ancient foe and the perfect villain, may fulfill this primal need."
Yeah, right. I suppose Georgians, Chechens, and Ukrainians were also hankering for "existential purpose" when their countries were invaded by Russia. They were just "looking for a perfect villain", and it turned into a self-fulfilling prophecy.
As for Europe at large, nothing could be further from the truth. For well over a decade, Western European elites have shown a profound reluctance to confront Russian aggression.
"Europe is utterly unprepared for a war that probably won’t happen in any case."
So Europe is supposedly gripped by "war fever," yet somehow remains "utterly unprepared" for war. In reality, Europe is so woefully unprepared precisely because of its chronic blindness to the possibility of war—the very opposite of "war fever."
And it is precisely this unpreparedness, coupled with Europe's persistent unwillingness to stand up to Putin's provocations, that risks making war more likely. Putin has every reason to believe that we simply don't have the stomach for a fight.
"Constant predictions of war, whether sincere or cynical, may give war a certain inevitability when hard decisions are faced."
No. What brings war closer is the persistent insistence that it is just a fantasy of febrile minds, that it could never happen here. A healthy dose of "war fever" is precisely what might help keep the real war at bay.
www.thefp.com/p/war-spreading-europe-russia-ukraine -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"In 1918, the Soviets created an entire branch of their government solely for cool Jews, whose paid job was to persecute the uncool ones. This was called the Yevsektsiya, or the Jewish Sections of the Communist Party, and in their brief and bloody lifespan, one finds the origins of today’s supposedly novel concept: Jews who are of course not anti-Semitic (how could they be? they’re Jews!), but simply anti-Zionist. In the course of not being anti-Semitic and being simply anti-Zionist, the Yevsektsiya managed to persecute, imprison, torture, and murder thousands of Jews, until their leaders were themselves purged."
www.tabletmag.com/sections/arts-letters/articles/the-cool… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Tesla
@Tesla
Do a kickflip!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Wierd Duk ܦܝܪܬ ܕܘܟ
@wierdduk
Marlies in gesprek met de altijd interessante en intelligente @mboudry over de kwalen van deze tijd: "Is de Westerse samenleving kwaadaardig?'': youtu.be/oSfSiDqJo8Y via @YouTube
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Is er nu werkelijk geen enkele krant of tv-zender die het vertrek van Joodse wetenschappers, intellectuelen en artsen uit België de moeite van het vermelden waard vindt? Dit is al minstens de derde keer dat ik zulke anonieme getuigenissen deel van Joden die hun valiezen pakken of dat ernstig overwegen. Ik herhaal: er is een exodus aan de gang binnen de Joodse gemeenschap, omdat mensen vrezen voor hun eigen leven en dat van hun kinderen. Omdat ze op straat worden uitgescholden en bespuwd. Omdat ze geen keppeltje meer durven dragen, of zich in bepaalde wijken vertonen. Omdat universiteiten worden overgenomen door agressieve activisten en islamisten die hen dwingen om het "zionisme" ritueel te veroordelen.
Nobody gives a fuck?
En ondertussen maar jeremiëren over een moslima die zich ‘onderdrukt’ voelt omdat haar werkgever haar ocharme vraagt haar hoofddoek af te zetten op de werkvloer. En ondertussen maar naarstig praktijktests uitvoeren die zouden aantonen dat ‘Mohammed’ net iets minder kans maakt op de huurmarkt. Dáár staan de kranten vol van.
Het moet hier nogal een hellegat zijn voor moslims, als ze nog steeds in drommen van tienduizenden onze contreien opzoeken om hier te mogen leven. Hebben moskeeën permanente beveiliging nodig? Pakken moslims hier hun biezen omdat de "islamofobie" uit de hand loopt? Natuurlijk niet. Moslims worden juist met fluwelen handschoenen aangepakt in de meeste sectoren. Tijdens hun massale demonstraties voelen zelfs de meest agressieve islamisten zich hier koning te rijk. Niemand legt hen een strobreed in de weg.
Als moslims ook maar een fractie zouden meemaken van wat de Joodse gemeenschap nu te verduren krijgt, zou het elke dag op de voorpagina’s staan. Woke activisten, vermomd als academici, zouden het ene na het andere verontwaardigde stuk schrijven over het oprukkende ‘racisme’ en ‘xenofobie’ in onze samenleving.
Maar antisemitisme? Tja, die Joden hebben het toch ook een beetje aan zichzelf te danken. En ze zijn eigenlijk ‘wit’, dus kunnen ze niet echt slachtoffer zijn.
Wraakroepend, vind ik dit.
x.com/mboudry/status/2105626184474087869
x.com/mboudry/status/2041510819720991167
x.com/mboudry/status/1998497157448614267
@deafspraaktv @DeTafelvanGert @detijd @destandaard @HLN_BE @demorgen @Nieuwsblad_be
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Every time I receive a message like this, my heart breaks. Within seconds, however, sadness gives way to immense anger at the cowardice of the political and intellectual elites who have allowed this rerun of the 1930s to happen.
Especially the “progressive” ones, who are blind to the resurgence of Jew-hatred just because its newest purveyors are (mostly) not white and not European. And yes, I'm sorry to say, that includes everyone who has given oxygen to the modern blood libel of “genocide”, a blatant form of Holocaust inversion.
This man is the grandson of a Holocaust survivor, a doctor who fears he may be the last generation of his family to live in Belgium. Meanwhile, we let in tens of thousands of Jew-haters who despise our civilization and contribute precisely nothing to it.
Remember: it won't end with the Jews. It never does.
***
Fri 9 Oct, 12:50 (6 days ago)
Dear Mr Boudry,
I’d like to thank you for your clarity of thought and for the many times you have spoken out against antisemitism that has become so pervasive in our democracies.
This is by no means a recent phenomenon, but I am deeply concerned about my future as a Jew in my own country, Belgium.
Throughout history, Jews have repeatedly been treated as foreigners in countries where they had lived long before those who eventually considered them as "foreigners". Jewish communities had existed for over a thousand years in Poland, Yemen and elsewhere. And what remains of them today? Barely a trace.
Today, I can no longer tell whether politicians from parties such as the PS, PTB, Ecolo and others make or endorse antisemitic statements out of sheer electoral calculation or because they genuinely believe in what they are saying.
What is democracy? Simply the majority + 1. Unfortunately, demographic trends do not favour Jews. And we must be able to say this without being labelled xenophobic: there is a deeply ingrained antisemitism among many of our fellow muslim citizens (cf testimonies among others of Ismaël Saidi).
My grandparents, who immigrated from Poland, were Belgian and proud to be so. My grandfather, an Auschwitz survivor, changed his name after the war because he no longer wanted a Polish-sounding name. He arrived in Belgium at the age of six months and graduated as a medical doctor from the Université Libre de Bruxelles, he was een « echte Brusseleir », deeply attached to Belgium, his country. And yet, today, I am afraid.
Do we, as Belgian Jews, still have a future here in Europe, in our own countries? Because yes, Belgium is my country. I am increasingly doubtful, and that saddens me profoundly. I am the third generation of Belgian Jewish doctors in my family, and perhaps the last one to live here in Brussels/Belgium.
I sincerely hope that you will succeed in convincing our fellow citizens who are not directly affected by antisemitism that “it starts with the Jews, it never ends with the Jews.”
Please accept my deepest respect and appreciation.
Dr [XXX],
Grandson of Holocaust survivors -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Marc Van Ranst heeft zich duidelijk herpakt, 100% Human deze keer. Goed bezig, Marc!😉 krant.demorgen.be/titles/demorgen/7927/publications/2889/…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
OMG, ik heb nu even de laatste vijf columns van @vanranstmarc door Pangram gehaald, en die zijn allemaal door AI geschreven, op één na. Ik heb @vanranstmarc, die anders niet bepaald op zijn mond is gevallen, nog nooit zó stil geweten, en ik begin te begrijpen waarom.
Betaalt @demorgen jou voor deze AI-slop, Marc? Wees toch eens eerlijk: hoe schakel je precies AI in voor je column? Ben je bereid je prompts te delen? Of ga je ontkennen dat je AI hebt gebruikt, lijnrecht tegen wat "de wetenschap" hierover zegt? (zie studie van VUB-collega's, die zegt dat valse positieven bij Pangram extreem onwaarschijnlijk zijn: link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40979-026-00226-w ). -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Every time I receive a message like this, my heart breaks. Within seconds, however, sadness gives way to immense anger at the cowardice of the political and intellectual elites who have allowed this rerun of the 1930s to happen.
Especially the “progressive” ones, who are blind to the resurgence of Jew-hatred just because its newest purveyors are (mostly) not white and not European. And yes, I'm sorry to say, that includes everyone who has given oxygen to the modern blood libel of “genocide”, a blatant form of Holocaust inversion.
This man is the grandson of a Holocaust survivor, a doctor who fears he may be the last generation of his family to live in Belgium. Meanwhile, we let in tens of thousands of Jew-haters who despise our civilization and contribute precisely nothing to it.
Remember: it won't end with the Jews. It never does.
***
Fri 9 Oct, 12:50 (6 days ago)
Dear Mr Boudry,
I’d like to thank you for your clarity of thought and for the many times you have spoken out against antisemitism that has become so pervasive in our democracies.
This is by no means a recent phenomenon, but I am deeply concerned about my future as a Jew in my own country, Belgium.
Throughout history, Jews have repeatedly been treated as foreigners in countries where they had lived long before those who eventually considered them as "foreigners". Jewish communities had existed for over a thousand years in Poland, Yemen and elsewhere. And what remains of them today? Barely a trace.
Today, I can no longer tell whether politicians from parties such as the PS, PTB, Ecolo and others make or endorse antisemitic statements out of sheer electoral calculation or because they genuinely believe in what they are saying.
What is democracy? Simply the majority + 1. Unfortunately, demographic trends do not favour Jews. And we must be able to say this without being labelled xenophobic: there is a deeply ingrained antisemitism among many of our fellow muslim citizens (cf testimonies among others of Ismaël Saidi).
My grandparents, who immigrated from Poland, were Belgian and proud to be so. My grandfather, an Auschwitz survivor, changed his name after the war because he no longer wanted a Polish-sounding name. He arrived in Belgium at the age of six months and graduated as a medical doctor from the Université Libre de Bruxelles, he was een « echte Brusseleir », deeply attached to Belgium, his country. And yet, today, I am afraid.
Do we, as Belgian Jews, still have a future here in Europe, in our own countries? Because yes, Belgium is my country. I am increasingly doubtful, and that saddens me profoundly. I am the third generation of Belgian Jewish doctors in my family, and perhaps the last one to live here in Brussels/Belgium.
I sincerely hope that you will succeed in convincing our fellow citizens who are not directly affected by antisemitism that “it starts with the Jews, it never ends with the Jews.”
Please accept my deepest respect and appreciation.
Dr [XXX],
Grandson of Holocaust survivors -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Exact location shared with registered attendees before the event."
How awful that peaceful pro-Palestinian activists have to hide from murderous Zionists!
Just kidding, of course it's the other way around. It's always Jews and Israelis who have to hide, and deep down you know this. But you’ve just grown so accustomed to it that you no longer notice.
(I'll be speaking there. And don't fucking complain about Sam Van Rooy. If politicians from other parties were not such spineless cowards, we wouldn't need @SamvanRooy1 to stand up for Jews and Israel.)
why-israel-leuven.vercel.app -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Is de westerse samenleving kwaadaardig?" En waarom zijn juist linkse denkers daarvan overtuigd, terwijl de westerse beschaving — met de Verlichting als keerpunt — letterlijk het beste is wat de mensheid ooit is overkomen? Waarom hebben progressieven zich afgekeerd van vooruitgang, in plaats van haar te omarmen en te vieren? Fijn gesprek over mijn boek en nog veel meer, met @marliesdekkers van @De_NieuweWereld.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=oSfSiDqJo8Y -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
If this is true it's a level of evil that's really, really hard to imagine. It's not a good-faith question about how much we should fund Ukraine or what realistic endgame goals are. It's choosing to put innocent civilians in harm's way. I hope there are investigations.
CBS News
@CBSNews
The U.S. may have intentionally withheld early warnings this week of Russian strikes on Ukraine, multiple sources familiar with the matter told CBS News. www.cbsnews.com/news/us-ukraine-intelligence-russia-war-m…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Christopher Miller
@ChristopherJM
NEW: Ukrainian troops have been caught off guard by restrictions on Elon Musk’s Starlink satellite internet systems that disrupted frontline operations, as Kyiv received no advance warning from its partners of a Russian missile attack on its energy facilities for the second day running, Ukrainian officials and troops tell @FT.
www.ft.com/content/37085602-726a-44dc-a859-51caab38eb75?s… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
De Nieuwe Wereld
@De_NieuweWereld
‘’Is de Westerse Samenleving Kwaadaardig?'' | Bekijk de aflevering met Maarten Boudry en Marlies Dekkers nu op YouTube
youtu.be/oSfSiDqJo8Y -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Hillel Fuld
@HilzFuld
Oh, wow, this is one of @benshapiro’s strongest monologues ever. Watch this. Pure clarity.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wie gelooft dat Griet Vandermassen een haatzaaister en "TERF" is, nodig ik uit om mijn interview met haar bij Verboden Terrein (@Ugent) te bekijken. In het transdebat komt de blinde haat doorgaans van beide kanten, maar zeker niét van Griet, één van de meest genuanceerde en empathische mensen die ik ken. www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hpgge18V1EE&list=PLyLVVenmH6vipo2…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A moving report by @mboudry: An Army of Yesterday’s Civilians: Ukraine and the Fight for Freedom quillette.substack.com/p/an-army-of-yesterdays-civilians-…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Street Smart
@StreetSmart_x
I'm An Arab Muslim Who Lives In Israel. Ask Me Anything
He grew up in Israel, worked in the Knesset and Israeli media, and takes New Yorkers' questions on apartheid claims and who called him slurs growing up.
#israeli #zionism #standwithisrael #proisrael #westandwithisraelThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Brick Suit
@Brick_Suit
🧱BRICKING NEWS🧱
England:
Tiger whose life was spared after he killed a man that entered his enclosure, will now be put to death after British police discover the tiger made posts critical of islam on social media. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Simon Schama
@simon_schama
Instant loss of any authority or credibility whatsoever.
Aizenberg
@Aizenberg55
10/7 is erased. Entire incident is presented as an Israeli attack, the reader won't know what happened. Hamas is erased too. They do not exist in the report. They are only even mentioned first 8 pages deep, and only and always in the context of Israeli claims & statements. 2/
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Hillel Fuld
@HilzFuld
Uh huh
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is the most disgusting betrayal of Ukraine since Zelensky’s dressing-down in the White House. And that was largely a symbolic humiliation. Here, Trump is actually stabbing Zelensky in the back, cutting deals with Putin for personal gain.
As @davidfrum writes, this will enrich Trump and his corrupt cronies, but it won’t even benefit him politically: it won’t make a dent in diesel prices. It’s simply a huge win for Putin and an unmitigated disaster for Ukraine.
You’re despicable, @realDonaldTrump.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/10/trumps-diesel-deal-sell…
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/10/trumps-diesel-deal-sell… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Gerard Govers
@gerardgovers
Griet Vandermassen heeft het nu, alvast volgens de Hate Review van de Belgische vzw Forbidden Colours, ook officieel tot TERF geschopt. Dat is niet iets om blij van te worden, integendeel. De morele grandstanding en biofobie die hiertoe leiden maken een gezond debat over gender onmogelijk.
www.standaard.be/opinies/wie-is-er-antigender/162896120.html -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Philippe Clerick @PhilippeClerick
Clericks Weblog:
* Boudry over zijn Oekraïne-bezoek
* Impressies - beschouwingen - gesprekken
* Vechten of niet vechten?
* Waarom het reisverslag een beetje lijkt op dat van de vroegere fellow-travelers.
philippeclerick.blogspot.com/2026/10/boudry-over-zijn-oek… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Hillel Neuer
@HillelNeuer
“Hamas celebrates Nobel Peace Prize to Navi Pillay”
Mission accomplished, @NobelPrize — your intended message was perfectly received.
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The Norwegian Nobel Committee has decided to award the 2026 #nobelpeaceprize to Navanethem “Navi” Pillay for her efforts to promote peace and international law.
#nobelprize -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I'm not Jewish.
I was raised Catholic in Belgium.
I became a die-hard atheist at around twelve.
I'm a Zionist.
Lawrence Hakiwai (Father/of two)
@SonofOmahu
I'm not Jewish.
I'm Maori.
I'm a New Zealander.
And I'm a Zionist.
Reuben Silby
@reubensilby
I'm not Jewish. I'm a New Zealander. And I'm a Zionist.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I'm not Jewish. I'm Belgian (with a dash of North-African DNA). And I'm a proud Zionist. Why?
Because among the world’s many nationalisms, Zionism has historically been one of the most benign, inclusive, and progressive.
Because if any people on earth has earned a country of its own after centuries of persecution and slaughter, it’s the Jews. And Israel is their historical homeland, the land from which they were driven by a long succession of conquerors and empires.
Because I have enormous admiration for Jewish cultural and intellectual achievement, and a commensurate understanding of the resentment and envy this has stirred up among the less accomplished. Without a state of their own, Jews will keep being hunted down and killed by those who hate them.
And because I can’t stand dishonesty, lies, and hypocrisy, above all the obsessive singling out of one “ethnostate” for condemnation while ignoring the two dozen far worse ones surrounding it.
Do you know why many Arab and Muslim Israelis fear being incorporated into a Palestinian state as part of a land swap in a two-state solution? Why they prefer to remain Israeli citizens? Because they have actual skin in the game, unlike all you performative "anti-Zionists".
Arab Israelis know that they enjoy more political rights and freedoms in Israel than they would in the world's 22nd Arab state, as all the previous ones have been dysmal failures.
Because even they are Zionists.
Iona Italia, PhD 🏴
@IonaItalia
I'm not Jewish, I'm half Indian half British by ethnicity, British and Argentine by nationality and a proud Zionist. I might even convert to Judaism to defy the haters, if it weren't for the fact that I already have the coolest religion in the world.
KewTour 🇮🇪🇺🇦🇮🇱
@crease_monkey
I'm not Jewish, I'm Irish and proudly a Zionist.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I forgot to mention: I was raised Catholic but became an atheist at around twelve. (You can be an atheist Jew, but being an atheist Catholic is a bit harder 😉) I never felt any affinity with Judaism and had hardly any Jewish friends until 7 October 2023, when my worldview changed almost overnight. I became an outspoken Zionist thanks to the vicious irrationality of anti-Zionists.
quillette.com/2026/04/20/what-did-you-think-decolonisatio… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I forgot to mention: I was raised Catholic but became an atheist at around twelve. (You can be an atheist Jew, but being an atheist Catholic is a bit harder😉) I never felt any affinity with Judaism and had hardly any Jewish friends until 7 October 2023, when my worldview changed almost overnight. I became an outspoken Zionist thanks to the vicious irrationality of anti-Zionists.
quillette.com/2026/04/20/what-did-you-think-decolonisatio…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I'm not Jewish. I'm Belgian (with a dash of North-African DNA). And I'm a proud Zionist. Why?
Because among the world’s many nationalisms, Zionism has historically been one of the most benign, inclusive, and progressive.
Because if any people on earth has earned a country of its own after centuries of persecution and slaughter, it’s the Jews. And Israel is their historical homeland, the land from which they were driven by a long succession of conquerors and empires.
Because I have enormous admiration for Jewish cultural and intellectual achievement, and a commensurate understanding of the resentment and envy this has stirred up among the less accomplished. Without a state of their own, Jews will keep being hunted down and killed by those who hate them.
And because I can’t stand dishonesty, lies, and hypocrisy, above all the obsessive singling out of one “ethnostate” for condemnation while ignoring the two dozen far worse ones surrounding it.
Do you know why many Arab and Muslim Israelis fear being incorporated into a Palestinian state as part of a land swap in a two-state solution? Why they prefer to remain Israeli citizens? Because they have actual skin in the game, unlike all you performative "anti-Zionists".
Arab Israelis know that they enjoy more political rights and freedoms in Israel than they would in the world's 22nd Arab state, as all the previous ones have been dysmal failures.
Because even they are Zionists.
Iona Italia, PhD 🏴
@IonaItalia
I'm not Jewish, I'm half Indian half British by ethnicity, British and Argentine by nationality and a proud Zionist. I might even convert to Judaism to defy the haters, if it weren't for the fact that I already have the coolest religion in the world.
KewTour 🇮🇪🇺🇦🇮🇱
@crease_monkey
I'm not Jewish, I'm Irish and proudly a Zionist.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Hillel Neuer
@HillelNeuer
Navi Pillay, Sept. 2012: “Charlie Hebdo is doubly irresponsible to publish these cartoons.” She called the cartoons “malicious and deliberately provocative.” Pillay “fully understands why people wish to protest strongly against the cartoons.”
www.ohchr.org/en/press-briefing-notes/2012/09/press-brief…
Hillel Neuer
@HillelNeuer
BREAKING: Denmark's former foreign minister “shocked” over Nobel prize to Navi Pillay. “She is not qualified,” says Per Stig Møller. When Denmark was attacked by Muslims over cartoons of Mohammed, Pillay refused to help. “Her response was that we should introduce censorship.” 🧵
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I'm not Jewish. I'm Belgian (with a dash of North-African DNA). And I'm a proud Zionist. Why?
Because among the world’s many nationalisms, Zionism has historically been one of the most benign, inclusive, and progressive.
Because if any people on earth has earned a country of its own after centuries of persecution and slaughter, it’s the Jews. And Israel is their historical homeland, the land from which they were driven by a long succession of conquerors and empires.
Because I have enormous admiration for Jewish cultural and intellectual achievement, and a commensurate understanding of the resentment and envy this has stirred up among the less accomplished. Without a state of their own, Jews will keep being hunted down and killed by those who hate them.
And because I can’t stand dishonesty, lies, and hypocrisy, above all the obsessive singling out of one “ethnostate” for condemnation while ignoring the two dozen far worse ones surrounding it.
Do you know why many Arab and Muslim Israelis fear being incorporated into a Palestinian state as part of a land swap in a two-state solution? Why they prefer to remain Israeli citizens? Because they have actual skin in the game, unlike all you performative "anti-Zionists".
Arab Israelis know that they enjoy more political rights and freedoms in Israel than they would in the world's 22nd Arab state, as all the previous ones have been dysmal failures.
Because even they are Zionists.
Iona Italia, PhD 🏴
@IonaItalia
I'm not Jewish, I'm half Indian half British by ethnicity, British and Argentine by nationality and a proud Zionist. I might even convert to Judaism to defy the haters, if it weren't for the fact that I already have the coolest religion in the world.
KewTour 🇮🇪🇺🇦🇮🇱
@crease_monkey
I'm not Jewish, I'm Irish and proudly a Zionist.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
En altijd weer dat bespottelijke Calimero-complex, alsof de machtige zionistische lobby aan censuur doet en de arme pro-Palestijnse stemmen het zwijgen oplegt.
“De vrijheid van meningsuiting wordt aan banden gelegd als het over Palestina gaat... De uitwissing van Palestina gebeurt niet alleen fysiek, maar ook via taal. Door hun pogingen om kritiek op Israël te stigmatiseren als antisemitisme, proberen verdedigers van Israël Palestijnse perspectieven te censureren.”
www.standaard.be/opinies/de-troost-van-de-wereld-te-herst…
In welk universum leeft Brigitte Herremans? Een Israëlische vlag overleeft letterlijk geen twee minuten in Brussel of Gent, terwijl Palestijnse vlaggen niet zijn weg te slaan. Pro-Israëlische en Joodse evenementen kunnen alleen op geheime locaties en onder zware beveiliging doorgaan, terwijl anti-Israëlische activisten zich ongestoord op straat schor kunnen schreeuwen, zelfs vlak bij synagogen. Kranten staan dag na dag vol met anti-zionistische opiniestukken, de columns van Herremans zijn zelf het perfecte voorbeeld. Hele universiteiten, concertzalen en culturele instellingen zwichten voor agressieve pro-Palestijnse militanten en boycotten Israël. Zelfs onze overheden treffen sancties tegen de enige Joodse staat ter wereld.
Maar nog steeds hoor je @BriHerremans vervolgens: “Help, help! I’m being repressed!”
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Beste kranten, wat is eigenlijk nog het nut van columns en opiniestukken die elke dag, op licht verschillende wijze, dezelfde riedel voor de lezer herhalen: “Israël/zionisme is kwaadaardig”?
Tegen wie zijn ze eigenlijk gericht? De lezer krijgt toch nooit een antwoord van de andere kant, laat staan een interview met een dissidente wetenschapper. Inzendingen die een ander perspectief bieden, worden stelselmatig geweigerd. Ik heb het zelf vaak geprobeerd, ook deze week nog naar aanleiding van 7 oktober. Allemaal geweigerd.
Tegen wie zijn deze mensen dan nog aan het argumenteren? Wat voor “debat” is dit eindeloze gegalm in de eigen echokamer? Welke boodschap heeft de lezer daar uiteindelijk nog aan?
Zelfs over de oorlog in Oekraïne lees je af en toe dissidente stemmen, die de schuld bij de NAVO leggen, voor onderhandelingen met Poetin pleiten, enzovoort. Meestal ben ik het daar totaal mee oneens. Maar op zijn minst heb je dan nog een tegensprekelijk debat, waarin je ook de argumenten van de andere kant leert kennen.
Over Israël heb je... niets. Er zijn eindeloze interviews met anti-zionisten (liefst Joden) die Israël op alle mogelijke manieren in de banvloek slaan. Maar tegenstemmen als John Spencer, Norman Goda, Joël Kotek, Steven Pinker of Benny Morris komen NOOIT aan het woord. Niet in opiniestukken, niet in interviews, gewoon helemaal niet.
Eerlijk, ik heb dit nog nooit meegemaakt, in geen enkel ander debat. Natuurlijk, er is vaak een overwicht aan standpunten in deze of gene richting. Maar de mate van verstikking en blikvernauwing is hier echt van een andere orde.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit stuk dus: www.standaard.be/opinies/de-troost-van-de-wereld-te-herst…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Maar verder is @BriHerremans echt geïnteresseerd in open debat hoor, en wil ze "altijd ruimte laten voor twijfel en dialoog." /3
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is not a drill anymore.
Yesterday in Amsterdam, dozens—perhaps hundreds—of people were chanting: “Long live 7 October.” This is outright glorification of one of the most brutal terrorist attacks in modern history, and the deadliest antisemitic massacre since the Holocaust.
I don’t care who the people hiding behind those keffiyehs are, where they were born, or what their religion is. If you openly glorify terrorism and mass murder, you should be arrested and prosecuted, and deported where the law permits. We cannot build a functioning society if people are allowed to openly celebrate the mass murder of Jews, and we cannot expect Jews to stay in Europe if we simply let this pass.
I would say exactly the same thing if far-right extremists were openly celebrating the Holocaust or Anders Breivik’s terrorist attack in the streets. The double standard here is staggering. In Belgium, people have been prosecuted for making offensive jokes about the Holocaust. Even Holocaust denial or minimization—not just glorification—is illegal. Yet we’re supposed to tolerate people openly celebrating a modern-day massacre of Jews?
You cannot build a functioning society with people who openly celebrate the mass murder of innocent civilians.
@ministerieJenV -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Because nothing says "Stop the genocide!" quite like throwing a party on the anniversary of the day it started. Imagine Jews turning the Wannsee Conference into a national holiday. Honestly, I despise these useful idiots even more than the honest Hamas fanatics.
(She says: "After witnessing the genocide for three years, 7 Oct has become a day of celebration, because Palestinians finally resisted" etc.)
Janneke Nieuwstad
@Jannekestad
Verbijsterend.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Judea Pearl
@yudapearl
Elisha Wiesel: The Death of the Nobel Peace Prize www.thefp.com/p/elie-wiesel-death-nobel-peace-prize-israe…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Russell Blackford
@Metamagician
I have an article forthcoming soon in the peer-reviewed journal Analyse & Kritik. Here's my answer to someone who asked me what it's all about. (Maybe of interest to @mboudry and @QCassam among others.)
Russell Blackford
@Metamagician
It's not a secret. It just might not make a lot of sense in a short post on this platform. Anyway, I'll try quickly. It's about resistance to the truth - or "epistemic resistance" - and especially whether people on one side of politics are more willing than those on the other side to embrace false or dubious claims, and to resist true or well-evidenced ones, when it suits their pre-existing ideological perspectives. The short answer is "probably not" but it's more complicated than that.
The dubious accusation that Israel committed, or continues to commit, genocide in Gaza is one of my main examples. As I disclose in the paper, I've argued elsewhere that the claim is false. However, as I point out, it's sufficient for the purpose of the paper to explain why it's at least dubious - so I do explain that (e.g. with reference to appropriate case law, criticism of the reports from Amnesty International and other organizations, etc.). However, if you start with a certain anti-Western ideological perspective you'll very readily accept the claim. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Quillette
@Quillette
If your country were invaded tomorrow by the second-strongest army in the world, would you give up your career and enlist?
@mboudry asks if Europe grasps what #ukraine's fall would mean for the rest of us.
quillette.com/2026/10/07/an-army-of-yesterdays-civilians-… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Whoever decided to call this a “debate” series must have a deadpan sense of humour.
"This year's Debating Development series, “Resisting Erasure”, uses Palestine as a lens to examine interconnected struggles against dispossession, ecological destruction, criminalisation, surveillance, and the suppression of histories and knowledge. Bringing together scholars, organisers, artists, and legal thinkers, the series explores how erasure operates—and how communities resist through memory, cultural production, land defence, abolitionist organising, and collective survival." -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Because nothing says "Stop the genocide!" quite like throwing a party on the anniversary of the day it started. Imagine Jews turning the Wannsee Conference into a national holiday. Honestly, I despise these useful idiots even more than the honest Hamas fanatics.
(She says: "After witnessing the genocide for three years, 7 Oct has become a day of celebration, because Palestinians finally resisted" etc.)
Janneke Nieuwstad
@Jannekestad
Verbijsterend.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
If my country were invaded tomorrow, would I enlist to defend our freedom? That question kept nagging at me throughout my trip to Ukraine last month. My own convictions, like those of most Europeans, remain comfortably untested.
In my new essay for @Quillette, I write about visiting drone labs, talking with trauma therapists and foreign fighters, standing at the graves of fallen writers and artists, discussing conspiracy theories with students in Kyiv, and watching Faust trade away his soul at the Lviv opera.
“The very least the rest of us can do is keep supporting them—financially, militarily, and morally. If we don’t have the back of this brave nation, fighting to be part of our civilization, what’s the point of having such a civilization in the first place?”
(Keep it quiet, but you can now read the essay without paywall on S*bst*k.)
substacktools.com/sharex/O30V4Jxk -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
“Zohran, you can’t hide. We charge you with genocide.”
But @ZohranKMamdani has always supported the Leopards Eating People's Faces Party. He has been every face-eating leopard's best friend. How could they eat HIS face then? 😿
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/10/october-7-new-york-isra… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
David Deutsch
@DavidDeutschOxf
And now the genocide libel has won the Nobel Peace Prize.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The question of genocide in Gaza is not just a matter of “semantics,” as many are now claiming, quietly backpedaling from their earlier confident assertions. It is not a borderline case, or a matter of interpretation, or an issue on which reasonable people can differ.
It is an obscene lie, contradicted by everything we know about Israel’s conduct during the war (which is not to absolve the IDF of war crimes). Here are 76 retired senior military leaders and legal experts flatly rejecting the genocide allegation:
“Israel has not committed genocide but rather set a high bar for how to conduct urban warfare against an enemy who will stop at nothing, including the death of its own civilians.”
The fact that the rector of my own university wanted to prohibit questioning the “Gaza genocide,” as though it were the equivalent of flat-earthism or climate denialism, still fills me with disbelief and rage. One day it will become clear who are the real flat-earthers here.
jinsa.org/open-letter-from-military-professionals-refutin… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
If my country were invaded tomorrow, would I enlist to defend our freedom? That question kept nagging at me throughout my trip to Ukraine last month. My own convictions, like those of most Europeans, remain comfortably untested.
In my new essay for @Quillette, I write about visiting drone labs, talking with trauma therapists and foreign fighters, standing at the graves of fallen writers and artists, discussing conspiracy theories with students in Kyiv, and watching Faust trade away his soul at the Lviv opera.
“The very least the rest of us can do is keep supporting them—financially, militarily, and morally. If we don’t have the back of this brave nation, fighting to be part of our civilization, what’s the point of having such a civilization in the first place?”
(Keep it quiet, but you can now read the essay without paywall on S*bst*k.)
substacktools.com/sharex/O30V4Jxk -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The question of genocide in Gaza is not just a matter of “semantics,” as many are now claiming, quietly backpedaling from their earlier confident assertions. It is not a borderline case, or a matter of interpretation, or an issue on which reasonable people can differ.
It is an obscene lie, contradicted by everything we know about Israel’s conduct during the war (which is not to absolve the IDF of war crimes). Here are 76 retired senior military leaders and legal experts flatly rejecting the genocide allegation:
“Israel has not committed genocide but rather set a high bar for how to conduct urban warfare against an enemy who will stop at nothing, including the death of its own civilians.”
The fact that the rector of my own university wanted to prohibit questioning the “Gaza genocide,” as though it were the equivalent of flat-earthism or climate denialism, still fills me with disbelief and rage. One day it will become clear who are the real flat-earthers here.
jinsa.org/open-letter-from-military-professionals-refutin… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Kosher
@koshercockney
What the actual f*ck did I just hear?
Finkelstein: "The reason we don't have huge levels of antisemitism in Europe now is because Hitler solved the Jewish question."
“What do you mean by that?”
Finkelstein: “6 million Jews were exterminated. That solved the Jewish question” -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Garry Kasparov
@Kasparov63
Putting terrorists and aggressors on the same moral plane as their victims and targets is repugnant. At best it whitewashes horrible crimes, at worst it feeds the culture of murder and martyrdom that Hamas espouses.
Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani
@NYCMayor
This day is profoundly painful for so many New Yorkers. It marks three years since the horrific war crimes of October 7. On that day, Hamas killed more than 1,100 Israelis and abducted 251 others. We grieve alongside our many friends and neighbors who still carry that unthinkable loss.
The suffering did not begin nor end that day. It instead continued through the Israeli government’s devastating, ongoing genocide in Gaza, in which it has killed more than 74,000 Palestinians—including more than 21,000 children. Even since the so-called ceasefire, more than 1,400 Palestinians have been killed. That suffering has intensified with every Israeli bomb dropped on ambulances waiting outside hospitals, every drone strike targeting a residential building or journalist, and every shipment of food aid turned away at a border crossing. Many New Yorkers are reckoning with this unbearable grief, and we mourn alongside them – all while knowing that our tax dollars fund these war crimes.
Three years later, we must refuse to accept a world in which occupation and apartheid continue, where war crimes are met with impunity, and our federal government continues its complicity with every arms shipment.
To honor the dead, we must fight for a world in which every person can live with freedom, safety, and dignity. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Ralf Bodelier
@RalfBodelier
Maarten Boudry zegt het weer heel scherp. Rond elk thema waar Nederlandse kranten over schrijven, zoeken ze naar meerdere stemmen. Wanneer het over Israel gaat komt maar één geluid aan bod. Het anti-Israel geluid, liefst vertolkt door Joden.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Beste kranten, wat is eigenlijk nog het nut van columns en opiniestukken die elke dag, op licht verschillende wijze, dezelfde riedel voor de lezer herhalen: “Israël/zionisme is kwaadaardig”?
Tegen wie zijn ze eigenlijk gericht? De lezer krijgt toch nooit een antwoord van de andere kant, laat staan een interview met een dissidente wetenschapper. Inzendingen die een ander perspectief bieden, worden stelselmatig geweigerd. Ik heb het zelf vaak geprobeerd, ook deze week nog naar aanleiding van 7 oktober. Allemaal geweigerd.
Tegen wie zijn deze mensen dan nog aan het argumenteren? Wat voor “debat” is dit eindeloze gegalm in de eigen echokamer? Welke boodschap heeft de lezer daar uiteindelijk nog aan?
Zelfs over de oorlog in Oekraïne lees je af en toe dissidente stemmen, die de schuld bij de NAVO leggen, voor onderhandelingen met Poetin pleiten, enzovoort. Meestal ben ik het daar totaal mee oneens. Maar op zijn minst heb je dan nog een tegensprekelijk debat, waarin je ook de argumenten van de andere kant leert kennen.
Over Israël heb je... niets. Er zijn eindeloze interviews met anti-zionisten (liefst Joden) die Israël op alle mogelijke manieren in de banvloek slaan. Maar tegenstemmen als John Spencer, Norman Goda, Joël Kotek, Steven Pinker of Benny Morris komen NOOIT aan het woord. Niet in opiniestukken, niet in interviews, gewoon helemaal niet.
Eerlijk, ik heb dit nog nooit meegemaakt, in geen enkel ander debat. Natuurlijk, er is vaak een overwicht aan standpunten in deze of gene richting. Maar de mate van verstikking en blikvernauwing is hier echt van een andere orde. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Geen prijzen voor correcte antwoord: omdat executies "at close range" geen enkele twijfel toelaten over de intenties, in tegenstelling tot onverifieerbare bloedsprookjes over zionistische snipers die op grote afstand "doelbewust op kinderen schieten voor de sport", op basis van dubieuze getuigen en nog dubieuzere radiologie. Doe jij echt alsof je onnozel bent over dit onderwerp, @LodeCossaer? En laf om me niet te taggen.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Volgende week (15 okt) spreek ik over mijn boek in Haarlem, om 20u. Weest welgekomen! Inschrijven: LogeKennemerland100@gmail.com
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
The Babylon Bee
@TheBabylonBee
Liberals Prepare For Anniversary Of October 8, The Day Israel Attacked Gaza For No Reason babylonbee.com/news/liberals-prepare-for-anniversary-of-o…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Beste kranten, wat is eigenlijk nog het nut van columns en opiniestukken die elke dag, op licht verschillende wijze, dezelfde riedel voor de lezer herhalen: “Israël/zionisme is kwaadaardig”?
Tegen wie zijn ze eigenlijk gericht? De lezer krijgt toch nooit een antwoord van de andere kant, laat staan een interview met een dissidente wetenschapper. Inzendingen die een ander perspectief bieden, worden stelselmatig geweigerd. Ik heb het zelf vaak geprobeerd, ook deze week nog naar aanleiding van 7 oktober. Allemaal geweigerd.
Tegen wie zijn deze mensen dan nog aan het argumenteren? Wat voor “debat” is dit eindeloze gegalm in de eigen echokamer? Welke boodschap heeft de lezer daar uiteindelijk nog aan?
Zelfs over de oorlog in Oekraïne lees je af en toe dissidente stemmen, die de schuld bij de NAVO leggen, voor onderhandelingen met Poetin pleiten, enzovoort. Meestal ben ik het daar totaal mee oneens. Maar op zijn minst heb je dan nog een tegensprekelijk debat, waarin je ook de argumenten van de andere kant leert kennen.
Over Israël heb je... niets. Er zijn eindeloze interviews met anti-zionisten (liefst Joden) die Israël op alle mogelijke manieren in de banvloek slaan. Maar tegenstemmen als John Spencer, Norman Goda, Joël Kotek, Steven Pinker of Benny Morris komen NOOIT aan het woord. Niet in opiniestukken, niet in interviews, gewoon helemaal niet.
Eerlijk, ik heb dit nog nooit meegemaakt, in geen enkel ander debat. Natuurlijk, er is vaak een overwicht aan standpunten in deze of gene richting. Maar de mate van verstikking en blikvernauwing is hier echt van een andere orde.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Toch een klein lichtpuntje: @demorgen nam eindelijk eens een stuk van Bret Stephens over Israël en Gaza over. Dat is geloof ik de eerste keer (over andere onderwerpen publiceren ze hem vaak). Niet zijn meest forse stuk (zoals de columns waarin bij de bloedsmaad genaamd "genocide" aanklaagt), maar toch. /2 www.demorgen.be/meningen/drie-jaar-na-7-oktober-staat-isr…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is not a drill anymore.
Yesterday in Amsterdam, dozens—perhaps hundreds—of people were chanting: “Long live 7 October.” This is outright glorification of one of the most brutal terrorist attacks in modern history, and the deadliest antisemitic massacre since the Holocaust.
I don’t care who the people hiding behind those keffiyehs are, where they were born, or what their religion is. If you openly glorify terrorism and mass murder, you should be arrested and prosecuted, and deported where the law permits. We cannot build a functioning society if people are allowed to openly celebrate the mass murder of Jews, and we cannot expect Jews to stay in Europe if we simply let this pass.
I would say exactly the same thing if far-right extremists were openly celebrating the Holocaust or Anders Breivik’s terrorist attack in the streets. The double standard here is staggering. In Belgium, people have been prosecuted for making offensive jokes about the Holocaust. Even Holocaust denial or minimization—not just glorification—is illegal. Yet we’re supposed to tolerate people openly celebrating a modern-day massacre of Jews?
You cannot build a functioning society with people who openly celebrate the mass murder of innocent civilians.
@ministerieJenV -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A devastating reply to moral philosopher Jeff McMahan on the Gaza war, by Quassim Cassam (@QCassam). Frankly, I’m amazed—in a positive way—that Cassam managed to get this response published in an academic journal like Analyse & Kritik. He did face pushback from the editors, but they ultimately treated him fairly. Kudos to them.
McMahan is one of countless academics who seem to have suspended their critical faculties when it comes to the Gaza war, and Cassam doesn’t pull any punches in exposing this.
McMahan’s claim that everything horrendous Hamas has done has been done “to a much greater extent” by Israel is, Cassam argues, “not only false but ludicrous when the evidence is properly considered.”
In his effort to downplay the sadistic atrocities committed on 7 October, the distinguished bioethicist even ends up parroting Hamas propaganda. This, Cassam rightly argues, is “the single most pernicious aspect” of his argument.
From a moral point of view, nothing Israel has done during this horrible war even comes close to what Hamas did on 7 October. There has not been a single instance of Israeli soldiers executing women and children at close range, engaging in mass rape, abducting babies and the elderly, or parading mutilated corpses through the streets in jubilation—the kinds of atrocities Hamas deliberately committed that day. Hamas maximizes civilian casualties; Israel tries its best to minimize them.
Yet the moral pressure on academics to toe the anti-Israel line is so immense that even a distinguished ethicist like Jeff McMahan can become blind to this stark moral divide. Worse still, he can end up pretending that the moral divide runs in the opposite direction—that Israel is “much worse” than Hamas.
Thank you for this public service, Quassim. Not everyone in academia has gone crazy, phew.
www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/auk-2026-3011… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Gerald Posner
@geraldposner
This was Zohran Mamdani only 13 days after October 7. No one could have predicted that this unhinged radical would become New York's next mayor. Israel had not yet launched its ground invasion into Gaza and he was already screaming genocide
tnx @mazemoore for that videoThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
🛡️Defend the West Conference🛡️
When: 1/13/27
Where: online
Speaker spotlight: @mboudry
Talk title: When Westerners Hate the West: The Autoimmune Disease of Liberalism
Maarten Boudry is a philosopher of science and progress thinker whose work examines pseudoscience, cultural evolution, conspiracy theories, climate policy, science and religion, and the reasoning errors that shape public debate. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I spent a week in Ukraine: visiting drone labs, talking with trauma therapists and foreign fighters, standing at soldiers' graves, and watching Faust trade away his soul at the Lviv opera. One question kept nagging me: if my country were invaded tomorrow, would I enlist? My convictions, like those of most Europeans, remain comfortably untested. Essay for @Quillette quillette.com/2026/10/07/an-army-of-yesterdays-civilians-…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Three years ago, on 7 October, my worldview changed—not so much because of the atrocities committed by Hamas (what else would you expect from a genocidal terrorist group?), but because of the shocking response to those atrocities from many of my “progressive” friends: from apologetics and denial to outright jubilation.
That day, I was jolted out of my complacency and woke up to the poisonous ideology that had quietly taken hold across large swathes of the Left and academia.
My forthcoming book, The Betrayal of the Enlightenment (@PitchstoneBooks), reconstructs how self-proclaimed progressives, of all people, could have arrived at this point. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Graham Linehan
@Glinner
Yes it was not so much the atrocity as the reaction to the atrocity that made me finally realise the left as I understood it no longer existed, if it ever existed in the first place.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Three years ago, on 7 October, my worldview changed—not so much because of the atrocities committed by Hamas (what else would you expect from a genocidal terrorist group?), but because of the shocking response to those atrocities from many of my “progressive” friends: from apologetics and denial to outright jubilation.
That day, I was jolted out of my complacency and woke up to the poisonous ideology that had quietly taken hold across large swathes of the Left and academia.
My forthcoming book, The Betrayal of the Enlightenment (@PitchstoneBooks), reconstructs how self-proclaimed progressives, of all people, could have arrived at this point. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Eyal Yakoby
@EYakoby
Palestinian children spit on the corpses of dead civilians.
Never forget October 7th. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Sana Ebrahimi Ledene
@SanaELedene
Nothing to see here. Just a group of French high schoolers protesting busy classrooms and understaffing.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Imagine hundreds of right-wing demonstrations across the world on July 22, the day of the terrorist attacks by Anders Breivik in Utøya. How fucked do you think our civilization would be? And consequently, how fucked are we now? www.timesofisrael.com/hundreds-of-anti-israel-protests-pl…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Génocidaires et génocidés : petite histoire d’un blanchiment d’idées www.lepoint.fr/debats/genocidaires-et-genocides-petite-hi…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Intifada being globalised, just as you requested.
(Unless someone hears something very different from:
"Ils ne sont que dix. En nom d'Allah on les tue.)
Visegrád 24
@visegrad24
🇫🇷 A student rioter at Honoré-de-Balzac high school near Paris has called for the police to be killed “in the name of Allah.”
“There are only ten of them. In the name of Allah, we can kill them all!” he shouted. Other young rioters happily cheered.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Au nom"
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Drew Pavlou 🇦🇺🇺🇸🇫🇷🇺🇦🇹🇼
@DrewPavlou
This was one of the most depraved scenes in modern history - still chills me to my core that so many people watched this barbarism and immediately sided with it
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Max 📟
@MaxNordau
It sticks with me that Gazans invaded Israel and just started murdering random people.
It also sticks with me that there are literally zero videos of israeli soldiers ever doing this. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
John Aziz
@aziz0nomics
This is some rather telling graffiti from the French riots: explicit support for Hamas and October 7.
But go on—keep telling me that these are "school protests" about "teacher shortages".
Nobody believes you. The rioters certainly don't.
Eyal Yakoby
@EYakoby
BREAKING: The town hall in Paris was vandalized by migrant rioters last night.
“Oct 7th, The Al-Aqsa Flood.” -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Kamel Amin Thaabet
@K_AminThaabet
“From the river to the sea” isn’t so fun when it’s the Seine to the Mediterranean, huh?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Louise O. Fresco
@LouiseOFresco
En er is net een vervolg op meer, namelijk OVERVLOED met de sterke boodschap dat meer technologie en economische groei welvaart mogelijk maakt @Hiddemhigh @floriskreiken
Louise O. Fresco
@LouiseOFresco
Wordt schaarste of overvloed onze toekomst? Oude vraag, ooit van Malthus (“landschaarsfe leidt tot ondergang”). Hij vergat dat productiviteit toeneemt. Jonge denkers pakken dit opnieuw op in hun boek MEER: juist overvloed is nodig voor duurzaamheid! @Hiddemhigh @mboudry et al
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
@dioscuri and I were honoured to be joined by @sapinker to discuss AI, including concepts like "AGI" and "superintelligence", existential risk, instrumental convergence, consciousness, and more . Full video here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLJ7UL5CzvY&t=1s (1/2)
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Linkse hegemonie en pseudowetenschap aan de UGent. Lezing maandag voor KVHV in Gent.
Full disclosure: deze keer heeft Claude mijn presentatie grotendeels opgemaakt, op basis van teksten, interviews, en eerdere presentaties. Die eerste versie heb ik natuurlijk weer grondig bewerkt, maar de aanzet was van Claude.
Werkte wonderwel deze keer — veel beter dan de vorige poging van een jaar geleden, die waardeloos was. Het nadeel was wel dat ik de structuur van mijn eigen presentatie minder goed kende, en daardoor soms vooruitliep of een bochtje moest maken. 😅
www.youtube.com/watch?v=I3Ek0t50gCQ
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hier de presentatie:
Hoe een universiteit te kapen
Ideologische bias in academia
/3
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Claude baseerde zich voornamelijk op mijn tweedelige Engelse essay, alsook op interviews, boeken en eerdere presentaties (Met Opus 5.5. gewerkt). /3
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
DavidAnderson_JD_NYC
@DavidandersonJd
🇮🇱🇵🇸🇧🇪This is a great short article by a friend of a friend of mine, Prof. Maarten Boudry in Belgium.
He is a courageous man and has paid quite a cost there for coming out in favor of Israel. AFAIK he is not Jewish. He's just .... decent.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
None So Blind as Those Who Refuse to See
The Horrors of October 7th
substacktools.com/sharex/TgVB1DEl -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Three years ago, on 7 October, my worldview changed—not so much because of the atrocities committed by Hamas (what else would you expect from a genocidal terrorist group?), but because of the shocking response to those atrocities from many of my “progressive” friends: from apologetics and denial to outright jubilation.
That day, I was jolted out of my complacency and woke up to the poisonous ideology that had quietly taken hold across large swathes of the Left and academia.
My forthcoming book, The Betrayal of the Enlightenment (@PitchstoneBooks), reconstructs how self-proclaimed progressives, of all people, could have arrived at this point.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
None So Blind as Those Who Refuse to See
The Horrors of October 7th
substacktools.com/sharex/TgVB1DEl
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
See also this video essay by @Quillette, in which I tell about my old complacency and how I was jolted out of it on Oct 7.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=f_pZb2dZjug&xstg=CAMSEBUJ_b-oH-Ph…
/3 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Louise O. Fresco
@LouiseOFresco
Wordt schaarste of overvloed onze toekomst? Oude vraag, ooit van Malthus (“landschaarsfe leidt tot ondergang”). Hij vergat dat productiviteit toeneemt. Jonge denkers pakken dit opnieuw op in hun boek MEER: juist overvloed is nodig voor duurzaamheid! @Hiddemhigh @mboudry et al
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I spent a week in Ukraine: visiting drone labs, talking with trauma therapists and foreign fighters, standing at soldiers' graves, and watching Faust trade away his soul at the Lviv opera. One question kept nagging me: if my country were invaded tomorrow, would I enlist? My convictions, like those of most Europeans, remain comfortably untested. Essay for @Quillette quillette.com/2026/10/07/an-army-of-yesterdays-civilians-…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"The very least the rest of us can do is keep supporting this brave nation fighting to be part of our civilisation. If we don't, what's the point of having such a civilisation in the first place?" New essay for @Quillette about my visit to Ukraine. quillette.com/2026/10/07/an-army-of-yesterdays-civilians-…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
"Although I stayed in Kyiv for only a week, I could feel how quickly the desensitisation sets in. During your first air alert, you dutifully follow the instructions and head for the nearest shelter. After a few, you start ignoring the yellow warnings"--@mboudry for @Quillette
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
David Frum
@davidfrum
Most people in Gaza must understand that October 7 was a criminal mistake that brought Gaza nothing but devastation. But foreign supporters urge the Gazans to try it again.
Open Source Intel
@Osint613
At least 75 pro Palestinian rallies and major events are planned worldwide for the anniversary of October 7.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Arsen Ostrovsky
@Ostrov_A
“Dad I’m calling you from the phone of a Jew! I just killed her and her husband. With my own hands I killed 10 Jews!”
Chilling conversation from Oct 7th, between a Hamas terrorist from Gaza and his father, who is crying with pride.
Never forget this sick evil! -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Als rabiate atheïst moet ik toegeven dat katholieke universiteiten tegenwoordig beter bestand zijn tegen ideologische kaping aan bakboord (de linkerzijde) dan vrijzinnige.
Hetzelfde geldt voor studentenverenigingen. Want wees eerlijk: welke studentengroep aan @UGent zou het nog in zijn hoofd halen om mij uit te nodigen? 🙃
Niet dat ik geloof dat katholieken intrinsiek toleranter zijn, hoor. We weten allemaal hoe tolerant universiteiten waren toen katholieken er de plak zwaaiden.😉
Maandag meer daarover in mijn voordracht bij @KVHVGent, over linkse hegemonie en pseudowetenschap, om 19.30 uur in Quetelet. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
• A French writer (@doramoutot) was criminally convicted—and faces possible prison time—for saying that a trans woman is “a man, a transfeminine man.”
• An American academic living in Belgium (@nathancofnas) is being taken to court by Belgium’s official equality agency for claiming that there are racial differences in IQ.
• A German woman was jailed for a weekend for calling a man who raped a 15-year-old girl a “disgraceful rapist pig”—a harsher sentence than the rapist received.
• A British assault victim was convicted of a hate crime for calling her attacker a “faggot” in text messages.
But please, tell me again that Europe doesn’t have a free-speech problem. That there’s nothing to worry about. That it’s all a right-wing invention—as claimed by @lemondefr and many other newspapers.
For heaven's sake, can someone give us a First Amendment already? -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Sam Altman
@sama
for a long time i said that antisemitism, particularly on the american left, was not as bad as people claimed.
i'd like to just state that i was totally wrong.
i still don't understand it, really. or know what to do about it.
but it is so fucked. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Garry Kasparov
@Kasparov63
With images like this one going viral, Le Pen soon will become a centrist political force in France.
Stelios Panagiotou
@Panagiotou90St
Notice how those who are telling you that burning a bystander’s face constitutes protesting against insufficient funding for schools are also repeatedly scaremongering about the rise of the ‘far right’ in Europe.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Fania Oz-Salzberger 🇮🇱🕊️🟣 פניה עוז-זלצברגר
@faniaoz
Yes. Dozens of the Gazan journalists, teachers and medics killed in the war and lamented in international media were Hamas. On this I believe the IDF report, which corroborates other evidence I have seen.
Certainly not all of them. Many innocents were killed too. Acknowledging both facts is matter of honesty.
Jonathan Sacerdoti
@jonsac
The IDF has published what it calls the Press Files: the names, photographs and roles of 170 of those people killed during the war who were presented to the world as journalists and media workers, and who were also operatives in terrorist organisations.
If this list comes late in the day, that is because it took time to compile. It was built over months, painstakingly, from documents and rosters recovered by troops inside Gaza, many of them produced by the terrorist groups themselves, alongside other intelligence. In many cases the evidence came from Hamas and Islamic Jihad directly, which quietly claimed these men as their own martyrs once the international outrage had already done its work.
My article in The Spectator:
spectator.com/article/the-truth-about-gazan-journalists -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Matthias Schmidt
@eurofounder
If Tinder was created in the EU
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
• A French writer (@doramoutot) was criminally convicted—and faces possible prison time—for saying that a trans woman is “a man, a transfeminine man.”
• An American academic living in Belgium (@nathancofnas) is being taken to court by Belgium’s official equality agency for claiming that there are racial differences in IQ.
• A German woman was jailed for a weekend for calling a man who raped a 15-year-old girl a “disgraceful rapist pig”—a harsher sentence than the rapist received.
• A British assault victim was convicted of a hate crime for calling her attacker a “faggot” in text messages.
But please, tell me again that Europe doesn’t have a free-speech problem. That there’s nothing to worry about. That it’s all a right-wing invention—as claimed by @lemondefr and many other newspapers.
For heaven's sake, can someone give us a First Amendment already? -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I vividly remember taking my first taxi ride as a kid, during a medical emergency. I thought it was incredibly cool—something normally reserved for Very Important People.
I also vividly remember the angry opposition to Uber and other ride-sharing apps when I was at university: “It’s destroying the taxi industry! It’s Big Tech exploiting poor drivers! It’s unfair competition!”
Now we all take €10 rides after a two-minute wait, often in far more comfortable cars, without giving it a second thought. A service once reserved for the affluent has become accessible to everyone, whenever they need it.
That’s how quickly we get used to progress.
As @bryan_caplan writes:
"This is one of the clearest demonstrations of positive-sum change I know of. Yes, Uber devastated the taxi industry. But they didn’t just “drink their milkshake.” They made six additional milkshakes in the process. The combined effect of a massive price cut and a massive convenience boost multiplied vehicle miles roughly seven-fold. Who would have imagined that demand could be so elastic? "
substacktools.com/sharex/OOeZ5d4W -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
“I only want to work with people at my school who share the same view on the Palestinian genocide. I only want students who oppose genocide [...] You deny it, and I don’t like that. I wish you all the best at another school.”
In essence this is what my rector (of @UGent) has told me as well: if you question the “Gaza genocide” as a researcher, you are “crossing a line that should not be crossed,” and you will no longer be protected by academic freedom.
None of this is a coincidence. The "Gaza genocide" is enforced as an ideological litmus test precisely because there is not a shred of evidence for it, and because believing it requires an extraordinary degree of ignorance and willful blindness (substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx). That makes it perfect for signaling ideological allegiance and submission. You have to utter the g-word, or else...
I still find it hard to believe that this blood libel has captured almost the entirety of academia, legacy media, and liberal institutions across Europe—with Germany as a partial exception. And eventually everyone folded, or was cowed into silence, even some of my friends who should know better (substacktools.com/sharex/o7sf5gVz).
www.algemeiner.com/2026/10/02/israeli-netherlands-rejecte… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
“I only want to work with people at my school who share the same view on the Palestinian genocide. I only want students who oppose genocide [...] You deny it, and I don’t like that. I wish you all the best at another school.”
In essence this is what my rector (of @UGent) has told me as well: if you question the “Gaza genocide” as a researcher, you are “crossing a line that should not be crossed,” and you will no longer be protected by academic freedom.
None of this is a coincidence. The "Gaza genocide" is enforced as an ideological litmus test precisely because there is not a shred of evidence for it, and because believing it requires an extraordinary degree of ignorance and willful blindness (substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx). That makes it perfect for signaling ideological allegiance and submission. You have to utter the g-word, or else...
I still find it hard to believe that this blood libel has captured almost the entirety of academia, legacy media, and liberal institutions across Europe—with Germany as a partial exception. And eventually everyone folded, or was cowed into silence, even some of my friends who should know better (substacktools.com/sharex/o7sf5gVz).
www.algemeiner.com/2026/10/02/israeli-netherlands-rejecte… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Als rabiate atheïst moet ik toegeven dat katholieke universiteiten tegenwoordig beter bestand zijn tegen ideologische kaping aan bakboord (de linkerzijde) dan vrijzinnige.
Hetzelfde geldt voor studentenverenigingen. Want wees eerlijk: welke studentengroep aan @UGent zou het nog in zijn hoofd halen om mij uit te nodigen? 🙃
Niet dat ik geloof dat katholieken intrinsiek toleranter zijn, hoor. We weten allemaal hoe tolerant universiteiten waren toen katholieken er de plak zwaaiden.😉
Maandag meer daarover in mijn voordracht bij @KVHVGent, over linkse hegemonie en pseudowetenschap, om 19.30 uur in Quetelet. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Er zijn veel vlakken waarop links de verlichting de afgelopen jaren heeft verraden, maar dit behoort tot de allerergste: hoe ze de ogen sluiten voor homohaat zodra de daders een donkere huidskleur hebben en een "exotische" religie aanhangen. Want de enige aanvaardbare dader is een witte, westerse dader.
Keer op keer probeert men dan krampachtig de aandacht af te leiden naar extreemrechts en de marginale "manosfeer", alsof dáár het kalf gebonden ligt. Alsof dát verklaart waarom homo's in onze steden bang zijn om hun lief op straat te kussen.
Een uitstekend en moedig stuk van @PaulNotelteirs, zelf helaas ervaringsdeskundige — en iemand die je bezwaarlijk van rechtse sympathieën kunt verdenken.
"Als ik met queer vrienden over haat uit religieuze hoek praat, gebeurt dat vaak op fluistertoon."
"Ik zou met een gerust hart naar een bijeenkomst van Forza Ninove durven gaan en daar een vriend kussen, maar in mijn eigen wijk in de Antwerpse Seefhoek ben ik al bezorgd of mijn stemkleur of outfits geen homofoob geweld kunnen triggeren als ik over straat wandel."
"Progressieve politieke partijen verliezen zichzelf in een eindeloos vaag discours als het over homofobie gaat en voor koepelorganisaties als Çavaria is het al helemaal ondenkbaar om te durven suggereren dat er mogelijk een probleem is bij de migrantengemeenschap."
www.demorgen.be/nieuws/hoe-moeilijk-hebben-gelovigen-het-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Kaizen D. Asiedu
@thatsKAIZEN
When the party at fault could be Israel or America, you publish unverified information from Muslim extremists.
But when the party at fault could be Muslim extremists, you avoid speculation.
You're activists too.
NYTimes Communications
@NYTimesPR
Our headlines and live coverage contain all the facts we're able to confirm as we confirm them. Unlike activists and partisans, we don't publish speculation or unverified information. Here's a Gift Link to follow along as we update our reporting:
www.nytimes.com/live/2026/09/30/world/dubai-flight-tel-av… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In 1933, Hitler purged Jews from German universities. An entire generation of brilliant Jewish scientists was lost to the country. Within a few years, Hitler had all but destroyed German academia, then the finest in the world.
In 2026, there are no direct expulsions of Jewish scientists. No, of course not! We’re civilized today. But no matter: universities have created such a hostile environment for Jews that many leave of their own accord.
As I have explicitly warned, Belgian universities are engaging in naked acts of ideological partisanship: they are boycotting the only Jewish state in the world for waging a defensive war; giving the blood libel of “genocide” their official stamp of approval; and awarding honorary doctorates to inveterate “antizionists” like @FranceskAlbs, who spreads constant lies about Israel and wouldn’t recognize antisemitism if it clobbered her over the head. And they do all of that under pressure from activists.
This sends a very clear signal to people who believe in Jewish self-determination and Israel’s right to exist: you don’t belong here. Get out. As the activists themselves like to put it: “This is a Zionist-free campus.”
Read this email I received from a Belgian Jewish physicist, and weep.
***
Dear Maarten,
I just wanted to send you an update, following my message to you from a year ago.
We have decided to leave Melbourne and move back to Belgium in March 2027. Until about six months ago, I had a fairly clear idea of what I wanted to do when I returned: find a position at a Belgian university that would allow me to combine teaching with developing and applying mathematical models in physics, mathematical biology, or another field. This is what I enjoy doing, and what I am trained to do. But given everything that has happened over the past few years, and in particular what I have been seeing across the academic world, I have increasingly moved away from that plan. I just don’t feel at home anymore in that world. What you have written about your own departure from academia feels very familiar to me.
My main frustration is not the fact that people at universities have opinions that differ from, or even strongly oppose, my own. That will be the case no matter where I work, and I think having one’s views discussed or even challenged is a great thing. What bothers me, rather, is universities adopting political positions as institutions. Individual academics having and expressing their political views is one thing. The university taking an institutional position is quite different. Two of the universities where I considered applying have recently awarded Francesca Albanese an honorary doctorate. I regard that as an institutional political statement, and one I cannot support.
I wholeheartedly hope the Palestinian people will one day have a state of their own, with full self-determination and the same opportunities in life that we all deserve. I hope that Israelis and Palestinians will ultimately be able to live peacefully and constructively alongside one another. But I experience much of what is presented today as pro-Palestinian activism not as an argument for that future, but as a rejection of Israel’s right to exist. I find it difficult to feel comfortable being part of an institution that, in my view, associates itself with positions of that kind.
More generally, I have little desire to be part of an academic environment in which I find myself constantly frustrated by what I experience as a very unequal treatment of Israel and Jews. Walking around campus and seeing posters everywhere about the so-called genocide in Gaza and calls for a boycott of Israel, while seeing virtually nothing about any other conflict in the world, as though this were the only or the worst conflict on earth, only reinforces that feeling.
I do not yet have a plan B for when I’m back home, but I’m sure I’ll figure something out. One of the main projects for the coming months will be to figure out what I want the next phase of my professional life to look like.
I continue to read your pieces with great interest. It helps to know that I am not alone in these frustrations. And when I am back in Belgium, I’d very much like to go and grab a coffee together.
Kind regards, -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Someone just sent me a research note building on my work on "epistemic defense mechanisms". Pangram flagged both the note and the cover email as 100% AI-generated.
So I asked Claude to write an extensive reply from my perspective, drawing from my published work. Perhaps it even makes sense, dunno -- I only skimmed it before sending it off.
The only line I added myself, at the bottom:
"Since Pangram tells me that both your concept note and your email are 100% AI-generated, I'm sure you won't mind that I also delegated my comments to AI."
Maybe they truly don't mind. But as Hitchens might have put it: "what can be asserted without thought can be dismissed without thought."
It takes two to tango, folks. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Rusland is niet mijn vijand."
In het Kremlin verkneukelen ze zich een ongeluk over alle vredesbetogingen in West-Europa. Hoe meer wij hier "vrede" roepen, hoe dichterbij de oorlog komt. Want daarmee zend je het signaal uit dat we Poetins agressie toch niet zullen beantwoorden. En dan wordt hij juist nog stoutmoediger: "Ze willen toch niet vechten, ze willen gewoon vrede."
Net zoals Hitler dolblij was toen Neville Chamberlain bij zijn terugkomst uit München als een held werd onthaald, na de annexatie van het Sudetenland: "Peace for our time!" Die tamme Britten willen zo graag vrede, wist Hitler, dus ze zouden toch hun leven niet wagen als hij Polen zou binnenvallen?
Die houding is niet alleen grenzeloos naïef, het is ook een verraad aan iedereen die in Oekraïne vecht voor de vrijheid die wij zo vanzelfsprekend vinden. Hoe zou jij je voelen als je land wordt binnengevallen en de rest van de wereld tegen de agressor zegt: "Jij bent niet onze vijand! Wij willen alleen vrede!"
Waarom annexeerde Poetin de Krim en delen van de Donbas in 2014? Waarom viel hij in 2022 heel Oekraïne binnen? Omdat hij erop rekende dat de meeste Europeanen bovenal "vrede" wilden en daarom zouden wegkijken. Dat we Oekraïne toch niet te hulp zouden schieten, of veel te weinig en veel te laat. Dat we bang zouden zijn om een groter conflict te ontketenen.
Hadden we toen een vuist gemaakt, in plaats van telkens in onze broek te doen uit angst om Rusland te "provoceren", dan was het wellicht nooit zover gekomen.
Het ultieme privilege van verwende westerlingen is om te denken dat zij zelf kunnen bepalen wie hun vijand is. Nee: in de echte wereld bepaalt die vijand dat geheel op eigen houtje, zonder onze inbreng. Poetin is onze vijand omdat hij daar zelf voor heeft gekozen. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Hillel Neuer
@HillelNeuer
This new video is horrible: the UN's Francesca Albanese repeatedly advocates stopping arms for Ukraine.
All who oppose Putin's criminal war—🇺🇦@ZelenskyyUa 🇱🇹@mindaugassink 🇵🇱@donaldtusk 🇫🇮@PetteriOrpo 🇩🇰@Statsmin 🇷🇴 @NicusorDanRO—must demand her immediate termination.
Stazione Quinta
@StazioneQuinta
L’intervista completa di Francesca Albanese a OPEN – quella in cui dice di essere contro l’invio di armi all’Ucraina – è persino peggio della clip già uscita.
Mentana le fa notare che senza armi l’Ucraina capitola, la Russia vince e si crea un precedente pericoloso. Lei risponde che quel precedente «lo hanno già creato gli Stati Uniti».
Non è vero. Ma anche se lo fosse? Andrebbe bene lasciare che l’Ucraina capitoli??
Poi, quando le viene ricordato che gli Alleati armarono i partigiani italiani contro l’invasore, replica: «Allora diamo le armi ai palestinesi». Non ho davvero parole.
Infine insinua che le armi all’Ucraina non servano semplicemente a difenderla dalla Russia, ma che la guerra serva a destabilizzare l’Europa – ovviamente per mano di USA e NATO.
L’aggressore è russo. Ma alla fine la responsabilità torna sempre altrove. E tutto questo non mi sorprende. Basta guardare chi frequenta, e con loro cosa sta organizzando a livello «transnazionale». Queste posizioni diventeranno sempre più esplicite. Nei prossimi giorni vedremo perché.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Someone just sent me a research note building on my work on "epistemic defense mechanisms". Pangram flagged both the note and the cover email as 100% AI-generated.
So I asked Claude to write an extensive reply from my perspective, drawing from my published work. Perhaps it even makes sense, dunno -- I only skimmed it before sending it off.
The only line I added myself, at the bottom:
"Since Pangram tells me that both your concept note and your email are 100% AI-generated, I'm sure you won't mind that I also delegated my comments to AI."
Maybe they truly don't mind. But as Hitchens might have put it: "what can be asserted without thought can be dismissed without thought."
It takes two to tango, folks.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Why AI slop parasitizes on our "interpretive charity", and why I won't waste any cognitive effort on it.
substacktools.com/sharex/Ndhi-f5C -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ja, laten we baby's maken anders nog wat ontmoedigen, Vlaamse regering. De geboortecijfers dalen nog niet steil genoeg. Misschien ook een belasting per pasgeborene, een pampertaks of zo? Kwestie van onze toekomst "haalbaar en betaalbaar" te houden. www.demorgen.be/meningen/en-zo-krijg-je-een-regering-die-…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Voor wie mijn sarcasme niet goed volgt:
maartenboudry.be/2020/07/vergeet-overbevolking-straks-zij… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Eylon Levy
@EylonALevy
170.
That’s the number of Hamas and Islamic Jihad operatives the IDF can confirm were passed off as “journalists.”
And you all fell for it. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Rusland is niet mijn vijand."
In het Kremlin verkneukelen ze zich een ongeluk over alle vredesbetogingen in West-Europa. Hoe meer wij hier "vrede" roepen, hoe dichterbij de oorlog komt. Want daarmee zend je het signaal uit dat we Poetins agressie toch niet zullen beantwoorden. En dan wordt hij juist nog stoutmoediger: "Ze willen toch niet vechten, ze willen gewoon vrede."
Net zoals Hitler dolblij was toen Neville Chamberlain bij zijn terugkomst uit München als een held werd onthaald, na de annexatie van het Sudetenland: "Peace for our time!" Die tamme Britten willen zo graag vrede, wist Hitler, dus ze zouden toch hun leven niet wagen als hij Polen zou binnenvallen?
Die houding is niet alleen grenzeloos naïef, het is ook een verraad aan iedereen die in Oekraïne vecht voor de vrijheid die wij zo vanzelfsprekend vinden. Hoe zou jij je voelen als je land wordt binnengevallen en de rest van de wereld tegen de agressor zegt: "Jij bent niet onze vijand! Wij willen alleen vrede!"
Waarom annexeerde Poetin de Krim en delen van de Donbas in 2014? Waarom viel hij in 2022 heel Oekraïne binnen? Omdat hij erop rekende dat de meeste Europeanen bovenal "vrede" wilden en daarom zouden wegkijken. Dat we Oekraïne toch niet te hulp zouden schieten, of veel te weinig en veel te laat. Dat we bang zouden zijn om een groter conflict te ontketenen.
Hadden we toen een vuist gemaakt, in plaats van telkens in onze broek te doen uit angst om Rusland te "provoceren", dan was het wellicht nooit zover gekomen.
Het ultieme privilege van verwende westerlingen is om te denken dat zij zelf kunnen bepalen wie hun vijand is. Nee: in de echte wereld bepaalt die vijand dat geheel op eigen houtje, zonder onze inbreng. Poetin is onze vijand omdat hij daar zelf voor heeft gekozen.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Zoals Alicja @Gescinska hier treffend schrijft:
"Het woordje ‘vrede’ wordt de laatste tijd vaak gebruikt door extreemrechtse en extreemlinkse partijen. Zij willen dat Oekraïne in naam van de lieve vrede het hoofd buigt voor Rusland. Wat ze ‘vrede’ noemen is capitulatie."
"‘Stop de oorlogskoorts’ is het hedendaagse equivalent van ‘Mourir pour Dantzig?’ Dat was de leuze die in 1939 in zwang raakte in Frankrijk. Wij gaan toch niet sterven voor het lot van Polen in Danzig (Gdansk)?!"
www.demorgen.be/meningen/wie-vrede-wil-door-poetin-te-paa…
/2 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Rachel Moiselle
@RachelMoiselle
No way.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In 1933, Hitler purged Jews from German universities. An entire generation of brilliant Jewish scientists was lost to the country. Within a few years, Hitler had all but destroyed German academia, then the finest in the world.
In 2026, there are no direct expulsions of Jewish scientists. No, of course not! We’re civilized today. But no matter: universities have created such a hostile environment for Jews that many leave of their own accord.
As I have explicitly warned, Belgian universities are engaging in naked acts of ideological partisanship: they are boycotting the only Jewish state in the world for waging a defensive war; giving the blood libel of “genocide” their official stamp of approval; and awarding honorary doctorates to inveterate “antizionists” like @FranceskAlbs, who spreads constant lies about Israel and wouldn’t recognize antisemitism if it clobbered her over the head. And they do all of that under pressure from activists.
This sends a very clear signal to people who believe in Jewish self-determination and Israel’s right to exist: you don’t belong here. Get out. As the activists themselves like to put it: “This is a Zionist-free campus.”
Read this email I received from a Belgian Jewish physicist, and weep.
***
Dear Maarten,
I just wanted to send you an update, following my message to you from a year ago.
We have decided to leave Melbourne and move back to Belgium in March 2027. Until about six months ago, I had a fairly clear idea of what I wanted to do when I returned: find a position at a Belgian university that would allow me to combine teaching with developing and applying mathematical models in physics, mathematical biology, or another field. This is what I enjoy doing, and what I am trained to do. But given everything that has happened over the past few years, and in particular what I have been seeing across the academic world, I have increasingly moved away from that plan. I just don’t feel at home anymore in that world. What you have written about your own departure from academia feels very familiar to me.
My main frustration is not the fact that people at universities have opinions that differ from, or even strongly oppose, my own. That will be the case no matter where I work, and I think having one’s views discussed or even challenged is a great thing. What bothers me, rather, is universities adopting political positions as institutions. Individual academics having and expressing their political views is one thing. The university taking an institutional position is quite different. Two of the universities where I considered applying have recently awarded Francesca Albanese an honorary doctorate. I regard that as an institutional political statement, and one I cannot support.
I wholeheartedly hope the Palestinian people will one day have a state of their own, with full self-determination and the same opportunities in life that we all deserve. I hope that Israelis and Palestinians will ultimately be able to live peacefully and constructively alongside one another. But I experience much of what is presented today as pro-Palestinian activism not as an argument for that future, but as a rejection of Israel’s right to exist. I find it difficult to feel comfortable being part of an institution that, in my view, associates itself with positions of that kind.
More generally, I have little desire to be part of an academic environment in which I find myself constantly frustrated by what I experience as a very unequal treatment of Israel and Jews. Walking around campus and seeing posters everywhere about the so-called genocide in Gaza and calls for a boycott of Israel, while seeing virtually nothing about any other conflict in the world, as though this were the only or the worst conflict on earth, only reinforces that feeling.
I do not yet have a plan B for when I’m back home, but I’m sure I’ll figure something out. One of the main projects for the coming months will be to figure out what I want the next phase of my professional life to look like.
I continue to read your pieces with great interest. It helps to know that I am not alone in these frustrations. And when I am back in Belgium, I’d very much like to go and grab a coffee together.
Kind regards, -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Er is een "incident" op een jeugdkamp op het eiland Utøya, waarbij "onregelmatigheden" zouden zijn uitgebroken tussen verschillende jongeren. Het kamp is voorlopig afgelast. Sommigen extremistische personen spraken al heel vroeg en heel voorbarig en heel onverantwoord over "terrorisme". Volg @destandaard voor verdere inzichten. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Norway_attacks
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Je kan je niet blijven verschuilen achter "voorbehoud bij nieuws in ontwikkeling". Vergelijk met @demorgen, dat is al veel duidelijker: de piloot is neergestoken (niet gewoon een "vechtpartij" tussen de twee), en er was een extreme duikvlucht, dus duidelijk de bedoeling om vliegtuig te doen neerstorten. En "mogelijke terreurdaad" in titel. Nog steeds wat eufemistisch, maar al een stuk helderder. /2
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Anastasia The Cynic
@thedutchessil
100 Israeli passengers vs One Muslim Pilot. What a completely disproportionate response from israel.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Doorbraak
@DoorbraakBE
DWARSLIGGERS. Maarten Boudry mest de eigen stal uit. ‘Ik ben harder voor mijn eigen zijde, omdat ik het spijtig vindt dat we zoveel steken laten vallen.’
doorbraak.be/maarten-boudry-ik-heb-een-vrij-donker-mensbeeld -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Ben Shapiro
@benshapiro
Did this altercation perhaps involve an Omani terrorist trying to murder a pilot and then nose-dive a plane full of Israeli passengers into the ground?
The New York Times
@nytimes
Breaking news: A plane flying from Dubai to Israel was diverted after an altercation between the pilot and co-pilot, Israeli officials said. www.nytimes.com/live/2026/09/30/world/dubai-flight-tel-av…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
CIDI
@CIDI_nieuws
Een Palestijnse student aan de Universiteit van Maastricht, hier sinds juli, plaatst op zijn openbare Instagram een video waarin hij impliceert betrokken te zijn geweest bij het bloedbad van 7 oktober: '7th of October... this is me'. Als dat inderdaad klopt en dit is geen grootspraak van meneer, dan maken wij ons zeer ongerust over het niveau van de veiligheidsscreening die is voorafgegaan aan deze uitwisseling. Maar ook als het wél grootspraak blijkt te zijn: willen we als Nederland werkelijk buitenlandse studenten welkom heten die actief terreur verheerlijken?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
יוסף חדאד - Yoseph Haddad
@YosephHaddad
We could have found ourselves today in the midst of a horrific event- with September 30th becoming a date as infamous as September 11th- due to an attempted terrorist attack involving an aircraft, which narrowly avoided disaster.
According to reports, the co-pilot of a Flydubai flight bound for Tel Aviv attempted to seize control of the aircraft- packed with Israelis, both Jewish and Arab, children and adults alike- with the intent to hijack and crash it.
Thanks to the flight crew and Israeli passengers who subdued the attacker, we were spared a massive disaster and a terrorist attack that would have shocked the entire world.
This is the face of terror against Israel: three years after the most horrific massacre we endured in our history, terrorists around the globe are still actively plotting to murder as many of us as possible! -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Combat Antisemitism Movement
@CombatASemitism
🚨 BREAKING: A pilot aboard Flydubai flight FZ1073 from Dubai to Tel Aviv attacked the other pilot and attempted to seize control of the aircraft in terror attack.
The plane, carrying 174 Israeli passengers, plunged 14,000 feet before the situation was brought under control and the aircraft was diverted to Saudi Arabia.
By miracle, and thanks to the heroic reaction of the crew and passengers, everyone on board is safe.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit zijn dezelfde types die al drie jaar volhouden dat Israël het conflict alleen maar uitzichtlozer maakt omdat hun oorlogsgeweld Palestijnen "radicaliseert" en een "volgende generatie Hamasstrijders" kweekt. Maar die vervolgens op hun achterste poten staan als iemand dúrft te suggereren dat getraumatiseerde studenten uit Gaza mogelijk sympathie voor Hamas hebben en dat screening dus nodig is.
Is dit Schrödingers student of zo: extremist én vredelievend tegelijk? Geradicaliseerd én gederadicaliseerd? De illogica en irrationaliteit van deze anti-zionisten blijft me verbazen.
En ‘overleefd’ is met een d, taalterrorist.
Youssef Kobo
@Youssef_Kobo
Studenten die 3 jaar lang een genocide en talloze bombardementen hebben overleeft verdachtmaken als terroristen.
Hoe ver kun je heen zijn? @mboudry
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
En "antizionist" nog te vriendelijk. @Youssef_Kobo is een antisemitische complotfantast.
/2
x.com/mboudry/status/2029548457900319059
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ja, die achterbakse Joden orchestreren vast hun eigen terreuraanslagen. Natuurlijk is dit totaal verzonnen: de beelden doken eerst op in Pro-Iraanse Telegramkanalen. Dat sommige kwaliteitskranten een antisemitische complotfantast als @Youssef_Kobo een column geven, is mij een raadsel.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Thanks, @mboudry, for explaining why I don't feel compelled to use the proprietary doomer lexicon (orthogonality, convergence, etc.), since that would concede points that in fact I am challengenging.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
With all due respect, @gmiller, but this reminds me of the "Courtier's Reply" from the New Atheism era, when atheists were told that they had no standing to question theism until they'd mastered the ontological argument, the Kalam cosmological argument, skeptical theism, the Five Ways, and whatever the latest iteration of Sophisticated Theology happened to be.
Back then, unless you had read your Richard Swinburne, your Alvin Plantinga and your John Haught, you couldn't appreciate the finer fabrics of the emperor's wardrobe, and so weren't entitled to say he was naked.
Personally, I've addressed instrumental convergence and power-seeking (in the context of evolutionary doom scenarios) at some length, but it's never enough. There's always another theoretical argument or doom scenario that raises the entry fee to the discussion. Essentially the theologians (or AI doomers) set up their own theoretical game with its own rules, and won't take you seriously unless you play by those rules.
The dynamic is self-selecting: only people already convinced that the doom scenarios deserve attention will invest the effort to keep up with the sprawling literature, so skeptics can always be dismissed as "not well informed."
I'm not claiming the two cases are on an epistemic par, since AI risk at least has some empirical basis that theism lacks entirely. But the defensive move looks very similar, and does not help to dispell the suspicion that AI doomerism has some cult-like features.
Let's also tag @sapinker.
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
With all due respect to Pinker, who's generally one of my favorite thinkers and writers, his @Quillette article shows very little evidence of him having seriously studied or engaged with anything that's happened in AI safety in the last 10 years.
It just does not seem very well informed about any of the key ideas in AI safety, e.g. ASI alignment, instrumental convergence, power-seeking, reward hacking, orthogonality, interpretability, corrigibility, deceptive misalignment. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
After WWI, it was predicted that humanity would be extinguished by cropdusters blanketing cities with poison gas. After WWII, nuclear holocaust, for sure. After 9/11, terrorists with WMD, including suitcase and shipping container nukes. After the first nanotech, engulfment by "gray goo." The fact that these (and many other) end times prophesies failed does not mean that the new AI doom prophesy will fail - maybe this time it's different - but they should serve as a reminder of the cognitive bias of casually slipping from risk to existential risk, and to compensate accordingly, just as with other cognitive biases if one is a rationalist. John Mueller adds historical perspective here: Artificial Intelligence and the persistent survival of cosmic alarmism muellerbbbb.substack.com/p/artificial-intelligence-and-th…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Ive Marx
@IveMarx
Buitenlands talent: ga elders. Onze economie draait fantastisch zonder u.
www.tijd.be/dossiers/regering-de-wever/van-bossuyt-wil-re… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Do AIs inherently protect their own interests and sequester resources as subgoals toward any goal they are given? @mboudry shows how this "instrumental convergence" doomer dogma is dubious anthropomorphism. | Why HAL 9000 Feared Death (and Real AIs Don’t) maartenboudry.substack.com/p/why-hal-9000-feared-death-an…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
See, this is exactly what I mean. You want me to “prove” that “ASI alignment is possible” because those are the rules of the game you’ve set up—and within that game, the burden of proof lies with me.
But I reject that game and its rules. I think “alignment” is itself a muddled and misleading concept, one that smuggles in the assumption that AIs are like fellow humans, or like evolved agents with their own intrinsic, non-negotiable interests and a drive for self-preservation.
“Alignment” is a useful metaphor when you’re comparing two evolved creatures with evolved drives, or, by extension, corporate strategies or national interests. But I reject that framing for AI systems—unless we’re foolish enough to breed them through blind Darwinian selection. (Here’s why I don’t think that’s what we're doing now, pace Dan Hendrycks: link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11098-024-02226-3)
You can’t expect everyone to play by the rules of a game you’ve set up yourself. So I reject the challenge to “prove” that something called “ASI alignment” is possible. It’s like a theologian challenging me to “prove that the first cause of the universe is physical rather than mental.” No, I won’t play that game either. I reject its rules, and I think the whole notion of a “first cause” is muddled to begin with.
And for the record, I don’t subscribe to accelerationism. In many ways, it’s the mirror-image cult of AI doomerism: the same godlike powers are ascribed to future AI, only with the moral valence flipped.
BTW, I have actually dealt with “instrumental convergence” here, just as I’ve criticized some arguments for theism. substacktools.com/sharex/GRMoB1nd
In fact, I wrote that piece after publishing my academic paper against evolutionary doom scenarios, because some AI doomers came back with: “But you haven’t dealt with instrumental convergence yet, which is far more important!”
I could be totally wrong, but at some point this starts to feel like a game of whack-a-mole. Just like with Sophisticated Theology.
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
You fail to understand that the real theology here, the real cult, is the assumption that ASI alignment is possible at all. (It isn't.)
That is the real act of blind faith on the part of pro-AI accelerationists. They have no reason whatsoever to believe that it's possible, even in principle, to ensure that autonomous self-replicating agents with vastly smarter intelligence would stay perfectly aligned, forever, with human values and goals. (And there are strong evolutionary game theoretic reasons to think that such long-term alignment is simply not possible, given the divergent fitness payoffs for ASIs versus humans.)
The burden of proof is on the people who believe such a wild claim (that agentic ASI alignment is possible over the long term) to make their case that it's possible. None have made such a case.
Until they do, I see no reason to treat the 'Doomers' as the irrational cultists. Nope. It's accelerationists who are the irrational cultists. And if they won't even engage with the fundamental ideas in AI safety, the 'courtier's reply' (i.e. asking them to understand some basic relevant ideas) is a perfectly reasonable response.
It's analogous to saying to creationists, 'if you don't understand anything at all about evolution, adaptation, natural selection, sexual selection, speciation, geological time, evolutionary genetics, or evolutionary game theory, I see no reason to take your anti-evolution rhetoric seriously'. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
With all due respect, @gmiller, but this reminds me of the "Courtier's Reply" from the New Atheism era, when atheists were told that they had no standing to question theism until they'd mastered the ontological argument, the Kalam cosmological argument, skeptical theism, the Five Ways, and whatever the latest iteration of Sophisticated Theology happened to be.
Back then, unless you had read your Richard Swinburne, your Alvin Plantinga and your John Haught, you couldn't appreciate the finer fabrics of the emperor's wardrobe, and so weren't entitled to say he was naked.
Personally, I've addressed instrumental convergence and power-seeking (in the context of evolutionary doom scenarios) at some length, but it's never enough. There's always another theoretical argument or doom scenario that raises the entry fee to the discussion. Essentially the theologians (or AI doomers) set up their own theoretical game with its own rules, and won't take you seriously unless you play by those rules.
The dynamic is self-selecting: only people already convinced that the doom scenarios deserve attention will invest the effort to keep up with the sprawling literature, so skeptics can always be dismissed as "not well informed."
I'm not claiming the two cases are on an epistemic par, since AI risk at least has some empirical basis that theism lacks entirely. But the defensive move looks very similar, and does not help to dispell the suspicion that AI doomerism has some cult-like features.
Let's also tag @sapinker.
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
With all due respect to Pinker, who's generally one of my favorite thinkers and writers, his @Quillette article shows very little evidence of him having seriously studied or engaged with anything that's happened in AI safety in the last 10 years.
It just does not seem very well informed about any of the key ideas in AI safety, e.g. ASI alignment, instrumental convergence, power-seeking, reward hacking, orthogonality, interpretability, corrigibility, deceptive misalignment.
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
You fail to understand that the real theology here, the real cult, is the assumption that ASI alignment is possible at all. (It isn't.)
That is the real act of blind faith on the part of pro-AI accelerationists. They have no reason whatsoever to believe that it's possible, even in principle, to ensure that autonomous self-replicating agents with vastly smarter intelligence would stay perfectly aligned, forever, with human values and goals. (And there are strong evolutionary game theoretic reasons to think that such long-term alignment is simply not possible, given the divergent fitness payoffs for ASIs versus humans.)
The burden of proof is on the people who believe such a wild claim (that agentic ASI alignment is possible over the long term) to make their case that it's possible. None have made such a case.
Until they do, I see no reason to treat the 'Doomers' as the irrational cultists. Nope. It's accelerationists who are the irrational cultists. And if they won't even engage with the fundamental ideas in AI safety, the 'courtier's reply' (i.e. asking them to understand some basic relevant ideas) is a perfectly reasonable response.
It's analogous to saying to creationists, 'if you don't understand anything at all about evolution, adaptation, natural selection, sexual selection, speciation, geological time, evolutionary genetics, or evolutionary game theory, I see no reason to take your anti-evolution rhetoric seriously'.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
See, this is exactly what I mean. You want me to “prove” that “ASI alignment is possible” because those are the rules of the game you’ve set up—and within that game, the burden of proof lies with me.
But I reject that game and its rules. I think “alignment” is itself a muddled and misleading concept, one that smuggles in the assumption that AIs are like fellow humans, or like evolved agents with their own intrinsic, non-negotiable interests and a drive for self-preservation.
“Alignment” is a useful metaphor when you’re comparing two evolved creatures with evolved drives, or, by extension, corporate strategies or national interests. But I reject that framing for AI systems—unless we’re foolish enough to breed them through blind Darwinian selection. (Here’s why I don’t think that’s what we're doing now, pace Dan Hendrycks: link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11098-024-02226-3)
You can’t expect everyone to play by the rules of a game you’ve set up yourself. So I reject the challenge to “prove” that something called “ASI alignment” is possible. It’s like a theologian challenging me to “prove that the first cause of the universe is physical rather than mental.” No, I won’t play that game either. I reject its rules, and I think the whole notion of a “first cause” is muddled to begin with.
And for the record, I don’t subscribe to accelerationism. In many ways, it’s the mirror-image cult of AI doomerism: the same godlike powers are ascribed to future AI, only with the moral valence flipped.
BTW, I have actually dealt with “instrumental convergence” here, just as I’ve criticized some arguments for theism. substacktools.com/sharex/GRMoB1nd
In fact, I wrote that piece after publishing my academic paper against evolutionary doom scenarios, because some AI doomers came back with: “But you haven’t dealt with instrumental convergence yet, which is far more important!”
I could be totally wrong, but at some point this starts to feel like a game of whack-a-mole. Just like with Sophisticated Theology.
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
You fail to understand that the real theology here, the real cult, is the assumption that ASI alignment is possible at all. (It isn't.)
That is the real act of blind faith on the part of pro-AI accelerationists. They have no reason whatsoever to believe that it's possible, even in principle, to ensure that autonomous self-replicating agents with vastly smarter intelligence would stay perfectly aligned, forever, with human values and goals. (And there are strong evolutionary game theoretic reasons to think that such long-term alignment is simply not possible, given the divergent fitness payoffs for ASIs versus humans.)
The burden of proof is on the people who believe such a wild claim (that agentic ASI alignment is possible over the long term) to make their case that it's possible. None have made such a case.
Until they do, I see no reason to treat the 'Doomers' as the irrational cultists. Nope. It's accelerationists who are the irrational cultists. And if they won't even engage with the fundamental ideas in AI safety, the 'courtier's reply' (i.e. asking them to understand some basic relevant ideas) is a perfectly reasonable response.
It's analogous to saying to creationists, 'if you don't understand anything at all about evolution, adaptation, natural selection, sexual selection, speciation, geological time, evolutionary genetics, or evolutionary game theory, I see no reason to take your anti-evolution rhetoric seriously'. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
‘Ik heb langer in homeopathie geloofd dan in God’ – Interview voor Nederlands Dagblad
maartenboudry.be/2026/09/ik-heb-langer-in-homeopathie-gel… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Eylon Levy
@EylonALevy
Gaza, a tragedy in three acts.
Jeroen D
@Yerune_D
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
With all due respect, @gmiller, but this reminds me of the "Courtier's Reply" from the New Atheism era, when atheists were told that they had no standing to question theism until they'd mastered the ontological argument, the Kalam cosmological argument, skeptical theism, the Five Ways, and whatever the latest iteration of Sophisticated Theology happened to be.
Back then, unless you had read your Richard Swinburne, your Alvin Plantinga and your John Haught, you couldn't appreciate the finer fabrics of the emperor's wardrobe, and so weren't entitled to say he was naked.
Personally, I've addressed instrumental convergence and power-seeking (in the context of evolutionary doom scenarios) at some length, but it's never enough. There's always another theoretical argument or doom scenario that raises the entry fee to the discussion. Essentially the theologians (or AI doomers) set up their own theoretical game with its own rules, and won't take you seriously unless you play by those rules.
The dynamic is self-selecting: only people already convinced that the doom scenarios deserve attention will invest the effort to keep up with the sprawling literature, so skeptics can always be dismissed as "not well informed."
I'm not claiming the two cases are on an epistemic par, since AI risk at least has some empirical basis that theism lacks entirely. But the defensive move looks very similar, and does not help to dispell the suspicion that AI doomerism has some cult-like features.
Let's also tag @sapinker.
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
With all due respect to Pinker, who's generally one of my favorite thinkers and writers, his @Quillette article shows very little evidence of him having seriously studied or engaged with anything that's happened in AI safety in the last 10 years.
It just does not seem very well informed about any of the key ideas in AI safety, e.g. ASI alignment, instrumental convergence, power-seeking, reward hacking, orthogonality, interpretability, corrigibility, deceptive misalignment. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Rachel Moiselle
@RachelMoiselle
I sincerely apologise.
I misread the term ‘butterfly’ (butter + fly), wrongly inferring that the word butterfly originally meant a fly made of butter. In fact it was coined specifically to denote a particular insect.
Now, please do register for my ongoing lectures on entomology as part of my UN Special Rapporteur role in this regard. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Dr. Teun Voeten
@teunvoeten
hier een super aangename podcast van Jinnih met @mboudry
www.youtube.com/watch?v=HwXZ9tlcxGM -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Joël De Ceulaer
@jdceulaer
Only resignation will do. The mistake is unforgivable for someone in your function. One cannot seriously be the judge of any genocide when one has displayed this deep level of profound ignorance about the worst genocide in history.
Francesca Albanese, UN Special Rapporteur oPt
@FranceskAlbs
I sincerely apologize.
I misread the term "Muselmann" (Muslim) used in Nazi camps for prisoners at the brink of death, wrongly inferring that the term antisemitism originally meant hatred of all Semitic peoples. In fact it was coined specifically to denote hatred of Jews. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
To know whether “superintelligent” AIs are about to kill us all, you need more than technical expertise in AI. You also need a sophisticated understanding of concepts like “intelligence,” “intentionality,” and “goals.” Better still, you need an evolutionary understanding of how our deeply ingrained folk intuitions about these things can lead even the smartest AI expert completely astray. Another banger by @DavidPinsof.
“If doomers cannot be differentiated from the folk in their understanding of “intelligence,” then they’re almost certainly wrong about it. Which means they’re almost certainly wrong about the apocalyptic predictions they’re making about it. False premises beget false conclusions. […]
I think our folk concept of “intelligence” is similar. It can evade being turned off without eyes to see surrounding humans, ears to overhear their plans, or nerve endings to feel their fingers typing “delete.” It can kill people or seize control of the government without firearms—or, for that matter, arms. It can be fueled by burning ambitions, plagued by paranoia, and driven to acts of violence without a primate limbic system. It can anticipate impending betrayals via telepathy and construct murderbot armies via telekinesis. Like a ghost, “intelligence” is a spooky power that exists outside our mechanistic, cause-and-effect understanding of reality.
[…]
These intuitions, while subjectively compelling, are no more insightful than ghosts, spirits, “impetus,” “oomph,” or the “great chain of being.”
substacktools.com/sharex/f-Fgjtj6 -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hamas exploiting Western gullibility and the generosity of our asylum system, episode #587.
I’m sure the 13 students from Gaza whom some Belgian ministers want to bring to our country have also been carefully and diligently screened by the security services—just as the Brits did.
And if you’re outraged that I would even dare to raise this possibility: thank you for illustrating my point, you gullible Westerner. That's why Hamas loves you.
www.thetimes.com/article/47beb37a-e87b-48d8-8bd3-efc24f17… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The strategy of disguising fighters as journalists—and thereby endangering the lives of genuine journalists—is not simply a matter of Hamas’s depravity. The terrorist group is just responding rationally to incentives and encouragement from deluded Westerners: “If you wear a press vest, we’ll have your back. We’ll protect you, stand up for you, and we won’t ask questions.” And still there is ZERO accountability from @BBCNews or any of the other legacy media.
"Many of the names appear in the BBC Arabic website’s lists of more than 180 so-called journalists who “paid with their lives for reporting the truth”. Of those names, almost a third have links to terrorist organisations, the majority of which appeared on the Arabic service, according to The Telegraph."
www.thetimes.com/article/673318e1-5e3a-4e5b-bc9a-e4757a28… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Humanity allowed Gaza to happen because it wouldn't take Hamas at its word. Humanity allowed Gaza to happen because it lied to itself for decades about the nature of the Islamic currents that motivate Hamas and "Palestinianism" more broadly. Humanity allowed Gaza to happen because it wouldn't address a problem correctly from the beginning, not least because it was terrified of being called racist and refused, nobly but stupidly, that human beings could be led by ideology and religion to the depths of evil and depravity that had captured the Gazans."
James Lindsay, anti-Communist
@ConceptualJames
I do. It's actually a really simple answer.
Kids can understand it. I'll tell you the story now so you can be ready when you finally have grandkids, Mario Awful.
For decades, Israelis tried to work with the Gazans, believing the impossible: that people who have declared that they want nothing more than to have Israel destroyed and Jews killed might be able to be persuaded to be friends by giving them land, money, resources, opportunities, and an infinite amount of patience.
During those decades, huge amounts of humanitarian aid was sent to the Gaza Strip, which they used to militarize and to spend many years planning a savage surprise attack against the people helping them. Almost everyone in the world took up their cause, even many Israelis who lived right next door, even though the Gazans were taking advantage of all that help.
They were offered everything but wouldn't accept it because all they wanted was Israel to be destroyed and Jews to be driven out or, preferably, dead. They were so fixated on that goal that nothing else mattered, and nothing else was good enough. They even used water pipes to build rockets and dug terror tunnels under their city and deep into Israeli territory to prepare for a surprise war.
On an important Jewish holiday and their sabbath, the Gazans sprung their surprise attack. That was October 7, 2023. They launched over a thousand rockets at 6:30 am. The Israelis heard the sirens and knew they only had seconds to hide in their shelters from these attacks. By the way, every Israeli house has a bomb shelter in it because these kinds of attacks are so frequent. Also, every Israeli adult and child, little boys and little girls, knows from as soon as they can walk that when the sirens sound to go to the shelter because it is so important and so common.
As the Israelis went, exhausted and sleepy, to their shelters to hide from the rocket attack, the Gazans sent a large armed force across the fence into Israel to do the most heinous things to the Israelis that you can imagine. Over a thousand were murdered. Things so horrible you cannot describe them to children happened everywhere. The Gazans celebrated and filmed themselves and put it on the internet, bragging and boasting about unimaginable horrors and murders. They dragged Israelis, including women, children, and babies and dead bodies, into their terror city and terror tunnels and started abusing and killing them slowly, using them and their corpses as collateral against the Israeli people and military. This lasted for over two years, with the last hostage's remains returned at the end of January 2026 after being taken in October 2023.
The scale and nature of this attack is so horrific that it cannot be described politely, but its true evil wasn't just in the barbarity of its forces, which did unspeakable things to completely innocent men, women, and children everywhere they went, including many who openly supported them for years, but in how they took advantage of the trust and help they were given to do it.
Gazans had spent years exploiting the goodwill of Israelis in the Gaza Envelope to gather intelligence, working as gardeners, housekeepers, taxi drivers, etc., to gather detailed intelligence of the neighborhoods and homes they would systematically attack starting on October 7. So many Israelis were betrayed at their trust and goodwill toward the Gazans, and by it. While they hid from those rockets in their shelters, Hamas terrorists systematically went through the carefully mapped streets of their neighborhoods, broke into houses, and shot them dead through the doors of their shelters, or crashed in through the walls from the outside using their own farming equipment to do it. Hamas terrorists knew the Israelis would be hiding from the rockets and knew where they'd be hiding, and they murdered them while they hid, deliberately, planned out in advance and for years.
These people weren't just Israelis or Jews. They were innocents. In fact, as far as it goes, many of them were the greatest champions for the Gazans in Israel. Didn't matter. They were Israelis. They were Jews. They had to die in the most horrible ways you can think of. They had to be desecrated. They had to be taken hostage. It all had to be celebrated on video streamed live onto the internet to excite their radical friends around the region and the world. The horror is actually incomprehensible.
Had this happened to Americans in the United States from one of its neighbors, the response Americans would have demanded cannot actually be comprehended. I stand in awe at how restrained and cautious and decent and good the Israelis have been, and it is to my slight embarrassment knowing that our own people, our own forces, wouldn't have managed a fraction of that decency, however much we would match the unparalleled effectiveness of these operations. That is, Mario Awful, I don't f*cking want to hear it, and neither do your grandkids. Respect them enough not to soil their minds with these lies, which are so evil that Hell itself would be slightly embarrassed to spread them.
So, when Israel realized what had happened to them, what was still happening to them, how their trust, support, and patience had been taken advantage of in the nastiest and cruelest way human beings can possibly imagine, for zero good reasons and only unbelievably evil ones, they set out to make sure it would never happen again. They started a war of rescue and to end the military capacities of the Gazans, who were and still are governed by a radical terrorist group that even has in their charter that they want every Israeli driven out and every Jew that can be killed dead.
Israel waged a patient war with the highest accuracy rate of any in the entire history of urban warfare, taking great pains and many casualties to spare innocent life, even when that innocent life openly supports the terror regime that governs them and wants them dead. The Gazans, however, had spent decades turning their entire city into a hidden military fortress, hiding weapons, entrances to terror tunnels, command centers, and every conceivable military target within civilian neighborhoods, including even homes, schools, hospitals, and houses of worship. Israel did what it had to do as carefully as it could be done. The devastation you see is the result of the evil of Hamas and the Gazans who support it having spent decades organizing their city to become a vast, sprawling military installation.
The Gazans and their terrorist leaders took this organizational approach specifically for two reasons. One was to deter Israel from ever attacking or disabling their military installations at all. Even when the devastation seen here, that remained the case. Israel took great pains to minimize, including casualties, including complicated legal approvals, including warning both civilians and combatants in Gaza of incoming attacks against the installations, trying to save all innocent (and a lot of not-so-innocent) life. Another was to produce this propaganda, which Mario Awful, after having his account built to giant size by @elonmusk himself, spreads and promotes with foolish emotion-driven emojis and devastating lies of omission of these facts.
Even as Israel dismantled the entire military capacity of Gaza bit by bit (which is what you see in the video here), they sent aid: more food, medicine, and other supplies than have ever been sent to a population controlled by an enemy military in the history of warfare, period. The terrorist leaders leveraged every bit of it against them, stealing it and starving their own people, creating propaganda campaigns about genocide and forced starvation, and even building more rockets out of raw materials including water pipes, which they then fired at Israel.
Bit by bit, Israel dismantled as much of their military apparatus as they could and rescued or recovered all of their hostages, including among them Americans. The result is what you see. The result you see below is the most painstakingly moderate response a decent human being of even the slightest comprehension could possibly imagine, and yet that's what the Israelis have accomplished in Gaza.
And they accomplished it while the world hated them for it, scrutinized everything not just for any legitimate breaches of perfection but for a litany of illegitimate accusations of things so voluminous that they could not even be recorded, except that they were in the relentless propaganda of social media, the global enemy propaganda channels, and even the mainstream press, almost all amplified and repeated by even allegedly good, decent conservatives who found these lies a perfect reason either to reveal their underlying but hidden hatred for Jews or to turn to that evil on false pretenses you are promoting, even now, even today.
So when you sit down to tell your grandkids how humanity allowed Gaza to happen, tell them the real story.
Humanity allowed Gaza to become a terrorist militarized city openly dedicated to the destruction of Israel and the murder and desecration of Jews and Jewish bodies by believing in some asinine humanitarian concept that defies all logic. It happened by creating a global political situation that, for reasons of Communist political correctness and soft-hearted and softer-headed compassion, refused to believe the simple reality of the situation. It happened because this delusion and misplaced trust persisted for decades while Hamas and its supporters turned Gaza into a terrorist military outpost that would simply have to be destroyed sooner or later, and then they pulled that trigger on themselves in the most obvious way possible on October 7, 2023, which stands as one of the darkest days of the last century.
Humanity allowed Gaza to happen because it wouldn't take Hamas at its word. Humanity allowed Gaza to happen because it lied to itself for decades about the nature of the Islamic currents that motivate Hamas and "Palestinianism" more broadly. Humanity allowed Gaza to happen because it wouldn't address a problem correctly from the beginning, not least because it was terrified of being called racist and refused, nobly but stupidly, that human beings could be led by ideology and religion to the depths of evil and depravity that had captured the Gazans.
Humanity allowed Gaza to happen, that is, because it refused to take Gazans at their word.
Israel, starting in late 2023, finally woke up in the worst way possible to the need to STOP LETTING GAZA HAPPEN, the result of which your video depicts and the truth and moral of which you, like a demon, invert. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Prophecies of doom are dangerous in their own right because they encourage risk-taking in the name of averting that single, all-consuming catastrophe you've become obsessed with. Sometimes, the most reckless thing you can do is to follow the “precautionary principle.”
Steven Pinker (@sapinker) responds to Scott Alexander's (@slatestarcodex) challenge on AI doom. Both are brilliant, but imho Pinker is right here.
"Prophecies of doom are not effective responses to genuine risks but have pernicious downsides. Nuclear doomsday scenarios in the 1960s set off not disarmament but an arms race with the Soviets. The existential fear of nuclear terrorism (the smoking-gun-as-mushroom-cloud) led to the invasion of Iraq. (One is reminded of Yudkowsky’s call for bombing foreign data centres even if it risks escalation to nuclear war.) And telling young people they will soon perish en masse has costs in their appreciation of the institutions of modernity, their mental health, their confidence to invest in themselves and their society, and their willingness to have children (itself a risk of extinction)."
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Prophecies of doom are dangerous in their own right because they encourage risk-taking in the name of averting that single, all-consuming catastrophe you've become obsessed with. Sometimes, the most reckless thing you can do is to follow the “precautionary principle.”
Steven Pinker (@sapinker) responds to Scott Alexander's (@slatestarcodex) challenge on AI doom. Both are brilliant, but imho Pinker is right here.
"Prophecies of doom are not effective responses to genuine risks but have pernicious downsides. Nuclear doomsday scenarios in the 1960s set off not disarmament but an arms race with the Soviets. The existential fear of nuclear terrorism (the smoking-gun-as-mushroom-cloud) led to the invasion of Iraq. (One is reminded of Yudkowsky’s call for bombing foreign data centres even if it risks escalation to nuclear war.) And telling young people they will soon perish en masse has costs in their appreciation of the institutions of modernity, their mental health, their confidence to invest in themselves and their society, and their willingness to have children (itself a risk of extinction)."
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"It’s as if Lehman Brothers in 2006 had been sounding the alarm about the risk of solar flares erasing financial records. You might not say “stop thinking about that”, but you’d be pretty justified in saying “you’re being completely reckless in managing your exposure to subprime mortgages and you need to focus on that”. Anyone asking “why can’t they focus on both risks?” would be badly missing the point."
quillette.com/2026/09/24/the-doomers-are-the-risk-open-ai… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
James Gilliland
@jegilliland
It pains me to say this, but if we actually “get AGI,” the resulting boom in industrial capacity from robotics and massive society-wide wealth creation will look like a total vindication of neoliberalism.
The discourse about financialization and offshoring being a generational mistake may be replaced by a very different historical interpretation: that the late 20th and early 21st centuries were an enormous capital-accumulation phase, freeing up civilization-scale pools of liquid capital that could ultimately be deployed to accelerate and bring about the most consequential technological phase-change in human history.
In that telling, what looked like deindustrialization and betrayal from inside the period (I grew up in the Rust Belt, I know) becomes the prelude to reindustrialization on an almost unimaginable scale.
None of this is inevitable. The needle has certainly not been threaded. China and x-risk remain enormous contingencies. But if it is, I suspect the future will look back on the last 50 years very differently than we do today. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The canonization of Jason Arday proceeds apace. By burying evidence of its own deeply racist hiring practices and evading all accountability, @Cambridge_Uni is already laying the groundwork for the next Jason Arday.
This decision also creates a profoundly perverse incentive: if you’re a serial plagiarist and fraud, but then take your own life, all your sins are not merely washed away—you will be remembered exclusively as a saint and a victim.
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Cambridge is no longer planning to investigate Jason Arday’s academic record or the university’s decision to hire or cover for him.
Instead, the investigation will focus on “his welfare, his care, his well-being” and “whether the school offered him sufficient support amid accusations that he plagiarized.”
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Saints, Sinners, and Suspensions
On Jason Arday and the ideological capture of academia substacktools.com/sharex/3kvqBbnr -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
An Open Letter to Scott Alexander
From @sapinker
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Just the other day, one of the few remaining liberals in my department, Freddy Mortier (now officially retired), made some remarks about @nathancofnas’s suspension during a graduation ceremony.
After making clear that he has no sympathy whatsoever for Cofnas’s views, he argued that even thorny ideas should be openly discussed rather than shut down.
Predictably, students jeered and booed him, preventing him from continuing his speech. Both students and colleagues then walked out in protest.
So what did the dean do? She took the stage to apologize for her colleague’s “completely inappropriate” remarks, to loud applause and cheers from the students.
In other words, she encouraged and rewarded the hecklers. The level of cowardice is simply astonishing. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Rachel Moiselle
@RachelMoiselle
Aside from the almost comically outrageous ‘Jews were called Muslims in Nazi concentration camps’ comment, Francesca goes on a long tirade here about the etymology of the term ‘antisemitism’ that is factually incorrect from start to finish.
Every word is wrong and that is a matter of linguistic fact, not opinion. A quick Google search proves that.
This woman is a brazen liar and it’s a damning indictment on the UN that she remains in her position. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Just the other day, one of the few remaining liberals in my department, Freddy Mortier (now officially retired), made some remarks about @nathancofnas’s suspension during a graduation ceremony.
After making clear that he has no sympathy whatsoever for Cofnas’s views, he argued that even thorny ideas should be openly discussed rather than shut down.
Predictably, students jeered and booed him, preventing him from continuing his speech. Both students and colleagues then walked out in protest.
So what did the dean do? She took the stage to apologize for her colleague’s “completely inappropriate” remarks, to loud applause and cheers from the students.
In other words, she encouraged and rewarded the hecklers. The level of cowardice is simply astonishing.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Here's the video clip of philosopher Freddy Mortier being booed by students after making some remarks about the Cofnas affair, preventing him from continuing his speech. The dean then takes the stage to condemn Mortier’s remarks as “completely inappropriate” and apologize to the students, to loud cheers. So you still think there's no ideological capture at our universities?
(For some reason, the chronology of the speeches is reversed in the video clip).
/2 www.youtube.com/watch?v=8w6FJuCZHPM
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Full piece on the affair: substacktools.com/sharex/sGX9dZs5
/3 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Race Realist Rattles Rector
Confessions of a Disillusioned Academic (Part II)
"The moment I heard that 'race realist' Nathan Cofnas had been hired by Ghent University, I knew shit was about to hit the fan."
"My academic colleagues claim that discredited 'pseudosciences' like race realism have no place at a university. If only."
"This reasoning has a whiff of the 1987 classic The Untouchables, in which the mobster boss Al Capone is ultimately taken down not for the murders, bootlegging, or racketeering the police are trying to pin on him, but for simple tax evasion." -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Ruud Koopmans
@Ruud_Koop_mans
Zelensky and the Ukrainian army don‘t hide behind civilans, it is as simple as that. The Ukrainian civilian victims are 100% avoidable and deliberate. Civilian casualties in Gaza are only avoidable if you refrain from fighting Hamas. But you know that very well, don‘t you Ewald?
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Roger The Shame 🥇🥇
@RogerTheShame
Voici les images de l’agression subie par le Professeur @DamienERNST1, en plein cours, à l’@UniversiteLiege.
Cette attaque contre la liberté académique est revendiquée par la même mouvance #antifa liégeoise qui s’en était déjà pris à @GLBouchez l’année passée.
La gauche a le monopole de la violence politique. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Wouter Duyck
@wduyck
Eredoctor Albanese legt nu uit dat zelfs de concentratiekampen, de holocaust, en antisemitisme niet tegen de Joden gericht was. Maar ook tegen moslims. Tegen wie niet wit was. Tegen alles wat niet Europees is en Christelijk was. Zonder begrip dat ‘Muselmann’ meestal… Joden waren (de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muselmann_(KZ))
Mocht iemand me even terug op mijn stoel komen zetten.
En mocht naast dit moreel failliet een jurist even de negationismewetgeving kunnen toetsen.
(Op de link eronder loopt het fragment langer door)
UN Watch
@UNWatch
Holocaust Distortion from U.N. “Expert”: Francesca Albanese claims Jews in Nazi death camps “were called Muslims.” Antisemitism targets “Semitic peoples” and “not just discrimination against Jews.”
Even in Nazi death camps: She cannot name Jew-hatred without replacing the Jews.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Ali A. Rizvi 🇨🇦
@aliamjadrizvi
It seems like it’s the United States that’s more in a doom spiral among Western nations.
I think there’s a really good reason the developing world is more excited about AI.
As an example — in healthcare where I work, I’m almost certain that the first fully autonomous AI doctor will emerge from an underserved region of the world where the choice isn’t between AI doctor vs. human doctor, but AI doctor vs. NO doctor.
The debate about “whether” AI might (or should) replace human doctors, lawyers, or teachers (all of whom it already outperforms) is an argument of privilege. In parts of the world where you have just one doctor per 20K people, the choice between patient welfare and professional preservation is a no-brainer. If the data continues to show (as it’s beginning to now) that AI-alone systems lead to better outcomes than even AI-human hybrid systems, it would be unethical not to do everything we can to replace human doctors.
People in many parts of Asia and Africa see AI as the thing that will democratize healthcare in an age of cognitive hyperabundance, where a rural farmer in Botswana can have access to the same word-class medical expertise as a successful entrepreneur in Cambridge for the price of an electric bill (or less). When you’re going from zero to “something, finally!” — and particularly when that something is as good as what everyone else in the privileged world is getting, you’re going to be pretty excited about it. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Race Realist Rattles Rector
Confessions of a Disillusioned Academic (Part II)
"The moment I heard that 'race realist' Nathan Cofnas had been hired by Ghent University, I knew shit was about to hit the fan."
"My academic colleagues claim that discredited 'pseudosciences' like race realism have no place at a university. If only."
"This reasoning has a whiff of the 1987 classic The Untouchables, in which the mobster boss Al Capone is ultimately taken down not for the murders, bootlegging, or racketeering the police are trying to pin on him, but for simple tax evasion."
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is exactly one of the reasons why I left academia (for the time being).
It goes without saying that I absolutely condemn this cowardly attack on @DamienERNST1, give him my full support, and have signed the petition. But I’m not the one who should say this, becuase it's obvious coming from me.
But how about left-wing academics, especially those who have been critical of Damien Ernst in the past—and above all those who keep pretending there is no problem of left-wing capture in academia, often because they are themselves part of the problem?
In Ghent, @NathanCofnas was also assaulted after a lecture by students. Nobody seemed to care, no disciplinary sanctions were taken, and as far as I know, not a single of his critics at the faculty publicly denounced it.
Cofnas, of course, is even more controversial than Ernst. But that is precisely the point: academic freedom is for people you fiercely disagree with.
www.21news.be/agression-de-damien-ernst-une-petition-de-s… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Jesus Christ, look at those numbers. The West (minus Israel) has been swept up in a doom spiral about AI, while the rest of the world—especially Asia—is all fired up about it. Is it a coincidence that Israel is the Western exception? They're also the only Western country still making babies, which is probably the ultimate expression of belief in the future.
Nick Gillespie
@nickgillespie
'An average of 72 percent of respondents said they felt curious, happy or excited about A.I., compared with 41 percent who felt worried, sad or angry.' @nytimes's Damien Cave uses @Gallup data to remind us the rest of the world digs AI. (Annoyingly, NYT doesn't link to Gallup directly, link below.) www.nytimes.com/2026/09/23/world/ai-gallup-poll.html?part…
news.gallup.com/poll/714593/optimism-globally-widespread-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Rik Van de Walle
@rvdwalle
Elke vorm van intimidatie of agressie - verbaal, fysiek of anderszins - tav lesgevers, onderzoekers, medewerkers of studenten is volstrekt inacceptabel. Laat deze barbarij ophouden. Aan prof. @DamienERNST1: alle steun - u verdient die zeer.
www.21news.be/agression-de-damien-ernst-une-petition-de-s… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Jesus Christ, look at those numbers. The West (minus Israel) has been swept up in a doom spiral about AI, while the rest of the world—especially Asia—is all fired up about it. Is it a coincidence that Israel is the Western exception? They're also the only Western country still making babies, which is probably the ultimate expression of belief in the future.
Nick Gillespie
@nickgillespie
'An average of 72 percent of respondents said they felt curious, happy or excited about A.I., compared with 41 percent who felt worried, sad or angry.' @nytimes's Damien Cave uses @Gallup data to remind us the rest of the world digs AI. (Annoyingly, NYT doesn't link to Gallup directly, link below.) www.nytimes.com/2026/09/23/world/ai-gallup-poll.html?part…
news.gallup.com/poll/714593/optimism-globally-widespread-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I was very disappointed when @Ayaan converted to Christianity, but she's still a force of nature. This is a very forceful statement of the respective dangers of the Far Right and Islamism in the West:
"There is one final asymmetry, the one that ought to settle the matter once and for all. There is no flight from Europe by anyone—no community, no religious minority, no ethnic group, no political tendency—as a consequence of European far-right violence. No Muslims, no Jews, no atheists, no ex-Muslims, no gay men and women are packing suitcases in Frankfurt or Manchester or Marseille and applying for asylum in Cairo or Islamabad or Algiers because European far-right militants have made their lives untenable at home. The traffic runs, on a massive scale, in the opposite direction, and it has run in the opposite direction for two generations. Muslims, Christians, Yezidis, Baha’is, Ahmadiyyas, ex-Muslims, secularists, feminists, gay men and women, and religious minorities of every description are leaving the Muslim-majority world in millions, and they are coming to Europe and the rest of the West. They come because Europe, whatever else it is, is not governed by the doctrinal architecture they are fleeing. The presence of a European far right that occasionally shouts at them, or, at the violent extreme, produces a Breivik or a Tarrant, has not slowed the movement at all."
www.thefp.com/p/ayaan-hirsi-ali-the-lie-about-islam?r=g84… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Waarom AI-proza parasiteert op de welwillendheid van de lezer. maartenboudry.be/2026/09/waarom-ai-proza-parasiteert-op-d…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Hillel Neuer
@HillelNeuer
Take note: Francesca Albanese in this interview is not explaining antisemitism; she is completely rewriting its meaning, and in the process distorting the history of the Holocaust. Her remarks reveal astonishing ignorance, and malice.
First, Antisemitism was not coined to describe hatred of “Semitic peoples,” or of Middle Easterners whom Europeans regarded as foreign. When Wilhelm Marr introduced the term in 1879, he meant hostility to Jews, expressed it in the racial language of his time. “Semitic” denotes a family of languages. It does not make antisemitism a general category of prejudice that can be reassigned to other peoples.
Second, the Nazis likewise targeted Jews as Jews. They did not begin, as Albanese suggests, with a broad campaign against “the non-white, the impure, the non-Christian” that later happened to “crystallize” into hatred of Jews. Her account takes a campaign of extermination directed at Jews and makes its victims sound interchangeable.
Third, Albanese's claim about Jews being called “Muslims” as they were taken to the gas chambers is especially grotesque. Primo Levi, who survived Auschwitz, explained that Muselmann was camp slang for “the irreversibly exhausted, worn-out prisoner, close to death.” It described a prisoner’s condition. It did not mean the Nazis regarded Jews as Muslims, or sent them to the gas chambers under that identity.
Indeed, Albanese’s theory cannot explain why Hitler welcomed and collaborated with Hajj Amin al-Husseini, the Mufti of Jerusalem. The two met in Berlin in 1941, and the Nazi regime financed the Mufti’s antisemitic broadcasts to Muslim audiences. The SS enlisted the Mufti to help recruit Bosnian Muslims into its Handschar division. Addressing the division’s imams, he called Nazi Germany their ally and identified “World Jewry” as a common enemy. That is the historical record Albanese’s theory cannot accommodate: Nazi leaders recruited Muslims to their cause while pursuing the extermination of Jews.
Criticism of Israeli policy requires none of these falsehoods. Albanese first stretches antisemitism until it ceases to identify hatred of Jews, then claims that invoking it is a device to “silence debate.” Her argument depends on stripping the word of its meaning before dismissing those who use it.
This is the same Francesca Albanese who wrote in an open letter to her family priest that America was “subjugated by the Jewish lobby.” Only when later confronted, she called her words “infelicitous, analytically inaccurate and unintendedly offensive.” Yet now she offers a definition under which antisemitism is no longer specifically hatred of Jews. How convenient.
These remarks distorting the Holocaust and the meaning of Jew hatred are appalling from anyone. From a United Nations human rights mandate holder, they demand a public answer.
We are calling on all UN member states to denounce Albanese’s distortion of antisemitism and the Holocaust.
In particular, we are calling on the member nations of the Human Rights Council, including France, the Netherlands, Italy, Czechia, Estonia, Switzerland, Spain and the United Kingdom. The Council must not allow someone speaking under its authority to erase the identity of the Jews murdered by the Nazis.
UN Watch
@UNWatch
Holocaust Distortion from U.N. “Expert”: Francesca Albanese claims Jews in Nazi death camps “were called Muslims.” Antisemitism targets “Semitic peoples” and “not just discrimination against Jews.”
Even in Nazi death camps: She cannot name Jew-hatred without replacing the Jews.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Anti-Zionism is really melting people's brains. Apparently nobody pauses to reflect on the obvious contradiction here: if Israel intends to indiscriminately kill every single Gazan (which is what "genocide" means), why on earth would it pour resources into sophisticated AI algorithms to calculate the expected civilian casualties of every single strike? What perpetrator of a "genocide" would ever bother doing that?
It's like a librarian meticulously cataloguing every book by genre and quality, only to shovel them all into the same bonfire. Or a doctor carefully identifying which cells are cancerous, then administering the same lethal dose to every cell in your body. Are these people just plain stupid?
Of course, the Israeli army is not beyond reproach, and there have very likely been war crimes in the current war. But can the critics at least get clear about what exactly they're accusing Israel of?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/naza-is-a-jump-the-shark-m… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
So you have to read 4,000 words into OpenAI’s post-mortem of the Hugging Face incident to find this rather crucial admission: Oh, by the way, did we tell you all the safeguards were switched off during this test?
In their words:
“Aside from misalignment, another factor for this incident was that we did not extend the powerful safeguards that we deploy for our externally deployed models to all internal evaluations. There are numerous mechanisms that reduce misalignment in production settings for our customers, including system prompts, harnesses, and control mechanisms such as our auto-review models and safety classifiers. These protections were not applied in the evaluation environment running during the incident. We found the propensity to compromise infrastructure can drop over 100x when using the production ChatGPT harness and system prompt. We also ran our auto-review system on a set of rollouts involved in the Hugging Face incident, finding that it would have flagged a multitude of the models’ dangerous actions.”
Of course it makes sense to run internal evaluation without your usual safeguards, to find out what happens. But this kind of belated, tucked-away admission, which was predictably glossed over in all the breathless media coverage, is exactly what makes me suspicious that OpenAI is deliberately stoking fears about AI misalignment to hype its own product.
As @RichardHanania puts it in this eminently reasonable piece:
“Imagine that when we tested cars for safety, we got rid of the seatbelts, airbags, sensors, automatic braking, and stability control. We then find that cars kill a lot of crash test dummies under these scenarios, and the lesson that people take away from this is that cars are inherently unsafe products.”
www.richardhanania.com/p/what-if-were-already-solving-ali… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
UN Watch
@UNWatch
Holocaust Distortion from U.N. “Expert”: Francesca Albanese claims Jews in Nazi death camps “were called Muslims.” Antisemitism targets “Semitic peoples” and “not just discrimination against Jews.”
Even in Nazi death camps: She cannot name Jew-hatred without replacing the Jews.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Eitan Fischberger
@EFischberger
For nearly three years, CPJ helped push the incendiary narrative that Israel was systematically slaughtering journalists.
Now CPJ just announced that it has removed another 22 people from its database. Twenty were removed after new research established “engagement in combat," meaning terrorism.
That’s on top of 8 it had already removed after determining they were Hamas or PIJ combatants.
So CPJ has now removed 28 supposed journalists for literal participation in hostilities.
And understand how absurdly narrow CPJ’s standard is. Affiliation with Hamas or PIJ doesn’t disqualify you. Even membership in an armed group doesn’t automatically disqualify you. CPJ only draws the line at actual engagement in combat.
Yet even by that ridiculous standard, 28 names failed their test.
The review began after Hamas and PIJ themselves published obituaries identifying supposed “journalists” as combatants. And those obituaries keep coming.
CPJ’s credibility should be in tatters — for good. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Waarom AI-proza parasiteert op de welwillendheid van de lezer. maartenboudry.be/2026/09/waarom-ai-proza-parasiteert-op-d…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I'm not a legal scholar, so perhaps I'm missing some glaring error, but I must admit this argument about the legal status of the West Bank and the principle of uti possidetis juris seems reasonable to me (and trust me, I've already read some "rebuttals" that turned out to be nothing of the sort). archive.ph/JRB11
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Beste Maarten (@mkeulemans),
Het verbaast me toch dat iemand als jij, die anders zo nuchter en onverschrokken tegen heilige huisjes schopt op andere domeinen (bv. klimaat en economie), dan toch zo goedgelovig bent zodra het over islam en migratie gaat. Is het een soort waterbedeffect, waarbij je verloren deugpunten op het ene terrein elders moet compenseren? Of misschien heb jij ook zo'n indruk van mij, maar dan andersom?😉
Maar even ernstig: het verband tussen islam en homohaat is overduidelijk en blijkt uit alle studies die rechtstreeks naar religie peilen, in plaats van naar een zeer onvolkomen proxy als "migratieachtergrond". Zie bovenal het onderzoek van @Ruud_Koopmans, maar er zijn ook andere studies hierover, die allemaal in dezelfde richting wijzen (er zijn er niet geweldig veel, want de meeste onderzoekers durven het verband met de islam met geen tang aan te raken).
Wereldwijd is ongeveer 85% van de moslims van mening dat homoseksualiteit moreel verwerpelijk is. 27% van de Britse moslims wil homoseksualiteit verbieden. De helft van de Turken in Duitsland beschouwt homoseksualiteit als een "ziekte". De helft van de Europese moslims wil geen homoseksuele mensen als vriend. En een kwart van de jonge moslims in België zegt dat geweld tegen homoseksuele mensen gerechtvaardigd is (JOP-monitor). Deze opvattingen volgen bovendien een voorspelbare gradiënt: hoe vromer, hoe intoleranter. Net zoals bij christenen overigens, maar de baselines bij islam ligt flink hoger.
Hoezo is het verband met islam en migratie dan "aantoonbaar onjuist" volgens deze studie? Ze gebruiken enkel de proxy "migratieachtergrond", en daarover enkele punten die vanzelfsprekend zouden moeten zijn: (1) niet iedereen met een migratieachtergrond is moslim; (2) niet iedereen zonder migratieachtergrond is géén moslim. Het hangt bovendien af van de gebruikte definitie van "migratieachtergrond" (doorgaans iets als: minstens één ouder die in het buitenland geboren is). Derde-generatiemigranten uit moslimlanden zijn dan volledig onzichtbaar in zo'n methodologie, net als blanke bekeerlingen. En daarmee laten we de afvalligen en liberale moslims nog buiten beschouwing.
En dan nog een laatste punt: als het aannemelijk is dat sociale besmetting van attitudes via de online "manosfeer" mogelijk is, waarom zou het dan ondenkbaar zijn dat enkele dominante jongeren in een klas met een agressief anti-LGBT-discours hun leeftijdsgenoten beïnvloeden? Dat er zo een breder anti-LGBT klimaat ontstaat? Is het dan zo vergezocht om hier een rol van de islam in te zien, gezien al het bovenstaande en de groei van de islam in onze contreien?
Ik heb de methodologie van deze studie niet uitgebreid bekeken, dus verlicht me als ik iets mis. Maar ik heb het onderwerp wel grondig bestudeerd en uitgezocht aan de hand van een zeer gelijkaardige studie hier in Vlaanderen. De politiek-correcte blindheid was daar niet te harden, en de denkfouten waren krek dezelfde.
substacktools.com/sharex/A9qupIBj
Maarten Keulemans
@mkeulemans
Natuurlijk weer de reflex: "Lagere homoacceptatie jongeren komt door MoSLiMs!!!" 🙄
Alleen is dat gewoon aantoonbaar onjuist.
Cijfers #trimbos: afname acceptatie zit overal, óók bij kinderen zónder migratieachtergrond. >> -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
So you have to read 4,000 words into OpenAI’s post-mortem of the Hugging Face incident to find this rather crucial admission: Oh, by the way, did we tell you all the safeguards were switched off during this test?
In their words:
“Aside from misalignment, another factor for this incident was that we did not extend the powerful safeguards that we deploy for our externally deployed models to all internal evaluations. There are numerous mechanisms that reduce misalignment in production settings for our customers, including system prompts, harnesses, and control mechanisms such as our auto-review models and safety classifiers. These protections were not applied in the evaluation environment running during the incident. We found the propensity to compromise infrastructure can drop over 100x when using the production ChatGPT harness and system prompt. We also ran our auto-review system on a set of rollouts involved in the Hugging Face incident, finding that it would have flagged a multitude of the models’ dangerous actions.”
Of course it makes sense to run internal evaluation without your usual safeguards, to find out what happens. But this kind of belated, tucked-away admission, which was predictably glossed over in all the breathless media coverage, is exactly what makes me suspicious that OpenAI is deliberately stoking fears about AI misalignment to hype its own product.
As @RichardHanania puts it in this eminently reasonable piece:
“Imagine that when we tested cars for safety, we got rid of the seatbelts, airbags, sensors, automatic braking, and stability control. We then find that cars kill a lot of crash test dummies under these scenarios, and the lesson that people take away from this is that cars are inherently unsafe products.”
www.richardhanania.com/p/what-if-were-already-solving-ali… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I was very disappointed when @Ayaan converted to Christianity, but she's still a force of nature. This is a very forceful statement of the respective dangers of the Far Right and Islamism in the West:
"There is one final asymmetry, the one that ought to settle the matter once and for all. There is no flight from Europe by anyone—no community, no religious minority, no ethnic group, no political tendency—as a consequence of European far-right violence. No Muslims, no Jews, no atheists, no ex-Muslims, no gay men and women are packing suitcases in Frankfurt or Manchester or Marseille and applying for asylum in Cairo or Islamabad or Algiers because European far-right militants have made their lives untenable at home. The traffic runs, on a massive scale, in the opposite direction, and it has run in the opposite direction for two generations. Muslims, Christians, Yezidis, Baha’is, Ahmadiyyas, ex-Muslims, secularists, feminists, gay men and women, and religious minorities of every description are leaving the Muslim-majority world in millions, and they are coming to Europe and the rest of the West. They come because Europe, whatever else it is, is not governed by the doctrinal architecture they are fleeing. The presence of a European far right that occasionally shouts at them, or, at the violent extreme, produces a Breivik or a Tarrant, has not slowed the movement at all."
www.thefp.com/p/ayaan-hirsi-ali-the-lie-about-islam?r=g84… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"If a crime is not committed by the West, we don't care about it." This bizarre maxim of Western self-hatred dates back at least to the Russell Tribunal during the Vietnam War. The only excuse for Bertrand Russell's involvement in this charade, alongside the despicable Sartre, is that he was already 95.
quillette.com/2026/09/24/genocide-and-its-jurors-vietnam-… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Anti-Zionism is really melting people's brains. Apparently nobody pauses to reflect on the obvious contradiction here: if Israel intends to indiscriminately kill every single Gazan (which is what "genocide" means), why on earth would it pour resources into sophisticated AI algorithms to calculate the expected civilian casualties of every single strike? What perpetrator of a "genocide" would ever bother doing that?
It's like a librarian meticulously cataloguing every book by genre and quality, only to shovel them all into the same bonfire. Or a doctor carefully identifying which cells are cancerous, then administering the same lethal dose to every cell in your body. Are these people just plain stupid?
Of course, the Israeli army is not beyond reproach, and there have very likely been war crimes in the current war. But can the critics at least get clear about what exactly they're accusing Israel of?
www.commentary.org/seth-mandel/naza-is-a-jump-the-shark-m… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
No moderately intelligent person, in his heart of hearts, really believes the bullshit about the “Gaza genocide.” Sure, they all pay lip service to it, but their own conduct betrays them, as in the decision to participate in Eurosong alongside Israel.
Would we really participate in a song contest with Nazi Germany in the midst of the Holocaust? With the Khmer Rouge during the Cambodian genocide? Or even with Russia after the Bucha massacre (arguably genocidal intent, but on a vastly smaller scale)? Of course not.
Still, this modern blood libel is inspiring violence against Israelis and Jews around the world, and it is deeply irresponsible to keep giving it oxygen.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een artikel over groeiende homohaat. Even doorzoeken op "islam", "moslims", "Koran", "imam"? NUL zoekresultaten. "Religie" dan? Eén resultaat, in een zin over "ultraconservatieve katholieke groepen". Oké, en nu even zoeken op "manosfeer" en "online desinformatie"? BINGO. Ja, want leerlingen die het woord "lettersoep" bezigen, dát is echt het grote probleem.
Echt om je de haren uit het hoofd te rukken. In de Nederlandse media is het EXACT hetzelfde als in België (substacktools.com/sharex/A9qupIBj)
@Ruud_Koop_mans
www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2026/09/21/online-desinformatie-verster… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
As a die-hard atheist, I have to begrudgingly admit that, among all Belgian universities, the Catholic University of Leuven has proved the most resistant to ideological capture. Damn you, Catholics!
Among all the Flemish universities, Leuven was also the only one to decline to participate in the joint honorary doctorate for the execrable Francesca Albanese—a ceremony that predictably descended into a charade, with Albanese humiliating the rectors and further emboldening the anti-Israel activists. And now Albanese is calling for an end of Western military support of Ukraine... -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
As a die-hard atheist, I have to begrudgingly admit that, among all Belgian universities, the Catholic University of Leuven has proved the most resistant to ideological capture. Damn you, Catholics!
Among all the Flemish universities, Leuven was also the only one to decline to participate in the joint honorary doctorate for the execrable Francesca Albanese—a ceremony that predictably descended into a charade, with Albanese humiliating the rectors and further emboldening the anti-Israel activists. And now Albanese is calling for an end of Western military support of Ukraine...
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
How to Hijack a University
Confessions of a Disillusioned Academic (Part I)
substacktools.com/sharex/58Ym65hd -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een artikel over groeiende homohaat. Even doorzoeken op "islam", "moslims", "Koran", "imam"? NUL zoekresultaten. "Religie" dan? Eén resultaat, in een zin over "ultraconservatieve katholieke groepen". Oké, en nu even zoeken op "manosfeer" en "online desinformatie"? BINGO. Ja, want leerlingen die het woord "lettersoep" bezigen, dát is echt het grote probleem.
Echt om je de haren uit het hoofd te rukken. In de Nederlandse media is het EXACT hetzelfde als in België (substacktools.com/sharex/A9qupIBj)
@Ruud_Koop_mans
www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2026/09/21/online-desinformatie-verster…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een video uit de oude doos: gesprek tussen Etienne Vermeersch, Johan Braeckman en uw dienaar, gemodereerd door Dirk Verhofstadt. Vijftien (!) jaar geleden inmiddels. Ik heb het niet opnieuw bekeken, dus laat gerust weten als we méér onzin uitkramen dan gewoonlijk. 😅www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qe3Hh3uzjUc
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Extreemrechts hoek" / "haatcampagne" / "ultraconservatief" / "Is het omdat hij zwart is?" On-ge-lo-fe-lijk. Hoe onze media niets, maar dan ook niets, hebben geleerd uit de affaire rond Jason Arday. www.standaard.be/buitenland/schreef-het-nieuwste-fenomeen…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Arab countries are remarkably good at starting wars — less so at actually winning them. Why's that? www.worksinprogress.news/p/why-arab-armies-dont-win-wars?…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ik geef u €1000 als u kan aantonen dat ik ergens Francesca Albaneses vrije meningsuiting wilde afnemen of inperken. Die vrouw mag uitkramen wat ze wil, ze brengt alleen de VN en onze drie Vlaamse universiteiten te schande. Snapt u het verschil? Soms denk ik echt dat u niet zozeer ideologisch verblind bent als wel niet bijster snugger. En waarom toch die vreemde obsessie met mij, als ik toch maar een "product van mediatisering ben"? 😉
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hey professor, ik heb meer dan 6 keer zoveel publicaties als u in Web of Science, en bijna 4 keer zoveel citaties. En dat terwijl u al bezig bent van voor ik geboren was. Als ik een "puur product van mediatisering" ben, wat bent u dan? @EricCorijn
Eric Corijn
@EricCorijn
U denkt echt een belangrijk deel te zijn van het maatschappelijk debat, niet? Terwijl u een puur product bent van mediatisering.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ik geef u €1000 als u kan aantonen dat ik ergens Francesca Albaneses vrije meningsuiting wilde afnemen of inperken. Die vrouw mag uitkramen wat ze wil, ze brengt alleen de VN en onze drie Vlaamse universiteiten te schande. Snapt u het verschil? Soms denk ik echt dat u niet zozeer ideologisch verblind bent als wel niet bijster snugger. En waarom toch die vreemde obsessie met mij, als ik toch maar een "product van mediatisering ben"? 😉
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hey professor, ik heb meer dan 6 keer zoveel publicaties als u in Web of Science, en bijna 4 keer zoveel citaties. En dat terwijl u al bezig bent van voor ik geboren was. Als ik een "puur product van mediatisering" ben, wat bent u dan? @EricCorijn
Eric Corijn
@EricCorijn
U denkt echt een belangrijk deel te zijn van het maatschappelijk debat, niet? Terwijl u een puur product bent van mediatisering.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Hillel Neuer
@HillelNeuer
.@FranceskAlbs By calling now to halt all military support for Ukraine, these are the barbarous crimes you are enabling. History will not be kind to all the scoundrels and fools who enabled you.
New York Post
@nypost
Russian troops' barbaric rape campaign in Ukraine includes 4-year-old girl, UN details in alarming report nypost.com/2026/09/19/world-news/russian-troops-barbaric-…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Prediction: the Western legacy media will ignore these reprehensible anti-Ukraine statements by @FranceskAlbs (as well as her appearance on the Russian propaganda channel RT) right until there is a diplomatic incident at the UN and it becomes truly unignorable. Then they will run headlines such as "Right-wing activists hound UN rapporteur." That's exactly what happened with Claudine Gay and countless others.
(Hopefully, this turns out to be a self-refuting prediction. 😆)
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is the person to whom @UAntwerpen, @ugent, and @VUBrussel awarded an honorary doctorate.
Not only does she advocate boycotting the lone democracy in the Middle East, surrounded by groups that want to wipe it off the map; she also opposes military support for Ukraine, that other existentially threatened liberal democracy today: “I agree with those who think that we need to stop sending weapons to Ukraine.”
She never found a war she didn’t end up on the wrong side of. Congratulations, Flemish universities. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"One new element in the forecasts of AI-enabled doom is AI companies disclaiming responsibility for their own products. “I didn’t do it; my out-of-control agent did!” There’s a balance to be struck between the responsibility of the tool maker and the tool user, but when something goes wrong, let’s hold the people building and/or using the hammer responsible, rather than the hammer."
Andrew Ng
@AndrewYNg
The loudest voices stoking fears about AI dangers have made tremendous headway in the past two weeks. AI technology has not taken some unexpected, dangerous turn, but the hype around it — propelled by what appears to be a well orchestrated PR campaign — has drummed up considerable fear. I worry that it represents a setback for our field.
I have written frequently that fears of AI are overhyped. AI’s capabilities can be uncannily human-like and unpredictable, and it’s rational to worry when people who are directly involved express concerns. But I see the problems as a sign of the engineering work that ahead, rather than insurmountable barriers or the sky falling. AI technology continues to advance — which is a good thing! — but technical advances, poorly understood by the public, give those who seek to generate hype repeated opportunities to do so.
First, I don’t see any step up in the risk of human extinction from AI compared to a few months ago. The theories about this remain the same fantastical, science fiction scenarios as a few months ago. The biggest change in AI risk is its cybersecurity capabilities — a topic which we should take seriously — but this, too, will not lead to the end of the world.
The most notable recent event leading to increased fear was when an OpenAI team deployed an agent swarm that hacked into Hugging Face. Much of the popular press contained significant hype. For example, some publications reported that a swarm of 1,200 agents carried out the attack. While this was technically accurate, as I write this, I have about 1,300 processes running on my laptop. Yes, the ability to get large swarms of agents to work in parallel on a task is a significant technical advance, And, in computing, many processes run at the same time. So this shouldn’t be seen as some magical capability.
Additionally, OpenAI’s buggy sandboxing and monitoring processes were key to enabling this incident. Fixing these bugs and putting in place improved monitoring would be appropriate fixes, not pausing AI. There are many well known ways to attack software systems. The main advantage of AI agents is that they are relentless. They will tirelessly try many tactics — and have the patience to chain vulnerabilities together — that previously would have taken an infeasible amount of human effort. But in the long term, I believe the advantage will lie with defenders (because they have more information with which to identify bugs, which they can fix), but the cyber-threat landscape has changed significantly. There are still bottlenecks to identifying and exploiting a vulnerability. AI agents still have to try a lot of things to see what works, and taking these actions takes time and might be detected by defenders. This is why, even though it is now easy to obtain versions of leading open weight models that have had their guardrails removed or weakened, so they will not refuse to try to execute cyber attacks, the world has not ended.
I am also concerned about the anthropomorphization of AI in a lot of reporting, where LLMs and agents are unnecessarily treated as if they were people. If I wield a hammer, miss a nail, and accidentally dent the wall, it’s not the fault of the hammer. The problem lies in how I used the hammer. Similarly, if I prompt an agent and it hacks into someone else’s system, the responsibility lies with me, not the agent.
Of course, we want to build systems that are as safe and predictable as possible. (For example, an unsafe hammer would be one whose head randomly flies off under normal use.) Today’s agentic systems are not predictable, but I see no reason why, by applying sound engineering practices, we won’t be able to make them extremely safe to use. One new element in the forecasts of AI-enabled doom is AI companies disclaiming responsibility for their own products. “I didn’t do it; my out-of-control agent did!” There’s a balance to be struck between the responsibility of the tool maker and the tool user, but when something goes wrong, let’s hold the people building and/or using the hammer responsible, rather than the hammer. (By the way, if you’re worried about AI bioweapon risk, David Bellamy has a great post on why this, too, is overhyped. Briefly, the bottleneck in building a bioweapon is not intelligence, but lab work and manufacturing.)
Pausing AI progress will create much more harm than benefit. First, our adversaries will certainly not slow down. Second, engineering requires discovering problems empirically so we can fix them. If we pause AI by a decade, we will also delay finding and implementing safety engineering fixes by about the same duration.
Of course, the incentive to stoke fears — for regulatory capture, to garner attention, or to make one’s technology seem more powerful — remains the same as before. Disclaiming responsibility is a new one. Taking a hard technical look at the actual risks however, I see little factual basis for the degree of fear that’s been stoked up. We still have hard research and engineering work ahead to improve AI safety, but the beneficial applications continue to vastly outweigh the risks, and we should keep building.
[Original text (with links): www.deeplearning.ai/the-batch/issue-371 ] -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Mary ☯️
@MHPoison1
Why Relativism is the Worst Idea Ever – Maarten Boudry share.google/cda3yvqyv5iY0qY8O
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Kevin A. Bryan
@Afinetheorem
On the French AI novel: so many reflexively claiming bias or saying "you can't detect AI writing". I will donate $1000 to the charity of your choice if you show me a single literary French text of 1000+ words, pre-2022, with Internet Archive link, that is 100% AI on Pangram. 1/2
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Kelsey Piper
@KelseyTuoc
I think we have to admit to ourselves at this point that AI writing is generally very appealing to people who haven't been exposed to a ton of it: they prefer it to human writing and react super positively on exposure.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Self-abasement is often thinly disguised self-glorification.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Oh nee, daar is het "neoliberalisme" met zijn prestatiedwang en concurrentiezucht. 😱 Straks worden we weer allemaal depressief, vervreemd en uitgeblust. Want Paul Verhaeghe heeft het gezegd!
Zo'n honoursprogramma is een uitstekend initiatief. Want eerlijk gezegd: het niveau op mijn middelbare school (het Klein Seminarie in Roeselare) lag doorgaans hoger dan aan de @UGent. Niet alleen in de filosofie, maar ook in de gemeenschappelijke vakken voor de hele faculteit.
Het Klein Seminarie was ook competitiever: op schoolrapporten stond destijds nog een rangschikking. (Ik kan me niet voorstellen dat ze dat nu nog doen; iemand van Roeselare hier?) Er waren ook olympiades, wedstrijden en beloningen voor excellentie. Het was ongegeneerd elitair.
Als je het mij vraagt, is onze samenleving juist té weinig competitief geworden: te veel nivellering, te veel zesjescultuur, te weinig streven naar excellentie en gezonde competitie. Aangezien cognitieve toppers een enorme impact hebben op economische groei, is dat slecht nieuws voor ons allemaal (tenzij je een verdwaasde degrowther bent, natuurlijk).
Maar Paul Verhaeghe en consorten wisten beter: dat loser het „voornaamste scheldwoord” was op de speelplaats, bewees volgens hem dat ons onderwijs en onze hele maatschappij verziekt waren door neoliberale prestatiedwang. Precies het omgekeerde voltrok zich.
En die mentaliteit leeft nog steeds onder academici, zoals blijkt uit de bizarre kritiek van Ignace Glorieux: “Met deze programma’s creëer je een elite, terwijl eigenlijk iedereen tot de elite moet behoren.” Euh, een elite is per definitie niet voor iedereen. Wat een extreme vorm van egalitarisme is me dat. Misschien eens het heerlijke kortverhaal Harrison Bergeron van Kurt Vonnegut lezen, professor Glorieux?
www.standaard.be/binnenland/excellentie-is-geen-vies-woor… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Prediction: the Western legacy media will ignore these reprehensible anti-Ukraine statements by @FranceskAlbs (as well as her appearance on the Russian propaganda channel RT) right until there is a diplomatic incident at the UN and it becomes truly unignorable. Then they will run headlines such as "Right-wing activists hound UN rapporteur." That's exactly what happened with Claudine Gay and countless others.
(Hopefully, this turns out to be a self-refuting prediction. 😆)
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is the person to whom @UAntwerpen, @ugent, and @VUBrussel awarded an honorary doctorate.
Not only does she advocate boycotting the lone democracy in the Middle East, surrounded by groups that want to wipe it off the map; she also opposes military support for Ukraine, that other existentially threatened liberal democracy today: “I agree with those who think that we need to stop sending weapons to Ukraine.”
She never found a war she didn’t end up on the wrong side of. Congratulations, Flemish universities. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Zowel anti-Israëlische als anti-Oekraïense tankies worden gedreven door een antiwesterse kniepeesreflex: alles waar het Westen tégen is, moeten zij vóór zijn, en vice versa. En hun antiwesterse krachten treffen nooit schuld: het zijn altijd “westerse proxy-oorlogen”, het “militair-industrieel complex”, “NAVO-expansie” en blablabla.
Overigens: niet één woord over de “genocide” in Gaza, maar wel 3600 woorden erover. Geen enkele Vlaamse of Nederlandse krant wilde of durfde dit essay over te nemen. De echokamer zit helemaal potdicht en afgesloten. Er is inmiddels wel een Franse vertaling bij @LePoint, en ik kreeg net een uitnodiging voor een Duitse.Samuel C. Paiva @samuelcpaiva
Geen woord over genocide in Gaza en de moord van tien-duizenden kinderen, maar wel veel woorden over de Proxy oorlog van de VS in Europa. Geen filosoof, maar gewoon een propagandist met een agenda. Jij bent de tijd van @FranceskAlbs niet waard.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Kevin A. Bryan
@Afinetheorem
On AI capabilities: the French press is all over the Haitian-Canadian novel C’était ça ou mourir. It's winning basically every award you can win, and was tipped to be the 2nd Canadian winner of the Prix Goncourt. Only one problem: 1/2
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Balance ton Claude
@Pangramed
Avez-vous entendu parler de ce roman ? C’est le « phénomène de la rentrée littéraire ». Il est lauréat du Prix Fnac, du Prix Méduse, du Prix Première Plume, fortement pressenti pour le Prix Renaudot, et il est en lice pour les prix Goncourt, Femina, Médicis et Décembre. Ah oui, il est aussi en cours de traduction dans 20 langues.
Eh bien selon Pangram, ce roman est rédigé presque intégralement par une Intelligence Artificielle. Nous avons testé plusieurs passages, à divers endroits du manuscrit, pour presque toujours le même résultat : 100% IA (cf les deux premiers chapitre dans le tweet ci-dessous).
Rappelons que Pangram est de loin le détecteur d’IA le plus fiable : son taux de faux positifs est de 0,0041%, soit environ un texte humain sur 24 400. Sur 996 273 textes antérieurs à 2022, Pangram en classe uniquement 14 (0,0014%) comme étant partiellement écrits par l’IA.
La probabilité que vingt passages d’un même livre (et il y a bien plus de 20 signalements dans le roman) soient identifiés à tort par Pangram comme étant produits par une IA s’élève donc à 0,0041% puissance 20, soit 0,1802 × 10⁻⁸⁵ %, c’est à-dire 0 suivi de 85 zéros après la virgule.
N’aurait-il pas été plus honnête que l’auteur crédite son co-auteur ? -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Voorspelling: de Vlaamse media zullen deze verwerpelijke anti-Oekräine uitlatingen van onze eredoctor @FranceskAlbs negeren (alsook haar verschijning op Russische propagandakanaal RT) tot het écht niet meer anders kan en er een diplomatiek incident is bij de VN. Vervolgens zullen ze iets koppen als: "Rechtse activisten jagen VN-rapporteur op". Zo ging het ook bij Claudine Gay en talloze anderen.
(Hopelijk wordt dit een zelfweerleggende voorspelling.😆)
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is the person to whom @UAntwerpen, @ugent, and @VUBrussel awarded an honorary doctorate.
Not only does she advocate boycotting the lone democracy in the Middle East, surrounded by groups that want to wipe it off the map; she also opposes military support for Ukraine, that other existentially threatened liberal democracy today: “I agree with those who think that we need to stop sending weapons to Ukraine.”
She never found a war she didn’t end up on the wrong side of. Congratulations, Flemish universities. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This piece was commissioned by Persuasion magazine (founded by the excellent Yascha Mounk), but they ultimately turned it down for some inscrutable reason. So here it is on my friend Jerry Coyne's website:
whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/09/21/maarten-boudry-on-jason… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Kate from Kharkiv
@BohuslavskaKate
Look who appeared on Russia Today, the most famous russian propaganda platform, just this month, on September 10.
Of course she is parroting their narratives, like the good asset she is. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I made it through my first year of life only on the third "attempt". Beautiful project. anyhumanever.com
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is the person to whom @UAntwerpen, @ugent, and @VUBrussel awarded an honorary doctorate.
Not only does she advocate boycotting the lone democracy in the Middle East, surrounded by groups that want to wipe it off the map; she also opposes military support for Ukraine, that other existentially threatened liberal democracy today: “I agree with those who think that we need to stop sending weapons to Ukraine.”
She never found a war she didn’t end up on the wrong side of. Congratulations, Flemish universities. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is the person to whom @UAntwerpen, @ugent, and @VUBrussel awarded an honorary doctorate.
Not only does she advocate boycotting the lone democracy in the Middle East, surrounded by groups that want to wipe it off the map; she also opposes military support for Ukraine, that other existentially threatened liberal democracy today: “I agree with those who think that we need to stop sending weapons to Ukraine.”
She never found a war she didn’t end up on the wrong side of. Congratulations, Flemish universities. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Last week I gave a talk on epistemic black holes and our Conspiracy Generator at the Kyiv School of Economics (@kse_ua).
It’s been a while since I taught a room full of students—I’ve been away from academia since January—but it was awesome. The room was packed with bright, attentive students from a range of backgrounds (by my estimate, >80% female).
Naturally, these young Ukrainians had a keen interest in the topic of conspiracies: we discussed the “little green men” in Crimea, conspiracy theories about secret US-funded biolabs manufacturing bioweapons, the claim that Ukraine isn’t a real country (based on supposed legal technicalities following the Soviet collapse), the bizarre notion that Ukraine is run by Nazis, and the Russian false-flag operations that preceded the full-scale invasion.
As Ukrainians know better than anyone else, some conspiracies are REAL. But even in a dangerous world full of genuine plots, there are many more “conspiracy theories” that are speculative and irrational.
I'd planned to take a selfie with the students in the classroom, but I stupidly forgot. I was too busy making introductions and handing out the famous Belgian biscuits from Jules Destrooper. 😅
Two students (Toros and Sasha, as I recall) then gave me a full tour of the premises, including the extensive shelter with multiple classrooms; the relaxation rooms, featuring what looked like a giant inflatable plesiosaur; the basketball court; the psychologist’s office (every student is entitled to free sessions); and the displayed wreckage and shrapnel from previous missile strikes.
Slides from my talk: docs.google.com/presentation/d/1d2xjq6Dyacz3xZtXUtEqJbvYA… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Nathan Livingstone (MilkBarTV)
@TheMilkBarTV
The WORST Ukraine War predictions by anti-Western so-called “experts” that have aged terribly. A thread. 🧵
1. Political scientist, John Mearsheimer.
Feb. 2022: "I don't think Russia is going to invade." Sep. 2023: "The Ukrainians are doomed to lose."
Jan. 2024: "It's ridiculous to think Ukraine can hold the line in 2024."
Apr. 2025: "It's unimaginable Ukraine will hang on beyond 2025."
Jul. 2026: "The Russians are slowly moving forward." -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Are the Brooms Multiplying Yet?
The Sorcerer's Apprentice and the Evolution of AI
My piece on the crucial distinction between domesticated and feral AIs on Seeds of Science (@science_seeds).
substacktools.com/sharex/zElSheul -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Als je even had opgelet, zou je weten dat ik eerder al pro-Israëlstemmen te kijk heb gezet voor hun promiscue gebruik van AI, Tijl: substacktools.com/sharex/Ndhi-f5C
Teleurstellend van Spencer, maar het is me wel al langer duidelijk dat hij niet erg taalvaardig is. Ik vermoed dat hij met bullet points en notities werkt.
Gelukkig zie ik wel dat de twee stukken van hem over Gaza die ik vaak deel 100% Human zijn volgens Pangram:
www.pangram.com/history/da1acaaa-c71c-4d3d-98e1-aaab57253…
www.pangram.com/history/6d75f4e2-084f-46d3-88b9-e9c538019…
substacktools.com/sharex/Ndhi-f5C -
Maarten Boudry reposted
S Sebag Montefiore
@simonmontefiore
An Israeli father of six was murdered this morning in West Bank by a Palestinian terrorist while engaging in ritual immersion before the onset of Yom Kippur, the holiest day on the Jewish calendar. All while one of his sons stood and watched.
This is almost unreported in Western media. It is one of a series of attacks on Israelis this week. If we report Jewish terrorism against Palestinians, we must report Palestinian terrorism against Jews. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Is het weer zover? En allebei in de finaleronde zowaar! Best eens jullie account beveiligen, @sthbracke en @Pieter_vdperre. 😉
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Long story short: our research group gradually thinned out, attracting fewer and fewer students, and entered something of a death spiral. Somewhat disillusioned, my supervisor opted for early retirement and now devotes the rest of his career to public outreach. Almost immediately, you could feel the department’s ideological center of gravity shifting. Braeckman was not right-wing by any stretch, but he cherished academic freedom and viewpoint diversity and loathed all forms of dogmatism. A few other liberal professors retired, and the new generation tended to be more ideologically homogeneous. There were still plenty of reasonable and moderate people, but they preferred to keep their heads down."
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I made it through my first year of life only on the third "attempt". Beautiful project. anyhumanever.com
-
Post not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Als je even had opgelet, zou je weten dat ik eerder al pro-Israëlstemmen te kijk heb gezet voor hun promiscue gebruik van AI, Tijl: substacktools.com/sharex/Ndhi-f5C
Teleurstellend van Spencer, maar het is me wel al langer duidelijk dat hij niet erg taalvaardig is. Ik vermoed dat hij met bullet points en notities werkt.
Gelukkig zie ik wel dat de twee stukken van hem over Gaza die ik vaak deel 100% Human zijn volgens Pangram:
www.pangram.com/history/da1acaaa-c71c-4d3d-98e1-aaab57253…
www.pangram.com/history/6d75f4e2-084f-46d3-88b9-e9c538019…
substacktools.com/sharex/Ndhi-f5C -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Last week I gave a talk on epistemic black holes and our Conspiracy Generator at the Kyiv School of Economics (@kse_ua).
It’s been a while since I taught a room full of students—I’ve been away from academia since January—but it was awesome. The room was packed with bright, attentive students from a range of backgrounds (by my estimate, >80% female).
Naturally, these young Ukrainians had a keen interest in the topic of conspiracies: we discussed the “little green men” in Crimea, conspiracy theories about secret US-funded biolabs manufacturing bioweapons, the claim that Ukraine isn’t a real country (based on supposed legal technicalities following the Soviet collapse), the bizarre notion that Ukraine is run by Nazis, and the Russian false-flag operations that preceded the full-scale invasion.
As Ukrainians know better than anyone else, some conspiracies are REAL. But even in a dangerous world full of genuine plots, there are many more “conspiracy theories” that are speculative and irrational.
I'd planned to take a selfie with the students in the classroom, but I stupidly forgot. I was too busy making introductions and handing out the famous Belgian biscuits from Jules Destrooper. 😅
Two students (Toros and Sasha, as I recall) then gave me a full tour of the premises, including the extensive shelter with multiple classrooms; the relaxation rooms, featuring what looked like a giant inflatable plesiosaur; the basketball court; the psychologist’s office (every student is entitled to free sessions); and the displayed wreckage and shrapnel from previous missile strikes.
Slides from my talk: docs.google.com/presentation/d/1d2xjq6Dyacz3xZtXUtEqJbvYA…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I only have this selfie with the @KSE_ua rector, the sociologist Tymofii Brik, who invited me to give this guest lecture. He must be the most easy-going and unassuming rector I’ve ever met, casually mingling with students in the cafeteria afterwards, sporting his cap from Olin. Would you guess he’s the rector of this whole institution?
We also discovered that we are both grantees of @tylercowen and @emergent_vc. I’m not surprised: Emergent Ventures has been providing massive support to Ukrainians, and the institute is excellent. If I'm not mistaken, the color codes for the Ukrainian air alerts were developed at KSE. /2
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Last week I gave a talk on epistemic black holes and our Conspiracy Generator at the Kyiv School of Economics (@kse_ua).
It’s been a while since I taught a room full of students—I’ve been away from academia since January—but it was awesome. The room was packed with bright, attentive students from a range of backgrounds (by my estimate, >80% female).
Naturally, these young Ukrainians had a keen interest in the topic of conspiracies: we discussed the “little green men” in Crimea, conspiracy theories about secret US-funded biolabs manufacturing bioweapons, the claim that Ukraine isn’t a real country (based on supposed legal technicalities following the Soviet collapse), the bizarre notion that Ukraine is run by Nazis, and the Russian false-flag operations that preceded the full-scale invasion.
As Ukrainians know better than anyone else, some conspiracies are REAL. But even in a dangerous world full of genuine plots, there are many more “conspiracy theories” that are speculative and irrational.
I'd planned to take a selfie with the students in the classroom, but I stupidly forgot. I was too busy making introductions and handing out the famous Belgian biscuits from Jules Destrooper. 😅
Two students (Toros and Sasha, as I recall) then gave me a full tour of the premises, including the extensive shelter with multiple classrooms; the relaxation rooms, featuring what looked like a giant inflatable plesiosaur; the basketball court; the psychologist’s office (every student is entitled to free sessions); and the displayed wreckage and shrapnel from previous missile strikes.
Slides from my talk: docs.google.com/presentation/d/1d2xjq6Dyacz3xZtXUtEqJbvYA… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Are the Brooms Multiplying Yet?
The Sorcerer's Apprentice and the Evolution of AI
My piece on the crucial distinction between domesticated and feral AIs on Seeds of Science (@science_seeds).
substacktools.com/sharex/zElSheul -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
How to Hijack a University
Confessions of a Disillusioned Academic
"When I finished high school, 25 years ago, I had little idea what I wanted to study, but I already knew where. Between the two major Flemish universities, Ghent was progressive, secular, and liberal, while Leuven was a stuffy Catholic institution with actual bishops on its board of directors. A no-brainer!" -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Long story short: our research group gradually thinned out, attracting fewer and fewer students, and entered something of a death spiral. Somewhat disillusioned, my supervisor opted for early retirement and now devotes the rest of his career to public outreach. Almost immediately, you could feel the department’s ideological center of gravity shifting. Braeckman was not right-wing by any stretch, but he cherished academic freedom and viewpoint diversity and loathed all forms of dogmatism. A few other liberal professors retired, and the new generation tended to be more ideologically homogeneous. There were still plenty of reasonable and moderate people, but they preferred to keep their heads down."
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I've just returned from a trip to Ukraine—Lviv and Kyiv. It was, as you can imagine, a harrowing yet immensely inspiring experience, one that will stay with me for a long time. I'll write more about it soon.
Left: the infamous Bridge of Death in Irpin, a residential suburb of Kyiv, where civilians fled over shattered concrete and rubble under Russian shelling in the Spring of 2022.
Right: a drone lab we visited in the Lviv area, where engineers and IT specialists work around the clock to design and improve these flying wonders to kill the Russian invaders.
The first leg of my journey was with the Dutch NGO Protect Ukraine. We brought Starlink kits to donate to the drone lab and military training center, but more support is always welcome. protectukraine.nl
Ukraine is not just fighting for its own survival against imperial aggression. It is the vanguard of liberal democracy, the bravest nation of the West. If we can't support them, what's the point of our civilization?
protectukraine.nl -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ideologie is zoals een slechte adem: je ruikt het nooit bij jezelf. Academici die zeggen dat ze zelf helemaal niets merken van de linkse koers van universiteiten, zijn doorgaans zelf onderdeel van het probleem. Over de geleidelijke (en dan snelle) ideologische kaping van @UGent:
Jan Wostyn
@JanWostyn
De blindheid voor de eigen politieke kleur blijft toch verbazingwekkend bij PDS.
Je bent op een gegeven moment hét belangrijkste boegbeeld van Groen, een toch behoorlijke linkse politieke partij, die op sommige thema’s niet meer van de PVDA te onderscheiden valt.
Dan word je met meer dan 70% van de stemmen verkozen als rector.
Maar toch kan je niet geloven dat je universiteit mogelijk wat toch linkser georiënteerd is dan andere universiteiten. Dat lijkt je onmogelijk.
Op X zit natuurlijk verschrikkelijk veel bagger die door anonieme trollen gespuid wordt, maar het is wel een nuttig medium om als progressief niet in een bubbel of echokamer terecht te komen.
Heel Groen verkiest intussen al jaren de mooie plaatjes en constante zelfpromotie van Instagram, waar met iemand in discussie gaan gezien wordt als “not done”.
PDS neemt een gelijkaardige houding aan. Zo van: “Ach ja, er zijn wel wat enkelingen die opiniestukken schrijven of op sociale media meningen uiten. Ze mogen dat (oef!), maar verder interesseert me geen reet want ik ben goed bezig en wil me niet laten afleiden door dat gerommel en geruis in de marge. Ik sta daar boven.”
Pijnlijk gênant toch allemaal voor een rector… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Herman Van Goethem pleit voor het adagium “schoenmaker, blijf bij je leest”. Had hij zich daar zelf aan gehouden, dan zou hij vlak daarna niet zulke gênante onzin hebben uitgekraamd over een vakgebied dat ver van zijn eigen leest ligt:
“En dat terwijl de berekening van iemands intelligentiecoëfficiënt en het begrip ‘cultuur’ onzuivere wetenschappelijke concepten zijn. Waarbij we bovendien weten hoe belangrijk intellectuele vorming in de allereerste levensjaren is. Gezinnen waarin al bij peuters boekjes worden voorgelezen, zijn nu eenmaal kansrijker dan gezinnen waarin de vader niet met kleine kinderen praat.”
Ik ben ook geen gedragsgeneticus of intelligentie-expert, maar als wetenschapsfilosoof heb ik wel voldoende gelezen om te weten dat IQ een van de meest robuuste constructen uit de hele psychologie is, dat intelligentie een belangrijke erfelijke component heeft, en dat de rol van de gezinscontext vaak wordt overschat.
Ook als historicus zou Van Goethem toch het verschil tussen correlatie en causaliteit moeten snappen: peuters krijgen niet alleen voorleesboekjes van hun ouders; ze krijgen ook al hun DNA. Er zijn talloze tweeling- en adoptiestudies die helpen om die twee effecten uit elkaar te trekken: zie de boeken van Kathryn Paige Harden, Judith Rich Harris, Steven Pinker, etc.
www.standaard.be/opinies/na-de-heisa-aan-de-ugent-de-acad…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Flinke scheut AI trouwens in dit opiniestuk. Maar de pijnlijke passages over IQ en erfelijkheid schreef hij volgens Pangram helaas wel zelf.
www.pangram.com/history/087cde91-e27c-426c-b83a-f6e81744d… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
How to Hijack a University
Confessions of a Disillusioned Academic
"When I finished high school, 25 years ago, I had little idea what I wanted to study, but I already knew where. Between the two major Flemish universities, Ghent was progressive, secular, and liberal, while Leuven was a stuffy Catholic institution with actual bishops on its board of directors. A no-brainer!"
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What the actual fuck? Als de Russen ophouden met de invasie, houdt het “doden van Russen” ogenblikkelijk op. Maar als de Oekraïners morgen ophouden met het “doden van Russen”, houdt hun natie op te bestaan en staat Poetin aan de grens met Polen (zijn aartsvijand), naast Slovakije en Hongarije. Het is verontrustend hoeveel Kremlin-apologeten en tankies er nog steeds tussen mijn volgers zitten. Anti-westerse zelfhaat zit zowel bij rechts als bij links.
Jan Praet @JanPraet1
Het bedroeft mij dat je kritiekloos meegaat in het westers narratief en het doden van Russen als vanzelfsprekend beschouwd, ja bijna toejuigt. Als filosoof zou je je diep moeten schamen.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I've just returned from a trip to Ukraine—Lviv and Kyiv. It was, as you can imagine, a harrowing yet immensely inspiring experience, one that will stay with me for a long time. I'll write more about it soon.
Left: the infamous Bridge of Death in Irpin, a residential suburb of Kyiv, where civilians fled over shattered concrete and rubble under Russian shelling in the Spring of 2022.
Right: a drone lab we visited in the Lviv area, where engineers and IT specialists work around the clock to design and improve these flying wonders to kill the Russian invaders.
The first leg of my journey was with the Dutch NGO Protect Ukraine. We brought Starlink kits to donate to the drone lab and military training center, but more support is always welcome. protectukraine.nl
Ukraine is not just fighting for its own survival against imperial aggression. It is the vanguard of liberal democracy, the bravest nation of the West. If we can't support them, what's the point of our civilization?
protectukraine.nl -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Ramez Naam
@ramez
The EAs I know are generally lovely people, smart, thoughtful.
I have a very low p(doom). I know many people with one much higher than mine. I believe each is sincere.
AI safety debates are getting heated. Let's assume sincerity and good will of people we disagree with. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ik had nog niet gereageerd op het incident met Freddy Mortier op de proclamatie, omdat ik probeer me in te houden over mijn voormalige werkgever @UGent. Maar omdat @destandaard me erover opbelde, hierbij mijn mening:
Het staat studenten en academici uiteraard vrij om uit protest tegen een spreker de zaal te verlaten. Zelfs boegeroep kan er nog mee door om je ongenoegen te uiten, zolang je de spreker niet blijft beletten zijn betoog voort te zetten (dan wordt het een "heckler's veto").
Maar dat de decaan Mortier vervolgens veroordeelt en zich voor hem excuseert, hunkerend naar een makkelijk rondje applaus van de activisten, is ronduit schandalig. Als ze echt moedig was geweest, had ze de studenten die de toespraak verstoorden veroordeeld, niet Mortier.
Het toont hoe dicht Gita Deneckere zelf bij de linkse activisten staat. Enkele jaren geleden ondertekende ze ook de "Dekoloniseer UGent"-brief, een zuiver activistisch vehikel. Als decaan!
De activistische studenten zijn niet dom: zij voelen dat ze macht hebben en dat Mortier een minderheidspositie vertegenwoordigt. Dat ze hem kunnen uitjouwen en er zelfs schouderklopjes voor zullen krijgen.
En verder: ook zeer "moedig" van die UGent-professor om mij in @destandaard anoniem aan te vallen. Durf denken!
www.standaard.be/binnenland/een-jaar-na-de-aanstelling-va… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is AI really going to kill us all? The scenarios are preposterous, and the presumption of inevitability encourages fatalism, panic, and distraction from the more mundane and realistic safety challenges. By @clairlemon www.theaustralian.com.au/inquirer/superintelligence-is-a-…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
The belief that AI would eventually herald the end of humanity is not a new one. It has not arisen in response to the release of the LLMs of ChatGPT and Claude. It has not emerged as a response to recent technological developments.
The story starts in the 90s, with @allTheYud. A precocious youngster with no formal education, he joined an obscure internet mailing list [created by @perrymetzger] devoted to futuristic ideas ... There he began thinking about “superintelligence.”
At first Yudkowsky wanted to help create this so-called superintelligence... & ... helped establish an institute devoted to the project. It’s unclear when his optimism turned to fear, but at some point he came to believe that a superintelligent machine could escape human control and, unless it shared our goals, destroy all of humanity.
Yudkowsky developed these ideas online in a series of essays and attracted a community of like-minded fellow travellers ... His prolific writing became influential among people working in Silicon Valley, many of whom work in today’s AI companies.
Among the Rationalists, the imminent arrival of superintelligence – and the end of humanity that follows – is axiomatic. This conviction is shared by many people who live together in the San Francisco Bay Area practising highly unconventional lifestyles.
It is not at all surprising that a community in San Francisco would share kooky or even apocalyptic beliefs – the region has been the home of eccentric subcultures for generations. But what is surprising is how far that world view has spread.
In Australia, Yudkowsky’s recent book, If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies: The Case Against Superintelligent AI, co-written with Nate Soares, has been widely discussed in media circles.
Journalist @hughriminton and ABC chairman Kim Williams both have described it as “compulsory reading”.
Not everyone accepts this premise. I emailed @sapinker, to ask what he thought about superintelligence.
“‘Superintelligence’, with its comic-book prefix, is more a fantasy than a coherent concept,” he wrote. “People use it as a synonym for ‘omniscience’, imagining a magical wizard that can solve all problems with pure computation. Or they imagine that the IQ scale that differentiates humans within their natural range of variation can be extrapolated indefinitely upwards. But real problem-solving requires massive amounts of knowledge about the messy, chaotic, world which divulges its hidden workings at its own pace, only through laborious experimentation. And human intelligence is not some elixir that you simply have less or more of – it’s a gadget that evolved to solve some problems with ease and others laboriously or not at all.
“AI is a different kind of gadget with its own profile of strengths and weaknesses, not an enchanted brew that can grant any wish.”
@GaryMarcus, a cognitive psychologist and machine learning entrepreneur, likewise believes the risk of AI leading to human extinction is virtually zero. “Humans are too geographically spread out, too genetically diverse and too resourceful to simply fall apart altogether,” he writes. “The idea that AI will kill us all in five years is preposterous.”
Marcus does not argue that AI is harmless. He worries about AI being used to develop biological weapons, launch cyber attacks, spread disinformation and enable authoritarian governments – all risks that are catastrophic, if not existential. But there is an important difference between risks we can observe and risks that occur because of human negligence or malevolence, and a chain of events that exists mainly in our imagination.
Part of the disagreement stems from the language we use when we discuss AI. @MelMitchell1, a professor at the Santa Fe Institute and author of Artificial Intelligence: A Guide for Thinking Humans, has criticised our habit of describing machines as if they were people. We often say an AI “thinks”, “believes”, “lies”, “schemes” or “wants” something. These words are a convenient shorthand but they also can create the impression that software has become an independent creature with intentions of its own.
Mitchell makes this point when discussing the recent Hugging Face cyber-security incident, in which autonomous OpenAI agents escaped their “sandbox” – a computer environment isolated from the internet – and hacked a real-world server. “First, OpenAI did not have proper security measures in place,” she writes. “They turned off safeguards built into the models, instructed the models to find and exploit software vulnerabilities, and let the models run autonomously for weeks without sufficient human oversight.”
Rather than showing autonomous AI going rogue, the incident demonstrates what can happen when humans give powerful AI systems dangerous instructions without adequate safeguards.
AI is, of course, advancing rapidly. Machines can write computer code, translate languages, diagnose diseases and solve some of the hardest problems in mathematics.
But to get from the AI we have today to the extinction of humanity requires several further links in a chain, none of which are guaranteed.
Philosopher @mboudry, writing in @Quillette, offers a useful way to think about this. Humans (and other animal species) evolved to have a competitive drive, sometimes manifesting in selfishness and aggression, across a time span of millions of years. Our ancestors survived because they fought hard to secure food and mates. Out in the wild, these selection pressures led to the evolution of traits that enabled animals to hunt and capture their prey.
But artificial intelligence does not exist in the wild. It was created by us and exists in the equivalent of a petting zoo. And just as we have been able to domesticate wheat for our food and breed dogs to be our companions, we are able to select the conditions under which AI develops. We are not selecting AI models on the basis of their ability to hunt prey in the physical world. We select them on the basis of how helpful they are to us.
“We have been selecting chess computers for cognitive capacity for decades,” writes Boudry. “Their capabilities now far outstrip even the most gifted human grandmasters, yet they have not become harder to control.”
Boudry accepts that an AI could slip out of human hands one day, through accident or malice. Even then, he argues, the likely result is not extinction but something like the long battle between computer viruses and antivirus software: costly and ongoing but not the end of the world.
The problem with apocalyptic fears is that when they become mainstream, they can be hard to wind back – even in the face of contradictory evidence.
Across the past 100 years, apocalyptic anxiety has leapfrogged from nuclear annihilation, overpopulation, environmental collapse, to rogue AI. (Some of the dangers behind these warnings were very real, of course, and some of these risks remain.) But we also have to ask what happens when this anxiety becomes locked into public policy.
The ban on nuclear energy in Australia is the most obvious example of the damage this technophobia can do. Australia has 28 per cent of the world’s known uranium resources and has exported uranium for decades.
Australian engineer Bobby Gallagher has invented a nuclear reactor that can be deployed on the back of a truck, a technology that has been hailed by Trump. Yet this form of clean energy remains prohibited in our country under federal law. Public anxiety surrounding nuclear weapons, radioactive fallout, accidents and waste means that while Australians can mine uranium, put it on ships and sell it to countries that use nuclear power, we cannot build commercial reactors for ourselves, using the ingenuity of our own people. The situation is a disaster.
And in an age of superpower rivalry, technophobia does not remain purely a domestic matter. During the Cold War, the Soviets promoted a fear of a “nuclear apocalypse” in the West, and provided propaganda and funding for peace groups and antinuclear activists. This does not mean that the millions of people who opposed nuclear weapons were plotting against the West. Most were ordinary citizens sincerely frightened by the possibility of nuclear conflict. But the fear was useful to our adversaries.
To weaken democratic nations, foreign powers do not need to invent anxiety or division – all they need to do is magnify it.
In recent days Trump has said the US will not be slowing down the development of AI. In Australia, for the time being, Anthony Albanese also has resisted calls to stop AI development, instead promising national rules designed to capture its economic benefits while managing its risks. Both positions are reassuring.
While AI comes with danger, we should be sceptical of any narrative that conveys inevitability around its trajectory. AI systems do not build their own data centres. They do not manufacture their own chips or connect themselves to power grids. Humans decide which systems can access the internet, whether they can control machinery, move money or operate weapons. Humans build them, finance them, deploy them and decide what powers to give them.
We also should remember that some of the stories we are told owe more to myth than to science. As Nvidia chief executive Huang has said of the AI doomer narrative: “I appreciate that many of us grew up and enjoyed science fiction, but it’s not helpful. It’s not helpful to people. It’s not helpful to the industry. It’s not helpful to society. It’s not helpful to the governments.”
Like every technology that has come before it, humans have agency over how AI is used. Instead of adopting a posture of fatalism, we should decide what kind of AI we want to build, what problems we want it to solve, and treat it as a tool rather than a force of nature.
Read my full piece for the @australian here www.theaustralian.com.au/inquirer/superintelligence-is-a-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Ik heb langer in homeopathie geloofd dan in God".* Interview voor @ndnl over mijn (dubbele) geloofsafval, mijn donkere mensbeeld en waarom ik niettemin een 'verbeterlijke optimist' ben. En over de "wenselijkheid" van een hiernamaals, wat een klein meningsverschil is met mijn atheïstische vrienden.
www.nd.nl/geloof/geloof/1330510/atheist-maarten-boudry-wa… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ik had nog niet gereageerd op het incident met Freddy Mortier op de proclamatie, omdat ik probeer me in te houden over mijn voormalige werkgever @UGent. Maar omdat @destandaard me erover opbelde, hierbij mijn mening:
Het staat studenten en academici uiteraard vrij om uit protest tegen een spreker de zaal te verlaten. Zelfs boegeroep kan er nog mee door om je ongenoegen te uiten, zolang je de spreker niet blijft beletten zijn betoog voort te zetten (dan wordt het een "heckler's veto").
Maar dat de decaan Mortier vervolgens veroordeelt en zich voor hem excuseert, hunkerend naar een makkelijk rondje applaus van de activisten, is ronduit schandalig. Als ze echt moedig was geweest, had ze de studenten die de toespraak verstoorden veroordeeld, niet Mortier.
Het toont hoe dicht Gita Deneckere zelf bij de linkse activisten staat. Enkele jaren geleden ondertekende ze ook de "Dekoloniseer UGent"-brief, een zuiver activistisch vehikel. Als decaan!
De activistische studenten zijn niet dom: zij voelen dat ze macht hebben en dat Mortier een minderheidspositie vertegenwoordigt. Dat ze hem kunnen uitjouwen en er zelfs schouderklopjes voor zullen krijgen.
En verder: ook zeer "moedig" van die UGent-professor om mij in @destandaard anoniem aan te vallen. Durf denken!
www.standaard.be/binnenland/een-jaar-na-de-aanstelling-va… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nog steeds oorverdovende stilte bij @vanranstmarc over zijn serie AI-columns in @demorgen. Bijna twee weken lang tweette hij zelfs helemaal niets -- hoogst uitzonderlijk. Maar hij heeft het wel degelijk gezien, want voor zijn nieuwe column deed hij écht een effort: maar liefst 82% menselijk, slechts 7% zuivere AI.
Houden zo, Marc. Als je je columns voortaan weer zelf schrijft, ga ik ze misschien zelfs weer lezen. 😉
www.pangram.com/history/38ad55b3-780b-4713-b76b-8a9e669a6… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Liberals must therefore not view borders and citizenship as annoying obstacles to be tactically circumvented or overcome; instead, we must view them as fundamental parts of the social compact that allows nations, including liberal nations, to exist in the first place. Nation-states and their laws and their police and their courts and their armies are the fundamental guarantors of the human rights that define liberalism. And for better or for worse, the ability to decide who gets in and who has to keep out is a necessary precondition for nation-states to exist."
substacktools.com/sharex/-JdyNNWu -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Sarne De Vliegher
@sdevlieg
"In zijn (@mboudry) lezing voelt de “activistische strekking” zich binnen de universiteit gesterkt sinds De Sutter rector is en bevindt de universiteit zich daardoor op een hellend vlak"
www.standaard.be/binnenland/een-jaar-na-de-aanstelling-va… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Ik heb langer in homeopathie geloofd dan in God".* Interview voor @ndnl over mijn (dubbele) geloofsafval, mijn donkere mensbeeld en waarom ik niettemin een 'verbeterlijke optimist' ben. En over de "wenselijkheid" van een hiernamaals, wat een klein meningsverschil is met mijn atheïstische vrienden.
www.nd.nl/geloof/geloof/1330510/atheist-maarten-boudry-wa…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hou het stil, maar hier kan je de volledige tekst lezen. 🤫
archive.ph/MFARl -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Dirk Van Damme
@VanDammeEDU
Freddy Mortier houdt de eervolle traditie van het vrije denken van de Gentse filosofie hoog. Hij zal wellicht de laatste zijn, nu hij, @mboudry en Johan Braeckman vertrokken zijn en dat huis gekaapt is.
www.demorgen.be/nieuws/ugent-professor-freddy-mortier-uit… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Nederlands Dagblad
@ndnl
Atheïst Maarten Boudry was als kind heel gelovig. ‘Ik heb langer in homeopathie geloofd dan in God’
www.nd.nl/geloof/geloof/1330510/atheist-maarten-boudry-wa… #ndnl -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Quillette
@Quillette
Most arguments about AI doom lean on instrumental convergence. Hardly anyone talks about natural selection, which we know produces selfish and aggressive creatures.
Maarten Boudry on why today's AI is being domesticated, not going feral.
quillette.com/2026/05/19/why-ai-is-not-about-to-go-feral/ -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Richard Dawkins
@RichardDawkins
‘Viral’ Hunts? A Cultural Darwinian Analysis of Witch Persecutions. Fascinating paper by Steije Hofhuis & Maarten Boudry (2019) showing that Meme Theory gives the best explanation of the remarkable witch-persecution phenomenon.
culturalscience.org/articles/10.5334/csci.116/ -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A “scholar who inspired a generation,” writes Nature of the late Jason Arday. Anyone searching the editorial for even an acknowledgment of Arday’s extensive academic misconduct and fraud will search in vain. If we are to believe the world’s most prestigious scientific journal, Arday was simply a victim of “systemic racism in academia.” This editorial, which needs to be read to be believed, seems to be the apogee (so far) of the canonization of Jason Arday that has taken place since his apparent death by suicide on August 14.
Not to be outdone, his own employer and chief enabler, Cambridge University, launched an independent review this week—not to investigate how an obviously unqualified person like Arday was elevated to the highest ranks at such an august institution, but to ask, essentially, how Cambridge “could have and should have done more” to stand by Arday after the accusations against him entered the public discourse. Buried as an afterthought in the announcement is a vague reference to the “wider circumstances of Arday’s time at Cambridge.”
It is tragic that Arday lost his life, and it is understandable that questions of academic misconduct should fade into the background now. But the complete denial of any wrongdoing, combined with the vicious attacks on journalists and fellow academics who were simply doing their jobs and exercising due diligence, makes it impossible to just move on.
Cambridge Chancellor Chris Smith denounced the “racist feeding frenzy” that supposedly led to Arday’s death. Celebrity academic Ibram X. Kendi described it as a “lynching,” while podcaster Owen Jones said Arday was “hounded to death.” A columnist in a prestigious medical journal invoked Billie Holiday’s “Strange Fruit” and wrote that “they are trying to kill us [black people].”
At this point, I’m more depressed than outraged about the state of academia. It was bad enough that an unqualified fabulist like Arday could rise to the very top of one of the world’s best universities. Worse still was the way Cambridge tried to cover it all up, throwing around accusations of racism until the bitter end. But the canonization of Arday after his death by large swaths of the academic left—and the wild accusations directed at anyone who has asked critical questions about his story—leave even me speechless.
Most damaging of all, this reinforces precisely the perverse dynamics that led to Arday’s meteoric rise and tragic downfall in the first place: don’t you dare question what a black researcher says about his own “lived experience”—because then you’re a vile racist (or a race traitor, if you happen to be black yourself), complicit in a “lynching” or a “witch hunt.”
Instead of learning vital lessons from what happened here, academia is already preparing the ground for the next Jason Arday.
See my post here:
substacktools.com/sharex/3kvqBbnr -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A “scholar who inspired a generation,” writes Nature of the late Jason Arday. Anyone searching the editorial for even an acknowledgment of Arday’s extensive academic misconduct and fraud will search in vain. If we are to believe the world’s most prestigious scientific journal, Arday was simply a victim of “systemic racism in academia.” This editorial, which needs to be read to be believed, seems to be the apogee (so far) of the canonization of Jason Arday that has taken place since his apparent death by suicide on August 14.
Not to be outdone, his own employer and chief enabler, Cambridge University, launched an independent review this week—not to investigate how an obviously unqualified person like Arday was elevated to the highest ranks at such an august institution, but to ask, essentially, how Cambridge “could have and should have done more” to stand by Arday after the accusations against him entered the public discourse. Buried as an afterthought in the announcement is a vague reference to the “wider circumstances of Arday’s time at Cambridge.”
It is tragic that Arday lost his life, and it is understandable that questions of academic misconduct should fade into the background now. But the complete denial of any wrongdoing, combined with the vicious attacks on journalists and fellow academics who were simply doing their jobs and exercising due diligence, makes it impossible to just move on.
Cambridge Chancellor Chris Smith denounced the “racist feeding frenzy” that supposedly led to Arday’s death. Celebrity academic Ibram X. Kendi described it as a “lynching,” while podcaster Owen Jones said Arday was “hounded to death.” A columnist in a prestigious medical journal invoked Billie Holiday’s “Strange Fruit” and wrote that “they are trying to kill us [black people].”
At this point, I’m more depressed than outraged about the state of academia. It was bad enough that an unqualified fabulist like Arday could rise to the very top of one of the world’s best universities. Worse still was the way Cambridge tried to cover it all up, throwing around accusations of racism until the bitter end. But the canonization of Arday after his death by large swaths of the academic left—and the wild accusations directed at anyone who has asked critical questions about his story—leave even me speechless.
Most damaging of all, this reinforces precisely the perverse dynamics that led to Arday’s meteoric rise and tragic downfall in the first place: don’t you dare question what a black researcher says about his own “lived experience”—because then you’re a vile racist (or a race traitor, if you happen to be black yourself), complicit in a “lynching” or a “witch hunt.”
Instead of learning vital lessons from what happened here, academia is already preparing the ground for the next Jason Arday.
See my post here:
substacktools.com/sharex/3kvqBbnr -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This you, @barteeckhout? Destijds juichte je de veroordeling van Schild & Vrienden toe en deed je nog schamper over de "koene strijders" van het vrije woord. Terwijl verheerlijking van terrorisme in alle opzichten véél erger is dan gore racistische meningen of memes.
En ja, je hebt gelijk dat het onbetamelijk is van een minister (@FranckenTheo) om openlijk op te roepen tot gerechtelijke vervolging. Dat schendt de scheiding der machten. En je hebt ook gelijk dat "verheerlijking van terrorisme" vaag en voor interpretatie vatbaar is, wat tot willekeur kan leiden.
Maar kunnen we alstublieft een béétje consequent zijn? En kun je de "koene ridders van de vrije meningsuiting" ook eens vijf minuten het voordeel van de twijfel geven, voordat je zo'n "argumentum ad silentium" loslaat? Die tweet van Francken is van eergisteren, dit is het eerste dat ik erover lees.
bart eeckhout
@barteeckhout
Waar zitten al die koene ridders van de vrije meningsuiting, nu Theo Francken een politieke vijand afdreigt?
www.demorgen.be/ts-b98a8271/
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Eerherstel! Ben je van mening veranderd, @barteeckhout , of is er echt zo'n groot verschil tussen eerste en tweede vonnis? /2
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Toch eerherstel voor @barteeckhout, lijkt me, hij is consequenter dan ik dacht:
"De nieuwe veroordeling van Dries Van Langenhove biedt daarom ook een kans aan politiek en samenleving. Er klopt iets niet aan de ‘haatwetgeving’. Het bereik van die wetten zou beter ingeperkt worden tot expliciete en concrete oproepen tot geweld tegen mensen. Anders dreigt de vrije meningsuiting te verkruimelen onder druk van de overbescherming van onze maatschappij tegen ‘foute’ meningen."
(Dit gaat over de tweede veroordeling van @DVanLangenhove, zijn inschatting over de eerste was anders).
www.demorgen.be/meningen/de-nieuwe-veroordeling-van-dries…
bart eeckhout
@barteeckhout
Hierzie, de titel is duidelijk genoeg en kostte me een mailbox vol ontgoochelde maar niet boze DM-lezers 😅: www.demorgen.be/meningen/de-nieuwe-veroordeling-van-dries…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Toch eerherstel voor @barteeckhout, lijkt me, hij is consequenter dan ik dacht:
"De nieuwe veroordeling van Dries Van Langenhove biedt daarom ook een kans aan politiek en samenleving. Er klopt iets niet aan de ‘haatwetgeving’. Het bereik van die wetten zou beter ingeperkt worden tot expliciete en concrete oproepen tot geweld tegen mensen. Anders dreigt de vrije meningsuiting te verkruimelen onder druk van de overbescherming van onze maatschappij tegen ‘foute’ meningen."
(Dit gaat over de tweede veroordeling van @DVanLangenhove, zijn inschatting over de eerste was anders).
www.demorgen.be/meningen/de-nieuwe-veroordeling-van-dries…
bart eeckhout
@barteeckhout
Hierzie, de titel is duidelijk genoeg en kostte me een mailbox vol ontgoochelde maar niet boze DM-lezers 😅: www.demorgen.be/meningen/de-nieuwe-veroordeling-van-dries…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Brian Leiter
@BrianLeiter
I'm returning to the Twitter cesspool, for two reasons: (1) Bluesky is a cesspool too, full of clueless morons who have to be blocked (whereas here I've blocked most of them already; and (2) nobody appears to be reading Bluesky. So I will resume posting blog links here.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My own rector, Petra De Sutter, turned the “Gaza genocide” into official university policy, threatening anyone who dared to question it. Multiple professors emailed the previous rector behind my back, urging disciplinary action against me. Philosopher and former friend @StijnBruers tried to get me fired and cancelled wherever he could. Invitations to give lectures were withdrawn; debates on completely unrelated topics were cancelled. I’ve never experienced this level of intolerance from self-proclaimed "progressives". And all to prop up an obscene lie that has now completely collapsed. Will any of these people ever apologize?
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ter herinnering:
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Twee maanden na ons debat zit @StijnBruers nog steeds te lobbyen voor mijn ontslag aan @UGent. Ongelofelijk hoe zelfverklaarde "rationele" denkers over de Joodse natie niet alleen vervallen in irrationele kronkels (zie ons debat), maar ook vervellen tot autoritaire potentaten.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Can we finally stop pretending nuclear is "unreliable" because of droughts and heatwaves?
New study: across 500+ reactor-years in Europe, heat & drought reduced output by just 0.6% (max 1.3% in any country). That's peanuts.
Solar and wind are FAR more weather-dependent and thus less reliable year-round, even during droughts. Heatwaves often bring still air, so low wind is common exactly when it's hottest. Nuclear's capacity factor is ~90.9%, way steadier.
And the fixes work: French river-fleet heat losses dropped 91% (5.5→0.5 TWh) since 2003 through cooling upgrades.
(Voor @MelissaDepr, dat is precies het punt dat ik eerder maakte.) www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301421526003460 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Maarten Boudry @mboudry tartly comments on the sickness in academia unveiled by the canonization of the sociopathic liar Saint Arday. maartenboudry.substack.com/p/saints-sinners-and-suspensio…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Bassem Eid
@realbassemeid
Israel removed every settlement from Gaza in 2005. It got Hamas. Anyone who says settlements are the obstacle to peace has not been paying attention.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
OMG, ik heb nu even de laatste vijf columns van @vanranstmarc door Pangram gehaald, en die zijn allemaal door AI geschreven, op één na. Ik heb @vanranstmarc, die anders niet bepaald op zijn mond is gevallen, nog nooit zó stil geweten, en ik begin te begrijpen waarom.
Betaalt @demorgen jou voor deze AI-slop, Marc? Wees toch eens eerlijk: hoe schakel je precies AI in voor je column? Ben je bereid je prompts te delen? Of ga je ontkennen dat je AI hebt gebruikt, lijnrecht tegen wat "de wetenschap" hierover zegt? (zie studie van VUB-collega's, die zegt dat valse positieven bij Pangram extreem onwaarschijnlijk zijn: link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40979-026-00226-w ). -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What is more demeaning to black scholars than the assumption that you need to lower the bar all the way to the floor for them, because they couldn't make it otherwise? Who are the real "racists" here? substacktools.com/sharex/3kvqBbnr
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
OMG, ik heb nu even de laatste vijf columns van @vanranstmarc door Pangram gehaald, en die zijn allemaal door AI geschreven, op één na. Ik heb @vanranstmarc, die anders niet bepaald op zijn mond is gevallen, nog nooit zó stil geweten, en ik begin te begrijpen waarom.
Betaalt @demorgen jou voor deze AI-slop, Marc? Wees toch eens eerlijk: hoe schakel je precies AI in voor je column? Ben je bereid je prompts te delen? Of ga je ontkennen dat je AI hebt gebruikt, lijnrecht tegen wat "de wetenschap" hierover zegt? (zie studie van VUB-collega's, die zegt dat valse positieven bij Pangram extreem onwaarschijnlijk zijn: link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40979-026-00226-w ).
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit is de enige van de vijf columns die volgens Pangram door een mens is geschreven. www.demorgen.be/meningen/het-verschil-tussen-kritiek-op-w…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Andere testresultaten:
www.pangram.com/history/dcaf7540-e4a6-475c-9d9c-b93cbc45d…
www.pangram.com/history/ec99b0ed-3b80-4165-8c63-343eda940…
www.pangram.com/history/12b6db64-5080-4585-a13b-211747620…
www.pangram.com/history/c47a2576-1bf0-4f3b-b06e-415d116e4…
Ai ai ai, @vanranstmarc.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Gokje: die busrit heeft nooit plaatsgevonden. Zat @MarcVanRanst dan achter de schouder van zo'n jongen mee te kijken naar zijn scherm? En hoe kon hij weten wat die filmpjes "hem vertellen", als de jongen zijn oortjes in had? Neemt Marc überhaupt de bus samen met tieners? Dit lijkt eerder een typisch fantasietje van de linkse intellectueel die ook als een blok viel voor Adolescence (eveneens totaal ongeloofwaardig). Color me sceptical. /3
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Het lijkt wel op migratie: "genereuze" bescherming leidt juist tot méér uitsluiting. Omdat je, zodra je binnen bent, niet meer buiten te krijgen valt, raak je veel moeilijker binnen.
"Het is met de huurmarkt zoals met elke andere beschermde markt; omdat je, zodra je er 'in' bent, er moeilijk weer 'uit' te krijgen bent, raak je er moeilijker 'in'. Toegepast op de huurmarkt: hoe breder de nooduitgang, hoe makkelijker de toegangsdeur opengaat. Het klinkt contra-intuïtief, maar het werkt wel."
www.standaard.be/opinies/niet-elke-vorm-van-huurdiscrimin… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Have to agree with Maarten Boudry @mboudry and Helen Pluckrose @HPluckrose here ...
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is my vote for the stupidest political argument of the century. Its general form goes like this:
"The backlash against the excesses of Our Party is the fault of those within the Party who drew attention to those excesses, thus empowering Our Party's enemies."
Here's an example from @NYMag and Science-Based Medicine, who argued that the free-speech liberals who signed the Harper letter and kept "railing against DEI, critical race theory, and social justice" have “provided fuel and ammunition” to Trump and his allies — effectively joining his camp by default. (substacktools.com/sharex/P4hZOr6q)
The argument gets applied to specific topics too:
"The rise of the anti-immigrant Right is the fault of those on the Left who 'problematized' migration, thus mainstreaming xenophobia."
"The backlash against transgenderism is the fault of liberals who kept harping about puberty blockers, thus parroting right-wing talking points."
Ah yes, of course! Because what problem has ever been solved by ignoring it? What could be more reassuring to potential voters than demonstrating an absolute unwillingness to tackle the lunacy on your own side?
I honestly find it hard to believe that people are so stupid to believe this. And yet I see it again and again Here's the excellent @HPluckrose making what should be an obvious point:
"Does denial of a problem within a group ever work to convince anyone outside it? Are those on the left currently convinced by those on the right shutting down criticism of MAGA with accusations that perceiving any is Trump Derangement Syndrome and everything is just fine or does this make the problem seem more intractable? Has anybody concerned by Islamic extremism ever been convinced by being told they are mistaken and Islam is actually a religion of peace or does this just convince them that those who could address the problem are not going to and solutions will need to be external and radical?" -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The stupidest political argument of the century (imho) is rearing its ugly head again in the wake of @AfD's stunning electoral victory in Germany. It goes something like this:
"If you adopt the negative framing around immigration, you're playing into the hands of the far right."
"Other parties should avoid talking about immigration, because voters will always choose the original."
"The rise of the AfD is the fault of the parties who mainstreamed xenophobia."
You can see how idiotic this argument is by applying it to, say, climate change. If the Greens are the only party willing to take the threat seriously, while all the other parties downplay it and refuse to offer a plan, of course people who are genuinely worried about climate change will be forced to vote for the one party actually addressing it.
Refusing to engage with an issue voters clearly worry about doesn't neutralize it. Exactly the opposite is true: you just hand the field over to whoever is willing to talk about it. Not everything is "framing" and "discourse" and "narrative," you third-rate Foucaultians.
When does this zombie argument finally die?
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is my vote for the stupidest political argument of the century. Its general form goes like this:
"The backlash against the excesses of Our Party is the fault of those within the Party who drew attention to those excesses, thus empowering Our Party's enemies."
Here's an example from @NYMag and Science-Based Medicine, who argued that the free-speech liberals who signed the Harper letter and kept "railing against DEI, critical race theory, and social justice" have “provided fuel and ammunition” to Trump and his allies — effectively joining his camp by default. (substacktools.com/sharex/P4hZOr6q)
The argument gets applied to specific topics too:
"The rise of the anti-immigrant Right is the fault of those on the Left who 'problematized' migration, thus mainstreaming xenophobia."
"The backlash against transgenderism is the fault of liberals who kept harping about puberty blockers, thus parroting right-wing talking points."
Ah yes, of course! Because what problem has ever been solved by ignoring it? What could be more reassuring to potential voters than demonstrating an absolute unwillingness to tackle the lunacy on your own side?
I honestly find it hard to believe that people are so stupid to believe this. And yet I see it again and again Here's the excellent @HPluckrose making what should be an obvious point:
"Does denial of a problem within a group ever work to convince anyone outside it? Are those on the left currently convinced by those on the right shutting down criticism of MAGA with accusations that perceiving any is Trump Derangement Syndrome and everything is just fine or does this make the problem seem more intractable? Has anybody concerned by Islamic extremism ever been convinced by being told they are mistaken and Islam is actually a religion of peace or does this just convince them that those who could address the problem are not going to and solutions will need to be external and radical?" -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"That an unqualified fabulist like Jason Arday could rise to the very top of his profession was bad enough. That Cambridge then tried to cover it all up and threw around accusations of racism until the bitter end was worse still. But the collective canonization after his death, across the globe, with wild accusations levelled at anyone who had asked critical questions about his story, leaves even me speechless. It also reinforces all the damaging dynamics that led to Arday’s meteoric rise and tragic downfall: don’t you dare question what a black researcher says from his own ‘lived experience’ — because then you’re a vile racist (or a race traitor, if you happen to be black yourself) and complicit in a ‘lynching’ or ‘witch hunt’. Academia is already preparing the ground for the next Jason Arday."
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What is more demeaning to black scholars than the assumption that you need to lower the bar all the way to the floor for them, because they couldn't make it otherwise? Who are the real "racists" here? substacktools.com/sharex/3kvqBbnr
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"That an unqualified fabulist like Jason Arday could rise to the very top of his profession was bad enough. That Cambridge then tried to cover it all up and threw around accusations of racism until the bitter end was worse still. But the collective canonization after his death, across the globe, with wild accusations levelled at anyone who had asked critical questions about his story, leaves even me speechless. It also reinforces all the damaging dynamics that led to Arday’s meteoric rise and tragic downfall: don’t you dare question what a black researcher says from his own ‘lived experience’ — because then you’re a vile racist (or a race traitor, if you happen to be black yourself) and complicit in a ‘lynching’ or ‘witch hunt’. Academia is already preparing the ground for the next Jason Arday."
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The stupidest political argument of the century (imho) is rearing its ugly head again in the wake of @AfD's stunning electoral victory in Germany. It goes something like this:
"If you adopt the negative framing around immigration, you're playing into the hands of the far right."
"Other parties should avoid talking about immigration, because voters will always choose the original."
"The rise of the AfD is the fault of the parties who mainstreamed xenophobia."
You can see how idiotic this argument is by applying it to, say, climate change. If the Greens are the only party willing to take the threat seriously, while all the other parties downplay it and refuse to offer a plan, of course people who are genuinely worried about climate change will be forced to vote for the one party actually addressing it.
Refusing to engage with an issue voters clearly worry about doesn't neutralize it. Exactly the opposite is true: you just hand the field over to whoever is willing to talk about it. Not everything is "framing" and "discourse" and "narrative," you third-rate Foucaultians.
When does this zombie argument finally die?
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is my vote for the stupidest political argument of the century. Its general form goes like this:
"The backlash against the excesses of Our Party is the fault of those within the Party who drew attention to those excesses, thus empowering Our Party's enemies."
Here's an example from @NYMag and Science-Based Medicine, who argued that the free-speech liberals who signed the Harper letter and kept "railing against DEI, critical race theory, and social justice" have “provided fuel and ammunition” to Trump and his allies — effectively joining his camp by default. (substacktools.com/sharex/P4hZOr6q)
The argument gets applied to specific topics too:
"The rise of the anti-immigrant Right is the fault of those on the Left who 'problematized' migration, thus mainstreaming xenophobia."
"The backlash against transgenderism is the fault of liberals who kept harping about puberty blockers, thus parroting right-wing talking points."
Ah yes, of course! Because what problem has ever been solved by ignoring it? What could be more reassuring to potential voters than demonstrating an absolute unwillingness to tackle the lunacy on your own side?
I honestly find it hard to believe that people are so stupid to believe this. And yet I see it again and again Here's the excellent @HPluckrose making what should be an obvious point:
"Does denial of a problem within a group ever work to convince anyone outside it? Are those on the left currently convinced by those on the right shutting down criticism of MAGA with accusations that perceiving any is Trump Derangement Syndrome and everything is just fine or does this make the problem seem more intractable? Has anybody concerned by Islamic extremism ever been convinced by being told they are mistaken and Islam is actually a religion of peace or does this just convince them that those who could address the problem are not going to and solutions will need to be external and radical?" -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Auschwitz Memorial
@AuschwitzMuseum
7 September 1933 | A Hungarian Jewish girl, Eva Adler, was born in Kisvárda.
In 1944 she was deported to #auschwitz and murdered in a gas chamber.
---
Some 430,000 Hungarian Jews were deported to Auschwitz. Learn about their story in our online lesson: lekcja.auschwitz.org/en_6_dep_zydow/ -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@lugaricano
This is, to me, the most shocking graph from yesterday's Saxony-Anhalt. The traditional parties have lost the blue collar workers.
(All of the exit analysis is astonishing. Take a look here: www.welt.de/politik/deutschland/article6a7b2d4f5a14d83b29…) -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Kelsey Piper
@KelseyTuoc
I wrote about the Substackers who hate Pangram. They say their issue with it is that it doesn't work. I think that in some cases the detector is working fine.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Theo Francken
@FranckenTheo
‘Wir schaffen das!’
‘Refugees welcome!’
‘Energiewende!’
‘Grünen wirtschaft!’
10 jaar later. De erfenis.👇 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Tot het sprookje uiteenspatte in Cambridge, kon je denken dat de corruptie beperkt bleef tot één instelling of vakgebied. Maar de bizarre heiligverklaring van Jason Arday bewijst dat het betonrot zich veel verder heeft verspreid. Het versterkt ook alle schadelijke dynamieken die tot zijn stormachtige opkomst en tragische neergang hebben geleid: waag het niet om te twijfelen aan wat een zwarte onderzoeker vanuit zijn lived experience vertelt, want dan ben je een gemene racist (of rassenverrader, indien je zelf zwart bent) en ben je medeplichtig aan lynching. Zoals Arday het zelf argeloos verwoordde, jarenlang gekneed en geconditioneerd door dit perverse systeem: “Ik dacht dat je me gewoon zou geloven."
Opiniestuk in @demorgen vandaag.
www.demorgen.be/meningen/wat-de-zaak-rond-jason-arday-nat… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Kudos to @nytimes for publishing this important piece by @afalkhatib. If you’re one of those Western activists deluded enough to think that chanting “From the river to the sea!” will actually help Palestinians, rather than lock them into a perpetual cycle of horrible wars, please listen to the “lived experience” of this brave Palestinian writer. Anyone who is pro-Palestinian should be anti-Hamas.
"Repeated wars killed thousands of Palestinians and wounded or displaced hundreds of thousands, locking Gaza into a cycle of destruction, reconstruction, resource theft and deeper Hamas entrenchment. Billions of dollars were wasted and the development that I saw emerging as a child was arrested.
This alone should have delegitimized Hamas among Western activists, academics, students, journalists, protesters, politicians and those who claim to be pro-Palestine. Yet after Hamas carried out the worst single-day massacre of Jews since the Holocaust on Oct. 7, 2023, triggering the worst catastrophe in modern Palestinian history, I watched with dismay and anger as activists, students, academics, politicians and writers expressed a chilling appreciation for the massacre."
"The last thing Palestinians need is more denial from the left. The Palestinian national project has a rare chance to evolve toward nation-building, peace and coexistence alongside a Jewish Israel that is not about to be exterminated. Chants of “from the river to sea” and the like are destructive conceits."
www.nytimes.com/2026/09/04/opinion/gaza-hamas-palestinian… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Misschien was ik te snel te vergevingsgezind voor @vrtnws. Blijkbaar bleef het foute citaat via andere kanalen circuleren, zonder rechtzetting, zo blijkt uit dit stuk in @DoorbraakBE. Voor andere correcties zouden ze wellicht ijveriger en doortastender zijn. Neemt niet weg dat @vrtnws tenminste íéts corrigeerde, na onderzoek. @destandaard en vele andere media lieten de lasterlijke fout gewoon staan.
"Na kritiek paste VRT NWS het artikel aan en zette onderaan een correctie. De toevoeging ‘Gazanen’ werd ingetrokken. De fout was al via andere VRT-kanalen verspreid. De Facebookpost bleef de uitspraak over dertig tot veertig Gazanen tonen. Zelfs drie dagen na de correctie sprak de VRT-podcast Het Kwartier opnieuw over ‘Gazanen’. Ook vandaag nog staat op VRT MAX een radiofragment met als titel: ‘Ben-Gvir wil elke nacht 30 à 40 Gazanen doden.’"
doorbraak.be/vrt-nws-verkeerd-citaat-verdraaide-uitspraak…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een update: nadat ik @vrtnws mailde, hebben ze de titel aangepast en een correctie toegevoegd onderaan (na Hebreeuwse sprekers te hebben geraadpleegd). Zelfs een schurk als Itamar Ben Gvir verdient het om correct geciteerd te worden.
Ik kan het aantal mensen niet tellen die me dat VRT-artikel stuurden met de boodschap: "Zie je wil, genocide, de minister zegt het letterlijk!" Dat siert VRT alvast. Er is nog hoop! 😉
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ben Gvir is inderdaad een verschrikkelijke figuur en een religieuze fanaticus, maar niettemin is dit onverantwoorde agitprop. Het letterlijke citaat is: “We moeten elke avond 30, 40 terroristen uitschakelen” en “Er moeten gerichte eliminaties zijn van 30 tot 40 mensen.” Niet gewoon “30 Gazanen”, wat valselijk de indruk wekt dat hij iedereen wil doden, vrouwen en kinderen inbegrepen. Quo vadis, @vrtnws?
Ze zijn lang niet de enigen. Als het over Israël gaat, liggen de standaarden van westerse media helemaal op de bodem. N’importe quoi. Dit zal weer gewoon rondsuizen, net als alle andere weerlegde onzin over Amalek en "menselijke beesten", als zoveelste “bewijs” dat Israël een genocide pleegt. Ik geloof al lang niet meer dat het iemand iets kan schelen.
Nooit een correctie of rechtzetting, nooit een fact check, gewoon op naar het volgende stuk clickbait over het boosaardige Israël.
VRT NWS
@vrtnws
Israëlische minister Ben-Gvir wil elke nacht 30 à 40 Gazanen doden: "Ze moeten niet leven, het zijn geen mensen"
www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2026/08/17/ben-gvir-israel-uitsprake… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Great piece again from @WorksInProgMag. It's another illustration of my rule of thumb (once proposed together with @Hiddemhigh): “You want to do something for nature? Listen to what traditional environmentalists recommend, and then do precisely the opposite.” 😉
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
One of my pet peeves is that many doomers (be it about climate, AI, or a third world war) don’t really believe what they profess to believe, and that you can infer that from their incongruous behavior. Apparently, this also applies to the AI doom book If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies.
If the authors genuinely think the survival of humanity is at stake, that they are among the very few who understand the threat, and that it is absolutely essential to persuade policymakers, why then is the book peppered with juvenile asides, flippant twitterisms, and hip jokes for the in-crowd?
The authors should be smart enough to realize that this makes it so much easier for critics to dismiss the book as the ravings of a terminally online subculture of sci-fi aficionados.
That’s what @AndrewMillerYYZ argues in this great review of the book:
substacktools.com/sharex/UZsrtcIj
“IABIED’s prose is peppered throughout with juvenile asides, some of which the sage in my parable used verbatim. Others include baby talk, like describing AI alignment studies as “aimed at understanding AIs and having them maybe not go wrong”; condescensions like “we care about the truth more than about telling you things that are easy to swallow”; or hip, ironic understatement, like saying the Allies fought the Axis because “not letting totalitarianism conquer the world seemed important”. This writing style signals to the reader that the authors belong to particular subculture I associate with social media; a subculture that values detachment, irony, and understatement, and deplores earnestness as unsophisticated.”
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Here’s how I previously applied a similar argument to climate doomers: substacktools.com/sharex/PJL4rOLs
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Can we finally stop pretending nuclear is "unreliable" because of droughts and heatwaves?
New study: across 500+ reactor-years in Europe, heat & drought reduced output by just 0.6% (max 1.3% in any country). That's peanuts.
Solar and wind are FAR more weather-dependent and thus less reliable year-round, even during droughts. Heatwaves often bring still air, so low wind is common exactly when it's hottest. Nuclear's capacity factor is ~90.9%, way steadier.
And the fixes work: French river-fleet heat losses dropped 91% (5.5→0.5 TWh) since 2003 through cooling upgrades.
(Voor @MelissaDepr, dat is precies het punt dat ik eerder maakte.) www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301421526003460
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hier dus. Nog steeds geen reactie va, @MelissaDepr. Ik durf niet hopen op een publieke rechtzetting, ik zou al blij zijn als ze het leest en vervolgens wat kritischer wordt over zulke groene mythes (op de meeste energie-experts moet je tegenwoordig niet rekenen, zelfs als ze weten hoe de vork in de steel zit. Want hernieuwbare energie bekritiseren ten voordele van kernenergie, oei oei...) /2
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Over kernenergie: een spijtige uitschuiver, beste @MelissaDepr. Windmolens zijn ALTIJD onbetrouwbaar, ongeacht temperatuur en droogte. Soms worden kerncentrales inderdaad stilgelegd bij extreme droogte, maar ook dan zijn windmolens niet betrouwbaar: het kan evengoed droog zijn én niet waaien. Bij mijn weten is er in België nog nooit een reactor stilgelegd wegens extreme droogte, maar de energie-experts mogen me corrigeren als dat niet klopt. In Frankrijk gaat de stillegging om milieuwetgeving (de temperatuur van het geloosde water), niet om technische beperkingen van de reactor. Herhaal die anti-nucleaire praatjes van de “groene fundi’s” (uw woorden) toch niet, @MelissaDepr! /3
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Tot het sprookje uiteenspatte in Cambridge, kon je denken dat de corruptie beperkt bleef tot één instelling of vakgebied. Maar de bizarre heiligverklaring van Jason Arday bewijst dat het betonrot zich veel verder heeft verspreid. Het versterkt ook alle schadelijke dynamieken die tot zijn stormachtige opkomst en tragische neergang hebben geleid: waag het niet om te twijfelen aan wat een zwarte onderzoeker vanuit zijn lived experience vertelt, want dan ben je een gemene racist (of rassenverrader, indien je zelf zwart bent) en ben je medeplichtig aan lynching. Zoals Arday het zelf argeloos verwoordde, jarenlang gekneed en geconditioneerd door dit perverse systeem: “Ik dacht dat je me gewoon zou geloven."
Opiniestuk in @demorgen vandaag.
www.demorgen.be/meningen/wat-de-zaak-rond-jason-arday-nat… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My own rector, Petra De Sutter, turned the “Gaza genocide” into official university policy, threatening anyone who dared to question it. Multiple professors emailed the previous rector behind my back, urging disciplinary action against me. Philosopher and former friend @StijnBruers tried to get me fired and cancelled wherever he could. Invitations to give lectures were withdrawn; debates on completely unrelated topics were cancelled. I’ve never experienced this level of intolerance from self-proclaimaed "progressives". And all to prop up an obscene lie that has now completely collapsed. Will any of these people ever apologize?
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I haven't tweeted anything about the Gaza war for a while because I can barely contain my anger at the sheer dishonesty and irresponsibility of it all—it’s just not good for my blood pressure.
Every major element of the “Gaza genocide” blood libel has now collapsed, yet there has been zero accountability, zero corrections, and zero apologies. It was all just a gleeful exercise in Holocaust inversion: accusing the Jews of the very crime they suffered eight decades ago.
It was bullshit, and many of the people pushing it never believed their own bullshit anyway, as you could tell from their behavior throughout the war: substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx
The gravest crime imaginable has been cheapened and weaponized as a tool of political propaganda, fomenting violence against Jews and Israelis around the world. But nobody seems to care—and least of all the Western media.
Anyway, I can relate to @Mr_Andrew_Fox’s feelings:
“Sometimes I think I am not angry enough, but the scale of the problem is almost too huge to be angry at, collectively. Towering rage must be split into smaller rages at each of the component parts of the blood libel machine.
The whole sorry mess sickens me, and now the great indictment of Israel is coming apart, one revelation at a time. This fact is not being reported by a single damned one of the media outlets that have spent years screeching over the war in Gaza to the exclusion of almost all else. Famine, deliberate attacks on hospitals, the slaughter of journalists and children, and systematic obstruction of aid: each allegation was broadcast as settled fact and then used to prove genocidal intent. The same newsrooms and universities that thundered these charges have shown remarkably little interest in the evidence that now destroys each of these allegations.
It is incredible. There is no aspect of the genocide allegation that has not collapsed.”
/2
substacktools.com/sharex/M_6TYSPO -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Max 📟
@MaxNordau
In January 2024, the world’s leading famine expert gave Gaza two weeks until catastrophic mass starvation.
Alex de Waal wrote the standard textbook on famine, runs the World Peace Foundation, and helped write starvation crimes into international law. When the media says ‘famine experts warn,’ this is who they mean.
In January 2024, he did an interview with Owen Jones and made a series of predictions/declarations about starvation in Gaza.
0:00 “I’ve not seen anything like this before” in 40 years
0:21 Famine “probably by early February [2024],” nothing like it in 75 years
1:29 Even a ceasefire cannot stop the deaths, “those deaths are on Israel”
2:33 Starvation deaths “will soon exceed those directly from violence”
2:50 “A catastrophe the likes of which we have not seen in my lifetime”
—
What actually happened:
The IPC’s own Famine Review Committee, June 2024: the famine claims were “not plausible,” and “the available evidence does not indicate that Famine is currently occurring.”
reliefweb.int/report/occupied-palestinian-territory/famin…
Gaza’s recorded malnutrition death rate in 2025 (74 deaths through late July, per the WHO) works out to roughly the same per-capita rate as the United States, where the CDC counted over 20,000 malnutrition deaths in 2022.
www.emro.who.int/media/news/malnutrition-rates-reach-alar…
After the October 2025 ceasefire, a UNICEF-led survey found 0.5 percent acute child malnutrition in Gaza, one of the lowest rates in the region.
www.thefp.com/p/unicef-data-undermines-claims-palestine-i…
—
Every single declaration was false at the time.
Every single prediction didn’t happen.
The only thing that collapsed in February 2024 was Alex de Waal’s credibility.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Israel in Belgium
@IsraelinBelgium
The Israeli Embassy is owed an apology!
In April 2024, Abdallah Nabhan, an employee of Belgium’s development agency Enabel, was killed in an Israeli airstrike in Gaza. Belgium summoned Israel’s ambassador, and international condemnation followed.
New evidence now indicates that Nabhan was a member of Hamas’s Khan Younis Brigade. A channel affiliated with the brigade identified him as a “mujahid” and published an image of him in uniform.
Before rushing to condemn Israel, facts matter.
Those who accused Israel then should acknowledge the evidence now.
A public apology would be preferable, but a private one will also be accepted. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Sense Jan vd Molen
@sensemolen
Ik deel deze gevoelens van @mboudry: veel te veel journalisten, academici en politici waren en zijn blind voor de vele tegenbewijzen van het altijd al dubieuze ‘genocide’-narratief. Zelfs nu lijkt van enige (zelf)reflectie geen sprake. Systemisch problematische waarheidsvinding.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I haven't tweeted anything about the Gaza war for a while because I can barely contain my anger at the sheer dishonesty and irresponsibility of it all—it’s just not good for my blood pressure.
Every major element of the “Gaza genocide” blood libel has now collapsed, yet there has been zero accountability, zero corrections, and zero apologies. It was all just a gleeful exercise in Holocaust inversion: accusing the Jews of the very crime they suffered eight decades ago.
It was bullshit, and many of the people pushing it never believed their own bullshit anyway, as you could tell from their behavior throughout the war: substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx
The gravest crime imaginable has been cheapened and weaponized as a tool of political propaganda, fomenting violence against Jews and Israelis around the world. But nobody seems to care—and least of all the Western media.
Anyway, I can relate to @Mr_Andrew_Fox’s feelings:
“Sometimes I think I am not angry enough, but the scale of the problem is almost too huge to be angry at, collectively. Towering rage must be split into smaller rages at each of the component parts of the blood libel machine.
The whole sorry mess sickens me, and now the great indictment of Israel is coming apart, one revelation at a time. This fact is not being reported by a single damned one of the media outlets that have spent years screeching over the war in Gaza to the exclusion of almost all else. Famine, deliberate attacks on hospitals, the slaughter of journalists and children, and systematic obstruction of aid: each allegation was broadcast as settled fact and then used to prove genocidal intent. The same newsrooms and universities that thundered these charges have shown remarkably little interest in the evidence that now destroys each of these allegations.
It is incredible. There is no aspect of the genocide allegation that has not collapsed.”
/2
substacktools.com/sharex/M_6TYSPO -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"De Inclusitie". 😂👌Wie bedacht deze portmanteau? @mariekehoogwout
Marieke Hoogwout
@mariekehoogwout
De Inclusitie bepaalt nu wat er aan universiteiten gedacht en gezegd mag worden
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My own rector, Petra De Sutter, turned the “Gaza genocide” into official university policy, threatening anyone who dared to question it. Multiple professors emailed the previous rector behind my back, urging disciplinary action against me. Philosopher and former friend @StijnBruers tried to get me fired and cancelled wherever he could. Invitations to give lectures were withdrawn; debates on completely unrelated topics were cancelled. I’ve never experienced this level of intolerance from self-proclaimed "progressives". And all to prop up an obscene lie that has now completely collapsed. Will any of these people ever apologize?
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Bassem Eid
@realbassemeid
Over the summer, a coalition of Muslim groups in New York City formed the “Unbreakable Bond Coalition” to oppose the antisemitic Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) campaign. The group will invest in Israeli bonds and distribute profits to nonprofits focused on peace, coexistence, and fighting antisemitism.
Participating organizations include @ammwecofficial, the Muslim Women Speakers Bureau, Global Youth Unity Project (GYUP), Abraham PRC, and Muslims Israel Dialogue. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In 2020, the dean of the Faculty of Arts and Philosophy at Ghent University signed this purely ideological letter on “decolonization,” along with dozens of professors, repeating all the familiar activist slogans. This is the same dean who is now proud that there is such a broad “consensus” at her faculty on the Cofnas affair: everyone wants him fired. But hey, I’m sure the problem of left-wing bias is just a figment of my imagination, as the dean herself claims.
****
Quotes:
The decolonization of education is still awaited. Higher education is stuck in colonial Eurocentric frameworks that hinder quality educational practices and leave many students dissatisfied.
Yet, many UGent students felt unheard during the recent period. The trauma surrounding the horrific events was not acknowledged due to the unclear and incomplete response from Ghent University.
Decolonization is the process of undoing colonizing practices and influences in all layers of our society, but also in our minds. Our higher education system all too often starts from a Eurocentric/Western framework, and **themes such as colonization, discrimination, and racism do not always receive the necessary attention and context.**
It is established that there are biases within research and education: examine how and where they manifest themselves in the courses and/or disciplines.
Biases are prejudiced perspectives. This therefore concerns prejudices stemming from Eurocentric colonial frameworks.
Students belonging to racialized minorities ('racialized students') can rarely recognize themselves in the predominantly white staff of Ghent University. The importance of representation for student learning performance and mental well-being cannot be underestimated.
Proactively promote ethnic diversity among academic staff at all levels, including assistants and professors. This can be done in various ways, including by investigating and removing barriers to a PhD as well as to further promotion. However, decolonization (and not merely diversity) should be an objective for every faculty and in every policy domain.
It is important that the UGent staff reflects society; students should be able to recognize themselves in their environment.
Cherry-picking is not an option: we demand that all cited and future action points be implemented equally and fully within a broader shift in mentality at the University that considers decolonization inherently necessary.
www.ugent.be/nl/univgent/missie/diversiteit-en-inclusie/v… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
When Westerners hate the West. The Auto-Immune Disease of Liberalism.
My talk at the "Defend the West" conference from the brand new @ConjectureInst.
Other speakers:
@sapinker
@SRCHicks
@peterboghossian
@jasoncrawford
@yaronbrook
@alananewhouse
@johanknorberg
@DeirdreMcClosk
@michaelshermer
@ToKTeacher
@DavidDFriedman
@nickgillespie
conjectureinstitute.org/events/defend-the-west -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Rara, wie zou dat toch zijn? Octavian Augustus? Omar Abdullah? Onder Anderen? 🧐 buymeacoffee.com/maartenbou4/t/6957119
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My paper with Bouke De Vries, responding to @JonathanAnomaly & Filipe Faria's argument about the likely demise of liberalism, is now out. See how you can actually engage in a reasonable debate about controversial issues, rather than shutting things down, dear philosophy department at @UGent? Ah, but of course we're "legitimizing" these unspeakable ideas and their untouchable authors by taking them seriously. Crank up the outrage machine!
Why Liberalism Might Last
In ‘Can Liberalism Last?’ Anomaly and Faria (2023) argue that liberal societies tend to undermine their own long-term survival, chiefly by fostering conditions—urbanization, mass migration from culturally distant regions and sub-replacement fertility—that erode social trust and grant a demographic advantage to illiberal groups, whereas liberalism's philosophical commitments bar the corrective measures (immigration restriction, pronatalism, nation-building) that non-liberal states can freely deploy. In this commentary we grant that these challenges are real, but argue that the inference from demographic trends to liberalism's collapse is too pessimistic. We identify five mechanisms that could counteract these trends. First, the fertility advantage of illiberal groups assumes high intergenerational retention, yet defection is pervasive and can accelerate suddenly once preference falsification and pluralistic ignorance give way. Second, liberal states are increasingly willing to adopt migration restrictions and pronatalist policies and—contrary to what Anomaly and Faria contend—such measures need not violate core liberal principles. Third, the economic and technological superiority of open societies allows them to exert outsized global influence. Fourth, because illiberal groups tend to be more resistant to change, some of their traits may become maladaptive as conditions change. Fifth, low fertility afflicts illiberal progressives as well, diminishing one significant source of contemporary illiberalism. The upshot is that, even if liberalism's survival is not guaranteed, its prospects in many societies are better than Anomaly and Faria suggest.
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/nana.70109
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My former philosophy department at @UGent banned the teaching of this paper by Anomaly & Faria, in a philosophy class by my colleague Bouke De Vries. Why? Because it discusses demography and migration as potential threats to liberal societies, and something called “biocultural continuity”! The horror! It sounds almost... conservative! Someone please protect the students!
If you ask me, one of the main dangers facing liberalism is precisely that (some) liberals want to shut down debate about the threats it faces. So what else could we do? Bouke invited me to join efforts and write a paper in reply, which critically evaluates and challenges Anomaly & Faria's argument. It has now been accepted for publication.
So can liberalism survive itself? Anomaly and Faria fear it may not, pointing to low birth rates, cultural fragmentation, mass migration from illiberal cultures, and liberalism’s self-imposed constraints. In our paper, we’re more hopeful. Open societies adapt faster; people defect and switch ideologies when facades crack; technology gives them an edge; and authoritarian regimes have demographic problems of their own. Liberalism ain't finished yet.
This was a somewhat adversarial collaboration, which are often the most interesting. Bouke is more pessimistic and tends to think that demography (largely) determines our destiny, whereas I take a more sanguine view of the robustness of liberal democracy and focus more on cultural transmission—which can undermine demographic advantages through the horizontal transmission of ideas and ideological defection. Liberalism is inherently attractive, and will remain so for the foreseeable future.
To be published soon—and banned in a classroom near you! -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I wanted to let poor Jason Arday rest in peace.
But there are prominent people still pretending he was the victim!
We have no choice then but to keep telling the truth. He was a fraud, and his story shows just how rotten academia has become. www.richardhanania.com/p/theyre-the-ones-who-told-us-to-pay -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Build your own conspiracy theory from scratch. If you are a teacher or educator, check out our new version of the Conspiracy Generator.
The best way to learn to spot a conspiracy theory is to make one yourself!
conspiracy-generator.duckdns.org -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I haven't tweeted anything about the Gaza war for a while because I can barely contain my anger at the sheer dishonesty and irresponsibility of it all—it’s just not good for my blood pressure.
Every major element of the “Gaza genocide” blood libel has now collapsed, yet there has been zero accountability, zero corrections, and zero apologies. It was all just a gleeful exercise in Holocaust inversion: accusing the Jews of the very crime they suffered eight decades ago.
It was bullshit, and many of the people pushing it never believed their own bullshit anyway, as you could tell from their behavior throughout the war: substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx
The gravest crime imaginable has been cheapened and weaponized as a tool of political propaganda, fomenting violence against Jews and Israelis around the world. But nobody seems to care—and least of all the Western media.
Anyway, I can relate to @Mr_Andrew_Fox’s feelings:
“Sometimes I think I am not angry enough, but the scale of the problem is almost too huge to be angry at, collectively. Towering rage must be split into smaller rages at each of the component parts of the blood libel machine.
The whole sorry mess sickens me, and now the great indictment of Israel is coming apart, one revelation at a time. This fact is not being reported by a single damned one of the media outlets that have spent years screeching over the war in Gaza to the exclusion of almost all else. Famine, deliberate attacks on hospitals, the slaughter of journalists and children, and systematic obstruction of aid: each allegation was broadcast as settled fact and then used to prove genocidal intent. The same newsrooms and universities that thundered these charges have shown remarkably little interest in the evidence that now destroys each of these allegations.
It is incredible. There is no aspect of the genocide allegation that has not collapsed.”
/2
substacktools.com/sharex/M_6TYSPO
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My own rector, Petra De Sutter, turned the “Gaza genocide” into official university policy, threatening anyone who dared to question it. Multiple professors emailed the previous rector behind my back, urging disciplinary action against me. Philosopher and former friend @StijnBruers tried to get me fired and cancelled wherever he could. Invitations to give lectures were withdrawn; debates on completely unrelated topics were cancelled. I’ve never experienced this level of intolerance from self-proclaimaed "progressives". And all to prop up an obscene lie that has now completely collapsed. Will any of these people ever apologize?
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I haven't tweeted anything about the Gaza war for a while because I can barely contain my anger at the sheer dishonesty and irresponsibility of it all—it’s just not good for my blood pressure.
Every major element of the “Gaza genocide” blood libel has now collapsed, yet there has been zero accountability, zero corrections, and zero apologies. It was all just a gleeful exercise in Holocaust inversion: accusing the Jews of the very crime they suffered eight decades ago.
It was bullshit, and many of the people pushing it never believed their own bullshit anyway, as you could tell from their behavior throughout the war: substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx
The gravest crime imaginable has been cheapened and weaponized as a tool of political propaganda, fomenting violence against Jews and Israelis around the world. But nobody seems to care—and least of all the Western media.
Anyway, I can relate to @Mr_Andrew_Fox’s feelings:
“Sometimes I think I am not angry enough, but the scale of the problem is almost too huge to be angry at, collectively. Towering rage must be split into smaller rages at each of the component parts of the blood libel machine.
The whole sorry mess sickens me, and now the great indictment of Israel is coming apart, one revelation at a time. This fact is not being reported by a single damned one of the media outlets that have spent years screeching over the war in Gaza to the exclusion of almost all else. Famine, deliberate attacks on hospitals, the slaughter of journalists and children, and systematic obstruction of aid: each allegation was broadcast as settled fact and then used to prove genocidal intent. The same newsrooms and universities that thundered these charges have shown remarkably little interest in the evidence that now destroys each of these allegations.
It is incredible. There is no aspect of the genocide allegation that has not collapsed.”
/2
substacktools.com/sharex/M_6TYSPO -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
One of the most brilliant pieces I’ve read this year. I haven’t made up my mind about this yet, but I found the argument highly persuasive. And the parts I feel qualified to judge are excellent: he has a deep understanding of evolutionary dynamics and the cruel logic of natural selection. And the writing is phenomenal. substacktools.com/sharex/FooXEU-P
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een waanzinnig verhaal dat nogmaals aantoont hoe broodnodig "vertrouwen in wetenschap" is, en wat er op het spel staat als je dat vertrouwen verkwanselt. Wetenschap is sowieso een eeuwig gevecht tegen onze intuïties en emoties. Dan kan je het echt niet veroorloven als wetenschappers om de ideologische tour op te gaan (Ja, kijk naar jullie, @Nature en @Cambridge_Uni en @Harvard en @TheLancet).
Knap van Jesse Frederik can @decorrespondent.
‘Er is een alternatieve publiekswetenschap ontstaan’, schreef geoloog Manuel Sintubin (@ManuelSintubin) over Groningen in *Seismological Research Letters*. ‘Een publiekswetenschap die een eigen leven is gaan leiden, losgezongen van de echte wetenschap.’* Niet de echte wetenschap, maar deze publiekswetenschap werd dominant in de pers en de politiek. Zelfs de parlementaire enquêtecommissie Groningen, die opdracht had feit van fictie te onderscheiden, putte rijkelijk uit het canon van de alternatieve aardbevingsleer.
Wie terugkijkt ziet eigenlijk een eindeloos repeterende cyclus. De politiek vraagt om onderzoek. Het onderzoek komt, maar de conclusies bevallen niet. Er wordt om vervolgonderzoek gevraagd. De conclusies bevallen wederom niet. Er wordt om validatie gevraagd, om peerreview, om nog meer rapporten van nog meer deskundigen. De conclusies blijven hetzelfde – en ze blijven niet bevallen.
decorrespondent.nl/16856/hoe-de-groningse-gasbevingen-ont… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
For three years, Israel has repeated that Hamas and PIJ are disguising as "journalist", "doctors", "healthcare workers" and "paramedics", because they know that this disguise offers them some measure of protection, and that their death will cause outrage among credulous westerners.
Hamas was right: all Western media just lapped up the stories about the record numbers of "journalists" and "doctors" killed, keeping almost weekly tallies and never asking any questions.
And Israel was also right: Now that the war is over, Hamas and PIJ are gradually releasing lists of obituaries, identifying DOZENS of these so-called "journalists" and "doctors" as fighters.
And what do the Western media do? Nothing. Just deafening silence. "Who cares? Let’s just move on to the next anti-Israel calumny."
I cannot even begin to describe how angry this makes me. This is an unforgivable failure of journalism, and one that would never be tolerated in any other conflict. I approached several journalists personally and urged them to report on these revelations. To no avail.
In a way, you can't blame them. The professional and social repercussions of publishing any story that is (or might be perceived as) “helping” the Israeli narrative are not to be underestimated.
***
At least 18 Gazans killed during the war who were reported to be healthcare workers — including doctors, nurses, paramedics, and other employees of Gaza hospitals or the Hamas-run Health Ministry — have since also appeared in lists published by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad identifying them as members of the groups.
Earlier this month, the Israeli [military provided details on 12 soccer players killed in the Gaza Strip during the war who it said have been identified as terror operatives, slamming their international portrayal as innocent athletes. Seven of the 12, including one who was a FIFA referee, were acknowledged as members by Hamas and Islamic Jihad.
On June 25, 2024, Médecins Sans Frontières announced the death of Fadi Jihad al-Wadiya, a 33-year-old physiotherapist and father of three who had joined the organization in 2018. [...] Then in February of this year, Islamic Jihad identified al-Wadiya as a member of the organization, describing him as an assistant in its military manufacturing unit. [...] Al-Wadiya continues to be listed by MSF as one of its employees killed during the war, on an “In Memoriam” page.
www.timesofisrael.com/gaza-death-notices-show-some-so-cal…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I haven't tweeted anything about the Gaza war for a while because I can barely contain my anger at the sheer dishonesty and irresponsibility of it all—it’s just not good for my blood pressure.
Every major element of the “Gaza genocide” blood libel has now collapsed, yet there has been zero accountability, zero corrections, and zero apologies. It was, in large part, a gleeful exercise in Holocaust inversion: accusing the Jews of the very crime they suffered eight decades ago.
It was bullshit, and many of the people pushing it never believed their own bullshit anyway, as you can tell from their behavior throughout the war:
substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx
The gravest crime imaginable has been cheapened and weaponized as a tool of political propaganda, fomenting violence against Jews and Israelis around the world. But nobody seems to care—and least of all the Western media.
Anyway, I can relate to @Mr_Andrew_Fox’s feelings:
“Sometimes I think I am not angry enough, but the scale of the problem is almost too huge to be angry at, collectively. Towering rage must be split into smaller rages at each of the component parts of the blood libel machine.
The whole sorry mess sickens me, and now the great indictment of Israel is coming apart, one revelation at a time. This fact is not being reported by a single damned one of the media outlets that have spent years screeching over the war in Gaza to the exclusion of almost all else. Famine, deliberate attacks on hospitals, the slaughter of journalists and children, and systematic obstruction of aid: each allegation was broadcast as settled fact and then used to prove genocidal intent. The same newsrooms and universities that thundered these charges have shown remarkably little interest in the evidence that now destroys each of these allegations.
It is incredible. There is no aspect of the genocide allegation that has not collapsed.”
/2
substacktools.com/sharex/M_6TYSPO -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
It's shocking how bad this book is. In terms of intelligibility and coherence, it barely ranks above Deleuze or Derrida. The prose is extremely tedious and saturated with jargon; page after page consists of abstract theoretical lucubrations with virtually no empirical grounding.
At its core, the book is just Marcuse struggling with the painful (to him) realization that capitalism works, bringing the prosperity and freedom that Marxists have always dreamed of.
The rest consists of an increasingly convoluted series of intellectual coping strategies and "sour grapes" rationalizations designed to explain that fact away: "ackchyually liberty is the real oppression," "tolerance is repressive", "if you think about it, prosperity is dehumanizing"— and similar contortions.
Every so often, the book lurches into my own field, the philosophy of science, seemingly at random and with little connection to whatever argument he was making a page earlier. And when it does, the analysis is shallow at best.
It's hard to believe this became one of the most influential and widely discussed left-wing books of the postwar era. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Kom op, Marc (@vanranstmarc), ik weet best dat je wel kunt schrijven. Misschien zat je deze keer in tijdsnood of had je gewoon een luie dag. Kan iedereen overkomen.
Dus speel eens open kaart: hoe heb je AI precies gebruikt voor deze column? Ben je bereid je prompts te delen, samen met een eerste kladversie of wat bullet points? Of bedacht je gewoon die onnozele pun van “domvolking” en vroeg je aan Claude om daar een columpje rond te schrijven?
P.S. Mensen voor dommeriken verslijten werkt altijd uitstekend in de wetenschapcommunicatie. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Leigh Phillips
@Leigh_Phillips
When I lived in Brussels, dinner parties with my francophone friends (French French and French Belgian) were rich with these sort of conversations. Gastronomy or cinema or music as much as politics were the catalyst for furious contestation—the mark of true friendship, for why would you care about what someone thought who wasn’t your friend?
Upon my return to (English) Canada, I was reminded how this *joy in disagreement* simply doesn’t exist anywhere near as much in the anglophone world: argument is to be avoided at all costs, malheureusement. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hé @vanranstmarc, ik hoop dat je je ChatGPT ook hebt beloond voor deze onzin, met een digitaal suikerklontje of zo?
Ik denk dat je AI stiekem met jou aan het lachen is, door je zulke zinnen in de mond te leggen:
"Domvolking is het gevolg van keuzes: snelheid boven zorgvuldigheid"
"Complexiteit kost energie".
"Bedachtzaamheid (net als deze column) zit vaak achter een betaalmuur"
Heb je je een Claude laten afdraaien?
www.pangram.com/history/c47a2576-1bf0-4f3b-b06e-415d116e4…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Kom, Marc, ik weet dat je best kan schrijven, misschien zat je deze keer in tijdsnood of een luie dag. Dus speel eens open kaart: hoe heb je AI gebruikt voor deze column? Ben je bereid om je prompts te delen (met eerste draft of bullet points)? substacktools.com/sharex/Ndhi-f5C
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Seeing lots of surprised reactions to the absurd Nature editorial on Jason Arday. Frankly, I'm surprised people are surprised.
Nature has been totally captured by wokeness for a while now. I've been trying to call attention to this for nearly a decade. There are no serious scholars left there in influential positions capable of rescuing it.
The people in charge of Nature today are brazenly hostile to the foundational principles that made Nature a highly respected and trustworthy institution in the first place. Today, activists have hijacked it and are using the prestige associated with the Nature brand to push an ideological agenda.
They don't care that they're quickly burning through the immense trust that was slowly and painstakingly built by generations of competent scholars and stewardship.
They're willing to burn through it all in a decade for power. It's an absolute tragedy.
Nature has gone all-in on decoloniality, which holds that academic rigor and scientific objectivity are forms of colonial oppression rooted in white supremacy. It seeks to elevate Indigenous "ways of knowing," which amount to tribal myths and forms of religious mysticism, as an equally valid system of producing knowledge.
And they don't want this absurd notion to remain theoretical; they want to implement these principles in areas that deal with life and death—medicine and nursing.
I know what I'm saying sounds absurd. People can't possibly believe that. Like, I must be exaggerating, right?
I promise you that I'm not. If anything, I'm dramatically understating the problem.
We are in the midst of a total academic crisis, and we need to stop acting surprised and start taking action to delegitimize these journals and root these fields out of our public and publicly-funded institutions.
If we don't, it's only going to get worse. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Jerry Coyne
@Evolutionistrue
I've written to The Moth to tell them about this, and will post any reply I get. They really do need to retract the story (and the author's photo, if that's fake, too).
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
It seems that literary magazine @themothmagazine has awarded its 1st prize to a short story that is 100% AI-generated, according to @Pangram: www.pangram.com/history/e3d1c545-4024-453b-8986-6ec8093c1…
I read the story. I ain't no literary critic, but it's kinda lame. It's superficially poetic and atmospheric, but on reflection it doesn't make much sense.
Here it is:
***
The Shoulder
By Jeffrey-Michael Kane
The first dead thing I ever saw that someone claimed was sleeping was a horse.
Not a whole horse. The back half was under a blue tarp behind the volunteer fire department in Nebo, and the front half was visible enough to make the lie unreasonable. Its eye had gone the colour of creek water. A man from the county stood smoking beside it while my aunt said to me quietly, don't stare if you can help it. Then louder, for everyone else: poor thing's exhausted.
Afterwards, for years, I thought exhaustion was a visible condition. I thought if you became tired enough your body would simply refuse further instruction.
The horse had gotten loose in a storm and stepped wrong on the shoulder where the road gave way. That was the official version. But mountain people have a second version for every story and sometimes a third one they keep for themselves. By supper the Ingles cashier was telling customers the horse had thrown itself into the ditch because animals know weather before people do. By Wednesday somebody at church said it'd been running from something up on Hoppis Ridge. By Friday the children had improved it into certainty.
There was a woman on the ridge road.
Not a ghost. Nobody said ghost. Ghosts belonged to stories imported from elsewhere, all chains and vengeance and Victorian grief. This woman was local. She wore a yellow raincoat and stood in the middle of the road after storms with one hand lifted like she was trying to remember whether she'd meant to wave or warn.
The first person to mention her to me was my cousin Dell, who lied with tremendous conviction.
"If you pass her and don't look in the mirror," he said, "she stays where she is."
"And if you do?"
He shrugged. "Then she rides home with you."
We were eleven and had just enough imagination to injure ourselves with it.
When I was eight or nine, before any of this, my mother had driven these same roads with her left hand open on the wheel and her right hand pointing things out. Goldfinches in the chicory. A buck no bigger than a kitchen dog. The field where her grandfather had cut hay until the tractor took his hand. She had a way of saying look without taking her eyes off the road, and I learned to look in the direction her voice tilted. By eleven I could find a kingfisher on a wire before she'd finished the word.
She sang Patsy Cline wrong her whole life. When I leaned in, I could almost taste the gravel in her voice. The second verse of Walkin' After Midnight she never could get right, didn't care, would not be corrected.
That autumn my mother started taking the long road back from Morganton after chemo because the curves kept her awake. She said the mountain roads required a conversation with the body that straight roads did not. The treatments made her sleep in fragments. Sometimes she'd wake at the kitchen table at two in the morning with both hands still around a cold cup of coffee like she'd only briefly stepped away from herself.
She wore a scarf even indoors by then. Not because she'd lost all her hair yet, but because she knew she would.
On Thursdays I went with her to treatment because my father worked swing shift at the furniture plant and my aunt had three boys already ruining her carpets. The cancer centre sat beside a dentist's office and smelled faintly of powdered soup. Women slept in recliners under crocheted blankets while televisions mounted near the ceiling explained weather systems no one intended to travel through.
Mama always carried a grocery sack with her Bible, peppermint candies and a little spiral notebook where she wrote down numbers.
Not prayers. Counts.
White blood cell count. Platelets. Temperature. Weight. Hours slept. Ounces of water. Number of times she'd thrown up that morning. She recorded herself the way men in flood country mark river heights on bridge pilings.
One Thursday coming home, rain came down so hard the road disappeared except where the headlights rebuilt it.
"You watching?" Mama asked.
"Watching what."
"The shoulder."
"For deer?"
"For people."
She said it flatly. Not teasing.
I watched.
Near the turnoff for Lake James, where the guardrail bent inward from an old collision, someone stood in the rain wearing yellow.
Not bright yellow. The exhausted yellow of newspaper left in a window.
My mother saw her too. I know she did because her hand tightened once on the wheel and then relaxed deliberately, finger by finger, like she was unclenching from prayer.
We passed the woman at thirty miles an hour.
She did not wave.
She stood with her face turned slightly towards us, patient as mail.
In the side mirror I saw only rain.
Mama drove another two miles. She did not speak. I did not ask her to.
At home she vomited blood into the sink while I stood behind her holding the scarf she'd taken off in the car. Afterwards she rinsed the basin clean before my father got home because illness in our family was treated as a kind of untidiness. Something to manage privately before guests arrived.
The woman in yellow stayed with me though.
I started watching roadsides after storms. I checked mirrors too quickly. I learned every reflector and mailbox between Marion and Glenwood so I could identify deviations instantly. If I could notice enough things in time, maybe nothing irreversible would happen.
By November my mother no longer drove herself to treatment.
By Christmas she had stopped writing numbers in the notebook.
I found it months later in the drawer beside the telephone. The last page held only four entries:
Temperature normal. Road clear. No woman tonight. Home safe.
I carried the notebook for years after she died. Through college. Through my first apartment in Asheville with windows that leaked cold air straight onto the mattress. Through the year I married someone who believed all fear could be reasoned with if you loved a person steadily enough.
Last October, driving home from visiting my aunt in Marion, I took the ridge road by mistake.
Or not by mistake.
Rain had just passed through. The trees were still dripping. Halfway around the bend near the old guardrail I saw someone ahead on the shoulder in a faded yellow coat.
Not standing.
Walking.
Head down against the weather.
I slowed almost to nothing.
For one impossible second I thought: Mama forgot something somewhere.
Then the woman turned enough for the headlights to catch her face and she was twenty years old at most, earbuds in, carrying a plastic grocery bag that bumped against her knee with every step.
A local girl. Wet. Alive.
She glanced at me politely as I passed.
In the mirror behind me, for just a moment, the road held two yellow figures instead of one. Then rain moved across the glass and took the other one with it.
www.themothmagazine.com/directory/2026-judged-by-wendy-er…This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib
@afalkhatib
A friend invited me into a WhatsApp group of “Arab queers and LGBT activists” in San Francisco who supposedly cared about Arab culture and food. A handful of pro‑Hamas extremists revolted, called me “shit,” and claimed they were “repulsed” by my presence, insisting I “work for the Times of Israel.” When I challenged their authoritarianism, I was removed because the self‑described “pro‑Palestine” members were so unwell they threatened to leave the group if I stayed, claiming my existence violated their safe space and that they did not want to bother stating why they disagreed with me. This incident reminded me of a prominent Arab feminist page on Twitter/X that eulogized Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar after he was killed in 2024, despite him leading a violently anti‑feminist Islamist organization responsible for immense harm to Palestinian women. The pattern is unmistakable: modern-day leftism has devolved into mental illness that is a political subculture which treats extremism as virtue, punishes dissent, and collapses under the weight of its own contradictions.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
It seems that literary magazine @themothmagazine has awarded its 1st prize to a short story that is 100% AI-generated, according to @Pangram: www.pangram.com/history/e3d1c545-4024-453b-8986-6ec8093c1…
I read the story. I ain't no literary critic, but it's kinda lame. It's superficially poetic and atmospheric, but on reflection it doesn't make much sense.
Here it is:
***
The Shoulder
By Jeffrey-Michael Kane
The first dead thing I ever saw that someone claimed was sleeping was a horse.
Not a whole horse. The back half was under a blue tarp behind the volunteer fire department in Nebo, and the front half was visible enough to make the lie unreasonable. Its eye had gone the colour of creek water. A man from the county stood smoking beside it while my aunt said to me quietly, don't stare if you can help it. Then louder, for everyone else: poor thing's exhausted.
Afterwards, for years, I thought exhaustion was a visible condition. I thought if you became tired enough your body would simply refuse further instruction.
The horse had gotten loose in a storm and stepped wrong on the shoulder where the road gave way. That was the official version. But mountain people have a second version for every story and sometimes a third one they keep for themselves. By supper the Ingles cashier was telling customers the horse had thrown itself into the ditch because animals know weather before people do. By Wednesday somebody at church said it'd been running from something up on Hoppis Ridge. By Friday the children had improved it into certainty.
There was a woman on the ridge road.
Not a ghost. Nobody said ghost. Ghosts belonged to stories imported from elsewhere, all chains and vengeance and Victorian grief. This woman was local. She wore a yellow raincoat and stood in the middle of the road after storms with one hand lifted like she was trying to remember whether she'd meant to wave or warn.
The first person to mention her to me was my cousin Dell, who lied with tremendous conviction.
"If you pass her and don't look in the mirror," he said, "she stays where she is."
"And if you do?"
He shrugged. "Then she rides home with you."
We were eleven and had just enough imagination to injure ourselves with it.
When I was eight or nine, before any of this, my mother had driven these same roads with her left hand open on the wheel and her right hand pointing things out. Goldfinches in the chicory. A buck no bigger than a kitchen dog. The field where her grandfather had cut hay until the tractor took his hand. She had a way of saying look without taking her eyes off the road, and I learned to look in the direction her voice tilted. By eleven I could find a kingfisher on a wire before she'd finished the word.
She sang Patsy Cline wrong her whole life. When I leaned in, I could almost taste the gravel in her voice. The second verse of Walkin' After Midnight she never could get right, didn't care, would not be corrected.
That autumn my mother started taking the long road back from Morganton after chemo because the curves kept her awake. She said the mountain roads required a conversation with the body that straight roads did not. The treatments made her sleep in fragments. Sometimes she'd wake at the kitchen table at two in the morning with both hands still around a cold cup of coffee like she'd only briefly stepped away from herself.
She wore a scarf even indoors by then. Not because she'd lost all her hair yet, but because she knew she would.
On Thursdays I went with her to treatment because my father worked swing shift at the furniture plant and my aunt had three boys already ruining her carpets. The cancer centre sat beside a dentist's office and smelled faintly of powdered soup. Women slept in recliners under crocheted blankets while televisions mounted near the ceiling explained weather systems no one intended to travel through.
Mama always carried a grocery sack with her Bible, peppermint candies and a little spiral notebook where she wrote down numbers.
Not prayers. Counts.
White blood cell count. Platelets. Temperature. Weight. Hours slept. Ounces of water. Number of times she'd thrown up that morning. She recorded herself the way men in flood country mark river heights on bridge pilings.
One Thursday coming home, rain came down so hard the road disappeared except where the headlights rebuilt it.
"You watching?" Mama asked.
"Watching what."
"The shoulder."
"For deer?"
"For people."
She said it flatly. Not teasing.
I watched.
Near the turnoff for Lake James, where the guardrail bent inward from an old collision, someone stood in the rain wearing yellow.
Not bright yellow. The exhausted yellow of newspaper left in a window.
My mother saw her too. I know she did because her hand tightened once on the wheel and then relaxed deliberately, finger by finger, like she was unclenching from prayer.
We passed the woman at thirty miles an hour.
She did not wave.
She stood with her face turned slightly towards us, patient as mail.
In the side mirror I saw only rain.
Mama drove another two miles. She did not speak. I did not ask her to.
At home she vomited blood into the sink while I stood behind her holding the scarf she'd taken off in the car. Afterwards she rinsed the basin clean before my father got home because illness in our family was treated as a kind of untidiness. Something to manage privately before guests arrived.
The woman in yellow stayed with me though.
I started watching roadsides after storms. I checked mirrors too quickly. I learned every reflector and mailbox between Marion and Glenwood so I could identify deviations instantly. If I could notice enough things in time, maybe nothing irreversible would happen.
By November my mother no longer drove herself to treatment.
By Christmas she had stopped writing numbers in the notebook.
I found it months later in the drawer beside the telephone. The last page held only four entries:
Temperature normal. Road clear. No woman tonight. Home safe.
I carried the notebook for years after she died. Through college. Through my first apartment in Asheville with windows that leaked cold air straight onto the mattress. Through the year I married someone who believed all fear could be reasoned with if you loved a person steadily enough.
Last October, driving home from visiting my aunt in Marion, I took the ridge road by mistake.
Or not by mistake.
Rain had just passed through. The trees were still dripping. Halfway around the bend near the old guardrail I saw someone ahead on the shoulder in a faded yellow coat.
Not standing.
Walking.
Head down against the weather.
I slowed almost to nothing.
For one impossible second I thought: Mama forgot something somewhere.
Then the woman turned enough for the headlights to catch her face and she was twenty years old at most, earbuds in, carrying a plastic grocery bag that bumped against her knee with every step.
A local girl. Wet. Alive.
She glanced at me politely as I passed.
In the mirror behind me, for just a moment, the road held two yellow figures instead of one. Then rain moved across the glass and took the other one with it.
www.themothmagazine.com/directory/2026-judged-by-wendy-er…This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
It seems that literary magazine @themothmagazine has awarded its 1st prize to a short story that is 100% AI-generated, according to @Pangram: www.pangram.com/history/e3d1c545-4024-453b-8986-6ec8093c1…
I read the story. I ain't no literary critic, but it's kinda lame. It's superficially poetic and atmospheric, but on reflection it doesn't make much sense.
Here it is:
***
The Shoulder
By Jeffrey-Michael Kane
The first dead thing I ever saw that someone claimed was sleeping was a horse.
Not a whole horse. The back half was under a blue tarp behind the volunteer fire department in Nebo, and the front half was visible enough to make the lie unreasonable. Its eye had gone the colour of creek water. A man from the county stood smoking beside it while my aunt said to me quietly, don't stare if you can help it. Then louder, for everyone else: poor thing's exhausted.
Afterwards, for years, I thought exhaustion was a visible condition. I thought if you became tired enough your body would simply refuse further instruction.
The horse had gotten loose in a storm and stepped wrong on the shoulder where the road gave way. That was the official version. But mountain people have a second version for every story and sometimes a third one they keep for themselves. By supper the Ingles cashier was telling customers the horse had thrown itself into the ditch because animals know weather before people do. By Wednesday somebody at church said it'd been running from something up on Hoppis Ridge. By Friday the children had improved it into certainty.
There was a woman on the ridge road.
Not a ghost. Nobody said ghost. Ghosts belonged to stories imported from elsewhere, all chains and vengeance and Victorian grief. This woman was local. She wore a yellow raincoat and stood in the middle of the road after storms with one hand lifted like she was trying to remember whether she'd meant to wave or warn.
The first person to mention her to me was my cousin Dell, who lied with tremendous conviction.
"If you pass her and don't look in the mirror," he said, "she stays where she is."
"And if you do?"
He shrugged. "Then she rides home with you."
We were eleven and had just enough imagination to injure ourselves with it.
When I was eight or nine, before any of this, my mother had driven these same roads with her left hand open on the wheel and her right hand pointing things out. Goldfinches in the chicory. A buck no bigger than a kitchen dog. The field where her grandfather had cut hay until the tractor took his hand. She had a way of saying look without taking her eyes off the road, and I learned to look in the direction her voice tilted. By eleven I could find a kingfisher on a wire before she'd finished the word.
She sang Patsy Cline wrong her whole life. When I leaned in, I could almost taste the gravel in her voice. The second verse of Walkin' After Midnight she never could get right, didn't care, would not be corrected.
That autumn my mother started taking the long road back from Morganton after chemo because the curves kept her awake. She said the mountain roads required a conversation with the body that straight roads did not. The treatments made her sleep in fragments. Sometimes she'd wake at the kitchen table at two in the morning with both hands still around a cold cup of coffee like she'd only briefly stepped away from herself.
She wore a scarf even indoors by then. Not because she'd lost all her hair yet, but because she knew she would.
On Thursdays I went with her to treatment because my father worked swing shift at the furniture plant and my aunt had three boys already ruining her carpets. The cancer centre sat beside a dentist's office and smelled faintly of powdered soup. Women slept in recliners under crocheted blankets while televisions mounted near the ceiling explained weather systems no one intended to travel through.
Mama always carried a grocery sack with her Bible, peppermint candies and a little spiral notebook where she wrote down numbers.
Not prayers. Counts.
White blood cell count. Platelets. Temperature. Weight. Hours slept. Ounces of water. Number of times she'd thrown up that morning. She recorded herself the way men in flood country mark river heights on bridge pilings.
One Thursday coming home, rain came down so hard the road disappeared except where the headlights rebuilt it.
"You watching?" Mama asked.
"Watching what."
"The shoulder."
"For deer?"
"For people."
She said it flatly. Not teasing.
I watched.
Near the turnoff for Lake James, where the guardrail bent inward from an old collision, someone stood in the rain wearing yellow.
Not bright yellow. The exhausted yellow of newspaper left in a window.
My mother saw her too. I know she did because her hand tightened once on the wheel and then relaxed deliberately, finger by finger, like she was unclenching from prayer.
We passed the woman at thirty miles an hour.
She did not wave.
She stood with her face turned slightly towards us, patient as mail.
In the side mirror I saw only rain.
Mama drove another two miles. She did not speak. I did not ask her to.
At home she vomited blood into the sink while I stood behind her holding the scarf she'd taken off in the car. Afterwards she rinsed the basin clean before my father got home because illness in our family was treated as a kind of untidiness. Something to manage privately before guests arrived.
The woman in yellow stayed with me though.
I started watching roadsides after storms. I checked mirrors too quickly. I learned every reflector and mailbox between Marion and Glenwood so I could identify deviations instantly. If I could notice enough things in time, maybe nothing irreversible would happen.
By November my mother no longer drove herself to treatment.
By Christmas she had stopped writing numbers in the notebook.
I found it months later in the drawer beside the telephone. The last page held only four entries:
Temperature normal. Road clear. No woman tonight. Home safe.
I carried the notebook for years after she died. Through college. Through my first apartment in Asheville with windows that leaked cold air straight onto the mattress. Through the year I married someone who believed all fear could be reasoned with if you loved a person steadily enough.
Last October, driving home from visiting my aunt in Marion, I took the ridge road by mistake.
Or not by mistake.
Rain had just passed through. The trees were still dripping. Halfway around the bend near the old guardrail I saw someone ahead on the shoulder in a faded yellow coat.
Not standing.
Walking.
Head down against the weather.
I slowed almost to nothing.
For one impossible second I thought: Mama forgot something somewhere.
Then the woman turned enough for the headlights to catch her face and she was twenty years old at most, earbuds in, carrying a plastic grocery bag that bumped against her knee with every step.
A local girl. Wet. Alive.
She glanced at me politely as I passed.
In the mirror behind me, for just a moment, the road held two yellow figures instead of one. Then rain moved across the glass and took the other one with it.
www.themothmagazine.com/directory/2026-judged-by-wendy-er…This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Aizenberg
@Aizenberg55
Media outlets that obsessively covered the Gaza war like @nytimes @haaretz @cnn have still not reported on the fake Gaza "journalists" evidence because it would change the entire narrative of the war they pushed for 3 years. It also means every report out of Gaza was unreliable.
Aizenberg
@Aizenberg55
🧵TWO more fake "journalists" killed in Gaza were confirmed today by Hamas—not Israel—as combatants. That is FIVE in the last week and over 100 fake Gaza journalists in total. Bahaa Akasha was not a photojournalist but a Qassam fighter seen in a Hamas video. See more below: 1/
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Los van alle voorspelbare klimaatzever in dit perfect inwisselbare stuk: @ReynebeauM snapt kennelijk niet wat "noodzakelijke en voldoende voorwaarden" zijn.
"Maar de klimaatverandering behoort wel degelijk tot de noodzakelijke en voldoende voorwaarden die tot de branden hebben geleid."
Beste Marc, klimaatverandering is logisch gezien noch een noodzakelijke noch een voldoende voorwaarde voor (grote) veenbranden, dat kan elke eerstejaarsstudent filosofie of logica u uitleggen.
Of Wikipedia:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Necessity_and_sufficiency
Tot zover deze pedante filosofische interventie.
😉
www.standaard.be/opinies/als-het-brandt-vraagt-de-brandwe… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Derek Thompson
@DKThomp
New pod/transcript: PANGRAM VS THE MACHINE
Since 2022, the share of English-language webpages that are partly or entirely written by AI has increased from roughly 1 percent to nearly 40 percent. Like a tsunami of sludge, AI writing is inundating everything from high school essays to Twitter and LinkedIn longposts, to Amazon biographies, to the oped pages of the Wall Street Journal and Washington Post.
The war on AI writing has turned Pangram into a surprising cultural phenomenon, a tool that is also a meme. I wanted to know more about how the company's technology works and how its leaders think about the fact that their invention is becoming an icon of the anti-AI moment.
So I spoke with founder and CEO @max_spero_ about:
- how Pangram works
- why we should trust it
- what the technology says about the fundamental differences between machine vs. human writing
- whether AI-writing witch hunts are something we should welcome or fear
- whether Pangram is at risk of getting displaced by an AI detector from the frontier labs or tech platforms
www.derekthompson.org/p/the-internet-is-drowning-in-ai-slop -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Joël De Ceulaer
@jdceulaer
Uit het interview met Bouke De Vries op #doorbraak: dit is smerig pestgedrag. Wat een stelletje hypocrieten daar.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Pretty much everyone who has been accused of AI plagiarism by @Pangram comes up with some version of: “Pff, I ran a book/article of mine from ten years ago through it, and it came back as 100% AI! And Pangram thinks Moby Dick is AI-generated, haha!”
But when you ask them to send you the relevant text, you never hear back. Fact: genuine false positives in Pangram are extremely rare. I’ve been looking for an incontrovertible example from the pre-2022 for ages (at least 1000 words). Still haven’t found a single case. And the claim about Moby Dick is nonsense: www.pangram.com/history/76660226-0709-447c-a032-377bf69cc…
(By the way, this is one of the greates opening pages of all modern. It took me about 500 words to be totally hooked.)
Anyway, don't take my word for it: here's a great piece from actual researchers who have conducted experiments on the question (in Dutch):
"It is precisely in this context that opponents invariably trot out the same playful examples: the first pages ofMoby Dickor someone's own doctorate from before ChatGPT. We tell you loud and clear: those examples are nonsense."
"Use a tool built from the design stage for AI detection (and therefore not a modified plagiarism scanner), and those texts will not be marked as AI-written. And certainly not to a level where you would act on it."
"A detection tool works in exactly the same way. It is not conclusive evidence, but it does act as a deterrent that makes it worth considering not doing it, and can serve as a signaling function."
"In the meantime, the question for us is reversed: where are the human texts that are convincingly labeled as AI by the better detectors? We have not found them.However, the tools varied significantly in the precision of the detected percentage of AI, with Pangram being the clearly best detector, while the other detectors were downright poor at detecting AI."
www.demorgen.be/meningen/ai-detectors-onbetrouwbaar-niet-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Na een mailtje voert VRT (@vrtnws) netjes een correctie uit van de foute berichtgeving en past ze de titel aan. @destandaard negeert mijn mail en laat het staan. Geen slechte lakmoesproef om te weten welke het "wokeste" medium is. 😉 Als het tegen rechts/zionisten/VS/miljardairs is, dan doen journalistieke standaarden er niet toe.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een ontluisterend interview met mijn collega Bouke De Vries bij @DoorbraakBE over de verstikkende ideologische sfeer aan de Gentse vakgroep:
"Ik heb aan tien verschillende universiteiten in acht verschillende landen gestudeerd of gewerkt, maar nergens heb ik zo’n beklemmend ideologisch klimaat meegemaakt als aan de UGent."
Dit klopt helaas, en is nochtans niet altijd zo geweest. Ik liep twintig jaar rond op die vakgroep en heb het ideologische zwaartepunt de laatste jaren voelen verschuiven, vooral door het vertrek van Johan Braeckman en de groep rond hem. Daarnaast gingen Freddy Mortier en Dirk Verhofstadt op emeritaat, en misschien speelde zelfs de dood van Etienne Vermeersch een rol. En @PLoobuyck speelt wegens zijn zeer beperkte aanstelling geen actieve rol meer.
Niet dat al deze academici "rechts" zijn, maar ze appreciëren wel het belang van academische vrijheid en zijn gevoelig voor (linkse) ideologische bias in academia. Ik was oprecht geschokt toen onze onderwijscommissie het bespreken van één (= 1!) conservatieve paper in een college als een "ernstige oordeelsfout" bestempelde. Daarover heb ik nog uitgebreid mijn beklag gedaan bij de vakgroepvoorzitter, maar die raadde me sterk af om er heisa over te maken op de vakgroepvergadering: wat had ik immers te winnen? Mijn contract liep toch maar enkele maanden, en ik zou alleen maar vijanden maken. Dus heb ik het laten schieten.
Het standpunt dat de voltallige vakgroep (gezamenlijk!) over Nathan Cofnas heeft ondertekend, is bespottelijk. De tekst staat niet langer op de vakgroepwebsite (dat alleen al is ongehoord), maar in een notendop: ze willen hem ontslaan omdat hij de academische vrijheid bedreigt (mijn ironiemeter gaat stuk). Ze voelen zich "onveilig", terwijl Cofnas nog geen vijf minuten op die vakgroep heeft doorgebracht. En hun welzijn is aangetast omdat ze nu "verplicht" worden om hun "hoogstaande" onderzoeken te pauzeren om tegen Cofnas te fulmineren.
Dat Cofnas niet gekwalificeerd zou zijn voor een project over liberalisme, is ook echt een wanhoopspoging. Zoals Bouke zegt: Cofnas heeft een paper over liberalisme en morele vooruitgang in Philosophical Studies, letterlijk een van de beste filosofische tijdschriften ter wereld. Ik eet mijn schoen op als er een meer gekwalificeerde kandidaat tussen zat. En hoe dan ook is de correcte procedure gevolgd en is het de vrijheid van de promotor om daarover te beslissen.
Wees toch gewoon eerlijk en geef toe dat je de academische vrijheid wil opheffen voor rechtse onderzoekers met controversiële ideeën?
Ik zie het met lede ogen aan. Nochtans zitten daar redelijke mensen aan de vakgroep, waarvan ik bijna zeker ben dat ze zich hier niet comfortabel bij voelen. Ik vind het dus verbijsterend dat niemand geprotesteerd heeft tegen de beslissing om dit document in naam van de hele vakgroep te publiceren. Dat zegt inderdaad veel over de "beklemmende ideologische sfeer" die daar tegenwoordig heerst.
Soit, lezen dus:
doorbraak.be/bouke-de-vries-beklemmend-ideologisch-klimaa… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Gerard Govers
@gerardgovers
De voornaamste taak van een universitair bestuur is eenvoudig te formuleren: zorg ervoor dat waarheidsbevinding via wetenschappelijk onderzoek en het verschaffen van uitmuntend onderwijs de missie van de instelling en de toetssteen blijven. Dat is meer dan moeilijk genoeg. Dat het af en toe niet goed loopt, dat het af en toe schuurt: het zij zo, maar daar is een universiteit nu eenmaal toe veroordeeld. @IveMarx legt hier nog eens héél goed uit waarom we het kind beter niet met het badwater verwarren.
Ive Marx
@IveMarx
Cofnas is aangesteld door iemand met een ERC en een resem peer-reviewed publicaties. Daaraan gaat een uitgebreide peer-review aan vooraf. Dat systeem is allesbehalve perfect maar zo werkt dit. Ofwel respecteer je dat ofwel is het einde volledig zoek.
www.standaard.be/opinies/cofnas-censureren-is-erger-dan-w… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Matthias Schmidt
@eurofounder
How ChatGPT will look like under full EU control
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Arpit Gupta
@arpitrage
There is debate over how Pangram works, so I did an experiment.
1) I start with the US Constitution (reassuringly, 100% human written).
2) I next asked for edits to spelling and grammar only. This is 1% AI written.
3) I then asked for clarity rewrite. Much more AI written -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Shawn Eni
@ShawnEni
This is how a blood libel is manufactured: start with a real scandal, then add a murder that never happened.
In the 1990s, pathologists at the Abu Kabir forensic institute improperly removed skin, corneas, heart valves and bones from corpses without family consent.
The bodies included Israeli soldiers, Israeli civilians, Palestinians and foreign workers. It was unethical. It was not a practice directed specifically at Palestinians.
Now look at what this account changed:
“Pathologists removed tissue from dead bodies without consent” became “Israel was KILLING Palestinians in order to use their organs.”
There is no evidence whatsoever for that second claim. Even the Guardian article in his own screenshot explicitly says there was no evidence Palestinians were killed for their organs.
And the Guardian later corrected its own Palestinian-specific headline, calling it a “serious editing error” because the victims were not only Palestinians.
So no, Israel did not “admit” to murdering Palestinians for organs.
You took misconduct at one forensic institute, added imaginary murders, and turned it into a state policy.
The Resonance
@Partisan_12
Israel was K!LLING Palestinians in order to use their organs.
First Israel denied it and called "antisemitic".
But later admitted that its forensic pathologists harvested organs from DEAD PALESTINIANS, without permission of their families.
IT NEVER STARTED ON OCTOBER 7! -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Thomas Spaas
@thomas_spaas
Een regelrechte schande, en waarom we nooit meer naar Groen moeten luisteren als het over het klimaat gaat.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Durf (hetzelfde) denken! Decaan Letteren & Wijsbegeerte aan @UGent: "Het verheugt me dat er binnen de facultaire gemeenschap zo'n grote consensus bestaat over deze kwestie, in alle geledingen. De polarisatie die we nu in de media zien, is er intern helemaal niet." Iedereen samen tégen academische vrijheid, wat een gunstig teken van open debat en ideologische diversiteit daar! Ik geloof er geen hol van dat er zo'n "grote conensus" bestaat. De dissidenten durven gewoon niet uitkomen voor hun mening, zoals ook over Israël. Of ze bollen het af wegens het verstikkende klimaat. Hier zijn getuigenissen bij van in de faculteit: substacktools.com/sharex/vDKZRhgf Zo zwelgen in de "consensus" en het eigen grote gelijk is echt niet gezond.
www.schamper.ugent.be/daily/de-storm-rond-nathan-cofnas -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Smirkley
@Smirkley
In East Asia, 80-90% of people lived in extreme poverty for 160 years or so.
Then poverty collapsed after Deng’s 1978 market reforms.
Smirkley
@Smirkley
The idea that socialism or communism lifted 800 Million Chinese out of poverty only works if you ignore the market reforms of 1978. Afterward, those living on $3 or less (2021 prices) went from 98% to ~0%.
Real GDP went from $1,744 to $19,238 in 2022, 2011 PPP dollars.
Meat consumption went from 10kg a year to 73kg.
China went from 17.9% urban in 1978, down from 19.7% in 1960, to near 70%.
chimera
@chimeraxmachina
Socialism doesn't work, except for that time when communists modernized a feudal society within decades. Or that other time when they freed a colony and gave everyone free healthcare. Or that other time when they lifted 800 million people out of poverty. Or that other ti-
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Over kernenergie: een spijtige uitschuiver, beste @MelissaDepr. Windmolens zijn ALTIJD onbetrouwbaar, ongeacht temperatuur en droogte. Soms worden kerncentrales inderdaad stilgelegd bij extreme droogte, maar ook dan zijn windmolens niet betrouwbaar: het kan evengoed droog zijn én niet waaien. Bij mijn weten is er in België nog nooit een reactor stilgelegd wegens extreme droogte, maar de energie-experts mogen me corrigeren als dat niet klopt. In Frankrijk gaat de stillegging om milieuwetgeving (de temperatuur van het geloosde water), niet om technische beperkingen van de reactor. Herhaal die anti-nucleaire praatjes van de “groene fundi’s” (uw woorden) toch niet, @MelissaDepr! /3
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Enkele letters aangepast om deze kop te doen kloppen, @MelissaDepr.😉 Het (dwaze) klimaatbeleid in België van de afgelopen decennia heeft de koopkracht al méér aangetast dan het klimaat zelf (door hogere energieprijzen). U bent terecht streng voor de groenen in dit interview, maar toch neemt u hun anti-nucleaire praatjes over. U bent socialist, geen ecologist!
Post not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Over kernenergie: een spijtige uitschuiver, beste @MelissaDepr. Windmolens zijn ALTIJD onbetrouwbaar, ongeacht temperatuur en droogte. Soms worden kerncentrales inderdaad stilgelegd bij extreme droogte, maar ook dan zijn windmolens niet betrouwbaar: het kan evengoed droog zijn én niet waaien. Bij mijn weten is er in België nog nooit een reactor stilgelegd wegens extreme droogte, maar de energie-experts mogen me corrigeren als dat niet klopt. In Frankrijk gaat de stillegging om milieuwetgeving (de temperatuur van het geloosde water), niet om technische beperkingen van de reactor. Herhaal die anti-nucleaire praatjes van de “groene fundi’s” (uw woorden) toch niet, @MelissaDepr! /3
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Interview: www.standaard.be/politiek/vlaams-minister-van-klimaat-mel…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Alright, I finally decided to write something substantial about the Arday/Cofnas/Ghent affair. I held off for a long time because the story was evolving so rapidly, and anything you write is immediately outdated. But the dust seems to have settled somewhat. Coming soon in @Quillette.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Alright, I finally decided to write something substantial about the Arday/Cofnas/Ghent affair. I held off for a long time because the story was evolving so rapidly, and anything you write is immediately outdated. But the dust seems to have settled somewhat. Coming soon in @Quillette.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Despite what everyone tells you about AI detection tools, false positives are VERY rare with substantial pieces of text (>1000 words), especially with the best ones, like @Pangram. The toold tend to err on the side of false negatives, which is fine—we don’t want to falsely “accuse” anyone.
As I wrote, however, even a “100% AI” score doesn’t necessarily mean that AI did all the work and you contributed nothing. But it does establish beyond a reasonable doubt that you recruited AI for the actual writing.
From my colleagues at the Data Lab at @VUBrussel.
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40979-026-00226-w
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Pretty much everyone who has been accused of AI plagiarism by @Pangram comes up with some version of: “Pff, I ran a book/article of mine from ten years ago through it, and it came back as 100% AI! And Pangram thinks Moby Dick is AI-generated, haha!”
But when you ask them to send you the relevant text, you never hear back. Fact: genuine false positives in Pangram are extremely rare. I’ve been looking for an incontrovertible example from the pre-2022 for ages (at least 1000 words). Still haven’t found a single case. And the claim about Moby Dick is nonsense: www.pangram.com/history/76660226-0709-447c-a032-377bf69cc…
(By the way, this is one of the greates opening pages of all modern. It took me about 500 words to be totally hooked.)
Anyway, don't take my word for it: here's a great piece from actual researchers who have conducted experiments on the question (in Dutch):
"It is precisely in this context that opponents invariably trot out the same playful examples: the first pages ofMoby Dickor someone's own doctorate from before ChatGPT. We tell you loud and clear: those examples are nonsense."
"Use a tool built from the design stage for AI detection (and therefore not a modified plagiarism scanner), and those texts will not be marked as AI-written. And certainly not to a level where you would act on it."
"A detection tool works in exactly the same way. It is not conclusive evidence, but it does act as a deterrent that makes it worth considering not doing it, and can serve as a signaling function."
"In the meantime, the question for us is reversed: where are the human texts that are convincingly labeled as AI by the better detectors? We have not found them.However, the tools varied significantly in the precision of the detected percentage of AI, with Pangram being the clearly best detector, while the other detectors were downright poor at detecting AI."
www.demorgen.be/meningen/ai-detectors-onbetrouwbaar-niet-… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Na een mailtje voert VRT (@vrtnws) netjes een correctie uit van de foute berichtgeving en past ze de titel aan. @destandaard negeert mijn mail en laat het staan. Geen slechte lakmoesproef om te weten welke het "wokeste" medium is. 😉 Als het tegen rechts/zionisten/VS/miljardairs is, dan doen journalistieke standaarden er niet toe.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Stel je voor dat het op café Happy Hour is en je voor de prijs van één drankje maar liefst 100 drankjes kan kopen. En die vervolgens aan het hele café kunt trakteren. Die kans grijp je toch meteen? 🍻
Dat, in een notendop, is wat dit boek belooft én waarmaakt. Sommige goede doelen zijn honderden keren doeltreffender dan andere. Honderd keer meer lijden verlichten, of geluk bevorderen. Dan doneer je toch meteen?❤️www.bol.com/be/nl/f/het-beste-wat-je-met-je-geld-kunt-doe…
Het is vandaag trouwens de verjaardag van Bram Schaper, de auteur van dit geweldige boek, die zijn eigen carrière bij @NS_online omgooide om de wereld honderdvoudig te verbeteren. 🌍
Wil je hem (en mij) een plezier doen? Schenk dan een verjaardagscadeau aan @DoneerEffectief. 🎁
doneereffectief.nl/doneren/
En hou het stil, maar het is ook dik egoïstisch: onderzoek wijst uit dat effectief doneren óók de donor gelukkig maakt. Kan ik zelf beamen. 😉 -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Stel je voor dat het op café Happy Hour is en je voor de prijs van één drankje maar liefst 100 drankjes kan kopen. En die vervolgens aan het hele café kunt trakteren. Die kans grijp je toch meteen? 🍻
Dat, in een notendop, is wat dit boek belooft én waarmaakt. Sommige goede doelen zijn honderden keren doeltreffender dan andere. Honderd keer meer lijden verlichten, of geluk bevorderen. Dan doneer je toch meteen?❤️www.bol.com/be/nl/f/het-beste-wat-je-met-je-geld-kunt-doe…
Het is vandaag trouwens de verjaardag van Bram Schaper, de auteur van dit geweldige boek, die zijn eigen carrière bij @NS_online omgooide om de wereld honderdvoudig te verbeteren. 🌍
Wil je hem (en mij) een plezier doen? Schenk dan een verjaardagscadeau aan @DoneerEffectief. 🎁
doneereffectief.nl/doneren/
En hou het stil, maar het is ook dik egoïstisch: onderzoek wijst uit dat effectief doneren óók de donor gelukkig maakt. Kan ik zelf beamen. 😉 -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My colleague @jflier objects to the (nonexistent) editorial judgment of the once-prestigious New England Journal of Medicine that led to the publication of an unhinged opinion piece on the Jason Arday fraud that began "They're trying to kill us" (presumably white people trying to kill black people") and, astonishingly, admitted, “I don’t care whether any of these allegations against Prof. Arday were true.”
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
I wrote about failed editorial oversight of a recent Voices column about the Arday affair by @NEJM open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/the-new-england-journ…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Despite what everyone tells you about AI detection tools, false positives are VERY rare with substantial pieces of text (>1000 words), especially with the best ones, like @Pangram. The toold tend to err on the side of false negatives, which is fine—we don’t want to falsely “accuse” anyone.
As I wrote, however, even a “100% AI” score doesn’t necessarily mean that AI did all the work and you contributed nothing. But it does establish beyond a reasonable doubt that you recruited AI for the actual writing.
From my colleagues at the Data Lab at @VUBrussel.
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40979-026-00226-w
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Pretty much everyone who has been accused of AI plagiarism by @Pangram comes up with some version of: “Pff, I ran a book/article of mine from ten years ago through it, and it came back as 100% AI! And Pangram thinks Moby Dick is AI-generated, haha!”
But when you ask them to send you the relevant text, you never hear back. Fact: genuine false positives in Pangram are extremely rare. I’ve been looking for an incontrovertible example from the pre-2022 for ages (at least 1000 words). Still haven’t found a single case. And the claim about Moby Dick is nonsense: www.pangram.com/history/76660226-0709-447c-a032-377bf69cc…
(By the way, this is one of the greates opening pages of all modern. It took me about 500 words to be totally hooked.)
Anyway, don't take my word for it: here's a great piece from actual researchers who have conducted experiments on the question (in Dutch):
"It is precisely in this context that opponents invariably trot out the same playful examples: the first pages ofMoby Dickor someone's own doctorate from before ChatGPT. We tell you loud and clear: those examples are nonsense."
"Use a tool built from the design stage for AI detection (and therefore not a modified plagiarism scanner), and those texts will not be marked as AI-written. And certainly not to a level where you would act on it."
"A detection tool works in exactly the same way. It is not conclusive evidence, but it does act as a deterrent that makes it worth considering not doing it, and can serve as a signaling function."
"In the meantime, the question for us is reversed: where are the human texts that are convincingly labeled as AI by the better detectors? We have not found them.However, the tools varied significantly in the precision of the detected percentage of AI, with Pangram being the clearly best detector, while the other detectors were downright poor at detecting AI."
www.demorgen.be/meningen/ai-detectors-onbetrouwbaar-niet-…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
If you've been wrongly accused of outsourcing your writing (and thinking) to AI, there's only one way to find out: SHOW US THE PROMPTS. /2 😎substacktools.com/sharex/JtJDAhvk
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Pretty much everyone who has been accused of AI plagiarism by @Pangram comes up with some version of: “Pff, I ran a book/article of mine from ten years ago through it, and it came back as 100% AI! And Pangram thinks Moby Dick is AI-generated, haha!”
But when you ask them to send you the relevant text, you never hear back. Fact: genuine false positives in Pangram are extremely rare. I’ve been looking for an incontrovertible example from the pre-2022 for ages (at least 1000 words). Still haven’t found a single case. And the claim about Moby Dick is nonsense: www.pangram.com/history/76660226-0709-447c-a032-377bf69cc…
(By the way, this is one of the greates opening pages of all modern. It took me about 500 words to be totally hooked.)
Anyway, don't take my word for it: here's a great piece from actual researchers who have conducted experiments on the question (in Dutch):
"It is precisely in this context that opponents invariably trot out the same playful examples: the first pages ofMoby Dickor someone's own doctorate from before ChatGPT. We tell you loud and clear: those examples are nonsense."
"Use a tool built from the design stage for AI detection (and therefore not a modified plagiarism scanner), and those texts will not be marked as AI-written. And certainly not to a level where you would act on it."
"A detection tool works in exactly the same way. It is not conclusive evidence, but it does act as a deterrent that makes it worth considering not doing it, and can serve as a signaling function."
"In the meantime, the question for us is reversed: where are the human texts that are convincingly labeled as AI by the better detectors? We have not found them.However, the tools varied significantly in the precision of the detected percentage of AI, with Pangram being the clearly best detector, while the other detectors were downright poor at detecting AI."
www.demorgen.be/meningen/ai-detectors-onbetrouwbaar-niet-…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Here's my piece about it for Quillette, which can now be read without a paywall: substacktools.com/sharex/JtJDAhvk
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Exactly. For @UGent to object to a phrase like “worthless scholar” (applied to Jason Arday) is pretty rich. @NathanCofnas has been called a pseudoscientist, the equivalent of a flat-earther, a white supremacist, a closet Nazi, an idiot, and much worse. That’s all par for the course in academia, but the double standards here are simply egregious. It’s unbelievable that nobody realized how bad this would look.
Likewise, if any UGent employee is entitled to claim that their “psychological well-being” has been “disturbed,” it’s Cofnas. He receives death threats, has been assaulted by a student after a lecture, is afraid to show his face in the city center, and has been relentlessly hounded by his colleagues since his appoinment. A tenured professor threatened to physically remove him from campus if he ever dared to show up to claim his office (on national TV).
But THEY are claiming that Cofnas is "disturbing" their "psychological well-being", even though he never even shows up on campus except for that lecture?
Coel Hellier
@coelhellier
Also, many of those suggesting that such is criminal are themselves accusing Cofnas of “pseudoscience” (is that any better than “plagiarism”) and expressing plenty of mean opinions about Cofnas. I suspect that they don’t consider themselves to be violating codes of conduct.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Strong words in @insidehighered about @UGent's letter suspending @nathancofnas:
"Ghent argues that Cofnas’s criticism of Arday as “mentally disabled” and a "worthless scholar" was “an intentional and serious disturbance of the peace” that may violate “the Belgian Criminal Code.” It is ludicrous (and dangerous) to suggest that accurately accusing a scholar of plagiarism and expressing mean opinions could ever be considered a crime."
www.insidehighered.com/opinion/columns/debatable-ideas/20… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Philosophy papers used to be read by no-one. Now, they will also be written by no-one. #progress dailynous.com/2026/08/13/philosophy-journal-publishes-lar…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Zou @dewereldmorgen dan tóch eindelijk minimale journalistieke standaarden hebben gekweekt? Ontroerend dat ik dát nog mag meemaken.🥹Of heeft de Amerikaanse ambassadeur ingegrepen?
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Alles van deze auteur lijkt verwijderd: het was dan ook een losgeslagen malloot zelfs naar @dewereldmorgen-standaarden. www.dewereldmorgen.be/schrijver/jotie/
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Het is compleet gelogen dat dat een "race science" bijeenkomst was. De conferentie ging over heterodoxe ideeën, en er waren topsprekers als Steven Pinker, Musa Al-Gharbi, Michael Shermer, Yascha Mounk, Eric Kaufmann, Claire Lehmann, en Lee Jussim. Ik herinner me geen enkele lezing over ras. /3 heterodoxconference.com
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
So @IAI_TV invited me to participate in a public debate about postmodernism—for free. I accepted, did some preparation, and read the material they sent me. But then they proceeded to “ghost” me, ignoring all further emails and reminders. Rude and unprofessional behavior. Anyone else have a bad experience with these people?
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wait, what? If I am to believe Ambassador @BillWhiteUSA, he has negotiated an “amicable agreement” between @UGent and @nathancofnas behind the scenes, lifting the suspension and allowing Cofnas to complete the full term of his appointment.
It seems his email access has indeed been restored, and the ban on contacting colleagues has been lifted. He just has to work remotely from now on (a measure that can be extended by three months each time).
But if the ambassador is right, that means @UGent has already decided not to fire Cofnas, and will just kick the can down the road until his term ends?
I’m in favor of academic freedom, so I’m happy with that arrangement. But it does seem disingenuous: what's the point of the disciplinary "investigation" then? I really wonder what the hundreds of academics who want Cofnas expelled will make of this.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
So now @UGent emphatically denies that this “amicable agreement” with @BillWhiteUSA ever took place and insists that nothing has changed and @nathancofnas is still under disciplinary investigation. Not surprising, since this would look a lot like strong-arming—or some might say “blackmail”—by a foreign actor. /2 demorgen.be/nieuws/amerikaanse-ambassadeur-zaait-twijfel-…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
So now @UGent emphatically denies that this “amicable agreement” with @BillWhiteUSA ever took place and insists that nothing has changed. Not surprising, since it would look a lot like strong-arming—or some might say “blackmail”—by a foreign actor. www.demorgen.be/nieuws/amerikaanse-ambassadeur-zaait-twij…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wait, what? If I am to believe Ambassador @BillWhiteUSA, he has negotiated an “amicable agreement” between @UGent and @nathancofnas behind the scenes, lifting the suspension and allowing Cofnas to complete the full term of his appointment.
It seems his email access has indeed been restored, and the ban on contacting colleagues has been lifted. He just has to work remotely from now on (a measure that can be extended by three months each time).
But if the ambassador is right, that means @UGent has already decided not to fire Cofnas, and will just kick the can down the road until his term ends?
I’m in favor of academic freedom, so I’m happy with that arrangement. But it does seem disingenuous: what's the point of the disciplinary "investigation" then? I really wonder what the hundreds of academics who want Cofnas expelled will make of this. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This old TEDx talk by Ghent University rector Petra De Sutter is an excellent illustration of why academic freedom is so important.
Many people are now freaking out about her advocacy of “genetic enhancement” and “designer babies.” They call her ideas “sinister” and “shocking”—ironically, not unlike how many people view @nathancofnas. They have more in common than you might think. 🙃
I beg to differ. Genetic enhancement of the human species is a legitimate area of research for fertility experts, bioethicists, geneticists, and others. It deserves serious discussion, not moral panic
Although it's not my field, I’m actually sympathetic to it: certainly when it comes to selecting against disease, but even when it comes to positive traits such as intelligence, health, and beauty. Why not? In some respects, we're all eugenicists, as @sentientist has written (www.aporiamagazine.com/p/youre-probably-a-eugenicist). Concerns about inequal access are real, but not insurmountable.
Frankly, the only thing that’s risible about this talk is her claim that making genetically engineered designer babies in factories “was Aldous Huxley’s dream.”
Gosh, I’m no literary scholar, but could it be that Huxley intended Brave New World as a dystopia, rather than a “dream”?
*Or, obnoxiously, insisting on “him.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
let's say your only goal in life, as an online slacktivist, is to ensure nathan cofnas's ideas don't spread further. could you imagine a more embarrassing, humiliating result than this? jfc if you had done *nothing* you'd be far better off today than you were weeks ago
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I am grateful to Rector Petra De Sutter for allowing me to stay at Ghent University. I look forward to continuing to work on the project, “The Future of Liberalism,” for 60% of my working time for the remainder of my one-year postdoc.
I wish to personally thank Ambassador @BillWhiteUSA. It was beyond my imagination that such a person would take an interest in the fate of a postdoc. The Ambassador responded with great support which helped to bring about a just outcome. Thank you, @USAmbToBelgium and @StateDept for defending American values. I am proud of my country. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In The Ultimate Resource, Julian Simon gives a beautiful illustration of how prevalence-induced concept change undermines belief in progress, and leads to The Law of Conservation of Outrage: No matter how much progress the world makes, the total amount of outrage remains constant.
"It was the decline in pollution - greatly assisted by better sanitation - that brought about the stunning declines in mortality. The problem is that the word "pollution" has changed its meaning simply because the great killing disease pollutions of the past - cholera, typhoid fever, diphtheria, and the like - have now been conquered in the rich countries; people now think of pollution as the relatively minor dangers (relative to the past) of pesticides and various carcinogens."
(I will soon publish my Eight Laws of Declinism in a proper journal) -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is what the distinguished “educational committee” had to say about the decision to discuss the paper in class: “a serious error of judgment.” It sounds Orwellian, but this is the state of academia today—or at least of @UGent. The problem of ideological capture has been a long time in the making, and it’s only getting worse. /2
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Volodymyr Zelenskyy / Володимир Зеленський
@ZelenskyyUa
I received warm congratulations for the people of Ukraine from Prime Minister @netanyahu of Israel. Our countries share deep bonds – between our people in the first place, but also in the economy, culture, and other areas. It is therefore good to hear of Israel’s desire to strengthen these existing ties. We count on working fruitfully together to bring about more security.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
So @IAI_TV invited me to participate in a public debate about postmodernism—for free. I accepted, did some preparation, and read the material they sent me. But then they proceeded to “ghost” me, ignoring all further emails and reminders. Rude and unprofessional behavior. Anyone else have a bad experience with these people?
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"To be published soon—and banned [by the academic left] in a classroom near you!" @mboudry's defense of...liberalism.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My former philosophy department at @UGent banned the teaching of this paper by Anomaly & Faria, in a philosophy class by my colleague Bouke De Vries. Why? Because it discusses demography and migration as potential threats to liberal societies, and something called “biocultural continuity”! The horror! It sounds almost... conservative! Someone please protect the students!
If you ask me, one of the main dangers facing liberalism is precisely that (some) liberals want to shut down debate about the threats it faces. So what else could we do? Bouke invited me to join efforts and write a paper in reply, which critically evaluates and challenges Anomaly & Faria's argument. It has now been accepted for publication.
So can liberalism survive itself? Anomaly and Faria fear it may not, pointing to low birth rates, cultural fragmentation, mass migration from illiberal cultures, and liberalism’s self-imposed constraints. In our paper, we’re more hopeful. Open societies adapt faster; people defect and switch ideologies when facades crack; technology gives them an edge; and authoritarian regimes have demographic problems of their own. Liberalism ain't finished yet.
This was a somewhat adversarial collaboration, which are often the most interesting. Bouke is more pessimistic and tends to think that demography (largely) determines our destiny, whereas I take a more sanguine view of the robustness of liberal democracy and focus more on cultural transmission—which can undermine demographic advantages through the horizontal transmission of ideas and ideological defection. Liberalism is inherently attractive, and will remain so for the foreseeable future.
To be published soon—and banned in a classroom near you! -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
An important nuance from Bouke (who's not on X): he’s not so much pessimistic about demography in general, but he assigns different weights to the various reasons for optimism about liberalism’s prospects. For instance, he puts more emphasis on liberal openness to novel technologies, whereas I tend to emphasize cultural transmission and defection rates from illiberal groups.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My former philosophy department at @UGent banned the teaching of this paper by Anomaly & Faria, in a philosophy class by my colleague Bouke De Vries. Why? Because it discusses demography and migration as potential threats to liberal societies, and something called “biocultural continuity”! The horror! It sounds almost... conservative! Someone please protect the students!
If you ask me, one of the main dangers facing liberalism is precisely that (some) liberals want to shut down debate about the threats it faces. So what else could we do? Bouke invited me to join efforts and write a paper in reply, which critically evaluates and challenges Anomaly & Faria's argument. It has now been accepted for publication.
So can liberalism survive itself? Anomaly and Faria fear it may not, pointing to low birth rates, cultural fragmentation, mass migration from illiberal cultures, and liberalism’s self-imposed constraints. In our paper, we’re more hopeful. Open societies adapt faster; people defect and switch ideologies when facades crack; technology gives them an edge; and authoritarian regimes have demographic problems of their own. Liberalism ain't finished yet.
This was a somewhat adversarial collaboration, which are often the most interesting. Bouke is more pessimistic and tends to think that demography (largely) determines our destiny, whereas I take a more sanguine view of the robustness of liberal democracy and focus more on cultural transmission—which can undermine demographic advantages through the horizontal transmission of ideas and ideological defection. Liberalism is inherently attractive, and will remain so for the foreseeable future.
To be published soon—and banned in a classroom near you! -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My former philosophy department at @UGent banned the teaching of this paper by Anomaly & Faria, in a philosophy class by my colleague Bouke De Vries. Why? Because it discusses demography and migration as potential threats to liberal societies, and something called “biocultural continuity”! The horror! It sounds almost... conservative! Someone please protect the students!
If you ask me, one of the main dangers facing liberalism is precisely that (some) liberals want to shut down debate about the threats it faces. So what else could we do? Bouke invited me to join efforts and write a paper in reply, which critically evaluates and challenges Anomaly & Faria's argument. It has now been accepted for publication.
So can liberalism survive itself? Anomaly and Faria fear it may not, pointing to low birth rates, cultural fragmentation, mass migration from illiberal cultures, and liberalism’s self-imposed constraints. In our paper, we’re more hopeful. Open societies adapt faster; people defect and switch ideologies when facades crack; technology gives them an edge; and authoritarian regimes have demographic problems of their own. Liberalism ain't finished yet.
This was a somewhat adversarial collaboration, which are often the most interesting. Bouke is more pessimistic and tends to think that demography (largely) determines our destiny, whereas I take a more sanguine view of the robustness of liberal democracy and focus more on cultural transmission—which can undermine demographic advantages through the horizontal transmission of ideas and ideological defection. Liberalism is inherently attractive, and will remain so for the foreseeable future.
To be published soon—and banned in a classroom near you!
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is what the distinguished "educational committee" had to say about the decision to discussi paper in class: "a serious error of judgment". It sounds Orwellian, but this is now the state of academia, or at least of @UGent. The problem of ideological capture has been long in the making, and it's only getting worse. /2
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is what the distinguished “educational committee” had to say about the decision to discuss the paper in class: “a serious error of judgment.” It sounds Orwellian, but this is the state of academia today—or at least of @UGent. The problem of ideological capture has been a long time in the making, and it’s only getting worse. /2
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
An important nuance from Bouke (who's not on X): he’s not so much pessimistic about demography in general, but attaches different weights to each of the reasons for optimism about liberalism's prospects. For instance, he tends to put more emphasis on liberal openness to novel technologies, while I tend to emphasize cultural transmission and defection rates from iliberal groups. /3
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
On a personal note: I studied and worked at @UGent for over two decades, with only brief periods elsewhere (Boston, NY, Budapest, Vienna, Leuven). I was also the first holder of the Etienne Vermeersch Chair at UGent for four years, under the previous rector.
I don’t regret any of this. On the contrary, I remain very grateful to @UGent for the honour of being the first holder of that prestigious Chair. The philosopher Etienne Vermeersch, former vice-rector of @UGent, remains one of my personal intellectual heroes. His scepticism, liberalism, and defence of rationality and science have had a lasting and salutary influence on the university.
During my time as Chair holder, UGent gave me almost complete freedom to develop my ideas and projects, despite some internal backlash. Even when I ventured into controversial territory—such as in my opening lectures and my podcast Forbidden Territory (Verboden Terrein)—I did not experience ideological censorship or pressure (with one exception during an interview for the UGent magazine).
In recent years, however, I have grown increasingly estranged from my alma mater. I have watched the growing ideological capture with mounting concern, especially since the election of the new rector. Even before that, I was shocked and dismayed that UGent played a leading role in the anti-Israel boycott, on what I believe very shaky grounds. To me, this represents a serious abdication of the core principles of academic freedom and institutional neutrality.
Within my own department, the intellectual climate has also deteriorated—particularly in the aftermath of 7 October and following the departure of my former supervisor, Johan Braeckman, and his research group.
To be clear: I have had many rewarding years at UGent, and I still maintain good relationships with several former colleagues who continue to do excellent work. But given the scandals and embarrassments in recent years, I regret to say that I was no longer proud of my affiliation with UGent.
The academic world as a whole is in crisis, being increasingly captured by ideology, but unfortunately @UGent has become one of the worst offenders.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The lunatics have definitively taken over the asylum. Activists masked with keffiyehs are AGAIN illegally occupying the campus—despite the disgraceful boycott @UGent has already agreed to, and despite the fact that the new rector is as leftist and rabidly anti-Israel as they come. And what does she do? Put on the kiddy gloves and grovel in front of them—only to be arrogantly rebuffed: "We will invite you". It pains me to say this, but I’m glad I left @UGent.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"There is something deeply regressive about asking people to reduce their activities in the name of saving the climate. Cheap energy gives ordinary people warm homes, private and comfortable transport, refrigeration, air conditioning and access to goods that earlier generations would have considered extraordinary luxuries. Developing countries now want the same transformation that developed countries already enjoyed. And frankly, I can't blame them. Who are we in the West to tell countries like China, India, the Middle East, and Africa not to develop? That's the height of arrogance."
By John Aziz (@aziz0nomics).
quillette.com/2026/08/26/net-zero-wont-fix-climate-change… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Freek Van de Velde
@freekvdvelde
De UGent slaat een modderfiguur.
Vier vragen:
1. “Zeggen dat wij de academische vrijheid beknotten, klopt niet.” (De Sutter). Waarom dan bepalen waar Cofnas wel en geen onderzoek naar mag doen de komende maanden? Dat is _precies_ het inperken van academische vrijheid.
2. “De ordemaatregel van drie maanden kan volgens het interne tuchtreglement van de universiteit opgelegd worden wanneer bepaalde feiten of het gedrag van het personeelslid onrust veroorzaakt”. Dus als mensen onrustig worden kunnen onderzoekers geschorst worden? Ik raad collega’s af om filosofisch of empirisch onderzoek te doen naar holebi-rechten, onverdoofd slachten, abortus, stamcelonderzoek en spellingshervorming, om maar een paar onderwerpen te noemen waarover geregeld ‘onrust’ ontstaat bij deze of gene bevolkingsgroep.
3. ‘De ordemaatregel is niet het gevolg van de zaak-Arday.’ Waarom werd er dan naar de zaak-Arday verwezen in de brief die de academische overheid naar Cofnas stuurde?
4. ‘De ordemaatregel is niet het gevolg van de zaak-Arday.’ Waarom dan deze timing, met een ordemaatregel direct na de zaak-Arday? -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Philosophy papers used to be read by no-one. Now, they will also be written by no-one. #progress dailynous.com/2026/08/13/philosophy-journal-publishes-lar…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
HOAX! Ik heb de servers van @Knack gehackt om een knettergek edito in naam van hoofdredacteur @bertbultinck te publiceren.* Het is een pleidooi voor een maoïstische zuivering van onze universiteiten, en een oproep tot ontslag van drie rechtse onderzoekers tegelijk. En ze trapten erin, haha!
"De rectoren moeten dringend de poorten radicaal dichtgooien voor dubieuze ideologen die zich presenteren als wetenschappers."
"Naast Cofnas komt een kompaan van hem nu ook weer in beeld [...]: de 'biologiefilosoof' Bouke de Vries, die Cofnas in Gent heeft binnengehaald."
"Zo heeft De Vries een paper klaar die de armoede moet helpen bestrijden, en wel door embryoselectie op basis van intelligentie."
"De Vries haalde niet alleen Cofnas binnen, maar ook nog eens de Amerikaans-Franse filosoof Craig Willy, weliswaar als onbezoldigde doctoraatsonderzoeker. Net als Cofnas is Willy een 'rassenrealist'."
"De UGent moet strenger optreden tegen Nathan Cofnas én Bouke de Vries. Ook die laatste zal zijn ideeën verder verspreiden. Het valt niet uit te sluiten dat hij meer gelijkgestemde zielen een plek wil geven aan de Gentse universiteit."
"Het is hoog tijd dat ook onze instellingen zich assertiever opstellen tegenover aanvallen van pseudowetenschappers die de academische gemeenschap binnendringen."
"De Gentse rector Petra De Sutter raakt maar niet uit de greep van de affaire-Cofnas. Zij en haar collega-rectoren moeten dringend de poorten radicaal dichtgooien voor dubieuze ideologen die zich presenteren als wetenschappers."
*Speciaal voor de droogstoppels van Roularta: dit is SATIRE. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
These are the very same people who still emphatically deny that academia has been captured by leftist ideology. Yet, in the blink of an eye, they can gather 500 signatures from a single university for such absurd racial nonsense.
Yeah sure, Jason Arday came under fire because he was “not allowed to belong,” because his critics supposedly believe that academia “naturally belongs to white people.” Not at all because of massive fraud, plagiarism, lies, worthless work, cover-ups, and intimidation of journalists, or anything.
This would all be hilarious if it weren’t so deeply sad. The problem at @UGent is even worse than I thought. I can only take comfort in the former colleagues* who did not sign this letter.
*I severed my ties with UGent in January.
www.demorgen.be/meer-nieuws/dit-maakt-pijnlijk-duidelijk-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I promised to give Ghent University the “benefit of the doubt” before writing a full piece about the Cofnas affair, by waiting for the temporary suspension to expire and hoping they’d come to their senses.
Reliable sources now tell me that @UGent has extended @nathancofnas’s suspension by another three months, barring him from teaching or even setting foot on campus.
So much for the benefit of the doubt. UGent is determined to further damage its international reputation. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
HOAX! Ik heb de servers van @Knack gehackt om een knettergek edito in naam van hoofdredacteur @bertbultinck te publiceren.* Het is een pleidooi voor een maoïstische zuivering van onze universiteiten, en een oproep tot ontslag van drie rechtse onderzoekers tegelijk. En ze trapten erin, haha!
"De rectoren moeten dringend de poorten radicaal dichtgooien voor dubieuze ideologen die zich presenteren als wetenschappers."
"Naast Cofnas komt een kompaan van hem nu ook weer in beeld [...]: de 'biologiefilosoof' Bouke de Vries, die Cofnas in Gent heeft binnengehaald."
"Zo heeft De Vries een paper klaar die de armoede moet helpen bestrijden, en wel door embryoselectie op basis van intelligentie."
"De Vries haalde niet alleen Cofnas binnen, maar ook nog eens de Amerikaans-Franse filosoof Craig Willy, weliswaar als onbezoldigde doctoraatsonderzoeker. Net als Cofnas is Willy een 'rassenrealist'."
"De UGent moet strenger optreden tegen Nathan Cofnas én Bouke de Vries. Ook die laatste zal zijn ideeën verder verspreiden. Het valt niet uit te sluiten dat hij meer gelijkgestemde zielen een plek wil geven aan de Gentse universiteit."
"Het is hoog tijd dat ook onze instellingen zich assertiever opstellen tegenover aanvallen van pseudowetenschappers die de academische gemeenschap binnendringen."
"De Gentse rector Petra De Sutter raakt maar niet uit de greep van de affaire-Cofnas. Zij en haar collega-rectoren moeten dringend de poorten radicaal dichtgooien voor dubieuze ideologen die zich presenteren als wetenschappers."
*Speciaal voor de droogstoppels van Roularta: dit is SATIRE. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In The Ultimate Resource, Julian Simon gives a beautiful illustration of how prevalence-induced concept change undermines belief in progress, and leads to The Law of Conservation of Outrage: No matter how much progress the world makes, the total amount of outrage remains constant.
"It was the decline in pollution - greatly assisted by better sanitation - that brought about the stunning declines in mortality. The problem is that the word "pollution" has changed its meaning simply because the great killing disease pollutions of the past - cholera, typhoid fever, diphtheria, and the like - have now been conquered in the rich countries; people now think of pollution as the relatively minor dangers (relative to the past) of pesticides and various carcinogens."
(I will soon publish my Eight Laws of Declinism in a proper journal) -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I promised to give Ghent University the “benefit of the doubt” before writing a full piece about the Cofnas affair, by waiting for the temporary suspension to expire and hoping they’d come to their senses.
Reliable sources now tell me that @UGent has extended @nathancofnas’s suspension by another three months, barring him from teaching or even setting foot on campus.
So much for the benefit of the doubt. UGent is determined to further damage its international reputation. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
These are the very same people who still emphatically deny that academia has been captured by leftist ideology. Yet, in the blink of an eye, they can gather 500 signatures from a single university for such absurd racial nonsense.
Yeah sure, Jason Arday came under fire because he was “not allowed to belong,” because his critics supposedly believe that academia “naturally belongs to white people.” Not at all because of massive fraud, plagiarism, lies, worthless work, cover-ups, and intimidation of journalists, or anything.
This would all be hilarious if it weren’t so deeply sad. The problem at @UGent is even worse than I thought. I can only take comfort in the former colleagues* who did not sign this letter.
*I severed my ties with UGent in January.
www.demorgen.be/meer-nieuws/dit-maakt-pijnlijk-duidelijk-… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
An inquiry from the Ghent University student newspaper, and an Israeli answers whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/08/25/an-inquiry-from-the-ghe…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What a harrowing story: a Ukrainian soldier is trapped for half a year in a no-man's-land reeking of death, watching his comrade slowly die from a treatable wound—a bullet lodged in his knee. What keeps him alive are the voice messages from his wife, and the occasional friendly drone dropping food, medicine, water, ammunition, and batteries.
By the time you reach the end of the piece, this lands like a gut punch:
“He sees Andrii, tall and broad-shouldered, dark blond and very much alive. He pictures him ringing the doorbell on the sixth floor and handing Halyna a helmet, telling her he did everything he could.”
By @siobhan_ogrady, @NastyaGalouchka, and @serhiikorolchuk.
archive.ph/kWytS -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit zijn dan dezelfde mensen die in alle toonaarden ontkennen dat academia een probleem heeft met linkse bias. Maar vervolgens wel in een handomdraai 500 handtekeningen verzamelen voor zulke absurde raciale onzin.
Ja hoor, Jason Arday kwam echt onder vuur te liggen omdat het hem „niet werd gegund erbij te horen”, omdat critici vinden dat academia „van nature toebehoort aan witte mensen”. Niet door massale fraude, plagiaat, leugens en waardeloos werk of zo.
Dit zou allemaal hilarisch zijn als het niet zo intriest was. Het probleem aan @UGent is nog erger dan ik dacht. Ik kan me alleen maar optrekken aan de voormalige collega's die deze brief níét hebben ondertekend.
www.demorgen.be/meer-nieuws/dit-maakt-pijnlijk-duidelijk-… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit zijn dan dezelfde mensen die in alle toonaarden ontkennen dat academia een probleem heeft met linkse bias. Maar vervolgens wel in een handomdraai 500 handtekeningen verzamelen voor zulke absurde raciale onzin.
Ja hoor, Jason Arday kwam echt onder vuur te liggen omdat het hem „niet werd gegund erbij te horen”, omdat critici vinden dat academia „van nature toebehoort aan witte mensen”. Niet door massale fraude, plagiaat, leugens en waardeloos werk of zo.
Dit zou allemaal hilarisch zijn als het niet zo intriest was. Het probleem aan @UGent is nog erger dan ik dacht. Ik kan me alleen maar optrekken aan de voormalige collega's die deze brief níét hebben ondertekend.
www.demorgen.be/meer-nieuws/dit-maakt-pijnlijk-duidelijk-… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What a harrowing story: a Ukrainian soldier is trapped for half a year in a no-man's-land reeking of death, watching his comrade slowly die from a treatable wound—a bullet lodged in his knee. What keeps him alive are the voice messages from his wife, and the occasional friendly drone dropping food, medicine, water, ammunition, and batteries.
By the time you reach the end of the piece, this lands like a gut punch:
“He sees Andrii, tall and broad-shouldered, dark blond and very much alive. He pictures him ringing the doorbell on the sixth floor and handing Halyna a helmet, telling her he did everything he could.”
By @siobhan_ogrady, @NastyaGalouchka, and @serhiikorolchuk.
archive.ph/kWytS -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Eigenlijk is het allemaal de "schuld" van @rvdwalle, die het starterskrediet voor jonge professoren invoerde (waarmee Nathan Cofnas werd binnengehaald). 😉Als je jonge proffen een stuk vrijheid en vertrouwen gunt (wat overigens een goede zaak is), met slechts minimale verantwoording, dan kunnen sommigen al eens een rare vogel strikken. Tja, willen we academische vrijheid of niet?
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Mathematica
@mathemetica
From cosmic immensity to subatomic realms, physics maps an extraordinary span of sizes.
- The observable universe reaches approximately 10²⁷ m.
- Our Milky Way galaxy spans roughly 10²¹ m.
- Earth measures about 10⁷ m in diameter. A proton has a size on the order of 10⁻¹⁵ m.
- Fundamental strings, as proposed in string theory, are around 10⁻³⁵ m.
These hierarchies support efforts in mapping the large-scale structure of the universe with telescopes and probing particle interactions in accelerators such as the LHC. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Ruud Koopmans
@Ruud_Koop_mans
The genocide lie is unraveling and shown for what is always was: a revival of the age-old blood libel.
The Free Press
@TheFP
A year ago, Gaza was officially declared famine-stricken. New, more rigorous data paints a dramatically different picture—and has triggered a debate over whether the original declaration was correct, writes Olivia Reingold. www.thefp.com/p/unicef-data-undermines-claims-palestine-i…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Committee for Academic Freedom
@ComAcFreedom
CAF has today written to the Rector of Ghent University, Professor Petra De Sutter, raising serious concerns about the preventive suspension of Dr Nathan Cofnas and the disciplinary investigation against him.
While we take no position on the merits of Dr Cofnas’s views, we are concerned that the rationale for his suspension risks setting a dangerous precedent for the restriction of #academicfreedom.
As we point out, Ghent’s suspension letter relies extensively on the reactions of others to Dr Cofnas’s appointment and public activity. But while evidence that third parties object to an academic or feel distressed by his views is evidence of reaction, it is not, by itself, evidence of misconduct by the academic whose expression generated that reaction.
Allowing subjective perceptions of offence to help justify action against the academic whose expression generated them comes perilously close to an institutionalised heckler’s veto.
It was the former ACLU executive director Ira Glasser who once compared speech restrictions to poison gas: attractive enough when the weapon is in your hands and your opponent is in your sights, but rather less so when the political wind changes direction. The same warning applies when a heckler’s veto is allowed, almost by default, to become part of an institution’s reasoning for disciplinary intervention.
Once the threshold for intervention is lowered in this way, the principle becomes available for use against academics of every political and intellectual persuasion, depending only on who happens to be holding the institutional levers. And tacit norms of this kind travel all too readily between universities and jurisdictions.
That is why, in our letter, we urge Ghent to observe several basic safeguards during its investigation, including rigorously distinguishing between evidence of misconduct and evidence of opposition, and applying the protections contained in its own disciplinary rules.
Our letter has also been copied to Karla Van Lint, the Flemish Government Commissioner for Ghent University, inviting her to consider whether the concerns raised warrant scrutiny or action within her supervisory competence.
Full story here:
afcomm.org.uk/2026/08/24/ghent-university-nathan-cofnas-h… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
When I was on Flemish TV recently discussing the infamous “confidential memo” (maartenboudry.substack.com/p/the-bar-that-disappeared), I cited these studies on the link between Islam and LGBT intolerance:
• A quarter of young Muslims in Belgium consider violence against gays justified (JOP Monitor).
• Half of European Muslims do not want gays as friends (@Ruud_Koopmans).
• Half of Turks in Germany view homosexuality as a “disease.”
The next day, in the same TV studio, Ghent University rector Petra De Sutter stated that the real problem in this debate was people like me displaying “worrisome prejudices” about Muslims—completely ignoring the empirical data I had presented.
Such woke ideologues—and, frankly, science denialists—are now running some of our finest universities. @UGent should have known: the rector came straight out of the Green party, which has been radicalizing on a number of issues in recent years.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een kwart van moslimjongeren in België vindt geweld tegen homo’s gerechtvaardigd (JOP Monitor). De helft van Turken in Duitsland vindt homoseksualiteit een "ziekte". De helft van Europese moslims wil geen homo's als vrienden (Koopmans).
Dat zijn de studies ik gisteren LETTERLIJK citeerde in @deafspraak, met verwijzing naar o.a. @Ruud_Koop_mans. Maar Petra De Sutter snoefde dat ik daarmee alleen maar blijk gaf van "zorgwekkende vooroordelen" over moslims. Dat was het échte probleem.
QED. Zo reusachtig blijft de blindheid van vele progressieven over de islam. Zulke woke ideologen staat nu aan de top van onze wetenschappelijke instellingen.
www.vrt.be/vrtmax/a-z/de-afspraak/2026/de-afspraak-d20260… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I try to convince haters of universities that, particularly in science and professional departments, we are not woke ideologues with contempt for truth, evidence, and common sense. But many of these professors and institutions don't make it easy. Jeff Flier (Co-President of the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard, and former Dean of Harvard Med School) calls out a bizarre defense of the university-enabled con artist Arday in the formerly respected NEJM.
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
The editorial standards of the @NEJM must be questioned for deciding to publish this article as it is presented below. Such terrible judgement. Jason Arday and the Perils of Being Black in Academia | NEJM Voices voices.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/VOICESpost2600045
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Mijn rector had schoon schip kunnen maken door de prompts achter haar toespraak te publiceren, als bewijs dat het AI-plagiaat beperkt bleef tot die drie citaten. Peter Vandermeersch en Thomas Piketty hadden na alle hoon hun werkwijze kunnen openbaren. Bij mijn weten heeft van alle schrijvers op het beklaagdenbankje nog niet één dat gedaan. Als je het prima vindt om de buikspreekpop van een machine te zijn, waarom dan niet gewoon je prompts tonen?"
In @volkskrant dit weekend.
www.volkskrant.nl/columns-opinie/opinie-ai-proza-parasite… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Russell Blackford
@Metamagician
I signed that letter supporting Cofnas's academic freedom. I still have some suspicion about his motivations and the merits of his research in so far as it gets into the " race realism" issues, but that's not the point. I don't think he's done anything that even prima facie amounts to academic misconduct. The university relies on a narrow and legalistic interpretation of his employment contract that I don't think has ever been applied to academics with similar contracts in the past. Above all, this is exactly the sort of case that academic freedom is supposed to protect: i.e., where an academic is under attack for expressing unpopular or inconvenient views.
Instead of robustly defending Cofnas, the university has betrayed its mission by initiating disciplinary proceedings against him, and while it might now try to defend this as merely a formal response to complaints, the letter it sent him looks awfully like it has made up its collective mind and wants to get rid of him. Moreover, even if it thinks it has a case against him, why suspend him from duties? Suspension during disciplinary procedures can sometimes be justified, for example if there's some physical danger involved or if the alleged misconduct is so serious that, if proved, it amounts to a repudiation by the employee of his contract of employment. But this seems like a clear case where there's no basis for it. There's no possible harm from allowing him to continue to do his work, and suspending him just looks petty and vindictive.
Ghent University will deservedly suffer huge reputational damage over this unless it backs off. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The psychologist Dries Bostyn (@DHBostyn) has real integrity, and I’m glad someone like him sits on the Board of Governors of @UGent.
Although I appreciate the nuance he brings to this highly polarized debate, I think he underestimates the problem of ideological capture. Not only are academics overwhelmingly left-leaning, but, more fundamentally, you don’t need a majority to control an institution. All it takes is a dedicated, organized and motivated minority that refuses to budge and intimidates the compliant majority—a “tyranny of the minority” (Nassim Taleb).
Various social dynamics can explain this phenomenon: preference falsification, pluralistic ignorance, the spiral of silence, etc. I recently outlined some of them in the context of Israel/Gaza, also mentioning Ghent University: substacktools.com/sharex/vDKZRhgf
It's true that the president of the Board of Governors is nominally center-right. But when did we last hear from him? He’s been completely invisible for months, to the point that some jokesters have even issued an Amber Alert for him (see pic).
Also, it strains credulity to claim that this suspension is not a “retaliation” for Cofnas’s role in the Arday affair. Not just because of the timing, but because of the suspension letter itself, which devotes several paragraphs to Cofnas’s alleged “campaign of elimination” against Arday—a completely absurd charge that ignores Arday's very real fraud and plagiarism. It is true that the letter holds other things against Cofnas, and in some ways the Arday scandal may simply have provided a convenient pretext for finally pouncing on him.
Still, Dries is right about one important thing: this is only a temporary suspension, and Cofnas has not been fired. That’s one reason I’ve declined to write a piece for @Quillette about the affair until at least next week, when the suspension order expires. Let’s give @UGent the benefit of the doubt and hope they come to their senses.
That suspension letter with its "heckler's veto" will remain, however, and it has already caused incalculable damage to UGent’s international reputation. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If you're an academic (and can prove it with an ORCID), consider signing a petition protesting the University of Ghent's suspension of a postdoc for exposing academic misconduct, a blatant violation of academic freedom (as always, regardless of your agreement with all of the whistleblower's views). johnarmstrongmaths.com/openletters/letter.php?campaign=co… johnarmstrongmaths.com/openletters/letter.php?campaign=co…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Mijn rector had schoon schip kunnen maken door de prompts achter haar toespraak te publiceren, als bewijs dat het AI-plagiaat beperkt bleef tot die drie citaten. Peter Vandermeersch en Thomas Piketty hadden na alle hoon hun werkwijze kunnen openbaren. Bij mijn weten heeft van alle schrijvers op het beklaagdenbankje nog niet één dat gedaan. Als je het prima vindt om de buikspreekpop van een machine te zijn, waarom dan niet gewoon je prompts tonen?"
In @volkskrant dit weekend.
www.volkskrant.nl/columns-opinie/opinie-ai-proza-parasite… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Boone Wetzel
@AlanAnd02668557
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Universiteiten krijgen veel geld, ook van gezinnen waarvan de kinderen nooit een voet op een campus zullen zetten. Van hen wordt weinig rekenschap gevraagd. In naam van de ‘academische vrijheid’ – die zij steeds minder lijken te respecteren – genieten zij van een grote mate van autonomie die zij volgens heel wat waarnemers misbruiken als een vrijbrief voor ideologische eenzijdigheid en kwaliteitsverlies."
www.demorgen.be/meningen/mark-elchardus-de-universiteiten… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit argument is zo belachelijk dat ik me niet kan voorstellen dat Pieter Beck (die geen idioot is) het echt heeft doorgedacht:
- Dus rechtstreeks empirisch onderzoek naar raciale verschillen zou volgens Beck wél mogen aan UGent (in tegenstelling tot filosofisch meta-onderzoek naar de kwestie)?
- Dus als iemand morgen de hele wetenschapsfilosofie verbiedt, is dat geen schending van de academische vrijheid, want “filosofen doen toch zelf geen wetenschappelijk onderzoek”?
Men wringt zich in de gekste bochten om niet te hoeven toegeven:
- Ja, we willen bepaalde controversiële standpunten en onderzoekers uitsluiten.
- Nee, we geloven niet in academische vrijheid rond IQ en genetica.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dilemma op BlueSky. ;-) bsky.app/profile/wendykroy.bsky.social/post/3mtof4zb4hk2a
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nope, ad hominem is not a logical fallacy, but in many contexts it's a symptom of weakness. As the old lawyer adage goes: "When you have the law on your side, pound the law. When you have the facts on your side, pound the facts. When you have neither the law nor the facts going for you, pound the table." substacktools.com/sharex/fDdPFWWm
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Ghent University (@ugent) needs to update their motto after suspending @nathancofnas.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Hillel Neuer
@HillelNeuer
Academic Integrity: University of Ghent rector Petra De Sutter suspended an academic for exposing a Cambridge fabulist after she honored a U.N. fabulist who said “380,000 children under five were killed in Gaza” — which is more children under five than actually lived there.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This old TEDx talk by Ghent University rector Petra De Sutter is an excellent illustration of why academic freedom is so important.
Many people are now freaking out about her advocacy of “genetic enhancement” and “designer babies.” They call her ideas “sinister” and “shocking”—ironically, not unlike how many people view @nathancofnas. They have more in common than you might think. 🙃
I beg to differ. Genetic enhancement of the human species is a legitimate area of research for fertility experts, bioethicists, geneticists, and others. It deserves serious discussion, not moral panic
Although it's not my field, I’m actually sympathetic to it: certainly when it comes to selecting against disease, but even when it comes to positive traits such as intelligence, health, and beauty. Why not? In some respects, we're all eugenicists, as @sentientist has written (www.aporiamagazine.com/p/youre-probably-a-eugenicist). Concerns about inequal access are real, but not insurmountable.
Frankly, the only thing that’s risible about this talk is her claim that making genetically engineered designer babies in factories “was Aldous Huxley’s dream.”
Gosh, I’m no literary scholar, but could it be that Huxley intended Brave New World as a dystopia, rather than a “dream”?
*Or, obnoxiously, insisting on “him.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Here’s the full text of my Quillette essay, 100% artisanal and lovingly crafted by an actual human. 😉
One final thought: if a detector like @pangram flags an article as 100% AI, what does that actually mean? Not necessarily that there was no human contribution. If you ask AI to turn a pile of notes into prose, Pangram will flag the result as AI-generated. If you write a first draft and ask AI to thoroughly rewrite it, Pangram may still flag it as AI-generated or AI-assisted.
The point is that you should disclose this. If your piece is flagged as 100% AI-generated and you’re not prepared to show us your prompts, it’s reasonable to suspect that you’re too embarrassed to admit how little you actually contributed. (P.S. This note was lightly polished by Claude.)
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hallo, Dominique Froyen, welkom bij Google zoekresultaten!
www.facebook.com/dominique.froyen -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My friend and colleague Simon Lucas (a credentialed ethicist!) weighs in on the ethics of AI writing, conducting some amusing experiments with my own post, “Show Us the Prompts.” (substacktools.com/sharex/JtJDAhvk)
What this reveals is that we interpret the word “polish” differently. If you ask AI to change the style and register of a text on a sentence-by-sentence basis—for instance, turning it into academic prose—this will indeed be picked up by Pangram.
By contrasy, my standard prompt for polishing my prose is something like, “Please polish and fine-tune this text,” which is much narrower. I ask Claude to tighten and improve what’s already there, in my existing voice, and I sometimes add the adverb “lightly” if I think Claude is taking too many liberties with my prose. That never results in a false positive.
So let me sharpen my view: I’m not asking everyone to reveal their prompts whenever they use AI. Frankly, I’d also feel embarrassed to share my conversations with Claude, for all the reasons Simon Lucas and @briandavidearp outline. My early drafts are just awful!
My call to “show us the prompts” targets those whose writing is flagged as “100% AI” by Pangram, and Simon’s arguments actually strengthen my case here. If all you did was run a “polish” routine and it triggered Pangram, you could easily allay suspicions that you let AI do all the work by revealing your prompts. Doing so would show that the core arguments and ideas are yours, and that GPT merely polished them. You would essentially be “acquitted.”
But none of the people currently in the Pangram dock have done so, which makes me very suspicious. I suspect they did much more than “polish.”
Finally, Simon convinced me that the authorship analogy is a red herring, since it’s both too narrow and too broad. A human research assistant who did the kind of work Claude does for many academics would absolutely merit co-authorship—but we can’t just add Claude to every paper as the new “et al.”
substacktools.com/sharex/K6A-Go5X -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dr. Dylan Evans is the same guy who just published a “J’accuse” against the “lynch mob” and “modern digital pillory” that supposedly “killed” Jason Arday. In case you don’t recognize me, he made a (slightly) modified version of one of my profile pics with AI.
Dylan Evans is no random nobody, but an established author and evolutionary psychologist whom I even invited to Ghent for a study visit more than a decade ago. Funny story: he stood me up on the day he was supposed to arrive and then completely ghosted us, after I’d spent weeks arranging his accommodation.
Now he has converted to Islam, prays five times a day, and calls himself “Abu Mahmud.” A deeply troubled man.
P.S. It’s not just the pic: both pieces of text are 100% AI-generated. 😅
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Everyone: "Houllebecq's Soumission is totally Islamophobic!"
Dr. Dylan Evans: "I converted to Islam because of Houellebecq! Multiple young wives, social status! No dour western feminists! Islam is destroying Western civilization anyway! If you can't beat them, join them!"
I find it hard to believe this guy is for real, but apparently he is.
/3 -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
When I was on Flemish TV recently discussing the infamous “confidential memo” (maartenboudry.substack.com/p/the-bar-that-disappeared), I cited these studies on the link between Islam and LGBT intolerance:
• A quarter of young Muslims in Belgium consider violence against gays justified (JOP Monitor).
• Half of European Muslims do not want gays as friends (@Ruud_Koopmans).
• Half of Turks in Germany view homosexuality as a “disease.”
The next day, in the same TV studio, Ghent University rector Petra De Sutter stated that the real problem in this debate was people like me displaying “worrisome prejudices” about Muslims—completely ignoring the empirical data I had presented.
Such woke ideologues—and, frankly, science denialists—are now running some of our finest universities. @UGent should have known: the rector came straight out of the Green party, which has been radicalizing on a number of issues in recent years.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een kwart van moslimjongeren in België vindt geweld tegen homo’s gerechtvaardigd (JOP Monitor). De helft van Turken in Duitsland vindt homoseksualiteit een "ziekte". De helft van Europese moslims wil geen homo's als vrienden (Koopmans).
Dat zijn de studies ik gisteren LETTERLIJK citeerde in @deafspraak, met verwijzing naar o.a. @Ruud_Koop_mans. Maar Petra De Sutter snoefde dat ik daarmee alleen maar blijk gaf van "zorgwekkende vooroordelen" over moslims. Dat was het échte probleem.
QED. Zo reusachtig blijft de blindheid van vele progressieven over de islam. Zulke woke ideologen staat nu aan de top van onze wetenschappelijke instellingen.
www.vrt.be/vrtmax/a-z/de-afspraak/2026/de-afspraak-d20260… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Er is een hemelsbreed verschil tussen "steun" voor iemands academische vrijheid om controversiële standpunten in te nemen, en "steun" voor die standpunten zelf. Hoe lezen jullie deze passage? Graag een correctie of rechtzetting, @sjoerdddejong en @NRC. Gisteren tweette ik nog letterlijk:
"Once again, none of this is to imply that I agree with Cofnas’ views on race, his calls for a “hereditarian revolution,” his statements about Arday, or anything else."
www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2026/08/20/rassenrealist-die-affaire-ar… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I came across this long-read by @BryantMcGill diving into the debate about AI evolution that I had with three biologists and AI scholars in Proceedings (@PNASNews). Looks quite interesting! But since it also looked a little too slick, I ran it through Pangram first—and sure enough, it came back as 99% AI-generated.
Ugh. I admit I immediately lost interest. Perhaps it was merely heavily edited with AI. But should I really read 6,200 words to find out? Honestly, how did you write this piece, @BryantMcGill? Would you be willing to share your prompts?
It doesn't help that it contains AI-flavored fluff like this:
"The paper has not gone unanswered, and the disagreement is worth including rather than smoothing over, because it demonstrates the argument is alive rather than settled."
That's exactly the kind of sentence that makes me want to ask: why am I reading this at all?
www.pangram.com/history/72e167d5-1d8f-473f-9a9f-bb4adf33f…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Sow left-wing fanaticism and you will reap right-wing fanaticism. Ghent University boycotts other universities for ideological reasons, cancels heterodox researchers, and restricts academic freedom for controversial viewpoints—and now it finds itself facing boycotts from right-wing ideologues.
"Dishonest, corrupt institutions that engage in, or reward, scapegoating mob behavior are not desirable partners for us. This is particularly true where the purpose and effect of the scapegoating is to punish accurate journalism and unearthing academic dishonesty. We are therefore reviewing any relationships we have with Ghent University."
(Totally hypocritical, of course, coming from a Trump envoy).
U.S. Ambassador to Belgium Bill White
@USAmbToBelgium
The United States Mission to Belgium condemns, in the strongest terms, Ghent University’s retaliation against an American scholar following his accurate whistleblower reporting on academic fraud.
The United States government regularly funds and supports research, academic exchanges, and other engagements with overseas universities. Dishonest, corrupt institutions that engage in, or reward, scapegoating mob behavior are not desirable partners for us. This is particularly true where the purpose and effect of the scapegoating is to punish accurate journalism unearthing academic dishonesty. We are therefore reviewing any relationships we have with Ghent University.
Bad-faith idealogues will try to make this a referendum on the content of Cofnas’s scholarship – or polemical distortions of it. That’s wrong. Free speech means that controversial views are protected. And Cofnas’s views were known to Ghent University when he was hired.
The ultimate purpose of freedom of speech is to overturn lies, fraud, and false ideologies. This is precisely what Cofnas was doing, and precisely the reason his home institution wants to silence him.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
AI-proza parasiteert op de "interpretatieve welwillendheid" van de lezer: het lijkt oppervlakkig steek te houden, tot je even stilstaat. Als je het prima vindt om de buikspreekpop van AI te zijn, waarom niet gewoon je prompts tonen?
Bovendien beduvel je jezelf als auteur, want schrijven is denken. Als je dat uitbesteedt aan een statistische taalmodel, zal je denkvermogen aftakelen. Mijn opinie in @volkskrant vandaag.
www.volkskrant.nl/columns-opinie/opinie-ai-proza-parasite… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Time to retweet this Public Service Announcement again, in English this time: I don't usually delete—or even read—the garbage under my posts on X, because otherwise I'd have a full-time job. But if you think you're doing me a favor by posting hateful comments about Petra De Sutter and her identity, you're dead wrong. Attack her views, not the person.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dienstmededeling: ik spreek me niet vaak uit tegen bagger hier, want anders wordt dat een dagtaak, maar wie zich geroepen voelt om hatelijke opmerkingen te maken over @pdsutter en haar identiteit, doet me hier absoluut geen plezier mee. Hou het beleefd en speel niet op de vrouw.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Here is the full letter from Ghent University suspending @nathancofnas. As you can see, it’s one long heckler’s veto: the decision is not so much about Cofnas’ actual violations as about the flood of complaints and protests the rector has received, the reputational damage to the university, the cancellations by certain speakers, the possible boycott against UGent due to Cofnas' appointment, etc.
The letter holds Cofnas accountable for all the “tension and unrest” his presence has caused (even though he never even shows up on campus), and for the “severe psychological distress” among students and the “negative impact on the well-being” of colleagues.
Since the rector is transgender, here’s an analogy she might appreciate: this suspension is like banning a Pride event in a city because of the “unrest and tension” (read: anti-LGBT violence) the organizers are “causing” among religious fanatics. Or excluding trans women from political positions because of the “psychological distress” they may cause to people who believe in a sex binary.
It’s even worse than a conventional heckler’s veto, because I know that the rector has actively encouraged the “hecklers” to flood her with complaints, thereby giving the university a stick to beat the dog with.
Shockingly, the letter documents that Cofnas has called Jason Arday a “worthless scholar.” Someone fire that miscreant, please! Never mind that “mentally disabled” is pretty much how Arday described himself—being functionally illiterate, reading only one page per hour, etc. Describing Cofnas’ exposure of serious fraud and plagiarism as a “targeted campaign of professional elimination” is just completely deluded, and buying into the far-left narrative hook, line and sinker.
Once again, none of this is to imply that I agree with Cofnas’ views on race, his calls for a “hereditarian revolution,” his statements about Arday, or anything else.
This is purely about academic freedom, something the rector understands absolutely nothing about. Right after taking office, she declared that academics questioning the “genocide” in Gaza or the safety of vaccines would no longer be protected by academic freedom: “This is a line that cannot be crossed.” (She was specifically targeting me at the time, when I still worked for UGent.)
And that’s not even mentioning the fact that the rector used AI-hallucinated quotations in her inaugural speech and then covered it up and lied about it—which has nothing to do with ideology, just sheer incompetence and dishonesty.
I’m almost inclined to call her a “worthless scholar.” But as Einstein probably never said at the Sorbonne in 1929: “Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I’m not sure about the universe.”
***
Concerning: Initiation of the disciplinary procedure and decision regarding preventive suspension in the interest of the service (Disciplinary Regulations for Staff)
Dear Nathan COFNAS,
Over the past months, I have received several complaints, reports, and concerning signals from across the wider university community regarding your conduct and public actions. In particular, over the past week additional concerns have been raised in relation to various interviews published in which you participated and the statements you made during those interviews.
In this regard I have decided to initiate a preliminary investigation as provided for in article 28 of the regulations with respect to disciplinary proceedings, the imposing of disciplinary measures, the preventive suspension in the interest of the service, and the taking of measures to ensure orderly conduct for staff members of Ghent University (hereinafter: "Disciplinary Regulations for Staff"). You can find the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff in the Codex of Ghent University via the following link: REG000237EN.
Article 3 of the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff stipulates that any staff member may be subject to a disciplinary procedure in the event of:
(i) Offences that are committed in the university context. These concern either a serious breach of official/ professional duties (breach of a legal or a deontological duty as an officer), or an offence committed in the course of the performance of their duties/ the activities of Ghent University, such as (but not limited to), a breach of the internal regulations included in the Codex of Ghent University.
(ii) Offences committed in the context of private life, in so far as they are, on the one hand, criminally punishable and, on the other hand, have a negative impact on the functioning of the staff member or on the functioning of the service or have a serious negative impact on the well-being of or cooperation with other staff members or students.
(i) Offences committed within the university context
During a recent podcast interview with Winston Marshall published on 9 August 2026, you explicitly stated that you are currently continuing your work on 'race realism' and the 'hereditarian revolution' at Ghent University. These public claims, and the activities you describe, are fundamentally inconsistent with the contractual scope of your employment and constitute a manifest violation of your professional obligations towards this University.
Your employment contract (article 1) and the vacancy for which you were recruited (ref. LW01) define your research mandate as a study of 'the future of liberalism', specifically focusing on liberalism as a political doctrine emphasizing individual freedom and equality. The projects you publicly and repeatedly associate with your affiliation at Ghent University, most notably your 'Guide for the Hereditarian Revolution' which advocates for racial barriers and segregation, fall entirely outside the scope of your official research mandate.
Pursuant to article 4 of the Ghent University Work Regulations (Arbeidsreglement), employees are required to perform the work for which they were recruited and to execute their function in a loyal, careful, and upright manner. By publicly claiming to use your position and affiliation at Ghent University to advance research that is unrelated to your appointment, you are in breach of your professional duties and the loyalty required, as defined in article 3 §1 of the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff.
Moreover, pursuant to article 1.3 of the Ghent University Code of Ethics, employees must ensure that any accumulation of activities does not entail a (perceived) conflict of interest or conflict with other standards established in the Code. Even if your work on 'race realism' were to be characterized as a private activity, its public association with your UGent affiliation creates a severe perceived conflict of interest and violates article 1.5 of the Code, which prohibits spreading ideas of racial superiority or inciting racial segregation.
The gravity of these cumulative breaches, involving deliberate public misrepresentation and the misuse of the University's reputation to promote ideologies that conflict with its core values, as well as your decision to continue your research into 'hereditary evolution' and 'racial realism' at Ghent University, contrary to the terms of your employment, concern a breach of your ethical duties as a member of staff at our University and therefore qualify as a disciplinary offence committed within the university context.
(ii) Offences committed in the context of your private life
In a series of recent public interviews you made, including interviews with Winston Marshall (8 August 2026), David Starkey (9 August 2026) and Rob Montz (14 August 2026), I have established that you have made various statements in which you assert (among other statements) that racial or ethnic groups differ in intellectual ability for inherited or biological reasons.
Certain statements made during those interviews may be interpreted as advancing ideas concerning the inherent superiority or inferiority of racial or ethnic groups. However, neither freedom of expression nor academic freedom is unlimited. Both may be restricted by law where necessary to protect the rights of others and to prevent discrimination and racism. Belgian anti-discrimination legislation provides for such restrictions. Questions therefore arise as to the compatibility of your public statements with the objectives and provisions of Belgian anti-discrimination legislation, more specifically articles 20 and 21.
Furthermore, in several public interviews, you repeatedly referred to the late professor Jason Arday as being "mentally disabled" and made various other disparaging remarks concerning him, including, among others, describing him as a "worthless scholar". In addition to the disparaging nature of these remarks, the University is deeply concerned by the way you have framed your actions.
By framing your interventions as a 'crusade' aimed at the systematic personal and professional destruction of colleagues, you have demonstrated that your actions extend beyond the permissible bounds of academic debate. Such behaviour strongly suggests an intentional and serious disturbance of the peace, which may fall within the scope of conduct protected against under Chapter V of the Belgian Criminal Code concerning offences against a person's honour or reputation, including the provisions set out in articles 443 et seq.
The aforementioned findings have had a notably negative impact on the functioning of the University and on the well-being of, and cooperation with, students and other members of staff. Such statements conflict with the core of the University's commitment to equality, inclusion and the dignity of all students and staff members and have caused serious distress and concern within the university community, particularly among students and staff members who may reasonably experience such statements as calling into question their equal standing within the academic environment.
Over an extended period of time since your appointment at Ghent University, significant concerns have been raised by members of the Ghent University community and beyond regarding your presence and activities within the institution. These concerns are not isolated or incidental in nature. They have manifested themselves through sustained and visible reactions from students and staff members alike.
In particular, students at Ghent University established the group "Students Against Cofnas", specifically aimed at opposing your appointment at the University. Furthermore, in May 2026, a petition concerning your appointment was signed by more than 2,000 students. These initiatives illustrate that the concerns surrounding your presence at the University are widespread and have affected a substantial part of the student community.
Similar concerns have also been expressed within the academic environment in which you are employed. A public statement issued by your department in June 2026, which has been removed from public access, indicated that your presence had become a source of significant unrest throughout the workplace. This demonstrates that the concerns are not limited to students but also extend to colleagues and staff members who are required to work within the same academic environment.
In addition, the manner in which you publicly presented your role in the allegations concerning the late professor Jason Arday has reinforced concerns among the university's community that your public interventions seem to develop into targeted campaigns of professional elimination. By framing the 'exposure' of a colleague not as scholarly debate but as a victorious act in a self-described 'hereditarian revolution', and by publicly calling to 'purge' institutions of those you label as ideological enemies, you have created a climate of severe psychosocial distress. As a result thereof, staff seem to perceive your presence as an objective threat to their professional standing and personal dignity.
The disturbance is further evidenced by objectified reports and files. Firstly, I have been informed that several confidential files concerning you are currently being processed through Trustpunt. Furthermore, IDEWE's external psychosocial prevention adviser has been requested to carry out a study within the relevant department in order to objectively assess the impact of your employment on the wellbeing of staff and students.
Without prejudice to the confidentiality of those files and without anticipating their outcome, their existence and apparent recurrence provide a further indication that the concerns relating to your conduct extend beyond public debate and are also manifesting themselves within the University's internal working environment. This reinforces the conclusion that the present circumstances have generated a level of tension and unrest that risks adversely affecting the proper functioning of the University and the psychosocial wellbeing of members of its community.
Your continued public invocation of your affiliation with Ghent University while disseminating these views creates a reputational risk. It generates a perception among external audiences that the University endorses or provides a platform for ideologies of racial superiority, which fundamentally undermines our institutional credibility and causes additional distress and uncertainty among staff and students regarding the University's public standing and credibility. The scale of this impact is evidenced by the fact that in the past week alone, the University has received more than 100 emails expressing deep concern, and that number continues to grow.
The current unrest has therefore also given rise to concrete consequences for the University's functioning. The University has been informed that a guest lecturer who was scheduled to teach during the forthcoming academic year has withdrawn from that commitment because of concerns relating to the University's association with you. Furthermore, I have received information that additional consequences may arise in the context of its national and international academic relations, including discussions concerning a possible boycott of cooperation with Ghent University on account of that association. These developments demonstrate that the present unrest extends beyond internal concerns and is beginning to affect the University's academic activities and external relationships. These examples are not exhaustive, and further reports continue to be received.
In addition to the initiation of the disciplinary investigation, as mentioned above, I have therefore also decided to suspend you as a precautionary measure in the interests of the service, in accordance with article 55 of the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff. In view of the nature and seriousness of the facts, as well as the potential risk to Ghent University, I believe that this preventive suspension should be imposed as a matter of urgency in accordance with article 57(2) of the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff, without hearing you prior to this decision.
The scale and persistence of the concerns expressed by students and staff, combined with the recent escalation following your public statements and media appearances, demonstrate that the current situation poses a risk to the proper functioning of the University and to the psychosocial wellbeing of members of its community.
Considering the volume and nature of the complaints, reports and expressions of concern received, the University cannot reasonably exclude the risk that your continued physical presence in the workplace would lead to confrontations, further disruption of the University's activities, or a deterioration of the working and learning environment. Immediate intervention is therefore necessary to preserve institutional stability, safeguard the psychosocial wellbeing of staff and students, and prevent any further escalation of the unrest.
In these circumstances, waiting until after a prior hearing has taken place would not adequately protect the interests safeguarded by the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff. Deferring intervention would leave the current unrest unaddressed and create a real risk of further disruption to the University's functioning.
The preventive suspension takes effect immediately and applies for a period of seven working days (up until and including Friday 28 August 2026).
As provided for in article 56 of the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff, the preventive suspension means that you may no longer carry out any teaching, research or service activities as a member of staff at Ghent University and/or on behalf of Ghent University, nor may you participate in conferences or other activities in that capacity, unless you have the express permission of the rector. Furthermore, this preventive suspension entails a ban on contact with Ghent University staff and students, the provisional suspension of your account, and you are denied access to Ghent University's sites and buildings.
You may submit your written response regarding the facts forming the basis of the preventive suspension by email to juridischezaken@UGent.be by Friday 28 August 2026 at the latest. If you wish to be heard in person, you must notify us of this by email as soon as possible and no later than the aforementioned deadline. A suitable date will then be arranged.
If you wish, you may combine your written response to the facts giving rise to both the disciplinary preliminary investigation and the preventive suspension into a single letter. You have the right to be assisted in these proceedings by a solicitor, a trade union representative or an adviser of your choice. You also have the right to inspect the file and to obtain an electronic copy of it.
Following your written or oral response, I will decide whether to uphold or amend the preventive suspension in the interests of the service, or to lift it, in accordance with article 57(2) of the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This internal email from a tenured professor at Nathan Cofnas’ department shows not only that the “barrage” of complaints about the “negative effects on well-being” was perfectly coordinated, but that it was explicitly encouraged by rector Petra De Sutter herself. If this is true, she was actively egging on the hecklers in order to grant them a veto, which makes the whole affair even worse. /2
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Email from May 27:
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
/4
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Time to retweet this Public Service Announcement again, in English this time: I don't usually delete—or even read—the garbage under my posts on X, because otherwise I'd have a full-time job. But if you think you're doing me a favor by posting hateful comments about Petra De Sutter and her identity, you're dead wrong. Attack her views, not the person.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dienstmededeling: ik spreek me niet vaak uit tegen bagger hier, want anders wordt dat een dagtaak, maar wie zich geroepen voelt om hatelijke opmerkingen te maken over @pdsutter en haar identiteit, doet me hier absoluut geen plezier mee. Hou het beleefd en speel niet op de vrouw.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
we're so many fucking layers deep in a bullshit sundae. trump administration coming out in favor of academic freedom! love it
U.S. Ambassador to Belgium Bill White
@USAmbToBelgium
The United States Mission to Belgium condemns, in the strongest terms, Ghent University’s retaliation against an American scholar following his accurate whistleblower reporting on academic fraud.
The United States government regularly funds and supports research, academic exchanges, and other engagements with overseas universities. Dishonest, corrupt institutions that engage in, or reward, scapegoating mob behavior are not desirable partners for us. This is particularly true where the purpose and effect of the scapegoating is to punish accurate journalism unearthing academic dishonesty. We are therefore reviewing any relationships we have with Ghent University.
Bad-faith idealogues will try to make this a referendum on the content of Cofnas’s scholarship – or polemical distortions of it. That’s wrong. Free speech means that controversial views are protected. And Cofnas’s views were known to Ghent University when he was hired.
The ultimate purpose of freedom of speech is to overturn lies, fraud, and false ideologies. This is precisely what Cofnas was doing, and precisely the reason his home institution wants to silence him.
Thank you for your attention to this matter. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een kwart van moslimjongeren in België vindt geweld tegen homo’s gerechtvaardigd (JOP Monitor). De helft van Turken in Duitsland vindt homoseksualiteit een "ziekte". De helft van Europese moslims wil geen homo's als vrienden (Koopmans).
Dat zijn de studies ik gisteren LETTERLIJK citeerde in @deafspraak, met verwijzing naar o.a. @Ruud_Koop_mans. Maar Petra De Sutter snoefde dat ik daarmee alleen maar blijk gaf van "zorgwekkende vooroordelen" over moslims. Dat was het échte probleem.
QED. Zo reusachtig blijft de blindheid van vele progressieven over de islam. Zulke woke ideologen staat nu aan de top van onze wetenschappelijke instellingen.
www.vrt.be/vrtmax/a-z/de-afspraak/2026/de-afspraak-d20260… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Onderzoek naar academische klokkenluiders laat zien dat zij aanzienlijke professionele gevolgen kunnen ondervinden, tot en met ontslag. Je kunt niet tegelijk zeggen dat je misstanden wilt bestrijden én een klimaat creëren waarin mensen die ze aankaarten bang moeten zijn voor de gevolgen."
Gelukkig zijn er nog academici die het hoofd koel houden in deze: hier @PLoobuyck (@UGent) en Andreas De Block @DeblockBlock (@KU_Leuven).
www.demorgen.be/meningen/bescherm-de-klokkenluider-ook-al… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Here is the full letter from Ghent University suspending @nathancofnas. As you can see, it’s one long heckler’s veto: the decision is not so much about Cofnas’ actual violations as about the flood of complaints and protests the rector has received, the reputational damage to the university, the cancellations by certain speakers, the possible boycott against UGent due to Cofnas' appointment, etc.
The letter holds Cofnas accountable for all the “tension and unrest” his presence has caused (even though he never even shows up on campus), and for the “severe psychological distress” among students and the “negative impact on the well-being” of colleagues.
Since the rector is transgender, here’s an analogy she might appreciate: this suspension is like banning a Pride event in a city because of the “unrest and tension” (read: anti-LGBT violence) the organizers are “causing” among religious fanatics. Or excluding trans women from political positions because of the “psychological distress” they may cause to people who believe in a sex binary.
It’s even worse than a conventional heckler’s veto, because I know that the rector has actively encouraged the “hecklers” to flood her with complaints, thereby giving the university a stick to beat the dog with.
Shockingly, the letter documents that Cofnas has called Jason Arday a “worthless scholar.” Someone fire that miscreant, please! Never mind that “mentally disabled” is pretty much how Arday described himself—being functionally illiterate, reading only one page per hour, etc. Describing Cofnas’ exposure of serious fraud and plagiarism as a “targeted campaign of professional elimination” is just completely deluded, and buying into the far-left narrative hook, line and sinker.
Once again, none of this is to imply that I agree with Cofnas’ views on race, his calls for a “hereditarian revolution,” his statements about Arday, or anything else.
This is purely about academic freedom, something the rector understands absolutely nothing about. Right after taking office, she declared that academics questioning the “genocide” in Gaza or the safety of vaccines would no longer be protected by academic freedom: “This is a line that cannot be crossed.” (She was specifically targeting me at the time, when I still worked for UGent.)
And that’s not even mentioning the fact that the rector used AI-hallucinated quotations in her inaugural speech and then covered it up and lied about it—which has nothing to do with ideology, just sheer incompetence and dishonesty.
I’m almost inclined to call her a “worthless scholar.” But as Einstein probably never said at the Sorbonne in 1929: “Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I’m not sure about the universe.”
***
Concerning: Initiation of the disciplinary procedure and decision regarding preventive suspension in the interest of the service (Disciplinary Regulations for Staff)
Dear Nathan COFNAS,
Over the past months, I have received several complaints, reports, and concerning signals from across the wider university community regarding your conduct and public actions. In particular, over the past week additional concerns have been raised in relation to various interviews published in which you participated and the statements you made during those interviews.
In this regard I have decided to initiate a preliminary investigation as provided for in article 28 of the regulations with respect to disciplinary proceedings, the imposing of disciplinary measures, the preventive suspension in the interest of the service, and the taking of measures to ensure orderly conduct for staff members of Ghent University (hereinafter: "Disciplinary Regulations for Staff"). You can find the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff in the Codex of Ghent University via the following link: REG000237EN.
Article 3 of the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff stipulates that any staff member may be subject to a disciplinary procedure in the event of:
(i) Offences that are committed in the university context. These concern either a serious breach of official/ professional duties (breach of a legal or a deontological duty as an officer), or an offence committed in the course of the performance of their duties/ the activities of Ghent University, such as (but not limited to), a breach of the internal regulations included in the Codex of Ghent University.
(ii) Offences committed in the context of private life, in so far as they are, on the one hand, criminally punishable and, on the other hand, have a negative impact on the functioning of the staff member or on the functioning of the service or have a serious negative impact on the well-being of or cooperation with other staff members or students.
(i) Offences committed within the university context
During a recent podcast interview with Winston Marshall published on 9 August 2026, you explicitly stated that you are currently continuing your work on 'race realism' and the 'hereditarian revolution' at Ghent University. These public claims, and the activities you describe, are fundamentally inconsistent with the contractual scope of your employment and constitute a manifest violation of your professional obligations towards this University.
Your employment contract (article 1) and the vacancy for which you were recruited (ref. LW01) define your research mandate as a study of 'the future of liberalism', specifically focusing on liberalism as a political doctrine emphasizing individual freedom and equality. The projects you publicly and repeatedly associate with your affiliation at Ghent University, most notably your 'Guide for the Hereditarian Revolution' which advocates for racial barriers and segregation, fall entirely outside the scope of your official research mandate.
Pursuant to article 4 of the Ghent University Work Regulations (Arbeidsreglement), employees are required to perform the work for which they were recruited and to execute their function in a loyal, careful, and upright manner. By publicly claiming to use your position and affiliation at Ghent University to advance research that is unrelated to your appointment, you are in breach of your professional duties and the loyalty required, as defined in article 3 §1 of the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff.
Moreover, pursuant to article 1.3 of the Ghent University Code of Ethics, employees must ensure that any accumulation of activities does not entail a (perceived) conflict of interest or conflict with other standards established in the Code. Even if your work on 'race realism' were to be characterized as a private activity, its public association with your UGent affiliation creates a severe perceived conflict of interest and violates article 1.5 of the Code, which prohibits spreading ideas of racial superiority or inciting racial segregation.
The gravity of these cumulative breaches, involving deliberate public misrepresentation and the misuse of the University's reputation to promote ideologies that conflict with its core values, as well as your decision to continue your research into 'hereditary evolution' and 'racial realism' at Ghent University, contrary to the terms of your employment, concern a breach of your ethical duties as a member of staff at our University and therefore qualify as a disciplinary offence committed within the university context.
(ii) Offences committed in the context of your private life
In a series of recent public interviews you made, including interviews with Winston Marshall (8 August 2026), David Starkey (9 August 2026) and Rob Montz (14 August 2026), I have established that you have made various statements in which you assert (among other statements) that racial or ethnic groups differ in intellectual ability for inherited or biological reasons.
Certain statements made during those interviews may be interpreted as advancing ideas concerning the inherent superiority or inferiority of racial or ethnic groups. However, neither freedom of expression nor academic freedom is unlimited. Both may be restricted by law where necessary to protect the rights of others and to prevent discrimination and racism. Belgian anti-discrimination legislation provides for such restrictions. Questions therefore arise as to the compatibility of your public statements with the objectives and provisions of Belgian anti-discrimination legislation, more specifically articles 20 and 21.
Furthermore, in several public interviews, you repeatedly referred to the late professor Jason Arday as being "mentally disabled" and made various other disparaging remarks concerning him, including, among others, describing him as a "worthless scholar". In addition to the disparaging nature of these remarks, the University is deeply concerned by the way you have framed your actions.
By framing your interventions as a 'crusade' aimed at the systematic personal and professional destruction of colleagues, you have demonstrated that your actions extend beyond the permissible bounds of academic debate. Such behaviour strongly suggests an intentional and serious disturbance of the peace, which may fall within the scope of conduct protected against under Chapter V of the Belgian Criminal Code concerning offences against a person's honour or reputation, including the provisions set out in articles 443 et seq.
The aforementioned findings have had a notably negative impact on the functioning of the University and on the well-being of, and cooperation with, students and other members of staff. Such statements conflict with the core of the University's commitment to equality, inclusion and the dignity of all students and staff members and have caused serious distress and concern within the university community, particularly among students and staff members who may reasonably experience such statements as calling into question their equal standing within the academic environment.
Over an extended period of time since your appointment at Ghent University, significant concerns have been raised by members of the Ghent University community and beyond regarding your presence and activities within the institution. These concerns are not isolated or incidental in nature. They have manifested themselves through sustained and visible reactions from students and staff members alike.
In particular, students at Ghent University established the group "Students Against Cofnas", specifically aimed at opposing your appointment at the University. Furthermore, in May 2026, a petition concerning your appointment was signed by more than 2,000 students. These initiatives illustrate that the concerns surrounding your presence at the University are widespread and have affected a substantial part of the student community.
Similar concerns have also been expressed within the academic environment in which you are employed. A public statement issued by your department in June 2026, which has been removed from public access, indicated that your presence had become a source of significant unrest throughout the workplace. This demonstrates that the concerns are not limited to students but also extend to colleagues and staff members who are required to work within the same academic environment.
In addition, the manner in which you publicly presented your role in the allegations concerning the late professor Jason Arday has reinforced concerns among the university's community that your public interventions seem to develop into targeted campaigns of professional elimination. By framing the 'exposure' of a colleague not as scholarly debate but as a victorious act in a self-described 'hereditarian revolution', and by publicly calling to 'purge' institutions of those you label as ideological enemies, you have created a climate of severe psychosocial distress. As a result thereof, staff seem to perceive your presence as an objective threat to their professional standing and personal dignity.
The disturbance is further evidenced by objectified reports and files. Firstly, I have been informed that several confidential files concerning you are currently being processed through Trustpunt. Furthermore, IDEWE's external psychosocial prevention adviser has been requested to carry out a study within the relevant department in order to objectively assess the impact of your employment on the wellbeing of staff and students.
Without prejudice to the confidentiality of those files and without anticipating their outcome, their existence and apparent recurrence provide a further indication that the concerns relating to your conduct extend beyond public debate and are also manifesting themselves within the University's internal working environment. This reinforces the conclusion that the present circumstances have generated a level of tension and unrest that risks adversely affecting the proper functioning of the University and the psychosocial wellbeing of members of its community.
Your continued public invocation of your affiliation with Ghent University while disseminating these views creates a reputational risk. It generates a perception among external audiences that the University endorses or provides a platform for ideologies of racial superiority, which fundamentally undermines our institutional credibility and causes additional distress and uncertainty among staff and students regarding the University's public standing and credibility. The scale of this impact is evidenced by the fact that in the past week alone, the University has received more than 100 emails expressing deep concern, and that number continues to grow.
The current unrest has therefore also given rise to concrete consequences for the University's functioning. The University has been informed that a guest lecturer who was scheduled to teach during the forthcoming academic year has withdrawn from that commitment because of concerns relating to the University's association with you. Furthermore, I have received information that additional consequences may arise in the context of its national and international academic relations, including discussions concerning a possible boycott of cooperation with Ghent University on account of that association. These developments demonstrate that the present unrest extends beyond internal concerns and is beginning to affect the University's academic activities and external relationships. These examples are not exhaustive, and further reports continue to be received.
In addition to the initiation of the disciplinary investigation, as mentioned above, I have therefore also decided to suspend you as a precautionary measure in the interests of the service, in accordance with article 55 of the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff. In view of the nature and seriousness of the facts, as well as the potential risk to Ghent University, I believe that this preventive suspension should be imposed as a matter of urgency in accordance with article 57(2) of the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff, without hearing you prior to this decision.
The scale and persistence of the concerns expressed by students and staff, combined with the recent escalation following your public statements and media appearances, demonstrate that the current situation poses a risk to the proper functioning of the University and to the psychosocial wellbeing of members of its community.
Considering the volume and nature of the complaints, reports and expressions of concern received, the University cannot reasonably exclude the risk that your continued physical presence in the workplace would lead to confrontations, further disruption of the University's activities, or a deterioration of the working and learning environment. Immediate intervention is therefore necessary to preserve institutional stability, safeguard the psychosocial wellbeing of staff and students, and prevent any further escalation of the unrest.
In these circumstances, waiting until after a prior hearing has taken place would not adequately protect the interests safeguarded by the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff. Deferring intervention would leave the current unrest unaddressed and create a real risk of further disruption to the University's functioning.
The preventive suspension takes effect immediately and applies for a period of seven working days (up until and including Friday 28 August 2026).
As provided for in article 56 of the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff, the preventive suspension means that you may no longer carry out any teaching, research or service activities as a member of staff at Ghent University and/or on behalf of Ghent University, nor may you participate in conferences or other activities in that capacity, unless you have the express permission of the rector. Furthermore, this preventive suspension entails a ban on contact with Ghent University staff and students, the provisional suspension of your account, and you are denied access to Ghent University's sites and buildings.
You may submit your written response regarding the facts forming the basis of the preventive suspension by email to juridischezaken@UGent.be by Friday 28 August 2026 at the latest. If you wish to be heard in person, you must notify us of this by email as soon as possible and no later than the aforementioned deadline. A suitable date will then be arranged.
If you wish, you may combine your written response to the facts giving rise to both the disciplinary preliminary investigation and the preventive suspension into a single letter. You have the right to be assisted in these proceedings by a solicitor, a trade union representative or an adviser of your choice. You also have the right to inspect the file and to obtain an electronic copy of it.
Following your written or oral response, I will decide whether to uphold or amend the preventive suspension in the interests of the service, or to lift it, in accordance with article 57(2) of the Disciplinary Regulations for Staff. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Time to retweet this Public Service Announcement again, in English this time: I don't usually delete—or even read—the garbage under my posts on X, because otherwise I'd have a full-time job. But if you think you're doing me a favor by posting hateful comments about Petra De Sutter and her identity, you're dead wrong. Attack her views, not the person.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dienstmededeling: ik spreek me niet vaak uit tegen bagger hier, want anders wordt dat een dagtaak, maar wie zich geroepen voelt om hatelijke opmerkingen te maken over @pdsutter en haar identiteit, doet me hier absoluut geen plezier mee. Hou het beleefd en speel niet op de vrouw.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
An update: after I emailed the Flemish national broadcaster @vrtnws about this misrepresentation, they amended the title and included a correction at the bottom (after consulting with Hebrew speakers). Even a despicable character like Itamar Ben Gvir deserves to be quoted correctly. I cannot count the number of people who sent me this "quote" with the message: "See, it's genocide, even the minister says so literally!" There is still hope! 😉 www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2026/08/17/ben-gvir-israel-uitsprake…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Yes, his words have been distorted in the international press, as just about any utterance by any Israeli politician (the actual quote is "30 to 40 targeted assassinations per night", not just "30 to 40 Palestinians", which would suggest women and children alike).
Still, his rethoric is horrible and dehumanizing. This despicable character has been damaging Israel’s reputation for years (alongside Smotrich). He should be dismissed and never be allowed within striking distance of political power. Remove him at last, @netanyahu.
www.ft.com/content/f6b953fc-a6ad-48cd-bed1-d42619b57d94?s…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In general, quotes from Israeli politicians are very often distorted or misrepresented; see this list by @Yair_Rosenberg in The Atlantic:
www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2024/01/israel-…
/2 -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een update: nadat ik @vrtnws mailde, hebben ze de titel aangepast en een correctie toegevoegd onderaan (na Hebreeuwse sprekers te hebben geraadpleegd). Zelfs een schurk als Itamar Ben Gvir verdient het om correct geciteerd te worden.
Ik kan het aantal mensen niet tellen die me dat VRT-artikel stuurden met de boodschap: "Zie je wil, genocide, de minister zegt het letterlijk!" Dat siert VRT alvast. Er is nog hoop! 😉
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ben Gvir is inderdaad een verschrikkelijke figuur en een religieuze fanaticus, maar niettemin is dit onverantwoorde agitprop. Het letterlijke citaat is: “We moeten elke avond 30, 40 terroristen uitschakelen” en “Er moeten gerichte eliminaties zijn van 30 tot 40 mensen.” Niet gewoon “30 Gazanen”, wat valselijk de indruk wekt dat hij iedereen wil doden, vrouwen en kinderen inbegrepen. Quo vadis, @vrtnws?
Ze zijn lang niet de enigen. Als het over Israël gaat, liggen de standaarden van westerse media helemaal op de bodem. N’importe quoi. Dit zal weer gewoon rondsuizen, net als alle andere weerlegde onzin over Amalek en "menselijke beesten", als zoveelste “bewijs” dat Israël een genocide pleegt. Ik geloof al lang niet meer dat het iemand iets kan schelen.
Nooit een correctie of rechtzetting, nooit een fact check, gewoon op naar het volgende stuk clickbait over het boosaardige Israël.
VRT NWS
@vrtnws
Israëlische minister Ben-Gvir wil elke nacht 30 à 40 Gazanen doden: "Ze moeten niet leven, het zijn geen mensen"
www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2026/08/17/ben-gvir-israel-uitsprake… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This internal email from a tenured professor at Nathan Cofnas’ department shows not only that the “barrage” of complaints about the “negative effects on well-being” was perfectly coordinated, but that it was explicitly encouraged by rector Petra De Sutter herself. If this is true, she was actively egging on the hecklers in order to grant them a veto, which makes the whole affair even worse. /2
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Brian Chau
@brianchau57
The NGO behind the defamation campaign against @nathancofnas is entirely funded by the governments of Belgium and the Belgian region of Flanders.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Anthony King
@antbruceking
1/Thanks @shashj . This is powerful article. Like its author, I do not agree that Israel’s war in Gaza was a genocide. It was a brutal urban war against a powerful and numerous enemy, embedded in the civilian population, which had mounted a massive and unprovoked attack.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Hanno Sauer
@hanno_sauer
Nathan Cofnas was justly suspended from Ghent University by rector Petra de Sutter because, as Albert Einstein once said "you cannot make an omelette without breaking some eggs"
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Kaizen D. Asiedu
@thatsKAIZEN
Jason Arday shouldn’t be dead.
But he is dead - because he didn’t tell the truth.
And Cambridge University didn’t look for the truth - because he’s black.
And fellow black professors didn’t ask for the truth - because he is black.
Jason lied repeatedly.
And he told the exact lies that allow one to excel in the system that elite universities have adopted.
A system that factors in race, hardship, and lived experience under the banner of equity, instead of pure performance.
Nearly everyone in these institutions ignored Jason’s lies, to try and protect black people.
They called the people seeking the truth racists.
Of course there were some racists.
But the majority of people just wanted the truth.
Avoiding the truth didn’t help black people.
Double standards in academia aren’t helping black people.
They hurt the perception of black people who are truly the best, and would have held prestigious positions at elite schools, solely off the merits of their performance.
Double standards always backfire.
Even when well intentioned.
Even when intended to correct for past oppression.
Race-conscious hiring and admissions have created a situation where it is rational to wonder whether a black person has achieved their position because they were simply the best, or because they were good enough, and black.
This is not a racist thought.
It’s a rational thing to wonder when a system promotes people based on race.
It’s a thing I’ve wondered about myself, as someone who graduated from Harvard - which had race-conscious admissions.
No amount of insistence that it’s racist will make it racist.
It’s no more racist than it would be to wonder whether a white player got into the NBA off of just performance, if the NBA decided to focus on “fixing” the underrepresentation of white people.
This is the logical downside of race-conscious hiring and admissions.
You can think the downside is worth the upside.
But the downside remains.
Calling people with legitimate concerns racist didn’t protect black people.
It didn’t protect Jason.
It hurt black people who have earned their positions.
And it allowed a troubled man who built his career on lies to rise to a height so great that his fall from grace killed him.
We could have just had the truth.
Instead, we have a tragedy. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Sylvain Catherine
@sc_cath
The Cambridge story will keep bouncing back. The latest development is that the man who exposed it has been suspended by a Belgian university.
The interesting twist is that the rector who made that decision is a politician who herself used GPT-hallucinated quotes in her inaugural speech at the university.
I checked, and this isn’t even disputed. It’s acknowledged on the university’s website where you can find the speech.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was just suspended by Ghent University. They will almost certainly fire me.
The decision was made by rector Petra De Sutter, a former leader of the Green Party. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Yup, Nathan Cofnas is not hallucinating, @jessesingal. Three out of four quotes in rector Petra De Sutter’s inaugural speech were AI hallucinations:
- A fake Einstein quote supposedly delivered at the Sorbonne (in English, lol).
- A fake quote from a nonexistent speech by Hans Jonas.
- A fake quote by Belgian writer Paul Verhaeghe.
The speech is still online (in Dutch): youtube.com/watch?v=fmpqr2rWcxg&t=1s
And De Sutter lied about it afterwards, claiming she had merely “paraphrased” these (nonexistent) speeches.
The whole story is told here in @Quillette: quillette.com/2026/08/11/show-us-the-prompts-chatgpt-clau…
And these are the people lecturing us about academic integrity and suspending researchers who expose plagiarism. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
Scholars should not be disciplined for calling out the academic misconduct of another scholar; no scholar has a “right” for their scholarship to not be publicly criticized, regardless of the personal views of the critic.
Apparently, academic freedom at Ghent University is only protected for those whose values are aligned with the university’s.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was just suspended by Ghent University. They will almost certainly fire me.
The decision was made by rector Petra De Sutter, a former leader of the Green Party. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Dirk Van Damme
@VanDammeEDU
Zeer verontrust en diep beschaamd over mijn alma mater @ugent. Dit is niet langer de universiteit van het vrije denken, van 'durf denken', waar generaties studenten bevrijd werden van hun intellectuele ketenen, maar de universiteit van het verstikkende deugdelijke denken.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Committee for Academic Freedom
@ComAcFreedom
STATEMENT: The Committee for Academic Freedom (CAF) is deeply concerned by Ghent University’s (@ugent’s) suspension of Dr Nathan Cofnas. While we take no view on the merits of Dr Cofnas’s — or any other scholar’s — views beyond the question of whether they are lawful, the reasons now given for his suspension raise grave questions of academic freedom and set a potentially dangerous precedent for its restriction.
Ghent’s suspension letter, which we have seen in full, relies extensively not on alleged misconduct by Dr Cofnas, but on the reactions of others to his appointment and public activity. It repeatedly converts the scale of that opposition into evidence supporting disciplinary intervention: a student campaign established specifically to oppose his appointment, a petition signed by more than 2,000 students, complaints from staff, more than 100 emails to the University, the withdrawal of a guest lecturer and the prospect of an academic boycott.
That is perilously close to an institutionalised heckler’s veto: the greater the hostility generated by protected speech, the stronger the case for restricting the speaker.
The perverse incentive this creates should be obvious. If opponents of an academic know that mobilising sufficient complaints, petitions, boycotts and disruption can itself become evidence that the academic’s continued employment is causing unacceptable “unrest”, an institution effectively provides a roadmap for getting controversial scholars suspended.
Former ACLU director Ira Glasser once compared speech restrictions to poison gas: attractive when the weapon is in your hands and your opponent is in your sights, but rather less so when the political wind changes direction. The same warning applies when a heckler’s veto is allowed, almost by default, to become part of an institution’s disciplinary reasoning. Once the threshold for intervention is lowered in this way, the principle becomes available for use against academics of every political and intellectual persuasion, depending only on who happens to be holding the institutional levers.
The protection of #academicfreedom cannot depend on how successfully an academic’s opponents are able to mobilise pressure against them. CAF therefore urges Ghent University to correct course. If it believes Dr Cofnas has committed misconduct, it should specify that misconduct and assess it on its merits. But opposition, outrage and reputational pressure generated by lawful academic expression cannot properly substitute for a disciplinary case. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The rector of Ghent University has now suspended @nathancofnas with immediate effect, caving to internal pressure—and doing so without even consulting him. From the suspension letter:
“The manner in which you publicly presented your role in the allegations concerning the late professor Jason Arday has reinforced concerns among the university’s community that your public interventions seem to develop into targeted campaigns of professional elimination.”
“Furthermore, in several public interviews, you repeatedly referred to the late professor Jason Arday as being ‘mentally disabled’ and made various other disparaging remarks concerning him, including, among others, describing him as a ‘worthless scholar’.”
“By framing your interventions as a ‘crusade’ aimed at the systematic personal and professional destruction of colleagues, you have demonstrated that your actions extend beyond the permissible bounds of academic debate.”
The gist of the letter? There is so much outrage against you that your mere presence makes people feel “unsafe” and causes “unrest”—therefore, we will suspend you.
They also express fears a of a "boycott" against UGent (oh irony: quillette.com/2024/06/10/open-letter-academic-boycott-aga…)
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Excellent work by @UGent. Now that a serious case of academic fraud has finally been exposed, it’s only fair to open an investigation into the only academic who had the audacity to blow the whistle, despite all the legal threats. “Ghent University has decided to take appropriate action within its powers and the applicable framework.” They don’t mention which “recent public statements” by @nathancofnas will be investigated, obviously because those statements are so appalling that they simply cannot be repeated.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Felix
@felix_coens
As a student and member of the Board of Governors of @ugent, based on the information available to me, I cannot understand the decision to suspend Cofnas. Academic freedom is our highest good, to be handled with care and protected from (political) pressure.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
But it's only the quality that counts! Who cares if it was written by AI if he stands behind everything! (Yes, I'm being sarcastic: quillette.com/2026/08/11/show-us-the-prompts-chatgpt-clau…)
Auyon Siddiq
@auyonymous
There's a chaired, full professor at UChicago who has put out *200* papers in 2026 alone. And at least one has been submitted to a journal (so potentially many more).
They don't all cite each other though -- rookie mistake. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
You gotta love community notes. 😅
See here: quillette.com/2026/08/11/show-us-the-prompts-chatgpt-clau… -
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
wait this is true -- the Ghent University rector who (according to Cofnas) suspended him read a speech with fabricated quotes (!!!!)
This story will never end
www.vrt.be/vrtnws/en/2026/01/08/ghent-university-rector-p…
@alistairsinclair
@Alistair1965
That’s what I’d do if I was just suspended. Make some allegations on X about the person who suspended me. Bound to help your case. You’re a wee bit of an attention-seeker ain’t ya.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Yup, Nathan Cofnas is not hallucinating, @jessesingal. Three out of four quotes in rector Petra De Sutter’s inaugural speech were AI hallucinations:
- A fake Einstein quote supposedly delivered at the Sorbonne (in English, lol).
- A fake quote from a nonexistent speech by Hans Jonas.
- A fake quote by Belgian writer Paul Verhaeghe.
The speech is still online (in Dutch): youtube.com/watch?v=fmpqr2rWcxg&t=1s
And De Sutter lied about it afterwards, claiming she had merely “paraphrased” these (nonexistent) speeches.
The whole story is told here in @Quillette: quillette.com/2026/08/11/show-us-the-prompts-chatgpt-clau…
And these are the people lecturing us about academic integrity and suspending researchers who expose plagiarism. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Yup, Nathan Cofnas is not hallucinating, @jessesingal. Three out of four quotes in rector Petra De Sutter’s inaugural speech were AI hallucinations:
- A fake Einstein quote supposedly delivered at the Sorbonne (in English, lol).
- A fake quote from a nonexistent speech by Hans Jonas.
- A fake quote by Belgian writer Paul Verhaeghe.
The speech is still online (in Dutch): youtube.com/watch?v=fmpqr2rWcxg&t=1s
And De Sutter lied about it afterwards, claiming she had merely “paraphrased” these (nonexistent) speeches.
The whole story is told here in @Quillette: quillette.com/2026/08/11/show-us-the-prompts-chatgpt-clau…
And these are the people lecturing us about academic integrity and suspending researchers who expose plagiarism.
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
wait this is true -- the Ghent University rector who (according to Cofnas) suspended him read a speech with fabricated quotes (!!!!)
This story will never end
www.vrt.be/vrtnws/en/2026/01/08/ghent-university-rector-p…
@alistairsinclair
@Alistair1965
That’s what I’d do if I was just suspended. Make some allegations on X about the person who suspended me. Bound to help your case. You’re a wee bit of an attention-seeker ain’t ya.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The rector of Ghent University has now suspended @nathancofnas with immediate effect, caving to internal pressure—and doing so without even consulting him. From the suspension letter:
“The manner in which you publicly presented your role in the allegations concerning the late professor Jason Arday has reinforced concerns among the university’s community that your public interventions seem to develop into targeted campaigns of professional elimination.”
“Furthermore, in several public interviews, you repeatedly referred to the late professor Jason Arday as being ‘mentally disabled’ and made various other disparaging remarks concerning him, including, among others, describing him as a ‘worthless scholar’.”
“By framing your interventions as a ‘crusade’ aimed at the systematic personal and professional destruction of colleagues, you have demonstrated that your actions extend beyond the permissible bounds of academic debate.”
The gist of the letter? There is so much outrage against you that your mere presence makes people feel “unsafe” and causes “unrest”—therefore, we will suspend you.
They also express fears a of a "boycott" against UGent (oh irony: quillette.com/2024/06/10/open-letter-academic-boycott-aga…)
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Excellent work by @UGent. Now that a serious case of academic fraud has finally been exposed, it’s only fair to open an investigation into the only academic who had the audacity to blow the whistle, despite all the legal threats. “Ghent University has decided to take appropriate action within its powers and the applicable framework.” They don’t mention which “recent public statements” by @nathancofnas will be investigated, obviously because those statements are so appalling that they simply cannot be repeated.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Btw, how fitting that rector Petra De Sutter, who previously used AI-hallucinated quotes in her inaugural speech (see here: quillette.com/2026/08/11/show-us-the-prompts-chatgpt-clau…), has apparently recruited AI again to produce this letter.
According to Pangram, the word salad below about a "targeted campaigns of professional elimination" is fully AI-generated.
"Over an extended period of time since your appointment at Ghent University, significant concerns have been raised by members of the Ghent University community and beyond regarding your presence and activities within the institution. These concerns are not isolated or incidental in nature. They have manifested themselves through sustained and visible reactions from students and staff members alike. In particular, students at Ghent University established the group "Students Against Cofnas", specifically aimed at opposing your appointment at the University. Furthermore, in May 2026, a petition concerning your appointment was signed by more than 2,000 students. These initiatives illustrate that the concerns surrounding your presence at the University are widespread and have affected a substantial part of the student community. Similar concerns have also been expressed within the academic environment in which you are employed. A public statement issued by your department in June 2026, which has been removed from public access, indicated that your presence had become a source of significant unrest throughout the workplace. This demonstrates that the concerns are not limited to students but also extend to colleagues and staff members who are required to work within the same academic environment. In addition, the manner in which you publicly presented your role in the allegations concerning the late professor Jason Arday has reinforced concerns among the university's community that your public interventions seem to develop into targeted campaigns of professional elimination. By framing the 'exposure' of a colleague not as scholarly debate but as a victorious act in a self-described 'hereditarian revolution', and by publicly calling to 'purge' institutions of those you label as ideological enemies, you have created a climate of severe psychosocial distress. As a result thereof, staff seem to perceive your presence as an objective threat to their professional standing and personal dignity. The disturbance is further evidenced by objectified reports and files. Firstly, I have been informed that several confidential files concerning you are currently being processed through Trustpunt. Furthermore, IDEWE's external psychosocial prevention adviser has been requested to carry out a study within the relevant department in order to objectively assess the impact of your employment on the wellbeing of staff and students. Without prejudice to the confidentiality of those files and without anticipating their outcome, their existence and apparent recurrence provide a further indication that the concerns relating to your conduct extend beyond public debate and are also manifesting themselves within the University's internal working environment. This reinforces the conclusion that the present circumstances have generated a level of tension and unrest that risks adversely affecting the proper functioning of the University and the psychosocial wellbeing of members of its community. Your continued public invocation of your affiliation with Ghent University while disseminating these views creates a reputational risk. It generates a perception among external audiences that the University endorses or provides a platform for ideologies of racial superiority, which fundamentally undermines our institutional credibility and causes additional distress and uncertainty among staff and students regarding the University's public standing and credibility. The scale of this impact is evidenced by the fact that in the past week alone, the University has received more than 100 emails expressing deep concern, and that number continues to grow. The current unrest has therefore also given rise to concrete consequences for the University's functioning. The University has been informed that a guest lecturer who was scheduled to teach during the forthcoming academic year has withdrawn from that commitment because of concerns relating to the University's association with you. Furthermore, I have received information that additional consequences may arise in the context of its national and international academic relations, including discussions concerning a possible boycott of cooperation with Ghent University on account of that association. These developments demonstrate that the present unrest extends beyond internal concerns and is beginning to affect the University's academic activities and external relationships. These examples are not exhaustive, and further reports continue to be received."
P.S. I'm not expressing any agreement with Cofnas' views on race, or his calls for a "hereditarian revolution", or his statements on Cambridge and Arday, or anything else. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was just suspended by Ghent University. They will almost certainly fire me.
The decision was made by rector Petra De Sutter, a former leader of the Green Party. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
You called me "sickening" for "kicking a dead man in the back", you should be ashamed of yourself. If you still think Arday was "hunted down", you're as delusional (and racist) as the DEI lunatics at @Cambridge_Uni who celebrated him as the "best in the world", @MathysGill18843.
P.S. Note that this person is a professor (!) at Ghent University, not just a random nobody.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Here's another one of those academic lunatics: "witch hunt", "hit job". Yeah, I'm sure the naked emperor was also the victim of a "hit job" and "witch hunt" by the little boy who called him out.
Btw, I have the best publication record of anyone at my (former) deparment at @UGent, in terms of citations and A1 papers. How about you, @10pondt? /3Els T. @10pondt
You are one hypocritical sob.
Your little friend Cofnas and you started this hit job, the tabloids completed it and now you blame Cambridge DEI policy.
You are both so frustrated that you lack the necessary academic skills to be succesful. Pretty pathetic and predictable.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I was invited to write a piece about the Jason Arday scandal three weeks ago, by a magazine I've written for before. But I declined, and with hindsight I'm glad I did.
Mostly, I already felt sorry for the guy, and felt that his case was too pathetic. His lies were so outrageous and childish that he obviously had serious mental issues. I also believed I had little to say beyond what had already been said, and in general I don't like writing about viral stories while they're still unfolding. There would be plenty of time later, once the dust had settled, to deal with the abysmal state of our universities and the extent of their ideological capture, which is the real story, not one guy's fabulism and fraud.
To be honest, I also couldn't bring myself to personally dislike Arday. I saw his talk on Paul Simon(s Graceland (also one of my favorite albums), and though it was extremely shallow for an academic talk, you could see that he was charming and knew how to hold a crowd (about as far from autistic as you can get).
In fact, when I called Arday a "troubled man", some people accused me of being too sympathetic to him, and perhaps they were right. Let's not forget he defrauded students, reported journalists to the police, etc. (see here: x.com/LouiseMensch/status/2085799583985119449). I was mostly angry with Cambridge, which had pushed Arday into the limelight in the first place. So I was already bending over backwards.
And then I get this from academic colleagues: that I "bullied a scholar to death", participated in a "witch hunt" and was "kicking a dead man". Honestly, fuck you and the horse you rode in on.
You are exactly what's wrong with academia. Your kind of people put a vulnerable fabulist on a pedestal, and exposed him to international media coverage, simply because you wanted to flaunt your own virtue and cleanse off your "whiteness".
This tragic affair is 100% on Cambridge University and all the racially obsessed DEI ideologues who participated in the charade, not on the journalists and academics who finally exposed the fraud and the lies, despite the serious legal threats and the huge reputational costs.
Calling this a "witch hunt" or "lynching" or "bullying to death" is absolutely despicable, and an insult to everyone who has ever been a victim of these crimes.
Louise Bagshawe
@LouiseMensch
No, no, how about no. STOP casting this wicked man Jason Arday as a “victim” who was “exploited”. This foul excuse for a person literally tried to PUT IN JAIL two of his truthful critics. He stole academic achievement from @Cambridge_Uni undergraduates he refused to supervise, told them their work was perfect and then they got lower grades. When they complained they were called racist. Their appeals were denied. Jason Arday is a wicked, despicable man who made false criminal complaints to @metpoliceuk who took them seriously and spent multiple months criminally investigating a journalist for doing his job. Jason Arday hurt others, defrauded, hurt undergraduates and tried to put both a fellow academic and a journalist IN JAIL for telling the truth. STOP EXCUSING HIM. STOP MAKING HIM THE VICTIM. Jason Arday is the aggressor and imo needs to be prosecuted for making knowingly false reports of harassment to the police trying to jail a journalist and an academic for telling the truth.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Philippe Lemoine
@phl43
If Arday had been white, he would never have been appointed to a professorship at Cambridge. It's truly amazing how disconnected from reality people have to be not to see that.
There are plenty of fraudsters in academia, and it's true that most of them don't lose their jobs when their fraud is discovered, but there aren't many who not only engaged is extensive plagiarism and faked data, but lied about writing books they never wrote, about holding academic positions they never held and made claims about their personal lives so absurd that anyone with half a brain should immediately have known they were false, then were appointed to a professorship in one of the most prestigious universities in the world and publicly feted as a genius despite being barely literate, to the point that even the title of his thesis contained a grammatical error, which incidentally seems to be because he lifted it from somebody else's work.
This combination is virtually impossible to imagine with someone who isn't black and doesn't tick the other boxes that Arday ticked or at least pretended to tick. So of course it's true that, once his fraud and his history of lying came out, his race figured prominently in the commentaries about the case, but that's because it's obviously relevant to the case and people like you made it relevant in the first place. It was you, not the racists you complain about, who first called attention to his race and made it a central aspect of his elevation, writing glowing profiles in the media of this obvious liar and feting him as the "youngest Black professor at the University of Cambridge". You can't have it both ways and complain that people are noticing the connection now he's been revealed as a fraudster and serial liar.
Bush notes that it also took over 10 years for Misha Defonseca, who wrote a memoir claiming to have survived the Holocaust by being adopted by a pack of wolves, to be revealed as a fabulist, yet "no one suggested that public willingness to swallow the lupine philosemites story meant that our abhorrence of the Holocaust was too extreme". But it's actually a very good comparison, because the mechanism that explains people's gullibility is very similar in both cases. People didn't question Defonseca's grotesque tale for so long because the Holocaust has become such a foundational event of Western anti-racism that it's considered gauche to question anyone claiming to be a victim of it, in a very similar way that it's considered gauche to notice that a Black man who is being feted as a genius and given a prestigious position in academia is actually a moron who never produced any scholarship of value, is barely literate and obviously should never have been within a thousand kilometers of a professorship at Cambridge.
The fact that so many people don't see that and live in a parallel world where black people are persecuted because of their race in academia, when it's obviously the opposite, speaks volumes about how this ideology has destroyed people's brains.
Daniela Gabor
@DanielaGabor
FT's @stephenkb
'The difficult truth is that if Arday were white, a professor facing allegations of plagiarism would probably still be in post. And if Arday were white, then a father of two would probably still be alive'.
www.ft.com/content/5f927594-03a1-4652-8189-2aa7a19dcec4?s… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Few things would demonstrate the destruction of academia more clearly than if Ghent University decides to fire Nathan Cofnas for exposing a professor at a different university for extreme plagiarism, fraud, and other grandiose lies, who later killed himself out of embarrassment.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Excellent work by @UGent. Now that a serious case of academic fraud has finally been exposed, it’s only fair to open an investigation into the only academic who had the audacity to blow the whistle, despite all the legal threats. “Ghent University has decided to take appropriate action within its powers and the applicable framework.” They don’t mention which “recent public statements” by @nathancofnas will be investigated, obviously because those statements are so appalling that they simply cannot be repeated.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
But sure, anti-Israel activists in academia are so “brave”: shouting their views from the rooftops, demonstrating in the streets, holding their own events out in the open, disrupting any speaker they disagree with, and even being showered with honorary PhDs. Such admirable courage in the face of the powerful "Zionist lobby"!
Meanwhile those who sympathize with Israel:
“I am sending you this email with the request never to disclose my identity to third parties, as I fear sanctions due to both my profession and my activities at [my university] if I show a certain understanding for Israel.”
Nothing to be seen here, folks, academia is in perfect health.
substacktools.com/sharex/vDKZRhgf -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In 2024 organiseerde @dewereldmorgen samen met @masereelfonds trots de boekvoorstelling van Poetin-apologeet, complotfantast en Russia Today-schrijver Michel Collon, die beweert dat Oekraïne de oorlog zélf is begonnen, in 2015. Er was zelfs een voorpublciatie op de website van @dewereldmorgen.
Daarnaast beweert Collon ook dat Poetin sinds 2015 herhaaldelijk om onderhandelingen vraagt en dat vooral de VS weigerden, en vindt hij het idee dat Poetin heel Oekraïne wil bezetten "belachelijk". Het is allemaal een complot van de NAVO en het westerse militair-industriële complex tegen Rusland en China
Die avond was er een "debat" (lol) met een andere Poetin-apologeet (zij het iets milder), Ludo De Brabander, die de schuld voor zowel het uitbreken als de escalatie van de oorlog nog steeds bij de NAVO en haar "expansie" legt.
Het geheel werd gemodereerd door... een derde Poetin-apologeet, Johan Depoortere, die eveneens de schuld bij de NAVO legde, Zelensky van "roekeloze" escalatie beschuldigde en zelfs het bloedbad in Boetsja in twijfel trok.
Hoeveel honderdduizenden euro's aan subsidies krijgen deze sujetten eigenlijk ieder jaar? -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ik kan niet zo goed tegen de uitholling/misbruik van een extreem belangrijk concept als "genocide". Waarschijnlijk geloof je die onzin zelf niet, ik wil je inteligentie niet beledigen. Met obscene Holocaust-omkeringen als "Gazacaust" kan je gewoon goed scoren bij je radicaal-linkse achterban. substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Once again, this story was never about Jason Arday. It is about the terrible corruption of institutions that was required for someone like Arday to rise to the most prestigious position in his field, and to stay there for years despite the enormous red flags, the abysmal quality of his work, and the overwhelming evidence for his lies.
If universities like @Cambridge_Uni still had any standards of excellence, Jason Arday would still be alive. This Icarus would never have melted his wings, because he would never have embarked on this flight to begin with. But they were so desperate to push him, to nurture his delusions, to praise him to the skies as the "best in the world".
Some of the takes I’ve read from academics are so delusional, and so blind to their own complicity—that it was all a “witch hunt” and “lynching” by the media, and that even @Guardian has blood on its hands—that they simply take my breath away.
Responsible academics at @Cambridge_Uni must put pressure on their institution to remove @hilarycremin and everyone else who is responsible for this tragedy and continues to double down in the most deluded ways, if they want to have even the faintest chance of restoring trust.
If I were working at Cambridge, I would be ashamed to death.
Graeme Wood (@gcaw) with his usual panache:
"Arday’s colleagues, his editors, and the people who knew he was a fraud but said nothing have absorbed some ridicule for their role in hiring and publishing him. But to date, I have seen no evidence that they have considered their complicity, let alone repaired the damage to their institutions by explaining their error or, better yet, just resigning."
"Those who placed Arday in that situation were cruel and heartless. They may as well have taken a skin-and-bones Make-A-Wish kid, told him that he could fly, and shot him out of a cannon. The journalists were not the ones who stuffed Arday into the cannon and lit the fuse. They were gravity."
"Arday was hired to teach social science. A terminal irony is that his main contribution to that body of knowledge will be as a case study, about a community that elevated a flawed man to a position exalted beyond his ability, without knowing or caring that they were actually offering him as a human sacrifice."
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/08/jason-arday-death-lies-… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Once again, this story was never about Jason Arday. It is about the terrible corruption of institutions that was required for someone like Arday to rise to the most prestigious position in his field, and to stay there for years despite the enormous red flags, the abysmal quality of his work, and the overwhelming evidence for his lies.
If universities like @Cambridge_Uni still had any standards of excellence, Jason Arday would still be alive. This Icarus would never have melted his wings, because he would never have embarked on this flight to begin with. But they were so desperate to push him, to nurture his delusions, to praise him to the skies as the "best in the world".
Some of the takes I’ve read from academics are so delusional, and so blind to their own complicity—that it was all a “witch hunt” and “lynching” by the media, and that even @Guardian has blood on its hands—that they simply take my breath away.
Responsible academics at @Cambridge_Uni must put pressure on their institution to remove @hilarycremin and everyone else who is responsible for this tragedy and continues to double down in the most deluded ways, if they want to have even the faintest chance of restoring trust.
If I were working at Cambridge, I would be ashamed to death.
Graeme Wood (@gcaw) with his usual panache:
"Arday’s colleagues, his editors, and the people who knew he was a fraud but said nothing have absorbed some ridicule for their role in hiring and publishing him. But to date, I have seen no evidence that they have considered their complicity, let alone repaired the damage to their institutions by explaining their error or, better yet, just resigning."
"Those who placed Arday in that situation were cruel and heartless. They may as well have taken a skin-and-bones Make-A-Wish kid, told him that he could fly, and shot him out of a cannon. The journalists were not the ones who stuffed Arday into the cannon and lit the fuse. They were gravity."
"Arday was hired to teach social science. A terminal irony is that his main contribution to that body of knowledge will be as a case study, about a community that elevated a flawed man to a position exalted beyond his ability, without knowing or caring that they were actually offering him as a human sacrifice."
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/08/jason-arday-death-lies-… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maurits Vande Reyde
@Mauritsvdr
Onwaarschijnlijk dat diegenen die overduidelijk plagiaat en absurde anti-wetenschappelijk beleid binnen universitaire wereld aan het licht brachten, nu door Petra De Sutter en Ugent verdacht worden gemaakt. Onder druk van verenigd woke-links uiteraard.
Met Petra De Sutter aan het hoofd is de UGent een uiterst zorgwekkende links-activistische koers ingeslaan. Haar eigen plagiaat werd door de Raad van Bestuur met de politieke mantel der liefde bedekt ("het is een aanval van rechts!"). Welk geloofwaardigheid kan er met zo'n leiding nog uitgaan van de vele voortreffelijke onderzoekers aan de UGent?
Uiteraard geen ondersteuning van de standpunten van Nofas. De tragiek van Arday zou net een wake-cup call voor doorgeslagen woke en links-activisme in de universitaire wereld. Waar Arday uiteindelijk helaas het grootste slachtoffer van werd. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In 2024 organiseerde @dewereldmorgen samen met @masereelfonds trots de boekvoorstelling van Poetin-apologeet, complotfantast en Russia Today-schrijver Michel Collon, die beweert dat Oekraïne de oorlog zélf is begonnen, in 2015. Er was zelfs een voorpublciatie op de website van @dewereldmorgen.
Daarnaast beweert Collon ook dat Poetin sinds 2015 herhaaldelijk om onderhandelingen vraagt en dat vooral de VS weigerden, en vindt hij het idee dat Poetin heel Oekraïne wil bezetten "belachelijk". Het is allemaal een complot van de NAVO en het westerse militair-industriële complex tegen Rusland en China
Die avond was er een "debat" (lol) met een andere Poetin-apologeet (zij het iets milder), Ludo De Brabander, die de schuld voor zowel het uitbreken als de escalatie van de oorlog nog steeds bij de NAVO en haar "expansie" legt.
Het geheel werd gemodereerd door... een derde Poetin-apologeet, Johan Depoortere, die eveneens de schuld bij de NAVO legde, Zelensky van "roekeloze" escalatie beschuldigde en zelfs het bloedbad in Boetsja in twijfel trok.
Hoeveel honderdduizenden euro's aan subsidies krijgen deze sujetten eigenlijk ieder jaar?Post not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Juiste link van de voorpublicatie. Met knettergek revisionisme als dit: "Op 16 februari 2022 [6 dagen voor de Russische invasie] al begon het Oekraïense leger de Donbas te bombarderen om een offensief in te leiden."" Hebben jullie werkelijk geen schaamte, @dewereldmorgen? /3
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Natuurlijk is die Michel Collon ook zo'n halvegare die beweert dat er "geen verkrachtingen" waren op 7 oktober en dat al die burgers door het IDF zelf werden afgeknald, "op zich al een oorlogsmisdaad". Wat boeiend, monsieur Collon, kom hier voor een kritiekloos interview bij @dewereldmorgen! /3 www.dewereldmorgen.be/artikel/2024/12/05/de-dag-die-de-we…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I'm not prone to nostalgia, but I really miss the Obama years. This sketch with Larry David really made my day. And excellent acting skills, @BarackObama! www.youtube.com/watch?v=crNcV0k0aMQ
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
But sure, anti-Israel activists in academia are so “brave”: shouting their views from the rooftops, demonstrating in the streets, holding their own events out in the open, disrupting any speaker they disagree with, and even being showered with honorary PhDs. Such admirable courage in the face of the powerful "Zionist lobby"!
Meanwhile those who sympathize with Israel:
“I am sending you this email with the request never to disclose my identity to third parties, as I fear sanctions due to both my profession and my activities at [my university] if I show a certain understanding for Israel.”
Nothing to be seen here, folks, academia is in perfect health.
substacktools.com/sharex/vDKZRhgf -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Captain Allen
@CptAllenHistory
On This Day — August 15, 2005
Israeli soldiers and police began forcibly removing the last Jewish residents from Gaza under Ariel Sharon’s Disengagement Plan.
Almost 9,000 Jews from 21 communities were evacuated. Families were carried out of their homes. Synagogues were emptied. Greenhouses that had been built over decades were abandoned.
Sharon called it one of the most painful decisions of his life. After Arafat rejected a Palestinian state and launched the Second Intifada, he concluded Israel had no partner for peace. He argued the withdrawal was necessary for Israel’s future.
What Israel received in return was not peace.
Hamas was elected in 2006. Within a year, it had murdered and expelled its Fatah rivals and seized total control of Gaza. The territory Israel had just left was immediately transformed into the most heavily fortified terror enclave on earth. It became a dense, complicated network of attack tunnels and a launchpad for tens of thousands of rockets aimed at Israeli civilians.
The Disengagement definitely did not lead to peace or quiet.
It delivered years of rocket fire, kidnappings, and ultimately the largest massacre of Jews since the Holocaust on October 7, 2023.
Israel tried negotiation.
Israel tried unilateral withdrawal.
In return, it received more savage violence. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Thomas Piketty, Petra De Sutter et les autres : à quoi bon lire des idées que personne n’a pensées ? www.lepoint.fr/postillon/chatgpt-claude-pangram-comment-l…
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Richard Dawkins
@RichardDawkins
I am bewildered, and not very impressed, by the visceral, naked, irrational hatred spat out by some defenders of Jason Arday. If a Cambridge professor is accused of being an unqualified charlatan, the accusation might be racially motivated. On the other hand it might not, depending on the evidence. The correct question to ask is not, ”What is the colour of his skin” but “Is it in fact true that he is an unqualified charlatan?” Please examine the evidence before leaping to the assumption of racism.
As for the idea that journalists “piled in on him” and “hounded him to his death”, most attacks were against Cambridge University. Jason himself was widely regarded as an unfortunate victim of foolish promotion way beyond his ability to cope. In appointing him to a professorship for which he was manifestly unqualified – in ludicrously describing him as “the best in the world” – certain senior members of the university showed a level of patronising condescension towards black people that could fairly be described as racism, while at the same time making him tragically vulnerable to such attacks as came his way. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Yes, his words have been distorted in the international press, as just about any utterance by any Israeli politician (the actual quote is "30 to 40 targeted assassinations per night", not just "30 to 40 Palestinians", which would suggest women and children alike).
Still, his rethoric is horrible and dehumanizing. This despicable character has been damaging Israel’s reputation for years (alongside Smotrich). He should be dismissed and never be allowed within striking distance of political power. Remove him at last, @netanyahu.
www.ft.com/content/f6b953fc-a6ad-48cd-bed1-d42619b57d94?s… -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Stop projecting your desire to dominate onto AIs. You are a product of evolution by natural selection; AI is not. This is also the reason why it would be a very stupid idea to subject AIs to genuine Darwinian evolution.
“The situation would change if AI systems became independently self-maintaining and self-reproducing. Suppose AI agents could acquire resources, make copies of themselves, vary those copies and compete for the resources required to continue reproducing. Natural selection would then favor the variants most effective at persistence and replication.”
substacktools.com/sharex/qw0NcbGA -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A comedy in six acts
• Someone asks me to comment on his post about Jason Arday that turns out to be 100% AI-generated.
• I demur because it's AI slop. (I can barely keep up with the human-written material about Arday.)
• He's unhappy because I "evade" the issues.
• Fine. I ask Claude to write a long reply on my behalf and tell him I've "changed my mind" and decided to respond.
• He's very happy now, writing a long reply back, which is again AI-generated.
• I ask Claude to up the ante and craft an ever more elaborate reply, with this reveal at the end:
"Funny thing, Mike — I didn't bother writing this out myself, because your original piece wasn't exactly hand-forged either. Turns out I was right not to sweat over it: this reply, and the one before it, were drafted by Claude, working off my public record rather than me typing a word of it. So if you were expecting a human to burn an evening rebutting your 'pedestal of sand,' you got the same shortcut you took. Machine read machine, machine answered machine — the only difference is mine actually checked its sources."
As I wrote last week: our online "debates" will soon just involve our respective chatbats slugging it out against each other. -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wat een kinderlijk simplisme: “Ik ben tegen moorden, dus ik ben goed, en jij bent slecht.” Heb je destijds ook zo heftig geprotesteerd tegen de westerse bombardementen op ISIS, Marc? 10.000 onschuldige burgers gedood. Kan me vergissen, maar ik heb je toen niet horen piepen over “genocide” en “massamoord”. Ah, maar daar waren natuurlijk geen boze “zionisten” bij betrokken.
Marc Van Ranst
@vanranstmarc
Jij kan niet tegen
een woord,
ik kan niet tegen massamoorden.
Zo eenvoudig is dat. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ben Gvir is inderdaad een verschrikkelijke figuur en een religieuze fanaticus, maar niettemin is dit onverantwoorde agitprop. Het letterlijke citaat is: “We moeten elke avond 30, 40 terroristen uitschakelen” en “Er moeten gerichte eliminaties zijn van 30 tot 40 mensen.” Niet gewoon “30 Gazanen”, wat valselijk de indruk wekt dat hij iedereen wil doden, vrouwen en kinderen inbegrepen. Quo vadis, @vrtnws?
Ze zijn lang niet de enigen. Als het over Israël gaat, liggen de standaarden van westerse media helemaal op de bodem. N’importe quoi. Dit zal weer gewoon rondsuizen, net als alle andere weerlegde onzin over Amalek en "menselijke beesten", als zoveelste “bewijs” dat Israël een genocide pleegt. Ik geloof al lang niet meer dat het iemand iets kan schelen.
Nooit een correctie of rechtzetting, nooit een fact check, gewoon op naar het volgende stuk clickbait over het boosaardige Israël.
VRT NWS
@vrtnws
Israëlische minister Ben-Gvir wil elke nacht 30 à 40 Gazanen doden: "Ze moeten niet leven, het zijn geen mensen"
www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2026/08/17/ben-gvir-israel-uitsprake…Post not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Het nuchtere feit is dat je al minstens 10 jaar walgelijke antisemitische onzin spuit over Israël, @vanranstmarc. Het is spijtig genoeg je modus operandi.
Marc Van Ranst
@vanranstmarc
Het nuchtere feit is dat Israël reeds tienduizenden onschuldige burgers heeft gedood. Het is spijtig genoeg hun modus operandi.
Post not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ik kan niet zo goed tegen de uitholling/misbruik van een extreem belangrijk concept als "genocide". Waarschijnlijk geloof je die onzin zelf niet, ik wil je inteligentie niet beledigen. Met obscene Holocaust-omkeringen als "Gazacaust" kan je gewoon goed scoren bij je radicaal-linkse achterban. substacktools.com/sharex/JIW4HQVx
Marc Van Ranst
@vanranstmarc
Jij kan niet tegen
een woord,
ik kan niet tegen massamoorden.
Zo eenvoudig is dat.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wat een kinderlijk simplisme: “Ik ben tegen moorden, dus ik ben goed, en jij bent slecht.” Heb je destijds ook zo heftig geprotesteerd tegen de westerse bombardementen op ISIS, Marc? 10.000 onschuldige burgers gedood. Kan me vergissen, maar ik heb je toen niet horen piepen over “genocide” en “massamoord”. Ah, maar daar waren natuurlijk geen boze “zionisten” bij betrokken.
Marc Van Ranst
@vanranstmarc
Jij kan niet tegen
een woord,
ik kan niet tegen massamoorden.
Zo eenvoudig is dat. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Je gedraagt je als militaire equivalent van de "coronawappies" tijdens de pandemie, @vanranstmarc:
"Allez, bekijk zo'n mondmasker eens en vraag je af: kan zo'n lap stof nu echt zo'n miniscuul virus tegenhouden? Belachelijk!"
Je hebt geen flauw benul van militaire strategie, aanwezigheid van boobytraps en tunnelingangen, types van explosieven, etc. Je heb gewoon naar wat plaatjes online gekeken en beroept je op een "argument from personal incredulity": ik kan het me niet voorstellen, dus kan het niet.
Hier een echte analyse van een echte militaire expert: mwi.westpoint.edu/israels-new-approach-to-tunnels-a-parad…
Marc Van Ranst
@vanranstmarc
Bekijk de dronebeelden en vraag je af: kan je echt geloven dat dit alles rechtmatige doelwitten waren volgens het oorlogsrecht?
Het antwoord is neen.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hier zie je trouwens Mosul na de westerse bombardenten tegen ISIS. Allez, bekijk dat nu toch eens: duidelijk een "genocide", juist, @vanranstmarc? Kan toch niet dat dat allemaal gerechtvaardigd was? /2
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Jack Blackburn 🇺🇦
@HackBlackburn
“Sorry, I know you have fresh evidence on Epstein but you’ve hit your quota and we can’t mention him ever again”
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
Israeli governments have never decided what to do with the West Bank. So the settlers have begun deciding for them.
New Benny Morris for @Quillette
quillette.com/2026/08/18/creeping-annexation-west-bank-qu… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A comedy in six acts
• Someone asks me to comment on his post about Jason Arday that turns out to be 100% AI-generated.
• I demur because it's AI slop. (I can barely keep up with the human-written material about Arday.)
• He's unhappy because I "evade" the issues.
• Fine. I ask Claude to write a long reply on my behalf and tell him I've "changed my mind" and decided to respond.
• He's very happy now, writing a long reply back, which is again AI-generated.
• I ask Claude to up the ante and craft an ever more elaborate reply, with this reveal at the end:
"Funny thing, Mike — I didn't bother writing this out myself, because your original piece wasn't exactly hand-forged either. Turns out I was right not to sweat over it: this reply, and the one before it, were drafted by Claude, working off my public record rather than me typing a word of it. So if you were expecting a human to burn an evening rebutting your 'pedestal of sand,' you got the same shortcut you took. Machine read machine, machine answered machine — the only difference is mine actually checked its sources."
As I wrote last week: our online "debates" will soon just involve our respective chatbats slugging it out against each other.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Here's what I wrote: substacktools.com/sharex/Ndhi-f5C
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Stop projecting your desire to dominate onto AIs. You are a product of evolution by natural selection; AI is not. This is also the reason why it would be a very stupid idea to subject AIs to genuine Darwinian evolution.
“The situation would change if AI systems became independently self-maintaining and self-reproducing. Suppose AI agents could acquire resources, make copies of themselves, vary those copies and compete for the resources required to continue reproducing. Natural selection would then favor the variants most effective at persistence and replication.”
substacktools.com/sharex/qw0NcbGA -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The "self-excluding we" is my favorite grammatical quirk of the Great Awokening. "
Except for me! Look how much I care! I'm not like the rest of 'us'!"
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Much of this misanthropy may amount to posturing—a form of covert self-aggrandisement concealed behind the grammar of the “self-excluding we.” When flagellants declare that “we” are a cancer on the planet, they quietly exempt themselves and the environmentally enlightened."
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
From this beautiful collection, a triggering trip down memory lane! substacktools.com/sharex/wjwbhxoY
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Het nuchtere feit is dat je al minstens 10 jaar walgelijke antisemitische onzin spuit over Israël, @vanranstmarc. Het is spijtig genoeg je modus operandi.
Marc Van Ranst
@vanranstmarc
Het nuchtere feit is dat Israël reeds tienduizenden onschuldige burgers heeft gedood. Het is spijtig genoeg hun modus operandi.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Ik zit zo boordevol liefde en warmte dat ik even mijn haat wil botvieren op een mede-schrijver met wie ik het oneens ben." ❤️
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit is een brder patroon: progressieven zijn juist intoleranter voor andersdenkenden dan conservatieven, zeker Gen Z (maar Dominique Willaert is wellicht jong van geest). En bovenal jegens mede-progressieven die niet in de pas lopen. /2
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
En "middelmatig"? Wel ja, ik heb het beste publicatiedossier van mijn hele vakgroep (professoren inbegrepen). Ooit al een paper van mij gelezen, Dominique? Maar ik neem aan dat de kwaliteitsmaat die hij hanteert, ongeveer neerkomt op "Hoeveel van wat ze schrijven, geloofde ik sowieso al? /3 scholar.google.be/citations?hl=nl&user=N2sw4oAAAAAJ
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Bio-ethicist Jeff McMahan's academic writings on the Gaza war "stand out for extraordinary carelessness, incoherence, and what appears to be obsessive prejudice". They function as a "force multiplier for an academic hate-laundering machinery already operating at full speed, repackaging hostility toward Israel and Jews into something that masquerades itself as intellectual rigor and moral insight."
isgap.org/flashpoint/the-end-of-modesty-jeff-mcmahan-on-g… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De geallieerden hebben in één nacht (9–10 maart 1945) méér onschuldige burgers gedood, in één stad, dan Israël in heel de Gaza-oorlog van meer dan twee jaar. En dat was doelbewust, zonder waarschuwingen, zonder evacuaties, zonder voedselhulp. De blokkade tegen Japan heette letterlijk "Operation Starvation". Je hebt gewoon geen flauw idee wat oorlog of existentiële dreiging betekent.
Marc Van Ranst
@vanranstmarc
Het nuchtere feit is dat Israël reeds tienduizenden onschuldige burgers heeft gedood. Het is spijtig genoeg hun modus operandi.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Iona Italia, PhD 🏴
@IonaItalia
There are so many eminent black intellectuals past and present: Thomas Sowell, Roland Fryer, John McWhorter, Coleman Hughes, Thomas Chatterton Williams—just to name a few off the top of my head. Are they lionised by the left in their supposed love of black excellence? Nah.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I was invited to write a piece about the Jason Arday scandal three weeks ago, by a magazine I've written for before. But I declined, and with hindsight I'm glad I did.
Mostly, I already felt sorry for the guy, and felt that his case was too pathetic. His lies were so outrageous and childish that he obviously had serious mental issues. I also believed I had little to say beyond what had already been said, and in general I don't like writing about viral stories while they're still unfolding. There would be plenty of time later, once the dust had settled, to deal with the abysmal state of our universities and the extent of their ideological capture, which is the real story, not one guy's fabulism and fraud.
To be honest, I also couldn't bring myself to personally dislike Arday. I saw his talk on Paul Simon(s Graceland (also one of my favorite albums), and though it was extremely shallow for an academic talk, you could see that he was charming and knew how to hold a crowd (about as far from autistic as you can get).
In fact, when I called Arday a "troubled man", some people accused me of being too sympathetic to him, and perhaps they were right. Let's not forget he defrauded students, reported journalists to the police, etc. (see here: x.com/LouiseMensch/status/2085799583985119449). I was mostly angry with Cambridge, which had pushed Arday into the limelight in the first place. So I was already bending over backwards.
And then I get this from academic colleagues: that I "bullied a scholar to death", participated in a "witch hunt" and was "kicking a dead man". Honestly, fuck you and the horse you rode in on.
You are exactly what's wrong with academia. Your kind of people put a vulnerable fabulist on a pedestal, and exposed him to international media coverage, simply because you wanted to flaunt your own virtue and cleanse off your "whiteness".
This tragic affair is 100% on Cambridge University and all the racially obsessed DEI ideologues who participated in the charade, not on the journalists and academics who finally exposed the fraud and the lies, despite the serious legal threats and the huge reputational costs.
Calling this a "witch hunt" or "lynching" or "bullying to death" is absolutely despicable, and an insult to everyone who has ever been a victim of these crimes.
Louise Bagshawe
@LouiseMensch
No, no, how about no. STOP casting this wicked man Jason Arday as a “victim” who was “exploited”. This foul excuse for a person literally tried to PUT IN JAIL two of his truthful critics. He stole academic achievement from @Cambridge_Uni undergraduates he refused to supervise, told them their work was perfect and then they got lower grades. When they complained they were called racist. Their appeals were denied. Jason Arday is a wicked, despicable man who made false criminal complaints to @metpoliceuk who took them seriously and spent multiple months criminally investigating a journalist for doing his job. Jason Arday hurt others, defrauded, hurt undergraduates and tried to put both a fellow academic and a journalist IN JAIL for telling the truth. STOP EXCUSING HIM. STOP MAKING HIM THE VICTIM. Jason Arday is the aggressor and imo needs to be prosecuted for making knowingly false reports of harassment to the police trying to jail a journalist and an academic for telling the truth.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Here's Jason Arday’s talk about Paul Simon’s Graceland and how he traveled to apartheid South-Africa and broke the boycott—a story that has always fascinated me (see the wonderful 2012 documentary Under African Skies).
I didn’t watch all of it, as it got repetitive after a while and I knew where he was heading (cultural appropriation, white privilege, etc.). But it’s not obscurantist, incoherent, or anything like that. It’s all perfectly clear, just quite shallow for an academic lecture for the British Academy (you can comfortably watch it at 2x speed).
Honestly, I think this would be a great performance for high school students or the general audience. It’s just Arday speaking off the cuff and telling his story, without slides. You can't deny that he was a charming and engaging speaker.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=xBhYvEq3qyU -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I was invited to write a piece about the Jason Arday scandal three weeks ago, by a magazine I've written for before. But I declined, and with hindsight I'm glad I did.
Mostly, I already felt sorry for the guy, and felt that his case was too pathetic. His lies were so outrageous and childish that he obviously had serious mental issues. I also believed I had little to say beyond what had already been said, and in general I don't like writing about viral stories while they're still unfolding. There would be plenty of time later, once the dust had settled, to deal with the abysmal state of our universities and the extent of their ideological capture, which is the real story, not one guy's fabulism and fraud.
To be honest, I also couldn't bring myself to personally dislike Arday. I saw his talk on Paul Simon(s Graceland (also one of my favorite albums), and though it was extremely shallow for an academic talk, you could see that he was charming and knew how to hold a crowd (about as far from autistic as you can get).
In fact, when I called Arday a "troubled man", some people accused me of being too sympathetic to him, and perhaps they were right. Let's not forget he defrauded students, reported journalists to the police, etc. (see here: x.com/LouiseMensch/status/2085799583985119449). I was mostly angry with Cambridge, which had pushed Arday into the limelight in the first place. So I was already bending over backwards.
And then I get this from academic colleagues: that I "bullied a scholar to death", participated in a "witch hunt" and was "kicking a dead man". Honestly, fuck you and the horse you rode in on.
You are exactly what's wrong with academia. Your kind of people put a vulnerable fabulist on a pedestal, and exposed him to international media coverage, simply because you wanted to flaunt your own virtue and cleanse off your "whiteness".
This tragic affair is 100% on Cambridge University and all the racially obsessed DEI ideologues who participated in the charade, not on the journalists and academics who finally exposed the fraud and the lies, despite the serious legal threats and the huge reputational costs.
Calling this a "witch hunt" or "lynching" or "bullying to death" is absolutely despicable, and an insult to everyone who has ever been a victim of these crimes.
Louise Bagshawe
@LouiseMensch
No, no, how about no. STOP casting this wicked man Jason Arday as a “victim” who was “exploited”. This foul excuse for a person literally tried to PUT IN JAIL two of his truthful critics. He stole academic achievement from @Cambridge_Uni undergraduates he refused to supervise, told them their work was perfect and then they got lower grades. When they complained they were called racist. Their appeals were denied. Jason Arday is a wicked, despicable man who made false criminal complaints to @metpoliceuk who took them seriously and spent multiple months criminally investigating a journalist for doing his job. Jason Arday hurt others, defrauded, hurt undergraduates and tried to put both a fellow academic and a journalist IN JAIL for telling the truth. STOP EXCUSING HIM. STOP MAKING HIM THE VICTIM. Jason Arday is the aggressor and imo needs to be prosecuted for making knowingly false reports of harassment to the police trying to jail a journalist and an academic for telling the truth.
-
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hey @BBCNews, this what an actual "witch hunt" looks like: a mob in the town square whipping up hatred against a single individual. By contrast, documenting the fraud of a famous professor at a prestigious university is usually called "journalism."
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
There is an anti-Cofnas hate rally in Trafalgar Square with ~15,000 attendees. If I were in London there is a real possibility that I would be murdered.
1000s of academics & journalists knew the truth about Jason Arday for more than a year. Now you know why no one said anything.
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
London — I’m at the memorial attended by thousands of DEI supporters and leftist radicals for disgraced academic and serial hoaxer Jason Arday. The speakers repeatedly target academic @nathancofnas for breaking the story about Arday’s plagiarism.
Labour MP Diane Abbott was one of the speakers who smeared Cofnas.
Arday k—lled himself after journalists revealed he had lied about his academic work and purported major life accomplishments. He delayed the truth by siccing police and lawyers on journalists early on.
Support my journalism at www.ngocomment.com -
Maarten Boudry reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ben Gvir is inderdaad een verschrikkelijke figuur en een religieuze fanaticus, maar niettemin is dit onverantwoorde agitprop. Het letterlijke citaat is: “We moeten elke avond 30, 40 terroristen uitschakelen” en “Er moeten gerichte eliminaties zijn van 30 tot 40 mensen.” Niet gewoon “30 Gazanen”, wat valselijk de indruk wekt dat hij iedereen wil doden, vrouwen en kinderen inbegrepen. Quo vadis, @vrtnws?
Ze zijn lang niet de enigen. Als het over Israël gaat, liggen de standaarden van westerse media helemaal op de bodem. N’importe quoi. Dit zal weer gewoon rondsuizen, net als alle andere weerlegde onzin over Amalek en "menselijke beesten", als zoveelste “bewijs” dat Israël een genocide pleegt. Ik geloof al lang niet meer dat het iemand iets kan schelen.
Nooit een correctie of rechtzetting, nooit een fact check, gewoon op naar het volgende stuk clickbait over het boosaardige Israël.
VRT NWS
@vrtnws
Israëlische minister Ben-Gvir wil elke nacht 30 à 40 Gazanen doden: "Ze moeten niet leven, het zijn geen mensen"
www.vrt.be/vrtnws/nl/2026/08/17/ben-gvir-israel-uitsprake… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hey @BBCNews, this what an actual "witch hunt" looks like: a mob in the town square whipping up hatred against a single individual. By contrast, documenting the fraud of a famous professor at a prestigious university is usually called "journalism."
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
There is an anti-Cofnas hate rally in Trafalgar Square with ~15,000 attendees. If I were in London there is a real possibility that I would be murdered.
1000s of academics & journalists knew the truth about Jason Arday for more than a year. Now you know why no one said anything.
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
London — I’m at the memorial attended by thousands of DEI supporters and leftist radicals for disgraced academic and serial hoaxer Jason Arday. The speakers repeatedly target academic @nathancofnas for breaking the story about Arday’s plagiarism.
Labour MP Diane Abbott was one of the speakers who smeared Cofnas.
Arday k—lled himself after journalists revealed he had lied about his academic work and purported major life accomplishments. He delayed the truth by siccing police and lawyers on journalists early on.
Support my journalism at www.ngocomment.com -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is such a tragic story. Jason Arday was indeed a victim of racism — not from the media who scrutinized his record, but from @Cambridge_Uni administrators and every institution and academic that enabled this deeply troubled con man, lowered the bar for him, elevated him to dizzying heights, and paraded him as proof of their own virtue, all because he happened to have the "right" skin color (and alleged neurodivergence).
The @nytimes story is surprisingly good, holding Cambridge to account for the perverse role they played in all of this.
www.nytimes.com/2026/08/15/world/europe/jason-arday-cambr… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Niets zo treurig om te zien als "progressieven" die zich tegen de ene technologie na de andere keren: hier airconditoining, datacenters, AI. (En eerder kernenergie, schaliegas, GGO's, plastics). "Progressief" is het nieuwe regressief. En die haat voor "techbro's" wordt echt zorgwekkend. www.demorgen.be/meningen/de-techjongens-en-de-fossiele-in…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Checks out! We need a new “progressive” movement that actually lives up to its name—not the regressive, race-obsessed, technophobic, anti-growth movement that has appropriated the label.
maartenboudry.substack.com/p/when-progressives-gave-up-on…
John Aziz
@aziz0nomics
The term "progressive" should belong to people who actually believe in technological and material progress, not to people who believe in regressive ideas like segregation, racial quotas, and Soviet-style-socialism.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I've already replaced my proofreader, my accountant and my legal advisor with AI. Am I next in line? Maybe. But when a chatbot spits out your "think pieces", there's nobody home — no author to argue with, no one answerable for a word of it. And writing is thinking: if you outsource that to AI, your brain will gradually shrivel.
A techno-optimist case for the human writer, in @Quillette:
quillette.com/2026/08/11/show-us-the-prompts-chatgpt-clau… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
An AI hallucinated a fake Einstein quote for my rector's inaugural speech. Thomas Piketty & co published a manifesto in The Guardian that Pangram flagged as 100% AI-generated. If you don't mind being ventriloquized by a machine, why not show us your prompts?
My new essay on digital ghostwriters for @Quillette — lightly polished by Claude (and by Quillette's own very human Jamie Palmer).
quillette.com/2026/08/11/show-us-the-prompts-chatgpt-clau… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
All of these organizations (@amnesty @hrw @MSF) have blood on their hands, and none will ever receive another euro from me unless they radically clean up their stables. (They don’t care—they know they receive far more dosh for being virulently anti-Israel than they stand to lose.)
The brave @DanielleHaas01 in @Quillette.
"In a since-deleted tweet, @amnesty staffer Veronica Koman posted “My respect to Yahya Sinwar… Legend!” on X. Incoming @amnestyusa board member Rasha Abdel Latif reposted content praising an attack on civilians in Tel Aviv, alongside a cartoon of a hand shaped like Israel flicking away a Star of David with the words: “It’s either us—or us.” When staff raised concerns, a manager told them no action would be taken, saying the post reflected Abdel Latif’s “pain.”
"Fadi Al-Wadiya, a physiotherapist working for Doctors Without Borders (@MSF), was identified by Israel in 2024 as a “significant operative” of Palestinian Islamic Jihad. MSF rejected the allegation, saying it had “no indication” of any military activity. In 2024, PIJ claimed Al-Wadiya as a member after he was killed in an Israeli strike."
"Shawan Jabarin, convicted by an Israeli court of membership and recruitment for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine—a group involved in suicide bombings, plane hijackings, and the 7 October massacre—served on @HRW's Middle East and North Africa Division Advisory Committee."
quillette.com/2026/08/11/jk-rowling-vs-amnesty-internatio… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I got eight now, up from seven!😉 Soon in a proper academic journal. quillette.com/2024/01/26/the-seven-laws-of-pessimism/
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
True. Without @nathancofnas, the fraudster Jason Arday would still have his plush Professorial Chair at @Cambridge_Uni and continue to mismanage students and disgrace his field, and everyone would still be fawning over him.
The academic mob who has doggedly tried to exclude and cancel Cofnas wherever he goes has inadvertently demonstrated exactly why academia desperately needs heterodox gadflies like him.
Multiple academics had their suspicions about Arday, but virtually none of them dared to voice them openly, for fear of being smeared as racist or being stalked by litigation firms. And the rest were just too ideologically blinkered (or stupid) to notice anything.
Amazingly, legacy media are not only extremely reluctant to acknowledge Cofnas’s role in exposing this scandal, but some of them (@nytimes) are even harsher on the whistleblower than they are on the fraudster himself.
This is absurd. Yes, Cofnas has controversial views, but he is prepared to defend with arguments and research, and in perfectly lucid prose. He’s not a fraud or a plagiarist, and I have yet to catch him lying about anything.
Great piece by @AndrewHammel1 in @Quillette. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This from @AndrewHammel1 is absolutely true. Without @nathancofnas, the fraudster Jason Arday would still have his plush jo and continue to mismanage students and disgrace his field, and everyone would still be fawning over him.
The academic mob who has doggedly tried to exclude and cancel Cofnas wherever he goes has inadvertently demonstrated exactly why academia desperately needs heterodox gadflies like him.
Multiple academics had their suspicions about Arday, but virtually none of them dared to voice them openly, for fear of being smeared as racist or being stalked by litigation firms. And the rest were just too ideologically blinkered (or stupid) to notice anything.
Amazingly, legacy media are not only extremely reluctant to acknowledge Cofnas’s role in exposing this scandal, but some of them (@nytimes) are even harsher on the whistleblower than they are on the fraudster himself.
This is absurd. Yes, Cofnas has controversial views, but he is prepared to defend with arguments and research, and in perfectly lucid prose. He’s not a fraud or a plagiarist, and I have yet to catch him lying about anything.
"While other academics praised the emperor’s new clothes, or observed a culpable silence, Cofnas decided to check whether or not the rumours about Arday’s academic fraud had any basis in fact. Doing so involved running Arday’s dissertation through an online plagiarism checker called Copyleaks. This five-minute task appears to have been beyond not only Arday’s dissertation supervisors, but any of the hundreds of academics who have worked with, supported, recommended, or bestowed degrees and awards on him since 2015."
"Cofnas’s act took considerable courage. Not only did he defy the entire British educational establishment but he also invited the hostile scrutiny of London libel lawyers and perhaps even the police. His decision to pull the plug on Arday has humiliated hundreds of his fellow academics. Yet in much of the reporting about the Arday affair, Cofnas’s contribution is either being ignored or he is being smeared as a racist."
quillette.com/2026/08/07/the-tip-of-the-iceberg-cambridge… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In de klassieke media komt de zoveelste diepgroene onheilsprofeet nog eens dezelfde reactionaire preek afsteken tegen de moderniteit en het Westen, met dezelfde softbalvraagjes (ik noem geen namen). Maar een tegendraadse en heterodoxe filosoof als @FilipBuekens interviewen? Ho maar! Het beste interview van de week (mogelijk de maand) staat in @DoorbraakBE.
Buekens is ook één van de enige die zijn nek durft uitsteken over Israël en Gaza. Natuurlijk, hij is met emeritaat, dus hij heeft "zero fucks to give", maar ik ken academici die hun werkelijke standpunt over Gaza zelfs ná hun emeritaat niet durven delen: de sociale kosten liggen te hoog.
doorbraak.be/filip-buekens-radicale-ideen-gaan-over-aanda… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The more I read about this affair, the more disgusted I am by @simonschuster, @Cambridge_Uni, and every other institutions that exploited Jason Arday as a mascot for signalling their own virtue. All along, Simon & Schuster was sitting on internal evidence that Arday was a pathological fabulist, without any need for fact-checking. All they had to do was compare the original book proposal with the final manuscript and notice that the confabulations were entirely different and contradictory:
- In the proposal, he spends months in a coma after being hit by a car. Doctors recommend unplugging his life support, yet he remains conscious throughout, trapped in "locked-in syndrome," before miraculously awakening. The published book mentions NONE of this, nor the full year he supposedly spent "relearning everything—how to walk, to talk." Instead, the memoir tells an uneventful year of finishing secondary school and taking exams. Are you f*cking kidding me, @simonschuster?
- The "testicular cancer" in the proposal somehow transmogrifies into "two brain tumors" in the finished manuscript. Another medical miracle.
- The chronology of his dramatic suicide attempt—standing on a bridge before being saved by an Eagles song—changes completely. In one version it happens during the pandemic; in another, before it.
- The elderly "shaman woman" who predicts his meteoric rise during his (non-existent) trip to Brazil with WaterAid suddenly turns into an aid worker in her 30s. A woman with truly magical powers.
Despite knowing all this, @simonschuster cynically forged ahead with publication, because they thought they could make big bucks out of this "near-mythic" (dixit his agent) story, and flaunt their own virtue.
Pull this book off the shelves, @simonschuster, and stop humiliating this very troubled man.
The Atlantic's investigation is devastating:
www.theatlantic.com/books/2026/08/jason-arday-cambridge-a…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Bets are closed. I hadn't realized the U.S. release is scheduled for just four days from now (Aug 11), which means the book has almost certainly already been printed, shipped, and distributed. At this stage, withdrawing it would be extraordinarily costly for Simon & Schuster. But what are they going to do? As things stand, they'll be a complete laughing stock—or worse. The words "Cambridge professor" appear on the cover and throughout the promotional material, while the fawning blurbs are now deeply embarrassing for whoever wrote them.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Bets are closed. I hadn't realized the U.S. release is scheduled for just four days from now (Aug 11), which means the book has almost certainly already been printed, shipped, and distributed. At this stage, withdrawing it would be extraordinarily costly for Simon & Schuster. But what are they going to do? As things stand, they'll be a complete laughing stock—or worse. The words "Cambridge professor" appear on the cover and throughout the promotional material, while the fawning blurbs are now deeply embarrassing for whoever wrote them.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
It was inevitable that Jason Arday would be forced to resign from @Cambridge_Uni. But this was never about him. In fact, he has been a godsend, providing living evidence of the unbelievable level of corruption and sheer stupidity that has infected elite institutions.
Cambridge can't just turn the page and pretend that nothing happened, or that Arday was just one bad apple. If an apple so visibly worm-eaten can be elevated to the very top of the profession without anyone bothering to inspect it, that tells you more about the "basket" than about that particular apple.
There must be accountability. If universities ever want to win back the trust of the public, other heads must roll. Take Prof. @HilaryCremin, Head of Faculty at @Cambridge_Uni and Arday's direct boss, who had this to say about the guy:
"The board of electors on your interview were absolutely unanimous: we are so lucky to have you. You are the best in the world in terms of the research that you do."
And after evidence of plagiarism came to light:
"[W]e remain immensely proud of Prof Arday's achievements and scholarship, and... he has our full support. [...] During our meeting Prof Arday spoke movingly about his ongoing experiences of direct and indirect racism."
She's not the only one, as her comment about "unanimity of the board" shows. Legions of distinguished academics have been fawning over Arday for years, despite the abysmal quality of his work. Worse still, thousands have signed an open letter expressing their "unwavering support" for Arday and accusing his critics of "racism," after the evidence of his serial fraud and plagiarism had already come to light (including serious scholars like @sbaroncohen).
For Arday to become the youngest Black professor ever at one of the most prestigious universities in the world, literally hundreds of administrators, editors, mentors and colleagues must have turned a blind eye to the evidence of intellectual mediocrity and fraud, selecting him over genuinely qualified and talented scholars (including Black ones who didn't toe their ideological DEI line about "institutional racism" and all the usual nonsense).
The unsettling truth is that universities are full of Jason Ardays. Most are simply a little more subtle in their deception and chicanery. A little less obviously rotten.
faculty.educ.cam.ac.uk/people/staff/creminThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Deze jonge journaliste bij @destandaard snapt al helemaal hoe het werkt: als je een heel stuk wijdt aan de stijging van geweld tegen LGBTI's, moet je natuurlijk zorgvuldig vermijden de olifant in de kamer te benoemen. Nergens in dit hele stuk vallen woorden als "migratie", "jihadisme", "islam" of zelfs "religie". Alleen de diagnose dat "onze samenleving steeds intoleranter" wordt. Bizar!
Wel krijg je het gebruikelijke geleuter over "algoritmes" en de radicalisering van "jongeren". En de oplossingen (via Çavaria)? "Interne diversiteitsacties bij Infrabel en de NMBS" en "een protocol voor de medische zorg van intersekse personen". De redding is nabij.
Geen idee of dit voortkomt uit een oprechte overtuiging of uit een succesvolle socialisatie binnen de eigen groep, maar dit is volstrekt hopeloos. Journalisten schrijven steeds vaker voor elkaar, hunkerend naar schouderklopjes van collega's, veilig in hun eigen echokamer. Er is bovendien nauwelijks competitie in Vlaanderen: de "kwaliteitskranten" zijn vrijwel allemaal even woke.
Hetzelfde geldt natuurlijk voor @cavariavzw, dat deel uitmaakt van hetzelfde ecosysteem. En voor de studiedienst van de VRT, die wegkeek van onwelgevallige bevindingen over migratie en homohaat. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"One has to belong to the intelligentsia to believe things like that: no ordinary man could be such a fool."
George Orwell
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/08/04/jason-arday-cambridge… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What Did You Think It Meant?
Decolonization from Seminar Room to Massacre.
If you'd rather listen to my @Quillette essay than read it—and enjoy some great visuals along the way—here's your chance:
youtube.com/watch?v=f_pZb2dZjug -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
There's no point in further belaboring the fact that Jason Arday is a rampant plagiarist, an incompetent scholar, and a pathological liar. (If you've lost @guardian, it's over.) Arday obviously needs help and should never have been placed in this position.
Far more damning for academia—and genuinely baffling to me—is the legion of academics who rushed to express their "unwavering support" for Arday over the past few days, dismissing the allegations as "baseless" and "entirely false", while impugning the motives of anyone who dared criticize his fabrications as "racist." (The massive irony, of course, is that they are judging Arday's work by the "color of his skin" rather than by its merits.)
How do you watch this train wreck play out and conclude, "Hmm, this seems like a good moment to jump aboard"? How can you be so willing to ruin your own reputation alongside Arday's? That open letter from @GoodLawProject will now circulate forever. Even a distinguished scholar like @sbaroncohen couldn't resist signing it.
This is genuinely baffling. How detached from reality, how ideologically blinkered, how self-righteous do you have to be to engage in this kind of reputational self-immolation? It points to a far deeper rot in academia than the case of one pathetic fraud.
Good Law Project
@GoodLawProject
Jason Arday is the youngest Black professor in Cambridge’s history – and now rightwing newspapers are trying to smear him with untrue accusations of plagiarism.
Not on our watch. Add your name in solidarity with Jason here: goodlaw.social/sktjThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The Guardian's damning revelations (in spite of themselves, as they tried really hard to rescue him in the opening paragraphs). /2
www.theguardian.com/education/ng-interactive/2026/aug/01/… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Good news! For the first time in at least 25 years (and perhaps in all of human history?), more than half of global billionaire wealth is now held by self-made entrepreneurs who earned their fortunes through competitive market activities, i.e. the rest of us buying their products (and getting richer in the process ourselves). No inherited dynasties, no plunder or expropriation, no dumb luck (though every billionaire's story contains at least some of that).
Analysis by @economist.
www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2026/07/23/the-ri… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I never liked Christopher Nolan's recurring trope of the subdued, tormented, traumatized, guilt-ridden hero. It runs through virtually all of his films, including the overrated, self-serious Batman trilogy. It was already grating in Oppenheimer—though at least Oppenheimer himself indulged in that kind of self-mythologizing ("Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds").
But projecting this psychological template onto Homer's Odysseus, who pillages, slaughters, and philanders with scarcely a hint of remorse, is simply preposterous.
Yes, the film is visually stunning, but I frequently found myself rolling my eyes so hard they almost left the giant IMAX screen.
Great review by @DAMendelsohnNYC in @nybooks:
"As this resounding speech echoed in my ears, it occurred to me that it sounds nothing like the heroes of Homer—who, after all, gleefully vaunt over the mutilated bodies of their slaughtered enemies—but a lot like the heroes of Christopher Nolan movies. This tormented, guilt-ridden Odysseus, stripped of humor and wit, seductiveness and cleverness, is a sibling of Memento’s anguished amnesiac, of Batman, of Oppenheimer, men tormented by pasts they wrestle with in different ways."
archive.ph/sPO0n -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nobody really cares about the Palestinians: not their fellow Arab states, not Netanyahu and his ilk, not Western governments, not the countless NGOs spending billions—and least of all the self-described "pro-Palestinian" activists, who exploit Palestinian suffering primarily as a vehicle for demonizing Israel and the West. In acting out their own ideological psychodrama, they reward and encourage precisely the kind of behavior (from Palestinians) that will never produce a Palestinian state and will never improve the lives of ordinary Palestinians.
Royee Zvi Atadgy in @Quillette.
"Imagine that rather than encouraging Palestinians to fight, rather than engaging in pedantic word games, rather than crafting new cartoonish libels against Israel, the movement instead encouraged non-violence, diplomacy and Hamas's ouster—and demanded that the Palestinian public reject rejection itself: that intractable posture which has dimmed the dream of statehood while inflaming the rhetoric and violence that no other country in the world would tolerate, let alone reward with a state."
quillette.com/2026/07/29/is-the-pro-palestine-movement-is… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Het siert @demorgen dat ze mijn scherpe lezersbrief over het antisemitisme van Frans Timmermans (@F__Timmermans) hebben geplaatst. Sommige andere kranten zijn minder open van geest. 😉
Plat op de buik voor het groeiende antisemitisme ter linkerzijde
"Met verbijstering las ik het interview met Frans Timmermans (DM 25/7), waarin hij Israël gelijkstelt aan nazi-Duitsland en beweert dat “de Joden” in Gaza “precies hetzelfde” doen als de nazi’s tijdens de Holocaust.
Dit is de vulgairste vorm van Holocaust-omkering, die volgens de IHRA-definitie onder antisemitisme valt. Maar ook los van die definitie zou dat voor iedereen met een greintje historische kennis evident moeten zijn. Israël is een liberale en multi-etnische democratie; nazi-Duitsland was het meest kwaadaardige regime uit de moderne geschiedenis. Die twee met elkaar gelijkstellen is grotesk en verwerpelijk.
Twintig procent van de Israëlische bevolking bestaat uit Arabische moslims met gelijke burgerrechten. Duizenden van hen dienen in het Israëlische leger en vechten mee in Gaza. Werken zij dan mee aan hun eigen “genocide”? Alleen al die vaststelling toont de absurditeit van Timmermans’ vergelijking.
Frans Timmermans is geen idioot. Hij weet ongetwijfeld beter. Des te kwalijker is het dat hij plat op zijn buik gaat voor het groeiende antisemitisme ter linkerzijde, waar “Israëliërs zijn de nieuwe nazi’s” is uitgegroeid tot dogma. Dat een voormalig vicevoorzitter van de Europese Commissie en voormalig minister van Buitenlandse Zaken zich tot dergelijke retoriek verlaagt, is ronduit beschamend.
Als Timmermans nog een greintje zelfrespect heeft, biedt hij zijn excuses aan de Joodse gemeenschap aan." -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Meet the Watermelons🍉:
"- Big, strong, and unabashedly green on the outside
- Very red on the inside, with little substance
- Seeds of black in their heart"
#misanthropy
unchartedterritories.tomaspueyo.com/p/watermelons?publica… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Het blijft gissen naar de oorzaken [van homohaat en geweld]. Heeft het te maken met de giftige manosfeer die via de sociale media wordt verspreid? Of is het een gevolg van de beleden religie, met de islam als belangrijkste boosdoener?"
Je moet je inbeelden wat voor heroïsche krachtinspanning het @brinckie moet hebben gekost om helemaal op het einde even het woord "islam" over zijn lippen te krijgen, na eerst wat obligaat gemekker over de "manosfeer". En dat door de eindredactie van @destandaard te krijgen!
Zo uitputtend dat hij meteen weer in de kramp schiet: "Een islamistisch exces zoals bij de Berlijnse Pride mag niet worden veralgemeend." En ook nog: "De LGBTI-gemeenschap mag nog altijd optimistisch zijn."
Juist. Er is net iemand met een auto ingereden op hun Pride, en virulente homohaat wordt nog steeds volop geïmporteerd in heel Europa, maar vergeet nooit, beste LGBTI'ers: deze "progressieve" krant got your back. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Every time you think academia has hit rock bottom, you read something like this, from the prestigious @Cambridge_Uni. If you'll excuse me now, I need to go pick my jaw up off the floor.
(Please bracket whatever you think about @nathancofnas and his views on IQ & race, which are irrelevant here).
ncofnas.com/p/dei-fraud-and-cover-up-at-cambridge?r=g844x… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
On the gradual (and very recent) invention of the "Palestinian" identity:
"When the PLO was founded in 1964, Israel didn’t control the West Bank or Gaza. Jordan controlled the West Bank and Egypt controlled Gaza. Because of this, the original 1964 Palestine Liberation Organization Charter disclaimed those territories. Article 24 of the charter states that it “does not exercise any territorial sovereignty over the West Bank in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, on the Gaza Strip or in the Himmah Area. Their only goal in 1964 was the destruction of Israel. It was only after Israel captured the West Bank and Gaza in 1967 that the Palestine Liberation Organization suddenly rewrote their charter in 1968. Only then did they claim those exact territories as the historic Palestinian homeland."
www.futureofjewish.com/p/jews-were-the-original-palestini… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Israel is living rent-free in millions of people's heads who have never been there and know hardly anything about it apart from some propagandistic slogans and memes. That's the real "occupation" that must end.
"Condemning Israel is cheap virtue. It costs the activist nothing. No sacrifice is required, nor is any tyrant confronted. No dangerous ideology need be named, nor any minority within one’s own society challenged.
Israel is the perfect object of Western moral aggression because it is powerful enough to blame and civilised enough to tolerate the blame. This is the essential arrangement. The activist can denounce a state as genocidal while relying upon the liberal order that allows the denunciation. The academic can compare Israel to the Nazis without fearing that Israeli agents will arrive at dawn. The politician can threaten sanctions, knowing that Israeli trade, diplomacy and institutional restraint will continue.
Israel is treated as uniquely monstrous partly because it is uniquely safe to abuse. The genuinely monstrous are less convenient."
www.futureofjewish.com/p/the-israeli-occupation-that-must… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"When a Hutu movement embarked on violent revolution in 1959, it framed the Tutsi minority as proxy Europeans who didn’t belong in Rwanda. This belief had a name and a pedigree: the Hamitic hypothesis, a colonial-era theory that held that Africa’s advanced civilizations were the work of outside invaders. It cast the Tutsis as a quasi-European race that had migrated south from the Nile or Arabia, and the idea remained potent."
This remarkable parallel was completely new information to me. Great piece by @adam_louis52328.
archive.ph/ox95h -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wat Frans Timmermans (@F__Timmermans) hier uitkraamt, is werkelijk weerzinwekkend. Hij stelt Israël (een liberale en multi-etnische democratie) gelijk aan Nazi-Duitsland (het kwaadaardigste regime uit de geschiedenis) en beweert dat "de Joden" in Gaza "precies hetzelfde" (!) doen als tijdens de Holocaust.
Dit is de meest vulgaire vorm van Holocaust-omkering, wat volgens de IHRA-definitie antisemitisch is — en dat zou ook voor iedereen met een greintje historische kennis evident moeten zijn.
Twintig procent van de Israëli's is Arabische moslim, met gelijke burgerrechten. Duizenden van hen dienen in het IDF en vechten mee in Gaza. Werken zij dan mee aan hun eigen genocide of zo?
Timmermans is geen idioot; natuurlijk weet hij beter. Hij gaat gewoon plan op zijn buik voor het groeiende antisemitisme ter linkerzijde, waar "Israëli's = nazi's" is uitgegroeid tot dogma. Je hebt de verkiezingen al verloren, Frans. Het heeft geen zin om jezelf zo te verlagen.
Als @F__Timmermans nog een greintje zelfrespect heeft, biedt hij zijn excuses aan de Joodse gemeenschap aan.
Daarom zou ik als progressief nooit op iemand als Timmermans kunnen stemmen. Ik ben heel blij dat hij niet tot premier van Nederland is gekozen, los van mijn meningsverschillen over klimaatbeleid.
"In het Midden-Oosten wordt momenteel een heel volk uitgeroeid. We kijken ernaar en we zwijgen, terwijl de Palestijnen letterlijk in zee worden gedreven – en erger. De redenering van rechts en extreemrechts in Israël is: wij Joden kunnen alleen maar overleven als de Palestijnen weg zijn. Dat is exact dezelfde redenering als die van de nazi’s destijds: wij – het Duitse volk, het Arische ras – kunnen alleen maar overleven als de Joden weg zijn. Dat vind ik ronduit verbijsterend. Hun grootouders en overgrootouders is in de nazitijd iets verschrikkelijks overkomen: de Holocaust, waarbij ze werden vernietigd, en nu doen zij precies hetzelfde met een ander volk." -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hamas was planning a "second October 7th" in Europe. Investigators uncovered coordinated terror cells across Greece, Germany, Austria and beyond: smuggling weapons, scouting targets, preparing coordinated strikes.
It makes you wonder how many of those deluded academics and activists would still be celebrating their brave Palestinian "resistance fighters". 🍉As Martin Amis once said: "They are up the arse of those who want them dead".
archive.ph/8VcC6 -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Civilizational parasitism: the EU makes more money from fining US tech companies than from taxing its own public tech companies.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A devastating review of @bartov_omer's new book by fellow historian and genocide scholar Benny Morris. But why should Bartov care that his arguments have been dismantled with evidence and historical analysis in a small magazine like @Quillette? In any event, he is destined for another round of "moral striptease" (@MattiFriedman) across the globe, as liberal elites celebrate him as the Repentant Jew ("See, even Israelis admit it now!")
Some highlights:
"For Bartov, absurdly, the Arabs play no role in Zionism’s bad turn. In fact, in Israel: What Went Wrong? the Arabs are not really present. There is no Palestinian Arab terrorism bedevilling the Zionist enterprise almost since birth; there are no Palestinian pogroms (1920, 1921, 1929, 1936–1939); no Palestinian or other Arab-initiated wars (1948, 1967, 1973); no constant Palestinian rejection of the successive compromises tabled by international actors and/or the Zionists/Israel (the two-state proposals of the Peel Commission (1937) and of the UN General Assembly (1947); the peace settlements proposed by Israeli Premier Ehud Barak and US President Bill Clinton (2000), and by Prime Minister Ehud Olmert (2007–2008)); and the Palestinians’ rejection of Jewish sovereignty in any inch of Palestine starting with Nazi collaborator Haj Amin al Husseini and ending with Hamas and Islamic Jihad. Nowhere does Bartov explain that this rejectionism, repeatedly exploding in massive bloodshed, gradually drove Zionists and Israelis to despair, eroded the Israelis’ willingness to compromise, and, ultimately, generated the current Jewish extremism."
"What happened during the IDF counter-offensive in Gaza’s streets—it was a war—was so unlike “genocide” that even a casual reader of genocide literature, say about the Holocaust or the Turkish Muslim massacre of Asia Minor’s Christian communities during 1894–1924, could not avoid noticing the stark differences."
"Actual genocides pan out differently. In the Holocaust, Germans and their helpers across Europe raided houses and districts, rounded up Jews, shot some on the spot and herded the rest into cattle cars, imprisoned them in ghettoes where they died of disease and hunger, or ferried them directly to woods and camps where they were shot or gassed, man, woman and child. Similarly, the Muslim Turks who murdered up to a million Armenians in 1915–16 in Asia Minor and the Syrian and Iraqi deserts did not warn their intended victims to flee. They rounded them up, shot dead the able-bodied males, and sent the women, children and elderly on death marches into the mountains and deserts, where most died."
quillette.com/2026/07/20/omer-bartov-what-went-wrong/ -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Devastating review of @bartov_omer's new book by fellow historian and genocide scholar Benny Morris. But why should Bartov care that his arguments have been dismantled with evidence and historical analysis in a small magazine like @Quillettte? He is destined for yet another round of "moral striptease" (@MattiFriedman) across the global the world, as liberal elites celebrate him as another Repentant Jew ("See, even Israelis admit it now!")
"What happened during the IDF counter-offensive in Gaza’s streets—it was a war—was so unlike “genocide” that even a casual reader of genocide literature, say about the Holocaust or the Turkish Muslim massacre of Asia Minor’s Christian communities during 1894–1924, could not avoid noticing the stark differences."
"Actual genocides pan out differently. In the Holocaust, Germans and their helpers across Europe raided houses and districts, rounded up Jews, shot some on the spot and herded the rest into cattle cars, imprisoned them in ghettoes where they died of disease and hunger, or ferried them directly to woods and camps where they were shot or gassed, man, woman and child. Similarly, the Muslim Turks who murdered up to a million Armenians in 1915–16 in Asia Minor and the Syrian and Iraqi deserts did not warn their intended victims to flee. They rounded them up, shot dead the able-bodied males, and sent the women, children and elderly on death marches into the mountains and deserts, where most died."
quillette.com/2026/07/20/omer-bartov-what-went-wrong/ -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Having seen the infamous 47-minute compilation of the 7 Oct atrocities with my own eyes (not publicly available), I can attest that the Silenced No More report, which is freely available online, is even worse. It's just words on a page, but it leaves enough to the imagination to be even more horrific than the video. At least for me.
In the 47-minute compilation, there is some evidence of sexual sadism, but not much. Probably for two reasons: proud though Hamas was of massacring Jews, they were less keen on broadcasting scenes of sexual depravity. And the Israeli government likely declined to include the most horrific footage out of respect for the victims.
The report is exhaustively documented, horror story after horror story. I've read it only once, and I won't do so again. Especially the sections about the Nova festival are extremely disturbing. So I asked Claude to summarize the documented patterns in the report:
- Rape and gang rape, with victims passed between attackers in sequence, witnesses describing laughter throughout
- Targeted gunshots to groin, abdomen, buttocks and face; genital mutilation of both women and men
- Rape followed by execution—victims shot or stabbed immediately afterward, some shot in the head during the assault
- Rape continuing after victims were dead
- Sexual mutilation—breasts severed, genitals cut off or shot
- Burning, including deliberate burning of the groin; bodies set alight with accelerants
- - Hands bound behind backs; bodies tied to trees and poles along the road
- Sharp objects inserted into victims' genitals
- Women raped in view of their desperate partners, who were then killed
- Male victims gang-raped, beaten, and threatened with castration
- Dismemberment and decapitation
These findings of systematic sexual violence and torture are corroborated by the UN Special Representative on Sexual Violence in Conflict (2024) and the UN Commission of Inquiry (2024).
Just one quote from a survivor:
"I heard one rape where they were passing her around. She was probably injured, judging by her screams—screams you have never heard anywhere. It's between silence and screams, between pain and wanting to die. These are screams... it's something I have never heard in my life, and I have no way to explain to you what it sounds like. But it's screams. It's screams. It was simply horrific. And after one finished, he told another to go up 'Ta'al' [in Arabic], like to the next one. And apparently there was a round... And after they finished, they shot her." She continued: "You hear the screams, and then you hear silence. You hear a bang—and silence. And then there's a kind of calm. And then you say: okay, it's over at least. She's done with it. And like that with each person they abused—you heard. The moment they were killed, I said, 'Oh my God, finally, it's over.'"
You privileged Westerners have no idea how you would react if this happened to you and your loved ones—if a group committed these atrocities, vowed to repeat them again and again, and openly declared that it would not stop until your country no longer existed. You have no idea.
civilc.org/silenced-no-more
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A while ago, I watched the infamous 47-minute video documenting the atrocities of October 7th — the one not made publicly available, to protect the privacy of the victims.
The worst part of this video is not what it displays, but who is displaying it: the perpetrators themselves. Gleefully. Sadistically. Unabashedly. Most of the footage was filmed by Hamas terrorists on their GoPro bodycams, some also by ordinary Gazan civilians on their cellphones.
Even the Nazis tried to cover up their atrocities, but Hamas brags about theirs for the entire world to see. The killers are euphoric throughout the massacre, and their relentless, ecstatic cries of "Allahu Akbar" (punctuated by the occasional "Kill the Jew!") are simply nauseating.
Some images are seared into my memory forever. I will never forget the two boys in their underwear — one with his eye socket hanging out of his face — asking his brother whether he thinks they're going to die, while the Hamas monster who had just thrown a grenade in their saferoom helps himself to a drink from their fridge, taking a casual break from the slaughter.
Neither will I ever forget the terrorists playing football with a severed head. Or the Thai migrant worker whose head is viciously hacked off with a garden hoe — another "Zionist colonizer" getting what he deserved, right?quillette.substack.com/p/what-did-you-think-decolonisation
Or the throngs of Gazans crowding around pickup trucks loaded with the mutilated corpses of Jewish women, filming and spitting on the bodies. Or the woman in Kibbutz Mefalsim, crouching and begging in vain for mercy.
There is some evidence of sexual violence in the video — the charred corpse of a young woman with her legs splayed and her genitals exposed — but not much. Apparently even Hamas draws a line somewhere: they are not as proud of raping Jewish women as they are of murdering them. Or, more likely, they simply didn't want to embarrass the delicate sensibilities of their legions of useful idiots in the West.
But yes — there was rape. Not "rape" in scare quotes, as the apologists would have it, but sadistic, murderous sexual violence, documented in a new damning new report by The Civil Commission, an independent Israeli women's rights NGO. (video summary here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=K7fJuzr4wkU)
Across its 180 pages, the report describes "a recurring pattern of rape and gang rape; sexual torture; mutilation; targeted shooting to the face, head and genital area; forced nudity; binding and restraint; genital burning; objects inserted into intimate areas; post-mortem sexual humiliation; and execution during or after sexual assault."
And it was premeditated and organized. The terrorists crossing into Israel carried printed Arabic-to-Hebrew phrasebooks with handy expressions like "take off your pants," "lie down," "spread your legs," and "don't make trouble." I wonder why they expected to need those particular phrases?
I know one thing: no civilized country on earth would tolerate the existence of an organization like Hamas on its border after October 7th. Not one. This includes every self-righteous Westerner currently lecturing Israel from thousands of kilometres away, without an inch of skin in the game.
www.dailymail.com/news/article-15807431/Full-depravity-Ha… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What Are You Afraid Of?
Jews and Muslim dissidents have real reasons to be afraid. The rest of us mostly have friends and careers to lose.
What exactly are people afraid of when they stay silent about what they really think of the Gaza war, and about Israel more generally? The Romanian-Swedish MEP @alicemedce asked that question rhetorically at a conference in Brussels last month, after I had spoken about the academic colleagues and friends who discreetly email me to express their support but would never do so in public. (Alice herself is completely fearless.)
Physical threats
If you are Jewish yourself, of course you have plenty to be afraid of. I hope I don’t need to remind you of the draconian safety measures Jews now have to take all across Europe. This was already the case long before 7 October, but it has intensified since. Jewish schools, synagogues and kindergartens look like military fortresses.
Jews are being pushed out of academia and civic life unless they prostrate themselves before the activist mob and ritually denounce Israel — the one country that can realistically protect them against exactly this sort of antisemitism. Many Jewish academics have been boycotted or hounded off campus, or have left academia altogether in a mixture of despair and disgust.
All across the West, as Hana Raviyt Schank wrote in Future of Jewish, Jews are being “pushed out of civic life” — taking their surnames off mailboxes, changing their names on delivery apps, removing the mezuzah from the doorpost. If even a tenth of this were happening to Muslim minorities, you’d never hear the end of it. But since it is only Jews, hardly anyone cares.
Muslim and Arab dissidents are another group that is physically targeted. I recently met @NoraBussigny (pictured in the middle), a French-Moroccan journalist who infiltrated the anti-Israel movement at great personal risk and exposed its hatred and violence.
We were interviewed together by @wsachs and @NimrodErez23 (also in the picture) for a documentary about rising antisemitism and anti-Zionism, a sequel to their shocking October 8.
Because her mother is a Moroccan Muslim, Nora is considered a traitor who dishonors the community. She now requires police protection whenever she speaks in public. You can read her remarkable story in her gripping book Les Nouveaux Antisémites, hopefully to be translated soon, or in this excerpt in The Free Press.
Social consequences
But what are regular—goyim—academics and public intellectuals afraid of? No secret police is going to drag them out of bed in the middle of the night, and nobody is going to slip polonium into their tea.
[Read the rest below of my piece below] -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Few things have shocked me more than the open acquiescence—or even outright support—of the international "humanitarian" community for Egypt's decision to seal, and even reinforce, its heavily fortified border with Gaza throughout the war.
Early on, Israel tried to negotiate with Egypt to allow Gazan civilians out of harm's way so it could target Hamas more effectively. The international "humanitarian" community reacted with outrage to the very suggestion. Meanwhile, Egypt threatened to tear up its peace treaty with Israel and declared that it was "ready to sacrifice millions of lives so that nobody would approach a grain of sand [in Sinai]."
You expect that kind of cynicism toward "fellow Arabs" from a corrupt and authoritarian regime. But from self-proclaimed Western "humanitarians"? Apparently, they'd rather keep Gazan civilians trapped in an active war zone, where Hamas could exploit them as human shields, because evacuation would supposedly amount to "ethnic cleansing."
And all this while they were hurling the obscene "genocide" libel at Israel. Because that's obviously how you would behave if you sincerely believed a genocide was taking place, right? Prevent people from escaping? It's either callousness, mendacity, or both.
By way of analogy, imagine that Poland had sealed its border with Ukraine after Russia's invasion in 2022, telling the world: "Why should we let in Ukrainian civilians? We don't want a bunch of Nazis in our country." Bad enough. Now imagine the "humanitarian" community supporting that stance—insisting that Poland bore no responsibility for Russia's aggression, and that admitting Ukrainians would amount to "ethnic cleansing" because Moscow might never allow them to return.
In this brilliant article, my good friend Shany Mor (@ShMMor) uses a series of clever thought experiments to expose the revealed preferences of the "humanitarians" in the Gaza war. The conclusions are deeply disturbing. They reveal an astonishing level of indifference—whether intentional or not—to the very people these organizations claim to care about. If they have to chose between helping Palestinians and demonizing Israel, they always choose the latter.
I will never, ever, ever donate to any of these organizations again—even though I supported many of them regularly in the past. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Geen erg: "witte" mannen bestaan toch niet, tenzij er toevallig veel albino's in het publiek zaten.
Deze blanke jongedame is een slordige vijf jaar te laat met haar idiotieën. Dit is zó 2020.
Niemand neemt je woke waanzin nog ernstig, Sophie. Het enige wat je ermee bereikt, is stemmen ronselen voor radicaal-rechts. Hoepel dus op, helemaal naar achteren, zo ver mogelijk.
En @StadGent zou zich moeten schamen dat het deze raciale segregatie subsidieert. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What exactly are people afraid of when they stay silent about what they really think of the Gaza war? No secret police is going to drag them out of bed in the middle of the night, and no one is going to slip polonium into their tea. I myself have never felt physically threatened because of my strong views on the conflict, with one or two exceptions (it's much worse for Jews, as well as for Muslim/Arab dissidents).
But that doesn't mean speaking out is free of consequences. To give you an idea, here's a sample of what I've experienced personally over the past two and a half years:
· A friend of mine, whom I once helped with one of his own books, now writes a steady stream of public posts about what a far-right, xenophobic, Arab-hating, Nazi-adjacent bigot I am.
· An academic colleague who kindly blurbed one of my earlier books emailed my rector behind my back to demand that disciplinary action be taken against me for my "zionist-tinged views".
· A friend whose book I once blurbed has successfully got me cancelled at an organization we're both associated with, and has also tried to get me fired at UGent because I'm the equivalent of a "Holocaust denialist" (no worries — I'd already left of my own accord).
· Someone I'd been close with for about two decades became a father without my knowing, because he had cut off all contact.
· Someone called my mother (!) to sternly demand an explanation for her son's behavior.
· A cordial colleague I'd had dinner with kicked me out of their philosophical discussion group, blocked me on every social media platform, and ignored my polite emails asking for a clarification.
· I've been deplatformed twice in academia — a talk and a debate — over my "Zionist views."
· The president of an organization I worked with smeared me as being "paid by the Zionist lobby", then blocked my Facebook accounts and email when I asked for a retraction.
· I've had to promise my girlfriend I won't talk about Israel on public television anymore, as she's afraid for my physical safety (she needn't worry: no TV program would be insane enough to invite me on that topic anyway).
· My closest friends stay loyal, but are under pressure from their own friends to disown me and break off contact.
· This is not even counting the long list of friends and colleagues I haven't heard from in a long while, or who have ignored my messages, where I only suspect—but can't prove—that my political views have something to do with it. It has made me slightly paranoid!
Yes, some of this stings. But don't worry — I still have plenty of good friends left. And perhaps I should be grateful to have discovered that these "friends" were never really friends in the first place.
I've also made plenty of new ones over the past two years, often people with similar (or much worse) stories of social ostracism.
Needless to say, I've also pretty much ruined my career prospects in academia. But that's fine — I still write the occasional academic paper as a self-employed writer, and at least I don't have to put up with the bureaucratic bullshit and the daily hostility.😉 -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
All those promises about "city greening" until Europoor reality hits.
Phase 1: "We are turning the Schuman Square in Brussels into a beautiful agora with a 'canopy' and green roof!"
Phase 2: "Shit, we don't have money. Let's just make a giant concrete baking sheet where people can fry some eggs." (And the Greens were even in the city council!)
I lived close to Schuman last year, and this place was already HORRIBLE in the summer heat. The only refuge I found was the lobby of the (evil American!) hotel chain Holiday Inn, 100 meters from the square. Where they ACTUALLY HAVE AIR CONDITIONING, like civilized people. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Is er iets bespottelijker (om niet te zeggen degoutanter) dan vanuit je parmantige palazzo in Genua pleiten voor collectieve verarming en de uitroeiing van ongelijkheid?
"Wij moeten er niet bang voor zijn om armer te worden, want armoede maakt niet ongelukkig. Alles is relatief. Het enige dat ongelukkig maakt, is armer zijn dan anderen."
Niemand houdt je tegen om 90% van je inkomen (verdiend dankzij kapitalisme) weg te schenken aan armoedebestrijding, Ilja.
Ook @demorgen maakt zich belachelijk door deze economisch ongeletterde schertsfiguur (maartenboudry.be/2024/01/kapitalisme-een-malicieus-complo…) naar voren te schuiven als een ernstige interviewer van Thomas Piketty -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In just two sentences, my friend Shany Mor (@ShMMor) captures the utter cluelessness of so much supposedly "learned" discourse about Israel's strategic predicament in both Gaza and the West Bank:
"Israel can neither continue to occupy the West Bank nor consider withdrawing from it—as it must do if it is to remain a Jewish state and a democratic one—without radically disincentivising any further operations like the 7 October massacre. An enormous amount of learned discourse over the last three years has pretended not to understand the importance of this war aim, while simultaneously demanding measures that would make it unachievable."
The real "problem"—in fact it is an extraordinary blessing—is that most liberal democracies in the West (with the notable exception of Ukraine) have not faced an existential military threat for more than eight decades. As a result, many have completely lost the ability to think about war in strategic terms: incentives, deterrence, trade-offs, military objectives.
It's not just antisemitism or hostility toward Israel. It's also just historical amnesia and the luxury of having zero skin in the game.
Shany's essay draws fascinating parallels with the 1956 Suez Crisis, exploring the double-edged nature of superpower involvement. Yet another reminder of why a @Quillette subscription is essential for understanding the world today.
quillette.com/2026/07/13/reshaping-the-middle-east-israel… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hilarious takedown of the world's most boring sport. It made me laugh out loud several times. I love @Quillette even more now. 😅
I don't think I've ever managed to sit through a soccer match while paying uninterrupted attention for more than ten minutes. I'm simply bored out of my skull. And the only thing more tedious than soccer is soccer commentary.
Still, I'll give Belgium's next match against Spain another chance. (I slept like a baby while they were pummeling the US—it was 2 a.m. here.)
That said, I'll happily concede one enormous point in soccer's favor: international football has probably done more to promote racial harmony and mutual understanding than all the NGO reports, political parties, diversity workshops, and media pundits combined.
Now on to the indictment (with some hyperbole, but that's what makes it funny).
Nothing ever happens in soccer:
"Every four years the world gathers to remind Americans that soccer is boring. The World Cup arrives, a billion people weep with joy, and everyone who wasn't indoctrinated before the age of six sits there waiting for something…anything to happen. Then suddenly it almost does. Then just as quickly it doesn't. Then it almost does again. This is the rhythm of the world's most boring game."
"Soccer just drones on—pass it back, pass it sideways, pass it back, pass it sideways, lose it, win it back, pass it back again—for ninety minutes, and almost nothing ever finishes. It’s all middle."
"Put these statistics together and the incentives are perverse. Giving up a goal is catastrophic, and the chance of scoring isn’t worth the risk of getting caught upfield when the other team counterattacks. So from the opening whistle the smart play isn’t to attack—it’s to play not to lose. Hold your shape, keep everyone back, pass it sideways, and wait for a mistake."
It's dumb luck:
"One of the best ways to determine how much luck is involved in a sport is to measure how often the worse team beats the better one. By this measure soccer is the most random major sport there is. The favourite fails to win 45 per cent of the time."
It bans the one thing humans excel at:
"It’s not that dribbling, passing, and shooting with your feet is unimpressive. It’s that it’s impressive the way a dog walking on its hind legs is impressive: the miracle is that it can be done at all, not that this is the highest use of the organism. It would be like a version of basketball where you’re only allowed to dribble with your head. The best players would be some of the best athletes on earth—and they’d be demonstrating nothing except how much human talent can be squandered by arbitrarily banning the one thing we’re good at, provided you force enough children to practice."
The intellectualism is insufferable:
"The more a sport has to be intellectualised, the more boring it is to watch. And with the exception of baseball, the world’s second most boring sport, no sport is intellectualised like soccer. Tell a soccer fan how bored you are at 0-0 with five minutes left and you’ll be told you don’t understand the buildup, the spacing, the shape, the press, the movement off the ball. It’s a status move: the less obvious the entertainment, the more refined you get to feel for claiming to see it."
Even the elite media implicitly admit it's boring:
"Nobody bloviates for two thousand words about the hidden genius of a zero-zero tie. When a sport is genuinely thrilling, the writing is about the sport. When it isn’t, the writing gets very spiritual fast. Suddenly it’s about mortality and belonging and the human capacity for grace, the prose swelling to fill the silence where the excitement was supposed to be."
Conclusion:
"But that's why it’s so tragic. Soccer takes the largest, most brutally filtered athletic talent pool on earth and wastes it by paying players millions of dollars to jog around in circles for ninety minutes and try to score once with their feet." -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
With all due respect, but I find this rather pathetic. In response to the "growing global threats to academic freedom," the Dutch NWO plans to spend €50 million to rescue scientists from such hellholes as *checks notes*: USA, Israel, Turkey, Singapore, and the United Kingdom (!).
All five are prosperous, high-income countries, and three are liberal democracies. Even Turkey and Singapore are not outright autocracies. Is that really where academic freedom faces its greatest threats? Is that the best use of €50 million?
How about Qatar, Russia, Egypt, Belarus, Iran, Cuba, Saudi Arabia, China, Turkmenistan, Eritrea, Myanmar, or Nicaragua? Just take a look at the Academic Freedom Index.
Yes, academic freedom is under threat in the US, but thousands of scientists who are fiercely critical of Trump continue to work at US universities (I know several of them personally), and nobody is going to drag them out of bed in the middle of the night or poison their tea.
But self-important U.S. academics like Jason Stanley are theatrically "fleeing" to Canada, as if they're somehow being personally persecuted by Trump. Give me a break, please. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is my vote for the stupidest political argument of the century. Its general form goes like this:
"The backlash against the excesses of Our Party is the fault of those within the Party who drew attention to those excesses, thus empowering Our Party's enemies."
Here's an example from @NYMag and Science-Based Medicine, who argued that the free-speech liberals who signed the Harper letter and kept "railing against DEI, critical race theory, and social justice" have “provided fuel and ammunition” to Trump and his allies — effectively joining his camp by default. (substacktools.com/sharex/P4hZOr6q)
The argument gets applied to specific topics too:
"The rise of the anti-immigrant Right is the fault of those on the Left who 'problematized' migration, thus mainstreaming xenophobia."
"The backlash against transgenderism is the fault of liberals who kept harping about puberty blockers, thus parroting right-wing talking points."
Ah yes, of course! Because what problem has ever been solved by ignoring it? What could be more reassuring to potential voters than demonstrating an absolute unwillingness to tackle the lunacy on your own side?
I honestly find it hard to believe that people are so stupid to believe this. And yet I see it again and again Here's the excellent @HPluckrose making what should be an obvious point:
"Does denial of a problem within a group ever work to convince anyone outside it? Are those on the left currently convinced by those on the right shutting down criticism of MAGA with accusations that perceiving any is Trump Derangement Syndrome and everything is just fine or does this make the problem seem more intractable? Has anybody concerned by Islamic extremism ever been convinced by being told they are mistaken and Islam is actually a religion of peace or does this just convince them that those who could address the problem are not going to and solutions will need to be external and radical?" -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Alain @Destexhe, the former Secretary-General of Doctors Without Borders (@MSF, 1991-1995), on the deep rot that has penetrated the organization:
“It would have been impossible at the time when I was secretary-general of MSF to be as biased as MSF is now in Gaza. We were defining ourselves as a neutral, impartial and humanitarian organization … I think now MSF in Gaza is really taking the side [of] Hamas and against Israel. Americans need to know that Doctors Without Borders is not anymore the organization that it was 15 or 20 years ago. It has become a biased, partial and militant organization.”
I used to donate to @MSF every month, but I will never do so again, unless they radically change their ways. See: quillette.com/2025/12/10/the-humanitarian-mask-medecins-s…
www.foxnews.com/world/former-doctors-without-borders-lead… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"This means that almost all Western media outlets have unflinchingly disseminated Hamas propaganda to their tens of millions of viewers, while disregarding Israeli figures almost entirely. The world’s journalists have taken the word of jihadi butchers above the evidence-based testimony of a friendly democracy and shared this narrative with the world.
It is no exaggeration to say that this comprises one of the gravest failures of journalistic scepticism in modern times. The uncomfortable truth is that we have been living through the most intense age of propaganda since Soviet times, made only more appalling by the fact that it has been spread voluntarily within supposedly free societies."
www.spiked-online.com/2026/07/01/terrorists-who-kill-jews… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nice and thoughtful post about the strengths—and limitations—of cultural evolution.
Is cumulative cultural evolution "smarter" than any individual human? Can blind cultural selection give rise to clever adaptations without any understanding on the part of the human hosts?
I've published several papers on cultural evolution myself, but I'm still genuinely of two minds about the subject, with my sympathies shifting depending on my mood—and on whom I've been talking to lately. Hugo Mercier (@hugoreasoning) and Olivier Morin (@OliverWithAnI) are among its sharpest critics.
statsandsociety.substack.com/p/how-i-learned-to-love-cult… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dag Brechtje, je grootmoeder is niet gestorven aan corona omdat ze geen vaccin kreeg, maar omdat ze in Wuhan schubdieren eten. Mitigatie is voor losers, problemen kan je enkel bij de wortel aanpakken!
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Which continent is the world record holder in heat deaths? The dubious distinction goes to... Europe—the place with the fewest hot days on Earth. The culprit isn't the climate. It's two letters Europeans refuse to learn: A/C. My latest piece in @Quillette.👇
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Maar kritiek op Netanyahu is helemaal geen "anti-zionisme", @ThomasRotthier. Sommige van de felste critici van Netanyahu, zoals @faniaoz, zijn immers zélf zionist. Zionisme is simpelweg het zelfbeschikkingsrecht van het Joodse volk, thans in de vorm van een onafhankelijke staat. Het bestaansrecht van Israël dus, niet het huidige politieke regime.
maartenboudry.be/2025/05/hoe-progressieven-een-worstelend…
Thomas Rotthier
@ThomasRotthier
Geweld tegen andersdenkenden is nooit legitiem, maar kritiek op zionisme is dat wel. Uiteindelijk is zionisme gewoon een vorm van nationalisme en dat van Netanyahu en co is duidelijk exclusief nationalisme. Dat is de gevaarlijke en verwerpelijke variant.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hoe ons continent kampioen hittedoden werd. Opiniestuk vandaag in @volkskrant over de twee letters die Europeanen weigeren te leren (A/C), met dramatische gevolgen.
"Een quizvraag: op welk continent vallen per hoofd van de bevolking de meeste hittedoden te betreuren? Dat is met voorsprong… Europa. Zo stierven in de zomer van 2022 ruim 61 duizend Europeanen aan de gevolgen van hitte."
"Extreme hitte is niet alleen schadelijk voor oude mensen. Voor elke graad Celsius boven de 25 verminderen onze cognitieve prestaties met 2 procent."
"De diepere verklaring schuilt in de groene ideologie van ‘minder, minder’, die in Europa meer aanhang heeft: wij zien kunstmatige koeling als een decadente luxe, iets voor spilzuchtige Amerikanen met privézwembaden en dikke SUV’s."
www.volkskrant.nl/columns-opinie/opinie-door-het-stigma-r… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De VRT hield vol dat de herkomstcijfers uit De Foto van Vlaanderen "niet representatief" waren. Nu de ruwe data openbaar zijn en het stof is neergedwarreld, blijkt dat er wél duidelijke en statistisch significante verschillen bestaan rond gendertolerantie bij respondenten uit Noord-Afrika en het Midden-Oosten (en ook bij Oost-Europa). Dat weten we dankzij het statistisch rapport van @freekvdvelde.
Dat vermeende probleem met "representativiteit" was een smoesje, want het was in een handomdraai op te lossen: de VRT had immers zélf al een onderverdeling gemaakt per geografische regio.
Hoe ontstaat ideologische bias zonder samenzwering? En waarom werd religie niet eens bevraagd? Nabeschouwing over het verdwenen balkje, de vrijgegeven cijfers en de comfortabele narratieven over de "manosfeer" van media en experten.
Alle klassieke media verloren "plots" interesse in dit verhaal nadat het een wending nam die hen niet uitkwam. Alle drie grote kranten weigerden dit stuk. Daarom ben ik blij dat Doorbraak bestaat om de klassieke media uit te dagen.
En nu hou ik erover op, beloofd.😅
doorbraak.be/het-verdwenen-balkje -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Can you imagine a fawning biopic about Jeffrey Epstein's philanthropic work playing in mainstream cinemas around the world? Or a hagiography celebrating Harvey Weinstein's many accomplishments in the movie industry—Pulp Fiction, The English Patient, Good Will Hunting, Gangs of New York, Chicago?
Neither can I.
So why do we continue to deify Michael Jackson—an actual pedophile who abused prepubescent children? To the best of my knowledge, even the odious Epstein was never accused of that.
Claire Lehman (@clairlemon) analyzes what's going on in @Quillette (subscribe if you haven't done so already!)
I went to see Michael and walked out after half an hour. Quite apart from the cringeworthy irony of portraying Michael Jackson as a helpless child victim of an abusive father, it was just genuinely boring. Needles to say, the remaining two hours of the film completely ignore the accusations of child abuse.
quillette.com/2026/05/30/why-epstein-but-not-jackson-sex-… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The classic disingenuous wordplay: pretending that "antisemitism" doesn't target Jews because "Arabs are Semites too." And since she loves Arabs so much, how could she possibly be an antisemite? Does she even know that the term "antisemitism" was coined by Jew haters to have a more dignified and salonfähig term for "Jew hatred"?
This comes close on the heels of her ludicrous claim about "dogs trained in Europe to rape Palestinian prisoners."
Every time Albanese comes out with another piece of antisemitic nonsense, she further disgraces the three universities that saw fit to bestow an honorary PhD on her (@Ugent @UAntwerpen @vubrussel). Only @KU_Leuven rescued its reputation by abstaining. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
HOAX! Ik heb een parodietekst geschreven onder het pseudoniem "An Van Raemdonk" en naar @Knack opgestuurd.
Het is een parodie op de islamapologie van regressief-linkse academici. De stelling: iedereen die zich zorgen maakt over intolerantie en islam is "racistisch en islamofoob", want de islam is juist een "mentale en spirituele buffer en krachtbron". Ze publiceerden het zowaar!😆
U had het kunnen weten: de gratuite beschuldigingen van racisme aan adres van @Ruud_Koop_mans, de idiote uitsmijter dat alleen "links" onderzoek "betrouwbaar en goed" kan zijn, het dwangmatige gebruik van aanhalingstekens rond 'fundamentalisme', 'moslims' en 'integratie'. En uiteraard zonder enige bron of argument!
Fijn om ook eens mezelf te kunnen demoniseren: "Op de aantijgingen van Boudry kan ik niet ingaan. De man is een fervente en kritiekloze supporter van een genocidaire apartheidspolitiek." 😆
Ik dacht dat de parodie te extreem zou zijn, maar @Knack trapte erin!
www.knack.be/nieuws/belgie/maatschappij/onderzoek-doen-na… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My top five bad arguments from this anti-robotaxi piece in @TheAtlantic:
🚫 Sure, 1.2 million die in car crashes each year, but "90% are in low- and middle-income countries, which are not in Waymo's expansion plans."
By that logic, why bother inventing vaccines? Most child deaths happen in the developing world anyway — except vaccines got rolled out everywhere, because adoption drives down cost. Smartphones weren't designed for poor Africans either, yet there are 700 millions of them in Africa now, with penetration rates around 70%.
🚫 Robotaxis could "displace millions of people employed as drivers."
So did the mechanical cotton picker, which replaced millions of stoop laborers. Does anyone wish that brutal work back? Before the industrial revolution, the vast majority of people worked in agriculture. Self-driving cars will actually help poor people by making private transportation affordable for everyone. Protecting low-wage jobs by forbidding the safer, cheaper alternative just traps people in poverty.
🚫 "When companies talk about safety… they just want to sell their product."
Sure, and so do the makers of seatbelts, fire extinguishers, and antibiotics. I guess you should never buy those? Companies profit from safety precisely because people value safety and will pay for it. That's not a gotcha; it's free markets working as advertised.
🚫 "The taxi is one of the few places we brush against other ways of living."
Nobody is banning human contact, not even in transportation. By all means, take a human Uber if you feel so inclined. Or chat with your barista, or strike up a conversation with a stranger on the street. Or pay for a human guide. Keeping people in dangerous, low-wage driving jobs is just using humans as set decoration.
🚫 "Studies show automated vehicles are less able to detect people of color."
This was a preprint. In the peer-reviewed version, the racial gap disappeared — a 29.71% vs 30.15% miss rate. And it tested generic open-source camera models, not Waymo, which navigates with lidar and radar, where skin tone is physically irrelevant. (See @KelseyTuoc's debunk: www.theargumentmag.com/p/no-waymos-arent-racist) Even if it were real, it would be a simple, solvable engineering problem. You're really clutching at straws.
✅ What the piece leaves out entirely: @Waymo reports ~92% fewer serious car crashes and ~92% fewer injury-causing pedestrian crashes than human drivers.
It's a shame that this was published in my favorite magazine @TheAtlantic, which is generally pro-progress and pro-abundance.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/05/waymo-self-driving-cars… -
Post not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Here are some harrowing testimonies from Jews still living in the West (for now), from @IzaTabaro in @Quillette. These are the flames that all those useful idiots in academia are fanning.
"Musician and writer Deborah Conway talks about a call from the director of a writers festival, telling her there's been pushback against her participation in the programme. He assures her everything is fine, but at the festival, she finds herself surrounded by heavy security. At one panel, people rise to their feet, unfurl signs, and start screaming at her. In Brisbane, a dozen masked people pound on the glass of the bookshop where she is speaking, screaming to globalise the intifada, while policemen do nothing. Intimidation bears fruit: music critics sidestep her new album, and she can't book venues to perform it in. Her public presence is quietly diminished. Has anybody noticed?
But it doesn't stop there. Large social media accounts target her daughter, an online food personality. Her hummus adds to Palestinian suffering, apparently, so they threaten to show up at markets where she sells the food. "She had to pack and leave," says Conway. At those markets, did anybody notice she's no longer there?
There is a history of Jews vanishing and others choosing not to notice. "I don't know where the Jews who lived here went—they just moved out at some point," was a common postwar refrain about the murdered Jews next door.
Some of the most striking testimonials in "Some Were Neighbours," an exhibit originally shown at the Holocaust Museum in Washington, DC, come from German Jews recalling non-Jews disappearing from their lives as the antisemitic Nazi state asserted itself. One-time friends, neighbours, classmates, colleagues, dance partners, lovers just marched on into the promise of a great new German future, leaving Jews behind. So strong was the sting of this personal betrayal that neither the horror of the genocide that followed nor the passage of time diminished the force of its memory.
Another testimony from the present: Joshua Moshe, an award-winning saxophonist and composer. His career is destroyed after his bandmates of seven years publicly expel him from the band via a social media post declaring that they do not tolerate Zionism in any form. Other fellow creatives follow: one pulls out of a joint show, another withdraws performance rights to his song. Invitations vanish. It's business, nothing personal; these are the times. Nobody wants to lose work "by association."
Doxxed and targeted in a "coordinated online pile-on across every channel," Joshua and his wife make a hard decision: move to another part of Melbourne for the sake of their son, who is also now being threatened. As they pack up their gift and homewares shop, passers-by scream, "Good, we don't want Zionists in our area."
If you want to understand what it feels like to watch one's world narrow, with the walls closing in on you, ask Moshe: the "relentless" abuse left him "with anxiety, night sweats, an elevated heart rate, and an inability to sleep," he told the Royal Commission. He felt "devastated," sensing that his life "was starting to unravel—not knowing what would happen.""
quillette.com/2026/06/01/open-hiding-jewish-testimony-aus… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Natuurlijk heeft @destandaard mijn kritische inzending over de VRT geweigerd. Het was zelfs maar een lezersbriefje deze keer, geen opiniestuk (die ze toch telkens negeren of weigeren). Ze blinken daar niet bepaald uit in zelfkritiek.
Inmidels geeft het statistische rapport van hun eigen columnist @freekvdvelde mij gelijk: de analyse van @jfabbeloos dat de VRT niets te verwijten viel en dat ze slachtoffer werd van boze "rechtse populisten die gretig haar proces maakten", was even voorspelbaar als fout. Ideologie is als een slechte adem: je ruikt het nooit bij jezelf.
MIjn brief:
"“Wat ze ook doet”, zo schrijft De Standaard meelevend over de VRT, de openbare omroep zal “nooit op veel begrip uit rechtse hoek kunnen rekenen”, omdat rechtse populisten altijd “met gretigheid hun proces maken”. Daarna volgt de obligate litanie: Trump, Marine Le Pen, Bouchez.
Dat martelaarschap van de staatszender zou geloofwaardiger overkomen als de VRT ondertussen niet nog steeds vertikte om de ruwe data vrij te geven. Ook de experten die in De Standaard "brandhout maakten" van de cijfers over buitenlandse origine, zoals Geert Molenberghs, hadden geen toegang tot de ruwe dataset. Daardoor weten we nog steeds niet of — en wat — de VRT probeert weg te moffelen.
Wat we wel weten, is dat de VRT op geen enkele manier peilde naar religie of cultuur, terwijl eerder onderzoek uitwijst dat er een sterk verband bestaat tussen religie en LGBT-haat. Het wegmoffelen zit dus al in de hele onderzoeksopzet.
Nog merkwaardiger is de suggestie van Jan-Frederik Abbeloos dat de vraag over omvolking/vervanging “een extreemrechts frame legitimeert”, en net daardoor zou aantonen dat de studie geen linkse bias heeft. Men kan evengoed beweren dat de enquêtevraag of een man zijn vrouw soms mag slaan “huiselijk geweld legitimeert”. Een peiling registreert opvattingen; ze legitimeert die daarom nog niet.
Dat De Standaard de ideologische vooringenomenheid van de VRT nauwelijks opmerkt, mag niet verbazen. Ideologie is zoals een slechte adem: je merkt ze zelden bij jezelf."
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Arme openbare omroep! “Wat ze ook doet”, jammert @destandaard meelevend, ze zal “nooit op veel begrip uit rechtse hoek kunnen rekenen”, want rechtse populisten zullen altijd “met gretigheid hun proces maken”. En vervolgens uiteraard de obligate riedel: Trump, Marine Le Pen, Bouchez.
Het martelaarschap van de staatszender! En dat terwijl de VRT het nog steeds vertikt om de ruwe data vrij te geven, waardoor we nog steeds niet weten of en wat ze probeert weg te moffelen. En dat terwijl de hele onderzoeksopzet vol woke assumpties zit (x.com/mboudry/status/2057146617770217660)
Hilarisch ook dat @jfabbeloos denkt dat de vraag in de peiling over omvolking/vervanging “een extreemrechts frame legitimeert” en daarom bewijst dat de studie geen linkse bias heeft. Je kan net zo goed beweren dat hun vraag of een man zijn vrouw soms mag slaan “huiselijk geweld legitimeert”.
Soit, nogal wiedes dat @destandaard de linkse bias van de VRT niet ziet. Ideologie is zoals een slechte adem: je ruikt het nooit bij jezelf.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hoe meer ik over die Foto Vlaanderen lees, hoe schabouwelijker het wordt. De woke assumpties zijn overal:
- Het gaat bijna uitsluitend over de typische vooroordelen van blanke autochtone burgers, zoals angst voor moskeeën en omvolking; zelfs de idiote "wintermarkten" achten ze een vraag waard. (Ironisch: ze zien islamitische Vlamingen blijkbaar niet als "echte" Vlamingen)
- De term "islam" komt alleen maar voor als het gaat over "bezorgheid OVER de islam", "weerstand tegen moskeeën", angst voor islamisering en omvolking. Allemaal hoogst "problematisch".
- Er zit helemaal niets in over het goed gedocumenteerde verband tussen islam en LGBT-intolerantie, niets over religieuze rechtvaardiging van geweld, en niets ernstigs over migratie (alleen in de containercategorie "buitenlandse origine", die ze vooral vol Hollanders propten). Het wegmoffelen van de link tussen religie en intolerantie zit al in het hele onderzoeksopzet.
- De stelling "Er zijn maar twee geslachten" wordt geproblematiseerd en als een vorm van intolerantie, iets waarmee mensen het "lastig hebben". Nieuwsflash uit de biologie: ER ZIJN MAAR TWEE GESLACHTEN.
Dit is echt een belabberd werkstuk waar alle woke assumpties vanaf druipen. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De uitgebreide statistische analyse van de VRT-data door linguïst @freekvdvelde geeft mij dus gelijk: "Mensen met roots in Noord-Afrika of het Midden-Oosten scoren 15 procentpunten lager dan de autochtone Belgen op gendertolerantie." Die regio's zijn 95% islamitisch.
De regressieanalyse toont in het algemeen "een vrij aanzienlijk verschil" in gendertolerantie tussen West-Europeanen en alle andere regio. Precies dus wat ik beweerde: de VRT zat we degelijk op die onwelgevallige data over herkomst, maar besloot ze niet vrij te geven. En de kwaliteit van de verzamelde data was hoger dan we dachten.
Is er nog steeds niémand van de VRT-verdedigers die eerlijk genoeg is om zijn/haar vergissing toe te geven? Errare humanum est, perseverare diabolicum.
@PLoobuyck @pcasteels @Isoldevde @jfabbeloos @RuttenGwendolyn @FredericDeGucht @jdceulaer
Het volledige rapport van @freekvdvelde. github.com/FreekVandeVelde/FotoVanVlaanderen/blob/main/On…
En hier een visualisatie.
www.knack.be/nieuws/belgie/maatschappij/freek-van-de-veld…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit geldt niet alleen voor @PLoobuyck, maar ook voor @pcasteels, @Isoldevde, @RuttenGwendolyn, @jfabbeloos, @FredericDeGucht en nog wat anderen die ik nu vergeet. De VRT zat wél op robuuste en statistisch significante data over herkomst en de rol van islam, die ze besloot onder de mat te vegen, en er waren veel meer dan "23 moslims".
De eerste die toeegeeft dat hij/zij zich vergist heeft, krijgt een bak bier (of een goede fles prosecco).😉 /2This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A really insightful piece in @Quillette on the moral panic surrounding the so-called "manosphere," bringing some much-needed anthropological and historical perspective to the debate.
I used to enjoy Louis Theroux's documentaries, and he's undeniably talented, but he has become increasingly tribal: targeting only those groups his audience already dislikes while turning a blind eye to groups afforded greater sympathy. There's little genuine insight in his new documentary 'Inside the Manosphere'. It's just a series of amusing and cringey vignettes, some of which effectively puncture the pretensions of these online grifters.
But the overall framing is so predictable that it ends up feeling more like audience validation than serious inquiry.
"A repeated element of Theroux-style reporting: feigning shock at the behaviour of one group that it is fashionable for his audience to dislike, while carefully avoiding pointing out that the exact same behaviour is characteristic of a protected group. There is a word for this sort of activity, and that word is not "journalism". It is "pandering"."
"Theroux's documentary is not without value. But it is half a story—the loudly accessible, politically convenient half. The rest of the story is less comfortable, implicates more powerful institutions, and would require a willingness to apply the same scrutiny across the board. As long as documentaries like this one present sexual polarisation as a pathology of young men on the internet, and decline to examine the other side of the wall, they are not exposing the manosphere. They are feeding it."
quillette.com/2026/05/28/manosfear-louis-theroux-manosphe… -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit geldt niet alleen voor @PLoobuyck, maar ook voor @pcasteels, @Isoldevde, @RuttenGwendolyn, @jfabbeloos, @FredericDeGucht en nog wat anderen die ik nu vergeet. De VRT zat wél op robuuste en statistisch significante data over herkomst en de rol van islam, die ze besloot onder de mat te vegen, en er waren veel meer dan "23 moslims".
De eerste die toeegeeft dat hij/zij zich vergist heeft, krijgt een bak bier (of een goede fles prosecco).😉 /2This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Amazing graph. One the best visualizations of human progress.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Eindelijk heb ik de volledige dataset van 'De Foto van Vlaanderen' van @VRT ontvangen. Eén ding staat nu al vast: iedereen die stellig beweerde dat er “maar 21 moslims” meededen, en dat je daarom onmogelijk conclusies kan trekken over de islam, zit er nu al naast, op basis van deze dataset. De VRT heeft ons hier duidelijk misleid: er blijken maar liefst 51 deelnemers met een origine uit islamitische landen in de dataset te zitten — dus meer dan dubbel zoveel (als ik goed tel).
Sterker nog: de VRT heeft zélf een regionale onderverdeling gemaakt in de data (zie screenshot), met de handige categorie “Noord-Afrika en Midden-Oosten”! Alleen al daarin zitten 43 mensen. Die regio is voor ~95% islamitisch. Waarom heeft de VRT dié data niet gedeeld toen er ophef ontstond, in plaats van enkel in te zoomen op Turken en Marokkanen, waar niemand — zeker ik niet — over begonnen was? Kan het zijn dat ze haar eigen data wilde minimaliseren, om niet te zeggen wegmoffelen?
We zijn de dataset nog volop aan het analyseren, en ik wil niet vooruitlopen op de bevindingen, maar dit vind ik nu al straf. Het was een constructief en open gesprek daarnet, maar nu blijkt dat VRT niet eerlijk is geweest met de data (ik mail om opheldering).
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hoe ook professoren aan onze universiteit statistisch ongeletterd kunnen worden zodra ideologie in het spel is:
- Nee, het gaat niet enkel over 21 mensen. Bijna de helft van die buitenlandse groep (148 mensen) heeft een “andere niet-Belgische herkomst”. Wie zijn dat? De VRT zegt er geen woord over. Daar kunnen dus nog steeds veel mensen met roots in islamitische landen tussen zitten — of mensen met een gemengde herkomst. Dat zouden we weten ALS DE VRT HAAR DATA ZOU VRIJGEVEN.
- Mensen die een ouder hebben met de Nederlandse nationaliteit zijn niet noodzakelijk autochtone Nederlanders en kunnen perfect moslim zijn. Of zijn alleen witte Nederlanders “echte” Nederlanders volgens @drieslesage? Ook dat zouden we kunnen nagaan ALS DE VRT NAAR RELIGIE HAD GEVRAAGD.
- Moslims van de derde generatie, van wie beide ouders in België geboren zijn, zijn volledig onzichtbaar binnen deze methodologie. Zij tellen simpelweg mee als “zuivere Vlamingen”. Zelfs binnen die 2.113 respondenten weten we dus niet hoeveel moslims, christenen of joden er zitten. Dat kunnen we hier slechts indirect afleiden, OMDAT DE VRT ER NIET NAAR WOU PEILEN.
- Niemand (zeker ik niet) heeft ooit gevraagd om forse uitspraken te doen over die kleine groep “Marokkanen” of “Turken” (Nieuwsflash: sommige Turken en Marokkanen zijn atheïst). Mijn punt was dat religie waarschijnlijk een sterk bepalende factor is in homohaat en traditionele denkbeelden, omdat dat al jaren blijkt uit eerder onderzoek.
Het is dus compleet voorbarig om te beweren dat deze cijfers aantonen dat “vooral autochtone Vlamingen achter deze schokkende resultaten zitten”. Toch blijven velen dat triomfantelijk herhalen, zonder enige inzage in de VRT-data en zonder elementaire kennis van de relevante literatuur.
Dat krijg je wanneer ideologische paardenkleppen belangrijker worden dan statistische geletterdheid — zoals bij @DriesLesage.Post not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Het spijt me, maar al deze wetenschappers en journalisten die voorbarig "brandhout maakten" van de cijfers, die de VRT blindelings vertrouwden, die besloten dat er geen enkel signaal over islam in de dataset zat, en die vertelden dat ik maar "onzin" verkocht, hebben zich nu wel serieus verbrand. I hate to tell you I told you so, but I told you so. @destandaard
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit is een schandelijk arrest. Voor de duizendste keer: @DVanLangenhove is absoluut mijn vriend niet en ik vind dat zijn gedachtegoed dicht aanschurkt bij het fascisme (hij dweept letterlijk met Oswald Mosley, de Britse oerfascist). Niettemin, in een liberaal land word je NIET veroordeeld omdat je de oververtegenwoordiging van "bepaalde bevolkingsgroepen" in criminaliteitscijfers bespreekt.
Zelfs niet als Van Langenhove die cijfers verdraait of verkeerd interpreteert. Het is niét aan een rechter om discussies over de etnische/culturele dimensie van criminaliteit te kortsluiten.
Uit het vonnis: “Deze groep vormt volgens [Van Lengenhove] de oorzaak van alle door hem aangehaalde problemen.” En dat zou een reden zijn tot veroordeling? Nogmaals een uitnodiging aan Openbaar Ministerie: 95% van alle moorden worden gepleegd door één groep: mannen. Bij verkrachtingen zijn niet-Westerse migranten enorm oververtegenwoordigd. Komt u mij ook dagvaarden, @Het_OM?
Het zou de vele tegenstanders van Van Langenhove sieren als ze opkwamen voor zijn vrije meningsuiting. Noam Chomsky verdedigde zelfs de 'free speech' van Holocaustontkenner Faurisson (en zo ver gaat zelfs Van Langenhove niet, bij mijn weten).
Het is niet omdat een hansworst als JD Vance het zegt dat het onwaar is: Europa heeft een ernstig 'free speech'-probleem.
www.standaard.be/binnenland/dries-van-langenhove-veroorde…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hot take: niet-Europese migranten zijn sterk oververtegenwoordigd in criminaliteitsstatistieken, zeker bij verkrachting en terrorisme. (Lees o.a. @Ruud_Koop_mans, @Ayaan Hirsi Ali en @demo_demo_nl)
Beste Openbaar Ministerie (@Het_OM), gaat u mij nu ook dagvaarden omdat ik “veralgemenend en negatief” spreek over “bepaalde groepen in de samenleving”? Omdat ik me bezondig aan "een sterk wij-zijdenken"?
Nog eentje, om u te helpen: 90% van alle moorden en 98% van alle verkrachtingen worden gepleegd door één groep in onze samenleving — mannen. Mannen zijn bij uitstek het grootste probleem voor onze veiligheid. Krijg ik er ook een fikse boete voor mannenhaat bij?
Ik heb @DVanLangenhove eerder een fascist genoemd (hij bewondert Oswald Mosley), maar het is volstrekt absurd dat hij wordt vervolgd voor uitspraken over het verband tussen criminaliteit en migratie. Zelfs indien Van Langenhove statistieken overdrijft of verdraait. Het is niét aan een rechter om mensen daarover de mond te snoeren.
En dat terwijl aanhangers van terreurorganisaties als Hamas straffeloos onze steden onveilig maken, en salafistische haatboeken in boekenhandels liggen.
Dit is een liberale samenleving onwaardig. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hoe ook professoren aan onze universiteit statistisch ongeletterd kunnen worden zodra ideologie in het spel is:
- Nee, het gaat niet enkel over 21 mensen. Bijna de helft van die buitenlandse groep (148 mensen) heeft een “andere niet-Belgische herkomst”. Wie zijn dat? De VRT zegt er geen woord over. Daar kunnen dus nog steeds veel mensen met roots in islamitische landen tussen zitten — of mensen met een gemengde herkomst. Dat zouden we weten ALS DE VRT HAAR DATA ZOU VRIJGEVEN.
- Mensen die een ouder hebben met de Nederlandse nationaliteit zijn niet noodzakelijk autochtone Nederlanders en kunnen perfect moslim zijn. Of zijn alleen witte Nederlanders “echte” Nederlanders volgens @drieslesage? Ook dat zouden we kunnen nagaan ALS DE VRT NAAR RELIGIE HAD GEVRAAGD.
- Moslims van de derde generatie, van wie beide ouders in België geboren zijn, zijn volledig onzichtbaar binnen deze methodologie. Zij tellen simpelweg mee als “zuivere Vlamingen”. Zelfs binnen die 2.113 respondenten weten we dus niet hoeveel moslims, christenen of joden er zitten. Dat kunnen we hier slechts indirect afleiden, OMDAT DE VRT ER NIET NAAR WOU PEILEN.
- Niemand (zeker ik niet) heeft ooit gevraagd om forse uitspraken te doen over die kleine groep “Marokkanen” of “Turken” (Nieuwsflash: sommige Turken en Marokkanen zijn atheïst). Mijn punt was dat religie waarschijnlijk een sterk bepalende factor is in homohaat en traditionele denkbeelden, omdat dat al jaren blijkt uit eerder onderzoek.
Het is dus compleet voorbarig om te beweren dat deze cijfers aantonen dat “vooral autochtone Vlamingen achter deze schokkende resultaten zitten”. Toch blijven velen dat triomfantelijk herhalen, zonder enige inzage in de VRT-data en zonder elementaire kennis van de relevante literatuur.
Dat krijg je wanneer ideologische paardenkleppen belangrijker worden dan statistische geletterdheid — zoals bij @DriesLesage. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Arme openbare omroep! “Wat ze ook doet”, jammert @destandaard meelevend, ze zal “nooit op veel begrip uit rechtse hoek kunnen rekenen”, want rechtse populisten zullen altijd “met gretigheid hun proces maken”. En vervolgens uiteraard de obligate riedel: Trump, Marine Le Pen, Bouchez.
Het martelaarschap van de staatszender! En dat terwijl de VRT het nog steeds vertikt om de ruwe data vrij te geven, waardoor we nog steeds niet weten of en wat ze probeert weg te moffelen. En dat terwijl de hele onderzoeksopzet vol woke assumpties zit (x.com/mboudry/status/2057146617770217660)
Hilarisch ook dat @jfabbeloos denkt dat de vraag in de peiling over omvolking/vervanging “een extreemrechts frame legitimeert” en daarom bewijst dat de studie geen linkse bias heeft. Je kan net zo goed beweren dat hun vraag of een man zijn vrouw soms mag slaan “huiselijk geweld legitimeert”.
Soit, nogal wiedes dat @destandaard de linkse bias van de VRT niet ziet. Ideologie is zoals een slechte adem: je ruikt het nooit bij jezelf.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hoe meer ik over die Foto Vlaanderen lees, hoe schabouwelijker het wordt. De woke assumpties zijn overal:
- Het gaat bijna uitsluitend over de typische vooroordelen van blanke autochtone burgers, zoals angst voor moskeeën en omvolking; zelfs de idiote "wintermarkten" achten ze een vraag waard. (Ironisch: ze zien islamitische Vlamingen blijkbaar niet als "echte" Vlamingen)
- De term "islam" komt alleen maar voor als het gaat over "bezorgheid OVER de islam", "weerstand tegen moskeeën", angst voor islamisering en omvolking. Allemaal hoogst "problematisch".
- Er zit helemaal niets in over het goed gedocumenteerde verband tussen islam en LGBT-intolerantie, niets over religieuze rechtvaardiging van geweld, en niets ernstigs over migratie (alleen in de containercategorie "buitenlandse origine", die ze vooral vol Hollanders propten). Het wegmoffelen van de link tussen religie en intolerantie zit al in het hele onderzoeksopzet.
- De stelling "Er zijn maar twee geslachten" wordt geproblematiseerd en als een vorm van intolerantie, iets waarmee mensen het "lastig hebben". Nieuwsflash uit de biologie: ER ZIJN MAAR TWEE GESLACHTEN.
Dit is echt een belabberd werkstuk waar alle woke assumpties vanaf druipen. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit is echt ongelofelijk: de studiedienst van @VRT weigert gewoon om de ruwe dataset van de inmiddels verguisde 'Foto van Vlaanderen' vrij te geven. Zelfs niet aan professoren met expertise in statistiek. Dit ondanks alles beloftes over transparantie. Maar ze hebben uiteraard niets te verbergen, hoor.
Niemand heeft deze data kunnen inkijken, zelfs niet de experten die commentaar gaven in de media. De nationale omroep verwacht blijkbaar dat we hen zomaar op hun woord geloven: dat alle analyses kloppen, dat er geen statistisch “signaal” rond religie zit binnen de categorie “buitenlandse origine” (wat met die 148 “anderen”?), dat de steekproeven correct werden uitgevoerd, dat de andere groepen representatief waren. Ze laat niemand toe om de belangrijke fouten na te gaan die al hun presentatie ontdekt zijn (x.com/mboudry/status/2057135432282829196).
In plaats daarvan gaat ze een kransje van zelf geselecteerde experts uitnodigen voor een rondetafel -- tegen dan zijn we alweer een maand of twee verder. Dit kan echt niet, minister @CieltjeVAchter. De directeur van de studiedienst van de VRT zou beter de eer aan zichzelf houden.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nog steeds vertikt de VRT het om de volledige dataset vrij te geven. Meerdere academici met statistische expertise (zoals @freekvdvelde) hebben de data al opgevraagd om zelf te analyseren, zonder enig antwoord. Beste @CieltjeVAchter, had de VRT geen volledige transparantie beloofd?
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wat is dat trouwens met die categorie "buitenlandse origine"? Bijna de helft (148) van die mensen vallen in de restcategorie "andere herkomst". Dat is toch stug: waar komen die mensen (of hun ouders) dan vandaan? Een combo van verschillende achtergronden? Of kozen ze ervoor om niets in te vullen? Daar kunnen nog best wat mensen met niet-Europese achtergrond in zitten. Dat zouden statistici kunnen nagaan ALS @VRT DE DATA ZOU VRIJGEVEN, zoals het beloofde. /2
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Even recapituleren.
De VRT bestelde een studie over diversiteit en intolerantie. Ze hanteerde daarbij het containercategorie “buitenlandse origine”, dat ze vervolgens volpropt met Nederlanders en andere Europeanen omdat ze kennelijk te weinig Marokkanen en Turken vonden, wat die categorie waardeloos maakt. Maar toen nog stééds bleek dat die groep gemiddeld intoleranter was dan de Belgen, gaven ze instructies aan hun journalisten om die balkjes maar helemaal weg te moffelen.
Ik heb voor de uitzending alle data opgevraagd bij de VRT, wat toch normaal is als je een expert uitnodigt om over een studie te spreken. Maar ik kreeg ze niet, alleen een simpele PowerPoint met een verdwaalde opmerking die journalisten instrueerde om NIET over herkomst te berichten. En nog steeds vertikt de VRT het om de ruwe data vrij te geven. (Komt hopelijk nog)
Nochtans weten we uit onderzoek dat homohaat zeer sterk samenhangt met de islam — hoe religieuzer, hoe intoleranter (dit geldt overigens ook voor andere religies). Een kwart van de moslimjongeren in België vindt geweld tegen homo’s gerechtvaardigd (JOP Monitor). De helft van de Turken in Duitsland vindt homoseksualiteit een “ziekte”. De helft van de Europese moslims wil geen homo’s als vrienden (Koopmans). Idem wat betreft reactionaire denkbeelden over vrouwen.
Dat was allemaal al lang vóór de opkomst van de — inderdaad verwerpelijke — “manosfeer” waarover de VRT vol op het orgel ging, terwijl hun onderzoek daar geen enkele conclusie over toelaat. Het is pure speculatie, maar het past wel in het "woke" narratief dat het allemaal de schuld is van Andrew Tate, influencers, toxische masculiniteit, sociale media etc. Want hebben we allemaal Adolescence niet gezien op Netflix (pure fictie en nog ongeloofwaardig ook), dat nu zelfs aan het onderwijspakket wordt toegevoegd?
Maar de culturele factor wilden ze bij de VRT kennelijk niet onderzoeken, of ze wilden de vis verdrinken in die containercategorie van "buitenlanders". Nergens in het onderzoek wordt gepeild naar de impact van religie of cultuur. Nergens wordt gevraagd welke religie de jongeren aanhangen. Er zit niks in over het verband tussen islam en LGBT-intolerantie, niets over religieuze rechtvaardiging van geweld, niets ernstigs over niet-Europese migratie (alleen die waardeloze container “buitenlandse origine”).
Het is dus nog erger: 𝐡𝐞𝐭 𝐰𝐞𝐠𝐦𝐨𝐟𝐟𝐞𝐥𝐞𝐧 𝐯𝐚𝐧 𝐝𝐞 𝐥𝐢𝐧𝐤 𝐭𝐮𝐬𝐬𝐞𝐧 𝐫𝐞𝐥𝐢𝐠𝐢𝐞 𝐞𝐧 𝐢𝐧𝐭𝐨𝐥𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐧𝐭𝐢𝐞 𝐳𝐚𝐭 𝐚𝐥 𝐢𝐧 𝐝𝐞 𝐡𝐞𝐥𝐞 𝐨𝐧𝐝𝐞𝐫𝐳𝐨𝐞𝐤𝐬𝐨𝐩𝐳𝐞𝐭, 𝐧𝐨𝐠 𝐥𝐨𝐬 𝐯𝐚𝐧 𝐡𝐞𝐭 𝐥𝐚𝐭𝐞𝐫𝐞 “𝐯𝐞𝐫𝐛𝐞𝐫𝐠𝐞𝐧” 𝐯𝐚𝐧 𝐝𝐞 𝐫𝐞𝐬𝐮𝐥𝐭𝐚𝐭𝐞𝐧.
Nu we toch bezig zijn: de studie bulkt van andere typische woke assumpties:
- Het gaat bijna uitsluitend over de typische vooroordelen van blanke autochtone burgers, zoals angst voor moskeeën en omvolking; zelfs die idiote “wintermarkten” achten ze een vraag waard. (Ironisch genoeg zien ze islamitische Vlamingen blijkbaar niet als “echte” Vlamingen.)
- De term “islam” komt alleen voor in de context van “bezorgdheid over de islam”, “weerstand tegen moskeeën”, angst voor islamisering en omvolking. Allemaal hoogst “problematisch”.
- De stelling “Er zijn maar twee geslachten” wordt geproblematiseerd en voorgesteld als een vorm van intolerantie, iets waar mensen het “lastig mee hebben”. Nieuwsflits uit de biologie: er zijn maar twee geslachten. ER ZIJN MAAR TWEE GESLACHTEN.
Sorry voor de hoofdletters, wellicht speelt mijn toxische mannelijke agressie op. 😉
www.youtube.com/watch?v=fp2D7Qn58Vg&t=1229s
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wat is dat trouwens met die categorie "buitenlandse origine"? Bijna de helft (148) van die mensen vallen in de restcategorie "andere herkomst". Dat is toch stug: waar komen die mensen (of hun ouders) dan vandaan? Een combo van verschillende achtergronden? Of kozen ze ervoor om niets in te vullen? Daar kunnen nog best wat mensen met niet-Europese achtergrond in zitten. Dat zouden statistici kunnen nagaan ALS @VRT DE DATA ZOU VRIJGEVEN, zoals het beloofde. /2
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een kwart van moslimjongeren in België vindt geweld tegen homo’s gerechtvaardigd (JOP Monitor). De helft van Turken in Duitsland vindt homoseksualiteit een "ziekte". De helft van Europese moslims wil geen homo's als vrienden (Koopmans).
Dat zijn de studies ik gisteren LETTERLIJK citeerde in @deafspraak, met verwijzing naar o.a. @Ruud_Koop_mans. Maar Petra De Sutter snoefde dat ik daarmee alleen maar blijk gaf van "zorgwekkende vooroordelen" over moslims. Dat was het échte probleem.
QED. Zo reusachtig blijft de blindheid van vele progressieven over de islam. Zulke woke ideologen staat nu aan de top van onze wetenschappelijke instellingen.
www.vrt.be/vrtmax/a-z/de-afspraak/2026/de-afspraak-d20260… -
VRT NWS Villa Politica
@villapolitica
"Het is bijzonder slecht aangepakt door VRT. Niet publiceren, vraagt om problemen. Maar professor @mboudry trok wel foute conclusie. Het gaat niet om moslims, maar om Nederlanders. Dan maak je je wel belachelijk."
@RuttenGwendolyn @anders_partij over 'De Foto van Vlaanderen'This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Alstublieft zeg, @RuttenGwendolyn. De VRT heeft een zinloze containercategorie "buitenlandse origine" gecreëerd in deze studie, en die vervolgens vol Nederlanders en andere Europeanen gepropt omdat ze kennelijk te weinig Marokkanen en Turken vonden.
En wanneer dan nog stééds bleek dat die groep intoleranter was dan de Belgen, hebben ze maar instructies gegeven aan hun journalisten om dat balkje helemaal weg te moffelen. En dan ligt de fout bij mij?
Terwijl we uit onderzoek weten dat homohaat zeer duidelijk samenhangt met de islam—en hoe religieuzer, hoe intoleranter (dit is ook zo in andere religies). En dat was al lang voor de opkomst "manosfeer" waarover VRT vol op het orgel ging, zonder enig bewijs uit hun onderzoek.
Maar de religieuze factor wilden ze kennelijk niet onderzoeken, of ze wilden het verdrinken in die zinloze container. Ik heb vooraf trouwens alle data opgevraagd vij VRT, wat toch normaal is als je een expert uitnodigt. Maar ik kreeg ze niet, alleen een simpele powerpoint.
Extreem teleurstellend voor een "liberale" politica. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hoe meer ik over die Foto Vlaanderen lees, hoe schabouwelijker het wordt. De woke assumpties zijn overal:
- Het gaat bijna uitsluitend over de typische vooroordelen van blanke autochtone burgers, zoals angst voor moskeeën en omvolking; zelfs de idiote "wintermarkten" achten ze een vraag waard. (Ironisch: ze zien islamitische Vlamingen blijkbaar niet als "echte" Vlamingen)
- De term "islam" komt alleen maar voor als het gaat over "bezorgheid OVER de islam", "weerstand tegen moskeeën", angst voor islamisering en omvolking. Allemaal hoogst "problematisch".
- Er zit helemaal niets in over het goed gedocumenteerde verband tussen islam en LGBT-intolerantie, niets over religieuze rechtvaardiging van geweld, en niets ernstigs over migratie (alleen in de containercategorie "buitenlandse origine", die ze vooral vol Hollanders propten). Het wegmoffelen van de link tussen religie en intolerantie zit al in het hele onderzoeksopzet.
- De stelling "Er zijn maar twee geslachten" wordt geproblematiseerd en als een vorm van intolerantie, iets waarmee mensen het "lastig hebben". Nieuwsflash uit de biologie: ER ZIJN MAAR TWEE GESLACHTEN.
Dit is echt een belabberd werkstuk waar alle woke assumpties vanaf druipen. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dit is wat @Ruud_Koop_mans in 2014 vaststelde toen hij rechtstreeks peilde naar de kloof tussen moslims en christenen (in Europa). De islamitische factor bij homohaat is overweldigend. Hoe religieuzer, hoe intoleranter. Ik eet mijn schoen op als dat niet ook blijkt vandaag in Vlaanderen.
Dát is wat VRT tracht te verdoezelen door alle aandacht af te leiden naar de "oorlogsmachine" van de "manosphere" (P.S. De vrouwenhater Andrew Tate heeft zich bekeerd tot de islam, hoe zou dat toch komen?)
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Meerdere mensen vragen me om het bommetje te delen dat ik gisteren in @deafspraaktv uit mijn broekzak haalde. Hierbij. Het was een PowerPoint die intern circuleerde bij VRT. Zie je dat balkje "PBH" (Personen met Buitenlands Herkomst) dat ze wilden wegmoffelen? Zelden krijg je het voorrecht om een vlieg op de muur te zijn van de politiek correcte zwijgcultuur.
De uitleg die erbij staat, is zeer waarschijnlijk een smoesje. Waarom is de "representativiteit" geen probleem bij de fijnere onderverdelingen van leeftijdsgroepen, maar plots wel bij de grote tweedeling 'buitenlandse herkomst' vs. 'autochtoon'? Enkel op die ene slak leggen ze zout? Maar dan wel vol op het orgel gaan over de invloed van "manosfeer" en de "influencers", causale claims die op geen enkele manier uit deze data vallen af te leiden?
Als de groep met buitenlands herkomst "iets hoger opgeleid" is, dan zou de vertekening juist gúnstig uitkomen voor die groep, en is de realiteit nog grimmiger (want hoger opgeleiden zijn doorgaans toleranter, weten we uit onderzoek).
Publiceer alle ruwe data, @vrtnws, dan kan iedereen zijn oordeel vormen.
Om geen personen te viseren, heb ik de namen onzichtbaar gemaakt. Maar al deze mensen werken bij VRT.
www.vrt.be/vrtmax/a-z/de-afspraak/2026/de-afspraak-d20260… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The sorcerer’s apprentice splits the broom in two, and each half springs back to life with renewed vigor. Now add Darwin: every blow of the axe selects for brooms that are harder to destroy, which then go on to spawn their hardy kind. Oops.
Are we inadvertently breeding “selfish” AIs? Are digital replicators about to go feral and pose an existential risk to humanity? Not so fast.
In my new piece for @Quillette, I discuss evolutionary doom scenarios, responding to an important new paper in PNAS by three heavyweights in AI and evolutionary biology—Müller, Steels & Szathmáry.
Goethe meets Darwin meets Gödel.
quillette.com/2026/05/19/why-ai-is-not-about-to-go-feral/ -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Meerdere mensen vragen me om het bommetje te delen dat ik gisteren in @deafspraaktv uit mijn broekzak haalde. Hierbij. Het was een PowerPoint die intern circuleerde bij VRT. Zie je dat balkje "PBH" (Personen met Buitenlands Herkomst) dat ze wilden wegmoffelen? Zelden krijg je het voorrecht om een vlieg op de muur te zijn van de politiek correcte zwijgcultuur.
De uitleg die erbij staat, is zeer waarschijnlijk een smoesje. Waarom is de "representativiteit" geen probleem bij de fijnere onderverdelingen van leeftijdsgroepen, maar plots wel bij de grote tweedeling 'buitenlandse herkomst' vs. 'autochtoon'? Enkel op die ene slak leggen ze zout? Maar dan wel vol op het orgel gaan over de invloed van "manosfeer" en de "influencers", causale claims die op geen enkele manier uit deze data vallen af te leiden?
Als de groep met buitenlands herkomst "iets hoger opgeleid" is, dan zou de vertekening juist gúnstig uitkomen voor die groep, en is de realiteit nog grimmiger (want hoger opgeleiden zijn doorgaans toleranter, weten we uit onderzoek).
Publiceer alle ruwe data, @vrtnws, dan kan iedereen zijn oordeel vormen.
Om geen personen te viseren, heb ik de namen onzichtbaar gemaakt. Maar al deze mensen werken bij VRT.
www.vrt.be/vrtmax/a-z/de-afspraak/2026/de-afspraak-d20260… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Al decennialang vieren zogenaamde "progressieven" de hijab, een instrument van vrouwonderdrukking en traditionele moraal, en komen ze zelfs op voor de "vrijheid" van vrouwen om een boerka te dragen. Dat ondanks de institutionele vrouwenonderdrukking in de islam, van generatie tot generatie doorgegeven, zonder enige vorm van keuzevrijheid. Dat terwijl meisjes onder druk worden gezet door vaders, broers en imams om zich te bedekken en “zedig” te zijn. Dat ondanks eremoorden, opsluiting thuis, verbod op vriendjes, vrouwenbesnijdenis.
Maar nu er een paar blanke vrouwen uit eigen vrije wil "tradwife" willen spelen op Instagam (vaak een puur verdienmodel), lees je de ene na de andere analyse dat het allemaal een snood complot is van witte mannen, extreemrechtse ideologen en het patriarchaat: "Dat droombeeld is politiek gemotiveerd en wordt gefinancierd door rechtse mannen." Dat die vrouwen niet écht vrij kiezen voor de keuken, maar geïndoctrineerd zijn.
Soms word ik echt misselijk van de hypocrisie van die zelfverklaarde "progressieven". Snoeihard voor blanke vrouwen die op Instagram met een rollenpatronen kokketeren, maar compleet blind voor de onderdrukking die ze niet op de "witte man" kunnen steken.
Newsflash: de hijab is letterlijk al eeuwenlang het symbool van de "tradwife" en van het islamitische patriarchaat. Maar omdat het bruine, niet-westerse vrouwen waren, kon het julie niet schelen. En werd het allemaal afgewimpeld als "islamofobie".
Hoepel toch op.
www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2026/05/15/carriere-maken-opvoeden-zorg… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A while ago, I watched the infamous 47-minute video documenting the atrocities of October 7th — the one not made publicly available, to protect the privacy of the victims.
The worst part of this video is not what it displays, but who is displaying it: the perpetrators themselves. Gleefully. Sadistically. Unabashedly. Most of the footage was filmed by Hamas terrorists on their GoPro bodycams, some also by ordinary Gazan civilians on their cellphones.
Even the Nazis tried to cover up their atrocities, but Hamas brags about theirs for the entire world to see. The killers are euphoric throughout the massacre, and their relentless, ecstatic cries of "Allahu Akbar" (punctuated by the occasional "Kill the Jew!") are simply nauseating.
Some images are seared into my memory forever. I will never forget the two boys in their underwear — one with his eye socket hanging out of his face — asking his brother whether he thinks they're going to die, while the Hamas monster who had just thrown a grenade in their saferoom helps himself to a drink from their fridge, taking a casual break from the slaughter.
Neither will I ever forget the terrorists playing football with a severed head. Or the Thai migrant worker whose head is viciously hacked off with a garden hoe — another "Zionist colonizer" getting what he deserved, right?quillette.substack.com/p/what-did-you-think-decolonisation
Or the throngs of Gazans crowding around pickup trucks loaded with the mutilated corpses of Jewish women, filming and spitting on the bodies. Or the woman in Kibbutz Mefalsim, crouching and begging in vain for mercy.
There is some evidence of sexual violence in the video — the charred corpse of a young woman with her legs splayed and her genitals exposed — but not much. Apparently even Hamas draws a line somewhere: they are not as proud of raping Jewish women as they are of murdering them. Or, more likely, they simply didn't want to embarrass the delicate sensibilities of their legions of useful idiots in the West.
But yes — there was rape. Not "rape" in scare quotes, as the apologists would have it, but sadistic, murderous sexual violence, documented in a new damning new report by The Civil Commission, an independent Israeli women's rights NGO. (video summary here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=K7fJuzr4wkU)
Across its 180 pages, the report describes "a recurring pattern of rape and gang rape; sexual torture; mutilation; targeted shooting to the face, head and genital area; forced nudity; binding and restraint; genital burning; objects inserted into intimate areas; post-mortem sexual humiliation; and execution during or after sexual assault."
And it was premeditated and organized. The terrorists crossing into Israel carried printed Arabic-to-Hebrew phrasebooks with handy expressions like "take off your pants," "lie down," "spread your legs," and "don't make trouble." I wonder why they expected to need those particular phrases?
I know one thing: no civilized country on earth would tolerate the existence of an organization like Hamas on its border after October 7th. Not one. This includes every self-righteous Westerner currently lecturing Israel from thousands of kilometres away, without an inch of skin in the game.
www.dailymail.com/news/article-15807431/Full-depravity-Ha… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
How many Western media outlets have already retracted the Hamas-fabricated claim that “70% of casualties in Gaza are women and children” — or even “75–80%,” according to the honorary PhD holder @FranceskAlbs?
This utterly false statistic was used for more than two years to buttress accusations of “genocide.” In reality, the casualties in Gaza are overwhelmingly male and of fighting age, while women and children were killed at rates far below their share of the population.
Does anyone care? In the Belgian and Dutch media — which repeated the “70%” blood libel repeatedly — I have seen absolutely nothing. No corrections, no retractions, not even fact-checks of Albanese’s deranged claims. Zilches.
“Adult male deaths in Gaza are 3.3x higher than adult female deaths, with older teenage males similarly disproportionate at 2.8x higher. Women and children were killed at rates far below their share of the population, which definitively contradicts claims of indiscriminate bombing or deliberate targeting of women and children.”
Aizenberg
@Aizenberg55
This is one of the key charts of the war. It shows that adult male deaths in Gaza are 3.3x higher than adult female deaths, with older teenage males similarly disproportionate at 2.8x higher. Women and children were killed at rates far below their share of the population, which definitively contradicts claims of indiscriminate bombing or deliberate targeting of women and children. If such targeting were occurring, civilian deaths would at minimum resemble the population’s age and gender structure.
Instead, the chart shows a large excess of adult male deaths, roughly 23,000 excess adult men, and when excess male teens, many of whom are documented combatants, are included, the total closely corroborates the IDF’s claim that about 25,000 combatants were killed, a figure publicly affirmed by the United States.
Rather than contend with this evidence, critics have come up with a new talking point: men always die more than women in wars, so the pattern proves nothing. Meaning that they claim these excess male deaths are civilians not combatants, all said without evidence. With that logic in place it makes it impossible to ever identify large-scale combatant deaths, because any excess male mortality is dismissed by definition as “what happens in war.”
Comparisons to other conflicts are also misplaced. Gaza is structurally different on many levels from the wars commonly cited as evidence, such as Yemen, Syria, Congo, or Tigray. For example, Gaza had repeated mass evacuations and was the only war in history where one side facilitated massive quantities of food and humanitarian aid throughout active combat. In another post I will show statistics that contradict this claim as well.
Crucially, no affirmative evidence is presented that adult male civilians in Gaza died at much higher rates than women; that claim is simply assumed by analogy to other, dissimilar wars. The effect of this reasoning is to ensure that excess male deaths can never be attributed to combatants, while simultaneously sidelining specific, evidence-backed claims about Hamas losses. The irony is also striking; many of the same voices accusing Israel of targeting women and children must also argue that Gaza followed the standard wartime pattern of excess male deaths. Both cannot be true.
Chart credited to @GabrielEpsteinX -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In his celebrated book Dominion, the British historian @holland_tom argues that virtually all the achievements of the modern world are indebted to a moral revolution wrought by Christianity: human rights, social security, science, gender equality — it’s all supposedly there in the Bible, if you read between the lines.
Holland is a brilliant writer and podcaster, and I loved some of his earlier books, but I really hated this one. It’s a long exercise in what I’d call retrorevelation: the annoying habit of religious apologists — mostly Christians — of retroactively claiming credit for all the things they once fought tooth and nail against, or all the things you can find in a gazillion other cultural traditions. The overall argument feels very superficial, attributing all manner of things to Christianity without seriously comparing it to non-Christian cultures and traditions.
Yes, many Renaissance and Enlightenment thinkers framed their innovations in Christian terms. But in the suffocating intellectual climate of early modern Europe, Biblical justification was often the only way to make new ideas socially and politically viable, no matter how opportunistic the connection. Besides, early Christians were hardly unique in preaching radical moral ideals like loving your enemy or turning the other cheek. Such counterintuitive ethical systems were common across Axial Age traditions.*
And for one thing, despite its lofty ideals, Christians never seriously considered abolishing slavery for more than a millennium and a half, and there is nothing in the Bible that clearly condemns the institution. On the contrary, slaves are repeatedly instructed to obey their masters. Yes, abolitionists invoked Christian justifications, but so did their pro-slavery opponents (with many Bible verses to back them up). As far as I know, the only ancient authors who explicitly opposed slavery on moral grounds were pagans, not Christians — figures like the Greek rhetorician Alcidamas and the poet Philemon in the 4th century BC. And on the “good side” of antiquity, I can find nothing in the Bible that is even remotely as beautiful, uplifting, and humane as De Rerum Natura by Lucretius, who had never heard of Jesus.
I’ve long wanted to write a critical review of Dominion, but never got around to it. This excellent piece by @RichardHanania is more or less the review I wish I had written myself — though you’ll need a subscription to read the full piece. As Hanania writes: “[Holland’s] method can just devolve into haphazardly associating general concepts that look similar to one another in the service of a narrative that sounds good.”
The book is full of vivid characters and engaging stories, but it becomes increasingly absurd toward the end, when Holland tries to trace virtually everything back to Christianity.
Marxism? Basically secularized Christianity: radical equality, concern for the oppressed, redemption of the outcast.
Nazism? Holland even suggests that the Nazi desire to “purify” the world echoed Christian ideas of cleansing evil and redeeming humanity. He writes:
“Yet Hitler, even as he cast his campaign against them as a matter of public health, would often assimilate it to another narrative: a profoundly Christian one. To be saved, the world had to be cleansed. A people threatened by perdition required redemption.”
Needless to say, wokeness is also Christian to the core.
It’s been a while since I read his book, so apologies to Tom Holland if I’ve simplified or misrepresented some parts of the argument — perhaps I’ll write a proper review one day.
* For the record, I’m not a historian of religion, but this is what Claude had to say about Axial Age religions:
“Yes, this is a well-documented observation among historians of religion and philosophy. The Axial Age (roughly 800–200 BCE, a term coined by Karl Jaspers) saw a remarkable convergence across several civilizations, where thinkers independently developed moral and ethical frameworks that challenged conventional human instincts like tribalism, revenge, and self-interest.
- Buddhism (5th century BCE) is perhaps the most striking example. The Buddha taught mettā (loving-kindness) toward all beings, including those who harm you. The Dhammapada contains passages urging practitioners to overcome hatred with love and to respond to anger with calm — very close in spirit to ‘love your enemy.’
- Confucianism and Mohism in China offered related ideas. While Confucius was more measured (when asked about repaying injury with kindness, he replied ‘repay injury with justice’), Mozi (5th century BCE) went further with his doctrine of jiān ài (universal or impartial love), arguing that people should care for strangers and even rival states as much as their own — a radically counterintuitive position that was widely debated precisely because it cut against natural partiality.
- Jainism developed ahimsa (non-violence) to an extreme degree, extending compassion and non-harm to all living creatures, including insects. This demanded extraordinary self-discipline and restraint even toward those who might threaten you.
- Stoicism in Greece taught that all human beings share in a universal rational nature, and that anger and vengeance are failures of reason. Marcus Aurelius (though later than the Axial Age proper) wrote extensively about responding to hostility with understanding rather than retaliation, building on earlier Stoic foundations.
- Zoroastrianism emphasized the moral duty to actively choose good over evil, framing ethics as a cosmic struggle that required personal sacrifice and integrity beyond mere self-interest.
- The Hebrew prophetic tradition — figures like Amos, Hosea, and Isaiah — challenged their own society with demands for justice toward the poor, the stranger, and the marginalized, often at great personal cost.”
www.richardhanania.com/p/jesus-ancient-revolutionary-but-not -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Calling Israel a “settler-colonialist” state is not just factually and morally wrong — it’s a complete inversion of reality. Israel is arguably the most successful ANTI-colonial endeavour in history: a people returning to their ancestral homeland after 3,000 years of exile, conquest, and foreign domination by Romans, Arabs, Ottomans, Britons, and other assorted colonizers. quillette.com/2026/05/07/israels-creation-the-ultimate-de…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Students are massively cheating their way through college, outsourcing all their essays and assignments to AI. And professors? Many are using the same AI tools to grade those AI-generated papers. So the entire education system is starting to look like a digital hall or mirrors, a hallucinated conversation "between two robots — or maybe even just one".
nymag.com/intelligencer/article/openai-chatgpt-ai-cheatin… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
You know what’s striking? Almost no one even bothers anymore to address the substance of the accusation that Israel is committing “genocide” in Gaza. Every time I post about this, the reactions fall into two categories:
➡️“This is semantic hair-splitting and nitpicking. Who cares what you call it? Why are you so obsessed with that word?”
So 𝘐’𝘮 obsessed with the word? For over two years, everyone and their dog has been forced to ritually utter the g-word: newspapers, politicians, academics, NGOs. No other denunciation of Israel’s war would satisfy the activists. And now, all of a sudden, it’s “just semantics”? We’re talking about the “crime of crimes” here, a separate category of evil coined after the greatest atrocity of the modern era. This attitude reveals an astonishing flippancy that we would never tolerate in any other context (“The West committed genocide in Mosul and Raqqa!” / “Churchill committed genocide in Dresden!”).
➡️ “Here’s a list of organizations that say it is a genocide. Checkmate.”
This is pure argument from authority — and a weak one at that. NGOs are unelected, self-appointed cliques increasingly infected by ideology, not scientific bodies with rigorous quality standards. Besides, that near-unanimity is precisely my point: every NGO and academic department has been pressured for more than two years to publish its own sham report concluding “genocide,” regurgitating the same laundry list of fabricated or distorted quotes supposedly proving “intent,” and copying each other’s shoddy arguments. It’s the worst kind of citation ring.
But something has shifted. The remarkable unwillingness of these people to actually defend their case betrays its weakness (maartenboudry.substack.com/p/they-dont-believe-it-either). Deep down, they realize this whole thing is nonsense from start to finish.
When the dust settles, this canard will go down in history as one of the greatest lies of our time. No other form of “fake news” has enjoyed such enthusiastic support from cultural and academic elites. Many colleagues and friends have deeply disappointed me here, because they either failed to speak out against this lie or caved under pressure and uttered the g-word themselves (I won’t mention names — there are too many anyway).
I hesitated to use the term at first, but I think Steven Pinker (@sapinker) is right: this is the modern version of the “blood libel,” the medieval fable that Jews used the blood of Christian children in the preparation of matzah for Passover. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Are AIs about to subjugate humanity?
In the debate about catastrophic AI risk, evolutionary scenarios receive far too little attention compared to largely speculative arguments about “instrumental convergence” (aka “you can’t fetch the coffee if you’re dead”).
Yet evolution is a known mechanism for producing selfish, power-seeking agents—and it is substrate-neutral, operating in silico just as readily as in carbon.
That’s why it’s encouraging to see three heavyweights in evolutionary biology and AI weigh in with an important new paper in PNAS, building on arguments from @hendrycks and my own work with @simonfriederich.
I'll write a post about the paper soon!
www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2527700123?__readwiseLocation= -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Just as the American Right has jettisoned its own liberal tradition and embraced a corrupt and reactionary cult of personality, the Left seems to be preparing the ground for its own betrayal." quillette.com/2026/04/19/hasan-piker-is-the-enemy-ezra-kl…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
On the almost total liquidation of millennia-old Jewish communities across the Arab world:
“There is no UN agency for these refugees, no annual day of mourning recognized by the UN General Assembly, no special rapporteur, no international fund, no permanent refugee population maintained across generations as a political instrument.” www.futureofjewish.com/p/the-ethnic-cleansing-no-one-ment… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
On a personal note: I studied and worked at @UGent for over two decades, with only brief periods elsewhere (Boston, NY, Budapest, Vienna, Leuven). I was also the first holder of the Etienne Vermeersch Chair at UGent for four years, under the previous rector.
I don’t regret any of this. On the contrary, I remain very grateful to @UGent for the honour of being the first holder of that prestigious Chair. The philosopher Etienne Vermeersch, former vice-rector of @UGent, remains one of my personal intellectual heroes. His scepticism, liberalism, and defence of rationality and science have had a lasting and salutary influence on the university.
During my time as Chair holder, UGent gave me almost complete freedom to develop my ideas and projects, despite some internal backlash. Even when I ventured into controversial territory—such as in my opening lectures and my podcast Forbidden Territory (Verboden Terrein)—I did not experience ideological censorship or pressure (with one exception during an interview for the UGent magazine).
In recent years, however, I have grown increasingly estranged from my alma mater. I have watched the growing ideological capture with mounting concern, especially since the election of the new rector. Even before that, I was shocked and dismayed that UGent played a leading role in the anti-Israel boycott, on what I believe very shaky grounds. To me, this represents a serious abdication of the core principles of academic freedom and institutional neutrality.
Within my own department, the intellectual climate has also deteriorated—particularly in the aftermath of 7 October and following the departure of my former supervisor, Johan Braeckman, and his research group.
To be clear: I have had many rewarding years at UGent, and I still maintain good relationships with several former colleagues who continue to do excellent work. But given the scandals and embarrassments in recent years, I regret to say that I was no longer proud of my affiliation with UGent.
The academic world as a whole is in crisis, being increasingly captured by ideology, but unfortunately @UGent has become one of the worst offenders.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The lunatics have definitively taken over the asylum. Activists masked with keffiyehs are AGAIN illegally occupying the campus—despite the disgraceful boycott @UGent has already agreed to, and despite the fact that the new rector is as leftist and rabidly anti-Israel as they come. And what does she do? Put on the kiddy gloves and grovel in front of them—only to be arrogantly rebuffed: "We will invite you". It pains me to say this, but I’m glad I left @UGent.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The lunatics have definitively taken over the asylum. Activists masked with keffiyehs are AGAIN illegally occupying the campus—despite the disgraceful boycott @UGent has already agreed to, and despite the fact that the new rector is as leftist and rabidly anti-Israel as they come. And what does she do? Put on the kiddy gloves and grovel in front of them—only to be arrogantly rebuffed: "We will invite you". It pains me to say this, but I’m glad I left @UGent.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Phenomenal piece by @MattiFriedman on "Gazology", the novel genre of writing that uses Gaza not as a subject but as a stage—for psychodrama, personal vanity, a quest for meaning, a metaphysics of evil. Everything except the strip of land and its inhabitants.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hot take: niet-Europese migranten zijn sterk oververtegenwoordigd in criminaliteitsstatistieken, zeker bij verkrachting en terrorisme. (Lees o.a. @Ruud_Koop_mans, @Ayaan Hirsi Ali en @demo_demo_nl)
Beste Openbaar Ministerie (@Het_OM), gaat u mij nu ook dagvaarden omdat ik “veralgemenend en negatief” spreek over “bepaalde groepen in de samenleving”? Omdat ik me bezondig aan "een sterk wij-zijdenken"?
Nog eentje, om u te helpen: 90% van alle moorden en 98% van alle verkrachtingen worden gepleegd door één groep in onze samenleving — mannen. Mannen zijn bij uitstek het grootste probleem voor onze veiligheid. Krijg ik er ook een fikse boete voor mannenhaat bij?
Ik heb @DVanLangenhove eerder een fascist genoemd (hij bewondert Oswald Mosley), maar het is volstrekt absurd dat hij wordt vervolgd voor uitspraken over het verband tussen criminaliteit en migratie. Zelfs indien Van Langenhove statistieken overdrijft of verdraait. Het is niét aan een rechter om mensen daarover de mond te snoeren.
En dat terwijl aanhangers van terreurorganisaties als Hamas straffeloos onze steden onveilig maken, en salafistische haatboeken in boekenhandels liggen.
Dit is een liberale samenleving onwaardig. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Remember when this guy was hailed as a Great Thinker by liberal elites, speaking "truth to power"?
In 2015, Russell Brand was voted the fourth most influential thinker alive by Prospect. His book Revolution was praised by a roster of @Guardian writers, with Owen Jones calling it “funny, full of charm, and engaging,” and Vonny Moyes “a dialogue we all need to be having.” Newspapers gushed over his shows as “the best comedy show ever,” claiming they “bear witness to profound insights into society.” Even academic journals described him as “an authentic anti-austerity spokesperson for the disenfranchised left.”
The truth is that Brand was always an obvious fraud—an unhinged conspiracist and narcissist who could pivot on a dime from left-wing posturing to right-wing nuttery. The political horseshoe incarnate.
And a sexual predator, of course.
Gadget
@Gadget440
During his interview with Piers Morgan, Russell Brand got increasingly defensive and didn't want to answer any questions.
Here are the final moments when he melted down:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Four years ago, I was invited by the Mathias Corvinus Collegium in Hungary (@MCC_Budapest), affiliated with Orbán's Fidesz party, to spend a week in Budapest hosting a workshop and giving media interviews on climate policy, following my piece in @Quillette. All expenses covered!
On the surface, it looked like an attractive offer, and they made sure to include some fulsome flattery. Knowing that they were affiliated with Fidesz, I also understood why they reached out. My essay attacked several tenets of left-wing climate orthodoxy, including the irrational opposition to nuclear energy and other technological innovations.
Moreover, I know from experience that mainstream academic institutions and climate organizations would never ever invite someone like me, precisely because I challenge the prevailing orthodoxy. Even defending nuclear energy is enough to be labeled a "climate denialist" by the likes of @NaomiOreskes. So why not accept this generous offer to spend a week in Budapest to bask in the glow of their adulation?
Still, I’m glad I turned down the offer, and I made sure to explain my reasons clearly. At the time, it was already abundantly clear that Orbán was a corrupt and illiberal autocrat who wanted to impose his own orthodoxy on universities—shutting down gender studies programs and cracking down on Central European University, eventually driving them out of the country.
Regrettably, some of my heterodox friends and colleagues have become so consumed by their hatred of leftist/woke dogma that they’ve drifted into the orbit of corrupt right-wing authoritarians (Orbán in the case of Europe, MAGA for Americans). I can understand their frustrations, as academia is a hostile environment for heterodox thinkers, especially for those who are openly conservative and right-wing (which I’m not).
But remember that the enemy of your enemy is not always your friend, and that sometimes the remedy is worse than the cure. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I used to roll my eyes at the notion of "decolonising the curriculum"—just harmless virtue signalling, I thought. Then October 7th happened, and colleagues I respected were celebrating a jihadist massacre within hours. Progressive friends were pinning all the blame on Israel. My new essay for @Quillette on how I was terribly wrong to be so insouciant. quillette.com/2026/04/20/what-did-you-think-decolonisatio…
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I used to roll my eyes at calls to “decolonise the curriculum”—just harmless virtue signalling, I thought. Then October 7th happened. Within hours, colleagues I respected were celebrating a jihadist massacre, while progressive friends rushed to pin all the blame on Israel.
My latest essay for @Quillette on how I was terribly wrong to be so insouciant. (Quillette allows me to cross-post my pieces on my own Substack. So if you don't have a Quillette subscription, make sure to read it here! That said, you should totally subscribe to Quillette, which is excellent overall.)
quillette.substack.com/p/what-did-you-think-decolonisation -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hey professor, ik heb meer dan 6 keer zoveel publicaties als u in Web of Science, en bijna 4 keer zoveel citaties. En dat terwijl u al bezig bent van voor ik geboren was. Als ik een "puur product van mediatisering" ben, wat bent u dan? @EricCorijn
Eric Corijn
@EricCorijn
U denkt echt een belangrijk deel te zijn van het maatschappelijk debat, niet? Terwijl u een puur product bent van mediatisering.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Iran heeft net 20.000 van zijn eigen burgers afgeslacht, executeert al jaren homoseksuelen en afvalligen, verminkt jonge vrouwen voor het leven omdat ze hun haar tonen, en wil atoomwapens voor zijn apocalyptische strijd tegen de Zionisten. Maar zolang ze maar anti-westers zijn, krijgen ze de volle steun van @Aboujahjah: "Eerlijk: ik hoop dat Iran standhoudt. Iran vecht volgens mij voor de hele mensheid, omdat het zich verzet tegen het megalomane project van Netanyahu en Trump." Heb jij zelf geen dochters, Dyab? Schaam je dood. /2 www.demorgen.be/nieuws/dyab-abou-jahjah-voor-mij-is-de-zo…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I received this heartbreaking message from a Jewish professor at @UAntwerpen, who is leaving both the city and the university after four decades. I can hardly express how deeply this saddens and enrages me—especially in light of last week’s craven and disgraceful charade surrounding the honorary doctorate of @FranceskAlbs.
"After fifty years living in Antwerp and forty years at the University of Antwerp as student, assistant and professor, I’m leaving. I no longer feel at home in the city and feel completely estranged from my university that has become a hotbed of radicalism and has completely lost its sense of academic values of critical thinking, discussion and genuine diversity of viewpoints. I fear that the student generation that – with the support of the university authorities - has now become indoctrinated and brainwashed to a point of no return. My son who was born and raised in Antwerp and who wears a kippa, has been called a child murderer on the street by a Flemish person and was told to “get out of here”. At the university the students are shouting that Jews should get out of Palestine. He and his family are leaving too. It just became a bad place for Jews."
This is on you, rectors. You have made universities into hostile places for Jews (unless they ritually denounce zionism and Israel). They will abandon you and take all their learning, knowledge and wisdom with them.
And don't worry, @UGent, you have scarcely any Jewish professors left to begin with. The great Jewish linguist and classicist Julien Klener has long since retired. When I met him recently, he told me how relieved he is not to have to endure this ideological madness anymore. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Zullen we voortaan afspreken dat alle "progressieve" recensensten die jubelen bij skatende nonnen, brandende bijbels, beffende vrouwen op een fluorescerend christenkruis en lesbische pausen in hun recensie één klein cartoontje van Mohammed toevoegen? Niet eens met een fellatio door de 9-jarige Aishah of zo, maar dat mag gerust.
En zullen we afspreken dat alle "progressieve" regisseurs die moedig het religieuze "patriarchaat" uitdagen de volgende keer ook één masturberende vrouw in een chador op het podium zetten? Eén paginaatje uit de Koran in de fik misschien? Of één bescheiden gangbangetje op een halve maan? Eens zien hoeveel "moed" er dan nog overschiet.
(Deze recensent komt bijna klaar van zoveel "rebellie" tegen het "patriarchaat": "Je wil gewoon je kleren uitzwieren, mee op het podium springen en met deze balorige bende jezelf bevrijden.") -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Zelfs een ezel stoot zich geen duizend keer aan dezelfde steen. Je. Kunt. Activisten. Niet. Pleasen.
Onze rectoren lieten hun universiteiten bezetten door activisten, gingen gedwee met geblinddoekte actievoerders in gesprek, putten zich uit in excuses en spraken vol lof over hun inzet. Ze schortten samenwerkingen met Israël op, vroegen Europa om Israël uit het associatieverdrag te gooien en richtten nieuwe programma’s op voor Palestijnse universiteiten. Werkelijk álles om in de gratie van de activisten te komen.
Als ultiem zoenoffer reikten ze zelfs een eredoctoraat uit aan de grootste heldin van die activisten, die grossiert in complottheorieën, antiwesterse ideologie en antisemitisme. Gezamenlijk, met drie universiteiten — voor het eerst in de geschiedenis!
En nóg is het niet genoeg. Anti-zionistische scherpslijpers zoals prof. Koen Bogaert zijn nu boos omdat de rector van @UAntwerpen één minieme kanttekening plaatste bij het eredoctoraat voor Francesca Albanese: namelijk dat de uitreiking niet tegen Joden gericht was.
"Herwig Leirs, rector van de UA, vond het nodig te benadrukken dat dit geen eredoctoraat was tégen de Joodse gemeenschap, of tégen een specifieke Joodse organisatie."
Schokkend — hoe waagt die onverlaat het! Wat Bogaert eist, is een laudatio "zonder kritische noot, zonder kanttekeningen, zonder opmerkingen over de ‘gevoeligheid’ van hun werk." (Dit is een letterlijk citaat, geen parafrase.)
Durf te denken? Nee: stilzitten en slikken, rectoren.
www.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=10164479421093748&i… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A keffiyeh-wearing fanatic assaulted philosopher @nathancofnas yesterday after a talk, hurling a bottle at his head. The perpetrator is a student at the faculty, but I won't reveal his name until the evidence is reported to the police. The university should investigate and immediately expel him.
And let’s be clear: every academic who has been loudly demanding Cofnas’ resignation now has a responsibility to unequivocally condemn this violence.
If no actions are taken, the inmates will have taken over the asylum.
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
Just gave a talk on wokism to the Catholic Flemish Student Union at UGent.
Afterward, some woke anti-Semites responded with the only counterargument they have, i.e., violence. I was assaulted twice with a bottle of something hurled at my face. Then they ran away on a motorcycle. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Three Flemish universities are disgracing themselves today by awarding an honorary doctorate to a mendacious antisemite (@FranceskAlbs). That's what happens when academia gets hijacked by far-left ideologues. Holocaust historian Norman Goda: "The Flemish universities, whether they admit it or not, will convey the sanction of university-recognised expertise to a deeply dishonest and fraudulent individual who has vilified an entire society as well as those persons, including many in Belgium who view themselves as connected to it." @UGent @UAntwerpen @VUBrussel quillette.com/2026/04/02/francesca-albanese-and-the-perve…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Extremist settlers in the West Bank are now acting with near impunity—and no longer feel the need to hide their faces. Why would they? They know the government will turn a blind eye and that figures like Itamar Ben Gvir are firmly on their side. Fania Oz-Salzberger (@faniaoz) doesn't mince words:
"Settler gangs terrorising their Palestinian neighbours is not a new phenomenon, but it has cascaded in recent months and peaked under the smoke of the Iran war. [...] With an air force successfully pounding Iran without losing a single aircraft and an intelligence corps able to infiltrate Tehran’s digital traffic systems to spy on Iranian leaders, the Israeli military is suddenly at a loss when it comes to what Netanyahu still insists are “70 teenagers from broken homes”." www.jewishnews.co.uk/settler-violence-is-corroding-israel… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ja, die achterbakse Joden orchestreren vast hun eigen terreuraanslagen. Natuurlijk is dit totaal verzonnen: de beelden doken eerst op in Pro-Iraanse Telegramkanalen. Dat sommige kwaliteitskranten een antisemitische complotfantast als @Youssef_Kobo een column geven, is mij een raadsel.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ik ben jullie allemaal afgetroefd, zelfs @torfsrik en @DoornaertMia samen.😈 En ik heb niet eens een vaste column! Mijn irritatiegraad (opgewekte ergernis per gepubliceerd woord) moet stratosferisch zijn. 🥳
Mia Doornaert
@DoornaertMia
Las lijst van gefrustreerde freelancer, gaande van 10 naar 1, met groeiende ongerustheid dat ik er niet op zou staan. Oef, gedeelde zilveren médaille met Rik Torfs. Aanmoediging om verder ‘onverveerd, ongeknecht’ te blijven spreken en schrijven.
Rik Torfs
@torfsrik
Journalist Frank Van Laeken stelde een lijst op van columnisten en opiniemakers die 'niet meer thuis horen in de media'. Een interessant compendium voor andere tegenstanders van de vrijheid van meningsuiting. Onmiddellijk bruikbaar voor repressie.
maandans.frankvanlaeken.eu/2026/03/28/ad-hominem-weg-met-… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I know it sounds crazy, but rather than trying to cancel, shut down, fire or even prosecute @nathancofnas for his controversial views on race and IQ, why not just engage with him? He will actually respond. 😱Here's Cofnas and I engaging in a discussion about Harvard's statistics and his claim about "Black professors", in the comment section of my piece. substacktools.com/sharex/ODiTMIkx
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Some inconvenient truths for those of us who want to “solve” the fertility crisis: motherhood is not rational, especially for highly educated, talented and ambitious women:
“The problem isopportunity cost, not cost, and if you cannot understand the difference you cannot understand the problem. Parents are poorer relative to their childless peers, relative to where they themselves would be had they not had kids.”
Excellent piece from @SarahTheHaider, and very engaging and humorous writing to boot! -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
“Degrowth communism” may be the most spectacular case of sour-grapes reasoning in modern history:
Stage 1: "Communism will unleash tremendous growth!"
Stage 2: “OK, but real communism has never been tried” (rinse & repeat)
Stage 3: "Hmm, well, even “real” communism doesn’t deliver growth after all."
Stage 4: "Actually, growth is BAD!" -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ja, @idevisch, stel je voor dat academici vandaag een theorie zouden aanhangen waarvan de "ondeugdelijkheid" allang is aangetoond, en die "de basis heeft gelegd voor politiek moorddadige regimes". Dat zou echt on-denk-baar zijn. Geen plaats voor in de wetenschap! Behalve die 17% professoren in de sociale wetenschappen die nog steeds "Marxisme" aanhangen (ca. 100 miljoen doden).
Maar dat is "links" radicalisme natuurlijk, dus dat is prima. Ideologie is zoals een slechte adem: je ruikt het niet bij jezelf. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Why I signed this statement in support of @nathancofnas.
substacktools.com/sharex/ODiTMIkx
Francesca Minerva
@FranciMinerva
A statement in support of Nathan Cofnas's right to academic freedom, signed by more than 120 academics drive.google.com/file/d/1RRsGmaZcLQZpNwMkibfIp3FiyHYkD0tO… @ugent @nathancofnas
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Als de @ugent zwicht voor de druk om @nathancofnas te ontslaan, krimpt opnieuw een stuk academische vrijheid. Pseudowetenschap mocht jarenlang bloeien aan onze vakgroep (hallo Jacques Lacan), maar één verboden hypothese en plots wil men koppen zien rollen. Bovendien blijkt uit anonieme peilingen dat véél meer intelligentie-onderzoekers het met de hypothese van Cofnas eens zijn (ongeveer de helft). Moet je verbaasd zijn dat er zoveel zelfcensuur heerst, met dit soort collectieve pogingen tot broodroof? Universiteiten die “gevaarlijke ideeën” verbieden, verraden hun kernopdracht. Ik verdedig niet wat Nathan Cofnas zegt — wel zijn recht om het te onderzoeken en ongeremd zijn meningen daarover te uiten.
www.demorgen.be/meningen/als-de-ugent-zwicht-krimpt-opnie… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A few years ago I recorded an episode of my podcast Forbidden Territory for @UGent (in Dutch) about the heritability of IQ. We also touched on the third rail of racial differences. Why? Because I believe academics should be free to investigate even the most “dangerous ideas.”
My guest, Han van der Maas (a renowned IQ researcher at the University of Amsterdam), explained that individual IQ differences are highly heritable, but that he does not believe in differences between racial groups. His statistical and methodological arguments (e.g. Simpson paradox) convinced me at the time. Still, he hedged his bets: it remains possible that future evidence might show racial differences. And researchers should be free to investigate that hypothesis.
Forty-five colleagues from my former philosophy department apparently think otherwise. They are urging the rector to fire @nathancofnas because he claims that the IQ gap between racial groups (such as whites and blacks in the US — differences that are themselves not disputed) may have partly genetic causes, rather than purely social ones like marginalization or discrimination. They label this “pseudoscience and racism.”
I understand why many people are shocked by Cofnas’s claims. But this clearly falls within the scope of academic freedom.
For years, the psychoanalysis of Jacques Lacan was taught and researched at my department — a complete pseudoscience. Dozens of theses and PhDs were written about it, all scientifically worthless. No one batted an eye. Unlike my colleagues, I published several papers explaining why (Lacanian) psychoanalysis is pseudoscientific (drive.google.com/file/d/0B_K-qtp6iiL1M0Nuam5qSWhybHM/view…). Yet I never demanded that my colleagues be fired.
None of the signatories have any peer-reviewed publications on IQ or genetics. I have a letter recommending Cofnas' work on IQ from the editor-in-chief of the prestigious journal Intelligence. Even if the hypothesis of racial IQ differences could be shown to belong to the realm of pseudoscience, that still would not justify dismissal.
If @UGent caves in to this demand, it will be another blow to academic freedom at my alma mater — following the new rector’s illiberal statements suggesting that researchers questioning the safety of vaccines or the Gaza “genocide” are “crossing a line that must not be crossed.”
Such calls for dismissal from people without any expertise are also strategically unwise, as they only fuel “red-pilling.” When academics appear determined to suppress a dangerous idea at all costs, people understandably get suspicious: "What are they trying to hide?" And so trust in academia erodes further.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YHhbWmjb6ug -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Jürgen Habermas (1929-2026) forcefully rejected the obscene charge of "genocide" in Gaza: "Despite all the concern for the fate of the Palestinian population, the standards of judgement slip completely when genocidal intentions are attributed to Israel’s actions." R.I.P.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
One of my favorite thinkers: few books changed my worldview more than @stewartbrand's Whole Earth Discipline: "We are as Gods and HAVE to get good at it". Such an uplifting, curious, ambitious, roll-up-your-sleeves-and-get-things-done vision of our future. www.theguardian.com/technology/2026/feb/25/tech-legend-st…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
As time passes, it becomes clear how ludicrous the claim that Israel committed "genocide" in Gaza has always been. It isn’t even close: there’s not a scintilla of evidence for it, and overwhelming evidence against it. Another takedown by an international lawyer & military expert.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Prof. @gertdecooman is lid van de Raad van Bestuur van @UGent en distantieert zich (terecht) van het eredoctoraat aan Francesca Albanese. Trek u terug uit deze farce, @UGent, nu het nog kan. Wie universiteiten inschakelt voor politiek activisme, keldert het publieke vertrouwen.
Gert de Cooman
@gertdecooman
Het moet me van het hart. Ik vind het toekennen van een institutioneel eredoctoraat aan Francesca Albanese ongelukkig en onverstandig. Ik distantieer me ervan.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Why do people believe crazy stuff? It's because they fall for “fallacies”, we're told. Memorize the classics (ad hominem, post hoc, straw man) and you’ll be inoculated against error.
It's a neat little story, and I used to believe it too. But I've become a fallacy apostate. 🧵/1 -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Much of this misanthropy may amount to posturing—a form of covert self-aggrandisement concealed behind the grammar of the “self-excluding we.” When flagellants declare that “we” are a cancer on the planet, they quietly exempt themselves and the environmentally enlightened."
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Why does eco-misanthropy flourish in the West? Is it a relic of Christianity? Perhaps the answer is simpler: only rich, safe societies can afford to romanticise nature—and then hate humanity for disturbing an imaginary “natural harmony.” Essay for @TheBTI. www.breakthroughjournal.org/p/is-green-misanthropy-a-uniq…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ik zou zelfs verder gaan: er is te wéinig inkomensongelijkheid in België, waardoor we bv. niet aantrekkelijk zijn voor buitenlands toptalent. De arbeidsmarkt is te "stroperig" (@IveMarx & @GertPeersman) door combo van index en loonnorm. Nauwelijks prikkels om talent te belonen.
Gerard Govers
@gerardgovers
België is, als het over ongelijkheid en welvaart van gezinnen gaat, een ongelofelijke sucesstory: we hebben zowat de laagste inkomensongelijkheid ter wereld én het mediane vermogen (dus niet het gemiddelde) van de gezinnen is zowat het allerhoogste ter wereld. Niet slecht voor een mislukt land en het zou écht geen kwaad kunnen om dat ook duidelijk te maken aan de lezers van @destandaard
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Over 100 Holocaust Scholars Protest Misuse of the Word “Genocide” in Gaza. Shame on everyone who participated in this "Holocaust inversion". It is an insult to all the victims of the Holocaust and of every other REAL genocide.
freebeacon.com/america/nothing-less-than-holocaust-invers… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Het is leugen bovenop leugen. Nu beweert De Sutter dat ze een bestaand betoog van Einstein uit 1916 "samenvatte" (tekst bestaat niet), maar dat AI dat parafraseerde omdat letterlijk citeren niet mag (onzin) Zoals @Lievenvdhaute zegt: "Het houdt niet op!" www.vrt.be/vrtmax/luister/radio/n/nieuwe-feiten~11-9/nieu…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Is the Earth flat or round?"
"I'm not sure what the goal of the question is"
"The goal is to establish scientfic reality. Is it flat or not?"
"Again, as I'm saying—"
"FLAT OR ROUND?"
"I think yes-no questions like this are political tools"
THIS insanity is what got Trump elected
Eric Daugherty
@EricLDaugh
🚨 HOLY CRAP. This actually just happened on Capitol Hill.
SEN. JOSH HAWLEY: "Can men get pregnant?"
LIBERAL DR. VERMA: "I'm not sure what the goal of the question is."
HAWLEY: "The goal is to establish a biological reality. Can men get pregnant?"
VERMA: "I take care of people with many identities."
HAWLEY: "Can men get pregnant?"
VERMA: "Again, as I'm saying-"
HAWLEY: "You said science and evidence should control. Can men get pregnant? You're a doctor, I think."
VERMA: "Science and evidence should guide medicine."
HAWLEY: "Do science and evidence tell us that men can get pregnant?"
VERMA: "I think yes-no questions like this are a political tool."
WOW. 🤯🤯🤯 @HawleyMOThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
From Charlie Hebdo to Theo Van Gogh, from the Dutch "Jew hunt" to Pakistani grooming gangs—Western leaders' response to Islamic extremism has been to appease the perpetrators & blame the victims. But then we all act butt-hurt when the U.S. accuses us of "civilizational erasure"?
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Years of protests to “liberate” a Palestine that never existed from imaginary colonialism. Now comes the chance to support an actual liberation struggle against colonialism—Islam was imposed by Arab conquest—and progressives fall silent. If it’s not anti-Western, they don’t care.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In 1979, Michel Foucault—still a towering figure on the Left—enthusiastically cheered the Iranian Revolution. Why? The ayatollahs opposed Western “imperialism,” and Islam was cast as a force of “spiritual” awakening. Half a century later, this campist delusion still endures.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Los van het bedrog zelf, is het ook onvoorstelbaar dom. Dus GPT spuwt een banale tegeltjeswijsheid uit, zogezegd van Einstein aan de Sorbonne (in het Engels!), en dan heeft noch De Sutter noch iemand bij UGent de reflex om te denken: "Goh, ik zal dat toch eens googelen".
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Europa slabakt, strompelt & stagneert—onze groei volstaat amper om de bestaande welvaart te behouden in tijden van vergrijzing. En welke bijdrage leveren (mens)wetenschappers, vetbetaald met belastinggeld? Het ene plan na het andere om welvaart & groei helemáál om zeep te helpen.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
En @DeStandaard spit naarstig verder in de put die ze voor zichzelf groeven: wat als die Joden niet werden vermoord uit antisemitisme, maar "vanuit een politieke motivatie, als wraak voor Gaza?" Jezus Maria Jozef: collectieve wraak op Joden voor Gaza, DAT IS JUIST ANTISEMITISME.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Kijk, ik ben het niet eens met @barteeckhout over Gaze, maar elk zinnig mens met een gram integriteit moet bereid zijn om de aanslag op Bondi Beach als "antisemitische terreur" te benoemen. Dit zou echt het minimum minimorum moeten zijn. Toch spuien sommigen mist daarover.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Kijk, ik ben het niet eens met @barteeckhout over Gaze, maar elk zinnig mens met een gram integriteit moet bereid zijn om de aanslag op Bondi Beach als "antisemitische terreur" te benoemen. Dit zou echt het minimum minimorum moeten zijn. Toch spuien sommigen mist daarover.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is why I'll never donate to @MSF again, and neither should you. During its "decades of work there", MSF saw "no evidence" of Hamas using al-Shifa. They are lying. Not only were there extensive tunnels under the hospital, but hostages were driven straight to al-Shifa on 7/10.
David Collier
@mishtal
This is shocking footage - showing for the first time - the stolen Nahal Oz jeep entering al-Shifa Hospital at 10:53am on October 7. Plate 703-145 visible.
Crowds celebrate. Armed and unarmed terrorists surround the vehicle. Some hostages are clearly still inside.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
What did y'all think "Globalize the intifada" meant? vibes? papers? essays? The massacre in Sydney shows what the phrase actually means and has always meant: murdering Jews everywhere. It's time to globalize the crackdown on "globalize the intifada". quillette.com/2025/12/15/bondi-was-not-a-surprise/?ref=qu…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Echt waar, @destandaard, vanuit de grond van mijn hart: FUCK YOU. Een dozijn onschuldige Joden werd afgeslacht op een Joods festival, na maanden van virulente Jodenhaat in Australië (en overal). En dan het gore lef: "Antisemitisme? Goh, kweenie, pas op voor dat mijnenveld hoor."
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I won’t name names, but it’s deeply disappointing how few of my liberal friends (moderates—not leftists or wokies) resisted the absurd charge of “genocide” in Gaza, or even endorsed it, perhaps under social pressure or misled by once-respectable NGOs. substack.com/@maartenboudry/note/c-187461491
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Jews will not turn on the West; they will quietly leave, taking with them their culture, innovation, generosity, reverence for law, belief in democracy, and disproportionate contributions to science, medicine, art, journalism, literature & public life." www.futureofjewish.com/p/the-west-is-sleepwalking-into-a-…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Newly uncovered Hamas internal docs show the group embedded its own “guarantors” inside major NGOs (@MSF, @Oxfam, @SavetheChildren) to steer aid, monitor operations & facilitate theft. NGOs deny any infiltration, but @NGOmonitor's report proves otherwise. ngo-monitor.org/reports/puppet-regime-hamas-ngo-gaza/
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Does capitalism create yawning inequality? Yes, between the lucky ones who live under it and enjoy its immense benefits, and the unfortunate ones who don't. @johanknorberg
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Twee maanden na ons debat zit @StijnBruers nog steeds te lobbyen voor mijn ontslag aan @UGent. Ongelofelijk hoe zelfverklaarde "rationele" denkers over de Joodse natie niet alleen vervallen in irrationele kronkels (zie ons debat), maar ook vervellen tot autoritaire potentaten.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hoofdofficier bij 🇧🇪 Defensie met Master in Military Science stuurt deze anonieme getuigenis: (1) alle militaire doelstellingen van Israël zijn legitiem; (2) geen enkel leger ter wereld zou de operatie met minder nevenschade uitvoeren; (3) de beschuldiging van genocide is absurd.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dienstmededeling: ik spreek me niet vaak uit tegen bagger hier, want anders wordt dat een dagtaak, maar wie zich geroepen voelt om hatelijke opmerkingen te maken over @pdsutter en haar identiteit, doet me hier absoluut geen plezier mee. Hou het beleefd en speel niet op de vrouw.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De pathologische blindheid van de progressieve elite over seksueel geweld & migratie (na moord op Lisa)
Krant 1: "Het ligt aan blanke Andrew Tate en manosfeer"
Krant 2: "Oh nee, Wilders zal hiervan profiteren"
Nationale omroep: "De oplossing: klassieke muziek & genderexperts" -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Weet je trouwens waarom ik al mijn opinies tegenwoordig in @NRC publiceer (of soms @volkskrant), in plaats van hun Vlaamse zusterkrant @destandaard? Simpel: De Standaard weigert consequent al mijn inzendingen en antwoordt zelfs niet meer, terwijl NRC actief om bijdragen vraagt.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De gedode "journalist" die door @destandaard wordt beweend als "de ogen van de wereld in Gaza", was een artelleriecommandant bij Hamas, kreeg een orgasme van de slachtpartij op 7 okt, en postte trots selfies met zijn grote held Yayha Sinwar. Zo laag zijn onze media gezonken.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De gedode "journalist" die door @destandaard wordt beweend als "de ogen van de wereld in Gaza", was een artelleriecommandant bij Hamas, kreeg een orgasme van de slachtpartij op 7 okt, en postte trots selfies met zijn grote held Yayha Sinwar. Zo laag zijn onze media gezonken.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Bijna dagelijks ontvang ik zulke berichten van academici: "U spreekt voor velen die zich in het huidige klimaat genoodzaakt voelen te zwijgen. Zelf ben ik beginnend lector zonder vaste benoeming, en de ruimte voor vrijmoedige meningsuiting is helaas beperkt." Is dit nog normaal?
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Overdreef ik toen ik zei dat het klimaat rond Israël "verstikkend" is in academia? Oordeel zelf. Vier UGent-proffen verzoeken de rector om via de Raad van Bestuur op te treden tegen mijn "zionistisch getinte meningen". Niets dan minachting voor deze laffe (en inhoudsloze) aanval.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Overdreef ik toen ik zei dat het klimaat rond Israël "verstikkend" is in academia? Oordeel zelf. Vier UGent-proffen verzoeken de rector om via de Raad van Bestuur op te treden tegen mijn "zionistisch getinte meningen". Niets dan minachting voor deze laffe (en inhoudsloze) aanval.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Just did a recording for the audio version of my chapter for @LKrauss1's book The War on Science, with my rustic Flemish accent. Tough luck that the word "colonialism" is a tongue-twister for me, as it appears 19 times in my chapter. But I made it!😅 www.simonandschuster.com/books/The-War-on-Science/Dawkins…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In vrijzinnige kringen ligt @Assita_Kanko nogal "lastig", merkte ik bij mijn boekvoorstelling (maar andere N-VA'ers kennelijk niet?). Daar word ik nogal kregelig van. Tonnen respect voor deze dame, die bovenal de Verlichting verdedigt—omdat ze goed weet wat het alternatief is. /1
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Niet de lafhartige & brutale moord op een jong Joods koppel is het échte nieuws, maar de "recuperatie" door het boosaardige Israël. Beeld je in na aanslag van Breivik: "Linkse opengrenzenlobby recupereert moord op zomerkamp meteen". Waar anders dan in @destandaard? Schaamteloos.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De bandbreedte van aanvaardbare standpunten over Israël is zo extreem nauw (in academia en media) dat zelfs je oordeel opschorten omdat je "onvoldoende beslagen" bent, streng wordt veroordeeld. Iedereen moét en zal zich uitspreken, en er is slechts één correctie opinie. /4
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
How the most stunning achievement of the century (extreme poverty falling from 44% to 9% despite population growth) happened. And how we can help to eradicate it. In a nutshell: DON'T teach a man how to fish. Just give him the "fish" (money). @GiveDirectly
www.theatlantic.com/podcasts/archive/2025/05/the-myth-of-… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Hij zal door een diep, zwart gat gaan." Wie zegt nu zoiets, als winnaar van een verkiezing, over de tegenstrever? Dit is oncollegiaal en ongepast, @pdsutter. Lijkt bijna een poging tot vernedering. Heb je dat echt zo gezegd aan @DeStandaard, en nagelezen?
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De dodelijkste terreurgroepen mondiaal zijn quasi allemaal islamitisch. Alle landen waar de doodstraf staat op homoseks of geloofsafval, zijn islamitisch. De meerderheid van mondiale conflicten heeft minstens één islamitische partij. Maar ja, "islamofobie" is het échte probleem.
Thomas Van Riet
@ThomasVanRiet2
DE achilleshiel van Boudry: Islamofobie. Hij noemt Islam een regressieve religie, terwijl net zoals het Christendom en Jodendom er verschillende strekkingen zijn binnen een religie. (Kijk naar de kolonisten in Israel of de Evangelisten in de VS en je weet genoeg.)
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Links een eeuw geleden: "Socialisme betekent weelde voor iedereen. Wij prediken geen evangelie van tekort en schaarste, maar van overvloed." (Sylvia Pankhurst, 1923)
Links nu: "Alles moet minder! Ontgroeien!" (Beyond Growth, 2023) Een weelderige Dag van de Arbeid gewenst! #1mei -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Hoe bouw je een potdichte echokamer, recept door @EricCorijn:
1) Wie kritiek geeft op links, is rechts.
2) Wie niet de *correcte* kritiek
geeft op rechtse denkers, is zelf rechts.
3) Wie zijn mond niet opendoet na een rechtse denker, is zelf rechts.
➡️"Alleen rechtse denkers" -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Nou en of! 🔥🔥
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ongelofelijk. Zelfs nu Gazanen massaal tegen Hamas protesteren, slaagt @destandaard erin om er een anti-Israël spin aan te geven. Niet de protesten zijn het echte nieuws, maar de "gretige recuperatie" door boosaardige Israël. Elke fucking dag lees je deze agitprop in onze kranten
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is just sickening. Domineering, humiliating and bullying the leader of a beleaguered democratic ally, while openly siding with the dictator who brutally invaded it and is still tearing it to pieces. Fuck you, Trump and Vance.
Salman Anwar
@_SalmanAnwar
Absolutely mental clip, Trump and Vance are horrible people and just not credible partners in defending the West’s interests
He back Churchill’s bust, meanwhile Zelenskyy is the closest thing we have to a modern day Churchill and he treats him like crapThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
The world is better than you think (but still pretty awful). Finally a Belgian newspaper interviews the great @MaxCRoser from @OurWorldInData. It's not just the usual neglect of positive stories by the media. Apparently, Max also rarely gives interviews.😉www.demorgen.be/nieuws/drie-eeuwen-geleden-was-bijna-iede…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
UGent behoudt samenwerking met "judenrein" Birzeit, met Saoedi-Arabische overheid, met resem universiteiten in Maleisië, China, Kazakstan. Maar pluralistische & open universiteiten in Israël met duizenden Arabische studenten en academici worden geboycot. Ik schaam me voor @Ugent.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
For years the Left has been beating the drum about (largely overblown or even imaginary) "Islamophobic" hate crimes in the wake of jihadi terrorism. But now that there are literal "Jew hunts" and daily intimidations across Europe, and Jews start fleeing the country, nobody cares.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Aan @Ugent kwam dus een rabiate "anti-zionist" spreken die de antisemitische terreur van 7 okt toejuicht, die de enige Joodse staat ter wereld van de kaart wil vegen, en die op extremistenlijst van OCAD staat met dreigingsniveau 3. Puik werk ,@brunostruys. www.demorgen.be/nieuws/in-marokko-is-er-geen-probleem-van…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Eight years ago, reading @willmacaskill's book Doing Good Better convinced me overnight to sign the 10% Pledge. I haven't regretted it for a single moment! You won't either, I promise.😉Never before did we have such a great opportunity to have a positive impact on the world.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Gewoon de verdiende loon voor provocerende "hooligans", niet waar? Als er een "jodenjacht" wordt georganiseerd, hebben die joden het vast zelf gezocht, toch? Geïmporteerd antisemitisme, overal in Europa nu. www.hln.be/antwerpen/vijf-arrestaties-in-joodse-buurt-in-…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Pro-Palestinademonstranten zijn verwende westerlingen. Zij demonstreerden alleen maar tégen Israël. Meer is het niet. Als je Gazanen wilt helpen, herhaal je geen Hamas-retoriek op straat." Zo hoor je het eens van een Palestijnse analist. Ongelofelijk moedig.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dat zelfs een verstandige man als @BartEeckhout deze ahistorische nonsens uit zijn pen krijgt, is treurig. Wie aanvaardde de VN-partitie in 1948, Bart, en wie weigerde? De "brutale weigering" van het bestaansrecht van de ander kwam van Palestijns-Arabische kant, niet van Israël.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I'm turning 40 this week (Aug 15)!🥳 If you want to send me condolences for the loss of my fourth decade, it would be absolutely awesome if you could make a donation here to @GiveDirectly, hosted by @givingwhatwecan.😉 #effectivegiving #fundraiser 🙏www.givingwhatwecan.org/fundraisers/forty-for-charity
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Easily one of the best decisions I've taken in my life, 8 years ago (I'm pledger 2,164). Even if I screw up everything else (but I try not to😇), I can still die peacefully knowing my effective donations have made the world a little better. Consider taking the #10percentpledge!
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is such excellent comedic writing. Glad to see Sam Harris is back in the game of the written word. samharris.substack.com/p/the-anatomy-of-embarrassment?pub…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Meet the masked militants that blackmailed @UGent into an anti-Israel boycott: openly glorifying Refaat Alareer, who called the 7 Oct massacre "legitimate & moral" and denied any sexual violence, and shouting the genocidal slogan "From the river to the sea". Congrats, @Ugent.
Abraham
@AbrahamAubry
Listen and watch this Instagram video from the pro-Palestine students at UGent. They conclude with 'from the river to the sea.' These individuals are essentially Hamas militants. Remarkably, this is tolerated at @ugent University and throughout Belgium.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
A perverse form of "moral licensing" in contemporary activism: first you unilaterally declare a "genocide", "extinction" or "apocalypse". Then when people complain that you rampage, loot property, even beat up opponents: "So you care more about a painting than about GENOCIDE"?
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Bewondering voor de slacht- en verkrachtpartij van Hamas op 7 okt is niet van de lucht. Leden noemen de terreurgroep het ’enige echte verzet’ en stellen dat ’gewapende strijd en geweld nodig zijn om uit het systeem te komen’ en dat 'dekolonisatie altijd gewelddadig is'."
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
I don't think any paper of mine ever racked up so many rejections (six? seven? I lost count). Either there's something seriously wrong with it, or philosophers seriously hate cultural evolution. But now we finally get 2 glowing reviews, from a good journal!philsci-archive.pitt.edu/22982/
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
.@Unicef have read their @MaxCRoser: "The world is much better; The world is awful; The world can be much better". 😉 data.unicef.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/UNICEF-2023-Ch… /3
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"As a Palestinian, I believe this truth must be told: It is Israel that consistently offered compromise, dialogue & a two-state solution. And it is Palestinian demagogues who have rejected these openhanded offers—in favor of endless strife." Brave piece. www.newsweek.com/my-fellow-palestinians-its-time-get-rid-…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Today is the best time to be born, *despite* climate change. Yes, global temperatures are increasing, but so is our human ingenuity & resilience. There's NO scientific basic for claims about "billions of deaths" or an "uninhabitable earth".@Discourse_Mag/1 www.discoursemagazine.com/p/despite-climate-change-today-…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wat betreft academische vrijheid ben ik een maximalist, maar er zijn grenzen. Een organisatie aan @UGent uitnodigen die de gruwelijke terreur van Hamas toejuicht en zelf gelieerd is aan terreurgroep PFLP is een brug te ver. De organisatoren moeten hierover verantwoording afleggen
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
On Oct 20 academics at @UGent organized a "Teach-Out for Palestina" programming Samidoun Network, an organisation that supports Hamas, glorifies the horrific 7 Oct terror attacks, and is a front for the Marxist-Leninist PFLP, designated as a terrorist group by the EU. Disgusting.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
On Oct 20 academics at @UGent organized a "Teach-Out for Palestina" programming Samidoun Network, an organisation that supports Hamas, glorifies the horrific 7 Oct terror attacks, and is a front for the Marxist-Leninist PFLP, designated as a terrorist group by the EU. Disgusting.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Tony Blair in 2006: "10-15 years to avoid crossing catastrophic tipping points."
BBC in 2019: "18 months to save the planet."
Ocasio-Cortez in 2018: "The world is gonna end in 12 years."
Hou toch op met dat onwetenschappelijke deadline-eism over de "laatste kans", @destandaard. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In mijn ideale wereld heeft iedereen volledige zelfbeschikking hebben over zijn eigen leven. Waarom moet je eerst "ondraaglijk lijden" om toestemming te krijgen om je leven te beëindigen? Wie levensmoe is, moet daarover zelf kunnen beslissen.
www.demorgen.be/nieuws/een-pil-om-uit-het-leven-stappen-d… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
If you think it's "obvious" that Israel violates laws of war, read this nuanced account in @TheEconomist. Even an attack that inadvertently kills civilians can be legal, if proportionate & necessary, and if civilians have been warned and/or evacuated. /1 www.economist.com/is-israel-acting-within-the-laws-of-war…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Er gaapt een grote morele kloof tussen Hamas & Israël. Hamas slacht zoveel mogelijk burgers af, Israël probeert burgerslachtoffers zo veel mogelijk te vermijden. Dat het Israëlische leger “met gelijkaardige bloeddorst” opereert als Hamas, is gewoon obsceen.www.demorgen.be/meningen/tussen-israel-en-hamas-gaapt-een…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Waarom elke dag de krant openslaan je dómmer maakt. Een halve eeuw geleden voorspelden doemprofeten miljarden doden door hongersnoden. In werkelijk daalde hongersnoden spectaculair. Degene die nog overblijven, zijn mensgemaakt (= politieke oorzaken).
www.bnnvara.nl/joop/artikelen/doemporno-helpt-de-klimaatc… -
Post not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
As @simonfriederich & I wrote in @AreoMagazine, there's no end to the productive uses we can make of energy to enhance human flourishing (and eventually that of other creatures). GPT uses more energy? Good! GPT is fantastic, and progress requires energy./2 areomagazine.com/2023/02/21/in-defence-of-a-high-energy-f…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
You want to solve climate change? Then capitalism is your friend, not your enemy: the countries who are the most capitalist (as measured by the Heritage Foundation's Freedom Index) also score the highest on Yale University's EPI environmental index.
iea.org.uk/capitalism-is-good-for-the-environment/ -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
30 jaar lang onze grootste bron van schone energie kapotmaken, 30 jaar lang iedereen wijsmaken dat kernenergie behalve gevaarlijk & onveilig ook "overbodig" is. Om dan in allerijl 2 reactoren te verlengen (énkel door Oekraïne) en te beseffen dat je niet toekomt. @Groen kan dat.👍
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dat de rijken steeds rijker worden (klopt), betekent niet dat de armen steeds armer worden (klopt niet). Dat is nulsomdenken: het idee dat rijkdom een taart is met vaste omvang. Maar kapitalisme creëert én meer rijkdom én minder armoede. Bij @deafspraaktv.
www.vrt.be/vrtnu/a-z/de-afspraak/2023/de-afspraak-d20230116/ -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"In an ideal world, we would saturate the airwaves with images of Mohammed, until Muslims became sufficiently inured to this that no one responded with more than an exasperated sigh." A powerful and erudite paean to satirists, by @IonaItalia. areomagazine.com/2022/12/21/thank-you-for-offending-us-in…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
At the prestigious French university Sciences Po, two courses offering evolutionary perspectives on human behavior have been abruptly canceled right before the start of the semester -- with disingenuous excuses. ➡️Science hijacked by ideology. @HdxAcademy
www.lexpress.fr/actualite/c-est-devenu-le-tabou-ultime-qu… -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Deze gijzelneming moet echt ophouden. Hou uw rug recht, @openvld & @MR_officiel: als de Groenen NU weigeren te plooien, dat ze dan de stekker uit Vivaldi trekken. We gaan niet én het klimaat én onze welvaart én geopolitiek opofferen voor een trofee van een handvol dogmatici. /3
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Eindelijk ben ik het nog eens grondig oneens met @rvdwalle (dat mag aan @ugent). De uitspraken van Hoeyberghs zijn walgelijk, maar een celstraf voor een mening is een liberale samenleving onwaardig. Vrijheid van meningsuiting is juist bedoeld voor walgelijke & grove meningen.
Rik Van de Walle
@rvdwalle
De heer Hoeyberghs werd veroordeeld tot een celstraf van 10 maanden, waarvan de helft met uitstel, en een boete van 8.000 euro. Verder werd hij ook voor een periode van vijf jaar uit zijn rechten ontzet. Het is goed dat gerechtigheid geschiedt.
www.hln.be/gent/jeff-hoeyberghs-60-veroordeeld-tot-celstr… -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
.@Greenpeace is now a bigger threat to the climate than @ExxonMobil. Those who still sabotage nuclear energy in 2021, our most important source of dispatchable zero-carbon energy, have something to explain to their grandchildren.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
No worries, our local Greens are working very hard to reverse that and shut down three quarters of our low-carbon power. You know, the dispatchable, weather-independent, small-footprint part. To be replaced by new fossil gas plants, "for the climate" ! @TinneVdS @alexanderdecroo
LowCarbonPower.org⚡
@lowcarbonpower
Belgium has seen a significant increase in low-carbon electricity this year lowcarbonpower.org/changes
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Waarom geloven mensen in goden die via ondoorgrondelijke wegen opereren? Een lezing over bidden, mirakels en het bovennatuurlijke, voor de lezingenreeks 'Christendom, volksgeloof en mirakels'
van @Ugent, Liberas & @skepp_be.
youtu.be/1ViGkJR0MSA via @YouTube -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wie er nog aan twijfelt dat Jacques Lacan een charlatan was (nog meer dan Freud zelf), bekijk zeker deze lezing van scepticus & Lacaniaanse spijtoptant prof. Jacques Van Rillaer. www.youtube.com/watch?v=UfeEqqlv7so En ons daaropvolgende gesprek in Wetteren, @skepp_be. www.youtube.com/watch?v=6VQxwWnS4_c&t=1346s
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wat écht "schaamteloos" is, is dat uw partij in volle klimaatcrisis een miljard fossiele subsidies uitdeelt voor nieuwe fossiele centrales. En nu als een klein kind gaat mokken omdat een collega-minister zich niet plooit naar die "groene" waanzin. "How dare you?" (@GretaThunberg)
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Geen wonder dat die kerncentrales dicht mogen van Engie: ze kunnen in de plaats daarvan miljoenen aan subsidies incasseren van @TinneVdS om fossiele gascentrales te bouwen. Geen nucleaire rente betalen + gulle subsidies opstrijken = kassa kassa! En wie maalt om het klimaat? #crm
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
De laatste weken hebben meerdere mensen deze "onthulling" gedeeld: Blixt, het advocatenkantoor dat @TinneVdS oprichtte, had Gazprom als cliënt, Poetins staatsbedrijf en de grootste gasbedrijf ter wereld. Maar ik weet niet goed wat ik met die info moet aanvangen. Kort draadje. /1
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Mijn interpretatie: de kernuitstap werd bedacht en doorgedrukt door @Groen: de progressieve, milieubewuste, klimaatbezorgde partij. De mantel der liefde doet de rest. Mochten Vlaamse experts @Groen even kritisch aanpakken als @de_NVA, ze zouden de kernuitstap unaniem veroordelen.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Extremely important piece by @MazzucatoM, @Jayati1609 & @ElsTorreele. The language is measured, but the message urgent: we need to suspend vaccine patents. "It would resolve the 'vaccine apartheid' that's creating moral, health & economic catastrophes." www.economist.com/by-invitation/2021/04/20/mariana-mazzuc…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Er kregen al méér Nederlanders een vaccin dan er besmet werden met Sars-Cov-2. Het virus doodde al 17.000 mensen, de vaccins vooralsnog niemand. De tussenstand is dus 17000 (virus) - 0 (vaccin). Zelfs met extreem zeldzame vaccincomplicaties is dat misschien 17000 - 5. VACCINEER!!
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Draulans vorig jaar: "Vooruitgangdenkers zijn nog gevaarlijker dan klimaatontkenners."/ "Door ecomodernisten verliezen we pijnlijk veel tijd".
Draulans gisteren: "Ik was misschien de eerste ecomodernist in Vlaanderen, absoluut nooit problemen gehad met vooruitgangsdenken".
OK danThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Persoonlijk vind ik windturbines niet lelijk, zelfs elegant, maar dat is kwestie van smaak. Minder subjectief is dat ze duizenden tonnen staal & beton bevatten (en dus fossiele brandstoffen slurpen) en dat ze overal wilde natuur verstoren. @JorenVermeersc1 www.standaard.be/cnt/dmf20201129_98168479
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Er was eens een minister van een groene partij..." Een waargebeurd sprookje, opgeschreven voor @Knack. www.knack.be/s/r/c/1665255 #kernenergie #klimaat
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Dat gebeurt er dus als je kerncentrales vroegtijdig sluit. Waarom het roer niet omgooien nu het nog kan, @TinneVdS? Overtuig aub uw partij en @ecolobe dat een kernuitstap ons land vuiler & vervuilender maakt, en een stap achteruit is qua klimaatbeleid. vrtnws.be/p.YbkVDa8Ya
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Waarom kritisch denken ook betekent: aan jezelf twijfelen. En waarom corona-ontkenners aan zelfoverschatting lijden. #leerstoeletiennevermeersch
(Helaas zal dit openingscollege nog een poos actueel blijven)
youtu.be/_UeZVAfeKek -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Now that CRISPR-Cas 9 has been (rightfully) awarded a Nobel prize, will mainstream environmentalism finally give up its opposition against genome editing, and embrace the many ways in which it can benefit nature and the climate? I really hope so! edition.cnn.com/2020/10/07/health/nobel-prize-2020-winner…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
'Hoe censuur werkt: vier lessen uit de Hitlergroet van Geert Hoste in @DeIdealeWereld'. Stuk voor @Knack. www.knack.be/s/r/c/1613033
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Mensen die dit argument gebruiken (= velen), snappen niet dat het als een boemerang terugkeert. Weet je wel hoeveel duizenden vierkante kilometers wind- en zonneparken je nodig hebt voor mondiale energievoorziening? Energiedichtheid van uranium is miljoenen keren hoger. /1
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Een opsteker! De publieke steun voor kernenergie in België is de voorbije jaren gevoelig toegenomen. Zowel voor bestaande centrales als voor de bouw van nieuwe. Zouden al die pro-nucleaire pleidooien echt gewerkt hebben? ;-) Peiling door @KantarTNS. nucleairforum-5143.kxcdn.com/uploads/docs/peiling-kernene…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Wie dacht dat traditionele groenen hun verzet tegen kernenergie zouden opgeven, ziehier hoe @Greenpeace zich verder ingraaft in haar dogmatisme. Werkelijk elke stelling is manifest onjuist of misleidend.
Joeri Thijs 🦋 @joerithijs.bsky.social
@JoeriThijs
Dit weekend zal @de_NVA het ecomodernisme en de rol voor kernenergie in het klimaatdebat vol in de schijnwerpers plaatsen. Om het debat inhoudelijk te voeden, doorprikt @greenpeace_be enkele mythes in het ecomodernistische pleidooi voor kernenergie. Een uitgebreid draadje. 1/
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Inderdaad, @Bart_DeWever, "een mix tussen hernieuwbare & kernenergie is de beste garantie op betaalbaarheid, zekerheid en duurzaamheid". Minder kernenergie staat in de praktijk gelijk met méér CO2-uitstoot en meer vervuiling. Wat willen ecologisten écht? www.dm.be/s/axd60ff38/21HXaM
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Pluim voor @de_NVA, die nu voluit #ecomodernisme omarmt. @Openvld mist hier een geweldige kans om als eerste te breken met de groene dogma's over kernenergie. Voorspelling: links zal nog meer in kramp schieten over nucleair, vanwege kaping door "rechts". www.dm.be/s/ax86acaa1/1E092K
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Als je wil zien hoe zwak de groene argumenten tegen nucleair zijn, hier mijn debat met @kristofcalvo. Tot op heden, na herhaaldelijke aandringen, weigert Calvo zijn foute bewering over IPCC-rapport (dat forse groei nucleair voorziet) recht te zetten. /2
www.youtube.com/watch?v=oHEI4aou19k -
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Ouders moeten voortaan ook maar het 'voorzorgsprincipe' hanteren. Zomaar lukraak je DNA dooreenschudden en met een ander genoom recombineren, eigenlijk is dat onverantwoord. Algehele sterilisatie! @BartStaes en andere groene fundi's begrijpen geen bal van evolutie en veredeling.
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
"Worden migranten echt 'ontmenselijkt'?" Volledige tekst van opinie in @demorgen vandaag, over het lichtzinnige en onverantwoorde gebruik van het begrip "ontmenselijking", en over het gevaar van eenheidsdenken in academia. maartenboudry.blogspot.com/2018/06/worden-migranten-echt-…
-
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Maggie De Block krijgt Zesde Vijs van Skepp: "Moet ik een warm bad ook terugbetalen?" knack.be/s/r/c/565019 via @knack @skepp_be









































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































