AZAZEL—THE SCAPEGOAT
Ty Gibson
Dr. Eric Mason (@pastoremase), again, I appreciate your willingness to hear what the Adventist Church actually believes on the topics you have raised. This says a lot about your integrity as a human being and your intellectual honesty as a scholar. Thank you! Pardon my delay, as my teaching schedule has been heavy over the last two weeks.
In my previous post, I responded to your question regarding Michael the Archangel. Here, I will address the the scapegoat question. In a follow up post, I will address the investigative judgment.
Yes, Adventists do believe that the scapegoat of the ancient Hebrew sanctuary service was a symbol for Satan, just as the Hebrew people themselves believed as the recipients, from God through Moses, of the sanctuary and its symbolic rituals. But Adventists absolutely, unequivocally DO NOT believe that the scapegoat ritual means, in any sense, that Satan is an atoning sin-bearer or that he contributes anything to human salvation. Rather, we believe that the scapegoat ritual communicated that Satan, the originator of evil, would be fully conquered by Christ at Calvary and will finally be made to bear responsibility for his crimes against God and humanity.
The Adventist Church believes that Christ alone—CHRIST ALONE!—is the sin-bearer by whom humans are redeemed. He alone is humanity’s “once for all” atoning sacrifice for sin, “when He offered up Himself” (Hebrews 7:27) on the cross of Calvary. We believe that “this Man (Jesus), after He had offered one sacrifice for sins forever, sat down at the right hand of God (the position of favor and victory)” (Hebrews 10:12). “For by one offering He has perfected forever those who are being sanctified” (Hebrews 10:14). According to the law of the sacrificial system, as the book of Hebrews plainly states, “Without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness of sins” (Hebrew 9:22, ESV). On that explicit biblical premise, Adventists believe that the scapegoat is NOT an atoning sin-bearer in any sense, by virtue of the fact that its blood was not shed and it was not sacrificed. There is zero forgiveness of sins, zero salvation, equated with or attached to the scapegoat ritual.
Regarding the scapegoat, as a symbol for Satan, our theological reasoning unfolds, in brief, like this:
1. The ancient Hebrew sanctuary and its ritual services were given by God as a symbolic educational system to communicate the gospel. The Hebrew calendar year entailed a series rituals enacted by the priests as a compressed and comprehensive theater of the whole plan of salvation.
2. There was the daily ritual service and the yearly one. The daily service centered on the sacrifice of a lamb, pointing forward to the voluntary self-sacrifice of Christ for our salvation (John 1:29). The yearly service—called Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement—centered on ritual actions performed with “two goats” (Leviticus 16). One goal was designated as “the LORD’S,” literally, “YAHWEH’S” goat. The other goat was designated “for the scapegoat,” literally, “for Azazel.” Both goats are not “YAHWEH’S,” which is to say, both goats are not representative of or associated with YAHWEH. A second name or entity or category is brought to view—“Azazel.” One goat is “YAHWEH’S” and the other is “for Azazel.”
3. YAHWEH’S goat was sacrificed. The High Priest was instructed to “bring its blood inside the veil…and sprinkle it on the mercy seat and before the mercy seat” (16:15). “So he shall make atonement…for ALL their sins” (16:16). “All” the sins of Israel were atoned for by this part of the ritual, by the sacrifice of YAHWEH’S goat.
4. Azazel’s goat was NOT sacrificed, its blood was NOT shed. Rather, something else was done with it, something that finds its antitypical fulfillment in the gospel of Christ, just as the sacrifice of the LORD’S goat finds fulfillment in Christ. Notice the crucial transition from the LORD’S goat to the scapegoat: “And when he has made an end of atoning”—note, “an END OF ATONING”—then “he shall bring the live goat” to perform another part of the Day of Atonement ritual (16:20). “Aaron shall lay both his hands on the head of the live goat (Azazel), confess over it all the iniquities of the children of Israel, and all their transgressions, concerning all their sins, putting them on the head of the goat” (16:21). Remember, we were just told in the previous verse that “an end of atoning” had already been reached prior to the actions now embarked upon with Azazel’s goat. So whatever is meant by the high priest putting the sins of Israel on Azazel’s goat, involved no atonement for sin. The only time the word atonement is used in proximity to the scapegoat is in verse 10, and the language is precise: “to make atonement UPON IT, and to let it go as the scapegoat into the wilderness.” The scapegoat ritual makes no atonement for the sins of the people, for its blood is not shed and taken into the sanctuary, and we are explicitly told in verse 16 that atonement for “all” the “sins” of the people was already made by the sacrifice of YAHWEH’S goat. The language, “atonement upon it” is used in Exodus 30, verse 10, regarding the altar, to “make atonement upon its horns.” The language simply means that the piece of furniture is designated for its ritual purpose, its symbolic role, and obviously does not mean that the article of furniture itself is sacrificed for the making of atonement. Likewise, the scapegoat is simply designated for its symbolic purpose, but its blood is not shed and therefore it does not make atonement for the sins of the people. What, then, was done with the scapegoat? The high priest “shall send him away by the hand of a fit man into the wilderness. And the goat shall bear upon him all their iniquities unto a land not inhabited: and he shall let go the goat in the wilderness” (16:21-22, KJV). Again, whatever is meant by the scapegoat bearing the people’s “iniquities unto a land not inhabited,” verse 20 has already informed us that it entails no salvational atonement for the people’s sins. Azazel does not bear the sins of the people by blood into to sanctuary, but rather is led away “unto a land not inhabited,” into “the wilderness.”
5. The Adventist Church did not originate the idea of Azazel, the scapegoat, symbolizing Satan. The Jewish people understood this to be the meaning of Azazel and Adventists simply saw the theological significance of the idea. Notice the following from The Jewish encyclopedia:
“Azazel: The name of a supernatural being mentioned in connection with the ritual of the Day of Atonement (Leviticus 16). After Satan, for whom he was in some degree a preparation (or symbolic construct), Azazel enjoys the distinction of being the most mysterious extra-human character in sacred literature” (The Jewish Encyclopedia, Vol. 2, pp. 365, 366; jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/2203-azazel).
“Far from involving the recognition of Azazel as a deity, the sending of the goat was . . . a symbolic expression of the idea that the people’s sins and their evil consequences were to be sent back to the spirit (demon) of desolation and ruin, the source of all impurity. The very fact that the two goats were presented before Jehovah before the one was sacrificed and the other sent into the wilderness, was proof that Azazel was not ranked with Jehovah, but regarded simply as the personification of wickedness in contrast with the righteous government of God” (The Jewish Encyclopedia, Vol. 2, pp. 365, 366; jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/2203-azazel).
6. Satan figures prominently into the biblical narrative, not only from the beginning of the human story in Genesis 3, but looping back to his original rebellion within the heavenly realm of angels. It would be strange if he was completely missing from the symbolic narrative of the plan of salvation as depicted in the sanctuary of ancient Israel.
According to the apostle John, “War broke out in heaven” (Revelation 12:7). That is to say, the war between good and evil did not begin on earth among humans, but in heaven among the angels. Satan, along with approximately “a third” of the angels (12:4), rebelled against God. “So the great dragon was cast out, that serpent of old, called the Devil and Satan, who deceives the whole world; he was cast to the earth, and his angels were cast out with him” (12:9).
With that heavenly backstory in place, we find Satan, in the form of a “serpent,” showing up in the Garden of Eden, positioned at “the tree of the knowledge of good and evil,” of which God had forbidden Adam and Eve to partake (Genesis 2:9; 3:1-5). Having been “cast out” of the heavenly society, Satan and his angels proceeded to take up their war against God on planet earth, with an attack on the newly created human race. The originator of evil in heaven now becomes the originator of evil on earth with the human race. Immediately, the first gospel prophecy came forth from the mouth of God in the form of a declaration of war:
“I will put enmity between you (the serpent) and the woman (the corporate people of God down through the ages) and between your offspring and hers; he (the coming messianic warrior) will crush your head, and you will strike his heel” (Genesis 3:15, NIV).
God would send a powerful messianic warrior into the world to conquer Satan. That’s the promise of the gospel. As the story unfolds from the promise of Genesis 3:15, after leading the children of Israel out of Egyptian bondage, God instructed them to build a sanctuary as a enacted illustration, a symbolic theatrical performance, designed to educate the world regarding how God would save humanity and conquer Satan. At the climax of the annual sanctuary narrative, the Day Atonement brings the whole story to a conclusion with the ritual regarding the two goats—one to be sacrificed as an atonement for sins and the other to be banished to “the wilderness” to perish. And this is precisely where things become crystal clear, because there is a whole body of biblical material regarding the final demise of Satan associated with the concept of banishment to the wilderness.
7. When Jesus comes into the world as our Savior, He performs two primary tasks by His death and resurrection: He makes atonement for all sin and He conquers Satan, thus ensuring the final demise of the instigator of evil:
“Once at the end of the ages, He has appeared to put away sin by the sacrifice of Himself” (Hebrews 9:26).
“He who sins is of the devil, for the devil has sinned from the beginning. For this purpose the Son of God was manifested, that He might destroy the works of the devil” (1 John 3:8).
We recall that Azazel was led by the hand of a “fit man,” a strong man, a man sufficient to the task, into “the wilderness,” where it would perish (Leviticus 16). Jesus told this very story about Himself and Satan:
“When a strong man, fully armed, guards his own palace, his goods are in peace. But when a stronger than he comes upon him and overcomes him, he takes from him all his armor in which he trusted, and divides his spoils” (Luke 11:21-22).
Satan is the “strong man” in the parable and Jesus is the one who “stronger than he,” who disarms the devil. Paul follows the gospel logic of this passage when he says:
“Having disarmed the powers and authorities (of evil), he made a public spectacle of them, triumphing over them by the cross” (Colossians 2:15, NIV).
In Leviticus 16, Azazel was “let go” in “wilderness” (miḏbār), and according to Rabbinic teaching “let go” means pushed off a cliff to its demise (Mishna, Yoma 6:6).
In Isaiah 14, Lucifer is indicted as the one “who made the world as a wilderness (miḏbār) and destroyed its cities,” and for his wrongs he is cast into “the lowest depths of the pit” (verses 15-17).
In the book of Revelation, “Satan” is thrown into a “bottomless pit” (Revelation 20:3).
The story of the demise of Azazel in Leviticus 16, and the story of the demise of Lucifer in Isaiah 14, and the story of the demise of Satan in Revelation 20, are all the same story!
So, yeah, there is a clear narrative thread in Scripture to warrant identifying Azazel as Satan, in addition to the other plain facts of Leviticus 16 that sharply distinguish the treatment of YAHWEH’S goat from the treatment of Azazel’s goat. One is a blood sacrifice and the other is not.
Eric, here’s what you can say with accuracy regarding the Adventist position on the scapegoat: we believe that Christ alone, by His shed blood, is the one and only atoning sacrifice for all sin, and that the scapegoat, Azazel, symbolizing Satan, was defeated by Christ and will be ultimately made to bear responsibility for his guilt as the originator of evil.
What you cannot say with accuracy is that the Adventist Church believes Satan bears sin in any atoning sense whatsoever. We simply do not.
Eric, certainly you believe that Jesus came into the world to accomplish both atonement for sin and the conquest of the devil. The only difference is that Adventist believe the scapegoat transaction covers that theological base within the Old Testament sanctuary system, and you do not. But at the level of theological substance, we both believe that Christ alone is the atoning sacrifice for sin, and we both believe Christ is victor over Satan, which ensures the final demise of evil and the eternal reign of righteousness. Certainly, now that you understand what the Adventist position actually is, our understanding of the scapegoat does not warrant you labeling this entire Protestant denomination a cult. Or, perhaps, now that you see the logic of our perspective on the scapegoat, you find it as compelling and beautiful as we do. If so, that would be lovely, because it is perfectly permissible for somebody of your statue to learn things you didn’t know before and make a shift in understanding 😉.