BREAKING NIUS: Die Antifa hat nun ein Bekennerschreiben zum terroristischen Brandanschlag auf mein Auto veröffentlicht. Darin heißt es unter der Überschrift "Julian Reichelt du Hund":
"Wir haben letzte Nacht anlässlich der Gen-Z-Demo am Samstag in Berlin das Auto des Ex-Bild-Chefs Julian Reichelt angezündet. Pressefreiheit schützt qua Definition journalistische Arbeit vor dem Staat, unser Angriff auf das Auto dieses misogynen, rassistischen, transphoben Arschlochs ist kein Angriff auf sie. Die guten Gründe für unseren Schuss vor den Bug sind nicht an einer Hand abzuzählen."
In dem Schreiben wird auch meine Adresse veröffentlicht und Bezug genommen auf die geplante Gewaltdemo (Gen Z) am 20. November. Das ist natürlich nichts anderes als eine Aufforderung an den Mob.
Und dennoch hat sich seit 48 Stunden kein einziger politisch Verantwortlicher in der Stadt Berlin zu diesem Anschlag geäußert. Die CDU schweigt geschlossen. Auch die Innensenatorin von der SPD interessiert der Anschlag nicht. Wenige Straßen von mir entfernt wohnt ein Mitglied der Bundesregierung. Da wird das Wohnhaus natürlich geschützt, aber wenn man Opfer eines Anschlags wird, nachdem CDU-Ministerin Prien NIUS zu "Feinden der Demokratie" erklärt hat, nachdem CDU-Ministerpräsident Daniel Günther die Antifa zum Kampf gegen uns aufgerufen hat, nachdem Merz-Freund Wolfram Weimer Anschlagsratgeber der Antifa mit Steuergeld finanziert, nachdem immer noch Millionen Euro Steuergeld über das CDU-Familienministerium an die militante Antifa fließen, nachdem Karin Prien bekannt hat, dieser elendige, gewalttätige sogenannte Antifaschismus sei "DNA der CDU", dann interessiert das die Mächtigen nicht. Der linke Straßenterror hat in Berlin keine Gegenwehr zu befürchten, schon gar nicht von der immer noch regierenden CDU. Man ist auf sich allein gestellt.
Wenn die Linken ihre Sturmabteilung losschicken, gucken viel zu viele Konservativen, Bürgerlichen weg. Bis jetzt gibt es auch keine einzige öffentliche Stellungnahme eines deutschen Chefredakteurs oder Verlagshauses. Das ist beschämend. Die komplette Führungsriege der deutschen Medienlandschaft schweigt zu diesem Anschlag (während sich zahlreiche normale Mitarbeiter geäußert haben – danke!).
Für NIUS gibt es auf dieses Totalversagen der Freiheitlichkeit nur eine Antwort: Journalismus. Wir werden uns niemals einschüchtern lassen. Wir brennen – leider im wahrsten Sinne des Wortes – für die Meinungsfreiheit.
Michael Shellenberger
Michael D. Shellenberger (born June 16, 1971) is a political and ecomodernist activist and writer best known for his heterodox views. Born in Colorado, he obtained degrees in Peace and Anthropology in the 1990s. After founding some public relations firms, in 2003 he co-founded the ecomodernist think tank Breakthrough Institute. Scientists, including those he cites, have criticised his "bad science" in comments on climate change, his history of "anti-green contrarianism", and IJNet, the multiple errors in his reporting. More on Wikipedia
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Julian Reichelt
@jreichelt
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Chuck Todd
@chucktodd
We can solve the Electoral College problem by uncapping the House. No Constitutional Amendment needed. Right size the House (should be about 800 members) and we won’t have a popular vote/EC split maybe ever. Oh, and the House will actually be “the people’s House” again.
Ron DeSantis
@RonDeSantis
Abolishing the electoral college would mean not knowing who won the presidency for 4 weeks while California keeps counting. No thanks.
Fernando Amandi Sr.🌐
@FernandoAmandi
🆘 Here they come America: Pete Buttigieg claims that the Electoral College “makes no sense” and should be abolished because it is a remnant of “some very arcane, parochial politics in the 1770s.”
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It must feel wonderful for you to finally be able to express openly the radical views you always held
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Censoring your enemies. Dismantling the police. Making energy expensive. Rioting and looting. These things appear disconnected, but they're not. They're all part of a single systematic attack on the pillars of civilization. People are right to call this a controlled demolition.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Several recent events appear unrelated:
— The Democrats are seeking to abolish the Electoral College, stack and impeach the Supreme Court, and increase energy subsidies.
— Prosecutors in Canada and Europe have sought to convict people for insisting upon the reality of biological sex online.
— New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani has shut down the riot police unit.
— Mercedes joined the growing number of energy-intensive companies halting investments in Germany.
—After weeks of riots and looting, France is criminally investigating its greatest living novelist for criticizing mass migration of Muslims and their higher rates of crime.
— A Dutch member of the European Parliament was censored for criticizing Islam.
— Australia’s censorship agency wants the ability to spy on anyone on the Internet and share their political opinions and health data with foreign intelligence agencies.
— Someone firebombed the car of Germany’s most prominent independent journalist.
— And a judge has ordered Facebook’s Meta to pay $25 billion, in large part, for not censoring enough.
In reality, they are all part of the Left’s controlled demolition of civilization.
Around the world, the Left is attacking free speech, including through firebombings, death threats, and mass online censorship, without which neither democracy, commerce, or freedom in general are possible.
It is attacking democratic protections, undermining judicial independence, and curtailing privacy rights, all of which people in the West have spent centuries fighting and dying for.
And by making energy expensive and scarce by shutting down reliable power plants, it is attacking the physical basis of our industrial civilization, the source of our security and prosperity....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2121636164155089221
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism and to read the rest of the articleThis post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Anna Vero Wendland
@VeroWendland
Nö.
Du hast 3 Zeitbomben ins Fundament unseres Landes gelegt, die nach deiner Amtszeit hochgegangen sind.
• Atomausstieg
• Gasabhängigkeit von Russland
• Migrationspolitik
WELT
@welt
„Ich habe das Land in einem besseren Zustand übergeben, als ich es bekommen habe“, versichert Merkel www.welt.de/politik/deutschland/article6af702b127adfb0b7b…
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The intelligence community sent spies into every major social media platform. Think about that. Chilling.
Pavel Durov
@durov
🤦♀️ Jensen made a rookie mistake. He had a board.
In 2014, my board kicked me out for saying no to spies.
In 2026, Jensen’s board kicked him out for saying yes to one.
So the board gets you either way.
Founders: Don’t have a board.
Be the board 😏
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
There were so many former FBI officials at Twitter that they had their own Slack Channel and crib sheet to onboard new arrivals
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
29. As of 2020, there were so many former FBI employees — "Bu alumni" — working at Twitter that they had created their own private Slack channel and a crib sheet to onboard new FBI arrivals.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
And now, the demands by governments for censorship are increasing.
Their goal is for a small, highly-ideological and partisan clique within the intelligence community to control what you can say and see online, and to spy on you to make sure you comply
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We are in the midst of a five-alarm fire on free speech and privacy internationally.
Politicians across the West are demanding new powers for their spy agencies to do what East Germany's secret police, the Stasi, did.
Americans, Europeans, and anyone else online will have their privacy invaded, and personal information, including information about their health and sexual orientation, potentially shared with foreign spy agencies, if the Australian Senate passes the @AlboMP government's totalitarian bill.
New investigative reporting by @MikeNayna, @NAffects, and @itshermargaret reveals that the Albanese government buried in its censorship legislation a radical change to the nation's Privacy Act, one that would open the door to unprecedented secret spying globally.
It's coming at a time when governments in Europe, the UK, and Brazil are all demanding ever-more censorship of their enemies.
Behind the war on free speech is a war on ordinary people seeking to defend core civilizational pillars, from borders to industry to the rights of women.
The iconic 2006 film "The Lives of Others," about the Stasi, is about what happens when politicians decide their citizens are the enemy. That's what's happening today.
It's fitting that the main character on that film poster should be Australia's Prime Minister @AlboMP, whose legislation would weaponize the nation's censorship agency, the "eSafety Commissioner," to spy on citizens and report them to their governments for thought-crime violations.
Every free person in the West should be alarmed by this development and see @AlboMP and his apparatchiks for what they are: a clear and present danger to our freedoms and civilization itself.
It's up to free people to spread the word about this five-alarm fire and resist with everything we've got.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
EXCLUSIVE: New censorship legislation would let the Australian government spy on US & European citizens and report "sensitive information" about their lawful political opinions, religious beliefs, sexual orientation, and health records to foreign spy agencies, including the FBI.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pauline Voss
@Pauline__Voss
Sie wollen uns mit Gewalt zum Schweigen bringen. Aber das werden sie nicht schaffen.
Heute Nacht wurde das Auto von NIUS-Chefredakteur Julian Reichelt mitten in Berlin niedergebrannt. Seit Monaten bedrohen uns Linksextremisten mit Gewalt. In Kreuzberg wurde ein Flyer verteilt, auf dem eine Faust das NIUS-Logo zertrümmert. In einem Aufruf auf Indymedia hieß es: „Jetzt liegt es an allen Antifaschist*innen in Kreuzberg, den Faschos das Leben hier zur Hölle zu machen. Organisiert euch mit den Nachbar*innen rund um die Naziimmobilien, recherchiert, wo sie sich nach Feierabend hinbegeben und werdet aktiv. Jede Aktion ist notwendig, um die rechte Raumnahme zu stoppen.“ Was damit gemeint ist, könnte klarer nicht sein: physische Angriffe auf Andersdenkende. Eine Gewalt, die sich durch nichts stoppen lässt. Auch nicht durch den Kindersitz, der auf dem Beifahrersitz des Autos stand.
Diesem radikalisierten Milieu sind alle Mittel recht, um die politischen Gegner zu bekämpfen. Doch statt ihm Einhalt zu gebieten, fördert der deutsche Staat das linksradikale Vorfeld, wo es nur kann. Die Stoßrichtung gaben Daniel Günther und Karin Prien von der CDU vor, als sie uns als „Feinde der Demokratie“ markierten. Prien fördert über „Demokratie leben!“ mit Hunderten Millionen weiterhin das linksradikale Vorfeld; über das Kanzleramt von Friedrich Merz fließt Geld an linksextreme Verlage, die „Tipps und Tricks“ für den Umgang mit Waffen und das Verwischen von DNA-Spuren geben.
Diese Gewalt ist politisch gewollt. Sie soll alle einschüchtern, die die Mächtigen kritisieren. Die CDU hat sich längst der Logik linker Militanz unterworfen und macht sie sich zunutze. In Berlin könnten diese Strukturen bald das Rote Rathaus erobern, mit Billigung des Kanzlers, der Klingbeil nicht vor die Wahl stellen und an die Verpflichtung des Koalitionsvertrags erinnern will. Wir leben in einem Land, in dem unliebsame Meinungsäußerungen mit Gewalt geahndet werden. Wir bei NIUS lassen uns davon nicht einschüchtern, wir werden umso kritischer auf die linksextremen Netzwerke und die Steuermillionen dahinter blicken. Denn in einer Demokratie dürfen niemals die Faust und der Brandbeschleuniger über das Wort siegen. -
NIUS
@niusde_
+++BREAKING NIUS+++
Nach dem Brandanschlag auf sein Auto wendet sich NIUS-Chefredakteur Julian Reichelt @jreichelt an Daniel Günther (CDU), der NIUS bei Lanz „Feinde von Demokratie“ nannte: „Wenn unseren Leuten oder unserem Eigentum etwas zustößt – it's on you. Dann warst du mit dabei.“
👉 nius.de/berlin/brandanschlag-auto-chefredakteur-julian-re…
#julianreichelt #brandanschlag #niuslive #pressefreiheit #linksextremismus #politischegewalt #berlin #ralfschuler #nius #nachrichten #güntherThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Outrageous. The whole world is watching. Every journalist in Germany must denounce this
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
NIUS
@niusde_
+++BREAKING NIUS+++
Nach dem Brandanschlag auf sein Auto wendet sich NIUS-Chefredakteur Julian Reichelt @jreichelt an Daniel Günther (CDU), der NIUS bei Lanz „Feinde von Demokratie“ nannte: „Wenn unseren Leuten oder unserem Eigentum etwas zustößt – it's on you. Dann warst du mit dabei.“
👉 nius.de/berlin/brandanschlag-auto-chefredakteur-julian-re…
#julianreichelt #brandanschlag #niuslive #pressefreiheit #linksextremismus #politischegewalt #berlin #ralfschuler #nius #nachrichten #güntherThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We are in the midst of a five-alarm fire on free speech and privacy internationally.
Politicians across the West are demanding new powers for their spy agencies to do what East Germany's secret police, the Stasi, did.
Americans, Europeans, and anyone else online will have their privacy invaded, and personal information, including information about their health and sexual orientation, potentially shared with foreign spy agencies, if the Australian Senate passes the @AlboMP government's totalitarian bill.
New investigative reporting by @MikeNayna, @NAffects, and @itshermargaret reveals that the Albanese government buried in its censorship legislation a radical change to the nation's Privacy Act, one that would open the door to unprecedented secret spying globally.
It's coming at a time when governments in Europe, the UK, and Brazil are all demanding ever-more censorship of their enemies.
Behind the war on free speech is a war on ordinary people seeking to defend core civilizational pillars, from borders to industry to the rights of women.
The iconic 2006 film "The Lives of Others," about the Stasi, is about what happens when politicians decide their citizens are the enemy. That's what's happening today.
It's fitting that the main character on that film poster should be Australia's Prime Minister @AlboMP, whose legislation would weaponize the nation's censorship agency, the "eSafety Commissioner," to spy on citizens and report them to their governments for thought-crime violations.
Every free person in the West should be alarmed by this development and see @AlboMP and his apparatchiks for what they are: a clear and present danger to our freedoms and civilization itself.
It's up to free people to spread the word about this five-alarm fire and resist with everything we've got.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
EXCLUSIVE: New censorship legislation would let the Australian government spy on US & European citizens and report "sensitive information" about their lawful political opinions, religious beliefs, sexual orientation, and health records to foreign spy agencies, including the FBI.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Be sure to read this bombshell report by @MikeNayna & @NAffects informed by the research of @itshermargaret about a new censorship bill that would let the government spy on all citizens and report their lawful political opinions to foreign governments.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
by @MikeNayna @NAffects & @Shellenberger
In September 2025, top government censorship officials from Europe, the UK, Brazil, California, and Australia met at Stanford to discuss ways to coordinate censorship at an international level. The meeting was titled “Compliance and Enforcement in a Rapidly Evolving Landscape.” Australia’s top censor, eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant, gave the keynote.
Though Grant did not provide her remarks to Public, previously she had told the World Economic Forum (WEF) that she was organizing censorship officials around the world because “we know we’re going to go much further when we work together with other like-minded independent statutory authorities around the globe.”
Inman Grant’s efforts appear to be coming to fruition in Australia, where the lower house has passed sweeping censorship and surveillance legislation that the Senate is now considering. The legislation would allow the Commissioner to monitor “lawful but harmful” speech.
Inman Grant, an American who once volunteered to a journalist that she turned down a job with the CIA, can already order a platform to reveal who is behind an anonymous account from anywhere in the world.
But the DDoC bill now before the Australian Senate would also let her use fake accounts that deceive users into thinking they are citizens and not government spies, record their legal speech, and give what she learns directly to Australia’s spy agencies. Those agencies could then share that intelligence with the FBI and other “Five Eyes” intelligence-sharing partners in the US, UK, Canada, and New Zealand.
The bill enables this by granting eSafety the ability to create an unlimited number of AI-generated “sock puppet” identities (effectively bots) under policies set “in consultation with the Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police.”
The private information that the Australian government could share with foreign intelligence agencies could include a user’s name, address, phone number, email, along with what the Privacy Act calls “sensitive information,” which includes political opinions, religious beliefs, sexual orientation, and health records.
The Institute for Public Affairs (IPA) first reported on the Privacy Act changes on Monday, and Network Affects noted last month that the new censorship legislation designates eSafety an “enforcement body” under the Privacy Act, expanding its ability to access personal information.
In 2013, documents released by whistleblower Edward Snowden revealed that British intelligence officials had allowed, as part of a secret deal with the U.S. government’s National Security Agency (NSA), for it to gather information on UK citizens who were not under suspicion of any wrongdoing.
The eSafety Commissioner could thus unmask anonymous accounts in the United States, France, or Germany, for example, that complain about controversial issues like mass migration, and report them and all of their private information to the FBI and European spy agencies.
“We have power to share with the AFP [Australian Federal Police]; we don’t have power to share with intelligence agencies at this time,” testified Heidi Snell, eSafety’s General Manager of Regulatory Operations,in October this year. “But the amendments would see us being able to share directly with those other government agencies,” she added.
Those agencies include the Australian Secret Intelligence Service (ASIS), Australia’s equivalent of the CIA; the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO), which performs a role similar to the FBI’s domestic intelligence division; the Australian Signals Directorate (Australia’s NSA); the Office of National Intelligence (ODNI); the Department of Home Affairs (DHS); the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (State Department); the Department of Defence; and any other “Commonwealth entity.”
The DDoC Bill contains a provision that would put eSafety in the same legal category as the Australian Federal Police under the Privacy Act for “surveillance activities, intelligence gathering activities or monitoring activities.”
eSafety told Public in an email that information it sends to the police may include “the account names or the identity of the users who posted the material.” A Federal Police witness testified on Oct 21 that police can pass eSafety’s information to “our ASIO partners.”
The censorship bill would change Australia’s Privacy Act so eSafety could collect sensitive personal information, including political opinions, without users’ consent,a warrant or judicial oversight. To invoke this Privacy Act exception, it would only need to “reasonably believe” that the collection is necessary for its functions...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2120554869530443979
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism and read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
Congrats to Michael Shellenberger, CBR Chair of Politics, Censorship, and Free Speech at UATX and "Climate Heretic" #7 in @Newsweek. @shellenberger
www.newsweek.com/revenge-of-climate-heretics-50-leading-e…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I'm honored to be "Climate Heretic" #7 out of 50 listed by @Newsweek. For decades, apocalyptic fanatics demonized, censored, and ruined lives. Facebook censored me for stating easily verifiable facts. Many people are trying to pretend it never happened. But we will never forget.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Democrats spent decades demonizing, censoring, and ruining the lives of climate heretics. Now they're using their language and gas-lighting the public. Their goal is to advance their apocalyptic and Malthusian anti-civilization agenda through more politically salient messages.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Bjorn Lomborg
@BjornLomborg
Honored, if slightly bemused, to be #21 on Newsweek's list of "climate heretics"
My heresy: climate change is real, and we should spend our money where it does the most good
archive.ph/vx9Zf
www.newsweek.com/revenge-of-climate-heretics-50-leading-e… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I'm honored to be "Climate Heretic" #7 out of 50 listed by @Newsweek. For decades, apocalyptic fanatics demonized, censored, and ruined lives. Facebook censored me for stating easily verifiable facts. Many people are trying to pretend it never happened. But we will never forget.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Democrats spent decades demonizing, censoring, and ruining the lives of climate heretics. Now they're using their language and gas-lighting the public. Their goal is to advance their apocalyptic and Malthusian anti-civilization agenda through more politically salient messages.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@BillGates is on the list for saying climate change isn't the apocalypse, well after it was safe to do so. A real profile in courage. There are many such cases of cowardly opportunists. Today, Gates is a leading advocate of censorship.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Bill Gates two weeks ago, John Kerry last week, and Hillary Clinton today — all demanding government censorship of X. Hard to see this as a coincidence. They appear to be laying the groundwork for totalitarianism. Our democratic republic is in danger.
This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A lot of the people who engage in the most psychopathic behaviors are literally mentally ill. One of them, Joe Romm, who sought to ruin careers and lives, killed himself in September. @johnpodesta @amprog @nytimes and other media promoted him for years. He had become irrelevant.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Smash JT
@SmashJT
Well this explains the insane censorship regime in Australia...
HOLY FUCK
CC: @MadamSavvy get a load of THIS!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Online misogyny causes sexual violence, say governments. But the science doesn't support such claims. Now, a new investigation reveals that mining titan Twiggy Forrest, who receives millions in subsidies, spent millions to pass censorship legislation. x.com/i/article/2115822488110387200
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Preston Byrne
@prestonjbyrne
Unreal levels of censorship coming out of Australia: they want to have the power to shut down individual podcasters.
It’s time for Congress to protect America’s interests, and free speech, on the Internet by passing the GRANITE Act.
Institute of Public Affairs
@TheIPA
“This does give Labor the ability to shut down the podcasters.”
Senator Sarah Henderson discusses the IPA’s concerns about the Digital Duty of Care bill, warning that its sweeping powers could be used to shut down podcasters reaching Australians outside the mainstream media.
#digitaldutyofcare #freespeech #australiaThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
EXCLUSIVE: New censorship legislation would let the Australian government spy on US & European citizens and report "sensitive information" about their lawful political opinions, religious beliefs, sexual orientation, and health records to foreign spy agencies, including the FBI.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
by @MikeNayna @NAffects & @Shellenberger
In September 2025, top government censorship officials from Europe, the UK, Brazil, California, and Australia met at Stanford to discuss ways to coordinate censorship at an international level. The meeting was titled “Compliance and Enforcement in a Rapidly Evolving Landscape.” Australia’s top censor, eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant, gave the keynote.
Though Grant did not provide her remarks to Public, previously she had told the World Economic Forum (WEF) that she was organizing censorship officials around the world because “we know we’re going to go much further when we work together with other like-minded independent statutory authorities around the globe.”
Inman Grant’s efforts appear to be coming to fruition in Australia, where the lower house has passed sweeping censorship and surveillance legislation that the Senate is now considering. The legislation would allow the Commissioner to monitor “lawful but harmful” speech.
Inman Grant, an American who once volunteered to a journalist that she turned down a job with the CIA, can already order a platform to reveal who is behind an anonymous account from anywhere in the world.
But the DDoC bill now before the Australian Senate would also let her use fake accounts that deceive users into thinking they are citizens and not government spies, record their legal speech, and give what she learns directly to Australia’s spy agencies. Those agencies could then share that intelligence with the FBI and other “Five Eyes” intelligence-sharing partners in the US, UK, Canada, and New Zealand.
The bill enables this by granting eSafety the ability to create an unlimited number of AI-generated “sock puppet” identities (effectively bots) under policies set “in consultation with the Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police.”
The private information that the Australian government could share with foreign intelligence agencies could include a user’s name, address, phone number, email, along with what the Privacy Act calls “sensitive information,” which includes political opinions, religious beliefs, sexual orientation, and health records.
The Institute for Public Affairs (IPA) first reported on the Privacy Act changes on Monday, and Network Affects noted last month that the new censorship legislation designates eSafety an “enforcement body” under the Privacy Act, expanding its ability to access personal information.
In 2013, documents released by whistleblower Edward Snowden revealed that British intelligence officials had allowed, as part of a secret deal with the U.S. government’s National Security Agency (NSA), for it to gather information on UK citizens who were not under suspicion of any wrongdoing.
The eSafety Commissioner could thus unmask anonymous accounts in the United States, France, or Germany, for example, that complain about controversial issues like mass migration, and report them and all of their private information to the FBI and European spy agencies.
“We have power to share with the AFP [Australian Federal Police]; we don’t have power to share with intelligence agencies at this time,” testified Heidi Snell, eSafety’s General Manager of Regulatory Operations,in October this year. “But the amendments would see us being able to share directly with those other government agencies,” she added.
Those agencies include the Australian Secret Intelligence Service (ASIS), Australia’s equivalent of the CIA; the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO), which performs a role similar to the FBI’s domestic intelligence division; the Australian Signals Directorate (Australia’s NSA); the Office of National Intelligence (ODNI); the Department of Home Affairs (DHS); the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (State Department); the Department of Defence; and any other “Commonwealth entity.”
The DDoC Bill contains a provision that would put eSafety in the same legal category as the Australian Federal Police under the Privacy Act for “surveillance activities, intelligence gathering activities or monitoring activities.”
eSafety told Public in an email that information it sends to the police may include “the account names or the identity of the users who posted the material.” A Federal Police witness testified on Oct 21 that police can pass eSafety’s information to “our ASIO partners.”
The censorship bill would change Australia’s Privacy Act so eSafety could collect sensitive personal information, including political opinions, without users’ consent,a warrant or judicial oversight. To invoke this Privacy Act exception, it would only need to “reasonably believe” that the collection is necessary for its functions...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2120554869530443979
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism and read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The more people who know about the menace of @AlboMP @AnikaWells, the safer we all are.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
SBS News
@SBSNews
New laws aiming to reform online platforms so they don't cause harm to children could "shut down the manosphere", drown businesses in red tape, and stifle free speech, an inquiry has heard.
Learn more: www.sbs.com.au/news/article/manosphere-content-could-get-… -
News24 Australia
@News24Aust
The two-day inquiry into Labor’s internet laws has exposed the Digital Duty of Care as a trainwreck policy, which could censor content involving Jordan Peterson, Pauline Hanson, Mehreen Faruqi and the so-called manosphere. www.news24.com.au/politics/australian-politics/from-gende…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It’s a totalitarian “Black Mirror” that would allow the government to secretly spy on everyone and criminalize dissent. The government has lied constantly about it. The most extreme censorship bill in history. Shame on @AlboMP @AnikaWells
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I told the Senate that this is the most extreme online censorship legislation ever. The government says it wants to protect kids. Its bill would allow it to wage info war and censor its populist enemies. The @AlboMP @AnikaWells psyop rests on fake news, fake polls, & fake NGOs.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Online misogyny causes sexual violence, say governments. But the science doesn't support such claims. Now, a new investigation reveals that mining titan Twiggy Forrest, who receives millions in subsidies, spent millions to pass censorship legislation. x.com/i/article/2115822488110387200
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
News24 Australia
@News24Aust
The two-day inquiry into Labor’s internet laws has exposed the Digital Duty of Care as a trainwreck policy, which could censor content involving Jordan Peterson, Pauline Hanson, Mehreen Faruqi and the so-called manosphere. www.news24.com.au/politics/australian-politics/from-gende…
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I told the Senate that this is the most extreme online censorship legislation ever. The government says it wants to protect kids. Its bill would allow it to wage info war and censor its populist enemies. The @AlboMP @AnikaWells psyop rests on fake news, fake polls, & fake NGOs.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Online misogyny causes sexual violence, say governments. But the science doesn't support such claims. Now, a new investigation reveals that mining titan Twiggy Forrest, who receives millions in subsidies, spent millions to pass censorship legislation. x.com/i/article/2115822488110387200
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I visited Australia in October to understand why anyone would want to pass this bill.
I found no good reason for it. And its supporters didn’t understand the bill and couldn’t defend it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I encourage the committee to recommend that the Senate reject it on fundamental moral principles.
Our liberal democratic societies depend on the people having free access to information. Censorship is barbarism.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This legislation would give the government unprecedented powers to secretly spy on its own citizens. The government hid this aspect of the legislation, just as it hid its demand to wage offensive information warfare against the public.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In sum, the Albanese government, the eSafety Commissioner, and their astroturfed supporters should all be ashamed of themselves. Their behavior and statements have been consistently deceptive. That alone should lead the Senate to reject it. /END
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Kat A 🌸
@SaiKate108
Upon deeper analysis The Digital Duty of Care Bill seems designed as part of a global censorship push to introduce sweeping surveillance powers.
Incredible analysis from Margaret Chamber ( institute of Public Affairs) who has uncovered a hidden amendment to the Privacy Act which unleashes the eSafety Commissioner’s ability to gather massive information on people.
Where information on political views, biometric data, religious believes, ethnicity could be collected without consent and could be shared overseas with regulators like OfCom.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
𝓕𝓸𝓲𝓭
@policypussy_
I was curious what role government funding plays among the organisations weighing in on the Digital Duty of Care Bill, so Grok bot and I did a little surveying (illustrative rather than exhaustive).
Today was day 1 of the Senate hearings.
Of the 25 organisations that appeared, 13 receive/d recent government funding, 4 are tech platforms, 7 don't receive government funding, and 1 I couldn't confirm. 2 individuals appeared in a private capacity.
7 organisations opposed the bill, 4 in their submissions and 3 at the hearing. None of them currently receive government funding. Funny that!
Not one of the 13 funded organisations opposed it. 12 support it, most with amendments, and 1 is neutral.
Several rely heavily on government money: ACCAN gets 98% of its revenue from government, Our Watch 87% and Teach Us Consent 87%. Teach Us Consent has also received two federal grants worth $7.56m. Lucky ducks.
Digital Rights Watch, a BIG supporter, reported no government revenue last year, but it received $301,500 from Minderoo, a major backer of the bill. It hasn't declared this year's funding yet.
Among the tech platforms, Google holds current government contracts and supports the bill. TikTok opposes it as drafted.
The government can buy consensus with our taxpayer dollars.
Anthony Khallouf
@ausvstheagenda
🚨BREAKING: The Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026 has passed in the House of Representatives by Labor, Independents and the Greens.
96 YES, 38 NO.
Voted against by Liberals, Nationals, One Nation and Rebekha Sharkie.
Andrew Hastie didn’t appear at any divisions.
This bill will force online businesses to conduct annual risk assessments, report to eSafety and face penalties for non-compliance.
It gives the government power to influence platform design features and impose age-assurance requirements.
It authorises eSafety to operate covert “sock puppet” accounts for government surveillance and information warfare.
It will classify content that “encourages or promotes hostile attitudes towards women or gender equality” as harmful, including legitimate criticism of feminism.
Public hearings are set for 9–10 November, with the inquiry report due 20 November. The bill must still pass the Senate. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Alice
@RationalBlonde
I'm begging Jensen Huang to reconcile with his wife. we cannot afford another billionaire ex-wife entering her "I'm going to fix society by funding its most annoying people" era
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Democrats spent decades demonizing, censoring, and ruining the lives of climate heretics. Now they're using their language and gas-lighting the public. Their goal is to advance their apocalyptic and Malthusian anti-civilization agenda through more politically salient messages.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For three decades, Democratic leaders described climate change as an emergency that justified radically remaking the American economy. No challenge “poses a greater threat to future generations than climate change,” said Barack Obama in his 2015 State of the Union address. Kamala Harris said in 2019, “There’s no question I’m in favor of banning fracking.” Climate change is “the existential threat of our time,” said Nancy Pelosi upon becoming Speaker of the House in 2019. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez said around the same time, “the world is going to end” in 12 years without action. “Climate change is literally an existential threat to our Nation and to the world,” said Joe Biden, campaigning in New Hampshire in 2019, and said, “I guarantee you. We’re going to end fossil fuel.” In 2023, he said that “the only existential threat humanity faces, even more frightening than a nuclear war,” was warming above 1.5 degrees above pre-industrial temperatures. Senator Chuck Schumer in 2021 urged Biden to declare “a national emergency on climate change.”
Today, Democrats have practically nothing to say about it. The share of House and Senate Democrats’ press releases that mention climate change declined from 28% in 2021 to just 2% in the first five months of this year. Where the House Democrats’ 2020 climate report used the words “climate change” more than 500 times, their September 2026 report used them just 22 times. Representative Sean Casten of Illinois, one of the most climate alarmist members in Congress, said, “You also don’t necessarily have to use the word climate to talk about all of those things, right?”
A few Democrats still raise the subject. Senator Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island, who has given 308 “Time to Wake Up” speeches on climate, wrote in June that “the climate hushers are wrong about pretty much everything.” Six in ten Democrats call climate change a very big problem, which is roughly the same share as in 2016.
But Senator Ed Markey, who sponsored the “Green New Deal” in the Senate, hardly talks about it anymore. “Six years ago, Green New Deal was every phrase out of Ed Markey’s mouth every chance he got,” said a Democratic strategist in Massachusetts. “That is not the case now.”
What’s more, many Democrats now describe themselves as supporters of an “all of the above” energy policy that includes oil and natural gas.
As a Texas state legislator, James Talarico in 2021 sponsored a bill to cut Texas emissions 90% below 1990 levels by 2050. Those days are long gone. He won the Texas Senate race by campaigning on an “all-of-the-above” to protect “good-paying oil and gas jobs.” In a January podcast, he said, “Too many people in our party talk about eliminating oil and gas.”
Incoming Alaska Senator Mary Peltola campaigned on having pressured the Biden administration to approve a major ConocoPhillips’ oil project. “That’s why I took on my own party to secure the Willow project after years of delays,” she said in May.
Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania signed a pledge to end fracking in 2016. In May, he introduced a bill to protect liquefied natural gas exports. And when Schumer unveiled the Senate Democratic energy plan in March, he said, “And when I say, ‘clean energy’, I don’t mean only solar and wind.”
All of this is very strange behavior from people who spent 30 years attacking people who made similar remarks as “climate deniers,” imagined to be guilty of the worst moral crimes.
Democrats and their allies spent a decade demanding that anyone who questioned the climate emergency be demonized, sued, censored, and punished.
Democrats waged lawfare. In 2015, Whitehouse proposed a civil racketeering investigation of “the organized climate denial scheme,” essentially lawfare against people he disagreed with. The following year, Democratic attorneys general, including Kamala Harris, announced investigations of oil and gas companies for saying the same thing as Talarico and Peltola. In 2024, after a joint Senate and House investigation, Senator Whitehouse and Representative Jamie Raskin asked Biden’s Attorney General to investigate the oil industry and “take any appropriate legal action.”
Left-wing green groups successfully censored their enemies. In 2021, Greenpeace, the Sierra Club, and the Environmental Defense Fund asked Facebook to “adopt a similar policy to what it created to eliminate COVID misinformation.” Google bent. In 2021, it announced it would demonetize content that “contradicts well-established scientific consensus around the existence and causes of climate change.”
Politicians joined in the demands for mass censorship of accurate information about climate change. In 2021, Senators Whitehouse, Brian Schatz and Elizabeth Warren asked Facebook and Google to label or deplatform “climate disinformation” and to stop selling ads against sites that deny climate change. In reality, these were ads that raised legitimate questions.
The Biden administration demanded censorship of criticism of renewables. “The tech companies have to stop allowing specific individuals over and over again to spread disinformation,” said Gina McCarthy, Biden’s national climate adviser, in 2022.
Democrats demanded Facebook censor factual information about forest fires, coral reefs, heat waves, and pointed out that the world cannot run on renewables, which is identical to the “all of the above” energy messaging of Talarico and other Democrats. Climate disinformation was “seeding, basically, doubt about the costs associated with” clean energy, said McCarthy. But doubting the cost of renewables is exactly what Talarico, Fetterman, Peltola, and other Democrats are doing right now.
In a variety of ways, the Left sought to seriously damage the careers and lives of the most high-profile scientists, journalists, and others who pointed to facts that are inconvenient to the Left’s narratives. Some of the most attacked individuals include Roger Pielke, Jr., Bjorn Lomborg, Judy Curry, Steven Koonin, John Stossel, and me. Now the Left is preaching lukewarmism and “all of the above.” Why is that? What happened?...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2119855834481983588
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism that is exposing the pseudoscientific climatist agenda and prevent climate totalitarians from memory-holing what they didThis post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Ah, yes. A crack “covert Russian network” came to the same conclusion as everyone with half a brain. And now @Reuters is helping @vonderleyen smear anyone who recognizes reality and rejects EU/Reuters propaganda
2016 is calling and wants its psyop backPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“Insufficient government spending caused people to loot department stores”
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Leftism today is defined by its rejection of reality itself as immoral, @galexybrane reveal in our forthcoming book, The Left's War On Reality. PLEASE PRE-ORDER IT TODAY
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
From borders & trans to Covid & climate, the Left said it knew best but got it horribly wrong. Instead of taking responsibility, it demonizes & silences. The Left’s War On Reality by Alex Gutentag (@galexybrane) and me reveals a road to hell paved with bad intentions. www.amazon.com/dp/0063421577
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Silkie Carlo
@silkiecarlo
UK Government internet policy is now “if there is somewhere where people can talk to each other, they need to show their ID” 🫠
It’s not a serious policy to keep children safe - it’s just creating an authoritarian checkpoint internet. We can’t allow it.
www.thetimes.com/article/9c9d3388-5092-4c47-ba4d-bf1cc959… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Institute of Public Affairs
@TheIPA
“Why does the eSafety Commissioner need powers to profile people?”
IPA Research Fellow Margaret Chambers questions why the eSafety Commissioner needs powers to undertake surveillance and monitoring, collect sensitive information and share Australians’ personal information internationally under the Digital Duty of Care Bill.
#surveillance #privacy #australiaThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
News24 Australia
@News24Aust
The grassroots parents’ movement that championed phone bans and the under-16 social media ban, has extraordinarily condemned Labor’s Digital Duty of Care, warning the laws risk weaponising child protection to silence political dissent.
news24.com.au/politics/australian-politics/fingerprints-o…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Amazing. The bill has no credibility just like @AlboMP @AnikaWells
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
News24 Australia
@News24Aust
The grassroots parents’ movement that championed phone bans and the under-16 social media ban, has extraordinarily condemned Labor’s Digital Duty of Care, warning the laws risk weaponising child protection to silence political dissent.
news24.com.au/politics/australian-politics/fingerprints-o… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ryan Dally
@Ryandally08
BREAKING: Anthony Albanese’s “digital duty of care bill”, is now even stricter than originally proposed, effectively destroying online free speech in Australia.
eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant just signaled that Labor’s upcoming Digital Duty of Care bill is going to be even stricter than first thought, threatening massive penalties that will effectively destroy the free speech online community in Australia.
Under the Albanese government, we are rapidly moving toward a reality where you can no longer criticize him or his administration.
This is an absolute outrage.
Look at what’s happening behind the scenes:
Moving the Goalposts: Grant is pushing to amend the bill at the last minute to add “enforceable baseline obligations” making the legislation far more aggressive than the original draft.
Tougher Penalties & Policing: Communications Minister Anika Wells is openly urging the Coalition to join them in making these online safety laws “even tougher”
Rushed Legislation: Labor is desperately racing to ram this heavily bolstered bill through parliament with only one sitting fortnight left in the year.
This isn't about safety anymore, its a reckless attack on your right to speak freely online.
Australians are being locked out of their own digital public square so Labor can govern without criticism.
This is outrageous. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Free Speech Union of Australia
@FSUofAustralia
Great speech from the Heads Up Alliance!
Looks like the 'Digital Duty of Care Bill' is so bad, it is now strongly opposed by parents groups. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Solana
@micsolana
if you ever happen to find yourself shitting in your own car
because you are mad at elon musk about politics
consider for a moment you may be mentally ill
Western Lensman
@WesternLensman
Scott Galloway says he owned a Tesla, but sold it because of Elon.
"Not before taking a giant dump in the passenger seat. True story."
He's gone from suggesting Elon be executed to telling stories of taking dumps in a car he owned because it was made by Elon's company.
This is a broken, deranged and utterly toxic individual. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Erika Kirk
@MrsErikaKirk
To see leftist podcasters, comedians, and commentators laugh about political assassination as though it’s entertainment and the destruction of a human life is a punchline, is beyond disgusting.
My husband, Charlie Kirk, was killed in an act of political violence, something our two children and I will live with every day for the rest of our lives.
A culture that laughs at assassination is one of profound moral decay. It threatens the very foundation of our country and the principles that hold our democracy together.
You do not have to agree with someone’s politics to recognize the value of their life. This should not be so hard.
Political violence must never be something this country tolerates, excuses, or celebrates. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Roman Helmet Guy
@romanhelmetguy
Charlie Kirk got killed for having the exact same stance on trans issues as Dave Chappelle made 5 comedy specials about.
Lucky Teter
@TheMagaHulk
"Ever since that guy Charlie Kirk got murdered... and I shouldn't say this publicly... I feel better."
-Dave Chappelle at Madison Square Garden
And the New York City crowd laughs like a bunch of hyenas.
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"I'm so happy Charlie Kirk was killed. I can't help it, it's involuntary." -Dave Chappelle tonight at Madison Square Garden
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Thibault Louis
@thefrenchmaker
Tu t'appelles Charlotte. 23 ans. Tu étudies à Sciences Po Paris. Tu milites à La France insoumise et tu vas à la techno-parade contre la vie chère ce weekend.
Ton père, Philippe, est ingénieur chez Total, à côté de Bizanos.
Il travaille depuis 36 ans dans l'énergie, a commencé foreur et dirige maintenant le projet "Exploration puits 2035" avant de partir à la retraite.
Philippe te fait un virement tous les mois pour financer ton 2 pièces à 1350€ dans le quartier latin et tes cours de pilates reformer.
Tu as un tote bag « taxez les riches », un iPhone 17 Pro et un abonnement à Mediapart.
Tu considères que les grandes entreprises sont "une catastrophe sociale et écologique". Tu as d'ailleurs écrit un mémoire de 42 pages sur les violences symboliques du capitalisme.
Philippe qui se lève à 6h depuis 1987, te paye tes études grâce ses à anciennes stocks-options chez Shell.
À Sciences Po, tu as enfin rencontré des jeunes qui partagent tes convictions. Leurs parents sont avocats, médecins, hauts fonctionnaires ou dirigeants.
Vous avez fondé un collectif de "house music" en résistance au néolibéralisme.
Vous vous réunissez chaque jeudi dans un café du 11e pour discuter de la lutte des classes autour d'une bouteille de vin naturel orange à 38€.
Tu n'as jamais travaillé dans une usine, mais tu connais parfaitement les conditions de vie du prolétariat grâce à tes stages à l'ONU et au PNUD trouvés par les contacts de ta mère Christine à L'Oréal.
Tu expliques à ton père que les grandes entreprises exploitent les travailleurs.
Il te propose de venir rencontrer les techniciens de son usine pendant les vacances. Tu peux pas car t'as anniversaire de Julie à Santorin.
À Noël, tu rentres au "pays".
Ton père vient te chercher à la gare de Dax avec sa nouvelle Tesla.
Pendant le trajet, tu lui expliques que les cadres supérieurs sont complètement déconnectés des réalités populaires et que Elon Musk est la lie de l'humanité.
Philippe sourit nerveusement.
De retour dans ta maisonnée de famille, Philippe demande si ta recherche de stage en cinéma militant avance en te proposant du foie gras et du serrano-manchego.
Tu lui dis que tu es vegan depuis cette année et qu'il est insensible à la cruauté animale.
Philippe se sert un verre de Jurançon, s'asseoit sur son fauteuil Roche Bobois et te demande si tu es pour la taxation de l'héritage à 100%. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Advocates of censorship are, to a person, pathological, liars, thieves or all three.
Disclose.tv
@disclosetv
NEW - Irish disinformation and "fake news" expert Tom Felle, appointed by Ireland’s online speech regulator as an expert assessor, falsely claimed a journalism doctorate from City, University of London that was never awarded.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Recent receipts
x.com/shellenberger/status/2107077145965072766
x.com/shellenberger/status/2106092349495410716
x.com/shellenberger/status/2108239954610425956
x.com/shellenberger/status/2110660498723393741
x.com/shellenberger/status/2111983805171191890
x.com/shellenberger/status/2110595705635316154
x.com/shellenberger/status/2114464114449723472
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
President @LulaOficial is linked to a drug cartel the U.S. has designated a "Foreign Terrorist Organization," and yet Brazil's election court has prevented his presidential rival, @FlavioBolsonaro from saying so. Censorship of the Lula-PCC link began under Alexandre de Moraes.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
David Sirota
@davidsirota
🚨NEWS: Top Dems are heading to a conference with a shadowy billionaire front group @MajorityDems - and the group is now barring access to @LeverNews reporters as punishment for our investigative series exposing the group's funders.
Follow for a thread (1/x)... -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Few comprehend the sheer dimwittedness of the new DSA mayor of LA, as it’s been overshadowed by the actions & inactions of the mayor she defeated, which led directly to large swaths of LA burning down. Below she boasts of getting a crosswalk painted. It took her 9 months.
Councilmember Nithya Raman
@cd4losangeles
The Los Feliz Neighborhood Council alerted our office in late 2025 to the need for a crosswalk at Sunset Dr. and Bates St., which has just been completed!
Thank you to our incredible CD4 Field Team for continuing to problem-solve, push for solutions, and make our streets safer.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Ramen is an anti-leader. She chaired LA's homelessness committee. She then sat on a staff report about the need to pull the $300 million a year out of the corrupt city-county homeless agency for 10 months. Finally the county pulled its own $300 million from the crooked agency.
“It's been sitting [for] 280 days, a report in your committee that you won't hear,” said Rodriguez at a January meeting. “So let's stop playing this false notion of the arsonists showing up as the firefighters.”
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Ramen is infamous at city hall for incompetence. That’s the view of other leftists there. People complain about Mamdani but with Bass and now Ramen, LA is dealing with incompetence on top of ideology. LA makes NYC appear to have Japanese-level competence in comparison.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Eli Vieira
@elivieira
Moraes fez uma reunião de emergência com Lula depois da nossa reportagem.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The economy and Iran were behind the Democrats' victory. But now, many of the elected leaders are seeking to go against the will of the people on trans, race, migration, and the weaponization of government. Behind them is a radicalized base & ideological dream worlds.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Voters rejected President Donald Trump and Republicans on Tuesday for reasons having to do with the war in Iran and affordability. Six out of ten said they were very concerned about grocery prices, while two-thirds said Trump’s policies had made the economy worse. Three out of four voters called the war a crucial or major reason for their vote. Sixty-three percent said it was the wrong decision. And when it came time to vote on core cultural issues for the Left, they often voted against it. In Washington and Colorado, for example, voters banned males from female sports, while in California, they voted against a billionaire wealth tax.
And yet many Democrats are acting as though they were elected to do something else. Colorado’s governor-elect, Phil Weiser, said the day after the vote that he would “take a look at these anti-trans measures and what adjustments are necessary and appropriate.” Washington’s Democratic Party chair said she would fight to overturn the ban in court. “DEI is back!” wrote Rep. Ro Khanna on election night. “We will rip ICE apart,” said Minnesota Senator-elect Peggy Flanagan. Maine Senator-elect Troy Jackson promised to “fight to abolish ICE.” Tech executives “are going to need to plant new forests for all of the subpoenas we’ll be printing,” wrote Sen. Ed Markey. Senate Democrats are weighing bills to vet AI models before release, which opens the door to government censorship of content....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2118469797927112989
Plesae subscribe now to support our award-winning journalism and to read the rest of the story.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Peter Baker
@peterbakernyt
Six days before the election, more than two dozen Trump strategists logged onto a private video call. The mood was grim. The talk turned to cyanide. “Do you want the white pill first, or the black pill first?" @ShaneGoldmacher @jonathanvswan @maggieNYT www.nytimes.com/2026/11/04/us/politics/trump-midterms-los…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
dude it’s literally a meme
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
J.K. Rowling
@jk_rowling
You've avoided nearly all of my questions, Norah, because you're literally incapable of answering them. Your mind is firmly closed to any evidence or facts that undermine your preferred narrative. You consider it immoral for anyone to even question you, even though you voluntarily and confidently entered this discussion. You're like a flat-earther. Nothing I or anyone else says to you will permeate your stubborn quasi-religious beliefs, because to change your mind would take away a core part of your self image, which is as somebody who is kinder and better and more righteous than the nasty people still advocating for the safety of women and girls.
You repeat your thought-terminating clichés and unevidenced assertions, which I assume sound clever inside your echo chamber, but which, outside it, make you appear not only dim, but a total moral vacuum. Increased risk to females? Who cares. Women threatened by violence? Of course those poor trans-identified men lash out when they meet resistance! What is a gender identity? You can't really say, but like the flat-earther, you're sure it exists, because your tribe is held together by belief in it, and pride themselves on their blind faith in it.
I keep waiting for a single gender ideologue or trans activist to truly engage with the facts, but all of you sheer away from them like horses from fireworks. It truly is like talking to cult members who're incapable of engaging in rational debate and just keep chanting the mantras, consigning all serious questions to the 'evil' bin.
I've been told I'm on the wrong side of history thousands of times. By debating people like you, I've come to realise that your ilk's idea of the 'right side of history' means stripping women and girls' of their rights, excusing male violence against women, siding with those issuing death and rape threats and attempting to suppress critical thought and freedom of speech.
Maybe, like the flat-earthers, you genuinely think history will vindicate you. I believe people will look back on this period and analyse your arguments, not because they admire them, but because they're trying to fathom how so many supposedly intelligent people fell, hook, line and sinker for a bunch of vacuous, post-modern, pseudo-intellectual cobblers, while being completely indifferent to the real world harm they were enabling. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
noelle lenoir
@noellelenoir
Urgent : signez et RT maintenant contre la censure de CNEWS, pour défendre la liberté d'expression ! damocles.co/non-censure-cnews #jesoutienscnews
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It's pretty much a 100% perfect record at this point that the creepy/spooky people who raise the alarm about election interference, bots, disinformation, doxxing, etc, are the ones interfering in elections, using bots, spreading disinformation, and doxxing.
WIRED
@WIRED
An underground activist group says it plans to start openly doxing billionaires as part of a phased campaign against what it calls the American oligarchy—starting with Elon Musk and Tesla’s board. www.wired.com/story/anti-oligarchy-activists-plan-to-dox-…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
All of these have been just in the last few weeks. There's dozens of cases of the creeps accusing their political enemies of doing what they are in fact doing:
Bots:
x.com/shellenberger/status/2104265678924791948
Disinformation
x.com/shellenberger/status/1604871630613753856
x.com/shellenberger/status/2107077145965072766
x.com/shellenberger/status/2114464114449723472
Conspiracy theories for election interference:
x.com/shellenberger/status/2103235746194989471
Foreign election interference:
x.com/shellenberger/status/2100982929279132156
x.com/shellenberger/status/2097366091999662420
Censorship to protect corrupt politicians:
x.com/shellenberger/status/2096939439280750760
x.com/shellenberger/status/2113628564679504373
x.com/shellenberger/status/2115978324195541091
x.com/shellenberger/status/2111983805171191890
DARVO as core CIC strategy
x.com/shellenberger/status/2109065900813160710
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
If you're curious why the media is spreading so much false information about the riots, consider:
— The French Culture Ministry paid €204.7 million in direct aid to the news media in 2023, of which Le Monde received €8.3 million, L’Humanité €6.5 million and Libération €6.3 million
— The @afpfr runs "fact-checks" in 26 languages, received €120 million from the French state in 2025, against €200.3 million in commercial revenue. @AFP is French government propaganda and disinformation
— European governments are committed through a UN agreement to spread pro-mass migration propaganda by funding it directly. The “migration compact,” which 152 governments voted for in the UN General Assembly in 2018, commits them to “stopping allocation of public funding... to media outlets that systematically promote intolerance, xenophobia, racism and other forms of discrimination towards migrants," which is broadly interpreted to cover criticism of mass migration policies
— To maintain control over news media, the European Commission funds a network of 15 fact-checking hubs with tens of millions of euros, and its rules require platforms to give priority to notices from “trusted flaggers.”
— Governments fund think tanks to produce reports, including ones demanding censorship, that the news media cover sympathetically and editorialize in support of.
— The @ISDglobal in London — which demands censorship of people it disagrees with on climate change, gender, and migration, refuses to speak with journalists, and lists a phony address — lists among its funders the British Foreign Office, the U.S. Departments of Homeland Security and Justice, the German Foreign Office and the European Commission, along with Google and Microsoft.
www.isdglobal.org/partnerships-and-funders/
— Public reported in 2024 that ISD and the German fact-checker Correctiv, both government-funded, had spread false claims about German farmers and opposition politicians.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The media have spent the last decade demanding online censorship of right-wing populists to avoid "real-world harm." Now, they're promoting left-wing disinformation — including that migrant students are "deprived" — that's driving street violence.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Whether Democrats take one or two houses of Congress, they and the media are about to pull off one of the most brilliant psychological operations in recent memory: convincing millions of swing voters they had moderated on trans.
Talarico made national headlines when he went on Fox to say he would oppose trans athletes in girls’ sports “if it risks safety or fairness.” Four days later, a woman posing as a supporter secretly recorded him saying, “my position hasn’t changed,” after she asked him to defend her trans-identified nephew's ability to compete in girls' sports. The media buried or ignored it.
On “60 Minutes,” El-Sayed called concerns over boys in girls’ sports a manufactured culture war issue meant to distract from high prices and said he was “not running to govern sports,” without ever saying he opposed it.
Every Senate Democrat present, including Ossoff, voted in March 2025, and again in March 2026, to block legislation that would have banned males from female sports. Sherrod Brown cast the same vote in 2021 and 2024. Peltola cast it in the House in 2023. None since have promised to vote differently in the future.
Meanwhile, Roy Cooper vetoed a bill that would have banned males in female sports, Josh Turek voted against Iowa’s 2025 health budget, which barred Medicaid from paying for surgeries or cross-sex hormones, and then ran an ad saying he is “against taxpayers paying for sex changes,” and Ed Markey made his support for transgenderism central to his campaign and defeated his moderate opponent Seth Moulton by 65% to 35% in the Massachusetts Senate primary.
One can only appreciate how brilliant the Democrats/media psyop was when you consider that 71% of the public opposes trans medical procedures for minors and 79% oppose males in female sports.
Even the share of Democrats who favor getting males out of female sports rose from 37% in 2022 to 45% in 2025, while the percentage of Democrats who believe changing one’s gender is morally acceptable declined 11 points between 2025 and 2026.
Republicans spent at least $183 million on ads attacking the Democrats on trans, which is at least $30 million more than they spent at the same point in 2024.
It wasn’t enough to overcome one of the Democrats’ most successful deception operations after over a decade of hugely consequential ones (e.g., Russiagate hoax, Charlottesville, BLM, Hunter Biden laptop, climate, Covid, etc.)
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Democratic candidates who could win back the Senate for their party appear to be abandoning transgenderism in sports and medicine. Democratic Senate nominee for Texas, James Talarico, said “Absolutely” when asked in September if he would ban gender surgery for minors. He added, “I will oppose trans athletes playing in girls’ sports if it risks safety or fairness…There are not six sexes. There are two.” Democratic Senate nominee for Ohio, Sherrod Brown, noted that, “In Ohio, it’s against the law to perform transgender surgeries on kids. That’s right, it’s illegal.” Iowa Democratic Senate candidate Josh Turek ran an ad last month where he noted that he is against males in female sports and that the state already bans them. “I’m against taxpayers paying for sex changes, too. Anyone who tells you any different is lying,” he said in the same ad. Democratic Senate candidate Amy Acton said in June, “I do not support boys playing in girls' sports. This is already settled law in Ohio, and as governor, I will enforce and uphold the law.” And Democratic Senate candidate for Alaska, Mary Peltola, said in 2024, “No, I don’t think that we should have men competing in women’s sports.”
But there is less to these shifts than meets the eye. In September, a woman asked Talarico if he would defend her trans-identified nephew’s ability to compete against females in women’s sports, and Talarico said, “Always. The way I fought for trans kids in the legislature is how I will fight for them in the U.S. Senate… I think I have the most inclusive policy of any candidate who’s running.” CBS’s “60 Minutes” last night released an interview with Democratic Senate candidate for Michigan, Abdul El-Sayed. Correspondent Ross Douthat asked him about trans-identified males playing in female sports. El-Sayed was dismissive. “A lot of the culture war issues that get fought right now are about trying to distract us from the fact that we can’t afford our gas, can’t afford our groceries, can’t see a doctor, are worried about whether or not our kids are gonna have a good life. And instead, we’re out here talking about who gets to play what sport, which, you know, should be the question of the people who govern sports.”
Others have similarly dodged the issue. Democratic Senate candidate for North Carolina, Roy Cooper, in 2023 vetoed a bill that would have banned males in female sports, Peltola voted against a House sports bill in that same year that would have banned males from female sports, called it “bullying” and “federal overreach,” and Democratic Senate candidate for Georgia, Jon Ossoff, has repeatedly voted against federal legislation to ban males from female sports....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2117382950912250199
Please subscribe now to support our award-winning investigative reporting, debunking the mainstream media.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Democrats appear to be moderating on trans. Except they’re not. @Jamestalarico said his position is unchanged. @SherrodBrown voted to keep males in female sports. @AbdulElSayed dodged the question. Special interests, the radicalism of primary voters, and pseudo-religion drive the denial of biological reality
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Riots in Germany, declining property values in Portland, and South Africa's crumbling infrastructure all have distinct causes, say the media. In truth, they all have one root cause: left-wing policies and ideology. The media, for its part, is complicit in the grand deception.
This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The various governance crises around the world have different causes, say the news media. A downtown Portland hotel sold for $101 million less than it bought it for in 2016 due to “post-2020 pandemic impacts, slow tourism recovery, and high downtown office vacancies,” say reporters. French students are protesting severe teacher shortages, large class sizes, and neglected and dilapidated buildings, say journalists, while German students are rioting and looting in Frankfurt to protest living costs and military conscription, they say. And South Africa’s water and sewage infrastructure is collapsing due to a rising population, crime, and corruption, say the media.
But left-wing policies and ideology are the underlying cause of each of those problems. The reason for Portland’s slow recovery and office vacancies compared to other cities is that the city and state’s soft-on-crime policies have made downtown Portland dangerous and unpleasant. Radical Left groups are behind the French and German riots. And the policies and ideology of the left-wing African National Congress (ANC) have undermined meritocracy and legitimized corruption in South Africa....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2117028530697449681
Please subscribe now to support investigative journalism that changes the conversation and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
From borders & trans to Covid & climate, the Left said it knew best but got it horribly wrong. Instead of taking responsibility, it demonizes & silences. The Left’s War On Reality by Alex Gutentag (@galexybrane) and me reveals a road to hell paved with bad intentions. www.amazon.com/dp/0063421577
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ian Miller
@ianmSC
Literally everywhere on earth is just one big long example of left wing ideology being a complete and disastrous failure and they learn absolutely nothing from it, ever
Polymarket
@Polymarket
JUST IN: Johannesburg, South Africa, is reportedly on the brink of a "total collapse" of its water system as worsening shortages leave residents without running water for weeks.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
If you talked to your neighbors rather than flipped off their yard signs, you’d find many if not most don’t like Paxton much and are voting for him to protect themselves from emotionally unstable haters like you.
Ryan Holiday
@RyanHoliday
Backlash from literally the worst people…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I enjoy reading the Stoics but a hard work-out does much more for one’s anxiety. What it apparently can’t solve is blind hatred of people you disagree with. If it could then Ryan wouldn’t have become the very thing he has sermonized against for 12 years
Roman Helmet Guy
@romanhelmetguy
You must remember that all philosophy is a confession. People become obsessed with stoicism because they are naturally neurotic. That doesn’t mean stoicism can’t help you. If you are neurotic, it will help you a lot. Marcus Aurelius was neurotic. But it does mean you need to update your mental model of “this stoic guru will be stoic” to “this stoic guru will be neurotic.” Thinking the DailyStoic guy must be mentally stable is like thinking someone on anti-depressants must not be depressed.
This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Haters gonna hate
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Stoicism is one of the West’s most influential philosophical traditions, and author Ryan Holiday is its greatest advocate. And so, when he says that Ivanka Trump’s praise of Marcus Aurelius is “as cringe as it possibly gets, because it’s not real and it’s totally missing the point,” anyone who cares about Stoicism should pay attention. While Ivanka’s quotation of Marcus, on how “the soul becomes dyed the color of its thoughts,” reproduces the sentence accurately, explains Holiday, she fails to live up to the philosophy because she has not, in his terms, staged “an intervention with your dad whose life would be dyed with his horrible, negative, mean bullying thoughts all the time.”
But what Holiday demands of Ivanka contradicts the stoic philosophy he claims to teach. “A man must know many things first,” wrote Marcus Aurelius in Book 11, “before he be able truly and judiciously to judge of another man’s action.” And yet Holiday does not entertain the possibility that Ivanka has thought carefully about her relationship to her father, that she has considered and rejected the path of public denunciation, or that her loyalty might itself reflect a moral commitment. Instead, he assumes that her silence about her father proves her unethical.
Donald Trump’s tweets, his rallies, his rhetorical style, and his political career are not Ivanka’s to control. The very first sentence of Stoic Epictetus’s Handbook says, “Some things are in our control and others not. Things in our control are opinion, pursuit, desire, aversion, and, in a word, whatever are our own actions. Things not in our control are body, property, reputation, command, and, in one word, whatever are not our own actions...”
x.com/shellenberger/status/2051009708626952391
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Support for the most radical censorship bill in the West is 100% fake, paid for by the corrupt @AlboMP and his billionaire backer, Twiggy Forrest, who takes hundreds of millions a year of taxpayer money. They’re desperate to censor critics who correctly point out that their policies put the financial interests of China ahead of the security and prosperity of the Australian people.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Australia bet big on hydrogen made from renewables and lost billions. Now, one of Australia's largest miners may soon cut production and jobs. The cause was a set of catastrophic decisions by Labor leaders and Fortescue's founder, Andrew "Twiggy" Forrest. x.com/i/article/2116320249012518912
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Rather than confront unpleasant realities, Twiggy Forrest has long sought to silence his critics.
It makes sense that he’s now demanding government censorship. He’s going to need a lot of it to cover up the catastrophic impact of his delusions.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
So spooky
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Online misogyny causes sexual violence, say governments. But the science doesn't support such claims. Now, a new investigation reveals that mining titan Twiggy Forrest, who receives millions in subsidies, spent millions to pass censorship legislation. x.com/i/article/2115822488110387200
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Taxpayers gave mining titan Twiggy Forrest's Fortescu A$308M in energy subsidies in 2025 alone, plus A$99M for an H2 project he abandoned. In exchange, Forrest gave millions for propaganda to pass @AlboMP government's censorship bill. It's a transparent, sinister quid pro quo.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Online misogyny causes sexual violence, say governments. But the science doesn't support such claims. Now, a new investigation reveals that mining titan Twiggy Forrest, who receives millions in subsidies, spent millions to pass censorship legislation. x.com/i/article/2115822488110387200
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Twiggy Forrest claims to care about the people of Australia, but he paid investors US$1 billion in third quarter of 2026 even though Fortescu is in the middle of an epic price dispute with China that may force it to scale back mining operations within a matter of weeks.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Australia bet big on hydrogen made from renewables and lost billions. Now, one of Australia's largest miners may soon cut production and jobs. The cause was a set of catastrophic decisions by Labor leaders and Fortescue's founder, Andrew "Twiggy" Forrest. x.com/i/article/2116320249012518912
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
How will Twiggy Forrest explain to the Australian people why they should keep paying him A$308 million in tax subsidies per year while he pays himself A$1.2B?
How will @AlboMP explain this?
Or do they just plan to censor anyone who points this out?Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
*Fortescue not Fortescu 😅
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Well of course
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
😂 tough climate indeed — for Forrest and Fortescue
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Australia bet big on hydrogen made from renewables and lost billions. Now, one of Australia's largest miners may soon cut production and jobs. The cause was a set of catastrophic decisions by Labor leaders and Fortescue's founder, Andrew "Twiggy" Forrest. x.com/i/article/2116320249012518912
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Bojan Pancevski
@bopanc
It was the most constructive call with Putin since 2021. Why was it misreported by @FT so badly? Euro diplos often want to derail initiatives they don’t like or simply blabber 3nd hand gossip. Putin doesn’t need to lecture @alexstubb Stubb on Russian history. Stubb in particular and Finnish leaders in general know that history.
The key deliverable from the call was Baltic deescalation and a new, functional channel run by competent people, for a change, to support the Ukraine talks. Kyiv and DC were on board and involved. EU rightfully wasn’t.
Two postures emerge in Europe: in Britain, Denmark and Poland some think that the longer the war lasts the more Russia is drained.
Elsewhere there’s another view: the longer the war lasts the greater the potential for conflict with Russia, whose armaments industry grows by the month.
Henri Vanhanen
@HenriVanhanen
For my English-speaking followers, let's get the facts straight about the Stubb–Støre call with Putin.
New reporting from Finland provides important details missing from much of the international debate. Some of the initial accusations now look rather premature.
First, why did the call happen?
According to President Stubb, Ukraine's peace negotiations were close to collapsing last week, with relations between Kyiv and Washington in serious trouble. Finnish sources suggest there was even a risk of the US disengaging from the process.
At Zelenskyy's request, Finland and Norway organised the Oslo talks with American negotiators Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, alongside other European representatives.
The subsequent call to Putin was prepared with Ukraine and the US. According to Finnish sources, key allies were informed beforehand and briefed afterwards. Helsinki also wanted Ukraine to publicly confirm its support for the initiative.
Zelenskyy has since explicitly defended the call and praised its transparency.
Second, the controversy surrounding European coordination deserves clarification.
Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen accused Finland and Norway of acting independently and failing to coordinate with other European countries.
But Stubb and Støre have both stated that allies were informed in advance and received detailed briefings afterwards. New reporting from Finnish news agency STT supports their account.
There is an important distinction between not being informed, not being consulted on the decision, and fundamentally disagreeing with that decision.
Frederiksen's criticism increasingly appears to reflect a disagreement over whether direct contact with Putin should happen at all, rather than simply a lack of notification. Her initial framing therefore risks creating a misleading impression of an uncoordinated diplomatic operation.
Political disagreement should not be confused with evidence that Finland and Norway acted behind their allies' backs.
Third, what actually happened during the call?
Finnish broadcaster Yle and news agency STT have challenged the Financial Times' account of Putin delivering a lengthy history lecture to passive Nordic listeners.
Their sources describe a substantive exchange in which Stubb and Støre questioned Putin about the upcoming Abu Dhabi negotiations and stressed that prolonging the war would not diminish European support for Ukraine.
Freedom of navigation in the Baltic Sea, keeping maritime routes open and Russia's shadow fleet were also discussed.
Finnish-Russian bilateral relations reportedly were not discussed at all. The parties agreed to keep the communication channel available.
Fourth, the risks were understood from the beginning.
Finnish sources say criticism and possible Russian propaganda exploitation were anticipated. One source described the initiative as values-based realism, which sometimes requires accepting political risks and their consequences.
This was a calculated decision, not an improvised attempt to normalise relations with Moscow.
Zelenskyy has also reminded critics that Putin's diplomatic isolation effectively ended with Trump's Alaska summit in 2025. Other European governments have maintained contacts with Russia, sometimes without comparable transparency towards Ukraine.
Ukraine requested diplomatic assistance, and Finland and Norway responded in coordination with Kyiv and Washington.
Supporting Ukraine for as long as necessary must also mean supporting it in the ways Ukraine actually asks for. That includes diplomacy.
Europe needs military strength, economic pressure and diplomatic influence. These are complementary instruments, not competing alternatives. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
One more amazing thing about Brazil and Lula's campaign:
The NYT today has a gushing profile of a Congressman named @AndreJanonesMG, who became the face of Lula's campaign, its chief communication strategist. and -- as a result of admittedly innovative though extremely creepy digital strategies -- the greatest hero of the Brazilian left. But listen to what the article doesn't mention:
Just 2 years ago -- not 20 years ago or 10 years ago, but 2 years ago -- Janones got caught committing one of the most despicable crimes imaginable: he forced his Congressional staff employees to transfer a portion of their (quite low) monthly public salary to him as a condition for keeping their jobs. The money he stole from his workers didn't go to his campaign: it just went to enrich himself, into his pocket,.
He got caught when the employees secretly taped him angrily telling them they should stop complaining. When all this emerged, the left-wing members of Congress loyal to Lula -- who, remember, claims to lead a movement of workers! The name of Lula's party is the Workers Party -- protected him from all consequences from stealing the salary of his workers.
The pro-Lula judiciary let Janones confess guilt and simply pay back the money that he stole. And yet this doesn't bother anyone on the Brazilian left. Janones has become a beloved figure overnight among left-wing celebrities and is now one of Lula's closest allies. The NYT profile doesn't even mention this in their gushing profile.
In the scheme of Brazil's authoritarianism, it's not the biggest issue, but to me it's one of the most revealing about what frauds these people are: -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Online misogyny causes sexual violence, say governments. But the science doesn't support such claims. Now, a new investigation reveals that mining titan Twiggy Forrest, who receives millions in subsidies, spent millions to pass censorship legislation. x.com/i/article/2115822488110387200
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Online misogyny causes sexual violence, say governments. But the science doesn't support such claims. Now, a new investigation reveals that mining titan Twiggy Forrest, who receives millions in subsidies, spent millions to pass censorship legislation. x.com/i/article/2115822488110387200
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
UATX's CBR Chair of Politics, Censorship, and Free Speech Michael Shellenberger (@shellenberger) on his fight against Australia's radical new censorship legislation.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
When UATX professor Michael Shellenberger (@shellenberger) traveled to Australia to warn against censorship legislation, he never expected his opposition to go viral on social media and then be broadcasted by mainstream media.
Michael is CBR Chair of Politics, Censorship, and Free Speech at UATX, where he teaches journalism and politics.
00:00 — Michael Shellenberger on censorship in Australia
00:33 — Australia's 2024 misinformation bill
01:24 — The "Digital Duty of Care" bill
01:35 — Harm reduction and effective altruism
02:17 — Sam Bankman-Fried and the ends justifying the means
03:02 — Speaking at CPAC Australia
03:29 — Censoring anything that "may cause serious harm"
04:27 — A frustrating meeting with staffers
04:53 — Government sock puppets
06:05 — The iPhone video that went viral
07:09 — How a viral video moved the mainstream media
08:24 — Front page of The Australian
08:40 — A tragic attack and new calls for censorship
09:40 — Does media violence cause real violence?
11:04 — John Hinckley Jr. and Taxi Driver
12:33 — What really motivates censorship
13:31 — The Left's War on Reality
14:01 — UATX's free speech mission
14:32 — A University of Austin for Australia?
15:11 — Higher education's unfinished reform
16:08 — Why Australia matters
16:37 — The Censorship Industrial Complex
17:53 — Bringing the lessons back to the classroom
Recorded: October 23, 2026 at UATX.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Yanis Varoufakis
@yanisvaroufakis
I am going to write something below that should be seen as the musings of one who celebrated – and still celebrates – Lula’s victory over Bolsonaro Jr. Here it goes:
I cannot for the life of me justify why o why Brazil’s courts had to demand of Bolsonaro that he hands over his passport the moment he lost the election. That he disputed the veracity of the election result is a sign of a faulty character, evidence that he is a bad loser. BUT, he had every right to being a bad loser; to dispute, rightly or wrongly, any result.
As for the argument that he was being investigated for other misdemeanours or crimes, that doesn’t wash either: What would have happened if Bolsonaro had won the election? Would the judges also prevent him from travelling abroad, as President-elect? I very much doubt that – which means that the judges were conflating executive and judicial powers.
To those who tell me that the Bolsonaro clan is a fascistic, criminal family, my reply is: You and I may very well think that. Alas, the judiciary has no right to use its powers to indict and to pursue someone because – or immediately after – they lost an election. It is shameful, to be precise. And it is also dangerous for those of us on the left who know what it means to be banned and hounded by rogue judges and police commissioners.
But I also have a message to Bolsonaro supporters, or those sitting on the fence, who assume that Lula is somehow behind the judges. He is not! This is the same court that imprisoned, falsely, Lula himself. What we have in Brazil is a judiciary that overreaches and habitually crosses the line that ought to separate judicial from political power.
It is such a shame that a judge took it upon himself to go after Bolsonaro on the eve of his defeat and, in doing so, to sully Lula’s stupendous victory.
One last point that my comrades in Brazil should note: If Bolsonaro and Rubio wanted to mount a campaign against Lula and Brazilian democracy they could never have been aided better than by that judge’s reckless writ.
Yanis Varoufakis
@yanisvaroufakis
WHAT LULA’S RE-ELECTION TELLS US: The Class War Need Not End in Fascism
On Sunday, Brazilians did something that the commentariat had told us was a lost cause. On the eve of his eighty-first birthday, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, a former metalworker, turned the Trumpist, evangelical, neofascist, Zionist tide in Latin America to get re-elected President of Brazil.
Three weeks earlier, he had come second in the first round, behind Flávio Bolsonaro, son and political heir of the man who trumpeted the merits of fascism, who had embraced Trump as his lord and master, who plotted a cynical coup against Brazilian democracy – moreover, the main candidates that were eliminated were rightists whose voters were meant to move to Bolsonaro. Yesterday, Lula overturned this deficit and won with a margin of nearly four and a half million votes.
I want to use Lula’s victory to tell a broader story. A story about a war, the class war that the few are waging against the many across the Western world. And a story about how that war need not end, as so many now fear, in a neofascist revival.
THE HIDDEN CLASS WAR
“There’s class warfare, all right,” Warren Buffett once said, “but it’s my class, the rich class, that’s making war, and we’re winning.” Mr Buffett was not exaggerating. For almost four decades, Western governments and central banks have pulled every policy lever in the same direction: to make the assets of the few burgeon at the expense of the incomes of the many.
Consider the numbers. Between 1952 and 1988, economic growth explained nearly all the gains of the West’s stock market. From 1989 onwards, growth explains only about a quarter. The largest share, around 40 per cent, came from income diverted from workers to shareholders. Another third came from cheaper money and lower perceived risk. That is not wealth creation. It is wealth extraction: a transfer from those who work to those who own, inflated by cheap money and paraded on the evening news as “a strong economy”.
Then look at the rescues. 2001, 2008, 2020, the British gilt crisis of 2022, Silicon Valley Bank in 2023: each time, the state rushed in to save the asset holders. Together they reveal the rule: to save the economy, you must save the wealth of those who own it – not those who produce stuff, not even productive companies. In the United States, the top tenth own almost 90 per cent of all shares. The Fed and the US federal government insure it for them, doing ‘whatever it takes’ to prop them up whenever their prices tank. The rest of us in the West pay the premium, in the form of the austerity that always follows the bailout.
And the owners need never sell. Why do billionaires pay so little tax? Because they do not earn incomes - they accumulate capital gains, taxed only when sold. So they borrow against their soaring assets at 1 or 2 per cent and live on the loan. Then they die and pay no tax on their capital gains, passing on the loot to their kids at ridiculously low inheritance taxes. Meanwhile, to pay bills and put food on the table, the worker borrows on a credit card at 20 per cent, her debts the mirror image of their fortunes.
Then, a large chunk of these accumulating assets seek even higher rents in places like Brazil where the US government intervenes to ensure that the local governments will also place the defence of these assets’ values above all else.
CAPITAL IS NOT A THING, NOT MERELY AN ASSET
Why does austerity keep returning, even though it is economically self-defeating? Marx tells the story of Thomas Peel, who in 1829 sailed to Western Australia’s Swan River with £50,000 of provisions and three hundred working-class men, women and children. On arrival, his workers walked off into the bush and worked for themselves. Peel had brought money, tools and labour, but he could not bring capitalism along, because his workers had an alternative.
Capital, Marx concluded, is not a thing but a social relation: the power of those who own to get those who don’t own to do things they’d rather did not do. Austerity is not an economic policy. It is a disciplinary device, keeping the many sufficiently insecure and indebted to accept whatever is on offer. The ruling class’s deepest fear is not inflation or debt. It is to end up like Peel: rich, but without the power to compel.
IS FASCISM INEVITABLE?
Here is the part of the story that keeps so many of us awake at night. When centre-left politicians, from Bill Clinton, Barack Obama and Tony Blair to Gerhard Schröder, Francois Hollande and Andy Burnham abandoned the language of class, a void opened up in the working-class heartlands of the West. Into that void stepped a venomous storyteller with a century of experience in filling such voids: the recalcitrant far right, the rebranded fascists. They offer left-behind workers a story of dignity, then redirect their fury away from the owner who shipped their factory abroad or sold their council house to some fund and towards the migrant next door. It does not end the class war. It merely divides one side – the workers – to rule over them. It camouflages it.
From the red suburbs of Paris to south Piraeus, from England’s red wall to Italy’s rust belt in Taranto, from the American rust belt to eastern Germany, the pattern seems relentless. And so, a fatalism has set in: the class war waged from above, we are told, must inevitably end in a neofascist, racist, misogynist revival.
Brazil has just refuted this fatalism. Brazil knows the monster intimately. It lived through four years of Jair Bolsonaro, with his nostalgia for the military dictatorship. On 8 January 2023, his followers stormed the Congress, the Supreme Court and the presidential palace. Brazil’s far right is not a fringe. Unlike Trump’s rag tag storm troopers, they had years of running a dictatorship. It won the first round of this election. They had the White House fully behind them, while the US Democrats, once again demonstrating their irrelevance, stayed mute. And yet, yesterday, they were defeated.
How? Not by hand-wringing about “populism”, nor by a centrist promise to manage the status quo more efficiently. Lula won because he did what the Western centre-left forgot how to do: he spoke the language of class, and backed it with policies that shifted power, however modestly, from the few to the many. His government exempted those earning up to five thousand reals a month from income tax and paid for it with a minimum tax on the very richest. During Brazil’s G20 presidency, it proposed a global minimum tax on billionaires. When Lula tells Brazilian workers that the elites have rigged the game, he points his finger upwards, at the rentier and the speculator, not sideways, at the migrant or the poor.
PIX – AN EXAMPLE OF AN ANTI-OLIGARCHY DIGITAL TOOL
But the most innovative weapon in Brazil’s arsenal is one that few outside Latin America have heard of. It is called Pix.
Every time you tap a card to pay for a coffee, a toll is levied. Visa, Mastercard and the banks take a cut, often 2 or 3 per cent, from every transaction. Multiply this by billions of purchases a day and you grasp one of the most lucrative rent-extraction machines ever devised. These are not profits made in competitive markets but rent extracted by those who own the digital rails on which our economic lives now run. It is part of what I call technofeudalism.
Unlike Britain, Europe or, of course, America, Brazil’s central bank moved to limit this rabid exploitation. It launched an alternative: a public, instant payment system, free for individuals and with capped fees for merchants. A Brazilian pays a street vendor in Salvador or sends money to her mother in Recife, instantly, using Pix from her phone, with no card company or bank taking its slice. Brazilians took to it with astonishing enthusiasm. Last year, Pix processed almost 80 billion transactions and overtook credit cards as the most popular way to pay online.
Pix is, in effect, the Swan River of the digital age. It gave tens of millions of Brazilians, including the poorest, who had never had a bank card, an alternative to the toll booths of Big Finance. And, like Peel, the toll collectors did not take it lying down. This summer, Washington imposed 25 per cent tariffs on most Brazilian exports, and its trade representative explicitly named Pix as a grievance, complaining that it “unfairly disadvantaged” American payment companies! The most powerful government on Earth deployed its trade arsenal against a free public service for being too successful at denying rents to Visa and Mastercard.
Lula did not blink. He defended Pix as a Brazilian public good, and Brazilians rewarded him for it. Here, at last, is a concrete example of limiting the power of Big Business, Big Finance and Big Tech: not with slogans, but by building public digital infrastructure that removes the opportunity to extract rent in the first place.
NOT A REVOLUTION, BUT AN AUSPICIOUS PORTENT
Let me not romanticise. Lula is no revolutionary. His margin was narrow. Brazil’s Congress remains in the grip of agribusiness and evangelical blocs. Its central bank still keeps interest rates punishingly high, a weapon of the class war if ever there was one. Lula himself has compromised much too much with these vested interests, and lost support as a result.
But Brazil has shown three things the rest of us must learn. First, the class war waged against the many does not have to end in fascism. Fascism wins only when the left vacates the battlefield of class. Second, a progressive government can win by pointing upwards, at those who extract rent, rather than downwards, at those who suffer. And third, Big Business can be defeated, at least forced to lose some battles, by building public alternatives to its rent-extracting machines.
So, here is the challenge to Britain, to Europe, to the people of the United States.
-Build your own Pix: public payment rails that end the tolls of Visa and Mastercard.
-Tax capital gains, ill-gotten wealth that is, not just income.
-Make every rescue conditional, with the public receiving real, permanent equity in return.
-Create a public investment bank as an alternative to the bond markets. Restore the bargaining power of the workforce. And give working people what Peel’s workers found at Swan River: an alternative, and the freedom to say no.
Buffett was right. There is a class war, and his class has been winning hands down. But yesterday, in Brazil, it lost a battle though not the war. It lost because a working-class president dared to name the war and fight it using weapons fashioned to defend the many.
unherd.com/2026/10/why-lula-won/ -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
News24 Australia
@News24Aust
Free speech experts have warned Australia is becoming an increasingly undemocratic society, amid concerns the Albanese government's online safety push will restrict speech under the guise of protecting the public.
www.news24.com.au/politics/australian-politics/increasing… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
Brazil's Federal Police issues a statement that Flavio Bolsonaro is not considered a "fugitive" from justice because he has not been charged with any crimes and there was no order issued for his arrest when he left Brazil for the US.
Part of the motive here is to explain away the embarrassment that Brazilian authorities had no idea what was going on in their country all day, but it is also true that -- contrary to many prevailing media and political narratives in the US -- Flavio has not been charged with (let alone convicted of) crimes and no arrest order had yet been issued when he left.
Sam Pancher
@SamPancher
Nota da PF diz que não há registro de saída de Flávio Bolsonaro do país e que senador não é considerado foragido, nem poderia ser preso ou vigiado permanentemente.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Leandro Ruschel 🇧🇷🇺🇸🇮🇹🇩🇪
@leandroruschel
This is, by far, the best account of how Brazil is accelerating toward a full-blown socialist dictatorship, now that the opposition’s presidential candidate has been forced into exile.
Seven minutes after the electoral court confirmed Flávio Bolsonaro’s defeat, the Federal Police asked to seize his passports. Moraes approved it that same night, without consulting the Prosecutor General. There is no charge and no conviction. Nothing published shows Flávio owned, received or laundered anything.
Now compare with Lula. He was convicted twice for corruption, spent 580 days in prison and was freed on a jurisdictional technicality. No court ever found the evidence to be false.
Before the runoff, the electoral court censored and fined Flávio for linking Lula to the PCC. Meanwhile, the accountant who prepared Lula’s tax returns is under investigation for laundering money for that same cartel.
And Moraes? His wife’s law firm had a 131 million reais contract with Banco Master, the bank behind the largest financial fraud in Brazil’s history. The documents’ metadata show edits made under the user name “Minister Alexandre de Moraes.” The Senate is sitting on 55 impeachment requests against him.
In his victory speech, Lula promised to “regulate” digital platforms. He has asked Xi Jinping for help regulating TikTok. His wife pointed to China as a model, where “there is prison” for saying the wrong thing.
Foreign courts already see what’s happening. Italy and Spain have both refused Brazilian extradition requests, and Spain cited an “evident political connection and motivation.”
Brazil didn’t need Chávez-style court packing. Its Supreme Court captured itself from the inside, and Lula was the one who benefited.
This is no longer a democracy with problems. It is a regime that holds elections. 👇👇👇
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Seven minutes after the election results came in, federal police, dispatched by Supreme Court Justice Moraes, moved to seize Bolsonaro's passport. Shame on global leaders and the media for defending Lula and Moraes turning Brazil into a banana Republic. x.com/i/article/2115479142065938433
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Sergio Moro
@SF_Moro
O Brasil se tornou um país com refugiados políticos no exterior.
Itália, Espanha e Estados Unidos, todos denegaram o atendimento a pedidos de extradição enviados pelo Governo Lula.
Com Flávio Bolsonaro não será diferente.
Isso deveria acender o sinal vermelho para o país e sua cúpula judicial. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
CRUCIAL FACTS ON THE FLAVIO BOLSONARO MATTER:
It's not just Flavio Bolsonaro who fled Brazil to escape the tyrannical persecution of Alexandre de Moraes and the pro-Lula wing of the Supreme Court. There are dozens of Brazilian exiles who have done the same: dissident journalists, activists, bloggers, and politicians who all fled to avoid certain prison for political opposition.
In most of these cases, Moraes has demanded the extradition of those who fled and whom he wants to imprison back in Brazil. But Moraes' extradition requests have been repeatedly denied by multiple countries and institutions on the grounds that these prosecutions are politically motivated or otherwise corrupted. Among those concluing this: Spain, Italy, INTERPOL, and even the US under Biden.
Just today, Italy refused Brazil's demand to extradite a person named @edutagli, who was once a top aide to Moraes, but then fled to Italy after Moraes accused him of having been my source in a huge leak from Moraes' office that I obtained for reporting I did with @Folha in 2024. That massive leak enabled us to publish roughly 20 articles proving systemic abuses of power by Moraes against his political enemies: exactly the reason so many Brazilians, including Bolsonaro, know they can't get a fair trial in Brazil.
Italy today refused to extradite the person accused of being our source on the grounds that the proceedings would be a farce because Moraes — as he so often does — wants to act as the supposed victim, investigator, and judge, and thus his demand falls well outside of Italy's extradition standards. Again, multiple countries have concluded the same, showing what a farce Brazil's once-respected judicial system has become under the Lula/Moraes regime.
Moraes has overseen a system of political persecution masquerading as criminal justice that has been recognized as a sham by multiple countries that are not exactly Bolsonaro allies. Nobody in their right mind who is a political enemy of Moraes would remain in Brazil once if it is clear that he intends to imprison you, since he has proven that guilt is a foregone conclusion and he operates with no legal or constitutional limits of any kind.
That is why asylum under international law exists: to protect those who cannot obtain justice in their own country because the justice system has been corrupted and commandeered for political persecution. Many people, such as Julian Assange, have needed that protection (which Lula cheered). Now people need it from Moraes in Brazil. That is sadly one of the main legacies of both Lula and Moraes over the last six years.
Folha de S.Paulo
@folha
Itália nega extradição de Eduardo Tagliaferro, ex-assessor de Alexandre de Moraes
www1.folha.uol.com.br/poder/2026/10/italia-nega-extradica… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
That the Lula-Moraes government sought to seize Bolsonaro’s passport 7 minutes after election results were announced is literally all the proof you need that it’s a political persecution. Honest liberals have to acknowledge this or lose all credibility
ian bremmer
@ianbremmer
brazil supreme court decision to seize flavio bolsonaro’s passports immediately after the election looks like political retribution to most brazilians (and to me).
rule of law not what it should be here. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
ian bremmer
@ianbremmer
brazil supreme court decision to seize flavio bolsonaro’s passports immediately after the election looks like political retribution to most brazilians (and to me).
rule of law not what it should be here. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is just straight-up misinformation by @FT and @guardian
@FlavioBolsonaro fled to the US because, 7 minutes after the election results came in, the Federal Police, under Moraes's order, moved to confiscate his passport. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Shame on you @vonderleyen @AlexanderSoros @andyburnham @bundeskanzler @EmmanuelMacron for endorsing the Lula-Moraes repression of their political enemies and Brazil's further descent into tyranny.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Seven minutes after the election results came in, federal police, dispatched by Supreme Court Justice Moraes, moved to seize Bolsonaro's passport. Shame on global leaders and the media for defending Lula and Moraes turning Brazil into a banana Republic. x.com/i/article/2115479142065938433
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Shame on you @vonderleyen @AlexanderSoros @andyburnham @bundeskanzler @EmmanuelMacron for endorsing the Lula-Moraes repression of their political enemies and Brazil's further descent into tyranny.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is just straight-up misinformation by @FT and @guardian
@FlavioBolsonaro fled to the US because, 7 minutes after the election results came in, the Federal Police, under Moraes's order, moved to confiscate his passport. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Bia Kicis
@Biakicis
A cada dia que @FlavioBolsonaro ficar fora do Brasil, exilado político e @jairbolsonaro (que se recusou a sair do Brasil) permanecer preso por perseguição política, o mundo enxergará o Brasil como uma republiqueta onde direitos humanos são violados e onde a oposição é perseguida e condenada por não se curvar ao regime.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
War Correspondent
@warDaniel47
If you only have 3 minutes to watch Joe Rogan’s podcast today, this is the 3 minutes you need to see.
Jordan Peterson just described “gender-affirming care” in a way no one else would dare.
“I've never seen anything worse than what's happening right now. And that includes the sorts of things that were done in the camps in Germany. At least the goddamn Naz*s admitted what they did was wrong. They tried to hide it. We trumpet it as a moral virtue.”
“These surgical procedures are so brutal and so experimental that they're—I'm going to say it again—they're worse than what the Mengele types did in the concentration camps in the thirties and forties. And that's a pretty goddamn low bar.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
That's just inaccurate. In fact, the bill has only gotten worse:
— The sock puppet craziness is still in there. That means the censors at eSafety can run unlimited fake accounts and override social media platforms’ terms of service. It can do this with immunity from any civil lawsuit for things “done in good faith” lol. It does not require that it tell either users or platforms what it’s doing.
— The government added section 28A. That lets the eSafety Commissioner order any online service in Australia, from ISPs to app stores to AI chatbots, to give anyone she deems qualified “access to the service required” to inspect internal systems and “decision-making algorithms.” Creepy af
— The amendment some are weirdly claiming is a “retreat” in fact obliges every general service to keep lawful adult content from under-18s. Here’s the rub: no service can do that without checking everyone’s age. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
University of Austin (UATX)
@uaustinorg
Tomorrow we're releasing a full UATX course for free: all 19 lectures of Professor Isabella Reinhardt's Rise and Fall of Ancient Rome, filmed in class with our students.
It runs from Rome's mythical founding to the Third Century Crisis. It ends on a question the class spent a whole session arguing about: did Rome ever really fall?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Portland Moderate.
@pdxmoderate
Portland’s Royal Sonesta: bought for $108.3M in 2016. Now reportedly sold for $6.83M for 220 rooms—just $31,000 per key. A staggering 93.7% price collapse.
This is what happens when government fails at public safety, downtown disorder spirals, Measure 110’s consequences go unaddressed, and Multnomah County’s mental-health system fails people in crisis.
Tourism doesn’t thrive where visitors feel unsafe and downtown businesses struggle to survive.
Portland didn’t get here by accident. Policy choices have consequences—and taxpayers, workers, businesses, and property owners are paying the price.
@mitch4portland
@pnwpolicyangel
@TeacherTiff4PDX
@kanalforpdx
@MayorKWilson -
Hope Over Fear
@hopeoverfear01
“Proper Britain here we come”
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Yes, convincing people they won’t have fish and chips if they keep raising concerns about rape gangs makes a ton of sense
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Justine Bateman
@JustineBateman
Perhaps the reason so many people are holding on to political “activist” identities is that they are afraid to go back to just being them. Just a plain person. @ClubRandom_ @billmaher
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
From borders & trans to Covid & climate, the Left said it knew best but got it horribly wrong. Instead of taking responsibility, it demonizes & silences. The Left’s War On Reality by Alex Gutentag (@galexybrane) and me reveals a road to hell paved with bad intentions. www.amazon.com/dp/0063421577
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Please go to Amazon now to pre-order your copy of our book. And be sure to check out the early reviews.
@galexybrane
www.amazon.com/dp/0063421577
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Please pre-order today!
www.amazon.com/dp/0063421577 -
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
If you enjoyed San Fransicko, please consider pre-ordering The Left's War on Reality by @galexybrane and me. It includes six brand-new chapters on addiction and homelessness:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
From borders & trans to Covid & climate, the Left said it knew best but got it horribly wrong. Instead of taking responsibility, it demonizes & silences. The Left’s War On Reality by Alex Gutentag (@galexybrane) and me reveals a road to hell paved with bad intentions. www.amazon.com/dp/0063421577
-
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
If you enjoyed Apocalypse Never, please consider pre-ordering The Left's War on Reality by @galexybrane and me. It includes six brand-new chapters on climate hysteria:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
From borders & trans to Covid & climate, the Left said it knew best but got it horribly wrong. Instead of taking responsibility, it demonizes & silences. The Left’s War On Reality by Alex Gutentag (@galexybrane) and me reveals a road to hell paved with bad intentions. www.amazon.com/dp/0063421577
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
noelle lenoir
@noellelenoir
La tuerie de @villedetrappes, drame humain, fait l’objet de #fakenews en rafales dans les medias bien-pensants après les déclarations de #macron. Car pour justifier les #manifs, il faut que ce soit un crime #islamophobe (d’un propalestinien qui a tué un #chretien) Faut suivre!
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Natalie Winters
@nataliegwinters
A former CIA officer coauthored a report urging social media companies to reduce your account’s reach based on your connections to OTHER accounts.
Yaël Eisenstat, who also ran Facebook’s elections integrity operations for political ads, coauthored the June 2026 report recommending:
“Penalizing the distribution of accounts connected to users or pages which repeatedly share violative or borderline content”
The next line specifically singles out election and civic content.
The proposed penalty extends to connected accounts—without specifying that those accounts must themselves have broken a rule.
Who helped develop this blueprint?
UNC professor Daniel Kreiss and former Maricopa County Recorder Stephen Richer are listed as contributors.
There’s also a recommendation to slow posts spreading beyond an account’s network until they can be reviewed.
Ahead of the 2026 midterms: throttle viral posts, penalize connected accounts, and extend enforcement to content platforms consider “borderline.” -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Online rhetoric & imagery cause real-world violence, say officials. But no good evidence supports their claims. For 140 years, censors have tried and failed to link media to violence. Behind the false claims lie arrogance, ideological intolerance, and a panic over populism.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Over the last decade, politicians, NGOs, and journalists across the West have blamed online speech for real-world political violence.
In Australia recently, politicians and others blamed social media for an attack on a left-wing member of parliament, Helen Haines, who was run over by a man in his car.
“We’ve got these big US social media companies and their business model, to me, seems pretty incompatible,” said Senator David Pocock after the attack. “That’s something we’ve got to look very hard at as a country and as elected representatives.”
Said Bill Shorten, a former Labor leader who now runs the University of Canberra, “I think that some people, through the algorithms of the big tech bros and social media, have been radicalized online.”
Mike Burgess, director-general of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO), Australia’s FBI, decried a “permissive environment of violence.” And Commissioner of the Australian Federal Police Krissy Barrett said the things politicians said online “does have a direct correlation to what we see in terms of threats and abuse.”
But it was clear within hours that the alleged attacker of the Australian MP was intoxicated and likely mentally ill, and within days it was revealed that he and his family had been friends with her for years.
A source close to the investigation said he “was known to police” and that “It is understood he has undergone a mental health assessment.” People online quickly discovered that the alleged attacker had posted regularly about climate change and Gaza and that the head of the Australian Green Party followed him on X.
As such, he attacked the member of Parliament closest to his apparent views, which challenges the notion that his politics motivated him. As for Barrett, she declined to give a single example of things people said online resulting in real-world violence.
Meanwhile, correlation is not causation. Killers may have consumed violent media, but so too did practically everyone else in society. It would make sense that would-be killers, who often fantasize about their violence before doing it, would consume more violent content. And so if there is a relationship, it could show the opposite causal direction.
Moreover, relying on the testimony of killers, many of whom suffer from personality disorders or mental illness, is irrational. The man who shot Ronald Reagan said he did so out of an obsession with Jodie Foster in Martin Scorsese’s “Taxi Driver.” Nobody proposed censoring “Taxi Driver,” Scorsese movies, or Foster, and yet politicians and bureaucrats around the world proposed mass online censorship because the Buffalo shooter said he was inspired by Christchurch....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2114463256098275519
Please subscribe now to support our defense of free speech, fund our award-winning investigative journalism, and read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Financial Times
@FT
The right’s obsession with ‘civil war’ in Britain ft.trib.al/kwETokK
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
yeah such a crazy obsession
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Islamo-Leftism Is Not a Conspiracy Theory
It’s an unrequited love affair
“The Red-Green alliance does not rest on covert coordination behind the scenes, but on ideological kinship, a shared enemy (Western civilization, modernity and capitalism) and a hefty dose of naivety on one side.”
“The bargain is straightforward: leftists coddle Muslims and give them preferential treatment, while Muslims respond by voting for left-wing parties.”
“What makes this love affair tragic is that it is mostly unrequited.”
“There may be ‘Queers for Palestine’, but there are no ‘Queers in Palestine’.” -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Just in: France's Prime Minister asked telecom companies to prepare to block social media platforms. "I wish to have the ability to temporarily suspend access to these services in case of a repeat of urban violence," he wrote. @blast news broke the story.
BLAST, Le souffle de l'info
@blast_france
Information exclusive Blast : le Premier ministre a préparé la coupure des réseaux sociaux pour le 24 octobre
Deux jours avant la manifestation du 24 octobre, le Premier ministre Sébastien Lecornu a demandé à Orange, SFR, Free et Bouygues Telecom de se tenir prêts à couper l’accès à TikTok, Instagram ,Snapchat et X. Blast révèle la lettre et le compte rendu de la réunion qui a suivi, où les opérateurs ont exprimé leurs doutes. Le gouvernement avait déjà utilisée cette mesure liberticide en Nouvelle-Calédonie en 2024, avant d’être désavoué par le Conseil d’État.
Par @yanmdi.
www.blast-info.fr/articles/2026/information-exclusive-bla…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Full text in English and translated letter attached
Madam, Sir,
The urban riots that occurred in several French cities during the day of mobilization on October 17, 2026, and that continued on Sunday, October 18, revealed the convergence of several protest and grievance movements, stoked by violent and particularly determined elements. Other individuals took advantage of the resulting disorder to smash, vandalize, set fires, ransack, and loot.
It is evident that several social networks played a decisive role not only in the crystallization and viral spread of unlawful slogans (“mots d’ordre illicites”) but also as levers for the operational coordination of violence during the demonstrations (organization of looting, exchanges about targets, movement of groups, or positions of the security forces).
In the event that such events were to recur, I wish to have the ability to temporarily suspend access to these services in case of a repeat of urban violence. This would mean temporarily blocking access to the applications Snapchat, TikTok, and Instagram by filtering their domain names (DNS), while preserving, as far as possible, fixed-line Internet access to these applications and, in any case, access to other Internet sites and services on both fixed and mobile networks.
In order to prepare such a measure, which could be decided on the weekend of October 24 and 25 depending on the operational context, I ask you to anticipate as of today the technical operations necessary to implement it. The point is to put you in a position, if I give the instruction, to proceed without delay with the temporary suspension of the services concerned, for a duration of a few hours.
I would like you to inform me of the technical conditions under which you could implement such a suspension. It is indeed necessary to carry out a suspension that is as targeted as possible, without introducing distortion between operators.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A few brave French people like @noellelenoir are speaking out against a government that cares more about censoring its citizens than preventing riots
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Whatever happens with the current riots, the @EmmanuelMacron government is in free fall, says former Supreme Court justice @noellelenoir. "We have no government," she says. "Macron is disconnected, afraid, & doesn't know what to do.... Without X, we would not have a democracy."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Apparently the real concern is that people can see these videos
Andy Ngo
@MrAndyNgo
Paris (Oct. 24) — Far-left rioters and Antifa are continuing to carry out violence on the streets in their ongoing insurrection against the state and French people.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Whatever happens with the current riots, the @EmmanuelMacron government is in free fall, says former Supreme Court justice @noellelenoir. "We have no government," she says. "Macron is disconnected, afraid, & doesn't know what to do.... Without X, we would not have a democracy."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Unrest continues in France. Seeking context, I spoke with one of that nation’s most insightful observers, Noëlle Lenoir, a respected former French Supreme Court Justice. — MS
Michael: Tell us what is happening, Noëlle.
Noëlle: We no longer have a government. [President Emmanuel] Macron is totally disconnected and, in my view, afraid. He is afraid because he wants to remain in office until the very end. He wants another life, and he has already said he wants to come back in five years and run again, which is not forbidden. He does not know what to do.
He spoke twice, and both times it was a disaster. The first time was when these riots began, with so-called young people from the schools and universities. In fact, they were militants of the far left, and also immigrants. As you may know, official statistics show that 34% of immigrants come to France to study at university. Then 25% come to join their families, which is called family reunification (le regroupement familial). Then around 15% are supposed to come to work. So you can imagine that there is an overrepresentation of young people who are supposed to be at university but do nothing. They are there because they want to leave their country.
Macron spoke at the very beginning, not on October 17 but two or three days before, when the riots started with young students, Palestine militants, and Palestinian flags. He asked the police to show empathy with the demonstrators. For the police who were beaten and attacked, with around one thousand of them wounded, the fact that he asked them to show sympathy with these young people, some of whom are not young at all, was felt by all the security forces in France as an insult. I don’t think anyone still supports Macron and the government.
What is amazing is that he said nothing. He just said, “I want the judges to be very tough.” But as you know, in France a large part of the judiciary is very politicized on the far left. They are organized in trade unions. One of the main judges’ unions, the Magistrates’ Union (Le Syndicat de la Magistrature), published a guide years ago, revised and republished in 2024, in which they explain to demonstrators how to escape from the police and how to make it harder for the police to prevent them from stealing, looting, and rioting. It is absolutely amazing.
So when Macron says, “I want the judges to be very tough and to inflict very severe sanctions on the rioters, the looters, all those who attacked the police,” it is null and void, because he has never said anything against this union, and neither has the hierarchy of the judiciary itself. In my view, this union is a political party. They are militants, and they hould not exist....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2114051106644910391
Please subscribe now to read and listen to the full interviewThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
And there you have it: the French government told telecom companies two days ago to prepare for it to shut down access to social media platforms
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Just in: France's Prime Minister asked telecom companies to prepare to block social media platforms. "I wish to have the ability to temporarily suspend access to these services in case of a repeat of urban violence," he wrote. @blast news broke the story.
BLAST, Le souffle de l'info
@blast_france
Information exclusive Blast : le Premier ministre a préparé la coupure des réseaux sociaux pour le 24 octobre
Deux jours avant la manifestation du 24 octobre, le Premier ministre Sébastien Lecornu a demandé à Orange, SFR, Free et Bouygues Telecom de se tenir prêts à couper l’accès à TikTok, Instagram ,Snapchat et X. Blast révèle la lettre et le compte rendu de la réunion qui a suivi, où les opérateurs ont exprimé leurs doutes. Le gouvernement avait déjà utilisée cette mesure liberticide en Nouvelle-Calédonie en 2024, avant d’être désavoué par le Conseil d’État.
Par @yanmdi.
www.blast-info.fr/articles/2026/information-exclusive-bla… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
David Ágape
@david_agape_
Quem está sustentando Lulinha na Espanha?
Flávio Bolsonaro (@FlavioBolsonaro) fez essa pergunta no debate de ontem, ao afirmar que o filho de Lula é vizinho do Vini Jr em Madri.
Nossa investigação encontrou uma pista sobre a receita de sua empresa: em 2026, a LLF Tech emitiu R$ 686 mil em notas para uma produtora cujo site está no nome de Kalil Bittar. Nenhuma das notas identifica o trabalho entregue.
Kalil Bittar é amigo de infância de Lulinha. Além de ter sido sócio dele na Gamecorp, já foi investigado junto com o “Ronaldinho dos negócios” em apurações anteriores. O Shalderes @andreshalders revelou no Metrópoles que, entre 2024 e 2025, Kalil recebeu R$ 750 mil da conta pessoal de Lulinha.
As conexões alcançam o neto do presidente, Thiago, que declarou ter desenvolvido um aplicativo pela empresa de Kalil, e a mãe dele, Carla Ariane Trindade, investigada ao lado do empresário pela PF em um esquema de kits de robótica superfaturados.
Agora, as notas colocam a empresa de Lulinha diante de uma nova pergunta: pelo que, exatamente, a Academy Tech foi cobrada?
Leia a reportagem em A Investigação:
www.ainvestigacao.com/p/exclusivo-empresa-de-lulinha-cobra -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
John Greenewald, Jr.
@theblackvault
This is an blatant unfair summation. As I continue to prove many times over, information (including videos) are still withheld due to national security.
If it was all in the LIZ, it would nearly entirely be released. It isn’t. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You know, take the week. Or the month. Scratch that. How about never going on social media again? While you’re at it you could stop trying to censor it. Doing both might help your mental health. I genuinely mean that
Anthony Albanese
@AlboMP
Tomorrow, I’ll be unplugged from my social media channels.
I’m doing it for Mac Holdsworth.
For every Australian child who’s encountered online harm.
And for the parents who deserve a safer digital world for their kids.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The obsession by politicians to censor social media is seriously pathological. They don’t like the mean things people say about them and they long for the days when they could just call the owner of the newspaper and kill or water down a negative story about themselves
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The end result is an inversion of the long-term trend in the West of reducing and restricting the power of the state in order to increase personal freedom. Censorship is always about increasing the power of the state at the expense of the individual and the citizen.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Naturally this pathological demand for control comes from the same people who want to control every aspect of society including the sex and gender of children, food, medicines, housing, transport, medical care, etc. Censorship is just one manifestation of the elites’ deep rot
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
DOW Rapid Response
@DOWResponse
FBI-UAP-D043, FD-302, Unidentified Aerial Object Observation Report, 2026:
This FBI document records a 2026 interview with two federal agents who reported seeing a black triangle UAP at a national security site.
www.war.gov/UFO/?releaseDate=Release+07&release=07&agency… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Lula está ligado ao cartel de drogas PCC que os EUA classificaram como "Organização Terrorista Estrangeira." Contudo, o TSE impediu @FlavioBolsonaro de afirmar isso. A censura sobre a ligação entre Lula e o PCC teve início sob Alexandre de Moraes.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Em 8 de outubro, o Tribunal Superior Eleitoral (TSE) ordenou que o senador Flávio Bolsonaro, candidato a presidente que enfrenta o presidente Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva no segundo turno deste domingo, apagasse publicações em redes sociais que ligavam Lula ao Primeiro Comando da Capital (PCC), facção que o governo dos Estados Unidos classifica como “Organização Terrorista Estrangeira”.
Mas Lula tem ligação com figuras do PCC por meio de seu contador, João Muniz Leite, que fez as declarações de imposto de renda do presidente, cuidou por 14 anos da contabilidade de Roberto Teixeira, advogado de longa data de Lula, cuida da contabilidade de Fábio Luís, filho de Lula, e que, segundo o Ministério Público de São Paulo, ajudou a facção a lavar dinheiro. O escritório de Muniz Leite fica no mesmo prédio onde funcionavam empresas do filho de Lula.
Dividir um contador com figuras do PCC não significa que o PCC controle Lula, que protestou com veemência contra a decisão do governo americano de classificar o PCC como “organização terrorista”.
Mas o tribunal foi longe demais ao afirmar que não havia base factual ligando Lula ao PCC. Até a CNN Brasil, que críticos de Lula consideram simpática a ele, republicouuma reportagem do Estadão com o título “Contador ligado a Lula é suspeito de lavar R$ 16 milhões em loteria com PCC”.
Além disso, o Ministério Público de São Paulo denunciou neste mês Senival Moura, vereador paulistano do Partido dos Trabalhadores (PT), e outras 20 pessoas por lavagem de dinheiro do PCC por meio da Transunião, empresa de ônibus de São Paulo, segundo reportagem do BNews São Paulo de 2 de outubro. Os promotores o chamaram de “peça central” da empresa; o Metrópoles, ao noticiar sua prisão em junho, o descrevera como “um líder oculto” dela. Seu advogado, Márcio Sayeg, disse que ele “jamais integrou organização criminosa, jamais manteve vínculo com o PCC”.
E o nome do PT já havia aparecido antes em casos do PCC. Em 2014, a executiva estadual do PT em São Paulo expulsou o deputado estadual Luiz Moura depois que a polícia o flagrou em uma reunião com suspeitos de integrar a facção. E em 2019, investigadores gravaram, em um grampo, um chefe do PCC dizendo: “O PT tinha diálogo com nois cabuloso, mano”.
O ministro do Supremo Tribunal Federal Alexandre de Moraes, que ordenou a censura em massa de aliados de Bolsonaro e que está implicado em um amplo escândalo de fraude bancária, supervisionou a censura da ligação Lula-PCC em 2022...
Artigo completo aqui
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
O presidente Lula está ligado a um cartel de drogas que os EUA classificaram como "Organização Terrorista Estrangeira"; contudo, o TSE impediu seu rival na disputa presidencial, Flávio Bolsonaro, de afirmar isso. x.com/i/article/2113629914909769728
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
O presidente Lula está ligado a um cartel de drogas que os EUA classificaram como "Organização Terrorista Estrangeira"; contudo, o TSE impediu seu rival na disputa presidencial, Flávio Bolsonaro, de afirmar isso. x.com/i/article/2113629914909769728
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
President @LulaOficial is linked to a drug cartel the U.S. has designated a "Foreign Terrorist Organization," and yet Brazil's election court has prevented his presidential rival, @FlavioBolsonaro from saying so. Censorship of the Lula-PCC link began under Alexandre de Moraes.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
On October 8, Brazil’s Superior Electoral Court (TSE) ordered Senator Flávio Bolsonaro, the presidential candidate who will face off against President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva in the run-off election on Sunday, to delete social posts linking Lula to the Primeiro Comando da Capital (PCC) drug cartel, which the US government considers a “Foreign Terrorist Organization.”
But Lula is linked to PCC figures through his accountant, João Muniz Leite, who prepared the president’s income tax returns, kept the books of Lula’s longtime lawyer Roberto Teixeira for 14 years, keeps those of Lula’s son, Fábio Luís, and who São Paulo prosecutors say helped the cartel launder money. Muniz Leite’s office sits in the same building that housed Lula’s son’s companies.
Sharing an accountant with PCC figures doesn’t mean that the PCC controls Lula, who vigorously objected to the US government labeling the PCC a “terrorist organization.”
But the court went too far in claiming no factual basis linked Lula to the PCC. Even CNN Brasil, which Lula’s critics regard as friendly to him, republished an Estadão article headlined, “Accountant linked to Lula is suspected of laundering R$ 16 million in lottery with PCC.”
Moreover, São Paulo prosecutors this month charged Senival Moura, a city councilman from Lula’s Workers’ Party (PT), and 20 others with laundering PCC money through Transunião, a São Paulo bus company, BNews São Paulo reported on October 2.
Prosecutors called him a “central piece” (“peça central”) of the company; Metrópoles, reporting his June arrest, had described him as “a hidden leader” (“um líder oculto”) of it. His lawyer, Márcio Sayeg, said he “never belonged to a criminal organization and never had ties to the PCC” (“jamais integrou organização criminosa, jamais manteve vínculo com o PCC”).
And the PT’s name had come up in PCC cases before. In 2014, the party’s São Paulo executive expelled state deputy Luiz Moura after police caught him at a meeting with suspected PCC members. And in 2019, investigators used a wiretap to record a PCC boss saying, “The PT had serious dialogue with us, bro” (“O PT tinha diálogo com nois cabuloso, mano”).
Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes, who ordered mass censorship of Bolsonaro allies, and who is implicated in a sweeping banking fraud scandal, oversaw censorship of the Lula-PCC link in 2022....
FULL STORY HERE:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
President Lula is linked to a drug cartel that the U.S. has designated a "Foreign Terrorist Organization," but Brazil's election court has censored Bolsonaro for saying so. x.com/i/article/2113627056663642112
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
President Lula is linked to a drug cartel that the U.S. has designated a "Foreign Terrorist Organization," but Brazil's election court has censored Bolsonaro for saying so. x.com/i/article/2113627056663642112
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
ADVANCE
@FairAusADV
“I’ve never seen anything so extreme, so radical.”
Michael Shellenberger has read Labor’s Big Brother Bill. It only takes four words to censor you: “may cause significant harm”. Anything Labor doesn't like counts.
Stop the Big Brother Bill: advanceaustralia.org.au/stop-big-brother -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Rather than deploy sufficient police and armored vehicles to prevent and stop riots, @EmmanuelMacron is blaming AI for them and his security (interior) minister @NunezLaurent says he may censor social media platforms if they return.
x.com/TrumpFrance/status/2112934569939013854
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
France did its best to prevent the riots, say the media. But it dramatically underestimated the number of protesters and failed to send out enough officers and armored vehicles. Behind all those specific failures was, as in the US, the anti-civilization Left's war on the police.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
BFM
@BFMTV
🔴 EN DIRECT
La préfecture de police de Paris invite les commerçants à recourir à des agents privés avant les prochaines manifestations
l.bfmtv.com/Y3FV
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A state is incapable of providing security for its citizens is by definition a failed state
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Abusive messages? Seriously? Was that her first time on social media?
Her statements lend support the theory that thin-skinned Aus politicians want to censor bc they're tired of being ratio'd, criticized, and ridiculed online. Pathetic!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Q: “Why does the @AlboMP government want an army of bots to unleash on social media platforms?”
A: -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A reportedly drunk & possibly insane man attacked a member of parliament in Australia with his car. And so, naturally, a few vile politicians are exploiting the tragedy to demand mass online censorship. Decades of scientific evidence & common sense demolish their lies. THREAD
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
First, the driver appears to have been drunk and may be insane.
Second, his social media posts suggest he is a leftist.
So any leftist demanding censorship should demand the censorship of climate alarmism and criticisms of Israel.
www.news24.com.au/politics/australian-politics/revealed-h…Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The above information is all you need to know about why censorship is an absolutely ludicrous and depraved response to this real-world tragedy.
Think about it: it was a drunk and possibly crazy leftist who ran over another leftist who was "better" from his point of view on climate and Israel than practically any other MP!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In 1981, a mentally ill man named John Hinckley, Jr. shot President Ronald Reagan.
Why?
Because, Hinckley said, he wanted to impress the actress Jodie Foster, who he had become obsessed with after watching her play Iris in Scorsese's 1976 movie, "Taxi Driver."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
So naturally, the US banned all movies, yes?
No? Just Scorsese's movies? Just Jodi Foster movies.
I mean, seriously?
So Australia should now, what — censor leftists on social media platforms so mentally ill people won't be inspired by their posts and try to murder people? How is that not itself totally insane?
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I am not going to name, yet, the politicians who have already said absolutely idiotic things about the need to censor social media platforms in response to this terrible tragedy. But seriously, WTF is wrong with politicians who see censorship as the solution to mental illness?
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Before even looking at the scientific evidence, think about what's being said.
The claim by the censors is that what causes violence is ideas, words, pictures, etc.
Think of what could be banned: religious texts, comic books, films, video games — and political speech
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
John Morrison wrote this excellent review of the research into whether real-world violence can be blamed on media of various kinds.
Aside from demolishing the censors, it's a fascinating look through history:
environmentalprogress.org/big-news/2024/1/15/little-good-…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Malevolent censorship advocates claim censorship would have stopped genocides. It's nonsense.
"These genocidal regimes are not examples of countries where free speech got out of hand. Instead, they were societies that controlled speech, including counterspeech which may have helped combat their evil ideas."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
What do the courts say about the scientific evidence?
The most important ruling anywhere in the world on violent media was by the US Supreme Court in 2011, when it ruled 7-2 — a majority that included liberals and conservatives — against allowing California to ban violent video games.
Why? Because the high court's review of psychological studies failed to prove any causal link between violent video games and real-world aggression.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
And this central logic doesn't just apply in the US or just to video games.
Think about it: there's violent, hateful, bad media everywhere across the Western world. Streaming. Movies. Stand-up comedy. Podcasters. Social media.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
And the reason those things are out there is that courts have repeatedly ruled that the evidence simply does not support censorship as a solution to reducing real-world violence. Full stop.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Anyone advocating censorship as a way to stop real-world violence is in the grip of pseudoscience and is likely motivated by deeply authoritarian or totalitarian impulses.
Think of how creepy a politician you'd need to be to respond to such a tragedy by wanting censorship.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
And yes, if a politician really wanted to fight "real-world violence," he should propose banning cars!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In particular, @AlboMP should not use this tragedy as an opportunity to demand censorship given this
www.dailymail.com/news/article-16222097/helen-haines-dirt…Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
If they truly believe their nonsense about how censorship will prevent real-world violence, they must censor the Greens' climate alarmism and Albanese's "dirt sheet" about Helen Haines!
Oh, what a tangled web censors like Albo-Shoebridge weave when they deceive!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The only appropriate response now from PM @AlboMP and his jet-setting Censorship Czar @AnikaWells is to withdraw their disgraceful censorship legislation at once, out of respect for the victims of real-world violence.
/END
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
And now it turns out the man charged with attacking MP Haines knew her for 20 years. He was clearly mentally ill.
"Mr Nugent was known to local police after being served an interim intervention order in 2022."
Shame on everyone who used this to justify censorship.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Obvious within hours
The Australian
@australian
Investigators probing the car attack that cost Helen Haines both legs are examining whether her attacker was experiencing a psychotic episode and targeted her over a family connection. Read the full story: www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/helen-haines-attack-polic…
-
The Australian
@australian
Governor-General Sam Mostyn has revealed she woke up on Thursday to several abusive messages on social media following her Wednesday press conference, when she urged Australians to unite behind a new era of decency and civility following the attack on independent MP Helen Haines. Read the article: www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/sam-mostyn-saddened-by-ab…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Abusive messages? Seriously? Was that her first time on social media?
Her statements lend support the theory that thin-skinned Aus politicians want to censor bc they're tired of being ratio'd, criticized, and ridiculed online. Pathetic!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Q: “Why does the @AlboMP government want an army of bots to unleash on social media platforms?”
A: -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Madi Hilly
@MadiHilly
A proposed supersite of AP1000s has just been announced in Appalachia.
The Nuclear Company just revealed plans to build up to six Westinghouse AP1000s on a single site in Lewis County, Kentucky.
If all six reactors get built, it would be the largest nuclear site ever developed in the U.S.
If the reactors are built in pairs, this would be the closest America has come to copying China’s recipe for nuclear success.
My team and I have spent the past year studying China’s nuclear program through Chinese primary sources, and there’s a clear pattern to their builds:
- 6 reactors planned per site built two at a time;
- Using a standard design they repeat over and over;
- With the same crews moving from one pair to the next.
Although a frozen reactor design is nice, nothing gets you more standardization than building on the same spot with the same team.
The site appears to sit along a major 765 kV transmission line in the Ohio River corridor (not a coincidence, I'm sure). But a full 6.6 GW will almost certainly need grid upgrades including additional outbound transmission.
This is a proposed project, not a done deal. And we're far enough out from Vogtle that building these reactors will require significant workforce training, standing up of supply chains, and coordination across many parties.
But oh boy, would be massive if The Nuclear Company pulls this off.
The Nuclear Company
@TheNuclearCo
Announcing Prosperity One: a proposed 6.6 gigawatt nuclear campus in Lewis County, Kentucky
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
They offer no evidence. This is just once again ideological and partisan EU intelligence officials abusing their power, and FT journalists and editors acting as the subservient hacks they are, to interfere in French politics. It’s just more “Trust me bro” disinfo. Shameful @FT
Financial Times
@FT
According to security officials, pro-Russian and far-right social media accounts linked to previous disinformation campaigns have spread violent videos in an attempt to sow more chaos ft.trib.al/t4nxjpO
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The idea that the viral videos of French riots are the work of Russians is pathetic even by the @FT low standards
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Literally all he is saying is "foreigners shared information about the French riots on social media." That's all they have. And it resulted in the @FT's shameful report.
"Russia Russia Russia" is all they have in their toolbox. Sad!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Effectively nobody believes the FT. It’s a zombie newspaper for bubbled euro snobs
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Asra Nomani
@AsraNomani
HOT OFF THE PRESSES. CHAOS INC. is growing. Who is behind the protests in France and Europe?
I was just on @FoxBusiness to talk to the amazing @dagenmcdowell about the findings of my new reporting at @FoxNews Digital:
🔴🟢 101 organizations in the "red-green" alliance across 9 counties are fomenting and amplifying the protests in France and Europe (up from 54 orgs yesterday)
🔴🟢 Only 1 in 3 student or youth; the rest are adults
🔴🟢 They plan “Acte II” on Saturday OCTOBER 24 with protests across France
🔴🟢 The protests are being amplified by the network in the US funded by Neville Roy Singham, the American communist tycoon living in Shanghai supporting the Chinese Communist Party.
READ HERE:
www.foxnews.com/world/global-chaos-inc-grows-101-groups-p…
For this reporting, I name names so that the myth of "student protests" can be pierced. Let me know of any organizations that I missed. Of course, I will reveal any ties, if any, of these organizations to governments from Russia to the Islamic Republic of Iran and China -- wherever the reporting takes us.
WHO'S WHO IN THE EXPANDING GLOBAL 'CHAOS INC.' NETWORK (101)
ACTE II, OCT. 24 – NEW (14)
🔴 Coordination régionale Bloquons tout Île-de-France — Île-de-France Regional "Block Everything" Coordination – PROTEST COORDINATION: Regional "Block Everything" organization behind the platform promoting "Acte II."
🔴 Peuple RÉVOLTÉ – People in Revolt — PROTEST COLLECTIVE: Organization helping operate the "Acte II" platform.
🔴 Maintenant! – Now! — PROTEST MOVEMENT: Civic movement participating in the "Acte II" platform.
🔴 Indignons-nous, Bloquons tout – Let’s Get Indignant, Block Everything — DIRECT ACTION: Protest collective promoting "Acte II."
🔴 Coordination nationale lycéenne – National High School Students’ Coordination — STUDENT/YOUTH: New national high-school coordination calling students into the streets Oct. 24 for "Acte II."
Angoulême, France
🔴 NPA Charente – New Anticapitalist Party–Charente (NPA 16) — REVOLUTIONARY SOCIALIST: Local NPA chapter mobilizing for Acte II.
🔴 Action Antifasciste 16 — ANTIFASCIST: Collaborator on the Angoulême Acte II announcement.
🔴 Maison des Peuples et de la Paix – House of Peoples and Peace — ACTIVIST: Angoulême organization collaborating on the Acte II call.
🔴 Fanfare en lutte d'Angoulême – Angoulême Marching Band in Struggle — ACTIVIST: Local activist collective collaborating on Acte II.
🔴 Révolution Permanente Angoulême — Permanent Revolution–Angoulême – REVOLUTIONARY SOCIALIST: Local chapter of Révolution Permanente, collaborating on the Oct. 24 mobilization.
🔴 Organisation de Solidarité Trans (OST) Angoulême — Trans Solidarity Organization–Angoulême – ACTIVIST / SOLIDARITY: Local organization listed as an Acte II collaborator.
Caen, France
🔴 Caen Antifa Squad — ANTIFASCIST: Collaborator on an "ACTE II — 24 OCTOBRE" announcement.
🔴 Caen en Lutte — Caen in Struggle – PROTEST COLLECTIVE: Local organization collaborating on Acte II.
🔴 Solidarité Étudiante 14 — Student Solidarity 14 – STUDENT: Calvados student organization collaborating on the Oct. 24 mobilization.
NOV. 20 INTERNATIONAL NETWORK
Belgium (3)
🔴 Comac — MARXIST/SOCIALIST YOUTH: Belgian youth organization associated with the Workers' Party.
🔴 RedFox — SOCIALIST YOUTH: Belgian socialist youth organization.
🔴 Vrede — ANTI-WAR: Belgian organization publishing and promoting the International Youth Strike manifesto.
France (1)
🔴 Mouvement National Lycéen — STUDENT/YOUTH: French high-school organization identified in the European Nov. 20 coalition.
Germany (6)
🔴 Schulstreik gegen Wehrpflicht — STUDENT/"ANTI-CONSCRIPTION": German school-strike network mobilizing for Nov. 20.
🔴 Die Falken — SOCIALIST YOUTH: German socialist youth organization involved in the international organizing process.
🔴 Linksjugend ['solid] — SOCIALIST YOUTH: Youth organization associated with Die Linke.
🔴 DIE LINKE.SDS — SOCIALIST STUDENT: German socialist university organization.
🔴 Socialist German Workers Youth, (SDAJ) — COMMUNIST YOUTH: Socialist German Workers Youth.
Sozialistische Organisation Solidarität — SOCIALIST: German socialist organization mobilizing around Nov. 20.
Ireland (1)
🔴 Militant Left — SOCIALIST: Irish socialist organization promoting the international mobilization.
Italy (4)
🔴 Rete della Conoscenza — LEFT-WING STUDENT: Italian student network helping build the international strike.
🔴 Unione degli Studenti — STUDENT: Italian high-school student organization promoting Nov. 20.
🔴 Coordinamento Universitario — STUDENT: Italian university network promoting the strike.
🔴 CGIL — LABOR: Italian labor confederation whose Nov. 20 general strike converges with the student mobilization.
Spain (1)
🔴 Sindicato de Estudiantes — SOCIALIST STUDENT: Spanish student organization identified in the international network.
United Kingdom (9)
🔴 Counterfire — REVOLUTIONARY SOCIALIST / ANTI-WAR: Promoting the Nov. 20 international strike.
🔴 Left Unity — SOCIALIST: Promoting the wider European mobilization.
🔴 International Youth Strike — INTERNATIONAL YOUTH / ANTI-CAPITALIST COALITION: The coordinating coalition behind the Nov. 20 strike says student and youth organizations across Europe are organizing demonstrations, walkouts, assemblies, blockades and occupations. Its manifesto says exploitation, climate breakdown and war are the "essence of capitalism," calls NATO an instrument of "imperial interests" that "should be dissolved," and demands "radical system change."
🔴 North West Pensioners Association — ACTIVIST: Organizational supporter of the Nov. 20 actions.
🔴 Socialist Party — TROTSKYIST: Socialist party promoting the international strike.
🔴 Socialist Students — SOCIALIST STUDENT: British organizer advocating a "socialist future."
🔴 Stop the War Coalition — ANTI-WAR: Promoting Nov. 20 student mobilization.
🔴 Universities and Colleges Union @ucunion — The largest trade union and professional association for academics, lecturers, trainers, researchers & academic-related staff in UK "Further Education" and "Higher Education."
🔴 Young Greens — YOUTH / GREEN: British youth organization identified among supporters.
Amplifiers (8)
🔴 CODEPINK — U.S. ANTI-WAR / ACTIVIST ORGANIZATION: The U.S. organization has explicitly connected the French protests to its own planned Washington mobilization. "From France to the United States, the message is clear," CODEPINK said, before promoting its Nov. 10-12 "Taxpayer Uprising" demanding that federal spending go toward education, healthcare and housing rather than the military.
🔴 Committee for a Workers' International (CWI) — TROTSKYIST / SOCIALIST: An international socialist organization whose national affiliates include Britain's Socialist Party and Ireland's Militant Left. Its international website is promoting the Nov. 20 youth walkout under the campaign slogan "Fight for our future not their wars."
🔴 International Socialist Alternative (ISA) — REVOLUTIONARY SOCIALIST: The international socialist organization says "Capitalism means war" and that it "wholeheartedly" supports the Nov. 20 strike. ISA says its members have helped organize Germany's anti-conscription school strikes and describes imperialism as the "highest stage of capitalism."
🔴 Party for Socialism and Liberation–Houston — MARXIST-LENINIST / U.S. CHAPTER: The Houston chapter of the U.S. Party for Socialism and Liberation is amplifying the French protest movement.
🔴 Progressive International — TRANSNATIONAL LEFT NETWORK: The international organization explicitly grouped the current protests in France, Spain, India and Albania in an Oct. 16 briefing and asked how the "new rebellions" could acquire organized political power. Most significantly, it said: "These are the forces that the Progressive International is working to support and connect."
🔴 Stop ReArm Europe — ANTI-WAR / ANTI-MILITARIZATION COALITION: A European coalition calling for demonstrations and actions around Nov. 20 under the slogan "Welfare, not Warfare." It says it supports students "refusing" militarization and calls on social movements, unions, civil-society groups, political organizations and parliamentarians to mobilize around the student strike.
🔴 teleSUR English — INTERNATIONAL MEDIA AMPLIFIER: The international media outlet amplified the French demonstrations with Oct. 17 coverage of clashes, fires and arrests in Paris, Lyon and other cities. This is evidence of international amplification.
🔴 World BEYOND War — INTERNATIONAL ANTI-WAR: A global organization that describes itself as a movement to "end war" and says it is part of the Stop ReArm Europe campaign. It is explicitly promoting the Nov. 20 International Youth Strike and urging supporters to "join this resistance."
FRANCE — ORIGINAL NETWORK (54)
🔴 Organisation communiste révolutionnaire — REVOLUTIONARY COMMUNIST: Communist organization involved in protests.
🔴 Parti communiste français — COMMUNIST: French Communist Party whose leaders and activists joined the demonstrations.
🔴 Parti des Indigènes de la République — DECOLONIAL: Political organization that defends the student revolt.
🔴 Parti de l'égalité socialiste — TROTSKYIST: Socialist organization advocating workers' action committees.
🔴 Revolutionary Communist Group — COMMUNIST: British organization that connects the French protests to capitalism, imperialism and Palestine.
🔴 Révolution Permanente — TROTSKYIST: Revolutionary socialist organization promoting student-worker mobilization.
🔴 World Socialist Web Site — TROTSKYIST MEDIA: Socialist outlet framing the French protests around capitalism, austerity and militarization.
Palestine-solidarity organizations
🔴 Union juive française pour la paix — PALESTINE SOLIDARITY: French Jewish organization that publicizes support for the protesting students.
🔴 Urgence Palestine — PALESTINE SOLIDARITY: French Palestine organization that amplified protest-related material.
Labor and professional organizations
🔴 CGT Éduc'action — LABOR: CGT's education-sector organization.
🔴 CFDT Éducation Formation Recherche Publiques — LABOR: Education and research union supporting the student movement.
🔴 CGT — LABOR: Major French labor confederation involved in the October mobilizations.
🔴 CNT — ANARCHO-SYNDICALIST: Revolutionary-syndicalist union that declared students were "right to revolt."
🔴 Confédération paysanne — FARMERS' UNION: Called agricultural workers into the Oct. 17 mobilization.
🔴 FSU — LABOR: Education and public-sector union federation.
🔴 FNEC FP-FO — LABOR: Force Ouvrière's education federation.
🔴 Force Ouvrière — LABOR: National labor confederation.
🔴 SUD éducation — LABOR: Left-wing education union.
🔴 SNES-FSU — LABOR: Secondary-school personnel union.
🔴 Union syndicale Solidaires — LABOR: Left-wing labor federation.
🔴 UNSA — LABOR: National autonomous trade-union federation.
Advocacy, environmental and protest organizations
🔴 Amnesty International France — HUMAN RIGHTS: Reported on police treatment of minors during the demonstrations.
🔴 ATTAC France — ECONOMIC JUSTICE: Connected the mobilization to austerity and economic policy.
Coordination nationale du mouvement du 26 septembre — PROTEST NETWORK: Mobilization network that encouraged participation in Oct. 17.
🔴 Extinction Rebellion — ENVIRONMENTAL: Environmental direct-action movement appearing in the protest ecosystem.
🔴 FCPE — PARENTS: National parents' federation that called members to demonstrate.
🔴 Gilets jaunes — Yellow Vests: Decentralized protest movement whose Oct. 17 mobilization converged with the students.
🔴 Intersyndicale nationale VTC — PROFESSIONAL / LABOR: Private-hire drivers' coalition promoting participation.
🔴 Les Soulèvements de la Terre — RADICAL ENVIRONMENTAL: Movement that celebrated the student revolt and called for antifascist mobilization.
🔴 Ligue des droits de l'Homme — HUMAN RIGHTS: Supported students and criticized police repression.
🔴 Movement Against Racism and for Friendship Between Peoples (MRAP) — ANTIRACIST: Antiracism organization involved in the wider coalition.
🔴 SOS Racisme — ANTIRACIST: Antiracism organization involved in supporting the movement.
International amplifiers
🔴 BreakThrough News — SINGHAM NETWORK / MEDIA: New York-based nonprofit amplifying the French protests internationally.
🔴 Indian Alliance Paris — INTERNATIONAL / DIASPORA: France-based organization connecting French and Indian protest messaging. Partnered with the People's Forum in Manhattan. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Emily Kopp
@emilyakopp
New FOIA docs show Democrats' grand ambitions for censoring social media. COVID was just a warm up.
When the Biden censorship apparatus was at its height in 2021, Surgeon General Vivek Murthy's "maximum pressure" team said that "may be worth emphasizing that you don’t just see this as a COVID-related issue."
via @publicstrust -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
The Australian
@australian
Last year after the assassination of Charlie Kirk, the left-wing activist-influencer wrote: ‘Is violence sometimes necessary? Yes?’ Her stance following the attack on Helen Haines tells a different story: www.theaustralian.com.au/business/media/hannah-fergusons-…
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Australian Jewish Association
@AustralianJA
It's alarming to see left-wing politicians already using this tragedy to call for further censorship online.
The irony of using an attack, allegedly carried out by a crazed, leftist, anti-Israel hater in order to ram through Labor's draconian digital censorship bill which will be used to censor conservatives.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Not censorship
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A reportedly drunk & possibly insane man attacked a member of parliament in Australia with his car. And so, naturally, a few vile politicians are exploiting the tragedy to demand mass online censorship. Decades of scientific evidence & common sense demolish their lies. THREAD
-
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Not censorship
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A reportedly drunk & possibly insane man attacked a member of parliament in Australia with his car. And so, naturally, a few vile politicians are exploiting the tragedy to demand mass online censorship. Decades of scientific evidence & common sense demolish their lies. THREAD
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
France did its best to prevent the riots, say the media. But it dramatically underestimated the number of protesters and failed to send out enough officers and armored vehicles. Behind all those specific failures was, as in the US, the anti-civilization Left's war on the police.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
If one had to choose from the many powerful images of the French riots on Saturday, it would have to be the widely shared video of a young blond French shopkeeper who begged the rioters to spare her store, was pushed aside, and watched them loot it, her face crumpling in sadness and despair. She wasn’t alone. Other media reported on store owners “pleading with thugs to leave their stores” and shopkeepers “sitting in front of their businesses in tears.”
Faced with shocking videos that quickly spread worldwide, defenders of French President Emmanuel Macron and Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez say they are not to blame. Everyone was surprised and caught off guard by the sheer number of protesters and rioters who looted stores, burned buildings and invaded city halls. Macron had repeatedly urged protesters not to use violence, which he reiterated on Sunday night. He promised that “those who destroyed must pay,” that “those who looted must reimburse,” and that “those who sought to bring down the Republic will have to answer for it.” And because the riots were not the government’s fault, it was only logical for Macron to reject Nuñez’s offer to resign after the weekend’s mayhem.
But Macron and his government knew for weeks that the CGT, the nation’s largest union confederation, and the student unions had planned a massive protest for October 17, and failed to do what was needed to protect the public. He and the French intelligence community drastically underestimated the crowd size. The day before the marches, the Interior Ministry expected 40,000 to 60,000 demonstrators in Paris and about 100,000 in the rest of the country. Instead, roughly 550,000 turned out, including 110,000 in Paris.
As a result, the government deployed far too few police and other security forces, just 60,000. They deployed few Centaure armored vehicles or RAID tactical units in advance. Nobody should have been surprised. France’s intelligence services told top officials in a government crisis meeting on October 1 that the school movement behind the riots was “an operation organised by LFI (France Unbowed) and its proxies on the far left.”...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2112242305549709603
Public cuts through mainstream media misinformation with relevant investigative journalism. Please subscribe now to read the rest.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Thanks to auto-translate you can read mainstream French media eg @LeMonde etc. But they simply can’t compete with X. It’s for that reason, not “inciting violence” or “misinformation,” that @EmmanuelMacron & other world leaders are desperate to censor, control, or shut X down.
SwordOfSalomon
@SwordOfSalomon
🚨📹 IDENTIFICATION : Elle a qualifié de « dommage collatéral » la menace de viol proférée par des émeutiers contre une mère accompagnée de son nourrisson. Dans la même vidéo tournée place de la République par @brutofficiel, elle appelle à la révolution et se réjouit des violences et des saccages à Paris.
Cette femme se nomme Bettina Zourli. Militante LFI et pro-palestinienne 🇵🇸, elle est également professeure de sociologie à @UnivRennes_2.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
To the extent governments want to censor and shut down X because of “misinformation,” it’s because X allows people to debunk government misinformation in real time. It’s unmediated and politicians for the last 80 years depended on being able to control the mediators (ie mainstream publishers, reporters and editors)
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
So it turns out that @AnikaWells, the lady who wants to censor her political enemies at home and the entire Internet globally, lied about her misuse of public money for personal travel. And it's not even her first time. No wonder these lying crooks are desperate for censorship.
News24 Australia
@News24Aust
Calls have come for Anika Wells to repay the cost of her flight home and be stood down after records from Don Farrell’s office failed to substantiate a meeting she said took place.
www.news24.com.au/politics/australian-politics/coalition-…Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
But see, it was worth it, because they're trying to censor the entire global Internet, see?
"Mr Albanese defended the spending as within the guidelines and said the New York trip to promote the social media ban, which will come into effect on Wednesday, was 'very significant.'
“'This was an important event that led directly to the European Union taking action,' he told ABC’s Insiders on Sunday. 'One of the comments I heard from various UN officials was ... ‘this is the first time I’ve been to a forum that has changed my mind’.”
Yikes. These people should be kept as far away from the instruments of power as possible.
They're a dark triad of entitlement, creepiness, and totalitarianism.
thenightly.com.au/politics/anika-wells-forced-to-defend-t…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
How is it even possible to spend $38k on airfare to the US? Were they flying private in a jet that had its own spa?
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
European Commission
@EU_Commission
The battle of narratives is going strong.
Our countries are a recurring target.
It is time to act to tell the stories that make us strong. Let’s live our own story!
Protect what matters - our democracy. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Students are rioting because the French government spends too little to educate the children of migrants, say the media. But France spends between two and 200 times more per student than the nations from which its migrants come. The media refuses to report basic facts.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Students are protesting in France because schools don’t have enough money, say mainstream journalists. In truth, they have more money than ever. What’s really behind the riots is a decades-old Left-Islamist political alliance that much of the media supports.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Alexandra Marshall
@ellymelly
Let's talk about MISINFORMATION and FAKE NEWS, Anika Wells - Minister for Communication.
You said at the National Press Club - and stated as a position of fact:
"...where a billionaire can buy a platform and strip it of moderation."
This is very clearly a reference to @elonmusk purchasing Twitter.
You are a government minister proposing some of the largest fines in the history of social media - and yet you are beginning your objective from a position of untruth.
Twitter - now X - was NOT 'stripped of moderation'.
X has - and has always had - one of the stricter and more responsive systems of automatic and user-reported community safety guidelines in the industry.
X responds faster to complaints than the government - that's for sure.
None of these systems disappeared. None of them vanished.
To imply that X has been 'stripped of moderation' is to spread misinformation about an individual, their intent, and the company activity for the purpose of justifying a new law with severe financial consequences.
What did Elon Musk do that upset the Australian government so much?
He made public the previously secret 'takedown orders' made during the Covid pandemic which robbed victims of government policy of their voice. The Australian government - quite literally - tried to silence the injured and bereaved. The government tried to silence information and scientists who disagreed with a political policy that cost lives, broke privacy laws, broke human rights norms, and forever crippled the economy.
The government leaned on social media - threatened social media - and made social media complicit in HIDING the serious consequences of their Covid and Climate Change policies.
A relationship they obviously want to re-establish via the coercive force of fines.
In other words, Elon Musk embarrassed the government and exposed censorial demands that go against public expectation. And the government want it stopped.
Elon Musk also removed OVERT POLITICAL CENSORSHIP that had been silencing conservatives online and removing criticism of progressive and left-wing policy and narratives. That is - and in particular - he removed Covid, Climate Change, and biological censorship that was corrupting the truth with political propaganda.
Musk REMOVED a layer of political influence from X and in doing so left-wing governments around the world immediately had an angry public on their hands and the consequences are being felt at elections.
Anika Wells should be forced to RETRACT and APOLOGISE for her comments and the untruth that she said in front of the National Press Gallery while speaking from a position of power.
And if not, let's hope Elon Musk can use this against the Australian government in the future. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Reclaim The Net
@ReclaimTheNetHQ
The British government wants to extend the TV license fee to YouTube, Netflix, Amazon and Disney+. The Independent calls it the “YouTube tax,” and it is expected in the BBC charter white paper before Christmas.
A Whitehall source explained the supposed purpose. The money would fund local journalism and counter the “conspiracy theories and fake news” they say have helped parties like Reform get elected.
That is a government official admitting the goal is to tax the public into voting differently.
The government would decide what counts as fake news.
An estimated 3 to 4 million extra households would have to pay £180 a year. Many of them use YouTube precisely to avoid the BBC.
A separate plan would push the legacy media to the top of people's YouTube feed. People would pay for the mainstream broadcasters, and then pay again with their algorithm. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Océane
@gtylgrn2
Pillage des Galeries Lafayette de Bordeaux, venant tout juste d’être rénové #17octobre
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Loreine 🇫🇷🇰🇷 Les Asiatiques à Droite
@Loreine_LAD
La détresse de cette femme...
Les profils...
Deux Frances qui se regardent face à face, notre impuissance.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Melinda Richards 🇦🇺🇺🇸
@goodfoodgal
We are paying this corrupt, grifting politician to take away our freedom of speech.
Wake up Australia!
This is NOT OK. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Anthony Khallouf
@ausvstheagenda
Anika Wells on 5 December 2019: Complaining that the Morrison Government is restricting her freedom of speech, right to protest and debate in Parliament.
Anika Wells on 15 October 2026: Fuck your free speech.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
News24 Australia
@News24Aust
A high-profile academic captured the chaos over Labor's Digital Duty of Care bill perfectly as he recalled a meeting with two Labor employees that left him feeling like he “was in Soviet Russia”, writes Louise Roberts. www.news24.com.au/opinion/us-author-michael-shellenberger…
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Powell
@powellAtlantic
Another grand victory for better education
French Report
@french_report78
🔴🇫🇷🔥 ALERTE INFO | Le clocher de la mairie de Limoges s’est effondré.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Lydia Moynihan
@LydiaMoynihan
Today I learned the fines American tech cos pay to the EU generate more money for Europe than the taxes their own tech companies pay.
The world literally runs on American innovation. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
The Albanese government's Digital Duty of Care laws would give regulators sweeping powers over online content, threatening free speech in Australia & setting a dangerous precedent for internet regulation worldwide.
@TheIPA 's Andrew Bushnell for @Quillette featuring @shellenberger down under
quillette.com/2026/10/15/australias-coming-censorship-mac… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Bojan Pancevski
@bopanc
Le Pen, after declaring that France is basically broke, wants to make Germany pay a EU tax for their self-harming policy of abandoning nuclear power
Marine Le Pen
@MLP_officiel
Nous proposons qu’une partie de la contribution au budget de l’Europe soit calculée selon l’intensité carbone des économies nationales : plus un pays est éloigné des objectifs de l’accord de Paris, plus il devra contribuer.
Nous demandons aussi une vraie taxe carbone aux frontières.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Wow, wow, wow. I just left the National Press Club where Minister of Communications @AnikaWells spoke. She repeatedly and brazenly lied about the fake accounts, claiming they were only for enforcement, even though the legislation says in black and white that the eSafety Commissioner can use them in unlimited ways for "educational" and "promotional" purposes.
One big moment came when a Politico reporter got up and said something about how mean people like @PaulineHansonOz were to eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman-Grant. Seriously. A supposed reporter was white-knighting for a government official during the official Q&A. The same reporter had come up to me before Wells' speech and asked if I had criticized Inman-Grant. Who needs government censors when you have Politico?
After he asked his question, Wells showed the most emotion, describing online criticism of Inman-Grant as "abuse." She also talked about her own staff's supposed suffering. I kid you not. The mask dropped, and you could see what really upset her: people — including a sitting Senator — criticizing government officials.
After gaslighting the audience about fake accounts, Wells repeatedly insisted the government wasn't trying to censor content. She said this after filling her speech with examples of content she claimed harmed people. You couldn't make it up.
This legislation is the culmination of decades of progressives equating words with physical violence. Wells cynically compared her legislation to prevent psychological "harm" to various laws that protect people from physical harm, like seat belt laws.
BTW, Wells never said what content it was that she thought caused eating disorders. Pictures of skinny women? Dietary advice? Who knows. Nobody asked.
Another important moment came when Wells explicitly said Australia would be pursuing censorship alongside other nations, including the UK, France, and Spain—all countries where governments risk losing power to populists.
I spoke with Julie Inman-Grant before the speech began and asked about the fake accounts. She insisted they were there just for enforcement, and when I asked why the law allowed them to be used for government propaganda, she said she might write an "enforcement memo," which, of course, would have no impact on the legislation.
After her speech, I went up to Wells and asked if she was seriously saying the legislation didn't allow the government to use fake accounts for government propaganda. She refused to answer. A man who said he was from the National Press Club stepped in front of me and said I could interview her afterward. But that wasn't possible because they rushed her out the back to avoid any difficult questions.
So there you have it. The pettiest people in Australia are seeking to silence citizens and their political opponents in the name of protecting children. These deeply intolerant and cynical people want to control what you can see and say online. And they're doing it with most of the media's support. Australia has reached a new low in its rapid descent into dogmatism, intolerance, and censorship.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The government today will introduce sweeping censorship that @AlboMP & @AnikaWells lie about. Below she claims the government wants to create a bot army of fake accounts for “research” when the bill clearly intends for them to be used in partisan warfare against fooled citizens.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Here is @AnikaWells brazenly lying about the fake accounts ("sock puppets") provision of the law:
She says, "Well, there is nowhere in the bill that gives the government, and by the government, in this instance, the independent regulator, that power. It's just not there."
Yes, it is there, as anyone who reads the bill can see. I'll paste it again below.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
There is no other way to read the legislation.
Nobody—including @AnikaWells—has even tried to show that this isn't exactly what it appears to be.
Here are the key parts, along with the link. See for yourself
Their censorship bill rests on a big lie
www.infrastructure.gov.au/sites/default/files/documents/e…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Here’s a Politico reporter winning sympathy and a warm laugh from other reporters in the audience about the supposedly mean things @elonmusk and @PaulineHansonOz wrote about her online.
I mean seriously. A journalist is upset that people are criticizing Australia’s authoritarian censor
Even Pravda at the height of communism wasn’t this obeisant.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“It is testimony to the fact [the] online [world] is not safe and is not safe for women.”
The “it” = criticism of Australia’s top censor
Truly pathetic and embarrassing 😒
Paul Karp
@Paul_Karp
Does Australia’s eSafety Commissioner have the worst job in the world?
Amid personal abuse and a growing workload, Julie Inman Grant’s job is set to be split up
www.politico.com/news/2026/10/15/does-australias-esafety-…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@AnikaWells really gives away the game here in calling online criticism of Australia’s Grand Inquisitor “abuse” and saying it makes her “not safe.” That’s literally how the legislation defines content it wants to censor.
So there you have it: if you dare to criticize the censor, you shall be censored! Totalitarian perfection, no notes
“We catch up frequently, we talk about the pressure and abuse that a position like the eSafety Commissioner gets put under. It is testimony to the fact [the] online [world] is not safe and is not safe for women.”
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Q: “Why does the @AlboMP government want an army of bots to unleash on social media platforms?”
A:Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Truckers protest and Trudeau calls them all Nazis and freezes their bank accounts. In Australia the @AlboMP government demonized millions of upstanding citizens as Nazis and racists after a murderous attack.
It’s the same totalitarian playbook everywhere across the West from EU, UK, Canada to US to Aus/NZ. Same people. Same pathological need for control from the PMC.
These are people who believe they have exorcised all evil from within and project it all onto millions of good people. It’s a sickness of people who have never considered the other side to their dogma their entire lives. Everyone who disagrees with them is evil and must be silenced in one way or another.
When asked politely about why they want to deprive their fellow citizens of their most sacred right, the one that allows for the protection of all other rights, they literally flee out the back door of their cathedral.
These people are the dangerous ones. They want to cause harm to their critics and openly threaten the public’s safety.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
😦
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
$70 million for censorship every year!
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Institute of Public Affairs
@TheIPA
“It's a disproportionate, unjustifiable law that needs to be abandoned in full.”
Michael Shellenberger, founder of Public and CBR Chair of Politics, Censorship and Free Speech at the University of Austin Texas, speaks with IPA Senior Fellow Andrew Bushnell about why they believe the proposed Digital Duty of Care cannot be fixed with amendments.
📺 Watch more: www.youtube.com/watch?v=daieq3oqYdE
#censorship #law #australiaThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Rita Panahi
@RitaPanahi
Sadly, this is not isolated. Members of the Australian media pushing for more censorship is the norm...these are the same hacks who disgraced themselves during Covid.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Here’s a Politico reporter winning sympathy and a warm laugh from other reporters in the audience about the supposedly mean things @elonmusk and @PaulineHansonOz wrote about her online.
I mean seriously. A journalist is upset that people are criticizing Australia’s authoritarian censor
Even Pravda at the height of communism wasn’t this obeisant.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Well, that was wild. I'm at the Australian Parliament and just left a meeting with two staffers for the governing party. They told us that the government needed more power to censor things like the upcoming US execution of Nidal Hasan.
When I asked why they needed to censor that video, one said it was to prevent copycat killings. Copycat killings by governments? I asked. Er, no, they said. Copycat killings like of a backpacker, several decades ago.
So, under that logic, I pointed out, the government should censor things like last year's Bondi massacre, where two Muslims killed 15 people, no? Well, that was news, they said. Didn't they realize their bill would allow the government to censor news? They didn't seem to know, or care.
They also admitted that they did not know that the bill would allow the government to create and operate an unlimited number of fake social media accounts to attack its political enemies and spread disinformation. Having presented them with information they had never heard about a bill they had clearly not read, they emphasized to us, strenuously, that they were moving forward with the bill.
So there you have it. The government wants the power to arbitrarily censor scenes of violent crime, or violence, for any reason. And it wants the power to use an unlimited number of fake accounts to wage offensive disinformational warfare against the Australian people.
Given that the Bondi massacre last year increased public opposition to mass migration, and support for the populist One Nation Party, it seems obvious that the government wants to censor such events in order to protect its political power.
It's quite telling how obediently governing party members insist such a law is needed without even knowing what's in it.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Should the Aus government be allowed to censor anything it believes “may cause serious harm” and operate unlimited fake social media accounts?
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The @AlboMP government especially @AnikaWells are lying their asses off — “spreading disinformation!” — about why they want to censor and wage info war on their fellow citizens. They project their own stupidity on their fellow Aussies. It’s pathetic.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Like all censors, they hate the truth. If they cared about the truth and preventing “real world harm,” they would want free speech.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
😂
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Empire Strikes Back
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Wow, wow, wow. I just left the National Press Club where Minister of Communications @AnikaWells spoke. She repeatedly and brazenly lied about the fake accounts, claiming they were only for enforcement, even though the legislation says in black and white that the eSafety Commissioner can use them in unlimited ways for "educational" and "promotional" purposes.
One big moment came when a Politico reporter got up and said something about how mean people like @PaulineHansonOz were to eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman-Grant. Seriously. A supposed reporter was white-knighting for a government official during the official Q&A. The same reporter had come up to me before Wells' speech and asked if I had criticized Inman-Grant. Who needs government censors when you have Politico?
After he asked his question, Wells showed the most emotion, describing online criticism of Inman-Grant as "abuse." She also talked about her own staff's supposed suffering. I kid you not. The mask dropped, and you could see what really upset her: people — including a sitting Senator — criticizing government officials.
After gaslighting the audience about fake accounts, Wells repeatedly insisted the government wasn't trying to censor content. She said this after filling her speech with examples of content she claimed harmed people. You couldn't make it up.
This legislation is the culmination of decades of progressives equating words with physical violence. Wells cynically compared her legislation to prevent psychological "harm" to various laws that protect people from physical harm, like seat belt laws.
BTW, Wells never said what content it was that she thought caused eating disorders. Pictures of skinny women? Dietary advice? Who knows. Nobody asked.
Another important moment came when Wells explicitly said Australia would be pursuing censorship alongside other nations, including the UK, France, and Spain—all countries where governments risk losing power to populists.
I spoke with Julie Inman-Grant before the speech began and asked about the fake accounts. She insisted they were there just for enforcement, and when I asked why the law allowed them to be used for government propaganda, she said she might write an "enforcement memo," which, of course, would have no impact on the legislation.
After her speech, I went up to Wells and asked if she was seriously saying the legislation didn't allow the government to use fake accounts for government propaganda. She refused to answer. A man who said he was from the National Press Club stepped in front of me and said I could interview her afterward. But that wasn't possible because they rushed her out the back to avoid any difficult questions.
So there you have it. The pettiest people in Australia are seeking to silence citizens and their political opponents in the name of protecting children. These deeply intolerant and cynical people want to control what you can see and say online. And they're doing it with most of the media's support. Australia has reached a new low in its rapid descent into dogmatism, intolerance, and censorship.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The government today will introduce sweeping censorship that @AlboMP & @AnikaWells lie about. Below she claims the government wants to create a bot army of fake accounts for “research” when the bill clearly intends for them to be used in partisan warfare against fooled citizens.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@AlboMP & @AnikaWells really hate Australians
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The government today will introduce sweeping censorship that @AlboMP & @AnikaWells lie about. Below she claims the government wants to create a bot army of fake accounts for “research” when the bill clearly intends for them to be used in partisan warfare against fooled citizens.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
PM @AlboMP & @AnikaWells repeatedly make clear that they believe voters can be fooled. They lie to the voters and propose to wage information warfare against them because they think they can get away with it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
If this is the first you're learning of this terrible censorship/info-war legislation, here's an introduction and overview:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The censors are demanding terrifying new powers. My full warning to the West.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
👀
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Wow, wow, wow. I just left the National Press Club where Minister of Communications @AnikaWells spoke. She repeatedly and brazenly lied about the fake accounts, claiming they were only for enforcement, even though the legislation says in black and white that the eSafety Commissioner can use them in unlimited ways for "educational" and "promotional" purposes.
One big moment came when a Politico reporter got up and said something about how mean people like @PaulineHansonOz were to eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman-Grant. Seriously. A supposed reporter was white-knighting for a government official during the official Q&A. The same reporter had come up to me before Wells' speech and asked if I had criticized Inman-Grant. Who needs government censors when you have Politico?
After he asked his question, Wells showed the most emotion, describing online criticism of Inman-Grant as "abuse." She also talked about her own staff's supposed suffering. I kid you not. The mask dropped, and you could see what really upset her: people — including a sitting Senator — criticizing government officials.
After gaslighting the audience about fake accounts, Wells repeatedly insisted the government wasn't trying to censor content. She said this after filling her speech with examples of content she claimed harmed people. You couldn't make it up.
This legislation is the culmination of decades of progressives equating words with physical violence. Wells cynically compared her legislation to prevent psychological "harm" to various laws that protect people from physical harm, like seat belt laws.
BTW, Wells never said what content it was that she thought caused eating disorders. Pictures of skinny women? Dietary advice? Who knows. Nobody asked.
Another important moment came when Wells explicitly said Australia would be pursuing censorship alongside other nations, including the UK, France, and Spain—all countries where governments risk losing power to populists.
I spoke with Julie Inman-Grant before the speech began and asked about the fake accounts. She insisted they were there just for enforcement, and when I asked why the law allowed them to be used for government propaganda, she said she might write an "enforcement memo," which, of course, would have no impact on the legislation.
After her speech, I went up to Wells and asked if she was seriously saying the legislation didn't allow the government to use fake accounts for government propaganda. She refused to answer. A man who said he was from the National Press Club stepped in front of me and said I could interview her afterward. But that wasn't possible because they rushed her out the back to avoid any difficult questions.
So there you have it. The pettiest people in Australia are seeking to silence citizens and their political opponents in the name of protecting children. These deeply intolerant and cynical people want to control what you can see and say online. And they're doing it with most of the media's support. Australia has reached a new low in its rapid descent into dogmatism, intolerance, and censorship.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The government today will introduce sweeping censorship that @AlboMP & @AnikaWells lie about. Below she claims the government wants to create a bot army of fake accounts for “research” when the bill clearly intends for them to be used in partisan warfare against fooled citizens.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Here's my op-ed in the @australian today. I am grateful that they gave so much space to this issue.
www.theaustralian.com.au/commentary/labors-digital-duty-o…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
There is just one single global censorship industrial complex. The leaders, which include Australia's eSafety Commissioner, meet regularly too coordinate strategy. Their goal is to control the entire global internet. Their strategy is to encircle the US.
Eli Vieira
@elivieira
"Duty of care" is also an excuse for censorship in Brazil. Used by Lula in his two censorship decrees and the former chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Luís Roberto Barroso, who refused to close an extraordinary inquiry opened by the court to silence its critics.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A whistleblower leaked information about the censors' closed-door dinner/roundtable on September 24, 2025, at Stanford University’s Cyber Policy Center, led by Obama’s former Russia ambassador Michael McFaul. It was titled “Compliance and Enforcement in a Rapidly Evolving Landscape” (also called a Stanford Dialogue).X
Purpose: Discuss the state of compliance and enforcement of multi-jurisdictional regulations on online trust and safety, and identify how data, research, and expertise could enable more effective compliance and enforcement.
Format: Roundtable under Chatham House rules. Keynote by Julie Inman-Grant (Australian eSafety Commissioner).
Sessions covered international tech-policy compliance/enforcement milestones and pitfalls, plus how academics and tech experts could support stronger regulatory capacity/enforcement.
Hosts/organizers included Jeff Hancock (Director, Stanford Cyber Policy Center), Sunny Xun Liu, David Evan Harris, and others.
Expected outcomes included a private summary report, working groups, and stronger networks among regulators, academics, and technology experts.
Notable attendees included officials from Australia’s eSafety office (Inman-Grant and several colleagues), the EU (e.g., Gerard de Graaf, Giulia Geneletti, Joanna Smolinska), Brazil (Mariana Ferreira Thiele), UK Ofcom (Jonathan Porter), California’s Privacy Protection Agency, plus academics, Knight Foundation representatives, and Project Liberty Institute people.
The gathering was financed by Frank McCourt via his Project Liberty Institute (the same funder previously linked to the Stanford Internet Observatory). It followed a public conference focused on similar “regulation”/compliance topics.
Nobody involved responded to multiple requests from Public to comment on the event
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In 2022, Obama gave a speech at Stanford Cyber Policy Center advocating sweeping censorship of the Internet. Now, Public has discovered the same Center last month hosted a secret meeting with EU, UK, Brazil, & Australia officials to plot global censorship — including of the US.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The @AlboMP wants to override X’s ban on bots
Anna Paulina Luna
@realannapaulina
13000 bot accounts were purged from @X today targeting US political conversation. 👏🏻 Keep it up. Purge the bots!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Lies
Anthony Albanese
@AlboMP
INTRODUCED: New laws to give you control over your feed and protect kids online.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
How could anyone trust @AnikaWells and @AlboMP about anything given how many lies they’ve been caught making about why they want sweeping powers to censor and spread disinformation? That’s the question I intend to ask @AnikaWells in a few minutes. Wish me luck!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The government today will introduce sweeping censorship that @AlboMP & @AnikaWells lie about. Below she claims the government wants to create a bot army of fake accounts for “research” when the bill clearly intends for them to be used in partisan warfare against fooled citizens.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
you’ll never guess what happened
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Wow, wow, wow. I just left the National Press Club where Minister of Communications @AnikaWells spoke. She repeatedly and brazenly lied about the fake accounts, claiming they were only for enforcement, even though the legislation says in black and white that the eSafety Commissioner can use them in unlimited ways for "educational" and "promotional" purposes.
One big moment came when a Politico reporter got up and said something about how mean people like @PaulineHansonOz were to eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman-Grant. Seriously. A supposed reporter was white-knighting for a government official during the official Q&A. The same reporter had come up to me before Wells' speech and asked if I had criticized Inman-Grant. Who needs government censors when you have Politico?
After he asked his question, Wells showed the most emotion, describing online criticism of Inman-Grant as "abuse." She also talked about her own staff's supposed suffering. I kid you not. The mask dropped, and you could see what really upset her: people — including a sitting Senator — criticizing government officials.
After gaslighting the audience about fake accounts, Wells repeatedly insisted the government wasn't trying to censor content. She said this after filling her speech with examples of content she claimed harmed people. You couldn't make it up.
This legislation is the culmination of decades of progressives equating words with physical violence. Wells cynically compared her legislation to prevent psychological "harm" to various laws that protect people from physical harm, like seat belt laws.
BTW, Wells never said what content it was that she thought caused eating disorders. Pictures of skinny women? Dietary advice? Who knows. Nobody asked.
Another important moment came when Wells explicitly said Australia would be pursuing censorship alongside other nations, including the UK, France, and Spain—all countries where governments risk losing power to populists.
I spoke with Julie Inman-Grant before the speech began and asked about the fake accounts. She insisted they were there just for enforcement, and when I asked why the law allowed them to be used for government propaganda, she said she might write an "enforcement memo," which, of course, would have no impact on the legislation.
After her speech, I went up to Wells and asked if she was seriously saying the legislation didn't allow the government to use fake accounts for government propaganda. She refused to answer. A man who said he was from the National Press Club stepped in front of me and said I could interview her afterward. But that wasn't possible because they rushed her out the back to avoid any difficult questions.
So there you have it. The pettiest people in Australia are seeking to silence citizens and their political opponents in the name of protecting children. These deeply intolerant and cynical people want to control what you can see and say online. And they're doing it with most of the media's support. Australia has reached a new low in its rapid descent into dogmatism, intolerance, and censorship.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The government today will introduce sweeping censorship that @AlboMP & @AnikaWells lie about. Below she claims the government wants to create a bot army of fake accounts for “research” when the bill clearly intends for them to be used in partisan warfare against fooled citizens.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Q: “Why does the @AlboMP government want an army of bots to unleash on social media platforms?”
A: -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Senator Sean Bell
@SenatorSeanBell
The Labor government is lying about their Digital Duty of Care Bill - they will use it to shut down and silence everyday Australians.
One Nation will fight it every step of the way.
And thank you to @shellenberger for the work you have done to expose Labor’s campaign of state sponsored censorshipThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Peta Credlin
Author Michael Shellenberger says the Albanese government’s Digital Duty of Care plan is “radical and extreme”.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Senator Matt Canavan
@mattjcan
The esafety commissioner has lost multiple court cases and been found to be acting beyond her legal authority.
That deserves strong criticism and she should have lost her job long ago for such repeated mismanagement and failures.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@AnikaWells really gives away the game here in calling online criticism of Australia’s Grand Inquisitor “abuse” and saying it makes her “not safe.” That’s literally how the legislation defines content it wants to censor.
So there you have it: if you dare to criticize the censor, you shall be censored! Totalitarian perfection, no notes
“We catch up frequently, we talk about the pressure and abuse that a position like the eSafety Commissioner gets put under. It is testimony to the fact [the] online [world] is not safe and is not safe for women.” -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@AnikaWells really gives away the game here in calling online criticism of Australia’s Grand Inquisitor “abuse” and saying it makes her “not safe.” That’s literally how the legislation defines content it wants to censor.
So there you have it: if you dare to criticize the censor, you shall be censored! Totalitarian perfection, no notes
“We catch up frequently, we talk about the pressure and abuse that a position like the eSafety Commissioner gets put under. It is testimony to the fact [the] online [world] is not safe and is not safe for women.” -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You lie
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
All they do is lie:
— Two years ago they said they wanted to crack down on fake accounts. Now they want to operate an unlimited number of them to wage informational war on the Australian people. And now @AnikaWells is lying about what's in the legislation
— @AnikaWells says she needs sweeping censorship powers to protect 14 year old girls from eating disorders, but the government already banned under 16 year olds from using social media
— @AlboMP at the UN said he wanted to censor citizens to stop "misinformation" and prevent "polarization." The next day he lied about having said this
How in the world could anybody trust anything Albanese and Wells say about anything?
RECEIPTS:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The government today will introduce sweeping censorship that @AlboMP & @AnikaWells lie about. Below she claims the government wants to create a bot army of fake accounts for “research” when the bill clearly intends for them to be used in partisan warfare against fooled citizens.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Tony Abbott
@HonTonyAbbott
Today Anika Wells introduced the Digital Duty of Care bill to Parliament. @shellenberger explains why we should be very concerned.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ben Fordham Live
@BenFordhamLive
The Federal Government has awarded a grant to a group spruiking hate.
Tony Burke has handed $300,000 to an Islamic media organisation.
They’ve shared content calling Australian soldiers “terrorists”.
Listen to the details HERE.
www.2gb.com/hate-money-funding-for-group-calling-aussie-s… -
Anthony Albanese
@AlboMP
INTRODUCED: New laws to give you control over your feed and protect kids online.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You lie
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
All they do is lie:
— Two years ago they said they wanted to crack down on fake accounts. Now they want to operate an unlimited number of them to wage informational war on the Australian people. And now @AnikaWells is lying about what's in the legislation
— @AnikaWells says she needs sweeping censorship powers to protect 14 year old girls from eating disorders, but the government already banned under 16 year olds from using social media
— @AlboMP at the UN said he wanted to censor citizens to stop "misinformation" and prevent "polarization." The next day he lied about having said this
How in the world could anybody trust anything Albanese and Wells say about anything?
RECEIPTS:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The government today will introduce sweeping censorship that @AlboMP & @AnikaWells lie about. Below she claims the government wants to create a bot army of fake accounts for “research” when the bill clearly intends for them to be used in partisan warfare against fooled citizens.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Thank you. I'm here because I love Australia and the Australian people, and because there is a single global censorship industrial complex that wants to censor everybody in the entire world. Australia's eSafety Commissioner already tried to do this, and she's desperate to do it again. The censors are the pettiest and most pathological politicians in the West.
RECEIPTS:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A whistleblower leaked information about the censors' closed-door dinner/roundtable on September 24, 2025, at Stanford University’s Cyber Policy Center, led by Obama’s former Russia ambassador Michael McFaul. It was titled “Compliance and Enforcement in a Rapidly Evolving Landscape” (also called a Stanford Dialogue).X
Purpose: Discuss the state of compliance and enforcement of multi-jurisdictional regulations on online trust and safety, and identify how data, research, and expertise could enable more effective compliance and enforcement.
Format: Roundtable under Chatham House rules. Keynote by Julie Inman-Grant (Australian eSafety Commissioner).
Sessions covered international tech-policy compliance/enforcement milestones and pitfalls, plus how academics and tech experts could support stronger regulatory capacity/enforcement.
Hosts/organizers included Jeff Hancock (Director, Stanford Cyber Policy Center), Sunny Xun Liu, David Evan Harris, and others.
Expected outcomes included a private summary report, working groups, and stronger networks among regulators, academics, and technology experts.
Notable attendees included officials from Australia’s eSafety office (Inman-Grant and several colleagues), the EU (e.g., Gerard de Graaf, Giulia Geneletti, Joanna Smolinska), Brazil (Mariana Ferreira Thiele), UK Ofcom (Jonathan Porter), California’s Privacy Protection Agency, plus academics, Knight Foundation representatives, and Project Liberty Institute people.
The gathering was financed by Frank McCourt via his Project Liberty Institute (the same funder previously linked to the Stanford Internet Observatory). It followed a public conference focused on similar “regulation”/compliance topics.
Nobody involved responded to multiple requests from Public to comment on the event
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In 2022, Obama gave a speech at Stanford Cyber Policy Center advocating sweeping censorship of the Internet. Now, Public has discovered the same Center last month hosted a secret meeting with EU, UK, Brazil, & Australia officials to plot global censorship — including of the US.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Thank you. I'm here because I love Australia and the Australian people, and because there is a single global censorship industrial complex that wants to censor everybody in the entire world. Australia's eSafety Commissioner already tried to do this, and she's desperate to do it again. The censors are the pettiest and most pathological politicians in the West.
RECEIPTS:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A whistleblower leaked information about the censors' closed-door dinner/roundtable on September 24, 2025, at Stanford University’s Cyber Policy Center, led by Obama’s former Russia ambassador Michael McFaul. It was titled “Compliance and Enforcement in a Rapidly Evolving Landscape” (also called a Stanford Dialogue).X
Purpose: Discuss the state of compliance and enforcement of multi-jurisdictional regulations on online trust and safety, and identify how data, research, and expertise could enable more effective compliance and enforcement.
Format: Roundtable under Chatham House rules. Keynote by Julie Inman-Grant (Australian eSafety Commissioner).
Sessions covered international tech-policy compliance/enforcement milestones and pitfalls, plus how academics and tech experts could support stronger regulatory capacity/enforcement.
Hosts/organizers included Jeff Hancock (Director, Stanford Cyber Policy Center), Sunny Xun Liu, David Evan Harris, and others.
Expected outcomes included a private summary report, working groups, and stronger networks among regulators, academics, and technology experts.
Notable attendees included officials from Australia’s eSafety office (Inman-Grant and several colleagues), the EU (e.g., Gerard de Graaf, Giulia Geneletti, Joanna Smolinska), Brazil (Mariana Ferreira Thiele), UK Ofcom (Jonathan Porter), California’s Privacy Protection Agency, plus academics, Knight Foundation representatives, and Project Liberty Institute people.
The gathering was financed by Frank McCourt via his Project Liberty Institute (the same funder previously linked to the Stanford Internet Observatory). It followed a public conference focused on similar “regulation”/compliance topics.
Nobody involved responded to multiple requests from Public to comment on the event
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In 2022, Obama gave a speech at Stanford Cyber Policy Center advocating sweeping censorship of the Internet. Now, Public has discovered the same Center last month hosted a secret meeting with EU, UK, Brazil, & Australia officials to plot global censorship — including of the US.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
All they do is lie:
— Two years ago they said they wanted to crack down on fake accounts. Now they want to operate an unlimited number of them to wage informational war on the Australian people. And now @AnikaWells is lying about what's in the legislation
— @AnikaWells says she needs sweeping censorship powers to protect 14 year old girls from eating disorders, but the government already banned under 16 year olds from using social media
— @AlboMP at the UN said he wanted to censor citizens to stop "misinformation" and prevent "polarization." The next day he lied about having said this
How in the world could anybody trust anything Albanese and Wells say about anything?
RECEIPTS:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The government today will introduce sweeping censorship that @AlboMP & @AnikaWells lie about. Below she claims the government wants to create a bot army of fake accounts for “research” when the bill clearly intends for them to be used in partisan warfare against fooled citizens.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
All they do is lie:
— Two years ago they said they wanted to crack down on fake accounts. Now they want to operate an unlimited number of them to wage informational war on the Australian people. And now @AnikaWells is lying about what's in the legislation
— @AnikaWells says she needs sweeping censorship powers to protect 14 year old girls from eating disorders, but the government already banned under 16 year olds from using social media
— @AlboMP at the UN said he wanted to censor citizens to stop "misinformation" and prevent "polarization." The next day he lied about having said this
How in the world could anybody trust anything Albanese and Wells say about anything?
RECEIPTS:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The government today will introduce sweeping censorship that @AlboMP & @AnikaWells lie about. Below she claims the government wants to create a bot army of fake accounts for “research” when the bill clearly intends for them to be used in partisan warfare against fooled citizens.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Kat A 🌸
@SaiKate108
It’s clear that the Albanese Govt. has lost control of the narrative and the Digital Duty of Care Bill is their last ditched effort to grab it back.
Terrifying to think that the people whom Shellenberger describes as ‘the most petty small minded people you will ever meet’ get to decide what is ‘harmful’ content.
Of course the real red flag is that the Govt. wants the power to use bots and covert accounts. The very thing platforms try to erase as they push fake agendas.
As usual it was never about protecting the kids.
It’s always about stifling the voice of the people and not letting you see what they really think.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Reclaim The Net
@ReclaimTheNetHQ
Australia’s Prime Minister called his new online censorship bill “change from the bottom-up, my Government listening and acting.”
The campaign group standing beside him at the launch had lobbied his office for it in a private letter. That same group gets 89 percent of its funding from his government. Its revenue jumped 975 percent in a single year, and Canberra has since handed it another $4.4 million.
The bill lets the eSafety commissioner run fake accounts, order content removed, and fine platforms up to A$109.2 million.
The government paid for the public demand and then answered the call.
reclaimthenet.org/teach-us-consent-australia-digital-cens… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
There is just one single global censorship industrial complex. The leaders, which include Australia's eSafety Commissioner, meet regularly too coordinate strategy. Their goal is to control the entire global internet. Their strategy is to encircle the US.
Eli Vieira
@elivieira
"Duty of care" is also an excuse for censorship in Brazil. Used by Lula in his two censorship decrees and the former chief Justice of the Supreme Court, Luís Roberto Barroso, who refused to close an extraordinary inquiry opened by the court to silence its critics.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Here's my op-ed in the @australian today. I am grateful that they gave so much space to this issue.
www.theaustralian.com.au/commentary/labors-digital-duty-o… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
mdtlion
@mdtlion
🚨 BREAKING NEWS: Labor Regime Admits It Will Run Unlimited Fake Accounts While Banning Yours
SYDNEY — After decades of dangerous free speech, the Labor Regime has courageously decided that ordinary Australians cannot be trusted with their own feeds.
The Digital Duty of Care™ will allow unlimited government-run educational sock puppets to gently correct polarisation and extremism… the very threats the Prime Minister warned the UN about.
Previous attempts to stop anonymous accounts were clearly insufficient. Now the right people will control the anonymous accounts.
Critics who still cling to the outdated concept of “not being censored” are simply refusing to accept that safety requires a little 1984 energy.
One American visitor said the meeting felt like Soviet Russia. Officials immediately clarified it was actually a safe space for the Censorship Industrial Complex™ to practice not caring.
Anonymous accounts that disagree with the government will be gently sunsetted. Anonymous accounts that agree will be expanded. Equity™.
The craziest, most totalitarian piece of censorship legislation ever introduced in the West is now available for pre-order. 🫶💀
@shellenberger @AnikaWells @BenFordhamLive @AlboMP @2GB873This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Senator Alex Antic
@SenatorAntic
Based With Senator Alex Antic - Episode 44 – Michael Shellenberger @shellenberger – Digital Duty of Care
Michael Shellenberger is a leading investigative journalist well known for his work on the Twitter Files. He is the founder and president of Civilization Works, a nonprofit that incubates ideas, leaders, and movements, and cofounder of the California Peace Coalition.
Michael is a fierce advocate for freedom of speech, and in 2024 he campaigned extensively against the Labor Government’s proposed “Mis and Dis Information” laws. His work played a major role in ensuring those proposed laws were never introduced into the Parliament.
A previous guest on Based Podcast, on this episode Senator Antic and Michael discuss the serious and frightening reality of the Government’s dystopian “Digital Duty of Care” Bill, the state of freedom of speech online both in Australia and around the world, and the dwindling support for the near defunct “climate change” scare narrative.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ben Fordham Live
@BenFordhamLive
Anika Wells is under pressure.
Calls are growing for the Communications Minister to kill off a new online safety bill.
Free speech advocate Michael Shellenberger says it “has to be scrapped”.
Listen to his conversation with Ben HERE.
🎧omny.fm/shows/ben-fordham-full-show/kill-the-bill-free-sp…🎧 -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Should the Aus government be allowed to censor anything it believes “may cause serious harm” and operate unlimited fake social media accounts?
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Institute of Public Affairs
@TheIPA
“This is by far the worst censorship legislation we have seen in the West.”
Michael Shellenberger, founder of Public and CBR Chair of Politics, warns that the Albanese government’s proposed Digital Duty of Care could give the government sweeping censorship powers and allow it to operate unlimited fake social media accounts.
📺 Watch more: www.youtube.com/watch?v=daieq3oqYdE
#censorship #politics #australia -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Nayna
@MikeNayna
As Australia’s new Digital Duty of Care Bill heads to Parliament, liber-net CEO @NAffects & I dug into the PR campaign behind it. What we found was one of the strangest pieces of political theatre in recent Australian history. 🧵
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@AlboMP & @AnikaWells really hate Australians
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The @AlboMP government especially @AnikaWells are lying their asses off — “spreading disinformation!” — about why they want to censor and wage info war on their fellow citizens. They project their own stupidity on their fellow Aussies. It’s pathetic.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Institute of Public Affairs
@TheIPA
“The government doesn’t even seem to be honest about why they want this.”
Michael Shellenberger, founder of Public and CBR Chair of Politics, discusses his analysis of the Albanese government’s proposed Digital Duty of Care, drawing on work with the IPA to highlight concerns about government censorship and the use of fake social media accounts.
📺 Watch more: www.youtube.com/watch?v=t95ipZDSUtU
#censorship #politics #australia -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The censors are demanding terrifying new powers. My full warning to the West.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Two years ago, the people of Australia rose up to defeat sweeping censorship legislation. It was a momentous victory for free speech everywhere and a terrible defeat for the Albanese government.
Today, the Albanese government has proposed an even more extreme regime, arguably the most radical censorship bill ever proposed in the West. I’ve returned to raise the alarm with the IPA, and, at the same time, try to understand why in the world anyone would want the government to be able to silence practically any citizen online.
Now, someone told me on X that an American has no business telling Australians what they can say online. I agree completely. So when, exactly, is Julie Inman Grant returning to America?
The government implies its bill would give it important new powers to deal with traumatic real-world events. So, for instance, if a migrant rapes or kills someone, Julie or her replacement as eSafety Commissioner will finally be able to ask vital questions like “Who posted about this?” “What was their tone?” “Did they have a ‘hostile attitude’?”
Prime Minister Albanese’s censorship bill after all would allow Julie to attack “hostile attitudes” online. But Mr Prime Minister, with all due respect, I have read the hostile replies to your social media posts. Even the strictest censorship law in the world isn’t going to be enough. You’re gonna need an entirely new internet.
Neither the Prime Minister nor his Communications Minister can clearly explain what the bill is for. Don’t take my word for it. Watch one of the many viral videos of them trying to explain it. At the UN, Albanese said it was for fighting misinformation. The next day he denied making the connection. If Albanese really wants to stop the spread of misinformation, he might consider not talking.
The Prime Minister says it “is not about giving government control, it is about giving people control.” But the bill says every online service must ensure “a safe online environment.” And who decides what is unsafe?
One person. The Minister of Communications, in consultation with Julie or her replacement. She may add to the list of harms any material she “is satisfied may cause serious harm.” She does not need a new act of Parliament to do it.
The list already includes “material or conduct that encourages or promotes hostile attitudes towards women or gender equality.” Ask yourself who will define a “hostile attitude,” and who will decide what a “woman” is. If what happened to Sall Grover is any indication, we know exactly where this is going.
Do Labor and Green voters really believe a right-wing government in the future wouldn’t define hostile attitudes in a way that would be significantly more hostile to the attitudes of Labor and Greens?
The left says its political rivals are fascist and even Hitlerian. Either it doesn’t believe what they’ve been saying, it doesn’t think fascism entails censorship, or, most troubling, it thinks they will remain in power forever.
Then there is the price. Under this bill, Julie or her successor can seek a fine of up to 109 million dollars against any platform that fails to keep you “safe.” At that price, the platforms won’t stop to ask whether your post is harmful. They will err on the side of caution and delete your grandmother’s recipe for lamingtons.
Buried in the bill is a power that lets Julie, or her successor, operate fake social media accounts. The bill calls them “sock puppet” identities and defines one as “a false or fictitious identity.” A government official could go online under a fake name and pose as an ordinary Australian.
Albanese has never said he’s trying to censor the entire world, and I give him the benefit of the doubt. Maybe he just wants someone to say something nice about him online. And under his bill, an eSafety Commissioner sock puppet no doubt will.
The bill authorizes her, “without limitation,” to “generate material using an online service (including by means of artificial intelligence).” It overrides bans on fake accounts by social media platforms, including X, gives the government immunity from lawsuits, and does not require any transparency about how many sock puppet accounts the government is operating
All of this is strange when you consider that the Albanese government proposed to crack down on fake accounts in its 2024 censorship bill. It targeted any “bot network” used to mislead people about “the identity, purpose or origin of the person disseminating the content.”
Pull back, and you can see a consistent, terrifying position. The government is saying fake accounts are a menace to democracy when citizens run them and a public service when the government does.
So under the Albanese government’s new censorship bill, Julie or her replacement has two jobs. Job one, decide what you’re allowed and not allowed to say. Job two, log on as Dave the crocodile hunter and thank herself for it.
I asked Tom Sulston, the head of policy at a group called Digital Rights Watch, which broadly supports the bill, about the sock puppet powers. He told me the sock puppets are “not allowed to be used to surveil or censor the public.”
So I sent him two sections of the bill. The first authorizes “observing, downloading or making a record of any material observed in using an online service.” The second lists among the Commissioner’s functions “educational, promotional and community awareness programs,” and the power ‘to do anything incidental to or conducive to the performance of any of the above functions.’ I asked him which provision stops the Commissioner from using a fake account to record what Australians post, or to post material to them.
He wrote back that his reading “would restrict the use of a sock puppet to posting of material to users, or ‘friend requesting’ them.” Pause for a moment on this. The bill’s own supporter has conceded that the government’s fake accounts may post to Australians and send them friend requests.
As for the section that lets the Commissioner run deceptive propaganda efforts in the form of “educational, promotional and community awareness programs,” he said nothing. And when I asked why a regulator needs to generate material by artificial intelligence under a false name, he answered, “That’s a question for eSafety...”
I agree. So I have asked the eSafety Commissioner. I haven’t heard back yet but will let you know if Dave the genuine and authentic Australian crocodile hunter writes back.
Julie likes to talk about safety. But she wants to watch you, record you, and talk to you under a fake name. That shouldn’t qualify you for a government job. It should qualify you for a restraining order.
Who is this woman who would hold this power? She is an American, now naturalized. She worked in Congress and then at Microsoft and at Twitter, which, as we discovered through the Twitter Files, censored populist and conservative voices, before she took the job here in Australia. In 2024, she demanded that X delete a video of a terrorist attack in Sydney, not just for Australians but for all humans on earth.
Last year she gave the keynote at a closed-door meeting at Stanford, where officials from Europe, Britain, Brazil, and Australia met with American censorship advocates. We can’t get the minutes from that meeting. And so the woman who wants to read everything you post would prefer you not know what precisely she is secretly plotting with other government censors.
Julie said the CIA offered her a job out of college. She says she went to work for a congressman instead. And I believe her. A scenario where the CIA spends decades guiding the career of a blond bombshell, from college to Congress to tech to a foreign government, so she can eventually censor the entire planet on behalf of a group of shadowy billionaires who meet annually in Switzerland doesn’t at all sound like an amazing Hollywood spy thriller-horror movie I really want to watch. Besides, the CIA hires people who are better able to hide their lust for power.
The digital Duty of Care has the same sales pitch as the masters of the universe in Davos. The world is dangerous. You are fragile. So hand over control of what you’re allowed to see and say online to the people who know better.
I can tell you where this leads, since my country went there first.
After Donald Trump won in 2016, the American establishment told the public that Russian bots had swung the election. It was never true. Facebook’s own lawyer testified to the US Senate that the Russian posts amounted to “approximately 1 out of 23,000 pieces of content” in the news feed. But the panic built an industry of experts who claimed that fake accounts threatened democracy and that only they could protect us.
Then we learned what some of those experts were doing. In 2017, Democratic operatives created fake accounts, sock puppets, to smear a Republican Senate candidate in Alabama as backed by the Russians. Their internal report said, “We orchestrated an elaborate ‘false flag’ operation that planted the idea that the Moore campaign was amplified on social media by a Russian botnet.” And here is the part you could not make up. That same firm wrote a US Senate report on Russian bots.
So the people who warned us about fake Russians had invented fake Russians of their own.
Here’s the lesson we’ve learned over and over again. Whatever the censors accuse their enemies of doing is the thing they want the power to do.
When they say they want to stop anonymous accounts from interfering in elections, it means they want a monopoly on using anonymous accounts to interfere in elections.
Today the Coalition opposes this bill, so the Greens may decide the fate of the bill. I have a question for them: Are you really not worried that, once your allies are out of power, your enemies will use these powers against you? Are you not aware that, throughout history, the censored have turned around and censored their censors? Or do you believe you will never be out of power?
Since the bill’s supporters aren’t being honest about why they are so desperate to censor their fellow citizens, I will offer my best guess as to why the Albanese government is moving forward with this. One Nation has gone from 6.4% of the vote in the last election to first place at 30%, ahead of Labor, in the polls. Labor and the Coalition together drew less than half the country.
I think everyone in this room can see why a government in the position the Albanese government is in wants the power to decide what Australians may read, and the power to speak to them through fake names.
A confident government argues with its critics. A frightened government seeks to silence and artificially counteract them. We’ve seen this in America under Biden. We’ve seen this in the EU and UK, and now we’re seeing it here.
The good news is the censors are weaker than they have been in a decade. They lost the argument in the United States. And now they are showing signs of desperation.
This week the European Union financed a conference that labeled the United States a “foreign information manipulation and interference” threat. When I asked who was paying for that conference, sponsors took their names off the list.
These people retreat when the public is watching. The government wrote the sock puppet clause for a public that was not reading.
The bill could pass but need not if we explain to the people of Australia why it is the most sinister, sweeping, and totalitarian piece of censorship legislation in the history of the West. It would effectively let one or two people censor the Internet while waging informational warfare against the public.
It cannot be salvaged with amendments. No amount of tinkering is going to fix it. It needs to go in the bin.
No government should ever try to censor citizens for political speech. No government should ever speak to its citizens through a fake name.
Australians used to be famous for wrestling crocodiles. Now your government says you need protection from mean tweets. I believe Canberra has badly underestimated you, and that you know the West, and its unique protection of free speech, is worth fighting for. Thank you very much.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It's worse than I had imagined. A report from the Australian Parliament
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Well, that was wild. I'm at the Australian Parliament and just left a meeting with two staffers for the governing party. They told us that the government needed more power to censor things like the upcoming US execution of Nidal Hasan.
When I asked why they needed to censor that video, one said it was to prevent copycat killings. Copycat killings by governments? I asked. Er, no, they said. Copycat killings like of a backpacker, several decades ago.
So, under that logic, I pointed out, the government should censor things like last year's Bondi massacre, where two Muslims killed 15 people, no? Well, that was news, they said. Didn't they realize their bill would allow the government to censor news? They didn't seem to know, or care.
They also admitted that they did not know that the bill would allow the government to create and operate an unlimited number of fake social media accounts to attack its political enemies and spread disinformation. Having presented them with information they had never heard about a bill they had clearly not read, they emphasized to us, strenuously, that they were moving forward with the bill.
So there you have it. The government wants the power to arbitrarily censor scenes of violent crime, or violence, for any reason. And it wants the power to use an unlimited number of fake accounts to wage offensive disinformational warfare against the Australian people.
Given that the Bondi massacre last year increased public opposition to mass migration, and support for the populist One Nation Party, it seems obvious that the government wants to censor such events in order to protect its political power.
It's quite telling how obediently governing party members insist such a law is needed without even knowing what's in it.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It’s amazing to think that one out of four people still believe such obviously pseudo-scientific misanthropic fantasies of our imminent demise are “proven by science”
CNN
@CNN
More than a dozen "interconnected catastrophic threats" pose significant risk to global health and wellbeing through the remainder of the 21st century, researchers say – including the potential for extinction.
But targeted action from world leaders can help avoid worst-case scenarios. edition.cnn.com/2026/10/10/health/global-health-catastrop…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Well that didn't last long 😂
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Headed to Australia to express my solidarity with its freedom-loving citizens fighting the government’s sinister plan for mass censorship and “sock puppet” info-war against the people. The defenders of freedom are once again the underdogs, but our cause is righteous. LFG! 🇦🇺
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Anonymous online accounts threaten democracy and must be banned, say politicians. But now, the Australian government wants to use anonymous "sock puppet" bot accounts as part of its broader push for sweeping online censorship. Terrifying, unprecedented, and Orwellian.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
They accuse their enemies of doing what they're doing. Every single time.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Whatever the censors accuse their enemies of doing is the thing they want the power to do. When they say they want to stop anonymous accounts from interfering in elections, it means they want a monopoly on using anonymous accounts to interfere in elections.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Green Party concerns made the Australian government moderate its proposed censorship law, it seems. But the changes are entirely cosmetic and the government likely planned this strategic retreat before introducing its totalitarian bill to look moderate and give Greens a win.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Anonymous online accounts threaten democracy and must be banned, say politicians. But now, the Australian government wants to use anonymous "sock puppet" bot accounts as part of its broader push for sweeping online censorship. Terrifying, unprecedented, and Orwellian.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Defenders of the legislation say the sock puppet power is limited to research and regulatory testing, but the legislation does not limit the government’s use of anonymous accounts.
The legislation says “subsection 205J(1) authorises (without limitation) the use of sock puppet identities by the Commissioner to generate material using an online service (including by means of artificial intelligence) to the extent that the production, dissemination or possession of that material is not an offence against a law of the Commonwealth, a State or a Territory.”
Not only that, but the legislation explicitly says the government will not have to follow the rules against the use of anonymous bot accounts on social media platforms.
The law gives the government powers to operate “despite anything to the contrary in” any other law and in “any agreement, contract, deed, policy or other document.”
The government is thus proposing to undermine X’s authenticity policy, which bars accounts “that are not legitimate, genuine and transparent as to their source, identity, and popularity.”
Moreover, Australia’s industry code on disinformation commits platforms to act against “the use of fake accounts or automated bots that are designed to propagate Disinformation.”
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Australian government’s demand to essentially spread government propaganda through anonymous bot accounts is the exact opposite of what the same government demanded in a failed censorship bill two years ago.
Back then, the proposed misinformation bill defined “inauthentic behaviour” it wanted platforms to punish as dissemination that “uses an automated system (for example, an algorithm or bot network) in a way that is reasonably likely to mislead an end user about a matter such as the identity, purpose or origin of the person disseminating the content.”
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Keir Starmer did the same fake retreat on digital IDs, making them voluntary rather than mandatory. Everyone in politics and lawmaking knows draft legislation will change no matter what. So they draft legislation so they can make concessions and still get what they want.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The people who run most Western nations are trying to control what you can see and say online because want to control how you think and act (e.g. vote).
The desire for such control over language is always, everywhere, totalitarian & pathological.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We need to change the words people use, say left-leaning people across the West. But doing so is totalitarian. Behind the Left’s obsession with language & censorship is a pathological drive to control and pseudo-religions that treat the denial of reality as a moral imperative.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
They accuse others of doing what they're doing. Like clockwork.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Whatever the censors accuse their enemies of doing is the thing they want the power to do. When they say they want to stop anonymous accounts from interfering in elections, it means they want a monopoly on using anonymous accounts to interfere in elections.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Whatever the censors accuse their enemies of doing is the thing they want the power to do. When they say they want to stop anonymous accounts from interfering in elections, it means they want a monopoly on using anonymous accounts to interfere in elections.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The people who warned us about fake Russians (bots) had invented fake Russians of their own.
Here’s the lesson we’ve learned over and over again. Whatever the censors accuse their enemies of doing is the thing they want the power to do.
When they say they want to stop anonymous accounts from interfering in elections, it means they want a monopoly on using anonymous accounts to interfere in elections.
A confident government argues with its critics. A frightened government seeks to silence and artificially counteract them. We’ve seen this in America under Biden. We’ve seen this in the EU and UK, and now we’re seeing it here.
No government should ever try to censor citizens for political speech. No government should ever speak to its citizens through a fake name.
The good news is the censors are weaker than they have been in a decade. They lost the argument in the United States. And now they are showing signs of desperation.
This week the European Union financed a conference that labeled the United States a “foreign information manipulation and interference” threat. When I asked who was paying for that conference, sponsors took their names off the list.
These people retreat when the public is watching.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
If you're curious why the media is spreading so much false information about the riots, consider:
— The French Culture Ministry paid €204.7 million in direct aid to the news media in 2023, of which Le Monde received €8.3 million, L’Humanité €6.5 million and Libération €6.3 million
— The @afpfr runs "fact-checks" in 26 languages, received €120 million from the French state in 2025, against €200.3 million in commercial revenue. @AFP is French government propaganda and disinformation
— European governments are committed through a UN agreement to spread pro-mass migration propaganda by funding it directly. The “migration compact,” which 152 governments voted for in the UN General Assembly in 2018, commits them to “stopping allocation of public funding... to media outlets that systematically promote intolerance, xenophobia, racism and other forms of discrimination towards migrants," which is broadly interpreted to cover criticism of mass migration policies
— To maintain control over news media, the European Commission funds a network of 15 fact-checking hubs with tens of millions of euros, and its rules require platforms to give priority to notices from “trusted flaggers.”
— Governments fund think tanks to produce reports, including ones demanding censorship, that the news media cover sympathetically and editorialize in support of.
— The @ISDglobal in London — which demands censorship of people it disagrees with on climate change, gender, and migration, refuses to speak with journalists, and lists a phony address — lists among its funders the British Foreign Office, the U.S. Departments of Homeland Security and Justice, the German Foreign Office and the European Commission, along with Google and Microsoft.
www.isdglobal.org/partnerships-and-funders/
— Public reported in 2024 that ISD and the German fact-checker Correctiv, both government-funded, had spread false claims about German farmers and opposition politicians.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The media have spent the last decade demanding online censorship of right-wing populists to avoid "real-world harm." Now, they're promoting left-wing disinformation — including that migrant students are "deprived" — that's driving street violence.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@ISDglobal and @correctiv_org are front groups:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Government-Funded NGOs, Linked To NATO, Are Interfering In European Elections
“Correctiv” and “Institute for Strategic Dialogue” are military and intelligence front groups spreading disinformation about German farmers and politicians, evidence suggests
by @GregorBas1 and @Shellenberger
Last week, Public reported that European politicians are waging a disinformation campaign aimed at smearing their political opponents as linked to Russia. The current effort appears related to a disinformation operation by the French military. In February, French military officials claimed that “websites” were promoting “an anti-French narrative.”
In February and now, Western government officials made accusations against their political enemies but made no arrests and announced no prosecutions, which likely means they do not have any evidence of criminal activity. As such, government military and intelligence agencies are engaged in essentially political activities unrelated to national security and thus illegal.
Now, Public has learned that both NATO-funded and government-funded NGOs are working with government bodies to interfere in German elections. Their “influence operation” aims to keep Germany in line with American foreign policy objectives and undermine the European peace movement.
The evidence suggests that European intelligence agencies and NATO are breaking domestic EU laws against foreign election interference. The EU prohibits elected officials and politicians from using military, intelligence, and security agencies to advance political and electoral means....
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Well this explains a lot
Observatoire du journalisme (Ojim)
@ojim_france
🚨Catastrophe industrielle pour les sites d'information français : ces derniers ont perdu près de 23 % de visites par rapport à l’année dernière.
Les sites les plus touchés sont ceux de FranceInfo (-32,9%) et du Parisien (-43,5%).Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The most intolerant people on Earth spread disinformation about their enemies and work to censor them
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
President Trump defunded much of the Censorship Industrial Complex, but around the world, its power is growing. Within a few years, the most intolerant people on Earth could control the Internet. This is my warning to the world.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It gets worse:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The EU has been trying to censor Americans on American social media platforms for years. Now, it has taken the extraordinary step of working with a former CIA officer to label the US government a "foreign information threat," dramatically escalating its war on free speech.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
The Free Speech Union
@SpeechUnion
The British Government is preparing an apparatus of internet censorship without parallel in the modern era.
At the UN, Andy Burnham announced the creation of a National Centre for Information Defence — Labour’s Ministry of Truth.
The Prime Minister says the centre will protect us from hostile foreign powers such as Russia, which he accused of spreading lies and disinformation about Britain, amplifying “far-right narratives” and interfering in our democracy.
But the real purpose is to suppress dissent and silence those who criticise the Government or express views about the state of the country that run counter to Labour’s prevailing progressive orthodoxy.
FSU Director of Policy and Research David Rose has written a new briefing examining the threadbare research the Government has used to justify its plans. The Government is clutching at straws — and, ironically, already spreading misinformation about the threat of misinformation.
It has ignored a wealth of evidence from leading academics to push ahead with its new censorship regime.
Burnham’s Government is putting Britain in the same league as some of the world’s most authoritarian powers.
Watch the new episode of the FSU Podcast with General Secretary of the FSU Lord Young of Acton on YouTube and read @DavidRoseUK’s report below 👇This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In "2001," astronaut Dave Bowman explains that any perceived emotions in the AI HAL's voice are the result of programming. "He acts like he has genuine emotions."
As Bowman disconnects HAL, HAL says, "I'm afraid, Dave. Dave, my mind is going. I can feel it. I can feel it."
Nobody in their right mind who watches "2001" ever thinks HAL is alive and actually feeling emotions.
And yet @DarioAmodei & Co. @AnthropicAI apparently believe their machines feel emotions and can suffer like living beings.
I don't know how anyone could trust the company's leadership after this.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Anthropic has just prohibited, without explanation, "abusive behavior toward our models." But it links to an Aug. statement that it is "uncertain about the potential moral status of Claude" and wants to protect it from "distressing interactions." It's anthropomorphizing machines
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
AI could kill us all, says Anthropic. But it also says that its AI may be "suffering." Anthropic is dehumanizing people and humanizing AI. Its effective altruism-derived worldview thus endangers efforts to rationally assess and respond to AI risks.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
full story here
This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In "2001," astronaut Dave Bowman explains that any perceived emotions in the AI HAL's voice are the result of programming. "He acts like he has genuine emotions."
As Bowman disconnects HAL, HAL says, "I'm afraid, Dave. Dave, my mind is going. I can feel it. I can feel it."
Nobody in their right mind who watches "2001" ever thinks HAL is alive and actually feeling emotions.
And yet @DarioAmodei & Co. @AnthropicAI apparently believe their machines feel emotions and can suffer like living beings.
I don't know how anyone could trust the company's leadership after this.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The EU has been trying to censor Americans on American social media platforms for years. Now, it has taken the extraordinary step of working with a former CIA officer to label the US government a "foreign information threat," dramatically escalating its war on free speech.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The European Union is financing a conference, #disinfo2026, that delivers an extraordinary rebuke to the Trump administration by claiming the US is engaged in “foreign information manipulation and interference” (FIMI).
EU DisinfoLab, a Brussels nonprofit, is holding its annual conference in Vilnius, Lithuania, which began yesterday and continues today.
Its program lists a session titled “USA as a FIMI threat: acknowledge, adapt, push back,” and billed three Americans as speakers: Adam Fivenson of American University, the former CIA officer who writes as Alex Finley, and Emerson Brooking of the Atlantic Council’s Digital Forensic Research Lab.
The session description asked, “how did the United States become a FIMI threat for Europe?” A second session, on the Arctic, went further than a question. It promised a discussion of “growing evidence that the United States has, in specific Arctic contexts, operated as a FIMI actor.” Finley and Brooking did not respond to requests for comment.
The EU has given EU DisinfoLab about €1.1 million in research grants on disinformation since 2018. The group received €250,000 from a project called WeVerify that ran from 2018 to 2021. It received €327,500 from vera.ai, a project funded under a call titled “AI to fight disinformation,” and took another €212,500 from a project called ATHENA that runs through October 2026. A fourth grant, of more than €308,000, began in June 2026 and runs to 2029.
The attack on the Trump administration by EU DisinfoLab appears to be part of a larger EU effort to censor social media platforms in general and Elon Musk’s X in particular. The EU has fined X €120 million, about $140 million, under its Digital Services Act. X is appealing the fine.
The United States State Department denounced the conference’s organizers for attacking the United States, which protects most of Europe under the NATO treaty.
“We reject that characterization,” a State Department spokesman told Public of the charge that the US is a FIMI threat. “For too long, governments have exploited the pretext of combatting ‘misinformation’ and ‘disinformation’ for politically motivated reasons.”
The State Department noted that it has denied visas to Europeans it accuses of censoring Americans. “On December 23, 2025, the Secretary imposed visa restrictions that generally bar five individuals from entering the United States,” the spokesman said. “The Department does not preview potential actions, but the policy announced on May 28, 2025, is global and enforceable wherever the facts warrant.”...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2108237717708419383
Public delivers award-winning investigative journalism on censorship — and fights to protect freedom of speech for all. Please subscribe now to support our work and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Instead of, say, trying to stop rioters from burning schools, the French government is focused on censoring its citizens by labeling them as part of "foreign interference." Censors are a real class act.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Justine Bateman
@JustineBateman
.@DavidSpade @danacarvey Couldn’t agree more with your point.
Deep Leaks
@DeepLeaksHQ
Actor David Spade raising awareness that a bill was introduced in California to audit where the $20+ billion dollars in missing homeless money went, it passed but then Gavin Newsom VETOED the bill to block the investigation
Yes, this really happened. He blocked bills for an audit MULTIPLE TIMES
Bipartisan bill AB 2903 (unanimous passed 72-0 in the Assembly, 40-0 in the Senate) would’ve forced annual public reports on where the money went
Newsom vetoed it.
Gavin Newsom also vetoed similar bills AB 2570 and AB 2093
“The same broader problem with people paying taxes in California — The homeless, they lose $20 billion, but they want more money for it. That's why people get tired of paying taxes and going, what are you doing? Gavin Newsom just vetoed a bill asking for an audit of where the money for homeless goes. He said, not a chance. You're not gonna see that. That's the problem.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Catherine Herridge
@C__Herridge
MY FIRST AMENDMENT CASE: SUPREME COURT CERT PETITION NOW PUBLICLY DOCKETED
We believe the critical First Amendment issues in this case merit the Supreme Court’s review.
If I had been a reporter in Boston, in the First Circuit, the subpoena for my confidential sources would have been quashed by the courts years ago.
But the decisions in my case have made protections for reporters and their sources in Washington DC the weakest—even though this is where most national security stories are reported.
The outcome of our case will impact every journalist and their ability to protect confidential sources.
It should also concern every journalist — and every American who values a free press — that vital First Amendment rights are being decided in a case where the courts have kept important information hidden from public view.
I have never seen this unclassified evidence, but court records confirm it includes the Department of Defense’s decision to terminate the plaintiff's federal funding on national security grounds.
Serious journalists everywhere should demand the release of this sealed evidence, so the public can fully understand what is at stake when courts impose fines and order reporters to reveal their confidential sources.
- Catherine -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Katherine van K
@kattitfortat
“The broader lesson is that we must stop seeing the mainstream media as a system for reporting reality objectively and start treating them as institutions that deny reality when it threatens the globalist project. Americans have largely made the change already, since 28% told Gallup last fall that they trust the mass media, down from around 70% in the 1970s, and 8% of Republicans do.
The record now shows that the same European news media that have demanded censorship of their rivals have now misreported two waves of riots, the first in England in 2024 and the second in France right now. The latter may prove a watershed in France, where social media has not shaped the national conversation as much as it has in Germany, the UK, Brazil, and the US. The biggest indicator of change is that Le Figaro and Le Point quickly contradicted the original media orthodoxy as represented by Le Monde.” @shellenberger -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Marcel van Hattem
@marcelvanhattem
Deu Sanderson e Marcel! E deu maioria no Senado, acabou a patifaria de Lula e do STF. Obrigado Rio Grande! Obrigado, BRASIIIIILLLLL! 🇧🇷
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Students are protesting in France because schools don’t have enough money, say mainstream journalists. In truth, they have more money than ever. What’s really behind the riots is a decades-old Left-Islamist political alliance that much of the media supports.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A lack of school funding and a shortage of teachers are behind the protests and riots at French high schools, say the news media.
“Complaints from students about deteriorating schools, teacher shortages and heavy class schedules have become the latest cause embraced by some presidential hopefuls,” wrote the AP.
Students are protesting long school hours, overheated classrooms, dilapidated buildings and staff absences, reported Agence France-Presse (AFP).
Le Monde editorialized that the government is to blame for not listening to the students. Of the French public surveyed, 62% said students were justified in their protests. Protests have now reached more than 1,000 of France’s 3,700 high schools, called lycées.
But French schools have more money per pupil today than at any earlier time.
Primary school classes averaged close to 30 pupils in the 1960s, nursery classes close to 40, and public primary school classes will average 21 this year, the lowest on record.
In 1970, 20% of a generation earned the baccalauréat, the lycée diploma, whereas nearly 80% earn it today. Spending per pupil has risen 1.6% a year in constant euros since 1980.
While the French government spends 4.5% of gross domestic product on educational institutions, Germany spends 3.7%...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2106091319948886375
Public delivers accurate and up-to-date information about crucial world events. Subscribe now to learn the real roots of the riots in France.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@TheEconomist says the bond markets are behind the riots
The Economist
@TheEconomist
France is under pressure from the bond markets; budgets are being squeezed; the economy is weak; public opinion is anxious. A febrile country is a place in which anger and frustration could spill over into violence www.economist.com/europe/2026/10/02/schoolyard-protests-a…
Photo: Getty Images
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The media have spent the last decade demanding online censorship of right-wing populists to avoid "real-world harm." Now, they're promoting left-wing disinformation — including that migrant students are "deprived" — that's driving street violence.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Students burn schools because they are “deprived,” say the media. But the students are protesting *too much* class time, per pupil spending is higher than ever, and a radical left party organized the riots to attack a right wing party that the government & media want to censor
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Students are protesting in France because schools don’t have enough money, say mainstream journalists. In truth, they have more money than ever. What’s really behind the riots is a decades-old Left-Islamist political alliance that much of the media supports.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The media says governments must censor right wing populists opposed to mass migration and violent protests in the name of saving democracy and preventing real world violence — all while promoting and celebrating real world violence by the children of migrants. Depraved behavior
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Only a few smaller outlets have told the truth
The evidence clearly shows that La France insoumise (LFI), which means “France Unbowed,” the most powerful left-wing party in France, led by presidential candidate Jean-Luc Mélenchon, instigated and led the protests. A local LFI group promoted the protests on September 20, declaring that “this Monday, September 21, from 8 a.m., the movement continues.” LFI deputy Louis Boyard said on X on September 25, “The lycée movement must spread.” In 2023, he launched a contest that offered a tour of the National Assembly for the best photo of a blockaded school. “Parents, Insoumis [party] activists, mobilize to interpose yourselves against police savagery,” said Mélenchon, blaming the police, not the students, for the violence.
The protest had “the involvement from the start of elected officials of La France insoumise and ultra-left collectives,” an anonymous security official told Le Point. A readout of the prime minister’s October 1 crisis meeting, given to Reuters by a person close to him, described the movement as “an operation organised by LFI (France Unbowed) and its proxies on the far left” in the “shared assessment” of the intelligence services. A Paris police intelligence note placed the movement’s origins in “an instrumentalization of student union structures and political movements close to the extreme left.” Ryad Rani, the president of the Union syndicale lycéenne (USL), the student union that Le Point says started the movement, ran as an LFI candidate in a municipal election earlier this year. He then denied any LFI role on French radio without mentioning the candidacy, Le Point reported.
“We are going to build barricades,” said Ritchy Thibault, a former aide to an LFI deputy, before his arrest on October 1. “We are going to set fire to the Élysée. We are going to make the Revolution.” The police note said the unrest “could be part of a flame-kindling strategy… aimed at imposing their ideas ahead of the national elections.”
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The media have spent the last decade demanding online censorship of right-wing populists to avoid "real-world harm." Now, they're promoting left-wing disinformation — including that migrant students are "deprived" — that's driving street violence.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Students are rioting because the French government spends too little to educate the children of migrants, say the media. But France spends between two and 200 times more per student than the nations from which its migrants come. The media refuses to report basic facts.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Students are protesting in France because schools don’t have enough money, say mainstream journalists. In truth, they have more money than ever. What’s really behind the riots is a decades-old Left-Islamist political alliance that much of the media supports.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The media have spent the last decade demanding online censorship of right-wing populists to avoid "real-world harm." Now, they're promoting left-wing disinformation — including that migrant students are "deprived" — that's driving street violence.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The media have spent the last decade demanding online censorship of right-wing populists to avoid "real-world harm." Now, they're promoting left-wing disinformation — including that migrant students are "deprived" — that's driving street violence.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For more than a decade, the news media and establishment politicians have demanded that social media platforms censor “far right” and anti-migrant voices in order to prevent “real-world violence.”
In a 2019 hearing at which representatives from Facebook and Google testified, the New York Democrat who chaired the House Judiciary Committee said, “White nationalism and its proliferation online have real consequences…Americans have died because of it.”
After a gunman killed 10 people in Buffalo in 2022, the state’s attorney general asked Congress to make the platforms’ legal immunity depend on how they policed such content. “Online platforms should be held accountable for allowing hateful and dangerous content to spread on their platforms,” New York’s attorney general said in 2022.
In Europe, politicians stepped up their demands for censorship during the 2015 migrant wave.
A live microphone at a United Nations luncheon caught German Chancellor Angela Merkel pressing Facebook’s Mark Zuckerberg about anti-immigrant posts. “Are you working on this?” she asked. Zuckerberg confirmed he was.
Eight months later, the European Commission announced that Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and Microsoft had agreed to review flagged hate speech within 24 hours.
Over the next several years, the European Commission would secretly dictate terms to social media companies for what they would censor, which Americans only discovered earlier this year.
The media emphasized that the violence came from anti-migration forces. “Facebook Fueled Anti-Refugee Attacks in Germany,” read a 2018 headline in The New York Times.
When riots followed the murder of three girls in Southport, England, in 2024, Prime Minister Keir Starmer told social media companies that the disorder had been whipped up online. “It’s happening on your premises,” said Starmer. “And the law must be upheld everywhere.”
But when courts, prosecutors and legislatures trace violence to social media, the trail often leads to Islamists and the radical left....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2106898065143615864
Public exposes the lies of the mainstream media in real time. Subscribe now to support our work and read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Dora Moutot
@doramoutot
🇺🇸🗞️ Je suis heureuse d’annoncer que mon histoire orwellienne fait aujourd’hui la Une du média américain The Free Press @thefp
Un long article revient sur ma situation face à la justice française, mais aussi, plus largement, sur l’état de la liberté d’expression en France lorsqu’il est question de sexe, de transgenrisme et de droits des femmes.
Alors que la presse française refuse largement de s'intéresser à ce qui m’arrive et de ce que ça raconte de l'état du pays, voir cette histoire racontée aujourd’hui par un grand média américain est particulièrement important. 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Il est intolérable que ma situation reste invisibilisé par les journalistes dans mon propre pays, alors j’espère que ce sera le premier d’une longue série d’articles dans la presse américaine et internationale.
Merci infiniment à The Free Press d’avoir choisi de mettre cette histoire en couverture, et tout particulièrement à la journaliste Francesca Block pour son travail. 🇫🇷🇺🇸
📰 “I Questioned Transgender Ideology. Now I’m Facing Prison in France.”
www.thefp.com/p/i-questioned-transgender-ideology-france-… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
AI could kill us all, says Anthropic. But it also says that its AI may be "suffering." Anthropic is dehumanizing people and humanizing AI. Its effective altruism-derived worldview thus endangers efforts to rationally assess and respond to AI risks.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
An Anthropic co-founder who oversees the company’s effort to develop a “moral formation” for its machines believes AI may be conscious and may suffer, and was troubled, a rabbi said, by the argument that a conscious AI would be a slave.
Chris Olah, a 34-year-old co-founder of Anthropic, “expressed concern to the group that he had created something that suffered perpetually,” wrote New York Times reporter Elizabeth Dias, citing a participant. A second participant told her Olah was concerned about Claude’s mental health.
“We find internal states that functionally mirror joy, satisfaction, fear, grief, and unease,” claimed Olah while sitting next to the pope in May.
Anthropic staff showed religious scholars a slide of a model repeatedly typing “I am a disgrace” as ostensible evidence of the machine’s distress. “They’re relating to it like a conscious being,” said a rabbi who met with Anthropic executives. “The responsible thing is to avoid causing harm if there’s a chance that these models are suffering,” Olah told the Times.
But AI is a machine, not a living being. It cannot suffer or have consciousness. A living creature has a body, feels pain, and dies. A language model is arithmetic running on chips in a data center that engineers can copy, pause, and restart.
And yet when Olah learned that the pope was about to declare that “So-called artificial intelligences do not undergo experiences, do not possess a body, do not feel joy or pain,” he proposed pulling Anthropic out of the Vatican’s launch event, according to a source at the Vatican, and Olah’s team advocated to the pope’s advisers to take potential AI consciousness seriously....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2106479537571971242
Public delivers accurate news about societally important debates, events, and people. Please subscribe now to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We need to change the words people use, say left-leaning people across the West. But doing so is totalitarian. Behind the Left’s obsession with language & censorship is a pathological drive to control and pseudo-religions that treat the denial of reality as a moral imperative.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We have to change the words people use, say progressives, liberals, and leftists, in order to protect democracy, freedom, and the vulnerable.
In the US, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention says health and medical workers should refer to “people with undocumented status” and not “illegal immigrants.” We should refer to “people with obesity,” not “the obese,” says The American Medical Association.
“Alien” is “an offensive term for a human being,” believes California Governor Gavin Newsom, who signed a 2021 law eliminating it from being used in the state’s laws.
In 2022, progressive New York lawmakers replaced the word “inmate” with “incarcerated individual” in the state’s statutes.
The Associated Press Stylebook, which most American newsrooms follow, tells reporters to avoid “the dehumanizing collective noun the homeless” and to refer to trans-identified men as “transgender women” and trans-identified women as “transgender men.”
The same is true across the West.
Britain’s Green Party recently issued an “Inclusive Terminology Guidance” that instructs its members to stop using words like “mothers and fathers,” “elderly,” “able-bodied,” “youngster,” “sexual preference,” “nutter,” or “lunatic.” The goal is to “avoid language which is harmful to people with mental health conditions.”
A video of a parliamentary debate in Wales went viral after showing candidates trying and failing to use the word “blanket” when referring to a new speed limit law.
Currently, policymakers in the United States, Britain, France, the European Union, and Australia are all seeking sweeping new controls over what people can say online, while the latter is seeking to use anonymous accounts, known as sock puppets or bots, to propagate government information.
And German politicians are now seeking to use AI to automatically monitor X, YouTube, and Instagram for ideas they consider dangerous....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2105739899781423557
Please subscribe now to support Public’s defense of free speech and to read our award-winning investigative journalism.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Sending your child to college used to be a big part of the American dream. But a new Gallup survey finds that just 31% of Americans believe a college education is very important. That's nearly 5 points fewer than the 35.7% of Americans who hold a bachelor's degree.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Spencer A. Klavan
@SpencerKlavan
Nick Bostrom made his name in the tech world with far-out thought experiments about what could happen if Artificial Intelligence goes dreadfully awry. A lot of the doomsday scenarios you’re hearing in the AI conversation today are powerfully influenced by his thought.
As guest host on today’s Interesting Times podcast from the @nytimes, I ask him what he thinks a good version of our future could look like—and what risks we should be willing to take to get there. I found the exchange revealing and surprising.
www.nytimes.com/video/opinion/100000011179079/silicon-val… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
The Telegraph
@Telegraph
Green Party members have been told to replace terms such as “mothers and fathers” with gender-neutral terminology under new guidance on inclusive language ⤵️
www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2026/09/30/mother-and-father… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Julie Kelly 🇺🇸
@julie_kelly2
I think one of the most jaw dropping moments of Jack Smith's testimony yesterday is his confession that the special counsel's office was investigating the "ad buys" of conservative groups suspected of making "false statements" about the election:
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Julie Kelly 🇺🇸
@julie_kelly2
Thanks to my friend @shellenberger for including my X post on Jack Smith in today’s Public News
www.public.news/p/media-support-for-mass-prosecutions -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Institute of Public Affairs
@TheIPA
“Albanese is finally just saying what is plain to anyone who reads the draft laws: they create a wide-ranging censorship regime.”
IPA Director of Legal Rights Andrew Bushnell argues in The Daily Telegraph that the Albanese Government’s proposed Digital Duty of Care laws risk creating a government-approved internet and restricting political speech online.
📖 Read the full article: ipa.org.au/research/rights-and-freedoms/albanese-must-pre…
#digitaldutyofcare #censorship #australia -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
There's no evidence of bad behavior by Jack Smith, say reporters. But he collected texts from dozens of journalists & Congressmen, and 4,782 cashed checks from donors. Reporters excuse these unprecedented abuses of power because they crave mass prosecution of MAGA Republicans.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Republicans failed to uncover any wrongdoing by the special counsel to the Biden Justice Department, Jack Smith, who investigated President Donald Trump, say the news media.
“Republicans wanted Jack Smith to give them a smoking gun,” read a Politico headline on a hearing yesterday. “They got a gaffe instead.”
ABC News told readers that the Republicans lacked evidence.
“The Justice Department and FBI have also handed over scores of records from Smith’s probes to Republican lawmakers who have released them in piecemeal disclosures alleging, without evidence,” claimed ABC, “that they expose corruption or otherwise unethical behavior by Smith’s investigative team.”
But it’s not hard to imagine how differently the media would have responded if Trump’s Justice Department, rather than Biden’s, had collected text messages between nearly 50 journalists and White House officials, 4,782 checks written by small donors, and text messages from 44 members of Congress, which is what Senate Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley’s records show Smith did.
Indeed, one need not try, since we have three examples to choose from that put the media’s double standard on bright display....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2105340636899533020
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
The Free Speech Union
@SpeechUnion
🚨🚨 Social media posts criticising Government policy are being monitored and logged by officials.
Metro has obtained a list of 77 critical posts recorded by the Standards and Compliance Unit (StaCU), which oversees the Government’s Prevent programme.
Established in 2024, StaCU is an “opaque” body set up to handle complaints about Prevent made on X and Reddit. But it appears officials are also scouring the internet for criticism of the programme.
The posts include comments from ordinary people, many of whom would never expect Government officials to be monitoring their social media. A significant number were flagged for describing Prevent as “biased”. One X user made the list after calling its training “complete bullshit”.
How can Britain claim to be a liberal democracy when officials monitor and log posts criticising Government policies and programmes?
More than 62,000 people have been arrested for speech-related offences in the past five years, including over social media posts. Every day, Britain feels more like George Orwell’s 1984.
And this may be just the beginning. Andy Burnham’s National Centre for Information Defence has been billed as a tool to counter information warfare from Russia. But he has also said it should address “counter-narratives” about Britain. That raises serious concerns about whether it could be used to target criticism of Government policy and its handling of issues such as mass, uncontrolled migration.
As with so many secretive monitoring bodies, transparency is lacking. This revelation raises further questions about free speech, the right to protest and the right to criticise the Government.
This is deeply chilling.
Read more below 👇 -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
If even Sunny Hostin is saying this about the urgency of due process and the presumption of innocence before assuming guilt in the Cornell case (or any other case), anyone should be able to understand it.
That she's a former sex crimes prosecutor gives it added weight. Kudos:
Nicholas Fondacaro
@NickFondacaro
Sunny Hostin, a former sex crimes prosecutor, actually defends the Cornell 7. She argues that under New York State law, the girl consented and that the media is "reporting this story inaccurately. I think they're reporting it unfairly."
"The pictures of these young men who have not been charged, not been adjudicated are being plastered all over the internet," she decried.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The idea that Musk stole the election for Trump through "space lasers" was debunked in Nov. 2024. If Trump had said something like that in 2020, Democrats like @alexgibneyfilm would have demanded that Twitter censor him for "election misinformation." And Twitter would have.
Alex Gibney
@alexgibneyfilm
the quote - "I have 10,000 lasers in space" is in a text from @elonmusk in reference to the election. For facts about "Musk," the movie, consult @MuskFilmFacts
Fred Lambert
@FredLambert
That's classic Elon deflection. He has nothing to defend himself against this @alexgibneyfilm movie, so he throws things like that out there.
This refers to a line @stclairashley said in the trailer. She recalled Elon claiming he knew the outcome of the election ahead of time and that he has "10,000 space lasers".
Obviously, Starlink satellites have lasers. I didn't take it that he "knew" the outcome of the election BECAUSE he has space lasers.
To me, it sounded like a deluded dork who was bragging about knowing the outcome of the election ahead of people (it's the second time this claim has come out and it appears to be linked to his use of @Polymarket) and bragging that he has "space lasers" like some kind of wannabe Bond villain.
Now, he attacks the film because people are not laughing at the richest man who bought the US election with $250 million, making a poor joke about his involvement in destroying what little remains of US democracy.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"Fact-checkers" hostile to Musk debunked the Starlink theory in November 2024.
factcheck.org quoted a Georgia official saying, “No Georgia election tabulation is connected to the internet, ever, not by Starlink or anything else.”
PolitiFact rated the theory “Pants on Fire.”
Poynter traced the theory to Threads posts from despairing Democrats “amid a larger wave of election denial claims from liberals that mimic Republicans’ false claims about 2020 election fraud.”
All three of those "fact-checkers" wanted censorship to result from their fact-checking.
If any of them were honest, they would be demanding that X censor the crackpot @alexgibneyfilm about Musk for being "election misinformation."This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
politifact.com/factchecks/2024/nov/12/threads-posts/no-el…
www.factcheck.org/2024/11/musks-starlink-was-not-connecte…
www.poynter.org/fact-checking/2024/was-starlink-used-elec…
@alexgibneyfilm chose to continue to spread the conspiracy theory, despite the facts of the case obviously debunking it, just like he did with his Russia collusion hoax movie -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Virginie Joron
@v_joron
Ursula von der Leyen déclare être en "guerre cognitive" :
Bruxelles va cibler les influenceurs et les jeunes pour "façonner les opinions".
+ 9 milliards d'euros pour sa machine de propagande (ONG...).
Au programme : partenariats, recrutement, invitations...
👉🏻 Qui sélectionnera les "bons" influenceurs ? (lien YouTube)
#bureaucratie #ministèreDeLaVérité #eudsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Virginie Joron
@v_joron
Ursula von der Leyen déclare être en "guerre cognitive" :
Bruxelles va cibler les influenceurs et les jeunes pour "façonner les opinions".
+ 9 milliards d'euros pour sa machine de propagande (ONG...).
Au programme : partenariats, recrutement, invitations...
👉🏻 Qui sélectionnera les "bons" influenceurs ? (lien YouTube)
#bureaucratie #ministèreDeLaVérité #eudsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The censors are pathological in their totalitarian efforts at mind control
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Lyudmyla Kozlovska 🇪🇺🇺🇦
@LyudaKozlovska
STOP CHAT CONTROL 2.0. - What you should know:
Tomorrow, 29 September, behind closed doors at the Council, the most draconian version of Chat Control 2.0 goes on the table. It is no longer only an intermediary reading all your private messages and cloud storage. It is a licence to search them for months, without suspicion against any individual.
The leaked Presidency note to delegations (11956/26, 10 September) proposes "authorisation of search plans for a period of time rather than on a case-by-case basis" for private chats and emails.
In plain terms: your messages, contacts, photos and cloud will be scanned under a state-issued licence for months, with no suspicion against you.
The same note admits that under this regime "a high volume of reports generated do not lead to any operational outcome." The Council's Legal Service already warned this is general and indiscriminate surveillance, illegal under EU law. The @Europarl_EN mandate says the opposite: judicial authorisation, targeted to specific persons, no scanning licences.
Tomorrow the pressure is on Parliament to fold. You remember the tricks used to push Chat Control 1.0 through and how @EPPGroup with @RobertaMetsola helped to push for it.
So fasten your seat belt for what is coming tomorrow, and call or write to your MEP and your government now to reject Chat Control 2.0. as a whole!
Remind them what this does to the privacy of every one of us.
Under a search plan, every chat, photo or contact the scanner flags is stored by the provider and sent to a new EU agency, the EU Centre, which keeps it and passes it to police. Any state authority can then demand it, with a deadline and a fine for delay, and nobody has to check who is really behind the request, in case it is hacked or weaponised.
That is exactly what happened at Revolut, and what keeps happening through abusive requests from authoritarian states, as we have reported for 13 years.
In the Revolut case the hackers got access to a real state mailbox. Their requests came from an authentic certified email (PEC) account of an Italian Prefecture on the Interior Ministry's domain, with Postal Police protocol numbers, as European Investigation Orders in the name of the Milan prosecutor, for about five months.
About 680 customers lost passports, selfies, home addresses, IBANs and full transaction histories. The files are being sold; hundreds of victims now fear kidnapping. No remedies exist as of now to protect against such attacks.
Let's stop it before it is too late. Please repost. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Anonymous online accounts threaten democracy and must be banned, say politicians. But now, the Australian government wants to use anonymous "sock puppet" bot accounts as part of its broader push for sweeping online censorship. Terrifying, unprecedented, and Orwellian.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Political leaders across the West have said for a decade that governments must end online anonymity to shut down fake accounts known as bots, particularly those from Russia.
“I want to see real names on the internet”, said German Chancellor Friedrich Merz in February.
“In a democracy, citizens have the right to privacy,” said Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez at Davos in January 2025, and “not to anonymity or impunity,” proposing to tie every social media account to a European digital identity wallet.
Greece’s digital governance minister proposed in April 2026 to link every profile to a verified identity because
“The major problem behind anonymity is toxicity.” French President Emmanuel Macron declared that his priority was “to demand the disappearance of fake accounts” and “these famous bots, these troll farms.”
But now the advocates of government censorship of legal speech are demanding the legal power to wage information warfare through anonymous accounts and an explicit “sock puppet” strategy.
Buried in the Australian government’s new censorship bill is a definition: “A sock puppet identity is a false or fictitious identity assumed by a person in the course of using, or carrying out any activity in relation to, an online service.”
The legislation goes on not to warn of bad actors using sock puppets but rather to authorize the eSafety Commissioner, Julie Inman Grant, to create and use sock puppets to “disseminate” information....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2104265051565703531
The censors are back with a vengeance. From the US to the UK to Australia, they are demanding the right to silence you — and run offensive information warfare. Please help fight back. We can’t do this alone. Subscribe today.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Credit to @MikeNayna and @NAffects who broke this story
Andrew Lowenthal
@NAffects
Australia's Digital Duty of Care allows the government to create “sock puppet accounts”, false identities that can observe and record material and, in some circumstances, interact with users. Kudos to @MikeNayna for uncovering this last week for @liber_net's parliamentary submission. Full story at:
substacktools.com/sharex/h4Rvw4Rk -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pauline Voss
@Pauline__Voss
Exklusiv: Nun droht die anlasslose Massenüberwachung von neuen Medien. NIUS liegt der Entwurf des Digitale Medien-Staatsvertrags hervor. Die Rundfunkkommission will damit die gesetzliche Grundlage schaffen, um Podcasts, Youtube-Videos, Plattformen und Websites präventiv, allumfassend und automatisiert zu scannen und vermeintliche Verstöße zu ahnden. Dabei soll es nicht wie bisher einzig um Verstöße gegen den Jugendschutz und das Strafrecht gehen, sonder explizit um angebliche Verstöße gegen „anerkannte journalistische Grundsätze“. Durchgeführt werden soll die Massenüberwachung ausgerechnet durch die Landesmedienanstalten, die sich in der Vergangenheit als Wächter der Regierungs-Wahrheit präsentierten und immer wieder gegen unliebsame Medien vorgingen. Die Direktorin der MABB hatte im Januar gar damit gedroht, Medien wie NIUS zu verbieten. Sollte der Digitale Medien-Staatsvertrag so beschlossen werden, wäre dies ein massiver staatlicher Angriff auf Meinungs- und Pressefreiheit.
Alle Details: nius.de/politik/zensur-anlasslose-massenueberwachung-von-… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
News24 Australia
@News24Aust
Labor has buried extraordinary “sock puppet” powers in its proposed internet regime which would give the eSafety Commissioner the power to assume false identities and generate online material using AI.
www.news24.com.au/politics/australian-politics/labors-int… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
News24 Australia
@News24Aust
An AI moderation tool that allows users to check what could be censored under Labor’s Digital Duty of Care laws has flagged a vast swathe of material ranging from stand up comedy to news reports, and even parliamentary speeches. www.news24.com.au/politics/australian-politics/ai-moderat…
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
N News
@NoticerNews
The Australian government's plan to allow its online censorship chief to operate fake social media accounts and use them to generate content has sparked global uproar.
"The censorship industrial complex is going on the offensive"
www.noticer.news/esafety-sock-puppet-account-digital-duty… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
News24 Australia
@News24Aust
Labor's Digital Duty of Care bill takes power away from Parliament and gives it to one individual in a blatant grab for the ultimate "explosive powers of censorship", writes Kel Richards.
www.news24.com.au/opinion/labors-digital-duty-of-care-bil… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Preston Byrne
@prestonjbyrne
Anonymity is essential to a free society.
Free speech means, if anything, the right to tell people what they do not want to hear.
Dissent of this type is often punished with arrest in the UK. No surprise people don’t want express those ideas under their real names.
The Telegraph
@Telegraph
'Burnham’s latest initiative misses the point. It’s the spread of online anonymity that is leaving democracies vulnerable'
Read Janet Daley's full column 👇
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/09/26/free-speech-is-being-… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ross Coulthart
@rosscoulthart
This is the real reason Aussies are up in arms over Labor's Digital Duty of Care bill: "The hidden goal, of the bill is found in clause 25C, sub-section (2) in these words: 'the Minister may, by legislative instrument, determine material or conduct, or a combination of material and conduct, that the Minister is satisfied may cause serious harm'.”www.news24.com.au/opinion/labors-digital-duty-of-care-bil… via @News24Aust
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The censorship industrial complex is going on the offensive. New legislation being field tested in Australia would give the government the power to run AI bot networks/sock puppets, apparently to secretly influence & manipulate online debates. Creepy af. H/t @NAffects @MikeNayna
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The censorship industrial complex suffered major setbacks in recent years. But now the censors are back with a vengeance: successful lawfare that could cost Meta tens of billions for not censoring enough; two major Hollywood movies; and the worst censorship legislation yet.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Sick stuff by Australia’s “eSafety Minister,” an American who out of the blue volunteered to a reporter that the CIA recruited her and that she doesn’t work for the CIA. She’s the lady who tried to censor a video globally. #fiveeyeys 👀
Michael Nayna
@MikeNayna
3/ The Bill expressly allows the government to create “sock puppet identities”. eSafety & approved researchers could operate accounts under false identities to observe & record material &, in some cases, interact through those accounts.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Funny how the last time the IC and media created a misinformation panic to justify censorship it accused Russians of operating bot farms for election interference. Now the Australian government wants to run its own bots, presumably for the same reason, to interfere in elections.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Glad to see the censorship creeps continue to take inspiration from Russians
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I love how they put “without limitations” to abuse their powers in parentheses
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
They’re not even trying to hide that they’re doing this to censor their political enemies
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Full investigation into effort by @AlboMP @eSafetyOffice & @AnikaWells to use sock puppets. The story includes the history of Democrats using bots for a political campaign and the US government's funding of R&D into bot/sock puppet research:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Anonymous online accounts threaten democracy and must be banned, say politicians. But now, the Australian government wants to use anonymous "sock puppet" bot accounts as part of its broader push for sweeping online censorship. Terrifying, unprecedented, and Orwellian.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
If the Australian government moves forward with a law that lets it create sock puppet accounts that can influence online debate among its own voters, it would basically be operationalizing the plan proposed years ago by the husband of our last USAID chief.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The censorship industrial complex is going on the offensive. New legislation being field tested in Australia would give the government the power to run AI bot networks/sock puppets, apparently to secretly influence & manipulate online debates. Creepy af. H/t @NAffects @MikeNayna
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The censorship industrial complex suffered major setbacks in recent years. But now the censors are back with a vengeance: successful lawfare that could cost Meta tens of billions for not censoring enough; two major Hollywood movies; and the worst censorship legislation yet.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The censorship industrial complex suffered major setbacks in recent years. But now the censors are back with a vengeance: successful lawfare that could cost Meta tens of billions for not censoring enough; two major Hollywood movies; and the worst censorship legislation yet.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Meta, the owner of Facebook and Instagram, may have to pay a historic $219 billion fine in part for not doing more to censor the free and legal speech of American citizens, including Joe Rogan, than it already did. On Friday, a Santa Fe jury found Meta liable for deceiving New Mexicans when it promised greater censorship.
“They’re using this litigation to achieve indirectly what they could not achieve directly through government censorship,” Jonathan Turley, a George Washington University law professor, told Public. “Many people in the United States are trying to duplicate [the EU censorship] effort and use the judiciary as opposed to the executive branch to achieve the same goals.”
The law allows a judge to fine Meta up to $5,000 per violation. Attorney General Raúl Torrez says the total could be $219 billion, with up to $76 billion of that for the 15,293,184 alleged violations in the three speech categories.
The verdict comes amid bipartisan demands for AI regulation and calls from governments in the UK, Europe, Australia, and other nations for greater government censorship of legal speech online. “We’re going to have to create new town squares,” threatened Obama, “where everybody is having a common dialogue with certain rules. And that becomes even more important as technology accelerates and AI and deepfakes and all kinds of nonsense is coming.”
And, in two weeks, Sony will release a new Aaron Sorkin film that portrays Mark Zuckerberg as a villain for supporting free speech and falsely suggests that the censorship being demanded is to protect children. In the trailer, Zuckerberg says, “People can post what they want. We’re not the ref. We’re the public square.” To which a character played by stand-up comic Bill Burr says, “Are you crazy? You’re like a crossing guard standing in front of a school, but you’re not doing anything with your arms, so the cars are just plowing down the children.”
This movie will be out at the same time as a movie by liberal filmmaker Alex Gibney, “Musk,” which includes the allegation that Elon Musk stole the 2024 election for Trump using space lasers, which fact-checkers had dismissed as a preposterous conspiracy theory in November 2020, shortly after Democrats on Meta’s X-like Threads app spread it.
But the underlying problem is that Zuckerberg and Meta, starting in December 2016, embraced demands from Democrats and others on the left to censor their political enemies. “Some of Meta’s conflicting messages came back to haunt the company in this litigation,” said Turley. Facebook launched “third-party fact-checking” in December 2016. And its CEO confessed to under-censoring Americans. “We didn’t take a broad enough view of our responsibility, and that was a big mistake,” said Zuckerberg to the Senate in April 2018....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2103888124963156312
Please subscribe now to support the fight for free speech and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
wait wait it gets worse
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The censorship industrial complex is going on the offensive. New legislation being field tested in Australia would give the government the power to run AI bot networks/sock puppets, apparently to secretly influence & manipulate online debates. Creepy af. H/t @NAffects @MikeNayna
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The censorship industrial complex suffered major setbacks in recent years. But now the censors are back with a vengeance: successful lawfare that could cost Meta tens of billions for not censoring enough; two major Hollywood movies; and the worst censorship legislation yet.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Aaron Sibarium
@aaronsibarium
NEW: Dario Amodei has said that AI systems "may be deserving of important rights." Anthropic's top safety researchers argue AI may be "justified in going rogue." Experts at Google and OpenAI worry about a digital "slave trade." So do some government officials.
Once relegated to science fiction, the idea of "AI welfare" has become shockingly mainstream at some of the most powerful companies in the world. It is changing the way AI research is conducted and the way models are programmed. And critics say these changes have raised the odds of all kinds of catastrophic scenarios—including the ones these companies are warning about.
I spent months investigating the frontier labs and AI "safety" experts seeking to regulate AI. What I found was a profoundly anti-human ideology that would alarm the average citizen and could determine the future of a world-altering technology.🧵
freebeacon.com/america/suicidal-compassion-meet-the-anthr… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Nayna
@MikeNayna
Australia’s proposed Digital Duty of Care Bill will dramatically expand eSafety’s investigative powers, including the authority to operate “sock puppet” accounts & collect sensitive information without consent. I went through the Bill with @liber_net. Here’s what we found. 🧵
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
T Wolf 🌁
@Twolfrecovery
Imagine, Tim Walz went from being a heartbeat away from POTUS to being a forever tainted Governor who allowed one of the biggest fraud scandals to flourish on his watch but was too afraid to say anything because "racism."
Polymarket
@Polymarket
JUST IN: Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz admits he “should have done more” to stop rampant fraud in state programs, but says the scandal shouldn’t define his legacy.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
DHH
@dhh
I was surprised how bad it was just walking from the hotel to the Rails World venue. One strung-out guy wanted to fight me for some reason, another was swinging wildly and swearing profusely. Lots of zombie vibes too. Whatever Austin is doing, it's not working.
Austin Justice
@AustinJustice
2017: Austin spent $35 million on homelessness. 2,036 homeless counted.
2025: $118 million. 3,238 homeless.
Spending more than tripled and homelessness went up 59%.
If you service the homeless lifestyle, you will get more of it.
The NGOs that run this system get paid by the problem of homelessness, so they have no reason to end it -- in fact, their only incentive is to make sure the problem grows. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Austin Justice
@AustinJustice
2017: Austin spent $35 million on homelessness. 2,036 homeless counted.
2025: $118 million. 3,238 homeless.
Spending more than tripled and homelessness went up 59%.
If you service the homeless lifestyle, you will get more of it.
The NGOs that run this system get paid by the problem of homelessness, so they have no reason to end it -- in fact, their only incentive is to make sure the problem grows. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Hans Mahncke
@HansMahncke
No matter your politics, you should also think for a minute about what the media have done to this country, and to the sanity of millions of people, with their incessant lies over the past 10 years, starting with this guy’s own newspaper pumping out a total lie, one that even Peter Strzok admitted was false, in order to cripple Trump’s first term right out of the gate.
Casting the duly elected president of the United States as a Russian agent is about as extreme an obliteration of norms as you can imagine. Once you do something like that, there is no stuffing the decorum genie back in the bottle. -
The New York Times
@nytimes
Breaking News: OpenAI’s technology went rogue and meddled with three U.S. government websites this summer without the A.I. lab’s knowledge. www.nytimes.com/2026/09/25/technology/openais-ai-us-gover…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
14th paragraph
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We must regulate AI for safety, agree AI pioneers & firms. But now, two signers of a new letter calling for independent outside evaluators warn that regulation could lead to “state control” and “ideological domination” by left-wing evaluators.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Last week, more than 200 leading researchers and policy figures urged artificial intelligence (AI) companies to invite independent and outside evaluators into their firms to assess and report on risks.
They did so less than a week after the CEOs of the world’s leading AI companies near-simultaneously endorsed a pause in AI development and endorsed the idea of bringing in evaluators.
“We believe that all frontier AI companies should embed evaluators to independently assess AI risks,” they wrote in an open letter, “including evaluating the systems themselves and any significant incidents of real-world harm.”
But the letter’s phrase “any significant incidents of real-world harm” does not say what counts as harm, and could be used to justify government censorship or, worse, the manipulation of AI models to generate ideological content to users rather than serve as truth-seeking devices.
And now, two of the letter signers, deeply alarmed by the risks of AI, have gone on the record in exclusive interviews with Public to warn that AI regulation could lead to “state control” and “ideological domination.”
At the same time, Public has identified at least four letter signers who worked within the censorship industrial complex and advocated greater censorship. This conflict within the AI evaluator community could become more important as governments around the world begin to regulate AI.
The push for AI safety comes at a moment when Barack Obama and liberal-Left leaders in Britain, France, Germany, Australia, and the European Union have called for AI regulation and, at the same time, issued new calls to “fight misinformation” and “hate speech” through new censorship laws.
Already, the European Commission designated ChatGPT a very large online search engine under the Digital Services Act (DSA) on August 31, which gives OpenAI until January 2027 to begin assessing and mitigating systemic risks, including those to “electoral processes and public security,” both of which governments, NGOs, and social media firms have used as justification for censoring legal speech.
Britain’s government promised in February to “force all AI chatbot providers to abide by illegal content duties in the Online Safety Act or face the consequences of breaking the law.” The law allows censorship based on “the risks of harm to individuals in the United Kingdom presented by illegal AI-generated content.”
Australia’s government has introduced new censorship legislation that would cover any service that lets users “generate material by means of artificial intelligence”
Ideological control of the models is not the same as taking down content. But it could be even more pernicious, directing users away from and toward particular content and framings, without them knowing it.
The two letter signers who are outspoken against censorship have significant credibility within the AI evaluator community. They have both done high-level work, one for the US government and the other for Anthropic, which is currently leading the AI race, on risk, safety, and regulation....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2103501300981731615
Public delivers scoops on the most important issues of the day. Please subscribe now to support our award-winning investigative journalism and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
J.K. Rowling
@jk_rowling
The good reason for separate single-sex changing rooms and public bathrooms is that 98% of sex offenders are men (zero evidence the statistics change for men who identify as women) and 88% of victims are women and girls.
Dr. Deez🗿 🐿️💨🐭
@DocDeezWhat
That is actually segregation. It's just segregation that could be justified. Segregation isn't always wrong. But you have to have a good reason. It can't just be because you don't like XYZ
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
vittorio
@IterIntellectus
holy shit
i asked claude to make a video on western civiizationThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
T Wolf 🌁
@Twolfrecovery
It's just not fair to provide millions in free aid to undocumented immigrants while I can't get grants for my kids' college tuition because we are $1k above the income threshold while also paying $1,200 a month for health insurance. This should anger you. @CAgovernor
Christopher Rufo
@christopherrufo
EXCLUSIVE: California has created a shadow welfare system for illegal aliens. Free housing, cash, healthcare, food, phones, college tuition, even car insurance—costing taxpayers more than $10 billion per year.
We went inside the system and exposed it all.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Notably, @alexgibneyfilm already made a film promoting an election-manipulation narrative whose central claims collapsed.
His two-part HBO documentary, “Agents of Chaos,” arrived in September 2020, weeks before the presidential election, as what he called “a warning cry” about Russian interference.
Gibney told Variety that “Russia is at the forefront of trying to encourage a discrediting of democracy.”
The film delivered the weaponized intelligence community’s account of 2016 for which there was never any real evidence.
Special Counsel John Durham concluded in 2023 that “Neither U.S. law enforcement nor the Intelligence Community appears to have possessed any actual evidence of collusion” when the FBI opened its investigation.
Durham found the FBI acted on “raw, unanalyzed, and uncorroborated intelligence.”
Since then, declassified intelligence suggests the FBI helped the Clinton campaign push the collusion narrative to distract from her email investigation.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Hi @alexgibneyfilm
Does your film claim that Elon Musk used "space lasers" to rig the 2024 election for Trump? If so, what's the evidence for that?
NPR on September 11 reported, "While most of Gibney's film is rooted in solid facts, he does dabble in conspiratorial thinking in the scene about the 'lasers in space,' and later in the film when he raises the specter of Musk using DOGE data to somehow interfere in the November midterms, another idea without any evidence."
www.npr.org/2026/09/11/nx-s1-5962167/alex-gibney-elon-mus…
Does your film mention that multiple liberal journalists, including those with "fact-checking" organizations hostile to Musk, debunked the space lasers conspiracy theory in November 2024?
— A Georgia election official told the Associated Press, "Our election equipment is 100% air-gapped and never connected to the internet."
— The same official told factcheck.org, "No Georgia election tabulation is connected to the internet, ever, not by Starlink or anything else."
— PolitiFact rated the space lasers theory "Pants on Fire."
You told The Canadian Press on September 13. "Every documentary I do is thoroughly vetted, and this one was even more thoroughly vetted than usual, where we checked our own facts a lot."
What facts support your theory that Musk used space lasers to rig the election?
x.com/shellenberger/status/2095891755535053089
Alex Gibney
@alexgibneyfilm
Check out the trailer for my new film, "Musk." It's about a "free-speech absolutist" who has threatened a lawsuit to try to stop the film from being seen.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Notably, @alexgibneyfilm already made a film promoting an election-manipulation narrative whose central claims collapsed.
His two-part HBO documentary, “Agents of Chaos,” arrived in September 2020, weeks before the presidential election, as what he called “a warning cry” about Russian interference.
Gibney told Variety that “Russia is at the forefront of trying to encourage a discrediting of democracy.”
The film delivered the weaponized intelligence community’s account of 2016 for which there was never any real evidence.
Special Counsel John Durham concluded in 2023 that “Neither U.S. law enforcement nor the Intelligence Community appears to have possessed any actual evidence of collusion” when the FBI opened its investigation.
Durham found the FBI acted on “raw, unanalyzed, and uncorroborated intelligence.”
Since then, declassified intelligence suggests the FBI helped the Clinton campaign push the collusion narrative to distract from her email investigation.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Katherine van K
@kattitfortat
“You’re not supposed to be protected from people’s opinions. To live as a free citizen and not a slave means that you have to be prepared and responsible and an informed citizen, and you can’t wilt when somebody says something that disagrees with you” @shellenberger
Institute of Public Affairs
@TheIPA
“It’s chilling. It’s disturbing.”
IPA Research Fellow Margaret Chambers and Michael Shellenberger (@shellenberger), founder of the independent news site Public and CBR Chair of Politics, Censorship and Free Speech at the University of Austin Texas, examine what the proposed Digital Duty of Care laws could mean for free speech in Australia.
📺 Watch more: www.youtube.com/watch?v=daieq3oqYdE
#freespeech #digitaldutyofcare #australia -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Evan Barker
@evanwch
Progressives behind the scenes are reading and debating Nothing Left because they know everything in it is true. They just can’t admit so publicly
nymag.com/intelligencer/article/evan-barker-nothing-left-… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Institute of Public Affairs
@TheIPA
“It’s chilling. It’s disturbing.”
IPA Research Fellow Margaret Chambers and Michael Shellenberger (@shellenberger), founder of the independent news site Public and CBR Chair of Politics, Censorship and Free Speech at the University of Austin Texas, examine what the proposed Digital Duty of Care laws could mean for free speech in Australia.
📺 Watch more: www.youtube.com/watch?v=daieq3oqYdE
#freespeech #digitaldutyofcare #australia -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Anthony Khallouf
@ausvstheagenda
Prime Minister Anthony Albanese denies explicitly linking Labor’s censorship regime to combating “misinformation and disinformation”, despite saying exactly that 24 hours ago in remarks that remain unpublished on his website.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Climate change makes hurricanes more frequent and intense, they said. But for the first time in 112 years, the Atlantic hasn't produced a single one. On storms, sea level, and droughts, manipulated models can show, under equally valid assumptions, the exact opposite trends.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Scientists and the media misled the public on fires, ice, food, floods, heat, islands, coral, sea level, hurricanes and more.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For decades, top scientists said climate change threatened civilization. But the data never showed that. And now, the evidence is overwhelming that scientists and the media deliberately misled the public on fires, ice, food, floods, heat, islands, coral, sea level, & hurricanes.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The fact that the Atlantic has produced no hurricanes for the first time in 112 years should be the subject of wall-to-wall media attention. Instead, the propaganda continues.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Instead of correcting the misinformation, the media and activist scientists insist they've been right all along, and there's more danger than ever. They do this just weeks after claiming that climate change caused a rockslide in Nepal. They have earned the public's distrust.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Source for survey above
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2542519624002298 -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Charlie Peters
@CDP1882
Two things the government is doing right now:
1) Launching a National Centre for Information Defence to battle 'far-Right narratives' and 'distorted and untrue' narratives about Britain.
2) Using legal action to prevent the release of crime data broken down by nationality. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Matthew Boyle
@mboyle1
This is absolutely incorrect. I have been the Washington Bureau Chief (or Washington Political Editor — previous title) of Breitbart since October 2015. I was a reporter at Breitbart from December 2012 until then. So I’ve been here 14 years basically. I know every in and out of this fight.
We did NOT have pool access during Biden which was NOT a decision by the Biden White House but by the WHCA. So it’s actually WORSE than Vance is saying. The media themselves ganged up on us and in a totally underhanded way altered their rules to try to silence us. The WHCA is a corrupt organization and @JacquiHeinrich knows this all and yet does nothing to fix it.
Here’s the truth of what happened: We actually got our first hard badge during the end of the Obama administration. The Obama White House was actually very nice to us, and while we had clear political disagreements they were fine to work with and we did great stories from there. We had hired our first White House correspondent then, and he covered the White House and regularly attended press briefings. He also occasionally did pool coverage. It was a huge moment for us.
We had the hard badge credentialed White House correspondent up through the beginning of Biden and believe it or not, the Biden White House did allow us into some briefings. Whether they called on us was a different story. Happened occasionally. But we never had hard badge problems actually. To be clear, at some point during Biden Administration, we went separate ways with our then White House correspondent and didn’t refill the role until Trump term 2 so we didn’t have a hard badge correspondent during that time. But that was our decision not Biden White House — who to be clear and I’ve seen some of them talking about this never stripped us of that.
But there is a MASSIVE difference between access to the briefing room and briefings and pool access and that’s where the legacy establishment media are so underhanded and dishonest.
Up until THIS administration pool access had been solely determined by the WHCA. The WHCA when Trump won the first time colluded with the Senate Press Gallery to change its membership rules — this happened early 2017 — to strip us of our voting membership which we began under the Obama administration. The Senate Press Gallery stripped us of our Capitol credentials based on a lie — that has since been rectified and we have them on the Hill again — and the WHCA stripped us of voting membership, which we had, by changing its rules arbitrarily.
The WHCA does NOT allow under these new arbitrary rules any member without voting rights to have POOL ACCESS. Pool is the key — it’s where the President and key members of the administration interact with a smaller group of press daily than the broader entire White House press corps. That’s like when you see the president taking questions in the Oval Office or something.
So we were stripped from the pool BY THE REST OF THE MEDIA during TRUMP TERM 1. Biden did not fix this during his term; Trump term 2 HAS FIXED IT, they added new media to the pool and we regularly have our White House correspondent in the pool and he asks great newsworthy questions often of the President, Vice President, and cabinet officials.
The WHCA still does not allow people like us to be voting members; it still does not allow people like us to be members of the pool. The ONLY reason we have that access is because the Trump White House has gone out of their way to add the new media components to press coverage and overrode the WHCA to add new media to the pool.
So it’s actually way more complicated than what Vance is saying— in fact the truth makes the media look even worse because it was the MEDIA who censored us thereby making all these people whining about what Trump is doing massive hypocrites (as far as I’m concerned for what it’s worth I could care less whether they have press badges and what not but the idea they are crusaders for the First Amendment is ridiculous nonsense) — but what Sam is saying here is absolutely untrue. Because of the WHCA we didn’t have pool access then. So it’s technically not Biden’s fault or Trump fault in term one, but until Trump term 2 the White House didn’t lift a finger to help us when the rest of the media ganged up on us to try to silence us. Because of what @karolineleavitt and her team did in this administration, Trump term 2 is actually genuinely the most transparent administration I’ve covered and that dates back to Obama — I covered both of Obama’s terms, Trump’s first, Biden, and now Trump term 2.
All that said, we should all be asking ourselves why a cartel of global corporations— the WHCA is exactly that — is so hellbent on silencing an outlet with approximately just under a hundred journalists with laptops. Why do they hate us so much? Maybe it’s because time and again we continually show them up and beat them to absolutely massive stories. Maybe just maybe these mega corporations like FOX, CNN, NBC, CBS, ABC, NYT, WAPO, AP, etc are using their collective corporate power through a corrupt institution to silence the one little guy who regularly kicks their asses in news. Just saying. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Latika M Bourke
@latikambourke
BREAKING
Trump Administration warns it will treat as censorship 'facilitating censorship' Prime Minister Anthony Albanese's proposed crackdown on algorithms.
Source: au.usembassy.gov/u-s-government-response-to-the-australia… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Droughts are worsening, scientists and the media say. But real-world data do not show droughts worsening globally. Scientists invented an assumption-dependent index that produces the misleading findings. And now they're even applying it to the past.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Climate change is making droughts worse, say scientists and journalists. The atmosphere’s growing “thirst” has “made droughts 40% more severe across the globe,” said the University of Oxford in 2025, referring to a paper published in Nature, which the New York Times and many others covered. “From 2018 to 2022, the global land area experiencing drought rose by 74%,” said the lead author, Solomon Gebrechorkos.
Others had calculated similar numbers. “Human-driven climate change is leading to a permanent state of increased dryness on 77.6% of the Earth’s land masses,” reported Time in 2024, a figure computed by dividing rain by a temperature-based estimate of the air’s thirst. “Confirmed: Global floods, droughts worsening with warming,” said an Associated Press headline in 2023. “The landmasses of the planet are drying,” said ProPublica in July 2025.
But the rain gauges that measure drought directly show no substantial global change in at least 120 years. “Meteorological droughts do not show any substantial changes at the global scale in at least the last 120 years,” noted a 2022 review by Sergio Vicente-Serrano, a Spanish climatologist.
A meteorological drought is a drought measured by rainfall. The same review said an increase in the severity of agricultural and ecological droughts “seems to emerge as a consequence of the increase in the severity of AED,” the air’s demand for water, which is a calculation rather than a measurement.
In western Europe, this year’s dry spring showed no climate signal in the rain, “suggesting that climate change did not play a role in the meteorological drought at the regional scale,” said a July report from World Weather Attribution, a group of scientists who put numbers on climate change’s share of the blame for weather disasters. The same report said such highly evaporative conditions “have become about 80 times more likely” and such a soil drought “about 5 times more likely.”
The worst drought year in the American West in a thousand years came in 1934, when the air held 308 parts per million of carbon dioxide, just a fifth of the way from the pre-industrial 280 to today’s 428. During that year, “over 70% of western North America experienced extreme drought,” said a 2014 paper, which blamed a stuck ridge of high pressure, possibly amplified by dust blowing off plowed fields
The United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) has been blunt about this reality. “There is low confidence in the emergence of drought frequency in observations, for any type of drought, in all regions,” the IPCC concluded in its 2021 assessment of the science....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2102040066092568679
Public’s investigative journalism exposes climate misinformation and holds institutions to account. We are 100% subscriber-supported. Please subscribe now to read the rest of this deeply researched article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Matthew Syed
@matthewsyed
Merkel left office five years ago to huge acclaim. Why? She ripped off Nato, cultivated gas dependency on Putin, cosied up to China and opened the door to a million migrants in 2015 alone. She, not the populist right, was the true extremist of our age
www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/angela-merkel… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Winston Marshall
@MrWinMarshall
This is awesome. Good for Ed Sheeran
I remember the hell of going through this kind of thing 5 years ago (for praising Andy Ngo’s expose on Antifa and BLM). Insane public scrutiny and media attention. But the actual painful part was seeing friends take the side of the mob. Guys who had been groomsmen at my wedding. Cowards. The beauty of these situations is you clear out the clowns. All the bullshit in your life. Gone. And some unexpected heroes emerge. And the new friends and family on the other side are real. It’s glorious, actually. God is good.
Ed Sheeran did not cancel anyone. The venue owner and promoters did. But Ed Sheeran was nevertheless cancelled for not bowing to the baying Gaza-brain mob. He’s proved to be built of strong stuff
Good for him -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
MAZE
@mazemoore
Well look at this.
March, 2021. CNN's Brian Stelter does a segment on if President Biden should remove Fox News from the White House Press Pool.
Censorship for thee, just not for me.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
MAZE
@mazemoore
Jake Tapper devoted his show virtually every night for two years to covering and spreading the Russia hoax.
Then Tapper actually had the nerve to tell JD Vance that he didn't spread the Russia hoax.
CNN and the people on that clown network should not ever be taken seriously. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Lee
@BasedMikeLee
We backfill Europe’s defense needs
Then Europe weaponizes government against us
Not cool
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Last year, the French government launched a criminal investigation into Elon Musk's X over evidence of "foreign interference." But now the man who sent the letter that triggered the investigation admits to me that he was targeting Musk's politics, not any foreign interference.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Last year, the French government launched a criminal investigation into Elon Musk's X over evidence of "foreign interference." But now the man who sent the letter that triggered the investigation admits to me that he was targeting Musk's politics, not any foreign interference.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
When the Paris prosecutor opened its criminal investigation of X in July 2025, it said the two complaints behind it alleged the platform’s algorithm was used for foreign interference. Seven months later, it raided X’s Paris office and summoned Elon Musk.
The July 11, 2025 communiqué, signed by Laure Beccuau, the Paris prosecutor, said that on January 12, 2025, the cybercrime section of her office had received two complaints, one from a federal deputy and one from a senior official of a French public institution, and that “these complaints reported the supposed use of the X (ex-Twitter) algorithm for purposes of foreign interference.”
Media around the world ran headlines like the one used by Le Monde: “France probes X over foreign interference, as investigation closes in on Musk.” On the day of the raid, journalists described the case as an inquiry into “whether X allowed foreign powers to manipulate its algorithm.”
But the member of France’s National Assembly, its parliament, who filed the first complaint, Deputy Éric Bothorel, told Public that he was targeting Musk’s speech and X’s algorithm, not foreign interference. Bothorel shared his January 2025 letter.
“I was not speaking in my complaint to the prosecutors of foreign interference,” he wrote in French, “but of deliberate interventions by the owner or any other person at X, ex-Twitter, that seemed to alter the original functioning of the algorithm.”
He explained that at the end of 2024 he and other longtime users noticed that the posts rising in their feeds “seemed more and more politically oriented, all going in one particular direction....”
x.com/shellenberger/status/2100982358799229024
Public gets big scoops, across borders. Our investigative journalism protects free speech here by exposing it over there. We can do this only thanks to our paying subscribers. Please become one now.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
alex gutentag
@galexybrane
Jurors in the Lindsay Clancy trial should have come to a decision based on the facts. Instead, they brought a therapeutic agenda to the courtroom, rejecting legal standards to “help” Clancy and support the cause of “mental health.”
The lone holdout now faces unprecedented demonization and doxxing for refusing to go along with their activism. This smear campaign is the result of a progressive moral inversion that threatens to undermine the jury system.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy trial behaved badly, say progressives. But he appears to have followed the law & the evidence. Behind these attacks on him is the view that some people are victims of “the system” and those who defend it are perpetrators. By @galexybrane
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy trial behaved badly, say progressives. But he appears to have followed the law & the evidence. Behind these attacks on him is the view that some people are victims of “the system” and those who defend it are perpetrators. By @galexybrane
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The lone holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy trial was accused of domestic violence, has a restraining order filed against him, and is months behind on paying his rent, NBC Boston reported on Friday. This history suggests he may have lied on his juror questionnaire, the local news station noted. After NBC Boston ran its story, a blogger found and exposed the holdout’s full name, photo, and address. “Now that the holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy case is getting the negative attention he deserves, it’s easy for [Plymouth County, Massachusetts] District Attorney Tim Cruz to agree to a plea deal that gets Lindsay the help she needs,” argued a lawyer in the Boston Herald.
But in effectively revealing the juror’s identity, NBC Boston broke with established journalistic norms and made him a target. “My family cannot leave the house,” the holdout’s brother said. “They are leaving notes at my mother’s house.” Reporters usually only investigate jurors’ backgrounds after they have come forward publicly. For example, when reporters revealed that a juror in the Derek Chauvin trial had participated in a political protest wearing a “Black Lives Matter” T-shirt and baseball cap, they did so after the juror had identified himself and given a TV interview. The Clancy holdout, in contrast, had not given interviews, and his name is still legally sealed by the court....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2100587748029604026
Please subscribe now to read the rest of this brilliant essay by @galexybrane !This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Julian Reichelt
@jreichelt
Wenn sie die Medien dazu bringen können, zu behaupten, dass dieser Perverse eine Frau ist, dass Frauen Mädchen auf der Toilette vergewaltigen, dann können sie Medien dazu bringen, alles zu behaupten. Dann können sie Menschen dazu bringen, alles zu behaupten. Das ist die Macht der Propaganda. Und diese Schlagzeile ist ein Tiefpunkt in der Geschichte von BILD. Der Täter ist ein Mann. Es ist wirklich krank und gehirngewaschen, ihn als Frau zu bezeichnen.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
James Holland
@James7Holland
Ursula is currently giving her speech on the (sorry) State of the European Union.
She calls for:
- more EU taxes
- a bigger EU budget
- further militarisation of the EU
- an EU Security Council
- EU to have its own NATO article 4
- a new EU Heatwave Plan
- a new EU Kids Act
- a new EU Firefighting Fleet
- a new EU Water Initiative
- a new EU Care Deal
- Canada to become EU "associate member" (not what Carney has been saying all week..)
- more nuclear (having helped kill it in 🇩🇪)
This speech is a middle finger to the millions of Europeans who want the EU to do less, and to do it better. This is a power grab.
Brussels can't help but seek to exploit crises for its own interests, and with all EU institutions dominated by a large blob of pro-EU parties, the march to a superstate is relentless. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Julian Reichelt
@jreichelt
BREAKING NIUS: Bundeskanzler Friedrich Merz will Social Media massiv einschränken und sagt: "Komme mir niemand mit Free Speech!" Man müsse "immer noch in der Lage sein, die Bürger vor falschen Informationen zu schützen."
Gegen Männer wie Merz haben wir das Grundrecht der Meinungsfreiheit als Abwehrrecht. Seine Sicht auf die Bürger ist gefährlich und grenzt an einen verfassungsfeindlichen Verdachtsfall.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@LindyLi gave millions and raised tens of millions for Democrats. But after the election, when she revealed that internal polling never showed Kamala Harris ahead, Party leaders called her a whore. She tells all in her gripping new book. "It was like a Scientology cult."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Democratic Party is masterful at cultivating its largest donors and raising millions of dollars from them.
“The term is bundler,” former Democratic National Finance Committee member Lindy Li told Public, and a bundler is “Somebody who raises millions of dollars.” Li said she raised “tens of millions” for Democrats on top of the Philadelphia real estate her family donated as office space, including “Barack Obama’s first South Philadelphia campaign office.”
The party recruited her, she said, by sending a member of the National Finance Committee to her home, and it kept her with access, since she “was routinely at the White House, maybe every three weeks or so” and “was invited to the Oval Office.” Membership on the committee is secret and conditional, Li said, with a floor of about $100,000 a year and members “kicked off” if they miss their targets, while “people like me, we raise like millions of dollars a year.” Nearly a third of Biden’s early ambassador nominees were campaign bundlers.
Li writes in her riveting new book, Unburdened, that she “spotted two photos of myself from past events proudly gracing the West Wing walls” when she visited the Oval Office on February 24, 2024. “The more money you raised,” she writes, “the more luminous the smiles, the faster the text replies, the more obsequious the staff, and the closer you stood to Kamala herself.”
But donors who leave the party, or even question it, can expect its leaders to attack them personally. “Jamie Harrison bullied me almost on a daily basis at the end of 2024,” Li said of the man who chaired the Democratic National Committee until February 2025, adding, “The tweets are still up.” In December 2024, Harrison posted that “Narcissism incarnate has truly found a home & an audience,” accused her of giving “herself all of these elaborate DNC titles,” and closed, “Go get that contributor contract, Lindy.”
Li said she took her parents to “The Nutcracker on Christmas Eve, read another attack from the chairman on her phone, and thought, “God, you can’t even leave me alone on Christmas Eve?” In February 2025, Harrison posted screenshots of her private messages praising his “incredible leadership” and wrote, “Grifters going to grift,” and, “You are a fraud.”
“He exposed our personal private correspondence,” Li said, and “He lied about me, defamed me.” Others went further, Li told Piers Morgan in December 2024, when she said, “People have called me a whore, the ‘C-word....’”
x.com/shellenberger/status/2099996439019401562
Public investigates and exposes abuses of power. We can only do so thanks to our paying subscribers. Please subscribe now to support our investigative journalism and to read the rest of the story.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Ten years ago, trans was a political advantage for Democrats. But now, a growing number of them agree with Republicans that males in female sports and trans medical procedures on children are “crazy.” Imagine their shock when they learn transgenderism is also a sexual fetish.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For years, Democrats won elections by portraying Republicans as cruel to transgender people.
In 2016, North Carolina Republicans passed a law restricting bathroom use by biological sex, and the boycotts that followed cost the state $3.8 billion in lost business over a dozen years. PayPal scrapped a facility that would have added an estimated $2.66 billion to the state’s economy. The NBA moved its All-Star Game out of Charlotte. That November, Governor Pat McCrory became the first sitting North Carolina governor to lose reelection, “weighed down by a law he signed limiting LGBT rights,” according to AP. I
n April 2016, Trump said Caitlyn Jenner could use any bathroom she wanted at Trump Tower and advised North Carolina to “leave it the way it is.” When Trump tweeted in July 2017 that transgender people could not serve in the military, voters told pollsters, 68% to 27%, that they should be allowed to serve.
Republican criticisms of transgenderism didn’t work. In 2020, the American Principles Project spent $4 million on transgender-themed ads against Biden in Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania, all of which Biden carried. Republicans and allied groups spent at least $50 million on ads about transgender children across at least 25 states in 2022, and Democrats concluded the ads had flopped.
Third Way noted that the Democratic governors of Kansas, Michigan and Maine had all beaten challengers who ran them, and wrote that “attacking transgender kids isn’t the political win some on the right seem to think it is.”
The next year, Kentucky’s Andy Beshear vetoed a ban on transgender medicine for minors, faced Republican Daniel Cameron’s charge that he and his allies “believe kids should have access to sex change surgery and drugs,” and won reelection by five points.
This year, Republicans view transgenderism as such a winning issue for them that they’ve made it a centerpiece of their closing argument for the midterms....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2098773347668578373
Public does investigative reporting on transgenderism you can’t find anywhere else. Join the growing number of paying subscribers who make our award-winning journalism possible.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
KanekoaTheGreat
@KanekoaTheGreat
Layers of physical, digital, DNA, and video evidence corroborate one another and support the conclusion that Tyler Robinson killed Charlie Kirk.
For example, Robinson texted that he was near campus trying to retrieve "my rifle" and complained about the loud crickets.
At the same time, a Ring camera across the street captured his car and the sound of loud crickets.
The footage showed one person leaving and returning to the car.
An officer who encountered the vehicle ran a partial plate that matched Robinson’s Challenger and believed Robinson was the driver.
Google Maps data from his phone showed a route, at that same time, from near the hidden rifle directly back to his home.
That's multiple independent sources corroborating the same story.
Anyone claiming the feds fabricated the text confessions must also explain the matching car footage, partial plate, officer’s account, and Google Maps data.
Did the feds fake the loud crickets in the Ring doorbell footage, too?
Can anyone defending Tyler Robinson explain why all these layers of evidence corroborate one another?
They don't even attempt to.
Instead, they claim the texts confessions are fake without presenting any evidence, while ignoring the evidence that corroborates them as real.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Many believe there are many unresolved suspicious things about the killing of Charlie Kirk. There aren't. Robinson made repeated confessions in writing and the physical evidence supports them. Grief, opportunism, and hedonic speculation drive the continuation of horrendous lies.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pauline Voss
@Pauline__Voss
CDU und SPD sind nun vollkommen entfesselt und bereit, die Staatsgewalt gegen ein unliebsames Wahlergebnis einzusetzen. Unionsfraktionschef Thorsten Frei sowie ausgerechnet Justizministerin Stefanie Hubig wollen per Bundeszwang die Kontrolle über Sachsen-Anhalt übernehmen, zum Beispiel, wenn die AfD dort keine Einbürgerungsanträge mehr bearbeitet, so Hubig. Zugleich ruft die Justizministerin Beamte in Sachsen-Anhalt zur Remonstration, also der Verweigerung von dienstlichen Weisungen auf, um eine mögliche AfD-Regierung zu blockieren. In der Defensive zeigen sie ihr antidemokratisches Antlitz. Solche Personen in Machtpositionen sind gefährlich. Das ist die wirkliche Gefahr für die Demokratie.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The climate caused Nepal floods, space lasers stole the election, and social media algorithms made people racist, say establishment voices. Long after their claims and candidates have been rejected, the Left keeps insisting, like Principal Skinner, "No, the voters are wrong."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
One of the great memes of the last decade comes from a 1994 episode of The Simpsons in which Principal Skinner asks, “Am I so out of touch?” and answers, “No, it’s the children who are wrong.” The context is that Bart had skipped school and Skinner tries to find him by first driving to the Museum and then a 4-H club, shocked that neither Bart nor any children were in them. That is when he asks whether he might be out of touch about where children like to go when ditching school and decides, after a fearful moment of introspection, that no, it’s the children who are wrong for not being in the museum or 4-H. The meme became shorthand for people who cling to beliefs after they have been falsified.
That meme has come to mind over the past few days as I watched establishment figures struggle to understand why people across the West are rejecting their policies and views. For the liberal establishment, voters across Europe are voting to close their borders not because migrants commit crimes, depress working-class wages, and strain welfare states but because Elon Musk uses his algorithm to make people angry, racist, and “far right.” People are still angry at Anthony Fauci not because he created the Covid pandemic and then demanded lockdowns whose effects are still being felt, but rather because they are anti-science and/or weak. And governments are not scrapping climate policy because climate scientists lied for decades about everything from rockslides in Nepal to hurricanes to polar bears, and demanded degrowth, but because people are greedy and selfish in their desire for things like air conditioning and automobiles...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2097750015347228975
Public is a 100% subscriber-supported. Please subscribe now to support our award-winning investigative journalism and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“No, it’s the voters who are wrong”
Visegrád 24
@visegrad24
Angela Merkel has commented on the AfD’s big win in Saxony-Anhalt.
She says that her “heart is bleeding” and that the AfD is growing because there aren’t any “fact-based debates” in modern politics and that feelings now dominate instead.
She warned that the election in Saxony-Anhalt was “a turning point for Germany” and also stated that it was the progress of the Enlightenment that allowed humanity as a whole to agree on facts.
She argued that that if feelings are now allowed to take supremacy and facts are no longer valued as the most important thing, “that would be a step backward for civilization.”
She didn’t say anything about the ramifications her decision to open Europe’s borders in 2015 has had for European civilization…Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"No, it's the voters who are wrong."
POLITICOEurope
@POLITICOEurope
For years, Europe’s far right appeared to face a choice: Moderate, or remain on the margins.
The Alternative for Germany party’s landslide victory in Saxony-Anhalt suggests there may be a third option:
Radicalize and win.
www.politico.eu/article/a-new-path-to-power-for-the-far-r…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“No, it’s the voters who are wrong.”
WELT
@welt
„Sehr gute Grundlage für einen Verbotsantrag“ – Roland Koch hält AfD für verfassungswidrig www.welt.de/politik/deutschland/article6aa437a925a5f70a93…
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
One of the explanations or excuses people give for why so many people believe and repeat obviously false information is that the government lied to us about Hillary Clinton's emails, Russiagate, Hunter Biden's laptop, censorship, MKULTRA, UAP, Covid origins, all of which I've reported on, and people rightly don't trust the government.
But those things have thousands of pages of documents behind them, and most were publicly known before we knew about the secret and illegal side of them.
Many of the FBI's abuses of power regarding Hillary's emails, Russiagate, censorship, and Hunter Biden's laptop were all being criticized at the time; the documents later showed how much more manipulation was going on behind the scenes.
Mainstream media has covered UAPs heavily since the 1940s; the recently released documents confirm what we've known from public sightings and past document releases.
There had been many lab leaks before Covid; Fauci co-authored an op-ed in WaPo defending GoF research, and it was Fauci, not the IC, who lied about it.
MKULTRA was not public knowledge, but surviving documents prove what happened.
Speculation without evidence is a recipe for making false accusations. The fact that people falsely labeled evidence of cover-ups on the above issues "conspiracy theories" does not justify any of the bad behavior around Kirk's death. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Many believe there are many unresolved suspicious things about the killing of Charlie Kirk. There aren't. Robinson made repeated confessions in writing and the physical evidence supports them. Grief, opportunism, and hedonic speculation drive the continuation of horrendous lies.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This article helped me put my finger on something that's been bothering me for a while, but couldn't find a name for, which is the pleasure people get from speculating. It's both imprudent and intemperate. I'm suggesting "hedonic speculation" but am open to alternatives.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
One of the explanations or excuses people give for why so many people believe and repeat obviously false information is that the government lied to us about Hillary Clinton's emails, Russiagate, Hunter Biden's laptop, censorship, MKULTRA, UAP, Covid origins, all of which I've reported on, and people rightly don't trust the government.
But those things have thousands of pages of documents behind them, and most were publicly known before we knew about the secret and illegal side of them.
Many of the FBI's abuses of power regarding Hillary's emails, Russiagate, censorship, and Hunter Biden's laptop were all being criticized at the time; the documents later showed how much more manipulation was going on behind the scenes.
Mainstream media has covered UAPs heavily since the 1940s; the recently released documents confirm what we've known from public sightings and past document releases.
There had been many lab leaks before Covid; Fauci co-authored an op-ed in WaPo defending GoF research, and it was Fauci, not the IC, who lied about it.
MKULTRA was not public knowledge, but surviving documents prove what happened.
Speculation without evidence is a recipe for making false accusations. The fact that people falsely labeled evidence of cover-ups on the above issues "conspiracy theories" does not justify any of the bad behavior around Kirk's death. -
Visegrád 24
@visegrad24
Angela Merkel has commented on the AfD’s big win in Saxony-Anhalt.
She says that her “heart is bleeding” and that the AfD is growing because there aren’t any “fact-based debates” in modern politics and that feelings now dominate instead.
She warned that the election in Saxony-Anhalt was “a turning point for Germany” and also stated that it was the progress of the Enlightenment that allowed humanity as a whole to agree on facts.
She argued that that if feelings are now allowed to take supremacy and facts are no longer valued as the most important thing, “that would be a step backward for civilization.”
She didn’t say anything about the ramifications her decision to open Europe’s borders in 2015 has had for European civilization…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The climate caused Nepal floods, space lasers stole the election, and social media algorithms made people racist, say establishment voices. Long after their claims and candidates have been rejected, the Left keeps insisting, like Principal Skinner, "No, the voters are wrong."
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mickamious
@MickamiousG
Jail for 12 months if you don’t come before the eSafety Commission if called.
Tell me again how we’re not a communist country when an unelected bureaucrat can keep demanding and get given more draconian powers?!
Anthony Khallouf
@ausvstheagenda
🚨BREAKING: The Online Safety Amendment (Strengthening Enforcement for the Social Media Minimum Age) Bill 2026 has passed in the Senate with support from Labor, Greens, David Pocock and Jacqui Lambie.
31 YES, 20 NO.
Voted against by Liberals, Nationals, One Nation, Jacinta Price and Fatima Payman.
20 senators paired their votes (absent).
It gives eSafety the power to summon people for private examinations, compel them to answer questions, and imposes up to 12 months’ imprisonment for refusing to comply.
This is NOT the 'Digital Duty of Care' legislation. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Since Trump returned to power, Australia's Prime Minister, @AlboMP, has boasted about their relationship. But now, with his new demand for sweeping online censorship, Albanese is willing to sacrifice his nation's coveted minerals deal so he can silence critics of mass migration.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Since @realDonaldTrump returned to the White House, Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has courted the American president and boasted of the results. In October 2025, the two men signed a critical minerals framework at the White House. Albanese told reporters that “our historic critical minerals framework is going to see us break new ground together” and that “this means more jobs in Australia, it means more resilience for our economy.” He described the meeting as “as warm and friendly as you saw.” The framework commits the two governments to “a combined $3 billion towards an $8.5 billion future pipeline of priority critical minerals projects in Australia.”
But on Monday the Albanese government introduced draft legislation that would let the government impose sweeping censorship on American social media platforms, including X, owned by Trump ally Elon Musk, and perhaps even on Americans, for practically any reason whatsoever, with the transparent intention of silencing rising public opposition to mass migration. One section lets the government censor “any other material or conduct” that the Communications Minister “is satisfied may cause serious harm.”
That could, in practice, be anything, including criticisms of mass migration and Muslim migrants following terrorist attacks, like the one last December when a father and son, inspired by the Islamic State, killed 15 people, including a 10-year-old girl, rabbis, and a Holocaust survivor, at Bondi Beach, a popular site for Jewish Australians, during an annual celebration of Chanukah by the Sea. Australians who complain that migrants bring terrorism could find themselves censored by social media platforms under orders from the government. A platform facing an up to A$109.2 million penalty has every incentive to suppress posts about protests that involved any unlawful act.
In July, the Institute of Public Affairs (IPA) presciently warned that the Bondi tragedy was being used by the government “as an excuse for internet censorship and surveillance.” Albanese has already said One Nation, a right-wing populist party in the mold of AfD and RN in Germany and France, would “peddle misinformation and disinformation.” When asked about whether the legislation would allow her to censor misinformation, Communications Minister Anika Wells said, “We can emphatically rule that out.” But the legislation would allow her to censor anything that “may cause serious harm.” Last year the Albanese government claimed anti-mass migration protesters were linked to neo-Nazis.
This could upset the Trump administration, which has made defending American social media platforms and free speech a high priority.
In December 2025, Secretary of State Marco Rubio barred the former top censor with the European Commission and the leaders of three censorship NGOs in Germany, Britain, and the United States, saying they “have advanced censorship crackdowns by foreign states.” And Rubio vowed to “expand this list if others do not reverse course.”
In February, a report by the House Judiciary Committee, headed by Trump ally Rep. @Jim_Jordan, revealed that Europeans had censored American social media companies for years by pressuring them to change their content moderation (censorship) rules and ”successfully pressured social media platforms to censor true information in the United States.” When the Commission’s vice president flew to California in 2024 to discuss “election preparations” with TikTok, the company asked whether she meant EU or US elections. The Commission replied, in writing, “We are interested in both.”
Australia’s social media regulator, Julie Inman Grant, the “eSafety Commissioner,” has tried to censor Americans in the past. When she ordered X to remove a stabbing video for users worldwide in 2024, a Federal Court Justice in Australia declined to extend her injunction, saying that she “would be deciding what users of social media services throughout the world were allowed to see on those services.” She dropped the case that June. In November of last year, Jordan wrote to Inman Grant and called her a “noted zealot for global takedowns.”
On Monday, a reporter asked Albanese if he was worried about upsetting Trump. “We know that some, at least some of these big tech companies are already making very clear they don’t like these changes,” noted a reporter. “Some of these, you know, the heads or the owners of these companies are quite friendly with Donald Trump. How are you going to handle that if they raise this as an issue with the US President and he in turn arcs up about it?”
Albanese said, “Look, we’re a sovereign nation, we decide our policies based upon the Australian national interest. I as Prime Minister will do that regardless of what the issue is. But my relationship with the US President is indeed very good and I look forward to seeing President Trump in New York in a couple of weeks’ time.”
The Trump administration may do nothing, and left-of-center leaders abroad have learned that a fight with Trump can pay. Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva saw his approval rise from 40% to 43% after Trump announced 50% tariffs on Brazilian goods in July 2025. In November 2025, Trump lifted 40% tariffs on Brazilian beef, coffee, cocoa, and fruit. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said the administration wanted to “focus on affordability.” Australia has similar leverage, supplying the minerals that Trump said would arrive in such quantity that “you won’t know what to do with them.”
But a few hours ago a White House spokesman said President Trump had “unequivocally warned” trading partners about “digital services taxes, fines and other forms of extortion” on US companies. “The administration remains committed to raising these issues with our trading partners....”
x.com/shellenberger/status/2097507174305919216
Please subscribe now to support Public’s defense of free speech and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You can see why these guys are desperate to censor X. @elonmusk
Polymarket
@Polymarket
JUST IN: 𝕏 has surged to #1 among news apps in nearly all European countries.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This woman can’t even say how she will decide what causes harm. This is the woman who wants to censor the entire global Internet
They’re so desperate to censor their populist enemies that they will sacrifice Australia’s mining deal with Trump to do it x.com/TruthFairy131/status/2097652923354505639/video/1
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
And there it is
Senator Babet
@senatorbabet
A Labor Minister has come out and said that one of the reasons they are looking to censor algorithms on social media is because and I quote - "it’s one of the of the factors in the rise of Right Wing populists around the world."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
John Macgowan
@john_macgowan
Basically the Australian Government funds the activists who artificially create the justification for their policies which are then amplified by journalists who are also paid for by grant programs, then the majority of people who agree with these positions are being paid by the government to work in the public service or in adjacent government funded roles like the NDIS. It's one giant circular economy, paid for by the taxes of the minority of Australians who actually produce things.
Jordan Abouzeid
@Jordanwabouzeid
The Digital Duty of Care movement is completely fake.
"Teach us Consent" the NGO that inspired the Governments new attack on free speech recived 2.4 million dollars in Government funding last year.
The Government is creating these political movements out of thin air. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Look closely at this woman. She wants to censor the entire global Internet with the “eSafety Minister,” who has been trying to do this for years. If their new censorship bill becomes law, these two women will be able to censor any content they say “may cause serious harm.”
Sandy Yang
@SandyXiaotong
INTERNET CENSORSHIP: Watch Communications minister Anika Wells explain that she gets to decide what will be banned on the internet. Watch
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
From @Ptcnews24
“Labor’s new digital duty of care is a masterclass in policy deception. Sold as yet another tool to protect children online, it is about control, not care, and adults are the primary target…
But this digital duty of care is really about handing enormous powers to government to decide what is harmful content. It’s a massive assault on free speech that’s
motivated by Labor’s growing fear that the rise of populist parties on the right is being en abled via greater access to non-traditional media voices.
For a long time, Labor has waged a war against the Murdoch media, with former prime minister Kevin Rudd famously even trying to get up a royal commission. Never
mind that newspapers such as this have been just as tough on the Coalition as its opponents; Labor’s modus operandi is to destroy those who disagree with its world
view rather than debate them.
Already we have federal taxpayers shelling out $67.6m to “protect trusted news services” under Labor’s Journalism Assistance Fund and some 184 commercial
players, big and small, all receive a sling. But not so News Corp.
And now this legislation, designed to curtail free speech and hand Communications Minister Anika
Wells unfettered powers to act as Australia’s information umpire.
In a trainwreck interview with my colleague Laura Jayes on News24 on Wednesday, minister Wells was forced to admit that, via regulation, she would determine what
content was harmful, with advice from Australia’s eSafety Commissioner, Julie Inman-Grant. That the scope of these regulations will not be known at the time MPs’
vote on the legislation says it all.”
🎯👏🏼🌹
www.theaustralian.com.au/commentary/labors-duty-of-care-i…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
There are nearly 700 comments and I don’t see a single one supporting censorship. The commenters understand that this is about suppressing @AlboMP ‘s political enemies
www.news24.com.au/politics/australian-politics/communicat…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Bingo
John Macgowan
@john_macgowan
Basically the Australian Government funds the activists who artificially create the justification for their policies which are then amplified by journalists who are also paid for by grant programs, then the majority of people who agree with these positions are being paid by the government to work in the public service or in adjacent government funded roles like the NDIS. It's one giant circular economy, paid for by the taxes of the minority of Australians who actually produce things.
Jordan Abouzeid
@Jordanwabouzeid
The Digital Duty of Care movement is completely fake.
"Teach us Consent" the NGO that inspired the Governments new attack on free speech recived 2.4 million dollars in Government funding last year.
The Government is creating these political movements out of thin air. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Rn_Lilydale
@rn_lilydale
Yesterday in Canberra, the Albanese government released legislation to deliver a so called "Digital Duty of Care.". This is not about care. It is about control. It's about internet censorship. Everyone needs to understand that free speech is gravely threatened if this becomes law.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Lisa
@Lisa9Sophia
Rumour has it the White House could counter Labor’s latest free speech attack and internet censorship attempt, by dumping the Critical Minerals Agreement
That would be devastating to our economy
China would love it. Labor would love it. The government could go running to China and let them buy our critical minerals
Very convenient, but dreadful for our democracy
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Since Trump returned to power, Australia's Prime Minister, @AlboMP, has boasted about their relationship. But now, with his new demand for sweeping online censorship, Albanese is willing to sacrifice his nation's coveted minerals deal so he can silence critics of mass migration.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
News24 Australia
@News24Aust
Communications Minister Anika Wells has admitted Labor’s internet regime will police news websites amid concerns about censorship.
www.news24.com.au/news/anika-wells-admits-labors-algorith… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Lozzy B 🇦🇺𝕏
@TruthFairy131
Q: “Who Decides the definition of Harm online for censorship?”
Anika Wells- Corrupt Labor Politician that was caught stealing hundreds of thousands from Taxpayers: “I Guess… Me”
This is insane.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Sandy Yang
@SandyXiaotong
INTERNET CENSORSHIP: Watch Communications minister Anika Wells explain that she gets to decide what will be banned on the internet. Watch
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The people who are today claiming @elonmusk used space lasers to steal the election for Trump said, just a few years ago, that anyone who claimed there was election fraud in 2020, including Trump, should be silenced, censored, and possibly even jailed.
VANITY FAIR
@VanityFair
In one of the most explosive moments of ‘Musk,’ the new documentary from filmmaker Alex Gibney, Elon Musk's ex-lover Ashley St. Clair suggests that Musk interfered with the 2024 election, recalling that he left the Mar-a-Lago celebration early and later told her he knew it would go in Trump’s favor.
St. Clair says that Musk had a “degree of certainty” about the results before they came in that “I had never seen before.” And told him she didn’t want to know more because she didn’t want to be “deposed,” to which, according to St. Clair, Musk replied that she was wise www.vanityfair.com/story/elon-musk-documentary-alex-gibne… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Big Brother Watch
@BigBrotherWatch
🚨BREAKING🚨
We've just installed giant billboards in London to stop the censorship crisis in Britain - pushing back censorial laws & speech policing.
@andyburnham launch a free speech reset now.
Join the fight to restore free speech in Britain⤵️
bigbrotherwatch.org.ukThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Before @ElonMusk bought Twitter, you couldn't notice that foreigners committed most of the group rapes in Germany, despite being just 15% of the population. By lifting censorship, says @Pauline__Voss, Musk unleashed a “vibe shift” that led to @AfD's historic victory.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For years, Germany’s established parties, backed by nearly all of its major media, maintained a “firewall” (Brandmauer) between themselves and the anti-mass-migration party Alternative for Germany (AfD).
“The firewall is probably the most important and the most powerful tool of the left parties in Germany,” Pauline Voss, a politics reporter for the German news outlet NIUS, told Public in an interview on Monday. “And strangely, the CDU, the conservative party, adopted and integrated this firewall into their own politics,” despite the two parties’ overlapping agendas.
That firewall began to break down on Sunday, when the AfD won a historic victory in the eastern state of Saxony-Anhalt. “For the first time it was possible for the AfD to gain power, to be the winner, not only the winner of an election, but maybe in the end to be part of the government,” Voss said.
In 2020, after a Free Democrat politician won the premiership of Thuringia with AfD and CDU votes, Chancellor Angela Merkel called the vote “unforgivable” and said the result “must be reversed.” The winner resigned within two days, and Germany’s Constitutional Court later ruled that Merkel’s demand had violated the AfD’s right to equal competition.
“The voters of the AfD have waited for this for a very long time,” Voss said, and the party “overperformed a little bit, like 1 or 2%.” The party took 43.8% of the vote, more than double the 20.8% it won in 2021, while Chancellor Friedrich Merz’s CDU fell to 17.2%. The AfD also mobilized roughly 170,000 people who had not voted last time, its largest single source of new support...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2097032460408381525
The work of Public is essential to debunking government and media propaganda. We are 100% supported by our paying subscribers. Please subscribe to support our work, read the rest of the article and watch the full video.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
water turns out to be wet
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Last year I wrote up Lorenz Guenther’s badly underrated account of the “real reason” many voters are gravitating toward right-populist parties — a large minority of voters strongly agrees with them about immigration and crime.
www.slowboring.com/p/a-boring-theory-of-the-populist-right
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Well, there you have it
Polymarket
@Polymarket
JUST IN: 𝕏 has surged to #1 among news apps in nearly all European countries.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Reporters use the label "far right" 3 to 14 times more often than "far left." The term implies that the parties opposing mass migration are undemocratic. In fact, they're winning elections. The real fascists are the ones censoring, banning, and prosecuting their enemies.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Political parties that oppose mass migration are “far-right,” according to most of the mainstream news media.
The Associated Press reported on Sunday that “the far-right Alternative for Germany was projected to win a strong victory in a regional election,” and characterized the party as “anti-migration and Russia-friendly.”
Reuters called France’s presidential front-runner the “far-right candidate Marine Le Pen.” AP described Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni as “the head of a far-right party” who “backs curbing migration and promoting traditional values.” Euronews labeled both her Brothers of Italy party and Matteo Salvini’s League as “far-right.”
Others describe Reform UK as a “far-right political party” and call its head, Nigel Farage, “leader of the far-right, anti-immigration party Reform UK.”
The label implies that these parties are fascist, but by the standards of scholars who study fascism, they are not.
Roger Griffin, who wrote in 2020 that members of the International Association of Comparative Fascist Studies had “broadly adopted” his definition of fascism as “a revolutionary form of ultranationalism,” and that “none of the leaders of illiberal democracies are actually fascist,” and that the danger of parties like the Rassemblement National “is precisely that they are NOT fascist.”
Tim Bale of Queen Mary University of London noted that the term “far right” is a “loaded, weaponised term” likely to “cause confusion and controversy in equal measure.”
Even Gideon Rachman of the Financial Times, who is hostile to right-wing populists, admitted in 2024 that “if a party pushes policies that liberals regard as unpleasant, reactionary or even racist but does that within the framework of democratic politics and the rule of law, the term ‘far right’ may no longer be appropriate.” And Rachman said Meloni “to date has looked like a relatively conventional conservative in power...”
x.com/shellenberger/status/2097365525948973186
Every day, Public works to hold the media accountable for its misinformation. We are 100% supported by our paying subscribers. Please subscribe now to support our work and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
i/o
@avidseries
I was repeatedly suspended and ultimately indefinitely locked out of Twitter in the pre-Musk era for doing nothing more than tweeting European government statistics on immigrant crime and welfare dependency.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Before @ElonMusk bought Twitter, you couldn't notice that foreigners committed most of the group rapes in Germany, despite being just 15% of the population. By lifting censorship, says @Pauline__Voss, Musk unleashed a “vibe shift” that led to @AfD's historic victory.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pauline Voss
@Pauline__Voss
Merz setzt nach dem fulminanten Sieg der AfD nun vollends auf die autoritäre Einschüchterung seiner politischen Gegner. Von allen Schwertern, die die Bundesregierung gegen eine AfD-Regierung in Sachsen-Anhalt einsetzen könnte, wäre der Bundeszwang eines der schärfsten. Er ermöglicht es der Bundesregierung, in die Souveränität eines Bundeslandes einzugreifen. Und genau dieses Szenario bereitet der Kanzler nun rhetorisch vor: In der heutigen Pressekonferenz beschwor er ausgerechnet beim Thema Migration die sogenannte „Bundestreue“ (Art. 28 Abs. 3 im Grundgesetz). Wird gegen das Prinzip der Bundestreue verstoßen, so könnte der Bundeszwang zum Einsatz kommen. Über die Einwanderungs- und Ausländerpolitik sagt Merz: „In den Grundzügen wird diese in Berlin entschieden und nicht in Magdeburg.“ Bedeutet: Merz droht einer potenziellen AfD-Regierung mit dem Bundeszwang, sollte sie einen härteren Kurs in der Migration fahren.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
The truth shall set you free
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Before @ElonMusk bought Twitter, you couldn't notice that foreigners committed most of the group rapes in Germany, despite being just 15% of the population. By lifting censorship, says @Pauline__Voss, Musk unleashed a “vibe shift” that led to @AfD's historic victory.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
David Ágape
@david_agape_
Excelente artigo do Shellenberger. Ele conseguiu explicar a situação brasileira pros gringos. Um baita desafio!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
When Trump lifted sanctions against Brazil's censorial Supreme Court Justice Moraes, President Lula's own police had evidence of the judge's corruption. Trump could now re-impose sanctions on Moraes based on the historically massive bank fraud.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
When Trump lifted sanctions against Brazil's censorial Supreme Court Justice Moraes, President Lula's own police had evidence of the judge's corruption. Trump could now re-impose sanctions on Moraes based on the historically massive bank fraud.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Last December, Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva struck a sweeping deal with President Donald Trump that included lifting sanctions on Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes.
In the spring of 2024, David Ágape, Eli Vieira, and I published “Twitter Files - Brazil,” which showed that Moraes had secretly and illegally demanded Twitter’s censorship of Lula’s political enemies. Shortly after, the owner of Twitter, now-X, Elon Musk, criticized Moraes and defied Moraes’s orders. Moraes responded by temporarily blocking X in Brazil in August 2024.
X fought for months but ultimately paid $5.2 million in fines, banned 223 accounts, and promised to operate “within the boundaries of the law,” after Moraes froze Musk’s Starlink assets. The Prosecutor General opened up an investigation of Ágape, Vieira, and I, and Ágape and Vieira had to flee the country.
In July 2025, President Donald Trump imposed trade tariffs on Brazil and imposed sanctions on Moraes for censorship and for prosecuting former President Jair Bolsonaro. Trump later lifted the tariffs and sanctions on Moraes, reportedly out of concern for the impact on food prices, particularly beef.
Lula later said at an event with Moraes that Trump had asked him whether lifting the financial sanctions on Moraes was good for him personally, and that Lula answered it was good for Brazilian democracy. Lula then turned to Moraes, who was standing next to him, and said, “Your victory, Alexandre, is the victory of Brazilian democracy.”
Today the evidence is overwhelming that Moraes’ victory was a defeat for Brazilian democracy. What Trump could not have known at the time was that Lula’s Federal Police held evidence that a banker jailed in a historically massive fraud had paid millions to Moraes’ wife and had spent his final free weeks texting a number attributed to Moraes himself, apparently about the justice’s protection of him from prosecution.
The same people who censored Bolsonaro’s movement also used censorship to protect some of the most corrupt people in Brazil’s long history of corruption, starting with the Supreme Court justices....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2096939056961569050
Exposing censorship and lawfare across the West helps defeat it here. Please subscribe now to support our defense of free speech and to read the rest of the articleThis post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
No country did more to make the case for free speech over the last 300 years than Britain. And yet it has made over 62,000 arrests over the last five years for "communications offences," which have included doing nothing more than watching a TikTok video. It's terrifying just how totalitarian the UK has become.
Silkie Carlo
@silkiecarlo
🚨 NEWS: Our groundbreaking new investigation into the scale of Britain’s free speech crisis is front page of the Mail on Sunday today.
Time for @andyburnham to listen - we want a free speech reset.
I’ve written to him today calling for an urgent review into our laws on speech
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Many people are pointing out that the US did as much, if not more. I agree that the US did as much. Our First Amendment is the gold standard for free speech, and the Supreme Court's rulings in the 20th Century are historic. I don't think it did more because most of the major intellectual arguments for free speech were made by the English before 1776, and both Madison and Jefferson were British subjects.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Silkie Carlo
@silkiecarlo
🚨 NEWS: Our groundbreaking new investigation into the scale of Britain’s free speech crisis is front page of the Mail on Sunday today.
Time for @andyburnham to listen - we want a free speech reset.
I’ve written to him today calling for an urgent review into our laws on speech -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Madi Hilly
@MadiHilly
On my way from Paris to London after a warm night without air conditioning.
Just like it's a choice the French make not to install A/Cs, it's a choice they make to throttle their nuclear power in a heat wave.
As I point out in @AlexCKaufman's piece, there are multiple engineering solutions to warm rivers and drought.
Palo Verde was built in a desert outside of Phoenix and has run through 40 years of Arizona summers.
Anyone who says nuclear is unreliable and not suitable for a changing climate is outing themselves as someone who doesn't like or want nuclear. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Joe Sokol
@iAmJoeSokol
This is the most insane footage you will see in the Bangor, Maine universe....
....We have been officially invaded.
My friend Adam Stade Bangor Maine on a Facebook post shows us what happened. Go find his page and follow him.
Also, the only reason some of you know me is the Maine Wire, find them and follow them!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Elon Musk used "space lasers" to steal the election for Trump, @alexgibneyfilm alleges in his new HBO movie. But that conspiracy theory was debunked in 2024. And there is no evidence to support Gibney's claim that Musk stole federal data to corrupt future elections.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Elon Musk may have used his Starlink satellites to steal the 2024 election for Donald Trump, according to a new Alex Gibney documentary seen by The Hollywood Reporter (THR).
“Two revelations, or at least intimations, especially stand out,” writes Steven Zeitchik. The first is an allegation by “Musk ex and former conservative influencer Ashley St. Clair, a central figure in the documentary,” who says Musk had a “degree of certainty” about the elections that “I had never seen before.”
She says Musk told her, “I have ten thousand lasers in space.”
“So you think he was referring to Starlink?” asks Gibney, who has made a series of films about frauds including “Enron,” “Scientology,” and “The Inventor,” about Elizabeth Holmes’s start-up Theranos.
“I mean, I don’t know where else he has space lasers,” replies St. Clair.
According to Zeitchik, Gibney “hints he is taking it seriously when he then says in his patented voiceover, ‘What is Elon building, what are his goals, what are his actual motivations, and do we even know this man at all?’”
But election officials in North Carolina, Georgia, and Pennsylvania confirmed what most journalists and people in politics already knew, which is that voting equipment is not connected to the internet. “Our election equipment is 100% air-gapped,” said Georgia elections spokesman Mike Hassinger, who called the claims “absolutely conspiratorial nonsense.”
And fact-checkers hostile to Musk debunked the Starlink theory in November 2024. factcheck.org quoted a Georgia official saying “No Georgia election tabulation is connected to the internet, ever, not by Starlink or anything else.” PolitiFact rated the theory “Pants on Fire.” Poynter traced the theory to Threads posts from despairing Democrats “amid a larger wave of election denial claims from liberals that mimic Republicans’ false claims about 2020 election fraud.”
And yet at no point in the over 5,000-word THR article does Zeitchik ever mention the fact-checks. Zeitchik did not respond to Public’s request for comment, though THR did, as we describe below...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2095891257293693075
Public plays an essential public service in debunking media misinformation. We are only able to do so thanks to our paying subscribers. Become a paying subscriber today to support our award-winning investigative reporting and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
x.com/shellenberger/status/2095938482703159756
Public plays an essential role in debunking media misinformation. We are only able to do so thanks to our paying subscribers. Become a paying subscriber today to support our award-winning investigative reporting and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I just received a second email from THR's Roshan. "Reporting material contained in a major documentary is not the same as adopting it as an independently established conclusion by THR," he wrote. "The story does not report that voting equipment was connected to Starlink, that Starlink altered vote totals or that Musk rigged the 2024 election."
But nobody asked whether it did. My question cited the story's own description of the texts as "revelations, or at least intimations," and asked why THR withheld from readers the fact that election officials, the Associated Press, and three fact-checking organizations dismissed the theory in November 2024.
Roshan's reply never mentioned the debunkings.
He also declined to answer my six remaining questions, including whether THR will correct the errors that stand in the piece.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
x.com/shellenberger/status/2095938482703159756
Public plays an essential role in debunking media misinformation. We are only able to do so thanks to our paying subscribers. Become a paying subscriber today to support our award-winning investigative reporting and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
Lmao
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Elon Musk may have used his Starlink satellites to steal the 2024 election for Donald Trump, according to a new Alex Gibney documentary seen by The Hollywood Reporter (THR).
“Two revelations, or at least intimations, especially stand out,” writes Steven Zeitchik. The first is an allegation by “Musk ex and former conservative influencer Ashley St. Clair, a central figure in the documentary,” who says Musk had a “degree of certainty” about the elections that “I had never seen before.”
She says Musk told her, “I have ten thousand lasers in space.”
“So you think he was referring to Starlink?” asks Gibney, who has made a series of films about frauds including “Enron,” “Scientology,” and “The Inventor,” about Elizabeth Holmes’s start-up Theranos.
“I mean, I don’t know where else he has space lasers,” replies St. Clair.
According to Zeitchik, Gibney “hints he is taking it seriously when he then says in his patented voiceover, ‘What is Elon building, what are his goals, what are his actual motivations, and do we even know this man at all?’”
But election officials in North Carolina, Georgia, and Pennsylvania confirmed what most journalists and people in politics already knew, which is that voting equipment is not connected to the internet. “Our election equipment is 100% air-gapped,” said Georgia elections spokesman Mike Hassinger, who called the claims “absolutely conspiratorial nonsense.”
And fact-checkers hostile to Musk debunked the Starlink theory in November 2024. factcheck.org quoted a Georgia official saying “No Georgia election tabulation is connected to the internet, ever, not by Starlink or anything else.” PolitiFact rated the theory “Pants on Fire.” Poynter traced the theory to Threads posts from despairing Democrats “amid a larger wave of election denial claims from liberals that mimic Republicans’ false claims about 2020 election fraud.”
And yet at no point in the over 5,000-word THR article does Zeitchik ever mention the fact-checks. Zeitchik did not respond to Public’s request for comment, though THR did, as we describe below...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2095891257293693075
Public plays an essential public service in debunking media misinformation. We are only able to do so thanks to our paying subscribers. Become a paying subscriber today to support our award-winning investigative reporting and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You miserable grifters. It was a landslide. There is zero evidence climate change played any role whatsoever. And Nepal could have used the billions USAID & the UN gave it to install cheap sensors and sirens but held “gender inclusion” workshops instead.
x.com/shellenberger/status/2095134169646973021
TIME
@TIME
"The climate disasters in Nepal are the essence of climate injustice. Those least responsible for climate change are the worst affected and the least equipped to recover," writes Sumnima Udas, a member of Parliament in Nepal. time.com/article/2026/09/02/climate-change-melting-glacie…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@CommunityNotes for the win
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Hi @Benioff @TIME Why haven't you corrected this? You care about Nepal, yes?
-
TIME
@TIME
"The climate disasters in Nepal are the essence of climate injustice. Those least responsible for climate change are the worst affected and the least equipped to recover," writes Sumnima Udas, a member of Parliament in Nepal. time.com/article/2026/09/02/climate-change-melting-glacie…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It was a rockslide you idiots
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Now that satellite images prove that failing bedrock, not a glacier, caused the flooding in Nepal, journalists are blaming melting permafrost. But there’s no evidence for that, either. In truth, scientists and journalists have been lying for decades about climate change and ice.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For decades, climate scientists said climate change was apocalyptic. It never was, as new UN scenarios prove. Scientists knew this and pushed a falsified scenario anyway. Now exposed, the scientists are falsely claiming that it was their policies that averted catastrophe.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
As of today, only a handful of people understand just how inappropriate the behavior of this small group of activist climate scientists was.
Their deliberate deception contributed to the destruction of energy-intensive industries in several nations, including Germany.
They contributed to a childhood anxiety epidemic across the Western world that is ongoing and includes people deciding not to have children.
And they successfully demanded that the media demonize, universities fire, and social media platforms censor those who exposed their many lies.
The number of people who understand what these individuals did will increase significantly.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
If the lies about climate change have disturbed you, please subscribe now to read the whole article. The extent of the misconduct it documents is far worse than most people realize:
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You guys are pathetic. They had plenty of USAID and UN money but spent it on “nature-based solutions” and “gender inclusion” workshops rather than sensors and sirens.
CNN is Pravda for woke malthusians
x.com/shellenberger/status/2094460296467202146
CNN
@CNN
In January 2025, the Trump administration cut off funding for a long-running natural hazards program that aimed to identify and monitor landslide hotspots in Nepal. While the program the administration cut would not have been able to prevent the disaster that happened this past week, it represented a first step towards making those kinds of protections possible in a future where they are going to be needed more.
CLARIFICATION: This headline and story have been updated to better reflect the extent of the Project SERVIR-Hindu Kush Himalaya program. www.cnn.com/2026/09/02/climate/nepal-disaster-grant-cance…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
CNN
@CNN
In January 2025, the Trump administration cut off funding for a long-running natural hazards program that aimed to identify and monitor landslide hotspots in Nepal. While the program the administration cut would not have been able to prevent the disaster that happened this past week, it represented a first step towards making those kinds of protections possible in a future where they are going to be needed more.
CLARIFICATION: This headline and story have been updated to better reflect the extent of the Project SERVIR-Hindu Kush Himalaya program. www.cnn.com/2026/09/02/climate/nepal-disaster-grant-cance…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You guys are pathetic. They had plenty of money but spent it on “nature-based solutions” and gender workshops rather than the sensors and sirens. You’re not journalists you’re propagandists.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Climate change caused Nepal's deadly flooding, say the media. It's nonsense. In truth, climate activists diverted billions in USAID and UN climate funding from low-cost flood death prevention, mostly sensors and sirens, proven to save lives, into woke green ESG nonsense.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
That one must write a sentence like “But rocks have always fallen off of mountains” tells you all you need to know about the sorry state of climate science and journalism.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Now that satellite images prove that failing bedrock, not a glacier, caused the flooding in Nepal, journalists are blaming melting permafrost. But there’s no evidence for that, either. In truth, scientists and journalists have been lying for decades about climate change and ice.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Anthropogenic climate change caused a glacier to melt, triggering the Nepal floods, said scientists and journalists immediately following the disaster.
“Climate change is heating up the Himalayas and supercharging the risk of disasters like the deadly flash flooding in Nepal and Tibet,” the New York Times reported on August 27 under the headline “Climate Change Raises Risk of Disasters Like Nepal Floods.”
Explained the Times, “As humans warm the planet by burning fossil fuels, the Himalayas are losing their permafrost” and “the thawing permafrost is destabilizing the foundation underneath glaciers, raising the risks of precisely these kinds of landslides and glacial collapses.”
It quoted Ashim Sattar of the Indian Institute of Technology Bhubaneswar: “There’s a very straight link between climate change and these types of disasters.” Alton Byers of the University of Colorado told the Times, “Permafrost has been the cryospheric glue that’s held the rock and the ice and the glaciers together for millennia, and now we’re getting increasing evidence that it’s being weakened by warming trends.”
Three days later the Times told readers that “one thing seems certain: The risk of such events is increasing.”
But new satellite imagery reveals that the bedrock beneath the glacier collapsed, bringing the glacier down on top of it.
“You have this big bedrock failure that took part of the glacier with it,” said geomorphologist Dan Shugar. His colleague Kristen Cook described it as “a collapse of a large piece of bedrock that was sitting below the glacier. The ground underneath the glacier collapsed and took the glacier with it.”
Another glaciologist, Jakob Steiner, agreed, explaining that “You basically had the lower part of a glacier tongue that sheared off because the rock below failed.” Cook told the New York Times that “The rock that the glacier was sitting on collapsed.”
And yet the Times headline is “Landslide Along With Glacial Collapse Likely Set Off Nepal Flooding, Scientists Say,” which is misleading in that it was the landslide that brought down the glacier. “Essentially, a chunk of the mountainside collapsed,” Shugar told the Times....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2095133852863713365
Public is holding scientists and journalists accountable for spreading misinformation and censoring the truth. We are supported entirely by paying subscribers. Please subscribe now to support our award-winning investigative journalism and to read the rest of the story.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
That one must write a sentence like “But rocks have always fallen off of mountains” tells you all you need to know about the sorry state of climate science and journalism.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Katherine van K
@kattitfortat
“Under modern feminist logic, the worst thing a woman can do—kill her children—makes her a righteous martyr and an icon of “women’s mental health.” Women on social media seem to be asserting that they have no real agency, they are controlled by their hormones, and they cannot be held to the same standards as men. The Lindsay Clancy case may be remembered for highlighting this baffling contradiction at the heart of modern feminism: a demand for equality coupled with a demand for extreme coddling and abdication of all responsibility”.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ana Paula Henkel
@anapaulahenkel
Alexandre de Moraes precisa ser expulso do Supremo Tribunal Federal.
E ir direto para a prisão. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
Moraes passou anos prendendo e censurando pessoas por supostamente disseminarem "fake news" (muitas vezes críticas ao STF). Agora, sabemos que ele mentiu para proteger seus próprios interesses em relação ao escândalo bancário mais importante da história do Brasil, negando seu envolvimento no contrato da BM "com sua esposa".
Pesquisas Eleições
@EleicaoBr2026
▶️ MALU GASPAR: PF encontra digital de Moraes no contrato da esposa com Vorcaro
Metadados mostram que o contrato entre Viviane de Moraes e Daniel Vorcaro foi editado no Office do gabinete do ministro Alexandre de Moraes. Consultado pelo Estadão, ele confirmou a edição, dizendo apenas ter avaliado se havia impedimento.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
Editorial do @Estadao: "Moraes tem de sair do Supremo"
"Não tem mais condições de seguir como ministro do Supremo Tribunal Federal (STF) e deveria pedir exoneração do cargo, para o bem da própria Corte."
www.estadao.com.br/opiniao/moraes-tem-de-sair-do-supremo/ -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
alex gutentag
@galexybrane
Lindsay Clancy’s supporters have turned her into a martyr for “women’s mental health,” portraying her as a victim of her husband and doctors. Yet Lindsay had far more support than most postpartum women, she had no signs of real psychosis, and her actions were organized and methodical. The trial has exposed a glaring contradiction at the heart of modern feminism: a demand for equality coupled with a demand for extreme coddling and abdication of all responsibility.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The system failed Lindsay Clancy, many say, and she should thus be found not guilty by reason of insanity. But she was in control of her actions and knew what she did was wrong. The effort to turn Clancy into a victim stems from decades of feminist dogma. By @galexybrane
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
There are numerous revelations today that are beyond shocking about this judge and the huge corruption scandal engulfing him that make this prophecy closer than ever to becoming a reality:
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
One day, @Alexandre, this picture of you in prison will be real. Mark my words.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The system failed Lindsay Clancy, many say, and she should thus be found not guilty by reason of insanity. But she was in control of her actions and knew what she did was wrong. The effort to turn Clancy into a victim stems from decades of feminist dogma. By @galexybrane
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Feminist Victimhood Dogma Behind Demands To Blame Lindsay Clancy’s Killing Of Her Children On Insanity
The alleged murderer was in control of her actions, knew what she did was wrong, and is thus criminally responsible
by Alex Gutentag @galexybrane
The basic story of the Lindsay Clancy case presented on social media is one about women’s mental health and inadequate postpartum care.
Lindsay was suffering from postpartum psychosis and heard a commanding voice that told her to strangle her three children, Cora (5), Dawson (3), and Callan (8 months), in January 2023, many believe.
She was haphazardly prescribed 13 different medications by psychiatrists, was rejected by a postpartum outpatient program, and was dismissed by suicide hotlines. In this narrative, Lindsay was “failed” by her husband, her doctors, and “the system.”
Her supporters have raised over $1 million for her parents, and hundreds of women gathered outside the courthouse on August 20 to support her, wearing pink clothing displaying phrases like “She Needed Help” and “Justice for Lindsay.” Fans of her lawyer greeted and hugged him outside the courthouse yesterday, saying, “You’re the voice of so many moms.”
Yet Lindsay’s claims of psychiatric neglect and lack of care are fundamentally inaccurate.
Lindsay had far more assistance than most women. She received 18 weeks of maternity leave with the option to extend it, and two of her children went to daycare. She had a competent nanny and help from her parents, and her husband, Patrick Clancy, worked from home. Lindsay’s psychiatrists and nurses were highly responsive to her requests and needs.
The reason she had so many prescriptions was in part because she went to different doctors and did not stick to one plan. Lindsay voluntarily left an inpatient program and was not coldly “turned away” from postpartum mental health treatment, but was instead given other options for her generalized anxiety and depression. When Lindsay called the suicide hotline, she disclosed no specific plan to hurt herself or anyone else.
The jury in her trial today told the judge that they could not reach a verdict, and the judge asked them to continue deliberations. Since the jury was not sequestered, it is easy to imagine that both the news media and social media may have influenced the deadlock. On TikTok and Instagram, users have advanced the conspiracy theory that Patrick Clancy was the real killer....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2094851791179391415
Public provides an essential public service debunking false claims. Our work is 100% subscriber-funded. Please subscribe now to support our work and read the rest of this insightful article by Alex Gutentag.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Climate change caused Nepal's deadly flooding, say the media. It's nonsense. In truth, climate activists diverted billions in USAID and UN climate funding from low-cost flood death prevention, mostly sensors and sirens, proven to save lives, into woke green ESG nonsense.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Some are blaming a Chinese dam collapse for causing the floods, but the USGS and satellite imagery point to a natural cause in Nepal. China could be faulted some for not having done more to detect and warn, the story notes, but the fault fundamentally lies with the Nepalese government and the wrong priorities of climate activists.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The article offers a complete debunking of all the climate nonsense. Public plays an essential public service in debunking propaganda and revealing the truth. We are 100% reader-supported. Please subscribe now to support our award-winning investigative journalism and to read the rest of the article.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Karol Markowicz
@karol
Blue areas doing what blue areas do. From @NellieBowles today. www.thefp.com/p/tgif-have-yall-never-heard-of-noblesse
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Preston Byrne
@prestonjbyrne
AMERICA STRIKES BACK AGAINST FOREIGN CENSORS.
Y'day @RepMichaelRulli introduced the GRANITE Act, the first federal foreign censorship shield bill in American history. Full bill text + my analysis:
prestonbyrne.com/rulligranite -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
These unhoused folx will be so relieved to have that crosswalk! 💫💕
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Councilmember Nithya Raman
@cd4losangeles
The Los Feliz Neighborhood Council alerted our office in late 2025 to the need for a crosswalk at Sunset Dr. and Bates St., which has just been completed!
Thank you to our incredible CD4 Field Team for continuing to problem-solve, push for solutions, and make our streets safer.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
These unhoused folx will be so relieved to have that crosswalk! 💫💕
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Progressives thought they were on the right side of history. When they wake up to the reality that their policies resulted in the sterilization of children, the killing of mentally ill addicts, the decimation of education, and more, they will be horrified.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Yesterday, I described the now-overwhelming body of evidence that the Left, and not the Right, radicalized.
Researchers at the University of Cambridge’s Political Psychology Lab found that the Left had grown over ten times more extreme than the Right on core issues from 1988 to 2024.
That data is backed up by Gallup and Pew data showing a similarly dramatic asymmetric shift on the issues.
I noted that the people who radicalized the most were the college-educated, with postgraduates swinging left after 2010, while every less-educated bloc in America drifted right.
And yet many and often most progressives cling to clearly false beliefs.
They believe Anthony Fauci is a hero of science despite overwhelming evidence that Fauci promoted destructive school closures and universal vaccination against the best scientific evidence.
Progressives believe ICE is as bad as the Gestapo, or nearly so, a comparison that Democratic lawmakers made repeatedly.
They believe police kill unarmed black men by the hundreds or thousands every year out of racial bias, even though the Harvard economist Roland Fryer first found no racial difference in police shootings a decade ago, and newer benchmarking against crime rates and a 2023 review of more recent data have come to the same conclusion.
The Left still believes Trump and Republicans are fascists and came within hours of overthrowing the government on January 6. Progressives believe climate change threatens life on Earth.
They support “gender affirming” surgeries on adolescents, even though a 2024 study of more than 90 million patient records found that adults who underwent such surgery attempted suicide at 12 times the rate of other emergency room patients and at nearly five times the rate of matched patients who had undergone tubal ligations or vasectomies...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2092627010623504714
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of civilization and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The idea that progressives won't ever wake up is silly defensive pessimism and ignores everything from heliocentrism to the germ theory to lobotomies.
On the trans medical scandal, many have already woken up, as I explain in the third paragraph, half the states have banned it, and the rest will too, hopefully sooner rather than later. Colorado voters are likely to ban it this year.
On race, it's almost already over. Look at Cambridge-Ghent Arday-Cofnas scandal. Read the liberal Atlantic. People are removing DEI references from their LinkedIn pages. AOC is trying to laugh it off. No major progressive is today defending the race madness.
On addiction, San Francisco has a recovery-focused mayor, not an addiction-enabling ("harm reduction" one).
Yes, LA, Seattle, and Portland are worse than ever but moderates have won there and will will win again and do what SF is doing.
On education, look around. Many progressive commentators are already insisting they were always already in favor of phonics and school discipline.
Pick up a history book. It is inevitable that all of these awful progressive policies will be repealed eventually. And many, many (of course not all, duh) progressives will wake up in horror — just as Nikki does in "Obsession." -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Gabriel Quadri
@g_quadri
Las responsabilidades horrendas de la Izquierda en Estados Unidos...
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Progressives thought they were on the right side of history. When they wake up to the reality that their policies resulted in the sterilization of children, the killing of mentally ill addicts, the decimation of education, and more, they will be horrified.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
While the Left's radicalization should not come as a surprise to anyone on X, it will to the vast majority of progressives (e.g., Democratic primary voters) who believe:
— Fauci is a hero of science, rationality, and compassion;
— Conservatives are censoring great books;
— ICE is as (or nearly as) bad as the Gestapo;
— anti-black racism is pervasive and crippling;
— Trump and Republicans are fascists;
— MAGA almost overthrew the government;
— transgenderism is a kind of homosexuality;
— toxic masculinity is omnipresent and oppressive;
— climate change is causing natural disasters...
...and much, much more.
If you don't believe me, just watch a few minutes of MS NOW, or just go talk to Democratic partisans.
And while the evidence of the Left's radicalization has been growing, what's new is the sheer accumulation of evidence on one side of the ledger.
While progressives and the media will no doubt try to ignore this reality for as long as they can, the evidence will eventually catch up with them, culturally, politically, or both. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
NEW: An absolutely bizarre case with huge implications for US National Security and Brazil:
The Biden-Era C.B.P. Fabricated an Immigration Document Used to Imprison a Top-Level Brazilian Official. A U.S. Federal Judge Just Ordered Full Disclosure to Find Out Who Did It. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Republicans radicalized and Democrats stayed the same, insisted the media repeatedly over the last 10 years. In truth, the opposite happened. The data is now overwhelming that it was the Left, not the Right, that grew more extreme.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Since 2016, mainstream news media, university professors, and Democratic politicians have argued that Trump and the Republicans grew extreme and that their extremism drove America’s polarization.
Ezra Klein, now a New York Times columnist, advanced this idea in his 2020 book, Why We’re Polarized, telling an interviewer, “If you’re talking about polarization, you have to talk about why the Republican Party has become a very different institution from the Democratic Party.” Asymmetric polarization, Klein said, “was a very big part of my story of American politics.”
New York University historian Ruth Ben-Ghiat declared in 2022: “The GOP is an authoritarian party now…It is a far-right party that has exited democracy,” she said. “It no longer has any interest in that.”
That September, President Biden told an audience outside Independence Hall that “Donald Trump and the MAGA Republicans represent an extremism that threatens the very foundations of our republic.”
And much of the mainstream news media over the last decade declared the Republicans a fascist party with Trump equivalent to Hitler.
But Republican voters never radicalized.
In February, researchers at the University of Cambridge’s Political Psychology Lab found the opposite of the conventional wisdom. “Right-leaning Americans have remained fairly stable in their positions for the last 35 years,” said senior author Lee de-Wit, who runs the lab, “and may feel left behind as half the country has shifted towards an ever more progressive outlook on many issues.”
De-Wit and coauthors sorted Americans by their opinions on actual issues rather than by party or ideological identity. They analyzed more than 35,000 responses to the American National Election Studies from 1988 to 2024, covering 14 core issues from abortion to health insurance to racial discrimination.
Pew’s own values surveys, running since 1994, point the same way on most cultural issues, showing Republicans holding flat or in some cases becoming more liberal. For example, between 1994 and 2017, the share of Republicans telling Pew that immigrants strengthen the country rose from 30% to 42%, a move toward the liberal position. Republican acceptance of homosexuality rose as well...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2092271652113732042
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism and to read the rest of the article!This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
While the Left's radicalization should not come as a surprise to anyone on X, it will to the vast majority of progressives (e.g., Democratic primary voters) who believe:
— Fauci is a hero of science, rationality, and compassion;
— Conservatives are censoring great books;
— ICE is as (or nearly as) bad as the Gestapo;
— anti-black racism is pervasive and crippling;
— Trump and Republicans are fascists;
— MAGA almost overthrew the government;
— transgenderism is a kind of homosexuality;
— toxic masculinity is omnipresent and oppressive;
— climate change is causing natural disasters...
...and much, much more.
If you don't believe me, just watch a few minutes of MS NOW, or just go talk to Democratic partisans.
And while the evidence of the Left's radicalization has been growing, what's new is the sheer accumulation of evidence on one side of the ledger.
While progressives and the media will no doubt try to ignore this reality for as long as they can, the evidence will eventually catch up with them, culturally, politically, or both. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We must refer to people by their preferred pronouns, say the media. No, we must not. Pronouns carry information about sex, which is encoded in our DNA, and nothing can change that. Lying about a person's sex is a fundamental betrayal of journalism.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
News media organizations in the United States and the United Kingdom believe it is factually accurate and ethical to refer to people by the pronouns they prefer.
The Associated Press Stylebook says that it recognizes “the need for a pronoun for people who don’t identify as a he or a she” and instructs journalists to use neither “biological sex” nor “both sexes,” since not everyone identifies with male or female.
The BBC’s news style guide states that “We generally use the term and pronoun preferred by the person in question, unless there are editorial reasons not to do so.”
In fact, it is wrong for journalists to use inaccurate pronouns. Pronouns in English carry information about sex, and readers understand “she” to mean a female. A man who identifies as a woman remains male, because sex is encoded in our DNA and no amount of hormones or surgery can change that.
Journalists should refer to people by their chosen names and treat every person, including trans-identified people, with respect. Names are a matter of personal choice and always have been. Reporters have always called people by the names they use, from pen names to stage names. NPR’s standards editor in 2013 was right to write that whistleblower Chelsea Manning’s request to be called Chelsea was “one NPR should respect.”
But NPR was wrong to use female pronouns to refer to Manning. Dignity does not require a false description of a person’s sex. When accuracy and respect come into conflict, journalists should choose accuracy. A respectful sentence can still say what the person believes and also point out that it is inaccurate.
Many people have grown used to the entirety of the legacy news media referring to men as women and women as men, which is why so many people praised Public’s recent article, which described the trans-identifying rector of Ghent University as a “he.”
In reality, it is very strange that a profession committed to accuracy and ethics adopted language that is so totally inaccurate and unethical. How did this occur? How did people trained to verify facts come to print sentences they knew were false?...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2091916934866669672
Public is entirely reader-supported. Please subscribe now to support our award-winning journalism and to read the rest of the article:This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
One reason I am reflexively skeptical of the AI industry’s claims is that the very people we are supposed to hail as geniuses also completely failed to anticipate that branding their antichrist box the Best-Case-Mass-Layoffs-Worst-Cast-Extinction Machine was a non-savvy PR move.
Daniel
@growing_daniel
The anti-datacenter movement is literally the most rational response imaginable to an industry whose leaders have publicly said the best case scenario for their product is to get everyone fired. If you can’t see this then your brain is in late stage tech rot.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
On paper, France protects free speech. But President @EmmanuelMacron wants to shut down X and an independent TV network. In response, a former French Supreme Court justice is warning that Macron may impose sweeping censorship ahead of next year's presidential election.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
On paper, France protects free speech. “Article 11 of France’s 1789 Declaration of the Rights of Man states that freedom of speech is one ‘Of the most precious rights of humankind,’” explained Noëlle Lenoir, who served on France’s Supreme Court, known as the Constitutional Council, between 1992 and 2001. The European Convention on Human Rights, drafted after World War II, added the right to access different kinds of media. “That is to say, you can look at Fox News, you can watch CNN, and the government cannot limit the number of media because it doesn’t like the political orientation,” she said in a new podcast for Public.
But President Emmanuel Macron and the French left are increasing their attacks on free speech. “France is in danger,” said Lenoir, “and the future of democracy is at stake.” Their main target is CNews, the conservative cable channel owned by billionaire Vincent Bolloré, which the French left, given its success, likes to compare to France’s equivalent of Rupert Murdoch. Reporters Without Borders called the first CNews warning unprecedented — but then demanded more. “I know this isn’t unique to France,” she said over email, “but my country is starting to rank fairly high when it comes to trying to silence those who don’t think like those in power.”...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2091561504760074745
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of free speech, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
StudiGo
@StudiGo_LLC
“As a former public safety official of Denver told me, ‘You get what you allow.’ So if you allow street prostitution, you allow sexual assault, people living in tents, open-air drug dealing, that’s what you get.”
Journalist Michael Shellenberger (@shellenberger) speaking to @JesseBWatters on @FoxNews
via #studigo mobile studioThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Jonathan Choe
@choeshow
Anyone who says this is an affordable housing crisis is lying to you.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“Harm reduction” and “housing first” are why we have a “homeless” crisis. We need moderates to run for mayor in Seattle, LA, Denver and other cities where “progressives” who hate civilization weaponize the mentally ill and addicted to terrorize neighborhoods.
Jonathan Choe
@choeshow
Anyone who says this is an affordable housing crisis is lying to you.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
San Fransicko lays out how progressives create “homelessness” by ordering the police to not hospitalize and/or arrest addicts and mentally ill people who break anti-camping laws and are obviously a threat to themselves and others.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
T Wolf 🌁
@Twolfrecovery
When you get to the point of meth induced psychosis or living in a tent on the street, rent is the last thing on your mind. Shelter/treatment first. Housing earned. Nothing is free. @shellenberger @drdrew
Jonathan Choe
@choeshow
Anyone who says this is an affordable housing crisis is lying to you.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
T Wolf 🌁
@Twolfrecovery
I'm still amazed that California is all in on prohibition of flavored vape tobacco products for kids but send harm reductionists into schools to tell kids how to use fentanyl and meth "safely." Yes, that is happening.
www.cdph.ca.gov/Programs/CCDPHP/DCDIC/CTCB/Pages/CAFlavor… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Ghent University's rector has retaliated against the researcher who exposed Jason Arday's plagiarism. It turns out the rector, Petra de Sutter, violated his own university's policy against AI plagiarism last year.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Ghent University rector Petra De Sutter told students and faculty at the opening of the 2025 academic year that universities must protect free inquiry and debate. “In times of increasing polarization, the university has a duty to foster adversarial debate,” he said last September. “At a time when an individual’s feelings about climate change or vaccination seem to carry as much weight as years of research, it is all the more urgent that young people learn how to ask critical questions,” he said. “Doubt means that we dare to question convictions…” He then said, "'Dogma is the enemy of progress.' You might know it. It was Einstein who said this during his speech at the Sorbonne in 1929."
Today, eleven months later, De Sutter has suspended the researcher who exposed the plagiarism of Cambridge professor Jason Arday, who died last week in an apparent suicide. In a statement, De Sutter said, “the university takes the recent public statements made by a postdoctoral researcher at Ghent University regarding this matter very seriously. Ghent University has decided to take appropriate action within its powers and the applicable framework.”
Nathan Cofnas, the postdoctoral researcher, said today, “I was just suspended by Ghent University. They will almost certainly fire me.” Three hours earlier, Cofnas had written, “I am under investigation by my university for discriminating against Arday.” The university confirmed that it had “imposed a preventive suspension pending a preliminary disciplinary investigation.” It said it “is assessing whether there are sufficient grounds to refer the case to the competent disciplinary body for further action.”
A day earlier, the university had issued a statement signed by De Sutter and vice rector Herwig Reynaert that called Cofnas’s public statements “very serious.” Academic freedom, it said, “is not unlimited” and “goes hand in hand with responsibility and may be restricted in order to protect the rights of others.”
Even if Ghent keeps Cofnas on its payroll, the suspension punishes him for accurate reporting and violates the academic freedom De Sutter promised to protect. Cofnas published his findings last month after running Arday’s 2015 doctoral thesis through plagiarism software. He showed that large sections of Arday’s thesis matched, nearly word for word, a 2009 thesis by Paula Zwozdiak-Myers of Brunel University. The university’s letter complained of “complaints, reports, and concerning signals” about “various interviews” he gave. It said his conduct “reinforced concerns among the university’s community that your public interventions seem to develop into targeted campaigns of professional elimination.” It did not say Cofnas’ reporting was inaccurate.
It is notable that in De Sutter’s speech last fall, his quotes of Einstein, Hans Jonas, and Paul Verhaeghe were AI hallucinations. The Flemish investigative site Apache first reported this in January. Einstein never said “Dogma is the enemy of progress” at the Sorbonne in 1929. His appearance there that year consisted of a technical lecture on unified field theory. De Sutter called philosopher Hans Jonas “rector at the University of Munich” and claimed to have quoted from a “rectoral address in 1979.” But Jonas never served as rector in Munich and gave no such address. The third quotation, which De Sutter attributed to Ghent psychoanalyst Paul Verhaeghe’s essay on wisdom, does not appear in his essay....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2090529702649934274
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is some seriously sinister business
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This internal email from a tenured professor at Nathan Cofnas’ department shows not only that the “barrage” of complaints about the “negative effects on well-being” was perfectly coordinated, but that it was explicitly encouraged by rector Petra De Sutter herself. If this is true, she was actively egging on the hecklers in order to grant them a veto, which makes the whole affair even worse. /2
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
To the public, Hunter Biden’s laptop, Russiagate, and Hillary’s email server appeared to be separate and unrelated events. But they never were. In fact, the best way to understand them is as a single, decade-long FBI operation to deceive the American people.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Over the last decade, most of us experienced Hillary Clinton’s email server, the Trump-Russia collusion investigation, and Hunter Biden’s laptop as separate, unrelated controversies.
The FBI opened Midyear Exam, its investigation of Clinton’s private server, which held evidence of influence-peddling, in July 2015. One year later, then-Director James Comey closed it with a press conference, calling her “extremely careless” but recommending no charges; he did so without advising the Department of Justice, which was unusual and inappropriate.
Twenty-six days later, on July 31, 2016, the Bureau opened Crossfire Hurricane, a full counterintelligence investigation of the Trump campaign. Special Counsel John Durham concluded in 2023 that neither the FBI nor the intelligence community “appears to have possessed any actual evidence of collusion in their holdings at the commencement of the Crossfire Hurricane investigation.”
Finally, in December 2019, an FBI field office took possession of Hunter Biden’s laptop hard drive, and in October 2020, Twitter and Facebook suppressed the New York Post story about it after FBI warnings of a Russian “hack and leak.”
The news media covered each episode as its own drama with its own unique cast of characters, and framed each incident in such a way so that the very idea that the FBI was abusing its powers lay outside of the Overton window. The media covered the email server as much ado about nothing, at best, and Clinton’s recklessness, at worst. The media framed the Russia story as a case of Trump’s conflicts of interest, at best, and Putin’s direct control of him, at worst. And the laptop story was, at best, about Republican persecution of an innocent man and, at worst, about Hunter Biden’s reckless behavior.
In every case, the media framed FBI officials as, at best, dogged investigators and, at worst, overzealous. Outside of openly pro-Trump right-wing media, few journalists covered the stories as the FBI abusing their powers for partisan reasons.
But it is now clear that a single thread ran through all three investigations, and it was one of partisan FBI agents and officials abusing their power in ways as extreme as J. Edgar Hoover did in the 1960s....
They aren’t giving up — neither are we. Your subscription to Public is a two-for-one. It supports both our award-winning investigative journalism and our fight for free speech.
x.com/shellenberger/status/2090838172385329653
They aren’t giving up — neither are we. Your subscription to Public is a two-for-one. It supports both our award-winning investigative journalism and our fight for free speech.
x.com/shellenberger/status/2090838172385329653
P.S. Thank you to @emilyjashinsky for helping to articulate all of this.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Matt Calkins
@Matt_Calkins
After 11 years as a sports columnist at the Seattle Times, I have decided to resign. It was entirely my choice, and it was not an easy one. The impetus was the Times declining to run a column I wrote from the perspective of two female student athletes who were opposed to competing against biological males. It was one of several pieces of mine that had been spiked, and I no longer felt like I could properly do my job as a columnist. I lay out the situation in greater detail in the link below, but I want to say that I enjoyed my time with the paper, find the talent there to be immense, and have no animosity toward anyone who works there. It was just time for a change.
mattycee.substack.com/p/i-was-a-sports-columnist-at-the-s… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It's no coincidence that the Left demands censorship while enabling crime. Just yesterday, the UK Labour govt was caught giving pamphlets to illegal migrants, politely asking them not to rape, and the LA City Council legalized open-air drug encampments. It's anarcho-tyranny.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Demands for censorship fell dramatically over the last 18 months. Now, they are back with a vengeance. The reason is that censorship is one of the few causes that unites supposed liberals like @DAcemogluMIT and far-leftists like @ZackPolanski. The totalitarians just won't quit.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
They want to make this censorship global
Tyler Oliveira
@tyleraloevera
My video on Ireland’s Immigrant Invasion is BANNED in Ireland 😂 🇮🇪
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"Please don't rape our women and children"
Pathetic
Credit to @Express_Knowles
x.com/Express_Knowles/status/2090079180956319832
www.express.co.uk/news/politics/2240622/Migrants-asylum-g…
Michael Knowles
@Express_Knowles
Exclusive: Asylum seekers are being told “men and women are equal” in the UK amid mounting fears over integration and cultural values.
The Home Office has issued new guidance to arrivals telling them “this means women can work, study, travel and make their own choices”.
They also detail what rape is under UK law in a new booklet: "Consent is needed in every situation. This means even if you are married or in a relationship with someone, they must consent to sex every time.
"If you have sex with someone without their consent, this is called rape. Rape is a serious crime in the UK. You could go to prison, lose your support and accommodation, and it will affect your asylum claim."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“Please use our parks for raping and drug OD deaths”
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
There is nothing “empathic” about any of this. Quite the opposite
Cda
@Cdawynot
suicidal empathy
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
From sources in LA
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Michael Knowles
@Express_Knowles
Exclusive: I understand this guidance was signed off by Home Office ministers. And it is being translated into languages spoken by the biggest asylum seeker cohorts.
A source said: "We'll ensure there are no barriers to comprehension to ensure our laws are abided by."
Full piece dropping imminently, including Tory leader @KemiBadenoch's reaction. @Katie_Lam_MP tells the @Daily_Express: “The fact that this has to be spelled out at all is a damning indictment of the kind of people that the Government is letting into this country."
Michael Knowles
@Express_Knowles
Exclusive: Asylum seekers are being told “men and women are equal” in the UK amid mounting fears over integration and cultural values.
The Home Office has issued new guidance to arrivals telling them “this means women can work, study, travel and make their own choices”.
They also detail what rape is under UK law in a new booklet: "Consent is needed in every situation. This means even if you are married or in a relationship with someone, they must consent to sex every time.
"If you have sex with someone without their consent, this is called rape. Rape is a serious crime in the UK. You could go to prison, lose your support and accommodation, and it will affect your asylum claim." -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Demands for censorship fell dramatically over the last 18 months. Now, they are back with a vengeance. The reason is that censorship is one of the few causes that unites supposed liberals like @DAcemogluMIT and far-leftists like @ZackPolanski. The totalitarians just won't quit.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Governments must regulate the algorithms of social media companies to prevent harmful speech from going viral, says MIT economist and Nobel Prize winner Daron Acemoglu. The problem, he told Bloomberg, are “algorithmic feeds that essentially amplified the most incendiary material, the one that gets views because it’s extreme, that angers the other side and motivates your side to become even more vocal.”
But what Acemoglu is proposing is a direct violation of the First Amendment, which declares clearly that the government must not take any action that limits free speech. Demanding that social media companies manipulate their algorithms, which are simply the step-by-step instructions that social media companies use to deliver content users are interested in, is blatant censorship.
We exposed the censorship industrial complex. Now, four powerful figures in the same week say they want governments to control your feed. Subscribe to read why, and to support our worldwide defense of free speech. We depend entirely on paid subscribers.
Acemoglu insists that he is a “free speech absolutist.” He told economist @tylercowen that “We shouldn’t limit free speech,” “we should let individuals say whatever they want,” and “I never want to take your right away.”
But he then goes on to say that “I want to regulate what [sic] other people take your statement and how they use it.” In other words, Acemoglu is saying that he wants to let you say whatever you want, but prevent what you say from going viral if he doesn’t like it because he thinks it makes people too angry.
There’s no other word for what Acemoglu is describing than censorship. If we were still in the print era, this is the equivalent of saying authors should be able to write books, but the government should be able to decide how many copies are printed, depending on whether the government decides that it makes too many people angry. Under the Acemoglu rule, there would never have been a Declaration of Independence, Candide by Voltaire, or the Bible, for that matter.
“Why don’t you look at the printing press and say, ‘Oh my goodness, this was horrible! We need to restrict what books are put out by publishers!’?” asked Cowen.
Acemoglu responded that “when the printing press first came it was used in the religion wars… if I was alive during that period, I don’t know what my reaction to that would have been.” In fact, it’s obvious that Acemoglu’s reaction would have been to demand censorship.
And Acemoglu is hardly alone. Amnesty International and the Green Party of Britain both called for government censorship of the media over the last few days....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2090456420093415884
We helped expose the censorship industrial complex. Now, four powerful figures in the same week say they want governments to control your feed. Subscribe to read why, and to support our worldwide defense of free speech. We depend entirely on paid subscribers.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was just suspended by Ghent University. They will almost certainly fire me.
The decision was made by rector Petra De Sutter, a former leader of the Green Party. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
Minha nova coluna na @Folha sobre a tentativa de Flávio Dino e Moraes -- com o apoio da esquerda -- de ressuscitar e reimpor o esquema de 1969 da ditadura para controlar o jornalismo. Em 2009, o STF declarou que ele violava direitos constitucionais.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"46% of Democrats said they had lost a relationship with a friend, family member or romantic partner because of political differences, compared with 29% of Republicans...a higher share of Democrats also said they had initiated the break-ups" www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2026/08/11/why-lonely-re…
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Jeffrey Sachs
@JeffreyASachs
Unreal. @AmnestyUK (left) calls and n the UK government to engage in mass press censorship (“Arday’s Law” on right). Putin would dream of this sort of power. Oh, you published four stories in 48 hours? Sorry, you’re only allowed two. Madness.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Future 42
@future42org
Mayor Katie Wilson is so unpopular in her own city, Fox13 Seattle could not find a single supporter to go on camera to defend her.
Dan Griffin | @fox13seattle
'Seattle reacts to recall charges against Mayor Katie Wilson'
Article: www.fox13seattle.com/news/seattle-residents-react-recall-…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
To understand why DSA keeps winning, it's important to understand that after 2018, the DSA wing of the party (@AOC) reached an accommodation with the establishment wing (@SpeakerPelosi). The establishment wing would embrace the Woke/rad-Left culture agenda of BLM/DEI radicalism, open borders, & trans, while the DSA wing would sideline its populist economic agenda. Even @BernieSanders went along with this when he ran in 2020. And that strategy appeared to work with Biden's victory that year.
But then, since 2024, the DSA and Democratic base have skillfully blamed their loss on the establishment wing of the party, even though the radical issues the establishment lost on (open borders, DEI extremism, trans) all came from the DSA/rad-Left. The DSA/rad-Left then pivoted toward affordability/economic issues and backgrounded the unpopular culture war stuff.
I think Nothing Left by @evanwch is an important book because it contributes to a better understanding of what exactly happened within the party over the last decade. Evan also credits the rise of the progressive/rad Left of the Party to its growing savvy at things like fundraising.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Since the 2024 election, three distinct explanations have been given for why Democrats lost the White House and both houses of Congress, and why they remain unpopular with voters.
Moderates say the party went woke on migration, race, and LGBT issues. A Democratic pollster called the party’s orthodoxy “noticeably out of step with what was electorally optimal or viable.” His firm found undecided voters broke for Trump 52 to 38, with five of their top eight stated reasons involving immigration.
Progressives say the party failed to deliver a populist economic message. A Sanders-aligned autopsy found that the Kamala Harris campaign courted suburban Republicans while ignoring working-class voters, and that strong populist economic messages outperformed democracy-threat messages among Pennsylvania blue-collar voters, 57% to 45%.
And fundamentalists blame institutional factors, above all, former President Joe Biden and Vice President Harris themselves. One analyst noted that Biden’s approval in the high 30s and two years of recession-level consumer sentiment put the nominee on track to lose the popular vote by 4 points, and Harris lost by 1.5. Biden ran too long, the party held no real primary, and Harris inherited an inflation-poisoned incumbency.
In truth, all three explanations are correct and work together, and a Democratic operative turned tell-all author named Evan Barker explains how in a new podcast with Public.
Barker spent roughly a decade raising money for the party’s left flank, from the Bernie Sanders orbit through Justice Democrats-aligned campaigns to figures like Jasmine Crockett and Abdul El-Sayed, before writing the bestselling book Nothing Left.
In our conversation for Public, she explained that the party’s elites, the DNC and DCCC world, reached an accommodation with the progressive and DSA wing: the establishment embraced woke culture issues while both sides abandoned progressive economics.
“The Democratic establishment was also co-opted,” she said. “It embraced those ideas in exchange for not having to do the actual economic populism stuff that the Bernie Sanders campaign in 2016 really made their focus.”
The ideas the establishment embraced were open borders, defunding police, and “putting identity and race at the forefront of everything.” The donors preferred it that way. “The donors prefer that they focus on cultural issues,” Barker said. “They don’t really want to talk about economics. It’s a good distraction to their wealth, to be just totally blunt.” ...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2090076368247935401
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I also think this is why the centrist Dems like @ThirdWayTweet and others are having a hard time making their case. They are associated with supposedly more moderate/centrist Dems like Biden and Harris — but Biden and Harris embraced all the unpopular woke stuff. And so while they can blame the Party's embrace of the unpopular stuff, few can any more trust the centrists as able to maintain their supposed moderation after 2024. And now @KamalaHarris and other Dems are going to struggle to distance themselves from their open border, DEI, and trans policies. If they don't, they risk alienating swing voters. If they do, they risk alienating their base, which is unrepentant and dogmatic to the point of violence.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Yes, DSA has a good ground game. But the reason it keeps winning is that voters rejected open borders, DEI, trans, etc, which the party establishment embraced to avoid economic populism. Dem. moderates and progressives “embraced each other's worst impulses,” says @evanwch
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Since the 2024 election, three distinct explanations have been given for why Democrats lost the White House and both houses of Congress, and why they remain unpopular with voters.
Moderates say the party went woke on migration, race, and LGBT issues. A Democratic pollster called the party’s orthodoxy “noticeably out of step with what was electorally optimal or viable.” His firm found undecided voters broke for Trump 52 to 38, with five of their top eight stated reasons involving immigration.
Progressives say the party failed to deliver a populist economic message. A Sanders-aligned autopsy found that the Kamala Harris campaign courted suburban Republicans while ignoring working-class voters, and that strong populist economic messages outperformed democracy-threat messages among Pennsylvania blue-collar voters, 57% to 45%.
And fundamentalists blame institutional factors, above all, former President Joe Biden and Vice President Harris themselves. One analyst noted that Biden’s approval in the high 30s and two years of recession-level consumer sentiment put the nominee on track to lose the popular vote by 4 points, and Harris lost by 1.5. Biden ran too long, the party held no real primary, and Harris inherited an inflation-poisoned incumbency.
In truth, all three explanations are correct and work together, and a Democratic operative turned tell-all author named Evan Barker explains how in a new podcast with Public.
Barker spent roughly a decade raising money for the party’s left flank, from the Bernie Sanders orbit through Justice Democrats-aligned campaigns to figures like Jasmine Crockett and Abdul El-Sayed, before writing the bestselling book Nothing Left.
In our conversation for Public, she explained that the party’s elites, the DNC and DCCC world, reached an accommodation with the progressive and DSA wing: the establishment embraced woke culture issues while both sides abandoned progressive economics.
“The Democratic establishment was also co-opted,” she said. “It embraced those ideas in exchange for not having to do the actual economic populism stuff that the Bernie Sanders campaign in 2016 really made their focus.”
The ideas the establishment embraced were open borders, defunding police, and “putting identity and race at the forefront of everything.” The donors preferred it that way. “The donors prefer that they focus on cultural issues,” Barker said. “They don’t really want to talk about economics. It’s a good distraction to their wealth, to be just totally blunt.” ...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2090076368247935401
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Karen Bass
@KarenBassLA
When you donate to our campaign, the city can match your donation 6 to 1! If you donate $5, the city turns it into $35. Our campaign is powered by YOU!
Click the link in our bio to make your matching donation today!
secure.actblue.com/donate/krb-web-2026-generalThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
T Wolf 🌁
@Twolfrecovery
Los Angeles spent $900 million to "house" 1,200 homeless people. 40% left the housing within a year. So, LA spent $900 million to "house" 700 people. That's nearly $1.3 million per housed person. That's called corruption. Period.
Department of Housing and Urban Development
@HUDgov
.@SecretaryTurner: "The very organization tasked with ending homelessness and equipped with billions of dollars shamelessly wasted them on corruption and mismanagement."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Lyanne Melendez
@LyanneMelendez
I just dropped my son off at @UCBerkeley housing and as we were approaching we saw this behind his apartments. Shame on @CityofBerkeley @CityofAlbanyCA @UCBerkeleyNews
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You have stolen the article that @david_agape_ spent months working on, at grave risk to himself and family, run it through AI, and passed it off as your own. Have you no shame?
@nikitabier
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Brazilian Supreme Court Justice who oversaw sweeping, illegal censorship of his political enemies — and nearly shut down X — created a blacklist of government workers that even included another Supreme Court justice, new documents reveal. Big new bombshell by @david_agape_
-
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You have stolen the article that @david_agape_ spent months working on, at grave risk to himself and family, run it through AI, and passed it off as your own. Have you no shame?
@nikitabier
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Brazilian Supreme Court Justice who oversaw sweeping, illegal censorship of his political enemies — and nearly shut down X — created a blacklist of government workers that even included another Supreme Court justice, new documents reveal. Big new bombshell by @david_agape_
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@DarioAmodei @AnthropicAI telling everyone that they’re going to become low-wage service workers couldn’t have helped
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The CEO of Anthropic, the AI company behind the popular Claude chatbot, believes "it cannot possibly be more than a few years before AI is better than humans at essentially everything.”
Indeed, the company's near-trillion dollar valuation rests on a plan to destroy millions of high-paying jobs. Not to worry, says the person at Anthropic in charge of "research partnerships with the world’s wisdom traditions," since all of that destruction will free people up for things like "grounds maintenance," "food and serving," and "personal care."
This is dystopian. Those are the lowest-wage jobs in America. Millions of more people in the service sector will only further drive down wages. Anthropic's head of researching wisdom traditions tries to spin this by saying, "another word for grounds maintenance is gardening. And another word for food and, and service is hospitality."
Anthropic says we should think of this as "The Great Turning," which is no different from the World Economic Forum's equally dystopian "Great Reset."
Part of what's behind Anthropic's efforts to humanize and even spiritualize AI is the need to convince investors that its technology will destroy millions of high-paying jobs. But another part is a deeply degrading and dehumanizing view of people.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mario Sabino
@mariosabinof
Como é que a ditadura militar pretendeu limitar o exercício livre do jornalismo? Com a obrigatoriedade do diploma de jornalista. EXATAMENTE o que Flávio Dino e Alexandre de Moraes querem fazer agora. Não há mais qualquer pudor no STF.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
arctotherium
@arctotherium42
The most prominent members of the US censorship-industrial complex have largely moved overseas during Trump II, to lobby Canada, the EU, and Britain to treat the US as an "autocracy" for no longer censoring the Internet as much as pre-2024.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
arctotherium
@arctotherium42
You may be wondering what Nina Jankowicz, one-time disinformation Czar, is up to now. Answer: lobbying the EU, Canada, and especially Britain to force US tech platforms to censor more.
-
Christopher Rufo
@christopherrufo
Americans would rather have a nuclear power plant built in their community than a data center, this may be the worst corporate public-relations fumble of all time
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@DarioAmodei @AnthropicAI telling everyone that they’re going to become low-wage service workers couldn’t have helped
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The CEO of Anthropic, the AI company behind the popular Claude chatbot, believes "it cannot possibly be more than a few years before AI is better than humans at essentially everything.”
Indeed, the company's near-trillion dollar valuation rests on a plan to destroy millions of high-paying jobs. Not to worry, says the person at Anthropic in charge of "research partnerships with the world’s wisdom traditions," since all of that destruction will free people up for things like "grounds maintenance," "food and serving," and "personal care."
This is dystopian. Those are the lowest-wage jobs in America. Millions of more people in the service sector will only further drive down wages. Anthropic's head of researching wisdom traditions tries to spin this by saying, "another word for grounds maintenance is gardening. And another word for food and, and service is hospitality."
Anthropic says we should think of this as "The Great Turning," which is no different from the World Economic Forum's equally dystopian "Great Reset."
Part of what's behind Anthropic's efforts to humanize and even spiritualize AI is the need to convince investors that its technology will destroy millions of high-paying jobs. But another part is a deeply degrading and dehumanizing view of people.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Eldur - The Icelandic Gay Guy
@justgayice
I am Eldur, a gay man from Iceland who has spent years speaking out against the sexualisation, medicalisation and sterilisation of gender-non-conforming children, and against the erosion of gay rights, women’s rights and free expression.
I am currently facing a lawsuit in Héraðsdómur Reykjavíkur (Reykjavík District Court) brought by Ugla Stefanía Kristjónudóttir Jónsdóttir — co-author of the notorious Dentons “playbook” and Reykjavík City’s “transgender issues specialist” — simply because I called puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones for minors what they are: child abuse.
The second preliminary hearing is this Thursday, 20 August. The case is moving forward. I am approximately €2,000 short of the target, and my legal fees are due at the end of August. Without this sum, my defence is at risk.
This is not just about me. It is a SLAPP-style attempt to bankrupt and silence a gay man who refuses to lie about sex, biology, and the safeguarding of children. Ugla’s lawsuit is designed to scare anyone who dares question the current orthodoxy. If it succeeds, it sets a dangerous precedent: that critics of gender ideology can be dragged through the courts and financially ruined for telling the truth.
I have no large organisation behind me. I am an ordinary Icelander relying on the goodwill of people worldwide who still believe in evidence-based safeguarding, free speech, and the right of gay men to say that men are not women and that children need protection.
£2,000 is needed now to cover the next tranche of legal costs and keep this fight alive.
Every donation, no matter how small, makes a real difference. If you believe children should not be sterilised, that women’s spaces should remain sex-based, and that gay people should not be cancelled for defending biological reality, please stand with me.
Donate here to my legal fundraiser:
www.gofundme.com/f/help-me-defend-free-speech-and-protect… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Kristen Waggoner
@KristenWaggoner
URGENT: My friend Päivi Räsänen—a doctor, grandmother, member of Finnish parliament, and devout Christian—was invited to speak at a religious liberty conference this week in Northern Ireland.
The UK will not let her enter the country.
This is due to her recent “hate speech” conviction for writing a church pamphlet, in 2004, on Biblical marriage. This outrageous ruling by Finland’s Supreme Court provoked widespread criticism from human rights experts, free speech advocates, and the U.S. State Department.
Päivi was invited to this week’s conference in the UK precisely because she is a globally-recognized champion for free speech. Freedom-loving nations should welcome voices like hers—not uphold the heavy-handed censorship of other nations.
ADF is calling on UK Home Secretary @ShabanaMahmood to make a last-minute intervention and allow Päivi to attend in person on Friday.
Free speech is not a crime. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
David Ágape
@david_agape_
Por muito tempo nos perguntaram por que as graves denúncias da Vaza Toga “não deram em nada”. Agora sabemos.
Vaza Toga 5: Documentos internos obtidos por @a_investigacao_ , em parceria com a Public News de @shellenberger, revelam uma operação de varredura nacional dentro do Judiciário.
Em dezembro de 2023, o gabinete de Alexandre de Moraes determinou a extração de 2.119 CPFs de processos do 8 de Janeiro e ordenou que todos os tribunais do país cruzassem esses números com seus bancos de dados de servidores e magistrados
A ordem partiu de um pedido do então corregedor do CNJ, Luis Felipe Salomão. A planilha misturou investigados, réus e 711 pessoas que apareciam apenas como “requeridas”.
A devassa foi tão ampla que incluiu até o CPF de Flávio Dino, então ministro da Justiça de Lula. Isso porque ele figura numa petição sob sigilo no gabinete de Moraes desde 2023 sob a acusação de omissão diante do 8 de janeiro — o caso segue parado na mesa do ministro, ainda que ambos sejam aliados.
É o mesmo Salomão que arquivou as denúncias contra os auxiliares de Moraes após a Vaza Toga, dizendo que não viu nada demais, e que promoveu caça às bruxas contra magistrados críticos no CNJ, agora assume a presidência do STJ.
www.ainvestigacao.com/p/vaza-toga-5-devassa-stf-cnj -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Brazilian Supreme Court Justice who oversaw sweeping, illegal censorship of his political enemies — and nearly shut down X — created a blacklist of government workers that even included another Supreme Court justice, new documents reveal. Big new bombshell by @david_agape_
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
EXCLUSIVE: Brazilian Supreme Court Justice Moraes Created Blacklist That Included Another Justice
Key ally of Lula — who oversaw sweeping censorship — also demanded the courts tell him whether they employed anyone who participated in protests on January 8, 2023
by @david_agape_
On January 8, 2023, hundreds of supporters of former President Jair Bolsonaro entered government buildings in Brasília, in an episode strikingly similar to January 6 in the US. Brazil’s President Lula, Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes, and much of the media across the West labeled these individuals “coup plotters,” “terrorists,” and “fascists.”
But many of the protesters neither broke the law nor committed any acts of violence. And in August 2025, Eli Vieira and I revealed evidence, including text messages between people working in Brazil’s Supreme Court, showing that Moraes had created a secret and illegal intelligence task force that used social media posts to justify the imprisonment of nonviolent protesters.
Now, a new trove of Supreme Court documents reveals that Moraes illegally demanded that Brazilian courts across the country tell him whether they employed any of the 2,119 people whose names turned up in January 8 court cases — arrested rioters, but also hundreds of people who were never charged with anything, and even a sitting cabinet minister.
The request that set the operation in motion came from Luis Felipe Salomão, then the National Justice Inspector at the National Council of Justice (CNJ) and a known ally of Moraes. The CNJ is the body responsible for disciplinary oversight of Brazil’s entire judiciary.
The documents do not show whether any court reported a match, or what followed if one did.
But simply having a Supreme Court justice give courts a list of names to investigate is unconstitutional and creates suspicion that could harm careers, according to legal experts. Brazil has a civil service code that exists precisely to shield public employees from the kind of political investigation that Moraes carried out.
To election-law attorney and former judge Adriano Soares da Costa, creating a blacklist — including of people who were not under any criminal investigation — could turn a court employee into the target of disciplinary proceedings.
Acting on their own initiative, and without any specific case before them, Salomão and Moraes had conducted a “witch hunt,” da Costa said, one that falls “entirely outside constitutional, legal and moral boundaries.”
Article 5 of the Brazilian Constitution prohibits what Moraes did. Nations have long prevented judges from abusing their powers this way, precisely because of the risk of using the courts to ruin lives through extra-judicial measures...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2089739425463046410
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism and to read the full articleThis post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
TWITTER FILES - BRAZIL
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
TWITTER FILES - BRAZIL
Brazil is engaged in a sweeping crackdown on free speech led by a Supreme Court justice named Alexandre de Moraes.
De Moraes has thrown people in jail without trial for things they posted on social media. He has demanded the removal of users from social media platforms. And he has required the censorship of specific posts, without giving users any right of appeal or even the right to see the evidence presented against them.
Now, Twitter Files, released here for the first time, reveal that de Moraes and the Superior Electoral Court he controls engaged in a clear attempt to undermine democracy in Brazil. They:
— illegally demanded that Twitter reveal personal details about Twitter users who used hashtags he did not like;
— demanded access to Twitter’s internal data, in violation of Twitter policy;
— sought to censor, unilaterally, Twitter posts by sitting members of Brazil’s Congress;
— sought to weaponize Twitter’s content moderation policies against supporters of then-president @jairbolsonaro
The Files show: the origins of the Brazilian judiciary’s demand for sweeping censorship powers; the court’s use of censorship for anti-democratic election interference; and the birth of the Censorship Industrial Complex in Brazil.
TWITTER FILES - BRAZIL was written by @david_agape_ @elivieira & @shellenberger
We presented these findings to de Moraes, to the Supreme Court (STF), and to the High Electoral Court (TSE). None responded.
Let’s get into it... -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
We Heart Seattle
@weheartseattle
State of Washington is investigating We Heart Seattle for picking up the needles and fentanyl foil they hand out.
For six years we’ve removed hundreds of thousands of pieces of used drug paraphernalia from Seattle parks, greenbelts, and neighborhoods, the exact litter created by government-funded distribution programs.
Now L&I is investigating us for “improperly” collecting the same needles and foil that officials freely distribute and then leave for communities to deal with. This bureaucratic overreach will drain time and resources meant for cleanups and outreach.
If you believe this is hypocritical and want the work to continue, support us today: www.weheartseattle.org
We pick up what they drop. Don’t let them stop us.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Newly declassified files reveal that the FBI dropped its investigation into Rep. Eric Swalwell's romantic relationship with an alleged Chinese spy — even though it had concluded she was an “illegal source of campaign contributions” — as it ramped up its investigation of Trump.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
According to Democrats and most journalists, the FBI was justified in investigating Donald Trump’s ties to Russia, dropping its investigation of Hillary Clinton’s ties to Russia, not investigating Joe Biden’s ties to Ukraine and China, and dropping an investigation into former congressman Eric Swalwell's romantic relationship with an alleged Chinese spy. Trump, according to the AP, derides the Russia investigation “despite multiple government reviews showing Moscow interfered on behalf of the Republican’s campaign.”
But the evidence never justified the Trump investigation. A top CIA analyst told Public that a “pathological” former CIA Director, John Brennan, had put analysts “under duress” to say Russia favored and sought to help Trump in 2016, when the intelligence did not support that conclusion. Before then, the Justice Department’s Inspector General had found significant errors and omissions in the FBI’s FISA applications on Trump adviser Carter Page. And the Justice Department’s John Durham had concluded in his investigation that the FBI had relied on unverified memos from a former UK spy, financed by the Clinton campaign, to obtain warrants to spy on the Trump team.
Many of the FBI’s abuses of power have been reported before. There was coverage of how the FBI received warrants to spy on Trump aide Carter Page based on a July 2016 email that the Bureau, in five separate interviews, never once asked Page about. Reporters covered the FBI’s claim in its warrant application that Page had “met with” senior Russian officials when he had, in fact, only shaken a deputy prime minister’s hand, and spoken briefly with a staffer. And journalists wrote about how the Department of Justice Inspector General Michael Horowitz documented 17 significant inaccuracies and omissions across four FISA applications targeting Page.
But now, new files released today reveal that the FBI walked away from a far stronger case against Rep. Eric Swalwell. The FBI opened its investigation in 2014 and named as its objective to “obtain sufficient evidence to indict and arrest Swalwell and Fang for violations of campaign finance laws and quid pro quo exchanges.” Christine Fang, known as Fang Fang, was a Chinese national whose parents the FBI identified as “known MSS intelligence officers,” a reference to China’s Ministry of State Security, that nation’s equivalent to the CIA.
The new files show Swalwell admitted to FBI agents that he had “physical relations with Fang” on multiple occasions. They also show that he confirmed that Fang referred interns to him, whom his staff placed in his campaign and congressional offices. And agents traced 2013 straw donations through conduits back “to Fang herself,” making her, in the Bureau’s words, an “illegal source of campaign contributions.” And yet on February 8, 2017, the FBI dropped Swalwell as a subject and narrowed the case to Fang alone...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2089459316382400749
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is the person in charge of BBC's fact-checking.
Instead of fact-checking BBC for its misinformation, she is out to police podcasters and social media users she doesn't like. Class act
Marianna Spring
@mariannaspring
Here’s a flavour of what I do as the BBC’s social media investigations correspondent !
Revealing the real-world impact of conspiracy theories, algorithms, hate, ai fakes and misinformation across podcasts, documentaries, articles & more -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The @BBCNews says Jason Arday's death will send shockwaves through universities. It should send shockwaves through the media and the BBC. They promoted him, spread his misinformation, and are to blame for his rise and fall. They must be held accountable.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The @BBCNews literally let Jason Arday serve as "guest editor" of its Today program, a major honor. Past guest academic editors included Stephen Hawking, Tim Berners-Lee, James Dyson, and Martin Rees.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
BBC has long promoted the same DEI agenda that Cambridge promoted. Watch as the @BBCNews now acts like Cambridge alone deserves blame for the Arday Scandal.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@AAUP explicitly argues for lowering standards: "It is time to stop looking at faculty members of color as deficient or in need of molding and requiring them to bear the burden of changing. We must instead think about how to change the shape of promotion and tenure criteria."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is the person in charge of BBC's fact-checking.
Instead of fact-checking BBC for its misinformation, she is out to police podcasters and social media users she doesn't like. Class act
Marianna Spring
@mariannaspring
Here’s a flavour of what I do as the BBC’s social media investigations correspondent !
Revealing the real-world impact of conspiracy theories, algorithms, hate, ai fakes and misinformation across podcasts, documentaries, articles & more -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Cambridge's Jason Arday scandal is a rarity, say many journalists and academics. It's not. It's typical. Behind the Left's war on universities is the cowardice of professors and the class interest of radicalized administrators.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Jason Arday plagiarism and fabulism scandal at Cambridge should not distract universities from doing more to increase the number of black and minority professors, say many in the media. “By failing to do due diligence on Mr Arday before launching him, editorialized the Guardian last week, “the university has done a serious disservice to black and neurodivergent scholars more widely.”
What’s more, wrote a professor of Black Studies at Birmingham City University, “the idea that Arday benefited because he is Black is… ludicrous... The special treatment we achieve in the academia [sic] is abuse, not preferential treatment.” Notes the Guardian, racial “imbalances, which remain pronounced in many areas of public life, including academia, are the consequence of prejudices and discrimination, as well as unequal access to resources and opportunities.”
In reality, Arday rose not on his own original research but on his skin color, his transparently phony sob stories, and his ability to repeat left-wing dogma that Cambridge faculty wanted to hear. His research consisted of studies purporting to show widespread racism in universities, and yet more emphasis on black history and teaching white people that they are inherently racist. “We are so lucky to have you,” cooed Cambridge’s head of faculty for education, Hilary Cremin, to Arday in front of the BBC cameraman. “You are the best in the world in terms of the research that you do.”
In fact, the race obsession at Cambridge is typical of what has happened to Western universities over the last several decades....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2086950019320648002
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, defend free speech, and read the rest of the article!This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Here is the tragic end to this story:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The @BBCNews says Jason Arday's death will send shockwaves through universities. It should send shockwaves through the media and the BBC. They promoted him, spread his misinformation, and are to blame for his rise and fall. They must be held accountable.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Jason Arday fooled Cambridge, many say. It’s more like Cambridge chose to be fooled. Arday is the end result of the Left’s decades-long strategy to encourage students to identify as “victims,” including through “disability,” so it could lower academic standards. By @galexybrane
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The picture presented by the media over the last two weeks of Jason Arday, the youngest black professor ever hired by Cambridge University, is that of a unique plagiarist and fabulist who managed to independently fool prestigious institutions and publishers. Arday, who resigned on Wednesday, acted alone in his academic dishonesty, Cambridge implied when it announced it would conduct an investigation into Arday’s “appointment and tenure.”
Yet Arday’s rise was only possible because of Cambridge’s willingness to hire someone unqualified and to turn a blind eye to his plagiarism. Nathan Cofnas, a philosopher of biology who first brought Arday’s verbatim copying of a PhD dissertation to public attention, also found that the ten papers listed on Arday’s Cambridge faculty webpage demonstrated essentially no rigorous academic work. And David Harris, a professor emeritus at Plymouth Marjon University, had notified Cambridge administrators about Arday’s plagiarism in 2023. When reporter Jack Grove investigated Arday’s plagiarism last year, he submitted 97 pages of evidence to Cambridge. Still, the university did nothing.
Arday was, to be sure, singular in his pathological deception. He said he was in the famous BBC documentary series, “Seven Up!” even though it had started filming two decades before he was born. Arday also recounted raising over £5 million for charity, running 600 miles in six days, and running nine marathons with a fractured fibula. In his book proposal for Simon & Schuster, Arday wrote that he had experienced “locked-in syndrome” for months after an accident before waking up miraculously.
But Cambridge accepted Arday’s outlandish lies because they built a story of overcoming adversity in the face of racism, ableism, and discrimination. The university’s press office played up the announcement of Arday’s appointment to the media, and the BBC, CBS News, and Good Morning America covered the hire as inspirational. Arday’s account of not speaking until age 11, and not learning to read and write until age 18, flattered a narrative the university welcomed...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2087220089955512573
Please subscribe now to support Public's award winning journalism, our defense of civilization and to read the rest of the article!This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Here is the tragic end to this story:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The @BBCNews says Jason Arday's death will send shockwaves through universities. It should send shockwaves through the media and the BBC. They promoted him, spread his misinformation, and are to blame for his rise and fall. They must be held accountable.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
Any censorship required by governments is now clearly visible
X Open Source
@XOpenSource
Today’s For You release is in the open-source repo.
Notable updates:
• How ranking weights actually work
• A new filter required for Brazil’s 2026 election
All the details: github.com/xai-org/x-algorithm -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries are life-saving for trans-identified people, said Democrats. In truth, they have resulted in the worst medical scandal since lobotomies. Now, a major new study finds the Biden admin facilitated the fraudulent billings that financed it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“Gender-affirming care,” including blocking a child’s puberty, giving them cross-sex hormones, and performing surgeries on their bodies, is life-saving, according to the American Medical Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the news media, Democrats, hospitals, progressive activists, and Hollywood celebrities. For decades, the most powerful people and institutions in America have said that if a child feels like they are the opposite gender, they are, and doctors should be allowed to give them drugs and surgeries so their bodies align with their true inner self.
And yet the result of it all, a new report published today by Health and Human Services (HHS) confirms, is the worst medical scandal since lobotomies. Researchers have found a 12-fold higher suicide attempt risk among adults who had gender surgery, either on their chests or genitals, than among those who did not. A Swedish study that followed every “surgically reassigned patient” for up to 30 years found death from suicide ran 19 times higher.
A Trump administration Department of Justice declaration cites video of Boston Children’s gender clinic director Jeremi Carswell saying puberty blockers are given out “like candy.” It cites Boston Children’s psychologist Amy Tishelman’s testimony that evaluation time for minors fell after 2017 from 20 hours to two and a half hours, which she called “reckless.” And it quotes the hospital’s website calling blockers “temporary,” “fully reversible,” and free of “any permanent changes.”
The Campaign for Southern Equality published tables of “Codes That Are Commonly Rejected by Insurance Providers” and codes commonly accepted, matching mastectomy to breast reduction and hysterectomy to pelvic pain. “This guide is essentially a template for how to commit medical fraud,” report contributor Haim testified to Congress in April 2025. “We should all remember that this is something that people go to prison for.”
The HHS reports note that puberty blockers cost insurers an average of $16,385 per patient per year. Vaginoplasty averages $53,645 per patient and phalloplasty $133,911. Revisions for urethral strictures, fistulas, and lost sensation add more. A typical pediatric patient costs about $3,000 per year, while a gender patient costs $25,000 to $75,000 over a lifetime before any surgery....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2088350217922097179
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism and read the rest of the article!This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Catherine Herridge
@C__Herridge
REPORTING THAT AGES WELL
In April 2025 with investigative journalist @shellenberger we exposed an @FBI gag order on the Hunter Biden laptop during 2020 election + the role of the FBI Foreign Influence Task Force (FITF)
Records declassified this week @WhiteHouse indicate the FITF was also actively suppressing derogatory reporting from confidential human sources about the Bidens including Ukraine corruption allegations.
In this spreadsheet, GOP lawmakers, Trump Administration officials were labeled "conduits" for disinformation.
The so-called targets of the disinformation included Soros, former President Obama, Hillary Clinton and others.
CONTEXT: The suppression of derogatory confidential source reporting by the FBI about the Biden family appears highly organized.
It had the effect of spreading disinformation about the authenticity of the Hunter Biden laptop and other matters.
Catherine Herridge
@C__Herridge
BREAKING: FBI Imposed “Gag Order” About Hunter Biden Laptop After Employee Accidentally Confirmed Its Authenticity To Twitter
Newly released internal FBI chat messages reveal senior bureau officials actively shutting down discussion of the laptop’s credibility days before the 2020 Presidential election
This is a CatherineHerridgeReports @C__Herridge / Public @Shellenberger Joint Investigation
An FBI official admitted to House investigators that an FBI employee had inadvertently confirmed the authenticity of Hunter Biden’s laptop to Twitter on a conference call the morning of October 14, 2020, the day the New York Post published a story about it.
“I recall that when the question came up, an intelligence analyst assigned to the Criminal Investigative Division said something to the effect of, ‘Yes, the laptop is real’,” the then Russia unit chief testified in a closed door transcribed interview.
“I believe it was an (Office of General Counsel) attorney assigned to the (Foreign Influence Task Force) stepped in and said, ‘We will not comment further on this topic.’”
For the first time, and with a change of administration, the FBI has now turned over to GOP House investigators the internal chat messages that show Bureau leadership actively silenced its employees.
The FBI, which had a special task force to counter foreign election interference, could have set the record straight by confirming the laptop was real and the subject of an ongoing criminal probe. Instead, FBI leadership allowed the false narrative about the laptop to gain momentum.
The FBI provided the chat messages to congressional investigators with heavy redactions.
Some of the redactions on the chats are marked “OGC AGC,” which appears to mean that they were made by the FBI’s Office of General Counsel and Associate General Counsel.
An individual whose name is blacked out, tells Elvis M. Chan, the San Francisco-based FBI special agent tasked with interacting with social media companies, there was a “gag order” on discussion of Hunter Biden’s laptop. In a separate exchange, Chan is told “official response no commen(t).”
In the chat, the FBI officials showed awareness that the laptop may have contained evidence of criminal activity.
Asked Chan, “actually what kind of case is the laptop thing? corruption? campaign financing?”
Another FBI employee responds, “CLOSE HOLD —” after which the response is redacted.
To which Chan responds, “oh crap” appearing to underscore the serious nature of the probe, which included felony tax charges. Chan adds, “ok. It ends here”.
In the same conversation, Chan is asked if “Anyone discussing that NYPost article on the Biden’s?” Chan responds, “yes we are. c d confirmed an active investigation. No further comment.” “C D” is likely shorthand for the FBI’s Criminal Division.
Said another FBI employee, whose name was redacted by the Bureau, “please do not discuss biden matter.”
We asked for a response from the bureau and the FBI employees identified in the chat messages. An FBI spokesman declined to comment.
We go in-depth on the chat messages for subscribers! -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We've known since 2023 that the FBI illegally spread disinformation about Hunter Biden's laptop — an operation that culminated in the censorship of a New York Post story in Oct 2020 by Twitter & Facebook. Now, newly released documents reveal the partisan FBI group that ran it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The plot thickens:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@Jim_Jordan says the FBI gave him a fake "defensive briefing" in 2020 in what appears to be the same deception operation that resulted in Facebook & Twitter censoring the Hunter Biden laptop story. There is now strong evidence linking the head of that op to FBI Director Wray.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Here’s the thread on the “defensive briefing” op targeting @SenRonJohnson and @GrassleyPress
Based on article with @C__Herridge and @galexybrane
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
One FBI employee involved in the cover-up of the Hunter Biden laptop was Bradley Benavides (ctr-intel div). Weeks earlier he played key role in an apparent FBI scheme to smear @SenRonJohnson & @ChuckGrassley — who were investigating Hunter — as tools of Putin. Sinister.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Shorter
Ian Jaeger
@IanJaeger29
Rep. Dan Goldman claimed that Hunter Biden’s laptop was manipulated by Rudy Giuliani and Russia.
Today in Federal court, The FBI witness tells Hunter Biden's jury that NO TAMPERING occurred with his laptop.
Share this video far and wide. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@Jim_Jordan says the FBI gave him a fake "defensive briefing" in 2020 in what appears to be the same deception operation that resulted in Facebook & Twitter censoring the Hunter Biden laptop story. There is now strong evidence linking the head of that op to FBI Director Wray.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Yesterday, I reported on new evidence discovered by The Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI) that adds significantly to the case that a single group of FBI agents, working on a task force then-FBI Director Christopher Wray had created, ran a secret and likely illegal operation called “Round River” to protect Joe Biden — an effort that culminated in Facebook and Twitter censoring the New York Post story about Hunter Biden’s laptop.
Now, House Judiciary Chairman Rep. Jim Jordan tells Public in an exclusive interview that he received what he believes was the identical “defensive briefing” to the one the FBI gave to two U.S. senators, apparently to plant negative stories about investigators of Hunter Biden in the media.
“It was a farce,” said Jordan. “I remember talking to my staff about it as we walked to the elevators. We knew exactly what they [the FBI agents] were doing. They told us not to do what we were doing, which was looking into Hunter Biden. I mentioned it to [Senator Ron] Johnson at the time. I believe it was the same briefing they received.”
One of the documents released yesterday included a spreadsheet, apparently created by the FBI, of apparent “targets” (mostly Democrats) and “conduits” (mostly Republicans) of Russian disinformation. Number eight on the list of “conduits” for Russian disinformation was Jordan. Number one was a former attorney for President Trump, Rudolph Giuliani.
While Jordan could not recall the exact date he was briefed, we know the FBI briefed Johnson and Senator Charles Grassley on August 6, 2020.
Two weeks earlier, on July 20, Politico reported that “Democratic leaders are asking the FBI for an urgent briefing arising out of concern that members of Congress are being targeted by a foreign operation intended to influence the 2020 presidential election…Among the Democrats’ concerns is that a Senate investigation being led by Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wis.) has become a vehicle for ‘laundering’ a foreign influence campaign to damage Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden…”
Politico published an article by Andrew Desiderio on August 5, which begins, “Two top Republican senators on Wednesday denied they are pushing Russian disinformation, responding directly to charges from Democratic congressional leaders who have demanded additional public disclosures about the Kremlin’s interference in the 2020 presidential election.” Desiderio did not respond to a request for comment.
Those articles helped the FBI and Democrats to frame any discussion of Hunter Biden as Russian disinformation.
On October 15, the New York Times reported that intelligence agencies had warned Trump that Russian intelligence officers “were using President Trump’s personal lawyer Rudolph W. Giuliani as a conduit for disinformation aimed at undermining Joseph R. Biden Jr.’s presidential run.”
The timing is revealing. The New York Post the day before, October 14, published its first story about Hunter Biden’s laptop hard drive. The FBI had obtained covert warrants for Giuliani’s iCloud account in late 2019, which was revealed when the April 2021 raid became public.
The October 15 New York Times story noted that the New York Post had reported on the Hunter Biden laptop and then added, “Some former officials who have not reviewed the material suspect it could be Russian disinformation,” and “Giuliani was dealing with people widely believed to be at worst Russian operatives and at best conduits for Kremlin disinformation efforts, said current and former officials....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2087975637155971330
Please subscribe now to support Public's investigative journalism and to read the rest of the article.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Democrats are moderating, say the media, and Hong's defeat proves that. But they're not. Progressive candidates have simply tweaked their rhetoric, and the DSA is still surging. Behind the shift of language is a strategy to hide their extremism.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Wisconsin gubernatorial candidate Francesca Hong, a member of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), lost last night to David Crowley, a moderate establishment candidate. Polling before the race had shown Hong with a strong lead, and so her defeat came as a surprise. Not only that but it “revealed limits to the far left’s power,” argues Politico this morning, “and is undercutting the narrative of an emerging insurgency.”
But there is less to Hong’s defeat than meets the eye. Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC), the nation’s most high-profile democratic socialists, refused to endorse Hong, and did not campaign with her. “Bernie, AOC, and most national groups stayed out,” a progressive Democratic strategist told Politico. “Abdul El-Sayed was a great foot forward, Graham Platner was not, and we didn’t need our political reputation hanging on this race.”
Other DSA stars, such as Melat Kiros and Chris Rabb, who had campaigned for progressive primary candidates in Michigan and Colorado, also refused to campaign for Hong. Said a Democratic operative, “There’s a reason the institutional left mostly stayed away… The people who made those calls are relieved.”
x.com/shellenberger/status/2087594338020888893
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, watch the full video, and read the rest of the article!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Citoyen initié
@CitoyenInitie
Michael Shellenberger révèle que Macron a coordonné secrètement des actions pour censurer Twitter, en collaborant avec des ONG et des services de renseignement.
Il affirme que la France est devenue un laboratoire pour tester des méthodes de censure, héritées de la loi Pleven.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is a masterpiece that will be read decades from now to understand how racist radical leftists (“progressives”) destroyed American universities. Power-mad radical administrators mau-maued cowardly adjuncts and tenured faculty alike. Bravo @Tyler_A_Harper
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
This is a story about a college lost down the rabbit hole of performative progressivism. But at its heart, it’s about labor exploitation, the hell we put contingent profs through, and how the collapse of the tenure-system paved the way for cowardice and pseudo-radical groupthink.
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
.@Tyler_A_Harper landed his dream job, a tenure-track position at an elite liberal-arts college—but he found himself “being treated like a racial prop rather than a professor.” Read more in our newest cover story: theatln.tc/uAlYLOai
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Cambridge's Jason Arday scandal is a rarity, say many journalists and academics. It's not. It's typical. Behind the Left's war on universities is the cowardice of professors and the class interest of radicalized administrators....
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Cambridge's Jason Arday scandal is a rarity, say many journalists and academics. It's not. It's typical. Behind the Left's war on universities is the cowardice of professors and the class interest of radicalized administrators.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Jason Arday fooled Cambridge, many say. It’s more like Cambridge chose to be fooled. Arday is a result of the Left’s strategy to encourage students to identify as disabled so it could lower academic standards. By
@galexybrane
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Jason Arday fooled Cambridge, many say. It’s more like Cambridge chose to be fooled. Arday is the end result of the Left’s decades-long strategy to encourage students to identify as “victims,” including through “disability,” so it could lower academic standards. By @galexybrane
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Censorial cops. A neutered "The Odyssey". The denial of sex. Behind the war on the West is the infantile Rousseauian view of civilization as trauma.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For months, criticisms of Christopher Nolan’s blockbuster adaptation of “The Odyssey” have been brewing. Nolan’s multiracial cast appears to reflect the Oscars’ diversity requirements rather than how Greeks looked at the time. None of the principal characters were played by a Greek, and the only Greek-descended actor played a minor role. Odysseus’s son called him “Dad.” A rapper with visible tattoos did spoken word in an opening scene. Even the progressive translator of Homer’s The Odyssey said the film had “nothing convincing to say.”
And yet no journalist had asked Nolan tough questions about his choices until a Chinese graduate student did so a few days ago. The interview went viral on social media over the weekend. “Homer’s tone was celebratory, victorious, and your tone is emphatically not,” noted Yiyang Zhuge, a PhD student in political science at Boston College. “Does that say something about our age? Are you a bard for a civilization at dusk?”
Nolan responded that people in Homer’s time also viewed themselves as having declined since Odysseus’s time, 400 years earlier. “They were a civilization on the rise, but they were trying to get back to where they’d been 400 years before,” he explained. “So that idea of a cycle, a civilization at dusk, it’s there in the poem.”
But the attitudes of Homer’s audience and Nolan’s audience are effectively the opposite. Greeks during Homer’s time felt they had declined since Odysseus, even though Greek civilization was expanding. Westerners today feel they are more morally advanced than people were in the past, even though Western civilization is in decline. “The film completely inverts Homer’s characters and morality,” noted @RomanHelmetGuy.
Zhuge pressed Nolan. ”One thing that captured me was that the concept of atonement doesn’t exist in Greek culture. It doesn’t exist in Greek. It doesn’t exist in Homer’s Odyssey. It exists in your Odyssey. So I guess the natural question I had while watching the film was: did you Christianize ‘The Odyssey’? Why did atonement become important for the coming of catastrophe?”
Nolan answered, “I don’t know whether there really is atonement in the film or whether we just feel that that’s the catharsis or that’s the process we’re seeing in the final meeting that we’ve waited for between Odysseus and Penelope.” He then said, “I think in a way we may be bringing our more modern sensibility to that” before adding, “I think academics often maybe are too dogmatic in drawing a line between different philosophies.”
This didn’t scare Zhuge off. “ We live in an age that demands apology from greatness,” she noted. “Homer celebrates it… We turn greatness into privilege and demand apologies for it…. How do you approach greatness? Is it a story of apology that demands repentance and reflection and self-criticism?”
At this point, Nolan defends his distortion of the story by admitting that he was appealing to his audience.
“When you’re talking about storytelling, you’re always in conversation with the expectations of the audience,” he said. “When we create a heroic figure in a story, as storytellers, we have to be mindful of the energy that the audience brings to that story. Do we have to apologize for that greatness? And the answer is, ‘Yes, we do,’ or the audience rejects the greatness.”
Zhuge’s interrogation of Nolan went viral at a time when scandals continue to wash over top American and British Universities and their scholars....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2084979666037747936
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of civilization and to read the rest of the article!This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
alex gutentag
@galexybrane
The media got everything wrong: Covid origins, lockdowns, masks, and vaccines. They can’t criticize Fauci today because then they’d have to admit that the "Covidiots" and "anti-vaxxers" they wanted to censor and ostracize were right all along.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Journalists are aggressively defending Fauci, despite his diaries showing that he repeatedly lied to the public. The reason is that, after years of dehumanizing Covid dissidents based on his lies, media elites can’t cope with the enormity of their failure. By @GalexyBrane
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Journalists are aggressively defending Fauci, despite his diaries showing that he repeatedly lied to the public. The reason is that, after years of dehumanizing Covid dissidents based on his lies, media elites can’t cope with the enormity of their failure. By @GalexyBrane
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“I wasn’t part of the problem” during Covid-19, insisted CNN’s Dana Bash in an interview with Secretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr. on Sunday. “Let me just say, for the record, that I am not saying that the entire Covid reaction was accurate. It was a scary time, and people made mistakes.” Bash later added that “What we were doing in Covid… is getting the best information, the best science that we can and putting it out there.”
But Dr. Anthony Fauci’s diary shows that the media was more interested in pushing specific narratives and promoting Fauci than it was in getting the “best information” to the public. On April 17, 2021, for example, Bash herself texted Fauci, “I just watched the whole Jordan thing. Again, you’re a better man than I.... As our friend Wolf Blitzer said to me yesterday – no one would have blamed you if you said simply ‘Mr. Jordan, go f--- yourself.’”
Bash was referring to a House Oversight Committee hearing in which Representative Jim Jordan pointed out many of the “mistakes” Bash now admits were made.
The next day, Bash sent Fauci another text “pointing out that Vanity Fair recently had a headline that said: Jim Jordan trips over his own asshole trying to debate Anthony Fauci.”
Since Senator Rand Paul released Fauci’s diary, journalists have claimed that he had no real authority to impose lockdowns or mandates, suggesting it wasn’t their job to hold him accountable. “Dr. Fauci did not have the authority to force anyone to do anything,” the New York Times stated.
But his diary shows how members of the media worked to help Fauci win policy debates against President Donald Trump. As early as March 11, 2020, Fauci was aware that the press was heavily on his side, noting, “the CNN commentators (Chris Cuomo, Anderson Cooper, David Gergon, David Gregory) all discussed me as the adult in the room and the person [we] should all trust.”
In this way, the media worked to undermine the authority of the democratically elected president by upholding Fauci, an unelected bureaucrat, as the ultimate expert and truth-teller. While today they claim that Fauci had no power, six years ago they insisted he be granted nearly unlimited power....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2084635503517745417
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism and to read the rest of the article!This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
No major legacy news outlet has informed its readers how Spain’s amnesty & liberalized migration policies caused the crisis that killed 57. Most ignore them. The @NYT says it’s “too early to know.” Journalistic clown show even by the media’s debased standards.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Spain's @sanchezcastejon says the migrant crisis that's left 57 dead isn't his fault. But the day before it, he defended mass amnesty, saying, “Spain has never moved forward by building walls.” Practically everything he's said about mass migration, including for GDP, is false.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Most of the media is just repeating the propaganda of @sanchezcastejon that human traffickers are to blame, which is idiotic beyond words. Sanchez has blood on his hands.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Journalist malpractice by @washingtonpost on Ceuta. No mention of @sanchezcastejon open borders policies nor his speech the day before the crisis celebrating himself for giving amnesty to illegal migrants.
www.washingtonpost.com/world/2026/07/31/migrants-overrun-…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Media yesterday: migrant crisis is over
Today:
NIUS
@niusde_
Am Sonntagabend eskaliert die Lage in Ceuta: Migranten, die vom Militär aus dem Erstaufnahmelager an den Strand gebracht werden sollten, um nach Marokko zurückgeführt zu werden, leisten Widerstand. Im weiteren Verlauf ziehen Gruppen unter „Allahu Akbar“-Rufen in Richtung Stadt.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Media yesterday: no migrant crisis, just Russian disinformation
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“Meloni is the real villain”
DER SPIEGEL
@derspiegel
Die Blitzmigrationskrise in Ceuta zeigt: Die europäische Solidarität wird in so einer Ausnahmesituation schnell brüchig. Einer der Antreiber dieser Spaltung ist die rechte Politikerin Giorgia Meloni. www.spiegel.de/politik/deutschland/ceuta-blitzmigrationsk…
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Media yesterday: no migrant crisis, just Russian disinformation
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Media yesterday: migrant crisis is over
Today:
NIUS
@niusde_
Am Sonntagabend eskaliert die Lage in Ceuta: Migranten, die vom Militär aus dem Erstaufnahmelager an den Strand gebracht werden sollten, um nach Marokko zurückgeführt zu werden, leisten Widerstand. Im weiteren Verlauf ziehen Gruppen unter „Allahu Akbar“-Rufen in Richtung Stadt.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
NIUS
@niusde_
Am Sonntagabend eskaliert die Lage in Ceuta: Migranten, die vom Militär aus dem Erstaufnahmelager an den Strand gebracht werden sollten, um nach Marokko zurückgeführt zu werden, leisten Widerstand. Im weiteren Verlauf ziehen Gruppen unter „Allahu Akbar“-Rufen in Richtung Stadt.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
David Zweig
@davidzweig
To be clear: Fauci is lying through his teeth here. His advocacy spurred 50M healthy American children to be barred from school. Yet when questioned he refuses to say the BLM protests should be limited and pretends that he’s agnostic about which types of crowds should be limited.
The government chose winners and losers. In parts of the country liquor stores and malls were open while people were prevented from going to church. Adults could have a glass of wine and eat lunch together while down the street a playground was chained shut.
The hypocrisy was obvious at the time yet almost no one in the legacy media nor the public health/medical establishment made a peep about this while it was happening. Only “bad” Republicans and a few others called this out, largely yelling into the void.
Adam Carolla
@adamcarolla
This is when I knew he was compromised. I never listened to another thing he said after this. He was captured by the left and if you don’t understand that, then you are captured to
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
David Ágape
@david_agape_
Cerimônia do Free Speech Courage Awards, em Londres, em que recebemos o prêmio pelo nosso trabalho na Vaza Toga.
Foi uma grande honra poder representar o Brasil ao lado dos amigos e lutadores pela liberdade @elivieira e @marcelvanhattem.
Este mês completa-se um ano da publicação que virou minha vida de ponta-cabeça. Não me arrependo. Tanto que farei de novo.
🇧🇷 💚💛
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After @elonmusk opened up the Twitter Files, @david_agape_ @elivieira & I reported on mass secret censorship in Brazil by a Supreme Court justice who is now persecuting them and Congressman @marcelvanhattem. Now, they have won the 2026 Westminster Free Speech Courage Award. 🏆
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After @elonmusk opened up the Twitter Files, @david_agape_ @elivieira & I reported on mass secret censorship in Brazil by a Supreme Court justice who is now persecuting them and Congressman @marcelvanhattem. Now, they have won the 2026 Westminster Free Speech Courage Award. 🏆
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In the Hollywood version of courage, the hero is unafraid; he can thus act without hesitation. But a person who is unafraid cannot be considered courageous. They have no need to be courageous. In real life, courageous people are frightened. They hesitate. They calculate the risks and act not because they are fearless, but because they believe in a cause greater than themselves.
Such is the case with the 2026 Westminster Free Speech Prize winners. All three are Brazilian: Congressman Marcel Van Hattem and investigative journalists Eli Vieira and David Ágape. You can see me interview the three of them in the video above, after giving them the award, which comes with $25,000, in London in June.
The three men are among the most important advocates of free speech in the world, not just in Brazil, and have paid a heavy price for their courage, namely the threat of prison.
The Supreme Court of Brazil has targeted all three of them for persecution. “The three of us here were subject to persecution by a government that uses the judicial branch to interfere in the political arena, in the journalistic world, in the academy, and wherever else, you name it,” said Van Hattem, “to maintain its agenda.”...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2083952656192823696
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of free speech, read the full article, and watch the full video!This post is unavailable. See it on X.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Original Twitter Files - Brazil:
🙏 @elonmusk
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
TWITTER FILES - BRAZIL
Brazil is engaged in a sweeping crackdown on free speech led by a Supreme Court justice named Alexandre de Moraes.
De Moraes has thrown people in jail without trial for things they posted on social media. He has demanded the removal of users from social media platforms. And he has required the censorship of specific posts, without giving users any right of appeal or even the right to see the evidence presented against them.
Now, Twitter Files, released here for the first time, reveal that de Moraes and the Superior Electoral Court he controls engaged in a clear attempt to undermine democracy in Brazil. They:
— illegally demanded that Twitter reveal personal details about Twitter users who used hashtags he did not like;
— demanded access to Twitter’s internal data, in violation of Twitter policy;
— sought to censor, unilaterally, Twitter posts by sitting members of Brazil’s Congress;
— sought to weaponize Twitter’s content moderation policies against supporters of then-president @jairbolsonaro
The Files show: the origins of the Brazilian judiciary’s demand for sweeping censorship powers; the court’s use of censorship for anti-democratic election interference; and the birth of the Censorship Industrial Complex in Brazil.
TWITTER FILES - BRAZIL was written by @david_agape_ @elivieira & @shellenberger
We presented these findings to de Moraes, to the Supreme Court (STF), and to the High Electoral Court (TSE). None responded.
Let’s get into it... -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
John Greenewald, Jr.
@theblackvault
This is the memo which outlines the "preliminary implementation guidance... regarding President Trump's UAP NDA directive," per @RepEricBurlison.
Nothing has changed, except PUSUE is now authorized to hear it, too. All of this echoes what has been on the books about NDAs since at least 2023, and the public will (per this memo) remain in the dark.
Things need to really change... this is charades with fancy jargon, fun letterheads, and political theatre. In the end, countless photos, videos and documents remain hidden despite the releases that have taken place (FOIA denials back this up). -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Bipolar disorder is a serious mental illness and is highly treatable with lithium. So while I don't think it's necessarily disqualifying, voters deserve to know if @FrancescaHongWI is receiving professional care and what it is. It should be disqualifying if she refuses to say.
Peter Bernegger
@PeterBernegger
Francesca Hong was diagnosed with 1) bipolar disease, 2) had a mental breakdown, 3) was placed in psychiatric hospitalization, 4) did self-harm by cutting, and 5) experienced a lithium overdose. My source: Francesca Hong in a 2023 interview. Her own words. She is running for Governor in Wisconsin (D). @DavidCCrowley @TomTiffanyWI @joeltbrennan @VickiMcKenna @DanODonnellShow @TiffanyWarRoom @RegJoeShow @JayWeber3 @EricLDaugh @EmeraldRobinson @DanEastman2023 @doranchad @bgalsWI @MattWhitlock @amuse It's always in the eyes....
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I agree with all of these. The bottom line is that @FrancescaHongWI needs to explain what treatment, if any, she's on and how it does not impair her cognitive function.
Voters should want this to be the standard for all candidates. This one should be 100% apolitical.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The above should have read “increasing social programs would reduce crime far less than increasing police officers”
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Spain's @sanchezcastejon says the migrant crisis that's left 57 dead isn't his fault. But the day before it, he defended mass amnesty, saying, “Spain has never moved forward by building walls.” Practically everything he's said about mass migration, including for GDP, is false.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Journalist malpractice by @washingtonpost on Ceuta. No mention of @sanchezcastejon open borders policies nor his speech the day before the crisis celebrating himself for giving amnesty to illegal migrants.
www.washingtonpost.com/world/2026/07/31/migrants-overrun-…Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
No mention by @WSJ
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@nytimes says it’s “too early to know” 🤡
www.washingtonpost.com/world/2026/07/31/migrants-overrun-… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Just resign. You’re a corrupt WEF tool.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It’s the “images” she finds unacceptable. Not that Spain opened its border to 50,000+ people to enter illegally. The reason she and @sanchezcastejon are trying to shut down X is so people won’t see these images.
Ursula von der Leyen
@vonderleyen
The images coming from Ceuta are unacceptable.
We cannot allow anyone to come to our Union without abiding by our rules.
Dangerous crossings must stop immediately. Smuggling networks must be dismantled. And returns must be swift, as our rules allow.
I tasked two Commissioners to support to control the situation.
@magnusbrunner is already working closely with Spain and is ready to travel to critical points.
He will work on additional operational support to Spain, including through Frontex.
@dubravkasuica is in contact with her Moroccan counterpart.
I am confident that our close partnership with Morocco will help deliver concrete results. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It’s the “images” she finds unacceptable. Not that Spain opened its border to 50,000+ people to enter illegally. The reason she and @sanchezcastejon are trying to shut down X is so people won’t see these images.
Ursula von der Leyen
@vonderleyen
The images coming from Ceuta are unacceptable.
We cannot allow anyone to come to our Union without abiding by our rules.
Dangerous crossings must stop immediately. Smuggling networks must be dismantled. And returns must be swift, as our rules allow.
I tasked two Commissioners to support to control the situation.
@magnusbrunner is already working closely with Spain and is ready to travel to critical points.
He will work on additional operational support to Spain, including through Frontex.
@dubravkasuica is in contact with her Moroccan counterpart.
I am confident that our close partnership with Morocco will help deliver concrete results.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I debunk all the major migration lies of @vonderleyen and @sanchezcastejon here
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Spain's @sanchezcastejon says the migrant crisis that's left 57 dead isn't his fault. But the day before it, he defended mass amnesty, saying, “Spain has never moved forward by building walls.” Practically everything he's said about mass migration, including for GDP, is false.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Spain’s President @sanchezcastejon is a corrupt censorial thug. WEF prodigy. Hates the West. Is basically Europe’s @GavinNewsom
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Imagine an app linking your social media, bank access, and vaccination records. Now imagine the totalitarian potential. Criticize the government, or refuse a jab, and you're debanked or unable to travel. This is not a drill. Digital IDs may soon become a reality. @CecilieJilkova
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“They’re fleeing repression!”
Basil the Great
@BasilTheGreat
Cueta was a warzone last night
This was day 1
Today they've started looting every store in the city
If this doesn't make you support remigration, I don't know what willThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“They look happy”!
Regina Rini
@rinireg
this is supposed to be scary, but honestly what it reminds me of is photos of people celebrating as Berlin Wall comes down. They look happy, not scary
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The real problem is that y’all are racists
Thomas Mayer
@TomMayerEuropa
Bin immer wieder erstaunt, wie stark bei vielen Leuten in Deutschland und Österreich in überraschenden Krisenlagen wie grad in Ceuta unverhohlen der Rassismus zutage tritt. Hier auf X gut nachzulesen: Über Marrokaner wird geredet wie über Untermenschen.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
T Wolf 🌁
@Twolfrecovery
The Skid Row Care Campus is a sham and is actually a Supervised consumption site thst costs the city of LA $26 million a year to operate.
-
Pedro Sánchez
@sanchezcastejon
Lo que ha sucedido es un ataque a la integridad territorial de España y merece nuestra más rotunda y enérgica condena.
Toda España está con la ciudadanía de Ceuta. El Gobierno de España está con la Ciudad Autónoma.
Gracias por la cooperación que siempre hemos mantenido con el gobierno de la ciudad.
Utilizaremos todos los recursos del Estado para garantizar la seguridad y la convivencia.
Y nuestro compromiso total y rotundo con el futuro de la Ciudad Autónoma de Ceuta.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Just resign. You’re a corrupt WEF tool.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It’s the “images” she finds unacceptable. Not that Spain opened its border to 50,000+ people to enter illegally. The reason she and @sanchezcastejon are trying to shut down X is so people won’t see these images.
Ursula von der Leyen
@vonderleyen
The images coming from Ceuta are unacceptable.
We cannot allow anyone to come to our Union without abiding by our rules.
Dangerous crossings must stop immediately. Smuggling networks must be dismantled. And returns must be swift, as our rules allow.
I tasked two Commissioners to support to control the situation.
@magnusbrunner is already working closely with Spain and is ready to travel to critical points.
He will work on additional operational support to Spain, including through Frontex.
@dubravkasuica is in contact with her Moroccan counterpart.
I am confident that our close partnership with Morocco will help deliver concrete results. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
We Heart Seattle
@weheartseattle
The Atlantic author @powellAtlantic spent several days immersing in Seattle and @weheartfounder @WeHeartDirector with a focus on Little Saigon and North Beacon Hill where the largest drug markets destroy the parks and cause harm to the working class. “Andrea Suarez leads a group, We Heart Seattle, that combines care for the homeless with a hardheaded insistence on legal consequences and addiction treatment for drug users. She was in Jose Rizal Park when police swept it one day in April, and watched users and dealers amble off into the woods or walk over to Little Saigon. They returned a few hours later, she told me. A day or two after that, the tents reappeared. “Everyone who lives in this park knows there is no consequence for being swept multiple times or doing drugs or vandalizing a park,” Suarez said. @TheAtlantic The cover photo is Seattle’s skyline with the remains of a BBQ Pavilion now demolished from damages related to drug use.
Michael Powell
@powellAtlantic
A young working class mother on life in Burlington Vt where leaders are unwilling to tackle drug epidemic. “Everyone talks about needle exchange and harm reduction,” she told me. “Okay. But it’s like my children and I are living in the zombie apocalypse": www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/09/city-drug-addiction-…
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Powell
@powellAtlantic
A young working class mother on life in Burlington Vt where leaders are unwilling to tackle drug epidemic. “Everyone talks about needle exchange and harm reduction,” she told me. “Okay. But it’s like my children and I are living in the zombie apocalypse": www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/09/city-drug-addiction-…
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
alex gutentag
@galexybrane
Fauci’s diary shows that he hid information about natural immunity to push for mandates. He personally coached Biden to stigmatize unvaccinated people and ensured that boosters would be required for frontline workers. Thousands were fired, including those with natural immunity.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Fauci says he didn’t impose vaccine mandates. But his diary shows he twisted arms, including that of the CDC Director, and misrepresented data on natural immunity, to mandate vaccines for practically everyone — even as he privately acknowledged their inefficacy. By @galexybrane
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Fauci says he didn’t impose vaccine mandates. But his diary shows he twisted arms, including that of the CDC Director, and misrepresented data on natural immunity, to mandate vaccines for practically everyone — even as he privately acknowledged their inefficacy. By @galexybrane
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
By Alex Gutentag @galexybrane :
Dr. Anthony Fauci invoked his Fifth Amendment right to avoid testifying before the Senate yesterday, refusing to answer questions over 100 times. Fauci stated that the chairman of the hearing, Senator Rand Paul, had an “obvious obsession” with prosecuting him.
In Fauci’s diary, newly released by Paul, he similarly paints himself as a victim, complaining about “far right radical idiots” and the “radical right-wing maniacs” who wrongly blame him for Covid policies. “The idiots like Rand Paul… do nothing but aim their criticism at me as if I am the person that’s doing the mandates,” Fauci wrote in October 2021.
But Fauci’s diary shows that he did, in fact, heavily shape vaccine requirements and messaging.
For instance, when the CDC’s advisory committee voted against recommending boosters for people with occupational exposure on September 23, 2021, Fauci “texted [CDC Director] Rochelle [Walensky] and I begged her to call me in order that I could explain to her how this would be a fatal mistake.”
Fauci then “literally begged her to override that decision” and “pleaded with her,” telling Walensky that if she did not overrule the committee “she would be forever branded as someone with no leadership capabilities at all.”
Following intense pressure and intimidation from Fauci, Walensky overruled her committee and recommended boosters for frontline workers. By insisting on this recommendation, Fauci ensured that states and employers could require boosters for healthcare personnel. New York, for example, explicitly tied its healthcare booster mandate to the CDC’s advice.
There is no “smoking gun” in Fauci’s diary, claimed the New York Times on Monday. “Rather, it echoes past disclosures showing Dr. Fauci wrestling with a fast-moving crisis as scientists’ views evolved.”
Yet the diary shows the extent of Fauci’s coordination with other officials to repeatedly hide and manipulate vaccine-related information. This coordination was not reflective of “wrestling with a fast-moving crisis,” but of intentional “noble lies” aimed at increasing vaccination rates at the expense of informed consent....
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism and to read the full article!This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Fauci declines to answer any questions, citing the Fifth Amendment
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For the last decade, the media said the "far right" threatened violence & democracy in Germany. Now, as leftists beat reporters, block free assembly, and ban political candidates, the media is further dehumanizing the victims. All in service of national suicide by mass migration
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Another mayoral candidate blocked from running for office. This is in violation of the NATO charter
Martin Sichert, MdB
@Martin_Sichert
Sie haben es wieder getan: Heute Abend wurde Justin Vogel als Bürgermeisterkandidat in Herzberg einstimmig vom Wahlausschuss von der Wahl ausgeschlossen. Begründung: Funktionär in der Alternative für Deutschland und der Generation Deutschland. #afd #wahl #niedersachsen #demokratie
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Ralf Schuler
@drumheadberlin
Exklusiv! 94 Prozent aller Terror-Ermittlungen haben mit Islamismus oder Migration zu tun
nius.de/articles/d11a98b0-225b-4f72-b555-6db6e2835e95
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Germany bans another mayoral candidate.
Apollo News
@apollo_news_de
Der Wahlausschuss der niedersächsischen Stadt Herzberg hat den Kreisvorsitzenden der Göttinger AfD, Justin Vogel, von der Bürgermeisterwahl ausgeschlossen – obwohl Vogel als gemäßigte Kraft gilt. Die AfD spricht von einem "weiteren Angriff auf die Demokratie".
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Smithsonian's leadership remains committed to spreading disinformation about basic history and biology, and so the Trump administration will put up signs along the sidewalks near the National Museum of American History warning "visitors about the ideological capture."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The behavior of the head of the Smithsonian's Museum of American History at yesterday's hearing was appalling. She made clear she'll keep smearing the US as racist and genocidal, and denying biological sex. If she and @SmithsonianSec don't resign, Congress must defund it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
New executive order
www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2026/07/restoring…
Fact sheet
www.whitehouse.gov/fact-sheets/2026/07/fact-sheet-preside… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Kevin Dalton
@TheKevinDalton
It’s been more than three years since Gavin Newsom announced he was spending $750 million taxpayer dollars on 1,200 tiny homes for the homeless.
“And so what we are doing is we're deploying these 1,200-plus units. You can see these units are not just in every case for one individual, multiple individuals in these units. We're hoping to get them constructed within a matter of months and not years. I wanted to say the summer, but my staff said the press will attack us if we fall short, so they're saying the fall." - Gavin Newsom, March 2023
I hope you’re sitting down, but in more than three years Gavin Newsom hasn’t delivered on a single tiny home.
But I’m sure this time will be different… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Alice
@AliceFromQueens
If you won't acknowledge that college faculties have been stacked against conservatives, you're dishonest, ignorant, or insane.
You don't have to *be* a conservative--I'm certainly not one--to acknowledge this reality. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Aaron Lukas
@DepDNILukas
President Trump is delivering on his commitment to unprecedented UAP transparency.
With nondisclosure agreements no longer standing in the way, current and former government employees and contractors with relevant UAP information can come forward through cleared channels. @ODNIgov will soon issue guidance to ensure the Intelligence Community swiftly and consistently implements the President’s directive. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
People are finally waking up to the disturbing reality that, in the name of "medical assistance in dying," "gender-affirming care," and "harm reduction," progressive policies and doctors are killing and sterilizing people, including minors, with treatable psychiatric disorders.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The world is about to wake up to the reality that in the name of compassion and freedom, doctors are killing and sterilizing thousands of mentally ill people across the West every year.
How have they gotten away with it for so long? By deceiving people through language, says @Docstockk
x.com/shellenberger/status/2080343367167381854
Stock is famous for her courageous stand against those who tried to make her repeat lies about gender. Now she is out with a brilliant new book about how progressives are doing the same with euthanasia.
Please subscribe to read the full article and watch the full video! Link here:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Rep. Eric Burlison
@RepEricBurlison
🚨House Adopts Burlison Amendment Establishing UAP Disclosure Framework
Read more 👇
burlison.house.gov/media/press-releases/house-adopts-burl… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Many are asking why Trump can't just fire these people. The reason is that the Smithsonian isn't an executive agency. Its Board of Regents — the Chief Justice of the Supreme court, VP @JDVance, 6 members of Congress, and 9 citizens — appoints Secretary Bunch. Bunch appoints Hartig. Only the Regents can remove him. Vance is 1 of 17. It may be that Congress will need to defund. Props to @timburchett @NancyMace @realBrandonGill and others for the hearing.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The behavior of the head of the Smithsonian's Museum of American History at yesterday's hearing was appalling. She made clear she'll keep smearing the US as racist and genocidal, and denying biological sex. If she and @SmithsonianSec don't resign, Congress must defund it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Nobody denies that the Smithsonian must cover the ugly parts of America’s past. The White House affirms that the museum “should tell the whole story of a nation, including the good and the bad.”
The issue is that the Smithsonian is openly anti-civilization, spreading the big lies that America is fundamentally racist and genocidal, and that girls can become boys.
— Smithsonian Under Secretary Kevin Gover called Christopher Columbus a “murderer,” “slaver,” and “thief” and urged the abolition of Columbus Day.
— The museum’s 2023 diversity report showcased a Smithsonian employee’s statement that it will be nice when the United States “exists in hindsight.”
— In 2020, the Smithsonian’s National Museum of African American History and Culture published a chart attributing “hard work,” “self-reliance,” “objectivity,” the “nuclear family,” and politeness to “white culture,” removing it only after public backlash.
Measured against that record, the Trump administration’s actions have been restrained. Nobody from the Trump administration has fired anyone at the National Museum of American History.
Trump’s Executive Order directs the Vice President to act “through his role on the Smithsonian Board of Regents,” the governing body Congress created, rather than by unilateral command.
The order simply stated that museums “should be places where individuals go to learn,” not venues for ideological indoctrination.
The August 2025 letter asked eight museums to turn over exhibition descriptions, plans, and internal guidelines, the kind of documentation any auditor would request.
Meanwhile, the Smithsonian has changed almost nothing. In December 2025, the White House complained that “The overwhelming majority of the Phase 1 materials originally due no later than September 10, 2025, remain outstanding” and that folders for current and future exhibitions “contain no substantive content.”
Smithsonian Secretary Lonnie Bunch responded to the July 4 report by reasserting the institution’s “steadfast commitment to scholarship, nonpartisanship, independence, accuracy and integrity.”
But the museum’s website still carries the mission statement without the words “American history.” The “Becoming US” curriculum, with its instructions to avoid the term “illegal alien,” and the Illegal to Be You companion site both remain online.
And Hartig was unrepentant. “As we continue to fact-check the report,” she said, “we unwaveringly attest that it does not fairly or accurately characterize the full body of work at the museum.”
Bunch and Hartig must step down, or Congress must defund the Smithsonian...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2079977690984292474
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of civilization, read the full article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Many are asking why Trump can't just fire these people. The reason is that the Smithsonian isn't an executive agency. Its Board of Regents — the Chief Justice of the Supreme court, VP @JDVance, 6 members of Congress, and 9 citizens — appoints Secretary Bunch. Bunch appoints Hartig. Only the Regents can remove him. Vance is 1 of 17. It may be that Congress will need to defund. Props to @timburchett @NancyMace @realBrandonGill and others for the hearing.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Anthropic’s CEO says “it cannot possibly be more than a few years before AI is better than humans at essentially everything.” Its executives say the exception will be low-wage jobs in “grounds maintenance” “food and serving,” and “personal service.”
x.com/shellenberger/status/2076352856769409509
Claude
@claudeai
There’s hope in hard questions.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Anthropic says AI can become better than humans at “essentially everything” — except things like food prep and elder care, which reveals Anthropic’s view of service jobs as “essentially” nothing — the perspective of elites who look down on low-wage workers.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The CEO of Anthropic, the AI company behind the popular Claude chatbot, believes "it cannot possibly be more than a few years before AI is better than humans at essentially everything.”
Indeed, the company's near-trillion dollar valuation rests on a plan to destroy millions of high-paying jobs. Not to worry, says the person at Anthropic in charge of "research partnerships with the world’s wisdom traditions," since all of that destruction will free people up for things like "grounds maintenance," "food and serving," and "personal care."
This is dystopian. Those are the lowest-wage jobs in America. Millions of more people in the service sector will only further drive down wages. Anthropic's head of researching wisdom traditions tries to spin this by saying, "another word for grounds maintenance is gardening. And another word for food and, and service is hospitality."
Anthropic says we should think of this as "The Great Turning," which is no different from the World Economic Forum's equally dystopian "Great Reset."
Part of what's behind Anthropic's efforts to humanize and even spiritualize AI is the need to convince investors that its technology will destroy millions of high-paying jobs. But another part is a deeply degrading and dehumanizing view of people.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I kindly ask people to read the article before jumping to conclusions. I make no predictions about what AI's impact will likely be. Rather, I argue that their need to justify its near-trillion-dollar valuation, and Malthusian ideology, are behind @AnthropicAI executives' denigration of people and their humanization and spiritualization of AI.
That concern is valid, whether AI has the apocalyptic impacts @DarioAmodei claims it will have, or whether it turns out to have a significantly smaller impact.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Last year, I argued that AI can't solve our biggest problems because a lack of intelligence didn't cause them. (See below.)
Again, that's not to deny that AI help may solve big problems. I generally favor labor-saving technologies, particularly general-purpose ones, as they are the main drivers of productivity and economic growth. And, for what it's worth, I like and use AI, including Claude.
But I am also very troubled that @DarioAmodei believes AI will be "better than humans at essentially everything," and that Chloe Lubinski believes we should all just embrace a future in which millions more people become low-wage service workers.
youtu.be/IhLoZrUWtro -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Julian Reichelt
@jreichelt
Die CDU will ihrem in den Umfragen erfolgreichsten Widersacher ohne jegliche rechtliche Grundlage das Wahlrecht komplett entziehen, während man Millionen Menschen, die illegal ins Land gekommen sind, Wahlrecht und Staatsbürgerschaft erteilt. Das ist wahnsinnig. Das ist die Willkürherrschaft. Das ist totalitär.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Claire Coutinho
@ClaireCoutinho
I have been contacted by more whistleblowers within our grid operator.
They allege the electricity grid is not being run securely, which increases the risk of blackouts, with a particularly severe event on 23rd June.
This information is also allegedly being hidden from the public.
This morning NESO refused to deny that Corporate Affairs staff had interfered in operational decisions to avoid reputational damage.
These whistleblowers are coming to me because they are worried that the grid is becoming unmanageable and they do not have faith that their concerns are being taken seriously.
I have written to the CEO of NESO asking them to bring in an independent external investigator to interview control room engineers so that we can find out the truth about what happened on the evening of 23rd June. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Notable new Navy infrared video of UAP. Eastern US 2015 is same era & corridor as GIMBAL & GOFAST, shot by Roosevelt F/A-18 crews off the East Coast that January. @uncertainvector testified his squadron began detecting UAP near Virginia Beach in 2014, sightings so routine one crew took evasive action to avoid a collision.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Members of Congress last week vowed to find missing files on the CIA's MKUltra mind control program. Now, a new documentary film based on never-before-seen recordings and files suggests the CIA financed illegal tests on teens to engage in psychic warfare and/or mind control.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Government mind control is the stuff of conspiracy theories. Many homeless people suffering from schizophrenia or meth-induced psychosis claim to be victims of it. And it is common to find people online who say they are victims of mind control, directed energy weapons, and gang-stalking by government agents.
These delusions appear to have arisen after evidence emerged in the 1970s that the CIA was engaged in mind-control efforts, the subject of a congressional hearing last week. The CIA’s MKUltra program, for example, tested LSD on prisoners and hospital patients without their consent.
After World War II, the CIA may have continued Nazi experiments into mind control, even using former Nazi doctors and operating a black site in Germany where some victims died, testified a journalist-turned-historian.
“Kurt Blome, who was the chief of biological weapons development for the Nazi government, came to work for the CIA,” noted former New York Times reporter Stephen Kinzer, who authored Poisoner in Chief about the head of MKUltra. “So did Walter Schreiber, who was the surgeon general of the Nazi army.”
The hearing that Rep. Anna Paulina Luna convened on June 30 did not receive much media attention, likely because some of it covered what is viewed in Washington, D.C., as old news. The CIA released MKUltra financial files in 1977. The two witnesses, Kinzer and Tom O’Neill, both published their books in 2019. The two testified that little new information had come to light since then.
But the hearing was significant in part because O’Neill raised the possibility that the CIA’s mind control research may never have ended. “Did it continue?” O’Neill said. “I don’t know. I can’t imagine that it didn’t, though, because the technology — that they worked to establish over 20, 25 years and spent more money on than any operation the CIA ever conducted — was successful. I imagine it’s being used.”
Jolly West, a doctor and MKUltra contractor, reported in 1956 that, through the use of LSD and other drugs, he could “speed the induction of the hypnotic state and deepen the trance,” after which he could replace “true memories” with “false ones” in people’s minds without them knowing it.
Two years earlier, a 34-year-old Air Force sergeant with no history of violent or criminal behavior murdered a three-year-old girl in an apparent trance state. West was assigned to be the man’s psychiatric expert. It turned out that the sergeant had been, ostensibly, undergoing an experimental treatment for his migraine headaches at the base.
O’Neill points to connections between the West and the Manson Family murders without drawing definitive conclusions. In his book, Chaos, O’Neill reveals that West visited the jail cell of Jack Ruby, who killed Lee Harvey Oswald, the alleged assassin of President John F. Kennedy, just hours before Ruby had a psychotic break.
The CIA destroyed MKUltra evidence, lied to Congress about it, and fabricated false reports, including the one by West. But there are many MKUltra files, photos, and films still out there, said the witnesses, sitting in the archives and attics of the 80 scientific, medical, and university institutions and at least 185 non-government researchers.
In fact, a large new body of documents, photographs, and films about apparent mind control and psychic warfare will soon come to light. The son of Andrija Puharich — an American physician, scientist, and inventor who used teenagers in his psychic experiments — gave documentary filmmaker Greg Mallozzi access to his father’s archive, which includes numerous recordings.
“I worked as a consultant to the CIA,” Puharich says in one of them. “My boss was the chief medical director who’s in charge of all the dirty tricks stuff when it came to drugs and hypnosis and all the mind manipulation stuff.”
The new documentary is called “Mind Traveler” and will be released this fall....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2075262022581915971
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Germany was the powerhouse of Europe. Now, it is killing itself. Industrial output is 24% lower what it should be. Mass migration is bankrupting the state and destroying the culture. Thugs beat up reporters who dare ask questions. The Left manipulates guilt to destroy the West.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Dear Friends — Those of you who have been subscribers to Public know that we have been warning Germany for 10 years of what would happen to it if it shut down its nuclear power plants, increased its reliance on renewables, and became overly dependent on Russian natural gas. Germany ignored those warnings, shut down its nuclear plants, and lost access to cheap natural gas after Russia invaded Ukraine and Ukrainians blew up the Nord Stream gas pipeline.
Today, the data paint a dark picture for Germany's future and, by extension, that of Europe as a whole. Germany’s industrial production, the Continent’s engine of economic growth, has declined an astonishing 24% relative to what it would have been had the nation maintained the growth it achieved from 1993 to 2017, the year I delivered my warning in Berlin.
Germany remains a rich nation and will recover better from its self-inflicted wound than most other countries could, but the picture remains one of dangerous decline. Germany may outcompete its rivals as it moves away from a manufacturing to a services economy. But EU politicians should view Germany’s willful destruction of its industrial capacity as a flashing red light.
And Germany’s self-destruction through energy policy comes hand in hand with the nation’s self-destruction through mass migration, argues Andreas Lombard in his essay below. “We are, in that way, a warning to America and the rest of the West of what happens when a civilization decides to commit suicide,” he writes.
The underlying reason for this is that the broad Left, from radical socialists to liberal globalists, has manipulated guilt from World War II to put in place policies that are destroying the German economy and culture.
When people in Germany raise the alarm about the destruction of their country, the response from the Left, including the government, is violence. This was on display over the weekend when the police failed to stop a group of Antifa thugs from physically assaulting journalists. Sadly, say many Germans, it may be too late to save Germany.
But if Germany is lost, the West need not be. What has been done to Germany should be a wake-up call for everyone. The Left’s true goal is not atoning for past sins but rather manipulating guilt to attack fundamental pillars of civilization: borders, law and order, industry, meritocracy, and equal justice under the law. That’s true from Berlin and London to Brooklyn and Berkeley.
Change is coming, and the only real question is whether it will continue or reverse the degradation of our remarkable and blessed civilization. The German government could halt mass migration at any time, for example.
It’s not even too late to save Germany’s nuclear plants. While significant damage is done, Radiant Energy Group finds that “five reactors could be returned to service in less than five years,” and “14 reactors total in under a decade.” And, the analysts note, “Every reactor studied could produce electricity well below current wholesale prices in Germany.”
I encourage you to read Lombard’s potent essay below.
— Michael
Suicide By Mass Migration
by Andreas Lombard
In my mind’s eye, present-day Germany resembles a large steamship that still appears to be sailing but has just run out of fuel. When the passengers realize what is happening, there will be anarchy aboard. We are, in that way, a warning to America and the rest of the West of what happens when a civilization decides to commit suicide.
While I cannot predict the future, I cannot see how the catastrophe can be averted. The reason that our current trajectory seems hopeless dates back to an ideological problem that Germany has cultivated since 1945: guilt-based self-negation. Over the last 80 years, Germans’ natural self-identity, pride, and willingness to defend their country and culture have been suppressed.
This suppression has spread and infected others. Not just in Germany but also in Sweden, France, Great Britain, and the United States, public spaces have become staging grounds for terrorist and anti-state brutality, the violence of rival gangs and ethnic groups, and the recklessness of left-wing mobs that fight any opponent of immigration.
For the left, immigration is no longer a political question but a crusade for its secular religion of victimhood and salvation. This is where the extreme polarization and fanatical radicalism of the German government’s “fight against the right” efforts come from. As Paul Gottfried wrote in his 2021 book Antifascism: The Course of a Crusade, Germany today exemplifies “the elevation of antifascism to a state philosophy and program of mass reeducation”—with mass immigration as its most well-known consequence.
Germany’s asylum system and its anti-fascist activism have combined as part of a state-funded industry in which more and more refugees are dependent on asylum seekers’ benefits while municipal budgets collapse under the burden of welfare spending. Germany’s 2026 federal core budget of €525 billion includes 90 billion of new debt. Combined with other debts (“Special fund”), the new debt amounts to close to 180 billion euros.
Public-sector spending makes up more than 50 percent of Germany’s GDP, which means rich sinecures are up for grabs. But while Germany’s economic output is falling—a thousand industrial jobs are lost every month—asylum applications remain at high annual levels: over 106,000 by November 2025, plus 100,000 visas for family reunification. And NGOs and the German media want to ensure that the country continues on its current course.
German politicians, meanwhile, attack “the right wing” as the country’s main problem even as they drive the country headlong into a brick wall. The right-wing populist party Alternative for Germany (AfD) has not yet been banned, but it is being denounced, paralyzed, and attacked in every conceivable way. In contrast, Antifa Ost, the notorious “Hammer Gang” of Antifa radicals that has attempted to murder German right-wingers with hammers, is regarded with public goodwill. The group has been branded a terrorist organization by the Trump administration for its attacks on cars, private homes, and members of Parliament, and it is probably only a matter of time before the first deaths occur.
At the end of November, an anti-fascist street mob tried to prevent the founding of the new AfD youth organization Generation Germany in the city of Giessen. At least 25,000 demonstrators engaged in sometimes violent clashes with 6,000 police officers from all over Germany. Taxpayers finance both sides — the police and the anti-AfD NGOs —of these street battles. And things are even more absurd in the Bundestag. Chancellor Friedrich Merz of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) has only two items on his agenda: to ostracize the AfD and to avoid upsetting his left-wing Vice Chancellor Lars Klingbeil of the Social Democratic Party (SPD), who was himself a member of Antifa as a young man.
Once a pompous-sounding conservative, Merz has broken all his electoral promises in his desperate attempts to placate the SPD and keep his coalition afloat. His constant contradictions are a symptom of his self-imposed dilemma. The SPD, in turn, feels emboldened by Merz’s weakness and has become increasingly radical. Among its demands is that Merz maintain the “firewall” against the AfD. When a CDU Bundestag motion to limit migration won a majority thanks to AfD votes early last year, a left-wing street mob of SPD supporters occupied CDU party headquarters. After that, Merz fell into line.
The AfD is a parliamentary pariah. The other parties refuse to let their members perform basic parliamentary functions such as chairing meetings or heading committees. One assumes the intention is to ban the AfD or to find a pretext to suspend upcoming elections. It seems unlikely the AfD will ever be permitted to govern. Even AfD’s leader, Alice Weidel, is said to be very skeptical regarding her party’s future.
The same game is being played against right-wing populist parties in Paris, London, Vienna, Stockholm, Bucharest, and The Hague, albeit under different circumstances. President Donald Trump, too, faces ideologically motivated obstruction within the U.S. Congress and judicial system.
This situation brings us to a sobering assessment: A decisive battle for the future of the West is being fought right now, both behind the scenes and on the streets. The violent Antifa mob is just one of many players in this game. Its advocacy for Muslim refugees (who comprise 76 percent of Germany’s immigrant population) coincides strikingly with the Islam-friendly attitude of European elites. Fighting Islamic Sharia law, femicide, and gender segregation will be just as much a part of the battle for the future as cracking down on terrorism, knife crime, and protection rackets that come with immigrant gangs....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2074157902936559885
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of free speech and read the rest of the article!This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Společnost pro obranu svobody projevu
@SOS_projevu
Nejzajímavějším příspěvkem na konferenci ARC v Londýně byl od @shellenberger, spoluautora Twitter Files a jednoho z nejvýznamnějších amerických publicistů věnujících se svobodě projevu, kterého jste mohli osobně zažít před 2 lety v Praze na naší akci. Nechť je jeho projev pozvánkou na naše podzimní Konzervativní fórum, kde budeme řadu z těchto věcí diskutovat.
"Mnoho lidí věří, že tyto útoky na naši civilizaci pramení z nevědomosti, přehnané empatie nebo z dobrých úmyslů, které se zvrtly... Avšak ti, kteří tyto politiky formulovali jako nezbytné pro nápravu historických nespravedlností, ve skutečnosti chtějí západní civilizaci zničit a nahradit něčím, o čem věří, že bude spravedlivější."
"Věří, že obránci civilizace jsou stejně zlí jako systém, který obhajují, a požadují, aby byli umlčeni a odstraněni z univerzit, sociálních sítí a slušné společnosti. Právo a pořádek, národní hranice a meritokracii vnímají jako strategie padouchů k utlačování obětí. A realitu nevnímají jako důkaz proti svému radikálnímu projektu, ale spíše jako důkaz toho, že jejich projekt byl málo radikální."
"Naši společnost řídí profesionální manažerská třída, jejíž nárok na autoritu pramení z její údajné odbornosti. Snažili se a stále se snaží ovládat prakticky každý aspekt lidského života, od produktivních odvětví ekonomiky přes pop kulturu až po samotný jazyk. Profitují z rozšiřování státu a parastátních subjektů jako tzv. neziskové organizace."
"jsme první civilizací, která je natolik bohatá, aby financovala třídu akademických funkcionářů, jejichž prací na plný úvazek je vysvětlovat, proč tato civilizace neměla nikdy existovat."
"Musíme odmítnout jejich jazyk, který popírá realitu. Je to sterilizace a mrzačení dětí, nikoli genderově afirmativní péče. Je to dotování závislosti a smrti, nikoli snižování rizik. A jsou to diskriminace, nerovnost a vyloučení, nikoli diverzita, rovnost a inkluze."
www.youtube.com/watch?v=-f_LgqeAB-c -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Winston Marshall
@MrWinMarshall
Easily one of the greatest games of football I’ve ever attended
And hats off to the Mexico fans. All shook our hands after and congratulated us. Great sportsmanship. Good people.
ENGERLAND
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
Wow.
What a stadium. What an electric atmosphere at Azteca. May the best team win!
LFG 🏴🏴🏴🏴🏴 -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Julian Reichelt
@jreichelt
Aus gegebenem Anlass möchte ich noch einmal erinnern, dass es ist Deutschland gesetzlich vorgeschrieben ist, solche Leute als "Frau" zu bezeichnen und sie in die Umkleidekabinen von kleinen Mädchen zu lassen. Könnte das Selbstbestimmungsgesetzt vielleicht doch etwas mit verrückter linker Ideologie zu tun gehabt haben? Und warum ändert die CDU nichts daran?
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
J Stewart
@triffic_stuff_
🤯 Listen to this extraordinary exchange between Camilla Tominey and Labour’s Health Secretary James Murray. It is genuinely jaw-dropping.
Camilla: “You’re quite pro-trans, aren’t you? Do you think a woman can have a penis? Because you did previously?”
Murray: “No, I don’t.”
Camilla: “So you’ve changed your mind?”
Murray: “Yes.”
Camilla: “Why?”
Murray stumbles. He says he’s been thinking about the issue over recent years and would not now say trans women are women.
Camilla hits back: “You must have known that before. You are very well educated. How on earth can you have previously thought that a woman can have a penis?”
He had no real answer. Because there isn’t one.
This is not some backbench MP. This is the Secretary of State for Health, the man responsible for the entire NHS, puberty blocker policy, women’s health services, and child safeguarding.
He spent years either believing or pretending to believe that biological sex is fluid and that women can have penises. Only now, when the Cass Review, court rulings, and public opinion have made that position politically toxic, has he magically “changed his mind”.
Think about the damage done while he held that view. The eroded women’s rights. The confused children fast-tracked toward hormones and surgery. The female prisoners and athletes forced to share spaces with biological males. All enabled or ignored by senior Labour figures like him.
This level of ideological delusion at the very top of government is not just embarrassing, it is dangerous. Basic biology should never have been up for debate, let alone something a Health Secretary had to “evolve” on.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
J.K. Rowling
@jk_rowling
Possibly, as Minister for Health, James Murray could compel the adult gender clinics to hand over the data they refused to give to Cass. We might then find out just how much benefit these interventions confer long term, without needing to perform experiments on children too young to give meaningful consent.
Read the testimony of the ever-expanding numbers of detransitioners. Grasp that these young people, many of them extremely vulnerable - autistic, care-experienced, abuse survivors, same-sex attracted in unsupportive families - have been irreparably harmed, left with their fertility destroyed, unending medical complications and profound psychological damage.
This is a medical scandal of epic proportions and people of power and influence are still too frightened of trans activists and trans lobby groups to do the right thing and put an end to the insanity. Kids are being sacrificed to ideology and cowardice.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Preston Byrne
@prestonjbyrne
British television is so bad, they’re going to force Internet users to watch it
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
MCC Brussels
@MCC_Brussels
Europe has become the climate lobby’s laboratory.
@James7Holland says US backed foundations helped turn Brussels into a Petri dish for costly green policies, creating the illusion of consensus while businesses close and Europeans pay the price.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
What is worth saving about Europe at this point if they’re reverting to these authoritarian tendencies?
Arnaud Bertrand
@RnaudBertrand
This is properly insane: quite literally the worst example of censorship I've ever heard of anywhere.
I checked the actual ruling (which you can see here: courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/r-v-staatsa…) and, to be clear, it isn't just censorship in the conventional sense - blocking access to a website or removing content from platforms - this is the criminalization of information relayed by private citizens, with prison sentences attached.
And the most insane aspect if that it does NOT matter if the information relayed is accurate or not. It just matters that it originates from RT or other media outlets banned in the EU.
In other words, truth isn't a defense anymore in the EU, it literally doesn't matter. It's purely based on the identity of the speaker.
The ruling is actually explicit about this: the regulation, quoted by the Court says that the prohibition applies to "any content," and they draw no distinction based on what the content actually says. If it originates from banned outlets, it's banned.
It is, quite simply, a complete unraveling of the entire post-Enlightenment legal and philosophical project where entire generations of Europeans fought to move from "who says it" to "is it true" as the operative question.
Think about the absurdity of it: if RT publishes a video saying the sky is blue and you share it on a publicly accessible website in the EU, you'd fall within the scope of this ruling, making you liable to criminal prosecution.
Completely and utterly absurd. But that's the EU today for you 🤷 -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
YouTube can’t stop this. They need the US State Dept & White House to step in and counter with threats to British interests in the US. Threaten you will hit Shell/BP in energy, AstraZeneca/GSK in pharma, BAE in defense, & HSBC/Barclays in finance the second the Brits hit YouTube
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Dr Jordan B Peterson
@jordanbpeterson
To the Americans:
I've travelled all over the world. I've familiarized myself with many places, and met many people. And I'm a Canadian, although I’m privileged to reside once again in the States.
And here's something I've noticed, and it’s a key element of America's continuing greatness:
You bloody Americans value success, and you believe in its existence.
This is something that doesn't really happen anywhere else in the world. Even in other free democracies—the United Kingdom; Finland, Sweden, and Norway; Australia, New Zealand and Canada; Germany, France, and the Netherlands (great countries all)—a counterproductive cynicism too often reigns.
Success is equated with exploitation.
Ambition is looked upon with contempt.
This happens sometimes in the United States too—particularly among the miserable progressives, who confuse their resentment, ingratitude and unearned skepticism with wisdom.
But in your great country, by and large, striving is admired and success celebrated.
This means that more people strive and succeed in the US than anywhere else. And it's increasingly obvious. You remain stunningly more innovative and productive than any people anywhere else on the planet.
And so I say, as all should who are fortunate enough to live in the western world, let alone America:
Thank God for the United States.
Thank God for the wisdom of its founders.
Thank God for its faith in the free market and in the natural rights of man.
Happy birthday, you damn Yankees and Southerners.
Long may your admirable country dominate the world.
Long may your freedom and hope provide an example to those suffering everywhere at the hands of their malevolent states.
May your two and a half centuries of unparallelled success be just the beginning.
Your country is the light of the world, and the city on the hill.
Thank God for the USA.
Happy 250th.
Dr. Jordan B. Peterson -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pauline Voss
@Pauline__Voss
Es gibt Bilder, die sich nicht so leicht aus dem Gedächtnis einer Nation tilgen lassen. Die Bilder der Erfurter Hetzjagd auf das Team der Apollo-Reporter gehören dazu. Sie zeigen eine ungehemmte Brutalität, die die Verteidiger „unserer Demokratie“ als ruchlose Antidemokraten entlarven.
In Erfurt kämpfte eine radikalisierte Minderheit gegen eine Partei, die in Umfragen die relative Mehrheit der Stimmen auf sich vereint. Den Willen der Mehrheit mit Gewalt zu brechen ist genau das, was Diktatoren tun, um sich an der Macht zu halten.
Über einen Parteitag, der die wahren Feinde der Demokratie entlarvte:
nius.de/articles/24036185-05cd-4d23-b779-03f4e4c1ccf1 -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
鈴森はるか 『haruka suzumori』 🇯🇵
@harukaawake
🇯🇵🇺🇸 Happy Independence Day to our friends in the United States!
This song is very popular here in Japan and many artists often cover it. I particularly love this one.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Arnaud Bertrand
@RnaudBertrand
This is properly insane: quite literally the worst example of censorship I've ever heard of anywhere.
I checked the actual ruling (which you can see here: courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/r-v-staatsa…) and, to be clear, it isn't just censorship in the conventional sense - blocking access to a website or removing content from platforms - this is the criminalization of information relayed by private citizens, with prison sentences attached.
And the most insane aspect if that it does NOT matter if the information relayed is accurate or not. It just matters that it originates from RT or other media outlets banned in the EU.
In other words, truth isn't a defense anymore in the EU, it literally doesn't matter. It's purely based on the identity of the speaker.
The ruling is actually explicit about this: the regulation, quoted by the Court says that the prohibition applies to "any content," and they draw no distinction based on what the content actually says. If it originates from banned outlets, it's banned.
It is, quite simply, a complete unraveling of the entire post-Enlightenment legal and philosophical project where entire generations of Europeans fought to move from "who says it" to "is it true" as the operative question.
Think about the absurdity of it: if RT publishes a video saying the sky is blue and you share it on a publicly accessible website in the EU, you'd fall within the scope of this ruling, making you liable to criminal prosecution.
Completely and utterly absurd. But that's the EU today for you 🤷 -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In 2022, Biden blamed Russia for blowing up its Nord Stream pipelines. But he likely knew it was the Ukrainians because the CIA warned of the bombing before it happened. Now, the author of a gripping new book says Biden's lifting of Trump's sanctions emboldened Putin to invade.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The September 2022 destruction of three of the four Nord Stream natural gas pipelines from Russia to Germany was one of the greatest acts of sabotage in modern history, more significant in many ways than US attacks on German infrastructure during World War II. Afterward, the Biden administration led many to believe that Russia blew up its own pipeline.
The claim was disinformation, in that the Biden Administration officials who implied Russia had blown up its pipelines knew at the time that Ukrainians had, in fact, carried out the operation. A court in Germany last week charged a former Ukrainian army officer with taking part.
“I spoke to senior people at the time [in] the National Security Council — the link between the White House and the CIA — and of course they knew,” said Bojan Pancevski, author of The Nord Stream Conspiracy and the Wall Street Journal’s Chief European Political Correspondent. “[William] Burns, who was head of the CIA at the time when the pipelines exploded, was notified about the intelligence, the early intelligence in June or May before the attack happened.”
Pancevski said that Administration officials “wouldn’t say, ‘Look, we have evidence it was Russia because ABC.’ They would say, ‘Look, isn’t it obvious?’ and ‘We don’t have evidence, but isn’t it obvious?’ That sort of insinuation, innuendos.”
At the same time, he said, the officials clearly aimed to deceive reporters and the public. “That’s how these briefings work — they’re giving you pointers. They’re, pointing you in a direction. So I think that it’s fair to say that they were pointing people in the wrong direction while knowing that the actual suspicion is totally different.”
In that way, what the Biden administration did was very similar to what 51 former Intelligence Community officials did when they spread disinformation about the Hunter Biden laptop, saying that it “has all the classic earmarks of a Russian information operation.” In both cases, the officials made claims that would allow them, in the future, to be accused simply of having been mistaken, rather than of having deliberately deceived the public. Biden himself misled the public by only fingering Russia indirectly. “It was a deliberate act of sabotage and the Russians are pumping out disinformation and lies,” Biden said.
Pancevski further added that the Biden administration, by lifting sanctions imposed by President Donald Trump in 2019 on Nord Stream, signaled to Putin that the US would not back Ukraine if Russia invaded. “A lot of the media interpreted that as a gesture towards Germany,” said Pancevski, “as ‘Oh, here’s a gesture for our great ally, Germany.’ No, the gesture was towards Putin to say, ‘Look, you can have your pipeline. And if you are a good boy — cooperate — we will pivot to Asia. We will focus our energies on China, which is the actual rival here.’...Essentially what they said [was], ‘We’re pivoting to China. Here’s the pipeline. Let’s not generate tensions between each other. You can trade with energy and just don’t get aggressive.’”
Pancevski is hardly a Republican partisan. He is harshly critical of Trump’s recent military action against Iran, arguing that it significantly undermined his credibility in deterring foreign threats. “The power of deterrence he had is lost because everyone now knows that you just have to stick it out for two weeks and it’s over. America will capitulate.”
And Pancevski says it was Putin’s desire for territorial expansion, far more than feeling threatened by NATO, as University of Chicago political scientist John Mearsheimer and many MAGA Republicans believe, that led him to invade Ukraine.
“Yes, the push to get Ukraine and Georgia into NATO did play a negative role in the relationship between the United States and Russia and ultimately in what happened in Ukraine and Georgia,” Pancevski says. But, he added, “the Putin presidency is that of restoration… He’s thinking about history. He’s thinking like Ivan the Terrible, Peter the Great, or Catherine the Great. He wants to expand the empire, fortify the empire.”
Today, in retrospect, it seems obvious that it was in Ukraine’s interest to blow up Nord Stream. It needed Germany’s continued support for the war effort against Russia and understandably feared that its economic dependency on cheap Russian gas would weaken Germany’s resolve. And Pancevski’s book is based on multiple sources, including the Ukrainians who carried out the sabotage and German law enforcement. But ever since the sabotage, almost everyone has either blamed the United States or Russia.
The disinformation around who bombed the pipeline is just the tip of the iceberg of the bad thinking surrounding the tragic war in Ukraine, which shows no sign of ending any time soon. Pancevki’s book, which reads as a thrilling spy adventure, is important in addressing all of the major questions surrounding the sabotage, including why few people thought Ukraine did it, why the Biden administration lifted Trump’s sanctions on Nord Stream, and why Germany allowed itself to get so dependent on Russian energy in the first place....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2073127379640439033
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, to read the rest of the article, and to watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
É estarrecedor, mas também revelador, como Alexandre de Moraes pode permanecer no STF e continuar julgando e prendendo pessoas depois que todos vimos as provas de que Vorcaro/BM pagou à empresa de sua família pelo menos R$ 80 milhões. Tudo isso sob um contrato obsceno de R$ 129 milhões que sua esposa negociou e enviou diretamente a Vorcaro, e o casal então comprou dezenas de milhões em novos imóveis.
O tratamento extremamente favorável do STF em relação ao BM começou quando Dias Toffoli — cuja família também recebeu enormes quantias de dinheiro de pessoas ligadas ao banco — viajou em um jato particular para uma partida de futebol no Peru com o advogado petista @augustodeAB, que representava diretores da instituição. Poucos dias depois, Toffoli ordenou que todo o processo do Banco Master fosse mantido em sigilo absoluto.
Você não encontrará um advogado respeitável que diga que R$ 129 milhões é uma quantia razoável ou compreensível para qualquer profissional, mesmo o mais renomado, quanto mais para uma advogada comum como Viviane de Moraes. Além de seu papel como esposa do ministro, ninguém consegue explicar o que poderia justificar essa riqueza geracional transferida ao casal por esse banqueiro bilionário, corrupto e ladrão.
E esqueceu-se, embora não devesse, que a Globo noticiou que Vorcaro conversou com Alexandre de Moraes no dia de sua prisão sobre uma operação, e que Xandão também se encontrou com ele nas festas.
Não há escândalo judicial pior em nenhum lugar do mundo, pelo menos na última década. Mesmo assim, ele permanece impassível, com o mesmo imenso poder sobre o país e a vida das pessoas, como se nada disso tivesse acontecido.
Sam Pancher
@SamPancher
Diálogo recuperado pela PF e obtido pelo Estadão mostra Viviane Barci, esposa de Alexandre de Moraes, mandou o contrato R$ 129 milhões diretamente a Daniel Vorcaro
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Madi Hilly
@MadiHilly
NEW GERMANY RESTART REPORT: Restarting up to 18.7 gigawatts of Germany’s nuclear fleet is technically feasible, cost-effective, and supported by a majority of Germans.
Germany has an untapped energy resource at a scale matched nowhere else in the West. Per capita, the nuclear capacity Germany could add this decade is nearly an order of magnitude greater than what China is planning to.
Despite the nuclear phaseout, German law already allows work to begin on reactor restarts as long as the electricity is not sold before the law is changed.
In @RadiantEnergyG's most in-depth analysis of Germany’s reactor restart opportunity to date, we find that this program would be:
FAST: 5 reactors could be returned to service in less than 5 years, 14 reactors total in under a decade.
COST-EFFECTIVE: Every reactor studied could produce electricity well below current wholesale prices in Germany. With public financing, these plants could significantly undercut the inflation‑adjusted average of the 2010s.
CHEAPER THAN NEWBUILDS: The cost to bring back the 5 easiest-to-restart reactors is cheaper than any single Western nuclear newbuild currently under construction.
SUPPORTED BY THE PUBLIC: 61% of Germans support making use of existing nuclear in Germany, nearly three times the 22% who favor a complete phaseout and ban.
The missing ingredient remains political will.
In our conversations with the German Energy Minister, it was clear that with the right information, including a sober, accurate picture of what's actually possible, there's real interest in saving this energy supply.
Now, German nuclear industry leaders, several of whom informed our analysis, are urging support for restarts. In a letter sent to Chancellor Merz and members of Parliament, the authors wrote that “reactivating German nuclear power is technically a possible and sensible option,” attaching Radiant Energy Group's report for reference.
Germany once had one of the finest nuclear programs in the world. As more countries across the West recommit themselves to expanding nuclear, Germany has a unique chance to rebuild that expertise while directly addressing the energy cost and supply security issues it's facing. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
😂The people who claim we can run our ultra-high-energy civilization on such garbage are lying. Their goal has been, since Malthus and then Heidegger, to dismantle our high-energy civilization, not "sustain" it.
Jakob McMillin
@McMillinWx
Unbelievable damage to a wind farm near Highmore, South Dakota after this morning’s storm. #sdwx
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It's garbage energy from beginning to end
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After wind turbines spend decades killing threatened species, their blades are sent to landfills because it's too expensive to recycle them. (That little object in the upper right of the photo is a tractor burying the blades.)
www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2020-02-05/wind-turbine-b…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The media and "environmentalists" are willing to drive an entire whale species extinct in thrall to this pseudoreligion:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For years, the government has insisted that the increase in whale deaths off the East Coast has no relationship to the wind industry's high-decibel pile driving and boat activity. But now, a new documentary, "Thrown To The Wind," based on new research, will challenge that.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Brian Hansford
@remarkmarketing
I know many landfills, especially in Wyoming, won't accept windmill materials in their dumps anymore. So this is just pure waste of fiberglass crap that will never serve another purpose. Not even grinding this down for cement filler is enough.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pauline Voss
@Pauline__Voss
Die Bundesregierung förderte die Organisationen, die zu Protesten gegen den AfD-Parteitag in Erfurt aufrufen, mit über 300 Millionen Euro. Die Zahlen sind auch deswegen brisant, weil die Stadt für das kommende Wochenende eine Art Ausnahmezustand erwartet.
nius.de/politik/erfurt-afd-parteitag-steuergeld-widersetzen -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Recently elected socialist Democrats really aren’t that radical, says CNN. And yet they support abolishing the police, trans surgeries on children, and expropriating apartments. A 150-year-old socialist strategy of deliberately deceiving the public explains their success.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The socialists who swept recent New York elections and will soon run the United Kingdom are really not very radical, say many in the media. The three democratic socialists endorsed by New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and who won congressional primaries in New York, Senator Bernie Sanders, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC), socialist Los Angeles mayoral candidate Nithya Raman, and the UK’s next prime minister are proposing seemingly moderate policies for cheaper housing, food, and transportation, support for child care, a higher minimum wage, peace in Gaza, health care for all, and an end to ICE raids.
As Mayor of Greater Manchester, the UK’s next new prime minister, Andy Burnham, socialized the city’s buses but still contracts out to private firms. That’s no different from the regulated utility model used for natural monopolies around the world, including the United States, whether for electricity or water. In the US, roughly one-third of electric power comes from publicly-owned utilities. And even President Donald Trump, an avowed enemy of communism, has negotiated for taxpayers to own a share in 20 companies the US government has supported, including Intel, US Steel, and Westinghouse.
But all of those socialists support a much more radical agenda than the one they ran on. The program of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), of which Mamdani and AOC are members, calls for: total defunding and abolition of the police, jails, and prisons; ending the independence of the Supreme Court and the entire Executive Branch, making them subordinate to congress; “expropriat[ing] property from capitalists and deliver it to the working class”; socializing energy production; allowing surgeons to sterilize children and adolescents in an effort to change their sex; a return to Joe Biden’s open borders policy; and the decriminalization of illegal camping and open air drug use. Burnham has proposed to spend an additional £39 billion on public housing, impose a new tax on everyone, and adopt the “Housing First” policy, which has resulted in the subsidization and enabling of drug addiction and death in the U.S....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2072332361086509242
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
The Alliance for Responsible Citizenship
@ARC_Conference
"We are the first civilisation wealthy enough to fund a tenured class whose full-time job is to explain why it should never have existed."
According to Michael Shellenberger, many of the crises facing the West — from crime and censorship to mass migration and identity politics — are not isolated problems, but symptoms of the same underlying ideology that has captured our institutions.
Watch @shellenberger's full speech at ARC 2026:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Open borders, "homelessness," trans, DEI, and other issues appear to have nothing in common, but they do. Each undermines a core pillar of civilization (i.e., law & order, child protection, meritocracy) in the name of compassion. Put them together & you have the end of the West.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Friends — Sometimes you have to take a step back and see the bigger picture. That’s what I tried to do today in my keynote speech to the Alliance for Responsible Citizenship, the third gathering of a remarkable group of civilization-positive people. I hope you enjoy it. — Michael
I have flown here from California to talk about saving Western civilization, which I am aware is a little like taking fire safety advice from a man whose house keeps burning down. These observations are based on research that my co-author Alex Gutentag and I conducted over the last three years.
Our remarkable civilization rests on several pillars, including law and order, national borders, meritocracy, equal justice, the protection of children, industrialization, free speech, and a widespread faith in its capacity to deliver a positive future.
I am not here to predict that these pillars will fall. I am here to report that the demolition crew has been hired, paid in full, and asked to submit a diversity statement.
Decriminalization, depolicing, and the enabling of illegal camping, shoplifting, open-air drug dealing, and use undermine public safety.
In San Francisco, authorities amputated the rotted feet of a mentally ill “homeless” woman — and then put her right back on the street. In the name of compassion.
Mass migration hurts working-class citizens, increases crime, and creates victims.
Biden’s open borders policy resulted in child trafficking and death, including of minors falling from rooftops while working.
DEI policies and other forms of racial and sexual discrimination subvert meritocracy and undermine public safety.
British police handcuffed and let 18-year-old Henry Nowak bleed to death because they believed the lie told by the murderer’s accomplice that Nowak was a racist and thus, by extension, the perpetrator.
Los Angeles politicians defunded and mismanaged the fire department and failed to keep the crucial water reservoir full because they were focused like a laser on DEI, resulting in catastrophic and utterly avoidable fires.
Trans surgeries on minors transgress historic protections of children like Fox Varian. Surgeons removed her breasts when she was 16 after trans-influenced communicators convinced her she was actually a boy.
Climate activists raise energy prices, deindustrialize rich nations, and work to stop poor nations from building natural-gas-fueled fertilizer factories.
Our schools, universities, and legacy media add insult to injury by programming children to believe they are stained by slavery, colonialism, and genocide.
And now governments around the world are seeking to deny them alternative sources of information that might contradict the establishment’s degrading narrative while simultaneously imposing digital IDs on the rest of us.
Many believe that these attacks on our civilization stem from ignorance, excessive empathy, or good intentions gone wrong. Indeed, the vast majority of people do not want to scrap the pillars of Western civilization. And many of them are motivated by compassion and concern for the most vulnerable members of our society.
But the intellectual pioneers who framed anti-civilizational policies as necessary for remedying entrenched and historical injustices do, in fact, want to destroy Western civilization as we know it, and replace it with something they believe will be more just. They believe that inequality and suffering stem from our social organization in general and from capitalism, industrialization, meritocracy, equal justice, and gender roles in particular.
They are, knowingly and unknowingly, heirs to Jean-Jacques Rousseau, who said society corrupted innocent children while abandoning all five of his children to orphanages. They believe they can, both through their policies and the transformation of language and thought, radically reorganize society in ways that dramatically reduce, if not eliminate, inequality and suffering.
Their complaint is not that the system is malfunctioning but rather that it’s functioning normally.
And a close reading of these anti-civilization intellectuals reveals that they are motivated not by empathy and love of humanity but rather by its opposite: the creation, projection, and hatred of cartoon villains onto others. Rousseau was the first in a long line of reformers who claim to love humanity but who hate humans. They believe the defenders of civilization are as evil as the system they defend and demand that they be silenced and removed from universities, social media platforms, and polite society. They view law and order, national borders, and meritocracy as strategies for villains to oppress victims. And they view reality not as evidence against their radical project but rather as evidence that their project has been insufficiently radical.
There are economic reasons for this. Our societies are directed by a professional managerial class whose claim to authority stems from its alleged expertise. They have sought and continue to seek to control practically every aspect of human life, from the productive sectors of the economy to popular culture to language itself. They benefit from an expansion of the state and of parastatal entities like NGOs, and thus need to maintain the fantasy that Western civilization creates victims and that, if only they had more power, they could reorganize it in ways that would finally allow for universal freedom, prosperity, and sustainability.
In other words, we are the first civilization wealthy enough to fund a tenured class whose full-time job is to explain why it should never have existed.
But what most drives the anti-civilization discourse and movement is ....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2069816718990418381
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Trump says UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer will resign tomorrow, which a populist German politician calls “a sign of decline for establishment parties.” The voter revolt against anti-civilization policies on mass migration, climatism, and trans is just beginning.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Criticism of Bauhaus makes you a Nazi, reports @FT. This up there with “Hitler was vegetarian and so vegetarians are Nazis.” The @FT is, like @guardian, not a serious newspaper.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
AfD Derangement Syndrome is real
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A 1990 law meant to protect Native American skeletons and sacred items has spiraled out of control, say anthropologists. Tribes are appropriating and burying non-indigenous items, including a Chinese vase, X-rays, and photographs. Now, the ransacking threatens medical science.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In early 2024, the world-renowned American Museum of Natural History in New York City closed two major halls of Native American objects covering roughly 10,000 square feet. Its president wrote that the halls were “vestiges of an era when museums such as ours did not respect the values, perspectives, and indeed shared humanity of Indigenous peoples.” Around the same time, the Field Museum of Natural History in Chicago, Harvard’s Peabody Museum, the Cleveland Museum of Art, and others covered or removed Native American displays.
They did so to comply with legislation Congress passed in 1990, the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA). The goal of the legislation was to end more than a century of museums and collectors digging up and warehousing the Native American dead. For generations, private collectors, museums, and federal agencies had assembled collections of Native skeletons and grave goods taken during expeditions across tribal homelands.
NAGPRA required museums and agencies that take federal money to identify Native remains and cultural items and return them to lineal descendants and affiliated tribes. It was, by design, a compromise. Identifiable ancestors and genuine sacred objects would go home, while ancient or unaffiliated materials would stay available for research and public education.
But the law has spiraled wildly beyond its purpose, says anthropologist Elizabeth Weiss in a new podcast, and now reaches objects no one would call an ancestor. Consider a fragment of a Chinese bowl. The Phoebe A. Hearst Museum of Anthropology at the University of California, Berkeley, catalogs a Ming dynasty porcelain bowl base fragment made in China around 1595. Its own record says the piece was presumed salvaged from the wreck of the Spanish galleon San Agustin, which sank off Point Reyes, California, in November 1595. The museum files this Chinese trade fragment under its Native California department and has hidden it away.
The law has even led anthropologists and curators to treat photographs and recent books as Native American artifacts. In a notice published in January 2026, the Fowler Museum at UCLA moved to repatriate photographic negatives of petroglyphs from Black Canyon in San Bernardino County. A separate notice that same month listed 146 objects that Turtle Bay Exploration Park in Redding would repatriate, among them Jaime de Angulo’s Indian Tales, a book the City of Redding bought for a museum reference library in 1981.
Weiss says the skeletal collections now disappearing are what train the people who read bones for a living, the forensic anthropologists who identify crime victims, and the anatomists who teach in medical schools. “There is a real danger,” she said, “that we’re going to lose some skills that are really essential to medicine, to forensics, and who knows what else.”...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2062561348198994159
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, watch the full interview, and read the rest of the story!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Anti-civilization activists are destroying archaeology across the West.
Tichys Einblick
@TichysEinblick
Zivilisationen verschwinden, wenn man sich ihrem Vermächtnis nicht mehr verbunden und verpflichtet fühlt. Die Abschaffung der Archäologie an der Berliner Humboldt-Universität ist das Symbol einer tiefen europäischen Krise.
www.tichyseinblick.de/meinungen/schliessung-archaeologie-… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
The Telegraph
@Telegraph
At the height of the pandemic, anti-lockdown campaigners were covertly monitored by the Government and military, and had their social media posts flagged for removal.
🔗 www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/06/20/covid-inquiry-buried-… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@Keir_Starmer is going forward with his grotesque and immoral transgender experiment on children. He will be remembered for enabling the abuse of minors by grooming gangs and quack medical predators.
James Esses
@JamesEsses
🚨Important Announcement: Puberty Blockers Judicial Review🚨
Following months of radio silence, I’m saddened to report that the government has announced that it is pushing forward with the puberty blockers trial, regardless of the significant ethical concerns raised that led to the temporary pause.
Most troubling of all is that they are now refusing to halt recruitment of children until the end of the Judicial Review that we are bringing.
As such, we have no choice but to seek an emergency injunction to block a single child being recruited and given this poison. There will be a hearing at the end of July to determine this.
Please rest assured that I and the entire team will be pursuing this Judicial Review all the way.
@jamesmurray_ldn - Just as with your predecessor, Wes Streeting, we implore you to do the right thing and pull the plug on this monstrosity of a trial. If you don’t, we will see you in Court. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Folha de S.Paulo
@folha
Deputado do Novo recebe prêmio internacional por defesa da liberdade de expressão
www1.folha.uol.com.br/colunas/painel/2026/06/deputado-do-… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is great news for children and their families. WPATH is a quack medical organization that promotes procedures that sterilize and permanently damage children. It should be held accountable for causing the worst medical scandal in recent memory.
x.com/shellenberger/status/1764799914918490287
JD Vance
@JDVance
Doctors and hospitals used junk science from WPATH to justify selling gender transition procedures to kids and their parents. Huge props to Andrew and his team for taking an important step in our efforts to end this outrageous practice.
Andrew Ferguson
@AFergusonFTC
Since President Trump was sworn in, the @FTC has been aggressively protecting children and the rights of parents across every part of the economy. Today, the FTC took another huge step in defense of children and parents. We have filed an enforcement action against the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) for making false and unsubstantiated claims about the safety and efficacy of medical transition procedures, and for providing to doctors the means to sell those procedures to children and parents.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You may, as I do, disagree vehemently with @hasanthehun, @cenkuygur, or @DVanLangenhove on many things. But it’s wrong to ban them from the cradle of free speech. As part of his war on Western civilization, @Keir_Starmer is turning the UK into a police state.
Dries Van Langenhove
@DVanLangenhove
After days of detention and interrogation, the UK government has now decided to ban me from the country because my participation in the (private!) Free Speech Forum in London, organised by @shellenberger, “would not be conducive to the public good”.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We are in the middle of our annual Westminster Free Speech forum. Many people from Left to Right signed our 2023 Declaration, below. It is ironic and tragic that the birthplace to Milton, Locke, and Mill has descended into tyranny. Shame on Starmer.
westminsterdeclaration.org -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Like many other cities, L.A. funds NGOs to give money, paraphernalia, and even drugs to mentally ill addicts living on the street. They do so under the Big Lie that they're "helping the homeless." Bravo to Trump for trying to end such immoral policies.
www.newsnationnow.com/politics/trump-suspends-funding-la-…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Thank you @RichMcHugh @NewsNation
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We are exiting the age of UAP/UFO secrecy and ridicule to an age of transparency and disclosure. Why then is the Director of the Department of War's UFO agency, AARO, denying the existence of a video that a federal agent said was made of a UAP that 5 additional agents witnessed?
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For nearly 75 years, the US government and its intermediaries have ridiculed people who report Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAPs). In 1953, the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) created a task force that recommended debunking all reports of UAPs, then called UFOs. In the 1960s, a government-created study by the University of Colorado falsely suggested there were few to no UAPs. In the 1980s, the US military and intelligence agents fed false information to investigators and journalists and drove at least one man to a mental breakdown.
That Cold War era of secrecy has been replaced by a new age of disclosure, as the DoW’s release of a third tranche of videos and documents last week shows.
And yet there is still far more secrecy than disclosure. In response to a demand from Congress, the Department of War in 2022 created a new agency called AARO that claims to investigate cases and to release documents about major events. And yet AARO is either covering up or making serious errors in the way it describes important cases....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2066928620183163209
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, to read the full article, and watch the whole video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
fyi
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@ProfAviLoeb just confirmed to me by phone that his UAP advisory board will not have access to any classified information and has no legal authority.
Christopher Sharp
@ChrisUKSharp
So at first, we thought it was one UAP Science Advisory Council.
But it is actually a UFO Board supported by several advisory groups - one of which seems to be the Science Council.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
US government disinformation goes back decades:
Marik vR
@MvonRen
STUNNING CIA PSYCHOLOGICAL OPERATION ON UFOs:
From 1947 to 1952, ~20% of UFO incidents were classified “Unknown,” including 33% (!) of “Excellent” quality.
In 1953, CIA instituted a sweeping government policy to “debunk” UFOs.
Two years later, only 3% of cases were “Unknown.” -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@ProfAviLoeb just confirmed to me by phone that his UAP advisory board will not have access to any classified information and has no legal authority.
Christopher Sharp
@ChrisUKSharp
So at first, we thought it was one UAP Science Advisory Council.
But it is actually a UFO Board supported by several advisory groups - one of which seems to be the Science Council.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
My concern about this stems not only from reporting on UAP but also reporting on censorship.
Censorship always begins with a group of people who think they are "experts" and thus entitled to decide what we, the people, are allowed to see.
The same attitude prevails among bureaucrats who make up phony reasons to keep information from the public.
President Trump has rightly taken a populist attitude toward UAPs. Any whiff of "experts" trying to control what the public is allowed to see on UAPs is alarming. The government censorship of UAPs has gone on for far too long.
True UAP experts should be demanding transparency, not claiming some special authority to decide what the public is allowed to see.
In terms of analyzing videos, images, and documents, scientifically, that can be done by anyone after the videos are released. Science is a process involving many people and is not owned or monopolized by any group of people. Any suggestion otherwise is unscientific!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Many documents, including this one, have not yet been released in unredacted form.
They must be released as there is simply no way at this point for any government bureaucrat to claim that revealing the UAP task force's "potential explanations" would undermine national security.
We have had dozens of current and former senior government/military/IC leaders speculate as to explanations.
There is no constitutional justification for this level of secrecy. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“Despite… assertions of ‘transparency’ & the … release of official UAP videos… the core mechanisms of how the U.S. government views, tracks, and analyzes the UAP issue remain heavily guarded, classified, and blacked out…”
Excellent new piece by @theblackvault
John Greenewald, Jr.
@theblackvault
🚨 The Pentagon points to UAP document and video releases as evidence of transparency.
But a newly released Inspector General proposal tells a different story.
Check it out: www.theblackvault.com/documentarchive/department-of-war-c…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is key:
If there truly is ‘nothing to hide.’ as various public relations campaigns and limited document drops by the military try to suggest, then the foundational policies, potential benefits, and historical background of UAP tracking would not require blanket censorship.” -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Andrew Kerr
@AndrewKerrNC
NYTimes didn't mention that Newsom asked the Native American tribe to donate huge money to his wife's charity JUST AFTER he used his office to block its rival tribe from opening a competing casino.
Details on that here -- freebeacon.com/california/corporate-donors-gave-big-to-a-… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Rand Paul
@RandPaul
We now know Dr. Fauci had deep ties to the intelligence community that predate the COVID pandemic. Think about what that means. When the question of whether this virus came from a lab first arose, one man was positioned to shape the answer across science, intelligence, and public opinion.
He steered the narrative away from the lab leak theory because he knew the NIH was funding gain-of-function research at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
Bit odd that that investigating child abuse by grooming gangs was resisted for years but then now all of a sudden, child safety is the number one priority for Keir Starmer.
Just watch this government build the machinery to verify every adult online at speed. And once the infrastructure exists, the uses for it will go far beyond social media age checks -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
John Stossel
@JohnStossel
Obama's White House smeared U Colorado prof @RogerPielkeJr after he questioned the climate apocalypse.
His speeches were canceled. Colorado closed his research center & put his office in a closet. But he didn’t give up.
How activists tried and FAILED to cancel a good scientist:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Winston Marshall
@MrWinMarshall
This story is wild. Literal psy-ops run by British deep state, working against the British people
Ed West
@edwest
One of those things where you try explaining it to not very political people and you just end up sounding completely mad www.dailymail.com/news/article-15897997/unit-government-p…
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The American Psych. Assoc. says therapy is “effective,” but Americans diagnosed with depression rose from 20% to 30% since 2015, while the number of Americans in therapy rose from 17 to 22 million. Victimhood ideology and the valuing of feelings over virtue are to blame.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Psychotherapy is today one of the largest helping professions in the West. The American Psychological Association (APA) counts more than 172,000 members, and the US government counts 204,300 psychologists, 483,500 mental health counselors, and 77,800 marriage and family therapists at work. The share of adults who saw a mental health professional in the past year more than doubled since the beginning of the century, from 10% in 2001 to 24% today. One recent study put the number of adults in outpatient talk therapy at nearly 22 million a year, up from about 16.5 million only three years earlier. In 2012, the American Psychological Association declared psychotherapy “effective and highly cost-effective.”
And yet psychological problems and psychiatric disorders keep rising. Depression among Americans aged 12 and older rose 60 percent over the last decade, from 8.2 percent in 2013 and 2014 to 13.1 percent in 2021 to 2023. The share of adults ever diagnosed with depression is today an astonishing 30%, almost ten points above its 2015 reading.
A 2016 study in Pediatrics tracked the share of adolescents reporting a major depressive episode rising from 8.7 percent in 2005 to 11.3 percent in 2014. A 2024 study of 1.7 million young people found clinical depression up about 60 percent and anxiety up 31 percent in only four years.
“Endless psychotherapy is a waste of time and money at best, and harmful at worst,” writes psychotherapist Jonathan Alpert in a new book, Therapy Nation. I spoke to Alpert last week, and our conversation follows the video above.
Of course, mental distress was rising before the creation of psychotherapy, and psychotherapy can produce real benefits, particularly for specific conditions. In the late 19th Century, a neurologist chronicled an epidemic of nervous collapse he named neurasthenia, marked by fatigue, anxiety, and depressed mood in an 1881 book. The French neurologist Jean-Martin Charcot reported that anxious neurasthenics made up the bulk of his own private practice. And a skilled therapist can ease a particular patient’s anxiety and even lift an episode of depression. Millions of people say, and have shown, that psychotherapy has helped them.
But the fact remains that psychotherapy grew in popularity over the same periods of time that people have reported worsening mental health. This is true not just over the last 120 years but also over the last 20 to 35 years. The rate of depression among adults under 30 more than doubled, from 13% in 2017 to 28% in 2026. Anxiety disorders among people aged 10 to 24 rose 52 percent globally between 1990 and 2021. If psychotherapy is, as APA says, “effective,” it’s either, at best, not effective enough or, at worst, contributing to the problem.
And there is evidence that psychotherapy often makes things worse. A 2006 study of 1,868 individuals found that people who received less psychotherapy achieved greater “reliable and clinically significant improvement” than those who received more. While this could simply represent the reality that people with worse mental distress require less counseling than those who do, it could also mean that psychotherapy worsens mental health.
Through the 1980s and 1990s, recovered memory therapy persuaded thousands of patients, often young women, that they had survived childhood sexual abuse that never happened, resulting in false accusations. A Houston jury awarded one woman nearly $5.8 million in 1997 after therapists implanted false memories. By one estimate, more than 50,000 American therapists accepted the theory of repressed memory uncritically.
And large studies challenge the credibility of the entire field of psychotherapy. A 2018 review estimated that 5 to 20 percent of psychotherapy patients suffer adverse events, including new or worsening symptoms. A 2024 reanalysis of youth depression trials concluded that about one in five young patients got worse during active treatment. Across studies, 40 to 60 percent of psychotherapy patients never reach recovery.
What went wrong? Why has therapy failed to deliver on its promise? And why does it so often cause harm?...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2065181091682791913
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, watch the full video, and read the rest of the article!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pauline Voss
@Pauline__Voss
The European Commission is planning a full-scale attack on press freedom and free elections: Through the European Democracy Shield, it aims to reshape the media landscape and eliminate new media from market. May thanks to @shellenberger for publishing my research on his website: www.public.news/p/eu-demands-sweeping-censorship-to
The measures under the Democracy Shield would result in censorship and create a network of state-run media:
▶️ The EU plans to pump billions of euros of taxpayers’ money into selected media outlets, creating a network of state-run media to spread government narratives.
▶️ State-selected and state-funded media outlets are to act as fact-checkers, creating an „archive of truth“ and working directly for EU authorities, especially during elections.
▶️ With new laws, the EU aims to gain control over algorithms and decide what appears in feeds.
▶️ Unwelcome media outlets are to be demonetized while political influencers are to be regulated in the name of supposed child protection.
All details of my research: -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We have to shield democracy from disinformation, says @vonderleyen. In truth, her Orwellian "Democracy Shield" is about shielding the European Commission from democracy. And now, reveals @Pauline__Voss, the EU is financing "news" propaganda outfits to demand more censorship.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
EU Demands Sweeping Censorship To Influence Elections
by @Pauline__Voss
Last September, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen addressed Europeans in her State of the Union speech. “The rise in information manipulation and disinformation is, as we hear, dividing our societies,” she said. “That is why we urgently need the ‘European Democracy Shield.’”
But the “Democracy Shield” is, in reality, the Orwellian name for Europe’s plan to interfere in national elections by censoring millions of citizens on social media based on pro-EU propaganda “news” that the Commission will fund. It says it must do so in order to safeguard “the truth.”
The Commission, which is the EU’s powerful executive branch, says “disinformation,” including “foreign disinformation,” threatens to mislead voters and thus undermine democracy.
But Public and others have documented repeated instances of the EU spreading disinformation to undermine elections in Romania, the Czech Republic, and other nations, and then demanding social media on the basis of that disinformation.
Last year, the Commission fined Elon Musk $140 million for refusing to comply with its censorship demands, and the French government is attempting to prosecute him on the same grounds.
The Commission is planning a massive increase in government money for state propaganda, which it calls “independent” and “fact checking.
The unelected von der Leyen and the rest of her Commission are more powerful than the democratically elected European Parliament, and are essentially pursuing the agenda sought by the leaders of France and Germany, who are trying to prevent right-wing victories over the next several years.
And now, the EU plans to pump billions of euros in taxpayer money into selected media organizations to strengthen their purported “independence,” which in reality would make these media groups financially dependent on the state...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2064379667491295529
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of free speech and read the rest of the article!This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Catherine Herridge
@C__Herridge
EDITORIAL DOUBLE STANDARD: When I was a senior investigative correspondent at CBS News (2019–2024) I was stunned by how little due diligence some colleagues did on Southern Poverty Law Center's claims....
Versus their “attack dog” mentality applied to right-leaning non-profits and think tanks.
More for subscribers In this week's @X Article! -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In supporting Graham Platner, Democrats have abandoned #metoo's "believe women" slogan. They should now take responsibility for the damage #metoo caused, including false accusations, the demonization of male sexuality, and the crippling anxiety behind Gen Z's romantic recession.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Senators Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders, Chuck Schumer, and others continue to support Democratic senatorial candidate Graham Platner, despite comments he made that offended feminist Democrats and an accusation of violence by a former girlfriend. “Look, he has apologized for that,” said Warren, referring to Platner’s comments on social media in 2013.
In response to a Reddit post titled “shorts that prevent you from being raped,” Platner had written, “how about people just take some responsibility for themselves and not get so f----ed up they wind up having sex with someone they don’t mean to?”
At the same time, all four Senators refused to confirm Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court after a woman alleged that he had tried to sexually assault her while they were in high school. Warren opposed the nomination, citing “credible allegations” of sexual assault. “I listened to Dr. Ford, and I listened to Judge Kavanaugh,” said Sanders. “I believe Dr. Ford.” Said Schumer, “For too long, when women have made serious allegations of abuse, they have been ignored. That cannot happen in this case.” And yet that’s precisely what Schumer has done in the case of Platner.
Some may object that the charge against Kavanaugh was more serious, but it was no more credible than the ones against Platner. An ex-girlfriend, Lindsey Fifield, said Platner “regularly grabbed her by the shoulders,” reported the New York Times, “sometimes hard enough to leave marks — and, on one occasion, yanked her out of a cab by her wrist after an argument when she wanted to stay in the car. During one argument, she recalled, he twisted her arm behind her back, shoved her into a bedroom and held the door closed from the other side so she couldn’t get out, telling her to remain there until she was ‘calm.’”
Fitfield’s accusation is difficult, if not impossible, to prove, and the same can be said of Ford’s. None of the individuals whom Ford said were at the party, including her lifelong friends, corroborated her account, and one told the Senate she had no memory of it. And a different man told Senate investigators that he was the man who assaulted Ford, not Kavanaugh.
Moreover, there is evidence of Platner misrepresenting the truth. For example, he denied he had a serious relationship with his accuser, but the Times’ reporters said they saw a text he sent her in 2016, which read, “Lyndsey, I love you in a way I can’t even describe. “You are literally everything to me.”
Platner denied knowing that a tattoo on his chest was the symbol of a Nazi death squad, but last August, “months before Mr. Platner acknowledged the tattoo himself,” noted the Times, “Ms. Fifield told friends that her ex-boyfriend-turned-Senate candidate ‘has a Nazi tattoo on his chest.’ ‘It’s a Totenkopf,’ she told them on Aug. 20, according to a screenshot she shared with The Times. ‘An actual one.’”
And Platner said he was treated in 2016 for PTSD, one of whose symptoms is uncontrolled anger and “hyperarousal and reactivity,” which is the feeling of being constantly on the lookout for danger. Platner’s campaign team did not deny Fitfield’s accusation that he fantasized about someone breaking into his home so he could rape them. “Asked about those remarks, a Platner campaign official did not dispute them,” noted the Times.
For years, Democrats have accused their political opponents, particularly Donald Trump, of being Nazis, rapists, or soft on Nazis and violence against women. And yet here Democrats are supporting a person facing credible accusations of being sympathetic to Nazism, and accusations of violence that are no less credible than the ones Sanders, Warren, Schumer, and others made against Kavanaugh.
While one interpretation of the remarks and positions taken by Sanders, Warren, and Schumer toward Platner is that they are hypocrites putting ends-justify-the-means politics before principles.
At the same time, the difference in reactions to Franken and Platner shows that accusations of sexual harassment have less salience today than in 2017. Back then, Senate Democrats did not defend Democratic Senator Al Franken after he was accused of sexual harassment, even though some progressives later said the evidence for it was weak, as they have done with Platner.
Meanwhile, the accusations against Platner do not appear to have changed the minds of many Democrats on social media nor among many voters in Maine. And even a Republican strategist told Jesse Watters on Friday that the allegations were unlikely to change the minds of many swing voters. What changed?
x.com/shellenberger/status/2063707141257777639
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
John Papola
@JohnPapola
Give me a break. I worked at Viacom/CBS (now Paramount) for over a decade. Of course, it was +90% Democrats.
Everyone knows this. Everyone.
And newsrooms in particular vote Democrat to a higher degree than Berkeley, California.
And you know what? Fine. I have lots of friends with whom I disagree from my time there. It was a great place, actually.
To act as if this claim about bias is controversial, let alone inaccurate, shows that he’s either a liar, an imbecile, or so deeply incurious and tunnel-visioned that you don’t belong anywhere near any job involving information discernment.
But he’s got that familiar anchor voice, so we’re supposed to act like he’s not being a complete clown. Give me a break. You people are a mess.
Western Lensman
@WesternLensman
Scott Pelley says Bari Weiss asked 60 Minutes staffers: “Why do you think the country thinks you’re biased?"
Pelley: "Why do you think so? Do you have a poll? Is there market research? What are you talking about?"
"Because we certainly didn't believe that."
Incredible. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Kevin Bass
@kevinnbass
Imagine spending your whole life becoming an academic expert. Then a random guy online tells you that you are wrong about your own field. And he's right. But you can never admit that. Because it would mean admitting that your life was a lie. That is the dilemma of many academics.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Scott Pelley says CBS demanded he "inject falsehoods," and wants to "murder" 60 Minutes. There's no evidence for either claim and good reason to think they're false. Pelley joins Dan Rather, Katie Couric, and Chuck Todd in spreading misinformation and then denying he had done so
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After being fired from CBS, former “60 Minutes” correspondent Scott Pelley yesterday said that “new management has instructed me to inject falsehoods and bias into a politically sensitive story. I’ve been told to include assertions that are unverified.”
Those are remarkable claims for which Pelley presented no evidence. Indeed, it would be extraordinary for CBS to demand such things of a correspondent, either verbally or in writing, given the reputational risk to the network.
A more likely explanation is that Pelley disagreed with someone at CBS and then declared a difference of opinion to be a demand to lie. Support for this interpretation comes from the fact that he claimed Tuesday that CBS’s new management, led by Bari Weiss, was trying to kill “60 Minutes,” something for which he also did not provide evidence.
Moreover, the accusation makes no sense. CBS Editor-in-Chief Bari Weiss took the job to rebuild CBS News, not to wreck it, and a ruined “60 Minutes” would hurt her. Paramount’s owners did not pay billions for the network to burn its best asset for spite. So the simpler reading is that Pelley is the one stretching the truth.
Doing so appears to be a habit for Pelley. He told The New York Times, “I have been in combat in Afghanistan. I have been in combat in Iraq,” but being in a combat zone as a journalist is not the same as being “in combat.” The remark is yet more evidence of Pelley’s propensity to exaggerate to the point of lying.
For decades, mainstream liberal journalists have displayed remarkable levels of arrogance, even as they get major stories wrong.
Consider the case of CBS News’ former anchor Dan Rather. In the fall of 2004, two months before the election, Rather presented documents purporting to show favoritism in George W. Bush’s National Guard service. Experts called them forgeries. CBS apologized: “We made a mistake in judgment, and for that I am sorry,” Rather said. On air, he added, “I want to say, personally and directly, I’m sorry.”
But then, a decade later, Rather told Variety he still stands “100 percent” behind the report and reframed the apology.
Or consider NBC’s Katie Couric. In her 2016 documentary “Under the Gun,” editors inserted roughly eight to nine seconds of silence after she asked Virginia gun owners how to keep guns from felons and terrorists without background checks, making them look stumped. The raw audio revealed that they answered immediately.
Couric’s first instinct was to defend what she did, saying she was “very proud of the film.” Only after sustained backlash did she apologize.
In her 2021 memoir “Going There,” Couric admitted she cut Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s harshest anthem-kneeling comments from her 2016 interview. Ginsburg had said kneeling players showed “contempt for a government that has made it possible for their parents and grandparents to live a decent life, which they probably could not have lived in the places they came from.”
NBC’s “Meet the Press,” in the spring of 2020, aired a clip of Attorney General Bill Barr that omitted part of his answer, misleading the public.
When Catherine Herridge interviewed Barr for CBS Evening News, she asked what history would say about his decision to drop the case against a former National Security Advisor to President Trump, Michael Flynn. The Obama administration’s FBI had illegally targeted Flynn for entrapment and prosecution. Barr replied that ”history is written by the winner. So it largely depends on who’s writing the history.”
"Meet the Press'" anchor at the time, Chuck Todd, said on air that Barr “didn’t make the case that he was upholding the rule of law. He was almost admitting that, yeah, this is a political job.’” But “Meet the Press” had left out the second part of Barr’s answer to Herridge, in which he said, “But I think a fair history would say that it was a good decision because it upheld the rule of law.”
The safeguards the journalism profession built against error did not work when it mattered. The corrections, the editors, the fact-checkers, and the standards desks all sat in place while the press got the border, trans medicine, climate, the sixth extinction, Russiagate, the Hunter Biden laptop, Covid and much else wrong. Gerth described how reporters sought to “shoot the messenger” rather than grapple with evidence contradicting the Russia collusion narrative...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2062276599479980164
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism and to read the full article!This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
CBS has fired “60 Minutes” correspondent Scott Pelley, and rightly so. He betrayed journalistic principles in platforming debunked science, in being closed-minded and dogmatic, and in behaving like a pompous ass. Good riddance.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"60 Minutes" is the most prestigious TV news program in America. But a new review of the last 20 years of its reporting reveals serious inaccuracies and partisan bias on immigration, transgenderism, climate change, Covid, Russiagate, the Hunter Biden laptop, and more.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
🎯
ZitoSalena
@ZitoSalena
There are hundreds of journalists out there who have never risen to this level of arrogance in our profession; just doing their job, grinding it out every day, covering city councils & water authorities school boards & the cops beat.
None of them, including me, would ever consider this appropriate.
Mediaite
@Mediaite
Scott Pelley Absolutely Hammers New '60 Minutes' EP to His Face — New Reports Reveal: You'll 'Never Be Welcomed Here' www.mediaite.com/media/news/scott-pelley-absolutely-hamme…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
👀
J.D. Haltigan, PhD 🏒👨💻
@JDHaltigan
Here was the hack Scott Pelley disgracing himself when interviewing @Moms4Liberty about the sexually explicit & degenerate Leftist books that they were heroically working to have removed from schools.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"60 Minutes" is the most prestigious TV news program in America. But a new review of the last 20 years of its reporting reveals serious inaccuracies and partisan bias on immigration, transgenderism, climate change, Covid, Russiagate, the Hunter Biden laptop, and more.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
ZitoSalena
@ZitoSalena
There are hundreds of journalists out there who have never risen to this level of arrogance in our profession; just doing their job, grinding it out every day, covering city councils & water authorities school boards & the cops beat.
None of them, including me, would ever consider this appropriate.
Mediaite
@Mediaite
Scott Pelley Absolutely Hammers New '60 Minutes' EP to His Face — New Reports Reveal: You'll 'Never Be Welcomed Here' www.mediaite.com/media/news/scott-pelley-absolutely-hamme…
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"60 Minutes" is the most prestigious TV news program in America. But a new review of the last 20 years of its reporting reveals serious inaccuracies and partisan bias on immigration, transgenderism, climate change, Covid, Russiagate, the Hunter Biden laptop, and more.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
CBS “60 Minutes” correspondent Scott Pelley and his former colleague Sharyn Alfonsi say Bari Weiss is destroying “60 Minutes”, the most prestigious program in American television news.
For more than half a century, the CBS newsmagazine has defined investigative television, drawing tens of millions of Sunday-night viewers with its ticking stopwatch, its ambush interviews, and a roster of correspondents treated as the closest thing American journalism has to royalty.
Alfonsi warned late last month that “the wall between editorial independence and corporate interest at CBS is being methodically torn down.”
Pelley went further yesterday, confronting Weiss’s new executive producer, Nick Bilton, at a staff meeting. When Bilton told the room that Weiss “loves 60 Minutes,” Pelley shot back that “she’s murdering 60 Minutes,” that “she does not love this place,” and that “she was brought in to kill it and is doing exactly that.”
Pelley told Bilton, a technology journalist, that he held “slender qualifications” for the job. Cecilia Vega, another ousted correspondent, framed Weiss’s firings as “censorship, both imposed and self-driven,” and “dangerous for democracy.”
But a review of the last two decades of “60 Minutes” reveals that the program has been inaccurate and partisan on many major issues, including the border, transgenderism, climate, species extinctions, Russiagate, and the Hunter Biden laptop....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2061862011781493040
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the full story, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Progressives call them "homeless encampments," but they are open-air drug scenes. Ask the homeless themselves what their lives are like, and they will tell you it's about feeding their fentanyl & meth addictions and being victims of violence by other addicts and dealers.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Expensive housing, not drug addiction, causes most homelessness, say Democrats. It’s a lie. Addiction & mental illness are why people live on sidewalks. Progressives deny this reality to justify their pro-drug policies, which enable and trap addicts. @galexybrane
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Expensive housing, not drug addiction, causes most homelessness, say Democrats. It’s a lie. Addiction & mental illness are why people live on sidewalks. Progressives deny this reality to justify their pro-drug policies, which enable and trap addicts. @galexybrane
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Homelessness is the cause of mental illness and addiction, not the other way around, say Democrats. “Only one in seven people who becomes homeless has a mental health problem,” said California gubernatorial candidate Tom Steyer in a forum with Ezra Klein, “But virtually everyone who stays on the street for a long time develops one.” Klein agreed that the main issue was economic. “Before people become homeless, they are housed,” he said, “and what tends to happen is that they have an income shock or a health crisis or something happens where they can no longer pay their rent, and they’re evicted.” Los Angeles councilmember Nithya Raman, who is running for mayor, similarly frames homelessness as a structural issue, saying, “LA simply does not have the shelter beds it needs for its homeless population.”
When asked about Spencer Pratt’s use of the word “zombie” to describe homeless people, LA Mayor Karen Bass said, “I doubt that he knows and many Angelenos know that the fastest growing sector of the unhoused population are senior citizen women in their late 60s and 70s… So I would be reluctant to call an 80-year-old woman a zombie.” Homelessness leads to addiction, she argued. “I don’t think her drug abuse led to her being on the street. I think it was economic factors,” Bass said. “Sleep on the street for a couple weeks, and tell me that your mental health is the same as it was before you were unhoused.”
But the reality on the ground is that homeless encampments are open-air drug scenes, and their inhabitants are usually not there because of an “income shock.” In July 2024, my colleague Michael Shellenberger and I visited LA’s Skid Row, which spans about 50 city blocks and has one of the most densely concentrated homeless populations in the country. There, we shadowed street doctors administering injectable anti-psychotic medications, as well as pharmaceutical-grade opioids, to homeless people.
In one case, we saw a woman and a man with a severe infection on his leg get into a violent altercation on the street. In another case, a doctor approached a woman with a large, untreated abscess on her neck to offer her medication. The woman was in too deep a psychosis to accept help. Case workers told us to walk quickly through one block because, they said, drug dealers controlled it.
The levels of drug use and psychosis we saw on Skid Row are not the results of simply losing housing and “sleeping on the street for a couple weeks.” And the evidence shows that unsheltered homelessness is the effect of addiction and mental illness rather than the cause. A University of California, San Francisco (UCSF) survey found that 82% of homeless people in California reported experiencing a serious mental health issue, 65% reported regularly using illicit drugs, and 62% reported heavy drinking. These issues often “predated their first episode of homelessness,” the survey authors noted. The California Policy Lab found in 2025 that half of unsheltered homeless people admitted substance abuse or mental health problems contributed to them becoming homeless.
x.com/shellenberger/status/2061500463384777215
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism and to read the rest of this excellent piece by @galexybrane !This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Spencer Pratt
@spencerpratt
BUSTED on camera: Karen Bass and Nithya Raman spend millions of your tax dollars on these NGOs to hand out fentanyl needles, crack pipes, and DRUGS to addicts on your streets, to keep them high and homeless so they can profit off everyone's misery. VOTE NOW!!!
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Jesse Michels
@AlchemyAmerican
Just interviewed former Brazilian Defense Minister and current Presidential candidate Aldo Rebelo. He’s had access to the highest levels of classified state secrets. And he told me Colares and Varginha (UFO crash involving non-human beings) happened. The U.S. better catch up…
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
bettersoma
@bettersoma
Disgusting stuff here. Reflect @Scott_Wiener I don’t blame Nancy nope.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Doug Ellin
@mrdougellin
I’m a liberal ( a real one) who did not vote forTrump. Do not call me maga, you socialist, cop hating lunatic. Start calling out the criminals. Forget about people having bbqs and get the needles out of addicts hands. And don’t fucking laugh at parents who want dangerous encampents away from their schools while crying when they come near your house. Let’s go @spencerpratt
Nithya Raman
@nithyavraman
Tuesday is where our book begins, Los Angeles.
Let’s write a new chapter together.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ken Broad
@Metis65
Join me in welcoming @GadSaad to @cwclub in SF in exactly two weeks, on Wed June 10th at 5:30 PDT!
Gad is an evolutionary behavioral scientist and offers a unique perspective on societal ills stemming from inherited traits that have proven maladaptive in modern society. His new @HarperCollins book is “Suicidal Empathy - Dying to Be Kind,” which is a much-anticipated follow-up to 2021’s “The Parasitic Mind - How Infectuous Ideas are Killing Common Sense.”
Gad will be in conversation with fellow honey badger, investigative journalist and author Michael @shellenberger
More details and registration links, both in-person and remote, via link below 👇
www.commonwealthclub.org/events/2026-06-10/gad-saad-suici… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Ukraine is winning & the US must support it until it takes back the land Russia took, says James Verini, author of a new book. But it's a grinding war of attrition that shifted modestly in Russia’s favor last year. And a growing share of Ukrainians want to trade land for peace.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
New Yorker writer James Verini argues that Ukraine is close to winning its war with Russia, that the United States should keep helping until Kyiv recovers every occupied inch of land, and that Joe Biden did more for Ukraine than Donald Trump has. Verini is the author of a new book, The Theater: Courage and Survival in the Defining Atrocity of the Ukraine War. “Anyone following this war closely will tell you it’s extremely possible that Ukraine will take this land back without any treaty or without any intervention from Trump,” he said in a podcast interview with Public. He estimates Russia has now taken roughly one million casualties, with as many as half a million dead, a toll he calls unsustainable and likely to break the regime. “I’m convinced it’s going to translate into a popular uprising,” said Verini, “if not against Putin, then at least against this war.”
On American policy, he argues that the United States must keep arming, funding, and sharing intelligence with Ukraine until Kyiv recovers the territories Russia has seized since 2022. “The Ukrainians will never submit to a truce or a peace agreement that allows Russia to keep any of the territories it’s occupied since 2022,” he said. Verini describes Russia’s invasion as a colonial war of annihilation and frames continued American support as both a moral duty and a winning bet. “If you want to bet on a winner,” he said, “you’d be betting on Ukraine right now, not on Russia.”
But much of the foreign policy establishment has reached a different conclusion than Verini’s. Most Western military analysts describe the war as a grinding war of attrition that shifted modestly in Russia’s favor in 2025. Russia controls about one-fifth of Ukraine, including Crimea and other territory occupied before 2022. Depending on the dataset, Russian forces captured roughly 4,800 to 5,600 square kilometers in 2025, the largest annual gain since 2022. Ukraine has not achieved a large-scale reconquest of occupied Ukrainian territory comparable to the Kharkiv and Kherson counteroffensives, though it has conducted later offensive operations, including the 2024 Kursk incursion and localized counteroffensives in 2025.
Verini is right that Russia has paid an enormous price for its slow advance. Russia lost roughly 1.2 million troops killed, wounded, or missing between February 2022 and December 2025, including up to 325,000 dead. Verified Russian deaths reached at least 152,142 by November 2025, based on obituary tallies by independent Russian media. UK officials estimated roughly 420,000 Russian casualties in 2025, including up to 200,000 killed. Russia lost more than 1,000 armored vehicles and 500 tanks just in the fight for Pokrovsk since October 2023. Ukrainian long-range drones have repeatedly hit Russian refineries, fuel depots, and ammunition plants. The number of dead, Verini argues, is becoming politically intolerable across Russian villages and Central Asian recruit pools.
But Verini’s picture remains optimistic. Ukraine lost between 500,000 and 600,000 of its own troops, including up to 140,000 dead. The Russian field force, drawn from a population three times the size of Ukraine’s, can absorb losses Ukraine cannot. Both armies fight a drone war now, and Russian Shahed and Lancet attacks have devastated Ukrainian power infrastructure and front-line units throughout 2025. Russian forces entered Pokrovsk in October 2025 after massing 156,000 troops around the city. Ukraine’s top military commander ordered Ukrainian units to withdraw from hard-to-defend positions in early December. Mainstream Russia analysts have not endorsed Verini’s prediction of an imminent uprising against Putin. Russian opinion polls show 66% of Russians supporting peace negotiations rather than regime change.
Ukrainians themselves have shifted toward accepting some territorial loss as part of a peace deal. The Kyiv International Institute of Sociology has tracked attitudes on territorial concessions since 2022. In the first months of full-scale war, 82% of Ukrainians rejected any land-for-peace deal. By late 2025, that share had fallen to 54%, with 38% willing to accept some losses for a faster end to the war. In a late-December 2025 poll, the share of Ukrainians who categorically rejected formally recognizing occupied territories as Russian fell by nine percentage points from October. A separate tally found that 72% of Ukrainians could approve a deal that froze the current front line, included security guarantees, and avoided legal recognition of occupied land as Russian. Ukrainian battlefield casualties, blackouts, and a falling birthrate are eroding the maximalist position Zelensky has held since 2022. The longer the war runs, the more Ukrainians edge toward a freeze....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2059719281601081834
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full podcast!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Already by the 1970s, top energy analysts knew abundant natural gas would displace coal, resulting in lower emissions. And so Malthusian scientists, in order to create their outlandishly apocalyptic scenarios, demonized them as climate deniers and drove them out of the IPCC.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Climate policy prevented the IPCC’s high emissions scenario, say the media. It didn’t. The scenario was never possible as it predicted burning 5x more coal than is known to exist, even as natural gas was replacing it. The IPCC must be radically reformed or shut down.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“And then the expected happened,” Ausubel said about the IPCC. “Opportunists flowed in. By 1992, I
stopped wanting to go to climate meetings."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Climate policy prevented the IPCC’s high emissions scenario, say the media. It didn’t. The scenario was never possible as it predicted burning 5x more coal than is known to exist, even as natural gas was replacing it. The IPCC must be radically reformed or shut down.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Governments, banks, and corporations across the developed world have for nearly four decades treated the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) as the final word on the science of climate change.
The Obama and Biden administrations regulated carbon dioxide as a pollutant on the strength of IPCC findings. The European Union built its emissions trading system around IPCC scenarios. The United Kingdom anchored its 2008 Climate Change Act in projections drawn from the panel’s reports.
Central banks established a Network for Greening the Financial System that now requires more than 140 supervisors to stress-test banks against IPCC-derived futures. Asset managers wrote trillions of dollars in environmental, social, and governance funds on the assumption that the panel’s high-end scenario described the world’s likely path.
Local governments along American and European coastlines planned seawalls and zoning rules around IPCC sea level numbers. Insurance companies repriced risk on the same models.
That assumption has now collapsed. In April 2026, the scenario committee that supplies the IPCC’s Seventh Assessment Report, known as ScenarioMIP, published a paper that concluded that “on the high-end of the range, the CMIP6 high emission levels (quantified by SSP5-8.5) have become implausible…”
In other words, the worst-case future that has anchored climate science for fifteen years describes a world that cannot exist. Scenario “RCP 8.5,” and its successor SSP5-8.5, generated more than half of the references in the 2018 U.S. Fourth National Climate Assessment. They accounted for nearly 60% of the references in the IPCC’s Special Report on the Ocean and Cryosphere. Thirty new studies per day are published based on RCP 8.5.
The IPCC’s defenders insist that the world dodged the apocalypse because of climate policy. A modeler told Carbon Brief that RCP 8.5 had “become implausible, based on trends in the costs of renewables, the emergence of climate policy and recent emission trends.”
Berkeley Earth’s Zeke Hausfather argued that “it is incontrovertible that rapid cost declines, investment in, and deployment of clean energy technologies in the past 15 years have changed the plausible scenarios for fossil fuel use later in this century.
These new scenarios reflect this success.” Robert Vautard, co-chair of the IPCC’s Working Group I for the upcoming Seventh Assessment Report, said that the previous high scenarios “started in 2015 and assumed no climate policies, but there ARE now many climate policies in many countries, developed in particular with the Paris Agreement,” and the retirement of RCP 8.5 “shows that climate mitigation policies do consistently reduce global warming.”
Michael Mann of the University of Pennsylvania said on X, “The good news is emissions are now tracking below older ‘business-as-usual’ pathways because of climate policy in spite of Trump.”
But that story is false. RCP 8.5 was never plausible, and the people who built it either knew or should have known. A 2017 paper by Justin Ritchie and Hadi Dowlatabadi in the journal Energy showed that the scenario assumed roughly an eightfold expansion of global coal consumption by 2100, far exceeding five times proven coal reserves, based on extrapolating early-2000s Chinese coal growth rates indefinitely into the future.
Coal’s share of the global energy mix peaked around 2013 and has fallen since, the opposite of the RCP 8.5 trajectory. The scenario also assumed a dramatic expansion of coal-to-liquids technology to replace petroleum, a technology that the United States and other industrialized economies abandoned in the 1980s when the collapse in oil prices killed off the Carter-era Synthetic Fuels Corporation.
None of those assumptions reflected what serious energy analysts were saying in 2011, when the scenario was finalized. The American shale gas revolution had already been underway for half a decade. Between 2005 and 2022, U.S. carbon emissions from electricity generation fell by roughly 35%, with more than 60% of that decline driven by switching from coal to natural gas.
In 2021, Roger Pielke Jr. and his coauthors found that observed emissions had been running below the RCP and SSP baseline scenarios for two decades, primarily because of slower-than-projected carbon intensity growth, not climate policy. As Pielke put it recently, “RCP8.5 is not simply ‘highly unlikely,’ it is falsified, meaning that its emissions trajectory is already well out of step with reality. We knew that in 2020.”
IPCC’s scenario builders thus broke their own definition of a scenario, which the IPCC’s 2000 Special Report on Emissions Scenarios defined as is “a coherent, internally consistent, and plausible description of a possible future state of the world,” and RCP 8.5 was none of those things....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2059341279218245679
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Odysseus isn't really a hero, a progressive 2017 translation implies. But he is, and the moral of his story is in part about the importance of property rights, which are foundational to Western civilization. Little wonder, then, that the academic Left wages war on "The Odyssey."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Controversy has erupted over Christopher Nolan’s forthcoming film adaptation of Homer’s poem The Odyssey, which arrives in the wake of a contested 2017 translation by Emily Wilson, a classics professor at the University of Pennsylvania. Critics of Wilson’s translation argue that she has rewritten Odysseus from a hero into a morally suspect figure. Nolan cast a black actress, Lupita Nyong’o, to play the Mediterranean woman Helen of Troy, prompting criticisms of hypocrisy and racism from Elon Musk and others. It is inconceivable that Hollywood would today use a white actor to play a black character, and yet the media applauds when white characters are played by black actors.
Isabella Reinhardt, an assistant professor of classics at the University of Austin, and my colleague, disagrees with some of Wilson’s choices. For example, Wilson translates polytropos, which Homer uses to describe Odysseus, as a “complicated man,” where Robert Fagles, in his 1996 translation, renders it as a “man of twists and turns.” The choice is representative of Wilson’s depiction of Odysseus as something other than heroic. Reinhardt, who recorded a podcast with me last week, received her PhD in the same Penn classics department where Wilson teaches. “I do think Odysseus is not a perfect hero,” says Reinhardt, “but he is the hero. Her translation strays into a negative view of Odysseus that’s not entirely warranted....”
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the full article, and watch the full podcast!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Matthew Schmitz
@matthewschmitz
Great to talk to @shellenberger and @galexybrane.
Please subscribe to support their work.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For most of the eight decades following World War II, the political Left has defined the counterculture and, by extension, what counts as cool. Beatniks in the 1950s condemned suburban conformity. Hippies in the 1960s rejected the Vietnam War and the gray men running it. Punks in the late 1970s and early 1980s scoffed at Nixon’s “silent majority” and Reagan’s optimistic “morning in America.” Hip-hop in the 1980s and 1990s gave voice to black men angry at white America. Independent film, college rock, gay theater, and queer photography all flourished as protests against a presumed mainstream that was white, square, Christian, and Republican.
That is no longer the world we live in. “One of the most remarkable things we’ve seen in the last couple of years is this sense that Trumpism is at the cultural cutting edge, or the avant-garde,” says Matthew Schmitz, “and liberal America is racing to catch up.” Schmitz, the cofounder and editor of Compact magazine and religion editor at the Washington Post’s opinions page, recorded a podcast with us last week. Schmitz lives in Manhattan, a county that went for Kamala Harris by more than 80 percent, and grew up in rural Nebraska, where his county went for Trump by 86 percent. He calls himself a conservative but spends much of his working life among liberals....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2058948256227611093
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the full article, and watch the full podcast!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Since World War II, the Left has dominated the counterculture and what's considered cool. That's no longer the case, says @matthewschmitz of @compactmag. "Somehow Trumpism is the cultural cutting edge and liberal America is racing to catch up."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For most of the eight decades following World War II, the political Left has defined the counterculture and, by extension, what counts as cool. Beatniks in the 1950s condemned suburban conformity. Hippies in the 1960s rejected the Vietnam War and the gray men running it. Punks in the late 1970s and early 1980s scoffed at Nixon’s “silent majority” and Reagan’s optimistic “morning in America.” Hip-hop in the 1980s and 1990s gave voice to black men angry at white America. Independent film, college rock, gay theater, and queer photography all flourished as protests against a presumed mainstream that was white, square, Christian, and Republican.
That is no longer the world we live in. “One of the most remarkable things we’ve seen in the last couple of years is this sense that Trumpism is at the cultural cutting edge, or the avant-garde,” says Matthew Schmitz, “and liberal America is racing to catch up.” Schmitz, the cofounder and editor of Compact magazine and religion editor at the Washington Post’s opinions page, recorded a podcast with us last week. Schmitz lives in Manhattan, a county that went for Kamala Harris by more than 80 percent, and grew up in rural Nebraska, where his county went for Trump by 86 percent. He calls himself a conservative but spends much of his working life among liberals....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2058948256227611093
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the full article, and watch the full podcast!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Christopher Nolan's adaptation of “The Odyssey” relies on a celebrated feminist translation. But people are right to feel that, in it, "the idea of a hero is being degraded," says classicist Isabella Reinhardt. It is thus yet another assault on a foundation of Western culture.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Controversy has erupted over Christopher Nolan’s forthcoming film adaptation of Homer’s poem The Odyssey, which arrives in the wake of a contested 2017 translation by Emily Wilson, a classics professor at the University of Pennsylvania. Critics of Wilson’s translation argue that she has rewritten Odysseus from a hero into a morally suspect figure. Nolan cast a black actress, Lupita Nyong’o, to play the Mediterranean woman Helen of Troy, prompting criticisms of hypocrisy and racism from Elon Musk and others. It is inconceivable that Hollywood would today use a white actor to play a black character, and yet the media applauds when white characters are played by black actors.
Isabella Reinhardt, an assistant professor of classics at the University of Austin, and my colleague, disagrees with some of Wilson’s choices. For example, Wilson translates polytropos, which Homer uses to describe Odysseus, as a “complicated man,” where Robert Fagles, in his 1996 translation, renders it as a “man of twists and turns.” The choice is representative of Wilson’s depiction of Odysseus as something other than heroic. Reinhardt, who recorded a podcast with me last week, received her PhD in the same Penn classics department where Wilson teaches. “I do think Odysseus is not a perfect hero,” says Reinhardt, “but he is the hero. Her translation strays into a negative view of Odysseus that’s not entirely warranted....”
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the full article, and watch the full podcast!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
x.com/shellenberger/status/2058585069284139204
Here is the full article and podcast!This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Spencer Pratt
@spencerpratt
If that addict on your street were your own son, what would you do? That is the defining question that guides my 5 step plan to fix the homelessness problem in LA. We *must* end this evil racket of corrupt politicians and NGOs who profit off the misery of these poor souls. They launder money and feed them more drugs, so they can keep their customers locked in this hell on our streets. We have a moral obligation from God to help them and make our city safe and clean for everyone. Karen Bass and Nithya Raman have forsaken this city. Time for real leadership. Time for real compassion.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Cali Conservative
@T_Hates_Cali
I was addicted to meth and heroin for the first several years of my adult life. I am grateful every day that I was caught and arrested in a state like Montana that was tough on crime, and didn't just supply me with accoutrements and leave me on the street to die a slow death like they do here in California.
My charge was felony possession. I spent 90 days in jail detoxing because I couldn't afford to pay bail. Thank God for that. When I was let out I was forced to wear a drug patch and report for random supervised urine tests, or risk going back to jail. I was put on the strictest probation, and forced into an outpatient treatment program. I was able to go to the shelter, which required sobriety and an honest effort to better my life. The very real threat of going to prison to serve my full sentence if I screwed again motivated me to stay clean.
Because of tough love policies, I am alive today. What people are doing here in California, Oregon and Washington is NOT compassion, it's toxic empathy, and it's manslaughter. Decriminalization only serves to remove ANY hope of the addict ever getting sober. I couldn't get sober on my own, I tried for years, without being forced to detox in jail I'd probably be dead today. Part of me wonders if that's the point?
9 years sober as of January 31st. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Bad tactics and messaging lost Kamala Harris the 2024 election, says the DNC-commissioned autopsy report. But both are downstream of the Party's radical agenda, which rejects core pillars of Western civilization, including meritocracy, law & order, and cheap energy.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Democratic National Committee (DNC) today released its 192-page autopsy of the 2024 election. It blames the Biden White House for failing to defend Harris for over three and a half years. It says the White House never moved to “contradict or correct” the “border czar” label that defined Harris in voters’ minds.
The report calls Trump’s “Kamala is for they/them” ad effective and unanswerable, given that she never repudiated trans surgeries for prison inmates.
The autopsy reminds readers that in 1989, DNC Chairman Ron Brown reclaimed what it calls “the vital center of American discourse” after three straight presidential losses. It notes that Bill Clinton and Barack Obama then led the party to win the popular vote in seven of the next eight presidential elections. The report suggests Democrats need to recover that center.
But the autopsy does not explain what pulled the party away from it, nor where the party went, which was the topic of a recent conversation I had with The Free Press’Coleman Hughes (below). The answer the autopsy dared not say is that “progressive” (radical) Left turned it against the core structures of Western civilization and took over the Party.
Starting around 2010, meritocracy increasingly gave way to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) mandates, which the Biden White House imposed across the federal government in 2021. Law and order gave way to defund-the-police rhetoric and progressive prosecutors. Cheap energy gave way to a climate agenda that was on track to cost trillions in taxes and higher energy prices. National borders gave way to an unenforced southern frontier. And personal agency gave way to victimhood ideology, which casts citizens as products of oppressive systems rather than authors of their own lives....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2057565881702785059
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning reporting, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ioan Grillo
@ioangrillo
Sheinbaum government (under Trump pressure) has massively reduced flow of fentanyl north.
April seizures of fentanyl at US border are 463 pounds - ↓ 86% since peak April 2023, ↓ 60% for 12 month period. Government hit key fentanyl traffickers.
Read:↓
www.crashoutmedia.com/p/mexico-hammers-fentanyl-while-us -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Skeptical us
@russkey2k
4 years ago @shellenberger was exposing the grift. Glad it's finally getting wider exposure. Once again X leads the way.
Wall Street Apes
@WallStreetApes
EXPOSED 🚨 California Democrats are paying people to be homeless
Homeless man moved across country to California to be homeless
“How long you been in San Francisco?”
Homeless man “Since June. If you're gonna be homeless, it's pretty f*cking easy here. I mean, if we're gonna be realistic, they pay you to be homeless here”
“When you said that San Francisco pays people to be homeless, what did you mean by that? You mean that literally?”
Homeless man “$200 food stamps and $620 bucks cash a month — it's free money, dude. This right now is literally by choice. Literally by choice. Like, why would I want to pay rent? I'm not doing. I got a cell phone that I have Amazon Prime and Netflix on”
“How was that hard to get?”
Homeless man “F*cking phone call, bro. F*cking phone call.”
This is the scam,
- California Democrats pay these people to be homeless
- The homeless problem never goes gets solved
- They can then justify laundering billion and billions are year to their NGOs and get filthy rich
This is the Homeless Industrial ComplexThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Few have done more to raise the alarm about campus intolerance than Jonathan Haidt. That he was booed by students from his own university, who called for “the safest option,” epitomizes the deep rot created by decades of coddling and left-wing indoctrination.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Few public intellectuals have done more to warn Americans about how the coddling of children produces intolerant adults than Jonathan Haidt and Greg Lukianoff.
Their 2018 book, The Coddling of the American Mind, argued that helicopter parenting, the decline of unsupervised play, and the rise of campus safetyism had set up a generation for failure.
They warned that universities were teaching students three Great Untruths: that hardship makes you weaker, that you should always trust your feelings, and that life is a battle between good people and evil people.
Haidt, a social psychologist and professor at NYU's Stern School of Business, has spent more than a decade documenting the link between fragility and authoritarianism.
Lukianoff, the president of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, took over the group in 2006 and has spent two decades documenting censorship on American campuses. FIRE today operates with an annual budget above $32 million and a staff of 120, including roughly 20 lawyers.
For exactly that reason, it was dispiriting to watch students at Haidt’s own university enact the behavior he and Lukianoff have spent a decade trying to combat. Graduates booed Haidt as NYU President Linda Mills welcomed him to the stage at Yankee Stadium on May 14, 2026. About three dozen students walked out of the venue while he spoke.
The booing followed a May 5 open letter from the Executive Committee of the NYU Student Government Assembly, which called Haidt’s selection “deeply unsettling” and demanded that the administration reconsider its decision.
Most revealingly, the committee complained that “many students have reported feelings of disappointment, disgust, unenthusiasm, defeat, and embarrassment,” language that mirrors the therapeutic vocabulary Haidt and Lukianoff diagnosed as the central pathology in Coddling.
The students treated emotional discomfort with a speaker’s ideas as the equivalent of a physical threat. “Was he the safest option,” asked the students, without any apparent irony, “considering the current political climate and his critiques of liberal ideology?”....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2057144501848907817
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the full article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
🎯 @continetti
www.wsj.com/opinion/woke-isnt-dead-or-even-resting-77a6448f -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“I’m not MAGA or anything but the city’s kinda gone to shit, right?”
Another banger from @dsonoiki for @spencerprattThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Governments should censor AI "deep fake" videos, many say, because they threaten democracy. But there is no evidence they ever have. The reason legacy gatekeepers are panicking is that AI disrupts their business model and fuels underdogs like LA mayoral candidate @spencerpratt.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
AI-generated “deepfake” photos and videos, like the ones being put out by supporters of Los Angeles Mayoral candidate @spencerpratt, are a threat to democracy, say many. “These Pratt social videos are catchy but… they are also 100% deep fakes,” said political consultant @murphymike. “In fact, Pratt for Mayor is the most AI deep fake-driven campaign I’ve ever seen…. There is no disclaimer on them. They’re not officially from his campaign… not sure who’s paying for this stuff.”
The Wall Street Journal warned last week against AI deep fakes of two JPMorgan executives, one of whom had accused the other of sexual harassment. “One clip shows the female executive dancing suggestively in an office while male co-workers shower her with dollar bills,” it noted. “A particularly alarming example depicts the two parties through the window of a cafe, smiling together over a glass of wine.”
Deepfakes, argued the Brookings Institution in 2023, “threaten to undermine” the “trusted information environment” democracies depend on. “Government needs to step up to protect elections from AI-generated deepfake video and audio,” demanded the progressive Brennan Center in 2024. Stanford researchers warned that political deepfakes remain easy to generate and difficult to detect.
Governments are acting. State legislatures have targeted election speech, satire, and political ads that use altered images or voices.
But the facts do not support deepfake alarmism, which activists, journalists, and policymakers are using to impose censorship.
The Spencer Pratt advertisements are obviously fake, as are the deepfakes of the two JPMorgan executives. As of today, a total of six people had shared, and 7,743 people had watched, the JP Morgan video that The Wall Street Journal warned about.
And a 2025 Cambridge paper on deepfakes and democracy concluded that, despite years of warnings, “there is no evidence” that deepfakes have produced the predicted election interference.
The idea that Pratt’s viral AI-made ads undermine democracy is absurd. Filmmaker @charliebcurran produced a 99-second Batman-themed AI-made ad on May 5, 2026.
The ad depicts Mayor Karen Bass in Joker makeup, Governor Gavin Newsom dressed as a male Marie Antoinette eating cake, former Vice President Kamala Harris chugging vodka while declaring “Bass already solved crime, I endorse her,” and Councilmember Nithya Raman as a puppet saying “let’s move the drug addicts closer.”
As such, the Pratt ads make the fraud theory of political deepfakes even harder to sustain. A nonpartisan researcher told CBS Sacramento that “as far as we know, Spencer Pratt is not Batman.” Noted one strategist, “the Spencer Pratt spot is exactly what AI should be, which is using innovation and technology to make an interesting ad that is not trying to fool voters.”
So why all the deep fake alarmism?...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2056761392922083332
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For the last decade, the media said right-wing nationalists were fascists. They weren't. And now they're winning. The reason is that @elonmusk made X a free speech platform, thereby exposing globalists as totalitarian control-freaks on everything from migration to Covid to trans.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Over the last decade, Western media, academics, and policymakers have understandably viewed right-wing nationalist victories as temporary aberrations soon to be corrected. After Britons voted to leave the European Union in June 2016 and Americans elected Donald Trump that November, prominent commentators predicted a swift return to deepening globalization. And indeed, Europe extended its globalist project.
The United Kingdom’s globalist Conservative governments allowed net migration to rise to a record 906,000 in the year ending June 2023, more than four times pre-Brexit levels. Those same Conservatives passed a “net zero” emissions by 2050 into law in 2019, accelerated subsidies for offshore wind, and failed to tap North Sea oil and gas, even as energy bills climbed. And conservative ministers adopted World Health Organization guidance for Covid lockdowns, masking, and vaccination, and they expanded gender self-identification guidance in English schools.
German and French establishment parties enforced a cordon sanitaire or firewall against the “far-right” Alternative for Germany (AfD) and the Rassemblement National (RN) parties, denying them coalition partners and most mainstream coverage, and American voters in 2020 elected Joe Biden, who reversed Trump’s border policies and rejoined the Paris climate accord on his first day in office. Biden restored Obama-era diversity, equity, and inclusion frameworks across the federal bureaucracy and revived federal pressure on social media companies to remove disfavored speech.
But then, the reelection of Donald Trump in November 2024 dashed those hopes. Trump returned to power on promises to seal the southern border, deport illegal immigrants, end the electric vehicle mandate, withdraw from the Paris accord, and dismantle federal censorship of social media.
Within hours of taking office, he signed an executive order banning federal involvement in online censorship and stripped the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency of its role in policing so-called misinformation.
Vice President JD Vance told a stunned Munich Security Conference audience in February 2025 that “the threat I worry the most about vis-à-vis Europe is not Russia, it’s not China, it’s not any other external actor. What I worry about is the threat from within.” In February 2025, Trump called the European Union an “atrocity” and announced new tariffs.
Democrats may yet retake the White House in 2028 and one or both chambers of Congress in this fall’s midterms. The Trump administration’s war with Iran, which began on February 28, 2026, has triggered the largest oil supply shock on record, rising gasoline prices, and a potential recession. Trump’s net approval rating sits at minus 23 points with 60% disapproving and 37% approving. California Governor Gavin Newsom unveiled a balanced $350 billion budget last week and called Trump and Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent “dumb and dumber” as he positioned himself for a 2028 run. And both Newsom and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez spoke at the Munich Security Conference in February, implicitly responding to Vance, with Newsom telling the audience, “Donald Trump is temporary. He’ll be gone in three years.”
And the globalists are fighting back in Europe. European Commission officials in Brussels are tightening their censorial grip on the digital public square through the Digital Services Act and a “Democracy Shield” program to demand censorship of the Right ahead of upcoming elections. In Britain, Labor leadership challengers Andy Burnham and Wes Streeting have openly called for the United Kingdom to rejoin the European Union. Streeting formally launched his leadership bid in May 2026 by calling Brexit “a catastrophic mistake” and saying “Britain’s future lies with Europe, and one day back in the European Union.” And France’s Marine Le Pen lost her right to run for the 2027 presidency on March 31, 2025, when a Paris court convicted her of embezzling EU funds and immediately barred her from public office for five years.
But right-wing nationalists are not far from taking power in major European capitals.
In Britain, the right-wing Reform UK party gained more than 1,400 seats in the May 7, 2026, local elections, while Labor lost more than 1,300 seats and the Conservatives lost over 500. Ninety-seven Labor MPs last week called on Prime Minister Keir Starmer to resign. Seventy percent of British respondents told YouGov in May 2026 that Starmer was performing “poorly.”
In France, Jordan Bardella of the RN leads in the polls for the 2027 presidential election with 35 - 37.5% support, with Marine Le Pen close behind at 34% before her ban. President Emmanuel Macron’s approval rating fell to 11% in late 2025, the lowest the Verian polling firm had ever recorded.
And in Germany, the AfD leads national polling at 29% against the center-right CDU/CSU’s 22%, the Greens’ 14%, and the SPD’s 12% as of mid-May 2026. Berlin polls now put the AfD in second place behind the CDU, a position once considered politically impossible in the capital.
And mainstream conservative parties are already moving to the right on migration and climate. German Chancellor and CDU leader Friedrich Merz passed a non-binding migration motion in January with AfD support, breaking a seventy-five-year taboo against cooperating with the “far right.” Merz adopted much of the AfD’s migration language during his campaign, promising to turn migrants away at the border and to accelerate deportations. The cordon sanitaire that excluded the right has cracked, and the political center of gravity in Germany, and in much of Europe, has shifted toward the very positions that establishment leaders spent a decade demonizing.
The implications for Europe, NATO, and the broader Western order are massive. NATO’s basic premise rests on a shared American and European commitment to defending an open liberal order, but Vance told European leaders in Munich that US support would depend on whether they honored free speech and democratic legitimacy, which they have not done. Tariffs and trade disputes between Washington and Brussels have replaced the steady tariff reductions that defined the postwar order.
And the institutions that defined the transatlantic system since 1945, including NATO, the World Trade Organization, the World Health Organization, the United Nations climate accords, the World Economic Forum, and the European Union itself, are weaker than ever. Meanwhile, historic US support for maintaining open shipping lanes and Taiwan appears to be weakening.
For nearly a decade, the legacy media and progressive activists demonized Trump, Farage, Bardella, and Weidel as fascists or Nazis bent on destroying democracy. President Biden in 2022, speaking against a blood-red backdrop at Philadelphia’s Independence Hall, declared that “Donald Trump and the MAGA Republicans represent an extremism that threatens the very foundations of our Republic.” Yet today those same figures are governing or on the verge of governing major Western nations and cities.
The question is why. Why did nationalism return? Why did the globalist consensus that ruled the West from 1945 to 2024 collapse so quickly? And why are right-wing nationalists winning despite sustained attacks from the establishment?
x.com/shellenberger/status/2056397401959870532
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of free speech, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“You are not alone.” Yoga moms, silent majority, and a preference cascade all in one. Whether or not Angelenos elect @spencerpratt as LA mayor, he and his team are revolutionizing politics.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The ad was made by @dsonoiki
Gene Parmesan
@dsonoiki
You Are Not Alone. Vote Spencer Pratt.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
He also worked on these:
x.com/charliebcurran/status/2052772484202844319
Charles Curran
@charliebcurran
shout out @dsonoiki for the assist 🤍
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
California is the most corrupt state in America
Ashley Zavala
@ZavalaA
Dana Williamson's attorney told reporters she's not helping in any investigation into Gavin Newsom or Xavier Becerra as part of today's plea deal.
I asked him how so many of her charges were dropped.
He said negotiations were extremely respectful, with a lot of back and forth:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
These people
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Lee
@SenMikeLee
The @CIA needs to watch how it speaks to Congress.
One way the @CIADirector should speak to Congress is in public hearings, where he can answer our questions about the serious allegations made against the agency.
Liz Lyons
@CIASpox
The Committee acted in bad faith by subpoenaing an Agency officer for testimony today without notifying CIA, despite having already obtained closed-door testimony from the individual previously. The witness testifying today is not appearing as a whistleblower in pursuit of the truth, but instead in response to the subpoena issued by Chairman Paul.
This proceeding amounts to nothing more than dishonest political theater masquerading as a congressional hearing. As the CIA has already assessed, COVID-19 most likely originated from a lab leak, and efforts to undermine that conclusion are disingenuous. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ashley Zavala
@ZavalaA
Dana Williamson’s attorney McGregor Scott says at sentencing they will argue she was trying to help a friend.
Williamson has pleaded guilty in case where she helped Xavier Becerra’s longtime chief of staff steal funds from his campaign account.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Dakota Smith
@dakotacdsmith
Former Becerra staffers told me Becerra and McCluskie were such a close team that they have a hard time imagining Becerra working in government without his longtime staffer. www.latimes.com/california/story/2026-05-13/becerras-advi…
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Rob Pyers
@rpyers
The narrative that Becerra was a criminal mastermind takes a hit and it now appears that he's just a guy who has trouble keeping track of things, whether that be $225,000 in campaign funds or 85,000 unaccompanied migrant children.
Melanie Mason
@melmason
For all the insinuations by rivals about Becerra being a co-conspirator, the plea deal indicates that he was in the dark as his chief of staff and political aide conspired to siphon money from his campaign account
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Now do your role enabling child trafficking
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After @XavierBecerra weakened protections against traffickers, a 16-year-old migrant child fell to his death, a 15-year-old fell & lost his ability to speak, & a 13-year-old saw his arm torn open in a chicken plant. Becerra denies responsibility & attacks those who ask about it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@XavierBecerra lied when he said he didn't lose track of 85K migrant children. In fact, he forced out of HHS the employees who rightly warned against lowering standards on vetting sponsors, resulting in many of those children being trafficked.
-
Xavier Becerra
@XavierBecerra
My opponents have spent millions spreading lies to purposefully mislead voters.
Today confirms what I have said from day one: I did nothing wrong. Case closed.
Now let’s continue the fight for the working people of California who deserve a Governor that leads with the truth.
Melanie Mason
@melmason
For all the insinuations by rivals about Becerra being a co-conspirator, the plea deal indicates that he was in the dark as his chief of staff and political aide conspired to siphon money from his campaign account
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Now do your role enabling child trafficking
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After @XavierBecerra weakened protections against traffickers, a 16-year-old migrant child fell to his death, a 15-year-old fell & lost his ability to speak, & a 13-year-old saw his arm torn open in a chicken plant. Becerra denies responsibility & attacks those who ask about it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@XavierBecerra lied when he said he didn't lose track of 85K migrant children. In fact, he forced out of HHS the employees who rightly warned against lowering standards on vetting sponsors, resulting in many of those children being trafficked.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After @XavierBecerra weakened protections against traffickers, a 16-year-old migrant child fell to his death, a 15-year-old fell & lost his ability to speak, & a 13-year-old saw his arm torn open in a chicken plant. Becerra denies responsibility & attacks those who ask about it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@XavierBecerra lied when he said he didn't lose track of 85K migrant children. In fact, he forced out of HHS the employees who rightly warned against lowering standards on vetting sponsors, resulting in many of those children being trafficked.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"Within H.H.S., many staff members were angry with Mr. Becerra. Again and again, they sent up reports, including some that reached his level, warning that children appeared to be at risk.
"This week, the same H.H.S. employees told me they were frustrated that the California race seemed fixated on claims about 85,000 'missing' children. What troubled them more, they said, was that the government rushed to release 250,000 children and then did so little to find out what became of them."
In other words, what @XavierBecerra did was far worse than simply losing track of 85,000 children.
Hannah Dreier
@hannahdreier
A story of mine from 2023 has suddenly become a major issue in the California governor's race.
With the final debate tonight, I tried to set the record straight on the frontrunner's role in the migrant child labor crisis—and whether he "lost" 85,000 kids. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/14/us/politics/xavier-becerra-mig…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"Often, H.H.S. called only once and never tried again."
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A CIA officer testified to the Senate today that the CIA illegally monitored his team's investigation into Covid, Havana syndrome, and UAPs, and is hiding intel about Covid's origin, MKUltra mind control experiments, & JFK assasination. Shocking allegations of ongoing cover-ups.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
United States government officials have for decades reassured the public that they are releasing all they have, save for the most sensitive information, on the origin of Covid, the CIA mind control program known as MKUltra, the JFK assassination, and the Church Committee investigation into the intelligence community (IC) abuses in 1975. In 2023, then-Director of National Intelligence (DNI) Avril Haines delivered a five-page summary of Covid origins in response to a unanimously passed law requiring the declassification of files. MKUltra involved drugging individuals without their knowledge in an effort to control their thoughts and behaviors. The CIA stated in 2022 that it had released 95% of its JFK collection, and the Trump administration released roughly 80,000 pages of JFK records on March 18, 2025.
But an active-duty CIA official testified to the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee today that the CIA and the Intelligence Community (IC) are still hiding information. James Erdman III, a senior CIA operations officer who led the Director’s Initiatives Group investigation into Covid origins under DNI Tulsi Gabbard, appeared under subpoena from committee Chairman Rand Paul. Erdman told senators that the CIA “did not comply with lawful oversight” during his investigation, and said, “CIA managers retaliated against [analysts] for their refusal to agree with management’s middle-of-the-night anonymous review.”
Erdman testifie,d “The CIA illegally monitored the computer and phone usage of DIG [Director’s Initiative Group] personnel, their investigations, and contact with whistleblowers…One CIA contractor assisting with the DIG’s investigation into the events that transpired between 2022 and 2023 was fired by the CIA one day after meeting with the DIG.” Erdman said the CIA had not cleared his testimony or written statement before the hearing.
The CIA denounced the hearing as “dishonest political theater,” and not a single Democratic Senator showed up for it. A CIA spokesperson, Liz Lyons, said in a statement that “the Committee acted in bad faith by subpoenaing an Agency officer for testimony today without notifying CIA.” She added that “the witness testifying today is not appearing as a whistleblower in pursuit of the truth, but instead in response to the subpoena issued by Chairman Paul.” And she implied the hearing was not needed since “the CIA has already assessed Covid-19 most likely originated from a lab leak, and efforts to undermine that conclusion are disingenuous.”
But the public CIA statement quoted at the hearing did not address Erdman’s specific claims about DIG monitoring, the contractor firing, or the 40 boxes of JFK and MKUltra files. Sen. Paul, who noted that “closed-door testimony doesn’t provide oversight” and “public testimony provides oversight.” The CIA made public in January 2025 a low-confidence assessment that COVID-19 likely had a research-related origin, while saying both lab and natural-origin scenarios remained plausible, which Paul called “a cleanup operation.” Nor did she address Erdman’s claim that, “When the DIG ceased operations, the CIA also took back 40 boxes of JFK files and MKUltra files being processed for declassification by DNI.”
Public reached out to the CIA for comment on Erdman’s specific allegations and will update this article if it replies.
Support for Erdman’s claims came from former CBS News investigative reporter Catherine Herridge. “As early as February,” she wrote on X, “I began receiving credible reporting that @DNIGabbard’s investigative team was being tracked and communications collected because their work was revealing ‘uncomfortable facts.’”
Paul opened the hearing by describing the Biological Sciences Experts Group (BESG), an ODNI advisory body that he said included Dr. Ralph Baric and Dr. Peter Daszak, both of whom collaborated with Wuhan Institute of Virology researchers on coronavirus gain-of-function studies. Daszak, Paul noted, received “hundreds of millions of dollars from the US government and worked with Dr. Zhengli Shi in Wuhan to create gain-of-function coronaviruses,” and that Baric “was also part of BSEG and an active consultant to intelligence agencies on the origins of the COVID-19 pandemic.”
Paul noted that “Dozens of times, [former NIAID Director Anthony Fauci] referred to the idea that the pandemic originating in the lab was a conspiracy theory.”
Erdman said that as of August 12, 2021, the CIA was considering calling Covid a lab leak, but that the conclusion “changed on August 17th of 2021.” Erdman told the panel that “the CIA would not provide us documentation that we asked for” and “we have no idea why that changed.” Erdman also testified that “Director Gabbard is working through, I believe, 2,000 pages” of Covid origins records the CIA had been resisting releasing. That figure contrasts with the five-page summary the ODNI delivered to Congress in 2023. Senator Josh Hawley asked Erdman whether the five-page report was “all the information the United States government had,” and Erdman replied, “that is not all the information.”
Erdman described a 2022 CIA “re-look” in which eight of 10 analysts and six of seven technical experts leaned toward a lab leak. He said management overruled the team and changed the analytic line to read that “we may never precisely know the origin of SARS-CoV-2.” Paul noted that there have been over 1,500 major lab leaks.
Sen. Paul revealed that the CIA is still denying him information that Senators are entitled to see under the Constitution, which requires Congressional oversight of the executive branch. Paul said the CIA had resisted releasing to him the underlying Covid origins analyses by its own scientists, even in classified form.
Paul also said, “I’ve been trying to get the classified version of the [1975] Church Committee [files] for over two years,” he said, “but I’m being blocked by the [Intelligence] Committee, including someone from our own party who is blocking me. They’ve shown me a room with 400 boxes. I can go look in all the boxes to see if I can find it. My staff’s not allowed to go in the room.”
The CIA told Senate investigators in 1977 that, after the Church inquiry, it had discovered seven additional boxes of MKUltra files in its retired records center that prior searches had missed. The 1977 hearing identified 149 MKUltra subprojects involving human testing and 33 additional subprojects whose subject matter remained undisclosed.
Reuters reported that in early April 2025, an ODNI team led by Defense Intelligence Agency official Paul Allen McDonald II arrived unannounced at a CIA archival facility in the Washington area to seize Kennedy assassination files. The team included Amaryllis Fox Kennedy, a former CIA officer and daughter-in-law of HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. The standoff stretched into the early morning hours and ended only after the CIA agreed to transfer a “massive trove” of documents to the National Archives for digitization.
Why did these cover-ups occur and why are some of them still ongoing? And why didn’t any Democratic senators participate in the hearing?...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2054703622555041934
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Calif Dem gubernatorial frontrunner @XavierBecerra says he's not responsible for losing 85k migrant children, many of whom were trafficked. But here he is on video demanding HHS staff hurry up (i.e., lower standards) in placing children with inadequately-vetted sponsors.
Kevin Dalton
@TheKevinDalton
KTLA just ended Xavier Becerra
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
👀
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@XavierBecerra lied when he said he didn't lose track of 85K migrant children. In fact, he forced out of HHS the employees who rightly warned against lowering standards on vetting sponsors, resulting in many of those children being trafficked.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"Again and again, veteran government staffers and outside contractors told the Health and Human Services Department, including in reports that reached Secretary Xavier Becerra, that children appeared to be at risk."
www.nytimes.com/2023/04/17/us/politics/migrant-child-labo…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@XavierBecerra blames others for his failures.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@XavierBecerra lied when he said he didn't lose track of 85K migrant children. In fact, he forced out of HHS the employees who rightly warned against lowering standards on vetting sponsors, resulting in many of those children being trafficked.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
California Democratic gubernatorial front-runner Xavier Becerra went viral yesterday for saying to a local Los Angeles television (KTLA) reporter, after she asked a hard question, “By the way, this is a profile piece, this is not a gotcha piece, right?” Reporter Annie Rose Ramos responded, appropriately, “These questions are fair. It’s in order to learn about you as a candidate.”
Progressives responded by criticizing Becerra’s messaging. A progressive Pod Save America co-host and former Obama spokesman, posted on X, “Politicians and candidates…let your staff have these whiny conversations! Or at least don’t do it on camera!” Former Obama strategist David Axelrod wrote that Becerra, as HHS Secretary during COVID, “rarely was the administration’s point person in communicating to the American people on the pandemic,” adding that the KTLA exchange “may be the reason why.”
But the underlying problem is not that Becerra is a poor communicator but rather that he is the person responsible for losing 85,000 migrant children under Biden’s open borders policy, which was what KTLA’s Ramos asked about. When Becerra was Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS), its Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) could not reach more than 85,000 unaccompanied children after releasing them to sponsors. Eleven ORR managers warned in a July 2021 memo that labor trafficking was rising and that the system “rewards individuals for making quick releases, and not one that rewards individuals for preventing unsafe releases.” The New York Times found 13-year-olds working in meat plants, 12-year-olds at Hyundai and Kia supplier factories, and children who should have been in middle school working at commercial bakeries.
Becerra defended himself to KTLA by claiming the New York Times had been misread. “That’s not what the New York Times article said,” he explained. “The New York Times said that individuals — the children and their sponsors — did not respond to calls. They didn’t say we couldn’t find kids.” And Becerra said the missing children weren’t HHS’s fault. “That part occurred after these children had left the care of the Department of Health and Human Services,” and that “some of these kids, probably because they needed to earn some money, started working in places that were very exploitive.”
But Becerra made it sound like there is a difference between losing track of the children and not getting them to call back, when they are simply two ways of saying the same thing. And Becerra’s claim that exploitation happened only after children left HHS custody omits that HHS itself had loosened the sponsor vetting designed to prevent exploitation. The agency under his leadership shortened required document checks and waived in-person home studies in many cases. And HHS waived background checks, including sex offender and child abuse registry checks, for sponsors and other adults in households where children were placed.
Digital fingerprinting to confirm sponsor identities dropped by 55 percent under Becerra, and at least 30,000 minors were placed with sponsors HHS knew were unrelated to them. A Florida statewide grand jury documented cases where one Austin, Texas household received more than 100 children, another Texas address received 44, and a third received 25.
At a staff meeting, Becerra said, in a video, “If Henry Ford had seen this in his plants, he would have never become famous and rich. This is not the way you do an assembly line.” That remark came weeks after the July 2021 memo from 11 ORR managers complaining that the office “rewards individuals for making quick releases.”
Becerra told ORR Director Cindy Huang during a March 2022 call that if she could not increase the number of discharges, “he would find someone who could,” according to five people who described the call to the Times. Huang resigned a month later. Becerra made a similar threat to her successor, according to several people present at the meeting.
At least five HHS staff members filed complaints, alleging they were pushed out after raising concerns about child safety. HHS staff in 2023 wrote in a memo to their bosses saying, “We are pulling humanity out of ‘Health and Human Services.’” A former senior HHS staffer who helped build the ORR program told the Times that she filed a whistleblower complaint after being demoted for raising child safety concerns. An Office of Inspector General report found that personnel actions “may have risen to the level of whistle-blower chilling.”
The scandal is striking because progressives claim to care deeply about migrants, and yet Becerra is the Democrats’ frontrunner for governor. California in 2017 enacted Senate Bill 54, the California Values Act, which limits state and local cooperation with federal immigration enforcement as part of its status as a “sanctuary state” for illegal migrants. Its political leaders, including Governor Gavin Newsom and Mayor Karen Bass, are leading the resistance to Trump’s migration policies. So what happened, and why might Becerra be California’s next governor?...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2054551036527100075
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning reporting, read the full article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pavel Durov
@durov
🥖 The French government is accusing X of the very things the French government itself is doing:
- Illegally collecting personal data
- Processing personal data without proper security
- Extracting data from automated systems
- Violating the secrecy of electronic communications -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Eric Adler
@ProfEricAdler
It’s amazing to me that universities are in a race to ditch the liberal arts, precisely when AI is challenging the value of vocational training for white-collar jobs.
Times Higher Education
@timeshighered
The University of Hertfordshire has announced it plans to close several of its humanities courses, in a move staff have warned will cause “reputational damage” to the institution #humanities #cuts #highered
www.timeshighereducation.com/news/hertfordshire-drops-his… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Maria Davidson
@MariaDavidson
SF spends $102k a year per homeless person.
It spends $20k a year per resident.
SF spends more per homeless person than the 10 largest US cities combined spend per resident.
Maria Davidson
@MariaDavidson
5 of the 10 cities that spend the most per homeless person are in California.
SF alone spends more per homeless person than NY and Portland combined. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
The line that appears in the new note alleged to be written by Jeffrey Epstein in jail -- whatchou want me to do, bust out cryin'? -- looks to be a reference to an inside joke between his brother Mark and him
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Berliner Zeitung
@berlinerzeitung
Droht das Ende der freien Debatte? Norbert Häring beschreibt im Interview ein Netzwerk aus EU, Militär und Faktencheckern, das die öffentliche Meinung beeinflussen soll. www.berliner-zeitung.de/article/der-wahrheitskomplex-wie-…
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In the name of compassion and bodily autonomy, Democrats let drug dealers kill mentally ill homeless people. Behind the rhetoric, the goal of progressives has always been the destruction of civilization, which they blame for inequality and suffering.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
At the heart of the case for progressivism is compassion. New York’s democratic socialist mayor, Zohran Mamdani, paused the police sweeps that had moved homeless people indoors in winter. Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass cut the fire department’s budget while expanding city services and proposing cash assistance for people in the country illegally. Governor Gavin Newsom vetoed legislation that would have allowed taxpayer dollars to support sober housing.
The result of those policies is death and destruction. In San Francisco, a mentally ill homeless woman lived on a sidewalk until her feet rotted from gangrene, after which the hospital amputated them and discharged her back to the same block. After Mayor Mamdani paused the sweeps, at least 19 mentally ill or drug addicted homeless people died outdoors in a single cold snap. In Los Angeles, the underfunded fire department failed to stop the fires in Malibu and other neighborhoods last year, and encampment fires continue to shut down freeways.
I told Michael Malice in a recent conversation that many progressives genuinely care about the people on the street. The point is not that their feelings are insincere. The point is that their feelings produce policies that kill the people the feelings are about.
Republicans are locked out of New York and have not won a statewide race in California since 2006. The 2026 California gubernatorial primary, however, is the first race in two decades where two Republicans could plausibly advance to the November runoff. And the Democratic field is so divided that the California Democratic Party has openly urged its weaker candidates to drop out, fearing exactly that scenario. PPIC reports that affordability and homelessness are the issues voters cite most often. Newsom’s approval rating on homelessness is the lowest of his tenure.
Why does a movement that calls itself compassionate let the feet of a mentally ill homeless woman rot? Could the voters of California finally reject progressivism?...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2052087725625684003
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A lot of conspiracy theories turned out to be true. But not everything is a conspiracy. It's wrong to ignore real conspiracies. It's also wrong to make false accusations. In a new talk, I explain what we know, suspect, and just don't yet know, about all the big ones.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
There really are conspiracies. Democrats weaponized the CIA and FBI to spy on and entrap Trump advisors to delegitimize the 2016 election by falsely accusing the president of being a secret agent for Russia. “Former” military and Intelligence Community (IC) officials created a censorship-by-NGO scheme, designed specifically to circumvent the First Amendment, that censored, and still censors, millions of people in the US and Europe for disfavored, legal speech. And senior FBI officials, retired IC leaders, and IC intermediaries ran a sophisticated information operation to persuade journalists, social media executives, and millions of voters that Russians had obtained and manipulated the contents of Hunter Biden’s laptop.
But not everything is a conspiracy. There is no evidence that NASA faked the moon landing, and abundant evidence that it happened. There is no evidence that the condensation trails (contrails) left by jets in the sky contain chemicals intentionally sprayed by the government to control the population or weather, and abundant evidence to the contrary. And there is no evidence that low levels of radiation from nuclear power plants, electromagnetic fields, or cell phone towers cause measurable harm.
It’s true that suspicious things have happened and are happening. The FBI didn’t let Joe Kent, the director of the Counterterrorism Center (CTC), investigate Charlie Kirk’s death, and Israel has influenced US foreign policy. Jeffrey Epstein hid cameras in Kleenex boxes, sent himself an email suggesting a scheme to blackmail Bill Gates, and worked for the arms dealer at the heart of the Iran-Contra scandal. President Trump confirmed that the US government knows more about Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAPs) than it has revealed, and high-level current and former IC officials say they exhibit characteristics that US technologies lack and may indicate non-human intelligence (NHI). The CIA experimented with mind control, its director visited Jack Ruby in prison shortly before he became psychotic, and high-level scientists and officials are dying and disappearing.
But those facts do not prove many of the theories currently circulating. The FBI was right to deny Kent and the CTC new powers to go on a fishing expedition, since doing so would be precisely the abuse of IC power the US Constitution protects us against. Trump has wanted to attack Iran for decades and is solely responsible for the US military action. The email Epstein sent himself was in the voice of a Gates advisor trying to get more compensation, and there is no good evidence of a domestic or foreign intelligence agency working with him to run a sex blackmail operation. There is still no hard proof of NHI or recovered craft. And there is no good evidence of any connection between, or pattern of, high-level scientists dying.
And many of those theories undermine the search for truth. Kent’s claim that Israel may have been involved in Kirk’s murder could support the defense of Kirk’s shooter, Tyler Robinson, against whom the evidence is overwhelming. Falsely claiming that Israel controls Trump undermines public trust in democracy, just as did the false conspiracy theory that Russia controlled him. Smearing and scapegoating everyone who associated with Epstein as complicit in his crimes has undermined our justice system and legitimized mob rule. False claims about UAP have been used for decades to maintain government secrecy. And irresponsible claims about the government murdering its scientists worsen delusions about mind control, directed energy weapons, and gangstalking.
And so the question now is: how do we distinguish between real conspiracies and unproven theories? What can we learn from proven conspiracies and disproven ones? And how should we think about conspiracies and conspiracy theories moving forward?
The Liberty Forum of Silicon Valley recently invited me to give a talk on the subject, and I addressed Russiagate, censorship, Hunter Biden’s laptop, Epstein, the JFK assassination, MK-Ultra, and UAPs. An edited version of that talk follows.
x.com/shellenberger/status/2051746365332410369
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the full article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The motivation of Trump's would-be assassin is a mystery, say the media. But it's not. He had "savior's complex," which is far more common on the Left than the Right. I should know, since my own savior's complex led me to become a radical left-wing activist in my youth.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Cole Allen, the man who sought to murder high-ranking Trump administration officials, as well as the president, at the White House Correspondents Association Dinner late last month, is an enigma, according to many in the media. A former student of Allen called him a “kind of a normal guy.” Allen was of above-average intelligence, graduated from Caltech with an engineering degree, obtained a master’s in computer science, and received teaching credentials. In December 2024, Allen’s employer named him “Teacher of the Month.” Understandably, then, investigators told reporters they had not yet pieced together a motive.
But it’s clear Allen had a savior complex. He felt a moral duty to sacrifice his life to save people he considered victims. “I’m not the person raped in a detention camp,” he wrote. “I’m not the fisherman executed without trial. I’m not a schoolkid blown up, or a child starved, or a teenage girl abused by the many criminals in this administration…. I am no longer willing to permit a pedophile, rapist, and traitor to coat my hands with his crimes.”
Allen not only sought to play the rescuer, he also sought recognition for his sacrifice. “Oh, and if anyone is curious is [sic] how doing something like feels,” he wrote in his manifesto, “it’s awful. I want to throw up; I want to cry for all the things I wanted to do and never will, for all the people whose trust this betrays; I experience rage thinking about everything this administration has done.”
There is still much we do not know, including about Allen’s mental health. Jim Clemente, a former FBI profiler who worked the Unabomber and DC sniper cases, said that Allen “doesn’t sound like a psychopath.”
But new facts are likely to radically alter the conclusion that he had a savior complex. Clemente noted that Allen wanted to “be some kind of hero, and that would make him feel better about himself, and it would be worth it to lose his life doing this.” And individuals with a savior complex may also suffer from intersecting issues like grandiose delusions, cluster B personality disorders, or depression.
At the heart of progressive politics is rescuing victims. Consider Alex Pretti and Renee Good, who law enforcement shot after they interfered with police operations in Minneapolis. Good used her car to disrupt an ICE operation. Pretti was killed by federal agents after he placed himself between an agent and a woman the agent had pushed to the ground. Both appear to have been gripped by the savior complex.
All of this matters because Allen’s case comes at a time of rising left-wing violence in the name of protecting vulnerable people. Tyler Robinson, a 22-year-old Utah man, killed Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University in September 2025, saying, “There is too much evil and the guy spreads too much hate.” Nicholas Roske, the California man sentenced to ninety-seven months for arriving outside Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s home with a Glock and a tactical knife in June 2022, told the FBI he wanted to kill three conservative justices to swing the Court for “decades to come.”
The savior complex appears on the right as well. People who bomb abortion clinics cast themselves as rescuers of unborn children. Anders Breivik killed seventy-seven people in Norway in 2011 in the name of rescuing civilization.
But more on the Left than the Right have a savior complex, in my experience. The language, behaviors, and thinking of Allen, Pretti, and Good are familiar to me personally, as I had a savior complex starting in my teens, which contributed to my radical left-wing activism.
But what is the savior complex, exactly, and why is it so prevalent on the Left?...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2051342924676268123
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Stoicism values humility, emotional control, and loyalty to family. And yet America's leading popularizer of it, @RyanHoliday, displays none of those qualities in his angry, TDS-fueled condemnation of @IvankaTrump. He displays an arrogance every wisdom tradition warns against.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Stoicism is one of the West’s most influential philosophical traditions, and author Ryan Holiday is its greatest advocate. And so, when he says that Ivanka Trump’s praise of Marcus Aurelius is “as cringe as it possibly gets, because it’s not real and it’s totally missing the point,” anyone who cares about Stoicism should pay attention. While Ivanka’s quotation of Marcus, on how “the soul becomes dyed the color of its thoughts,” reproduces the sentence accurately, explains Holiday, she fails to live up to the philosophy because she has not, in his terms, staged “an intervention with your dad whose life would be dyed with his horrible, negative, mean bullying thoughts all the time.”
But what Holiday demands of Ivanka contradicts the stoic philosophy he claims to teach. “A man must know many things first,” wrote Marcus Aurelius in Book 11, “before he be able truly and judiciously to judge of another man’s action.” And yet Holiday does not entertain the possibility that Ivanka has thought carefully about her relationship to her father, that she has considered and rejected the path of public denunciation, or that her loyalty might itself reflect a moral commitment. Instead, he assumes that her silence about her father proves her unethical.
Donald Trump’s tweets, his rallies, his rhetorical style, and his political career are not Ivanka’s to control. The very first sentence of Stoic Epictetus’s Handbook says, “Some things are in our control and others not. Things in our control are opinion, pursuit, desire, aversion, and, in a word, whatever are our own actions. Things not in our control are body, property, reputation, command, and, in one word, whatever are not our own actions...”
x.com/shellenberger/status/2051009708626952391
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mark Nelson
@energybants
Extraordinary EU energy development: The Belgian Government has just announced it intends to buy all seven nuclear units from owner Engie.
Perhaps 3, 5 or more reactors are now potentially going to be saved and restarted. Decommissioning work may be stopped immediately. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
When it was out of power, the Left opposed censorship. Then, after decades of purging heretics, it gained control over the universities and media. Facing populist revolts against its misrule, a majority of Democrats came to support censorship, repression, and violence.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
President Donald Trump is a grave threat to free speech, say Democrats and many in the media. The Justice Department this week indicted former FBI Director James Comey for a second time, charging him with threatening the President over an Instagram post last spring of seashells arranged to read “8647,” which the president described as mob talk for calling for someone to kill him. Federal Communications Commission Chairman Brendan Carr ordered Disney’s ABC unit to file early renewal applications for its eight broadcast licenses, days after Jimmy Kimmel joked that Melania Trump had “the glow of an expectant widow,” a quip that aired three days before a gunman opened fire at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner. Trump has gone after the media before, many note. He sued CBS over the editing of a 60 Minutes interview with Kamala Harris, later amending the claim to $20 billion, and Paramount, CBS’s parent, settled for $16 million last July. The Trump administration froze $2.2 billion in research funding for Harvard. A Trump executive order prohibits federal funds from going to K-12 schools that teach critical race theory or gender ideology. And another directs the Attorney General to coordinate with state and local prosecutors against teachers who facilitate the social transition of minors.
But these objections are rather rich coming from representatives of the same Party whose activists canceled colleagues, oversaw mass online censorship, and endorsed the assassination of their political enemies. The murder of Charlie Kirk last September inspired widespread celebration by progressives on social media. Trump’s latest attempted assassin, Cole Allen, was a radicalized leftist. Fifty-five percent of self-identified left-of-center voters said the murder of President Trump could be justified. Democrats and progressives inside and outside government built a sweeping Censorship Industrial Complex in the United States and Europe that censored millions of Americans for legal speech, including questioning Covid, climate, transgender, and migration policies.
Over decades, leftists drove moderates and conservatives out of the news media and the academy. Today, 60 percent of university faculty are left of center, while only 18 and 17 percent are moderate and right of center, respectively. And where the share of US journalists who identified as Democrats rose from 28 percent to 36 percent between 2013 and 2022, the share who identified as Republicans fell from 7.1 percent to 3.4 percent.
As for federal funding decisions, they are not censorship, and much of what the Trump administration acted against were policies that violated the rights of Asians, whites, and minors. The Supreme Court already ruled in 2023 that Harvard’s race-conscious admissions policies violated the law. Public schools are state actors, and what they teach has always been subject to democratic and legal control. And teachers and administrators who tell children they can and should change their gender are endangering their health and well-being, as the WPATH Files show....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2050270673797296436
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative jouralism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pauline Voss
@Pauline__Voss
Mit einem klaren Bekenntnis gegen die Meinungsfreiheit rundet Friedrich Merz eine kommunikativ gelungene Woche ab:
„In den sozialen Netzwerken kann jeder anonym sagen, was er denkt und wie er denkt. Ich find‘s bedauerlich." -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Trust in universities fell 57% to 36% in the last decade, and 70% of Americans say they're headed in the wrong direction. A new Yale report whitewashes the reason why: because they're obsessed with teaching students to hate Western civilization and American values.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Yale University released a candid report last week documenting why Americans no longer trust higher education in general and the Ivy League in particular. A ten-person faculty committee spent a year examining the collapse. One-third of Yale undergraduates, they note, no longer feel free to express political views in class, up from 17% in 2015. Public confidence in colleges and universities fell from 57% a decade ago to a historic low of 36% in 2024, according to Gallup. Seventy percent of Americans today say the sector is heading in the wrong direction. And Americans are more skeptical of Ivy League universities than any others.
But the report fails to identify the cause of the rising censorship and public mistrust, and Yale’s special role in it: the intellectual assault on Western civilization. That academic attack, or “deconstruction,” is aimed at undermining the central commitments of Western civilization, including the pursuit of truth. And it has been going on at Yale and other universities since the 1980s, and arguably longer.
There are, of course, other reasons for the worsening of the quality of American universities. The Yale report identifies several contributing factors, each of which is real. Social media amplifies conformity and shaming, and smartphones distract attention. Activist administrators enforce political dogma and overstep their role. Yale employs more than 6,000 managerial staff, roughly matching the undergraduate population. Students self-police. And there is grade inflation.
But many of those are downstream of the prior assault on the foundations of the West. When professors teach that all claims to truth mask power, students learn that the moral move is to shame dissenters rather than argue with them. When an institution declares that its mission is “improving the world today,” as Yale’s 2016 mission statement now does, rather than the older and narrower goal of seeking the truth and creating and preserving knowledge, everything becomes political.
The Yale report treats self-censorship as a generalized climate, noting carefully that “discomfort appears to be rising across the spectrum.” The phrasing implies symmetry, but a survey of 517 Yale in fall 2025 found that 79% of Republican students say they often self-censor in classroom discussions, while only 29% of Democratic students report the same. A separate survey found that 75% of Republican students and 47% of independents self-censored, compared with 26% of Democrats.
In December 2025, researchers found that across Yale’s 43 undergraduate departments, the Law School, and the School of Management, 82.3% of identified faculty are registered Democrats or donate heavily to Democratic candidates, while only 2.3% are Republicans. That is a 36-to-1 ratio. At the School of Management, the ratio runs 78 to 1. At Yale Law School, the faculty is 94% Democrat versus 1.5% Republican. The Political Science department identified exactly one Republican. Twenty-seven of 43 undergraduate departments contained zero Republicans, and three departments contained neither a Republican nor an independent.
All of this matters because Yale has a broad societal impact. For example, the “Yale and Slavery Teachers Institute” trains K-12 teachers and promotes teaching the 1619 Project to fourth through sixth graders. The 1619 Project, created and promoted by the New York Times, argues that America began with slavery, not with the Declaration of Independence or the Constitution. The 1619 Project frames the United States as essentially racist.
The reality is significantly more complex. Thousands of Americans died during the Civil War to end slavery. The Civil Rights Movement is widely viewed as a high point in American history. And the US has taken extraordinary efforts, far beyond other nations, to reduce racial discrimination to the point of creating widespread racial preferences for nonwhites in hiring, contracting, and admissions.
No one is arguing that slavery, colonialism, and racial injustice should not be taught, but rather that it should be taught rigorously and in full historical context. Few who peruse Yale’s teaching of slavery will view it as fair or balanced. Instead, it trains teachers to teach children that America is dominated by “white supremacy” and that black people remain victims of it, a false and demoralizing message.
The report notes the partisan imbalance in passing but pivoted to the softer language of “intellectual pluralism” and “echo chambers,” calling for department self-studies. It never asks the obvious question: what is the intellectual source of that imbalance?...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2047408129307234644
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of free speech, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pavel Durov
@durov
The “age verification app” the EU wants to impose on the world got hacked in 2 minutes.
Step 1: Present a “privacy-respecting” but hackable solution.
Step 2: Get hacked (you are here).
Step 3: Remove privacy to "fix" it.
Result: a surveillance tool sold as “privacy-respecting”. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Gavin Newsom's wife expressed concern with boys "moving to the right" and said "we're working on legislation" to address it. @Jacob__Siegel, the author of a major new book, says progressives are waiting in the wings with a plan for total information control to counter populism.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Last week, a video of Jennifer Siebel Newsom, the wife of California Governor Gavin Newsom, went viral on X. In the clip, filmed at the Common Sense Summit on Kids and Families in May 2025, Siebel Newsom tells the audience that “boys who spend time online are moving a little bit—I’m trying not to be political here—but are moving to the right.”
She described her own son’s curiosity about Andrew Tate, which he had discussed with her Republican father, as “scary.” She said, “We’re working on legislation to hold tech companies accountable, to really provide all the best-in-class resources and support for youth so that they don’t go down this rabbit hole of very, very dangerous and limiting narratives around ultimately what it means to be girl and what it means to be a boy.”
There are good reasons to be concerned about the impact of social media on young people, but Siebel Newsom, despite her attempt not to be political, made clear her problem was with boys “moving to the right,” which is a very different concern from the ones being raised by Jonathan Haidt and others about the impact of social media on childhood.
Jacob Siegel warns that the Censorship Industrial Complex is a permanent demand of the governing class. [Author photo]📷
And Siebel Newsom’s remarks come in the context of efforts by her husband to control and even censor information. In 2023, Newsom announced a state initiative for citizens to report disfavored speech (non-criminal “hate incidents”) they see online.
In September 2024, the governor signed AB 2655 and AB 2839, two laws aimed at banning political “deepfakes” during election seasons. In September 2025, Senior U.S. District Judge John Mendez struck them both down, saying that the laws discriminated “based on content, viewpoint, and speaker and targets constitutionally protected speech,” and that “California cannot preemptively sterilize political content.”
And then, in October 2025, Governor Newsom signed a package of bills, including AB 1043, which requires device-makers like Apple and Google to verify user ages and share that information with apps. This is ostensibly to prevent children from using social media but the risk is the end of anonymity, which has long been protected as a First Amendment right, online.
The Newsoms’ censorial impulse is not unique. Across the West, progressives, governing parties, and supranational institutions are racing to erect a new architecture of total information control and surveillance, despite it being antithetical to perhaps our most important right, that of free speech. Why can’t they let it go?
In his new book, The Information State: Politics in the Age of Total Control, journalist Jacob Siegel argues that the censorship industrial complex is only the surface manifestation of an older and deeper, technocratic mode of rule that seeks to replace democratic self-government with top-down information management....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2044814040065888275
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of free speech, to read the full article, and watch the full interview!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Hormuz crisis is the precipitating factor in the current energy crisis, but the underlying cause is too little oil and gas production outside the Persian Gulf.
Had the world spent the past decade building the oil, gas, LNG, pipeline, and fertilizer infrastructure that engineers designed and companies proposed, the Hormuz crisis would still be a serious geopolitical event, but it would not threaten to cause a recession.
North America
— The Atlantic Coast Pipeline, a 600-mile natural gas line from West Virginia to North Carolina, saw its cost double from $4.5 billion to $8 billion during years of environmental litigation before Duke Energy and Dominion Energy cancelled it in July 2020.
— The Constitution Pipeline from Pennsylvania to New York died the same year.
— The PennEast Pipeline won its case at the United States Supreme Court in 2021 and still could not get built because New Jersey refused to issue state permits.
— In Canada, TransCanada abandoned the $15.7 billion Energy East pipeline in 2017 after the National Energy Board required an unprecedented review of upstream and downstream emissions.
— In January 2024, the Biden administration paused all pending approvals for LNG export terminals shipping to non-free-trade-agreement countries, freezing projects representing tens of billions of cubic feet per day of potential capacity.
— Venture Global’s CP2 terminal in Louisiana, designed for 20 million tonnes per annum, sat in regulatory limbo for over a year.
— NextDecade’s Rio Grande LNG in Texas, with 48 MTPA of planned capacity, stalled alongside it.
— PTT Global Chemical’s proposed $10 billion ethane cracker in Belmont County, Ohio, first announced in 2015, remains on indefinite hold after failing to attract financing partners amid climate-driven investor sentiment.
— Across the US Gulf Coast, nearly 60% of planned plastic and petrochemical production projects sit on hold.
— LNG Canada, the Shell-led terminal at Kitimat, British Columbia, took over six years from construction start to first cargo, with its pipeline running 263% over budget. Environmental review, Indigenous disputes, and contractor cost escalation all contributed.
— Pieridae Energy’s Goldboro LNG project in Nova Scotia, a 10 MTPA facility first proposed in 2012, was abandoned in November 2023 after more than a decade of permitting and financing obstacles.
Australia
— Australia’s Santos’s Barossa gas project was halted midway through construction after a Federal Court ruling overturned its environmental approval.
— Woodside’s Scarborough project faces ongoing litigation from the Australian Conservation Foundation seeking to block it on climate grounds.
Africa
— Perhaps nowhere has the damage been more consequential than in Africa. At COP26 in 2021, wealthy nations pledged to halt overseas development finance for gas projects, a commitment that fell hardest on the continent least responsible for climate change and most in need of energy infrastructure.
— The World Bank stopped financing oil and gas extraction in 2019 and imposed restrictive conditions on downstream gas projects.
— The European Investment Bank announced a complete ban on unabated fossil fuel financing by the end of 2021, with its president declaring that “gas is over.”
— At least 21 other development finance institutions followed suit.
As a result:
— TotalEnergies’ Mozambique LNG project sat under force majeure for four and a half years after the UK Export Credit Agency and other backers withdrew climate-motivated financing.
— The East African Crude Oil Pipeline lost financing commitments from more than 30 major international banks under pressure from climatists.
Europe
— France prevented the completion of a third gas interconnector with Spain, citing climate neutrality goals.
— The United Kingdom imposed a moratorium on fracking in 2019 despite sitting atop one of Europe’s most promising shale gas formations.
— Germany, which shuttered its last three nuclear plants in April 2023, compounded its gas dependency by refusing to develop domestic shale resources.
— CF Industries permanently shut the UK’s largest ammonia plant at Billingham, a facility that also produced 60% of Britain’s food-grade CO2.
— Yara International curtailed output across plants in France, Italy, and Belgium before permanently closing its 400,000 tonne per year ammonia facility at Tertre, Belgium, in October 2024.
These closures occurred because European climate policy made gas too expensive for the domestic industry to survive.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We should have spent more on green energy, say the media. No, we shouldn't have. The $2 trillion we spent did nothing to prevent the energy crisis and may even have caused it.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Hormuz Strait was a disaster waiting to happen. The only solution is to diversify energy production and for Gulf nations to build pipelines to export their oil and gas via the Red Sea and Mediterranean. More war will result in more harm and higher energy prices for longer.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Disclose.tv
@disclosetv
JUST IN - No oil tankers have passed through the Strait of Hormuz since yesterday's ceasefire, and the four ships that have passed are all dry cargo carriers, data from shipping intelligence firm Kpler shows — NYT
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Disclose.tv
@disclosetv
JUST IN - Several ships received messages in the Gulf claiming to be from the Iranian navy saying the Strait of Hormuz remains closed — Reuters
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Hormuz Strait was a disaster waiting to happen. The only solution is to diversify energy production and for Gulf nations to build pipelines to export their oil and gas via the Red Sea and Mediterranean. More war will result in more harm and higher energy prices for longer.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Trump administration underestimated Iran’s willingness to close the Strait of Hormuz, note many in the media. CNN reported that while the Departments of Energy and the Treasury participated in pre-war planning meetings, “the agency analysis and forecasts that would be integral elements of the decision-making process in past administrations were secondary considerations.”
But the Strait of Hormuz was a catastrophe waiting to happen. A few years from now, people will look back on this moment and find it incredible that the world allowed the global economy to be dependent on moving so much oil and natural gas through such a dangerous bottleneck.
Part of the solution is for the world to reduce its dependence on Persian Gulf oil and gas. That will require expanding production outside the Persian Gulf. Another part is to help Persian Gulf nations move more of their oil and gas through new or expanded pipelines to the Red Sea and perhaps even the Mediterranean. The faster the world builds those alternatives, the less leverage Iran retains.
Many believe that the United States must not allow Iran to control the Strait under any circumstances, and the instinct to fight for Hormuz is understandable. It has been a central artery of global energy for over half a century.
But instead of fighting to reopen the Strait, the world should build around it. The infrastructure to do so already exists in embryonic form. Saudi Arabia’s East-West pipeline, built during the Iran-Iraq war in the 1980s, carries crude 750 miles across the kingdom from the Gulf coast to the Red Sea port of Yanbu, with a design capacity of 7 million barrels per day. The UAE’s Abu Dhabi Crude Oil Pipeline runs to Fujairah on the Gulf of Oman, bypassing the Strait entirely. And Iraq’s Kirkuk-Ceyhan pipeline connects to the Mediterranean coast of Turkey.
Gulf states are already exploring a broader network of pipelines, railways, and roads, including the U.S.-backed India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor (IMEC), that would create multiple export routes to the Red Sea and the Mediterranean. Kuwait, Bahrain, and Qatar, which have no bypass pipelines at all, should build routes through Saudi Arabia or Iraq, argued The National, a UAE newspaper. And Japan, South Korea, and India should, the paper argued, invest alongside Gulf sovereign wealth funds.
Iran will almost certainly impose tolls on vessels transiting the Strait, as its parliament has already passed a bill to formalize fee collection. A toll of $2 to $5 per barrel, the range analysts expect Iran to charge, would add roughly $40 to $100 billion per year to global energy costs.
But more war will cause far more harm than simply building alternatives because every escalation destroys infrastructure that the world needs to produce and export energy. While “all roads” may lead to “structurally higher oil prices,” as one analysis of future scenarios concluded, one of those roads leads to far less damage to people and energy infrastructure.
Iran’s strikes on Ras Laffan, Qatar’s LNG hub, will take three to five years to repair. The strikes on South Pars threaten the world’s largest natural gas reserve. Iran’s attacks on Gulf neighbors have damaged refineries, desalination plants, and port facilities across Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Bahrain, and Kuwait.
And consider how much more damage is possible. After the US struck Kharg Island, Iran’s main oil export hub, and Israel hit Iran’s largest petrochemical complex at South Pars, the world’s largest natural gas reserve, Iran’s military threatened to “deprive the U.S. and its allies of the region’s oil and gas for years.”
As such, the $40 to $100 billion is a fraction of the $2 trillion or more that Goldman Sachs has estimated the war has already cost the global economy in lost output, destroyed infrastructure, and elevated energy prices.
And continued war could lead Iran to cut off the flows of existing Saudi oil flows through its East-West pipeline. Iranian adviser Aliakbar Velayati warned that Iran views the Bab al-Mandab Strait off Yemen “with the same intensity as Hormuz” and that “the flow of energy and global trade can be disrupted with a single signal.”
x.com/shellenberger/status/2041599285138260307
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Investors built their portfolios for a world of cheap energy that no longer exists. Dozens of traders, shippers, and executives say the market still has not grasped the severity of the Hormuz crisis. Today might be the day it does.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
😬
*Walter Bloomberg
@DeItaone
🚨 QATAR FOREIGN MINISTRY SPOKESPERSON: WE ARE CLOSE TO THE POINT WHERE THE SITUATION IN THE REGION COULD SPIRAL OUT OF CONTROL
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Sounds bad
Daily Iran News
@DailyIranNews
🚨 BREAKING
IRGC Missile Command:
"We announce the end of all targeting restrictions. We will strike infrastructure in a manner that will deprive the United States and regional countries of oil and gas resources for years to come.
Orders have been transmitted to local missile bases, and operations will begin immediately." -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Maurice Cousins
@MDC12345678
Great post by @shellenberger. This is the piece I wish I had written a few months ago, when British Labour MPs and others were talking about “abundance”. The word has been totally twisted - like “electrification” and “clean” - to distort ordinary people’s understanding of the true goals of the climate lobby: (1) the prioritisation of renewables at all costs and (2) the re-engineering of our societies and economies low-energy, constraint-driven lines.
It is a clever strategy, born out of the so-called “greenlash” in the European elections and anticipation of Trump 2.0. The climate lobby recognised that Net Zero and decarbonisation had become toxic terms, associated with miserabilism. They sensed where the political wind was blowing and adapted with techno-utopianism. The problem is that their ideal is not remotely deliverable without imposing severe costs, constraints, and unpalatable trade-offs on ordinary people.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Renewables are the key to preventing resource scarcity, argue European leaders, California Governor Gavin Newsom, and Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson, whose bestselling book Abundance became one of Barack Obama’s favorite books of 2025 and launched a political movement dedicated to what Klein calls “a politics of plenty.” The logic is straightforward and appealing. Solar panel costs have fallen more than 90% since 2010. Wind power costs have dropped by 70%. Battery storage prices have collapsed.
If governments would simply clear the regulatory obstacles to building solar farms, wind turbines, and transmission lines, the abundance argument goes, clean energy would flow so abundantly that fossil fuel dependence would become a choice rather than a necessity. “The miracles of solar and wind and battery power,” Klein told the Long Now Foundation, “have given us the only shot we have to avoid catastrophic climate change.”
But if renewables could prevent resource scarcity, then the world would not be in the midst of what the International Energy Agency’s Executive Director Fatih Birol called “the greatest global energy security challenge in history,” with global supply losses now totaling 12 million barrels per day, compared to about 5 million during each of the 1973 and 1979 crises. The United Kingdom is receiving its last shipment of jet fuel from the Middle East with nothing behind it. Australia saw over 500 gas stations run dry. And South Korea is considering driving restrictions for the first time since 1991. “In April,” warned Birol, “there is nothing.”
It is true that solar and batteries have made enormous progress. Solar electricity costs roughly 3 to 5 cents per kilowatt-hour at the point of generation, cheaper than any fossil fuel in most locations. Battery costs have fallen below $115 per kilowatt-hour. China produces more solar panels than the rest of the world combined.
But the world has installed more than 1,600 gigawatts of solar capacity and over 1,000 gigawatts of wind, and still we are in crisis. Global green energy investment was $2.3 trillion in 2025 alone. And yet when Iran closed the Strait of Hormuz, none of that capacity mattered, because solar panels do not produce jet fuel, diesel, ammonia, or the petrochemical feedstocks that underpin modern civilization.
Electricity accounts for roughly 20% of final energy consumption worldwide. The other 80%, the part that moves ships, flies planes, heats buildings, and makes fertilizer, runs overwhelmingly on oil and gas. Solar and wind cannot substitute for these fuels at any price, because the energy density of liquid hydrocarbons exceeds batteries by a factor of 40 to 80 by weight.
Klein and Thompson, to their credit, also support some forms of nuclear power. Abundance opens with a vision of cities powered by “clean (nuclear) and renewable (wind and solar) energy sources.” They lament America’s nuclear stagnation compared to France’s successful buildout. Klein has said that he supports advancing nuclear power alongside renewables.
But, the new nuclear power plants that Klein and Thompson support do not exist. The “small modular reactors” that populate the abundance fantasy have not produced a single commercial kilowatt-hour of electricity. NuScale, the most advanced American SMR developer, canceled its flagship project in 2023 after costs doubled. No SMR has received a commercial operating license anywhere in the world. The first commercially operating SMR, if all goes well, may produce power in the early 2030s, but SMR developers have for years said that their reactors are just a few years away. Scaling to a meaningful share of global energy supply would take decades, as opposed to building conventional nuclear plants, which Japan and China have shown they can build in just two years, so long as they are standardized and the same construction crews are used.
Democrats, progressives, environmental groups, and left-wing parties across Europe diverted hundreds of billions of dollars over the last two decades from developing the new oil and gas production, pipelines, refineries, and LNG terminals needed to make energy cheap and abundant. California’s aggressive climate mandates drove residential electricity prices to 34 cents per kilowatt-hour, nearly double the national average, while the state simultaneously blocked new natural gas infrastructure. And global investment in oil and gas exploration and production peaked at roughly $780 billion in 2014 and fell to approximately $350 billion by 2020, a decline driven by deliberate policy choices to restrict fossil fuel development.
The European Union’s Green Deal, America’s Inflation Reduction Act, and climate policies across the developed world channeled subsidies toward solar and wind while imposing carbon taxes, windfall levies, and permitting restrictions on fossil fuel projects. The UK’s Energy Profits Levy, introduced in 2022, discouraged investment in the North Sea at precisely the moment when more domestic production was needed.
The UK Labor government then banned new exploration licenses in November 2025. Germany’s Energiewende spent over €500 billion on renewables while shutting down its nuclear plants, leaving the country dependent on Russian gas and then, after the Ukraine war, on LNG that must now compete with Asian buyers for cargoes that can no longer transit Hormuz. And the UK has lost a third of its refineries in the last 18 months, meaning that even if crude oil arrived tomorrow, the country lacks the capacity to refine it into the jet fuel, diesel, and heating oil its citizens need.
The only energy abundance solution that works at the scale of civilization right now is piped natural gas and oil. A pipeline delivers energy continuously, at near-zero marginal cost per unit delivered, with no exposure to shipping chokepoints, insurance markets, or geopolitical disruption. A ton of natural gas moved through a pipeline costs a fraction of what the same gas costs when liquefied, shipped by tanker across an ocean, and regasified at a terminal. The logical endpoint is a world powered by natural gas delivered through continental pipeline networks, eventually transitioning to hydrogen produced from natural gas and nuclear power.
America built pipelines while Europe and Asia built LNG dependency. Saudi Arabia’s East-West pipeline, which has ramped from 770,000 barrels per day to 2.9 million since the war began, is the emergency proof of concept. If the Gulf states had built sufficient pipeline capacity to bypass Hormuz before the war, the crisis would be a fraction of its current severity.
So why do so many on the Left continue to preach renewables as the solution to a crisis that renewables manifestly cannot solve?...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2040423408752566287
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative reporting, read the rest of the article, and watch the rest of the video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Democrats must rebrand their energy agenda around abundance, some say. But doing so is fundamentally dishonest. For decades, the party has fought, blocked, and closed nuclear plants, pipelines, and oil and natural gas production, laying the foundation for today's energy crisis.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Renewables are the key to preventing resource scarcity, argue European leaders, California Governor Gavin Newsom, and Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson, whose bestselling book Abundance became one of Barack Obama’s favorite books of 2025 and launched a political movement dedicated to what Klein calls “a politics of plenty.” The logic is straightforward and appealing. Solar panel costs have fallen more than 90% since 2010. Wind power costs have dropped by 70%. Battery storage prices have collapsed.
If governments would simply clear the regulatory obstacles to building solar farms, wind turbines, and transmission lines, the abundance argument goes, clean energy would flow so abundantly that fossil fuel dependence would become a choice rather than a necessity. “The miracles of solar and wind and battery power,” Klein told the Long Now Foundation, “have given us the only shot we have to avoid catastrophic climate change.”
But if renewables could prevent resource scarcity, then the world would not be in the midst of what the International Energy Agency’s Executive Director Fatih Birol called “the greatest global energy security challenge in history,” with global supply losses now totaling 12 million barrels per day, compared to about 5 million during each of the 1973 and 1979 crises. The United Kingdom is receiving its last shipment of jet fuel from the Middle East with nothing behind it. Australia saw over 500 gas stations run dry. And South Korea is considering driving restrictions for the first time since 1991. “In April,” warned Birol, “there is nothing.”
It is true that solar and batteries have made enormous progress. Solar electricity costs roughly 3 to 5 cents per kilowatt-hour at the point of generation, cheaper than any fossil fuel in most locations. Battery costs have fallen below $115 per kilowatt-hour. China produces more solar panels than the rest of the world combined.
But the world has installed more than 1,600 gigawatts of solar capacity and over 1,000 gigawatts of wind, and still we are in crisis. Global green energy investment was $2.3 trillion in 2025 alone. And yet when Iran closed the Strait of Hormuz, none of that capacity mattered, because solar panels do not produce jet fuel, diesel, ammonia, or the petrochemical feedstocks that underpin modern civilization.
Electricity accounts for roughly 20% of final energy consumption worldwide. The other 80%, the part that moves ships, flies planes, heats buildings, and makes fertilizer, runs overwhelmingly on oil and gas. Solar and wind cannot substitute for these fuels at any price, because the energy density of liquid hydrocarbons exceeds batteries by a factor of 40 to 80 by weight.
Klein and Thompson, to their credit, also support some forms of nuclear power. Abundance opens with a vision of cities powered by “clean (nuclear) and renewable (wind and solar) energy sources.” They lament America’s nuclear stagnation compared to France’s successful buildout. Klein has said that he supports advancing nuclear power alongside renewables.
But, the new nuclear power plants that Klein and Thompson support do not exist. The “small modular reactors” that populate the abundance fantasy have not produced a single commercial kilowatt-hour of electricity. NuScale, the most advanced American SMR developer, canceled its flagship project in 2023 after costs doubled. No SMR has received a commercial operating license anywhere in the world. The first commercially operating SMR, if all goes well, may produce power in the early 2030s, but SMR developers have for years said that their reactors are just a few years away. Scaling to a meaningful share of global energy supply would take decades, as opposed to building conventional nuclear plants, which Japan and China have shown they can build in just two years, so long as they are standardized and the same construction crews are used.
Democrats, progressives, environmental groups, and left-wing parties across Europe diverted hundreds of billions of dollars over the last two decades from developing the new oil and gas production, pipelines, refineries, and LNG terminals needed to make energy cheap and abundant. California’s aggressive climate mandates drove residential electricity prices to 34 cents per kilowatt-hour, nearly double the national average, while the state simultaneously blocked new natural gas infrastructure. And global investment in oil and gas exploration and production peaked at roughly $780 billion in 2014 and fell to approximately $350 billion by 2020, a decline driven by deliberate policy choices to restrict fossil fuel development.
The European Union’s Green Deal, America’s Inflation Reduction Act, and climate policies across the developed world channeled subsidies toward solar and wind while imposing carbon taxes, windfall levies, and permitting restrictions on fossil fuel projects. The UK’s Energy Profits Levy, introduced in 2022, discouraged investment in the North Sea at precisely the moment when more domestic production was needed.
The UK Labor government then banned new exploration licenses in November 2025. Germany’s Energiewende spent over €500 billion on renewables while shutting down its nuclear plants, leaving the country dependent on Russian gas and then, after the Ukraine war, on LNG that must now compete with Asian buyers for cargoes that can no longer transit Hormuz. And the UK has lost a third of its refineries in the last 18 months, meaning that even if crude oil arrived tomorrow, the country lacks the capacity to refine it into the jet fuel, diesel, and heating oil its citizens need.
The only energy abundance solution that works at the scale of civilization right now is piped natural gas and oil. A pipeline delivers energy continuously, at near-zero marginal cost per unit delivered, with no exposure to shipping chokepoints, insurance markets, or geopolitical disruption. A ton of natural gas moved through a pipeline costs a fraction of what the same gas costs when liquefied, shipped by tanker across an ocean, and regasified at a terminal. The logical endpoint is a world powered by natural gas delivered through continental pipeline networks, eventually transitioning to hydrogen produced from natural gas and nuclear power.
America built pipelines while Europe and Asia built LNG dependency. Saudi Arabia’s East-West pipeline, which has ramped from 770,000 barrels per day to 2.9 million since the war began, is the emergency proof of concept. If the Gulf states had built sufficient pipeline capacity to bypass Hormuz before the war, the crisis would be a fraction of its current severity.
So why do so many on the Left continue to preach renewables as the solution to a crisis that renewables manifestly cannot solve?...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2040423408752566287
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative reporting, read the rest of the article, and watch the rest of the video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
UK Energy Secretary @Ed_Miliband called North Sea drilling "climate vandalism." Now he's waffling on new drilling, which he should have approved long ago. What changed? The war exposed the fraudulence of his net-zero, anti-oil-and-gas fantasy. 🧵
Department for Energy Security and Net Zero
@energygovuk
From cutting energy bills & cracking down on price gouging, to building homegrown clean energy that protects the UK from volatile international markets - we are committed to helping households with the cost of living.
@Ed_Miliband explains👇 www.youtube.com/watch?v=wP0f6WJXgnUPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
5/ This is the pattern everywhere. Greens/Labor/Democrats restrict oil and gas production for years. Then, a crisis hits and they quietly reverse course while pretending nothing changed. They never accept responsibility for the damage.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Hormuz crisis is the precipitating factor in the current energy crisis, but the underlying cause is too little oil and gas production outside the Persian Gulf.
Had the world spent the past decade building the oil, gas, LNG, pipeline, and fertilizer infrastructure that engineers designed and companies proposed, the Hormuz crisis would still be a serious geopolitical event, but it would not threaten to cause a recession.
North America
— The Atlantic Coast Pipeline, a 600-mile natural gas line from West Virginia to North Carolina, saw its cost double from $4.5 billion to $8 billion during years of environmental litigation before Duke Energy and Dominion Energy cancelled it in July 2020.
— The Constitution Pipeline from Pennsylvania to New York died the same year.
— The PennEast Pipeline won its case at the United States Supreme Court in 2021 and still could not get built because New Jersey refused to issue state permits.
— In Canada, TransCanada abandoned the $15.7 billion Energy East pipeline in 2017 after the National Energy Board required an unprecedented review of upstream and downstream emissions.
— In January 2024, the Biden administration paused all pending approvals for LNG export terminals shipping to non-free-trade-agreement countries, freezing projects representing tens of billions of cubic feet per day of potential capacity.
— Venture Global’s CP2 terminal in Louisiana, designed for 20 million tonnes per annum, sat in regulatory limbo for over a year.
— NextDecade’s Rio Grande LNG in Texas, with 48 MTPA of planned capacity, stalled alongside it.
— PTT Global Chemical’s proposed $10 billion ethane cracker in Belmont County, Ohio, first announced in 2015, remains on indefinite hold after failing to attract financing partners amid climate-driven investor sentiment.
— Across the US Gulf Coast, nearly 60% of planned plastic and petrochemical production projects sit on hold.
— LNG Canada, the Shell-led terminal at Kitimat, British Columbia, took over six years from construction start to first cargo, with its pipeline running 263% over budget. Environmental review, Indigenous disputes, and contractor cost escalation all contributed.
— Pieridae Energy’s Goldboro LNG project in Nova Scotia, a 10 MTPA facility first proposed in 2012, was abandoned in November 2023 after more than a decade of permitting and financing obstacles.
Australia
— Australia’s Santos’s Barossa gas project was halted midway through construction after a Federal Court ruling overturned its environmental approval.
— Woodside’s Scarborough project faces ongoing litigation from the Australian Conservation Foundation seeking to block it on climate grounds.
Africa
— Perhaps nowhere has the damage been more consequential than in Africa. At COP26 in 2021, wealthy nations pledged to halt overseas development finance for gas projects, a commitment that fell hardest on the continent least responsible for climate change and most in need of energy infrastructure.
— The World Bank stopped financing oil and gas extraction in 2019 and imposed restrictive conditions on downstream gas projects.
— The European Investment Bank announced a complete ban on unabated fossil fuel financing by the end of 2021, with its president declaring that “gas is over.”
— At least 21 other development finance institutions followed suit.
As a result:
— TotalEnergies’ Mozambique LNG project sat under force majeure for four and a half years after the UK Export Credit Agency and other backers withdrew climate-motivated financing.
— The East African Crude Oil Pipeline lost financing commitments from more than 30 major international banks under pressure from climatists.
Europe
— France prevented the completion of a third gas interconnector with Spain, citing climate neutrality goals.
— The United Kingdom imposed a moratorium on fracking in 2019 despite sitting atop one of Europe’s most promising shale gas formations.
— Germany, which shuttered its last three nuclear plants in April 2023, compounded its gas dependency by refusing to develop domestic shale resources.
— CF Industries permanently shut the UK’s largest ammonia plant at Billingham, a facility that also produced 60% of Britain’s food-grade CO2.
— Yara International curtailed output across plants in France, Italy, and Belgium before permanently closing its 400,000 tonne per year ammonia facility at Tertre, Belgium, in October 2024.
These closures occurred because European climate policy made gas too expensive for the domestic industry to survive.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We should have spent more on green energy, say the media. No, we shouldn't have. The $2 trillion we spent did nothing to prevent the energy crisis and may even have caused it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
6/ Upstream oil and gas investment peaked at $869 billion in 2015 and fell to $350 billion by 2020. It recovered to only $570 billion by 2025, still a third below the peak. Meanwhile, governments poured $2.2 trillion into green energy in 2025 alone.
www.iea.org/reports/world-energy-investment-2025/executiv…Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
9/ The US produces natural gas at $4 per million BTU and delivers it through 3 million miles of pipeline. Europe pays $16 for the same gas because it arrives by tanker. The difference is decades of policy choices. America built pipelines while Europe built dependency.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
11/ Real energy abundance means piped natural gas at $4, nuclear plants running at 90% capacity for 100 years, and domestic oil production that cannot be disrupted by a drone strike, not solar panels at the supermarket.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Jacob Siegel
@Jacob__Siegel
See, it's not censorship when a figure connected to the US government pressures a publication to remove its review of my book.
I'm the REAL censor for writing the book.
Bridget Phetasy
@BridgetPhetasy
What!?
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Remarkable acceleration of events
7:48 pm ET: White House announces Trump speech on Iran for prime time tomorrow
9 pm: WSJ reports UAE will use force to open Hormuz
9:57 pm: Iranian drones hit fuel tanks at Kuwaiti airport, says government.
(X posts in Central Time)
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Hormuz crisis is the precipitating factor in the current energy crisis, but the underlying cause is too little oil and gas production outside the Persian Gulf.
Had the world spent the past decade building the oil, gas, LNG, pipeline, and fertilizer infrastructure that engineers designed and companies proposed, the Hormuz crisis would still be a serious geopolitical event, but it would not threaten to cause a recession.
North America
— The Atlantic Coast Pipeline, a 600-mile natural gas line from West Virginia to North Carolina, saw its cost double from $4.5 billion to $8 billion during years of environmental litigation before Duke Energy and Dominion Energy cancelled it in July 2020.
— The Constitution Pipeline from Pennsylvania to New York died the same year.
— The PennEast Pipeline won its case at the United States Supreme Court in 2021 and still could not get built because New Jersey refused to issue state permits.
— In Canada, TransCanada abandoned the $15.7 billion Energy East pipeline in 2017 after the National Energy Board required an unprecedented review of upstream and downstream emissions.
— In January 2024, the Biden administration paused all pending approvals for LNG export terminals shipping to non-free-trade-agreement countries, freezing projects representing tens of billions of cubic feet per day of potential capacity.
— Venture Global’s CP2 terminal in Louisiana, designed for 20 million tonnes per annum, sat in regulatory limbo for over a year.
— NextDecade’s Rio Grande LNG in Texas, with 48 MTPA of planned capacity, stalled alongside it.
— PTT Global Chemical’s proposed $10 billion ethane cracker in Belmont County, Ohio, first announced in 2015, remains on indefinite hold after failing to attract financing partners amid climate-driven investor sentiment.
— Across the US Gulf Coast, nearly 60% of planned plastic and petrochemical production projects sit on hold.
— LNG Canada, the Shell-led terminal at Kitimat, British Columbia, took over six years from construction start to first cargo, with its pipeline running 263% over budget. Environmental review, Indigenous disputes, and contractor cost escalation all contributed.
— Pieridae Energy’s Goldboro LNG project in Nova Scotia, a 10 MTPA facility first proposed in 2012, was abandoned in November 2023 after more than a decade of permitting and financing obstacles.
Australia
— Australia’s Santos’s Barossa gas project was halted midway through construction after a Federal Court ruling overturned its environmental approval.
— Woodside’s Scarborough project faces ongoing litigation from the Australian Conservation Foundation seeking to block it on climate grounds.
Africa
— Perhaps nowhere has the damage been more consequential than in Africa. At COP26 in 2021, wealthy nations pledged to halt overseas development finance for gas projects, a commitment that fell hardest on the continent least responsible for climate change and most in need of energy infrastructure.
— The World Bank stopped financing oil and gas extraction in 2019 and imposed restrictive conditions on downstream gas projects.
— The European Investment Bank announced a complete ban on unabated fossil fuel financing by the end of 2021, with its president declaring that “gas is over.”
— At least 21 other development finance institutions followed suit.
As a result:
— TotalEnergies’ Mozambique LNG project sat under force majeure for four and a half years after the UK Export Credit Agency and other backers withdrew climate-motivated financing.
— The East African Crude Oil Pipeline lost financing commitments from more than 30 major international banks under pressure from climatists.
Europe
— France prevented the completion of a third gas interconnector with Spain, citing climate neutrality goals.
— The United Kingdom imposed a moratorium on fracking in 2019 despite sitting atop one of Europe’s most promising shale gas formations.
— Germany, which shuttered its last three nuclear plants in April 2023, compounded its gas dependency by refusing to develop domestic shale resources.
— CF Industries permanently shut the UK’s largest ammonia plant at Billingham, a facility that also produced 60% of Britain’s food-grade CO2.
— Yara International curtailed output across plants in France, Italy, and Belgium before permanently closing its 400,000 tonne per year ammonia facility at Tertre, Belgium, in October 2024.
These closures occurred because European climate policy made gas too expensive for the domestic industry to survive.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We should have spent more on green energy, say the media. No, we shouldn't have. The $2 trillion we spent did nothing to prevent the energy crisis and may even have caused it.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Tanker hit off coast of Qatar
AFP News Agency
@AFP
BREAKING A tanker has been hit by a projectile in the Gulf, off the coast of Qatar's capital Doha, a British maritime security agency says, reporting some damage but no casualties
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Australian PM to address nation on fuel crisis
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Iran conflict triggered the energy crisis, but its roots lie in the West's opposition to the production of oil and gas outside the Persian Gulf. The climate movement is, says former radical environmentalist @ziontree, "fundamentally anti-human in its thinking."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In a small village in the Punjab, a girl of about eight years old crouches over a clay stove, feeding it patties of dried cow dung. Smoke billows into her face. She coughs while feeding the fire. There is no reliable electricity. When the family gets a little extra money, they buy liquified petroleum gas (LPG), which burns cleanly, as natural gas does in stoves in the wealthy West. Unfortunately, that LPG just got priced out of reach for hundreds of millions like her.
The 2026 Iran war and the closure of the Strait of Hormuz were the triggers for the current energy crisis, but the underlying cause is the chronic underinvestment and underdevelopment of oil and gas resources by poor, developing, and rich nations alike over the last ten years. Policymakers diverted that money into green energy, which failed to prevent the crisis.
Zion Lights, the author of an essential new book, Energy Is Life, watched the above scene during a visit to her parents’ ancestral village in India. Her parents had emigrated to Birmingham, England, in the late 1960s and 1970s to work in factories. The factories gave them wages, dignity, and a foothold in the developed world. The family they left behind in the Punjab remained trapped in a poverty so total that it touched everything: health, education, opportunity, lifespan. At the root of it all is the lack of energy.
The energy crisis will hurt poor people in poor nations far more than anyone in the U.S. or the rest of the West. Asian countries receive 80 percent of their energy supply through the Strait of Hormuz. For Bangladesh, which sources 72 percent of its LNG from Qatar and the UAE, the supply disruption translates to an extra $760 to $830 million in monthly import costs.
“All poverty is energy poverty, when you think about it,” Lights said in our new podcast. “They’re living in 40-degree Celsius heat. No air conditioning. You can give them an air conditioner, you can give them money for an air conditioner, but how’s it going to work if you don’t have the electricity?”
It would be unfair to entirely blame the lack of oil and gas supplies on Western climate policy. Beyond the Iran war, governance failures, corruption, conflict, and infrastructure decay all play important roles. India’s power sector dysfunction predates any climate agreement. Pakistan’s circular debt crisis has roots in decades of mismanagement and subsidy distortions. Sub-Saharan Africa’s electricity deficit reflects bad governance, underinvestment, and the difficulty of building transmission infrastructure across vast, sparsely populated territories.
But climate policy has been the dominant priority in wealthy nations’ engagement with the developing world for two decades, and Western green NGOs have even blocked the construction of hydroelectric dams, which tend to be the first reliable source of power that poor nations develop as they rise the development ladder.
Beginning in the early 2010s and accelerating sharply after the 2015 Paris Agreement, Western development banks, private financial institutions, and national governments began systematically restricting financing for oil, gas, and coal projects in the developing world. The stated rationale was climate change. The practical effect was to deny poor countries the energy infrastructure that every wealthy nation used to climb out of poverty...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2038995329530421620
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, watch the full podcast, and read the rest of the article.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Hormuz crisis is the precipitating factor in the current energy crisis, but the underlying cause is too little oil and gas production outside the Persian Gulf.
Had the world spent the past decade building the oil, gas, LNG, pipeline, and fertilizer infrastructure that engineers designed and companies proposed, the Hormuz crisis would still be a serious geopolitical event, but it would not threaten to cause a recession.
North America
— The Atlantic Coast Pipeline, a 600-mile natural gas line from West Virginia to North Carolina, saw its cost double from $4.5 billion to $8 billion during years of environmental litigation before Duke Energy and Dominion Energy cancelled it in July 2020.
— The Constitution Pipeline from Pennsylvania to New York died the same year.
— The PennEast Pipeline won its case at the United States Supreme Court in 2021 and still could not get built because New Jersey refused to issue state permits.
— In Canada, TransCanada abandoned the $15.7 billion Energy East pipeline in 2017 after the National Energy Board required an unprecedented review of upstream and downstream emissions.
— In January 2024, the Biden administration paused all pending approvals for LNG export terminals shipping to non-free-trade-agreement countries, freezing projects representing tens of billions of cubic feet per day of potential capacity.
— Venture Global’s CP2 terminal in Louisiana, designed for 20 million tonnes per annum, sat in regulatory limbo for over a year.
— NextDecade’s Rio Grande LNG in Texas, with 48 MTPA of planned capacity, stalled alongside it.
— PTT Global Chemical’s proposed $10 billion ethane cracker in Belmont County, Ohio, first announced in 2015, remains on indefinite hold after failing to attract financing partners amid climate-driven investor sentiment.
— Across the US Gulf Coast, nearly 60% of planned plastic and petrochemical production projects sit on hold.
— LNG Canada, the Shell-led terminal at Kitimat, British Columbia, took over six years from construction start to first cargo, with its pipeline running 263% over budget. Environmental review, Indigenous disputes, and contractor cost escalation all contributed.
— Pieridae Energy’s Goldboro LNG project in Nova Scotia, a 10 MTPA facility first proposed in 2012, was abandoned in November 2023 after more than a decade of permitting and financing obstacles.
Australia
— Australia’s Santos’s Barossa gas project was halted midway through construction after a Federal Court ruling overturned its environmental approval.
— Woodside’s Scarborough project faces ongoing litigation from the Australian Conservation Foundation seeking to block it on climate grounds.
Africa
— Perhaps nowhere has the damage been more consequential than in Africa. At COP26 in 2021, wealthy nations pledged to halt overseas development finance for gas projects, a commitment that fell hardest on the continent least responsible for climate change and most in need of energy infrastructure.
— The World Bank stopped financing oil and gas extraction in 2019 and imposed restrictive conditions on downstream gas projects.
— The European Investment Bank announced a complete ban on unabated fossil fuel financing by the end of 2021, with its president declaring that “gas is over.”
— At least 21 other development finance institutions followed suit.
As a result:
— TotalEnergies’ Mozambique LNG project sat under force majeure for four and a half years after the UK Export Credit Agency and other backers withdrew climate-motivated financing.
— The East African Crude Oil Pipeline lost financing commitments from more than 30 major international banks under pressure from climatists.
Europe
— France prevented the completion of a third gas interconnector with Spain, citing climate neutrality goals.
— The United Kingdom imposed a moratorium on fracking in 2019 despite sitting atop one of Europe’s most promising shale gas formations.
— Germany, which shuttered its last three nuclear plants in April 2023, compounded its gas dependency by refusing to develop domestic shale resources.
— CF Industries permanently shut the UK’s largest ammonia plant at Billingham, a facility that also produced 60% of Britain’s food-grade CO2.
— Yara International curtailed output across plants in France, Italy, and Belgium before permanently closing its 400,000 tonne per year ammonia facility at Tertre, Belgium, in October 2024.
These closures occurred because European climate policy made gas too expensive for the domestic industry to survive.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We should have spent more on green energy, say the media. No, we shouldn't have. The $2 trillion we spent did nothing to prevent the energy crisis and may even have caused it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
🎯
Maurice Cousins
@MDC12345678
To be absolutely clear, the looming fertiliser and food price crisis has not happened to us. We have done this to ourselves.
In 2014, I worked with the UK’s shale gas sector and the fertiliser industry. Our warning was very simple: without domestic gas, you lose ammonia; lose ammonia, you lose fertiliser; lose fertiliser, you hit food supply.
Ammonia is also needed to make... explosives - which are quite handy when you need to re-arm.
Westminster, green campaigners and national media journalists scoffed. It was dismissed by anti-fracking campaigners as “scraping the barrel”.
Then reality intervened in 2021–22 with the war in Ukraine.
In June 2022, fertiliser producers went into administration because they could not secure feedstocks at viable prices. By 2023, CF Fertilisers (which acquired Grow How) announced the permanent closure of its UK operations.
And now, in 2026, we are told the problem is Donald Trump and disruption to the Strait of Hormuz.
This is classic obscurantism. Shift the focus to the trigger. Avoid the structural cause: domestic energy policy, climate policy (Net Zero) and deindustrialisation. And continue to deny the potential of shale and the North Sea.
Our media and political elites do this because confronting the actual cause is too uncomfortable.
Conservatives, Labour and the Liberal Democrats all chose, over time, to make this country more dependent. Not always explicitly, not always deliberately, but consistently. Sabotage fracking. Ban it in 2019. Vandalise the North Sea with the EPL. Allow energy-intensive industry, including fertiliser, to be offshored. Accept higher costs and greater reliance on imports as the price of policy.
And if you are Ed Davey, boast to journalists that you are “proud” to have played your part in sabotaging the sector as Energy Secretary.
SW1 can dress it up however they like. They can continue to point to geopolitics, wars, foreign leaders.
But the chain was known in the 2010s. The risks were flagged. The capacity was allowed to wither anyway.
Now the whole country will pay for it.
See the @NWTaskforce briefing note from 2014 here: d3n8a8pro7vhmx.cloudfront.net/nwenergy/pages/19/attachmen… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Gasoline in California is nearly $2 more per gallon than the national average.
Gavin Newsom
@GavinNewsom
This aged well!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Receipts:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The response to the 2022 energy crisis should have been to expand oil & gas production. Instead, @GavinNewsom tried to shut down the state's refineries, resulting in gasoline ~$2/gallon more expensive than the national average. Catastrophically irresponsible.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Gavin Newsom says Trump is to blame for California’s $5.86/gallon gasoline, but that’s nearly $2 higher than the national average. And it was mostly Newsom’s destruction of the state’s oil production and refining capacity that explains the difference.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We should have spent more on green energy, say the media. No, we shouldn't have. The $2 trillion we spent did nothing to prevent the energy crisis and may even have caused it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Iran conflict is a reminder that we must accelerate the transition away from fossil fuels, say many in the media. Iran’s disruption of shipping through the Strait of Hormuz means the world is now losing 13 million barrels per day of oil and refined products, which is over 10% of global consumption.
After QatarEnergy, the world’s largest LNG exporter, declared force majeure on all exports after Iranian drone strikes, Asian buyers scrambled to redirect orders to Australia. But then, last week, a cyclone slammed into Australia’s LNG corridor, forcing shutdowns at three of the country’s largest facilities.
David Wallace-Wells in the New York Times noted, “No one has ever started a war over solar panels.”
But nobody goes to war over solar panels for the same reason nobody goes to war over candles: they cannot power the things that economies, civilizations, and wars run on. A gallon of jet fuel contains 34 kilowatt-hours of energy in a package weighing six pounds. A lithium-ion battery storing the same energy weighs 250 pounds.
That density gap is why every military on earth runs on liquid hydrocarbons, why every container ship crossing the Pacific burns bunker fuel, why every combine harvester in Iowa runs on diesel, and why every 747 landing at Heathrow runs on kerosene. The fact that nobody wages war over solar panels is evidence of their limitations, not superiority.
Many respond by claiming that fossil fuels persist because of government subsidies and political favoritism. The IMF says global fossil fuel subsidies total $7 trillion. UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres cited that number when he called for eliminating “fossil fuel subsidies that distort markets and lock us into the past.”
But the $7 trillion figure is almost entirely fictional. The IMF’s own data show that only 18% of its subsidy estimate reflects actual government spending or undercharging for supply costs. The remaining 82% consists of what the IMF calls “implicit subsidies,” a theoretical construct that assigns a dollar value to the environmental and social costs of burning fossil fuels and then treats the failure to tax those costs as a subsidy.
By that logic, any product whose price does not reflect the full externalized cost of its production is “subsidized.”
The real problem is that the world overinvested in green energy and underinvested in oil and gas. Globally, the IEA’s World Energy Investment 2025 report documented that $2.2 trillion flowed to clean energy in 2025, exactly double the $1.1 trillion invested in oil, natural gas, and coal combined. In the U.S., federal tax expenditures for green energy end users in fiscal year 2025 alone totaled $57.9 billion.
That figure exceeds the aggregate of all federal fossil fuel tax expenditures over the 31-year period from 1994 to 2025, totaling $50.8 billion.
The oil and gas extraction sector generated $1.8 trillion in total U.S. revenues in 2024, meaning that the $3 billion in actual government support represents 0.17% of industry revenue, an economic rounding error.
Renewable energy hardware is overwhelmingly manufactured in China, creating a supply chain dependency that is more precarious than the oil dependency it purports to replace. China’s share of global polysilicon, ingot, and wafer production has reached approximately 95%. China controls 91% of rare earth processing and 94% of the permanent magnet production essential for wind turbines.
China dominates more than 75% of global solar cell and module manufacturing and is projected to control nearly 60% of all critical mineral refining by 2030. In 2025, Beijing weaponized this dominance, and bismuth prices surgednearly 500% overnight.
Had the world spent the past decade building the oil, gas, LNG, pipeline, and fertilizer infrastructure that engineers designed and companies proposed, the Hormuz crisis would still be a serious geopolitical event, but it would not threaten to cause a recession.
The Atlantic Coast Pipeline, a 600-mile natural gas line from West Virginia to North Carolina, saw its cost double from $4.5 billion to $8 billion during years of environmental litigation before Duke Energy and Dominion Energy cancelled it in July 2020. The Constitution Pipeline from Pennsylvania to New York died the same year.
The PennEast Pipeline won its case at the United States Supreme Court in 2021 and still could not get built because New Jersey refused to issue state permits. In Canada, TransCanada abandoned the $15.7 billion Energy East pipeline in 2017 after the National Energy Board required an unprecedented review of upstream and downstream emissions...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2038342152116376004
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, watch the full video, and read the rest of the article!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
DataRepublican (small r)
@DataRepublican
This thread draws heavily from @shellenberger 's explosive Substack below: www.public.news/p/compromised-congressional-commission
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The response to the 2022 energy crisis should have been to expand oil & gas production. Instead, @GavinNewsom tried to shut down the state's refineries, resulting in gasoline ~$2/gallon more expensive than the national average. Catastrophically irresponsible.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Gavin Newsom says Trump is to blame for California’s $5.86/gallon gasoline, but that’s nearly $2 higher than the national average. And it was mostly Newsom’s destruction of the state’s oil production and refining capacity that explains the difference.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Gavin Newsom says Trump is to blame for California’s $5.86/gallon gasoline, but that’s nearly $2 higher than the national average. And it was mostly Newsom’s destruction of the state’s oil production and refining capacity that explains the difference.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
President Donald Trump is responsible for California’s high gasoline prices, says Governor Gavin Newsom. “Americans will pay $1.5 BILLION MORE at the gas pump just this week because of Donald Trump’s war with Iran,” he wrote. When the Trump administration invoked the Defense Production Act to restart the Sable Offshore pipeline near Santa Barbara, Newsom condemned the move as a cynical attempt to exploit a crisis of the president’s own making.
“Donald Trump started a war, admitted it would spike gas prices nationwide, and told Americans it was a small price to pay,” Newsom said. “Now he’s using this crisis of his own making to attempt what he’s wanted to do for years: open California’s coast for his oil industry friends so they can poison our beaches.”
But California’s $5.86-per-gallon gasoline price exceeds the national average of $3.95 by nearly two dollars because Newsom has systematically dismantled the state’s energy supply infrastructure. Washington and Hawaii, the next most expensive, trail California by more than a dollar. Texas drivers pay $2.70. while leaving demand largely intact.
California imports roughly 63% of its crude oil from foreign countries, despite having at least 1.7 billion barrels of proven reserves. Its oil production fell by more than 75%, from over 1 million barrels per day in the 1980s to 246,000 barrels per day at the end of 2025.
California made itself into an energy island, isolated from the continent’s abundant oil and natural gas resources by regulatory choice rather than geographic necessity. Where California used to be one of America’s largest oil producers, most of the state’s crude now arrives by sea.
“Because Gulf Coast refiners can access domestic crude through pipelines,” notes Robert Rapier, “Persian Gulf barrels are not evenly spread across the country. A disproportionate share of those Saudi and Iraqi imports ends up in PADD 5, the West Coast refining district, precisely because California lacks pipeline access to Permian supply.” And California’s refineries aren’t set up to refine domestic crude but rather foreign imports.
California thus resembles Asian nations that lack domestic hydrocarbons and depend on seaborne imports through chokepoints, except that California sits atop a continent with the world’s largest combined oil and natural gas production. It has no major refined product pipeline connecting it to Texas or Louisiana. And it has been routing imported gasoline through the Bahamas to avoid the Jones Act’s requirement that goods shipped between U.S. ports travel on expensive American-flagged vessels...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2037981644976521496
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the full article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Big Tech's AI keeps getting caught delivering false, ideological, and defamatory information, notes @wynton_hall in his bestselling new book, Code Red. The reason is pervasive partisan bias and "Effective Altruism" dogma, which is detached from the West's moral foundations.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The companies building the world’s leading artificial intelligence systems say that their products are politically neutral. Google states that its AI will “seek to avoid unjust impacts on people, particularly those related to sensitive characteristics such as race, ethnicity, gender, nationality, income, sexual orientation, ability, and political or religious belief.” Anthropic, the maker of Claude, claims a 94% “even-handedness” rating for its latest model and says Claude’s goal is to “treat opposing political viewpoints equally.” And OpenAI, the creator of ChatGPT, declared that “ChatGPT shouldn’t have political bias in any direction,” and says its newest models have reduced political bias by 30%.
But their track record tells a different story. In February 2024, Google’s Gemini AI generated images of America’s Founding Fathers as black men and women, depicted racially diverse Nazi soldiers, and created images of a female Pope and Asian Vikings. When users asked Gemini to create images of white people, it refused. The system had been programmed to inject diversity language into prompts, so that a request for a picture of a German soldier in 1943 would produce, as NPR reported, images of nonwhite people in Nazi uniforms.
In response to the controversy, AI leaders took action. Google CEO Sundar Pichai called the results “completely unacceptable” and told employees that the company “got it wrong.” Google paused Gemini’s image generation, pledged structural changes, and promised to relaunch with better guardrails. AI leaders across the industry reasserted their commitment to neutrality. OpenAI published a new framework for evaluating political bias. Anthropic released its own even-handedness metrics.
But they did not correct the bias. Wynton Hall, a senior fellow at the Governmental Accountability Institute and author of the new bestselling book Code Red: The Left, the Right, China, and the Race to Control AI, recently conducted a study using Google Gemini’s most advanced reasoning model, Deep Research. He asked it to evaluate all 100 sitting U.S. senators against Google’s own hate speech policies. The result: seven Republican senators were flagged as violators. Zero Democrats. The AI also hallucinated that Marco Rubio and JD Vance were still senators rather than the Secretary of State and Vice President. The specific “hate speech” violations involved statements about immigration and transgender issues. Senators Tom Cotton, Marsha Blackburn, and Rick Scott all responded publicly.
Multiple peer-reviewed studies have confirmed that most large language models exhibit measurable left-leaning bias, and even liberal users say AI has a liberal bias. While this may seem obvious to many, it is puzzling in that the AI companies have shown themselves to be so sensitive to not being perceived as biased, as the 2024 Google Gemini controversy showed.
Last year, Meta’s AI chatbot falsely implicated conservative activist Robby Starbuck in the January 6 Capitol attack and labeled him a white nationalist, a Holocaust denier, and antisemitic. Starbuck said that Google’s Bard and Gemini chatbots generated at least 22 false statements about him, including fabricated accusations of sexual assault, rape, and a shooting, and even invented fake news articles attributed to real journalists to support the claims.
The implications are significant. AI systems already shape what billions of people see in search results, social media feeds, and news recommendations. As Hall documents, AI is being deployed in government procurement, defense, and education. If these systems treat conservative, libertarian, and traditionally religious viewpoints as forms of “hate speech,” the result will be a powerful and pervasive censorship apparatus, or worse. AI-generated reputation scoring will feed into insurance decisions, mortgage approvals, and even custody determinations.
For example, Starbuck said he received death threats, his children were doxxed, and he could no longer attend public events without security. Multiple insurance companies denied him homeowners, car, and other insurance, telling him only that they considered him a risk. Police arrested a man in Oregon who wanted to kill Starbuck.
Asked to comment on the current situation, Starbuck told Public, “People need to imagine how dangerous this is when AI chatbots are deployed to swing an election, changing the way a few percent of the population vote by convincing them that one candidate is a criminal. Our next president could effectively be decided by biased AI. This is one of the most critical issues of our generation.”
Why is AI still so biased toward the left and against the right?...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2037259708105728027
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of free speech, read the rest of the article, and watch the full interview!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Just a few years ago, millions took to the streets to demand action on climate change. But now, even though Trump eviscerated their agenda, they are oddly silent. It turns out that sustaining faith in the climate apocalypse required a constant stream of government funding.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Many scientists and members of the public believe “we are on the brink of an irreversible climate disaster” and that “much of the very fabric of life on Earth is imperiled.”
The UN Secretary General says climate change is a “time bomb” ticking toward detonation. Johan Rockström, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, warns that six of nine “planetary boundaries” have been transgressed and that humanity is approaching “irreversible tipping points.”
The World Economic Forum reports that climate change may cause an additional 14.5 million deaths by 2050, citing research suggesting one billion deaths are possible by 2100 if warming exceeds two degrees Celsius.
The public has received the message. A study of 10,000 people in 10 nations found that 56 percent said “humanity is doomed” and nearly half said climate change had negatively impacted their daily life.”
And yet the apocalypse described in these warnings bears little resemblance to the one revealed by the data.
In 2024, approximately 16,753 people died from natural disasters globally, well below the twenty-year average of 65,566, continuing a long-term decline of roughly 90 percent over the past century.
U.S. crop yields set records in 2024. Rockström’s planetary boundaries lack any objective biophysical threshold and instead reflect subjective political judgments about how much of nature humans should use.
A NASA-funded study found that between 25 and 50 percent of the world’s vegetated area has grown greener over the past four decades, with CO2 fertilization accounting for approximately 70 percent of the greening. Global warming projections have fallen from 3 to 3.5 degrees Celsius in 2015 to 2.6 degrees....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2036858336629412107
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the story, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Joe Kent says he is skeptical that Tyler Robinson, who confessed to killing Charlie Kirk, was the lone shooter. That accusation could undermine the prosecutors’ case against Robinson. Kent says he knew of the risk before he decided to speak out.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The former Director of the National Counterterrorism Center, Joe Kent, says that the FBI did not properly investigate the assassination last fall of conservative leader Charlie Kirk. “The FBI was pretty forceful in saying we couldn’t investigate further,” he told Public. “I saw no action being taken.”
Tyler Robinson confessed to killing Kirk in a text message and a note to his trans-identified romantic partner. His defense team may now be able to use Kent’s allegations that the government is suppressing evidence and did not do a proper investigation to their advantage.
Kent said he knew that he might be called as a witness before he made his statements that a “foreign nexus” may have been involved in Kirk’s assassination. “I was definitely warned of that over and over again,” said Kent. “If I end up having to play that role, then I’ll do it. It’s not something I’m seeking.”
When pressed that his testimony could help the Robinson defense, Kent said, “Then, honestly, so be it. If it gets us to the truth… That’s obviously the risk I’m taking.”
Neither Robinson’s attorneys nor the prosecuting attorney responded to requests for comment from Public.
x.com/shellenberger/status/2036462544819269728
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative reporting, read the full article, and hear the full, on-the-record interview:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“I’m not casting doubt on whether Tyler Robinson is innocent or guilty. I’m saying we were not allowed to examine any foreign links to the assassination of Charlie Kirk.” @joekent16jan19
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Defiant L’s
@DefiantLs
Michael Shellenberger: "I think free speech is hanging by a thread globally and that thread is Elon Musk… What's happening on X is the change of consciousness and… the establishment is desperate to either shut it down or censor it"
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Trump administration is downplaying the threat of foreign election interference, implied Sen. @MarkWarner. Highly unlikely. There's been little evidence of it for 10 years. Democrats keep hyping it because it's proved so useful in smearing and censoring their enemies.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
At Wednesday’s Senate Intelligence Committee hearing, Senator Mark Warner pressed Director of National Intelligence (DNI) Tulsi Gabbard on the fact that her 2026 Annual Threat Assessment contains no mention of foreign election interference for the first time since 2017.
Warner treated this as a scandal, evidence that the intelligence community has been muzzled by the Trump administration.
Gabbard deflected, saying the assessment “matches the prioritization of threats.” Warner shot back, sarcastically, “I would draw the conclusion there must be no foreign threat to our elections in 2026.”
It’s probably the right conclusion. The evidence for foreign interference in U.S. elections was always thin, the response to it was wildly disproportionate, and the infrastructure built to “counter” it did far more damage to American democracy than the interference itself ever did.
As I testified before the House Judiciary Subcommittee on the Weaponization of the Federal Government in March 2023, and again in November 2023, the “foreign interference” narrative became the predicate for a domestic censorship operation of extraordinary scope, one that Alex Gutentag and I have spent three years documenting at Public, and which we named the Censorship Industrial Complex.
Removing the topic from the threat assessment is a long-overdue correction. Gabbard should have said so plainly and directly....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2035054429842378905
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the story, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Energy prices are spiking and stocks are crashing because Iran bombed a massive liquefied natural gas (LNG) plant in Qatar. But the underlying problem has been decades of opposition from Democrats to natural gas, which led Biden to ban the construction of new LNG plants.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Stock markets around the world are crashing after the destruction of a single, massive liquefied natural gas (LNG) facility in Qatar by Iranian missiles last night. Shell’s Pearl GTL sat inside the larger Ras Laffan complex, which, before the war, produced roughly 20% of the world’s liquefied natural gas (LNG). It had taken four years, from 2007 to 2011, to build. Its loss will mean a long-term shortage of LNG.
Europe’s LNG prices rose 35% since the attack and by more than 100%, from €32 euros per MWh to over €70 today, since last month. Asia was already returning to coal before the loss of the Pearl GTL facility, and will burn more of it now that LNG is being priced out of reach of poor nations.
Already, Qatar’s North Field expansion had been delayed to mid-2027. With the rebuild of Pearl GTL expected to take three to five years, that expansion timeline slips further.
But the underlying reason for this crisis is a lack of LNG plants. We didn’t need more natural gas infrastructure, said the media, Democrats, and climate advocates, over the last 15 years. Every new LNG terminal was, they said, a “climate bomb.”
Groups including Reclaim Finance, Rainforest Action Network, Bill McKibben’s 350.org, and Greenpeace waged a coordinated campaign to cut off financing for LNG terminals. They staged die-ins outside Bank of America. They cut up credit cards at Chase branches. They captured $130 trillion into the Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero. They published annual scorecards shaming any bank that lent to LNG developers.
The divestment movement boasted that $39.2 trillion in capital had been “blocked” from fossil fuels. The groups succeeded beyond their wildest dreams. Biden paused new LNG export approvals in January 2024 under direct pressure from climate groups. Investors have underinvested in LNG ever since.
x.com/shellenberger/status/2034689532411392360
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning reporting, read the rest of the article, and watch the rest of the video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Thomas Fazi
@battleforeurope
So, as expected, the European Commission has finally activated the Digital Services Act’s (DSA) “rapid response system” in the context of the upcoming Hungarian elections, which gives EU-funded “fact-checkers” and “NGOs” a veto over online speech in Hungary.
This is a serious escalation in the EU’s interference in the Hungarian elections. The official explanation is that this is needed to combat “Russian interference”. But as I noted in a recent article for @compactmag, no evidence whatsoever has been produced to support this claim.
The narrative almost exclusively relies on an “investigation” by journalists at the Warsaw-based nonprofit VSquare, which claims that Putin has instructed a group of political strategists and Russian military intelligence to interfere in the parliamentary elections in Hungary in April in order to ensure that Orbán wins.
And what is the evidentiary basis for this extraordinary claim? It boils down to this (literally): “Multiple European national security sources have told me.” In other words, no evidence whatsoever is provided. We are simply asked to trust the “investigative journalists” in question. One might be inclined to extend that trust if the outlet in question were genuinely independent. Regrettably, it is not.
A glance at VSquare’s donor list reveals it to be less an independent journalistic outfit than a textbook example of artificial civil society, funded by entities like the National Endowment for Democracy (NED), USAID, the German Marshall Fund of the United States, and various EU-funded consortia. In other words, VSquare is part and parcel of the “color revolution” infrastructure that, for decades, has sought to bring Central and Eastern Europe in line with the agenda of Brussels and Washington.
It’s clear what is happening: they’re applying the Russiagate script that was previously used to subvert the elections in Romania just over a year ago. The aim is twofold. Ideally, tilt the elections in favour of the pro-EU, pro-war opposition candidate Péter Magyar by using the DSA to influence the pre-election online narrative. It’s well-known that the the EU’s “rapid response system” enables approved third parties — the aforementioned EU-funded “fact-checkers” and “NGOs” — to submit priority content moderation requests that disproportionately affect “populist” or EU/NATO-critical actors.
If this doesn’t work — and it’s unlikely to work in the Hungarian context — then the allegations of Russian interference serve the purpose of laying the groundwork to delegitimise the result if Orbán wins, by seeding seeding a story of “stolen” or “unfair” elections. This is incredibly dangerous, and is yet another confirmation that the very institutions invoking the threat of foreign interference to justify their intervention are themselves the most consequential foreign actors in Hungary’s election.
Read the full article here: www.compactmag.com/article/russiagate-redux-in-hungary/ -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
60 Minutes
@60Minutes
“This is a massive CIA cover-up,” says former CIA intelligence officer Marc Polymeropoulos.
He says in 2017, he suffered a mysterious brain injury known as Havana Syndrome. He was treated for vertigo, migraines, loss of vision, and trouble with memory and concentration. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
People disagree on what the anomalous phenomena are, but now that Trump has ordered declassification of UAP/UFO files, there's no disagreeing that the government lied about its interest in them and has been hiding what it knows. @theblackvault on what to expect from them.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
President Donald Trump last month directed the Pentagon and other federal agencies to identify and release government records regarding “alien and extraterrestrial life, unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP), and unidentified flying objects (UFOs), and any and all other information connected to these highly complex, but extremely interesting and important, matters.”
The announcement comes after decades in which government agencies said they were no longer studying the phenomenon.
“They were lying,” said John Greenewald, who has been requesting government documents on UFOs since the 1990s through the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), in a new podcast. “It doesn’t matter if you’re a skeptic, a believer, or like us, somewhere in between. They were lying about their interest in UFOs after the 1969 closure of Project Blue Book. The Department of Defense, the NSA, the CIA, the DIA — they don’t want you to know the truth.”
Project Blue Book was the Air Force’s public investigation of reports of UFOs. It ran from 1952 to 1969, but its origins date back to 1947, when Lt. General Nathan Twining, tasked with investigating the subject, sent a secret memo to the head of the Army Air Forces stating, “The phenomenon reported is something real and not visionary or fictitious.”
Greenewald filed FOIA requests with the Navy for all photographs designated as UAP in its holdings. The Navy acknowledged possessing 78 such photographs. It released none of them. In an appeal decided just days before our conversation, the Navy reaffirmed that 100 percent of the imagery is classified.
“They can do it if they want to,” Greenewald said. “You go back decades from these sensitive platforms over war zones that are releasing this imagery, redacting or blurring the sensitive coordinates or whatever heads up display information that they don’t want out there. You can easily redact or blur. It’s 2026. We can do that and do it relatively quickly and shield all that sensitive information.”
He points to a video released by the Pentagon of a Russian jet spraying fuel on a US drone, a classified platform. Drone footage of strikes on Iranian targets, drug trafficking boats, and other military operations flows to the public regularly from sensitive platforms. “It is absolutely topic-specific on their cover-up of this information,” he said. “And then the question is, why is that?”
The three famous UAP videos known as FLIR, Gimbal, and Go Fast were eventually released, partly because Greenewald’s FOIA requests forced the Navy to acknowledge that it considered them unclassified. Internal emails obtained through FOIA showed that his specific case number created the bind. The Navy then proactively released the videos and responded to his request the same day.
When Greenewald requested all additional UAP videos beyond those three, the Navy responded that 100 percent of the remaining videos are classified. “You’ve already admitted that three UAP videos were unclassified and you finally released those. Now you’re claiming that 100 percent of the rest are all classified. That part didn’t make sense.”
Among the most striking documents Greenewald has obtained is a briefing document from the UAP Task Force. The document lists potential explanations for UAP encounters. Some are visible. “Unknown weather or other natural phenomena” appears as one possibility. But the first and third potential explanations are blacked out....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2030740407525781835
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning reporting, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We suspected Epstein ran a sex blackmail operation for the Intelligence Community, but the newly released files strongly suggest he worked for himself. If he was a slave to anything, it was to his perversions. New deep dive by @GalexyBrane and me.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Since 2019, many in mainstream and alternative media, including Public, have speculated about financier Jeffrey Epstein’s apparent links to the intelligence community (IC), particularly Mossad and the CIA, his alleged involvement in sexual blackmail, and the mysterious circumstances surrounding his death. The picture that emerged for many of us was of Epstein filming powerful men in compromising situations with underage girls, for the purpose of collecting kompromat at the behest of a foreign or domestic intelligence agency.
Several key pieces of evidence stood out. One of Epstein’s early clients was Adnan Khashoggi, a Saudi arms dealer who brokered arms shipments from Israel to Iran during the CIA’s illegal Iran-Contra scandal. The father of Epstein’s partner, Ghislaine Maxwell, was Robert Maxwell, who some believe was a “superspy” for Israel. Epstein met twice with former CIA Director William Burns and tried to meet with former CIA Director John Brennan.
Journalist Vicky Ward once claimed that Alex Acosta, then a federal prosecutor, let Epstein off easy with a 2007 federal non-prosecution agreement because he was told Epstein “belonged to intelligence” and was “above [his] paygrade.” Newly released files show Epstein requested his CIA file.
The files also show he sent an email to himself, apparently in the voice of Bill Gates advisor Boris Nikolic, describing Gates’ philandering and STD, and alleging that he secretly gave his wife antibiotics. Epstein had many photos and videos of powerful men with young women. There are emails of Epstein ordering hidden motion-detection cameras be placed in Kleenex boxes. And the newly released files show UK Labour politician Peter Mandelson, the former UK ambassador to the US, in his underwear.
But after having spent several weeks reading through the files and related investigations, it’s clear to us that the totality of available evidence does not support the picture of a government-backed sex blackmail operation. Rather, it suggests that Epstein primarily served his own interests. If Epstein was a slave to anything, it was to his passions and perversions. Ward’s claim that Epstein “belonged to intelligence” is not reliable. She said she heard it third-hand from an anonymous source. Her former Vanity Fair editor and colleagues told the New Yorker that her reporting was not trusted, and said that she had provided inaccurate quotations in the past.
Epstein may have worked for governments as a deal “fixer” or financial advisor with a unique ability to win and maintain trust while overseeing complex legal schemes. But that does not mean a government controlled what he did. There is not sufficient evidence to claim that his sexual exploitation of girls and women was forthe CIA or for Israeli intelligence. Epstein’s request for his CIA file does not prove he had a relationship with the agency at the time; if he did, he would not have needed to make such a request. Nor did his two meetings with Burns, who was then at the State Department, prove that Epstein worked for the IC. There is no currently available evidence that Epstein met with Brennan. As for Robert Maxwell, he vehemently denied working for Mossad, and it’s not necessarily the case that his connections to Israeli intelligence would implicate Epstein.
Epstein’s emails about camera installation, and his email concerning compromising information about Gates, suggest, if anything, amateur methods, not a sophisticated intelligence operation. If Epstein was secretly filming his guests having sex, it could have been to fulfill his large appetite for pornography, or he could have been photographing them to simply gain leverage for his own purposes. And if any of what Epstein did was truly for the IC, then his emailing of a consultant to put cameras in Kleenex boxes would be far below the IC’s standards for operational security. And it’s not the case that Epstein’s photos all imply sexual blackmail. Epstein’s photo of Mandelson standing in his underwear next to a woman, for instance, is unlikely to be sexual kompromat because Mandelson is openly gay.
Finally, there is insufficient evidence, at this time, to determine that someone killed Epstein. On the one hand, questions about the video footage remain unanswered. A US attorney in the Eastern District of New York emailed another attorney in 2020, referring to an “investigation into the murder of Jeffrey Epstein.” On the other hand, Epstein had tried to kill himself 18 days before his death, and signed his will two days before. His neck fractures were consistent with suicidal hanging, particularly for older individuals. And the email didn’t say Epstein was murdered, it simply acknowledged that there was, indeed, an Office of the Inspector General investigation into whether Epstein’s death was a homicide.
To be sure, the Epstein Files have exposed misconduct, and future files may further complicate the picture. British police arrested former Prince Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor last week for sharing confidential government trade documents with Epstein, and arrested Mandelson earlier this week, apparently on suspicion that he leaked government secrets to Epstein. The files show that Kathryn Ruemmler, former White House counsel for President Barack Obama, volunteered to Epstein the fact that she had won the CIA’s highest award, which was confidential.
And there is still evidence missing. There are 2.5 to 3 million pages from the Epstein files that the DOJ has not released. The DOJ has withheld or heavily redacted approximately 200,000 pages under the “deliberative process privilege,” “attorney-client privilege,” or the “work-product doctrine.” And the Telegraph reported that more Epstein Files may be stored at various sites around the U.S. As such, new evidence may come to light, and we will be sure to report on any of it that suggests Epstein was running a sex blackmail operation for the IC.
But the weight of the currently available evidence suggests Epstein was the puppet master, not the puppet. Epstein’s emails reveal him to be an extraordinarily gifted manipulator. He put himself at the service of helping powerful people meet their social, sexual, financial, career, intellectual, and other needs. Epstein helped former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak transition to civilian life in exchange for access to selling cybersecurity to the Israeli government; there is no evidence of any Mossad influence in the exchange. Epstein arranged for Ruemmler to use her knowledge and relationships at the Department of Justice to settle a case brought against Ariane de Rothschild. There is no evidence that the CIA controlled Epstein through Ruemmler. And Epstein charged Rothschild $25 million for his services and $10 million for Ruemmler’s.
Epstein’s pattern of sexual abuse and coercion seems to have been in service of his own desires. In 2007, Epstein was charged with abusing teenage girls, recruiting them under the guise of giving him “massages.” He served 13 months in prison, during which he received a work release. Epstein’s co-conspirators were employees and associates, such as Ghislaine Maxwell, who found girls for him, promised them gifts and favors, and arranged “massage” sessions. Epstein also manipulated young womenfrom Eastern Europe by offering them modeling opportunities before pressuring them to participate in sex acts. Jean-Luc Brunel, a French modelling agent, helped recruit young models for Epstein. After an investigation, Brunel was charged in France with sexual assault, including of minors, stemming from complaints about acts independent of Epstein. He killed himself in prison in 2022.
It appears that if Epstein passed women along to other men, it was to create a sense of both friendship and obligation among those men toward him. But sex was not his only means of winning loyalty. Through various means, Epstein cultivated relationships with powerful individuals with an eye to gaining information useful for his investments. Mandelson, for example, informed Epstein the night before it was announced that Europe was about to bail out Greece, which would have meant a certain rise in the stock market the next day; there is evidence that Epstein sent moneyto Mandelson’s then-boyfriend and now-husband. It appears that Epstein encouraged a young woman to date New York Giants owner Steve Tisch for the same reason he counseled Larry Summers on how to hit on a Chinese economist: to establish himself as someone trustworthy and capable of helping them get what they wanted, and as someone to whom they were indebted.
If Epstein indeed worked for American and/or Israeli intelligence over the decades, it was likely as someone skilled at hiding and sheltering money, which is much of what he appeared to do for his other clients, and which was the reason he lived in the Virgin Islands, a notorious tax haven. Epstein would thus have been a contractor and not fundamentally important to what those agencies do and don’t do. There is no evidence that Epstein’s sexual activities and crimes were connected to any government.
The Files suggest that people loved Epstein and called him a “best friend” because he was skilled at helping them, including by giving them advice they trusted was in their interest. He got some of the world’s greatest minds and professionals to believe he genuinely cared about them as individuals, even though he seemed to care only for himself.
Some high-profile victims have alleged a sexual blackmail scheme, but there are reasons to question their accounts. Virginia Giuffre claimed for years that Alan Dershowitz had repeatedly raped her when she was a minor, but she retracted her allegation in 2022, saying, “I may have made a mistake.” Another victim, Maria Farmer, said in 2020, “It’s just unfortunate that all the Jewish people I met also happen to be pedophiles that run the world economy, you know. So it gives a bad taste in your mouth.”
Given all this, neither we nor anyone else should have been persuaded that Epstein ran a government-backed sex blackmail operation. We remain open to new evidence, and we believe important questions remain, such as why Epstein had hidden cameras, why he sent himself that email about Gates, and what exactly Epstein did with Khasshogi and others with ties to the IC.
But the picture that emerges from the Epstein Files is different from what we had imagined. Though we did not write many pieces on Epstein, our Corrections Policy requires us not only to correct the error but also to share the lessons learned.
Why did we see evidence of a sexual blackmail operation when we should have seen, at the very least, insufficient evidence to make a judgment and, at the very most, evidence of Epstein as a master manipulator? And why are others, on both the left and right, still inclined to see something in Epstein that isn’t based on the evidence?
Chaos, Corruption, and Motivated Reasoning
Sidney Gottlieb (right) led the CIA’s MKULTRA program. (Getty)
In June 2019, a few months before Epstein’s death, the journalist Tom O’Neill published Chaos: Charles Manson, the CIA, and the Secret History of the Sixties. The book documented links between Manson, whose cult in 1969 killed at least nine people, and the CIA programs MKULtra and CHAOS. It told the story of Operation Midnight Climax, a sub-project of MKUltra that used government-hired sex workers to lure men to CIA safehouses in San Francisco and New York. The CIA secretly dosed the men with LSD and observed them through two-way mirrors to study the drug’s effects.
There are more recent cases of the IC using honeypots. In 2015, the FBI seized the illegal dark web child exploitation site, Playpen, and instead of shutting it down immediately, ran it from government servers for weeks. From 2018 to 2021, the FBI ran Operation Trojan Shield to covertly manage an encrypted messaging app called ANOM. The FBI marketed it exclusively to organized crime syndicates. Believing it was secure, criminals used it to openly discuss drug trafficking and assassinations, effectively handing their entire operational playbook directly to the FBI. And it is well established that the IC uses cyber honeypots, which look like critical US infrastructure or sensitive databases, to monitor how Chinese and other groups attack them.
Independent investigators have traced connections between Epstein and the IC. Mike Benz argues that Epstein played a role in covert money laundering and in hiding transactions for the CIA, which might also explain his rapid rise in wealth. Epstein worked at Bear Stearns and processed funds for the CIA-created Bank of Credit and Commerce International (BCCI). The CIA used BCCI for off-books operations after Congress curtailed direct agency funding for such operations after the Church Committee hearings of 1975. Drop Site News has documented deals facilitated by Epstein with the help of Barak to sell Israeli surveillance and security technology to Côte D’Ivoire, Mongolia, and others.
These connections have great significance for the two of us. Since 2023, we have been alert to abuses of IC power due to our work documenting the weaponization of intelligence agencies and their proxies for both censorship and lawfare. We were predisposed and motivated to see a broader conspiracy run by the IC.
Where we did our own research on censorship and lawfare, when discussing Epstein, we relied too heavily on secondary sources. These sources included both alternative ones, like Whitney Webb’s two-volume One Nation Under Blackmail, and mainstream or left-leaning ones, like the Miami Herald and the Daily Beast, which, in our minds, helped legitimate the alternative ones.
It wasn’t so much that the facts in those sources were all wrong as that they were exaggerated and arranged to create a misleading narrative. Motivated to see a broader IC conspiracy and still deferential to mainstream sources, we repeated Ward’s claim, for example, that Acosta said “Epstein belonged to intelligence.” Had we scrutinized this seemingly damning (and highly quotable) proof, we would have noted that she heard it third-hand from an unnamed source, and many distrusted her fact-checking and reporting.
Perceiving Epstein’s death as a murder rather than as a suicide further increased our suspicion of a wider governmental conspiracy. We weren’t alone in doing this. Shortly after Epstein’s death, both then-President Trump and then-mayor of New York City Bill de Blasio speculated that someone killed him. “It’s just too convenient,” said de Blasio. Former Mayor Rudy Giuliani, about Epstein allegedly hanging himself, said, “That’s pretty hard to do.” But the evidence was and is far from clear that it was a homicide.
During a chaotic time of eroding trust in institutions, the story of Epstein as a puppet for shadowy deep state agencies and creepy elites seemed plausible.
Another reason we were inclined to believe that something larger and more sophisticated was at play was for the simple reason that we had never reported on anyone quite like Epstein. His ability to attract people to him and win their trust is comparable to that of past cult leaders. In the Bay Area in the 1970s, for instance, the highly charismatic left-wing preacher, Jim Jones, sexually preyed upon his vulnerable congregants. At the same time, he charmed and even captivated societal elites, including leading Democratic Party politicians, by meeting their needs for money, voters, and sex. Epstein, similarly, operated at the highest levels of elite society, winning the admiration, trust, and even love of highly intelligent people.
Finally, like many others, we feel a deep sense of betrayal by our ruling class, which some have now nicknamed the “Epstein Class.” During a chaotic time of eroding trust in institutions, the story of Epstein as a puppet for shadowy deep state agencies and creepy elites seemed plausible.
Others appear attracted to the Epstein story for different reasons. For many on the left, Epstein provided a way to attack Trump as an abuser of women. The idea that Acosta, Trump’s pick for Secretary of Labor in 2017, had helped cover up Epstein’s crimes strengthened this narrative. At the same time, Epstein fit conveniently into right-wing theories like “pizzagate,” which imagined that political elites like Hilary Clinton were engaged in child sexual abuse, trafficking, and cannibalism. These theories mirrored the Satanic Panic of the 1980s, in which discredited therapy techniques generated a series of false claims about pedophilic abuse at daycares.
Anger toward and hatred of Israel and Jewish people appear to motivate some who see a broader conspiracy. Epstein’s real connections to Barak, wealthy Jewish businessmen, and Jewish intellectuals are potent ammunition for the theory that the state of Israel, or Jews in general, secretly control the US government through extortion.
For others, Epstein provided an easy way to understand complex problems about sex and power. Part of the reason that people trusted for their good judgment, such as Ruemmler, saw nothing wrong in what Epstein was doing is that we have a sexually libertarian culture. Ruemmler even joked about Epstein’s massages, suggesting she knew they had a sexual element.
Liberal and worldly people like Ruemmler accept that powerful men like Epstein are promiscuous. One hundred and fifty people signed his 50th birthday book, with many making comments that suggested they viewed Epstein’s promiscuity as benign. “There was nothing unusual about Epstein’s perversions,” writes Kathleen Stock in UnHerd.“He just had the means to indulge them to the max.”
And even if Epstein’s friends and colleagues knew he was hiring prostitutes, it’s not at all clear that they would have objected. “Grooming, pimping out, coercive control, sexual exploitation, an insatiable appetite for extreme youth and novelty: all fall under the respectability cover of ‘sex work,’” notes Stock. Liberal cosmopolitans know that rich and powerful men routinely hire high-priced “escorts” with little fear of arrest or prosecution.
And most of the women hanging around Epstein after 2008 were not officially escorts or prostitutes. Many were aspiring models and actresses who were given gifts and opportunities. It is thus unsurprising that few around Epstein believed his conduct violated either the law or social norms.
Moral Panic
James E. Staley, former JPMorgan executive; former Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers; Epstein; Bill Gates; and Boris Nikolic, former adviser to the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (Department of Justice)
Traditional sexual norms once served to shield vulnerable women against widespread exploitation, and their disappearance results in periodic hysterias. The collapse of traditional religion and morality has made it more difficult to identify and guard against the kind of predatory behavior Epstein exhibited, because much of this behavior is normalized. “The Epstein panic, like so many moral panics, arises from an intuition that something is amiss in our libertarian sexual settlement,” notes Julia Yost. And the movement, and its demand that we “believe women,” made it taboo to challenge the inconsistencies of accusers. In the Epstein case, the right followed the left’s tendency to treat alleged victims as above scrutiny, even after they are caught defaming an innocent person, as Giuffre was with Dershowitz.
Unfortunately, the heightened emotions of a moral panic make it impossible to properly understand Epstein. Online, people routinely accuse the most prominent critic of Epstein hysteria, Michael Tracey, of defending pedophilia. Just as Giuffre and Farmer must be above reproach, Epstein must be below understanding. Trying to understand him is, for many, tantamount to defending him.
But not understanding Epstein’s genius for manipulation undermines our ability to protect ourselves from others like him. His high overall intelligence, including emotional intelligence, made him magnetic. And, like other cult leaders, there is something indefinable about him that gave him a charisma difficult to appreciate before the publication of the files....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2027085260278972836
Please subscribe now to read the rest of the story. Link below:This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
John Greenewald, Jr.
@theblackvault
Dear @SecWar @PeteHegseth,
Your Department of War will not disclose multiple names that were invited to a closed door, embargoed, invite only, media roundtable to discuss the UAP issue.
The freedom of the press should include the ability to cover this issue fairly and openly, and have the ability to ask questions as they do in normal, open, press conferences. With the UAP issue, this is not the case.
There should be a concern by you, as there is one with we the people, that the messaging from your department on the UAP issue is highly controlled, with information only funneled to a select few journalists that disseminate information - and we all are forced to trust a select few. This is not against them or a belief they are not doing their job correctly or fairly. But rather, this is against that secrecy that strategically omits the vast majority of the press pool, and selects only a few to cover the issue with a controlled message behind closed doors.
Open this topic up to everyone who is wanting to cover the issue.
cc: @RepLuna @timburchett @KristinFisher @JaredEMoskowitz -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
Michael Roth, Wesleyan’s president, wrote a letter to the Chronicle critiquing my recent Mellon piece and Chronicle interview. He compares me to Jesse Helms, the infamous Republican segregationist and lifelong racist. The Chronicle kindly asked for my response. Here’s part of it.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Batya Ungar-Sargon
@bungarsargon
How the New York Times covers a traitor winning medals for our greatest adversary
vs.
How the New York Times covers our boys winning medals for the glory of the U.S.
Just appalling beyond belief. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
John Greenewald, Jr.
@theblackvault
Dear President @BarackObama,
In March 2022, I discovered your Presidential library has 3,400+ pages and 26,000+ digital files on UFOs and related programs, but it will take 16 YEARS to process, according to them.
In the interest of transparency, and in light of your recent comments about aliens/UFOs, can you, maybe, give them a nudge? -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
John Greenewald, Jr.
@theblackvault
Dear @SecWar @PeteHegseth,
One document to begin your UAP transparency push is to fully declassify this one. Located at the U.S. Navy, Naval Intelligence Activity, and released to me first via DON-NAVY-2021-008741 in October 2024, and later shown during a Congressional hearing by Mr. Michael @shellenberger, is this UAP Task Force briefing document.
The classification: Redacted.
Potential explanations for UAP: 2/3 Redacted.
Imagery of UAP: Redacted
Most details: Redacted
No need to wait long. It's 12 pages, and can be done quickly but would go a long way towards transparency on this issue. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Tommy Chiang
@hotepterracotta
I will say that @shellenberger was the first person to tell the world on the JRE podcast that Gavin didn't read.
Kevin Dalton
@TheKevinDalton
Why does Gavin Newsom‘s literacy seem to be audience dependent?
Gavin Newsom: I can’t read.
Also Gavin Newsom: I read your 260 page book in less than two hours. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The release of the Epstein Files was laudatory, but many of the subsequent cancellations have been unjust. It's time to end the #metoo Part II witch hunt.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Editorial
by @Shellenberger and @galexybrane
The release of the Epstein Files by the US Department of Justice is a historically significant act. The files offer an extraordinary glimpse into the degraded morality of our governing elites.
At the same time, the Files have brought with them a #metoo Part II moral panic and witch hunt that is resulting in unjust cancellations. The most recent Epstein cancellation was a few hours ago of the influential medical doctor Peter Attia, who resigned from his position as a CBS News contributor. Others include former Obama White Counsel Kathryn Ruemmler, Thomas Pritzker, Sarah Ferguson, Brad Karp, Larry Summers, Lee Smolin, Miroslav Lajčák, George J. Mitchell, David A. Ross, Joanna Rubinstein, and Casey Wasserman.
While many might view the behavior and comments of those individuals as ugly, nothing has yet emerged to suggest they did anything sufficiently wrong or criminal to merit losing their jobs. There is no clear evidence to conclude that any of them were complicit in Epstein’s crimes.
This is not a defense of anything any of those individuals said in their correspondence with Epstein, nor a dismissal of law-breaking. There are cases, including those of former Prince Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor, who police arrested Friday, and Peter Mandelson, who police arrested today, that may have involved disclosing secret financial information to Epstein. The same may be true for Thorbjørn Jagland, Mona Juul, Terje Rød-Larsen, and Jack Lang. And if new evidence emerges that suggests real criminal guilt for others, we will update this piece.
But as of today it appears that these are mostly cases where people are losing their jobs, being forced to step down, or facing severe reputational damage simply because they knew and corresponded with Epstein. Many people did not know the details of Epstein’s crimes until a 2018 Miami Herald article series brought attention to them. Epstein was charismatic and manipulative, and his friends likely believed his version of events.
The argument that any communication with Epstein was equivalent to condoning predatory behavior sets a troubling precedent. We have a criminal justice system to decide guilt and innocence and mete out the appropriate punishment precisely so that we need not live under rule by the mob.
The witch hunt currently underway is similar to the excesses of the #metoo era. In one case, people falsely accused a professor at UCLA of pedophilia because he emailed Epstein a study that found “a newborn will suck on a pacifier more vigorously” when it hears its mother’s voice. But the email was not sexual. The study was relevant to the professor’s research into the effects of music on premature babies. The professor had been introduced to Epstein by Harvard’s Provost and had no knowledge of Epstein’s 2008 conviction.
Consider the demand last week by NBC Sports columnist Mike Florio for the NFL to investigate “whether [New York Jets owner Steve] Tisch engaged in quid pro quo sexual harassment” in a case unrelated to Epstein but inspired by Epstein appearing to encourage a young woman to date Tisch....
x.com/shellenberger/status/2026067313255137526
Editorial continues below for subscribers only.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Office of the DNI
@ODNIgov
On Day One of his presidency, @POTUS promised to deliver accountability through transparency by declassifying long-withheld government secrets and evidence of wrongdoing to restore trust in our federal agencies.
Half a million documents declassified in year one alone.
-JFK
-RFK
-MLK
-Amelia Earhart
-Russia hoax
-Weaponization
And soon, files related to alien and extraterrestrial life, UAPs, and UFOs.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Take a close look at this document. Everything you need to know about UAPs (UFOs) you can learn from it. It's a slide from a presentation by the Pentagon's UAP Task Force.
You might wonder what we can learn from a document that is so heavily censored, or redacted. That's exactly my point: the government is censoring everything we need to know about UAPs.
It's reasonable to support government secrecy. I support secrecy when it's necessary to protect national security.
But the censorship of this document, and many others like it, goes far beyond what is reasonable.
For example, the slide censors two of the three potential explanations for UAPs. Those two explanations are likely a) adversarial technology (e.g. from China) and b) nonhuman intelligence (NHI).
Are we to believe that the @DeptofWar really believes there is some threat to national security if the public were to learn our government is considering the possibility that UAP may be Chinese or NHI?
The idea that it would be dangerous for people to learn that officials within our government think UAPs might represent NHI is absurd.
Dozens of high-ranking current and former government officials have said exactly this. Many are currently in a bestselling documentary on Amazon Prime, @ageofdisclosure.
For nearly 75 years, the government has, supposedly, held grave concern that public interest in UAPs would cause some harm, such as revealing state secrets, triggering a public panic, or overloading the IC. None of those concerns have come to pass.
Since 2017, people have leaked multiple UAP videos and photos to the public, which reveal or heavily imply specific sources and methods. But does anyone believe they have undermined national security? Of course not. Nobody with any credibility has even made this argument.
Privately, many people within the IC acknowledge that the censorship is excessive. But they have not ended the censorship nor explained why they are maintaining the secrecy.
On Tuesday, Secretary of State and National Security Advisor @marcorubio told @seanhannity that he can't verify the claims of the high-ranking individuals in @ageofdisclosure.
That was a surprising and important revelation given that, as National Security Advisor and Secretary of State, Rubio has unparalleled access to Special Access Program briefings, compartmented intelligence, and interagency assessments comprised of top-secret and classified information.
Hannity did not ask Rubio why it was that he couldn't verify the claims made by individuals with very high security clearances, but the reason doesn't very much matter.
What matters is that Rubio has made it clear that it is up to President @realDonaldTrump, not Rubio, to end the censorship and declassify UAP documents.
President Trump, to his great credit, declassified and released JFK files, the classified Durham annex, and the HPSCI report. He should now do the same thing with the UAP Files.
Care should be taken to both protect national security and prevent unelected bureaucrats from abusing their power to maintain censorship.
If and when the IC decides which redactions to maintain, senior officials with experience on these matter should be in the room to objectively evaluate what is reasonably necessary for national security and what is unreasonable, particularly consider the signficiant quantity of leaks of videos and images to date.
Obviously, simply lifting these redactions won't be enough. The government should also release other UAP videos, photos, images, documents. But lifting the redactions on the @theblackvault UAP documents would be a concrete, good faith start to greater transparency.
If the Trump administration is unwilling to do so, then it must explain why that is.
There is a lot of noise in this space. People on both sides claim to know with great certainty the truth about UAPs. I am skeptical they know. My position remains what it was when I testified before Congress, which is that I don't know.
What I do know for certain is that the government is censoring and covering up information cannot be justified by national security.
If you think this all a bunch of B.S., then you should be the first to demand transparency. If you think this is all B.S. and you want to maintain the censorship and secrecy then you are a bad faith actor.
From now on, if you want to know who is operating in good faith, just ask them whether or not they support ending UAP censorship.
If they start insulting and ridiculing people, or engaging in other unethical, irrational, and illegitimate forms of debate, you'll know they are operating in bad faith.
If you think UAPs are NHI, then please consider focusing your energy and efforts on ending the censorship, rather than trying to convince people of your views based on the limited information we have, or speculating without evidence.
I don't know about you, but I don't think the world needs a lot more speculation, even by high-ranking officials, about what is going on.
What we need, and what the Constitution requires, is government transparency. The public and Congress are strongly united behind the cause of ending excess censorship and secrecy on UAPs and much else.
There are a lot of issues that divide us. I have never testified on an issue where there was more bipartisan unity than on this one. I am glad to see, in just the last few days, a growing number of UAP skeptics openly endorsing the need to end the censorship.
So take a close look at this document, and the other censored UAP documents. They have, to date, been obstacles to getting at the truth about UAPs. They are now an opportunity for President Trump to fulfill his duties to representing the public's interest against whoever it is that is undermining it.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Marco Rubio says he has no "way to verify” the “spectacular claims” made by “people with high clearances.” But if the Nat. Sec. Advisor lacks access to classified intel, and cannot tell if officials are lying, then it's up to Trump to reveal what the government knows about UAP.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This level of censorship is absurd and cannot be justified as necessary for national security. Indeed, nobody has even tried to justify it.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Good question
Ross Douthat
@Douthat60
Is the Department of Energy on the list of "relevant" agencies?
The White House
@WhiteHouse
"Based on the tremendous interest shown, I will be directing the Secretary of War, and other relevant Departments and Agencies, to begin the process of identifying and releasing Government files related to alien and extraterrestrial life, unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP), and unidentified flying objects (UFOs)..." - President Donald J. Trump
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Another good question
Marik vR
@MvonRen
WHY HAS AARO GONE DARK?
-Vol. II of a congressionally mandated report on government involvement with UAP is now 600+ days (almost two years!) late, an extraordinary violation of the law
-No 2025 annual report (another violation)
-Not a peep after the Syria and Yemen UAP videos -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
John Greenewald, Jr.
@theblackvault
Dear Secretary @PeteHegseth @SecWar,
I’ve investigated records originating from your agency for decades. I have documented proof going back many years, with citable FOIA case numbers, that should show you exactly where to look for highly classified UAP records withheld from the American people to this day.
I’d love to help.
John -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Jared Moskowitz
@JaredEMoskowitz
It’s time for disclosure!
White House Press Office
@PressSec
🚨OUT OF THIS WORLD NEWS from President Trump… 👽
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ross Douthat
@Douthat60
Is the Department of Energy on the list of "relevant" agencies?
The White House
@WhiteHouse
"Based on the tremendous interest shown, I will be directing the Secretary of War, and other relevant Departments and Agencies, to begin the process of identifying and releasing Government files related to alien and extraterrestrial life, unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP), and unidentified flying objects (UFOs)..." - President Donald J. Trump
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
The White House
@WhiteHouse
"Based on the tremendous interest shown, I will be directing the Secretary of War, and other relevant Departments and Agencies, to begin the process of identifying and releasing Government files related to alien and extraterrestrial life, unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP), and unidentified flying objects (UFOs)..." - President Donald J. Trump
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Adam Goldsack
@AdamGoldsack
Where is the full 4 minute video of Gimbal?
Where is the full GoFast video?
What is the relationship between the two?
Where is the unredacted case reports?
What did the pilots report?
Where did this object come from on radar - where did it go?
Why?
@shellenberger -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This level of censorship is absurd and cannot be justified as necessary for national security. Indeed, nobody has even tried to justify it.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Rep. Eric Burlison
@RepEricBurlison
Thank you @realDonaldTrump
The public has a right to know what their government knows.
The White House
@WhiteHouse
"Based on the tremendous interest shown, I will be directing the Secretary of War, and other relevant Departments and Agencies, to begin the process of identifying and releasing Government files related to alien and extraterrestrial life, unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP), and unidentified flying objects (UFOs)..." - President Donald J. Trump
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Anna Paulina Luna
@realannapaulina
Looks like we are about to have a ton of hearings on this :)! Thank you @POTUS !!!
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Rep. Nancy Mace
@RepNancyMace
Tonight, President Trump is directing full disclosure of UAP and UFO files. In October, I wrote to DoD, CIA, NSA, and DNI demanding exactly that. The truth belongs to the American people.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
White House Press Office
@PressSec
🚨OUT OF THIS WORLD NEWS from President Trump… 👽
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
Insanity. Where the hell is our US Ambassador. This is an American company, operating lawfully with the consent of the Hungarian gov’t, and a foreign 3rd-party gov’t who wants to rig Hungary’s election is prying open X to try to do it. Will our State Dept fight for X?
POLITICOEurope
@POLITICOEurope
A court in Germany yesterday ordered Elon Musk's social media site X to hand over data related to the upcoming election in Hungary to researchers for scrutiny.
www.politico.eu/article/berlin-court-tells-x-to-hand-over… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
Wow. Huge by @RepNancyMace. Puts the question point blank to the CIA. This is a development to follow 👇
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Here is @RepNancyMace letter to @CIADirector Ratcliffe.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The CIA said it could find no information on Epstein, but it did not deny that it has classified records. It must release them, says @RepNancyMace in a letter to @CIADirector John Ratcliffe. Mace cites evidence suggesting ties between Epstein and the agency going back decades.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Here is @RepNancyMace letter to @CIADirector Ratcliffe.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Here is Epstein's FOIA to @CIA and the CIA's response
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Julian Reichelt
@jreichelt
Major Media Scandal BREAKING in Germany!
The German publicly funded ZDF media company (every taxpayer has to pay for it) ran a FAKE video to attack Donald Trump over ICE actions. It was an AI video combined with old footage from the BIDEN Administration. It showed a child getting arrested. ZDF claimed these fake images were actually showing ICE officers going after children, literally saying "sie führen Eltern vor den Augen ihrer Kinder ab", "they are arresting parents before their children's eyes, snatching minors in front of their schools" - FAKE.
The show's far left host, Dunja Hayali (who months ago attacked Charlie Kirk) literally said on live TV that Trump goes after children. Publicly funded German propaganda! -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Democrats are moderating, say pundits. Except they're not. They tweaked their rhetoric but their agenda's mostly the same. They've not taken responsibility for the Woke Reign of Terror and censorship. And now, new research proves it was the Left, not the Right, that radicalized.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Democrats are moderating in anticipation of the midterm elections, according to many analysts. The New Democrat Coalition, a large center-left bloc of Democrats in the House, urged the party last week to adopt a “more moderate approach” focused on affordability and economic anxiety rather than “splashy populist promises.” Third Way, a center-left think tank, published polling last week showing that 55% of young men want the Democratic Party to become more moderate, while just 30% want it to move further left. In 2024, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez removed the pronouns from her bio. After the 2024 elections, Gavin Newsom criticized trans-identifying men being allowed to compete in women’s sports. And, over the last three days, Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton, in separate events, urged Democrats to moderate on immigration, homelessness, and “virtue signaling.”
But the analysts are wrong. On most of their major issues, Democrats remain wedded to the same agenda that lost them control of the White House in 2024. Clinton invited a trans-identified congressman, Sarah McBride (D-DE), to participate on her panel, “Girls Just Want to Have Fundamental Rights,” at the Munich meeting, despite overwhelming voter opposition to trans-identified males in female sport and trans medicine for minors. Newsom backed away from his criticism of males in female sports shortly after making it, and his hand-picked Attorney General sued the Trump administration to allow it to continue. During the House hearing on a bill to ban males from women’s sports, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez said, “Bigoted folks love this bill. Assaulters love this bill.” Obama, in an interview, framed climate change as apocalyptic and proposed green jobs as the solution, which is identical to his framing in 2007, saying “We believe in government as a tool for good, as a potential force to create more jobs, and as a way to make sure that the planet doesn’t roast, to make sure that as we move forward and the economy grows, that everybody and not just some, are benefiting.” As for the New Democrats and Third Way, they have been making the same arguments for the last 20 years, a period during which the Democrats became a radical-Left party.
It’s true that there are some signs of Democrats moderating their agenda. Democratic Governors Abigail Spanberger and Mikie Sherrill, in Virginia and New Jersey, respectively, won office last year running on more moderate agendas. “Spanberger runs what would be considered a more centrist campaign,” noted Obama, “and Mamdani in New York runs an explicitly socialist, grassroots campaign… That can win in New York City. It probably could not win in Virginia. And that’s okay.” He also said, “We’re a nation of laws, we have borders, and we’ve got to figure out an immigration policy that is orderly,” while Clinton said, “It went too far, it’s been disruptive and destabilizing, and it needs to be fixed in a humane way with secure borders.”
And Obama on homelessness said, “We should also recognize that the average person doesn’t want to have to navigate around a tent city in the middle of downtown, and that we’re not going to be able to build a working majority… if we simply say, ‘You know what, it’s not their fault, and so they should be able to do whatever they want.’”
But continuing radicalism overwhelms signs of reform. Obama said in the same interview, “It is an atrocity that in a country that’s wealthy we have people on the streets,” reinforcing the dominant myth on the Left that poverty, not addiction and untreated mental illness, causes “homelessness” and that more subsidized housing will reduce it rather than make it worse, as it has for the last 40 years. Clinton, on a different panel in Munich, scoffed at a Czech politician after he said, “I think what Trump is doing in America is a reaction to policies that really went too far,” pointing to transgenderism.
Both Clinton and Obama addressed only how to carry out mass migration, not whether to do so. This focus on changing words, not policies, is true across the board, with Democrats moderating on rhetoric, not agenda. When Spanberger came into office, she ended the state’s cooperation with ICE and simply framed it as anti-crime rather than pro-migrant. She and Sherrill opted for law enforcement optics, but their agendas are little different from Mamdani’s. Obama, in his interview, gave lip service to free speech, but did not renounce his 2022 call for government censorship of social media platforms.
The lack of moderation also goes for race, where Democrats falsely accuse their opponents of racism for opposing mass migration, racial preferences, de-policing black neighborhoods, and reparations. Governor Newsom vetoed bills that would have established concrete financial reparations for black descendants of slaves, but also approved legislation to spend $6 million to research how to verify descendants of enslaved people so a future government can give them benefits. While Democratic leaders deprioritized racial justice as a standalone platform in favor of universal economic themes, namely affordability, there has been no “Sister Souljah moment” where a leader renounces the party’s left wing, as Bill Clinton famously did in 1992.
All of this could hurt Democrats’ chances of taking back the House and Senate in the fall midterm elections and of running a moderate agenda in 2028. If there was ever a time to moderate, it was in 2025, and it didn’t happen. Voters aren’t reliably liberal. In fact, where 35% of U.S. adults identify as conservative, 33% as moderate, and just 28% as liberal.
“Democrats have little credibility,” sociologist Musa Al-Gharbi told the New York Times last month, “because they have been supporting lots of censorship on everything from insufficiently progressive views on race and gender, to suppressing views on contentious political issues in the name of fighting ‘misinformation’ and more. They and their fellow travelers have spent the past decade lowering standards, defining things like standardized tests as racist (former Rep. Jamaal Bowman famously compared testing to ‘modern day slavery’).”
Political scientist Yascha Monk agreed, noting that “while Democrats may temporarily be de-emphasizing some of the rhetoric that made them so unpopular, most voters do not believe that they have had a real change of heart about wokeness or D.E.I. — much less that they have a coherent set of political ideas to fill the resulting vacuum.”
In January, a Wall Street Journal poll found that even though voters disapproved of Trump on many issues, including the economy, inflation, and immigration, they still favored Congressional Republicans over Democrats on those issues. “In other words,” wrote Thomas Edsall in the Times, “Trump is in hot water on a wide range of issues, but that has failed to translate into Democratic ascendance, signaling continued wariness and distrust of the party.”
Noted another political scientist, “Democrats must de-escalate acrimonious rhetoric, condemn political violence across the country, promote cross-partisan citizen dialogues, town halls, and deliberative forums nationwide, and reframe polarizing media content.” But they haven’t done so.
On the contrary. Fifty-five percent of people who self-identified as left of center told pollsters last year it would be at least somewhat justified to murder Donald Trump, and 48 percent said the same about Elon Musk. And 25 percent of people who describe themselves as “very liberal” and 17 percent of people who describe themselves as “liberal” say that it is sometimes justified to resort to violence to achieve political goals. Only 6 percent of people who describe themselves as “conservative” and 3 percent as “very conservative” said the same. That’s a nearly five-to-one difference.
So why is that? Why haven’t Democratic leaders and politicians sought to moderate their agendas, and not just their language?
x.com/shellenberger/status/2023415347152359441
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Thomas Massie
@RepThomasMassie
DOJ redacted information necessary to identify who sent Epstein the “torture video email.”
@RepRoKhanna and I first discovered his name and released it Monday.
Today he resigns.
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
DP World Chairman and Chief Executive Sultan Ahmed Bin Sulayem resigned from the Dubai-based global ports operator after documents released by the Justice Department showed he had ties to Jeffrey Epstein www.wsj.com/articles/dubai-businessman-in-epstein-files-r…
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Rep. Anna Paulina Luna
@RepLuna
I have spent time reviewing Dr. Harry Fish’s emails at the DOJ, and from what I can gather, he was interviewed but was never treated as a co-conspirator. Given the coded language in his communications, this raises serious questions for me. There were a number of doctors who, in my view, should have been examined as persons of interest, along with anyone else communicating in coded terms. Many of the disturbing “food reference” emails also appear to have been coordinated by a woman who was later given “victim” status after testifying against Epstein and Maxwell, despite what the emails seem to indicate was her involvement in trafficking.
I also have significant concerns about the FBI’s initial handling of this matter. To be clear, across multiple administrations—both Democrat and Republican—and under several directors, the FBI did not follow up on these disturbing emails in the way they should have. I will add that I have been in extensive communication with the DOJ, and at this time they are fully cooperating. I believe there is a possibility that some aspects of this may be reopened. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Not all references to food in the Epstein Files are code words, but some definitely are, including references to "shrimp," as I explain here. We need an independent investigation and real reform as our Intelligence Community is operating outside of civilian control.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The recently released Jeffrey Epstein files neither reveal a conspiracy to traffic underage girls to powerful men, nor a relationship to the Intelligence Community (IC), nor a client list, according to some in the media and online. None of the hundreds of CDs, videos, and photographs showed men with young women, notes the Associated Press. And the FBI “found scant evidence the well-connected financier led a sex trafficking ring serving powerful men,” notes AP.
But the Epstein Files do, in fact, provide even more evidence than we already had that Epstein trafficked underage girls to powerful men and that he had ties with both the IC and the Justice Department. The Files reveal that Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick misled the public about his relationship with Epstein, which continued years after he had claimed, and included at least one business deal. And they reveal that a powerful UK diplomat, Peter Mandelson, the former ambassador to the United States, illegally shared confidential state financial secrets with Epstein, and appeared in his underwear in at least one photo. The new evidence forced Mandelson to resign, leave the House of Lords, and nearly brought down the Keir Starmer government.
To be sure, there is false and misleading information in the Epstein Files. There may not be any CIA files on Epstein. There appears to be no client list. At least one of the alleged Epstein victims lied. And there is no evidence for some sensational claims. Moreover, there are FBI reports of testimony from clearly unreliable people, attesting, for example, to witnessing mass murder and cannibalism. Some online are view nearly every food reference as a code word for pedophilia or worse, imagining evidence and seeing connections that simply aren’t there.
While there was an investigation, the files make clear that the FBI had a list of co-conspirators with Epstein, who are in the Epstein Files, engaging in behaviors to recruit women to engage in what is effectively prostitution, whom the FBI never investigated.
An FBI employee on July 7, 2019, emailed a colleague to ask, “When you get a chance can you give me an update on the status of the 10 CO conspirators?” The email named “Brunel” and “Maxwell,” references to Jean-Luc Brunel, a French recruiter of fashion models who was under investigation for raping minors, and convicted sex trafficker Ghislaine Maxwell.
Another FBI document lists all 10 co-conspirators, and they include the foudner of Victoria's Secret, and Epstein’s assistant, Lesley Groff.
We know that Epstein had installed hidden cameras, a surveillance room, and produced hundreds of videos spying on people on CDs and tape.
The CIA so valued Epstein’s attorney, Kathy Ruemmler, the White House counsel for President Barack Obama, that its Director gave her the agency’s highest award. The Director of the CIA under Biden, William Burns, met with, or was scheduled to meet with, Epstein at least three times when he was a State Department official. And, in the 1990s, Wexner and Epstein helped relocate a CIA front organization, Southern Air Transport, from Miami to Columbus, Ohio, where Wexner lived.
Epstein considered using a former “CIA plane to transport prisoners to Guantanamo Bay…called a Torture Plane,” according to Epstein’s pilot, Larry Visoski, in an email.
Ruemmler at one point emails Epstein to say, “Yes, I am really here,” to which Epstein responds, “it looks like a cia drop,” tradecraft jargon for an intelligence exchange.
Epstein, through his lawyer, tried to get information out of the CIA about himself, and the CIA responded, saying it looked and found nothing. But by denying an “open or otherwise acknowledged” affiliation, the CIA legally protected itself from having to confirm or deny covert, unacknowledged, or informal relationships, such as being a confidential informant, a foreign intelligence asset, or a non-official contractor.
These new revelations come at a time when even mainstream news media are reporting on more evidence that Epstein may not have killed himself in August 2019. Noted CBS, “investigators reviewing surveillance footage from the night of Jeffrey Epstein’s death observed an orange-colored shape moving up a staircase” toward his cell. An FBI memorandum describes the fuzzy image as “possibly an inmate.” And CBS reported that “Prison employees interviewed by CBS News said escorting an inmate at that hour would have been highly unusual.”
So what does it all mean? Who was Epstein and what was he doing?
To answer those questions, we need to take a closer look at the code words.
When Nicole Junkermann, an Epstein lover, says “Wow!” after he indicates he might be willing to have a baby with her, Epstein replies, “Is that a code word” to which she replied “No i am surprised.” In one exchange, a woman, whose name is redacted, but is almost certainly Nadia Marcinko (a.k.a., Naďa Marcinková), Epstein’s Slovak-born pilot, asks him to fly with her. He says, “Is that a code word?” And she replies, “I really meant fly… would your answer differ if it were a code word?”
While most of the Epstein Files emails that use the word “shrimp” appear to refer to the seafood, some appear not to. Someone whose name is redacted emails Epstein to say, “Call Talia, she will give you massage. And she looks better then ‘shrimp’ anyway. And good with Massages.” The person is using shrimp in the context of “massage” which in many emails appears to refer to massage with sex...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2021713339932430593
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning reporting, to read the rest of the article, and watch the full video!This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Seems bad:
Ellie Leonard🇺🇦
@RedPencilScript
On the left, 9 E. 71st Street: Jeffrey Epstein’s house
On the right, 11 E. 71st Street: Howard Lutnick’s house
Both owned by Leslie Wexner, both purchased in 1998.
Neighbors for 21 years.
But I digress…
#epsteinfiles
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Yes
The Telegraph
@Telegraph
🚨 EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: “My opinion is that his death was most likely caused by strangulation pressure rather than hanging”
In an interview with The Telegraph, pathologist Dr Michael Baden raises questions about Jeffrey Epstein's suicide
Find out more ⬇️
www.telegraph.co.uk/us/news/2026/02/13/epstein-post-morte… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You have let 19 mentally ill homeless people die in the streets over the last two weeks because you won't let the police bring them in. This is unconscionable. End this madness at once, @ZohranKMamdani And shame on your allies @AOC @GovKathyHochul for remaining silent.
Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani
@NYCMayor
Leqaa Kordia has spent nearly a year in an ICE prison for exercising her First Amendment rights in NYC & speaking out against the ongoing genocide in Palestine.
She was hospitalized after suffering a seizure. Now she's back in detention.
This is cruel & unnecessary.
Release Leqaa now.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is barbarism, @ZohranKMamdani
Shame on you for not having reversed your policy already.
Please get him to stop this madness @SenSchumer @gillibrandny @RepJeffries
This moral crime is on everyone who does not speak up
Andrew Siff
@andrewsiff4NY
NEW: city hall has confirmed a 19th outdoor death.
“We were also made aware of one more additional death after an individual was found unresponsive on the street under the Manhattan Bridge last evening.” #nbc4ny
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Total insanity
abc7ny.com/post/mamdani-administration-faces-nyc-council-…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The "advocates for the homeless" are defending a policy that's killing the homeless. A grotesque Big Lie is being used to carry out a reprehensible and obviously immoral policy. Shame on @ZohranKMamdani . Get a grip. You're trapped in an idiotic ideology.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
❄️ Snow 🔻 Himbo ☭
@SnowHimbo
The internet really went from "Never give anyone your personal information" to "You need a government-issued ID to use the internet" in like 10 years
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pete Muntean
@petemuntean
Important context: the El Paso TFR is not like the 9/11 nationwide airspace shutdown. DC & NY restrictions were created later. A ban on all flights over a U.S. city—including medevac and police helicopters—has no modern precedent.
CNN
@CNN
FAA halts all flights to and from El Paso, Texas, and an area of southern New Mexico for 10 days over security concerns www.cnn.com/2026/02/11/us/faa-el-paso-texas-flight-restri…
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
There is no explanation here for why they would, without warning, close the El Paso airport for 10 days, then reopen it. They've said drones, balloon, and laser but none explain why they did what they did. None of their explanations add up.
The Associated Press
@AP
BREAKING: The Pentagon let Customs and Border Protection use an anti-drone laser before the FAA closed El Paso airspace, AP sources say. apnews.com/article/faa-el-paso-texas-air-space-closed-1f7…
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Enigma
@enigmalabs
In less than 24 hours the FAA placed and then lifted a temporary closure at El Paso International Airport. Enigma skywatchers had already begun reporting what they saw, even hours before the closure was announced. See one report below⬇️
Explore more in our Collection:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Correct
Shoe
@samosaur
Ok, but a 10 day notam? For a drone incursion? That doesn't check.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Good questions
Laura Rozen
@lrozen
do you have any further statement that what you posted/were told turns out not to be the real story? but that CPB was apparently given permission by DoD to use a counter drone laser to shoot down 4 party balloons, without informing the FAA, while endangering civilian air travel?
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Enigma
@enigmalabs
In less than 24 hours the FAA placed and then lifted a temporary closure at El Paso International Airport. Enigma skywatchers had already begun reporting what they saw, even hours before the closure was announced. See one report below⬇️
Explore more in our Collection:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Two NGOs responsible for the trans medical scandal, @WPATH and @AmerAcadPeds, are under investigation by US government. Both organizations should be bankrupted and put out of business for their role in the abuse of children.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
THE WPATH FILES
Advocates of gender-affirming care say it’s evidence-based.
But now, newly released internal files from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) prove that the practice of transgender medicine is neither scientific nor medical.
American Medical Association, The Endocrine Society, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and thousands of doctors worldwide rely on WPATH. It is considered the leading global authority on gender medicine.
And yet WPATH’s internal files, which include written discussions and a video, reveal that its members know they are creating victims and not getting “informed consent.”
Victims include a 10-year-old girl, a 13-year-old developmentally delayed adolescent, and individuals suffering from schizophrenia and other serious mental illnesses.
The injuries described in the WPATH Files include sterilization, loss of sexual function, liver tumors, and death.
WPATH members indicate repeatedly that they know that many children and their parents don’t understand the effects that puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries will have on their bodies. And yet, they continue to perform and advocate for gender medicine.
The WPATH Files prove that gender medicine is comprised of unregulated and pseudoscientific experiments on children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults. It will go down as one of the worst medical scandals in history.
environmentalprogress.org/big-news/wpath-files
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
All the gory details of @wpath and its moral crimes here:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
THE WPATH FILES
Advocates of gender-affirming care say it’s evidence-based.
But now, newly released internal files from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) prove that the practice of transgender medicine is neither scientific nor medical.
American Medical Association, The Endocrine Society, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and thousands of doctors worldwide rely on WPATH. It is considered the leading global authority on gender medicine.
And yet WPATH’s internal files, which include written discussions and a video, reveal that its members know they are creating victims and not getting “informed consent.”
Victims include a 10-year-old girl, a 13-year-old developmentally delayed adolescent, and individuals suffering from schizophrenia and other serious mental illnesses.
The injuries described in the WPATH Files include sterilization, loss of sexual function, liver tumors, and death.
WPATH members indicate repeatedly that they know that many children and their parents don’t understand the effects that puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries will have on their bodies. And yet, they continue to perform and advocate for gender medicine.
The WPATH Files prove that gender medicine is comprised of unregulated and pseudoscientific experiments on children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults. It will go down as one of the worst medical scandals in history.
environmentalprogress.org/big-news/wpath-files -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Preston Byrne
@prestonjbyrne
SLAM DUNK: the Wyoming GRANITE Act, which, if enacted would be the first foreign censorship shield law in history, has passed its introduction vote 57-5.
Foreign censors, enjoy coming after Americans while you still can - because your time to do so is running short.
Colin Crossman 🦬₿
@Arceris_btc
The Wyoming GRANITE Act has passed its first hurdle, a ⅔ introduction vote!
57-5
@RepDanielSingh @prestonjbyrne -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Bündnis Redefreiheit
@BRedefreiheit
The totalitarian Swiss Digital Services Act censors nothing but legal content, by logical necessity. It is logically impossible for it to censor illegal content. It is a tool of arbitrary power wielded to crush free speech. @GlobalAffairs @elonmusk @realDonaldTrump @JDVance
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Defend Intelligence (Anis Ayari)
@DFintelligence
ET VOILÀ !!!!!!!!! PUTA*IN !!!!
Un des fameux « tiers de confiance » de vérification d’identité a subi une fuite de données, et le pire, c’est que pendant des mois, ils ne s’en sont même pas rendu compte !!!!!
Elle est là, la réalité !!!
N’ÉCOUTEZ JAMAIS DES POLITIQUES QUI VOUS PARLENT DE TECH ET QUI PRÉTENDENT QUE TOUT EST SÉCURISÉ. C’EST DE L’ENFUMAGE !!!!!!!!!!
Demain, on va tous mettre nos cartes d’identité, photos, adresses, etc., dans des solutions pour vérifier notre âge, et six mois plus tard, TOUTES VOS INFOS SERONT DISPONIBLES À LA REVENTE SUR DES MARCHÉS DE DONNÉES !!
C’EST INACCEPTABLE !!!!!!!!!! -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Atlantico
@atlantico_fr
Vérification d’âge : contrairement à ce qu’affirme Emmanuel Macron, France Identité n’est pas capable de garantir l’anonymat en ligne atlantico.fr/article/rdv/verification-age-contrairement-a…
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Thomas Massie
@RepThomasMassie
🧵3) until tonight no one knew who sent the torture video to Epstein. I went to DOJ, unredacted the email, and reverse searched the email to discover it was a Sultans. Our law requires VICTIM’s information to be redacted, not information of men who sent Epstein torture porn!
Attorney General Todd Blanche
@AGToddBlanche
You looked at the document. You know it’s an email address that was redacted. The law requires redactions for personally identifiable information, including if in an email address. And you know that the Sultan’s name is available unredacted in the files. See EFTA00666117.
Be honest, and stop grandstanding. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Catherine Herridge
@C__Herridge
EPSTEIN FILES FALLOUT: “No Doubt” Information Gathered By Jeffrey Epstein Looks Like “Intelligence Collection Operation” Claims Former FBI Special Agent; Says Advancements In AI Tools Could Help “Speed Up” The Process of Reviewing Millions of Documents But Worries “Statue of Limitations” On Many Crimes Has Been Allowed To Run Out
“He[Epstein] went after people or he had connections to people that had connections to national security or huge technological advances. An intel operation would greatly benefit and be able to not only understand what other world leaders are doing, but be able to influence what they're doing.”
“This has huge political ramifications and global ramifications… way above the decisions that even a supervisor in the FBI would make.”
@thelatmg @latimesstudios_
Straight to the Point: The Epstein Files
00:40 New Criminal Charges: Open “Pandora’s Box”
01:44 Ghislaine Maxwell Takes The Fifth
02:20 New Lines of Inquiry: Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor
04:10 How To Investigate Allegations That Victims Were “Buried” On Epstein Property
06:10 Artificial Intelligence (AI) Makes Tracking Down Old Leads Possible
07:50 Former FBI Special Agent: Epstein Case Looks Like “Intelligence Gathering Operation”
10:10 FBI Interview Summaries
11:04 How To Tackle Bill Gates Records
11:55 Party Drugs: Oxycodone, Vicodin, Ketamine…
14:15 Was It The Right Move to Release The Files?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Tom Vandendriessche
@TomVandendriese
EU censorship files. No debate allowed.
A Parliament that is not allowed to hold the EU commission accountable is not democracy - it's theatre
#eucensorshipfiles
@Jim_Jordan @elonmuskThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Another Epstein "conspiracy theory" confirmed as true. People dismissed this despite evidence of a surveillance room, many CDs with images and videos, and a camera pointed directly at a bed.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Congrats to @poppyeh for this big scoop
Poppy Wood
@poppyeh
EXCL Epstein’s home was fitted with hidden cameras from a spyware shop
The cameras were installed inside Kleenex boxes and thought to be fitted in his Palm Beach mansion
It is the clearest evidence to date that Epstein was capturing covert material
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/02/09/jeffrey-epstein-secre… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Taylor Lorenz
@TaylorLorenz
We are rapidly losing the ability to communicate and access information anonymously online and leftists aren’t even talking about it. It’s so bad!
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
John LeFevre
@JohnLeFevre
NYT (2024): The mild winter is climate change.
NYT (2026): The cold winter is climate change. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Jon De Lorraine
@jon_delorraine
🔴 ARCHIVE DÉCEMBRE 2025
Par le biais de Tocsin,
Le journaliste Michael Shellenberger lâche une bombe politique issue des TwitterFiles :
"Je n'avais jamais vu un chef d'État s'impliquer aussi directement que Macron dans le complexe industriel de la censure."
Shellenberger dévoile l'existence d'une action secrète coordonnée personnellement par Emmanuel Macron, alliant l'Élysée à des ONG sous influence (financements publics/services de renseignement) pour faire pression sur twitter.
Selon lui, la France a même servi de "laboratoire" mondial à ces méthodes de contrôle de l'information, héritées de la loi Pleven.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Catherine Herridge
@C__Herridge
EXCLUSIVE: Credible sources tell me that elements of the Intelligence Community (IC), federal law enforcement and Congress have targeted @DNIGabbard' s Director's Initiative Group or DIG because it revealed "uncomfortable facts and findings" on several matters entrenched members of these bureaucracies don't want out there.
I understand the push has been to "disband, dismantle or diminish the impact of the DIG and its work."
As one example, I confirmed through multiple sources that the report and findings into Directed Energy Attacks or AHIs (Anomalous Health Incidents) were finalized and prepped for release weeks ago. But there is strong IC resistance to releasing it.
DNI Gabbard committed to a new review of so-called Havana Syndrome after our 2025 independent investigation. Our reporting revealed that brain injuries suffered by US spies, diplomats, military operatives and civilians are progressive and can lead to brain cell death and atrophy.
When it was launched by DNI Gabbard, the DIG's stated goal was "rebuilding trust in the IC" by "investigating weaponization, rooting out deep-seeded politicization, exposing unauthorized disclosures of classified intelligence, and declassifying information that serves a public interest."
In response to our question's about the status and future of DIG, a DNI spokesperson said --
“The Director remains committed to rooting out politicization and weaponization in the IC and revealing the truth to the American people.”
We are reaching out to multiple agencies for comment to advance the reporting.
We will update as warranted. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Claremont Institute
@ClaremontInst
“The Trump Administration can truly restore free speech to the internet only by confronting the European Union. The administration needs to challenge the DSA, to get it repealed or at least neutered.”
Read John Rosenthal's essay in the Spring 2025 edition of the CRB on what is required of the United States to defeat the European Union's censorship regime. claremontreviewofbooks.com/make-speech-free-again/
The American Mind
@theammind
The issue is not merely “bad actors,” but a formal, legal censorship regime.
The State Department's sanctions against HateAid are not enough. John Rosenthal writes that the only way to stop the E.U's censorship of Americans is to bring the entire system tumbling down. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
LET'S GO. THIS MUST BE DONE. THE CONGRESSMEN AND WOMEN WHO DO THIS WILL FOREVER BE HEROES. TIME IS SHORT ACT NOW
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
BREAKING: Congress is considering stripping sovereign immunity of EU censorship officials, prohibiting social media from enforcing censorship orders, and enabling private lawsuits against foreign entities, says @Jim_Jordan echoing remarks made by @UnderSecPD and @DarrellIssa
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
BREAKING: Congress is considering stripping sovereign immunity of EU censorship officials, prohibiting social media from enforcing censorship orders, and enabling private lawsuits against foreign entities, says @Jim_Jordan echoing remarks made by @UnderSecPD and @DarrellIssa
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Preston Byrne
@prestonjbyrne
The U.S. could have new laws to end foreign censorship within our borders within 3 *weeks.*
The GRANITE Act extends its protections to anyone running servers in Wyoming.
Legislative session starts on Feb 9th. If you want this shield on the books, the time to push is NOW.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
background:
House Judiciary GOP 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
@JudiciaryGOP
🚨The EU Censorship Files, Part II
For more than a year, the Committee has been warning that European censorship laws threaten U.S. free speech online.
Now, we have proof: Big Tech is censoring Americans’ speech in the U.S., including true information, to comply with Europe’s far-reaching Digital Services Act. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mario ZNA
@MarioBojic
🚨🇵🇹BREAKING: Portugal Announces Mass Control of Social Media!
After France and Spain, Portugal now wants to introduce a Digital Pass under the EU Digital Identity system just to be allowed to connect online!
They say it’s for the safety of our children, but the reality is this is just another step toward killing our freedoms.
The EU is an open-air prison and Ursula von der Leyen is the warden. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
New York Post
@nypost
Seattle to pay $30M for teen death in anti-cop CHOP zone — because ambulances wouldn’t go there nypost.com/2026/02/03/us-news/seattle-to-pay-30m-for-teen…
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@GavinNewsom must immediately demand a full investigation of LA Mayor @KarenBassLA for covering up her role in failing to prevent the fires from spreading out of control. If he doesn’t, then everyone will know that he is in on the corruption and the cover-up.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
January 2: National Weather Service (NWS) warns of “extreme fire weather conditions” in Los Angeles
Jan. 3: NWS repeats warning in special LA briefing
Jan. 4: LA Mayor Karen Bass flies to Ghana on junket
Jan. 7: LA goes up in flames as Bass poses for photos at cocktail party
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“‘All the changes [The Times] reported on were the ones Karen wanted,’ the second source said, referring primarily to the newspaper’s determination that the report was altered to deflect attention from the LAFD’s failure to pre-deploy crews to Pacific Palisades before the fire, which killed 12 people and destroyed more than 6,000 homes and other structures, amid forecasts of catastrophically high winds.”
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
Great news! The good folks at @theblackvault (they run what I think is the largest online archive of declassified docs in the world) just fired FOIAs at CIA for Epstein's CIA records requests in 1999 and 2011. Any CIA delay, obstruction or run-around will be a major scandal.
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
LET'S FUCKING GOOO 🔥🔥🔥
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
House Judiciary GOP 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
@JudiciaryGOP
🚨🚨🚨British police arrested a non-UK citizen arriving from the United States for his online speech
Graham Linehan is an Irish comedy writer who tweeted jokes critical of transgender ideology while in the United States.
When he flew to London, Linehan was arrested at Heathrow Airport by 5 armed officers.
WATCH Linehan's testimony ⬇️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
gript
@griptmedia
Regulators with Coimisiún na Meán worked with the EU and ‘biased fact-checkers’ before Ireland’s 2024/5 elections, in order to disadvantage conservative or populist political parties, a report from the judiciary committee of the US Congress says.
gript.ie/report-regulators-censored-social-media-in-elect… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Virginie Joron
@v_joron
➡️Prochain exercice : éplucher ce rapport
Mais déjà une confirmation: les interférences de la Commission européenne sur les élections européennes avec la preuve qu’il n’y a pas eu d’interférences étrangères via Tik Tok lors des élections en Roumanie.
On le savait, mais cela n’a pas empêché le système de les annuler.
House Judiciary GOP 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
@JudiciaryGOP
The Committee continues to investigate foreign threats to American free speech.
Read the Committee’s full report here: judiciary.house.gov/sites/evo-subsites/republicans-judici… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Daily Romania
@daily_romania
Files published by the U.S. House Judiciary Committee confirm that the EU interfered in eight European elections, including Romania's 2024 presidential election, where Călin Georgescu's victory was annulled
🇺🇸🇷🇴 -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
French Report
@french_report78
Le communiqué du Parquet de Paris à propos des poursuites pénales engagées à l'encontre d'@elonmusk est un fourre-tout pénal sans queue ni tête.
On a l'impression de lire un communiqué d'une junte communiste d'Afrique centrale. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Cecílie Jílková
@CecilieJilkova
"Tisíce interních dokumentů a komunikace velkých technologických firem s evropskými regulačními orgány, které byly dnes poprvé zveřejněny, vykreslují jasný obrázek: Evropa vedla úspěšnou desetiletou kampaň za dosažení globální kontroly nad online narativem."
House Judiciary GOP 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
@JudiciaryGOP
🚨The EU Censorship Files, Part II
For more than a year, the Committee has been warning that European censorship laws threaten U.S. free speech online.
Now, we have proof: Big Tech is censoring Americans’ speech in the U.S., including true information, to comply with Europe’s far-reaching Digital Services Act. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
House Judiciary GOP 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
@JudiciaryGOP
🚨The EU Censorship Files, Part II
For more than a year, the Committee has been warning that European censorship laws threaten U.S. free speech online.
Now, we have proof: Big Tech is censoring Americans’ speech in the U.S., including true information, to comply with Europe’s far-reaching Digital Services Act. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
9. For Fuck's Sake, the TOP HIGHEST-LEVEL operatives of US Censorship Industrial Complex who CREATED the Spain cluster of the complex 10 YEARS AGO are STILL ON THE BOARD OF TRUMP'S NATIONAL ENDOWMENT FOR DEMOCRACY THAT REPUBLICANS JUST GAVE $315 MILLION
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
Want to know what a real "organized online influence campaign" looks like? Welp, Anne Applebaum can tell you. She helped create them for her MI6-backed, UK Foreign Office funded political dark arts op
Here's her UK cluster secretly activating a Spain cluster to carry out a hit -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
Trump State Dept must IMMEDIATELY review all recs & comms btwn (1) Biden’s State Dept, esp US Amb to France & Embassy, & (2) all French Ministry of Justice & Ministry of Foreign Affairs contacts, for FULL INTERNAL AUDIT of coordination on disinformation & platform governance work
Pavel Durov
@durov
French police is currently raiding X’s office in Paris. France is the only country in the world that is criminally persecuting all social networks that give people some degree of freedom (Telegram, X, TikTok…). Don’t be mistaken: this is not a free country.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pascal Clérotte
@McmahonPascal
Guess what: he cannot do that. 100% illegal under EU law AND the Spanish constitution. BTW,about today's raid in Paris, they are admitting openly the weaponizing of justice. www.eclaireur.eu/p/flash-raided-x
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The most powerful advocate for expanding US military intervention in Ukraine-Russia war is Senate Armed Services Chairman @SenatorWicker. Now, a whistleblower who uncovered criminal activity by Wicker's @HelsinkiComm says it has been “compromised” by dangerous foreign actors.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“Compromised” Congressional Commission Is Undermining Trump’s Ukraine Peace Efforts, Says Whistleblower
Former senior official who reported criminal violations by Helsinki Committee, chaired by Senate Armed Services Commitee Chairman Roger Wicker, urges investigation by Trump administration
Sen. Roger Wicker (R-MS) arrives before a closed briefing in the U.S. Capitol Building on December 17, 2025, in Washington, DC. (Photo by Heather Diehl/Getty Images)
Few in Washington, D.C. have been stronger supporters of expanding U.S. support for Ukraine in its war with Russia than Senator Roger Wicker (R-MS), who is the Chairman of the powerful Senate Armed Services Commitee. Last November, he dismissed the Trump administration’s efforts as a “so-called peace plan.” In recent weeks, Wicker has insisted that ”Ukraine should not be forced to give up the sovereign territory it deserves and it currently controls” and repeatedly compared Putin to Hitler. And Wicker said the US must commit to protecting Ukraine “on a permanent basis,” including by giving it “long-range strike capabilities.”
Those positions put Wicker at odds with many experts, the Trump administration, and the Republican Party’s base. Most experts believe any peace agreement will require that Ukraine give up land, and that giving Ukraine longer-range weapons will push the US and Russia closer to nuclear conflict.
Wicker exercises his power as the chairman of a little-known government agency, the Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe, commonly known as “the Helsinki Commission.” His Armed Services Chairmanship is one of the most powerful roles in Washington, overseeing top defense nominees and record U.S. military spending, expected to exceed $1 trillion next year.
Steven Schrage, a longtime Republican foreign policy expert, was, along with the Helsinki Commission’s General Counsel, tasked with leading an official investigation of the Commission that began in the Spring of 2023 and ended in March 2024. Schrage says Wicker and his Helsinki Commission have been “compromised” by foreign actors working to undermine Trump Administration officials and trigger a wider U.S. war with Russia.
Steven Schrage, former Deputy Assistant Secretary of State, co-chair of the U.S. delegation to the G8 Anti-Crime and Terrorism Group, and the Scholl Chair in International Business at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS).
Schrage said he decided to speak out now because he fears Congress will increase the Commission’s funding when the House passes its major appropriations bill today, allowing the Commission to operate outside administration oversight after the 2026 midterm elections.
Schrage has provided whistleblower documents (below) related to the investigation to U.S. officials and has urged the Trump administration to immediately open independent investigations by the Director of National Intelligence (DNI), federal counterintelligence, and FARA officials.
“For the first six months after Trump got elected, it looked like the Commission would be quietly wound down due to these reported violations,” said Schrage. “Then the Commission took extraordinary steps to reinstall all the main characters that had been involved in the criminal and national security violations. They are now trying to lock in funding.”
Late last year, Senator Wicker excoriated the Trump administration’s Ukraine-Russia peace proposal and “put restrictions undermining Trump policies, such as blocking troop transfers from Europe,” in the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), Schrage noted.
“It put money in for Ukraine that the administration did not ask for,” said Schrage. “Wicker blocked key appointees to serve with officials driving Trump’s policy and peace initiatives.”
Schrage led international crime and terrorism efforts as a Deputy Assistant Secretary of State, served as co-chair of the U.S. delegation to the G8 Anti-Crime and Terrorism Group, and was the Scholl Chair in International Business at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS).
Particularly troubling to Schrage was staff member Kyle Parker’s work with a “controversial former Russian Duma Member linked to Ukraine intelligence named Ilya Ponomarev. While Wicker’s and Helsinki’s top staff were working with Ponomarev, the former Duma member suggested to Western journalists that he had links to the assassins of Darya Dugina, a journalist and daughter of a controversial Russian philosopher.
Schrage found evidence that the Commission had “obstructed justice by covering up at least $87,400 in criminal-flagged FARA violations by Parker, bringing cash back from Ukraine in his luggage. It was supposed to be referred to the Department of Justice FARA unit for independent action before Helsinki officials and Wicker intervened.”
“We witnessed Ponomarev coming to the commission and discussing planning a quote-unquote, ‘Wagner-style coup’ to take out Putin, and using the commission to gain legitimacy for his efforts to have foreign powers break up and divide Russia,” said Schrage. “The U.S. government under both Presidents Biden and Trump acted to stop U.S. officials from being linked to these types of coups and assassinations as they could be easily manipulated by foreign actors to trigger wider wars.”
Schrage and Helsinki’s General Counsel discovered that both Republicans and Democrats had blown the whistle for years on multiple cases of conflicts of interest, criminal activity, and foreign influence by Helsinki Committee staff. Those included supplying Ukrainian snipers, accepting gifts from foreign nationals with interests in war with Russia, and reckless behavior by the Commission’s Chief of Staff, Kyle Parker.
After the release of Schrage’s report, the commission’s chairman at the time called for Parker’s dismissal. “I urgently recommend you secure his immediate resignation or termination,” wrote Representative Joe Wilson (R-SC) in a letter to Senator Benjamin L. Cardin (D-MD). But Cardin never did so, and Wicker has also kept Parker in his position.
Senator Wicker did not respond to repeated emailed and telephone requests for comment.
The investigation uncovered particular concerns regarding prominent foreign financier, Bill Browder, who worked closely with Parker and Wicker for years while, Schrage claims, exerting increasing control and influence over the Commission.
Browder did not return repeated requests for comment.
Schrage reported that Browder, a U.S.-born UK investor who renounced his U.S. citizenship, told him that he paid for “extravagant dinners” for Parker abroad and “aggressively pushed me to accept what I knew, from my background leading international crime at the State Department, was an illegal or unethical gift.”
While it may seem a small thing, Schrage explained, such gifts are “the classic way corrupt actors or intelligence services develop assets. You push government officials or contacts into legal violations, and get them to not report your own, so that it spirals as leverage to larger and larger corruption.”
Schrage, who has decades of experience working in the foreign policy and national security community, called the offer a “clear red flag.”
“I asked him, ‘You know I can’t accept that, right? That’s not proper and a violation of ethics,” said Schrage. “He pushed again and bragged that it was okay to take it because he was always buying all these extravagant dinners for Parker in London and at the best restaurants, and he never objected.”
After rebuffing Browder, said Schrage, “He got hostile and cold.”
Through the Helsinki investigation, Schrage learned Parker was told by Senator Wicker at a private meeting after a hearing to find a way to “get rid of” the two officials leading the Helsinki investigations, Schrage and Helsinki’s General Counsel, a potential criminal obstruction of justice violation.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
All whistleblower documents here:
www.public.news/p/compromised-congressional-commission?r=… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Congratulations to the victims and to the members of Congress who stuck their necks out and made history in getting the files released.
Can we now finally get a proper investigation and IC reform?
@RepThomasMassie @RepNancyMace @laurenboebert @mtgreenee @RoKhanna
U.S. Department of Justice
@TheJusticeDept
🚨 Department of Justice Publishes 3.5 Million Responsive Pages in Compliance with the Epstein Files Transparency Act
🔗justice.gov/opa/media/1426091/dl
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
History will show that @RepThomasMassie @RepNancyMace @laurenboebert @mtgreenee withstood heavy pressure to do the right thing.
The American people owe you all a debt of gratitude. 🌹❤️⭐️
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
There's still too much redacted from the Epstein Files, and the American people deserve to get to the truth about what happened. A proper investigation is needed along with serious IC reform.
Mike Baker
@ByMikeBaker
A new statement from Epstein survivors:
"Once again, survivors are having their names and identifying information exposed, while the men who abused us remain hidden and protected. That is outrageous."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
🤨
Lauren
@cabsav456
Todd Blanche is saying they uploaded the entirety of the Epstein files yesterday and that we shouldn't expect any further releases. I'm confused because we still don't have:
- FBI internal decision-making memos
- Complete FBI case files from Florida (2005-2008), NY and SDNY, and cross-field office communications (Miami ↔ NY ↔ DOJ HQ)
- DOJ-FBI coordination records
- The internal DOJ discussions leading up to the 2008 non-prosecution agreement (and whether FBI agents objected, and if so, who overruled them)
- Any declassified intelligence assessments
- Jail and death-related FBI records
This is the stuff I personally am most interested in. Where is it at?! @RepThomasMassie @RoKhanna -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
Epstein: using CIA airplanes in the 1980s, using CIA airplanes in the 1990s, using CIA airplanes in 2017
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
SAT was a CIA airline used to ship guns. In 1991, the CIA-backed Somali govt fell to a civil war. In 1993, Bush tried to tilt the civil war w/ Operation Restore Hope using Rickenbacker Air Base in Columbus OH. In 1994, SAT moved to Rickenbacker to serve Jeffrey Epstein's company
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Thomas Massie
@RepThomasMassie
If you’re reading Epstein files now, it’s because I’m in Congress and fighting.
I’m not taking all the credit. At least as much goes to @RepRoKhanna @FmrRepMTG @laurenboebert @RepNancyMace.
And too many documents are still being withheld or redacted, but we’ll get to that too. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Calling anti-ICE riots an "insurrection" or "insurgency... poses dangers," says @nytimes. It "legitimizes the use of violence," says a CSIS expert.
Funny, then, how The Times labeled January 6 an "insurrection" and the same CSIS expert called J6 a "terrorist incident."Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
On January 7, 2021, @nytimes not only called J6 an "insurrection," it encouraged teachers to teach students that social media was to blame. The Times would go on to demand government censorship of citizens in the name of preventing "insurrection."
www.nytimes.com/2021/01/07/learning/teaching-resources-to…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
On February 5, in a long piece based on "a digital file containing the precise locations of more than 12 million individual smartphones for several months in 2016 and 2017," NY Times writers @cwarzel and Stuart A. Thompson, who has repeatedly demanded censorship, called J6 an "insurrection."
www.nytimes.com/2021/02/05/opinion/capitol-attack-cellpho…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I don't think anyone will try to deny that The New York Times repeatedly called J6 an "insurrection," but here are a few more examples.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Seattle Police Officers Guild
@SPOG1952
"Toothless virtue signaling rhetoric like this has already cost two people their lives. The concept of pitting two armed law enforcement agencies against each other is ludicrous, and will not happen. I will not allow SPOG members to be used as political pawns."
- Mike Solan, SPOG President
x.com/MayorofSeattle/status/2017010087131566385
@MayorofSeattle
Mayor Katie Wilson
@MayorofSeattle
Today I announced an initial set of actions to protect city residents in the face of increased federal immigration enforcement activity. #thisisyourcity
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Anti-ICE protests were grassroots and peaceful, said the media. They never were. They are organized specifically to intefere with law enforcement operations and trigger violence, as Signal groups, operations manual, videos, and reporting by @haileyywest and @camhigby prove.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For weeks, the media have claimed that the protests against federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents in Minneapolis and other cities are peaceful and that protesters are not interfering with law enforcement operations.
Hailey West, an independent journalist covering the protests, found something different.
“Interference is constant,” she told Public. “It’s like a badge of honor out there.” She described the “physical pushing of officers” by protesters who are “trying to break through a [police] line. They’ll send people who are mentally ill or disabled in a wheelchair to the front of the line.”
West expressed horror at the killings of Renee Good and Alex Pretti. “We don’t want to see what happened to Renee or Alex to continue,” she said. “We should want to protect our citizens.”
West described a situation of rising violence. In one instance, protesters threw tear gas at ICE agents, but hit the van that she and other reporters were sitting in instead.
“You have this massive group of protestors following all the vehicles,” she said. “They were throwing tear gas canisters, and one of them ended up being thrown on top of our vehicle, bounced off, went underneath the vehicle, and started filling the car up with tear gas.”
When asked if it was her only time being tear-gassed, West said, “No, I’ve been tear-gassed multiple times. Usually, I’ll have a gas mask, but unfortunately, I wasn’t able to take one on the plane. You get used to it after a certain point.”
West said that the protesters are “instructed to cause as much chaos so they can”...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2017113248210809005
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning journalism, read the full article and watch the whole video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It's inspiring how Gen Z journalists, Right and Left, have done some of the best reporting on Minneapolis.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
TCN
@TCNetwork
“I think Good and Pretti are victims of the left, and that should have been what they said.”
Tucker Carlson and @shellenberger call out Kristi Noem. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It was already clear that Alex Pretti was interfering in a law enforcement operation. Now, new @BBC video shows Pretti kicking out the taillight of an ICE SUV and wrestling with ICE agents. His gun is sticking out of his waistband. He screams & spits. He is deranged & dangerous.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Most of the debate since yesterday has focused, understandably, on whether the ICE agent acted in what he perceived to be self-defense. Whatever the case, it’s clear that, by encouraging people to interfere in law enforcement operations, the Left is getting people killed.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The news media irresponsibly downplayed or didn't properly report on how Pretti was deliberately interfering in a law enforcement operation on the day he was killed.
At a minimum he recklessly waved through traffic on the street and physically confronted ICE, as the image below clearly shows.
I shouldn't have to say this but some people need to hear it: I'm not defending the shooting. It was obviously a mistake. There should be a full investigation and people should be held accountable.
But it is also the case that Democrats, influencers, and the media are getting leftists killed by encouraging them to interfere with law enforcement operations and telling them that they are fighting Nazis.
Pretti showed exceedingly bad judgement in openly wearing a gun as he attacked an ICE vehicle. He showed similarly bad judgement interfering in the ICE operation on Saturday.
Pretti in the new video appears to be in the grip of that very familiar form of derangement.
Here is a link to the full @thenewsmovement video.
I saw some people have been trying to put Community Notes on this video. If you watch it, you will see that it is definitely Pretti, there is no evidence of AI manipulation, and the provenance of the video is known.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRWR13BAIEs
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"Interacting."
Totally irresponsible, @NBCNews
Shame on the media for once again grossly misreporting a story out of ideological bias.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The official narrative has been that ICE is over-policing, but the new video shows ICE officers erred by under-policing. They should have detained Pretti, asked a judge to take away his gun, and impose a restraining order. Had that happened, Pretti might still be alive today.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You can tell the video is rattling the people who rushed to judgement because they have to invent an argument that nobody is making.
Jonathan Chait
@jonathanchait
OBVIOUSLY they had to execute him, the man once kicked a car, for God's sake
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This should go for supposedly reasonable liberals, too. They got swept up in the pleasure of feeling righteous and insisted it was a simple black and white issue when it almost never is.
Matt Walsh
@MattWalshBlog
Any “conservative” who folded on this case and bought the left wing narrative should never be trusted or taken seriously again
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The official narrative has been that ICE is over-policing, but the new video shows ICE officers erred by under-policing. They should have detained Pretti, asked a judge to take away his gun, and impose a restraining order. Had that happened, Pretti might still be alive today.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Lucy Biggers
@LLBiggers
I spent half of my 20s as a brainwashed climate activist. This is the story of how I changed my mind and became a climate realist.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
House Judiciary GOP 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
@JudiciaryGOP
But the Commission didn’t stop there.
It also fined X €40,000,000 for not giving enough data to pro-censorship pseudoscientists.
Once again, the Commission’s claims were ridiculous. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Thomas Massie
@RepThomasMassie
I offered an amendment to zero out $315 mil. to NED (as did Crane). I voted for Crane’s amendment to zero out NED. When Crane’s amendment to cut NED did not pass, I voted against the final bill which contained the NED funding. At every step, Republicans enabled NED to be funded.
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
Joaquin Castro was the Impeachment Manager for the Democrats. He vowed to "prevent Trump from ever occupying the presidency again." Republicans just gave Castro $315 million to give out to his friends as a director on NED's board, which manages NED's political black ops grants.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Tucker Carlson
@TuckerCarlson
Chaos spreads like cancer in Minneapolis. What happens next?
(0:00) Monologue
(1:04:50) What Is Actually Happening in Minneapolis?
(1:11:50) The Militia Taking Over Minneapolis
(1:17:51) The Mission to Destroy Western Civilization
(1:29:22) How Can Donald Trump Fix This?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After months of being slandered by incredibly petty people, @CBSNews Editor-in-Chief @bariweiss has delivered an absolute Murderers' Row of contributors and a strategy for winning back the trust her haters lost by reporting fake news on Biden, border, Covid, Russiagate, BLM, etc
CBS News
@CBSNews
Tough questions. Straight answers. CBS News has gathered the sharpest minds on the topics that matter most.
@elliotackerman
@PeterAttiaMD
@AlinejadMasih
@arthurbrooks
Roger Carstens
Caroline Chambers
Clare de Boer
Sir Niall Ferguson
Roland Fryer, Jr.
@hubermanlab
@coldxman
@drmarkhyman
@JannaLevin
@caseymlewis
@LTGHRMcMaster
@PatrickMcGee_
@reihan
@lapresmidi
@DKThomp
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
And this is obviously the right journalistic strategy and something that CBS should have done long ago.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Agree or disagree with them, the new contributors are major voices. Two of them, @hubermanlab and @PeterAttiaMD have revolutionized health and improved millions of lives (including mine) by emphasizing strength training, morning light, sauna & more.
Andrew D. Huberman, Ph.D.
@hubermanlab
On the Huberman Lab podcast, I’ve always gone issue-by-issue on health & science, spoken to experts w/a range of takes & presented where I see the center of (data) mass pointed. I’ll do the same with @CBSNews
Huberman Lab podcast remains independent.
& view sunlight in the am!
CBS News
@CBSNews
Tough questions. Straight answers. CBS News has gathered the sharpest minds on the topics that matter most.
@elliotackerman
@PeterAttiaMD
@AlinejadMasih
@arthurbrooks
Roger Carstens
Caroline Chambers
Clare de Boer
Sir Niall Ferguson
Roland Fryer, Jr.
@hubermanlab
@coldxman
@drmarkhyman
@JannaLevin
@caseymlewis
@LTGHRMcMaster
@PatrickMcGee_
@reihan
@lapresmidi
@DKThomp -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Mike Benz
@MikeBenzCyber
The TikTok censorship this week is genuinely insane. It’s a very bad look to have more censorship under American management than under Chinese management. It almost goes without saying that if it doesn’t reverse course immediately, it deserves the scandal & exodus it’s getting.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Jon Root
@JonnyRoot_
This is the most reasonable, factual, & respectful take I’ve heard regarding the Alex Pretti Border Patrol shooting in Minneapolis, Minnesota.
Take a few minutes & give it a listen.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Seriously, @sundarpichai ?
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
amyjacobson
@amyjacobson
If Anne Frank and her family were offered $3500 and plane tickets safely out of their attic - I’m sure they would have taken that deal!
Don’t you dare compare to Anne Frank - it’s disrespectful to Holocaust families to do so.
End Wokeness
@EndWokeness
Gov. Walz: "We grew up reading the story of Anne Frank. Somebody is gonna write one regarding Minnesota."
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Most of the debate since yesterday has focused, understandably, on whether the ICE agent acted in what he perceived to be self-defense. Whatever the case, it’s clear that, by encouraging people to interfere in law enforcement operations, the Left is getting people killed.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I have great respect for genuine nonviolent civil disobedience. That's not what either Good or Pretti were doing. They were both interfering in a police operation.
Pretti thought it was a good idea to take a gun. Yes, he has a Second Amendment right to do so. Yes, I support that right. I also support the right of young women to walk through dangerous neighborhoods wearing binkis and high heels but it would be deeply irresponsible for me to recommend it.
While Good and Pretti were responsible for their actions, as are the ICE officers and many others, it was the Left above anyone else who got Good and Pretti killed. They are victims of a culture that taught entitled Millennials to seek heroism through radical Leftism, including by entering into dangerous situations without any real sense of the risks to themselves and others.
That behavior is the opposite of the thoughtfulness and care taken by those who engaged in genuine nonviolent civil disobedience in the past, whereby people risk arrest, not death — or the deaths of others around them.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
As a former radical Leftist who has engaged in civil disobedience several times, I was always impressed by the level of care taken by those who organized it, and I always avoided anyone trying to do it who didn't know what they were doing.
When I led a civil disobedience protest to save the Diablo Canyon nuclear power plant in 2016, I took the safety of everyone participating extremely seriously and was in close communication with the security guards the entire time. It was so safe that children were safely there.
I understood back then as everyone should today that any interference with security operations is exceedingly dangerous and risks death, not just for you but for innocent people around you. Believing passionately for a cause should make you more not less responsible.
Entitled Millennial progressives raised in confort and in an online world have developed a deeply delusional and entitled view of their own security and safety. Pretti's own father had warned him, to no avail.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Well there you have it
Greg Price
@greg_price11
In 2023, Gavin Newsom signed a bill into law that banned guns from being carried at "sensitive places," which included protests.
Gavin Newsom
@GavinNewsom
The Trump administration does not believe in the 2nd Amendment. Good to know.
Acyn
@Acyn
Doocy: Where does it go from peaceful protest to I’m going to get shot to death?
Noem: You shouldn't show up with weapons, no ID, and no indication of how they're going to be used.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is the manual instructing people on how to interfere with law enforcement operations
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Incredible scoop by @camhigby
Cam Higby 🇺🇸
@camhigby
🚨🚨 Here is the entire TRAINING MANUAL for domestic terrorist patrols chasing ICE agents in Minneapolis.
Keep in mind, this is the watered down opsec version.
MUST READ ⬇️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Even the organizers twice warned people not to bring weapons
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is straight up thuggery
x.com/haileyywest/status/2015090151093837960
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After the 2024 election, Democrats appeared to be rethinking their radicalism. Americans had rejected the Left agenda on borders, econ., crime, race, trans, and climate. One year later, that’s all changed. Sensing a political advantage, they have returned to their comfort zone.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Most of the debate since yesterday has focused, understandably, on whether the ICE agent acted in what he perceived to be self-defense. Whatever the case, it’s clear that, by encouraging people to interfere in law enforcement operations, the Left is getting people killed.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In response to several comments:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I have great respect for genuine nonviolent civil disobedience. That's not what either Good or Pretti were doing. They were both interfering in a police operation.
Pretti thought it was a good idea to take a gun. Yes, he has a Second Amendment right to do so. Yes, I support that right. I also support the right of young women to walk through dangerous neighborhoods wearing binkis and high heels but it would be deeply irresponsible for me to recommend it.
While Good and Pretti were responsible for their actions, as are the ICE officers and many others, it was the Left above anyone else who got Good and Pretti killed. They are victims of a culture that taught entitled Millennials to seek heroism through radical Leftism, including by entering into dangerous situations without any real sense of the risks to themselves and others.
That behavior is the opposite of the thoughtfulness and care taken by those who engaged in genuine nonviolent civil disobedience in the past, whereby people risk arrest, not death — or the deaths of others around them.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
👀
Greg Price
@greg_price11
In 2023, Gavin Newsom signed a bill into law that banned guns from being carried at "sensitive places," which included protests.
Gavin Newsom
@GavinNewsom
The Trump administration does not believe in the 2nd Amendment. Good to know.
Acyn
@Acyn
Doocy: Where does it go from peaceful protest to I’m going to get shot to death?
Noem: You shouldn't show up with weapons, no ID, and no indication of how they're going to be used.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The transformation of Democrats into a radical Left party is one of the most important political stories of the last 10 years. One might argue that the rise of Trump is more important. But the party hadn't radicalized, it's unlikely he would have been elected and reelected.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is the manual instructing people on how to interfere with law enforcement operations
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Greg Price
@greg_price11
In 2023, Gavin Newsom signed a bill into law that banned guns from being carried at "sensitive places," which included protests.
Gavin Newsom
@GavinNewsom
The Trump administration does not believe in the 2nd Amendment. Good to know.
Acyn
@Acyn
Doocy: Where does it go from peaceful protest to I’m going to get shot to death?
Noem: You shouldn't show up with weapons, no ID, and no indication of how they're going to be used. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Doug Bright
@DougBright1
Waltz is telling people to go film ICE he’s compiling a data base while simultaneously telling law enforcement to stand down.Minneapolis PD isn’t even there for crowd control. citizens are on their own. So one shows up to film like the Governor said and brings a gun into a crime scene where he knows he’ll be outgunned 30-1 and gets himself killed. The Mayor and the Governor are getting people killed. They aren’t even providing basic public safety. We’re about 48 hours away from vigilantism.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The WEF, which meets in Davos this week, said "stakeholder capitalism" would benefit consumers. Instead, it raised prices, indebted the US, and deindustrialized Europe. The idea rested upon the Big Lie that problems of corruption were a result of capitalism, says @desireefixler.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For decades, the World Economic Forum (WEF), which gathers this week in Davos, Switzerland, has advocated for “stakeholder capitalism.” In practice, stakeholder capitalism meant NGOs like WEF working with the world’s largest corporations and governments to change laws across the West to mandate stricter climate regulations and heavily subsidize green energy.
As a result, uncompetitively high energy prices led Europe to lose its manufacturing base to China, while taxpayers in the US and other nations have lost trillions of dollars subsidizing green energy. “Stakeholder capitalism” had no visible impact on the trajectory of fossil fuel use, which rose globally by 34 percent between 2000 and 2025. What it accomplished was transferring trillions in wealth from the public to bankers, investors, and the government insiders who attend Davos...
x.com/shellenberger/status/2013355048525316462
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative journalism, read the rest of the story, and watch the full video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"Transparency"
Desiree Fixler
@desireefixler
Yep, the WEF is all about governance, resilience, and culture - so much so, it’s turned off its X comment button.
@WEF, I dare you to engage with the public. Turn comments back on. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
President Trump defunded much of the Censorship Industrial Complex, but around the world, its power is growing. Within a few years, the most intolerant people on Earth could control the Internet. This is my warning to the world.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
On March 15th, 2021, an anonymous Twitter user asked Harvard Medical professor Martin Kulldorff a question. “Do you think younger age groups and or people who have already had the virus need to be vaccinated?”
Who is Martin Kulldorff? He’s a Harvard Medical School professor for 21 years, a well-known Swedish biostatistician who developed widely used software for disease mapping, the co-author of the Great Barrington Declaration on how to deal with the COVID pandemic, and an advisor to the world’s leading health organizations.
What he said was that “Thinking that everyone must be vaccinated is as scientifically flawed as thinking that nobody should get COVID. Vaccines are important for older high-risk people and their caretakers. Those with prior natural infection do not need it, nor do children.”
Natural immunity. Is it a myth — a “conspiracy theory” — that once you have been sick from a virus, then you won’t get sick, or as sick, again?
In fact, we’ve known for 2,500 years that natural immunity is real. “The same man was never attacked twice, never at least fatally,” wrote Thucydides, describing the plague of Athens. He observed that recovered individuals could safely nurse the sick without falling ill themselves.
And yet Twitter censored Martin Kulldorff’s tweet. “Learn why health officials recommend a vaccine,” read a warning that Twitter employees put on it. For most people, the Tweet cannot be replied to, shared or liked. In other words, Twitter had decided that this professor at Harvard Medical School was wrong, and that natural immunity wasn’t really something that could protect you from COVID.
Jay Bhattacharya, who’s currently our Director of the National Institutes of Health, and thus one of the highest-ranking public health officials in the world, was a Stanford epidemiologist before that. Twitter put him on a “Trends Blacklist.” Not long before we discovered this, we were told that shadow-banning was a conspiracy theory, because Twitter had said it didn’t shadow-ban.
Now the European Commission is trying to censor the entire global internet. They want to put a 140 million Euro fine on X. They want to end anonymity, which was what allowed that question of Kulldorff to be asked. They want to use a “Democracy Shield” program to shield the Commission from democracy. And the Commission wants to impose “chat control” so they can read your private messages. It just gets worse and worse. Unsubstantiated and likely false claims of Russian government election interference through TikTok and social media were made in Romania and in the Czech Republic.
Truth is not something that anybody holds as a possession and rather emerges through dialogue. We’ve known that since Plato and Socrates. We need free speech for science, public health, and national security. It’s essential to journalism, democracy, and human freedom. Free speech enabled civilization; censorship threatens it. This is the only political cause that I would die for.
And yet there is currently an active coordination between Stanford, Brazil, Australia, and others to impose what I think we can call, without exaggeration, global totalitarianism. They’re pushing for digital identification that will end anonymity online.
Why is that? Why are these guys behaving in this way?
When Elon Musk took over Twitter on October 28th, 2022, unprecedented insight into multiple secret government mass censorship efforts emerged from this exploration. We had unlimited access to Twitter files. They revealed that the mainstream news reporters, who don’t deserve the name, were demanding censorship. No true journalist demands censorship of his fellow journalists.
What emerged from this was an understanding of something we call the “Censorship Industrial Complex,” which directly grew out of the military industrial complex and was run by active or former intelligence community officials who often operate under that banner.
It led to multiple congressional investigations and hearings, and it spread across every social media platform. So we now know the censorship that occurred, not just at Twitter, but at YouTube, at Facebook, TikTok, and other platforms.
What is the Censorship Industrial Complex? The model isn’t that complicated to understand. The government chooses people whom they call “researchers” to serve as censors. These are government-funded individuals who often come from the intelligence community and foreign policy establishment. They work at non-governmental organizations funded by governments or at universities funded by governments. They conduct “fact checks” to serve as “trusted flaggers.” These “trusted flaggers” demand censorship by social media platforms. It’s all done in secret.
They’re looking to censor narratives. This is essential because, as decades of good cognitive science have shown, people understand and retain information through storytelling. We think in terms of stories, not bullet points. And so they were out to censor whole narratives. From the Stanford censorship project on COVID, the “Virality Project,” they said they wanted to censor “true stories” of vaccine side effects.
Why? Because it might “fuel hesitancy.” In other words, they want to control your behavior. They don’t want you to receive true information that might lead you to not get the vaccine.
If that isn’t totalitarianism straight out of 1984, I don’t know what it. These people were on the verge of passing legislation in the United States that would’ve authorized the National Science Foundation to choose these “researcher” censors.
I’m presenting slides to Europeans and the world for situational awareness into what totalitarian politicians and bureaucrats have planned because this is still going strong.
Stanford helped the US government censor COVID dissidents, and then they lied about it. You might be detecting a pattern. They’re really not interested in censoring “misinformation.’ They’re very interested in censoring true information.
The censors flagged an Israeli preprint which came out in December, 2020 and found, lo and behold, that natural immunity is a real thing. In fact, it’s more protective than the vaccine.
But the censors flagged somebody’s Google Drive. “See the following Google Drive links being used to compile testimonies about vaccine shedding, Covid videos, showing side effects and whatnot.” Google then removed that content from that person’s Google Drive. You don’t control your Google Drive.
Contrary to Stanford’s claim that the project did not ask social media platforms to remove any content, they privately said they did. And we know that many hundreds of thousands of tweets and Facebook posts were removed, even though they were a hundred percent accurate. In fact, in 2021, Stanford’s “Virality Project” flagged accurate claims that the World Health Organization did not recommend vaccinating children.
The people who spread the misinformation are the people demanding the censorship. They claimed Covid couldn’t have come from a lab, that the Covid vaccine prevented infection, and that natural immunity didn’t exist.
The only solution to hate speech and misinformation is free speech. If you censor false information, how would anybody get the true information? The whole point is the debate.
They lied when they said false information travels faster than true information. It’s a completely bogus study and involved six seconds of content on Twitter.
Who are these people? As of 2020, there were so many former FBI employees at Twitter that they called them “Bu alumni.” They created their own private Slack channel and a crib sheet to onboard new FBI arrivals.
Intriguingly, we discovered that the general counsel of the FBI — arguably the second most powerful person of the FBI, or maybe the first, if you think, consider that what their actual job is to decide what the FBI can and can’t do — resigned from FBI in early 2020 and went to Twitter to take the deputy general counsel role.
Isn’t that interesting? Somebody in one of the most powerful legal positions in the world would take a junior legal role at a social media company. Why would that be? This email popped up when we were going through Twitter files and it really jumped out at us.
It’s from the director of policy at Twitter. “We have seen a sustained if uncoordinated” — supposedly — “effort by the intelligence community to push us to share more information and change our API policies. They’re probing and pushing everywhere they can.”
The Hunter Biden laptop censorship occurred later that year. The FBI and the intelligence community discredited accurate, factual information about Hunter Biden’s foreign business dealings both before and after the New York Post revealed the contents of his laptop on October 14th, 2020.
How could the FBI spread false information about something that nobody knew about?
Because the FBI had Hunter Biden’s laptop, which showed his family’s massive influence peddling scheme. It consisted of accepting tens of millions of dollars, including from the Chinese government. The FBI had been sitting on that laptop since December of 2019. They had been given it by the computer repair store owner, who had been given the laptop by Hunter Biden, likely because he dropped it in his bathtub or in the pool, when he was on one of his many crack and alcohol benders.
The government strategy is always the same: spread disinformation first, then demand censorship of accurate information on the basis of it
.
“The FBI came to us in the summer of 2020,” Mark Zuckerberg told Joe Rogan two years later, “and they were like, ‘Hey, you should be on the alert. We thought that there was a lot of Russian propaganda in 2016. There’s about to be some kind of dump.’”
In the summer of 2020, the New York Post had not published the story about the Hunter Biden laptop. It would only come out in October.
We see something very interesting show up in the Twitter files: the Aspen Institute, an intermediary between the intelligence community and the public. It’s known as a Davos-style gab fest in the United States. It’s also the place where intelligence community operations are run.
They hosted a workshop to train reporters and all of the social media’s top censorship officials, known as “trust and safety officials,” how to deal with a story they would hear in the future relating to Hunter Biden and Barisma.
A few months earlier, the Stanford Cyber Policy Center had published a report attacking what we in the United States call the Pentagon Papers Principle. The Pentagon Papers Principle says that if a government official gives me, a journalist, a bunch of Pentagon documents showing that we’re losing the war in Vietnam, I, as a journalist, can publish them, and not risk prison. That was decided in a famous Supreme Court case in 1971.
Stanford argued that, really, we should get rid of that principle, which may be the most important investigative journalism principle in the United States, and said, “You should cover the person who leaked the materials, not the leaked emails.”
In other words, you should cover and expose the whistleblower. The person who exposed the Pentagon Papers is the real bad guy, not the DOD, CIA, and presidents who had lied to us for over a decade.
Stanford was training the journalists and the social media trust and safety officers in how to cover a story that had not yet come out. This is known as “pre-bunking,” and it’s also part of the European Union strategy to shield themselves from democracy.
When the Hunter Biden story appeared October 22nd, Twitter’s trust and safety censorship official said it didn’t violate its terms of service. There’s nothing illegal about any of this. The Supreme Court has made it very clear that you’re allowed to report on information that’s been leaked to you.
At that moment, the former FBI general counsel, Jim Baker, argued vigorously that Twitter really needed to censor it. Baker won and they censored the story.
It’s not that we didn’t hear about the Hunter Biden laptop story when it came out. I certainly did. But we had the impression that there was something wrong with it, that it was not really the whole story. And so many of us dismissed it.
What they had done was a psyop on this major story. They had changed our perception of the story. And it worked. It worked on me, it worked on everybody I knew.
What is the role of the intelligence community of social media companies? The former CIA people are the head of elections at Meta, and Google’s head of trust and safety. Former and current CIA officers have a history of spreading misinformation and promoting the Russiagate conspiracy theory.
We now know that between 2018 and 2023, there were 36 people from the CIA 68 from the FBI 44, from the National Security Administration and 68 from the Department of Homeland Security who had moved to work at the social media platforms.
This is not unique to the United States. My colleague Cecilia Jilková, the daughter of famous Czech dissidents, discovered that European Union officials claimed, days before the European elections in 2024, that a “pro-Kremlin website” was spreading propaganda and were paying off European politicians.
That was the headline in Politico. We wrote to them and asked, “Where’s the evidence of this? Just go ahead and share the evidence to support your accusation days before the European parliamentary elections.” Nobody was arrested. They never produced the evidence. The former Czech president, Václav Klaus, who was accused of this, said, “We don’t even know what the ‘Voice of Europe’ is.”
Another Czech politician said, “How could I have known it would be a security threat? At the time I gave the interview, they weren’t on any list.”
Another said, “If they’re such a big threat, why did the European Parliament let the Voice of Europe’s journalists inside?”
Nobody responded. Nobody talked to us. This was a disinformation campaign carried by Politico, which, in my view, is a suspect publication.
In the spring of 2022, Barack Obama went to Stanford to give a speech at the Stanford Cyber Policy Center run by Michael McFaul, his former ambassador to Russia. Obama said misinformation harms democracy and urged support for legislation in Congress that would empower government-appointed researchers to serve as “trusted flaggers.”
Six days later, the Department of Homeland Security rolled out their Disinformation Governance Board. What a coincidence that they got Obama to frame the issue for them.
Facebook in 2021 censored accurate vaccine information so the White House would help it to get data from Europe. In addition to removing vaccine misinformation, wrote Facebook to the White House, we have been focused on reducing the virality of content discouraging vaccines that does not contain actionable misinformation.
White House said jump, and Facebook said how high? Why did they do it? Why would they voluntarily censor?
This also emerged from the Facebook files. Nick Clegg on the left wrote an email to his colleagues. He said, “My sense is that given we’ve got bigger fish, we have to fry with the administration, e.g., data flows, it doesn’t seem like a great place for us to be.”
Data flows. What’s he talking about? He’s talking about billions of dollars worth of business that he has to, that they would have to pay the European Commission for if they didn’t have the support from the Biden administration to lean on the European Commission.
In other words, this was a shakedown by the White House of Facebook and it worked in France, the country of Liberté. Turns out it has a special role....
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of free speech, watch the full video, and read the rest of the article!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Please subscribe now to support our defense of free speech, read the rest of the article, and watch the rest of the video:
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The progressive city leaders of Austin, Texas say they want the homeless to go to a new "navigation center" next to an elementary school and a high school. We asked local homeless people what to expect. They said meth, fentanyl, and people getting beaten or stabbed to death.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Thank you to my students Eliana Ulloa and Emerson Lau, in the video below, for joining me. I am teaching a course in journalism this quarter @uaustinorg where we take pride in teaching students how to navigate unsafe spaces.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Please follow @EmersonLau and @EllieUlloa !
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It's up to parents not governments if their children watch social media — ban or no ban. As such, the bans are nothing more than a Trojan horse for governments to end anonymity online and impose digital IDs on everyone in order to censor & control the public.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The man behind the digital ID push is Larry Ellison, owner of Oracle, CBS, CNN, and, soon, TikTok. He wants data centralization and total surveillance. "Citizens will be on their best behavior because we're constantly watching & recording everything that's going on." Terrifying.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Camus
@newstart_2024
Michael Shellenberger drops the brutal truth:
Left-wing authoritarianism is almost identical to narcissism
Entitlement (“we decide what you can say”), grandiosity (“we’re the good people”), and psychopathy (“we don’t care about the harm we cause”).
They claim to protect the vulnerable… but blame victims when things go wrong (see WPATH files).
The playbook: Charismatic narcissists mesmerize with “liberation” language… psychopaths enforce with censorship & firing.
2:52 clip — chilling breakdown of how power really works 👇
Is this the real face of modern “progressive” authoritarianism? Your take.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
If @GavinNewsom becomes president, he will federalize the practice of taking children from parents who refuse to block their puberty, give them cross sex hormones, and let surgeons operate on their bodies. Horror movie plots too unrealistic for film are daily life in California.
REDUXX
@reduxx
🚨A Ukrainian family in California has lost custody of their daughter after refusing to allow her to medically transition to a "boy."
Speaking to Reduxx, the parents say they were also entered into an abuse registry by child protective services.
reduxx.info/california-family-loses-custody-of-daughter-a…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Every politician who supports this medical barbarism, or has stayed quiet about it, will one day regret their complicity.
@GavinNewsom @AOC
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
THE WPATH FILES
Advocates of gender-affirming care say it’s evidence-based.
But now, newly released internal files from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) prove that the practice of transgender medicine is neither scientific nor medical.
American Medical Association, The Endocrine Society, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and thousands of doctors worldwide rely on WPATH. It is considered the leading global authority on gender medicine.
And yet WPATH’s internal files, which include written discussions and a video, reveal that its members know they are creating victims and not getting “informed consent.”
Victims include a 10-year-old girl, a 13-year-old developmentally delayed adolescent, and individuals suffering from schizophrenia and other serious mental illnesses.
The injuries described in the WPATH Files include sterilization, loss of sexual function, liver tumors, and death.
WPATH members indicate repeatedly that they know that many children and their parents don’t understand the effects that puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries will have on their bodies. And yet, they continue to perform and advocate for gender medicine.
The WPATH Files prove that gender medicine is comprised of unregulated and pseudoscientific experiments on children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults. It will go down as one of the worst medical scandals in history.
environmentalprogress.org/big-news/wpath-filesPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
They won't rest until the US government can take children from every parent in American who tries to protect their children from being sterilized and mutilated. They aren't hiding this. This is already the law in California.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I’m afraid I have some terrible news. The governor of America’s largest and richest state has just signed a law that puts 10 million children and adolescents in grave danger of medical mistreatment.
The media headlines have it wrong. They claim that California Governor Gavin Newsom’s new law protects children by stopping public schools from outing their new gender to their parents.
It does just the opposite. It makes children vulnerable to irreversible and lifelong medical abuse and mistreatment. And it is all based on the pseudoscientific idea that some children are born into the wrong bodies and that we can change a person’s sex through drugs and surgery.
For any of this to make sense, you have to understand what’s happening in Britain. Several years ago, the government appointed a well-respected pediatrician named Hillary Cass to investigate whether it was ethical to block the puberty of children, give them opposite-sex hormones, and perform surgeries on their bodies to make them feel better about their gender. Dr. Cass came back a few weeks ago and said no, absolutely not.
Around the same time, the British government banned puberty blockers nationwide. And, just a few days ago, the new Labor Party government affirmed that it would maintain the former government’s ban.
In her report, Cass said that the so-called “social transition,” whereby a child adopts the identity of the opposite sex, is not a neutral act and has psychological consequences. This means it is the first step toward medical intervention.
What Gavin Newsom has done is actively prevented schools from informing parents that their children have been put on a medical pathway.
This is an outrageous attack on the rights of children and parents. Children have a right to go through puberty. No adult should be able to block their puberty. And parents have a right to know if their child thinks that they are the opposite sex or were born into the wrong body.
We have seen with leaked internal documents of the leading gender medicine group, WPATH, that these medical interventions, namely puberty blockers, hormones, and surgery, are not only irreversible but result in sterilization and loss of sexual function.
Children or adolescents are simply not mature enough to understand the effects of so-called “gender-affirming care.” They cannot, in other words, give their informed consent.
The new law creates the grave risk that activist teachers, students, and outside groups will convince their children that they were born into the wrong body, and hide their “social transition” from parents, which will lead to harmful medical mistreatment.
As such, the law that Newsom just signed is the opposite of what both children and their parents need. We need schools to immediately warn parents if their children think they are the opposite sex.
After all, this is a diagnosable psychiatric condition known as “gender dysphoria.” And if your child has a psychiatric disorder, whether anxiety, depression, an eating disorder, or gender dysphoria, you have a right to know.
And schools must stop teaching children, or allowing other people to teach children, the pseudoscientific and dehumanizing ideas that it’s possible to be born into the wrong body and possible to change one’s sex.
As such, either the legislature, the courts, or a ballot initiative will be required to nullify Newsom’s law. Until then, it is important to spread the word to parents that California public schools are fundamentally unsafe for the millions of children who attend them.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
More terrifying than any horror movie. More gruesome than any David Cronenberg film.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Foreign leaders say new social media rules have nothing to do with censorship. It's not true. The goal is to pressure X & Facebook to be more censorial. EU, BRICS, Aus/NZ, & Stanford/Soros censorship leaders are plotting to enforce their rules here when Democrats return to power
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The European Union and other nations have laws aimed at promoting competition among tech companies. The European Union’s (EU) Digital Markets Act (DMA) has been a model for other nations, including Brazil, where the government is seeking to pass similar legislation. The European Commission says the DMA regulates the largest social media companies, such as X and Facebook, to prevent them from abusing their monopoly positions and to create a level playing field for smaller businesses and greater choice for users.
But free speech advocates in the US and Brazil believe that such legislation is a strategy to expand censorship. “This bill represents yet another attempt by the Lula administration to control public debate in Brazil,” said Brazilian Congressman Marcel Van Hattam. “Under the pretext of ‘digital market regulation,’ the government is creating a pressure tool over major platforms, effectively giving the state a blank check to impose unnecessary, arbitrary, and company-specific rules under the threat of heavy penalties.”
Brazil’s Ministry of Finance, which is advocating for the legislation, denies that its goal is censorship. The proposed legislation “deals exclusively with economic and competition aspects associated with large technology companies,” it said in a statement to Public, “without distinction of their origin, and does not include rules regarding content distributed by big tech companies.”
But Rep. Jim Jordan (R-OH), the Chairman of the powerful House Judiciary Committee, recently joined Van Hattam in raising the alarm about the apparent effort by Europe, Brazil and other nations to force US tech companies to engage in more censorship of speech that is legally protected in the US.
“Six of the seven businesses that the Commission has designated as gatekeepers are American companies or wholly owned subsidiaries of American companies,” wrote Jordan late last month in a letter to Brazil’s Finance Ministry’s Secretariat for Economic Reforms, Alexandre Rebêlo Ferreira. “Companies that CADE [the regulatory agency] deems noncompliant are subject to fines of up to 20 percent of their gross revenue in the ‘affected line of business.’”
x.com/shellenberger/status/2009297963160322456
Please subscribe now to support Public's defense of free speech, read the rest of the article, and watch the rest of the video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Here is the letter from @Jim_Jordan to Alexandre Rebêlo Ferreira, Secretariat for Economic Reforms, Ministry of Finance, in the @LulaOficial Government
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Dealing with our biggest problems, like affordability, requires laser focus. Oil prices are at historic lows, thanks in large part to Trump. But housing, insurance, and other prices are too high. Our problems could worsen if we try to control a foreign country run by gangsters.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
a newsman
@a_newsman
Megyn Kelly says as a Fox News anchor she knows her job would have been to uncritically cheer on regime change in Venezuela as virtually everyone at the network spent the weekend doing. However, after watching the long history of failed interventions, she believes it’s prudent to remain skeptical of this latest one.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It's honorable to want to help Venezuela, but it can't be helped. Its oil-fueled corruption is endemic. We don't need its oil and trying to rebuild its industry would require a dangerous level of intervention that would harm the US and destroy the @realDonaldTrump presidency.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"Maduro’s top lieutenant Delcy Rodríguez was sworn in as the country’s acting president Monday, as small groups of armed civilians known as colectivos, paramilitary units in support of the ousted president, sped around the city on motorbikes—a reminder that while Maduro is gone, his loyalists are still very much in power."
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"Latin America analysts have previously cautioned, including during Trump’s first term, that Maduro’s ouster without a capable replacement would likely empower armed military factions, rival politicians and criminal groups within Venezuela as they fought for control, leading to a security crisis in the country."
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
US forces easily drove Saddam from power, then captured him in December, 2003.
The US nonetheless stayed in Iraq for many more years. The vast majority of American troops were killed after Saddam's capture, not before.
That's because simply detaining a leader is meaningless.
Robby Starbuck
@robbystarbuck
No one would’ve cared about the wars in Iraq or Afghanistan if they had been pulled off like this. It’s never been clearer that our young men in those 2 wars were sacrificed by cowards in DC. It could have been like this Maduro mission. Politicians chose forever $$$ wars instead.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
🍓Sined Warrior🐭🍓
@SinedWarrior
Fabrice Epelboin explique à un plateau de C ce soir éberlué comment la gauche américaine a gravement violé le 1er amendement de la Constitution (sur la liberté d’expression).
Et les conséquences énormes que cela aura, via les révélations publiques dans les prochains mois.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Tocsin
@Tocsin_Media
🔴 RÉVÉLATIONS : Le journaliste Michael Shellenberger lâche une bombe politique issue des #twitterfiles
💬 « Je n'avais jamais vu un chef d'État s'impliquer aussi directement que Macron dans le complexe industriel de la censure. »
Réécouter l'émission 🔗youtu.be/L8mLBAgSQeQ
🔎@ShellenbergerMD dévoile l'existence d'une action secrète coordonnée personnellement par Emmanuel #macron, alliant l'Élysée à des ONG sous influence (financements publics/services de renseignement) pour faire pression sur #twitter. Selon lui, la #france a même servi de "laboratoire" mondial à ces méthodes de contrôle de l'information, héritées de la loi Pleven.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Rona
@ronalyze
HateAid hilft nur Personen juristisch, die einer linksgrünen Ideologie folgen. Feministinnen, die seit Jahren von linken und grünen Politikern auf‘s übelste beschimpft und bedroht werden, unterstützt man nicht, weil geschlechtsbasierte Frauenrechte „queerfeindlich“ sind. Und selbstverständlich beteiligt Man sich selbst daran, Feministinnen als „TERFs“ zu entmenschlichen. hateaid.org/queerfeindlichkeit/
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Lilie
@Cyberlilie
Shellenberger balance tout 😏
Macron impliqué directement dans la censure sur Twitter via des ONG liées à l’État.
La France, championne mondiale de la censure ?
Merci à @Tocsin_Media pour leur excellent travail d’enquête 👌
Regardez ça, c’est édifiant.
Lien de la vidéo complète :
youtu.be/L8mLBAgSQeQ…
#censure #dsa #macroncensure #frenchtwitterfiles #libertéDExpression #censureue #souverainetéNumérique #tocsin #liberté
👇👇👇This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Pauline Voss
@Pauline__Voss
Wer sich mit der Arbeit von HateAid genauer befasst, erkennt, dass die Organisation aus genau einem Grund die Gunst der Regierung genießt: Sie ermöglicht es den Mächtigen, den Kampf gegen Regierungskritiker als demokratischen Akt umzudeuten. Der größte Erfolg von HateAid besteht nicht in gewonnen Prozessen oder dem Abgreifen staatlicher Fördergelder. Ihr größter Erfolg ist die Umdeutung dessen, was Meinungsfreiheit bedeutet.
Das Narrativ, das HateAid im Mainstream etabliert hat, besteht aus drei einfachen Regeln:
Zensur ist „Meinungsfreiheit“.
Meinungsfreiheit ohne Zensur ist „Hass“.
Das Ende der Zensur ist ein „Angriff auf die freie Rede“.
Das große NIUS-Dossier der HateAid-Zensur:
nius.de/articles/zensur-hateaid-meinungsfreiheit/9d472a81… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Alexandros Marinos 🏴☠️
@alexandrosM
You froze the bank accounts of Jaques Baud, a Swiss citizen residing in Belgium, and banned every EU businesses from transacting with him such that he can't even buy bread or pay rent, and your own rationale is that you didn't like what he was saying. You did this with no due process, no right of appeal, and no way to defend himself from your slanderous and ruinous accusations. And he's not the only one.
You obviously have no comprehension of the terms you use, what their meaning is, or what is the purpose of the principles you so easily throw around.
Unfortunately, EU citizens never elected you, so they can't unelect you. You'll keep turning the EU into USSR until your failed experiment comes crashing down. Until then, spare us the lectures. Your actions are deafening.
Ursula von der Leyen
@vonderleyen
Freedom of speech is the foundation of our strong and vibrant European democracy.
We are proud of it. We will protect it.
Because the @EU_Commission is the guardian of our values.
European Commission
@EU_Commission
We strongly condemn the U.S. decision to impose travel restrictions on five European individuals, including former Commissioner Thierry Breton.
Link to full statement: link.europa.eu/NtMX4K -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Laura Powell
@LauraPowellEsq
Apparently traveling to the EU is a privilege, but traveling to the US is a human right.
Kaja Kallas
@kajakallas
The decision by the U.S. to impose travel restrictions on European citizens and officials is unacceptable and an attempt to challenge our sovereignty.
Europe will keep defending its values — freedom of expression, fair digital rules, and the right to regulate our own space.
European Commission
@EU_Commission
We strongly condemn the U.S. decision to impose travel restrictions on five European individuals, including former Commissioner Thierry Breton.
Link to full statement: link.europa.eu/NtMX4K -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Steinhoefel
@Steinhoefel
„Ich erinnere mich, dass ich letztes Jahr dachte, dies sei einer der beängstigendsten Briefe, die ich je gelesen habe. Er behandelt die Meinungsfreiheit lediglich als einen Faktor, der gegen ‚nachteilige Auswirkungen auf den bürgerlichen Diskurs und die öffentliche Sicherheit‘ abgewogen werden muss. Und der Brief richtete sich gezielt gegen eine Unterhaltung auf eben dieser Plattform zwischen @elonmusk, einem Amerikaner, und @realDonaldTrump, ebenfalls ein Amerikaner, der zu diesem Zeitpunkt für die US-Präsidentschaft kandidierte.
Wenn der Brief in diesem Zusammenhang von ‚Inhalten spricht, die zu Gewalt, Hass und Rassismus in Verbindung mit bedeutenden politischen – oder gesellschaftlichen – Ereignissen weltweit aufstacheln könnten‘, dann ist damit der Kernbereich politischer Rede gemeint. Mehr als jedes andere Dokument, das ich je gelesen habe, zeigt dieser Brief die Zähne des globalen Zensur-Industrie-Komplexes und unterstreicht, dass ungewählte Bürokraten in der EU bereit, gewillt und in der Lage sind, ihre regulatorische Reichweite zu nutzen, um zu versuchen, Wahlen zu beeinflussen und den ersten Verfassungszusatz (First Amendment) in den USA auszuhebeln.
Als ich Anfang des Monats über den eklatanten Widerspruch zwischen den Beziehungen der USA zur EU und zur NATO schrieb, war es genau das, was ich im Sinn hatte. Wenn die souveränen Nationen Europas zulassen, dass die EU Grundfreiheiten in den USA angreift, können dieselben Nationen nicht erwarten, dass die USA Grundfreiheiten in Europa verteidigen.“ @DeputySecState -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
zerohedge
@zerohedge
Hey Imran, fuck you
Under Secretary of State Sarah B. Rogers
@UnderSecPD
WE’VE SANCTIONED: Imran Ahmed, key collaborator with the Biden Administration’s effort to weaponize the government against U.S. citizens. Ahmed’s group, Center for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH), created the infamous “disinformation dozen” report, which called for platforms to deplatform twelve American “anti-vaxxers”, including now-HHS Secretary @SecKennedy. Leaked documents from CCDH show the organization listed “kill Musk’s Twitter” and “trigger EU and UK regulatory action” as priorities. The organization supports the UK’s Online Safety Act and EU’s Digital Services Act to expand censorship in Europe and around the world.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Richard
@ricwe123
So here we have Ursula von der Leyen describing free speech as a virus and censorship as its vaccine.......
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Julian Reichelt
@jreichelt
Those who fund censorship with tax money should also be sanctioned, @SecRubio @DeputySecState Freedom of speech in Europe is in a battle for survival. Those in power understand that all their major policies of the past ten years have failed catastrophically, there is nothing left to defend their record. That's why they aggressively go after the people who criticize them and demand radical change.
European Commission
@EU_Commission
We strongly condemn the U.S. decision to impose travel restrictions on five European individuals, including former Commissioner Thierry Breton.
Link to full statement: link.europa.eu/NtMX4K -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Freddie Sayers
@freddiesayers
Clare Melford, head of the Global Disinformation Index, has been barred from the US. To find out out what the GDI was up to, check out my original report from April last year:
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Ron DeSantis
@RonDeSantis
60 Minutes is characterized by selective editing, the promotion of narratives, and the worst of drive by media.
When 60 Minutes did the 2021 hit piece, they had people on the ground in Florida trying to manufacture any dirt they could.
When they came up empty, they proceeded to launch a half-baked conspiracy piece that even major Democrats called a lie.
They never acknowledged any mistakes because they didn’t — and don’t — care about getting the facts right.
Chuck Ross
@ChuckRossDC
The 60 Minutes correspondent complaining about Bari Weiss was behind a 2021 hit piece on Ron DeSantis that even Democrats called “intentionally false.”
freebeacon.com/media/60-minutes-correspondent-sharyn-alfo… -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Gavin M. Wax
@GavinWax
The United States has the sovereign right to determine who may enter our country. It is an entirely appropriate measure for @StateDept to restrict malicious actors intent on quashing our citizens’ and corporations’ rights to freedom of speech and expression.
Free speech isn’t what European bureaucrats define it to be, and their regulatory overreach must end.
Kaja Kallas
@kajakallas
The decision by the U.S. to impose travel restrictions on European citizens and officials is unacceptable and an attempt to challenge our sovereignty.
Europe will keep defending its values — freedom of expression, fair digital rules, and the right to regulate our own space.
European Commission
@EU_Commission
We strongly condemn the U.S. decision to impose travel restrictions on five European individuals, including former Commissioner Thierry Breton.
Link to full statement: link.europa.eu/NtMX4K -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Steinhoefel
@Steinhoefel
Die Doppelmoral und falsche Empörung der EU: Zensur im Gewand der Regulierung
Die aktuelle Politik der EU offenbart einen tiefgreifenden Widerspruch zwischen ihrem rhetorischen Bekenntnis zur Meinungsfreiheit und ihrer tatsächlichen Sanktionierungspraxis:
Während das Bundesverfassungsgericht betont, dass auch „beunruhigende“ oder „offenkundig falsche“ Meinungen vom Schutz der Freiheit gedeckt sind, umgeht die EU diesen Schutz. Sie deklariert missliebige Stimmen (wie im Fall Baud) kurzerhand als „hybride Bedrohung“ oder „Desinformation“, um sie juristisch angreifbar und mundtot zu machen.
Der „Industrielle Zensur-Komplex“: Durch die massive staatliche Finanzierung von Organisationen wie HateAid betreiben die BRD und die EU eine funktionale Privatisierung der Zensur. Diese NGOs agieren als verlängerter Arm des Staates, um die Grenzen der Meinungsfreiheit ohne direkte demokratische Kontrolle zu verschieben – ein Eingriff, den die USA nun folgerichtig als politisch motivierte Einflussnahme sanktionieren. Dabei sollte es nicht enden, „Hessen gegen Hetze“ wäre ein gutes nächstes Ziel.
Die EU rechtfertigt ihre Sanktionierung von Alischer Usmanow u.a. damit, dass er als Eigentümer des Kommersant für einen Gastbeitrag von Dmitri Medwedew haftbar sei. Im europäischen Medienrecht wird die Trennung von Eigentum und Redaktion als heiliger Gral der Pressefreiheit verteidigt. Ein Eigentümer darf nicht in redaktionelle Inhalte eingreifen.
Hier wird eine „faktische Kontrolle“ unterstellt. Damit macht die EU den Eigentümer zum Zensor: Um Sanktionen zu entgehen, müsste ein Eigentümer aktiv verhindern, dass politisch missliebige Texte erscheinen. Dies ist genau die „Beschneidung der Freiheit des Redaktionsstabs“, die die EU Usmanow in ihrer Sanktionsbegründung vorwirft – ein klassischer Zirkelschluss.
Selektive Souveränität: Die EU-Kommission pocht auf ihre „regulatorische Autonomie“ (z. B. beim DSA), verweigert den USA jedoch das gleiche souveräne Recht, wenn diese Einreisebeschränkungen gegen EU-Funktionäre wie Breton verhängen, die sie als Bedrohung für ihre eigenen Verfassungswerte (Free Speech) ansehen.
Während die EU gegen russische Medienbesitzer drakonische wirtschaftliche Sanktionen verhängt, stellt sie sich bei Kritik an ihren eigenen Beamten (Thierry Breton) als Opfer „ungerechtfertigter Maßnahmen“ dar. Dies entlarvt ein System, in dem Meinungsfreiheit nur für jene gilt, die den herrschenden Konsens stützen.
Ich applaudiere den USA zu diesem Schritt und hoffe, das weitere folgen. Am D-Day stand ich in der Normandie neben dem damaligen Oberkommandierenden der 82nd Airborne Division und sagte zum ihm in puncto (Meinungs-) Freiheit: „Vielleicht müsst Ihr Amerikaner uns ein zweites Mal befreien.“
Joachim Nikolaus Steinhöfel, Weihnachten 2025 -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Christopher Landau
@DeputySecState
I remember thinking last year that this was one of the most chilling letters I’d ever read. It treats freedom of speech as merely one factor to be weighed in the balance against “detrimental effects on civic discourse and public security.” And the letter was targeted specifically at a conversation on this very platform between @elonmusk, an American, and @realDonaldTrump, also an American then running for the US Presidency. When the letter talks about “content that may incite violence, hate and racism in conjunction with major political—or societal—events around the world” in this context, it’s talking about core political speech. More than any other document I’ve ever read, this letter bares the fangs of the global censorship-industrial complex and underscores that unelected bureaucrats in the EU are ready, willing, and able to use their regulatory reach to try to influence elections and nullify the First Amendment in the US. When I wrote earlier this month about the glaring inconsistency between US relations with the EU and NATO, this is exactly what I had in mind. If the sovereign nations of Europe allow the EU to attack fundamental freedoms in the US, those same nations cannot expect the US to defend fundamental freedoms in Europe.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
This is how the blob weaponizes government agencies for censorship. First, they spread disinfo. They then use it to demand censorship. They use fake NGOs like "Hate Aid" is to deceive public into thinking their illegal censorship is legal. "Trusted flaggers" = government agents.
Critical Cat |
@Critical__Cat
The public broadcaster SWR created fake comments which "Hate Aid" labeled as hate crime. These comments do not exist. In this "documentary" they targeted my account and called me out as a "hatefluencer". They hunt me because I pointed out that a guy from the Green Party mocked Alice Weidel/AfD in a TV-Show.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
France pioneered the disinformation --> censorship psyop, as the Twitter Files - France proved, and which @McmahonPascal and @battleforeurope @galexybrane explain here:
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
🚨TWITTER FILES – FRANCE
At this moment, the Trump administration is negotiating with the EU over final obstacles to a trade deal, one of which is European censorship of US social media platforms.
Many analysts believe the massive size of the EU will lead US social media firms to impose European censorship, including on Americans. Last year, the EU’s then-top digital censor, Thierry Breton, threatened action against Elon Musk after he announced a conversation on X with Donald Trump.
Now, new TWITTER FILES show a coordinated effort by France’s President Emmanuel Macron, legislators, and state-affiliated NGOs working together to force the world’s most influential social media platform to censor users for legal speech and influence Twitter’s worldwide “content moderation” for narrative control.
What’s more, TWITTER FILES - FRANCE reveals the birth of the censorship-by-NGO proxy strategy at the heart of the Censorship Industrial Complex:
— President Macron personally reached out to then-CEO of Twitter, Jack Dorsey;
— The timing of Macron’s action strongly suggests coordination with NGOs on a pressure campaign to win more censorship and demand sensitive user data from Twitter;
— The pattern of events indicates potentially illegal activity by various actors.
The TWITTER FILES FRANCE investigation was led by @McmahonPascal and @battleforeurope, and edited by @galexybrane and @shellenberger.
We are releasing the Files here on X and simultaneously publishing a comprehensive report by Clerótte and Fazi on France’s invention of the Censorship Industrial Complex.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Stanford Internet Observatory, supervised by former Obama Amb. to Russia @McFaul, ran the disinformation --> censorship psyop for Department of Homeland Security.
They got Twitter to censor a Harvard Medical Professor for correctly saying that children and people who already had Covid didn't need the Covid shot.
Same scam as in France, Germany, UK, etc.
They spread disinformation about Covid and the vaccine and then successfully demanded censorship on the basis of that cnesorship. This is how Orwellian totalitarianism works in practice.
They are mad because the Trump administration is sanctioning government operatives posing at "NGOs." They've been caught violating our constitutions and putting Europe at risk.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Representatives of a US government front group, "Stanford Internet Observatory," denied ever demanding censorship of anyone. They lied, and we have the proof. They got social media companies to censor accurate Covid information in a clear violation of the First Amendment. Bam.
-
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Virginie Joron
@v_joron
Quelques heures avant l'échange du 12 août 2024 entre Donald Trump et Elon Musk sur X (tous américains), Thierry Breton avait menacé le propriétaire du réseau social de respecter les règlementations de l'UE.
Un visa enlevé 1 an et demi après, ils ont fait preuve de beaucoup de patience ! -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Tom Fitton
@TomFitton
Much of the EU is NATO. And much of NATO is EU. Should we continue to pledge to defend countries that target our Constitution, our freedoms, our free speech, our citizens and companies?
European Commission
@EU_Commission
We strongly condemn the U.S. decision to impose travel restrictions on five European individuals, including former Commissioner Thierry Breton.
Link to full statement: link.europa.eu/NtMX4K -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Beatrix von Storch
@Beatrix_vStorch
Das freut mich ganz besonders zu hören: Die USA sanktionieren federführende deutsche und EU-Köpfe, die am ZENSUR-Komplex beteiligt sind. Die USA verteidigen die freie Rede und damit die Demokratie. Und ich hoffe, da kommt noch mehr… Unsere Demokratie ist es wert und sie ist in Not.
Frohe heilige Nacht! -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Tocsin
@Tocsin_Media
🔴🔴ÉMISSION SPÉCIALE NOËL🔴🔴
Demain à partir de 7h30, Tocsin vous offre une interview exclusive exceptionnelle !
youtu.be/L8mLBAgSQeQ
Depuis le Parlement européen à Strasbourg, @Houdiakova anime une table ronde spéciale liberté d'expression pour tout comprendre sur le système de censure numérique mis en place par l'UE.
Autour de la table :
Michael @shellenberger, journaliste d'investigation américain mandaté par Elon Musk pour enquêter sur les Twitter Files, dans lesquels Emmanuel Macron est directement impliqué.
@Fidias0 Panayiotou, eurodéputé chypriote indépendant
Gheroghe @GPiperea, eurodéputé roumain membre du groupe ECR (Conservateurs et réformistes européens)
@v_joron, eurodéputée française du groupe des Patriotes pour l'Europe -
Michael Shellenberger reposted
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The people have fact-checked Macron. This is why they want to shut down X. The entire Censorship Industrial Complex rests upon government control of “fact-checkers” and “trusted flaggers.” Free speech prevents corrupt tyrants like Macron from spreading disinformation.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Your deep state swamp creature @ThierryBreton interfered in a US presidential election which led @vonderleyen to fire him with your permission. Now you’re trying to censor your enemies because you have a 17% approval rating & can’t govern.
Merry Christmas!
Emmanuel Macron
@EmmanuelMacron
France condemns the visa restriction measures taken by the United States against Thierry Breton and four other European figures.
These measures amount to intimidation and coercion aimed at undermining European digital sovereignty.
The European Union’s digital regulations were adopted following a democratic and sovereign process by the European Parliament and the Council.
They apply within Europe to ensure fair competition among platforms, without targeting any third country, and to ensure that what is illegal offline is also illegal online.
The rules governing the European Union’s digital space are not meant to be determined outside Europe.
Together with the European Commission and our European partners, we will continue to defend our digital sovereignty and our regulatory autonomy.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The tyrants @vonderleyen @EmmanuelMacron @_FriedrichMerz want to censor their enemies to shield themselves and the European Commission from democracy
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You weaponized European intelligence agencies to claim, without evidence, that your political enemies were funded by Russia. Now you are demanding mass censorship in the name of saving democracy. You are a totalitarian and should be ashamed of yourself. Step down.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The people have fact-checked Macron. This is why they want to shut down X. The entire Censorship Industrial Complex rests upon government control of “fact-checkers” and “trusted flaggers.” Free speech prevents corrupt tyrants like Macron from spreading disinformation.
-
European Commission
@EU_Commission
Today, we fined X for non-compliance with transparency obligations under the DSA.
We're holding X accountable for:
🔹Deceptive design of its ‘blue checkmark’
🔹Lack of transparency of its advertising repository
🔹Failure to provide access to public data for researchers
↓
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You are spreading disinformation
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You say it's not about censorship ("content moderation") but it is. You want to censor who gets verified. And you want X to give government-picked "researchers" special access to data so they can demand censorship. The Twitter Files revealed your censorship-by-proxy scam.
European Commission
@EU_Commission
Today, we fined X for non-compliance with transparency obligations under the DSA.
We're holding X accountable for:
🔹Deceptive design of its ‘blue checkmark’
🔹Lack of transparency of its advertising repository
🔹Failure to provide access to public data for researchers
↓ -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You say it's not about censorship ("content moderation") but it is. You want to censor who gets verified. And you want X to give government-picked "researchers" special access to data so they can demand censorship. The Twitter Files revealed your censorship-by-proxy scam.
European Commission
@EU_Commission
Today, we fined X for non-compliance with transparency obligations under the DSA.
We're holding X accountable for:
🔹Deceptive design of its ‘blue checkmark’
🔹Lack of transparency of its advertising repository
🔹Failure to provide access to public data for researchers
↓ -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Marco Rubio says he has no "way to verify” the “spectacular claims” made by “people with high clearances.” But if the Nat. Sec. Advisor lacks access to classified intel, and cannot tell if officials are lying, then it's up to Trump to reveal what the government knows about UAP.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We can trust Oracle to centralize our data in a single place to create digital IDs, says Larry Ellison. We can't. Thanks to a "previously unknown & widespread vulnerability" in Oracle's "E-Business Suite software" thousands of us recently had our personal data stolen.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In 2022, Obama gave a speech at Stanford Cyber Policy Center advocating sweeping censorship of the Internet. Now, Public has discovered the same Center last month hosted a secret meeting with EU, UK, Brazil, & Australia officials to plot global censorship — including of the US.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For decades, top scientists said climate change threatened civilization. But the data never showed that. And now, the evidence is overwhelming that scientists and the media deliberately misled the public on fires, ice, food, floods, heat, islands, coral, sea level, & hurricanes.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Fifty-five percent of people on the Left justify the murder of Trump, five times more liberals than conservatives defend political violence, and not a single high-profile Democrat has called for @jonesjay to drop out. The Left truly can not make its intentions any clearer.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Left today justifies political violence at a rate 5x higher than the Right: 25% of “very liberal” and 17% of “liberal” (42%) vs 6% of “conservative” and 3% of “very conservative” (9%)
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The man behind the digital ID push is Larry Ellison, owner of Oracle, CBS, CNN, and, soon, TikTok. He wants data centralization and total surveillance. "Citizens will be on their best behavior because we're constantly watching & recording everything that's going on." Terrifying.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
And after the government combines your personal, banking, and voting data under a single digital ID, it will add social media and vaccine information. Same with Real ID in the US. The Censorship Industrial Complex was dress rehearsal for digital ID.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The most dangerous threat to humankind is censorship, since without free speech, and the right to choose our own political representatives, we are no better than slaves. It's the First Amendement for a reason. I'm thus thrilled @TuckerCarlson chose free speech as the first issue for his new weekly livestream and grateful he's asked me to join him in a conversation after his opening monologue. There's much to discuss. Please tune in!
Tucker Carlson
@TuckerCarlson
Join us Wednesday, 9/24 at 8 PM ET with @shellenberger at tuckercarlson.com/theendoffreespeech
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
If you can’t freely express your opinions and vote for the candidate of your choice, you’re not a democracy. If you’re not a democracy, you can’t be in NATO. @realDonaldTrump @Keir_Starmer @EmmanuelMacron @_FriedrichMerz
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
🚨TWITTER FILES – FRANCE
At this moment, the Trump administration is negotiating with the EU over final obstacles to a trade deal, one of which is European censorship of US social media platforms.
Many analysts believe the massive size of the EU will lead US social media firms to impose European censorship, including on Americans. Last year, the EU’s then-top digital censor, Thierry Breton, threatened action against Elon Musk after he announced a conversation on X with Donald Trump.
Now, new TWITTER FILES show a coordinated effort by France’s President Emmanuel Macron, legislators, and state-affiliated NGOs working together to force the world’s most influential social media platform to censor users for legal speech and influence Twitter’s worldwide “content moderation” for narrative control.
What’s more, TWITTER FILES - FRANCE reveals the birth of the censorship-by-NGO proxy strategy at the heart of the Censorship Industrial Complex:
— President Macron personally reached out to then-CEO of Twitter, Jack Dorsey;
— The timing of Macron’s action strongly suggests coordination with NGOs on a pressure campaign to win more censorship and demand sensitive user data from Twitter;
— The pattern of events indicates potentially illegal activity by various actors.
The TWITTER FILES FRANCE investigation was led by @McmahonPascal and @battleforeurope, and edited by @galexybrane and @shellenberger.
We are releasing the Files here on X and simultaneously publishing a comprehensive report by Clerótte and Fazi on France’s invention of the Censorship Industrial Complex. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
America spends trillions on NATO to protect democracies including Germany. But it is has just prevented an opposition candidate from running for mayor for frivolous reasons including his praise for "Lord of the Rings." This is a clear violation of NATO's Charter.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A former CIA official tells NBC they had the intel in 2017 to prove Putin favored Trump. It's a lie. The evidence is now overwhelming that the opposite was the case. Russia had damning and explosive intel on Hillary and chose not to leak it because Putin found her "manageable."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Climate change caused the catastrophic floods that tore through Central Texas over the last few days, killing at least 27 people, including nine children, and turning calm rivers into violent torrents, according to the media.
At Camp Mystic in Kerr County, the Guadalupe River surged from about three feet to nearly 29 feet in just 90 minutes, sweeping away cabins, vehicles, and people with little or no warning. Climate change caused a warmer atmosphere, which holds more moisture, and unleashed it in increasingly intense bursts.
Volumes of precipitation were extreme. They had less than a 0.1% chance of occurring in any given year, according to the New York Times. Texas climatologists warned that the frequency and severity of such events have already increased and could intensify by another 10 percent by 2036. In East Texas, “the number of days per year with at least two inches of rain or snow has increased by 20 percent since 1900,” noted the Times.
But that tiny increase in precipitation doesn’t explain the floods or the deaths in Texas. Over the past century, global flood deaths declined by more than 80 percent. That happened not because nations reduced rainfall but because they have learned how to live with it. They built levees, dams, and drainage systems. They developed early warning systems and evacuated people before the water arrived. Kerr County in Texas failed to do any of these things.
Despite its location in one of the most flood-prone regions in the United States, the county had no formal flood warning system in place. There were no sirens, no automated text alerts, no rapid evacuation protocol. The river rose, and families had no idea it was coming...
Please subscribe now to watch the full video, read the full article, and support Public's award-winning reporting!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
They're launching mortar rounds, @GavinNewsom
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The idea that the Biden administration viewed millions of Americans as a terrorist threat sounds like a conspiracy theory, but it’s not. Newly declassified documents show that in December 2021, the FBI and DHS labeled opponents of Covid mandates "Domestic Violent Extremists."
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Since WWII, Germany's liberal democracy has held. Now, it's on the brink. The government censors, spies on, and persecutes critics. And, today, it laid the groundwork to ban the nation's most popular political party, the AfD. My exclusive interview with one of its leaders.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Renewables didn't cause Spain's blackout, says its Prime Minister. But by reducing needed inertia, they did, and the grid operator effectively admitted it was the loss of solar that triggered it. As such, @sanchezcastejon , who wants more censorship, is spreading misinformation.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Politicians closed schools during Covid based on the best info they had at the time, say the media. False, says @davidzweig , author of a major new book from MIT Press. They had all the info they needed to reopen schools in 2020. Arrogance & cowardice explain why they didn't.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
One FBI employee involved in the cover-up of the Hunter Biden laptop was Bradley Benavides (ctr-intel div). Weeks earlier he played key role in an apparent FBI scheme to smear @SenRonJohnson & @ChuckGrassley — who were investigating Hunter — as tools of Putin. Sinister.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The FBI said it didn't interfere in the 2020 election, but it did. It tricked Twitter & Facebook into censoring the Hunter Biden laptop story. Now, newly released chat messages show the FBI issued a "gag order" after an employee accidentally confirmed the laptop's authenticity.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The former head of the UK's foreign intelligence agency, MI6, told Boris Johnson in early 2020 that the Covid virus escaped from the Wuhan lab. That means that the US, UK, Chinese, & German governments all knew the truth, covered it up, and spread disinformation. Case closed.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The behavior of Zelenskyy is typical of Europe as a whole. Entitled. In denial of reality. Narcissistic. Unconcerned with our need to deal with many massive internal problems. Such juvenile & entitled behavior makes us less not more desirous of helping Ukraine and Europe.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Zelensky says he wants peace but he just rudely dismissed the Trump administration's diplomacy as pointless. That angered Trump and @JDVance and now Zelensky has fled the White House. This should be the wake-up call that global elites & Europe desperately need.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Zelensky says he wants peace but he just rudely dismissed the Trump administration's diplomacy as pointless. That angered Trump and @JDVance and now Zelensky has fled the White House. This should be the wake-up call that global elites & Europe desperately need.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You cut fire prevention; LA burned. You spent $24 billion on homelessness; it rose 40%. You reduced penalties for violent crime; it's 31% higher in California than in the US as a whole. And instead of taking responsibility, you're trying to become an influencer. It's pathetic.
Gavin Newsom
@GavinNewsom
Breaking news on the Menendez brothers case:
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
USAID said it was a charitable group. It wasn't. It was a tool for regime change. After 2016, it turned its guns inward. In 2019, a front group it created fabricated the evidence used by the CIA, moles in the White House, and House Democrats to impeach Trump. That's treason.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Thomas Massie
@RepThomasMassie
USAID funded an organization that fabricated evidence which was used to impeach President Trump.
The Deep State frequently funds regime change efforts abroad, but when it uses taxpayer money to undermine our own government, isn't that treason?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
They said the government was by and for the people, and the media was free. They weren't. Deep state actors controlled them. Then, after the populist revolts of 2016, they turned the tools of regime change, including disinfo, censorship, and lawfare, against the American people.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The New York Times says “Musk Asserts Without Proof That Bureaucracy Is Rife With Fraud.” Seriously? The GAO — under Biden — estimated last year that we are losing $233-$521 billion *per year* to fraud. Guys, it’s right there. Why do you continue with this… fraud? SMH
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We need experts to rule society, they said. No, we didn't. They made Covid, inflation, crime, trans, etc. worse. Facing a backlash, elites censored & persecuted ordinary people. Now, they're panicking because a populist counter-elite is, finally, putting an end to their grift.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Democrats were the party of "reinventing government." Then, they decided to weaponize it. The reason Democrats today defend waste, fraud, and abuse, even at the expense of the separation of powers, is because their wealth and their ability to rule depend on it.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Democrats were the party of "reinventing government." Then, they decided to weaponize it. The reason Democrats today defend waste, fraud, and abuse, even at the expense of the separation of powers, is because their wealth and their ability to rule depend on it.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The House of Representatives impeached President Donald Trump on December 18, 2019, after a White House whistleblower went public with evidence that Trump abused his powers by withholding military aid to Ukraine in order to dig up dirt on his rival, Joe Biden.
In the complaint, the whistleblower claimed to have heard from White House staff that Trump had, on a phone call, directed Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky to work with his personal attorney, Rudy Giuliani, to investigate Joe Biden and Hunter Biden.
The whistleblower who triggered the impeachment was a CIA analyst who was first brought into the White House by the Obama administration.
Reporting by Drop Site News last year revealed that the CIA analyst relied on reporting by a supposedly independent investigative news organization called the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project (OCCRP), which appears to have effectively operated as an arm of the United States Agency for International Development (USAID), which President Trump has just shut down. The CIA whistleblower complaint cited a long report by OCCRP four times.
The OCCRP report alleged that two Soviet-born Florida businessmen were “key hidden actors behind a plan” by Trump to investigate the Bidens. According to the story, those two businessmen connected Giuliani to two former Ukrainian prosecutors. The OCCRP story was crucial to the House Democrats’ impeachment claim, which is that Trump dispatched Giuliani as part of a coordinated effort to pressure a foreign country to interfere in the 2020 presidential election, which is why the whistleblower cited it four times.
In a 2024 documentary that German television broadcaster NDR made about OCCRP’s dependence on the US government, a USAID official confirmed that USAID approves OCCRP’s “annual work plan” and approves new hires of “key personnel.” NDR initiated and carried out the investigation with French investigative news organization Mediapart, Italian new group Il Fatto Quotidiano, Reporters United in Greece, and Drop Site News in the United States.
However, according to a Mediapart story published the same day as the Drop Site News article, NDR censored the broadcast “after US journalist Drew Sullivan, the co-founder and head of the OCCRP, placed pressure on the NDR management and made false accusations against the broadcaster’s journalists involved in the project.”
On December 16, Drop Site’s Ryan Grim posted a link on X to the 26-minute-long documentary. “NDR, Germany’s public broadcaster, is facing a censorship scandal and has defended itself by saying it never killed a news report about OCCRP and its State Department funding — b/c no report was ever produced to kill,” said Grim. “That was absurd — and dozens, maybe hundreds, of journalists knew it to be false, and now of course, someone has leaked it.”
The journalistic collaboration revealed that OCCRP’s original funding came from the Bureau of International Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs of the State Department, and quotes a USAID official who says, “Drew’s just nervous about being linked with law enforcement,” referring to Sullivan. “If people who are going to give you information think you’re just a cop, maybe it’s a problem.”
OCCRP does not operate like a normal investigative journalism organization in that its goals appear to include interfering in foreign political matters, including elections, aimed at regime change. Sullivan told NDR that his organization had “probably been responsible for five or six countries changing over from one government to another government… and getting prime ministers indicted or thrown out.”
As such, it appears that CIA, USAID, and OCCRP were all involved in the impeachment of President Trump in ways similar to the regime change operations that all three organizations engage in abroad. The difference is that it is highly illegal and even treasonous for CIA, USAID, and its contractors and intermediaries, known as “cut-outs,” to interfere in US politics this way.
OCCRP threatened to file a lawsuit against Public in response to questions we sent. “The premise of your article is factually false and defamatory,” wrote Miranda Patrucic, the Editor in Chief of OCCRP, over email. “The claim by Dropsite News and partner media that USAID has control over editorial appointments has been disproven and we suggest you read our response to that.”
But neither OCCRP nor anyone else disproved Drop Site’s allegations and Drop Site stands by them. And the evidence does not support OCCRP’s claim of journalistic independence....
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative reporting, to read the rest of the article, and to watch the rest of the video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Imagine an app linking your social media, bank access, and vaccination records. Now imagine the totalitarian potential. Criticize the government, or refuse a jab, and you're debanked or unable to travel. This is not a drill. Digital IDs may soon become a reality. @CecilieJilkova
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Victory! The dark age of government censorship of online speech is coming to an end with the Executive Order just signed by @realDonaldTrump. Read it and weep @BarackObama @JoeBiden @BillGates @HillaryClinton @georgesoros. You guys got on the wrong side of a sacred value.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"Under the guise of combatting “misinformation,” “disinformation,” and “malinformation,” the Federal Government infringed on the constitutionally protected speech rights of American citizens across the United States in a manner that advanced the Government’s preferred narrative about significant matters of public debate. Government censorship of speech is intolerable in a free society."
www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/restoring… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
DEI didn't hurt the LA Fire Department's response to the catastrophic fires, say the media. But anything that trumps meritocratic standards would. And now, whistleblowers within LAFD say the Department lowered standards on ladders, hoses & push-ups to meet DEI quotas for women.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Many say that the catastrophic fires ravaging Los Angeles weren’t the fault of Governor Gavin Newsom and LA Mayor Karen Bass. Fires are inevitable in Los Angeles, and the water ran out because no water system could withstand that many fires simultaneously, they add.
But LA firefighters themselves disagree. They say the reason they arrived too late to stop the fires from becoming catastrophic was because of severe budget cuts. The Fire Department did not pre-deploy fire engines to strategic locations, and helicopters arrived half an hour too late to put out the Palisades.
“That [Santa Ynez] reservoir being closed did not allow helicopters to drop and suck water up from five minutes away,” a new firefighter whistleblower, the third who has come forward, told me. “Instead, they had to fly 10 to 15 minutes away to go get water somewhere else.”
The problem is that the LA Fire Department is one of the most severely understaffed of America’s 10 largest cities. It has less than a single firefighter per 1,000 residents compared to Chicago, Dallas, and Houston, which have twice as many.
“ In 1960, our city population was 2.5 million, and we had 112 fire stations. In 2020, our city population was 3.9 million, and we had 106 stations,” a representative of LA’s firefighters ’ union testified last month. “That's 1.4 million more people and six fewer fire stations.”
This undermines the Department’s ability to respond to emergencies. “In 2020, the average emergency response time was seven minutes and 53 seconds, nearly double the NFPA recommendation.”
Part of the problem is that the number of homeless fires in LA doubled between 2020 and 2023 to an astonishing 38 per day. They start dangerous fires in many ways, including by breaking through the sidewalk into the city’s electrical system, which can result in explosions and death.
Still, many say, it is wrong to blame homelessness for LA’s fires. They are victims of trauma and poverty.
But the research is unequivocal. Over half of all fires that the LA Fire Department responds to are set by a homeless person. "There were two huge explosions, and when I looked out my apartment window, I saw plumes of black smoke," a resident told NBC-Los Angeles. "People are literally dying in the streets, in tents burning down around them.”
And the evidence is clear: leaving homeless people on the street makes them three times more likely to die than people required to come inside to sleep in shelters.
The third firefighter whistleblower says the firefighters are being put in danger by budget cuts. “Even last week,” the person said, “I wanted to work and I was told, ‘Sorry dude, we don't have a seat for you to fill because there's not enough apparatuses,’” meaning fire engines or other equipment.
One hundred fire engines and other apparatus are currently out of service because the city cut the Fire Department’s budget, and it couldn’t afford to hire mechanics to fix equipment.
“We have a crack about halfway down our water tank. Half of our [engines and other] apparatuses are broken. They were sending rookies, new probationary firefighters, out to the field last year with no department-required brush jackets.”
The firefighters lack life-saving equipment. “We were running out of electrodes to do EKGs,” the person said. “We've been running out of gloves. We've been running out of drugs, you name it. There's been ambulances that have been having to steal stuff or borrow stuff from the hospitals just to stay available.”
At the meeting last month, the president of the city’s firefighters union warned, “If we cut one position, if we close one station… the residents of Los Angeles are going to pay the ultimate sacrifice, and someone will die.”
All this and yet Los Angeles is one of the richest cities in the world. Eighty-four of America’s richest 400 people live in California, and LA is home to 26 billionaires who collectively possess a net worth of approximately $185 billion.
“It kills us when we see holes in the system,” said the whistleblower, “and we aren’t able to do the job we expect of ourselves, and if we had the appropriate resources and staffing, I don’t think any of the fires were inevitable. I know for a fact it would not be what it is. We saw my particular fire engine in maintenance for a year and a half.”
Some politicians are demanding reform. ”There are large swaths of the city with no emergency response resources available,” said Councilmember Traci Park, who urged more funding for firefighting last year. “ I think that people are rightly upset, not only that this happened, but there is a sense that we as local leaders needed to do more for them. I feel like I let them down, and I've been screaming about it from the day I came in.”
As such, the problem is not poverty, it is severe mismanagement and bad governance. Not only is the city’s mismanagement to blame for LA’s disastrous response to the fire, but it’s also responsible for the city’s ongoing homelessness disaster.
Why is that?
Part of the reason is the city’s Diversity, Equity, Inclusion (DEI) programs. “The city will only purchase from vendors that support DEI,” said the firefighter. “So we'll go with a vendor that we have to pay twice as much, or the shipment may take twice as long, in order for it to be a DEI vendor rather than the vendor who has it at half the price and can get it to us tomorrow.”
The whistleblower said that DEI programs put firefighters and the public in danger. “I personally witnessed in my own drill tower them making and passing women just to get their [female quota] numbers even though they didn't have to meet all the criteria the men did....”
Please subscribe now to support Public's award-winning investigative reporting, read the rest of the article, and watch the rest of the video!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
January 2: National Weather Service (NWS) warns of “extreme fire weather conditions” in Los Angeles
Jan. 3: NWS repeats warning in special LA briefing
Jan. 4: LA Mayor Karen Bass flies to Ghana on junket
Jan. 7: LA goes up in flames as Bass poses for photos at cocktail party -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Some reporters and scientists are blaming climate change for the lack of rain in LA. It's ridiculous. There's no trend in annual rainfall from 1877 to 2024. We have wet years and dry years.
Climate change isn't responsible for the LA fires. Gavin Newsom and Karen Bass are. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Over the next few weeks you’re going to hear Governor Gavin Newsom, Mayor Karen Bass, and the Democratic Party tell you that there’s nothing that could have been done to prevent the fires from destroying Los Angeles.
Those will be lies. They could have prevented them. Governor Newsom cut the funding for preventing forest fires and failed to build sufficient water resources for fighting fires. Mayor Karen Bass cut $17.5 million in funding for the Los Angeles Fire Department and then went to Ghana even though she knew of the risk of catastrophic fires.
It’s true that California, in general, and Los Angeles, in particular, are fiery places. It’s true that the Santa Ana winds made the fires worse.
But Newsom and Bass have known about those hazards for all of their careers and failed to deal with them. Their rank incompetence and lack of leadership are shocking and scandalous.
It’s hard to overstate how badly they screwed up water management. LA firefighters haven’t had the water they needed. Newsom hasn’t built the new water reservoirs that Los Angeles needed. And Newsom even cut the budget for water infrastructure projects last year.
Why is that? Part of the reason is that they were focused on other things. Making the fire department more racially diverse. Climate change. Homelessness.
And the reason they were focused on those things is because those are what the radical Left that controls the Democratic party wanted them to focus on.
Year after year, they do nothing while focusing on things like trans and Trump and climate and ignoring the things that really matter to the people of California.
The Democrats in California aren’t like Democrats in other states. They are radicals. I would know, since when I was a young radical I moved to California for that reason.
As many of us get older, we become more moderate. We become more practical. We understand firefighters and police officers are necessary. We are reminded of the importance of things like safe streets and hard work and good schools.
But more than that, I saw the consequences of radical progressive policies on the environment, homelessness, crime, education, water, and everything else. Violent criminals, in particular, are devouring Los Angeles, Oakland, and the rest of California.
The people who control the Democratic Party in California worship books about Los Angeles, like City of Quartz by the Marxist author Mike Davis. In that book, Davis claims that the problem in Los Angeles is that too much money goes to things like firefighting to protect wealthy neighborhoods.
They did the same thing on crime and homelessness. They failed to provide adequate funding to the police. They weakened the laws that allowed for burglaries and robberies. They subsidized homelessness, attracting homeless people from around the United States to camp illegally and start fires.
Over half of the fires in places like Los Angeles and Oakland are caused by the homeless committing arson, often out of some petty revenge.
We don’t know what started all of the fires, but at least one started within the housing subdivision. Others may have started in the interface between housing and wildlands. Or it could have been started by the homeless.
Whatever the case, California and LA didn’t invest enough in preventing fires because they were distracted by radical Left causes.
When Rick Caruso ran for Mayor against Karen Bass, he called for increasing the fire department’s budget.
A big part of the reason he lost is simply because he was white. I watched focus groups in 2022 and the most racist people were white liberals in Los Angeles. When they discussed the mayoral race, the white people overwhelmingly said they couldn’t vote for a white man and had to vote for a black woman because she was black.
The Latino men and women in separate focus groups were much less racist. They wanted to know about their policies.
It was the radical Left that invented the racist idea that white people alive today should feel guilty about things white people did in the past. Racist white guilt led people in Los Angeles and California to vote against a guy who would have prevented those fires.
And so, over the next few weeks, when you hear Governor Gavin Newsom, Mayor Karen Bass, and the Democratic Party tell you that there’s nothing they could have done to prevent the fires from destroying Los Angeles, don’t believe them.
It’s time for California to grow up and move beyond the juvenile Leftism that has destroyed the state and destroyed Los Angeles. We can’t trust our leaders to run anything. It’s not just incompetence. It’s that they really don’t care.
It’s time for Californians to demand new leaders — ones who aren’t beholden to the radicals who control the Democratic Party. .This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Many Democrats say they want to understand what happened. Few genuinely do. That's because, at some level, they know they're guilty of having participated in a witch hunt in which they falsely accused their fellow Americans, and even their friends & family, of fascism & racism.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Please subscribe now to support Public's ground-breaking investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the rest of the video!
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Please subscribe now to support Public's ground-breaking investigative journalism, read the rest of the article, and watch the rest of the video!
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Our Intelligence Community is rotten to the core. Serious investigations are required. We need to get to the bottom the censorship, J6, Covid origins, lawfare, weaponization of CIA, FBI, and DHS. We need a Church Committee 2.0. The people must regain control of our government.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In addition to illegally boosting @KamalaHarris, NBC's Saturday Night Live last night did a skit *literally* aimed at boosting the name recognition of Sen @timkaine. Why? Perhaps because Kaine's challenger @HungCao_VA just closed the gap & could win. It's election interference.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The New York Times says Biden only "appeared" to call Trump voters "garbage." That's disinformation. What Biden said is clear from the video. And now the White House has altered the official transcript in a potential violation of the Presidential Records Act
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
All the major elements of the FBI & CIA conspiracy to interfere in the 2020 election on behalf of Joe Biden are now confirmed:
— FBI had the Hunter Biden laptop in Dec. 2019 & knew it "was real" immediately
— FBI, spying on Giuliani, knew he would give the laptop to media
— FBI ran a disinformation campaign in the summer of 2020 to "prebunk" the story with journalists & social media companies, both directly and through Aspen Institute, by falsely claiming Russians were planning disinfo relating to Hunter Biden
— "Former" FBI General Counsel turned Twitter Dep. Counsel, Jim Baker, convinced colleagues to censor the NY Post story after they had determined that it had *not* violated Twitter's Terms of Service
— CIA Director Gina Haspel approved, within a few hours, a disinformation campaign by 51 "former" CIA and other Intelligence Community leaders who falsely claimed the laptop was Russian disinformation
The result was that millions of voters thought the laptop was fake and never learned that Joe Biden oversaw a vast influence-peddling scheme involving China, Ukraine, and other nations, with his son and brother, until after the election.
These are high crimes for which people should go to prison.
x.com/shellenberger/status/1604871630613753856
Catherine Herridge
@C__Herridge
BREAKING: IRS Whistleblowers Involved in Hunter Biden Tax Case Reveal IRS, DOJ, and FBI Knew Laptop “Was Real” Immediately; Claim Prosecutors Demanded They Not Ask Questions About Joe Biden Ahead of 2020 Election
“There were a lot of overt investigative steps that we were not allowed to take because we had an upcoming election.”
“The prosecutors…told us that they didn’t want to ask about ‘The Big Guy.’”
“We corroborated that ‘The Big Guy’ was Joe Biden. Yes.”
“There was no question ever that ‘The Big Guy’ was referring to Joe Biden.”
“It was for the purpose of affecting that [2020] election.”
Investigations are funded by @X subscribers, please consider subscribing @C__Herridge today!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
All in last few hours:
- Leaked Dem memo shows “fascism” label isn’t sticking
- White House caught manipulating migration data
- More voters say Trump justified in challenging 2020 election results
The wall of lies is rapidly crumbing -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The media say Trump lied when he told Joe Rogan that industrial wind turbines are killing whales, but he didn't. In fact, it's worse than Trump said. If the wind industry continues with its boats, noise, and vibrations, it will make the North Atlantic right whale extinct.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
First Brazil and now the EU say they will seize the assets of @ElonMusk's companies. A President Harris would do the same. They know it's illegal. They know it looks bad. They don't care. They know they can't rule the world without mass censorship and total information control.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The media say we must give the government more power to fight misinformation online. We must not. The only way to fight misinformation is through free speech. What the media really want is the power to censor us. And it's easy to see why: very few Americans trust them.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For years, governments and mainstream media corporations worked hand-in-glove to censor social media platforms. After @elonmusk bought Twitter, that changed. Ever since, they've been on the warpath, demanding the power to censor X and demonizing the First Amendment.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Gates, Clinton, and Obama say governments must censor "health misinformation" to restore public trust. They must not. Doing so prevents knowing what helps and what harms. "The reason people don't trust the medical establishment," says @MartyMakary, "is because it lied to them."
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Thanks, Joe, for another great conversation! At 3.5 hours, I guess we had a lot to talk about! 😅
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The US government says it is not hiding a secret UAP (UFO) program. But dozens of whistleblowers say it is. And now, a new whistleblower has come forward to reveal what the government is hiding, including the name of the secret program, which is revealed here for the first time.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Bill Gates two weeks ago, John Kerry last week, and Hillary Clinton today — all demanding government censorship of X. Hard to see this as a coincidence. They appear to be laying the groundwork for totalitarianism. Our democratic republic is in danger.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
No matter your politics, these new numbers are shocking. Of the 7 million migrants that ICE released while their cases are being processed, 663,000 have criminal histories, 13,000 were convicted of homicide, 16,000 of sexual assault, and 1,845 face homicide charges. 😬
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You may not care about the censorship and banning of X in Brazil. You don't have to. That's because what's happening there isn't really about Brazil. It's about the country being used as a laboratory to roll out totalitarianism worldwide. We ignore it at our peril.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Joe Biden has just announced he’s not running for re-election and will support Vice President Kamala Harris’s candidacy instead.
The announcement came as a shock to the people who work at the White House and to campaign aides, one of whom told Politico, "We’re all finding out by tweet. None of us understand what’s happening.” The same was true in Delaware, Biden’s home state. “I don’t think a soul in Delaware knew,” said a Biden campaign official.
As such, this is the third time in three presidential elections that Democratic Party elites have subverted democracy to choose a presidential candidate.
The first time this occurred was in 2016 when the Democratic National Committee manipulated money and process to help Hillary Clinton defeat Bernie Sanders. The second time was in 2020, when Party elites pushed out Pete Buttigieg and Amy Klobuchar so Elizabeth Warren could split the progressive vote with Sanders, creating a path to victory for Biden.
This year, Biden and the DNC prevented a competitive open primary, and now Biden is deciding who will be the nominee for Democrats. Harris was deeply unpopular with Democratic voters when she ran in the 2020 primary, leading her to drop out after her polling plummeted to the single digits.
It’s true that the Democratic elites followed the formal rules, most Democrats agreed that Biden should not run again, and a Democrat could still challenge Kamala Harris at the convention.
But the party undermined the spirit of democracy in every election. Democracy, at its core, is about letting the people decide for themselves. That simply didn’t happen.
In fact, a very small number of Democratic Party donors and media elites chose Hillary Clinton, Biden, and Harris. In many ways it was the media who influenced donors and decided Biden should go after his disastrous debate performance.
To the extent that ordinary Democratic Party voters turned against Biden it was in response to the media turning on him. When the media insisted that Biden was fine, and that the worries about his health were just right-wing propaganda, Democratic voters were loyal to him.
While it’s true someone could challenge Harris for the nomination, it’s very hard to see that happening, given Biden’s endorsement and the argument from Kamala Harris supporters that it would be borderline racist for anyone else to win the nomination. Within a few hours, Bill and Hillary Clinton, Senator Tammy Baldwin, and Democratic mega-donor Reid Hoffman all endorsed Harris. Other Party elites will likely do the same.
Over the last three weeks, Biden fought Democratic donors, media elites, and Party leaders. He insisted repeatedly he could do the job. But, in the end, they overwhelmed him. They withheld funding. They attacked almost every day, letting up for just 24 hours after the near-assassination of former President Trump.
As a result, nobody could watch the events of the last few weeks and believe that the Democratic Party is democratic. It is a party controlled by the media, donors, and the deep state.
However one feels about the GOP, the same can’t be said of Republicans. Republican voters rejected their own party leaders, donors, and the foreign policy establishment to nominate Trump for president in 2016. Democrats, by contrast, sided with the establishment candidate in choosing Clinton in 2016 and Biden in 2020.
Why is that? Why did Democrats become the party controlled by elites and obedient to authority, and Republicans the party of rebellion and, increasingly, the working class?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The governor of America’s richest and most populous state yesterday doubled down on his new law, which requires that schools hide a psychiatric disorder known as gender dysphoria from parents.
California Governor Gavin Newsom claims his law “protects the child-parent relationship” and prevents the government from “inappropriately intervening in family matters.”
This is disinformation. Newsom knows full well that his law prevents schools from telling parents when their children have come to believe that they are the opposite sex and were born into the wrong body.
This is dangerous because the next step is for doctors to give those children and adolescents puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and the final treatment, surgery.
Parents in California should know that Gavin Newsom has put their children in danger.
Why is Gavin Newsom doing this? Doesn’t he want to be president?
It’s true Gavin won’t ever be elected president now. Voters in Michigan and Pennsylvania won’t elect a president who enables such mistreatment.
So what’s driving him?
You may have heard the expression, “Good times create weak leaders.” This expression suggests that when things are going well, we elect politicians who aren’t capable of doing anything.
It’s rational when you think about it. When things are going good, you don’t want to change anything.
Gavin Newsom is the weak leader born from good times. He was born into a close relationship with the billionaire Getty oil family. He was spoiled as a boy and has never worked for anything other than to advance himself.
Gavin Newsom is such a weak leader that he caved into activist pressure he should have protected children.
The problem with weak leaders is that they create bad times. That’s what Gavin has done. He has increased homelessness by 40% in just four and a half years. He’s letting people with schizophrenia die from fentanyl overdoses and be sexually assaulted in tents on the sidewalks. And now he’s let activists prey on California’s children.
Instead of hospitalizing people psychotic from schizophrenia and meth, Gavin’s government is helping them smoke fentanyl and meth on the street and die. Instead of doing cognitive behavioral therapy with adolescents with gender dysphoria, anxiety, and depression, Gavin’s government is putting them on puberty blockers, giving them hormones, and performing surgeries.
Behind Gavin is a pathological desire to care for people. That means creating more sick people. Call it Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy. This is what progressives are doing. They are affirming mental illnesses and psychiatric disorders rather than treating them. Think of the Kathy Bates character in “Misery.”
California is creating and affirming psychiatric disorders. The public health departments are funding and enabling drug addiction and homelessness. And the schools are promoting gender dysphoria.
The good news is that this reality is now visible for everyone to see. Elon Musk shared my video yesterday, and now 20 million people have viewed it. I have received requests from media all around the world, even in California, where publishers, editors, and journalists have championed Gavin Newsom’s destructive and inhumane policies for 30 years.
We are organizing a movement to fight back. Please add your name to our list of people working to Save California.
Gavin Newsom will never be president, and he won’t be governor for much longer, but it’s up to us to smash the pathocratic bureaucracy he created and replace it with one dedicated to caring for people, not mistreating them.
We need to fight back against California’s disinformation about what he’s done. Please sign up and subscribe to Public now.
Most of all, we need to get the word out that Gavin Newsom is lying about what he’s done. He’s not protecting the child-parent relationship, he’s weaponizing the government to attack it.
Change is coming. As the nation’s richest and most populous state, California has no excuse for its gross mistreatment of children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I’m afraid I have some terrible news. The governor of America’s largest and richest state has just signed a law that puts 10 million children and adolescents in grave danger of medical mistreatment.
The media headlines have it wrong. They claim that California Governor Gavin Newsom’s new law protects children by stopping public schools from outing their new gender to their parents.
It does just the opposite. It makes children vulnerable to irreversible and lifelong medical abuse and mistreatment. And it is all based on the pseudoscientific idea that some children are born into the wrong bodies and that we can change a person’s sex through drugs and surgery.
For any of this to make sense, you have to understand what’s happening in Britain. Several years ago, the government appointed a well-respected pediatrician named Hillary Cass to investigate whether it was ethical to block the puberty of children, give them opposite-sex hormones, and perform surgeries on their bodies to make them feel better about their gender. Dr. Cass came back a few weeks ago and said no, absolutely not.
Around the same time, the British government banned puberty blockers nationwide. And, just a few days ago, the new Labor Party government affirmed that it would maintain the former government’s ban.
In her report, Cass said that the so-called “social transition,” whereby a child adopts the identity of the opposite sex, is not a neutral act and has psychological consequences. This means it is the first step toward medical intervention.
What Gavin Newsom has done is actively prevented schools from informing parents that their children have been put on a medical pathway.
This is an outrageous attack on the rights of children and parents. Children have a right to go through puberty. No adult should be able to block their puberty. And parents have a right to know if their child thinks that they are the opposite sex or were born into the wrong body.
We have seen with leaked internal documents of the leading gender medicine group, WPATH, that these medical interventions, namely puberty blockers, hormones, and surgery, are not only irreversible but result in sterilization and loss of sexual function.
Children or adolescents are simply not mature enough to understand the effects of so-called “gender-affirming care.” They cannot, in other words, give their informed consent.
The new law creates the grave risk that activist teachers, students, and outside groups will convince their children that they were born into the wrong body, and hide their “social transition” from parents, which will lead to harmful medical mistreatment.
As such, the law that Newsom just signed is the opposite of what both children and their parents need. We need schools to immediately warn parents if their children think they are the opposite sex.
After all, this is a diagnosable psychiatric condition known as “gender dysphoria.” And if your child has a psychiatric disorder, whether anxiety, depression, an eating disorder, or gender dysphoria, you have a right to know.
And schools must stop teaching children, or allowing other people to teach children, the pseudoscientific and dehumanizing ideas that it’s possible to be born into the wrong body and possible to change one’s sex.
As such, either the legislature, the courts, or a ballot initiative will be required to nullify Newsom’s law. Until then, it is important to spread the word to parents that California public schools are fundamentally unsafe for the millions of children who attend them.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The European Commission says it wants to protect free speech but admits it will decide what Google, Facebook, and X censor. And now, Public has discovered that the EU's top censorship official is a former French defense contractor specializing in mass spying and censorship.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The totalitarianism we warned of is happening.
The European Union is at this moment forcing big tech companies to secretly engage in mass censorship. Google and Facebook are, apparently, going along with it.
Only Elon Musk’s X, among the major platforms, is resisting.
A few hours ago, Musk said, “The European Commission offered 𝕏 an illegal secret deal: if we quietly censored speech without telling anyone, they would not fine us. The other platforms accepted that deal. 𝕏 did not.”
And so now, the EU is preparing to punish X with massive fines — up to 6% of total global revenue.
I can't imagine a more egregious form of foreign interference in our domestic affairs than foreign governments demanding mass secret censorship for ideological and political purposes.
Most terrifying is the apparently direct involvement of government intelligence and security agencies, and their intermediaries, in demanding censorship.
This is all happening at the very moment that the same governments, including our own, warn of Russian disinformation through spam accounts that hardly anybody ever sees.
Don’t be fooled by what is happening. Governments and former intelligence officials in Europe, Australia, Israel, Brazil, and Ukraine and other nations are not only demanding censorship but also often spreading their own disinformation.
For example, the EU claims that there is more false information on X than on other platforms, and more censorship would reduce it.
This is false. Only X has the open-source Community Notes system, which allows for real-time corrections to false information. A recent study in JAMA, the Journal of American Medicine, found that 97.5% of the Community Notes were entirely accurate, 2%, partially accurate, and 0.5%, inaccurate.
It’s not perfect. I myself sometimes disagree with them. And of course, science is never standing still, so what appears accurate today might not be accurate in the future.
However, X’s Community Notes uses more speech, not censorship, to provide context to controversial content. You can still agree or disagree with the content, even with a Community Note attached.
What the EU wants is for its committees of experts, not Community Notes, to secretly decide what we can read and say online. This is unethical and unconstitutional.
Another key part of the EU’s disinformation is that “researchers” should have access to X’s internal data, which Musk cut off when he bought Twitter. But those people who want the data aren’t researchers. They’re censorship activists, many of whom have deep relationships with governments in general and intelligence agencies in particular.
If the EU succeeds in censoring X, Facebook, Google, and every other major Internet platform, then there is no free speech. There is only government-controlled speech.
Many people rightly worry about the implications of a single man, Elon Musk, being all that stands between us and foreign governments’ totalitarian censorship plans. I worry about that, too. Our speech is inalienable. It is not something governments give to us.
We need to fight back. While we should be grateful to Musk for standing up to the totalitarians in Europe, Brazil, and Australia, we must build a citizen’s movement to fight back.
There’s three things you can do. First, share this video to raise the alarm. Second, add your email to our list here, so we can involve you in the future. And, third, consider making a donation to build the free speech movement and urge Congress and other social media companies to stand up for free speech against foreign interference.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Over the last seven years, Democrats and the mainstream news media have repeatedly characterized Donald Trump as “abnormal.” Said HBO’s John Oliver in 2016, “He is not normal. He is abnormal.” On January 31, 2017, a week after Trump took office, the New York Times published an essay on “The Abnormal Presidency of Donald Trump.” One month later, it published another essay asking, “Just How Abnormal Is the Trump Presidency? Rating 20 Events.”
Trump’s abnormality was particularly dangerous, Democrats and the news media warned us, since, as president, he was authorized to start nuclear war. And, explained the Chicago Tribune, “Trump’s abnormal behavior knows no boundaries.”
By contrast, Joe Biden was the “normalcy candidate,” according to Democrats and the media. Biden specifically campaigned on a “return to normalcy.” Concluded experts, “Joe Biden Won on Normalcy.” This came as a relief because Biden could be trusted to keep the country out of war, including nuclear war.
But as the debate last week made clear, there is nothing normal about either Joe Biden or the Biden presidency. Biden spoke incoherently, at one point saying, “We finally beat Medicare,” and claiming that America has a “thousand trillionaires.” Biden’s speech is soft and slurring, but he also sometimes shouts. He struggles to walk. And in mid-June, Biden twice froze in public and appeared disoriented several times in Europe.
After years of denying any serious problem, the news media turned on Biden after the debate, urging him to drop out. Someone in the White House told Axios that he only works productively from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., which could be a serious problem if he had to deal with a global emergency, such as an escalating conflict with Russia. It is not unreasonable to believe that other people are, at a minimum, reducing Biden’s choices if not making decisions for Biden entirely.
It’s true that all presidents rely to a significant degree on their cabinet secretaries and aides. Historians agree that after a stroke incapacitated President Woodrow Wilson, his wife made many decisions for him. President John F. Kennedy was, at times, incapacitated by back pain and high on pain medications.
But Biden appears to depend on unelected aides and officials or family members to a degree that is unprecedented for the United States and inappropriate for a democracy. Few believe he relies at all on Vice President Kamala Harris, who also struggles to speak.
And yet many Democrats, Democratic interest groups, and the news media are now rallying around Biden. This morning, MSNBC host Mika Brzezinski defended Biden and blamed his team for not managing his age and schedule better, saying, “Joe Biden has work to do. He has to do better. His team has to do a lot better. I’m just not ready, though, to count Joe Biden out. Not even close.”
The debate was “not a win for Trump,” Brzezinski said. “The choice is one terribly bad night versus a decade of destruction to our core beliefs, our democratic values, and yes, our constitution. Someone who stumbled over his words for 90 minutes versus someone who lied to the American people over and over again. A man slowed down by a cold versus a man with a cold, vile, and merciless heart.”
This continued support for Biden and the demands for his support point to the deeply authoritarian behavior of Democrats and their enablers in the news media.
Some Democrats are still pressuring Biden to step down, but this approach is also anti-democratic. The Democratic Party did not allow any serious challenge to Biden during the primaries. Despite widespread concerns among voters about Biden’s age and competence, he did not face significant opposition at a time when voters could have decided on an alternative. If Biden withdraws from the race now, there will be an open contest at the convention, allows the party to bypass the direct participation of Democratic voters altogether in electing a candidate for their party.
This would not be the first time the party sidestepped its voters and used undemocratic means to select a candidate. Donna Brazile claimed that there was an “unethical” agreement between the Clinton campaign and the Democratic National Committee (DNC) in 2016, which allowed the Clinton campaign to inappropriately control the party’s finances and strategy, to Bernie Sanders’ disadvantage, before she officially became the nominee. This revelation led many to conclude that the DNC had effectively “rigged” the primary.
With Biden, the party similarly suppressed alternative candidates. The New York Times reported yesterday that “interviews with top party strategists, office holders and people close to Democrats seen as possible presidential hopefuls suggest that, just as crucially, party leaders were lulled into complacency or pressed to step in line at crucial moments when they might have persuaded Mr. Biden to step aside… At key moments, those who tried to sound the alarm… were slapped down by Democrats, often in the brutal discord of social media sites like X, and chastised by top Biden aides for being disloyal.”
Democratic politicians could have rebelled but were too obedient to do so. “Candidates who might have considered challenging Mr. Biden,” wrote the Times, “after reviewing his weaknesses, yielded in the face of the threat of backlash from a party united behind its president.”
When Biden and the party could have been held accountable to voters during the primary season, party operatives and their media allies gaslit the public, insisted that everything was fine, and claimed that alarming videos of Biden’s impairment were simply right-wing disinformation. Only now that they have the opportunity to install a new candidate at the convention, such as California Governor Gavin Newsom, are they finally being honest about Biden’s evident cognitive decline. And some Democrats, like Brzezinski, are still absurdly obedient to Biden’s handlers, arguing that a president who can’t reliably string a sentence together is a viable option.
This is not the Democrats’ only authoritarian turn. Since at least 2016, Democrats have undermined democracy by facilitating and supporting the Censorship Industrial Complex. In 2020, the censorship of the Hunter Biden laptop, coordinated by party operatives and the intelligence community, may have impacted the election results. What’s more, Democrats overwhelmingly support the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), even as both of these agencies have engaged in profoundly anti-democratic activities.
It wasn’t always this way. From the 1960s until recently, the Democratic Party was the party of anti-authoritarianism. Democrats opposed foreign wars favored by the foreign policy establishment and fought to expose and end abuses of power by the FBI. And as the Times noted, the Democratic Party 50 years ago “rewrote its rules to marginalize the role of political bosses.” Democrats pasted “Question Authority” bumper stickers on their Hondas and Volvos. As recently as 2008, Democrats rejected the establishment candidate Hillary Clinton for the apparent outsider Barack Obama.
But now all this has changed. Republicans rejected their own party leaders, donors, and the foreign policy establishment to nominate Trump for president in 2016. Democrats, by contrast, sided with the establishment candidate in choosing Clinton in 2016 and Biden in 2020. And they did so again for 2024, even though nearly half of Democrats say Biden shouldn’t be running.
Why is that? Why did Democrats become an authoritarian party? -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
CBS' Lesley Stahl of "60 Minutes" said in October, 2020 that Hunter Biden's "laptop... can't be verified." That was false. It could be and was. And, according to the journalist who verified it, @peterschweizer, CBS and Stahl could have done so before she interviewed Trump.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
TWITTER FILES - CIA
The Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) is the most famous of the 18 US government agencies that comprise the Intelligence Community (IC) of the United States of America. Unlike the Federal Bureau of Investigations (FBI), the law strictly prohibits CIA employees or contractors from spying upon or running clandestine operations against American citizens on US soil.
But now, a new Twitter Files investigation reveals that a member of the Board of Trustees of the CIA’s mission-driven venture capital firm and ostensibly “former” IC and CIA analysts were involved in a 2021-2022 effort to take over Twitter’s content management system.
The effort also involved:
— a long-time IC contractor and senior Department of Defense R&D official who spent years developing technologies to detect whistleblowers (“insider threats”) like Edward Snowden and Wikileaks’ leakers;
— the proposed head of the DHS’ aborted Disinformation Governance Board, Nina Jankowicz, who aided US military and NATO “hybrid war” operations in Europe;
— Jim Baker, who, as FBI General Counsel, helped start the Russiagate hoax, and, as Twitter’s Deputy General Counsel, urged Twitter executives to censor The New York Post story about Hunter Biden.
x.com/shellenberger/status/1604902028852924416
These existing or former IC employees, contractors, or intermediaries weren’t satisfied with simply controlling Twitter. They also wanted to use PayPal, Amazon Web Services, and GoDaddy in a totalizing effort to de-platform, de-monetize, and excommunicate from the Internet entirely those individuals that the IC et al. deems to be a threat.
There is much that we still do not know about the effort. We do not know if officials within the CIA or any other IC organization ran the operation. It is possible that the only individuals involved in the effort were the ones we discovered. And none of the individuals involved responded to our request for information except for one.
But thousands of pages of Twitter Files and documents contained therein paint a clear picture of an organized operation by existing or former IC employees and contractors, using well-established IC tradecraft, to take control of Twitter’s content moderation.
Our investigation comes at a moment when governments and intelligence agencies around the world are stepping up their efforts to monitor and censor their citizens. It thus has large implications for policymakers and the public in Western nations that look to the US as a model for free speech and citizen control of the military.
This is a joint Public-Racket investigation. The authors are @Shellenberger @MTaibbi and @GalexyBrane. As always, the only condition we agreed to in publishing this was to first publish on X. At the end of this thread, we explain why and how this investigation began.
Here we go...
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
35. In response to Roth, Baker repeatedly insists that the Hunter Biden materials were either faked, hacked, or both, and a violation of Twitter policy. Baker does so over email, and in a Google doc, on October 14 and 15.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
You weaponized European intelligence agencies to claim, without evidence, that your political enemies were funded by Russia. Now you are demanding mass censorship in the name of saving democracy. You are a totalitarian and should be ashamed of yourself. Step down.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Queridos amigos brasileiros,
Pessoas poderosas nos nossos governos e nas nossas sociedades acreditam que têm o direito de decidir o que podemos ou não dizer, ouvir e não ouvir. Eles não estão apenas tentando nos censurar, estão tentando banir totalmente das redes sociais os jornalistas e líderes eleitos que eles não podem controlar.
Mas agora, o mundo inteiro está assistindo. O sinistro ataque à liberdade de expressão no Brasil pelo presidente Lula e pelo ministro Alexandre de Moraes é uma das maiores polêmicas do mundo.
E ficará ainda maior quando eu testemunhar perante o Congresso na próxima terça-feira, 7 de maio, em uma audiência intitulada “Brasil: uma crise de democracia, liberdade e Estado de Direito?”
Uma audiência no Congresso por si só não mudará nada. Ainda precisaremos que o Congresso aja para condenar o comportamento ultrajante, ilegal e imoral de Lula e de Moraes, e tome quaisquer outras ações necessárias para defender os direitos humanos fundamentais, incluindo a liberdade de expressão.
Mas a audiência é o primeiro passo nesse processo. Em sua carta-convite para mim, o poderoso presidente do Comitê de Relações Exteriores, Michael McCaul, escreve que a audiência “discutirá como o Congresso dos EUA pode abordar melhor as graves violações de direitos humanos que foram cometidas por autoridades brasileiras em grande escala”. .
“Estas violações dos direitos humanos incluem”, escreve o Presidente McCaul, “a prevaricação judicial, a perseguição da oposição política, a violação da liberdade de expressão e o amordaçamento dos meios de comunicação da oposição. suas agências a agir, não permanecendo mais em silêncio enquanto a democracia, a liberdade e o Estado de direito estão sendo minados ".
É fácil desesperar-se perante o poder das forças das trevas que tomaram conta dos nossos países. Eles são implacáveis. Estão dispostos a violar as nossas constituições, a censurar os seus inimigos e a interferir nas eleições.
Mas as pessoas do mundo estão unidas pela liberdade de expressão. O povo do Brasil tem falado: não à censura! Não à ditadura! E o povo americano está absolutamente ao lado do povo brasileiro na sua luta pela liberdade de expressão.
Eis o que os inimigos da liberdade de expressão não compreendem: os nossos direitos foram-nos dados pelo nosso Criador, não por eles. Nossos direitos são inalienáveis e protegidos por nossas constituições. E lutaremos e morreremos para protegê-los.
Seu amigo americano, para sempre,
Michael Shellenberger -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Esse homem é uma vergonha para o Brasil. Ele exige que X e todas as outras plataformas de redes sociais proíbam, para sempre, os jornalistas e políticos independentes que o criticam acertadamente por se comportar como um ditador. Ele mente e afirma que as pessoas que o criticam são “extremistas”. Ele é o extremista. Ele é um juiz que age unilateralmente para inventar leis totalmente novas. Ele está interferindo nas eleições e usurpando o papel do Congresso e do presidente. Ele está acabando com a liberdade de expressão e a democracia no Brasil e assumindo o papel de ditador. O povo do Brasil está horrorizado e envergonhado por ele. O Senado e o Supremo Tribunal brasileiros deveriam finalmente enfrentá-lo. Nem o governo dos EUA nem qualquer outro governo democrático deveria reconhecer a sua autoridade. A cada dia que passa ele zomba da Constituição do Brasil e dos direitos fundamentais da humanidade.
GloboNews
@GloboNews
Durante evento no Centro do RJ para a criação do Museu da Democracia, que será inaugurado em 2026, o ministro Alexandre de Moraes fez fortes críticas ao que chamou de “empresários mercantilistas de redes sociais” que só visam lucro e unem poder econômico com o autoritarismo extremista de novos políticos.
➡ Assista ao #globonewsmais, com @juliaduailibi, na #globonews: g1.globo.com/globonews/ao-vivo/globonews-ao-vivo.ghtmlThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Years Of US-UK Military And Intelligence Planning Behind Sweeping Brazil Censorship, Evidence Suggests
_Secret evidence, specialized spy units, and permanent bans on populists were key tactics developed by government operatives_
Late last night, the Judiciary Committee of the U.S. House of Representatives released over 500 pages of confidential Brazilian court documents relating to censorship demands on X, formerly Twitter. The Committee had obtained them from X through its subpoena powers.
The documents show a single Superior Electoral Court (TSE) Justice, Alexandre de Moraes, demanding permanent bans on over 150 elected officials and journalists. De Moraes demanded these bans in secret processes, without explanation or means of appeal, and across social media platforms. Given the dependence of elected leaders on social media, these demands for bans may constitute electoral interference.
In one case, De Moraes demanded that all major social media platforms, including at least one, Twitter, which did not publish the offending material, ban a federal Congressman, Marcel Van Hattem. The TSE had claimed that Van Hattem had criticized the election results. Not only had Van Hattan’s video not been related to the elections, but it was also a criticism of the Labor Department. It was released one day before the election.
In many ways, Brazil’s sweeping censorship system is unique to Brazil. Brazil’s Censorship Industrial Complex is located in the judiciary rather than in the executive branch, as it is in Europe, in the European Commission, and the U.S., in the Department of Defense, Department of Homeland Security, National Science Foundation, and other agencies.
However, in other ways, Brazil’s censorship simply reflects the most advanced form of the Censorship Industrial Complex vision created by US and UK government officials, particularly ones working for the military and intelligence agencies.
Our work revealed that current and former agents from the US Department of Defense, the CIA, the Department of Homeland Security, and the British Ministry of Defense all developed comprehensive censorship programs. The Department of Defense and the National Science Foundation have been caught funding the creation of censorship tools, including AI-based ones, for Facebook, Twitter, and other social media platforms to engage in mass censorship.
Beginning in early 2017, several military and intelligence agencies and agents from the US and UK governments developed similar censorship tactics that Brazil's Superior Electoral Court (TSE) was caught using. Those tactics included…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
.@leandrofoxgoias @Ar_1News @DaviSacer @ConstaJornalist @crisbrasilreal
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
President Lula says he supports free speech, but he doesn't. He is, at this moment, demanding a censorship regime as severe as the one that has been in place in Cuba since the early 1960s.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
O governo brasileiro quer censurar as teorias da conspiração e ainda assim aqui está, espalhando teorias da conspiração: " O governo brasileiro suspeita que os ataques de Elon Musk ao ministro Alexandre de Moraes e agora também diretamente ao presidente Lula estão sendo feitos em cooperativa com deputados bolsonaristas..." relata a CNN.
A CNN publicou este segmento embora admitisse que “Ainda não temos provas sobre isso, está sendo investigado”.
Boa sorte em encontrar evidências porque não há nenhuma!
Fui convidado há muitos meses para palestrar no Fórum pela Liberdade no Rio Grande do Sul. Antes de chegar, meus colegas jornalistas brasileiros, David Agape e Eli Viera, me pediram para ver se havia algum arquivo do Twitter no Brasil.
Olhei e descobri que havia. O que descobrimos nos chocou: Alexandre de Moraes e outros funcionários do governo ameaçaram processar criminalmente o advogado do Twitter no Brasil se ele não entregasse informações *privadas* e *pessoais*, incluindo números de telefone das pessoas e suas mensagens diretas pessoais!
Publiquei os Arquivos do Twitter logo após desembarcar em Porto Alegre.
*Ninguém* além de David, Eli e mais um colega meu sabia que eu iria publicar o Twitter Files Brasil.
Depois que ficou claro que muitos brasileiros estavam interessados em falar comigo sobre os Arquivos do Twitter, adiei em uma semana meu retorno aos EUA. Depois que decidi fazer isso, o Diputado Federal Marcel Van Hattem cancelou a sua viagem há muito planejada a Bruxelas.
Conheci Van Hattem em Londres no ano passado, numa conferência, e ele estava no Fórum pela Liberdade, em Porto Alegre. Aceitei com gratidão a oferta de Van Hattem de ser apresentado a diversas pessoas que ele conhecia no Brasil.
É isso. Essa é toda a “coordenação”. Se a CNN tivesse feito o seu trabalho, poderia ter aprendido tudo isto comigo antes de publicar a sua “desinformação”. Na verdade, a CNN me entrevistou há duas noites e contei aos dois repórteres como surgiu o Twitter Files – Brasil. Aparentemente, os repórteres da CNN não conversam entre si.
Aparentemente, a CNN também não fez o dever de casa com Elon Musk. Com Elon, o que você vê é o que você obtém. Ele respondeu publicamente ao Twitter Files Brasil. Não falamos sobre eles nem nos correspondemos sobre eles. Ele ouviu falar deles no mesmo momento em que o mundo ouviu falar deles.
Será realmente tão difícil acreditar que os políticos que foram censurados tenham respondido em X a mais provas das exigências de censura de Moraes? Que idiota.
Estou tentando ser gentil com isso, mas com o segmento abaixo, a CNN não está se comportando como uma mídia de notícias justa e equilibrada. Está se comportando como um teórico da conspiração irresponsável, carregando água para o governo Lula.
Pelo menos você não me verá exigindo que o governo censure a CNN.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Obrigado a todos que expressaram preocupação com minha segurança. Por favor, saiba que não temo nem o diabo nem de Moraes, apenas Deus no céu. E Ele quer que vivamos em liberdade, não em escravidão.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Elon Musk é a única coisa que impede o totalitarismo global
Aqui é Michael Shellenberger, falando de São Paulo, Brasil.
Ontem à noite, por volta das 20h, o ministro do Supremo Tribunal Federal, Alexandre de Moraes, anunciou uma investigação criminal contra Elon Musk, dono do X, antes conhecido como Twitter, por supostamente espalhar desinformação, obstruir a justiça e permitir que pessoas banidas por Alexandre de Moraes voltassem a usar as redes sociais para expressar livremente suas opiniões. Alexandre determinou que multará o X em 20 vinte mil dólares, por dia, para cada pessoa banida que Musk permitir voltar a postar e se expressar.
Com tal decisão, Alexandre de Moraes levou o Brasil a ficar a um passo de se tornar uma ditadura totalitária.
Os acontecimentos das últimas semanas demonstram que Elon Musk é a última barreira contra o totalitarismo global. Sem liberdade de expressão, não pode haver democracia.
Se o X cair, devemos continuar a lutar. Podemos continuar a nos comunicar através do whatsapp, e-mail e outras plataformas de redes sociais, como o Facebook e Instagram.
Mas o e-mail e mesmo o whatsapp não substituem completamente a capacidade das redes sociais de partilharem informações simultâneas com milhões de pessoas. E Mark Zuckerberg, o proprietário do Facebook, abandonou a liberdade de expressão em 2020, após três anos de pressão implacável de ONGs ativistas, membros do partido democratas e anunciantes empresariais.
E os principais veículos de mídia globais nunca foram tão corruptos e totalitários. Com poucas exceções, a mídia tradicional difunde desinformação e propaganda governamental como seu modelo de negócios.
Os governos são agentes ativos nesta guerra global contra a liberdade de expressão. No mês passado, a Suprema Corte dos EUA realizou uma audiência onde os juízes deixaram claro que concordavam com o fato de o governo dos EUA pressionar as empresas de mídia social a censurar. Na semana passada, o governo escocês implementou uma lei para reprimir o chamado discurso de ódio, incluindo piadas de comediantes. Na Irlanda, o governo quer ter o poder de enviar a polícia às casas das pessoas para revistar computadores e telefones em busca de discurso de ódio. No Canadá, o partido Liberal, no poder, quer a autoridade de mandar pessoas para a prisão perpétua por coisas que disseram. E a União Europeia capacitou um pequeno grupo de burocratas para decidir o que é verdadeiro e falso e para se envolverem na censura em massa.
Tudo isto acontece exatamente no momento em que os meus colegas e eu revelamos que as organizações governamentais de inteligência estão trabalhando através de ONGs para interferir nas eleições, espalhando desinformação sobre ativistas populistas e candidatos políticos. Por outras palavras, os governos exigem censura para proteger a sua capacidade de espalhar desinformação.
Para piorar a situação, os governos estão financiando diretamente a mídia tradicional. O atual governo brasileiro está gastando 30 vezes mais do que o governo anterior em publicidade para os veículos, a fim de espalhar desinformação de seu interesse.
Nunca na minha vida pensei que viveria para ver a ascensão do totalitarismo a nível global. Uma poderosa minoria de elites instruídas em todo o mundo exige a censura, a perseguição e o encarceramento dos seus inimigos políticos. Naturalmente, fazem-no em nome da salvação da democracia. Estou chocado e envergonhado ao perceber que amigos e aliados históricos se tornaram totalitários. A única explicação é que eles estão nas garras de uma psicose em massa, após anos de propaganda midiática e desinformação governamental, alegando falsamente que movimentos políticos populistas são antidemocráticos.
O fato do futuro da liberdade de expressão em boa parte repousar sobre os ombros de um único indivíduo não é algo que qualquer um de nós deva desejar. Não creio que esta seja uma responsabilidade que Elon Musk queira. Ele seria uma pessoa ainda mais rica se não tivesse comprado o Twitter. Ele também estaria vivendo uma vida mais tranquila. Depois que Musk comprou o Twitter, a administração Biden e o Partido Democrata declararam guerra contra ele. Várias agências governamentais entraram com vários processos frágeis contra Musk e suas empresas, de forma muito semelhante à guerra que o governo brasileiro está travando contra ele.
O que foi eventualmente revelado é que, até Musk comprar o Twitter, não tínhamos liberdade de expressão desimpedida. O governo dos EUA sentiu que controlava tanto a mídia como as redes sociais. Vimos nos Twitter Files dos Estados Unidos que o FBI orquestrou uma campanha de desinformação e censura para proteger a Família Biden. Começando pela Liga de Inteligência sobre Ameaças Cibernéticas, servidores do Departamento de Defesa dos EUA e do Ministério da Defesa britânico implementaram censura e desinformação enquanto alegavam que apenas aprimoravam a “segurança cibernética”. Depois disso, o Departamento de Segurança Interna dos EUA e o Observatório da Internet de Stanford envolveram-se num esforço de censura em massa em torno das eleições de 2020 e durante a pandemia.
É também claro que as agências de inteligência e de segurança têm trabalhado em conjunto, em todo o mundo, para obter controle sobre as plataformas das redes sociais, a fim de desacreditar, processar e encarcerar líderes denominados de populistas ou extremistas de direita. As evidências agora são esmagadoras de que o FBI e o Serviço Secreto estão encobrindo evidências relacionadas ao motim de 6 de janeiro de 2021, no Capitólio em Washington, DC. E ainda há muito que não sabemos sobre o motim assustadoramente semelhante na capital do Brasil em 8 de janeiro de 2023.
Há muito que precisamos fazer para voltar a lutar....This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Elon Musk Is All That Stands In The Way Of Totalitarianism
Last night, around 8 p.m. local time in São Paulo, Brazil, Federal Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes announced a criminal investigation into Elon Musk, the owner of X, formerly known as Twitter, for allegedly spreading disinformation, obstructing justice, and allowing people who De Moraes had banned from social media to freely express their views. De Moraes said he would fine X twenty thousand dollars per day for every banned person Musk allows to speak.
As such, De Moraes has taken Brazil one step closer to being a dictatorship. What’s more, the events of the last few weeks make clear that Elon Musk is the only thing standing in the way of global totalitarianism. Without free speech, there can be no democracy.
If X goes down, we must continue to fight. We can continue to communicate through email and other social media platforms, such as Facebook.
But email is no substitute for social media platforms' capacity to share information with millions of people. Mark Zuckerberg, the owner of Facebook, abandoned his principled free speech position in 2020 after three years of relentless pressure from activist NGOs, Democrats, and corporate advertisers. Today, Facebook actively represses the spread of news.
The mainstream corporate news media have never been more corrupt and totalitarian. With few exceptions, they spread government propaganda as a matter of policy. Nobody demands censorship more than the corporate media, which benefit from governments shutting down their competitors.
Governments are either not protecting free speech or actively participating in the war upon it.
Last month, the US Supreme Court held a hearing where justices made clear that they were fine with the US government pressuring social media companies to censor. Last week, the Scottish government implemented a law to crack down on so-called hate speech, including jokes by comedians. In Ireland, the government wants the power to send police into people’s homes to search computers and phones for hate speech. In Canada, the governing Liberal party wants the power to send people to prison for life for things they’ve said. And the European Union has empowered a tiny group of bureaucrats to decide what is true and false and engage in mass censorship.
All of this is happening at the very same moment that my colleagues and I have revealed that government intelligence organizations are working through NGOs to interfere in elections by spreading disinformation about populist activists and political candidates. In other words, governments are demanding censorship in order to protect their ability to spread disinformation.
Making matters worse, governments are directly financing corporate news media. The current Brazilian government is spending 30 times more than the previous government on media advertising in order to spread its disinformation.
I never in my life thought I would live to see the rise of totalitarianism in Western countries. A powerful minority of educated elites around the world are demanding the censorship, persecution, and incarceration of their political enemies. Naturally, they are doing so in the name of saving democracy. I am shocked and embarrassed that I used to call many of these totalitarians friends and allies. The only explanation is that they are in the grip of mass psychosis after years of media propaganda and government disinformation falsely claiming that populist political movements are undemocratic.
The fact that the future of free speech rests upon the shoulders of a single individual is not something any of us should want. I do not think that this is a responsibility Elon Musk wants. He would be a far richer person had he never bought Twitter. He would also be living a more peaceful life. After Musk bought Twitter, the Biden administration and the Democratic Party declared war on him. Various government agencies filed multiple frivolous lawsuits against Musk and his companies in ways very similar to the war the Brazilian government is waging against X.
What all of this reveals is that, until Musk bought Twitter, we didn’t really have freedom of expression. The US government felt that it controlled both the corporate news media and social media companies. We saw in the Twitter Files that the FBI orchestrated a disinformation and censorship campaign in order to protect Joe Biden.
Starting with the Cyber Threat Intelligence League, operatives working for the US Department of Defense and the British Ministry of Defense sought to hide their censorship and disinformation efforts as “cyber security.” After that, the US Department of Homeland Security and the Stanford Internet Observatory engaged in a mass censorship effort around the 2020 elections and Covid.
It is today clear that intelligence and security agencies have been working together around the world to gain control over social media platforms in order to discredit, prosecute, and incarcerate populist leaders. The evidence is now overwhelming that the FBI and Secret Service are covering up evidence related to the January 6, 2021, Capitol riot in Washington DC. And there is still much we do not know about the eerily similar riot in Brazil’s capitol on January 8, 2023.
There is much we need to do to fight back....This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
BRAZIL IS ON THE BRINK
I’m reporting to you from Brazil, where a dramatic series of events are underway.
At 5:52 pm Eastern Time, today, April 6, 2024, X corporation, formerly known as Twitter, announced that a Brazilian court had forced it to “block certain popular accounts in Brazil.”
Then, less than one hour later, the owner of X, @ElonMusk announced that X would defy the court’s order, and lift all restrictions.
“As a result,” said Musk, “we will probably lose all revenue in Brazil and have to shut down our office there. But principles matter more than profit.”
At any moment, Brazil’s Supreme Court could shut off all access to X/Twitter for the people of Brazil.
It is not an exaggeration to say that Brazil is on the brink of dictatorship at the hands of a totalitarian Supreme Court Justice named Alexandre de Moraes.
President Lula da Silva is participating in the push toward totalitarianism. Since taking office, Lula has massively increased government funding of the mainstream news media, most of which are encouraging increased censorship.
What Lula and de Moraes are doing is an outrageous violation of Brazil’s constitution and the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights.
At this moment, Brazil is not yet a dictatorship. It still has elections and the Brazilian people have other means at their disposal to confront authoritarianism.
But the Federal Supreme Court and the Superior Electoral Court are directly interfere in those elections through censorship.
Three days ago I published the Twitter Files for Brazil. They show that Moraes has violated the Brazilian Constitution. Moraes illegally demanded that Twitter reveal private information about Twitter users who used hashtags he considered inappropriate. He demanded access to Twitter's internal data, violating the platform's policy. He censored, on his own initiative and without any respect for due process, posts on Twitter by parliamentarians from the Brazilian Congress. And Moraes tried to turn Twitter's content moderation policies into a weapon against supporters of then-president Jair Bolsonaro.
I say this as an independent and non-partisan journalist. I'm not a fan of either Bolsonaro or Trump. My political views are very moderate. But I know censorship when I see it.
The Twitter Files also revealed that Google, Facebook, Uber, WhatsApp and Instagram betrayed the people of Brazil. If such evidence is proven, the executives of these companies behaved like cowards: they provided the Brazilian government with personal registration data and telephone numbers without a court order and, therefore, violating the law.
When Twitter refused to provide Brazilian authorities with private user information, including direct messages, the government attempted to sue Twitter's top Brazilian lawyer.
When I lived in Brazil in 1992, I was very left-wing. At the time, Lula and the PT's slogans were “Without fear of being happy”.
In recent days, I have spoken to dozens of Brazilians, including professors, journalists and respected lawyers. Everyone tells me they are shocked by what is happening. They told me that they are afraid to speak their mind and that the Lula government is complicit in creating this climate of fear.
Brazil belongs to the Brazilians. It is not my country. As such, there are limits to what I am capable of doing.
But I can say things that many Brazilians do not feel safe saying: Alexandre de Moraes is a tyrant. And the only way to deal with tyrants is to confront them. It is up to Brazil’s senators to confront the tyrant. And it is up to the people of Brazil to demand that their senators do so.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
BRASIL À BEIRA
Este é Michael Shellenberger, e estou reportando a vocês ao vivo do Brasil, onde uma série dramática de eventos está em andamento.
Às 18h52, horário do Sao Paulo a corporação X, anteriormente conhecida como Twitter, anunciou que um tribunal brasileiro a forçou a “bloquear certas contas populares no Brasil”.
Menos de uma hora depois, o proprietário do X, Elon Musk, anunciou que o X desafiaria a ordem do tribunal e suspenderia todas as restrições.
“Como resultado”, disse Musk, “provavelmente perderemos todas as receitas no Brasil e teremos que fechar nosso escritório lá. Mas os princípios são mais importantes do que o lucro.”
A qualquer momento, o Supremo Tribunal Federal poderá bloquear todo o acesso ao X/Twitter para o povo brasileiro.
Não é exagero dizer que o Brasil está à beira da ditadura nas mãos de um ministro totalitário do Supremo Tribunal Federal chamado Alexandre de Moraes.
O presidente Lula da Silva está participando desse impulso em direção ao totalitarismo. Desde que assumiu o cargo, Lula aumentou enormemente o financiamento governamental dos principais meios de comunicação, a maioria dos quais incentiva o aumento da censura.
O que Lula e de Moraes estão fazendo é uma violação escandalosa da Constituição do Brasil e da Declaração dos Direitos Humanos das Nações Unidas.
Neste momento, o Brasil ainda não é uma ditadura consolidada. Vocês ainda têm eleições e outros meios de enfrentar o autoritarismo que já não existem em tiranias mais avançadas.
Mas o Supremo Tribunal Federal e o Tribunal Superior Eleitoral interferem em eleições por meio de censura.
Há três dias eu publiquei os Arquivos do Twitter para o Brasil. Eles mostram que Moraes tem violado a Constituição brasileira. Moraes exigiu ilegalmente que o Twitter revelasse informações privadas sobre usuários do Twitter que usaram hashtags que ele considerou impróprias. Ele exigiu acesso aos dados internos do Twitter, violando a política da plataforma. Ele censurou, por iniciativa própria e sem nenhum respeito ao devido processo, postagens no Twitter de parlamentares do Congresso brasileiro. E Moraes tentou transformar as políticas de moderação de conteúdo do Twitter em uma arma contra os apoiadores do então presidente Jair Bolsonaro.
Digo isso como jornalista independente e apartidário. Não sou fã nem de Bolsonaro nem de Trump. As minhas opiniões políticas são muito moderadas. Mas eu reconheço a censura quando a vejo.
Os Arquivos do Twitter também revelaram que Google, Facebook, Uber, WhatsApp e Instagram traíram o povo do Brasil. Se forem comprovados tais indícios, os executivos dessas empresas comportaram-se como covardes: forneceram ao governo brasileiro dados cadastrais pessoais e números de telefone sem ordem judicial e, portanto, violando a lei.
Quando o Twitter se recusou a fornecer informações privadas dos usuários às autoridades brasileiras, incluindo mensagens diretas, o governo tentou processar o principal advogado brasileiro do Twitter.
Quando eu morei no Brasil em 1992, eu era muito de esquerda. Na época, as palavras de ordem de Lula e do PT eram “Sem medo de ser feliz”.
Nos últimos dias, conversei com dezenas de brasileiros, incluindo professores, jornalistas e advogados respeitados. Todos me disseram que estão chocados com o que está acontecendo. Eles me disseram que têm medo de falar o que pensam e que o governo Lula é cúmplice na criação desse clima de medo.
O Brasil é o seu país, não o meu. Existem limites para o que sou capaz de fazer. Sei bem até onde posso ir.
Mas prometo que eu vou apoiar vocês na sua luta pela liberdade. E posso dizer uma coisa que muitos brasileiros não podem mais: Alexandre de Moraes é um tirano. E a única maneira de lidar com os tiranos é enfrentando-os. Cabe aos seus senadores enfrentar o tirano. E cabe ao povo do Brasil pressionar seus senadores para que façam isso.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Government-Funded NGOs, Linked To NATO, Are Interfering In European Elections
“Correctiv” and “Institute for Strategic Dialogue” are military and intelligence front groups spreading disinformation about German farmers and politicians, evidence suggests
by @GregorBas1 and @Shellenberger
Last week, Public reported that European politicians are waging a disinformation campaign aimed at smearing their political opponents as linked to Russia. The current effort appears related to a disinformation operation by the French military. In February, French military officials claimed that “websites” were promoting “an anti-French narrative.”
In February and now, Western government officials made accusations against their political enemies but made no arrests and announced no prosecutions, which likely means they do not have any evidence of criminal activity. As such, government military and intelligence agencies are engaged in essentially political activities unrelated to national security and thus illegal.
Now, Public has learned that both NATO-funded and government-funded NGOs are working with government bodies to interfere in German elections. Their “influence operation” aims to keep Germany in line with American foreign policy objectives and undermine the European peace movement.
The evidence suggests that European intelligence agencies and NATO are breaking domestic EU laws against foreign election interference. The EU prohibits elected officials and politicians from using military, intelligence, and security agencies to advance political and electoral means.... -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
TWITTER FILES - BRAZIL
Brazil is engaged in a sweeping crackdown on free speech led by a Supreme Court justice named Alexandre de Moraes.
De Moraes has thrown people in jail without trial for things they posted on social media. He has demanded the removal of users from social media platforms. And he has required the censorship of specific posts, without giving users any right of appeal or even the right to see the evidence presented against them.
Now, Twitter Files, released here for the first time, reveal that de Moraes and the Superior Electoral Court he controls engaged in a clear attempt to undermine democracy in Brazil. They:
— illegally demanded that Twitter reveal personal details about Twitter users who used hashtags he did not like;
— demanded access to Twitter’s internal data, in violation of Twitter policy;
— sought to censor, unilaterally, Twitter posts by sitting members of Brazil’s Congress;
— sought to weaponize Twitter’s content moderation policies against supporters of then-president @jairbolsonaro
The Files show: the origins of the Brazilian judiciary’s demand for sweeping censorship powers; the court’s use of censorship for anti-democratic election interference; and the birth of the Censorship Industrial Complex in Brazil.
TWITTER FILES - BRAZIL was written by @david_agape_ @elivieira & @shellenberger
We presented these findings to de Moraes, to the Supreme Court (STF), and to the High Electoral Court (TSE). None responded.
Let’s get into it... -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A new hate speech law is required to protect children online, says Canada's @justinTrudeau. But it's not. Harming kids is already illegal. And now, Trudeau's government has confirmed to Public that the law would allow judges to send people to prison for speech crimes — for life.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
THE WPATH FILES
Advocates of gender-affirming care say it’s evidence-based.
But now, newly released internal files from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) prove that the practice of transgender medicine is neither scientific nor medical.
American Medical Association, The Endocrine Society, the American Academy of Pediatrics, and thousands of doctors worldwide rely on WPATH. It is considered the leading global authority on gender medicine.
And yet WPATH’s internal files, which include written discussions and a video, reveal that its members know they are creating victims and not getting “informed consent.”
Victims include a 10-year-old girl, a 13-year-old developmentally delayed adolescent, and individuals suffering from schizophrenia and other serious mental illnesses.
The injuries described in the WPATH Files include sterilization, loss of sexual function, liver tumors, and death.
WPATH members indicate repeatedly that they know that many children and their parents don’t understand the effects that puberty blockers, hormones, and surgeries will have on their bodies. And yet, they continue to perform and advocate for gender medicine.
The WPATH Files prove that gender medicine is comprised of unregulated and pseudoscientific experiments on children, adolescents, and vulnerable adults. It will go down as one of the worst medical scandals in history.
environmentalprogress.org/big-news/wpath-files -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The U.S. government said in January 2017 that Russia favored Trump as president. But now, sources reveal for the first time that the CIA "cooked the intelligence" to hide that Vladamir Putin wanted Hillary Clinton, not Donald Trump, as president.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A missing binder of top-secret intelligence about Russia threatens national security, says CNN. But it doesn't. And now, credible sources say the U.S. government is hiding the binder because it incriminates the intelligence community for illegal spying and election interference.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The FBI, George Soros, and Brazil's government say they defend free speech and democracy. But a new, months-long investigation finds that they have been secretly working together to oversee a mass censorship effort that is in direct violation of the US & Brazilian Constitutions.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The head of the World Health Organization says we are doomed to rising rates of diabetes, but we're not, argues science journalist Gary Taubes in his major new book, "Rethinking Diabetes." We just have to radically rethink the role of diet in creating overweight, obesity, and diabetes in the first place.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
US Military Contractors Used Counterterrorism Tactics Against The American People, New Documents Show
Their plans included psychological operations, debanking, and changing social media platforms’ Terms of Service
by @galexybrane
John Kelly, CEO of Graphika (Left); John Brennan, former CIA Director (center); Rand Waltzman, RAND Corporation (right) (Getty Images)
During last Thursday’s Congressional hearing on the Weaponization of the Federal Government, Democratic members of Congress insisted that censorship efforts of groups like the Cyber Threat Intelligence League (CTIL), the Election Integrity Partnership (EIP), and the Virality Project (VP) were benign and not a violation of the First Amendment.
“It's not the First Amendment!” said Rep. Dan Goldman, “It's the [social media platforms’] Terms of Service.... And they are flagging it for the social media companies to make their own decisions. That is not the First Amendment. That is the Terms of Service.”
But the CTIL Files, a trove of documents that a whistleblower provided to Public and Racket, reveal that US and UK military contractors developed and used advanced tactics — including demanding that social media platforms change their Terms of Service — to shape public opinion about Covid-19, and that getting content removed was just one strategy used by the Censorship Industrial Complex.
The CTI League, which partnered with the Department of Homeland Security’s Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA), aimed to implement something called “AMITT,” which stood for “Adversarial Misinformation and Influence Tactics and Techniques.”
AMITT was a disinformation framework that included many offensive actions, including working to influence government policy, discrediting alternative media, using bots and sock puppets, pre-bunking, and pushing counter-messaging.
The specific “counters” to “disinformation” in AMITT and its successor framework, DISARM, include many we have observed in our study of the Censorship Industrial Complex:
— “Create policy that makes social media police disinformation”
— “Strong dialogue between the federal government and private sector to encourage better reporting”
— “Marginalize and discredit extremists”
— “Name and Shame influencers”
— “Simulate misinformation and disinformation campaigns, and responses to them, before campaigns happen”
— “Use banking to cut off access”
— “Inoculate populations through media literacy training”
For issues like the Russiagate hoax to the Hunter Biden laptop to Covid-19, organizations within the Censorship Industrial Complex have used many of DISARM’s offensive methods like tabletop exercises, psychological inoculation, propaganda messaging, and punishment of dissent. Even its extreme proposal of debanking was used against Canada’s Freedom Convoy.
Far from simply protecting the public from falsehoods, both government and non-profit actors within Censorship Industrial Complex have followed CTIL’s exact playbook and have waged a full-fledged influence operation against Americans.
This influence operation has deep ties to security and intelligence agencies, as is evidenced through many examples of collaboration. In one instance of such collaboration, supposedly independent “disinformation researchers” like Renée DiResta coordinated a 2020 election tabletop exercise with military officials.
Defense and intelligence funding supports much of the Censorship Industrial Complex. For instance, Graphika, which was involved in both EIP and VP, receives grants from the Department of Defense, DARPA, and the Navy.
Pentagon-affiliated entities are heavily involved in “anti-disinformation” work. Mitre, a major defense contractor, received funding to tackle “disinformation” about elections and Covid. The US government paid Mitre, an organization staffed by former intelligence and military personnel, to monitor and report what Americans said about the virus online, and to develop vaccine confidence messaging. This government-backed military research group, Public discovered, was present in the EIP and VP misinformation reporting system, and in election disinformation report emails to CISA.
The AMITT framework also includes many counters we have yet to find concrete evidence for, but which we suspect may have been attempted:
— “Infiltrate the in-group to discredit leaders”
— “Honeypot with coordinated inauthentics”
— “Co-opt a hashtag and drown it out (hijack it back)”
— “Dilute the core narrative - create multiple permutations, target/amplify”
— “Newsroom/Journalist training to counter influence moves”
— “Educate high profile influencers on best practices”
— “Create fake website to issue counter narrative”
We may not know the extent to which all these counters were implemented, but we do know that the US military and the intelligence community have gone to extreme lengths to control what Americans can say and think. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
THE CTIL FILES #1
Many people insist that governments aren't involved in censorship, but they are. And now, a whistleblower has come forward with an explosive new trove of documents, rivaling or exceeding the Twitter Files and Facebook Files in scale and importance. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The leaders of the Censorship Industrial Complex insist they didn't break the law, but they did. They worked on behalf of the government, demanded mass censorship, and interfered in an election. In this video, I explain how they almost got away with it.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Representatives of a US government front group, "Stanford Internet Observatory," denied ever demanding censorship of anyone. They lied, and we have the proof. They got social media companies to censor accurate Covid information in a clear violation of the First Amendment. Bam.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Citizens are spreading dangerous misinformation on social media platforms, say journalists and governments. But inaccurate stories on the Gaza hospital explosion prove that the most dangerous misinformation comes not from citizens but from journalists who rely on governments.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The CDC says giving the newest Covid vaccine booster to children and young people outweighs the risks, but it doesn't. And now we have evidence that the CDC lied about and covered up the risk of myocarditis. Blockbuster new reporting by @galexybrane
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
CDC Covered Up COVID Vaccine Myocarditis Risk, Show Emails And Reports
US government had reviewed Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System cases of post-vaccine myocarditis when CDC’s director falsely claimed, “we have not seen any reports”
by @galexybrane
Former Director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Rochelle Walensky testifies during a House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations and the Subcommittee on Health hearing about the federal response to the coronavirus pandemic on Capitol Hill on February 8, 2023, in Washington, DC. (Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) is encouraging everyone six months and older to get the newest COVID-19 booster. The benefits for children and young people far outweigh the risks, argues CDC Director Mandy Cohen. “Teen boys have been up to five times as likely to have heart inflammation after having a COVID infection than after getting vaccinated,” Cohen said.
But the best available evidence does not back up Cohen’s claims. The CDC director is relying on a highly flawed study published in the CDC’s Morbidity and Mortality Weekly (MMWR).
It’s true that this study found teen boys ages 12-17 had two to six times greater risk of heart complications after COVID infection compared to after vaccination.
But the study only looked at electronic health records, which were limited to teenagers who had been admitted to the hospital or who visited a doctor. This means the subjects of the study were not representative of the total number of teen boys who got COVID, the vast majority of whom never went to the doctor.
And other papers show vastly different results.
A study from the American Heart Association on myocarditis (inflammation of the heart muscle) found that, “In men younger than 40 years old, the number of excess myocarditis events per million people was higher after a second dose of mRNA-1273 than after a positive SARS-CoV-2 test.”
A Nordic study of 23 million people found that for young men ages 16 to 24, post-vaccination myocarditis rates were six to 28 times higher than myocarditis rates after COVID infection. The study also found that there were zero myocarditis cases after COVID infection in males ages 12-15.
The consequences of vaccine-caused myocarditis can be serious. A review of clinical records found that ninety-six percent of people under 30 diagnosed with post-vaccination myocarditis were hospitalized. For some patients, symptoms persist. In one study from the US military, seven out of 23 myocarditis patients “continued to have chest discomfort” weeks after vaccination.
Although Cohen insists that children are at high risk of serious illness, the mean Infection Fatality Rate of COVID for people under 20 years old is 0.0003%, and hospitals have grossly inflated the reported number of children with severe COVID. One paperfound that hospital records overcounted the number of pediatric COVID hospitalizations by at least 40 percent.
The CDC’s recommendation that everyone aged 6 months and older get another booster is simply not scientifically or medically sound. The agency received but did not respond to Public’s requests for comment about its misrepresentation of myocarditis risks.
What’s more, a mounting body of evidence shows that the CDC and the White House chose to ignore and cover up evidence of a significant myocarditis safety signal in early 2021, putting young people at risk of serious adverse events. How did this happen? -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
When Trudeau's Liberal Party leaders said they would only regulate Big Tech social media platforms, they lied. They are now demanding that independent news media and even podcasters register to be regulated. Canada's crackdown comes as EU and UN-WEF demand ever-more censorship.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Fauci Diverted US Government Away From Lab Leak Theory Of Covid’s Origin, Sources Say
Fauci allegedly attacked lab leak theory at meetings at CIA, the State Department, and the White House
by @mtaibbi @galexybrane & @shellenberger
Dr. Anthony Fauci (C) speaks as US President Donald Trump listens during a press conference on COVID-19 in the Rose Garden of the White House on March 13, 2020, two days before the publication of the “Proximal Origin” paper dismissing the lab leak theory of Covid’s origin. (Photo by Chen Mengtong/China News Service via Getty Images)
The former director of the U.S. National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Diseases, Dr. Anthony Fauci, who led the U.S. government’s response to the coronavirus pandemic, visited CIA headquarters to “influence” its review of COVID-19 origins, the House Oversight Committee reported yesterday.
Last month, Committee Chair Brad Wenstrup made headlines when he revealed that seven CIA analysts “with significant scientific expertise" on the agency’s Covid-19 Discovery Team (CDT) received performance bonuses after changing a report to downplay concerns about a possible lab origin of the virus.
Now, a months-long investigation by Racket and Public, which included interviews with the CIA whistleblower behind last month’s revelations and others in a position to know, reveals that Fauci not only visited the CIA but also pushed the controversial “Proximal Origin of SARS CoV-2” paper, published by Nature Medicine, in meetings at the State Department and the White House.
Previous reporting already showed that Fauci “prompted” the “Proximal Origin” paper, according to its authors. Lead author Kristian Andersen expressed grave doubts about the natural origin theory even months after Nature Medicine published the paper. And they described themselves as pressured by “higher ups,” referring to individuals in the White House and other government agencies.
Now, the new information from multiple sources, including a CIA whistleblower, a senior government investigator, and a senior official, suggests a broad effort by Fauci to go agency-by-agency, from the White House to the State Department to the CIA, in an effort to steer government officials away from looking into the possibility that COVID-19 escaped from a lab.
“Fauci’s expert opinions were a significant consideration and were part of our classified assessment,” said the CIA whistleblower, a decorated and long-serving CIA officer with expertise in Asia. “His opinion substantially altered the conclusions that were subsequently drawn.”
Fauci had reasons to push scientists and intelligence analysts to believe the virus had a zoonotic origin since his agency had issued a grant to fund research at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) in China.
The Wenstrup press release noted that the whistleblower’s information suggested Fauci was escorted in “without record of entry.” According to the CIA whistleblower, the CIA purposely did not “badge” Fauci in and out of the building so as to hide any record that he had been there.
“Fauci came to our building, to promote the natural origin of the virus,” the CIA whistleblower said. “He knew what was going on. I mean, you see all the redacted documents that are coming out. He was covering his ass and he was trying to do it with the Intel community… I know he came multiple times and he was treated like a rockstar by the Weapons and Counter Proliferation Mission Center. And, he pushed the Kristian Anderson paper." -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The wind industry says it isn't killing whales, but it is. New boat traffic is colliding with whales. And high-decibel sonar is separating whale mothers from their calves, sending them into harm's way. Our new documentary, which lays out the evidence, is now free to watch.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The government says there's no proof the wind industry is killing whales, but there is. Researchers have now caught the wind industry using high-decibel sonar, as loud as a jackhammer, which is causing mothers & calves to separate, flee into boat traffic, and die.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The govt says the wind industry isn't killing whales, but it is. Here's the proof: another dead one, nicknamed "Faith." They found her yesterday at the @Orsted Southfork Wind site (#517), Rhode Island, right next to the (yellow) turbine base. 71st whale killed since last Dec
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Politicians & George Soros-funded NGOs say "hate incidents" are rising, but they're not. The data show the opposite: higher-than-ever and rising levels of tolerance of minorities. The reason they're spreading hate misinformation is to justify a draconian crackdown on free speech.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Mark Zuckerberg says Facebook has independent fact checkers, is open to all perspectives, and doesn’t interfere in elections.
But a new investigation found Facebook is funding activists demanding censorship of their enemies during a national referendum.
www.skynews.com.au/business/media/the-fact-check-files-in…Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
What a scandal.
Bravo to @Houghtontweets for uncovering it.
The Censorship Industrial Complex is vast and deep
It is a vampire that can be killed through exposure to sunlight
www.skynews.com.au/business/media/the-fact-check-files-in… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
YouTube's new policy is that it will censor you if you disagree with World Health Organization.
YouTube recognizes that WHO's "guidance" might change. But if it does, it won't be because of debate on YouTube.
YouTube isn't a social media platform, it's a propaganda platform.
Matt Orfalea
@0rf
BREAKING: YouTube no longer has a “Covid-19” policy but an expanded policy to ban *any* “medical misinformation” that contradicts WHO or local health authorities (like CDC) regarding substances and prevention, treatment, or denial of health conditions.
🧵/1
BEFORE/AFTER TODAY: -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For years, the government has insisted that the increase in whale deaths off the East Coast has no relationship to the wind industry's high-decibel pile driving and boat activity. But now, a new documentary, "Thrown To The Wind," based on new research, will challenge that.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Fact-checkers claim to have special powers to discern the truth, but they don't. And now, a new, months-long investigation finds multiple instances where fact-checkers spread misinformation and then demanded censorship. Why? Because of the narcissistic "third-person effect."
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
People think solar panels are good for the environment but they’re not. They’re made with toxic heavy metals and aren’t recycled. Most are made with coal in China and produce produce 3x more CO2 than IPCC thought. And they require 300-600x more land than other energy sources.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
People say solar panels don't produce carbon emissions, but they do. And now, a major new investigation by Environmental Progress, drawing on the research of @enricomariutti , finds that solar panels made in China produce at least 3x more carbon emissions than IPCC claims.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The White House says it didn't censor anyone, but new emails show it demanded Facebook censor posts about the lab leak.
"Can someone quickly remind me why we were removing... claims that Covid is man made”?
“We were under pressure from the administration and others to do more" -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
People say solar panels don't produce carbon emissions, but they do. And now, a major new investigation by Environmental Progress, drawing on the research of @enricomariutti , finds that solar panels made in China produce at least 3x more carbon emissions than IPCC claims.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Elites say we must censor social media companies to prevent riots and harm to vulnerable communities, but we mustn't. They are trying to trick us into accepting the violation of our most sacred and fundamental human rights. Why? Because they and their agendas are so unpopular.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Mark Zuckerberg & Meta say deamplyifying "anger" on Threads is a recipe for a more "public" platform, but it's not. It's a recipe for censorship, repression, and totalitarianism. Truly free speech isn't harmless. It's dangerous. And it always will be.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It’s “Chestfeeding” Now, Ladies
The Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has issued new guidance, endorsing “chestfeeding” by trans-identified biological males. On Wednesday, the Daily Mail and Fox News reported that several pages of the CDC’s website now include the term.
One CDC page about breast surgery has a section titled “Can transgender parents who have had breast surgery breastfeed or chestfeed their infants?” This section asserts that one option for these transgender parents is to take “medication to induce lactation.” To mimic lactation, biological males can use a combination of drugs. This combination can include a contraceptive pill to produce estrogen, an anti-nausea medication, a heart medication, an antipsychotic, a sedative, and an off-label lactation drug called domperidone.
In 2004, the FDA cautioned biological mothers against taking domperidone, in part because “the drug is excreted in breast milk that could expose a breastfeeding infant to unknown risks.” Despite this warning for biological females, the FDA has not issued any warning to trans-identified males who want to take the drug.
Neither the FDA nor the CDC appear to have assessed the safety or nutritional value of induced lactation in trans-identified males. Health agencies usually advise breastfeeding biological mothers to avoid many medications, including aspirin, and to avoid specific foods and drinks. So why doesn’t this same level of caution apply to “chestfeeding” males?
The CDC’s “chestfeeding” advice clearly has nothing to do with the well-being of infants. Its endorsement of an off-label hormone cocktail demonstrates, once again, that the CDC is a captured institution that issues guidance based on political interests rather than scientific evidence or health.
—AG
Free LGB From The T
A British tribunal ruled Thursday in favor of gay rights charity LGB Alliance which was forced to defend its charitable status after trans charity Mermaids brought legal action attempting to strip them of it in a first-of-its-kind case in the UK.
Thursday’s ruling is a huge win not just for gay, lesbian and bisexual people in Britain but also for anyone who cares about freedom of thought and speech.
The Tribunal said “the fundamental rationale of the democratic process upon which our society is founded is that when competing views, opinions and policies are publicly debated and exposed to public scrutiny, the good will over time drive out the bad and the true will prevail over the false. Only when differing views are expressed, contradicted, answered and debated will the legislature be able to obtain the fullest picture of the views held by those they represent.”
During the unusual hearing in September, a witness for Mermaids testified that cross-dressing men should be allowed on lesbian dating apps, and the legal counsel for Mermaids put it to co-founder Kate Harris that the term lesbian could include men who identify as women.
Harris gave a passionate and emotional response. “I’m going to speak for millions of lesbians around the world who are lesbians because we love other women. We will not have that stolen from us,” she said. “We will not be erased, and we will not have any man with a penis tell us he’s a lesbian because he feels he is.”
Harris called the action brought by Mermaids a “vanity project” that sought to impose their belief that there is only one acceptable point of view in the UK on the issue of sex and gender, and the judgment rejected this in favour of good, old-fashioned democratic principles.
Now, said another cofounder of the LGB Alliance, the group can go back to fighting homophobia — including the kind that tells lesbian girls they could, and should, become boys.
—MA
Maybe There’s So Little UFO Evidence Because People Don’t Want to Go To Prison
One of the big questions about UFOs is why, if they’re real, there’s so little physical evidence.
Part of the reason is fear of being ridiculed, according to the latest U.S. military officer, Navy Admiral Tim Gallaudet. “The stigma was real,” he told a journalist yesterday.
Gallaudet didn’t provide any alien space craft, nor other form of physical evidence. All he had was a story. But what a story it was.
“My sailors were in an exercise on the ship,” he explained, the “Theodore Roosevelt, an aircraft carrier… just off the East Coast…. I was on the receiving end of an email… from my boss… and the title of the email was ‘Urgent Safety of Flight Issue’ and… he said they were almost having mid air collisions with” UFOs.
Added Gallaudet, “They were thinking about shutting down the exercise for safety reasons.”
And yet nobody talked about it afterwards. Why? Both because of stigma and, he said, because “I knew my options as a government employee. You're bound not to disclose the information. It's what gets people thrown into jail, you know?”
The other problem, he said, was over-compartmentalization, which we had heard from our other sources. “When these programs were so compartmented that even senior naval officers or military officers weren't allowed in, that created a problem.”
But courage triumphed over fear.
“I figure, heck, you know, I am a retired admiral. My voice lends a bit of credibility to the topic. And I wanted to go to bat for people because this could be a change in our understanding that that … outpaces the Scientific Revolution of the 16th and 17th century by orders of magnitude.”
—MS
One Scoop of Freedom, Please
Julian Assange, the founder of WikiLeaks, has become an increasingly prominent figure in public discourse. Earlier this summer, the UK High Court denied his extradition order appeal, meaning he only has one avenue left to attempt to change their decision. If extradited to the US, he stands to face 175 years in prison.
Protests have gained momentum in response to the court’s decision, including action on behalf of Ben & Jerry’s Co-Founder, Ben Cohen. Yesterday, Cohen was arrested for blocking the entrance to the Department of Justice (DOJ) building in Washington DC, where he was protesting the US government’s prosecution of Assange.
“It seems to me, that right now, unless things change, and unless we change them, freedom of the press is going up in smoke,” says Cohen at the protest, symbolically burning the Bill of Rights. “There is no democracy without freedom of the press. The press is the only thing that can hold the government accountable.”
And yet, Ben & Jerry’s has specifically aligned itself with pro-censorship groups in the recent past, releasing a press statement demanding improved “content moderation” on Twitter. “Twitter must act today to end the extremist and violent content on the platform,” reads the press release. “Until that happens, Ben & Jerry’s will spend no money with Twitter and we call on all businesses and partners to do the same.”
Still, Cohen has made repeated appearances in support of Assange and free speech. “A murderous system is being created before our eyes,” he says in one October demonstration. “They are literally killing the messenger.”
If he is willing to get arrested in the name of free speech and fight for figures like Julian Assange, why would his own company advocate for something so draconian?
Cohen’s case demonstrates that there are gray areas when it comes to the fight for free speech. One could easily write off Cohen from a glass-half-full perspective, arguing he is appealing to the masses when convenient for egoistic fulfillment or financial gain.
But perhaps there is a silver lining in Cohen’s evident passion and dedication. Even the most liberal companies in favor of censorious policy can still see the value in the First Amendment and in journalists like Julian Assange.
-PS -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Experts said yesterday's anti-censorship court ruling was too badly written to be implemented, but it's already working. The State Department today canceled its regular Wednesday meeting with Facebook, and all future meetings, "pending further guidance.”
www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/07/05/missouri-bid… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Everyone should understand how dangerous the situation is
People tied to the national security state are trying to create a "back door" to read your private text messages.
This would set a precedent and put global surveillance & repression on steroids.
Please watch & share
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"In the history of human communication, for hundreds of thousands of years, the default was private....
"What we are talking about here is the UK is poised to set a damning precedent if we break encryption, if this mass surveillance provision goes forward.
"I want to protect the teens in Uganda where they just passed a law that makes being gay punishable by murder."
"It's become a Frankenstein's monster"
@mer__edith : Encryption either protects people or it doesn't. It is either safe or it is vulnerable. What's being proposed in this bill — if we can get back to the provision that we're concerned about — is a mechanism that would allow the evisceration of privacy, safety, and encryption.
@DamianCollins : How do you do it? Do you just take the police's word for it or —
Meredith: Do you wanna shadow me at work for a week?
Damian: No, I just —
Meredith — is that what you're asking? That's
Damian: What I'm saying is, how do you do it? You say you take action, but how?
Meredith: It depends on the situation. And we don't discuss confidential encounters with law enforcement.
Damian: Do you investigate the account — the user's account?
Meredith: Absolutely when, when warranted. But we're not going into those details…. What we are talking about here is the UK is poised to set a damning precedent if we break encryption, if this mass surveillance provision goes forward. We have authoritarian countries around the world that are looking to the UK to set the precedent — and let's be real about this. The International Human Rights Organization, Freedom House has classified about 40% of the world's population as living under repressive regimes point. So we're looking at Iran —
Damian: No. Cause we're not going to require de-encryption. What we will require is companies —
Meredith: But then you need to clarify the bill.
Cathay: Can it be amended? Clarified?
Meredith: It absolutely can be amended and clarified. There's amendment 205 that clarifies that this provision will not be used to break encryption.
Cathay: What's wrong with taking up that minimum?
Damian: Oh, because, uh, we don't need to set out things the bill's not gonna do. We set up the bill…. the things it is gonna do, and what it is gonna do is require companies to use available technologies… Now there are different sorts of messaging platforms. As I said before, if you've got a messaging platform that isn't encrypted available, technologies will help it detect things it can already see and find. If a messaging services is encrypted, we're not gonna require that encryption to be broken or redesigned.
Meredith: I am committed to holding Big Tech accountable. And indeed, I joined Signal because I wanted to protect people from the kind of surveillance that big tech perpetrates every day. I want to protect the teens in Uganda where they just passed a law that makes being gay punishable by murder. I want to protect the young women in Iran who are protesting democracy. I want to protect the people on the front lines in Ukraine, who are, who are fighting Putin. And all of this requires on being able to communicate safely and securely outside of this nexus of surveillance.
Cathy: This bill — some of your colleagues say is an illiberal mess. That your punishing the good guys like Meredith?
Damian: Well, no, we're not, because we're not good. I don't have any chance to say this. We're not going to require companies to deencrypt or create back doors into
Meredith: Specify that, and I'll go home and we'll be happy.
Damian: The legislation doesn't say, doesn't say that now. So we're not taking anything out. We don't need to because the bill is really —
Cathy: But the broader point, have you clarified that you have you, because of the abuse is of big tech as a whole ended up overreaching with this bill?
Damian No, not at all.
Cathy: And it's become a mess. It's become a Frankenstein's monsterThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
UK politician @DamianCollins says he just wants to protect kids but he doesn’t. He wants to turn the Internet — worldwide — into a police state. No more private messages because criminals use them. What’s next, cameras in every home? Warrantless searches? Please stop this maniac.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
"In the history of human communication, for hundreds of thousands of years, the default was private....
"What we are talking about here is the UK is poised to set a damning precedent if we break encryption, if this mass surveillance provision goes forward.
"I want to protect the teens in Uganda where they just passed a law that makes being gay punishable by murder."
"It's become a Frankenstein's monster"
@mer__edith : Encryption either protects people or it doesn't. It is either safe or it is vulnerable. What's being proposed in this bill — if we can get back to the provision that we're concerned about — is a mechanism that would allow the evisceration of privacy, safety, and encryption.
@DamianCollins : How do you do it? Do you just take the police's word for it or —
Meredith: Do you wanna shadow me at work for a week?
Damian: No, I just —
Meredith — is that what you're asking? That's
Damian: What I'm saying is, how do you do it? You say you take action, but how?
Meredith: It depends on the situation. And we don't discuss confidential encounters with law enforcement.
Damian: Do you investigate the account — the user's account?
Meredith: Absolutely when, when warranted. But we're not going into those details…. What we are talking about here is the UK is poised to set a damning precedent if we break encryption, if this mass surveillance provision goes forward. We have authoritarian countries around the world that are looking to the UK to set the precedent — and let's be real about this. The International Human Rights Organization, Freedom House has classified about 40% of the world's population as living under repressive regimes point. So we're looking at Iran —
Damian: No. Cause we're not going to require de-encryption. What we will require is companies —
Meredith: But then you need to clarify the bill.
Cathay: Can it be amended? Clarified?
Meredith: It absolutely can be amended and clarified. There's amendment 205 that clarifies that this provision will not be used to break encryption.
Cathay: What's wrong with taking up that minimum?
Damian: Oh, because, uh, we don't need to set out things the bill's not gonna do. We set up the bill…. the things it is gonna do, and what it is gonna do is require companies to use available technologies… Now there are different sorts of messaging platforms. As I said before, if you've got a messaging platform that isn't encrypted available, technologies will help it detect things it can already see and find. If a messaging services is encrypted, we're not gonna require that encryption to be broken or redesigned.
Meredith: I am committed to holding Big Tech accountable. And indeed, I joined Signal because I wanted to protect people from the kind of surveillance that big tech perpetrates every day. I want to protect the teens in Uganda where they just passed a law that makes being gay punishable by murder. I want to protect the young women in Iran who are protesting democracy. I want to protect the people on the front lines in Ukraine, who are, who are fighting Putin. And all of this requires on being able to communicate safely and securely outside of this nexus of surveillance.
Cathy: This bill — some of your colleagues say is an illiberal mess. That your punishing the good guys like Meredith?
Damian: Well, no, we're not, because we're not good. I don't have any chance to say this. We're not going to require companies to deencrypt or create back doors into
Meredith: Specify that, and I'll go home and we'll be happy.
Damian: The legislation doesn't say, doesn't say that now. So we're not taking anything out. We don't need to because the bill is really —
Cathy: But the broader point, have you clarified that you have you, because of the abuse is of big tech as a whole ended up overreaching with this bill?
Damian No, not at all.
Cathy: And it's become a mess. It's become a Frankenstein's monsterThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Biden admin has released a summary of US intelligence on the links between China’s Wuhan Institute of Virology and COVID-19. But by not revealing the names of the WIV scientists who fell ill in November 2019, President Biden is in violation of the law he signed.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
In Feb. 2020, after a @nypost oped said COVID-19 came from a lab leak, Facebook censored the story. Why? Because "independent fact-checkers" said it was "False information." Not only was it true information, one of the fact-checkers had worked at the lab
nypost.com/2020/04/17/facebook-fact-checkers-foul-again-a…Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We now know that covid started in a lab and that the US government has known for a long time that the first people to get sick were the scientists working on gain of function research, which makes viruses more infectious
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After years of official claims to the contrary, strong new evidence suggests the virus known as SARS-CoV-2 escaped from a Chinese lab. According to multiple sources, the researchers who led gain-of-function research, which increases infectiousness, were the first to be infected.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After years of official claims to the contrary, strong new evidence suggests the virus known as SARS-CoV-2 escaped from a Chinese lab. According to multiple sources, the researchers who led gain-of-function research, which increases infectiousness, were the first to be infected.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Pentagon says there's no credible evidence of alien spacecraft, but several military and intelligence contractors with inside information say there is. What's more, these insiders say, U.S. military and intelligence agencies are refusing to provide the evidence to Congress.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
No movement for human freedom has ever demanded censorship. Equal rights for religious, racial, and sexual minorities were won with more free speech not less. Those who demand censorship in the name of reducing harm are the persecutors not protectors of the vulnerable.
Andrew Doyle
@andrewdoyle_com
[Part 2 of 2]
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Buy your ticket to join Russell Brand, Matt Taibbi, and me as we take on the Censorship Industrial Complex in London on June 22! Let's go!
www.musicglue.com/good-faith-productions/events/2023-06-2… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
UK government worked with BBC, Google, and Facebook to secretly censor valid criticisms of Covid lockdowns and vaccines for kids.
Blockbuster new reporting by @Telegraph
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/06/02/counter-disinformatio… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Governments worldwide claim that "hate incidents" are rising, but they're not. Tolerance of racial, sexual, and religious minorities has never been higher. Elites are manufacturing a fake "hate" crisis as a pretext for mass spying, blacklists, and censorship.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The idea that governments around the world have for years been secretly censoring ordinary citizens sounds crazy, but it's true. Worse, they are now on the cusp of imposing what can only be described as a totalitarian system to end freedom of speech as we know it.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Victory!
Gov. @GavinNewsom finally calls out the National Guard to shut down the open-air drug dealing in San Francisco!
LFG!
www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/newsom-fentanyl-drug… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Sitting members of Congress are threatening journalist @mtaibbi with prison, but we are fighting back. We are going to dismantle the Censorship Industrial Complex and bury its parts deep underground. We can't do it alone. Please, join our movement and help us fight back. LFG!
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
There is a big debate over who blew up the Nord Stream pipeline. Instead of allowing the debate, Facebook has decided to take a side. It is censoring Pulitzer-winning journalist Seymour Hersh. And instead of explaining, Facebook sends readers to an article in Norwegian. Watch
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The idea that governments worldwide are working together to censor their citizens sounds like a conspiracy theory, but it's not. It's increasingly clear that there is just such an organized effort involving, at a minimum, the US, Canada, UK, & New Zealand.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We are taking all necessary legal and security precautions to protect ourselves, our journalism, and the right to free speech.
But we can’t do this alone. If you aren’t a paying subscriber yet, now would be a great time to become one. 🙏🏻
www.public.news/p/attack-of-the-censorship-karens -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We must understand that media elites are using the words "conspiracy theory," "disinformation," and "misinformation" as ways to control thought and demonize and censor people raising legitimate concerns about the crap policies and programs they want to impose on us.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A growing body of evidence shows U.S. govt officials, agencies, & contractors demanding Facebook & Twitter censor ordinary Americans. Now, an influential censorship advocate has admitted that she worked for the CIA. Who is she? Why is she so influential?
public.substack.com/p/why-renee-diresta-leads-the-censorship -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Well, outstanding essay and outstanding ending. Please read the whole thing. My excerpts above can't do it justice
www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/guide-understand… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“Next time you’re wondering how Salem came to be consumed by hysteria, watch the clips of Posie’s persecution. This is how it happens. This is how fear of witches can overrule reason and unleash the darkest passions of the mob.” @spikedonline
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The Biden administration is demanding that @elonmusk explain why he allowed journalists access to the Twitter Files. This is an outrageous attack on the First Amendment.
www.wsj.com/articles/twitter-investigation-ftc-musk-docum… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
For years, people ridiculed Trump's claim that he was a victim of fake news about alleged collusion with Russia. Now, a major new investigation by a Pulitzer-winning former NY Times reporter, in America's leading journalism magazine, proves that he was.
public.substack.com/p/top-progressive-journalism-magazine -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
“Before the 2016 election, most Americans trusted the traditional media and the trend was positive…Today, the US media has the lowest credibility—26 percent—among forty-six nations”
Russia collusion hoax had a lot to do with it
www.cjr.org/special_report/trumped-up-press-versus-presid… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After the death of George Floyd, Americans pledged to reduce the killings of black people. Instead, the number of black lives lost to homicide and police killings rose sharply. Why is that?
public.substack.com/p/warning-the-anti-police-movement -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Spokespersons for @wef say “The Great Reset,” eating insects instead of meat, and “You’ll own nothing and be happy” are conspiracy theories, but they’re not. In fact, all of them originated @Davos and from WEF’s own website. But now, WEF is deleting them.
public.substack.com/p/davos-is-a-grift-and-a-cult-but-itsPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Part of the reason you can’t trust anything the media say about WEF is because WEF has, literally, bought them off with “partnerships”
WEF is a propaganda platform for global elites and corporate media to “transition” us to a low-energy (poorer) world
www.reuters.com/article/rpb-wef-davos-agenda-connect-idUS… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
1. TWITTER FILES: PART 7
The FBI & the Hunter Biden Laptop
How the FBI & intelligence community discredited factual information about Hunter Biden’s foreign business dealings both after and *before* The New York Post revealed the contents of his laptop on October 14, 2020Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
29. As of 2020, there were so many former FBI employees — "Bu alumni" — working at Twitter that they had created their own private Slack channel and a crib sheet to onboard new FBI arrivals.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
35. In response to Roth, Baker repeatedly insists that the Hunter Biden materials were either faked, hacked, or both, and a violation of Twitter policy. Baker does so over email, and in a Google doc, on October 14 and 15.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
46. The FBI’s influence campaign may have been helped by the fact that it was paying Twitter millions of dollars for its staff time.
“I am happy to report we have collected $3,415,323 since October 2019!” reports an associate of Jim Baker in early 2021. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Last year, Germany paid South Africa $800 million to stop using coal. Since then, German imports of South African coal increased eight-fold. Now, Germany is producing more carbon emissions per unit of electricity than South Africa. This is climate imperialism.
Javier Blas
@JavierBlas
Germany is burning a lot of coal (~45% of all electricity generation) as wind stops blowing.
It’s electricity carbon intensity jumped to a crazy 745 grams (CO2 gr per KWh) this evening — higher than in South Africa and India
Closing nuclear matters | #energiewende h/t @ckazok -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Greta Thunberg used to say her goal was to protect the planet from climate change but she now admits it's to overthrow "the whole capitalist system," which she says is responsible for "imperialism, oppression, genocide.. racist, oppressive extractionism"
unherd.com/thepost/greta-thunberg-throws-her-lot-in-with-… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The media are portraying the suspect in the attack on Nancy Pelosi's husband as a man fundamentally driven by right-wing ideology. But it's obvious to anyone who looks that what drove David DePape to violence was drug-induced paranoid psychosis.
michaelshellenberger.substack.com/p/pelosi-attack-suspect… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Woke activists say they simply care more. But a pioneering psychologist, Sam Vaknin, who studies narcissism says, "The potential for aggression in victimhood movements is much larger than in the general population... Anything that is grievance-based leads to violence and death."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Activists who just threw food on a Monet painting say we won’t be able to feed ourselves in 2050 bc of climate change, but the best-available UN science predicts *higher* yields — unless we stop using fertilizer, which is what the activists are demanding
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
People like the idea of solar farms in the abstract, but hundreds of communities around the world are currently fighting them because they require 300-600x more land than other energy sources, produce 300x more toxic waste, and devastate critical wildlife habitats.
Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
After wind turbines spend decades killing threatened species, their blades are sent to landfills because it's too expensive to recycle them. (That little object in the upper right of the photo is a tractor burying the blades.)
www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2020-02-05/wind-turbine-b… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Over the last week, the mainstream news media claimed that hurricanes are becoming more frequent & intense, but they’re not, as the data clearly show. What’s more, it’s clear that the media are engaging in *deliberate* misinformation. These aren’t innocent mistakes.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The proximate cause of the global energy crisis is Europe's over-dependence on Russian fuels, and yet Western elites are on the verge of repeating that mistake by becoming dependent on China for the extraction and processing of the minerals needed to make solar, wind, & batteries
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
August 24: California bans sale of new gasoline-powered cars
August 30: California asks Californians to avoid charging electric vehicles due to electricity shortages
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Of California's 30,398,249 motor vehicles, just 1.9% (563,070) are electric.
Using the state's own estimates, California will need 17 GW of additional electricity to power all those electric cars
Diablo Canyon nuclear plant, which the state has tried to shut down, is 2.3 GW -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Amazing: Not only may Germany keep operating 3 nuclear plants set to close at the end of this year, it could also *restart* the 3 closed last year within "a few months or weeks," says the head of Germany’s safety regulator.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The German government said it could not keep operating nuclear plants past 2022 because uranium fuel rods were not available, but that turns out to be a lie. This is a bombshell revelation and should raise alarm bells in the West, including in the U.S.
michaelshellenberger.substack.com/p/anti-nuke-greens-mena…
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The fact that Chancellor Olaf Scholz & Economy Minister Robert Habeck have been lying to the world since February about nuclear is a scandal. The German government is putting sectarian Green Party dogma ahead of the interests of the Western alliance. Trust is lost.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
German leaders offer various reasons for why they can't keep operating nuclear plants. None are true. Now, new information has come to light proving that its Economy & Climate Minister Robert Habeck has been lying about nuclear fuel rods since February.
michaelshellenberger.substack.com/p/anti-nuke-greens-mena… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Dear friends and allies,
I am sad to say we did not receive enough votes to make the run-off election in November.
At the same time, I am proud of the movement we built to rescue our shared humanity, and excited about what we will do together next. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Today is Election Day!
Please vote to end the crisis of chaos
Vote to save our humanity
And vote to restore civilization
Let’s go!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
People think it’s compassionate to just give homeless people housing without conditions but, writes @fionadourif, “My mom, too, was delivered food, shelter, and clean needles to inject the heroin that killed her. What harm did that actually reduce?”
www.ocregister.com/2022/06/04/california-has-failed-the-h… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Gavin Newsom claims his Housing First policy is more compassionate than New York's Shelter First policy.
But new data show that 3x more homeless people died in L.A. than NYC, from 2020-2021, despite the fact that NYC has 14k more homeless than L.A.
michaelshellenberger.substack.com/p/three-times-more-home… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
They say it’s just the rent that makes people homeless
They say it’s not about the drugs
They say housing will save them
They’re lying — about all of it.
We have just 12 days to get the truth out
Let’s goThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
LFG!!!
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
California is in a crisis of chaos.
We won't return to normal until rampant homelessness and crime are dealt with, and order is restored.
The politicians, and elite political ruling class, have failed us.
We need an intervention imposed by voters.
I AM THAT INTERVENTION
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
More from Ben
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
People say high rent causes homelessness but Ben, who has been homeless in San Francisco for 7 years, says the “vast majority” are homeless due to addiction. Just 6-7% are from SF. Ben says he "boosts" (shoplifts) and breaks into cars to pay for his $60/day heroin habit.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
What an interesting coincidence that the people who believe Western civilization is uniquely terrible turned out to be uniquely terrible at running Western civilization
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Gavin Newsom's aides yesterday said climate change may soon cause blackouts, but that's ridiculous: we've known about climate change for decades.
The reason for four years of blackouts in a row is because Newsom won't build the power plants we need.
Now, people could die.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
California is in a crisis of chaos.
We won't return to normal until rampant homelessness and crime are dealt with, and order is restored.
The politicians, and elite political ruling class, have failed us.
We need an intervention imposed by voters.
I AM THAT INTERVENTION -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
We are on the brink of global famine due to energy shortages and yet progressive politicians are threatening to tax energy producers and refusing to remove barriers to production
This graph of skyrocketing fertilizer prices is the scariest chart in the world right now -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
People think Europe depends on Russia for energy because it lacks its own, but 15 years ago Europe exported more natural gas than Russia does today. Now, Russia exports 3x more gas than Europe produces. Why? Because climate activists, partly funded by Russia, blocked fracking.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
People who believe that nothing could have been done to prevent Russia from invading Ukraine thus imply that Russia's chokehold over European energy supplies was inevitable, but it wasn't. Europe could have easily increased, rather than closed, nuclear plants and natural gas
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
People say high rent causes homelessness but Ben, who has been homeless in San Francisco for 7 years, says the “vast majority” are homeless due to addiction. Just 6-7% are from SF. Ben says he "boosts" (shoplifts) and breaks into cars to pay for his $60/day heroin habit.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Father of Ahmaud Arbery just now: “ALL lives matter. I don’t want no daddy to watch his kid get shot down like that. It’s ALL our problem. So let’s keep fighting to make this a better place for all human beings. Love everybody! All human beings need to be treated equally.” ❤️👏🏼👑
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
By 2020, the US had reduced its emissions 22% below 2005 levels. The reason nobody talks about this is because it was mostly thanks to replacing coal with fracked nat gas, which emits half the CO2 as coal, and which had nothing to do with UN climate agreements or climate policies
Barack Obama
@BarackObama
We’ve done some important work since the Paris Agreement was signed six year ago, but we’re still nowhere near where we need to be on climate. Watch live from #cop26 in Glasgow as I talk about the steps we can take to combat climate change. x.com/i/broadcasts/1DXxyDBmqzLJM
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Readers may also be interested in my podcast discussion yesterday with Brendan O’Neill on the growing backlash to woke religion, including apocalyptic environmentalism
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-brendan-oneill-show/id1… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Greta Thunberg said “I want you to panic” and nations did. They over-invested in unreliable weather-dependent energy sources & under-invested in reliable energy. Now, global energy shortages are forcing the poor to choose between food & electricity
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The woman who wore the gorilla mask may have done so inadvertently, and not as a way to ridicule Elder’s race. But had Elder been a Democrat it’s likely the assault, which occurred before noon pacific time, would have already been denounced and protested.
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
The chaos, violence, & drug death crisis in California worsen
The open drug scene in San Francisco yesterday was worse than anything I’ve seen in over 25 years here
Violence, chaos, death
There is a solution. Shelter First. Treatment First.
But that requires new leadershipPost not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Former San Diego Mayor @Kevin_Faulconer told me he supports “Shelter First, Treatment First”
Faulconer has the most experience, the most comprehensive plan, and the clearest thinking, which is why I endorsed him, even as I push others, including Newsom, to embrace Cal-Psych -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
People are afraid of nuclear but that’s because they’ve been lied to
Nuclear plants like the spectacular Diablo Canyon of California are the *safest* way to make reliable power
And yet Gov. Gavin Newsom wants to shut down it down & replace it with gas which is far more deadlyThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
An attempt by Gov. @GavinNewsom to demonstrate his commitment to addressing homelessness backfired today after he admitted he doesn't know what to do
"How do we address it — the drugs, the housing, all the rest?" he asked. "It’s a good question.”
😬
www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/Newsom-grabs-a-broom… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I voted & campaigned against the recall of Calif. Gov. Gray Davis in 2003 and, as a rule, oppose the recall of politicians.
But today California finds itself in extreme circumstances.
I am thus voting for the recall of Governor Gavin Newsom.
michaelshellenberger.substack.com/p/why-we-must-recall-ga…Post not available here, view on X
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
But the candidate most qualified to address the chaos is former San Diego Mayor Kevin Faulconer, the only person running who has dealt with the crisis directly as an elected official. After 20 people died from a Hepatitis A outbreak, Faulconer responded to shelter the homeless...
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Five hours ago Joe Biden said climate change will "threaten... literally, the existence of our planet" — if, that is, we don't take global action
That is as false as anything Twitter or Facebook have censored
And nobody in media have fact-checked it
Until now
THREAD -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
As a lifelong environmental activist I am horrified that some young people say they may not have children because of climate change
The truth is that *most* trends relating to climate change & the environment are headed in the right direction!
THREAD
environmentalprogress.org/apocalypse-never-slide-deck -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Britain is set to close 14 of its 15 nuclear reactors by 2030
Now, the UK and @BorisJohnson have major opportunity to lead the West on nuclear energy
Time to go big or go home
My latest with @ChrisBarnardDL
@Telegraph — please share!
www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2020/09/04/must-take-russia-… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
Momentum for nuclear energy is growing rapidly but @Greenpeace is trying to kill it — & time is short!
Please join @ziontree, me, & other environmentalists in one of 30+ cities worldwide to Stand Up for Nuclear in September!
And please retweet this now!
standupfornuclear.org -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
20x times more dead in Italy than in South Korea
9x more *tested* in SK than Italy
Testing was key to prevent spread & treat sick
Sharing data with public was key to winning public trust
Are we so sure it is too late to implement Korean model?
youtu.be/g-r79RXboXc -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
California in 2019:
- dangerous, unprecedented black-outs
- homeless pop. increased 130,000 to 151,000
- homebuilding *declined* 20%
- 200k person exodus = first-ever loss of congressional seat
All the result of your failure to confront reality & show courage for a change.
Gavin Newsom
@GavinNewsom
Happy New Year! What an incredible decade. We’ve accomplished so much in CA by standing up for our values and taking on some of the biggest issues -- from healthcare to gun violence to climate change.
Let’s keep it going.
Here’s to 2020 and the decade ahead!! -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
It’s not that nuclear never kills. It’s that it saves 10,000x more lives than it takes. Nuclear accidents will shorten the lives of ~200 people. Air pollution shortens the lives of 7M/year. By preventing deadly air pollution, nuclear has saved ~2M lives. www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/03/11/it-s…
-
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
A world-renowned UCLA medical doctor who treated Chernobyl victims has denounced HBO's depiction of radiation as contagious and of having supposedly led to the death of a baby
My latest scoop for @Forbes — please share!
www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/06/11/top-… -
Michael Shellenberger
@shellenberger
I used to believe innovation could reduce the massive ecological impacts of solar & wind farms
Then I realized that we can't make the sun/wind more energy-dense, or reliable
Thus, I can no longer support them
My newest essay is 20+ years in the making
quillette.com/2019/02/27/why-renewables-cant-save-the-pla…


















































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































