In a recent post on his Gregorian Rant Substack, Gregory Schlueter @Fatherofseven7, who also writes for Crisis magazine @EricRSammons, announced that there “is a moral duty, etched in the heart of every Catholic” to defend the Holocaust narrative. Schlueter is an expert on this topic because:
“In 1977, at ten years old, I sat riveted before our family’s flickering television in Oshkosh, Wisconsin, as The Holocaust miniseries tore through my innocence. Gaunt faces, stripped of humanity, herded like cattle into brutality, crammed onto trains bound for death camps—the images seared my soul. My world cracked open. Where were the adults in the room of humanity—those with the spine of common-sense rationality and authentic faith to defy evil’s tide? By every credibly documented account, somewhere in the range of six million Jewish lives were extinguished under the gaze of a nation that still thought of itself as Christian.”
Schlueter then attacks “anonymous influencers who promote unverified claims, thriving in shadows where prejudice festers and truth withers.” But he also names two “influencers” who are not anonymous: “Nowhere is this more evident than in the rising tide of antisemitic conspiracies,” promoted by Candace Owens and E. Michael Jones. When Schlueter got push back from someone familiar with my work, he doubled down:
“When pressed to provide scholarly, credible sources, this individual invoked the name of E. Michael Jones. A brief review revealed that, for many holding similar views, Jones is a central figure and often the most prominent source cited. Thus, I address him and his adherents directly—not as a personal attack but as an invitation to all who cite him to elevate their discourse. If his claims hold merit, they must withstand scrutiny. If they crumble under reason, then the denial they support must be firmly rejected.”
After this edifying appeal to the truth, Schlueter deliberately misrepresented what I said, claiming that I engaged in a “justification of Nazi actions”:
“In The Jewish Revolutionary Spirit, Jones argues that Jewish ‘messianism,’ exemplified by Bolshevism, provoked Nazi policies. ‘National Socialism saw itself as the only force capable of stopping Bolshevism, which was, at its core, a Jewish movement.’ This framing shifts moral responsibility for Nazi atrocities onto Jewish communities.”
Nowhere in any book I have written have I engaged in a “justification of Nazi actions.” Even the sentence Schlueter uses to “prove” I did wouldn’t prove that as it aims to explain rather than endorse, but I didn’t write that sentence, as an electronic search of the book confirms. Schlueter gave no citation because there is no citation. Schlueter could have cited what I did say, for example, “On April 20, 1929, Allen Dulles, later head of the CIA, wrote: ‘as a result of the leading role which Bavarian Jews played in communist groups, the tolerance of the prewar era has changed and a new strongly anti-Semitic movement has come into being.’ Von Bieberstein writes: ‘A minority of radical Jews, fighting for the dictatorship of the Proletariat, set loose an avalanche of aggressive anti- Semitism.’” But, as you will read later, I suspect Schlueter has not read any of my books.
Schlueter is in a bind. If he were to cite my work accurately, the reader might be persuaded by the plausibility of my claims and sources. Schlueter maintains that my explaining what happened and why it happened means I am justifying what happened, and asserts that “This framing shifts moral responsibility for Nazi atrocities onto Jewish communities.” No! What a sleight of hand! Whether it’s committed by Jew or Nazi or the United States or any other party, each party bears moral responsibility for an atrocity it commits. And an atrocity by one does not justify an atrocity by another. I have never said or implied otherwise.
After fabricating a quotation and misrepresenting my position in The Jewish Revolutionary Spirit, Schlueter goes on to say that I based The Holocaust Narrative on the writings of Ernst Zuendel and Fred Leuchter. This also is not true. As related in that book, the Holocaust narrative is based on a series of texts which began after World War II as part of Allied propaganda, beginning with Billy Wilder collaborating with C.D. Jackson in creating the propaganda film Death Mills, which displayed a lampshade allegedly made out of Jewish skin, an ashtray allegedly made out of a human pelvis, and two shrunken heads. My book was based on an analysis of texts like Wilder’s Death Mills, not on anything that Zuendel or Leuchter wrote.
In order to make his case against me, Schlueter again puts words in my mouth by fabricating quotes. The phrase “The gas chamber myth fell apart during the Zündel trials in Canada during the 1980s” cannot be found in The Holocaust Narrative or any other book I wrote.
Grok, however, tells me that phrase quoted by Schlueter can be found in “multiple critical analyses and backgrounders from organizations monitoring extremism.” Schlueter, in other words, got the quote from “The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) backgrounder on Jones” which “cites a similar phrasing from his writings leading into or within the book.” Grok finally admits that the only place the phrase “the gas chamber myth fell apart during the Zuendel trials in Canada during the 1980s” is found is in the ADL’s attack on me, suggesting again that Schlueter never read the books he allegedly relies on.
If he had actually read The Holocaust Narrative, Schlueter would know that there are exactly three references to Fred Leuchter and one reference to Ernst Zuendel, both of whom I mention in passing. By invoking them, Schlueter has created a straw man in an attempt to claim that I based my entire book on these writers:
“E. Michael Jones’s Holocaust denial arguments frequently reference the Zündel trials and the Leuchter Report as evidence against the systematic extermination of Jews during World War II. By relying on these sources, Jones ties his credibility to the legacy of a convicted propagandist and a debunked pseudo-scientific report. ... The reliance on Ernst Zündel and the Leuchter Report reveals the intellectual bankruptcy of Holocaust denial. This narrative collapses under scrutiny, as its foundations are built on the work of unqualified individuals, faulty methodologies, and deliberate distortions of historical evidence. By invoking such sources, E. Michael Jones perpetuates a legacy of denialism that is not only factually baseless but also morally reprehensible. ... In the pursuit of truth, claims like those of Zündel, Leuchter, and Jones must be exposed for what they are: a retreat from reason, an assault on truth, and an affront to the memory of millions. Let this stand as a call to reject denial and embrace the light of evidence, reason, and accountability.”
Schlueter then exhorts his readers to rely on sources like Deborah Lipstadt, whom he describes as “a historian specializing in Holocaust studies and Jewish history. She holds the Dorot Chair in Modern Jewish History and Holocaust Studies at Emory University and is renowned for her work confronting Holocaust denial.” Lipstadt, Schlueter tells us, “approaches Holocaust denial with a commitment to evidence-based scholarship, focusing on the tactics and motivations of denialists. Her work is widely respected for its clarity, impartiality, and depth.”
Lipstadt’s “scholarship,” we are told, “has been extensively peer-reviewed and validated through rigorous academic and legal scrutiny.”
Missing from Schlueter’s attack on me is the fact that, unlike his claims about Zündel and Leuchter, I did devote a lot of attention to Deborah Lipstadt in The Holocaust Narrative. She has 12 entries in the index, including one which cites a passage which goes on for ten pages.
If he had read that passage, Schlueter would know that Lipstadt endorsed the notorious Holocaust fraud “Binyamin Wilkomirski,” who claimed to be a Latvian Jew in his book Fragments but was later revealed to be a Swiss Christian by the name of Bruno Doessekker, who made up his story out of whole cloth. Lipstadt continued to promote his book even after it was exposed as a fraud on 60 Minutes. Am I guilty of Holocaust denial because I pointed this out in my book? If so, please explain why. There are 26 references to Bruno Doessekker in The Holocaust Narrative. Why hasn’t Schlueter mentioned them? I suspect that he didn’t mention them because he didn’t know about them and that he didn’t know about them because he did not read my book.
In order to disguise his dishonesty in citing my writings, Schlueter waxes preachy:
“From a Catholic perspective, E. Michael Jones’s views on the Holocaust are theologically and morally indefensible. His justification of Nazi atrocities and engagement in Holocaust denial directly contradict Church teaching, undermine the principle of human dignity, and betray the Catholic commitment to truth, reconciliation, and justice.”
He then goes on to say without citation that Pope Benedict XVI “condemned Holocaust denial as ‘a sin against truth.’” Gosh, that sounds convincing until we realize that Schlueter made that quote up as well.
According to Grok:
“Pope Benedict XVI did not use the exact phrase ‘a sin against truth’ in reference to Holocaust denial based on available records of his statements, speeches, letters, or Vatican documents . . . the Pope made several strong condemnations of Holocaust denial, but none match the specific wording you mentioned.”
Grok, of course is not infallible, so here’s a Google AI cross check:
“The quote is likely attributed to Pope Benedict XVI, who issued a strong condemnation of Holocaust denial in February 2009. While he frequently used strong language, the specific phrasing ‘sin against truth’ appears to be a popular interpretation or common synthesis of his and other Church officials’ statements rather than his exact formal decree.”
After putting words into the mouth of Pope Benedict, Schlueter goes on to say that:
“Jones’s views, by excusing or denying the atrocities of the Holocaust, represent a profound betrayal of these Catholic values. His positions contradict Nostra Aetate and the consistent teachings of recent popes, all of whom have reaffirmed the Church’s mission to uphold truth, justice, and the dignity of all people. Catholics are called to reject these falsehoods and to honor the memory of those who suffered, ensuring that such atrocities are never forgotten. As Pope Francis, Pope Benedict XVI, and Pope St. John Paul II remind us: truth is a cornerstone of moral and spiritual life, and its rejection is a betrayal of our shared humanity.”
This is especially rich. The man who has fabricated one quote after another in his attack on me, then invokes “the Church’s mission to uphold truth.” Schlueter continues: “E. Michael Jones’s arguments fail the test of reason, facts, and theological integrity. Yet this article is not a condemnation of Jones or his followers. It is an invitation—an invitation to humility, to engage in respectful dialogue, and to embrace the truth.”
Well, God bless you, Mr. Schlueter. I am happy to accept your offer to “embrace the truth.” You can begin by publishing this response on your Gregorian Rant Substack. You can then apologize for fabricating quotes to slander me. After that, I suggest you read my books; you might learn something.
gregorianrant.substack.com/p/truth-in-daylight-candace-ow…
gregorianrant.substack.com/p/part-ii-an-invitation-to-hol…