That's exactly it,@ericweinstein. Thanks for reposting it. Perhaps, I was too cryptic in my original tweet. So let me be more clear:
(1) Independent media is an absolutely essential cornerstone of democraric society. None of the major news organizations is flawless. And yes, they have all done gov't bidding in the past that is regrettable (to say the least). One day they will have to reckon with that and say, "mea culpa." But they have also come through on many occasions (see the Pentagon papers, and many other cases). Their independence has given citizens at least some measure of confidence that the gov't does NOT have a free hand to do what it wants. This is invaluable and must be preserved and strengthened.
(2) We are currently witnessing a relentless and systematic assault on all independent entities: news organizations, universities, law firms, courts. (Perhaps, I am more acutely aware of this because I grew up in the Soviet union.) Alas, some of them have folded (Columbia University, CBS, and some law firms), but some of them are fighting back (Harvard, Wall Street Journal, some law firms, courts). Good for them! We must support them.
I see this as a major stress-test of the whole system of checks and balances. And I do see a silver lining in all this: it's good to shake up the system every once in a while and see whether there's some energy and integrity left in it - it's a risky thing, for sure, but perhaps we have gotten to the point at which this is a necessity.
Let us hope that there are still organizations with cojones, resources, and intelligence to withstand this stress-test. If they persevere (as I hope they will), these organizations will emerge stronger than ever before, and we will all be better off for it. As for those that fold, they will be wiped out - and perhaps on would then be justified to say, "good riddance."
(3) CBS execuvies have folded, and in a spectacular fashion. See my original post. Their canceling of @colbertlateshow should not be seen in isolation. It is part of a series of their recent actions: settling what appears to be largely a frivolous lawsuit; dismantling of CBS News and 60 minutes, and now muffling the voice of a comedian who was not afraid to criticize them for that.
They are squandering their reputation built over the years by dedicated journalists, such as Edward Murrow, Walter Cronkite, and Mike Wallace (and their teams). And for what: to get in gov't "good graces" so their merger with Skydance would be be approved, and they get their pay day ("I want my 8 billion dollars now, pease!"). Pathetic.
(4) There's one more thing I want to address: the political bias of late night shows. This has to be admitted and changes have to be made, and more conservative voices and opinions have to be included. But this is no excuse for what's happening.
(5) @StephenAtHome will be fine, and perhaps better of for all this. In my book, he is one of the best of the best. See my original tweet.
This was an important post from a dear friend. It went right by me. I was too caught up to understand what he was saying.
It isn’t about Colbert. It was about CBS from a man who grew up in Russia.
Ed was making the point that CBS was once team America in a *very* complicated way. At times CBS was complicit in American narrative manufacturing and at other times independent enough to act as a check on that very manufacturing of national story telling when it spun out of control.
But nations with interests need stories. And CBS was both part of that storytelling and part of curbing its excesses. The friend who will take you out on a pub crawl for a night on the town when you need it, but who will also demand your keys when you are too drunk to drive home.
And Ed didn’t live that. But he got it nevertheless. Unfortunately it went right by me. The loss of CBS over time.
I was too caught up in the Colbert part to see the point.
Like many of you, I am mourning the cancelation of @colbertlateshow. To me, it's personal: I was a guest on @StephenAtHome's old Colbert Report, and his tenure at @CBS followed that of my beloved David Letterman. This is a BIG DEAL: it shows how decades of trust-building (remember Walter Cronkite?) could be undone with one stroke of a pen... and for what? For 30 pieces of silver (or perhaps 8 billion, they say). Squandering the legacy of one of the most trusted TV networks like this? Makes me wonder what the CBS execs were thinking. What about your integrity? You really think this stain can ever be shampooed off? I don't thnk so.
As for Stephen, I bet he'll be fine; unchained from his ignorant "masters," he will now enter a new, and even more glorious, phase of his illustrous career, continuing to dazzle us with his iniminatble humor and just sheer humanity and goodness. American Icon, who refused to bend the knee.
What a great teachable moment, and a cautionary tale, for all of us.
(find the link to the @nytimes Op-Ed below)