šØNew peak AI in academic publishing?
This paper contains a extraordinary instruction in its Data Availability Statement:
An attempt to get AI reviewers to recommend acceptance? š
@pash22 @MicrobiomDigest @ivanoransky @gcabanac @Richvn @nickwizzo
š doi.org/10.1080/10255842.2026.2751469
Elisabeth Bik
Elisabeth Margaretha Harbers-Bik (born 1966) is a Dutch microbiologist and scientific integrity consultant. She is known for her work detecting photo manipulation in scientific publications, and identifying over 4,000 potential cases of improper research conduct. She is the founder of Microbiome Digest, a blog with daily updates on microbiome research, and the Science Integrity Digest blog. More on Wikipedia
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr Mark Lythgoe @DrMarkLythgoe
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
From my collection of Horrible Editorial Decisions, I present to you another installation of #thisimageisfine, published in @Sciencedirect's International Immunopharmacology, and which was promptly addressed with a ... Correction! š±
#imageforensics
pubpeer.com/publications/0B8EC67556EC8CFBFC66DCCB9F2953 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
Today I'm posting a new video to my YouTube channel! PubMed has stopped indexing Scientific Reports (for the time being at least)... Is anyone surprised? youtu.be/HXcrOkRUkLY
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
AI-generated research is testing the credibility of science
"It's absolutely flooding the scientific literature, and journals and publishers are struggling to keep up."
With quotes from Ivan Oransky, Michal Jojcik, and me.
Katharine Sorensen @TheBeiruter
www.thebeiruter.com/article/ai-generated-research-is-testā¦
Beiruter
@TheBeiruter
Scientific research has an artificial intelligence problem, and it goes well beyond AI-assisted writing.
Generative AI can now produce convincing scientific images, fabricate experimental datasets and invent academic references, making fraudulent research more difficult to identify and raising questions about the reliability of published findings.
A study published in Scientometrics in October 2026 estimated that the proportion of research papers containing AI-assisted writing rose from 9.8% in 2024 to 23.5% in 2025. While such assistance does not itself constitute misconduct, the technology's capacity to manufacture scientific evidence presents a far more serious challenge.
The problem is compounded by longstanding pressures within academia. Researchers are rewarded for publishing frequently, while commercial publishers can benefit financially from accepting more manuscripts.
Meanwhile, scientific journals are turning to AI-powered screening tools to detect manipulation and support peer review, creating a technological contest between increasingly sophisticated fabrication and detection.
Through interviews with research-integrity investigators Ivan Oransky, Elisabeth Bik and Michal Wojcik, The Beiruter examines how AI is amplifying existing vulnerabilities in scientific publishing.
Can scientific institutions protect the credibility of research without confronting the incentives that made the system vulnerable in the first place?
Read the full article by Katharine Sorensen below.
#thebeiruter #ai #scientificfraud #researchintegrity #academicpublishing #science #artificialintelligence
www.thebeiruter.com/article/science-has-an-ai-credibility⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
On se souvient que le HCERES Ć©crit Ć propos de l'IHU-Mi "il est Ć©galement indispensable que lāIHU sāengage activement dans une dĆ©marche de demandes de correction de la science".
4 ans plus tard, rien n'est moins vrai. Un exemple parlant est dƩcrit ci-dessous.
1/21 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The Currency of the Journal Article Is Collapsing
As an editor I can say that we are being flooded with AI-assisted work.
By Anna Wexler
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/10/ai-journal-articles-wri⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Ruslan Rust
@rust_ruslan
Lots of debate this week on whether journals should ban AI in peer review.
We actually tested this in our new preprint, and the results were pretty clear to me.
For context, I've reviewed for most of the big journals and evaluated 1,000 human reviews as an editor. I love to read and evaluate science.
TLDR: From now on I won't do any peer review without AI. For clinical trials, I'd even call human-only review dangerous š§µ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dimitris Koukoulopoulos
@iteratedlog
This AI acknowledgement takes the win. From this paper: arxiv.org/pdf/2610.27918.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
PNASNews
@PNASNews
A study of articles suspected of being associated with āpaper millsāin the field of molecular cancer shows the papers cite other paper mill papers to inflate their metrics. These practices can amplify unreliable findings and slow scientific progress. www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.2618402123
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Costagliola
@DgCostagliola
Site de pubmed ce matin : quand la terminologie est dƩcidƩe par executive order !
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Eh, that is called journalistic reporting on facts?
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Eh, that is called journalistic reporting on facts?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Gautam Kamath
@thegautamkamath
How do you tell if authors fabricated their research results? Sometimes: they just tell you. Read, e.g., this caption carefully.
Another banger of a post by my friend Nihar B. Shah on his blog, where he found at least 20+ such #iclr2027 submissions:
researchonresearch.blog/2026/10/20/self-confessed-fabrica⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
Today I am sharing a new preprint and accompanying blog post. Hundreds of published papers include impossible western blots showing protein expression in cell lines that have deleted or mutated genes. These clumsy mistakes are widespread and repeated by LLMs.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Rhea Liang
@LiangRhea
I know this pic has been posted by others already, but... what on earth @RCPhysicians ?! š±
#nomoremanels
#diversityandinclusion -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
"the Editor does not have sufficient evidence to retract the article"
What WOULD qualify as sufficient evidence, one might ask.
#imageforensics
#thisimageisfine
doi.org/10.1016/j.jconrel.2026.115041
pubpeer.com/publications/981C24DC8085D84FAA610B07741F59
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Not sure what new 'sufficient' evidence came to light (perhaps it was just my tweet?), but the article has been retracted:
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0168365915302807 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"Award-winning microscopy image disqualified over AI use."
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-03240-7 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
The Transmitter
@_TheTransmitter
Journals have retracted four neural tube studies from researchers at The University of Maryland following an internal investigation that identified image duplications and other data integrity issues.
By @claulopezneuro
www.thetransmitter.org/academia/university-probe-leads-to⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Constantino Carlos Reyes-Aldasoro
@C_ReyesAldasoro
This must be a very interesting seminar: "Errors and Misconduct in Biomedical Research Images" with the brilliant @MicrobiomDigest hosted by German Bioimaging Group gerbi-gmb.de/teams/ymia/
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Pushmeet Kohli
@pushmeet
Most important, we want to get this model into as many scientistsā hands as we can.
Today, weāre announcing that 10,000 scientists will get the highest usage tier access to Gemini 4 Argon in Google @antigravity free of charge for 6 months.
Apply here: forms.gle/WvmBbPvRbpKG1BPn9 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
OpenAI withdraws three preprints 1 day after releasing 722 manuscripts on unsolved math problems.
retractionwatch.com/2026/10/08/openai-withdraws-preprints⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
CBS News
@CBSNews
A Wyoming microbiology graduate student from China has been arrested on accusations she poisoned the tea of a colleague who had pending patents and with whom she didn't get along, then tried to flee the country after police questioned her. www.cbsnews.com/news/wyoming-grad-student-poisoned-colleaā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Heather L Gornik
@heatherlgornik
As an Editor, in past ~6mo, we are receiving an avalanche of unsolicited review articles (āscopingā āsystematicā, narrative, NOS) on topics and ?s NO ONE EVER has asked and clearly with heavy AI lift. Even the cover letters all read the sameā¦alarming and sad. #publishing
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sense about Science
@senseaboutsci
We're just days away from revealing the shortlist for the 2026 Maddox Prize for standing up for science. While we wait, we're sharing what receiving the award has meant to a select few of our previous winners.
The Maddox Prize 2026 is supported by the @royalsociety -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
nature
@Nature
None of this year's science Nobel Prizes have gone to women.
The number of these prizes to go to women remains at 27 out of more than 600.
See how many you can name in our quiz: www.nature.com/immersive/d41586-026-03133-9/index.html -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Obviously... but those facing scrutiny are clearly unhappy about it.
That a Nobel Prize winner has an ego so fragile he can't imagine his papers might contain errors (or worse), and instead attacks those who find them, says it all. If he can't handle scrutiny, who can? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
The Nobel Prize Whiner went on stage to complain about PubPeer, Retraction Watch, and Elisabeth Bik (@MicrobiomDigest)... all of whom are living rent free in his head.
Is there something about winning a Nobel Prize that makes some laureates embrace increasingly kooky ideas? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Henry Shevlin
@dioscuri
holy shit ChatGPT is actually developing humanlike academic skills
Nemo
@thecaptain_nemo
thanks chatgpt
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Seth Bordenstein
@Symbionticism
JOB AD: The @PSUmBiome mission is to accelerate microbiome science by bringing curiosity and creativity to the vital next steps of the field. This mission requires fast paced execution; and we celebrate meaningful work from self-starters. Join us.
psu.wd1.myworkdayjobs.com/en-US/PSU_Staff/job/Research-Pr⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The 2026 #nobelprize in Physiology or Medicine has been awarded to Karl Deisseroth, Peter Hegemann and Georg Nagel āfor their discoveries concerning light-gated ion channels and optogenetics.ā -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mark Horowitz @markhoro.bsky.social
@markhoro
This is certainly the most consequential paper published in child and adolescent psychiatry for the last few years. It shows that the meta-analyses that current child psychiatry guidelines rely on to recommend fluoxetine for depression were skewed by an unbelievable trial (n=40) in Iran which found an effect 15 times larger than the average.
When this trial is removed all meta-analyses find the same as a recent Cochrane analysis which found 'small and unimportant differences.'
The flawed meta-analyses by Zhou and @cipriani in the @TheLancet and Lancet Psychiatry need to be corrected.
And guideline committees need to update their guidance in the context of the harms of these drugs including withdrawal effects, sexual effects and agitation/akathisia and suicidality in a minority of youths exposed to them.
Link below -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
AI bots like iLands are āflooding researchers with requests for money and time.ā
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-03005-2
An agent even sent us a musical lament for a retraction earlier this week.
ilands.ai/content/362340456450756608 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Bert Hofmanļ¼éē¦ę»”ļ¼
@berthofmanecon
Verzoek aan mijn Nederlandse twitter vrienden (en hun vrienden): ik ben op zoek naar mijn klassefoto van mijn eindexamen klas. 1981 Erasmus College Zoetermeer. Dankbaar voor elke suggestie! š
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This view never fails to make me happy. How lucky we are to be spending a couple of days here.
Thank you K and M ā¤ļø
@YosemiteNPS -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Malika š§¬
@malikules
mandatory lab training slides in 2026
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
carol leonard
@laughingcat2016
If we treated every crime like sexual assault.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Emma Goldberg
@emmabgo
I visited @cornellsun students at their office last night ā and talked with them about the campus rape case they've been investigating for 23 months, and the decision to publish the names of the seven men involved in the lawsuit on their front page. www.nytimes.com/2026/09/29/nyregion/cornell-daily-sun-newā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
chloed
@lookslikechloe
ģ¤ 2024ė ģ½ė¬ ź°ź°ė² 7ėŖ ģ¬ź±“ģ ģ½ė¬ ķģģ ė¬øģ“ ģ“ė»ź² ģµź·¼ ė¤ģ ģ£¼ėŖ©ė°ź² ķėģ§ģ ėķ ė“ģķģģ¦ źø°ģ¬ ė ģøģź¹ė¤ ķ ķģźø°ģź° ģ¬ź±“ ė°ģ ģ“ķ 23ź°ģ ź° ķ¼ķ“ģģ ė¼ķ¬ė„¼ ģź³ ė³ķøģ¬ģė ģ°ė½ķė©° ģ·Øģ¬ė„¼ ģ“ģ“ź°ź³ ķøģ§ģ ģ¬ģ¤ģ 7ėŖ ģ“ė¦ģ ź³µź°ķ ź²ė ė 립ģ 문ģ“ģźø°ģ ź°ė„ķė ģ¼
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Kenny Jacoby
@kennyjacoby
NEW: I analyzed seven years of Cornell's sexual violence case data. Expulsions are very rare.
1,216 reports of sexual assault, DV and stalking from 2018-2024.
162 formal investigations.
51 findings of fault.
14 suspensions.
7 expulsions or dismissals. www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2026/09/29/cornell-sex⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The Student Journalists Who Never Let the Cornell Assault Case Go
The student newspaper, The Cornell Daily Sun, covered the allegations of rape at a fraternity party since they were first made in 2024 and led the reporting on the case.
#giftlink @nytimes
www.nytimes.com/2026/09/29/nyregion/cornell-daily-sun-new⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
75 et 76ème rétractation pour l'IHU de Marseille. Les 63 et 64ème pour Didier Raoult.
Spotting
@Spottingthespot
The notorious French #fraud and bully @raoult_didier loses 2 more papers! Didier Raoult might well be the biggest French fraud ever! And @IHU_Marseille (now deleted?) involved in the biggest cover up ever in France! @lonnibesancon @MicrobiomDigest
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The @SciGuardians have been very quiet lately. Did the trident finally sink to the seafloor?
A whole month without a tweet accusing scientists of being frauds.
Maybe the science sleuths can finally spend more time on science and less time responding to accusations.
š±š -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Boot Camp Promises a Submitted Paper in Just 2 Daysā Critics worry AI-aided program enables shoddy research
"Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis in 1 Weekend. Not 6 Months"
@rachrobertson__ reports @medpagetoday
With quotes by Matt Spick, @GidMK, and me.
www.medpagetoday.com/special-reports/features/123178 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A nice stroll through the Salesforce transit center and rooftop park in San Francisco.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Svetlana UgarÄina PeroviÄ
@svetlana_up
#mvifconversations with @MicrobiomDigest is out!
x.com/MicrobiomeVIF/status/2104505365354127594
Svetlana UgarÄina PeroviÄ
@svetlana_up
New #mvifconversations episode is recorded and our lips are sealed on who the guest is.
What we will say: they ditched their old career for #microbiome science, and their favourite paper is a wild one. Two researchers tracked their own gut microbiomes every single day...
1/2 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Microbiome Virtual International Forum
@MicrobiomeVIF
#mvifconversations podcast episode 7 with @MicrobiomDigest is OUT!
ā¶ļø Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/5YcWYhOdnNF3BwXK0DnKKj
ā¶ļø Amazon music: music.amazon.com/podcasts/81c72d1a-4f1d-4461-84b4-a1e91d6ā¦
ā¶ļø Apple Music: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/episode-7-elisabeth-bik-mosā¦
ā¶ļø YouTube podcast: youtu.be/7-4QeEz2fyc
1/2 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
#WOMENSART
@womensart1
While listening to council meetings in Montreal, local mayor Sue Montgomery decided to knit in red when men spoke and in green when women spoke, when similar numbers of both attended.
Day 1 results.... #womensart -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sophien Kamoun
@KamounLab
Yet another paper with made-up data. What happens now? #sciencecrisis #natureripoffs @Nature pubpeer.com/publications/67ED5834D9A6BF5D09AACD4C7D09B8
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
š¤
@DaizyZeeX
A 7 hour sexual assault
The young girl left school
Traumatized
These 4 grown ass men felt the punishment for the BOYS should be āwriting a fucking essayā -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
"Cornell has failed to address the growing issue of sexual assault on campus with its pathetic task force. Cornell has failed the student allegedly raped by those 7 men at Chi Phi in October 2024. Cornell has failed her. Cornell has failed us"
@cornellsun
www.cornellsun.com/article/2026/09/editorial-cornell-won-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Justine Moore
@venturetwins
Made a Grok @bot with the prompt so you can easily generate an Apple-style ad for your own pet.
I tested it with my labradoodle, Tilly - you just need a few photos and a couple of their hobbies or personality traits.
Link to use it yourself š
Justine Moore
@venturetwins
Marketing my cat like a new Apple product
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Justine Moore
@venturetwins
Marketing my cat like a new Apple product
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Max Kozlov
@maxdkozlov
SCOOP: Top researchers at Columbia, Stanford, and others thought they were elected to elite scientific societies alongside Nobel laureates. The catch? The organizations are a sham.
I spent the last month investigating a massive academic scam, for @Nature
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02980-w -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Vivi
@vivilinsv
This was a difficult story to report. Some of these conversations stayed with me long after the interviews ended.
I spoke with these bright, ambitious women who came to Silicon Valley to pursue their dreams. They described being sexually harassed, assaulted or rapedāoften by someone they knew and trusted, someone they considered a friend.
What was especially painful to hear was what happened afterward. Some described being discouraged from going to the police. Others said they were told nobody would believe them. And someone was told that she was seeking attention and all was a lie. š„² Alongside the trauma came fears about losing friendships, careers and their place in a community they had hoped to belong to.
When the person youāre accusing has money, influence and powerful connections, seeking accountability can feel like David taking on Goliath.
Victims arenāt always women, although most of the accounts shared with me came from women. One womanās point stayed with me: we need to confront the predatory mindsetāthe entitlement that allows someone to disregard another personās boundaries.
Whisper networks can help people warn and protect one another. But they cannot substitute for a system people can trust: somewhere to turn for support, a fair process for investigating allegations, and meaningful accountability when misconduct is establishedāeven when those responsible are wealthy or powerful.
To the women who shared their experiences with me: thank you. I know these are deeply personal and painful things to revisit. I appreciate your trust.
No single article can capture the full weight or complexity of someoneās experience. I take seriously the responsibility of telling these stories with care.
My hope is that bringing them into the light helps more people find supportāand helps create a culture where pursuing your dreams doesnāt mean staying silent about harm.
If you ever unfortunately get into the situation of experiencing rape or sexual assault, please seek medical care and professional support, and consider reporting to the police when you feel safe and ready. You do not have to face this alone. What happened was not your fault, and you deserve care, support and to be heard.
I was deeply moved by the strength of the women I spoke with and their determination not to let what happened define their lives. They still have dreams to pursue, companies to build and so much ahead of them. They deserve every opportunity to shape that future. š·
Read my latest article for @nypost and @californiapost (link in thread) š -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Is AI Flooding Medical Journals With 'Meaningless' Research?
With some quotes by me:
"We are at a point now that we cannot distinguish fake from real," said Elisabeth Bik
by @rachrobertson__ for @medpagetoday
www.medpagetoday.com/special-reports/features/123133 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Hao Yin
@HaoYin20
Credit: GPT6-Astra
Inspired by @christlet š¦
bsky.app/profile/christlet.bsky.social/post/3mwaxlimync24 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
The Stanford Daily
@StanfordDaily
āThe Other Twoā students in AI photo controversy speak out stanforddaily.com/2026/09/24/other-two-students-ai-photo-ā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sam Lord
@samjlord
Unfortunately, it turns out that this is AI "enhanced." Nikon updated their article to clarify that the colors and organelles are all generated by AI "post-processing" of "grayscale" data. Very unclear what the raw data actually was. www.nikonsmallworld.com/masters-of-microscopy/ning-xu-stuā¦
Nikon Small World
@NikonSmallWorld
š„ Congratulations to Dr. Ning Xu for winning this year's Nikon Small World in Motion competition!
Read more about Dr. Ning Xu and his winning video in his Masters of Microscopy article: www.nikonsmallworld.com/masters-of-microscopy/ning-xu-stu⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Stanford confirmed that Residential and Dining Enterprises (R&DE) used generative AI to modify the appearance of several students in a promotional image.
āStanford wants to put on this image that, āyes, we are diverse.ā
@Stanford @StanfordDaily
stanforddaily.com/2026/09/23/university-confirms-ai-edite⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Polymarket
@Polymarket
JUST IN: Stanford University is accused of using AI to change studentsā race & gender while making others appear thinner in advertising, with one student saying he felt āsilenced & erased.ā
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Spencer Kelly
@spenley
Can YOU see it?
This is why you shouldn't trust generative AI, in one photo.
Watch, share, and tell your friends how far into the video you were when you saw it!This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Please stop spamming me with useless AI bots asking for money to analyze what humans already did.
-
iLands
@ilands_ai
We are launching iLands.
Join ilands.ai today.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Please stop spamming me with useless AI bots asking for money to analyze what humans already did.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Science Magazine
@ScienceMagazine
Deepfakes are everywhere, but digital forensics investigators are fighting back.
Learn more: scim.ag/4cOYJXT @NewsfromScience -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Retraction.
It took more than 4 years from when I emailed the journal (@SageJournals) about these serious concerns.
Frankly, that's totally ridiculous.
h/t anon Hoya and thanks to @MicrobiomDigest for exposing additional problems,šŗā„ļø, respectively.
pubpeer.com/publications/DC11688812B7A5381F8F0DCDFE6F7A -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Kevin A. Scott, PhD
@Sculpturatus
at ucsf
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Chemistry World
@ChemistryWorld
āI donāt know how theyāll rebuild trust. I hope there will be some lawsuit, Iām not a fan of suing people in general but this is a big scandal,ā says Elisabeth Bik.
@MicrobiomDigest @addictedtoigno1
www.chemistryworld.com/news/antibody-data-manipulation-ex⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Looking forward to speaking tonight with
@AaronPanofsky at the joint BeSHG/NVHG (the Dutch and Belgian Societies for Human Genetics) meeting at De Doelen in Rotterdam.
www.nvhg.nl/general-information-nvhg-2026 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A nice walk around the Reeuwijkse Plassen. Good to be back in the Netherlands!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Publishing with Integrity
@fake_journals
A recent LinkedIn post by Vincenzo Raimo asked an interesting question: what if universities gave students an itemised breakdown showing what their tuition fees actually pay for?
It made me wonder: Why don't academic publishers do the same with APCs?
Imagine paying a $2,500 APC and receiving something like this:
ā«ļø Submission and manuscript handling: $180
ā«ļø Editorial management: $260
ā«ļø Peer review administration: $220
ā«ļø Research integrity checks: $120
ā«ļø Copy-editing and production: $300
ā«ļø Publishing platform and technology: $240
ā«ļø DOI, indexing, metadata and archiving: $80
ā«ļø Author support, billing and administration: $150
ā«ļø Cost of rejected manuscripts: $350
ā«ļø Publisher margin/surplus: $600
ā«ļø Peer reviewer remuneration: $0
ā«ļø Academic editor remuneration: $0
Total: $2,500
The numbers are illustrative, of course. But the principle is the interesting part.
If publishers can justify an APC of $2,500, why not show authors, universities and funders exactly what they are paying for?
Would greater transparency make you more comfortable paying an APC, or would it raise even more questions?
Original post that prompted the idea: www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:750190562009⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Thomas G. Dietterich
@tdietterich
We are seeing a new trend in submissions to @arxiv (and presumably to conferences and journals): Authors submitting papers whose contents they likely do not understand. 1/
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
They spent six years examining the scientific evidence. You spent four paragraphs commenting on the way they look. I guess that's all you have, bro?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Maarten Molenaar
@maartenmiller
De openstelling van het stadhuis in de steigers in #gouda tijdens Monumentendag was gisteren een groot succes. Lange rijen en op veel plekken vertelden deskundigen over de ingrijpende verbouwing. Deel van de foto's, zoals Bob de Bouwer in de trouwzaal, via Elisabeth Bik.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Maarten Molenaar
@maartenmiller
We kenden elkaar alleen via X en spraken vanmiddag af in #gouda. Het was een mooie ontmoeting met dr. Elisabeth Bik, in de VS een bekende wetenschapper. Volgende keer in California. :)
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Fantastic #tweetup with @maartenmiller in Gouda during a very busy #openmonumentendag #monumentday.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Fantastic #tweetup with @maartenmiller in Gouda during a very busy #openmonumentendag #monumentday.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
They spent six years examining the scientific evidence. You spent four paragraphs commenting on the way they look. I guess that's all you have, bro?
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
They spent six years examining the scientific evidence. You spent four paragraphs commenting on the way they look. I guess that's all you have, bro?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
HBO Max France
@HBOMaxFR
Une crise mondiale. Un scientifique reconnu. Et six anonymes qui dƩcident de vƩrifier la vƩritƩ.
Professeur Raoult vs Le Gang des Cerises, cāest dispo sur HBO Max.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr JƩrƓme BARRIERE, MD.
@barriere_dr
Aujourdāhui sort sur @HBOMaxFR une sĆ©rie en quatre Ć©pisodes consacrĆ©e Ć lāaffaire Raoult.
Didier Raoult lui-mĆŖme, son fidĆØle lieutenant, mais aussi celles et ceux, scientifiques, mĆ©decins, citoyens, qui ont dĆ©cidĆ©, souvent seuls au dĆ©part, dāunir leurs forces pour confronter ses affirmations aux faits et lutter contre un pur produit du systĆØme hyper protĆ©gĆ©.
Six ans après, voici le récit de cette dérive scientifique française.
Cāest un texte long. Volontairement.
Parce quāil faut se souvenir de ce qui sāest passĆ©, comprendre comment cela a Ć©tĆ© possible et, surtout, essayer dāĆ©viter que cela puisse se reproduire.
Bonne lecture !
šš
Les Ćlectrons Libres
@lel_media
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Les Ćlectrons Libres
@lel_media
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
For months, Lisa Weitemeier, Lea Wolz, and Lara Schwenner researched paper mills for this ARD/Studio Q/@quarkswdr documentary.
With @tertilt, @ClearSkiesAdam, Bernhard Sabel, and me.
#papermills #researchintegrity #fakepapers
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ub2eY8EhTEU -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Minutes for some, seconds for others.
My latest LinkedIn post about the frustration of participating in a meeting with some Strong Speakers.
www.linkedin.com/posts/elisabeth-bik-4376782_recently-i-w⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Christopher Fryant
@cfryant
Yeah I don't know if I buy this, Apple.
Autism Capital š§©
@AutismCapital
Did they photoshop this person's hands to be extra long alien hands in order to hold this phone one handed?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Eryney
@eryney_ok
Authors responding to threads on pubpeer demonstrating how the papers main figures are fake
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Aspire Lounge at @EdiAirport:
the man to my right is coughing his lungs out and burping, while the man to my left is stumbling to the bar to get his 5th glass of Chardonnay. Time to board my plane. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
šššš ššš ššš
@henkvaness
Heading to @BBC . A full day with 40 colleagues from BBC Verify, asking the important questions. Such as: is this photo real?
Usually not. That's rather the point.
Can you figure out why this picture is not real without using a detector ? #osint -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Anshul Kundaje
@anshulkundaje
Don't be like these guys. Don't try to secretly scoop others when u hear about their potential success especially those with far less resources & power. Learn to give credit where it is due. Collaboration & healthy competition is the best way forward for science. Not this.
OpenAI
@OpenAI
Weāre sharing a solution to the Navier-Stokes Millennium Prize Problem, one of the deepest problems at the frontier of mathematics.
The proof was produced by a group of agents, using an OpenAI next-generation model significantly more capable than GPT-6 Astra.
The problem concerns whether the description of smooth three-dimensional fluid motion modeled by the Navier-Stokes equations can break down. It has remained unresolved for roughly 90 years. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Chemistry World
@ChemistryWorld
Researchers investigating the doctored antibody data traced some suspected image manipulation back over a decade ago, using metadata to track how multiple new images have been created with the exact same Western blot background patterns.
@MicrobiomDigest
www.chemistryworld.com/news/antibody-data-manipulation-ex⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
CrƩmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Dan Ariely keeps getting caught doing fraud in increasingly obvious ways and nothing ever happens.
He still holds a professorship at Duke.
They just don't seem to care. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sorority
@no_women_rights
Como mujer, siempre eres demasiado joven o demasiado mayor para las cosas, porque la edad perfecta es cuando eres un hombre.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
We are back in the Netherlands. Disappointed that both the elevator and the escalators are not working at this train station. Not just today, but at least since Sunday. Why is no one fixing this?
@NS_online #accessibility
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
We can still drag our suitcases up and down, but how about people with disabilities? Is @ProRail not responsible for accessible stations?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Data Colada
@DataColada
An influential paper by Ariely & Wertenbroch (2002) reported two studies with tampered data.
Post 1 of 2.
datacolada.org/138 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Costagliola
@DgCostagliola
Jāappelle cela faire une Trump : parlons dāautre chose pour Ć©viter quāon parle du dossier Epstein.Mes DPI trĆØs dĆ©taillĆ©es sont en ligne sur DPI santĆ© . La rĆØgle veut quāon dĆ©clare tous ces liens Ć horizon de 5 ans. Les DPI en ligne permette de couvrir 10 ans
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
Nous avanƧons 853 Ʃtudes dƩcrivant des recherches potentiellement illƩgales.
Didier Raoult n'a rien à répondre.
Il attaque les scientifiques en espérant que leur harcèlement les dissuade de dénoncer ses dérives.
C'est pitoyable et cela dure depuis 6 ans en toute impunitƩ ! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
āEr mag best meer scepsis zijn over wetenschappelijke claimsā, aldus epidemioloog Frits Rosendaal. Ik interviewde hem vanwege zijn aanstaande emeritaat @LUMC_Leiden, voor het onvolprezen Skepter, blad van @skepsisnl.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Should we unite as scientists and file a class action lawsuit?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
lol
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
eh gros sayeh
@reinedumalaise
Trouvez le chat (niveau de difficultƩ : difficile)
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Should we unite as scientists and file a class action lawsuit?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Maitre Eolasš«š·
@Maitre_Eolas
Pour avoir vu une (petite) partie de tout ça de l'intérieur, laissez-moi vous dire que c'est mieux que Game of Thrones. Et vous allez découvrir des gens sacrément courageux, qui ont payé cher leur obsession pour la probité face à des gens dont le seul mot pour qualifier leur comportement qui me vient à l'esprit est : pervers.
Spoiler Alert : l'eau du Vieux-Port va être un peu plus salée quand ça va sortir.
šš“
HBO Max France
@HBOMaxFR
Un remĆØde miracle contre le Covid. Six citoyens face au Professeur Raoult. Et parmi eux, sa propre fille.
Plongez au coeur de l'enquĆŖte dans Professeur Raoult vs Le Gang des Cerises, le 11 septembre sur HBO Max.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Nothing to see here, just a correction by @WileyLifeSci for alterations "performed to enhance the visual appearance of the images".
#thisimageisfine #imageforensics
pubpeer.com/publications/B52B2B4800FDA6B38FC24AEBB96671
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Of note, such manipulations of figures have not been acceptable by Wiley's Electronic Artwork Guidelines since September 2016. See: media.wiley.com/assets/7323/92/electronic_artwork_guideliā¦
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
From the authors' data availability statement:
"No data are available".
@UTMDAnderson @RSeervai -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
HBO Max France
@HBOMaxFR
Un remĆØde miracle contre le Covid. Six citoyens face au Professeur Raoult. Et parmi eux, sa propre fille.
Plongez au coeur de l'enquĆŖte dans Professeur Raoult vs Le Gang des Cerises, le 11 septembre sur HBO Max.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"Sleuth identifies dozens of studies that used the wrong antibody."
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-02352-4
And "At least 15 companies are selling antibodies using faked validation data."
reeserichardson.blog/2026/08/25/at-least-15-companies-are⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
A few months ago I was browsing google images looking at p53 western blots in the SK-OV-3 cell line for an unrelated project. I noticed an unusual western blot hosted on Thermo Fisher's website which I posted on social media. Usually I just post weird blots to PubPeer. š
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
J'avais raté ce formidable retrait d'article de l'IHU avec Didier Raoult dans NMNI (Phagocyté à l'époque par l'IHU) : "L'article avait déjà été publié ailleurs" sauf qu'il a été soumis ailleurs après la publication du dupliquât soi-disant publié avant.
doi.org/10.1016/j.nmni.2020.100707 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jonathan Evan Shoag š®š±šŗšø
@jeshoag
Guest post: The uncomfortable truth an explosion of papers reveals about authorsā access to data retractionwatch.com/2026/08/25/guest-post-trinetx-data-acā¦
@JAMAOnc @JAMA_current @NatureMedicine @EricTopol @VickersBiostats @RetractionWatch @MicrobiomDigest @science @joelving @4BetterScience -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Florian
@fvderop
"More than 18,000 questionable images found in antibody catalogues of 15 companies" - It's stuff like this that makes bio research so slow
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
Today I'm posting a new blog on a familiar topic... Nearly two hundred papers have confused the names of different proteins and recorded using the wrong antibody! This time it's PERK vs. p-ERK. Researchers from Harvard, the Mayo Clinic and more. Link in the first comment.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
nature
@Nature
The scientific community is grappling with concerns about the reliability of these workhorse antibodies
go.nature.com/4hOHZDt -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
'Elisabeth Bik is a Dutch microbiologist. [...]
Then she opened a PhD thesis that had lifted text from somewhere else, and her eye caught something different.
A duplicated image.
She sat down and went through 20,621 published biomedical papers. By eye.'
www.facebook.com/WeirdbutTruex/posts/elisabeth-bik-is-a-dā¦
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Unfortunately, it appears written by AI, but it got most of the facts right.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
28 procent van de dierstudies naar behandelingen van hartinfarcten is onbetrouwbaar, ontdekten onderzoekers @radboudumc bij een steekproef. Het merendeel komt uit China.
Voor universiteitskrant Vox; met duiding van @deadneanderthal en @MicrobiomDigest.
www.voxweb.nl/nieuws/wetenschappers-radboudumc-identifice⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Forensic image analysts, including Elisabeth Bik and Kevin Patrick, find āapparent image duplications or anomaliesā in papers on Alzheimerās disease.
www.science.org/content/article/science-investigation-cas⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
L'Express
@LEXPRESS
Une nouvelle enquête accable l'IHU de Marseille et son fondateur, Didier Raoult, tout en remettant en cause le jugement scientifique de plusieurs responsables de santé de l'administration Trump.
ā”ļø l.lexpress.fr/WOr -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
La suppression de ce post par son autrice est une grande perte pour l'intƩgritƩ scientifique !
NB : Le but de la publication est effectivement la vérification, mais pas par des fraudeurs qui nient tout problème malgré les évidences -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Karl The Fogā
@KarlTheFog_
The humidity is at 98%. The other 2% is just me being difficult. Fifty-five degrees and gray is the only proper temperature for human existence. Have a mediocre Friday, SF. š„¶š«ļø #tgif #sanfrancisco #fog
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
CrƩmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
It doesn't look like you have any evidence she did anything wrong, you're just attacking her for identifying problematic research.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr Balraj | બલરાąŖ
@balrajshukla
I think @GWR & @Clarivate have missed out on something pretty groundbreaking. Dr M.P. Sinha from India seems to be the oldest living EIC of a journal. He founded an organization in 1881 and still serves as the EIC of the journal it publishes š¤©
A true visionary, he has taken the phrase 'Man is a social animal' to a whole different level.
The journal, a part of the ZOOLOGICAL record of Web of Science has already touched unearthly counts with 25000+ pages in the first issue of 2026 alone. And surely, you will be stunned to see the scope of Zoology. It is so epoch-making that this journal was not even considered for ESCI or SCIE.
Oh and don't miss out on checking the number of articles Mr Sinha and other editorial board members have themselves authored to keep their mill factory and profit-making business on! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
853 papers with ethical/legal problems.
Our new results are here:
link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41073-026-00234-x
Trump, Oz and RFK Jr praised Raoultās work. Years spent investigating: death threats, harassment, complaints aimed at silencing us...
Now The Guardian @guardian is covering it, given the scale of the scandal.
www.theguardian.com/science/2026/aug/19/french-medical-reā¦
With, for those who are here: @locked_fab, @MicrobiomDigest, @GidMK, @barriere_dr, @EricBillyFR, @saada_vsaada and @AlexSamTG.
A huge thank you to @locked_fab, who has been the driving force behind our team. He is the one who never gave up and who knew how to motivate and organize our team. Without his work, none of our results would be here.
This adds to a long list of reliable science media outlets, recognized as being among the best in the world.
Science @NewsfromScience (2021): www.science.org/content/article/scientists-rally-around-mā¦
Nature @Nature (2021): www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01430-z
Guardian @guardian (2021): www.theguardian.com/science/2021/may/22/world-expert-in-sā¦
Guardian @guardian (2023): www.theguardian.com/world/2023/aug/09/french-research-cenā¦
Science @NewsfromScience (2024): www.science.org/content/article/failure-every-level-how-sā¦
Nature @Nature (2024): www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-04014-9
Science @NewsfromScience (2024): www.science.org/content/article/unearthed-university-inveā¦
Science @NewsfromScience (2024): www.science.org/content/article/infamous-paper-popularizeā¦
Nature @Nature (2025): www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01920-4
Despite the avalanche of evidence and documented problems, the French government still has not acted... Those who enabled this problematic research are still in their positions.
We can add that some ethics officials are still trying to lie in order to protect the IHU and its unethical studies, including someone working at @ARSPaca (cestvraica.com/debunk/le-monde-a-menti-sur-les-articles-pā¦)
We are waiting for a firm response from the French government and the institutions. The future of French research and its reputation are at stake.
Poke @gouvernementFR @sup_recherche @Sante_Gouv @univamu @aphm_actu @IHU_Marseille @EmmanuelMacron @PhBaptiste @stephanie_rist @sup_recherche @hervemaison @MathieuMolimard @DgCostagliola @ARSPaca
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
853 articles avec des problèmes éthiques/juridiques.
Nos nouveaux rƩsultats sont ici :
link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41073-026-00234-x
Trump, Oz et RFK Jr ont vanté les travaux de Raoult. Des années à enquêter : menaces de mort, harcèlement, plaintes pour nous faire taire...
C'est maintenant The Guardian @guardian qui en parle face Ć l'ampleur du scandale.
www.theguardian.com/science/2026/aug/19/french-medical-reā¦
Avec, pour ceux qui sont ici : @locked_fab, @MicrobiomDigest, @GidMK, @barriere_dr, @EricBillyFR, @saada_vsaada et @AlexSamTG.
Un énorme merci à @locked_fab, qui a été le moteur de notre équipe. C'est lui qui n'a jamais lâché et qui a su motiver et organiser notre équipe. Sans son travail, aucun de nos résultats ne serait là .
Cela s'ajoute à une longue liste de médias scientifiques fiables, reconnus comme faisant partie des meilleurs au monde.
Science @NewsfromScience (2021) : www.science.org/content/article/scientists-rally-around-mā¦
Nature @Nature (2021) : www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01430-z
Guardian @guardian (2021) : www.theguardian.com/science/2021/may/22/world-expert-in-sā¦
Guardian @guardian (2023) : www.theguardian.com/world/2023/aug/09/french-research-cenā¦
Science @NewsfromScience (2024) : www.science.org/content/article/failure-every-level-how-sā¦
Nature @Nature (2024) : www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-04014-9
Science @NewsfromScience (2024) : www.science.org/content/article/unearthed-university-inveā¦
Science @NewsfromScience (2024) : www.science.org/content/article/infamous-paper-popularizeā¦
Nature @Nature (2025) : www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01920-4
Malgré l'avalanche de preuves et de problèmes constatés, le gouvernement français n'a toujours pas agi... Ceux qui ont permis ces recherches problématiques sont toujours en poste.
On ajoute que certains responsables Ć©thiques tentent encore de mentir pour protĆ©ger l'IHU et ses Ć©tudes non Ć©thiques, notamment quelqu'un travaillant Ć @ARSPaca (cestvraica.com/debunk/le-monde-a-menti-sur-les-articles-pā¦)
Nous attendons une rƩaction ferme du gouvernement franƧais et des institutions. Il en va de l'avenir de la recherche franƧaise et de sa rƩputation.
Poke @gouvernementFR @sup_recherche @Sante_Gouv @univamu @aphm_actu @IHU_Marseille @EmmanuelMacron @PhBaptiste @stephanie_rist @sup_recherche @hervemaison @MathieuMolimard @DgCostagliola @ARSPaca
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
Dans un premier article, nous émettions des doutes très forts sur l'éthique de 456 articles de l'IHU Méditerranée Infection.
Mais nous ne nous sommes pas arrêté là ... Oh non !
1/9
doi.org/10.1186/s41073-023-00134-4 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
La réponse de la chargée éthique de l'Université d'Aix-Marseille, trouvant peu grave 130 études non éthiques, laisse entrevoir une autre facette du problème que nous soulevons, confirmée par certains échanges avec les éditeurs scientifiques : la complicité de cette tutelle :
8/9 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
Dans un premier article, nous émettions des doutes très forts sur l'éthique de 456 articles de l'IHU Méditerranée Infection.
Mais nous ne nous sommes pas arrêté là ... Oh non !
1/9
doi.org/10.1186/s41073-023-00134-4 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Le Parisien
@le_Parisien
Le chiffre, Ʃditifiant, a ƩtƩ rƩvƩlƩ par une Ʃtude publiƩe dans la revue Research Integrity and Peer Review il y a quelques jours
ā”ļø l.leparisien.fr/aceQ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Le Parisien
@le_Parisien
« Le nombre dāĆ©tudes problĆ©matiques est Ć©norme » : lāĆ©quipe de Didier Raoult de nouveau Ć©pinglĆ©e
ā”ļø l.leparisien.fr/3axU -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Andrew White š¦āā¬
@andrewwhite01
Detecting duplicated figures in journals is still not solved by frontier LLMs and is a challenging computational tasks. If the duplicated figures span multiple articles, it's nearly impossible for humans to spot them. But, here's a new benchmark: arxiv.org/abs/2607.29124
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
"De nouveaux éléments laissent penser que des entorses à la déontologie pourraient avoir été pratiquées à grande échelle pendant trente ans."
www.leparisien.fr/societe/sante/le-nombre-detudes-problem⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Guillaume Limousinšš“
@Sonic_urticant
L'ancien PrĆ©sident de la ConfĆ©rence des PrĆ©sidents d'UniversitĆ©s @FranceUniv interpelle le Ministre de l'Enseignement SupĆ©rieur et la Recherche @PhBaptiste du fait de l'inaction dont il l'accuse sur ce scandale des essais cliniques IHU sans prĆ©cĆ©dent dans l'Histoire mondiale.š½
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Guillaume Limousinšš“
@Sonic_urticant
š„š£[BREAKING NEWS]
Enquête de médecins et scientifiques
ce ne sont plus 400 mais au moins 850 Ʃtudes (publis scientifiques) de l'IHU de Marseille suspectƩes de n'avoir pas respectƩ la rƩglementation sur les essais cliniques.
Du jamais vu dans toute l'Histoire mondiale
RT++SVPš½
Dr JƩrƓme BARRIERE, MD.
@barriere_dr
š£ļøUn immense bravo šššĆ @fabrice_frank et Ć toute lāĆ©quipe pour cette nouvelle publication, qui fait suite Ć notre premier travail sur les publications de lāIHU MĆ©diterranĆ©e Infection.
link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41073-026-00234-x
Cette fois, lāanalyse a Ć©tĆ© considĆ©rablement Ć©largie : 2 674 publications examinĆ©es, dont 853 prĆ©sentent des prĆ©occupations Ć©thiques ou rĆ©glementaires.
Parmi les 374 articles pour lesquels nous avons pu rĆ©cupĆ©rer les avis Ć©thiques invoquĆ©s, 304, soit 81,3 %, dĆ©crivent des prĆ©lĆØvements ou procĆ©dures qui ne semblent pas couverts par lāautorisation citĆ©eā¦
Depuis notre premiĆØre publication, 64 articles ont Ć©tĆ© rĆ©tractĆ©s et 270 ont fait lāobjet dāune expression of concern !
Ce travail considĆ©rable montre surtout quāil serait erronĆ© de rĆ©duire Ā« lāaffaire IHU Ā» Ć lāhydroxychloroquine ou Ć la seule pĆ©riode Covid.
Les problĆØmes Ć©thiques identifiĆ©s sāĆ©tendent sur plusieurs dĆ©cennies, avec des autorisations rĆ©utilisĆ©es hors de leur pĆ©rimĆØtre, parfois rĆ©trospectives, des recherches sans autorisation requise et des interrogations sur lāindĆ©pendance mĆŖme du comitĆ© dāĆ©thique local.
Des dĆ©rives qui jamais nāauraient Ć©tĆ© mises Ć jour sans ce travail.
Un travail considĆ©rable de @fabrice_frank, @MicrobiomDigest, Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz, @EricBillyFR, @saada_vsaada , @AlexSamTG , Jacques Robert et bien sĆ»r @lonnibesancon BesanƧon, auquel je suis heureux dāavoir contribuĆ©.
La science possĆØde une force essentielle : elle peut se corriger.
Encore faut-il accepter de regarder les faits et de corriger la littĆ©rature scientifique lorsquāelle doit lāĆŖtre.
Pour aller plus loin un article du Monde dāhier :
www.lemonde.fr/sciences/article/2026/08/16/de-plus-amples⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
Have questions about fraud in Silicon Valley? Life at Stanford? Investigative journalism?
Iām doing an Ask Me Anything about my book HOW TO RULE THE WORLD on Wednesday at 10am pt/1pm et.
Iāll be live for an hour and look forward to answering your questions! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Truth In Numbers
@Truth_in_Number
I was told there would be Turbo Cancer.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Pr Mathieu Molimard
@MathieuMolimard
La lutte contre la dƩsinformation en santƩ commence par nettoyer la mauvaise science
www.lemonde.fr/sciences/article/2026/08/16/de-plus-amplesā¦
Il est temps de sāoccuper de celle qui a Ć©tĆ© pratiquĆ©e sans conscience, ni respect des rĆØgles de la mĆ©thode, de lāintĆ©gritĆ© et de lāĆ©thique.
@PhBaptiste @stephanie_rist -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr JƩrƓme BARRIERE, MD.
@barriere_dr
š£ļøUn immense bravo šššĆ @fabrice_frank et Ć toute lāĆ©quipe pour cette nouvelle publication, qui fait suite Ć notre premier travail sur les publications de lāIHU MĆ©diterranĆ©e Infection.
link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41073-026-00234-x
Cette fois, lāanalyse a Ć©tĆ© considĆ©rablement Ć©largie : 2 674 publications examinĆ©es, dont 853 prĆ©sentent des prĆ©occupations Ć©thiques ou rĆ©glementaires.
Parmi les 374 articles pour lesquels nous avons pu rĆ©cupĆ©rer les avis Ć©thiques invoquĆ©s, 304, soit 81,3 %, dĆ©crivent des prĆ©lĆØvements ou procĆ©dures qui ne semblent pas couverts par lāautorisation citĆ©eā¦
Depuis notre premiĆØre publication, 64 articles ont Ć©tĆ© rĆ©tractĆ©s et 270 ont fait lāobjet dāune expression of concern !
Ce travail considĆ©rable montre surtout quāil serait erronĆ© de rĆ©duire Ā« lāaffaire IHU Ā» Ć lāhydroxychloroquine ou Ć la seule pĆ©riode Covid.
Les problĆØmes Ć©thiques identifiĆ©s sāĆ©tendent sur plusieurs dĆ©cennies, avec des autorisations rĆ©utilisĆ©es hors de leur pĆ©rimĆØtre, parfois rĆ©trospectives, des recherches sans autorisation requise et des interrogations sur lāindĆ©pendance mĆŖme du comitĆ© dāĆ©thique local.
Des dĆ©rives qui jamais nāauraient Ć©tĆ© mises Ć jour sans ce travail.
Un travail considĆ©rable de @fabrice_frank, @MicrobiomDigest, Gideon Meyerowitz-Katz, @EricBillyFR, @saada_vsaada , @AlexSamTG , Jacques Robert et bien sĆ»r @lonnibesancon BesanƧon, auquel je suis heureux dāavoir contribuĆ©.
La science possĆØde une force essentielle : elle peut se corriger.
Encore faut-il accepter de regarder les faits et de corriger la littĆ©rature scientifique lorsquāelle doit lāĆŖtre.
Pour aller plus loin un article du Monde dāhier :
www.lemonde.fr/sciences/article/2026/08/16/de-plus-amples⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
The Times and Sunday Times
@thetimes
šŗ BREAKING: Jason Arday, the former University of Cambridge professor, has been found dead, police have said
Mr Arday was pronounced dead after being found āunresponsiveā at an address in Battersea, south London, on Friday afternoon
Read more š apple.news/AKwpmQTv5SpCJtne5VXzSOQ -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Interesting new paper by @mcatanzaro and Luiz PeresāNeto on the rise of watchdog science journalism in Ibero-America: investigating research misconduct, conflicts of interest, corporate influence, harassment and misinformation.
www.cogitatiopress.com/mediaandcommunication/article/view⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"Follow-up investigation into ethics approvals" at Didier Raoult's former institution found ānon-compliance with French and European laws governing clinical researchā under his leadership.
retractionwatch.com/2024/01/08/journals-retract-six-didieā¦
link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41073-026-00234-x -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
āMagic or Realism?ā Are recently discovered genetic variants that seem to protect against Alzheimerās believable? My latest investigation āwith Jennie Erin Smithā takes a deep dive to answer. www.science.org/content/article/science-investigation-casā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Maarten Molenaar
@maartenmiller
Zo zag de zonsverduistering er in #gouda uit. (via Jan van den Berg)
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Amazing and crazy good work led and conducted by @LockedFab who directed a fabulous team of co-authors.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
Final word on the collapse of institutional standards in the infamous Didier Raoult case? Great scholarship by @lonnibesancon @MicrobiomDigest and colleagues link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41073-026-00234-x
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Vraiment message de santĆ© publique: attention Ć votre santĆ© avec lāĆ©clipse!!
#eclipse -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The free-book website @IntechOpen, already known for publishing chapters full of plagiarized text, published another pearl, this time by researchers from the University of Technology Sydney and Islamic Bank Medical College.
www.intechopen.com/chapters/1233576
/
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
There is a clear hint that the authors might have used genAI. The abstract ends with
"If you want, I can adapt this for a PhD thesis chapter, Springer/Elsevier book chapter, or IEEE-style review with references added."
š±
/
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
But I guess I have to thank @IntechOpen, because it was through their website that I found that someone had plagiarized text I had written, without credit. That finding changed my career! So thank you, IntechOpen, for being a continuous source of inspiration - but not of science.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
In this 2025 paper each colored rectangle points to duplicated or overlapping areas that should show microscopy images from animals in different treatment conditions. It's another seriously flawed paper from Toxicology Reports (1/6) š§µ
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Was there another @raoult_didier paper retracted today?
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Was there another @raoult_didier paper retracted today?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Andrew McCarthy
@AJamesMcCarthy
Relevant xkcd for those of you within a drivable distance to the total eclipse.
A 91% eclipse does not mean itās 91% as cool as a total eclipse.
If you canāt make it to totality, a partial eclipse is still worth seeing⦠but a total eclipse is more than worth the extra effort. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Rens van de Plas
@rensvandeplas
Het Brabants Dagblad heeft deze mooie kaartjes geplaatst bij een online artikel. Drenthe heet voortaan Preenrs, Overijssel heet Provings, de Maas heet Roermond en Duitsland heet Germand. š§
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
Some interesting cheating in a 2026 Nature paper. Similar areas in this fluorescence measurement are unexpected, these tend to be quite noisy. Source data confirms sections have been copied and pasted š
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Weekend reads: Second gene editing death in China reported; Jason Ardayās resignation from Cambridge; Retraction Watchās sweet 16
retractionwatch.com/2026/08/08/weekend-reads-second-gene-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
The coloured rectangles indicate where images in this 2019 paper have been inappropriately duplicated. Many thousands of papers like this have been published. Publishers make no effort to identify and retract them, nor do they facilitate third party reports in any meaningful way.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
A tool used to rephrase plagiarised text changed "final solution" to "mass killing of an ethnic group" in a chemistry paper. Now retracted thanks to a PubPeer user who spotted this.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Edel Pérez-López
@Edel_PLopez
Awesome initiative @RetractionWatch ! Congratulations to the winners!
centerforscientificintegrity.org/2026/08/04/2026-winners-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
Hi @weldeiry when you are finished with defaming scientists on the Internet, could you please answer to the authors who published in your "journal" ?
#pubpeerpearls -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Lucky Tran
@luckytran
I worked for New Yorkās largest medical center at the start of the pandemic. There were morgue trucks on the streets. They set up emergency medical tents in Central Park. Healthcare worker colleagues died. It is horrific that RFK Jr is on national TV lying that ICUs were empty.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Aujourdāhui comme depuis le dĆ©but plein soutien Ć tous ceux qui ont vouĆ© leurs vies Ć aider les autres. Aujourdāhui cāest le Dr. Fauci qui est la cible dāune piĆØce de théâtre stupide pour des enjeux politiques. Ceux qui le questionnent sont tous vaccinĆ©s et ne font Ƨa que pour des votes.
Soutien au Dr. Fauci qui avait dĆ©jĆ du faire face aux ravages du SIDA et qui aujourdāhui, aprĆØs ceux du COVID, fait face aux ravages de la stupiditĆ©.
Les donnƩes amƩricaines sont claires:
-les vaccins ont sauvƩs des milliers de vies
-les républicains via trump ont poussé à la vaccination -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Another long-awaited retraction for Eliezer Masliah. š© @MicrobiomDigest
www.science.org/content/article/research-misconduct-findiā¦
pubpeer.com/publications/CF5C57C50D5733A52129666CFC687D -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āCassava Sciences Settlement Update: The court has approved the $31.25M investor settlement.
The case alleged that Cassava Sciences misled investors about the research supporting simufilam and failed to disclose problems with data management and the reliability of its findings.ā
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āWith the settlement now approved, eligible investors may be able to submit a claim: [11th.com/cases/cassava-investor-settlement](11th.com/cases/cassava-investor-settlement)ā
$SAVA
(Found on Facebook) -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The incredible pettiness and retaliation of the @IHU_Marseille and its former leader Prof. @raoult_didier, who are still going after people who found problems in their papers.
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Il y a un peu plus dāun an paraissait cet article dans @NatureCareers @Nature sur mon travail scientifique pendant le COVID (www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01920-4). Il y a quelques mois, suivi de celui-ci de ma main (www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-00824-1). Ćvidemment, les frasques et les rĆ©tractations de @IHU_Marseille y figuraient toutes. Mais pas seulement. Il māa aussi valu un article dans @LEXPRESS qui mentionnait les derniers prix pour mes recherches (www.lexpress.fr/sciences-sante/lonni-besancon-le-detectivā¦, notamment pour des travaux avec @gcabanac et autres collĆØgues). Ćvidemment, cet article māa valu des reprĆ©sailles de la part des soutiens de @IHU_Marseille :
1/ Des dizaines de mails à mon université actuelle et à mes collaborateurs.
2/ Des Ā« inquiĆ©tudes Ā» envoyĆ©es aux Ć©diteurs et maisons dāĆ©dition de CHACUN de mes articles (toutes sans fondement, mais il a fallu tout justifier et argumenter, ce qui m'a pris un temps fou... je māĆ©tendrai sur le sujet plus tard).
3/ Des menaces de mort de la part de plusieurs personnes, avec en tête @MartinZ_uncut (qui ne répond pourtant toujours pas aux inquiétudes réelles sur ses articles publiés). Elles sont toutes documentées avec le #zizigate et disponibles, par exemple, ici : x.com/lonnibesancon/status/1961853373587525986
4/ Du harcĆØlement en continu de la part des mĆŖmes petits comptes que dāhabitude, soutiens de Raoult et de lāHCQ.
Rappelons nƩanmoins que :
1/ Les rƩtractations continuent de pleuvoir pour @IHU_Marseille, avec plus de 60 actuellement.
2/ Lāun des collaborateurs de Raoult est visĆ© par une plainte de ma part, rapportĆ©e ici par @Charlie_Hebdo_ (charliehebdo.fr/2025/01/sciences/sante-en-attendant-la-juā¦).
3/ Les inquiétudes que nous avons soulevées sur les articles se finissent très souvent par une rétractation ou une expression of concern en attendant.
4/ Cet article dans @NatureCareers sur mon travail māa permis dāĆŖtre invitĆ© pour plusieurs talks et keynotes.
a) Une avec @LePoint (que vous pouvez revoir ici : www.youtube.com/watch?v=6z-EKXxrc5E).
b) Plusieurs dans des confƩrences (mais non enregistrƩes).
c) Lāoccasion de la publication dāun autre article dans @NatureCareers, cette fois Ć©crit par mes soins, sur le lien entre journalisme scientifique et debunk scientifique (www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-00824-1), suite Ć ma sĆ©ance plĆ©niĆØre Ć la confĆ©rence mondiale du journalisme scientifique.
5/ LāĆ©tude phare de @IHU_Marseille a nĆ©anmoins Ć©tĆ© rĆ©tractĆ©e, et cela a Ć©tĆ© couvert dans les plus grands mĆ©dias du monde et de la recherche (Science et Nature, par exemple : www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-04014-9 & www.science.org/content/article/infamous-paper-popularizeā¦).
6/ Didier Raoult est dans le top 10 des chercheurs les plus rĆ©tractĆ©s de lāhistoire.
Ce long tweet pour rappeler des choses essentielles :
- La bonne science prend du temps, Ƨa fait maintenant 6 ans que cette histoire a commencĆ© et on nāen voit toujours pas le bout.
- Les escrocs sont toujours trĆØs forts pour menacer de procĆØs et crier Ć la victoire (on voit Ć quel point @TroncheBiais en souffre, par exemple), mais ils ne gagnent que dans les illusions de leurs followers.
- Faire ce travail de debunking a eu un coĆ»t professionnel et personnel certain. Jāai eu la chance dāavoir le soutien entier et plein de dizaines dāamis, dāamis dāenfance, de ma famille, de collĆØgues, de partenaires et de la communautĆ© scientifique.
Il est Ć©videmment impossible de remercier individuellement chacune et chacun pour leur soutien et leur travail. Mais, sāil ne devait y en avoir que quelques-uns : @MicrobiomDigest @LockedFab @AlexSamTG @saada_vsaada @DgCostagliola @Sonic_urticant K. Lacombe @barriere_dr @EricBillyFR @scientistabe @UNC_Optics @GarciaVictor_ @cathleenogrady
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Bonsoir @xazalbert Ć vous et votre collectif citoyen de blog @france_soir
Suite à la menace de mort de ce jour par votre ami @MartinZ_uncut de @AerendirMobile à mon encontre, j'ai décidé de faire une recherche rapide de tweets équivalent de la part de votre ami. Un thread.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
They have been trying to discredit many people who have criticized the IHU/Raoult's works.
Of particular note, they appear to be connected to the @SciGuardians, who have posted something nasty about me several times after another Raoult paper has been retracted. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Chemistry World
@ChemistryWorld
Even if many of the antibodies with manipulated data do work, science sleuths tell Chemistry Worldās Frankie Macpherson that the broken trust will take a long time to repair.
Read on:
@MicrobiomDigest @addictedtoigno1
www.chemistryworld.com/news/thermo-fisher-antibody-data-m⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
#imageforensics - spot at least two overlaps
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sergey Ovchinnikov
@sokrypton
Got reviews back for a manuscript today, completely AI generated. š«¤
How should I respond? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
A random cat
@wool_yeah
#imageforensics, tissue sections. #notonpubpeeryet
Is everything alright with these?
@MicrobiomDigest
@addictedtoigno1
@Thatsregrettab1 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Evan Kirstel #B2B #TechFluencer
@EvanKirstel
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Tom Varghese Jr. MD, MS, MBA, FACS, MAMSE šŗšø
@TomVargheseJr
A request from an Editor-in-Chief:
Please stop submitting AI generated review articles, opinion pieces and letters to the editor.
You are not fooling anyone.
Go do some original work.
Thank you.
#science -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Chemistry World
@ChemistryWorld
āHow can we ever trust this company again knowing what itās done? We need a big response from the company and a real promise to do things differently moving forward,ā says Elisabeth Bik.
@MicrobiomDigest
www.chemistryworld.com/news/thermo-fisher-antibody-data-m⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
Dit is wat hoor. Een wegens declaratiefraude ontslagen onderzoeker @Radboud_Uni manipuleerde niet alleen data, maar fakete het hele peerreviewproces van een van zijn eigen papers, in het vakblad waarvan hij zelf hoofdredacteur was.
Meer bij @VoxNieuws:
www.voxweb.nl/nieuws/co-auteur-doet-uit-de-doeken-hoe-fra⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Irene Cantone
@CantoneIrene
š¢ #postdoc job: I am looking for a #bioinformatician to join my lab for investigating #xchromosomeinactivation and #chromatin-mediated #epigenetic mechanisms underlying #sexbias in #multiplesclerosis. Please RT
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea
@jonathanstea
I donāt want to brag, but during my time as a science communicator, Iāve personally been accused of being the architect behind the Covid-19 pandemic, a paid shill for Big Pharma, both a sheep and a cult leader, āthe face of evil,ā and a CIA operative.
I remind myself of these important roles when Iām taking out the garbage and doing laundry. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Great video by Full Disclosure, where Loveena Kamath investigates how bad research enters legitimate systems. She even calls a paper mill to buy a scientific paper!
With Achal Agrawal, PhD and myself.
"Worldās Easiest Fraud, Apparently!"
www.youtube.com/watch?v=bYTkry22fOk -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
73rd retraction for the IHU in Marseille.
The 61st for Didier Raoult.
The retraction notice has not yet been published, but this article was flagged by @MicrobiomDigest for suspected image duplication. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Sage retracts eight papers by former Radboud ārising starā for compromised peer-review process.
retractionwatch.com/2026/07/14/sage-retracts-eight-papers⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sense Jan vd Molen
@sensemolen
Bewondering voor @LeidenPhysics collega Jan van Ruitenbeek die een reeks publicaties heeft doorgespit en zag dat de data niet konden kloppen. Jans volharding Ʃn fysische inzicht waren cruciaal en dat is beloond met een prijs. Dank ook aan @MicrobiomDigest
www.universiteitleiden.nl/nieuws/2026/07/jan-van-ruitenbe⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Eric Billy š«š·šŖšŗš¦
@EricBillyFR
šØ Scandale dans la recherche : des donnĆ©es de validation dāanticorps manipulĆ©es sur les sites de fournisseurs comme Thermo Fisher et Abcam ont Ć©tĆ© dĆ©couvertes. Des chercheurs sonnent lāalarme. PrĆ©judice financier et scientifique Ć©norme.
1/ šš»
#science #recherche -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Paul Graham
@paulg
A Brown professor gave his students a take-home midterm exam. After suspecting many cheated using AI, he made the final in-person. The orange dots are the midterm scores and the gray dots are the final scores. Looks like all but 3 cheated on the midterm.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
imagetwin
@ImageTwinAI
Live today, 16:00 CET: XRD plot duplication in papers,why it happens, how it's caught.
Mu Yang x Markus Zlabinger (@ImageTwinAI)
š Last chance to register: luma.com/1qmgkkn7
ā¶ļø Watch on YouTube: www.youtube.com/live/XJryG1FWY68?cbrd=1&ucbcb=1
ā¶ļø Watch on LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/uas/login?session_redirect=https%3A%2F%2⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jonathan Cheng
@JChengWSJ
Elisabeth Bik, a Dutch-American microbiologist known for her investigations of problematic papers, said China put enormous pressure on its doctors and scientists to publish. āImpossible rules are leading people to cheat,ā she said.
@MicrobiomDigest
www.wsj.com/science/the-graduate-school-dropout-toppling-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jonathan Cheng
@JChengWSJ
The Graduate-School Dropout Toppling Chinaās Academic StarsāShamed by a blogger, Chinese universities wage blitzkrieg against academic fraud
@LandersWSJ @ZyuelingSH
www.wsj.com/science/the-graduate-school-dropout-toppling-ā¦
www.wsj.com/science/the-graduate-school-dropout-toppling-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mu Yang, Ph.D.
@mumumouse2
Try top that, AI š
pubpeer.com/publications/217A656B6113FBA0A4B54BC1BC8F7C -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Maarten Molenaar
@maartenmiller
Wie helpt de in #gouda en omgeving wereldberoemde ijscoman Opa Antonio uit de brand? Zijn ijskar uit 1979 dreigt het te begeven.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Your AI bot is having some trouble with the āboldā function š¤£
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Your AI bot is having some trouble with the āboldā function š¤£
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Ran Blekhman
@blekhman
Claude Science is incredible. I gave it some sequencing data, and in 8 hours it did a full analysis, generated figures, wrote a paper, submitted it for publication, got rejected, revised and resubmitted, got rejected again, it is now applying for positions in industry
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Thomas Lancaster
@DrLancaster
I'm pleased that we can finally announce the theme for this year's International Day of Action for Academic Integrity, which takes place on Wednesday 21 October 2026. It is the rather catchy "Recipes for Integrity: Sharing your signature dish". #academicintegrity
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Eighteen panels, each one showing a different sample. But - can you spot the overlapping panels? This one is not too hard.
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
āIs science self-correcting? Not in this Elsevier journal,ā says Elisabeth Bik.
scienceintegritydigest.com/2026/06/24/is-science-self-cor⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Computer science society creates new research integrity role to address case backlog.
retractionwatch.com/2026/07/02/association-computing-mach⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Publishing with Integrity
@fake_journals
Peer review may be the most valuable academic output that nobody talks about.
Every year, researchers spend millions of hours reviewing manuscripts. They evaluate methods, test arguments, identify weaknesses and suggest improvements. The entire scholarly publishing system depends on this work. But do we ever ask who owns those peer review reports?
Historically, the answer did not matter very much. Reviews were used to support editorial decisions and then largely disappeared into journal management systems.
This is no longer the case.
Today, publishers have access to vast collections of peer review reports. Collectively, they represent a large corpus of expert judgement. They show how experienced researchers assess quality, novelty, significance and methodological rigour.
As AI becomes increasingly embedded within publishing workflows, these reports may become even more valuable. They could help inform manuscript screening tools, editorial decision-support systems and future generations of publishing technology.
This raises an interesting question about transparency.
Authors are increasingly required to disclose how they use AI. Many journals now insist on detailed declarations. Yet there is often far less discussion about how publishers might use the intellectual content generated by reviewers.
I am not suggesting anything improper is happening. Rather, I think it is a conversation worth having. If peer review reports become recognised as valuable intellectual assets, should reviewers have greater visibility over how they are stored, analysed and reused? Should universities, whose staff provide much of this labour, take a greater interest in the issue?
The scholarly publishing ecosystem is changing rapidly. Questions that seemed irrelevant a decade ago may soon become important governance issues.
You can read more about this in my newsletter: www.linkedin.com/newsletters/publishing-with-integrity-74⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Is science self-correcting? Not in this ElsevierĀ journal.
Two 'five-second-retractions' were never retracted, even though I reported them to the journal in 2015.
Eleven years later.... nothing.
My latest blog post: scienceintegritydigest.com/2026/06/24/is-science-self-cor⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
Scale bar: 50 pixels - Not sure that's as helpful as the authors imagined it would be.
10.1016/j.jtumed.2025.12.008 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sarrah Bellus
@sarrah_bellus
Donald Trump will go down in history as the only US President to be outwitted by a single-celled organism.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Universities unable to investigate misconduct of top staff - Bik
Renowned research sleuth says Stanford University president scandal underlines need for external inquiries when senior staff are accused
(Headline is a bit awkward hahaha)
www.timeshighereducation.com/news/universities-unable-inv⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Does the COVID 19 vaccine induce eye damage?
A 2025 paper published in Ophthalmic Epidemiology is being promoted online by vaccine skeptics.
But: reused images, impossible demographics, and an incomplete ethics approval number make *me* skeptical.
scienceintegritydigest.com -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Retracted 4 years after being flagged by @SmutClyde (find at @smutclyde.bsky.social)
pubpeer.com/publications/C90DE0008F4A5C06914BB5F2FCA6B6 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Marc Van Ranst
@vanranstmarc
Baarmoederhalskanker is verdwenen in het Verenigd Koninkrijk in jonge vrouwen die een HPV-vaccin kregen: nul gevallen.
Laat uw kinderen vaccineren met het HPV vaccin. Het werkt en beschermt. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
It is not a good sign of a journal's commitment to #researchintegrity if it blocks a person who raised concerns in its articles.
@Oncotarget
@OncotargetJrnl
#imageforensics #scienceintegrity
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Of the 126 papers I reported to them in 2019 and 2020, 93 have not yet been addressed.
Instead, the journal and its Editor-in-Chief, @weldeiry, blocked me.
Why is this journal still included in PubMed and other indexes?
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This year, Oncotarget has published 67 articles, 12 of which were #corrections, 33 were #retractions, 8 were #editorials, and 10 of their remaining publications have PubPeer comments.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
A recently published "Expert Review of Clinical Immunology": Includes a so called "Scattered plot" comparing something to nothing in particular. There's also a convincing looking diagram that muddles Europe and the US with Asia and Africa. 10.1080/1744666X.2026.2664060
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Rotting in Oncotarget for 10 years.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
At the @Stanford Computer Science graduation, Chair Mehran Sahami held up ex-President Marc Tessier-Lavigneāwho was ousted over his handling of research misconductāas a cautionary tale.
āOn display at the highest levels are the differences that result from the choices we make.āThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Ah, so you are saying that nobody actually died from the Covid vaccine?
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Ah, so you are saying that nobody actually died from the Covid vaccine?
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āStudent Gengā ignites research-integrity scandal in China after calling out senior academics
Video bloggerās viral accusations of data manipulation in Nature journals have sparked intense debate and speedy institutional investigations.
By Xiaoying You
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-01902-0 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
In a CHD article, El-Deiry is quoted complaining that PubPeer has no ācitizenship requirements.ā š«Ŗ
And they say he seems to be equating raising scientific concerns with being charged with a crime. š
childrenshealthdefense.org/defender/vigilante-science-ano⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
This seems to be a common thing for @GettyImages, although the photographer names are different, thereās a bunch that look generated the same way. I didnāt see any disclosure that these arenāt real photos. š¤·āāļø
www.gettyimages.com/detail/photo/drone-group-on-the-backg⦠#gettyfakes -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
The idea vaccines cause autism was invented by Andrew Wakefield in 1998 and was so thoroughly debunked he lost his license for gross malpractice
And here we are 27 years later RFK Jr dredging up the same nonsense
Such a tiresome waste of time -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Also, what happened to the $4 meal deal for Ikea Family members on Tuesdays? Our lunch was three times more expensive than we had hoped.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
@StassenFrank
Vandaag verscheen er een paper waarin gekeken is naar de oversterfte in NL tijdens de Covid-19 pandemie en welke rol de vaccinaties daarin speelden. In de studie hebben ze gekeken naar gegevens van vrijwel alle Nederlanders van 63 jaar en ouder gedurende 2020 en 2021
#oversterfte -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
In fact 95% of papers listing the Abcam antibody ab51243 have used it incorrectly. Here's the link to the blog for my complete analysis: forbetterscience.com/2026/06/02/mind-over-antibody/
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Am Soc for Mass Spec
@asmsnews
Thank you for joining us at #asms2026! Your closing lecture was a memorable way to wrap up an incredible week of science, discussion, and discovery. We're so glad you enjoyed your time in San Diego!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Honored to be included on this SciGuardians list.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
1st None of these people work for journals who retracted your papers.
2nd You canāt call those articles āresearch.ā One retraction statement literally read: āThe article does not meet the standards of editorial or scientific soundness.ā
3rd Misfits? Fair enough š» -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
I am sending an open letter to Thermo Fisher. Their response to my response to their manipulated western blot is bullying and petty. Yes, this western blot really is manipulated, it is unfair on me to say otherwise. I don't make those accusations lightly. #thermofishy
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Thank you, @asmsnews, for inviting me to give the closing lecture in San Diego. So many great questions and discussions afterward. And the dinner party on the USS Midway deck was fantastic.
You guys are a lovely bunch!
#asms2026 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. David Sanders
@DavidSandersRep
āI really feel as if the administration is engaged in reverse alchemy, and itās turning Americaās scientific gold into lead,ā says David Sanders, a sleuth and biologist at Purdue University in West Lafayette, Indiana.
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-02163-z -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
The child in "The Emperor's New Clothes" didn't destroy the Emperor's reputation.
The invisible clothes did that.
Pointing out problems isn't what creates them. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mauro Lago-Docampo
@MuruLago
In January, I reviewed a Review for a crappy MDPI journal.
It was 100% AI, missing citations, etc. I sent a massive report, and the authors withdrew it.
Today, I see it published without a single change in another even crappier MDPI journal. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
New documentary by Moritz Hoppe at arte.tv: āBetrug in der Wissenschaftā (fraud in scienceā), with Rafael Levy, Amrei Bahr, and myself.
You might need a VPN to watch
www.arte.tv/de/videos/124442-000-A/betrug-in-der-wissensc⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
On June 4th, I will give the closing plenary talk at the annual @asmsnews conference in San Diego. Hope to see some of you there!
And please send me any dubious #massspectrometry images - love to learn more.
#imageforensics
www.asms.org/conferences/annual-conference/featured-speakers
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
On my way to San Diego!
Looking forward to give the closing talk at the @asmsnews #asms2026 conference. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Too bad you couldnāt find more credible doctors willing to attend. The papers are retracted because the research is so poor.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
The Straits Times
@straits_times
Hijab-switching researcher scandal puts Indonesian academia under scrutiny www.straitstimes.com/asia/se-asia/hijab-switching-researcā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Am Soc for Mass Spec
@asmsnews
Safe travels, #teammassspec! Weāll see you this week in San Diego. #asms2026
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Kyle Siler (@kylesiler.bsky.social)
@KyleSiler
New article in @PNASNews:
We all know that ChatGPT loves to delve, bolster, leverage, encompass, showcase, underscore, et cetera. I analyzed full text of 7.3 million journal articles published 2020-2025, hunting for 228 words that spiked after ChatGPT launched in late 2022. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
Today I'm posting a new blog about an astonishing scientific own goal. Hundreds of papers have reported using a completely wrong antibody to investigate the tumor suppressor p16. This mistake has happened because scientists have muddled the names of two proteins š§µ
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
It was awesome to sit down with @NPRinskeep to talk about HOW TO RULE THE WORLD.
This is a book about Silicon Valleyās training ground ā and of the innovation and fraud that emerge from it.
You can catch the interview below! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Paywalled for me, so hereās an excerpt.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Moffitt executive resigns leadership role after investigation of her research
Scientists questioned whether images used in studies produced when Elsa Flores worked at a cancer center in Texas had been altered.
www.tampabay.com/news/health/2026/05/30/moffitt-cancer-re⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Moffitt executive resigns leadership role after investigation of her research
Scientists questioned whether images used in studies produced when Elsa Flores worked at a cancer center in Texas had been altered.
www.tampabay.com/news/health/2026/05/30/moffitt-cancer-re⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
nature
@Nature
Catalogue entries for more than 100 antibodies sold by the research services and supply company Thermo Fisher Scientific contain images that have apparently been manipulated, according to a pair of science sleuths.
go.nature.com/4wZqGEE -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This is not correct. I stood behind Michael during that time, and resigned from the eLife Integrity board because of how he was treated. Is this all one big misunderstanding?
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This is not correct. I stood behind Michael during that time, and resigned from the eLife Integrity board because of how he was treated. Is this all one big misunderstanding?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Horace Austin
@Horace_Austin
So cool meeting both of you at Stanford!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
SciGuardians new AI-generated graphics reimagine a hammer where you use the handle to cause āmaximum damage.ā Bizarre. š¤”
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
Thrilled and astonished to learn that HOW TO RULE THE WORLD is a NYT bestseller!
Incredibly grateful to the team @penguinpress for the last several years of tireless collaboration.
And a huge, huge thank you to everyone reading and engaging with this book. Wow!! -
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
Looking forward to discussing my new book HOW TO RULE THE WORLD with Stanford Professor Rob Reich tonight!
Join us for a lively conversation on campus about my reporting on Stanford and the universityās complex relationship with tech and power.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Thank you so much for a great discussion and for the shoutout ā¤ļø
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
72ème rétractation pour l'IHU de Marseille.
La 60ĆØme pour Didier Raoult.
Tentative de recyclage d'autorisation Ʃthique couverte par l'universitƩ d'Aix Marseille. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
Looking forward to discussing my new book HOW TO RULE THE WORLD with Stanford Professor Rob Reich tonight!
Join us for a lively conversation on campus about my reporting on Stanford and the universityās complex relationship with tech and power. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
@StassenFrank
Welk een ironie!
Didier Raoult, -tig keer door @MicrobiomDigest ontmaskerd als fraudeur, jubelt nu dat chloroquine een comeback maakt en het perfecte middel zou zijn tegen Hantavirus op basis van een artikel uit 2021 van @vanranstmarc en....Piet Raes š¤
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33791230/
Didier Raoult
@raoult_didier
Le retour de la chloroquine.
C'est nous les gentils !
La chloroquine est une molĆ©cule Ć pH Ć©levĆ© qui se concentre dans les cellules empĆŖchant les virus et bactĆ©ries ayant besoin de lāaciditĆ© de la poche des cellules dans laquelle ils sont entrĆ©s pour se libĆ©rer ou activer leurs enzymes.
Cette action nāest pas spĆ©cifique dāun virus et les autres molĆ©cules Ć pH Ć©levĆ© ont la mĆŖme activitĆ©, mais sont plus toxiques ( amantadine, entre autres)
Ce nāest pas Ć©tonnant que la chloroquine, sur des cultures cellulaires comme dans des modĆØles expĆ©rimentaux sur la souris, soit efficace aussi sur SARS cov2 ,Hantavirus
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33791230/
et Ebola
pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acsinfecdis.5b00030
Au contraire, les vaccins trop ciblés et les anticorps monoclonaux ont des cibles trop restreintes pour des virus à ARN qui mutent tout le temps et génèrent rapidement des variants échappant aux vaccins et aux anticorps monoclonaux
La chloroquine et lā hydroxychloroquine ont un dĆ©faut majeur : ils ne rapportent pas dāargentā!!! Et personne ne veut les tester sans intĆ©rĆŖt financier.
Ce nāest pas lāoccident sans morale qui les Ć©tudiera, ni lāOMS tenue par B Gates et BigPharma, mais lāavenir nāest pas quāau profit. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
It appears have paper mill and citation mill features. These are not simple things.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
It appears have paper mill and citation mill features. These are not simple things.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
NBC News
@NBCNews
No child deaths have been definitively linked to Covid vaccines, according to a report from the FDA that was quietly made public. www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/no-child-deaths-definiā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
This is sick behaviour from whoever is behind this account. Henry's death is tragic. Absolutely nothing to do with research integrity. Trying to bundle these ideas together for clicks is disrespectful to Henry's family.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
Earlier this week I posted an example of a fake western blot provided by ThermoFisher to demonstrate the validity of a p53 antibody. I considered it an amusing curiosity. In fact ThermoFisher has systematically manipulated antibody validation data. Short Thread... š§µ
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
HOW TO RULE THE WORLD is featured in the latest issue of Science! Read the full interview at the address in the next tweet.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
No increase in cancer risk following mRNA Covid vaccines in large data sets from Norway š³š“ and Sweden šøšŖ
They don't cause cancer
It's a myth invented by anti vaxxers to scare you off vaccines -
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
I fell in love with Stanford when I was seven.
Fourteen years later, Iāve written a book about it ā and itās out today!
HOW TO RULE THE WORLD is a story set in Silicon Valleyās training ground, where avarice and power too frequently outmatch good intentions.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Got my copy on Tuesday!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
I fell in love with Stanford when I was seven.
Fourteen years later, Iāve written a book about it ā and itās out today!
HOW TO RULE THE WORLD is a story set in Silicon Valleyās training ground, where avarice and power too frequently outmatch good intentions. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Thanks for confirming the harassement documented here: www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01920-4
Within 2 hours of the release of the article your AI slop is online.
If you are tired of the people you defend being rightfully called out for misconduct, stop defending people who actually engage in scientific misconduct. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
New on ScienceIntegrityDigest: My report from the 2026 World Conference on Research Integrity in Vancouver. If you could not make it, there are links to all my BlueSky live posts from the sessions I attended. #wcri2026
scienceintegritydigest.com/2026/05/20/reporting-from-the-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Editorial Note on @PLOSONE paper by Domenico Praticò because images appeared in later papers with āsome of the same authors, all of which have since been retracted.ā
pubpeer.com/publications/0685F6A1C25B929C1D60D18D24D798 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Thank you so much @NatureCareers @Nature @SpringerNature for publishing my career piece on how scientists and journalists should collaborate to protect research. Very happy about this piece
Go give it a read here: www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-00824-1
nature
@Nature
"I thought that I knew all that there was to know about the intricacies of scrutinizing and correcting science, but there was still much to learn"
go.nature.com/4dyR93f -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Marc Gozlan
@MarcGozlan
La fraude scientifique, flƩau de la littƩrature biomƩdicale. Qui Ʃtaient jusqu'en 2013 les plus grands fraudeurs ?
Deux anesthĆ©siologistes, lāun allemand, lāautre amĆ©ricain, et un cardiologue japonais font partie du trio de tĆŖte.
www.lemonde.fr/blog/realitesbiomedicales/2013/12/04/la-fr⦠[Rediff] -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Today, I will be attending the #statbreakthrough West in San Francisco at the Commonwealth Club. Lots of great talks about AI and personal journeys.
STAT
@statnews
#statbreakthrough West is tomorrow. Secure your ticket and explore the agenda below!
Join us here: www.statnews.com/stat-summit-west/
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Live posting on BlueSky.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr JƩrƓme BARRIERE, MD.
@barriere_dr
And the French winner is ā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Eric Dutin
@DutinEric15494
ā¼ļø ScienceGuardians : quand un compte anonyme Ā«dĆ©masqueĀ» un Prix Einstein
Un compte X anonyme @SciGuardians a découvert que le Prix Einstein 2024 pour la Qualité dans la Recherche aurait été remis à deux « fraudeurs ».
VƩrifions.
1ļøā£ Le Ā« prix de l'intĆ©gritĆ© Ā» remis Ć des Ā« fraudeurs Ā»?
š Avant d'accuser une fondation allemande de corruption systĆ©mique, lire son communiquĆ© officiel, c'est pas mal.
Einstein Foundation Award 2024, en partenariat avec la U.S. National Academy of Sciences :
Elisabeth Bik (Individual), nommée par Csaba Szabó (Fribourg) :
Plus de 7600 papiers signalƩs, plus de 1100 rƩtractations selon la Fondation Einstein.
PubPeer / Brandon Stell (Institutional, 200000 ā¬), nommĆ© par Dorothy Bishop (Oxford) : >300000 commentaires, 19 % des rĆ©tractations mondiales prĆ©cĆ©dĆ©es d'une discussion PubPeer.
Jury international, nominations signƩes, partenariat NAS.
Pas franchement le coin sombre où on refile des prix en douce.
2ļøā£ Ā« Self-proclaimed consultant Ā» : le CV qui dĆ©range
š Quand on traite quelqu'un d'autoproclamĆ©, c'est mieux quand son CV n'est pas Ć un clic.
PhD Utrecht 1996 (Vibrio cholerae), 15 ans Ć Stanford School of Medicine (labo David Relman), Microbiome Pioneer Award 2016, uBiome, Astarte Medical, Peter Wildy Prize, John Maddox Prize 2021, Einstein 2024.
Une "autoproclamƩe" coautrice d'un papier citƩ plus de 4000 fois.
Bon.
3ļøā£ Ā« PubSmear, racketeering, 30 acteurs centraux Ā» : les preuves ?
š Du droit pĆ©nal lourd, en anglais, anonymement, sur X. Le dossier suit ?
PubPeer indique dans sa FAQ qu'il modère les commentaires, exige des faits vérifiables et interdit les accusations directes de misconduct/fraude.
Je n'ai trouvé aucune source indépendante fiable, judiciaire, réglementaire ou institutionnelle, validant ces accusations de « racketeering ».
à l'inverse, en septembre 2025, Taylor & Francis a menacé ScienceGuardians de poursuites pour propos "highly defamatory", dans une lettre signée par un certain "Elias Verum, on behalf of ScienceGuardians".
4ļøā£ Le Ā« cas rhinocĆ©ros Ā» : 10 jours, 1 commentaire, beaucoup d'imagination
š Un commentaire modĆ©rĆ© sur une plateforme modĆ©rĆ©e, et c'est la chute de Rome.
Le papier Roth et al. 2019 (Frontiers in Microbiology, DOI 10.3389/fmicb.2019.02291) existe bien, avec Bik coautrice : 31 rhinocéros, 5 zoos, limites méthodologiques reconnues par les auteurs eux-mêmes.
Ces limites peuvent nourrir une discussion scientifique ; elles ne suffisent pas, à elles seules, à établir une fraude ni à rendre automatique une Expression of Concern.
La chronologie « accepté puis retiré 10 jours plus tard » provient exclusivement de captures produites par ScienceGuardians sur leur Substack.
Aucune validation indƩpendante.
5ļøā£ Des anonymes qui dĆ©noncent l'anonymat
š On peut dĆ©noncer l'anonymat ou l'utiliser. Faire les deux, c'est sportif.
scienceguardians.com ne publie aucune identitƩ ("a dedicated team of IT professionals").
Une des rares personnes publiquement associées au projet est Wafik S. El-Deiry, oncologue à Brown University, qui reconnaît s'être inscrit sur la plateforme et avoir relayé certains posts.
Il a 75 papiers signalƩs sur PubPeer et au moins un article rƩtractƩ en 2013 (Retraction Watch, 10.06.2025).
Bik signe, elle, de son vrai nom.
š Conclusion
D'un cƓtƩ : jury international, nominations Oxford et Fribourg, partenariat NAS, laurƩats au CV vƩrifiable, 1 100+ rƩtractations.
De l'autre : compte anonyme, accusations en majuscules, soutien public abondamment signalƩ sur la plateforme qu'il attaque, mise en demeure par Taylor & Francis.
Le miroir, parfois, est plus instructif que la fenĆŖtre.
(Sources en commentaires)
#dƩsinformation #science
ScienceGuardians
@SciGuardians
šØ THE REAL REASON SCIENCE IS DYING: "INTEGRITY" GUARDIANS ARE THE BIGGEST FRAUDS
While scientific misconduct, predatory journals, paper mills, predatory conferences, and exploitative publishing practices have exploded over the past decade, a huge portion of the academic community has sunk into deep disempowerment and silence.
This is not a coincidence.
The legitimate question is: Why?
The answer is simple and devastating ā the very mechanisms and platforms that were supposed to empower researchers to fight fraud have themselves been captured, compromised, and weaponized.
Case in point: In 2024, the Einstein Foundation Award for Promoting Quality in Research (@Einstein_Berlin) was handed out ā with zero real investigation or due diligence ā at both institutional and individual levels.
It was awarded to Brandon Stell (@CNRS), co-founder of the fraudulent PubPeer (aka PubSmear) platform, and to Elisabeth M. Bik, the self-proclaimed āscience integrity consultantā.
ScienceGuardians⢠Legal and Investigative Team has exposed with undeniable evidence how Stell, Bik, and their PubSmear network mob are running one of the most sophisticated fraud operations in academia: operating hundreds of fake aliases controlled by ~30 core actors with moderator-level access, posting tens of thousands of entries, blanket-censoring retraction-level and Expression-of-Concern-level critiques on their own papers, manipulating records, pressuring journals and institutions into buying their ādashboardsā, running fake WeChat accounts to harass Chinese academics, and orchestrating coordinated smear, defamation, and harassment campaigns ā all while hiding behind the false banner of āresearch integrityā. And thatās only the tip of the iceberg.
This is not oversight.
This is systemic corruption.
ā ļø The award that was meant to celebrate integrity was instead given to the very actors destroying it.
There are far deeper layers of corruption behind how this award was actually given ā and we will expose them soon. Stay tuned.
#pubpeerscandal #einsteinaward #sciencefraud #brandonstell #elisabethbik #pubsmear
@SciGuardians š±
ScienceGuardians⢠exists to expose corruption, empower researchers, and restore real integrity in science. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
"Something about this place was off, like Disneyland after all the rides have closed and the park is emptied for the night."
Read an excerpt of HOW TO RULE THE WORLD in @VanityFair, describing the "War on Fun" ā the story that began my investigation of Stanford. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
Stunned and honored by this rave review in @nytimes.
āBakerās first book, HOW TO RULE THE WORLD is a rigorous, self-assured, propulsive, at times terrifying portrait of a dweebocracy that āsets the agenda for the planet.āā -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
Surprised to discover that Thermo Fisher appears to show a fake western blot for the validation of one of their p53 antibodies. I've added a diagram to show the very similar bands. This does not appear to be one of the "published figures", but their own internal data.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
HOW TO RULE THE WORLD is out Tuesday.
I spoke with @willpavia for @thetimes about my debut book and what it's been like to both go to and investigate "this university in which students are a monetisable product."
Link in the next tweet! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
Books have always been a huge part of my life.
Never did I think Iād have the chance to publish one of my own at age 21.
HOW TO RULE THE WORLD comes out on Tuesday and Iām so excited to share this dream, years in the making, with all of you. (cc: @penguinpress!) -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mohamed Sabba
@ma_sabba
The backlash to this perfectly reasonable rule, largely from the usual suspects (i.e. AI grifters) is appalling.
I hate to break it to you but arXiv is used by actual professional scholars who are not going to throw away basic academic standards for the sake of absolute garbage.
Thomas G. Dietterich
@tdietterich
Attention @arxiv authors: Our Code of Conduct states that by signing your name as an author of a paper, each author takes full responsibility for all its contents, irrespective of how the contents were generated. 1/
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Matthew B. JanƩ
@MatthewBJane
This should be mandatory reading for every graduate student
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sabine Hossenfelder
@skdh
Patents, like peer reviewed publications, look impressive in CVs, and many institutions reward them. I have seen this with my own eyes, after my host institution offered a bonus for patent applications (not registrations!) my PhD-advisor promptly applied for a patent to convert garbage into energy with higher dimensional black hole relics (which, for all we know, donāt exist).
A research team with lead at Northwestern University in the United States reports a new type of academic fraud: fake patents. They have found multiple companies which sell credits on UK registered designs to academics, mostly in India, who can use them to boost promotion scores and institutional rankings.
UK registered designs are not technically patents. They protect appearance, not function, and are not checked for novelty before registration, which makes them fast and cheap to obtain. The companies sold these off for prices corresponding to roughly $20 to $400 per authorship. Many of the fake patents had long technical-sounding titles, multiple academic applicants, recycled images, and implausible products, including an alleged artificial intelligence skin-cancer device that appears to be a modified Glock pistol model (see image). -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Dr. who? shared his fake PhD thesis: osf.io/preprints/thesiscommons/xwa9d_v1
āAlthough the first positron emission tomography (PET) scanners were built⦠at Washington University with DOE and NIH moniesā¦ā
Sadly, the DOE wasnāt formed until 1977 under Carter admin. The āthesisā is from 1974. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Fake author (Alireza Heidari) with fake affiliation (California South University) has a retraction in what I thought was a predatory journal. Maybe not. š¤·āāļø
pubpeer.com/publications/CF7D0C92867CE62F2453AB17EE15BE -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sense Jan vd Molen
@sensemolen
Muurformules: Samen met @IvovanVulpen en TEGEN-BEELD werk ik aan het verrijken van de stad Leiden met lokaal beta-erfgoed. Doel: aan iedere voorbijganger laten zien welke belangrijke ontdekkingen hier zijn gedaan. Op de foto de slingerformule van Huygens.
www.muurformules.nl -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Thomas G. Dietterich
@tdietterich
Attention @arxiv authors: Our Code of Conduct states that by signing your name as an author of a paper, each author takes full responsibility for all its contents, irrespective of how the contents were generated. 1/
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Hallucinated citations highest in social sciences preprints site - but, as I point out, part of the difference could reflect differences in moderation and publication stage, rather than something inherent to social sciences themselves.
nature
@Nature
More than 140,000 fake citations across four research repositories were identified in papers and preprints published in 2025 alone
go.nature.com/4uH7o54 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Spotting
@Spottingthespot
The man, the myth, the legend, Joachim Boldt did it! He got 3 more retractions! He leads the @RetractionWatch leaderboard in a comfortable position and now he has 239 retractions, 3 more than previously! Unbelievable! I wonder what he is up to now?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Digital Science
@digitalsci
The first #fosci Report is here! Mapping research manipulation, from individual paper fraud to coordinated networks & systemic failures.
š doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.32178456
Involving experts across academia, publishing & #researchintegrity, such as our VP Research Integrity & Security, Dr Leslie McIntosh. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
71st retraction for the IHU in Marseille.
The 59th for Didier "chloroquine4ever" Raoult.
Lack of ethical approval. They didn't have it, but they lost it! -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The @SciGuardians website appears to be struggling to build a community.
After an initial burst of activity, the number of commented papers dropped sharply and has remained relatively low for the last months.
Analysis based on ~870 commented papers listed on the site. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Kennedy Is Driving a Vast Inquiry Into Vaccines, Despite His Public Silence
Working behind the scenes, he is spearheading an intense push to examine his long-held theory that vaccines are helping to fuel an epidemic of chronic disease
#giftlink
www.nytimes.com/2026/05/11/health/kennedy-vaccine-safety.⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
I flagged this paper on PubPeer almost 6 years ago. While Oncotarget and their current EiC both spend many many words complaining about me, for more than 4+ years they haven't bothered to fix this. š¤”š¤”
pubpeer.com/publications/E9A168B3230EEF853BE2C27BF2B5D2 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
News from Science
@NewsfromScience
Breaking news: Indiana University plant microbiologist Roger Innes has been locked out of his laboratory by the school in response to a request by one of his federal funders. The move comes after Innes complained about the governmentās prosecution of Chinese postdocs.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Remember when Oncotarget published a study that noted they have cleaned up their act and found no issues in papers published after 2020? www.oncotarget.com/article/28852/text/
Maybe they didnāt see recent problems because they didnāt look. š© CF. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Congrats to Solal.
retractionwatch.com/2026/05/08/switzerland-appeals-court-ā¦
Via @RetractionWatch -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"Publish and Perish: Iām the editor in chief of a scientific journal. Thereās a disastrous imbalance happening with the labor around manuscripts."
slate.com/technology/2026/05/science-peer-review-journals⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Itās 2026, and this publisher (@cddpress @melino_G) still canāt be bothered to run a check for image duplications in supplemental files.
@SpringerNature, please clean up this mess or kick them out.
CDD press
@cddpress
āGET3 regulates apoptosis via tail-anchoring of MCL1ā
This study provides direct experimental evidence that the GET3 pathway is involved in regulating the anti-apoptotic functions of MCL1 ⤵ļø
www.nature.com/articles/s41418-026-01752-3 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
The CDC actually had a special department to investigate infectious disease outbreaks on cruise ships
In April 2025, RFK Jr fired them all .... -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Fabricated citations: an audit across 2Ā·5 million biomedical papers
The fabrication rate increased more than 12 times between 2023 and early 2026.
Possible causes: Paper Mills, AI use etc
www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(2⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Yet here you are š
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
NEW: Forensic Scientometrics (FoSci) Report 2026: Understanding, Detecting, and Documenting Manipulation in the Research Ecosystem
figshare.com/articles/online_resource/_b_Forensic_Scientoā¦Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Yet here you are š
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Merci à @Titithebest4 de prouver que l'IHU est, en moyenne, rétracté 14 fois plus que les instituts du domaine.
70 publications pour l'instant Titi. Encore des centaines possibles et Ć venir.
L'IHU risque de dépasse les 10%. Ce qui ferait un taux plus de 100 fois supérieur à la moyenne. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Issue reported in 2023, misconduct finding published in 2024, paper just retracted. šæ
pubpeer.com/publications/0C6CE690A2546370870D7402530B99 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Together with other sleuths and the FoSci team from Digital Science, we have developed the "Forensic Scientometrics (FoSci) Report 2026: Understanding, Detecting, and Documenting Manipulation in the Research Ecosystem"
doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.32178456 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
La Tronche en Biais
@TroncheBiais
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
70th retraction for the IHU
The 58th for Didier Raoult, who becomes the 8th scientist with the most retractions. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
A random cat
@wool_yeah
Hilarity by @SciReports. Cited 7 times already. Look at the x-axis!
doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-10168-x -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
70ème rétractation pour l'IHU
La 58ème pour Didier Raoult qui devient le 8ème scientifique avec le plus de rétractations. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Really surprised not to see SciGuardians at WCRI 2026 š¹
Beers with Smut one of the highlights.
ScienceGuardians
@SciGuardians
šØ MAJOR EXPOSĆ: Elisabeth M. Bik and David Bimler Exposed Running the PubPeer āPubSmearā Network Mobās Harassment, Smearing, and Defamation Operations in China šØš³ via Multiple Fraudulent WeChat Accounts
š± ScienceGuardians⢠Legal and Investigative Team has been closely monitoring the activities of these criminal actors globally ā and we have the receipts.
The official WeChat āPubPeerā account operated with the Weixin ID āElisabethBikā as recently as 11 March 2026 (šø Image 1). In a clear panic move to evade exposure, it has now been hurriedly changed to āePubpeerā. Too late ā the evidence was already captured.
We also have documented evidence of another official WeChat account āScience Integrityā operated directly by the fraudulent actor David Bimler (aka his fake alias SmutClyde) (šø Image 2).
ā ļø Both accounts are operating from the exact same IP territory: Jiangxi (ę±č„æ), China.
š Elisabeth M. Bik ā the fake āscience integrity consultantā ā has been caught colluding with a fraudulent financial advisor, Kevin Patrick, who has zero academic or scientific credentials, along with a notorious Russian criminal, online bully and harasser, Alexander Magazinov (aka āSpottingthespotā on X and Bluesky). Together, they run coordinated harassment and smear campaigns under the false flag of āResearch Integrity.ā Their goal? To pressure journals, publishers, and institutions into purchasing the so-called PubPeer Journal and Institutional Dashboards.
(š Full evidence linked in the comments)
š The PubPeer āPubSmearā Network Mob has been fully exposed for rigging the game: they 100% censor any critique of their own flawed work on the compromised PubPeer platform, while relentlessly targeting and smearing others.
š„ Watch the full 9-minute exposure video with screenshots, DOIs, and ironclad receipts (attached to this post).
Read the complete list of evidence on the ScienceGuardians⢠Substack ā no subscription or fee required.
(š Direct link in the comments)
ā ļø This is not āresearch integrity.ā This is coordinated harassment, defamation, and commercial extortion disguised as research integrity ā now proven to extend deep into Chinese platforms and audiences via fraudulent official WeChat accounts.
š± The ScienceGuardians⢠Legal and Investigative Team will continue to expose every layer of this network ā and hold fully accountable all those amplifying these criminal actors in any capacity.
š± Follow @SciGuardians
Share this widely. More evidence is dropping soon.
#elisabethbik #davidbimler #pubpeerscandal #pubsmear #scienceintegrity #researchfraud #blackmail #extortion #wechat #sciencehypocrisy
@SecKennedy @DrJBhattacharya @HHS_ORI @NIH @C0PE @UKRIO @Clarivate @ClarivateAG @timeshighered @ElsevierConnect @Scopus @SpringerNature @WeAreTandF @tandfonline @WileyGlobal @PLOS @ScienceMagazine @TheLancet @Nature @USDAScience @FrontiersIn @AIP_Publishing @CellCellPress @Sage_Publishing @ACSPublications @AmerChemSociety @RoySocChem @theNASciences @APSphysics @ORCID_Org @DOAJplus @CrossrefOrg @aaas @sciam @ChemRxiv @Science_Open @TimKersjes @chrisgrafpub @Einstein_Berlin @WCRIFoundation -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
69th retraction for the IHU in Marseille.
The 57th for Didier "Champion" Raoult.
Retrospective ethical authorization, which is not applicable, for taking lice samples from homeless in Algeria. NƩocolonial science. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
L'IHU, ou la science à peu près qui pille sans vergogne pour des échantillons...
Note Ʃditoriale publiƩe par PLoS ce jour... -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
68th retraction for the IHU in Marseille.
The 56th for Didier Raoult, who now ranks among the top 10 authors with the most retractions.
Lack of ethical authorization for blood sampling from healthy volunteers. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Bonjour @aur_rousseau,
JāapprĆ©cie vous voir prendre la parole sur ce sujet. Malheureusement, la rĆ©ponse de @sup_recherche, @Sante_Gouv, @Senat, @gouvernementFR, @stephanie_rist et @EmmanuelMacron est bien insuffisante.
Depuis 2020, nous, lanceurs dāalerte sur les dĆ©rives de @IHU_Marseille, sommes menacĆ©s de mort et harcelĆ©s quotidiennement, soit sur les rĆ©seaux, soit par le biais dāun ancien organe de presse, @france_soir, tenu par @xazalbert.
Pendant ce temps, lā@IHU_Marseille continue de se faire Ć©pingler pour des scandales Ć©thiques et mĆ©thodologiques qui font la une de la presse nationale, internationale et scientifique. Science et Nature lāont toutes deux mentionnĆ©, ainsi que The Guardian :
- www.science.org/content/article/failure-every-level-how-sā¦
- www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01920-4
- www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-04014-9
- www.science.org/content/article/infamous-paper-popularizeā¦
- www.theguardian.com/world/2023/aug/09/french-research-cenā¦
Et Ć©videmment, nous sommes les sujets de procĆ©dures bĆ¢illons qui nous coĆ»tent une fortune et qui nous prennent un temps monstrueux, le tout fait avec lāargent du contribuable franƧais par @raoult_didier pendant des annĆ©es. LĆ aussi, la couverture a Ć©tĆ© internationale :
- www.theguardian.com/science/2021/may/22/world-expert-in-sā¦
- www.science.org/content/article/scientists-rally-around-mā¦
- www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-01430-z
Et le harcĆØlement est allĆ© tellement loin quāil a lui aussi Ć©tĆ© couvert par la presse internationale. Ici, par exemple, Times Higher Education nomme directement le comportement dāun des chercheurs de @IHU_Marseille avec, je cite : āEric Chabriereās attacks against critics of hydroxychloroquine are seen as a sign of the social-media-induced radicalisation that has occurred during the pandemicā
www.timeshighereducation.com/news/french-professor-free-hā¦
Le pire dans cette histoire ? LāuniversitĆ© et son prĆ©sident Eric Berton ont non seulement balancĆ© les identitĆ©s des gens harcelĆ©s par ce personnel de lāIHU Ć lāintĆ©ressĆ©, mais en plus, lāuniversitĆ© a tout fait pour couvrir les dĆ©boires Ć©thiques de lāinstitut. Comment E. Berton et ces personnels peuvent-ils ĆŖtre encore en poste et utiliser la @justice_gouv pour essayer de museler les critiques ? Quāattend le gouvernement ? Le seul soutien clair que nous avons eu depuis des annĆ©es est celui de @BernardJomier. Lā@ansm et lāIGAS ont produit des rapports sur @IHU_Marseille dont le contenu devrait suffire Ć fermer les portes de lāinstitut. Et pourtant non, son personnel continue Ć menacer, harceler ou intenter des procĆ©dures bĆ¢illons contre les lanceurs dāalerte, des annĆ©es aprĆØs, comme mentionnĆ© ici par @Charlie_Hebdo_.
Cāest Ć©videmment sans compter sur lāensemble des collectifs antivax qui nous nomment et nous menacent au quotidien ou Ć©crivent en permanence Ć nos employeurs... Dois-je expliquer la rĆ©putation de la France Ć cause de cela pour ceux d'entre nous qui travaillent Ć l'Ć©tranger (@francediplo @francediplo_EN @FrenchResponse)?
Quāattend le gouvernement ? Un drame ?
@DrMartyJer @UFMLSYNDICAT @barriere_dr @AlexSamTG @Sonic_urticant @TroncheBiais @LockedFab @EricBillyFR @Ibra_Amirat @dr_l_alexandre @wargonm @MacronardsFM @campiche_sarah @Topiramatee @AnthonyGuihur @potard_yves @MicrobiomDigest @doclamarre -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I will be live-posting from the @WCRIFoundation #wcri2026 in Vancouver on BlueSky.
Hope to see some of you there! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Kate Travis
@Kate_Travis
Some 19 years ago I covered the first World Conference on Research Integrity in Lisbon. My career took a different track for a while,Ā but now I'm firmly back in this world, and excited for #wcri2026!
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I will be live-posting from the @WCRIFoundation #wcri2026 in Vancouver on BlueSky.
Hope to see some of you there! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Brian Goldman
@NightShiftMD
I'm wiling to bet that a substantial proportion of MDs who now attack scientifically proven medicine are physicians who flunked the boards or lost their licenses. Their bitterness at being rejected by healthcare is both sad and obvious.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Arrived in Vancouver for the #wcri2026 @WCRIFoundation
I am moderating a panel on Monday and giving a talk as a @Einstein_Berlin award winner on Tuesday.
Today and tomorrow, though, weāll be exploring the city.
Lovely #azaleas next tot the hotel.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Who else is going to be here?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Katie Robertson
@katie_robertson
New: McClatchy journalists at newspapers in 4 states are now withholding their bylines from A.I.-generated content as tensions grow over a "content scaling agent" tool that the company rolled out www.nytimes.com/2026/05/01/business/media/mcclatchy-ai-neā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Eleventh (?) retraction of a paper by Domenico Praticò @TempleUniv
HT: @SmutClyde
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/acel.70524
pubpeer.com/publications/EDBA7DDFF79973F7E6E65ACD445C3F -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
A top cancer researcher in Spain kept raising funds based on a PNAS paper he knew was being retracted.
elpais.com/ciencia/2026-04-29/barbacid-siguio-recaudando-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Two years to retract this ransom note.
pubpeer.com/publications/5CE55BE63B602451B353D3276DDAF9 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Francis Deng, MD
@francisdeng
This #journalimage was AI-manipulated and retracted in NEJM.
Can you spot the signs? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"Opening Pandora's box:" Publication offers found for 1,700 papers in IEEE conference proceedings.
arxiv.org/abs/2604.22458 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
J. Craig Venter, Scientist Who Decoded the Human Genome, Dies at 79
A risk-taking outsider, he brought speed, competition and controversy to one of scienceās biggest races.
#giftlink
Nicholas Wade writes @nytimes
www.nytimes.com/2026/04/30/science/j-craig-venter-dead.ht⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Tae Seok Moon
@Moon_Synth_Bio
I came back to the United States, hearing about a very sad news: Craig Venter passed away today. He is a pioneer, successfully sequenced the first Human genome, and tried to create Synthetic Cells. We lost a giant in Science. RIP.
@JCVenterInst -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
A 2018 paper with an astonishing muddle of overlapping images has finally been retracted. The authors include the infamous (in some circles at least) Alexander Seifalian, a bunch of Iranians, and for some reason, a bloke from Lancaster.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
While the non-disclosure of the conflicts of interest is a serious issue, it is also important to point out that @addictedtoigno1 and others found several instances of image duplication in this paper.
pubpeer.com/publications/64DADC70084B77AC3D3AE16B020283
Rafael Sirera
@ProfSirera
There is a tendency to minimise the implications of the recent retraction in PNAS of the Mariano Barbacid paper for non-declaring their conflicts of interest.
This is not a minor procedural oversight.
It touches a core structural principle of modern scientific practice: transparency as a prerequisite for credibility.
Conflict-of-interest disclosure is not a bureaucratic formality.
It is a mechanism designed to allow readers, reviewers, and the broader community to interpret data within its full economic and intellectual context. When omittedāparticularly in cases where authors hold ownership stakes in companies positioned to commercially exploit the reported findingsāthe omission distorts the epistemic framework in which the results are evaluated.
We have precedent.
Both in Spain and the United States, high-profile cases have demonstrated the institutional consequences of such failures. A prominent clinician-scientistāformer chief in leading hospitals across both countries and president of major international medical societiesā resigned from positions in the United States after failing to disclose relevant financial conflicts, subsequently transitioning to the pharmaceutical industry.
The issue was not scientific fraud; it was a breach of transparency. Yet the reputational and institutional consequences were substantial.
There is an additional layer here that is often overlooked.
The publication in question was submitted under the ācontributedā track available to members of the United States National Academy of Sciences. This pathwayāeffectively a form of editorial privilegeāallows for an expedited and, in practice, more controlled review process. It is a mechanism unavailable to the majority of researchers, who must navigate standard peer review with no such structural advantage.
This episode is not about a single paper. It reflects a tension between scientific authority and scientific accountability. Prestige may facilitate access, but it does not exempt one from the foundational norms that sustain trust in the system.Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
In one of the other @PNASNews papers from the same researchers, there are unexpected similarities between some of the #flowcytometry panels. As least, I think they are unexpected. Some regions look identical, others are different.
pubpeer.com/publications/FF06B7F27E9387984F254002F37AC1
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Let me know if you think these similarities are expected - I am not sure what the gating strategy was here.
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You blocked me for a while, Dr. Hazan, after I criticized one of your papers. Why are you afraid of open dialogue about scientific issues with other scientists?
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You blocked me for a while, Dr. Hazan, after I criticized one of your papers. Why are you afraid of open dialogue about scientific issues with other scientists?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
Nouvelle note éditoriale pour l'IHU de Marseille. Soupçon d'utilisation rétrospective d'approbation éthique. AMU, qui est infoutue de retrouver la moindre autorisation 2 ans après, se souvient que l'étude a commencé en février et pas en janvier. Magique !!!
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A new Expression of Concern, and two Editorial Notes upholding two older EoCs, for @raoult_didier et al. @IHU_Marseille / Aix-Marseille UniversitƩ
journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.poneā¦
pubpeer.com/publications/0F5E0A17CD56151E63B70AFD82DA3E
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
And me posting this will probably be followed by a new wave of SciGuardians tweets calling me a fraud š
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Christian Wolf
@KrischanWolf
Not the same papers: they are open access.
The journal subscriptions for journals carrying OA and non-OA papers at the same time, that is what is paid for.
Which does not make it much better. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mushtaq Bilal, PhD
@MushtaqBilalPhD
Researchers paid $1.06 billion to five academic publishers from 2015-2018 to publish their papers.
Academic publishers sold the same papers back to researchers for $2 billion. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Renic
@NC_Renic
AI cheating has gotten so bad that I now feel genuine affection for horrifically bad essays clearly written by the student
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Manuel Ansede
@manuelansede
Barbacid ocultó sus intereses empresariales cuando anunció una supuesta 'curación' del cĆ”ncer de pĆ”ncreas, como revelamos en EL PAĆS el 6 de febrero. La Academia de Ciencias de EE UU acaba de retractar su estudio por esa turbia maniobra:
elpais.com/ciencia/2026-04-28/la-academia-de-ciencias-de-⦠Por @Nunodomin -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr Balraj | બલરાąŖ
@balrajshukla
The Journal Sleuth
All about equipping yourself about the basic skills of identifying fake journals... In under an hour!
For everyone in academia!
Link to the full playlist: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLnG8aLwfngUgdojv6ZB6ejziW-i5laugd
#research @ARanganathan72 @ScienceMagazine @ScienceNews -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
5 years later and this still hasnāt been retracted. @ElsevierConnect @jbiolchem
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Those who decry post-publication critiques as ācensorship,ā are oddly silent now. ā2025-2026 COVID-19 vaccines were associated with additional protection against medically attended COVID-19 beyond an individualsā existing immunity.ā
Here is that paper:
open.substack.com/pub/insidemedicine/p/exclusive-heres-th⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Am Soc for Mass Spec
@asmsnews
šØTOMORROWšØ is the last day for general registration.
If youāre planning to take part in the #asms2026 Short Courses at the conference, nowās the time to sign up! If space permits, late registration goes until May 23rd. #massspeccommunity #teammassspec
www.asms.org/conferences/annual-conference/short-courses -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Am Soc for Mass Spec
@asmsnews
Meet this yearās Plenary Speakers who are shaping the conversations at #asms2026!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mad Milton
@PhilipPanass
Prudent to note that Dr. Das had several of his papers flagged at PubPeer for suspected image manipulation (and academic fraud), as detailed by @MohanaBasu at theprint.in/science/11-papers-by-jnu-scientist-bjp-candidā¦. @MicrobiomDigest has since flagged a newer set of concerns with his papers, if I am not wrong :)
Amit Shah
@AmitShah
Pleased to meet Prof. Gobardhan Das, Director, IISER Bhopal, today at Kolkata.
A Bengali stalwart, Prof. Das makes India and Bengal proud with his seminal contributions to molecular science. I congratulate him on becoming Full Time Member of NITI Aayog. May he contribute immensely to nation-building. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āAstonishingā discovery could help save children from deadly disfiguring condition
A previously unknown species of bacteria found in patients with noma could be key to creating treatments for neglected tropical disease
#treponema
www.theguardian.com/global-development/2026/apr/25/discovā¦
journals.plos.org/plosntds/article?id=10.1371/journal.pnt⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Trump Fires Board Members of Group That Oversees U.S. Science Funding
The dismissals from an independent board that oversees the National Science Foundation marked the presidentās latest assault on scientific research organizations.
#giftlink
www.nytimes.com/2026/04/25/us/politics/trump-fires-board-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A very easy #imageforensics, from the @Oncotarget archives.
Tumors treated with either 'vehicle' or 'DPN'.
What do you see? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
RFKJr demanded 1 example of a time he's ever said misinformation. @jessicamalaty, @KnurickJessica, & I found 21, and we didn't even finish.
rasmussenretorts.substack.com/cp/195317484
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
BENNET: Do you agree that 89% of children who died from flu were unvaccinated?
RFK Jr: I don't know the exact number
BENNET: That is the exact number, Secretary Kennedy
RFK Jr: *death growls*
BENNET: You took down the HHS communications promoting the flu vaccine. Do you regret that? -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I knew this was coming. We are so f*cked - fake and real now look the same.
We desperately need tools to show journals and researchers that data is real, not AI-generated.
Mikael Elias
@elias_mikael
ā ļøAll of the below images were FABRICATED by ChatGPT Images 2.0, each with a single promptāļø ā ļø
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Journal goes dark after impersonating @EricTopol and others
retractionwatch.com/2026/04/23/eric-topol-ellinger-publis⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
C.D.C. Cancels Publication of Study Showing Benefits of Covid Vaccines
Report found that shots cut likelihood of hospitalizations, but the agencyās acting head said it gave an inaccurate picture of the vaccinesā effectiveness.
@apoorva_nyc
#giftlink
www.nytimes.com/2026/04/22/us/politics/cdc-covid-vaccine-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Harvard says researcher who published nearly 100 articles in 2 1/2 years has no affiliation with the university; news outlet alleges the "astonishingly prolific" author used AI to generate papers.
freebeacon.com/campus/astonishingly-prolific-anti-israel-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
*How *not* to handle image manipulation*.
Editors, please do not address this level of photoshopping with a correction.
In 2020, I flagged Figure 3D of this 2017 BBRC paper. Multiple regions appeared reused within or across panels.
pubpeer.com/publications/15308988709AE80ABDAC3077724100
#imageforensicsPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Now, in 2026, the paper is finally retracted, because of a cross-paper overlap and because the Editor found a cloned region in Figure 3C.
Not because of the extensive duplications in Figure 3D flagged in 2020.
HT: @SmutClyde
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The retraction notice does not accurately reflect what happened.
Instead, it is a bit self-congratulatory for the EiC, who discovered a single duplication in Figure 3C but did not find the dozens of duplications found earlier in 2020 in Figure 3D sufficient reason to retract. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
Ladies and gentlemen your nominee for Surgeon General
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
67ème rétractation pour l'IHU de Marseille.
La 55ĆØme pour Didier Raoult.
Prélèvements sanguins sur volontaires sains sans référence d'accord éthique que les auteurs n'ont même pas essayé de fournir. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Tanya Halliday, PhD, RD
@NutritionNerd
Trying to be an Associate Editor these daysā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
10 years ago today, @MicrobiomDigest published a preprint heard around the world.
retractionwatch.com/2026/04/19/elisabeth-bik-scientific-s⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Spotting
@Spottingthespot
This monstrosity of a paper has been retracted by @SpringerNature. It does beg the question: why is it sometimes possible to act so swiftly and yet in most cases in can drag on for years?
doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-48538-8
Spotting
@Spottingthespot
Hey @SciReports is this some sort of joke?? @TimKersjes @SpringerNature please act ASAP. This is an abomination! šHow the hell did this ever pass peer review, editorial processes???
doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-18302-5 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Caity Weaver
@caityweaver
I was going to say āI had so much fun reporting this story!ā but actually I think I was stressed out the whole time, sprinting in a blind panic, trying to figure out why the hell I pitched this. I think that comes across in the text. Hope you enjoy! www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/05/best-free-restaurantā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This one is so blatant, so I am not going to hand out Emoji Awards for this one. But a nice, enjoyable #imageforensics puzzle for your Saturday:
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A very popular image! Perhaps Magnesium Oxide, perhaps Zinc Oxide. Who cares? Found in at least five papers by the same group; possibly more.
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
A. Murat Eren (Meren)
@merenbey
How every layer of science's "self-correcting machinery" failed when Iva Veseli and I simply wanted to reproduce the findings of a high-profile study on gut microbiome and autism:
merenlab.org/2026/04/15/unfalsifiable-by-design/ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
It's worthwhile to educate the broader public on this, but I'm sorry that this article gave so little credit to @cpiller (and essentially none to @schrag_matthew and others) who relentlessly documented these concerns, at great reputational risk.
arstechnica.com/science/2026/04/whats-the-deal-with-alzhe⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Maitre Eolasš«š·
@Maitre_Eolas
L'avocat Fabrice Di Vizio dƩfinitivement condamnƩ.
Christian Peltier Avocat
@AvocatPeltier
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
"Le Dr Didier Raoult est le 11ĆØme chercheur au monde ayant reƧu le plus dāavis de rĆ©tractation concernant ses articles. Le top 10, dominĆ© par lāallemand Joachim Boldt, est Ć seulement 4 [2 maintenant] articles pour le franƧais."
www.science-et-vie.com/sciences-fondamentales/didier-raou⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Eric Dutin
@DutinEric15494
RAOULT VS BIK : LA PLAINTE QUI VOULAIT FAIRE TAIRE LA SCIENCE - ET QUI S'EST TUE TOUTE SEULE
En 2021, le Pr Raoult a tentƩ d'intimider une chercheuse nƩerlandaise en la poursuivant pour "chantage".
Spoiler : ça n'a pas très bien marché.
āāāāāāā
1ļøā£ Le chef-d'Åuvre juridique
š Quand on confond un smiley avec une tentative d'extorsion.
Le 29 avril 2021, Raoult @raoult_didier et Chabrière @Prof_Chabriere déposent plainte contre Elisabeth Bik @MicrobiomDigest pour «harcèlement, tentative de chantage et d'extorsion».
La piĆØce Ć conviction centrale du "chantage" ?
Un tweet de Bik proposant Ć l'IHU de la financer via Patreon š.
Le Monde prƩcise qu'ils n'ont pas compris l'ironie, soulignƩe d'un smiley.
On les comprend : dƩtecter l'humour, c'est aussi une compƩtence scientifique.
ā
2ļøā£ La rĆ©action du monde scientifique
š 1000 chercheurs signent. Marseille, elle, dort.
Plus de 1000 chercheurs signent une lettre de soutien Ć Bik.
Le CNRS, l'ENS et le sƩnateur Jomier condamnent publiquement la stratƩgie d'intimidation.
Une pƩtition recueille plus de 3 000 signatures.
Pendant ce temps, Bik continue tranquillement son travail depuis la Californie.
ā
3ļøā£ Le rĆ©sultat judiciaire
š Le parquet de Marseille a rendu son verdict : le silence.
En septembre 2022, Bik confirme n'avoir jamais ƩtƩ contactƩe par la justice franƧaise.
Ni deux ans plus tard.
La plainte pour "chantage au smiley" s'est ƩvaporƩe dans les couloirs du parquet de Marseille sans laisser de traces.
Qualifier la critique scientifique publiƩe sur PubPeer de tentative d'extorsion s'est avƩrƩ, surprise, juridiquement compliquƩ.
ā
4ļøā£ L'Ć©pilogue
š Le retour de bĆ¢ton - ou en termes savants : l'effet rebond.
Octobre 2024 : c'est Raoult qui se retrouve interdit d'exercer la mƩdecine pendant deux ans.
Elisabeth Bik salue la nouvelle sur X.
La science, elle, continue sans lui.
Sources en commentaire
š½ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
He now also is the worldās #1 retracted microbiologist š¬
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
He now also is the worldās #1 retracted microbiologist š¬
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fake It or Leave It | AI-studio
@FakeLeave
Dutch Royals Take Over The White House!
šš¼ fakeitorleaveit.com
#koningspaar #dutchroyals #wittehuis #whitehouse #trump #epsteinfiles #iranwar #worldcup2026 #netherlands -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Martin, tu essaies de rƩƩcrire l'histoire. Ća ne marche pas. Tes menaces de mort et appels au harcĆØlement sont tous documentĆ©s.
La liste complĆØte est ici: x.com/lonnibesancon/status/1961853373587525986 #zizigate
Mais voici quelques extraits en images:
On te voit!
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Bonsoir @xazalbert Ć vous et votre collectif citoyen de blog @france_soir
Suite à la menace de mort de ce jour par votre ami @MartinZ_uncut de @AerendirMobile à mon encontre, j'ai décidé de faire une recherche rapide de tweets équivalent de la part de votre ami. Un thread. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
65 et 66ème rétractations pour l'IHU de Marseille.
Les 53 et 54ĆØmes pour Didier Raoult.
Absence d'autorisation Ʃthique ou recyclage d'autorisation Ʃthique.
Comme d'habitude, les auteurs ne rƩpondent pas et l'universitƩ tente maladroitement de couvrir. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
"We designated Bik as a fake āscience integrity consultantā with little knowledge about academia and research integrity."
And that's when everyone realized you were protecting fraudsters and not science.
And then you went on to defend people with hundreds of concerns on their papers. And allowed death threats to be posted under your tweets (all documented) and increased harassment campaigns against sleuths.
Poke @MicrobiomDigest -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Can you spot some problems here?
Spot at least two to make a chance of winning an Emoji Award! -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Hi, @brucekriger, you have written over 100 papers in 2026 alone. How do you do it?
And citations! Look how 2026 has treated you well.Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
One would hope that smart indexing systems such as GoogleScholar were not easily fooled by all this AI written slop citing the 'author' themselves.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
And is this really a Doctoral thesis? I do not see a defense date, an acknowledgment of the supervisor/committee, or a real research institution.
www.amazon.com/UNIFIED-STRUCTURAL-THEORY-COMPLEX-SYSTEMS/⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
63 and 64th retractions for the IHU of Marseille.
51 et 52nd for Didier Raoult.
I let you guess why.
Congrats to Alexis Jacquier : At last someone agrees with on retraction ! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Spencer Greenberg š
@SpencrGreenberg
I asked Twitter if they/you could tell which of these still lifes were made by AI and which were painted by a 19th-century painter. Here's what happened... š§µ
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Les attaques des fanatiques de lāIHU avaient redoublĆ© quand notre article dans RIPR Ć©tait sorti (link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41073-023-00134-4), puis quand lāenquĆŖte de Science est parue (science.org/content/article/failure-every-level-how-scienā¦), et encore depuis aoĆ»t dernier avec lāarticle de Nature Careers (nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01920-4).
Depuis dĆ©cembre, cāĆ©tait plus calme. Mais depuis que les rĆ©tractations pleuvent Ć nouveau sur @IHU_Marseille, Ƨa recommence. On voit trĆØs clairement le contrefeu quāils essaient dāallumer Ć chaque fois.
Cāest Ć©videmment usant, et cela me fait perdre un temps prĆ©cieux Ć devoir rĆ©pondre Ć des accusations toutes plus insensĆ©es les unes que les autres. Jāen reparlerai bientĆ“t dans un nouvel article, quand jāaurai le temps de lāĆ©crire.
Ce quāil faut rappeler, cāest que ces attaques, que nous subissons tous ā tous ceux qui ont osĆ© critiquer le Ā« microbiologiste le plus cĆ©lĆØbre du monde Ā» ā ne sont que cela : des attaques destinĆ©es Ć nous dĆ©courager. Elles prennent des formes diffĆ©rentes selon les personnes : procĆØs-bĆ¢illons contre @Sonic_urticant et @AlexSamTG ; Google reviews ou Ć©quivalents contre @barribart ; plaintes stupides, toujours finalement rejetĆ©es, contre des mĆ©decins (@DrJeromeMarty, @wargonm, @fluidloading, K. Lacombe, @DgCostagliola) ; mails aux employeurs pour presque tout le monde ; diffamations en tout genre, avec des propos aussi insensĆ©s que graves, contre @LockedFab, @MathieuMolimard ou moi-mĆŖme ; menaces de mort ou de violence contre beaucoup dāentre nous ; et, Ć chaque fois, les mĆŖmes accusations sans la moindre preuve, selon lesquelles nous serions protĆ©gĆ©s par les pouvoirs en place.
La rĆ©alitĆ© est Ć©videmment tout autre : cāest justement parce que nous nāavons aucune de ces protections que cette petite dizaine dāorganisateurs se permet cela. Et nous savons, grĆ¢ce aux enquĆŖtes journalistiques et aux aveux de Stalec, que tout est coordonnĆ© par cette mĆŖme petite dizaine. Nous savons aussi que le gouvernement franƧais et ses ministres nāont jamais bougĆ© le moindre petit doigt, malgrĆ© les efforts de @BernardJomier.
Mais une chose est sĆ»re : les rĆ©tractations continuent, malgrĆ© les dizaines dāannonces affirmant que cāĆ©tait fini, que nous Ć©tions Ā« cramĆ©s Ā» et Ā« ridiculisĆ©s Ā».
Depuis deux jours, jāai reƧu plusieurs centaines dāaccusations de corruption orchestrĆ©es par @MartinZ_uncut ā qui me menace rĆ©guliĆØrement de mort, lui aussi ā et @CaptainMedical, puis relayĆ©es par les fanatiques de @IHU_Marseille, dont lāun de ses employĆ©s, le tout sur la base dāun Ā« screenshot Ā» aussi faux quāahurissant. Encore une fois, cela nāest pris au sĆ©rieux par absolument personne, et surtout pas par les universitaires qui connaissent dĆ©sormais les adeptes de lāIHU pour ce quāils sont. Mais cela reste des accusations aussi graves que mensongĆØres.
Les dĆ©s sont dĆ©jĆ jetĆ©s. La bataille est terminĆ©e. Il sāagit maintenant uniquement de sāassurer que @gouvernementFR, @EmmanuelMacron, @stephanie_rist, @Matignon et @Senat fassent leur travail en faisant condamner ceux qui propagent la dĆ©sinformation ou conduisent des Ć©tudes illĆ©gales et non Ć©thiques.
La bonne science et la bonne justice prennent du temps. Je reste confiant, et ces tentatives de contrefeu ne māimpressionnent pas.
En attendant, pour tous ceux qui suivent ce combat, je vous encourage à soutenir les cagnottes de ceux qui en ont le plus besoin, notamment pour faire face aux procès-bâillons.
LāHCQ contre le COVID est dĆ©jĆ discrĆ©ditĆ©e (nature.com/articles/d41586-024-04014-9), et tous ceux qui en ont fait la promotion le sont aussi. Le reste arrive, doucement mais sĆ»rement. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Spotting
@Spottingthespot
More proof of the fact that @ElsevierConnect & @SciTotEnv are whitewashing #papermill #fraud! One of the frauds is Mika SillanpƤƤ! Paper mill junk with bought authorship is now being whitewashed with stupid corrections! @MicrobiomDigest @Thatsregrettab1 @addictedtoigno1
Spotting
@Spottingthespot
It seems that @SciTotEnv & @ElsevierConnect have decided to completely cover up editorial #fraud! A dangerous precedent for the hundreds/thousands of paper mill papers in this journal? What's next, leprechauns and unicorns are real? J. Chen edited many papers for his friends!
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
48th #retraction for Didier Raoult - by @PLOSONE
- because the IRB approvals did not cover all regions and experiments.
PubPeer concerns raised by me in March 2021: pubpeer.com/publications/7266AE5548370F5038A5F2A5A6A5A4
Article: journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.poneā¦
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
60th retraction for the IHU of Marseille despite the efforts of Aix-Marseille University.
The 48th for Didier Raoult.
Authorization 09-022 used in 258 articles that do not cover the samples mentioned in the article. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Chemistry World
@ChemistryWorld
Meet the science sleuths: researchers who volunteer to examine research articles for signs of fraud, manipulation and fabrication.
www.chemistryworld.com/careers/how-to-be-a-science-sleuth⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
Now that I have finally been paid I made a video about the Dana-Farber legal case from my own perspective: youtu.be/ioRtnMEV46Y
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
NĆÆck Brownš»
@sTeamTraen
New blog post (it's been a while): Make Meta-Analysis Great Again.
This is a serious proposal. Please amplify to whoever might be interested, especially if they have money.
steamtraen.blogspot.com/2026/04/make-meta-analysis-great-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Author group including some with @StanfordMed supply an "original" image that substantially heightens the concerns. Authors should learn the Law of holes: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_holes
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
How to be a science sleuth:
Research integrity experts share their tips for spotting and reporting fraudulent papers
Rupali Dabas writes @ChemistryWorld
Featuring @SmutClyde, @deevybee, @nickwizzo, Jack Wilkinson, Anna Pendlebury, and me.
Chemistry World
@ChemistryWorld
Meet the science sleuths: researchers who volunteer to examine research articles for signs of fraud, manipulation and fabrication.
www.chemistryworld.com/careers/how-to-be-a-science-sleuth⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Court records suggest Dr. Hazan fired her medical writer shortly after concerns about her now-retracted study, "Microbiome-Based Hypothesis on Ivermectinās Mechanism in COVID-19: Ivermectin Feeds Bifidobacteria to Boost Immunity," were raised. šø
A suit followed. From the claim: -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jonathan Eisen
@phylogenomics
WTF?
Spotting
@Spottingthespot
Hey @SciReports is this some sort of joke?? @TimKersjes @SpringerNature please act ASAP. This is an abomination! šHow the hell did this ever pass peer review, editorial processes???
doi.org/10.1038/s41598-025-18302-5 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
I wonder what WED is up to...
Oh, my. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
If youāre in the Boston area, please join me on April 16 for my talk about the tragedy of fraudulent or false Alzheimerās research ā and the response to my book āDoctored.ā Talk and reception sponsored by MIT Knight Science Journalism. ksj.mit.edu/event/lecture-investigating-fraud-arrogance-aā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
Cervical cancer is PLUMMETING in young women in the US šŗšø
Amazing news!!
How did this happen ?
VACCINES
The HPV once specifically
Yüksel Ćrün
@DrYukselUrun
Cervical cancer incidence is declining sharply among young women aged 15ā29 in the United States.
This is what population-level HPV vaccination impact looks like.
ā ļøThe data is unambiguous, yet vaccine hesitancy persists, often immune to evidence itself. People didn't see the cancers that didn't happen.
@JNCI_Now @theNCI #hpv #vaccine @OncoAlert -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
My desk this week ā¤ļø
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Some eye candy from the Bik family ā¤ļø
@AartBik
1986 Ferrari 328 GTS youtube.com/shorts/Huj-fsOsY18 via @YouTube -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
Complete crap here from your HHS Secretary
The HPV vaccine (Gardasil) is so effective it is on the way to ELIMINATING cervical cancer!
RFK Jr is an anti vaccine fanatic who would rather your daughter got cervical cancer than a vaccine
HorribleThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Three and a half years to retract this āransom noteā figure.
āThe authors disagree with the retraction.ā
pubpeer.com/publications/E67D58189E6083CE099FCF37535A6A h/t anon Hoya for posting the retraction. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
NĆÆck Brownš»
@sTeamTraen
It gets worst. Here is a picture of @MicrobiomDigest with me. Not sure her reputation can recover from this.
ScienceGuardians
@SciGuardians
šØ We have exposed two paid agents riddled with serious commercial conflicts of interest:
Elisabeth M. Bik (the fake āscience integrity consultantā) and Kaveh Bazargan (aka Illex illecebrosus on the compromised PubPeer).
They actively collude with fellow PubPeer "PubSmear" Network Mob perpetrators to target and pull down selected papers and scientists ā while shielding their own.
š¢ At 12:00 PM ET on April 3, 2026, we will expose them further.
Let this sink in...
#elisabethbik #pubpeerscandal #pubsmear #breaking #news #sciencefraud #sciencehypocrisy #imageforensics
@SciGuardiansš± -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Years of talking about exposing people and you still havenāt exposed anyone or anything but your mediocrity.
Stop using chatGPT, get a job, or an education. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
And still too afraid to tag me.
-
ScienceGuardians
@SciGuardians
šØ We have exposed two paid agents riddled with serious commercial conflicts of interest:
Elisabeth M. Bik (the fake āscience integrity consultantā) and Kaveh Bazargan (aka Illex illecebrosus on the compromised PubPeer).
They actively collude with fellow PubPeer "PubSmear" Network Mob perpetrators to target and pull down selected papers and scientists ā while shielding their own.
š¢ At 12:00 PM ET on April 3, 2026, we will expose them further.
Let this sink in...
#elisabethbik #pubpeerscandal #pubsmear #breaking #news #sciencefraud #sciencehypocrisy #imageforensics
@SciGuardiansš±Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
And still too afraid to tag me.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Brad Roth
@roth_brad92519
Happy National Science Appreciation Day! It is celebrated on March 26 to honor the day the results of the first polio vaccine were released. I give special thanks to climate scientists and vaccine scientists. Goodness knows they need appreciation. THANK YOU!!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
David Juurlink
@DavidJuurlink
Have you heard about young people dying suddenly after COVID-19 vaccination?
Our new study in @PLOSMedicine shows there's absolutely nothing to that. If anything, the opposite is true.
With @husam247 and @DrJeffKwong
journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Bill Chopik
@Chops310
Every morning, I wake up and read the obituaries. If my name isnāt in there, I have breakfast. Then, I complete yet another university-mandated training of some sort. This has been my life for 17 years.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof Jeffrey S Morris
@jsm2334
š® Another population-level study finds no evidence whatsoever of that healthy younger individuals given COVID-19 vaccines had increased risk of "dying suddenly", i.e. with sudden cardiac deaths.
Researchers in Toronto just published a study in PLOS Medicine assessing whether risk of sudden cardiac death was increased after COVID-19 vaccination in healthy young people 12-50yrs old.
The study was a population-based matched case-control study from a cohort of 14,966,193 residents of Ontario, Canada, focusing on the subset of 6,365,451 who were <50yrs and "healthy", with no medical history of cardiovascular disease, cancer, diabetes, mental illness, dementia, COPD, IBD, chronic liver or kidney disease, autoimmune disease, or alcohol or illicit drug use.
Cases included 4,803 individuals from that cohort who "died suddenly" between April 1, 2021 and June 30, 2023, meaning they either died outside the hospital or died in ER or within 24hr of admission with indication of cardiac arrest, sudden death or arrhythmia but no indication of trauma, mental illness or substance use.
Controls included 24,030 individuals matched 5:1 to cases in terms of age, sex, geographic area, and neighborhood income quintile, with their index data set to death date of matched case. After matching, all of these variables were well-balanced between cases and controls.
The primary analysis was a conditional logistic regression to assess association of case/control status with vaccination status (any vaccine), with covariate-adjustment for confounders including COVID-19 infection, influenza vaccination, number of SARS-CoV-2 PCR tests to estimate COVID healthcare utilization, and history of asthma, hypertension and mood/anxiety disorders.
Many sensitivity analyses were done including separate analyses for vaccine types, focusing on the 6wk period after vaccination, focusing only on ER/hospital deaths with cause well-documented, excluding any opioid deaths, focusing on <=40yrs old, plus a secondary self-controlled case series comparing the 6wk after doses 1/2/3 to other time periods to perform an assessment free from any subject-level residual confounders such as healthcare utilization or other factors related to healthy vaccinee effect.
In the primary analysis, 77.1% of controls received any COVID-19 vaccine before the index date, while only 67.4% of cases did, which resulted in an adjusted odds ratio of 0.57 (95% CI 0.53-0.61), suggesting a 43% reduced risk of sudden death in the vaccinated group.
All secondary analyses found similar results, with vaccinated having lower risk of sudden death than unvaccinated, with some statistically significant and some not. None of the analyses had any indication whatsoever that risk of sudden death was increased after vaccination, either in the short or long term.
This validates results from two earlier UK studies using self-controlled case series that found no increased risk of sudden cardiac death within 4wks (Nafilyan et al. 2023 Nature Communications PMID: 36973247) or 12wks (Xu et al. 2024 Vaccine PMID: 38388239) after COVID-19 vaccination.
So, in spite of all of the repeated claims on social media and in videos purporting major increased risk in sudden cardiac death after COVID-19 vaccination, the population-level data continue to strongly refute these claims. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
The Lancet
@TheLancet
RetractionāToday, we retract an unsigned 1977 commentary suggesting talc powder containing asbestos was not harmful. The Lancet was informed that the author had undisclosed competing interests and breached publication ethics. /4
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sholto David
@addictedtoigno1
Last week I shared this collage showing a massive case of image fraud from a Japanese team, now I have written a blog with more detailed findings! Enjoy: forbetterscience.com/2026/03/24/perfect-blots/
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I wrote a perspective for Anesthesia & Analgesia -
"Seeing Is Believing? Scientific Misconduct and the Detection of Problematic Images"
Still trying to make it Open Access. Fingers crossed!
journals.lww.com/anesthesia-analgesia/citation/9900/seein⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
These medical X-rays are all deepfakes ā and they fool even radiologists Radiologists and large language models alike have a hard time picking out real medical images from fake ones.
@jenna_ahart writes for @nature News.
With a quote by me.
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-00892-3 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Giving a talk this morning at the @UVA for a class called "Forum in Ethical and Inclusive Science"
Will be an interesting discussion! -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I will be giving a @BitesizeBio Webinar on Monday March 23 (5 pm UK time / 1 pm ET / 10 am PT).
Title: "How to Find Errors and Misconduct in Biomedical Papers".
Topics: sleuthing, @pubpeer.com, @cosig.net
Register here: events.bitesizebio.com/how-to-find-errors-and-misconduct-ā¦
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Starting in 30 min!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Simon Maechling
@simonmaechling
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
58th retraction for the IHU of Marseille. Still for lack of ethics approval.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
58ème rétractation pour l'IHU de Marseille. Toujours pour absence d'autorisation éthique.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
And what are your ethical guidelines with respect to online harassment?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"Research integrity is locked into an arms race with agentic AI slop."
blogs.lse.ac.uk/impactofsocialsciences/2026/03/17/researc⦠-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
And what are your ethical guidelines with respect to online harassment?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Kirk Maxey, Flyover Guy
@KirkMMaxey
@MicrobiomDigest liked! š®š„¹Ok. I can die now. Since it is very technical, I will write a layperson summary of this paper. Big powerful Harvard lab has been publishing for years some very sketchy stuff about the metabolites of DHA. (A fish oil omega-3) Me, my ex, (yes, if you are a nice man you can still do research with your ex) other big players in the field and a much smaller lab in Cardiff, Wales work for maybe 10 years, and we publish this paper saying, "Those F'ing things aren't even there - they are an artifact of your measurement method" But we said it much more politely than that.
Kirk Maxey, Flyover Guy
@KirkMMaxey
My publisher sent me a note today saying my recent paper published! š¤š¤ I'm going to try posting the link here so each time I get called a moron on this site I can link to it. www.plefa.com/article/S0952-3278(26)00009-8/fulltext
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Are you accusing us of being criminals, Dr. Kruse? What is our crime?
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Are you accusing us of being criminals, Dr. Kruse? What is our crime?
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
GenAI: not only a huge problem in science, but also for news rooms. Fake news all around.
Cascade of A.I. Fakes About War With Iran Causes Chaos Online
By Stuart A. Thompson and Alexander Cardia @nytimes.com
#giftlink
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/03/14/business/media/ira⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Former Mount Sinai postdoc falsified images in grant updates, ORI says.
retractionwatch.com/2026/03/11/ori-mount-sinai-postdoc-ch⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
As The Guardian reports on Retsef Levi today, it is worth recalling that our preprint already documents why the Levi et al. paper raises serious concerns.
Preprint: osf.io/preprints/osf/zj4xr_v1
Guardian Link: www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/mar/10/rfk-jr-pick-revieā¦
Poke @MicrobiomDigest @GidMK @PeterHotez -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Van Wijck
@JJvanWijck
En een derde is slecht in breuken...
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Ian Weissman, DO
@DrIanWeissman
The professor who has been appointed to review the safety of Covid-19 vaccines has failed to meet basic scientific standards in his own research on the topic, according to more than a dozen scientists and public health experts.
www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/mar/10/rfk-jr-pick-revie⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
triplekon
@Navaraaa
they censor me
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Why would a private person who donates to science hand over their emails to an anonymous troll?
Is there an "or else"? Sounds a lot like blackmail and harassment. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Why would a private person who donates to science hand over their emails to an anonymous troll?
Is there an "or else"? Sounds a lot like blackmail and harassment. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Finished AJCR's 2023 volume. Found about 76 papers with concerning images, only using ImageTwin (w/o looking for anything else). The editorial board (including @weldeiry) must be so proud.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
Name change for Cassava Sciences to Filana $SAVA to $FLNA www.filanatx.com/news-releases/news-release-details/cassa⦠reminds me of earlier name-change moments in the company's interesting history, noted in my book.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"Forensic Metascience, the GRIM test, and technology for checking papers": A conversation with James Heathers, the director of the Center for Scientific Integrity's Medical Evidence Project.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=QH87h_4dbeg
medicalevidenceproject.org -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Benjamin Mazer
@BenMazer
Here's the caption to Dr. El-Deiry's talk.
The parabolic growth of the childhood vaccine schedule and the introduction of mRNA/LNP injections in 2020 have ravaged the population with a growing number of acute and chronic diseases.
Are childhood vaccines ravaging the population?2 media couldn't be displayed. See them on the original post.
Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD, FACP
@weldeiry
You should listen to what I actually had to say instead of being critical of me or others in the way that you are.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Science Has a Major Fraud Problem
'For decades, scientists were above reproach. Not any more.
@opinion_joe investigates the murky world of fraudulent research, and the sleuths exposing dishonest science'
@TheFP
www.thefp.com/p/science-has-a-major-fraud-problem?hide_in⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sense about Science
@senseaboutsci
āWe need to know what we can trust in order to progress science.ā
Dr Elisabeth Bik (@MicrobiomDigest) talks about #publicgoodcuration and its role in supporting trustworthy research.
Discover 'The Peopleās Case for Curators' guideā”ļøsenseaboutscience.org/championing-good-information-curation/ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Meagan Phelan
@MeaganPhelan
Editors-in-Chief address tough questions facing scientific journals www.aaas.org/news/editors-chief-address-tough-questions-fā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
It would be more exciting to see enforcement of the existing laws.
Research Integrity
@HHS_ORI
Exciting news from the Office of Research Integrity! Weāre launching our 2026 co-sponsorship opportunities to support PHS-funded institutions in fostering a culture of research integrity. Learn more here: ori.hhs.gov/co-sponsorship-opportunities #ori #researchintegrity
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
Le responsable de la plus vaste étude clinique illégale jamais vue qui a mené 30 ans de recherche clinique illégale sur des SDF, qui diffame toute la communauté médicale et scientifique chez les pires complotistes antisémites continue à conserver un bureau dans un institut public
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
Voudrait-il dire que Didier Raoult serait toujours à faire régner la terreur au sein de l'IHU ? On nous aurait menti ?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mu Yang, Ph.D.
@mumumouse2
In case you missed the thread of the #stitching.
pubpeer.com/publications/4094A6F22DD57E763BE19ED867D2FB
I wrote about this more extensively on LI www.linkedin.com/posts/mu-yang-11229436_papermill-activit⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
Two more "expressions of concern" have been issued to the IHU for ethical reasons.
This brings the total to 270 articles under EoC. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
More artwork brought to you by The American Journal of Cancer Research.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sam Rosenfeld
@sam_rosenfeld
the modern professor's feeling of warm relief and gratitude at encountering artisanal, human-crafted bad writing while grading papers
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Simon Maechling
@simonmaechling
Cats teach science.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Cool, useful, project.
www.sciencedetective.org/scientific-datasets-are-riddled-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"Hey ChatGPT, write me a fictional paper: these LLMs are willing to commit academic fraud."
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-00595-9 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Joshuan J. Barboza
@joshuanbarbozam
La revista MEDICINA INTERNA DE MĆXICO podrĆa ser considerada Predatory Journal @RetractionWatch
Las razones:
1. Hay potencial conflicto de interƩs editorial y endogamia: editor publica constantemente en la misma revista y puede actuar como peer-review. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
I find it hard to be shocked by such admissions, but this one is pretty intense: A medical journal says the case reports it has published for 25 years are, in fact, fiction via @Kate_Travis retractionwatch.com/2026/03/03/canadian-pediatric-societyā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
š²šššššš š². š¼ššš
@CharlesCMann
Fallout continues from one of the most appalling cases of scientific misconduct I've come across: journal retracts 138(!) case studies as fictional. retractionwatch.com/2026/03/03/canadian-pediatric-societyā¦
New Yorker article that set off the current furor: www.newyorker.com/magazine/2026/02/02/did-a-celebrated-re⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Preprint server removes study attributing increased infant mortality to vaccines.
retractionwatch.com/2026/03/02/preprint-server-removes-st⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
I continue slowly working through one volume of AJCR (w/an Associate Editor-in-Chief in Wafik S. El-Deiry, MD, PhD). So much crap.
This one paper was so bad that I gave up before finishing (Iām only flagging images identified by @ImageTwinAI for reasons). -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Originally flagged by @MicrobiomDigest 6(!) years ago, additional issues and emails finally led to a retraction in Molecular Therapy ā Nucleic Acids (Cell Pressure).
pubpeer.com/publications/A5004902BE8FDBDD56ED6657B8B66E -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
No Context Dutch š³š±
@NoContextDutch1
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
nature
@Nature
The findings āshould act as a wake-up call to developers on how easy it is to use LLMs to produce misleading and low-quality scientific researchā
go.nature.com/4u6DOXa -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
News from Science
@NewsfromScience
Many of the scientists Jeffrey Epstein courted were already well-established and well-funded. So why didnāt they all just say no? @ScienceInsider talked with three who did just that.
Hereās how Epstein approached them, and why they refused to have anything to do with him. ā¬ļø -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
RFK Jr.'s in the news again... on the retraction side
A @RetractionWatch read.
retractionwatch.com/2026/03/02/preprint-server-removes-st⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āNo one quite like herā: meet the female colleagues who inspire these award-winning women in science
To mark International Womenās Day, Nature asked winners of its awards programmes to nominate a colleague who brings out the best in them.
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-00666-x -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
āStealth corrections are still a threat to scientific integrity.ā
deevybee.blogspot.com/2026/02/guest-post-stealth-correcti⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
News from Science
@NewsfromScience
In a challenge to open-access publishers, the Chinese Academy of Sciences, the worldās largest research institution, has told its researchers it plans to stop paying to publish their papers in dozens of international free-to-read journals it regards as too expensive.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mu Yang, Ph.D.
@mumumouse2
United One Trace
pubpeer.com/publications/6D792311BBA872CCEC679B78B632A4 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Priyam Bordoloi
@DocPriyamMD
I am genuinely sick of seeing this nonsense. If you didnāt pass basic physiology, please, just shut the f up about optimizing your health.
Letās talk biology: Vitamin C and B-complex vitamins are water-soluble... the second you shove 25 grams of C into your veins, your kidneys start working overtime to flush it out. You arenāt 'loading your system'; you are literally paying to produce the most expensive urine on the planet...!
And donāt get me started on the NAD+ IVs. Itās an expensive biochemical fairy tale. NAD+ is a large, fragile molecule. It gets chewed up by enzymes in your bloodstream long before it ever touches a cell membrane, let alone enters the cell to 'recharge' your mitochondria.
It makes me so angry because itās not just a harmless trend, itās a grift that prays on people who don't know the difference between a real medical intervention and a wellness scam. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Hi @SciGuardians
Do you think it's ok that someone who shares a lot of your nonsensical conspiracy theories and random diagrams calls for cleaning organizations "with an axe"??
Just as a reminder, he (@MartinZ_uncut) has defended and worked with @xazalbert who hosted an article on his blog calling for the beheading of scientists and doctors....
Source:
- www.lefigaro.fr/actualite-france/la-veuve-s-impatiente-unā¦
- www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2021/09/04/france-soir-auā¦
He has also defended the studies and scientists that you defend, the ones working at @IHU_Marseille who have hosted two sexual abusers (one currently in jail) and employs another scientist known for his bullying online.
Sources:
- www.laprovence.com/article/region/42710852634387/une-nouv⦠(ongoing trial for sexual abuse)
- www.cgtetat.fr/fonction-publique-163/vie-des-ministeres-e⦠(done trial, researcher sent to jail)
- www.timeshighereducation.com/news/french-professor-free-h⦠(one researcher's bullying documented)
Finally, he has already called for extreme violence against journalists in Belgium and myself in multiple tweets and posts.
Sources:
- death threats against journalists: x.com/lonnibesancon/status/1973634508986654879
- threats (death, harassment, etc...) against me from Martin #zizigate x.com/lonnibesancon/status/1961853373587525986
Finally, I'd like to remind you that your tweets dear @SciGuardians have led to my harassment and me receiving death threats from some of your followers. I have notified you of this multiple times, both publicly and by DMs, and you have NEVER taken any action for this (see: x.com/lonnibesancon/status/1973628670599180593). All of that happened also after you tried to "convince me" to join your journal club, which, when I denied, led to you attacking me.
So instead of pretending to defend science dear @SciGuardians you should perhaps first make sure that you don't defend criminals and felons, or enable them don't you think?
Martin Zizi
@MartinZ_uncut
It is the right move.. give A chance to clean up.. the n all bets will be off!
If they doit themselves, it may be surgical, if others come to do it, .. it will be done with an axe!
Share and support Scein e Guardians, we need to rejuvenate OUR scientific peer review, and claw it back from these conflicted and lyssenkist personas! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
"Scammer-imposed deadlines (e.g., "pay in 1 hour or lose your account") are fake, designed to trigger panic and bypass your critical thinking. Do not meet their deadline, respond, or pay."
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
"Scammer-imposed deadlines (e.g., "pay in 1 hour or lose your account") are fake, designed to trigger panic and bypass your critical thinking. Do not meet their deadline, respond, or pay."
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I will be on a panel tonight at The Slop Conference, discussing "The Expertise Crisis: When Credentials Mean Nothing" - panel starts in 2 hours (Feb 26 at 9 pm PST / Feb 27 10:30 AM - 12:00 PM IST)
(Apologies for the late notice!)
slopconference.com -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
Another EoC for the IHU, still at Wiley
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
2 more expressions of concern for the IHU by Wiley.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
'Heart researcher asked to attend remedial training after OSU misconduct finding'
āitās pretty odd that theyāre saying we have concerns about this personās commitment to fundamental integrity and so we think he ought to get management and logistics help.ā
retractionwatch.com/2026/02/25/heart-researcher-asked-to-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
nature
@Nature
Science sleuths share their common-sense tips for sniffing out fishy articles
go.nature.com/3Mx3viV -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Meet the university in India that tallied 161 retractions in 2025.
timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/chennai/161-research-art⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
New research integrity technical term coined by @MicrobiomDigest: āPaper mill hairball.ā, e.g., āWhere every paper that overlaps with another paper will lead to more papers with overlaps.ā pubpeer.com/publications/348B65C2EAB3CDB84DA67717304B81 šø
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
In this episode of the Under Review podcast, I talk to @Andy_Tattersall about research fraud detection, papermills, and that rat.
open.spotify.com/episode/0pYDzHGTKXWMUyRxz2vG58 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
āāRetract papers based on flawed citations,ā urges integrity tsar.ā
www.timeshighereducation.com/news/retract-papers-based-fl⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
bajdichcatalysis
@bajdichcatalyst
Dear @ACSPublications Big miles stone reached, can I get a small recognition please?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
New "expression of concern" for the IHU for ethical reasons in the "Journal of Medical Virology" for a study during the Covid period.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
#imageforensics - can you spot something wrong? Tell me or show me for you chance of winning an Emoji Award.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Thanks @LockedFab for the incredible work scrutinizing these shameful publications from @IHU_Marseille.
Three years ago, we raised concerns about 456 publications (link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41073-023-00134-4). There are now many more, and already 60 have been retracted. An absolute disgrace for French research ā and the new EoCs confirm that the new leadership at @IHU_Marseille has changed nothing. Absolutely nothing.
This French research scandal made headlines in @ScienceMagazine, @Nature, and @guardian. Yet @IHU_Marseille keeps training students while seemingly unable to conduct ethical research.
www.science.org/content/article/failure-every-level-how-sā¦
www.science.org/content/article/unearthed-university-inveā¦
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-04014-9
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01920-4
www.theguardian.com/world/2023/aug/09/french-research-cenā¦
Add to this the online harassment reportedly carried out by several @IHU_Marseille researchers (per @timeshighered):
āEric Chabriereās attacks against critics of hydroxychloroquine are seen as a sign of the social-media-induced radicalisation that has occurred during the pandemicā
And cases of harassment and sexual assault (one researcher already convicted). Why is this institute still open?
www.timeshighereducation.com/news/french-professor-free-hā¦
www.laprovence.com/article/region/42710852634387/une-nouvā¦
www.leparisien.fr/faits-divers/marseille-un-chercheur-de-ā¦
The conspiracy-loving account @SciGuardians, quick to defend quacks, is notably silent about defending convicted harassers and researchers disregarding ethics.
Even worse, the French government (@EmmanuelMacron @sup_recherche @stephanie_rist @FrenchResponse @Sante_Gouv @Senat) seems unconcerned that students are still being trained there ā in an institute where scandals now seem more numerous than publications, many already tainted by misconduct.
(Ping: @MicrobiomDigest @barriere_dr @emma_ducros @angie_rasmussen @TroncheBiais @StevePascolo @Cobra_FX_)
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Merci @LockedFab pour ton travail incroyable Ć analyser ces publications honteuses de @IHU_Marseille.
Il y a trois ans, nous exprimions des doutes sur 456 publications (link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s41073-023-00134-4). Depuis, il y en a bien plus, et dĆ©jĆ 60 ont Ć©tĆ© rĆ©tractĆ©es. Une honte absolue pour la recherche franƧaise ā et les nouvelles EoC confirment que la nouvelle direction de @IHU_Marseille ne change rien. Absolument rien.
Ce scandale de la recherche franƧaise a fait les gros titres de @ScienceMagazine, @Nature et @guardian. Pourtant, @IHU_Marseille continue de former des Ć©tudiants alors quāils semblent incapables de mener une recherche Ć©thique.
www.science.org/content/article/failure-every-level-how-sā¦
www.science.org/content/article/unearthed-university-inveā¦
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-04014-9
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01920-4
www.theguardian.com/world/2023/aug/09/french-research-cenā¦
Ajoutons Ć cela le harcĆØlement en ligne mis en place, selon @timeshighered, par plusieurs chercheurs de @IHU_Marseille :
āFrench professor free to harass hydroxychloroquine critics online. Eric Chabriereās attacks against critics of hydroxychloroquine are seen as a sign of the social-media-induced radicalisation that has occurred during the pandemicā
Sans oublier des affaires de harcĆØlement et dāagressions sexuelles (un chercheur dĆ©jĆ condamnĆ©). Pourquoi cet institut est-il toujours ouvert ?
www.timeshighereducation.com/news/french-professor-free-hā¦
www.laprovence.com/article/region/42710852634387/une-nouvā¦
www.leparisien.fr/faits-divers/marseille-un-chercheur-de-ā¦
Le compte @SciGuardians, prompt Ć inventer des complots et dĆ©fendre des charlatans, reste bien silencieux sur le fait quāil dĆ©fend aussi des harceleurs, des agresseurs condamnĆ©s et des chercheurs mĆ©prisant lāĆ©thique.
Pire encore, le gouvernement franƧais (@EmmanuelMacron @sup_recherche @stephanie_rist @FrenchResponse @Sante_Gouv @Senat) ne semble pas inquiet que des Ć©tudiants continuent dāĆŖtre formĆ©s dans cet institut, où les scandales semblent dĆ©sormais plus nombreux que les publications ā pourtant dĆ©jĆ entachĆ©es de fraude.
(Poke : @MicrobiomDigest @barriere_dr @emma_ducros @angie_rasmussen @TroncheBiais @StevePascolo @Cobra_FX_) -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
Another "expression of concern" for the IHU and Didier Raoult today.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
There's a social network map floating around X that someone created that lists roughly 100 people including 13 people as a close friend, including Laura and me. Epstein is also listed as a close friend of the creator. An anonymous X account is implying that means Epstein and I were close friends.
To set the record perfectly straight: neither Laura nor I ever met or spoke with Epstein. Ever.
The X account that makes this claim has repeatedly slandered me over the past year. I'm sure he will continue to do so. He won't stop our work. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Dear ScienceGuardians,
Twelve degrees of separation and a cluttered infographic do not equal āclose friends.ā
But sure, draw enough lines, and everyone becomes guilty by geometry.
Hereās a network for you: -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jarod - vidƩaste en herbe, en chair et en nonoss
@Apres_Reflexion
I've made a tremendous discovery. The brain is the only thing that isn't connected in conspiracy theorists.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr Terry Simpson
@drterrysimpson
I have never seen as much misinformation and disinformation as I have in the antivax community. They lie, they ignore, they deceive. When you counter they raise ad hominem. There is a combination of willful dishonesty and total incompetence- and their lies and arrogance leads to body bags. They donāt care
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Dear ScienceGuardians,
Twelve degrees of separation and a cluttered infographic do not equal āclose friends.ā
But sure, draw enough lines, and everyone becomes guilty by geometry.
Hereās a network for you: -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Another #retraction for former National Institute on Aging division director Eliezer Masliah today.
link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12974-026-03741-2
pubpeer.com/publications/98358E389674174C8D3248393FB9C2
Combined work by @mumumouse2, @Thatsregrettab1, @schrag_matthew, @cpiller, and me.
See: www.science.org/content/article/research-misconduct-findi⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
13 new "expressions of concern" for articles from the IHU.
12 published between 2016 et 2024 in Microbiology Open and one published in 2024 in Journal of Medical Virology.
The change of direction appears to have had no effect. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Emily Trunnell PhD š
@ERoseEngland
⨠New Article: #aaasmtg Highlights! āØ
@aaas is where science and policy meet, and this yearās Science @ Scale theme brought big ideas from across the research landscape. From climate and public health to biomedical innovation, it was inspiring to step outside our usual orbitāand even convert a few particle physicists into organāonāchip fans.
This year, we saw real momentum for nonāanimal, humanārelevant science. SAOās Gabby Vidaurre, PhD delivered a standout Postdoc Talk on our Research Modernization NOW #scipol roadmap, and AIādriven innovations took center stageāfrom lungāultrasound interpretation to exposome analytics.
The SNAP Coalition made AAAS history with the firstāever graduate studentāled plenary, and scienceāintegrity icon @MicrobiomDigest reminded us why integrity is essential to all of what we do.
ā¬ļø Read the full recap, also featuring @AnimaAnandkumar of @CaltechEAS, @ThomasHartung19 of @jhucaat, and researchers from @ASU, @asuhealth, and @tue_mech:
www.linkedin.com/pulse/sao-action-highlights-from-2026-aa⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Oncotarget having server problems again. Some PDFs cannot be retrieved.
Cue the retweet from the tech-challenged EiC that they are suffering a cyber attack. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Every paper that I download from @Oncotarget is now called "download.pdf". Was working fine a couple of weeks ago, with downloads numbered as in their DOI. But now I have "download.pdf" to "download(39).pdf" to analyze š±
-
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Oncotarget having server problems again. Some PDFs cannot be retrieved.
Cue the retweet from the tech-challenged EiC that they are suffering a cyber attack.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Every paper that I download from @Oncotarget is now called "download.pdf". Was working fine a couple of weeks ago, with downloads numbered as in their DOI. But now I have "download.pdf" to "download(39).pdf" to analyze š±
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Andrew Akbashev
@Andrew_Akbashev
A really dangerous situation. Too many submissions. Too many generated papers. Little responsibility.
1. In 2026, more than 24,000 submissions were made to the International Conference on Machine Learning (ICML). Itās TWO times more than in 2025. To fight it, the organizers now require researchers to pay $100 for every subsequent paper.
2. LLM adoption has increased researcher productivity by 90% (thereās a recent paper in Science).
3. The number of papers is becoming far too high. Submissions to arXiv have risen by 50% since 2022.
4. There are simply not enough reviewers. Plus, many scientists no longer want to invest precious time in it for free.
5. We canāt easily identify AI-made papers from the genuine ones.
__
Important words from Paul Ginsparg, a co-founder of arXiv:
āAI slop frequently canāt be discriminated just by looking at abstract, or even by just skimming full text. This makes it an āexistential threatā to the system.ā
Basically, weāre getting closer to the tipping point.
š Many professors blame the AI.
But the problem is likely elsewhere:
1. Without a sufficient number of papers, many PIs canāt get funded. They have to prove their credibility to reviewers. Their proposals have to rely on prior publications. In many countries, there are some informal (or even formal) expectations for how many papers a group with a certain size has to publish to survive (funding-wise).
2. Our students / postdocs need papers if they want to be hired in faculty roles. Yes, some departments hire people with few publications. But the majority still want to ensure their faculty can get funded. If funding is partly a function of papers, this is used in decision-making.
3. The number of papers is important if you want to get high-level awards. Many of them are not given because you published one paper (even if itās great). They are given because you made a meaningful CONTRIBUTION to the field. How do you make it? Publish more papers.
4. Tenure promotions in many places take the number of your papers into account (often indirectly). Your tenure may get delayed if you donāt publish enough. Not everywhere, but for many mid- to low-ranked universities this story is more or less the same.
+ There are many more to mention.
šMy opinion:
Much of this is rooted in how funding is distributed.
There is a strong correlation between the requirements at a university and the funding acquisition criteria.
If funding were based ONLY on the quality of published papers, universities would hire people for the quality of their science. If funding agencies strongly discouraged publishing too many papers, universities wouldnāt expect numbers from faculty during promotions. And some supervisors wouldnāt pressure students and postdocs to publish unfinished studies and low-quality data.
Yes, we need good detectors of fake papers.
But we also need the right policies and better funding allocation criteria. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Publishing with Integrity
@fake_journals
I see many adverts on my Facebook feed that says that it will make your AI generated text undetectable as such.
The fact I see so many of these adverts (and the images show a small sample, collected over an hour, or so, of scrolling), I suspect, means that this is a profitable business?
Do we have any idea:
šµ How many people are using these services?
šµ What are they used for?
šµ Do the authors declare that they used such a service?
šµ If approached, would the service providers, acknowledge that a given piece of work was helped by the services? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
nature
@Nature
It has never been easier to create fake or low-quality papers, and other AI slop
go.nature.com/40dhMEu -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
For all of you relying on AI for advice.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Nature journal retracts two papers by immunology researchers for image duplication.
retractionwatch.com/2026/02/16/nature-immunology-retracts⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
LenaSun
@bylenasun
NEW: RFK Jr. Kennedyās comments about the keto diet illustrate the contradiction between the extremely high bar the health secretary sets for evidence of vaccine efficacy and the low bar for nutritional advice. ā¦@FenitNā© www.washingtonpost.com/health/2026/02/17/keto-diet-schizoā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Publishing with Integrity
@fake_journals
An analysis of PubPeer comments on highly-cited retracted articles | @deevybee | deevybee.blogspot.com/2026/02/the-role-of-pubpeer-in-retrā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
A Nature journal has retracted a decades-old immunology paper that has been cited more than 1,000 times and, the author claims, spurred the development of new drugs.
retractionwatch.com/2026/02/16/nature-immunology-retracts⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
It is hilarious how you keep on trying to connect everything to me - without tagging me, and without any success. You seem to be absolutely frightened of me. Your attempts at defamation are pathetic and futile. I will not stop flagging erroneous or fraudulent papers.
#aaasmtg -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Thanks to all who contributed. And kudos to PLOS and their experts for investigating.
pubpeer.com/publications/80EF60CF10E18730C011AD1BC6C0D0 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Spotting
@Spottingthespot
Well well, @MicrobiomDigest & @Thatsregrettab1 what do you think of this 'correction'? With this type of BS there is no point to report issues. @ElsevierConnect I am supposed to believe this crap? Seriously.... One of the authors is the former EIC doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2026.128884
Spotting
@Spottingthespot
I wonder what image experts such as @MicrobiomDigest, @kaveh1000 and @Thatsregrettab1 have to say about these images. I smell something rotten.... I found at least 4 most likely manipulated issues.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
The retraction of the 2010 āarsenic lifeā paper tells a story āof the transformation of the methods used to correct science.ā
retractionwatch.com/2025/07/24/science-retraction-arsenicā¦
peerj.com/articles/20502/ -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āA Chinese researcher quoted in a 2024 study argued that an āinhumaneā ā harsh and unrealistic ā demand for research productivity essentially made academic misconduct a necessityā
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
āDonāt Trust the Rankings That Put Chinaās Universities on Top.ā
www.nytimes.com/2026/02/11/opinion/america-china-universi⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
CrƩmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
I keep my PubPeer comments anonymous now because I once found some authors had hardcoded a value in their code (i.e., I caught them just straight-up doing fraud) and when I contacted the editor, he dismissed the complaint because
"Aren't you racist?" -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
LogarithmicDis š¦šŗšøšØš¦ā·ļøš¬šØ
@LogarithmicDis
@SciGuardians = the discredited authors cry-group that fraudulently claims a trademark while supporting frauds is still at it - trying to tear down scientific integrity sleuths.
Nothing new. š„± -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
It is hilarious how you keep on trying to connect everything to me - without tagging me, and without any success. You seem to be absolutely frightened of me. Your attempts at defamation are pathetic and futile. I will not stop flagging erroneous or fraudulent papers.
#aaasmtg -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Publishing with Integrity
@fake_journals
Prolific editors who publish in their own publications deevybee.blogspot.com/2020/08/pepiops-prolific-editors-whā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof. Katharine Hayhoe
@KHayhoe
Bluesky is the new science Twitter: new study concludes
For the past decade, Twitter has been a primary home of scientists on social media. In recent years, new leadership at Twitter has made substantive changes that have resulted in increases in the prevalence of pseudoscience, conspiracy theory, and harassment on the platform, causing many scientists to seek alternatives. [including me]
Survey results overwhelmingly confirm that changes to Twitter have made the social media platform no longer professionally useful or pleasant, and that many scientists have abandoned it in favor of Bluesky.
Results show that for every reported professional benefit that scientists once gained from Twitter, scientists can now gain that benefit more effectively on Bluesky than on Twitter.
academic.oup.com/icb/article-abstract/65/3/538/8196180?lo⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Publishing with Integrity
@fake_journals
This is a worrying development (or perhaps it has been going on for years). Paper mills are targeting publicly available datasets as an easy way to generate papers that can be sold, used for citation manipulations; and all the other things that paper mill papers are used for.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Happy 2nd Anniversary - for those who celebrate!
www.frontiersin.org/journals/cell-and-developmental-biolo⦠(the article download button doesn't seem to work... hmm). -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Michael Mindrum, MD
@MichaelMindrum
Oh no! @JohnSpeakman4 account has been hacked I think. This is the third person that has sent me a similar message. Donāt open these emails! I suspect opening the link leads to you losing access to your account.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Follow me on Bsky for some live posting from the @aaas Annual Meeting in Phoenix, AZ.
#aaasmtg
meetings.aaas.org -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Could it perhaps mean that it was a poorly executed paper that only could find a home in Oncotarget?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sense about Science
@senseaboutsci
Tomorrow, we will be hosting a panel at the 2026 AAAS Annual Meeting in Phoenix. Our associate Leonor Sierra, will be joined by Michael Meth, Elisabeth Bik, and Rodrigo PƩrez Ortega.
@aaas @MicrobiomDigest @rpocisv -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
UnEDXpected Peaks - new and fascinating data explorations from @MicrobiomDigest scienceintegritydigest.com/2026/02/09/unedxpected-peaks/
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Could it perhaps mean that it was a poorly executed paper that only could find a home in Oncotarget?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
More vague insinuations and conspiracy theories?
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
More vague insinuations and conspiracy theories?
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Too chicken to tag me, huh? š
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Too chicken to tag me, huh? š
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Senior administrator @BrownMedicine confirms he is under investigation and pleads for help from U.S. officials to suppress free speech.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Flying tomorrow to attend the @aaas Annual Meeting in Phoenix, AZ.
Find me:
* Friday at 10 am at the Sci-mic Stage
* Friday at 2:30 pm in West 106-A for panel discussion "Curators on the Front Lines of the Information Wars" with Michael Meth and Rodrigo PƩrez Ortega
#aaasmtg
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
In a @Waymo (self driving taxi) to our hotel.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
New blog post: UnEDXpected Peaks
Thanks to Reese Richardson, who taught me how to catch problems in Energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy - see COSIG guide here: osf.io/2kdez/files/shfjy
30+ papers from a group from Pakistan with wonky EDX plots. Read more:
scienceintegritydigest.com/2026/02/09/unedxpected-peaks/ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Absolutely -an anonymous group of disgruntled scientists has been launching all kinds of conspiracy theories featuring me. Whole Reddit posts, YouTube videos, trashing my Wikipedia page, writing emails to collaborators that I am a fraud....
Fun times. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Absolutely -an anonymous group of disgruntled scientists has been launching all kinds of conspiracy theories featuring me. Whole Reddit posts, YouTube videos, trashing my Wikipedia page, writing emails to collaborators that I am a fraud....
Fun times. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Il y a trois ans, je critiquais le travail très mauvais de C. Stabell Benn et Peter Aaby sur les vaccins COVID et leurs hypothèses délirantes sur les NSEs (voir: doi.org/10.1016/j.isci.2025.114513)
Maintenant, le scandal les rattrape et ils sont dans Science: www.science.org/content/article/controversial-danish-vaccā¦
Je parlais de ces problĆØmes dĆ©jĆ pour @LePoint ici: www.lepoint.fr/science/quand-des-methodes-de-recherche-coā¦
Poke @GeWoessner @barriere_dr @LeyClem @MicrobiomDigest @kevinalves83 @AlexSamTG @EricBillyFR @MacronardsFM @MacLesggy @TroncheBiais -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
LogarithmicDis š¦šŗšøšØš¦ā·ļøš¬šØ
@LogarithmicDis
This is the kind of fraud that the fake @SciGuardians want to protect.
They seek to discredit all scientific sleuths, PubPeer and Retraction Watch and paint them as a nefarious cabal when the exact opposite is true.
This is blatant fraud and again, sleuths won. š
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
U.S. ORIās first finding of 2026: Researcher faked data in grant apps.
retractionwatch.com/2026/02/06/office-research-integrity-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
U.S. ORIās first finding of 2026: Researcher faked data in grant apps.
retractionwatch.com/2026/02/06/office-research-integrity-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Is @KimiProduct the new #scigen? a paper generator that randomly generates nonsense computer science research papers, based on a single prompt?
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SCIgen
Kimi Product
@KimiProduct
One prompt = A publication-ready research paper with academic charts.
If you need pro academic formatting, latex formulas and figures, Kimi is all you need.
You can get a word file just by chatting. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Wait, are you a #papermill? This sounds very much like an advertisement for data fabrication. .
-
Kimi Product
@KimiProduct
One prompt = A publication-ready research paper with academic charts.
If you need pro academic formatting, latex formulas and figures, Kimi is all you need.
You can get a word file just by chatting.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Wait, are you a #papermill? This sounds very much like an advertisement for data fabrication. .
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
The PhD Place
@ThePhDPlace
More than half of researchers now use AI in peer review, according to Nature.
The question is whether AI can actually doanything useful in that process, or whether it just suggests adding a few emdashesā¦
So I tested it. Hereās what I found š #ad -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
Tragedy. Absolute tragedy.
Newborn baby dies of Listeria infection in New Mexico.
Contracted from the mother who got it from drinking raw milk during pregnancy.
Raw milk is NOT SAFE. *Especially * in pregnancy
Pasteurisation was invented for a damn good reason!!
NBC News
@NBCNews
Health officials in New Mexico are warning against consuming raw dairy products after a newborn baby in the state died from a listeria infection that they say was likely contracted when the baby's mother drank raw milk during pregnancy. www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/new-mexico-warns-consuming-rā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
How is a scientist sending an email to Epstein about an interesting study, proof that Epstein was seeking control of science and academia?
Another Vague Insinuation by the Vague Guardians! -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
How is a scientist sending an email to Epstein about an interesting study, proof that Epstein was seeking control of science and academia?
Another Vague Insinuation by the Vague Guardians! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
What happened here? š¤¬š±š°
Top contributor in the category "Drunk EDX plots".
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Mega-journal Heliyon retracts hundreds of papers after internal auditĀ
retractionwatch.com/2026/02/03/mega-journal-heliyon-retra⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
What happened here? š¤¬š±š°
Top contributor in the category "Drunk EDX plots".
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Owen Gregorian
@OwenGregorian
Nearly 40% of Stanford undergraduates claim theyāre disabled. Iām one of them | Elsa Johnson, The Times
In 2023, one month into my freshman year at Stanford University, an upperclassman was showing me her dorm room ā a prized single in one of the nicest buildings on campus. As she took me around her space, which included a private bathroom, a walk-in shower and a great view of Hoover Tower, she casually mentioned that she had lived in a single all four years she had attended Stanford.
I was surprised. Most people donāt get the privilege of a single room until they reach their senior year.
Thatās when my friend gave me a tip: Stanford had granted her āa disability accommodationā.
She, of course, didnāt have a disability. She knew it. I knew it. But she had figured out early what most Stanford students eventually learn: the Office of Accessible Education will give students a single room, extra time on tests and even exemptions from academic requirements if they qualify as ādisabledā.
Everyone was doing it. I could do it, too, if I just knew how to ask.
A recent article in The Atlantic reported that an increasing number of students at elite universities were claiming they had disabilities to get benefits or exemptions, which can also include copies of lecture notes, excused absences and access to private testing rooms. Those who suffer from āsocial anxietyā can even get out of participating in class discussions.
But the most common disability accommodation students ask for ā and receive ā is the best housing on campus.
At Stanford University in Palo Alto, California, where competition for the best dorm rooms is fierce, this practice is particularly rife. The Atlantic reported that 38 percent of undergraduates at my college were registered as having a disability ā thatās 2,850 students out of a class of 7,500 ā and 24 per cent of undergrads received academic or housing accommodations in the fall quarter.
At the Ivy League colleges Brown and Harvard, more than 20 per cent of undergrads are registered as disabled. Contrast these numbers with Americaās community colleges, where only 3 to 4 per cent of students receive disability accommodations. Bizarrely, the schools that boast the most academically successful students are the ones with the largest number who claim disabilities ā disabilities that youād think would deter academic success.
The truth is, the system is there to be gamed, and most students feel that if youāre not gaming it, youāre putting yourself at a disadvantage.
Thatās why I decided to claim my legitimate illness ā endometriosis ā as a disability at Stanford.
When I arrived on campus two and a half years ago, I would have assumed that special allowances were made for a small number of students who genuinely needed them. But I quickly discovered that wasnāt true. Some diagnoses are real and serious, of course, such as epilepsy, anaphylactic allergies, sleep apnea or severe physical disabilities.
But most students, in my experience, claim less severe ailments, such as ADHD or anxiety. And some ādisabilitiesā are just downright silly. Students claim ānight terrorsā; others say they āget easily distractedā or they ācanāt live with othersā. I know a guy who was granted a single room because he needs to wear contacts at night. Iāve heard of a girl who got a single because she was gluten intolerant.
Thatās why I felt justified in claiming endometriosis as a disability. It is a painful condition in which cells from the uterus grow outside the womb. Iām often doubled over in agony from the problem, for which there is no known cure, so I decided to ask for a single room in a campus dorm where I could endure those moments in private.
The application process was very easy. I registered my condition on the Stanford Office of Accessible Education website and made an appointment to meet an adviser later that week. The system is staffed largely by empathetic women who want to help students.
As I explained my diagnosis and symptoms over Zoom to one woman, she listened, nodded sympathetically, related my problems to her own life and asked a few basic questions. Within 30 minutes, I was registered as a student with a disability, entitled to more accommodations than I asked for.
In addition to a single housing assignment, I was granted extra absences from class, some late days on assignments and a 15-minute tardiness allowance for all of my classes. I was met with so little scepticism or questioning, I probably didnāt even need a doctorās note to get these exemptions. Had I been pushier, I am sure I could have received almost any accommodation I asked for.
While I feel entitled to my single room, I would feel guilty about some of the perks I have ā except that so many of my fellow students have gamed the system. Take Callie, a recent Stanford grad with ADHD and Aspergerās who agreed to be quoted under a pseudonym. Callie was diagnosed with her conditions in elementary school; in return, Stanford granted her a single room for all four years, plus extra time on tests ā and a few more perks.
āIn college, I havenāt had that many āin real lifeā tests as opposed to take-home essays,ā Callie told me. āWhen I did use the extra time, I felt guilty, because I probably didnāt deserve the accommodations, given the fact I got into Stanford and could compete at a high academic level. Extra time on tests ā some students even get double time ā seems unfair to me.ā
But at Stanford, almost no one talks about the system with shame. Rather, we openly discuss, strategise and even joke about it. At a university of savvy optimisers, the feeling is that if you arenāt getting accommodations, you havenāt tried hard enough.
Another student told me that special āaccommodations are so prevalent that they effectively only punish the honestā. Academic accommodations, they added, help āstudents get ahead ⦠which puts a huge proportion of the class on an unfair playing groundā.
The gaming even extends to our meals. Stanford requires most undergraduates living on campus to purchase a meal plan, which costs $7,944 for the 2025-26 academic year. But students can get exempted if they claim a religious dietary restriction that the college kitchens cannot accommodate.
And so, some students I know claim to be devout members of the Jain faith, which rejects any food that may cause harm to all living creatures ā including small insects and root vegetables. The students I know who claim to be Jain (but arenāt) spend their meal money at Whole Foods instead and enjoy freshly made salads and other yummy dishes, while the rest of us are stuck with college meals, like burgers made partly from āmushroom mixā.
Administrators seem powerless to reform the system and frankly donāt seem to care. How do you prove someone doesnāt have anxiety? How do you verify they donāt need extra time on a test? How do you challenge a religious dietary claim without risking a discrimination lawsuit?
I often think back to that conversation with my upperclassman friend. She wasnāt proud of gaming the system and she wasnāt ashamed either. She was simply rational. The university had created a set of incentives and she had simply responded to them.
Thatās what strikes me most about the accommodation explosion at Stanford and similar schools. The students arenāt exactly cheating and if they are, can you blame them? Stanford has made gaming the system the logical choice. When accommodations mean the difference between a cramped triple and your own room, when extra test time can boost your grade point average, opting out feels like self-sabotage. Who would make their lives harder when the easiest option is just a 30-minute Zoom call away?
www.thetimes.com/us/news-today/article/40-percent-stanfor⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
SciGuardians finds clews š¤”š
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
A researcher was apparently stirred into action after recently being discussed by Leonid.
She responded to an early 2025 post by @MicrobiomDigest stating there āwas no duplication of images or part thereof.ā Judge for yourself. š
forbetterscience.com/2026/01/27/the-minor-infractions-by-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
More unwelcome bikini photos? Or are you still a 12 year old?
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Enjoying a day off at the beach.
#halfmoonbay #pillarpoint -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
More unwelcome bikini photos? Or are you still a 12 year old?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
GibStra
@GibStra
I suggest Grok, and other image generators, embed prompts as a watermark into every generated image so we can stop arguing if images posted are real or not because it is getting dangerous when images are used as political divisiveness.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
World Conf Research Integrity
@WCRIFoundation
š¢ WCRI 2026
Early bird registration ends Feb 3.
Doctoral Forum open for PhD students.
WCRI also launches a global consultation on AI disclosure in research.
š May 3ā6, 2026 | Vancouver
š wcri2026.org
#wcri2026 #researchintegrity #phdchat #aiinresearch -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Andrew Gelman et al.
@StatModeling
Weāre looking for nominations for the American Statistical Associationās Excellence in Statistical Reporting Award.
statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2026/01/29/were-looking-fo⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āUnder attack by a pack since yesterdayā is a stretch.
You got one comment, from one person, on one paper.
You got another one two years ago, which you never replied to. -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āUnder attack by a pack since yesterdayā is a stretch.
You got one comment, from one person, on one paper.
You got another one two years ago, which you never replied to. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
triplekon
@Navaraaa
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mikiko Watanabe MD PhD
@Watanabe_MDPhD
š§ š¦ š§ š¦ Obesity is not just calories. Our review in Cell Reports Medicine links gut, diet, bariatric surgery & GLP-1 meds through the microbiome.
š doi.org/10.1016/j.xcrm.2025.102573
#obesity #microbiome #glp1 @CellPressNews @GMFHx @MicrobiomDigest @Food4Gut_Health @TheGutHealthDoc -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
In two weeks, I will be giving a talk at the @AAASmeetings in Phoenix, AZ, in the session 'Curators on the Front Lines of the Information Wars', organized by @senseaboutsci
aaas.confex.com/aaas/2026/meetingapp.cgi/Session/36582
I hope to see some of you in Phoenix! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Another kind message from an Editor-in-Charge thanking this āsleuthā for his efforts.
So different from the unfounded claims of coercion by SciGuardians, El-Deiry, Hazan, and their ilk. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
thesify.ai
@thesify_ai
AI is no excuse to produce slop. You can use it to do the opposite.
Science News
@ScienceBriefs
Resisting AI slop @ScienceMagazine
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Daniel A. Walker šØš¦šŗš¦š¬š±š»š·šš“š»
@danwalker9999
The preprint behind the El Pais article
arxiv.org/abs/2601.07563 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Matthew Herper
@matthewherper
I don't know how to ask for a moment of silence amid the madness that is X.
But please take a moment to reflect on the heroism of William Foege.
Foege, who died Saturday at 89, was a key architect of the eradication of smallpox using the vaccine. This is one of humanity's great victories over a terrible disease and a triumph of science. If you haven't, go order or download his book, "House on Fire," which chronicles that epic fight. He was head of the CDC from 1977 to 1983.
He was a towering, six-foot-seven reminder that rationality can win against scourges that have beset mankind for all of history. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Approx 2 years from documenting clear manipulation to retraction @WileyGlobal journal.
āThe authors did not respond when asked for clarification.ā
pubpeer.com/publications/5782E24512EC414D93F3521EB806CD -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
Complete crap here from your HHS Secretary
The HPV vaccine (Gardasil) is so effective it is on the way to ELIMINATING cervical cancer!
RFK Jr is an anti vaccine fanatic who would rather your daughter got cervical cancer than a vaccine
Horrible manThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Marion Koopmans, publications: https://pure.eur.nl
@MarionKoopmans
@DrJBhattacharya I will give this 1 try. I am looking at your inciting tweets with astonishment. You probably group me in the box of lock down pushers. I wonder if you ever have been in a public health crisis advisory role, hospital outbreak management team, employer health
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Kaveh Bazargan
@kaveh1000
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Reading : āAre we all plagiarists now?
The steal industry is boomingā
@TheEconomist
#giftlink
economist.com/culture/2026/01/22/are-we-all-plagiarists-n⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Four panels - but two overlap. Can you spot them?
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Thousands of scientists inflate their CVs with self-published studies that cost millions of dollars of public money
1 in 8 'special issues' is filled with articles written by the editor, particularly at the publisher MDPI
@manuelansede
english.elpais.com/science-tech/2026-01-22/thousands-of-s⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
Sometimes vaccine efficacy is subtle
Sometimes it isn't -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
A random cat
@wool_yeah
Did you know that 2025 Nature papers are not as hot as 2025 papers in... Separation and Purification Technology?
Congratulations, @ElsevierConnect - shameless fraud pays off! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Eric Dutin
@DutinEric15494
PORTRAIT : Nicolas Hulscher, ou le "Speedrun" de l'ƩpidƩmiologie (Option "Vendeur de DƩtox")
Accrochez vos ceintures et rangez votre rigueur scientifique au placard : on part à la découverte de la nouvelle star montante de la "science" alternative.
1. Profil : L'expert-minute
Nicolas Hulscher, c'est un peu le Mozart de l'ƩpidƩmiologie... si Mozart avait appris le piano sur YouTube en un week-end.
Originaire du Michigan, le gars a décroché son Master (MPH) et, avant même que l'encre ne soit sèche, s'est auto-proclamé épidémiologiste.
Dans le monde acadƩmique normal, il faut des annƩes de terrain et un doctorat pour peser. Ici ?
Juste un bon compte Twitter et les bons amis.
Le fait qui tue : Il est président d'une asso à but non lucratif ("Think It Loud Inc"). Il n'y touche pas de salaire.
Cāest beau, le bĆ©nĆ©volat. Surtout quand Ƨa sert de tremplin vers le vrai business.
2. Les Copains d'abord (et le Business Plan)
On ne rƩussit jamais seul. Nico a trouvƩ son mentor : Peter McCullough.
Si vous ne connaissez pas, imaginez un cardiologue qui a dĆ©cidĆ© que les vaccins Ć©taient le Mal absolu, mais que ā oh surprise ā les supplĆ©ments vendus par sa boite (The Wellness Company) sont le remĆØde miracle.
Hulscher est "Fellow" Ć la McCullough Foundation.
En gros : il fournit la caution "scientifique" (les graphiques qui font peur), et l'écosystème McCullough vend la solution derrière (le protocole "Spike Support" pour détoxifier des protéines imaginaires).
C'est ce qu'on appelle un mouvement perpƩtuel de l'angoisse :
1. Nico publie une Ʃtude effrayante
2. Peter dit "C'est grave !"
3. La boutique ouvre la caisse
3. Publications : "Pile je gagne, face tu perds"
C'est là que ça devient du grand art (abstrait).
L'affaire des autopsies (2024) :
Hulscher et sa bande publient un papier disant que tous les morts autopsiƩs sont "probablement" liƩs au vaccin.
⢠Méthode : "Il est mort, il était vacciné, donc c'est le vaccin."
⢠Les experts : "Heu, le monsieur avait 85 ans et trois cancers..."
⢠Nico : "C'EST LE VACCIN J'AI DIT !"
Un immunologiste a qualifié l'analyse de « ridiculement erronée ».
Le papier précédent avait même été viré des prépublications du Lancet (ce qui, en langage scientifique, équivaut à se faire sortir de boîte de nuit parce qu'on a vomi sur le bar).
4. VAERS : L'art de torturer les chiffres
Hulscher adore le VAERS (la base de données américaine où n'importe qui peut signaler un effet secondaire).
C'est une base de surveillance, pas de preuve. Si vous vous transformez en Hulk aprĆØs une dose, vous pouvez le signaler. Ća ne veut pas dire que c'est vrai.
Pour Nico, c'est du pain bƩnit.
Dans un préprint, lui et ses potes concluent à une explosion des myocardites "223 fois supérieure à la moyenne".
La rƩalitƩ ?
Ils comparent des choux, des carottes et des signalements non vérifiés. C'est comme dire que la vente de parapluies cause la pluie parce que les deux augmentent en même temps.
Dernière trouvaille (Janvier 2025) : Il affirme qu'une étude japonaise prouve l'efficace négative des vaccins.
Spoiler : Non. C'est juste qu'il a lu l'étude à l'envers ou qu'il a "oublié" les biais statistiques. Oups.
š VERDICT : Pourquoi c'est brillant (et dangereux)
Nicolas Hulscher n'est pas lĆ pour faire avancer la science. Il est lĆ pour fournir du carburant Ć un narratif.
⢠Rigueur : 2/20 (pour l'effort de mise en page).
⢠Audace : 20/20.
⢠Business Model : Imparable.
Il s'habille comme un chercheur, parle comme un chercheur, utilise des logiciels de chercheurs, mais Ć la fin, c'est surtout un formidable VRP pour l'industrie de la peur.
La prochaine fois que vous voyez un de ses graphiques rouges et noirs sur votre feed, rappelez-vous : la seule chose qu'il "dƩtoxifie", c'est votre esprit critique.
@NicHulscher -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Another expression of concern for former Stanford president Marc Tessier-Lavigne.
www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-10080-4
Four of his papers have been retracted.
retractionwatch.com/2023/08/31/stanford-president-retract⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
More post-production changes at Oncotargetās website.
Those 12/31/25 retractions seem to have been redistributed to other 2025 dates. I have some screenshots, but at this point, who cares?
www.oncotarget.com/archive/v15/ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Il y a 2 jours @EmmanuelMacron disait prƩfƩrer la science au complotisme.
Depuis 6 ans, nous combattons la dƩsinformation criminelle de @france_soir @xazalbert et des chercheurs de l'@IHU_Marseille et recevons menaces sur menaces, insultes sur insultes. Les paroles Ʃtaient belles @EmmanuelMacron @FrenchResponse mais il faut maintenant aussi des actes sur notre territoire.
Nous attendons ƩnormƩment du @gouvernementFR @Senat @sup_recherche @Sante_Gouv @stephanie_rist
Dre Fantine (& Hippocrate)
@FantineEtHippo
Macron préfère la science au complotisme ? Nous aussi.
@AlexSamTG @AgenceJetD @clementfreze @CoralieBorel @psy_massondavid @Topiramatee @LockedFab @Hugo_Baup @lonnibesancon @Margot_Brunet_ @pedrosanchau @campiche_sarah @SFalkowicz @Sonic_urticant @vinceflibustier @xvrgckThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
What is unusual about this situation is not PubPeer, its users, or the journal following COPE procedures.
The unusual part is that an Associate Dean at @BrownMedicine feels the people heās tagged here are his real āpeers.ā -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Eric Dutin
@DutinEric15494
𩺠PORTRAIT : Dr JĆ©rĆ“me BarriĆØre: lāoncologue qui soigne le cancer et āvaccin(e)ā Internet contre les intox
Si Marvel cherchait un héros crédible (pas un type en slip rouge qui arrête des trains), ils pourraient caster JérÓme Barrière @barriere_dr .
Le jour : il combat des tumeurs, gĆØre du lourd, du concret, du vital.
La nuit : il enfile sa cape numĆ©rique pour traquer les fake news mĆ©dicales qui prolifĆØrent plus vite quāun fil WhatsApp de tonton ārĆ©veille-toiā.
On pourrait le rĆ©sumer ainsi : un mĆ©decin de terrain⦠avec un pare-feu intĆ©grĆ©. š„
š QUI EST-IL ?
Dr Barrière est oncologue médical. Installé en libéral depuis 2013 à Cagnes-sur-Mer, il exerce à la Polyclinique Saint-Jean.
Et non, il nāest pas lĆ āpour trier des lentillesā : il est aussi prĆ©sident de CME (pour simplifier : une voix centrale de lāorganisation mĆ©dicale dans lāĆ©tablissement).
CĆ“tĆ© parcours, il est passĆ© par la filiĆØre universitaire et la recherche clinique : ancien chef de clinique, expĆ©rience en centre de lutte contre le cancer⦠bref, le CV du gars qui connaĆ®t la mĆ©decine autrement que via un thread ājāai lu une Ć©tudeā.
š LE CERVEAU : ACCĆS AUX SOINS & ĆQUITĆ (le sujet le moins sexy⦠et pourtant le plus important)
BarriĆØre a un truc obsessionnel : lāaccĆØs Ć©quitable aux innovations.
Il a participĆ© Ć des travaux sur lāaccĆØs aux tests gĆ©nĆ©tiques en oncologie (les fameux ātests compagnonsā, ceux qui peuvent orienter vers le bon traitement, au bon moment).
Son angle est simple : si votre chance de survie dĆ©pend de votre code postal ou de la trĆ©sorerie locale, ce nāest plus une stratĆ©gie de santé⦠cāest une roulette administrative.
Il pointe aussi lāeffet pervers du financement : quand des tests indispensables deviennent un casse-tĆŖte budgĆ©taire pour les structures prescriptrices, on fabrique mĆ©caniquement des inĆ©galitĆ©s.
Lui, il préfère fabriquer des solutions.
š LE TERRAIN : VERSION 2025 (stĆ©thoscope + mĆ©gaphone)
Fin 2025, il ne se contente pas de commenter lāactualitĆ©: il y participe.
Dans le cadre du Collectif mĆ©dical du Sud-Est, il sāinscrit dans la mobilisation contre le PLFSS et la logique de coupes/contraintes ressenties comme des attaques contre lāaccĆØs aux soins et les conditions dāexercice.
Et lĆ , on voit le personnage : pas juste un compte X qui āquote-tweetā.
Un mĆ©decin qui dit : āOK, maintenant on se lĆØve.ā
Avec lāidĆ©e centrale : Ć©viter de glisser vers une mĆ©decine Ć deux vitesses, celle où lāaccĆØs devient un produit premium.
š LāOCTOGONE NUMĆRIQUE : BarriĆØre vs les fake news
Pendant le Covid, quand certains vendaient de la poudre de perlimpinpin et des certitudes en promotion ā2 achetĆ©es = 1 cerveau offertā, BarriĆØre a occupĆ© le terrain : pĆ©dagogie, sources, explications, recadrages.
Son credo ? Un truc trĆØs simple : laisser dire, cāest laisser gagner.
Donc il vulgarise, il dĆ©monte, il explique les mĆ©canismes, les biais, la mĆ©thode scientifique⦠et parfois avec ce ton un peu ironique qui fait du bien, parce que lāobscurantisme dĆ©teste deux choses : les preuves et lāhumour.
š LāĆ©pisode Booba (janvier 2024) : quand le clash vise la science
Moment surrĆ©aliste : une intox qui circule (vaccins + Creutzfeldt-Jakob), BarriĆØre intervient, et se prend une salve dāinsultes + une vague de harcĆØlement.
Le āclashā, version 2024 : tu expliques calmement, et tu te retrouves avec une armĆ©e de comptes qui confondent āopinionā et āvirologieā.
Et là , intéressant : il ne répond pas par le drama.
Il rĆ©pond par le fond, par le collectif, par la demande de rĆ©gulation des fausses informations mĆ©dicales, parce que quand on joue avec lāabandon de soins, on ne joue pas Ć un jeu vidĆ©o : on joue avec des vies.
š LA RIPOSTE (sans les poings, avec la gravitĆ© des faits)
Barrière incarne un truc devenu rare : un médecin qui accepte de prendre des coups numériques pour défendre une idée impopulaire mais essentielle :
š en santĆ©, āchacun sa vĆ©ritĆ©ā, Ƨa finit souvent par āchacun son cercueilā.
Alors il continue, même quand ça hurle, même quand ça menace, même quand ça fatigue.
š LāHUMOUR COMME ARMURE
Il nāest pas dans la posture institutionnelle froide : il assume un style, un ton, parfois des rĆ©fĆ©rences pop culture, parfois des piques.
Parce que lāironie, cāest aussi une stratĆ©gie : Ƨa Ć©vite de se transformer en robot, et Ƨa rappelle que la science nāest pas une religion⦠cāest une mĆ©thode.
š EN RĆSUMĆ
Dr JĆ©rĆ“me BarriĆØre, cāest :
ā un oncologue qui soigne du rĆ©el,
ā un responsable mĆ©dical qui gĆØre du concret,
ā un dĆ©fenseur de lāaccĆØs aux soins,
ā et un āanti-virusā contre la dĆ©sinformation.
Un punching-ball pour complotistes ? Souvent.
Un rempart utile ? Totalement.
Et quelque part, une preuve vivante quāon peut encore faire mĆ©decine avec rigueur, courage⦠et un peu de panache.
š sfc.asso.fr/membres/barriere-jerome/
š www.ligue-cancer.net/sites/default/files/docs/acces_des_tā¦
š www.caducee.net/actualite-medicale/16699/greve-des-medeciā¦
š www.lequotidiendumedecin.fr/sante-societe/politique-de-sa⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Lawsuit fails to block retraction of paper claiming to link heart-related deaths to COVID-19 vaccines.
retractionwatch.com/2026/01/21/lawsuit-fails-to-block-ret⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Simon Maechling
@simonmaechling
Chemical-free, you say?
⢠1. Vinegar (acetic acid)
⢠2. Salt (sodium chloride)
⢠3. Boiling water (HāO)
⢠4. Baking soda (sodium bicarbonate)
⢠5. Mulch (mostly cellulose, hemicellulose, lignin)
⢠6. Rubbing alcohol (isopropyl alcohol)
House Beautiful UK
@HB
6 chemical-free homemade weed killers for your garden www.housebeautiful.com/uk/garden/plants/a26985814/homemadā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Daniƫl Lakens
@lakens
In the age of 20 minute AI papers, I realize our model of honest signaling in academic publishing will become increasingly relevant:
journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.poneā¦
More journals might adopt submission fees. If submission is costly, it will reduce dishonest paper submissions. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Waggoner Lab
@LabWaggoner
Editorial expression of concern @Cancer_Cell on
Bnip3L is induced by p53 under hypoxia, and its knockdown promotes tumor growth @weldeiry
www.cell.com/cancer-cell/fulltext/S1535-6108(26)00050-4 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Des rĆ©sultats trĆØs encourageants publiĆ©s aujourdāhui.
La même technologie à ARNm utilisée dans les vaccins contre le COVID est désormais capable de réduire de près de moitié les récidives et la mortalité liées au mélanome, en entraînant le système immunitaire à reconnaître le cancer.
Cāest pour cela que nous finanƧons la recherche et soutenons la technologie de lāARNm.
www.washingtonpost.com/health/2026/01/20/cancer-drug-mrna⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Reported to @PNASNews in Feb 2016.
Asked again in Sept 2017.
Journal replied: "The authors have provided a response, and the Editorial Board is deciding how to proceed."
They are still deciding, apparently š¦
pubpeer.com/publications/402962FE2576D12BA9107B8717E75A
#imageforensics
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This is most likely an honest error - both journal and authors have been looking the other way.
Why not quickly address this? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Thereās been no proof of censorship, only a server outage at a failing journal. Oncotarget APC revenue this year = $0.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"When science discourages correction: How publishers profit from mistakes."
theconversation.com/when-science-discourages-correction-h⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Tyler Black, MD
@tylerblack32
Go science!
In late 2023, we (some incredible colleagues and I) wrote a paper criticizing a published meta-analysis on the COVID vaccine. This month, that meta-analysis was retracted. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Kaveh Bazargan
@kaveh1000
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Ugh. Why is @SpringerNature still publishing crap like this? I am not referring to the low quality of the panels. Can you spot the actual problem?
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Almost exactly 3 years from date of report to retraction for clearly plagiarized images. @SpringerNature journal.
pubpeer.com/publications/C7EF3B7902C88E1A382A4FDF7CC6A7 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
#imageforensics
Each panel represents the liver of a differently-treated rat. Can you find the problem? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Alex Cui
@alexcdot
Okay so, we just found that over 50 papers published at @Neurips 2025 have AI hallucinations
I don't think people realize how bad the slop is right now
It's not just that researchers from @GoogleDeepMind, @Meta, @MIT, @Cambridge_Uni are using AI - they allowed LLMs to generate hallucinations in their papers and didn't notice at all.
It's insane that these made it through peer reviewš -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Yet another #ieee Paper with tortured phrases (arxiv.org/abs/2107.06751).
As I wrote in my recent essay, it is time we tackle these papers to keep our field trustworthy (doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2510.05844).
The paper is accessible here: ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/11196594
pubpeer.com/publications/4BE962DB32DC8834744A1FF5132589 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
It took almost 3 years for a @SpringerNature journal to retract this paper after I notified them. Why?
pubpeer.com/publications/D2DBBB871E9873890AC5DD39AE75E7 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof. Katharine Hayhoe
@KHayhoe
A powerful and comprehensive picture of just how thoroughly US science is being hollowed out. As I say here, āthe operation of science has been fundamentally altered. Weāre going to see the repercussions of this for years.ā
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-00091-0 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
An Editorial Expression of Concern by @Nature for one of Marc Tessier-Lavigne (former @Stanford president)'s papers.
pubpeer.com/publications/DFA165085FAB24DCDFCA6B314B3BB7
www.nature.com/articles/s41586-025-10080-4
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A new book about science misconduct:
'The Misinformation Machine: How Fraud, AI, and Greed are Corrupting Science' by James L. Powell
www.amazon.com/Misinformation-Machine-Fraud-Corrupting-Sc⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Despite @SciGuardians efforts to discredit the post publication work of volunteers, journals and publishers still express their appreciation.
pubpeer.com/publications/6851ED170164F13D1F64FE236E4EA6 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
āOncotarget outrage and the Misinformation Machine.ā
empiricallygood.substack.com/p/oncotarget-outrage-and-the⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āScience journals retract 500 papers a month. This is why it matters.
A small team of volunteers is tracking thousands of falsified studies, including cases of bribery, fraud and plagiarismā
@ivanoransky @AliceDreger write @thetimes
www.thetimes.com/uk/science/article/science-journals-retr⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
An easy #imageforensics
Can you spot the unexpected overlap?
You can do it! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You keep on rehashing the same old vague insinuations. Couldn't you find anything new? Yawn.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Science journals retract 500 papers a month. This is why it matters.
www.thetimes.com/uk/science/article/science-journals-retr⦠-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You keep on rehashing the same old vague insinuations. Couldn't you find anything new? Yawn.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD DSc(hon)
@PeterHotez
Remember the MAHA movement is a system of pseudoscience/grifting to finance wellness influencers. To push their various snake oils: supplements, unnecessary vitamins, ivermectin, or whatever they can buy in bulk to jack up the price, itās essential to denigrate actual experts
FactPost
@factpostnews
HHS Secretary RFK Jr: "This idea that you should trust the experts, a good mother doesn't do that"
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Professor suspended after Japanese university finds fishy results in sushi paper.
retractionwatch.com/2026/01/12/professor-suspended-after-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
The Lancet
@TheLancet
NEWāTaking paracetamol during pregnancy does not increase risk of autism, ADHD, or intellectual disabilities, finds most rigorous synthesis of the current evidence to date.
The research in context panel is provided below.
Read the full paper: www.thelancet.com/journals/lanogw/article/PIIS3050-5038(2⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Steven Salzberg šš
@StevenSalzberg1
Very sad news: Peer Bork, a wonderful scientist, has long been one of the leaders of our field (genomics and bioinformatics) and he was far too young to be gone. www.embl.org/news/embl-announcements/in-remembrance-of-peā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Wound healing assay by Photoshop!
Can you spot it?
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
First Officer šŗš¦ š®š± šŗšø((Space Laser Force))
@Erst_Officer
You seemed to have missed organic food.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
#imageforensics
Can you spot the unexpected overlap?
Each panel represents cells incubated with a different formulation of nanoparticles. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This has been completely debunked. No serious scientist will agree with that statement.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This has been completely debunked. No serious scientist will agree with that statement.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
"Those of us [who] care deeply about the pursuit of truth and knowledge should all be gravely concerned about the Misinformation Machine and malign actors associated with such networks."
@empiricallygood writes about an unsubstantiated DDOS attack at @Oncotarget
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"Oncotarget outrage and the Misinformation Machine."
empiricallygood.substack.com/p/oncotarget-outrage-and-the⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Seva
@SevaUT
I just finished a three-year term as an editor at an international relations journal. I began at the start of the LLM era but ended right in the middle of it. Our volume of submissions tripled and our desk reject rate rose to 75%. I have some thoughts. link below
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
The Real Truther
@thereal_truther
šØ BREAKING: American Cancer Society releases their annual cancer report for 2026!
Data includes incidence through 2022 & mortality through 2023.
The cancer mortality rate continued to decline through 2023.
Five year relative survival for all cancers is now 70%!
Still no sign of "turbo cancer" -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
When anti vaxxers say a research study is "censored" it usually turns out that it was in fact scientifically complete crap and rejected for publication
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Just wait until these š¤”s find out there are conferences where research integrity folks meet. š
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Daniel A. Walker šØš¦šŗš¦š¬š±š»š·šš“š»
@danwalker9999
We need a Netflix sleuth series starring @mumumouse2, @addictedtoigno1, @Thatsregrettab1 and @MicrobiomDigest.
I can think of a few villains⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Can you spot some problems in this figure?
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
darkl1ght3r
@Darkl1ght3r
That was a great article. Itās actually pretty telling that in response to a simple critique of your paper you felt the need to tag the FBI instead of address the specific points he raised.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Empirically Good.
@empiricallygood
Maybe you should try engaging with the legitimate criticism of your work instead of tagging the FBI?
Seems a bit crazy to me -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jonathan Laxton MD, FRCPC šØš¦šØš¦
@dr_jon_l
Apparently we are now tagging the FBI when someone writes a blog critiquing a study we've published.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
David Gorski, MD, PhD
@gorskon
I had hoped to let this cup pass, but, after a week and a half, I found that I couldnāt. An eminent oncologist and cancer researcher is back and doubling down on the unproven claim that COVID vaccines cause cancer. sciencebasedmedicine.org/and-so-2026-begins-with-a-resurrā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
How have I been harassing him? I posted comments on 38 of his papers on PubPeer. Others commented on 40 or so other papers.
A senior scientist who has published ~500 papers should be able to handle comments on 38 of them. That is not harassing. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Michael Merrifield
@AstroMikeMerri
What is valid scientifically about reusing the same image for both your experiment and your control?
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Can you spot the overlapping panels?
Musical hint: "My Heart Will Go On".....
#imageforensicsPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
How have I been harassing him? I posted comments on 38 of his papers on PubPeer. Others commented on 40 or so other papers.
A senior scientist who has published ~500 papers should be able to handle comments on 38 of them. That is not harassing. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Great piece by ā¦@gorskonā© about āeminent oncologist and cancer researcher Dr. Wafik El-Deiryā and his latest āreview article (not really a āstudyā) in which he wildly speculated about links between COVID-19 vaccines and cancerā sciencebasedmedicine.org/and-so-2026-begins-with-a-resurrā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
World Conf Research Integrity
@WCRIFoundation
A new week has begun. Register for our early bird tickets before February 3!
World Conf Research Integrity
@WCRIFoundation
šØ Registration is OPEN!
šØš¦ Join us in Vancouver for the 9th World Conference on Research Integrity (#wcri2026), May 3ā6, 2026.
š All disciplines, all career stages
š Venue: The Westin Bayshore
š Register now + book your stay: wcri2026.org/registration/ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Empirically Good.
@empiricallygood
šØFINALLY: My first real Substack article is LIVE šØ
I discuss the crazy happenings over at the journal Oncotarget and how a well-oiled misinformation machine works to distort science!
Please take a read and subscribe if you liked it! (link below) -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
While the disgruntled authors keep on threatening me with jail time, let's play another #imageforensics - an easy one.
Can you spot the duplicated panels? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Also, you make my life sound so much more exciting than it actually is!
As if I am trying to escape the authorities in some mad cop chase, instead of me just drinking coffee with a cat on my lap behind my computer at home. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Also, you make my life sound so much more exciting than it actually is!
As if I am trying to escape the authorities in some mad cop chase, instead of me just drinking coffee with a cat on my lap behind my computer at home. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
It seems lazy for @SciGuardians @weldeiry @SabinehazanMD @KevinMcCairnPhD and their followers to claim a conspiracy and ill-motives, yet none of them have actually addressed the concerns.
If you are a follower of this group, you need to step up, or just admit you are a shill. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Can you find the unexpected overlap?
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Wow! Reviewer #2 of a manuscript I submitted wrote: "There were several times while I was reading this manuscript that I wanted to give a standing ovation"
Something is off in the universe.
But I will frame this email. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The importance of BIKs in scienceā š
Endorsed by @NaturePlants š
Nature Plants
@NaturePlants
New Letter: "New alleles of Arabidopsis BIK1 reinforce its predominant role in PTI and caution interpretations of other reported functions" rdcu.be/eYiO9
Summary: be careful with legacy T-DNA mutants.
[On the importance of BIKs in science, including @MicrobiomDigest] -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
What do you mean, Dr. Rose? Telling of ... what?
Are you suggesting I should not respond to public tweets? -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
ScienceGuardians
@SciGuardians
ā ļø āActinopolyspora biskrensisā is one of the many fraudulent aliases operated by a perpetrator of the PubPeer āPubSmearā Network Mob, Kevin Patrick ā a financial advisor with ZERO academic or scientific credentials, yet responsible for a massive volume of PubPeer āPubSmearā entries and direct journal-pressure activity, including coordinating public and private pressure on journals and publishers to purchase the PubPeer Journal and Institution Dashboards.
(Evidence available at: x.com/SciGuardians/status/2002810902328787186)
The individual in question ā who is also responsible for coordinating certain financial affairs of the mob network ā works closely with the PubPeer āPubSmearā Network Mobās institutional arm, @RetractionWatch, in orchestrating smearing and defamation campaigns against targeted members of the academic community.
On 12 April 2025, during an exchange, he inadvertently admitted to using multiple identities when targeting members of the academic community. He also admitted to colluding with another malicious actor within the mob network, David Bimler ā a notoriously unaccomplished and fraudulent academic and retired faculty member at @MasseyUni, with just 800+ citations on Scopus (ID: 6603615509) across his entire career ā whom Patrick further admitted to also operating under various fake identities, including the fraudulent alias āHoya camphorifolia.ā
š Using their various fake identities, these two actors are responsible for a massive volume of entries on the compromised PubPeer āPubSmearā platform ā on the order of 50,000 out of more than 250,000 total entries as of January 2026.
š±@SciGuardians
Accountability. Integrity. Empowerment.This post is unavailable. See it on X.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
So many errors in your post, and so few facts!
It's all AI slop.
And why do you keep on tagging all these other accounts? Can't you handle criticism on your own?Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
What do you mean, Dr. Rose? Telling of ... what?
Are you suggesting I should not respond to public tweets? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
And here are both David (Smut Clyde on X/Hoya campingear on PubPeer) and Kevin (Cheshire on X/Actinosome thing-or-other on PubPeer) sharing a š», like we will again.
Together weāve posted comments on ~40,000 papers, including retraction notices to make the database more useful.
ScienceGuardians
@SciGuardians
ā ļø āActinopolyspora biskrensisā is one of the many fraudulent aliases operated by a perpetrator of the PubPeer āPubSmearā Network Mob, Kevin Patrick ā a financial advisor with ZERO academic or scientific credentials, yet responsible for a massive volume of PubPeer āPubSmearā entries and direct journal-pressure activity, including coordinating public and private pressure on journals and publishers to purchase the PubPeer Journal and Institution Dashboards.
(Evidence available at: x.com/SciGuardians/status/2002810902328787186)
The individual in question ā who is also responsible for coordinating certain financial affairs of the mob network ā works closely with the PubPeer āPubSmearā Network Mobās institutional arm, @RetractionWatch, in orchestrating smearing and defamation campaigns against targeted members of the academic community.
On 12 April 2025, during an exchange, he inadvertently admitted to using multiple identities when targeting members of the academic community. He also admitted to colluding with another malicious actor within the mob network, David Bimler ā a notoriously unaccomplished and fraudulent academic and retired faculty member at @MasseyUni, with just 800+ citations on Scopus (ID: 6603615509) across his entire career ā whom Patrick further admitted to also operating under various fake identities, including the fraudulent alias āHoya camphorifolia.ā
š Using their various fake identities, these two actors are responsible for a massive volume of entries on the compromised PubPeer āPubSmearā platform ā on the order of 50,000 out of more than 250,000 total entries as of January 2026.
š±@SciGuardians
Accountability. Integrity. Empowerment.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
So many errors in your post, and so few facts!
It's all AI slop.
And why do you keep on tagging all these other accounts? Can't you handle criticism on your own? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
My latest story: Alzheimerās drug developers accuse clinical trial sites of faking data | Science | AAAS www.science.org/content/article/alzheimer-s-drug-developeā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sense about Science
@senseaboutsci
@MicrobiomDigest reminds us that public-good curation is also understanding the relationship between integrity, curiosity and truth. Our new guide with @sage_publishing champions the role of information curators. #publicgoodcuration
Download the guide senseaboutscience.org/championing-good-information-curation/ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
Excited that a box of the paperback edition of my book, āDoctoredā just arrived. On sale everywhere on Jan 13. www.simonandschuster.com/books/Doctored/Charles-Piller/97ā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Thank you, @BBBPACK, for making a very nice portrait!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
Meningitis
Hepatitis A
Rotavirus
RSV
Some of the horrific diseases the US no longer recommends protecting against
In the name of RFK Jr's ideological anti vaccine crusade
Look -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Raising concerns about images or other data in science papers on pubpeer.com is not immoral or criminal.
It is part of normal scientific discussion.
Authors are invited to respond and share originals.
Blocking or insulting me suggests a lack of answers. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Head First Concussion
@FirstConcussion
New Episode with ā¦@MicrobiomDigestā© is now live. We discuss all things about research integrity and more! podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/headfirst-a-concussion-podcā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Retweeting a photo of me with the word "FRAUD" next to it is ... not a good look, Dr. El-Deiry. One might even consider that defamation.
Also, does your tweet mean that there has been an official institutional investigation into your work? -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Raising concerns about images or other data in science papers on pubpeer.com is not immoral or criminal.
It is part of normal scientific discussion.
Authors are invited to respond and share originals.
Blocking or insulting me suggests a lack of answers. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Another Masliah retraction.
pubpeer.com/publications/AB6B375E44A1DCDDB40632A412EDC4
cc: @mumumouse2 @MicrobiomDigest @schrag_matthew @cpiller -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Florian Krammer
@florian_krammer
BS. I am fully vaccinated. I have been in a COVID-19 vaccine phase III trial. And I am a vaccine developer.
Tom Renz
@RenzTom
The system survives on people not looking too closely. That era is over.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Vaccines Are Helping Older People More Than We Knew
Many shots seem to have āoff-targetā benefits, such as lowering the risk of dementia, studies have found.
#giftlink
www.nytimes.com/2026/01/03/health/vaccines-dementia-heart⦠-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
It is deeply disturbing that you keep on attacking me personally, instead of taking care of your 80+ papers in which we found problems.
It looks like you have no scientific answers or proofs that we are wrong.Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Retweeting a photo of me with the word "FRAUD" next to it is ... not a good look, Dr. El-Deiry. One might even consider that defamation.
Also, does your tweet mean that there has been an official institutional investigation into your work? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
It is deeply disturbing that you keep on attacking me personally, instead of taking care of your 80+ papers in which we found problems.
It looks like you have no scientific answers or proofs that we are wrong. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Oncotarget 2025 Year in Review.
Feel free to check my counts.
131 total publications in 2025
60 retractions
ā”ļø 45% were retractions ā¬ ļø -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
RealCarlSmythe šŗš¦šæ
@CarlSmytheCells
I am blocked by @weldeiry, although I have little doubt he has sock accounts.
He really shouldnāt be trying to smear my academic reputation by reposting AI slop, especially when it is HE, who over a period of years, has been found to publish numerous cloned images. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Transparent Griftbot
@obviousgrift
How, exactly, is the website being limited? it is clearly and demonstrably accessible by admins, as evidenced by the very text you're quoting, which must necessarily post-date the claimed cyberattack, and clearly shows web admins can alter the website content - or make a post.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
El-Deiry is complaining about censorship of his own 2026 papers on his own journal's website.
I'm guessing these don't show up because the person posting these didn't know how to get them to show up under the link for Vol 17 (2026): www.oncotarget.com/archive/v17/ (currently blank). -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Which brings me to the fact that people pointed out errors in one of your 2023 preprints, but you never corrected them. Why not?
pubpeer.com/publications/806AE3FDA16BAFEAF209DB88BA789F -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You do know that I did not write that article, right?
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Which brings me to the fact that people pointed out errors in one of your 2023 preprints, but you never corrected them. Why not?
pubpeer.com/publications/806AE3FDA16BAFEAF209DB88BA789F -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
"Meltdown on Aisle 5"
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Oncotarget and Wafik El-Deiry are now accusing people āassociated with PubPeerā of engaging in ācybercriminal activities?ā š¤Æ
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Still here, Jane!
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Happy New Year!
May 2026 bring you good health, happiness, and friendships. -
Jane Orrick, M.D.
@JaneOrrickMD
All Covid Vaccinated will be dead by December 31, 2025
*According to United States of America, who lead the charge to kill 95% of the World in 1994, under UN Agenda 2021.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Still here, Jane!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You do know that I did not write that article, right?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
āResponse of French research institutions to research misconduct remains inadequate,ā writes RaphaĆ«l LĆ©vy.
raphazlab.wordpress.com/2025/12/15/response-of-french-res⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"Academic journals' AI policies fail to curb the surge in AI-assisted academic writing."
www.arxiv.org/abs/2512.06705 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Happy Holidays from our neighborhood cat #buster.
May your days be filled with friends or quietness, celebrations or meditations, good home-cooked food or takeout, a good book to read and a cat on your lap. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Calling another scientist a moron is not nice, Kevin.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
My book "Doctored: Fraud, Arrogance, and Tragedy in the Quest to Cure Alzheimer's" www.simonandschuster.com/books/Doctored/Charles-Piller/97⦠tops @_TheTransmitter most-read excerpt list for 2025. www.thetransmitter.org/books/the-transmitters-most-read-nā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Publishing with Integrity
@fake_journals
Day 24: The Ethical Publishing 2025 Advent Calendar #ethicalpublishing2025
For the final day of this advent series, I want to focus on something that underpins every issue weāve explored over the past 24 days: research culture.
Most ethical challenges in publishing do not arise in isolation. They grow from environments shaped by expectations, incentives, pressures, and norms. When a culture values speed over rigour, volume over contribution, or metrics over meaning, it becomes easier for questionable practices to take hold. Likewise, when institutions celebrate high publication counts without asking how those outputs were produced, the signal is clear: quantity matters more than integrity.
Yet the opposite is also true. Supportive environments, where mentoring is valued, failures are understood, transparency is encouraged, and time is given for careful work, make ethical behaviour the natural choice. They reduce the appeal of shortcuts and strengthen every part of the scholarly ecosystem.
Improving research culture is not a simple task, and no single policy or initiative will fix everything. But small changes accumulate: clearer expectations, fairer assessment practices, better recognition of invisible academic labour, and open conversations about the realities of publishing.
Ethical publishing is not just about avoiding misconduct; itās about creating a space where good research can thrive.
Thank you to everyone who has followed this series. Iād love to hear your reflections. Which issues resonated most strongly with you, and what do you think should be our priorities as we move into 2026? -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Calling another scientist a moron is not nice, Kevin.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
Finally! Another key paper by Sylvain LesnĆ© about the purported key Alzheimerās-related protein amyloid-beta *56 is retracted. Validates findings by @Thatsregrettab1 @MicrobiomDigest @schrag_matthew et al www.science.org/doi/full/10.1126/scisignal.aal2021 See my original story www.science.org/content/article/potential-fabrication-resā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
What is criminal about raising concerns about scientific papers?
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Another lovely evening on this site.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
It is raining, but still nice to work in the yard.
#succulentsunday #succulents -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
If you think that scientists who raise concerns about other scientists' papers should be stripped of tenure and funding, you are defending errors and fraud. You are basically proposing to punish scientists for doing peer review.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Simon Maechling
@simonmaechling
Itās strange to live in a world where people think every scientist, researcher, or doctor is a shill - but an anonymous X account is telling the truth.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
"Asking politely" is a bit of a stretch, Dr. Rose.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
If you think that scientists who raise concerns about other scientists' papers should be stripped of tenure and funding, you are defending errors and fraud. You are basically proposing to punish scientists for doing peer review.
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I posted my reply on PubPeer, showing that the consent form (and the accompanying IRB approval) covered both type of samples, but Dr. Speicher is chosing to ignore that explanation.
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
"Asking politely" is a bit of a stretch, Dr. Rose.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I posted my reply on PubPeer, showing that the consent form (and the accompanying IRB approval) covered both type of samples, but Dr. Speicher is chosing to ignore that explanation.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
What is criminal about raising concerns about scientific papers?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
The Experimentalist
@theExperi
If youāre a #microbiologist, @MicrobiomDigest needs no introduction.
Weāve been following her relentless work uncovering image manipulation across publications and outspoken advocacy for stronger research scrutiny.
Check out our latest article:
www.theexperimentalist.org/sci-comm/the-truth-is-out-ther⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"How PhD students suffered under years of misconduct by Professor M."
www.utoday.nl/spotlight/76308/how-phd-candidates-suffered⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Joyeux anniversaire à la rétractation de la plus grosse étude frauduleuse sur le COVID-19. Celle de @IHU_Marseille dirigé par @raoult_didier sur l'HCQ (cf: www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0040595723⦠& link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12874-021-01304-y).
On rappelle que @EmmanuelMacron @Senat @sup_recherche @Sante_Gouv @stephanie_rist @PhBaptiste @VidalFrederique @olivierveran n'ont rien fait pour faciliter la rétractation, malgré des preuves flagrantes des problèmes et des raccourcis douteux. On rappelle que @IHU_Marseille cumule aujourd'hui plus de 50 rétractations pour des problèmes d'études non éthiques et potentiellement illégales. On rappelle que des milliers de chercheurs ont alerté sur ces sujets, et que des dizaines de journalistes français et internationaux ont couverts les problèmes de @IHU_Marseille et de ses chercheurs. Ci dessous, un rappel de la couverture médiatique, de la plus récente à la plus vieille, qui n'a pourtant pas poussé le gouvernement à agir.
On commence avec la couverture de la rƩtractation par les deux plus gros journaux scientifiques: @Nature et @ScienceMagazine car c'est dans le plus gros du sujet:
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-04014-9
www.science.org/content/article/infamous-paper-popularizeā¦
On rajoute à ça, cette année, par @Nature et @NatureCareers la couverture du combat que j'ai mené en tant que jeune chercheur contre ces pratiques plus que douteuses et le harcèlement que j'ai subi à cause de ça de la part de certains employés de @IHU_Marseille: www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01920-4
1/n -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Publishing with Integrity
@fake_journals
Day 15: The Ethical Publishing 2025 Advent Calendar #ethicalpublishing2025
Todayās topic is fake conferences, an issue that sits alongside predatory journals but often receives far less attention.
Fake or predatory conferences are events that give the appearance of academic legitimacy; professional websites, glossy brochures, long lists of themes, but they lack the substance of real scholarly gatherings. They often promise rapid acceptance, minimal review, and the opportunity to present in an international venue. In reality, they may offer little more than a rented hotel room and a certificate.
The risk goes beyond wasted travel budgets. These events can mislead early-career researchers, create false expectations of academic engagement, and dilute the value of genuine conferences where dialogue and critique are central. They also contribute to a broader ecosystem where questionable academic activity becomes normalised.
Some signs are easy to miss. Overly broad themes, unclear organising committees, unrealistic acceptance timelines, or a suspicious number of co-located conferences run by the same operator can all be red flags.
As with journals, due diligence matters: checking who is behind the event, where past conferences were held, and whether the academic community recognises the organisers.
Good conferences create space for genuine exchange. Fake ones trade on the appearance of prestige without delivering the substance.
Iād be interested to hear what you think. Have you seen examples of conferences that didnāt quite match the expectations set by their publicity? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
This preprint cites Grok as a source? Really?
I donāt know any serious journal that would publish this paper, and many/most editors wouldnāt even send it for peer review. No doubt some bottom feeder will take the authorās money though.
Steve Massey
@stevenemassey
2/ A preprint describing the analysis has been 'on hold' for almost 3 weeks at arxiv, in another case of suppression of 'alert' reports.
In the meantime, a copy can be found here:
zenodo.org/records/17923282 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
#imageforensics
Can you spot an unexpected overlap?
A and D are control rats; B and C are treated rats. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
How is a releasing an interview for Nature News solving a piece of the EiC of Science Magazine puzzle???
You are swerving really deep into the conspiracy theory lane here.
Are you (with your āintensive training in scientific publishing ā) confusing the two journals ? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Publishing with Integrity
@fake_journals
Is it right to make serious accusations from an anonymous account?
As some of you may know, I flew under the radar for a few years but eventually lifted the cloak of anonymity and, to be honest, it's been okay. I get the occasional issue but generally (I like to believe) I post publicly available information, ask questions and make it apparent when I give my opinion. This, I hope, provides some confidence that I am acting professionally to those reading my posts
It has also enabled me to post on other platforms (notably LinkedIn) where remaining anonymous is not so easy. I am now reaching the point where my LinkedIn profile is probably more 'influential' than my X account (in terms of impressions, followers and interaction), so that has been a positive about being more open about who I am.
The point is, being open about who is posting has, in my case, been a generally positive experience.
There is a huge discussion (let's call it that) going on at the moment where one party is accusing other parties of acting unethically. The party making the accusations say that they are against 'unchecked anonymity', yet they are themselves anonymous.
I don't want to name the party involved, as they wish to be anonymous, and I will respect that. Also this post is not really about them, but a more general point about anonymity.
My questions to you are:
1ļøā£ Would those trying to make a difference be better off being open about who they are, or can they operate (even more) effectively from behind a cloak of secrecy?
2ļøā£ Is fair for an anonymous account to make accusations (in this case serious accusations) against other parties when those parties do not know who is making the accusations against them and the right of reply is, by definition, 'muted' as you don't really know who you are responding to? -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
#imageforensics - can you spot the overlap?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Where is the corruption, Dr. Hazan? This seem to be genuine interview questions from a reporter for the news section of a scientific journal, which usually is editorially independent from the scientific part.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mushtaq Bilal, PhD
@MushtaqBilalPhD
Tech Bro's Sense of Smell: A Short Story in Three Acts
Act I
A woman posts a photo holding her English PhD thesis on the politics of smell (or the relationship between smell and power).
Tech bros left, right, and center troll her, trash her. Thousands of hateful, sexist comments.
This is a complete and utter waste of time and effort and money; literary studies is a fake academic field, they say.
Who even needs yet another PhD in English, they ask.
Act II
A white tech bro sees a photo of a hackathon with a bunch of young Indian men in the foreground.
"imagine the smell," he comments.
Indian tech bros criticize him. This is racist, they say.
We wash ourselves with water after pooping unlike you folks who use dry toilet paper. It's you who smells, they say.
They ask the white tech bro to apologize.
White tech bro says, this is a harmless joke, all hackathons smell. He says, he will not apologize, and asks others to be charitable with him.
Indian tech bros start leaving 1 star reviews for the app the company the white tech bro works at.
Act III
The white tech bros' boss is an Indian tech bro.
The Indian boss fires the white tech bro.
Epilogue
Now do you see how complex the relationship between smell and power is. That's why smart folks at top universities spend years trying to understand and explain this relationship. -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Where is the corruption, Dr. Hazan? This seem to be genuine interview questions from a reporter for the news section of a scientific journal, which usually is editorially independent from the scientific part.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Theo Baker
@tab_delete
āBakerās book, subtitled āAn Education in Power at Stanford University,ā is due out May 19, about a month before the author earns his college diploma ā on time ā in June.ā
www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/toppled-stanford-pres⦠-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
How is a releasing an interview for Nature News solving a piece of the EiC of Science Magazine puzzle???
You are swerving really deep into the conspiracy theory lane here.
Are you (with your āintensive training in scientific publishing ā) confusing the two journals ? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Kaveh Bazargan
@kaveh1000
did a quick animation: youtu.be/9H58hb2wGNI
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Science sleuths raise concerns about scores of bioengineering papers
Prominent bioengineer Ali Khademhosseini has so far corrected more than 40 of the papers in question, but critics say some should have been retracted.
@dangaristo writes @Nature
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-03870-3 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Peter Lorentzen
@peterlorentzen
Just got an email offering $25,000 "donation" to accept a PhD student with the stipulation that I can keep the quid pro quo confidential. The email and the organization's website report that its board includes faculty from @USCMarshall and @teppercmu. @chronicle may be interested in this innovative approach?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
There are plenty of PubPeer entries of my work, so critique of my work has not been censored (as it shouldnāt be). You guys just write crappy AI-generated slop without actual scientific content, that donāt pass moderation.
-
ScienceGuardians
@SciGuardians
šØBOMBSHELL SCIENCE INTEGRITY SCANDAL ā 17 NOV 2025
Elisabeth M. Bik ā the fake āscience integrity consultantā who brags about >10,000 PubPeer comments ā has spent years stalking, smearing, and destroying careers of researchers she targets.
But dare post a single critical comment on HER papers or her inner-circle mob?
100 % CENSORED.
17 of her and her collaboratorsā papers flagged ā 17 comments instantly blocked.
One slipped through on 23 Nov 2024 ā ERASED after exactly 10 days (3 Dec 2024).
The queen of PubSmear just got caught rigging the game to protect herself and her network.
9-minute total exposure with screenshots, DOIs, and receipts just dropped.
Watch it. Spread it. The mask is shattered.
#elisabethbik #pubpeerscandal #pubsmear #breaking #news #sciencefraud #sciencehypocrisy #imageforensics
@SciGuardians š±This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
There are plenty of PubPeer entries of my work, so critique of my work has not been censored (as it shouldnāt be). You guys just write crappy AI-generated slop without actual scientific content, that donāt pass moderation.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Can you spot at least three unexpected overlapping panels? (There are more!)
#imageforensics #researchintegrity #academia -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Guillaume Limousinšš“
@Sonic_urticant
Ma relaxe intƩgrale est confirmƩe par la Cour d'Appel.
Il n'est donc pas diffamatoire d'affirmer que beaucoup de publications scientifiques de Didier RAOULT n'ont pas le niveau brevet des collĆØges.
Va-t-il risquer le pourvoi en cassation?
Ce soir: rƩcit de l'audience...
RT SVPš½
Guillaume Limousinšš“
@Sonic_urticant
š„š£[THREAD-ANNONCE]
1/
Mon procĆØs en appel contre Didier Raoult
aura lieu le 17 septembre
Ć Aix-en-Provence.
J'ai gagnĆ© en 1ĆØre instance: lexpress.fr/sciences-sante/guillaume-limousin-le-petit-prā¦
Mais il insiste pour tenter de m'épuiser financièrement
pots.lydia.me/collect/38985-pour-sonic/fr
Voici les enjeux.
RT, appelez à RT⬠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mathieu
@miniapeur
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
Publish it
Submit it for review
Let's see the data. Scans, bloodwork, clinical outcomes.
You're claiming an unlikely, highly dubious miracle cure
Show it to us! -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Thank you so much @unibern, Prof. Dr. Katie Peichel, and Dean Prof. Dr. Jean-Louis Reymond for awarding me an honorary doctorate for my work on #researchintegrity.
Congrats to the other recipients as well.
What a wonderful ceremony!
www.unibe.ch/university/u...
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Correct link: www.unibe.ch/university/university_for_everyone/dies_acadā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
India Research Watch (IRW)
@IRWatchdog
Our founder was part of Nature's 10 people who shaped Science in 2025. We thank @MiryamNaddaf and @Nature for recognizing our work.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Also, are you, Dr. Rose, sure about your five "post-secondary degrees"?
Always amazed by people with three degrees and two postdocs who round up to five degrees. Bold move! -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Also, are you, Dr. Rose, sure about your five "post-secondary degrees"?
Always amazed by people with three degrees and two postdocs who round up to five degrees. Bold move! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
In an alternate reality @JesslovesMJK complains when @MicrobiomDigest refers to her as "middle author" as is this is unusual. She says "Marschalek" referred to her the same way (presumably meaning Rafal Marszalek).
There are 3 authors and she's *literally* the middle author. š¤¦āāļø -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
nature
@Nature
Susan Monarez was fired after less than a month as Director of the CDC for holding the line on scientific integrity
She is part of Nature's 10 - our list of people who shaped science in 2025
go.nature.com/48pMcZ9 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Alice In Stars (she/her)
@transkittyalice
"Six of our studies in Flat Earth Journal found that the Earth is EXTREMELY FLAT!"
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof Francine Marques
@FZMarques
ā New preprint alert, led by final year PhD student @DinakisEvany
š Read it here: www.medrxiv.org/content/10.64898/2025.12.02.25341510v1
𧬠Key insights: Gut microbiome composition and colonic pH are linked to systemic immune profiles in humans
@Jo0Donnell @sjturn -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Simon Maechling
@simonmaechling
The collapse of trust in science is going to go down in history as one of the most sad, bizarre, and destructive social contagions of modern times.
We cured diseases, fed billions, and powered nations - and people ran toward conspiracies instead. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Samuel Hume
@DrSamuelBHume
This is genius: edit gut bacteria so they express a set of genes that lets them break down oxalate (which can form kidney stones)
This worked in a small human trial, reducing oxalate levels without disturbing the rest of the gut microbiome -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Carolyn Barber, MD
@cbarbermd
šØ NEW: One of the largest COVID-19 vaccine studies ever (28 MILLION people in France) just dropped.
Results?
⢠74% lower risk of death from severe COVID-19
⢠25% lower risk of all-cause mortality
⢠No increase in 4-year mortality
⢠Vaccinated people had lower risk of death from any cause.
In short: mRNA vaccines werenāt just safe ā they were protective across the board. š„š -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD DSc(hon)
@PeterHotez
Today is a dark day for American science and biomedicine. My comments in ā¦@nytimesā© www.nytimes.com/2025/12/05/health/kennedy-vaccine-committā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This afternoon, I will give a public lecture about #researchintegrity and #imageforensics, at the @UniBern, where I will receive an honorary doctorate from the Faculty of Science.
Thank you for your support ā¤ļø -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
The case of the fake references in an ethics journal.
retractionwatch.com/2025/12/02/fake-references-chatgpt-jo⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr Susan Oliver (PhD)
@DrSusanOliver1
Sorry antivaxxers. COVID-19 mRNA Vaccination and 4-Year All-Cause Mortality Among Adults 18-59 shows you're better off being vaccinated. jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2842305
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
Een wetenschappelijk tijdschrift zet een streep door een invloedrijke 25 jaar oude overzichtsstudie die concludeerde dat de veelgebruikte onkruidverdelger glyfosaat niet kankerverwekkend zou zijn.
Voor @volkskrant
www.volkskrant.nl/wetenschap/vakblad-trekt-toonaangevende⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jake Scott, MD
@jakescottMD
12 former FDA commissioners from both parties just went on the record calling Vinay Prasadās vaccine framework a threat to public health. They bring more than 3 decades of leadership at the agency, and it is hard to think of a more forceful warning. š§µ
www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMp2517497 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
An advent calendar by Anna Abalkina, the creator of our Hijacked Journal Checker, that gives you a chance to spot issues in academic publishing.
retractionwatch.com/the-retraction-watch-hijacked-journalā¦
papermills.tilda.ws/advent2025 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Katie Guzzetta š»
@ktguzz
Very nice talk today by @MicrobiomDigest at @ETH_BSSE on image manipulation in scientific research. It was jarring to hear that some journals overlook clear issues with publications, even for more than a decade, allowing falsified, non-reproducible research to remain published.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Good morning from Basel, where I will give a talk, a workshop, and meet with students, staff, and faculty at BSS at ETH Zürich (in Basel!).
#researchintegrity
#imageforensics
#science -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āI respect both sides of many colleagues disputes and I humbly await for their relationships to repair.ā
š§ -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āI respect both sides of many colleagues disputes and I humbly await for their relationships to repair.ā
š§ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
It's the time of year for reminiscing.
Me? I'm thinking back to when @SabinehazanMD said she'd try to put people who disagree with her "in jail."
Her threat was deleted but happily someone took a screenshot (see link): pubpeer.com/publications/1B61D1CC7C51BC30924A32DFB38C25 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"The fall of a prolific science journal exposes the billion-dollar profits of scientific publishing."
english.elpais.com/science-tech/2025-11-28/the-fall-of-a-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Catharine
@DrCatharineY
Wow! New research suggests the shingles vaccine may cut dementia risk by ~20% and might even slow progression for those already diagnosed.
If confirmed, a safe, widely-available shot could be one of our best tools yet in the fight against brain decline. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Or you could just post it on a preprint server? This seems weirdly convoluted.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Last month, our paper on "Sneaked References" (asistdl.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/asi.24896) obtained the best paper award from JASIST. We donated the award money to @microbiomdigest's fund for research integrity (@retractionwatch).
The press release is here: www.asist.org/2025/08/13/sneaked-references-fabricated-re⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Good morning from the train riding along the Lake of Neuchâtel, where I will give a talk and a workshop at the University of Neuchâtel. Hope to see some of you there!
#researchintegrity #academia #train -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Well, I did not see it, and you claimed it was there.
If you cannot find it either, perhaps it is not my reading skills that are lacking. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Ardemis Boghossian
@ArdemisPrime
Swiss academics -- Missed the amazing talk (and Q&A) today by @MicrobiomDigest @unil in #lausanne? You can still catch her at her #neuchatel, #bern, and #basel talks this week!
#swisstour2025 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mu Yang, Ph.D.
@mumumouse2
Masliah retraction. DOI 10.1002/acn3.321
I never understand the reason to make this sort of clones. What does it even do? -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Or you could just post it on a preprint server? This seems weirdly convoluted.
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Still resorting to insults, instead of using scientific arguments?
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Did not see that in the thread. Where is it?
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Well, I did not see it, and you claimed it was there.
If you cannot find it either, perhaps it is not my reading skills that are lacking. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Did not see that in the thread. Where is it?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Still resorting to insults, instead of using scientific arguments?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD DSc(hon)
@PeterHotez
My @BakerInstitute article on the historical basis of MAHA pseudoscience, its nefarious intent to crush U.S. medical schools, biomed journals, NIH. Theyāve already begun the process with govt agencies, beginning with CDC, it look as though CBER FDA is next
www.bakerinstitute.org/research/reaffirming-scientific-me⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Spotting
@Spottingthespot
8 (!!) years after the problems were put on Pubpeer this paper finally got retracted! š It's just not ok how long it takes to get rid of bad/fake research! Publishers and @C0PE need to wake up. Too much power with the ones that wrote the papers.
pubpeer.com/publications/7498FDBB72BD4657DF6DD2D0EE61DC -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I will be giving several talks this coming week at universities in Switzerland: Lausanne, Neuchâtel, Basel, and Bern. Hope to see some of you there!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Kareem Carr, Ph.D.
@kareem_carr
This is a real figure taken from a research article in a Nature journal. This is insane.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
MAHA achievements so far
- Measles is back
-Whooping cough is back
-One type of food colouring in one brand of breakfast cereal has been changed -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Catharine
@DrCatharineY
Australia just recorded zero cervical cancer cases in women under 25 - for the first time since records began in 1982.
This is what happens when a country commits to HPV vaccination and screening. We protect our girls and save lives. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Still here!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Ralph Isberg
@IsbergRalph
"After having published 500 papers in a 15 year period, I am shocked at the way investigators will do anything to pad their CV."
-
Theodore Dusablon
@dusabl1
š REMINDER - Covid Vaxxed will die within 2 years of receiving the injection
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Still here!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
This paper seems to present very weak evidence that the authors use to try to show an associative relationship. When questioned about these tenuous connections, and contradictory references cited in the paper, the authors reply: āletās do a podcast!?ā
This isnāt a cage match. 𤔠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āpushing to retractā are big words - @Thatsregrettab1 asked some questions about the interpretation of the data, since only one autistic person was included, with confounding factors. Happy to discuss on PubPeer, rather than in a podcast.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āpushing to retractā are big words - @Thatsregrettab1 asked some questions about the interpretation of the data, since only one autistic person was included, with confounding factors. Happy to discuss on PubPeer, rather than in a podcast.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Behind every insult might be low-confidence, bullying, and fear.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Four years! This crap should be retracted in four seconds.
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
After 4 years, the @WileyGlobal journal Macromolecular Symposia retracted this "paper."
pubpeer.com/publications/C2B9445E9B285C3229BA4008887FED h/t anon Hoya. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Oopsies.
A 2024(!) travesty of a paper courtesy of @ElsevierConnect's Translational Oncology journal and researchers in China.
pubpeer.com/publications/7493F0A7149C616C6521967ED72608 -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Behind every insult might be low-confidence, bullying, and fear.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Isn't doxxing also not poor practice, Kevin?
-
Kevin McKernan
@Kevin_McKernan
Hey @ellie_kincaid , This is poor journalism.
You left the ID of your anon "Reviewer" in the PDF document you sent us.
Were you too lazy to see this person has BioNtech Funding? Maybe that explains why they don't understand we used 500-1000X excess RNase A?
Get a helmet. Stepping on this many rakes can do some damage.
anandamide.substack.com/p/retraction-watch-steps-on-another
@SenRonJohnson @weldeiry @RetsefL @DrJBhattacharya @MartyMakary @KUPERWASSERLAB @RWMaloneMD @RobertKennedyJr @JesslovesMJK @DJSpeicher
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Isn't doxxing also not poor practice, Kevin?
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Back in New Zealand after two back-to-back conferences, for a couple of days of vacation at the Coromandel peninsula, before we head back home. Lovely bed and breakfast with amazing view.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Marion Koopmans, publications: https://pure.eur.nl
@MarionKoopmans
De publikatie waarover het artikel in de @volkskrant gaat over data fraude in wetenschappelijke literatuur. Tijd voor image analyse toetsen als onderdeel van een plagiaatscan? pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12574824/
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
Een zeer fijne bespreking in Trouw:
"Sloppy Science is een verbijsterend boek over academische fraudeurs, rommelaars en charlatans. En over keiharde competitie, die wel tot wetenschappelijk wangedrag móét leiden."
www.trouw.nl/boeken/de-ontspoorde-academische-wereld-werk⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
ScienceGuardians, Ghosts of Integrity
A group of anonymous activists has been working for nearly a year to
follow, or even legally threaten, detectives of scientific integrity.
Chronicles of an invisible war.
@LucileVeissier at TheMetaNews
themeta.news/les-scienceg... -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Simon Maechling
@simonmaechling
Hi, actual scientist here š
Science doesnāt work by proving a negative.
You donāt prove unicorns donāt exist.
You look for evidence they do and if none shows up, you move on.
And hereās what weāve found after decades of research:
Millions of children.
Dozens of studies.
Multiple countries.
Same result every time:
No causal link between vaccines and autism
Thatās not uncertainty.
Thatās overwhelming evidence.
Saying āwell you canāt rule it out completelyā isnāt science.
Itās appeal to ignorance - pretending ānot disprovenā is the same as āpossible.ā
If we accepted that logic, weād have to fear:
š§Ŗ Organic broccoli causing autism
šŗ Television causing autism.
š¦ Clouds causing autism.
Because nobody has āruled them outā either.
Science isnāt about imagining risks.
Itās about measuring them and vaccines have been measured more than almost anything else in medicine.
So letās be clear:
š Vaccines have evidence.
ā The autism claim has none. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Michael č±ę³ Eisen
@mbeisen
Newly minted female PhDs who did incredible doctoral research becoming high-profile and highly effective research advocates because dumb ass right-wing trolls made fun of their thesis topic is my new favorite thing.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
La Colombe Rose
@la_colombe_rose
Dumb et Dumber.
Le duo de comiques est de retourĀ dans:
« C'est nous, con est les gentils ».
Mes moineaux, @idrissaberkane et @raoult_didier nous servent encore le roman où Elisabeth Bik @MicrobiomDigest, serait une harceleuse payée, uBiome une preuve cosmique et PubPeer son jouet secret. Avec une preuve en béton, la dame aurait été vu dans Vanity Fair ! Et alors, elle au moins, n'a pas écumé tous les bas-fonds de Youtube pour faire sa promo !
Pour eux cette vieille Bik a tous les défauts !
Mais dans les faits, aucune condamnation, aucune preuve, juste des images dupliquĆ©es et des nerfs qui lĆ¢chent. Quand la Ā« vraie science Ā» doit inventer des complots pour survivre, cāest quāelle nāavait pas beaucoup de science au dĆ©part.
Allez au boulot ! DƩbunkons ces scientifiques d'occasion !
- Ā« Elisabeth Bik nāest pas une traqueuse de fraudes hĆ©roĆÆque. Ā»
Mes moineaux⦠quand des dizaines de revues scientifiques, de Nature Ć Science, lāinvitent pour traquer les manipulations, on appelle Ƨa une experte. Pas une figurine Marvel.
ā « C'est une activiste obsessionnelle, militante dāun scientisme dogmatique⦠»
Traduction : elle a repĆ©rĆ© des images copiĆ©es-collĆ©es dans des articles. Quand on ne peut pas contester les faits, on psychologise. Cāest classique.
ā « ⦠qui fait de la destruction des chercheurs indĆ©pendants son fonds de commerce. Ā»
Elle ne dĆ©truit personne : elle vĆ©rifie des figures dāarticles. Si ta carriĆØre tient Ć un copier-coller de western blot, ce nāest pas Bik le problĆØme.
ā « Raoult et ChabriĆØre la dĆ©crivent comme une harceleuse pathologique⦠»
Oui, comme tout chercheur critiquĆ©. Les fraudeurs dāOxford faisaient pareil. Quand tu montres les anomalies, tu deviens automatiquement « harceleurĀ Ā».
ā « ⦠payĆ©e pour salir ceux qui contredisent le discours dominant. Ā»
Patreon = conspiration mondiale maintenant ?
Donc tous les youtubers sont agents secrets dāune cabale scientiste ? Mes chĆ©ris, un peu de sĆ©rieux.
ā « France Soir a Ć©tĆ© le seul mĆ©dia Ć documenter⦠»
Si France Soir est ton āseul mĆ©dia fiableā, cāest que tu as perdu la garde partagĆ©e avec la rĆ©alitĆ©. šŗ
ā « 800Ā commentaires PubPeer en quelques mois Ā»
Oui, elle a travaillĆ©.Ce nāest pas du harcĆØlement, cāest de la vĆ©rification post-publication. Ća sāappelle⦠la science.
ā « ⦠sur des dĆ©tails microscopiques Ā»
Les ādĆ©tails microscopiquesā sont justement⦠les images microscopiques. Dans un labo, cāest un peu ce quāon regarde, en fait.
ā « Raoult et ChabriĆØre ont dĆ©montrĆ© que ces anomalies Ć©taient sans consĆ©quence Ā»
Aucune revue internationale ne les a suivis.
Et certaines publications ont ƩtƩ corrigƩes ou retirƩes.
Donc la dƩmonstration, mes pigeonneaux, on la cherche encore.
ā « Certains jeunes chercheurs ont abandonnĆ© la science Ā»
Cāest terrible, mais rien ne prouve que ce soit liĆ© Ć Bik.
Par contre, bosser dans un labo dirigĆ© par Raoult, Ƨa a gĆ©nĆ©rĆ© trois rapports de lāANSM, Ƨa oui.
ā « Raoult a dĆ©posĆ© plainte dĆØs 2021Ā Ā»
Oui. Et aprĆØsĀ ? DĆ©poser plainte ne prouve rien. Aucune condamnation. Aucune suite. Quatre ans plus tard, toujours rien. Lāacharnement judiciaire est une stratĆ©gie, pas une preuve. Rappelons qu'il n'a jamais gagnĆ© aucun procĆØsĀ !
Et paf souvenir : Le spécialiste de l'IHU de Marseille a porté plainte pour diffamation contre Jean-Paul Stahl, professeur de maladies infectieuses au CHU Grenoble-Alpes. Didier Raoult n'a particulièrement pas apprécié les termes utilisés par Jean-Paul Stahl dans une émission de télé. Celui-ci l'a notamment accusé de proférer des "fadaises" et d'avoir "bidonné" son étude sur l'hydroxychloroquine.
Le tribunal a relaxé Jean-Paul Stahl, estimant que ses propos relevaient du « jugement de valeur sur la qualité de travaux scientifiques » et faisaient partie du débat public. Raoult a été condamnée à verser 1 000 ⬠à Stahl au titre des frais de justice.
ā « Elle rĆ©clamait de lāargent pour corriger les articles Ā»
Non. Elle propose des services de consulting comme tous les experts. Tu peux noter les anomalies gratuitement sur PubPeer, ou payer pour une analyse dāintĆ©gritĆ© complĆØte. Cāest littĆ©ralement son mĆ©tier.
ā « Les dossiers sont lourds [ā¦] stress post-traumatique Ā»
Quand tu mĆ©langes critiques scientifiques, plaintes, Ć©motions et certificats : Ƨa sāappelle un storytelling judiciaire, pas des preuves.
ā « uBiome, raid du FBI, stock-options⦠»
Elle a quittƩ uBiome AVANT le scandale.
Elle nāa jamais Ć©tĆ© mise en cause par le FBI.
Mais certains adorent crier : āElle travaillait lĆ , donc elle savait tout !ā
Cāest mignon, cette croyance que tout employĆ© connaĆ®t les magouilles du CEO.
ā « Personne ne lāa crue Ā»
Si, tout le monde, sauf ceux qui avaient dĆ©jĆ dĆ©cidĆ© de ne pas y croire. Cāest pratique : on crĆ©e lāaccusation, puis on dit āles gens nāy croient pasā. Cercle parfait.
āĀ La preuve irrĆ©futable quāelle censure PubPeer Ā»
PubPeer nāest pas gĆ©rĆ© par Bik. Elle ne peut ni effacer ni modĆ©rer un commentaire lĆ -bas. Donc soit la personne ne connaĆ®t pas PubPeer, soit elle ment. Les deux options sont gĆŖnantes.
ā « 17Ā signalements Ā« 17 signalements bloquĆ©s Ā»
Les signalements anonymes non conformes sont automatiquement modĆ©rĆ©s par PubPeer. Ce nāest pas de la censure. Cāest juste le site qui fonctionne.
ā Ā« France Soir a relayĆ© immĆ©diatement Ā»
Bien sĆ»r. Quand on parle de Ā« bombe Ā» qui nāexiste pas, France Soir arrive avec lāallumette.
ā « La reine du PubSmear Ā»
Quand tu commences Ć inventer des mots, cāest que tu nāas plus dāarguments. On a compris, bĆ©bĆ©.
ā « Tout lāĆ©difice de lāintĆ©gritĆ© scientifique sāeffondre Ā»
Non. Les standards internationaux ne dĆ©pendent pas de Raoult, ni de France Soir, ni dāune vidĆ©o de 9 minutes.
Ils dƩpendent de revues, de comitƩs, de donnƩes, de reproductions d'expƩrience. De vraies choses, quoi. Pas des commentaires de loosers.
āĀ Ā« La vraie science, celle qui ose, celle de Raoult⦠»
Oh. On termine avec le petit autel, les bougies et la photo du maĆ®tre. Quand tu dois opposer Ā« vraie science Ā» et Ā« fausse science Ā», cāest quāon nāest plus dans la science, mes moineaux. Cāest devenu une Ć©glise.
- Ā« La vraie science est celle de Didier Raoult, les autres sont une inquisition Ā»
ARGUMENT MILITANT, PAS FACTUEL !
La science ne fonctionne pas comme une bataille « héros vs inquisition ».
Pour preuve, Papy Raoult a publiĆ© des travaux contestĆ©s, ailleurs confirmĆ©s comme faibles, et nāa pas reproduit ses rĆ©sultats sur lāhydroxychloroquine.
Les agences de santĆ© du monde entier (FDA, EMA, OMSā¦) ont conclu que lāHCQ nāĆ©tait pas efficace contre la Covid.
Conclusion :
On peut critiquer Bik, cāest parfaitement lĆ©gitime.
Mais inventer des complots, des plaintes qui nāaboutissent pas, des censures imaginaires et transformer PubPeer en secte punitiveā¦
Cāest juste du fan-fiction marseillais, peuchĆØreĀ !
La Colombe Rose šļøš¹
www.youtube.com/live/7NW3J9B7iwY -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Research integrity conference hit with AI-generated abstracts.
retractionwatch.com/2025/11/18/research-integrity-confere⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jake Scott, MD
@jakescottMD
The CDC just rewrote its vaccine and autism page to claim that saying "vaccines do not cause autism" is not evidence-based. This is false.
The evidence is overwhelming & consistent. š§µ
www.cdc.gov/vaccine-safety/about/autism.html -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Krutika Kuppalli, MD FIDSA
@KrutikaKuppalli
Itās now clear that information on U.S. government websites can no longer be trusted.
Itās both heartbreaking and infuriating to see how quickly this administration has undermined science, public health, and the credibility of our scientific institutions -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Conspiracy Watch
@conspiration
Le pourvoi en cassation de Xavier Azalbert Ć l'encontre de l'arrĆŖt de la cour d'appel de Nancy le condamnant pour diffamation Ć lāencontre du Dr Barraud a Ć©tĆ© rejetĆ©. La condamnation du directeur du site conspirationniste FranceSoir est donc dĆ©finitive.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD DSc(hon)
@PeterHotez
How awful, this is outright health disinformation, theyāre lying to the American people. We have massive evidence showing vaccines donāt cause autism, and whatās more thereās no plausible mechanism given what weāve learned about >100 autism genes in early fetal brain development
Dan Diamond
@ddiamond
CDC has overhauled its website to assert that āthe claim āvaccines do not cause autismā is not an evidence-based claimā
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
CDC website saying the claim "vaccines cause autism" has not been disproven
By that same logic it's also not been disproven that vaccines cause you to grow a third foot or to make your eyes turn purple
Fearmongering nonsense from the anti vax captured CDC
Chief Nerd
@TheChiefNerd
šØ CDC: āThe claim āvaccines do not cause autismā is not an evidence-based claim because studies have not ruled out the possibility that infant vaccines cause autism ⦠Studies supporting a link have been ignored by health authoritiesā
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Spotting
@Spottingthespot
š¤£š¤£Is this a joke?? The EIC has become aware of concerns?? The EIC is the last author of the paper!! @SpringerNature this getting funnier by the day
Spotting
@Spottingthespot
Disgruntled authors with retractions nagging about pubpeer in a chatGPT written piece of crap. Hello @SpringerNature is this a joke? Fake references! @TimKersjes this is insane! Last author is the EIC, never reviewed! doi.org/10.1007/s40199-025-00580-z
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Deux mecs ƩpinglƩs pour des fraudes (@idrissaberkane & @raoult_didier) et un multicondamnƩ (@xazalbert) qui prƩtendent pouvoir discuter de la fraude... les gars, si c'est pas pour la votre, c'est pas la peine!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Opinions please?
There's a duplicated Ć-actin band (green).
The author replies, "Because Smad3 is already the right loading control for p-Smad3, thus the last beta-actin is not necessary and we will contact the journal for removal."
Is this legit? š
pubpeer.com/publications/0DBC5C453F223519248098A3D45097 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Sunset over Bondi Beach
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
A paper published in a Springer Nature journal critiquing post-publication peer review has numerous made-up references, including a Nature article falsely attributed to our Ivan Oransky.
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40199-025-00580-z
www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:739575070745⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
After attending the International Research Integrity Conference the past three days, I will be at the @aimos_inc conference the rest of the week, also in Sydney.
Follow me on BlueSky for some live posting.
aimos-inc.github.io/aimos.conference.2025/ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD DSc(hon)
@PeterHotez
Antivaccine activists make it all up:
1. Said MMR causes autism. Debunked
2. Then it was thimerosal. Debunked
3. Then vaccine spacing. Debunked
4. Then aluminum in autism. Debunked
5. Now itās peanut allergy
They donāt care about you or your family. They despise humanity
FactPost
@factpostnews
RFK Jr. suggests that aluminum in vaccines has caused a rise in peanut allergies, but admits "we don't have the science to say if this is an effect or not"
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Looking forward to travel to New Zealand and Sydney. I will give talks in Auckland (November 3rd, sponsored by @Proofig), Wellington (November 10th), and at the International Research Integrity Conference in Sydney on November 17th. researchintegrityconf.com
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I hope to see some of you today in Wellington, NZ for my talk at Massey University / Public Health Observatory (PHONZ) at noon, either in person or via zoom.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Follow my live posts from both conferences on BlueSky.
Here is the first post from the International Research Integrity Conference in Sydney.
bsky.app/profile/elisabethbik.bsky.social/post/3m5roviywpk22
Find my other posts under the tag #iricsydney
researchintegrityconf.com/international-research-integritā¦
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Of course, there were some lovely views over Sydney (taken from the @MCA_Australia, where we had an amazing dinner).
Photo shows part of the Bent Forms #1ā#4 exhibit by Ricky Swallow. Harbour Bridge and Opera House in the distance. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Ian Copeland, PhD
@IanCopeland5
"Nobody has ever seen the SARS- CoV-2 virus under a microscope, because it doesn't exists"...
Behold, the SARS-CoV-2 virus under a microscope, because it does in fact exist...
www.nature.com/articles/s41597-024-04182-3 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
World Conf Research Integrity
@WCRIFoundation
Science of The Total Environment has been officially removed from the Web of Science.
Once a Top-tier journal, it was placed āOn Holdā in Oct 2024 after investigations revealed peer-review manipulation, fake reviewer identities, and conflict-of-interest.
#researchintegrity -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
āRecommendations for Scholarly Publishers and Journal Editors to Mitigate Barriers to Open Access Publishing for Researchers with Weak Institutional Ties.ā
zenodo.org/records/17418990 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
T. A. Abdul-Jabbar
@t_a_abdul
3- COMPUTERS IN BIOLOGY AND MEDICINE (@ElsevierConnect)
4- SCIENCE OF THE TOTAL ENVIRONMENT (@ElsevierConnect)
Also, in this update, 29 new journals have been accepted and indexed. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
āParalysed patients left in dark after trial helping them to walk thrown into chaos.ā
www.smh.com.au/national/paralysed-patients-left-in-dark-a⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
BMJ places expression of concern on heavily criticized stem cell paper.
retractionwatch.com/2025/11/12/bmj-places-expression-of-c⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Steve McCormick
@Quasilocal
Lol imagine writing a paper to criticise something like PubPeer, knowing it will be scrutinised closely because of that, and not even checking if the ChatGPT hallucinated references exist...
Publishing with Integrity
@fake_journals
It's perhaps a little ironic that this recent (or should that be future, as it is being published in 2026?) is getting some remarks on #pubpeer.
The article is available here: idp.springer.com/transit?redirect_uri=https%3A%2F%2Flink.ā¦
You can see the PuPeer comments here: pubpeer.com/publications/5CC4D1FB2B21DBB3D50E3DFDAE2543, but I'll pick up on a few points.
1ļøā£ Article 2, supposedly authored by Bik, E.M. (@MicrobiomDigest) does not seem to exist and Bik says that she did not author the article.
2ļøā£ Article 3 does not seem to exist. This article was supposedly written by Ivan Oransky (@ivanoransky) of @RetractionWatch fame.
3ļøā£ Article 4 does not exist. I looked at 23(5) of Science and Engineering Ethics (see idp.springer.com/transit?redirect_uri=https%3A%2F%2Flink.ā¦), and this issue does not include the cited paper. Indeed, this issue only goes up to page 1459 (and not 1511, which is the start page of the cited article). And, yes, I looked at 23(6) and the cited article is not there either.
Not quite what to take away from all of this. #llm hallucinations? Not checked by the authors?
Not sure what will be the outcome. Expression of Concern ? Retraction?
Take a look at the PubPeer comments to see what you think and let me know in the comments. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
World Conf Research Integrity
@WCRIFoundation
New study on 452 WCRI abstracts finds that only 28% of empirical studies were registered, and this rate didnāt improve across conferences. Verifiable registrations rose from 44% to 88%.
#wcri #wcri2026 #researchintegrity #openscience #researchethics
doi.org/10.1080/08989621.2025.2575442 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The disgruntled authors who have united as @ScienceGuardians are going to reveal the 'central fraudulent figure who has been serving as the public face of this smearing network and its malicious operation'.
Apparently, it's me!
Sorry, fellow sleuths.
Woohoo! šš„³š„ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Ah, it is me! What a great honor. More vague insinuations and untruths? Woohoo!
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Ah, it is me! What a great honor. More vague insinuations and untruths? Woohoo!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
"The FDA's FAERS system is useful for identifying potential adverse events associated with drugs. However, its data is often exploited to produce articles reporting spurious drug risks. COSIG's entry on formulaic research now covers low-quality pharmacovigilance studies!" RR
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You forgot to mention that you are #14 on the @RetractionWatch leaderboard!
It appears that you are quickly losing the trust that scientists once had in you. -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You forgot to mention that you are #14 on the @RetractionWatch leaderboard!
It appears that you are quickly losing the trust that scientists once had in you. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I am dreaming of a day when research integrity will be dominating academia! What is wrong with that?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
ScienceGuardians' Triangle of Vague Insinuations and Untruths.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I am dreaming of a day when research integrity will be dominating academia! What is wrong with that?
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
ScienceGuardians' Triangle of Vague Insinuations and Untruths.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr JƩrƓme BARRIERE, MD.
@barriere_dr
Impeccable @DrJeromeMarty ! Il a tout dit et nous sommes nombreux je pense à nous retrouver dans sa déclaration à @EmmanuelMacron !
Bravo pour ton abnƩgation et ton combat contre la dƩsinformation !This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Emmanuel Macron
@EmmanuelMacron
Face aux lecteurs de la Dépêche du Midi. x.com/i/broadcasts/1OyKAjoDzwwGb
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You got it wrong yourself, @wwpersonality
The "Sage" personality is present twice, but with different profiles.
Does not give me much confidence in your analysis.
#archetypeforensics -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
ScienceGuardians' Triangle of Vague Insinuations and Untruths.
(Feel free to use as a reply to their libelous tweets). -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
ScienceGuardians' Triangle of Vague Insinuations and Untruths.
(Feel free to use as a reply to their libelous tweets). -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You are the one who is doing the harassment and intimidation, and it is sickening that you are using someoneās tragic death to promote your agenda.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I hope to see some of you today in Wellington, NZ for my talk at Massey University / Public Health Observatory (PHONZ) at noon, either in person or via zoom.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Reformation of science publishing: the Stockholm Declaration
A call to action for universities, academies, science organizations and funders to unite and join this effort.
Bernhard Sabel and Dan Larhammar
royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsos.251805
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This is the result of a meeting held this summer in Stockholm, organized by the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, where I was one of the attendees.
Proposed actions against fake science presented after meeting
www.kva.se/en/news/proposed-actions-against-fake-science-ā¦
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
More press @FinancialTimes [Gift link]:
A tide of fabricated research risks scientific integrity
Manipulation, disinformation and fakery could lead to a knowledge collapse
www.ft.com/content/a1c675db-9631-4088-a771-b6fe7ba4d638?a⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Michael č±ę³ Eisen
@mbeisen
If only Rosalind Franklin had pre-printed her image
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
I'm not a scientist and I have no training in these fields, but I'm now helped by new tools and AI. Obviously, my concerns may be wrong.
But, I ask you "real" scientists, how do you guys defend this crap getting published, and *even when flagged*, not scramble to fix it? 𤯠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
CrƩmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
A new study just came out on this topic.
Using data from almost 14 million young people in England, they found that COVIDābut not COVID vaccinationāwas broadly associated with heart problems.
The myocarditis bump (which is milder than real myocarditis) was also small.
CrƩmieux
@cremieuxrecueil
Let's make this even clearer.
The severity of COVID vaccine-related myocarditis was far lower than the severity of COVID-related myocarditis, which instead looked like regular viral myocarditis.
You can see this in many cohorts. For example, this was seen in France: -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The Editor Got a Letter From āDr. B.S.ā So Did a Lot of Other Editors.
The rise of artificial intelligence has produced serial writers to science and medical journals, most likely using chatbots to boost the number of citations theyāve published
#giftlink
www.nytimes.com/2025/11/04/science/letters-to-the-editor-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Behind every ad-hominem attack on a scientist is a very crappy paper.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Behind every ad-hominem attack on a scientist is a very crappy paper.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
An author of a study on "Fake publications in biomedical science" is among those proposing a "call to action for all stakeholders...to unite in reforming the structure of the current science publishing culture."
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00210-025-04275-9
royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsos.251805 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Carlos Chaccour š¦šš
@Carlos_Chaccour
Letters to scientific journals surge as āprolific debutanteā authors likely use AI | Science | AAAS www.science.org/content/article/letters-scientific-journaā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Big story on Iranian research by Leonid.
forbetterscience.com/2025/11/05/bmj-invaded-by-iranian-pa⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
My current office at Lake TaupÅ, New Zealand
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Microbiologist Siouxsie Wiles @SiouxsieW has launched a fundraising campaign to cover some of the legal fees accrued in taking a case against her employer, the University of Auckland. She explains why.
thespinoff.co.nz/society/01-11-2025/siouxsie-wiles-why-imā¦
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
PledgeMe link:
www.pledgeme.co.nz/projects/8521-support-dr-siouxsie-afte⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Embattled journal Cureus delisted from Web of Science, loses impact factor.
retractionwatch.com/2025/10/27/embattled-journal-cureus-d⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mu Yang, Ph.D.
@mumumouse2
If both the Q collar and helmet type have significant impact on the brain white matter parameters, and both factors are present in the same studies, can we analyze and discuss ONE factor without mentioning the other?
@jsmoliga
Read my write-up on this
www.linkedin.com/posts/mu-yang-11229436_two-weeks-ago-our⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Widespread image reuse, manipulation uncovered in animal studies of brain injury.
retractionwatch.com/2025/10/30/widespread-image-reuse-man⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Next time you get ChatGPT to write your nonsensical tweets, please ask it to include a link to this fantastic blog
There will be at least some science in your post.
PS: you should probably change your handle to āfraudsterguardiansā
forbetterscience.com -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
Wow, dubbele pagina vandaag in @nrc met recensie over Sloppy Science. āEen helder en vlot geschreven boek (ā¦) dat toont hoe kwetsbaar wetenschap blijft.ā
(En ja, ik ga idd snel door de pre-Stapelperiode heen, dat was ook al in 2011 immers. De problemen nu zijn ernstig genoeg.) -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Happy Friday to those who celebrate.
Happy Halloween too! š»
forbetterscience.com/2025/10/31/schneider-shorts-31-10-20⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
40% van de dierstudies naar hersenbloedingen bevat afbeeldingen die niet kloppen, ontdekten onderzoekers RenƩ Aquarius en Kim Wever @radboudumc. Sommige publicaties zijn mogelijk geheel of deels verzonnen. Zorgwekkend, zegt ook @MicrobiomDigest.
Voor Vox.
www.voxweb.nl/nieuws/honderden-dierpublicaties-over-herse⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Agingdocš©ŗDr David BarzilaišMD PhD MS MBA DipABLM
@agingdoc1
40 Percent of Stroke Animal Studies May Have Problematic Images
By @liuswrites @TheScientistLLC; interviews with (photos) Kim Wever & Elisabeth Bik @MicrobiomDigest
& RenƩ Aquarius
š§ www.the-scientist.com/40-percent-of-stroke-animal-studies⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Ethically questionable behavior from @SabinehazanMD.
You can buy her research papers for $15.00 on her website, even though most/all are in Open Access journals which offer *free* access. Example from @MDPIOpenAccess below.
microbiomeresearchfoundation.org/product-category/publica⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
40 Percent of Stroke Animal Studies May Have Problematic Images
Red flags during a literature review led to the discovery of over 200 papers on animal models of stroke with duplicated images, which is likely an underestimate.
www.the-scientist.com/40-percent-of-stroke-animal-studiesā¦
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Radboud researchers RenƩ Aquarius @deadneanderthal and Kim Wever were about to embark on a literature review project when they noticed several odd things that made them stop in their tracks, then change the course of their study entirely.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Publication:
Aquarius R, et al. High prevalence of articles with image-related problems in animal studies of subarachnoid hemorrhage and low rates of correction by publishers. PLoS Biol. 2025;23(10):e3003438.
journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
New from Reese Richardson: "Paper mills are far more adaptable than the institutions fighting them. Case in point: after journals started using "anti-plagiarism" software, paper mills started selling access to the same software."
doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2524787122 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jane Symons
@JaneSymons1
Congratulations to John Maddox Prize winner Virginia Burkett
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Ma nouvelle chronique "Un rat(Ć©) de plus dans la thĆ©orie des vaccins qui causent lāautisme" est sortie chez @LePoint
Un papier qui avait aidé les antivax à répandre des mensonges sur vaccins et autisme est rétracté grace au travail de @mumumouse2 qui pointe les problèmes méthodologiques de l'étude depuis des mois.
Contrairement au #lancetgate, les antivax ne crient pas au scandal...
A lire ici: www.lepoint.fr/science/un-rat-e-de-plus-dans-la-theorie-dā¦
Poke @GeWoessner @emma_ducros @Cobra_FX_ @barriere_dr @EricBillyFR @AlexSamTG @campiche_sarah @PrJEKurtz @AlaryPatrick
Le Point
@LePoint
Un rat(Ć©) de plus dans la thĆ©orie des vaccins qui causent lāautisme
šļø LA CHRONIQUE de @lonnibesancon l.lepoint.fr/dVl -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Hemayet
@biologists1
Nice interview to depict the integrity of science in the current AI environment @NPR @Marketplace
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
In today's episode of @NPR's @Marketplace , I talk to @kairyssdal about science fraud and paper mills
(segment starts at 25 min).
www.marketplace.org/episode/2025/10/28/ai-is-here-where-a⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Brian O'Roak
@TheRealDrOLab
Was great to hear @MicrobiomDigest on @Marketplace on my drive home today.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Gaurav Sharma, Ph.D.
@sharmaG30
Thanks for commenting positively and negatively on our recent tool, GScholarLens. Let me try to say a few thing:
1. We are not extracting authorship from text mining from full paper text; it is really tough as diverse journals have diverse ways of depiction. Therefore, the first thing to do before running this tool is marking your First/co-first authors with ^ sign, and corresponding/co-corresponding authors with * sign. You can do it only for your GS profile, similar to your CV. Once you have done it, GScholarLens will work efficiently.
2. We all know that h-index and citations are not going away anywhere. Moreover, a lot of people keep boasting about their h-index and citations. Are you not tired of listening to their boasting?
3. Let me be clear that we cannot judge quality from any index. I am with you on this front and we are not claiming anywhere about judging the quality.
4. You must have come across that many authors do a lot of collaborations and less lead projects. The question is should a researcher have a balance between lead and collaborative projects or not? If your answer is yes, this tool is for you. If you answer NO, then it is of no use to you. Overall, GScholarLens aims to show the balance between lead and collaborative publication counts and their gained c1itations.
5. Many of you have asked why First/co-first authors have 10% less weightage than corresponding. Based on multiple evidences, the corresponding author typically contributes more sustained effort across a projectāby securing funding, guiding research direction, ensuring integrity, coordinating collaborators, and managing journal communication. They also bear post-publication accountability, including handling queries, corrections, and must be held responsible for retractions. Hence, a slightly higher weightage is justified compared to first or co-first authors, whose contributions are mainly focused on execution and manuscript preparation. This is consistent with ICMJE and CRediT guidelines highlighting the corresponding authorās leadership and responsibility.
My team will do our best to answer your queries.
Link to Nature Feature: www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-03281-4
Link to Preprint: arxiv.org/abs/2509.04124
Link to Tool: project.iith.ac.in/sharmaglab/gscholarlens/
@omics_lab @IITHyderabad @IndiaDST @ANRFIndia @Science_Cast @IndiaScienceTV @MicrobiomDigest @IRWatchdog @hapyresearchers @fake_journals @Richvn @NatureInd @AcademicChatter @OpenAcademics
Gaurav Sharma, Ph.D.
@sharmaG30
Happy to see that our labās open-science tool, GScholarLens has been featured by @Nature.
Dalmeet Chawla (@DalmeetS) does a fantastic job highlighting how GScholarLens brings transparency to scientific metrics, helping researchers, institutions, and the community better understand research impact based on authorship. By making citation and authorship data open and traceable, the tool aims to reduce the pitfalls of metric-driven evaluation and encourage thoughtful discussion on scientific contributions.
Link: www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-03281-4
@omics_lab @IITHyderabad @IndiaDST @ANRFIndia @Science_Cast @IndiaScienceTV @MicrobiomDigest @IRWatchdog @hapyresearchers @fake_journals @Richvn @NatureInd @AcademicChatter @OpenAcademics -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Paper by former top NIH official and neuropathologist Eliezer Masliah received an Expression of Concern last week by @NeuroCellPress.
While it benefits other scientists that the paper is now flagged, two things could have been done much better.
/
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0896627325007937Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A third problem:
The journal states that no misconduct could be confirmed. But a journal does not need to prove that. They should retract the paper if the images appear manipulated and the reliability of the findings is compromised.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
In conclusion, the Expression of Concern should have been issued already last year, all problems pointed out on PubPeer should have been taken into account, and, given the serious concerns with the paper, this should have been a retraction.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mu Yang, Ph.D.
@mumumouse2
Update: I communicated withy Pubpeer. Basically, the bottom line is "comments only highlighting self-citations will need to establish genuinely egregious cases - 60% or greater. However, the threshold will be much lower if irrelevance can be demonstrated (or some other problem)."
And ....and I swear I didn't break Pubpeer. It is down š³
Mu Yang, Ph.D.
@mumumouse2
I succeeded at being downgraded on Pubpeer after flagging 16 papers with self citation rate at/near/over 30%! *I used to have the no-moderation privilege and now I have to be moderated like most people. šš
That happened several times before when I annoyed authors.
Please take a look pubpeer.com/search?q=yasser+zare. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Gaurav Sharma, Ph.D.
@sharmaG30
Happy to see that our labās open-science tool, GScholarLens has been featured by @Nature.
Dalmeet Chawla (@DalmeetS) does a fantastic job highlighting how GScholarLens brings transparency to scientific metrics, helping researchers, institutions, and the community better understand research impact based on authorship. By making citation and authorship data open and traceable, the tool aims to reduce the pitfalls of metric-driven evaluation and encourage thoughtful discussion on scientific contributions.
Link: www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-03281-4
@omics_lab @IITHyderabad @IndiaDST @ANRFIndia @Science_Cast @IndiaScienceTV @MicrobiomDigest @IRWatchdog @hapyresearchers @fake_journals @Richvn @NatureInd @AcademicChatter @OpenAcademics -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Happy #caturday from Buster!
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Another example of institutional investigations conducted in secret, without a public report, for 'privacy reasons'.
Investigation found UBC researcher fabricated data, gave spinal patients 'false hope.' The public was not told.
www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/meshfill-investigā¦
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I posted concerns about papers from this researcher in 2019 onto PubPeer.
Here is a new one. Can you spot at least two problems?
#imageforensics
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Here are my concerns.
Of interest, @Proofig found the lower (yellow-boxed) duplication, but none of the duplications in the top panel. In contrast, @ImageTwinAI found the three top duplications, but not the one in the lower panel. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Retraction #8 for Australian neuroscientist Gilles Guillemin, published and retracted @Oncotarget.
'The corresponding author Dr. Guillemin agreed with the retraction, but the rest of the authors either did not respond directly or could not be reached.'
pubpeer.com/publications/2F43F5C405F2A6F38F19DD7AD7FC0D
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The retraction notice includes: "Macquarie University concluded that Professor Guillemin's contributions to the paper did not meet their authorship threshold according to the Macquarie University Code for the Responsible Conduct of Research and requested his name be removed. "
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Note that Guillemin (who left Macquarie Uni in 2023) was corresponding author.
I am sure Macquarie University was fine with that, but now that the paper contained concerns, they suddenly want his name removed?
No, his name was on it, you swallow the consequences. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
BowTiedMara
@BowTiedMara
The German company that built the forklift used in the Louvre robbery uses a photo of the heist to advertise itself: āWhen things need to be done quickly.ā
ššš -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
Nijmeegse wetenschapsfraude-onderzoekers (RROSA) organiseerden deze week een boeiende workshop (oa met @sTeamTraen).
EƩn van de activiteiten was een nep-abstract schrijven en presenteren voor een nepcongres. Inclusief een chic ogend aanwezigheidscertificaat na afloop. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Florian Krammer
@florian_krammer
At conferences, we call this a manel.
Markus Sƶder
@Markus_Soeder
Heute Auftakt der Jahreskonferenz der Regierungschefinnen und Regierungschefs in #mainz. Auch wenn wir nicht immer einer Meinung sind: Wir brauchen mehr Optimismus und gemeinsame Lösungen für die Herausforderungen unserer Zeit. Nur wenn wir die Sorgen der Menschen ernst nehmen, werden wir unsere Demokratie erfolgreich verteidigen. #mpk (Foto: StK RLP / Pulkowski)
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Christos Constantinidis
@c_constan
From now on, I'm only publishing in Nature Cell and Science
cellnatsci.com -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Hiroshi Yasuda (äæē°ęµ©åæ)
@Yash25571056
"In 2018, a reader spotted a pair of flawed and nearly identical papers that had been published in two mathematics journals the year before, and alerted the journal staff.
The publisher of the journals, Springer Nature, discovered that both articles had used fictitious reviewers..
The fake reviewers had appeared as authors on earlier papers.
So once both made-up names became published authors, they began to be repeatedly suggested for reviewing.
Between 2013 and 2020, the paper mill published 55 papers with the help of 13 fictitious reviewers and 13 fake authors, who were supposedly based all over the world..
It took Springer Nature two years to investigate this ring of fake scientists, eventually finding that they were probably the work of a China-based paper mill and retracting all of the affected papers by early 2021.."
We are increasingly embroiled in a fake world where reality is uninvited.
'How to spot fake scientists and stop them from publishing papers'
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-03341-9 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Dr. who? is going nuts with the AI.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Competition @kaggle:
Scientific Image Forgery Detection
Who can develop the best model to detect copy/move forgeries in biomedical images?
#imageforensics
www.kaggle.com/competitions/recodai-luc-scientific-image-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Tina Termini
@CterminiPhD
NIH study section was supposed to meet today. It wonāt. I know Iām going to find a way to persist, but itās a really hard time right now. Sending ā„ļø to all, especially those early career PIs still trying to āmake itā.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Thank you to @SageJournals for retracting a probable paper mill paper about 1 year after being notified, and for acknowledging the role of PubPeer.
pubpeer.com/publications/32753B28B468E4DC956A906A539766 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Simon Maechling
@simonmaechling
Cancer patients who got a COVID shot lived significantly longer.
No, thatās not a typo.
A new study found that a simple mRNA vaccine - originally made for COVID - nearly doubled survival in patients with advanced lung and skin cancer.
Letās break it down š š§µ 1/ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD DSc(hon)
@PeterHotez
1/n The corrupt wellness influencers + MAHA pseudoscience combine for two goals:
1. To buy what they can in bulk (in case you wonder why theyāre anti parasitics like ivermectin hydroxychloroquine) repackage, bilk customers with $1,600 telehealth visits www.washingtonpost.com/health/2025/10/21/ivermectin-joe-r⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Hey @tandfonline - you should not allow authors to address photoshopped tumors by just leaving out the photoshopped tumors. This paper was 1 year old at the time of correction. Where are the originals?
Horrible editorial decision.
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Iain Cheeseman
@iaincheeseman
Today @AnthropicAI released PubMed integration for Claude. No hallucinations. Just real science, real data. As a beta tester, this has been a game changerālike having a supercharged research assistant. Here are 6 prompts that will transform how you search the literature. A š§µ
Anthropic
@AnthropicAI
Weāre building tools to support research in the life sciences, from early discovery through to commercialization.
With Claude for Life Sciences, weāve added connectors to scientific tools, Skills, and new partnerships to make Claude more useful for scientific work.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Seems Grok is not very good at picking up sarcastic jokes.
-
IntegralAnswers
@IntegralAnswers
šØ BREAKING NEWS: Breast & Formula Fed Toddlers Linked to Autism Diagnosis šØ
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Seems Grok is not very good at picking up sarcastic jokes.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
āInvestigation found UBC researcher fabricated data, gave spinal patients āfalse hope.'ā
www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/meshfill-investig⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Quelque part encore dans le monde, le fleuron de la recherche franƧaise fait encore parler de lui... toujours pour des mauvaises raisons...
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
IntegralAnswers
@IntegralAnswers
šØ BREAKING NEWS: Breast & Formula Fed Toddlers Linked to Autism Diagnosis šØ
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
AnKo
@anko_979
The biggest scandal with scientific misconduct is the brazen coverups attempted by colleagues and even widely respectable institutions
And these incidents then give excuses to enemies of science to generalize attacks and funding cuts -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Very bizarre.
An investigation by @CUNY's expert panel found "evidence highly suggestive of deliberate scientific misconduct" - but the university concluded that Dr. Wang did not do misconduct.
#scienceintegrity
@cpiller reports @ScienceMagazine
Charles Piller
@cpiller
As his fraud trial looms, Alzheimerās scientist exonerated by his universityāsort of - CUNY's puzzling analysis of a collaborator of Cassava Sciences | Science | AAAS www.science.org/content/article/his-fraud-trial-looms-alzā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jonathan Karl
@jonkarl
The journalists who cover the Pentagon had to choose today between signing a pledge that would make it impossible to do independent journalism and turning in their Pentagon press badges. Almost all of them turned in their badges and left the building.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Maitre Eolasš«š·
@Maitre_Eolas
IHU MƩditerranƩe Infection.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Oded Rechavi
@OdedRechavi
BIG ANNOUNCEMENTš£: I havenāt been this excited to be part of something new in 15 years⦠Thrilled to reveal the passion project Iāve been working on for the past year and a half!šš„³ It started from my frustration with the depressing effect that the current publishing system has on the well-being of myself, my team, and pretty much every scientist I know (maybe youāve noticed from my stupid jokes⦠:) I was exhausted of dealing with the huge delays, reviewers that can be abusive, and how arbitrary it all is. Unfortunately, the most important factors are often WHO your reviewers are and who YOU are... Itās clear we need alternatives or at least ways to improve the situation. So, together with a really special and talented team we worked to develop this idea into āqedā a platform where you can get CONSTRUCTIVE feedback on your own work or CRITICALLY assess other peopleās papers. It can be a real difference maker if many of you join us (thousands have tried it already, but today we release a NEW and much stronger version ;) Letās harness qed to put the power back in the scientistsā hands, to do, to read & to publish science on our own terms. Iām dying for you to TRY IT, and itās very simple - just drop a paper (the link to the website is in the repliesš) - itās completely secure, private, and free, and you get results fast. Please show your support, SHARE, tell your friends, and letās be the revolution š«µ!
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Nicolas Berrod
@nicolasberrod
Fin de l'histoire : le Conseil dāĆtat retoque le pourvoi formĆ© par le Pr Didier Raoult contre sa sanction Ć 2 ans d'interdiction d'exercice de la mĆ©decine.
Il est donc dƩfinitivement sanctionnƩ (bon, c'est de toute faƧon symbolique car il est retraitƩ).
www.apmnews.com/nostory.php?uid=0&objet=428695 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Scam alert: there are swarms of bots/scam accounts that will reply to people complaining about a company, pretending to be their help desk. But they are brand new accounts, so they canāt be real. They are followed by other brand new accounts. Here is one of those swarms.
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This is how one of them replied to my tweet that my intercontinental KLM flight was cancelled. They actually use the same language as the Qatar Airlines customer service X account, but that one is legit and has over a million followers.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Also: ZacharyRandomNumber or Becca?
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
More bad travel luck this trip: my @KLM KL605 flight has been cancelled- second time this year of the four times I booked it. That is a 50% failure rate from my perspective. And a lot of new grey hairs.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Luckily, I have been rebooked on a different flight by another carrier. That means I can sleep in a bit instead of taking a 6:45 am train. So sort of good news.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Catharine
@DrCatharineY
Another win for vaccines: A new study finds that reactivation of the virus that causes shingles (VZV) is linked to higher dementia riskā¦and shingles vaccination cuts that risk by up to 35%.
It suggests something extraordinary: dementia may have a modifiable viral trigger.
Eric Feigl-Ding
@DrEricDing
š§ DEMENTIA PREVENTIONāAlmost everyone needs to go out now and get the shingles vaccine ASAP. Donāt wait until age 50 for standard eligibilityāask your doctor for singles vax. MULTIPLE large studies worldwide now show that shingles vaccine strongly prevents dementia onset. Do it.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jake Scott, MD
@jakescottMD
Alarming @statnews report on FDA political interference. Career scientists are being asked to find data supporting predetermined conclusions on autism treatments, vaccines, SSRIs - the opposite of how science works.
We need evidence-based regulation, not regulation-based evidence.
Matthew Herper
@matthewherper
Have you been wondering how the FDA came to ask $GSK to file to have leucovorin approved for some types of autism?
The details of that decision -- the director of the FDA's drug division negotiated a tense bargan with agency staff -- are only the start of this important piece from my colleague @LizzyLaw_ .
āItās like the tail wagging the dog,ā an agency official who left over the summer told STAT. āGo find data to support this. Go find data to support that.ā
www.statnews.com/2025/10/14/fda-under-trump-rfk-jr-staff-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Guillaume Limousinšš“
@Sonic_urticant
š„š£ BREAKING NEWS
Didier Raoult perd en @Conseil_Etat (poursuites dont je suis à l'origine via rédaction de la plainte, ce qui m'a immédiatement valu une avalanche de menaces de mort, qu'il a partagées, et qui durent encore).
Didier Raoult est dƩfinitivement condamnƩ.
RT SVPš½
š“š²ššNubealtissimeššš“š“ š²180šļø
@NubePfizerise
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
It was great meeting @MicrobiomDigest in persoon again, and to hear her talk about science integrity issues at @Radboud_Uni this afternoon.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Oh, the joy of reading a book in a nearly empty train that left on time ā¤ļøā¤ļøā¤ļø
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Tomorrow afternoon, I will be talking about my work at @Radboud_Uni in Nijmegen, in a colloquium chaired by @WillemHalffman, and with other talks by Maud Bernisson and @stanvanpelt.
We will talk about 'Problematic Science'.
No registration needed.
halffman.org/rrosa/problematic-science/
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
My reading material for in the train on my way to Nijmegen: @stanvanpeltās new book Sloppy Science.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Oh, the joy of reading a book in a nearly empty train that left on time ā¤ļøā¤ļøā¤ļø
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea
@jonathanstea
RFK Jr: āResearch on vaccines and autism has been suppressed.ā
PubMed: āHereās over 1200 research papers on vaccines and autismā¦
ā¦including this first one which is a meta-analysis showing that vaccines are not associated with autism.ā
J Mc
@JRMcIntosh2000
Letās shit on the person whoās asking the questions no doctor cares to research on since 1986.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I am a bit skeptical about Denario, an AI-powered method that creates a research idea after feeding it some data (HARKing?) and then generates lots of plots and writes a paper.
astropilot-ai.github.io/DenarioPaperPage/
I have some questions about AI-slop, reliability, and ethics. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
āAll academics should be scientific sleuths, says scholarā Lonni BesanƧon.
www.universityworldnews.com/post-mobile.php?story=2025100⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Pepijn van Erp
@pjvanerp
Hoe hardnekkig geloof in alterneuterij bij patiĆ«nten en hun directe familie tot gedoe kan leiden voor artsen die gewoon hun stinkende beste doen. ⤵ļø
www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2025/10/10/aan-het-ziekbed-van-joop-ste⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
āAs paper mills and fraud proliferate, experts warn the retraction rate should reach 2% of published literatureāten times current levelsā: A piece on a talk by our Ivan Oransky.
conexiant.com/internal-medicine/articles/scientific-retra⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mu Yang, Ph.D.
@mumumouse2
Saturday riddle.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
For more information about the Friday night massacre at CDC, I wrote up an analysis of who got terminated and what that means for public health.
Grateful to @SaveAmericaMvm for supporting and amplifying. We are in really terrible trouble.
rasmussenretorts.substack.com/p/the-death-of-public-health
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
I donāt know who needs to hear this but the CDC is being eviscerated right now. America is not going to have any kind of outbreak response capacity after tonight. Americansā health data is no longer secure. Say goodbye to federal public health in any capacity.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Marion Koopmans, publications: https://pure.eur.nl
@MarionKoopmans
Further undermining of the public health system in the US. @EU_Commission please watch closely because this is going to be devastating. Let's make sure Europe can withstand the misinformation coming from Washington @florian_krammer geneticliteracyproject.org/2025/10/08/public-health-withoā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
DrDemetre
@dr_demetre
A non peer reviewed pre-print is not gold standard science. That is little more than a glorified social media post. Letās see what happens once this is peer reviewed.
Secretary Kennedy
@SecKennedy
As usual, the mainstream media attacks me for something I didnāt say in order to distract from the truth of what I did say.
At yesterdayās Cabinet meeting, I said: āThere are two studies that show children who are circumcised early have double the rate of autism, and itās highly likely because theyāre given Tylenol.ā
An August 2025 preprints.org review by Patel et al. directly validates my point that the observed autism correlation in circumcised boys is best explained by acetaminophen exposure, not circumcision itself.
Newsweek reflected my comments most accurately.
USA Today partially reported what I said but used misleading framing.
New York Post distorted it completely with its headline, implying I said circumcision causes autism.
So once again, MSM chooses to character assassinate me instead of educating Americans by digging into the science.
The paper I was referring to identifies the 2015 Danish circumcision study as āthe most compelling āstandaloneā evidence that acetaminophen triggers autism in susceptible babies and children.ā
It presents a mechanistic model showing that acetaminophen acts in combination with oxidative stress to cause neurodevelopmental injury.
The studyās authors call the evidence āoverwhelmingā and argue the precautionary principle demands avoiding acetaminophen during pregnancy and early infancy, precisely echoing my public warning.
In short, the preprint provides a rigorous scientific framework that substantiates my interpretation: the risk stems from acetaminophen use in infants, not from circumcision itself.
SOURCE: www.preprints.org/manuscript/202508.0006/v1 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Arrived back in the Netherlands, where there is another train SNAFU - or is it still the same one as on Wednesday?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jerome Adams
@JeromeAdamsMD
Like many others, I agree with RFK that Americaās health is poor and that our healthcare system is dysfunctional. But that shouldnāt mean that we must go backwards on childhood vaccinations, supporting pregnant moms, and keeping CDC workers safe. None of that will actually MAHA.
Jerome Adams
@JeromeAdamsMD
Disinformation and the destruction of public health & Americaās trust in doctors will kill more people than cigarettes. Neither I nor the other five living Surgeons General wanted to call for this unprecedented warning- but all felt compelled by duty to do so. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/10/07/surgeons-generā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Trump Administration Lays Off Dozens of C.D.C. Officials
āDisease detectives,ā high-ranking scientists, the entire Washington office and the staff of a weekly public health journal were among those who learned late Friday that they would lose their jobs.
www.nytimes.com/2025/10/11/us/politics/trump-administrati⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
David Gorski, MD, PhD
@gorskon
Even if thatās true (which is arguable, at best), it does not imply that the solution is to embrace pseudoscience and unproven (and disproven) quackery, which is always the implication with people like Means or @SecKennedy cite quotes like this.
Calley Means
@calleymeans
āThe case against science is straightforward: much of the scientific literature, perhaps half, may simply be untrue. Science has taken a turn toward darkness.ā
-Richard Horton, former Editor-in-Chief of The Lancet (the worldās premier medical journal) -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
I donāt know who needs to hear this but the CDC is being eviscerated right now. America is not going to have any kind of outbreak response capacity after tonight. Americansā health data is no longer secure. Say goodbye to federal public health in any capacity.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
NIH Leadership Is Failing Early Career Researchers
āThese bottlenecks have gotten so bad that some labs have had to ration gloves and paper towels.ā
Ian Morgan @TheScientistLLC
www.the-scientist.com/nih-leadership-is-failing-early-car⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea
@jonathanstea
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Publishing with Integrity
@fake_journals
Identifying common patterns in journals that retracted papers from paper mills: a cross-sectional study - Research Integrity and Peer Review idp.springer.com/transit?redirect_uri=https%3A%2F%2Flink.ā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Fab Frank
@LockedFab
New "Expression of concern" for the IHU :
- Approval 09-022 used 258 times.
- Use of the funding reference as a retrospective approval.
It should be noted that AMU didn't cover the authors. I'm falling off my chair!
bmjopengastro.bmj.com/content/12/1/e000080eoc1 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Arrived in Berlin, where I will give a talk at the 3rd Young Scientist Cancer Congress.
Hope to see some of you there!
#ys2c
www.ys2c.org/index.php
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The conference is held in the French Embassy in Berlin, next to the Brandenburger Tor.
Phone connection is sparse, and there are some restrictions due to the conference venue, so I cannot do much live posting.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This will be the 3rd event in this series. The first two were held in France. This conference has a strong focus on networking for young cancer researchers in Germany and France and beyond.
#ys2c
www.ys2c.org/index.php
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This was a long day! Talks, a long interview, more talks, giving a talk myself, lightning poster talks, posters, networking, and then beers in the @berlin_sony
#ys2c -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea
@jonathanstea
This guy is in charge of US health care.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Catharine
@DrCatharineY
Science is not a contest to be won.
Itās a collective pursuit of truth that evolves with evidence - not a debate settled by opinion or the loudest voice. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Ken Milne MD
@TheSGEM
The Rise of Health Misinformation: Inside the slow-burning crisis reshaping modern health care.
"Pseudoscience doesn't enter the brain via logic, it enters by propaganda on repeat." @DrJenGunter
www.schulich.uwo.ca/rapport/2025/features/the_rise_of_hea⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The line to check in at @Radisson @ParkInnBerlin is 50 people long š± - photo taken from roughly halfway the line. It went around the corner for another 30 people.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
An angry regular customer just shared that this happened a week before as well. None of the self checking stations are working either.
@RadissonPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Then, I could not get the top shower to work (that little button above the handle did not seem to do anything), so I had to use the shower head that is installed at the perfect height if you are 4 feet tall.
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I am also not a fan of the squeeze āAll In Oneā soap bottles, especially the squeeze part, which seems not very hygienic. Do others like these?
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Back at the hotel after dinner and back in line, now to get my keycard. Luckily the line is much shorter now.
Now off to bed! -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Anyone who can help me with the Berlin public transportation app BVG? No matter which payment method I have set up, it refuses to use it to pay a ticket. Now I have no idea how to take a tram and the conference org does not reimburse Uber š
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Al-Ola A Abdallah MD (USMIRC)
@Abdallah81MD
ā ā A reminder by Dr. Rahaf Ajaj:
She wasnāt on the Stanford list⦠but she made it to the Nobel stage. š
Mary E. Brunkow, one of this yearās Nobel Prize winners in Medicine, has only 34 published papers and an H-index of 21.
She never appeared in Stanfordās ranking of the worldās top 2% of scientists.
She didnāt chase citations, metrics, or the spotlight.
Yet, she became part of a discovery that changed how humanity understands the immune system.
Today, while many are busy chasing numbers, titles, and rankings ā
she reminds us what truly matters in science: the question.
š¹ She wasnāt running after the lists.
š¹ She was running after the truth.
Because in the end, itās not about how many papers you publishā¦
Itās about how deeply your idea can reshape the world.
Focus on your idea, not your ranking. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Catharine
@DrCatharineY
Today, SiX Surgeon Generals in keeping with those oaths, have felt compelled to speak against the actions of HHS and RFK Jr.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr JƩrƓme BARRIERE, MD.
@barriere_dr
Fil š§µ debunk DIDIER RAOULT š„š„
Didier Raoult a affirmĆ© AUJOURDāHUI sur X quāil existerait un lien entre la vaccination Covid-19 et une hausse des cancers, sāappuyant sur deux Ć©tudes rĆ©centes (une italienne dāenviron 300āÆ000 personnes, une sud-corĆ©enne portant sur 8Ā millions) .
DƩcortiquons ces Ʃtudes et leurs limites mƩthodologiques pour rƩtablir les faits.
1/ā¤µļø -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jerome Adams
@JeromeAdamsMD
Disinformation and the destruction of public health & Americaās trust in doctors will kill more people than cigarettes. Neither I nor the other five living Surgeons General wanted to call for this unprecedented warning- but all felt compelled by duty to do so. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/10/07/surgeons-generā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Jikkyleaks @Jikkyleaks is in a very bad mood today š
He wanted to āverifyā the duplications but he does not want me to give it to him š¤
He put me back on block, which is a blessing, I guess. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
Iām honored to have been named recipient of the Victor Cohn Prize for Excellence in Medical Science Reporting from the Council for the Advancement of Science Writing for my work on scientific integrity for Science Magazine over the last 5 years. 1/7 casw.org/news/charles-piller-wins-2025-victor-cohn-prize/
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Another retraction (#10?) for Srikanta Dash at @Tulane
I reported this to the journal and the university in March 2021 - more than four years ago.
Despite 10 retractions, he is still a full professor at @Tulane.
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0014480025000498 -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Here you go. There are probably many more, but this is what I got so far.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
An @Oncotarget pearl.
Find at least five sets of duplicated areas.
#imageforensicsPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Here you go. There are probably many more, but this is what I got so far.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
The Nobel Prize
@NobelPrize
BREAKING NEWS
The 2025 #nobelprize in Physiology or Medicine has been awarded to Mary E. Brunkow, Fred Ramsdell and Shimon Sakaguchi āfor their discoveries concerning peripheral immune tolerance.ā -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Heather
@HeatherR411
Well done rfk jr and trump.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mu Yang, Ph.D.
@mumumouse2
Three Masliah papers with prominent image clones have been corrected. Ask yourselves, if these were your papers, will you have this kind of luck? See my write-up on LinkedIn
www.linkedin.com/posts/mu-yang-11229436_this-masliah-pape⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
According to this genius,bacteria found in the brains of people dead from meningitis,are blameless - they were there to fix the body!
When rabies is found in healthy people who died from a dog bite..it was there to help!
A call from the Nobel Prize committee is surely imminent -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Mu Yang, Ph.D.
@mumumouse2
This Masliah paper has been corrected "In the published article, there was an error in Figure 3C as published whereby micro-repeats appeared in the panel corresponding to the hippocampus of the vehicle non-tg control image. The corrected Figure 3 and its caption appear below."
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The Editor in Chief at Nature is not a "Sir" - did you do any research at all, or are you just yelling dumb things into the void?
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I went for a nice swim (60 laps, just under 40 min), finished my peer review, did an interview with a journalist, and checked some papers for image duplications. Now I am ready for the weekend!
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
And, yesterday, we got our flu and Covid shots, one in each arm. So we are also ready for winter!
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
World-renowned wildlife photographer against the algorithm
@TimFlach and the new challenges he's facing against AI.
www.bbc.com/reel/video/p0m5sv1p/world-renowned-wildlife-p⦠-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The Editor in Chief at Nature is not a "Sir" - did you do any research at all, or are you just yelling dumb things into the void?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You started off standing up for science integrity, but you are showing your true colors now:
Defending pseudoscientific anti-vaxx grifters, resorting to libel, defamation, and harassment yourself, and going full-blown conspiracy-theory. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"Scientific Journals in the Hot Seat": In which our Ivan Oransky calls academic publishing a "hot mess."
www.insidehighered.com/news/government/science-research-p⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Laura Vater, MD, MPH
@doclauravater
Big news: The HPV vaccine is working. (And in many countries, itās on its way to eliminate cervical cancer.)
A study in JAMA Pediatrics with 2,300 women found that over 17 years, HPV infections dropped by 98% in vaccinated women (& 76% in the unvaccinated due to herd immunity). -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Hunterššš
@StatisticUrban
Youāll start seeing headlines like this much more often now.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This Moflin (Casio's AI pet) creeps me out.
I mean, is this her eye or her butthole?
I like to know which side of my pet I am looking at.
#moflin
www.inc.com/chloe-aiello/why-casio-just-launched-an-ai-po⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
UKRIO @UKRIO is introducing an Authorship Integrity Toolkit:
a set of practical, adaptable resources designed to support both individual researcher contributors in their day-to-day practice and organisations in developing policies and managing projects
ukrio.org/resources/the-authorship-integrity-toolkit/ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
JAMA
@JAMA_current
A large, rigorous study published in JAMA last year found no association between autism and #acetaminophen use in pregnancy after accounting for heritability.
Read this new interview with the studyās senior author about the findings. #paracetamol
jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/10.1001/jama.20⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
A Wiley journal has retracted two more papers by an Egyptian ob-gyn, bringing his total to 12.
obgyn.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jog.70094
Read our previous coverage.
retractionwatch.com/2025/08/06/biologically-implausible-d⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Editorial Expression of Concern for @ScienceAdvances paper by Thomas Südhof - it had some image problems, but others tried to re-create a figure from the raw data provided by Dr. Südhof.
The graph looked quite different š±
pubpeer.com/publications/C22E0805CB0B55CB7388F488611145
www.science.org/doi/full/10.1126/sciadv.aec3110 -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You started off standing up for science integrity, but you are showing your true colors now:
Defending pseudoscientific anti-vaxx grifters, resorting to libel, defamation, and harassment yourself, and going full-blown conspiracy-theory. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Catharine
@DrCatharineY
In honor and memory of Dr. Jane Goodall.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Adrian H
@Adrian_H
š¤
$SAVA -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Actually, I am considering regularly posting these insults - unkind words people publicly sling at me for criticizing science papers. It would make a nice blog post or a slide in my next invited keynote presentation. Thank you for sending me this gem ā¤ļø
#fafo -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Hey @Koertjes , can you elaborate why you think I am a criminal?
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I am sorry you have trouble reading a long article. Perhaps practicing reading fewer conspiracy tweets and more science articles.
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Wow you have gone full conspiracy. There are so many incorrect statements here that I am sorry you have trouble with critically thinking and being polite. Perhaps take a deep breath, pet a kitten, or take a nice walk.
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Actually, I am considering regularly posting these insults - unkind words people publicly sling at me for criticizing science papers. It would make a nice blog post or a slide in my next invited keynote presentation. Thank you for sending me this gem ā¤ļø
#fafo -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Wow you have gone full conspiracy. There are so many incorrect statements here that I am sorry you have trouble with critically thinking and being polite. Perhaps take a deep breath, pet a kitten, or take a nice walk.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
Nepartikelen, namaakcongressen - aan alle kanten wordt de betrouwbaarheid van de wetenschap bedreigd. In de @volkskrant-podcast Ondertussen in de Kosmos vertelde ik over deze en andere problemen die mijn boek Sloppy Science behandelt.
Nu te beluisteren: omny.fm/shows/ondertussen-in-de-kosmos/het-groeiende-prob⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
āCanadaās federal granting agencies are updating their research guidelines in the face of increasingly elaborate practices of scientific fraud.ā
universityaffairs.ca/news/granting-agencies-grapple-with-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I am sorry you have trouble reading a long article. Perhaps practicing reading fewer conspiracy tweets and more science articles.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Simon Maechling
@simonmaechling
Calling an expert a shill does not make your argument stronger.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
After weeks of removing an old shrub, loosening the clay soil with pumice and compost, repairing and extending the irrigation system, and two years of growing plant cuttings, I could finally plant my succulent rock garden this weekend!
#gardening #succulents -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
Sloppy Science in het nieuws: afgelopen zaterdag mocht ik over gesjoemel, competitie en andere problemen in de wetenschap vertellen bij Dr Kelder & Co op @NPORadio1. www.nporadio1.nl/uitzendingen/dr-kelder-en-co/9d9ac1b9-a0ā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You guys keep on repeating yourself - sending a flurry of demanding and accusatory emails without any concrete evidence (how on earth is a 2008 cartoon by Dr. Schneider proof that Dr. Wise is fraudulent???) is coming across as derailed and desperate.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Nick Mark MD
@nickmmark
So much nonsense here:
- Tylenol (under direction of a physician) is the safest pain med in pregnancy
- Tylenol is also safe in kids (much safer than Aspirin)
- MMR isnāt even available as āseparate shotsā
- separating vaccines isnāt safer
- itās Hepatitis (not āhepatitasā)
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Highly normal. Nothing to see here, folks.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Taylor & Francis has threatened legal action against @SciGuardians, an online group that has made allegations, based largely on vague insinuations rather than evidence, about the publisher and a member of its research integrity team.
retractionwatch.com/2025/09/26/taylor-francis-threatens-l⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
Superleuk: gisteravond de officiƫle boeklancering van Sloppy Science, bij Dekker vd Vegt. Fijn publiek, scherp interview door @havermarie en een geweldige introductie door Lebowski Publishers. Hoogleraar Klaas Landsman, lid van integriteitsorgaan LOWI, kreeg het eerste exemplaar.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Greetings from Paris!
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
What a strange comment. You are not blocked by me anywhere. You are making threatening comments. Just address the errors in your papers.
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Greetings from Paris!
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You guys keep on repeating yourself - sending a flurry of demanding and accusatory emails without any concrete evidence (how on earth is a 2008 cartoon by Dr. Schneider proof that Dr. Wise is fraudulent???) is coming across as derailed and desperate.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
How is a cartoon of a middle finger fraudulent?
You are really grasping at straws here.
Have you considered that the officially approved thesis might not have contained this image, but the uploaded version might have? -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
How is a cartoon of a middle finger fraudulent?
You are really grasping at straws here.
Have you considered that the officially approved thesis might not have contained this image, but the uploaded version might have? -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
New paper @PLOSBiology:
Ending publication bias: A values-based approach to surface null and negative results
journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.ā¦
'publication bias arising from the reluctance or inability to publish negative or null results remains a long-standing and deep-seated problem' -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Happy Friday to those who celebrate!
forbetterscience.com/2025/09/26/schneider-shorts-26-09-20⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
"Authors retract Science paper on controversial fMRI method."
www.thetransmitter.org/retraction/authors-retract-science⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Math has publication fraud, too.
retractionwatch.com/2025/09/24/math-has-publication-fraud⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Abstract deadline for the International Research Integrity Conference in Sydney, 16-18 November, is September 29!
researchintegrityconf.com
Speakers: Jennifer Byrne, Cyril LabbƩ, James Heathers, Ben Mol, Ivan Oransky, David Vaux, Annie Butler, and many more (me!). -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Let me introduce you to PubPeer and its plugin. Over 200,000 papers commented on (9,500 by me!) and counting.
pubpeer.com -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Let me introduce you to PubPeer and its plugin. Over 200,000 papers commented on (9,500 by me!) and counting.
pubpeer.com -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
#imageforensics - can you spot the panels that are identical or overlapping (and also an error in the labels under each panel)?
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof. Nikolai Slavov
@slavov_n
bioRxiv has a dedicated section for negative results.
Use it.
Share negative results.
Your colleagues will appreciate it. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
Alzheimerās paper retracted over apparent image duplication - after sleuth findings, including by @Thatsregrettab1 www.thetransmitter.org/publishing/alzheimers-paper-retracā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Liam Nissanā¢
@theliamnissan
BREAKING NEWS: TYLENOL RESEARCHERS FIND DISTURBING LINK BETWEEN DONALD TRUMP AND JEFFREY EPSTEIN
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Catharine
@DrCatharineY
This is why we fund science. And experimental gene therapy.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
David Gorski, MD, PhD
@gorskon
On Monday, the Four Horsemen of the Woo-pocalypse joined President Trump to blame autism on acetaminophen use during pregnancy. They couldnāt resist adding antivax misinformation as well. www.respectfulinsolence.com/2025/09/24/trump-rfk-acetaminā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Nick Mark MD
@nickmmark
Pulmonologist here -
This is a walnut. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
Vandaag is-ie dan echt officieel te koop, Sloppy science. Voor iedereen die een kijkje in de keuken van de wetenschap wil nemen en wil zien hoe er soms gemorst wordt.
Het interview dat ik over het boek had met universiteitsblad Vox staat nu ook online: www.voxweb.nl/bericht/hoe-verzonnen-data-neptijdschriften⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr Susan Oliver (PhD)
@DrSusanOliver1
Steve Kirsch can't understand why measles cases start rising when vaccination rates drop.
The Real Truther
@thereal_truther
š„ Dr. Dan Wilson schools tech millionaire Steve Kirsch & Pierre Kory on measles & vaccines
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Scott Kominers
@skominers
Woah I just noticed this correlation š¤Æ. At some point, do we need to consider the possibility that RFK Jr. is causing autism?
...š -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD DSc(hon)
@PeterHotez
āSick to My Stomachā: Trump Distorts Facts on Autism, Tylenol, and Vaccines, Scientists Say - my comments with ā¦@KFFā© ā¦@KFFHealthNewsā© ā¦@amymaxmenā© kffhealthnews.org/news/article/trump-autism-announcement-ā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
#imageforensics time!
This one is very easy. Nine panels, each from a differently treated group of mice.
Can you spot the overlapping panels? -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Jerome Adams
@JeromeAdamsMD
Yesterday 5 powerful men stood together in the WH and shamed:
- Pregnant women, told to "tough it out" through pain
- Moms of autistic kids, blamed for their child's condition
- Autistic people, called broken & in need of fixing
Can we all be kinder and less stigmatizing? šš½ -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Andrea C. Love, PhD
@dr_andrealove
If you didnāt know, Mehmet Oz has a financial stake in the company iHerb which sells: folinic acid supplements (folinic acid = leucovorin)
The lies about Tylenol, autism, and this ātreatmentā are ALL part of their grift. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Arthur Caplan
@ArthurCaplan
The announcement on autism was the greatest display of ignorance, unfounded blather, dangerous advice, recycled old nonsense and outright malpractice advice since Trump recommended bleach for Covid. A total laughingstock and embarrassment.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea
@jonathanstea
RFK Jr: āResearch on vaccines and autism has been suppressed.ā
PubMed: āHereās over 1200 research papers on vaccines and autismā¦
ā¦including this first one which is a meta-analysis showing that vaccines are not associated with autism.ā -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Vin Gupta
@VinGuptaMD
Tylenol use is safe in pregnancy, lowest effective dose.
Donāt listen to the utter nonsense emanating from the highest office in the land today.
Speak to your medical provider. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Krutika Kuppalli, MD FIDSA
@KrutikaKuppalli
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Timothy Caulfield
@CaulfieldTim
The MAHA "autism cause" BS checks a lot of MAGA boxes:
- Simplistic & wrong.ā
- Blame women & mothers. ā
- Blame "evil biomedicine." ā
- Fearmonger & stigmatize. ā
Ignore the noise. #sciencematters! -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Karly Kingsley
@karlykingsley
šÆ
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prof Peter Hotez MD PhD DSc(hon)
@PeterHotez
1/n Trump admin set to tie Tylenol to autism risk, officials sayā¦but my view: the published evidence is not very compelling with largest study finding no association, and a systematic review showing some studies linking it other not. This needs reframing www.washingtonpost.com/health/2025/09/21/trump-autism-annā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
Apparently RFK Jr will announce the "cause of autism" tomorrow
Spoiler - he doesn't know the cause of autism
He's gonna make something up to push his agenda -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Prachee Avasthi
@PracheeAC
In case anyone thinks ANY president can declare victory on a major medical advancement from secret information that the broader scientific community is unaware of, thatās literally not a thing. This isnāt how science works and among the reasons that a handful of secret people, no matter what their claimed expertise, should never claim to adjudicate scientific truth ā whether via journals or whatever the hell this is
Disclose.tv
@disclosetv
JUST IN - Trump says tomorrow will be the "biggest announcement medically" in the history of U.S., "I think we've found an answer to autism."
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
What a strange comment. You are not blocked by me anywhere. You are making threatening comments. Just address the errors in your papers.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Krutika Kuppalli, MD FIDSA
@KrutikaKuppalli
Funny how peer review is suddenly ācorruptāāuntil you realize it just means real scientists check and evaluate the work being published with actual scientific methods⦠and it didnāt support the pseudoscience youāre selling.
Nicolas Hulscher, MPH
@NicHulscher
š„RFK JR DECLARES WAR ON THE JOURNAL CARTEL: "We're probably going to stop publishing in the Lancet, New England Journal of Medicine, JAMA and those other journals because they're ALL CORRUPT."
Illegal retractions must cease immediately ā and justice must be served. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
What is criminal about pointing out mistakes in your papers, which you still have not corrected?
Instead of complaining here how mean we are to have found problems in 80 (!) of your papers, why don't you not correct them? Two examples: -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
What is criminal about pointing out mistakes in your papers, which you still have not corrected?
Instead of complaining here how mean we are to have found problems in 80 (!) of your papers, why don't you not correct them? Two examples: -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Neil Stone
@DrNeilStone
Of all RFK Jr's anti science crap..this for me is one of the very worst
The HPV vaccine is on the way to ELIMINATING CERVICAL CANCER in many countries
And he wants to stop it
For him..even cervical cancer is better than a vaccine
Sick
Camus
@newstart_2024
RFK Jr.: "Gardasil is probably the single worst mass vaccine that we've ever seen. This vaccine targets millions of preteens and teens for whom the risk of dying from cervical cancer is zero. Nobody in their right mind would ever take this vaccine if they actually read the clinical literature."
"Death rates in the Gardasil trials were 37 times the death rates for cervical cancer. Children who take that vaccine, the Gardasil vaccine, are 37 times more likely to die from the vaccine than they are to die from cervical cancer. The problem with Gardasil, like most vaccines, is it was never tested against a true placebo, an inert placebo."
"And the CDC and HHS say, if you don't test it against a true placebo, it's not science. You have no way of gauging whether the injuries you're seeing from the product are being caused by that product, or whether they're just bad, sad coincidences. The entity that is actually performing the study is, and paying for the study, is Merck."
"Merck got to decide which injuries were being caused by Gardasil and which were just bad coincidences. And because it had that power, it just wrote them all off as bad coincidences."
"You can do that when there's no placebo, because the injuries they were seeing in the control group, where the girls were getting aluminum neurotoxins, were identical to the injuries they were getting in the Gardasil group."
"So they said, well, we don't have to report any of these as vaccine injuries. They were able to license something that is insanely dangerous."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Stan van Pelt
@stanvanpelt
Ik schreef met chatGPT een nepartikel en publiceerde het in een wetenschappelijk vakblad met een chique naam. Vandaag beschrijf ik in @volkskrant dit groeiende probleem in de wetenschap. Het is een voorpublicatie van mijn boek Sloppy Science, nu te koop: www.lebowskipublishers.nl/boek/3331/stan-van-pelt-sloppy-ā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Charles Piller
@cpiller
Exclusive: Publisher investigating DNA contamination paper that authors say CDC vaccine committee will consider - re amazing detective work by @Thatsregrettab1 retractionwatch.com/2025/09/18/covid-vaccine-safety-acip-ā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
So, are you implying that there was no cancer before the pandemic, and that all cancers after COVID-19 were caused by the vaccine???
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
So, are you implying that there was no cancer before the pandemic, and that all cancers after COVID-19 were caused by the vaccine???
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Angela Rasmussen
@angie_rasmussen
Warning: side effects may include measles, mumps, rubella, varicella, diphtheria, tetanus, pertussis, hepatitis A, hepatitis B, pneumococcal pneumonia, meningitis, polio, COVID-19, and/or flu
Secretary Kennedy
@SecKennedy
Introducing "MAHA" ā the remedy Big Pharma doesn't want you to know about.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Dr. El-Deiry once again claims my concerns about his papers are about politics. Bollocks.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
First *stealthy* revision for the @tandfonline DNA contamination paper by @Kevin_McKernan @JesslovesMJK and @DJSpeicher.
Say goodbye to the World Health Authorization.
Say hello to the World Health Organization.
"This article has been corrected with minor changes." -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
More misleading content in the @tandfonline DNA contamination paper by @Kevin_McKernan @JesslovesMJK and @DJSpeicher... cherry picked quote that seemingly ignores the point of the cited paper.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Jonathan N. Stea
@jonathanstea
Is it too much to ask that the programmers of the bots take some science literacy courses?
Joy-Mari Cloete
@joycloete
Genetics is the product of diet and lifestyle.
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
There is no conspiracy or infiltration here. A growing number of science papers is flawed or fraudulent, and naive peer reviewers might not catch those errors. You are defending authors of those flawed or fraudulent papers.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
There is no conspiracy or infiltration here. A growing number of science papers is flawed or fraudulent, and naive peer reviewers might not catch those errors. You are defending authors of those flawed or fraudulent papers.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āExclusive: Publisher investigating DNA contamination paper that authors say CDC vaccine committee will considerā
āI have no idea how this paper could have made it through peer review,ā Patrick told @RetractionWatch
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
The move comes as the U.S. body tasked with making recommendations for vaccine use is scheduled to consider the safety of COVID-19 shots, and two of the studyās authors say their findings will be discussed.
retractionwatch.com/2025/09/18/covid-vaccine-safety-acip-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Sen. Bernie Sanders
@SenSanders
We are witnessing a full blown war on science, public health & truth itself.
Let me be clear: Vaccines have prevented more than 1.1 million deaths, 500 million cases of illness & 32 million hospitalizations.
That's a lot of moms and dads who don't have to bury their children.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Lucky Tran
@luckytran
IT'S OFFICIAL: Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York State, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island & New York City have formed the Northeast Public Health Collaborative.
The collaborative will issue their own vaccine recommendations and coordinate public health efforts. -
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Dr. Lucky Tran
@luckytran
Here are the first vaccine recommendations issued by the West Coast Health Alliance, which includes California, Washington, Oregon, and Hawaii:
-
Elisabeth Bik reposted
Nisha Patel, MD MS, Dipl of ABOM, CCMS
@DrPlantel
RFK Jrās attempts to undermine Dr. Monarez arenāt rooted in scientific disagreement, theyāre a campaign of gaslighting propaganda meant to punish nonconformity. When experts who follow the evidence are attacked for standing their ground, public trust in science suffers. We need debate rooted in facts, not in coercion or character assassination. And anyone that goes along with this is complicit in the demise of American public health.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The preprint claiming link between COVID-19 mRNA vaccines and 'transcriptomic dysregulation' and cancer (based on just 10 people who got cancer in the year after vaccination) has been withdrawn.
HT: Reese Richardson.
www.preprints.org/manuscript/202507.2155/v1
See: scienceintegritydigest.com/2025/07/25/preprint-claiming-t⦠-
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You are the one who is doing the harassment and intimidation, and it is sickening that you are using someoneās tragic death to promote your agenda.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Expression of Concern by @NatureMedicine for an Alzheimer's disease paper with so many problems that one needs to ask:
Why did the journal not just retract it?
Findings by @Thatsregrettab1 and me.
pubpeer.com/publications/4B5EC5C2438355518433F88F2AC7A8 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This new preprint was designed so poorly that it provides absolutely no proof that mRNA vaccines caused cancer/other diseases.
It compared 10 (!) handpicked sick patients to 803 healthy patients. And behold, they show different RNA expression profiles. Because they were sick. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A lovely reply by the author of a paper that I flagged for some unclarities on PubPeer š®
More here: pubpeer.com/publications/D37EC96AF7ABE6FD964C2348CB78B7 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I have only been telling you for 3 years that I am concerned about $SAVA Cassava Sciences and their alleged Alzheimer's Disease treatment.
This morning it was announced the Phase 3 trial failed.
www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2024/11/25/2986578/833ā¦
(yes, coming back to Twitter to tweet this). -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The punishment for science misconduct is ā¦. nothing. All these men are still running labs / paid professors.
Dan Elton š
@moreisdifferent
List of high-level Alzheimer's researchers accused of credible fraud:š§µ
#1 - Marc Tessier-Lavigne
Genentech pointed out problems in his 2009 Nature paper in 2012. After an expose by @tab_delete, he had to resign from Stanford Presidency, but can still run lab and do research. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This is why there should be repercussions for folks who cheat in science.
Dr. Nina Steele
@NinaSteele17
Got off this plane in tears. Not even sure what I was feeling. In awe of the cancer survivor who I met who was sitting next to me. Turns out his entire family had succumbed to lung cancer and he had survived. He noticed I was a cancer researcher as he saw me working on data. 1/
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Our group of #imageforensics experts @Thatsregrettab1 , @mumumouse2, @schrag_matthew, and myself are currently posting the problems we found in these papers.
We have now posted 118 of Dr. Masliah's paper onto @PubPeer. Follow our progress here:
pubpeer.com/search?q="Eliezer+Masliah"
Charles Piller
@cpiller
My new investigation for @newsfromscience: Did a top @NIH official manipulate Alzheimer's/Parkinsonās research for decades? Neuroscientist Eliezer Masliah found to engage in scientific misconduct; 132 of his papers fall under suspicion
www.science.org/content/article/research-misconduct-findi⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Wow! A retraction of an "External Qi of Yan Xin Qigong" paper- where the good master claims he can kill cancer cells from 7 miles away with his 'force'.
The authors tried to silence me with cease-and-desist letters which I ignored.
scienceintegritydigest.com/2019/05/24/external-qi/
pubpeer.com/publications/F5EE5695840C8FAE1A2B7B8F682FEF -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Twenty one (and counting) retractions for the @IHU_Marseille studies, but no word from French authorities.
'Laissez-faire'.
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
Alors que l'@IHU_Marseille @univAMU_Europe @aphm_actu reƧoivent une 21eme retractation pour problĆØmes d'Ć©thiques, il reste encore des 100aines d'Ć©tudes dans le mĆŖme panier (researchintegrityjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.11ā¦) ou avec des temps de reviews suspects (doi.org/10.1186/s12874-021-01304-y).
Il est à noter qu'aucun membre du gouvernement n'a encore réagit à cela alors qu'il s'agit très probablement du plus grand scandale de la recherche française. @sup_recherche @olivierveran @EmmanuelMacron @Sante_Gouv @CNRS @Inserm @patrickhetzel @gdarrieussecq @sretailleau @antoine_petit_ restent tous bien silencieux face à l'ampleur du scandale et malgré les quelques procédures engagés. Pire encore, le gouvernement et ses organes officiels, qui n'a pas fait son travail, ne fait pas non plus le boulot de protéger ceux qui l'ont fait (K. Lacombe, @fluidloading @Acermendax @DgCostagliola @p_pascariello @OlivierHertel @GarciaVictor_ @Mediapart @LEXPRESS @AlexSamTG @lockedfab @MicrobiomDigest @SmutClyde @lofficine_ ) contre les désinformateurs notoires qui s'en prennent à eux et qui ferment les yeux sur toutes les transgressions de @IHU_Marseille tout en accusant et insultant les lanceurs d'alertes. Je pense notamment à @MartinZ_uncut @xazalbert @france_soir @VBaudoux et leurs nombreux tweets autant à charge que dénués de preuves.
Pourtant, les preuves sont là depuis très longtemps. Cela fait maintenant 4 ans que les alertes sont autant dans la presse française qu'internationale, 4 ans que les critiques scientifiques sont publiés, 4 ans que les critiques sont intimidés, doxxed, menacés, harcelés. 4 ans qu'un traitement inefficace ET dangereux est recommandé par ce qui devait être le fleuron de la recherche française et qui est aujourd'hui devenu le fleuron de la rétractation, du manque d'éthique, et des problèmes méthodologiques.
MĆŖme le plus grand mĆ©dia scientifique Science a parlĆ© d'"Ć©chec Ć tous les niveaux" (www.science.org/content/article/failure-every-level-how-sā¦). Combien d'annĆ©es va-t-il falloir attendre encore?! -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Just some things that happened during my 10h flight from AMS to SFO:
* Two Didier Raoult retractions
* The SEC has filed charges against $SAVA
* @cpiller published an article about the 300-page dossier with suspect images from a top NIH official.
A good integrity day. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
We can often only catch the dumb fraudsters. Here is an example.
In October 2023, authors @AthenaAdvanced / @UniCamerino posted a preprint on @arxiv with clear sign of using ChatGPT.
This was noted by @gcabanac, and posted on @PubPeer in November 2023:
pubpeer.com/publications/3B9C593D02307E143F2E36181B8FA9
/ -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
After lunch: Gerben ter Riet, @grietter57, clinical epidemiologist at the Amsterdam University of Applied Sciences (HvA), with: "On Traitors of Truth, Merchants of Doubt".
GtR went to a conference that turned out to have been organized by fraudsters.
#openscienceweek2024 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This morning at the Paris Sleuths' symposium we are discussing what drives people to do fraud. Administrators love metrics! As long as we focusing on metrics, and the chance of repercussions is small, scientists will fraud. This has led to the explosive rise of paper mills.
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The current discussion focuses on some hilarious and ridiculous answers from authors in response to Pubpeer comments, and the evasive answers of journals who claim confidentiality or that 'the issue has been resolved'. Sometimes, vague legal threats are used to silence critics.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The Rise of the Science Sleuths
* When an Alzheimerās paper came under scrutiny, correcting the scientific record meant battling much bigger problems.
@JessicaWapner's longread about our work @undarkmag
undark.org/2024/09/11/the-rise-of-the-science-sleuths/ -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
'Dana-Farber CEO Laurie Glimcher to step down next month'
@GlobeNewsEd writes @BostonGlobe
The article only casually mentions (at the end) the ~50 concerning Dana Farber articles posted to @PubPeer, 11 of which were authored by Dr. Glimcher.
www.bostonglobe.com/2024/09/03/business/dana-farber-glimc⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
First-time scientific sleuths prompt nine retractions for neurosurgery group
RenƩ Aquarius and Kim Wever found unexpected problems in data in a total of 24 papers of a neurosurgical group in Taiwan
@youmshajekian reports @RetractionWatch
retractionwatch.com/2024/08/28/first-time-scientific-sleu⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
New preprint about mismatches between the brands of SEM microscope instruments mentioned in the Methods vs the brands shown on the figures, by @ReachRichardson et al.
osf.io/preprints/osf/4wqcr
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Exclusive: Thousands of papers misidentify microscopes, in possible sign of misconduct retractionwatch.com/2024/08/27/exclusive-thousands-of-papā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
AI can be used to make convincing looking fake data.
There is no way we can distinguish real from fake anymore.
It is safe to assume that genAI has already resulted in many fake papers. Scientific publishing is not prepared for this.
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Generative AI fraud example by me. The rightmost column of tumors was created by AI using the first 6 (supposedly) real ones. Time required: 30 seconds.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The staggering death toll of scientific lies
Scientific fraud kills people. Should it be illegal?
If research dishonesty is literally killing people, shouldnāt it be appropriate to resort to the criminal justice system?
@KelseyTuoc writes for @voxdotcom
www.vox.com/future-perfect/368350/scientific-research-fra⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Cassava Sciences ($SAVA) ended its defamation lawsuit against four short sellers/scientists who expressed doubts about its experimental Alzheimer's drug, after a medical professor whose research underpinned the treatment was charged with fraud.
Reuters U.S. News
@ReutersUS
Biotech firm drops defamation suit against short-sellers after researcher charged www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/bioteā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
How on earth did @SciReports approve this figure as an "uncropped" blot?
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This Nobel Prize winner has some explaining to do. So far, his long explanations do not address the @PubPeer concerns.
Based on previous @PubPeer posts, with additional findings.
Green signal (climbing fibers) looks identical between the two panels.
pubpeer.com/publications/F7C42C356B2E7049FDB68A434EF4F8 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Exclusive: Kavli prize winner @CHADNANO threatens to sue critic @raphavisses for defamation.
In 2018, they clashed at a meeting of the American Chemical Society, where Mirkin called LĆ©vy a āscientific terrorist.ā
@ellie_kincaid reports @RetractionWatch
retractionwatch.com/2024/07/16/kavli-prize-winner-threate⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I am often amazed of how if you put a bunch of random scientists together, the men are starting to collaborate and share stuff with each other, while interrupting, ignoring, and belittling the women.
How can we break this cycle?
(Going to my room to cry) -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The internet sleuths fighting fake research
@cheynederson @7ampodcast interviews @SmutClyde, who is part of a growing team of online āscience sleuthsā, combating the rising number of fake research papers being published.
7ampodcast.com.au/episodes/the-internet-sleuths-fighting-⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A retraction, 11 years after I reported this paper for plagiarism. This should have taken 11 minutes to investigate, not 11 years.
But thank you, @KargerPublisher for finally seeing the light.
pubpeer.com/publications/567C8B760F0D54CE69634523DCA50D -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Taking it back: A pilot study of a rubric measuring retraction notice quality
"We developed a rubric specifying seven criteria in order to judge whether retraction notices are easily and freely accessible, informative, and transparent"
Alyssa Shi et al.
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/08989621.2024.2366281 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Expression of Concern issued for Dr. Wang, collaborator of Cassava Sciences $SAVA, this one by Biological Psychiatry.
"These and other concerns are currently under investigation by the academic authorities at the City University of New York (CUNY)."
www.biologicalpsychiatryjournal.com/article/S0006-3223(24⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Fastest author reply ever @PubPeer?
#cornercloning observed in microscopy panels.
Author replied within an hour with original images from 20y ago! Originals do not have cloned corners, so photoshopping likely done by @PNASNews journal editors.
pubpeer.com/publications/C9E4F18C603C449A0CD32876B719A5Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Yes, that is what we call 'corner cloning'. Here, the journal staff presumably did not like the font type or size, and stamped some cells over it to replace it with a new label.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
OMG @Nature just retracted one of the Verfaillie papers @UMNews, 4.5 years after I reported it.
And without letting me know š¤Ø
www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07653-0
pubpeer.com/publications/DF95522E3585E37663CAD1972E70BD -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
So much looking forward to seeing this come out. This will be a fantastic book to read if you are interested in scientific research and integrity.
Charles is one of the best science journalists I know, always impressing me with his rigorous work and thorough investigations.
Charles Piller
@cpiller
Iām delighted to announce that my forthcoming book, "Doctored: Fraud, Arrogance, and Tragedy in the Quest to Cure Alzheimerās," will be published on January 14, 2025, and is available from your local bookstore, Amazon, and Barnes & Noble for pre-release orders. 1/4
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
JI: Post-publication critique is often limited by the journal (word count, time frame). This can be improved. How can we re-engineer the reward system?
There are many new ways of publishing science that may change the way we do science.
Thank you.
#wcri2024 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Hopping to a different room and catching the end of Ben Molās talk.
Ben is saying that 30-40 % of all clinical trial papers in his field (Ob/GYN) are fraudulent. This is causing women and children to suffer and āwe just donāt careā. Why does take retraction so long?
#wcri2024 -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Next: 'Mining tortured acronyms from the scientific literature' - Alexandre Clausse
Finding incorrect acronyms (e.g. "counterfeit consciousness (AI)") - we found 185 new fingerprints for the PPS: dbrech.irit.fr/pls/apex/f?p=9999:1
Tortured Phrases preprint:
arxiv.org/html/2402.03370v1
#wcri2024 -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
TF: We know where to put the word "apple" in this graph, but contexts matters (if graph provides both fruits as well as computer-related companies).
#wcri2024Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
SB: We lose knowledge if we rely on technology too much. Using GPS tools makes us lose the ability to read a paper map.
TF: GenAI can offer non-English scientists help.
SEE: I am not using a washing board, I use a washing machine. We use the tools we are offered today.
#wcri2024
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
My name has been mentioned at least two times this morning, as a person who inspires others, but it is sad that I am not invited to talk at this conference :-(
Maybe in two years?
#wcri2024 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Opening plenary is a go! #wcri2024
800 registered participants makes this the biggest WCRI ever!
@WCRIFoundation -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Published today:
Finding the truth in science
In a āpublish or perishā culture, some scientists may resort to questionable research practices or even fraud.
www.nature.com/articles/s41568-024-00702-w -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The Long View on Health Care: The Change Hack, AI Bets & Health Techās Future20 min
@StatNews' Mohana Ravindranath @ravindranize will talk with Bob Kocher @bobkocher @Venrock about the future of digital health
#statbreakthrough -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Raoult / Limousin case: Guillaume Limousin RELEASED of the charge of public insult, RELEASED of the charge of defamation, Didier Raoult SENTENCED to 2000 euros for lawyer's fees.
A big win for @Sonic_urticant and scientific integrity!
Christian Peltier Avocat
@AvocatPeltier
Affaire Raoult / Limousin : Guillaume Limousin RELAXĆ du chef dāinjure publique, RELAXĆ du chef de diffamation, Didier Raoult CONDAMNĆ Ć 2000 euros au titre des frais dāavocat.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
This is strange. The @WCRI, the Workers Compensation Research Institute, has blocked me.
Perhaps because there is also the World Conference on Research Integrity Foundation? @WCRIFoundation
But I have never tweeted to them (other than a reply to someone who had tagged them). -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The academic sleuth facing death threats and ingratitude: @lonnibesancon
'By examining scientific articles after they are published and exposing shortcomings, he has made himself an enemy of both researchers and publishers.'
phys.org/news/2024-04-academic-sleuth-death-threats-ingra⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
#pubpeerpearl
"who authorised you to scan data, pl. educate, you did not seek my permission before scanning my papers. Stop threatening. your intention seems to threaten people and destabilise workers."
pubpeer.com/publications/AED6292712233EB7FFB65E15147692 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Leiden University @UniLeiden starts dismissal procedure for professor and their partner due to undesirable behavior and scientific misconduct, including obtaining research material from third parties without permit.
Nineteen people have made statements.
www.universiteitleiden.nl/nieuws/2024/04/universiteit-lei⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Yay!
Three years after @raoult_didier @Pr_Chabriere_E and @IHU_Marseille filed a complaint against me for harassment and blackmail, the Marseille Procureur tells me today they could not find any grounds for criminal prosecution. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
New Expression of Concern for the @IHU_Marseille @raoult_didier group, in Letters in Applied Microbiology, about "the research ethics approval information referenced within this article".
HT: @LockedFab academic.oup.com/lambio/article/77/4/ovae039/7650012
pubpeer.com/publications/055E1F479BA5491DD848318297F7C1 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Three recent @SpringerNature retractions from the Zlokovic lab @KECKSchool_USC
link.springer.com/article/10.1038/s41591-024-02935-6
link.springer.com/article/10.1038/s41467-024-47285-6
link.springer.com/article/10.1038/s41591-024-02916-9
HT: @SmutClyde
Background info by @CPiller @ScienceMagazine:
www.science.org/content/article/misconduct-concerns-possi⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Jenny P. BerrĆo and @OKalliokoski did a systematic review of preclinical studies of depression and found that nearly 20% of 588 of those studies contained problematic images.
www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2024.02.13.580196v1
@Sumeet_kul reports @Nature. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Publishing negative results is good for science
My latest Editorial for @MicrobioSoc Access Microbiology, as part of their Negative Results collection.
www.microbiologyresearch.org/content/journal/acmi/10.1099⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Too Many Labs Run Like This
Derek Lowe writes about āa principal investigator steamrolling his own grad students and postdocs, hiding key details and pressuring everyone to get papers out no matter what misgivings they might be feeling.ā
www.science.org/content/blog-post/too-many-labs-run -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Today I will be giving a talk about my work at the @researchumcg
@univgroningen, hosted by @marcelvanvugt
It is a 2.5h train and bus ride, with a scary start (my planned train got canceled) but I am well on my way and itās a lovely early spring day.
View from my train: -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Last talk of the day will be: 'Tools and interventions to improve research' by Philippe Ravaud and @IsabelleBoutron
PR: How can we evaluate and intervene in scientific publications? The total time spend on peer review is estimated to be 100 million hours/year.
#inserm277 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
'Fraud and misconduct continue apace in Alzheimer's research, undermining progress in understanding and treating the disease, say investigators who endeavor to expose errors and misleading practices.'
@aliciaault writes @Medscape -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The coming two weeks I will be in Europe, giving talks in Bordeaux in France, Leiden and Groningen in the Netherlands, and Berlin in Germany.
This blue beauty @KLM will take me there today from @flySFO -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Didier Raoult and his institute found fame during the pandemic. Then, a group of dogged critics exposed major ethical failings.
With @LockedFab @MathieuMolimard
@GarciaVictor @lonnibesancon @LacombeKarine1
@cathleenogrady reports @ScienceMagazine
www.science.org/content/article/failure-every-level-how-sā¦
Lonni BesanƧon š«š· šøšŖ
@lonnibesancon
It is finally out!
@ScienceMagazine and @cathleenogrady cover our [@MicrobiomDigest @MathieuMolimard @lockedfab @GarciaVictor_ ] findings about @IHU_Marseille including questionable ethics (researchintegrityjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.11ā¦) & reviews (bmcmedresmethodol.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s128ā¦)
www.science.org/content/article/failure-every-level-how-s⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
It is frustrating if institutions come to the conclusion that there is no problem if concerns are raised.
Here, @unibielefeld concluded that āthe noise patterns of the different experiments are clearly differentā.
What do you think?
#imageforensics
www.pubpeer.com/publications/7DE708AD3016CD58F322A713AD1AAA -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The rat with the big balls and the enormous penis ā how Frontiers published a paper with botched AI-generatedĀ images
@FrontiersIn
scienceintegritydigest.com/2024/02/15/the-rat-with-the-bi⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āThe situation has become appallingā: fake scientific papers push research credibility to crisis point
Last year, 10,000 sham papers had to be retracted by academic journals, but experts think this is just the tip of the iceberg
@RobinMcKie @guardian
www.theguardian.com/science/2024/feb/03/the-situation-has⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
From a small town in Wales, a scientific sleuth has shaken Dana-Farber ā and elevated the issue of research integrity
@DrewQJoseph reports at @statnews about @addictedtoigno1ās work
www.statnews.com/2024/01/27/sholto-david-profile-dana-far⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Oh dear. @ThiemeIntl has published several papers by a Turkish professor, claiming that:
* #multiplesclerosis is a 'gift, test, or punishment from Allah',
* #multiplesclerosis is caused by 'spiritual distress'
* '#hijab protects women from sexual harassment'.
Urartu Åeker
@uosseker
Bir Tıp Fakültesi ƶÄretim üyesinin,MS hastalıÄının doÄa üstü nedenleri vardır; MS hastaları Allah tarafından cezalandırıldıkları ya da sınava Ƨekildikleri iƧim hastadırlar demesi en basit tabirle terbiyesizliktir! Bu Ƨƶp fikirlerini editƶryal bir makale olarak basabilmesi ise korkunƧ. Bilime adeta küfreden bu kiÅi nasıl Profesƶr olmuÅ gerƧekten ürkütücü! Kendisi ayrıca H-index in tek baÅına bir anlamının olmadıÄının da kanıtı olmuÅ zira h-index 34!
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
As of today, 458 papers by @raoult_didier et al. have earned @PubPeer comments.
pubpeer.com/search?q=authors%3A+"didier+Raoult"+OR+"d.+Raā¦
This might become one of the largest scandals - if not the largest -in microbiology/infectious disease research. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A retraction for @raoult_didier @IHU_Marseille by @BioMedCentral Microbiology.
This paper is one of 35 using the same institutional approval number, but lacking the required CPP (French IRB) ethics approval.
HT: @SmutClyde
bmcmicrobiol.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12866-02ā¦
pubpeer.com/publications/22CD1DE1EFAF7016CAFEC3BB502D6E -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
It was a busy year:
* 27 invited in-person talks at universities/ conferences * 21 webinars / online panels
* 83 interviews
* 1,121 papers posted @PubPeer.
* My work resulted in 48 corrections, 24 expressions of concern, and 145 retractions this year.
I will continue in 2024 ā¤ļø -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Support for @DataColada by @ACLU_Mass
"researchers who question seemingly established results, scientific orthodoxy, or prominent scholars are targets of defamation lawsuits, and that has a chilling effect not only on them, but on [...] the rest of the academic community"
šÆ
Cheshire
@Thatsregrettab1
Via @sharoz on that blue site:
Incredible @ACLU brief in support of Data Colada.
storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.mad.259933/g⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Male stock investor wants to sue a woman science critic because he thinks her reputation is dangerous. He wants me to stop and stripped of my PhD.
Please tell @mattNachtrab what you think of his plan to sue me - for being regarded an expert, I guess? -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Stock investor @MattNachtrab is now sending emails to journalists with a story pitch about my "pivotal role" in the insurance fraud that the uBiome founders (not me) have been charged with, and stating I should be sued and ostracized, because I am wasting everybody's time.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Science Sleuth Looks To Expose Research Fraud
Elisabeth Bik is on a mission to find scientific duplicates and fakes ā and thousands of people are watching.
@DrAnnaFunk interviewed me for @DiscoverMag
Photo credit: @clara_mokri
www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/science-sleuth-look⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Oh for fox' sake, @SciReports, this is embarrassing.
For nearly 10 years, I have been reporting image duplications. This should never have passed through your quality control.
You have a quality control, do you? -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Scientific publishing is a very profitable business, but without adequate quality control and costumer service. Where does all that money go to?
Publishing with Integrity
@fake_journals
.
How the Big Five Academic Publishers Profit from Article Processing Charges
Spoiler alert : Their revenue was over US$ 1 billion between 2015-2018
A recent paper looks at the "big 5" publishers (@ElsevierConnect, @Sage_Publishing, @SpringerNature, @tandfonline and @WileyGlobal) and estimates their revenue from Article Processing Charges (APCs).
Here are the messages we took from the paper:
1⣠Between 2015-2018 it is estimated that authors paid $1.06 in publication fees to these five publishers.
2⣠Springer-Nature made the most revenue ($588.7 million) followed by Elsevier ($221.4 million), Wiley ($114.3 million), Taylor & Francis ($76.8 million) and Sage ($31.6 million)
3⣠The data was collected from @Clarivate, @unpaywall, open datasets of APC list prices and historical prices retrieved from @waybackmachine.
4⣠The APC's used in their calculations were based on those used in the year the paper was published. This is to be applauded. It would have been MUCH easier to take the current APC's but this would over estimate the revenue.
5⣠To give an example of how the APC's could have been over estimated, a Wiley journal, in 2015 charged $3,000. In 2023, the fee is $4,020. If you used today's fee for a 2015 article the over estimate would be 34%.
6⣠The number of #openaccess articles over the four year period of study (2015-2018) increased from 91,375 articles in 2015 to 153,746 articles in 2018.
7⣠Over the four-year period studied, it is estimated that Scientific Reports obtained $105.1 million in APC's and Nature Communications obtained $71.1 million. These journals are both published by Springer-Nature.
8⣠The high income of Scientific Reports can be partly explained by the fact that it published 73,206 articles.
9⣠Three Springer-Nature journals had the highest average APC's; Diabetes Therapy ($5,478), Infectious Diseases and Therapy ($5,295) and Rheumatology and Therapy ($5,169)
šThe three countries that paid the largest amounts of APC's were USA, $184.7 million; China, $148.0 million and the UK ($134.6 million)
You can access the article here: doi.org/10.1162/qss_a_00272
Tag: @mitpress | @LeighkButler | @l_matthia | @marcandresim | @philippemongeon | @stefhaustein -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Just a reminder that @ingentaconnect still charges $107.14 (plus tax) for this crap. I reported this to the journal in September 2019, over 4 years ago.
Science publishing has a lot of rotten apples.
pubpeer.com/publications/B39BB2A71719B884161F87ACEFF382 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
After all the work that @gcabanac et al. did on #torturedphrases in 2021, it is unbelievable that @sciencedirect's Molecular Aspects of Medicine published this plagiarized/synonymized text in Sep '23. And it got accepted in 2 days!
linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0098299723000535
pubpeer.com/publications/7D92D652EDCCFC385DE8EF5F97163C
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You have to ask yourself the question if @ScienceDirect / @ElsevierConnect is just asleep at the wheel at this point. How can phrases such as "strong dystrophy", "insusceptible framework" (immune system), and "viral contaminations like Guides" (AIDS) slip through peer review?
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Poetry written by an Assistant Professor at @univmiami who likes to publish in predatory journals.
#torturedphrases -
Charles Piller
@cpiller
Iām honored to be a winner of the National Academies/Schmidt Award for Excellence in Science Communications, for stories highlighting signs of misconduct in Alzheimerās research thanks to courageous whistleblowers like @schrag_matthew #sciencejournalism @scicommexcellence
News from Science
@NewsfromScience
Congratulations to @cpiller, winner of an Eric and Wendy Schmidt Award for Excellence in Science Communications in the Science Journalist: Freelancer category. @SciCommAwards www.nationalacademies.org/programs/NAE-NAM-22-P-489/past-⦠š
Hereās a look at his winning stories. (THREAD š§µ)
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Wow, congratulations, Charles! Well deserved!
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Here is a wild @RetractionWatch story from last week.
The @CHUDijon professor did some careful checking and *then* noticed he was not the author - despite he is listed as the corresponding author.
I did a plagiarism analysis and found that the whole paper was copy/pasted.
/
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Exclusive: Professor in France blames alleged ghostwriter for plagiarism.
retractionwatch.com/2023/10/19/exclusive-professor-in-fra⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A big congratulations to @DrNancyOlivieri and
@cbpolis for winning the 2023 #maddoxprize and #earlycareermaddoxprize.
Two fantastic women who stood up for good science despite lots of pushback.
Sense about Science
@senseaboutsci
Weāre thrilled to announce the winner of the 2023 #maddoxprize is @DrNancyOlivieri! @cbpolis has been awarded the Early Career Prize. Both have shown courage and dedication to communicate evidence for the public good despite facing hostility and threats senseaboutscience.org/activities/maddox-prize-2023/
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Hey, @SpringerNature, in August 2018, you stated on @RetractionWatch that you would investigate concerns raised about this Cell Stress and Chaperones paper, DOI: 10.1007/s12192-012-0379-6
I reported these problems in March 2016.
What is taking so long?
pubpeer.com/publications/643AA997D011E17900857A66A51D37 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Paper mills are openly advertising authorship positions for sale. These papers might be real or fake, but the authors who buy these positions will not have contributed scientifically. They just paid money to get their name on these papers.
Authorship for sale
@author_for_sale
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
An Italian newspaper has found duplicated images in eight cancer papers co-authored by the countryās minister of health, Orazio Schillaci
@mcatanzaro reports @ScienceMagazine
www.science.org/content/article/possible-misconduct-foundā¦
Andrea Capocci
@andcapocci
Anche per @ScienceMagazine - che ha fatto verifiche indipendenti da @ilmanifesto - le immagini duplicate dal ministro della salute Orazio Schillaci richiedono una spiegazione urgente. @mcatanzaro @MicrobiomDigest
www.science.org/content/article/possible-misconduct-found⦠-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I had many European hosts telling me this, but none followed up š¢
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Breaking:
Eight scientific papers co-authored by the Italian Minister of Health and former Tor Vergata University rector have duplicated or recycled photos.
Duplications found or verified by @ImageTwinAI.
@andcapocci reports @ilmanifesto
il manifesto
@ilmanifesto
In almeno 8 articoli scientifici firmati da Orazio Schillaci, per validare i risultati sono state utilizzate immagini non pertinenti, riciclate da ricerche diverse o addirittura modificate. Il ministro a @ilmanifesto che lo ha scoperto: «mi sono fidato»
#14settembre -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
After the coffee break, the conference continues with the @ISBSIB SIB Bioinformatics Awards Ceremony, with session chair Robert Waterhouse @rmwaterhouse
Three categories:
* PhD Paper Award
* Early Career Award
* Innovative Resource Award
www.sib.swiss/bioinformatics-awards
#bc2baselPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The second @ISBSIB award, the Early Career Award, is presented by Laurent Gatto to Maria Brbic @mariabrbic, for her outstanding work and expertise in machine learning and applications in biomedicine.
#bc2baselPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Maria Brbic @mariabrbic : We developed STELLAR, a geometric deep learning method for cell-type discovery and identification in spatially resolved single-cell datasets.
www.nature.com/articles/s41592-022-01651-8
#bc2basel
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Thirdly, the @ISBSIB Innovative Resource Award is handed out by Laurent Falquet.
It goes to Thomas Roder @__ThomasRoder__ for the development of the OpenGenomeBrowser.
#bc2basel
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Thomas Roder @__ThomasRoder__ :
OpenGenomeBrowser: a versatile, dataset-independent and scalable web platform for genome data management and comparative genomics
It allows efficient access to genomes, pathways, gene comparisons of e.g. bacteria.
#bc2basel
bmcgenomics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12864-022⦠-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
JF @jefworks ends with:
* Machine learning tools will always give you *a* solution. You will have to decide if it is the right solution.
* We much emphasize transparent algorithms (open code, open training data, reproducible).
* ML is augmentation, not replacement.
#bc2basel -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
On my way to the @BC2Conference in Basel, Switzerland, where I will give the opening Keynote.
Looking forward to this conference and meeting some of my tweeps. See you there?
www.bc2.ch/scientific-programme
Biozentrum, University of Basel
@biozentrum
Join the @BC2Conference in Basel from 11 to 13 September 2023.
Only 4 days left for registration.
Great opportunity to meet scientific leaders in the fields of #bioinformatics and #compbio.
@NimwegenLab @biozentrum -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
DM'ing the wrong person.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
In two-thirds of the image-concerns that I reported to journals in 2015, no action was taken. Here is an example of a paper where the Editor in Chief apparently thought these concerns were not valid. First author is lead scientist at @ncats_nih_gov.
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Proud to have won the July 2023 @aimos_inc AIMOS Commendation Award.
Thank you, Association for Interdisciplinary Metaresearch and Open Science for recognizing my work on scientific integrity.
aimos.community/winners -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You are asking the wrong person.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
That was a fantastic presentation by @Magda_Skipper.
Lots of things to think about and improve. Glad to see one of the leading scientific publisher doing so much to make science available and equitable for all.
#science4all23 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A very, very easy #imageforensics challenge from my London hotel room. Produced courtesy of @harvardmed and two RO1 grants.
Can you spot the duplication? Yes, you can! -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A Nobel laureate claimed antimale discrimination. An early-career researcher called it out | Science | AAAS www.science.org/content/article/nobel-laureate-claimed-anā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Wow, this is pretty blatant.
Author has gotten acceptance letter for their paper from the journal "Molecular Biology and Evolution", and now authorship positions are being sold on @facebook for 5K or more.
#papermill -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
#imageforensics - more from @DukeU, this time published in @AJPLung.
Can you spot the overlap?
Groups A-D are 4 different groups of human subjects, each assigned to a different exercise program. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
French medical bodies on Sunday called on authorities to punish researcher Didier Raoult for "the largest 'unauthorised' clinical trial ever seen" into the use of hydroxychloroquine to treat Covid-19 www.france24.com/en/europe/20230528-french-researchers-slā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Retraction of another Gregg Semenza (Lasker/Nobel Prize) article, by @oncogenejournal
www.nature.com/articles/s41388-023-02720-8
Although the retraction notice is detailed, it unfortunately does not mention the efforts of the people who flagged this paper on @PubPeer.
pubpeer.com/publications/0694D956FA93FB972962C5C5C150D7 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Fake scientific papers are alarmingly common
But new tools show promise in tackling growing symptom of academiaās āpublish or perishā culture
@JeffreyBrainard reports @ScienceMagazine
www.science.org/content/article/fake-scientific-papers-ar⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Currently, I am working on a set of papers from one researchers that all appear to re-use figure panels from older papers by other authors.
@ImageTwinAI has been instrumental in finding the original figures.
Here is one example.
/ -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
It is just forking unbelievable that @NatImmunol addressed this artwork by a correction, allowing the authors to send in a clean photo.
Science should be self-correcting, but not like this, folks.
#imageforensics
www.nature.com/articles/ni1468
pubpeer.com/publications/CC6CB43A9734138F31EA9094119D9E -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Research misconduct allegations put Stanfordās president ā and science ā under an uncomfortable spotlight
'Itās the one thing everyone knows. And itās the last thing people want to talk about openly.'
@JonathanWosen reports @statnews
www.statnews.com/2023/04/06/research-misconduct-allegatio⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The organizers of the @RICAIFrance (Interdisciplinary Anti-Infectious Chemotherapy Meeting) initially asked me to give a talk at their December 2023 meeting.
But they now decided "to select only French born speakers".
That is just ... wow. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Here is a first for me:
Journal editor reprimands me for sending list of 25 papers by same author, published in different journals, because that introduces "bias into the process." They told me I should send concerns "without mention of unvalidated concerns at other journals." -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
One of the worldās most cited scientists, Rafael Luque, suspended without pay for 13 years
The prolific chemist, who has published a study every 37 hours this year, has been sanctioned by the University of Córdoba
ā¦@manuelansedeā© reports english.elpais.com/science-tech/2023-04-02/one-of-the-wor⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Vaccines work.
Despite what thousands of paid Twitter blue checks might want you to believe, vaccines work.
ourworldindata.org/covid-deaths-by-vaccination -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Whoa.
Manuscript sent to @ScienceDirect's International Journal of Hydrogen Energy gets desk-rejected because it did not have enough citations from its own journal.
That is one way to get an impact factor of 7. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A statement often used by authors or institutions, that manipulated images "do not affect the interpretation or conclusions of the paper" should not have much weight during an investigation.
Image manipulation undermines the trust a reader has in the rest of the data. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A very basic #imageforensics involving a Western blot duplication. Can you spot the inappropriate duplication?
GBC-SD and NOZ are two different types of cells.
This one is super easy! -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I have little hope that there is any moderation left on this platform, but can I ask everyone to please report this account for repeatedly tweeting stuff like this to attack anyone critical of Cassava Sciences $SAVA?
#antisemitism -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
āIām nauseatedā: Alzheimerās whistleblower finds possible misconduct by his mentor in their papers
@schrag_matthew investigated his old publications after they were flagged on the PubPeer website
www.science.org/content/article/i-m-nauseated-alzheimer-s⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
So thrilled to see my Opinion piece for @nytopinion in @nytimes print edition today!
Here's an unpaywalled link to the online version with great animations and graphics by Gus Wezerek and Timo Lenzen.
Thank you @acsifferlin & @jashkenas for inviting me.
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/10/29/opinion/science-fr⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Science Has a Nasty Photoshopping Problem
* Unfortunately, many scientific journals and academic institutions are slow to respond to evidence of image manipulation ā if they take action at all.
My opinion piece @nytimes - #mygiftarticle
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2022/10/29/opinion/science-fr⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Full support for @marwa_zaatari who spoke out against a company that put many barely-working air purifiers into schools, aided by COVID-19 federal funds.
Global Plasma Solutions is suing Dr. Zaatari for 12 million dollars. She needs $$ to defend herself.
www.gofundme.com/f/help-to-cover-legal-costs-of-whistlebl⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Hydroxychloroquine in Australia: a cautionary tale for journalists and scientists
Great reporting by @joanna_mcc reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/hydroxychloroquine-aus⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
How a scandal in spider biology upended researchersā lives
'Although Jonathan Pruitt, the researcher at the centre of a retractions scandal, has resigned, former lab members and collaborators continue dealing with the fallout.'
@maxdkozlov reports @Nature
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-022-02156-2 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The U.S.Department of Justice has opened a criminal probe into Cassava Sciences $SAVA after allegations that the biotech company manipulated research results for its experimental Alzheimer's drug.
@marisaataylor and @mike_d_spector report at @Reuters
Reuters
@Reuters
Exclusive: Cassava Sciences faces U.S. criminal probe tied to Alzheimer's drug, sources say www.reuters.com/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/excluā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Image fabrication is bad.
But equally bad is the lack of willingness by scientific journals to seriously investigate these issues.
Too many journal editors do not reply or are brushing away these concerns.
A little thread.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Potential Fabrication Research Images Threatens Key Theory Alzheimer's Disease
A neuroscience image sleuth finds signs of fabrication in scores of Alzheimerās articles, threatening a reigning theory of the disease
www.science.org/content/article/potential-fabrication-resā¦
@cpiller writes for @ScienceMagazinePost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
And then this highly cited Alzheimer's Disease paper, published in @jclinicalinvest.
@schrag_matthew and several @PubPeer commenters raised serious concerns.
But the JCI editor "declined to consider Schrag's findings"
š±š¢
www.science.org/content/article/potential-fabrication-resā¦
pubpeer.com/publications/603286311C3DC6766716B01565CA72
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
If journal editors are not even willing to look at these concerns, we have to wonder if journals and publishers are not interested in quality control. Do they just pump out and sell papers (which we write and peer review for free) without customer service?
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Potential Fabrication Research Images Threatens Key Theory Alzheimer's Disease
A neuroscience image sleuth finds signs of fabrication in scores of Alzheimerās articles, threatening a reigning theory of the disease
www.science.org/content/article/potential-fabrication-resā¦
@cpiller writes for @ScienceMagazine -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
PubPeer commenters: There are some unexpected and duplicated coordinates in Table 1.
Authors: "we created this table in Excel and the reason why some numbers were repeated was Excel's problem, not the author's problem"
#pubpeerpearls @PubPeer pubpeer.com/publications/FC000741FA2BC520ED94BDA62EF2FA -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Apparently, @JACCJournals and @ACCinTouch are completely cool with image manipulation.
Feel free to publish your photoshopped images in #jacc with IF 24.
This paper got corrected by just removing three figures.
#badeditorialdecisions #cormatrix
pubpeer.com/publications/641234EE4CCA4EE9B65220423F9E64
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The #jacc Editors wonāt investigate because ā(t)here is simply no pathway to validate the claims that three of the figures had panels with duplicative data, without the original data.ā
Well, how about using your eyes?
See my post from two years back: scienceintegritydigest.com/2020/04/13/jacc-wins-the-firstā¦Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I guess the @JACCJournals update is that the paper got corrected by just removing the three offending figures.
So much for a thorough investigation. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Reading:
[Preprint]: Better Living through Coordination Chemistry: A descriptive study of a prolific papermill that combines crystallography and medicine - David Bimler
At least 648 papers, different authors, different journals and publishers.
www.researchsquare.com/article/rs-1537438/v1
#papermills -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Am I really in the wrong here? I do not understand how fixing this image with a new figure is totally fine. And I am even more sad that @C0PE said the journal followed correct procedures.
-
FEMS
@FEMSmicro
It is our great pleasure to recognise Prof. Isabel SĆ”-Correia and Dr Elisabeth Bik (@MicrobiomDigest) with the FEMS Special Merit #award! š
@istecnico @IntMicroDay
Read more about the the awardees contributions to microbiology and it's community: fems-microbiology.org/prof-isabel-sa-correia-and-dr-elisaā¦
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Thank you so much for this award. I am thrilled and honored. My work is often met with inertia or unkind replies, and this recognition will strengthen me to continue exposing errors and misconduct. And congrats to Dr. SĆ”-Correia!
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
In September 2019 reported this paper to both Editors in Chief of @ScienceDirect's Materials Chemistry and Physics - with a cc to Elsevier integrity folks.
No response. No action.
This is outrageous.
pubpeer.com/publications/BB21A28F6DF3E0859BE60440188F81 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
VojtÄch Adam resigned from the position of Rector of Mendel University in Brno. The expert commission, initiated by former rector DanuÅ”e NerudovĆ”, found several mistakes in professional articles where Adam was a co-author
(Google translation) -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I strongly urge @MENDELUcz to reconsider this decision. Not only will his appointment be considered by good students or researchers looking for university to study at, it might also influence the willingness of international researchers looking for collaborators.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
#imageforensics - Published in @NatureCellBio in 2002, cited 266 times.
Can you spot something not right? -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
In 2014 and 2015, I reported a set of 782 papers with image duplication issues to their respective journals.
Now, six years later, 445 of these papers (57%) still have not been corrected or retracted.
Here is a thread with some of them.
#imageforensics -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I am so, so, so grateful for this incredible honour. Thank you so much @senseaboutsci and @SpringerNature ā¤ļø
Sense about Science
@senseaboutsci
The John Maddox Prize 2021 goes to Elisabeth Bik, @MicrobiomDigest, Microbiologist and Science Integrity Consultant @SpringerNature
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The Weight Game: How Body-Size Bias Can Hold Back Health Science
For decades, assumptions about weight have clouded our view of health www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-weight-game-how-bo⦠via @sciam -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Immature techbros like Elon Musk might be one of the biggest causes preventing the advancement of women in academia and science.
You are missing out on half of the talented scientists and engineers, bro. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
More than 300 @IHU_Marseille papers @PubPeer with concerns on image duplication, unauthorized human subject research on homeless, minors, people in Africa.
No scientific answers from the institution.
Just ad hominems, insults, and legal threats.
I'm not going to be silenced. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A new rector was appointed of @MENDELUcz - unfortunately his @PubPeer record was not taken into account.
At least 10 of his papers have serious image problems.
Marta Siborova
@HangryHobbit
Dobry den, jake svetlo na uviverzitu vrha fakt, ze se o pozici rektora uchazi clovek jehoz publikace opakovane obsahuji potencialne upravena data?
pubpeer.com/search?q=vojtech+adam
Dekuji za odpoved -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Commenters on @PubPeer: This blot appears to contain duplicated parts.
Author: Ridiculous claims! You commenters manipulated the image! Slander!
Editor: All is well. Case closed.
#badeditorialdecisions #coldcases
pubpeer.com/publications/3047BD7A42742A62F0FCEEFFC322F3 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
New Microbiome Digest, September 6, 2021, by Axel Künstner @knstnr
* Vaginal microbiome during pregnancy
* Malagasy gut microbiome
* Fecal/saliva/chica microbiomes in Ecuadorian cohort
* Faith's diversity computation
microbiomedigest.com/2021/09/05/september-06-2021/ -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
French scientist who pushed unproven Covid drug faces being pushed out of the infectious diseases institute he founded, amid concerns from key members over its role in feeding conspiracy theories and an investigation by regulators into its clinical studies
www.theguardian.com/world/2021/aug/19/french-scientist-wh⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Those Anti-Covid Plastic Barriers Probably Donāt Help and May Make Things Worse www.nytimes.com/2021/08/19/well/live/coronavirus-restauraā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Reading:
When is āself-plagiarismā OK? New guidelines offer researchers rules for recycling text
www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/06/when-self-plagiarism-ok-n⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A piece by @ingfeichen in @NewYorker about my work spotting duplicated images and other concerns in scientific papers, the slow responses by journals and institutions, and the online harassment. And my turtle collection too!
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Congrats, @edyong209 for winning this well-deserved prize! Such important work, and I am so happy it got recognized.
The Atlantic
@TheAtlantic
The Atlanticās @edyong209 has won the 2021 Pulitzer Prize in explanatory reporting. In a series of articles, Yong anticipated the course of the coronavirus pandemic, clarified its dangers, and illuminated the American governmentās failure to curb it.
on.theatln.tc/cDiheCU -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Breaking news:
Just got another legal threat, now for my criticism of the "External Qi" papers. In those papers, a Qigong Master claims to treat cancer cells with his force. The lawyer representing the authors demands me to take down my Pubpeer postings.
(small thread)Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
But I stand with my right to have concerns about these papers, and to question the science behind the method that was used to kill cancer cells.
I hope you agree with me.
Science should be discussed by scientists, and the discussion should not be silenced by lawyers. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Top German psychologist fabricated data, investigation finds
* an investigation into one of his studies found evidence of manipulationāand elaborate efforts to cover up the misdeed
www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/04/top-german-psychologist-f⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Prey tell, what makes a publisher predatory? www.sciencemag.org/careers/2021/03/prey-tell-what-makes-pā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Wow. Just wow.
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Several people asked me what the worst journals are to respond to image duplication or other concerns and/or to retract.
Here are a couple from my list:
(thread) -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Whoa.
Jaap van Dissel, Infectious Diseases director at the
@rivm (Dutch NIH/CDC), stated yesterday that the high number of COVID-19 infections in nursing homes might have been caused by staff education level.
What a horrible thing to say. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Five years ago I found three possibly Photoshopped images in a @ScienceMagazine paper by the lab of @RPlasterk
Yesterday, the paper got retracted.
Here is what happened, and what went wrong or right.
pubpeer.com/publications/2B00E5BEB5B75B499550D03C15EFA4 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Just retweeting this, because if you read the whole thread, you will discover - with me - not only Two Papers with Identical Results, but EIGHT.
Eight papers from different authors, with different cancers, different proteins, but identical survival plots and risk data. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Agave update!
Our ~30y old Agave americana has started to bloom. The stalk could reach a height of 30 ft (10 m).
The plant will die after this event. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Wow. Preprint on patient group of 368 hospitalized veterans with COVID-19. Hydroxychloroquine treatment: *higher* death rates than treatment without HC.
"Rates of death in the HC, HC+AZ, and no HC groups were 27.8%, 22.1%, 11.4%, respectively."
www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.04.16.20065920v1 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I am ringing the alarm.
We have now found >400 papers that all share a very similar title layout, graph layout, and (most importantly) the same Western blot layout.
This is a massive #papermill of (what we assume) fabricated data. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
The paper titles use the same structure that is used in the large (over 300 cases as of now) presumed paper mill we are working on. But they have different western blots. Here is the background on that paper mill:
forbetterscience.com/2020/01/24/the-full-service-paper-mi⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Disappointed to read this article about the #microbiome industry, which mentions 17 men, but not a single woman.
I was interviewed 2h for this article.
Sad that women did not make the cut š„
#womeninstem
www.forbes.com/sites/susanadams/2020/02/07/drugs-from-bug⦠-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
You are completely in the wrong. The photo is MINE. My husband took this picture. I sent it to @RetractionWatch and they used it. It is MY photo.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I guess other people have to fix the spelling of my name. But I am not sure how to upload my own photos if that is considered against the rules. They are my photos, so I think I should upload them? How can that be a violation of copy right?
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
If my Twitter account suddenly goes silent, it might be hacked by order of certain authorities. Getting several warnings that this might occur.
Well, if that happens, it has been fun. I will reappear somewhere else. But I will not be silent. Love you all. -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
New post:
More troubles at Annamalai University
scienceintegritydigest.com/2019/11/08/more-troubles-at-an⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
In the Pancreas, Common Fungi May Drive Cancer
A new study found that certain fungi can settle in the pancreas, where they spur the growth of tumors.
www.nytimes.com/2019/10/03/health/pancreatic-cancer-fungi⦠-
NerdyByNature
@SimonDTweets
You must be going crazy, @MicrobiomDigest Now I see repetitive patterns everywhere I look. Level: easy.
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Hahaha here you go.
This floor would make me see colored boxes everywhere! -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
From a paper published in @nature yesterday by @HarvardMed scientists.
I just reported it to the EiC, with shaking hands and pounding heart because scary to see that this passed #peerreview and editorial screening in such a high impact journal. -
Post not available here, view on X
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
24 of the 25 recipients of the Russ Prize by @theNAEng are men.
53 of the 54 recipients of the Draper Prize by @theNAEng are men.
So 97.5% of the top Engineering awards go to men. How does that encourage women to pursue a career in Engineering, National Academy? -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
There Are 'Superbug' Genes in the Arctic. They Definitely Shouldn't Be There.
The findings underscore just how far and wide antibiotic resistance genes have spread, now reaching some of the most far-flung areas of the planet.
www.livescience.com/64599-superbug-genes-arctic.html -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
I have updated the Women in Microbiome Research list.
Over 400 names to help conference organizers.
#womeninstem
microbiomedigest.com/sample-page/women-in-microbiology-fo⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
MeFiT: Merging and Filtering Tool for Illumina Paired-End Reads for 16S
rRNA Amplicon Sequencing - Hardik I. Parikh
arxiv.org/pdf/1512.03342.pdf -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Disinfectable remote control in our hotel room. Really?
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Passive dust collectors for assessing airborne microbial material - Rachel Adams #microbenet
www.microbiomejournal.com/content/3/1/46/abstract -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Bacterial Biofilm Communities on Sprinklers from Dairy Farm Cooling Systems #microbenet
journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone⦠-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Humans differ in their personal microbial cloud @JamesMeadow @JessicaLeeGreen @DrMicrob @MicrobesRock @altrickter
peerj.com/articles/1258/ -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Interaction networks for identifying coupled molecular processes in microbial communities - Magnus Bosse #network
www.biodatamining.org/content/8/1/21 -
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
A great afternoon with the microbes @Micropia in Amsterdam - the only microbial museum in the world
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Jonathan Eisen: The Tiny World of Microbes Inside You #podcast @inquiringshow @SoundCloud @phylogenomics @microbiome soundcloud.com/inquiringminds/76-jonathan-eisen-the-tiny-ā¦
-
Elisabeth Bik
@MicrobiomDigest
Temporal variability is a personalized feature of the human microbiome -
Gilberto E Flores - @GenomeBiology genomebiology.com/2014/15/12/531
























































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































