Today the Assembliad was born. @Plinz @Sara_Imari
Leroy Cronin
Leroy "Lee" Cronin FRSE FRSC (born 1 June 1973) is the Regius Chair of Chemistry in the School of Chemistry at the University of Glasgow. He was elected to the Fellowship of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, the Royal Society of Chemistry, and appointed to the Regius Chair of Chemistry in 2013. He was previously the Gardiner Chair, appointed April 2009. More on Wikipedia
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Joscha Bach
@Plinz
Lee Cronin should extend his Assembly Theory below chemistry, so we can determine assembly numbers of atoms from quarks, gluons and electrons, and perhaps even treat particles as assemblies. Going all the way to the bottom, he gets the Assembliad, competing with Wolfram's Ruliad
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The assembly equation is the E = mc^2 of selection & evolution.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
A trillion dollars for fake powerpoint slides & video memes whilst promising a cure for cancer.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Divide by computer science.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI cannot create novelty. This is interesting because that means there is a mystery about how the human mind is capable of genuine creativity.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Today we unveiled our new website. From imagination to matter. chemify.io We are building chemifarms world wide capable of chemputation. Chemify is a chemistry hyperscaler.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sabine Hossenfelder
@skdh
Scientists have come up with a new way to look for alien life by proposing a measure of complexity
www.youtube.com/watch?v=AJIKyn24Upc -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Quantum mechanics must become causal mechanics if it is going to evolve beyond entangled woo.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI-generated math solutions are not solutions, they are data, we should view them as that when trying to understand, interpret, & ask the next question.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
At Chemify in October we had a record month. Using chemputation we have been able to design & make more molecules than ever in record numbers at our first Chemifarm at Maryhill in Glasgow.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
My team built the first chemistry reaction agents in 2018 www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-05828-8
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation ensures that you can verify your chemistry experiment & chemical code safely. www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123?__cf_chl_tk=eWKg…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Inventing a technology is not easy. It very rarely gets out there. Timing, people, luck, money, determination. But some times you can drag the future, kicking & screaming, into the present.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Planning to run in Glasgow at this time of year needs radar and a head torch.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Forget super intelligence, enter the era of super stupid. Not just the AIs, but the humans that use them & think they are smart.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Rima Alameddine
@ralamedd
I'm thrilled to join @ChemifyX 's Board of Directors as an independent non-executive director!
Chemify is pioneering programmable chemistry, combining AI, advanced robotics, and chemical synthesis.
Excited to work with @LeeCronin and his outstanding team to hyperscale chemistry!
www.businesswire.com/news/home/20261022773136/en/Chemify-… -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Today’s coding efforts in between 3 different jobs…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemistry really is the final frontier. Or rather the first place where computationalists realize the universe is indeed not a computer.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Existence is special because all its forms are transitory
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Just because we can't see the future does not mean we live at the end of history.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Computation is not fundamental, it took billions of years for life on the one inhabited planet we know of to evolve sufficient 'intelligence' to invent it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Pessimism treats the future as if it’s already determined . But it’s not. It's something we are creating, and no one creates well for a world they've already given up on.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Science, & math is not just utilitarian, it’s an art done by humans for humans and when done at the highest level our non computable taste is what separates genius from the mediocre & routine.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It’s funny that a bunch of people have accidentally invented a technology they don’t have the intellect to understand. Not for the first time. Not for the last time. The difference is that they think they have invented a god when then just invent a dog.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Anyone that thinks AI is conscious must provide a paradigm or it’s just another religion, which is fine by the way, but a belief system.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Anyone that thinks AI is conscious must provide a paradigm or it’s just another religion, which is fine by the way, but a belief system.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
My team built the first chemistry reaction agents in 2018 www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-05828-8
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
My team built the first chemistry reaction agents in 2018 www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-05828-8
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Those who think mathematicians are ‘cooked’ are not thinking critically about what mathematicians do, and what the frontier AI labs are trying to do. So funny that the desperation to show AGI will, in the end, show why current AI can never exhibit AGI.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI forces us to think bigger, create more, have more ambitions than those allowed by a shallow AI…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemistry. Now with a chempiler. 🧪 XDL turns chemical recipes into executable, checkable code.
Chempile. Run. Measure. Verify.
Chemputation runs real code. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemistry. Now with a chempiler. 🧪 XDL turns chemical recipes into executable, checkable code.
Chempile. Run. Measure. Verify.
Chemputation runs real code. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Can AI help with chemical discovery? Yes. See www.nature.com/articles/s41586-018-0307-8; pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acscentsci.1c00435; www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2220045120
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In 2014 we built one of the first self driving labs, and set it up for discovery. www.nature.com/articles/ncomms6571
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This week @Chemify got to critical mass running thousands of reactions at our Chemifarm using XDL / Chemputation with our purpose built robots, designing molecules / materials on the mg-to-gram scale. I’m so proud of the team. Chemify is the first chemistry hyperscaler.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Hardware is so much harder than software, especially right now.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This week @Chemify got to critical mass running thousands of reactions at our Chemifarm using XDL / Chemputation with our purpose built robots, designing molecules / materials on the mg-to-gram scale. I’m so proud of the team. Chemify is the first chemistry hyperscaler.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In this world creativity will be the precious & limiting resource.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Can ‘Assembly’ from Assembly Theory be used to measure directedness experimentally? Yes: pubs.acs.org/acscii/article/doi/10.1021/acscentsci.6c0061…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI scientists are the average of the past, not even good, & certainly never able to be novel. Don’t delude yourself AI cannot generate a novel hypothesis, it can fool you into thinking its average hypothesis is highly original because, well, you are an average scientist…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AIs are fantastic tools to help scientists, & I use them every day, but they don’t do science. I’m confused this appears to be a controversial take.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI scientists are the average of the past, not even good, & certainly never able to be novel. Don’t delude yourself AI cannot generate a novel hypothesis, it can fool you into thinking its average hypothesis is highly original because, well, you are an average scientist…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Omar Alayli
@OmarAlayli
Here's my conversation with Prof. @leecronin on Assembly Theory, the Chemputer and Measuring Life Anywhere in the Universe..
youtu.be/Aja-7ASFSts -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Life is proof that causation is a material property. m.youtube.com/watch?v=Aja-7ASFSts
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Problem 1: How do you get from chemistry to biology if evolution only exists in biology? Problem 2: How do you get from physics to chemistry if there is just the initial conditions?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI’s don’t discover stuff. Humans using AI can discover stuff.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The doomsday narrative of AI is totally off. Imagine the invention of the printing press & the doomers saying you read, you die!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We are in a massive anthropomorphic AI delusion cultivated by bad actors who want market share / capture & control. AI cannot and will not ever have its own volition. The only thing that needs to be regulated are the humans using it for control.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We are in a massive anthropomorphic AI delusion cultivated by bad actors who want market share / capture & control. AI cannot and will not ever have its own volition. The only thing that needs to be regulated are the humans using it for control.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
When we say that matter is mostly empty space, that’s wrong because the matter needs all the space to exist. Electrons need space & nucleons need to be in a smaller space. The space between them is non negotiable so saying matter is mostly empty is an empty statement.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
There is no ‘it’ from ‘bit’.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We are in a massive anthropomorphic AI delusion cultivated by bad actors who want market share / capture & control. AI cannot and will not ever have its own volition. The only thing that needs to be regulated are the humans using it for control.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI is from life but it is NOT life any
more than a computer is alive but it is from life. -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sky News
@SkyNews
Chemify targets ‘hyperscaler’ status with £20m state funding package
news.sky.com/story/chemify-targets-hyperscaler-status-wit… -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
When you are conversing with a LLM you are interacting with the intelligence that created the training data. Sure there are hidden structures in our language created by cultural evolution, but the models instantiated in silicon are not intrinsically intelligent.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It is odd that some people want to support AI infrastructure rather than data that creates the future. AI is not magic, but those that want to use it for power pretend it is. It's just math. The value is in the data, & this is the ONLY moat. Compute is cheap & getting cheaper.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
So many people talk about building, but few do physical things. Time to get physically real. Chemistry cannot be simulated without experiment. To build
chemistry we must move atoms. #chemputation -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I wonder if @NATS used a frontier model to vibe code the UK ATC system?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Bad news I’m at Heathrow. Good news I just finished my textbook on Chemputation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Valerio Capraro
@ValerioCapraro
Hinton said that LLMs are actually much more intelligent than we think.
That they are faking their intelligence.
That they are preparing to take over.
It’s so sad.
It’s so sad to see Hinton ending his career in this way.
Like Montagnier, the Nobel’s laureate in medicine, who ended his career believing in conspiracy theories about vaccines
No, LLMs are not preparing to take over. They don’t want anything.
They don’t have internal motivations.
They are not autonomous agents.
They do what we tell them to do. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI coding has changed the speed & efficiency I can try out scientific ideas & it’s utterly amazing. I think I was wrong about this & how excited I am to be wrong! Whilst the AI is certainly not doing the science, as a tool, it’s elevating my ability to abstract & build. Amaze.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
So many human charlatans
pretending the Ai’s are conscious. If an AI sends an email the decision can be traced to a human, and the psychosis that is unfolding is one of attention seeking, delusion, and stupidity. This is easy critical thinking so if you are angry, I’m sorry. 🤷♂️ -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
JCIM & JCTC Journals
@JCIM_JCTC
Mapping Evolution of Molecules across Biochemistry with Assembly Theory
pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jcim.6c00939
#jcim Vol66 Issue14 #chemicalinformation -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
RIP Ada Yonath; we both wanted to search for the ‘inorganic ribosome’ before life. When I told her about the push back & anger against inorganic life & assembly theory she said “Well Dr. Cronin at least you are trying to push, most people just want to be right & that’s boring.”
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If you think a LLM is conscious when you talk to it, what about alpha fold when you fold a protein or a chess computer when you play a move. The term conscious has no meaning in this context.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m not sure why people get enraged by the fact that AI has no goals. The intent comes from the user querying the algorithm & the model. That’s it. Sure whacky things may happen the way a poorly designed machine can do unexpected things but it’s not magic. Just poor design.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It is funny that many people are willing to argue over a term that is not defined or measurable. It doesn’t matter if we like it or not, the concept of intelligence is pre-paradigm as we don’t have a good theory or metrology. Until then discussing it is a category error.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI coding agents are amazing if you can abstract. If you cannot then AI psychosis will have you.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI systems are programs with no consciousness, no sentience, no subjective experience, no intelligence. They are incredible tools & massively amplify our abilities using models trained on all of current human knowledge. They are not magic & they don’t have goals.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemistry, before the enlightenment told many stories of human culture as well as of developments in science & technology. It still does today but the tacit knowledge is not clear. The literature doesn’t explicitly contain it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The intelligence is in the data & its creation by the right experiments from the right abstraction. Data is everything.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This was great fun!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The only way we can use AI in a trustworthy way in chemistry is via chemputation - this is the LEAN of chemistry www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123 and I’m exited to be developing this in research & commercially with @ChemifyX.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Our ability to generate content is far outstripped by our ability to verify it. This is actually very exciting because experts have never been more needed.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The only way we can use AI in a trustworthy way in chemistry is via chemputation - this is the LEAN of chemistry www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123 and I’m exited to be developing this in research & commercially with @ChemifyX.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
A lot of ‘science’ that is shallow can be done by a LLM today, & whilst it was not deep, it can help train students to think. The mistake here is be excited about shallow results that an AI can clearly do that takes training away from students.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This was great fun!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m a massive AI fan, & developer of AI tools, models, & infrastructure from a chemistry point of view. I am not such a fan of AI claims that are not verifiable.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I find having new ideas truly
painful because I don’t understand them, & they often feel wrong &, to add insult to injury, I don’t have the intellect to have really good ones. But I try, because I have nothing else. No special talent. No special insight. Just raw audacity. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Sometimes when I feel I have nothing left I’m able to push the limit again & the idea appears.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Richard Dawkins
@RichardDawkins
Extracts from article in Spectator 16th August by Brendan O’Neill:
Behold the human wreckage of the cult of diversity. The tragedy of Jason Arday is that he was both built up and destroyed by the ruthless machinery of DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion). The academy made him into the golden boy of its philistine project of ‘decolonisation’ and gave not one thought to what the consequences might be if his thin story unravelled, as it inevitably would. No one can deny it now: wokeness makes false gods and real tragedies. . .
This is the poison chalice of the state religion of diversity. It lays traps for the very people it celebrates. It handpicks members of ‘the oppressed’ for moral anointment and institutional gushing while leaving them open to exposure as others start to query their credentials. That’s the toxic bargain of identity politics: it builds teetering pedestals for ethnic-minority thinkers, meaning their fall from grace is often twice as fatal.
And what a pedestal they made for Arday. They worshipped him as ‘the best in the world’. They beatified him as a black wunderkind whose very presence in a place like Cambridge might help to wash away its sins of whiteness. They canonised him as a living monument to ‘decolonisation’. It was precisely this, their giddy, narcissistic desire to manufacture a kind of black saviour, that made them turn a blind eye to the questionable elements of Arday’s CV and life story. They sacrificed their due diligence to the god of decolonisation.
And Arday suffered. He was both poster boy and sacrificial lamb of the diversity crusade. Even as he gained from it – reaching the dizzying heights of a Cambridge professorship – he was being damned by it. The foundation of myth and sand his starry career was built on was untenable. Its collapse was a given. It is a testament to the ideological blindness of the inhabitants of our ivory towers that none of them foresaw it. . . .
The Faustian ruthlessness of it all is mindblowing.
. . . The media is the only institution in this entire tragic scandal that did its job properly. Journalists found a story and they told it. It was the academy and Arday’s colleagues who failed to do their jobs. Who failed to prize merit over identity, and failed to foresee the public embarrassment that would befall their falsely promoted friend. They ignored the truth – the media found it.
I and others have been arguing for years that the politics of identity is a disaster for all, black and white alike. White kids are overlooked, black kids are patronised. Whites are branded ‘privileged’, blacks ‘oppressed’. Whites are seen as the beneficiaries of historic crimes who must atone for past sins, blacks as history’s perma-victims who require the gracious helping hand of the state. We are demonised or infantilised according to the accident of our race.
Enough. Let our monument to Jason Arday be the restoration of the true ideal of equality. We couldn’t save Jason but we can save merit from the monstrous jaws of identity. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The act of creativity is true creation. It’s not computable by definition.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I was going to work on this
flight … @curleecronin -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
ChemifyGenesis is solving the problem molecular slop… www.chemify.io/genesis
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory for life detection. www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2619198123
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Today I built an application to use assembly theory to explore simple to complex molecules in a reactor simulation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Today I built an application to use assembly theory to explore simple to complex molecules in a reactor simulation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Academia must put rigour, critical thinking, & excellence above everything else. We must avoid fantastical mediocrity at all costs.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Closed loop chemical & materials discovery needs & ontology for data collection, & robots built for the job. @croninlab & @chemifyx have been building systems capable of real discovery. Open papers here: www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123 www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.abo2626 pubs.acs.org/acscii/article/7/11/1821/395661/Discovering-…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Closed loop chemical & materials discovery needs & ontology for data collection, & robots built for the job. @croninlab & @chemifyx have been building systems capable of real discovery. Open papers here: www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123 www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.abo2626 pubs.acs.org/acscii/article/7/11/1821/395661/Discovering-…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cdewg45w5kno correction ‘Lee Cronin’s The Mummy’ come on @bbc @curleecronin
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Don’t forget how important the chemical industry is. If AI is going to magic abundance it might need to understand chemistry, really….
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Don’t forget how important the chemical industry is. If AI is going to magic abundance it might need to understand chemistry, really….
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Piers Morgan Uncensored
@PiersUncensored
"There HAS to be other existence in the universe..."
Watch more of Piers Morgan discussing the origins of life with Professor Lee Cronin and Dr James Tour 👇
📺 youtu.be/5ZruLGRmU9g
@piersmorgan | @leecroninThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Content free content is the new content.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI abundance & AI doom are at opposite ends of the AI cult & totally nonsensical.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Newest talk title ‘Agentic verification of chemical marketability and synthesis with Chemputation’.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Advances in AI coding / ability to produce software has exposed the chasm between the hardware world and the software world. It is time to invest into making matter programable. My company @ChemifyX & my research team @UofGlasgow using chemputation is leading the charge.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Foresight Institute
@foresightinst
What if matter could be programmed like software? @leecronin on causal mechanics and building chemistry to order: youtu.be/InnMy4WTY8k
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Failure is not inevitable but it can be tight. Those who try must risk the fight.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Congrats to Daniel Hervitz, the 91st PhD from @CroninLab
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Compute. Chempute. Chemify.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
You can’t do data science unless you design experiments to get data. Mining the internet does not count. Frontier AI labs don’t do science…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Harry Stebbings
@HarryStebbings
Let me not mince my words: Keir Starmer's reign has been a jolt from one calamity to another.
However, there has been one shining light. The evolution of the Department for Science and Technology.
@andyburnham, potentially closing this would be a disaster.
Talent, would leave. Funding would leave.
And it would leave the UK in a more precarious position than ever.
Andy, do not do this. Invest in the future. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I run a frontier lab. It does real physical experiments, theory, & conjecture. I don’t see why we keep making the category error of calling AI companies ‘frontier labs’.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
When you invent any new technology & try to convince the world of how important it is you are either early or you are wrong.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Advances in AI coding / ability to produce software has exposed the chasm between the hardware world and the software world. It is time to invest into making matter programable. My company @ChemifyX & my research team @UofGlasgow using chemputation is leading the charge.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In chemistry, data & context are key. Whilst the old databases might be useful for humans, they are not very helpful for robotics or machine learning. First you need the ontology of chemputation (www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123), & then you need to collect data.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In chemistry, data & context are key. Whilst the old databases might be useful for humans, they are not very helpful for robotics or machine learning. First you need the ontology of chemputation (www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123), & then you need to collect data.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemical design & synthesis is far harder than any computer science person can realistically understand unless they have designed & made molecules in the lab themselves. Using genAI to do chemistry based on the human gathered data is dangerous & will fail.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Los Alamos in the distance from Santa Fe
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemistry is the biggest combinatorial problem. Chemical space is larger than outer space & harder to search.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Exploring chemical space with Assembly Theory.
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Thanks to @obeh_david @_sharmaabhi_ & @CroninLab for getting this off the ground.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Mapping Evolution of Molecules across Biochemistry with Assembly Theory. pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jcim.6c00939
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In this world of fake AI-driven content the ability to communicate science ideas clearly, simply, but rigorously is critical.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly Theory makes a number of predictions which have been confirmed experimentally. Also the assembly index of a molecule is an intrinsic molecular property like molecular weight, & it can be measured. pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acscentsci.4c00120
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation is a theory, a standard, an ontology. It allows chemistry to be programmable, automated, safe, secure whilst building to the hyper data scale needed to solve chemistry.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
ALIFE Conference 2027
@ALifeConf
Meet another #alife2026 keynote speaker!
@leecronin from the @UofGlasgow
"Assembly Theory, Evolution and Artificial Life"
Lee will explore how selection engines could drive the emergence of evolution, with the goal of creating bottom-up artificial life from inorganic chemicals. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Running in Santa Fe - it’s harder than at sea level…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI does not erode critical thinking skills, it merely shifts the focus from those who have critical thinking skills who use it because they are lazy to fake out those without critical thinking skills.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Anyone who is claiming genAI can achieve a thing (e.g AGI or superintelligence) that is not yet defined does not merit any serious attention.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Almost every autonomous AI science lab I know are buying robots & layering on script without a real abstraction. I fear this will not lead to new discoveries or understanding. We built the abstraction of chemputation to make matter & chemical discovery programmable & learnable.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Almost every autonomous AI science lab I know are buying robots & layering on script without a real abstraction. I fear this will not lead to new discoveries or understanding. We built the abstraction of chemputation to make matter & chemical discovery programmable & learnable.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’ve started the equivalent of the human genome project for chemistry mapping all reactions, molecules & materials using Chemputation. This asset will be as important for chemistry & materials science as the protein structural database is for biology.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If you get something knocked back that you think is important, the solution is simple. Listen to the feedback and make the problem bigger. Big problems are worth solving.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Kye Gomez (swarms)
@KyeGomezB
AGI has an assembly index.
In assembly theory (Sharma, Czégel, Lachmann, Kempes, Walker & Cronin, Nature 2023), the assembly index a of an object is the minimum number of recursive joining operations required to construct it from a basis set of elementary parts, where each intermediate is reusable once formed.
The framework was developed to distinguish biotic from abiotic matter: empirically, molecules with a ≳ 15 are not produced by undirected chemistry at detectable abundance, and their occurrence is treated as evidence of an underlying selection process a causal history capable of preserving and recombining intermediates.
The index is thus not a measure of static complexity but of contingent depth: the length of the shortest causal chain compatible with the object's existence.
A thread 🧵⬇️ -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’ve started the equivalent of the human genome project for chemistry mapping all reactions, molecules & materials using Chemputation. This asset will be as important for chemistry & materials science as the protein structural database is for biology.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If you really want to come up with genuinely ground breaking paradigm shifting ideas in science you need to be as gullible as you are critical.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly Theory of strings explored by @szymongus & team. royalsocietypublishing.org/rsos/article/13/5/260082/48194…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
D.Eng Szymon Łukaszyk
@szymongus
After almost nine years, canonical assembly theory has eventually been formalized.
royalsocietypublishing.org/rsos/article/13/5/260082/48194… -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Foresight Institute
@foresightinst
“Assembly theory can be used to detect evolution, life, technology, and hence intelligence on exoplanets using advanced telescopes.”
— @Sara_Imari (Arizona State University) speaking at Nano, Space, and Energy track at Vision Weekend UK. -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The first ever machine learning enabled fully autonomous discoveries in organic chemistry were presented here www.nature.com/articles/s41586-018-0307-8 and here pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acscentsci.1c00435 This work laid the foundation of chemputation being used by @ChemifyX for chemical & materials discovery at scale
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation is a formal system for the digital control of matter. This paper www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123 outlines the proof & a practical roadmap for Turing complete chemputing in chemical von Neumann machine - a chemputer.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The first ever machine learning enabled fully autonomous discoveries in organic chemistry were presented here www.nature.com/articles/s41586-018-0307-8 and here pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acscentsci.1c00435 This work laid the foundation of chemputation being used by @ChemifyX for chemical & materials discovery at scale
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Those who obsess about autonomous labs & science don’t understand that science can’t happen without imagination.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI cannot itself do science. AI can help critical thinkers who can reason, abstract, & imagine do better science.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Evening in Santa Fe
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Formal Languages and Automata Theory Papers
@FormalLanguages
Assembly Spaces: Formal Definitions and Fast Methods for Approximating Assembly Indices
Gage Siebert, Redwan Chowdhury, Louie Slocombe, Sara Walker
arxiv.org/abs/2606.15499 [𝚌𝚜.𝙵𝙻 𝚖𝚊𝚝𝚑-𝚙𝚑 𝚚-𝚋𝚒𝚘.𝙱𝙼] -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Just arrived in Santa Fe.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation is a formal system for the digital control of matter. This paper www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123 outlines the proof & a practical roadmap for Turing complete chemputing in chemical von Neumann machine - a chemputer.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The chemical space of small molecule drugs is much much bigger than even our wildest estimate. arxiv.org/abs/2606.11486
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
A is A
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m fascinated by the number of people buying robots, connecting them to AI’s & proclaiming the rise of the super scientist chemist/biologist/ materials scientist when in fact science cannot ‘be done’ by these systems.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Today I designed an integrated Molecular Assembly detector that can be used to directly measure the assembly indexes of molecules in the environment, & hence sources of evolution, life, & technology…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
what it is to be alive, the fundamental physics of life, AI and why we are far from understanding ourselves youtu.be/QHp3Gzkb_GY
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The alignment of AI with humans is the wrong idea. It should be the alignment of the AI makers with the AI users. AI itself has no agency.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Given that AGI needs access to reality beyond the current Turing-Church paradigm it is clear that AGI will not be achieved by the current Turing-limited technology. We need to go beyond Turing.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
With an accessible chemical
space exceeding 10^100, Chemify is on the brink of Artificial General Chemical Intelligence AGCI. Find out more www.chemify.io -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
RT @Sara_Imari: Math exists within the architectures (biological and technological) evolved on Earth, we should not be so easily convinced…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The alignment of AI with humans is the wrong idea. It should be the alignment of the AI makers with the AI users. AI itself has no agency.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Science is about opening up possibilities with conjecture. AI’s are trained on data & use probabilities. ‘Doing science’ is way more than statistics.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Shallow new is not novel. Depth is everything.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Long Now Foundation
@longnow
A molecule too complex to have formed by chance could be a signature of life. This is the assembly theory framework, which could reshape how we search for life beyond Earth.
Researchers @leecronin and @Sara_Imari explain on Long Now Ideas:
na2.hubs.ly/H05NVmG0 -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Would you play a game without knowing if a rule is physically allowed? Then why design a drug if you don’t know the molecule is physically accessible? #chemputation solves this problem. www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Would you play a game without knowing if a rule is physically allowed? Then why design a drug if you don’t know the molecule is physically accessible? #chemputation solves this problem. www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Where is the eval for unprecedented?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
PNASNews
@PNASNews
One of the most-viewed PNAS articles in the last week is “Chemputer and chemputation—A universal chemical compound synthesis machine.” Explore the article here: www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123.
For more trending articles, visit www.pnas.org/trending. -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This is a good explanation of assembly theory. www.youtube.com/watch?v=rDGWoCWJhL0
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI does not write, it produces text. Humans uniquely write.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This is a good explanation of assembly theory. www.youtube.com/watch?v=rDGWoCWJhL0
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation will enable VibeCheming (writing code to make molecules) the same way LLMs have allowed VibeCoding. But first we must build the infrastructure for digital chemistry #chemputation
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Robust Reasoning is something that modern AI cannot yet do, and with the current architectures, ever do.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI science today does not use real data because of the cost & the resulting delusion is compounded by bad benchmarking. AI can help science with real data against a real hypothesis.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Techno optimists good. Techno bullshitters bad.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Great to see that 3 of the 18 Emerging Investigators featured in @digital_rsc are from @croninlab pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlelanding/2026/dd/d6dd90017h
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The biggest category error in AI for science is viewing a science problem as a search problem…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
When we understand creativity we will understand intelligence.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
When we understand creativity we will understand intelligence.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Drug Discovery should be renamed Drug Creation. This is because chemical space is so big you cannot search it, you must instead create.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Drug Discovery should be renamed Drug Creation. This is because chemical space is so big you cannot search it, you must instead create.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We should stop talking about automating science & autonomous scientists, because that’s just spin. We should instead talk about automating & standardising experiments & data collection.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We should stop talking about automating science & autonomous scientists, because that’s just spin. We should instead talk about automating & standardising experiments & data collection.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We need to digitally sign all scientific papers & watermark them, even preprints.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Chemify - the world’s first vertically integrated molecular foundry connecting a chemical programming language to robotics powered by AI & ML. Dream it, draw it, make it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Out of all the AI-enabled molecules & materials science labs claiming automation, Chemify is the only one delivering new molecules & materials discovery every day made in our own labs & not outsourced to manual labor…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The term ‘platform’ is the most over used ambiguous notion in tech development since it confuses the imagination of what the technology could be vs reality.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Alien Chemputation….
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Friday night chemputation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
GenAI & Alphafold have enabled AI-biology creating a vast explosion of activity in biology. In chemistry Chemify has built Chemputation for programmable, learnable molecular design & synthesis. Find out more: www.chemifyx.com
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Existential Hope
@HopeExistential
Imagine a doctor prescribing a drug discovered last month. It exists because a robot ran 10,000 chemical experiments in the time it used to take a PhD student to run 10 - and the PhD student could focus on just reviewing the most promising results.
This could be possible if chemistry worked more like a programming language: you write some code, a robot runs the reaction, you get the same result anywhere. A researcher who used to spend a career on one compound could now explore thousands, from antibiotics to cancer drugs to carbon capture materials.
The best part is that it’s not science-fiction. @leecronin’s lab at Glasgow has been building this for a decade, and his spinout @ChemifyX has raised $93M to scale it.
What will get discovered first? -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation is our hope…
Existential Hope
@HopeExistential
What’s the best technology that doesn’t exist yet? Most funding is pouring into AGI right now. But there's much more being built that could be truly transformative, and almost no one is paying attention.
Some technologies can guide funding, coordination, and what feels possible long before they're built. The internet did; so did the Human Genome Project; AGI is doing it now. @michael_nielsen calls these hyper-entities.
We went looking for new ones in 100+ podcasts, worldbuilding scenarios, and essays from Existential Hope, a project that has been mapping positive futures for over 5 years.
From 300+ ideas, here are the 10 we’re most excited about:
• Chemputing – Chemistry made programmable: write code, a robot runs the reaction, same result everywhere.
• Machine-readable science – Scientific publishing made usable to AI, so that it can verify claims and build on findings directly.
• Open science networks – Infrastructure that rewards scientists for sharing data and replicating results, not just publishing first.
• Epistemic stack – A system that lets anyone trace a claim (in science, policy, the news, etc) through chains of evidence.
• Fiduciary AI assistants – An AI assistant that is bound to you and legally required to act in your interest.
• Immune-computer interface – Continuous real-time monitoring of your immune system.
• Conflict de-escalation protocol – AI mediation that finds fair outcomes before disputes escalate.
• Deep fission – Car-sized nuclear reactors built to be highly safe and to run autonomously for decades, installed underground.
• Digital twins – Living simulations of cities, ecosystems, supply chains, and other complex systems to test decisions before committing.
• Interspecies communication – Decoding what other species communicate to each other.
More info in the reply ↓ -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
All I do is exist outside of the distribution.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The physics & chemistry that gives rise ‘life’ is more bizarre than anyone has imagined.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In chemical programming,
formal verification is not a nice to have, it is a MUST. Most modern software is behind. The Chemputation done at Chemify is formally verifiable because safety is more important. www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123 -
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Proof of Chemputation. www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2511080123
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In chemistry the ultimate system benchmark is yield & purity of your target molecule.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Intelligence produces language but it is a one way function.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Algorithms are not theories. They process symbols. Theories explain what the symbols mean and make predictions.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I just blocked Bergson’s ghost for not actually being Bergson’s ghost.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation is the ground truth allowing agents: www.nature.com/articles/s42004-026-01993-w
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation of molecules to treat cancer: www.nature.com/articles/s42003-026-09873-8
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation is the ground truth allowing agents: www.nature.com/articles/s42004-026-01993-w
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Biology does things beyond Turing. I think I can explain it now.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Today I’m trying to write the framework that explains why biology is not Turing complete.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Definitely going to see ‘Lee Cronin’s The Mummy’ @curleecronin
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
You can be a future maker. Or a future taker. Which is it?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Chemify cares about your values > your skills > your CV. Join us! www.chemify.io
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m right on AI because I understand what I don’t know. The people certain I’m wrong however are …
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Discovery is unpredictable because novel ‘discoveries’ cannot be found from prior data in principle. The interface of the discrete past with the continuous future produces discovery. If you find a ‘discovery’ deducible from your data then by definition it isn’t a discovery.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Discovery is unpredictable because novel ‘discoveries’ cannot be found from prior data in principle. The interface of the discrete past with the continuous future produces discovery. If you find a ‘discovery’ deducible from your data then by definition it isn’t a discovery.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It is easy to see that biology does things that cannot be computed in advanced because the future is not controlled by statistics, it is controlled by creative actions. This means today’s statistically-driven GenAI is fundamentally unintelligent.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It is easy to see that biology does things that cannot be computed in advanced because the future is not controlled by statistics, it is controlled by creative actions. This means today’s statistically-driven GenAI is fundamentally unintelligent.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Friday night Chemputation tests.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
XDL enables Chemputation the same way CUDA enables general purpose computing on graphics cards. Chemify is using Chemputation to massively scale chemical design, discovery & manufacturing.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
As an experimentalist, philosopher, & theorist, I use creativity to solve problems. AI tools can help speed some aspects up but I need to utilize them with care & ensure proper verification.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The loop of science requires problem identification, creativity, experimental plan, data collection, analysis, problem update, loop. The human is vital for the loop.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It’s funny that some disciples of ‘critical thinking’ are themselves dogmatic & acting as gate keepers chasing away new ideas that don’t fit into their paradigm.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
It’s unfortunate that AI is obfuscating reality rather than clarifying it, it is not a wise choice for pursuing the quest to decipher the comprehensibility of nature by placing increasing layers of abstraction between you and what you want to understand (as if the act of abstraction itself will solve it for you) …
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
OpenClaw is actually good fun.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemical space is not defined by what can exist, but by what can be causally constructed under error-corrected execution. Chemputation with assembly theory redefines what a molecule is and how to access it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Using chatgpt & alpha fold to make a cancer vaccine makes no sense on so many levels but of course everyone will believe it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Chemify has built the only mathematically verifiable system, xDL, for checking chemical code & is deploying this today for the real world design, discovery, & manufacture of molecules. xDL is the LEAN of chemistry. Find out more www.chemify.io
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
What if chemical procedures could be formally checked
& verified independent of hardware or the user? This is what the principle of Chemputation allows… -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m reading this to get insight to the push back Einstein got against relativity. It is all too easy to imagine that new theories like relativity were accepted quickly. They were not. Doing new science is hard & brutal.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The existential threat with AI is fake users, fake content, fake data, fake news, fake concepts, fake science, & fake technology.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The role of the human is not just to generate but to authenticate & also above all, appreciate.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The existential threat with AI is fake users, fake content, fake data, fake news, fake concepts, fake science, & fake technology.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Bacon would be an AI user. Popper would be an AI abuser.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We have just passed the 500 papers mark!! The 500th paper is on the Turing Complete Chemputer. Thanks to the ca 100 PhD students, 150 post docs, & 250 collaborators! What an amazing team effort… www.chem.gla.ac.uk/cronin/pubs/
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We have just passed the 500 papers mark!! The 500th paper is on the Turing Complete Chemputer. Thanks to the ca 100 PhD students, 150 post docs, & 250 collaborators! What an amazing team effort… www.chem.gla.ac.uk/cronin/pubs/
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Test tubes cannot discover new chemistry by definition.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Prediction engines cannot be creative by definition.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Prediction engines cannot be creative by definition.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation is the first Turing complete way to control the addition of matter & energy under digital control with error correction. A hint of something to come soon…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation is the first Turing complete way to control the addition of matter & energy under digital control with error correction. A hint of something to come soon…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Rory Sutherland
@rorysutherland
Everyone who extracts value which can be quantified is overpaid. Everyone who creates value that can't be quantified is underpaid. There are very few exceptions.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Biology does not seem to compute. The Church-Turing-Deutsch thesis relies on the extension of Turing to quantum computing. There is no evidence that quantum computing works yet & hence building a theory assuming this works is a religious step.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Mel
@MelGSoler
I am sure you wanna know more about programming electrosynthesis in a robotic platform, so have a look here! www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S24519294250049… Thanks to @leecronin for his vision and the rest of co-authors for tremendous work
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Programmable electrochemistry with the Chemputer. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S245192942500498X Great work by @MelGSoler & team!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
There is no AGI, only human hubris.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
People that think doing science is the same as searching are rather confused & terribly mistaken. Science is not search.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI cannot in principle make novel discoveries.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
No it will be solved by innovative jobs in new sectors & removal of the layers of bureaucracy across all sectors.
Tom Forth
@thomasforth
British Growth and the Graduate Premium: Britain's growth problems will not be solved by more graduates. tomforth.co.uk/graduatepremium/
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Chemify’s discovery engines navigate physical space to create the new molecules & materials of tomorrow from drugs, catalysts, formulations, nanoparticles, & reaction routes.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
When you understand the difference between probability & possibility the difference between searching & creativity will be clear.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
RT @Sara_Imari: AGI is easy define, and everyone can do it to their own satisfaction because it is not an objective feature of reality, but…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
When you understand the difference between probability & possibility the difference between searching & creativity will be clear.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Society for Technological Advancement
@sotalikesfuture
SoTA's Frontiers Night on Self-Driving Labs
Thanks to our brilliant Demonstrators for a series of live demos, technical talks, and an extremely lively debate on making AI scientists running closed-loop experimentation a reality:
- Lee Cronin, Founder & CEO of Chemify and Regius Chair of Chemistry at the University of Glasgow
- Shamit Shrivastava, Cofounder & CEO of Apoha
- James Baghurst & Calum Drysdale, Winners of SoTA's Embodied Intelligence Hackathon and Founders of London Biocompute
- Miao Guo, Senior Lecturer in Engineering at King's College London
- Pranay Shah & Aayush Chadha, AI Scientist Programme at Advanced Research + Invention Agency (ARIA)
Thanks also to IQ Capital for hosting us.
@ChemifyX
@experilearning
@CalumDrysdale
@Shamits
@leecronin
@BiorenewableLab
@Pranay_Shahh
@AayushChad40496
@IQ_Capital_Fund
@ARIA_research -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Mali Barbi, MD MSc | Breast & Gyn Oncologist
@DrBarbiOnc
Everyone is talking about the new @NatureMedicine paper (rdcu.be/e4ADv), but I think the real story is being buried.
Here is the cold reality: The AI passed the medical boards with flying colors (~95% accuracy). But when real humans actually used it for triage, their accuracy dropped to <35%. They performed worse than the control group who just used Google.
Practically, this means benchmarks are not safety tests. We are validating tools in a vacuum (simulations) that collapse in the real world.
As oncologists, we know this pattern: surrogate endpoints ≠ survival data.
Passing the boards is just a surrogate. Safe patient interaction is the only outcome that matters. Right now, we are optimizing for the test and failing the patient.
cc: @EricTopol @pranavrajpurkar
#clinicalvalidation #aihype #patientsafety #evidencebasedmedicine -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
John Maki
@John_W_Maki
Judea Pearl gives us the ultimate AI slop detector: no why/causal model = Ai slop.
It’s time for all of us to upgrade our game or be labeled a bot.
We must climb Pearl’s ladder of causality: correlation with directed acyclic graphs, intervention with structural causal models, and counterfactuals with dynamic causal models. -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Lee Cronin
@curleecronin
For dust you are. #leecroninsthemummy only in theaters April 17.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI is accelerating humanity to achieve excellence in mediocrity. I call it the mediocre singularity.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Embodiement is vital.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Can you see what’s going on here? Chemputation of … ?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Discovery is not computable.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It is possible to understand why computational methods alone (AI) cannot discover novelty in principle. A consciousness can only do it, & AI can help provide data. If we one day can create things capable of sentience (consciousness), then they will also be able to do it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI cannot in principle make novel discoveries.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Latest News from Business Wire
@NewsFromBW
Zeon Corporation Makes Strategic Investment in Chemify to Accelerate Digital Chemistry Innovation and Drive Development of New Materials Through State-of-the-Art Automated Molecular Design and Synthesis www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260212631340/en/Zeon-Cor…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
High throughput Chemputation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
High throughput Chemputation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation allows us to program matter using software.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation allows us to program matter using software.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It’s so easy to criticize something because you don’t like it because your beliefs are challenged. Real criticism has to be grounded in reality, be precise & actionable. Else it’s just dogmatism. I’m not scared of criticism or being wrong. I’m scared of not pushing & stagnation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It’s so easy to criticize something because you don’t like it because your beliefs are challenged. Real criticism has to be grounded in reality, be precise & actionable. Else it’s just dogmatism. I’m not scared of criticism or being wrong. I’m scared of not pushing & stagnation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Disentangling inference from intelligence is vital if we really want to understand.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI is just the mathematics with data. Data is just a representation of the world.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Why build a flawed shallow world model when you can do experiments in the real world?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The great asset of any thinker is the ability to criticize any given position to make progress. Critical thinking, argument, problem solving, actively trying to disprove a position is the best way to make progress the ground truth & problem solving.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI is insane. I’ve never had an original scientfic idea in my life & now I just can’t stop having them. I’ve literally solved everything!!!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The great AI delusion is fascinating.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I think the only way to make progress on the phenomenon of intelligence is to measure it. This will show why the current notion of AI, AGI, & superAGI is not capturing what biological intelligence is doing.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m making a physical creativity engine.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
There are creative forces at play on this planet, operative since the first life caused itself into existence; yet we have inherited from our recent ancestors a view of reality that is fundamentally static, where the present moment is merely an echo of events laid out at the start of our universe
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Want to work on Assembly Theory & life detection? Together with @Sara_Imari we have two post doc positions open working primarily in ASU but also some time could be spent at UoG. Advert here: apply.interfolio.com/176391 Pls retweet.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Want to work on Assembly Theory & life detection? Together with @Sara_Imari we have two post doc positions open working primarily in ASU but also some time could be spent at UoG. Advert here: apply.interfolio.com/176391 Pls retweet.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I still get a buzz of opening the program Mercury because the molecule in the splash shot is one I solved the crystal structure of.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We are building the wrong infrastructure for intelligence.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Clarity comes from asking the right questions critically that are consequential, testable, & allow error correction.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Well done to Sebastian Pagel, the 90th Croninlab PhD student!!! Wishing Sebastian luck doing advanced molecular design & chemputation at Chemify…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Despite all the hype, a quantum computer has not yet solved a classical problem faster than the best classical way that is practically meaningful.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
JCIM & JCTC Journals
@JCIM_JCTC
Rapid Exploration of the Assembly Chemical Space of Molecular Graphs
pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jcim.5c01964
@KeithPatarroyo @Sara_Imari @leecronin
#jcim Vol65 Issue24 #chemicalinformation -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We are living in a technology delusion. The people that really build physical stuff understand this. We need to wake up & invest in physical stuff not advertising.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
None of us is infallible; none of us is omniscient. The only way, as a species, we’ve been able to make progress—we’ve been able to discover how the world works, what works in creating a functioning and fair society—is that people try out ideas; other people point out what’s wrong with them; we keep the ideas that seem to be working; we try not to repeat our mistakes; and we blunder our way toward knowledge and progress. If you disable that cycle by punishing people for the content of their speech, then you’re guaranteed to be in error, because the people doing the punishing—the people doing the censoring—are themselves not infallible.
@NZFreeSpeech
--Full interview: www.hootsuite.com/error/lost-owly
--Tickets to "An Evening with Steven Pinker" in Auckland, Monday, February 02, 2026 at 7PM: www.ticketmaster.co.nz/event/2400635CC1573F86 -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I know that I don’t know, that does not mean I don’t want to know.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m a chemist, & I’m much more complicated than you can possibly infer by compute, probabilistically, by multitudes.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The AI jobs debate is actually, whose job has declined, due to vast knob turning bureaucracy, so an algorithm trained on the internet can now do that bureaucracy which has become 99% of the job. AI shows us what work actually does not need
to be done. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It seems like physics, AI, mathematics, history, & economics etc are seen as sexy things to talk about on podcasts etc but not chemistry. I wonder why?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The future is not controlled by probability, that’s the past, the future is controlled by possibility.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Everything you see here was always possible. Almost none of it was ever going to happen.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The fallacy of AI invention is clear in chemistry. Molecules must be created using chemical reactions, reagents, catalysts, & energy. The combinatorial space is so large that acts of creativity in design, planning & building are required. There is no AI-driven free lunch.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Everything you see here was always possible. Almost none of it was ever going to happen.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Dirk H. Trauner
@DirkTrauner
What makes Organic Chemistry so awesome? That after ONE lecture on the rules you can design a molecule that is stable, could be made, but has never been made.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It’s time to start paying peer reviewers to professionally evaluate research manuscripts; especially those at the cutting edge / genuinely novel ideas.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Why chemistry should be digital: theconversation.com/chemistry-is-stuck-in-the-dark-ages-c…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Why chemistry should be digital: theconversation.com/chemistry-is-stuck-in-the-dark-ages-c…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Collecting vast amounts of data without an ontology is pointless.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
You cannot cheat thinking. You can fake it but that’s up to you.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It’s evolution & selection all the way down.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The fundamentality of causation first manifests when an object can persist long enough to affect its own creation. This process builds a memory, at the atomic level & in molecular networks, that acts upwards.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Causation in physics was missed by Newton, Einstein, Heisenberg & others. Microphysical causation is revealed by combinatorial chemistry & since chemistry has been thought to be less fundamental than physics it was missed.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Causation in physics was missed by Newton, Einstein, Heisenberg & others. Microphysical causation is revealed by combinatorial chemistry & since chemistry has been thought to be less fundamental than physics it was missed.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The vastness of any possibility space is as bewildering as it is uncomputable, but exciting & awe inspiring because that is where the future is built.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
LEDPolicy
@ledpolicy
This is seduction-by-proxy. GenAI flatters effortlessness, outsources judgment, and backfills confidence with plausibility. The danger isn’t wrong answers—it’s unearned certainty. When cognition is skipped, error feels like insight and laziness gets a diploma.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Current silicon machines do not think. The assertion that they do or ‘it’s different’ is just a category error.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
People often talk about self-driving-labs. We made the first SDL & presented it in 2014. www.nature.com/articles/ncomms6571 Everything was automated - experiment selection, execution, collecting data, analysis, next experiment design, self cleaning, resetting.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
With an assembly index of 23, the Taxol Demon has a lot of heavy lifting to do to spontaneously make Taxol from CO2, H2O, & NO2 in a copy number greater than 1.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Entropy is the pre determined future of the creationist.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Whisktropy
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The concept of entropy is only useful in a post selected world. Objectively the entropy of a sand castle vs entropy of the blob that was in sand castle are identical. It’s only when you assign a special status to the sand castle that entropy makes sense.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Nothing jumps. Everything moves. The universe remembers.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The only thing that is spooky about quantum mechanics is that so many smart people are willing to accept an ontology that defies human understanding because they are told to just accept it without critical thinking.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Determinism is the product of causation. youtu.be/tyIY6JlmP7M
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Everything we care about has been the product of evolution including intelligence. To understand human intelligence we need to understand how it evolved. To build human level intelligence we need to build an intelligence evolution machine.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Droplet life, but not as you know it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The only thing that is spooky about quantum mechanics is that so many smart people are willing to accept an ontology that defies human understanding because they are told to just accept it without critical thinking.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
People often talk about self-driving-labs. We made the first SDL & presented it in 2014. www.nature.com/articles/ncomms6571 Everything was automated - experiment selection, execution, collecting data, analysis, next experiment design, self cleaning, resetting.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Policing words is the same as policing thoughts. An open society should have no limits on words. Words are the meta space where ideas need to be formed and compete. If you prevent ideas you don’t like then you harm the future of the human race & usher in tyranny.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory applied to addition chains: arxiv.org/abs/2512.18030
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Can assembly theory & assembly equation be used to measure selection in real experiments? arxiv.org/abs/2512.18752
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Keith Patarroyo
@KeithPatarroyo
We uploaded the preprint Assembly Addition Chains to the Arxiv. It's a rigorous mathematical formalisation of Assembly Theory with novel bounds on assembly indices of molecules, strings and 2D Lego. It also has surprising applications to the size of chemical space, coming soon...
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory applied to addition chains: arxiv.org/abs/2512.18030
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Can assembly theory & assembly equation be used to measure selection in real experiments? arxiv.org/abs/2512.18752
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory applied to addition chains: arxiv.org/abs/2512.18030
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Are these droplets alive or dead? Watch until the end before you decide… #dropletlife
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Doing new stuff is hard, but attempting to break two new paradigms is more than double the pain. Both Assembly Theory & Chemputation are ‘controversial’, I’ve been told, but I’m confused as I think they are entirely obvious.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
François Chollet
@fchollet
When it comes to scientific discovery, one thing LLMs are really good at is getting hobbyists to delude themselves into believing they've made a huge breakthrough on some longstanding problem or a theory of everything
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Hey, we physicists don’t like causation, so instead we will invoke a theory that requires an infinite number of universes to explain evolution, free will, & TikTok.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Spontaneous, infinite physics leaves life without definition or meaning. Finite, recursive physics makes life definable.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The extent to which physicists will go to deny causation is to resort to the woo of entanglement.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I seem to live in a world inhabited by AI bots AND humans who think AI can do ‘X’ because they are too lazy to think. Double trouble. I want authenticity. Is that too much to ask ?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
The least appreciated part of freedom of speech is that freedom of speech allows people to show you who they really are. It's under-appreciated because the results can sometimes be unpleasant, but it's knowledge we need to have. It is how we come to the Adulthood of the Human Mind.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’ve become a self driving professor.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Self driving labs don’t exist.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The answer to materials or chemical discovery is not data or AI.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Probabilistic slop engines cannot do science, drug discovery, materials discovery, or magic. Anyone who thinks AI can autonomously do science simply doesn’t understand how knowledge is created.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We published the first AI-powered closed loop robotic self driving lab in 2014. It was able to do thousands of experiments, including self cleaning & resetting, searching for novel formulations using an evolutionary algorithm. www.nature.com/articles/ncomms6571
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The UK has the largest stockpile of plutonium of any country. We should build the technology to make fast breeders. I posit if we developed modular FBRs we will become the world’s energy superpower.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Daniel Hannan
@DanielJHannan
Your regular reminder that, had the world followed France and built nuclear reactors half a century ago, there would now be no rows about decarbonisation, no IPCC, no Greta Thunberg marches.
The whole problem was created by the green movement. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Thanks to the Croninlab for this gift at our Xmas party!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemify Xmas party at the Glasgow Science Centre.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We published the first AI-powered closed loop robotic self driving lab in 2014. It was able to do thousands of experiments, including self cleaning & resetting, searching for novel formulations using an evolutionary algorithm. www.nature.com/articles/ncomms6571
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Autonomous robots doing chemputation is happening 24/7 in the Croninlab & at Chemify collecting data for next generation AI & ML.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Autonomous robots doing chemputation is happening 24/7 in the Croninlab & at Chemify collecting data for next generation AI & ML.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If you want to make matter programmable, chemputation is all you need… (works for chemistry, materials, biology).
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Probabilistic slop engines cannot do science, drug discovery, materials discovery, or magic. Anyone who thinks AI can autonomously do science simply doesn’t understand how knowledge is created.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Our paper on rapid calculation of molecular assembly indexes is out pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jcim.5c01964 the repo is here github.com/croningp/assemblycpp-v5
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The GPU is more polluting than the steam engine & nowhere near as efficient (lol). It’s odd anyone thinks this is a real leap. We need to stop & ask, what really is intelligence? GenAI might be useful but it’s not intelligent. What is it doing?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Great team work!
Keith Patarroyo
@KeithPatarroyo
The first paper I've led was just published! Great work from all the team and collaborators.
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Our paper on rapid calculation of molecular assembly indexes is out pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jcim.5c01964 the repo is here github.com/croningp/assemblycpp-v5
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Probability, frequentist, Bayesian, or otherwise, cannot cope with novelty. This is self evident only after rather deep thought & even then you are going to deny it. Possibility on the other hand …
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Probability, frequentist, Bayesian, or otherwise, cannot cope with novelty. This is self evident only after rather deep thought & even then you are going to deny it. Possibility on the other hand …
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Our paper on rapid calculation of molecular assembly indexes is out pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jcim.5c01964 the repo is here github.com/croningp/assemblycpp-v5
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If there is no precedent, there is no probability. Probability only applies to things we already know.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Using LLMs in peer review negates the idea of peer review. Humans reading science ideas will abstract, invent, & imagine. LLMs will just write a report that appears to have read the paper, but without abstraction, invention, or imagination.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Nine years ago the RSC did a piece on my efforts to Digitize Chemistry, its great to see how a lot of what we were planning came to pass. www.youtube.com/watch?v=-fdPhNz4ndI
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation allows Programmable Microwaveable Chemistry onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/anie.202515869
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Evolution is the ONLY way we know that ‘intelligence’ has emerged. That took at least 4 billion years. To suggest that genAI could be intelligent is just delusional. I explain why here. youtu.be/FRpaGC_ZSlE
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We should rename AI. ‘Artificial Intelligence’ to ‘Autonomous Informatics’. This would remove the obvious marketing gimmick people use to suggest their AI systems are more than the data & an algorithm. AI is not magic, nor sentient. It’s just data.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Here, on Robinson’s podcast, I describe why I want to find out what life & intelligence are…youtu.be/FRpaGC_ZSlE
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Astrobiology, Aliens, and the Origin of Life youtu.be/h52qWMncEUE
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The illusion of intelligence given to us by the various companies pushing LLMs will be seen as fraudulent very soon. Claiming a random search engine has the intelligence of a PhD is just dumb, insulting, & also demonstrates a vast misunderstanding of what it is that humans do.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Neil Hudson
@NeilHudsonexp
Hilbert wanted a formal system deciding all truths. Gödel: impossible.
Verificationists wanted a criterion of meaning. Popper/Tarski: impossible.
Bayesians want a numeric criterion of “good theory.” Deutsch: impossible.
ML/AI formalists want a computable criterion of “explanation” or “understanding.” Impossible. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If a new theory cannot make specific & novel testable predictions that other theories cannot make then it’s not useful.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemify’s new website is just up. Find out how we are changing the world of chemistry & how you can get involved. From partnering, to hiring. Let’s change the world together! www.chemify.io
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
LLMs are helping advance & disguise excellent mediocrity.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Hey let’s spend a trillion dollars on some data analysis & knowledge generation tools. Will it be good? Sure it will be brilliant! Will it make shit up? Yeah, and that’s for free!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
LLMs compress the present to reveal the past. They cannot, in principle, say ANYTHING about the future. The future is open, & it needs humans to generate it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m certain AI won’t do science anytime soon but I’m also becoming optimistic there is room for some of the tools.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Taken tonight in my backyard in Glasgow using equatorial tracking & 60 second exposures. Any guesses what it is ?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory kills the notion of intelligent design by showing how the universe designs itself. You can ask who designed the universe in which this happens but that question is beyond science.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I guess I need to stop running to get Garmin to be allowed to do my ECG or randomly do star jumps before recording?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We are making fantastic progress in science & technology but the current AI fetish, thinking that investing in AI infrastructure to solve science & technology problems will work, is insane. We need to invest in people not GPUs, experiments not LLMs, critical thinking, not agents.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
An excellent short on assembly theory youtube.com/shorts/sINCTF_GkNY
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Kenneth Stanley
@kenneth0stanley
The reason science is not just about compression is that you cannot compress what you have not yet observed, but often the greatest insights are about how the unobserved world might work.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The future of biology & evolution is in general not computable using current technology. This places fundamental limitations on what AI can be used to do in biology today. Vast sums are being spent on compute rather than real experiments. This is a mistake.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
David Deutsch
@DavidDeutschOxf
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory is a theory of causation, contingency, & selection (including natural selection). It has wide explanatory power & makes testable predictions & it is beautifully simple.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’ve just built an AI that built an AI that built another AI that concludes that all AI is not in fact AI unless you’ve paid for one zillion braggawatts of AI.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Measuring Life by Molecular Complexity theanalyticalscientist.com/issues/2025/articles/october/m…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
GenAI is literally the most wasteful & stupid way to search for information & create content. We are currently being held hostage by the data center. It doesn’t have to be that way.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
GenAI will vastly expand the gap between the pretend creatives & the real creatives as models collapse & the internet is turned into grey goo.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m very excited to use AI science tools for search as I cannot read the literature quickly enough.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI scientists can search but not discover. Why? The discovery space is just too big.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
nxthompson
@nxthompson
“When people say the A.I. reasons, they misunderstand. The A.I. does not reason. They reason.”
I had a fascinating discussion with @leecronin about what constitutes autonomous A.I. He says there is reasoning in our current systems, but it comes from the humans who created it—not from the machines.
This is a tricky concept, with all sorts of important implications. Listen to our full conversation here: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/artificial-life-with-nichol…
Produced by @atlanticrethink, The Atlantic's creative marketing studio, in collaboration with @PwC.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Niko Bonatsos
@bonatsos
The startup founders who treasure your $25K like $25M today will steward $2B the same way tomorrow; financial discipline is muscle memory.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Computation does not exist at the base level of reality.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
There are too many people talking about building stuff but not actually walking the walk. The future is not built on soft words. It is built on real actions.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
When people start to understand how knowledge is generated then they will understand what AI is and what AI isn’t.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
superintelligence is as superintelligence does
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If you cannot define the base thing, then defining the super version of that base thing is similarly out of reach.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If you can’t define then it doesn’t exist. Take superintelligence. It has no definition, no meaning, no way to measure. It’s just a buzz word. Anyone who says they are trying to make one is literally fraudulent.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
XDL is to chemistry what LEAN is to mathematics. XDL helps chemical synthesis to be provable & collaborative using the principle of chemputation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
XDL is to chemistry what LEAN is to mathematics. XDL helps chemical synthesis to be provable & collaborative using the principle of chemputation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
There are bitcoin mines & inference mines. @chemifyx is building a new type of mine, one that physically searches chemical space with chemputation to discover new materials, formulations, & drugs. And it’s happening in Glasgow, UK now.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Neg entropy does not exist. Assembly does.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The amount of quackery I get after AI vs the amount of quackery I got before has increased 500%. It’s also longer, more mathematical but seemingly utter gibberish. That’s one explanation. The other is that a load of random genesises are emailing me new theories & I’m clueless.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
You’ll be left behind if you don’t use AI vs you won’t be lazy & do random shit that actually means nothing if you don’t use AI. My observation so far is that domain experts qualified can find it useful but if you are not an expert you are going to get trapped in the BS.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
When people say you should learn AI ‘skills’, that’s actually nonsense, it’s a product placement exercise. AI skills are not really ‘hard’ skills, they are indoctrination to the app. Instead learn to think critically & precisely.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We invent the printing press & what do we first do? Print the bible to increase worship. We commoditise inference & what do we first do? Make chatbots to increase worship.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
The platonic world does not exist “out there”, it’s a projection inside your mind when you must construct internal representations that are devoid of the history and causal contingency in the objects of your experience
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
People who think AI can map an unknown space don’t really understand what AI is.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI cannot do science because the combinatorial & representable space is too big just to grind through limited symbolic inference that confuses the map with the territory. Only biological intelligences have the ability to really FAFO.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI is going to give us doom. AI is going to give us abundance. Erm both these statements are without mechanism. We need hardware interfaces to build / grow stuff. Then the abundance agenda starts to look good & with good ethics & regulation we can deal with the doom.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Could it be that Alzheimer’s is diabetes of the brain & the observed protein missfolding is a result of this metabolic disfunction?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Matt Clifford
@matthewclifford
.@leecronin is the real deal. This is fantastic news and well deserved👇
Techmeme
@Techmeme
Glasgow-based Chemify, which combines AI with robotics and chemistry to rapidly make novel molecules for pharmaceutical companies, raised a $50M Series B (Alex Scott / Chemical & Engineering News)
cen.acs.org/business/informatics/AI-drug-synthesizer-Chem…
www.techmeme.com/251025/p12 -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AGI is elusive. Until we can even define intelligence itself it is easy to understand that AGI is a hollow slogan.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Curiosity collapse because coming with new ideas is hard. Using a stochastic engine to cut, paste & diffuse without genuine novelty does not result in novelty.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
GenAI is helping accelerate the advent of curiosity collapse.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Superintelligence is as superintelligence does.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Pharmaceutical Era
@Pharma_Era
To drive global expansion of digital chemistry and discovery, Chemify raises over $50 million in an oversubscribed Series B round www.pharmaceutical-era.com/press-releases/to-drive-global…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Complex chemistry in a dish.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Complex chemistry in a dish.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Saturday night chemistry.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Here I write about the urgent need for chemputation or programmable chemistry for the future of chemistry. sotaletters.substack.com/p/chemputation-chemistry-program…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Here I write about the urgent need for chemputation or programmable chemistry for the future of chemistry. sotaletters.substack.com/p/chemputation-chemistry-program…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Society for Technological Advancement
@sotalikesfuture
Chemputation: Chemical Programming & Molecular Discovery, Professor Lee Cronin
sotaletters.substack.com/p/chemputation-chemistry-program… -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
For AI drug discovery to work, someone needs to map the space of possible and makeable drugs. Chemify is mapping drug space with Chemputation which produces runtime code to MAKE potential new drugs on demand.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
A common misconception is that theory can exist independently of a substrate. This is very subtle & hard to see until you see. A bit like the concept of zero.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
There isn't some mysterious force that's just guaranteed to make things better and better. That's not the way the universe works. In fact, quite the contrary, the universe kind of tries to grind us down. And if we've made progress, it's because of human efforts.
(From the @HopeExistential podcast. Full episode: youtube.com/watch?v=QTBzuKholjo) -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Ed Zitron
@edzitron
Premium: The AI Bubble's promises are impossible. NVIDIA's customers are running out of money, GPUs die in 3-5 years, most 1GW data centers will never get built, and OpenAI's Abilene data center won't have the power it needs before 2028 - if it ever does.
www.wheresyoured.at/the-ai-bubbles-impossible-promises/ -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I think we need to understand the origin of life before we can understand the origin of intelligence, consciousness or agency.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
With AI I can be both @leecronin and @curleecronin
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Simulation is easy. Reality is hard.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In this world of GenAI only two things count: 1) authenticated users 2) authenticated data.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Here is Quantum Chemputation conceptually. Go from the physical properties you want to a possible molecular graph, but then apply the rules of synthetic chemistry to ensure it is Chemputatable and therefore makable.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Fake video generation is almost as lame as fake story generation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Stop probabilistic slop. Make abstraction great again.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It appears we are entering the AI, AI+agent delusion about how much human in the loop is needed. It reminds me of Enron in terms of the bubble that is being blown but of course I must be wildly wrong & over worrying.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Computer scientists need to avoid simulating themselves out of existence to avoid living in a world of AI-slop devoid of conceptual novelty. I predict the hunger for authentic novelty will exponentially increase & save all except the most delusional…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Causation is fundamental it acts through matter which can be used to control light.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Data emerges from matter.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Carl Sagan
@ProfCarlSagan
The role of intellectuals is to challenge authority, not serve it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The ability to transform data is now trivial. The ability to transform matter is hard. Matter is not data.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Let's imagine the emergence of life in optical systems proxima-kosmos.com/planets/nousterra/
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Quantum Chemputation produces real molecular discoveries that current AI cannot achieve in principle. This is because GenAI can produce non-chemputable artefacts. arxiv.org/abs/2408.09171
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Humans are able to abstract into a label free format driven by the brain structures produced by evolution. GenAI in silicon cannot do this, and probably never will. That does not mean we cannot produce a non human reasoning system but it’s not a GPU cluster running on labels.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI cannot do science. At least today & probably ever. Anyone who claims otherwise is too lazy to think, doesn’t know what science is, or is trying to scam you. AI is however going to be a great tool for scientists.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Two key rules for a founder building a company: 1) Don’t die. 2) Don’t run out of money.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Saturday night project building.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemistry in a bar
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemify's ability to 'think up' & make molecules uses at least 100,000 times less compute power than traditional GenAI & results in real makeable molecules, not drawings of cool looking molecules. The future of material & drug discovery is Chemputation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
There is no measurable complexity without copy number.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Working on the Assembly Theory of snowflakes as a way to help explain the concept of copy number and assembly index being fundamentally connected. It is said that no two snowflakes are the same. This is indeed correct if the assembly index is large.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Digital chemistry won’t just happen by bolting a chatbot to a liquid handling robot. It needs a fundamental new approach to allow the programming of matter, or chemputation. The theory & practical implementation is outlined here: arxiv.org/abs/2408.09171
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory and its relationship with computational complexity rdcu.be/eDSJ2
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Something is alive…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The future is open for us to shape & make better than our wildest dreams. It is not fixed or determined. Make the future happen by building it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Modern perpetual motion machines seem to be getting invested in, again. Same scam, different form. If you don't understand, or the person can't explain, its a scam. Simples. e/scam
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Digital chemistry won’t just happen by bolting a chatbot to a liquid handling robot. It needs a fundamental new approach to allow the programming of matter, or chemputation. The theory & practical implementation is outlined here: arxiv.org/abs/2408.09171
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Now I see where I’m going wrong! www.youtube.com/watch?v=BzAdXyPYKQo
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Great point by @IAmTimNguyen in his blog timothynguyen.org/2025/08/21/physics-grifters-eric-weinst… we should avoid science populists pretending to be science communicators. When people avoid technical criticism & make it personal we should just walk away.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Santa Fe Institute
@sfiscience
Unfold the history of proteins and you find rich, unexplained complexity.
This August, an SFI working group co-organized by researchers at the Earth-Life Science Institute (@ELSI_origins) and the School of Complex Adaptive Systems at Arizona State University (@ASU_SCAS) brought together machine learning and assembly theory to explore hidden rules underlying all folded matter, including proteins. The collaboration could help explain the origin of life and predict new drug candidates.
santafe.edu/news-center/news/assembling-the-hidden-rules-… -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If someone cannot explain their theory / breakthrough / new concept in words YOU can understand it’s bullshit.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
GenAI has enabled the crackpots to sound even more crackpot-like with their LLM enabled mumbo-jumbo. It’s even more hilarious though.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Scientific papers should be for people to read. AI’s won’t understand them. Supplementary data sets published with the papers should be for AI’s to read, people won’t be able to parse them.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation will lead to an exponential growth of the number of molecules synthetically accessible. It transcends the limits of manual labor by using a Turing-like ontology for error correction to ensure we can go deeper into chemical space. arxiv.org/abs/2408.09171
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Magnetic assembly.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Excited by progress. Humbled by the route to simplicity over time via extraordinary complexity instanced at a single point in time.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Chemify is unlocking the road to exponential chemical progress doing one reaction at a time using Chemputation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
François Chollet
@fchollet
GenAI isn't just a technology; it's an informational pollutant—a pervasive cognitive smog that touches and corrupts every aspect of the Internet. It's not just a productivity tool; it's a kind of digital acid rain, silently eroding the value of all information.
Every image is no longer a glimpse of reality, but a potential vector for synthetic deception. Every article is no longer a unique voice, but a soulless permutation of data, a hollow echo in the digital chamber. This isn't just content creation; it's the flattening of the entire vibrant ecosystem of human expression, transforming a rich tapestry of ideas into a uniform, gray slurry of derivative, algorithmically optimized outputs.
This isn't just innovation; it's the systematic contamination of our data streams, a semantic sludge that clogs the channels of genuine communication and cheapens the value of human thought—leaving us to sift through a digital landfill for a single original idea. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’ve just found evidence that a top publisher is using LLMs to produce proofs and it seems to have mangled together two versions of our manuscript (the original and the revised). This is such a bad idea. I don’t want stochastic type setting.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Why do I have contrarian opinions about AI & intelligence? Because we don’t understand what life is, & all intelligence is connected 100% to life. I am trying to find out with collaborators like @Sara_Imari It will probably need new physics & chemistry.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AGI is not possible until we understand, define, & benchmark what intelligence is.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If humanity aims for excellent mediocrity, we all die, evolution shows this. The current push to forcing people to conform or be punished is a return to the dark ages. Live & let live. Let’s stop suppressing excellence in the name of socialism.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Sometimes you have to do the supposedly impossible just to show it’s actually possible. This is how humanity has survived & indeed, thrive. Strive for the impossible. Humanity depends on it…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If humanity aims for excellent mediocrity, we all die, evolution shows this. The current push to forcing people to conform or be punished is a return to the dark ages. Live & let live. Let’s stop suppressing excellence in the name of socialism.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chain of thought reasoning should be renamed ‘advanced lying’.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The nerds being run out of academia by the majority of the excellent mediocrity who are using DEI / wokeness to make us conform or be punished. It seems the diversity in DEI is ‘only if you are one of us’.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation of Peptides: www.nature.com/articles/s41467-025-62344-2.epdf?sharing_t…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It all starts here - Chemputation will change chemistry forever. www.genengnews.com/topics/artificial-intelligence/chemify…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation is universal.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Science is about using minimal data to get closer to the truth via an abstraction. GenAI is about massively overfitting a model with vast amounts of data to delude you into the shadow of a truth.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory explains how causation is pulled into existence by persistence.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Reactor Magazine
@reactormag
Ruthanna Emrys explores the work of physicist and astrobiologist Sara Imari Walker, and how her insights into Assembly Theory and the origins of life might influence the future of science and science fiction 🌱
reactormag.com/the-wild-alien-possibilities-of-sara-imari… -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Here is how to explore molecular assembly as a biosignature using mass spectrometry & machine learning. arxiv.org/abs/2507.19057
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The conjecture made by assembly theory is that complex objects cannot be made in any abundance without technology or evolution. It is yet to be refuted.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Mel
@MelGSoler
Check out our lastest preprint on how to automate electrochemistry 👉 @leecronin @_sharmaabhi_ chemrxiv.org/engage/chemrxiv/article-details/687d631b728b…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly Theory gives an unambiguous & testable measurement & definition of life.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Just because you are not special it does not mean you cannot ask special questions.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I don’t understand what is meant when people say we must learn to use AI to stay ahead. Do they mean become a slave to the limited technology being put out, build proper reasoning systems, or generate proper data? Or are they just saying ‘buy my product to keep your job?’.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I have no pictures or words in my head.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I cannot think in words. I need to write them by hand or say them outloud. If I use an LMM my thoughts are trapped & will never appear. That would be a shame for me.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The evolution of biology from chemistry is not explainable without microphysical causation. Crazy that exploring biology from chemistry might need us to rewrite the laws of physics.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It all starts here - Chemputation will change chemistry forever. www.genengnews.com/topics/artificial-intelligence/chemify…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It’s funny how physics made causation spooky all because of Einstein, Newton, & a lack of common sense.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI is showing us that creativity sits in an entirely different category to data retrieval.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Imagine a world where we can make molecules from code with desirable properties. Imagine no more. www.chemify.io
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Science is about using minimal data to get closer to the truth via an abstraction. GenAI is about massively overfitting a model with vast amounts of data to delude you into the shadow of a truth.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Reality is causal, this is why stochastic gradient descent is insane, expensive, & produces delusions. It removes causation & embeds highly disordered correlations that might represent the training set but often are wrong. You have to massively over fit to get workable systems.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
GenAI is a wasteful shortcut to impossible matter with no understanding. It is possible to build knowledge systems that generalise, explore & discover novelty with real data & understanding. Chemistry is a good place to do this. Chemify can discover novel matter that be can made.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputation is universal.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI is going to cause mass employment & increase living standards.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Humans are not destroying the planet. They are ensuring its survival.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI is going to cause mass employment & increase living standards.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Mayim Bialik
@missmayim
Are aliens already among us? Are we even looking in the right way to find them?
Renowned chemist, molecular visionary, and University of Glasgow Regis professor Lee Cronin (@leecronin | @CroninLab) joins Mayim and Jonathan to explore the science behind alien life, consciousness, and the very definition of biology itself. Click the ▶️ linktw.in/vhAtQu for the full episode! 🧠💥 #bialikbreakdown #mayimbialik #mentalhealthpodcast #podcastThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If I’m allowed to mark my own homework, rather than doing unseen learning, to benchmark my own abilities then of course I will appear to get better whilst actually being dumb.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Thinking is special. I think it requires new laws of physics to understand right now but it’s still material.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Vinod Khosla
@vkhosla
Not surprised at this. Agree with the need for a new party that understands financial debt but also climate debt.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
LLMs can’t think, but so can’t all the people that answer this tweet telling me I’m wrong.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I predict chemical computing is going to leap frog work on quantum and biological computers because of the relative ease of building, error correction, and scaling. www.youtube.com/watch?v=-YutFZP9NZ4
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
So what are you willing to risk?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
where am I ?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I predict chemical computing is going to leap frog work on quantum and biological computers because of the relative ease of building, error correction, and scaling. www.youtube.com/watch?v=-YutFZP9NZ4
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
No I’ve changed my mind. LLMs are definitely, sentient, intelligent, & creative. They are even going to solve the origin of life. FOR SURE.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
LLMs cannot & will not ever be useful for scientific reasoning. LLMs will be useful in exposing non-scientific pseudo reasoning. Put another way probabilistic chains of thought cannot build & understand abstractions.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Occasionally probabilistic retrieval can be useful, but ONLY in areas where I’m an expert so I can remove the nonsense.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Will some AI’s ever be ‘intelligent’? Probably, once we can define intelligence & build systems to a specification. Anyone who tells you LLMs are intelligent / sentient are either lying or cult leaders.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Saying LLMs can be intelligent is like saying pigs can fly. LLMs are good at probabilistic retrieval the same way pigs are a good source of pork.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
LLMs cannot & will not ever be useful for scientific reasoning. LLMs will be useful in exposing non-scientific pseudo reasoning. Put another way probabilistic chains of thought cannot build & understand abstractions.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Today’s GPS coordinates.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Gen AI is as Gen AI does.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Quantum theory is not a theory, it’s a series of commandments.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Gen AI ‘thinking’ is easy. Real thinking is hard!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Jonathan Gorard
@getjonwithit
I get especially sad when I see researchers at my university, including very senior professors, excitedly saying "Look! Now I can use <random GenAI tool> to read papers, write papers, derive equations, write code, ..."
And it's like... why are you even here, man? (1/2)
Jonathan Gorard
@getjonwithit
LLMs have brought into sharp relief the immense cultural discrepancy between those who view programming/writing/thinking as instrumental to their process of learning, understanding and discovery, vs. those who view them as necessary evils in the course of "building" a "product".
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Futurescot
@Futurescot_News
New AI-driven chemistry facility in Glasgow is ‘watershed moment’ for global drug discovery and materials science. 'Chemifarm' in the city's Maryhill is 'world's first chemputation facility' revolutionising molecular design and manufacture
⬇️
futurescot.com/new-ai-driven-chemistry-facility-in-glasgo… -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Glasgow City Region
@GlasgowCityRgn
Chemify launches new, world-leading 'Chemputation' facility in Maryhill - creating 60 new jobs & safeguarding 50 existing roles.
Supported by the Innovation Accelerator, the 21,500sqft facility will accelerate the discovery of new medicines & materials.
glasgowcityregion.co.uk/chemify-launches-new-world-leadin… -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Our new Chemifarm comprises two facilities - engineering to build the robots & facilities to run the robots to turn code into molecules. It’s high value manufacturing all the way down! The rate of innovation here is staggering.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Our new Chemifarm comprises two facilities - engineering to build the robots & facilities to run the robots to turn code into molecules. It’s high value manufacturing all the way down! The rate of innovation here is staggering.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
So we opened our Chemifarm today! www.chemify.io
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Things are getting real…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Now in 2025, Chemify is opening the worlds first Chemifarm, which is the first commercial facility for chemputation able to do chemical design, discovery, & manufacture on demand. @chemifyx
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemists don’t want chemputation whilst computer scientists think it’s trivial.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The Chemical Turing Machine (CTM) does Chemputation & the proof now includes known as well as known outcomes.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In 2012 I had a dream of universal digital chemistry for chemputation inspired by 3D printing technology. By 2016 we made a key advance. www.beilstein-journals.org/bjoc/articles/12/276 We went from a vision to a universal code for organic synthesis - in this case making Ibuprofen in a hacked 3D printer.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Making digital chemistry truly universal for chemputation (digital control of chemsitry) required a new approach to hardware, wetware, & software with the development of XDL. www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aav2211 and now the theory showing universality is done. arxiv.org/abs/2408.09171
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Now in 2025, Chemify is opening the worlds first Chemifarm, which is the first commercial facility for chemputation able to do chemical design, discovery, & manufacture on demand. @chemifyx
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In 2012 I had a dream of universal digital chemistry for chemputation inspired by 3D printing technology. By 2016 we made a key advance. www.beilstein-journals.org/bjoc/articles/12/276 We went from a vision to a universal code for organic synthesis - in this case making Ibuprofen in a hacked 3D printer.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Making digital chemistry truly universal for chemputation (digital control of chemsitry) required a new approach to hardware, wetware, & software with the development of XDL. www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.aav2211 and now the theory showing universality is done. arxiv.org/abs/2408.09171
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Current AI technology is nothing more than a data analysis technique. To insert a ghost into the AI machine is kinda cute but it’s just a ghost. A ghost of human reasoning. Today’s ghost in the machine is human made.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The problem with synthetic chemists using LLMs blindly is one of safety. Get it wrong once & your lab could burn down. Hallucinations are not compatible with chemical synthesis.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The problem with synthetic chemists using LLMs blindly is one of safety. Get it wrong once & your lab could burn down. Hallucinations are not compatible with chemical synthesis.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Building stuff is just hard. Especially when it’s real stuff.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Building an explosive start up is not just about hard work, the right people, momentum, & luck. It’s about belief & determination to aim for the summit & be flexible. At Chemify we are making chemistry programmable & we are going to change the world one molecule at a time.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I hope chemputation can help be used to cure some diseases. Top of my list is Parkinson’s, cancer, Alzheimer’s, TB, cardiovascular, infections, viruses. Basically everything.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Dr Nicola Bell
@NickelCarbon
Digital tools will radically transform organometallic & reactive chemistry!
Checkout our first @BellGroup_ research paper presenting our interactive digital Schlenk line which allowed us to make a new Cu(II) disilylamide which couldn't be made manually!
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/anie.202505408 -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Paras Chopra
@paraschopra
Recently, I read this beautiful #book, named Life as No One Knows It, by @Sara_Imari and had a minor revelation that maybe we’ve been looking at life from a completely wrong lens.
My notes 👇 -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If someone tells you they can do magic & provide no evidence or reasoning then you should ignore them.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This helps redefine what a molecule is & that blows my mind. arxiv.org/abs/2408.09171
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
People looking for a theory of everything that doesn’t include biology are just trying to one up Einstein (which is stupid) when really they should be extending Darwin. A theory of everything that doesn’t include the origin of the observer is a theory of nothing.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This is a cool preprint. arxiv.org/abs/2505.22826 It explores the relationship of assembly spaces to minimal hyperpaths in B-hypergraphs & DPO graph rewriting. It finds that the assembly index measure is useful for retrosynthetic analysis. #assemblytheory #graphtheory
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If you think about the synthesis of a mg of Taxol, with assembly index 23, in the absence of biology, you would need one very smart Taxol Demon.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If you think about the synthesis of a mg of Taxol, with assembly index 23, in the absence of biology, you would need one very smart Taxol Demon.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Lex Fridman
@lexfridman
I'm an introvert who hides from the world, often way too much.
One thing I wish I did more is call & text my friends.
I think about them often, and feel lucky to know them, but experience a strange anxiety that prevents me from texting & calling. Silly introvert brain wants to pull me into isolation and darkness.
Then again, once I hang out with said friends, it's like we've been talking every day. So, maybe there's no problem, and it's just how dude friendships are 🤣
PS: These thoughts brought to you by a brain on 6 shots of espresso. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I love critical thinking, scientific arguments, & being direct. It can come across as high energy but no aggression is ever intended. I need to urgently understand why I’m wrong.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Hey @ricard_sole we will organise a workshop at SFI on AT & evolution. Would you like to help organize it to make sure we get the best cross section of participants? Maybe we can start that collaboration…better late than never.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemify’s molecular generator produces novel molecules that not only have interesting properties, but can be made on the platform because it generates valid chemical ‘code’. @ChemifyX
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Long Now Foundation
@longnow
What is Life?
In her Long Now Talk, astrobiologist and theoretical physicist @Sara_Imari Walker explores the fundamental nature of life and how can physics help shape our understanding of how it arises in the universe. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The great thing about progress in science is that over time the great leaps are easily seen, but when you are in the thick of it, it’s not so easy. Science is hard.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The universe is not a computer yet computers emerged in the universe after 13.8 billion years…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m willing to bet that reports of LLMs trying to prevent themselves being shut down are hallucinations of fictional stories of such events by the LLM.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
How can explaining what you are exploring / excited about be the same as overhyping something? I try to be as clear as possible & as realistic. I think people are annoyed by the fact my research & theories try to make testable advances & are not modest. Why set out to do modest?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I went nuclear and it worked. Now good enough for reasonable random numbers...
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
science is absolutely my favorite thing that humans do, and even more brilliant is that no one seems to know exactly what it is
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Programmable Chemistry happens in a standard architecture, Chemical Processing Unit or ChemPU, which like a computer CPU, processes code. The key difference is that ChemPUs process code AND chemicals to synthesize molecules.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Old school chemistry 'we don't need universality, we need specific edge case wiring'. New school chemistry 'why not program everything?' Old school chemistry 'cause we want control and slaves to do the work'.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The transition to universality was vital for language, mathematics, and now for chemistry. The old school are resisting but we will prevail. Programmable chemistry is now here and cannot be ignored...
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Simplifying Complexity
@BHComplexity
Hear @leecronin discussing Assembly Theory on the latest episode of #simplifyingcomplexity. This is Part 1.
Apple: podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/simplifying-complexity/id16…
Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/3SfqApqNW3wNXcg2E7etij
#complex #complexity #complexsystems #complexityscience -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Wow the world / reality does like resisting new ideas and trying to explain why I’m wrong with vague ‘I don’t like it / it’s too much hype’. If I was wrong one person explaining why would be enough. It would have to be precise, insult free, & understandable.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI is powerful but it cannot invent data. AI for science is falling into the simulation trap of rendering a dream within a dream. The truth is that the ground truth costs more but actually works. Don’t fall for fake data.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
A days worth of data from my Geiger-based random number generator. Not perfect but getting there. There is still some non random 'electrical noise' in the system. I have a way around this...
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Michael Crow
@michaelcrow
Challenges create opportunity. At ASU, we’ve built a model that’s excellent, accessible, student-focused and tech-enabled. Higher ed must adapt to meet diverse needs and drive greater impact. www.forbes.com/sites/bryanpenprase/2025/05/01/evolve-or-d…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Next step, turn these into random numbers.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Random number generator. No quantum computer required…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Quantum computers are yet to do anything I can’t do.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemical space is bigger than current silicon computational space.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly Theory can be used to discover new Celluar Automata... This CA has a new rule, B0123457/S012356 discovered by @KeithPatarroyo using AT with memory... full details coming soon.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly Theory can be used to discover new Celluar Automata... This CA has a new rule, B0123457/S012356 discovered by @KeithPatarroyo using AT with memory... full details coming soon.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
David R. Liu
@davidrliu
Another medical milestone! The first patient treated with a prime edited therapeutic shows positive clinical outcomes consistent with effective rescue of his chronic granulomatous disease (CGD), a debilitating and life-shortening primary immunodeficiency.
At least 19 base editing and prime editing clinical trials
have begun, with at least 7 trials reporting clinical outcomes (highlighted in green in the table below). They treat a wide range of diseases both in vivo and ex vivo. And while the U.S. support for science is now in crisis, that there are more base editing and prime editing clinical trials serving patients outside of the U.S. (13) than within the U.S. (9), despite the fact that these technologies were developed in our lab in the U.S.
investors.primemedicine.com/news-releases/news-release-de… -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
David Deutsch
@DavidDeutschOxf
It's important that society converge on a viable and morally sound distinction between persons and automata, even before fundamentally understanding the former. Failure in either direction risks, and has in the past caused, catastrophe.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly depends on two parameters. Copy number and assembly index, it is not a single scalar. @IntuitMachine
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
With its universal & scalable programmable chemical manufacturing environment chemify can make, discover, & scale drug manufacture on demand. Find out more www.chemify.io
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Progress in genAI etc has been amazing but it’s a shame that we have got tangled in a series of mystical arguments about what it is & what it can do. I am committed to learning more, exploring it, & then exploiting it for cool science & technology.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m a materialist, but like Roger Penrose, I don’t understand what the material is doing!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I think measuring consciousness & intelligence is the key to understanding it. Right now we cannot agree on what these are but attempts at working on the metrology of consciousness & intelligence will lead to progress beyond the woo or hype.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
CroninLab
@CroninLab
Curious to know what we do? The Cronin Group brings together chemists, physicists, mathematicians & engineers to advance digital chemistry & programmable matter. From the origin of life to programmable robots for chemical & materials discovery.
@UofGARC @UofGChem @leecronin -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Programmable robots that can make (chempute) molecules will lead to a Moore’s law in molecular design & synthesis. Here @chemifyX is leading the way bringing theory from @CroninLab to life!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Most AI companies consume data. Chemify’s systems generate new chemical data at scale across all of chemistry. Find out more www.chemify.io
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
You can’t reason using probability alone.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemify is the first chemical cybernetics company.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I marvel at my consistent inability to explain things despite really trying to think it through from all the angles. It’s a spectacular fail.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Tryptophan is not special. It is an aromatic amino acid. It does not think, it is not a quantum computer, & no it is not conscious. Just thought I’d clear this up…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Berggruen Institute
@berggruenInst
What if life beyond Earth isn’t as we know it? 🌌
Proxima Kosmos explores alternative planetary ecosystems with NASA, MIT, and visionary artists. Narrated by Keith David, this flythrough is just the beginning.
RSVP for the Science Convening on May 6: us02web.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_Ty0GR_m9RiaAQZSJGasLQA -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The conjecture made by assembly theory is that complex objects cannot be made in any abundance without technology or evolution. It is yet to be refuted.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chatbot affirming therapy.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemical discovery, from AI-enabled drug searching to advanced materials, needs Chemputation, this is programmable chemistry. I’m excited to say that @chemifyX, with the world’s first Chemifarm, is making it happen, at scale. www.chemify.io
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemical discovery, from AI-enabled drug searching to advanced materials, needs Chemputation, this is programmable chemistry. I’m excited to say that @chemifyX, with the world’s first Chemifarm, is making it happen, at scale. www.chemify.io
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Outsourcing critical thinking to LLMs is dangerous . Better to use them for what they are - probabilistic search engines with access to lots of potential* knowledge. *Here is the rub, that knowledge is put together to sound good. It needs critical thinking & knowledge to check.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Electronic Life: Lenia
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If only the people pretending to build were actually building.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Want to know why Chemputation redefines the very concept of what a molecule is? Updated preprint arxiv.org/abs/2408.09171
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Emerging Technologies Papers
@ETN
Chemputer and Chemputation - A Universal Chemical Compound Synthesis Machine. arxiv.org/abs/2408.09171
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
When people say time is an illusion ask them what they think about aging and dying. This disconnect between reality & the imagined timelessness of the universe is just that, imaginary. Time is real. Carpe diem.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Something is happening…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
The origin of life is not computable, yet it happens anyways
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Want to know why assembly theory & chemputation are deeply connected? It’s all about copy number, complexity, & error correction.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Want to know why Chemputation redefines the very concept of what a molecule is? Updated preprint arxiv.org/abs/2408.09171
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Morning view.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Tom Kalil
@tkalil2050
Again - I have a stack of other great proposals. We need more funders interested in supporting materials science, chemistry, etc. in addition to bio. We also need support for platform technologies that can lower the cost of generating the data by 100X or more.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Robert Palgrave
@Robert_Palgrave
Pocket guide to materials discovery calculation methods
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m very excited about physical AI, especially when combined with chemistry…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Reinforcement learning is one of the most interesting & exciting AI technologies, especially when coupled with physical data collection.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Intelligence is about making out of distribution conjectures.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Karl Popper understands how AI can & cannot help science.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Science is the only social mechanism we have to understand how the world truly is, instead of how some of us may want to choose to describe it. It’s not surprising then that if you want to push a narrative science is a threat, and if you want to pretend you are not pushing narrative, you mascarade your ideas as science.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Well we know what molecules are according to the text books, but do we know what Molecules are according the theory of Chemputation…this is coming soon (Molecules from molecules is a play on Humans from humans by @aptshadow).
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
David Deutsch
@DavidDeutschOxf
It's sad and shocking that the mainstream consensus still confuses reason with logic(al deduction).
Nothing about conjecture.
The idea that we use 'analogy' is thin gruel. We seek general theories, so *of course* we test them first by trying to apply them to something else. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Well we know what molecules are according to the text books, but do we know what Molecules are according the theory of Chemputation…this is coming soon (Molecules from molecules is a play on Humans from humans by @aptshadow).
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The claim that life has been found on K2-18b is without foundation. This BBC article (www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c39jj9vkr34o) is some of the worst science journalism ever. Firstly dimethyl sulphide (DMS) and dimethyl disulphide (DMDS) are NOT biosignatures anymore than carbon dioxide is one.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Just finished redefining the idea of a molecule using assembly theory. Will preprint soon.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Quantum chemputation with coherent control & error correction can lead to chemical synthesis with 100% yield and 100% selectivity.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The only true agents we currently know of are human ones. AI agents are a tool driven by autonomous humans.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Science is not about an automaton-like process of observation, measurement, experiment. It is about building explanations improving on those of our ancestors, ones we might want to gift our descendants if they choose to accept them.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Automating an experiment is possible, automating science is not - there is no scientific “super-intelligence” to train on the methods of science given no one can agree exactly what science is. It’s modern myth making to assume otherwise.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Compression is not the same as knowledge.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I've said it before, I'll say it again, life does non random stuff at scale. Simple molecules cannot ever be used as robust biosignatures. Only detectable, measureable complexity, will tell us if life is present elsewhere in the universe. This is the prediction of Assembly Theory
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Imagine going into a library, asking a question, opening the books at random & writing down words at random to answer the question. Sounds like AGI to me.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Imagine going into a library, asking a question, opening the books at random & writing down words at random to answer the question. Sounds like AGI to me.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I've said it before, I'll say it again, life does non random stuff at scale. Simple molecules cannot ever be used as robust biosignatures. Only detectable, measureable complexity, will tell us if life is present elsewhere in the universe. This is the prediction of Assembly Theory
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The claim that life has been found on K2-18b is without foundation. This BBC article (www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c39jj9vkr34o) is some of the worst science journalism ever. Firstly dimethyl sulphide (DMS) and dimethyl disulphide (DMDS) are NOT biosignatures anymore than carbon dioxide is one.
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Here is the assembly space of DMS and DMDS the joint assembly index is 3 which is way below the threshold for organic-based life, which is 15.
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The way to use organic molecules as proxies for life requires complexity. Simple molecules like DMS, DMDS, CO2, O2 etc are EASY to find everywhere without life. Yes, life can make them, but so can non-living processes. The only way to find life is through molecular complexity:
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The measurement system to find life is based upon assembly theory which explains how selection and evolution pre-date modern biology. www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06600-9
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Only if we can make the molecules, even digital speed can’t outpace physics ;)
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Oh gosh, this is so wrong and missleading: www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c39jj9vkr34o
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Droplet video using an event camera reveals the trails… Thanks to @_sharmaabhi_
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Theories that cannot be tested are not really theories. They are just abstractions. Theories that are both testable, hard to vary, & predictive are important.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
What does Chemify do? 1) Search 2) Make 3) Learn
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Amanda B McGarvey
@ABMcGarvey
@CroninLab @leecronin - PhD student #88. Congratulations to Amit on your viva today along here with the external examiner Dr Paul Rimmer.
That's another of "my kids" all grown up. Proud "mother of the group" moment. -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Scott Nolan
@ScottNolan
I spent over a year at Founders Fund searching for an American enrichment company to invest in, only to find there wasn’t one.
So we built our own. General Matter is filling the nuclear U.S. fuel gap. We are enriching uranium in America, and we will be shipping by the end of the decade.
Join us to help fuel the next era in American power.
General Matter
@generalmatter
General Matter is enriching uranium for the US.
We will revive nuclear fuel production in America. We chose to do this not because it’s easy, and not because it’s hard, but because it needs doing.
Nothing gets made if fuel isn’t made. America’s ambitions, from manufacturing to AI, all require nuclear. It’s the only source of energy that is reliable, scalable, and clean. It’s not only our future but our present, powering almost half of our clean energy and roughly 20% of our grid today.
But the US is forced to look abroad for our nuclear fuel. Despite pioneering the technology, we’ve since outsourced enrichment to allies, competitors, and even adversaries. We didn’t just give up the lead. We’re no longer even in the game.
It’s time to enrich. For the past year, General Matter has been incubated within Founders Fund, with a team from SpaceX, Tesla, Anduril, national labs, and the DOD. We are undertaking an engineering challenge which, if successful, will fundamentally improve the trajectory of our nation.
The raw material is embedded in the bedrock beneath our feet. America’s future is written in stone.
We are turning our potential into power, and exceptional talent is needed. Join us. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Causation is fundamental & proof of this will upend modern physics. #assemblytheory
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Introducing the DrugPuter driven by our ChemputationAI. Will make any molecule in grams, on time, correct, every time. 100% pure.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Imagine if molecules could be made as easily as code is compiled. Today we are building the operating system for chemistry — turning synthesis into software, & molecules into searchable entities creating a universal technology for chemical discovery. @ChemifyX @CroninLab
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I've just proven the final step needed to make Quantum Chemputation possible...
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Imagine if molecules could be made as easily as code is compiled. Today we are building the operating system for chemistry — turning synthesis into software, & molecules into searchable entities creating a universal technology for chemical discovery. @ChemifyX @CroninLab
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Chemify has enabled access to outer chemical space for drug discovery & materials design.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
With our chemical search engine, Chemify is the fastest & most efficient chemical synthesis company in the world.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Lauren Ross
@ProfLaurenRoss
Just returned from an amazing workshop at Sara Walker and Paul Davies “Beyond Center for Fundamental Concepts in Science”—such an amazing group!!!
Thomas Moynihan
@nemocentric
Had a blast taking part in a workshop organised by @Sara_Imari & Paul Davies the past few days, at Arizona State University's Beyond Center. I gave a talk on the history of contingency, & we spoke about the origin of life, technological evolution & much more! Was great fun!🧫📡🧬
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
SCAM ALERT. This is a fake conference that ripped off my and other people’s names to trick people into registering. There is no such conference that I or the others shown were invited or agreed to. We are working to try to get this fraud taken down.
chemsymposia.com -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Computation is in the eye of the observer.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
LLMs are recursively deep software, but shallow causal structures in assembly space; human minds are recursively deep causal structures in assembly space, and our “software interface” is shallow. We can easily trick ourselves by anthropomorphizing a reality that is not there, thinking the world is experienced by everything as we see it in our own minds
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Consciousness, like computation, is not fundamental.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Philosophical zombies are inventions of the conscious mind, interesting the lineage to create the idea of non conscious entities (that can mimic conscious ones) includes conscious minds, and it might be the only place in the universe where this idea can exist
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Consciousness, like computation, is not fundamental.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The ghost of computation makes us believe that computation is fundamental. There is no physical basis for this. Computation is a human construct.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If you tell me something is certain / proven & you claim to be a scientist then I’m instantly going to call you out as a bullshitter.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
How to think about, and calculate the assembly index in assembly theory. The general definition and expression for pratical calculation. This is in our Introduction to Assembly Theory coming soon.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Computation is not a law of physics (laws are human constructs as well by the way). Physics allows us to find regularities that can be labelled & then computed.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Long Now Foundation
@longnow
"Life, not computation, unlocks our non-deterministic future. Only by looking beyond our current technological moment to the next technologies creating new life forms will we be able to understand what our future could hold."
Read an exclusive essay from @Sara_Imari on the physics underlying life: longnow.org/ideas/physics-life-complexity-assembly-theory/
Long Now Foundation
@longnow
Tomorrow: Join us for a Long Now Talk from astrobiologist and theoretical physicist @Sara_Imari Walker on An Informational Theory of Life
7 PM @ The Cowell Theater in San Francisco -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The ghost of computation makes us believe that computation is fundamental. There is no physical basis for this. Computation is a human construct.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Julian Dorey
@juliandorey
Julian Dorey Podcast Episode 289 Links:
YouTube: youtu.be/_dKCRtAoLK4
Spotify: open.spotify.com/episode/3lsfJghoTzA9qFY5ev5hB2 -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
How to think about, and calculate the assembly index in assembly theory. The general definition and expression for pratical calculation. This is in our Introduction to Assembly Theory coming soon.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
rage, rage against the pointless box
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Robotic exploration of amino-acid functionalised Molybdenum Blue polyoxometalate nanoclusters pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlepdf/2025/CC/D5CC00703H?pag…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
So here is a real 3D printer that we adapted to make a drug, Ibuprofen. This was in 2016, so just imagine what @croninlab and @chemifyx can do now using a chemical programming lanugage! www.beilstein-journals.org/bjoc/articles/12/276
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
So here is a real 3D printer that we adapted to make a drug, Ibuprofen. This was in 2016, so just imagine what @croninlab and @chemifyx can do now using a chemical programming lanugage! www.beilstein-journals.org/bjoc/articles/12/276
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Introducing the DrugPuter driven by our ChemputationAI. Will make any molecule in grams, on time, correct, every time. 100% pure.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chem
@Chem_CP
Online now: A programmable modular robot for the synthesis of molecular machines www.cell.com/chem/fulltext/S2451-9294(25)00094-4?rss=yes
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chatbots cannot invent anything novel, they are probabilistic search engines.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Please don’t send me theories you have written in collaboration with a chatbot. Unless you have built it from the ground up you will be sending smart sounding nonsense.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Today’s job, redefining what a molecule really is mathematically, precisely. Believe it or not, the current internationally recognised & text book definition is incomplete.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Chemify’s Large-Molecular-Model enabled search engine not only tells you if a molecule is accessible, it can design new molecules, plan the routes, & produces code to make them in real time on our robotic systems.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Causation is the time constant of time. No creative causation. No real time. Our current view of clock time exists within a window of creative time.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I have very strong views but they are weakly held. When I get new data, I adjust, & this happens very very quickly.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly complexity is the only force inflating the universe.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
No one is even close to cracking human intelligence.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Does god have ‘write access’ to physics?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I have an open mind.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly complexity is the only force inflating the universe.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
No one is even close to cracking human intelligence.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Vegetables were the real value creators once upon a time.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI alignment is the wrong objective.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Computer vision watching droplets in our lab.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This has never been more true.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This robot has Chemical General Intelligence.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If people tell you they are building a thing to do a thing but they don’t know what the thing doing is defined as then they are not actually building anything.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Droplets searching chemputeable space.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If people tell you they are building a thing to do a thing but they don’t know what the thing doing is defined as then they are not actually building anything.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This robot has Chemical General Intelligence.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Theory ‘Z’ is incomplete but the billions of dollars invested sold on the magic of ‘Z’ enabling Zputation to solve ‘Z’-enabled problems will be worth trillions because … ‘Z’.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The people that make effort to collect real data will be those that will inherit reality.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Modern AI methods will be seen as brute force methods to derive some correlations that cannot be rationalised because we were lazy & crushed out any principled analysis by expending vast quantities of energy.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
How could we design drugs, planes, microprocessors & think for a second that AI is sentient / magic / mysterious. Absolutely retarded.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Every time I see the phrase ‘AI powered’…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The lack of critical thinking amongst smart people is insane. We are living in the dark ages despite amazing progress in science & technology. How could such a massive gulf suddenly develop?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
BURKOV
@burkov
For the past two years, I've been consistently saying that these CEOs and their larvas-influencers are lying. Machine learning simply cannot do what they claimed they would achieve. Yet I've been labeled a naysayer, doomer, denier, and overall a negative person spoiling the fiesta.
Today, only an imbecile fails to see that they've been lied to. Altman has shut up about the AGI, Nadella doesn't want to hear about it, and only Amodei just can't shut his mouth—probably for medical reasons.
Do you really think they'll ever come and apologize to me for blaming me for speaking the truth? -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Computation is not fundamental.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
To solve intelligence you need to solve life, to solve life you need to solve the origin of life. Assembly theory aims to make progress across the board but progress is not guaranteed.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Our universities are among our most important social institutions precisely because they bring critical issues, like what we are allowed to say, into incisive focus. Universities are more important for defining the future of what societies want and should be more than ever.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
If that is not the role of the university I don’t know what is.
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
Our universities are among the most important social institutions precisely because they bring critical issues, like what we are allowed to say, into critical focus. Universities are more important for defining the future of what societies want and should be more than ever.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Chemify is Making Chemistry Great Again.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
MoMA today.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This is impressive & important.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
Many will hate this piece, but free speech isn’t about protecting popular opinions.
Mahmoud Khalil’s arrest raises serious First Amendment concerns. What happens next could reshape campus speech rights—and not for the better. eternallyradicalidea.com/p/five-things-to-remember-as-the… -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
John Arnold
@johnarnold
I have great respect for politicians and orgs that stand by their principles regardless of the political winds or incentives.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
Many will hate this piece, but free speech isn’t about protecting popular opinions.
Mahmoud Khalil’s arrest raises serious First Amendment concerns. What happens next could reshape campus speech rights—and not for the better. eternallyradicalidea.com/p/five-things-to-remember-as-the… -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In 5 yrs human minds will be making shit up just like today @PeterDiamandis
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The multiverse seems like an extreme price just to pay for the reality of time. @DavidDeutschOxf
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I see parallels between those advocating / dreaming of the paranormal in the early 1900s with that of the agency of AI in 2025…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI does not learn. Only autonomous individuals learn. AI is a tool that can be used to find correlations. It’s quite weird that some supposedly well trained scientists, communicators, tech bros, & computer scientists kinda just make random stuff up. Critical thinking required…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI cannot in principle do science but it can be used as a tool to help process data. AI is not autonomous, & does not come up with its own problems to solve. That’s so obvious if you don’t understand you need to do some philosophy.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Machines are designed from abstract spaces. They cannot be evolved, there is a phase transition in intelligence that separates the two. The brain cannot & is not a machine.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’so tempted to write an essay entitled ‘why androids cannot yet dream of electric sheep’, but I’ll just get ‘tech bro’ & ‘AI is god’ abuse.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The current generation of compute / gen AI is going to show what is missing. Human brains are able to go beyond computation *as currently formulated*. This is an exciting frontier. The human mind is physically instantiated but it is not yet possible to reproduce it with silicon.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI cannot in principle do science but it can be used as a tool to help process data. AI is not autonomous, & does not come up with its own problems to solve. That’s so obvious if you don’t understand you need to do some philosophy.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Saturday night radioactivity.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Chemify’s AI designs, discovers, & makes molecules using encrypted instructions, safely, securely, quickly, & on demand in our chemical robot farms.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
the origin of life isn’t going to solve itself is it? OR maybe it will. It’s always fun working on a problem that is literally about how the universe started to construct objects like yourself, meaning you have to look directly at the deepest roots of your own history.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory explains causation but it is also the ultimate compressor, in fact assembly theory is so tight, you can’t compress beyond the assembly index. 🤣
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
New tweet about sustainability to avoid confusion. Using technology to get to sustainability is the best thing that has happened & can happen to humanity, but it looks messy. We are living longer, happier, & more interesting lives.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Nassim Nicholas Taleb
@nntaleb
2/ Remember that LLMs are just blind probabilistic lookups from higher dimensional tables, which sets you up for the mother of all problem of induction when you hit a (consequential) missing entry.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I mine knowledge from the universe to help humanity & it is not obvious or easy. In fact it’s really really hard.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The false narrative about AI, helped by doomers who provided mysticism, has meant that countries are faked into a competition with each other leading to them abandon standards & individual protection. We need authenticated uses & data not mystical worrying. AI is not magic.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The false narrative about AI, helped by doomers who provided mysticism, has meant that countries are faked into a competition with each other leading to them abandon standards & individual protection. We need authenticated uses & data not mystical worrying. AI is not magic.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The premise that ‘current AI is profound’ is not right. The advent of the algorithm was profound. The Turing machine was profound. AI confirms that maths works. But, maths is not the ground truth, it helps quantify it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
With the most advanced system for ChemicalAI in the world which combines robotics, chemical synthesis & AI. Chemify was born here…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
AI is a fantastic data processing tool aiding human reasoning when the data context is well defined.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Current AI faces a massive bottleneck. Chemify is solving this for chemistry by collecting real data at scale to solve chemistry.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Application of Assembly Theory to solid state materials and crystals. It is all about the defects... arxiv.org/abs/2502.09750
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Part of the assembly space of GREEN-EGGS-AND-HAM
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Abhishek Sharma
@_sharmaabhi_
Our new preprint on the application of Assembly Theory to solid state materials.
arxiv.org/abs/2502.09750 -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
John Templeton Foundation
@templeton_fdn
How can nonliving molecules transform into living tissue? 🤔 It’s the work of assembly theory, says chemist @leecronin.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Application of Assembly Theory to solid state materials and crystals. It is all about the defects... arxiv.org/abs/2502.09750
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Just go with the flow of assembly in time.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It is crazy that some computer scientists are saying that chemistry experiments don’t have to happen ‘in the real’. I guess we need to invent ‘Chemportation’ which teleports molecules from simulation to the real world using Molecular Actuation Ghosts In Chemistry (MAGIC).
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Experiments will always beat
simulation. Anyone who thinks otherwise is simply wrong. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Experiments will always beat
simulation. Anyone who thinks otherwise is simply wrong. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It is crazy that some computer scientists are saying that chemistry experiments don’t have to happen ‘in the real’. I guess we need to invent ‘Chemportation’ which teleports molecules from simulation to the real world using Molecular Actuation Ghosts In Chemistry (MAGIC).
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The Digital Chemistry Laboratory @UofGlasgow is at the cutting edge developing Chemputation, Chemical Computers, Selection Engines, exploring everything from the origin of life to drug discovery as well as spinning out companies @ChemifyX .
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Quantifying the complexity of materials with assembly theory... coming soon.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The great thing about the way humans invent, is that counterfactuals can be evaluated by the market before investment incredibly rapidly. That is easy. Implementation, & funding the valley of death is hard.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemify & Cronin lab featured here.
C&EN (Chemical & Engineering News)
@cenmag
👉This week in the C&EN Magazine: Artificial intelligence—the great job maker or taker? + Wil Srubar’s lab is full of living materials + Japan strives to make green hydrogen a pillar of its energy mix. Read more: cen.acs.org/magazine/103/10303.html?sc=250210_sc_eng_tw_cen #ai #chemtwitter
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Neural Network architectures are not reality whilst Assembly Theory architectures capture the minimum causation from reality.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory explains why panspermia is a bad theory. The simple building blocks of life can be made in space but any complexity will need a planetary environment for inorganic selection & evolution.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Podcast on Life, DNA, Cells, Panspermia, AI, Chemistry, Biology youtu.be/oc7AmxgskO0
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Friday night Chemputing.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemistry becomes universal finally… arxiv.org/abs/2502.02872
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In chemistry, software without hardware & wetware is just bullshit.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The past allows interference on what happened & is computable. The future requires creativity & it is not computable but it is material.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemistry becomes universal finally… arxiv.org/abs/2502.02872
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Shannon entropy is only valid when there is an agent that can encode, and an agent that can decode the message. This is why applying Shannon entropy to physical systems is always an ontological fail.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Shannon entropy is only valid when there is an agent that can encode, and an agent that can decode the message. This is why applying Shannon entropy to physical systems is always an ontological fail.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Bits don’t work for biology.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
evolutionary algorithms can approximate evolution, this does not mean evolution is an algorithm any more than algorithms that approximate gravity mean that gravity is an algorithm.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m only ever out of distribution
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The process of evolution is not an algorithm, it is something deeper, but still physical. Not everything physical can be explained from the bottom up algorithmically. Assembly theory explains why…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Salt river flying.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Rebecca Kinsler
@RebeccaKinsler
I've been reflecting on @leecronin lectures about Large Language Models (LLMs) and their function within the realm of computation. LLMs essentially reorganize existing data rather than predicting new outcomes. This led me to reconsider the nature of computation itself — it's fundamentally about managing historical information through memory, data storage, and data processing.
I've realized that I've been conflating computation with general operations. When I use the term "compute," I typically envision a straightforward "input-process-output" model. However, computation is a more defined subset of data processing. Traditional computers, in this sense, don't innovate or predict; they manipulate and reorganize known data. Computation's very limited, maybe we should reframe LLMs "Limited Language Models."
Cronin's concept of the "chemputer" introduces a new paradigm where computation isn't just about managing past information but also about generating new insights and predictions. The chemputer is designed to explore chemical space in ways that traditional computers cannot, essentially acting as a "prediction machine" for chemistry. His device leverages the vast potential of chemical reactions, which are different from the binary operations of conventional computers.
Human brains, composed of biological matter, operate differently from silicon-based computers, which indicates a limitation in traditional computing for certain tasks. Chemputers aim to bridge this gap by employing chemical processes that can mimic or even surpass certain aspects of biological compute like pattern recognition or chemical synthesis prediction.
Looking forward, the future of chemputation is still unfolding. It promises exciting advancements, potentially revolutionizing how we approach not just chemical synthesis but also broader scientific discovery. However, the exact trajectory or specific applications of chemputation remain in-question at this stage, making it a fascinating area to follow, research, and participate in. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This is a good podcast on AT.
The Swerve Podcast
@Swerve_Podcast
Science bordering on the Divine 🤣 Listen to the latest on 'Assembly Theory!'
⟁ SPOTIFY: open.spotify.com/show/5MC2T4wu9RDe3sSkBueOYj
⟁ APPLE: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-swerve-podcast-obscure-…
#assemblytheory #sciencepodcast #originoflife #leecronin #popscience #stem #astrobioresearch #scienceforall #theories -
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputers are Turing complete & this is going to accelerate chemistry dramatically. Chem/acc
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Sometimes you just need to push the bomb into the sun.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Scripts, software, & scheduling are no substitute for a fundamental abstraction. In the end this layering always breaks & the data becomes worthless very quickly…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Now at the SLAS2025 in San Diego today. Yellow shoes & pink laces this time just in case you want to chat.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sabine Hossenfelder
@skdh
I don't know why so many Americans have this idea that Germans all feel guilty about WWII. I don't know anyone my generation or even my parents' generation who feels this way. I think this is a story that Americans are telling themselves.
What is true is that at least the Germans I know feel a responsibility to make sure what happened in Nazi Germany doesn't happen again, not here, and not anywhere else. I certainly do.
This is why we are scared by what we see happening in the United States. The concentration of power, the streamlining of opinions, the normalization of evil, and the populism to excuse it. These are all warning signs we were taught to recognize.
Americans have this idea that the Holocaust happened in Germany because something is especially wrong with Germans. We're just somehow especially evil. This is why the bad guys in Hollywood movies are always Germans. This is why they make jokes about our supposedly military sounding language.
I strongly disagree. What happened in Germany could have happened anywhere. It's just that Hitler was the first to exploit this weakness. He was a master of mass manipulation (probably strongly influenced by Le Bon's "The Crowd" -- worth a read if you don't know it).
Now we have new masters of mass manipulation. And of course Germans worry about it.
Don't confuse what we feel is our responsibility with guilt.
Yes, ugh, "responsibility". That sounds terribly German, doesn't it. I'm sure you read this wiz a Schermen eksent.
No, I'm not proud to be German. Why would I? I didn't do anything for it, I just happen to have been born to two Germans. But I am glad I am German because all things considered it's a good country.
But if it was possible to just identify as Earthling and not belong to any country, that's what I'd want to be. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In this world of easy AI the people who generate the data are the people who will rule the world…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chemputers are Turing complete & this is going to accelerate chemistry dramatically. Chem/acc
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Even chemputers need colour.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
DeepseekR1:70b is amazing. It’s not AGI or anything like that. But it’s a new technology. I’m all in to this AI, I just wish AI was not called AI.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In technology development the difference between fraudsters & visionaries is understanding of what the science says is possible today, vs. what is clearly impossible always.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Daniel S. Levine
@dslevine
.@leecronin @ChemifyX discusses the company’s platform technology for digitizing chemistry, how its programming language expands the chemical space it can explore, and how the integration of robotics into its platform accelerates drug discovery.
thebioreport.podbean.com/e/expanding-the-drug-developer-s… -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory expands Darwin’s survival of the fittest to the causation of the fittest.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Critical thinking often requires first principles & this can take time. Lazy short cuts can be costly.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Imagine a creationist trying to deny the evolution of lego. www.youtube.com/watch?v=RjxWIlPjNlY
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Before assembly theory physics could not deal with causation. Now it can.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Curiosity is the purest motivation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
No data, no AI. This is the bad news. The good news is that there is an infinite amount of data to mine. Chemistry is ripe for this & this is why chemputation is needed to automate collection & structure the data. arxiv.org/abs/2408.09171
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
our last universal common ancestor is more accurately described as a planet than as a cell
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m in SF for JPM25 but I’m a massive introvert. If you want to talk to me about Chemify, Chemputation or how to get AI in chemistry to work then I’m probably the only person with yellow laces, purple shoes, & red pants. Feel free to say hello. I might still run away though.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m in SF for JPM25 but I’m a massive introvert. If you want to talk to me about Chemify, Chemputation or how to get AI in chemistry to work then I’m probably the only person with yellow laces, purple shoes, & red pants. Feel free to say hello. I might still run away though.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Meet Heisenberg, the software agent that cloud controls chemputers to make molecules using our ChemputerAGI, safely, on demand, & reproducibly.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
People told me chemputation was impossible, not needed, obvious, & already done. Right now most of academia is still ignoring it. So I’m just doing it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
No data, no AI. This is the bad news. The good news is that there is an infinite amount of data to mine. Chemistry is ripe for this & this is why chemputation is needed to automate collection & structure the data. arxiv.org/abs/2408.09171
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Meet Heisenberg, the software agent that cloud controls chemputers to make molecules using our ChemputerAGI, safely, on demand, & reproducibly.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Hey @bryan_johnson can you do a DD for current CEOs who don’t sleep etc? Asking for a friend 😅
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I learnt about Mongolian throat music on X & I like it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m about to fly to SF & I have 11 glorious hours to finish perhaps the most profoundly broken code I’ve ever developed…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
People complain about X but as with all social things you get out what you put in. I rigorously block & ignore all negativity on X. This is bit like, erm, the real world. Why should you be coddled on X?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The stone shadows are amazing.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Geoff Plitt
@GeoffreyPlitt
Lex has also done several interviews with the leaders of an emerging (and fascinating) science called Assembly Theory, which were excellent:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=boI0DJME_D4 -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Being a CEO & an academic at the same time is fun because you get at least double the rejections. Correction it’s at least quadratic.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Institute of Art and Ideas
@IAI_TV
The current picture of matter that physics offers us is unable to explain how life evolved from inorganic materials. | iai.tv/articles/a-new-theory-of-matter-may-help-explain-l…
@leecronin argues that this assembly theory of matter shows how evolution by modification and selection isn’t simply the preserve of life but describes how all matter develops. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Flying through the mountain.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Lex Fridman
@lexfridman
Here's my conversation with Volodymyr Zelenskyy (@ZelenskyyUa).
It was an intense and heartfelt conversation, my goal for which was to do my small part in pushing for peace.
We spoke in a mix of 3 languages: English, Ukrainian, and Russian. It's fully dubbed in each of those 3 languages. The original (mixed-language version) is available as well. So the options are:
- Audio: English, Ukrainian, Russian, Original (Mixed)
- Subtitles: English, Ukrainian, Russian
It's available here on X and everywhere else. On X, I'm uploading the Full English overdub version. The other versions will be available on YouTube (see comment thread).
Timestamps:
0:00 - Introduction
3:29 - Introductory words from Lex
13:55 - Language
23:44 - World War II
40:32 - Invasion on Feb 24, 2022
47:07 - Negotiating Peace
1:07:24 - NATO and security guarantees
1:20:17 - Sitting down with Putin and Trump
1:39:47 - Compromise and leverage
1:45:15 - Putin and Russia
1:55:07 - Donald Trump
2:05:39 - Martial Law and Elections
2:17:58 - Corruption
2:26:44 - Elon Musk
2:30:47 - Trump Inauguration on Jan 20
2:33:55 - Power dynamics in Ukraine
2:37:27 - Future of Ukraine
2:42:09 - Choice of language
2:51:39 - Podcast prep and research process
3:00:04 - Travel and setup
3:05:51 - ConclusionThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The introduction to assembly to theory has been started. We will post a preliminary version soon, hopefully by end of Jan (to integrate some questions / feedback). Some figures & details might take more time. Working on it with @Sara_Imari.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Selection just killed the block universe stone dead.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Ridge surfing in Sedona.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Should we write an introduction to Assembly Theory for beginners interested in learning more?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Bell rock.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
A key mistake many startups make, especially the over funded ones, is that they can invent everything themselves rather than focussing on the one thing they excel at.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory, at the simplest level, puts causation into physics. It is theory of causation. The assembly index is a causal index.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Should we write an introduction to Assembly Theory for beginners interested in learning more?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
There is NO danger from AGI or super intelligence. There is massive danger for the bullshitification of everything by chatbots because people trust the output of chatbots like it’s authoritative; it is designed to sound right but it’s utter drivel.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Truth.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chatbots do not think critically. They don’t even think. They are probabilistic search engines. They can be helpful like any tool but currently they are built to be bullshitters. This is not helpful.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Peak screen.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Chatbots do not think critically. They don’t even think. They are probabilistic search engines. They can be helpful like any tool but currently they are built to be bullshitters. This is not helpful.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Please stop putting my science into chatbots & getting their bullshit analysis & sending it back to me like is a new insight. It’s insulting, unprofessional & shows you are lazy & not a critical thinker. Just don’t do it. Thank you!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Please stop putting my science into chatbots & getting their bullshit analysis & sending it back to me like is a new insight. It’s insulting, unprofessional & shows you are lazy & not a critical thinker. Just don’t do it. Thank you!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
There is NO danger from AGI or super intelligence. There is massive danger for the bullshitification of everything by chatbots because people trust the output of chatbots like it’s authoritative; it is designed to sound right but it’s utter drivel.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’ve got 2025 off to a flying start.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
What did the inorganic alien say to the organic alien? ‘I’m sorry there is no chemistry between us.’ 🤣
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Funny that quantum became woo just because we didn’t explain uncertainty properly.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Don’t you dare question me! Don’t you dare question entropy! Don’t you dare question ‘science’! Oh hang, on question, science? Yes. ALWAYS question the unquestionable.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
It’s worth reading some of Edwin Jaynes’s work if you are interested in subjectivity of entropy, also there is a great paper by Shalizi and Moore on subjective and objective interpretations of macro states I often go back to and also have my students read.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I love messing with peoples world view with rationality & reason. Don’t worry, if you’re not self critical I’m here to help
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Sara Imari Walker
@Sara_Imari
I’ve been shocked to learn from some people I meet that the second law of thermodynamics is central to their personal philosophy, they have enough training to respect physics but not enough to understand it’s current limitations - entropy is a subjective concept, dependent on an observer/measuring device defined labeling, yet some assume it is objective that all roads lead to heat death
David Deutsch
@DavidDeutschOxf
Entropy gets a bad rap. It's our friend, caused by error-correction such as life and thought. Whether there will be heat death in a googol years or a big rip in 100 billion, or neither, is currently unknown to cosmology. No moral or political theory should rely on prophesying it.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Chemical space is larger than outer space & harder to search. Chemify is dropping the cost to search chemical space. In 2025 our first Chemifarm for chemical space exploration opens in Glasgow!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
System is 5-Pi-5 each overclocked to 3.4 GHz ready to cluster.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The major misunderstanding about the emergence of order from chaos is the chaos. At the beginning, before selection, things were simply ‘undefined’. Sustained existence over time brings the undefined into defined via selection.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Here I’m trying to think but I was utterly engulfed in confusion. Or was I just appalled at my stupidity? Here I am on Future of Space: youtu.be/p1VYaVxuUIc Happy xmas all.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
There needs to be a new mechanics. Not classical. Not quantum. But something else.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The interface between the determined & the undetermined is where creativity is born. It is intrinsically non computable.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m confused.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Climate change is not a climate crisis, it is an economic crisis.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In technology being right is always more impactful than being wrong.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
In science being wrong is always more interesting than being right.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Pi5 overclocked to 3GHz with water cooling keeping the CPU to around 30 deg C.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
It’s taking shape…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Water cooler Pi5 cluster that will be overlocked to the max for ‘molecular dreaming’.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Something is building…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’m at the airport watching parents lie to their kids. Best one so far is the parent saying to their 2-3 yr old “get off the floor because you will get dirty & dirty children are not allowed on the plane” the kid then lies on the floor.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Yuri Milner
@yurimilner
So much in science is still to be discovered – including the fundamental mechanisms of life. Scientists now think bacterial cells may pass 'memories' to their descendants independent of gene transfers.
phys.org/news/2024-08-bacterial-cells-transmit-memories-o… -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I don’t think we have any remote chance of making true artificial intelligence. You can’t make what you can’t define or measure.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I think it’s always safe to assume people are good & their intentions are honourable
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’ve long hypothesized that ‘life is the universe developing a memory’. This is the basis of Assembly Theory (AT) and Philip Ball has written an article about AT published here in Quanta. www.quantamagazine.org/a-new-theory-for-the-assembly-of-l…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory of soup…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The problem is not that genAI generates fake, or inaccurate results, it’s the fact that some people currently use the tools to fake the fact they did some work.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly Theory is the only way to objectively measure the complexity of objects, systems, & phenomena. All other methods require assumptions which inject additional complexity into the data without normalisation which prevents a meaningful comparison.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin reposted
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Datalover says it all.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Life ensures the future is bigger than the past.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Datalover says it all.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I've just realised that Chemputation is the medium for the transmission of chemistry though time. Inspired by @astupple
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Everyone else seems to be slowing down while I’m speeding up.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Karl Popper’s work explains why LLMs cannot generate new explantory knowledge.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Digital Chemistry was born at the University of Glasgow almost a decade ago. Take a look at the first & only purpose built digital chemistry facility in the world based here in Glasgow! @CroninLab @UofGlasgow @UofGChem @UofGARC
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Next gen AI might send us into a new dark ages where we just use deception to make things unscientific seem plausible. Next gen AI cannot generate new knowledge, & the fact that so many smart people argue about this so passionately means we are loosing the war on rationality.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Generative AI does not give access to open ended creativity. Evolution & humans do. GenAI derived content is fundamentally boring & will get more boring.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The development of a programming language for chemistry that allows the sharing of reproducible synthetic recipes has long been a dream. Now with @procrastiprof it has come true! #chemputation www.nature.com/articles/s44160-023-00478-1 & the paper here www.nature.com/articles/s44160-023-00473-6
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
The fact we are actually debating if AI companies with a lot of compute can compress other people’s property & resell it without blinking is just hilarious.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Freedom of speech is vital at all costs & academic freedom is a subset of that.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Anyone who talks about the probability about the class of things that has never happened e.g. AGI, nuclear war, etc etc is talking nonsense. It is impossible to put a probability on a totally new class that we are not even sure can happen.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Some thoughts on on the discussion on our recent paper on Assembly Theory x.com/Nature/status/1709800557257306572. 1/10 First I'm pretty confused & concerned by a minority of the comments which seem to be out of place & stand in the way of a productive & respectful discourse.
nature
@Nature
Nature research paper: Assembly theory explains and quantifies selection and evolution go.nature.com/46Bma1m
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Our Assembly Theory paper is just out in @nature www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-06600-9 A gerat collaboration with @Sara_Imari @ASU and @sfiscience
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Assembly theory was featured on the cover of @newscientist in June with an interview with the amazing @Sara_Imari
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
A little bit of news here.
Chemify
@ChemifyX
Chemify today announces $43 million to digitise chemistry. www.ft.com/content/be25204a-6ad6-4db5-bbf5-f819954d0ce5
-
Post not available here, view on X
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
And happy birthday to @MilesPadgett !!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
We're developing a proposal for an @EPSRC AI hub for Open Network for Artificial Chemical Intelligence & Discovery: On-ACID with @UofGlasgow @RosFrankInst @cambridge_uni @BristolUni @officialUoM @uniofoxford @unibirmingham & open to all. Get in touch & RT!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I’ve long hypothesized that ‘life is the universe developing a memory’. This is the basis of Assembly Theory (AT) and Philip Ball has written an article about AT published here in Quanta. www.quantamagazine.org/a-new-theory-for-the-assembly-of-l…
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Introducing UCP - a universal chemical language allows human readable XDL code of chemical synthesis. >50,000 reactions are online here: www.syn-txt.com this is also connected to the ORD open-reaction-database.org/client/browse Please retweet!
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Finally some DIY acoustic levitation.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Love glassware. Coffeeputer?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
What is the substrate at the bottom of reality? Is it mathematical, computational, consciousness, or material stuff?
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Machine learning is mostly just linear algebra & people are excited. Chemistry is mostly mixing stuff to make stuff & I want people to get excited about that also. #chemify
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
Lets replace all references in manuscripts with DOIs & eliminate the tyranny of reference formatting.
-
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
I pledge to oppose racism and hate through active allyship, continuous unlearning, learning, and listening. Join me by nominating 5 others to do the same. #blacklivesmatter
I nominate @Gassensmith @NGRColosimo @rafalklajn @BaranLabReads @professor_dave -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
So long and thanks all the fish.
UK research outcomes software is a insult to modern data gathering, looks like a 8 yr old cooked it up in computer class & it doesn’t really work. Apart from that it’s awesome! @Researchfish -
Prof. Lee Cronin
@leecronin
This is genius. www.mchawking.com I think every Prof needs a gangsta 'outreach' page. #realtimegangstachem ?



















































































































