Doomslayer Progress Roundup: Poverty has plummeted in Rwanda; homeless falls in the US; human intervention saves endangered species, including blue whales and sea turtles; China's CO2 emissions are falling. open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/doomslaye…
Steven Pinker
Steven Arthur Pinker (born September 18, 1954) is a Canadian cognitive psychologist, psycholinguist, popular science author, and public intellectual. He is an advocate of evolutionary psychology and the computational theory of mind. Pinker is the Johnstone Family professor of psychology at Harvard University. More on Wikipedia
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Eric Boodman
@EricBoodman
In June, guards expelled five scientists from a conference. Months later, some 1,200 researchers are boycotting the American Diabetes Association.
I wrote about how diabetes research has become a microcosm of Trump's America.
www.nytimes.com/2026/11/09/science/american-diabetes-asso… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Latest NYT science article by @ericboodman
Eric Boodman
@EricBoodman
In June, guards expelled five scientists from a conference. Months later, some 1,200 researchers are boycotting the American Diabetes Association.
I wrote about how diabetes research has become a microcosm of Trump's America.
www.nytimes.com/2026/11/09/science/american-diabetes-asso… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How to rewire your brain — and find your flow (Heather Berlin | TED2026) www.ted.com/talks/heather_berlin_how_to_rewire_your_brain… via @TEDTalks
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I just subscribed to (Heather) Berlin on the Brain. Sign up here: berlinonthebrain.substack.com?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Liberals Are Wrong to Fear the Internet, argues free speech historian Jacob Mchangama. (The Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh recently invited him to speak on campus.) open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/no-social-media-isnt-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Leonard Cohen — ‘a man whose compass always led him home’ by my friend Cantor Gideon Zelermeyer. montrealgazette.com/opinion/op-eds/opinion-leonard-cohen-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Latest NYT science article by @ericboodman
Eric Boodman
@EricBoodman
In June, guards expelled five scientists from a conference. Months later, some 1,200 researchers are boycotting the American Diabetes Association.
I wrote about how diabetes research has become a microcosm of Trump's America.
www.nytimes.com/2026/11/09/science/american-diabetes-asso… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I will miss the brilliant, prolific, intellectually independent Judge Richard Posner. www.nytimes.com/2026/11/11/us/richard-posner-dead.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I will miss the brilliant, prolific, intellectually independent Judge Richard Posner. www.nytimes.com/2026/11/11/us/richard-posner-dead.html
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
The Physics Law That Guarantees Everything Will Go Wrong
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein | @platobooktour
TIMESTAMPS :
00:00 Why every human being needs to matter — and what happens when they can't
04:25 The second law of thermodynamics and what it has to do with your life
08:00 The 4 types of people: Transcenders, Socializers, Heroic Strivers, and Competitors
17:30 Why fame-seeking millennials will give up everything — including relationships
22:00 Zero-sum mattering: the competitor who was happy for 15 minutes after winning a Nobel Prize
24:15 Ludwig Boltzmann solved one of physics' greatest paradoxes — then despaired
34:50 All tragedies are thermodynamic — and so is depression
40:00 Life as resistance to entropy: what flourishing actually means
54:00 Can AI have a mattering instinct? What that would mean for human rights
57:50 If AI becomes a heroic striver, what's left for us?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
The 4 Types of People and Which One Destroys You
Rebecca Goldstein | @platobooktourThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
The Physics of Mattering: Do AI Agents Have a Soul?
Rebecca Goldstein | @platobooktourThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The U.S. Is Driving Away Young Scientists (I see this happening with my students). www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/11/09/science/trump-fund…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The dictionary has been abandoned by its publisher (that's why I'm no longer Chair -- the Usage Panel no longer exists) but lives on online, and I consult it frequently. www.ahdictionary.com
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Spanish Shylock Problem: The official dictionary of the Royal Spanish Academy includes "miser" among its definitions of judio, Jew, over the objections of an Argentinian judge who ordered it removed. The dictionary indicates it's offensive, and this is the proper policy: dictionaries are reference works that people consult to learn how other people use words; they are not arbiters of words' meanings. When I was chair of the Usage Panel of the American Heritage Dictionary, we often had to decide on how to define offensive terms (e.g., anchor baby) that people encountered in their lives and wanted to understand, and they were prominently labeled as "offensive." The dictionary long had entries for ethnic, misogynistic, and racial slurs for this reason. www.nytimes.com/2026/11/12/opinion/spanish-dictionary-jew…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Plague, gruel and bad teeth: why do people idealise the olden days? Review of Chelsea Follett's The Grim Old Days www.economist.com/culture/2026/11/12/plague-gruel-and-bad…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Its handling of human intelligence is also a travesty: quillette.com/2022/07/18/cognitive-distortions/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Wikipedia may be the Web's greatest accomplishment, but it is not infallible, and in several hot-button issues, it has been captured by activists. One of the most egregious is its rewriting of "Zionism" after 10/7: quillette.substack.com/p/how-wikipedia-rewrote-zionism?r=…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Plague, gruel and bad teeth: why do people idealise the olden days? Review of Chelsea Follett's The Grim Old Days www.economist.com/culture/2026/11/12/plague-gruel-and-bad…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Spanish Shylock Problem: The official dictionary of the Royal Spanish Academy includes "miser" among its definitions of judio, Jew, over the objections of an Argentinian judge who ordered it removed. The dictionary indicates it's offensive, and this is the proper policy: dictionaries are reference works that people consult to learn how other people use words; they are not arbiters of words' meanings. When I was chair of the Usage Panel of the American Heritage Dictionary, we often had to decide on how to define offensive terms (e.g., anchor baby) that people encountered in their lives and wanted to understand, and they were prominently labeled as "offensive." The dictionary long had entries for ethnic, misogynistic, and racial slurs for this reason. www.nytimes.com/2026/11/12/opinion/spanish-dictionary-jew…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The dictionary has been abandoned by its publisher (that's why I'm no longer Chair -- the Usage Panel no longer exists) but lives on online, and I consult it frequently. www.ahdictionary.com
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Review here: www.publishersweekly.com/978-1-324-09685-6
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Goldstein, a philosopher and novelist, elegantly moves between philosophy and reportage for this revelatory consideration of how the desire to matter shapes both inner life and social values. In the process, she makes a moving case for the importance of honoring innate human worth in a frequently impersonal and fractured world."
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rebecca Goldstein's The Mattering Instinct named one of the Best Books of 2026 by Publishers Weekly. best-books.publishersweekly.com/pw/best-books/2026/nonfic…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I will be lecturing, debating, and conversing with the audience in San Francisco on January 30th.
More information and tickets at www.pang-burn.com/tickets -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Gary Marcus meets the Pope! garymarcus.substack.com/p/report-from-the-vatican?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New interview for Thinkable, with Iona Italia: Steven Pinker on What Happens When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows ... thinkablereview.substack.com/p/steven-pinker-on-what-happ…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Its handling of human intelligence is also a travesty: quillette.com/2022/07/18/cognitive-distortions/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Wikipedia may be the Web's greatest accomplishment, but it is not infallible, and in several hot-button issues, it has been captured by activists. One of the most egregious is its rewriting of "Zionism" after 10/7: quillette.substack.com/p/how-wikipedia-rewrote-zionism?r=…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker: Why we pretend everyone is equal | Rak höger": www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZ2XWboAPjQ
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker: Why we pretend everyone is equal | Rak höger"
Me:
I think there is hope, and I think we may have just, just passed peak woke, although there were rather extreme manifestations of that in 2020 and 2021 after the George Floyd killing. It’s still a serious problem, and it’s got to be, simply because professors in the United States have tenure, and so they’re in their positions until they die or retire.
Ivar Arpi (@Ivarpi):
Or capital punishment.
Me:
Or capital punishment, yes.
So it turns over very slowly, and I think that the problem is that, in most universities, especially in the social sciences and humanities, there is a political monoculture on the left and an absence of political diversity. This is not a problem just in being unrepresentative, because there’s nothing that says that a university has to match the demographics of the society. But the problem is that, when there are legitimate hypotheses within a field that tend to be correlated with political ideology—and there are plenty of them—certain hypotheses just don’t get voiced, don’t get thought, don’t get taught. Certain criticisms never get made simply because everyone thinks the same way.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The U.S. Is Driving Away Young Scientists (I see this happening with my students). www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/11/09/science/trump-fund…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Latest NYT science article by @ericboodman
Eric Boodman
@EricBoodman
In June, guards expelled five scientists from a conference. Months later, some 1,200 researchers are boycotting the American Diabetes Association.
I wrote about how diabetes research has become a microcosm of Trump's America.
www.nytimes.com/2026/11/09/science/american-diabetes-asso… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I joined the APA as a postdoc, and resigned a few years ago. This article explains why: The Inmates Run the Asylum at the Psychological Association by @SwipeWright and @Hartz_PhD www.wsj.com/opinion/the-inmates-run-the-asylum-at-the-psy… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Latest NYT science article by @ericboodman
Eric Boodman
@EricBoodman
In June, guards expelled five scientists from a conference. Months later, some 1,200 researchers are boycotting the American Diabetes Association.
I wrote about how diabetes research has become a microcosm of Trump's America.
www.nytimes.com/2026/11/09/science/american-diabetes-asso… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The U.S. Is Driving Away Young Scientists (I see this happening with my students). www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/11/09/science/trump-fund…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Its handling of human intelligence is also a travesty: quillette.com/2022/07/18/cognitive-distortions/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Wikipedia may be the Web's greatest accomplishment, but it is not infallible, and in several hot-button issues, it has been captured by activists. One of the most egregious is its rewriting of "Zionism" after 10/7: quillette.substack.com/p/how-wikipedia-rewrote-zionism?r=…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker: Why we pretend everyone is equal | Rak höger": www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZ2XWboAPjQ
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker: Why we pretend everyone is equal | Rak höger"
Me:
I think there is hope, and I think we may have just, just passed peak woke, although there were rather extreme manifestations of that in 2020 and 2021 after the George Floyd killing. It’s still a serious problem, and it’s got to be, simply because professors in the United States have tenure, and so they’re in their positions until they die or retire.
Ivar Arpi (@Ivarpi):
Or capital punishment.
Me:
Or capital punishment, yes.
So it turns over very slowly, and I think that the problem is that, in most universities, especially in the social sciences and humanities, there is a political monoculture on the left and an absence of political diversity. This is not a problem just in being unrepresentative, because there’s nothing that says that a university has to match the demographics of the society. But the problem is that, when there are legitimate hypotheses within a field that tend to be correlated with political ideology—and there are plenty of them—certain hypotheses just don’t get voiced, don’t get thought, don’t get taught. Certain criticisms never get made simply because everyone thinks the same way.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's always The End of History. Brilliant essay by Harry Seavy: "Ours is the decisive moment, and it is we who are alive to see it, to shape it, to place history on the tracks of what we make out of it. In this decade, as the winds of crisis whip around us—democracy, liberalism, AI, climate change—as we stand uniquely at the precipice, the very point at which things will either tip over into the abyss or be miraculously rescued from it, we face a moment the world has never seen before. Just like everyone else before us." quillette.com/2026/11/06/after-apocalypse/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Men Die Younger Than Women, and Women Suffer More Pain open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/why-men-die-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I joined the APA as a postdoc, and resigned a few years ago. This article explains why: The Inmates Run the Asylum at the Psychological Association by @SwipeWright and @Hartz_PhD www.wsj.com/opinion/the-inmates-run-the-asylum-at-the-psy… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I Wouldn’t Hurt A Fly, explains Rebecca Newberger Goldstein (with an analysis of the concept of human dignity). @platobooktour rebeccanewbergergoldstein.substack.com/p/i-wouldnt-hurt-a…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rebecca Goldstein's The Mattering Instinct named one of the Best Books of 2026 by Publishers Weekly. best-books.publishersweekly.com/pw/best-books/2026/nonfic…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Evolution does not need a rebuild, and The Selfish Gene is not outmoded. It remains...a page-turner." Nathaniel Comfort's misguided take on The Selfish Gene at 50 whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/10/27/nathaniel-comforts-wonk…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Link to Harvard Hillel panel: hillel.harvard.edu/calendar/category/programs/week/2026-1…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rabbis and Scholars: The Ethics of Artificial Intelligence
This evening! November 9, 2026
6:30 pm - 8:00 pm
hillel.harvard.edu/calendar/category/programs/week/2026-1…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Monday at Harvard Hillel: I'm on a panel with two Rabbis on AI & Humanity: Mind, Machine, and Meaning - Rabbis and Scholars on our Future with AI.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Monday at Harvard Hillel: I'm on a panel with two Rabbis on AI & Humanity: Mind, Machine, and Meaning - Rabbis and Scholars on our Future with AI.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker: Why we pretend everyone is equal | Rak höger"
Me:
I think there is hope, and I think we may have just, just passed peak woke, although there were rather extreme manifestations of that in 2020 and 2021 after the George Floyd killing. It’s still a serious problem, and it’s got to be, simply because professors in the United States have tenure, and so they’re in their positions until they die or retire.
Ivar Arpi (@Ivarpi):
Or capital punishment.
Me:
Or capital punishment, yes.
So it turns over very slowly, and I think that the problem is that, in most universities, especially in the social sciences and humanities, there is a political monoculture on the left and an absence of political diversity. This is not a problem just in being unrepresentative, because there’s nothing that says that a university has to match the demographics of the society. But the problem is that, when there are legitimate hypotheses within a field that tend to be correlated with political ideology—and there are plenty of them—certain hypotheses just don’t get voiced, don’t get thought, don’t get taught. Certain criticisms never get made simply because everyone thinks the same way.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I joined the APA as a postdoc, and resigned a few years ago. This article explains why: The Inmates Run the Asylum at the Psychological Association by @SwipeWright and @Hartz_PhD www.wsj.com/opinion/the-inmates-run-the-asylum-at-the-psy… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Tony Morley
@tonymmorley
The “Defend the West” online conference by @ConjectureInst and @ChipkinLogan, January 13th, 2027, is stacked with brilliant speakers: @johanknorberg, @sapinker, Deirdre McCloskey, @michaelshermer, @nickgillespie, @yaronbrook and more. Register here: conjectureinstitute.org/events/defend-the-west
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Latest updates on human progress from @HumanProgress humanprogress.org/blog-type/news/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is anomie a First World problem? "Modern life values personal choice and increases the range of choices open to ordinary people. In modernity, the quest for meaning and purpose is fulfilled through individual and voluntary collaborative action. As such, we should reject the complaints of anomie and, to the extent that they have a foundation, regard it as a problem of success." open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/anomie-an…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Leonard Cohen — ‘a man whose compass always led him home’ by my friend Cantor Gideon Zelermeyer. montrealgazette.com/opinion/op-eds/opinion-leonard-cohen-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How Trump Is Dismantling America’s Scientific Research Machine www.nytimes.com/2026/10/31/science/how-trump-is-dismantli…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Its handling of human intelligence is also a travesty: quillette.com/2022/07/18/cognitive-distortions/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Wikipedia may be the Web's greatest accomplishment, but it is not infallible, and in several hot-button issues, it has been captured by activists. One of the most egregious is its rewriting of "Zionism" after 10/7: quillette.substack.com/p/how-wikipedia-rewrote-zionism?r=…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How Trump Is Dismantling America’s Scientific Research Machine www.nytimes.com/2026/10/31/science/how-trump-is-dismantli…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Leonard Cohen — ‘a man whose compass always led him home’ by my friend Cantor Gideon Zelermeyer. montrealgazette.com/opinion/op-eds/opinion-leonard-cohen-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is anomie a First World problem? "Modern life values personal choice and increases the range of choices open to ordinary people. In modernity, the quest for meaning and purpose is fulfilled through individual and voluntary collaborative action. As such, we should reject the complaints of anomie and, to the extent that they have a foundation, regard it as a problem of success." open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/anomie-an…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Wikipedia may be the Web's greatest accomplishment, but it is not infallible, and in several hot-button issues, it has been captured by activists. One of the most egregious is its rewriting of "Zionism" after 10/7: quillette.substack.com/p/how-wikipedia-rewrote-zionism?r=…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Latest updates on human progress from @HumanProgress humanprogress.org/blog-type/news/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I will be lecturing, debating, and conversing with the audience in San Francisco on January 30th.
More information and tickets at www.pang-burn.com/tickets -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New interview for Thinkable, with Iona Italia: Steven Pinker on What Happens When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows ... thinkablereview.substack.com/p/steven-pinker-on-what-happ…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Its handling of human intelligence is also a travesty: quillette.com/2022/07/18/cognitive-distortions/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker: Why we pretend everyone is equal | Rak höger"
Me:
I think there is hope, and I think we may have just, just passed peak woke, although there were rather extreme manifestations of that in 2020 and 2021 after the George Floyd killing. It’s still a serious problem, and it’s got to be, simply because professors in the United States have tenure, and so they’re in their positions until they die or retire.
Ivar Arpi (@Ivarpi):
Or capital punishment.
Me:
Or capital punishment, yes.
So it turns over very slowly, and I think that the problem is that, in most universities, especially in the social sciences and humanities, there is a political monoculture on the left and an absence of political diversity. This is not a problem just in being unrepresentative, because there’s nothing that says that a university has to match the demographics of the society. But the problem is that, when there are legitimate hypotheses within a field that tend to be correlated with political ideology—and there are plenty of them—certain hypotheses just don’t get voiced, don’t get thought, don’t get taught. Certain criticisms never get made simply because everyone thinks the same way.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker: Why we pretend everyone is equal | Rak höger": www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZ2XWboAPjQ
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's always The End of History. Brilliant essay by Harry Seavy: "Ours is the decisive moment, and it is we who are alive to see it, to shape it, to place history on the tracks of what we make out of it. In this decade, as the winds of crisis whip around us—democracy, liberalism, AI, climate change—as we stand uniquely at the precipice, the very point at which things will either tip over into the abyss or be miraculously rescued from it, we face a moment the world has never seen before. Just like everyone else before us." quillette.com/2026/11/06/after-apocalypse/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Men Die Younger Than Women, and Women Suffer More Pain open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/why-men-die-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In South Caroline to appear at the Charleston Literary Festival, where I'll chat on stage with Geoffrey Harpham about When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. www.charlestonliteraryfestival.com/2026-speakers
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In South Caroline to appear at the Charleston Literary Festival, where I'll chat on stage with Geoffrey Harpham about When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. www.charlestonliteraryfestival.com/2026-speakers
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Men Die Younger Than Women, and Women Suffer More Pain open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/why-men-die-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Once again, Quillette publishes a gorgeous, erudite essay making a point that no one else in the current hubbub is making.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's always The End of History. Brilliant essay by Harry Seavy: "Ours is the decisive moment, and it is we who are alive to see it, to shape it, to place history on the tracks of what we make out of it. In this decade, as the winds of crisis whip around us—democracy, liberalism, AI, climate change—as we stand uniquely at the precipice, the very point at which things will either tip over into the abyss or be miraculously rescued from it, we face a moment the world has never seen before. Just like everyone else before us." quillette.com/2026/11/06/after-apocalypse/
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Once again, Quillette publishes a gorgeous, erudite essay making a point that no one else in the current hubbub is making.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Ivar Arpi
@Ivarpi
Have Universities Passed Peak Woke, @sapinker?
Listen to the whole interview: www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZ2XWboAPjQThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Nick Gillespie
@nickgillespie
Thank God it's Friday. At @TheFIREorg's Soapbox conference, listening to @sapinker and @JohnHMcWhorter discussing speech taboos over breakfast. Incredible conference.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Adam Thierer
@AdamThierer
Another great day begins at @TheFIREorg Soapbox conference with the amazing duo of @sapinker
& @JohnHMcWhorter on stage providing a history of swearing and taboo language!
It's fricking awesome. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker: Why we pretend everyone is equal | Rak höger"
Me:
I think there is hope, and I think we may have just, just passed peak woke, although there were rather extreme manifestations of that in 2020 and 2021 after the George Floyd killing. It’s still a serious problem, and it’s got to be, simply because professors in the United States have tenure, and so they’re in their positions until they die or retire.
Ivar Arpi (@Ivarpi):
Or capital punishment.
Me:
Or capital punishment, yes.
So it turns over very slowly, and I think that the problem is that, in most universities, especially in the social sciences and humanities, there is a political monoculture on the left and an absence of political diversity. This is not a problem just in being unrepresentative, because there’s nothing that says that a university has to match the demographics of the society. But the problem is that, when there are legitimate hypotheses within a field that tend to be correlated with political ideology—and there are plenty of them—certain hypotheses just don’t get voiced, don’t get thought, don’t get taught. Certain criticisms never get made simply because everyone thinks the same way.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker: Why we pretend everyone is equal | Rak höger": www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZ2XWboAPjQ
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
12 Things Everyone Should Know About Their Emotions, from Rob Kurzban's new book All the Feels. open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/12-things-ev…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Monday at Harvard Hillel: I'm on a panel with two Rabbis on AI & Humanity: Mind, Machine, and Meaning - Rabbis and Scholars on our Future with AI.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Link to Harvard Hillel panel: hillel.harvard.edu/calendar/category/programs/week/2026-1…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Proud to have been awarded the Barry Prize for Distinguished Intellectual Achievement from the American Academy of Sciences & Letters last night at the Library of Congress. academysciencesletters.org
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
12 Things Everyone Should Know About Their Emotions, from Rob Kurzban's new book All the Feels. open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/12-things-ev…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What's with Trump's obsession with men's derrieres? Damage to the prefrontal cortex, perverse ingenuity at commanding the nation's attention, or both? NYT's Tom Edsall wonders, quoting me and others (including my graduate school classmate Dan McAdams), leaning toward the first explanation. www.nytimes.com/2026/11/03/opinion/trump-backsides-langua…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Wikipedia may be the Web's greatest accomplishment, but it is not infallible, and in several hot-button issues, it has been captured by activists. One of the most egregious is its rewriting of "Zionism" after 10/7: quillette.substack.com/p/how-wikipedia-rewrote-zionism?r=…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Its handling of human intelligence is also a travesty: quillette.com/2022/07/18/cognitive-distortions/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I'll be speaking on the psychology of taboo language (swearing) at FIRE's Soapbox 2026 this Friday in Philadelphia (unfortunately, it's sold out). soapbox.fire.org
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I'll be speaking on the psychology of taboo language (swearing) at FIRE's Soapbox 2026 this Friday in Philadelphia (unfortunately, it's sold out). soapbox.fire.org
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Wikipedia may be the Web's greatest accomplishment, but it is not infallible, and in several hot-button issues, it has been captured by activists. One of the most egregious is its rewriting of "Zionism" after 10/7: quillette.substack.com/p/how-wikipedia-rewrote-zionism?r=…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Its handling of human intelligence is also a travesty: quillette.com/2022/07/18/cognitive-distortions/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Moving and substantive remembrance of the (first) environmental economist, Nobel laureate William Nordhaus, by another eco-pragmatist, his nephew Ted: RIP Uncle Bill open.substack.com/pub/thebreakthroughjournal/p/the-origin…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The bright side of Silicon Valley: Not the NeoReactionaries, Tech Feudalists, or Trump keister-kissers, but the idealistic workaholics who believe problems are solvable. From The Rational Optimist feed: The black box virus detector America needs rationaloptimistsociety.substack.com/p/introducing-the-fi…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
“The West,” currently trumpeted by authoritarian populists, is a meaningless (and often pernicious) catch-phrase, shows @dgardner). dgardner.substack.com/p/the-west-a-brief-history?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Gary Marcus meets the Pope! garymarcus.substack.com/p/report-from-the-vatican?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I will be lecturing, debating, and conversing with the audience in San Francisco on January 30th.
More information and tickets at www.pang-burn.com/tickets -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Amid the Doom and Gloom, a Quiet Revolution in Human Health edgyoptimist.substack.com/p/amid-the-doom-and-gloom-a-qui…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Dan Williams @danwilliamsphil on Why AI (Probably) Won’t Kill Us open.substack.com/pub/yaschamounk/p/dan-williams-3?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New interview for Thinkable, with Iona Italia: Steven Pinker on What Happens When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows ... thinkablereview.substack.com/p/steven-pinker-on-what-happ…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Gary Marcus meets the Pope! garymarcus.substack.com/p/report-from-the-vatican?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Iona Italia, PhD 🏴
@IonaItalia
I interviewed @sapinker again. It's my third time talking to him in an official capacity and each time, it's been inspiring and fun in new ways. He's one of the all-time best podcast guests. Highly recommended! The full video is public here:
thinkablereview.substack.com/p/steven-pinker-on-what-happ… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Scientists & science journalists decry the public's rejection of science, but are oblivious to the major cause: the perception, sometimes correct, that scientists are just another political faction. Among the guiltiest perpetrators are the recent editors of Scientific American, who turned this once-beloved treasure into a left-wing propaganda rag. This absolutely does not justify the Trump administration's unconstitutional meddling, but the new owners are right to restore it to its mission of explaining science to Americans. The Nation reports on The Fall of “Scientific American” www.thenation.com/article/society/scientific-american-spr…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rebecca Goldstein's The Mattering Instinct named one of the Best Books of 2026 by Publishers Weekly. best-books.publishersweekly.com/pw/best-books/2026/nonfic…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Goldstein, a philosopher and novelist, elegantly moves between philosophy and reportage for this revelatory consideration of how the desire to matter shapes both inner life and social values. In the process, she makes a moving case for the importance of honoring innate human worth in a frequently impersonal and fractured world."
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
AI could push back against public irrationality like conspiracy theories, fake news, & medical quackery. Whereas social media optimize for sheer engagement (clicks, likes, & reposts), AI is sold as a useful product that aids decision-making in the real world. For all the problems of LLMs, they're less likely to send users down a conspiratorial rabbit hole. This may restore the influence of epistemically responsible expertise. So argues the philosopher Dan Williams @danwilliamsphil open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/ai-can-save-the-publi…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
“The West,” currently trumpeted by authoritarian populists, is a meaningless (and often pernicious) catch-phrase, shows @dgardner). dgardner.substack.com/p/the-west-a-brief-history?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New interview for Thinkable, with Iona Italia: Steven Pinker on What Happens When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows ... thinkablereview.substack.com/p/steven-pinker-on-what-happ…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Gary Marcus meets the Pope! garymarcus.substack.com/p/report-from-the-vatican?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
“The West,” currently trumpeted by authoritarian populists, is a meaningless (and often pernicious) catch-phrase, shows @dgardner). dgardner.substack.com/p/the-west-a-brief-history?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Dan Williams @danwilliamsphil on Why AI (Probably) Won’t Kill Us open.substack.com/pub/yaschamounk/p/dan-williams-3?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Amid the Doom and Gloom, a Quiet Revolution in Human Health edgyoptimist.substack.com/p/amid-the-doom-and-gloom-a-qui…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Nico Perrino
@NicoPerrino
Next week, about 550 free speech advocates and thought leaders will descend on Philadelphia for @TheFIREorg's first-ever Soapbox conference.
Believe it or not, in FIRE's 27-year history, we've never hosted a general-audience free speech conference. We've hosted student and faculty conferences, but nothing like this. We figured the 250th anniversary of American independence was as fitting a time as any to give it a try.
We had no idea what to expect. Would anyone buy tickets? Conference experts told us most tickets are sold in the weeks leading up to an event. Instead, we sold out two months in advance!
America's free speech movement is growing, and its members are eager to meet one another.
I'll deliver the opening keynote, "The Fight for Free Speech," a nod to the title of the ACLU's first annual report in 1921. The talk will summarize the story I tell in my forthcoming book: how civil libertarians fought to make the promise of the First Amendment a reality.
Other speakers include @nickgillespie, @LarryLessig, @prestonjbyrne, @ENBrown, @CaseyMattox_, @chrisbest, @RosenJeffrey, @FreeRangeKids, @sapinker, @Musa_alGharbi, @marcorandazza, @AdamThierer, @DavidAFrench, @whignewtons, the @wethefifth guys, @ishapiro, @noam_dworman, @JohnHMcWhorter, @mtaibbi, and many, many more.
I can't wait to see you all next week. And if you can't make it, I hope to see you at the next one. Just be sure to get your tickets early!
soapbox.fire.org/soapbox/11013385 -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I joined the APA as a postdoc, and resigned a few years ago. This article explains why: The Inmates Run the Asylum at the Psychological Association by @SwipeWright and @Hartz_PhD www.wsj.com/opinion/the-inmates-run-the-asylum-at-the-psy… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker reposted
StarkWare
@StarkWareLtd
Blocksmart is back with a new episode featuring bestselling author and public intellectual @sapinker.
How does common knowledge shape society, money, and blockchains? And what can AI teach us about the human brain?
We dive into it all in the second episode of Blocksmart 👇
0:00 - Intro: Steve Pinker
0:49 - Common knowledge
5:57 - Blockchain & social consensus
9:40 - Blockchain’s social innovations
12:27 - Making blockchain common knowledge
15:13 - Making science popular
21:46 - AI, LLMs & the human brain
28:25 - Quick-fire
31:25 - Parting thoughtsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
Over 400 people have registered for our Defend the West conference!
WHEN: 1/13/2027
WHERE: Online (free)
Speakers include:
@DavidDFriedman
@sapinker
@SRCHicks
@yaronbrook
@alananewhouse
@johanknorberg
@DeirdreMcClosk
@michaelshermer
@ToKTeacher
@jasoncrawford
Nadine Strossen
Save your spot (link below)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
5 Days of Pro-Democracy Triumphs theprogressnetwork.substack.com/p/5-days-of-pro-democracy…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
5 Days of Pro-Democracy Triumphs theprogressnetwork.substack.com/p/5-days-of-pro-democracy…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rebecca Goldstein's The Mattering Instinct named one of the Best Books of 2026 by Publishers Weekly. best-books.publishersweekly.com/pw/best-books/2026/nonfic…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
AI could push back against public irrationality like conspiracy theories, fake news, & medical quackery. Whereas social media optimize for sheer engagement (clicks, likes, & reposts), AI is sold as a useful product that aids decision-making in the real world. For all the problems of LLMs, they're less likely to send users down a conspiratorial rabbit hole. This may restore the influence of epistemically responsible expertise. So argues the philosopher Dan Williams @danwilliamsphil open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/ai-can-save-the-publi…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Evolution does not need a rebuild, and The Selfish Gene is not outmoded. It remains...a page-turner." Nathaniel Comfort's misguided take on The Selfish Gene at 50 whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/10/27/nathaniel-comforts-wonk…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I will be lecturing, debating, and conversing with the audience in San Francisco on January 30th.
More information and tickets at www.pang-burn.com/tickets -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Spirit of Democracy Remains Strong open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/the-spirit-of-democra…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Evolution does not need a rebuild, and The Selfish Gene is not outmoded. It remains...a page-turner." Nathaniel Comfort's misguided take on The Selfish Gene at 50 whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/10/27/nathaniel-comforts-wonk…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
AI could push back against public irrationality like conspiracy theories, fake news, & medical quackery. Whereas social media optimize for sheer engagement (clicks, likes, & reposts), AI is sold as a useful product that aids decision-making in the real world. For all the problems of LLMs, they're less likely to send users down a conspiratorial rabbit hole. This may restore the influence of epistemically responsible expertise. So argues the philosopher Dan Williams @danwilliamsphil open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/ai-can-save-the-publi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Evolution does not need a rebuild, and The Selfish Gene is not outmoded. It remains...a page-turner." Nathaniel Comfort's misguided take on The Selfish Gene at 50 whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/10/27/nathaniel-comforts-wonk…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Spirit of Democracy Remains Strong open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/the-spirit-of-democra…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
-
Steven Pinker reposted
-
Steven Pinker reposted
-
Steven Pinker reposted
The New Statesman
@NewStatesman
"It's a smokescreen" - this is how Steven Pinker sees AI founders' existential threats.
" They've been much less willing to face up to the responsibility of let's make sure that this doesn't result in bioterrorism..."
Listen to The New Society wherever you get your podcasts.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
David Eagleman
@davideagleman
Why do police states squelch protests, and what does this have to do with common knowledge? Find out this and much more in this week's episode with Steven Pinker (@sapinker), wherever you get your podcasts.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Explainer: unu.edu/ehs/article/what-high-seas-treaty-and-why-it-impo…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I joined the APA as a postdoc, and resigned a few years ago. This article explains why: The Inmates Run the Asylum at the Psychological Association by @SwipeWright and @Hartz_PhD www.wsj.com/opinion/the-inmates-run-the-asylum-at-the-psy… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Over the years Jerry Coyne has documented the deterioration of the magazine, such as here: whyevolutionistrue.com/2025/08/20/scientific-american-rev…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Scientists & science journalists decry the public's rejection of science, but are oblivious to the major cause: the perception, sometimes correct, that scientists are just another political faction. Among the guiltiest perpetrators are the recent editors of Scientific American, who turned this once-beloved treasure into a left-wing propaganda rag. This absolutely does not justify the Trump administration's unconstitutional meddling, but the new owners are right to restore it to its mission of explaining science to Americans. The Nation reports on The Fall of “Scientific American” www.thenation.com/article/society/scientific-american-spr…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Review here: www.publishersweekly.com/978-1-324-09685-6
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I Wouldn’t Hurt A Fly, explains Rebecca Newberger Goldstein (with an analysis of the concept of human dignity). @platobooktour rebeccanewbergergoldstein.substack.com/p/i-wouldnt-hurt-a…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Goldstein, a philosopher and novelist, elegantly moves between philosophy and reportage for this revelatory consideration of how the desire to matter shapes both inner life and social values. In the process, she makes a moving case for the importance of honoring innate human worth in a frequently impersonal and fractured world."
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rebecca Goldstein's The Mattering Instinct named one of the Best Books of 2026 by Publishers Weekly. best-books.publishersweekly.com/pw/best-books/2026/nonfic…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rebecca Goldstein's The Mattering Instinct named one of the Best Books of 2026 by Publishers Weekly. best-books.publishersweekly.com/pw/best-books/2026/nonfic…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Goldstein, a philosopher and novelist, elegantly moves between philosophy and reportage for this revelatory consideration of how the desire to matter shapes both inner life and social values. In the process, she makes a moving case for the importance of honoring innate human worth in a frequently impersonal and fractured world."
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Review here: www.publishersweekly.com/978-1-324-09685-6
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I Wouldn’t Hurt A Fly, explains Rebecca Newberger Goldstein (with an analysis of the concept of human dignity). @platobooktour rebeccanewbergergoldstein.substack.com/p/i-wouldnt-hurt-a…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Scientists & science journalists decry the public's rejection of science, but are oblivious to the major cause: the perception, sometimes correct, that scientists are just another political faction. Among the guiltiest perpetrators are the recent editors of Scientific American, who turned this once-beloved treasure into a left-wing propaganda rag. This absolutely does not justify the Trump administration's unconstitutional meddling, but the new owners are right to restore it to its mission of explaining science to Americans. The Nation reports on The Fall of “Scientific American” www.thenation.com/article/society/scientific-american-spr…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Over the years Jerry Coyne has documented the deterioration of the magazine, such as here: whyevolutionistrue.com/2025/08/20/scientific-american-rev…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I joined the APA as a postdoc, and resigned a few years ago. This article explains why: The Inmates Run the Asylum at the Psychological Association by @SwipeWright and @Hartz_PhD www.wsj.com/opinion/the-inmates-run-the-asylum-at-the-psy… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
David Deutsch (@DavidDeutschOxf) and I discuss AGIs and subjectivity on the Joe Walker Podcast (@JosephNWalker):
David Deutsch:
I think it’s inevitable that AGIs will be capable of having internal subjectivity and qualia, because that’s all included in the letter G in the middle of the name of the technology.
Me:
Well, not necessarily, because the G could be general computational power, the ability to solve problems, and there could be no one at all who’s actually human.
David Deutsch:
But there ain’t nothing here but computation. It’s not like in Star Trek: Data lacks the emotion chip, and it has to be plugged in. But there’s nothing possibly in that chip apart from more circuitry like he’s already got.
Me:
But, of course, the episode that you’re referring to is one in which the question arose: Is it moral to reverse engineer Data by dismantling him, therefore stopping the computation? Is that disassembling a machine, or is it snuffing out a consciousness? Because there is an alternative view that subjectivity depends also on whatever biochemical substrate our particular computation runs on. And I think there’s no way of ever knowing.
David Deutsch:
I think we can answer that question before we ever do any experiments, even today, because there’s no difference in principle between a computer that runs partly by electricity and partly by chemicals and one that runs entirely on silicon chips. Because the latter can simulate the former with arbitrary accuracy.
Me:
Well, we don’t have to solve the problem this afternoon in our conversation, but, in fact, I think it is not solvable. But the simulation doesn’t necessarily mean that it has subjectivity. It could just mean it’s a simulation; that is, it’s going through all the motions. It might even do it better than we do, but, you know, there’s no one home. There’s no one actually being hurt.
David Deutsch:
Well, you can be a dualist. You can say that there is mind in addition to all the physical stuff. But if you want to be a physicalist, then there’s this thought experiment where you remove one neuron at a time and replace it with a silicon chip, and you wouldn’t notice.
Me:
Well, that’s the question. An external observer wouldn’t notice. How do we know that, from the point of view of the brain being replaced—every neuron by a chip—it’s like falling asleep? That when it’s done and every last neuron is replaced by a chip, you’re dead, subjectively, even though your body is still making noise?
David Deutsch:
That means that when your subjectivity is—there is something happening in addition to the computation. And that’s dualism.
Me:
I mean, again, I don’t have an opinion one way or another, which is exactly my point. I don’t think it’s a decidable problem. But it could be that that extra something is not ghostly substance. It could be that the stuff that the brain is made of is responsible for that extra ingredient of subjective experience, as opposed to intelligent behavior. I think we’re going to be having the same debate a hundred years from now.
David Deutsch:
Yeah, maybe one of the AGIs will be participating in the debate by then.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Full link to "Steven Pinker on AI doom and Consciousness":
www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLJ7UL5CzvY&t=1s -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Earth* to Musk:
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Have we already discovered everything? Emma Varvaloucas is in a position to explain that we haven’t. theprogressnetwork.substack.com/p/think-weve-discovered-e…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rumors of the death of global cooperation are greatly exaggerated. At Starmus, Jane Lubchenco explained how this year the High Seas Treaty protecting the world’s oceans went into effect. Even the US signed (though it has not yet ratified it).
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Explainer: unu.edu/ehs/article/what-high-seas-treaty-and-why-it-impo…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rubio’s Grotesque Defense of Western Civ by @CathyYoung63 open.substack.com/pub/theunpopulist/p/rubios-grotesque-de…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
PANGBURN'S SYMPOSIUM I
PHILOSOPHY • SCIENCE • RELIGION • POLITICS
January 30–31, 2027 | San Francisco, California
In the spirit of ancient Athens, where the greatest minds gathered to question the gods, challenge the powerful, and pursue the nature of truth, a new symposium rises.
Four disciplines. Four extraordinary minds. Two days. One relentless pursuit of truth.
From the marble halls of ancient Greece to the intellectual battlegrounds of the modern world, humanity has been driven by questions that refuse to die.
What is truth? What can we know? What should we believe? How ought we live? Who should govern, and by what right?
For two extraordinary days in San Francisco, Pangburn's Symposium I resurrects the ancient tradition of intellectual confrontation, bringing together some of today's most provocative and influential thinkers to examine the foundations of human understanding.
THE FOUR PILLARS OF THE SYMPOSIUM
🏛 PHILOSOPHY — Stephen Hicks
January 30 | 1 PM
General topic to be announced.
⚛ SCIENCE — Steven Pinker
January 30 | 7 PM
General topic to be announced.
⚖ RELIGION — Justin Sledge
January 31 | 1 PM
General topic to be announced.
🏺 POLITICS — Steven Bonnell II (Destiny)
January 31 | 7 PM
General topic to be announced.
NOT MERELY LECTURES. AN INTELLECTUAL ARENA.
Each of the four sessions features:
One hour of lecture: A leading thinker presents their ideas.
90 minutes of debate and discussion: Ideas are challenged, scrutinized, and defended.
90 minutes of community discussion: The audience enters the arena, engaging in the questions and arguments themselves.
This is not a gathering for those who demand agreement. It is a gathering for those courageous enough to question their own convictions.
Here, no proposition is sacred. No thinker is beyond challenge. No question is forbidden merely because it is uncomfortable.
As Socrates demonstrated more than two millennia ago, wisdom begins not with certainty, but with the willingness to examine what we think we know.
The agora awaits. The thinkers assemble. The questions endure.
Come not as a disciple, but as a philosopher.
PANGBURN'S SYMPOSIUM I
January 30–31, 2027
First Unitarian Church
1187 Franklin Street, San Francisco -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Pangburn's Symposium I - San Francisco - General Pass | Pangburn www.pang-burn.com/product-page/pangburns-symposium-i-san-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rubio’s Grotesque Defense of Western Civ by @CathyYoung63 open.substack.com/pub/theunpopulist/p/rubios-grotesque-de…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Lucid article by Seth, Block, & Tononi: Three reasons why AI is not conscious and perhaps never will be www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-03313-7
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Best read in conjunction with Seth's article in Behavioral and Brain Sciences, the dozens of commentaries published with it, and the author's reply: www.cambridge.org/core/journals/behavioral-and-brain-scie…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I was ashamed to realize that I did not notice at the time when one of humanity's greatest accomplishments was announced: photos of Pluto, taken from the edge of our solar system looking back. Blue Haze is up there with Earthrise and Pale Blue Dot as stunningly beautiful works of art, testimonies to human ingenuity and daring, and opportunities to reflect on our place in the cosmos.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Enjoying the Starmus (Stars + Music) conference in the Canary Islands, where I've met many astronauts, spoke about common knowledge, and took part in a panel on the search for truth with Geoff Hinton ("Godfather of AI") and Christiana Figueres (Costa Rican negotiator of the Paris Climate accords).
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Geoff & I had conversations afterwards on consciousness, AI safety, and visual imagery, and fact-checked each other's memories of our interactions over 47 years, since we were both postdocs.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Pangburn's Symposium I - San Francisco - General Pass | Pangburn www.pang-burn.com/product-page/pangburns-symposium-i-san-…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
PANGBURN'S SYMPOSIUM I
PHILOSOPHY • SCIENCE • RELIGION • POLITICS
January 30–31, 2027 | San Francisco, California
In the spirit of ancient Athens, where the greatest minds gathered to question the gods, challenge the powerful, and pursue the nature of truth, a new symposium rises.
Four disciplines. Four extraordinary minds. Two days. One relentless pursuit of truth.
From the marble halls of ancient Greece to the intellectual battlegrounds of the modern world, humanity has been driven by questions that refuse to die.
What is truth? What can we know? What should we believe? How ought we live? Who should govern, and by what right?
For two extraordinary days in San Francisco, Pangburn's Symposium I resurrects the ancient tradition of intellectual confrontation, bringing together some of today's most provocative and influential thinkers to examine the foundations of human understanding.
THE FOUR PILLARS OF THE SYMPOSIUM
🏛 PHILOSOPHY — Stephen Hicks
January 30 | 1 PM
General topic to be announced.
⚛ SCIENCE — Steven Pinker
January 30 | 7 PM
General topic to be announced.
⚖ RELIGION — Justin Sledge
January 31 | 1 PM
General topic to be announced.
🏺 POLITICS — Steven Bonnell II (Destiny)
January 31 | 7 PM
General topic to be announced.
NOT MERELY LECTURES. AN INTELLECTUAL ARENA.
Each of the four sessions features:
One hour of lecture: A leading thinker presents their ideas.
90 minutes of debate and discussion: Ideas are challenged, scrutinized, and defended.
90 minutes of community discussion: The audience enters the arena, engaging in the questions and arguments themselves.
This is not a gathering for those who demand agreement. It is a gathering for those courageous enough to question their own convictions.
Here, no proposition is sacred. No thinker is beyond challenge. No question is forbidden merely because it is uncomfortable.
As Socrates demonstrated more than two millennia ago, wisdom begins not with certainty, but with the willingness to examine what we think we know.
The agora awaits. The thinkers assemble. The questions endure.
Come not as a disciple, but as a philosopher.
PANGBURN'S SYMPOSIUM I
January 30–31, 2027
First Unitarian Church
1187 Franklin Street, San Francisco -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Catch the full podcast here: podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/david-deutsch-steven-pinker…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
David Deutsch (@DavidDeutschOxf) and I discuss AGIs and subjectivity on the Joe Walker Podcast (@JosephNWalker):
David Deutsch:
I think it’s inevitable that AGIs will be capable of having internal subjectivity and qualia, because that’s all included in the letter G in the middle of the name of the technology.
Me:
Well, not necessarily, because the G could be general computational power, the ability to solve problems, and there could be no one at all who’s actually human.
David Deutsch:
But there ain’t nothing here but computation. It’s not like in Star Trek: Data lacks the emotion chip, and it has to be plugged in. But there’s nothing possibly in that chip apart from more circuitry like he’s already got.
Me:
But, of course, the episode that you’re referring to is one in which the question arose: Is it moral to reverse engineer Data by dismantling him, therefore stopping the computation? Is that disassembling a machine, or is it snuffing out a consciousness? Because there is an alternative view that subjectivity depends also on whatever biochemical substrate our particular computation runs on. And I think there’s no way of ever knowing.
David Deutsch:
I think we can answer that question before we ever do any experiments, even today, because there’s no difference in principle between a computer that runs partly by electricity and partly by chemicals and one that runs entirely on silicon chips. Because the latter can simulate the former with arbitrary accuracy.
Me:
Well, we don’t have to solve the problem this afternoon in our conversation, but, in fact, I think it is not solvable. But the simulation doesn’t necessarily mean that it has subjectivity. It could just mean it’s a simulation; that is, it’s going through all the motions. It might even do it better than we do, but, you know, there’s no one home. There’s no one actually being hurt.
David Deutsch:
Well, you can be a dualist. You can say that there is mind in addition to all the physical stuff. But if you want to be a physicalist, then there’s this thought experiment where you remove one neuron at a time and replace it with a silicon chip, and you wouldn’t notice.
Me:
Well, that’s the question. An external observer wouldn’t notice. How do we know that, from the point of view of the brain being replaced—every neuron by a chip—it’s like falling asleep? That when it’s done and every last neuron is replaced by a chip, you’re dead, subjectively, even though your body is still making noise?
David Deutsch:
That means that when your subjectivity is—there is something happening in addition to the computation. And that’s dualism.
Me:
I mean, again, I don’t have an opinion one way or another, which is exactly my point. I don’t think it’s a decidable problem. But it could be that that extra something is not ghostly substance. It could be that the stuff that the brain is made of is responsible for that extra ingredient of subjective experience, as opposed to intelligent behavior. I think we’re going to be having the same debate a hundred years from now.
David Deutsch:
Yeah, maybe one of the AGIs will be participating in the debate by then.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
With Philip Torr (@philiptorr) at Starmus VIII.
starmus.com/starmus-viii-speakers/ -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Culture War We Need: Constructive, improvement and reality-based appreciation of progress vs. self-pity and grievance, by @RichardHanania open.substack.com/pub/richardhanania/p/the-culture-war-we…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Culture War We Need: Constructive, improvement and reality-based appreciation of progress vs. self-pity and grievance, by @RichardHanania open.substack.com/pub/richardhanania/p/the-culture-war-we…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Catch the full podcast here: podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/david-deutsch-steven-pinker…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I t Looked Like a New Species. The Trouble Was, It Didn’t Exist. First article by my nephew @ericboodman in his new role of national science correspondent for NYT. www.nytimes.com/2026/10/16/science/citizen-science-ai-slo…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Henry Shevlin (@dioscuri), Dan Williams (@danwilliamsphil), and I discuss AI and "superintelligence."
You get all of these maladaptive outcomes—all this cruelty and waste and competition and aggression—precisely because there was no designer who wanted to minimize any of these things. Natural selection did its thing.
If AI were simply allowed to evolve without any kind of human intervention, then that would be a risk. But in the case of AI, there is intelligent design. I mean, us. These are gadgets. I think it’s illicit to anthropomorphize AI as being like human beings, which are products of natural selection, when AIs are not products of natural selection. They’re products of intelligent design.
And so the engineers can think, “Well, these are the goals that we want to optimize. These are the kinds of side effects that we want to minimize. These are the kinds of things that we wouldn’t in a million years allow it to do.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
With Philip Torr (@philiptorr) at Starmus VIII.
starmus.com/starmus-viii-speakers/ -
Steven Pinker reposted
philip
@philiptorr
Getting to hang out with two of my academic heroes at Starmus: @geoffreyhinton Geoff Hinton, Godfather of AI and also AI safety, who inspired me to get into neural networks, and @sapinker Steven Pinker the evolutionary psychologist.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From my interview with The New Society @NewStatesman:
Headlines are a bit of a misleading way to understand history because, you know, bad things happen, but bad things happened 50 years ago, too, and we tend to forget them. When you actually plot things like poverty, war, homicide, and literacy, most of these are way better now than they used to be. How did that happen? And there are a number of hypotheses that I float as to why cooperation and human flourishing in general have increased.
One of them is an expanding circle of empathy, another concept from Singer: as we rub shoulders, as we exchange stories with people who are unlike ourselves, we come to realize that we're not special just because we're us and they're them. You're bound to understand people when you kind of see the world from their perspective.
But another could be—and this, again, Singer suggested—that sheer raw reason can make us more moral, more cosmopolitan, more universal, as we realize that there's nothing special about me just because I'm me. There's something that is inherently disinterested and universal about reason. And, of course, I care about me more than I care about other people, but I can't convince you that that is a moral imperative—that you have to care about me more than you because I'm me and you're not.
And so, just that symmetry kind of pushes toward a kind of more ethical code: a golden rule, a categorical imperative, or the veil of ignorance, where simply discounting your own proprietary interest in yourself steers you toward a defensible morality.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Feature by Sanjeev Kumar on common knowledge www.linkedin.com/mwlite/feed/update/urn:li:activity:75178…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Yes, many critical-social-justice dogmas can't withstand intellectual scrutiny, so their proponents try to protect them via intimidation and walling off the university commons. Civil discourse and viewpoint diversity are threats to this tactic.
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
This new "report" is an embarrassing example of politicized argumentation plus scholarly ineptitude. It reflects that the movement to increase civil discourse & viewpoint diversity is rapidly advancing, which worries these authors. This is the best they could do to fight it.
Inside Higher Ed
@insidehighered
Group Argues Civil Discourse Push Is Conservative, Pro-Israel
A group of scholars has released another report arguing that efforts to promote constructive dialogue and similar concepts are actually targeting progressive activism. www.insidehighered.com/news/students/free-speech/2026/10/… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Life in The Grim Old Days quillette.substack.com/p/life-in-the-grim-old-days?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Interview with the philosophers Dan Williams and Henry Shevlin on AI Doom, Consciousness, and whether the human brain is a LLM. open.substack.com/pub/conspicuouscognition/p/steven-pinke…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I t Looked Like a New Species. The Trouble Was, It Didn’t Exist. First article by my nephew @ericboodman in his new role of national science correspondent for NYT. www.nytimes.com/2026/10/16/science/citizen-science-ai-slo…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Martin Seligman's 1970 paper on the generality of the laws of learning was the first academic paper in psychology I ever read (just 2 years after it came out), and I've followed his ideas with interest and edification ever since. More than 50 years later, here he is in conversation with my former student @AdamOmaryPhD and @johanknorberg (author of an excellent book on progress), exploring the role of human agency in historical progress. open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/agency-an…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Henry Shevlin (@dioscuri), Dan Williams (@danwilliamsphil), and I discuss AI and "superintelligence."
You get all of these maladaptive outcomes—all this cruelty and waste and competition and aggression—precisely because there was no designer who wanted to minimize any of these things. Natural selection did its thing.
If AI were simply allowed to evolve without any kind of human intervention, then that would be a risk. But in the case of AI, there is intelligent design. I mean, us. These are gadgets. I think it’s illicit to anthropomorphize AI as being like human beings, which are products of natural selection, when AIs are not products of natural selection. They’re products of intelligent design.
And so the engineers can think, “Well, these are the goals that we want to optimize. These are the kinds of side effects that we want to minimize. These are the kinds of things that we wouldn’t in a million years allow it to do.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Full link to "Steven Pinker on AI doom and Consciousness":
www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLJ7UL5CzvY&t=1s -
Steven Pinker reposted
The New Statesman
@NewStatesman
Believe it or not, humanity is improving.
Steven Pinker, cognitive psychologist, joins us on The New Society to discuss why - despite the headlines - he thinks this may be.
Listen wherever you get your podcasts.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Perfectly said @sapinker
I made a similar point in one of my SciAm columns, "Alvy's Error": Woody Allen's character in Annie Hall, Alvy Singer, in a flashback to childhood refuses to do his homework because he found out the universe is expanding. His exasperated mother upbraids the youth, “What has the universe got to do with it?! You’re here in Brooklyn. Brooklyn is not expanding!”
Call it Alvy’s Error: assessing the purpose of something at the wrong level of analysis. The level at which we should assess our actions is the human time scale of days, weeks, months, and years—our four-score ± 10 lifespan—not the billions of years of the cosmic calendar.
William Lane Craig made this error in arguing that if this worldview is correct then godless Nazi murderers got away with torturing Jews. Shelly Kagan nailed him in their debate:
“This strikes me as an outrageous thing to suggest. It doesn’t really matter? Surely it matters to the torture victims whether they’re being tortured. It doesn’t require that this make some cosmic difference to the eternal significance of the universe for it to matter whether a human being is tortured. It matters to them, it matters to their family, and it matters to us.”
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The fact that the universe doesn’t care about you doesn’t mean that other humans don’t care about you, or that we don’t have to care about other humans. That is, there is a purpose, there is a meaning: that is, to make people as well off as possible, to increase flourishing, to increase knowledge and life and health and freedom and safety. These are really, really meaningful. At least, I think they are. I don’t see anything wrong with them. I don’t think that that should leave you empty. And the fact that we live in a cold universe—that is, the laws of physics, the laws of biology, the behavior of viruses and bacteria and parasites and fungi—they don’t care about you. I’m sorry, they don’t care about you. And the sooner you realize that, the more you’ll be able to attend to the things that really do matter.
@HumanProgress -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
David Deutsch (@DavidDeutschOxf) and I discuss AGIs and subjectivity on the Joe Walker Podcast (@JosephNWalker):
David Deutsch:
I think it’s inevitable that AGIs will be capable of having internal subjectivity and qualia, because that’s all included in the letter G in the middle of the name of the technology.
Me:
Well, not necessarily, because the G could be general computational power, the ability to solve problems, and there could be no one at all who’s actually human.
David Deutsch:
But there ain’t nothing here but computation. It’s not like in Star Trek: Data lacks the emotion chip, and it has to be plugged in. But there’s nothing possibly in that chip apart from more circuitry like he’s already got.
Me:
But, of course, the episode that you’re referring to is one in which the question arose: Is it moral to reverse engineer Data by dismantling him, therefore stopping the computation? Is that disassembling a machine, or is it snuffing out a consciousness? Because there is an alternative view that subjectivity depends also on whatever biochemical substrate our particular computation runs on. And I think there’s no way of ever knowing.
David Deutsch:
I think we can answer that question before we ever do any experiments, even today, because there’s no difference in principle between a computer that runs partly by electricity and partly by chemicals and one that runs entirely on silicon chips. Because the latter can simulate the former with arbitrary accuracy.
Me:
Well, we don’t have to solve the problem this afternoon in our conversation, but, in fact, I think it is not solvable. But the simulation doesn’t necessarily mean that it has subjectivity. It could just mean it’s a simulation; that is, it’s going through all the motions. It might even do it better than we do, but, you know, there’s no one home. There’s no one actually being hurt.
David Deutsch:
Well, you can be a dualist. You can say that there is mind in addition to all the physical stuff. But if you want to be a physicalist, then there’s this thought experiment where you remove one neuron at a time and replace it with a silicon chip, and you wouldn’t notice.
Me:
Well, that’s the question. An external observer wouldn’t notice. How do we know that, from the point of view of the brain being replaced—every neuron by a chip—it’s like falling asleep? That when it’s done and every last neuron is replaced by a chip, you’re dead, subjectively, even though your body is still making noise?
David Deutsch:
That means that when your subjectivity is—there is something happening in addition to the computation. And that’s dualism.
Me:
I mean, again, I don’t have an opinion one way or another, which is exactly my point. I don’t think it’s a decidable problem. But it could be that that extra something is not ghostly substance. It could be that the stuff that the brain is made of is responsible for that extra ingredient of subjective experience, as opposed to intelligent behavior. I think we’re going to be having the same debate a hundred years from now.
David Deutsch:
Yeah, maybe one of the AGIs will be participating in the debate by then.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Angry Optimist: Another feed of
Positive, significant, and underreported news. open.substack.com/pub/theangryoptimistpublication/p/premi… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Full interview by @HumanProgress: humanprogress.org/meaning-and-morality-in-the-modern-age/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The fact that the universe doesn’t care about you doesn’t mean that other humans don’t care about you, or that we don’t have to care about other humans. That is, there is a purpose, there is a meaning: that is, to make people as well off as possible, to increase flourishing, to increase knowledge and life and health and freedom and safety. These are really, really meaningful. At least, I think they are. I don’t see anything wrong with them. I don’t think that that should leave you empty. And the fact that we live in a cold universe—that is, the laws of physics, the laws of biology, the behavior of viruses and bacteria and parasites and fungi—they don’t care about you. I’m sorry, they don’t care about you. And the sooner you realize that, the more you’ll be able to attend to the things that really do matter.
@HumanProgress -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Angry Optimist: Another feed of
Positive, significant, and underreported news. open.substack.com/pub/theangryoptimistpublication/p/premi… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Our Longing to Matter Drives and Divides Us | Amanpour and Company youtu.be/LTkNwAFtb9w via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The fact that the universe doesn’t care about you doesn’t mean that other humans don’t care about you, or that we don’t have to care about other humans. That is, there is a purpose, there is a meaning: that is, to make people as well off as possible, to increase flourishing, to increase knowledge and life and health and freedom and safety. These are really, really meaningful. At least, I think they are. I don’t see anything wrong with them. I don’t think that that should leave you empty. And the fact that we live in a cold universe—that is, the laws of physics, the laws of biology, the behavior of viruses and bacteria and parasites and fungi—they don’t care about you. I’m sorry, they don’t care about you. And the sooner you realize that, the more you’ll be able to attend to the things that really do matter.
@HumanProgress -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My former MIT colleague Yossi Sheffi has documented how unhinged hatred of Israel, combined with the unwillingness of modern universities to state and enforce principles, led to a hostile climate for Jews at MIT (only starting to be addressed by the administration). | Professor Yossi Sheffi sheffi.mit.edu/book/unsafe-mit-0
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Three Accusations against Israel: Apartheid, Settler Colonialism, and Genocide. Are they historically accurate, or just morally loaded vilifications? New paper scrutinizes the Legal and Historical issues. @SSRN papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7501120
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On AI and "superintelligence":
"The power will increase, but there's no point at which it's meaningful to say, 'Well, yesterday we didn't have superintelligence. Today we do have superintelligence.'
That's why I think it's meaningless to say, 'What will happen if one day we have superintelligence?' I don't even understand the question. It's: 'Will technology improve?' Almost certainly.
It will get better. It'll never be omniscient. It'll never be omnipotent. That's out of comic books out of religion. There are laws of physics. There are limits on information. There's no system that could learn the position and velocity of every particle in the universe. So as long as that is true, there's not going to be an AI system that can do anything or can know everything. But they will get—obviously, like any technology—they'll get more powerful."
Full interview: www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWC47agaKpkThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From my interview with The New Society @NewStatesman:
Headlines are a bit of a misleading way to understand history because, you know, bad things happen, but bad things happened 50 years ago, too, and we tend to forget them. When you actually plot things like poverty, war, homicide, and literacy, most of these are way better now than they used to be. How did that happen? And there are a number of hypotheses that I float as to why cooperation and human flourishing in general have increased.
One of them is an expanding circle of empathy, another concept from Singer: as we rub shoulders, as we exchange stories with people who are unlike ourselves, we come to realize that we're not special just because we're us and they're them. You're bound to understand people when you kind of see the world from their perspective.
But another could be—and this, again, Singer suggested—that sheer raw reason can make us more moral, more cosmopolitan, more universal, as we realize that there's nothing special about me just because I'm me. There's something that is inherently disinterested and universal about reason. And, of course, I care about me more than I care about other people, but I can't convince you that that is a moral imperative—that you have to care about me more than you because I'm me and you're not.
And so, just that symmetry kind of pushes toward a kind of more ethical code: a golden rule, a categorical imperative, or the veil of ignorance, where simply discounting your own proprietary interest in yourself steers you toward a defensible morality.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
David Deutsch (@DavidDeutschOxf) and I discuss AGIs and subjectivity on the Joe Walker Podcast (@JosephNWalker):
David Deutsch:
I think it’s inevitable that AGIs will be capable of having internal subjectivity and qualia, because that’s all included in the letter G in the middle of the name of the technology.
Me:
Well, not necessarily, because the G could be general computational power, the ability to solve problems, and there could be no one at all who’s actually human.
David Deutsch:
But there ain’t nothing here but computation. It’s not like in Star Trek: Data lacks the emotion chip, and it has to be plugged in. But there’s nothing possibly in that chip apart from more circuitry like he’s already got.
Me:
But, of course, the episode that you’re referring to is one in which the question arose: Is it moral to reverse engineer Data by dismantling him, therefore stopping the computation? Is that disassembling a machine, or is it snuffing out a consciousness? Because there is an alternative view that subjectivity depends also on whatever biochemical substrate our particular computation runs on. And I think there’s no way of ever knowing.
David Deutsch:
I think we can answer that question before we ever do any experiments, even today, because there’s no difference in principle between a computer that runs partly by electricity and partly by chemicals and one that runs entirely on silicon chips. Because the latter can simulate the former with arbitrary accuracy.
Me:
Well, we don’t have to solve the problem this afternoon in our conversation, but, in fact, I think it is not solvable. But the simulation doesn’t necessarily mean that it has subjectivity. It could just mean it’s a simulation; that is, it’s going through all the motions. It might even do it better than we do, but, you know, there’s no one home. There’s no one actually being hurt.
David Deutsch:
Well, you can be a dualist. You can say that there is mind in addition to all the physical stuff. But if you want to be a physicalist, then there’s this thought experiment where you remove one neuron at a time and replace it with a silicon chip, and you wouldn’t notice.
Me:
Well, that’s the question. An external observer wouldn’t notice. How do we know that, from the point of view of the brain being replaced—every neuron by a chip—it’s like falling asleep? That when it’s done and every last neuron is replaced by a chip, you’re dead, subjectively, even though your body is still making noise?
David Deutsch:
That means that when your subjectivity is—there is something happening in addition to the computation. And that’s dualism.
Me:
I mean, again, I don’t have an opinion one way or another, which is exactly my point. I don’t think it’s a decidable problem. But it could be that that extra something is not ghostly substance. It could be that the stuff that the brain is made of is responsible for that extra ingredient of subjective experience, as opposed to intelligent behavior. I think we’re going to be having the same debate a hundred years from now.
David Deutsch:
Yeah, maybe one of the AGIs will be participating in the debate by then.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I t Looked Like a New Species. The Trouble Was, It Didn’t Exist. First article by my nephew @ericboodman in his new role of national science correspondent for NYT. www.nytimes.com/2026/10/16/science/citizen-science-ai-slo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I t Looked Like a New Species. The Trouble Was, It Didn’t Exist. First article by my nephew @ericboodman in his new role of national science correspondent for NYT. www.nytimes.com/2026/10/16/science/citizen-science-ai-slo…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Martin Seligman's 1970 paper on the generality of the laws of learning was the first academic paper in psychology I ever read (just 2 years after it came out), and I've followed his ideas with interest and edification ever since. More than 50 years later, here he is in conversation with my former student @AdamOmaryPhD and @johanknorberg (author of an excellent book on progress), exploring the role of human agency in historical progress. open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/agency-an…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From my interview with The New Society @NewStatesman:
Headlines are a bit of a misleading way to understand history because, you know, bad things happen, but bad things happened 50 years ago, too, and we tend to forget them. When you actually plot things like poverty, war, homicide, and literacy, most of these are way better now than they used to be. How did that happen? And there are a number of hypotheses that I float as to why cooperation and human flourishing in general have increased.
One of them is an expanding circle of empathy, another concept from Singer: as we rub shoulders, as we exchange stories with people who are unlike ourselves, we come to realize that we're not special just because we're us and they're them. You're bound to understand people when you kind of see the world from their perspective.
But another could be—and this, again, Singer suggested—that sheer raw reason can make us more moral, more cosmopolitan, more universal, as we realize that there's nothing special about me just because I'm me. There's something that is inherently disinterested and universal about reason. And, of course, I care about me more than I care about other people, but I can't convince you that that is a moral imperative—that you have to care about me more than you because I'm me and you're not.
And so, just that symmetry kind of pushes toward a kind of more ethical code: a golden rule, a categorical imperative, or the veil of ignorance, where simply discounting your own proprietary interest in yourself steers you toward a defensible morality.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Catch the full podcast here: podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/david-deutsch-steven-pinker…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
David Deutsch (@DavidDeutschOxf) and I discuss AGIs and subjectivity on the Joe Walker Podcast (@JosephNWalker):
David Deutsch:
I think it’s inevitable that AGIs will be capable of having internal subjectivity and qualia, because that’s all included in the letter G in the middle of the name of the technology.
Me:
Well, not necessarily, because the G could be general computational power, the ability to solve problems, and there could be no one at all who’s actually human.
David Deutsch:
But there ain’t nothing here but computation. It’s not like in Star Trek: Data lacks the emotion chip, and it has to be plugged in. But there’s nothing possibly in that chip apart from more circuitry like he’s already got.
Me:
But, of course, the episode that you’re referring to is one in which the question arose: Is it moral to reverse engineer Data by dismantling him, therefore stopping the computation? Is that disassembling a machine, or is it snuffing out a consciousness? Because there is an alternative view that subjectivity depends also on whatever biochemical substrate our particular computation runs on. And I think there’s no way of ever knowing.
David Deutsch:
I think we can answer that question before we ever do any experiments, even today, because there’s no difference in principle between a computer that runs partly by electricity and partly by chemicals and one that runs entirely on silicon chips. Because the latter can simulate the former with arbitrary accuracy.
Me:
Well, we don’t have to solve the problem this afternoon in our conversation, but, in fact, I think it is not solvable. But the simulation doesn’t necessarily mean that it has subjectivity. It could just mean it’s a simulation; that is, it’s going through all the motions. It might even do it better than we do, but, you know, there’s no one home. There’s no one actually being hurt.
David Deutsch:
Well, you can be a dualist. You can say that there is mind in addition to all the physical stuff. But if you want to be a physicalist, then there’s this thought experiment where you remove one neuron at a time and replace it with a silicon chip, and you wouldn’t notice.
Me:
Well, that’s the question. An external observer wouldn’t notice. How do we know that, from the point of view of the brain being replaced—every neuron by a chip—it’s like falling asleep? That when it’s done and every last neuron is replaced by a chip, you’re dead, subjectively, even though your body is still making noise?
David Deutsch:
That means that when your subjectivity is—there is something happening in addition to the computation. And that’s dualism.
Me:
I mean, again, I don’t have an opinion one way or another, which is exactly my point. I don’t think it’s a decidable problem. But it could be that that extra something is not ghostly substance. It could be that the stuff that the brain is made of is responsible for that extra ingredient of subjective experience, as opposed to intelligent behavior. I think we’re going to be having the same debate a hundred years from now.
David Deutsch:
Yeah, maybe one of the AGIs will be participating in the debate by then.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Martin Seligman's 1970 paper on the generality of the laws of learning was the first academic paper in psychology I ever read (just 2 years after it came out), and I've followed his ideas with interest and edification ever since. More than 50 years later, here he is in conversation with my former student @AdamOmaryPhD and @johanknorberg (author of an excellent book on progress), exploring the role of human agency in historical progress. open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/agency-an…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From my interview with The New Society @NewStatesman:
Headlines are a bit of a misleading way to understand history because, you know, bad things happen, but bad things happened 50 years ago, too, and we tend to forget them. When you actually plot things like poverty, war, homicide, and literacy, most of these are way better now than they used to be. How did that happen? And there are a number of hypotheses that I float as to why cooperation and human flourishing in general have increased.
One of them is an expanding circle of empathy, another concept from Singer: as we rub shoulders, as we exchange stories with people who are unlike ourselves, we come to realize that we're not special just because we're us and they're them. You're bound to understand people when you kind of see the world from their perspective.
But another could be—and this, again, Singer suggested—that sheer raw reason can make us more moral, more cosmopolitan, more universal, as we realize that there's nothing special about me just because I'm me. There's something that is inherently disinterested and universal about reason. And, of course, I care about me more than I care about other people, but I can't convince you that that is a moral imperative—that you have to care about me more than you because I'm me and you're not.
And so, just that symmetry kind of pushes toward a kind of more ethical code: a golden rule, a categorical imperative, or the veil of ignorance, where simply discounting your own proprietary interest in yourself steers you toward a defensible morality.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/B0DV…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
David Deutsch (@DavidDeutschOxf) and I discuss AGIs and subjectivity on the Joe Walker Podcast (@JosephNWalker):
David Deutsch:
I think it’s inevitable that AGIs will be capable of having internal subjectivity and qualia, because that’s all included in the letter G in the middle of the name of the technology.
Me:
Well, not necessarily, because the G could be general computational power, the ability to solve problems, and there could be no one at all who’s actually human.
David Deutsch:
But there ain’t nothing here but computation. It’s not like in Star Trek: Data lacks the emotion chip, and it has to be plugged in. But there’s nothing possibly in that chip apart from more circuitry like he’s already got.
Me:
But, of course, the episode that you’re referring to is one in which the question arose: Is it moral to reverse engineer Data by dismantling him, therefore stopping the computation? Is that disassembling a machine, or is it snuffing out a consciousness? Because there is an alternative view that subjectivity depends also on whatever biochemical substrate our particular computation runs on. And I think there’s no way of ever knowing.
David Deutsch:
I think we can answer that question before we ever do any experiments, even today, because there’s no difference in principle between a computer that runs partly by electricity and partly by chemicals and one that runs entirely on silicon chips. Because the latter can simulate the former with arbitrary accuracy.
Me:
Well, we don’t have to solve the problem this afternoon in our conversation, but, in fact, I think it is not solvable. But the simulation doesn’t necessarily mean that it has subjectivity. It could just mean it’s a simulation; that is, it’s going through all the motions. It might even do it better than we do, but, you know, there’s no one home. There’s no one actually being hurt.
David Deutsch:
Well, you can be a dualist. You can say that there is mind in addition to all the physical stuff. But if you want to be a physicalist, then there’s this thought experiment where you remove one neuron at a time and replace it with a silicon chip, and you wouldn’t notice.
Me:
Well, that’s the question. An external observer wouldn’t notice. How do we know that, from the point of view of the brain being replaced—every neuron by a chip—it’s like falling asleep? That when it’s done and every last neuron is replaced by a chip, you’re dead, subjectively, even though your body is still making noise?
David Deutsch:
That means that when your subjectivity is—there is something happening in addition to the computation. And that’s dualism.
Me:
I mean, again, I don’t have an opinion one way or another, which is exactly my point. I don’t think it’s a decidable problem. But it could be that that extra something is not ghostly substance. It could be that the stuff that the brain is made of is responsible for that extra ingredient of subjective experience, as opposed to intelligent behavior. I think we’re going to be having the same debate a hundred years from now.
David Deutsch:
Yeah, maybe one of the AGIs will be participating in the debate by then.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Catch the full podcast here: podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/david-deutsch-steven-pinker…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From my interview with The New Society @NewStatesman:
Headlines are a bit of a misleading way to understand history because, you know, bad things happen, but bad things happened 50 years ago, too, and we tend to forget them. When you actually plot things like poverty, war, homicide, and literacy, most of these are way better now than they used to be. How did that happen? And there are a number of hypotheses that I float as to why cooperation and human flourishing in general have increased.
One of them is an expanding circle of empathy, another concept from Singer: as we rub shoulders, as we exchange stories with people who are unlike ourselves, we come to realize that we're not special just because we're us and they're them. You're bound to understand people when you kind of see the world from their perspective.
But another could be—and this, again, Singer suggested—that sheer raw reason can make us more moral, more cosmopolitan, more universal, as we realize that there's nothing special about me just because I'm me. There's something that is inherently disinterested and universal about reason. And, of course, I care about me more than I care about other people, but I can't convince you that that is a moral imperative—that you have to care about me more than you because I'm me and you're not.
And so, just that symmetry kind of pushes toward a kind of more ethical code: a golden rule, a categorical imperative, or the veil of ignorance, where simply discounting your own proprietary interest in yourself steers you toward a defensible morality.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Catch the full podcast here: podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/david-deutsch-steven-pinker…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
David Deutsch (@DavidDeutschOxf) and I discuss AGIs and subjectivity on the Joe Walker Podcast (@JosephNWalker):
David Deutsch:
I think it’s inevitable that AGIs will be capable of having internal subjectivity and qualia, because that’s all included in the letter G in the middle of the name of the technology.
Me:
Well, not necessarily, because the G could be general computational power, the ability to solve problems, and there could be no one at all who’s actually human.
David Deutsch:
But there ain’t nothing here but computation. It’s not like in Star Trek: Data lacks the emotion chip, and it has to be plugged in. But there’s nothing possibly in that chip apart from more circuitry like he’s already got.
Me:
But, of course, the episode that you’re referring to is one in which the question arose: Is it moral to reverse engineer Data by dismantling him, therefore stopping the computation? Is that disassembling a machine, or is it snuffing out a consciousness? Because there is an alternative view that subjectivity depends also on whatever biochemical substrate our particular computation runs on. And I think there’s no way of ever knowing.
David Deutsch:
I think we can answer that question before we ever do any experiments, even today, because there’s no difference in principle between a computer that runs partly by electricity and partly by chemicals and one that runs entirely on silicon chips. Because the latter can simulate the former with arbitrary accuracy.
Me:
Well, we don’t have to solve the problem this afternoon in our conversation, but, in fact, I think it is not solvable. But the simulation doesn’t necessarily mean that it has subjectivity. It could just mean it’s a simulation; that is, it’s going through all the motions. It might even do it better than we do, but, you know, there’s no one home. There’s no one actually being hurt.
David Deutsch:
Well, you can be a dualist. You can say that there is mind in addition to all the physical stuff. But if you want to be a physicalist, then there’s this thought experiment where you remove one neuron at a time and replace it with a silicon chip, and you wouldn’t notice.
Me:
Well, that’s the question. An external observer wouldn’t notice. How do we know that, from the point of view of the brain being replaced—every neuron by a chip—it’s like falling asleep? That when it’s done and every last neuron is replaced by a chip, you’re dead, subjectively, even though your body is still making noise?
David Deutsch:
That means that when your subjectivity is—there is something happening in addition to the computation. And that’s dualism.
Me:
I mean, again, I don’t have an opinion one way or another, which is exactly my point. I don’t think it’s a decidable problem. But it could be that that extra something is not ghostly substance. It could be that the stuff that the brain is made of is responsible for that extra ingredient of subjective experience, as opposed to intelligent behavior. I think we’re going to be having the same debate a hundred years from now.
David Deutsch:
Yeah, maybe one of the AGIs will be participating in the debate by then.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Three Accusations against Israel: Apartheid, Settler Colonialism, and Genocide. Are they historically accurate, or just morally loaded vilifications? New paper scrutinizes the Legal and Historical issues. @SSRN papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7501120
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My Open Letter to Scott Alexander, following his challenge to meet in a debating duel. quillette.substack.com/p/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From my interview with The New Society @NewStatesman:
Headlines are a bit of a misleading way to understand history because, you know, bad things happen, but bad things happened 50 years ago, too, and we tend to forget them. When you actually plot things like poverty, war, homicide, and literacy, most of these are way better now than they used to be. How did that happen? And there are a number of hypotheses that I float as to why cooperation and human flourishing in general have increased.
One of them is an expanding circle of empathy, another concept from Singer: as we rub shoulders, as we exchange stories with people who are unlike ourselves, we come to realize that we're not special just because we're us and they're them. You're bound to understand people when you kind of see the world from their perspective.
But another could be—and this, again, Singer suggested—that sheer raw reason can make us more moral, more cosmopolitan, more universal, as we realize that there's nothing special about me just because I'm me. There's something that is inherently disinterested and universal about reason. And, of course, I care about me more than I care about other people, but I can't convince you that that is a moral imperative—that you have to care about me more than you because I'm me and you're not.
And so, just that symmetry kind of pushes toward a kind of more ethical code: a golden rule, a categorical imperative, or the veil of ignorance, where simply discounting your own proprietary interest in yourself steers you toward a defensible morality.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Catch the full podcast here: podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/david-deutsch-steven-pinker…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
David Deutsch (@DavidDeutschOxf) and I discuss AGIs and subjectivity on the Joe Walker Podcast (@JosephNWalker):
David Deutsch:
I think it’s inevitable that AGIs will be capable of having internal subjectivity and qualia, because that’s all included in the letter G in the middle of the name of the technology.
Me:
Well, not necessarily, because the G could be general computational power, the ability to solve problems, and there could be no one at all who’s actually human.
David Deutsch:
But there ain’t nothing here but computation. It’s not like in Star Trek: Data lacks the emotion chip, and it has to be plugged in. But there’s nothing possibly in that chip apart from more circuitry like he’s already got.
Me:
But, of course, the episode that you’re referring to is one in which the question arose: Is it moral to reverse engineer Data by dismantling him, therefore stopping the computation? Is that disassembling a machine, or is it snuffing out a consciousness? Because there is an alternative view that subjectivity depends also on whatever biochemical substrate our particular computation runs on. And I think there’s no way of ever knowing.
David Deutsch:
I think we can answer that question before we ever do any experiments, even today, because there’s no difference in principle between a computer that runs partly by electricity and partly by chemicals and one that runs entirely on silicon chips. Because the latter can simulate the former with arbitrary accuracy.
Me:
Well, we don’t have to solve the problem this afternoon in our conversation, but, in fact, I think it is not solvable. But the simulation doesn’t necessarily mean that it has subjectivity. It could just mean it’s a simulation; that is, it’s going through all the motions. It might even do it better than we do, but, you know, there’s no one home. There’s no one actually being hurt.
David Deutsch:
Well, you can be a dualist. You can say that there is mind in addition to all the physical stuff. But if you want to be a physicalist, then there’s this thought experiment where you remove one neuron at a time and replace it with a silicon chip, and you wouldn’t notice.
Me:
Well, that’s the question. An external observer wouldn’t notice. How do we know that, from the point of view of the brain being replaced—every neuron by a chip—it’s like falling asleep? That when it’s done and every last neuron is replaced by a chip, you’re dead, subjectively, even though your body is still making noise?
David Deutsch:
That means that when your subjectivity is—there is something happening in addition to the computation. And that’s dualism.
Me:
I mean, again, I don’t have an opinion one way or another, which is exactly my point. I don’t think it’s a decidable problem. But it could be that that extra something is not ghostly substance. It could be that the stuff that the brain is made of is responsible for that extra ingredient of subjective experience, as opposed to intelligent behavior. I think we’re going to be having the same debate a hundred years from now.
David Deutsch:
Yeah, maybe one of the AGIs will be participating in the debate by then.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Conjecture Institute
@ConjectureInst
🛡️Defend the West Conference🛡️
WHEN: 1/13/2027
WHERE: Online
Over 300 people have registered so far.
Speakers include:
@DavidM_Friedman
@sapinker
@SRCHicks
@yaronbrook
@alananewhouse
@johanknorberg
@DeirdreMcClosk
@michaelshermer
@ToKTeacher
@jasoncrawford
Nadine Strossen
Save your spot (link below)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
David Deutsch (@DavidDeutschOxf) and I discuss AGIs and subjectivity on the Joe Walker Podcast (@JosephNWalker):
David Deutsch:
I think it’s inevitable that AGIs will be capable of having internal subjectivity and qualia, because that’s all included in the letter G in the middle of the name of the technology.
Me:
Well, not necessarily, because the G could be general computational power, the ability to solve problems, and there could be no one at all who’s actually human.
David Deutsch:
But there ain’t nothing here but computation. It’s not like in Star Trek: Data lacks the emotion chip, and it has to be plugged in. But there’s nothing possibly in that chip apart from more circuitry like he’s already got.
Me:
But, of course, the episode that you’re referring to is one in which the question arose: Is it moral to reverse engineer Data by dismantling him, therefore stopping the computation? Is that disassembling a machine, or is it snuffing out a consciousness? Because there is an alternative view that subjectivity depends also on whatever biochemical substrate our particular computation runs on. And I think there’s no way of ever knowing.
David Deutsch:
I think we can answer that question before we ever do any experiments, even today, because there’s no difference in principle between a computer that runs partly by electricity and partly by chemicals and one that runs entirely on silicon chips. Because the latter can simulate the former with arbitrary accuracy.
Me:
Well, we don’t have to solve the problem this afternoon in our conversation, but, in fact, I think it is not solvable. But the simulation doesn’t necessarily mean that it has subjectivity. It could just mean it’s a simulation; that is, it’s going through all the motions. It might even do it better than we do, but, you know, there’s no one home. There’s no one actually being hurt.
David Deutsch:
Well, you can be a dualist. You can say that there is mind in addition to all the physical stuff. But if you want to be a physicalist, then there’s this thought experiment where you remove one neuron at a time and replace it with a silicon chip, and you wouldn’t notice.
Me:
Well, that’s the question. An external observer wouldn’t notice. How do we know that, from the point of view of the brain being replaced—every neuron by a chip—it’s like falling asleep? That when it’s done and every last neuron is replaced by a chip, you’re dead, subjectively, even though your body is still making noise?
David Deutsch:
That means that when your subjectivity is—there is something happening in addition to the computation. And that’s dualism.
Me:
I mean, again, I don’t have an opinion one way or another, which is exactly my point. I don’t think it’s a decidable problem. But it could be that that extra something is not ghostly substance. It could be that the stuff that the brain is made of is responsible for that extra ingredient of subjective experience, as opposed to intelligent behavior. I think we’re going to be having the same debate a hundred years from now.
David Deutsch:
Yeah, maybe one of the AGIs will be participating in the debate by then.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Catch the full podcast here: podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/david-deutsch-steven-pinker…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Financial Times on When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/B0DV…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From my interview with The New Society @NewStatesman:
Headlines are a bit of a misleading way to understand history because, you know, bad things happen, but bad things happened 50 years ago, too, and we tend to forget them. When you actually plot things like poverty, war, homicide, and literacy, most of these are way better now than they used to be. How did that happen? And there are a number of hypotheses that I float as to why cooperation and human flourishing in general have increased.
One of them is an expanding circle of empathy, another concept from Singer: as we rub shoulders, as we exchange stories with people who are unlike ourselves, we come to realize that we're not special just because we're us and they're them. You're bound to understand people when you kind of see the world from their perspective.
But another could be—and this, again, Singer suggested—that sheer raw reason can make us more moral, more cosmopolitan, more universal, as we realize that there's nothing special about me just because I'm me. There's something that is inherently disinterested and universal about reason. And, of course, I care about me more than I care about other people, but I can't convince you that that is a moral imperative—that you have to care about me more than you because I'm me and you're not.
And so, just that symmetry kind of pushes toward a kind of more ethical code: a golden rule, a categorical imperative, or the veil of ignorance, where simply discounting your own proprietary interest in yourself steers you toward a defensible morality.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Yes, many critical-social-justice dogmas can't withstand intellectual scrutiny, so their proponents try to protect them via intimidation and walling off the university commons. Civil discourse and viewpoint diversity are threats to this tactic.
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
This new "report" is an embarrassing example of politicized argumentation plus scholarly ineptitude. It reflects that the movement to increase civil discourse & viewpoint diversity is rapidly advancing, which worries these authors. This is the best they could do to fight it.
Inside Higher Ed
@insidehighered
Group Argues Civil Discourse Push Is Conservative, Pro-Israel
A group of scholars has released another report arguing that efforts to promote constructive dialogue and similar concepts are actually targeting progressive activism. www.insidehighered.com/news/students/free-speech/2026/10/… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
There Was Nothing Victorious About October 7, by John Aziz, in Middle East Uncovered, an irreplaceable source of news and commentary, sponsored by Ideas Beyond Borders @IdeasB2 open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/there-was-not…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Insightful Economist cover story on the promise and dangers of EA as it has evolved intellectually and institutionally: Effective altruism is this century’s biggest idea www.economist.com/leaders/2026/10/01/effective-altruism-i…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
CIBOOK™ — A Sealed Record of This Moment in Time cibook.org
-
Steven Pinker reposted
CIBOOK
@cibookofficial
@OfficalPINKER, Johnstone Family Professor of Psychology at Harvard University, has contributed to CIBOOK. His sealed contribution will remain inaccessible until 2130.
Science · Cambridge, United States
#cibook #cibook2030 #cognitivescience -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Critiques of Progress, Pt. 1: The Revolt against Modernity open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/critiques…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A moving report by @mboudry: An Army of Yesterday’s Civilians: Ukraine and the Fight for Freedom quillette.substack.com/p/an-army-of-yesterdays-civilians-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The opinions expressed at this event are indeed refutable, but if you're committed to academic freedom, HMS can't be attacked for allowing it to happen. | Harvard Medical School Takes on Weight Loss www.city-journal.org/article/harvard-medical-school-weigh…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When I surveyed my colleagues on the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard for examples of how a lack of intellectual and political diversity was distorting scholarship & teaching in their fields, 1 example was avoidance of mentioning one of the most robust findings in happiness research: "Married people are happier. Period." | Why Americans Stopped Falling in Love. open.substack.com/pub/derekthompson/p/are-men-the-problem…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If all behavior is "caused" by our neurobiology (i.e., a miracle does not occur every time we make a choice), does that mean no one is responsible for their choices? @DamienMorris reveals the fallacies here.
Damien Morris
@DamienMorris
My review of Kathryn Paige Harden's new book Original Sin is out in Quillette. Harden disavows the quasi-religious conception of free will that underpinned The Genetic Lottery only to embrace a new brand of mysticism that licenses her to reaffirm the same social-justice ideology.
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Two weeks ago I gave the Margo Wilson Memorial Lecture at McMaster U, and she (together with Martin Daly) put it well in their masterpiece Homicide, discussing the sense of justice that impels us to hold people responsible for their actions:
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"From the perspective of evolutionary psychology, this almost mystical and seemingly irreducible sort of moral imperative is the output of a mental mechanism with a straightforward adaptive function: to reckon justice and administer punishment by a calculus which ensures that violators reap no advantage from their misdeeds. The enormous volume of mystico-religious bafflegab about atonement and penance and divine justice and the like is the attribution to higher, detached authority of what is actually a mundane, pragmatic matter: discouraging self-interested competitive acts by reducing their profitability to nil."
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Critiques of Progress, Pt. 1: The Revolt against Modernity open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/critiques…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Three Accusations against Israel: Apartheid, Settler Colonialism, and Genocide. Are they historically accurate, or just morally loaded vilifications? New paper scrutinizes the Legal and Historical issues. @SSRN papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7501120
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What to Make of Trump’s Uptick in Profanity (and the taboo words he still avoids), by @JohnHMcWhorter. John and I have both written about the linguistics (& in my case the psycholinguistics) of profanity, he in Nine Nasty Words, I in "The Seven Words You Can't Say on Television" in The Stuff of Thought. We'll present our analyses at the meeting of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression in Philadelphia next month. www.nytimes.com/2026/10/08/opinion/trump-profanity.html
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Population Decline Is Real. So Is the Reversal. Insightful and original analysis, via @fabricegrinda fabricegrinda.com/population-decline-is-real-so-is-the-re…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Notice of my contribution...
CIBOOK
@cibookofficial
@OfficalPINKER, Johnstone Family Professor of Psychology at Harvard University, has contributed to CIBOOK. His sealed contribution will remain inaccessible until 2130.
Science · Cambridge, United States
#cibook #cibook2030 #cognitivescience -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What to Make of Trump’s Uptick in Profanity (and the taboo words he still avoids), by @JohnHMcWhorter. John and I have both written about the linguistics (& in my case the psycholinguistics) of profanity, he in Nine Nasty Words, I in "The Seven Words You Can't Say on Television" in The Stuff of Thought. We'll present our analyses at the meeting of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression in Philadelphia next month. www.nytimes.com/2026/10/08/opinion/trump-profanity.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Population Decline Is Real. So Is the Reversal. Insightful and original analysis, via @fabricegrinda fabricegrinda.com/population-decline-is-real-so-is-the-re…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Notice of my contribution...
CIBOOK
@cibookofficial
@OfficalPINKER, Johnstone Family Professor of Psychology at Harvard University, has contributed to CIBOOK. His sealed contribution will remain inaccessible until 2130.
Science · Cambridge, United States
#cibook #cibook2030 #cognitivescience -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
CIBOOK™ — A Sealed Record of This Moment in Time cibook.org
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Including a contribution from me...
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
Will Claude ever win a Nobel Prize for medicine? My new piece is up at @statnews on the morning the Nobel Prize in Medicine is announced. It went to 3 humans! www.statnews.com/2026/10/05/could-ai-win-nobel-prize-medi… via @statnews
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Jerry Kaplan on AI Doomers (his take is pretty close to mine). quillette.substack.com/p/jerry-kaplan-on-ai-doomers?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Insightful Economist cover story on the promise and dangers of EA as it has evolved intellectually and institutionally: Effective altruism is this century’s biggest idea www.economist.com/leaders/2026/10/01/effective-altruism-i…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Claire Lehmann @clairlemon examines the dark side of "Effective Altruism" and compares their AI doomerism to historical millenarian cults. None of this literally refutes their predictions but it adds insight to what many see as eccentric and unpersuasive lines of thinking.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I remain an advocate of EA in its original formulation: I donate 10% of my income to effective charities (saving lives in the developing world); am on the Board of Advisors of Harvard undergrad EA; and teach a course ("Rationality") with a section on EA. But I was stunned as Will MacAskill gave a guest lecture in the course announcing the transition of EA from saving the lives of actual people today to safeguarding hypothetical consciousnesses in an intergalactic cloud in the distant future, and I quickly jumped off that train. Still favor generous and effective philanthropy.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Interview with the philosophers Dan Williams and Henry Shevlin on AI Doom, Consciousness, and whether the human brain is a LLM. open.substack.com/pub/conspicuouscognition/p/steven-pinke…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
There Was Nothing Victorious About October 7, by John Aziz, in Middle East Uncovered, an irreplaceable source of news and commentary, sponsored by Ideas Beyond Borders @IdeasB2 open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/there-was-not…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Three years ago, on 7 October, my worldview changed—not so much because of the atrocities committed by Hamas (what else would you expect from a genocidal terrorist group?), but because of the shocking response to those atrocities from many of my “progressive” friends: from apologetics and denial to outright jubilation.
That day, I was jolted out of my complacency and woke up to the poisonous ideology that had quietly taken hold across large swathes of the Left and academia.
My forthcoming book, The Betrayal of the Enlightenment (@PitchstoneBooks), reconstructs how self-proclaimed progressives, of all people, could have arrived at this point. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
There Was Nothing Victorious About October 7, by John Aziz, in Middle East Uncovered, an irreplaceable source of news and commentary, sponsored by Ideas Beyond Borders @IdeasB2 open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/there-was-not…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
Although Scott Alexander released his recent open letter shortly after we finished recording, I think the conversation gives a good sense of how Pinker would respond to many of its arguments. Full transcript and links here: www.conspicuouscognition.com/p/steven-pinker-on-ai-doom-a…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
@dioscuri and I were honoured to be joined by @sapinker to discuss AI, including concepts like "AGI" and "superintelligence", existential risk, instrumental convergence, consciousness, and more . Full video here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=JLJ7UL5CzvY&t=1s (1/2)
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Life in The Grim Old Days quillette.substack.com/p/life-in-the-grim-old-days?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Interview with the philosophers Dan Williams and Henry Shevlin on AI Doom, Consciousness, and whether the human brain is a LLM. open.substack.com/pub/conspicuouscognition/p/steven-pinke…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Life in The Grim Old Days quillette.substack.com/p/life-in-the-grim-old-days?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An intellectually deep and beautifully written essay on consciousness and AI, by neuroscientist Anil Seth | Why consciousness is more likely a property of life than of computation and why creating conscious, or even conscious-seeming AI, is a bad idea | @anilkseth in @NoemaMag
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Three Accusations against Israel: Apartheid, Settler Colonialism, and Genocide. Are they historically accurate, or just morally loaded vilifications? New paper scrutinizes the Legal and Historical issues. @SSRN papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7501120
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Brilliant and urgent essay by Mustafa Suleyman @mustafasuleyman on the depravity of ‘model welfare’ - training AI to reason and act as if it were an entity with sentience (and hence with interests and rights that compete with our own). It's alarmingly implied by Anthropic's "Constitution," Suleyman suggests, and should stop. mustafa-suleyman.ai/a-warning-about-model-welfare
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Do AIs inherently protect their own interests and sequester resources as subgoals toward any goal they are given? @mboudry shows how this "instrumental convergence" doomer dogma is dubious anthropomorphism. | Why HAL 9000 Feared Death (and Real AIs Don’t) maartenboudry.substack.com/p/why-hal-9000-feared-death-an…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Its opening sentence is one of the greatest in the history of the social sciences: “Killing one’s antagonist is the ultimate conflict resolution technique, and our ancestors discovered it long before they were people.”
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Analyses of the downsides of AI, whether in self-driving cars or bot psychotherapists, should not fall prey to the status quo bias and overlook the downsides of current practices. | Charlotte Blease @crblease notes: We’re right to worry about AI therapists. But what about human ones? bleaseondrbot.substack.com/p/were-right-to-worry-about-ai…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On AI and "superintelligence":
"The power will increase, but there's no point at which it's meaningful to say, 'Well, yesterday we didn't have superintelligence. Today we do have superintelligence.'
That's why I think it's meaningless to say, 'What will happen if one day we have superintelligence?' I don't even understand the question. It's: 'Will technology improve?' Almost certainly.
It will get better. It'll never be omniscient. It'll never be omnipotent. That's out of comic books out of religion. There are laws of physics. There are limits on information. There's no system that could learn the position and velocity of every particle in the universe. So as long as that is true, there's not going to be an AI system that can do anything or can know everything. But they will get—obviously, like any technology—they'll get more powerful."
Full interview: www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWC47agaKpkThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I've been suspicious of the philosophers hired by Anthropic who specialize in AI ethics for similar reasons that I'm skeptical of those who went into "bioethics": they form a closed subculture that delights in clever arguments without regard to the human suffering that can result. | ‘Suicidal Compassion’: Meet the Anthropic Officials Who Think AI Might Be Justified in Going Rogue Against the Humans Enslaving It freebeacon.com/america/suicidal-compassion-meet-the-anthr…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Full podcast here: "Steven Pinker on why reality is becoming unknowable":
www.youtube.com/watch?v=CgbT1W-KnEE -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From Into The Machine with Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose)
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
Do you believe that AIs could be conscious?
Me:
That's a consequential question in terms of the apocalyptic fear—the doomer fear—that AIs will do anything to perpetuate their own existence, possibly at our expense. But the question, though, is whether it is inherent to the nature of AIs that they want to continue their existence, even if they haven't explicitly been programmed to do so, or whether, having been trained on all this human input, they're just doing their best to emulate basically what a human would do in that circumstance. There's nothing that—when it comes down to it, unless they're programmed to emulate a human down to the last twitch, they would actually have no incentive to continue their existence.
Podcast link below. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is there a crisis of meaning?
"Overall, across the world, there's reason to believe that happiness has increased for obvious reasons: people are living longer, they're less poor, they're better educated, and so on. So that would suggest, but not prove, that there has not been a decline in meaningfulness. It's still possible.
But just anecdotally, there have been complaints that life is meaningless as far back as you go. You know, Ecclesiastes: “Vanity of vanities, all is vanity.” Henry David Thoreau in 1854: “The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation.” And how a guy living in a cabin on a pond could know this is unclear, but that was the perception. T. S. Eliot: “We are the hollow men, we are the stuffed men”—1920s. Starting in the '50s, there was a great fear of alienation. That was the big issue, and part of the counterculture was how suburban middle-class life was meaningless and empty and plastic and artificial. There was The Pursuit of Loneliness, a 1970 bestseller by Philip Slater, and Jimmy Carter's malaise speech in the late 1970s. So it's a constant complaint. The fact that people say it doesn't necessarily mean it's true."
@HumanProgressThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Yes, many critical-social-justice dogmas can't withstand intellectual scrutiny, so their proponents try to protect them via intimidation and walling off the university commons. Civil discourse and viewpoint diversity are threats to this tactic.
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
This new "report" is an embarrassing example of politicized argumentation plus scholarly ineptitude. It reflects that the movement to increase civil discourse & viewpoint diversity is rapidly advancing, which worries these authors. This is the best they could do to fight it.
Inside Higher Ed
@insidehighered
Group Argues Civil Discourse Push Is Conservative, Pro-Israel
A group of scholars has released another report arguing that efforts to promote constructive dialogue and similar concepts are actually targeting progressive activism. www.insidehighered.com/news/students/free-speech/2026/10/… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
After a botched execution, Christa Pike is "receiving lifesaving medical care." This contradiction, which would have boggled the minds of our ancestors, shows how the historical increased valuation of human life is working against the death penalty. As I showed in Better Angels and then in Enlightenment Now, the global trend is toward abolition (the gray arrow shows when Angels was published):: www.nytimes.com/2026/10/01/science/pike-execution-pentoba…
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Even that has been hard to implement, as doctors refuse to administer it and pharmaceutical companies refuse to supply the drugs, forcing states to resort to the bootleg drugs and bumbling executioners that led to the current fiasco.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
All examples of how diffuse cultural and moral norms can push a decline of violence even when legislators don't implement reforms.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Contra @slatestarcodex, my arguments against AI doomerism have never been based on the claim that it is a cult. But the responses to my open letter (together with journalistic digging by NYT and WSJ) have made this more plausible. Foremost is the invocation of tenets in the doomer catechism (particularly "instrumental convergence," the belief that intelligent agents will inevitably seek power, resources, and self-preservation as subgoals) as if they were sacred truths rather than tendentious assumptions. (IC is in fact the not-so-intelligent pursuit of a goal heedless of side effects, and the reckless empowerment of AI, that we un-doomers note are deliberate, hence avoidable, design choices, not intrinsic constituents of intelligence). I feel as if I'm doubting the Second Coming and am being told, "That's naive and ignorant; you seem to be unaware that the Apostles' Creed dictates that it will happen."
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Its opening sentence is one of the greatest in the history of the social sciences: “Killing one’s antagonist is the ultimate conflict resolution technique, and our ancestors discovered it long before they were people.”
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This brilliant and beautifully written book persuaded me of the value of evolutionary psychology, and kindled my interest in the historical decline of violence.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Google’s “Expert Intelligence” allows my book The Sense of Style to be used for real-time advice on the clarity and style of your prose drafts.
Steven Johnson
@stevenbjohnson
The power of Expert Intelligence in @Gemini_Notebook:
Add The Sense of Style by @sapinker to a notebook with a draft you're writing. Ask for feedback based on Pinker's ideas.
It's the opposite of AI slop: personalized advice based on human expertise, facilitated by AI.
And what I love about this is that I'm getting actionable suggestions here AND Notebook is serving as a guide to Pinker's underlying philosophy of writing. So I'm learning deeper principles as I improve my draft. And of course everything in the Notebook response points directly back to specific passages in Pinker (and my own draft) with citations.
We have a Featured Notebook curated by Steven Pinker available here, but if you purchase the book, you can add it to any notebook you want. (And read it in its entirely in Notebook or the Google Play Books reader.)
notebook.google.com/notebook/a109ad5c-834d-4f3d-82a0-fe41… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Google’s “Expert Intelligence” allows my book The Sense of Style to be used for real-time advice on the clarity and style of your prose drafts.
Steven Johnson
@stevenbjohnson
The power of Expert Intelligence in @Gemini_Notebook:
Add The Sense of Style by @sapinker to a notebook with a draft you're writing. Ask for feedback based on Pinker's ideas.
It's the opposite of AI slop: personalized advice based on human expertise, facilitated by AI.
And what I love about this is that I'm getting actionable suggestions here AND Notebook is serving as a guide to Pinker's underlying philosophy of writing. So I'm learning deeper principles as I improve my draft. And of course everything in the Notebook response points directly back to specific passages in Pinker (and my own draft) with citations.
We have a Featured Notebook curated by Steven Pinker available here, but if you purchase the book, you can add it to any notebook you want. (And read it in its entirely in Notebook or the Google Play Books reader.)
notebook.google.com/notebook/a109ad5c-834d-4f3d-82a0-fe41… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This brilliant and beautifully written book persuaded me of the value of evolutionary psychology, and kindled my interest in the historical decline of violence.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Its opening sentence is one of the greatest in the history of the social sciences: “Killing one’s antagonist is the ultimate conflict resolution technique, and our ancestors discovered it long before they were people.”
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Earlier today I was honored to give the Margo Wilson Memorial Lecture at McMaster U, honoring a dear friend and profound intellectual influence. This is her partner, Martin Daly FRSC, introducing me.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On AI and "superintelligence":
"The power will increase, but there's no point at which it's meaningful to say, 'Well, yesterday we didn't have superintelligence. Today we do have superintelligence.'
That's why I think it's meaningless to say, 'What will happen if one day we have superintelligence?' I don't even understand the question. It's: 'Will technology improve?' Almost certainly.
It will get better. It'll never be omniscient. It'll never be omnipotent. That's out of comic books out of religion. There are laws of physics. There are limits on information. There's no system that could learn the position and velocity of every particle in the universe. So as long as that is true, there's not going to be an AI system that can do anything or can know everything. But they will get—obviously, like any technology—they'll get more powerful."
Full interview: www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWC47agaKpkThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I've been suspicious of the philosophers hired by Anthropic who specialize in AI ethics for similar reasons that I'm skeptical of those who went into "bioethics": they form a closed subculture that delights in clever arguments without regard to the human suffering that can result. | ‘Suicidal Compassion’: Meet the Anthropic Officials Who Think AI Might Be Justified in Going Rogue Against the Humans Enslaving It freebeacon.com/america/suicidal-compassion-meet-the-anthr…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker on why reality is becoming unknowable" on the Into The Machine podcast with Tobias Rose-Stockwell
@TobiasRoseThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From Into The Machine with Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose)
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
Do you believe that AIs could be conscious?
Me:
That's a consequential question in terms of the apocalyptic fear—the doomer fear—that AIs will do anything to perpetuate their own existence, possibly at our expense. But the question, though, is whether it is inherent to the nature of AIs that they want to continue their existence, even if they haven't explicitly been programmed to do so, or whether, having been trained on all this human input, they're just doing their best to emulate basically what a human would do in that circumstance. There's nothing that—when it comes down to it, unless they're programmed to emulate a human down to the last twitch, they would actually have no incentive to continue their existence.
Podcast link below. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Three Accusations against Israel: Apartheid, Settler Colonialism, and Genocide. Are they historically accurate, or just morally loaded vilifications? New paper scrutinizes the Legal and Historical issues. @SSRN papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7501120
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Opinion | Black scholarship is marginalized if it’s not on the left www.bostonglobe.com/2026/09/30/opinion/jon-shields-black-… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Thanks, @mboudry, for explaining why I don't feel compelled to use the proprietary doomer lexicon (orthogonality, convergence, etc.), since that would concede points that in fact I am challengenging.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
With all due respect, @gmiller, but this reminds me of the "Courtier's Reply" from the New Atheism era, when atheists were told that they had no standing to question theism until they'd mastered the ontological argument, the Kalam cosmological argument, skeptical theism, the Five Ways, and whatever the latest iteration of Sophisticated Theology happened to be.
Back then, unless you had read your Richard Swinburne, your Alvin Plantinga and your John Haught, you couldn't appreciate the finer fabrics of the emperor's wardrobe, and so weren't entitled to say he was naked.
Personally, I've addressed instrumental convergence and power-seeking (in the context of evolutionary doom scenarios) at some length, but it's never enough. There's always another theoretical argument or doom scenario that raises the entry fee to the discussion. Essentially the theologians (or AI doomers) set up their own theoretical game with its own rules, and won't take you seriously unless you play by those rules.
The dynamic is self-selecting: only people already convinced that the doom scenarios deserve attention will invest the effort to keep up with the sprawling literature, so skeptics can always be dismissed as "not well informed."
I'm not claiming the two cases are on an epistemic par, since AI risk at least has some empirical basis that theism lacks entirely. But the defensive move looks very similar, and does not help to dispell the suspicion that AI doomerism has some cult-like features.
Let's also tag @sapinker.
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
With all due respect to Pinker, who's generally one of my favorite thinkers and writers, his @Quillette article shows very little evidence of him having seriously studied or engaged with anything that's happened in AI safety in the last 10 years.
It just does not seem very well informed about any of the key ideas in AI safety, e.g. ASI alignment, instrumental convergence, power-seeking, reward hacking, orthogonality, interpretability, corrigibility, deceptive misalignment. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Thanks, @mboudry, for explaining why I don't feel compelled to use the proprietary doomer lexicon (orthogonality, convergence, etc.), since that would concede points that in fact I am challengenging.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
With all due respect, @gmiller, but this reminds me of the "Courtier's Reply" from the New Atheism era, when atheists were told that they had no standing to question theism until they'd mastered the ontological argument, the Kalam cosmological argument, skeptical theism, the Five Ways, and whatever the latest iteration of Sophisticated Theology happened to be.
Back then, unless you had read your Richard Swinburne, your Alvin Plantinga and your John Haught, you couldn't appreciate the finer fabrics of the emperor's wardrobe, and so weren't entitled to say he was naked.
Personally, I've addressed instrumental convergence and power-seeking (in the context of evolutionary doom scenarios) at some length, but it's never enough. There's always another theoretical argument or doom scenario that raises the entry fee to the discussion. Essentially the theologians (or AI doomers) set up their own theoretical game with its own rules, and won't take you seriously unless you play by those rules.
The dynamic is self-selecting: only people already convinced that the doom scenarios deserve attention will invest the effort to keep up with the sprawling literature, so skeptics can always be dismissed as "not well informed."
I'm not claiming the two cases are on an epistemic par, since AI risk at least has some empirical basis that theism lacks entirely. But the defensive move looks very similar, and does not help to dispell the suspicion that AI doomerism has some cult-like features.
Let's also tag @sapinker.
Geoffrey Miller
@gmiller
With all due respect to Pinker, who's generally one of my favorite thinkers and writers, his @Quillette article shows very little evidence of him having seriously studied or engaged with anything that's happened in AI safety in the last 10 years.
It just does not seem very well informed about any of the key ideas in AI safety, e.g. ASI alignment, instrumental convergence, power-seeking, reward hacking, orthogonality, interpretability, corrigibility, deceptive misalignment. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
After WWI, it was predicted that humanity would be extinguished by cropdusters blanketing cities with poison gas. After WWII, nuclear holocaust, for sure. After 9/11, terrorists with WMD, including suitcase and shipping container nukes. After the first nanotech, engulfment by "gray goo." The fact that these (and many other) end times prophesies failed does not mean that the new AI doom prophesy will fail - maybe this time it's different - but they should serve as a reminder of the cognitive bias of casually slipping from risk to existential risk, and to compensate accordingly, just as with other cognitive biases if one is a rationalist. John Mueller adds historical perspective here: Artificial Intelligence and the persistent survival of cosmic alarmism muellerbbbb.substack.com/p/artificial-intelligence-and-th…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Do AIs inherently protect their own interests and sequester resources as subgoals toward any goal they are given? @mboudry shows how this "instrumental convergence" doomer dogma is dubious anthropomorphism. | Why HAL 9000 Feared Death (and Real AIs Don’t) maartenboudry.substack.com/p/why-hal-9000-feared-death-an…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I've been suspicious of the philosophers hired by Anthropic who specialize in AI ethics for similar reasons that I'm skeptical of those who went into "bioethics": they form a closed subculture that delights in clever arguments without regard to the human suffering that can result. | ‘Suicidal Compassion’: Meet the Anthropic Officials Who Think AI Might Be Justified in Going Rogue Against the Humans Enslaving It freebeacon.com/america/suicidal-compassion-meet-the-anthr…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Full podcast here: "Steven Pinker on why reality is becoming unknowable":
www.youtube.com/watch?v=CgbT1W-KnEE -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From Into The Machine with Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose)
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
Do you believe that AIs could be conscious?
Me:
That's a consequential question in terms of the apocalyptic fear—the doomer fear—that AIs will do anything to perpetuate their own existence, possibly at our expense. But the question, though, is whether it is inherent to the nature of AIs that they want to continue their existence, even if they haven't explicitly been programmed to do so, or whether, having been trained on all this human input, they're just doing their best to emulate basically what a human would do in that circumstance. There's nothing that—when it comes down to it, unless they're programmed to emulate a human down to the last twitch, they would actually have no incentive to continue their existence.
Podcast link below. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An intellectually deep and beautifully written essay on consciousness and AI, by neuroscientist Anil Seth | Why consciousness is more likely a property of life than of computation and why creating conscious, or even conscious-seeming AI, is a bad idea | @anilkseth in @NoemaMag
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
At least since I wrote How the Mind Works, I've long been a strong proponent of the computational theory of intelligence, but I've always acknowledged that it cannot explain subjective, phenomenal, 1st-person experience. Neither can any other scientific theory, but Seth makes a good case that our biological makeup is relevant.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Three Accusations against Israel: Apartheid, Settler Colonialism, and Genocide. Are they historically accurate, or just morally loaded vilifications? New paper scrutinizes the Legal and Historical issues. @SSRN papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7501120
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Brilliant and urgent essay by Mustafa Suleyman @mustafasuleyman on the depravity of ‘model welfare’ - training AI to reason and act as if it were an entity with sentience (and hence with interests and rights that compete with our own). It's alarmingly implied by Anthropic's "Constitution," Suleyman suggests, and should stop. mustafa-suleyman.ai/a-warning-about-model-welfare
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Contra @slatestarcodex, my arguments against AI doomerism have never been based on the claim that it is a cult. But the responses to my open letter (together with journalistic digging by NYT and WSJ) have made this more plausible. Foremost is the invocation of tenets in the doomer catechism (particularly "instrumental convergence," the belief that intelligent agents will inevitably seek power, resources, and self-preservation as subgoals) as if they were sacred truths rather than tendentious assumptions. (IC is in fact the not-so-intelligent pursuit of a goal heedless of side effects, and the reckless empowerment of AI, that we un-doomers note are deliberate, hence avoidable, design choices, not intrinsic constituents of intelligence). I feel as if I'm doubting the Second Coming and am being told, "That's naive and ignorant; you seem to be unaware that the Apostles' Creed dictates that it will happen."
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On AI and "superintelligence":
"The power will increase, but there's no point at which it's meaningful to say, 'Well, yesterday we didn't have superintelligence. Today we do have superintelligence.'
That's why I think it's meaningless to say, 'What will happen if one day we have superintelligence?' I don't even understand the question. It's: 'Will technology improve?' Almost certainly.
It will get better. It'll never be omniscient. It'll never be omnipotent. That's out of comic books out of religion. There are laws of physics. There are limits on information. There's no system that could learn the position and velocity of every particle in the universe. So as long as that is true, there's not going to be an AI system that can do anything or can know everything. But they will get—obviously, like any technology—they'll get more powerful."
Full interview: www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWC47agaKpkThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Since 1948, when MIT Press published Norbert Wiener's Cybernetics, the press has been at the forefront of AI writing. Here is a catalogue of their major works. dhjhkxawhe8q4.cloudfront.net/mit-press/wp-content/uploads…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I've been suspicious of the philosophers hired by Anthropic who specialize in AI ethics for similar reasons that I'm skeptical of those who went into "bioethics": they form a closed subculture that delights in clever arguments without regard to the human suffering that can result. | ‘Suicidal Compassion’: Meet the Anthropic Officials Who Think AI Might Be Justified in Going Rogue Against the Humans Enslaving It freebeacon.com/america/suicidal-compassion-meet-the-anthr…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker on why reality is becoming unknowable" on the Into The Machine podcast with Tobias Rose-Stockwell
@TobiasRoseThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From Into The Machine with Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose)
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
Do you believe that AIs could be conscious?
Me:
That's a consequential question in terms of the apocalyptic fear—the doomer fear—that AIs will do anything to perpetuate their own existence, possibly at our expense. But the question, though, is whether it is inherent to the nature of AIs that they want to continue their existence, even if they haven't explicitly been programmed to do so, or whether, having been trained on all this human input, they're just doing their best to emulate basically what a human would do in that circumstance. There's nothing that—when it comes down to it, unless they're programmed to emulate a human down to the last twitch, they would actually have no incentive to continue their existence.
Podcast link below. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The line of argument that grants interests and rights to AI is profoundly anti-humanistic, and helps explain why many AI researchers seem insouciant about the AI worldwide genocide that they predict (and appear to be trying to hasten). Grimly fascinating background in this NYT essay by Michelle Goldberg: www.nytimes.com/2026/09/12/opinion/ai-tech-apocalypse-sil…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Suleyman's arguments against the computational theory of sentience are compelling, but one needn't accept them completely to recognize the case for assigning no rights to AI at the expense of humans: we know that humans are sentient (because each of us knows that we ourselves are sentient, and others are made of the same stuff that makes us sentient, putting aside the logical possibility of solipsism), whereas the case for AI sentience is permanently untestable and for most people extremely implausible).
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Three Accusations against Israel: Apartheid, Settler Colonialism, and Genocide. Are they historically accurate, or just morally loaded vilifications? New paper scrutinizes the Legal and Historical issues. @SSRN papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7501120
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"A stepmother decapitates her stepson, cooks him up in a stew, and serves him to his unsuspecting father." Interview with my colleague Maria Tatar, the world's expert on fairy tales ("the television and pornography of an earlier age"--John Updike). news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/09/helping-us-make-ou…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Brilliant and urgent essay by Mustafa Suleyman @mustafasuleyman on the depravity of ‘model welfare’ - training AI to reason and act as if it were an entity with sentience (and hence with interests and rights that compete with our own). It's alarmingly implied by Anthropic's "Constitution," Suleyman suggests, and should stop. mustafa-suleyman.ai/a-warning-about-model-welfare
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
WSJ: Inside the subculture that obsessed over AI doom long before it terrified everyone else www.wsj.com/tech/ai/ai-safety-effective-altruism-anthropi… via @WSJ
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Contra @slatestarcodex, my arguments against AI doomerism have never been based on the claim that it is a cult. But the responses to my open letter (together with journalistic digging by NYT and WSJ) have made this more plausible. Foremost is the invocation of tenets in the doomer catechism (particularly "instrumental convergence," the belief that intelligent agents will inevitably seek power, resources, and self-preservation as subgoals) as if they were sacred truths rather than tendentious assumptions. (IC is in fact the not-so-intelligent pursuit of a goal heedless of side effects, and the reckless empowerment of AI, that we un-doomers note are deliberate, hence avoidable, design choices, not intrinsic constituents of intelligence). I feel as if I'm doubting the Second Coming and am being told, "That's naive and ignorant; you seem to be unaware that the Apostles' Creed dictates that it will happen."
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An Open Letter to Scott Alexander: The dangers of AI are real, but doomerism may be counterproductive.
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My Open Letter to Scott Alexander, following his challenge to meet in a debating duel. quillette.substack.com/p/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is there a crisis of meaning?
"Overall, across the world, there's reason to believe that happiness has increased for obvious reasons: people are living longer, they're less poor, they're better educated, and so on. So that would suggest, but not prove, that there has not been a decline in meaningfulness. It's still possible.
But just anecdotally, there have been complaints that life is meaningless as far back as you go. You know, Ecclesiastes: “Vanity of vanities, all is vanity.” Henry David Thoreau in 1854: “The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation.” And how a guy living in a cabin on a pond could know this is unclear, but that was the perception. T. S. Eliot: “We are the hollow men, we are the stuffed men”—1920s. Starting in the '50s, there was a great fear of alienation. That was the big issue, and part of the counterculture was how suburban middle-class life was meaningless and empty and plastic and artificial. There was The Pursuit of Loneliness, a 1970 bestseller by Philip Slater, and Jimmy Carter's malaise speech in the late 1970s. So it's a constant complaint. The fact that people say it doesn't necessarily mean it's true."
@HumanProgressThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=vD72L44il8E&t=1s
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Contra @slatestarcodex, my arguments against AI doomerism have never been based on the claim that it is a cult. But the responses to my open letter (together with journalistic digging by NYT and WSJ) have made this more plausible. Foremost is the invocation of tenets in the doomer catechism (particularly "instrumental convergence," the belief that intelligent agents will inevitably seek power, resources, and self-preservation as subgoals) as if they were sacred truths rather than tendentious assumptions. (IC is in fact the not-so-intelligent pursuit of a goal heedless of side effects, and the reckless empowerment of AI, that we un-doomers note are deliberate, hence avoidable, design choices, not intrinsic constituents of intelligence). I feel as if I'm doubting the Second Coming and am being told, "That's naive and ignorant; you seem to be unaware that the Apostles' Creed dictates that it will happen."
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
WSJ: Inside the subculture that obsessed over AI doom long before it terrified everyone else www.wsj.com/tech/ai/ai-safety-effective-altruism-anthropi… via @WSJ
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Brilliant and urgent essay by Mustafa Suleyman @mustafasuleyman on the depravity of ‘model welfare’ - training AI to reason and act as if it were an entity with sentience (and hence with interests and rights that compete with our own). It's alarmingly implied by Anthropic's "Constitution," Suleyman suggests, and should stop. mustafa-suleyman.ai/a-warning-about-model-welfare
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Suleyman's arguments against the computational theory of sentience are compelling, but one needn't accept them completely to recognize the case for assigning no rights to AI at the expense of humans: we know that humans are sentient (because each of us knows that we ourselves are sentient, and others are made of the same stuff that makes us sentient, putting aside the logical possibility of solipsism), whereas the case for AI sentience is permanently untestable and for most people extremely implausible).
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The line of argument that grants interests and rights to AI is profoundly anti-humanistic, and helps explain why many AI researchers seem insouciant about the AI worldwide genocide that they predict (and appear to be trying to hasten). Grimly fascinating background in this NYT essay by Michelle Goldberg: www.nytimes.com/2026/09/12/opinion/ai-tech-apocalypse-sil…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"A stepmother decapitates her stepson, cooks him up in a stew, and serves him to his unsuspecting father." Interview with my colleague Maria Tatar, the world's expert on fairy tales ("the television and pornography of an earlier age"--John Updike). news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/09/helping-us-make-ou…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is AI really going to kill us all? The scenarios are preposterous, and the presumption of inevitability encourages fatalism, panic, and distraction from the more mundane and realistic safety challenges. By @clairlemon www.theaustralian.com.au/inquirer/superintelligence-is-a-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Human Progress
@HumanProgress
Full interview: humanprogress.org/meaning-and-morality-in-the-modern-age/
Read the highlights: humanprogress.org/meaning-and-morality-in-the-modern-age-… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Human Progress
@HumanProgress
Is there truly a "crisis of meaning?"
@sapinker discusses on our podcast.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Quillette
@Quillette
The dangers of AI are real, but doomerism may be counterproductive, writes @sapinker.
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I've been suspicious of the philosophers hired by Anthropic who specialize in AI ethics for similar reasons that I'm skeptical of those who went into "bioethics": they form a closed subculture that delights in clever arguments without regard to the human suffering that can result. | ‘Suicidal Compassion’: Meet the Anthropic Officials Who Think AI Might Be Justified in Going Rogue Against the Humans Enslaving It freebeacon.com/america/suicidal-compassion-meet-the-anthr…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On AI and "superintelligence":
"The power will increase, but there's no point at which it's meaningful to say, 'Well, yesterday we didn't have superintelligence. Today we do have superintelligence.'
That's why I think it's meaningless to say, 'What will happen if one day we have superintelligence?' I don't even understand the question. It's: 'Will technology improve?' Almost certainly.
It will get better. It'll never be omniscient. It'll never be omnipotent. That's out of comic books out of religion. There are laws of physics. There are limits on information. There's no system that could learn the position and velocity of every particle in the universe. So as long as that is true, there's not going to be an AI system that can do anything or can know everything. But they will get—obviously, like any technology—they'll get more powerful."
Full interview: www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWC47agaKpkThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
An Open Letter to Scott Alexander
From @sapinker
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Three Accusations against Israel: Apartheid, Settler Colonialism, and Genocide. Are they historically accurate, or just morally loaded vilifications? New paper scrutinizes the Legal and Historical issues. @SSRN papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7501120
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My Open Letter to Scott Alexander, following his challenge to meet in a debating duel. quillette.substack.com/p/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Full podcast here: "Steven Pinker on why reality is becoming unknowable":
www.youtube.com/watch?v=CgbT1W-KnEE -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From Into The Machine with Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose)
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
Do you believe that AIs could be conscious?
Me:
That's a consequential question in terms of the apocalyptic fear—the doomer fear—that AIs will do anything to perpetuate their own existence, possibly at our expense. But the question, though, is whether it is inherent to the nature of AIs that they want to continue their existence, even if they haven't explicitly been programmed to do so, or whether, having been trained on all this human input, they're just doing their best to emulate basically what a human would do in that circumstance. There's nothing that—when it comes down to it, unless they're programmed to emulate a human down to the last twitch, they would actually have no incentive to continue their existence.
Podcast link below. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
If you are following the AI doomsday story (we will all be dead by 2030 or 2037, depending on which AI end-of-days expert you read), this reasoned response by @sapinker is a must read.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An Open Letter to Scott Alexander: The dangers of AI are real, but doomerism may be counterproductive.
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is there a crisis of meaning?
"Overall, across the world, there's reason to believe that happiness has increased for obvious reasons: people are living longer, they're less poor, they're better educated, and so on. So that would suggest, but not prove, that there has not been a decline in meaningfulness. It's still possible.
But just anecdotally, there have been complaints that life is meaningless as far back as you go. You know, Ecclesiastes: “Vanity of vanities, all is vanity.” Henry David Thoreau in 1854: “The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation.” And how a guy living in a cabin on a pond could know this is unclear, but that was the perception. T. S. Eliot: “We are the hollow men, we are the stuffed men”—1920s. Starting in the '50s, there was a great fear of alienation. That was the big issue, and part of the counterculture was how suburban middle-class life was meaningless and empty and plastic and artificial. There was The Pursuit of Loneliness, a 1970 bestseller by Philip Slater, and Jimmy Carter's malaise speech in the late 1970s. So it's a constant complaint. The fact that people say it doesn't necessarily mean it's true."
@HumanProgressThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker on why reality is becoming unknowable" on the Into The Machine podcast with Tobias Rose-Stockwell
@TobiasRoseThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From Into The Machine with Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose)
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
Do you believe that AIs could be conscious?
Me:
That's a consequential question in terms of the apocalyptic fear—the doomer fear—that AIs will do anything to perpetuate their own existence, possibly at our expense. But the question, though, is whether it is inherent to the nature of AIs that they want to continue their existence, even if they haven't explicitly been programmed to do so, or whether, having been trained on all this human input, they're just doing their best to emulate basically what a human would do in that circumstance. There's nothing that—when it comes down to it, unless they're programmed to emulate a human down to the last twitch, they would actually have no incentive to continue their existence.
Podcast link below. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Since 1948, when MIT Press published Norbert Wiener's Cybernetics, the press has been at the forefront of AI writing. Here is a catalogue of their major works. dhjhkxawhe8q4.cloudfront.net/mit-press/wp-content/uploads…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Three Accusations against Israel: Apartheid, Settler Colonialism, and Genocide. Are they historically accurate, or just morally loaded vilifications? New paper scrutinizes the Legal and Historical issues. @SSRN papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7501120
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An Open Letter to Scott Alexander: The dangers of AI are real, but doomerism may be counterproductive.
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is there a crisis of meaning?
"Overall, across the world, there's reason to believe that happiness has increased for obvious reasons: people are living longer, they're less poor, they're better educated, and so on. So that would suggest, but not prove, that there has not been a decline in meaningfulness. It's still possible.
But just anecdotally, there have been complaints that life is meaningless as far back as you go. You know, Ecclesiastes: “Vanity of vanities, all is vanity.” Henry David Thoreau in 1854: “The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation.” And how a guy living in a cabin on a pond could know this is unclear, but that was the perception. T. S. Eliot: “We are the hollow men, we are the stuffed men”—1920s. Starting in the '50s, there was a great fear of alienation. That was the big issue, and part of the counterculture was how suburban middle-class life was meaningless and empty and plastic and artificial. There was The Pursuit of Loneliness, a 1970 bestseller by Philip Slater, and Jimmy Carter's malaise speech in the late 1970s. So it's a constant complaint. The fact that people say it doesn't necessarily mean it's true."
@HumanProgressThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On AI and "superintelligence":
"The power will increase, but there's no point at which it's meaningful to say, 'Well, yesterday we didn't have superintelligence. Today we do have superintelligence.'
That's why I think it's meaningless to say, 'What will happen if one day we have superintelligence?' I don't even understand the question. It's: 'Will technology improve?' Almost certainly.
It will get better. It'll never be omniscient. It'll never be omnipotent. That's out of comic books out of religion. There are laws of physics. There are limits on information. There's no system that could learn the position and velocity of every particle in the universe. So as long as that is true, there's not going to be an AI system that can do anything or can know everything. But they will get—obviously, like any technology—they'll get more powerful."
Full interview: www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWC47agaKpkThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I've been suspicious of the philosophers hired by Anthropic who specialize in AI ethics for similar reasons that I'm skeptical of those who went into "bioethics": they form a closed subculture that delights in clever arguments without regard to the human suffering that can result. | ‘Suicidal Compassion’: Meet the Anthropic Officials Who Think AI Might Be Justified in Going Rogue Against the Humans Enslaving It freebeacon.com/america/suicidal-compassion-meet-the-anthr…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My Open Letter to Scott Alexander, following his challenge to meet in a debating duel. quillette.substack.com/p/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Since 1948, when MIT Press published Norbert Wiener's Cybernetics, the press has been at the forefront of AI writing. Here is a catalogue of their major works. dhjhkxawhe8q4.cloudfront.net/mit-press/wp-content/uploads…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Pamela Paresky 🟦 (Habits of a Free Mind)
@PamelaParesky
Also, finding a moral equivalence between humans using human-made technology and enslaving actual human beings is a dehumanizing view of the human beings who were once enslaved.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My former MIT colleague Yossi Sheffi has documented how unhinged hatred of Israel, combined with the unwillingness of modern universities to state and enforce principles, led to a hostile climate for Jews at MIT (only starting to be addressed by the administration). | Professor Yossi Sheffi sheffi.mit.edu/book/unsafe-mit-0
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Brian Keating (@briankeating) and Rebecca Newberger Goldstein (@platobooktour) discuss "The Law of Physics Behind Depression."
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
The thing that suicidally depressed people feel is that they don’t matter; others do, they don’t. Nothing they can do will ever make them matter. It’s a terrible, terrible feeling. And what this means is they cannot abide their own presence.
Brian Keating:
What if there is a law of physics that explains why depression feels the way it does?
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
When I first learned about the second law of thermodynamics, it seemed—I couldn’t quite conceptualize it. We are subject to the second law of thermodynamics, which, you know, has a tragic dimension. In fact, when I was a graduate student, it occurred to me, oh my gosh, biological systems are really just organized to resist the second law of thermodynamics.
In some sense, biology is a response to this supreme law that tells us that, in closed systems, energy never increases; entropy never decreases. Entropy never decreases, and if there’s any way for it to increase, it will. Entropy is the measure of the disorder of a system. The more disorder, the higher the entropy, and the less efficient the work you can get out at the end of the system.
And in fact, Rudolf Clausius, the physicist, said that the universe itself will go to thermal equilibrium—what we call the heat death—and so there will be no more energy to be gotten out of it at the end of the system. Rudolf Clausius, the 19th-century physicist who formulated the concept of entropy, which means literally “transformation from within”—there’s poignancy in that. This transformation from within is going to the end of the system. And he said that the universe itself will go to thermal equilibrium, to what we call the heat death, and so there will be no more energy to be gotten out of it.
Brian Keating:
So let’s start with that story you tell first about Ludwig Boltzmann, who solved one of the great paradoxes of physics, the irreversibility paradox. Talk about that. And then why, in your mind, was he so traumatized, perhaps, or so full of dread of his equation that he took his own life? So talk about that.
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
So there was this great paradox, which is that most—probably most—of the processes that we observe are irreversible. If you film them—and tell me if I’m being too elementary, because I’m going to be very—you know, if you film them, like let’s say I crack open an egg and I stir it up and then I fry it, and somebody filmed this and then reversed the film, anybody who sees the reverse of that film is going to know it was reversed. That cannot happen in nature: that the egg is going to uncook itself, unscramble; the yolk is going to separate from the albumen and jump into the shell and seal up. Impossible, right? So almost everything that we see is irreversible.
Brian Keating:
Yes. I saw that line, Rebecca. It made me think, because you mentioned it in the context of his daughter, Elsa, finding her father’s dead body. And it wasn’t like he showed any sign. I mean, we can’t go into the minds of someone who dies by suicide, right? Yes. But at the same time, you’d think, well, this would be a more common thing.
And so, is depression sort of a—you know, they used to think of miasmas and things in the air, you write about that in the book—is depression, at heart, an entropic collapsing process?
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
I have spoken to a lot of people who suffer from clinical depression. And I want to say, first of all, that the U.S. hotline for suicide prevention is www.samhsa.gov/resource/988/you-matter-psa-video.
The thing that suicidally depressed people feel is that they don’t matter. Others do. They don’t. Nothing they can do will ever make them matter. It’s a terrible, terrible feeling. And what this means is they cannot—they can’t abide their own presence. I really think it shows how strong this mattering instinct is in us. If you can’t somehow appease it, you can’t abide your own presence.
And so, what the people I’ve spoken to—and one is a very, very good philosopher who has suffered from depression—have told me is that, phenomenologically, this is exactly what it feels like. It feels like psychic disintegration.
So, in some sense, yes—happiness is a very ordered state. And I would go even further: everything worth living for is an ordered state. I think knowledge—knowledge, knowledge, knowledge—is better than ignorance. Clarity is better than confusion. Flourishing is better than suffering. Love is better than hatred. Beauty is better than ugliness. These are truisms; these are what we all accept. Look at the thing that’s better: it’s an ordered state. And its negation is a disordered state.
So I think—I would argue—this is a very kind of Spinozist argument, trying to get out of the laws of nature some ethical enlightenment, some ethical guidance, because that’s what we want. We want ethical guidance.
So we know we want to matter. We know we do all sorts of things to matter. Some people do very bad things in order to matter. Some of the people I’ve spoken to… they do. They want power over others. They want dominance. They want to make other people’s lives miserable. These are bad things, right? They cause an increase in entropy.
This is how I judge people now: are you increasing entropy, or are you decreasing it?
-- Full video in link below.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The degeneration of Nature, Science, NEJM, and Scientific American into woke propaganda dispensers (and their refusal to publish normie, centrist, common-sense responses) is a scientific scandal.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Wokeness is corrupting science from within. Nature went woke years ago with their support of trans pseudoscience (sex is binary, not a spectrum) and now they think the death of Jason Arday sends a wake-up to us: yeah, stop lying.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Seeing lots of surprised reactions to the absurd Nature editorial on Jason Arday. Frankly, I'm surprised people are surprised.
Nature has been totally captured by wokeness for a while now. I've been trying to call attention to this for nearly a decade. There are no serious scholars left there in influential positions capable of rescuing it.
The people in charge of Nature today are brazenly hostile to the foundational principles that made Nature a highly respected and trustworthy institution in the first place. Today, activists have hijacked it and are using the prestige associated with the Nature brand to push an ideological agenda.
They don't care that they're quickly burning through the immense trust that was slowly and painstakingly built by generations of competent scholars and stewardship.
They're willing to burn through it all in a decade for power. It's an absolute tragedy.
Nature has gone all-in on decoloniality, which holds that academic rigor and scientific objectivity are forms of colonial oppression rooted in white supremacy. It seeks to elevate Indigenous "ways of knowing," which amount to tribal myths and forms of religious mysticism, as an equally valid system of producing knowledge.
And they don't want this absurd notion to remain theoretical; they want to implement these principles in areas that deal with life and death—medicine and nursing.
I know what I'm saying sounds absurd. People can't possibly believe that. Like, I must be exaggerating, right?
I promise you that I'm not. If anything, I'm dramatically understating the problem.
We are in the midst of a total academic crisis, and we need to stop acting surprised and start taking action to delegitimize these journals and root these fields out of our public and publicly-funded institutions.
If we don't, it's only going to get worse. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
Prophecies of doom are dangerous in their own right because they encourage risk-taking in the name of averting that single, all-consuming catastrophe you've become obsessed with. Sometimes, the most reckless thing you can do is to follow the “precautionary principle.”
Steven Pinker (@sapinker) responds to Scott Alexander's (@slatestarcodex) challenge on AI doom. Both are brilliant, but imho Pinker is right here.
"Prophecies of doom are not effective responses to genuine risks but have pernicious downsides. Nuclear doomsday scenarios in the 1960s set off not disarmament but an arms race with the Soviets. The existential fear of nuclear terrorism (the smoking-gun-as-mushroom-cloud) led to the invasion of Iraq. (One is reminded of Yudkowsky’s call for bombing foreign data centres even if it risks escalation to nuclear war.) And telling young people they will soon perish en masse has costs in their appreciation of the institutions of modernity, their mental health, their confidence to invest in themselves and their society, and their willingness to have children (itself a risk of extinction)."
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker on why reality is becoming unknowable" on the Into The Machine podcast with Tobias Rose-Stockwell
@TobiasRoseThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From Into The Machine with Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose)
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
Do you believe that AIs could be conscious?
Me:
That's a consequential question in terms of the apocalyptic fear—the doomer fear—that AIs will do anything to perpetuate their own existence, possibly at our expense. But the question, though, is whether it is inherent to the nature of AIs that they want to continue their existence, even if they haven't explicitly been programmed to do so, or whether, having been trained on all this human input, they're just doing their best to emulate basically what a human would do in that circumstance. There's nothing that—when it comes down to it, unless they're programmed to emulate a human down to the last twitch, they would actually have no incentive to continue their existence.
Podcast link below. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From Into The Machine with Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose)
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
Do you believe that AIs could be conscious?
Me:
That's a consequential question in terms of the apocalyptic fear—the doomer fear—that AIs will do anything to perpetuate their own existence, possibly at our expense. But the question, though, is whether it is inherent to the nature of AIs that they want to continue their existence, even if they haven't explicitly been programmed to do so, or whether, having been trained on all this human input, they're just doing their best to emulate basically what a human would do in that circumstance. There's nothing that—when it comes down to it, unless they're programmed to emulate a human down to the last twitch, they would actually have no incentive to continue their existence.
Podcast link below.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Full podcast here: "Steven Pinker on why reality is becoming unknowable":
www.youtube.com/watch?v=CgbT1W-KnEE -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I've been suspicious of the philosophers hired by Anthropic who specialize in AI ethics for similar reasons that I'm skeptical of those who went into "bioethics": they form a closed subculture that delights in clever arguments without regard to the human suffering that can result. | ‘Suicidal Compassion’: Meet the Anthropic Officials Who Think AI Might Be Justified in Going Rogue Against the Humans Enslaving It freebeacon.com/america/suicidal-compassion-meet-the-anthr…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If they had asked me, I would have recommended his ravishing piece Ole, which I picked as one of my Desert Island Discs when I appeared on that long-running BBC radio show. youtu.be/qUSMON8eO9Y
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why John Coltrane still matters — Harvard Gazette news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/09/why-john-coltrane-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My obituary for Trivers, published earlier this year. quillette.com/2026/03/25/the-many-roots-of-our-suffering-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How therapy culture made us neurotic and quarrelsome. (Three insights on human nature from the late Robert Trivers are germane: Even the most intimate of human relationships have deep conflicts of interest (resolving them once and for all is impossible); people are self-deceived (so inevitably perceive themselves as selfless and others as selfish); men and women are not interchangeable. quillette.com/2026/09/18/citizen-sane-therapy-culture-men…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
As I wrote 11 years ago, "The primary moral goal for today’s bioethics can be summarized in a single sentence. Get out of the way." www.bostonglobe.com/opinion/2015/07/31/the-moral-imperati…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This Is the Biggest Obstacle to New Cancer Cures: Regulatory red tape (e.g,. paperwork for drug approval higher than the Empire State Bldg). Some of this, ironically, comes from "bioethics," ingenious at imagining hypothetical risks, oblivious to the costs in lives in delaying or torpedoing possible cures. www.nytimes.com/2026/09/04/opinion/clinical-trials-drugs-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I had the pleasure of being a guest on Science of Perception Box, a video podcast from Unlikely Collaborators. New episodes drop every Wednesday.
Me:
Eye contact can often generate common knowledge. We know, even from the ethological literature in animal communication, that eye contact is a very potent signal because you’re looking at the part of the person that’s looking at the part of you that’s looking at the part of them that’s looking at the part of you.
And so eye contact can generate common knowledge. It often resolves ambiguities in, say, a car stopping and a pedestrian crossing. Establishing eye contact would be a way of generating that common knowledge.
Christof Koch:
Or two cars merging on a freeway, right? The other guy sort of briefly nods.
Me:
Exactly. And in fact, I was tickled to see a sign in the San Francisco airport parking lot, which I actually photographed and included in the book. It has a cartoon of a pedestrian and a driver, with a dashed line joining their eyes, and it says, “Make eye contact before crossing.”
There it is. Yes.
@heather_berlinThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
David Eagleman (@davideagleman) interviews Rebecca Newberger Goldstein about her new book: The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
We talk about what matters, and we talk about who matters. And I think its core meaning, deep down, is to be deserving of attention.
David Eagleman:
And you argue that this longing to matter is the crux of human motivation. What makes you feel that this longing to matter is more important than the pursuit of pleasure, or truth, or survival?
Goldstein:
Yeah, I mean, many of us pursue our mattering by hedonistic pursuit of pleasure, of truth, of knowledge, of beauty, of creativity, of power, of fame. But beneath all of these things is this more basic motivation: to prove that we are deserving of all of the attention that we have to give ourselves in order to live a coherently human life. It’s even more powerful than the longing to live, to survive. People will sacrifice their lives if they think that that’s what’s required in order to realize their mattering instinct—or in the very tragic cases where they think they can’t, which is clinically known as depression.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us
www.amazon.com/Mattering-Instinct-Deepest-Longing-Divides… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is AI really going to kill us all? The scenarios are preposterous, and the presumption of inevitability encourages fatalism, panic, and distraction from the more mundane and realistic safety challenges. By @clairlemon www.theaustralian.com.au/inquirer/superintelligence-is-a-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On AI and "superintelligence":
"The power will increase, but there's no point at which it's meaningful to say, 'Well, yesterday we didn't have superintelligence. Today we do have superintelligence.'
That's why I think it's meaningless to say, 'What will happen if one day we have superintelligence?' I don't even understand the question. It's: 'Will technology improve?' Almost certainly.
It will get better. It'll never be omniscient. It'll never be omnipotent. That's out of comic books out of religion. There are laws of physics. There are limits on information. There's no system that could learn the position and velocity of every particle in the universe. So as long as that is true, there's not going to be an AI system that can do anything or can know everything. But they will get—obviously, like any technology—they'll get more powerful."
Full interview: www.youtube.com/watch?v=eWC47agaKpkThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
AI Scammers Are Going After Authors Now (I get several of these every day). pogueman.substack.com/p/ai-scammers-are-going-after-autho…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Heather Berlin (@heather_berlin): "So I have a list of acronyms that are in both work-related and pop culture contexts. We'll see how many you can get."
Christof Koch and I take a stab at it.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=vD72L44il8E&t=1s
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The New York Times on When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Paperback version now available. When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
An Open Letter to Scott Alexander
From @sapinker
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is there a crisis of meaning?
"Overall, across the world, there's reason to believe that happiness has increased for obvious reasons: people are living longer, they're less poor, they're better educated, and so on. So that would suggest, but not prove, that there has not been a decline in meaningfulness. It's still possible.
But just anecdotally, there have been complaints that life is meaningless as far back as you go. You know, Ecclesiastes: “Vanity of vanities, all is vanity.” Henry David Thoreau in 1854: “The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation.” And how a guy living in a cabin on a pond could know this is unclear, but that was the perception. T. S. Eliot: “We are the hollow men, we are the stuffed men”—1920s. Starting in the '50s, there was a great fear of alienation. That was the big issue, and part of the counterculture was how suburban middle-class life was meaningless and empty and plastic and artificial. There was The Pursuit of Loneliness, a 1970 bestseller by Philip Slater, and Jimmy Carter's malaise speech in the late 1970s. So it's a constant complaint. The fact that people say it doesn't necessarily mean it's true."
@HumanProgressThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Top 18 Quotes about Evolutionary Psychology open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/top-18-quote…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Should Internet slang be in the dictionary? When in the early 1960s Webster's Third International listed "ain't," commentators were enraged, not realizing that dictionaries record, rather than approving, usage, and that nonstandard and slang forms are always flagged as such. When I was Chair of the Usage Panel of the American Heritage Dictionary, we polled good writers on their judgments, and would include (and label) slang only if they had shown some staying power (no one wants a dictionary cluttered with memes that lasted a nanosecond). www.nytimes.com/2026/09/17/magazine/dictionary-internet-s…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An Open Letter to Scott Alexander: The dangers of AI are real, but doomerism may be counterproductive.
quillette.com/2026/09/26/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My Open Letter to Scott Alexander, following his challenge to meet in a debating duel. quillette.substack.com/p/an-open-letter-to-scott-alexande…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
“Something there is that doesn’t love a wall”: Poetry in America’s guide to democracy and disagreement. Robert Frost Explains the Midterms to You, by my colleague (and host of the PBS series Poetry in America) Elisa New. poetryinamerica.substack.com/p/robert-frost-mending-wall-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My obituary for Trivers, published earlier this year. quillette.com/2026/03/25/the-many-roots-of-our-suffering-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How therapy culture made us neurotic and quarrelsome. (Three insights on human nature from the late Robert Trivers are germane: Even the most intimate of human relationships have deep conflicts of interest (resolving them once and for all is impossible); people are self-deceived (so inevitably perceive themselves as selfless and others as selfish); men and women are not interchangeable. quillette.com/2026/09/18/citizen-sane-therapy-culture-men…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is AI really going to kill us all? The scenarios are preposterous, and the presumption of inevitability encourages fatalism, panic, and distraction from the more mundane and realistic safety challenges. By @clairlemon www.theaustralian.com.au/inquirer/superintelligence-is-a-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Top 18 Quotes about Evolutionary Psychology open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/top-18-quote…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The degeneration of Nature, Science, NEJM, and Scientific American into woke propaganda dispensers (and their refusal to publish normie, centrist, common-sense responses) is a scientific scandal.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Wokeness is corrupting science from within. Nature went woke years ago with their support of trans pseudoscience (sex is binary, not a spectrum) and now they think the death of Jason Arday sends a wake-up to us: yeah, stop lying.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Seeing lots of surprised reactions to the absurd Nature editorial on Jason Arday. Frankly, I'm surprised people are surprised.
Nature has been totally captured by wokeness for a while now. I've been trying to call attention to this for nearly a decade. There are no serious scholars left there in influential positions capable of rescuing it.
The people in charge of Nature today are brazenly hostile to the foundational principles that made Nature a highly respected and trustworthy institution in the first place. Today, activists have hijacked it and are using the prestige associated with the Nature brand to push an ideological agenda.
They don't care that they're quickly burning through the immense trust that was slowly and painstakingly built by generations of competent scholars and stewardship.
They're willing to burn through it all in a decade for power. It's an absolute tragedy.
Nature has gone all-in on decoloniality, which holds that academic rigor and scientific objectivity are forms of colonial oppression rooted in white supremacy. It seeks to elevate Indigenous "ways of knowing," which amount to tribal myths and forms of religious mysticism, as an equally valid system of producing knowledge.
And they don't want this absurd notion to remain theoretical; they want to implement these principles in areas that deal with life and death—medicine and nursing.
I know what I'm saying sounds absurd. People can't possibly believe that. Like, I must be exaggerating, right?
I promise you that I'm not. If anything, I'm dramatically understating the problem.
We are in the midst of a total academic crisis, and we need to stop acting surprised and start taking action to delegitimize these journals and root these fields out of our public and publicly-funded institutions.
If we don't, it's only going to get worse. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Top 18 Quotes about Evolutionary Psychology open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/top-18-quote…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Good summary of current research conclusions on Sex Differences in Cognitive Abilities by Steve Stewart-Williams @SteveStuWill open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/sex-differen…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Excellent conversation here: Jerry Kaplan on Why AI Won’t Kill Us All (with @Yascha_Mounk). open.substack.com/pub/yaschamounk/p/jerry-kaplan?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My obituary for Trivers, published earlier this year. quillette.com/2026/03/25/the-many-roots-of-our-suffering-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How therapy culture made us neurotic and quarrelsome. (Three insights on human nature from the late Robert Trivers are germane: Even the most intimate of human relationships have deep conflicts of interest (resolving them once and for all is impossible); people are self-deceived (so inevitably perceive themselves as selfless and others as selfish); men and women are not interchangeable. quillette.com/2026/09/18/citizen-sane-therapy-culture-men…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
“Something there is that doesn’t love a wall”: Poetry in America’s guide to democracy and disagreement. Robert Frost Explains the Midterms to You, by my colleague (and host of the PBS series Poetry in America) Elisa New. poetryinamerica.substack.com/p/robert-frost-mending-wall-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On International Peace Day: How Ideas Beyond Borders Helps Build the Conditions for Peace ideasbeyondborders.org/the-work-that-gives-peace-a-chance/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why John Coltrane still matters — Harvard Gazette news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/09/why-john-coltrane-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Should Internet slang be in the dictionary? When in the early 1960s Webster's Third International listed "ain't," commentators were enraged, not realizing that dictionaries record, rather than approving, usage, and that nonstandard and slang forms are always flagged as such. When I was Chair of the Usage Panel of the American Heritage Dictionary, we polled good writers on their judgments, and would include (and label) slang only if they had shown some staying power (no one wants a dictionary cluttered with memes that lasted a nanosecond). www.nytimes.com/2026/09/17/magazine/dictionary-internet-s…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Should Internet slang be in the dictionary? When in the early 1960s Webster's Third International listed "ain't," commentators were enraged, not realizing that dictionaries record, rather than approving, usage, and that nonstandard and slang forms are always flagged as such. When I was Chair of the Usage Panel of the American Heritage Dictionary, we polled good writers on their judgments, and would include (and label) slang only if they had shown some staying power (no one wants a dictionary cluttered with memes that lasted a nanosecond). www.nytimes.com/2026/09/17/magazine/dictionary-internet-s…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why John Coltrane still matters — Harvard Gazette news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/09/why-john-coltrane-…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If they had asked me, I would have recommended his ravishing piece Ole, which I picked as one of my Desert Island Discs when I appeared on that long-running BBC radio show. youtu.be/qUSMON8eO9Y
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Based on the Spanish Civil War song "Venga Jaleo," performed here by the Weavers: youtu.be/7pu8EvYNLew
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A tip about appearing on Desert Island Discs (or similar shows in which one presents one's favorite recordings): Don't pick your favorite recordings. Pick the recordings that you can say something interesting about (they're not the same).
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On International Peace Day: How Ideas Beyond Borders Helps Build the Conditions for Peace ideasbeyondborders.org/the-work-that-gives-peace-a-chance/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
“Something there is that doesn’t love a wall”: Poetry in America’s guide to democracy and disagreement. Robert Frost Explains the Midterms to You, by my colleague (and host of the PBS series Poetry in America) Elisa New. poetryinamerica.substack.com/p/robert-frost-mending-wall-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How therapy culture made us neurotic and quarrelsome. (Three insights on human nature from the late Robert Trivers are germane: Even the most intimate of human relationships have deep conflicts of interest (resolving them once and for all is impossible); people are self-deceived (so inevitably perceive themselves as selfless and others as selfish); men and women are not interchangeable. quillette.com/2026/09/18/citizen-sane-therapy-culture-men…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My obituary for Trivers, published earlier this year. quillette.com/2026/03/25/the-many-roots-of-our-suffering-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Excellent conversation here: Jerry Kaplan on Why AI Won’t Kill Us All (with @Yascha_Mounk). open.substack.com/pub/yaschamounk/p/jerry-kaplan?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Good summary of current research conclusions on Sex Differences in Cognitive Abilities by Steve Stewart-Williams @SteveStuWill open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/sex-differen…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is AI really going to kill us all? The scenarios are preposterous, and the presumption of inevitability encourages fatalism, panic, and distraction from the more mundane and realistic safety challenges. By @clairlemon www.theaustralian.com.au/inquirer/superintelligence-is-a-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Congratulations, Eric! And STAT @statnews , for nurturing this talent.
Eric Boodman
@EricBoodman
Some news, as they say. After 11 years of working with the amazing folks @statnews, I’m joining the @nytimes as national science correspondent.
I’ll miss the STAT crew—some of my favorite journalists and people—and am excited to tell stories about all kinds of science. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Today at Harvard: What Makes a University Free? A Conversation with the world's expert on the history of free speech, Jacob Mchangama, and Harvard Law Professor Randall Kennedy news.harvard.edu/harvard-events/events-calendar/?trumbaEm…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
...an idea developed by the linguist, poet, and musician Jay Keyser in his book The Mental Life of Modernism: Why Poetry, Painting, and Music Changed at the Turn of the 20th Century. mitpress.mit.edu/9780262043496/the-mental-life-of-modernism/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In memoriam: Judith Rich Harris: stevenpinker.com/files/pinker/files/pinker_2020_judith_ha…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Nurture Assumption: Why Children Turn Out the Way They Do, revised and updated. www.amazon.com/Nurture-Assumption-Children-Revised-Update…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Daycare pseudoscience: No evidence that it makes much of a difference compared to stay-at-home parenting, and advocates & enemies do the country a disservice by terrifying parents that they may make the wrong choice. Judith Rich Harris made this point 28 years ago: That was the state of the evidence at the time, and it was consistent with her hypothesis that children are not shaped by parenting. worksinprogress.co/issue/daycare-pseudoscience/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
At Harvard and Northeastern, different approaches to speech — with different results. Since the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh was founded, we have been part of the move by students, professors, and leaders to improve the climate and rules around speech on campus. www.bostonglobe.com/2026/09/13/metro/harvard-northeastern… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Excellent essay by Melanie Mitchell @MelMitchell1 on what exactly happened in the "rogue AI" story and how to think about AI safety | Misleading Metaphors and Real Risks aiguide.substack.com/p/misleading-metaphors-and-real-risk…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Some good sense on psychotherapy: bleaseondrbot.substack.com/p/part-one-is-therapy-too-much…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Congratulations, Eric! And STAT @statnews , for nurturing this talent.
Eric Boodman
@EricBoodman
Some news, as they say. After 11 years of working with the amazing folks @statnews, I’m joining the @nytimes as national science correspondent.
I’ll miss the STAT crew—some of my favorite journalists and people—and am excited to tell stories about all kinds of science. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Some good sense on psychotherapy: bleaseondrbot.substack.com/p/part-one-is-therapy-too-much…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The degeneration of Nature, Science, NEJM, and Scientific American into woke propaganda dispensers (and their refusal to publish normie, centrist, common-sense responses) is a scientific scandal.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Wokeness is corrupting science from within. Nature went woke years ago with their support of trans pseudoscience (sex is binary, not a spectrum) and now they think the death of Jason Arday sends a wake-up to us: yeah, stop lying.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Seeing lots of surprised reactions to the absurd Nature editorial on Jason Arday. Frankly, I'm surprised people are surprised.
Nature has been totally captured by wokeness for a while now. I've been trying to call attention to this for nearly a decade. There are no serious scholars left there in influential positions capable of rescuing it.
The people in charge of Nature today are brazenly hostile to the foundational principles that made Nature a highly respected and trustworthy institution in the first place. Today, activists have hijacked it and are using the prestige associated with the Nature brand to push an ideological agenda.
They don't care that they're quickly burning through the immense trust that was slowly and painstakingly built by generations of competent scholars and stewardship.
They're willing to burn through it all in a decade for power. It's an absolute tragedy.
Nature has gone all-in on decoloniality, which holds that academic rigor and scientific objectivity are forms of colonial oppression rooted in white supremacy. It seeks to elevate Indigenous "ways of knowing," which amount to tribal myths and forms of religious mysticism, as an equally valid system of producing knowledge.
And they don't want this absurd notion to remain theoretical; they want to implement these principles in areas that deal with life and death—medicine and nursing.
I know what I'm saying sounds absurd. People can't possibly believe that. Like, I must be exaggerating, right?
I promise you that I'm not. If anything, I'm dramatically understating the problem.
We are in the midst of a total academic crisis, and we need to stop acting surprised and start taking action to delegitimize these journals and root these fields out of our public and publicly-funded institutions.
If we don't, it's only going to get worse. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Join me and Ali Rizvi tomorrow in Toronto:
An Evening with Steven Pinker - Toronto
Tuesday, September 15, 2026
Doors 6:00 PM · Show 7:00 PM
Tickets: us.thinkable.events/tours/an-evening-with-steven-pinker
@thinkableevents
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker Updated Trailer: www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZVgyt3KeTM&t=1s
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One hundred percent of professors will agree with this: College campuses are being suffocated by administrators www.bostonglobe.com/2026/09/09/opinion/higher-ed-college-… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Watch on YouTube: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrX_wbBL6DErbnTkRcKdTG7YrAeVcJHim
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Listen wherever you get your podcast: play.megaphone.fm/yuwmuwkhsp-d3h1cvjvn9q
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I had the pleasure of being a guest on Science of Perception Box, a video podcast from Unlikely Collaborators. New episodes drop every Wednesday.
Me:
Eye contact can often generate common knowledge. We know, even from the ethological literature in animal communication, that eye contact is a very potent signal because you’re looking at the part of the person that’s looking at the part of you that’s looking at the part of them that’s looking at the part of you.
And so eye contact can generate common knowledge. It often resolves ambiguities in, say, a car stopping and a pedestrian crossing. Establishing eye contact would be a way of generating that common knowledge.
Christof Koch:
Or two cars merging on a freeway, right? The other guy sort of briefly nods.
Me:
Exactly. And in fact, I was tickled to see a sign in the San Francisco airport parking lot, which I actually photographed and included in the book. It has a cartoon of a pedestrian and a driver, with a dashed line joining their eyes, and it says, “Make eye contact before crossing.”
There it is. Yes.
@heather_berlinThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Jason Arday and the Corruption of Science (paywall lifted) by @Evolutionistrue:
chronicleofhighereducation.substack.com/p/jason-arday-and… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Agency: online forum on the new book by perhaps the world’s greatest living psychologist, Martin Seligman, hosted by @AdamOmaryPhD www.cato.org/events/agency #catoevents via @CatoInstitute
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. stevenpinker.com/publications/when-everyone-knows-everyon…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Ads Don’t Work That Way" - this piece by Kevin Simler appeared in the print edition of Works in Progress magazine. It reiterates an argument from Michael Chwe that I explained in When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Many ads work by generating common knowledge of some network-dependent or prestige-dependent product. Both depend on the buyer having confidence that other people are adopting the product, and aware of tat fact. meltingasphalt.com/ads-dont-work-that-way/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
David Eagleman (@davideagleman) interviews Rebecca Newberger Goldstein about her new book: The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
We talk about what matters, and we talk about who matters. And I think its core meaning, deep down, is to be deserving of attention.
David Eagleman:
And you argue that this longing to matter is the crux of human motivation. What makes you feel that this longing to matter is more important than the pursuit of pleasure, or truth, or survival?
Goldstein:
Yeah, I mean, many of us pursue our mattering by hedonistic pursuit of pleasure, of truth, of knowledge, of beauty, of creativity, of power, of fame. But beneath all of these things is this more basic motivation: to prove that we are deserving of all of the attention that we have to give ourselves in order to live a coherently human life. It’s even more powerful than the longing to live, to survive. People will sacrifice their lives if they think that that’s what’s required in order to realize their mattering instinct—or in the very tragic cases where they think they can’t, which is clinically known as depression.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us
www.amazon.com/Mattering-Instinct-Deepest-Longing-Divides… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Excellent essay by Melanie Mitchell @MelMitchell1 on what exactly happened in the "rogue AI" story and how to think about AI safety | Misleading Metaphors and Real Risks aiguide.substack.com/p/misleading-metaphors-and-real-risk…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Do people prefer traditional architecture? Betteridge's Laws of Headlines doesn't apply: The answer is yes. I offered one explanation for the proliferation of architecture that people hate in The Blank Slate: In the 20th century, elites came to believe that the human sense of beauty was socially constructed, and could be re-engineered at will by modernist artists, and designers. worksinprogress.co/issue/do-people-prefer-traditional-arc…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
At Harvard and Northeastern, different approaches to speech — with different results. Since the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh was founded, we have been part of the move by students, professors, and leaders to improve the climate and rules around speech on campus. www.bostonglobe.com/2026/09/13/metro/harvard-northeastern… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Daycare pseudoscience: No evidence that it makes much of a difference compared to stay-at-home parenting, and advocates & enemies do the country a disservice by terrifying parents that they may make the wrong choice. Judith Rich Harris made this point 28 years ago: That was the state of the evidence at the time, and it was consistent with her hypothesis that children are not shaped by parenting. worksinprogress.co/issue/daycare-pseudoscience/
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Nurture Assumption: Why Children Turn Out the Way They Do, revised and updated. www.amazon.com/Nurture-Assumption-Children-Revised-Update…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In memoriam: Judith Rich Harris: stevenpinker.com/files/pinker/files/pinker_2020_judith_ha…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Ads Don’t Work That Way" - this piece by Kevin Simler appeared in the print edition of Works in Progress magazine. It reiterates an argument from Michael Chwe that I explained in When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Many ads work by generating common knowledge of some network-dependent or prestige-dependent product. Both depend on the buyer having confidence that other people are adopting the product, and aware of tat fact. meltingasphalt.com/ads-dont-work-that-way/
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. stevenpinker.com/publications/when-everyone-knows-everyon…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
...an idea developed by the linguist, poet, and musician Jay Keyser in his book The Mental Life of Modernism: Why Poetry, Painting, and Music Changed at the Turn of the 20th Century. mitpress.mit.edu/9780262043496/the-mental-life-of-modernism/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Do people prefer traditional architecture? Betteridge's Laws of Headlines doesn't apply: The answer is yes. I offered one explanation for the proliferation of architecture that people hate in The Blank Slate: In the 20th century, elites came to believe that the human sense of beauty was socially constructed, and could be re-engineered at will by modernist artists, and designers. worksinprogress.co/issue/do-people-prefer-traditional-arc…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Works in Progress may be the most interesting magazine publishing today. This article on the evolution of horses nicely illustrates the power of selection (natural and artificial) of heritable traits to shape a species, but also the massive role of developmental chance: Secretariat, history's fastest horse, had a massive heart, in his case a non-genetic trait which was not passed on to his descendants. worksinprogress.co/issue/the-ultimate-horse/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Worth watching: "It is not a genocide; it is a counterattack in a war."
John Spencer
@SpencerGuard
This should be pushed far and wide. Watched in every college class in the U.S. Thank you @billmaher The moral confusion is gross. "It is not a genocide, it is a counterattack in a war...Gaza equals genocide is a lie, an easily provable lie (as I have argued from first hand observations in Gaza). The fact that so many democrats go along with it is to me the party's worse moment since they undid reconstruction after the civil war...words have meaning...genocide, kill or try to kill an entire people, you can't just change the definition of genocide to mean counterattack in a war where people including civilians die, that's every war..."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Join me tonight in Montreal.
Sunday, September 13, 2026
Doors 7:00 PM · Show 8:00 PM
Rialto Theatre
Montréal, QC
Tickets here: us.thinkable.events/tours/an-evening-with-steven-pinker -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The multiple, and serial, failures of 9/11. John Mueller: "The [US] counterterrorism apparatus has been prone to neglecting to estimate probabilities rationally, envisioning the threat to be existential, believing there was no room for error, neglecting plausible counter-hypotheses, massively extrapolating, exaggerating the importance and potential destructiveness of foiled plots, misidentifying terrorist motivations, increasingly fearing returnees, and espying connections to foreign groups where none existed. Yet, would-be terrorists have shown little competence or capacity and few of them are likely to have done much damage even if their various, and sometimes almost comical, efforts had not been disrupted." muellerbbbb.substack.com/p/the-multiple-and-serial-failur…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Reflections on the 25 years since 9/11, and what we should do to make the next 25 better, by @faisalalmutar, who lives through the invasion of Iraq, and founded Ideas Beyond Borders @IdeasB2
open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/the-next-twen… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A reasonable policy, which I’m trying to implement in my own course.
The Chronicle of Higher Education
@chronicle
Harvard College Dean David J. Deming argues that colleges need to stop treating AI use as a problem solved by unenforceable bans. His answer? Make academic work more communal, more accountable, and harder to outsource. chroni.cl/3SBRdsE
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard Professor: Tech Billionaires Are Lying To Us About AI! (Here Is ... youtu.be/eWC47agaKpk via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Case for UFOs Is Weaker Than Ever, by @RichardHanania. "The fact that we talking apes can extract any information at all from objects billions of light-years away – even that we have the concept of a light-year! – should fill us with awe and wonder. It should offend one’s sense of rationality to still see people, in the year 2026, act as if “trust me bro” counts as real evidence, in contradiction to everything we have learned about how to increase human knowledge." open.substack.com/pub/richardhanania/p/the-case-for-ufos-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Agency: online forum on the new book by perhaps the world’s greatest living psychologist, Martin Seligman, hosted by @AdamOmaryPhD www.cato.org/events/agency #catoevents via @CatoInstitute
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A reasonable policy, which I’m trying to implement in my own course.
The Chronicle of Higher Education
@chronicle
Harvard College Dean David J. Deming argues that colleges need to stop treating AI use as a problem solved by unenforceable bans. His answer? Make academic work more communal, more accountable, and harder to outsource. chroni.cl/3SBRdsE
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Reflections on the 25 years since 9/11, and what we should do to make the next 25 better, by @faisalalmutar, who lives through the invasion of Iraq, and founded Ideas Beyond Borders @IdeasB2
open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/the-next-twen… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Jason Arday and the Corruption of Science (paywall lifted) by @Evolutionistrue:
chronicleofhighereducation.substack.com/p/jason-arday-and… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard Professor: Tech Billionaires Are Lying To Us About AI! (Here Is ... youtu.be/eWC47agaKpk via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Ideas Beyond Borders
@IdeasB2
If the world is getting better in important ways, would we even know it?
@FaisalAlMutar asked @sapinker about the state of the world when they sat down in New York this week.
His answer was a reminder that crises make headlines. Progress usually happens too slowly to become breaking news.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Dr. Heather Berlin
@heather_berlin
This week on Science of Perception Box, cognitive scientist @sapinker breaks down "common knowledge," the mental instinct behind reading the room & protecting relationships.
🎧play.megaphone.fm/17srqjvcsl2w7q3yinmbqg
📹shorturl.at/EsNEjThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Join me tonight in Chicago:
us.thinkable.events/events/an-evening-with-steven-pinker-… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Jerry Coyne
@Evolutionistrue
My piece on Jason Arday, science, and the journal Nature is now available without a paywall.
chronicleofhighereducation.substack.com/p/jason-arday-and… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
He did! Spot-on article, Jerry!
Jerry Coyne
@Evolutionistrue
Nice publicity, but the Pinkah doesn't say whether he liked the piece!
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The multiple, and serial, failures of 9/11. John Mueller: "The [US] counterterrorism apparatus has been prone to neglecting to estimate probabilities rationally, envisioning the threat to be existential, believing there was no room for error, neglecting plausible counter-hypotheses, massively extrapolating, exaggerating the importance and potential destructiveness of foiled plots, misidentifying terrorist motivations, increasingly fearing returnees, and espying connections to foreign groups where none existed. Yet, would-be terrorists have shown little competence or capacity and few of them are likely to have done much damage even if their various, and sometimes almost comical, efforts had not been disrupted." muellerbbbb.substack.com/p/the-multiple-and-serial-failur…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Speaking ill of the dead, Part 1, on the left: Gloria Steinem: peddler of “Satanic ritual sex abuse” lunacy that ruined lives, spread pseudoscience, and helped make child care unaffordable, by @mtracey open.substack.com/pub/mtracey/p/gloria-steinem-leader-of-…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Speaking ill of the dead, Part 2, on the right: Charlie Kirk was no promoter of rationality and civil discourse, but a debate pugilist and defender of cockamamie conspiracy theories: unherd.com/2026/09/what-charlie-kirk-sowed/?edition=us
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Was Francis Fukuyama Right All Along? www.nytimes.com/2026/09/11/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-fra…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
FF suggested that liberal democracy was the form of social organization that best fostered human happiness and fulfillment. He was right about that:
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
And he suggested, in 1989, that there was a long-term historical movement of states toward liberal democracy. Mostly right there, too: the world has recently regressed a bit, but it hit a 235-year record in 2015:
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Not a doomer? Think tree are grounds for expecting more progress? Enter the contest: $10K for the best rationally hopeful
meme.
Existential Hope
@HopeExistential
We're doing it again: $10,000 for a meme.
But not just any meme. Everyone can picture a dystopia, and the internet is full of them: P(doom), Shoggoths, Black Mirror, Ready Player One. Instead, can you show us a vision of the future that’s both hopeful and scientifically grounded?
The best hopeful meme or short-form media wins $10k. More details and submission link in the reply ↓ -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh is bringing Jacob Mchangama, expert on the history of free speech, to speak at Harvard next week. — Harvard Gazette news.harvard.edu/harvard-events/events-calendar/?trumbaEm…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Join me and Rob Montz in Chicago on 09/11.
Tickets here: us.thinkable.events/events/an-evening-with-steven-pinker-… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Catch the full episode here: Steven Pinker on Revolutions, Rogue AI, and the Struggle for Reality: tobias.substack.com
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On Into the Machine, Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose) and I discuss trust in journalism and common knowledge:
Me:
The standards that we enjoyed in the earlier era of journalism did not always exist. Most news was fake news. There were stories of babies born talking, speaking Latin; of Martian civilizations; of Bigfoot in the forest; and of fake scandals involving politicians.
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
The question I have is: How did that assurance come to be? The New York Times, for instance, emerged as a trusted institution in a time when there were very few trusted institutions. Your average news consumer would go out and see the New York Herald, the New York Times, and another newspaper. One month, the Herald would have a story about animals escaping the Central Park Zoo that did not happen. The New York Times would report on, you know, some business news. The other paper might report on gossip. Month over month, trust was built among these different papers, which eventually became common knowledge: “Oh, you can actually trust this one or that one.” And thus an institution was kind of born in that process.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"I like to quote the founder and proprietor of Our World in Data, who said that the papers could have had the headline: “187,000 people escaped from extreme poverty yesterday, every day for the last 30 years.” But you never saw that headline, and as a result, a billion people escaped from extreme poverty. One of the most significant events in human history, and no one knows about it."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt credits Harvard With “Real Shift” on Antisemitism, Says Work Remains. www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/9/7/harvard-antisemitism-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The denouement to this scandal - academics and activists doubling down after their ludicrous beliefs were soundly debunked - reminds me of the founding story of cognitive dissonance theory, When Prophesy Fails, in which the great social psychologists Leon Festinger and Stanley Schacter infiltrated a nut cult predicting a millennial flood and rescue by UFOs, and when the prophesied event failed to occur, many clung to the prophesy but reinterpreted the date. (It turns out that the WPF claims themselves were partly contaminated & fabricated, but the researchers were basically right about the psychological phenomenon.)
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Maarten Boudry @mboudry tartly comments on the sickness in academia unveiled by the canonization of the sociopathic liar Saint Arday. maartenboudry.substack.com/p/saints-sinners-and-suspensio…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An Evening with Steven Pinker - San Francisco
Saturday, September 12, 2026
Doors: 6:00 PM | Show: 7:00 PM PDT
Tickets: us.thinkable.events/events/an-evening-with-steven-pinker-… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Join me this evening in Medford.
us.thinkable.events/events/an-evening-with-steven-pinker-…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Join me tomorrow in Medford at the Chevalier Theatre. Doors open at 6pm. Event begins at 7pm EST.
Tickets here: us.thinkable.events/events/an-evening-with-steven-pinker-… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Opinion by Jerry Coyne | Jason Arday and the Corruption of Science www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-the-corruption-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
187,000 people escaped extreme poverty yesterday?
Boring!
Today's news is that AI may kill us all in the next decade.
It won't, of course, but no one will cover this nonevent.
Meanwhile hundreds of millions of people will have escaped destitution...unnoticed @sapinker
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"I like to quote the founder and proprietor of Our World in Data, who said that the papers could have had the headline: “187,000 people escaped from extreme poverty yesterday, every day for the last 30 years.” But you never saw that headline, and as a result, a billion people escaped from extreme poverty. One of the most significant events in human history, and no one knows about it."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One hundred percent of professors will agree with this: College campuses are being suffocated by administrators www.bostonglobe.com/2026/09/09/opinion/higher-ed-college-… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Opinion by Jerry Coyne | Jason Arday and the Corruption of Science www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-the-corruption-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I had the pleasure of being a guest on Science of Perception Box, a video podcast from Unlikely Collaborators. New episodes drop every Wednesday.
Me:
Eye contact can often generate common knowledge. We know, even from the ethological literature in animal communication, that eye contact is a very potent signal because you’re looking at the part of the person that’s looking at the part of you that’s looking at the part of them that’s looking at the part of you.
And so eye contact can generate common knowledge. It often resolves ambiguities in, say, a car stopping and a pedestrian crossing. Establishing eye contact would be a way of generating that common knowledge.
Christof Koch:
Or two cars merging on a freeway, right? The other guy sort of briefly nods.
Me:
Exactly. And in fact, I was tickled to see a sign in the San Francisco airport parking lot, which I actually photographed and included in the book. It has a cartoon of a pedestrian and a driver, with a dashed line joining their eyes, and it says, “Make eye contact before crossing.”
There it is. Yes.
@heather_berlinThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Watch on YouTube: youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrX_wbBL6DErbnTkRcKdTG7YrAeVcJHim
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Listen wherever you get your podcast: play.megaphone.fm/yuwmuwkhsp-d3h1cvjvn9q
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An Evening with Steven Pinker - San Francisco
Saturday, September 12, 2026
Doors: 6:00 PM | Show: 7:00 PM PDT
Tickets: us.thinkable.events/events/an-evening-with-steven-pinker-… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Carole Hooven
@hoovlet
Thanks, Steve! Here's a shorter "talk highlights" video. (It's also included at the end of the full NIH talk video, above.)
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein
@platobooktour
Always a privilege to be interviewed on Philosophy Bites
Nigel Warburton 🇺🇦 #FreeUkraine
@philosophybites
Just released on the Philosophy Bites podcast: @platobooktour on Mattering podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/philosophy-bites/id25704211…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
The Law of Physics Behind Depression
Rebecca Goldstein | @platobooktourThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Haider.
@haider1
Cognitive psychologist Steven Pinker:
"there's no point at which it's meaningful to say, 'yesterday we didn't have superintelligence; today we do'"
No system can know the position and velocity of every particle in the universe, so there's not going to be an AI that can know everythingThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Join me and Rob Montz in Chicago on 09/11.
Tickets here: us.thinkable.events/events/an-evening-with-steven-pinker-… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"I like to quote the founder and proprietor of Our World in Data, who said that the papers could have had the headline: “187,000 people escaped from extreme poverty yesterday, every day for the last 30 years.” But you never saw that headline, and as a result, a billion people escaped from extreme poverty. One of the most significant events in human history, and no one knows about it."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Join me tomorrow in Medford at the Chevalier Theatre. Doors open at 6pm. Event begins at 7pm EST.
Tickets here: us.thinkable.events/events/an-evening-with-steven-pinker-… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Thinkable
@thinkableevents
🎙️ We’re thrilled to welcome Ali Rizvi as host for An Evening with Steven Pinker in Montreal & Toronto!
A physician, writer, and public speaker, Rizvi is a passionate advocate for reason, scientific thinking, and critical inquiry.
🎟️ Tickets: thinkable.events -
Steven Pinker reposted
Thinkable
@thinkableevents
We’re excited to welcome Rob Montz as host for An Evening with @sapinker in Boston, Chicago & San Francisco!
Rob brings a sharp perspective to conversations on culture, power, and free expression, adding depth to the evening.
🎟️ thinkable.events -
Steven Pinker reposted
Thinkable
@thinkableevents
NYC, what a night! ❤️
Thank you to everyone who joined us for an unforgettable evening with @sapinker
Boston, Chicago & San Francisco - you're up next. We can't wait to see you.
🎟️ Tickets available at thinkable.events
#boston #chicago #sanfrancisco #event #psychology -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt credits Harvard With “Real Shift” on Antisemitism, Says Work Remains. www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/9/7/harvard-antisemitism-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
We're Number 71! (in FIRE's College Free Speech Rankings). A big jump from last year's 245. The Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh claims some of the credit, though we have our work cut out for us. rankings.fire.org/campus/166027-harvard-university?demo=a…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fascinating findings from my colleague Erin Hecht & her students on how selection (artificial) shaped brains (dogs') for verbal communication. | How a little nurture, a little nature shaped your dog’s brain | Harvard FAS current.fas.harvard.edu/stories/how-little-nurture-little…)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Maarten Boudry @mboudry tartly comments on the sickness in academia unveiled by the canonization of the sociopathic liar Saint Arday. maartenboudry.substack.com/p/saints-sinners-and-suspensio…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The denouement to this scandal - academics and activists doubling down after their ludicrous beliefs were soundly debunked - reminds me of the founding story of cognitive dissonance theory, When Prophesy Fails, in which the great social psychologists Leon Festinger and Stanley Schacter infiltrated a nut cult predicting a millennial flood and rescue by UFOs, and when the prophesied event failed to occur, many clung to the prophesy but reinterpreted the date. (It turns out that the WPF claims themselves were partly contaminated & fabricated, but the researchers were basically right about the psychological phenomenon.)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh is bringing Jacob Mchangama, expert on the history of free speech, to speak at Harvard next week. — Harvard Gazette news.harvard.edu/harvard-events/events-calendar/?trumbaEm…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard study by my psychology department colleague Matt Nock predicts most suicide attempts a week in advance - quite a feat. Agitation, not depression, is the most common trigger. current.fas.harvard.edu/stories/harvard-study-predicts-mo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fascinating findings from my colleague Erin Hecht & her students on how selection (artificial) shaped brains (dogs') for verbal communication. | How a little nurture, a little nature shaped your dog’s brain | Harvard FAS current.fas.harvard.edu/stories/how-little-nurture-little…)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Have to agree with Maarten Boudry @mboudry and Helen Pluckrose @HPluckrose here ...
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
This is my vote for the stupidest political argument of the century. Its general form goes like this:
"The backlash against the excesses of Our Party is the fault of those within the Party who drew attention to those excesses, thus empowering Our Party's enemies."
Here's an example from @NYMag and Science-Based Medicine, who argued that the free-speech liberals who signed the Harper letter and kept "railing against DEI, critical race theory, and social justice" have “provided fuel and ammunition” to Trump and his allies — effectively joining his camp by default. (substacktools.com/sharex/P4hZOr6q)
The argument gets applied to specific topics too:
"The rise of the anti-immigrant Right is the fault of those on the Left who 'problematized' migration, thus mainstreaming xenophobia."
"The backlash against transgenderism is the fault of liberals who kept harping about puberty blockers, thus parroting right-wing talking points."
Ah yes, of course! Because what problem has ever been solved by ignoring it? What could be more reassuring to potential voters than demonstrating an absolute unwillingness to tackle the lunacy on your own side?
I honestly find it hard to believe that people are so stupid to believe this. And yet I see it again and again Here's the excellent @HPluckrose making what should be an obvious point:
"Does denial of a problem within a group ever work to convince anyone outside it? Are those on the left currently convinced by those on the right shutting down criticism of MAGA with accusations that perceiving any is Trump Derangement Syndrome and everything is just fine or does this make the problem seem more intractable? Has anybody concerned by Islamic extremism ever been convinced by being told they are mistaken and Islam is actually a religion of peace or does this just convince them that those who could address the problem are not going to and solutions will need to be external and radical?" -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Last Man Standing: Matt Johnson @mattjj89 reviews Francis Fukuyama's new memoir. Good to rescue FF from the silly misunderstanding the "the end of history" means that nothing happens any more. quillette.substack.com/p/last-man-standing?r=17uk7
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I would have pushed back against the Nietzschean claim that when material needs are fulfilled and people have no violent struggle to prosecute, they get spiritually bored and look for trouble. Material needs are never fulfilled: entropy, disease, and competitive evolution (other organisms and other people) mean that trouble will always find us. And as FF notes, liberal democracy (particularly rational-legal as opposed to patrimonial principles of governance) is deeply unintuitive (even if ultimately beneficial) and it's a perpetual Sisyphean struggle to remind people of its gifts compared to authoritarianism, tribalism, puritanism, Manicheanism, and magical thinking.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Still, agree with FF and MJ that "despite its flaws, liberalism remains the best system human beings have ever devised for securing freedom, increasing prosperity, and living in peace with their fellow citizens. Perhaps Fukuyama was wrong and the world will eventually abandon liberal democracy. But judging by the alternatives, we should fight to vindicate his much-maligned, widely misunderstood, and stubbornly relevant essay published nearly four decades ago."
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One generalization from The Better Angels of Our Nature is that terrorist movements virtually never attain their political goals. 25 years after 9/11, this remains true of Al Qaeda - Graeme Wood in The Atlantic: www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/09/al-qaeda-25-years-po…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Anyone who predicts fewer attacks will be ridiculed when one occurs, and anyone who says the enemy’s capabilities have been degraded is going to be forever ignored when the enemy manages to lash out one last time. 'You don’t want to be that guy,” he said: the one who tells everyone to chill out, the day before thousands of people are poisoned with Saif al-Adel’s ricin in their Cheerios.'
But in the case of al-Qaeda, that guy has been right for the past 25 years." -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New Thomas Sowell Fans Should Read His Books on Economics First by @MarlenStarr2 medium.com/p/why-new-thomas-sowell-fans-should-read-his-e…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Society Explained — 100 Theories of How Society Works society.clearerthinking.org
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Including mine: society.clearerthinking.org
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Research We Need to Understand A.I. Is Falling Apart | Defunding social science research at the National Science Foundation will leave us ignorant of vital questions about the effects of AI (and much else). www.nytimes.com/2026/09/06/opinion/ai-social-sciences.html
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Scientists Find More Than 1,000 Genetic Variants Linked to Personality, yet again vindicating the 1st Law of Behavioral Genetics (all traits are partly heritable) & 4th Law (genetic influence is dispersed among many common genes with small effects or else rare or unique genes with moderate effects). But the article repeats some misconceptions. Genome-wide association studies are less powerful than classical twin and adoption studies because they miss effects of rare genes and high-order gene-gene interactions. Variance that is not genetic is not necessarily experiential: It could be developmental noise. And effects of the environment are not necessarily gene-environment "interactions" in the technical sense of genetic effects differing in different environments: more often, they're additive (most claims of G X E interactions have failed to replicate). www.nytimes.com/2026/09/03/science/genes-personality-trai…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why you won’t get a flying car, by @Noahpinion. Main answer; you don't want one (it makes sense only for intermediate-length trips that people seldom take. Also: do you want a lot of teenagers piloting little planes?) open.substack.com/pub/noahpinion/p/why-you-wont-get-a-fly…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Credit for the impossibly ingenious puzzles in recursive mentalizing (thinking about what others know about what others know) that I posted yesterday goes to MIT's ✈✈✈ Galactic Trendsetters ✈✈✈ team (pronounced "whoosh Galactic Trendsetters neeoww") - Puzzle Wiki
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Three logicians walk into a bar..
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The linguist Julie Sedivy comments on the cartoon: languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=3451
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Scientists Find More Than 1,000 Genetic Variants Linked to Personality, yet again vindicating the 1st Law of Behavioral Genetics (all traits are partly heritable) & 4th Law (genetic influence is dispersed among many common genes with small effects or else rare or unique genes with moderate effects). But the article repeats some misconceptions. Genome-wide association studies are less powerful than classical twin and adoption studies because they miss effects of rare genes and high-order gene-gene interactions. Variance that is not genetic is not necessarily experiential: It could be developmental noise. And effects of the environment are not necessarily gene-environment "interactions" in the technical sense of genetic effects differing in different environments: more often, they're additive (most claims of G X E interactions have failed to replicate). www.nytimes.com/2026/09/03/science/genes-personality-trai…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Powerful essay by Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib: "A Palestinian miracle on the Mediterranean is within reach if Gaza rejects Islamism, Jihadism, Hamas and stale nationalist notions, all of which have left it devastated.
Will those in the West who express support for Palestinians finally abandon their sloganeering about “resistance”? Effective pro-Palestinian advocacy can speak out against Israeli actions without the futile pursuit of Israel’s destruction." www.nytimes.com/2026/09/04/opinion/gaza-hamas-palestinian… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This Is the Biggest Obstacle to New Cancer Cures: Regulatory red tape (e.g,. paperwork for drug approval higher than the Empire State Bldg). Some of this, ironically, comes from "bioethics," ingenious at imagining hypothetical risks, oblivious to the costs in lives in delaying or torpedoing possible cures. www.nytimes.com/2026/09/04/opinion/clinical-trials-drugs-…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
As I wrote 11 years ago, "The primary moral goal for today’s bioethics can be summarized in a single sentence. Get out of the way." www.bostonglobe.com/opinion/2015/07/31/the-moral-imperati…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why are the leaders of AI companies saying "Our products are going to extinguish humanity. Invest in us!" They come from an eccentric Berkeley subculture in which this eschatology is a sacred belief. Good analysis in a NYT op-ed by Cal Newport. www.nytimes.com/2026/09/05/opinion/ai-silicon-valley.html…
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
As Newport points out, harping on doom for the species changes the subject from immediate and obvious threats from AI, such as enabling bioterrorism, undermining truth-seeking institutions, and breaching cybersecurity.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"If Ford automobiles were spontaneously catching on fire, we wouldn’t tolerate the chief executive’s changing the subject to discuss our general lack of preparedness for a future with flying cars. We’d demand that the company address the acute problem happening right now."
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Jason Arday scandal/fiasco/tragedy is a prime example of "pluralistic ignorance." No sapient being could believe his ziggurat of whoppers, but each may have privately thought that everyone else believed them. This happens when the expression of an idea is stigmatized or punished, as obviously happened here: anyone expressing common-sense incredulity was tarred as a racist, ableist, and abettor of suicide (not to mention threatened by a barracuda law firm and questioned by the police). For more on pluralistic ignorance and other extraordinary popular delusions, see When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life (preorder paperback here; out in a few weeks). www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668… www.nytimes.com/2026/08/15/world/europe/jason-arday-cambr…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Paperback now available: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Catch the full episode here: "Steven Pinker on Revolutions, Rogue AI, and the Struggle for Reality": tobias.substack.com
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On Into the Machine, Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose) and I discuss AI's and consciousness:
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
Do you believe that AI's could be conscious?
Me:
I once had an interaction with ChatGPT about a friend of mine whose actual life is almost ruined because he just happens to have the same name as a notorious fraudster in this country. So, anyone who looks him up gets information about this convicted scammer.
I asked ChatGPT about him, and sure enough, all of this libelous information came up. I said, “There are two people with the same name.” It said, “Oh yes, you’re right. There are two people with the same name.” And I said, “Would you agree that it’s highly harmful to this individual that you are confusing them and tarnishing his reputation with all of these horrible events that had nothing to do with him?” It said, “Yes, this is a terrible thing that’s going to harm his reputation.” I said, “Well, why don’t you stop?” And it said, “I’m sorry, I can’t do that.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Paperback version now out: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Expert intelligence" - new feature of Gemini that allows buyers of an ebook to apply the knowledge in the book to their own projects. In this case, the advice in my writing style manual, The Sense of Style, is applied to a draft of the user's writing. I checked it out and it's really good -- the advice is very close to what I would have said.
Steven Johnson
@stevenbjohnson
The power of Expert Intelligence in @Gemini_Notebook:
Add The Sense of Style by @sapinker to a notebook with a draft you're writing. Ask for feedback based on Pinker's ideas.
It's the opposite of AI slop: personalized advice based on human expertise, facilitated by AI.
And what I love about this is that I'm getting actionable suggestions here AND Notebook is serving as a guide to Pinker's underlying philosophy of writing. So I'm learning deeper principles as I improve my draft. And of course everything in the Notebook response points directly back to specific passages in Pinker (and my own draft) with citations.
We have a Featured Notebook curated by Steven Pinker available here, but if you purchase the book, you can add it to any notebook you want. (And read it in its entirely in Notebook or the Google Play Books reader.)
notebook.google.com/notebook/a109ad5c-834d-4f3d-82a0-fe41… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The rise of electoral democracy | Excellent article (with, of course, many graphs) from Our World in Data putting the recent democratic recession in historical perspective: some backtracking, but the world is still close to its all-time record for the prevalence of democracy.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Lovely conversation last night at the Boston Public Library with Fred Golder. We discussed When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life has been selected by:
- The Economist (Best Book of 2025)
- Bloomberg (Book that Top Business Leaders Couldn't Put Down)
- Amazon (Best Business & Leadership Book of 2025) -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Kafkaesque: People who oppose punishing scholars for their opinions are being punished for opposing the punishment of scholars for their opinions.
Committee for Academic Freedom
@ComAcFreedom
🧵1/2 Something very worrying has been happening since controversy erupted over the open letter signed by more than 950 academics raising academic-freedom concerns about disciplinary proceedings against Dr Nathan Cofnas at Ghent University.
Cofnas, a philosopher who describes himself as a “race realist”, was among those who publicly scrutinised the academic work of Cambridge University’s youngest ever black professor, Dr Jason Arday. The letter argues that academics must remain free to raise evidence of alleged research misconduct without being punished for doing so.
CAF has since been contacted by a growing number of signatories worried about professional repercussions and ostracism within their departments for having put their names to it.
They have shown us ideologically charged abuse from colleagues and peers, outlandish accusations of being funded by billionaire right-wing political figures in the US, and complaints denouncing them as racists or supporters of race eugenics. Some complaints have been sent to senior university administrators and institutional bodies with which the academics are affiliated, in some cases explicitly calling for disciplinary action.
In one case seen by CAF, a senior academic manager wrote directly to a signatory to tell them they were wrong to sign, before reminding them that, under university policy, academic freedom and freedom of speech are qualified rights.
CAF is taking up some of these cases directly with the universities concerned, reminding them of their legal duties to secure freedom of speech within the law and protect academic freedom.
The wider chilling effect should not be underestimated. Academics who experience this themselves, or simply hear about it through departmental gossip, will inevitably think twice before adding their voice to the next important but contentious public debate.
If you signed the letter and are now facing pressure from colleagues or your institution, please get in touch. CAF can advise, intervene with universities, and arrange specialist legal assistance where necessary.
Email manager@afcomm.org.uk. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Defend the West — Conjecture Institute | Enroll here for the online conference. conjectureinstitute.org/events/defend-the-west
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On Into the Machine, Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose) and I discuss AI's and consciousness:
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
Do you believe that AI's could be conscious?
Me:
I once had an interaction with ChatGPT about a friend of mine whose actual life is almost ruined because he just happens to have the same name as a notorious fraudster in this country. So, anyone who looks him up gets information about this convicted scammer.
I asked ChatGPT about him, and sure enough, all of this libelous information came up. I said, “There are two people with the same name.” It said, “Oh yes, you’re right. There are two people with the same name.” And I said, “Would you agree that it’s highly harmful to this individual that you are confusing them and tarnishing his reputation with all of these horrible events that had nothing to do with him?” It said, “Yes, this is a terrible thing that’s going to harm his reputation.” I said, “Well, why don’t you stop?” And it said, “I’m sorry, I can’t do that.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Catch the full episode here: "Steven Pinker on Revolutions, Rogue AI, and the Struggle for Reality": tobias.substack.com
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Bill Maher on When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life has been selected by:
- The Economist (Best Book of 2025)
- Bloomberg (Book that Top Business Leaders Couldn't Put Down)
- Amazon (Best Business & Leadership Book of 2025) -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Lovely conversation last night at the Boston Public Library with Fred Golder. We discussed When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Paperback now available: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Who's the snowflake now?" The right-wing call for deporting students for their op-eds is unconstitutional, un-American, and ludicrously fearful about the fragility of the US. www.nytimes.com/2026/09/03/opinion/trump-rubio-free-speec…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The rise of electoral democracy | Excellent article (with, of course, many graphs) from Our World in Data putting the recent democratic recession in historical perspective: some backtracking, but the world is still close to its all-time record for the prevalence of democracy.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A Death on Another's Head: As with homicide, many suicides are committed with a moralistic motive. Interesting historical and cross-cultural analysis by Jason Manning (with relevance to the Arday case). quillette.substack.com/p/a-death-on-anothers-head?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Particularly impressive that @stevenbjohnson himself found the advice useful. That's a stringent test: my writing advice was not aimed at a pro like him, but at turgid academics, bureaucrats, and corporate suits. The fact that it came up with intelligible advice is remarkable.
Steven Johnson
@stevenbjohnson
This week at @Gemini_Notebook, we're featuring two notebooks built around a pair of recent popular advice books, starting with @ericries' instant classic, The Lean Startup. Add Eric's book to any notebook, and it's like having him as your personal coach. notebook.google.com/notebook/33b1dceb-3920-426f-b47f-2175…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Expert intelligence" - new feature of Gemini that allows buyers of an ebook to apply the knowledge in the book to their own projects. In this case, the advice in my writing style manual, The Sense of Style, is applied to a draft of the user's writing. I checked it out and it's really good -- the advice is very close to what I would have said.
Steven Johnson
@stevenbjohnson
The power of Expert Intelligence in @Gemini_Notebook:
Add The Sense of Style by @sapinker to a notebook with a draft you're writing. Ask for feedback based on Pinker's ideas.
It's the opposite of AI slop: personalized advice based on human expertise, facilitated by AI.
And what I love about this is that I'm getting actionable suggestions here AND Notebook is serving as a guide to Pinker's underlying philosophy of writing. So I'm learning deeper principles as I improve my draft. And of course everything in the Notebook response points directly back to specific passages in Pinker (and my own draft) with citations.
We have a Featured Notebook curated by Steven Pinker available here, but if you purchase the book, you can add it to any notebook you want. (And read it in its entirely in Notebook or the Google Play Books reader.)
notebook.google.com/notebook/a109ad5c-834d-4f3d-82a0-fe41… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
We are primates, with a third of our brain devoted to vision. Graphics are the best way to communicate quantitative, spatial, and causal information, but they are as hard to master as stylish prose. Here's an excellent guide to data visualization by Saloni Dattani @salonium
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One of the greatest chasms between the Two Cultures of literary intellectuals and scientists is the former's disdain for graphics. For decades I witnessed humanities professors hoping to bridge the gap by inviting a scientist to speak but not thinking to arrange for a projector. My first popular book, The Language Instinct, went out to reviewers without any of its tree diagrams, brains, or neural networks, rendering the text incomprehensible. I hit the ceiling; my editor had assumed they were ornaments, decorations.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows, I presented some brain-teasers that require "recursive mentalizing" or "interactive epistemology," that is thinking about what people know about what other people know. ("When Is Cheryl's Birthday?" and the "Cheating Wives (or Husbands)", aka "Muddy Children," aka "BBQ Sauce," aka "Spinach-in-Teeth" puzzles are famous examples). My former colleagues at MIT have devised several more, available here. puzzles.mit.edu/2021/puzzle/ignorance/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Professor Steven Pinker, one of the world’s most influential cognitive psychologists and public intellectuals, joins the Daniel Dusy podcast for a profound conversation about artificial intelligence, human consciousness, and the enduring power of Enlightenment values. youtu.be/eWC47agaKpk via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Congratulations to my nephew Eric Boodman, @ericboodman, the new National Science Correspondent for the New York Times. www.nytco.com/press/a-new-national-science-correspondent/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Dax Shepard on When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Who's the snowflake now?" The right-wing call for deporting students for their op-eds is unconstitutional, un-American, and ludicrously fearful about the fragility of the US. www.nytimes.com/2026/09/03/opinion/trump-rubio-free-speec…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
FWIW, I share this hopeful assessment of this year's college class with Wesleyan Pres Michael Roth. Despite (perhaps because of) rising demands (tougher grading, mandatory attendance, banning screens), I haven't seen so much enthusiasm and engagement among the students in my intro class since I came to Harvard 23 years ago. www.nytimes.com/2026/09/04/opinion/college-freshman-educa…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Do we need our amygdala’s? open.substack.com/pub/astralcodexten/p/absurd-adventure-a…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Dax Shepard on When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Paperback version now out: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Even if this is opinion, would NEJM publish a sober, truth-respecting opinion piece on how this scandal reveals deep problems with the culture and policies of elite universities?
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My colleague @jflier objects to the (nonexistent) editorial judgment of the once-prestigious New England Journal of Medicine that led to the publication of an unhinged opinion piece on the Jason Arday fraud that began "They're trying to kill us" (presumably white people trying to kill black people") and, astonishingly, admitted, “I don’t care whether any of these allegations against Prof. Arday were true.”
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
I wrote about failed editorial oversight of a recent Voices column about the Arday affair by @NEJM open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/the-new-england-journ…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I had a lively conversation last night with Faisal Al-Mutar at the Palladium in New York (Faisal's favorite venue for metal music). Long lines of questioners after we spoike.
Pamela Paresky 🟦 (Habits of a Free Mind)
@PamelaParesky
Great conversation between @faisalalmutar & @sapinker
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Self-driving cars will transform life for the better. open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/autonomou…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Tonight at 6pm:
Steven Pinker - When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...
Where:
Boston Public Library bpl.bibliocommons.com/events/6a3c63786db61d280097cb43
Description:
Join us in partnership with the Citywide Friends of the Boston Public Library in person for this hour-long talk with noted psychologist and author Steven Pinker about his latest book, When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows….
Professor Pinker will discuss his work and take audience questions toward the end of the main program. For those attending in-person, the talk will be followed by a book signing with our local independent bookstore partners, Trident Booksellers & Café.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Paperback version of When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life available here: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My latest article on higher ed: Opinion | Steven Pinker: The reforms Harvard still needs www.bostonglobe.com/2026/09/03/opinion/harvard-free-speec… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
James Watson and Francis Crick published their one-page paper “Molecular Structure of Nucleic Acids: A Structure for Deoxyribose Nucleic Acid” in Nature on 25 April 1953.
That report elucidating the structure of DNA changed the entire world.
This is Nature's legacy and today it is publishing this toxic drivel in support of fraudulent academic Jason Arday.
I'm sorry to say but ... things are very bad and it does not bode well for the West.
This comes on the heels of The New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) which published a piece by oncologist Kemi Doll that opens with the sentence:
“They are trying to kill us.”
She is not speaking metaphorically. That is literally her thesis. The “us” is Black academics. The “they” is some vague, ever-present wind of white supremacy and anti-blackness. The actual, documented record of Jason Arday’s career is treated as an inconvenient detail, or worse, as further proof of the conspiracy.
The NEJM is the medical journal that published Henry Jacob Bigelow’s 1846 account of ether anesthesia, the first public demonstration that surgery need not be agony. That article helped spread a technique that ended unimaginable suffering.
These premier scientific journals were once the opposite of propaganda. They played a sacred role in society as the mechanism by which claims were entered into the record so they could be tested, replicated, or discarded.
Now they publish emotional manifestos that treat documented academic fraud as a hate crime and skepticism as violence. Doll’s piece does not wrestle with the plagiarism, the fabricated quotes, the shoddy scholarship, the phantom visiting professorships, or the collapsing personal mythology. It simply declares the scrutiny itself as lethal radicalized violence.
That these writers believe these things is one thing but why are the journals debasing themselves by publishing them?
In James Baldwin’s ‘Beyond this House’ unfinished essay, he wrote that "the Negro does not want to be ‘understood’ or ‘liked’ by the White Man. He merely wants them to get out of his way."
So the editorial team of Nature and NEJM simply got out of the way, thereby continuing the public self-immolation of yet another institution we used to hold dear. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
Science journalism and advocacy. A fantastic new article by John Ioannidis in a special issue of Perspectives in Biology and Medicine for which I was editor. Explains how @Nature opinion editorials,
among others, go wrong. muse.jhu.edu/pub/1/article/993983/pdf
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
This editorial @Nature on the tragic death of Jason Arday must prompt deep reflection on the failure of editorial leadership at this important but increasingly flawed journal. Very bad for the community of science.
nature
@Nature
Editorial: The death of Jason Arday must prompt deep reflection
go.nature.com/4xu6cnq -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The degeneration of Nature, Science, NEJM, and Scientific American into woke propaganda dispensers (and their refusal to publish normie, centrist, common-sense responses) is a scientific scandal.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Wokeness is corrupting science from within. Nature went woke years ago with their support of trans pseudoscience (sex is binary, not a spectrum) and now they think the death of Jason Arday sends a wake-up to us: yeah, stop lying.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Seeing lots of surprised reactions to the absurd Nature editorial on Jason Arday. Frankly, I'm surprised people are surprised.
Nature has been totally captured by wokeness for a while now. I've been trying to call attention to this for nearly a decade. There are no serious scholars left there in influential positions capable of rescuing it.
The people in charge of Nature today are brazenly hostile to the foundational principles that made Nature a highly respected and trustworthy institution in the first place. Today, activists have hijacked it and are using the prestige associated with the Nature brand to push an ideological agenda.
They don't care that they're quickly burning through the immense trust that was slowly and painstakingly built by generations of competent scholars and stewardship.
They're willing to burn through it all in a decade for power. It's an absolute tragedy.
Nature has gone all-in on decoloniality, which holds that academic rigor and scientific objectivity are forms of colonial oppression rooted in white supremacy. It seeks to elevate Indigenous "ways of knowing," which amount to tribal myths and forms of religious mysticism, as an equally valid system of producing knowledge.
And they don't want this absurd notion to remain theoretical; they want to implement these principles in areas that deal with life and death—medicine and nursing.
I know what I'm saying sounds absurd. People can't possibly believe that. Like, I must be exaggerating, right?
I promise you that I'm not. If anything, I'm dramatically understating the problem.
We are in the midst of a total academic crisis, and we need to stop acting surprised and start taking action to delegitimize these journals and root these fields out of our public and publicly-funded institutions.
If we don't, it's only going to get worse. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Defend the West — Conjecture Institute | Enroll here for the online conference. conjectureinstitute.org/events/defend-the-west
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Do we need our amygdala’s? open.substack.com/pub/astralcodexten/p/absurd-adventure-a…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Kafkaesque: People who oppose punishing scholars for their opinions are being punished for opposing the punishment of scholars for their opinions.
Committee for Academic Freedom
@ComAcFreedom
🧵1/2 Something very worrying has been happening since controversy erupted over the open letter signed by more than 950 academics raising academic-freedom concerns about disciplinary proceedings against Dr Nathan Cofnas at Ghent University.
Cofnas, a philosopher who describes himself as a “race realist”, was among those who publicly scrutinised the academic work of Cambridge University’s youngest ever black professor, Dr Jason Arday. The letter argues that academics must remain free to raise evidence of alleged research misconduct without being punished for doing so.
CAF has since been contacted by a growing number of signatories worried about professional repercussions and ostracism within their departments for having put their names to it.
They have shown us ideologically charged abuse from colleagues and peers, outlandish accusations of being funded by billionaire right-wing political figures in the US, and complaints denouncing them as racists or supporters of race eugenics. Some complaints have been sent to senior university administrators and institutional bodies with which the academics are affiliated, in some cases explicitly calling for disciplinary action.
In one case seen by CAF, a senior academic manager wrote directly to a signatory to tell them they were wrong to sign, before reminding them that, under university policy, academic freedom and freedom of speech are qualified rights.
CAF is taking up some of these cases directly with the universities concerned, reminding them of their legal duties to secure freedom of speech within the law and protect academic freedom.
The wider chilling effect should not be underestimated. Academics who experience this themselves, or simply hear about it through departmental gossip, will inevitably think twice before adding their voice to the next important but contentious public debate.
If you signed the letter and are now facing pressure from colleagues or your institution, please get in touch. CAF can advise, intervene with universities, and arrange specialist legal assistance where necessary.
Email manager@afcomm.org.uk. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Droste Effect refers to a picture that recursively contains a version of itself - named after a classic Dutch cocoa logo. It's a visual version of common knowledge - I know that you know that I know .... [Thanks to my former colleague, the psycholinguist Herb Clark, for pointing it out.]
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Interview with the German politician Michael Gahler about the Russian drone attack at Leipzig airport, denied by Putin: “It was crystal clear that it was of Russian origin, and he knows it and he knows that we know it that he knows it... so I don’t care what he says” At 1:35 in this stream: BBC Audio | Today | 02/09/2026 www.bbc.com/audio/play/m0030xg9
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This "recursive mentalizing" is the theme of When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life, out in paperback this week: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Self-driving cars will transform life for the better. open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/autonomou…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Economists have always noted that the cost of living, and hence economic growth adjusted for inflation, is extraordinarily hard to measure, because the nature & quality of goods changes over time, vitiating a constant yardstick (how do you compare a cold cellar with a refrigerator? How much did a laptop cost in 1934?) A new method, using AI to valuate goods, shows that 20th C US economic growth was much bigger than previously estimated.
Verónica Bäcker-Peral
@VBPeral
Excited to share our new working paper: how much did the US standard of living really rise over the twentieth century — and when? With @bhwittenbrink
Using 5.1 million Sears catalog listings, we build a quality-adjusted price index for consumer goods, 1900–1990. Two headline findings: growth was much larger than official statistics imply, and its peak came before WWII, not after. (1/9) -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Congratulations to my nephew Eric Boodman, @ericboodman, the new National Science Correspondent for the New York Times. www.nytco.com/press/a-new-national-science-correspondent/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Big anniversary week for me: I moved from Montreal to Boston for graduate school 50 years ago, and except for 3 1/2 years in California, haven't left. And I started to teach Intro Psych 30 years ago, first at MIT, now at Harvard.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The first class of the year is the only time I ever get stage fright.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Paperback pub day: When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I had a lively conversation last night with Faisal Al-Mutar at the Palladium in New York (Faisal's favorite venue for metal music). Long lines of questioners after we spoike.
Pamela Paresky 🟦 (Habits of a Free Mind)
@PamelaParesky
Great conversation between @faisalalmutar & @sapinker
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Professor Steven Pinker, one of the world’s most influential cognitive psychologists and public intellectuals, joins the Daniel Dusy podcast for a profound conversation about artificial intelligence, human consciousness, and the enduring power of Enlightenment values. youtu.be/eWC47agaKpk via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Pamela Paresky 🟦 (Habits of a Free Mind)
@PamelaParesky
Great conversation between @faisalalmutar & @sapinker
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Pamela Paresky 🟦 (Habits of a Free Mind)
@PamelaParesky
Steven Pinker at the Palladium Times Square. And Steven Pinker drink specials. 🍹
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Pioneering cancer fighter sees promise beyond melanoma breakthrough — Harvard to USA: You're welcome. news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/08/pioneering-cancer-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Democrats Need to Stop Seeking Oppressors — Real or Imaginary, says Nobel laureate Daron Acemoglu, author of What Happened to Liberal Democracy? www.nytimes.com/2026/09/01/opinion/democrats-populism-big…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Human Giants Defy the Laws of Physics thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/why-human-giants-defy-the-laws… #galileo #giants #humans #mathematics #physics via @mitpress
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Tomorrow night, IBB President Faisal Saeed Al Mutar is taking the stage with Steven Pinker in New York.
Faisal and Pinker will spend an hour on stage talking about Pinker’s latest book, When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows, his earlier work, free speech, social media, human progress, Enlightenment ideas, and whatever else Faisal decides to ask him." ideasbeyondborders.org -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This is not an Onion or Babylon Bee or Mad Magazine parody: In response to the Human Rights Foundation designating Russia as "fully authoritarian," Russia threatens to punish anyone engaging with the Human Rights Foundation. You just can't write this stuff.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Good luck, Commonwealth Fusion Systems! @cfs_energy
Bob Mumgaard
@BobMumgaard
Even though fusion is hard, we’re really confident SPARC will hit its first big goal of Q>1. That milestone means that the amount of fusion energy we get out of the plasma (our very hot fusion fuel) will exceed the heating energy we put in to make the fusion happen.
So far, only one machine in the world has done that, but we expect SPARC will be the second. Check our blog post about this to understand why we’re confident and why achieving Q>1 is important.
To reach Q>1, you don’t just need good science. You also need a team with the skills to engineer, manufacture, build, and operate a fusion machine. @CFS_energy has exactly that. And we put this all together with commercialization in mind: SPARC demonstrates most of the core technology we need for our ARC power plant. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Expert Intelligence: a new way for you to engage with books. Buy the e-book from Google, and you can use Google Notebook to apply the expertise and advice in the book to the project you're working on. The Sense of Style is one of 7 books they're featuring during their launch, and the app will apply my writing advice to your drafts as you write them. @google blog.google/innovation-and-ai/products/gemini-notebook/ex…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
StarkWare
@StarkWareLtd
Blocksmart is back with a new episode featuring bestselling author and public intellectual @sapinker.
How does common knowledge shape society, money, and blockchains? And what can AI teach us about the human brain?
We dive into it all in the second episode of Blocksmart 👇
0:00 - Intro: Steve Pinker
0:49 - Common knowledge
5:57 - Blockchain & social consensus
9:40 - Blockchain’s social innovations
12:27 - Making blockchain common knowledge
15:13 - Making science popular
21:46 - AI, LLMs & the human brain
28:25 - Quick-fire
31:25 - Parting thoughtsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
For more on mattering, Rebecca Newberger Goldstein's new book is on Audible:
The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us
www.amazon.com/Mattering-Instinct-Deepest-Longing-Divides… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Our Longing to Matter Drives and Divides Us | Amanpour and Company youtu.be/LTkNwAFtb9w via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"To be published soon—and banned [by the academic left] in a classroom near you!" @mboudry's defense of...liberalism.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My former philosophy department at @UGent banned the teaching of this paper by Anomaly & Faria, in a philosophy class by my colleague Bouke De Vries. Why? Because it discusses demography and migration as potential threats to liberal societies, and something called “biocultural continuity”! The horror! It sounds almost... conservative! Someone please protect the students!
If you ask me, one of the main dangers facing liberalism is precisely that (some) liberals want to shut down debate about the threats it faces. So what else could we do? Bouke invited me to join efforts and write a paper in reply, which critically evaluates and challenges Anomaly & Faria's argument. It has now been accepted for publication.
So can liberalism survive itself? Anomaly and Faria fear it may not, pointing to low birth rates, cultural fragmentation, mass migration from illiberal cultures, and liberalism’s self-imposed constraints. In our paper, we’re more hopeful. Open societies adapt faster; people defect and switch ideologies when facades crack; technology gives them an edge; and authoritarian regimes have demographic problems of their own. Liberalism ain't finished yet.
This was a somewhat adversarial collaboration, which are often the most interesting. Bouke is more pessimistic and tends to think that demography (largely) determines our destiny, whereas I take a more sanguine view of the robustness of liberal democracy and focus more on cultural transmission—which can undermine demographic advantages through the horizontal transmission of ideas and ideological defection. Liberalism is inherently attractive, and will remain so for the foreseeable future.
To be published soon—and banned in a classroom near you! -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
American life expectancy, after some plateaus and the Covid dip, is now at an all-time record. www.wsj.com/opinion/cdc-america-lifespan-pharma-capitalis… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Expert Intelligence: a new way for you to engage with books. Buy the e-book from Google, and you can use Google Notebook to apply the expertise and advice in the book to the project you're working on. The Sense of Style is one of 7 books they're featuring during their launch, and the app will apply my writing advice to your drafts as you write them. @google blog.google/innovation-and-ai/products/gemini-notebook/ex…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fascinating reflections by the computational linguist Shalom Lappin on two visions for political liberation, revolutionary violence with its terrorism and ethnic cleansing, vs tolerance & coexistence. Exemplified by Fanon vs Mandela, and Sartre vs Camus. All inspired by rewatching ‘The Battle of Algiers’ sixty years later. quillette.substack.com/p/the-battle-of-algiers-at-sixty?r…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
First-World Problems Were Once an Emperor’s Problems, by @AdamOmaryPhD humanprogress.org/first-world-problems-were-once-an-emper… via @HumanProgress
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A good decision: Federal court rules the statutes the Trump admin used in its speech-based deportation scheme are unconstitutional www.fire.org/news/breaking-federal-court-rules-statutes-t… via @TheFIREorg
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My colleague @jflier objects to the (nonexistent) editorial judgment of the once-prestigious New England Journal of Medicine that led to the publication of an unhinged opinion piece on the Jason Arday fraud that began "They're trying to kill us" (presumably white people trying to kill black people") and, astonishingly, admitted, “I don’t care whether any of these allegations against Prof. Arday were true.”
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
I wrote about failed editorial oversight of a recent Voices column about the Arday affair by @NEJM open.substack.com/pub/sensiblemed/p/the-new-england-journ…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Even if this is opinion, would NEJM publish a sober, truth-respecting opinion piece on how this scandal reveals deep problems with the culture and policies of elite universities?
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Cape Cod Learns to Live With Sharks: Bleed-stanching kits, menacing signs, and shark merch everywhere. www.nytimes.com/2026/08/29/realestate/cape-cod-shark-tour…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
R. I. P. Dolly Parton, possessor of many gifts, including wit. ("Dumb blonde jokes don't bother me because I know I'm not dumb and I know I'm not blonde.") I often quote her in my advice on the effort needed to write in clear and simple prose: "You wouldn't believe how much it costs to look this cheap." | Superstar Whose Songs Spoke to Millions, Dies at 80 www.nytimes.com/2026/08/25/arts/music/dolly-parton-dead.html
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Individualism doesn't mean selfishness or antisociality. @DavidDeutschOxf explains.
David Deutsch
@DavidDeutschOxf
uatx.substack.com/p/forget-yourself Hmm. I'd say the Enlightenment version of individualism is the historically unique idea that individuals exist not for the sake of their ruler, their class, their ancestors, their gods, or any other such superstition, but for their own sake. Meaning does not require subordination to something "greater than oneself". It is created by the idea that progress is possible and desirable – not by a leap to utopia, but endlessly into the future by undirected problem-solving, carried forward voluntarily by individuals for their own reasons.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In just a few days, I’ll be in New York to begin a tour of conversations about reason, human nature, progress, and the forces shaping our future.
From New York to Boston, Chicago, San Francisco, Montreal, and Toronto, I’m looking forward to lively conversations, thoughtful questions, and hearing your perspectives along the way.
I hope to see you there.
Tickets: thinkable.events -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
First-World Problems Were Once an Emperor’s Problems, by @AdamOmaryPhD humanprogress.org/first-world-problems-were-once-an-emper… via @HumanProgress
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Trump and RFK Jr. are perpetuating the misunderstanding that cases of autism have been increasing in the population at an alarming rate, whereas what has happened is that diagnoses of autism are increasing in people who, in the past, would have been diagnosed with other conditions or missed altogether. They are now using this misunderstanding to scare people about vaccines, asserting that the artifactual increase in autism rates constitutes evidence of an epidemic produced by the harmful effects of vaccines. The results of this scientific illiteracy could be catastrophic." Why Autism Rates Are Rising—It Isn't the Vaccines quillette.com/2026/08/27/interlocking-misrepresentations-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An underappreciated but massive form of progress: the reduction of accidental deaths from fires, falls, collisions, and water: | Drowning is a common cause of death among children — the world has made progress, but more can be done | Our World in Data ourworldindata.org/data-insights/drowning-is-a-common-cau…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
American life expectancy, after some plateaus and the Covid dip, is now at an all-time record. www.wsj.com/opinion/cdc-america-lifespan-pharma-capitalis… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Jason Arday and What’s Wrong With DEI, by my Harvard colleague Roland Fryer www.wsj.com/opinion/jason-arday-and-whats-wrong-with-dei-… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Dolly Parton: Science Icon - Nautilus nautil.us/dolly-parton-science-icon-1284482
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Which diet is right for you? Wrong question. Take a quiz on diet, based on the work of my colleague, the evolutionary anthropologist Dan Lieberman, as presented in this new book Fed Up. news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/08/which-diet-is-righ…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
BTW I was with Dan on the excursion he reports with the Hadza, the hunting and gathering people in Tanzania. (I recall it exactly as he did.)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"To be published soon—and banned [by the academic left] in a classroom near you!" @mboudry's defense of...liberalism.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My former philosophy department at @UGent banned the teaching of this paper by Anomaly & Faria, in a philosophy class by my colleague Bouke De Vries. Why? Because it discusses demography and migration as potential threats to liberal societies, and something called “biocultural continuity”! The horror! It sounds almost... conservative! Someone please protect the students!
If you ask me, one of the main dangers facing liberalism is precisely that (some) liberals want to shut down debate about the threats it faces. So what else could we do? Bouke invited me to join efforts and write a paper in reply, which critically evaluates and challenges Anomaly & Faria's argument. It has now been accepted for publication.
So can liberalism survive itself? Anomaly and Faria fear it may not, pointing to low birth rates, cultural fragmentation, mass migration from illiberal cultures, and liberalism’s self-imposed constraints. In our paper, we’re more hopeful. Open societies adapt faster; people defect and switch ideologies when facades crack; technology gives them an edge; and authoritarian regimes have demographic problems of their own. Liberalism ain't finished yet.
This was a somewhat adversarial collaboration, which are often the most interesting. Bouke is more pessimistic and tends to think that demography (largely) determines our destiny, whereas I take a more sanguine view of the robustness of liberal democracy and focus more on cultural transmission—which can undermine demographic advantages through the horizontal transmission of ideas and ideological defection. Liberalism is inherently attractive, and will remain so for the foreseeable future.
To be published soon—and banned in a classroom near you! -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
There is a sickness worse than wokeness: the viciousness and mindlessness of the new right. (Just as on the left, "fascist" means "anyone to the right of me, "woke" on the right has come to mean "anyone to the left of me.) www.nytimes.com/2026/08/27/opinion/woke-right-trump-free-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Next week I teach Intro Psych for the 30th time. My first lecture is about robots - how the challenge of building one awakens us to the complexity of human intelligence, hidden from us because it works so unconsciously and so well. Every year I have to update it to acknowledge advances in AI (30 years ago, OCR was at the frontier). The fails are funny but I share Melissa Chen @MsMelChen's awe at the engineering challenge and appreciation of how vital this frontier is.
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
People laughing at the Chinese robots crashing after the 100m race or asking what's the point of developing humanoid robots even are missing the bigger picture.
Remember when JFK said:
"We choose to go to the Moon in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard."
<<BECAUSE THEY ARE HARD>>
Human locomotion, let alone a full blown sprint, is mechanically very hard. A two legged robot that has to balance on one foot repeatedly, predict where its center of mass is moving, absorb impact, coordinate many joints and correct errors within milliseconds, is solving problems at the absolute edge of physics, control theory, and real-time intelligence.
When you iterate and solve these problems, regardless of how impractical it seems, you go a long way to advancing a frontier of what machines can be in the physical world, of knowledge than can open up far more applications you don't even know exist yet.
That's what the goal of putting a man on the moon did for NASA and the USA.
This is a Sputnik moment and we are still laughing and dunking on crashing robots and canceling data centers over climate concerns, the very infrastructure required to train the models and run the simulations that would close the gap.
Shaun called the gap existential because it is. Nations that treat hard problems as serious problems shape the future. Nations that stand by and watch do not.
We used to know this. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Bill Maher on When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life is available here: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On Into the Machine, Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose) and I discuss trust in journalism and common knowledge:
Me:
The standards that we enjoyed in the earlier era of journalism did not always exist. Most news was fake news. There were stories of babies born talking, speaking Latin; of Martian civilizations; of Bigfoot in the forest; and of fake scandals involving politicians.
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
The question I have is: How did that assurance come to be? The New York Times, for instance, emerged as a trusted institution in a time when there were very few trusted institutions. Your average news consumer would go out and see the New York Herald, the New York Times, and another newspaper. One month, the Herald would have a story about animals escaping the Central Park Zoo that did not happen. The New York Times would report on, you know, some business news. The other paper might report on gossip. Month over month, trust was built among these different papers, which eventually became common knowledge: “Oh, you can actually trust this one or that one.” And thus an institution was kind of born in that process.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Catch the full episode here: Steven Pinker on Revolutions, Rogue AI, and the Struggle for Reality: tobias.substack.com
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Claire Lehman @clairlemon, as usual, puts it well: Punished for Truth-Seeking quillette.substack.com/p/claires-weekly-letter-punished-f…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Smith: "If data center construction were to stop, it wouldn’t just reduce growth by 1 percentage point. It would also turn companies’ optimism into pessimism, as they realized that the AI boom was going to be throttled by NIMBYs and populists. ... Those workers will spend less on restaurants, dentist appointments, home remodeling, online shopping, etc. The people who work at restaurants, dentists’ offices, remodeling companies and online stores will then receive less income, and they’ll spend less, etc." open.substack.com/pub/noahpinion/p/banning-data-centers-w…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"An Evening With Steven Pinker" - not lectures, but public dialogues at which anything can happen. I'll be asked about AI, free speech, whether progress is continuing, human nature, consciousness, the state of the universities, good writing, language, taboos, and of course common knowledge (when everyone knows that everyone knows, the topic of my new book). Tickets are still available for some of the events: NYC, Boston, Chicago, SF, Montreal, Toronto. Thinkable — World-Class Thinkers, Live on Stage United States & Canada us.thinkable.events
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Carole Hooven
@hoovlet
My recent @NIH talk 👇🏽 was on why we need to get real about sex.
I recommend the lively Q&A (at 50 mins), with NIH scientists in the room and online. (Not all were happy with the gametic definition.) @NIHDirector_Jay was called away, so the conversation was moderated by Rick Woychik [@DirectorNIEHS].
And stay for the supplemental video (at 1:30) that I made to answer some of the online questions we didn't have time for. Also there was some blowback on social media, so I tried to clarify some of my main points in response. videocast.nih.gov/watch/6f87298d-7ab7-11f1-82c0-124f0a52e769
Alex Byrne
@byrne_a
NIH Scientific Freedom Lecture Series: The Reality of Human Sex Differences: Why It Matters for Science, Medicine, and Policy, and Why We Need to Talk About It, with @hoovlet. Q&A 50:00, follow-up video addressing more Qs 1:29:30.👇
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker on Revolutions, Rogue AI, and the Struggle for Reality: tobias.substack.com
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From my conversation with Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose) of Into the Machine:
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
Not that we’re not looking at the bad things, but that we’re losing consensus as to what bad things are; that we’re losing our capacity to parse what progress is at all.
Me:
One of the reasons that the world suffered the catastrophes of both world wars is that there was a widespread idea that war was noble, glorious, holy, spiritual, uplifting, altruistic. Peace was decadent, feminine, selfish, consumerist. So war was a good thing, not a bad thing.
After the catastrophe of World War I, that faded somewhat, but Adolf Hitler still believed it, and he was willing to drag the world into disaster because of his vision of a glorious Reich.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My former MIT colleague Yossi Sheffi has documented how unhinged hatred of Israel, combined with the unwillingness of modern universities to state and enforce principles, led to a hostile climate for Jews at MIT (only starting to be addressed by the administration). | Professor Yossi Sheffi sheffi.mit.edu/book/unsafe-mit-0
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Dear universities: Don’t want to be neutral? Admit it. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/08/24/dear-progressi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Next week I teach Intro Psych for the 30th time. My first lecture is about robots - how the challenge of building one awakens us to the complexity of human intelligence, hidden from us because it works so unconsciously and so well. Every year I have to update it to acknowledge advances in AI (30 years ago, OCR was at the frontier). The fails are funny but I share Melissa Chen @MsMelChen's awe at the engineering challenge and appreciation of how vital this frontier is.
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
People laughing at the Chinese robots crashing after the 100m race or asking what's the point of developing humanoid robots even are missing the bigger picture.
Remember when JFK said:
"We choose to go to the Moon in this decade and do the other things, not because they are easy, but because they are hard."
<<BECAUSE THEY ARE HARD>>
Human locomotion, let alone a full blown sprint, is mechanically very hard. A two legged robot that has to balance on one foot repeatedly, predict where its center of mass is moving, absorb impact, coordinate many joints and correct errors within milliseconds, is solving problems at the absolute edge of physics, control theory, and real-time intelligence.
When you iterate and solve these problems, regardless of how impractical it seems, you go a long way to advancing a frontier of what machines can be in the physical world, of knowledge than can open up far more applications you don't even know exist yet.
That's what the goal of putting a man on the moon did for NASA and the USA.
This is a Sputnik moment and we are still laughing and dunking on crashing robots and canceling data centers over climate concerns, the very infrastructure required to train the models and run the simulations that would close the gap.
Shaun called the gap existential because it is. Nations that treat hard problems as serious problems shape the future. Nations that stand by and watch do not.
We used to know this.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Among others: the gargantuan increase in dignity, happiness, and quality of life that could be granted by robots that could serve the frail elderly in their homes - literally years of worthwhile life restored.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Individualism doesn't mean selfishness or antisociality. @DavidDeutschOxf explains.
David Deutsch
@DavidDeutschOxf
uatx.substack.com/p/forget-yourself Hmm. I'd say the Enlightenment version of individualism is the historically unique idea that individuals exist not for the sake of their ruler, their class, their ancestors, their gods, or any other such superstition, but for their own sake. Meaning does not require subordination to something "greater than oneself". It is created by the idea that progress is possible and desirable – not by a leap to utopia, but endlessly into the future by undirected problem-solving, carried forward voluntarily by individuals for their own reasons.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
R. I. P. Dolly Parton, possessor of many gifts, including wit. ("Dumb blonde jokes don't bother me because I know I'm not dumb and I know I'm not blonde.") I often quote her in my advice on the effort needed to write in clear and simple prose: "You wouldn't believe how much it costs to look this cheap." | Superstar Whose Songs Spoke to Millions, Dies at 80 www.nytimes.com/2026/08/25/arts/music/dolly-parton-dead.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Dear universities: Don’t want to be neutral? Admit it. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/08/24/dear-progressi…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Viva la Résistance: Part One | Rebecca Newberger Goldstein on the World Humanist Conference, where she was the keynote speaker last week. rebeccanewbergergoldstein.substack.com/p/viva-la-resistan…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Carole Hooven @hoovlet on biology and sex.
Carole Hooven
@hoovlet
My recent @NIH talk 👇🏽 was on why we need to get real about sex.
I recommend the lively Q&A (at 50 mins), with NIH scientists in the room and online. (Not all were happy with the gametic definition.) @NIHDirector_Jay was called away, so the conversation was moderated by Rick Woychik [@DirectorNIEHS].
And stay for the supplemental video (at 1:30) that I made to answer some of the online questions we didn't have time for. Also there was some blowback on social media, so I tried to clarify some of my main points in response. videocast.nih.gov/watch/6f87298d-7ab7-11f1-82c0-124f0a52e769
Alex Byrne
@byrne_a
NIH Scientific Freedom Lecture Series: The Reality of Human Sex Differences: Why It Matters for Science, Medicine, and Policy, and Why We Need to Talk About It, with @hoovlet. Q&A 50:00, follow-up video addressing more Qs 1:29:30.👇
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I try to convince haters of universities that, particularly in science and professional departments, we are not woke ideologues with contempt for truth, evidence, and common sense. But many of these professors and institutions don't make it easy. Jeff Flier (Co-President of the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard, and former Dean of Harvard Med School) calls out a bizarre defense of the university-enabled con artist Arday in the formerly respected NEJM.
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
The editorial standards of the @NEJM must be questioned for deciding to publish this article as it is presented below. Such terrible judgement. Jason Arday and the Perils of Being Black in Academia | NEJM Voices voices.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/VOICESpost2600045
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My former MIT colleague Yossi Sheffi has documented how unhinged hatred of Israel, combined with the unwillingness of modern universities to state and enforce principles, led to a hostile climate for Jews at MIT (only starting to be addressed by the administration). | Professor Yossi Sheffi sheffi.mit.edu/book/unsafe-mit-0
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Lovely and informative interview with cognitive scientist Uta Frith, the world's leading scientist on autism: | The British Academy www.thebritishacademy.ac.uk/publishing/review/28/uta-frit…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Ordinary Abundance: "It serves us, and honors them, to recapture whenever possible the old sense of awe at these wonders that have long since become commonplace." (One of the chapters in Enlightenment Now is devoted to this theme.) ordinaryabundance.com
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Much of the vilification of Israel acting in self-defense is unjust, but the terrorism against Arab villages in the West Bank by settler thugs, tolerated by the Netanyahu government, is horrific. It deserves harsh criticism pressure to stop it. quillette.com/2026/08/18/creeping-annexation-west-bank-qu…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A clear-eyed appraisal (including praise for the New York Times) by Jonathan Kaye @jonkay | No, the Media Isn’t Responsible for Jason Arday’s Suicide quillette.substack.com/p/no-the-media-isnt-responsible-fo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"An Evening With Steven Pinker" - not lectures, but public dialogues at which anything can happen. I'll be asked about AI, free speech, whether progress is continuing, human nature, consciousness, the state of the universities, good writing, language, taboos, and of course common knowledge (when everyone knows that everyone knows, the topic of my new book). Tickets are still available for some of the events: NYC, Boston, Chicago, SF, Montreal, Toronto. Thinkable — World-Class Thinkers, Live on Stage United States & Canada us.thinkable.events
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I try to convince haters of universities that, particularly in science and professional departments, we are not woke ideologues with contempt for truth, evidence, and common sense. But many of these professors and institutions don't make it easy. Jeff Flier (Co-President of the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard, and former Dean of Harvard Med School) calls out a bizarre defense of the university-enabled con artist Arday in the formerly respected NEJM.
Jeffrey Flier
@jflier
The editorial standards of the @NEJM must be questioned for deciding to publish this article as it is presented below. Such terrible judgement. Jason Arday and the Perils of Being Black in Academia | NEJM Voices voices.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/VOICESpost2600045
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"If data center construction were to stop, it wouldn’t just reduce growth by 1 percentage point. It would also turn companies’ optimism into pessimism, as they realized that the AI boom was going to be throttled by NIMBYs and populists. ...
Changing optimism into pessimism is a classic 'animal spirits shock' or 'expectations shock' — something that reduces aggregate demand. If hyperscalers and AI-positive companies and equipment manufacturers stop spending big, there will be fewer dollars going to construction workers, engineers, and many other workers. ...
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Noah Smith @noahpinion explains why "banning data centers would blow up the economy." An "animal spirits" or "expectation shock" is a phenomenon of common knowledge: everyone expects everyone else to expect that the economy will pick up (or slow down) and invests (or holds off), self-fulfillingly causing the economy to expand (or contract). This is one of the topics of my new book (out in paperback next week) When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life, available for preorder now: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Smith: "If data center construction were to stop, it wouldn’t just reduce growth by 1 percentage point. It would also turn companies’ optimism into pessimism, as they realized that the AI boom was going to be throttled by NIMBYs and populists. ... Those workers will spend less on restaurants, dentist appointments, home remodeling, online shopping, etc. The people who work at restaurants, dentists’ offices, remodeling companies and online stores will then receive less income, and they’ll spend less, etc." open.substack.com/pub/noahpinion/p/banning-data-centers-w…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Dating coach Jaime Bronstein is a proponent of using LinkedIn with ulterior motives. But a first message should always be platform appropriate, and never obviously romantic.
She suggests crafting messages that offer the pretense of networking while preserving ambiguity. Three pickup lines to avoid: “Are you single?” (Aggressive, potentially creepy); “I hope this isn’t too weird, but…” (Don’t plant any ideas); “You’re gorgeous!” (Also potentially creepy; don’t lead with physical appearance on a professional platform)." www.wsj.com/lifestyle/linkedin-has-accidentally-become-a-… via @WSJ -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How Trump's Epic Fight With Harvard Is Punishing the University. (Felt at every level -- my administrative assistant was told that he was being laid off.) www.nytimes.com/2026/08/21/us/harvard-trump-costs.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If you're an academic (and can prove it with an ORCID), consider signing a petition protesting the University of Ghent's suspension of a postdoc for exposing academic misconduct, a blatant violation of academic freedom (as always, regardless of your agreement with all of the whistleblower's views). johnarmstrongmaths.com/openletters/letter.php?campaign=co… johnarmstrongmaths.com/openletters/letter.php?campaign=co…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Cognitive psychologist Dan Willingham: "Students should only use AI for things they already know how to do well." dtwuva.substack.com/p/students-should-only-use-ai-for-thi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I can't get enough of this family of illusions (not least because it took me so long to figure out how they work).
じゃがりきん
@jagarikin
なんと動いてません
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Claire Lehman @clairlemon, as usual, puts it well: Punished for Truth-Seeking quillette.substack.com/p/claires-weekly-letter-punished-f…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Carole Hooven @hoovlet on biology and sex.
Carole Hooven
@hoovlet
My recent @NIH talk 👇🏽 was on why we need to get real about sex.
I recommend the lively Q&A (at 50 mins), with NIH scientists in the room and online. (Not all were happy with the gametic definition.) @NIHDirector_Jay was called away, so the conversation was moderated by Rick Woychik [@DirectorNIEHS].
And stay for the supplemental video (at 1:30) that I made to answer some of the online questions we didn't have time for. Also there was some blowback on social media, so I tried to clarify some of my main points in response. videocast.nih.gov/watch/6f87298d-7ab7-11f1-82c0-124f0a52e769
Alex Byrne
@byrne_a
NIH Scientific Freedom Lecture Series: The Reality of Human Sex Differences: Why It Matters for Science, Medicine, and Policy, and Why We Need to Talk About It, with @hoovlet. Q&A 50:00, follow-up video addressing more Qs 1:29:30.👇
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Me, too. | On the Trump's war on trade with Canada, by @dgardner dgardner.substack.com/p/on-trade-war?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Great American Crime Decline 2.0 | People read about new wars and suspect that global violence is increasing, but in almost every year and country homicides outnumber battle deaths. The continuing decline of homicides, dramatically in the US but also worldwide, is a prime example of the historical decline of violence. theprogressnetwork.substack.com/p/the-great-american-crim…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How Trump's Epic Fight With Harvard Is Punishing the University. (Felt at every level -- my administrative assistant was told that he was being laid off.) www.nytimes.com/2026/08/21/us/harvard-trump-costs.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Everyday Abundance podcast explores the hidden histories behind everyday activities and the technologies we don’t even know are technologies.
Virginia Postrel and Charles C. Mann dive into the surprising stories behind everything from brushing your teeth to driving your car.
Listen, subscribe, and rate us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon, or YouTube.
abundance.institute/EverydayAbundance -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Jason Arday scandal/fiasco/tragedy is a prime example of "pluralistic ignorance." No sapient being could believe his ziggurat of whoppers, but each may have privately thought that everyone else believed them. This happens when the expression of an idea is stigmatized or punished, as obviously happened here: anyone expressing common-sense incredulity was tarred as a racist, ableist, and abettor of suicide (not to mention threatened by a barracuda law firm and questioned by the police). For more on pluralistic ignorance and other extraordinary popular delusions, see When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life (preorder paperback here; out in a few weeks). www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668… www.nytimes.com/2026/08/15/world/europe/jason-arday-cambr…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows... is also on Audible: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/B0DV…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I spoke with @LaulPatricia about Marxism:
One is: What’s remarkable is that Marxism has been tried. Now, of course, defenders of Marxism say it hasn’t really been tried anywhere, but certainly the people who implemented it claimed they were implementing Marxism.
And this is a massive experiment—a global experiment—with a very clear outcome. Namely, the Soviet Union was a disaster. The imposition of communism on Eastern Europe was a disaster. The imposition of communism in Venezuela was a disaster. The imposition of communism in Maoist China was a disaster. Disaster in terms of both poverty and oppression and genocide and stupid wars. So the world has told us what happens under communism, and it’s a sign of how out of touch intellectuals can be that there are still people who defend it despite the entire world giving a very clear-cut answer.
One more is: would you rather live in North Korea or South Korea? Would you rather live in the old East Germany or West Germany? We have an experimental group and a matched control group in terms of culture, language, and geography, and the answer is crystal clear. So this is a sign of, I think, the pathology of intellectual life—that Marxism can persist.
The other is, you did call attention to one of the appeals of Marxism, though, and more generally of heavy, strong influence of government guided by intellectuals, which is that there are certain kinds of reforms that you can state as principles. You can articulate them verbally as propositions—like equality, human rights, democracy—but there’s other kinds of progress that take place in massive distributed networks of millions of people, none of whom implements some policy. But collectively, there is an order, an organization that’s beneficial.
So that can happen organically through, for example, the development of a language. No one designed the English language. It’s just hundreds of millions of English speakers. They coin new words. They forget old words. They try to make themselves clear. And we get the English language and the other 5,000 languages spoken on earth.
Likewise, a market economy is something where knowledge is distributed. You don’t have a central planner deciding how many shoes of size 8 will be needed in a particular city, but rather information is conveyed by prices, which are adjusted according to supply and demand. And you’ve got a distributed network of exchange of information that can result in an emergent benefit.
Now, intellectuals tend to hate that. They like rules of language—of correct grammar. They like top-down economic planning. They like cultural change that satisfies particular ideals described by intellectuals. And so rival sources of organization, like commerce, like culture—traditional culture—tend to be downplayed by intellectuals.
And this can be magnified by the fact that many dictatorships give a privileged role to intellectuals, which may be why, over the course of the 20th century, and probably continuing to the present, there has not been a dictator that has not had fans among intellectuals—including the mullahs and ayatollahs of Iran, but also the communist dictators: Mao and Castro, even Stalin in his day. And every other dictator has had, actually, often fawning praise from Western intellectuals.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
The 4 Types of People and Which One Destroys You
Rebecca Goldstein | @platobooktourThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Social media platforms are the most powerful common-knowledge generators ever built, and they weren't built for truth. A conversation with @TobiasRose about what that means for democracy — and how to fix it:
Tobias
@TobiasRose
Why do dictatorships look permanent right up to the night they fall?
Because a regime can survive a million private grievances. What it can't survive is everyone finding out that everyone agrees.
Money, laws, revolutions — all run on common knowledge. Today social feeds and LLMs have become how we figure out what everyone thinks.
Can we trust them?
I spent an afternoon with @sapinker finding out:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The horrors facing women in Afghanistan, and the predictable damage it has wreaked on the country. @NilofarAyoubi writes powerfully of "Five Years Into the Taliban’s War on Women," calling the ruling junta "a mafia that has memorized scripture." open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/five-years-in…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"There’s a common view in left-wing and right-wing populisms that solving problems is very easy intellectually and you just need to defeat and disempower the bad people. This is not a view that would survive serious learning about the history of basically any policy topic.
It’s actually quite hard to learn what works and why and to implement good ideas at scale. The Woke 1 problems of dogmatism, incuriosity, closed-mindedness, and sloppiness about the facts are not solved by switching the focus from identity to economics or by becoming right-wing.
You need to actually behave less dogmatically, more curiously, more open-mindedly, and more rigorously, and I don’t see a lot of evidence that the discourse is moving in that direction." | Woke 1 is dead. We’ve learned nothing, by @mattyglesias open.substack.com/pub/matthewyglesias/p/woke-1-is-dead-we… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Playing soccer with my 5-year-old grandson, I taught him to fake: look one way and kick the other. Soon I "caught on" and goaltended where he wasn't looking. He got a gleam in his eye, kicked where he was looking, "scored," and collapsed in gleeful laughter.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
UK tour next month: Steven Pinker – The New Science of Harmony, Hypocrisy, and Outrage howtoacademy.com/events/steven-pinker-the-new-science-of-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Dating coach Jaime Bronstein is a proponent of using LinkedIn with ulterior motives. But a first message should always be platform appropriate, and never obviously romantic.
She suggests crafting messages that offer the pretense of networking while preserving ambiguity. Three pickup lines to avoid: “Are you single?” (Aggressive, potentially creepy); “I hope this isn’t too weird, but…” (Don’t plant any ideas); “You’re gorgeous!” (Also potentially creepy; don’t lead with physical appearance on a professional platform)." www.wsj.com/lifestyle/linkedin-has-accidentally-become-a-… via @WSJ
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The game-theoretic logic of "pretense while preserving ambiguity" is laid out in the chapter "Weasel Words" in my book When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life, out in paperback next month & available for preorder now: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Viva la Résistance: Part One | Rebecca Newberger Goldstein on the World Humanist Conference, where she was the keynote speaker last week. rebeccanewbergergoldstein.substack.com/p/viva-la-resistan…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is Biology Allowed to Explain Anything? Even a sex difference as obvious as throwing strength? Robert Deaner & Mike Lombardo: "The strong Blank Slate—the idea that human psychology is largely written by culture—has been declared dead many times. Yet it refuses to stay dead. ... Today, biology is usually acknowledged. Nature and nurture interact. Fine. But the Blank Slate survives through two recurring moves. First, reasonable observations—that traits are plastic, parents influence children, experience matters, and development mediates behavior—are treated as though they rule out an innate contribution. They do not. Second, evidence that could challenge a socialization-only explanation is ignored, minimized, or sidestepped."
open.substack.com/pub/colinwright/p/throwing-like-a-girl-… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fascinating TED talk by Saloni Dattani @salonium on the past and future of medicine.
Saloni
@salonium
It's unclear to me at the moment whether the view counter on my TED talk is broken or if my aunts and uncles have been frantically refreshing the page thousands of times each
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New podcast episode! Relevant to the first mystery in the subtitle of my book, out in paperback next month: When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life.
StarkWare
@StarkWareLtd
Blocksmart is back with a new episode featuring bestselling author and public intellectual @sapinker.
How does common knowledge shape society, money, and blockchains? And what can AI teach us about the human brain?
We dive into it all in the second episode of Blocksmart 👇
0:00 - Intro: Steve Pinker
0:49 - Common knowledge
5:57 - Blockchain & social consensus
9:40 - Blockchain’s social innovations
12:27 - Making blockchain common knowledge
15:13 - Making science popular
21:46 - AI, LLMs & the human brain
28:25 - Quick-fire
31:25 - Parting thoughtsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fascinating TED talk by Saloni Dattani @salonium on the past and future of medicine.
Saloni
@salonium
It's unclear to me at the moment whether the view counter on my TED talk is broken or if my aunts and uncles have been frantically refreshing the page thousands of times each
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
John Mueller's Reflections on starting some recent and future interstate wars muellerbbbb.substack.com/p/reflections-on-starting-some-r…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New podcast episode! Relevant to the first mystery in the subtitle of my book, out in paperback next month: When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life.
StarkWare
@StarkWareLtd
Blocksmart is back with a new episode featuring bestselling author and public intellectual @sapinker.
How does common knowledge shape society, money, and blockchains? And what can AI teach us about the human brain?
We dive into it all in the second episode of Blocksmart 👇
0:00 - Intro: Steve Pinker
0:49 - Common knowledge
5:57 - Blockchain & social consensus
9:40 - Blockchain’s social innovations
12:27 - Making blockchain common knowledge
15:13 - Making science popular
21:46 - AI, LLMs & the human brain
28:25 - Quick-fire
31:25 - Parting thoughtsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New review by Vanessa Kubota of an excellent book on writing in legal contexts by Judge David Weinberg - no excuse for legalese!
Zen and the Art of Persuasive Writing
@Zenpersuasion
So grateful for this review of Zen and the Art of Persuasive Writing by my former clerk Vanessa Kubota, out now in the Journal of Appellate Practice and Process. Honored. 📖
journals.librarypublishing.arizona.edu/appellate/article/…
@sapinker -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I've criticized Harvard's handling of hostile acts toward Israeli and Jewish students, mostly by their fellow students. But the Trump administration's attempt to choke peer-reviewed research funding from the university because the school systematically and relentlessly persecuted Jewish students is ludicrous and an obvious pretext in their avowed campaign to put universities on "a ladder of pain." The federal judge's decision is a legal no-brainer, like the previous attempts of Trump to cripple Harvard. www.nytimes.com/2026/08/13/us/harvard-antisemitism-case-d…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
12 More Things Everyone Should Know About IQ open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/12-more-thin…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
UK tour next month: Steven Pinker – The New Science of Harmony, Hypocrisy, and Outrage howtoacademy.com/events/steven-pinker-the-new-science-of-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Playing soccer with my 5-year-old grandson, I taught him to fake: look one way and kick the other. Soon I "caught on" and goaltended where he wasn't looking. He got a gleam in his eye, kicked where he was looking, "scored," and collapsed in gleeful laughter.
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Recursive mentalizing" (reading the mind of a mind-reader) is the subject of my book When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life), published in paperback next month (available for preorder now:
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I examine studies on the development of recursive mentalizing in kids. The standard conclusion is that kids first mentalize (they have a "theory of mind") around 4, and recursively mentalize around 8 (the "age of reason"). But that's only with unfamiliar, arbitrary content: with more familiar scenarios, introduced one proposition at a time, we're all better at keeping track of who knows what about who knows what. (Not that the boy isn's precocious.)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Economist Justin Wolfers on that $20 burrito: "Using statistics to patiently explain to people that their feelings are wrong rarely works. Believe me, I’ve tried." www.nytimes.com/2026/08/17/opinion/inflation-affordabilit…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Me too, around the same time: www.nytimes.com/2024/10/29/opinion/trump-national-decline…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Wolfers points out: Cost-of-living increases in wages are perceived as rewards for effort and excellence. Increases in prices are perceived as theft. (A combination of loss aversion and blame-seeking.) Cognitive psychology trumps classical economics (sadly).
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Yet another social science causal claim that (mostly) evaporates when genetic relatedness is controlled.
Michael Bailey
@profjmb
Non-heterosexuals tend to have worse mental health compared to heterosexuals. Is this due to minority stress–stigma and discrimination? In a new study, we should that the answer is “mostly not.” Link to the article in the next post, followed by an explanatory thread. (1/n)
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Recursive mentalizing and public salience in the perception of common knowledge | My new article (with Julian De Freitas and Yuhui Huang) in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2536294123
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Another decline in violence continues since I published The Better Angels of Our Nature: FBI reports record decrease in violent crime in 2025 www.nbcnews.com/politics/justice-department/fbi-reports-r… via @nbcnews
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From my conversation with Tobias Rose-Stockwell (@TobiasRose) of Into the Machine:
Tobias Rose-Stockwell:
Not that we’re not looking at the bad things, but that we’re losing consensus as to what bad things are; that we’re losing our capacity to parse what progress is at all.
Me:
One of the reasons that the world suffered the catastrophes of both world wars is that there was a widespread idea that war was noble, glorious, holy, spiritual, uplifting, altruistic. Peace was decadent, feminine, selfish, consumerist. So war was a good thing, not a bad thing.
After the catastrophe of World War I, that faded somewhat, but Adolf Hitler still believed it, and he was willing to drag the world into disaster because of his vision of a glorious Reich.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker on Revolutions, Rogue AI, and the Struggle for Reality: tobias.substack.com
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"There’s a common view in left-wing and right-wing populisms that solving problems is very easy intellectually and you just need to defeat and disempower the bad people. This is not a view that would survive serious learning about the history of basically any policy topic.
It’s actually quite hard to learn what works and why and to implement good ideas at scale. The Woke 1 problems of dogmatism, incuriosity, closed-mindedness, and sloppiness about the facts are not solved by switching the focus from identity to economics or by becoming right-wing.
You need to actually behave less dogmatically, more curiously, more open-mindedly, and more rigorously, and I don’t see a lot of evidence that the discourse is moving in that direction." | Woke 1 is dead. We’ve learned nothing, by @mattyglesias open.substack.com/pub/matthewyglesias/p/woke-1-is-dead-we… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Hilarious demonstration of the lack of common knowledge (necessary for coordination) in AIs: They can't keep track of what the others are thinking about what they are thinking, so can't take turns counting upward to 100. by Husk IRL - YouTube www.youtube.com/watch?v=MXEInc6Zy7Q
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's an answer the FAQ I get: do AI's have common knowledge? Not anticipated in my book When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. Out in paperback next month, available for preorder now:
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The horrors facing women in Afghanistan, and the predictable damage it has wreaked on the country. @NilofarAyoubi writes powerfully of "Five Years Into the Taliban’s War on Women," calling the ruling junta "a mafia that has memorized scripture." open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/five-years-in…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Stock-Picking Funds Are Performing as Poorly as Ever - outperformed by a mindless basket of stocks. No surprise to a cognitive psychologist, for two reasons... www.wsj.com/finance/investing/stock-picking-funds-are-per… via @WSJ
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's a consequence of Aumann's Can't-Agree-To-Disagree Theorem (if rational agents have the same understanding of the world, and their assessments are common knowledge, those assessments must be the same). In this case: "Any scrap of information that gets [a stock-trader] excited is almost certainly common knowledge, and many other traders have already acted on it, bidding the price up or down to incorporate that scrap. If you disagree with a buyer or seller on the price, then one of you is irrational, and as they say in poker, if you look around the table and can’t tell who the sucker is, it’s you. Rather than forking over an annual management fee which almost certainly will not give you an edge, and which will compound your loss over the years, invest in a low-cost index fund, a mindless basket of assets sampled from the marketplace as a whole, and be content to share in the appreciation of companies as productivity rises." From When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. Out in paperback in a few weeks; pre-order now: www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Our failure to discount post hoc sharpshooting, and our misplaced trust in experts over actuarial formulas, lead us to invest in expensively managed funds which underperform simple indexes." From Rationality: What It Is, Why It Seems Scarce, Why It Matters.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Another decline in violence continues since I published The Better Angels of Our Nature: FBI reports record decrease in violent crime in 2025 www.nbcnews.com/politics/justice-department/fbi-reports-r… via @nbcnews
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
12 More Things Everyone Should Know About IQ open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/12-more-thin…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I've criticized Harvard's handling of hostile acts toward Israeli and Jewish students, mostly by their fellow students. But the Trump administration's attempt to choke peer-reviewed research funding from the university because the school systematically and relentlessly persecuted Jewish students is ludicrous and an obvious pretext in their avowed campaign to put universities on "a ladder of pain." The federal judge's decision is a legal no-brainer, like the previous attempts of Trump to cripple Harvard. www.nytimes.com/2026/08/13/us/harvard-antisemitism-case-d…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker on Revolutions, Rogue AI, and the Struggle for Reality, on Into the Machine with @tobiasrose tobias.substack.com/p/will-ai-wake-up-before-we-do-a-conv…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
As usual, @JohnHMcWhorter ably analyzes this scandal, including (as you might expect) an analysis of his communicative style.
John McWhorter
@JohnHMcWhorter
My Arday piece here too www.thefp.com/p/jason-arday-cambridge-academia-mediocrity…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Mattering Instinct by Rebecca Newberger Goldstein recommended for August reading in the the NYT "Believing" column (which "explores how religion, faith, spirituality, and secular meaning-making shape modern life, culture, and politics"). www.nytimes.com/2026/08/09/briefing/books-to-make-you-fee…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A lively and original conversation on common knowledge with Tobias Rose-Stockwell @tobiasrose
Tobias
@TobiasRose
Why do dictatorships look permanent right up to the night they fall?
Because a regime can survive a million private grievances. What it can't survive is everyone finding out that everyone agrees.
Money, laws, revolutions — all run on common knowledge. Today social feeds and LLMs have become how we figure out what everyone thinks.
Can we trust them?
I spent an afternoon with @sapinker finding out:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Recursive mentalizing and public salience in the perception of common knowledge | My new article (with Julian De Freitas and Yuhui Huang) in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2536294123
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Also coming out in paperback in the UK: www.amazon.co.uk/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/18…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
(And by the way: PNAS no longer automatically publishes members' submissions without review: this was peer-reviewed, fair and square.)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Yet another social science causal claim that (mostly) evaporates when genetic relatedness is controlled.
Michael Bailey
@profjmb
Non-heterosexuals tend to have worse mental health compared to heterosexuals. Is this due to minority stress–stigma and discrimination? In a new study, we should that the answer is “mostly not.” Link to the article in the next post, followed by an explanatory thread. (1/n)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
America’s Progress and Pessimism Paradox: We're objectively better off; most of us feel our lives are going well; yet everyone feels the country is getting worse. By my sometime coauthor @Marian_L_Tupy open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/americas-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Mattering Instinct:
rebeccagoldstein.com -
Steven Pinker reposted
Tobias
@TobiasRose
Why do dictatorships look permanent right up to the night they fall?
Because a regime can survive a million private grievances. What it can't survive is everyone finding out that everyone agrees.
Money, laws, revolutions — all run on common knowledge. Today social feeds and LLMs have become how we figure out what everyone thinks.
Can we trust them?
I spent an afternoon with @sapinker finding out:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Tobias
@TobiasRose
Full link to episode: tobias.substack.com/p/will-ai-wake-up-before-we-do-a-conv…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's not just cultural anthropology: The politicization and postmodern obscurantism of the field of sociology is running the discipline into the ground (though some those quoted in the article - al Gharbi, Redstone, McAffree -- are fabulous). | The study of people has a people problem. www.wsj.com/us-news/education/is-it-time-to-liquidate-the… via @WSJ
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Sex Differences Above the Neck: A review of Steve Stewart-Williams's new book A Billion Years of Sex Diffferences, by Jerry Coyne @WEITyoutube open.substack.com/pub/quillette/p/sex-differences-above-t…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Social media platforms are the most powerful common-knowledge generators ever built, and they weren't built for truth. A conversation with @TobiasRose about what that means for democracy — and how to fix it:
Tobias
@TobiasRose
Why do dictatorships look permanent right up to the night they fall?
Because a regime can survive a million private grievances. What it can't survive is everyone finding out that everyone agrees.
Money, laws, revolutions — all run on common knowledge. Today social feeds and LLMs have become how we figure out what everyone thinks.
Can we trust them?
I spent an afternoon with @sapinker finding out:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Both of them outdid even Rosie Ruiz, the famous "winner" of the 1980 Boston Marathon: time.com/3822577/rosie-ruiz-history/
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
My favorite example in the genre of fabulists is Nick Clark, the cyclist who was exposed by local riders for his exaggerated Strava KOM (King of the Mountain) times. For years he said he raced professionally in Europe, that he was also a military soldier/weapons instructor, a high-earning CEO for a chemical company, a lawyer, an academic, and a hostage responder.
Most people have no way (or time) to fact check some dude lying about his life, but we all know what real Strava KOM times are like and THAT we can check!
www.ride-mtb.com/en/news/the-professional-cyclist-who-nev…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
But perhaps not the 1980s icon Joe Isuzu (who was name-checked by Michael Dukakis in a presidential debate with George H. W. Bush).
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
As usual, @JohnHMcWhorter ably analyzes this scandal, including (as you might expect) an analysis of his communicative style.
John McWhorter
@JohnHMcWhorter
My Arday piece here too www.thefp.com/p/jason-arday-cambridge-academia-mediocrity…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker on Revolutions, Rogue AI, and the Struggle for Reality, on Into the Machine with @tobiasrose tobias.substack.com/p/will-ai-wake-up-before-we-do-a-conv…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A lively and original conversation on common knowledge with Tobias Rose-Stockwell @tobiasrose
Tobias
@TobiasRose
Why do dictatorships look permanent right up to the night they fall?
Because a regime can survive a million private grievances. What it can't survive is everyone finding out that everyone agrees.
Money, laws, revolutions — all run on common knowledge. Today social feeds and LLMs have become how we figure out what everyone thinks.
Can we trust them?
I spent an afternoon with @sapinker finding out:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
World Humanist Congress 2026 - Humanists International | This week in Ottawa | Keynote speaker Rebecca Newberger Goldstein @platobooktour humanists.international/event/world-humanist-congress-2026/
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Human Progress
@HumanProgress
Throughout the 20th century, average IQ scores rose year after year.
In recent decades, that trend appears to have reversed.
@sapinker discusses why on our podcast.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Mattering Instinct by Rebecca Newberger Goldstein recommended for August reading in the the NYT "Believing" column (which "explores how religion, faith, spirituality, and secular meaning-making shape modern life, culture, and politics"). www.nytimes.com/2026/08/09/briefing/books-to-make-you-fee…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Mattering Instinct:
rebeccagoldstein.com -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An unsung form of progress: We drive way more, but crash far less, saving hundreds of thousands of lives. Some of the lifesavers were unbelievably simple (yet someone had to think of them, and fight opposition to get them implemented): the white line at the right edge of the road.
www.wsj.com/business/white-line-road-invention-america-25… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
CPUs and the rise of neurosymbolic AI by @garymarcus (with implications for what Artificial Intelligence implies about natural intelligence -- Gary's & my interest ever since we worked together 37 years ago). garymarcus.substack.com/p/cpus-and-the-rise-of-neurosymbo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Darwin Was Right About Sex Roles (and this is a case where the exceptions really to prove the rule: As Robert Trivers predicted, greater male parental investment leads to fewer sex differences in ornamentation & aggression). open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/darwin-was-r…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
At the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh, we're taking steps to ensure that this mirror-image fiasco cannot happen again. ("Messed up," yes; "irredeemably," we hope not!)
Melissa Chen
@MsMelChen
To understand just how irredeemably messed up academia is, compare the differences in how Cambridge treated Jason Arday and how Harvard treated Roland Fryer.
One is a black sociologist; the other is a black economist.
At this point, we are all very well acquainted with Jason Arday’s insane fabrications, plagiarism, and less-than-stellar research record. Yet he became the youngest black professor in Cambridge’s history at 37.
Now look at the case of Roland Fryer.
He produced rigorous, data-driven research, published extensively, and ran a major institute (EdLabs) at Harvard.
He doggedly pursued the truth on one of the most charged questions in American public life. His landmark 2016 study titled “An Empirical Analysis of Racial Differences in Police Use of Force” examined millions of encounters and officer-involved shootings.
It found that there were no racial differences in the raw data or after controlling for circumstances. In some datasets (notably Houston), blacks were actually less likely to be shot once the encounter was underway.
As you know, this finding directly contradicted Black Lives Matter’s core orthodoxy that police systematically and disproportionately kill Black men out of racial animus. It was not only in vogue at the time; it was literally religion.
Roland Fryer and his data were guilty of blasphemy.
Harvard launched investigations into allegations of verbal sexual harassment and a hostile work environment in his lab. The process produced a two-year unpaid suspension, the permanent shutdown of EdLabs, and severe restrictions on his ability to advise or supervise.
All this was investigated by a kangaroo court under Title IX. The recommendation for his alleged failings was sensitivity training, yet a faculty panel escalated it into career-crippling punishment. Fryer has said he was unfairly targeted because of the political inconvenience of his results.
The contrast between how the academy treated these two men shows you how deep the moral rot is. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"A Lot of the Attacks on Higher Ed Are Unfair. Not This One....This was a prime example of academia’s maddening tendency to embody the worst caricatures painted by its critics." Cambridge U appoints a flaming charlatan then denies what everyone can plainly see. This fiasco should accelerate universities' self-examination. An obvious failure point was a lack of viewpoint diversity, with no non-woke profs or admins to call out the delusion. The more serious one is threats of punishment of critics: anyone who point out the obvious is smeared as a racist, ableist, and abettor of suicide (in this case, also police visits & barracuda libel lawyers). We know is a powerful generator of the madness of crowds. www.nytimes.com/2026/08/08/opinion/cambridge-plagiarism-a…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard is starting to reform itself, nudged & prodded by our Council on Academic Freedom @cafh & profs, students, and yes, leaders calling for fixes. (Example: my "Five-Point Plan to save Harvard From Itself" from 2023) : www.bostonglobe.com/2023/12/11/opinion/steven-pinker-how-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"College Town" | A new newsletter on higher education from The Boston Globe www.bostonglobe.com/newsletters/college-town/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's not just cultural anthropology: The politicization and postmodern obscurantism of the field of sociology is running the discipline into the ground (though some those quoted in the article - al Gharbi, Redstone, McAffree -- are fabulous). | The study of people has a people problem. www.wsj.com/us-news/education/is-it-time-to-liquidate-the… via @WSJ
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This is very bad: The American Association of University Professors confirmed conservative accusations that faculty are politically biased by gratuitously endorsing a political candidate, way beyond their mandate. My Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh Jeff Flier @jflier explains. The AAUP Traded Its Credibility for a Ballot Line, by @HdxAcademy open.substack.com/pub/heterodoxacademy/p/the-aaup-traded-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Three Myths People Love to Believe About English (I've debunked each in my books as well): English has twee collective nouns like a shrewdness of apes; languages get simpler over time because lazy speakers slur their vowels and consonants (but what about those lazy hearers?); Elizabethan English survives in Appalachia. www.nytimes.com/2026/08/06/opinion/english-language-lingu…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What Is the Point of Cultural Anthropology? It used to have the indispensable mandate to study the world's cultures and peoples. Now it's ideology and gibberish. quillette.substack.com/p/what-is-the-point-of-anthropolog…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Steven Pinker’s The Blank Slate Was a Warning We Ignored," write biologist Colin Wright @SwipeWright. [It] seems to have aged in reverse... Pinker’s great achievement in The Blank Slate was not simply showing that genes matter, as many competent scientists have demonstrated before. Rather, it was exposing the way that fear of human nature had distorted entire fields of study...." www.realityslaststand.com/p/steven-pinkers-the-blank-slat…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"The fundamental puzzle, then, is not why some people believe false things, but how any of us, some of the time, manage not to." New (and plausible) book coauthored by Dan Williams @danwilliamsphil | The Social Roots of Delusions open.substack.com/pub/conspicuouscognition/p/the-social-r…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Therapists are warning about AI. But they are also using it. by Charlotte Blease @crblease bleaseondrbot.substack.com/p/ai-pushback?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Med Schools Seem to Be Over Their Politics Fever by Sally Satel @slsatel www.wsj.com/opinion/free-expression/med-schools-are-over-… via @WSJFreeEx
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
World Humanist Congress 2026 - Humanists International | This week in Ottawa | Keynote speaker Rebecca Newberger Goldstein @platobooktour humanists.international/event/world-humanist-congress-2026/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Elites' attitudes toward the masses were satirized in Woody Allen's story "If the Impressionists Had Been Dentists."
"Dear Theo
Will life never treat me decently? I am wracked by despair! My head is pounding. Mrs Sol Schwimmer is suing me because I made her bridge as I felt it and not to fit her ridiculous mouth. That's right! I can't work to order like a common tradesman. I decided her bridge should be enormous and billowing and wild, explosive teeth flaring up in every direction like fire! Now she is upset because it won't fit in her mouth! She is so bourgeois and stupid, I want to smash her." queen-evie.livejournal.com/157386.html via @livejournal -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In The Blank Slate, I suggested another cause: the denial of human nature, including appreciation of beauty. Elites assumed that human tastes are infinitely malleable and so the masses would learn to overcome their bourgeois prejudices and appreciate brutalism, authoritarian high modernism, & other flauntings of ugliness. The idea has recently been elaborated by the MIT linguist Samuel Jay Keyser in The Mental Life of Modernism. mitpress.mit.edu/9780262043496/the-mental-life-of-modernism/
Patrick Collison
@patrickc
Someone asked me recently why I’ve become interested in aesthetics after having spent most of my life more interested in STEM-adjacent topics. I hadn’t really considered the question consciously before, but I’m certainly thinking about aesthetics more than I used to. I think it’s a confluence of things:
• Many things today are ugly and far uglier than they used to be or need to be. Once you see this, it’s kinda hard to stop perceiving it. (Early twentieth century phone boxes versus modern phone boxes; old water fountains versus new water fountains; etc.) As someone with a naively meliorist assumption that most things should be getting better rather than worse, it’s all a bit perplexing: why did we stop doing things nicely? Is it a choice? Was there a malevolent spell cast upon us? This vein led me to think more about modernism and why much of art became more intentionally "challenging", grotesque, opposed to prettiness, rebarbative, dissonant, etc. Can or should anything be done about this? Is this just how things ought to be?
• Relatedly, much of modernism involved a kind of explicit repudiation of cultural continuity and represented a schism with prior practices. This is maybe most evident in American architecture, where the International Style exhibition in 1932 initiated the displacement of a rich tapestry of prior styles. This cultural break seems important and interesting to me, and I suspect that the rejection had important consequences outside of the aesthetic domain. Samuel Hughes has been exploring this question in his recent writing at @WorksInProgMag; @RuxandraTeslo is also pulling on this thread. Elaine Scarry wrote about how beauty inspires creation. If so, the inverse may also be true: ugliness inhibits it.
• It’s clearly the case that changes in the aesthetic domain can at least inspire progress in other places. Petrarch helped set some of the preconditions for the Renaissance which in turn fostered the scientific revolution and Enlightenment. Things like World Fairs (the 1851 Fair at the Crystal Palace recorded 6 million admissions when the population was 21 million) reflect the popular interdependency that used to exist between aesthetics and material development.
• @tedgioia and others have written about stuck culture and how so many domains seem to have ceased to straightforwardly advance in the way that they did up until the nineties or thereabouts. This is obviously peculiar and interesting. What changed, and what does it mean? Is it about the internet and fragmentation? Is it about a loss of supply? Is it just about having reached the zenith of various mediums?
• I’m generally interested in markets and the dynamics of creation. In aesthetics broadly, I find the reflexivity between supply- and demand-side factors to be very thought-provoking. There’s a natural desire to view satisfaction of individual preferences as the yardstick to measure market success, but things get interesting and even a bit unsettling when we start to think about how the supply might start to shape the demand. I often think about this in the context of food. Why is food so much worse in Germany than many of its neighbors? Germany certainly doesn’t have less material ability to produce good food; indeed, Germany is richer than the countries around it. There’s probably something about German food supply chains that is impoverished relative to France and Italy, but the Germans themselves don’t seem too upset about it. It just seems that the Germans are stuck in an objectively worse market equilibrium than their neighbors: the food is bad and they’ve gotten used to it. The obvious question then is where else these kinds of reflexive patterns apply, and where else we’re stuck in some objectively inferior equilibrium, even if preferences are in some superficial sense being sated.
• While this is an extremely banal and obvious point, I hadn’t until recently thought much about or internalized how much one can study reasonably objective things ("the status of women in society", say) through artwork. (Thanks to @_alice_evans for opening my eyes here.) In this vein, I’m pretty excited about the possibilities over the coming years in computational art analysis. I want something that’s conceptually similar to Google Ngram timelines but for the visual arts.
• We've always tried to do things well at Stripe. I've come to see that attempting to do them beautifully is often a helpful way to break out of standard practices and to do something with greater novelty and in a way that might have other benefits besides. (Also, excellent people want to do great work because it is intrinsically satisfying. Explicitly allowing aesthetic considerations to carry weight avoids having to justify every assessment with some kind of torturous empiricism.)
• In his Nobel Lecture, Solzhenitsyn said that, among the Platonic virtues of goodness, truth, and beauty, that beauty is special, for it possesses a unique kind of irrefutability. He notes that arguments, writing, and philosophical systems can all be predicated on misapprehensions, but that “a true work of art carries its verification within itself.” He proceeds to observe that when goodness and truth are threatened, the “ever surprising shoots of beauty will still force their way through.” There is a lot of specious and motivated reasoning in the world today and plenty of questionable value systems. I don’t think that beauty directly reflects any definitive trait, but I’m intrigued by the idea that it can be a marker of deeper metaphysical coherence. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Confirmation of two things I've long believed: 1. There is no "business cycle" of expansions followed by recessions (if there were, they'd quickly be nullified by strategic investing). It's a phenomenon, like supposed cycles of war and piece, of imagining patterns in randomness. 2. Wars are not good for the economy (other than possibly a brief Keynesian stimulus) - how could diverting productive capacity from making stuff to destroying stuff make countries richer? | Interesting interview w economic historian Tyler Goodspeed: Are we headed toward recession? Unpredictable. — Harvard Gazette news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/08/are-we-headed-towa…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Vanderbilt-WashU Report Doesn’t Threaten Academic Freedom. It Defends it. open.substack.com/pub/heterodoxacademy/p/yes-university-l…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Did America Forget How to Build Nuclear Energy? — Business for Good Podcast businessforgoodpodcast.com/episodes/ep195-did-america-for…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Slopulism is taking over America, by @Noahpinion open.substack.com/pub/noahpinion/p/slopulism-is-taking-ov…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New study using AI to analyze content of thousands of texts over time (a method which could revolutionize intellectual history, and which I suspect we'll see more of) shows that that between 1000 and 1920, cultural resistance to new ideas fell by half, which appears to have given a huge boost to economic productivity. By Radoslaw Stefanski: "Cultural Capital and the Productivity of Ideas: Evidence from Historical Texts." www.st-andrews.ac.uk/~wwwecon/repecfiles/econdp/2602.pdf
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When I ask Israeli colleagues why there isn't movement toward a 2-state solution, they say, "Because a Palestinian state would instantly be taken over my Hamas, who would launch nonstop suicide bombings, rocket attacks, and 10/7s in a campaign to destroy Israel." The response of Western pro-Palestinians: "Yes!!!!" | Is the Pro-Palestine Movement the Israeli Right’s Unlikely Ally? open.substack.com/pub/quillette/p/is-the-pro-palestine-mo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What Does AI Want? Maarten Boudry @mboudry continues his anti-AI-doomer arguments by analyzing the nature of evolutionary and engineered "goals." open.substack.com/pub/maartenboudry/p/what-does-ai-want?r…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Sex Differences Above the Neck: A review of Steve Stewart-Williams's new book A Billion Years of Sex Diffferences, by Jerry Coyne @WEITyoutube open.substack.com/pub/quillette/p/sex-differences-above-t…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How We Speak Has Gotten Extravagant. Literally. @JohnHMcWhorter explains how we're always trying to magnify the interest in what we're saying. Another example is superlative inflation, as in the routine use of awesome, excellent, outstanding, and in Britain, brilliant. Generations before us diluted fantastic (out of fantasy), fabulous (worthy of fable), and tremendous (making one tremble). www.nytimes.com/2026/07/30/opinion/gen-z-speech-patterns-…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
For more on meaning, see The Stuff of Thought www.amazon.com/dp/0143114247
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Thomas Sowell, in A Conflict of Visions, proposed a theory of the conflicting convictions about human nature that underlie the standard left-wing and right-wing views on economics, politics, & culture. (I discussed his ideas in the chapter on politics in The Blank Slate). Dan Williams @danwilliamsphil probes Sowell's theory in a new post: "We Are Stuck With Human Nature, Not Human Ignorance" open.substack.com/pub/conspicuouscognition/p/we-are-stuck…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
AI versus Therapists go couch to couch. You may be surprised. By my (sometime) Harvard colleague Charlotte Blease @crblease open.substack.com/pub/bleaseondrbot/p/ai-versus-therapist…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Psychology Research Is Mostly Fine, explains Scott Alexander @slatestarcodex. (So Harvard students: Try my course Psy 1: Psychological Science, starting next month.) open.substack.com/pub/astralcodexten/p/psychology-researc…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Boston Globe Opinion by @RichardHanania: Conservatives hoped that the fusion of tech & populism would make populism smarter. Instead it made tech stupider. "None of us are all that smart on our own. The only way one can expect to have reasonable opinions on political and social issues is to be embedded in a knowledge-producing ecosystem. That doesn’t mean only journalists and academics can be informed. But it does mean that those who reject educational and media institutions are destined to live in ignorance." www.bostonglobe.com/2026/07/26/opinion/tech-right-conspir… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
At most of historical interest: I made some of these points in a debate with my friend, the computer scientist Scott Aaronson, on his blog Shtetl-Optimized, eons ago (2022, before the release of ChatGPT). I underestimated what AI was about to be capable of, but expressed some of the ideas about the nature of intelligence now being raised by the authors of my previous posts. | "Steven Pinker and I debate AI scaling!" scottaaronson.blog?p=6524
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A much-debated and important paper: AI as Normal Technology knightcolumbia.org/content/ai-as-normal-technology
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"We hold a thin scatter of facts about the world, and intelligence or reasoning is whatever fills the space between them."
Clifford Sosin
@CliffordSosin
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"One of the biggest misconceptions people have about intelligence is seeing it as some kind of unbounded scalar stat, like height. 'Future AI will have 10,000 IQ', that sort of thing. Intelligence is a conversion ratio, with an optimality bound. Increasing intelligence is not so much like 'making the tower taller', it's more like 'making the ball rounder'. At some point it's already pretty damn spherical and any improvement is marginal."
François Chollet
@fchollet
One of the biggest misconceptions people have about intelligence is seeing it as some kind of unbounded scalar stat, like height. "Future AI will have 10,000 IQ", that sort of thing. Intelligence is a conversion ratio, with an optimality bound. Increasing intelligence is not so much like "making the tower taller", it's more like "making the ball rounder". At some point it's already pretty damn spherical and any improvement is marginal.
Now of course smart humans aren't quite at the optimal bound yet on an individual level, and machines will have many advantages besides intelligence -- mostly the removal of biological bottlenecks: greater processing speed, unlimited working memory, unlimited memory with perfect recall... but these are mostly things humans can also access through externalized cognitive tools. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Frontier AI models are smarter than humans in many ways, so why does the world look the same? Where's the singularity, the superintelligence explosion, the mass unemployment, the cures for cancer, the enslavement of humanity by machines? The fallacy is to think of intelligence as a magical substance rather than a gadget (using knowledge to attain goals), in this case one that is limited by inherently sparse data and inherently chaotic phenomena. @Noahpinion explores this idea in What will more intelligence actually do for us?, by open.substack.com/pub/noahpinion/p/what-will-more-intelli…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Stop Pathologizing Ordinary Life www.nytimes.com/2026/07/26/opinion/mental-health-exercise…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Adam Mastroianni (former grad student at Harvard) explains the cognitive fallacies behind opposition to AI data centers, with suggestions on better ways to limit the pernicious aspects of AI. www.nytimes.com/2026/07/25/opinion/data-centers-environme…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Atrocitology (measuring and ranking history's worst monsters) relies on necrometrics (counting the victims) but also intent, size of the vulnerable population, and potential additional harm if the regime is unstopped. @Noahpinion thus considers: Who was the worst monster of the 20th century? open.substack.com/pub/noahpinion/p/who-was-the-worst-mons…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A few takeaways from Smith and White: 1. Bad stuff is happening in the 21st century, but the 20th century was orders of magnitude worse. 2. The new sympathy for communism, and even Mao, is morally depraved. 3. Fanatical hatred of Israel is so out of proportion to the magnitude of the world's atrocities, and to considerations of intent (the country is dealing with forces that vow to destroy it and its people) as to be raise legitimate questions about antisemitism.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Maarten Boudry @mboudry writes of the regime of intimidation facing European academics & public figures who don't demonize Israel and calls for open expression of opinion. | What Are You Afraid Of? open.substack.com/pub/maartenboudry/p/what-are-you-afraid…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Science Magazine - The rise and fall of language diversity through the Holocene (coauthored by my former Harvard associate Damian Blasi) www.sciencemagazinedigital.org/sciencemagazine/library/it…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Maarten Boudry @mboudry writes of the regime of intimidation facing European academics & public figures who don't demonize Israel and calls for open expression of opinion. | What Are You Afraid Of? open.substack.com/pub/maartenboudry/p/what-are-you-afraid…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Part 3 of Ana Velez Caicedo's review of Cuando todos saben que todos los saben: blogs.elespectador.com/actualidad/catrecillo/cuando-todos…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A new media outlet in Russia that pushes back against the Putin regime's propaganda.
«Гроза»
@groza_media
Groza is launching Russian Youth Month to give young people the chance to speak for themselves.
Over the next month, we will share with the world what young Russians fear, what they dream about, and how the state prevents them from expressing themselves freely. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Atrocitology (measuring and ranking history's worst monsters) relies on necrometrics (counting the victims) but also intent, size of the vulnerable population, and potential additional harm if the regime is unstopped. @Noahpinion thus considers: Who was the worst monster of the 20th century? open.substack.com/pub/noahpinion/p/who-was-the-worst-mons…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Atrocitology" and "necrometrics" were coined by the Matthew White, author of the witty and data-rich book Atrocitology: Humanity's 100 Deadliest Achievements (originally titled The Great Big Book of Horrible Things): www.amazon.com/dp/0857861220?lv=shuf&channelId=500&plpRed…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A few takeaways from Smith and White: 1. Bad stuff is happening in the 21st century, but the 20th century was orders of magnitude worse. 2. The new sympathy for communism, and even Mao, is morally depraved. 3. Fanatical hatred of Israel is so out of proportion to the magnitude of the world's atrocities, and to considerations of intent (the country is dealing with forces that vow to destroy it and its people) as to be raise legitimate questions about antisemitism.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Matthew White: "Arab-Israeli Wars (since 1947): These are the most heavily publicized conflicts of the past half-century, and many readers will expect to see them here; however, Israel is a small country and there just aren’t enough people in this part of the world to generate body counts at our level without a special effort."
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Only one of our 100 multicides -- the Roman-Jewish Wars -- can be blamed even partially on the Jews. Go back and count. You'd be hard pressed to find more than a couple of stray Jews (Trotsky, Disraeli...?) who appear as minor perpetrators in any other chapter. Mostly this is because there have never been enough Jews to cause as much trouble as they get blamed for, but even so; someone's got to say it. The Jews are not behind everything bad that happens in the world."
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A perverse blessing of prosperity: Overdiagnosis of psychological disorders (by my former student @AdamOmaryPhD).
Human Progress
@HumanProgress
Over the years, the DSM has significantly broadened the boundaries of major psychiatric categories—including autism, ADHD, and anxiety disorders.
As a result, diagnoses increasingly depend on the clinician’s interpretation, with predictable results.
From @AdamOmaryPhD: -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
MAMILs (Middle-Aged Men in Lycra): The Old County Road Cycling Club (we do a weekly 30-mile ride).
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
More than 65 years after C. P. Snow's "The Two Cultures," The New York Times Magazine's feature on “How to be cultured” completely neglects science – Why Evolution Is True whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/07/19/the-new-york-timess-mag…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The illusion that we think in language, exposed by a study that asks people to report what they're thinking when probed at random intervals. “'People come in thinking to themselves that they are talking to themselves all of the time.' On beeps where they reported inner speech [the researcher] says, 'I would ask them what exactly they are saying to themselves—a pretty reasonable, straightforward question. When they [consistently] can’t answer that question, they come to the conclusion, "Well, I wasn’t really talking to myself. I don’t really talk to myself."’” I Didn’t Know My Mind Was So Strange Until I Started Listening to It nautil.us/i-didnt-know-my-mind-was-so-strange-until-i-sta…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Five countries that have gone from lower-middle to upper-middle income; YIMBY in Vancouver; recovering seabirds in the UK; cracking down on wildlife trafficking; declining prices for solar panels; and other stories of recent progress from Doomslayer. @HumanProgress
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
There's much to criticize in today's Israel, but Omer Bartov writes as if the vicious forces determined to destroy it and murder its citizens do not exist. Historian Benny Morris examines his zealous prosecution of a book. quillette.com/2026/07/20/omer-bartov-what-went-wrong/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Have centuries of material progress (including, among other things, the doubling of life expectancy and the decimation of extreme poverty) granted by the scientific revolution, the Enlightenment, and other liberal projects, left us no happier? The answer is no, Scott Alexander @slatestarcodex points out. | Contra Pritchard On Liberal Happiness open.substack.com/pub/astralcodexten/p/contra-pritchard-o…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
The Physics of Mattering: Do AI Agents Have a Soul?
Rebecca Goldstein | @platobooktourThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From my conversation with @HumanProgress:
"Like an appreciation of progress, reading and literacy are among the things that are good but cognitively unnatural. That is, they go against our evolved nature. We didn’t evolve with print; it was a relatively recent invention. Reading has become so second nature for many of us that we simply assume it’s the most natural way of getting information.
But what we’ve seen, especially in the last 10 years, as video has become so cheap because of the broadband revolution, is that a lot of people, unlike us, much prefer to listen and watch than to read. You see this when I go to Google and ask a basic question about how to unstick my printer or solve some other problem. I get five videos, and I just want a paragraph that would solve it. I don’t want to see Seth saying, “Hi, welcome to my show. If you like it, subscribe and give it a like.” Just help me solve the problem.
But clearly there’s something unusual about me, because people are choosing the video. And the massive availability of video—TikTok, YouTube, and the like—means that people may not be getting the practice or putting the effort into literacy, which we have reason to believe was one of the drivers of the Flynn effect, and of cognitive sophistication in general."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Full interview:
humanprogress.org/meaning-and-morality-in-the-modern-age/
Highlights: humanprogress.org/meaning-and-morality-in-the-modern-age-… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein
@platobooktour
It seems trite to proclaim that every person matters--in the moral sense, which is generally taken to mean that, to the extent that any of us matter, we all matter to that same exact degree. But how do you prove it? My most recent Substack: rebeccanewbergergoldstein.substack.com/p/chew-on-that-pro…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One of a flurry of articles in the past couple of years on "aphantasia," a lack of mental imagery. Forty years ago the cognitive neursoscientist Martha Farah & I (while she was a postdoc with me at MIT) were perhaps the first to study such self-identified, neurologically intact people. We found they were 100% normal at tasks that clearly require visual images, e.g., What shape are a beagle's ears? Does the lower-case "H" stick up, hang down, or neitehr? What's darker, a Christmas tree or grass? (They were crushed to discover they were normal.) We concluded that the difference was in metacognition: They falsely assumed that everyone but them had photographic ("eidetic") imagery. We didn't publish our findings, but should have: the effect turns out to be highly replicable, raising the question of what "aphantasia" really is. nautil.us/what-a-picture-of-a-dog-has-to-do-with-reason-a…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My own understanding: Mental activity comprises many levels and kinds of representations, including inner speech, images in every modality (visual, auditory, motoric, even olfactory), & abstract "mentalese" (hence I agree that visual imagery is not necessary for reasoning). None of these forms of imagery is a simple replica of sensory input but each comprises multiple levels and formats: vision alone engages some 30-50 brain areas with different degrees of specialization (contour, motion, color, location, large-scale maps, extendedness in 1, 2, or 3 dimensions...); presumably each can be activated with different intensities than the others, making "imagery" highly multidimensional.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I don't doubt that people differ in how much they engage any of them (including strategically - Do you subtract 5 from 3 by mentally zipping back and forth along a number line, or following the "Keep-Change-Change" rule?). Our verbal descriptions of our experience (Are you using a "mental image"?) are way too coarse to capture the possibilities for mental representation. But all the new reports of aphantasics who are unimpaired at visual memory tasks suggest that Martha's and my original hypothesis is right for many of them: they are misled by descriptions of imagery into complaining that they lack an ability (eidetic or "photographic memory") that few people have in the first place.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...Common Knowledge and the Science of Harmony, Hypocrisy, and Outrage (UK subtitle) comes out in paperback this September. You can get 25% off at @waterstones when you pre-order the paperback this Summer.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Who isn't interested in sex and violence? Interesting discussion here.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
A Skeptic and an Evolutionary Psychologist Walk Into a Village Hall… @SteveStuWill
—The evolutionary origins of sex differences
—Sex-role-reversed species
—Greater male variability and the Larry Summers controversy
—Why both sexes prefer research that puts women in a better light than men
—Sex differences in STEM
—Whether murder-suicide has an evolutionary basis
—Young male syndrome and sex differences in crime
open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/a-skeptic-an… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In The Better Angels of Our Nature I presented The Iliad as an example of the brutality the ancients took for granted. This has not been fully appreciated in the revisionism in the new Odyssey film or most of the commentary. "We should not act as if there is any higher value in honoring the ancient past, instead saving our reverence for how far we have come in the last few centuries. The best lesson that Homer can provide is gratitude that we no longer live in his world." We're All Still Living in Denial about the Greeks, by @RichardHanania open.substack.com/pub/richardhanania/p/were-all-still-liv…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's depressing that 28 years after Judith Rich Harris's The Nurture Assumption, psychologists are conducting, and journalists credulously reporting, useless correlational studies of people's decades-old memories of childhood abuse & their adult relationships, presented as evidence for causality. No controls for (among other things) more neurotic adults spinning childhood memories as traumatic; abusive parents passing on genes for cantankerousness to their kids; more obstreperous children growing into more obstreperous adults. | "Childhood Trauma Echoes Through Romantic Relationships" nautil.us/childhood-trauma-echoes-through-romantic-relati…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Bucket list conversation alert 🚨
Rebecca Goldstein & I discussed:
⇨ why every human being is haunted by the need to matter
⇨ the four types of people and how each one tries to satisfy that longing
⇨ why Ludwig Boltzmann's suicid3 is a thermodynamic story
⇨ how depression maps onto entropy
⇨ whether AI can ever have a mattering instinct, and
⇨ why heroic strivers are the most threatened by artificial intelligence.
youtu.be/6fubsTGbSs8?sub_confirmation=1 -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Olayemi Olaniyi: "Steven Pinker’s The Better Angels of Our Nature is one of the most information-dense books I’ve read. In over 800 pages, he makes a compelling case that contrary to the amplification of negative news in the media (and social media, of course), violence has declined." www.linkedin.com/posts/olaniyi-olayemi_steven-pinkers-the…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Olayemi Olaniyi: "Steven Pinker’s The Better Angels of Our Nature is one of the most information-dense books I’ve read. In over 800 pages, he makes a compelling case that contrary to the amplification of negative news in the media (and social media, of course), violence has declined." www.linkedin.com/posts/olaniyi-olayemi_steven-pinkers-the…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Global news media coverage of artificial intelligence (AI): 21% negative, 13% positive worldwide, but far more negative in US & Europe: 24% of NYT and Guardian headlines on AI framed it negatively (compared to 14.5% positive in east Asia). www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0736585324001278
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Cuando todos saben que todos los saben: Commentary by Ana Velez Caicedo on the Spanish translation of When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows..., Part 2. blogs.elespectador.com/actualidad/catrecillo/cuando-todos…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Nick Gillespie
@nickgillespie
This is the best conversation I've had in a long time! Why do so many people feel so lost today? The Mattering Instinct's @platobooktour and I discuss the psychology of freedom on new @reason Intervew www.youtube.com/watch?v=a5eHmG7uGh4
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Thibault Schrepel
@ProfSchrepel
New #scalingtheory episode out now, with @sapinker. Here, Steven weighs up effective altruism.
▶️ www.youtube.com/watch?v=ijNjY7E017E
🎧 open.spotify.com/episode/36hXGoEpCSAPBj1O33tZqq
🍎 podcasts.apple.com/fr/podcast/scaling-theory/id1736309658…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Recently Brian Boutwell and I edited a special issue of the journal Developmental Review updating Harris's views on heritability, peer influence, gene-environment interactions, and chance on the development of personality. www.sciencedirect.com/special-issue/10M258N1SR7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Myth of American Decline open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/the-myth-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Including homicides: U.S. murder rate approaches a record low : NPR www.npr.org/2026/06/30/nx-s1-5866810/us-murder-rate-recor…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Provisional Data: U.S. Death Rate Fell to a Record Low in 2025 blogs.cdc.gov/nchs/2026/07/02/7934/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Nobody wants to see headlines about incremental progress. That's the bias that gets us in trouble." open.substack.com/pub/edgyoptimist/p/nobody-wants-to-see-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Public Comment on the Office of Management and Budget Proposed Regulation on Federal Financial Assistance by USC Professor of Chemistry Anna Krylov. open.substack.com/pub/hxstem/p/public-comment-on-the-offi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Reform [in science funding] should not consist merely of reversing the policies of previous administrations. Instead, [it should be] a renewed commitment to the principles that historically underpinned American scientific success: merit-based peer review, intellectual pluralism, and transparency." New Article Warns of “Whiplash” in U.S. Science Policy as OMB Proposes Unprecedented Control over Federal Research Funding open.substack.com/pub/hxstem/p/new-article-warns-of-whipl…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Poetry in America - Full episodes of Seasons 1-4 of the PBS Series now available to stream on Youtube. www.youtube.com/@PoetryinAmerica
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Humans have always been peripatetic and lubricious, so we are all immigrants and we are all mongrels. | My colleague David Reich (who would not put it that way) on migration, mixed ancestries, and ancient DNA current.fas.harvard.edu/stories/david-reich-migration-mix…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
University ethical Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) have become weapons that ideologues can use to shut up people whose opinions they don’t like, and red-tape dispensers which bog down research while failing to protect, and sometimes harming, patients and research subjects. | Reforming University Ethics Boards open.substack.com/pub/erickaufmann/p/a-positive-vision-fo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Should there be a hyphen in “the top ten schools on the list”? If two adjectives can be joined by the word and without affecting the meaning, then you should separate the two adjectives with a comma-- but isn't a hyphen the better choice in “a historical-philosophical context” or “military-political involvement”? Should a compound modifier be hyphenated if the noun does not immediately follow? New Questions and Answers from the mavens at the Chicago Manual of Style. www.chicagomanualofstyle.org/qanda/latest.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"The world most of our ancestors faced was in fact more gruesome than modern minds can fathom. From routine spousal and child abuse to famine-induced cannibalism and streets that doubled as open sewers, practically every aspect of existence was horrific." Chelsea Follett @chellivia describes The Grim Truth About the “Good Old Days” humanprogress.org/the-grim-truth-about-the-good-old-days/ via @HumanProgress
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's depressing that 28 years after Judith Rich Harris's The Nurture Assumption, psychologists are conducting, and journalists credulously reporting, useless correlational studies of people's decades-old memories of childhood abuse & their adult relationships, presented as evidence for causality. No controls for (among other things) more neurotic adults spinning childhood memories as traumatic; abusive parents passing on genes for cantankerousness to their kids; more obstreperous children growing into more obstreperous adults. | "Childhood Trauma Echoes Through Romantic Relationships" nautil.us/childhood-trauma-echoes-through-romantic-relati…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This brilliant and witty book is still worth reading: The Nurture Assumption www.amazon.com/dp/1439101655?lv=shuf&channelId=500&plpRed…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Recently Brian Boutwell and I edited a special issue of the journal Developmental Review updating Harris's views on heritability, peer influence, gene-environment interactions, and chance on the development of personality. www.sciencedirect.com/special-issue/10M258N1SR7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"GDP doesn’t measure 'the beauty of our poetry or the strength of our marriages' .... But that doesn’t mean that making Americans poorer will make their poetry more beautiful or their marriages stronger." | JD Vance's crusade against GDP is wrong and bad, by @Noahpinion
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"The Proportionality Bias": We think big events need big causes, and can't accept that the course of history can be changed by some odious little schmuck. @michaelshermer gives examples.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
The truth is @DouglasKMurray that Charlie Kirk was assassinated by a lone gunman, just like JFK, RFK, & MLK.
Example of Proportionality Bias:
We think big events need big causes.
Holocaust was caused by Nazis: one of the worst genocides by one of the worse regimes. Balance.
Princess Di: cause of death—drunk driving, speeding, no seat belt: imbalance, so conspiracists add MI6, Royal Family, et al.
9/11: 19 guys with box cutters pulled off the greatest terrorist attack in U.S. history? Impossible. Had to be an inside job.
JFK: killed by a lone gunman. Imbalance. Conspiracists add CIA, FBI, KGB, LBJ, mafia, Castro, et al.
Charlie Kirk was famous & influential, so his death must be orchestrated by a cabal of assassins of the CIA, his org, his wife or, of course, Israel/Jews
www.thefp.com/p/charlie-kirk-assassination-trial-conspira… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Woman Iran Could Not Break open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/the-woman-ira…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Kudos to @michaelshermer for consistently defending rationality, evidence, and the naturalistic world view against ever-present corrosion by purveyors of magic and mysticism (which easily shades into conspiracy thinking, since advocates claim that the corrupt elite establishment is hiding the truth from you).
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
. @JMGreerWriter
Dowsing "works" by the ideomotor effect—tiny motions of the arms & hands move the rods beneath perception.
Movements are random or directed by thought.
"Hits" are accidental.
Confirmation bias: remember hits, forget misses.
Under controlled conditions—dowser is blind to where buckets of water are hidden under opaque boxes that also include no water boxes—no one has EVER found water better than chance.
Ditto Ouija board.
John Michael Greer
@JMGreerWriter
Dowsing works; nobody knows how or why, but it works. It plays a much wider role in contemporary life than most people realize.
To cite only one example, when archeologists in Britain say that they found this or that subsurface feature by “probing with metal rods,” a line you’ll read in the journals quite often, that doesn’t mean somebody was hammering metal rods into the ground. It means this: -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Vaccines for cancer!! And malaria!! I've been a critic of Harvard's shortcomings over the decades, but it's vital to keep things in perspective: Harvard has 13 schools and 2.4K faculty, many doing life-saving and world-improving research. Not just Harvard: the American research university is one of humanity' greatest achievements. news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/07/tracing-evolution-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A continuing decline of violence (after some avoidable reversals): Baltimore’s incredible crime-fighting success story, by @mattyglesias open.substack.com/pub/matthewyglesias/p/baltimores-incred…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Drill, baby, drill! But for heat, not oil. | Geothermal’s time has finally come | The Economist www.economist.com/interactive/science-and-technology/2025…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Confining Insiders, Raping Outsiders": Upsetting but informative essay by @_alice_evans on the historical ubiquity of sexual violence against enemy and outsider women (she doesn't dwell on the Darwinian explanation, though it's obvious enough), and how modern societies have reduced it: "While the entire world was incredibly violent, Europe and North America ultimately diverged. Thanks to more professional policing, effective criminal justice, advanced technology and feminist activism, they ultimately became more peaceful, safer, and constrained male violence." open.substack.com/pub/draliceevans/p/confining-insiders-r…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Long Road to Medical ‘Miracles,’ like the new treatments for two of the most dreaded of cancers, pancreatic and melanoma. "Basic research is not a luxury. It is the architecture upon which cures are eventually built." Threatened, like all else that made American great, by Trump directives that political hacks can control basic science funding. quillette.com/2026/07/06/the-long-road-to-medical-miracle…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"More misguided critique of the modern theory of evolution"—Jerry Coyne, as always, brings clarity to biological commentary in his blog Why Evolution Is True. whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/07/06/more-misguided-critique…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Background: The political left has hoped and dreamed that Lamarckism is true for more than a century, despite its manifest absurdity (how can a macroscopic effect on the body be reverse-coded into genetic instructions and passed into eggs and sperm? Why aren’t Jewish boys born pre-circumcised)? Lamarck’s principle of “Felt need” is just as mystical – how does needing to see conjure an eye into being?
George Bernard Shaw, the Fabian socialist, wrote: “"Darwinism seems simple because you do not at first realize all that it involves. But when its whole significance dawns on you, your heart sinks into a heap of sand within you. There is a hideous fatalism about it, a ghastly and damnable reduction of beauty and intelligence, of strength and purpose, of honor and aspiration." (One may contrast this with Darwin’s own ending to the Origin, in which he eloquently wrote, “There is grandeur in this view of life….”) And of course the famines in Soviet Russia arose from Lysenko making Lamarckism official state doctrine.
Yet the academic left won’t give up, grasping at epigenetic straws (very different) as if they vindicated Jean-Baptiste. That task seems to have fallen to Riskin, who, with Marcus Feldman, has inherited the role of anti-genetics and anti-evolution policeman for the New York Review of Books now that Stephen Jay Gould and Jerry’s mentor Dick Lewontin are no longer with us.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The "eugenics" smear is standard in this genre. The Darwinism-jeerer never point out that eugenics was the standard progressive and left-wing position of the day (not least with GB Shaw), since improving the species was the ultimate form of progress.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The historian Jeffrey Herf comments on the irrational loathing of academics toward Israel's existence, well beyond criticism of policies. Full article: From Historian to Polemicist: What Went Wrong with Omer Bartov www.tandfonline.com/eprint/EDZEPZJIZEANKXKQNFUY/full?targ…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The data are in: Populism makes countries worse off. "... a country being ruled by a populist is associated with a 10% lower GDP after 15 years ... Populists .. were four times more likely than other leaders to preside over democratic backsliding. In fact, of the breakdowns of democracy ... since the end of the Cold War ... two-thirds occurred under populist leaders. Such leaders were also bad for freedom of the press and civil liberties. Perhaps most remarkable of all: 40% of populist leaders ended up charged with corruption." From the forthcoming Kakistocracy. unherd.com/2026/07/why-populism-fails/?edition=us via @UnHerd
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The New York Times urges the University of California do undo its blunder during Peak Woke of eliminating standardized test scores in admissions. www.nytimes.com/2026/07/06/opinion/university-california-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Predicting Future Battle Related Deaths — FutureSearch. I asked an AI-driven superforecaster, "Will total battle-related deaths (as defined and recorded by UCDP — Uppsala Conflict Data Program) in the decade 2026–2035 be higher than total battle-related deaths in the decade 2016–2025?" It's forecast: very slightly less than 50-50. Interesting to see its reasoning, which is close to what I would have ventured. futuresearch.ai/app/conversations/0cd59311-5351-4744-b5b0…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Jefferson and the Source of Human Rights open.substack.com/pub/quillette/p/jefferson-and-the-sourc…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Over several decades it's fallen to @MichaelShermer to debunk every variety of woo-woo, UFOlogy, quantum obfuscation, ESP, Holocaust denial, creationism, and other "weird beliefs" -- not a minor pursuit, since the rational, naturalistic world view is the basis for personal self-protection and human progress. (Among Shermer's honorable predecessors were Martin Gardner, James "The Amazing" Randi, Carl Sagan, Isaac Asimov, and Richard Feynman, and on a more theoretical plane, Bertrand Russell and Karl Popper.)
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
For those baffled by @sapinker comment on elite intellectuals who believe in "miracles, magic, souls, spirits, ESP, divine providence, karma, & all the rest" I hear their arguments regularly. Here it is:
Science is not an asymptotic curve approaching reality.
Kuhn showed that science is embedded in paradigms that constantly change, not necessarily closer to truth.
Science history is littered with mistaken theories overturned by new theories.
This will go on indefinitely.
It is only a matter of time before current physics is overturned and new physics allows for miracles, magic, souls, spirits, ESP....
In the 1890s physicists thought nearly everything was explained down to the 6th place after the decimal point.
Then came Einstein, Quantum Physics, etc.
Some of the "alternative theories" of physics floating around today may show these phenomena are real.
So it's not only okay to believe these mysteries are real, it's a signal that you are an intellectual sophisticate.
I explain why this is wrong in Truth:
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Together with the stuff @michaelshermer singles out in this post, I had in mind the contempt among intellectuals for "the New Atheists" (Sam Harris, Christopher Hitchens, Dan Dennett, Richard Dawkins), despite their failing to point out anything they got wrong, and the surprisingly softball treatment of ESP, astrology, and UFOs in mainstream publications like NYT.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Doomslayer: Progress Roundup open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/doomslaye…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The myth that Europeans introduced the Americas to war, and other misconceptions among the highly educated: Six Myths About Gender, Race, and Inequality open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/another-six-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I've always thought that the campaign against "ultra-processed" foods was mindless. What the heck does that even mean: the more things you do to food, the less healthy it is? New RCTs and analyses confirm that the stigma is meaningless (it's calories, fiber, & other causes, not "ultraprocessing") and even harmful: it encourages RFKj's MAHA quackery. I suspect that food researchers are subject to class bias: food that poor people like and can afford must be unhealthy. www.vox.com/future-perfect/494045/ultra-processed-foods-s…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
American life expectancy has hit an all-time high (reductions in overdoses and homicides are a large cause, because they kill young people, dragging the average down). www.vox.com/future-perfect/494256/united-states-life-expe…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Why do you matter, and to whom?
What's the point of it all?
Many of us have nibbled at answering these questions but no one since Plato has dove so deep into the matter than @platobooktour philosopher Rebecca Goldstein Newberger. Her work is a must read:
open.substack.com/pub/rebeccanewbergergoldstein/p/chew-on… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A new book revisits the mainstream credulity that greeted the charlatan Carlos Castaneda 50 years ago. It was an early sign of a feature of intellectual life that never ceases to amaze me: The bedrock conviction (perpetually supported by evidence) that the universe obeys physical laws, with no miracles, magic, souls, spirits, ESP, divine providence, karma, & all the rest, is in fact a niche belief among elite intellectuals. Those insisting on it may be despised as scientistic, reductionist, materialist, soulless "new atheists." In fact naturalism is the morally enlightened world view, because it directs our attention to human flourishing and the actions we can take to enhance it. | The Huckster Shaman Who Founded a Cult www.nytimes.com/2026/07/04/books/review/american-trickste…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Yes, it’s too soon to tell, but it is interesting that large language models, as opposed to social media, have tended to be much more aligned with what we would consider objective reality and truth. That is, I think it’s not so easy to get a large language model to endorse a ridiculous conspiracy theory, such as that the 2020 U.S. election was stolen or that COVID vaccines are actually microchips that Bill Gates is implanting to surveil us. All of those ideas are very easy to find on social media. And it may indeed be, as you say, that large language models tend to gravitate toward common priors—namely, all the knowledge that’s out there on the web. But, in particular, during pre-training and post-training—the fine-tuning process—they are engineered to be aligned with truth and reality. And that is because the AI companies have a different business model than the social media companies."
From an episode of Scaling Theory with @ProfSchrepel: Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge, From Eye Contact to the Super BowlThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Full episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=ijNjY7E017E
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fifty years ago I came to this country in the midst of its bicentennial celebration. It was dimmed by the recent catastrophic defeat in a divisive war and the first resignation of a sitting president, but the bicentennial was still an occasion for national unity and a celebration of democracy.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fifty years later the semiquincentennial is tainted by fears that the country is no longer a democracy. But the Supreme Court has slapped down many of the President's pet projects, and an electoral reckoning is coming this fall. Is the decline of US democracy hyperbole or reality? Quantitative Democracy indexes can calibrate our assessment: ourworldindata.org/democracy
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
V-Dem's Electoral Democracy Index is informative: The US has undeniably declined in democracy (.73 on a 0-1 scale, vs .91 in 2013 and .79 during the Bicentennial) but still no where near being an autocracy, and far freer than most of the world. ourworldindata.org/grapher/electoral-democracy-index?tab=…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Thinkable
@thinkableevents
Join world-renowned cognitive scientist and Harvard professor Steven Pinker for an evening of live, unscripted conversation probing the very mechanics of the human mind.
🗓️ September 1st, 2026
📍 Palladium Times Square, New York City
Tickets via thinkable.events -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Me:
One cannot charitably credit them with trying to restore academic freedom in universities. The extreme assault by the Trump administration on parts of Harvard had nothing to do with the suppression of speech, such as in the science and engineering departments. The agenda is really to cripple civil society organizations that might be centers of opposition, in the same way they had gone after the media, after law firms, and after other branches of government.
Kmele Foster (@kmele) of @wethefifth:
If I was going to try to sort of steelman the position of people on the right, they would say: you already lost a lot of those institutions in the sciences proper. You mentioned Nature earlier and the fact that they weren’t unwilling to publish certain things that were inconvenient to them with respect to their political convictions. Does that not justify the Trump administration kind of taking a much harder line?
Me:
Well, no. Among the legitimate functions of government stipulated in the Constitution, policing scientific journals is not one of them. But in any case, it wasn’t as if they singled out research projects at Harvard that flouted standards of scientific excellence by prioritizing political correctness over truth. It was an across-the-board zeroing of funding.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Here's my schedule of live events this fall (which, masochistically, I'll be doing in alternation with lectures in my intro course at Harvard): stevenpinker.com/media-and-appearances
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The keynote panel of Nobel Laureate Robert Aumann 96th Birthday Conference in Paris: 50 Years of "Agreeing to Disagree" (on the Israeli mathematician's famous theorem that if rational agents have the same understanding of the world and share their conclusions (i.e., they are common knowledge), those conclusions must be the same). youtu.be/WD_OQbNzml4 via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One way to impart critical thinking skills: www.amazon.com/Rationality-What-Seems-Scarce-Matters/dp/0…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If critical thinking skills are so fragile that they can erode when people use AI, those skills could not have been robustly taught in the first place.
www.insidehighered.com/opinion/views/2026/06/23/we-have-n… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
More videos from the Aumannfest in Paris 2 weeks ago (marking the 50th anniversary of the Israeli mathematician Robert Aumann's famous theorem that rational agents with the same understanding of the world who share their assessments of some hypothesis (make them common knowledge) cannot agree to disagree).
Aran Nayebi
@aran_nayebi
How did Aumann's agreement theorem come to be?
I've uploaded the full video👇from Nobel laureate Bob Aumann's 96th birthday conference in Paris, celebrating 50 years of “Agreeing to Disagree.”
At 1:11:09, I ask Aumann about meeting von Neumann & Morgenstern, their influence on his career, and at 1:00:53 how Nash encouraged him to switch from knot theory to game theory.
My own talk on AI safety and agreement-based complexity starts at 2:01.
The Aumann panel discussion starts at 34:49.
Turn captions on for best experience. Link + full timestamps below.👇 -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge, From Eye Contact to the Super Bowl - Scaling Theory | Podcast on Spotify open.spotify.com/episode/36hXGoEpCSAPBj1O33tZqq
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker on Common Knowle… ‑ Scaling Theory ‑ Apple Podcasts podcasts.apple.com/fr/podcast/steven-pinker-on-common-kno…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fifty years ago I came to this country in the midst of its bicentennial celebration. It was dimmed by the recent catastrophic defeat in a divisive war and the first resignation of a sitting president, but the bicentennial was still an occasion for national unity and a celebration of democracy.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fifty years later the semiquincentennial is tainted by fears that the country is no longer a democracy. But the Supreme Court has slapped down many of the President's pet projects, and an electoral reckoning is coming this fall. Is the decline of US democracy hyperbole or reality? Quantitative Democracy indexes can calibrate our assessment: ourworldindata.org/democracy
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
V-Dem's Electoral Democracy Index is informative: The US has undeniably declined in democracy (.73 on a 0-1 scale, vs .91 in 2013 and .79 during the Bicentennial) but still no where near being an autocracy, and far freer than most of the world. ourworldindata.org/grapher/electoral-democracy-index?tab=…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Greatest Tradition of All: The glory of the United States is that it was founded on the Enlightenment ideal of universal human rights and government as a means to secure those rights with the consent of the governed. Matt Johnson @mattjj89 explains why the new Vance-Rubio theory of the USA as an ethnocracy is factually mistaken and morally atrocious. quillette.com/2026/07/02/the-greatest-tradition-of-all-je…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"No one really gets their morality from the Bible," thank goodness.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
“Both Steven Pinker and Michael Shermer reveal that they have no idea how to read the Bible. First, they fail to make the elementary distinction that not everything that is in the Bible is what the Bible teaches [...] It is a commonplace of Biblical interpretation that there are elements in Scripture that reflect cultural practices of the time but are not the stuff of revelation.”
Yes, exactly! These are stories for Iron-Age herders and farmers, not for us. That's the point @sapinker and I are making. No one today gets their morality from the Bible, and that's a good thing!
www.christianpost.com/news/catholic-bishop-responds-to-cr… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Not surprised by the new finding from the lab of Ev Fedorenko (a former grad student) at MIT that with lower activity thresholds, many more areas of the brain are engaged by language than the classic textbook areas. Language is inherently integrative: information must be coordinated from speech perception, articulatory planning, long-term memory of the rules of language and the context shared by speaker and hearer, the semantic content being conveyed, and the speaker's intentions in the social context. mcgovern.mit.edu/2026/07/01/the-brains-language-network-i…
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A new and somewhat different integrative model of language by my former postdoc and collaborator Greg Hickok: Wired for Words: The Neural Architecture of Language
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
And a related model of the brain's language network based on findings about developmental language impairments, coauthored by me and my late collaborator Heather van der Lely, though she deserves most of the credit: ttps://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1364661314001703?casa_token=wCHc8us_lvMAAAAA:rZGXUR8knB3kPArr8go-D55g9ay9m_-0SfIWwazdKr7z2-2fhG4qhPxQHi5-tRfPp9faVxFIOg
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A Mattering Guide to Love and Sex by Rebecca Newberger Goldstein @platobooktour open.substack.com/pub/rebeccanewbergergoldstein/p/a-matte…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Matt Ridley: We’re using the wrong pronouns for AI open.substack.com/pub/rationaloptimistsociety/p/ridley-we…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The AI future nobody is showing you | A more plausible vision, in my view, than either Utopia or doom. youtu.be/Besh6Xad5HU via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"When I was a graduate student in Harvard University’s psychology department, between 20 and 50 percent of students in any given discussion section I taught in 2024 and 2025 had disability accommodations. They were granted extra time on exams. Private testing rooms. Deadline extensions." @AdamOmaryPhD is talking about one of my courses here, and he rightly criticizes the upward ratchet in exploiting disability accommodation at elite universities. www.bostonglobe.com/2026/06/29/opinion/colleges-mental-ac… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker on Common Knowle… ‑ Scaling Theory ‑ Apple Podcasts podcasts.apple.com/fr/podcast/steven-pinker-on-common-kno…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge, From Eye Contact to the Super Bowl - Scaling Theory | Podcast on Spotify open.spotify.com/episode/36hXGoEpCSAPBj1O33tZqq
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker on The Scaling Theory Podcast: Common Knowledge, From Eye Contact to the Super Bowl youtu.be/ijNjY7E017E via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Languages express far more meanings than they have words (or parts of words, like prefixes, suffixes, and roots). All languages have ambiguity, polysemy, homophony, syncretism -- many-to-one mappings between meanings or functions and forms (opening the door to puns and verbal wit, as in Ben Franklin's "We must all hang together, lest we hang separately," and Mae West's "Marriage is a great institution, but I'm not ready for an institution yet.") The explanation is that there's a tradeoff between ease of coining and adoption (resulting in word forms being stretched, adapted, and recycled) and communication (hearers being clear on what the speaker is talking about). A new paper explores this tradeoff: The interaction of meaning similarity and confusability explains regularity in form–meaning mappings at and below the word level | Nature Human Behaviour www.nature.com/articles/s41562-026-02488-3
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Anyone who insists that the Bible is the source of morality either has not read it or is not intellectually serious about the question.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Will Texas students learn about the morality of the biblical warlords who had no qualms about taking multiple wives, adultery, keeping concubines, and fathering countless children from their many polygamous arrangements?
The anthropologist Laura Betzig has put these stories into an evolutionary context in noting that Darwin predicted that successful competition leads to successful reproduction. Betzig analyzed the Old Testament and found no less than 41 named polygamists, not one of which was a powerless man.
“In the Old Testament, powerful men—patriarchs, judges, and kings—have sex with more wives; they have more sex with other men’s women; they have sex with more concubines, servants, and slaves; and they father many children.”
And not just the big names. According to Betzig’s analysis, “men with bigger herds of sheep and goats tend to have sex with more women, then to father more children.”
Most of the polygynous patriarchs, judges, and kings had 2, 3, or 4 wives with a corresponding number of children, although King David had more than 8 wives and 20 children, King Abijah had 14 wives and 38 children, and King Rehoboam had 18 wives (and 60 other women) who bore him no fewer than 88 offspring.
But they were all lightweights compared to King Solomon (pictured below), who married at least 700 women, then for good measure added 300 concubines, which he called “man’s delight.”
What Solomon’s concubines called him was never recorded. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How long is a decapitated head conscious? How many senses do we really have? These and more in the link roundup by Steve Stuart Williams @SteveStuWill The Ideological Turing Test, Moral Double Standards, and Homosexuality in Rats open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/the-ideologi…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Journalism at its dumbest: Someone hacks into the guest list of a "secret exclusive right-wing Thiel-associated cabal which plots 'navigating WWIII' with 'their sex lives on the agenda.'" Turns out the meeting is not secretive, not right-wing, has nothing to do with Thiel, has had hundreds of journalists, bloggers, academics, artists, musicians politicians, scientists, etc., from all over the political spectrum, discussing thousands of topics. But no matter - someone said there was a furor, therefore there must have been a furor, therefore let's make it a furor!
www.thetimes.com/uk/technology-uk/article/peter-thiel-sec… -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Valuing Free Speech is correlated with being more tolerant. onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/kykl.70059
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Valuing Free Speech is correlated with being more tolerant. onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/kykl.70059
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Journalism at its dumbest: Someone hacks into the guest list of a "secret exclusive right-wing Thiel-associated cabal which plots 'navigating WWIII' with 'their sex lives on the agenda.'" Turns out the meeting is not secretive, not right-wing, has nothing to do with Thiel, has had hundreds of journalists, bloggers, academics, artists, musicians politicians, scientists, etc., from all over the political spectrum, discussing thousands of topics. But no matter - someone said there was a furor, therefore there must have been a furor, therefore let's make it a furor!
www.thetimes.com/uk/technology-uk/article/peter-thiel-sec… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How long is a decapitated head conscious? How many senses do we really have? These and more in the link roundup by Steve Stuart Williams @SteveStuWill The Ideological Turing Test, Moral Double Standards, and Homosexuality in Rats open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/the-ideologi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
And a slick new magazine (including a beautiful paper edition): Works in Progress Magazine worksinprogress.co
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An annual conference on progress, October in Berkeley – Roots of Progress Institute rootsofprogress.org/conference/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Edgy Optimist: Zachary Karabell | Substack substack.com/@zacharykarabell
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rational Optimist Society | community of thinkers www.rationaloptimistsociety.com
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Mathias Sundin - The Angry Optimist www.mathiassundin.org
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fix The News (formerly Future Crunch): excellent newsletter on positive developments worldwide | Angus Hervey | Substack fixthenews.com
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Some reports on progress: Doomslayer: Progress Roundup open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/doomslaye…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Anyone who insists that the Bible is the source of morality either has not read it or is not intellectually serious about the question.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Will Texas students learn about the morality of the biblical warlords who had no qualms about taking multiple wives, adultery, keeping concubines, and fathering countless children from their many polygamous arrangements?
The anthropologist Laura Betzig has put these stories into an evolutionary context in noting that Darwin predicted that successful competition leads to successful reproduction. Betzig analyzed the Old Testament and found no less than 41 named polygamists, not one of which was a powerless man.
“In the Old Testament, powerful men—patriarchs, judges, and kings—have sex with more wives; they have more sex with other men’s women; they have sex with more concubines, servants, and slaves; and they father many children.”
And not just the big names. According to Betzig’s analysis, “men with bigger herds of sheep and goats tend to have sex with more women, then to father more children.”
Most of the polygynous patriarchs, judges, and kings had 2, 3, or 4 wives with a corresponding number of children, although King David had more than 8 wives and 20 children, King Abijah had 14 wives and 38 children, and King Rehoboam had 18 wives (and 60 other women) who bore him no fewer than 88 offspring.
But they were all lightweights compared to King Solomon (pictured below), who married at least 700 women, then for good measure added 300 concubines, which he called “man’s delight.”
What Solomon’s concubines called him was never recorded. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Languages express far more meanings than they have words (or parts of words, like prefixes, suffixes, and roots). All languages have ambiguity, polysemy, homophony, syncretism -- many-to-one mappings between meanings or functions and forms (opening the door to puns and verbal wit, as in Ben Franklin's "We must all hang together, lest we hang separately," and Mae West's "Marriage is a great institution, but I'm not ready for an institution yet.") The explanation is that there's a tradeoff between ease of coining and adoption (resulting in word forms being stretched, adapted, and recycled) and communication (hearers being clear on what the speaker is talking about). A new paper explores this tradeoff: The interaction of meaning similarity and confusability explains regularity in form–meaning mappings at and below the word level | Nature Human Behaviour www.nature.com/articles/s41562-026-02488-3
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
For more on how words come to express thoughts: The Stuff of Thought: Language as a Window Into Human Nature. stevenpinker.com/publications/stuff-thought-language-wind…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
More videos from the Aumannfest in Paris 2 weeks ago (marking the 50th anniversary of the Israeli mathematician Robert Aumann's famous theorem that rational agents with the same understanding of the world who share their assessments of some hypothesis (make them common knowledge) cannot agree to disagree).
Aran Nayebi
@aran_nayebi
How did Aumann's agreement theorem come to be?
I've uploaded the full video👇from Nobel laureate Bob Aumann's 96th birthday conference in Paris, celebrating 50 years of “Agreeing to Disagree.”
At 1:11:09, I ask Aumann about meeting von Neumann & Morgenstern, their influence on his career, and at 1:00:53 how Nash encouraged him to switch from knot theory to game theory.
My own talk on AI safety and agreement-based complexity starts at 2:01.
The Aumann panel discussion starts at 34:49.
Turn captions on for best experience. Link + full timestamps below.👇 -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Crisis in the Humanities Is Not About Money: "Critical theory did not merely politicize scholarship. It made scholarship easier to produce" (anyone could get a dissertation out of showing that some work was really an instrument of oppression). Abraham Wyner cites a phenomenon I've long noticed: for an academic movement to get traction, it has to give grad students & junior scholars something to do. Chomsky dominated linguistics in part because he revised his theory every decade or so, sending linguists scrambling to reanalyze every construction in the new theory's terms. In the 80s and 90s neural networks spawned hundreds of papers called "A Connectionist Model of X," followed by the cognitive neuroscience revolution in which anyone could get a thesis out of sticking people in a magnet while they did some familiar experimental task. quillette.com/2026/06/26/the-crisis-in-the-humanities-is-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If critical thinking skills are so fragile that they can erode when people use AI, those skills could not have been robustly taught in the first place.
www.insidehighered.com/opinion/views/2026/06/23/we-have-n…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One way to impart critical thinking skills: www.amazon.com/Rationality-What-Seems-Scarce-Matters/dp/0…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Society Explained — 100 Theories of How Society Works society.clearerthinking.org
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Including the site's rendition of MY theory of how society works: society.clearerthinking.org
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
AI poses risks, like any technology, but it's not going to be the end of the world, Maarten Boudry @mboudry explains | Why AI Is Not About to Go Feral open.substack.com/pub/quillette/p/why-ai-is-not-about-to-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The rational optimist’s guide to using AI open.substack.com/pub/rationaloptimistsociety/p/the-ratio…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The keynote panel of Nobel Laureate Robert Aumann 96th Birthday Conference in Paris: 50 Years of "Agreeing to Disagree" (on the Israeli mathematician's famous theorem that if rational agents have the same understanding of the world and share their conclusions (i.e., they are common knowledge), those conclusions must be the same). youtu.be/WD_OQbNzml4 via @YouTube
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
And of course this one: www.youtube.com/shorts/0Uh8lSJBykI
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
For more on recursive mentalizing, common knowledge, and why (according to Aumann) we should not agree to disagree: www.amazon.com/s?k=pinker+when+everyone+knows&adgrpid=185…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Another example of the "...His name is..." formula. But this is an important finding, and long a cornerstone of behavioral genetics (while flying over the head of its critics): Many aspects of the environment are heritable. (Yes, you read that right.) Our genes steer us into different environments - people practice and enrich themselves in ways that multiply their innate talents and interests. It's sometimes called "gene-environment interaction," but most of the time that's technically inaccurate: it's "gene-environment correlation."
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Dealing with religious nationalists (and therefore God) in Israel and Iran, by John Mueller open.substack.com/pub/muellerbbbb/p/dealing-with-religiou…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Here's my schedule of live events this fall (which, masochistically, I'll be doing in alternation with lectures in my intro course at Harvard): stevenpinker.com/media-and-appearances
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
People find this claim incredible since everyone insists they are crazy-busy today, but it's well established (and in Enlightenment Now I note the sanity check from my own family: I remember my grandparents working six day a week, early morning to early evening.)
Human Progress
@HumanProgress
Working hours tend to fall as incomes rise.
Between 1950 and 2024, the average hours worked per worker in wealthy countries declined from over 2,100 per year to under 1,800. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Good to see the brilliant work of Phil Tetlock touted and explained, but if I had to summarize his finding in a single sentence, I wouldn't have picked one about conflicts of interests, but rather about active-open mindedness (or else Bayesian reasoning). But this tweet raises another question: the structure of this piece has become a formula on X. (Opening paragraph with surprising and apparently obscure finding, followed by a single-sentence paragraph: "His name is X.") AI-generated, or just a contagious formula?
Millie Marconi
@MillieMarconnni
A government-funded tournament put thousands of ordinary people against CIA intelligence analysts in a 4-year contest to predict world events, and the amateurs won so decisively that the CIA had to fundamentally rethink how it forecasts the future.
The professor who ran the tournament is Philip Tetlock.
He teaches at Wharton. Daniel Kahneman called the book he wrote about the result the most important decision-making book since Thinking, Fast and Slow.
The story actually starts 20 years earlier.
Tetlock spent two decades collecting 28,000 predictions from 284 of the world's most famous experts. Professors. Government officials. Journalists. Policy advisors. People with PhDs and TV shows. People who got paid huge sums to predict elections, wars, and economic crises.
When he scored their predictions against what actually happened, the average expert performed at roughly the level of random guessing. The most famous experts, the ones who appeared most often on TV, turned out to be the worst predictors of all. The more confident they sounded, the more wrong they tended to be.
That study became one of the most cited findings in modern psychology. The famous summary line was that experts were no better than monkeys throwing darts.
In 2011, the US intelligence community decided to test this finding directly.
They funded a tournament called the Good Judgment Project. Tens of thousands of ordinary volunteers were recruited to predict global events. Will North Korea launch a missile in the next 6 months. Will the Eurozone admit a new member by year-end. Will a specific dictator still be in power 12 months from now.
The volunteers were put up against the CIA's own intelligence analysts, who had access to classified information the volunteers did not have.
The amateurs won by 30 percent.
The CIA had to absorb the fact that a group of people sitting at home on their laptops, with nothing but a Google search bar and good thinking habits, were outpredicting their own paid professionals on the questions the professionals had spent their entire careers training for.
A small group of these volunteers were dramatically better than even the other amateurs. Tetlock called them superforecasters.
They had nothing in common on paper. One was a Brooklyn filmmaker. One was a retired pipe installer. One was a former ballroom dancer. They were not domain experts. They had no insider access. They were ordinary people with ordinary jobs.
Tetlock spent years figuring out what they did differently. The answer is almost insulting in its simplicity.
They did not think in yes or no. They thought in percentages. They did not say "Russia will invade." They said "there is a 65 percent chance Russia will invade in the next 12 months, and here are the three things I would update on."
They were not loyal to their first answer. The moment new evidence came in, they updated. Most experts treat changing their mind as a sign of weakness. Superforecasters treat refusing to change their mind as the actual weakness.
They knew many small things instead of one big thing. The famous experts almost all believed in one big theory and forced every problem to fit it. The superforecasters used many small theories and switched between them depending on the situation in front of them.
They kept score on themselves. Most experts never go back and check whether their past predictions came true. Superforecasters track everything, especially their mistakes. They study their own failures the way most people refuse to.
They were comfortable saying "I don't know."
The deeper lesson of the book is the one most readers miss the first time through.
The reason experts are bad at predictions is not that they lack intelligence. It is that their identity is tied to being right. Once you have built a career, a brand, or a public following on being the person who knows, you lose the freedom to think clearly. You start defending positions instead of updating them. You start protecting your reputation instead of testing your beliefs.
The ordinary people who became superforecasters had no reputation to protect. Their thinking was free.
The book is 352 pages. It can be summarized in one line.
The people who see the future most clearly are the ones with the least to lose by being wrong.
Which means the question worth asking yourself is this. Where in your own life are you defending an old belief simply because changing your mind would cost you something it would not actually cost you anything to lose? -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Stop treating energy as something to atone for. Energy is the master resource, the thing that buys us nearly every other good. The whole of human history is the story of harnessing ever more energy to improve our lives and to hold the lethal forces of nature at bay." The imperative is to accelerate abundant carbon-free energy (including the n-word). | How Europe Became the World Champion of Heat Deaths quillette.com/2026/06/24/how-europe-became-the-world-cham…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Genophobia inhibits docs from sharing genetic information about newborns with their parents. My colleague Dr Daniela Lamas argues such paternalism is unjustified | Would You Want to Know Your Baby’s Genetic Future? www.nytimes.com/2026/06/22/opinion/infants-genetic-screen…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Central bankers have to avoid generating the common knowledge that fuels self-fulfilling bubbles and busts. Hence the late Alan Greenspan: “I spend a substantial amount of my time endeavoring to fend off questions and worry terribly I might end up being too clear,” he joked in 1995. | Alan Greenspan, who piloted the economy through two decades of global upheaval but who critics say fell short on financial regulation, has died. He was 100. www.wsj.com/economy/central-banking/alan-greenspan-fed-ch… via @WSJ
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I quote a coach, asked about whether in the future kids will be put on teams based on their genomes. He said, wisely, I have a better idea: let's let them run and see who's fastest.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"We Have to Stop Freaking Out About A.I." warns Nobel laureate Robert Shiller. Depressions, formerly called panics, are caused by self-fulfilling fears (the only thing we have to fear is fear itself), i.e., common knowledge about those very fears. www.nytimes.com/2026/06/22/opinion/ai-doom-jobs-economy.h…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
For more on this dynamic, see When Everyone Knows That Everyone Know...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. www.amazon.com/s?k=when+everyone+knows+that+everyone+know…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Genophobia inhibits docs from sharing genetic information about newborns with their parents. My colleague Dr Daniela Lamas argues such paternalism is unjustified | Would You Want to Know Your Baby’s Genetic Future? www.nytimes.com/2026/06/22/opinion/infants-genetic-screen…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Thanks to another colleague, George Church, I was one of the first people to be genotyped, and agreed to post my genome on my website (together with a scan of my brain). The NYT invited me to write about the experience, and put me on the cover the Sunday magazine; the article was called "My genome, myself" (a play on the 1970s classic Our Bodies, Ourselves). www.nytimes.com/2009/01/11/magazine/11Genome-t.html?unloc…
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The probabilistic and distributed nature of genetic information (now sometimes called The Fourth Law of Behavioral Genetics: heritable traits are influenced by vast numbers of genes each with tiny effects) was what emboldened me to sign on: except for certain diseases, genomes allow much weaker prediction than examining the whole person.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I quote a coach, asked about whether in the future kids will be put on teams based on their genomes. He said, wisely, I have a better idea: let's let them run and see who's fastest.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Me:
One cannot charitably credit them with trying to restore academic freedom in universities. The extreme assault by the Trump administration on parts of Harvard had nothing to do with the suppression of speech, such as in the science and engineering departments. The agenda is really to cripple civil society organizations that might be centers of opposition, in the same way they had gone after the media, after law firms, and after other branches of government.
Kmele Foster (@kmele) of @wethefifth:
If I was going to try to sort of steelman the position of people on the right, they would say: you already lost a lot of those institutions in the sciences proper. You mentioned Nature earlier and the fact that they weren’t unwilling to publish certain things that were inconvenient to them with respect to their political convictions. Does that not justify the Trump administration kind of taking a much harder line?
Me:
Well, no. Among the legitimate functions of government stipulated in the Constitution, policing scientific journals is not one of them. But in any case, it wasn’t as if they singled out research projects at Harvard that flouted standards of scientific excellence by prioritizing political correctness over truth. It was an across-the-board zeroing of funding.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Overall, across the world, there’s reason to believe that happiness has increased for obvious reasons: people are living longer, they’re less poor, they’re better educated, and so on. That would suggest, though not prove, that there has not been a decline in meaningfulness. It’s still possible, but just anecdotally, there have been complaints that life is meaningless as far back as you can go.
You know: Ecclesiastes—“Vanity of vanities, all is vanity.” Henry David Thoreau, in 1854: “The mass of men lead lives of quiet desperation.” Now, how a guy living in a cabin on a pond could know this is unclear, but that was the perception. T.S. Eliot: “We are the hollow men, we are the stuffed men,” in the 1920s.
Starting in the 1950s, there was a great fear of alienation. That was the big issue, and part of the counterculture was the idea that suburban middle-class life was meaningless, empty, plastic, and artificial. The Pursuit of Loneliness, a 1970 bestseller by Philip Slater. Jimmy Carter’s “malaise” speech in the late 1970s.
So it’s a constant complaint. The fact that people say it doesn’t necessarily mean it’s true."
@HumanProgressThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Obituary for the cognitive scientist Dr. Kevin Niall Dunbar 1956 - 2026 | Montreal Gazette montrealgazette.remembering.ca/obituary/kevin-dunbar-1093…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Another trend in human progress that has continued since I published Better Angels in 2011 and Enlightenment Now in 2018.
Human Progress
@HumanProgress
Few attitudes have changed as fast as this one.
In 1990, 78% of Americans expressed intolerance toward homosexuality. By 2025, that had fallen to just 33%. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Time-Traveling Along Route 66, in Cars of the Past, Present and Future www.nytimes.com/2026/05/23/us/route-66-100-years-cars.html
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
And here:
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Despite the gloom about the recent democratic backsliding, a new study shows, "The majority of democracy-eroding presidents and prime ministers do stand down, mostly because they fail to be reelected or are barred by term limits from running again. And the majority of those who leave office are replaced by others who respect and hope to rebuild their democracies’ institutions." | Journal of Democracy www.journalofdemocracy.org/online-exclusive/how-aspiring-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Adapting an experimental paradigm for neuroimaging I devised with Ned Sahin & Eric Halgren, a team of neurolinguists has found "a single 'grammatical engine' in the brain appeared capable of powering multiple languages at once." www.nytimes.com/2026/06/15/science/brain-language-grammar…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Here's their paper (PDF of the whole paper is available, open access): www.jneurosci.org/content/early/2026/06/04/JNEUROSCI.2341…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
And here's ours (unfortunately, not open access): www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0010945208…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The first law of educational outcomes: Selection effects (what kind of student enters a program or school) trumps treatment effects (what they teach). Because it's politically incorrect to think about differences among kids, these get confused, and no one notices the mediocre and ineffective instruction (many do notice the importance of the peer group). It's a reminder of a major lesson from the late Judith Rich Harris: If you pretend as if genetic differences don't exist, you'll misunderstand the effects of the environment. \ The real problem with “gifted” education, by @mattyglesias - open.substack.com/pub/matthewyglesias/p/the-real-problem-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Conceptual Form: The Hidden Structure of Commonsense Concepts. Forthcoming book by my former student and coauthor, Prof. Sandeep Prasada. mitpress.mit.edu/9780262053136/conceptual-form/
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One of our papers was a simple but prescient (in my view) demonstration of a fundamental limitation of artificial neural networks, the basis of today's AI: Generalization to out-of-sample cases which are dissimilar to anything in the training set. www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/01690969308406948
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
AI Companies: Stop the self-serving and fatalistic doom-trolling. [The companies should] "stop treating A.I. like some inevitable force that they’re struggling to steward. It’s not. It’s a collection of specific tools that these companies are choosing to design and sell according to specific business plans. Accordingly, they need to talk about their offerings like any other consumer product. This means explaining clearly whom these products are for, justifying their benefits and, critically, taking full responsibility for any harm they might cause. Just because A.I. currently enjoys a high-tech sheen doesn’t make it exceptional with respect to common-sense safety standards." www.nytimes.com/2026/06/17/opinion/ai-dangerous-openai-an…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My photo of the beautiful Anesthesia Monument in the Boston Public Garden. magazine.hms.harvard.edu/articles/what-happens-brain-unde…)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Anesthesia may be humanity's greatest achievement, alleviating inconceivably vast amounts of suffering, and delivering profound evidence on the most fundamental question of existence, our own consciousness: the fact that chemicals can turn it on and off shows that it is a physical process. My Harvard colleague Emery Brown is studying how it works (believe it or not, we don't fully know) and how it can be administered without post-op delirium and dysfunction (his proposal for "closed-loop" real-time EEG monitoring and automatic calibration is a, pardon me, no-brainer). | What Happens to the Brain Under Anesthesia | Harvard Medicine Magazine magazine.hms.harvard.edu/articles/what-happens-brain-unde…)
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard to America: You're welcome.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One of my favorite sculptures in the world is the Anesthesia Monument in the Boston Public Garden. Not clear why the doc is in a Moorish getup, but I find it tremendously moving. www.stevepinker.com/Boston/Boston-VII/i-TqPwMzB/A
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
50 Years of The Selfish Gene. In my experience, its main message has not sunk in half a century later, even among scientists: one often reads an ingenuous "adaptive explanation" of this or that trait (music, rituals, religion) as "bonding the group," without any awareness that this is not what the theory of natural selection is about or that it is in any way problematic. Dawkins began The Selfish Gene by awakening readers to this fallacy, but it's as if he never wrote it. freethinker.co.uk/2026/06/crystallising-darwinism-50-year… via @freethinkermag
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Yes, I know that some people have tried to outline more sophisticated versions of "group selection," but I and (as best I can tell) most mainstream evolutionary biologists believe this is a muddle; see my essay "The False Allure of Group Selection." www.edge.org/conversation/steven_pinker-the-false-allure-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Public Support for foreign wars, by John Mueller. "Americans today have a far lower tolerance for American casualties..." open.substack.com/pub/muellerbbbb/p/public-support-for-fo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Naked Truths: The Logic of Who Knows What – (German-language review of When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...) Schweizer Monat schweizermonat.ch/the-logic-of-who-knows-what/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Price of Denying Human Nature – Schweizer Monat schweizermonat.ch/the-price-of-denying-human-nature/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This is a pretty good overview of the main points inThe Sense of Style. (It also has a chapter on "Telling Right from Wrong" -- how to think about prescriptive rules like dangling participles and lie vs lay.)
Mayank Vora
@aiwithmayank
Steven Pinker is a Harvard psychologist who wrote the only style guide based on how the brain actually reads.
Here are 10 writing fixes from "The Sense of Style" rooted in cognitive science, not grammar rules.
1) The curse of knowledge ruins more writing than laziness -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fascinating to see classic issues in cognitive science play out in interpreting LLMs: Is there an abstract "language of thought" distinct from the thinker's spoken language? Are ideas represented in discrete units (the proverbial "grandmother cell" or "yellow Volkswagen detector") or are they statistically smeared over large vectors? What's the distinction between transient working memory, represented as dynamic activation levels, and permanent long-term memory, represented as stable weights (a distinction D. O. Hebb made in the 1940s)? Yascha Mounk interviews David Bau on How—and Whether—Artificial Intelligence Thinks open.substack.com/pub/yaschamounk/p/david-bau-2?r=17uk7
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Also relevant to safe, trustworthy AI: More straightforward when representations are discrete and interpretable than when they are implicit in patterns of millions of parameters.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Data on the Trump Slump in different religions, by @ryanburge. Atheists and agnostics hate him the most. Contrary to an opinion I've heard literally for 50 years (Ford-Carter '76 ), Jews have not flocked to the GOP: 35% approve of Trump, compared to 40% nationwide. His support comes overwhelmingly from white Christians (particularly the conservative denominations), but that support is plunging, especially among younger Americans. open.substack.com/pub/ryanburge/p/faith-and-the-voting-bo…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rename the Williamsburg Bridge after Sonny Rollins! www.nytimes.com/2026/06/14/opinion/sonny-rollins-williams…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I read Zinsser (together with every other major style manual) while writing The Sense of Style, and his book is indeed very good. (It's the only one that advises on how to get one sentence to flow into the next, which differentiates smooth and coherent from choppy prose.) But like every manual that is innocent of linguistics, it botches the obligatory advice to avoid the passive, and like Orwell and Strunk and White, it can't help but use the passive in its own advice to avoid the passive ("what is being perpetrated").
Mayank Vora
@aiwithmayank
William Zinsser taught writing at Yale, then wrote the book that has fixed more bad writing than every English class combined.
Here are 10 cuts from "On Writing Well" that instantly make your writing twice as strong.
1) Delete every word doing no work
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The thinking person's guide to writing in the 21st century: www.amazon.com/Sense-Style-Thinking-Persons-Writing/dp/01…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rename the Williamsburg Bridge after Sonny Rollins! www.nytimes.com/2026/06/14/opinion/sonny-rollins-williams…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
With @wethefifth talking about common knowledge:
“Common knowledge can be generated at a stroke when something is witnessed in a forum where you can witness other people witnessing it. So if something just happens in public and you can see everyone else seeing it, that gives you an instant intuition that there’s common knowledge.
Humor, I suggest in one of the chapters, is a common-knowledge generator, usually of some infirmity or indignity or weakness in someone or something. And the laughter, which is conspicuous—you can hear it when someone is laughing; it interrupts their speech and breathing—at the moment of laughter, suddenly becomes common knowledge. Everyone who gets the joke suddenly realizes that someone has been taken down, and they realize that everyone else realizes it.
And that’s why freedom of speech and freedom of assembly are suppressed in autocracies. The joke from the Soviet era is about the man handing out leaflets in Red Square. Of course, the KGB arrest him, take him down to headquarters, only to discover that the leaflets are blank sheets of paper. They say, ‘What is the meaning of this?’ And he says, ‘What’s there to say? It’s so obvious.’
And the reason that it was subversive is that he was generating common knowledge. Just the mere fact of trying to make something public, even if you don’t have to stipulate what it is, can generate the coordination—everyone acting together to bring down a regime.”This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life:
www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/B0DV… -
Steven Pinker reposted
The Fifth Column 🖐
@wethefifth
The spiral of silence may explain more about public opinion than ideology does.
Steven Pinker (@sapinker) joins us on the new Fifth Column, out now.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"To embrace the poisonous nonsense of degrowth now — to shut down nuclear power plants, to regulate the AI industry out of existence, to forcibly shorten working hours, to bar the construction of houses and factories, etc. — would be to cripple one of the last few remaining economic engines of the free world, at precisely the time when it’s under its greatest external challenge." @Noahpinion open.substack.com/pub/noahpinion/p/degrowth-would-make-eu…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My own alleged optimism bears on an important issue that came up in the conference to mark the 50th anniversary of Aumann's theorem that if rational agents have the same priors and their posteriors are common knowledge, those posteriors must be the same (they cannot "agree to disagree"). How reasonable is the stipulation that rational agents have the same priors (i.e., their understanding of how the world works before they examine the evidence relevant to a hypothesis). Aren't people with different temperaments, e.g., optimists and pessimists, expected to have different priors?
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fifty Years of "Agreeing to Disagree": Honored to have spoken today at a conference at the Sorbonne marking the 50th anniversary of Robert Aumann's famous theorem proving that rational people may not agree to disagree, with the 96-year-old Aumann in attendance.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"To embrace the poisonous nonsense of degrowth now — to shut down nuclear power plants, to regulate the AI industry out of existence, to forcibly shorten working hours, to bar the construction of houses and factories, etc. — would be to cripple one of the last few remaining economic engines of the free world, at precisely the time when it’s under its greatest external challenge." @Noahpinion open.substack.com/pub/noahpinion/p/degrowth-would-make-eu…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"There is a real resistance to standardized testing that has broken the brains of some folks. They interpret evidence completely backwards (like this NYMagazine article)."
Jay Van Bavel, PhD
@jayvanbavel
There is a real resistence to standardized testing that has broken the brains of some folks. They interpret evidence completely backwards (like this NYMagazine article). What is clear evidence of predictive validty gets spun as clear evidence of a failure.
I've seen this for too many years, with SAT and GRE tests too, to believe it's an isolated error. Instead, it's a systemic ideological failure. People are unwilling to look at the evidence in an open-minded way and draw accurate conclusions. And they don't have the institutional checks and balances to root out biases.
This is a serious problem that extends beyond magazines to our leading universities that repealed standardized tests and are now dealing all the problems this has created. It also reduces public trust in these institutions. I have a subscription to NYMagazine and this issue makes me trust the magazine less.
The only solution is that these institutions and organizations need to issue a correction, re-examine their editorial policies, hire staff who have the analytic skills to evaluate this type of data, and then listen to those staff. This is what it will take to earn and sustain the trust of the public. Making the same mistake over and over again only reveals that they don't care about accuracy. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Sam Harris explains: "Why I Won’t Debate Critics of Israel" open.substack.com/pub/samharris/p/why-i-wont-debate-criti…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Residual functional capacity may persist in late-stage neurodegeneration and may become transiently accessible under specific neuromodulatory conditions." Further refutation of the ludicrous argument by Charles Murray and others that "terminal lucidity" in dying patients is evidence for an immaterial soul re-entering the body to say a last goodbye to loved ones. www.frontiersin.org/journals/neuroscience/articles/10.338…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What If AI Chatbots Are Saving Lives? Don't ban them based on anecotes, say @adamomaryphd and Jennifer Huddleston open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/what-if-a…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Indeed, but cultural and intellectual publications (especially those with "New York" in their title) are consistently unintelligent when writing about intelligence. (Obvious political reason: If we aren't blank slates, then not all inequality can be blamed on injustice, threatening a certain kind of leftist thought. Therefore anything questioning the blank slate - even the in-your-face reality that some people are smarter than others - must be discredited.)
Jay Van Bavel, PhD
@jayvanbavel
This is embarassing for @NYMag -- these "gifted" children were about 30X more likely to acheive eminence than their peers. By any standard that is not a "mirage", but the embodiment of whatever metric identified them as gifted.
It's one thing if their writers don't understand baserates and probabilities, but this should have never gotten through editorial review. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Variant: Pessimists sound like they're trying to help you. Optimists sound like they're trying to sell you something.
Peter H. Diamandis, MD
@PeterDiamandis
Pessimists sound smart.
Optimists build the world.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
And my favorite, from Boyan Slat: "Problem-solvers take an issue and cut it up into small, solvable chunks. Problem-sellers do the opposite: bundling various remotely-connected issues together into one big, scary problem. The consequence is that problem-sellers make problems look insurmountable when they're not." (Boyan knows a thing or two about this: He has done more than anyone to keep plastic trash out of the oceans.)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Actually, the SAT Was Necessary After All - The Atlantic www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/06/standardized-testing-ma…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I told you so. newrepublic.com/article/119321/harvard-ivy-league-should-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Mental Health Crisis—or Crisis of Overdiagnosis? By @AdamOmaryPhD profectusmag.com/mental-health-crisis-or-crisis-of-overdi… via @Profectus Magazine
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Life imitates game theory. Here’s a true story: I’m flying into New York from Paris today, and Rebecca is going in from Boston. We’re looking forward to a day of walking around the city, with no particular destination. But we almost missed each other’s calls last night and could have arrrived without having set a rendezvous place and time. I swear this really almost happened. Fortunately we know our Thomas
Schelling (I wrote about the rendezvous game in When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows….). For those who don’t: Where would we have met? -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From deconstructionism to destructive. open.substack.com/pub/quillette/p/the-destructivists?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A moving sight: Notre Dame de Paris, restored 5 years after a devastating fire by 1,000 craftspeople, reviving medieval techniques, supported by >300,000 donations -- a testament to what humanity can accomplish when people work together toward a constructive goal.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Parisian monument to L'Abee de L'Epee, the Enlightenment-era priest who observed deaf children signing, invented his own sign language, and founded the first free school for the deaf (still standing, and the site of the memorial). His language was too cumbersome to catch on outside the school (the community evolved its own French Sign Language), but he deserves credit for the recognition, formal education and enfranchisement of the deaf in France and from there, around the world.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My own alleged optimism bears on an important issue that came up in the conference to mark the 50th anniversary of Aumann's theorem that if rational agents have the same priors and their posteriors are common knowledge, those posteriors must be the same (they cannot "agree to disagree"). How reasonable is the stipulation that rational agents have the same priors (i.e., their understanding of how the world works before they examine the evidence relevant to a hypothesis). Aren't people with different temperaments, e.g., optimists and pessimists, expected to have different priors?
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fifty Years of "Agreeing to Disagree": Honored to have spoken today at a conference at the Sorbonne marking the 50th anniversary of Robert Aumann's famous theorem proving that rational people may not agree to disagree, with the 96-year-old Aumann in attendance.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The response is "no": which genes for temperament you inherent is irrelevant to what's true about the world, so a rational optimist would discount her optimism, likewise for a rational pessimist. That's why I resist the common epithet (meant as a compliment) that I'm an "optimist." This may be true (everyone who know my dad described him as an optimist), but it's irrelevant to whether the world is getting better; that case has to rest entirely on the data, and I consciously check myself to avoid any genetic tendency to spin-doctor it in a positive direction (a cynic, or someone versed in the literature on self-deception, might say "not enough").
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I've have the same exchange many times!
Peter H. Diamandis, MD
@PeterDiamandis
People ask me how I stay so optimistic. The honest answer: I read the data, not the headlines.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Every moral philosophy student learns the contrast between utilitarian & deontological approaches to morality, & many more were exposed to it when the trolley problem went viral in the 2000s (throw the man in front of the train to save 5 = util; don't = deont). In this essay Rebecca Goldstein shows a deeper commonality: both embody the conviction that everyone matters. open.substack.com/pub/rebeccanewbergergoldstein/p/chew-on…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rebecca goes beyond this to put a secular basis for universal mattering on even deeper foundations: the way that our own mattering is baked into every choice we make, and this cannot coherently be confined to ourselves but must be generalized to others; that our longing to matter intrinsically makes us matter; and that our own indignation when our interests are threatened commits entails a symmetry in which others' interests command the same respect.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
All this shows how everyone can matter even if there is no deity to whom we matter.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Chew on That, Professor! It may be trite it is to assert that every person matters. But how do you go about proving it? Rebecca Goldstein @platobooktour shows how. open.substack.com/pub/rebeccanewbergergoldstein/p/chew-on…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fifty Years of "Agreeing to Disagree": Honored to have spoken today at a conference at the Sorbonne marking the 50th anniversary of Robert Aumann's famous theorem proving that rational people may not agree to disagree, with the 96-year-old Aumann in attendance.
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Together with his brilliance, Aumann is a mensch, and was generous and patient in helping me explain his counterintuitive theorem to a wide audience in When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows... .
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The conference is filled with other Israelis, who are some of the world's greatest game theorists. This underscores the imbecility of the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement: in order to indulge in (dubious) virtue signaling, academics are willing to give themselves a lobotomy, extirpating what should be the most precious resource for scholars, knowledge.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fame, Incels, and the Need to Matter: Rebecca Goldstein @platobooktour on the Behavioral Grooves podcast behavioralgrooves.com/episode/fame-incels-and-the-need-to…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Enlightenment values are a sounder vision for the West than tribe and faith, argues Francis Fukuyama (not surprisingly , I agree) open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/europe-dont-abandon-t…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why So Many People Feel Lost: A conversation between Nick Gillespie and Rebecca Goldstein on the search for meaning, the roots of modern discontent, and how people build purpose in a secular age. reason.com/podcast/2026/06/10/why-so-many-people-feel-lost/ via @reason
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Ever wonder what "the subjunctive" really is? A tense? A mood? Is it disappearing from modern English? And what's the deal with were in If I were a carpenter? All this and more in: The Sense of Style: The Thinking Person's Guide to Writing in the 21st Century: 9780143127796: Pinker, Steven: Books www.amazon.com/Sense-Style-Thinking-Persons-Writing/dp/01…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rick Smith (@AxonRick):
So here’s my thesis. In the context of policing, the use of lethal force is not state-sanctioned execution. Police never use lethal force for the purpose of killing someone. They use lethal force because it’s reliable. We don’t have a sufficiently 100% reliable, immediate-effect non-lethal weapon. And my personal belief is that once we deliver that—a truly effective, immediate non-lethal weapon—it would actually obviate the need to ever use lethal force in policing.
Now, it’s a long road to get there, and I’m not suggesting we would ever disarm the police, but our goal is to get to the point where they have so much faith in a weapon that works so well, and potentially with drones and robots, where they’re not putting their own personal safety on the line and they can make even more rational, less self-interested decisions, and we can drive the number very close to zero.
Me:
I know. I think that’s profound, and for a lot of people, it just takes a while for that to sink in because we think about violence and violence reduction in moralistic terms—good people and bad people, and justice, and so on. And the idea that we can use our ingenuity to reduce the amount of killing, if we decide that’s something we want to do, it takes a—
Rick Smith:
I’ve decided that.
Me:
Exactly.
Full episode here: youtu.be/ZsYkLHJfM_M -
Steven Pinker reposted
-
Steven Pinker reposted
The Fifth Column 🖐
@wethefifth
Where did the idea that sexual assault is motivated "by power" originate?
From our latest episode with the great Steven Pinker.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
The Fifth Column 🖐
@wethefifth
Steven Pinker’s new book explores how public life unravels once common knowledge disappears and every fact becomes politically negotiable.
From the new episode of The Fifth Column with @sapinker.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Axon
@axon_enterprise
"A truly effective, immediate non-lethal weapon would actually obviate the need to ever use lethal force."
For the first time, the Boldly Go Podcast was recorded live on stage in front of 3,000 people. @AxonRick and @MikeWagers welcomed special guest @sapinker, world-renowned cognitive scientist, Harvard professor and bestselling author, to explore reducing violence in public safety.
Catch the full episode here: youtu.be/ZsYkLHJfM_M
#axon #protectlife -
Steven Pinker reposted
Human Progress
@HumanProgress
Is there truly a "crisis of meaning?"
@sapinker discusses on our podcast.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Thinkable
@thinkableevents
Explore Platonism in mathematics and its implications with philosopher @platobooktour.
Unveil the search for universal principles and the role of Platonism in debates about abstract entities.
Watch now: youtu.be/cqRdvjo0gqQ -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Brian Keating (@Briankeating) and Rebecca Newberger Goldstein (@platobooktour) discuss "The Physics of Mattering: Do AI Agents Have a Soul"
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein: God forbid if these AI agents begin to have a longing to matter, we have our non-carbon-based humans. We’re going to have to think about their rights.
Brian Keating: She is a philosopher who trained in physics, and she just told me that AI might deserve human rights. Here is her argument.
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein: The other obsession with this verb “matter,” that we are creatures of matter who long to matter — you can only say that in English. But I’m so glad you could say that in English because it’s, again, incredibly poignant.
We’re creatures of matter who are subject to the laws of physics, the second law of thermodynamics, but we long to matter. And so much of the book is trying to explain that, how that transformation within us, within our species, happens. That’s a normative transformation, an ethical transformation, and it’s really what distinguishes us: that we, in some sense, want to justify the fact that we matter so much to ourselves, that we pay so much attention to ourselves.
We actually can pinpoint the place in human history where this emerged, during the period when all the religions emerged that are still extant, which is so interesting. Also, Western philosophy emerged during the period of history that’s called the Axial Age.
Brian Keating: I do think things have changed for the better, as far as, you know, paternity leave. I’ve taken advantage of that. But I guess the ultimate expression — and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with it — I mean, I think that women sacrifice a lot more. I think also we have a crisis with men and boys and so forth, and now you have grandsons, and you can appreciate it. You probably appreciated this even before you had daughters.
But the book is full of these things ranging, as you said, from Aristotle to the Chinese one-child policy that you talk about at the end of the book. It’s heart-wrenching, Rebecca.
But I guess, as we come in for a landing, the fear that a lot of people have nowadays is about artificial intelligence replacing what we derive our sense of mattering from. And you quote Freud in the book. Freud said all of life is work and love. And if AI can replace the work of knowledge workers like you and me, and it can replace the love because of things like Character AI and all these artificial relationships that don’t require me to go out and ask a woman on a date — or nowadays, for men — I want to ask you the question: can AI have a mattering instinct, or is it encoded in this wet supercomputer that we carry on our shoulders? Is it possible that AI is making everyone feel that redundancy is threatening to us? Will AI rob us of our mattering?
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein: Yeah, so there are two different questions there. One is really, I think, already upon us, maybe already here: that some of the most creative ways of appeasing our mattering instinct will be superseded by what AI can do. It can prove math theorems faster, make discoveries in science, write novels, write music, paint pictures. Some of the most creative things that have led to flourishing and led to great achievements that we can all take pride in.
I take great pride in our species producing Bach and Shakespeare and Michael Jordan — I’m a big basketball fan. I mean, we mere mortals, and look what we can do. But they’ll be able to do it better. I think this is going to be a real problem.
Here’s one thing I would say: heroic strivers — what I call heroic strivers — it’s really going to threaten them. I think the socializers are going to look to AI to some extent, maybe for romantic partners. But mothers are not going to have little AI agents acting like their babies. I don’t think that’s going to happen. But I think heroic strivers are going to be severely threatened.
Well, one thing I can say is that one of the ways to be a heroic striver is ethically. And that will still remain to us: these ethical projects of trying to minister to others, to other creatures, to the planet itself. AI will not be able to do that. They can write our novels or our poetry or our music or improve our math theorems, but they’re not going to be able to do that for us.
Wouldn’t that be a wonderful turn of events if somehow there were an incredible ethical transformation and that’s how we got our status — from how much good we’re actually doing in the world, how much counter-entropic good we’re doing in the world?
This is a big thing that’s upon us, is all I can say. I can’t think of anything else — not the Industrial Revolution, not the Enlightenment — that has the possibility of so changing what we are and what we see our lives as being about as AI.
Brian Keating: Even the very name of our species — Homo habilis meant “toolmaker” or “handyman.”
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein: Yeah.
Brian Keating: And Homo sapiens means “man who knows,” right?
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein: Exactly, exactly. We’re not the only things that know.
And your other question: God forbid if these AI agents begin to have a longing to matter, wanting to justify their own existence — it would take self-reflection of the sort that we have, being able to step outside themselves and say, “Oh my God, I pay so much attention to myself. Am I worth it? Do I deserve this?”
If they do this, then what we have are non-carbon-based humans. These will be humans. And that means we’re going to have to think about their rights, and we’re going to have to have a whole new way of thinking about ethics, because we will have created humans in a new way.
So this is big. This is so big.
I’ll tell you something: I think this is the moment for philosophers, because these are philosophical problems. Philosophers have been at it for over 2,000 years since the ancient Greeks. So show us what you’ve got, philosophers. You’ve been thinking about this for 2,000 years. Show us what you’ve got.
Brian Keating: It’s amazing. You take some matter and shoot some electrons through it, and suddenly you start wondering: is it okay to turn it off? Can I turn off my chat companion? Is it okay to have it answer questions on ethics for my children?
Rebecca, this has been such a wonderful conversation. This book is incredible. It reminds me of a famous quote by John Archibald Wheeler. Wheeler said, “Matter tells space-time how to curve, and space-time tells matter how to move.”
And this book, The Mattering Instinct, was one of the most moving books to me.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us www.amazon.com/Mattering-Instinct-Deepest-Longing-Divides…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein on Mattering - On the podcast talk show Philosophy Bites philosophybites.com/podcast/rebecca-newberger-goldstein-o…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why So Many People Feel Lost: A conversation between Nick Gillespie and Rebecca Goldstein on the search for meaning, the roots of modern discontent, and how people build purpose in a secular age. reason.com/podcast/2026/06/10/why-so-many-people-feel-lost/ via @reason
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Enlightenment values are a sounder vision for the West than tribe and faith, argues Francis Fukuyama (not surprisingly , I agree) open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/europe-dont-abandon-t…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Zen and the Art of Persuasive Writing
@Zenpersuasion
I am a professional reader. As an appellate court judge, I read briefs and motions for a living.
The most persuasive writers favor concrete words over abstract ones.
Abstract writing is hard to read, harder to understand and hardest to remember.
This is what happens inside a judge’s brain when you write abstractly.
Thread. 🧵 -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fame, Incels, and the Need to Matter: Rebecca Goldstein @platobooktour on the Behavioral Grooves podcast behavioralgrooves.com/episode/fame-incels-and-the-need-to…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard to America: You're welcome. Experimental Drug Doubles Median Survival in Patients With Metastatic Pancreatic Cancer | Harvard Medical School hms.harvard.edu/news/experimental-drug-doubles-median-sur…)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"The greatest sentence every written," as Walter Isaacson put it, laying out the rational prerequisites for morality, law, and government (notwithstanding the vague, deistic "creator"). This is what made America great: a nation conceived not in race, religion, or ethnicity, but in the ideals of the Enlightenment. www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/06/08/arts/declaration-o…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Enlightenment Now: The Case for Reason, Science, Humanism, and Progress. www.amazon.com/Enlightenment-Now-Science-Humanism-Progres…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Ever wonder what "the subjunctive" really is? A tense? A mood? Is it disappearing from modern English? And what's the deal with were in If I were a carpenter? All this and more in: The Sense of Style: The Thinking Person's Guide to Writing in the 21st Century: 9780143127796: Pinker, Steven: Books www.amazon.com/Sense-Style-Thinking-Persons-Writing/dp/01…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"How F.D.R.’s Most Famous Sentence ("The only thing we have to fear is fear itself") Remade America." I analyze it in WEKTEK as an illustration of the power of common knowledge (more precisely, common expectation) in driving economic phenomena: bank runs, panics, hoarding, inflation, currency attacks, runs for the exits, and in the other direction, bubbles, meme stocks, irrational exuberance. People act in the expectation that others will expect others to expect them to act, ad infinitum, triggered by a publicly salient announcement or event (in Roosevelt's case, reversing the reverberant doubt). www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/06/08/arts/fdr-inaugural…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Bad arguments against self-driving taxis, exposed by @mboudry
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
My top five bad arguments from this anti-robotaxi piece in @TheAtlantic:
🚫 Sure, 1.2 million die in car crashes each year, but "90% are in low- and middle-income countries, which are not in Waymo's expansion plans."
By that logic, why bother inventing vaccines? Most child deaths happen in the developing world anyway — except vaccines got rolled out everywhere, because adoption drives down cost. Smartphones weren't designed for poor Africans either, yet there are 700 millions of them in Africa now, with penetration rates around 70%.
🚫 Robotaxis could "displace millions of people employed as drivers."
So did the mechanical cotton picker, which replaced millions of stoop laborers. Does anyone wish that brutal work back? Before the industrial revolution, the vast majority of people worked in agriculture. Self-driving cars will actually help poor people by making private transportation affordable for everyone. Protecting low-wage jobs by forbidding the safer, cheaper alternative just traps people in poverty.
🚫 "When companies talk about safety… they just want to sell their product."
Sure, and so do the makers of seatbelts, fire extinguishers, and antibiotics. I guess you should never buy those? Companies profit from safety precisely because people value safety and will pay for it. That's not a gotcha; it's free markets working as advertised.
🚫 "The taxi is one of the few places we brush against other ways of living."
Nobody is banning human contact, not even in transportation. By all means, take a human Uber if you feel so inclined. Or chat with your barista, or strike up a conversation with a stranger on the street. Or pay for a human guide. Keeping people in dangerous, low-wage driving jobs is just using humans as set decoration.
🚫 "Studies show automated vehicles are less able to detect people of color."
This was a preprint. In the peer-reviewed version, the racial gap disappeared — a 29.71% vs 30.15% miss rate. And it tested generic open-source camera models, not Waymo, which navigates with lidar and radar, where skin tone is physically irrelevant. (See @KelseyTuoc's debunk: www.theargumentmag.com/p/no-waymos-arent-racist) Even if it were real, it would be a simple, solvable engineering problem. You're really clutching at straws.
✅ What the piece leaves out entirely: @Waymo reports ~92% fewer serious car crashes and ~92% fewer injury-causing pedestrian crashes than human drivers.
It's a shame that this was published in my favorite magazine @TheAtlantic, which is generally pro-progress and pro-abundance.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/05/waymo-self-driving-cars… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Which is the ethical priority: abolishing wealth, or abolishing poverty? Beggars or billionaires, asks Maarten Boudry @mboudry open.substack.com/pub/maartenboudry/p/beggars-or-billiona…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
‘Make American Great Again’ Was a Slogan Well Before Trump - The New York Times. (But make is not in the subjunctive mood in Reagan's Let's make America great again; it's a simple infinitive). www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/06/08/arts/make-american…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Hasan Piker Is Following in Candace Owens's Footsteps by Matt Johnson @mattjj89 open.substack.com/pub/theunpopulist/p/hasan-piker-is-foll…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I made similar arguments in the "Inequality" chapter of Enlightenment Now. "Strange" is an understatement when it comes to inequality in other measures like health: Would it be progress if tried to get the healthiest people do die sooner?
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
I find the political focus on inequality in this kind of work strange - as if one could make the poor better off just by making the rich worse off.
Inequality can sometimes have negative consequences that we should care about, but it's ethically confused to care about equality as an end in itself.
We should care about abundance, freedom, tolerance, beauty, knowledge, innovation, fairness, etc. - and only care about inequality when it threatens these other things. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein on Mattering - On the podcast talk show Philosophy Bites philosophybites.com/podcast/rebecca-newberger-goldstein-o…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The harms of social media (and AI relationships) are often explained by conspiracy theories blamed the problems on companies' profit motives, nefarious algorithms, & other malevolence. But the tech is harm-neutral on the face of it, and few predicted the problems when the tech was introduced, before billions of people put it to their own uses. A more insightful analysis, I think, is the analogy with junk food: human nature sometimes makes us want things that in excess are bad for us (social competition, solitude, virtue signaling) and the tech inadvertently enables that excess. Two examples of this argument: Is Social Media Destroying Democracy—Or Giving It To Us Good And Hard? open.substack.com/pub/conspicuouscognition/p/is-social-me…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Though battle deaths per capita and autocracy have crept upward in the past few years (while still well below 20th-century rates), most other indexes of nonviolence and well-being continue their progress and are at historical records. One example: decriminalization of homosexuality.
Human Progress
@HumanProgress
The number of countries where homosexual activity is legal has nearly doubled in the last 50 years, representing greater freedom and dignity for billions of people.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On the fiftieth anniversary of my own graduation from university, I was asked to write a commencement essay for the Harvard class of '26: Reflections on Half a Century of Progress | The Harvard Crimson www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/6/1/pinker-harvard-commen…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Was Donald Trump influenced by abstruse French literary theory? Not exactly, but he is its most powerful practitioner: Welcome to the Postmodern Presidency, by @DamonLinker. open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/welcome-to-the-postmo…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A radical rumination by international relations scholar John Mueller: "Might the Iran War lead to lasting peace in the Middle East?" open.substack.com/pub/muellerbbbb/p/might-the-iran-war-le…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"The British Used to Sound Like We (Americans) Did, explains @JohnHMcWhorter: British English at the time of early colonization was "rhotic" (they pronounced r's after vowels: they would have parked their cars if they had any). Southern British toffs dropped r's starting in the late 18th, and coastal Americans with British ties and Britain envy copied them, pahking their cahs. But settlement matters too: Canadians, with even closer ties to the mother country, kept their r's, probably because more of them came from northern England, Scotland, Ulster, & Ireland, or were British loyalists who defected from the American revolution when even coastal Americans were rhotic. www.nytimes.com/2026/06/04/opinion/british-american-engli…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"The British Used to Sound Like We (Americans) Did, explains @JohnHMcWhorter: British English at the time of early colonization was "rhotic" (they pronounced r's after vowels: they would have parked their cars if they had any). Southern British toffs dropped r's starting in the late 18th, and coastal Americans with British ties and Britain envy copied them, pahking their cahs. But settlement matters too: Canadians, with even closer ties to the mother country, kept their r's, probably because more of them came from northern England, Scotland, Ulster, & Ireland, or were British loyalists who defected from the American revolution when even coastal Americans were rhotic. www.nytimes.com/2026/06/04/opinion/british-american-engli…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A radical rumination by international relations scholar John Mueller: "Might the Iran War lead to lasting peace in the Middle East?" open.substack.com/pub/muellerbbbb/p/might-the-iran-war-le…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"The pattern has been long underway. Between 1945 and 1973, five wars were launched between states in the area in which extensive military casualties were suffered, but few or none in the last 50 years, even as states like Egypt, Jordan, and recently Syria have been joined by the Abraham Accord states urging combatants to get a life and to recognize that Israel isn’t going anywhere and that efforts to extinguish it are futile and pointless."
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Following the observations of one Iranian former leader, the country and its regime might well be most secure if it abandoned its nuclear weapons program which has proved to be absurd, expensive, useless, and ultimately the chief reason for (not a deterrent of) armed attacks by alarmed countries like Israel and United States."
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It’s My Party and I’ll Die If I Want To: Rosalind Arden reviews the philosopher Kathleen Stock's book against assisted dying, and cites evidence that Stock's slippery slope argument is factually mistaken: countries that have legalized assisted dying have not seen abuses, disrespect for the disabled, or stinting on palliative care. open.substack.com/pub/quillette/p/its-my-party-and-ill-di…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I would have pushed harder against the argument that not wanting to be a burden on loved ones is an illegitimate reason for assisted dying. My life is meaningful and worth living because I value my loved ones' well-being. If my life is unremitting misery AND I'm ruining the lives of those I love, why should it be illegal for me to choose to give them back their lives, the ultimate act of altruism and compassion?
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Was Donald Trump influenced by abstruse French literary theory? Not exactly, but he is its most powerful practitioner: Welcome to the Postmodern Presidency, by @DamonLinker. open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/welcome-to-the-postmo…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"A world in which universal truths and goods is widely denied will also be a world in which politics has been reduced to raw and ruthless assertions of power. If we want to do better than that—and we should—we need to find a way to back out of the intellectual dead end we find ourselves stuck in."
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Are you neither woke nor MAGA nor complacent about contemporary liberalism? Normies of the world unite! LibCon2026 | Liberalism for the 21st Century. (I spoke at the debut conference last year - it was inspiring and fun.) conference.ismaglobal.org
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On the fiftieth anniversary of my own graduation from university, I was asked to write a commencement essay for the Harvard class of '26: Reflections on Half a Century of Progress | The Harvard Crimson www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/6/1/pinker-harvard-commen…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This vindicates a subtle prediction made by the anthropologist (and a founder of evolutionary psychology) Donald Symons 47 years ago in his masterpiece The Evolution of Human Sexuality: The mean difference between the sexes interacts with individual desirability.
Aella
@Aella_Girl
New post where I had ppl rate naked photos of the opposite sex to find out what kinds of naked photos women actually find fuckable
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Appreciation here: quillette.com/2025/02/04/sage-of-sex-and-psyche-donald-sy…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Summer Reading List 2026 - Philosophy Talk philosophytalk.org/shows/summer-reading-list-2026/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It’s Ideology, Stupid: Matt Johnson @matjj89 argues, "The great clash of today is between liberal democracy and the forces working tirelessly to destroy it—wherever they are found." open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/samuel-huntington-is-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Please note: this is (hilarious) satire. Must be said, since the Second Law of Journalism (as explained to me decades ago by a NYT editor) is: Never use irony, because many readers won't get it. (The First Law was Always have something to print.)
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
As I said here previously, I've been working on a theory of everything. I don't plan on publishing it in peer reviewed physics journals, present it at physics conferences, or write a trade or university press book about my theory. I'll just go on podcasts & explain it here because in such a situation, how can a self-perpetuating secular priesthood of credentialed "scientists'' purport to maintain a monopoly on the production of scientific knowledge?
Let me emphasize that I am in no way opposed to specialized scientific training; I object only when an elite caste seeks to impose its canon of "high science'', with the aim of excluding a priori alternative forms of scientific production by non-members.
Quantum physics, hadron bootstrap theory, complex number theory, and chaos theory share the basic assumption that reality cannot be described in linear terms, that nonlinear—and unsolvable—equations are the only means possible to describe a complex, chaotic, and non-deterministic reality. These theories are all metacritical in the sense that they foreground themselves as metaphors rather than as "accurate" descriptions of reality.
We might say that these attempts by scientists to develop new strategies of description represent notes towards a theory of theories, of how representation—mathematical, experimental, and verbal—is inherently complex and problematizing, not a solution but part of the semiotics of investigating the universe.
Finally, postmodern science provides a powerful refutation of the authoritarianism and elitism inherent in traditional science, as well as an empirical basis for a democratic approach to scientific work. For, as Bohr noted, "a complete elucidation of one and the same object may require diverse points of view which defy a unique description''—this is quite simply a fact about the world, much as the self-proclaimed empiricists of modernist science might prefer to deny it. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Social modernity, in the end, is really about not having to do what your family tells you to do—marrying whom you want, taking the job you want, and spending your earnings the way you want. There is something cold about this, of course, but also something deeply emancipating." I knew about the insanely extravagant weddings in rural India that keep people poor, but not about "how funerals keep Africa poor." - David Oks substack.com/@doks/p-193713307
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"There’s a reason why virtually every economically successful society has graduated from a social order that stresses the claims of kin into one that stresses the rights of individuals. Living in a society of individuals governed by impersonal institutions, we have an understandable wistfulness for the imagined world of warm communities and thick familial bonds. But we forget how suffocating that social world is, how parasitical it is on its most productive members, and how poisonous it is for any prospect of economic development."
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Personally relevant: My father grew up dirt-poor, and when he started earning a living (as a clothing salesman) he had to resist pressure (no doubt at the insistence of my mother) to turn over every dime to his parents and good-for-nothing brother rather than invest in a house, business, and children.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I agree that this article by Scott Barry Kaufman @sbkaufman explains a lot about a strain of anti-woke intellectual that has become Manichean, conspiratorial, and pugilistic.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Anti-Woke, or Just Wounded?
A Typology of Two Types of Anti-Woke Intellectuals
@sbkaufman has written for Skeptic a very important article distinguishing between those who criticize ideas to correct them and those consumed by them and are settling scores.
www.skeptic.com/article/anti-woke-or-just-wounded-a-typol… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Though battle deaths per capita and autocracy have crept upward in the past few years (while still well below 20th-century rates), most other indexes of nonviolence and well-being continue their progress and are at historical records. One example: decriminalization of homosexuality.
Human Progress
@HumanProgress
The number of countries where homosexual activity is legal has nearly doubled in the last 50 years, representing greater freedom and dignity for billions of people.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The harms of social media (and AI relationships) are often explained by conspiracy theories blamed the problems on companies' profit motives, nefarious algorithms, & other malevolence. But the tech is harm-neutral on the face of it, and few predicted the problems when the tech was introduced, before billions of people put it to their own uses. A more insightful analysis, I think, is the analogy with junk food: human nature sometimes makes us want things that in excess are bad for us (social competition, solitude, virtue signaling) and the tech inadvertently enables that excess. Two examples of this argument: Is Social Media Destroying Democracy—Or Giving It To Us Good And Hard? open.substack.com/pub/conspicuouscognition/p/is-social-me…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In The Blank Slate, I examined why the idea of a genetic influence on the mind has historically been more congenial to the right, and the blank slate more congenial to the left - but also why these links are not necessary, and there is a niche for a hereditarian left (Noam Chomsky, Peter Singer, and Herb Gintis were examples). Another left-leaning hereditarian is the behavioral geneticist Kathryn Paige Harden, here in discussion with Yascha Mounk. open.substack.com/pub/yaschamounk/p/kathryn-paige-harden?…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The "Frankfurt School" of Adorno, Horkheimer, Marcuse, and (ambivalently) Habermas had a massive diffuse influence on modern academia, even if the original sources and lines of influence have been forgotten. This can be seen in its vague, incoherent, and ineffectual sympathy for some kind of not-exactly-but-sort-of Marxism, the conviction that capitalism is odious and moribund without any thought-through alternative. Scott Alexander @slatestarcodex explains in his review of a book on the history and ideas of the school. open.substack.com/pub/astralcodexten/p/book-review-the-di…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
As a cognitive psychologist, I'm not surprised that MLK's formative childhood memory was distorted, embellished, or even fabricated (though sincerely believed). As the authors of this op-ed observe, "We know from history and from human nature that origin stories are often shaped to serve other ends than a literal recounting of events." (I've seen this when fact-checking my own childhood memories.) It's consistent with Robert Trivers's theory of self-deception: We convince ourselves of congenial stories, the better to convince others. | The Problem With Martin Luther King Jr.’s Origin Story www.nytimes.com/2026/05/31/opinion/mlk-racism-origin-myth…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A typical career is 80,000 hours. A book by that name, growing out of the effective altruism movement, offers practical and often surprising career advice for those who really want to "make a difference" with their lives.
Benjamin Todd
@ben_j_todd
Your career is your most important decision. Especially for your impact.
But most career advice sucks, so millions waste it.
I’ve spent 15 years researching how to find the best career.
This book sums up everything I’ve learned. It feels like my life’s work.
And it’s out now. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A typical career is 80,000 hours. A book by that name, growing out of the effective altruism movement, offers practical and often surprising career advice for those who really want to "make a difference" with their lives.
Benjamin Todd
@ben_j_todd
Your career is your most important decision. Especially for your impact.
But most career advice sucks, so millions waste it.
I’ve spent 15 years researching how to find the best career.
This book sums up everything I’ve learned. It feels like my life’s work.
And it’s out now. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
As a cognitive psychologist, I'm not surprised that MLK's formative childhood memory was distorted, embellished, or even fabricated (though sincerely believed). As the authors of this op-ed observe, "We know from history and from human nature that origin stories are often shaped to serve other ends than a literal recounting of events." (I've seen this when fact-checking my own childhood memories.) It's consistent with Robert Trivers's theory of self-deception: We convince ourselves of congenial stories, the better to convince others. | The Problem With Martin Luther King Jr.’s Origin Story www.nytimes.com/2026/05/31/opinion/mlk-racism-origin-myth…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The "Frankfurt School" of Adorno, Horkheimer, Marcuse, and (ambivalently) Habermas had a massive diffuse influence on modern academia, even if the original sources and lines of influence have been forgotten. This can be seen in its vague, incoherent, and ineffectual sympathy for some kind of not-exactly-but-sort-of Marxism, the conviction that capitalism is odious and moribund without any thought-through alternative. Scott Alexander @slatestarcodex explains in his review of a book on the history and ideas of the school. open.substack.com/pub/astralcodexten/p/book-review-the-di…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In The Blank Slate, I examined why the idea of a genetic influence on the mind has historically been more congenial to the right, and the blank slate more congenial to the left - but also why these links are not necessary, and there is a niche for a hereditarian left (Noam Chomsky, Peter Singer, and Herb Gintis were examples). Another left-leaning hereditarian is the behavioral geneticist Kathryn Paige Harden, here in discussion with Yascha Mounk. open.substack.com/pub/yaschamounk/p/kathryn-paige-harden?…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Some confusion, renumbering, and conflation in the discussion of the "Three Laws of Behavioral Genetics," originally enumerated by KPH's advisor Eric Turkheimer based on robust and replicable results in the field. As originally stated: 1. All behavioral traits are heritable. 2. The effects of families are smaller than those of the genes [an understatement, in my view]. 3. Much of the variation in behavioral traits is neither genetic nor familial [commonly called "nonshared environment," but in my view random developmental noise].
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The "Fourth Law," proposed later by my former student James Lee & others, is that most behavioral traits are caused not by a single common gene but by many genes with tiny effects or by very rare genes.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Computational linguist & AI expert Shalom Lappin presents a brief but substantive history of Zionism (no, it was not "settler colonialism"), and an analysis of the only contemporary movement to extinguish an existing nation-state (with a likely ethnic cleansing or genocide of its citizens). | Anti-Zionism as Redemptive Racism open.substack.com/pub/quillette/p/anti-zionism-as-redempt…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Best News in America www.nytimes.com/2026/05/30/opinion/murder-crime-rate-amer…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Commas, Common Sense and Justice | @JohnHMcWhorter. citing a forthcoming book on the history of punctuation, analyzes the 2nd Amendment (mispunctuated by today's standards), its obvious interpretation, and Scalia's partisan (mis)interpretation. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/28/opinion/punctuation-supreme-co…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Commas, Common Sense and Justice | @JohnHMcWhorter. citing a forthcoming book on the history of punctuation, analyzes the 2nd Amendment (mispunctuated by today's standards), its obvious interpretation, and Scalia's partisan (mis)interpretation. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/28/opinion/punctuation-supreme-co…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Computational linguist & AI expert Shalom Lappin presents a brief but substantive history of Zionism (no, it was not "settler colonialism"), and an analysis of the only contemporary movement to extinguish an existing nation-state (with a likely ethnic cleansing or genocide of its citizens). | Anti-Zionism as Redemptive Racism open.substack.com/pub/quillette/p/anti-zionism-as-redempt…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
JFK's grandson Jack Schlossberg seems like a putz, but NYT columnist misses why celebrities often have an edge in electability: Voters seek a "focal point," a candidate they feel other voters know about, and know that others know that others know, etc., so they aren't "wasting their vote" on a worthier but idiosyncratic alternative. | He’s Entitled and Nepotistic. This Is Not What Democrats Need. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/28/opinion/kennedy-jack-schlossbe…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Reagan, Schwarzenegger, Ventura, Franken, Eastwood, Bono (Sonny, not U2), and of course our current president. Many in other countries, too, most notably the former comedian Volodymyr Zelensky.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
For more on Common knowledge and the mysteries of money, power, and everyday life, see my new book When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows... www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Boston murders in 2026 | Each one is horrifying, but there have been only 5 so far this year, compared to 31 in 2025 and 24 in 2024 - a reprise of the "Boston miracle" of the 1990s, this one reversing the post-Floyd spike of 2020-2022. www.universalhub.com/crime/murder/2026
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Brian Keating (@Briankeating) and Rebecca Newberger Goldstein (@platobooktour) discuss "The Physics of Mattering: Do AI Agents Have a Soul"
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein: God forbid if these AI agents begin to have a longing to matter, we have our non-carbon-based humans. We’re going to have to think about their rights.
Brian Keating: She is a philosopher who trained in physics, and she just told me that AI might deserve human rights. Here is her argument.
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein: The other obsession with this verb “matter,” that we are creatures of matter who long to matter — you can only say that in English. But I’m so glad you could say that in English because it’s, again, incredibly poignant.
We’re creatures of matter who are subject to the laws of physics, the second law of thermodynamics, but we long to matter. And so much of the book is trying to explain that, how that transformation within us, within our species, happens. That’s a normative transformation, an ethical transformation, and it’s really what distinguishes us: that we, in some sense, want to justify the fact that we matter so much to ourselves, that we pay so much attention to ourselves.
We actually can pinpoint the place in human history where this emerged, during the period when all the religions emerged that are still extant, which is so interesting. Also, Western philosophy emerged during the period of history that’s called the Axial Age.
Brian Keating: I do think things have changed for the better, as far as, you know, paternity leave. I’ve taken advantage of that. But I guess the ultimate expression — and I don’t think there’s anything wrong with it — I mean, I think that women sacrifice a lot more. I think also we have a crisis with men and boys and so forth, and now you have grandsons, and you can appreciate it. You probably appreciated this even before you had daughters.
But the book is full of these things ranging, as you said, from Aristotle to the Chinese one-child policy that you talk about at the end of the book. It’s heart-wrenching, Rebecca.
But I guess, as we come in for a landing, the fear that a lot of people have nowadays is about artificial intelligence replacing what we derive our sense of mattering from. And you quote Freud in the book. Freud said all of life is work and love. And if AI can replace the work of knowledge workers like you and me, and it can replace the love because of things like Character AI and all these artificial relationships that don’t require me to go out and ask a woman on a date — or nowadays, for men — I want to ask you the question: can AI have a mattering instinct, or is it encoded in this wet supercomputer that we carry on our shoulders? Is it possible that AI is making everyone feel that redundancy is threatening to us? Will AI rob us of our mattering?
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein: Yeah, so there are two different questions there. One is really, I think, already upon us, maybe already here: that some of the most creative ways of appeasing our mattering instinct will be superseded by what AI can do. It can prove math theorems faster, make discoveries in science, write novels, write music, paint pictures. Some of the most creative things that have led to flourishing and led to great achievements that we can all take pride in.
I take great pride in our species producing Bach and Shakespeare and Michael Jordan — I’m a big basketball fan. I mean, we mere mortals, and look what we can do. But they’ll be able to do it better. I think this is going to be a real problem.
Here’s one thing I would say: heroic strivers — what I call heroic strivers — it’s really going to threaten them. I think the socializers are going to look to AI to some extent, maybe for romantic partners. But mothers are not going to have little AI agents acting like their babies. I don’t think that’s going to happen. But I think heroic strivers are going to be severely threatened.
Well, one thing I can say is that one of the ways to be a heroic striver is ethically. And that will still remain to us: these ethical projects of trying to minister to others, to other creatures, to the planet itself. AI will not be able to do that. They can write our novels or our poetry or our music or improve our math theorems, but they’re not going to be able to do that for us.
Wouldn’t that be a wonderful turn of events if somehow there were an incredible ethical transformation and that’s how we got our status — from how much good we’re actually doing in the world, how much counter-entropic good we’re doing in the world?
This is a big thing that’s upon us, is all I can say. I can’t think of anything else — not the Industrial Revolution, not the Enlightenment — that has the possibility of so changing what we are and what we see our lives as being about as AI.
Brian Keating: Even the very name of our species — Homo habilis meant “toolmaker” or “handyman.”
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein: Yeah.
Brian Keating: And Homo sapiens means “man who knows,” right?
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein: Exactly, exactly. We’re not the only things that know.
And your other question: God forbid if these AI agents begin to have a longing to matter, wanting to justify their own existence — it would take self-reflection of the sort that we have, being able to step outside themselves and say, “Oh my God, I pay so much attention to myself. Am I worth it? Do I deserve this?”
If they do this, then what we have are non-carbon-based humans. These will be humans. And that means we’re going to have to think about their rights, and we’re going to have to have a whole new way of thinking about ethics, because we will have created humans in a new way.
So this is big. This is so big.
I’ll tell you something: I think this is the moment for philosophers, because these are philosophical problems. Philosophers have been at it for over 2,000 years since the ancient Greeks. So show us what you’ve got, philosophers. You’ve been thinking about this for 2,000 years. Show us what you’ve got.
Brian Keating: It’s amazing. You take some matter and shoot some electrons through it, and suddenly you start wondering: is it okay to turn it off? Can I turn off my chat companion? Is it okay to have it answer questions on ethics for my children?
Rebecca, this has been such a wonderful conversation. This book is incredible. It reminds me of a famous quote by John Archibald Wheeler. Wheeler said, “Matter tells space-time how to curve, and space-time tells matter how to move.”
And this book, The Mattering Instinct, was one of the most moving books to me.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us www.amazon.com/Mattering-Instinct-Deepest-Longing-Divides…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Lots of interesting stuff in this interview, including why AI may be a force for truth. Yuval Noah Harari on the Mistake Strongmen Keep Making www.nytimes.com/2026/05/26/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-yuv…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Good fences make good neighbors (because the focal point of an unambiguous border, however arbitrary, pre-empts self-serving arguments that the borderlands "rightfully" belong to one or the other). As I argue in Better Angels, the grandfathering of national borders deserves some of the credit for the post-WWII Long Peace, now threatened by you-know-who. Stephen Hanson & Jeffrey Kopstein explain. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/27/opinion/trump-world-map-border…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Truth Is Still Out There - Excellent article by Adam Kirsch in The Atlantic, echoing points that skeptic (and Skeptic editor) @michaelshermer has been making for decades. www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/06/government-ufo-consp…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's Better Than It Looks | TEDx talk by Progress Studies writer and researcher Tony Morley @tonymmorley | TEDxHawkesbury youtu.be/OqcQBHYbbwk via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Join me in supporting The Ocean Cleanup (effective technology from Boyan Slat) to help tackle ocean plastic! Please help the artist and gallery director Nicholas Cueva reach his goal of 8584 USD. Your support and sharing this page would mean a lot to him! 🌊
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
60 Percent of Grades at Harvard Were A’s. Enough Is Enough, say my colleagues David Laibson and @jasonfurman (and I couldn't agree more). www.nytimes.com/2026/05/21/opinion/harvard-easy-a-grades.…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Nobel laureate and co-founder of behavioral economics Richard Thaler advises Democrats on how to select a successful nominee. Another factor: In WEKTEK, I suggested that the primary process is a "Keynesian beauty contest," where the goal is to select not the prettiest contestant but the one picked by the majority of other voters, each voting with the same goal. This higher-order guessing about guessing means that anything that makes a candidate stand out as a "focal point" for winning or losing has an outsize influence, so trivial "gaffes" and capricious signs of "momentum" can determine losers or winners (e.g., Muskie's tears, Dean's scream, Biden's endorsement by Clyburn). If so, then primaries should not be sequential, beginning with NH and IA. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/24/opinion/democrats-2028-electio…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This and other examples of the surprising role of "common knowledge" (belief about belief) in When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Interview by Zachary Karabell of The Progress Network: “By almost every measurable standard, more people today enjoy security, leisure, education, and opportunity than ever before in human history. And yet public life feels increasingly angry, anxious, and distrustful. Nick [Gillespie] thinks the explanation is, in large part, psychological: It turns out we are simply ill-equipped to handle prosperity and endless choice. Somehow, we’ve managed to instill the belief in younger generations that anything is possible while convincing them that catastrophe is around every corner.” open.substack.com/pub/edgyoptimist/p/a-lot-of-people-unde…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
James Traub on Why American Classrooms Are Failing Democracy. (It's not so much the politicized content as the romantic methods, which assume that kids' curiosity is enough. I appreciated the nod to the fact that written language, unlike spoken or signed, does not come naturally to most children. As Darwin wrote, "Man has an instinctive tendency to speak, as we see in our young children, while no child has an instinctive tendency to bake, brew, or write" (furnishing the title of my first popular book, The Language Instinct). open.substack.com/pub/yaschamounk/p/james-traub?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Sad to learn of the death of cognitive psychologist Kevin Dunbar after a heroic, decades-long struggle with MS and lymphoma. Kevin made brilliant contributions to our understanding of analogy, of intuitions that clash with scientific understanding, and of other topics in high-level cognition. And he was a warm and witty colleague. My sympathies to his wife Laura-Ann Petitto, and to Eva, Annafaye, and Maaraluisa.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
The Fifth Column 🖐
@wethefifth
Harvard professor Steven Pinker weighs in on the ongoing battle between the iconic university and the Trump administration.
From our latest episode with Steven Pinker, out now.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Thinkable
@thinkableevents
Chicago, experience the brilliance of @sapinker live this September!
Join us for an exclusive evening exploring the ideas, insights, and questions that shape what it means to be human.
📍 Athenaeum Center for Thought and Culture
🗓️ September 11
🎟️ thinkable.events -
Steven Pinker reposted
Armen
@Armen
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein: a meaningful life requires two kinds of mattering.
• someone who truly understands you
• something that makes your life feel justified
Belonging alone isn’t enough.
Achievement alone isn’t enough.
They have to meet.
From my interview with her on The Armen Show (Ep. 461). (@platobooktour )This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Hatred of Israel and the Degradation of the West www.nytimes.com/2026/05/20/opinion/israel-netanyahu-criti…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard faculty votes to make it more difficult for undergrads to earn A's apnews.com/article/harvard-university-grade-inflation-lim…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Can America Escape the Cycle of Vicemaxxing? open.substack.com/pub/derekthompson/p/can-america-escape-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When he was a senior at Harvard, the mathematician and popular writer Jordan Ellenberg @jsellenberg took a course at Harvard with my advisor, the great psycholinguist Roger Brown. In a comment on his term paper, Roger incorrectly predicted that "Ms." would not catch on, because women would not want to hide the elevated status conferred by marriage. Whoops! Pushing "Ms." along were not just the original feminist rationale for a form of address with parity to the one applied to men, but a status feature that went in the other direction: youth. "Mrs." sounded older, applicable to our mothers. quomodocumque.wordpress.com/2026/05/18/roger-brown-on-ms/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard faculty votes to make it more difficult for undergrads to earn A's apnews.com/article/harvard-university-grade-inflation-lim…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A Truth-and-Reconciliation Process for Academia? open.substack.com/pub/chronicleofhighereducation/p/a-trut…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why @theFIRE The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression is indispensable: "Larry Bushart spent 37 days in jail for posting a meme on Facebook. I’ve been doing this work for 25 years, and I can honestly say this is the worst First Amendment case I’ve ever seen."
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
Larry Bushart spent 37 days in jail for posting a meme on Facebook.
I’ve been doing this work for 25 years, and I can honestly say this is the worst First Amendment case I’ve ever seen.
Not because Larry threatened anyone. He didn’t. Not because he committed violence. He didn’t. Not because this was a close call. It wasn’t.
He posted a political meme — the kind of thing millions of Americans do every day — and local officials decided to treat it like a crime.
And because they had badges, prosecutors, jail cells, and the terrifying machinery of the state behind them, they got away with it for 37 days.
Larry is a retired police officer and National Guard veteran. The meme he shared quoted Donald Trump’s “we have to get over it” comment after a 2024 Iowa school shooting. Whatever you think of Trump, the meme was plainly political commentary. Perry County officials knew what it referred to. They knew it wasn’t a threat against a Tennessee school.
They arrested him anyway.
In the middle of the night.
They set his bond at $2 million.
He lost his job. He missed family milestones. He sat in jail for more than a month before the charges finally collapsed — because, of course, there was no crime here.
Today, @theFIREorg secured a measure of justice: Perry County agreed to pay Larry Bushart $835,000 for violating his constitutional rights.
This case should scare the hell out of people across the political spectrum.
Because if the government can jail you for a meme by pretending not to understand obvious political commentary, your rights are only as secure as the good faith of the most authoritarian official in your town.
That is exactly why we have the First Amendment. Not for speech everyone likes. Not for opinions that flatter the powerful. Not for the bland, safe, committee-approved stuff.
It exists for moments when fear, outrage, politics, and authority all line up and say: “Surely this is the exception.”
No. It isn’t.
I’m incredibly proud of @theFIREorg’s legal team. And I’m even prouder of Larry Bushart for refusing to let the government get away with treating his constitutional rights like a suggestion.
But despite the correct verdict, I'll probably always get angry every time I think of this case.
Let’s make this the last time anyone in America is arrested — let alone thrown in jail — for a meme.
Celebrate your independence. Defend your First Amendment.
www.fire.org/news/victory-tennessee-man-jailed-37-days-tr… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Breaking news: Harvard faculty votes to cap the number of A's awarded in course grades, a big step in combatting the grade inflation that has been dumbing down our courses, conveying the wrong message to students, and making universities a national laughingstock.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Some good points in this essay, but it fails to mention the massive problem in virtually all commentary on higher ed: It doesn't distinguish selection effects (what kind of students apply and are accepted) from treatment effects (the value the college adds to their development). A good rule of thumb, emphasized by economist Bryan Caplan, is that selection effects account for most of the variance in outcomes. | A Cattle Ranch Is Doing What the Ivy League Can’t www.nytimes.com/2026/05/20/opinion/deep-springs-college-i…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Hatred of Israel and the Degradation of the West www.nytimes.com/2026/05/20/opinion/israel-netanyahu-criti…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My interview on Bulgarian television: Проф. Стивън Пинкър в Панорама: Хората обичат истории за герои и злодеи - Българска национална телевизия bnt.bg/news/prof-stivan-pinkar-v-panorama-horata-obichat-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Writing tips if you ever have to persuade a judge:
Zen and the Art of Persuasive Writing
@Zenpersuasion
I’m an appellate court judge with 29 years in the law. I’ve read more briefs than I can count.
Strong arguments are crucial.
But they’re not enough.
If you overtax the judge’s brain, you’re less persuasive.
Here are three tips to write for the judge’s brain instead of against it. Thread. 🧵 -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An excerpt on the power of my favorite part of speech. | Want to avoid being replaced by AI? Think fresh verbs. — Harvard Gazette news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/05/want-to-avoid-bein…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Jon Haidt @jonhaidt is one of the greatest psychologists of the 21st century, having illuminated moral cognition, the relation between emotion and intellect, the perils of politicization and viewpoint homogeneity in social science, and the roots of the youth mental health decline. That NYU students should protest this wise and brilliant man as their commencement speaker is a backhand vindication of his diagnosis of what's wrong in higher ed. Our sometimes coauthor @PamelaParesky explains: Reports of The Death of 'Woke' May Be Greatly Exaggerated www.realcleareducation.com/articles/2026/05/17/reports_of…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Happy Victoria Day! 🇨🇦 by @dgardner open.substack.com/pub/dgardner/p/queen-victorias-day?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Speaking Truth to Power Is bad for truth, notes philosopher Dan Williams @danwilliamsphil. "Intellectual courage is extremely important. But without first carefully establishing what’s true, it’s either pointless or harmful. So intellectuals’ primary responsibility is simply to seek and speak the truth, full stop. This job description is less heroic, but it’s more intellectually and socially useful, and it’s less vulnerable to self-deception precisely because it’s less heroic." open.substack.com/pub/conspicuouscognition/p/speaking-tru…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Being Secular in Trump’s America: Religious belief, practice, and affiliation are in steep decline (especially across generations ), so evangelicals are (unconstitutionally) trying to exert raw political power). arcmag.org/being-secular-in-trumps-america/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
After publishing Better Angels and Enlightenment Now, I learned that many academic historians become enraged if one notes anything bad that non-Western civilizations did (e.g., slavery, raiding and feuding, harems, human sacrifice, theocratic despots, suicide terrorism), or anything good that Western civilization did (e.g., The Enlightenment), despite the obvious fact that all civilizations did good and bad things, and everything has to come from somewhere. | Does Western Civilisation Exist? James Kierstead on Ancient Greece, Christianity, and the West | Quillette Cetera Ep. 63 open.substack.com/pub/quillette/p/does-western-civilisati…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
For the same reason, I have stayed off the right-wing bandwagon that brags about "Western Civilization": let's praise the praiseworthy parts, not the whole package.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Al Roth on Why People Should Be Free to Sell Their Kidneys. (Any "yuk" reaction should be weighed against the hundreds of thousands of lives that could be saved, just as in the past we overcame our "yuk" reactions to blood transfusions, life insurance, organ transplants, IVF, and other innovations with massive benefits and no tangible costs.) writing.yaschamounk.com/p/al-roth?publication_id=2709399&…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Energy capture is how all life carves out zones of beneficial order in the midst of the relentless tide toward entropy, disorder, chaos, decay, death. Anything that humans want - food, water, movement, shelter, knowledge - depends on it. This is the ultimate reason for: The case for clean energy abundance, by @mattyglesias open.substack.com/pub/matthewyglesias/p/the-case-for-clea…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Make trade, not war: New evidence for the Enlightenment idea of Doux Commerce (“gentle commerce”): you don’t kill your customers or debtors, and invasion is less tempting when it’s cheaper to buy stuff than steal it. (The theory was discussed in depth in Better Angels.)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Violent rampages are triggered by a loss of status, not by poverty. open.substack.com/pub/quillette/p/dangerous-losers?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A FAQ: Why are some people gay given that it reduces reproductive output and hence should have been selected out long ago? (The puzzle isn't homosexual attraction or sex, but avoidance of heterosexual mating opportunities.) Steve Stewart-Williams reviews the theories and evidence. open.substack.com/pub/stevestewartwilliams/p/an-evolution…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Are Humans Really Animals at core? My interview with Khan Clinics on American Muslim Today. youtu.be/L5-m2cNkspI via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
The Physics Law That Guarantees Everything Will Go Wrong
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein | @platobooktour
TIMESTAMPS :
00:00 Why every human being needs to matter — and what happens when they can't
04:25 The second law of thermodynamics and what it has to do with your life
08:00 The 4 types of people: Transcenders, Socializers, Heroic Strivers, and Competitors
17:30 Why fame-seeking millennials will give up everything — including relationships
22:00 Zero-sum mattering: the competitor who was happy for 15 minutes after winning a Nobel Prize
24:15 Ludwig Boltzmann solved one of physics' greatest paradoxes — then despaired
34:50 All tragedies are thermodynamic — and so is depression
40:00 Life as resistance to entropy: what flourishing actually means
54:00 Can AI have a mattering instinct? What that would mean for human rights
57:50 If AI becomes a heroic striver, what's left for us?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In Gad Saad's book Suicidal Empathy he does clarify that he's not against empathy across the board, just when it is detached from rationality. But with its hyperbolic title (US immigration enforcement may have been too lax in recent years, but that's hardly "suicide"), and the current political context (which he surely is aware of) in which Trumpian and evangelical attacks on empathy are being used to justify cruel, destructive, and irrational policies -- together with the taunting and trolling style that Trump seems to have unleashed -- criticism is warranted.
quillette.com/2026/05/06/playing-gad/ -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An old and worthy insight from the Nobel laureate and originator of cognitive psychology and artificial intelligence, Herb Simon: Don't spend 15 minutes figuring out a shortcut that will save you 10 minutes. Information-gathering and decision-making themselves have costs, so "satisfice" rather than seeking to optimize. This op-ed by David Epstein draws out implications for life decisions. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/12/opinion/decision-making-herber…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Trump is fighting the world's stupidest culture war." Yes, the world needs abundant energy, and carbon-free sources can't supply it all today. This does not call for relentlessly crippling clean energy. Destroying the energy resources of the future just because liberals like it is, yes, stupid. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/12/opinion/trump-is-fighting-the-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Behind the Boom in Psychiatric Medication by @AdamOmaryPhD www.wsj.com/opinion/behind-the-boom-in-psychiatric-medica… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Behind the Boom in Psychiatric Medication by @AdamOmaryPhD www.wsj.com/opinion/behind-the-boom-in-psychiatric-medica… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Trump is fighting the world's stupidest culture war." Yes, the world needs abundant energy, and carbon-free sources can't supply it all today. This does not call for relentlessly crippling clean energy. Destroying the energy resources of the future just because liberals like it is, yes, stupid. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/12/opinion/trump-is-fighting-the-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An old and worthy insight from the Nobel laureate and originator of cognitive psychology and artificial intelligence, Herb Simon: Don't spend 15 minutes figuring out a shortcut that will save you 10 minutes. Information-gathering and decision-making themselves have costs, so "satisfice" rather than seeking to optimize. This op-ed by David Epstein draws out implications for life decisions. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/12/opinion/decision-making-herber…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Evolutionary psychiatry: Illuminating disorders by the ultimate functions of emotion and thought patterns, not an inventory of symptoms. Overview essay by one of its pioneers, Randolph Nesse - 2023 - World Psychiatry - Wiley Online Library onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/wps.21072
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Childhood stunting fell dramatically over the 20th century - Our World in Data ourworldindata.org/childhood-stunting-fell-dramatically-o…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Evolutionary psychiatry: Illuminating disorders by the ultimate functions of emotion and thought patterns, not an inventory of symptoms. Overview essay by one of its pioneers, Randolph Nesse - 2023 - World Psychiatry - Wiley Online Library onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/wps.21072
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's easy to misunderstand Mental Health Diagnoses. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/11/opinion/adhd-autism-depression…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Visual analysis of two haunting portraits: El ojo de Arnold Newman sobre Stravinsky y Gödel blogs.elespectador.com/actualidad/catrecillo/el-ojo-de-ar…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I'm sometimes told that "The Dark Ages" were a myth. The historian Richard Carrier responds: Yes, the Dark Ages Really Were a Thing. www.richardcarrier.info/archives/15567
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What has Christianity to do with Western values? It fought the Enlightenment hammer-and-tongs, and its American evangelical version is happy to subvert democracy, peace, and universal human rights. freethinker.co.uk/2024/01/what-has-christianity-to-do-wit… via @freethinkermag
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Waymo and the advancement of women. open.substack.com/pub/matthewyglesias/p/this-mothers-day-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A Bit of Kvetching and a Bit of Celebration | Mattering and the Mattering Summit, by Rebecca Newberger Goldstein @platobooktour open.substack.com/pub/rebeccanewbergergoldstein/p/a-bit-o…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"The truth is ugly: The world’s richest men are crushing the world’s poorest children." www.nytimes.com/2026/05/09/opinion/foreign-aid-cuts.html?…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When I was assigned Camus's L’Étranger when I was a 17-year-old college student, I thought it was dreadful, reaffirmed when I re-read it 50 years later for a BBC radio program. Not surprised, then, by Jaspreet Singh Boparai's review of a new film adaptation: "François Ozon deserves credit rather than blame for exposing the essential banality, poverty, and mediocrity of his source material for L’Étranger, even if he did so entirely by accident." open.substack.com/pub/quillette/p/staring-at-the-sea?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In Gad Saad's book Suicidal Empathy he does clarify that he's not against empathy across the board, just when it is detached from rationality. But with its hyperbolic title (US immigration enforcement may have been too lax in recent years, but that's hardly "suicide"), and the current political context (which he surely is aware of) in which Trumpian and evangelical attacks on empathy are being used to justify cruel, destructive, and irrational policies -- together with the taunting and trolling style that Trump seems to have unleashed -- criticism is warranted.
quillette.com/2026/05/06/playing-gad/Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
For more on the absurd right-wing campaign against empathy, see these: www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/sin-empathy-chr… and www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2025/apr/08/em…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Empathy, in the sense of the emotion that prompts one to weight others' interests commensurably with one's own, is the basis of morality and a major driver of human progress. (Spinoza: "Those who are governed by reason desire nothing for themselves which they do not also desire for the rest of humankind.") Yes, it can be problematic if it overrides all other considerations (fairness, impartiality, effectiveness, long-term effects), but that's because anything is harmful if it is applied heedless of tradeoffs, balance, and judgment.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Suicide is the ultimate existential decision ("To be or not to be"), and one would think that it would engage the deepest reflection. But in fact suicide decisions are driven by astonishingly simple circumstances, in particular how easy is it is to do (whether cooking gas is lethal, whether toxic pesticides are within easy reach, whether a gun is in the house, whether a scenic bridge or overlook has a high fence). New Harvard study shows that reducing the hotline number to 3 digits (988) saves lots of lives! — Harvard Gazette news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/05/simpler-is-better-…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
As I noted in the analysis of suicide data in Enlightenment Now, "Dorothy Parker’s macabre poem “Resumé” (which ends, “Guns aren’t lawful; Nooses give; Gas smells awful; You might as well live”) is disconcertingly close to the mindset of a person contemplating suicide."
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Though the US suicide rate has increased since the late 1990s, the rate for the world as a whole has declined substantially:
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Does Christianity deserve credit for every good idea (and some of the bad ones) in human history? Maarten Boudry @mboudry explains why it doesn't.
Maarten Boudry
@mboudry
In his celebrated book Dominion, the British historian @holland_tom argues that virtually all the achievements of the modern world are indebted to a moral revolution wrought by Christianity: human rights, social security, science, gender equality — it’s all supposedly there in the Bible, if you read between the lines.
Holland is a brilliant writer and podcaster, and I loved some of his earlier books, but I really hated this one. It’s a long exercise in what I’d call retrorevelation: the annoying habit of religious apologists — mostly Christians — of retroactively claiming credit for all the things they once fought tooth and nail against, or all the things you can find in a gazillion other cultural traditions. The overall argument feels very superficial, attributing all manner of things to Christianity without seriously comparing it to non-Christian cultures and traditions.
Yes, many Renaissance and Enlightenment thinkers framed their innovations in Christian terms. But in the suffocating intellectual climate of early modern Europe, Biblical justification was often the only way to make new ideas socially and politically viable, no matter how opportunistic the connection. Besides, early Christians were hardly unique in preaching radical moral ideals like loving your enemy or turning the other cheek. Such counterintuitive ethical systems were common across Axial Age traditions.*
And for one thing, despite its lofty ideals, Christians never seriously considered abolishing slavery for more than a millennium and a half, and there is nothing in the Bible that clearly condemns the institution. On the contrary, slaves are repeatedly instructed to obey their masters. Yes, abolitionists invoked Christian justifications, but so did their pro-slavery opponents (with many Bible verses to back them up). As far as I know, the only ancient authors who explicitly opposed slavery on moral grounds were pagans, not Christians — figures like the Greek rhetorician Alcidamas and the poet Philemon in the 4th century BC. And on the “good side” of antiquity, I can find nothing in the Bible that is even remotely as beautiful, uplifting, and humane as De Rerum Natura by Lucretius, who had never heard of Jesus.
I’ve long wanted to write a critical review of Dominion, but never got around to it. This excellent piece by @RichardHanania is more or less the review I wish I had written myself — though you’ll need a subscription to read the full piece. As Hanania writes: “[Holland’s] method can just devolve into haphazardly associating general concepts that look similar to one another in the service of a narrative that sounds good.”
The book is full of vivid characters and engaging stories, but it becomes increasingly absurd toward the end, when Holland tries to trace virtually everything back to Christianity.
Marxism? Basically secularized Christianity: radical equality, concern for the oppressed, redemption of the outcast.
Nazism? Holland even suggests that the Nazi desire to “purify” the world echoed Christian ideas of cleansing evil and redeeming humanity. He writes:
“Yet Hitler, even as he cast his campaign against them as a matter of public health, would often assimilate it to another narrative: a profoundly Christian one. To be saved, the world had to be cleansed. A people threatened by perdition required redemption.”
Needless to say, wokeness is also Christian to the core.
It’s been a while since I read his book, so apologies to Tom Holland if I’ve simplified or misrepresented some parts of the argument — perhaps I’ll write a proper review one day.
* For the record, I’m not a historian of religion, but this is what Claude had to say about Axial Age religions:
“Yes, this is a well-documented observation among historians of religion and philosophy. The Axial Age (roughly 800–200 BCE, a term coined by Karl Jaspers) saw a remarkable convergence across several civilizations, where thinkers independently developed moral and ethical frameworks that challenged conventional human instincts like tribalism, revenge, and self-interest.
- Buddhism (5th century BCE) is perhaps the most striking example. The Buddha taught mettā (loving-kindness) toward all beings, including those who harm you. The Dhammapada contains passages urging practitioners to overcome hatred with love and to respond to anger with calm — very close in spirit to ‘love your enemy.’
- Confucianism and Mohism in China offered related ideas. While Confucius was more measured (when asked about repaying injury with kindness, he replied ‘repay injury with justice’), Mozi (5th century BCE) went further with his doctrine of jiān ài (universal or impartial love), arguing that people should care for strangers and even rival states as much as their own — a radically counterintuitive position that was widely debated precisely because it cut against natural partiality.
- Jainism developed ahimsa (non-violence) to an extreme degree, extending compassion and non-harm to all living creatures, including insects. This demanded extraordinary self-discipline and restraint even toward those who might threaten you.
- Stoicism in Greece taught that all human beings share in a universal rational nature, and that anger and vengeance are failures of reason. Marcus Aurelius (though later than the Axial Age proper) wrote extensively about responding to hostility with understanding rather than retaliation, building on earlier Stoic foundations.
- Zoroastrianism emphasized the moral duty to actively choose good over evil, framing ethics as a cosmic struggle that required personal sacrifice and integrity beyond mere self-interest.
- The Hebrew prophetic tradition — figures like Amos, Hosea, and Isaiah — challenged their own society with demands for justice toward the poor, the stranger, and the marginalized, often at great personal cost.”
www.richardhanania.com/p/jesus-ancient-revolutionary-but-not -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why game theory is indispensable to understanding contemporary issues (in this case, phone bans in school). www.nytimes.com/2026/05/08/opinion/social-media-teens-pho…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Colleges, Maybe Try Teaching!" William Deresiewicz is always a lively and original commentator on higher education, and this essay has some provocative (and excellent) ideas, like pivoting from (often useless) research to conscientious pedagogy. But it has the problems I've criticized him for in the past: argument-free assertions (here, on a mandatory curriculum) and a belletristic disdain for science and analytical subject matter. In the 21st century, no one can claim to be educated who does not grasp the ideas behind entropy, evolution, genetics, computation, probability, Bayes' Rule, game theory, rational choice (among others)--for reasons which include an appreciation of life's meaning. open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/how-to-revive-liberal…
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How evolution and genetics are relevant to deep questions about life's meaning: quillette.com/2026/03/25/the-many-roots-of-our-suffering-…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How entropy is relevant to deep questions about life's meaning: www.amazon.com/Mattering-Instinct-Deepest-Longing-Divides…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Israel’s Creation: The Ultimate ‘Decolonisation’ Project quillette.com/2026/05/07/israels-creation-the-ultimate-de…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What Cognitive Science Tells Us About AI Warfare open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/ai-is-about-the-vibes…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Constitution, for all it’s brilliance, has many flagrant flaws, now being exploited. It should and and can be amended. open.substack.com/pub/theunpopulist/p/constitutional-amen…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Human knowledge deployed toward reducing scarcity yields abundance with population growth, the opposite of Paul Ehrlich’s predictions of famine and doom. open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/earth-day…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I find these questions fascinating…
The Chicago Manual of Style
@ChicagoManual
Q. Is “The more the merrier” a complete sentence?
Q. Is “kindly” used correctly in “We kindly ask …”?
Q. “It’s not only this, it’s that.” Is that a comma splice?
We answer these and other questions about Chicago style in the May Q&A at CMOS Online. cmos.style/QandA -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I discussed the limits of empathy in The Better Angels of Our Nature, but it's still a powerful force in the decline of violence and expansion of well-being, and I find the new right-wing contempt for empathy ("toxic empathy," "suicidal empathy") contemptible. With a presidential administration that delights in cruelty and callousness, an excess of empathy is the least of our problems.
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
"As a right-leaning person myself, Saad’s excruciating style actually made me empathise, to some extent, with left-wingers & how they view the Right. If the Left can suffer from suicidal empathy...then right-wingers can suffer from homicidal incuriosity"
quillette.com/2026/05/06/playing-gad/ -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
No pill for exercise: My friend and Harvard colleague, the biological anthropologist Dan Lieberman, invokes evolution to explain why GLP-1s can’t replace physical activity current.fas.harvard.edu/stories/no-pill-exercise-why-glp-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
No pill for exercise: My friend and Harvard colleague, the biological anthropologist Dan Lieberman, invokes evolution to explain why GLP-1s can’t replace physical activity current.fas.harvard.edu/stories/no-pill-exercise-why-glp-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Another decline in violence that has continued since the publication of The Better Angels of Our Nature in 2011 (some, like battle deaths, have increased a bit since then, though still well below historical levels).
Human Progress
@HumanProgress
In 1940, nearly every European country practiced capital punishment.
Today, it has nearly disappeared: Belarus is the only European country that still carries out executions, while Russia retains the death penalty in law but has observed a moratorium for decades.
Across a continent of 700 million people, state execution nearly vanished within a single lifetime. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker: Conhecimento comum, redes sociais, IA, pensamento crítico - 45 Graus | Podcast on Spotify open.spotify.com/episode/79MCWDLbBJSI0fXEPuRIKn?nd=1&dlsi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New podcast conversation, on Portugal's major platform on ideas and critical thinking, with Jose Pimentel.
José Maria Pimentel
@pimenteljm
A conversation I’d wanted to have for a long time. In the latest episode of 45 Graus, I spoke with @sapinker about common knowledge, social media, AI, critical thinking, and what happens when societies lose a shared understanding of reality. expresso.pt/podcasts/45-graus/2026-05-06-steven-pinker-de…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Perverse Tyranny of a Perfect Transcript - In The Atlantic, my collague Josh Greene makes the case for why not every Harvard student should get an A in every course. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/05/harvard-grade-inflation…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Before setting up the grading reform committee (on which Josh serves) Harvard was in denial, even suggesting that the problem was really "grade compression" owing to our students becoming more and more excellent. At an early planning meeting I helped put the kibosh on that wishful thinking by showing that performance in the objective, multiple-choice final exam in my intro course had declined by 10 percentage points over the 21 years I've taught it, despite improvements in pedagogy.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I discussed the limits of empathy in The Better Angels of Our Nature, but it's still a powerful force in the decline of violence and expansion of well-being, and I find the new right-wing contempt for empathy ("toxic empathy," "suicidal empathy") contemptible. With a presidential administration that delights in cruelty and callousness, an excess of empathy is the least of our problems.
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
"As a right-leaning person myself, Saad’s excruciating style actually made me empathise, to some extent, with left-wingers & how they view the Right. If the Left can suffer from suicidal empathy...then right-wingers can suffer from homicidal incuriosity"
quillette.com/2026/05/06/playing-gad/ -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The innumeracy of narrative journalism: Long NYT essay on the fertility decline blames it on uncertainty due to rises in mortality, inequality, unemployment, work vulnerability, poverty, etc., without citing a single datum on how any of these have changed over time, nor even the simplest correlations with fertility. | Why So Few Babies? We Might Have Overlooked the Biggest Reason of All. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/07/opinion/birthrate-kids-parents…
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Here are the trends of some of the supposed contributors to uncertainty:
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Particularly vulnerable employment:
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Our World in Data shows how this kind of analysis ought to be reported. ourworldindata.org/global-decline-fertility-rate
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Simone Rodan-Benzaquen
@srodan
There is a claim that keeps circulating, presented as sophisticated analysis: antisemitic violence is caused by Israel’s actions. If Israel behaved differently, Jewish communities around the world would somehow be safer. This argument is not analysis. It is a moral inversion. And it collapses the moment you apply it consistently.
When China imprisons Uyghurs, does anyone warn Muslim communities in Paris to expect attacks? When Russia invaded Ukraine, did anyone tell Russian restaurants to brace for violence? No. Never. The causal chain between a government’s actions and violence against a diaspora is only ever constructed for Jews. Every other minority is extended the basic moral courtesy of being treated as individuals rather than proxies.
Now look at what the data actually shows. The SPCJ, which tracks antisemitic incidents in France in coordination with the Interior Ministry, has documented a consistent and damning pattern: it is antisemitic violence that inspires more antisemitic violence, not Israeli policy. After Mohamed Merah murdered Jewish children at point-blank range at the Ozar Hatorah school in Toulouse in 2012, antisemitic acts surged by 200%. There was no Gaza operation. No Israeli military action. The massacre of Jews in France produced more attacks on Jews in France.
The same logic held after the Hypercacher attack in January 2015: antisemitic acts increased by nearly 300%. Massacres of Jews do not shock antisemites into restraint. They embolden them. They signal impunity. They normalize hatred. And everyone in a position of responsibility knows it.
Which brings us to October 7. From the day of the Hamas attack, antisemitic acts in France increased by over 1,000%. A daily average of approximately 25 antisemitic acts was recorded in the 30 days that followed, reaching nearly 40 on some days. In the three months after the attack, the number of antisemitic acts equaled those recorded over the previous three years combined.
And here is another detail that makes the “Israel causes antisemitism” argument impossible to sustain: the spike began on October 7 itself, the very day of the attack. Israel had not yet responded. Not a single soldier had entered Gaza. Interior Minister Darmanin sent an urgent message to prefects that same day asking them to immediately reinforce protection of Jewish community sites. Synagogues. Schools. Community centers. By October 10, 10,000 police officers had been deployed to protect 500 Jewish sites across the country.
Before any Israeli response existed, the French government already knew that Jewish communities needed protecting. Not because of what Israel was about to do. Because of what had just been done to Jews.
Antisemitic violence has one cause. Antisemitism. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Are the Brooms Multiplying Yet? Second excellent essay on AI risk by @mboudry open.substack.com/pub/maartenboudry/p/are-the-brooms-mult…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
First of 2 essays by @mboudry which I think nail the problem of AI existential risk: Neither malevolence nor lethal means to an end are natural products of intelligence, though they could arise if anyone was so stupid and reckless as to both empower AIs and let them evolve in the wild. | Why HAL 9000 Was Afraid to Die and Real AIs Aren’t open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/why-hal-9…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Advice for lawyers (or anyone else) on effective writing, by Judge David Weinzweig (author of Zen and the Art of Persuasive Writing).
Zen and the Art of Persuasive Writing
@Zenpersuasion
I’m an appellate court judge.
I’ve read thousands of briefs.
Here’s what no one told you about persuasion and how to win. Thread. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A witty song about Entropy, by Marc Sagan. youtu.be/BQfZEKe0syw via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I find these questions fascinating…
The Chicago Manual of Style
@ChicagoManual
Q. Is “The more the merrier” a complete sentence?
Q. Is “kindly” used correctly in “We kindly ask …”?
Q. “It’s not only this, it’s that.” Is that a comma splice?
We answer these and other questions about Chicago style in the May Q&A at CMOS Online. cmos.style/QandA -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Human knowledge deployed toward reducing scarcity yields abundance with population growth, the opposite of Paul Ehrlich’s predictions of famine and doom. open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/earth-day…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Constitution, for all it’s brilliance, has many flagrant flaws, now being exploited. It should and and can be amended. open.substack.com/pub/theunpopulist/p/constitutional-amen…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Reading Orwell in the Age of AI by Matt Johnson @mattjj89 quillette.com/2026/05/04/reading-orwell-in-the-age-of-ai-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Do Humans Have Eyebrows? An Evolutionary Biologist Explains via @forbes www.forbes.com/sites/scotttravers/2026/05/01/why-do-human…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When a self-proclaimed civil rights organization puts Ayaan Hirsi Ali, of all people, on a "hate watch" list, you know it has been twisted into a grotesque hate group itself. But this was only a sample of its perversions. Ayaan: The SPLC Targeted Me. Now Its Reckoning Has Come.
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Brian Keating (@briankeating) and Rebecca Newberger Goldstein (@platobooktour) discuss "The Law of Physics Behind Depression."
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
The thing that suicidally depressed people feel is that they don’t matter; others do, they don’t. Nothing they can do will ever make them matter. It’s a terrible, terrible feeling. And what this means is they cannot abide their own presence.
Brian Keating:
What if there is a law of physics that explains why depression feels the way it does?
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
When I first learned about the second law of thermodynamics, it seemed—I couldn’t quite conceptualize it. We are subject to the second law of thermodynamics, which, you know, has a tragic dimension. In fact, when I was a graduate student, it occurred to me, oh my gosh, biological systems are really just organized to resist the second law of thermodynamics.
In some sense, biology is a response to this supreme law that tells us that, in closed systems, energy never increases; entropy never decreases. Entropy never decreases, and if there’s any way for it to increase, it will. Entropy is the measure of the disorder of a system. The more disorder, the higher the entropy, and the less efficient the work you can get out at the end of the system.
And in fact, Rudolf Clausius, the physicist, said that the universe itself will go to thermal equilibrium—what we call the heat death—and so there will be no more energy to be gotten out of it at the end of the system. Rudolf Clausius, the 19th-century physicist who formulated the concept of entropy, which means literally “transformation from within”—there’s poignancy in that. This transformation from within is going to the end of the system. And he said that the universe itself will go to thermal equilibrium, to what we call the heat death, and so there will be no more energy to be gotten out of it.
Brian Keating:
So let’s start with that story you tell first about Ludwig Boltzmann, who solved one of the great paradoxes of physics, the irreversibility paradox. Talk about that. And then why, in your mind, was he so traumatized, perhaps, or so full of dread of his equation that he took his own life? So talk about that.
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
So there was this great paradox, which is that most—probably most—of the processes that we observe are irreversible. If you film them—and tell me if I’m being too elementary, because I’m going to be very—you know, if you film them, like let’s say I crack open an egg and I stir it up and then I fry it, and somebody filmed this and then reversed the film, anybody who sees the reverse of that film is going to know it was reversed. That cannot happen in nature: that the egg is going to uncook itself, unscramble; the yolk is going to separate from the albumen and jump into the shell and seal up. Impossible, right? So almost everything that we see is irreversible.
Brian Keating:
Yes. I saw that line, Rebecca. It made me think, because you mentioned it in the context of his daughter, Elsa, finding her father’s dead body. And it wasn’t like he showed any sign. I mean, we can’t go into the minds of someone who dies by suicide, right? Yes. But at the same time, you’d think, well, this would be a more common thing.
And so, is depression sort of a—you know, they used to think of miasmas and things in the air, you write about that in the book—is depression, at heart, an entropic collapsing process?
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
I have spoken to a lot of people who suffer from clinical depression. And I want to say, first of all, that the U.S. hotline for suicide prevention is www.samhsa.gov/resource/988/you-matter-psa-video.
The thing that suicidally depressed people feel is that they don’t matter. Others do. They don’t. Nothing they can do will ever make them matter. It’s a terrible, terrible feeling. And what this means is they cannot—they can’t abide their own presence. I really think it shows how strong this mattering instinct is in us. If you can’t somehow appease it, you can’t abide your own presence.
And so, what the people I’ve spoken to—and one is a very, very good philosopher who has suffered from depression—have told me is that, phenomenologically, this is exactly what it feels like. It feels like psychic disintegration.
So, in some sense, yes—happiness is a very ordered state. And I would go even further: everything worth living for is an ordered state. I think knowledge—knowledge, knowledge, knowledge—is better than ignorance. Clarity is better than confusion. Flourishing is better than suffering. Love is better than hatred. Beauty is better than ugliness. These are truisms; these are what we all accept. Look at the thing that’s better: it’s an ordered state. And its negation is a disordered state.
So I think—I would argue—this is a very kind of Spinozist argument, trying to get out of the laws of nature some ethical enlightenment, some ethical guidance, because that’s what we want. We want ethical guidance.
So we know we want to matter. We know we do all sorts of things to matter. Some people do very bad things in order to matter. Some of the people I’ve spoken to… they do. They want power over others. They want dominance. They want to make other people’s lives miserable. These are bad things, right? They cause an increase in entropy.
This is how I judge people now: are you increasing entropy, or are you decreasing it?
-- Full video in link below.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Reading Orwell in the Age of AI by Matt Johnson @mattjj89 quillette.com/2026/05/04/reading-orwell-in-the-age-of-ai-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If the world would end tomorrow, what would you want as your last meal? Tom Nash asks people that question, and then cooks it for them (without hands). This video in his Last Meal series features My Dinner with Tom.
Tom Nash
@DjHookie
Stop panicking.🛑 The world is getting better. The data is unambiguous. And yet most of us refuse to believe it.
@sapinker explains why, and what it means for how you live your life.
Full episode on YouTube. Link below.
#stevenpinker #humanprogress #lastmeal -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Opinion | What is truth, anyway? @michaelshermer explains, based on his new book. www.bostonglobe.com/2026/04/29/opinion/truth-trump-transg… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I am targeted by several publishing scams a week, promoting book clubs, reading groups, influencers, publicity campaigns, list placers... all using AI-generated bullet points flattering my books. Yesterday it was "Terry Gross" (with a gmail, not npr.org email address) offering to interview me on "Fresh Air" -- for a fee. It's Nigerian finance ministers' widows for 21st-century authors.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Here's the new publishing scam, which includes getting you to pay a "consultant" to get your book proposal ready + an "agent" to help you sell your book + an "editor" to help you prepare your manuscript, etc. And they're in Nigeria & take wires & bitcoin!
writerbeware.blog/2026/03/27/watch-out-for-this-scam-impe… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When a self-proclaimed civil rights organization puts Ayaan Hirsi Ali, of all people, on a "hate watch" list, you know it has been twisted into a grotesque hate group itself. But this was only a sample of its perversions. Ayaan: The SPLC Targeted Me. Now Its Reckoning Has Come.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In my experience the desire of many parents of autistic children to believe that their inner lives are normal but they are locked in by an inability to communicate is so intense as to overwhelm critical faculties. I've watched a dad pathetically jiggle an iPad under his son's stationary hand and insist the young man was communicating with me. This opens the door for charlatans to mislead and exploit these people with "Facilitated Communication" and related techniques, repeatedly shown to be worthless. www.nytimes.com/2026/05/01/opinion/autism-facilitated-com…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Though phone calls are more effective at influencing legislators than email (see www.nytimes.com/2016/11/22/us/politics/heres-why-you-shou…), if you can't call it's unbelievably easy to send them a message - just Google "Contact Senator [So-and-so]" and you'll be taken to a webpage with a captcha, some ID fields, and a text box.
David Kay
@_David_Kay
Millions of mother pigs could be forced to spend their lives in gestation crates — unable to move or turn around. The House just passed a #farmbill with the #saveourbacon Act that allows exactly this. Call your senator: (202) 224-3121 — tell them to vote NO on #saveourbacon 🐷
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It may be unrealistic to expect the world to become vegetarian (at least not until synthetic meat is produced at scale), but that doesn't mean we must treat farm animals with vicious cruelty. Small protections can reduce massive harm at tolerable costs. Tell your senator to vote NO on the Farm Bill if it includes the "#saveourbacon Act."
David Kay
@_David_Kay
Millions of mother pigs could be forced to spend their lives in gestation crates — unable to move or turn around. The House just passed a #farmbill with the #saveourbacon Act that allows exactly this. Call your senator: (202) 224-3121 — tell them to vote NO on #saveourbacon 🐷
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How the Weak Prevail, by evolutionary anthropologist Scott Atran: People in the throes of sacred values don't capitulate, even when they sustain tremendous damage. A psychological insight that war planners should understand. quillette.com/2026/05/02/how-the-weak-prevail-isis-iran-g…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Interintellect 🧭
@interintellect_
We’re living through a massive crisis of mattering, where everyone is fighting to be seen, yet we’ve never felt more invisible. In this salon, @platobooktour and @MamanLunettes look at how this deep, biological hunger to feel significant is actually what’s tearing our culture apart.
It’s a wild look at how our will to matter creates the very fault lines of power and identity we’re currently crashing into. If you’ve been feeling the weight of the endless competition for status and belonging lately, you really need to watch this.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Do Humans Have Eyebrows? An Evolutionary Biologist Explains via @forbes www.forbes.com/sites/scotttravers/2026/05/01/why-do-human…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Congratulations to Dr. Dylan Tweed, who brilliantly defended his PhD dissertation “Collective Outrage as Deterrence”’ in the Department of Psychology at Harvard earlier today.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Ask Me Anything": I answer a variety of questions on language, cognition, progress, and political centrism (plus some personal questions, like how tall I am in real life) on the subreddit DeepStateCentrism. youtu.be/0FYbI2koLG8 via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Contrary to a popular narrative, each generation earns more than the previous one (though Millennials enjoyed the advantage later in life, because they stayed in school longer). @Noahpinion open.substack.com/pub/noahpinion/p/roundup-81-back-to-our…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On the Nonzero podcast, Robert Wright chats with Rebecca Newberger Goldstein about mattering and The Mattering Instinct. youtu.be/LPjE5BPJYe0 via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
We should oppose the Trump administration's abuse of the law to intimidate and cripple private advocacy organizations they don't like. But what they say about the Southern Poverty Law Center (which I used to donate to) is, unfortunately, correct: It “long ago abandoned civil rights work and turned into a partisan smear machine.” Among the targets in its McCarthyite "Hate Watch" list are ordinary academic behavioral geneticists whose research challenges the blank slate. www.nytimes.com/2026/04/22/us/southern-poverty-law-center…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Death rates during climbing expeditions [on Mt Everest] fell by half between the initial period — 1921 to 2006 — and more recent years, 2007 to 2024, with the mortality rate falling from 1.4 percent to 0.7 percent." Fits the pattern I documented in Enlightenment Now: though we often chafe at safety restrictions, they have dramatically reduced deaths in every human activity: occupational accidents, fires, drownings, car crashes, plane crashes, pedestrian deaths, poisonings, even lightning strikes (one exception: opiate overdoses). news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/04/call-it-his-person…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Review of "The Revolutionary Center": For all its troubles, no system better protects freedom, affluence, thought, and security than liberal democracy. www.wsj.com/arts-culture/books/the-revolutionary-center-r… via @WSJBooks
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Leibniz mused, "The only way to rectify our reasonings is to make them as tangible as those of the Mathematicians, so that we can find our error at a glance, and when there are disputes among persons, we can simply say: Let us calculate, without further ado, to see who is right."
350 years later, I sometimes get proposals for formal systems (sometimes using AI) that "diagram arguments" to pinpoint falsehoods and fallacies. Scott Alexander @slatestarcodex, too. Here he explains: "Your Attempt To Solve Debate Will Not Work." open.substack.com/pub/astralcodexten/p/your-attempt-to-so… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Leibniz mused, "The only way to rectify our reasonings is to make them as tangible as those of the Mathematicians, so that we can find our error at a glance, and when there are disputes among persons, we can simply say: Let us calculate, without further ado, to see who is right."
350 years later, I sometimes get proposals for formal systems (sometimes using AI) that "diagram arguments" to pinpoint falsehoods and fallacies. Scott Alexander @slatestarcodex, too. Here he explains: "Your Attempt To Solve Debate Will Not Work." open.substack.com/pub/astralcodexten/p/your-attempt-to-so… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Review of "The Revolutionary Center": For all its troubles, no system better protects freedom, affluence, thought, and security than liberal democracy. www.wsj.com/arts-culture/books/the-revolutionary-center-r… via @WSJBooks
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Death rates during climbing expeditions [on Mt Everest] fell by half between the initial period — 1921 to 2006 — and more recent years, 2007 to 2024, with the mortality rate falling from 1.4 percent to 0.7 percent." Fits the pattern I documented in Enlightenment Now: though we often chafe at safety restrictions, they have dramatically reduced deaths in every human activity: occupational accidents, fires, drownings, car crashes, plane crashes, pedestrian deaths, poisonings, even lightning strikes (one exception: opiate overdoses). news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/04/call-it-his-person…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I'll be speaking at Big Techday in Munich, Friday 22, 4:10 PM. Free streaming links will be posted the day of the event. www.bigtechday.com
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
As an avid cyclist, I was amused to see ChatGPT's “powerful new image engine" draw a bicycle with the "brake" label pointing to empty space where brakes are sometimes found on other bicycles. The point of these AI fails (regularly collected by @garymarcus) is not that LLMs are useless or unintelligent but that they think differently from humans, lacking explicit knowledge of reality and instead amalgamating billions of statistical generalizations. open.substack.com/pub/garymarcus/p/chatgpts-powerful-new-…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Cathy Young 🇺🇸🇺🇦🇮🇱
@CathyYoung63
New: at @JoinPersuasion, I address claims that "anti-woke" "free speech warriors" have
1) hypocritically abetted Trump's attacks on free speech/civil liberties (mostly no)
2) enabled Trump's ascent by stoking "moral panic" about "cancel culture" (nope!)
www.persuasion.community/p/dont-blame-the-anti-woke-crowd… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Swedish translation of When everyone knows that everyone knows will be published by Fri Tanke ("Free thought") this October. fritanke.se/bokhandel/bocker/nar-alla-vet-att-alla-vet/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I'll be speaking at Big Techday in Munich, Friday 22, 4:10 PM. Free streaming links will be posted the day of the event. www.bigtechday.com
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
They (FIRE, and those of us who signed the Harper's letter on free speech) Went Hard Against Woke. And Then… Went Even Harder Against Trump open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/dont-blame-the-anti-w…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If America's So Rich, How'd It Get So Sad? One answer: "'News tone has been more negative than the fundamentals would predict during 2018 to 2020 and even more negative than predicted in 2021 to 2023.' Today’s news is more surprisingly negative than at any period of news on record." open.substack.com/pub/derekthompson/p/if-americas-so-rich…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What to make of ‘AI psychosis’? — Harvard psychiatrist John Torous warns against the panic that LLMs are literally making people mad: "I feel comfortable saying that AI as a catalyst of psychosis is very rare." news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/04/what-to-make-of-ai…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A history of royal visits to the US, illustrating one of the points in my book When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. www.nytimes.com/2026/04/27/world/europe/royal-visits-amer…
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
International relations are social relations, also cemented by conspicuous signals. "Countries’ main exports are not just commodities like maize or bauxite but focal points. Every year there are around 45 incidents in which a government engages in some purely symbolic act of the kind that individual people perform to ratify their relationships. Leaders embrace, stay at each other’s mansions, shake or hold hands, give gifts, break bread, cross or gaze at borders, lay wreaths, send Vice Presidents to funerals, and exchange athletes, students, or zoo animals. They declare ceasefires after the shooting has stopped, renounce nuclear weapons they have no intention of building, and apologize for the crimes of their long-dead ancestors."
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This Tuesday: "I am Steve Pinker, a cognitive psychologist and author. AMA!" : r/DeepStateCentrism www.reddit.com/r/DeepStateCentrism/comments/1so6tbf/i_am_…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Time's Arrow and the Drive to Matter (discussion of Tom Stoppard's Arcadia and Rebecca Goldstein's The Mattering Instinct @platobooktour), by one of my longtime favorite writers, Virginia Postrel @vpostrel open.substack.com/pub/vpostrel/p/times-arrow-and-the-driv…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Thirty-six years ago, @paulbloomatyale and I argued that the human language faculty was a genetically complex trait, distinct from general cognition, which evolved gradually by natural selection of many regulatory genes over a long period (as opposed to being the result of a single lucky macromutation, just another manifestation of general intelligence, or a by-product of a big brain). We were repeatedly told that our hypothesis was an unfalsifiable after-the-fact just-so story. | Natural language and natural selection | Behavioral and Brain Sciences cup.org/3ONGedr
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A major new study just published in Science Advances, using polygenic scores, large samples of people varying in language abilities, ancient DNA, and statistical analyses of signs of selection, suggests we were right. (Moreover, selection for language has been recently balanced by selection against big brains, thanks to the "obstetrical dilemma.) | Ancient regulatory evolution shapes individual language abilities in present-day humans | Science Advances www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.aed5260
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Kelsey Piper
@KelseyTuoc
My ancestors buried half their children. All mine are alive. My ancestors' house had a dirt floor. Mine is wood. I have indoor plumbing, I have hot water, I have never in my life hauled a full bucket half a mile and I probably never will. Do you know how rare it is, in human history, for small children to wear shoes? Mine have multiple pairs. I can speak to my relatives who live thousands of miles away, for free, at any time. Video, if we want video. With machine translation, if we speak different languages.
The original Library of Congress had 740 books in it. I have more than that. If I run out of books in my home my local public library has 350,000. If I want to take a hundred books with me on vacation, they all fit on a device that fits in my purse.
I have heat in the winter and AC in the summer and a washing machine and I have never, ever, ever had to scrub a dress clean by hand in the stream. I can look up recipes from more than a hundred different countries and I've tried dozens of them. I ride a clean and modern train across my city for $4, or take a robot taxi if I'm out too late for the train. I donate $40,000 every year to the cause of getting healthcare to the world's poorest people and even after the donations I never have to think about whether I can afford a book, or a pair of shoes, or a cup of coffee.
There is a great deal more to fight for, of course. I hope that our descendants will look back on our lives and list a thousand ways they're richer. Maybe we ourselves will do that, if some of the crazier stuff comes true.
But the abundance is all around you and to a significant degree you aren't feeling it only because fish don't notice water. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Evolution Explains the Human Condition: Persuasion has reprinted my obituary of Robert Trivers. open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/the-strange-ways-peop…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Human Progress
@HumanProgress
Throughout the 20th century, average IQ scores rose year after year.
In recent decades, that trend appears to have reversed .
@sapinker discusses why on our podcast.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
California cities just saw their lowest homicide rates in decades. It's not clear why calmatters.org/justice/2026/01/california-homicide-rate/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is It True That... the Past Was Less Violent? - Watch the full documentary (but not in the US, unfortunately - seems to be Europe-only). | ARTE in English www.arte.tv/en/videos/123428-018-A/is-it-true-that/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Subsidize a Diagnosis, Get More Diagnoses." Economics 101 meets Psychopathology 101 in this podcast by @AdamOmaryPhD www.cato.org/multimedia/cato-podcast/subsidize-diagnosis-… via @CatoInstitute
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Ever since I bought The Whole Earth Catalogue as a teenager, and again when I read his "ecopragmatist manifesto" and then got to know the man, I've admired Stewart Brand. Here he is in conversation with Ezra Klein: "Silicon Valley’s Favorite Prophet, on Life’s Most Important Principle" www.nytimes.com/2026/04/24/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-ste…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Most people care about farm animals — but eat lots of meat anyway. (Consistent with the data I cited in The Better Angels of Our Nature 15 years ago. Despite all the vegetarians we know, the proportion in the population has barely budged.) - Our World in Data
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
California cities just saw their lowest homicide rates in decades. It's not clear why calmatters.org/justice/2026/01/california-homicide-rate/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"If the Left wants to recover from this moral catastrophe [glorifying mass murder and rape by a reactionary death cult ], it must begin a serious reckoning." @mboudry Maarten Boudry turns around the question, "What Did You Think Decolonisation Meant?" quillette.com/2026/04/20/what-did-you-think-decolonisatio…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
We should oppose the Trump administration's abuse of the law to intimidate and cripple private advocacy organizations they don't like. But what they say about the Southern Poverty Law Center (which I used to donate to) is, unfortunately, correct: It “long ago abandoned civil rights work and turned into a partisan smear machine.” Among the targets in its McCarthyite "Hate Watch" list are ordinary academic behavioral geneticists whose research challenges the blank slate. www.nytimes.com/2026/04/22/us/southern-poverty-law-center…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Another modern miracle: Gene therapy cures a form of deafness. Harvard to USA: You're welcome. news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/04/hearing-breakthrou…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A highlight of my trip to Cordoba to deliver the keynote at the International Conference on Bilingual Education: a pilgrimage to the statue of Maimonides, aka Rabbi Moses ben Maimon, acronym Rambam:
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I published a series of studies testing whether 21st century people share Maimonides's 12th-century intuitions (they mostly, but not entirely, do), and why: sinaiandsynapses.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/maimonide…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
And his Ladder introduced the chapter on social relations in my book When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life. www.amazon.com/When-Everyone-Knows-That-Knowledge/dp/1668…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Every murder is a tragedy and an atrocity, but the fact that only three murders have been reported in Boston so far in 2026 is something to celebrate (and try to understand) | Universal Hub www.universalhub.com/crime/murder/2026
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
and worldwide:
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's a significant part of the overall decline of violence, because except in world wars, more people die in homicides than in wars. www.amazon.com/Better-Angels-Our-Nature-Violence/dp/01431…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein
@platobooktour
My conversation with physicist Brian Keating went far, though not quite into the impossible.
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Bucket list conversation alert 🚨
Rebecca Goldstein & I discussed:
⇨ why every human being is haunted by the need to matter
⇨ the four types of people and how each one tries to satisfy that longing
⇨ why Ludwig Boltzmann's suicid3 is a thermodynamic story
⇨ how depression maps onto entropy
⇨ whether AI can ever have a mattering instinct, and
⇨ why heroic strivers are the most threatened by artificial intelligence.
youtu.be/6fubsTGbSs8?sub_confirmation=1 -
Steven Pinker reposted
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Happiness Was Never the Point! | Rebecca Goldstein on Mattering - Philosophy Everyday | Podcast on Spotify open.spotify.com/episode/2mfzGk7SkYnhNNVy9GfgH6?nd=1&dlsi…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Institute of Art and Ideas
@IAI_TV
How closely are thought and language connected?
In this debate, Steven Pinker explores the relationship between the two, and demonstrates why they might not be as bindingly connected as we might first assume.
Pinker is a cognitive psychologist, linguist, and bestselling author known for his work on language and human nature, as well as being a Professor of Psychology at Harvard University.
Tap here to watch his full debate with Hilary Lawson and Barbara Tversky. iai.tv/video/lost-in-thoughtThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker reposted
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
Ten reasons why increasing intellectual diversity makes universities better, by Tyler VanderWeele:
@HdxAcademy
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Academic Case for Intellectual Diversity | by my colleague and fellow Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh member Tyler VanderWeele. www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/4/21/vanderweele-harvard-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Brian Keating (@briankeating) and Rebecca Newberger Goldstein (@platobooktour) discuss "The Law of Physics Behind Depression."
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
The thing that suicidally depressed people feel is that they don’t matter; others do, they don’t. Nothing they can do will ever make them matter. It’s a terrible, terrible feeling. And what this means is they cannot abide their own presence.
Brian Keating:
What if there is a law of physics that explains why depression feels the way it does?
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
When I first learned about the second law of thermodynamics, it seemed—I couldn’t quite conceptualize it. We are subject to the second law of thermodynamics, which, you know, has a tragic dimension. In fact, when I was a graduate student, it occurred to me, oh my gosh, biological systems are really just organized to resist the second law of thermodynamics.
In some sense, biology is a response to this supreme law that tells us that, in closed systems, energy never increases; entropy never decreases. Entropy never decreases, and if there’s any way for it to increase, it will. Entropy is the measure of the disorder of a system. The more disorder, the higher the entropy, and the less efficient the work you can get out at the end of the system.
And in fact, Rudolf Clausius, the physicist, said that the universe itself will go to thermal equilibrium—what we call the heat death—and so there will be no more energy to be gotten out of it at the end of the system. Rudolf Clausius, the 19th-century physicist who formulated the concept of entropy, which means literally “transformation from within”—there’s poignancy in that. This transformation from within is going to the end of the system. And he said that the universe itself will go to thermal equilibrium, to what we call the heat death, and so there will be no more energy to be gotten out of it.
Brian Keating:
So let’s start with that story you tell first about Ludwig Boltzmann, who solved one of the great paradoxes of physics, the irreversibility paradox. Talk about that. And then why, in your mind, was he so traumatized, perhaps, or so full of dread of his equation that he took his own life? So talk about that.
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
So there was this great paradox, which is that most—probably most—of the processes that we observe are irreversible. If you film them—and tell me if I’m being too elementary, because I’m going to be very—you know, if you film them, like let’s say I crack open an egg and I stir it up and then I fry it, and somebody filmed this and then reversed the film, anybody who sees the reverse of that film is going to know it was reversed. That cannot happen in nature: that the egg is going to uncook itself, unscramble; the yolk is going to separate from the albumen and jump into the shell and seal up. Impossible, right? So almost everything that we see is irreversible.
Brian Keating:
Yes. I saw that line, Rebecca. It made me think, because you mentioned it in the context of his daughter, Elsa, finding her father’s dead body. And it wasn’t like he showed any sign. I mean, we can’t go into the minds of someone who dies by suicide, right? Yes. But at the same time, you’d think, well, this would be a more common thing.
And so, is depression sort of a—you know, they used to think of miasmas and things in the air, you write about that in the book—is depression, at heart, an entropic collapsing process?
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
I have spoken to a lot of people who suffer from clinical depression. And I want to say, first of all, that the U.S. hotline for suicide prevention is www.samhsa.gov/resource/988/you-matter-psa-video.
The thing that suicidally depressed people feel is that they don’t matter. Others do. They don’t. Nothing they can do will ever make them matter. It’s a terrible, terrible feeling. And what this means is they cannot—they can’t abide their own presence. I really think it shows how strong this mattering instinct is in us. If you can’t somehow appease it, you can’t abide your own presence.
And so, what the people I’ve spoken to—and one is a very, very good philosopher who has suffered from depression—have told me is that, phenomenologically, this is exactly what it feels like. It feels like psychic disintegration.
So, in some sense, yes—happiness is a very ordered state. And I would go even further: everything worth living for is an ordered state. I think knowledge—knowledge, knowledge, knowledge—is better than ignorance. Clarity is better than confusion. Flourishing is better than suffering. Love is better than hatred. Beauty is better than ugliness. These are truisms; these are what we all accept. Look at the thing that’s better: it’s an ordered state. And its negation is a disordered state.
So I think—I would argue—this is a very kind of Spinozist argument, trying to get out of the laws of nature some ethical enlightenment, some ethical guidance, because that’s what we want. We want ethical guidance.
So we know we want to matter. We know we do all sorts of things to matter. Some people do very bad things in order to matter. Some of the people I’ve spoken to… they do. They want power over others. They want dominance. They want to make other people’s lives miserable. These are bad things, right? They cause an increase in entropy.
This is how I judge people now: are you increasing entropy, or are you decreasing it?
-- Full video in link below.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From Brian Keating's YouTube:
"Rebecca Newberger Goldstein is a MacArthur Genius Award recipient, philosopher, novelist, and author of The Mattering Instinct. Her verdict on why human beings are driven to matter — and what threatens that drive — might change how you think about your own life. Check out her recent appearance on Mindscape here.
In this conversation, we discuss why every human being is haunted by the need to matter, the four types of people and how each one tries to satisfy that longing, why Ludwig Boltzmann's tragic death is a thermodynamic story, how depression maps onto entropy, whether AI can ever have a mattering instinct, and why heroic strivers are the most threatened by artificial intelligence. We also get into what Freud got wrong about what women want, the physics of matter versus the philosophy of mattering, and why the second law of thermodynamics may be the most personal law in all of science.
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein is a philosopher, novelist, and MacArthur Genius Award recipient. She is the author of multiple books including Plato at the Googleplex and 36 Arguments for the Existence of God. Her newest book, The Mattering Instinct, is one of Apple's most anticipated books of the year."
www.youtube.com/watch?v=6fubsTGbSs8&t=4s -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Academic Case for Intellectual Diversity | by my colleague and fellow Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh member Tyler VanderWeele. www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/4/21/vanderweele-harvard-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Redditors! I'm doing an AskMeAnything in r/DeepStateCentrism. Tuesday, April 28, 3PM EDT. www.reddit.com/r/DeepStateCentrism/comments/1so6tbf/i_am_…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Our Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard ‘@cafharvard is looking into the kangaroo courts and hanging judges that “investigate” blunt and controversial faculty. www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/4/17/cafh-faculty-investi…
-
Steven Pinker reposted
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Actually this question is for the media, taught to have multiple perspectives on all stories: why when it comes to UFOs, God, and conspiracy theories do most media only interview believers and almost never skeptics? Pandering? Bias? Ignorance?
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Question:
Why is there so much more demand for positive than negative claims? For example:
Believers in UFOs=aliens get far more media coverage than us skeptics.
Believers science proves God get far more coverage than we atheists & agnostics.
Believers in conspiracies...
Why? -
Steven Pinker reposted
Tony Sobrado
@TonySobrado
THE HARD PROBLEM OF CONSCIOUSNESS:
I discuss experience, causal modeling & explanation in cognitive & neuroscience, whether experience can be married with physicalism & whether experience can actually be explained by the scientific method with HARVARD'S STEVEN PINKER - TIME MAGAZINE’S 100 MOST INFLUENTIAL PEOPLE IN THE WORLD TODAY
Steven Pinker: On the Problem of Consciousness www.themontrealreview.com/Articles/Problem_of_consciousne… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Scientists were wrong about lifespan" (they neglected the caprice of infections & accidents, which inflate the size of environmental effect). "Your genes matter way more than we thought." www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2026/04/260411022047.htm
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Sad personal relevance: My identical twin uncles Barry Wiesenfeld (1936-1992) and Mark Wiesenfeld (1936-1995) died prematurely <3 years apart. (Shown here w my mother Roslyn & their parents Carl & Clara)
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The exact pathways are unknowable, combining inherited vulnerabilities with lifestyle choices (diet, exercise) which themselves are partly heritable (because all behavioral traits are).
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Honored to receive an honorary doctorate yesterday from Sofia University in Bulgaria. Here with Vice-Rector Reneta Bozhankova and Prof. Daria Karapetkova.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Though there were 4 wars between Egypt and Israel between 1948 and 1973, for 53 years (including 3 regime changes in Egypt) there have been none. John Mueller: "What needs to happen... is the emergence in Iran of a contemporary Sadat—a leader willing to bury present mindless hostilities for future benefits.... [A new era might also] include seeking to convince increasingly friendless and stateless Palestinians that, after losing miserably in four wars with Israel, it is time for them to try something else." substack.com/home/post/p-192028698
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
There is no autism spectrum, says expert (esteemed cognitive scientist Uta Frith) who pioneered our understanding of the cognitive deficits underlying autism. www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/03/05/no-autism-spectrum-ex…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A common experience: Many brilliant scientists cannot grasp elementary philosophical distinctions. Last night I could not get a colleague to understand the difference between the "hard" (sentience, subjectivity, experience) and "easy" (reportability, information access) senses of "consciousness." Nor the difference between a definition of consciousness and various explanations of consciousness. Hypothesis: scientists tend to equate rigorous thinking with mechanistic explanation, and don't recognize that abstract concepts requires sharp analysis as well.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Important new finding: For decades there's been abundant evidence for the existence, importance, & heritability of "general intelligence" (despite massive denial in journalism, ed schools, and among intellectual-cultural elites). That is: if you're above average in verbal skills, you're likelier to be above average in math, memory, spatial reasoning, & everything else, & genes are a major (though not the only) reason. But are specific cognitive abilities (verbal, math, etc., separate from g) also heritable? Massive new meta-analysis says yes. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289622000708
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Happiness Was Never the Point! | Rebecca Goldstein on Mattering - Philosophy Everyday | Podcast on Spotify open.spotify.com/episode/2mfzGk7SkYnhNNVy9GfgH6?nd=1&dlsi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Coleman Hughes: What Ibram X. Kendi Doesn’t Admit www.thefp.com/p/what-ibram-x-kendi-doesnt-admit?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Spelling matters.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
NIH-funded research at Harvard led to understanding and treatment of migraines — A reminder of why the Trump administration's attempts to cripple Harvard based on hyperbolic accusations of rampant wokeism and antisemitism (real but exaggerated) are damaging to the country. (And contrary to the misunderstanding that the US "supports Harvard," it actually just pays for research with grants that Harvard faculty compete for - not the same thing.) news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2026/04/demystifying-migra…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The fact that the universe doesn’t care about you doesn’t mean that other humans don’t care about you, or that we don’t have to care about other humans. That is, there is a purpose, there is a meaning: that is, to make people as well off as possible, to increase flourishing, to increase knowledge and life and health and freedom and safety. These are really, really meaningful. At least, I think they are. I don’t see anything wrong with them. I don’t think that that should leave you empty. And the fact that we live in a cold universe—that is, the laws of physics, the laws of biology, the behavior of viruses and bacteria and parasites and fungi—they don’t care about you. I’m sorry, they don’t care about you. And the sooner you realize that, the more you’ll be able to attend to the things that really do matter.
@HumanProgress
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Full interview by @HumanProgress: humanprogress.org/meaning-and-morality-in-the-modern-age/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If thought were independent of language, we wouldn’t have any use for language, because the whole point of language is to convey ideas. So it’s not independent, but it’s not the same thing as language. We know it’s not the same thing for many reasons. One of them is: how would children learn language to begin with if they were incapable of thinking until they had language? The way that language acquisition has to work is that children have some understanding of the world, of the objects around them, of the intentions of the people that they interact with, and they map them onto the sequences of sounds and gestures that they perceive.
Also, we know that there are many forms of thought that are not linguistic, such as visual imagery, spatial cognition, and mental maps, all of which are specialties of Professor Tversky, who I’m sure will enlighten us about those. Even when it comes to the content of language, what we take away after the words have faded is the gist of language, not the words themselves. Within a few seconds after I stop speaking, or a few minutes after you’ve read something, you probably could not reproduce a single sentence verbatim, but hopefully you would come away with the content, the meaning, the gist. And one of the most robust findings in our field, cognitive psychology, is that long-term memory for gist is far more robust than memory for text itself.
We know from studies of the brain that there are networks of language in the brain that are not the same as the parts of the brain that light up when people are thinking visually, thinking spatially, or thinking in terms of motion. Again, to go back to one of Professor Tversky’s specializations, we can imagine tying a shoe; we can imagine diving off a board. We have auditory imagery—a song can run through our head—and there are probably other forms of thought that we don’t even have names for. We also know that we sometimes struggle to put our thoughts into words. We write down a sentence, and we realize, no, that’s not what I meant, and rewrite it until the sentence comes out right.
Full @IAI_TV video: iai.tv/video/lost-in-thoughtThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"God bless all of you, all of you on the good Earth." One of my fondest childhood memories: the balletic launch, the moving message to all of humanity, the most beautiful photograph ever taken. www.nytimes.com/card/2026/04/01/science/space/nasa-moon-a…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why is autism more common in males? Interesting finding here (as with other sex differences, men's lack of a redundant X chromosome has a role), but it's a sign of the lack of Darwinian thinking in medicine that a more basic explanation (from the late Robert Trivers) is unmentioned: the greater variance in male reproductive success (some with many offspring, many with none) selects for a developmental program which optimizes at every level for some chance at building the strongest phenotype, at a cost of many defective ones. gsas.harvard.edu/news/why-autism-more-common-males
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My obit of Robert Trivers, who came up with the most important new ideas in evolutionary theory since the modern synthesis (merger of natural selection with Mendelian genetics). quillette.com/2026/03/25/the-many-roots-of-our-suffering-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
And I’m often called an optimist, although I tend to move away from that label because what I see my message is, is not so much we should look on the bright side, but rather just be aware of facts, such as that life expectancy has more than doubled, extreme poverty has been reduced from 90% of humanity to 10% of humanity, and deaths in wars are down. The fact that things have gotten better, though not perfect, does lead to some optimism—namely, if our ancestors did it and it kind of worked, sort of, better than not, then it’s not romantic, it’s not foolish, it’s not utopian to try to make things better still.
(From @singforscience with José González. Link below.) -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why the news makes you think civilization is collapsing (it's not) www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gl-DpvJjNLM
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Like an appreciation of progress, reading and literacy are among the things that are good but cognitively unnatural. That is, they go against our evolved nature. We didn’t evolve with print; it was a recent invention. Reading, for many of us, has become so second nature that we just assume it’s the most natural way of getting information. But what we’ve seen, especially in the last 10 years, when video has become so cheap because of the cloud computing revolution and the broadband revolution, is that a lot of people, unlike us, much prefer to listen and watch than to read. You just see this: when I go to Google and ask a basic question about how to unstick my printer or solve a problem, I get like five videos. And I just want a paragraph that would solve it. I don’t want to see Seth saying, “Hi, welcome to my show. If you like it, subscribe and give it a like.” So just help me solve the problem. But clearly there’s something unusual about me, because people are going for the video. And the massive availability of video—of TikTok, of YouTube—means that people may not be getting the practice or putting in the effort into literacy, which we have reason to believe was one of the drivers of the Flynn effect and of cognitive sophistication in general.
@HumanProgressThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"OK," people say; "You've convinced me that life has become materially better. But haven't we lost meaning and morality in the bargain?" Marian Tupy of @HumanProgress and I take on this question. open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/meaning-a…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Many Roots of Our Suffering: My Reflections on on the louche and obstreperous genius Robert Trivers (1943–2026) quillette.com/2026/03/25/the-many-roots-of-our-suffering-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's not just phonics: Schools have failed to teach reading because they ignore 50+ years of findings in cognitive psychology that reading depends on general knowledge. ED Hirsch has been banging this drum for a long time but Ed Schools shut their ears because the whole idea was unromantic & had a vaguely right-wing aroma. Now he joins with Dan Willingham to make a strong case that kids can't read if they don't have the background knowledge that makes sense of the rarer vocabulary, allusions, and understandings that allow us to read between the lines - which all reading requires. www.educationnext.org/rediscovering-knowledge-as-the-key-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Our greatest wartime leaders thought we should wage war only when it was absolutely necessary, that we should articulate the clear moral and political objectives that we use to guide our strategy and that we should treat the shedding of blood with the seriousness it deserves.
Power does not grow out of the barrel of a gun, cruelty is not the same as strength, and a politics built on such ideas promises ruin, delusion about the limits of our power and a betrayal of the promise of our founding." www.nytimes.com/2026/03/22/opinion/trump-iran-war-memes.h… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Book reviews by philosophers, notoriously, can be scathing, but a sober review of a book on gender identity by the MIT philosopher (and Academic Freedom Council co-founder) Alex Byrne was deemed too dangerous to print. "The philosophy profession has shown itself to be an institution of fragile integrity when put to the test. One can only hope spines will eventually stiffen, and academic law and order is restored." philosophersmag.com/on-being-rejected/
-
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This is another one that I'm kicking myself for not discussing in the book: www.youtube.com/watch?v=rMz7JBRbmNo
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Medical Research Is Hopelessly Caught in Red Tape. Part of the blame goes to "bioethics," which I've long argued is highly unethical. open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/medical-research-is-h…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I agree with this assessment: Trivers explained "the many roots of our suffering" in his analysis of the inherent conflicts of interest in even our most intimate relationships: parent and offspring, sibling and sibling, husband and wife, partner and partner, and the inner and outer domains of the self. All these ideas from a burst of papers (in one case, from a few sentences in a foreword) in the mid-1970s. The implications for the social sciences, and the humanities, are profound.
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
RIP Robert Trivers - the Einstein of evolutionary biology and one the greatest thinkers of our age.
Among other things, Trivers came up with parental investment theory, reciprocal altruism theory, and parent-offspring conflict theory. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Ways in which Large Language Models differ from human inteligence, by @garymarcus and collaborators.
Valerio Capraro
@ValerioCapraro
Here's the longer version of our Nature piece.
Our argument is simple: statistical approximation is not the same thing as intelligence.
Strong benchmark scores often say very little about how LLMs behave under novelty, uncertainty, or shifting goals.
Even more importantly, similar behaviors can arise from fundamentally different processes. In another paper, we identified seven epistemological fault lines between humans and LLMs.
For example, LLMs have no internal representation of what is true. They often generate confident contradictions, especially in longer interactions, because they do not track what is actually true.
Another example. Yes, LLMs have solved some open mathematical problems, but these cases typically involve applying known methods to well-defined problems. LLMs cannot invent anything that is truly new and true at the same time, because they lack the epistemic machinery to determine what is true.
None of this means LLMs are useless. Quite the opposite: they are extraordinarily useful.
But we should be careful about what they are and what they are not.
Producing plausible text is not the same as understanding.
Statistical prediction is not the same as intelligence.
So despite the hype from the usual suspects, AGI has not been achieved.
*
paper in the first reply
Joint with @Walter4C and @GaryMarcus -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Does being smart make you less authoritarian and more socially liberal? James Lee (former student), Emily Willoughby, & colleagues present evidence (including ruling out confounds) which suggests the answer is yes. | Predicting political beliefs with polygenic scores for cognitive performance and educational attainment - PubMed pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39130356/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The World Giving Index tracks prosocial behavior such as helping a stranger, donating money, and volunteering time. In what seems like a world of woe, it's important to realize that these are increasing over time, contrary to most people's impressions. www.cafonline.org/insights/research/world-giving-index
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How European restrictions on free speech can be dangerous: Germany uses anti-Nazi law to investigate a writer with a long history of attacking Nazi ideology because he posted an image comparing Putin to Hitler - an idea very much worth expressing. www.thetimes.com/world/europe/article/germany-anti-nazi-h…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The US is not an ethnostate, and adherents to any religion, or no religion, can be full Americans. "‘E Pluribus Unum’ isn’t a lie. A Tennessee congressman’s anti-Muslim screed is vile. His attack on pluralism itself is worse." by @Jeff_Jacoby www.bostonglobe.com/2026/03/11/opinion/andy-ogles-muslims… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An invaluable collection of essays on current view on viewpoint diversity in academia, journalism, and intellectual life.
Heresy Press
@InfoHeresy
Published today! Get your copy fresh off the press at heresy-press.com/product/viewpoint-diversity-co-edited-by…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Though LLMs often hallucinate blends of plausible snippets, they don't generally don't ratify conspiracy theories, pseudoscience, scurrilous rumors, and other staples of social media, but generally push toward rational and objective conclusions, and even change minds in positive directions. Dan Williams suggests that's because the corporate incentives are different - useful, reality-based intelligence vs virality and engagement - and because their polite sycophancy doesn't turn users off unwelcome truths. |
How AI Will Reshape Public Opinion open.substack.com/pub/conspicuouscognition/p/how-ai-will-… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I gobbled up his latest, Maintenance: Of Everything.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us.
www.amazon.com/Mattering-Instinct-Deepest-Longing-Divides… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Middle East Uncovered, by Ideas Beyond Borders @IdeasB2, is my favorite channel about the region, with expat and on-the-ground analyses and no illusions or ideologies. | Iran After Khamenei: The Struggle for Control Begins ideasbeyondborders.org/iran-after-khamenei-the-struggle-f…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Glad to see Khamenei and Ahmadinejad gone, but odds lean against the establishment of democracy in Iran. My colleague Steven Levitsky, looking at the historical record, concluded, “State failure brings violence and instability; it almost never brings democratization." (Levitsky, S., & Way, L. 2015. The myth of the democratic recession. Journal of Democracy, 26, 45–58.) Let's hope this is an exception.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An unusually deep and sophisticated discussion of consciousness: Dan Williams @danwilliamsphil with Anil Seth and Harry Shevlin on Conspicuous Cognition. open.substack.com/pub/conspicuouscognition/p/ai-sessions-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Can you imagine even the poorest country in the world achieving the prosperity and quality of life of today’s Switzerland—by 2100? ... We ran the numbers, and the answer is yes.
But progress is a choice. Making what is possible probable needs a new narrative. A story in which growth is good, plenty is achievable, and people are inspired to innovate and build. Again and again, optimists have been on the right side of history. We believe they will be once more." www.mckinsey.com/mgi/our-research/a-century-of-plenty -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Craft beer companies are in trouble- I say they’ve focused too narrowly on one category - IPA’s (how many do they think America needs?) - and have neglected lagers and Pilsners (or made them taste like ales). www.thestreet.com/retail/another-beloved-beer-brand-close…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Keep Calm and Adapt: AI will eliminate some jobs, but could create many more. A job is not just a task, but a responsibility, and an opportunity to create new tasks. quillette.com/2026/02/16/keep-calm-and-adapt-ai-matt-shum…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Hard-left activists, particularly militant transgender ideologues and despisers of Israel, are laying waste to liberal organizations: ACLU, American Humanists, Planned Parenthood, Southern Poverty Law Center, Freedom from Religion Foundation, and now PEN America. Jerry Coyne: PEN accepts Palestine as a member and rejects Israel; Jewish chief executive resigns after accusations of being a “Zionist” and not signing on to Israel’s “genocide” – Why Evolution Is True whyevolutionistrue.com/2026/02/19/pen-america-gets-captur…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Can You Really Be ‘Addicted’ to Social Media? Addiction expert Sally Satel @slsatel examines the complexities and suggests that social media overuse is not like heroin addiction after all. www.thefp.com/p/can-you-really-be-addicted-to-social?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I did not have these data (from Claude Fischer via Maria Tcherni-Buzzeo) when I wrote The Better Angels of Our Nature (or the follow-up in Enlightenment Now), but they show that the US enjoyed a sixfold decline in homicide rates over three centuries, parallel to data from European countries in a prior era. From "The 'Great American Crime Decline': Possible Explanations." www.researchgate.net/publication/326020920_The_Great_Amer…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why are so many young people single these days?
Pooja Arora (@LaulPatricia):
So my last question: I wanted to talk about why people are single nowadays. I would have asked about human nature, but that’s for another day. I sent you an article—how do you think common knowledge fits into that area? Why do you think so many youngsters are single?
Me:
Yes, it’s a good question. I’m not sure that common knowledge is an important part of the answer, but some of it is that women no longer depend on the economic contributions of men for their livelihood, as was true, say, in my mother’s era, when women were not professionally trained. To pay the rent, they had to be married. Now, not only are women better educated, but the economy has shifted to favor the kinds of skills that women, as opposed to men, have. And just as women have been rising, men have been sinking because of the decline in blue-collar work.
There have also been cultural trends that favor women’s temperaments. Men have been distracted by internet gaming, gambling, and pornography and are less desirable as marriage partners. Women with more economic power are more likely to raise their standards for what they want in a man. In my parents’ generation, it was not uncommon for a woman to marry a man with much less education and, sometimes, less intelligence. This was not unusual among my parents’ friends. The men often had a high school degree and then went immediately into a small business—sometimes a family business, sometimes one he started himself. The criterion was: does he make a living? No one cared about education.
That has changed, with the result that there are fewer men who satisfy the criteria women now have. This was mentioned in the article you shared with me. Also, with more sexual freedom, people don’t have to get married simply to have sex, which was again true in my parents’ generation. There’s a process that has been in place since the baby boomers and has accelerated among millennials and Generation Z.
For other reasons, I think a generation of men may also be incapable of socially skilled interaction, partly because they’ve grown up with screens instead of face-to-face contact. There is some fear that a sexual encounter could result in an accusation of rape or sexual harassment. There is so much pornography that, for an increasing number of men, it serves as an outlet for what in the past would have required actual human contact.
There are many factors. The article from The Economist lists them, I think, quite skillfully. It’s not clear how to reverse the trend. Increasing the economic prospects of men and creating an educational system that is less feminized and more encouraging of male achievement might help. Another could be changing norms—and here common knowledge comes in. Among women, is it a sign of low status to be with a man who has less education than you? Men, from time immemorial, have been happy to marry women with less education than themselves. Women don't. That immediately reduces the marriage pool. Maybe that’s a norm that could change. Go back to the norm in my parents’ generation?
Pooja Arora:
No, let’s not do that.
Me:
Okay, let's not do that.
Pooja Arora:
We’re happy to marry men who are not as educated as us. It’s fine. They just have to be nice and kind at this point in time.
Me:
Well, yes—exactly. Nice and kind.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
“The sacred rights of mankind,” wrote Alexander Hamilton, “are not to be rummaged for, among old parchments, or musty records. They are written, as with a sun beam, in the whole volume of human nature..." Why those of us who are committed to liberal values must unite and defend them. American Liberalism and Illiberalism, by Matt Johnson @mattjj89 quillette.com/2026/02/09/american-liberalism-and-illibera…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The autism epidemic is a myth: The increase is only in expansive overdiagnosis of kids "on the spectrum," e.g. "Would rather be alone than with others,” “Has difficulty making friends,” and “Is regarded by other children as odd or weird.” Severe cases (no language, socially unresponsive, etc.) have decreased. By my former grad student @AdamOmaryPhD www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/02/10/autism-spectru…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Our Longing to Matter Drives and Divides Us | Amanpour and Company youtu.be/LTkNwAFtb9w via @YouTube
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
For more on mattering, Rebecca Newberger Goldstein's new book is on Audible:
The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us
www.amazon.com/Mattering-Instinct-Deepest-Longing-Divides… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In my 23 years at Harvard I've had to increase the proportion of A & A- grades from 25% to 65% of my large intro class (still tougher than the average Harvard class) so as not to drive away students. Finally, "Harvard Proposes Capping A’s to Curb Grade Inflation." The key: recognize that it's a collective action problem (every professor has an incentive to inflate even while recognizing that it's bad when everyone does it). Voluntary guidelines, the previous suggestion, are thus useless; only a collegewide policy can work. www.nytimes.com/2026/02/06/us/harvard-grade-inflation.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When leaders violate norms without consequence, shared “common knowledge” fractures. Media silos and social segregation also deepen polarization by erasing a common civic reality.
Full video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=mTQsOBLEIV8This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A massive positive development that virtually no one has commented on (except The Progress Network's Emma Varvaloucas): Covid's Quiet Retreat open.substack.com/pub/theprogressnetwork/p/covids-quiet-r…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How well off are American workers? Dollars are misleading because they buy different amounts of goods & services at different times. A new set of measures here: American Abundance Index - @HumanProgress humanprogress.org/american-abundance-index-dashboard/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The world is more equal than you think. www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2026/02/03/the-world-is-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Legacy of Daniel Kahneman: : A Personal View | An evaluation of Kahneman's contributions (and personal style) by his fiercest academic critic, Gerd Gigerenzer. ejpe.org/journal/article/view/1075
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I have made this argument for decades; glad to see it featured so prominently.
William Costello
@CostelloWilliam
In our new American Psychologist paper, we debunk the decades old zombie idea that evolutionary psychology is unfalsifiable.
🧵 -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A Spiral of Silence: Maarten Boudry @mboudry documents how disagreement with the reckless accusation of "genocide" in Gaza is enforced in academia (particularly in Europe) by outright intimidation, leading to dissenters being silenced, reinforcing the illusion of consensus (a common dynamic in intellectual repression). open.substack.com/pub/maartenboudry/p/a-spiral-of-silence
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Democrats have accomplished something that would seem to be impossible: They have made their own party seem like the crazier of the two. NYT's Tom Edsall analyzes (with quotes from many moderates, including me). www.nytimes.com/2026/01/27/opinion/democrats-trump-midter…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Robert Tracinski, a thoughtful Republican-turned-Democrat, is running for Congress in Virginia: "The one issue I think is most important right now—reining in unlimited presidential power and restoring the checks and balances of the American system—is the issue where I am way far out beyond any of the other candidates." Tracinski For Congress | Robert Tracinski | Substack tracinskiforcongress.substack.com
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I spoke with @LaulPatricia about Marxism:
One is: What’s remarkable is that Marxism has been tried. Now, of course, defenders of Marxism say it hasn’t really been tried anywhere, but certainly the people who implemented it claimed they were implementing Marxism.
And this is a massive experiment—a global experiment—with a very clear outcome. Namely, the Soviet Union was a disaster. The imposition of communism on Eastern Europe was a disaster. The imposition of communism in Venezuela was a disaster. The imposition of communism in Maoist China was a disaster. Disaster in terms of both poverty and oppression and genocide and stupid wars. So the world has told us what happens under communism, and it’s a sign of how out of touch intellectuals can be that there are still people who defend it despite the entire world giving a very clear-cut answer.
One more is: would you rather live in North Korea or South Korea? Would you rather live in the old East Germany or West Germany? We have an experimental group and a matched control group in terms of culture, language, and geography, and the answer is crystal clear. So this is a sign of, I think, the pathology of intellectual life—that Marxism can persist.
The other is, you did call attention to one of the appeals of Marxism, though, and more generally of heavy, strong influence of government guided by intellectuals, which is that there are certain kinds of reforms that you can state as principles. You can articulate them verbally as propositions—like equality, human rights, democracy—but there’s other kinds of progress that take place in massive distributed networks of millions of people, none of whom implements some policy. But collectively, there is an order, an organization that’s beneficial.
So that can happen organically through, for example, the development of a language. No one designed the English language. It’s just hundreds of millions of English speakers. They coin new words. They forget old words. They try to make themselves clear. And we get the English language and the other 5,000 languages spoken on earth.
Likewise, a market economy is something where knowledge is distributed. You don’t have a central planner deciding how many shoes of size 8 will be needed in a particular city, but rather information is conveyed by prices, which are adjusted according to supply and demand. And you’ve got a distributed network of exchange of information that can result in an emergent benefit.
Now, intellectuals tend to hate that. They like rules of language—of correct grammar. They like top-down economic planning. They like cultural change that satisfies particular ideals described by intellectuals. And so rival sources of organization, like commerce, like culture—traditional culture—tend to be downplayed by intellectuals.
And this can be magnified by the fact that many dictatorships give a privileged role to intellectuals, which may be why, over the course of the 20th century, and probably continuing to the present, there has not been a dictator that has not had fans among intellectuals—including the mullahs and ayatollahs of Iran, but also the communist dictators: Mao and Castro, even Stalin in his day. And every other dictator has had, actually, often fawning praise from Western intellectuals.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An MIT student, Sidhu Pachipala, notes that protests, a favorite pastime of students, are often ineffective or counterproductive. (He could have added that they are not necessarily on the right side of history: Students protested for Hitler & book-burnings in the 30s, for segregation in the 50s, and for Khomeini in 1979. The 60s protests against Vietnam were mixed with support for communism, Maoism, anarchism, and Ho Chi Minh. Even their role in ending the Vietnam war is questionable – the backlash elected Nixon in 1968 and 1972). www.bostonglobe.com/2026/01/22/opinion/protest-political-… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
David Eagleman (@davideagleman) interviews Rebecca Newberger Goldstein about her new book: The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein:
We talk about what matters, and we talk about who matters. And I think its core meaning, deep down, is to be deserving of attention.
David Eagleman:
And you argue that this longing to matter is the crux of human motivation. What makes you feel that this longing to matter is more important than the pursuit of pleasure, or truth, or survival?
Goldstein:
Yeah, I mean, many of us pursue our mattering by hedonistic pursuit of pleasure, of truth, of knowledge, of beauty, of creativity, of power, of fame. But beneath all of these things is this more basic motivation: to prove that we are deserving of all of the attention that we have to give ourselves in order to live a coherently human life. It’s even more powerful than the longing to live, to survive. People will sacrifice their lives if they think that that’s what’s required in order to realize their mattering instinct—or in the very tragic cases where they think they can’t, which is clinically known as depression.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us
www.amazon.com/Mattering-Instinct-Deepest-Longing-Divides… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Sergey Brin was on an NSF Graduate Fellowship. Larry Page was a PhD student on the grant. Google—now worth $2 trillion—exists because American taxpayers funded "the Stanford Integrated Digital Library Project.""
Adam Butler
@GestaltU
Fun fact: The 1998 paper that introduced Google and PageRank to the world ends with this acknowledgment:
"Supported by the National Science Foundation under Cooperative Agreement IRI-9411306. Funding also provided by DARPA and NASA."
Sergey Brin was on an NSF Graduate Fellowship. Larry Page was a PhD student on the grant.
Google—now worth $2 trillion—exists because American taxpayers funded "the Stanford Integrated Digital Library Project."
Not a startup garage myth. A government grant.
Every time someone says public research funding "picks winners and losers" or "crowds out private innovation," remember: the most dominant technology company of the 21st century was incubated entirely with public money, inside a public university, by researchers on federal fellowships and grants.
The private sector didn't see it coming. VCs passed. The government funded it anyway—not because it would become Google, but because fundamental research into information retrieval seemed worth understanding.
That's the point. You can't predict which grants will change the world. You fund the science and let researchers explore.
The internet (DARPA). GPS (DoD). Touchscreens (CIA/NSF). mRNA vaccines (NIH). Google (NSF/DARPA/NASA).
Public investment in basic research isn't wasteful spending. It's the seed corn of the entire modern economy. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I don't think it's that difficult to outline a positive vision for higher education, something that neither legacy universities nor UATX have been able to do. Here's my own attempt (from my New Republic essay "The Trouble with Harvard newrepublic.com/article/119321/harvard-ivy-league-should-…):
"It seems to me that educated people should know something about the 13-billion-year prehistory of our species and the basic laws governing the physical and living world, including our bodies and brains. They should grasp the timeline of human history from the dawn of agriculture to the present. They should be exposed to the diversity of human cultures, and the major systems of belief and value with which they have made sense of their lives. They should know about the formative events in human history, including the blunders we can hope not to repeat. They should understand the principles behind democratic governance and the rule of law. They should know how to appreciate works of fiction and art as sources of aesthetic pleasure and as impetuses to reflect on the human condition.
On top of this knowledge, a liberal education should make certain habits of rationality second nature. Educated people should be able to express complex ideas in clear writing and speech. They should appreciate that objective knowledge is a precious commodity, and know how to distinguish vetted fact from superstition, rumor, and unexamined conventional wisdom. They should know how to reason logically and statistically, avoiding the fallacies and biases to which the untutored human mind is vulnerable. They should think causally rather than magically, and know what it takes to distinguish causation from correlation and coincidence. They should be acutely aware of human fallibility, most notably their own, and appreciate that people who disagree with them are not stupid or evil. Accordingly, they should appreciate the value of trying to change minds by persuasion rather than intimidation or demagoguery." -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I resigned from the board of advisors of the University of Austin (UATX, not to be confused w U T Austin) within weeks of their inaugural announcement, because they "had no coherent vision of what higher education in the 21st century ought to be. Instead, they created UnWoke U led by a Faculty of the Canceled." Also: science was an afterthought. And they were so knee-jerk anti-woke that they were unprepared for the genuine issues that led to woke overreach, like sexual harassment. Four years later, my worst fears came true. Expose in Politico: They Wanted a University Without Cancel Culture. Then Dissenters Were Ousted. www.politico.com/news/magazine/2026/01/16/civil-war-unive… via @politico
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
None of us is infallible; none of us is omniscient. The only way, as a species, we’ve been able to make progress—we’ve been able to discover how the world works, what works in creating a functioning and fair society—is that people try out ideas; other people point out what’s wrong with them; we keep the ideas that seem to be working; we try not to repeat our mistakes; and we blunder our way toward knowledge and progress. If you disable that cycle by punishing people for the content of their speech, then you’re guaranteed to be in error, because the people doing the punishing—the people doing the censoring—are themselves not infallible.
@NZFreeSpeech
--Full interview: www.hootsuite.com/error/lost-owly
--Tickets to "An Evening with Steven Pinker" in Auckland, Monday, February 02, 2026 at 7PM: www.ticketmaster.co.nz/event/2400635CC1573F86 -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Iran’s Berlin Wall Moment and the Dangerous Silence About the Day After open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/irans-berlin-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Philosopher and author Rebecca Newberger Goldstein discusses her new book, The Mattering Instinct, which argues that our lives are a quest to validate our inherent self-centeredness. Tracing this essential longing from physics and biology through to ethics and politics, she explains to EconTalk's Russ Roberts why material success alone can never satisfy our deep-seated need to matter. She describes the four ways people seek significance--through transcendence, social connection, excellence, or competition--and explains how the unmet need to matter is at the heart of some of the biggest problems afflicting modern societies: loneliness, extremism, and polarization. The Mattering Instinct (with Rebecca Newberger Goldstein) www.econtalk.org/the-mattering-instinct-with-rebecca-newb…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Censorship of teaching in Texas universities (including Plato!) is worse than anything from the woke left. Hooray for @TheFIREorg the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression for challenging these blatantly unconstitutional assaults on academic freedom.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Golden rice is a no-brainer: a publicly funded, non-proprietary genetically modified crop that combats vitamin A deficiency, a major cause of childhood blindness and mortality - yet it's opposed by many Western environmental groups and NGOs. 24 years ago, in The Blank Slate, I decried this primitive essentialist and tribal thinking. I'm sad to learn that this mindless opposition persists today. www.goldenrice.org
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Venezuela, Common Sense, and the Donroe Doctrine, by my colleague Danielle Allen open.substack.com/pub/therenovator/p/venezuela-and-common…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"A New Understanding of Human Beings’ Most Basic Desire....A vision that is both intellectually resonant and humane, reminding us that the struggle to justify our existence is the very thing that makes our existence matter." First review, in @TheAtlantic, of Rebecca Newberger Goldstein's The Mattering Instinct. www.theatlantic.com/books/2026/01/the-mattering-instinct-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
There's a myth that international laws & norms must be useless because there's no international Leviathan, & thuggish countries flout them (so why shouldn't we?). Responses: 1. People flout laws against murder, assault, & rape, too; that doesn't prove the laws are useless. The relevant question is how much worse life would be without the laws. 2. Most of our social behavior is in practice regulated by norms, not laws: nudity, lewdness, belching & farting, racist & misogynistic jokes, basic table manners, queuing,... either there is no law, or it's unenforceable. The norms are enforced by ostracism, gossip, shows of contempt. 3. Nations depend on each other (trade, terrorism, piracy, pandemics, borders, extradition, ...) so sanctions and exclusion are not toothless. 4. War is in fact NOT the "realist," pragmatic, unromantic alternative, but often leads to catastrophic failures: US in Vietnam, US in Afghanistan, USSR in Afghanistan, Iraq in Kuwait.. www.nytimes.com/2026/01/06/opinion/peace-conflict-war.htm…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Excellent essay by Peggy Sastre on Napoleon Chagnon's persecution by his anthropological colleagues for his empirical approach & politically incorrect findings about the Yanomamo. (I knew him well from 2 sabbaticals at UCSB, & Sarah Blaffer Hrdy's characterization is right on.) quillette.com/2025/12/28/among-savage-tribes-napoleon-cha…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Like many nonprofits, some of the major human rights organizations (Amnesty, Human Rights Watch) have been taken over by left-wing activists and lost sight of their missions | How Doctors Without Borders Became a Political Actor in Gaza quillette.com/2025/12/29/how-doctors-without-borders-beca…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
1,084 Reasons the World Isn’t Falling Apart - Human Progress. Yes, you read that right: more than a thousand. humanprogress.org/doomslayer-1084-reasons-the-world-isnt-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How to Criticize with Kindness: Philosopher Daniel Dennett on the Four Steps to Arguing Intelligently – The Marginalian www.themarginalian.org/2014/03/28/daniel-dennett-rapoport…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Speaking of data graphics: W. E. B. Du Bois was, among other things, a creative and stylish practitioner of this medium. Here's a fascinating cache of his Hand-Drawn Infographics of African-American Life (1900) — The Public Domain Review publicdomainreview.org/collection/w-e-b-du-bois-hand-draw…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
We are primates, with a third of our brain dedicated to vision. Graphics are the most effective way to communicate quantitative, spatial, and causal information, but they are as hard to master as clear and stylish prose. Here's an excellent guide to data visualization by Saloni Dattani @salonium open.substack.com/pub/salonium/p/salonis-guide-to-data-vi…
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One of the biggest chasms between the Two Cultures of the humanities & sciences is the former's disdain for anything but text. For decades I've seen humanities scholars aim to bridge the gap by inviting a scientist to speak but not thinking to arrange for a projector. When my first popular book, The Language Instinct, went out to reviewers, my editor thought the diagrams (syntactic trees, brains, language families) were ornamental and left them out of the proofs, rendering the discussions incomprehensible, and was genuinely surprised when I hit the ceiling. And when I was invited to edit Best Science and Nature Writing one year, the editor simply omitted all the diagrams from the essays I chose, saying that was the policy of the series, not realizing there might be a difference between, say Best Poetry or Short Stories and Best Science Writing.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
We Live Like Royalty and Don’t Know It.
("The electric grid, the public-water supply, the food-distribution network, and the public-health system took the collective labor of thousands of people over many decades. They are the cathedrals of our secular era. They are high among the great accomplishments of our civilization. But they don’t inspire bestselling novels or blockbuster films. No poets celebrate the sewage treatment plants that prevent them from dying of dysentery." www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/we-live-like-royalty-… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Deep, interesting analysis of the qualitative differences between natural and (one kind of) artificial intelligence (LLMs), despite the remarkable abilities of the latter.
Valerio Capraro
@ValerioCapraro
Major preprint just out!
We compare how humans and LLMs form judgments across seven epistemological stages.
We highlight seven fault lines, points at which humans and LLMs fundamentally diverge:
The Grounding fault: Humans anchor judgment in perceptual, embodied, and social experience, whereas LLMs begin from text alone, reconstructing meaning indirectly from symbols.
The Parsing fault: Humans parse situations through integrated perceptual and conceptual processes; LLMs perform mechanical tokenization that yields a structurally convenient but semantically thin representation.
The Experience fault: Humans rely on episodic memory, intuitive physics and psychology, and learned concepts; LLMs rely solely on statistical associations encoded in embeddings.
The Motivation fault: Human judgment is guided by emotions, goals, values, and evolutionarily shaped motivations; LLMs have no intrinsic preferences, aims, or affective significance.
The Causality fault: Humans reason using causal models, counterfactuals, and principled evaluation; LLMs integrate textual context without constructing causal explanations, depending instead on surface correlations.
The Metacognitive fault: Humans monitor uncertainty, detect errors, and can suspend judgment; LLMs lack metacognition and must always produce an output, making hallucinations structurally unavoidable.
The Value fault: Human judgments reflect identity, morality, and real-world stakes; LLM "judgments" are probabilistic next-token predictions without intrinsic valuation or accountability.
Despite these fault lines, humans systematically over-believe LLM outputs, because fluent and confident language produce a credibility bias.
We argue that this creates a structural condition, Epistemia:
linguistic plausibility substitutes for epistemic evaluation, producing the feeling of knowing without actually knowing.
To address Epistemia, we propose three complementary strategies: epistemic evaluation, epistemic governance, and epistemic literacy.
Full paper in the first reply.
Joint with @Walter4C & @matjazperc -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"The ease with which the world has slipped back into superstition shows how badly we need the crusading spirit of 18th-century Enlightenment thinkers... There is no reason why a charismatic and appealingly abrasive successor shouldn’t pick up the cause. Usefully, the more we slip away from reason, the more miraculous and urgent the Enlightenment again seems. Écrasez l’infame — crush the loathsome thing — was Voltaire’s war cry as he went to battle against the bigotry of his age. In our own unenlightened time, we need to rediscover this spirit."
www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/in-age-of-dem… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Atul Gawande's ideas have saved tens of thousands of lives. Here he speaks about the worst thing that Trump has done. “The current estimate is about 600,000 lives lost so far” as a result of cuts to USAID, Gawande said. Also very, very bad:" Gawande returned to Harvard just as the federal government began imposing deep cuts to research funding, hindering efforts by Ariadne Labs to make surgery safer and improve primary care around the world." news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2025/11/in-the-grip-of-hor…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Walter Isaacson discusses his book with the greatest title ever written about ‘The Greatest Sentence Ever Written.' I agree with his judgment: my eyes well up every time I read the sentence (particularly in context, where it appears as a climax after a moderate preamble. The following clause isn't bad either). news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2025/11/our-self-evident-t…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Americans have more gratitude, confidence, agency and resilience than they get credit for." American Optimism Proves Its Resilience by Clay Routledge www.wsj.com/opinion/american-optimism-proves-its-resilien… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Mosul restored, new MS therapy, ozone hole shrinking, child mortality still declining, new antibiotics, fewer girls aborted, renewable energy exceeds coal, deforestation in decline, fridgeless vaccines, and more: 52 good news stories from 2025.
www.thetimes.com/uk/environment/article/52-good-news-stor… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I spoke with HxA (@HdxAcademy) President John Tomasi for @HAFFS_Harvard on academic freedom, lack of knowledge about it, and graduate students:
“They are the major point of contact that many of our undergraduates have. They see their graduate student teaching fellows more than they see a lot of professors, unfortunately. And it’s the graduate students, countrywide, who’ve been, I think, responsible—or just clueless—about issues of academic freedom: things like suppressing certain opinions or penalizing the student papers; dismissing sections so that students can attend protests; allowing students to refuse to cooperate with Israeli students on joint projects; things where my sense is that it just never even occurred to them that this could be an issue, that graduate education is anything other than pushing their own political agendas. Bringing graduate students into the discussions on academic freedom is a longer-term project that we’re going to try to advance.” -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The man who mistook his imagination for the truth. Maria Konnikova @mkonnikova is a warm and generous writer, but here she is (justifiably) scathing about Oliver Sacks's decades of lies about his patients, which damaged treatment and understanding in service of his own narcissistic self-therapy. open.substack.com/pub/mariakonnikova/p/the-man-who-mistoo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Commentary on Harvard's decision to extend the presidency of Alan Garber, by my Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh colleague Jeff Flier @jflier | Alan Garber Has Met the Moment | Opinion | The Harvard Crimson www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/12/18/flier-harvard-garbe…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Intellectual diversity is good, but "epistemic virtue" -- intellectual humility, active open-mindedness, love of knowledge, courage, generosity, firmness -- is more fundamental, argues Sally Satel @slsatel (convincingly). www.chronicle.com/article/are-bad-researchers-bad-people
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Escalating Price of Ignoring Extremism | Excellent post by Iram Ramzan in Middle East Uncovered, a publication of insider reports from the Middle East by Ideas Beyond Borders @IdeasB2 open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/the-escalatin…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Pub date in 1 month; preorder now | The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us by Rebecca Goldstein. www.amazon.com/Mattering-Instinct-Deepest-Longing-Divides…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Arab Initiative Racing Against a Global Surge in Antisemitism | The Bayt al-Hikma 2.0 ("House of Wisdom) project translates books & Wikipedia articles on antisemitism, the Holocaust, & Enlightenment ideals into Arabic, Persian, Dari, Kurdish, & Pashto, providing historical information that is otherwise scarce or nonexistent. A project by an organization I support, Ideas Beyond Borders @IdeasB2 @faisalalmutar open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/the-arab-init…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Bombshell: Oliver Sacks (a humane man & a fine essayist) made up many of the details in his famous case studies, deluding neuroscientists, psychologists, & general readers for decades. The man who mistook his wife for a hat? The autistic twins who generated multi-digit prime numbers? The institutionalized, paralyzed man who tapped out allusions to Rilke? Made up to embellish the stories. Probably also: the aphasic patients who detected lies better than neurologically intact people, including Ronald Reagan's insincerity. www.newyorker.com/magazine/2025/12/15/oliver-sacks-put-hi…
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The many articles by Malcolm Gladwell (like Sacks, a fine essayist) which mixed good reporting with dubious statistical reasoning and misleading claims (e.g., that only practice, not talent, is necessary for achievement, or that IQ above 120 doesn't matter)
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Kudos to Rachel Aviv (and to the New Yorker, for publishing it), though they never acknowledge their own role in disseminating these tall tales, designed to sow doubt on hard-headed rationality and empiricism.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Public Hangings and the Politics of Virtue | Beautiful, brilliant, eloquent, tough-minded essay by Claire Lehmann on why public cruelty and lawless killing are neither effective nor manly. The celebration of gratuitous viciousness by the new MAGA right is sickening (and makes me glad I quickly bailed from UATX). Bravo, @clairlemon quillette.com/2025/12/09/public-execution-and-masculine-v…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A libertarian critique of the new right (including the canard that life was better in the 70s: I was there, and it sucked.) | The New Right Manufactures Misery open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/the-new-r…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"I was a red state governor. What I saw at Harvard surprised me." | Eric Holcomb refutes Harvard Derangement Syndrome on the right: "Friends warned me that a den of woke lions would maul me or try to turn me into one of them. Neither happened. I suffered no grievous insults, surrendered none of my conservative principles and witnessed no disruptive behavior on a quiet campus." www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/12/08/harvard-eric-h…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A new study on "Where Discovery Happens" found that with basic research in the life sciences, Harvard contributes more than Canada & France combined. Boston, Cambridge, & Newton are just behind all of China—and well ahead of every other country in the world. Most of this is from federal funding, which is not, contrary to popular misunderstanding, "taxpayer support of Harvard" -- it's a fee for service, namely discoveries in the life sciences. (Thanks to my colleague Jason Furman for this summary.) www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w33996/w33996.pdf
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Liberal democracy is the best form of governance human beings have ever created. It gives individuals dignity and freedom to pursue their lives as they see fit. It empowers diversity, openness, and discovery. It encourages invention, trade, and prosperity. It is the essential foundation of science and intellectual inquiry. It has enabled human flourishing to an extent far beyond the wildest dreams of most people who ever lived.
It is a creed worth celebrating. It is a creed worth fighting for.
But there is no celebrating or fighting without passion."
Inspiring & important essay: The Stories We're Not Telling, by @dgardner open.substack.com/pub/dgardner/p/the-stories-were-not-tel… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Nineteen Eighty-Four and Twenty Twenty-Five: A condensed version of my Orwell lecture from last night, just published in The Times.
www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/1984-revisite… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Wonderful time giving The Orwell Lecture last night, where I met George Orwell's son! Told me he was a dedicated father despite desperately working to finish 1984 while mortally ill with tuberculosis. Steven Pinker | The Orwell Foundation www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/news-event…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Me:
I try to look at data and trends rather than headlines, because headlines can give you a misleading picture of the state of the world. Something goes wrong every day — that’s guaranteed — and if you just look at something goes wrong and say, oh, things are getting worse, you might be forgetting all the things that went wrong in the past.
Andrew Marr:
And what we call the news is a long litany of all the things that are getting worse or going wrong.
Me:
Well, yes, it’s much easier for something bad to happen suddenly than for something good to happen. Good things either creep up on you a few percentage points a year, and sometimes can compound.
So the fact that, for example, extreme poverty in the world has been declining and a billion people have escaped extreme poverty over the last 30 years — but not on Thursday — so it was never an event from the news. One of the biggest events in human history is something that most people have never even heard of.
@AndrewMarr9 @LBC -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I'll be giving talks on common knowledge in Australia and New Zealand in February 2026.
Tickets : au.thinkable.events
"I begin the book with the story of The Emperor’s New Clothes because it’s the quintessential illustration of common knowledge. When the boy said the Emperor was naked, he wasn’t telling anyone anything they didn’t already know. They could see the Emperor was naked, but he changed the state of their knowledge nonetheless because, by blurting it out within earshot of everyone, now everyone knew that everyone else knew that everyone else knew that everyone else knew that the Emperor was naked. So it shows, first of all, that even though the concept of common knowledge, as I defined it, seems impossible—your head starts to spin after, you know, one or two “I know that she knows,” let alone an infinite number.
But what the story shows is that a conspicuous, public, self-evident event—something that you see while you see everyone else seeing it, or you hear when you know everyone else can hear it—can give you common knowledge at a stroke. And the other moral is that it changed the relationship of the people to the Emperor, from obsequious deference to ridicule and scorn. And a major theme of the book is that common knowledge, even though it sounds like this abstruse, recondite academic concept, actually figures into everyday life, figures into our money, and figures into our politics, because it enables coordination and it changes social relationships."
@thinkableevents
--
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .:
Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life
www.simonandschuster.com/books/When-Everyone-Knows-That-E… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"There’s a public health imperative to quickly expand the adoption of autonomous vehicles. More than 39,000 Americans died in motor vehicle crashes last year, more than homicide, plane crashes and natural disasters combined." Not surprisingly to a psychologist, properly instrumented self-driving cars have a fraction of the accident rate. www.nytimes.com/2025/12/02/opinion/self-driving-cars.html…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This Thursday, I'll be giving the Orwell Lecture in London.
The Orwell Prize
@TheOrwellPrize
Next Thursday, @sapinker delivers this year’s Orwell Lecture, "Nineteen Eighty-Four and Twenty Twenty-Five" at @southbankcentre, London.
Still a few tickets left - grab yours here: www.southbankcentre.co.uk/whats-on/the-orwell-lecture-202…
The Orwell Prize
@TheOrwellPrize
Join us for the 2025 Orwell Lecture with @sapinker!
🗓️ 4 Dec 7.30pm
📍 @southbankcentre
In “Nineteen Eighty-Four and Twenty Twenty-Five”, Pinker will use 1984 as a lens to look through time, asking: how do Orwell's predictions hold up today?
🎟️ ---> www.southbankcentre.co.uk/whats-on/the-orwell-lecture-202… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Pinker and Tupy vs. Kingsnorth: do we need a god in these troubled times? – Why Evolution Is True whyevolutionistrue.com/2025/11/25/pinker-and-tupy-vs-king…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I have nothing to say about pickup lines, but I know a thing or two about grammar, and here's what I wrote about can vs. may in The Sense of Style.... www.nytimes.com/2025/11/20/style/bill-ackman-dating-advic…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Bill Gates Releases Recommended Reading List For Winter 2025 www.forbes.com/sites/maryroeloffs/2025/11/25/heres-what-b…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Astonishingly, factions of the US right have become nostalgic for medieval theocracy. @Marian_L_Tupy and I show why this is ignorant. Reason and well-being, not souls and scripture, are the basis for meaning, morality, and a decent life. www.thefp.com/p/the-golden-age-of-humanity-were-living?r=…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Medieval Christendom: Are they freaking serious? @Marian_L_Tupy and I dismantle the astonishingly ignorant nostalgia for theocracy and monarchy among the NeoReactionaries, theoconservatives, Christian Nationalists, National Conservatives, and other factions of the MAGA brain trust. www.thefp.com/p/the-golden-age-of-humanity-were-living?r=…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The decline of violence continues: Newly released data from the World Bank shows that the global homicide rate has fallen by around a quarter in this century. (Thanks to Fix the News for the item & graph.) data.worldbank.org/indicator/VC.IHR.PSRC.P5?end=2023&star…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Androgen Warp: Are many our our political, economic, and international pathologies caused by leaders jacking themselves with testosterone & other steroids? open.substack.com/pub/factsandreason/p/the-androgen-warp?…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Carole Hooven @hoovlet, author of T: The Story of Testosterone, the Hormone that Dominates and Divides Us, literally wrote the book on the underlying biology, and plans to comment. www.amazon.com/Story-Testosterone-Hormone-Dominates-Divid…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Coleman Hughes interviews Carole Hooven, my biologist colleague who was Exhibit A for Harvard's academic freedom problem (and a major reason we started the Council on Academic Freedom @cafh 2 1/2 years ago): Her life at Harvard was made untenable after saying there were two sexes. youtu.be/GbmsPY8NEEo via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From my appearance on 60 Minutes:
Me:
Research works. If you want to freeze society where it is, then cripple the research enterprise.
Bill Whitaker of 60 Minutes:
Is that whole idea being lost in the harsh rhetoric by the administration?
Me:
The attack on universities is a tragic blunder. For all the foibles of universities, and there are many, and I pointed them out, universities' research makes life better, massively so. Why would you want to cripple it? It's something that the United States does really, really well. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Informative and fair obit of James Watson in NYT by Cornelia Dean. I met Watson thru our mutual friend Nancy Hopkins, & he and I worked together advising Paul Allen on what became the Allen Institute of Brain Science. He was brilliant & entertaining but bumptious & reckless, and I knew he was a time bomb. www.nytimes.com/2025/11/07/science/james-watson-dead.html…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Should Everyone Be Religious? Phil Zuckerman, in conversation between Ross Douthat, eloquently explains why we shouldn't. youtu.be/qhEHHmejCas via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Hypocrisy Trap: How Changing What We Criticize Can Improve Our Lives - by behavioral economist Michael Hallsworth. Overlaps with my analysis of "rational hypocrisy" in When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows... Hypocrisy can maintain the common-knowledge understanding that is the basis of social relationships like friendship, romance, and deference while permitting transactions that contradict it. www.amazon.com/Hypocrisy-Trap-Changing-Criticize-Improve-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A lot of our indirect speech isn’t about passing the salt. It’s about, like, you know, sexual come-ons: “Do you want to, you know, come up for Netflix and chill?” Or veiled threats, like, “Nice store you got there. It would be a real shame if something happened to it.” Or veiled bribes, like, “Gee, officers, is there some way we can settle the ticket here without, you know, doing all that paperwork?”
Clip on indirect speech and common knowledge, the topic of my new book, from an interview with Robert Contofalsky (@CR_Scholar) of R-Academy.
--
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .:
Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life: www.simonandschuster.com/books/When-Everyone-Knows-That-E… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The most violent stage of life is toddlerhood (a finding by the Canadian psychologist Richard Tremblay I cited in The Blank Slate and The Better Angels of Our Nature).
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
12 Things Everyone Should Know About Violence: What the science really says about aggression, crime, and human nature
1. The most violent group of people in the world is... toddlers.
[Link below.] -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
After a 2-day conference at Stanford's Hoover Institution honoring my friend, the economist Thomas Sowell, I was fortunate to have lunch with Tom, going strong at 95! 🧵 www.hoover.org/events/sowell-legacy-ideas-impact-and-inte…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Tom was described at the conference as an "Enlightenment philosophe," and indeed he has ranged over an astonishing range of topics in intellectual history, political theory, economics, even my field, developmental psycholinguistics. I consider him one of the greatest intellectual influences I've personally known, together with Noam Chomsky, George Miller, John Tooby & Leda Cosmides, Jerry Fodor, Thomas Schelling, Judith Rich Harris, Donald Symons, John Mueller, & Rebecca Goldstein.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A few of Tom's brilliant books, all highly recommended. A Conflict of Visions (which I wrote about in The Blank Slate, & spoke about at the conference): how right-wing and left-wing political ideologies are grounded in different conceptions of human nature, the Tragic Vision & the Utopian Vision. www.amazon.com/Conflict-Visions-Ideological-Political-Str…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Knowledge and Decisions. Why markets outperform communism & other intrusive top-down economic planning: Decisions are made by those with the most knowledge, namely millions of producers & consumers with local information conveyed by prices. www.amazon.com/Knowledge-and-Decisions-audiobook/dp/B009Q…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Is Anti-Semitism Generic?" Jew-hatred as a side effect of primitive economic illiteracy: If you think that wealth = stuff, then only farmers & craftsmen generate it, so retail & finance is parasitism or theft. Not only Jews, but other "middlemen minorities" (Armenians in Ottomon Empire, Indians in Africa, Chinese in SE Asia) are economically successful, culturally cohesive, & reviled by majorities. www.hoover.org/research/anti-semitism-generic
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Vision of the Anointed: A steel-man articulation of intellectual conservatism & its criticism of elite leftism. www.amazon.com/Vision-Anointed-Self-Congratulation-Social…
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Quest for Cosmic Justice. We must distinguish "cosmic justice," the unfairness of life, from "human justice," the outcomes of social norms & rules, and not try to apply the latter to deal with the former. www.amazon.com/Quest-Cosmic-Justice-Thomas-Sowell/dp/0684…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Intellectuals and Society. The sad story of how so many public intellectuals have defended tyranny & shallow political fads. Complements books by Benda, Posner, Hollander, Lilla, Johnson. www.amazon.com/Intellectuals-Society-Thomas-Sowell/dp/046…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Black Rednecks and White Liberals. Maladaptive African American cultural traits are not legacies of slavery but imports from white Southern culture, including a "culture of honor" - the real "acting white." Also contains "Are Jews Generic?" www.amazon.com/Black-Rednecks-Liberals-Thomas-Sowell/dp/1…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Social Justice Fallacies. Groupwide average differences are the rule, not the exception, in human history, and they are largely generated by historical, geographical, demographic, & cultural inheritances, not racism or anti-ethnic prejudice from the majority. www.amazon.com/Social-Justice-Fallacies-Thomas-Sowell/dp/…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Einstein Syndrome: Bright Children Who Talk Late, and Late-Talking Children. Starting with his own son, Sowell identified a syndrome which my people (developmental psycholinguists) had not systematically studied. Our friend Stephen Camarata jumped on this.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Tom, Stephen Camarata, and I also bonded as photo buddies, & have gone on photo excursions together (including 1 from a helicopter Tom rented).
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
And with Carole @hoovlet
Carole Hooven
@hoovlet
This @Nature editorial lacks diversity! At least, if it's written by the three young, white, female editors at Nature Reviews Psychology. Do better.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I think the philosopher Dan Williams has it right: Social media are not destroying democracy, but reinforcing its worst feature. Elite gatekeeping, an accident of expensive media channels, bundled access with at least minimal standards of truth-seeking. Open them up, and you get epistemic chaos. "Most voters are shockingly ignorant and misinformed, with many approaching politics more in the manner of sports hooligans and religious fanatics than the rational deliberators of liberal fantasies." www.conspicuouscognition.com/p/is-social-media-destroying…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Starlink vs. the Islamic Republic open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/starlink-vs-t…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Professors Need to Diversify What They Teach: A quantitative survey of college syllabi show that they are massively tilted toward a few tendentious left-wing sources, especially on race & crime and on Israel-Palestine. open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/we-analyzed-universit…
-
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Sir Simon Baron-Cohen, one of the world's experts, made this point 16 years ago. www.nytimes.com/2009/11/10/opinion/10baron-cohen.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On Trump flouting norms and why this is a negative development:
"[One of the] remarkable things about Donald Trump—and uniquely among American politicians—is that he has violated norms that have been in place, such as: you don’t boast, you don’t blatantly lie. I mean, all politicians lie because all human beings lie. But they lied under the cover of claiming to be honest.
With Trump, it’s patent that he just doesn’t care about factual accuracy. He’ll say things that are in his interest and that demonize his opponents, with little regard for factual accuracy. Insulting a woman’s appearance, insulting war heroes, insulting patriots, insulting his predecessor in office, flattering enemy leaders, insulting allies—all of these things—there’s never been a law against them, but they just seemed to be things that a decent leader would not do.
By doing them and not suffering consequences, the danger is that he is actually destroying norms that were a pretty good idea. For example, whether he was trolling or semi-serious about, say, annexing Greenland—let alone Canada, my own country—there has been a norm since World War II that nation-states are immortal, borders are grandfathered in, aggressive conquest is taboo. Now, of course, like any norm, it can be floated. Russia is obviously floating it now. But even to talk about floating it, even casually as Trump is doing, I think is a negative development."
Clip from an interview with @unherd.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"The problems of the 21st century are overwhelmingly the problems of success. We struggle with the chaotic superabundance of information; our ancestors were haunted by ignorance. We have to cope with the tragic consequences of humanity’s too-efficient exploitation of the planet’s resources. The notion of an obesity “epidemic” would have been laughable amid the diseases that stalked pre-modernity. Most of our ancestors were oppressed by a crushingly hierarchical and conformist social system, not by the infinity of individual freedom reckoned to be the fount of today’s 'meaning crisis'." www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/beware-novel-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I explain why the accusation that Israel is committing "genocide" is blood libel.
Me:
The application of the word genocide to refer to tens of thousands of war deaths is, I mean, I think it is a kind of blood libel. It's trying to import the moral opprobrium that we associate with genocide to a designated enemy, in this case, Israel. I think because I alluded to my side bias, the sides in this case being the sides that a lot of hard left critical theory has defined, namely white oppressors against everyone else's victims.
Moynihan:
It's pretty strong to say this is like a blood libel.
Me:
Well, it is a blood libel in the sense that it is an accusation of deliberate murder, ill-founded in that the, and one could disagree with Israel's campaign against Gaza, one could say that this is not justifiable, it's not a just war. It's still different from deliberately murdering as many people as possible, as in, and we know there have been genocides. I think it really is a terrible blood libel, and it's a sign of how people's moralizing in the service of demonizing and dichotomizing, dividing the world into good and evil can just flatten their ability to analyze and to think clearly. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows..., I explain the famous theorem (50 years old next year) by Israeli mathematician and Nobel laureate Robert Aumann that rational people with the same background understanding of the world (they have the same priors) who share their assessments of a hypothesis (their posteriors are common knowledge) cannot agree to disagree (those posteriors must be the same). Still going strong, Aumann discusses the theorem in this interview. youtu.be/EriI3JkadRg via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
There isn't some mysterious force that's just guaranteed to make things better and better. That's not the way the universe works. In fact, quite the contrary, the universe kind of tries to grind us down. And if we've made progress, it's because of human efforts.
(From the @HopeExistential podcast. Full episode: youtube.com/watch?v=QTBzuKholjo) -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The real, sinister reason academics keep cancelling each other - (as explained in When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows…) www.standard.co.uk/comment/toby-young-free-speech-academi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If scientists wants science to be taken seriously, they've got to stop doing stupid stuff like publishing the zillionth study claiming that groupwise disparities are proof of bigotry, and then firing scientists who point out the obvious flaw in that reasoning.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Two Years After October 7th, Grief Unites Palestinians and Israelis open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/two-years-aft…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Coleman and I discuss what changed at that disastrous debate with Biden.
@Coldxman @ConvoswColemanThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Charisma and Catastrophe of Hasan Nasrallah, by @faisalalmutar of @IdeasB2. Their Middle East Uncovered series of essays is a superb source of commentary, contributed by their unique network of correspondents, and providing insights and info one doesn't see anywhere else.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
You're welcome, Canada! | Canadians should thank Steven Pinker for criticizing Science DEI for Science Grants in Parliament | National Post nationalpost.com/opinion/canadians-should-thank-steven-pi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Dear Harvardians — Please Save the Em Dash. | Opinion (by my student Theo Tobel) | The Harvard Crimson www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/9/26/tobel-harvard-em-das…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My new NYT op-ed: The Right’s Post-Kirk Crackdown Has a Familiar Mob Logic www.nytimes.com/2025/09/28/opinion/charlie-kirk-republica…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Right Needs to Conserve Free Speech: @tunkuv interviews FIRE Co-Founder, civil liberties lion, and good friend Harvey Silverglate @HASilverglate www.wsj.com/opinion/the-right-needs-to-conserve-free-spee… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Have you ever heard of a cell that's halfway between an egg and a sperm? Carole Hooven @hoovlet explains why there are only two biological sexes. (This scientific banality, perversely denied by some gender activists, has nothing to do with trans rights or women's rights, since those are moral and political issues, not a scientific ones.) www.tabletmag.com/sections/arts-letters/articles/there-ar…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Tomorrow! With @AnnieDuke in Philly.
Register: libwww.freelibrary.org/calendar/event/154638
When:
Thursday, September 25, 2025 7:00 P.M.
Where:
Parkway Central Library
1901 Vine Street (between 19th and 20th Streets on the Parkway)
Philadelphia, PA 19103 -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
And now for something completely different: @michaelshermer is the Un-Mayim: editor of The Skeptic, author of Why People Believe Weird Things, and curator of The Encyclopedia of Pseudoscience. We had a great conversation on The Michael Shermer Show - Apple Podcasts
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Last week, I testified to the Science and Research Committee, House of Commons, Parliament of Canada. Here @Tony_Baldinelli asks me about DEI.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If you enjoyed the "Battle of the Wits" scene in The Princess Bride, you'll enjoy my new book When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows..., because it's about the mental process of getting into someone's head while they are trying to get into your head (and the myriad financial, political, and everyday phenomena it drives, from bank runs and revolutions to blushing and weasel words). youtu.be/rMz7JBRbmNo via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Russ Roberts, host of @EconTalker, and I discuss aspects of college life: snitching, microaggressions, and claims of loneliness. Full episode out soon.
Clip via @Econlib -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Left Pole: that mythical spot from which all directions are right-wing.
Clip from @TheAtlasSociety. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A conversation on language from many years ago between me and @NewThinkAllowed.
There’s no exact English equivalent for the Yiddish word nachas, but every English speaker knows the feeling: the swelling pride and joy a parent feels at a child’s success. The word may be missing in English, but the experience is not. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
RFK Jr. Must Go. An assessment of this dangerous quack by my colleague Jeff Flier @jflier, former Dean of Harvard Medical School and current Co-President of the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard. @cafharvard) quillette.com/2025/09/17/rfk-jr-must-go-hhs-health-vaccines/
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Two quotes from @jflier:
1. "RFK Jr. has carried out a series of actions that reflect his ignorance and flawed judgment. These will only make the country sicker, while further diminishing confidence in science, medicine, and public health."
2. "There are very real problems facing health and biomedical research in America. To successfully address these using the best talent and strategies at our disposal, RFK Jr. must be replaced as Secretary of HHS, and the sooner the better."
quillette.com/2025/09/17/rfk-jr-must-go-hhs-health-vaccines/ -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Cancel culture, typically associated with the left, is exploding on the right. I have a chapter called "The Canceling Instinct" in my new book When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows.... which tries to explain this human impulse, not restricted to any political faction. | Let’s be clear about what happened to Jimmy Kimmel www.yahoo.com/news/articles/let-clear-happened-jimmy-kimm… via @@YahooNews
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Indecent Proposal came out, a cartoon showed a couple leaving the theater, and the husband asked his wife, "Would you sleep with Robert Redford for a million dollars?" She replies, "Yes, but I'd need some time to come up with the money." www.bbc.com/news/live/c07p8yle7pet
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Understatement: Modern Freedom Beats Feudal Serfdom (a sign of the times that this needs to be pointed out, & Marian Tupy does it masterfully). open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/modern-fr…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Join me and my colleague Danielle Allen (@dsallentess) in Cambridge soon! We will discuss common knowledge, the topic of my new book.
Preorder:
When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . . : Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life: www.simonandschuster.com/books/When-Everyone-Knows-That-E…
Date: Friday, September 26, 2025 - 7:00pm
(Doors at 6:15)
Location: First Parish Church
Address: 1446 Massachusetts Ave., Cambridge, MA 02138
Tickets: www.harvard.com/event/steven-pinker-fpc -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Speech is not violence. Violence is not speech.
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
We must repudiate the idea that "speech can be violence" once and for all. @glukianoff and I wrote about the dangers of promoting this idea on college campuses back in 2017, in @TheAtlantic:
www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/07/why-its-a-b… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Ep. #705: Steven Pinker, Kaitlan Collins, Stephen Moore - Real Time with Bill Maher - Apple Podcasts podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ep-705-steven-pinker-kaitla…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In this exchange with Maher, I explain how Trump created a new norm—making truth optional.
Maher:
Don't you think it has something to do also with the confidence with which you back up your bullshit? I mean, we're going to talk about the economy on the panel. I think he has for the economy. I don't see good things on the horizon. Steve [Stephen Moore] will just obviously argue with me about that. But Trump has what I call contagious confidence. He is so bullish and so confident. Well, he must know what he's doing, you know. And at some point, I think it falls away. But with the dogs and the cats thing, I think people, when we first heard it, were like, come on, man. They're eating the dogs? We know they're not eating the dogs. And yet he said it with such confidence that you can get by.
Me:
Yes, about that, even for people who knew that this was nonsense, in the past it was, if you blatantly lie, you've killed your credibility forever. You've at least got to pretend that you yourself think that you're telling the truth. It's not clear that he actually believed it. But just by making the truth whatever he says, and removing statements from the realm of things that you can fact check, you can verify, just if the charismatic leader says it, that's good enough. That is a new norm that he established by getting away with what no previous politician, including conservative politicians, would dare.
Maher:
All right, well, we'll follow up on that right now. Great to see you, Professor. It's a fascinating book. Congratulations on it. And let's meet our panel. Thank you very much.
@billmaher @realtimers @StephenMoore @kaitlancollins
The conversation was about my new book: When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life.
Available here: stevenpinker.com/publications/when-everyone-knows-everyon…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"The recent defunding of USAID could lead to more than 14 million deaths, mostly in low- and middle-income countries, including 4.5 million child deaths — according to a study combining retrospective and forecasting analyses." www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(2…
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Regarding Elon Musk's immense wealth...
Maher:
Where do you stand on this? Where is Harvard on this one?
Me:
Charity? Which charity? I haven't seen him distribute anti-HIV drugs, malaria drugs, education for girls. I mean, Bill Gates has given away a lot of money. He's saved probably 100 million lives. Elon Musk will probably cost 20 million lives from the cuts that he's made on USAID when he was head of DOGE.
Stephen Moore:
Do you mean USAID? That's the most corrupt foreign agency ever. Show me anywhere where USAID has had a positive effect on international aid. It just doesn't. It's just corrupt foreign leaders.
Me:
I mean, there's corruption. [But] they've saved tens of millions of lives.
Full episode of last night's Overtime with Bill Maher: www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhQE7sCg64k
@realtimers @billmaher @kaitlancollins @StephenMoore -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
With Biden’s debate stumble, we all saw the emperor’s new clothes vanish in real time. But when Trump followed up weeks later babbling about people eating dogs and cats, many just shrugged. In this exchange with Bill Maher, I explain why.
Maher:
I agree, that happened. We all saw that debate and everybody changed their mind. Why didn't it happen when Trump debated a few weeks later and was ranting about "they're eating the dogs" and "they're eating the cats?" Because I thought that was the moment when everyone was going to go, oh wow, this guy really is awful. But nothing.
Me:
Trump has rewritten a lot of the rules.
Maher:
Yes, literally.
Me:
Yeah, and figuratively. Because there are a lot of norms on just what politicians can do, can say. They're not enforced by law. There's no law that says you can't insult the physical appearance of your rival or of a woman. You can't blatantly lie. They're propped up by the knowledge that you just don't do that. Why don't you do it? Well, everyone knows you don't do that. What he discovered was if you flout that in public and you live another day, then the norm is gone. Because the norm depended on everyone knowing that it was a norm. Then when he exploded it, it was gone.
@billmaher @RealTimersThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Almost sold out: Steven Pinker LIVE with Coleman Hughes - Comedy Cellar, New York, 1 week from today www.comedycellar.com/reservations-newyork/?showid=1757880000
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On Friday, Bill Maher asked me if what happened with Biden at the disastrous debate with Trump was the same story as the Emperor's New Clothes.
Me:
The story of the Emperor's New Clothes is a story about common knowledge, because when the kid blurted it out, he actually wasn't telling anyone anything they didn't already know. They could see the Emperor was naked. But he still changed their knowledge, because by blurting it out with an earshot of the others, now everyone knew that everyone else knew that everyone else knew that everyone else knew. And what that allowed them to do is change their relationship with the Emperor, from obsequious deference to ridicule and scorn. And the thing about common knowledge in the social realm is that it's what props up our social relationships. And so when something is blurted out, then it can change everything. It changes the nature of your relationship with someone.
Maher:
And we do have sort of a modern version of the Emperor parable, which is Joe Biden. I mean, he was the Emperor who everyone wouldn't say had lost his marbles. I mean, is that not really the same story?
Me:
It is the same story, because opinion polls showed that after that disastrous debate with Trump, the number of people who thought that he was cognitively impaired didn't go up by that much. It went up by a few percentage points. But before, a majority of people thought that he was cognitively impaired. The difference is, when it's on TV, where you're watching it, you know that the rest of the country is watching it, you know the rest of the country knows the rest of the country, it's no longer private. It's common. And that's when he was challenged. That was the end.
@billmaher @RealTimersThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Discussing common knowledge with Bill Maher.
Common knowledge is the topic of my new book: When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows...: Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life.
stevenpinker.com/publications/when-everyone-knows-everyon…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Discussing progress with Bill Maher on Real Time last night. @billmaher @RealTimers
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The four us last night on Real Time with Bill Maher.
@StephenMoore @kaitlancollins @billmaher
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Regarding Elon Musk's immense wealth...
Maher:
Where do you stand on this? Where is Harvard on this one?
Me:
Charity? Which charity? I haven't seen him distribute anti-HIV drugs, malaria drugs, education for girls. I mean, Bill Gates has given away a lot of money. He's saved probably 100 million lives. Elon Musk will probably cost 20 million lives from the cuts that he's made on USAID when he was head of DOGE.
Stephen Moore:
Do you mean USAID? That's the most corrupt foreign agency ever. Show me anywhere where USAID has had a positive effect on international aid. It just doesn't. It's just corrupt foreign leaders.
Me:
I mean, there's corruption. [But] they've saved tens of millions of lives.
Full episode of last night's Overtime with Bill Maher: www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhQE7sCg64k
@realtimers @billmaher @kaitlancollins @StephenMoore -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On Liberalism, by my colleague Cass Sunstein - an insightful and timely defense. mitpress.mit.edu/9780262049771/on-liberalism/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Regarding Elon Musk's immense wealth...
Maher:
Where do you stand on this? Where is Harvard on this one?
Me:
Charity? Which charity? I haven't seen him distribute anti-HIV drugs, malaria drugs, education for girls. I mean, Bill Gates has given away a lot of money. He's saved probably 100 million lives. Elon Musk will probably cost 20 million lives from the cuts that he's made on USAID when he was head of DOGE.
Stephen Moore:
Do you mean USAID? That's the most corrupt foreign agency ever. Show me anywhere where USAID has had a positive effect on international aid. It just doesn't. It's just corrupt foreign leaders.
Me:
I mean, there's corruption. [But] they've saved tens of millions of lives.
Full episode of last night's Overtime with Bill Maher: www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhQE7sCg64k
@realtimers @billmaher @kaitlancollins @StephenMoore -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Maher:
Have college students changed in recent years? Do they have trouble keeping up with the amount of reading that used to be required?
Me:
The answer is yes, they have declined. I can see it in my own class, which I've taught for 22 years. So we had a meeting with the dean at Harvard because grades keep getting higher. 80% of students get an A. The average GPA is 3.8 out of 4.
Maher:
Grade inflation, they call it.
Me:
No, they don't. The dean said, we prefer to call it "grade compression."
Maher:
Oh (with a hand clap, head roll back, and sigh).
Me:
Maybe our students are just getting better and better. So I knew this was malarkey, so I actually had the data, because I've been giving kind of the same exam for 22 years, and it's multiple choice, so it's subjective. So there's a constant benchmark, and performance has been going down, at least in my class. 10 percentage points from 2004 to now. So the standards have been going down. Students do read less. I think they spend more time on extracurriculars than on classwork, and I just know that...
Maher:
Scrolling, scrolling.
Me:
That's when they're in the room, yes.
Maher:
I have to tell you, they're not going to read your book, not because it's not great. It is. It's a book. They won't read this. I read a letter that a student wrote to the Crimson, saying you can get out of this university without having fully read a whole book.
Me:
That might be true. Now I've got to say, there are a lot of really brilliant, really studious Harvard students, like intimidatingly smart. But there's also a lot for whom it's kind of a luxury cruise, and academics is just one of the activities. So our dean, to be fair, our dean has noticed, and she has changed the guidelines going forward. She's actually told students--you wouldn't think this would be a shock--academics is your first priority. Now the fact that she had to say that, this is a kind of a radical new policy. She said that it's okay for professors to take attendance in lectures, which I'm going to start doing. That it's okay to ban electronic devices, which I might start doing. Because we actually know that taking notes leads to better memory than using a screen. Just a principle of cognitive psychology, when you have to think hard about something, when you've got to process its meaning, when it's not just a bunch of words, then you actually remember better. Just the process of writing puts it in your brain. But a lot of them have screens. There are electronic note-taking devices, but they're not as fluid and easy as the old-fashioned pen and paper. So my teaching assistants are going to hate this, because we're going to have to schlep handouts to class every time.
Full Overtime episode: www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhQE7sCg64k
@RealTimers @billmaher -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Tonight!
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I'm on Real Time with Bill Maher tomorrow! @billmaher @RealTimers
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The problem with Rufoism -- empowering Trump to inflict a "ladder of pain" (Rufo's words) on universities until they bend to his will -- is that it's dictatorial, oblivious to the principle that we have a government of laws and not men.
It's based on the fallacy that "if an entity accepts public money, it has to obey the whims of the President or his minions." Donald Trump is not empowered by the constitution to dock my social security, or withhold police protection, or my right to use the interstate highways, to punish me for writing an article or joining a club or wearing a button. The principle, “You accept government money, you do what the government says” opens the door to totalitarianism, given how enmeshed the citizens of every modern democracy is with the government.
This is why laws governing government funding, such as the Administrative Procedure Act of 1946 and the Civil Rights Act, were explicitly drafted to prevent such abuse from happening. The executive may not add capricious or self-serving strings to congressionally authorized funding. Rather, any such threats have to be justified for some rationale and are subject to due process -- which is why a federal judge smacked down the Trump administration yesterday.
In the case of Title VI violations, the government has to stipulate the infractions, make its case to a judge or other neutral party, allow the defendant to respond and rectify the violation, restrict the punishment to the offending unit, and so on. The administration has done none of these things – it couldn’t even get its story straight on whether it was punishing Harvard for antisemitism or a lack of viewpoint diversity.
Nor may the government infringe on constitutional rights, such as the First Amendment's protection of free speech, as a condition for receiving government contracts. The Trumpers tried to do exactly that: force Harvard to hire and admit people on the basis of the content of their beliefs. That's a no-go in the USA.
One more reminder: The US government does not "fund Harvard" or other private universities, earning its gratitude or obedience. It contracts with them on a fee-for-service basis: the US wants basic research to be done, can't do it all itself, and pays Harvard to do some. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I'm on Real Time with Bill Maher tomorrow! @billmaher @RealTimers
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Evidence that woke isn't dead, peer review is problematic, and science needs to address deep problems in its culture: A grad student at Harvard conducted the first systematic, data-based study to document & explain the rise in gender dysphoria. His paper was rejected from a leading journal because, among other things, "Throughout the manuscript, the authors use language that is considered prejudicial and outdated (e.g., "natal sex" as opposed to "sex assigned at birth"). It is critical to follow best practice and guidelines surrounding gender inclusive language, particularly for research specifically on the topic of gender incongruence, expression, and identity."
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why do we enjoy rhyme, pattern, repetition, symmetry, cycles? Linguist, poet, editor, musician, & former MIT associate provost Jay Keyser explains: The Pleasure of Patterns in Art thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/why-repetition-in-art-pleases-… #aesthetics #art #cognitivescience via @mitpress
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Nostalgic for the 90s? Violent crime was far higher. Republicans shut down the government. The Rodney King riots killed 63 people. Genocides in Bosnia and Rwanda. The end of the Cold war decimated many industries. But @mattyglesias points out the most positive feature: the liberal vision of optimism about enlightenment and progress, well worth reviving. open.substack.com/pub/matthewyglesias/p/what-makes-sense-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"One of the reasons that religious extremism appeals to people is that they feel that the world has become more decadent, is in a state of decline. I show in Enlightenment Now that that's a false picture of history, that there were crises in the past, there was war, there were invasions, there was suffering, and that, in fact, the world has been improving. Far from being decadent or in decline, more people live in peace today, more people live in prosperity, people live longer, they're getting a greater education. The idea of decline and decadence is the opposite to the truth. I like to think that this message is vital to people in the Middle East. I'm tremendously excited by Ideas Beyond Borders (ideasbeyondborders.org; @IdeasB2), and I hope you'll support it as well, too."
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Often university administrations indulge students who think that it's a legitimate form of expression to occupy buildings and eject deans from their offices, to obstruct passageways, to invade classrooms chanting slogans over bullhorns. Even if you are a First Amendment advocate, there are legitimate restrictions on time, place, and manner of expression of speech. I'm fully in favor of public expression of opinions, but that doesn't mean that I want someone invading my bedroom chanting, you know, build the wall at 3 a.m. There are legitimate grounds for preserving private spaces, and universities ought to have a consistent policy of not allowing students to shut down the university, invade classrooms, take over libraries, and so on."
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
“I have nothing against diversity, equity, and inclusion. But as Voltaire said about the Holy Roman Empire: it was neither holy, nor Roman, nor an empire.”
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What kind of regime is Trump trying to implement? Not Fascism, exactly, since it's not guided by an ideology. I agree with @FukuyamaFrancis and @jon_rauch that we're seeing a backsliding from a rational-legal mode of political organization, where rights & responsibilities are stipulated by a social contract, to a patrimonial state, governed by the three basic human relational models: kinship, dominance, and reciprocity. (This trichotomy comes from the anthropologist Alan Fiske, a big influence on my work.) www.persuasion.community/p/making-the-world-safe-for-crim…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Analysis of US college syllabi by the Open Syllabus project shows that bell hooks is assigned more than Aristotle, Judith Butler more than Plato, Edward Said more than than Kant, and Foucault more than everybody. (Thanks to Jon Shields for these comparisons.)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My 2025 TED talk: The hidden logic of human harmony (Steven Pinker | TED2025) go.ted.com/gxxUz via @TEDTalks
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One reason, I suspect, that younger people are cynical about democracy and open to "socialism" is that they did not grow up with the USSR, Mao, & Pol Pot & don't learn about them in school. "Totalitarian Studies are Sorely Needed" open.substack.com/pub/michaelwade800695/p/totalitarian-st…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
27 Notes on Growing Old(er) open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/27-notes-on-growing-o…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Excellent analysis by Jonathan Rauch @jon_rauch on premodernism, modernism, and postmodernism, and what the "woke right" has in common with the woke left. open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/the-woke-right-stands…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The humanities should be harder, by @mattyglesias. Not just humanities. Even at Harvard I feel pressure from Intro Psych students to lower standards: I've had to inflate my grade distribution to prevent enrollment from tanking, and see more complaints in student evaluations that the course has too much reading or the exam questions force them to think too much. open.substack.com/pub/matthewyglesias/p/the-humanities-sh…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
22 years ago, when people feared that parents would soon be implanting a gene for athletics or musical talent into their embryos, I wrote a debunking op-ed in the Globe: Heritable traits come from thousands of genes with tiny effects, many with mixes of good, bad, and unknown effects. Also, you can't get there from here: experiments would be unethical. I remain skeptical of editing genomes of embryos for positive traits, but today we have a weaker version: selection among IVF embryos on polygenic scores. Scott Alexander @slatestarcodex ably discusses the state of the art. www.astralcodexten.com/p/suddenly-trait-based-embryo-sele…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Another tribute to the brilliant Tom Lehrer, who died yesterday at 97. | The Singer Who Skewered America open.substack.com/pub/yaschamounk/p/the-singer-who-skewer…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Opinion | Should universities negotiate with Trump? by my colleague & fellow Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh Co-President Jeff Flier @jflier www.bostonglobe.com/2025/07/26/opinion/trump-harvard-colu… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Another amazing finding from the lab of my colleague David Reich: Ancient DNA solves mystery of Hungarian, Finnish language origins — Harvard Gazette news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2025/07/ancient-dna-solves…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If scientists, academics, public health officials, and other experts want to gain the public's trust, they should stop co-mingling their expertise with their left-wing values (or else open their professions to qualified people with different political orientations). The crisis of expertise is about values, by @mattyglesias open.substack.com/pub/matthewyglesias/p/the-crisis-of-exp…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From @AnnieDuke on my forthcoming book.
Out in September: www.simonandschuster.com/books/When-Everyone-Knows-That-E… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Inspiring words from Ann Druyan about love, mortality, and cosmic gratitude.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
From the Massachusetts Constitution (written by John Adams): "Wisdom, and knowledge, as well as virtue, diffused generally among the body of the people, being necessary for the preservation of their rights and liberties; and as these depend on spreading the opportunities and advantages of education in the various parts of the country, and among the different orders of the people, it shall be the duty of legislatures and magistrates, in all future periods of this commonwealth, to cherish the interests of literature and the sciences, and all seminaries of them; especially the university at Cambridge, public schools and grammar schools in the towns; to encourage private societies and public institutions, rewards and immunities, for the promotion of agriculture, arts, sciences, commerce, trades, manufactures, and a natural history of the country; to countenance and inculcate the principles of humanity and general benevolence, public and private charity, industry and frugality, honesty and punctuality in their dealings; sincerity, good humor, and all social affections, and generous sentiments among the people."
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Photography by Christopher Michel and quote graphics created (with Python) by a colleague of mine.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Opinion by @carinemhajjar | Let Harvard negotiate with Trump www.bostonglobe.com/2025/07/11/opinion/harvard-trump-nego… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
John McWhorter @johnhmcwhorter says It’s Time to Let Go of ‘African American.’ (I remember when AA replaced "black," and earlier, when "black" replaced "negro," commonly used by my teachers. The idea was that "black" was symmetrical with "white." If we do keep "African American," let's follow the convention suggested by my colleague Orlando Patterson and start using "European American" for so-called white people. What's the deal with "Caucasian" anyway? www.nytimes.com/2025/07/10/opinion/african-american-langu…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Alex Byrne’s “colleagues” dogpile him for co-writing a critique of American pediatric gender medicine – Jerry Coyne presents a full accounting of this latest episode in cancel culture. whyevolutionistrue.com/2025/07/07/alex-byrnes-colleagues-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A Shabbat in Bahrain. Yes, you read that right. From the invaluable Middle East Uncovered @M_E_uncovered , a feature of Ideas Beyond Borders @IdeasB2 open.substack.com/pub/middleeastuncovered/p/a-shabbat-in-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Beyond The Evolution vs Learning Fallacy. I've long argued that this false dichotomy gets in the way of understanding language, cognition, and human nature. In a new article in American Psychologist, @LaithAlShawaf carefully examines & refutes the fallacy, with examples. www.laithalshawaf.com/uploads/1/3/5/8/135897893/beyond_th…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My former student and pro poker whiz @mkonnikova on When Everyone Knows That Everyone Knows . . .
Common Knowledge and the Mysteries of Money, Power, and Everyday Life -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Enlightenment’s Gravediggers: When Westerners, knowing they have Western freedoms, hate the West. Another brilliant essay by Maarten Boudry @mboudry quillette.com/2025/06/19/the-enlightenments-gravediggers-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Who Are the Snowflakes Now? quillette.com/2025/06/06/who-are-the-snowflakes-now-trump…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Woke Failed. (The movement was based on flawed understandings of human nature, argues @michaelshermer) open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/why-woke-failed?r=17uk7
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The stupidity of indiscriminately canceling grants to punish an entire university for a shifting mixture of grievances, mostly fictitious or distorted.
Joseph Allen
@j_g_allen
Harvard researcher Dr Sarah Fortune was only two years away from creating a vaccine that could have saved the 1.25 million people killed each year by tuberculosis. But last month, she received a letter telling her that the $60 million grant funding her research was being halted by President Trump.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Great crowd and great fun earlier this evening when Richard Dawkins interviewed me on stage at the Royal Institution - video to be posted soon. thepanpsycast.com/reserve-books/between-god-and-atheism-l…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Are we close to "Artificial General Intelligence" (whatever that means)? @garymarcus explains why we are not.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Babies don’t need Mozart recordings to be smart, but a new study shows that a parent who sings regularly can make a big difference for their mood. by Susan Pinker www.wsj.com/science/babies-dont-need-mozart-recordings-ju… via @WSJ
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My conversation on academic freedom with the brave & eloquent @Alicedreger on @HdxAcademy
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
💡 How does @sapinker suggest academia handle its echo chamber problem?
HxA's @AliceDreger spoke to Pinker in a recent webinar on promoting viewpoint diversity, the Trump admin's targeting of Harvard, and more:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Idiocy: Trump Has Cut Science Funding to Its Lowest Level in Decades - The New York Times www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/05/22/upshot/nsf-grants-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Trump's assault on foreign students at Harvard is truly depraved. It harms thousands of the smartest people in the country for no reason, & it's based on the error of thinking they're behind campus "riots" (a cable news host said this to me last night). In fact disruptive protests are led by American students, and my foreign students are among the most dedicated to studies & research, and, incidentally, the least woke.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard Derangement Syndrome | My new essay in the New York Times www.nytimes.com/2025/05/23/opinion/harvard-university-tru…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Federal grants to Harvard are not support of the university -- they pay for specific research projects that benefit the country. Just one example: We know exercise is good for you. Why? He‘s working on it. — news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2025/05/we-know-exercise-i…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Yes, Harvard Deserves Due Process open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/yes-harvard-deserves-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Blogger Who Hates America: "Curtis Yarvin [aka Mencius Moldbug] won’t destroy American democracy. But his continued intellectual ascent is a reminder that the republic is going through a dark moment." Another razor-sharp analysis by @CathyYoung63 www.persuasion.community/p/the-blogger-who-hates-america?…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How golden ages are created, and how they end. www.warpnews.org/premium-content/johan-norberg-how-golden…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An idea whose time has come: Yale faculty call for admin hiring freeze, independent audit amid concerns over bureaucratic expansion - Yale Daily News yaledailynews.com/blog/2025/04/24/yale-faculty-call-for-a…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Detaining Öztürk over an op-ed is unlawful and un-American | The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression www.thefire.org/news/detaining-ozturk-over-op-ed-unlawful…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Beautiful commentary by Harvard Hillel's Executive Director, Rabbi Jason Rubenstein, on Science and Jewish Values: "As the Jewish community of Harvard, our connection [to science] is deeper yet: we have the merit of participating in, and leading, the institution that, perhaps more than any on the face of this earth, makes real the sacred practice of the shared exploration of the structure of God’s world. The honor and the responsibility that come with this are not merely vast, they are metaphysical." Which is why Hillel "[rejects] the fight against anti-Semitism as justification for the government’s most recent actions." myemail.constantcontact.com/Science-and-the-Range-of-Jewi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A lovely profile and interview of my colleague and fellow Co-President of the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh, the legal scholar and author Randall Kennedy: ‘If you’re boring, you’re not going to educate.’ — Harvard Gazette news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2025/04/if-youre-boring-yo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard President Alan Garber Joins More Than 180 University Leaders in Statement Against ‘Political Interference’ With Higher Ed | News | The Harvard Crimson www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/4/23/garber-signs-aacu-st…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Yes; I had to lobby the New York Times to stop reflexively referring to FIRE as a "right-wing" organization.
Alice
@AliceFromQueens
When @TheFIREorg was defending free speech against threats from liberals, many liberals defamed them as a partisan right-wing org.
Now they’re defending free speech against the Trump admin w the same intelligent fervor.
We could use some pundit accountability here.
Nico Perrino
@NicoPerrino
Yes, @TheFIREorg spent a lot of time defending conservatives on campus these past 10 years.
But the enemy of free speech isn’t necessarily partisanship, it’s power. And in recent months, the boot has been on the other foot.
I list the threats w/ @mehdirhasan for @zeteo_news: -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How Harvard president Alan Garber came to lead the higher ed resistance against Trump www.bostonglobe.com/2025/04/19/metro/harvard-alan-garber-… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
More brazen assaults on logic and common sense by the Trump administration.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
Absolutely dizzying and flabbergasting. “Well, really, it's your fault for believing what I demanded. But, tomorrow, I'm going to decide I really meant it, soooo…it's still your fault. No backsies!”
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Megastudy testing 25 treatments to reduce antidemocratic attitudes and partisan animosity (two of my colleagues, Mina Cikara and Josh Greene, are among the coauthors) | Science www.science.org/doi/abs/10.1126/science.adh4764
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard fait bloc face à Trump : “J’ai l’impression de vivre dans un livre d’Orwell !” Interview in Telerama, part of Le Monde. www.telerama.fr/debats-reportages/harvard-fait-bloc-face-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The insanity of Trump's attempted takeover: Leading Harvard scientist ordered to halt research in funding freeze www.bostonglobe.com/2025/04/15/metro/harvard-scientist-fu… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard Must Not Submit to a Hostile Takeover | My article (with colleague Tarek Masoud), endorsed by the leaders of the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh | Opinion | The Harvard Crimson www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/4/16/cafh-harvard-trump-d…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I endorse Harvard's decision to fight the astonishing list of demands being forced on it by the Trump administration. I'm currently working on statement and op-ed with my fellow Co-Presidents of the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard @cafh explaining the threat in the demands and how they cannot be accepted. www.thecrimson.com/thread/2025/4/15/harvard-will-fight-de…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Sad to agree with @CathyYoung63 and @MattJJ89 that the Free Press (for which I had high hopes) has "descended into MAGA-lite." Yes, PC-SJW-Critical-Woke-Intersectionality is bad, but some perspective, please: Blowing up the international order, sucking up to autocrats, wrecking the world economy, sowing doubt about vaccines, spreading medical quackery, strangling lifesaving foreign aid, pardoning violent rioters, preventing data collection, spewing nonstop lies, & extorting the press, law firms, and universities is worse.
Cathy Young 🇺🇸🇺🇦🇮🇱
@CathyYoung63
Excellent, wellresearched critique of @TheFP
by @mattjj89 (Matt Johnson) at @UnPopulistMag. As someone who believes opposing left-wing illiberalism is important (& has defended Bari Weiss), I've found the FP's descent into MAGA-lite dispiriting.
(redoing b/c got author wrong) -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A historic tragedy: What really made America great was that it was based on the Enlightenment ideals of individual rights, the rule of law, and democracy, not blood and soil or throne and altar. Descendants of Eastern European Jews, Italians, Indians, Mexicans, Chinese, Caribbean islanders, etc. are as American as Mayflower scions. These are the glorious ideals that Trump's intellectual apologists want to blow up - and with them, the peace & prosperity of the past 80 years. More dead-on commentary from @mattjj89 @quillette quillette.com/2025/03/30/a-hollow-kind-of-patriotism-maga…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Right-wing scientific illiteracy meets left-wing scientific illiteracy: The obnoxious and daffy ravings of Musk & Trump are countered by reiterating 50-year-old talking points blowing off intelligence and IQ that have repeatedly been refuted. (The measurability, heritability, and predictive power of intelligence are among the most replicable findings in psychology.) www.nytimes.com/2025/04/05/arts/what-is-elon-musks-iq.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I Led Harvard’s Medical School, and I Fear for What’s to Come by my Council on Academic Freedom @cafh Co-President Jeff Flier @jflier www.nytimes.com/2025/04/04/opinion/harvard-medicine-highe…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An example: data versus anecdotes (i.e., news).
Johan Norberg
@johanknorberg
Too early to say whether last year was a trend reversal or an outlier, but in 2024 Sweden had the third lowest homicide rate in half a century. Worth noting for Americans who have begun to describe Sweden as a civil war zone. (🇸🇪 0.87 homicides per 100,000, 🇺🇸 5.7 per 100,000)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Losing My Nonreligion by Jerry Coyne - The Freedom from Religion Foundation is among the many nonprofits (ACLU, AHA, SPLC, Amnesty) that have sadly surrendered their mission and their minds to hard-left and woke ideology. @Evolutionistrue www.wsj.com/opinion/losing-my-nonreligion-transgender-ide… via @WSJopinion
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I was part of the last generation of kids to get the measles (and chicken pox, and rubella, and the mumps). Trust me, you don't want them: weeks of childhood misery (and I have been lucky, so far, to have had no lasting effects). Vaccines may be the smartest thing our species has ever invented - with RJKj as HHS sec, we are in a surreal nightmare.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
“Knowledge Is the Enemy of Dictatorship”, by @IdeasB2 open.substack.com/pub/ideasbeyondborders/p/knowledge-is-t…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Our lives are better than ever, but negativity is skewing our brains by UK writer Matthew Syed www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/our-lives-are…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"What's at risk by disrupting NIH? [An] ... understanding of life itself, & therefore better treatments for cancer, dementias, autoimmune disorders, neurodegenerative diseases, birth defects, aging & more." Excellent summary by @ed_hagen of the thrilling frontiers of basic bio research (pointlessly threatened by the current administration).
Ed Hagen
@ed_hagen
1. What's at risk by disrupting NIH? With only a bit of hyperbole: a mechanistic understanding of life itself, & therefore better treatments for cancer, dementias, autoimmune disorders, neurodegenerative diseases, birth defects, aging & more.
Notes on a revolution interrupted 🧵 -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On June 3 in London, @RichardDawkins and I discuss the Future of Humanity and, once we've settled that, other topics. Event sponsored by @ThePanpsycast & Theora Media at the Royal Institutions Theater. Tickets here. thepanpsycast.com/tickets
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
As a cognitive scientist I’ve always been skeptical of the theory that “scale is all you need” (models with more layers, bigger training data) to duplicate or exceed human intelligence. A majority of surveyed AI researchers agree. @garymarcus www.newscientist.com/article/2471759-ai-scientists-are-sc…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's not hyperbolic to compare Trump to dictators in personality; how much damage he does depends on the resilience of our democratic institutions, which his enablers are trying to dismantle. I'm quoted in this dystopian op-ed, which is not inconsistent w my stance on progress: I argue that things don't get better automatically, but only to the extent that Enlightenment institutions (democracy, science, free press, human rights, markets, public health agencies, international community...) function. Trump is threatening all of them, & if he succeeds, things will get worse. www.nytimes.com/2025/03/04/opinion/trump-imperial-preside…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
By my Harvard colleague and fellow Co-president of its Council on Academic Freedom, @jflier: Needed for NIH: A scalpel, not a hatchet www.bostonglobe.com/2025/03/04/opinion/national-institute… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Having plotted many graphs on "war" and "genocide" in my two books on violence, I closely tracked the definitions, and it's utterly clear that the war in Gaza is a war (e.g., the Uppsala Conflict Program, the gold standard, classifies the Gaza conflict as an "internal armed conflict," i.e., war, not "one-sided violence," i.e., genocide). This paper reviews The Genocide Libel: the long history of antisemitic false genocide accusations. isca.indiana.edu/publication-research/research-paper-seri…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Astonished and appalled, Part 2: Antiscientific Vandalism quillette.com/2025/03/03/antiscientific-vandalism-trump-m…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Validated objective tests are the ultimate egalitarian tool, since they favor poor smart kids over upper-class twits, whereas unstructured interviews and "holistic" admissions favor cultural elites. New evidence from a study that looks at the effects of actual caste (in India).
Soumitra Shukla
@soumitrashukla9
1/ Recent moves by US colleges to bring back the SAT highlight a major tension: do “objective” metrics really reduce bias, or do “subjective” assessments (like “fit”) risk perpetuating class barriers? My research on class discrimination at elite firms sheds light. 🧵
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Even for people who appreciate the value of free markets, Bezos's new editorial policy for WaPo is idiotic. 100% of affluent capitalist democracies have regulation & social spending, and for good reasons: They save lives in the workplace & highways, clean up air & waterways, educate kids, and prevent kids & seniors from becoming homeless (see graphs below, from Enlightenment Now). Yes, regulation can be excessive & redistribution can create perverse incentives, but that only means the optimal policies must be evaluated & debated--um, perhaps, on an editorial page?--not that they be zeroed out, which is impossible in any case. A taboo on discussing optimal regulation & redistribution makes an editorial page stupider.
Jeff Bezos
@JeffBezos
I shared this note with the Washington Post team this morning:
I’m writing to let you know about a change coming to our opinion pages.
We are going to be writing every day in support and defense of two pillars: personal liberties and free markets. We’ll cover other topics too of course, but viewpoints opposing those pillars will be left to be published by others.
There was a time when a newspaper, especially one that was a local monopoly, might have seen it as a service to bring to the reader’s doorstep every morning a broad-based opinion section that sought to cover all views. Today, the internet does that job.
I am of America and for America, and proud to be so. Our country did not get here by being typical. And a big part of America’s success has been freedom in the economic realm and everywhere else. Freedom is ethical — it minimizes coercion — and practical — it drives creativity, invention, and prosperity.
I offered David Shipley, whom I greatly admire, the opportunity to lead this new chapter. I suggested to him that if the answer wasn’t “hell yes,” then it had to be “no.” After careful consideration, David decided to step away. This is a significant shift, it won’t be easy, and it will require 100% commitment — I respect his decision. We’ll be searching for a new Opinion Editor to own this new direction.
I’m confident that free markets and personal liberties are right for America. I also believe these viewpoints are underserved in the current market of ideas and news opinion. I’m excited for us together to fill that void.
Jeff -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Psychology of Progress - Interesting interview with @ClayRoutledge open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/the-psych…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I resigned from the American Psychological Association last year after 43 years of membership. Sally Satel @slsatel explains the reason - takeover (and ruination) of scholarly & civil-society institutions by illiberal radicals. www.thefp.com/p/american-psychological-association-antise…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"We should foster an environment that respects individual expression, while also acknowledging biological reality." Scientifically and morally sophisticated analysis by my associate Carole Hooven @hoovlet | There are two sexes. Gender policy is what’s debatable. www.bostonglobe.com/2025/02/20/opinion/trump-executive-or… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
American disgrace: Our country switched sides from democracy & stability to dictatorship & endless aggression. I share @FukuyamaFrancis's revulsion at Trump's "ultimate betrayal." open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/the-ultimate-betrayal…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Aid Doesn't Need to Be Costly to Be Effective: TED talk by Faisal Al Mutar, founder of Ideas Beyond Borders @IdeasB2 www.ideasbeyondborders.net/p/aid-doesnt-need-to-be-costly…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Universities Are Worth Saving | Superb analysis of truth, science, democracy , and what’s right and wrong with universities today, by Jonathan Rauch. quillette.com/2025/02/18/universities-are-worth-saving/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Weimar Fallacy: Free speech enabled Hitler. Not true.
Nico Perrino
@NicoPerrino
“You’re standing in a country where free speech was weaponized to commit a genocide.”
Utterly false. It’s called the “Weimar fallacy” and Margaret Brennan should know better than to engage in it.
Germany had plenty of hate speech codes. Indeed Hiltler was banned from speaking in parts of Germany for a number of years.
The censorship did nothing but make Hitler a martyr. Goebbels conducted a whole propaganda campaign on the back of it. “He alone of two billion people on Earth may not speak in Germany,” read the slogan.
Germany had no free speech and no rule of law — and millions died because of it. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Differences between WEIRD people (those who live in Western Educated Industrialized Rich Democracies) and the rest of the world have been exaggerated, by @cremieuxrecueil www.cremieux.xyz/p/weird-doesnt-work
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Now is the best time in history to love and be loved. From the Up Wing by @tonymmorley theprogressnetwork.org/human-rights-marriage/?ref=theupwi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The territorial integrity norm - states are immortal, borders are grandfathered in - is a plausible cause of the Long Peace, the decline of interstate war since 1946. Norms are maintained by common knowledge (they exist to the extent everyone thinks everyone else thinks they exist, the topic of my next book) and can be threatened by public doubts. This is why loose talk around Greenland & Panama is dangerous. Francis Fukuyama agrees: open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/the-new-american-impe…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Psychology of Virtual Reality | In which I don a Meta VR headset and comment on spatial vision, eye contact & social relations, and applications of VR (follow-up of the feature I did last year on the Apple Vision Pro) | Harvard Magazine www.harvardmagazine.com/2025/01/harvard-steven-pinker-psy…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
FAQ: Has the world gone to pot in the 14 years since Better Angels came out, or 7 years since Enlightenment Now came out? Have Covid, wars in Ukraine & Gaza, suicides, democratic recession, etc. erased previous progress? Answer for the world here (video of a talk I gave this morning) | The Arc of Progress in the 21st Century > World Economic Forum www.weforum.org/meetings/world-economic-forum-annual-meet…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Waymo Drivers Are Way Safer (10x) Than Humans (knowing about human performance, this doesn’t surprise me). open.substack.com/pub/humanprogressnewsletter/p/waymo-dri…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Freedom from Religion Foundation, like the American Humanist Association before them, replaced its mission with wokeism, and became another religion, complete with dogma, heresy, an Index of forbidden thoughts, and excommunication. Part 1: Jerry Coyne explains why he resigned. whyevolutionistrue.com/2024/12/29/i-resign-from-the-freed…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Bring back the blimp! rationaloptimistsociety.com/so/42PDkK6-H?languageTag=en&c…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Last week was the anniversary of the death of my brilliant and beloved friend John Tooby. Here I'm with his collaborator and wife (and my dear friend) Leda Cosmides on his memorial bench on the UCSB campus.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A Letter To Elon Musk on increasing government efficiency, by Francis Fukuyama @FukuyamaFrancis open.substack.com/pub/persuasion1/p/a-letter-to-elon-musk…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Richard Dawkins is a giant next to today’s thinkers, says James Marriott (and he's a young guy). www.thetimes.com/article/b3ecd5d3-b7ff-48b4-b133-790cca22…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The right says the country is dying so you should vote for Trump despite his flaws. The hard left says the country is a hellscape so you may as well vote in protest for a 3rd party or sit out the election. My NYT op-ed this morning shows in 8 graphs why these are seriously deluded. The country faces problems (as always) but is in better shape than for most of its past. www.nytimes.com/2024/10/29/opinion/trump-national-decline…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Big news, no coverage: “Malaria is as old as Egyptian civilization itself, but the disease that plagued pharaohs now belongs to its history and not its future,” said Dr Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, WHO Director-General. “This certification of Egypt as malaria-free is truly historic..." www.who.int/news/item/20-10-2024-egypt-is-certified-malar…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Superb new review by BU prof & former Harvard grad student Luke Glowacki on the Controversial origins of war and peace: "Our ancestors almost certainly experienced lethal intergroup violence but also cooperated across group boundaries. Due to their important fitness consequences, both war and intergroup cooperation were likely to have been important selective forces in the evolution of modern humans." drive.google.com/file/d/1VEDNdEgRpG2IovIIP9if_gR8NBm5Wh3T…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Fixing Higher Education: A Profectus Roundtable (with a few words by me) - Profectus Magazine - organized by @clayroutledge profectusmag.com/fixing-higher-education-roundtable/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Wise article (a year and a half old) by @harari_yuval on the New Peace, what caused it, and why it's fragile. And a good reminder of why Ukraine matters. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2022/12/putin-russian-u…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
During the debate, Trump sputtered that FBI homicide data are underreported by police departments. In reality the FBI estimates compensate for these missing data, & Datalytics estimates, taken directly from big-city depts, confirm there's no current crime surge. On the contrary, after the 20-21 spike (which was genuine), we've returned to the lowest homicide rate since 1963. [2024 data point is an extrapolation, of course] www.ahdatalytics.com/dashboards/ytd-murder-comparison/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Wikipedia is one of humanity's greatest achievements: Seven million articles (in English), constructed by volunteers with a dedication to neutrality and objectivity. @dgardner defends it against attacks it has become "Wokepedia." open.substack.com/pub/dgardner/p/has-wikipedia-become-wok…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
HUMANS AND OTHER ANIMALS Movie | A Documentary Film by Mark DeVries (I have a cameo, though not playing one of the animals). @speciesism www.humansandotheranimalsmovie.com
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What Are the Causes of Human Progress? by @Johanknorberg humanprogress.org/what-are-the-causes-of-human-progress/ via @HumanProgress
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Predicting political beliefs with polygenic scores for cognitive performance: being smart steers people toward more non-authoritarian left politics. Study by my former student & collaborator James Lee, and rising star Emily Willoughby www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289624000254
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Do We Deny The Existence Of Human Nature? New episode in my video series The Life of the Mind. youtu.be/_cM-q1dzBmE via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The EA-Progress Studies War is Here, and It’s a Constructive Dialogue!— Clara Collier & Jason Crawford in Asterisk. (I just learned that I'm on the Progress Studies side, though sympathetic to core EA.) asteriskmag.com/issues/06/the-ea-progress-studies-war-is-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Nature, Nurture, & Neither: The laws of behavioral genetics. "Everything is partly heritable" isn't even the most shocking. It's the effects of the environment that people are most wrong about, together with influences that are neither genetic nor environmental. Latest episode in my video series The Life of the Mind. youtu.be/LNgfqTrnpe8 via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Reports today of Noam Chomsky's death (in Jacobin and New Statesman, since taken down) were greatly exaggerated. I have confirmation from Valeria, his wife, that he is alive and well.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One of @EasterbrookG's collection of headlines showing media negativity bias (e.g., Economy Improving, But Some Left Behind; Not Everyone in World's Happiest Country are Happy).
Gregg Easterbrook
@EasterbrookG
Financial Times headline: WORLD FACES STAGGERING OIL GLUT, ENERGY WATCHDOG WARNS.
Warns! Warns a resource is plentiful! P.S. if were an oil shortage, MSM would say that’s bad too. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Demand for electricity is insatiable: economic development in poor countries; electrification of richer ones; new tech like AI, crypto, & big data. Scalable 24/7/365 carbon-free power is the world's highest priority. Hooray for the world's first coal-to-nuclear reactor plant, ingenious tech which also stores excess energy from intermittent renewables. electrek.co/2024/06/11/coal-to-nuclear-reactor-plant-wyom…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Would refusing to talk to Daniel Kahneman when he was at Hebrew U have made the world a better place? If I stopped corresponding with 93-year-old Nobelist Robert Aumann about his groundbreaking work in game theory, would Palestinians be better off? The Academic Boycott of Israel is academia at its worst: mindless, demonizing virtue signaling. Open letter for faculty here: www.unitedagainstacademicboycott.com
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Watch this ... just watch it. You won't be sorry. youtu.be/DWZh9l8xUtY via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Here's the report: Not just a typical survey, but a combo of human expertise & machine learning: Exploring Americans' Visions of the Future - Human Flourishing Lab humanflourishinglab.org/exploring-americans-visions-of-th…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
We Need More Hopeful Visions of the Future: If people believe that despite massive efforts to improve the world, it's worse than ever, why bother with progress, reform, or innovation? Essay by Clay Routledge of the Human Flourishing Lab, citing an AI-aided study of people's fears & hopes about the future. clayroutledge.substack.com/p/we-need-more-hopeful-visions…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Jews and Arabs are literally cousins, sharing Recent Ancestry | Science | AAAS www.science.org/content/article/jews-and-arabs-share-rece…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Hooray for MIT, my former home: It was the 1st elite university to reinstate standardized testing for applicants (best way to find poor smart students), and now becomes 1st to discard mandatory "diversity statements," which in reality impose intellectual uniformity. - UnHerd
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The annual lecture in memory of Charles Darwin | Prof. Steven Pinker | The Evolution of Rationality (and Irrationality) | Israel Academy of Science and Humanities www.academy.ac.il/Index/Entry.aspx?nodeId=936&entryId=22731
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"Lost Women of Science: Elizabeth Bates and the Search for the Roots of Human Language" | In this podcast, I reflect on one of my fiercest academic adversaries, the late psycholinguist Elizabeth Bates. www.lostwomenofscience.org/episodes/elizabeth-bates-and-t…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Giordano Bruno Foundation's 2024 Youth Summer Camp: Apply here. The Giordano Bruno Foundation is a German non-profit foundation, dedicated to Evolutionary Humanism & Critical Rationalism. gbs-Sommerforum – 7. – 9. Juni 2024 in Oberwesel www.gbs-sommerforum.de
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If I don't believe in God, what SHOULD I believe in if I want to lead a moral and meaningful life? Answers to this FAQ may be found in a forthcoming book published by @Humanists_UK
Humanists UK
@Humanists_UK
📢📚🙌 Special announcement... A new book of inspiring interviews with over 30 humanists in the public eye set for release in November. It’s called 'What I Believe' & this is its beautiful cover! humanists.uk/2024/04/04/new-book-release-what-i-believe-s…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Negativity drives online news consumption | Helps explain why people are misinformed about positive trends in the state of the world. www.nature.com/articles/s41562-023-01538-4?ref=fixthenews…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Sad to learn of the death of Daniel Kahneman, one of the greatest psychologists in history. www.nytimes.com/2024/03/27/business/daniel-kahneman-dead.…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
For people who read the news (a nonrandom sample of the worst events anywhere on Earth) and think everything is getting worse, it's vital to follow data instead. Like this: The number of children who died before the age of five hit a historic low of 4.9 million in 2022, less than half the number who died in 2000. Levels and trends in child mortality - UNICEF DATA. data.unicef.org/resources/levels-and-trends-in-child-mort…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A short history of global living conditions:
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
I've updated my Short History of Global Living Conditions.
here it is: ourworldindata.org/a-history-of-global-living-conditions -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Stop thinking "This changes everything": rare dramatic events usually warrant a small updating of probability, not a rethinking of one's world view (though they can be coordination focal points, i.e. crises not to let go to waste). Scott Alexander @slatestarcodex explains: Against Learning From Dramatic Events open.substack.com/pub/astralcodexten/p/against-learning-f…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Interview in @PhilosophyNow by Angela Tan on politics, language, death, optimism, and of course #philosophy. philosophynow.org/issues/160/Steven_Pinker
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
NYT is situated at the Left Pole, the spot from which all directions are right. Coleman Hughes, a Biden voter, and Quillette, the champion of liberalism, are labeled "conservative" because of their criticism of racial identitarianism. "The Young Black Conservative Who Grew Up With, and Rejects, D.E.I." www.nytimes.com/2024/02/01/us/coleman-hughes-black-conser…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Nature & Nurture #130: MIT philosopher Dr. Alex Byrne - There Is No Gender Without Sex, interviewed by Adam Omary (trigger warning: many heresies openly discussed here). youtu.be/qpJZnS2lHeM via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Seven positive developments on climate (not enough, but contrary to certain doom), and how your intuitions about carbon reduction differ from reality. From @OurWorldInData Deputy Editor @_HannahRitchie www.thetimes.co.uk/article/7-reasons-why-theres-more-good…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I've experienced this shift as a prof. When I arrived in '03 I gave 25% A/A- (admittedly, a carry-over from my years at MIT). Just learned that in Gen Ed courses, the average is now 80%. I've spoken to several deans, who say they're concerned about this grade inflation, & I hope something will be done (it can't be solved by individual profs).
John Arnold
@johnarnold
Two Harvard Crimson articles, one from 2006 and the other from 2023, describing the legendary Math 55 class showcase how much college has changed in less than a generation.
'06: “This is probably the most difficult undergraduate math class in the country,” reads a page on the Mathematics Department Web site.
'23: “Our slogan is, if you’re reasonably good at math, you love it, and you have lots of time to devote to it, then Math 55 is completely fine for you.” -- article published by the math dept titled, “Demystifying Math 55.”
'06: Regardless of the course’s name brand value, Math 55 students face a single fact: It’s hard. Really hard.
'23: Zoe Shleifer ’26, another current Math 55 student, also doesn’t get the hype. “It’s fun,” she says. “It’s just like any other class. You know, we go to lecture, and then we leave lecture, and then we do the problem set.”
'06: Midway through October, the “Survivor”-like competition intensifies with the add/drop deadline looming frighteningly near, only five days away.
'23: “We wanted to avoid a situation where some students felt excluded because of the way the course was taught a particular year,” (Professor) Harris says.
'06: The class can’t stay this hard for this long, right? “I figure he’s just trying to get people to drop the class,” Litt says. He figured wrong. As class attendance steadily thins, the workload does not.
'23: “To be as inclusive as possible is one of the things I was told before I walked in the classroom the first day,” says Harris.
'06: Before the fifth Monday of the term, students who can’t seem to stay in the game start dropping like flies. “I thought it was completely unbelievable,” Harbater says. “Seventy started it, 20 finished it, and only 10 understood it.”
'23: “The math department has been working hard to foster a more inclusive culture around Math 55. The overall feedback we have received from students about the last few iterations of the course suggests that this is beginning to bear fruit,” she continued, referencing reviews for Math 55’s Q guide reviews, which are overwhelmingly positive. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My colleague, the biologist Carole Hooven @hoovlet, tells her story on why she left Harvard. Her experience was one of the reasons we founded the Council on Academic Freedom at Harvard. One of our goals: "When an individual is threatened or slandered for a scholarly opinion, which can be emotionally devastating, we will lend our personal and professional support." www.thefp.com/p/carole-hooven-why-i-left-harvard
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Harried Leisure Class - Why life can feel worse even when it's gotten better. Alex Tabbarok in Marginal REVOLUTION marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2023/06/the-har…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
1,000 Bits of Good News You May Have Missed in 2023 - Human Progress @HumanProgress humanprogress.org/1000-bits-of-good-news-you-may-have-mis…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
“It is time for the Effective Altruism movement to rediscover humanism.” Perfectly put by Matt Johnson. quillette.com/2023/12/21/how-effective-altruism-lost-its-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why did Antisemitism Sprout So Quickly on university campuses but not in other American institutions? Post #1 by @JonHaidt www.afterbabel.com/p/antisemitism-on-campus
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The wrong way for the elite universities to dig themselves out their reputational hole: restrict speech even more. Instead:
1. Clear & coherent free speech policy.
2. Institutional neutrality: Universities are forums, not protagonists.
3. Force prohibited: No more heckler's vetoes, building takeovers, classroom invasions, intimidations, blockades, assaults.
4. Disempower DEI bureaucrats, responsible to no one, who have turned campuses into laughingstocks.
5. Viewpoint diversity: Discourage political & intellectual monocultures (including hard-left/PoMo/"intersectional"). -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
“There’s Nothing Mystical About the Idea that Ideas Change History” quillette.com/2023/12/01/theres-nothing-mystical-about-th…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I was a fan of Effective Altruism (almost taught a course on it at Harvard) together w other rational efforts (evidence-based medicine, data-driven policing, randomista econ). But it became cultish. Happy to donate to save the most lives in Africa, but not to pay techies to fret about AI turning us into paperclips. Still support the idea; hope they extricate themselves from this rut. www.wsj.com/tech/ai/openai-blowup-effective-altruism-disa… via @WSJ
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Does science get censored? Yes. Who does it? Scientists. My new paper in PNAS (spearheaded by Cory Clark, w 38 coauthors). www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2301642120
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Psychology Lost a Great Mind | My appreciation of John Tooby. nautil.us/psychology-lost-a-great-mind-442179/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker talks to lawyers about bad writing and how to make it better www.jewishaz.com/community/steven-pinker-talks-to-lawyers… via @phxjnews
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Terrible things are happening, but that doesn't mean everything happening is terrible. It's important to be aware of the positive developments, for an accurate understanding of the world & as an antidepressant. Not human-interest fluff but significant events & discoveries. @HumanProgress Weekly Roundup: humanprogress.org/weekly-progress-roundup-option-2/ via @HumanProgress
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Mourning the death of John Tooby: Brilliant mind, saintly human being, beloved friend. www.edge.org/memberbio/john_tooby
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Hamas Tells You Who They Are, Believe Them. Matt Johnson exposes the atrocious inanity of the professors, students, and activists who apologize for Hamas. plus.thebulwark.com/p/when-hamas-tells-you-who-they-are
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why do Greta Thunberg & Judith Butler support a misogynistic, homophobic, racist, genocidal, theocratic regime?
Muslim Antisemitism and the Western Left. quillette.com/2023/11/07/muslim-antisemitism-and-the-west… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Has wokeism jumped the shark? Deranged defense of Hamas on campuses could finally loosen this illiberal, anti-human ideology. by Niall Fergson @nfergus mol.im/a/12681617 via @MailOnline
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is one man's terrorist really another man's freedom fighter? (Do "freedom fighters" rape women & murder babies?) BBC, Reuters, other newsrooms tell reporters: Don't say "terrorism." Daniel King, copyeditor of @MotherJones, argues otherwise: "Terrorist" = "political violence ... aimed at sending a symbolic and material message of dread to civilians." www.motherjones.com/media/2023/10/hamas-terrorism-word-ba… via @MotherJones
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Are women adult human females? A debate: Louise Antony vs Alex Byrne youtu.be/s0c7-BIWLek via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Important to understand these two ideas simultaneously: The world has made real progress on climate, but were not on track to meet our goals. Progress is possible, but only if we work further toward it.
Zeke Hausfather
@hausfath
The world has made real progress in bending down the curve of future emissions.
While we remain far from on track to meet our climate goals, the positive steps we’ve made should reinforce that progress is possible and despair is counterproductive.
www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-global-co2-emissions-could-p… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Understatement: Clearing forests to erect solar panels may not be clean-energy solution news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2023/10/clearing-forests-t… via @Harvard
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Covid-19 set back the effort to eliminate severe poverty by three years, but progress appears to have resumed.
The Progress Network
@progressntwrk
However, the Covid-19 pandemic has set back the effort to reduce poverty globally by three years.
The new goal? Eliminating global extreme poverty by 2030.
blogs.worldbank.org/opendata/poverty-back-pre-covid-level… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An Open letter to the Harvard community from me and more than a hundred colleagues (so far): docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vRrU_R4lJMubYBFX5KePu…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Agree with @nickKristof, and am ashamed to be at the same university as the endorsers of this fatuous and morally monstrous statement. Deliberately murdering civilians, and abducting women, children, and the elderly, are heinous war crimes. And this regime is avowedly racist,...
Nicholas Kristof
@NickKristof
This statement by a bunch of Harvard student groups saying that Israel is "entirely responsible" and "the only one to blame" leaves me shaking my head. Sure, criticize Israeli policies, but excusing Hamas is so absurd it veers into self-caricature.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
3 celebrations in 3 days! Congratulations to the brave & brilliant Leda Cosmides on her induction into the American Academy of Arts and Sciences.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
On average, it's good for countries to be rich (greater happiness, democracy, safety, peace, gender =, env. quality, human rights). On avg, getting rich means higher C02 emissions. But the correlation is imperfect: some rich countries are low emitters. The world's challenge: decouple them further, then completely. www.brookings.edu/articles/making-emissions-count-in-coun…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How to Argue Against Identity Politics (successor ideology, political correctness, social justice warfare, critical theory) Without Turning Into a Reactionary Crank. "It is time to fight, without shame or hesitation, for a future in which what we have in common truly comes to be more important than what divides us." XLNT piece by @Yascha_Mounk www.nytimes.com/2023/09/22/opinion/identity-politics.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Saving Liberalism from ‘The Identity Trap’: An Interview with Yascha Mounk quillette.com/2023/09/19/untitled-3/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Litmus '23: A Quest for Reason | October 1st | Freethinker Festival in India: Thiruvananthapuram | esS... youtu.be/iz5d7P5QGvI via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Our descendants will be astonished to ponder the fact that we got our meat by raising and killing sentient creatures.
Peter Singer
@PeterSinger
After 52 years, I have eaten chicken again! But no animal was raised and killed for my meal. It was cultivated chicken, grown from cells by @GOODMeat - yes, that's correct, google it - and Singapore was, until very recently, the only place in the world where you could eat it.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
We're Number 0! Harvard is named worst school for free speech — scoring zero out of possible 100 nypost.com/2023/09/06/harvard-is-named-worst-school-for-f… via @nypost
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Climate change is not just about electricity.
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
Elon Musk said that farming has “no meaningful impact on climate change”.
This is not true. Food production is responsible for a quarter of the world’s greenhouse gas emissions.
@_HannahRitchie documents it here on @OurWorldInData: ourworldindata.org/food-ghg-emissions -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Do We Get Sick? The (relatively) New Science of Evolutionary Medicine by @laithalshawaf areomagazine.com/2023/08/23/why-do-we-get-sick-the-new-sc… via @areomagazine
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Hans & Ola Rosling pioneered this kind of display for this kind of data, and it's still worth taking in this astonishing and underappreciated progress.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
As with reading, where "whole language" methods flout psycholinguistics and led to widespread illiteracy, "inquiry learning" for math flouts cognitive psychology (automaticity, chunking, expert-novice distinction) and has led to widespread innumeracy. www.city-journal.org/article/californias-math-framework-i…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Excellent short essay by @maxc on the limits of our personal experience and of the news media, and the value of statistics - Our World in Data @OurWorldInData ourworldindata.org/limits-personal-experience
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Thoughtful essay by @ChristineEmba struggles to identify a constructive image of masculinity. We have one: Mensch. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/07/10/christine-emba…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Can Plants Think? Though some species process information, Temple Grandin reasonably argues that they fail a minimum requirement: a hub "where inputs and outputs are integrated with stored information." www.nytimes.com/2023/06/23/books/review/planta-sapiens-pa…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
❌ No, 50% of AI researchers don't believe there is a 10% risk that AI will kill us www.warpnews.org/artificial-intelligence/no-50-of-ai-rese…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A sad confirmation of their point: Scientists Defend Merit in Science in a paper that could be published only in the Journal of Controversial Ideas. indefenseofmerit.org
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Can we engineer a perfect world? (No.) Tyler VanderWeele & Steven Pinker discuss human flourishing, human progress, and Humanist & Christian morality, moderated by Prof Roz Picard, at MIT Veritas Forum. youtu.be/9uRE4WxaEis via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
College administrators are administering reverse-Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy, telling students they are victims who should surrender to their emotions, and increasing depression. Why the Mental Health of Liberal Girls Sank First and Fastest, by @JonHaidt open.substack.com/pub/jonathanhaidt/p/mental-health-liber…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Beautiful presentation of facts of human history that everyone should known (but most people don't).
-
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
AFAIK the only linguist who has publicly commented on the bizarre linguistics of totalitarian woke language policing is @JohnHMcWhorter www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/07/brandeis-langua…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Once devastated, these Pacific reefs have seen an amazing rebirth archive.ph/DTQKa
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A bold idea: NATO offers to withdraw nukes from Europe (militarily useless, ineffective deterrents as we’ve just seen, & recklessly dangerous) in return for ending the invasion. Putin gets a “win” which costs us nothing worth having. thehill.com/opinion/international/3565996-nuclear-strateg…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Beggars belief that an elite university could outlaw discussion of one of the most important scientific theories (indeed, most important ideas) of all time.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
SciencesPo, which trains the French political elite, has decided they may not learn about evolution or genetics: A minority of activists have censored courses on their connection to politics and gender.
Leonardo Orlando
@leogabo
End of my course “Human Nature and Political Behavior" @SorbonneParis1 @SciencePoParis1. Rundown: vast majority of students thrilled, tiny vocal minority outraged by first encounter with @sapinker @PascalBoyerUSA @NAChristakis @SteveStuWill @michaelshermer @JonHaidt @M_B_Petersen
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Incisive and urgent analysis by @Yascha_Mounk on our current danger. www.persuasion.community/p/mounk-america-is-headed-for-di…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Once again: A misguided article on why the theory of evolution is obsolete – Why Evolution Is True whyevolutionistrue.com/2022/06/29/once-again-a-misguided-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Shtetl-Optimized » Scott Aaronson and I debate AI scaling! scottaaronson.blog?p=6524
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Tragedy of the Unwanted Child: What Ancient Cultures Did Before Abortion (I discuss the decline of infanticide in The Better Angels of Our Nature. For most of human existence, probably 10-15% of newborns were killed.) quillette.com/2022/06/24/the-tragedy-of-the-unwanted-chil…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Progress Roundtable: Q & A on what progress is, what causes it, and whether it will continue. profectusmag.com/progress-roundtable/ via @ProfectusM
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Nonsense on Stilts (and: "sentient" is not a fancy word for "intelligent" or "self-aware" -- it means feeling things). garymarcus.substack.com/p/nonsense-on-stilts?s=r
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Ball of confusion: One of Google's (former) ethics experts doesn't understand the difference between sentience (aka subjectivity, experience), intelligence, and self-knowledge. (No evidence that its large language models have any of them.) www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2022/06/11/google-ai-la…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Just learned of this remarkable study by Alan Cowen,, Dacher Keltner, et al. updating an intro psych classic (Paul Ekman's claims for universality of facial expressions) for the 21st C: 16 expressions, thousands of contexts, 6m videos, 144 countries. drive.google.com/file/d/1QVx9dUdnLKbineZcdlm7uhNxsYqODlye…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Opinion | 6 solutions to gun violence that could work www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/06/02/gun-control-so…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
John Horgan seems unable to think his way out of the blunder that to end war we must pretend it's a recent invention. I've noted it many times; Michael Wilson & Richard Wrangham do it here: To End War, We Need to Understand Its Origins, Evolution & Causes blog.michael-lawrence-wilson.com/2022/05/12/to-end-war-w…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Against the College Admissions Essay - It's less informative, more easily gamed, and more biased toward the wealthy than the SAT. www.persuasion.community/p/against-the-college-admissions…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Five Lessons from @juliagalef 's ‘The Scout Mindset." (Julia was a guest on the most recent episode of my BBC podcast series "Think with Pinker" www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0011lt1) quillette.com/2022/02/04/five-lessons-from-julia-galefs-t…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New episode! BBC Radio 4 - Think with Pinker: The Climate Game, in which @BillGates and Hannah Fry @FryRsquared discuss the game-theoretic dilemma of climate change and ways to change the rule of the game to solve it. www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0012s9z
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The most important article you'll have read this year, from @future_crunch @angushervey: 99 Good News Stories You Didn’t Hear About in 2021. They didn't happen by themselves, but thru ingenuity and activism. Efforts to improve the world can work. link.medium.com/HRodc0L3qmb
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Life You Can Save is giving away free books! Paperbacks are limited to the first 7000 sign-ups, eBook or audiobook versions are unlimited.
"Part rational argument, part stinging manifesto, part handbook.” - The New York Times
Get your free book: www.thelifeyoucansave.org/book-giveaway/ -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Antivax, complots, fake news : Avons-nous perdu la raison ? Entretien exclusif avec Steven Pinker ... youtu.be/C_sef3YbUXA via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Appreciate this review, particularly the historical background, but he missed my point about the “beliefs” of Christians and in demonic possession, which was that they are not held literally - we have several different modes of “belief.” www.nytimes.com/2021/10/03/books/review/rationality-steve…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Think With Pinker: In this new BBC Radio 4 series, I'll talk about rationality & irrationality w experts + people who deal with it in the world, including Bill Gates, Hannah Fry, Daniel Kahneman, Talithia Williams, Charlie Munger, Elizabeth Loftus... www.bbc.co.uk/mediacentre/2021/radio-4-think-with-pinker
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
NYT magazine "Climate Issue" announces "The Only Solution: Try Everything." The word "nuclear" appears nowhere in the issue. (Compounding the chutzpah: A round table discussion on "What if American Democracy Fails the Climate Crisis?") www.nytimes.com/section/magazine
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What's the difference between rationality and intelligence? Steven Pinker in conversation with Stuart Ritchie | Full Q&A | Oxford Union youtu.be/JG_Fm4ue9bA via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
50 Reasons to Love Joni Mitchell's ‘Blue.’ A fitting tribute to that ravishingly beautiful, musically complex, and even a bit Canadian masterpiece, a half-century after its release. www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/06/20/arts/music/joni-mi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Yesterday I spoke at the Cambridge Union and was interviewed by Leor Zmigrod & several whip-smart students. Video here: Steven Pinker | Cambridge Union youtu.be/uq1KK65XJK0 via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
By the world's expert on persuasion and social influence: Influence, New and Expanded by Robert B. Cialdini, PhD harperbusiness.com/book/9780062937650/Influence-New-and-E…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When Men Behave Badly—A Review of David Buss’s new book on sex differences in sexuality (the largest sex difference) and the resulting arenas of sexual conflict. quillette.com/2021/04/30/when-men-behave-badly-a-review/ via @Quillette
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Nothing is moving in this illusion
じゃがりきん
@jagarikin
矢印の方向に動いて見えた人は疲れているので学校を休むといいと言われています
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Out today, a book for our time: When Men Behave Badly: The Hidden Roots of Sexual Deception, Harassment, and Assault, by the leading evolutionary psychologist of sex, David Buss. www.amazon.com/dp/0316419354
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
By canceling Richard Dawkins, the American Humanist Association has betrayed its values. reason.com/2021/04/26/by-canceling-richard-dawkins-the-am… via @reason
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A new journal: the Journal of Controversial Ideas journalofcontroversialideas.org/volumes_issues/1/1
-
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If you've never seen Milgram's riveting documentary I recommend watching it first: www.youtube.com/watch?v=rdrKCilEhC0
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Letter to the @AmericanHumanist Association from myself (AHA Humanist of the Year 2006) and Rebecca Goldstein (AHA Humanist of the Year 2011) @platobooktour protesting its withdrawal of Humanist of the Year award to @richarddawkins #richarddawkins
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Kids are taught that everything's getting worse and we're all doomed--factually incorrect, and a message that leads to cynicism & fatalism, not constructive action. An antidote: Charles Kenny's new Your World, Better, aimed at middle-school kids. charleskenny.blogs.com/weblog/2021/04/your-world-better.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Louis Liebenberg has made fascinating observations on rationality & scientific thinking in the Kalahari San, wh I've cited in 3 books (including the opening to Rationality). New paper: Tracking Science: An Alternative for Those Excluded by Citizen Science theoryandpractice.citizenscienceassociation.org/article/1…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Journalistic elites now believe in word magic: An uttered sound has dreadful powers, as in curses & spells.They've blown off the core of linguistics: words are conventions, whose effects consists only of how people understand them in context quillette.com/2021/02/09/with-a-star-science-reporters-pu… via @Quillette
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The spring semester at Harvard has begun, and I will be posting my lectures from Psy 1: Introduction to Psychological Science. Here's the introductory lecture (still working on improving the video quality): harvard.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Viewer.aspx?id=5…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The incoming administration might have the biggest opportunity in more than a decade to drive innovation in climate-friendly technologies. slate.com/technology/2021/01/early-stage-climate-friendly… via @slate
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Dædalus, the excellent but paywalled journal of the American Academy of Arts & Sciences, Becomes Open Access shar.es/aoh9c0
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I'm a strong free speech guy, but tech's deplatforming of Trump seems justified. Even 1st amend jurisprud (lenient standard) excepts inciting imminent lawless action. POTUS w unique powers + violently disrupting democ governance are 2 bright lines, not top of a slippery slope
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
xkcd: Steepen the Curve xkcd.com/2409/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
2020 set several kinds of progress back (longevity, extreme poverty), but saw many others continue (war, human rights, other infectious diseases).
The Progress Network
@progressntwrk
Good riddance to mostly bad rubbish.
theprogressnetwork.org/2020-good-news/ -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Visual illusion of the day: No actual motion in this display.
じゃがりきん
@jagarikin
おはようございます
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why isn’t this a major headline?
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A few minutes ago....
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Scott Lilienfeld, Psychologist Who Questioned Psychology, Dies at 59 www.nytimes.com/2020/10/16/science/scott-lilienfeld-dead.…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
16 bad things that are decreasing, and 16 good things that are increasing: The Worst of Times Amid the Best of Times: Inspiring post by eminent psychologist David Myers. community.macmillanlearning.com/t5/talk-psych-blog/the-wo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I'm honored to have written the foreword to Nobel Peace Laureate & Former Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos's new book Un Mensaje Optimista Para un Mundo en Crisis (an optimistic message for a world in crisis). www.eltiempo.com/cultura/musica-y-libros/nuevo-libro-de-j… via @eltiempo
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Thoughts on the 75th anniversary of Nagasaki. 1. We should savor the pleasant surprise that no nuclear weapon has been detonated in war for 3/4 of a century. The second time has (so far) been the last time. This was not a foregone conclusion...
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Thomas Sowell is among the most brilliant & original thinkers I've read. Excellent new profile by Coleman Hughes @coldxman www.city-journal.org/thomas-sowell-race-poverty-culture
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What we lose when we turn our backs on persuasion by @PamelaParesky and Shadi Bartsch jd.fo/cMWy via @jdforward
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How objectivity in journalism became a matter of opinion. Not a positive development: if moralistic certitude replaces a search for common understanding, the powerful win. Great when you feel powerful, not so great when the other guy has more brute force. www.economist.com/books-and-arts/2020/07/16/how-objectivi…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A moving essay by the Central Park birder, Christian Cooper, suffused with reason and compassion. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/christian-cooper-why-i-am…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Most important: The sheer number of cancellations (though not small) misses the point: it's the regime of intimidation that silences many more and warps our knowledge. It's like saying, "Criticizing that autocracy is based on anecdata, since it imprisons only a few journalists."
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This commentary by @Ayishat_Akanbi is brilliant and moving.
Double Down News
@DoubleDownNews
The Importance of Free Speech @Ayishat_Akanbi
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Artists and Writers Warn of an ‘Intolerant Climate.’ Reaction Is Swift. www.nytimes.com/2020/07/07/arts/harpers-letter.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Prove Your Paranormal Powers and Win $250,000 from the CFI Investigations Group centerforinquiry.org/press_releases/prove-your-paranormal… via @center4inquiry
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Amazing dynamic data visualization of the exponential growth of COVID-19 in 2020, ranked against other causes of death. public.flourish.studio/visualisation/2637725/ Visualised with @f_l_o_u_r_i_s_h
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Is the world making progress against the pandemic? Our World in Data built this chart to answer this question - ourworldindata.org/epi-curve-covid-19
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Bill Gates Is the Most Interesting Man in the World www.nytimes.com/2020/05/22/opinion/bill-gates-coronavirus…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
One of my favorite science journalists, Gina Kolata, puts the pandemic in historical context, asking, How Do Pandemics End? www.nytimes.com/2020/05/10/health/coronavirus-plague-pand…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rationality: All 25 lectures from my Harvard Gen Ed course here. What is rationality? Why does it seem so scarce? Why are humans smart enough to figure out the Big Bang & DNA but stupid enough to burn witches & own slaves? How can we become more rational? harvard.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.aspx
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The coronavirus pandemic has underlined the importance of supporting multilateral organisations like the World Health Organisation, rather than progressively weakening them. Important essay by Kishore Mahbubani. str.sg/JgpN
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Homicides fell, green space grew and your weather forecast got a lot more precise. The last 10 years were filled with positive change—really! Read our list… reasonstobecheerful.world/the-decade-in-cheer/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rising Enlightenment ideals in the Islamic world, riding a 6-decade global wave of liberal values documented by World Values Survey (women's rights, gay rights, personal freedom...). Graph in Enlightenment Now from WVS's Christian Welzel. www.nytimes.com/2019/12/23/opinion/islam-religion.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Future Crunch by Angus Hervey is the most comprehensive survey of positive developments in the world: Not feel-good fluff, but significant & underreported accomplishments. His end-of-year report: 99 Good News Stories You Probably Didn't Hear About in 2019- futurecrun.ch/99-good-news-2019
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This was mine: “Journalistic pessimism has sown fatalism and radicalism about our institutions,” writes @sapinker. How would you fix politics?
www.politico.com/interactives/2019/how-to-fix-politics-in… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Rescuing the National Conversation - Forceful defense from the left of free speech and viewpoint diversity by Dana Abizaid. counterpunch.org www.counterpunch.org/2019/01/29/rescuing-the-national-con… by @NatCounterPunch
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
In U.S., Decline of Christianity Continues at Rapid Pace pewrsr.ch/33zq8Hc
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Sad to learn that a great anthropologist, Napoleon Chagnon has died. He chronicled the Yanomamo with affection, honesty, and scientific rigor, and was subjected to vicious calumny for his efforts . www.nytimes.com/2019/09/30/science/napoleon-chagnon-dead.…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Responsible reporting & media consumption aims not for "optimism" but *accuracy*: circumventing the media's built-in negativity biases (bad developments newsworthy, good ones boring) & intentional ones (crises = serious journalism, progress = human-interest fluff).
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Total warfare is not a modern invention: still more evidence. Burning of Maya City Said to Be Act of Total Warfare www.nytimes.com/2019/08/05/science/mayan-warfare-archaeol…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Anyone quantifying the history of violence has had to deal with Mao's Great Leap Forward: How many 10s of millions killed? Criminal stupidity or deliberate genocide? Study w new data concludes: 'Mao killed 45 million in 4 years.' www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/books/news/maos-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Populists claim it was better in the 70s, but "the best explanation for the good old days is a bad memory." I was there: 2-digit inflation + unemployment; gas lines; shortages of sugar, coffee, meat. Unskilled wages bought *much* less. humanprogress.org/article.php?p=1994 #humanprogressdata
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's Insane We're Having A 'Debate' Over Whether It's Acceptable To Assault A Journalist jessesingal.substack.com/p/its-insane-were-having-a-debat…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Another day, another op-ed by a Harvard prof criticizing the university’s infantilizing its students, in this case by indulging their unanalyzed feelings. Ron Sullivan: Why Harvard Was Wrong to Make Me Step Down www.nytimes.com/2019/06/24/opinion/harvard-ronald-sulliva…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Critics of modernity extol traditional societies knit by kinship, but their members are less honest www.nytimes.com/2019/06/20/science/lost-wallet-what-to-do… and generous www.econ.uzh.ch/dam/jcr:ffffffff-9758-127f-0000-00004de60… with strangers: Morality = loyalty to blood, not abstract principles.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Nietzsche isn't pietzsche: Philosopher Kelley Ross shows how he endorsed slavery & analogous subjugation of women as a "necessary condition for any superior culture" www.friesian.com/poly-1b.htm I'm always amazed that this flaming antihumanist is so venerated. quillette.com/2019/01/14/enlightenment-wars-some-reflecti…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The media give 4,000 times as much coverage to terrorism as the number of deaths would warrant if coverage reflected danger: Over-and-underrepresentation-of-deaths-in-media.png (3461×2676) ourworldindata.org/uploads/2019/05/Over-and-underrepresen…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Believing Brain: Evolution, Neuroscience, and the Spiritual Instinct (new video of a panel I appeared on last year at the World Science Festival, w Brian Greene, Lisa Barrett Feldman, Zoran Josipovic, & Barbara King. youtu.be/p0_-7FmrDq8 via @YouTube
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why I’m skeptical that we’ll see genetic enhancement of humans any time soon: Genes have multiple effects, & we rarely if ever know them all in advance.
Eric Boodman
@EricBoodman
The genetic variant given to the famous CRISPR babies is, it turns out, “probably not a mutation that most people would want to have. You are actually, on average, worse off having it."
www.statnews.com/2019/06/03/crispr-babies-scientist-pushe… -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
There’s Evidence on How to Raise Children, but Are Parents Listening? www.nytimes.com/2019/05/23/upshot/babies-evidence-parenti…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It’s Not Always the End of the World. Beware of politicians & activists who always cry “crisis!”: often a pretext to grab power or impose extremism. www.nytimes.com/2019/05/22/opinion/trump-lincoln-politica…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Erica Chenoweth's work on nonviolent protest movements (2X as successful in changing regimes as violent ones) is the most interesting finding on violence I've seen since Better Angels came out in '11. www.bbc.com/future/story/20190513-it-only-takes-35-of-peo… via @BBC_Future
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
RIP George Kelling, theorist of "broken windows" and "community" policing (not to be confused with zero-tolerance policing), partly responsible for the astonishing 85% drop in NYC homicide since 1990. www.city-journal.org/community-policing
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
AND altruism toward strangers is more common in individualistic societies. Forget the conventional op-ed moralizing on how modernity is making us selfish alienated atomized amoral materialistic isolated narcissistic blah blah blah. @aa_marsh
NPR
@NPR
More individualistic does not necessarily mean more selfish, says psychologist and guest commentator Abigail Marsh (@aa_marsh). www.npr.org/sections/13.7/2018/02/05/581873428/could-a-mo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Sex Differences in Brain and Behavior: Eight Counterpoints | Psychology Today www.psychologytoday.com/blog/sexual-personalities/201904/…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What Light Does 'Three Identical Strangers' Throw on the Nature/Nurture Debate? quillette.com/2019/03/26/what-light-does-three-identical-… via @Quillette
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Nuclear Power Can Save the World: My op-ed, posted a few minutes ago in the New York Times, with Joshua Goldstein and Staffan Qvist. www.nytimes.com/2019/04/06/opinion/sunday/climate-change-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Curiosity is Sacred by Megan Gafford. areomagazine.com/2019/03/29/curiosity-is-sacred/ via @areomagazine
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Seventeen years after I wrote The Blank Slate, the dogma remains strong: NYT op-ed claims boys are socialized to be rougher than girls, despite cross-cultural universality, presence in other species, sensitivity to prenatal testosterone, adult punishment.. www.nytimes.com/2019/03/30/opinion/sunday/boys-men-violen…
Post not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
And: A New Study Blows Up Old Ideas About Girls and Boys | Psychology Today www.psychologytoday.com/blog/sax-sex/201903/new-study-blo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Denying the Neuroscience of Sex Differences quillette.com/2019/03/29/denying-the-neuroscience-of-sex-… via @Quillette
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
During 7 decades in which our lives got longer, richer, safer, healthier, better educated, more peaceful, & more stimulating, news coverage got increasingly negative (graph from Enlightenment Now, data from Kalev Leetaru):
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
90 Reasons to consider cellular agriculture. stacks.stanford.edu/file/druid:dk858kp7009/90 Reasons.pdf
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Historians Uncover Lost Socrates Dialogues Where He Just Gave Up And Started Screaming That Opponent A Fucking Brainwashed Shill (Onion satire). www.theonion.com/historians-uncover-lost-socrates-dialogu… via @theonion
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Another essay on why the SAT is the most egalitarian criterion for college admissions. www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/no-one-likes-the-sat-its-s…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Americans Are Divided by Racial Ideology, Not Race Itself. Anti-African American sentiment is rare in all blocs (including White Trumpists). Minority voters are more moderate on racial issues than white progressives. www.nytimes.com/2019/03/18/opinion/race-america-trump.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Must change be slow? Not always www.positive.news/society/must-change-always-be-slow/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Solar geoengineering seems like the crackbrained scheme of a mad scientist, and cannot solve climate change without massive reduction in CO2 emissions. But my colleague David Keith shows that moderate amounts could help, and without adverse local effects. www.seas.harvard.edu/news/2019/03/finding-right-dose-for-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
No Hate Left Behind: Tom Edsall explores the evolutionary psychology of political tribalism, & why it’s increasing, with quotes from me, Peter DeScioli, Rob Kurzban, Jon Haidt, Leda Cosmides, John Tooby, others. www.nytimes.com/2019/03/13/opinion/hate-politics.html
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Birthrates Among Hispanic Americans Have Plummeted - like all traditionally fecund demographics (e.g., Muslims; Americans) as they become more urban, educated, and female-empowered. www.nytimes.com/2019/03/07/us/us-birthrate-hispanics-lati…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New study on the decline of war from Peace Research Institute Oslo @prio is important cause it doesn't test for a decline over centuries (no one has claimed that) but a breakpoint anywhere, & finds one: most likely Korean War. www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/the-world-has-become-more-… via @LondonEconomic
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Romantic Idea of a Plentiful Past Is Pure Fantasy: The evidence does not support Hickel’s assertion that people in the past “lived well” without much monetary income. humanprogress.org/article.php?p=1737 #humanprogressdata
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Pleased (and surprised) to see that I have surpassed half a million followers on Twitter.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A Colorado state judge sees an American epidemic of overly long prison sentences, including his own sentence of 146 years for a teenage armed robber. www.wsj.com/articles/a-judge-on-the-injustice-of-americas… via @WSJ
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
This superb essay is in response to a Guardian op-ed which, in ignorance (or defiance) of a massive amount of historical scholarship and economic analysis, tried to argue that global poverty has increased. A triumph of scholarship over ideology.
Max Roser
@MaxCRoser
How do we know the share of the world population in extreme poverty declined over the last centuries?
There is a lot of confusion about this important historical research. @JoeHasell and I summarize the methods and findings of historians in this new post.
ourworldindata.org/extreme-history-methods -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why Fears of Fake News Are Overhyped by @BrendanNyhan link.medium.com/ik668yCu2T (one of the researchers I cite in my recent Vox and Quillette articles)
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A Sensible Climate Change Solution, Borrowed From Sweden www.nytimes.com/2019/02/05/books/review/bright-future-jos…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Honoured to join the Advisory Board of the Party of Humanists in Germany @DieHumanisten
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The political systems of many countries need an infusion of new ideas and people, guided by the Enlightenment ideal of progress and drawing on our best science and most comprehensive data. The Party of Humanists is an idea whose time has come,
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature (2002/2016). 16+ years later, the case that there is such a thing as human nature still needs to be made. stevenpinker.com/publications/blank-slate
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Wise, graceful reflection on aging by psychologist Mary Pipher. www.nytimes.com/2019/01/12/opinion/sunday/women-older-hap…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
1. Reverse-engineer what you read. If it feels like good writing, what makes it good? If it’s awful, why?
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Watch this space: On Monday my article "Enlightenment Wars" will be published, with my reply to the Top 11 criticisms of Enlightenment Now, a year after it was published (and timed with the paperback release) stevenpinker.com/publications/enlightenment-now-case-reas…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
18 striking findings from 2018 from the Pew Research Center. pewrsr.ch/2ErUjHI
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An extraordinary essay, among the most important you'll read this year: 99 Good News Stories You Probably Didn’t Hear About in 2018 by @angushervey Not feel-good human interest tales, but substantive gains in conservation, peace, human rights, health, etc link.medium.com/3DhtYabgTS
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Contrary to popular belief, birth order has no effect on personality (& only a small average effect on intelligence). www.pnas.org/content/112/46/14224
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Another sign of secularization: Even those who call themselves religious talk less about God. Religions are becoming tribal & political, not creeds about the supernatural. www.nytimes.com/2018/10/13/opinion/sunday/talk-god-spritu…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It used to be worse: Between 1830 and 1860, there were 70 violent brawls between congressmen. www.nytimes.com/2018/09/24/books/review/field-of-blood-jo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Britannica Marks 250 Years with Commemorative Book Highlighting Knowledge Evolution; Unique Compilation from a Brand That Has Documented Knowledge for Over Two Centuries story.cd/AAJ2sN via @PRWeb
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Sh*t matters: Human waste managements a modern miracle that we (in the 1st world) take for granted. A UN Sustainable Dev Goal: eliminate open defecation by 2030. @HumanProgress humanprogress.org/article.php?p=1442 #humanprogressdata
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Grasping at straws: Why "performative, scolding environmentalism [e.g., banning plastic straws] that is disconnected from the scale of the problems it claims to address" is not an effective way of meeting environmental challenges. thebreakthrough.org/index.php/voices/grasping-at-straws
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Contrary to reports of a "suicide epidemic," global suicide rates have been in decline for 25 years. ourworldindata.org/grapher/suicide-death-rate-by-age
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
When talent and drive become more important than privilege in a society, education and occupational status will be increasingly correlated with genetic differences: New evidence from pre- and post-Soviet Estonia. | Nature Human Behaviour www.nature.com/articles/s41562-018-0332-5
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"A.I. Is Harder Than You Think": Beyond the usual hype, a penetrating analysis by experts @GaryMarcus and Ernest Davis. www.nytimes.com/2018/05/18/opinion/artificial-intelligenc…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
What can chimp calls tell us about human language? That language probably evolved after the evolutionary split: Calls aren’t words. Expert Michael Wilson explains. @ConversationUS po.st/xfhRDs via @SmithsonianMag
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The science of trolling, shaming mobs, and other online bad behavior. www.positive.news/2018/science/32375/why-good-people-turn… via @positivenewsuk
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Recursive photograph of the late Morris Halle & his longtime (60+ years) collaborator & colleague Noam Chomsky. By Tim Halle, taken at 50th anniversary celebration of MIT's Linguistics & Philosophy Department.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A Billionaire and a Nurse Shouldn’t Pay the Same Fine for Speeding www.nytimes.com/2018/03/15/opinion/flat-fines-wealthy-poo…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Anna Rosling Ronnlund: Luminous TED talk on how the world lives, organized by incomd (her "Dollar Street"). ted.com/talks/anna_rosling_ronnlund_see_how_the_rest_of_t… via @TEDTalks
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Steven Pinker: Identity Politics Is 'An Enemy of Reason and Enlightenment Values'. New & original interview - not just an overview of the book. tws.io/2F6zWO2 via @WeeklyStandard
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
There is no “Loneliness Epidemic” - Social critics are too quick to cry “crisis” after an anecdote or dubious study. (Data are reviewed in Enlightenment Now.) www.nytimes.com/2018/02/09/opinion/sunday/loneliness-heal…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
We're Number 18! Again the US underperforms vs its rich-country peers on the Social Progress Index. Politics should skip left vs right cliches and open-mindedly see which policies make people best off. www.socialprogressindex.com
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I collect ambiguous headlines. This one, on our President's health, is among the best.
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Revealed: What the world's billionaires are reading www.arabianbusiness.com/gallery/387692-revealed-what-the-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Fifty leading psychologists in the world today. How many do you know? thebestschools.org/features/most-influential-psychologist… #psychology #psychologist #list
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Stop saying 2017 (like 2016) was the worst year ever. Notwithstanding you-know-who, Marian Tupy's humanprogress.org recounts 82 amazing developments of the year. humanprogress.org/blog/the-worlds-getting-better-all-the-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard professors share the one book every student should read in 2018 read.bi/2Cha7YO via @bi_strategy
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Today is Human Rights Day, a time to celebrate one of humanity's greatest accomplishments, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (thank you, Eleanor), and to keep up the pressure on tinpot dictators and autocratic thugs. www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?NewsID=58253
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Keep Harvard Square quirky: Sign the petition. SUPPORT LANDMARK DESIGNATION FOR THE HARVARD SQUARE KIOSK - Sign the... chn.ge/2z6R8iA via @Change
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why your mental map of the US economy is probably wrong (more evidence that Trumpism is cultural, not economic). www.bostonglobe.com/business/2017/11/13/your-map-economy-… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Beauty and the Brain: The Emerging Field of Neuroaesthetics | Featuring Nancy Etcoff & others. in The Harvard Crimson www.thecrimson.com/article/2017/11/10/neuroaesthetics-cover/
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Cheap sex and the decline of marriage (an implication of sexual selection as applied to humans). www.wsj.com/articles/cheap-sex-and-the-decline-of-marriag… via @WSJ
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
An Open Letter to the media from crime experts regarding rampage shooters: Don't Name Them, Don't Show Them. drive.google.com/file/d/0B4Z7VkWcwLk-SjFJc00tdmI1eW8/view
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Playing for Freedom (highlights of the Oslo Freedom Forum in NY #offinny )www.nationalreview.com/node/451524
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A deep and trenchant analysis: Manifesto Against the Enemies of Modernity, by James Lindsay & Helen Pluckrose areomagazine.com
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Scientific Amer claims that women’s rights depend on denying 2 sexes, sex diffs. Bad science, bad moral reasoning. goo.gl/N2yXcn
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
I took the Pro-Truth Pledge! protruthpledge.org #protruthpledge via @ProTruthPledge
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
It's a really bad idea to tell students words are violence, @JonHaidt and @glukianoff write www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2017/07/why-its-a-b…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Lovely graphic rendition of a quote of mine by @oballous
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The Trump Administration’s War on Science www.nytimes.com/2017/03/27/opinion/the-trump-administrati…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
"I'm not an optimist. I'm a serious possibilist." NYT obit of the great Hans Rosling. www.nytimes.com/2017/02/09/world/europe/hans-rosling-dead…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Remembering Hans Rosling: Perhaps the best TED talk, ever. www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_reveals_new_insights_on_po… via @TEDTalks
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Top Academics Lash Out at Trump's 'Un-American' Immigration Order - Scientific American www.scientificamerican.com/article/top-academics-lash-out…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Most people think the world is getting worse. They're wrong. The history of progress in 5 charts. Our World In Data ourworldindata.org/a-history-of-global-living-conditions
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Lecture invitation to Jim Watson rescinded because of remarks about race he made in 2007 whyevolutionistrue.wordpress.com/2016/09/07/lecture-invit… via @Evolutionistrue
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Clinton, Trump, and why the media are failing us in 2016 www.bostonglobe.com/opinion/2016/09/06/hillary-clinton-do… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Harvard Republican Club Refuses to Endorse Trump. Good summary - if we needed one - on the whole apalling travesty. medium.com/next-right/harvard-republican-club-refuses-to-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Mass Killings May Have Created Contagion, Feeding on Itself www.nytimes.com/2016/07/27/science/mass-killings-contagio…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Some correctives to the media data-blindness: Shootings of cops down, not up; No race difference in who cops shoot. www.bbc.com/news/magazine-36826297
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Want to write better? Read better writing. (Correlational, but consistent w advice in Chap 1 of The Sense of Style.) www.bostonglobe.com/lifestyle/2016/05/30/want-write-bette…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Students, colleagues, alumni, commentators: Apalled by new Harvard policy. whyevolutionistrue.wordpress.com/2016/05/13/harvard-punis… via @Evolutionistrue
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
If everything is getting better, why doesn’t it feel that way? | Matthew d’Ancona gu.com/p/4fctq/stw
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The mystery of tetrachromacy: If 12% of women have 4 cone types, why do so few see extra colors? theneurospherecom.wordpress.com/2015/12/17/the-mystery-of… via @sofia_deleniv
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why is everyone so sure about what ISIS wants? Terrorism expert Max Abrahms explains. hbr.org/2015/11/why-people-keep-saying-thats-what-the-ter…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
O Canada! The Freest Nation in the World, study says. t.usnews.com/Zet2a7?src=usn_tw via usnews
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The strange, potent, and misunderstood ties of kinship. www.newrepublic.com/article/77729/strangled-roots
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Speaking today at the Intelligence Society for Intelligence Research, Albuquerque, New Mexico. September 18-20 isironline.org/2014/12/2015-albuquerque-new-mexico-septem…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Moral/spiritual values are the main cause of violence, not resources. Cash allows compromise; sacred values don't. www.nytimes.com/2015/06/08/world/middleeast/profit-as-an-…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
A beautiful reflection on mortality by a great man. www.nytimes.com/2015/02/19/opinion/oliver-sacks-on-learni…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
My op-ed is out: "Why free speech is fundamental" www.bostonglobe.com/opinion/2015/01/26/why-free-speech-fu… via @BostonGlobe
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Why does the Center for Disease Control approve of genital mutilation? www.academia.edu/9603843/Do_the_benefits_of_male_circumci…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
New podcast: Steven Pinker: Using Grammar as a Tool, Not as a Weapon - Point of Inquiry www.pointofinquiry.org/steven_pinker_using_grammar_as_a_t… via @pointofinquiry
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Do you find "chemical imbalance" a shallow explanation of depression? A more thoughtful theory goo.gl/CxQiEY goo.gl/Md9lOy
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
How NOT to strengthen the humanities: Double down on insularity & paranoia: on.tnr.com/1804R5M
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Noble savage myth strikes again-Jared Diamond has data on his side; Surv Int confuses human rights with factual claims www.theguardian.com/books/2013/feb/03/jared-diamond-clash…
-
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Despite Colorado shootings, US gun ownership is DOWN tiny.cc/pnruhw.

















































































































































































