Growing up, I remember having to challenge extremists like Al-Muhajiroun, who would label those of us attending and organising events like an open Iftar — where people of all faiths (Christians, Jews, Hindus, Sikhs, Muslims of all sectarian denominations, and more) and those without a faith were welcome — as non-believing “Kuffars”, un-Islamically integrating into a “kuffar system.”
Many of us spent years battling those extremist ideas, including personally leading many campaigns and debates to prevent them poisoning young minds.
Their message was simple: Islam was incompatible with a pluralistic western liberal democracy like Britain. For them, you could not be a believing Muslim and a proud Briton, engaging actively in society and holding shared British values. They were wrong, and those who now echo their narratives are wrong too.
Their approach relied on online preaching with no link to the rich history of classical Islamic scholarship, where debate, disagreement and pluralism flourished. For them, it was one way, their extreme hate-filled narratives or you were out of the folds of faith. Young people, unfortunately without a true grasp of the faith’s depth, would fall prey to these simplistic, rhetoric-filled slogans with no foundation or premise in the actual faith of Islam. Years of effort by global scholars, organisations and Muslim communities struggled to tackle these narratives. Their remnants no doubt still remain, but they have most definitely been pushed to the peripheries.
However, today another group is propagating a version of Islam that the likes of Anjem Choudary would nod along to. Many may call me naive, but whilst there will no doubt be bad faith actors, I believe many pseudo-intellectuals have had no real interaction with Muslim scholarship, its rich history and tradition, or any genuine connection to Muslim communities. In such ignorance or misunderstanding, they find themselves aligned in thought with those they claim to be challenging.
Many of us, including the Mayor of London, have spent our lives standing firm that there is no contradiction between our faith and our national identity. That being British and being Muslim can be one and the same. Being a follower of Islam does not diminish our loyalties, our pride, or our deep love for who we are as Britons. Our engagement across a pluralist society, in democracy, in the rule of law, in Britishness itself, holds no incoherence.
Experience has shown that whilst it is virtually impossible to convince bad faith actors or those hate-filled puritans not open to fair intellectual dialogue, however, there are always those who have sadly fallen down the rabbit hole of a simplistic and misappropriated version of any faith or belief.
To those open to discussion, genuine dialogue and critique, who may feel the premise being put forward has merit - I say: let’s discuss, debate, and perhaps even come and see an open Iftar for yourself.
This isn’t about prayer in a public space. This is about rejecting a false portrayal of Muslim identity, one that is not only intellectually bankrupt, but does the very work of the extremists we have long fought against.