There is certainly one fundamental point in @javeednusrat Sahib’s argument that deserves consideration: if today, in the context of a long march or sit-in by one political party, the court lays down the principle that the lives, livelihoods, movement, and fundamental rights of ordinary citizens cannot be affected, then tomorrow the same principle can also be applied to the long march of another party, including the Pakistan Peoples Party.
But, in my view, the issue goes one step further.
The real issue is that the very tradition of protesting in Pakistan by blocking roads, paralysing cities, and holding ordinary citizens hostage should come to an end.
Whether it is Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf, the Pakistan Peoples Party, the Pakistan Muslim League, the Muttahida Qaumi Movement, or any other political party, political disagreement is their right, protest is their democratic right, and raising their voice is also their right; but making the lives of ordinary citizens a living hell is no one’s right.
At present, the common man is already struggling under unbearable inflation, unemployment, electricity bills, business difficulties, and economic pressure. Why should he have to bear the consequences of politicians’ battles? A father leaves home to seek employment for his child, a patient tries to reach a hospital, a student goes to take an examination, and a labourer goes out to earn his daily wage. When the roads of all these people are blocked, whose public interest is ultimately being defended?
The time has now come to find new and modern methods of protest. When political parties can use social media, digital platforms, live streaming, online campaigns, public venues, and other modern means to promote their narratives, why can’t they also adopt methods of protest that do not paralyse the functioning of the state and the lives of ordinary citizens?
Democracy does not mean that a few hundred or a few thousand people should bring the lives of millions of citizens to a standstill in order to demonstrate their political power.
The road belongs to the public; it is not the private property of any political party.
By all means, protest. By all means, criticise the government. Go to the courts, raise your voice in parliament, run campaigns through the media and social media, and hold large public gatherings—but choose a course of action in which your political right remains protected while the ordinary person’s right to live, work, travel, and provide for his children is also protected.
Pakistan does not need the politics of protest; it needs civilised and modern methods of protest.
And this principle should be applied equally to everyone—today to Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf, tomorrow to the Pakistan Peoples Party, and thereafter to any other political party.