If you're looking for free entertainment next Thursday night, you can register with the University of Utah S.J. Quinney College of Law to see UVA Prof. Sai Prakash and me debate unitary executive theory. The program starts at 5:30 MST/7:30 EST. utahlaw-uofu.nbsstore.net/the-41st-annual-jefferson-b-for…
Peter M. Shane
Peter Milo Shane (born 1952) is an American legal scholar and writer. He is currently the Jacob E. Davis and Jacob E. Davis II Chair in Law Emeritus at the Moritz College of Law at The Ohio State University, where he taught from 2003-2021.[1] Since 2022, he has been a Distinguished Scholar in Residence and Adjunct Professor at the New York University School of Law. [2] As an academic, Shane is best known for his writings in constitutional and administrative law, with a special focus on issues of executive power and democracy. Political scientists William G. Howell and Terry M. Moe have credited Shane, along with Bruce Ackerman, as having “the insight and analytics, early in the game, to see the authoritarian threat” latent in the late-20th/early-21st century U.S. presidency. [3] Shane’s 2009 book, Madison’s Nightmare, described and analyzed the theory and practice of "presidentialism" as executive branch lawyers advanced increasingly aggressive theories of presidential power from 1981 to 2009. [4] He argued that their theories were rooted in a view of constitutional originalism that mistakenly attributes to the Founding generation a theory of presidential power that history does not support. Shane expanded on his argument in the 2022 book, Democracy’s Chief Executive: Interpreting the Constitution and Defining the Future of the Presidency. [5] The latter volume offered a yet more general critique of originalism as a method of constitutional interpretation, while arguing that, even taken on its own terms, originalism does not support the unitary executive theory that undergirds the presidentialist jurisprudence of the current Roberts Court. More on Wikipedia
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For the Regulatory Review's annual set of essays on the prior Supreme Court Term, I catalogue the FTC removal case's flaws and expand on the Court's obliviousness to institutional consequence and its pretense that their unanimous predecessors were idiots: www.theregreview.org/2026/07/20/shane-article-ii-removal-…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Slaughter is the ultimate legal triumph of Reaganite unitary executive theory. It joins other Roberts Court decisions that limit the permissible range and impact of the exercise of legislative power. washingtonmonthly.com/2026/06/30/the-roberts-court-and-th…. The Atlantic piece on UET is: www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/06/ultimate-triumph-unitar….
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The surprise is it took so long.
Jonathan H. Adler
@jadler1969
The Court's denial of certiorari in the Carroll case should surprise no one.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Last month, I published an essay on the conservative divide over "major questions doctrine" in Trump's tariff loss, and how it might defeat his civil service shenanigans. I am grateful to Touro Law for inviting me to share the thoughts in podcast form. www.youtube.com/watch?v=_1OVY5hNhx8&list=PLp2wqnnrHcMPfIw…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Washington Monthly
@monthly
The Supreme Court rebuke of Trump tariffs might mean serious problems for other Trump initiatives, like gutting the civil service. Much depends on the Court’s internal fight over the “major questions doctrine,” @petermshane writes.
washingtonmonthly.com/2026/03/18/how-the-supreme-courts-l… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The logic behind the use of the major questions doctrine in Trump's tariff loss suggests that the three conservatives who joined the liberal Justices in denying POTUS tariff power should also oppose his attempts to politicize the civil service. washingtonmonthly.com/2026/03/18/how-the-supreme-courts-l…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Turns out the surge at the border started before Biden and receded before Trump 2.0. And the shifts happen too early to suggest that migrants were anticipating a change in the next election. Fact Checking the “Success” of Trump Border Patrol Policies at www.justsecurity.org/130422/fact-check-trump-border-policy/
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Something about the Fed seems to put the Roberts Court in a pragmatic mood. I wish it were equally attentive to the institutional dangers of applying its unitary executive narrative to the rest of government. Today's @monthly essay: washingtonmonthly.com/2026/02/03/trumps-firing-of-a-fed-g…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My July @monthly essay on the bipartisan embrace of presidential unilateralism in deploying military force explains how political practice has eviscerated the Framers' emphasis on interbranch deliberation as a constitutional precondition for warmaking. washingtonmonthly.com/2025/07/03/trumps-bombing-iran-and-…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Not that I'm expecting it, but I explain in Washington Monthly why upholding Congress's power to create independent multimember agencies could coexist with the Roberts Court's other holdings on POTUS removal power and would enhance the Court's legitimacy. washingtonmonthly.com/2026/01/02/save-humphreys-executor-…
Washington Monthly
@monthly
A modest proposal for how the justices can do the right thing and be true to themselves as they decide the fate of independent agencies. From @petermshane:
washingtonmonthly.com/2026/01/02/save-humphreys-executor-… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
SCOTUS has let stand the bar to Trump's use of the National Guard for law enforcement in Illinois. As I mentioned recently in @monthly, the Court has an easier time policing Trump's overreading of statutes than his simply disobeying or ignoring them.
www.documentcloud.org/documents/26438519-25a443-order/ -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Perhaps fitting in this season of year-end wrap-ups, I published an essay in @monthly trying to sum up how the Roberts Court throughout 2025 has been enabling Trump’s assault on the constitutionally intended distribution of government powers. washingtonmonthly.com/2025/12/15/how-the-roberts-court-in…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
From today's @nytimes
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Appreciate your recommendation, but we don’t predict that the Court will uphold the tariffs.
Sougat Chakraborty
@sougat18
Interesting commentary from @BrookingsInst by @petermshane @BobLitan on Legal and economic aspects of the Supreme Court’s upcoming tariff decisions.
They make an argument that the "Supreme Court is likely to hold that the tariffs are lawful and the economic consequences, regardless of the judicial outcome".
The most interesting aspects, which is noteworthy and should be highlighted, are:
1. Even if the Court upholds the lower courts’ rulings against the president, he likely has the requisite authority under other trade laws essentially to reimpose the IEEPA tariffs going forward, albeit with some procedural speedbumps. The only immediate, major consequence if the president loses these cases is that his administration will have to rebate roughly $130 billion in tariff duties by the end of the year. The amount could be higher if the Court issues its decision thereafter.
2. The immediate economic impact of the Trump tariffs, under whatever authority they are issued, is also modest in the short run, mainly because there has been little retaliation, relative to the extensive retaliation in response to the Smoot-Hawley tariffs during the Depression.
3. The one exception to watch, however, is whether and to what extent China sharply reduces exports of rare earth minerals down the road, once the recently negotiated truce on that issue between the U.S. and China expires. That could have a noticeable impact not only on the U.S. economy generally but also on our defence industries and thus national security.
Conclusion:
The economic effects of the Supreme Court’s decision about the reach of the IEEPA may prove marginal at most, depending on how far the administration goes in imposing tariffs pursuant to other statutory authorities. It will be the legal precedent and the Court’s rationale that will matter most to the overall trajectory of presidential power. The scope of authority the Court reads into the IEEPA, the degree of deference the Court does or does not give to presidential fact-finding, and anything the Court might say about the future of the nondelegation doctrine will all be of keen interest.
www.brookings.edu/articles/legal-and-economic-aspects-of-… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Brookings has posted a paper by @BobLitan and me on tomorrow's tariff cases. We think challengers have the better case, long-term economic implications are limited, but that these will be important developments in shaping the trajectory of executive power. www.brookings.edu/articles/legal-and-economic-aspects-of-…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Enjoyed talking to Michael Popok on a new Legal AF episode about the Supreme Court’s inaction on ICE racial profiling and the state of separation of powers law in the Roberts Court. youtu.be/HKBxBP_ftrM (I don’t title the episodes!)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Planning weekend podcast listening? The latest @monthly podcast features my talk with fellow law prof Garrett Epps on Justice Kavanaugh's recent opinion justifying the lifting of a stay against ICE raids in LA based on racial profiling. washingtonmonthly.com/2025/09/24/the-supreme-court-greenl…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The Roberts Court rejects race-based decision making in affirmative action plans. In ICE raids, not so much. My take in @monthly on SCOTUS’s latest stay of a lower court injunction: washingtonmonthly.com/2025/09/10/supreme-court-blocks-rel…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
George Washington did not establish the Department of War. Congress did. And now a few words from the War of 1812. . .
Acyn
@Acyn
Hegseth: After winning a war for Independence in 1789, George Washington established the war department. This country won every major war after that. To include World War I and World War II. Total victory. !50 years after that, we changed the name. We haven’t won a major war since.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/2 The Stanford Law Review Online has just published an essay I co-wrote with my friend and casebook co-editor, UVA law professor Aditya Bamzai. He and I disagree on how to interpret the Constitution . . . www.stanfordlawreview.org/online/the-removal-question-a-t…
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
2/2 with regard to the President’s removal powers. Stanford asked us to write what they call an “adversarial collaboration” on the topic, i.e., an “essay to clarify points of agreement, precisely identify areas of disagreement, and engage with the evidence supporting each side.”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
“Trump’s use of executive power is not a distortion of the Roberts Court’s theory of the presidency; it is the Court’s theory of the presidency, brought to life.” My take in the Atlantic. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2025/07/supreme-court-r…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"In 2025, however, no one in authority takes war powers originalism seriously. The remaining institutional constraint—politics—is, for now, not even a speed bump slowing a belligerent president." My take on what bombing Iran reveals about war powers. washingtonmonthly.com/2025/07/03/trumps-bombing-iran-and-…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In a crossover episode of @demchiefexecpod, I go from host to guest. @LindsayLangholz, @acslaw Sr. Dir. of Policy & Program and host of the ACS podcast, Broken Law, asked about Trump’s independent agency firings and the shaky future of checks and balances. open.spotify.com/episode/0juJYH3yHAbyPEthOzTtqC
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The Supreme Court’s combination of glib history and hubris continues to fuel an executive-indulgent constitutional jurisprudence at odds with both text and political reality.
Washington Monthly
@monthly
Read @petermshane's explainer:
washingtonmonthly.com/2025/06/04/another-supreme-court-bl… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Pleased to be quoted in this story on Trump's efforts to "deregulate" by ignoring the law. As usual, the novelty is in the scope of Trump's lawlessness. Anything others did occasionally, he will do systematically. "Obama jaywalked? Let's do armed robbery!" www.washingtonpost.com/nation/2025/05/18/trump-enforcemen…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Attached is the letter signed by Ohio State Moritz College of Law faculty, in their individual capacities, in light of current threats to constitutional democracy and the rule of law in the U.S.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
On 3/12 I debated Aditya Bamzai of UVA on, “Does the Law Provide for a Unitary Executive?” at Harvard. From 20:27 to 29:22, I argue originalism is unsound, text and history favor checks and balances, and a modest UET was bound to metastasize à la Trump. youtu.be/3NEpMm-wGWw
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If you’re wondering what unitary executive theory is, how an extreme version is enabling Trump, why constitutional text doesn’t align with it, and where we might be headed, here’s the link to my 3/10 conversation with Tom Gerety about the issues. youtu.be/ynEclhsYXbs
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/2 Trump's EO attacking independent regulatory agencies and Congress's power to create them is unitary executive theory run amok. I have 2 new essays today on the resulting threat to checks and balances. One focuses on how Trump differs from predecessors. washingtonmonthly.com/2025/03/03/trump-escalates-his-war-…
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
2/2 My 2d essay today on Trump's order on independent agencies explains how unitary executive theory distorts constitutional text and licenses authoritarianism. www.theregreview.org/2025/03/03/shane-the-unbearable-ligh… Both essays pin blame on how John Roberts characterized POTUS' powers June's immunity opinion.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Proud to be among 950+ law professors signing a letter organized by BC law prof @Kentgreenfield1 for @acslaw challenging the rampant illegality of the Trump Administration. A post at www.acslaw.org/press_release/more-than-950-law-scholars-s… contains a link to the letter and its signatories.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If your copy of the Constitution is missing Article I, Section 8, cl. 18, a copy is available here: www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/articlei
California Is A 3rd World Country
@sailing1103
Congress funds and oversees the executive branch much like a Board of Directors. it does not dictate how the government operates.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The title of my essay published in The Atlantic is pretty much what I'd have thought to be a unanimous understanding of the Constitution: “Presidents May Not Unilaterally Dismantle Government Agencies.” Yet Trump's assault on checks and balances continues. www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2025/02/trump-cant-dism…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I had the privilege yesterday of being interviewed by Mitch Jeserich for the Letters & Politics program on Pacifica's KPFA radio. We discussed the history of executive power as interpreted by the Supreme Court and how we got to the present moment. kpfa.org/program/letters-and-politics/
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Jordan Ascher of Governing for Impact and I explain in today's @monthly what's wrong with Trump's Schedule F scheme. As the subhead says: "It violates statutes, undoes a century of civil service reform, and would derail government services." washingtonmonthly.com/2025/02/10/trumps-schedule-f-plan-f…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I urge in @monthly that progressives opposed to the Trump-Musk regime's abuses now turn to courts with the same energy and creativity that Red States brought to bear against Biden. washingtonmonthly.com/2025/02/04/to-save-democracy-start-…. Many have started. Just Security has a tracker: www.justsecurity.org/107087/tracker-legal-challenges-trum…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I actually give them points for candor.
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
Putting aside the normative issues, speaking merely as a student of politics, the American right could really use a dash of rhetorical subtlety. You’re not “abolishing the administrative state,” you’re protecting it from those who would corrupt it. You’re not “purging” DOJ, you’re restoring it to its true mission. Etc.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Trump’s early moves aim to bring under his control the levers of power that the Constitution gives Congress to support its role as a co-equal branch of government. Madison had a word for the system Trump would erect: tyranny. My latest in @monthly washingtonmonthly.com/2025/01/30/trumps-fusillade-of-tyra…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
To mark Inauguration Day, Brookings posted a new paper by Bob Litan and me on the improbability of Trump/DOGE fulfilling their deregulatory ambitions. There will be damage & misery inflicted by the new regime, but not as much as they hope. www.brookings.edu/articles/trumps-regulatory-housecleanin…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My critique of presidentialism was quoted today by . . . George Will. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/01/10/republicans-tr…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is truly one of your cruelest and most damnable lies.
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
These fires are easily avoidable, but nonsense regulations in California prevent action being taken, so year after year homes burn down and more people die
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Privileged to on this amicus brief, shepherded by @normeisen.bsky.social, urging SCOTUS to turn down Trump's application to stay sentencing in his hush money case. "Bipartisan" hardly covers the breadth of political views represented among the signatories. www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/24/24A666/336918/202501091…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My essay in @monthly urges support for lawyers trying to take on Trump 2.0 in the courts, but also ambitious efforts to organize journalists, activists, public interest groups and others around a bold reinvigoration of the regulatory state. washingtonmonthly.com/2025/01/05/reconstruct-the-administ…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Part of the antidote to the Trump/Musk/Ramaswamy shock and awe assault on the administrative state is spreading recognition of how much of their bravado is based on lies and half-truths. In @monthly @washingtonmonthly.bsky.social I dissect a dozen of them. washingtonmonthly.com/2024/12/09/musk-and-ramaswamys-doge…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Washington Monthly
@monthly
The Ted Olson I Knew by @petermshane. The acclaimed conservative attorney who championed the right to same-sex marriage and who died last week at 84 demonstrated the humane qualities we need now.
washingtonmonthly.com/2024/11/18/the-ted-olson-i-knew/ -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My X time probably nears an end. Squelching is afoot-it's a miracle if you see this. I still get good info here from folks who share my "priors" and from more conservative voices too, e.g., @kewhittington, @jacklgoldsmith, @jadler1969, @BillKristol. But the septic tank overflows.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I had hoped that the info shared in our @demchiefexecpod series on Project 2025 would help make the series irrelevant after the election. Alas, they may now help in seeing what’s coming. Our earliest episodes on law and the presidency also urgent. open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Waiting to see how this promise works out www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/watch-trump-promises-to-set…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The Biden economy he inherits will be the subject of his boasts on Inauguration Day, foreshadowing the great claims he’ll make for national reconstruction as the infrastructure projects teed up under Biden go forward.
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
My assumption is that Trump will do everything he can (through pressure, law, or whatever means) to juice the economy in the short term without concern for its overall harmful effects in the long term.
From 2018: www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/1824670/trump-shrugs-off-… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/20/25 should mark the launch of a Pete Buttigieg podcast.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In memory of the extraordinary #quincyjones, I have been unable to get "Billie Jean" out of my head since the moment I woke up today.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Apparently, in his mind, being the nephew of an MIT professor confirms a genetic basis for his stable genius intellect, but being the daughter of a tenured Stanford economist and a Ph. D. biomedical scientist . . .
Acyn
@Acyn
Trump: I have an uncle.. 41 years at MIT. Has so many degrees he did not know what to do with them all. In the most complicated— I understand a lot of this stuff. I believe in that. Jack Nicklaus is not going to produce a bad golfer. That is the way it works.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
To help with podcast selection in this weekend before the election, a schedule appears below of all episodes in the @demchiefexecpod series on Project 2025. All episodes available from virtually any platform from which you obtain your podcasts!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Why is @washingtonpost poll averaging more favorable for Harris than @nytimes poll averaging?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I remain optimistic (even if anxious) about next week. But, at the very least, I hope this misspeak by an extraordinarily good POTUS will at least spare us any, "We could have done better with Joe as a candidate" talk regardless of the outcome.
Joe Walsh
@WalshFreedom
5 thoughts on the Biden thing:
1. I don’t think he called Trump supporters “garbage.” I think he meant to call that Trump supporting comedian & some of the other ugly stuff that was said at MSG “garbage.”
2. Biden can’t communicate coherently. At all. So he shouldn’t be speaking. At all.
3. Kamala Harris has been nothing but gracious toward Trump supporters. She wants to be President for ALL Americans. She’s done nothing but preach unity, ending the hate, being respectful, and finding common ground between the two sides.
4. Trump is the greatest purveyor of hate in American politics today. Every single word out of his mouth is hate, fear, & division. Been that way for years.
5. So Trump supporters, quit whining about Biden. You’ve eagerly embraced the guy who said his political opponents are evil, who said they’re the “enemy within,” who just today said they’re “horrible people,” and who said he’ll use the military to go after his political opponents. Respectfully MAGA, get lost with your crocodile tears. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Trump says he’s “the opposite of a Nazi.” Technically, does that mean he’s Stalin?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If after Trump's MSG fiasco you're wondering what Project 2025 recommends on immigration and DEI policy, I recommend the @demchiefexecpod episodes called "Furthering the Anti-Immigration Agenda" open.spotify.com/episode/2C6wXoSFb6pzdUofPdGsOw & "Resisting the Nation's Diversity" open.spotify.com/episode/3tJOFaHWBXodsfOy4iD4Cu
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Punxsutawney Phil > Dr. Phil
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Did anyone foresee Tony #hinchcliffe as the James Comey of 2024?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This thoughtful, in some ways heartbreaking thread from @davidfrum is a perfect companion piece to Michelle Obama's exhortation to men at the @KamalaHarris Houston rally. He is speaking for, as well as to, many men, as well as women.
David Frum
@davidfrum
I posted the below last night in an emotional mood. It was answered by many generous comments in remembrance of my lost Miranda, and I thank every commenter. Of course there were also some other comments. A thread about those....
David Frum
@davidfrum
I dropped my ballot in the mailbox today. It was my signature on the form. But it was my daughter's vote I placed inside the envelope.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: For your weekend podcast listening, on Ep. 11 of the @DemChiefExecPod “Project 2025: Revealed” series, @GeorgetownLaw’s Mary McCord talked to @petermshane about dangers of direct White House control of the Justice Department. open.spotify.com/episode/730SZm6vevTdDdnrE6kDgI?nd=1&dlsi…. A clip appears below.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: For your weekend podcast listening, on Ep. 10 of the @DemChiefExecPod “Project 2025: Revealed” series, Brendan Duke explained to @petermshane the consequences for families if the Project’s tax recommendations became law. open.spotify.com/episode/5WESveswUXUBfVguPxACyW. A clip appears below.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: For your weekend podcast listening, on Ep. 9 of the @DemChiefExecPod “Project 2025: Revealed” series, @NYULaw’s Cynthia Estlund talked to @petermshane about the Project’s agenda on unions and labor policy. open.spotify.com/episode/5P18kTSdfKHBINTd6nsac4 A clip appears below.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I guess the courts having “neither force, nor will” isn’t fulfilling enough for some judges.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: For your weekend podcast listening, on Ep. 8 of the @DemChiefExecPod “Project 2025: Revealed” series, Angela Vallot and Mitchell Karp talked to @petermshane and Dale Russakoff about the Project’s demonization of DEI, open.spotify.com/episode/3tJOFaHWBXodsfOy4iD4Cu
A clip appears below. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: For your weekend podcast listening, on Ep. 7 of the @DemChiefExecPod “Project 2025: Revealed” series, Lisa Heinzerling of @GeorgetownLaw talked to @petermshane about the Project’s dangerous agenda on climate and environment. open.spotify.com/episode/1iaSV1nftbvwGe15P24h71 A clip appears below.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: For your weekend podcast listening, on Ep. 6 of the @DemChiefExecPod “Project 2025: Revealed” series, @rudalev talked to @petermshane about what a “dictator for a day” could and could not do through unilateral action. open.spotify.com/episode/2o64UABCensMGWKLxImfsr. A clip appears below.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: For your weekend podcast listening, on Ep. 5 of the @DemChiefExecPod “Project 2025: Revealed” series, Cristina Rodriguez talked to @petermshane and Dale Russakoff about the Project’s implausible, draconian immigration agenda. open.spotify.com/episode/2C6wXoSFb6pzdUofPdGsOw. A clip appears below.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: For your weekend podcast listening, on Ep. 4 of the @DemChiefExecPod “Project 2025: Revealed” series, Paul Verkuil and @petermshane discussed why the Project’s push for an obsequious civil service is not real civil service reform. open.spotify.com/episode/620kdgElbaozOavnrrDNDM Hear a clip below.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: For your weekend podcast listening, on Ep. 3 of the @DemChiefExecPod “Project 2025: Revealed” series, Diane Ravitch talked to @petermshane and Dale Russakoff about the Project’s destructive agenda for public education. open.spotify.com/episode/0UvstOT5EAGOrBVGJwrd3Q
A clip appears below. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: For your weekend podcast listening, on Ep. 2 of the @DemChiefExecPod “Project 2025: Revealed” series, Lynn Paltrow talked to @petermshane and Dale Russakoff about the Project’s dangerous agenda for reproductive rights. open.spotify.com/episode/6WS0Vqb9AmMXyTJw6xFxNg. A clip appears below.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Is it really controversial whether law students should become conversant with, i.e., able both to use and to critique, all approaches to constitutional interpretation that appear in Supreme Court opinions??
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Few parts of Project 2025 are as scary as its enthusiasm for a politicized justice dept. On the latest @demchiefexecpod, @GeorgetownLaw's Mary McCord talks to @petermshane about the dangers, intensified by SCOTUS’s current view of presidential immunity. open.spotify.com/episode/730SZm6vevTdDdnrE6kDgI?nd=1&dlsi…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
There seems to be a complete disconnect between how the CNN Professional Pundit panel reacted to @KamalaHarris (meh) and how the panel of voters responded (enthusiastically). Maybe the best gauge of voter reaction is . . . voter reaction?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I hope 7 of 9 voters agree!
Jeri Ryan
@JeriLRyan
SO EXCITED to cast my vote for @KamalaHarris & @Tim_Walz and Democrats up and down the ballot!
We are NOT GOING BACK! ✊🏼💙🇺🇸🗳️🇺🇸💙✊🏼
#harriswalz2024 #vote #voteblueThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Want to know how much Project 2025’s tax recommendations would cost your family if enacted? @Brendan_Duke breaks it down on a new @demchiefexecpod. As a bonus, he even explains who pays tariffs! open.spotify.com/episode/5WESveswUXUBfVguPxACyW
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Knocked one thing off my to-do list today!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is why we created a podcast series devoted to exploring Project 2025! Look for “Democracy’s Chief Executive—The Podcast” @DemChiefExecPod wherever you get your podcasts. www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/10/22/us/politics/projec… via @NYTimes
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"Trump’s performances over the past few days seem to confirm that the 2024 October surprise is the increasingly obvious mental incapacity of the Republican candidate....It seems clear that a vote for Trump is really a vote for ... Ohio senator J.D. Vance." open.substack.com/pub/heathercoxrichardson/p/october-19-2…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Wondering which Project 2025 chapter cites Genesis (and not the band)? On a new @DemChiefExecPod episode on "Project 2025: Revealed!" @nyulaw's Cynthia Estlund and @petermshane discuss the Project’s agenda for workers and unions. It's . . . different. open.spotify.com/episode/5P18kTSdfKHBINTd6nsac4?nd=1&dlsi…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It seems as if, almost irrespective of what I post, it is viewed 180-190 times only. Please let me know if you see this.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Among the many statements by Trump and his campaign I believe to be lies is that anyone associated with Project 2025 would be barred from a Trump 2.0 administration. Most of these authors worked on Trump 1.0 and he has no policy platform apart from theirs. open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In Episode 8 of the “Democracy’s Chief Executive: The Podcast” series, “Project 2025 Revealed!” leading #dei consultants Angela Vallot and Mitchell Karp talk to @petermshane and Dale Russakoff about the demonization of DEI and the #project2025 attack. open.spotify.com/episode/3tJOFaHWBXodsfOy4iD4Cu?nd=1&dlsi…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I know this is too much to hope for, but I fantasize that, with Sinwar gone, Israel sends a message through intermediaries to whatever's left of Hamas leadership that if they return the hostages now, a permanent cease-fire is up for discussion.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
On today’s new @DemChiefExecPod episode in the “Project 2025: Revealed!” series, @GeorgetownLaw prof Lisa Heinzerling talks to @petermshane about proposals to disempower the EPA and undermine the whole-of-government attack on accelerating climate change. open.spotify.com/episode/1iaSV1nftbvwGe15P24h71
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Somehow a lot of what Musk does—e.g., giving millions of bucks to support a candidate who has promised him a big government job (and contracts??)—seems at least corruption-adjacent.
Rick Hasen
@rickhasen
Requiring proof of voting in Pennsylvania to gain entrance to a speech could well violate federal law against vote buying. It is giving something of value in exchange for voting.
Elon Musk
@elonmusk
Tomorrow night through Monday, I will be giving a series of talks throughout Pennsylvania.
If you’d like to attend one of my talks, there’s no attendance fee. You just need to have signed our petition supporting free speech & right to bear arms & have voted in this election.
America
@america
Sign our petition in defense of YOUR Constitutional rights to Free Speech & Bear Arms!
Goal is to get 1M voters in swing states to sign this petition.
For each registered swing state voter you refer that signs the petition, you get $47!
petition.theamericapac.org -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Thanks, Dakota! I will always think of it as “the Mashaw book,” and a brand new edition should be available for spring adoptions.
Dakota Rudesill
@DakotaRudesill
the book by my colleague @petermshane is excellent
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is probably only the 74th weirdest thing about Trump’s town sway last night, but it seems odd that he played nothing by his biggest (only?) musician supporters. I mean, I wouldn’t listen to Ted Nugent either, but Kid Rock isn’t awful.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is a spectacular thread. Ackman’s likely takeaway: “Wow, I’m getting so much attention!”
Stuart Stevens
@stuartpstevens
Bill, saying you support the candidate who has promised to cut taxes for billionaires vs. the candidate who will raise taxes on billionaires, but you don't really support the tax cuts is a bit like the old "I read Playboy for the articles." But fine, let's assume you are convinced that all the benefits of a Trump presidency compensate for the burden of having your taxes cut. Let's look at your 33 reasons.
But first, let's dispense with the misty-eyed absurdity that you can vote for an openly racist Trump, but you'd like it known that you don't support racism. The ballot box isn't a cafeteria where you can go down the line and pick and choose what you like. If you vote for Trump, you are voting for a criminal out on bail who describes non-white immigrants with the same language as National Socialism described Jews. Don't pretend that by voting for Trump you get some pass because you insist that's not who you are. It may well not be who you are, but it is very much who Donald Trump is.
(1)open the borders to millions of immigrants who were not screened for their risk to the country, dumping them into communities where the new immigrants overwhelm existing communities and the infrastructure to support the new entrants, at the expense of the historic residents
Historic residents? What are you talking about here, Bill? The "historic residents" like my paternal grandfather's family that came to America in the 1700s or the "historic residents" like my maternal grandfather's family, who were Irish immigrants. Are you talking about the 'historic residents" of New York City before Ellis Island opened in 1892? Curious: How long have the Ackmans been "historic residents."
Perhaps you don't realize how referring to "historic residents" is the language of white supremist. Perhaps you are choosing to ignore that it was Donald Trump who killed the most aggressive border security reform in history. Perhaps you are unaware that Barack Obama deported more undocumented immigrants than Donald Trump. And perhaps you have missed that the current border crossings are lower than at the same point in 2020 under Donald Trump.
(2)introduce economic policies and massively increase spending without regard to their impact on inflation and the consequences for low-income Americans and the increase in our deficit and national debt
Perhaps you are unaware that the national debt increased more under Donald Trump than any non-wartime president in US history. Perhaps you do not realize that President Biden cut the deficit by $1.7 trillion in the first two years, the largest cut in US history.
Perhaps you have not read the multiple projections of how much another Trump presidency will increase the deficit. Here's a good start: washingtonpost.com/business/2024/10/07/trump-harris-natio…
(3)withdraw from Afghanistan, abandoning our local partners and the civilians who worked alongside us in an unprepared, overnight withdrawal that led to American casualties and destroyed the lives of Afghani women and girls for generations, against the strong advice of our military leadership, and thereafter not showing appropriate respect for their loss at a memorial ceremony in their honor,
It's accurate that President Biden honored the deal Donald Trump made with the Taliban. It's also accurate that more Americans died in Afghanistan under Trump than Biden. It's odd that you see Donald Trump as some positive alternative for the women of Afghanistan, as Trump insists that he has always opposed American efforts to fight the Taliban.
(4) introduce thousands of new and unnecessary regulations in light of the existing regulatory regime that interferes with our businesses' ability to compete, restraining the development of desperately needed housing, infrastructure, and energy production with the associated inflationary effects,
Republicans have used this line for years. But somehow, despite all these regulations that hurt business, the stock market is at record highs, and more Americans are working today than ever before. Perhaps you are unaware that Donald Trump is the first president since Herbert Hoover to leave office with fewer jobs than when he was inaugurated.
(5) modify the bail system so that violent criminals are released without bail,
Bill, I didn't make the Willie Horton ads, but I have made many ads accusing Democrats of being weak on crime. But if you trust FBI statistics – though you may agree with Donald Trump that they are just an arm of the Deep State – murders increased by 5,795, from 16,619 in 2019 to 22,414 in 2020.
The number of murders had never increased by more than 2,000 in a year, meaning that 2020's increase was nearly triple the previous record.
Under Biden, murders and other violent crimes have decreased.
(6) destroy our street retailers and communities and promote lawlessness by making shoplifting (except above large thresholds) no longer a criminal offense,
What in the world are you talking about, Bill? Can you find a quote from VP Harris advocating decriminalizing shoplifting? Perhaps you are confusing California, where a referendum passed in 2014 that reduced jail sentences for shoplifting under $950, with Texas, where the limit is $2,500.
(7) limit and/or attempt to limit or ban fracking and LNG so that U.S. energy costs increase substantially, and the U.S. loses its energy independence,
VP Harris has stated she is not opposed to fracking. But if you want to point to the Biden-Harris administration record, as Donald Trump likes to do, oil production is higher today than at any point in US history. We are now the largest oil exporter in the world.
(8) promote DEI ideologies that award jobs, awards, and university admissions on the basis of race, sexual identity and gender criteria, and teach our students and citizens that the world can only be understood as an unfair battle between oppressors and the oppressed, where the oppressors are only successful due to structural racism or a rigged system and the oppressed are simply victims of an unfair system and world
While a case can be made for the sort of diversity and equity approach that enabled J.D. Vance to be selected at Yale as a disadvantaged applicant, this idea that a Harris Administration will usher in a DEI Dark Ages is best left to the pages of the Daily Stormer, where the case is frequently articulated.
, (9) educate our elementary children that gender is fluid, something to be chosen by a child, and promote hormone blockers and gender reassignment surgeries to our youth without regard to the longer-term consequences to their mental and physical health, and allow biological boys and men to compete in girls and women's sports, depriving girls and women of scholarships, awards, and other opportunities that they would have rightly earned otherwise,
Bill, relax, no one is coming for your gender identity under a Harris presidency. You are confusing policies adopted by states and different educational institutions with a national policy. As Republicans, we called this Federalism and considered it a good thing.
(10) encourage and celebrate massive protests and riots that lead to the burning and destruction of local retail and business establishments while at the same time requiring schools to be shuttered because of the risk of Covid-19 spreading during large gatherings,
It is so odd that you cite protests and riots as a reason for supporting Donald Trump since it was under Trump that America had the most recent incidents of large-scale protests following the murder of George Floyd. Trump's solution was to attempt to issue illegal orders to the military and walk into Lafayette Park holding a Bible.
(11) encourage and celebrate anti-American and anti-Israel protests and flag burning on campuses around the country with no consequences for the protesters who violate laws or university codes and policies,
This is confusing. On the one hand, many on the left attack Biden-Harris for the Administration's record-breaking level of support for Israel, military and economic. As for disrespecting the flag, it's Donald Trump who is often photographed holding onto an American flag on stage grotesquely and disrespectfully.
(12) allow antisemitism to explode with no serious efforts from the Administration to quell this hatred
Bill, Bill. Haven't you read that Trump says if he doesn't win, it will be the fault of the Jews? Are you really longing for a "blame the Jews" new movement in America?
(13) mandate vaccines that have not been adequately tested nor have their risks been properly considered compared with the potential benefits adjusted for the age and health of the individual, censoring the contrary advice of top scientists around the world,
There is a clear choice on medical issues across the board between Harris and Trump, from women's health rights to vaccines. Harris supports school vaccinations, as has been US policy for the last century. Trump and Vance oppose ALL school vaccinations, which means no measles or polio vaccinations. Perhaps there is a "let's bring back polio, measles, and whooping cough" argument to be made. Please feel free.
(14) shut down free speech in media and on social media platforms that is inconsistent with government policies and objectives,
It's Donald Trump who has threatened to sue and shut down CNN, ABC, NBC Sixty Minutes, The Washingon Post and the New York Times, among others.
Live in reality, Bill. It's not as frightening as your imaginary world.
(15) use the U.S., state, and local legal systems to attack and attempt to jail, take off the campaign trail, and/or massively fine candidates for the presidency without regard to the merits or precedential issues of the case,
Have you seriously forgotten that Donald Trump was elected to chants of "Lock her up?" I work with the Lincoln Project, and Donald Trump demanded his Department of Justice shut down the Lincoln Project. If you think the unanimous jury in New York who convicted Donald Trump on 34 counts was politically motivated, including the juror who listed "Truth Social" as his main information source, that's your prerogative. But if you are taking up the cause of unjust prosecution, it would be better to start with those who cannot afford competent representation rather than the Billionaire who spends millions on lawyers (though he does call his own lawyers incompetent.)
(16) seek to defund the police and promote anti-police rhetoric causing a loss of confidence in those who are charged with protecting us,
I will buy you a new Tesla of your choice if you can demonstrate that a Harris Administration would support defunding the police.
(17) use government funds to subsidize auto companies and internet providers with vastly more expensive, dated and/or lower-quality technology when greatly superior and cheaper alternatives are available from companies that are owned and/or managed by individuals not favored by the current Administration,
Bill, this might be helpful: latimes.com/business/la-fi-hy-musk-subsidies-20150531-sto… Your issue is with Elon Musk. Take it up with him.
(18) mandate in legislation and otherwise government solutions to problems when the private sector can do a vastly better, faster, and cheaper job,
What exactly do you want to privatize, Bill? We have private prisons, private roads, private hospitals, private schools, private delivery services, etc. What's on your wish list to privatize?
(19) seek to ban gas-powered cars and stoves without regard to the economic and practical consequences of doing so,
Your Wolf gas stove is safe, Bill. Just as is my Landcruiser.
(20) take no serious actions when 45 American citizens are killed by terrorists and 12 are taken hostage
What is it that you want the US military to do in Gaza that is not being done? What's your plan?
, (21) hold back armaments and weaponry from our most important ally in the Middle East in the midst of their hostage negotiations, hostages who include American citizens who have now been held for more than one year,
More military aid has been spent on Israel under Biden-Harris than any US president.
(22) eliminate sanctions on one of our most dangerous enemies enabling them to generate $150 billion+ of cash reserves from oil sales, which they can then use to fund terrorist proxy organizations who attack us and our allies. Exchange five American hostages held by Iran for five Iranians plus $6 billion of cash in the worst hostage negotiation in history setting a disastrous and dangerous precedent,
This number 22 is sort of a dog's breakfast of ill-informed grievances. Why is it that military leaders who served with Trump overwhelmingly oppose him? Because they want America to be less safe? Is that really your view, Bill?
(23) remove known terrorist organizations from the terrorist list so we can provide aid to their people, and allow them to shoot rockets at U.S. assets and military bases with little if any military response from us,
What in the world are you talking about, Bill?
(24) lie to the American people about the cognitive health of the president and accuse those who provide video evidence of his decline of sharing doctored videos and being right wing conspirators,
Bill, you seem concerned that another Trump presidency would result in his palace guard, like his campaign, trying to hide and deny his cognitive decline. I agree, that is a very serious concern.
(25) do nothing about the deteriorating health of our citizens driven by the food industrial complex, the fraudulent USDA food pyramid, and the inclusion of ingredients in our food that are banned by other countries around the world which are more protective of their citizens,
Bill, I'm not sure backing the obese president, who is a walking advertisement for super-sizing every fast food portion, is the most credible way to pursue this argument.
(26) do nothing about the proliferation of new vaccines that are not properly analyzed for their risk versus the potential benefit for healthy children who are mandated to receive them,
This sounds like something you heard from RFK, jr. while falconing. America has the safest drug system in the world.
(27) do nothing about the continued exemption from liability for the pharma industry that has led to a proliferation of mandatory vaccines for children without considering the potential cumulative effects of the now mandated 72-shot regime,
See number 26 above.
(28) convince our minority youth that they are victims of a rigged system and that the American dream is not available to them,
Let me get this straight. One candidate is the daughter of immigrants, raised by a single mom, who worked her way through college and rose to become Vice President vs. a candidate who inherited $443 million with a trust fund that made him a millionaire in high school. Which one do you think is better proof that the American dream is alive?
(29) fail to provide adequate Secret Service protection for alternative presidential candidates,
Unlike you, Bill, I've spent a fair amount of time around the Secret Service working for presidential candidates. They do an extraordinary job under the most difficult situation. Was it Ronald Reagan's lack of support of the Secret Service that resulted in him being shot? Or the two assassination attempts against President Ford? No one is arguing for less funding for the Secret Service. Quit attacking law enforcement and start laying the blame on those who break the law.
(30) litigate to prevent alternative candidates from getting on the ballot, and take other anti-competitive steps, including threatening political consultants who wish to work for alternative candidates for the presidency, and limit the potential media access for other candidates by threatening the networks' future access to the Administration and access to 'scoops' if they platform an alternative candidate,
I was a political consultant at the highest levels for 30 years, and let me reassure you that business is just fine for political consultants, though I appreciate your concern.
(31) select the Democratic nominee for president in a backroom process by undisclosed party leaders without allowing Americans to choose between candidates in an open primary,
I'd refer you to the Constitution. There is no mention of political parties. Political parties are no more than bowling clubs, private organizations that can make any rules they so choose. You were free to announce your candidacy against President Biden in the primary or after he decided not to accept the nomination. Just as Donald Trump turned the RNC into a family held scam, political parties are free to govern themselves
(32) choose an inferior candidate for the presidency when other much more qualified candidates are available and interested to serve
Is this more of your "Jamie Dimon should be president" trope?
, (33) litigate to make it illegal for states to require proof of citizenship, voter ID, and/or residence in order to vote at a time when many Americans have lost confidence in the accuracy and trustworthiness of our voting system.
The problem we have in America is getting people to vote when it is legal, not illegal voting. By refusing to accept his crushing defeat in 2020, Donald Trump has done more to weaken faith in American democracy than almost a century of attacks from the Communist Party of the USSR. It's disgraceful, and supporting a candidate for president and vice-president who will not state that America has a legal president is shameful.
Hope this helps -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If this were Harris or Walz, right-wing media would be on it 24/7, MSM headlines would be apocalyptic for Dems, and the DNC would be investigating a change in candidates.
Decoding Fox News
@DecodingFoxNews
I watched the entire Trump rally in Oaks, Pennsylvania and broke it down minute by minute. Trump awkwardly danced onstage for over 35 minutes for no discernible reason. There were two brief medical issues with members of the audience that appeared to resolve quickly.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Much appreciated kind words from another presidency scholar!
Pat Sobkowski
@PJSobkowski
Thanks to @petermshane’s excellent @demchiefexecpod pod episode with Paul Verkuil for drawing my attention to this initiative. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/democracys-chief-executive/…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
As political songs go, Stevie Nicks’s The Lighthouse is pretty great for this moment. Should play at all Harris rallies! youtu.be/m1PpthYqJks
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Dear Legal History Twitter, Has anyone theorized about the relevance of ongoing historical research to the operation of stare decisis, especially with regard to decisions that look specifically to history as a source of interpretive authority?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Has there ever been a smoke alarm with a dying battery that starts its warning chirp during one's waking hours?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For weekend listening: #6 in the @demchiefexecpod "Project 2025: Revealed!” series: Poli. scientist @rudalev discusses what a POTUS “dictator for a day” can and cannot do unilaterally. open.spotify.com/episode/2o64UABCensMGWKLxImfsr If you missed our immigration talk, it’s here: open.spotify.com/episode/2C6wXoSFb6pzdUofPdGsOw
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
As is often the case with brilliant younger colleagues in the academy, I wish I could have taken their classes 50 years ago! This is a great interview.
Yale Law School
@YaleLawSch
LISTEN: Professor Cristina Rodríguez talks to @demchiefexecpod about the president’s central role in implementing immigration policy and what Project 2025 says about immigration.
open.spotify.com/episode/2C6wXoSFb6pzdUofPdGsOw?nd=1&dlsi… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Mike Nellis
@MikeNellis
If you’re voting for Kamala Harris and you’re still on Twitter, let’s be friends.
Respond to this tweet and share it with your friends and I’ll follow you back.
We have to stick together to organize on this hell site.
Inspired by @karlykingsley -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I'm reading that Trump is planning a late-campaign rally at Madison Square Garden and thinking, "Hasn't it already been done?" www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2019/02/20/695941323/when… (For a podcast on Project 2025 and immigration policy: open.spotify.com/episode/2C6wXoSFb6pzdUofPdGsOw)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I’m enough to remember when Ford’s fatal gaffe was suggesting the USSR in 1976 did not dominate Eastern Europe.
George Conway ⚖️🇺🇸
@gtconway3d
I’m old enough to remember when Republicans got big mad ’cause Obama said something he thought was off-mic to Medvedev
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is a devastating thread.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I host a podcast exploring a right-wing agenda setting project titled with next year's date, and I suspect X is suppressing posts linking to our episodes. Here's a link to the #immigration episode, but a pic of my #corgi, who hopes to fool algorithms. open.spotify.com/episode/2C6wXoSFb6pzdUofPdGsOw?nd=1&dlsi…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In a new @demchiefexecpod “Project 2025: Revealed!” episode, prominent immigration scholar Cristina Rodríguez explains to @petermshane and Dale Russakoff why the Project 2025 agenda is misguided, unrealistic, and not limited to unlawful immigration. open.spotify.com/episode/2C6wXoSFb6pzdUofPdGsOw
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My 1L reading group at @nyulaw last night discussed chapters on the promise and demise of Reconstruction from Skip Gates’s Stony the Road and The Anti-Oligarchy Constitution by Joey Fishkin and Willy Forbath. Really excellent texts and discussion.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This promises to be a great read. Congratulations!
Keith E. Whittington
@kewhittington
New book alert!
@YaleLawSch @PrincetonUPress -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Keith E. Whittington
@kewhittington
New book alert!
@YaleLawSch @PrincetonUPress -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
On a new Ep. 4 of the @DemChiefExecPod series on #project2025, Paul Verkuil, former chair of @acusgov talks to @petermshane about the difference between real civil service reform and making a bureaucracy march in lockstep to presidential command. open.spotify.com/episode/620kdgElbaozOavnrrDNDM
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: @DemChiefExecPod Ep. 3 in “#project2025 Revealed!” focusing on education up now. Historian Diane Ravitch explains to Dale Russakoff and me the disastrous implications for education of prioritizing parental choice over well-resourced public schools. open.spotify.com/episode/0UvstOT5EAGOrBVGJwrd3Q
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For your weekend podcast listening consideration: Eps. 1-2 of "#project2025: Revealed!" a/k/a, Season 3 of @demchiefexecpod. # 1 explains what it is and who's behind it. # 2 focuses on #reproductiverights. (#education drops on Wednesday!) All episodes at open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
#abortion appears 198 times in the #project2025 agenda book. In a new @demchiefexecpod episode of “Project 2025: Revealed!” @petermshane and Dale Russakoff interview attorney Lynn Paltrow on the implications for women’s health care and reproductive rights. open.spotify.com/episode/6WS0Vqb9AmMXyTJw6xFxNg
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This may be the most amazing thing you’ll read today.
Joseph Fasano
@Joseph_Fasano_
oh my god
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: Yesterday, Dale Russakoff and I debuted episode #1 in our new @demchiefexecpod series on #project2025. A childhood friend wrote to tell me he found it "clear, to the point, and even entertaining, in a scary sort of way." Ambitions fulfilled! podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/democracys-ceo-pod/episod…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
OK, but what about the price of crudité? Hasn't that gone à travers le toit??
Jerrad Christian
@JerradChristian
JD Vance's first official act as President would be to make a dozen 24.
He went to a store to rant about egg prices claiming eggs were $4 a dozen. Behind him the eggs are $3 a dozen while he holds two dozen eggs.
This incident describes the entire MAGA movement. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This AM, my quoting a great piece by @steve_vladeck got 13.5K views. A link to my new podcast project at the same time got 118 views. So, with apologies for exploiting friends, the link's below and you should follow Steve, @ProfMMurray, @LeahLitman, @tribelaw, and @joshchafetz!
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Here it is! @petermshane and Dale Russakoff launch the first episode in the 10-part @demchiefexecpod series exploring the #project2025 agenda. What is it? Who created it? What’s the connection to Trump World? open.spotify.com/episode/4BjTLJEUOQ1tpAebIHkqoA
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This splendid riposte by @steve_vladeck to a judge taking umbrage at his critique of judge-shopping deserves the attention of every citizen who cares about the integrity of the federal judiciary.
Steve Vladeck
@steve_vladeck
My thanks to @OrinKerr for inviting me to respond to Judge Reed O’Connor’s recent speech on judge-shopping—which accused law professors of “increasingly teach[ing] students to presume malicious intention on the part of judges with whom they disagree.”
reason.com/volokh/2024/09/25/stephen-vladeck-replies-to-j… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Here it is! @petermshane and Dale Russakoff launch the first episode in the 10-part @demchiefexecpod series exploring the #project2025 agenda. What is it? Who created it? What’s the connection to Trump World? open.spotify.com/episode/4BjTLJEUOQ1tpAebIHkqoA
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Season 3 of “Democracy’s Chief Executive: The Podcast” @demchiefexecpod, entitled, #project2025 Revealed!” launches on 9/25! In 10 episodes coming over 5 weeks, Dale and I talk to experts to shed light on this right-wing coalition’s ambitions and agenda. open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
As is so often the case with Trump, his accusations—in this case, of weaponizing the government against polo opponents—turn out to be confessions. www.nytimes.com/2024/09/21/us/politics/trump-investigatio… via @NYTimes
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Polo opponents = political opponents.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Tell me this is a parody account.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The immunity opinion, which purports to decide many issues not before the Court, is rooted in a largely mythical narrative of the separation of powers, which Roberts has championed since his Reagan days. No Justice has contributed more to ease the glide path to authoritarianism.
Melissa Murray (@ProfMMurray on Threads 🧵)
@ProfMMurray
Another blockbuster story on the Court's deliberations in the 3 Trump cases from OT2023. Absolutely incredible. www.nytimes.com/2024/09/15/us/justice-roberts-trump-supre… via @NYTimes
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It was outrageous that ABC’s moderators gave five+ more minutes of speaking time to Trump they gave to @VP. This was clearly stacking the deck for Harris, no? 😉
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If I ask a question in class, is an acceptable response, “I have a concept of an answer?” Asking for a professoriate.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I am truly, deeply grateful to the Cheneys for seeing the stakes for democracy in 2024 and embracing a Harris vote as the best defense. But no elected leader before Trump worked harder than Dick Cheney to legitimate the expansive model of executive power Trump now seeks to deploy
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Please tell me that someone is creating an audio with one of Trump’s stolen election claims followed by his podcast statement that he “lost by a whisker.” Just in case there was any doubt in anyone’s mind that he knew he lost and was lying to his supporters.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Will there be a mashup of Kimberly Guilfoyle dancing to Lara Trump's music video?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This may be the best thing written about a civil servant ever. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/interactive/2024/michael-…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This will happen right after Infrastructure Week.
Patrick Svitek
@PatrickSvitek
Trump in Michigan: "I’m announcing today, in a major statement, that under the Trump administration, your government will pay for — or your insurance company will be mandated to pay for — all costs associated with IVF treatment. ... We want more babies, to put it very nicely."
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
“Like the Shroud of Turin, but classier!” #satire
Yashar Ali 🐘
@yashar
Former President Trump is selling portions of the suit he wore to the debate with President Biden in June.
Fans who buy 15 or more of his digital trading cards will receive a physical trading card with a piece of his “knockout suit.”
The cost of the digital trading cards is $99, so this means spending at least $1,485.
Fans who buy 75 or more of his digital trading cards ($7,425) will receive an invitation to a dinner at his country club in Jupiter, Florida. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Just to be clear: Trump's team had to push back an official at Arlington Cemetery so he could take this unspeakably inappropriate photo in a section of Arlington where photos are not allowed. www.npr.org/2024/08/27/nx-s1-5091154/trump-arlington-ceme…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Note to media: RFK, Jr. + Tulsi Gabbard = Nothingburger. The transition team is the team assembling and ready to implement #project2025. It actually calls itself, "The Presidential Transition Project." They'll work with the America First Policy Institute headed by Linda McMahon.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
No, and the media should stop covering his so-called hints which are just intended as clickbait and to lower expectations in case @harris_wins shreds him. This phony suspense creation is not news.
Morgan J. Freeman
@mjfree
Will Trump back out of the first debate?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I heard that @TheOnion was going back to a print edition. I didn’t think it was this one. www.nytimes.com/2024/08/26/opinion/advice-for-trump-win.html via @NYTOpinion@
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I can’t say often enough how deeply I respect and appreciate this line of thought from conservatives helping Harris.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It's as if he had hired Dr. Oz's advance team.
W. Kamau Bell
@wkamaubell
I know I’m a weird messenger to be giving advice, but I truly mean this to be helpful, @JDVance.
Fire your whole team. They clearly hate you. This is TV production 101, and they failed it.
1) Someone is supposed to scout ahead and make sure everyone there is interested in being on camera AND excited to talk to you. And if your team finds out that no one at the place is interested in talking to you and some don’t even want to be on camera with you - situations that I’m sure you are used to by now - then your team needs to find another establishment.
2) Someone is supposed to prep you with names and talking points. This is especially true because, as you know, you are horrible at small talk. Your team must even know this by now. Your team has to give you follow up questions so you are ready to go. “What is your bestselling donut?” “What’s your favorite?” “What do you recommend?” “What’s your favorite part of your job?” “Do you eat too many donuts because you work here.” This is simple stuff. But again, I get that it is extremely hard for you to speak to humans. That’s why you need a better team.
3) in lieu of small talk, which I would recommend you skipping because you are - again - HORRIBLE at it, your team should have given you a pre decided order so you were ready for the “difficult task” of ordering donuts. Here are a few suggestions for next time. “I’ll take a dozen glazed.” “Just give me a dozen of your bestsellers.” “JUST FILL THE BOX WITH SPRINKLES THAT YOU SCRAP OFF OF SPRINKLE DONUTS, AAAAAARGH!!!”
That last one was a trick. If you believed it then you need more help than I even imagined.
The good news is I’ll happily take you on as a client to teach you how to appear more human, all for the price of one jabilliondee dollar bucks. Currently, there is a 1% discount. But I need your answer by… more -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
W. Kamau Bell
@wkamaubell
I know I’m a weird messenger to be giving advice, but I truly mean this to be helpful, @JDVance.
Fire your whole team. They clearly hate you. This is TV production 101, and they failed it.
1) Someone is supposed to scout ahead and make sure everyone there is interested in being on camera AND excited to talk to you. And if your team finds out that no one at the place is interested in talking to you and some don’t even want to be on camera with you - situations that I’m sure you are used to by now - then your team needs to find another establishment.
2) Someone is supposed to prep you with names and talking points. This is especially true because, as you know, you are horrible at small talk. Your team must even know this by now. Your team has to give you follow up questions so you are ready to go. “What is your bestselling donut?” “What’s your favorite?” “What do you recommend?” “What’s your favorite part of your job?” “Do you eat too many donuts because you work here.” This is simple stuff. But again, I get that it is extremely hard for you to speak to humans. That’s why you need a better team.
3) in lieu of small talk, which I would recommend you skipping because you are - again - HORRIBLE at it, your team should have given you a pre decided order so you were ready for the “difficult task” of ordering donuts. Here are a few suggestions for next time. “I’ll take a dozen glazed.” “Just give me a dozen of your bestsellers.” “JUST FILL THE BOX WITH SPRINKLES THAT YOU SCRAP OFF OF SPRINKLE DONUTS, AAAAAARGH!!!”
That last one was a trick. If you believed it then you need more help than I even imagined.
The good news is I’ll happily take you on as a client to teach you how to appear more human, all for the price of one jabilliondee dollar bucks. Currently, there is a 1% discount. But I need your answer by… more -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Was this determination made pursuant to a formal hearing under the APA? @emilysbremer @chris_j_walker @Aaron_L_Nielson
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A lot of Trump’s universe seems to be people he brought into government who now despise him, and people who despised him but now help him in the hope of acquiring power.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If we had a rational conservative party in the U.S., Adam Kinziger would be accepting its nomination for president, not speaking to the #dnc. He gave an excellent speech.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The @washingtonpost “fact check” called this “cherry-picked,” because 1989 excludes Reagan’s 16 million. OK. That would change the score to 50-17, still a shellacking—and GOP POTUS’s had 5 more years to create jobs during the 1981-2024 period than Dems (24-19 years in office)
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
RFK, Jr.’s endorsement of Trump would be as grotesque a betrayal as one can imagine of his father’s and uncles’ legacies. I hope the stories are exaggerated or those who advise him talk him out of it.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Does #dnc2024 set the record for the national party convention featuring the largest slate of prominent Jewish speakers—Raskin, Schumer, Sanders, Pritzger, Emhoff, Shapiro (coming), at least?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Is he reading a book report??
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
it's the second straight day where a sedated-sounding Trump has been ranting incoherently at an event (this time in Howell, Michigan) while people are forced to stand behind him for way too long. Note the complete lack of reaction to everything he says & the fact that he appears to be in a parking garage
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In a better universe, the #dnc2024 is celebrating all that @HillaryClinton accomplished during her two terms as President.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If Biden had been as energetic at The Debate as he was at the #dnc, he’d still be the nominee. Ironically, the last month has proven how lucky the Democrats are that he had such a bad night. He has done a super job as POTUS, but letting go was right for the country.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In his entire career, @VP Harris's opponent has never given--and is not now capable of giving--a policy statement as clear and responsive as this.
Aes🇺🇸
@AesPolitics1
She’s absolutely brilliant.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
As much as I am sure we would still have plenty to argue about, my respect for conservatives willing to say, "Vote for Harris" runs very deep. It is no small thing to step outside one's circle in this way. It means much more than "I can't vote for either candidate." Thank you.
Bruce Bartlett
@BruceBartlett
I've already stated that I will vote for Harris/Walz, but would like to remind people that I, like my friend Michael Luttig, was a Republican for a long time. I was driven out of the party well before Trump made my decision final. I will never go back.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
#chatgpt just acknowledged to a friend that it made a mistake. Though less than 2 years old, it has thus managed a level of moral development Trump has not managed in 78.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Wait until he hears about bar code scanning in supermarkets! (That’s a George H.W. Bush reference for those too young to know.)
Acyn
@Acyn
Trump: I love the playback controls you have nowadays. They used to call it TiVo, now they TiVo— I think it’s the single greatest invention. it is better than television.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
RFK, Jr.’s campaign has a definite Connor Roy vibe.
Yashar Ali 🐘
@yashar
NEWS
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. sought a meeting last week with Democratic nominee Kamala Harris to discuss the possibility of serving in her administration, perhaps as a Cabinet secretary, if he throws his support behind her campaign and she wins.
Harris and her advisers have not responded with an offer to meet or shown interest in the proposal.
Full Story: www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2024/08/14/rfk-jr-kamala-… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I suspect that one victory from the 2016 #hillary campaign is that, for most U.S. voters, it made the experience of voting for a woman for President feel natural. Even if you thought the vote was somehow adventurous in 2016, now it's just "voting." The force of misogyny weakens.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Can't pick just 1 great line from this superb essay but here's the gist:This [DC] press corps is generally not equipped to scrutinize candidates on matters of fact and substance. I say this because this press corps has conspicuously traded matters of fact and substance for vibes.
The Editorial Board
@johnastoehr
My latest. Lemme know what you think.
Kamala Harris is taking power back from the press corps www.editorialboard.com/kamala-harris-is-taking-power-back… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I’m not proud that this makes me laugh every time.
𝕊𝕦𝕟𝕕𝕒𝕖_𝔾𝕦𝕣𝕝
@SundaeDivine
The Trump campaign sure has that "Hitler in the bunker" energy these days.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
“The world’s strongmen will eat Harris alive” may be a tougher line for Trump to sell after Harris cornered Trump into capitulating on the September 10 debate.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I have wondered, had any other conservative Justice embraced Barrett, whether the liberals would have joined to make it a majority opinion.
Keith E. Whittington
@kewhittington
Posted a draft of my paper on the Trump v. United States decision. Paper will be published in the Cato Supreme Court Review.
Presidential Immunity <br> papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4919454 -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Is Trump still campaigning? Is the plan just to go wherever Harris goes and draw a smaller crowd?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Speaks my sentiments, as well.
Josh Chafetz
@joshchafetz
This is pathetic. If you have any evidence of antisemitism by Harris or Walz, show it.
If your only claim is that they didn’t choose Shapiro, (a) neither did Trump, (b) Shapiro doesn’t seem to think it’s antisemitic, and …
Nikki Haley
@NikkiHaley
Democrats are going to have to explain this movement towards deeper antisemitism. We are seeing it in the protests, in the rhetoric by the Squad and members of Congress, and now in the VP pick. They can’t talk this away as coincidence. It’s concerning.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
And the prize for best comic performance by a city sanitation department goes to . . .
NYC Sanitation
@NYCSanitation
Wondering how to dispose of a dead animal in New York City? Get the facts: on.nyc.gov/4fvz5Ho
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I have deep respect for self-described GOP ‘ers who are publicly opposing Trump. To Never Trumpers now saying, I may have to write in X because @GovTimWalz is liberal, please remember the next POTUS will be @VP Harris or Trump. Unless you are indifferent to the choice, go Harris.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Somewhere, the soul of Hubert Humphrey is smiling.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Might this also be “weird?”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I guess the whole, “I could have been a gymnast except I wear glasses,” delusion is gone.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Finally found the text of the proposed #nokingsact www.democrats.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/SIL24569.pdf
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I was fooled. I thought he would somehow try to take credit for the release, which he did say he’d produce even before his next inauguration. Perhaps he suspects that his ever-pragmatic Moscow friend is no longer invested in helping him win.
Bill Kristol
@BillKristol
Boy, Trump really is just a repulsive creep and an inhumane jackass.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Given that all the VP prospects have virtually identical positions, targeting the one prospect who is Jewish seems like the agenda is something other than just “pro-Palestinian.” www.nytimes.com/2024/08/01/us/politics/shapiro-vp-israel.… via @NYTimes
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
As I search for the text of a @SenSchumer bill to overturn Trump v. U.S. on the #immunity of former POTUSs to criminal prosecution, I beg: Would news outlets reporting on primary documents please include links to those documents in their online stories? There’s no excuse not to.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I didn’t immediately connect with the strategy of calling MAGA weird. But saying a proud graduate of Howard had not identified in her youth as Black is, among other things, weird.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
To quote my wise college classmate Chris Foreman: "It's not over until the cat lady sings!"
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is hilarious.
Republicans against Trump
@RpsAgainstTrump
Kamala Harris recalls meeting her Jewish mother-in-law for the first time x.com/SudarakaA/status/1153007467854475264/video/1
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The key to “boss speak” is ambiguity—the threat must be accompanied by deniability. Maybe “Will no one rid me of this troublesome priest?” could just mean, “Can’t we get a rabbi for the wedding?”
Melissa Murray (@ProfMMurray on Threads 🧵)
@ProfMMurray
TBF, Trump's statement is open to multiple interpretations. No need to vote in the future because he'll have done such a great job at being an autocrat. Or maybe because he will have eliminated free elections. Who's to say? Let's give him the benefit of the doubt. 🙄 #textualism
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
I'm not one to defend Trump, but I disagree w/the many claiming that Trump said there would be no more elections if he wins. I hear him more as just saying he'll do such a fantastic job he'll save the country so the stakes of future elections will be a lot lower.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Sounds bad: "4 more years, you know what: it’ll be fixed, it’ll be fine. You won’t have to vote anymore, my beautiful Christians….Get out, you’ve got to get out and vote. In 4 years, you don’t have to vote again, we’ll have it fixed so good you’re not going to have to vote.”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
America’s historical amnesia is troubling. Amid all the social media talk of who’s the worst VP candidate ever, Palin or Vance, I have yet to see any mention of Admiral Stockdale. Age has some advantages. youtu.be/T1w3FgB0Ohc
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I see the title, but the blurb sounds as if she’s written a book about Simone Biles.
Meridith McGraw
@meridithmcgraw
NEW YORK (AP) — Former first lady Melania Trump has a memoir coming out this fall, “Melania,” billed by her office as “a powerful and inspiring story of a woman who has carved her own path, overcome adversity and defined personal excellence.” apnews.com/article/melania-trump-memoir-first-lady-0461db…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Can media elites determine that Zach Galifianakis has to play J.D. Vance on SNL or must there be an open convention? (I vote for Galifianakis.)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
On the question whether @VP should have cancelled her commitment to address an historically Black sorority to preside over Netanyahu's address to Congress, I found it interesting to see that address dismissed in @haaretzcom as "narcissistic politicking." www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2024-07-24/ty-article/.premiu…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Has Trump started blaming undocumented immigrants for putting Vance on the ticket yet?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
via @NYTOpinion This is an extraordinary essay by a woman who should have been president, who welcomes the chance to witness that glass ceiling finally break. Thank you, Hillary Clinton. www.nytimes.com/2024/07/23/opinion/kamala-harris-donald-t…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
We get space lasers either way, right? #satire
Gary Shteyngart
@Shteyngart
Astronaut or Jew? Kamala certainly has an exciting choice to make.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Torts exam waiting to happen
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It seems unfair to Biden given his record, but it is undeniable that the impending nomination of @VP #harris gives those tired of Trump the feeling they are voting FOR something, not just AGAINST something.
George Conway ⚖️🇺🇸
@gtconway3d
I had this image in my head last night of @rufusgifford sitting in a warehouse in Wilmington with legions of Gen Zers dumping wheelbarrows of cash at his feet, which he was desperately trying to count, but then he made the mistake of answering the phone and lost track and had to start all over 🤣
Rufus Gifford
@rufusgifford
More than 100 million raised to elect @KamalaHarris since @POTUS endorsed her. Less than 36 hours.
Completely unprecedented. Something’s happening here….
🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸 -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Trump will make up names to call @VP. She need only call him the names juries have already bestowed upon him.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
There is nothing George Washington did of greater importance to the future of American democracy than voluntarily stepping away from power. If U.S. democracy survives in 2024, @POTUS’s following that example will be nearly as important, as was his defeat of Trump in 2020.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This thread on law school curricula captures my own sentiments, as well. It would also help law students to be better writers if judges were better writers. Judicial opinions constitute much of a law student’s reading, and what you read affects how you write.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If Biden is thinking it’s not obvious that another candidate has a better chance of beating Trump, he may be right. But a Harris-Cooper ticket would put NC very much in play. Harris-Beshear would be more youthful and might also help in purple parts of the South.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My @monthly take on overruling Chevron & other SCOTUS blockbusters: "The upshot of [Roberts Court] jurisprudence makes it harder for Congress to legislate and for agencies to implement reasonable understandings of the discretion they have been given." washingtonmonthly.com/2024/07/16/the-roberts-courts-chevr…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Giving the Cannon opinion the careful read that I am professionally required to give it is going to be a slog if every page of the 93 strikes me as preposterous and as self-aggrandizing as page 2. But I retain an open mind. I will just breathe slowly and take lots of breaks.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Every time I hear or read political leaders saying that a horrible act of gun violence is “not who we are as Americans,” I think they missed the class on normative vs. descriptive. allyourprettywords.tumblr.com/post/187306113518/america-i…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Question: Does anyone calling for @POTUS to drop out have any actual evidence that someone else on the Democrats’ bench has a better chance of beating Trump? The idea that our message is so much better that anyone delivering it less haltingly can beat Trump isn’t much of a case.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My @TheRegReview essay argues that the Court’s poorly reasoned #immunity opinion elevated a “formal, wooden” historically dubious version of the separation of powers over checks and balances and the rule of law. Sets up a frightening future presidency. www.theregreview.org/2024/07/08/shane-the-king-presumptiv…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The “Col. Klink I know nuthink” disavowal is a preposterous lie. www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/donald-tr…
Max Burns
@themaxburns
Here are just a few of the nightmares contained in Project 2025, the @GOP's far-right extremist vision for a second Trump presidency:
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
“Maybe Nixon was wrongly decided . . .Maybe the tension of the time led to an erroneous decision.” - Brett Kavanaugh knowing better in 1999 than a unanimous Supreme Court in 1974 apnews.com/article/3ea406469d344dd8b2527aed92da6365
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I am relieved that people seem finally to be waking up to the extremism of #project2025. In case this is still news to you, I am re-upping my @monthly story about it from last November. washingtonmonthly.com/2023/11/13/blitzkrieg-against-the-a…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Anyone else having trouble with the X website??
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It just occurred to me: Roberts Court #originalism = “There’s no basis in text, history, or precedent for our interpretation of the Constitution. It’s original!!”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Given the Roberts Court's concern for history and tradition, one would expect the majority to probe the Nixon resignation and pardon. It is a critical moment when an incumbent POTUS had to wrestle with a predecessor's vulnerability to prosecution. It is never mentioned. #immunity
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In the 1980s, the right saw POTUS power as the likeliest route to yank public policy rightward. "Unitary executive theory" blossomed. The Court is now the product of a long-term campaign to assemble the human and intellectual capital needed to support the authoritarian vision.
Whit Stillman
@WhitStillman
What might explain the Supreme Court's sharp turn toward an authoritarian view of the presidency? No WASPS.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"Will no one rid me of this meddlesome priest?" -- Official consultation with confidential advisors on government strategy, entitled to presumption of immunity. #satire
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Roberts' ##immunity opinion embraces 2018 Barr claims to Rosenstein on why Trump couldn't be prosecuted for obstruction, e.g., POTUS "alone" IS the executive branch. No testing of official acts for corrupt motive. IMHO, Mueller's refutation was persuasive. www.documentcloud.org/documents/5638848-June-2018-Barr-Me…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I've posted below the gist of what I have been telling reporters about my day-after take on the #immunity case.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If Trump loses the election, the #immunity opinion may help him less than he hopes. But the opinion is shockingly devoid of any discussion of text or history or any pragmatic consideration other than concern for the majority’s wooden, ahistorical view of separation of powers.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Under the #immunity opinion, I guess the pardon of #nixon was superfluous. This majority would find him immune from prosecution for obstruction of justice.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For a follow-up, do obstruction of justice.
Alan Mygatt-Tauber - @amtappeals.bsky.social
@AMTAppeals
Can someone explain how the Court’s bribery example works? If we can’t put in evidence of the President’s motives, how do you ever prove corrupt intent?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For this year’s Harvard Law Review “Foreword,” I think Gillian Metzger should be invited to write a piece called, “I Told You So.” harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-131/1930s-redux-the-admini…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Headlines should be, "Court Rejects Trump Argument for Absolute Presidential Immunity from Prosecution."
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Congress will undoubtedly respond by immediately authorizing dozens of new federal judgeships to help the already overtaxed courts. #satire
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
So, if I am ideologically opposed to an old rule, I need only open a business "burdened" by it and, voila, I have six years to challenge it in court.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
TFW the summer project is updating a co-authored administrative law text and your chapter is NOT the chapter on scope of judicial review. (Hint: It’s relief.)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I'm not a debate coach, but shouldn't the first answer to the first question have been, "I'm glad to address that. But first, let me tell you what this election is about . . ." Framing comes first. How could POTUS not have been prepped to do that?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Biden’s second half is better than the first, but @NickKristof’s assessment remains accurate.
Nicholas Kristof
@NickKristof
I have a bad feeling about how the debate is beginning. Trump is speaking nonsense on many topics, but he's projecting energy; Biden is more substantive but in voice and manner is playing into the Trump narrative that he's old for this job. Thoughts?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Civ pro/admin folks: If agencies can go after alleged fraudsters via an unjust enrichment theory that entitles them to disgorgement rather than damages, that would not require a jury trial, right?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Bob Bauer-busy as faux Trump in Biden’s campaign prep-was twice a @demchiefexecpod guest. In S1, he and @jacklgoldsmith reviewed the role of the POTUS's lawyers. open.spotify.com/episode/1xYbu7jM2W9x3imlGkd0L9 S2, he and Ben Ginsberg talked about lawyering presidential campaigns. open.spotify.com/episode/7jgNE2a4WUtQUF7qYepZfZ
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This should be required viewing just before 9 p.m.
Jon Cooper 🇺🇸
@joncoopertweets
In honor of tonight’s presidential #debate, I present @sarahcpr’s new “How to Boat.”
You’re welcome! 😃This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Nothing about SCOTUS really calls for levity, I suppose, but I can't help wishing that the Moyle case had been about circumcision. (Apology for juvenile humor.)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Justice Sotomayor, dissenting in #jarkesy: "Judicial aggrandizement is as pernicious to the separation of powers as any aggrandizing action from either of the political branches." www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/22-859_1924.pdf
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Link to leaked version of the SCOTUS order dismissing the cert grant in Moyle v. Ohio, thus leaving in place orders preventing Idaho from enforcing its abortion ban when the termination of a pregnancy is needed to prevent serious harms to a woman's health: assets.bwbx.io/documents/users/iqjWHBFdfxIU/rJo5436tVr08/v0
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Absolutely. I wish ALL news stories about primary documents would include links to those documents.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The Court votes 6-3 to apply narrowly a statute that bars corrupt gratuities as a reward for prior official acts. Trying hard not to be cynical here.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I have a recommendation as to where our Vice President (former California senator) and the Second Gentleman should be heading right now.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Protesting outside a synagogue instead of an Israeli consulate or embassy is a tell.
Meghan McCain
@MeghanMcCain
In Los Angeles, California in 2024…. heinous, despicable, insane.
And no this is not about Israel, you all just hate Jews like Hitler did.
Today is America
@TodayisAmerica
🚨BREAKING: Protestors call for bloody revolution against Jews (intifada) outside of synagogue in LA.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Well, what would a historian know about . . .oh, right! 😉(Can't wait to read.)
Jonathan Gienapp
@TheGNapp
There's been a lot of chatter these past few days about history and tradition in U.S. constitutional interpretation. My forthcoming book, now available for pre-order, explores these themes in depth. www.amazon.com/Against-Constitutional-Originalism-Histori…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A review well worth reading. "As legal scholars like Jamal Greene, Reva Siegel, and Mary Ziegler have shown, originalism has dominated not because it’s a powerful interpretative method (it’s not) but because of its adoption by an effective and energized political coalition."
The New Republic
@newrepublic
A new book argues that worship of the Constitution has distorted our politics.
@JohnFabianWitt reviews:
newrepublic.com/article/182334/united-states-devoted-cons… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Did the Court take over 6 months to decide Rahimi so that three concurring law review essays could be written on, “Why Originalism is Coherent Even After Bruen and Rahimi?” (Still isn’t.)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Any chance #reggiejackson would do a guest stint on our class session covering the Heart of Atlanta Motel and Ollie's Barbecue cases? (BTW, the night after the 1977 NY bar exam, he won a game against the Orioles with a bottom-of-the-ninth home run. Still a favorite memory.)
Aaron Nagler
@AaronNagler
This is why “Make America Great Again” is so insulting. It wasn’t great, for a lot of folks, for a long time. The country moved forward. Stop trying to drag us back.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I identify with much of my friend’s reflective thread. In 1978, I visited my old high school principal to thank him for writing a letter to the bar. He said he could never really tell if I was way left or conservative. I think it’s the reluctance to give up on institutions.
Noah Rosenblum
@narosenblum
À propos the fun conversation about the Teles article: this may sound strange, but I’ve always thought of myself as a moderate. The world is obviously full of unfair misery. A totally understandable response would be to say: screw it, burn it down, radical change now! (1/4)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
According to @nytimes: Backbeat — you can’t use it. Beg to differ.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This @washingtonpost headline is accurate. Every voter should take note.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I think you may be missing the word "sometimes" before "endeavor." Grateful to Judge Kacsmaryk and the Fifth Circuit for giving SCOTUS its "moderate" moments.
Jonathan H. Adler
@jadler1969
That #scotus rejected AHM's standing unanimously --even though this was an abortion case -- is a reminder that justices endeavor to do law, not policy.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Had a great conversation with @ARozenshtein on the @DougBeckerSC1 podcast, @ScholarsCircle, talking about the potential impacts of Trump's NY fraud convictions on the election and (alas, theoretically) possible Trump second term. scholarscircle.org/scholars-circle-trumps-conviction-of-f…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Unanimous rebuke to the Fifth Circuit -- plaintiffs had no standing to challenge FDA action regarding #mifepristone www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/23-235_n7ip.pdf
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This will deservedly be viewed as one of the most important administrative law articles of the last few years—and considering how much great stuff is out there, that’s saying something.
Noah Rosenblum
@narosenblum
Absolutely delighted to share my latest article, coauthored with @LevMenand and Ash Ahmed, just live in the @HarvLRev, on the growth of presidential administrative legal authority in the second half of the twentieth-century. (1/7)
harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-137/the-making-of-presiden… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Noah Rosenblum
@narosenblum
Absolutely delighted to share my latest article, coauthored with @LevMenand and Ash Ahmed, just live in the @HarvLRev, on the growth of presidential administrative legal authority in the second half of the twentieth-century. (1/7)
harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-137/the-making-of-presiden… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The problem is that narcissists experience all attention as positive reinforcement.
George Conway ⚖️🇺🇸
@gtconway3d
I guess what I’m advocating is a variant of “grey rock.” You don’t go silent when they attack. You affirmatively laugh at them. The idea with Trump is to provoke him, which usually isn’t the object when we personally deal with toxic narcissists in everyday life.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Craig Rozniecki
@CraigRozniecki
Including the most recent jobs report, here is the updated jobs-breakdown, courtesy of the U.S. Bureau of Labor.
George H.W. Bush (Republican, 4 years): +2.633M
Bill Clinton (Democrat, 8 years): +22.904M
George W. Bush (Republican, 8 years): +1.371M
Barack Obama (Democrat, 8 years): +11.570M
Donald Trump (Republican, 4 years): -2.670M
Joe Biden (Democrat, 3+ years): +16.270M
Republican Presidents (16 years): +1.334M
Democratic Presidents (19+ years): +50.744M
data.bls.gov/timeseries/ces0000000001?output_view=net_1mth
#republicansaretheproblem #voteblue -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Happy International Corgi Day to all who celebrate.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This characteristically insightful essay by Garrett Epps, taking a nuanced view of the @washingtonpost 2021 decision not then to publicize the Alito flag incident, is thoughtful about both journalistic and judicial ethics.
Washington Monthly
@monthly
The Alito Flags: Garrett Epps, a former @washpost Supreme Court reporter on the paper, the flag flap, and why we must deal with the dangers of Justice Samuel Alito now, even if the roots of what happened with his spouse is never known.
washingtonmonthly.com/2024/06/04/what-was-the-alito-flag-… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"Out of the facial expressions and squirming bodies of babes."
Aaron Fritschner
@Fritschner
So sorry I was slow responding to your email, I was tied up watching this over and over again
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Some Americans take the view that Biden has weaponized law enforcement against his political enemies. Isn't that theory hard to square with the facts that Biden has no control over the New York DA, and a department that Biden does oversee is prosecuting his son? (And Menendez.)
Kelly O'Donnell
@KellyO
NEW: Statement from President Joe Biden:
“I am the President, but I am also a Dad. Jill and I love our son, and we are so proud of the man he is today. Hunter’s resilience in the face of adversity and the strength he has brought to his recovery are inspiring to us. A lot of families have loved ones who have overcome addiction and know what we mean. As the President, I don’t and won’t comment on pending federal cases, but as a Dad, I have boundless love for my son, confidence in him, and respect for his strength. Our family has been through a lot together, and Jill and I are going to continue to be there for Hunter and our family with our love and support.” -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I hope this won't be considered pre-judging the verdict, but I have already determined not to vote for #hunterbiden for President.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In April 2023, the final episode of @demchiefexecpod Season 1 focused on the NY indictment in a discussion with @NormEisen, @CBHessick, and @ric_l_simmons. Today’s verdicts accord with their view of the case over a rear ago. Still worth a listen! open.spotify.com/episode/1MeUARFMP6U1FpnVrKisTr
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Beset by this ear worm. youtu.be/Phh9B1-4EYs
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Given Amendments 1, 13, 14, 15, 17, 19, 22, 23, 24, 25, and 26, the idea that our Constitution is opposed to democracy is really a tad out of date, no?
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
An excellent explanation why the Labor Department's new rule indexing threshold levels for overtime pay is well within @USDOL authority. Nothing to See Here: Misconceptions About the Overtime Rule’s Inflation Adjuster, by Will Dobbs-Allsopp and Reed Shaw www.yalejreg.com/nc/nothing-to-see-here-misconceptions-ab…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Jeff Hauser
@jeffhauser
Stephen Gillers reversing himself upon new evidence should get at least as much attention as his surprisingly soft initial take on Alito did. www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2024/05/24/supreme-court-…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It appears the boilerplate Justice Department language on which Trump based a nonsensical claim that the Biden Administration was targeting him for potential assassination at Mar-a-Lago was also part of the documentation for the search of Biden's home. Suicide by search warrant?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Trump will be offering his policy on reproductive rights and his post-trial testimony under oath during Infrastructure Week.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I wonder how others *who have read it* are reacting to this article in @NYTmag. I have read few things that left me more frightened or depressed for the future of Israel. www.nytimes.com/2024/05/16/magazine/israel-west-bank-sett….
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Thomas writing to uphold the #cfpb was not on my Bingo card.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is important work. The effects of the Court’s failures to protect voting rights are hardly random in their distribution across the polity. The idea that “the text made us do it” is risible. The excerpt in @monthly deserves your attention.
Washington Monthly
@monthly
The Stigma of Felon Disenfranchisement: In an excerpt from @JoshuaADouglas's new book on the Supreme Court, the legal scholar shows how it undermines voting rights by using an obscure phrase to bless the disenfranchisement of millions.
washingtonmonthly.com/2024/05/14/the-stigma-of-felon-dise… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
His love of RV’ing to be around “regular people” has a somewhat different valence given his veritable land yacht of an RV. Thomas says critics are pushing ‘nastiness’ and calls Washington a ‘hideous place’ www.politico.com/news/2024/05/10/clarence-thomas-critics-… via @politico
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I'm confused on defense strategy. Daniels is relevant only to show there was a narrative she was ready to share at a crucial moment that could damage Trump, and he would be motivated to buy her off. The cross-x doesn't undermine that and gives her more air time with the jury.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Because stare decisis supposedly works with extra force in statutory cases--in principle, Congress could have fixed anything the Court got wrong--no prior decision upholding an agency reading should be in jeopardy, right? Unless the norms are different for a YOLO Court?
Chris Walker
@chris_j_walker
Attn #adlaw geeks: If Chevron is overruled, which judicial precedents upholding agency statutory interpretations come to mind that might then be challenged in court? I'll keep a 🧵 here of good examples.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Imagine the right-wing response if Democratic-appointed judges announced a boycott of George Mason or Pepperdine or, indeed, anywhere.
Ramesh Ponnuru
@RameshPonnuru
Thirteen federal judges say that absent major changes at Columbia, they won't hire anyone who chooses to go there (undergrad or law school) following this year.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
There is no way participating faculty can know if they are hurting their current students unless they know no one outperformed their GPA in their respective classes. Could other faculty withhold grades unless demonstrators are expelled? What are the ethical limits here?
Nick Craig
@nicholasmcraig
BREAKING: A professor at UNC Chapel Hill is apparently going to withhold grades from students if the administration does not unsuspend students who were part of protests last week #ncpol #ncga
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
“Neither Force, Nor Will” is apparently for weaklings.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
“I had to choose between the dog and my kids,” taken out of context, is not a great line given the puppy’s demise.
Steven Mazie
@stevenmazie
But the book is called...No Going Back
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Dear Columbia FedSoc Members, To make sure Columbia is a welcoming environment for conservative law students, we’ve decided to deny them job opportunities if they go there. You’re welcome. Signed, 13 Judges Confused About Their Job Description
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Won’t boycotting Columbia mean these judges are going to have to search harder to find law students instructed in the wrongheaded theory that the administrative state is unconstitutional?
Josh Chafetz
@joshchafetz
You will be shocked to learn that not only are all 13 Republicans; they're all Trump appointees.
7 of them are district judges in Texas.
Ramesh Ponnuru
@RameshPonnuru
Thirteen federal judges say that absent major changes at Columbia, they won't hire anyone who chooses to go there (undergrad or law school) following this year.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Josh Chafetz
@joshchafetz
You will be shocked to learn that not only are all 13 Republicans; they're all Trump appointees.
7 of them are district judges in Texas.
Ramesh Ponnuru
@RameshPonnuru
Thirteen federal judges say that absent major changes at Columbia, they won't hire anyone who chooses to go there (undergrad or law school) following this year.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"OK, so I lied about staring down a dictator, but I really did shoot my puppy," is probably not the ideal way to introduce yourself as a viable candidate for national office.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Well, they make a measurable difference in administrative workload and time diverted from teaching and research, so there’s that.
Robert Anderson
@ProfRobAnderson
Is there at some point going to be an assessment of assessment in education? Like to what extent do all these learning outcomes, syllabus boilerplate, and consultant fees make a *measurable* difference in anything?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The @DailyMailUK has posted a piece about producers of a popular TV program refusing to “change tact,” and I think we have definitively witnessed the death of copy editing.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If I were @POTUS, I’d be seeking an OLC opinion on whether there is a statutory or constitutional basis for insisting @POTUS has discretion to delay a formal finding on int’l law compliance by an aid recipient when the deadline would affect POTUS’s int’l negotiating flexibility.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Apparently, shoe-wearing pets can smoke?
Dakota Rudesill
@DakotaRudesill
Assume this is prohibited under animal welfare statutes but these days can’t hurt to spell it out
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I’d like to be in that space.
Tim Miller
@Timodc
We need to create a space in the discourse for people who are against terrorism/hostage taking, against reckless bombing of aid workers, against perpetuating famine, against anti-Semitic protests, against only protesting one side of the conflict, and against militarized police marching on the portlandia quad like they are invading Fallujah.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Trump will announce his stance on abortion during Infrastructure Week.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Rather than cutting a “rule for the ages” from whole cloth, shouldn’t the obvious move be, “Without foreclosing the possibility that there might be some scope for an ‘official acts’ immunity from criminal prosecution, the acts alleged here fall clearly beyond that scope?”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Despite X's pathologies, I use it to link to my work, to work by others I recommend, and to contribute to public law convos within my expertise. If these show up in 1000+ feeds, it's a great day. I made a snarky comment about #noem last night that's at 146,000 feeds and climbing.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
She learned the, “Cruelty is good” lesson and the “Never admit a mistake” lesson. She just didn’t get to the, “Don’t shoot your puppy” lesson.
Republicans against Trump
@RpsAgainstTrump
Kristi Noem just issued a new statement justifying the murder of her puppy:
“The fact is, South Dakota law states that dogs who attack and kill livestock can be put down. Given that Cricket had shown aggressive behavior toward people by biting them, I decided what I did…As I explained in the book, it wasn't easy. But often the easy way isn't the right way.” -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If you’re looking for the #presidentialimmunity Clause in the Constitution, it’s right next to the Presidential #removalpower Clause.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My inclination is more often to read a SCOTUS oral argument transcript than to listen in real time, and I’m always blown away by SG Prelogar’s skills as an advocate. Her preparation and presentation are off-the-charts exceptional.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/2 In our @monthly essay, @ReedShaw16 and I urged agencies to use of regulatory severability clauses to help protect ambitious new regulations. The new Labor Department rule increasing the compensation thresholds for overtime eligibility wisely does. washingtonmonthly.com/2024/04/16/protecting-biden-adminis…
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Here's the rule: www.dol.gov/sites/dolgov/files/WHD/flsa/ot-541-final-rule…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I live awfully close to a certain bridge I'd be happy to sell to anyone who thinks Alito is all about federalism.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Sara has been a lawyer's lawyer, as well as a scholar's scholar. She may know more about grand jury law than anyone else on earth.
Duke Law
@DukeLaw
WATCH: #endofanera - Prof. Sara Sun Beale is retiring after a legendary 45 years at Duke Law! Last week, she taught her final class, and fellow faculty, staff, and current students met her with 😍😍😍 and 👏👏👏 afterward. Thank you, Sara! We will miss you, dearly. 💙💙💙
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Isn’t Harry Connick, Jr. the obvious choice?
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Privileged to collaborate with @ReedShaw16 on a @monthly piece explaining that admin agencies can use severability clauses to help defend new rules from being voided in toto rather than forego public interest ambitions in the rush to beat CRA deadline washingtonmonthly.com/2024/04/16/protecting-biden-adminis…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
ICYMI: With Trump's Manhattan trial set to start Monday, it's a perfect time to listen to a @demchiefexecpod interview @CBHessick and I recorded last spring with @NormEisen and @OSU_Law prof and former NY ADA @ric_l_simmons concerning the Bragg indictment! open.spotify.com/episode/1MeUARFMP6U1FpnVrKisTr
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Below is a photo of all the women voters in the Arizona Territory in 1864 standing next to all the women legislators voting for the 1864 #arizonaabortionban.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
RFK's Trumpy manager is laying out an argument in '28 for Don Jr.: "“Bobby doesn’t have to go to president school. He knows how to be a president. He knows what his uncle did." RFK Jr. Campaign Official: My ‘No.1’ Priority Is Stopping Another Biden Win www.thedailybeast.com/rfk-jr-campaign-official-my-no1-pri…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For those who missed his pieces in @PennCERL on the unconstitutionality of unilateral presidential deployment of nuclear arms should Russia launch a nuclear attack on Ukraine-or if you just want the full-on analytic treatment-I highly recommend @DakotaRudesill's new paper on SSRN
Dakota Rudesill
@DakotaRudesill
What if US threatened & prepared plans for war and nobody discussed whether war would be constitutional? That has happened since 2022. Now out: my full-length legal analysis @OhioStateLJ @OSU_Law of US/NATO threats to strike Russia for nuking Ukraine. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4751901 1/4
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This thread provides a handy guide to an important @monthly initiative assessing the relative effectiveness of POTUS's 45 & 46 in accomplishing their key policy objectives--not whose policies are better, but who got more done. Hint: The Only-I-Can-Fix-It Guy not so impressive.
Paul @glastris.bsky.social Glastris
@glastris
Who got more done as president, Trump or Biden? This question could determine the outcome in November and @monthly answers it definitely in its latest issue. 1/ washingtonmonthly.com/2024/04/07/introduction-who-got-mor…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Very excited about this upcoming event!
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Proud to be on this brief.
Constitutional Accountability Center (CAC)
@MyConstitution
Our Constitution created a government with presidents, not kings. Read CAC's #scotus amicus brief on behalf of @tribelaw, @petermshane, @FOBowman3, @kewhittington, @ProfBrianKalt, and Michael Gerhardt explaining that Trump is not immune from prosecution:
www.theusconstitution.org/litigation/trump-v-united-states/ -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
As classy as she is talented, and that’s saying a lot.
Chad Leistikow🆑
@ChadLeistikow
Got to ask Caitlin Clark her final media question as a Hawkeye: How did you hold it all together and bring it every night, all the way to scoring 18 points in the first quarter of the national championship game?
Her final answer as a Hawk:
“Oh, gosh. I don’t know. I don’t get nervous for games. It’s crazy, like it’s the national championship, and I walk out there and I’m as calm as can be. I think that’s because I trust all the work I’ve put in. I know I’ve been ready for these moments. … I know this is my last time playing in a Hawkeye uniform, like there’s nothing to lose. We’re the underdog. Go out there and have a blast. I feel like that’s what I’ve done. I’m proud of the way I’ve carried myself. It’s certainly been hard at times, to always be in the spotlight and have everybody’s eyeballs on you. But I wouldn’t change it for the world. The positive and the negative. I’m so lucky, I’m so fortunate. That’s what I always remind myself. There’s so many people that would want to be in my shoes. It’s been a lot of pressure, but it’s been a lot of fun. And I feel like our team has risen to every single moment, every single challenge. Just so proud of our program.” -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Chad Leistikow🆑
@ChadLeistikow
Got to ask Caitlin Clark her final media question as a Hawkeye: How did you hold it all together and bring it every night, all the way to scoring 18 points in the first quarter of the national championship game?
Her final answer as a Hawk:
“Oh, gosh. I don’t know. I don’t get nervous for games. It’s crazy, like it’s the national championship, and I walk out there and I’m as calm as can be. I think that’s because I trust all the work I’ve put in. I know I’ve been ready for these moments. … I know this is my last time playing in a Hawkeye uniform, like there’s nothing to lose. We’re the underdog. Go out there and have a blast. I feel like that’s what I’ve done. I’m proud of the way I’ve carried myself. It’s certainly been hard at times, to always be in the spotlight and have everybody’s eyeballs on you. But I wouldn’t change it for the world. The positive and the negative. I’m so lucky, I’m so fortunate. That’s what I always remind myself. There’s so many people that would want to be in my shoes. It’s been a lot of pressure, but it’s been a lot of fun. And I feel like our team has risen to every single moment, every single challenge. Just so proud of our program.” -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I think the "tell" regarding bias in Cannon's most recent opinion is her reference to Smith's request for a ruling on the PRA as "unjust." That's a very odd and defensive word to use even if she thinks the motion was premature. She has not chided Trump for any frivolous filing.
Mueller, She Wrote
@MuellerSheWrote
THREAD: I've read over all the filings, & after consulting a bunch of experts, & after recording this weekend's episode of the Jack podcast, here's what I think Jack Smith will do w/re to Cannon's ruling on Trump's motion to dismiss based on the Presidential Records Act. 1/
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The epicenter was Trump's Bedminster golf course, so she could have a point.
@scottjshapiro.bsky.social
@scottjshapiro
<Neil deGrasse Tyson voice>
There is actually no scientific evidence to back this claim. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I'm not an enthusiast for reductionist amateur psycho-biographical explanation for insidious politicians, but watching #rfkjr, I can't help wonder about the impact of a traumatic childhood loss of the widely revered father whose name you share.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
#nolabels = No Candidate = Good news
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My take in @monthly: Alito’s questions on standing in the #mifepristone case seem conspicuously at odds with several key #standing precedents written by Alito. washingtonmonthly.com/2024/04/02/with-abortion-drug-alito…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The mental effort required to distinguish satirical #aprilfoolsday2024 prank tweets promoting Trump, right-wing extremism, and jurisprudential nonsense from sincere tweets promoting about Trump, right-wing extremism, and jurisprudential nonsense is exhausting.
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
So exhausting that I forgot to delete "about"
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
On April 11, I will be talking “Law and the Presidency in Crisis Times” at a free public program at the New School for Social Research. A special joy will be joining with my good friend, Dean Alex Aleinikoff. It's open to all, but registration is required. event.newschool.edu/lawandthepresidency
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Trump on his Bible: “I hear people say it’s the best testament. Unbelievable. Six Books of Moses and Ten Corinthians! The world’s never seen anything like it!”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Thanks to amazing guests like Russ Feingold, Kate Masur, @Nedfoley, Elaine Kamarck, @RickPildes, Bob Bauer, Theda Skocpol, @WendyRWeiser, Gilda Daniels, Alex Keyssar, @kateashaw1 , @geoffgarin, @WhitAyres, Peniel Joseph, Steve Skowronek, Ben Ginsberg, Bertrall Ross, @LizaGoitein
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
As of today, our library of episodes from Seasons 1 & 2 have elicited 3700 listens. On behalf of @petermshane and his Season 2 cohost, Dale Russakoff, thank you! If you haven’t checked out the conversations on presidential election season, now’s the time. open.spotify.com/episode/0ej7D36un1YsouLF1sPD7k
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Not to mention Garrett Epps, Gerard Magliocca, @NormEisen, Sam Issacharoff, Ellen Weintraub, Margaret Kwoka, Heidi Kitrosser, Ric Simmons, @CBHessick, Mark Rozell, Matt Waxman, Mike Gerhardt, Liz Holtzman, Sandy Maisel, @rudalev, Lee Drutman, and Charlotte Hill!
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
And Payvand Ahdout!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Listening to just a bit of this morning's mifepristone arguments, I am 110% persuaded that Justice Alito opposes abortion. The Solicitor General's command of the record is a master lesson in advocacy.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
There should be a series of @BidenHQ ads with the same look and feel, each of which shows a former highly placed Trump Administration official denouncing him followed by a clip of Trump illustrating what the speaker is denouncing.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I just received a Dem fundraising text ostensibly from @alfranken that begins, “They say a picture is worth a thousand words.” I greatly respect @alfranken and wish he were a Senator, but I can’t imagine a less felicitous way for a Franken text to begin.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Thank you sincerely for this. If anything, “taking one for the team” is more morally vacuous than, “just following orders,” and the latter doesn’t tend to work out so well either.
Liz Cheney
@Liz_Cheney
Ronna facilitated Trump’s corrupt fake elector plot & his effort to pressure MI officials not to certify the legitimate election outcome.She spread his lies & called 1/6 “legitimate political discourse.” That’s not “taking one for the team.” It’s enabling criminality & depravity.
Meet the Press
@MeetThePress
WATCH: Former RNC Chair Ronna McDaniel says she doesn’t support freeing those charged and convicted with crimes related to January 6th — something Donald Trump has promised to do if re-elected.
@kwelkernbc: “Why not speak out earlier?”
@RonnaMcDaniel: “When you’re the RNC Chair, you kind of take one for the whole team." -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I read this with great interest, but am not sure how to apply the idea. Would prosecuting the president for accepting a bribe in return for a pardon be impermissible? What about firing an FBI director in order to corruptly impede an investigation? www.lawfaremedia.org/article/moving-beyond-absolutes-on-p…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Here's the deal(s): How about Dems offer Johnson 5 votes if he'll put Ukraine and border security up for a vote? OR Dems offer 50-50 Senate-type committee leadership deal to Republic moderates for 5 votes to make @RepJeffries speaker?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Here’s the latest on student loan relief from the Biden Administration—including for teachers, nurses, and firefighters. www.npr.org/2024/03/21/1239931447/biden-student-loan-publ…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For a thorough guide to how SCOTUS, in the name of separation of powers, is helping to incapacitate both Congress and the executive branch, Lisa Heinzerling has you covered. www.theregreview.org/2024/03/18/heinzerling-the-supreme-c…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Will the false insinuation that your dad was involved in the JFK murder keep you from endorsing Trump? (Cruz: No.) How about years of maliciously slandering and race-taunting your wife? (McConnell: No.) How about telling rioters you deserve to hang? (Pence: A noose too far.)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
via @NYTimes As New York’s most powerful Jewish political leader with a steadfastly pro-Israel record, this is a very big deal. I feel grateful for Schumer’s act of leadership. www.nytimes.com/2024/03/14/us/politics/schumer-netanyahu-…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Who had the most memorable--for the wrong reasons--GOP response to a Democratic SOTU Address?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is not the lesser of two evils. It’s a positive vision of social solidarity.
Headquarters
@HQNewsNow
New ad just dropped 🔥
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Just a friendly reminder to Alabama: You’ve been represented by some really smart Senators in the past, whether as conservative as Howell Heflin or more liberal, like Doug Jones. Why not do better?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Translation: “I had no principles then. I have no principles now.”
Manu Raju
@mkraju
Asked Mitch McConnell how he reconciled his Trump endorsement with the fact that he called him practically and morally responsible for January 6th, and the fact that Trump insulted him and his wife repeatedly.
McConnell’s response: “February 25th, 2021, shortly after the attack on the Capitol, I was asked a similar question, and I said I would support the nominee for president even if it were the former president.” -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I fear that among its allies, the U.S. is going from “friend we look up to” to “friend whose advice we seek so that we can do the opposite.”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Today's majority seems to say Sec. 3 enforcement against federal candidates must rely on a statute specifically tailored to Sec. 3. If true even for a federal civil action, the Electoral Count Reform Act probably can't be used to challenge electors pledged to an insurrectionist.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
With a SCOTUS majority unnecessarily deciding states can't on their own disqualify anyone from holding any federal office, not just the presidency, under the 14th Am., incumbent Congress members who may become implicated in the Jan. 6 prosecutions are no doubt breathing easier.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
After 11 @DemChiefExecPod episodes with experts on POTUS elections, co-hosts @petermshane and Dale Russakoff did a short podcast linking themes from the 11 to current events. open.spotify.com/episode/28NvRDvQjHMmTtoUbYVNNY Below, they discuss the disconnect between experts and the Court on the 14th Am.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Time for #potus to propose broad IVF-protection legislation at the federal level. Protecting against liability for tort damages that rest upon a legal characterization of frozen embryos as persons is within Congress’s power to protect clinic participation in interstate commerce.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/2 With Putin raising the specter of nuclear conflict, @DakotaRudesill has explained why - absent clear indications that Russia is seriously preparing or has initiated an armed attack on the U.S., U.S. forces, or NATO allies – presidents lack authority to www.penncerl.org/the-rule-of-law-post/presidential-war-po…
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
2/2 attack Russia simply because Russia uses a nuclear weapon against Ukraine. Another part of his series lays out alternatives for punishing Russia should it use nuclear weapons in Ukraine. www.penncerl.org/the-rule-of-law-post/alternatives-to-pun…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
To round out “12 Days of President’s Day,” @DemChiefExecPod offers a new “Connecting the Dots” episode! Co-hosts @petermshane and Dale Russakoff talk about how prior episodes inform their reactions to SCOTUS arguments in the Colorado disqualification case. open.spotify.com/episode/28NvRDvQjHMmTtoUbYVNNY
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/2 When I wrote months ago in @monthly about #project2025, the right-wing recruitment and agenda setting initiative headed by the Heritage Foundation, I hoped to alert readers to the frightening aspirations of Trump 2.0. washingtonmonthly.com/2023/11/13/blitzkrieg-against-the-a… @CarlosNYT in today's @nytimes...
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
has a masterful summary of the project's new version of "Mandate for Leadership." The close reading he provides of the book's 887 pages is a major service to the cause of democracy. Don't let anyone fool you about the stakes in the 2024 election. www.nytimes.com/2024/02/29/opinion/project-2025-trump-adm…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For Day 11 of the “12 Days of President’s Day,” hear Garrett Epps and Gerard Magliocca discuss on @Demchiefexecpod Ep. 11 the 14th Am. disqualification of insurrectionists. open.spotify.com/episode/6kIlWmQlcrWGXpFwFjkzeu Gerard explains below how Sec. 3 dominated the news when the 14th Am. was adopted.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The SCOTUS schedule itself need not preclude a trial before Election Day. What I fear is the invention of some ridiculous “scope of immunity” test requiring further legal argument in the lower courts. THAT would make a trial before Election Day impossible.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Shouldn't only the best of this material have survived?
Niko McCarty.
@NikoMcCarty
Everything that Charles Darwin ever wrote is now available online.
All of his books. All of his diary drafts. All of his notebooks. In one place.
Darwin Online has assembled "a complete catalog of Darwin's personal library virtually." It took 18 years.
darwin-online.org.uk -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For Day 10 of the “12 Days of President’s Day,” @Yale's Stephen Skowronek and @UVALaw's Bertrall Ross explore the presidency and U.S. democracy on Ep. 10 of @demchiefexecpod. open.spotify.com/episode/7H4ucKuVGzTAkDO52Ne5oh Below, Steve talks about a pattern in our perception of presidential leadership.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If I were an agency general counsel, helping to wind up a significant regulatory initiative in this election year, I’d lose more sleep over the major questions doctrine than the future of Chevron. My essay in @monthly explains why. washingtonmonthly.com/2024/02/27/this-will-be-a-big-year-…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For Day 9 of the “12 Days of President’s Day,” scholars @PenielJoseph, @KateMasur, and Theda Skocpol put the January 6 Capitol attack in historical perspective on @Demchiefexecpod Ep. 9. open.spotify.com/episode/3ffpMOIGXwPEu95FBzydFT Below, Kate explains how disinformation fed insurrection in 1861.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
FWIW, I didn’t see the dismay expressed by law profs quoted by Jesse Wegman over the challenges of teaching con law as a plea for sympathy. Being paid to probe important issues with talented students and gifted scholarly colleagues is an amazing privilege, even on a “bad day.”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
On Day 8 of the “12 Days of President’s Day,” @demchiefexecpod Ep. 8 reviews the Electoral Count Reform Act w/ Genevieve Nadeau, and Alberto Gonzales & Mary McCord talk about prosecuting presidents. open.spotify.com/episode/6N2MSYuhW2cxcrm2uYlwGg Below, the former AG bemoans MAGA's anti-DOJ rhetoric.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
On Day 7 of the “12 Days of President’s Day,” get an inside view of POTUS campaign lawyering via @DemChiefExecPod from Bob Bauer (D) and Ben Ginsberg (R). Hear also about the causes that unite Bob and Ben. open.spotify.com/episode/7jgNE2a4WUtQUF7qYepZfZ In this clip, Ben describes the job's scope.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
On Day 6 of "The Twelve Days of President's Day," listen to @BrennanCenter VP @WendyRWeiser and Prof. Gilda Daniels discuss the right to vote on @demchiefexecpod. open.spotify.com/episode/2GX0IKDH6SP3ZfKVpzyHzp Feel like it was easier to vote amid COVID? On the clip below, Wendy explains.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The Alabama Supreme Court construes an 1872 wrongful death statute as creating a claim for punitive damages based on death of "extrauterine children," a phrase that would surely have puzzled legislators a century before the first IVF birth. publicportal-api.alappeals.gov/courts/68f021c4-6a44-4735-…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Mark Day 5 of the “12 Days of President’s Day” with @demchiefexecpod Ep. 5! @acslaw Pres @russfeingold and @FEC member Ellen Weintraub discuss Big Money and Politics. Below, Russ names the key reform piece SCOTUS expected, but Congress never enacted! open.spotify.com/episode/2FaHIDu7sXGY5xrmKLfyIi
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Wanting puzzles on Day 4 of the “12 Days of President’s Day?” In Ep. 4 of @demchiefexecpod, poli. sci. folk @leedrutman, @hill_charlotte, and @SandyMaisel explore our 2-party system. open.spotify.com/episode/2p92BrDrMA4Yt3AzPrsJNa Lee mentions below a disconnect between voter preferences and behavior.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Does 2024 seem different from earlier seasons? The Dems’ vanity candidates went nowhere, and the GOP is now the party of Trump, even if the GOP establishment would have blocked him if given a chance in 2016.
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
The most significant change we've made to the structure of elections in the last 50 years is the replacement of the convention system with today's system of primaries for choosing the parties' nominees for President. Few know more about this than Elaine Karmarck.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Celebrate Day 3 of the “Twelve Days of President’s Day” with Ep. 3 of @demchiefexecpod: Choosing Candidates. Political scientist Elaine Kamarck and legal scholar @RickPildes bemoan the diminished role of political parties. Below, a short clip of Elaine. open.spotify.com/episode/22rM45F11MphxusKZYQwRK
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Mark Day 2 of “The 12 Days of President’s Day” with Episode 2 of this season of @demchiefexecpod, exploring political polling. @WhitAyres and @geoffgarin share insider perspectives. Here’s Whit explaining the uniqueness of political forecasting in 2024. open.spotify.com/episode/5daoAyF6OmAn2nLaMMkOAR
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Welcome to “The 12 Days of President's Day!” Each day we'll highlight 1 of 11 @demchiefexecpod episodes focusing on POTUS elections. On Day 12, we debut a mini-episode for Dale & me to talk about how insights from the episodes resonate in daily headlines. open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
To celebrate Day 1, I offer for your consideration Episode 1 in which Dale Russakoff and I talk to historian and social scientist Alex Keyssar and Election Law scholar @Nedfoley about the #electoralcollege-its origins, how it shapes elections, and efforts to reform or abolish it.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Closely related to "Standing Too Close to Hotel Window Syndrome"
Julia Ioffe
@juliaioffe
The Russian authorities are now, I shit you not, saying @navalny’s death was caused by “sudden death syndrome.” If Alexey heard it, he’d make some amazing jokes about it. meduza.io/news/2024/02/17/materi-navalnogo-soobschili-v-k…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Judge Engeron’s surprised that Trump couldn’t own up to a venial sin?? He can’t even admit that mixing up Nicki Haley and Nancy Pelosi was inadvertent. He would have told his father that the cherry tree committed suicide.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If you need another reason to despise our weird system for choosing presidents, @derektmuller has a thoughtful guide to the chaos that awaits on 1/6/25 if Trump appears to have 270+ electoral votes and the disqualification issue has not been resolved. electionlawblog.org?p=141403
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My take on #immunity: "The Court should act quickly to reject a claim of legal immunity for former presidents that lacks any constitutional basis and is so at odds with the rule of law." This case is easier and ultimately more important than the Colorado ballot case.
Washington Monthly
@monthly
Why the Supreme Court should promptly reject Trump’s immunity claim and why there's a damn good chance they will by @Petermshane in the Washington @Monthly.
washingtonmonthly.com/2024/02/14/why-the-supreme-court-sh… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/2 I wonder about the impact of the #mayorkas impeachment on impeachment-related norms. As far as I know--and I could be wrong--the Senate has never refused to hold a trial after receiving Articles from the House, but is this a constitutional obligation? A Senate rule? Norm?
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
2/2 If it becomes acceptable for the House to bring charges below the "high crimes" standard when Senate acquittal is a foregone conclusion, should it be acceptable for Senate to dismiss such Articles without trial--at least for non-POTUS targets? @joshchafetz? @kewhittington?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Jack, no Trumper, writes a "defining characteristic of the Trump era...is that institutional actors violate norms in response to Trump’s norm violations and possibly illegal actions, thus further damaging norms and institutions." But one-sided observance of a norm = no norm. In
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Jack Smith's rush to prosecute Trump for the events of Jan. 6 violates Justice Department rules. The Supreme Court now faces the question whether it too will be a party to this rush, and, if not, how it will avoid it.
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-consequences-of-jack-smi…
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
the Prisoner's Dilemma, the prisoner who maintains the norm of noncooperation while the other makes a deal gets the longest possible sentence. A normative equilibrium cannot be reestablished through one-sided acquiescence in another party's breaches.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Proud to be on this brief opposing Trump's application for a stay.
Constitutional Accountability Center (CAC)
@MyConstitution
Our Constitution created a government with presidents, not kings. Read CAC's #scotus amicus brief on behalf of @tribelaw, @petermshane, @FOBowman3, @kewhittington, @ProfBrianKalt, and Michael Gerhardt explaining that Trump is not immune from prosecution: www.theusconstitution.org/litigation/trump-v-united-states/
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Unfortunately, and with every good intention, @nyulaw reposted a quote attributed to me by a good reporter who, because of my careless email writing, understandably misread the email as the opposite of what I think. Moral: Don't email hastily if you have a head cold. What I...
This post is unavailable. See it on X.
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
thought I conveyed to the reporter was that I regard the anti-immunity arguments as so strong, I have a hard time imagining that Kavanaugh or Barrett would vote for immunity, i.e., in favor of Trump's position.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
“Nikki Haley, please do an online search for famous quotes by Martin Niemoller and get back to us.”
Kyle Griffin
@kylegriffin1
Nikki Haley: "Why is there silence from the Republican Party? Like, where is everybody? … Where are the Republicans in defense of our men and women in uniform that sacrifice for us and protect our country?"
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
As additional relief...Trump requests that this Court direct that the D.C. Circuit’s mandate is stayed pending the resolution, not just of proceedings in this Court, but also of ...Trump’s planned petition for en banc consideration in the D.C. Circuit, which he intends to file...
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Thanks to @danieltdeacon for the link to Trump's stay application!
Dan Deacon
@danieltdeacon
From NBC News: www.documentcloud.org/documents/24424126-23a745
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Anyone have a copy of Trump's SCOTUS filing to stay the D.C. Circuit's mandate?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If I am allowed to nominate a candidate for Best Black History Month Thread/Sports Category, here's my entry. For someone who has followed football only sporadically, at best, this was fascinating.
Michael Harriot
@michaelharriot
Today, a lot of old Black men will be rooting for the KC Chiefs.
It has nothing to do with Taylor Swift, a Black QB or Travis Kelce's pioneering haircut. It's about HBCUs, Black history, a kidnapping & white affirmative action.
How Racism Invented the Super Bowl
A thread. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Until they give birth to the child who discovers the cure for cancer while also reversing the effects of climate change, it’s hard to imagine a better week for @taylorswift13 and @tkelce than winning Album of the Year and the Super Bowl.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I’m not one to think that it is the plan of a Supreme Deity that puts political leaders in their respective offices. But in terms of meeting the challenges of their moment, I’d find it easier to write that brief for @POTUS than for Speaker Moses—I mean, Mike—Johnson.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Attacks on younger Biden’s gaffes were meant to say he was culturally out of step or not smart. Now that his slips fit a culturally handy age-related stereotype, that’s the narrative. Here’s my take: He is an imperfect, but phenomenally accomplished public servant who misspeaks.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The press is saying @POTUS confused the presidents of Egypt and Mexico. He did not. He said the right president, but Mexico instead of Egypt. His analysis of the situation suggests he has full command of policy and strategy.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Two possible lessons from @Trevornoah hosting the Grammy’s: (1) He should host all awards shows. (2) When, having been invited to host a party, you find yourself surrounded by some of the most talented people in the world, share the excitement of that setting and ditch the snark.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
So the Senate GOP strategy is, "Democrats, we may give you the President's top priorities as long as you don't make us vote for the things we wanted because we don't want you to take credit for compromising with us?" Seems weird.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The Peter Principle (named for sociologist Laurence Peter) that people in hierarchical organizations get promoted until they’re in a position for which they are not competent isn’t enough to explain the House GOP. We need an MTG Principle to explain this level of incompetence.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Today’s events made clear that @SenatorLankford committed the sin that MAGA won’t forgive: taking governance seriously, even when it means keeping your word and bargaining in good faith. Power for the extreme right = performance art, and they are mindblowingly incompetent at it.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
So far, my thoughts on immunity have been viewed about 400 times and about #fastcar 50,000+, which makes me think our national priorities are not out of whack.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
While your mind is darting today between "No #immunity for Trump" and "Could I just see Tracy and Luke one more time?" check out this excellent thread.
AJ Chan
@mrajchan
Like everyone else, I was moved by Tracy Chapman & Luke Combs at the Grammy's
Tracy's an anti-celebrity:
-uncomfortable in the public eye
-doesn't own a smart phone
-not on social
There isn't a lot of info on her
But here's what I found on her and the history of Fast Car 🧵This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
D.C. Circuit: ""Trump’s alleged efforts to remain in power . . . were, if proven, an unprecedented assault on the structure of our government." Question: Might that be an "#insurrection" against the Constitution of the United States? Sounds insurrection-y.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"Trump’s alleged efforts to remain in power . . . were, if proven, an unprecedented assault on the structure of our government. He allegedly injected himself into a process in which the President has no role . . . thereby undermining constitutionally established procedures . . ."
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"President Trump has become citizen Trump, with all of the defenses of any other criminal defendant. But any executive immunity that may have protected him while he served as President no longer protects him against this prosecution." storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cadc.40415/g…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The D.C. Circuit's unanimous opinion affirming the denial of #immunity from prosecution is here storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cadc.40415/g…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
D.C. Circuit affirms Chutkan on Trump's lack of immunity.
Kyle Cheney
@kyledcheney
BREAKING: Donald Trump is *NOT* immune from prosecution, DC Circuit rules.
Details TK -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
MAGA's upset by a driven, talented woman getting girls to care about football and voting. But today’s #1 streamed song is a white male country star and an Af-Am woman folk legend singing about poor young people struggling to find hope and belonging. Maybe love does conquer hate
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Kellyanne Conway's NYT advice on Trump's VP pick offers much nonsense. A choice bit is that he pick "a person of color," not as "identity politics," "but as an equal helping to lead a. . .movement" with "more . . .Hispanics, Asian Americans and African Americans." Parse that.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Because there’s no such thing as too much speculation about the future of Chevron, here’s my take. (No J.D. required.)
Washington Monthly
@monthly
As the Supreme Court Reconsiders “Chevron Deference,” Will Its Ruling Be Monumental or “Meh”? @petermshane explains.
washingtonmonthly.com/2024/02/02/as-the-supreme-court-rec… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If @taylorswift13 supports overturning #chevron, I don't know if I could shake it off. (satire)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In the world of subjects about which I should know and care less: I am puzzled why, with new media interest in and discussion of @SuitsPeacock and an apparent LA spinoff, @RickHoffman_ doesn't get mentioned more. His dramatic chops & comic timing were central to many an episode.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I am hardly alone in thinking that, although the 14th Amendment disqualifies Trump from being POTUS, SCOTUS won’t say so, for motives either prudential or cynical. If so, how they dodge that outcome is important. In @monthly I suggest the least bad option. washingtonmonthly.com/2024/01/25/the-least-harmful-way-to…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/2 The # of legal and political issues enmeshed in the 14th Am. disqualification fight makes coverage in a single hour tough! Here's a guide to great podcast discussions you can lean from: @demchiefexecpod - Garrett Epps and Gerard Magliocca open.spotify.com/episode/6kIlWmQlcrWGXpFwFjkzeu;
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
2/2 Supreme Myths – @espinsegall and @DorfonLaw
open.spotify.com/episode/36Hj943SbonHNeyeW7vxBd; Divided Argument – Dan Epps and Wil Baude
open.spotify.com/episode/6DnmbXk3GVvb0IB3EmMS15; The @EzraKlein Show – with David French
open.spotify.com/episode/0qisgNBqbnir0FONSmRAg9;
Broken Law – Jeanne Hruska and Leslie Langholz
open.spotify.com/episode/1yCaxB53P9SFzwtHZnfagp -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is a lively and hugely informative conversation on @DemChiefExecPod with two 14th Amendment scholars, Garrett Epps and Gerard Magliocca. Gerard wrote a major article on the Disqualification Clause BEFORE January 6. We ask what else he can predict! 😉
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Bonus episode! @petermshane & Dale Russakoff talk to Garrett Epps & Gerard Magliocca about Donald Trump and the 14th Amendment Disqualification Clause. Does it cover POTUS? Need Congress legislate first? Is Trump an "insurrectionist?" What will SCOTUS do? open.spotify.com/episode/7H4ucKuVGzTAkDO52Ne5oh
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is comedy gold.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
One theory for how curbing Chevron could affect courts: we’ll see more use of the major questions doctrine. Chevron makes judicial decision making easier. Curbing it makes the court’s work more demanding. What makes life easier again? MQD. (But it could make little difference.)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Hmmm. . .I seem to be only 10 followers short of 3000, and at least 25 of the 2990 are not catfishing bots.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
An interesting/revealing graphic based on research by Professors Lee Epstein and Mitu Gulati
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Trump is doing us the rare favor of saying exactly what he wants — to be accountable to no one. Remember the flood of prosecutions that followed Nixon needing a pardon and Clinton making a plea deal? Right—there was none.
The Lincoln Project
@ProjectLincoln
"Even events that 'cross the line' must fall under total immunity"
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It was already persuasive in MSWord and totally compelling in print. Congrats to @narosenblum and @ascoseriakatz. (P.S. Would love to have the reprint on my bookshelf 😉.)
Noah Rosenblum
@narosenblum
Behold! In print w/ @ascoseriakatz!!! Thank you to @ColumLRev and our great editor Jackson Springer and the rest of the team!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In a @demchiefexecpod episode taped in Oct., GOP Pollster @WhitAyres predicted the results of the Iowa GOP caucuses and the Christie and Hutchinson dropouts, explaining why all of this would happen. For the full talk also with Dem @geoffgarin, check out open.spotify.com/episode/22rM45F11MphxusKZYQwRK."
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If you're reading the #iowa #caucus news and thinking, "This is maybe not the best way to choose presidential candidates!" you'll enjoy the conversation between @RickPildes and @EKamarck on @demchiefexecpod about "Choosing Candidates" open.spotify.com/episode/22rM45F11MphxusKZYQwRK
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The 10 pre-planned @demchiefexecpod Season 2 episodes are available now. A bonus episode feat. Garrett Epps and @GerardNMagliocc on Trump and the #disqualification Clause launches next week. While waiting, check out our discussions giving context to daily Election Year news!
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
All 10 regular Season 2 episodes! They resonate with today’s headlines. For example, after reading this story on POTUS’s fund-raising haul www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2024/01/15/biden-fundrais…, listen to our discussion with @russfeingold and Ellen Weintraub about campaign finance. open.spotify.com/episode/2FaHIDu7sXGY5xrmKLfyIi
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Worth a read. From Ha’aretz. www.haaretz.com/opinion/2024-01-03/ty-article-opinion/.pr…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A great find from the indefatigable @jedshug.
Jed Shugerman
@jedshug
I'm interrupting my 2-month Twitter hiatus b/c I've just found a highly relevant speech from the Ratification debates (1788):
Against Presidential Immunity & Unitary Executive theory (interpreting the Opinions Clause).
Future SCOTUS Justice Iredell, NC Convention, 7/28/1788: -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I repeat: He will try to speak at any trial without testifying under oath.
Robert Costa
@costareports
Trump told me today at 40 Wall Street that he plans to attend all of his trials, civil and criminal, state and federal. A remark that could have an impact on the campaign calendar and general election, if he packs his time with sometimes voluntary appearances in various courthouses. @CBSNews
COSTA: Have you made decision about whether you're going to show up for the federal trials? You’ve showed up here in New York for your civil fraud trial. You just said you're going to show up for the E Jean Carroll case. Are you planning to show up in court…
Trump: Yeah – [crosstalk]
COSTA: … when they begin, whenever they begin.
TRUMP: Sure, sure
COSTA: In that documents case and the January 6th case?
TRUMP: I would do that. … I want to go to all of my trials… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Trump will try to give a closing statement at any criminal trial he faces because it’s a way to testify not under oath. He saw it on Suits.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
What is utterly amazing about this is that he cannot imagine any presidential motivation other than revenge. For normal presidents, the certainty that they would one day be former presidents would be a powerful disincentive to play prosecutorial tit-for-tat.
Acyn
@Acyn
Reporter: Do you agree with what your lawyers argued that you could not be prosecuted if ordered Seal Team Six to kill your political opponent?
Trump: If a President does not have immunity, he’ll be totally ineffective -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"That everyone on both airliners walked away is, indeed, a miracle...of regulation, training, expertise, effort and constant improvement of infrastructure, as well as the professionalism and heroism of the crew." The Truth About Airplane Safety www.nytimes.com/2024/01/09/opinion/alaska-airlines-safety…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Someone has had it with shoveling snow.
Chris Walker
@chris_j_walker
👀👀
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Honored to have joined this letter by constitutional law scholars explaining why even deep disagreements with @HHSGov Secretary #mayorkas over immigration enforcement policy do not amount to constitutional grounds for impeachment. www.justsecurity.org/91123/constitutional-law-scholars-on…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The last scheduled @demchiefexecpod this season (hint: a bonus episode is coming) was great. Does POTUS play irreconcilable roles? Does our election system increase risk of democratic failure? Do frustrations with our separation of powers lay groundwork for authoritarianism?
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
The last pre-scheduled episode of @DemChiefExecPod S2 asks if U.S. democracy is well-served by the presidency in its current form. @Petermshane & Dale Russakoff explore the issues with @Yale political scientist Stephen Skowronek & @UVALaw’s Bertrall Ross. open.spotify.com/episode/7H4ucKuVGzTAkDO52Ne5oh
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
And now for something not political: For all the curiosity I’ve seen about Meghan Markle’s absence from the #goldenglobes #suits reunion, what I’ve been wondering is, where was Rick Hoffman?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I am trying to imagine what it would be like to have this man’s resources at my disposal and think THIS is how I could best use my time and fortune to make life on this planet better.
Bill Ackman
@BillAckman
Last night, no one at @MIT had a good night’s sleep.
Yesterday evening, shortly after I posted that we were launching a plagiarism review of all current MIT faculty, President Kornbluth, members of MIT’s administration, and its board, I am sure that an audible collective gasp could be heard around the campus.
Why? Well, every faculty member knows that once their work is targeted by AI, they will be outed. No body of written work in academia can survive the power of AI searching for missing quotation marks, failures to paraphrase appropriately, and/or the failure to properly credit the work of others.
But it wasn’t just the MIT faculty that did not sleep last night. The @Harvard faculty, its governing board members, and its administrative leadership did not sleep either. Because why would we stop at MIT?
Don’t we have to do a deep dive into academic integrity at Harvard as well?
What about Yale, Princeton, Stanford, Penn, Dartmouth? You get the point.
While we are going to do a detailed review of plagiarism at MIT, we are not going to be the only ones who do so.
Every college and university in the world is going to have to do the same for themselves. They will do so because they will need to validate all plagiarism accusations, or someone else will do it for them.
The best approach, however, is probably to launch an AI startup to do this job (I would be interested in investing in one) as there is plenty of work to do, and many institutions won’t have the resources to do it on their own. Perhaps more importantly, the donors are going to demand that the review is done by an independent third party.
For who today is going to trust higher education to review itself?
Consider the inherently irreconcilable conflicts of interest. Would you trust today’s university president to do an examination of their faculty? What are the chances that the reviews would be weaponized to go after faculty members whose politics were not favored by leadership?
We have seen this before with other tools used by university presidents and their deans. Consider the weaponization of MeToo accusations, speech codes, and the other tactics of cancellation that have destroyed free speech on campus, and many faculty members’ reputations, careers, and their families.
By analogy, who would trust even our most credible corporations with auditing their own financial statements? There is a reason why all public companies have independent auditors who are carefully examined by regulators to ensure they maintain quality, standards, accuracy, and independence.
And what if a plagiarism review turned into an incredible embarrassment for the entire university? It could lead to wholesale firings of faculty. Donors terminating their donations. Federal funding being withdrawn, and a massive litigious conflagration where faculty members and universities sue one another about what is plagiarism, and what is not. Think about the inevitable destruction of the reputations of thousands of faculty members as it rolls out around the country, and perhaps the world.
And maybe that’s a good thing.
The Impact of Higher Education on Society and Our Country
When I woke up on the morning of October 7th, my first thought was not that I was going to launch an effort to save higher education from itself. I had other more pressing concerns about the world, and I still have these concerns. But as we all know, our higher education system (HES) is critically important as it can affect and influence the minds of our younger generations, thereby profoundly impacting the lives of all of us.
The HES can affect what’s taught to toddlers and what is taught in elementary and high schools, as ed schools train the next generation of teachers and superintendents, and design the curricula they teach.
The HES can convince a generation that some of us are oppressors, and others are the oppressed, and provide justifications for what kinds and what degree of violence and terrorism are appropriate tools to address this perceived oppression.
The HES can affect our medical establishments and the ethics of medicine, e.g., some of our most controversial procedures and medicines, and the advisability of their use on children, and so on. You get the point, I am sure.
The HES affects our legal system, our ethics, and our basic understanding of right and wrong.
It affects how we think about capitalism and our economic system, and how we address wealth inequality, taxation, monetary and fiscal policy, and consider universal basic income and other alternatives.
It also affects religion and how it is practiced and no longer practiced around the country.
It can advance a monetary theory which states that the U.S. as a sovereign nation has effectively no limit to its spending because it can just print new money without any consequences or loss of solvency.
And then, of course, the graduates of our education system over time become the judges, the Supreme Court justices, the politicians, the members of the media, and the other people that influence and determine our way of life, and help us understand the truth, but whose truth? you might ask.
The HES influences how our national voting system should be administered; the standards for eligibility to run for office; how the primary system works, and what it takes to qualify to be on a ballot in a state.
I could continue, but I am sure that you already understand the power of the HES. You don’t need me to tell you how important it is.
In light of the power of HES, those interested in power would of course desire to take control of our most prestigious and influential universities so that they could ultimately take control of our education system, our government, and then the country at large.
The Power of AI and Its Impact on Plagiarism
Now that we know that the academic body of work of every faculty member at every college and university in the country (and eventually the world) is going to be reviewed for plagiarism, it’s important to ask what the implications are going to be.
If every faculty member is held to the current plagiarism standards of their own institutions, and universities enforce their own rules, they would likely have to terminate the substantial majority of their faculty members.
Over the last few weeks and months, I have literally received hundreds of emails, texts, hand- and type-written letters and cards, and phone calls of support (and 10s if not 100s of 1000s of posts and replies on X) – from friends and strangers, alumni, faculty and students, senior leaders of foreign countries, U.S. senators and members of congress, high profile members of the media, and several presidential candidates – for my efforts to help address the problems at Harvard, MIT, Penn and the higher education system at large. All of that said, most have been pessimistic about the opportunity for necessary change, as nearly everyone believes that it will take decades to fix the problem because of the life tenure system for faculty.
The good news, however, is that with AI, getting rid of tenured faculty is no longer as much of a challenge because it is much easier to fire faculty who have problems with their academic record. It is a near certainty that authors will miss some quotation marks and fail to properly cite or provide attribution for another author on at least a modest percentage of the pages of their papers. I say percentage of pages rather than number of instances, as the plagiarism of today can be best understood by comparison to spelling mistakes prior to the advent of spellcheck.
For example, it wouldn’t be fair to say that two papers are both riddled with spelling mistakes if each has 10 mistakes, when one paper has 30 pages and the other has 330. The standard has to be a percentage standard.
How pervasive are the spelling/plagiarism mistakes? is another question that should be asked. Does the purported plagiarism appear in a small minority of their papers or in the majority of their work?
Importantly, the most productive and important scholars are at the greatest risk under the current system because the more papers and pages you have written, the greater the probability that you missed a citation or some quotation marks, and it is much more likely that someone will check, (until yesterday). Plagiarism is the biggest threat for the most outstanding and most cited scholars because if no one ever reads your work and you do not have a public profile (nor or married to a high-profile person), no one will ever take the time to look.
The more impactful the work and the more important it is, the more likely it will be at risk of being reviewed for plagiarism. But if you have published only a dozen papers of modest length, and the papers are not particularly impactful or highly cited, the risk of having a large number of instances of plagiarism and having it be discovered should be relatively small.
Oppenheimer
The weaponization of AI for plagiarism has become the tactical nuke of the U.S. higher education system. That is potentially good news as the more I have learned about the HES, the clearer it has become that tactical devices and other powerful weapons may be required to win this war.
That said, as we learned in Oppenheimer, nuclear bombs can win wars, but they can also create enormous collateral damage and massive loss of innocent lives. They can kill tens, if not hundreds, of thousands of innocent civilians, so we need to be extremely careful about how these weapons are used. Because if the plagiarism nukes get into the wrong hands, even more damage can be done to our HES and the country.
So what should we do?
If you think about what plagiarism standards were designed for, the purpose was to protect scholars from the theft of their intellectual property. And protecting intellectual property is critically important as it is the lifeblood of our authors, composers, researchers, designers, architects, artists, companies, and effectively all modern institutions.
Interestingly, while AI can identify plagiarism, AI itself is the ultimate plagiarist. Large language models are by design built off the work of others, as computers have no innate knowledge, at least not yet. [As a side note, I am sure all of us are looking forward to learning the outcome of the NY Times lawsuit against OpenAI in light of its importance.]
As a result of AI, all institutions of higher learning are going to have to update their plagiarism standards.
The good news is that no paper written by a faculty member after the events of this past week will be published without a careful AI review for plagiarism, that, in light of recent events, has become a certainty.
But what do we do about papers written before today, which will inevitably fail an AI plagiarism test? The answer I believe is that there are different kinds of plagiarism, and it depends.
Some plagiarism is due to the laziness of the author. Laziness is not a great excuse for a member of the faculty, but it does not seem like a crime to me. It is more a reflection of the competency and motivation of the faculty member. In the real world, employees can be fired for being lazy, but this can be challenging to do under the tenure system.
Some plagiarism arises from being human, at least before AI systems. A tenured member of the faculty with thousands of pages of published work before the launch of AI systems is going to make some number of unintentional mistakes. The more papers they have published and the more total pages they have, the greater the likelihood of instances of plagiarism.
Other kinds of plagiarism, however, are much more pernicious, like for example, when important ideas are intentionally stolen without attribution. The worst form of plagiarism would be a case where an author intentionally stole another person’s work and presented it as his own, and it represented an important part of the new paper. I expect that this kind is rare, but it is clearly outright theft, and should be treated as such.
There remains, however, many open questions about plagiarism. For example:
Can one use a definition from an online dictionary or encyclopedia without attribution? I honestly don’t know the answer. I have never seen WikiPedia or dictionary.com cited in any paper. Before Business Insider emailed last night, I never thought about this before. And on this point, what was the standard 15 years ago for citing WikiPedia? Was it different then versus now?
This also raises a more modern question: Is it ok to plagiarize from ChatGPT today? Or does it depend on the outcome of the NY Times case?
You probably get my point by now. We are going to have to come up with new standards for plagiarism.
I think the standard will ultimately be the same as the one the Supreme Court uses for pornography.
To paraphrase Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart:
We will know it, when we see it.
I think universities will ultimately be forced to conclude that there are different kinds and degrees of plagiarism, and the punishment, if any, and the degree of its severity to the faculty member or student will have to be adjudicated based on the specific facts of each case.
As a result of recent events, academic/plagiarism review committees at universities will have to be expanded, as this now becomes a very big job. New standards will have to be designed, and new approaches will have to be taken to ensure that plagiarism review committees are comprised of independent members whose politics, friendships, or otherwise do not affect their judgment in adjudicating these cases.
How nefarious identified plagiarism is determined to be, I expect, will likely be a function principally of: (1) the nature and form of the plagiarism, (2) how pervasive it is in the scholar’s oeuvre, and (3) the nature and importance of what has been plagiarized, and perhaps to some extent, who or what has been plagiarized.
I do believe that intent matters with plagiarism as it does in the securities laws. For example, mens rea, in Latin “guilty mind” (Source: Google search top of page), which is defined by dictionary.com (!) as “the intention or knowledge of wrongdoing that constitutes part of a crime, as opposed to the action or conduct of the accused that plays an important role in determine[ing] the innocence or guilt of the accused in certain legal contexts.” This is not a great definition, but I will use it here in the interest of time.
I think intent matters because character matters. If the plagiarism was truly unintentional (and there are ways to judge whether this is the case), then I wouldn’t question the character of the author.
Unintentionality could simply be a result of rushing to meet a deadline, something all of us remember from our college days. Or it could be due to a misunderstanding or a lack of clarity as to whether one needs to cite dictionary.com or the amorphous “Google” as I did above for the translation of the Latin words mens rea.
In order to assess all of the above, we also need to know what the actual standards were at the time of the subject document’s creation.
Universities will need plagiarism review boards to systematically review and adjudicate each of the cases individually. That’s the only fair way to judge whether plagiarism meets the standard for various forms of punishment or not. The legal and practical implications for not doing so will cause severe harm to the accused who is convicted by the panel, and create enormous legal liability for the university, as it will have to defend itself in cases brought by faculty members and students whose careers and lives have been harmed and/or destroyed by punishments and reputations have been irreparably harmed.
Which brings us right back to where we started
I did not originally seek Claudine Gay’s removal as President of Harvard due to plagiarism allegations. In fact, from the beginning I was simply trying to help her address the rise of antisemitism on campus. I encourage you to read the concluding section of my first letter to her. Unfortunately, she did not respond to my first letter or any of my efforts at my outreach to her, nor did the Corporation board. To this day, neither former President Gay or the Corporation board has ever responded to any of the three letters I wrote.
I only sought former President Gay’s removal after her congressional testimony. And I didn’t just seek her removal, I advocated for the removal of all three university presidents who all happened to be women: a Black woman, a White Christian woman, and a White Jewish woman (there is some debate as to whether White should be capitalized, but I am following the Macarthur Foundation recommendation which appears first when you google the question).
So far, I have only been accused of racism against Black people as a result of my advocacy for all three stepping down from their roles. I have not yet been accused of misogyny as far as I am aware. I have been ecumenical and color blind in my advocacy here. Please also note my post last night about why I believe the Chairman of MIT must resign for apparent tax fraud. I note that he happens to be a Jewish man. Am I am also an antisemite?
Getting back to Kornbluth, Gay, and Magill; in my opinion and that of many others, they are failed leaders of our country’s most important institutions, and all three lack the necessary moral clarity that is critical for leaders, particularly during this challenging time in history. That is why I and many others believed that they should resign or be fired.
I did not know anything about Claudine Gay’s academic record prior to others bringing this issue to the fore.
When Gay resigned and was awarded a position on the faculty and continued to receive president-level compensation, I publicly questioned how the board could have approved her remaining on the faculty in light of the amount, nature, and degree of plagiarism that had surfaced in her work.
In coming to my conclusion, I reviewed the undisputed 50 or so plagiarism allegations in 6 of her 11 publications, and relied somewhat on academia’s public assessment of her plagiarism, and her overall academic oeuvre and record.
In short, I was convinced by others more expert than I, that her academic oeuvre was not of sufficient scale or quality, and that the plagiarism issue was sufficiently troubling that she was not qualified to continue as a senior member of the Harvard faculty, particularly at well-above market compensation for her continuing role. It looked like her lawyer did an excellent job negotiating a settlement, but that’s not how faculty positions should be awarded.
In retrospect, I shouldn’t have had to form my own conclusions about plagiarism in her work. That should have been determined in a formal and transparent process by an administrative board comprised of independent members who could have judged her work without personal consequences to themselves or without the impact on the outcome from university politics. Unfortunately, I do not believe that such a committee exists at Harvard, but I welcome learning otherwise.
All of above said, I thought Claudine Gay was a failed leader without regard to her academic record, and that’s why I thought she should not be president of Harvard.
Lastly, a few thoughts on MIT and the media
My wife, Neri Oxman, as you may well know by now, spent 15 years of her life at MIT before she left MIT and moved to New York.
Neri’s published work is vast. She has published 74 peer-reviewed papers, 8 peer-reviewed book chapters, and numerous other journal papers and proceedings. But her written work is only a small portion of her life’s work. She has been awarded 15 patents for her technological innovations, not including recent patents pending. You might want to watch this video to learn more about her work oxman.com/mission
In that Neri’s work is more about product design, architecture, and technological innovations, most of her intellectual property is represented by her patented and unpatented technologies, and in the physical manifestation of their forms, for which she shares credit with the other inventors, principally her students. Neri’s scholarship is breathtaking in its creativity, vast in its scale and enormous in its potential for impact. Often, her work also happens to be incredibly beautiful, which explains the MoMA and SFMoMA retrospectives of her work, and the 116 exhibitions in which they have been featured around the world, and the 22 of works which remain in permanent collections around the world.
And yes, Neri is intensely human, and she makes mistakes as we all do. She also owns her mistakes, and learns from them. We both have learned many times from the experience that comes from making mistakes and learning from them.
Neri has yet to vet yesterday’s plagiarism allegations, but she will get to them when she has time to do so. Notably the first 15 of the 28 examples that came from Business Insider’s “thorough review of her published work” were definitions of words or terms that Neri may have used from Wikipedia including the definition of: “weaving,” “computer graphics,” “computer-aided design,” “pain,” “manifold,” “heat flux,” “optimization,” and “sustainable design,” to name more than half of the examples BI calls plagiarism.
Is this plagiarism? Let’s assume that in writing her dissertation Neri used Wikipedia as a dictionary for these terms and it is deemed to be plagiarism, does it any way affect the quality and originality of the research in her dissertation? I think that’s worth an important discussion among the experts.
It does not strike me as plagiarism, nor do I think it takes anything away from her work. I am not sure who would even complain that they were not cited properly. I also wish I knew how to reach a human being at Wikipedia as my Wikipedia biography needs correcting, and could be meaningfully improved if there was someone I could speak to.
I am sure that when Neri wrote her dissertation she thought that there was nothing wrong with using Wikipedia as a dictionary. When I was a student, I remember having a thesaurus and a dictionary on my desk that I would consult when I wrote a paper and needed a synonym or a definition of a word. I never thought to quote or cite my thesaurus or dictionary for basic words, term or synonyms.
The good news is that none of the above will interfere with Neri’s success or in any way diminish any of the technologies and innovations that she, her colleagues, and students have developed, and new ones that she and her team will create in the future.
Now that all of her non-family time and energy is intensely focused on OXMAN, her success will largely depend on what comes next. And yes, I think she made a brilliant decision to leave academia behind.
Neri left MIT in some part due to her marriage to me and her desire to start a family in New York, but she was also motivated by the opportunity to change the world, which she felt she had a greater chance of achieving by leaving academia behind, launching a start up in the form of a benefit corporation, and recruiting an extremely talented team of scientists, engineers, roboticists, synthetic biologists, plant biologists, material scientists, and more.
OXMAN is still hiring, so if you are interested and possess unique and relevant talents and skills, and you are a wonderful human being, you should check out oxman.com, follow @NeriOxman, and go to oxman.com/contact.
OXMAN has been in stealth mode for the last several years, but they have made a lot of progress. Neri and her 27 team members recently moved to a new 36,000 square feet research, design, and wet lab space that has taken several years to construct. OXMAN is in the process of developing a number of new technologies, which will lead to future product launches, some of which you will hear about later this year.
On Journalism and the Media
Over the last several days, we have seen some of the worst forms of journalism and how it operates. Business Insider gave Neri only several hours to respond to the reporter’s first request for comment for her story on Thursday. Bear in mind, we were on vacation and out of the country and did not have ready access to necessary source materials or decent WiFi, but Neri dropped everything, and responded politely and accurately to the allegations in the few hours she was given.
Yesterday, at 5:19pm after sundown on Friday night, the same reporter sent a 12-page email to Fran who heads communications for Pershing Square. Bear in mind that Pershing Square and OXMAN have nothing to do with each other, other than the founder of one is married to the founder of the other. One should also understand that this Israeli woman, husband and child look forward to and celebrate Shabbat dinner with our family on Friday nights.
continues below -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Translation: “A leader’s job is not to lead, but to remain in power.”
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Haley: "I knew half of South Carolinians saw the Confederate flag as heritage and tradition ... my job wasn't to judge either side ... that is the way we have to work on issues that try and divide us ... a leader doesn't decide who's right."
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In case you were wondering whether you’d rather do business — or have dinner with — @mcuban or King Anti-Midas, this should help you out.
Mark Cuban
@mcuban
Let me help you out and give you my thoughts on DEI
1. Diversity
Good businesses look where others don't, to find the employees that will put your business in the best possible position to succeed.
You may not agree, but I take it as a given that there are people of various races, ethnicities, orientation, etc that are regularly excluded from hiring consideration. By extending our hiring search to include them, we can find people that are more qualified. The loss of DEI-Phobic companies is my gain.
1a. We live in a country with very diverse demographics. In this era where trust of businesses can be hard to come by, people tend to connect more easily to people who are like them. Having a workforce that is diverse and representative of your stakeholders is good for business. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Season 2, episode 9 of Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast @demchiefexecpod explores January 6 against the backdrop of America's history of political violence and the evolution of right-wing extremism. open.spotify.com/episode/3ffpMOIGXwPEu95FBzydFT
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
In time to mark the 3rd anniversary of the January 6 insurrection, @DemChiefExecPod has a new episode with 3 extraordinary scholars putting that day in historic context: @PenielJoseph, @katemasur, & Theda Skocpol. Hosted by @petermshane and Dale Russakoff. open.spotify.com/episode/3ffpMOIGXwPEu95FBzydFT
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Feeling like I am in very good company!
Washington Monthly
@monthly
Our final articles of 2023
David Masciotra reviews “Doppelgänger” washingtonmonthly.com/2023/12/29/the-paranoid-style-of-na…
Garrett Epps & @jimzirin on Trump & the 14th
washingtonmonthly.com/2023/12/26/the-wrong-reasons-to-kee…
washingtonmonthly.com/2023/12/27/will-trumps-disqualifica…
@petermshane on Trump’s immunity claim washingtonmonthly.com/2023/12/26/trumps-laughable-claim-o…
Happy New Year! -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The #cottonbowl is . . . not really great football.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Whether or not the 14th Am., properly read, includes the President, there is obvious structural difficulty bringing it to bear on an election across multiple jurisdictions with a variety of different procedural rules among them for challenging candidate qualifications.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Does whatever playbook counseling GOP candidates not to mention slavery in connection with the Civil War also preclude blaming World War II on Nazism? Asking for a flummoxed would-be presidential contender.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My take: Corrupt presidents have no claim of immunity from criminal prosecution after leaving office. washingtonmonthly.com/2023/12/26/trumps-laughable-claim-o…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My take: Corrupt presidents have no claim of #immunity from criminal prosecution after leaving office. washingtonmonthly.com/2023/12/26/trumps-laughable-claim-o…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
via @NYTimes Disappointing, but perhaps influenced by the expedited treatment at the D.C. Circuit www.nytimes.com/2023/12/22/us/politics/trump-supreme-cour…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My reaction to the academic record of @Harvard President Dr. Claudine Gay is tempered by my view of the excellent 20-year tenure of Derek Bok. Although later a prolific writer, he was best known prior to 1971 as a casebook co-author. Westlaw shows 5 pieces in print before then.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I find the arguments persuasive, but still think the Court will overrule.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Despite serious arguments for beating Trump at the polls instead of disqualification, it's counterintuitive that a document that refers repeatedly to the presidency as an "office," e.g., "faithfully execute the Office of President," would not include POTUS as an "officer."
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I suspect #scoco has helped Jack Smith get expedited SCOTUS victory, which he deserves on the merits. SCOTUS will find a reason that avoids a court decision ousting Trump from the election, but will want to avoid seeming in the tank for Trump. Answer: quick no-immunity decision.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
“If you don’t give me what I want, I’m going to give you extra dessert,” is not the way threats work.
Christopher Webb
@cwebbonline
Vivek Ramaswamy ‘pledges’ to withdraw from the Colorado Republican primary in solidarity with Trump and he ‘demands’ Ron DeSantis, Nikki Haley and Chris Christie do the same. 🥴
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
But www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/tru…
Acyn
@Acyn
After saying “they are destroying the blood of our country” Trump tells the voters of Iowa that he never read Mein Kampf
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
But the Court second-guessed Florida on Florida election law. I fear the SCOTUS opinion leaving Trump on the ballot will make Bush v. Gore seem like tight legal reasoning.
Neal Katyal
@neal_katyal
Some are saying this is a 4-3 decision, with 3 Justices disagreeing. True, but much of the dissents are about Colorado state election law, which is irrelevant as this case goes to the US Supreme Court. The US Supreme Ct cannot second guess the Colorado Supreme Ct on its own law
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Should Dems consider legislation lifting Trump’s disqualification in return for legislation enacting the Biden-McCarthy budget deal and specific authorization for all major Biden policy initiatives on voting, child poverty, gun regulation, student loan relief, health care? In …
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Other words, let voters decide if they want Trump in 2024 after Biden is allowed to give the voters what they said they wanted in 2020?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The following brief thread from @demchiefexecpod previews the discussion we posted today on the Electoral Count Act, its reform, and how prosecutors should think about prosecuting former presidents for trying to disrupt the certification of a successor. open.spotify.com/episode/6N2MSYuhW2cxcrm2uYlwGg
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
1/3 In the spirit of generous holiday giving, Democracy’s Chief Executive: The Podcast debuts today a supersized Episode 8 for its second season, “Behind the Vote.” Called “The Electoral Count Act and the Rule of Law,” it explores, first, . . . open.spotify.com/episode/6N2MSYuhW2cxcrm2uYlwGg
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
'Twas a privilege this week to be both podcast host and podcast guest. The guest stint was with a great host, @espinsegall, to chat about presidential immunities, Project 2025, and other constitutional worries. I also get to host a new @demchiefexecpod, launching tomorrow.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Perhaps worth remembering that Art. II, sec. 3 of the Constitution empowers the President to convene both Houses of Congress “on extraordinary occasions.” www.huffpost.com/entry/ukraine-immigration-senate_n_657b7…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This extremely well-written editorial in The Harvard Crimson makes me even prouder (if that were possible) to be among that paper's alumni. It gives a clearer picture of the situation at Harvard than anything you'll get from any other coverage I have seen. www.thecrimson.com/article/2023/12/12/editorial-gay-harva…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A reminder of the great conversations Dale Russakoff and I have been having on Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast. open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
It’s the 7th night of Hanukkah. @DemChiefExecPod Season 2 has posted 7 episodes so far. Should you not have listened to at least one by now?
EP. 1 – Electoral College (Keyssar & Foley)
Ep. 2 – Political Polling (Ayres & Garin) . . .
open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
An excellent statement by the Harvard Board of Overseers. view.hu.harvard.edu?qs=4e89181f5c18906d637d4958f63553e681…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Want to know what it's like to be chief counsel to a major party presidential campaign? Want to know what two experienced political opponents agree is essential for our democracy? This new episode of @demchiefexecpod is for you!
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
On Season 2, Ep. 7 of @demchiefexecpod, up today, two veteran counsel to nat’l presidential campaigns, Dem Bob Bauer and GOP'er Ben Ginsburg, review the challenges of the role and their work on improving election processes and defending election officials. open.spotify.com/episode/7jgNE2a4WUtQUF7qYepZfZ
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The struggle for real voting equality is apparently never-ending. On Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast @demchiefexecpod, our guests give us reasons for both concern and for hope.
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
On Season 2, Ep. 6 of @demchiefexecpod, Prof. @gilda_daniels of @ubaltlaw and @WendyRWeiser of @BrennanCenter talk to Peter and Dale about vote suppression and what you can do to make sure your voice gets heard (and your vote counted) on Election Day 2024. open.spotify.com/episode/2GX0IKDH6SP3ZfKVpzyHzp
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Truly privileged to be hosting these discussions with Dale Russakoff. There will be 10 episodes in season 2 of #demchiefexecpod - and the first five are up now. Number 6, "How secure is your right to vote?" with @gilda_daniels and @WendyRWeiser drops Tuesday!
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Season 2 so far:
EP. 1 – Electoral College (Keyssar & Foley)
Ep. 2 – Political Polling (Ayres & Garin)
Ep. 3 – Choosing the Candidates (Kamarck & Pildes)
Ep. 4 – 2-Party System (Drutman, Hill, & Maisel)
Ep. 5 – Big Money & Politics (Feingold and Weintraub)
open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Sad to hear of the death of Justice Sandra Day O'Connor. While disagreeing profoundly with some opinions, I felt she was trying authentically to play the appropriate role of a judge. Her voice was also valuable as the only Justice in recent years to have held elected office.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
But there are $666 in activity fees not covered!
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If, on what is Giving Tuesday, you are in a giving mood, I urge you to consider @acslaw, whose network of lawyer and student chapters help advance a vision of multi-racial, representative democracy true to the rule of law. Proud to be a long-time member. donorbox.org/2023petershaneeoy
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
And thus does the elite anti-administrativist libertarian wing remind the populist ethno-nationalist wing of the party whose pockets are deepest.
Jonathan Karl
@jonkarl
SCOOP- Koch-backed AFP is endorsing @NikkiHaley for president. They plan to spend tens of millions to try to defeat Trump in the primaries
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
That Walter Mondale and Dan Quayle were so disloyal. And Thomas Jefferson? Don’t get me started!
Jonathan Karl
@jonkarl
ABC News Exclusive: Pence notes reveal he had initially decided not to preside over electoral count on January 6:
“Not feeling like I should attend electoral count. Too many questions, too many doubts, too hurtful to my friend. Therefore I’m not going to participate in certification of election.”
via @KFaulders @alex_mallin @MLevineReports
abcnews.go.com/US/pence-told-jan-6-special-counsel-harrow… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
How did @russfeingold wind up partnering with John McCain on campaign finance regulation? How did Hon. Ellen Weintraub become an @FEC commissioner for 22 years and counting? @demchiefexecpod has the answers on today’s new episode. open.spotify.com/episode/2FaHIDu7sXGY5xrmKLfyIi
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
80%+ of BOTH Dems and Repubs think big donors play too big a role in elections. Episode 5 of our “Behind the Vote” season is up! @acslaw pres and former Senator @russfeingold and @FEC Commissioner Ellen Weintraub discuss Big Money and Politics. open.spotify.com/episode/2FaHIDu7sXGY5xrmKLfyIi
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
An excellent analysis by my friend and colleague @narosenblum
Noah Rosenblum
@narosenblum
I’m in @TheAtlantic this morning with a warning about Jarkesy, a case the Supreme Court is hearing on Wednesday — the latest judicial attack on functional government.
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/11/securities-and-… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Still time to catch up on the first 4 episodes of Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast @demchiefexecpod season 2, "Behind the Vote" before Episode 5 drops Tuesday with guests @russfeingold and FEC Commissioner Ellen Weintraub. You can guess the topic!😉open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Sad ending to #thegame
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Guests include @AlexKeyssar, @Nedfoley, @geoffgarin, @WhitAyres, @RickPildes, Elaine Kamarck, @leedrutman, @hill_charlotte, @SandyMaisel. Pumpkin pie optional!
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
The @demchiefexecpod Season 2 “Behind the Vote” Thanksgiving menu:
Ep. 1: Electoral College
Ep. 2: Political Polling
Ep. 3: Choosing Candidates
Ep. 4: The Two-Party System
Hosted by @petermshane and Dale Russakoff open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I still recall the shock of seeing Bob Dylan on the front cover of the AARP magazine . . .quite a few years ago.
Jill Lawrence
@JillDLawrence
I am slightly beside myself to learn that 1, the Rolling Stones -- average age 78 -- are going on tour next year and 2, the @AARP -- really and truly -- is sponsoring the tour. I mean, what are we supposed to think about this? Help me out, folks. www.axios.com/2023/11/21/rolling-stones-2024-tour-tickets
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
On Season 2, Episode 4, we ask if the U.S. would be better off with a genuine two-party system. What reforms might enable multiple parties to emerge without being "spoilers" in a presidential election? What features of our electoral system support a dominant duopoly?
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Democracy’s Chief Executive: The Podcast @DemChiefExecPod has a new episode on the virtues and vices of the two-party system! @petermshane and Dale Russakoff explore with political scientists @leedrutman, @hill_charlotte, and @SandyMaisel. open.spotify.com/episode/2p92BrDrMA4Yt3AzPrsJNa
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Fred Zacharias was my YLS classmate. He died way too young, but would have been thrilled to know his name would forever be linked to great legal ethics scholarship. Congrats to @jonleelawprof!
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Kudos to Chief Judge Smith in dissent for . . . following the law.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This week, I'm feeling especially grateful to an audience that has given Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast @demchiefexecpod programming over 2100 listens. If you haven't sampled yet, Season 2 is all about presidential elections. 3 episodes up so far and a new one tomorrow!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Should I gather from my X feed that someone put together newsreel clips of sailors playing cards aboard ship in the early 1940s and now World War II never occurred?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
@demchiefexecpod has its first 3 Season 2 episodes up: On the electoral college (with Alex Keyssar and @Nedfoley), political polling (with @geoffgarin and @WhitAyres), and candidate selection (with Elaine Kamarck and @RickPildes, with a preview below). Enjoy!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
Apropos of @mattyglesias recent substack on how there is no "Democratic" or "Republican" party there to manage the presidential nominations process, this podcast I did with Elaine Kamarck explains how we got to our current nominations system and what was lost in that change
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is one theme of Rick’s conversation on @demchiefexecpod with Elaine Kamarck, Dale Russakoff, and me now up! open.spotify.com/episode/22rM45F11MphxusKZYQwRK @mattyglesias also explores what primaries have done to the parties at www.slowboring.com/p/the-parties-cant-decide
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
And for perspective on how differently most democracies go about choosing their candidates for chief executive, see this article of mine with Stephen Gardbaum:
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3064938 -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is a fascinating conversation! Elaine Kamarck and @RickPildes explain on Democracy's Chief Executive how the U.S. literally stumbled into its unique system for choosing presidential candidates, with consequences no one intended. open.spotify.com/episode/22rM45F11MphxusKZYQwRK
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Season 2, Ep. 3 of @demchiefexecpod is up! Political scientist Elaine Kamarck and Law of Democracy scholar @RickPildes discuss presidential primaries, "probably the most significant change we've made to American democracy in the last 50 years." open.spotify.com/episode/22rM45F11MphxusKZYQwRK
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"Ivana Trump told her lawyer Michael Kennedy that from time to time her husband reads a book of Hitler’s collected speeches, My New Order, which he keeps in a cabinet by his bed." Marie Brenner, "After the Gold Rush," Vanity Fair (Sept. 1990), www.vanityfair.com/magazine/2015/07/donald-ivana-trump-di…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
On the episode launching tomorrow, Dale Russakoff and I interview political scientist Elaine Kamarck and Law of Democracy scholar @RickPildes on America's unique approach to choosing candidates for head of government.
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Today’s the last day to listen to Episodes 1 (Electoral College) and 2 (Political Polling) of Behind the Vote, season 2 of @DemChiefExecPod – well, the last day before we debut Episode 3 tomorrow on how we choose presidential candidates! open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My take on Project 2025: ""Trump's first assault on democracy would be nothing compared to the program of authoritarian control and regulatory decapitation that the architects of Project 2025 hope to unleash."" Blitzkrieg Against the Administrative State washingtonmonthly.com/2023/11/13/blitzkrieg-against-the-a…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Keep your eye on @monthly this week!
BrooklynDad_Defiant!☮️
@mmpadellan
The media is inadequately covering the fact that Project 2025 is a fascist plan trump's allies have hatched in case he wins in 2024.
That's why Tuberville and Paul are blocking appointments; they're holding them for trump.
DO YOUR DAMN JOBS.
@CNN @MSNBC @washingtonpost @CBSNews -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I feel more than a little humbled to be included on this list of people whose work both educates and inspires me.
Jed Shugerman
@jedshug
And apparently Clement is not reading @KexelChabot or @Jane_C_Manners or @LevMenand or @narosenblum or @ascoseriakatz or @petermshane or @TheGNapp or @jdmortenson... or the briefs in Jarkesy:
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4562616 -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I suspect Sen. #manchin won’t run for president because he will know a third party candidate cannot win. He’s not naive. If he wanted to leave politics as a loser, he’d be trying to keep his Senate seat. I think his ego will steer him in the right direction.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I still strongly recommend Jeff Powell's 1987 article in the @VirginiaLawRev called "Rules for Originalists." "Rule 8: If your history uniformly confirms your predilections, it is probably bad history." scholarship.law.duke.edu/faculty_scholarship/444/
Joe Patrice
@JosephPatrice
The law is about “history” but historians are bad because they keep finding contemporaneous documentary evidence proving that history doesn’t actually line up with our personal policy preferences is an unintentionally honest Originalism take.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I keep thinking of Logan Roy's almost-last words to Kendall, Roman, Siobhan, and Connor: "You are not serious people!"
Charles P. Pierce
@CharlesPPierce
We're now barreling toward a government shutdown and the House of Representatives is completely paralyzed. Mike Johnson is no more capable, and far less competent, at getting things done than Kevin McCarthy was. Who'd-a thunk it? www.esquire.com/news-politics/politics/a45803618/mike-joh…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Have you folks not heard of the doctrine of stare historia?? @jedshug @jdmortenson @KexelChabot
Josh Chafetz
@joshchafetz
yes it’s just appalling when historians revise their understanding of the past based on new evidence
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If all bipartisan conversation were as thoughtful and constructive as this one turned out to be, it would be a different world. You can hear it all at open.spotify.com/episode/5daoAyF6OmAn2nLaMMkOAR
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Picking weekend podcasts? S2 of @DemChiefExecPod w/ @petermshane & Dale Russakoff is all about presidential elections. Ep. 2 is on polling, with leading Dem pollster @geoffgarin & leading GOP pollster @WhitAyres. Here's Whit on the unpredictability of the current election season.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is rich from a candidate who helped bring us four MAGA years and three MAGA Supreme Court picks. You have no chance of winning a single state. All you can do is increase the likelihood of another presidency based on a popular vote loser.
Dr. Jill Stein🌻
@DrJillStein
The political system is broken. Over 60% of us now say the two-party establishment has failed us and we need a party that serves the people.
I’m running for President to offer a better choice for the people. Join us!
www.jillstein2024.comThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Joe #manchin’s departure from the Senate was a foregone conclusion, given his inevitable loss had he run. The Dems have a tough map, but it’s no harder today than yesterday.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Alex Keyssar and @NedFoley launched Season 2 in a great discussion with Dale Russakoff and me.open.spotify.com/episode/4iM96OiedtA9t8xaOP6U8d
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Season 2 of Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast is called "Behind the Vote" and focuses on presidential elections. Episode 1, available now, features historian Alex Keyssar and legal expert @Nedfoley on the Electoral College. Here's a sample of Prof. Keyssar's analysis.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I today regret having moved from Ohio to New York in 2022 only because I cannot claim that a vote I cast was part of the splendid victory for individual rights that Ohio voters scored last night. But I share exuberantly nonetheless in the joy of Buckeye friends and colleagues.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
How do candidates use polling? Can the public trust polls not based on random sampling? Leading GOP pollster @WhitAyres and leading Dem @geoffgarin discuss with @petermshane and Dale Russakoff on Democracy’s Chief Executive: The Podcast, available now. open.spotify.com/episode/5daoAyF6OmAn2nLaMMkOAR
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
How did we get the Electoral College? What mischief might it cause? How could we reduce the risks it poses? @Nedfoley and Alex Keyssar discuss on a new episode of @demchiefexecpod -- now available at open.spotify.com/episode/4iM96OiedtA9t8xaOP6U8d
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Tomorrow is Launch Day for Season 2 of @demchiefexecpod, all episodes at podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/democracys-ceo-pod. Season 2’s theme is “Behind the Vote.” Tomorrow's new episodes focus on the Electoral College and a perspective on political polling from leading Democratic and Republican pollsters.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This may seem like a superficial messaging point, but I wonder, if Trump's verbal stumbles were broadcast as often and as widely as Biden's whether that would have impact. The idea that Trump is vigorous and mentally acute in a way Biden is not is preposterous.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Now is a great time to dip into Democracy’s Chief Executive: The Podcast @DemChiefExecPod and pick up Season 1 episodes you missed. Season 2 launches Tuesday with 2 episodes: @NedFoley & @AlexKeyssar on the Electoral College and @GeoffGarin & @WhitAyres on political polling!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It’s a week before Election Day 2023—which also means it’s launch day for Season 2 of Democracy’s Chief Executive: The Podcast. @DemChiefExecPod This season’s theme? “Behind the Vote.” We’re exploring everything about presidential elections from nitty-gritty mechanics to . . .
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
big questions about democracy and the presidency. On November 7, we’ll launch two episodes—one on the Electoral College and one on political polling. For more details, watch this space! And if you haven’t yet listened to the Season 1 episodes, why wait?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A thoughtful thread, well worth reading.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
To whom will he throw his supporter?
Acyn
@Acyn
Pence: I have decided to suspend my campaign for president, effective today
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Even in a world stalked by despair, the power of friendship, empathy, and compassion still exists. evanstonroundtable.com/2023/10/15/district-65-board-joint…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"[N]o religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States." U.S. Const., Art. VI, par. 3.
Acyn
@Acyn
Johnson: I believe that scripture and the bible is very clear that god is the one that raised up each of you and god has allowed us to be brought here to this specific moment and time.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This idea aged out in about 5 minutes.
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Time, I think, for just enough Dems to get Emmer to 217 and put an end to the clown show.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Time, I think, for just enough Dems to get Emmer to 217 and put an end to the clown show.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Democracy’s Chief Executive: The Podcast, a/k/a, @demchiefexecpod, asks: How well does the presidency serve U.S. democracy? S1 asked how law shapes POTUS's powers. S2, “Behind the Vote,” launches 11/7 and surveys how we elect presidents. Hosted by @petermshane and Dale Russakoff.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If every state’s Democratic Party had organizing talent of the caliber of Ben Wikler, it would be huge. Wisconsin Dems’ big wins for the rule of law might be an inflection point www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/10/22/democrats-wisc…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
How about the House Dems finding a Republican they respect, who may even be retiring, and offering to support that person for Speaker?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A Biden presidency had he been elected after either of his two prior runs would not have been as important as is his presidency now.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
How often do you get to be the “adults in the room” while simultaneously messing big-time with your opponents?
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Now might be a cool moment for the Dems and 6 McCarthy voters to resurrect McCarthy.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Now might be a cool moment for the Dems and 6 McCarthy voters to resurrect McCarthy.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Israeli leftist academics call out political allies for tolerating Hamas www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2023-10-15/ty-article/.premiu…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
Wise words from Benjamin Wittes on how not to respond to what is happening in Israel.
www.dogshirtdaily.com/p/how-not-to-respond-to-a-terrorist -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It would be hard to improve on this analysis. "For the liberal justices, holding at bay the most dangerous, least coherent silliness the Fifth Circuit has to offer is the best outcome they can hope for." slate.com/news-and-politics/2023/10/supreme-court-liberal… via @slate
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Whoever succeeds McCarthy will still face the reality that the narrow GOP majority will not be able to enact any legislation without Democratic votes that will ever pass the Senate—even if the GOP caucus is unanimous, which it won’t be.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I’d say to my students this week, “Remember when Eric Cantor, Paul Ryan, and Kevin McCarthy we’re being hailed as the future of GOP House leadership?” except they wouldn’t have any memory of Eric Cantor or Paul Ryan.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Melissa Murray (@ProfMMurray on Threads 🧵)
@ProfMMurray
Originalism.
Out of Context Human Race
@NoContextHumans
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Democrats should condition any support for @SpeakerMcCarthy on a binding promise of a prompt vote on aid to Ukraine in a clean bill. That assumes, of course, @SpeakerMcCarthy understands the phrase “binding promise.”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This chart from today’s @washingtonpost notes the pivotal role of legal opinions written by the late Ben Civiletti. At age 28, working with the AG on these opinions would prove my most impactful work in public administration. He thought the opinions would deter shutdowns.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If the Attorney General is looking for someone whose outlook is skewed by a view of Alabama "stuck in 1963," he should perhaps look closer to home. x.com/davidgura/status/1706838403092717617
Heather Cox Richardson (TDPR)
@HC_Richardson
Refers to the Supreme Court as “left-wing activists.” 😳
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
if Joe Biden confused Jeb and George W. Bush, Hannity would anchor special coverage that would last until the 2024 election
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
a confused Trump seems to think Jeb Bush was president when the US invaded Iraq
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Can Notre Dame pull off a Hail Mary pass?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Removing Menendez from the Senate wouldn't put GOP in control. Urging Thomas to resign SCOTUS would not put liberals in control. Seems like those who wish to maintain their control over each institution have room to "do the right thing," cleanup-wise, without much political risk.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
First, Jordan won't wear a jacket. Then, Fetterman won't wear a tie. What's next? The majority party in the House of Representatives going home for a long weekend eight days before a likely government shutdown??
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In early August, I explained in @monthly why the current service of Acting Labor Secretary Julie Su is entirely lawful. washingtonmonthly.com/2023/08/02/republicans-are-wrong-ab…. Yesterday, @GAO released its opinion, reaching the same result. Not a surprise. This is pretty much a case of, “Just read the statute.”
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If Republicans in Congress would imagine their reaction should it turn out that Justice Sotomayor has been a guest speaker at private George Soros fundraisers and then proceed in the exact same fashion vis-a-vis Justice Thomas, there would soon be another vacancy on the Court.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Will the 2024 election turn on which party better connects with Joe-50-dollar-single-malt-whiskey-pack?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I’m not really an anagrams guy, but “LAUREN BOEBERT” also spells “BE NEAR TROUBLE.” Kind of a warning, no?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Once a Buckeye . . .
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Host @petermshane may live in NY, but @demchiefexecpod counts as an Ohio podcast because he is an emeritus prof at @OSU_Law. In fact, it's among the top Ohio podcasts! blog.feedspot.com/ohio_law_podcasts/ Season 2 is under production! All Season 1 episodes at open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
U.S. Constitution, Article VI: "No religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States."
Andrew—#IAmTheResistance
@AmoneyResists
Fortunately for the rest of us, you can’t always get what you want.
The United States of America is not and never will be your church, @BenZeisloft. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Nope. POTUS on 1/21/2025 will be whoever has 270+ electoral votes or 26 state delegations in the House, if no one reaches 270. West isn't a plausible winner in enough states to reach 270, even if he could get 51% of the nat'l popular vote (he won't). Saying otherwise is nonsense.
Briahna Joy Gray
@briebriejoy
Weird because seems to me that Cornel West is going to be on the ballot and if 51% of Americans vote for him, we don’t have to be stuck with two corporate parties.
Odd that no one in the mainstream media will acknowledge this.This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
“And a transfer tax on a used dinosaur, fuhgeddaboudit!”
No Lie with Brian Tyler Cohen
@NoLieWithBTC
Marjorie Taylor Greene: “You’re going to tell me that back in the Ice Age, how much taxes did people pay, and how many changes did governments make to melt the ice?” (@acyn)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Given the choice between the express A and the local C arriving simultaneously at Washington Square, I took the C … because it had A/C.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Good policy would also be good politics here. Let’s hope Congress is listening. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/09/05/bipartisan-fam…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Could episodes involving our political leaders prompt more nuanced discourse about disability and work? Biden’s misspeaking and hesitations do not incapacitate him. Nor is Greg Abbott’s paralysis or Fetterman’s aphasia incapacitating. Feinstein, McConnell raise serious issues.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If states adopted laws awarding statewide office (including presidential electors) to candidates supported by actual majorities—e.g., through runoffs or ranked-choice voting—3d parties could offer voters a range of platforms to support w/o causing minority rule. H/t @Nedfoley
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Enough voters in the 1968, 2000, and 2016 elections accepted the “both major parties the same” line and/or voted for 3rd-party candidates as a supposed progressive alternative to launch three presidencies with disastrous consequences at home and abroad. I’ll mention one: SCOTUS.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The way to demonstrate the strength of a progressive electorate in 2024 would be, as Bernie did, to run in Democratic primaries, not to run in the general election which will have either no impact or help Trump to win.
Power to the People ☭🕊
@ProudSocialist
I disagree with @krystalball.
It’s Biden & the Democrats failure to deliver for the people that’s helping re-elect Trump not Cornel West.
Stop punching down at those of us who are fighting for something better than what the corporate duopoly is offering.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This tribute, by an author of so many reports I've consulted, prompts this thought about CRS. CRS provides well-researched, nonpartisan analysis on a huge range of public law and policy issues. As a researcher, it's a gift to find that CRS has addressed some part of your subject.
Kevin R Kosar
@kevinrkosar
1. This Thursday, Walter Oleszek retires from the Congressional Research Service. He arrived there 55 years ago back when CRS was the Legislative Reference Service.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
These are great tips for new scholars and great reminders for the more experienced. Readers will be grateful to authors who follow these guidelines. And law review editors, please respect authors who follow #3. The trend of claiming novelty invites claims often wrong or trivial.
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
<My "Top 5" law review article writing tips for those new to law review article writing, esp those on the market:
1) Try not to have a long literature review section. Summarize prior scholarship quickly; spending a lot of pages summarizing prior works comes off as student-like. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Siri, what is a non sequitur?
Sen. Marsha Blackburn
@MarshaBlackburn
The Left is able to release Donald Trump’s mugshot, but they still can’t tell us who brought cocaine into the White House.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
There's nothing like the feeling just before school starts when a student in your course emails you to say (erroneously, as it turns out) that the course is not scheduled when the syllabus says it is scheduled.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Inspiration for the mug shot?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Devastating.
@mrrjnkns
@MrRJNKNS
Wow. Never seen it all put together like this. Definitely worth a watch.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For better or worse, I've assigned U.S. v. Texas to my fall con law section for the class on standing. Gotta say: Kavanaugh's majority opinion is a conceptual mess. If a concrete injury is not "legally and judicially cognizable," that's a conclusion on the merits, not standing.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Sharing the chagrin of @ProfMMurray, I urge every Cornel West enthusiast to read Ch. 18 of @seanwilentz's "Rise of American Democracy" on the election of 1844 and how the Liberty Party "broke" Whig/Democratic "duopoly" by handing victory to pro-slavery Polk over anti-slavery Clay
Briahna Joy Gray
@briebriejoy
If your goal is breaking the corporate duopoly, then voting for Dr. Cornel West *is* the most strategic choice.
George Takei
@GeorgeTakei
I remember the 2000 Election. There were enough votes for Ralph Nader to hand the election to George W. Bush.
I remember the 2016 Election. There were enough votes for Jill Stein to hand the election to Donald Trump.
In 2024 the Green Party is running Cornell West. Let’s not repeat this history, friends
Your vote is not a marriage. You’re not choosing a life partner. It’s a chess move for what’s best for the country and the world. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is an exceptional diplomatic achievement.
Victor Shi
@Victorshi2020
Wow. Here is President Biden with the Prime Minister of Japan & President of South Korea at Camp David now. President Biden doesn’t just get enough credit for what he does at home; he doesn’t get enough credit for restoring global confidence & alliances. This is leadership.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Delighted that David Unger @DavidCUnger of the International Institute for Strategic Studies @IISS_org chose Democracy's Chief Executive, published by @ucpress, to highlight among five recent books on U.S. affairs. Always happy to be found "useful and timely!"
IISS News
@IISS_org
@DavidCUnger assesses five books on the United States by @pastpunditry, @CRWDietrich, @genezubovich, @petermshane and Deborah Birx.
This article appears in the April–May 2023 issue of Survival.
FREE TO READ. www.iiss.org/online-analysis/survival-online/2023/08/rece… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
To read the #georgiaindictment is to understand not only why the investigation took years, but also to appreciate the extraordinary labor, once the facts were developed, to organize so great a volume of evidence in proper form. Courageous work, admirable lawcraft.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I disagree that pursuing the alleged misdeeds of Trump, et al., should have been left to the feds. Electing presidents through 51 state/DC contests for electors gives states vital interests in protecting election integrity and safety of election officials. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/08/14/georgia-indict…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I think a volume on African-American Women Who Tried to Save the Republic would have a lot of chapters.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is an important and super-helpful thread for understanding why there was no procedural irregularity in the designation of Weiss as special counsel for the investigation of Hunter Biden.
Charlie Savage
@charlie_savage
Seeing folks portraying it as a problem or gotcha that Garland appointed Weiss – a sitting US attorney – special counsel even though a 1999 regulation for special counsels has a provision that envisions them being appointed from outside government. Here's an explanation. /1
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The nation needs a @springsteen rendition of Woody Guthrie and Ryan Harvey’s “Old Man Trump.” Please.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is the attitude of officials who think they are entitled to choose their voters rather than trust voters to choose their officials. aldailynews.com/alabama-republicans-frame-redistricting-c…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Congratulations, Ohio!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Fellow law profs: Is it worth taking a precious hour out of Con. Law I, already overloaded with material, to discuss the Court's recent vacillations on state standing to challenge executive branch action--or leave that to administrative law, civ. pro., or federal courts?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Under Oath > Truth Social
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The juxtaposition of Bill Barr’s assessment of Trump with his explanation why Trump might still have his vote is the most depressing thing I’ve read all week.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
And what are you paying for this search for GIFs?
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Business groups and Senate Republicans are arguing that @JulieSuCA's appointment as Acting Secretary of Labor is unlawful. Both the Labor Department's succession statute and the Federal Vacancies Reform Act say otherwise. My take in @monthly. washingtonmonthly.com/2023/08/02/republicans-are-wrong-ab…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Every applicant for an entry-level law school teaching job would be well-served by reading this superb thread. I’d like to know @danepp’s advice on one matter that had been relevant to both of us (in my case, decades ago): how and when to raise the matter of a partner’s search?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Law & Governance
@LawAnGovernance
Lots of SCOTUS recaps these days, but you’re not likely to find a more lively and fun one than here Wed 3:30 pm ET, when host @NeysunM is joined by @jdmortenson, @cmrodriguez95, @DavidLat, @TaraLeighGrove1, @lsepper, @petermshane. Tune in live or later at x.com/i/spaces/1nAJEraeXdexL
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I won’t even call the 59th Street Bridge the Queensborough, much less the some-former-mayor bridge. None of that would feel groovy.
Alan Mygatt-Tauber - @amtappeals.bsky.social
@AMTAppeals
I will stop calling this place Twitter right after I stop calling that building in Chicago the Sears Tower.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For fans of interpretation via text, history, and structure, Congress's power to make laws regulating the courts is twice made explicit (once even with the word "regulation"), Congress has regulated the Court since 1789, and the structure aims to secure checks and balances.
Laurence Tribe 🇺🇦 ⚖️
@tribelaw
“I know this is a controversial view, but I’m willing to say it,” Justice Alito said. “No provision in the Constitution gives [Congress] the authority to regulate the Supreme Court — period.”
That’s absurd.
The man has gone off the deep end. Period.
www.politico.com/news/2023/07/28/alito-congress-supreme-c… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
“Constitutional text and structure are for thee, and not for me,” says Justice Alito.
Nate Raymond
@nateraymond
Justice Alito tells the @WSJ that Congress has no business policing SCOTUS. "I know this is a controversial view, but I’m willing to say it... No provision in the Constitution gives them the authority to regulate the Supreme Court—period." www.wsj.com/articles/samuel-alito-the-supreme-courts-plai…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Congress’s power to make all laws “necessary and proper” for carrying into execution the powers of the judicial “department” of government is explicit in Article I. The word “all” is comprehensive just as its absence in the Art. II executive vesting clause suggests the opposite.
Nate Raymond
@nateraymond
Justice Alito tells the @WSJ that Congress has no business policing SCOTUS. "I know this is a controversial view, but I’m willing to say it... No provision in the Constitution gives them the authority to regulate the Supreme Court—period." www.wsj.com/articles/samuel-alito-the-supreme-courts-plai…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I wrote Democracy's Chief Executive (www.amazon.com/Democracys-Chief-Executive-Interpreting-Co…) to explain how a legal theory incubated on the right lends aid and comfort to authoritarian yearnings. This shows the stakes.
Trump and Allies Forge Plans to Increase Presidential Power in 2025 www.nytimes.com/2023/07/17/us/politics/trump-plans-2025.html -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I hope every professor conscripted to a university strategic planning exercise, inspired by the mantra that universities should “think more like businesses,” will feel empowered to attach this tweet to an email that says to the provost, “Here’s the plan: Do everything.”
Linda Yaccarino
@lindayaX
There’s absolutely no limit to this transformation. X will be the platform that can deliver, well….everything. @elonmusk and I are looking forward to working with our teams and every single one of our partners to bring X to the world.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Israel’s July 24 looks like a reverse image of our January 6–the coup is inside the building, defenders of the heretofore established order in the streets.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
X makes New Coke seem like brilliant marketing.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The obvious question is, “Y?”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
💯
Nell Minow (she/her)
@nminow
This is a catastrophically bad decision. There is no reason to believe that anyone wants any of that. You have turned a useful if problematic service into a dumpster fire of disinformation and bigotry and are now adding additional chaos. Pity I can't short the stock.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Why exactly would anyone think rebranding as Brand X would be a good thing?
Pop Crave
@PopCrave
Twitter will officially rebrand as X later today, Elon Musk confirms.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Whatever one thinks of regulatory review, I was heartened when GW Bush chose John Graham, a distinguished policy scholar to head OIRA, rather than a deregulation dogmatist. This interview is a reminder of his professionalism. www.theregreview.org/2023/07/16/sunday-spotlight-regulato…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
An absurdly long wait for a gifted lawyer and now judge, but what wonderful news! www.cleveland.com/news/2023/07/us-senate-confirms-rachel-…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
An interesting perspective, even if I don’t share the author’s optimism that opponents of AA would find it politically hard to attack race-conscious admissions in prep programs, albeit copied from the military. How the Military Can Save Affirmative Action washingtonmonthly.com/2023/07/18/how-the-military-can-sav…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In case you’re looking for a book explaining why unitary executive theory is dangerous and unsound interpretation, whether on an originalist or no originalist basis, I wrote one. www.ucpress.edu/book/9780520380905/democracys-chief-execu… #democracyschiefexecutive @ucpress
Charlie Savage
@charlie_savage
Trump and Allies Forge Plans to Increase Presidential Power in 2025 w/ @jonathanvswan @maggieNYT www.nytimes.com/2023/07/17/us/politics/trump-plans-2025.html
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The typed version of the "concise statement of basis and purpose," for "Improving Income Driven Repayment for the William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan Program and the Federal Family Education Loan (FFEL) Program," is 427 pp. The rule's text starts on 392. www2.ed.gov/policy/highered/reg/hearulemaking/2021/nfridr…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My essay on why Chevron deference is superior to what I call "West Virginia [v. EPA]" skepticism as a paradigm for judicial review of agency legal interpretation is now up on the @YaleJREG Notice & Comment blog. www.yalejreg.com/nc/chevron-deference-is-superior-to-west…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If you want to read a statement by an elected official who is truly asking how they can best serve the nation and the causes in which they believe, not how they can best maximize their personal status, read this one: jamieraskin.com/news/2024
Jamie Raskin
@jamie_raskin
I am profoundly grateful to all those who have provided encouragement, wise advice & insight as I faced the question of how I can best serve in the struggle to safeguard our future as a democratic nation. See below for my statement about my plans for 2024:
jamieraskin.com/news/2024 -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
TFW you know it's satire and so wish it weren't.
The Halfway Post
@HalfwayPost
BREAKING: Donald Trump is threatening the DOJ that he'll direct all his supporters to boycott elections for the rest of their lives if his Bedminster golf club gets searched.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My take in @monthly on student loan cases: "A Court obsessed with the possibility that the executive branch is making legislative policy should be more alert to the prospect that its decisions are doing the same."
washingtonmonthly.com/2023/07/07/unforgiven-the-supreme-c… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
FWIW, I can’t see myself moving to another Zuckerberg platform.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is perhaps the first story about athletes I've read from beginning to end since Roger Maris duked it out with Mickey Mantle for the then-home run record. It is a fabulous piece of writing about two remarkable humans.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
An excellent essay on the #majorquestionsdoctrine. I would add only a friendly amendment that #mqd allows the Court to ignore the lack of a consensus version (even among the conservatives) of a reinvigorated nondelegation doctrine beyond the "intelligible principle" requirement.
Pat Sobkowski
@PJSobkowski
I’ve got an essay up on @YaleJREG this morning.
Of Major Questions and Nondelegation, by Patrick J. Sobkowski
Short thread w/ thoughts: 1/6
www.yalejreg.com/nc/of-major-questions-and-nondelegation-… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It is worth reading this entire thread explaining why the premise of Justice Barrett's not-entirely-successful attempt to domesticate the #majorquestionsdoctrine is premised on error.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/3 In today's episode of Trump-Judge-Makes-Up-Law-to-Mess-With-Biden-Administration, here's the memo by Judge Doughty (W.D. La.) supporting his unprecedented order barring federal officials from "meeting with social-media companies . . .www.washingtonpost.com/documents/75e9f7a3-da4e-45af-8430-…
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
2/3 for the purpose of urging, encouraging, pressuring, or inducing in any manner the removal, deletion, suppression, or reduction of content containing protected free speech posted on social-media platforms." Putting aside problems of standing and state action, the injunction...
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
3/3 is mind-blowingly broader than even the most generous reading of the judge's opinion would support. Here's the order itself. Kudos to @washingtonpost for providing these links and raspberries to @nytimes for not doing so. www.washingtonpost.com/documents/0e1edd23-3c69-4bce-ab7c-…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Perhaps laying the groundwork for returning affirmative action to a pre-Bakke rationale? "Diversity" became the lodestar because of Powell. On another front, I am puzzled by the majority footnote suggesting military academies may have compelling interests not present elsewhere.
Jonathan H. Adler
@jadler1969
CJ Roberts majority opinion in the SFFA decisions reconceptualized the Court's precedents on affirmative action in university admissions. Interestingly, the dissents did as well, stressing racial injustice as much if not more than the benefits of diversity in education
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
One might have thought the Court's purported inability to apply strict scrutiny in a principled way would counsel abstaining, not voiding the practice altogether. (Isn't that more or less the rationale for treating gerrymandering as a political question??)
Noah Rosenblum
@narosenblum
Like everyone else still making sense of SFFA. But I’m struck by the way the court frames the legal problem. It’s not that diversity isn’t a compelling interest. It’s that it is “not sufficiently coherent for purposes of strict scrutiny.” (1/2)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/4 Two thoughts about today's affirmative action decisions. www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/20-1199_hgdj.pdf Thought 1: The opinion casts doubt on plans like Texas's Top 10 Percent Plan, which plainly aims in part at racial diversity. . . .
Post not available here, view on X
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
3/4 discussion of how race affected his or her life, be it through discrimination, inspiration, or otherwise. . . . A benefit to a student who overcame racial discrimination, for example, must be tied to that student’s courage and determination. Or a benefit to a student whose
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
4/4 heritage or culture motivated him or her to assume a leadership role or attain a particular goal must be tied to that student’s unique ability to contribute to the university."
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
As much as I appreciate the role @judgeluttig is playing, the “not only” clause is, to put it mildly, preposterous.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Mike Stern
@mls1776
I thought the rich were Republicans
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is but the latest example of a red state Senator boasting about an initiative he opposed, another program advocated and disproportionately paid for by blue state politicians and the voters who elect them.
Coach Tommy Tuberville
@SenTuberville
Broadband is vital for the success of our rural communities and for our entire economy.
Great to see Alabama receive crucial funds to boost ongoing broadband efforts. yellowhammernews.com/alabama-to-receive-1-4b-for-broadban… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Amen to the sigh of relief, but a variant is still on the menu. The Court holds out the prospect that, although state courts may still hold state legislatures to account, SCOTUS remains the ultimate authority about whether state courts have gone too far in individual cases.
Steven Mazie
@stevenmazie
Moore is a huge sigh of relief. A key crazytown strategy to thwart an electoral loss in 2024 appears to be off the table.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
To borrow from a Scalia trope, the #independentstatelegislature theory appears to be dead, dead, dead. Not shocked that Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch dissent. www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/21-1271_3f14.pdf
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It seems especially appropriate that he lived a long life. John B. Goodenough, 100, Dies; Nobel-Winning Creator of the Lithium-Ion Battery www.nytimes.com/2023/06/26/science/john-goodenough-dead.html
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A thoughtful call for a multi-faceted strategy. We Need to Talk About Overturning the Dobbs Decision www.nytimes.com/2023/06/24/opinion/dobbs-overturn-strateg…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I wonder if Alito went to see Hamilton, loved the song about the Reynolds Pamphlet, and thought, “I should write one of those!”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Now and then, it's good to recall we had leadership like this. "For, in the final analysis, our most basic common link is that we all inhabit this small planet. We all breathe the same air. We all cherish our children's future. And we are all mortal." youtu.be/0fkKnfk4k40
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Transcript of the next congressional oversight case to reach the Supreme Court:
Petitioner: This subpoena was nothing but a fishing expedition!
Thomas and Alito: What’s wrong with that? -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Or a parent who taught him the best thing to do after writing an angry letter is put it in a drawer, take it out a week later, and rip it up? The sense of victimization in one who wields so much power is just mind-blowing.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Robert Jackson: "We're not final because we're infallible, but we are infallible only because we are final."
Samuel Alito: "How dare you criticize me, and what part of 'Supreme' don't you understand?"This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This reminds me of the time Justice . . .(checks notes) uh, never mind.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If you're looking for a good thread by a smart, young conservative lawyer that explains the differences between Hillary's email scandal and the Trump indictment, here's it is.
Heath Mayo
@HeathMayo
Let’s walk through this blow by blow, since it appears to be the last-ditch argument the GOP wants to try to hang its hat on:
Why is the Hillary situation different from the Trump situation and why is it *not* a double standard to charge Trump and not Hillary? (1/) -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Link to the Trump indictment: int.nyt.com/data/documenttools/trump-indictment-document/…
Pages 15-16 deserve a table read. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The meticulous detail of the 38-count Trump/Nauta #indictment reveals just how complex and painstaking must be the investigation and documentation of even what seemed to many (including me) a "slam dunk" case. Care obviously had to be exercised in deciding which docs to focus on.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My “For You” thread is chock full of MAGA Republican nonsense about the Florida Trump indictment. As it happens, I follow no Maganians. In possibly unrelated news, blue sky is again visible over NYC.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Am I just missing the apologies on Twitter from everyone who said AG Merrick Garland was not serious about holding Trump accountable?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Is this really a front-burner issue?
House Republicans
@HouseGOP
“This week, House Republicans will proudly pass the Save Our Gas Stoves Act and the Gas Stove Protection and Freedom Act." - @RepStefanik
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If we have to have the heir of an iconic political name running for president, couldn’t it be Ron Reagan?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This should be a Netflix series.
Sarah Bee🐝
@BirrelleBee
This flying squirrel faked his own death, and created a whole crime scene…for attention. I think I’m in love. x.com/kkMrRay/status/1665007776588783619/video/1
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A good essay to read today: "You can’t love your country when you hate half of the people in it, and are ready to make war against them."
Steve Schmidt
@SteveSchmidtSES
On June 5, 1968, Robert Francis Kennedy was shot by Sirhan Sirhan, and died the next day. On the eve of the 55th anniversary of his death, I wanted to share an essay that I wrote last fall about two of the greatest speeches of all time — one from Martin Luther King, and the other from RFK: steveschmidt.substack.com/p/remembering-rfk
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is an exceptional essay, and the LBJ clips are riveting. Vietnam derailed an extraordinary presidency.
Steve Schmidt
@SteveSchmidtSES
"I’ve been thinking lately about the greatest generation of Americans. I don’t think they’ve been born yet... The greatest generation though will be the one that finally creates what Winthrop imagined, and that Dr. King saw from the mountaintop. It is a just, harmonious, peaceful, beautiful 'city upon a hill.'"
steveschmidt.substack.com/p/americas-greatest-generation-… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Has anyone seen my dog?? #corgicrew
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I emphatically concur with @Dahlialithwick in the case of Complainers v. #tedlasso lm.facebook.com/l.php?u=https://slate.com/culture/2023/06…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The Founders intended that the first debt limit statute be enacted after World War I.
Kevin McCarthy
@SpeakerMcCarthy
President Biden and Senator Schumer demanded a “clean debt limit,” which really means more taxes and more spending. But that’s not what the American people wanted, or our Founders envisioned, or what Republicans were going to allow. x.com/i/broadcasts/1mnxeRQyDVNKX
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
When the automated placement of an ellipsis inadvertently reveal’s someone’s real thinking.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
And this post has the link!
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
The podcast's namesake, "Democracy's Chief Executive: Interpreting the Constitution and Defining the Future of the Presidency," by @petermshane is part of the @ucpress 40% off sale on its entire catalog for the month of May. Just order by Wednesday.😉www.ucpress.edu/book/9780520380905/democracys-chief-execu…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I just realized that @ucpress is having a 40% off sale on its entire catalog for the month of May. You can get -- ahem -- "Democracy's Chief Executive: Interpreting the Constitution and Defining the Future of the Presidency" at a hefty discount. And much else! 😉@demchiefexecpod
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is *potentially* quite important. You should follow @BridgetDooling's entire thread because this is deep in the weeds, but will require further analysis once we see the text.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This week, the GOP-controlled Texas House impeached Ken Paxton and refused to abolish the tenure system at Texas universities. In related news, Satan was spotted putting on ice skates.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/2 @acslaw has a new episode of the Broken Law podcast on which Garrett Epps and I review with host @jeanne_hruska @POTUS's options if a deal to raise the #debtlimit does not materialize. open.spotify.com/episode/2cJnZy54jmVT0ddZqn2L7O
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
2/2 Despite talk of a "#14thamendment option," I share the view that @POTUS has statutory authority to pay our debts without declaring the #debtlimit statute unconstitutional. If you're craving more #debtlimit discussion for your Memorial Day Weekend, this one's for you!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If there is a heaven, here’s what’s playing tonight.
youtu.be/sDX3dH0twFo -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
An excellent analysis of why the mifepristone case should be thrown out for lack of standing.
Jonathan H. Adler
@jadler1969
CA5 heard oral argument in AHM v. FDA today. Let's hope the current panel does not repeat the errors of the last one.
reason.com/volokh/2023/04/13/the-good-and-bad-of-the-fift… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/4 My latest at @Monthly discusses the apparent eagerness of the right-wing SCOTUS supermajority to narrow the deference that judges owe to administrators in interpreting the law. So-called Chevron deference is rooted in a 1984 SCOTUS decision...washingtonmonthly.com/2023/05/15/the-next-regulatory-disa…
Post not available here, view on X
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
3/4 agency heads. Interestingly, though, the lower court opinion that the Supreme Court reversed was written by Judge Douglas Ginsburg, who Reagan announced several years later as his intended nominee to succeed Lewis Powell on the Supreme Court after Bork was rejected. Ginsburg
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
4/4 withdrew from consideration after reports he had smoked marijuana with some of his law students at Harvard. But, as a former head of OMB's Office of Regulatory Affairs, Judge Ginsburg was well steeped in the subject on which he was opining.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The downside of retiring from @OSU_Law includes not getting to work closely with the phenomenal new faculty the College of Law has hired. The upside includes not having to witness the problematic-to put it nicely-decline in OSU governance beyond Moritz. www.chronicle.com/article/as-bizarre-as-it-sounds-at-ohio…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/3 Reflecting on different analyses made powerfully by @profepps and @dorfonlaw, I wrote nearly 10 yrs ago in support of what Mike Dorf and Neil Buchanan called the "least unconstitutional option." @POTUS should treat appropriations laws as implicitly... www.huffpost.com/entry/the-constitutional-stakes_b_4098595
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
2/3 authorizing sufficient borrowing to allow POTUS to both carry out those laws and to repay U.S. debts on time, notwithstanding any debt limit statute. Otherwise, to keep up debt payments, POTUS would have to cut spending unilaterally and without legislative guidance. This...
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
would aggrandize executive power far beyond just treating the debt limit statute as invalid. @Profepps now has a @monthly article defending the latter as the best course. He might be right. Either way, the practice of holding the economy hostage must end. washingtonmonthly.com/2023/05/08/ive-argued-for-years-tha…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
No, if my favorite Justices are receiving secret gifts worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, they, too, should resign.
This post is unavailable. See it on X.
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I should have started this: "Acknowledging this is a sarcastic take on what some of Thomas's defenders are saying, my response is, "No . . ."
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Feeling a little bad that my most noticed tweet ever was quote-tweeting what was actually a sarcastic parody of the position with which both I and the parodist disagree, but the framing suggests I was criticizing the parodist, which I did not intend. Apologies, @SCOTUSPlaces!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
“Rich people enriching a Supreme Court Justice and his family were not trying to influence the Justice’s ideology, but just to show appreciation for it,” is not all that reassuring a defense of judicial independence.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
An important paper.
anya bernstein
@anyabernstein
Now out, with @cmrodriguez95 in @YaleLJournal! Government accountability takes so much more than elections. We show how US administrative agencies support deliberation, inclusivity, and responsiveness (and argue that we should support them further).
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I'm sure @chris_j_walker and I can find stuff to disagree on, but this thread won't be it (except, I suppose, that I am not as sympathetic to the MQD as my former office neighbor.)
Chris Walker
@chris_j_walker
Reupping this 🧵 in light of #scotus grant today in this case on whether to overrule Chevron (or at least narrow it further) 👇
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Panda-monium?
Nature is Amazing ☘️
@AMAZlNGNATURE
Hey, you.
This is important.
Four Panda pals having a meeting over some apples.
What do you think they're talking about? -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Talking with actual criminal law experts @CBHessick, @NormEisen, and @ric_l_simmons (an assistant Manhattan DA before starting his teaching career) helped to clarify my own thinking about the Trump indictment. I hope listeners feel the same.
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
This week's bonus episode on which @petermshane and @CBHessick discuss the NY Trump indictment with @NormEisen and @ric_l_simmons has grown its audience fastest. We urge listeners newly discovering @demchiefexecpod to check out the episodes they missed! open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Palsgraf anyone? www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12004403/Pensioner-urina…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Feeling a little sorry for @donlemon that CNN didn't fire him on a day on which, "CNN Fires Don Lemon" would at least be the top headline even in the Cable-Network-News-Firings category.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It’s up! “Prosecuting Past Presidents” is a bonus episode of @demchiefexecpod. What does the NY Trump indictment augur for Trump? The rule of law? The presidency? @CBHessick and I discuss the issues with @NormEisen and @ric_l_simmons. open.spotify.com/episode/1MeUARFMP6U1FpnVrKisTr?dd=1
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I'm thinking we were too hard on Harriet Miers.
Steve Vladeck
@steve_vladeck
Justice Alito last night: “The majority is wrongly granting emergency relief in a case in which I’m not convinced the criteria are satisfied.”
Justice Alito on April 6: “We should grant emergency relief because we should put aside the reasons why the criteria are not satisfied.” -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A separation of powers scholar and three criminal law experts walk into a podcast and . . . @demchiefexecpod
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Coming Monday 4/24: @petermshane and co-host @CBHessick, director of the Prosecutors and Politics Project at @UNC_Law, discuss specifics of the NY Trump indictment and its larger implications with @NormEisen and @ric_l_simmons on a bonus Episode 7 of @demchiefexecpod Season 1!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I learned a lot from this conversation. Given @NormEisen's deep anti-corruption experience, @ric_l_insimmons' background in the Manhattan DA's office, and @CBHessick's exploration of democracy's role in shaping the job of prosecutor, there was a lot to discuss! @DemChiefExecPod
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Coming next week! The bonus Episode 7 of Democracy Chief Executive’s first season: "Prosecuting Past Presidents." Host @petermshane and co-host @CBHessick take a “big picture,” as well as detailed look at the NY Trump indictment with @NormEisen and @ric_l_simmons.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
One value I have derived from Twitter is reading thoughts from conservative legal scholars with whom I typically disagree, but who challenge me and illuminate other points of view. I now see them in my feed hardly ever or never. @jadler1969 @wrdcsc @kewhittington @chris_j_walker
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I can't overstate how gratifying it is to get this reaction to @demchiefexecpod. The next "listen" our Season 1 programming attracts will be Number 1000. And yes, a bonus episode is coming soon!
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
This came to my inbox: "I have now listened to all of these, and they are terrific. You picked terrific people on every topic. I have recommended all the episodes to my Con Law students. Thank you for doing these, and I hope there will be more to come in the future!" So grateful.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
There’s going to be a BONUS Season 1 episode of @demchiefexecpod because events demand it. Super grateful to all Season 1 listeners!
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Did we say our plan was a “six-episode Season 1?” Well, a bonus seventh episode of Democracy’s Chief Executive is coming in a couple of weeks: “Prosecuting Past Presidents.” Co-host and guest details soon! Meanwhile, catch Episodes 1-6 wherever you get your podcasts.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It turns out that one of the plagues was Bluebooking. How Many Plagues Were There in Egypt? Surprise! - Archaeology
www.haaretz.com/archaeology/2023-04-09/ty-article/how-man… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I'm haunted today by a line from Elton John/Bernie Taupin song, "Empty Garden": It's funny how one insect can damage so much grain.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Because life can’t be all Trump all the time: If you’ve ever had #tetris addiction — or if the idea of a fast-paced, suspenseful, politically themed movie about intellectual property and video games appeals to you — you must see Tetris on @AppleTVPlus — an unsolicited review!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Fifth Circuit panel unanimously rejects state standing to challenge Biden administration guidance on social cost of greenhouse gas emissions www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/22/22-30087-CV0.pdf
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Just having @michelebgoodwin in the same time zone is making me exceedingly happy!
Victoria Nourse
@vicnourse
Well @LawrenceGostin, you are not the only one who is *exceedingly* happy today. Kudos to @michelebgoodwin who adds immensely to our luster in so many ways....
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Not every day can be Festivus.
George Conway ⚖️🇺🇸
@gtconway3d
"The teleprompter speech Trump delivered was low-energy, not just by his standards, but by nearly any standards — a routine, if grievance-filled, stump speech on a historic night. Speaking to a crowd of dues-paying club members and Trumpworld loyalists — some of his adult children, Roger Stone, a close coterie of 2024 campaign aides — Trump failed to harness the moment, or even offer compelling television. Some cable channels cut away from him mid-remarks."
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My new essay on @monthly echoes the warnings of @russfeingold and Peter Prindiville about any new constitutional convention and advances their argument that we need a new process for formal constitutional amendment. washingtonmonthly.com/2023/04/03/amend-the-constitutional…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If, for some reason, your mind is drifting to thoughts of law and the presidency, but you have not yet listened to all six Season 2 episodes of Democracy’s Chief Executive, maybe this weekend is a good time to start. @demchiefexecpod open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v?dd=1
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I meant Season 1!!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I think this is called experiential learning.
George Conway ⚖️🇺🇸
@gtconway3d
it's so good to see that the ol'-drop-it-in-the-mail-just-before-leaving-on-vacation trick is alive and well
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In the reassuring voices of everyone saying humanity will be “just fine” amid the advance of AI, I hear the echoes of newspaper publishers’ assurances that their industry would be “just fine” after the invention of the Internet.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Garrett Epps has a fine essay in the new @monthly profiling John Eastman, with whom he has had "the friendship one law professor develops with another across ideological lines." He links Eastman's rabbit hole journey with the GOP's 2000 Florida experience. washingtonmonthly.com/2023/03/28/the-dangerous-journey-of…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For example, this might be a great week to listen to @RickPildes and me talking with @SIssacharoff and @PAhdout about “Presidents in Court” (Episode 5). @demchiefexecpod
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Because all six episodes of Democracy’s Chief Executive Season 1 are up, there’s no new episode to debut today. But if there are one or more you haven’t yet listened to, they can still make their debut in your queue!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Last month, a @washingtonpost newsletter framed the SCOTUS case on student loan relief this way: "The question at the core of this case is this: Biden canceled the debt via executive order. Is that allowed?" If you don't see the writer's goof, Ep. 4 of @demchiefexecpod explains!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Ep. 2 is on POTUS emergency and war powers. Ep. 4 is on the reach of executive orders. Ep. 6 is on impeachment, incl. an interview with @RepHoltzman about her experience on the 1973-74 House Judiciary Committee and reflections on recent impeachments. Wherever you get podcasts!
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Do Trump's private lawyers' travails make you wonder about the job of a President's government lawyers? (Ep. 1) Does talk of executive privilege leave you uncertain about its scope? (Ep. 3) Can courts keep presidential power in check? (Ep. 5) Add @DemChiefExecPod to your queue!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The interview with Mike Gerhardt amounted to something of an audio primer on impeachment law. We discussed the (mistaken) argument that "high crimes and misdemeanors" refers only to statutory crimes, and he explained why "double jeopardy" does not apply in an impeachment context.
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
"Here's the point behind impeachment: We don't have impeachment because we need another forum for federal criminal trials. We have impeachment as a means to get at misconduct that's not gettable by any other means." - @unc_law Prof. Gerhardt
open.spotify.com/episode/3F6DqGn71P1DztsvcQ3qYS -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The interview with @RepHoltzman was fascinating. Her account of Peter Rodino's approach as Judiciary Committee chair and the way in which committee members overcame rank partisanship is illuminating.
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
This week on the pod: @RepHoltzman, who served on the House Judiciary Committee during the Watergate investigation, discusses the differences between recent impeachments and the Nixon impeachment: 👇
open.spotify.com/episode/3F6DqGn71P1DztsvcQ3qYS -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Episode 5, focusing on courts and presidents launched this week. @RickPildes and I got to explore the issues with @PAhdout and @SIssacharoff. Sam reminded us that it’s not just the U.S. struggling with checks and balances. @demchiefexecpod
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
This week on the pod, @SIssacharoff discusses the growth of the executive in democracies around the world: 🧵
“[T]he legislative branch is in decline and it’s to the point of being dysfunctional in a great many democratic countries.” [1/2] -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It was a privilege and much fun.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I’m old enough to remember when “judicial temperament” was considered an actual thing—both a qualification for office and a virtue to be practiced while serving. I seem to recall it had something to do with humility, respect, craft, intellectual integrity, and self-restraint.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
On Democracy’s Chief Executive, I am interviewer. On the @acslaw #brokenlaw podcast, I had the fun of being interviewee. Many thanks to @jeanne_hruska for the opportunity to discuss #separationofpowers law and @demchiefexecpod!
American Constitution Society
@acslaw
Question: How powerful should our democracy's chief executive be? @jeanne_hruska speaks w/ @petermshane on this wk's #brokenlawpodcast about this question +the evolution of executive power over the last 40 yrs
Listen wherever u get ur #podcasts or here
www.acslaw.org/podcast/episode-93-how-powerful-should-ame… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
via @NYTimes I no longer think it hyperbolic to call the Supreme Court’s prescribed methodology, as interpreted by lower courts, for identifying constitutionally acceptable gun regulations insane. Any resemblance to actual law is coincidental. #bruen www.nytimes.com/2023/03/14/us/gun-law-1791-supreme-court.…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Neither snow, nor rain, nor spring break shall keep us from releasing a great new discussion on Democracy’s Chief Executive! @demchiefexecpod
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
On Episode 5 of Democracy’s Chief Executive, @petermshane explores with @nyulaw Profs. @RickPildes and @SIssacharoff and Prof. @PAhdout of @UVALaw the role of courts in checking executive power. Do courts do enough? Can executive overreach be checked without judicial overreach?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"We've been asked which treats are best for corgis. We like the 'more' kind. You can't go wrong giving us more treats. Or listening to the Democracy's Chief Executive podcast. While giving us more treats. Thank you for listening." #corgicrew @demchiefexecpod
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
On Ep. 4 of Democracy's Chief Executive, @rudalev explains that while unitary executive theory may attract some as a constitutional reading, it doesn't really describe the executive branch's organizational reality-even when it comes to drafting executive orders. @demchiefexecpod
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
On this week's episode: “[M]y research suggests that there's no such thing as the unitary executive. It's a complicated large executive branch, and that makes the job of the President a managerial one in many ways.” - @rudalev [1/2]
open.spotify.com/episode/0SM4p0MbAcCW85PyIvcTup -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The conversations on Democracy's Chief Executive benefit from including academic experts who also have high-level government experience. @kateashaw1 is a great example. @demchiefexecpod
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Can the Court consider presidential statements (and, perhaps, tweets?) when interpreting executive orders? @kateashaw1 discusses:
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Since Lincoln, presidents have issued over 14,000 executive orders. What are they? Are they law? What do they accomplish? @GillianMetzger2 and I explore the topic with political scientist @rudalev and @kateashaw1 of @CardozoLaw and @StrictScrutiny_ on Ep. 4 of @demchiefexecpod!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Ep. 4 of Democracy's Chief Executive drops tomorrow! Columbia's @GillianMetzger2 and I explore with political scientist @rudalev and @kateashaw1 of @CardozoLaw and @StrictScrutiny_ if presidents can run the country with executive orders. @demchiefexecpod Catch up on Eps. 1-3 now!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If you feel lost among news stories referring to “executive privilege,” “classified information,” “Presidential Records Act,” etc., may I recommend Ep. 3 of Democracy’s Chief Executive for weekend podcast listening? @demchiefexecpod A new episode drops Monday!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"Listen! Do you wanna know a [presidential] secret?" On Episode 3 of the Democracy's Chief Executive podcast, @MarkJRozellGMU and I explore w/ @heidikitrosser & Prof. Margaret Kwoka why getting executive branch info can be tough. Alas, no #beatles are involved.
@demchiefexecpod -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"Listen! Do you wanna know a [presidential] secret?" On Episode 3 of Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast, @MarkJRozellGMU and I explore with @heidikitrosser & Prof. Margaret Kwoka why getting executive branch info can tough. Alas, no #beatles are involved. @demchiefexecpod
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
THREAD 🧵: @MarkJRozellGMU asks @NorthwesternLaw Prof. Heidi Kitrosser: “There's this whole controversy over who exactly can claim executive privilege. Does a former President have any right to do that at all? How far does this power extend into the executive branch itself?” 👇
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
THREAD 🧵: @OSU_Law Prof. Margaret Kwoka on executive privilege, the Freedom of Information Act, and the Presidential Records Act 👇
open.spotify.com/episode/79o0lUmgzuZgPhEQTSK93W -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
"The idea behind this version of executive privilege, the presidential communications privilege, is that the President has a right—even a responsibility—under Art. II of the Constitution, to withhold some information." - Prof. Heidi Kitrosser open.spotify.com/episode/79o0lUmgzuZgPhEQTSK93W
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Great fun on Episode 3 joining @MarkJRozellGMU of @ScharSchool, @heidikitrosser of @NorthwesternLaw and Prof. Margaret Kwoka of @OSU_Law in trying to bring some clarity to the complicated legal landscape regulating access to executive branch information! @demchiefexecpod
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
THREAD 🧵: @MarkJRozellGMU asks @NorthwesternLaw Prof. Heidi Kitrosser: “There's this whole controversy over who exactly can claim executive privilege. Does a former President have any right to do that at all? How far does this power extend into the executive branch itself?” 👇
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Episode 3 of Democracy’s Chief Executive is up! The focus is on executive branch secrets. (It’s not a secret that you can listen to our first 3 episodes in any order!) Follow @demchiefexecpod.
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Can democracy afford to pay no attention to the man behind the curtain of executive privilege? This week, @petermshane is joined by @MarkJRozellGMU, @OSU_Law Prof. Margaret Kwoka & @NorthwesternLaw Prof. Heidi Kitrosser to discuss presidential secrecy.
open.spotify.com/episode/79o0lUmgzuZgPhEQTSK93W?si=e4a881… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If you wonder about the difference between executive privilege and classified info or why getting info on policy making deliberations inside the executive branch is hard, @demchiefexecpod Ep. 3, debuting tomorrow, is for you! Meanwhile, Sunday's perfect to catch up on Eps/ 1 & 2.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The Spelling Bee is not into financial planning.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Still choosing a weekend media menu? May I suggest Democracy's Chief Executive? Besides Episode 1 described below, Episode 2 is up, featuring
@mattwaxman1, @dmdriesen and @lizagoitein on presidential power in war and nat'l emergencies. Episode 3 lands Monday! @demchiefexecpod
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Best way to celebrate President's Day? Tune in for the launch of a new podcast on law and the presidency and follow us on @demchiefexecpod. On Episode 1, @kassopn joins me in talking to Prof. Bob Bauer and @jacklgoldsmith for an inside look into the president’s lawyers.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1st-week excitement for Democracy's Chief Executive = watching audience grow and how almost everyone listening to one of our first 2 episodes listens to both! Ep. 3, on POTUS secrecy, drops 2/27. Ep. 1, on POTUS's lawyers and Ep. 2, on war/emergency power up now! @demchiefexecpod
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I had today the disquieting realization that my speaking to my Con Law class about Watergate as if it were yesterday would be like a law professor in a 1972 con law class reminiscing about the Harding Administration.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
ICYMI: On Episode 2 @lizagoitein describes the Biden Administration’s use of executive action to forgive student debt as “a slippery slope.” 👇[1/5]
open.spotify.com/episode/1K9K9OYkbcOJ9iZEHG4jfk -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
“Government attorney-client privilege is very different than attorney-client privilege, because the White House Counsel is the lawyer for the office of the presidency, and serves at the pleasure of the government.” -@kassopn
open.spotify.com/episode/1xYbu7jM2W9x3imlGkd0L9 -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
“Historically, emergency powers have not just led to atrocities like Japanese internment, but actually brought down democratic states or contributed to the bringing down of democratic states.” -@dmdriesen [1/2]
open.spotify.com/episode/1K9K9OYkbcOJ9iZEHG4jfk -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
We're on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and Google Podcasts! Subscribe now for alerts when a new episode drops👇
open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/democracys-chief-executive/…
music.youtube.com/googlepodcasts -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Democracy’s Chief Executive: The Podcast launched yesterday! I’m amazed to say we even have listeners in Germany, Mexico, and the UK. I’ve been advised, however, that my corgi companion, Berwyn, should be enlisted in spreading the word. So here he is. @demchiefexecpod
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Witn @kassopn as co-host, talking about presidential lawyering to @jacklgoldsmith and Bob Bauer on @demchiefexecpod was an ideal way to start the series.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Great discussion w @petermshane and @kassopn and Bob Bauer on lawyering for the presidency. Looking forward to the rest of this series on the presidency and democracy.
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Best way to celebrate President's Day? Tune in for the launch of a new podcast on law and the presidency and follow us on @demchiefexecpod. On Episode 1, @kassopn joins me in talking to Prof. Bob Bauer and @jacklgoldsmith for an inside look into the president’s lawyers.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
POTUS's Day! A double feature to launch "Democracy's Chief Executive": On Ep. 1, @kassopn and I talk to Bob Bauer & @jacklgoldsmith about lawyering POTUS. On Ep. 2, @dmdriesen, @LizaGoitein of @BrennanCenter, & @mattwaxman1 and I talk POTUS war/emergency powers. @demchiefexecpod
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
🧵THREAD 🧵: "Some of the most egregious abuses of executive power have actually relied on claims of inherent constitutional emergency authority."- @LizaGoitein [1/3]
open.spotify.com/episode/1K9K9OYkbcOJ9iZEHG4jfk -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
“[The Office of Legal Counsel] was not there to tell the President what he wanted to hear. That was not our job.” -@jacklgoldsmith
open.spotify.com/episode/1xYbu7jM2W9x3imlGkd0L9 -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
🚨 CODE RED 🚨: Episode 2 on presidential power during war and national emergencies just dropped. Join Peter and guests @mattwaxman1 @dmdriesen and @lizagoitein for a discussion on holding the executive accountable in the face of exigency.
open.spotify.com/episode/1K9K9OYkbcOJ9iZEHG4jfk -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Happy President’s Day! Celebrate with the inaugural episode of Democracy’s Chief Executive: The President’s Lawyers. From John Dean to Don McGahn, who are these influential Executive Branch lawyers and who are they representing?
open.spotify.com/episode/1xYbu7jM2W9x3imlGkd0L9 -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
TOMORROW: Episode 1 of Democracy’s Chief Executive, with @petermshane, @kassopn, Bob Bauer, & @jacklgoldsmith. Plus, stay tuned for a BONUS EPISODE with @mattwaxman1, @dmdriesen, & @LizaGoitein on the presidency in war & national emergencies.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social reposted
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
What does it mean to be “the President’s lawyer?” This President’s Day, @petermshane & SUNY New Paltz Prof. @kassopn talk to former White House Counsel & NYU Law Prof. Bob Bauer and former Assistant AG & Harvard Law Prof. @jacklgoldsmith.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Here's the Day 1 launch program for @DemChiefExecPod. Thank you, studio crew at @nyulaw! Season 1 guests include @kassopn @jacklgoldsmith @MarkJRozellGMU @heidikitrosser @dmdriesen @lizagoitein @mattwaxman1 @GillianMetzger2 @rudalev @kateshaw1 @RickPildes @PAhdout @SIssacharoff
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
TOMORROW: Episode 1 of Democracy’s Chief Executive, with @petermshane, @kassopn, Bob Bauer, & @jacklgoldsmith. Plus, stay tuned for a BONUS EPISODE with @mattwaxman1, @dmdriesen, & @LizaGoitein on the presidency in war & national emergencies.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Getting ready for tomorrow, President’s Day! @demchiefexecpod
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
We're on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and Google Podcasts! Subscribe now for alerts when a new episode drops👇
open.spotify.com/show/59gIdLq8eLWelZphAXcn5v
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/democracys-chief-executive/…
music.youtube.com/googlepodcasts -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is a man who, for all the years he has been afforded, still deserves more. He has made every year count. I am glad that his passing will occur under a successor who will pay him the respect he is due. It was a privilege to start my legal career during his Administration.
💙Brittney💙
@AZ_Brittney
President Carter is receiving Hospice Care. Drop a 💙 if you support him.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Monday, my new podcast on law and the presidency, “Democracy’s Chief Executive,” launches. Last night, my fortune cookie said this. Don’t listen to the podcast because I told you to. Listen because the cookie told you to. We’re @DemChiefExecPod. (No, I don’t know the baker!)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
TFW your Friday night fortune cookie knows that on Monday, you’re launching a new podcast series, “Democracy’s Chief Executive!” @demchiefexecpod
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Super-excited to be presenting this afternoon and to hear from so many people whose work I admire!
Jed Shugerman
@jedshug
TODAY:
10:40:
I. The Founding
1 pm:
II. Art II & Executive Practice
@petermshane @ascoseriakatz @cmrodriguez95 @anyabernstein & co.
2:45:
III. Art III & Adjudication
@narosenblum et al
(Bonus: Find the hidden substantive constitutional argument in the schedule!) -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Talking presidential lawyering with those who have done it! @demchiefexecpod
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
What does it mean to be “the President’s lawyer?” This President’s Day, @petermshane & SUNY New Paltz Prof. @kassopn talk to former White House Counsel & NYU Law Prof. Bob Bauer and former Assistant AG & Harvard Law Prof. @jacklgoldsmith.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If a one-minute trailer isn’t enough to satisfy your curiosity prior to launch day, we now have a three-minute trailer previewing our themes. Look for “Democracy’s Chief Executive” wherever you get your podcasts! @demchiefexecpod
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Best way to celebrate President's Day? Tune in for the launch of a new podcast on law and the presidency and follow us on @demchiefexecpod. On Episode 1, @kassopn joins me in talking to Prof. Bob Bauer and @jacklgoldsmith for an inside look into the president’s lawyers.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Thanks to @monthly for helping to spread the word!
Washington Monthly
@monthly
Great news! Washington Monthly Contributing Writer @petermshane will be hosting a new podcast on law and the presidency, making its launch on President's Day February 20!
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Best way to celebrate President's Day? Tune in for the launch of a new podcast on law and the presidency and follow us on @demchiefexecpod. On Episode 1, @kassopn joins me in talking to Prof. Bob Bauer and @jacklgoldsmith for an inside look into the president’s lawyers.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Best way to celebrate President's Day? Tune in for the launch of a new podcast on law and the presidency and follow us on @demchiefexecpod. On Episode 1, @kassopn joins me in talking to Prof. Bob Bauer and @jacklgoldsmith for an inside look into the president’s lawyers.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Themes of the new podcast @demchiefexecpod
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
Over the last half century, Congress & the courts have policed the legal & constitutional boundaries of presidential authority more than ever before. Can the US have a presidency that is healthy for democracy & the rule of law, while still strong enough to meet modern challenges?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Not fake news! I have the privilege of hosting a new podcast on law and the presidency, "Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast," launching on President's Day, February 20. Follow us on @demchiefexecpod!
Democracy's Chief Executive: The Podcast
@demchiefexecpod
COMING SOON: Democracy’s Chief Executive: The Podcast. Constitutional scholar @petermshane brings together legal experts to explore the question “Are presidents above the law?”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Sarah Huckabee Sanders said the voters will get to choose between “crazy” and “normal.” I think we have to agree to agree on that.
Michael Steele
@MichaelSteele
Pathetic on every level.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For all the comparisons people made early of @POTUS to FDR, the #sotu really seemed to channel the mix of assertiveness and bonhomie that was Hubert Humphrey.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Amazed at how much of the criticism about our response to the Chinese surveillance #balloon seems like so much . . . hot air.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I am eager to read the new book by @SIssacharoff!
Sam Issacharoff
@SIssacharoff
Pleased to announce my new book, Democracy Unmoored, available in March
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is not a parody account??
House Judiciary GOP 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
@JudiciaryGOP
THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION TRIED TO HIDE THE CHINESE SPY BALLOON FROM THE AMERICAN PUBLIC.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/2 The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit has determined that prohibiting the possession of firearms by someone subject to a domestic violence restraining order violates the #secondamendment under #bruen. The panel acknowledges that, under . . . www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/21/21-11001-CR1.pdf
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
2/2 the post-#heller interpretive consensus among the courts of appeals, the law was fine. But after the hubristic nonsense--I mean, majority opinion--in #bruen, the available historical analogies were insufficiently compelling to disarm persons under protective court orders.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Yes, yes, yes!
Josh Chafetz
@joshchafetz
To the extent that the College Board is removing material from the AP curriculum to satisfy anti-intellectual dimwits, universities should reevaluate giving credit for those AP exams.
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Aren't #ap courses supposed to represent college-level work? If that's the case, how can a college-level #ap course in Afro-American History omit elements of what surely must be regarded in 2023 as elements of basic competency in the subject?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Aren't #ap courses supposed to represent college-level work? If that's the case, how can a college-level #ap course in Afro-American History omit elements of what surely must be regarded in 2023 as elements of basic competency in the subject?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My prediction-to-manifestation time is not usually quite so short. www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/doj-tells-jim-jordan-that…
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The authority of Jim Jordan’s “weaponization” committee to explore “open investigations” runs headlong into the executive branch’s duty not to share open law enforcement files with Congress. My take in @monthly washingtonmonthly.com/2023/01/20/jim-jordans-reckless-new…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The authority of Jim Jordan’s “weaponization” committee to explore “open investigations” runs headlong into the executive branch’s duty not to share open law enforcement files with Congress. My take in @monthly washingtonmonthly.com/2023/01/20/jim-jordans-reckless-new…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This can’t be retweeted often enough!
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
So George #santos has been assigned to the House Committee on Small Business and the Committee on Space, Science, and Technology, or as they appear on his resume, the Nobel Prize for Economics Committee and the Council of the United Federation of Planets.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Kevin McCarthy was finally elected Speaker-ish.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Picture, 1000 words, etc.
Andrew Harnik
@andyharnik
Rep. Hudson, R-N.C., left, pulls Rep. Rogers, R-Ala., as he confronts Rep. Matt Gaetz, R-Fla., during the 14th round of voting for speaker as the House meets for the fourth day to try and elect a speaker in Washington, Friday, Jan. 6, 2023. (@AP Photo/@andyharnik)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This speech is amazing. Hope from A to Z. @RepJeffries
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Two random thoughts on Speaker Vote 12: It would be hard for Dems to write an ad against Republicans more biting than Gaetz’s attack on McCarthy. Also, Lacey Chabert should play Boebert in the inevitable TV movie. (Because of resemblance, not politics.)
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If Kevin McCarthy had led negotiations for the release of Brittney Griner, Putin would have been promised U.S. withdrawal from NATO, Super Bowl tickets, his face on Mt. Rushmore, changing Washington, D.C. to Putinsburg . . .and @brittneygriner would still be in the Gulag.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Note to GOP House pragmatists: There is another way forward. Moderate' Republican Jason Stephens snatches Ohio House Speaker position in surprise upset - Ohio Capital Journal ohiocapitaljournal.com/2023/01/04/moderate-republican-jas…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I don’t know who will be #speakerofthehouse on 1/5/23, but I have a pretty good guess as to who will be #speakerofthehouse on 1/3/25. @RepJeffries
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Memo to Any 6 GOP House members who care about government: You can become independent, caucus with D’s, and be the collective “Joe Manchin of the House.” Progressive Dems like me will hate the deals needed to satisfy you, but you’ll wind up with a record of achievement to run on.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Who could have imagined that a party that embraced the mantra, “Government is the problem,” would eventually elect candidates who are content to see the end of government?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This just in from Wishful Thinking Island: 6 House Republicans from swing districts could make themselves the most powerful affinity group in DC by becoming an independent "Getting Something Done Caucus" and negotiating with Democrats to give their speaker votes to @RepJeffries.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
To pay the 222 members of the House GOP caucus will cost the American taxpayers $38,628,000, not including the extra pay for the Speaker and Majority Leader. How's that investment working out so far?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Who can forget the immortal words of Hon. Nathaniel Banks (Speaker of the House, 1855-1857), "The 133rd time is a charm!"
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Can anything testify more powerfully to Trump’s declining relevance than his inability to bring unity to the House GOP caucus even with CAPS-LOCK on??
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is an early public service message in anticipation of the government shutdown coming inevitably on 10/1/23: Don't plan vacations in the national parks or to see the Air & Space Museum this fall. A party unable to elect a speaker will be unable to agree on a budget. #dcchaos
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
TFW your book is honored with an honor to which you did not know you could aspire! Very deep thanks to @RichardAlbert @ucpress
Richard Albert
@RichardAlbert
🎉 The 2022 Books of the Year | Separation of Powers 📚
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I had not known that the great-great-grandfather of @RepLizCheney fought four years for the Union during the Civil War. Her service on the @January6thCmte honors his memory.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
My latest @monthly installment!
Washington Monthly
@monthly
#scotus’s disregard of precedent, embrace of slipshod “originalist” history, and mischaracterization of fact has trickled down to lower courts, writes @petermshane. And it produces opinions that match the right-wing agenda but not well-established law. washingtonmonthly.com/2022/12/14/the-trickle-down-supreme…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Given recent decisions by jurors in New York and voters in Georgia, I have a lot of Billy Joel and Ray Charles playing in my head today.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Thoughtful of Utah to beat USC as badly as Michigan beat Ohio State. Go bucks!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Could there be a more crystalline expression of our depraved cultural moment than a pathologically dishonest extremist trying (unsuccessfully!) to tone down his “guest’s” antisemitism with a suggestion that, as a clothing designer, he perhaps meant only to praise Nazi uniforms?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"By attentive action in three areas—strategic regulatory planning, rulemaking review, and coordinated communications—policymakers can put regulations on stronger legal footing and continue to develop regulations that will protect the public." www.theregreview.org/2022/11/29/dobbs-allsopp-klarmn-shaw…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
With a law professor/novelist/journalist let loose on a story like this, I can only shout, "Hallelujah!" A Rare Inside Look at Our Corrupt Supreme Court | Washington Monthly washingtonmonthly.com/2022/11/28/a-rare-inside-look-at-ou…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
So much of what is needed to secure a relatively well-functioning U.S. democracy is just a little education and showing up at key moments, e.g., voting. Compared to the bravery of Ukrainians or the courage of demonstrators in Iran or the PRC, these seem pretty light demands.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I typed too quickly ("hours . . .is"), but maybe calculated too hastily. If Utah upsets USC in the PAC-12 championship, OSU has a shot at the playoffs. (For the record, had I not taught at @OSU_Law for 18 years, I could not imagine knowing enough to write that last sentence.)
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A lot of hours I might have spent watching postseason football is now freed up.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A lot of hours I might have spent watching postseason football is now freed up.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Say what you will about Sigmund Freud. He definitely nailed it with the concept of "projection."
John Harwood
@JohnJHarwood
Bill Barr says "the defining feature of our political landscape continues to be the sharp leftward lurch of the Democratic Party," allowing Republicans to attract "classical liberals who are repulsed by the left’s authoritarianism." nypost.com/2022/11/21/trump-threatens-to-burn-down-the-go…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A favorite memory of being Dean at @PittLaw in the mid-90s was co-writing a letter with @nyulaw’s then-Dean John Sexton, joined by all but a few ABA law deans and sent to all LSAT-takers, explaining @usnews rankings were nonsense. Their impact has been awful. I hope it unravels.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Two lawyers argue that Biden's action under the Antiquities Act of 1906 to designate 53,804 acres of Colorado land a national monument violates the separation of powers. Please tell Herbert Hoover who did the same to the 2 million acre Death Valley.
thehill.com/opinion/white-house/3738630-biden-reaches-for… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Here's part 2 of my reactions to contributors to the three-week @YaleJREG Notice & Comment blog symposium on "Democracy's Chief Executive" -- this time focusing on issues of constitutional interpretation and where we go from here.
www.yalejreg.com/nc/symposium-shane-democracy-chief-execu… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Hard to believe Wales would have a commercial for international travel that features zero corgis.
This is Cymru Wales
@walesdotcom
The warmest of Welsh welcomes to our friends in the USA!
C'mon in – everyone’s invited. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The @YaleJREG Notice & Comment blog ran 3 weeks of posts on my @ucpress book, "Democracy's Chief Executive." My response to 14 constructive commenters takes 2 essays! Part 1 is up today. So grateful to @ascoseriakatz and @chris_j_walker for organizing. www.yalejreg.com/nc/symposium-shane-democracy-chief-execu…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Looking at unofficial OH vote totals today liveresults.ohiosos.gov - it looks like 181,500 or so potential ballots left to count -- Democratic candidates so far have received 43% of the votes for the House, which ideally would mean 6-7/15 of the House races go D. They lead in 5.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If 51 D Senators, D’s get Judiciary Comm. majority (no discharge petitions needed for D judicial nominees), Schumer can let @Sen_JoeManchin do whatever best for his ‘24 reelection, and if D’s miraculously keep House, tax reform without Sinema becomes doable.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I just subscribed to One First stevevladeck.substack.com
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
As much as I look up to him, I’m pretty sure Jimmy Carter appeared on television and was under 5’ 10”—not by much, however
Chris Hayes
@chrislhayes
This is incredibly dumb and shallow, but it's a real thing: Americans haven't elected a president under 5'10" in the TV age. DeSantis has his work cut out for him.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I am deeply grateful for @blakeprof's thoughtful review. I will be sharing my substantive reactions to all the contributors in a brief essay next week.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Given that our potential younger voters, by definition, will live longest with the outcomes to public policies enacted today, it is hugely heartening to see the outpouring of energy and policy creativity coming out of GenZ and their successors.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The GOP approached #midterms amid 8% inflation and against the backdrop of a Dem presidential approval rating < 45%. They may wind up with 1 fewer Senate seat and the barest of House majorities--even with the help of grotesquely gerrymandered maps. This is truly a dismal showing.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It's amazing how, after getting tenure, some people finally do speak their minds.
Aaron Rupar
@atrupar
Obama "If there was an asteroid headed toward earth, it's gonna land in like two weeks, if you went into the Republican caucus and said, what do you want to do? 'Well, we need a tax break for the wealthy. That's gonna help.' I'm only barely exaggerating."
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The entire @mrc_ent statement on abandoning their Kanye West documentary is great. "Last week [West] sampled and remixed a classic tune that has charted for over 3000 years – the lie that Jews are evil and conspire to control the world for their own gain." www.mrcentertainment.com/newsroom/shelving-of-our-kanye-w…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The brief by Akhil & Vik Amar & Steven Calabresi demolishing #independentstatelegislature fraud is laudable. Its unusual structure and blunt tone reflect authors' status as insiders speaking to insiders. It's, "Don't kill (y)our brand by buying this BS." www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/21/21-1271/243761/20221024…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Thrilled to see launch of 3-week @YaleJReg-hosted symposium on my @ucpress book "Democracy's Chief Executive." Profoundly grateful to organizer @ascoseriakatz, who gets things started with an intro to key themes, and to instigator-in-chief @chris_j_walker. www.yalejreg.com/nc/symposium-shane-democracy-chief-execu…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Not usually an enthusiast for period films accompanied by wildly anachronistic soundtracks, but @lenadunham’s #catherinecalledbirdymovie is spectacularly entertaining. Extra points if you’re feeling the need for some uplift these days.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
She will rule your life. He controls mine. Resistance is futile.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Voodoo economics--which really was a 1980 canard on voodoo--working its magic in 2022.
The Daily Show
@TheDailyShow
These Fox Business experts absolutely nailed it on Liz Truss 🙃
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Con Law profs on Twitter: Have you taught from a casebook of which you are not a co-author that you would recommend to others?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Sorry, but I had to turn in my membership card today in the Never Caught COVID Society. Getting antivirals tomorrow.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Genuine questions: Do we know how much of the various models of "likely voters" incorporate assumptions of fairly low participation in midterms by 18-25-year-old voters? Is there plausible evidence to suggest the young voter turnout in 2022 will be uncharacteristically strong?
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I am profoundly disappointed by the seeming lack of puns on #truss in headlines announcing her resignation, e.g., Truss Collapses, Truss Loses All Support, etc.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Not quite Washington's letter to the Jews of Newport: "It is now no more that toleration is spoken of as if it were the indulgence of one class of people that another enjoyed the exercise of their inherent natural rights, for, happily, the Government of the United States,
Maggie Haberman
@maggieNYT
Former US president warns US Jews to get their “act together,” be more like Israelis, and appreciate him more
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
which gives to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance, requires only that they who live under its protection should demean themselves as good citizens in giving it on all occasions their effectual support...
May the children of the stock of Abraham ...
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
who dwell in this land continue to merit and enjoy the good will of the other inhabitants — while every one shall sit in safety under his own vine and fig tree and there shall be none to make him afraid.
tourosynagogue.org/history/george-washington-letter/washi… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Have I mentioned that, decades ago, I was a starship officer? My #badge was also a communicator.
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I forgot to add: I was also a Vulcan.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Never has the caveat, "Dictated, but not read," seemed so apt.
Scott MacFarlane
@MacFarlaneNews
In sprawling, 14-page response to House Jan 6 Select Cmte, Trump doesn’t commit to an interview or to sharing documents… instead doubling-down on baseless election fraud claims, with mentions of “Antifa”, “Hacks and Thugs”, “Hoax”, “Fake News”… and an opening line in ALL CAPS
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The classic Trumpian move would not be to challenge the subpoena immediately, but to pretend he's willing to negotiate an appearance and then drag it out. Would maintain faux suspense and keep him in the headlines.
Steve Vladeck
@steve_vladeck
Eventually, Trump would likely lose a challenge to the subpoena. But it's hard to see how the judicial process runs its course between now and 1/3/23.
So the likelihood of Trump ever having to comply depends almost entirely on whether the Democrats maintain control of the House. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Even as a triple-boosted American, I didn’t really pay attention to the conspiracy theorists who said something or other would be triggered in my system yesterday. But now that October 10 has passed and I didn’t acquire special spidey powers, I’m feeling a little cheated.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Call me naive, but every time a legislator boasts about a bill they voted against, I am surprised anew by such brazen hypocrisy.
John Kennedy
@SenJohnKennedy
I am proud to welcome scientists and researchers from around the world to Louisiana as the American Innovation and Manufacturing Act starts to do its work protecting our jobs and environment.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
A lovely and well-earned tribute. Why Anthony Fauci is the greatest public servant I have known www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/10/10/anthony-fauci-…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Let’s see — there’s Seattle Grace, Cook County General, Chicago Med, St. Bonaventure, St. Elsewhere …
Eric Hananoki
@ehananoki
"'I supervise six hospitals around the United States,' [Herschel Walker] said. ... There is no evidence that Walker ever supervised or started hospitals or medical centers." www.huffpost.com/entry/herschel-walker-hospitals_n_633d94…
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
How could I forget Princeton Plainsboro Teaching Hospital?!!? Apologies, Dr. House!
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
But it's also important to keep in mind that differences of degree may become differences in kind if participants in an institution are seen as abandoning the norms that kept dysfunction within relatively stable parameters.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
"In the construction of a doubtful and ambiguous law, the cotemporaneous construction of those who were called upon to act under the law and were appointed to carry its provisions into effect is entitled to very great respect." Edwards' Lessee v. Darby, 25 U.S. 206, 210 (1827).
Chris Walker
@chris_j_walker
Looking to read a defense of the major questions doctrine? Former Gorsuch clerk Lou Capozzi has posted to @SSRN a draft of a new article (@OhioStateLJ forth'g) that is worth a close read: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4234683
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For a federal judge to campaign for other federal judges to join him in a boycott of law clerks from any particular law school is despicable. Judge Ho may hire or not whomever he chooses, but this is an abuse of his office. news.bloomberglaw.com/business-and-practice/fifth-circuit…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Privileged to be in this group!
BK
@BradKutner
NEW from me: Law Professors Oppose Jan. 6 Immunity for Trump
@TheNLJ @MyConstitution @andrewkent33 @DaphnaRenan @petermshane #appellatetwitter
www.law.com/nationallawjournal/2022/09/30/law-professors-… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
If a legal scholar says it, it's got to be true.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Wouldn’t it be great if @lizzo’s enthusiasm for history actually excited a bunch more young people to study more history? Even when truth hurts?
Elie Mystal
@ElieNYC
White people freaking out over Lizzo playing a slaver’s flute is my favorite Twitter right now.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Great team for an excellent project!
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
.@wcd_a and I argue in @monthly that the Biden Administration’s plan to partially #cancelstudentdebt is on stronger legal ground than critics say—if courts apply administrative law doctrine non-cynically. washingtonmonthly.com/2022/09/28/the-republicans-are-comi…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Taking a moment's break from law and politics to heartily recommend #rebootonhulu with @KeeganMKey -- you know, just in case you need more laughter in your life.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Federal district judges in D.C. are bound to follow In re Lindsey, 158 F.3d 1263 (D.C. Cir. 1998), holding that the gov’t lawyer version of atty-client privilege does not excuse the attorney from providing evidence of a crime to a grand jury, even as to conversations with POTUS.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
For Trump, Judge #dearie’s commitment to “Put up or shut up!” must seem perplexing. He’s been effectively called on his BS so rarely in consequential contexts. #specialmaster
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
The wave of judicial competence washing over the litigation is a very welcome change.
Andrew Weissmann (weissmann11 on Threads/Insta)🌻
@AWeissmann_
BREAKING: Dearie’s order means business. No more pussy-footing around. Third day of the rule of law holding Donald Trump to account.
storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.618763/… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
It's a little weird that Judge Cannon, who attended Duke undergrad and apparently had a fine record at @UMichLaw, before going on to a federal clerkship and a pretty long stint as an AUSA, seems to be floundering when it comes to civil procedure.
Kyle Cheney
@kyledcheney
JUST IN: Judge Cannon has responded to the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals stay decision by striking aspects of her order appointing a special master.
storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.618763/… -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Wondering how many law profs this fall will be saying, “My grades aren’t late. I just ‘thought’ them instead of ‘posting’ them.”
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Amid Trump's gaslighting about declassification, it's important to recall that "classification" is not an element of the 18 USC 793 offense. The info still "relat[es] to the national defense" or "could be used to the injury of the [U.S.] or to the advantage of any foreign nation"
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Serious question: how far off is this from probable cause to search other Trump properties?
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Historians have just unearthed this rare photo of President Biden telepathically reclassifying all telepathically #declassified documents.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Next line of defense: If you put a document under your My Pillow at night, the Tooth Fairy declassifies it.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Short version of the 11th Cir. opinion: Not only is the gov’t entitled to complete, exclusive access to the docs with #classified markings, but U.S. will likely win its appeal because Cannon had no jurisdiction to intervene. Quite the unanimous rebuke including 2 Trump appointees
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
This is YUGE. #mar-a-Lago www.huffpost.com/entry/trump-court-lifts-hold-records_n_6…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
#dearie could perform a service by writing a set of instructions that happens to lay out the actual rules of law applicable to the mess Cannon created #naralago
Andrew Weissmann (weissmann11 on Threads/Insta)🌻
@AWeissmann_
2. She ORDERS plaintiff to divide docs into only two categories: those covered by the "PRA" and those that are "personal." But there is a third category: govt docs that are not presidential records under the PRA (such as agency docs Trump stole), but are still govt records. 2/2
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
#wordle freed me from its clutches today. There are 7 English words that start and end with the letters in positions 1, 2, 4, and 5. I didn’t guess the correct letter in position 3. I am relieved to be rid of this daily ritual.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
I’m old enough to remember when conservative legal objections to constitutionalizing #abortion rights were supposedly rooted in #federalism. www.huffpost.com/entry/abortion-ban-republicans_n_6320838…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
1/6 The Trump team's legal filing yesterday conceded that FBI counterintelligence personnel could participate in reviewing the seized documents and that evidence of crime discovered incidental to that search would be available in a prosecution. They say: storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.flsd.618763/…
Post not available here, view on X
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
5/6 the Government cannot undertake an action in which the purpose is to further the criminal investigation until after the Special Master has completed the required review. Although this yields discretion to intelligence personnel engaged in the security assessment, such ...
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
6/6 individuals must utilize such discretion judiciously to maintain the integrity of the Government in such unprecedented circumstances." This strikes me as likely to be a familiar arrangement for the FBI.
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Trump says the investigation of his potentially criminal violation of the Espionage Act is "a document storage dispute." In a posthumous filing, lawyers for Willy Sutton say his escapades widely called "bank robberies" were just money storage disputes. int.nyt.com/data/documenttools/trump-response/e240301c645…
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
In his eyes, I’m already a special master. #corgicrew
-
petermshane a/k/a petermshane.bksy.social
@petermshane
Valuable though written before Chevron put in doubt: "[C]ontrol over administrative policy change has increasingly moved into the purview of the courts and away from Congress" Chevron, State Farm, & Impact of Judicial Doctrine on Bureaucratic Policymaking www.cambridge.org/core/journals/perspectives-on-politics/…



















































































