I've finally gotten around to posting a draft of "Story's Anxiety: The Problem of the Local in General Law." It uses some of Story's own writings and cases to illustrate how pesky local variation was (and is). Abstract below! papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7711058
Jack Goldsmith
Jack Landman Goldsmith III (born September 26, 1962) is an American legal scholar. He serves as the Learned Hand Professor of Law at Harvard Law School, where he has written extensively in the fields of international law, civil procedure, federal courts, conflict of laws, and national security law. Writing in The New York Times, Jeffrey Rosen described him as being "widely considered one of the brightest stars in the conservative legal firmament". More on Wikipedia
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Molly Brady
@mollyxbrady
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
My Tribute to Richard Posner (from 2017; another to come, I hope).
www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2017-09-03/richard-pos… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
RIP Richard Posner.
He was an intellectual colossus and (outside of academic fights) a sweet man from whom I learned a lot.
But more importantly, he married my wife and me when we eloped 31 years ago.
It was a doubly stressful moment for a young academic—meeting Posner for the first time, and eloping.
“The only material question,” Posner said as he pulled a folder of wedding ceremonies from his desk, “is whether you want an allusion to a divine being.”
"Yes, please” said my dear bride, “we’re getting our marriage blessed in church when we get home.”
Posner the impish atheist looked at us with a twinkle and married us before God.
(And we did indeed have the wedding officially blessed a month later.)
Much love to Richard Posner and condolences to his family. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Zachary S. Price
@ZacharySPrice
I've posted some speculative thoughts about checks and balances after the midterms. The gist of it is that while Congress will have a lot of formal power, the more important question may be whether it retains the functional power to shape the perceived legitimacy of other branches' actions. www.yalejreg.com/nc/congresss-formal-and-functional-power…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss why the Trump administration's long-planned efforts at election interference fizzled.
www.execfunctions.org/p/an-extraordinary-vindication-of-the -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer: "What accounts for the normalcy of this Election Day, and the mail and early voting that preceded it? ... I point to a few key factors that contributed to a different outcome—a free and fair election conducted under law—than many had feared." open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/thoughts-on-wh…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My piece on "General Law Revivalism and the Problem of 1938," written with my great three-decade co-author, @curtisabradley, is out.
yalelawjournal.org/pdf/136-1-general-law-revivalism-1.pdf -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ben Buchanan
@BuchananBen
I led AI policy in the Biden administration, and my colleague @tantumscollins was Director for Technology on the National Security Council. Our book on AI and national security -- THE BITTER STRUGGLE -- comes out in 11 days. @tylercowen said it “will become the standard source” on the history of the China chip bans and Biden-era AI policy. @crmiller1 said it is “essential reading for understanding how AI will impact geopolitics and how the great powers are shaping AI.”
We wrote this book because the decisions shaping AI -- and the future for all of us -- are too important to only be debated behind closed doors. If you're planning on reading it, pre-ordering is one of the best ways to help us bring this conversation to a broader audience.
www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/821154/the-bitter-strugg… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The “criminal information” the Department of Justice filed on Oct. 5 against former FBI Director James Comey is legally flawed. The problem is not just that two sets of prosecutors in the Trump 1.0 Justice Department investigated this matter and declined to bring charges. The more immediate problem is that the Trump 2.0 Justice Department waited too long to bring the case.
www.execfunctions.org/p/dojs-third-effort-to-get-comey-is -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I talk to Caleb Nelson about his criticisms of Slaughter in his article the “Dictatorial Presidency.” "So my criticism is partly about timing. Even if you think there’s a stronger case for unitary executive theory than I do, this is an extraordinarily dangerous time, I think, for the Supreme Court to upend precedent and to move in that direction. And my criticism is also about history. Chief Justice Roberts keeps repeating claims about the First Congress that I’m pretty sure aren’t true and that scholars have, I think, debunked."
www.execfunctions.org/p/1b6b1348-56c4-4d07-b930-4db7ee13e866 -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the politics of tit-for-tat. "Is there any claim that the legal strategies against Trump vindicated the rule of law or left the Justice Department or the rule of law in a better place? I don't see the argument."
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-politics-of-tit-for-tat?publi… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
Some people think that Learned Hand had the perfect name for a judge. But "Learned" was the judge's middle name, not his first name.
Hand's real first name was better suited for a lawyer: Billings. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
In the (faculty) mail, Diego Zambrano's new book, "How Americans Enforce the Law."
www.amazon.com/dp/1503648397 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
highly recommended
Dan Epps
@danepps
Law folks: If you’re not using Claude Code or ChatGPT’s Codex, you have no idea what you’re missing. So I’m distributing my research tools that provide a huge boost to legal scholarship. Research assistance, cite-checking, proofreading, and more (thread):
danepps.github.io/legal-research-skills/ -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My thoughts on Senator Slotkin’s U of C remarks and Republicans’ hypocritical reactions. "Trump won the election and could have stopped the cycle. But that was contrary to his vengeful nature and, in any event, would have been seen by his side as unilateral disarmament. And so he engaged in astonishingly harsh and broad retaliation for what the Biden administration did, in order to deter rivals on many dimensions. The Democrats are now contemplating whether and how to respond when they gain power. The incentive for brutal retaliation will be overwhelming, especially since it will be argued, just as Vance argued, that the other side has already done it, will do it again if possible, and thus must be maximally deterred.
And so on.
It’s a bleak future."
www.execfunctions.org/p/senator-slotkins-imprudent-remarks -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Barack Obama
@BarackObama
It is a basic principle of American democracy that the government can’t selectively target individuals simply because of their political beliefs or what they say. But that’s exactly what the Trump Administration is doing to Congresswoman Ilhan Omar of Minnesota.
To understand why this is so appalling, it’s important to know the facts. Congresswoman Omar came to this country with her father when she was 12 years old. Five years later, her father became a naturalized citizen. If Ilhan had been 18 at the time, she would have had to apply for citizenship separately. But because she was 17, she became a naturalized citizen automatically.
Congresswoman Omar went on to graduate from college, work as a community organizer, become the first Somali-American legislator elected to public office in the U.S., and win a seat in Congress. There, she has been one of the Trump Administration’s fiercest critics, which has led the president to repeatedly single her out as someone who he believes does not belong in this country.
Now the Administration is actively trying to deport Congresswoman Omar, seemingly based solely on the unsubstantiated theory that she was actually 18 when her father was naturalized, and therefore is not a citizen. Federal agents have raided her home, confiscated personal records, and seized her phone — all to try and uncover a nonexistent smoking gun from 20 years ago that will somehow make their case.
Think about that. The full weight of the federal government is being brought down on a law-abiding elected official because she has dared to criticize the president. And it’s not the first time this has happened. Under President Trump, the Justice Department has repeatedly gone after those he considers his political enemies — from the Attorney General of New York, to the former head of the FBI, to members of the Federal Reserve.
In those cases, the prosecutions either stalled or were dismissed for having no basis in law, and the same is likely to happen in this case. But not before Congresswoman Omar’s life has been turned upside down, her legal bills have piled up, and she’s been forced to spend time fighting unsubstantiated charges instead of serving the people of Minnesota.
The fact that any president, or any administration, is willing to engage in such transparent efforts to intimidate someone should outrage all Americans, regardless of how they feel about Congresswoman Omar’s political views. Because if this becomes the new normal, there’s no reason to believe it will stop with her — or that future presidents, in either party, won’t do the same. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Francis Fukuyama explaining to Bob Bauer that lawyers care about procedure and voters care about outcomes. Part of a broader interesting conversation. www.execfunctions.org/p/francis-fukuyama-reflects-on-his?…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Super interesting opinions re vote safety next month. Most remarkable is bipartisan consensus against negative extremes (eg no expert "very concerned" about vote integrity and all experts "moderately" or "very" confident Sup Ct will be "fair/impartial")
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/10/13/opinion/midterm-el… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion with Catherine Grace Katz about her great new book on the Hindenburg disaster.
www.execfunctions.org/p/scrambling-to-regulate-a-sensitive -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Jason Willick
@jawillick
Samuel Alito’s new book sounds grave warnings about executive branch policy making displacing Congress. The concern is nowhere evident in his rulings during the second Trump administration.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
UVA Law School
@UVALaw
Prof. John Duffy has been appointed general counsel and acting solicitor of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. @uspto www.law.virginia.edu/news/202610/duffy-named-general-coun…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Melanie Marlowe
@profmarlowe
You got a few shoutouts as @RealChrisPreble, @tomkarako, and I discussed the OEF IG report last week!
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/unpacking-the-ig-report-on-… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
"Alito’s nominal adherence to originalism even as he struggles to revamp it is but one indication that the doctrine is becoming a zombie creed that functions more as a shibboleth than as an actual guide to conservative constitutional decision making."
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
This is from my view of Justice Alito's new collection of essays, for @TheAtlantic.
www.theatlantic.com/magazine/2026/11/samuel-alito-origina… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on two important, relatively new inspector general reports. IGs are diminished but not yet dead in the post-Slaughter post Trump v. U.S. unitary executive.
www.execfunctions.org/p/inspectors-general-live?r=4xo6yq -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer interviews Tammy Patrick, Chief Executive Officer for Programs at the Election Center and former Federal Compliance Officer for the Maricopa County Elections Department, about how election officials are preparing for the midterm elections. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/election-admin…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@Vermeullarmine likes Justice Alito'' originalism.
thenewdigest.substack.com/p/common-sense-originalism?r=4x… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Julia D Mahoney
@JuliaMahoneyUVA
Planes, beer, and forfeiture: my @SCOTUSblog column on Jouppi v. Alaska www.scotusblog.com/2026/09/planes-beer-and-forfeiture/
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the president's political advertising on the taxpayer's dime. www.execfunctions.org/p/advertising-the-president-on-the
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The amazing Dr. Öberg joins an impressive list. www.pas.va/en/about/pius-xi-medal.html
Sachin Jose
@Sachinettiyil
Dr. Karin Öberg, a Harvard University professor of astronomy and a convert to Catholicism, received the Pius XI Medal from Pope Leo XIV. The medal recognizes her contributions to scientific research.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@WilliamBaude: "I opened up Claude Code yesterday morning, tuned to Fable 5.1, Max effort, and asked it to expand the previous day’s blog post into a law review article with no further input from me." open.substack.com/pub/dividedargument/p/claude-generated-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
San Francisco on Monday sued Trump Media & Technology Group Corp., alleging that its 100k/mo early access feed to Truth Social posts by POTUS violates insider trading laws. I spoke with former SEC GC John Coates about this topic. www.execfunctions.org/p/is-trump-medias-early-access-feed
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Must watch: @whignewtons interviews @RickPildes on NYT "Interesting times" on what to fear in midterm elections. Great discussion.
www.nytimes.com/2026/09/24/opinion/interesting-times-sara… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
"If it were a different government official doing this, one the current administration didn’t like, they’d have ample legal room to go after them." Former SEC GC John Coates and I discuss the legality of Trump Media’s early-access feed.
www.execfunctions.org/p/is-trump-medias-early-access-feed -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Thrilled with this news.
hls.harvard.edu/today/sherif-girgis-joins-the-harvard-law… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Galleys have arrived!
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
New paper (in draft): The Moral Obligations of Government Lawyers. @jacklgoldsmith @lsolum #kindofasermon #sorrynotsorry
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7499138 -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Lessig 🇺🇦
@lessig
I've launched a new podcast, Left Right: leftrightpodcast.substack.com?r=7dgxu
Now a new conversation with a high school friend about Trump. Hopefully, a platform for similar conversations between others. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Rachel Bayefsky
@RachelBayefsky
Here's my piece on Tradition & Federal Judicial Power: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7479060 - examining/critiquing the Supreme Court's turn to tradition in several contexts involving federal judicial power, incl. standing, equitable remedies, non-Article III courts, and more! Comments welcome
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
Delighted to be able to post the final version of my article, "The Moving Property Problem in Fourth Amendment Law," just published in the @VirginiaLawRev.
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6117407 -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Dan Epps
@danepps
NEW PAPER: Now up on @SSRN, my and @danielledonfro's "Constitutional Rights and General Private Law," forthcoming in @HarvLRev. Check it out!
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7473400 -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
Every time I reread the Kalven Report, I'm struck again by what a great document it is.
E.g., I've always loved "a good university, like Socrates, will be upsetting," "it is not itself the critics," and "It is not a club." (And much more in these two paragraphs.) But . . . -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Happy 25th Birthday (sort of), 2001 AUMF! Sorry you are no longer (very) relevant. www.execfunctions.org/p/the-25th-anniversary-of-the-2001?…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Marty Lederman with a good analysis of the postal case at the Supreme Court, with an update on Judge Nichols' recent ruling. www.justsecurity.org/156963/usps-mail-ballots-solicitor-g…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
New in Confirmation Tales:
Did John Marshall Continue as Secretary of State? No, as a curious scheme perpetrated by Thomas Jefferson helps show -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Elias Neibart
@EliasNeibart
Very excited to announce that next month I'll be presenting a new working-paper--The Law of Legislative Power--at the @NDLaw Legal History Colloquium in Chicago!
Here's the abstract: -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
On Chief Justice Roberts' claim that the meaning of the Constitution is not "trapped in amber."
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7416978 -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
Today from me @thenewdigest: some Gaullist administrative law. Do Presidential directives give agencies sufficient reason for action under the Administrative Procedure Act? Contrary to the academic consensus, I argue that the answer is yes.
Enjoy!
thenewdigest.substack.com/p/pro-ratione-voluntas-praesidi… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The surveillance state will grow, probably a lot, to meet AI-enhanced bio (and probably other) threats. www.execfunctions.org/p/elizabeth-sherwood-randall-on-bio…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
Here’s my most recent article, “Extradition in the Early Republic: International Law and Constitutional Authority,” hot off the presses from the Chicago Law Review. (Link provided in comment below.) In the last couple of years, I’ve been writing about how international law ideas of sovereignty have interacted with U.S. constitutional law, and I’m now completing a book on that topic. My latest article in this vein focuses on the early U.S. practice of extraditing criminal suspects. In recounting the history, I show how governmental actors resolved core issues of federalism, presidential power, and sovereignty-based legislative authority, in part by referencing international law understandings of nationhood. Importantly, though, I also document how these actors played a significant role in constructing those same understandings. This relational dynamic between the construction of international law and the construction of U.S. constitutional law will be a key theme of the book. @CambridgeUP , @TheGNapp , @_John_Mikhail , @adambcox , @MaggieBlackhawk
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My conversation with Elizabeth Sherwood-Randall on Bioweapons in the Age of AI. www.execfunctions.org/p/elizabeth-sherwood-randall-on-bio…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Soren Dayton
@sorendayton
This is a very important question from @jacklgoldsmith.
The combination of fears about AI and the ability to process data means that nearly all of the biosecurity proposals imagine very substantial increases in state surveillance of individuals. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
With the new academic year beginning, it's time to re-post my favorite passage about law professors: In 1958, the great Judge Learned Hand, then in his 80s, gives a set of lectures at Harvard Law School and reflects on his professors there in the 1890s. "Go ye and do likewise."
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Molly Brady
@mollyxbrady
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My latest: The Unitary Executive and Comey’s Vindictive Prosecution Claim
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-unitary-executive-and-comeys -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
The Supreme Court’s realignment roundup: October Term 2025 | SCOTUSblog www.scotusblog.com/2026/08/the-supreme-courts-realignment…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Everyone is overthinking the Trump "Greats." He stole the ratings and pics from Arthur Schlesinger Sr.'s famous 1948 Life article, and adjusted for later presidents. No philosophy of government implied by the "greats."
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Counterpoint on how to think about presidential "greats," including the Schlesingers' lists, for contemporary issues:
www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Presidential-Great… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss litigation over the Trump administration’s executive order on the Postal Service and election integrity, and the recent final rule that the Postal Service issued to implement the order.
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-postal-service-and-the-2026-e… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I write on OLC's strange opinion extending the presidential communications privilege to private advisors. "Why did the White House ask, and why did OLC publish? We are not sure."
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/olcs-strange-o… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Great piece.
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
New in Confirmation Tales: The Kidney Stones that Made John Marshall Chief Justice
It’s easy in hindsight to think that some individuals were destined to become Supreme Court justices. But there is no such thing as an inevitable justice. Every justice’s path to the Supreme Court involves happenstance.
John Marshall’s tenure as Chief Justice was so foundational to the role of the Supreme Court in the American system of government that it’s easy to overlook the remarkable serendipities that made it possible.
Link to post in reply. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Zachary S. Price
@ZacharySPrice
I have a new Notice & Comment post about apparent efforts by the Trump administration to entrench its preferred policies and insulate them against reversal in a future Democratic administration. www.yalejreg.com/nc/attempted-administrative-entrenchment/
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ben Buchanan
@BuchananBen
I was the first White House Special Advisor for AI. My friend Tantum Collins was Director for Technology and National Security, joining government after five years at Google DeepMind. Our jobs were to help make AI safe and ensure that democracies led the way in inventing and using it well. Today, I’m a professor at Johns Hopkins and an advisor to Anthropic and others, and Tantum is the CEO of Inherent.
Long before we served in government, we thought that humanity was on track to create AI systems that outperform humans at virtually every cognitive task. This was once a fringe hypothesis. It now seems inevitable.
THE BITTER STRUGGLE is our new book about what’s happened, what’s coming, and what’s at stake. From nanometer-scale chips to gigawatt data centers, we will show you why AI is so powerful, and why its progress will accelerate from here in ways that feel like science fiction. We will take you into the Oval Office with President Biden, the Situation Room with the Cabinet, and the Roosevelt Room with leading CEOs — and we will examine what has happened under President Trump. The decisions made in these rooms, and in Silicon Valley, will determine which nations gain a decisive lead in AI. Whoever wields that technology will gain a power unlike any in history. The next few years may decide the next few decades.
But, most of all, together we will confront AI’s hardest questions. What is the proper relationship between the companies inventing the technology, the government, and the public? How can we make sure AI is safe and trustworthy? How do democracies win without losing our values?
And how can humanity figure all of this out when we are so quickly running out of time?
That question is why we wrote this book — and why we believe the answers are too important to only be debated in closed rooms, including the ones we once sat in. We are so excited to finally share our work with you.
The book is available for pre-order now and out November 10th from Crown. www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/821154/the-bitter-strugg… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Christian Burset
@cburset
New draft paper with Sam Bray (@UChicagoLaw): "Why General Law?" Abstract here; link below.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Sadie Blanchard
@prof_blanchard
My article, "Contracting for Equity," defending the historical and current role of equity in contract law is now on SSRN (in draft, comments welcome) and will be coming out in the Duke Law Journal. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7211099
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
Thanks to @WilliamBaude for flagging my new draft article, which you can read here:
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7238178 -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
A court trapped in amber | SCOTUSblog www.scotusblog.com/2026/08/a-court-trapped-in-amber/
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
The written version of Beyond Tit-for-Tat (forthcoming in the Indiana Law Journal) is now up:
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Danielle D'Onfro
@danielledonfro
Come for the con law. Stay for the private law theory.
Dan Epps
@danepps
Thrilled that my and @danielledonfro's new paper, "Constitutional Rights and General Private Law," will be in @HarvLRev next year. It's a sequel to our 2023 @YaleLJournal piece, "The Fourth Amendment and General Law." We need to revise, so no @SSRN yet, but here's the abstract:
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
It is because of existential dread? www.nytimes.com/2026/07/30/opinion/american-gerontocracy-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Important, illuminating paper on "The First Century of the Interim Docket," by R. Ashton Macfarlane, coming out in 94 U. Chi. L. Rev. __ (2027) papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=7116499
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Former DHS Secretary and DOD General Counsel Jeh Johnson and I discuss presidential war powers and the feckless Congress.
www.execfunctions.org/p/jeh-johnson-on-presidential-war-p… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
USG withdraws subpoenas against NYT after being "criticized by a federal judge for sloppy legal work." apnews.com/article/usmediatimesair-force-one-42429e4d4da8…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Kahn was right and I was wrong -- but my general point that the USG has the upper hand on the law, with competent lawyering, remains.
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-trump-administrations-portentous -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
It’s out today! Here’s the latest edition of my monograph on international law in the U.S. legal system. As you might guess, there were a lot of new developments to cover since the 2021 edition. www.amazon.com/International-Law-US-Legal-System/dp/01978…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Elena Chachko
@ElenaChachko
Just got around to posting my forthcoming paper, "The Executive Order". It considers what executive orders can and cannot do and how their internal structure affects agency implementation. Plus empirical insights based on a study of all EOs from Reagan to early Trump II.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Something for Congress to consider as it appropriates for the Iran war -- appropriation for war can be and often is authorization for war, despite the War Powers Resolution.
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-stakes-in-the-coming-fight-over -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
On "A Court of Two Crises" - by Richard M Re blog.dividedargument.com/p/on-a-court-of-two-crises
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the Trump administration's subpoenas of NYT reporters, which "highlight the fragility of judicially enforceable legal safeguards for journalists, who are protected from government subpoenas and prosecutions more by norms than by law."
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
piece here: www.execfunctions.org/p/the-trump-administrations-portentous
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
justin curl
@curl_justin
Update: I’ve joined @AnthropicAI’s new AI & Rule of Law team.
We’re tackling questions like:
1. How do we ensure AI agents follow the law?
2. How do we limit AI’s potential to concentrate power (e.g. AI-enabled coups or mass surveillance)?
3. How can AI empower citizens and strengthen democracy?
I’ve said before that these are the most important questions of our time. Delighted to be working on them with @MattBotvinick, @JackClarkSF, and the amazing people at Anthropic.
More soon — there’s no time to waste.
justin curl
@curl_justin
So glad there’s a team at Anthropic doing this. Right now, few questions are as important as how we redesign our institutions and legal systems in light of AI
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
By @WilliamBaude and me
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
77-page Summer Supp. for Bradley, Deeks, Goldsmith, Foreign Relations Law: Cases and Materials. Includes edited tariff case + analysis, analysis of Cisco and Fuld, lots of new war-related stuff, and update and analysis of Alien Enemies Act litigation.
drive.google.com/file/d/1UbNWJn-TwDbIVCvsaiqylt6n880Pdz0Y… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss how the Trump administration is using law enforcement and executive power more generally to influence the congressional elections--aims, tactics, failures to date, and more.
www.execfunctions.org/p/trump-and-the-midterms?publicatio… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
Is Chief Justice Roberts moderating from the front? | SCOTUSblog www.scotusblog.com/2026/07/is-chief-justice-roberts-moder…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Indeed, Trump v. US has not been cited in a majority decision in the two years since it was decided -- not in a merits opinion, not in an interim order. It is decisio non grata. www.execfunctions.org/p/the-fate-to-date-of-trump-v-united
Jason Willick
@jawillick
Notable that neither majority nor dissent in Slaughter ever mentions Trump v. U.S., the immunity case, despite its extensive discussion of removal power.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Thanks, interesting
anonmadison
@anonmadiso2420
Pragmatic choice to wait in light of expected legislative change to the Library of Congress appointment process
rollcall.com/2026/06/08/house-librarian-of-congress-appoi… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
anonmadison
@anonmadiso2420
Pragmatic choice to wait in light of expected legislative change to the Library of Congress appointment process
rollcall.com/2026/06/08/house-librarian-of-congress-appoi… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The Court’s denial of a stay on Tuesday in Blanche v. Perlmutter is interesting.
This was the case where the district court had enjoined the president’s removal of the Register of Copyrights, Shura Perlmutter. The Solicitor General sought a stay in October. He argued that the Register “is an inferior officer appointed by the Librarian of Congress, who is, despite his title, a principal executive officer—“a ‘Head of Department’ within the Executive Branch” appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate” and that the Register was removable because she “wields executive power by exercising “significant regulatory authority over copyrights,” – impacting a wide array of crucial intellectual-property issues.”
The Court deferred ruling on the application “pending Trump v. Slaughter, No. 25-332, and Trump v. Cook, No. 25A312.”
At oral argument in Slaughter, the Chief Justice said:
“I think there are a lot of agencies in the federal government where it's hard to parse whether it's an executive function they're engaged in or a legislative function. We obviously have the Perlmutter case holding, where you do -- deal with the Library of Congress, which half of it's a library, half of it's things like the copyright. What are we supposed to do with that if you're correct?”
SG Sauer in response did not take the firm position he took in the application. Instead, he said:
“Well, Mr. Chief Justice, in Free Enterprise Fund, this Court I think very aptly stated that the vast and varied nature of the federal government is a reason not to make general pronouncements on issues that haven't been briefed and argued. There are certainly -- there are certainly situations where there are tough line-drawing problems. You raised the Perlmutter case as one that may raise arguments of that nature.”
The Chief said he was “not sure” the SG answered the question. He then asked about what the Court is supposed to do when an agency exercises some executive functions and some-non-executive functions:
“[I]s this a severance issue? Do we -- so the agency is okay so long as, you know, half of it -- half of it survives in one branch and half in the other, and if so, who gets to decide that?”
Sauer said in part:
“if there are agencies that kind of straddle the line between legislative and executive, that might present harder severability kinds of issues.”
The Chief Justice in his opinion in Slaughter did not address the status of the Register of Copyrights. He did say: “Because the FTC’s activities fall well within the heartland of executive power, we have no occasion today to define the bounds of what such power entails.” And he in footnote 3 repeated earlier formulations about severability in the removal context without addressing the problem of “agencies that kind of straddle the line between legislative and executive.” The Court also ruled that the Federal Reserve’s for-cause provision and broader independence was lawful in lights of its unique history even though (as the Court implicitly but not expressly acknowledged) it, like the Register of Copyright, exercised executive powers in addition to non-executive powers.
In this light, what does it mean that the Court—without noted dissent—declined to stay the injunction that kept Perlmutter in office? The Court stated that the denial “is not a ruling on the merits of the legal issues presented in the litigation.” But of course a stay denial is never a ruling on the merits. Did the Court mean that its decision did not reflect even a tentative assessment of likelihood of success? Despite the disclaimer, does the stay denial possibly indicate that there are not five justices who support the maximalist view of the unitary executive, as some have read Slaughter? Was the order based on a relative assessment of irreparable harm?
There is, of course, no way to know for sure, but Perlmutter is likely to stay in office for a while, which is a defeat for the President.
Thoughts welcome. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Jeannie Suk Gersen
@JeannieSGersen
What is law and where does it come from? The semiquincentennial of our country is the perfect time for liberals to reclaim natural law and not cede it to their antagonists. @NewYorker www.newyorker.com/news/the-lede/why-have-liberals-abandon…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
Today from me @thenewdigest: Trump v. Cook left a big mess as to judicial review of presidential action, quite apart from the question of the Fed.
thenewdigest.substack.com/p/cooking-up-a-mess -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
justin curl
@curl_justin
THE thing to read about the legal basis for fable restrictions
That said, I’m more convinced than Alex by the argument that model access = release because of distillation
It seems much easier to recreate frontier model model capabilities from API access than it is to reverse engineer source code from object code -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Watch Jack's full discussion with Sai Prakash here: www.execfunctions.org/p/sai-prakash-on-slaughter-and-cook
Jason Willick
@jawillick
“Remarkably thin to the point of nonexistent”—@jacklgoldsmith on SCOTUS analysis distinguishing Fed from other agencies. Yikes. Via @Exec_Functions podcast.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I'm guessing that many people won't like this one: "The Powerful, Resilient, Independent Supreme Court. The vindication of its authority is remarkable."
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-powerful-resilient-independent -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The Court's weak argument for the Fed exception.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Sai Prakash's view on the choice progressives face after Slaughter.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion with UVA's Sai Prakash on Slaughter and Cook -- mainly on Slaughter's implications for the president’s control over inferior officers, civil servants, and non-Article III courts, and the validity of the Fed carve-out.
www.execfunctions.org/p/sai-prakash-on-slaughter-and-cook -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Listen to me cheerfully make the case for AI pessimism on @jacklgoldsmith's Executive Functions substack podcast. It's kind of uplifting, in a way...
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Peter Berkowitz
@BerkowitzPeter
I am pleased to announce that my new book, Reclaiming Liberal Education in America, is available for preorder at Amazon:
www.amazon.com/Reclaiming-Liberal-Education-America-Berko… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Terrific (and admirably concise) analysis by Alex Zhao about why access to the Anthropic models is probably not a technology release under relevant export control laws.
harvardlawreview.org/blog/2026/06/is-access-to-fable-an-e… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
Examples of this Court closing doors to litigation left open (if narrowly) during the Kennedy era: Rucho (partisan gerrymandering), Vannoy (retroactive crim pro rights), and now Cisco Systems (alien tort suits).
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My conversation with @robertwrighter about his new book, "The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning" --
0:11 AI through an evolutionary lens
13:54 The promises and perils of AI
17:20 Global instability and the U.S.-China race to superintelligence
22:30 Preserving cognitive sovereignty
32:30 Global governance as a solution
42:25 Tribalism, attribution error, and the challenge of cooperation
58:29 What is the “God Test”?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed this conversation with @jacklgoldsmith on his Executive Functions podcast. I'm flattered by how closely he must have read the book to ask such good questions.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My chat w/ Robert Wright about his fascinating new book (out next week),"The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning." Topics: AI through evolutionary lens, AI safety, US-China cooperation, personal transformation.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-god-test?r… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The Pentagon is reportedly soon going to make an Iran war appropriations request. Last month I argued that "such funding could count as an authorization for the conflict" and "could also be a vehicle to constrain the administration’s conduct of the war." www.execfunctions.org/p/the-stakes-in-the-coming-fight-over
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My chat w/ Robert Wright about his fascinating new book (out next week),"The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning." Topics: AI through evolutionary lens, AI safety, US-China cooperation, personal transformation.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-god-test?r… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Wise words by UT Law Dean @BobbyChesney on AI and legal education.
drive.google.com/file/d/1gLqI6o5D-K4pMktpiDuoiN6UX4AGy1iZ… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@juliettekayyem has a great new substack, "Early Warning," about "helping people understand big, uncertain things."
earlywarningwithjuliette.substack.com -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Why (I think) domestic law prevents Trump from waiving Iran sanctions as contemplated by the new MOU; what the USG counterarguments will be; and why the legal bar is likely unenforceable.
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-president-is-legally-barred-from -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
"The Iran adventure is the latest instance of the 'one person decides' principle of U.S. foreign policy that Trump has taken to new extremes, and that undeservedly has received less critical attention than Trump’s domestic unilateralism."
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-iran-deal-in-the-context-of-the -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss what's at stake in the Blanche confirmation: whether the Senate will endorse, and thus take responsibility for, Trump’s DOJ weaponization campaign.
executivefunctions.substack.com/p/attorney-general-todd-b… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Zachary S. Price
@ZacharySPrice
I was honored to give a talk in April at the Stanford Constitutional Law Center on "Congress's Power of the Purse and the Trump Administration." A recording is now up on YouTube: www.youtube.com/watch?v=enV0W5a-pyA
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Mark Jia
@MarkZJia
Sharing here a forthcoming paper of mine entitled, "Law Power." It proposes a theory of national legal power similar to existing theories of military and economic power. Link here and abstract below. Comments highly welcome. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6864920
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Thomas Berry
@Thomas_A_Berry
The appointment of an acting director of national intelligence with no national intelligence experience highlights two flaws in the Vacancies Act:
First, anyone serving in a Senate-confirmed position across the entire federal government is statutorily eligible to serve as an acting officer in any office. That pool of eligibility is too broad; Congress should narrow it to only Senate-confirmed officials within the same department or agency, who are much more likely to have the relevant experience.
Second, many positions have statutory qualification requirements based on experience or education, but these requirements most likely don't apply to actings. The National Security Act requires that a Senate-confirmed DNI must have national security experience, yet a non-Senate confirmed acting DNI can have none. The Vacancies Act should be clarified so that statutory qualifications for an office also apply to acting officers.
Anthony Adragna
@AnthonyAdragna
Trump says Bill Pulte will serve as acting DNI.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer talks to Avril Haines, President Biden's Director of National Intelligence, about the Department that President Trump designated Bill Pulte to lead as Acting Director. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/what-exactly-i…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Nicholas Bednar
@NicholasBednar
Happy to see my final piece on the Presidential Control of the Civil Service published with Minn. L. Rev.
scholarship.law.umn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1204&… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
One of the most famous debates in the field of Federal Courts concerns congressional power to strip the federal courts of jurisdiction—a debate between the “traditional view” and the “essential functions thesis.” In this article, "Court-Stripping, Court-Packing, and Court-Defying: Revisiting the Supreme Court's Official Functions," which just came out in the Texas Law Review, Neil Siegel and I revisit that debate. (A link to the article is provided in the comment below.) We argue that some of the structural arguments against jurisdiction-stripping are relevant to debates over Court-packing, and that the essential functions literature has defined the core functions of the Supreme Court too narrowly. We also use the debate as a lens for examining the nature of structural constitutional argumentation, a type of interpretive reasoning that has been insufficiently explored in both the courts and the academy. @NeilScottSiegel
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
"Thus far, my prediction that the executive branch would aggressively use the non-immunity aspects of Trump v. U.S. to its advantage against the other branches has not been borne out in public legal documents."
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-fate-to-date-of-trump-v-united -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Sarah Isgur
@whignewtons
I’m moving back to Texas, y’all 🤠
www.chevron.com/newsroom/2026/q2/chevron-names-new-genera… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
Still feels new
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
Prosecuting Contempt by Samuel L. Bray, Aditya Bamzai papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6816160
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the audacious combo of government abuse and self-enrichment reflected in the DOJ/IRS "settlement" with Trump and others that creates an "Anti-Weaponization Fund" and immunity from IRS scrutiny.
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-anti-weaponization-fund-and-tax -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Elena Chachko
@ElenaChachko
New for @YaleJREG on Learning
Resources v. Trump (the tariffs case). I analyze the decision in the broader context of judicial review of executive use of statutory emergency powers, drawing on a recent paper. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Robert P. George
@McCormickProf
A wonderful profile of the great Jennie Lichter in the Harvard Law Bulletin. Jennie, a Harvard Law graduate, is president of March for Life. Kudos to the editors of the Bulletin for publishing the profile. They'll take a lot of heat for it ... but it was exactly the right thing to do, and is yet more evidence that Harvard Law School is in the lead in recognizing achievement and distinction (in admissions, faculty hiring, and other ways) in an ideologically non-partisan manner.
hls.harvard.edu/today/leading-the-march/ -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the stakes in the upcoming fight in Congress over appropriations for the Iran War.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-stakes-in-… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Garrett West
@e_garrett_west
New paper--A Functional Theory of State Action. Abstract here and link below.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Sebastian Mallaby
@scmallaby
Ahead of the Trump-Xi summit, I spoke with @eliotxchen about chip-export controls, AI safety, and learning the lessons of the cold war.
www.thewirechina.com/2026/05/10/sebastian-mallaby-on-why-… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Peter Berkowitz
@BerkowitzPeter
"Harvey C. Mansfield’s Honorable Quest To Educate Harvard," RealClearPolitics, May 10, 2026
In a 1975 essay exploring Leo Strauss’ interpretation of Machiavelli, Harvey C. Mansfield asserts that “no paragraph in The Prince and the Discourses has been understood until you have found something funny in it.” Consequently, advises Mansfield, “If you are not in more or less constant amusement when reading Machiavelli’s books, you should consider yourself bewildered.” Mansfield’s amusing observations about the philosophical importance of amusement to Machiavelli’s exploration of serious matters applies to Mansfield’s many writings, certainly his amusingly titled new book, “Where Harvard Went Wrong: Fifty Years of Commentary that Fell on Deaf Ears.” . . .
www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2026/05/10/harvey_c_ma… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Charlie Savage
@charlie_savage
In the real world, DOJ’s Office of Legal Counsel said the WPR 60 day clock provision (the part at issue) *is* constitutional both times it is known to have analyzed it - 1980 & 1993. No president has ever said it applied to a situation but defied it on a constitutional theory.
Department of State
@StateDept
SECRETARY RUBIO: The War Powers Act is 100% unconstitutional. This has been the position of every single presidential administration since this law passed. It’s an infringement on the president’s constitutional powers.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
President Trump is the most inconstant Commander in Chief in American history. Distant runners up: Madison, LBJ, early Lincoln.
truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/116524418935002706 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on Supreme Court reform and prez power.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/how-the-wrong-… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Wonderful remembrances of a wonderful man, Stewart Baker.
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/remembering-lawfare-contribu… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the War Powers Resolution debate. Trump's interpretation is the latest in a long line of opportunistic interpretations of the statute. Yet the WPR is not, yet, irrelevant.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/trumps-interpr… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Sebastian Mallaby
@scmallaby
Also re-upping @ChrisRMcGuire’s excellent arguments on @CFR_org’s The Spillover podcast
www.cfr.org/podcasts/spillover/u-s-china-ai-race-escalate… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Sebastian Mallaby
@scmallaby
As @jacklgoldsmith says on the Substack, a key issue in this debate is how much value one sees in a six month AI lead over China.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Sebastian Mallaby
@scmallaby
On the larger questions around chip export controls and the fruitfulness of an alternative “NPT-like” approach to China, I debated this a couple of days ago with the brilliant @jacklgoldsmith on his Substack.
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-many-challenges-of-ai-safety -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
UChicago Law School
@UChicagoLaw
A well-deserved standing ovation for Geoffrey R. Stone following his speech and portrait unveiling at Reunion Weekend.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion with Sebastian Mallaby about his new book, "The Infinity Machine," and the many challenges of AI governance. Great, compelling book, highly recommended.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-many-chall… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Nice salute to IG power and usefulness by WH Deputy Press Sec after DOJ drops criminal case against Powell. Despite unitary theory, the quasi-independent watchdogs in fact serve useful/important roles. (Obviously much more going on here; but statement is remarkable nonetheless)
Kush Desai
@KushDesai47
American taxpayers deserve answers about the Federal Reserve’s fiscal mismanagement, and the Office of the Inspector General’s more powerful authorities best position it to get to the bottom of the matter.
The White House remains as confident as before that the Senate will swiftly confirm Kevin Warsh as the next Federal Reserve Chairman to finally restore competence and confidence in Fed decision-making. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Inspectors general live despite the Trump purges! The Labor Secretary this week was felled by a Trump-appointed IG investigation. DHS head Noem was earlier taken down in part by a Trump-appointed IG investigation. A career DOJ deputy IG, who is leading the office with a Trump nominee before the Senate, yesterday announced an “audit” of DOJ’s compliance with the Epstein Files Transparency Act. Will that audit be robust and critical and will DOJ leadership cooperate? We will see. Finally, DOJ dropped its criminal investigation of Fed head Powell and nodded to the IG investigation of the building cost overrun matter, which has been underway for a while and which might have been on hold due to the criminal investigation. So the Fed IG will now have a big say and maybe the last word on that issue. For my analysis of IGs in Trump 2.0 a month ago—which painted a mixed picture that still basically prevails—see www.execfunctions.org/p/inspectors-general-in-trump-20.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
I'm looking forward to the publication this summer of the latest edition of my monograph on International Law in the US Legal System. Much has happened since the last edition!
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My critical take on the NYT reporting on the 'Shadow Papers'
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-nyt-and-the-shadow-papers -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
For background on the astonishing UK turnaround on Diego Garcia, see my chat with Richard Ekins. www.execfunctions.org/p/richard-ekins-on-diego-garcia-and
This is a major secondary impact of the Iran war.
www.politico.eu/article/uk-diego-garcia-handover-chagos-i… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Marty Lederman and I discuss the Presidential Records Act, why the Trump administration wants to avoid it, the OLC opinion that ruled it unconstitutional, and whether Congress could enact a Supreme Court Records Act.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/who-owns-presi… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
Yay! Launch piece. Please read and share-and preorder the book-if it sounds interesting harpers.org/archive/2026/05/the-old-guard-samuel-moyn-ger…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on the 25th Amendment Under Vice Presidential Control: open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-25th-amend…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Quietly devastating analysis by Biden OLC head of Trump OLC head's opinion on the Presidential Records Act. www.justsecurity.org/136242/presidential-records-act-cons…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Trump’s harsh reactions toward the Supreme Court's tariff decision were a “gift to the Chief Justice,” according to @whignewtons.
execfunctions.org/p/the-last-branch-standing
amazon.com/Last-Branch-Standing-Potentially-Occasionally/…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Kavanaugh v. Gorsuch, according to @whignewtons.
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-last-branch-standing
www.amazon.com/Last-Branch-Standing-Potentially-Occasiona…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion with @whignewtons (Sarah Isgur) about her great new book about the Supreme Court, "The Last Branch Standing." We focus on the Court's relationship with the Trump administration and its stance toward presidential power more generally.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-last-branc… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Gene Healy
@GeneHealy
To ensure he doesn't, there's no substitute for formal checks from coordinate branches of government. Relimiting the presidency will take a large-scale reform effort that seems nearly unthinkable now. Yet as @jacklgoldsmith wrote last year: "the consequential 1970s post-Vietnam, post-Watergate reforms of the presidency were unfathomable just a few years before they occurred. A reckoning after Trump 2.0—or after the retaliation it provokes—could mirror the 1970s moment."
www.nytimes.com/2025/05/05/opinion/trump-obama-biden-pres… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Interested in editing me? Executive Functions is hiring a paid full-time executive editor.
www.execfunctions.org/p/executive-functions-is-hiring-9bf -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
Thanks to Jack for arranging this discussion. He asked astute questions, as always. My view, as made clear here, is that if President Trump tries to withdraw the United States from NATO without obtaining congressional approval, he will be violating a valid federal statute.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Can Trump pull out of NATO? @curtisabradley and I discuss whether the president or Congress controls treaty withdrawal, and whether a suit challenging withdrawal could be brought in federal court.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/can-trump-pull… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Can Trump pull out of NATO? @curtisabradley and I discuss whether the president or Congress controls treaty withdrawal, and whether a suit challenging withdrawal could be brought in federal court.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/can-trump-pull… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Trump says he is "absolutely" considering withdrawing from NATO. A Sen. Rubio-sponsored law bars him from doing so w/o congressional or 2/3 Senate consent. Can Trump pull out anyway? "The law is unclear, but he probably can," I concluded, in Dec 2024
www.execfunctions.org/p/can-trump-defy-congress-and-pull -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Me and Bob Bauer: One month in, Epic Fury is the second most consequential unauthorized presidential uses of force in all of American history. It’s also a new nadir in the decline of Congress’s check on presidential war.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-second-mos… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss Congress’s failed efforts to halt the Iran conflict, a proposal for a constrained AUMF, Trump limited engagement with lawmakers, the importance of appropriations, War Powers Resolution issues, and the relevance of OLC ops.
substack.com/profile/298420802-jack-goldsmith/note/c-2343… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Me on how Trump is diminishing the Inspector General corps, with an assist from Congress, especially the Senate. “The IG story is part of a larger tale of Congress giving up its prerogatives and supporting Trump’s unitary executive despite its abuses.”
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/inspectors-gen… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A conversation with @CassSunstein on his new book, why the executive is the most dangerous branch, unitary executive theory in light of the Trump v. Slaughter oral argument, and MQD after the tariffs decision.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-most-dange… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Super-interesting: Mapping AI Policy: Where, Why, and How to Intervene, by @curl_justin and @ARozenshtein law-ai.org/mapping-ai-policy-where-why-and-how-to-intervene/
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on state bars v DOJ. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-perilous-w…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
Once again, a stay delayed is a stay denied.
Steve Vladeck
@steve_vladeck
#scotus just granted certiorari before judgment in *both* the Syria and Haiti TPS cases—and will hear argument on the merits in late April.
But it *deferred* the Trump administration's stay applications in both cases, so the DHS actions in those cases remain blocked for now: -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Aaron Nielson
@Aaron_L_Nielson
Some thoughts on the MQD.
Civitas Outlook
@CivitasOutlook
The major questions doctrine needs to be applied in an evenhanded manner. This is not a new development. Read more from Civitas Institute senior fellow @Aaron_L_Nielson. civitasoutlook.pulse.ly/vkwetew4mo
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
Beyond Tit-For-Tat, my Jerome Hall Lecture: youtu.be/fOfjsoMT6Co via @YouTube
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Adrian Vermeule on Judge VanDyke's dissent. thenewdigest.substack.com/p/judicial-rhetoric-artful-and-…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Dan Epps
@danepps
I'm excited that @DividedArgument is now a @SCOTUSblog partner podcast!
SCOTUSblog
@SCOTUSblog
SCOTUSblog is expanding its podcast lineup.
We’re proud to welcome @amaricas_const and @DividedArgument as new editorial partners, joining Advisory Opinions in a growing Supreme Court and constitutional law media ecosystem.
Listen to a special Advisory Opinions episode featuring hosts from all three podcasts here: thedispatch.com/podcast/advisoryopinions/what-are-the-lib… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Aaron Nielson
@Aaron_L_Nielson
Honest question: why isn’t this person a principal officer who must be appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate? Individual federal public defenders are not principal officers (and maybe not officers at all). But someone paid by the US to act *systemically*?
Jimmy Hoover
@JimmyHooverDC
SCOOP: Judiciary OKs new Supreme Court defender office to help represent indigent defendants at #scotus.
Its full-time director will serve as counterweight to the U.S. solicitor general in federal criminal cases. The first will be former Kagan clerk and SG atty Ashley Robertson. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Adrian Vermeule could've but didn't say "I told you so." (see thenewdigest.substack.com/p/chevron-by-any-other-name)
Vermeule, “Mixed Questions” of Law and Fact after Loper Bright
open.substack.com/pub/thenewdigest/p/mixed-questions-of-l… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Asked by NYT “if there were any limits on his global powers,” Trump said “My own morality. My own mind. It’s the only thing that can stop me.”
I’m afraid those are the only constraints on Trump’s use of nuclear weapons in Iran.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/trump-iran-nuc… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Charlie Savage
@charlie_savage
DOJ has produced, and Judge Boasberg has ordered unsealed, transcripts from three hearings in the investigations that led to Trump's federal indictments.
charliesavage.com/2026/03/hearing-transcripts-unsealed-fr… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Great timely interview — Zanny Minton Beddoes interviews Anthropic’s boss (from @TheEconomist) www.economist.com/insider/the-insider/zanny-minton-beddoe…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Josh Craddock
@joshjcraddock
I’m flattered that a tenured Yale Law School professor has taken aim at my 2017 student note in her latest article. While I think her critique ultimately misses the mark, I always appreciate thoughtful engagement with my scholarship!
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
The Equity Docket by Thomas P. Schmidt, Kellen Funk papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6342962
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on Trump/DOJ law firm flip flop open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/why-trump-firs…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
“Realigned: Standing and Substantive Due Process”
This post comments on SCOTUS’s decision this week in Mirabelli v. Bonta. blog.dividedargument.com/p/realigned-standing-and-substan… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
How might the resource allocations and career official firings in DOJ/FBI and DHS impact efforts now to protect the homeland from what USG acknowledges are heightened threats related to the Iran war? Full conversation here. www.execfunctions.org/p/homeland-security-in-a-time-of-war
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
If you are confused about why the most conservative Supreme Court in memory is pro substantive due process in Mirabelli this evening, I have some links for you:
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4937024
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5363502 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Homeland Security in a Time of War with Iran: My discussion with Biden Homeland Security Advisor Elizabeth Sherwood-Randall on how the U.S. government would normally prepare for domestic threats during periods of heightened risk. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/homeland-secur…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Unfortunate timing for the government as it simultaneously warns us of heightened cyber security threats due to the Iran war. abcnews.com/US/department-homeland-security-warns-potenti…
Justin Doubleday
@jdoubledayWFED
Scooplet today: @CISAgov is losing another key leader who oversees governmentwide cybersecurity programs. Her departure continues a steady drumbeat of resignations and leadership turmoil at the cyber defense agency.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Charlie Savage
@charlie_savage
Meanwhile:
Pentagon Watchdog Stalls Proposal to Review Targeting in Trump’s Boat Strikes
A new inspector general is said to have raised its potential political ramifications, in a test of the watchdog system in President Trump’s second term.
www.nytimes.com/2026/02/28/us/politics/trump-boat-strikes… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Sohrab Ahmari 🇺🇸
@SohrabAhmari
Somehow, JD Vance, a fierce Trumpian critic of the neoconservatives, ended up in government at the highest levels---only to help implement the foreign-policy preferences of a John Bolton or Elliott Abrams.
My UnHerd essay.
unherd.com/2026/03/how-jd-vance-lost-the-foreign-policy-war/ -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
"the rhetoric of legal constraint, and debates about the legality of presidential uses of force, are empty. And they deflect attention from Congress’s constitutional responsibility...."
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/law-is-irrelev… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Lael Weinberger
@LaelWeinberger
Delighted that my paper, "The Origins of Church Autonomy: Religious Liberty After Disestablishment," is forthcoming in the @VirginiaLawRev.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
Delighted to post the final version of my article, "Data Scanning and the Fourth Amendment," in the @BCLawReview, on how much of a search occurs with a government-ordered scan—an issue very relevant to SCOTUS's geofence warrant case to be argued in April. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5175686
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The Tariff Refund Problem: A discussion-primer on the legal hurdles to recovering money unlawfully collected pursuant to IEEPA tariffs, with Matthew Seligman. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-tariff-ref…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My assessment of the damage Trump and Hegseth are doing to the DOD legal culture. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-decaying-l…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Shalev Roisman
@Shalev_Roisman
NEW PAPER: I have posted a draft of my latest paper on "The Exclusive Powers Presidency" on SSRN. (Link at end of 🧵) Abstract below!
The Article argues that the Roberts Court has transformed separation of powers law by centering the President's "exclusive" powers. 1/6 -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Sarah Isgur
@whignewtons
Like I told yall back in December…Actually, the Supreme Court has a plan: Give the President more control over a weaker presidency. www.nytimes.com/2025/12/05/opinion/supreme-court-trump-co…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
I have always said that in any head-on confrontation with the President, the Court was on its strongest ground in the tariffs case. This is not a context in which presidential "defiance" of the Court's decision is possible. The President needs the Court's legal endorsement to be able to continue to impose the tariffs. He can't simply have customs agents extorting money from importers at the border.
The question of refunds for past tariffs is potentially more complicated, but we are not at that stage yet.
@jacklgoldsmith @CassSunstein -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My thoughts on the Tariff Decision and the President's angry reaction, which affirmed the remarkable power of the Court.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/quick-thoughts… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
For background on Trump's apparent flip-flop on the Chagos Islands and Diego-Garcia in particular, see my chat on the issue with Richard Ekins. www.execfunctions.org/p/richard-ekins-on-diego-garcia-and…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
Preorder for parents (or self)
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bauer and I discuss how the judicial system this week rebuffed the Trump administration's efforts to punish the six Democrats in Congress who said that members of the military may or must resist illegal orders.
www.execfunctions.org/p/prosecuting-members-of-congress?r… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
Bray on How Equity Changes, with focus on CASA papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6226118
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
I'm delighted that the @HarvLRev has published a book review of "The Digital Fourth Amendment." The review, by @granick, is here:
harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-139/fourth-amendment-equil… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Jeremy Christiansen
@TradVat2
This morning at @thenewdigest, I have posted a short presentation of the arguments of Alexander Hamilton the lawyer in one of his famous cases. You tell me. Was this man a textualist?
thenewdigest.substack.com/p/alexander-hamilton-classical-… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Hugely interesting piece on Congress's historical struggles to vindicate the power of the first purse vis a vis the executive, by Zach Price. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6194119
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
James Rosen
@JamesRosenTV
EXCLUSIVE: My guest essay in today’s @nytimes @NYTOpinion: “The Secret History of the Deep State,” based on newly declassified documents
www.nytimes.com/2026/02/08/opinion/trump-nixon-watergate-… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take, building on arguments by James Comey, on the extraordinary degree to which federal courts, including the Supreme Court, have successfully checked the Trump administration in the last year.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-federal-co… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Richard Ekins and I discuss the puzzling Trump flip-flop to allow British transfer of sovereignty over the Diego Garcia military base. www.execfunctions.org/p/richard-ekins-on-diego-garcia-and
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion with Richard Ekins on the UK transfer of sovereignty over the Chagos Islands (including Diego Garcia) and Trump administration reactions.
01:07 background on the Chagos Islands dispute
04:42 legal issues & why American consent is required
6:25 the current U.S. position
7:46 security concerns raised by the transfer
11:24 what’s driving the U.K. government
14:03 legal risks to U.S. operations at Diego Garcia
16:38 nuclear weapons and the Treaty of Pelindaba
18:07 why wouldn’t Trump veto this?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
President Trump just signaled reversal of his criticisms about Great Britain's transfer of sovereignty over the Diego Garcia base to Mauritius. I spoke to Oxford prof Richard Ekins about historical and legal background and implications for US security.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/richard-ekins-… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer speculates on why DOJ has removed its Manual on Federal Prosecution of Election Offenses from its website.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/yet-another-si… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
I’m excited to report that my new paper with Jack Goldsmith on Erie and general law (link in separate message below) will be published by the Yale Law Journal. The paper argues that the pre-Erie general law regime was dysfunctional; that Erie now undergirds large swaths of modern law; that trying to undo it would cause massive and unjustified system costs; that the pre-Erie regime is not recoverable in any event; and that all of this presents a challenge for at least some strands of originalism. @jacklgoldsmith @YaleLJournal
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
With Justice Alito's book on its way, I believe that makes the vote 7-2 in the case of Book Income vs. No Book Income, with only the Chief Justice and Justice Kagan dissenting.
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
If I could draft an ideal ethics rule for Supreme Court Justices, here's one more I would consider: No book deals. They could write a book and post it for free if they like, but no selling their books, which as a practical matter are marketed only to one side of the aisle.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Soon - Launch of my new book, SEPARATION OF POWERS, in, well, Washington, DC. @mitpress @JonahDispatch @jacklgoldsmith
politics-prose.com/cass-sunstein22226 -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
So this seems like. . . . a good idea? www.nytimes.com/2026/02/02/us/supreme-court-nondisclosure…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
FDR v. Donald Trump by @samuelmoyn and me.
www.nytimes.com/2026/02/02/opinion/trump-roosevelt-execut… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
I found a historical analogy I like www.nytimes.com/2026/02/02/opinion/trump-roosevelt-execut…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
Sorry to have missed this, @chad_mizelle. Let's see if we can flesh out what you mean.
1. Candidate A and Candidate B are identical, with one exception: Candidate A commits to enforce the prosecutorial agenda of whoever is president. Candidate B commits to enforce Trump's prosecutorial agenda but says he won't enforce the agenda of a Democratic president. Who earns your recommendation?
2. If someone chose to vote for Biden in 2020 and Harris in 2024 and remains content to have done so, is that person excluded from your category of "patriots"?
3. Do you believe that the vesting of executive power in the president renders civil-service laws unconstitutional?
Chad Mizelle
@chad_mizelle
@EdWhelanEPPC — The President sets enforcement priorities; AUSAs execute them. If someone isn’t enthusiastic about prosecuting Trump’s anti-crime agenda, why would DOJ hire them to do the job?
OPM’s merit plan asks candidates how they’d implement the President’s EOs. This is alignment with the mission—not a loyalty oath.
Reread Article II. Executive power is vested in one person: President Trump.
DOJ hires people who want to wield the President’s power, not sabotage it.
DMs remain open for patriots who get it. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the Georgia voting records search warrant and Trump’s $10 billion lawsuit against the IRS. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/donald-trump-i…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
James Rosen
@JamesRosenTV
Look who just got a baby brother!
Learn about Antonin Scalia and you will understand modern America—and how we got here.
Volume II, covering the first half of his thirty years on the Supreme Court, comes out February 10. Order now:
www.amazon.com/Scalia-Supreme-Court-Years-1986/dp/1510786910 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A new draft of "General Law Revivalism and the Problem of 1938." Improvements throughout, I hope, including more nuanced engagement w/ the extent to which the Erie Algorithm challenges various stripes of originalism and related theories. Comments welcome papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6035456
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer: How Donald Trump Can Continue to Make Billions in Office open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/how-donald-tru…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
I propose that and more in my forthcoming book #gerontocracyinamerica
Center for American Progress
@amprog
BREAKING—@RahmEmanuel announces a proposed ban on holding a position in any branch of government if you're over the age of 75 years old.
It's part of a plan for reestablishing trust with the public that also includes stronger anticorruption efforts.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Just ordered and looking forward to reading: Leigh Snead, "Infertile but Fruitful: Finding Fulfillment When You Can’t Conceive."
sophiainstitute.com/product/infertile-but-fruitful/ -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Good clear straightforward opinion by Justice Barrett today in Berk v. Choy. Perhaps most noteworthy: A strong reaffirmation of the (easy-to-satisfy) Sibbach test for the validity of federal rules under the Rules Enabling Act. www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/25pdf/24-440_1b82.pdf
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Here is my discussion with Sai on the pardon power.
0:25 unpacking the pardon clause
6:35 why the Framers included the pardon power
9:26 anti-federalist fears and the absence of checks
12:54 Washington's role in shaping Article II expectations
16:07 historical uses and abuses of the pardon power
22:43 clemency under the Biden and Trump administrations
28:39 a very limited role for the courts
31:42 reform options and challengesThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion with Sai Prakash about his great (and short!) new book on the Pardon Power (www.amazon.com/Presidential-Pardon-Clause-Troubled-Histor…)
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/sai-prakash-on… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Excellent concise summary and great graphics on Trump's presidential power claims.
www.nytimes.com/interactive/2026/01/19/us/trump-president… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Are the war on terrorism cases a guide to how the Supreme Court will consider/interpret the Insurrection Act?
www.execfunctions.org/p/what-happens-if-trump-invokes-theThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bauer and I w/ latest on Insurrection Act.
0:17 implications of Trump v. Illinois
4:10 how Sup Ct might respond
7:04 unresolved constitutional questions
13:10 political risks/public opinion
16:46 competing narratives on ICE conduct
21:19 implications for the midterms
29:25 inherent Article II authority
www.execfunctions.org/p/what-happens-if-trump-invokes-the -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A brief tribute to the great Edward Levi, the 71st Attorney General of the United States.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/edward-levis-d… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Some of my work with Bob Bauer (and others) on the Insurrection Act.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/trump-threaten… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
Today’s decision in Bost is more evidence of the standing realignment.
We have been revising and expanding our paper, now forthcoming in the Supreme Court Review. A new version will be posted in due course.
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
“The Standing Realignment,” a draft by Yoav Paz-Priel and myself.
Comments welcome! papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5765282 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the law and politics of the DOJ criminal investigation of the Fed Chair. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-criminal-i…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
In connection with this NYT story about Russia and theNorwegian archipelago Svalbard, see this excellent (seven-year-old but prescient and still informative) backgrounder: dash.harvard.edu/entities/publication/bf4a4972-49b5-4aed-…
www.nytimes.com/2026/01/11/world/europe/svalbard-norway-a… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Just received first copies of my coming book, SEPARATION OF POWERS @mitpress
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I enjoyed talking with @LynnThoman on her @3_takeaways podcast about presidential power, present and past.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/presidential-power-how-it-g… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
This will be awesome. All Yalies welcome.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
My latest, "Marbury Now," is out in newest issue of Liberties! (@readliberties).
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
New paper with @curtisabradley: "General Law Revivalism and the Problem of 1938." Short version: Erie is incompatible with and precludes many versions of originalism. (Comments welcome.)
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=6035456 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
“Why has Congress given the president this massive military force without constraints, why does it continue to acquiesce in the POTUS's uses of force, why isn’t congress exercising its [] prerogatives and responsibilities to check these things?"www.execfunctions.org/p/law-and-the-venezuela-invasion
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Venezuela strike: "It's law in the hands of the political branches and its up to the political branches to sort it out" www.execfunctions.org/p/law-and-the-venezuela-invasion
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I chat about the legality of the U.S. invasion of Venezuela to capture President Nicolás Maduro, how law matters to presidential uses of force, and what legal issues to expect at Maduro’s trial.
www.execfunctions.org/p/law-and-the-venezuela-invasion -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
On the Legality of the Venezuela Invasion" Executive branch precedents can be garnered to support the action—which does not, of course, mean that it is lawful. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/on-the-legalit…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My quick take on the legality of the Venezuela invasion.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/on-the-legalit… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
puzzling choice
Sarah Isgur
@whignewtons
I went with @jacklgoldsmith on the protective power www.execfunctions.org/p/the-presidents-protective-power?r…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Sarah Isgur
@whignewtons
I went with @jacklgoldsmith on the protective power www.execfunctions.org/p/the-presidents-protective-power?r…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
Some people think the "reasonable expectation of privacy" test in 4th Amendment law is just made up and inconsistent with the constitutional text and original public meaning.
They're wrong.
I explain why in this 2022 article, "Katz as Originalism":
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3894008 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
May have sent bad link earlier on my discussion with Chris Mirasola about the president's protective power and its relevance to Trump's domestic military deployments--a potentially big issue going forward. Now fixed.
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-presidents-protective-power -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion with Chris Mirasola about the president's protective power and its relevance to Trump's domestic military deployments--a potentially big issue going forward.
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-presidents-protective-power
Chris's great article on this: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4591793 -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
Just a reminder, in my latest article, I take on the question of what the heck the Jones trespass test of Fourth Amendment law really means—and how it's different from Katz.
Download it here:
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5129549 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My thoughts on the Interim Order in Trump v. Illinois. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/thoughts-on-th…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Re-upping my take from a year ago on Trump and Greenland: "Trump has a habit of making the unthinkable thinkable. But he faces complex legal and political hurdles to making the thinkable a reality." open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-danish-wes…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The Executive Functions “Roundup” is a daily summary of executive branch developments, including executive actions, litigation, and commentary, that I find indispensable for keeping up. www.execfunctions.org/s/morning-roundup
You can receive “The Roundup” by email if you sign up here. docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeDK95_5qU5EoRQkI3idsnZL…
We’ve now added something new: the “Executive Functions Roundup Library.” www.execfunctions.org/p/roundup-database.
The Library is a categorized, running index of storylines in our Roundup coverage. It helps readers follow developments and locate relevant documents and original reporting on topics such as Justice Department prosecutions, immigration and visa policy, pardons and clemency, and National Guard deployments. It also includes a page collecting the Supreme Court’s interim orders relating to executive power, with pending and resolved cases listed in reverse chronological order. www.execfunctions.org/p/scotus-interim-orders. It is still a work in progress.
If you have suggestions for how to improve the Library, or anything else, please email ex.functions@gmail.com. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
On the first anniversary of Executive Functions, Bob Bauer and I assess Trump's impact on executive power to date. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/trumps-impact-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Self-damning for a SecDef who typically loves to display boat striker videos. www.nytimes.com/2025/12/16/us/politics/hegseth-congress-b…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
New adventure: writing about interim orders @SCOTUSblog with @danepps and @WilliamBaude .
www.scotusblog.com/interim-docket-blog/ -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion with @ARozenshtein on Executive Power in the Age of Artificial Intelligence: Bureaucracy and the presidential "oracle" www.execfunctions.org/p/executive-power-in-the-age-of-art…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Two takeaways from Trump v. Slaughter oral argument:
1. The government will definitely lose the tariffs case.
2. Teaching Federal Courts after this decision next summer is going to be even more fun than usual. Lots of foundational federal courts issues potentially implicated. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
Other than the Federal Reserve, will there be other entities that remain independent after the Supreme Court's decision in Trump v. Slaughter?
I discuss the importance of this issue for the two commissions that regulate the federal election process, the FEC and ECA, in this post: electionlawblog.org?p=153385
@jacklgoldsmith -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
I’m delighted that my recent book has received an Honorable Mention from Scribes: The American Society of Legal Writers.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Sprouting shoots of normal accountability functions: (i) an IG report critical of Sec Def; (ii) serious congressional engagement with the Venezuela boat strikes; (iii) a change in DOD protocols, presumably sparked by internal legal concerns, to rescue rather than kill first-strike survivors.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
What a treasure Hankins is, and what a loss for Harvard.
Leo Koerner
@LeoAKoerner
Prof. James Hankins gave his last lecture at Harvard today, giving us a historical overview of Western thought.
He concluded by pointing out the loss of the Christian religious-philosophical pole in modern science and theory is to blame for the soullessness of our age.
Not only are we losing one of the last conservative leaning professors at Harvard, but after his departure there will be no general course on the history of ancient and medieval philosophy. As we swap another plank of pine for plastic the ship of Western institutions is reconstituted slowly enough to be barely noticed, and yet steadily enough to be rapid.
Prof. Hankins’ classes have been some of my favorite during my time here and I thank him and wish him the best for the future. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Richard Ekins' Vaughan Lecture: "Questioning the Dogmas of Textualism." youtu.be/sbgrNeJxx2c
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Ben Wittes and I had a conversation yesterday on the second-strike boat strike controversy, implications for and within DOD, and how members of Congress reviewing the matter should think about it.
www.dogshirtdaily.com/p/yeah-thats-a-war-crime-with-jack?… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Recall way back in March that Hegseth began “a sweeping overhaul of the judge advocate general’s corps as part of an effort to make the US military less restricted by the laws of armed conflict” www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/mar/13/pete-hegseth-pent…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Very much looking forward to this book next summer by @scmallaby -- "The Infinity Machine: Demis Hassabis, DeepMind, and the Quest for Superintelligence." www.amazon.com/gp/product/0593831845?tag=randohouseinc798…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A Dishonorable Strike: Indulging all assumptions in favor of the administration’s boat strikes, killing helpless men is murder. www.execfunctions.org/p/a-dishonorable-strike?r=4xo6yq&sh…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My Walter Berns Constitution Day Lecture at @aei: "Presidential Greatness and the Fragility of Judicial Supremacy." www.aei.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Presidential-Great…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Scorching, fascinating dissent by Judge Oldham on Erie: "The Big Bang in the federal courts’ universe came in 1938. See Erie R.R. Co. v. Tompkins, 304 U.S. 64 (1938). Erie changed everything."
www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/24/24-60509-CV0.pdf -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Super-interesting paper: The Standing Realignment, by @RichardMRe and Yoav Paz-Priel. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5765282
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Epstein Bill says AG Bondi may “withhold . . . records” that “would jeopardize an active federal investigation or ongoing prosecution.” Bondi is currently—at the president’s command—investigating Epstein’s past ties with democrats. Massie and others worry that the administration will invoke this investigation to block release under the new law. But Trump cannot hide behind Bondi here. He entirely controls the (made up) investigation—he ordered it, and he can stop or qualify it. If DOJ invokes the “active investigation” loophole it will mean that Trump himself is stonewalling. This is, after all, one point of the administration’s unitary-executive-on-steroids: the president is clearly responsible/accountable for all executive branch decisions.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
Just a reminder to law profs who teach from my Computer Crime Law casebook that the new 6th edition will be out next month, in time for use in the Spring 2026 semester.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer: After a Strategic Retreat, Trump Has Many Moves Left to Prevent Release of the Epstein Records. After the House vote, he can resume playing hardball. www.execfunctions.org/p/after-a-strategic-retreat-trump-has
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Final of my essay, "Interim Orders, the Presidency, and Judicial Supremacy" in @HarvLRev. Bottom line: "the Court has acted, as it generally has through its history, to maximize its authority in the face of the reality that it lacks sword or purse"
harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-139/interim-orders-the-pre…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Thanks to the editors of @HarvLRev, who were terrific.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Outstanding cover (and book)-- out in June.
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
Cover reveal
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion with David Pozen about his elucidating essay, with Jedediah Britton-Purdy, entitled: "What Are We Living Through? Three competing narratives of the second Trump administration." @BostonReview www.execfunctions.org/p/what-are-we-living-through
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
One of the best (most interesting, provocative, insightful, etc.) Harvard Law Review Forewords in many years: @RichardMRe, "To a Conservative Warren Court."
harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-139/to-a-conservative-warr… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I very much look forward to this book.
James Rosen
@JamesRosenTV
Coming February 3. Pre-order now. a.co/d/33NQgL0
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the tariffs oral argument. www.nytimes.com/2025/11/05/opinion/supreme-court-tariffs-…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Jonathan H. Adler
@jadler1969
@jacklgoldsmith writes: "the norm of inter-administration comity after Trump 2.0 may not hold, or may not hold to the same degree, given the radicalness of the Trump administration’s approach to law and norms." Is this the end of OLC as we've known it? 1/
Jonathan H. Adler
@jadler1969
Must read
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the significance of the classified OLC opinion for the Venezuela boat strikes. www.execfunctions.org/p/the-venezuela-boat-strikes-and-th…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the significance of the classified OLC opinion for the Venezuela boat strikes. www.execfunctions.org/p/the-venezuela-boat-strikes-and-th…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
A prophetic paper: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3213954
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
perfect, and perfectly revealing, in every detail
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Dangerous enough to try to kill with military force but not dangerous enough to detain and prosecute via lawful methods--almost certainly because a lawful case could not be made before a court. Especially awkward for DOD. www.nytimes.com/2025/10/18/us/politics/boat-strike-surviv…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer: The Weaponization of the IRS www.execfunctions.org/p/the-weaponization-of-the-irs?r=4x…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Some reactions to the NYT report yesterday that Trump had made a covert action “finding” that “would allow the C.I.A. to carry out lethal operations in Venezuela and conduct a range of operations in the Caribbean.”
Yesterday afternoon Trump was asked why he “authorize[d] the CIA to go into Venezuela.” The President said he had done so because Venezuela had emptied their prisons into the United States and because lots of drugs came into the United States from Venezuela. The president declined to say whether the CIA had the “authority to take out Madura.”
Four thoughts:
First, a “covert action” is defined in 50 U.S.C. § 3093 as “an activity or activities of the United States Government to influence political, economic, or military conditions abroad, where it is intended that the role of the United States Government will not be apparent or acknowledged publicly.” The president's acknowledgment likely renders at least the fact of the CIA authority no longer covert. This has political and military and diplomatic implications, but also potential legal ones under Title 50 as well.
Second, the ultimate legal basis for the CIA covert action is probably Article II. Somewhere in the bowels of the government—in CIA, in DOJ, in the White House—some lawyer has determined that the president has the authority under Article II to order action inside Venezuela. This is almost certainly an expansion of the president's Article II authority to use force over prior extravagant executive branch understandings of this authority.
Third, 50 U.S.C. § 3093 says that a presidential finding “may not authorize any action that would violate the Constitution or any statute of the United States.” This has been viewed to give the CIA wiggle room from the constraints of international law that the Defense Department, traditionally anyway, took more seriously. If the United States is going into Venezuela with kinetic force, that action is not obviously consistent (and is probably inconsistent) with international law constraints jus in bello and jus ad bellum. CIA action under Title 50 skirts those concerns within the U.S. government. Also, the War Powers Resolution, or what is left of it, does not apply to CIA actions.
Fourth, I do not mean to suggest that the CIA would not be concerned about conducting these actions. I am sure there are strongly mixed feelings about this task, and the president’s acknowledgment of it, at Langley. One big difference between this task and, say, the CIA interrogation and black site program in the 2000s, is that Trump is not keeping it super-secret. Rather, as he often does when he is breaking law or norms, he acts openly and without shame or concern. It is a very effective method for defanging the public impact of law and norms—at least in the short run. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss internal rifts at DOJ, the loyalty pressures shaping the Trump administration, and whether constitutional reform is needed to curb the spiral of politicized prosecutions. www.execfunctions.org/p/decision-making-disarray-at-the-d…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Sai Prakash, January 2026: "The Presidential Pardon: The Short Clause with a Long, Troubled History." Great book. a.co/d/dKx8aHj
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the Oregon National Guard case and on the Insurrection Act road ahead: "President Trump Holds the Legal Cards on the Use of the Military in the Domestic Sphere" www.execfunctions.org/p/president-trump-holds-the-legal-c…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Good primer on selective/vindictive prosecution and the Comey indictment. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-comey-indictment-and-sel…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss (and in places disagree about) the Oregon National Guard decision, deference to the President, the President’s Truth Social comments, and the ultimate limits on the President’s power to use the military in the domestic sphere. www.execfunctions.org/p/the-oregon-national-guard-ruling?…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Keith E. Whittington
@kewhittington
ICYMI
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Is Donald Trump a Reconstructive President? @kewhittington and I discuss Trump’s constitutional ambitions, judicial supremacy versus departmentalism, and whether Trump will defy the Supreme Court. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/is-donald-trump-a-recon…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Reactions to the Court’s deferral of action—without explanation or recorded dissent—on the Government’s application for a stay in the Cook case pending oral argument in January:
1. This is a good example of why “emergency docket” is a misnomer and “interim orders docket” is better. The government is seeking a stay of a preliminary injunction, which is an interim order. But the Court does not view the case as an emergency: It is not going to pass on the application for a long time. Nothing about interim order applications requires emergency treatment. Sometimes the Court moves fast or super-fast; but usually not. The timing is entirely in the Court’s discretion. The general category is interim orders, not emergency orders.
2. The Court’s deferral is modest rebuke to the USG, which asked for a stay and an administrative stay. The Court did not do either, even though it had granted administrative stays in prior removal cases (Wilcox and Slaughter). Not only did the Court not issue an administrative stay pending resolution of the application, it deferred consideration of the application for more than three months pending oral argument. This is a longer lead time than in other recent cases setting oral argument on interim orders (CASA (1 month), Ohio v. EPA (2 months, though the Court waited two months to announce oral argument), NFIB v. OSHA (less than a month). If the Court viewed this issue as urgent, it could have set a briefing schedule for oral argument in December and possibly November. Clearly the Court does not see this issue with nearly the same urgency as the SG.
3. The setting of oral argument indicates that the Court wants fuller briefing and deliberation on this issue than a typical interim order application. But why is the Court taking its sweet time? No way to know for sure. One thing it may indicate is that the Court views Fed removal differently than the other removal issues before it. The Court has already indicated in the Wilcox order in May that it views the Federal Reserve constitutional removal issues differently. The issue in the Cook case is not Article II removal – it is the meaning of the statutory for-cause removal provision. But the Court pretty clearly thinks the Fed is different, full stop –- perhaps for a legal reason, perhaps for some other reason. Another explanation for the timing might be that the Court wants the benefit of the briefing and December oral argument in the FTC removal case, Slaughter, which raises similar remedial issues as the Cook application.
4. No one on the Court—and only one person that I have seen in the commentariat bsky.app/profile/richardre.bsky.social/post/3m25r3mt5ck23— complained about the lack of explanation for the Court’s action. True, the Court did not resolve the application and did not analyze a legal issue, and the deferral has no formal impact on other cases. But the decision not to stay the injunction for a long time means that Cook stays in office for a long time. That is a very big deal and somewhat legally controversial. And yet not a word of explanation. I think that is just fine. The Court acts with significant legal impact all the time without explanation—in interim orders, in cert. denials, and in other contexts. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Charlie Savage
@charlie_savage
In case useful, I made a chart (w/ CourtListener links) of newly disclosed attorney-client privilege material from the Trump J6 & docs grand jury investigations & how they compares to the executive privilege-focused files that became public last October.
charliesavage.com/2025/09/newly-revealed-material-from-th… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Status Quo or Revolution?: Fascinating article by Yuval Levin on the reality of spending changes in Trump 2.0. www.nationalreview.com/2025/09/status-quo-or-revolution/
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
New paper:
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Good updated analysis on whether Lindsey Halligan was validly appointed as United States Attorney by @EdWhelanEPPC. www.nationalreview.com/bench-memos/re-was-lindsey-halliga…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the Comey indictment. www.execfunctions.org/p/the-comey-indictment?r=4xo6yq&tim…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
And @AndrewCMcCarthy says the indictment is "so ill-conceived and incompetently drafted, [Comey] should be able to get it thrown out on a pretrial motion to dismiss."
www.nationalreview.com/2025/09/the-indictment-against-com… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Was Lindsey Halligan Validly Appointed as United States Attorney? @EdWhelanEPPC says no. www.nationalreview.com/bench-memos/was-lindsey-halligan-v…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Questioned answered: No.
Next question: Can a jury trial check a weaponizing president/DOJ.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Events in EDVA are a major test whether (i) career prosecutors, (ii) Justice Man. 9-27.220 (prosecution allowed only if probable that person will "be found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt by an unbiased trier of fact”), and (iii) grand jury, can check weaponizing president/DOJ.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
Can’t believe Obama just blurbed my book
Acyn
@Acyn
OBAMA: It's fair to say that 80% of the world's problems involve old men hanging on who are afraid of death and insignificance, and they won't let go. They build pyramids, and they put their names on everything. They get very anxious about it.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I highly recommend this book. I recently read it and found it enormously elucidating for understanding Trump 2.0.
Keith E. Whittington
@kewhittington
And some background reading (available at a steep discount!). My thanks to Jack for the conversation
www.amazon.com/Political-Foundations-Judicial-Supremacy-C… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Events in EDVA are a major test whether (i) career prosecutors, (ii) Justice Man. 9-27.220 (prosecution allowed only if probable that person will "be found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt by an unbiased trier of fact”), and (iii) grand jury, can check weaponizing president/DOJ.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Is Donald Trump a Reconstructive President? @kewhittington and I discuss Trump’s constitutional ambitions, judicial supremacy versus departmentalism, and whether Trump will defy the Supreme Court. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/is-donald-trump-a-recon…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
An administration happy to downsize and to shed federal government employees has an asymmetric weapon against Congressional government shutdown threats. From OMB memo:
With respect to those Federal programs whose funding would lapse and which are otherwise unfunded, such programs are no longer statutorily required to be carried out. Therefore, consistent with applicable law, including the requirements of 5 C.F.R. part 351, agencies are directed to use this opportunity to consider Reduction in Force (RIF) notices for all employees in programs, projects, or activities (PPAs) that satisfy all three of the following conditions: (1) discretionary funding lapses on October 1, 2025; (2) another source of funding, such as H.R. 1 (Public Law 119-21) is not currently available; and (3) the PPA is not consistent with the President’s priorities. RIF notices will be in addition to any furlough notices provided due to the lapse in appropriation. RIF notices should be issued to all employees working on the relevant PPA, regardless of whether the employee is excepted or furloughed during the lapse in appropriations.
Schumer’s response: “These unnecessary firings will either be overturned in court or the administration will end up hiring the workers back, just like they did as recently as today.”
I seriously doubt Schumer is right, although the end-of-day scale of government employee losses is unknowable. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on pretext in the Federal Reserve "for cause" case. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/presidential-pretext-an…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Many interesting amicus briefs filed today in tariff case in Sup Ct, but to me this one, by Professor Aditya Bamzai, stands out in importance -- it's a deep dive into the Trading With the Enemy Act history and its relevance to IEEPA and tariffs. www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/24/24-1287/375663/20250923…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My examination of the “ethics of service” for political appointees in the Justice Department in light of DOJ's handling of the Siebert matter, among other things. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/how-should-a-d…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
David Schleicher
@ProfSchleich
🚨🚨New Pod!! 🚨🚨@samuelmoyn and I kick off a new season of Digging a Hole talking about the constitutional law and politics of executive power with the great Bob Bauer podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/digging-a-hole-the-legal-th…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
This brief in Murthy v. Missouri, for amici Charlie Kirk, David Harris, and Robby Starbuck, by Counsel of Record Jay Sekulow, is worth a read. www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/23/23-411/300226/202402091…
So too is the brief for Missouri, with now-Solicitor General John Sauer on the brief. www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/23/23-411/299644/202402021…
Indeed, all the amicus briefs shaded in dark green, in support of Respondents, are worth a read. www.scotusblog.com/cases/case-files/murthy-v-missouri-3/ -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
On September 12, the Harvard Catholic Forum held an event on “Christian Nihilism and Romanticism” at which I spoke, with an excellent response by Fr. Nathaniel Sanders, the Harvard undergraduate chaplain.
Today my talk, “Three Mistakes About Power and Justice,” is posted @thenewdigest. Fr. Sanders’ response will run tomorrow.
Enjoy!
api.omarshehata.me/substack-proxy/articles/thenewdigest-s… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer disagrees with me on the Tariff Case and the Major Questions Doctrine open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/a-disagreement…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
As you know, Schlesinger wrote before the era of modern political polarization began, let alone before the hyperpolarized parties we have now had for many years. When a party's electorate fate in general is tied so closely to the favorability of a same-party President, that party's members in Congress mostly fall in line.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Rereading Schlesinger's Imperial Presidency for a class tomorrow. So much about it is dated, but so much is still insightful. This sentence says a lot about where we are today: "Historically, Congress had preserved the rough balance of the Constitution because it retained three vital powers: the war-making power, the power of the purse, and the power of oversight and investigation."
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Rereading Schlesinger's Imperial Presidency for a class tomorrow. So much about it is dated, but so much is still insightful. This sentence says a lot about where we are today: "Historically, Congress had preserved the rough balance of the Constitution because it retained three vital powers: the war-making power, the power of the purse, and the power of oversight and investigation."
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
So sad to hear of the death of Bob Cooter, a tremendous scholar, a fantastic colleague, and a great friend (with a devilish smile). Reminder: Kindness is good, and more is better; we are all mortal. @jacklgoldsmith @lsolum
www.law.berkeley.edu/article/deans-message-the-passing-of… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take:
The Tariff Case and the Major Questions Doctrine
Trump has strong legal arguments but legal arguments alone likely won't decide the case.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
piece here
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-tariff-cas… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Matt Gluck with a good review of Casey Dominguez, “Commander in Chief: Partisanship, Nationalism, and the Reconstruction of Congressional War Powers” www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-commander-in-chief-in-co…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
Based-my forthcoming book us.macmillan.com/books/9780374607647/gerontocracyinamerica/
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
elucidating
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
Here's my take on the Supreme Court's order today in the Los Angeles immigration enforcement case. A deep dive for the law nerds, now up at Volokh.
reason.com/volokh/2025/09/08/supreme-court-lifts-injuncti… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the performance of White House Counsel David Warrington and examine last week’s lethal strike on alleged Venezuelan terrorists—including its possible implications for domestic presidential military strikes.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/fateful-lawyer… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I think this is an accurate descriptive assessment. Team Trump is playing by rules it perceives the left to have used, though often in a more extreme guise. Some in the administration (and some new righters outside the administration) justify actions once condemned by saying, referring to Dems, "they did it first" or "they were going to do it to us." Others relatedly acknowledge that left was successful with techniques the right once eschewed but is now mimicking -- lawfare, Title IV, non-enforcement of law, etc. Many possible outcomes in the next round of a Dem president, ranging from detente to a further extreme ratcheting up of retaliatory weaponization, with many possibilities in between, depending on the issue.
Sean T at RCP
@SeanTrende
I feel like a broken record but, yes. A large portion of the new right has decided to play under what they see as rules that the left plays under, only flipped to the right. It is the key to understanding Trumps second term.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
So much extraordinary dysfunction here at the intersection of pardons and autopen. Worse on both dimensions than I imagined. www.axios.com/2025/09/06/biden-pardon-autopen-concerns
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Amazingly useful time-saving and even fun tool for legal nerds.
Ben Eidelson
@beidelson
Case Viewer, my quirky side project of building my ideal legal search & reading app, has come a long way. With lots of help, it's grown into the best way to find & read cases on a Mac or iOS. Check it out or download on the App Store below. And follow @CaseViewerApp for updates!
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I agree with those who speculate that there is a connection between the growing militarization of the fight with Tren de Aragua abroad and the administration's domestic legal position in the Alien Enemies Act litigation.
Concretely, I expect the administration to invoke POTUS’s dramatic expansion of his power to use force against Tren de Araguadrug smugglers to serve “vital U.S. national interests and in the collective self-defense”— a White House perversion of an already perverted OLC legal categories for use of force – to help the legal argument in the CA5 Alien Enemies Act on appeal to Supreme Court. That case involves the president’s attempt to use the AEA to expel alleged Tren de Aragua members based on his determination that they engaged in an” invasion or predatory incursion” within the meaning of the AEA.
The dispute in CA5 is basically about whether the president’s determination about incursion or invasion is conclusive on the courts. The USG will now surely argue more loudly than before, citing the Prize Cases, that the call is entirely the presidents to make in light of his determination that force was needed and appropriate against the speedboat smugglers. And the hotter the conflict with Tren de Aragua is, the harder it will be for the Court to disagree on the law. At least on one dimension.
But of course it is perverse to indulge the president’s wild unilateral expansion of his power to use military force in this context as the justification to expand the president’s domestic authority under the AEA. As Justice Jackson said in Youngstown Steel in an analogous context: “[N]o doctrine that the Court could promulgate would seem to me more sinister and alarming than that a President whose conduct of foreign affairs is so largely uncontrolled, and often even is unknown, can vastly enlarge his mastery over the internal affairs of the country by his own commitment of the Nation's armed forces to some foreign venture.” -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Great explainer on pocket rescissions, which Trump just exercised, by @PhilipWallach. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/legal-controversy-and-politi…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Twenty Things Republicans Once Opposed But Now Support or Accept. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/twenty-things-…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Philip Wallach
@PhilipWallach
Looks like we’re really doing this, unfortunately.
To catch up, read my recent @lawfare explainer of pocket rescissions.
Bottom line: Congress needs to respond to this quickly and decisively. Its power of the purse is in danger of being snatched.
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/legal-controversy-and-politi…
New York Post
@nypost
Trump scraps $5B in foreign aid in rare ‘pocket rescission’ nypost.com/2025/08/28/us-news/trump-scraps-5b-in-foreign-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
"The ABA does not deserve this power over the training of American legal professionals. States would do well to provide alternative avenues for law schools to demonstrate their ability to train future lawyers — outside the control of the ABA."
Lael Weinberger
@LaelWeinberger
The ABA is the gatekeeper for American legal education - but some states are considering changing that. They should. In an op-ed today in @wapo, I explain that ABA is losing confidence in its control over legal ed - on a bipartisan basis. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2025/08/29/aba-law-school…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Marty Lederman asks very good questions on Trump's firing of Cook.
balkin.blogspot.com/2025/08/what-are-legal-questions-at-i…
My tentative hunches (just hunches):
1. Yes
2. Uncertain, but I don't think Loper-Bright is relevant to deference-to-POTUS issues.
3. Court will almost certainly not enjoin POTUS in this context but if it issues coercive remedy against USG (see 9 below) it will likely run against non-presidential officials (which is tricky here but not impossible).
4. Not sure about basis for confidence re counterfactual.
5. I am doubtful they will if they can and I am not sure if they can.
6. I doubt it under the "logic" of Shurtleff and Reagan, especially since this statute (unlike others in this context) is silent on hearing, but issue is unclear. See x.com/Vermeullarmine/status/1960871104714506691
7. Not much of one if any.
8. No idea but surely POTUS would get some deference.
9. Very hard question. Gorsuch in Bessent dissent said no injunctive relief but maybe quo warranto.
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
Just want to add the following to the excellent comments of @jacklgoldsmith and @adityabamzai linked below:
The Shurtleff decision from 1903, mentioned in their discussion, involved a statute that provided for removal for “inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance in office.”
There is however a predecessor case, Reagan v. US, 182 U.S. 419 (1901), that involved a statute allowing removal “for causes prescribed by law.” Because no other statute had provided such causes, the Court essentially faced a pure “for cause” removal provision — akin to the one currently at issue for the Fed. And the Court in Reagan seems to say that where the statute contains a pure “for cause” standard, discretion to remove is very broad, if even reviewable at all. (See the screenshot). As the Court says, “removal for cause, when causes are not defined … is a matter of discretion, and not reviewable.”
Now, Reagan involved an odd statutory scheme involving federal commissioners in Indian territory, removable by federal district judges in the relevant districts, rather than principal officers. Hence the case is distinguishable on its facts. Still, the broad language in Reagan could be taken as interpretive background for the enactment of later statutes - such as the pure “for cause” removal provisions of, say, the Federal Reserve Act of 1913. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Can anyone point me to a legal analysis of how the USG can convert (i) the $5.7 billion in awarded but unpaid grants to Intel under the U.S. CHIPS Act, plus $2.2 billion in CHIPS grants Intel has received to date, plus $3.2 billion awarded to Intel under the Secure Enclave program, into (ii) a $11.1 billion USG equity stake in Intel? There must be some deep-plumbing legal authority to do this that USG is relying on (since these transactions have enormous real-world commercial consequences) but I have no idea what it is. On the transactions see newsroom.intel.com/corporate/intel-and-trump-administrati…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Agree and, despite @Vermeullarmine's careful qualifications, this line, highlighted below, will surely feature in the USG briefs: "removal for cause, when causes are not defined nor removal for cause provided for, is a matter of discretion, and not reviewable."
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
Just want to add the following to the excellent comments of @jacklgoldsmith and @adityabamzai linked below:
The Shurtleff decision from 1903, mentioned in their discussion, involved a statute that provided for removal for “inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance in office.”
There is however a predecessor case, Reagan v. US, 182 U.S. 419 (1901), that involved a statute allowing removal “for causes prescribed by law.” Because no other statute had provided such causes, the Court essentially faced a pure “for cause” removal provision — akin to the one currently at issue for the Fed. And the Court in Reagan seems to say that where the statute contains a pure “for cause” standard, discretion to remove is very broad, if even reviewable at all. (See the screenshot). As the Court says, “removal for cause, when causes are not defined … is a matter of discretion, and not reviewable.”
Now, Reagan involved an odd statutory scheme involving federal commissioners in Indian territory, removable by federal district judges in the relevant districts, rather than principal officers. Hence the case is distinguishable on its facts. Still, the broad language in Reagan could be taken as interpretive background for the enactment of later statutes - such as the pure “for cause” removal provisions of, say, the Federal Reserve Act of 1913. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A long discussion with Aditya Bamzai (@adityabamzai) at @UVALaw on whether President Trump can lawfully fire Fed Governor Lisa Cook. We discuss POTUS' constitutional removal power, whether POTUS satisfied the statutory “for cause” standard in firing Cook, why that issue is hard, whether Cook’s pre-Fed actions are relevant, whether Cook gets notice and a hearing before firing, and whether a reinstatement remedy is available.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/can-president-… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
There have been two institutional constraints on Trump 2.0: The courts and markets. The firing of Lisa Cook "for cause" may be pretextual but is not obviously illegal. The big question is how the markets react. One hears over and over that concrete threats to Fed independence will tank the markets. Tomorrow we will find out.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@RichardMRe -- Alleging Bad Faith in NIH v. APHA blog.dividedargument.com/p/alleging-bad-faith-in-nih-v-ap…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Discussing executive power today with @PreetBharara and Bob Bauer.
Stay Tuned with Preet
@cafedotcom
This afternoon, @PreetBharara went live with @jacklgoldsmith and Bob Bauer on Substack to discuss the FBI raid of John Bolton’s home and Trump’s ever-widening use of executive power.
Watch the full conversation: cafe.visitlink.me/_z9mUcThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Must watch for 1Ls.
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
NEW VIDEO: "So You're About To Start Law School: An Incoming Law Student's Guide to the First Month" My tips, especially for those first-gen students who don't know a lot of lawyers. Hope students find it useful.
WATCH IT HERE: www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ayl3fl3Hzus -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Julia D Mahoney
@JuliaMahoneyUVA
Just posted on @ssrn by my colleague Ann Woolhandler: Contracts, Grants, and the Limits of Executive Discretion papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5396026 @UVALaw
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Excellent analysis of interim orders at Supreme Court, by @AdamUnikowsky open.substack.com/pub/adamunikowsky/p/rip-doe?r=4xo6yq&sh…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@RickPildes has a good essay that complements the one I wrote today. electionlawblog.org?p=151606
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Nonsense and Sense About Supreme Court Interim Orders: Legitimate questions about interim orders are harmed by exaggeration and distortion open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/nonsense-and-s…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Matthew Waxman
@mattwaxman1
Re-upping this in light of today's NYT reporting
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/using-force-against-mexican-… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Two years ago today: "The Prosecution of Trump May Have Terrible Consequences". www.nytimes.com/2023/08/08/opinion/trump-indictment-cost-…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
Just finished: “Gerontocracy in America: How the Old Hoard Power and Wealth - and What to Do About It,” coming early June 2026
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Philip Wallach
@PhilipWallach
We could soon see a major showdown between the president and Congress, with the weapon of choice being “pocket rescissions.”
What are they and why do they appeal to Trump’s Office of Management and Budget? Why does the GAO think they’re unlawful?
I explain @lawfare. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
First full draft of a new paper: A (very) deep dive in to the Supreme Court's interim orders related to Trump thus far this year.
Highlights: (1) The dominant theme of the orders is the Court’s efforts to effectuate judicial supremacy vis a vis executive branch and lower courts; (2) the orders do not support the appeasement thesis; (3) the Court innovated to enhance its vertical control over lower federal courts—control that can be analogized to (and justified on analogous grounds to) the Executive branch’s directive power; (4) CASA’s Section 11 analysis is muddled; (5) CASA extracted a historic executive branch pledge of fealty to Supreme Court “judgments and opinions”—an episode that illustrates the Court’s strengths and weaknesses vis a vis the executive; (6) the Court’s sharp dispute resolution rhetoric in its criticisms of Justice Jackson’s dissent is belied by its extreme assertions of a law-declaration, overseer-of-government effect for its “opinions and judgments.” Draft still rough. Comments welcome! papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5378193 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss executive branch scandal management and conflicts of interest in the Epstein matter. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/epstein-scanda…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer: "Weak Ethics and Deep Politics at DOJ in the Epstein Case: The Role of Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche has drawn attention--but not enough." open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/weak-ethics-an…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My conversation with Anne Joseph O’Connell on the New Jersey US Attorney intrigues. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/anne-joseph-oc…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
John J. Vecchione
@VecchTweets
Exactly right. It is an important statement that will, if followed, slow additions to the emergency docket in virtually identical cases.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I think -- am I wrong? -- that this sentence (from the just-announced Trump v. Wilcox) is the most extensive and important explanation for how and why Supreme Court interim orders are vertically "binding":
"Although our interim orders are not conclusive as to the merits, they inform how a court should exercise its equitable discretion in like cases."
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
PS: by "vertically binding" I meant binding on the entire lower federal judiciary in cases other than the controlling interim order.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
Essential reading.
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
Last fall, the editors of the Harvard Law Review invited me to write the Foreword for this year's Supreme Court issue.
My working draft is below, and comments are most welcome.
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5363502 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
We're at day 26 of the Trump admin's compliance w Supreme Court’s universal injunction in the last sentence of Trump v. CASA: “Consistent with the Solicitor General’s representation, §2 of the Executive Order shall not take effect until 30 days after the date of this opinion.”
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Marty Lederman has some details about the broader context. bsky.app/profile/martylederman.bsky.social/post/3luntewdn…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Devastating and brutally credible indictment.
eburke
@JamesWHankins1
The University of Florida is the new leader in the study of Western and American civilization. So-called elite universities have abandoned the study of Western culture and politics over the last 25 years, and that betrayal has given other institutions the opportunity to create new centers of excellence. news.ufl.edu/2025/07/hamilton-school-faculty-expansion/
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the legal and ethical obligations of the firms that are violating the TikTok ban. Should a firm violate the law in the service of profits and other goods when there is practically zero chance of legal liability ? open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/does-it-matter…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer looks at the corporate duty side of the TikTok ban that the companies are violating but for which the Attorney General has provided practical immunity from DOJ enforcement. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/corporate-resp…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Great stuff from a truly great man. Not on the list is another extraordinary piece, perhaps the most apt for our current moment: "Judicial Supremacy, Departmentalism, and the Rule of Law in a Populist Age," in which Dick concludes (among many other things) that "our system is not, never has been, and never could be one of pure judicial supremacy," and explains deep implications. Insightful on every page. blog.dividedargument.com/p/things-to-read-dick-fallon-tri…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
I’m still confused about this whole discourse (including the Court’s recent aside) because there is no statutory for-cause protection for the Fed chair as such. Only for the members as such. There is arguably an unwritten convention, but if we are now enforcing unwritten conventions in court, I have a long list of suggestions.
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
Reminder — when discussing removal issues, don’t leap straight to the constitutional issues; check the statutes first.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Love this poem (though I'm biased): "The Southern Porches of Our Youth," by Leslie Williams open.substack.com/pub/onlypoems/p/the-southern-porches-of…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
see also www.nga.gov/artworks/119052-tomorrow-i-may-be-far-away
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
Let me guess: it’ll end up being a building on the edge of campus where the “classical liberals” can be quarantined and ignored
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
This fleshes out the possible mistake I've been discussing on X re Trump v. CASA.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Link: open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/a-legal-mistak…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
Exactly right. There are two basic reasons that telling the elite universities to “just stop discriminating against conservatives” won’t work:
(1) The people doing the hiring don’t think they are engaged in ideological discrimination. The psychology is: “We’re perfectly open to hiring conservatives! But it just so happens that we’ve never seen a conservative candidate we thought was good enough.” (Funny how that works).
(2) Progressivism is in their view not something separate from “merit.” It is a component of merit, indeed it is the highest standard of merit.
Overall, the elite universities cannot be reformed by arguments that they cannot even hear, and they will not reform themselves from within. They must be subjected to a more profound structural reorganization.
Dave Greene
@GreeneMan6
“Just not discriminating against conservatives would fix the problem!”
What? Is this idea going to be implemented in the 1990s? How is a conservative liberal arts scholar going to advance when half the departments are ideologically left in their inception? When the journals and chairs are all progressive ideologues who think advancing their cause is the primary point of their field?
You can’t just tell these institutions to “be good” and then fix them. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I have different views on the Supreme Court's stay of the lower court injunction of the Administration’s Workforce Reduction EO and OMB memo.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
link here:
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/was-the-court-… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Two smarter-than-I-am federal courts friends pointed out that Section 11 also authorized suits in equity in lower federal courts where “the United States are Section 11 of the 1789 Act provides jurisdiction over suits in equity in suits where “the United States are **plaintiffs, or petitioners.**” I am not sure that saves the Court's analysis, but it might. Here the USG was not a plaintiff or a petitioner in the lower courts. (It was an applicant for partial interim relief in the Supreme Court and thus plausibly a “petitioner” there but it was not a petitioner in the lower courts, which is what matters.) The plaintiffs in CASA invoked 28 USC 1331 and 28 USC 1346. The latter provides jurisdiction when the United States is a **defendant.** I suppose that if 28 USC 1346, which says something quite different than Section 11 (US as plaintiff v. US as defendant), is somehow a successor to Section 11, then what the Court did would make sense. But if 1346 is more like 1331 than 1332 in the sense of being a new and later standalone statute that is not connected in the revisionary trail to Section 11--a point I do not know the answer to--then what the Court did would not work. IN any event it sure would have been useful to flesh out so crucial a point.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Please correct me if I am wrong but isn’t this an error, or at least a glitch, in Trump v. CASA?: The Court said “The Judiciary Act of 1789 endowed federal courts with jurisdiction over “all suits . . . in equity,” §11, 1 Stat. 78, and still today, this statute “is what authorizes the federal courts to issue equitable remedies,” S. Bray & E. Sherwin, Remedies 442 (4th ed. 2024).” (I have not been able to track down the context in which Bray and Sherwin say this.). This was the premise of the rest of the analysis. But Section 11 authorized lower federal court diversity jurisdiction over “suits of a civil nature at common law or in equity.” Grupo too, on which the Court relied, was a diversity case. But Trump v. CASA was not a case premised on Section 11 or a successor diversity statute. It was premised on federal question jurisdiction, which traces to an 1875 statute that authorizes federal question jurisdiction over suits at common law or in equity. On the Court’s logic doesn’t that mean it needs to explain why the 1875 statute authorized equitable remedies (I seriously doubt that it did fwiw). And more importantly, perhaps, shouldn't the Court have focused on the state of equitable remedies circa 1875, not 1789? The point might not seem to matter in light of the Court’s conclusion that “universal injunctions were not a feature of federal-court litigation until sometime in the 20th century.” But the analysis would sure look different. And I don’t think the 1948 Revision of the Judicial Code makes this problem go away. I am truly puzzled. What am I missing?
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Please correct me if I am wrong but isn’t this an error, or at least a glitch, in Trump v. CASA?: The Court said “The Judiciary Act of 1789 endowed federal courts with jurisdiction over “all suits . . . in equity,” §11, 1 Stat. 78, and still today, this statute “is what authorizes the federal courts to issue equitable remedies,” S. Bray & E. Sherwin, Remedies 442 (4th ed. 2024).” (I have not been able to track down the context in which Bray and Sherwin say this.). This was the premise of the rest of the analysis. But Section 11 authorized lower federal court diversity jurisdiction over “suits of a civil nature at common law or in equity.” Grupo too, on which the Court relied, was a diversity case. But Trump v. CASA was not a case premised on Section 11 or a successor diversity statute. It was premised on federal question jurisdiction, which traces to an 1875 statute that authorizes federal question jurisdiction over suits at common law or in equity. On the Court’s logic doesn’t that mean it needs to explain why the 1875 statute authorized equitable remedies (I seriously doubt that it did fwiw). And more importantly, perhaps, shouldn't the Court have focused on the state of equitable remedies circa 1875, not 1789? The point might not seem to matter in light of the Court’s conclusion that “universal injunctions were not a feature of federal-court litigation until sometime in the 20th century.” But the analysis would sure look different. And I don’t think the 1948 Revision of the Judicial Code makes this problem go away. I am truly puzzled. What am I missing?
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Please correct me if I am wrong but isn’t this an error, or at least a glitch, in Trump v. CASA?: The Court said “The Judiciary Act of 1789 endowed federal courts with jurisdiction over “all suits . . . in equity,” §11, 1 Stat. 78, and still today, this statute “is what authorizes the federal courts to issue equitable remedies,” S. Bray & E. Sherwin, Remedies 442 (4th ed. 2024).” (I have not been able to track down the context in which Bray and Sherwin say this.). This was the premise of the rest of the analysis. But Section 11 authorized lower federal court diversity jurisdiction over “suits of a civil nature at common law or in equity.” Grupo too, on which the Court relied, was a diversity case. But Trump v. CASA was not a case premised on Section 11 or a successor diversity statute. It was premised on federal question jurisdiction, which traces to an 1875 statute that authorizes federal question jurisdiction over suits at common law or in equity. On the Court’s logic doesn’t that mean it needs to explain why the 1875 statute authorized equitable remedies (I seriously doubt that it did fwiw). And more importantly, perhaps, shouldn't the Court have focused on the state of equitable remedies circa 1875, not 1789? The point might not seem to matter in light of the Court’s conclusion that “universal injunctions were not a feature of federal-court litigation until sometime in the 20th century.” But the analysis would sure look different. And I don’t think the 1948 Revision of the Judicial Code makes this problem go away. I am truly puzzled. What am I missing?
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
PS: The whole thing is especially puzzling since Guaranty Trust Co. v. York, 326 U.S. 99 (1945) said, correctly in my view, that equitable remedies were general law prior to Erie. So the whole idea that the diversity statute or the federal question statute **authorized** equitable remedies seems anachronistic at best.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
100%, reckoning on more than one dimension.
Varad Mehta
@varadmehta
This is why Trump v. CASA merely postponed the reckoning and didn't stop it from happening.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The basic question is: What does the Supreme Court after CASA need to do to transform a non-universal lower court injunction into a directive that binds the government universally. At one extreme, I tend to doubt that an unexplained denial of a stay of a district court non-universal injunction means the govt must accept the district court injunction universally. At the other extreme, the implications of the SG concession, FN 18, and the last sentence of the opinion seems to be that an affirmative Supreme Court injunction will for some unexplained reason be respected by the government universally. For everything in between, and there are many possibilities, not sure, and pretty sure the Court has not thought about it.
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
Suppose a DC grants preliminary relief to a specific set of plaintiffs, the govt seeks emergency relief from the Court, and the Court declines to grant a stay. Does the govt now accept the DC merits judgment on a universal basis? If the Court denied a stay and said we agree with the DC's preliminary judgment on the merits, the govt would presumably honor that universally. But what if it's just an unexplained denial of a stay?
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The basic question is: What does the Supreme Court after CASA need to do to transform a non-universal lower court injunction into a directive that binds the government universally. At one extreme, I tend to doubt that an unexplained denial of a stay of a district court non-universal injunction means the govt must accept the district court injunction universally. At the other extreme, the implications of the SG concession, FN 18, and the last sentence of the opinion seems to be that an affirmative Supreme Court injunction will for some unexplained reason be respected by the government universally. For everything in between, and there are many possibilities, not sure, and pretty sure the Court has not thought about it.
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
Suppose a DC grants preliminary relief to a specific set of plaintiffs, the govt seeks emergency relief from the Court, and the Court declines to grant a stay. Does the govt now accept the DC merits judgment on a universal basis? If the Court denied a stay and said we agree with the DC's preliminary judgment on the merits, the govt would presumably honor that universally. But what if it's just an unexplained denial of a stay?
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@ARozenshtein with a good take on the Bondi TitTok letters. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-government-s-astonishing…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the Bondi letters related to not enforcing the TikTok ban--"an astounding assertion of executive power—maybe the broadest I have ever seen any president or Justice Department make, ever, in any context—and that is saying something." open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/an-authority-t…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
link: executivefunctions.substack.com/p/an-authority-to-license…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Thanks to all for a great discussion.
Preet Bharara
@PreetBharara
The Supreme Court just severely limited nationwide injunctions in the birthright citizenship case. So what happens now? Professors Trevor Morrison, @ProfMMurray & @jacklgoldsmith joined me for an in-depth analysis on Stay Tuned. Listen: cafe.visitlink.me/gpfGa7
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Preet Bharara
@PreetBharara
The Supreme Court just severely limited nationwide injunctions in the birthright citizenship case. So what happens now? Professors Trevor Morrison, @ProfMMurray & @jacklgoldsmith joined me for an in-depth analysis on Stay Tuned. Listen: cafe.visitlink.me/gpfGa7
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
In a piece about the TikTok nonenforcement, I mentioned a case in which Tony Tan filed a shareholder books and records suit against Google’s parent, Alphabet, alleging wrongful refusal to produce internal documents about Google’s noncompliance with the TikTok ban. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/trumps-continuing-illeg…
On July 1 Alphabet filed its answer in the case, here: www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/0uhc6qqs2hizk7kb5izsb/Defendant-Al….
In it Alphabet “admits that it received a Letter dated February 11, 2025, from the Attorney General.” This letter has been widely reported but not (I think) yet confirmed by a company recipient. Alphabet does not here disclose the letter. But according to news reports, and as explained in my piece, it purports to “license illegal conduct,” which is what the Supreme Court said quite clearly in Kendall v. United States, 37 U.S. 524 (1838), the executive branch cannot do, and which has until now been a firm limit on executive branch discretion. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on the CBS 60 Minutes Settlement with Trump: Trump’s Big Win in His Escalating War on the Press open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/trumps-big-win…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
DOJ acknowledges that under Trump v. CASA, “July 27, 2025, is the earliest date on which Defendants may begin to apply Executive Order 14160 to persons covered by the order.” www.documentcloud.org/documents/25987147-casaeoimplementa…. I.e. it complies with command in the last line of Trump v. CASA on a universal basis (i.e. re all "persons covered" by the EO). For background see executivefunctions.substack.com/p/the-clear-winner-in-tru…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Did the Supreme Court "Meet the Moment" in Trump v. Casa? Is that even the relevant question? Bob Bauer and I disagree a bit as we analyze what the Supreme Court did, and the implications.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
link here: open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/did-the-suprem…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Great piece on war powers by @JeannieSGersen. www.newyorker.com/magazine/2025/07/07/trump-congress-and-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on Trump v CASA. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-clear-winn…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
Justice Kagan for the Court in FCC v. Consumers’ Research, squarely reasserts the “intelligible principle test,” and then makes a classic legal process (Hart & Sacks) move that looks to “reasonable constitutional values.”
The “intelligible principle” test was endorsed only by a plurality in the Gundy decision in 2019 (also written by Kagan), and was sharply criticized by Justice Gorsuch. Yesterday, however, it commanded six votes, and Justice Gorsuch had to dissent again. This is an undeniable success for Justice Kagan’s view.
(Justice Kavanaugh did not participate in Gundy; his concurrence in yesterday’s case endorsed the intelligible principle test as well, with some interesting further observations. His vote was not, however, necessary to make a majority).
Overall, the libertarian-originalist critique of nondelegation looks to be well past its peak and now on the decline. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
It’s complicated. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3726262
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
So when the U.S. Supreme Court rules in the preliminary injunction stage that a party is "likely" to prevail on the merits, that's pretty much just a merits ruling, right? I mean, it's the Supreme Court ruling, there's not a lot of speculation about what happens later.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
There are many important limitations on (or potential workarounds to) the Court’s disallowance today of “universal” injunctions, including orders by the Court itself, class actions, suits brought by states, APA actions, and the ability of lower courts to grant complete relief to parties. In part for this reason, I am doubtful that the decision will do much to reduce the pressures on the Court’s emergency docket. If anything, it may increase that pressure, since it will seem intolerable in some settings to allow what may be irreparable injury to persist in some parts of the country but not others.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The points in CASA that stood out to me based on a quick first read:
1. The Court holds that Section 11 of the 1789 Judiciary Act (as embodied in contemporary successor) does not authorize universal injunctions, i.e. injunctions that apply beyond parties to non-parties.
2. But the Court potentially qualified the scope or impact of the holding by remanding on whether “complete relief” to the State plaintiffs warrants injunctive relief that could approach the functional equivalent of a universal injunction.
3. The Court rejects universal injunctions in lower courts but insists on the universality of its own “judgments and the opinions” without citation except for a concession by the Solicitor General. For explanation see executivefunctions.substack.com/p/the-solicitor-general-e…
4. There are a lot of issues left open by the opinion (on universal injunctions and substitutes) and much room for subsequent debate. See Justice Alito concurrence.
5. If you think this opinion will disincentivize or temper early Supreme Court interim order intervention (i.e. “emergency” orders) in response to litigation about executive action, read Justice Kavanaugh’s concurrence and think again.
6. This is going to be very fun to teach in federal courts class in the Fall. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Judicial supremacy buried in an opinion (CASA) about judicial modesty: "the Solicitor General represented that the Government will respect both the
judgments and the opinions of this Court." As predicted: "Sauer’s extraordinary concessions to judicial supremacy will likely feature in the Court’s opinion as a lynchpin to the demise of, or at least attenuation of, universal injunctions." executivefunctions.substack.com/p/the-solicitor-general-e… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
This statement from CASA will recur and be fought over for a long time: "A modern device need not have an exact historical match, but under Grupo Mexicano, it must have a founding-era antecedent."
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss/debate whether one can say with any certainty whether the Iran attack was unconstitutional (or constitutional), why it matters, etc. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/was-the-iran-a…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Charlie Savage
@charlie_savage
Was Trump’s Iran Attack Illegal? Presidential War Powers, Explained.
Bombing Iran without congressional authorization escalated a bipartisan trend of presidents bypassing the original intent of the Constitution.
www.nytimes.com/2025/06/23/us/politics/trump-iran-war-pow… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
Assessing the constitutionality of the Iran strikes is more difficult than you might expect, in part because of longstanding historical practice. If you want to know how we got to where we are on this issue, and why Congress is at least partly to blame, I discuss the history in my recent book.
www.amazon.com/Historical-Gloss-Foreign-Affairs-Constitut… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the constitutionality of the Iran strike. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/was-the-iran-s…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the third (and still-illegal) non-enforcement order re TikTok, which, I predict, Republicans will one day rue. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/trumps-continuing-illeg…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Sound CA9 op in support of a stay of Judge Breyer's TRO against Trump administration deployment of national guard. s3.documentcloud.org/documents/25979849/trumpguardca9stay…. Very good discussion of Martin v. Mott: significant but not absolute deference to POTUS. For background see executivefunctions.substack.com/p/martin-v-mott-enters-th…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on Trump's second and still-illegal extension of his order declining enforcement of the TikTok ban and seeking to wipe out private liability under the law, with assessment of implications. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/trumps-continu…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the possibility of the US joining in on Israel's strikes on Iran: legal authorities, Congress's role, and the politics. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-iran-confl…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The VP says: POTUS "may decide he needs to take further action to end Iranian enrichment. That decision ultimately belongs to the president."
An arresting statement given the context and the stakes, but one supported in executive branch precedents. See www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-middle-east-and-the-pres… (concluding that "Just about any conceivable circumstance in which the president (or his relevant subordinates) would think it prudent to use force in the Middle East can be justified under an Article II self-defense theory."). Only Congress can claw back its war powers. Good luck with that.
JD Vance
@JDVance
Look, I'm seeing this from the inside, and am admittedly biased towards our president (and my friend), but there's a lot of crazy stuff on social media, so I wanted to address some things directly on the Iran issue:
First, POTUS has been amazingly consistent, over 10 years, that Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon. Over the last few months, he encouraged his foreign policy team to reach a deal with the Iranians to accomplish this goal. The president has made clear that Iran cannot have uranium enrichment. And he said repeatedly that this would happen one of two ways--the easy way or the "other" way.
Second, I've seen a lot of confusion over the issue of "civilian nuclear power" and "uranium enrichment." These are distinct issues. Iran could have civilian nuclear power without enrichment, but Iran rejected that. Meanwhile, they've enriched uranium far above the level necessary for any civilian purpose. They've been found in violation of their non-proliferation obligations by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), which is hardly a rightwing organization.
It's one thing to want civilian nuclear energy. It's another thing to demand sophisticated enrichment capacity. And it's still another to cling to enrichment while simultaneously violating basic non-proliferation obligations and enriching right to the point of weapons-grade uranium.
I have yet to see a single good argument for why Iran needed to enrich uranium well above the threshold for civilian use. I've yet to see a single good argument for why Iran was justified in violating its non-proliferation obligations. I've yet to see a single good pushback against the IAEA's findings.
Meanwhile, the president has shown remarkable restraint in keeping our military's focus on protecting our troops and protecting our citizens.
He may decide he needs to take further action to end Iranian enrichment. That decision ultimately belongs to the president. And of course, people are right to be worried about foreign entanglement after the last 25 years of idiotic foreign policy.
But I believe the president has earned some trust on this issue. And having seen this up close and personal, I can assure you that he is only interested in using the American military to accomplish the American people's goals. Whatever he does, that is his focus. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@Vermeullarmine writes a very important essay on "Law-Skepticism On The New Right: A Sympathetic Critique." open.substack.com/pub/thenewdigest/p/law-skepticism-on-th…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My assessment of Martin v. Mott, which will be crucial in resolving the L.A. Deployment case and other more aggressive domestic military deployments.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Link here: open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/martin-v-mott-…
-
Post not available here, view on X
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Link here: open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/martin-v-mott-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the L.A. Deployment Ruling open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-weak-la-de…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Justice Story in Martin v Mott, 1827, after explaining the reasons for extreme deference to POTUS on the triggers for an earlier version of the Insurection Act: “It is no answer that such a power may be abused, for there is no power which is not susceptible of abuse. The remedy for this, as well as for all other official misconduct, if it should occur, is to be found in the Constitution itself. In a free government, the danger must be remote, since in addition to the high qualities which the Executive must be presumed to possess, of public virtue, and honest devotion to the public interests, the frequency of elections, and the watchfulness of the representatives of the nation carry with them all the checks which can be useful to guard against usurpation or wanton tyranny.”
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
California Sues USG and and the Marines Enter L.A.:
A longer-than-usual chat with Bob Bauer in which we disagree, a bit, on the law and politics of the USG-CA standoff. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/california-sue… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
I don't understand why Newsom is running to court. If it's his position that (1) he's commander-in-chief of California's National Guard, and (2) any valid federalizing of the state's National Guard under 10 USC 12406 needs to be via orders issued "through" him, wasn't it his option to tell the state units to stand down? He failed to exercise that authority.
Josh Gerstein
@joshgerstein
JUST IN: California sues Trump admin, says Trump's order deploying National Guard is illegal/unconstitutional. AG says protests were 'under control' until Trump announced Guard deployment.
Doc: storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.450934/…
Earlier: www.politico.com/news/2025/06/09/california-national-guar… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
Third Amendment devotees on high alert. www.sfchronicle.com/california/article/national-guard-cal…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Not sure what CA legal claim will be but a CA lawsuit seems imprudent since it is probably a loser and since Trump can improve any weaknesses in his legal position by invoking Insurrection Act provisions that require no communication or cooperation with governor.
The New York Times
@nytimes
Breaking News: California will sue President Trump over the National Guard deployment, Gov. Gavin Newsom said, as Los Angeles braced for more clashes over the immigration crackdown. Get updates. www.nytimes.com/live/2025/06/09/us/la-protests-immigratio…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss legal and other issues related to POTUS National Guard Memo and troops in LA. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/troops-in-los-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Short, sound, and straightforward legal analysis of the National Guard in LA, by @cmirasola1. Bottom line: 10 USC 12406 is the authority to federalize national guard, but the "protective power" exercised by POTUS is Article II-based. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-national-guard-in-los-an…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
This short but important OLC opinion will be getting lots of attention in next few days in connection with this sentence from potus memorandum re LA: “In addition, the Secretary of Defense may employ any other members of the regular Armed Forces as necessary to augment and support the protection of Federal functions and property in any number determined appropriate in his discretion.” www.justice.gov/file/147726/dl?inline
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
Second all that - a quality journal (yes there still are a few).
The final version of my Loper piece is in there as well.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Another great issue of Supreme Court Review. Honored to have my Trump v US piece here among so many terrific pieces. www.journals.uchicago.edu/toc/scr/2025/2024
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Excellent piece by @sorendayton on congressional power via “soft vetoes.” Pretty sure this power is still robust in some contexts (e.g. armed services comms) but it seems to have diminished in others (e.g. appropriations comms). Is that right?open.substack.com/pub/prototypingpolitics/p/dead-letter-l…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Another great issue of Supreme Court Review. Honored to have my Trump v US piece here among so many terrific pieces. www.journals.uchicago.edu/toc/scr/2025/2024
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on why Trump openly flaunts his corruption. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-money-game…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Worth a read: So-Called “Administrative Stays” in Trump 2.0, by Chris Moore. texaslawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/Moore_So-Ca…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss Trump's attack on the Federalist Society, the Emile Bove nomination to the federal court of appeals, and Trump 2.0 vision for the federal judiciary.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
LInk here: open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/trumpifying-fe…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
My take on this from yesterday.
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
There are some of those students, with the number seeming to vary by year depending on whether the Supreme Court in the prior year has ruled in ways that advance political views widely held on the right. But my sense is that it has been a small group recently, at least until late January 2025.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
This is an accurate description of trends I see among conservative students at a number of top law schools.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@Vermeullarmine on the NEMA decision: "on the best current evidence, there will likely be no Loper Bright 'revolution.'” (Which he predicted in Law's Abnegation- in 2016: "the long-term trend of judicial deference to agency legal interpretations . . . predates Chevron by many decades and . . . would persist in de facto form even if Chevron were overruled de jure") open.substack.com/pub/thenewdigest/p/yes-there-will-be-no…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the weaknesses in the Trump tariff rulings and the extraordinary importance, underemphasized in those rulings, of the major questions doctrine to the legality of the Trump IEEPA tariffs.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
No. This is one of the most blatantly unlawful acts by the Administration. But since no one has sued (and perhaps no one can sue), very few are paying attention, and the administration has offered no legal defense.
Charles C. W. Cooke
@charlescwcooke
Has the Trump administration released any sort of explanation—however cynical or tangential—for why it’s not enforcing the TikTok law that Congress passed and the Supreme Court upheld 9-0, or is it just . . . not doing it?
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss Trump v. Wilcox, the Supreme Court’s important emergency docket ruling on Presidential removal power, including what it means for Humphrey’s Executor, and other potential short- and long-term consequences. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-supreme-co…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Roundup, featuring developments in the evolving South Sudan deportations case, an Alien Enemies Act ruling, and more. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-rou…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Elucidating analysis of the issues and stakes in Trump v. CASA by Adam White. thedispatch.com/article/nationwide-injunctions-vs-nationw…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Roundup, featuring two Alien Enemies Act rulings, two announcements from the DOJ, and commentary from @NicholasBednar and Erwin Chemerinsky. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-rou…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
The proposition that the Court does not have rightful authority to enjoin a particular action by the Trump administration does not imply that the Trump action is lawful. So, for example, it is entirely coherent to agree with the Alito/CT dissent last Friday on Venezuelan detainees and also believe (as I do) that the enjoined Trump actions are blatantly unlawful.
So if you're going to condemn the Court on this one, you should also take a hard look at whether you also think the Trump administration deserves condemnation. It's not an either-or. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Interesting and IMO fair assessment, mainly, but not only, about "the politics of higher education in Trump II" as revealed in the McMahon letter. www.compactmag.com/article/does-trump-want-to-destroy-har…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Jonathan H. Adler
@jadler1969
For those that don't already know, some news.
law.wm.edu/news/stories/2025/jonathan-adler-to-join-the-w… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Thank you Orin!
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
You're reading @jacklgoldsmith, right?
executivefunctions.substack.com/p/the-solicitor-general-e… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Sounds like WH doesn't think the argument went so well. Or maybe it did not like SG Sauer's pledge, over and over, to “respect the opinions and the judgments of the Supreme Court.” See my analysis: executivefunctions.substack.com/p/the-solicitor-general-e…
Donald J. Trump
@realDonaldTrump
THE SUPREME COURT IS BEING PLAYED BY THE RADICAL LEFT LOSERS, WHO HAVE NO SUPPORT, THE PUBLIC HATES THEM, AND THEIR ONLY HOPE IS THE INTIMIDATION OF THE COURT, ITSELF. WE CAN’T LET THAT HAPPEN TO OUR COUNTRY!
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
And Bauer and I discuss the details of the oral argument and my post as well. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-birthright…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My quick views on yesterday's oral argument: Sauer's amazing embrace of judicial supremacy. But can the Court trust him? open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-solicitor-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My quick views on yesterday's oral argument: Sauer's amazing embrace of judicial supremacy. But can the Court trust him? open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-solicitor-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
As predicted here, executivefunctions.substack.com/p/solicitor-general-john-…, the Justices ask Sauer "whether the government will act in good faith toward its orders in courts below, ... In short, May 15 may be the first time an administration official is held to general public account for the administration’s actions toward federal courts."
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Richard L. Garwin, a Creator of the Hydrogen Bomb, Dies at 97. A great, brilliant, and immensely thoughtful man. RIP. www.nytimes.com/2025/05/14/science/richard-l-garwin-dead.…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the administration’s habeas trial balloons, the legal issues and possible strategic aims underlying the comments, and how this all fits into the administration’s larger attacks on the courts. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-anatomy-of…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
I'm looking forward to testifying before a committee of the British House of Lords today about how countries can ensure that there is sufficient review and transparency of non-binding international agreements.
committees.parliament.uk/event/24139 -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
Bench Memos Turns 20! www.nationalreview.com/bench-memos/bench-memos-turns-20/
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the Stephen Miller habeas troll.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/trolling-about… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss reports of extensive corrupt conduct in the Trump administration, the innovations that facilitated the corruption, the reasons for the muted public reaction, what might generate a stronger reaction, reform possibilities, and more. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/corruption-in-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Looking forward to May 12, 3 PM EDT, talk w/ @carnegieendow Prez Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar & @aarondmiller2 on #carnegieconnects to discuss the impacts of the Trump Administration's unprecedented expansion of power over the judiciary. RSVP to tune in: carnegieendowment.org/events/2025/04/trump-and-the-courts…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
👏👏👏👏👏👏
The University of Chicago
@UChicago
Prof. Adam Chilton has been appointed dean of @UChicagoLaw, effective July 1. A renowned legal scholar, Chilton said it’s an “extraordinary honor” to lead the school where he’s served as a faculty member since 2014.
Learn more: news.uchicago.edu/story/adam-chilton-appointed-dean-unive… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Good points and underlying opinions worth reading
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
It's the longstanding position of DOJ's Office of Legal Counsel, memorialized in an opinion by yours truly, that the president's authority to name *acting* United States Attorneys operates alongside, and independent of, his authority to name *interim* U.S. Attorneys. 1/
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Setting aside legal issues in the current dispute, on which I believe Harvard has the better of the argument, the future funding cutoff for Harvard was both predictable and predicted. As @Vermeullarmine and I wrote eight years ago: “Conservative politicians and their constituents hear, on the one hand, that government owes universities a continuance of largesse and, on the other, that conservatives are ignorant, unworthy or corrupt. This sounds suspiciously like special pleading by an intellectual elite that wants to indulge in social criticism at the expense of the criticized, in both figurative and literal senses. Universities have become distinctively sectarian, limiting their appeal to federal elected officials who do not share those sectarian views and who are less and less willing to pay the universities to trumpet them.” www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/elite-colleges-are-making…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
In this post, @jacklgoldsmith, @oonahathaway, and I assess the legality and transparency of the recent U.S.-Ukraine minerals agreement and additional future implementing agreements. One takeaway is that U.S. citizens should not have to depend on disclosures by other countries in order to know what the U.S. government is doing in their name.
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-u.s.-ukraine-agreement--… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss my oped this morning in NYT: "We Have to Deal With Presidential Power" (links below)
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
op-ed: www.nytimes.com/2025/05/05/opinion/trump-obama-biden-pres…
Discussion with Bob: executivefunctions.substack.com/p/runaway-presidencies -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Damon Linker
@DamonLinker
My latest essay in the NYT is about a tradition of right-wing thinking that advocates enhanced executive power and how its arguments are now being used to justify Trump's unprecedented power-grabs. You'll find a gift link in the following tweet.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Roundup, featuring a ruling on the merits of Trump's Alien Enemies Act deportations, a new government application in the Supreme Court, commentary from @chrisgeidner and @IlyaSomin, and more. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-rou…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Roundup, featuring a deadlocked vote in the Senate on Trump's tariffs, a survey of historians on Trump 2.0, and @pbump's criticism of the House Oversight Committee for its lack of focus on Trump's business ties. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-rou…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Executive Functions is hiring a paid full- or part-time executive editor position starting this spring/summer.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/executive-func… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
The Rapoport Rules - on disagreement, fairness, decency, respect. @jacklgoldsmith
casssunstein.substack.com/p/the-rapoport-rules -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the firing of Bill Burck, one of Harvard's key lawyers, from his position as outside ethics advisor of the Trump Organization, and other developments in the Harvard-USG case. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/trump-organiza…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Roundup, featuring an order to return another individual deported under the AEA, commentary from @steve_vladeck, @tphillips, John Bessler, and @BillGalston, and more. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-rou…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Executive Functions is hiring Summer and Fall interns. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/executive-func…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss how courts are reacting to Trump administration gamesmanship, with special attention to the Supreme Court's weekend order in the Alien Enemies Act matter. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-courts-rea…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My thoughts on SG Sauer, weekend AEA order, the Abrego Garcia case, & why the 5-15 Birthright Citizenship argument "may be the 1st time an administration official is held to general public account for the administration’s actions toward federal courts"
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/solicitor-gene… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Roundup, featuring Judge Wilkinson's opinion in the Abrego Garcia case, scheduled oral argument in the birthright citizenship cases, much commentary, and more. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-rou…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Katherine Mims Crocker
@ProfKMCrocker
For those interested in Judge Wilkinson's approach to cases asking courts to review executive-branch actions, @jacklgoldsmith & I (who both clerked for Wilkinson) published an essay about just that last fall. Read it here ➡️ papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4968442. Bottom line here ⬇️
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
WILKINSON, Circuit Judge, with whom KING and THACKER, Circuit Judges, join:
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss Wilkinson’s CA4 opinion and the Boasberg contempt opinion. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/wilkinsons-imp…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My interview (taped Monday) w/ @DouthatNYT on Trump administration's legal strategy against Congress, courts, and institutions, how the courts will and should respond, and what it means for executive power generally, in this presidency and the next.
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/17/opinion/ross-douthat-interesti… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
@oonahathaway, @jacklgoldsmith, and I have a new post out discussing how transparency rules enacted by Congress in 2022 may help reveal the terms of the agreement that the United States has made with El Salvador concerning the detention of migrants, and whether those terms contradict representations that the administration has made to the courts in the Abrego Garcia litigation.
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-new-transparency-rules-a… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My former boss Judge Wilkinson, joined by judges King and Thacker, issues a strongly but respectfully worded decision denying USG request for emergency relief in the Abrego Garcia case. storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.ca4.178400/g…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Thanks for the great conversation.
Ross Douthat
@Douthat60
Interesting Times, Episode 2: A conversation with @jacklgoldsmith about the Trump executive power revolution:
www.nytimes.com/2025/04/17/opinion/ross-douthat-interesti… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Excellent contrarian analysis of Trump v. U.S. by @RichardMRe.
open.substack.com/pub/dividedargument/p/trump-v-us-anti-c… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A recent tribute by me to the much-missed Bill Stuntz: "Citizen of Heaven and Harvard: A Remembrance of Bill Stuntz." papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5219440
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Roundup: a discovery order in the Abrego Garcia case, injunctions against the Trump administration, commentary from Bob Bauer, @JonathanHafetz, @IlyaSomin, @steve_vladeck, @GrahamDavidA, and @CassSunstein, and more. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-rou…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Jeannie Suk Gersen
@JeannieSGersen
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Robert P. George
@McCormickProf
Every single one of us has a profound interest in government at every level strictly observing due process of law. All of us should be deeply concerned by any violation of anyone's due process rights, whether in criminal or administrative matters. We might like what government can more efficiently accomplish by disregarding proper legal procedures today. But we will rue the day we licensed such governmental misconduct when, tomorrow, a different government disregards legal procedures to achieve quickly results we abhor. The government in power, whatever it is, will not always be in power. There will "arise a pharaoh who remembereded not Joseph." If we want due process for ourselves and in defense of things we cherish and believe in, we must insist on due process for everyone.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer: "Burck’s representation of Harvard suggests, as does the text of Harvard’s response to the administration and the post-publication amendment to the Garber public letter, that the university has not ruled out a negotiation of some kind" open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/harvards-compl…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Great book
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
Prof Ashley Deeks has a new book on AI and national security: “The Double Black Box” www.amazon.com/Double-Black-Box-Intelligence-Accountabili…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Roundup featuring updates on the Abrego Garcia case, commentary from Mary McCord and @GrahamDavidA, and more. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-rou…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Shalev Roisman
@Shalev_Roisman
I have an essay out in the @HarvLRev blog on "President Trump in the Era of Exclusive Powers."
The basic claim is that we can understand Trump 2.0 as an exercise in taking the Supreme Court's recent separation of powers jurisprudence at its word.
harvardlawreview.org/blog/2025/04/president-trump-in-the-… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
Robert Bork to Alex Bickel, on dreading a return to Yale Law School's faculty politics:
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Roundup featuring updates on the Abrego Garcia case, more on the Alien Enemies Act, and much commentary. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-rou…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss how the Sup Ct is doing vis a vis Trump on emergency orders docket, the significance of it order in Noem v. Garcia, and the latest on the Trump attacks on law firms (and why the administration wins even when it loses in court). open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/cautious-but-f…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I've been asked by a few people why the Supreme Court Is cowering before Trump on the shadow docket. Answer: It isn't. My explanation here. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-supreme-co…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
Some Observations on Strong Supreme Court Ruling Requiring Trump Administration to ‘Facilitate’ Return of... www.nationalreview.com/bench-memos/some-observations-on-s…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
In a world of separation of parties, not powers, the bond market remains one of the few effective checks and balances.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Stephen E. Sachs
@StephenESachs
Clearly, law schools should hold more events on the wrongness of Erie!
www.law.edu/news-and-events/2025/04/2025-0408-USNews.html
Constitution and Catholic Intellectual Tradition
@CIT_CUA
Join @Harvard_Law Prof. @StephenESachs for a discussion highlighting how Erie Railroad Co. v. Tompkins affected the American understanding of the nature of law, the doctrinal implications of that change, and the merits of reconsidering Erie.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the Supreme Court’s emergency order ruling in the Alien Enemy Act case, and more. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/deportation-li…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
Very savvy of Chief Justice Roberts to get AG Bondi to celebrate a ruling that ensures individual habeas hearings for all deportees. www.nationalreview.com/bench-memos/a-solomonic-act-of-jud…
Attorney General Pamela Bondi
@AGPamBondi
This is a landmark victory for the rule of law.
Liberal district judges thought they could control President Trump’s foreign policy. They cannot.
We will continue to deport violent terrorsts, and we are going to make America safe again. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
As a formalist, I can't say that I'm fond of efforts at judicial statesmanship. But there is a certain political brilliance in per curiam opinion (which was surely written by Chief Justice Roberts).
www.nationalreview.com/bench-memos/a-solomonic-act-of-jud… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
So much to say about the Supreme Court's emergency order in the Alien Enemies Act case. One thing: The dissent rightly questions the truncated process behind merits ruling on the exclusivity of habeas. But the Court did the same thing with its consequential merits rulings on judicial review. Detainees get judicial review on "interpretation and constitutionality" of the AEA and also "must receive notice after the date of this order that they are subject to removal under the Act," and the "notice must be afforded within a reasonable time and in such a manner as will allow them to actually seek habeas relief in the proper venue before such removal occurs." This important ruling too "creates new law on the emergency orders docket" (Sotomayor, in dissent), or at least clarifies massively important and complicated issues in detainees favor that the USG had at various stages and in various ways contested.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Amazing how pervasively the shadow docket permeates the news.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
I might be wrong, but seems to me that per curiam's declaration that detainees "must be afforded [notice] within a reasonable time and in such a manner as will allow them to actually seek habeas relief in the proper venue before such removal occurs" rejects much more aggressive position that Administration has taken.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Here is the essence of the Wilkinson view.
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
Reagan appointee J. Harvie Wilkinson joins denial, construes district-court order as calling for US government to “facilitate” return of alien mistakenly deported.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on "The Dangerous Legacy of the Adams Prosecution: The Department of Justice’s radical revision of the rulebook on federal prosecutions" open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-dangerous-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Outstanding paper on how Trump team is "asserting unilateral authority to condition, delay, cancel, or otherwise disrupt federal obligations and expenditures without regard to longstanding legal understandings and norms." Learned a lot. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5202418
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My arguments against Edward Martin's confirmation for U.S. Attorney in DC. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-senate-and…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
An oldie but a goody, relevant to Trump's third-term bid. supreme.findlaw.com/legal-commentary/the-case-for-a-gore-…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
The Rule of Law means that people you don’t like, even terrible people, are entitled to the benefit of existing laws.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Massive roundup of executive power developments today.
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Roundup, featuring several developments in the Alien Enemies Act case and in the challenges to Trump's removal of members of executive branch boards, commentary about these cases, and a whole lot more. executivefunctions.substack.com/publish/posts/detail/1602…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Outstanding 40K foot view on where we are, from Ben Wittes. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-situation--an-attempted-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the latest on the Trump attacks on law firms and the legal profession. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/attacks-on-law…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Christopher Landau
@ChrisLandauUSA
Today I’m grateful to all three branches of our Federal Government. Thank you @POTUS @realDonaldTrump for nominating me to work with @SecRubio to make our beloved country safer, stronger, and more prosperous. 🇺🇸 Thank you U.S. Senate for confirming me. 🇺🇸 And thank you Justice Clarence Thomas for swearing me in as the 23rd Deputy Secretary of State. 🇺🇸
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Many people have asked me, in light of Signal mess, how POTUS has the authority to attack the Houthis. What about Congress? The short answer is that the executive branch has claimed massively broad authority to use force under Article II w/o Congressional authorization, and Congress and the courts have basically gone along. On authority for offensive force, see this, www.lawfaremedia.org/article/olcs-meaningless-national-in…; on defensive force, see this, www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-middle-east-and-the-pres….
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Roundup, featuring a busy day in the Alien Enemies Act deportation case, commentary from @J_A_Hillman, Aziz Huq, @tylerblindley, Morgan Bronson, Wesley White, @AWeissmann_, and @DebPearlstein, and more. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-rou…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on Paul Weiss's Deal With Donald Trump: "it is hard to imagine that the damage done to the profession by this deal won’t prove worse than the threat from the federal government that it was meant to contain." open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/paul-weisss-de…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Roundup, featuring the conflict between President Trump and law firms, a new DHS policy terminating legal status for certain migrants, and commentary from @judgeluttig, Bob Bauer, and Ilya Somin. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-rou…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Big George Foreman (with notes on Muhammed Ali and Joe Frazier). @jacklgoldsmith @GeorgeForeman @trboxing @BoxingNewsED
casssunstein.substack.com/p/big-george-foreman -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
The “Bush DOJ lawyer” here is my former Office of Legal Counsel colleague (and former Clarence Thomas law clerk) John Yoo.
John is a champion of a robust vision of executive power. It’s remarkable to see MAGA world’s attack in the replies.
Fox News
@FoxNews
Bush DOJ lawyer warns Trump admin against 'terrible mistake' in judicial standoff www.foxnews.com/politics/bush-doj-lawyer-warns-trump-admi…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The authoritative Sam Bray weighs in with terrific points about the current universal injunction spats, in part in response to what I wrote this morning.
blog.dividedargument.com/p/whats-new-and-whats-not-new-wi… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I discuss the (amazing) Paul Weiss “settlement” with the White House, and the possible validity of the administration’s attacks on universal injunctions. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/paul-weiss-and…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Thoughts on universal injunctions against Trump Admin. There is something to the complaints about UIs, and may be something to bias charge, though neither is limited to Trump admin, and bias charge must be discounted by legally careless Trump actions. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/problems-with-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
insightful analysis by Christopher Caldwell. www.compactmag.com/article/trump-has-embraced-the-machine…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
New feature on Executive Functions: Bob Bauer and I do a quick video chat--12 minutes on Boasberg case, the administration’s strategy in court, Institute of Peace story, and whether Trump is winning in battle with court. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/executive-func…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Two cheers for Thayerism.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My thoughts on the Alien Enemies Act, DOJ v. Boasberg, Trump v. Roberts, and where we are. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-alien-enem…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on the Trump administration's attacks on law firms. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/donald-trumps-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Fun discussion with my brilliant former student @oren_cass .
Commonplace
@commonplc
As new lawsuits aim to slow down Trump's agenda, many Americans are wondering: how much power does the president rightfully have?
@jacklgoldsmith joins @oren_cass on the @AmerCompass Podcast to talk everything from impoundment to "the unitary executive." commonplace.org/2025/03/14/the-unitary-executive-with-jac… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
In light of the Biden autopen pardon issue, there's lots of interesting history/analysis in this 2005 OLC opinion ruling that POTUS can sign a bill "by directing a subordinate to affix the President’s signature to such a bill, for example by autopen." www.justice.gov/file/494411/dl?inline
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The Supreme Court temporizes in a big way on emergency docket, DEI initiatives get breathing space, administration attacks another law firm, Trump's DOJ speech, the ACLU's pre-enforcement challenge to Alien Enemies Act removals, and more.
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring a leisurely briefing schedule in the birthright citizenship case, another EO targeting a law firm, commentary from @steve_vladeck, @JeffreyToobin, and @IgnatiusPost, and more. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup: a birthright citizenship filing, reinstatement of federal workers, commentary from Samuel Bray, @IlyaSomin, @JoshMBlackman, @Jed_Rubenfeld, @VolokhC, @JaneYakowitz, @noor_ham12, and David McKean, and more. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Honored to be giving a Keynote Address at the Society for Benefit-Cost Analysis in DC today. (Noting that BCA has a slight feel, just these days, of A Canticle for Leibowitz, which is highly recommended.) @Caseyco231 @jacklgoldsmith
www.benefitcostanalysis.org/2025-annual-conference -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Lots going on, including four important court rulings, Trump GTMO transfer, a planned Trump DOJ rule of law speech, and commentary by Bauer, Bray, Adler, Berger.
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring a new window into DOGE's authority, the reinstatement of another fired official, Perkins Coie's preliminary win in court, much commentary, and more (first three stories below). executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring a ruling on a govt motion related to the birthright citizenship EO, a hearing in the Mahmoud Khalil case, commentary from @cmirasola1 and @JoshMBlackman, and more (first three stories below). executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on how Trump's elimination of conflict of interest rules leads, beyond the lining of pockets, to the expansion of executive power. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/corruption-and…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
I'm only now learning that the Court granted an Erie case (a Hanna / Shady Grove case) yesterday!
www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/berk-v-choy/ -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring another development in the foreign assistance case, a ruling on DOGE transparency, commentary from @JeffreyToobin and @GrahamDavidA, and more (first three stories below). executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring a Trump admin motion for a stay of a nationwide injunction blocking implementation of Trump's refugee policies, consequences of Trump v. U.S., and commentary from @CassSunstein. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring more ousters at DOJ, a repeat of the Trump 1.0 pardons process, commentary from @joshgerstein, @emptywheel, David Post, and Erwin Chemerinsky, and more (first three stories below). executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Dan Epps
@danepps
So… @WilliamBaude and I are extending the @DividedArgument brand to a new medium: a blog/substack with a bigger stable of contributors. My first post, with reactions to the Smith & Wesson oral argument, is up!
blog.dividedargument.com/p/reactions-to-the-smith-and-wesson -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring the end of the Hampton Dellinger case, the district court's next move in the ping ponging foreign assistance case, commentary from @S_R_Anders, @jadler1969, and @JoshMBlackman, and more. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Nicholas Bagley
@nicholas_bagley
For those following the USAID litigation, below are a handful of pieces (including a couple from me) to help you wrap your head around it.
First up, @jacklgoldsmith on the Supreme Court’s temporizing on its shadow docket: open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/supreme-court-… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Reflections on yesterday's two important emergency order decisions. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/supreme-court-…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring the Supreme Court's foreign assistance ruling, commentary from @jacklgoldsmith and @NicholasBednar, a new Trump timeline from @rgoodlaw and Audrey Balliette, and more (first three stories below). executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Supreme Court's first emergency order on Trump 2.0--denying relief from district court order requiring administration to disburse foreign assistance funds. s3.documentcloud.org/documents/25551544/24a831-order-2.pdf
My primer on what emergency orders are and why important. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/supreme-court-emergency…
More tomorrow. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My effort at a very simple primer on emergency orders and why they will be so important in Trump 2.0. Part II later this week. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/supreme-court-…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring the D.C. U.S. Atty's reported efforts to indict Sen. Schumer, commentary from @kateashaw1 on Musk and the Appointments Clause, and more (first two stories below). executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
Fear of Balancing, by me, forthcoming in the Supreme Court Review:
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Executive Functions Roundup: CFPB lives, Rubio bypasses Congress, new GTMO lawsuit, and commentary by Bauer, @IlyaSomin, @Vermeullarmine, @jadler1969 and @JoshMBlackman. Sign up to receive by email here. docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeDK95_5qU5EoRQkI3idsnZL…
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/executive-func… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Rachel Barkow
@RachelBarkow
I highlight six key criminal law cases that should be overturned on originalist grounds in my book, Justice Abandoned: How the Supreme Court Ignored the Constitution and Enabled Mass Incarceration. Will the Court take a principled approach even if the outcome is a liberal one?
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
More evidence of a very aggressive non-enforcement authority being asserted by the Trump administration. I wrote about this here executivefunctions.substack.com/p/the-presidents-favorite… and here papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5162059.
Treasury Department
@USTreasury
The Treasury Department is announcing today that, with respect to the Corporate Transparency Act, not only will it not enforce any penalties or fines associated with the beneficial ownership information reporting rule under the existing regulatory deadlines…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A new paper: The Presidency After Trump v. United States. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5162059. Forthcoming, Supreme Court Review.
Comments welcome. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on Trump using DOJ to intimidate Congress. @Exec_Functions
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-trump-admi… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I had forgotten until this morning about Justice Alito’s dissent in United States v. Texas, and about the Biden’s administration’s position on non-enforcement of federal law, both of which are quite relevant to much of the Trump non-enforcement program. The Court held that plaintiffs lacked standing to challenge the Biden administration’s alleged non-compliance with a statutory duty to enforce certain federal immigration laws. Justice Alito did not like this ruling. In his dissent he said:
“At argument, the Solicitor General was asked whether it is the position of the United States that the Constitution does not allow any party to challenge a President’s decision not to enforce laws he does not like. What would happen, the Solicitor General was asked, if a President chose not to enforce the environmental laws or the labor laws? Would the Constitution bar an injured party from bringing suit? She responded:
‘That’s correct under this Court’s precedent, but the framers intended political checks in that circumstance. You know, if—if an administration did something that extreme and said we’re just not going to enforce the law at all, then the President would be held to account by the voters, and Congress has tools at its disposal as well.” Tr. of Oral Arg. 50 (emphasis added).’ …
[N]othing in our precedents even remotely supports this grossly inflated conception of “executive Power,” U. S. Const., Art. II, §1, which seriously infringes the “legislative Powers” that the Constitution grants to Congress, Art. I, §1. At issue here is Congress’s authority to control immigration, and “[t]his Court has repeatedly emphasized that ‘over no conceivable subject is the legislative power of Congress more complete than it is over’ the admission of aliens.” Fiallo v. Bell, 430 U. S. 787, 792 (1977). In the exercise of that power, Congress passed and President Clinton signed a law that commands the detention and removal of aliens who have been convicted of certain particularly dangerous crimes. The Secretary of Homeland Security, however, has instructed his agents to disobey this legislative command and instead follow a different policy that is more to his liking. And the Court now says that no party injured by this policy is allowed to challenge it in court.” -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup: the next round in the battle over the admin's effort to fire Hampton Dellinger, more demotions for DOJ prosecutors, commentary from @S_R_Anders and @ElenaChachko, and more (first three stories below). executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring two orders that permit the Trump admin to move forward with the firing of federal workers, commentary from @steve_vladeck, @JoshMBlackman, and @DavidAFrench, and more (first four stories below). executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring the Chief's administrative stay of an order for the govt to disburse foreign aid, helpful commentary from @NicholasBednar and @chris_d_moore, and more (see the first three stories below). executivefunctions.substack.com/p/executive-functions-mor…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Very timely piece by @chris_d_moore explaining "administrative stays" and how and why they are often abused today by district courts reviewing Trump administration actions. "So-Called “Administrative Stays” in Trump 2.0"
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Judges are growing increasingly "frustrat[ed]" (as Judge Ali put it) with the cat-and-mouse "compliance" games of the Trump administration. Judge AliKhan's denial of a "presumption of good faith" by the administration is especially noteworthy.
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring a tough day in multiple courts for the Trump administration, a named DOGE administrator, commentary from @CassSunstein, @jadler1969, and @EBHarrington, and more (the first four stories below). executivefunctions.substack.com/p/morning-roundup-d9c
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring a tough day in multiple courts for the Trump administration, a named DOGE administrator, commentary from @CassSunstein, @jadler1969, and @EBHarrington, and more (the first four stories below). executivefunctions.substack.com/p/morning-roundup-d9c
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Thank you Bob it was a fun conversation.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This was an extremely illuminating conversation. Jack really knows the territory--by virtue of both his scholarship and his past government service--and he lays out the legal and normative issues clearly. His Substack, Executive Functions, provides great Trump chaos coverage, btw
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My long (2 or so hour) conversation with the great @robertwrighter about Trump 2.0 and the the law. (Second half paywalled on Bob's substack.)
www.youtube.com/watch?v=GAZNcxpxZc0 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My long (2 or so hour) conversation with the great @robertwrighter about Trump 2.0 and the the law. (Second half paywalled on Bob's substack.)
www.youtube.com/watch?v=GAZNcxpxZc0 -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring limits on DOGE, more in the Trump-AP saga, helpful commentary from @AndrewCMcCarthy, @steve_vladeck, and @AdamUnikowsky (just the first five stories below). executivefunctions.substack.com/p/morning-roundup-dbb
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
An explanation of the extraordinary mechanisms put in place to ensure that Trump Is the Law for the Executive Branch.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/trump-is-the-l… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
On OLC website (but for how long?), in contrast w POTUS/AG directives: OLC “provide[s] advice based on its best understanding of what the law requires--not...an advocate's defense of...contemplated action or position proposed by ... the Administration" www.justice.gov/olc/page/file/1511836/dl?inline
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Morning Roundup open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/morning-roundu…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Ready today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring USAID firings, Elon Musk's check-in with federal workers, and other news and commentary. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/morning-roundup-557
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Eight items in Morning Roundup (w/ commentary): Sup Ct Dellinger order, Ho delay re Adams, Trump DOD firings, four judicial rulings, and @kyledcheney on DOGE. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/morning-roundu…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Read today's Executive Functions Morning Roundup, featuring primary sources, news developments, and commentary related to executive power. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/morning-roundup-28e
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Morning Roundup of executive power primary documents, news, and commentary. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/morning-roundu…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer on the "Business Model" Presidency open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/its-just-busin…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Bob explains how President Trump’s repudiation of government ethics is key to his “business model” presidency. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/its-just-business-and-i…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A different and different kind of very helpful overview. www.nytimes.com/2025/02/20/upshot/trump-executive-orders-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
IMO this, by @TheEconomist, is the best and most sober analysis of the first month of Trump 2.0--and not because it quotes me. The analogy to FDR is especially instructive, since that is what Trump 2.0 thinks the model is. www.economist.com/briefing/2025/02/20/donald-trump-is-a-r…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Grateful to The Economist for a chance to examine Trump 2.0's first month.
www.economist.com/by-invitation/2025/02/20/donald-trump-i…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The Supreme Court is "the main institution standing between Mr Trump and lawlessness. This calls to mind Aesop’s fable of the old man, exhausted by age and toil, who wished for death but when Death appeared quickly changed his mind and asked only for help carrying his load."
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A useful daily roundup with links of executive power primary documents, news, and commentary. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/morning-roundu…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Robert P. George
@McCormickProf
Congratulations to my friend and former Princeton colleague @kewhittington
on launching his new Center for Academic Freedom and Free Speech at Yale Law School. An important development in American higher education.
yaledailynews.com/blog/2025/02/18/yale-law-conference-rea… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Poof! The Independent Agencies Are No Longer Independent. @jacklgoldsmith @Atul_Gawande
casssunstein.substack.com/p/poof-the-independent-agencies… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
Link to EO here: www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/02/ensuring-…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Executive Functions
@Exec_Functions
The "Ensuring Accountability" EO asserts directive power over all agencies but defines "employees" in accord with 5 USC 2105 and limits the requirement to conform to POTUS/AG legal interpretation to "employees." Why?
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and me on The White House Counsel and the Adams Affair. "the Adams episode implicates a major fault line running through this administration with the root of the problem not at 950 Pennsylvania Avenue, but rather at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue." open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-white-hous…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Nine too-quick reactions to the SG’s request for emergency relief in the Supreme Court concerning the TRO that the district court issued against the government to prevent President Trump from removing Hampton Dellinger as the single head of the Office of Special Counsel. It is an important moment. utexas.app.box.com/s/h0m91y7nesdrww7hty6mg24czcl3tukg
First, this appears to be the opening salvo in the scores of emergency orders fights ahead that will determine the short-to-medium-term fate of the Trump program.
Second, despite the atmospherics about not complying with judicial decisions, the Acting SG, consistent with Trump’s remark about judicial compliance on Tuesday, says: “The Executive Branch takes seriously its constitutional duty to comply with the orders of Article III courts.” (This came in response to a question about compliance before the district court.) “Constitutional duty” is a very strong phrase—I do not recall such a strong acknowledgment of judicial supremacy from the SG’s Office (which doesn’t mean they do not exist). The Acting SG understands the seriousness and stakes of this issue. (Technically the SG committed only to following judicial orders, which almost all departmentalists agree with even if they think the executive need not comply with underlying constitutional interpretations. See executivefunctions.substack.com/p/can-trump-defy-the-supr…)
Third, the growing Caesarian rhetoric and administration (and administration-adjacent) atmospherics about non-compliance with decisions, impeachment of judges due to their decisions, etc., will not, as the Acting SG realizes, help the Trump administration before the Court.
Fourth, in a normal atmosphere, I would say that the Acting SG has a pretty strong case for the Court to “vacate the temporary restraining order issued by” the district court, for reasons Judge Katsas states in dissent in the court of appeals. I think Katsas is probably right about the TRO, primarily (as Katsas argues) because the government’s likelihood of success on the merits is high under Seila Law and Collins, and because of the nature of relief issued here, despite the statutory for-cause protection.
Fifth, I also agree with Katsas’ dissent that the TRO should be immediately appealable. See e.g. Nixon v. Fitzgerald, which said that “serious and unsettled issues” that “alleg[e] a threatened breach of essential Presidential prerogatives under the separation of powers” could be appealed on an interlocutory basis.
Sixth, I have not studied all the decisions closely enough to have a firm judgment, but at least a few of the Trump 2.0 era district court “administrative stays,” including the one here, seem like stretches. The behavior of the district courts in this respect reminds me a tad of the norm-breaking reactions by courts to Trump’s norm-breaking in February 2017. www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2017/10/will-donald-…
Seventh, the SG cites Trump v. U.S. right up front: “Congress cannot act on, and courts cannot examine, the President’s actions on subjects within his ‘conclusive and preclusive’ constitutional authority”—including “the President’s ‘unrestricted power of removal’ with respect to ‘executive officers of the United States whom [the President] has appointed.’” It is POTUS’s favorite decision, on many dimensions having nothing to do with immunity, as I explained last Monday. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/the-presidents-favorite…
Eighth, although the Supreme Court will of course be watching the anti-court atmospherics, I hope it bases the issuance of relief (or not) in response to emergency orders requests strictly on the basis of legal principles concerning the requested relief, which includes an assessment of the actual merits of the case. The Court cannot help but be influenced by the atmospherics. The Acting SG’s statement about compliance is essentially a request to the Court to disregard the atmospherics. IMO the best strategy over the course of the scores of Trump cases coming to the Court—especially the emergency order requests—is for the Court to play it straight on the law as much as possible.
Ninth, when the atmospherics spill over one iota into actual noncomplicance with judicial orders, then the government's actions in light of the atmospherics should and will inform emergency orders and every other element of judicial review. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Trevor Morrison and @RickPildes -- "This Is What the Courts Can Do if Trump Defies Them" www.nytimes.com/2025/02/16/opinion/what-if-trump-defies-c…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
"Supreme Court’s 1-17 decision upholding the [TikTok ban] initially appeared to signal the end of TikTok's presence in America. Yet what followed was a remarkable sequence of events that has effectively nullified the law." @ARozenshtein www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-tiktok-ban-withers-away
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Jonathan H. Adler
@jadler1969
Under unitary executive theory, the President may order subordinates to take specific (lawful) actions, but it does not mean that the orders are themselves honorable or proper, and there is no dishonor in resigning in lieu of following an improper or dishonestly justified order.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Weighing in on departmentalism. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/can-trump-defy…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Note that the William A. Burck who represents Adams in this mess appears to be the same lawyer--a managing partner of Quinn, Emmanuel--who is "outside Ethics Advisor" to the Trump Organization's faux conflict of interest policy. www.nytimes.com/2025/02/13/nyregion/adams-lawyers-justice…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Here is the conflict of interest policy: reason.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/2025-Trump-Conflict…
Here is an analysis that concludes that the policy allows "foreign governments, and ... foreign government-connected enterprises, to influence POTUS and to enrich him while in office" executivefunctions.substack.com/p/the-meme-coin-is-just-t… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
To state the very obvious: The Supreme Court's emergency orders rulings will determine the fate of a large chunk of the short-term success or failure of the Trump 2.0 program.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Dan Epps
@danepps
NEW PAPER: It's the 100th Anniversary of the Judiciary Act of 1925—a perfect day to drop my and @marinklevy's "Judicial Reform from the Inside Out," prepared for @NotreDameLRev's great symposium honoring that anniversary.
Check it out! papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5136328 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Jody Freeman and Sharon Jacobs apply their prescient "structural deregulation" idea to illuminate Trump 2.0. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/president-trump-s-campaign-o…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Good analysis by @EdWhelanEPPC . www.nationalreview.com/bench-memos/on-the-rule-of-law-and…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
New on Executive Functions: Bauer, Why is the Trump Administration Weakening "Foreign Influence" Enforcement? Linking together the AG's Foreign Influence Memo, the FCPA EO, the "ethics" rules governing POTUS and Trump Org, etc. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/why-is-the-tru…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Outstanding essay by Yuval Levin. The answer to the question is: oppose it. www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/deeper-question-nih-g…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Byron York
@ByronYork
Indeed, the Trump response goes into some detail about how the administration is complying with the order.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Two points about this argument. First, it is pure Trump v. U.S., as I described here. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/the-presidents-favorite…. Second, at this point this is an argument that the court got it wrong, and is not a defiance of a court order.
Byron York
@ByronYork
Filed last night, the Trump administration answers Judge Engelmayer: storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.636609/…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
CONSTITUTIONAL VERTIGO. No, that is not a comment, but the title of a long law review article, by Sai Prakash and yours truly, to be appearing in @VirginiaLawRev. Years in coming; about big constitutional change, not the current moment (though it might come up). @jacklgoldsmith
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Two points about this argument. First, it is pure Trump v. U.S., as I described here. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/the-presidents-favorite…. Second, at this point this is an argument that the court got it wrong, and is not a defiance of a court order.
Byron York
@ByronYork
Filed last night, the Trump administration answers Judge Engelmayer: storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.636609/…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on how Trump v. U.S. is behind the Trump administration's early controversial actions. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-presidents…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
The judicial power is the power to issue binding judgments on cases within the court’s jurisdiction.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The Supreme Court agrees that "Judges aren't allowed to control the executive's legitimate power." That is part of the holding e.g. in Trump v U.S. The important question is: Who decides definitively what counts as "the executive's legitimate power"--the Court or POTUS?
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
1/ Trump's terminates the Kennedy Center Board of Trustees and names himself Chairman. I'm not impressed. If he really wants to show who is in charge, he should fire the Chancellor of the Smithsonian Institution: Chief Justice Roberts.
apnews.com/article/trump-kennedy-center-board-chairman-fi…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
2/ I doubt Trump can fire Roberts lawfully, by the way, even if he were dumb enough to try do so (though the lawsuit would be ... wonderful). The Smithsonian is, as this OLC opinion explains in detail, a “very unusual entity.” www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/olc/opinions/2008/02/…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Lincoln: "In this and like communities, public sentiment is everything. With public sentiment, nothing can fail; without it nothing can succeed. Consequently he who moulds public sentiment, goes deeper than he who enacts statutes or pronounces decisions. He makes statutes and decisions possible or impossible to be executed." Lincoln uttered this in the context of challenging Douglas's efforts to shape public opinion for ends Lincoln opposed. The statement expressed both a truth--an axiom about how democracy operates--and a warning about the power of public sentiment.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Just Security
@just_security
A recent clarification on prepublication review could help former government employees write and speak more freely, write @jacklgoldsmith and @oonahathaway, although ambiguity remains.
A x-publication w/our friends at @lawfare. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Oona Hathaway and I analyze an important ODNI clarification of the standards for prepublication review. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/a-step-in-the-right-directio…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
This reminds me of Stansfield Turner's reduction of 800 or so operational agents in CIA, which had terrible national security consequences. www.wsj.com/politics/national-security/the-cia-is-about-t…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Heritage Foundation used to worry about this. "But lacking human assets to steal state secrets, Carter & Turner almost assured Washington would be blindsided by int'l events that might otherwise have been foreseen. And that is exactly what happened" www.heritage.org/homeland-security/commentary/cia-clash-t…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Excellent analysis by Marty Lederman: "Trump’s interpretation of the Citizenship Clause breaks with well over a century of consensus understandings throughout the U.S. government. And it’s mistaken."
www.justsecurity.org/107321/doj-brief-birthright-citizens… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Lessig 🇺🇦
@lessig
This is an important piece by Bob Bauer and @jacklgoldsmith. But the right frame here is not a "mini-constitutional convention" to amend Article II. It is @backermanyale's "constitutional moment": These first steps are the challenge; they will be resisted; the difficulty is that there is not likely to be a ratifying election.
www.execfunctions.org/p/the-trump-executive-orders-as-rad… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
1/ In light of the possibility of a “radical constitutionalism” from the right that defies judicial precedents and possibly judicial judgments, I am wondering how my progressive friends who have been pushing in recent years against “constitutionalism,” against judicial review, against judicial supremacy, and in favor of presidential over judicial constitutional interpretation, and of political constitutionalism, and the like, are thinking about the apparent development of these ideas by the Trump administration.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-trump-exec…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
2/ Likewise, I am wondering how my conservative friends who have been treating these progressive ideas as abhorrent anti-constitutional barbarisms, or worse, are feeling about the possible the use of these ideas by the Trump administration.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
3/ I'm reminded of Schlesinger, who noted that “views of the proper distribution of power between the Congress and the President [and, I'd add, the courts] depended a good deal less on considerations of high principle than on preferences about the uses to which power was put.”
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Grateful for this discussion with Isaac Chotiner @newyorker on the significance of the Trump EOs. www.newyorker.com/news/q-and-a/how-donald-trump-is-transf…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My newsletter w/ Bob Bauer assesses the evidence, based on EO patterns thus far and the views of incoming OMB head Russ Vought, that the Trump EOs reflect Vought's "radical constitutionalism" that portends (inter alia) defying Supreme Court judgments.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-trump-exec… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Good story, and am grateful to be quoted, but I think it more likely that Trump's actions ***on balance*** will result in contractions of presidential power. www.nytimes.com/2025/01/29/us/politics/trump-firings-offi…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Not sure Trump OMB “freeze” memo is lawful, if implemented. But also not sure the district court “administrative stay” of the memo is lawful! I doubt OMB is an “agency” under the APA (as court said), or that anyone is yet injured for standing purposes, or that a district court can (as court did) enjoin implementation of an OMB memo, absent any merits analysis, via a so-called administrative stay."
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Here is order: storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.dcd.276842/g…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
The Power of the President (7 basic propositions, all of which bear on current and coming events). @RandyEBarnett @lsolum @JoyceCarolOates @DukeLawJournal @elerianm @FriedrichHayek @jacklgoldsmith @chrislhayes @clairlemon @samuelmoyn open.substack.com/pub/casssunstein/p/the-power-of-the-pre…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Excellent background/explainer by Zach Price. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/a-primer-on-the-impoundment-…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
Jack Goldsmith: Maximum Executive Power and the Fate of the Unitary Executive open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/maximum-execut…
This new Executive Functions s*bstack by Jack and Bob Bauer is always worth reading, whether or not you agree with everything.
I have a quibble with @jacklgoldsmith on this one. 1/ -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
"Trump’s early political and messaging wins on executive orders are signaling a cavalier-about-the-law presidency that will make it hard for Trump to prevail even before the unitarians on the Supreme Court for many of his aggressive Article II actions." open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/maximum-execut…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My (long and technical) take on Trump's firing of 17 IGs: Probably lawful despite the statutory restriction; but, more significantly, Congress has lawfully constrained Trump's power to replace IGs with loyalists, though not in an airtight way. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/trump-fired-17-inspectors-ge…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer explains Trump's privatized and non-transparent "conflict of interest" policy that "permits a wide range of transactions laden with the potential for conflicts: virtually everything is on the table." open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-meme-coin-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I'll be writing about the inspector general firings soon. Meanwhile some background:
1. The 2022 IG law that Trump disregarded (30-day notice): www.lawfaremedia.org/article/inspector-general-reform-ndaa
2. Constitutionality of for-cause removal for IGs. journals.law.harvard.edu/jlpp/wp-content/uploads/sites/90…
3. Podcast w/ former IG Glenn Fine on what the IG does, why important, etc. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/lawfare-daily--what-does-the…
4. The 2022 law puts constraints on POTUS' ability to naming acting IG. See #1 above. On why these constraints constitutional, see: www.lawfaremedia.org/article/constitutional-response-trum… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
This new paper, "Sovereign Power Constitutionalism," is one of the most challenging papers I've ever written. It shows how conceptions of nationhood have long informed U.S. constitutional interpretation and have helped to fill in gaps and resolve ambiguities. Forthcoming in @UChiLRev but still plenty of time for comments!
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5107635 -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Guillermo J GS
@GJGarciaSanchez
1/ Trump’s latest orders affecting Mexico underscore a deeper issue: U.S.-Mexico bureaucratic engagement has dropped sharply, harming cooperation. In my forthcoming @FordhamILJ article, I analyze 20 yrs of agreements showing the decline and its impacts. ssrn.com/abstract=3826409
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Hate Endowment Taxes? Reform the University www.compactmag.com/article/hate-endowment-taxes-reform-th…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Alan Rozenshtein
@ARozenshtein
Companies that are still doing business with TikTok are putting themselves at immense legal risk, Trump's executive order notwithstanding. My latest for @lawfare.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
On governing through executive orders and policy instability:
One theoretical criticism of two-party systems rather than multi-party ones has been the risk that policies can swing back and forth via elections even when voter support changes by only a few points. In a winner-take-all system, 51% support is enough to get 100% of the power.
This is less likely in PR systems, since representation more closely tracks voting support.
This risk was always more theoretical in the US than in the UK. Given our system of bicameralism and separation of powers, and all the veto points that exist, it is less likely for enacted policies to flip flop dramatically from one election to another.
But as we are witnessing now, the more governance comes to be done through executive orders, the more we will experience quick flip flopping between various policies based on which side wins the White House. What can be done with a pen in the hands of one person can easily be undone by the next President holding that pen. So policy instability is one of the costs of governing through executive order.
@jacklgoldsmith -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
It seems clear as a matter of practice that Trump has the authority to initiate withdrawal from the World Health Organization agreement. He seems to accept, correctly in my view, that he is subject to the one-year waiting period that Congress specified for withdrawal. He might claim, however, that he should get credit for the approx. 198 days that elapsed when he tried to withdraw from the WHO near the end of his first term (which was not successful because Biden rescinded the notice of withdrawal when he took office). The idea that these earlier days of attempted withdrawal should carry over, despite an entire four-year administration in the interim, seems unpersuasive to me, but his executive order is written in a way that could suggest it.
www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/withdrawi… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The DOGE EO builds a structure that circumvents the Federal Advisory Comm. Act because it's composed entirely of employees or special gov't employees. Unless Musk & friends are made SGEs, they can't participate. If they aren't SGEs but participate stealthily, then DOGE is a FACA.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take, with Bob Bauer, on "The Risks In Trump’s Barrage of Executive Orders" open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-risks-in-t…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Trump pulls out of Paris Agreement but unlike last time he doesn't give requisite one-year notice. Far from clear that POTUS has domestic law power to do this, and this doesn't effectuate w/drawal under int'l law either. www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/01/putting-a…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
And here is my high-level take on the slew of Trump executive orders coming today: "The Trump 2.0 Executive Orders Will Take Time to Sort Out" open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-trump-20-e…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Aaron Sibarium
@aaronsibarium
Biden attempts to preempt fascism by (checks notes) making it impossible to hold government officials accountable for alleged wrongdoing.
The Associated Press
@AP
BREAKING: Biden pardons Anthony Fauci, Mark Milley and the Jan. 6 committee in an extraordinary use of presidential power against potential Trump "revenge." apnews.com/article/biden-trump-fauci-milley-pardons-janua…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
One of many unfortunate future implications is a danger of executive branch illegality much great than the Trump v. US immunity ruling: a corrupt president can at the end of his term just pardon everyone he induced to act illegally.
www.nytimes.com/2025/01/20/us/politics/biden-pardons-fauc…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
As explained here: "A bad-man president could pardon subordinates who ... carried out an assassination or a coup, just as Trump in the 2 weeks after Jan 6 could have pardoned everyone involved who was later indicted, thereby precluding the indictments." www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-core-issues-in-trump-v.-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on Trump 2.0 at its outset. Plenty in here for everyone to dislike. www.nytimes.com/2025/01/20/opinion/trump-great-president.…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
If "shock and awe" deportations are heavy-handed or a sharp departure from past practice, they will be self-defeating before courts, at least in the short run. Symbolism will often be at war with policy success, here and elsewhere. www.ft.com/content/f216ff88-bfd3-473a-b52f-d7d78a4d54e1
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Two good pieces on TikTok: First, @andrewkwoods on 3 lessons from Sup Ct decision: (i) US has given up on internet freedom; (ii) for the rest of the world, Meta, Google, and X are American TikToks; (iii) Court justifies a speech ruling on privacy grounds. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/three-lessons-from-the-supre…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Second, @ARozenshtein on (among other things) Trump's "four main options for executive intervention [to help TikTok], none of which appear particularly promising." www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-supreme-court-rules-agai…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Keith E. Whittington
@kewhittington
Deep state wins again, I guess
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Thank you @PowerUSAID for your service - and heartfelt thanks to everyone, D or R, who has worked hard and well on behalf of the American people over the years. @jacklgoldsmith
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A reminder, from the January 21, 2009, that headline-grabbing Inauguration-day executive orders do not always work out. Some announced changes are quickly realized, some are slow and grinding, and some are never realized.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Super-interesting paper by Eric Posner and Shivam Saran: "Judge AI: Assessing Large Language Models in Judicial Decision-Making." Main takeaway: "'Judge AI' is a formalist judge, not a human judge." papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5098708
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
And for a super-interesting complementary paper, see Jack Kieffaber, "Predictability, AI, And Judicial Futurism: Why Robots Will Run The Law And Textualists Will Like It ." papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4966334
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Senate confirmation is a vital separation of powers check. Nominee after nominee renounces past extreme views and moves toward the center. Commitments made before Senate are not legally binding but have a restraining impact once official is in office.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The confirmation hearings this week are the calm before the double 1-20 explosion of (i) new executive orders that seek to dramatically change the nation's direction, and (ii) new lawsuits seek to stop or slow that change.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
I’m honored that my new book, "Historical Gloss and Foreign Affairs," is the subject of commentary this week on the Balkinization site. There's a great lineup of commentators, and I'm very appreciative of their engagement with my work.
balkin.blogspot.com -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
In assessing DOGE & related schemes for private sector assistance in govt initiatives, I've focused on FACA and special govt employees (executivefunctions.substack.com/p/billionaires-and-multim…), but a third v relevant law is Anti-Deficiency Act's ban on federal govt accepting voluntary services. 31 USC 1342.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
Thrilled to be doing this - with one great judge, and in honor of another!
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Honored to returning to the University of Chicago, my home for more than 25 years, to give the Dewey Lecture on Wednesday; hoping to see friends there. #emotional
www.law.uchicago.edu/events/2025-dewey-lecture-law-and-ph… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on what the U.S. purchase of the Virgin Islands from Denmark in 1917 can teach about the law and politics of Trump's gambit to get Greenland from Denmark: "The parallels ... are remarkable." open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-danish-wes…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
DOGE is being designed to skirt conflicts of interest and transparency rules of Federal Advisory Committee Act: "DOGE itself is now unlikely to incorporate as an organized outside entity ... ." www.nytimes.com/2025/01/12/us/politics/elon-musk-doge-gov…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
DOGE will rely heavily on the "special governmental employee" status, which has conflict of interest requirements that are (like the whole category of SGE) fluid, as discussed here: executivefunctions.substack.com/p/billionaires-and-multim…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
More evidence of the new regime on high-level government work while remaining in private sector, with coming adjustments to conflict of interest, transparency, and related rules. Bob Bauer and I wrote about it here: executivefunctions.substack.com/p/billionaires-and-multim…. www.washingtonpost.com/business/2025/01/10/musk-ramaswamy…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My chat w/ @OrinKerr on his insightful and accessible new book, "The Digital Fourth Amendment: Privacy and Policing in Our Online World." We also discuss how Orin got into this field (or almost didn't), and how he thinks about the relationship between scholarship and judges.
Lawfare
@lawfare
On Lawfare Daily, @jacklgoldsmith talked to @OrinKerr about his new book, “The Digital Fourth Amendment,” the history and physicality assumptions of the Fourth Amendment, and how the courts are interpreting the Fourth Amendment in a digital age.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer and I seek to explain the emerging philosophy of conflicts of interest in Trump 2.0, especially for those (like Musk and Sacks) who will serve simultaneously in the private sector and at (or near) the highest levels of government.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/billionaires-a… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
He was a truly great man. My favorite of his many important articles, one which I must have read 100 times: "The Protective Power of the Presidency." scholarship.law.columbia.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=…
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Marbury and the Administrative State. Brilliant, hugely important paper by the great and beloved Henry Monaghan, who died yesterday. @jacklgoldsmith @Vermeullarmine @pojanowski @chris_j_walker @chrislhayes @adamliptak
scholarship.law.columbia.edu/faculty_scholarship/154/ -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the New Orleans attack as "a wake-up call about the stakes in President-elect Trump’s nominees to run the federal agencies responsible for national security, especially the domestic security elements of national security."
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-new-orlean…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
"Starting with their confirmation hearings, and especially once in office, the Trump nominees will find their criticisms and reform ambitions checked by the enormous and enormously difficult responsibility of keeping the nation safe."
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@JoshMBlackman asks re TikTok case: “If the Court can issue an administrative stay to preserve the status quo, why not issue an administrative injunction to preserve the status quo? … I don’t know any obvious reason why the Court could not do so.”
reason.com/volokh/2024/12/30/can-scotus-issue-an-administ…Post not available here, view on X
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Under the All Writs Act, the writ must be “agreeable to the usages and principles of law.” As I explained in Lawfare last March, that language tends to countenance “familiar procedures” and “historic aids”—not entirely novel remedies. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-continue-withholding-dir…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
It could be inherent authority. As same post explained, the Court has sometimes rested its stay power at bottom on inherent authority. But the Court should not lightly rest an entirely novel remedy on inherent authority. See Missouri v. Jenkins (1995) (Thomas, J., concurring)
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
Today's Lawfare Daily is a 2023 archive ep where @jacklgoldsmith spoke to with @pbstephan3 about whether international law is failing, why the highest courts of important states are increasingly rejecting international law, and Stephan's prescriptions for these problems.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
milesabell
@milesabell
Finally, a good beach read.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
This was hard and involved many people. Thanks to co-editors, past editors, colleagues, research assistants, and student users.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on whether Trump can pull out of NATO despite a congressional restriction devised by his Secretary of State to be, Marco Rubio: "If Trump decides to leave NATO, he will probably get away with it."
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/can-trump-defy… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
thx!
Protect Democracy
@protctdemocracy
What we're reading: @jacklgoldsmith and Bob Bauer have a new Substack newsletter on executive power. Give them a follow: executivefunctions.substack.com/subscribe
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Jonathan H. Adler
@jadler1969
It's not just the slavish description of Trump and his capabilities. It's also the substance of the argument, which seems not to grasp how the law actually operates. Presumably this is the sort of thing that career attorneys in the SG's office could fix- or so one would hope.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
In DT TikTok brief, SG-to-be John Sauer, in first filing after nomination, publicly kisses the ring and diminishes his credibility before the Court even before assuming Office. The first of many self-defeating actions that will plague the Trump 2.0 DOJ. www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/24/24-656/336151/202412271…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
In DT TikTok brief, SG-to-be John Sauer, in first filing after nomination, publicly kisses the ring and diminishes his credibility before the Court even before assuming Office. The first of many self-defeating actions that will plague the Trump 2.0 DOJ. www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/24/24-656/336151/202412271…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Bob Bauer: George Washington offered to serve w/o pay. JFK did too. And now Trump does it for the second time. "Implicated in the choice to accept or reject the pay is the proper conception of what the job of being president entails." executivefunctions.substack.com/p/why-it-matters-that-a-p…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
The power to prosecute or not to prosecute; the pardon power; the power to enforce or not to enforce civil statutes; all these are peculiarly difficult to subject to fully specified legal principles and (hence) to legal oversight, such as judicial review. They inevitably require good faith and prudence in their exercise. It’s no accident that they are the first casualties of a legal order in which bad faith and partisan fanaticism are so pervasive.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Super-interesting essay.
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
Asked by @CassSunstein to contribute to a forthcoming “Social Research” dossier on liberalism under siege, I propose comparisons of different crises of liberalism (by way of reviewing the great Stephen Holmes’s career)-open to revision; thoughts welcome. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5066991
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Decline of treaties: 3 days ago Prez Biden sent *2d* treaty (118-2) of this 2-year Congress (ends in 2 weeks) to Senate for consent. www.congress.gov/treaty-document/118th-congress/2?s=1&r=1. Other one: www.congress.gov/treaty-document/118th-congress/1?s=1&r=2. This on top of 3 treaties in 117th Congress. So: Five total.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
“Realigning Standing with Substantive Due Process,” focusing on the recent cert denial in Parents Protecting Our Children richardresjudicata.wordpress.com/2024/12/20/realigning-st…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A "round table" exchange with @kateashaw1, @DavidAFrench and me on Trump 2.0. www.nytimes.com/2024/12/20/opinion/trump-supreme-court-se…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Another thing that warrants more attention: What Jody Freeman and Sharon Jacobs call "structural deregulation" -- incapacitating agencies by defunding, understaffing, delegitimating, etc. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/what-to-expect-in-trump-20
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
One thing that warrants more attention -- an effort to change conflict of interest norms. executivefunctions.substack.com/p/what-to-expect-in-trump…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My first effort on Executive Functions Newsletter: What To Expect in Trump 2.0, including recess appts, vacancies, DOGE, FACA, Loper, MQD, impoundment, civ service, IGs, DOJ independence, lawfare, conflicts of interest, troops at home, pardons, much more. open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/what-to-expect…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Starting a new (free) substack today with Bob Bauer, called "Executive Functions." We're covering executive power issues in detail.
Welcome intro here: executivefunctions.substack.com/p/welcome-to-executive-fu…
Please subscribe here: executivefunctions.substack.com/subscribe
First substantive piece tomorrow. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
A bit of flagrant self-promotion — a roundup 🧵 collecting several papers I’ve posted in recent weeks:
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I was wondering who the Acting Attorney General might be on Trump 2.0 Day 1, January 20, 2025, and came across this excellent pre-election overview/explainer by @joshgerstein. I wonder also who the acting FBI Director will be. www.politico.com/news/2024/10/31/trump-day-1-department-o…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Funny and insightful. econ.st/3ZGs0MS
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Good conversation with @BillKristol on the Coming Trump Presidency youtu.be/cepel3piwdE via @YouTube
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Good student note on the Federal Tort Claims Act’s Discretionary Function exception. harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-138/recovering-the-lost-me…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
jus ad bellum collapses entirely. www.wsj.com/world/middle-east/syria-assad-power-vacuum-9f…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
An important guide to the coming “structural deregulation,” which “targets an agency’s core capacities” by attacking its “staffing, leadership, resource base, expertise, and reputation,” by Jody Freeman and Sharon Jacobs. harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-135/structural-deregulation/
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Valuable and immensely instructive discussion of Loper Bright by @Vermeullarmine
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5049347 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
And speaking of inspectors general, wow: "A Review of the Department of Justice’s Issuance of Compulsory Process to Obtain Records of Members of Congress, Congressional Staffers, and Members of the News Media": oig.justice.gov/sites/default/files/reports/25-010.pdf
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Inspectors general--semi-independent exec branch investigatory watchdogs w/ reporting obligations to Congress--play a vital role in exec. branch accountability. I spoke w/ Glenn Fine (former DOJ and acting DOD IG) about his new book on the topic. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/lawfare-daily--what-does-the…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Politico summary: www.politico.com/news/2024/12/10/doj-inspector-general-le…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Inspectors general--semi-independent exec branch investigatory watchdogs w/ reporting obligations to Congress--play a vital role in exec. branch accountability. I spoke w/ Glenn Fine (former DOJ and acting DOD IG) about his new book on the topic. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/lawfare-daily--what-does-the…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
Just posted a new draft @SSRN, forthcoming in the Supreme Court Review: “The Old Regime and the Loper Bright Revolution.” The link and abstract are below. Hope you enjoy!
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5049347 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Foreseeable, and indeed invited, in light of failure to tighten conflict of interest rules during last four years after Trump's first-term conflicts. www.nytimes.com/2024/12/05/us/politics/trump-organization…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Great backgrounder and analysis by @dbyman on the fall of Assad. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/how-to-think-about-the-fall-…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
Today being the anniversary of the repeal of Prohibition, on December 5, 1933, we pause to remember the particularly measured and balanced reaction of perhaps the greatest judge of the 20th century, Judge Learned Hand, to Prohibition's end:
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Excellent overview of the legal issues related to the civil service in the upcoming Trump administration, by @NicholasBednar. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/a-primer-on-the-civil-servic…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Shalev Roisman
@Shalev_Roisman
NEW PAPER ALERT: My article on "The Limits of Formalism in the Separation of Powers" is now officially published in the Journal of Legal Analysis:
academic.oup.com/jla/article/16/1/178/7901712 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Want to get up to speed on many of the executive power issues of the second Trump administration? Consider Bauer & Goldsmith, After Trump. It seeks to give historical context and clear explanations for a number of complex legal rules empowering and governing the presidency, including pardons, vacancies, presidential conflicts of interest, war powers, Insurrection Act, special counsels, press-presidential relations, investigations of past administrations, the role of White House Counsel and OLC, and more. The book is four years old but the law on these issues has hardly changed. And the book describes in detail the baseline post-Watergate presidential norms (eg on DOJ independence) that are about to be challenged on a broad scale. Seems to be free with Kindle Unlimited membership! www.amazon.com/After-Trump-Reconstructing-Jack-Goldsmith-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Depends on who you ask. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/smorgasbord-views-self-pardo…
Bill Ackman
@BillAckman
Can a president pardon himself? What is the law on this?
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@EdWhelanEPPC was one of the few commentators on recess appointments to note the federal vacancies reform act option. www.nationalreview.com/bench-memos/a-much-better-qa-on-tr…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Jeannie Suk Gersen
@JeannieSGersen
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Biden’s pardon of his son going back to 2014 covers Hunters’ Burisma activities. Whether or not there was criminality, there might have been an investigation by the incoming Trump administration. That is off the table now (as is Hunter’s 5th Amendment claim before congressional investigators). Also off the table is any Trump administration investigation of Biden for issuing the pardon to obstruct justice, on a theory of obstruction akin to the ones Mueller was floating (though not in the pardon context) in Volume II of his report. Bob Bauer and I explained in “After Trump,” p. 127 ff., why a president could theoretically be prosecuted for using a pardon to obstruct justice. We also explained (p. 126) why such a prosecution would not necessarily be precluded by the Article II pardon power, which makes the pardon absolute for the beneficiary of the pardon, but “does not afford the president , as the grantor, immunity from commission of a crimes in connection with the granting of the pardon.” However, Biden is protected by the Supreme Court’s July immunity decision from criminal investigation for possible obstruction of justice by the incoming Trump administration. The Court said that a pardon was a conclusive and preclusive presidential power, and that the president's exercise of such a power is broadly immune from criminalization, investigation, or prosecution by a subsequent administration. The Court in reaching this conclusion expressed worry about “an Executive Branch that cannibalizes itself, with each successive President free to prosecute his predecessors.” I.e. Biden is the first beneficiary of Trump v. U.S.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The vast majority of Trump’s 238 clemency decisions were influenced by a personal/political connection w/ him. None so personal as Biden’s pardon of his son, which is lawful but unfortunate as Trump returns to wield pardon power in unprecedented ways. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1K52z9rlRsShGtMNvDNVXp-kmk…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A different analysis showed (as best as could be shown via public data) that Trump relied on the DOJ pardon attorney recommendation 11% or so of the time. Did Biden skirt the DOJ pardon attorney process? Highly likely, but journalists should ask. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/trump-and-pardon-attorney
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
On Kash Patel and the Underappreciated Federal Vacancies Reform Act:
A NYT article today about Trump nominees and Senate independence worries that Trump could “erode the Senate’s authority to pass judgment on nominees by,” among other things, “sidestepping it through recess appointments.”
Like so many analyses of Trump’s appointments strategy, this article ignores a different and entirely lawful route for Trump to appoint loyalists to senior executive branch positions without Senate confirmation: the Federal Vacancies Reform Act (FVRA). FVRA establishes rules for presidents to appoint “temporary” (but long-term) acting officials to positions for which Senate advice and consent is otherwise needed. It applies whenever a vacancy occurs because a Senate-confirmed official “dies, resigns, or is otherwise unable to perform the functions and duties of the office.” 5 USC 3345.
Trump’s announcement yesterday that he will nominate Kash Patel to be Director of the FBI is a great example of how FVRA might work. Patel won’t be confirmed for months after Trump becomes president on January 20, if ever. But current FBI Director Chris Wray will either resign before January 20 or be fired on that date. A crucial issue for the incoming Trump administration, therefore, is to determine who will be acting FBI Director on January 20.
Under FVRA, Trump could appoint someone as acting FBI Director for potentially more than two years without Senate confirmation. The importance of FVRA goes far beyond Patel, since it gives the president broad authority to skirt the Senate and appoint loyalists to Senate-confirmed positions throughout the executive branch on an “acting” basis.
The FBI succession regulation will determine in the first instance who runs the FBI if Wray resigns before January 20, or is fired on that date. See Federal Register, February 14, 2007, at page 7343. During the period after Wray leaves (by whatever means) and Patel or someone else is confirmed as FBI Director, Deputy FBI Director Paul Abbate—assuming he doesn’t resign and isn’t fired—would be first in succession to be acting Director under the regulation, until Trump as President chooses otherwise. (Since Wray named Abbate as Deputy Director in 2021, I assume Abbate is unlikely to be viewed with favor by the incoming Trump administration.) After Abbate comes Associate Deputy Director Brian Turner, then Executive Assistant Director of the National Security Branch, Larissa Knapp, followed by several other senior career officials.
The regulation sets the succession default—a default that accords with Trump’s first option to name an acting Director under FVRA, since that option is to replace Wray with “the first assistant to the office.” 5 USC 3345 (a)(1). But FVRA gives Trump two additional options to replace Abbate or a different regulation-specified successor as acting Director of FBI.
First, Trump could choose any Senate-confirmed officer from anywhere in the administration to serve as acting director. 5 USC 3345 (a)(2). That means that Trump could name anyone the Senate confirms for any position in the Trump administration to serve as Acting FBI Director. This implication of FVRA raises the stakes nontrivially for every Trump nominee before the Senate! Trump could also appoint a loyalist currently in a Senate-confirmed position on a multi-member board with partisan requirements. He could, for example, name Brendan Carr—who Trump nominated to be FCC Chair, but who is currently a Senate-confirmed FCC Commissioner—as acting FBI Director. Holdover Senate-confirmed FEC Commissioner Trey Trainor, who worked on Trump’s 2016 presidential campaign, is another possibility. There are others.
Second, Trump can choose any FBI official whose rate of pay is “equal to or greater than the minimum rate of pay payable for a position at GS–15 of the General Schedule” and who has been in the FBI for 90 days during the previous year. 5 USC 3345 (a)(3). There are several hundred people in the FBI whose rate of pay is equal to or greater than a GS-15 position. I expect that the Trump team is currently scouring this group for a loyalist. (There are other restrictions under 5 USC 3345 that I think are not plausibly relevant here.)
Someone appointed by Trump via either of the two mechanisms above could run the FBI for a long time. An acting official appointed at the beginning of an administration can serve for 300 days. 5 USC 3349a. But the clock would stop running when Trump formally nominates Patel and during his pending nomination. If the Senate rejects Patel, or Patel withdraws, the clock is reset for 210 days. 5 USC 3346. If Trump nominates a second candidate who is rejected or withdraws, the clock starts yet again. Anne Joseph O’Connell in the definitive work on FVRA says this scheme in theory permits an acting official to serve for more than two and a half years. See O’Connell, Actings, 120 Colum. L. Rev. 613, 631 (2020).
Viewed through the FVRA lens, the Patel nomination is a win-win for Trump. The Patel nomination will be a lengthy affair at a minimum. If the Senate rejects him or he withdraws, the length of the process, followed by what may be another controversial nominee, gives the President the backup option of a loyalist atop the FBI for a long time without Senate confirmation. Trump has the option, that is, if he can find a loyalist who is at GS-15 pay or greater within the FBI or who is in some Senate-confirmed slot in the administration.
I am confident the Trump Team has thought through the FVRA mechanism described above. The Trump administration used (or tried to circumvent) FVRA in imaginative ways during its first term. The Trump team has been planning since 2021 to exploit every legal avenue for a re-elected Trump to impose his will maximally throughout the executive branch. Moreover, the first Trump administration was not by a mile the first to fill many senior executive branch positions with acting officials for a lengthy period. The loophole-filled FVRA was a (failed) congressional response in 1998 to President Clinton’s perceived manipulation of the prior Vacancies Act. And the George W. Bush and Obama administrations used acting officials under FVRA aggressively.
The FVRA path, in short, is well trod in the executive branch. And the use of FVRA as described above to appoint acting officials is perfectly lawful since Congress expressly authorized it.
FVRA applies to basically all vacancies in Senate-confirmed offices throughout the executive branch, including cabinet level officials. Remember acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker? Trump chose him to run the Department after Trump fired Jeff Sessions and until William Barr was confirmed. Because Whitaker had been Sessions’ chief of staff at a pay rate equal to or greater than GS-15 for over a year, Trump could appoint him as acting Attorney General under 5 USC 3345 (a)(3). OLC approved the move even though DOJ has a Department-specific succession statute for the Attorney General. See 28 USC 508. Section 508, OLC concluded, did not “displace the President’s authority to use [FVRA] as an alternative.” OLC Memorandum on Designating an Acting Attorney General, 11-14-18.
Bob Bauer and I in our book “After Trump” described the FVRA scenarios above and many other FVRA loopholes, and proposed reforms to narrow presidential discretion to circumvent the Senate (in exchange for Congress significantly reducing the member of Senate-filled positions). This proposal, like so many others to reconstruct the presidency, got nowhere in the last four years.
I should for completion’s sake note two caveats to the above analysis. First, if Wray stays on and forces Trump to fire him, Trump’s authority under FVRA to replace him could narrow. The reason is that it is unsettled whether a vacancy created by presidential firing triggers the FVRA authority due to the officeholder being “unable to perform the functions and duties of the office” under 5 U.S.C. § 3345. On that issue, and some of the possible implications, see this terrific student Note: Ben Miller-Gootnick, Boundaries of the Federal Vacancies Reform Act, 56 Harv. J. on Legis. 459 (2019).
Second, the president has options to achieve the functional equivalent of acting officials by circumventing FVRA through delegation of the tasks of the vacant office. O’Connell discusses how this works at pp. 633-35 of her piece. Bauer and I describe it at pp. 318-19, and 324-25 in “After Trump.” This gambit too has been used by many presidential administrations.
I close by noting my surprise at the exorbitant attention given to recess appointments and the relative dearth of attention given to the president’s options under FVRA. The excessive focus on recess appointments resulted from Trump's November 10 tweet: “Any Republican Senator seeking the coveted LEADERSHIP position in the United States Senate must agree to Recess Appointments (in the Senate!), without which we will not be able to get people confirmed in a timely manner.”
But as Bauer and I wrote in 2020 in “After Trump”: FVRA “gives the president pretty broad discretion, with fairly long time periods, to appoint acting officials for vacant Senate-confirmable slots. And presidents have used this authority as they saw fit. The need to do so grew after the Supreme Court’s decision in NLRB v. Noel Canning and the Senate practice of conducting pro forma sessions practically killed the possibility of recess appointments.”
FVRA is the way that Trump will put in place loyalists through the administration on January 20. Recess appointments are largely a distraction.
PS: I wrote this quickly and FVRA is very technical. Please let me know if I made a mistake and I will amend.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
First mistake identified, for which I apologize. This appears to be wrong: "Trump could also appoint a loyalist currently in a Senate-confirmed position on a multi-member board with partisan requirements. He could, for example, name Brendan Carr—who Trump nominated to be FCC Chair, but who is currently a Senate-confirmed FCC Commissioner—as acting FBI Director. Holdover Senate-confirmed FEC Commissioner Trey Trainor, who worked on Trump’s 2016 presidential campaign, is another possibility. There are others." Reason: 5 USC 3349c(1)(A) excludes Senate-confirmed officials on multi-member boards from the the list of candidates otherwise-available under §3345(a)(2).
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Another view: It is possible, and perhaps best, to read 5 USC 3349c(1) a different way -- to specify only that vacant slots on a multi-member commission cannot be filled by the candidates available under §3345(a)(2). Which would make my original claim right. But in any event I should have flagged 5 USC 3349c(1) in noting the possibility of filling a vacancy with a Senate-confirmed official on a multi-member commission.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
Today's Lawfare Daily is a 2019 archive ep in which @jacklgoldsmith sat down with Michael Anton, a former Trump admin national security official, to discuss his essay in Foreign Policy on the 'Trump Doctrine' and the philosophy behind Trump's foreign policy.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Foreshadows how the FBI will be chopped down starting 1-20: "Mr. Trump’s team has so far refused to sign an agreement with the Justice Department to allow the F.B.I. to do security clearances for transition members."
www.nytimes.com/2024/11/26/us/politics/trump-transition-b…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The most interesting immediate question is whether the Senate will confirm Department heads and other top officials who lack FBI security checks. That is the only point of leverage. Otherwise POTUS controls the security system within Executive branch.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Administrative law's grand narrative. (Relevant to current events.) @jacklgoldsmith
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4986085 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
1/ It’s going to be a wild ride for executive power during Trump 2.0. Here is a quick list of important issues where executive power is likely to be pushed hard, rethought, resisted, and/or, when possible, litigated. What am I missing?
Post not available here, view on X
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
4/ Related to last two points: Congress in 2022 made it harder for the president to remove inspectors general and to replace them with presidential loyalists. Are these restrictions consistent with Article II?
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
5/ Trump has refused to sign agreements under Presidential Transition Act (including ethics pledges), isn’t participating in formal transition, and is cutting out FBI background checks, w/ uncertain legal/political implications for what happens on 1-20, and Sen. confirmations.
Post not available here, view on X
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
16/ Is Congress’s prohibition on the president withdrawing from the North Atlantic constitutional? If Trump withdraws from the treaty, can the issue be tested in court? (Standing, political question doctrine, etc.)
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
17/ We are going to learn a lot about the contours of Article II in the next four years. (We are also going to learn a lot more about Supreme Court doctrine on standing and emergency orders.) Again, what am I missing?
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
True: "We Asked for It: The politicization of research, hiring, and teaching made professors sitting ducks." www.chronicle.com/article/we-asked-for-it
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on a closely related issue, seven years ago (with @Vermeullarmine). www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/elite-colleges-are-making…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Definitive legal analysis. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/how-can-trump-deploy-the-mil…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
This thoughtful piece by Bob Bauer reminds me of what I wrote in "After Trump" in the Fall of 2020 -- before J6, before the classified documents imbroglio, before the Smith indictments. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/did-the-legal-process-over-t…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Trump says the Dep’t of Gov’t Efficiency (DOGE) "will provide advice and guidance from outside of Government.” DOGE will thus be a Federal Advisory Committee, 5 USC App. 3, and subject to transparency and recordkeeping requirements, see 5 USC App. 10. Should be fun to behold.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Powerful critique (longer version here: snfagora.jhu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/Taking-Democr…) of the billions spent in resistance to Trumpian populism. www.philanthropy.com/commons/trump-resistance-funding
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My talk with @kewhittington about his terrific new book "The Impeachment Power: The Law, Politics, and Purpose of an Extraordinary Constitutional Tool." www.amazon.com/Impeachment-Power-Politics-Extraordinary-C…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
Looking forward to being back at my alma mater next week to discuss my new book. Thanks to my friend (and frequent co-author) @jacklgoldsmith for agreeing to serve as the commentator. Hopefully this will be a good diversion from election-related anxiety.
hls.harvard.edu/events/glossing-the-foreign-affairs-const… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Amazingly prescient book, first published 23 years ago.
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Might possibly have not gotten this one wrong, back in ancient times. #stoppedclockisrighttwiceaday
www.amazon.com/Republic-com-Cass-R-Sunstein/dp/0691095892 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Important forthcoming book by Ashley Deeks: "The Double Black Box: National Security, Artificial Intelligence, and the Struggle for Democratic Accountability."
global.oup.com/academic/product/the-double-black-box-9780… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@CassSunstein on (among other things) the constitutionality of the Electoral Count Reform Act. www.wsj.com/opinion/on-jan-6-will-vice-president-harris-c… via @WSJopinion
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Matthew Waxman
@mattwaxman1
Congratulations to my wonderful colleague @anubradford for a superb book
International Science Council
@ISC
🏆 Thrilled to announce that @anubradford (@columbialaw) has won the 2024 Stein Rokkan Prize for her book #digitalempires.
Her seminal work tackles one of the major challenges of our time - the global fight to regulate technology.
council.science/news/anu-bradford-wins-2024-stein-rokkan-… @UiB @UiB_sampol @ECPR -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
great review of a great scholar
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
I reviewed Richard Tuck’s new book (and great career) for @commonwealmag www.commonwealmagazine.org/counsels-humility
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
Here’s my latest foray with Ernie Young into the law of standing. This time we focus on standing to assert injuries that depend on probabilistic assessments, an issue that comes up in a wide variety of settings. Just out in @michlawreview.
repository.law.umich.edu/mlr/vol122/iss8/2/ -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A follow up to my piece in the NYT last week (www.nytimes.com/2024/10/09/opinion/jack-smith-trump-biden…) that asks why DOJ did not take up the DOJ IG's 6-year-old suggestion to clarify the meaning and scope of the 60-Day Rule. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/what-does-the-60-day-rule-re…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The gist:
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Important new paper by my colleague Larry Schwartztol: "Congress's Power Over the Electoral Count". papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4982913
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Lael Weinberger
@LaelWeinberger
Grateful for the "highly recommended" from @lsolum on his indispensable blog regarding my latest paper lsolum.typepad.com/legaltheory/2024/10/weinberger-on-the-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Good question.
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
Here's an interview in which I talk about my new book, "Historical Gloss and Foreign Affairs." I start with the question: how has our old and hard-to-change Constitution managed to keep up with the massive changes in both the United States and the world?
faculti.net/historical-gloss-and-foreign-affairs-constitu… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
“Just about any conceivable circumstance in which the president (or his relevant subordinates) would think it prudent to use force in the Middle East can be justified under an Article II self-defense theory.” www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-middle-east-and-the-pres…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Shalev Roisman
@Shalev_Roisman
Happy to share that my article "Balancing Interests in the Separation of Powers" is now out in @UChiLRev
lawreview.uchicago.edu/sites/default/files/2024-08/02_Roi…
Thanks to the editors for their terrific editorial assistance and to innumerable colleagues for generous comments. Remaining flaws are mine!
UChicago Law Review
@UChiLRev
Volume 91.5 is now live, featuring two Articles by @Maceyjoshua and @Shalev_Roisman, and three Comments by Laura Hu, Samuel P. LeRoy, and Helen Zhao! Read now at: lawreview.uchicago.edu.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Looking forward to this episode of @DividedArgument -- with Daryl Levinson, about his new book, "Law for Leviathan"--even more than usual. dividedargument.com/episodes/separation-of-powers-police
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My review of Harold Koh's new book, "“The National Security Constitution in the 21st Century.”
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/presidential-unilateralism-i… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
Look at what just arrived in the mail! After years of research and countless discussions about the book with colleagues and students, it’s very gratifying to finally be launching it into the world.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
New, with @oonahathaway: ODNI's new pre-publication review directive "contains very disappointing speech-harming provisions, ... On the whole, the directive is very disappointing." @JameelJaffer
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-odnis-new-and-disappoint… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
New, w/ @curtisabradley: Explains in detail how so-called “foreign affairs exception" to nondelegation doctrine, which is really an “independent presidential power qualification," should work; and assesses carefully how MQD should apply in this context. scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=986…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
27 years (yikes) of happy collaboration. scholarship.law.duke.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1981…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Richard M. Re
@RichardMRe
On “Legal Realignment” richardresjudicata.wordpress.com/2024/08/31/on-legal-real…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
I look forward to seeing many friends at my upcoming book talks! The Fall schedule is now set: Duke (9/17); Stanford (10/9); Berkeley (10/10); Yale (10/22); UVA (10/30); Harvard (11/6-7); Columbia (11/14); GW (11/20); Chicago (12/4).
www.amazon.com/Historical-Gloss-Foreign-Affairs-Constitut… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
A right not to be manipulated? The core of such a right is here.
www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2024… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
"any conceivable circumstance in which POTUS (or ... subordinates) would think it prudent to use force in the Middle East can be justified under an Art. II self-defense theory. Which means that a lot rests on the POTUS', and his subordinates’, prudence." www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-middle-east-and-the-pres…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Matthew Waxman
@mattwaxman1
This is must-read (or now must-listen) for anyone interested in digital tech and its regulation globally
Anu Bradford
@anubradford
Excited to announce that #audiobook of #digitalempires is now out! It is beautifully narrated by Nancy Peterson. @OUPLaw
Download your own copy here:
www.amazon.com/Digital-Empires-Global-Regulate-Technology… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
49 years ago today, Jimmy Hoffa disappeared from a suburban Detroit mall parking lot and was never heard from again. Amazingly, "there is still not one single piece of direct evidence about what happened to Hoffa" that day. #greatestunsolvedcrime
www.amazon.com/Hoffas-Shadow-Stepfather-Disappearance-Det… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Dan Geer reacts to the Crowdstrike/Microsoft disaster, which he (with others) warned about 2+ decades ago. “There is, in a basic sense, nothing new to be said about the global computer outage of the week just past.” www.lawfaremedia.org/article/it-is-time-to-act
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
On the Biden administration lecturing other countries about preserving judicial independence to preserve democracy, and the domestic push for Supreme Court reform. www.documentcloud.org/documents/24530092-liberties-israel…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Biden tonight: "Supreme Court reform . . . is critical to our democracy,”
Biden 2023: “The genius of American democracy and Israeli democracy is that they are both built on strong institutions, on checks and balances, on an independent judiciary." -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Looking forward to this on-line discussion of the Insurrection Act tomorrow with @LizaGoitein, @konima1, and @josephanunn.
Brennan Center
@BrennanCenter
The Insurrection Act is a threat to American democracy.
Join @LizaGoitein, @konima1, @JackLGoldsmith, and @JosephANunn on Thursday, July 25, at 3pm ET for a virtual discussion on how to reform the outdated law: brennan.swoogo.com/insurrectionact/register?ref=OrganicSo… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The mystery of international law in two sentences: “The court was issuing an advisory opinion that, while not binding, carries authority and legal weight. It is unlikely to affect Israeli policy but could shape international opinion.”
www.nytimes.com/live/2024/07/19/world/israel-gaza-war-ham… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Erica Gaston
@ericagaston
My book is finally out! cup.columbia.edu/book/illusions-of-control/9780231210133 Building from over a decade of research in #afghanistan #iraq and #syria, as well as with DC policymakers, it delves into the security, human rights, and other democratic policy dilemmas that emerge when the US backs local forces.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My talk w @chrismkirchhoff about his book (w Raj Shah): “Unit X: How the Pentagon & Silicon Valley Are Transforming the Future of War”--about @DIU_x effort to bring tech innovation to Pentagon; and relationship between innovation, defense, & procurement www.lawfaremedia.org/article/lawfare-daily--christopher-k…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Matthew Waxman
@mattwaxman1
well deserved!
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My big-picture take on Trump v. US. Weedier comments later. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/broad-reflections-on-trump-v…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
And for a different view: www.lawfaremedia.org/article/a-decision-of-surpassing-rec…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Vermeule: "the Loper Bright opinion “expressed a mood,” as Justice Frankfurter once said. The heated reactions on both sides to Loper Bright remind me of the reactions to US v Lopez.
open.substack.com/pub/thenewdigest/p/chevron-by-any-other… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
Today's Lawfare Daily is a 2020 archive ep in which @jacklgoldsmith spoke to Eric Posner about his book, "The Demagogue's Playbook," the ways the founders tried to prevent a demagogue from becoming president, and how Trump's demagoguery helped him win.
shows.acast.com/lawfare/episodes/lawfare-archive-eric-pos… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Great book, out today: Bauer, "The Unraveling: Reflections on Politics without Ethics and Democracy in Crisis." "The crisis of democratic politics is a crisis of public faith in politics. To restore faith in govt, the role of politics has to be defended."www.amazon.com/Unraveling-Reflections-Politics-without-De…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Thanks. More considered and elaborate view: www.lawfaremedia.org/article/some-thoughts-on-the-weak-u.…
Matthew Continetti
@continetti
Very interesting read
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Some v. quick thoughts on the extraordinarily weak Bilateral Security Agreement Between the United States of America and Ukraine. www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2024…. (I wrote this quickly so if I get something wrong please let me know and I will amend.)
@SangerNYT in the @nyt says the agreement was “designed to demonstrate to President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia that the United States and its allies had no intention of packing up and leaving.” Yet as I will explain, the agreement sends the opposite signal.
Preliminaries: The agreement appears to be an executive agreement made solely on the president’s authority, though the precise authority is not specified. It is unclear whether it is a legally binding or nonbinding agreement. It is probably best seen as a binding agreement with mostly non-binding terms. Some provisions use the language of binding agreements (e.g. the parties “shall … meet” if one is attacked; the entry into force clause) and others seem nonbinding (e.g. “the policy of the Parties to work together to deter … aggression”). On binding v. nonbinding agreements, see chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=6….
But: I do not think the agreement’s status as binding or non-binding matters at all since the "commitments" in the agreement are so extraordinarily weak.
The only real obligation upon attack is to “immediately meet, where possible within 24 hours, at the most senior levels to determine appropriate next steps and additional defense needs.”
At that meeting the Parties “may” decide to “implement additional appropriate defense and deterrent responses.” Or, by implication, they may not. The Parties also “stand ready to share available and appropriate information and intelligence immediately,” but there is no obligation here to share the information.
The key commitment to “help deter and confront any future aggression against the territorial integrity of either Party” and "to assist Ukraine in maintaining a credible defense and deterrence capability" is stated as a “policy” and is not backed up by any commitment, much less a firm one. Future aggression against Ukraine is described as a matter of “grave concern” but no obligations to act is triggered.
The Parties also agree to “further implement[] existing security agreements,” to “meet on a regular basis,” and to “further bolster their defense and security cooperation” in ways that “may,” but need not, include training, provision of defense articles, joint planning, cybersecurity cooperation, etc.
The agreement later states that the Parties “agree to advance the appropriate sharing of intelligence and to promote enhanced cooperation between their intelligence services,” but the nature and scope of this "appropriate" sharing and cooperation is unspecified and thus imposes no real commitment.
Perhaps most importantly, “providing sustainable levels of security assistance for Ukraine” is stated as a mere policy, not obligation, and rather than commit funds, the United States “intends” (but is not obliged) “to seek from … Congress appropriation of funds to help sustain a Ukrainian credible defense and deterrent capability, in war and peace.” I.e. the president as a matter of policy but not obligation agrees to ask Congress for money. Neither Congress nor the United States agrees to provide the money.
Cooperation on Economic Recovery and Reform is further stated in terms of an “inten[t] to cooperate,” not an obligation. The parties do state that they “shall cooperate” on institutional reforms to advance Euro-Atlantic cooperation, but there’s no commitment on Ukraine’s NATO membership although there is a nod to it.
There are some very thin and vague obligations assumed later in the document, e.g., the Parties “shall cooperate to advance a just and lasting peace that has broad global support.”
Any disagreements about the extraordinarily weak commitments in the agreement “shall be resolved only through consultation between the Parties” and not in any court—ie if the party disagree on the agreement, the remedy is to talk about it.
Perhaps most hilarious (or sad): “This Agreement shall enter into force upon signature by both Parties. This Agreement shall remain in force 10 years from entry into force and may be extended by mutual written agreement of the Parties.” It is also registered with the UN.
These provisions aim to give the document a patina of seriousness and bindingness. But the agreement that enters into force imposes no commitments of substance. The United States assumes no firm commitment to help Ukraine.
Same with “termination” provision with 6 months notice. I am surprised that the Biden team insisted on such a short termination clause. But it too is a ruse; the agreement imposes no obligations of substance to actually help Ukraine, so during the 6-month termination period the US needn’t do anything of substance (unless you consider meeting after an attack as something of substance).
President Biden said that the U.S. goal in the agreement was “to strengthen Ukraine’s credible defense and deterrence capabilities for the long term.” www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/speeches-remarks/2024/06…
The agreement does not do this. The Biden Team was entirely unwilling (or, perhaps, unable) to make real commitments to Ukraine’s security in the agreement. This sends a devastating signal since this weakness comes from directly the Biden administration and not from Congress.
One might have thought that the Biden goal would be to make the hardest and most specific possible commitments to Ukraine’s security to make it more difficult for future, less committed presidents to back away. But not so. This agreement will be very easy for a future president to ignore, or interpret away, or terminate, or all of the above, if that president wishes to not support, or to provide less support to, Ukraine.
Separate from this agreement, “the G7 signed a plan to finalize and unlock $50 billion from the proceeds of those frozen assets, to put that money to work for Ukraine,” as President Biden put it. This is a real commitment and a consequential one that is separate from the security pact. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My more considered view on the "Bilateral Security Agreement Between the United States of America and Ukraine": It does not, as the national security adviser says, signal U.S. resolve. Quite the opposite. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/some-thoughts-on-the-weak-u.…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Great issue, great publication, great editors -- honored to be in it.
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
And the 2023 Supreme Court Review is here!
cc @CassSunstein @rtushnet @jacklgoldsmith @daniellecitron @StephenESachs @JuliaMahoneyUVA -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Out now, with Alan Sykes: "The California Effect, Process-Based Regulation, and the Future of Pike Balancing." www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/epdf/10.1086/730768. Thanks to the great crew at Supreme Court Review, especially, this time, David Strauss.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Some v. quick thoughts on the extraordinarily weak Bilateral Security Agreement Between the United States of America and Ukraine. www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2024…. (I wrote this quickly so if I get something wrong please let me know and I will amend.)
@SangerNYT in the @nyt says the agreement was “designed to demonstrate to President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia that the United States and its allies had no intention of packing up and leaving.” Yet as I will explain, the agreement sends the opposite signal.
Preliminaries: The agreement appears to be an executive agreement made solely on the president’s authority, though the precise authority is not specified. It is unclear whether it is a legally binding or nonbinding agreement. It is probably best seen as a binding agreement with mostly non-binding terms. Some provisions use the language of binding agreements (e.g. the parties “shall … meet” if one is attacked; the entry into force clause) and others seem nonbinding (e.g. “the policy of the Parties to work together to deter … aggression”). On binding v. nonbinding agreements, see chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=6….
But: I do not think the agreement’s status as binding or non-binding matters at all since the "commitments" in the agreement are so extraordinarily weak.
The only real obligation upon attack is to “immediately meet, where possible within 24 hours, at the most senior levels to determine appropriate next steps and additional defense needs.”
At that meeting the Parties “may” decide to “implement additional appropriate defense and deterrent responses.” Or, by implication, they may not. The Parties also “stand ready to share available and appropriate information and intelligence immediately,” but there is no obligation here to share the information.
The key commitment to “help deter and confront any future aggression against the territorial integrity of either Party” and "to assist Ukraine in maintaining a credible defense and deterrence capability" is stated as a “policy” and is not backed up by any commitment, much less a firm one. Future aggression against Ukraine is described as a matter of “grave concern” but no obligations to act is triggered.
The Parties also agree to “further implement[] existing security agreements,” to “meet on a regular basis,” and to “further bolster their defense and security cooperation” in ways that “may,” but need not, include training, provision of defense articles, joint planning, cybersecurity cooperation, etc.
The agreement later states that the Parties “agree to advance the appropriate sharing of intelligence and to promote enhanced cooperation between their intelligence services,” but the nature and scope of this "appropriate" sharing and cooperation is unspecified and thus imposes no real commitment.
Perhaps most importantly, “providing sustainable levels of security assistance for Ukraine” is stated as a mere policy, not obligation, and rather than commit funds, the United States “intends” (but is not obliged) “to seek from … Congress appropriation of funds to help sustain a Ukrainian credible defense and deterrent capability, in war and peace.” I.e. the president as a matter of policy but not obligation agrees to ask Congress for money. Neither Congress nor the United States agrees to provide the money.
Cooperation on Economic Recovery and Reform is further stated in terms of an “inten[t] to cooperate,” not an obligation. The parties do state that they “shall cooperate” on institutional reforms to advance Euro-Atlantic cooperation, but there’s no commitment on Ukraine’s NATO membership although there is a nod to it.
There are some very thin and vague obligations assumed later in the document, e.g., the Parties “shall cooperate to advance a just and lasting peace that has broad global support.”
Any disagreements about the extraordinarily weak commitments in the agreement “shall be resolved only through consultation between the Parties” and not in any court—ie if the party disagree on the agreement, the remedy is to talk about it.
Perhaps most hilarious (or sad): “This Agreement shall enter into force upon signature by both Parties. This Agreement shall remain in force 10 years from entry into force and may be extended by mutual written agreement of the Parties.” It is also registered with the UN.
These provisions aim to give the document a patina of seriousness and bindingness. But the agreement that enters into force imposes no commitments of substance. The United States assumes no firm commitment to help Ukraine.
Same with “termination” provision with 6 months notice. I am surprised that the Biden team insisted on such a short termination clause. But it too is a ruse; the agreement imposes no obligations of substance to actually help Ukraine, so during the 6-month termination period the US needn’t do anything of substance (unless you consider meeting after an attack as something of substance).
President Biden said that the U.S. goal in the agreement was “to strengthen Ukraine’s credible defense and deterrence capabilities for the long term.” www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/speeches-remarks/2024/06…
The agreement does not do this. The Biden Team was entirely unwilling (or, perhaps, unable) to make real commitments to Ukraine’s security in the agreement. This sends a devastating signal since this weakness comes from directly the Biden administration and not from Congress.
One might have thought that the Biden goal would be to make the hardest and most specific possible commitments to Ukraine’s security to make it more difficult for future, less committed presidents to back away. But not so. This agreement will be very easy for a future president to ignore, or interpret away, or terminate, or all of the above, if that president wishes to not support, or to provide less support to, Ukraine.
Separate from this agreement, “the G7 signed a plan to finalize and unlock $50 billion from the proceeds of those frozen assets, to put that money to work for Ukraine,” as President Biden put it. This is a real commitment and a consequential one that is separate from the security pact. -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Looking forward to reading this latest in Ward Farnsworth's line of great books on argument and rhetoric. www.amazon.com/Farnsworths-Classical-English-Argument-Far…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
.@curtisabradley, @jacklgoldsmith, and @oonahathaway find that the large-scale reforms governing executive agreements enacted by Congress in 2022 have increased transparency, but there are still opportunities for improvement. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/transparency-of-internationa…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Jed Rubenfeld
@Jed_Rubenfeld
I just released the first episode of my new show—Straight Down the Middle—where I take a look at the Trump Verdict and what it REALLY means from a constitutional perspective.
Straight Down the Middle — The Trump Verdict —Ep. 1 youtu.be/u23t__ysVjU via @YouTube -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
On Saturday the @UChicagoLaw school awarded its first honorary degree in many years -- to Professor Randall Kennedy @Harvard_Law. He's a pathbreaking scholar of race and the law, and also a powerful advocate of free speech and academic freedom. I think we chose well.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Orin Kerr
@OrinKerr
Pleased to share the book cover for my forthcoming book, "The Digital Fourth Amendment," with Oxford University Press. The book won't be out until sometime in the fall, but at least we have the cover now.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Keith E. Whittington
@kewhittington
New book has dropped. You can own it today!
An explanation and defense of academic freedom and the freedom to teach in universities and the First Amendment problems with legislative restrictions on classroom discussions.
www.amazon.com/You-Cant-Teach-That-University/dp/1509564535/ -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Stephen E. Sachs
@StephenESachs
NOW ON @SSRN: "Good and Evil in the American Founding," forthcoming in @HarvardJLPP .
Somewhat less strictly legal than most things I publish; maybe among the most hot-button; certainly the most personal and heartfelt. (And short!)
I'd be honored if you read it. Link below. -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
@scottjshapiro.bsky.social
@scottjshapiro
Thrilled that "Fancy Bear Goes Phishing" was selected for the @nytimes Paperback Row. FBGP is now out in paperback.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Matthew Continetti
@continetti
Congratulations to Adam J. White! @AEI www.aei.org/social-cultural-and-constitutional-studies/wh…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Now out: Leslie Williams' new poetry collection, "Matters for You Alone."
www.amazon.com/Matters-You-Alone-Leslie-Williams/dp/16398… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Jameel Jaffer
@JameelJaffer
Dave Pozen's new book about the war on drugs includes a mind-expanding chapter about the 1A and cognitive liberty. His argument: current 1A doctrine "trivializes the expressive, epistemic, and psychic harms of the war on drugs while subsidizing the speech of licit drugmakers."
Lawfare
@lawfare
On today's Lawfare Daily, @jacklgoldsmith spoke to David Pozen from @ColumbiaLaw about his book, “The Constitution of the War on Drugs,” why the drug war was not curbed by constitutional doctrines about personal autonomy, and more. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/lawfare-daily-david-pozen-on…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
Today's Lawfare Daily is a 2017 ep in which @jacklgoldsmith interviewed @JameelJaffer about his book, "The Drone Memos: Targeted Killing, Secrecy, and the Law," targeted killing and its legality, Jaffer's work at the ACLU, and more. shows.acast.com/lawfare/episodes/lawfare-archive-jameel-j…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
On How to Become Famous and (I regret to report) its author. #buthedoesnotwearglasses
www.newyorker.com/magazine/2024/05/20/a-semi-famous-fame-… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Terrific Harvard Law Review emergency docket Note # 2: Tom Koenig, “Halting Administrative Action in the Supreme Court” harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-137/halting-administrative…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Terrific Harvard Law Review emergency docket Note #1: John Czubek, “The Role of Certiorari in Emergency Relief” harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-137/the-role-of-certiorari…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My conversation w David Pozen about his important new book, “The Constitution of the War on Drugs.” Amazingly, it can be downloaded for free: papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4692949. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/lawfare-daily-david-pozen-on…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
David Ignatius
@IgnatiusPost
Some bracing questions from @matthew_gluck of @lawfare about the space warfare issues in my new novel “Phantom Orbit.” www.lawfaremedia.org/article/chatter-phantom-orbit-with-j…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
The Economic Constitution of the United States.
pubs.aeaweb.org/doi/pdfplus/10.1257/jep.38.2.25 -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Good student Note: "Equity and the Power of Procedural Supervision" harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-137/equity-and-the-power-o…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
The only real issue
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
James Burnham on Michael Dreeben's strangest argument for presidential immunity. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/05/01/jack-smith-arg…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
Amazing new paper by Justin Driver on antisubordination theory and its strange career lawreview.uchicago.edu/print-archive/strange-career-antis…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Yes it does.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take on the reaction in some quarters to the oral argument in Trump v. US. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/catastrophizing-the-oral-arg…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Preet Bharara
@PreetBharara
Should former President Trump be immune from criminal charges for actions taken while in office? SCOTUS heard oral arguments yesterday and @lawfareblog's @jacklgoldsmith and I broke it down. Listen: cafe.com/stay-tuned/trumps-scotus-immunity-jack-goldsmith/
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@JoshMBlackman on the clear statement rule that came up in oral argument in Trump v US. reason.com/volokh/2024/04/25/presidential-bribery-and-the… via @reason
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Grateful to @PreetBharara for having me on his show to talk about Trump v. US. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/stay-tuned-with-preet/id126…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The argument went as I thought it would. No real appetite for Trump's v broad immunity argument, and near-exclusive concern about the impact on future presidencies--abusive and virtuous--and with the application/constitutionality issues getting big play. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-core-issues-in-trump-v.-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
True. This case raises v important issues, and it is v. hard to write a narrow opinion that will not massively impact future presidents (which was the Court's main concern today). It might not see these issues again for a long time and has to think through the implications now.
Rick Pildes
@RickPildes
I want to make this point again about today's immunity argument. The Court could have decided to approach the issues narrowly, with a focus on the specific acts alleged in the indictment and how any theory of immunity might apply to them. That approach would likely produce a decision sooner.
Or the Court could have -- as it did -- attempt to think through the full range of issues to attempt to generate a broad set of principles on the scope of immunity generally.
I didn't see any difference between the liberal and conservative Justices on this. All took the second path. A Justice who thought it was urgent to try to issue a decision quickly would have pushed hard on that first path. I didn't see anyone doing that.
@steve_vladeck @rgoodlaw @jedshug
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Also, the Court as an institution has no huge impulse to hurry, as we saw from the cert grant and April argument, w/o dissent.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Ed Whelan
@EdWhelanEPPC
Jack Goldsmith’s Road Map on Trump v. United States www.nationalreview.com/bench-memos/jack-goldsmiths-road-m…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion w Robert Lighthizer on his 2023 book “No Trade is Free” and his very influential trade views.
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/lawfare-daily-ambassador-rob… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
I’d say not a nationalist project fundamentally-but even to the extent it is, one that broadens opportunity and shares fairly in the new economy rather than hankering for manufacturing?
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
I’m very grateful for the generous blurbs for my forthcoming book. I do feel like it’s one of the best things I’ve written, and it reflects decades of my thinking about the foreign affairs powers of the government. It’s never too early to pre-order!
www.amazon.com/Historical-Gloss-Foreign-Affairs-Constitut… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
What is that plausible sequel? 😊
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
Fascinating Robert Lighthizer interview. Hard to think of a more transformative recent US government official, though ultimately his 1950s restorationism is not a plausible sequel to the neoliberalism he’s done more than anyone to displace. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-lawfare-podcast/id49889…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
Fascinating Robert Lighthizer interview. Hard to think of a more transformative recent US government official, though ultimately his 1950s restorationism is not a plausible sequel to the neoliberalism he’s done more than anyone to displace. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-lawfare-podcast/id49889…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My (long, sorry) take on the Trump v. U.S. immunity case.
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-core-issues-in-trump-v.-… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
"Just about any conceivable use of force in the Middle East can be justified under an Article II self-defense theory. Which means that a lot rests on the president’s, and his subordinates’, prudence." www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-middle-east-and-the-pres…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Volokh Conspiracy
@VolokhC
[Stephen E. Sachs] Remarks to the HLS FedSoc Alumni Dinner reason.com/volokh/2024/04/10/remarks-to-the-hls-fedsoc-al…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
The American Law Institute
@AmLawInst
Bipartisan group issues guidance for Insurrection Act Reform. Led by Bob Bauer @nyulaw and @jacklgoldsmith @Harvard_Law, the document proposes deleting antiquated terms and strengthening conditions for the Act’s use. www.ali.org/news/articles/guidance-insurrection-act-refor…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Cass Sunstein
@CassSunstein
Coming in (gulp) Sept.: CAMPUS FREE SPEECH: A POCKET GUIDE. Many thanks, @Harvard_Press #pedaltothemetal @sapinker @JonHaidt @jacklgoldsmith @JonahDispatch @nytdavidbrooks
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Very important issue and argument.
www.lawfaremedia.org/article/there-is-no-general-first-am… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Congrats to @samuelmoyn and great for Hopper College.
Samuel Moyn 🔭
@samuelmoyn
Someone gave me responsibility 🤷🏻♂️
Seriously: this will be great! news.yale.edu/2024/04/03/samuel-moyn-named-next-head-hopp… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
On today's Lawfare Podcast, @matthew_gluck talked to Chuck Rosenberg, Ben Wittes, @jacklgoldsmith, and @qjurecic about the history of the special counsel institution and its predecessors, its current flaws, and how it should change. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-lawfare-podcast-what-sho…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Down the emergency orders docket rabbit hole with @thomaskoenig98 re the Trump v. U.S. order granting certiorari. Thanks to @marty_lederman, @steve_vladeck, @RichardMRe, and @WilliamBaude for help and comments, though none should be assumed to agree. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-continue-withholding-dir…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Trump brief in immunity case raises key hypothetical for understanding the complexities: Would Prez Obama be immune from criminal prosecution for targeted killing of U.S. citizens abroad by drone strike without due process? If so, under what theory?
www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/23/23-939/303418/202403191…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Trump brief cites special counsel from oral argument below: See, e.g., J.A.164 (Special Counsel admitting that a “drone strike” where “civilians were killed … might be the kind of place in which the Court would properly recognize some kind of immunity”)
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
This hypo also highlights the tricky position Special Counsel (and DOJ) face in articulating a principle that gives Trump no immunity but that (as DOJ typically seeks to do) protects presidential prerogatives going forward. This is the key to the case IMO.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Matthew Waxman
@mattwaxman1
For those interested in war powers and interbranch checks, my exchange @YaleLJournal w/ @becingber, in which she calls the status quo worse than most critics think and I call it better.
www.yalelawjournal.org/collection/exchange-war-powers-and… -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Slant Books
@SlantBooks
"Matters for You Alone," a brand-new collection by the gifted poet, Leslie Williams, coming soon from @SlantBooks. Watch this space!
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Soren Dayton
@sorendayton
Everyone who worries about unlimited executive branch power and Congress giving up power needs to think hard about why not a single Member of Congress of either party has forced a vote on the Houthi strikes.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I am late to this outstanding piece by @calabresim on the intelligence community strategic declassification efforts.
time.com/6835724/americas-intelligence-secrets/ -
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Curtis Bradley
@curtisabradley
Page proofs!
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The @HarvardFedSoc is hosting the Federalist Society National Student Symposium this weekend on the subject “Why Separate Powers?” All of the panels will be streamed online live or available to watch after the event.
Harvard Federalist Society
@HarvardFedSoc
Beginning later this evening, we'll post links to live video from the 2024 @FedSoc National Student Symposium on the theme #whyseparatepowers. For a complete schedule or to bookmark the broadcasts you'd like to see, visit: fedsoc.org/conferences/2024-national-student-symposium
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Harvard Federalist Society
@HarvardFedSoc
Beginning later this evening, we'll post links to live video from the 2024 @FedSoc National Student Symposium on the theme #whyseparatepowers. For a complete schedule or to bookmark the broadcasts you'd like to see, visit: fedsoc.org/conferences/2024-national-student-symposium
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Good interview with @ByronTau about his new book on how the government skirts intelligence law and policy by purchasing commercially available public information.
Lawfare
@lawfare
On today's Lawfare Podcast, @jacklgoldsmith talked to @ByronTau about his book, “Means of Control,” why the government can purchase bulk private data with few legal restrictions, and the threat to privacy and civil liberties that inheres in the practice. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-lawfare-podcast-the-hidd…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Lawfare
@lawfare
On today's Lawfare Podcast, @jacklgoldsmith talked to @ByronTau about his book, “Means of Control,” why the government can purchase bulk private data with few legal restrictions, and the threat to privacy and civil liberties that inheres in the practice. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-lawfare-podcast-the-hidd…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Noah Feldman
@profnoahfeldman
Audiobook, read by yours truly, available today -- so is the hard cover!
www.audible.com/pd/To-Be-a-Jew-Today-Audiobook/B0CMYQ23NB -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My interview with @lessig about his important new book with @Matt_Seligman -- How to Steal a Presidential Election.
Lawfare
@lawfare
On today's Lawfare Podcast, @jacklgoldsmith talked to Lawrence Lessig about his new book, “How to Steal a Presidential Election,” the complex role of faithless electors, strategic behavior related to recounts, and more. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-lawfare-podcast-how-to-s…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
1. Another QU in Trump v US: What role (if any) will the SG and AG have behind the scenes? The Special Counsel “must consult w/ appropriate offices within the Dept. for guidance with respect to established practices, policies and procedures of the Dept.” www.ecfr.gov/current/title-28/chapter-VI/part-600
Post not available here, view on X
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
3. One challenge for the Special Counsel, and the Department more generally, is to convince the Court that its prosecution of Trump will not have unduly adverse implications for future presidents.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
4. This tension between the aim of prosecuting Trump and the aim of protecting future presidencies was on display a bit in the courts below. But it will be much more front and center at the Supreme Court. This tension is, I think, the main reason the Court granted cert.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
1. Quick speculation about the QU the Court crafted in Trump v. US: “Whether and if so to what extent does a former President enjoy presidential immunity from criminal prosecution for conduct alleged to involve official acts during his tenure in office.” www.supremecourt.gov/orders/courtorders/022824zr3_febh.pdf
Post not available here, view on X
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
9. Note: I'm purposefully vague on “core” Article II functions. It might mean all Article II powers. Or it might include only a subset of powers, though I think it would need to go beyond exclusive Article II powers. Still thinking this through. Again, all speculation.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
10. PS: Note the amazing power that inheres in the Court’s discretion to craft the question presented.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Related thoughts from a different piece. (The Court did not stay but did the functional equivalent by withholding the mandate until it decides the case.) www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-consequences-of-jack-smi…
Damon Linker
@DamonLinker
Jack Goldsmith disagrees and he’s a far better guide to the court than Judge Luttig, whose track record by this point is pretty bad.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
Teaching Constitutional Law in a Crisis of Judicial Legitimacy reason.com/volokh/2024/02/26/teaching-constitutional-law-…
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Adrian Vermeule
@Vermeullarmine
When are we going to have a big New York Times piece about the crisis in teaching administrative law after SCOTUS’ treatment of interim final rules in Little Sisters? 😭
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Noah Feldman
@profnoahfeldman
It’s happening. Out March 5. The product of three years of work and roughly 50 years of love and struggle.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
William Baude
@WilliamBaude
The Ohio v. EPA Oral Argument and Standards of Review on The Emergency Docket -- Thomas Koenig journals.law.harvard.edu/jlpp/ohio-v-epa-oral-argument-an…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@charlie_savage with several war-related legal scoops—including the latest forthcoming executive branch circumvention of the war power’s resolution. www.nytimes.com/2024/02/22/us/politics/biden-congress-hou…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Good analysis of Great Lakes by @Tarheel_Lawprof. tlblog.org/u-s-supreme-court-decides-great-lakes/
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
1. This @protctdemocracy brief gives away the game in its 1st sentence, which cites Barker v. Wingo—a case about the *defendant’s* right to a speedy trial—in support of “the public’s profound interest” in a speedy trial against Trump. www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/23/23A745/300593/202402141…
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
2. Barker's “societal interest in providing a speedy trial” wasn’t speaking about rushing a defendant, but rather about the costs to society of *state-sponsored* delay.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
3. The Court mentioned that delay “is not an uncommon defense tactic,” but only to show that violation of the D’s speedy trial rights are not always prejudicial. And the Court emphasized the “concern that all accused persons be treated according to decent and fair procedures.”
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
4. Perhaps “preventing the existential threat of Trump’s return to the presidency justifies violating DOJ rules and the normal rules of fairness to a D.” But those who seek to preserve norms should be attentive to the costs of doing so in a one-sided way. www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-consequences-of-jack-smi…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Tom Koenig has an interesting and informed take on Ohio v. EPA oral argument and emergency docket standards of review. journals.law.harvard.edu/jlpp/ohio-v-epa-oral-argument-an…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Peter Thiel's Feb. 10 Keynote address at Harvard Conservative and Republican Student Conference, followed by a conversation between Thiel and @Vermeullarmine. www.youtube.com/watch?v=euzxpbBOju8
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Stephen E. Sachs
@StephenESachs
This is truly an honor. Harvard's FedSoc does such great work, and I'm very glad to be a part of it.
Harvard Federalist Society
@HarvardFedSoc
We are delighted to announce that @StephenESachs will serve as the new faculty advisor to the Harvard Federalist Society. Professor Sachs succeeds the late Professor Charles Fried, who served as the chapter's advisor since its founding.
-
Jack Goldsmith reposted
Soren Dayton
@sorendayton
This is fascinating and forces you to confront how weak constitutional law can be. A very important reminder.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My interview with Daryl Levinson about his important new book, "Law for Leviathan: Constitutional Law, International Law, and the State" www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-lawfare-podcast-constitu…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A friend says I am wrong in claiming in my piece on Smith: “It would not be *too out of the ordinary* for the Court to grant certiorari in mid-to-late February and put the case on its docket for decision this term by June.” www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-consequences-of-jack-smi…
Post not available here, view on X
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
But as my friend points out, the Court granted three cases on 1/12, over a month ago, and scheduled two for this term and one for next term. And it granted on 1/22 and scheduled for next term.
www.supremecourt.gov/orders/23grantednotedlist.pdf
www.supremecourt.gov/orders/24grantednotedlist.pdf
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
So granting now and scheduling in April would be out of the ordinary at a minimum compared to other grants this term. But doing so would still distance the Court from Smith’s rush-to-trial request for a March oral argument.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My interview with Daryl Levinson about his important new book, "Law for Leviathan: Constitutional Law, International Law, and the State" www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-lawfare-podcast-constitu…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Garland appointed Smith + Hur to vindicate DOJ norms of independence, etc. Both special counsels are deeply impacting prez election in ways that 2 different halves of country will view as bringing discredit on DOJ. Much to reflect on re rule of law, "independence," and politics.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion with @cliff_sloan about his excellent new book, "The Court at War: FDR, His Justices, and the World They Made." www.lawfaremedia.org/article/the-lawfare-podcast-the-cour…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
A new draft piece with @curtisabradley -- "Foreign Affairs, Nondelegation, and the Major Questions Doctrine." Fun topic, with many interesting, hard, unresolved issues. Comments welcome. papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4619040
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Looking forward to this symposium on "The Statutory Foreign Affairs Presidency" at @pennlaw on October 13 -- great lineup of participants. www.eventbrite.com/e/the-statutory-foreign-affairs-presid…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
This is one of the least appreciated and understudied "loopholes" in government surveillance laws: USG buys vasts amounts of data from private firms, basically without constitutional or statutory restriction. www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-spy-agencies-buy-vast-quantities…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion with @JeffreyToobin about his new book--Homegrown: Timothy McVeigh and the Rise of Right-Wing Extremism. www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-timothy-mcveigh-and-r…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@curtisabradley and I are organizing a symposium with @PennLRev on "The Statutory Foreign Affairs Presidency." The "Call for Papers" is below.
University of Pennsylvania Law Review @PennLRev
The University of Pennsylvania Law Review is now accepting paper abstracts for our Vol. 172 Symposium Issue, "The Statutory Foreign Affairs Presidency." Abstracts are due by July 7, 2023. We look forward to reading your submissions!
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Second of two pieces with @curtisabradley on Turkiye Halk Bankasi v. United States. If FSIA does not govern immunity, what law, if any, does? www.lawfareblog.com/turkiye-halk-bankasi-v-united-states-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
On why the FSIA immunizes foreign states from criminal prosecution. With @curtisabradley. (First of two posts on Turkiye Halk Bankasi A.S. v. United States.) www.lawfareblog.com/turkiye-halk-bankasi-v-united-states-…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My discussion with @beverlygage about her outstanding, relentlessly rich and informative new bio of J Edgar Hoover. I have studied Hoover for two decades but learned something new in every one of the 58 chapters. www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-j-edgar-hoover-and-ma…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The entire prepublication review edifice rests on a 3-sentence footnote in the procedural history section of a shadow docket summary reversal decision, Snepp, issued w/o merits briefing or oral argument, as @oonahathaway and I explain. www.lawfareblog.com/prepublication-review-and-quicksand-f…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@oonahathaway and I are Amici in support of cert. in the @knightcolumbia/@aclu challenge to the appalling, colossal system of prior restraint known as "prepublication review." (Huge thanks to David Zimmer and Ben Hayes for their outstanding work.) www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/21/21-791/206746/202112291…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Three more terrific papers in the @HooverInst Aegis series on the (understudied) topic of government access to marketplace data as a tool for circumventing the 4th Amendment.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Thanks to Katerina Linos for a great conversation (along with @oonahathaway and @curtisabradley) about a paper Oona, Curt and I are writing on nonbinding agreements.
@BerkeleyLaw www.law.berkeley.edu/podcast-episode/non-binding-agreements/ -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Excited about great Hoover Aegis essays on govt circumvention of 4th Am. via buying data in private marketplace:
@lynch_jen:
www.hoover.org/sites/default/files/research/docs/lynch_we…
@barryfriedman1: www.hoover.org/sites/default/files/research/docs/friedman…
@Farhang_Heydari: www.hoover.org/sites/default/files/research/docs/heydari_…
@JaneYakowitz www.hoover.org/sites/default/files/research/docs/bambauer… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
The ideas in this old (7 years) but great paper by @BobbyChesney -- esp. the post-armed conflict "continuous-threat" framework -- will have increasing relevance for US ops in the "endless war" after US w/drwal fr Afghanistan & pull-back elsewhere. poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=321102020088086121087…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Sliding Into War Watch:
www.politico.com/news/2021/07/10/biden-iraq-syria-respons… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Looking forward to this: "The Broken Constitution: Lincoln, Slavery, and the Refounding of America," by @NoahRFeldman.
www.amazon.com/Broken-Constitution-Lincoln-Slavery-Refoun… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Nothing like this anywhere: @BobbyChesney compares U.S. and U.K. cyber law and policy regimes.
Hugely learned and interesting.
Lawfare
@lawfare
"Adapting to the Cyber Domain: Comparing U.S. and U.K. Institutional, Legal and Policy Innovations," the latest from @BobbyChesney: www.lawfaremedia.org/adapting-cyber-domain-comparing-us-a…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Challenging but great job.
www.lawfareblog.com/come-work-lawfare-our-managing-editor -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Self-defeating: "Officials" tell NYT that "over the next three weeks" the USG will engage in "a series of covert counterstrikes on Russian networks." USG is only country that regularly signals and boasts about its "secret" offensive cyber ops.
www.nytimes.com/2021/03/07/us/politics/microsoft-solarwin… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
.@ProfBrianKalt has studied this more thoroughly than anyone. His full analysis here, poseidon01.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=460001024021103092092…, and in brief in this podcast, www.lawfareblog.com/lawfare-podcast-late-impeachments. There is no clear cut answer here, but the balance of considerations cuts in favor of late impeachments IMO.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Very informative update. "Some of the compromised SolarWinds software was engineered in Eastern Europe, and American investigators are now examining whether the incursion originated there, where Russian intelligence operatives are deeply rooted." www.nytimes.com/2021/01/02/us/politics/russian-hacking-go…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Important, recently published OLC foreign relations law ops: (1) POTUS has authority to w/draw from NAFTA (10-18). www.justice.gov/olc/file/1347516/download. (2) Congressional advance notice restriction on POTUS’ w/drawal from Open Skies Treaty is unconstitutional (9/20). www.justice.gov/olc/file/1348136/download.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
This is an indispensable podcast--by @BobbyChesney and @steve_vladeck--for national security geeks. Super-duper-serious expertise, conveyed clearly, on all the important topics, week after week.
Lawfare
@lawfare
"The National Security Law Podcast: Not *That* Enterprise," the latest from @bobbychesney and @steve_vladeck: www.lawfaremedia.org/national-security-law-podcast-not-en…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Years of work went in to this one. Thx to great co-authors @oonahathaway & @curtisabradley, & the many students who helped over the years, & @HarvLRev editors. "The Failed Transparency Regime For Executive Agreements: An Empirical And Normative Analysis." harvardlawreview.org?p=6685
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
New book, out today. From preface: "We are worried about the institution of the presidency, we believe reform is necessary, and we worry about the wrong types of reform. This book is our effort to frame the debate and strike the right balance."
www.amazon.com/After-Trump-Reconstructing-Bob-Bauer/dp/17… -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
I’ve been thinking whether in American presidential history there’s ever been an act of cowardice and impotence as brazen as @realDonaldTrump's “I don’t take responsibility at all” comment, followed by his efforts—3+ years into his term—to blame his predecessors. 1/
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
GAO concludes that OMB withholding of funds appropriated to DOD for security assistance to Ukraine violated the Impoundment Control Act (ICA).
www.gao.gov/assets/710/703909.pdf -
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
It arrived. Seven+ years of investigation and learning, packed into 313 pages. Pub date in 3.5 weeks, September 24. inhoffasshadow.com
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
1/ A few reflections on the distributional consequences of the “Federal Law Clerk Hiring Plan” announced in February 2018. The plan was a two-year “pilot program” and was voluntary in the sense that only participating judges were bound by it.
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
It is heartening to see my friend Eric Posner come round from the thesis of this book, www.amazon.com/Executive-Unbound-After-Madisonian-Republi…, to the thesis of this book, www.amazon.com/Power-Constraint-Accountable-Presidency-Af… www.nytimes.com/2019/04/23/opinion/mueller-report-trump-w…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Sober, informed take on today's filings. www.lawfareblog.com/totally-clears-president-what-those-m…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My quick take on yesterday's events. tws.io/2NcjgYJ
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
Agree that 1994 opinion is important because it articulated the “anticipated nature, scope, and duration” test for war in constitutional sense that might require congressional authorization. But that goes to prong 2 of the contemporary test, not prong 1, which we focused on. END
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
@samuelmoyn on Jesner v. Arab Bank lawfareblog.com/time-pivot-thoughts-jesner-v-arab-bank
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My take: The Cost of Trump's Attacks on the FBI - The Atlantic www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/12/the-high-pri…
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
It is hard to exaggerate how demoralizing this is for people who work in DOJ. It's not just that the President says this. It's also, and especially, that the Attorney General does not stand up for the Department, either because he can't, or does not care.
Donald J. Trump
@realDonaldTrump
Many people in our Country are asking what the “Justice” Department is going to do about the fact that totally Crooked Hillary, AFTER receiving a subpoena from the United States Congress, deleted and “acid washed” 33,000 Emails? No justice!
-
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
1/ Trump’s actions since January, & especially in last month, take us so far beyond normal that it’s hard to have any faith in Exec branch.




























































































































































































































































