Here's why the Mirabelli v Bonta case is so important for the entire nation: over 1000 school districts across the country have the same kinds of policies at issue now. Remember, teachers were being forced to honor a student's transgender identity on campus AND hide that information from parents. Here's why these policies are so widespread:
In 2016, GLSEN came out with the first model policy for trans-identified students on school campuses which advocated for secrecy from parents. This policy was developed, disseminated, and endorsed by the National Education Association, the American Federation for Teachers, the National School Boards Association, and the National School Counselors Association. I've spoken to multiple school board members who passed policies like this after being told these policies were just about student privacy, etc. But when you look into that GLSEN model policy document you find recommendations for deceptive record keeping and even discussion about how to hide trans identities from non-affirming siblings in case the story might get home to mom and dad. This was an incredibly radical document.
Shortly after that, the Obama administration changed the way schools were to handle Title IX, changing its protections from being sex-based to gender-based and sent out guidance encouraging schools to treat students according to their gender identity rather than their biological sex.
The adoption of these policies picked up rapidly across the country with little public awareness until 2020 hit. It was at that point that Covid kept kids home, and parents began to discover what on earth was happening at their schools -- and it wasn't pretty.
What teachers Mirabelli and West stood up against was the morally reprehensible idea of lying to confused kids by pretending they were something they're not, and lying to loving parents who needed to know what was happening to these students. They did this in California, but the results of their suit will benefit schools across America. Kids need their parents involved, and parents need to know what's going on with their kids.
In vacating the 9th Circuit Court's stay on Judge Roger Benitez's emergency injunction against these parental secrecy policies while the case works its way through the appellate process, the Supreme Court said, "The State argues that its policies advance a compelling interest in student safety and privacy. But those policies cut out the primary protectors of children's best interests: their parents."
This is good for the nation's kids, families, and teachers. We never should have gotten here, but we did. And I think we should take a SERIOUS look at the NEA and its ilk who helped get us here.
I'm so glad those teachers said no, and the Thomas More Society helped them do it.
www.thomasmoresociety.org/news