More technical detail on what Claude found in Gödel
Very cool AI-assisted work!
I'm currently in an email thread (via Dana Scott) w/ Jan von Plato, who led this effort, & he sent us his Claude-assisted writeup.
While Gödel's notes do *not* actually have a proof of the independence of AC from full set theory (ZF), from what I can tell so far:
1. Gödel's notebooks instead contained a proof of independence of the axiom of constructibility in type theory (by 1942).
2. Jan, working w/ Claude, reconstructed and completed Gödel's unfinished argument to prove the independence of the Axiom of Choice *in type theory* (Gödel was missing a key definition that makes comprehension hold in the model where AC fails).
3. In proving 1, Gödel had anticipated, 23-24 years prior, many of the central ideas from Boolean-valued forcing (BVF), which was Dana & Bob Solovay's '65-66 simplification of Cohen's original '63 forcing, for which Cohen got the only Fields Medal in logic.
For example, it looks like Gödel had much of the machinery for assigning Boolean truth values to mathematical statements*, but hadn't completed the construction of an entire universe of sets governed by those truth values.
* - E.g. Gödel had finite observations playing the role of Cohen forcing conditions, regular open sets as Boolean truth values, and Boolean interpretations of logical connectives & quantifiers. (However, Gödel lacked the full transfinite construction of a Boolean-valued universe of sets, together with a proof that it obeys all the rules of ZF set theory.)
4. On Jan's reading, in how Gödel develops the precursors to Boolean-valued forcing, you can see how his post-1944 Platonism could coexist with his earlier use of intuitionistic methods which, prior to this, was a bit of a puzzle that Sol Feferman & others acknowledged.
Namely, Gödel's precursors to BVF support a philosophical view of observations from a finite observer defining neighborhoods of possible worlds & regular open sets giving Boolean truth values.
In other words, Gödel believed mathematical reality needn't be limited solely to what a finite observer can construct or determine.
Hidden secrets unlocked in Gödel's notebooks, with AI translating the mysterious Gabelsberger script, finding numerous unknown proofs, including an argument for the consistency of the negation of the axiom of choice.
www.theguardian.com/science/2026/nov/13/kurt-godel-notebo…















































































































































































































































































































































































