I'm very proud to say that Kill List has won an Edward R Murrow award for journalism - huge congrats to the team and, as ever, a massive thank you to everyone who made the series possible.
www.rtdna.org/2025-national-edward-r-murrow-award-winners
Carl Miller (author)
Carl Jack Miller is an author, speaker and researcher at Demos, a think tank based in London, where he co-founded the Centre for the Analysis of Social Media (CASM) in 2012. As of 2019 Miller is also a visiting scholar and research fellow at King's College, London. More on Wikipedia
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
-
Carl Miller reposted
DW Global Media Forum
@DW_GMF
"We have to re-understand what being a journalist does mean. Our job will be to help people navigate what is real or not," stated @carljackmiller.
-
Carl Miller reposted
DW Global Media Forum
@DW_GMF
"AI is reshaping the profession of journalism itself: how audiences are reached, the skills that are needed and even perhaps what journalism really is", says @carljackmiller. He shares his take on how AI is rewriting the rules of journalism and what he hopes to discuss at #gmf25.
-
Carl Miller reposted
UnHerd
@unherd
Over half of CharacterAI’s users are under 24 and many, judging from Reddit, are much younger than that.
Read @carljackmiller on the next generation’s favourite AI 👇
unherd.com/2025/06/will-chatbots-become-cult-leaders/ -
Carl Miller reposted
Literary Review
@Lit_Review
As Apple has grown, one country above all has proved able to supply the skills and capacity it needs: China.
What compromises has Apple made in its pivot east? @carljackmiller investigates.
literaryreview.co.uk/return-of-the-mac -
Carl Miller reposted
UnHerd
@unherd
‘The difference is that ChatGPT wants you to use AI to solve a problem you care about. CharacterAI wants you to care about the AI itself.’
Read @carljackmiller 👇
unherd.com/2025/06/will-chatbots-become-cult-leaders/ -
Carl Miller reposted
Literary Review
@Lit_Review
Out now! Literary Review's June 2025 issue, featuring
Piers Brendon on A C Benson
@RichardvReeves on the manosphere
@zoeguttenplan on Virginia Woolf
Tanya Harrod on Gwen & Augustus John
@carljackmiller on Apple in China
and much, much more: literaryreview.co.uk -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If you're going to be at @hayfestival this weekend, come and talk with me and @JamieJBartlett about true crime podcasting and the various pressures, highs and lows that come with long-term investigative journalism
www.hayfestival.com/p-23411-jamie-bartlett-and-carl-mille… -
Carl Miller reposted
The Thinking Digital Conference
@ThinkingDigital
Meet the Minds of #tdc25 on 14 & 15 May..
🚀@juliantreasure: a TED Talk Titan on reconnecting with our powers of listening;
🚀@erinkinnee: an @AccentureUK innovation strategist on how emerging tech will change the future of collaboration;
🚀@conradwolfram: on the future of AI beyond Generative AI;
🚀@drupad_t & @stumpw0rk50 of @OfficialUoM: on the incredible story of how a nurse with olfactory superpowers is changing early disease detection;
🚀@carljackmiller: on the unbelievable truth of the people hiring assassins via the Dark Web;
🚀Sophia Rose Long of @NorthumbriaUni: on how microwave technology represents the future of communication hardware, cybersecurity and quantum computing.
🚀@AndyStanfordClark of @IBMUKI: discussing AI and autonomous ships;
🚀@natashaboulding of @LowCarbonM: an @EarthshotPrize finalist on her efforts to turn buildings & roads into carbon sinks;
🚀BrendanDawes: a digital explorer on his work blending code, data, design & art;
🚀Emer Maguire: a @FameLab winner who blends singing, songwriting, humour & science in her unique performances.
👉Join us on May 14 & 15, 2025, for an unforgettable experience. thinkingdigital.co.uk/speakers/ -
Carl Miller reposted
DW Global Media Forum
@DW_GMF
At #gmf25, you will get the chance to experience key notes as well as panel discussions and get in touch with experts like Carl Miller, Nighat Dad, Nic Newman, Olga Rudenko and many more! Find out who else is joining #gmf25 and register now via www.dw.com/gmf 🎟️
-
Carl Miller reposted
The World Today
@TheWorldToday
Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg have made big changes to their social media platforms.
@carljackmiller & @akrasodomski consider the geopolitical implications of a fragmenting online ‘public square’.
www.chathamhouse.org/publications/the-world-today/2025-03… -
Carl Miller reposted
The Thinking Digital Conference
@ThinkingDigital
A quick reminder that Early Bird registration ends tomorrow, Thursday 3 April at 5pm.
We’ve just revealed our first six speakers, and they are absolutely brilliant:
🚀 Andy Stanford-Clark – How an AI-powered ship sailed the Atlantic with no crew 🛳️🤖
🚀Emer Maguire – The hilarious reality of being an autistic adult 🎤😂
🚀@conradwolfram – The future of AI, computing & human intelligence – are we ready? 🤯💻
🚀@carljackmiller – Unraveling a Dark Web murder-for-hire conspiracy 🕵️💀
🚀Dr. Natasha Boulding:– Turning buildings into carbon sinks to fight climate change 🏗️🌱
🚀Brendan Dawes – The rise of generative AI in art & a film with 52 quintillion versions 🎨🎬
Be sure to invest in yourself in 2025 by joining us on the 14th & 15th of May. You won't regret it!
thinkingdigital.co.uk/register/ -
Carl Miller reposted
The Thinking Digital Conference
@ThinkingDigital
Thinking Digital 2025 will be our sixteenth Conference and looks set to be our best ever! The journey to hashtag #tdc25 begins with six amazing innovators including..
🚀 Andy Stanford-Clark: Former IBM UK CTO & IBM Master Inventor who'll talk on how he recreated the Pilgrims journey to Plymouth, USA but this time with a radically updated, AI-powered, autonomous version of the Mayflower vessel! 🚢
🚀 @carljackmiller : Host of The Guardian's no 1 podcast of 2024, the Kill List, on how he discovered a Dark Web assassination website and the stunning identities of those who were hiring to kill via the Internet. 👀
🚀 Dr. Natasha Boulding: CEO & Co-Founder of Low Carbon Materials (LCM) on her journey from a Durham University Material Sciences PhD to an internationally recognised startup seeking to turn the built environment into a global carbon sink. 🏠
🚀 @conradwolfram : The European CEO of the legendary software firm, Wolfram Research, who will paint a picture of the future of computing & AI. He's promising plenty of tech demos too. 🙌
🚀 Emer Maguire: She's the brilliantly funny singer songwriter of science who's coming to TDC to give her unexpected & entertaining insights on how she navigates the world as an autistic adult. 🎸
🚀 Brendan Dawes : He's the renowned digital artist who finds ingenious ways to bring data & code to physical objects and everyday items that provokes thought and elicits wonder. While he's based in Northern England you'll find his work featured at MOMA NYC or being auctioned by Sotheby's. 🤩
To learn more about our first six magnificent speakers please head over to.. thinkingdigital.co.uk/speakers/
Early Bird registration ends this Thursday, 3 April. -
Carl Miller reposted
Jack Rhysider 🏴☠️
@JackRhysider
New episode! 🚨
Ep 156: Kill List
Take my hand. We're going into the darknet.
Thanks to @carljackmiller and @Deku_shrub.
Special extra episode this month because I❤️u.
darknetdiaries.com/episode/156 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Ahoy there everyone! It's time: you can now book to set sail on the @WonderyExhibitC @SXMLiveLoud True Crime Cruise January 26-30, 2026. Connect with your favourite podcast hosts, attend expert panels and more.
Check it out at exhibitccruise.com. It will be unforgettable. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Thanks @TEDxManchester - that was awesome
-
Carl Miller reposted
Thomas @ TyneSight
@TyneSightPhoto
That’s the shot… #tedxmanchester @BridgewaterHall
-
Carl Miller reposted
South China Morning Post
@SCMPNews
Kill List, Law & Crime, America’s Most Wanted podcast hosts to join murder mystery cruise
www.scmp.com/lifestyle/travel-leisure/article/3299617/kil… -
Carl Miller reposted
TEDxManchester
@TEDxManchester
It's the most wonderful time of the year for our team as we announce the full 2025 speaker lineup! Please help us welcome twelve remarkable humans including.. 🙌
🔴 An Olympic Cycling Gold Medalist, @Chris_Boardman of Active Travel England
🔴 Host of the 'Kill List', Guardian's No 1-rated podcast of 2024, @carljackmiller
🔴 A Cancer Detection Innovator, @SimonaFrancese
🔴 An Anxiety Healer, Joshua Fletcher
🔴 A Bioengineering Explorer, Aled Deakin Roberts
🔴 An Artist's Whisperer, @AmieMcnee
🔴 A Hypnotic Mind Reader, @aaroncalvert
🔴 A Child Psychology Advisor, Dr Charlotte Armitage
🔴 An Inclusive Exercise Evangelist, @J7healthJaveno
🔴 A Grassroots Changemaker, @WarhurstPamela
🔴 A TV Doctor & Humourist, @kiranmorjaria
🔴 A Computer Scientist for Animals, @Ilyena
For talk topic summaries & full biographies please head over to our Speaker Page.. www.tedxmanchester.com/speakers-2025/
Join us on Saturday, 1 March at The Bridgewater Hall 🚀 -
Carl Miller reposted
TEDxManchester
@TEDxManchester
.@carljackmiller is host of podcast "Kill List", which was The @Guardian’s No. 1-rated podcast of 2024 & produced by @WonderyMedia. He joins #tedxmanchester to share the story of his discovery of a “murder for hire” site on the Dark Web, where hundreds were targeted for assassination, his battle to convince the police to act & the race to warn potential victims of the threat to their lives.
-
Carl Miller reposted
TEDxManchester
@TEDxManchester
@carljackmiller is the host of the hit podcast "Kill List", which was named The Guardian’s No. 1-rated podcast of 2024. As the founder of the Centre for the Analysis of Social Media at Demos and author of The Death of the Gods: The New Global Power Grab (Penguin), Carl is an expert in exploring the darker corners of the digital world.
He joins us at #tedxmanchester to share the gripping story of his discovery of a “murder for hire” site on the Dark Web, where hundreds were targeted for assassination, his battle to convince the police to act and the race to warn potential victims of the very real threat to their lives. -
Carl Miller reposted
Esperanza Escribano
@esperanzaec
El ex de Ana García contrató a un sicario en la deep web para matarla. No lo consiguió, pero a pesar de que se gastó 18.000 euros, sigue sin haber juicio. Han pasado cuatro años y Ana y yo nos hemos hecho amigas. Así empezó todo 🧵
-
Carl Miller reposted
TEDxManchester
@TEDxManchester
The journey to #tedxmanchester 2025 begins with six amazing people we can't wait for you to meet. Allow us to introduce..
🔴@carljackmiller: host of Kill List, the Guardian's No. 1 rated podcast of 2024;
🔴@simonafrancese: the chemist seeking to revolutionise cancer screening;
🔴@J7healthJaveno: the fitness evangelist specialising in inspiration & inclusion;
🔴Dr Charlotte A.: the psychologist helping us tame our smartphone addiction;
🔴@warhurstpamela: Yorkshire's extraordinary grassroots changemaker;
🔴@Chris_Boardman: the legendary Team GB Olympic cycling gold medalist
We hope you can join us! Early Bird ticketing ends this Friday, 24 Jan at 3pm.
For full info on our speakers & their talk topics please head over to tedxmanchester.com/speakers-2025/ -
Carl Miller reposted
TEDxManchester
@TEDxManchester
The journey to TEDxManchester 2025 begins with six amazing people we can't wait for you to meet. Allow us to introduce..
🔺@carljackmiller: host of Kill List, the Guardian's No. 1 rated podcast of 2024;
◼️@simonafrancese: the chemist seeking to revolutionise cancer screening;
🔺@J7healthJaveno: the fitness evangelist specialising in inspiration & inclusion;
◼️Dr Charlotte A.: the psychologist helping us tame our smartphone addiction;
🔺@warhurstpamela: Yorkshire's extraordinary grassroots changemaker;
◼️@Chris_Boardman: the legendary Team GB Olympic cycling gold medalist
We hope you can join us! Early Bird ticketing ends this Friday, 24 Jan at 3pm.
or full info on our speakers & their talk topics please head over to www.tedxmanchester.com/speakers-2025/ -
Carl Miller reposted
Esperanza Escribano
@esperanzaec
At last! Ana's story comes to light. You can listen to the full story on Kill List, thanks to the work of @carljackmiller and Novel. Meanwhile, Ana is still waiting for justice elpais.com/espana/galicia/2025-01-18/vivir-sabiendo-que-t…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Imperial War Museums
@I_W_M
What have artists and photographers exposed about the horrors of war—and how have governments tried to hide the truth?
In this week’s Conflict of Interest podcast, @carljackmiller takes a journey through art at IWM London to find out.
Listen: pod.fo/e/29ed75
<1/2> -
Carl Miller reposted
Frontline Club
@frontlineclub
We’re kicking off 2025 with a range of exciting, thought-provoking events. Join us on 14th January for ‘Investigating the Dark Web’, panel discussion with @lizziedearden and @carljackmiller. Tickets via the link below: www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/panel-discussion-investigating-the…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Podchaser
@Podchaser
And finally🥁🥁🥁…ranked number 🥇 in the #podchaser100 for hottest, up-and-coming podcasts of 2024…
Kill List
🎚️ @WonderyMedia & Novel
🎙️ @carljackmiller
Full list here: www.podchaser.com/lists/top-100-new-podcasts-in-2024-11SK…
www.podchaser.com/podcasts/kill-list-5838909 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
An extraordinary Christmas present: the Guardian named Kill List the best podcast of 2024. Very pleasing that our approach was seen as "methodical" rather than cliffhanger-chasing
Hope you're all having an amazing holiday everyone; see you all in 2025
www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2024/dec/24/the-20-best-… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
There is nothing stranger than speaking into a microphone in a dark, hot, sound dampened box for months on end, and that leading to a whole church-full of people with questions on what you've said. That was Kill List Live though, and here it is:
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/kill-list-live-part-1/id708… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The latest episode of Kill List is - probably - the most starkly shocking of any that we covered across the years of the investigation. It's really like none of others, and is out today.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/kill-list/id1769072368?i=10… -
Carl Miller reposted
David Gioe
@GioeINT
The Cambridge Security Initiative has launched a shorter 2 week academic program designed for professionals working in the intel and security space. We call it ISI-PRO. Apply here: thecsi.org.uk/isi-pro/ PLEASE retweet! @ISICambridge @77_msg @kclintelligence @dRichterova
-
Carl Miller reposted
Charlotte Henry
@charlotteahenry
Today's newsletter: The Power of the Podcast Live Show
theaddition.net/views/the-power-of-the-podcast-live-show/
Reflected on this after seeing @carljackmiller, @JamieJBartlett and co. on stage on Tuesday. -
Carl Miller reposted
Podchaser
@Podchaser
And finally…ranked number 🥇 in the #podchaser25 for hottest, up-and-coming podcasts of November 2024…
Kill List
🎚️ @WonderyMedia & Novel
🎙️ @carljackmiller
Full list here: blog.podchaser.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/Podchaser-2…
www.podchaser.com/podcasts/kill-list-5838909 -
Carl Miller reposted
Find That Pod
@FindThatPod
Happy Friday #podcast fans. Edition no. 290 of @FindThatPod is out.
5 great podcasts to discover:
🎙️ Hyperfixed @hyperfixedpod
🎙️ Dive Club
🎙️ A Fine Mess
🎙️ The Man Who Calculated Death @WonderyMedia
🎙️ Kill List
Till next week! -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Hey there everyone! In just over a week's time, we'll be at Union Chapel UK talking about the making of Kill List, with Intelligence Squared. Unheard material, possible future directions, and the realities of making it - it'll all be there. Come along :)
www.intelligencesquared.com/events/kill-list-live/ -
Carl Miller reposted
Jamie Bartlett 🇬🇧
@JamieJBartlett
This is going to great!!
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Hey there everyone! In just over a week's time, we'll be at Union Chapel UK talking about the making of Kill List, with Intelligence Squared. Unheard material, possible future directions, and the realities of making it - it'll all be there. Come along :)
www.intelligencesquared.com/events/kill-list-live/ -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The next episode of Kill List takes us to Sun Prairie, Wisconsin - where we tell Travis - an air traffic controller and former marine - that someone is trying to have him killed.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/kill-list/id1769072368?i=10…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Over the course of two episodes, we untangle the reality of a expansive, years-long battle fought across the local court, police, schools and hospitals.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Hey there everyone! In just over a week's time, we'll be at Union Chapel UK talking about the making of Kill List, with Intelligence Squared. Unheard material, possible future directions, and the realities of making it - it'll all be there. Come along :)
www.intelligencesquared.com/events/kill-list-live/ -
Carl Miller reposted
James Patterson
@JP_Books
Sometimes truth really is stranger than fiction. In this bonus episode of ‘Kill List,’ @carljackmiller and I talk about the differences (and surprising parallels) between reporting on real killers and writing fictional ones. podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/kill-list/id1769072368?i=10…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I spoke @JP_Books - one of the best selling authors of all time - where we reflected on the parallels and differences between the reality and fiction of crime. I was talking about our experiences on Kill List, and James his Alex Cross series.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/kill-list/id1769072368?i=10… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Our latest episode of Kill List is out today (Novel | @WonderyMedia) - is out today. It takes us to Knoxville, Tennessee, where we intercept a kill order on the same day the orderer was hoping to have their target, Anne, killed on her way to work.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/knoxville/id1769072368?i=10… -
Carl Miller reposted
Union Chapel London
@UnionChapelUK
"Every day, hundreds of people go about their lives with no idea that someone has paid to have them killed."
Stories & twists behind the hit podcast plus a chance to get your questions answered.
Kill List: Live | 3 Dec
Tickets at unionchapel.org.uk/venue/whats-on/kill-list-live
youtu.be/IPKAQlRUlgU -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Our latest episode of Kill List is out today (Novel | @WonderyMedia) - is out today. It takes us to Knoxville, Tennessee, where we intercept a kill order on the same day the orderer was hoping to have their target, Anne, killed on her way to work.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/knoxville/id1769072368?i=10…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Her husband, Nelson Reploge, is quickly arrested by the FBI - and the case quickly becomes a Whydunnit rather than a Whodunnit.
From COVID-induced personality change to possibly longer-standing motives, we try to untangle a really complicated bundle of possible explanations. -
Carl Miller reposted
Fox News
@FoxNews
Romanian scammers ran fake hitman-for-hire site, lured desperate perpetrators as 'incompetent assassins' www.foxnews.com/us/romanian-scammers-ran-fake-hitman-hire…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We are doing a LIVE EVENT about Kill List!
For @intelligence2 in collaboration with Novel and @WonderyMedia - it'll be at the absolutely beautiful venue of @UnionChapelUK in London. 3rd of December. It'll be a very special evening.
www.intelligencesquared.com/events/kill-list-live/ -
Carl Miller reposted
Great Pods - USC Startup
@GreatPods
'Top of the Pods' this past week on greatpods.co
5. Talk Tuah - @betr
4. Sweet Bobby - @tortoise
3. Kill List - @WonderyMedia
2. Hildy the Barback and the Lake of Fire - @LemonadaMedia
1. Sidebar: A Suits Watch Podcast - @Stitcher
#comedy #truecrime -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We are doing a LIVE EVENT about Kill List!
For @intelligence2 in collaboration with Novel and @WonderyMedia - it'll be at the absolutely beautiful venue of @UnionChapelUK in London. 3rd of December. It'll be a very special evening.
www.intelligencesquared.com/events/kill-list-live/ -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Nancy airs today, the latest episode of Kill List. It was really one of the first episodes that taught me that this whole investigation was less about the dark net, and more about the institutions that shape all of our lives and how they can fail.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/nancy/id1769072368?i=100067…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
In Nancy, a young woman has been trying to leave her abusive boyfriend for years. But when she finally does, the harassment doesn’t stop. She had been trying to raise the alarm long before we reached her with warnings of a secret dark net murder plot.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Entertainment Now
@EntmtNow
Podcast of the Week: The Kill List entertainment-now.com/2024/11/podcast-of-the-week-the-kil…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Intelligence Squared
@intelligence2
🔥 JUST ANNOUNCED: Kill list live with @carljackmiller this December in London.
Get your tickets at: www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/kill-list-live-tickets-1077442181569 -
Carl Miller reposted
Union Chapel London
@UnionChapelUK
Hit podcast KILL LIST comes to @intelligence2 at Union Chapel on 3 December.
@carljackmiller and producers share audio, outtakes and untold backstories about the making of the series, reveal new twists and answer your questions live.
Book now at unionchapel.org.uk/venue/whats-on/kill-list-live -
Carl Miller reposted
Amy Talks
@amytalkspodcast
I didn’t know @audibleuk created original podcasts, but their series about Michael Jackson was really intriguing 🤔
I’ve also got some new shows on my #followfriday list for this week - check them out 😄👇🏻🎧
@sarahtreleaven @jsmooth995 @audible_com @amandaseales -
Carl Miller reposted
Podchaser
@Podchaser
And finally…ranked number 🥇 in the #podchaser25 for hottest, up-and-coming podcasts of October 2024…
Kill List
🎚️ @WonderyMedia & Novel
🎙️ @carljackmiller
Full list here: blog.podchaser.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/11/Podchaser-2…
www.podchaser.com/podcasts/kill-list-5838909 -
Carl Miller reposted
Charlotte Henry
@charlotteahenry
I just had a great chat with @carljackmiller about his latest podcast, Kill List. You'll want to hear how he created this brilliant show:
theaddition.net/category/podcast/ -
Carl Miller reposted
rich turner
@ricardissimmo
Fantastic piece @loosewomen @ITV with @carljackmiller + @Cathornham on to talk about #1 hit podcast #killlist from @WonderyMedia and Novel
@indiehousepr #podcasts #wondery #truecrime -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Wow. What a day. I was on ITV Loose Women a few hours ago with Caroline Thornham talking about our new series, Kill List.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/kill-list/id1769072368This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
To go from an investigation that was continued in secret for a number of years to then - suddenly - be in a television studio is surreal, but I'm so grateful for the opportunity to reach all the people we did today with the story we've spent the last few years inhabiting.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The six episodes of Kill List so far has traced the years we investigated a murder-for-hire site on the dark net. But we've only scratched the surface.
From now on, each episode will dive deeply into a specific case on the Kill List.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/beverly-hills/id1769072368?… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The six episodes of Kill List so far has traced the years we investigated a murder-for-hire site on the dark net. But we've only scratched the surface.
From now on, each episode will dive deeply into a specific case on the Kill List.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/beverly-hills/id1769072368?…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
When a shy 19 year old from rural Arizona, applies to be the admin of a fan page for her favorite TV show, she has no idea it will lead to the FBI asking her to fake her own death.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Apple Podcasts
@ApplePodcasts
If you like… bombshell revelations. 😱
What would you do if you found a list of names on a murder-for-hire site?
In @WonderyMedia’s Kill List, @carljackmiller discovers a disturbing corner of the web and races to uncover the truth before it’s too late.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/kill-list/id1769072368?itsc… -
Carl Miller reposted
Dr. Sanjee Perera
@SanjeePerera1
A fascinating conversation about qualia, umwelt, epiphenomenalism, sapience, entrainment, animation, GAI and anthropocentrism in today's discussion of the #consciousplanet @morethanadodo with @NayanikaM, @mgreinecke, @thorogoodchris1, @carljackmiller, @kncukier & @WillemKuyken.
Dr. Sanjee Perera
@SanjeePerera1
Another interesting panel discussion on the #consciousplanet at @morethanadodo on October 25th in Oxford with experts including @NayanikaM, @mgreinecke, @thorogoodchris1, @carljackmiller, @kncukier & @WillemKuyken.
Book here: oxfordculturalprogramme.org.uk/event/conscious-planet/ -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Episode 5 of Kill List is out today. After several years of intercepting and disclosing assassination orders to law authorities and their targets, we decide that the only way of actually ending what we are doing is to learn more about the site itself and who operates it.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Forum @ NED
@ThinkDemocracy
New information spaces are being built to buttress democracy and connect international institutions directly with the public. This edition’s #bigstory is adapted from @carljackmiller’s essay, Reclaiming Technology for Democracy: www.ned.org/leveraging-ai-for-democracy-civic-innovation-…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Episode 5 of Kill List is out today. After several years of intercepting and disclosing assassination orders to law authorities and their targets, we decide that the only way of actually ending what we are doing is to learn more about the site itself and who operates it.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We find a sprawling and remarkably resourceful cybercrime empire that includes (believe it or not) a hitman-for-hire comparison site, tons of search engine manipulation and a disinformation campaign targeting the very person who created it.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If all of this sounds weird, it's because it is, but it also does have some more general lessons about how influence works online and how beliefs are most effectively manipulated.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/yura/id1769072368?i=1000670… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Happy weekend everyone
We've reached episode 4 of Kill List this week. It marks marks a real inflection point in the investigation. It all began with a small team trying to make sense of these orders from the dark net. Then, it moved off the dark net... -
Carl Miller reposted
chris evans
@notcapnamerica
Listening to a podcast about a journalist who discovered that there’s a page on the dark web where people are paying in bitcoin to have their loved ones murdered.
Whoever runs the page is scamming people, taking their money and then not carrying out the hit.
But after one guy realized he was being scammed he just went ahead and killed his wife himself. So now he’s trying to contact everybody else that’s on the list to inform them that someone wants them dead.
But the people keep hanging up on him thinking he’s selling something or running some kind of con. 😳 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Happy weekend everyone
We've reached episode 4 of Kill List this week. It marks marks a real inflection point in the investigation. It all began with a small team trying to make sense of these orders from the dark net. Then, it moved off the dark net...
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
as we managed to meet the targets of these orders, and understand why they'd been put onto the site. But it is with episode 4 that we see another, and probably the most consequential expansion of all: law enforcement investigations.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The chain of events that started with an excel spreadsheet drawn from the dark net now sees FBI agents spread out across Spokane International airport, waiting for a flight to land...
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/kill-list/id1769072368?i=10… -
Carl Miller reposted
Guardian Tech
@guardiantech
The podcast Kill List doesn’t reflect badly on the internet – it reflects badly on us | John Naughton www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/oct/19/the-podcast…
-
Carl Miller reposted
nickharding
@nickharding
Had the pleasure of interviewing @carljackmiller for @theipaper about his incredible new podcast, Kill List. Well worth a listen. inews.co.uk/inews-lifestyle/i-infiltrated-an-assassins-fo…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Republik
@RepublikMagazin
An der Spitze der Podcast-Charts in den USA findet sich derzeit der True-Crime «Kill List». Mit dabei: Franziska Engelhardt, die im Mai 2023 ihren Teil der Geschichte in der Republik veröffentlichte. www.republik.ch/2023/05/27/ein-job-fuer-die-internet-killers
-
Carl Miller reposted
FT Weekend
@ftweekend
'Listening to the opening episode of Kill List, which documents what Miller and Monteiro did next, I admit I had my doubts.' www.ft.com/content/8e8a2ccd-21ff-4b58-b957-ec09c6d06a59
-
Carl Miller reposted
-
Carl Miller reposted
Catrin Nye
@CatrinNye
‘I lost £165k to fraud in an hour’ - we found that Revolut was named in more reports of fraud in the last financial year than any of the major High Street banks.
If you missed our @BBCPanorama investigating Britain's Newest Bank - it's on @BBCiPlayer here
www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m00226h0/panorama-britains-… -
Carl Miller reposted
Josh Saunders
@journosaunders
Exclusive: Murky world of ‘#hitmen for hire’ sites exposed – including ‘kill list’ monster who paid $50k to inject ex with heroin www.thesun.co.uk/news/31002900/hitman-kill-list-website-t…
Many thanks to @carljackmiller for the chat (and @ricardissimmo as always) #podcast #crime #truecrime -
Carl Miller reposted
Yolanthe Fawehinmi
@yolafawehinmi
Our five #podcast picks to listen to this week are Kill List, The Mind Full Podcast, Reclaiming Narratives – The 4D Podcast, Parents vs. The Internet and Never Live It Down. Happy listening.
www.independent.co.uk/life-style/cillian-murphy-internet-… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It’s widely released tomorrow, everyone. I really hope you give it a listen.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/kill-list/id1769072368 -
Carl Miller reposted
Josh Saunders
@journosaunders
Listen to this brilliant #podcast, out now: podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/kill-list/id1769072368
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This… is an emotional post to write. What I’m about to talk about is - I’m absolutely sure - the most important work I’ve ever done or will ever do.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Apple Podcasts
@ApplePodcasts
How do you warn a stranger that they're on the Kill List?
On our pick of the week, @carljackmiller unravels the disturbing true story of a murder-for-hire website with the names of hundreds of innocent people.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/kill-list/id1769072368?itsc… -
Carl Miller reposted
Jamie Bartlett 🇬🇧
@JamieJBartlett
The biggest podcast of 2024 will be Kill List by @carljackmiller. It's out TODAY.
It's one of the craziest stories I've ever heard: about a dark net hitman site. But it's also about much more.
I've written about why this story matters so much here:
jamiejbartlett.substack.com/p/how-to-hire-a-dark-net-hitman
/1 -
Carl Miller reposted
Caroline Thornham
@cathornham
After nearly five years of investigation, reporting and production, Kill List is finally out in the world today. I know I’ll never work on a story like it ever again.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This… is an emotional post to write. What I’m about to talk about is - I’m absolutely sure - the most important work I’ve ever done or will ever do.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This… is an emotional post to write. What I’m about to talk about is - I’m absolutely sure - the most important work I’ve ever done or will ever do.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Five years ago, a hacker I knew made a fateful discovery. He found a teeny vulnerability on a hitman-for-hire site on the dark net. A gap that he could squeeze through, and onto the backend of the site. There, he could see the kill orders being placed through the site.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
He came to me for help. So just as COVID was coming down, we found ourselves with live kill orders dropping into our inbox. Names. Addresses, pattern of life information, payments and in many cases page after page of grotesque elaboration.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
What happened next became a pellmell scramble spanning over a dozen countries. It involved the FBI and Interpol, 175 threat to life orders handed to the authorities, prosecutions, convictions, dawn raids and midnight worries.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It’s widely released tomorrow, everyone. I really hope you give it a listen.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/kill-list/id1769072368 -
Carl Miller reposted
Forum @ NED
@ThinkDemocracy
NEW REPORT | Leveraging AI for Democracy: Civic Innovation on the Digital Playing Field
@BethKerley @ThinkDemocracy, @fecampa, and @carljackmiller, explore possible paths toward a prodemocratic vision for AI. 🧵 www.ned.org/leveraging-ai-for-democracy-civic-innovation-… -
Carl Miller reposted
Smidge Project
@SmidgeProject
We just attended #disinfocon 2024, a deeply insightful event focused on the impact of AI, digital platforms and social media on society. Discussions highlighted how these technologies are influencing democracy, journalism and cybercrime—key areas that align with the #smidgeproject’s commitment to addressing digital threats.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Democracy Reporting International
@DemocracyR
🤔 Need more reasons to tune in to our #disinfocon?
Here's ➕ 1️⃣: @carljackmiller will join us as our keynote speaker! 🎙️
At @Demos, Miller uncovers evidence to help us understand the digital world. He is also a published author and regular contributor to media outlets ⬇️ -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
recently wrote a piece for EU Disinfo Lab largely out of a growing sense that our response to disinformation has gone off in the wrong direction. In the piece, I try to explain the two reasons at the heart of it. 1/
www.disinfo.eu/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/20240818_D-RAIL…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
(1) We've misunderstood the problem. The vast majority of the work in this area describes the problem as 'disinformation'. It isn't. The things that actually injure democracies are (often hidden) influence campaigns that sometimes use disinformation, but other tactics too.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
(2) Our responses have therefore focussed on stemming the flood of lies circulating on the Internet. At the expense, I think, of a series of effective ways of making covert influence campaigns more expensive, riskier and less effective.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
That is what we really need to build out: ways of disrupting the money flows, people, technical infrastructure and access to audiences that these campaigns need.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The piece suggests some ways of practically thinking about disrupting illicit influence campaigns, and the different roles different bits of society can play in doing so.
-
Carl Miller reposted
EU DisinfoLab
@DisinfoEU
In our latest blogpost, @carljackmiller as guest author presents D-RAIL, proposing a strategy shift from combatting disinformation to disrupting the infrastructure, funding, and personnel behind illicit influence operations (IIOs).
⬇️
www.disinfo.eu/publications/directing-responses-against-i… -
Carl Miller reposted
Madhumita Murgia
@madhumita29
Thanks for this beautiful essay/review @carljackmiller!
Patrick Walsh
@Walsh_e_Patrick
“… leaving the bubble of Silicon Valley far behind, she wants to know what happens when AI is pulled into the messy tangle of human life”.
Great Literary Review appraisal by Carl Miller of Madhumita Murgia’s CODE DEPENDENT, just out in the UK from Picador. -
Carl Miller reposted
Intelligence Squared
@intelligence2
Can we ever be free in a world of work?
@nsrnicek and @carljackmiller talk the fight for free time on the latest episode of Intelligence Squared:
pod.link/708371900/episode/5e7ed2a3fd8e8e976fabb57d9f37c34f -
Carl Miller reposted
Madhumita Murgia
@madhumita29
Loved this conversation with the inimitable @carljackmiller that dives into the stories in my book.
Intelligence Squared
@intelligence2
Congratulations to @madhumita29 for her @WomensPrize shortlist!
Hear more about the inner workings of this fascinating book on the IQ2 podcast👇
megaphone.link/NSR9953189296
PEW Literary
@pew_literary
“A chilling and essential read about AI and the way it imports and exacerbates existing social inequalities.” ~ Professor Nicola Rollock
Absolutely thrilled that Madhumita Murgia’s CODE-DEPENDENT has been shortlisted for the Women’s Prize for Non-Fiction! -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I’m very excited to be speaking at the CSi Conference this year in Cambridge - with the indefatigable @GioeINT @77_msg @ISICambridge
thecsi.org.uk/conference/ -
Carl Miller reposted
Lauri Bambus 🇪🇪
@LauriBambus
Defining a New Era. Serious & important topics #geopolitics #climate #international #cooperation #ai #taxes #recycling discussed at the Norwegian Shipowners’ Association Conference.
Best of luck @Rederiforbundet, @gmbutts
Today we have more challenges than ever. #strongertogether -
Carl Miller reposted
French Embassy UK🇫🇷🇪🇺
@FranceintheUK
An essential discussion during #nightofideas at @ifru_london about combating disinformation. Fake news & manipulations of ideas often shape the geopolitical landscape and impact public opinion, so it’s a common challenge we have to tackle.
@JessicaCecil
@acsector
@carljackmiller
Institut français UK
@ifru_london
At a time when truth and transparency are all the more needed, how to tackle the expansion of fake news?
With experts @carljackmiller, Charlotte Sector @acsector and @JessicaCecil.
#nightofideas #faultlines 8 Feb @ifru_london -
Carl Miller reposted
Jamie Bartlett 🇬🇧
@JamieJBartlett
My new podcast out today!
The Gatekeepers: who decides what you see online - and how did such a small group of firms come to control what we see, say, and even think?
THE most important subject in the world right now.
With brill @_caitlinasmith podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-gatekeepers/id1728044298 -
Carl Miller reposted
Shu Yang Lin
@shuyanglin
Happy to have @v_taiwan and our Recursive Public project covered in Somewhere on Earth podcast. Interviewed by reported and producer @ShiromaTSilva, @carljackmiller and I talked about democratic input to AI.
Shiroma Silva
@ShiromaTSilva
Most of us are both excited and fearful about AI but want to see it properly governed. podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-global-ai-arms-race/id1… looked at ways where you and I set the rules, learning from a system in Taiwan. Hear my report at 11’15” featuring x.com/carljackmiller and x.com/shuyanglin
-
Carl Miller reposted
Center For Humane Technology
@HumaneTech_
For 2024 elections, focus should be on covert influence operations that shape beliefs, not just disinformation. On #yourundividedattention, @carljackmiller and Renee DiResta address securing our information environment over merely labeling disinformation. www.humanetech.com/podcast/how-will-ai-affect-the-2024-el…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Institut français UK
@ifru_london
At a time when truth and transparency are all the more needed, how to tackle the expansion of fake news?
Join the debate with experts @carljackmiller, Charlotte Sector (@acsector) and @JessicaCecil.
#nightofideas 8 Feb @ifru_london
🎟️nightofideas.co.uk/whats-on/ -
Carl Miller reposted
Chine McDonald
@ChineMcDonald
Thank you to @carljackmiller for coming in to have breakfast with us all at @Theosthinktank this morning. Fascinating to talk about the role and purpose of think tanks, power, AI, dis-information, conspiracy theories, spirituality, and social change... over pastries.
-
Carl Miller reposted
David Gioe
@GioeINT
Apps to the @Cambridge_CSi Int'l Security & #intelligence program are at a record pace & more impressive than ever. 2024 could be the best cohort yet. ISI operates rolling admissions so apply early. ISI alums pls retweet! @kclintelligence @77_msg @Sandbagger_01 @carljackmiller
-
Carl Miller reposted
Centre for Drones and Culture
@AestheticsDrone
In the final panel, @JessikkaAro, @purisamir1, @carljackmiller, @Chris_Co1e talk about the dangers of being trolled; the way disinformation targets friendships & intimate lives; & why accepting the notion we are at permanent war means the lessening of rights #hybridwarfarelive
-
Carl Miller reposted
Warrior Diplomacy
@WDiplomacy_pod
🎙 In our latest episode we asked @carljackmiller how should the West fight against Information Warfare.
Listen to the full episode on your favourite podcast platform open.spotify.com/episode/6iwAn6UVzW1KP3tyk6tZ9Z -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Myself and @jamesrbuk have teamed up for @Demos. Paper is out today.
It looks at one of the thorniest, and I would say angriest and most passionately conducted debates currently raging across AI governance: what do you do about open source?
demos.co.uk/research/open-sourcing-the-ai-revolution-fram… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Yep, although i look completely mad
Digital Science
@digitalsci
How great are these pics from the latest @digitalsci #futurepub in London! Thanks to everyone who spoke at and attended this special @AISummitFringe event. 🙌 #aifringe
See the FuturePub videos at Cassyni: cassyni.com/s/futurepub
📸 by @huwmjames
#ai #aiforgood #techforgood -
Carl Miller reposted
Warrior Diplomacy
@WDiplomacy_pod
🌐 Conflict in Ukraine and Gaza have underscored the significance of the digital battleground.
In this episode,@carljackmiller helps us to understand how "Information Operations" and other disruptive technologies and platforms impact global affairs.
open.spotify.com/episode/6iwAn6UVzW1KP3tyk6tZ9Z -
Carl Miller reposted
Demos
@Demos
Ahead of the AI Safety Summit, where governments and tech companies will consider the challenges of AI governance, we're delighted to launch our latest paper, supported by @PwC_UK, which goes to the heart of regulating AI: what to do about open source.
demos.co.uk/research/open-sourcing-the-ai-revolution-fram… -
Carl Miller reposted
Flynn Devine
@FlynnDevine
Very much enjoyed supporting on this @Demos paper by @carljackmiller and @jamesrbuk. Highly recommend a read.
I'm a big believer in #opensource tech, but it definitely raises some interesting (and impactful) questions when it comes to many forms of #artificialintelligence
Demos
@Demos
Ahead of the AI Safety Summit, where governments and tech companies will consider the challenges of AI governance, we're delighted to launch our latest paper, supported by @PwC_UK, which goes to the heart of regulating AI: what to do about open source.
demos.co.uk/research/open-sourcing-the-ai-revolution-fram… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Myself and @jamesrbuk have teamed up for @Demos. Paper is out today.
It looks at one of the thorniest, and I would say angriest and most passionately conducted debates currently raging across AI governance: what do you do about open source?
demos.co.uk/research/open-sourcing-the-ai-revolution-fram…Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Demos convened 40 leading voices on it across civic society, VC, tech companies themselves and HMG. We were looking to not only track divergence of views, but to work out what the drivers of this divergence was - empirical, ideological, or something else.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The paper comes forward with two things:themes we drew from the debate: different ideas of risk, the metaphors we use, and whether open-source AI really is like open-source software. We then propose our own principles that we think can move the debate forwards.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Polly Curtis
@pollycurtis
Fascinating experiment to find consensus amid a lot of division, by @jamesrbuk and @carljackmiller for @Demos
Demos
@Demos
Ahead of the AI Safety Summit, where governments and tech companies will consider the challenges of AI governance, we're delighted to launch our latest paper, supported by @PwC_UK, which goes to the heart of regulating AI: what to do about open source.
demos.co.uk/research/open-sourcing-the-ai-revolution-fram… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We're very proud and pleased at CASM Tech to be joining the Christchurch Call Community - an extremely important group of partners spanning Governments, tech companies and researchers (like us) working to eliminate terrorist and violent extremist content online.
New Zealand Ministry of Foreign Affairs & Trade
@MFATNZ
The Christchurch Call Community is excited to welcome seven new partner organisations in our work to eliminate terrorist and violent extremist content online ➡️ www.christchurchcall.com/media-and-resources/news-and-upd…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carnegie Council
@carnegiecouncil
Ahead of #globalethicsday, listen to our "AI & Equality" podcast hosted by Senior Fellows @AnjaKasp & @WendellWallach.
Thank you to guests Joseph Fins, @UNTechEnvoy @gioasempre, @NitaFarahany, @theCAIDP's @HickokMerve & @MarcRotenberg, & @CarlJackMiller. carnegiecouncil.co/3rXRR6j -
Carl Miller reposted
Catharine Hughes
@catharinehughez
However much or little you know about AI, and its skew of power, I would encourage going on this journey with @carljackmiller to find out how this force is affecting our lives on every level.
Very proud and excited this it out in the world!
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/power-trip-the-age-of-ai/id… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Hello friends! I'm very proud to announce the launch of my first podcast series. It's with @intelligence2 and it explores how power is changing in the age of AI.
A quick thread....
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/power-trip-the-age-of-ai/id… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Hello friends! I'm very proud to announce the launch of my first podcast series. It's with @intelligence2 and it explores how power is changing in the age of AI.
A quick thread....
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/power-trip-the-age-of-ai/id…Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Next, we’ll look at power across society - and begin to look at the role of culture and background both as things which could be reshaped but also things which shape the technology in turn.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
i’ll look at the things that have always shaped and ultimately constrained power: laws, rules, - governance, as we’ll see how AI may be controlled. And last, the broadest most expansive question of all - humanity, the singularity, and power over humanity’s fate itself.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Weird as it sounds, as this place disintegrates, I increasingly use LinkedIn to stay in touch. Come connect with me there:
www.linkedin.com/in/carl-miller-889484172/ -
Carl Miller reposted
The Voices Of War
@TheVoicesOfWar
@carljackmiller returns to #thevoicesofwar to discuss one of the most pressing issues of our time: the ethical governance of #ai. Listen now!
🎧 podcasts.apple.com/au/podcast/100-carl-miller-the-ai-revo… -
Carl Miller reposted
Cyprus Forum
@CypForum
Now on the stage of #cyprusforum at #theclassichotel “#democracy 2.0: Automation And Decentralisation Deployed For #transparency” by #apla with @carljackmiller, J.F Hertogh, @fotisfitsilis, @mariamilt1479 , Marc Papinutti, @pzaphiri, S.Kyprianou and P.Georgiou.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carnegie Council
@carnegiecouncil
AI is going to "reshape almost an unimaginable number of things."
@CarlJackMiller discusses with Senior Fellow @AnjaKasp the various implications of AI on our lives and society during the latest episode of "Artificial Intelligence & Equality" podcast. carnegiecouncil.co/3tcYfa3 -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I was the 51st and now 100th episode of the brilliant podcast @TheVoicesOfWar with Maz. This time we dig into AI and I talk about two new projects: One is my own podcast series about to come out exploring AI and power. Two is...
www.podbean.com/media/share/pb-xbg9s-14b1925 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I was the 51st and now 100th episode of the brilliant podcast @TheVoicesOfWar with Maz. This time we dig into AI and I talk about two new projects: One is my own podcast series about to come out exploring AI and power. Two is...
www.podbean.com/media/share/pb-xbg9s-14b1925
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
A project with Chatham House and vTaiwan to build new, democratic ways to control and govern AI in the future.
www.recursivepublic.com -
Carl Miller reposted
The Voices Of War
@TheVoicesOfWar
🚨Today, I'm thrilled to welcome back @carljackmiller, Research Director at @Demos and a leading expert in #ai ethics.
We delve deep into the ethical quandaries and societal implications of #artificialintelligence.
www.podbean.com/ep/pb-xbg9s-14b1925 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
And so the Online Safety Bill becomes an Act...
As someone who has, one way or another, called for Government regulation for a decade now, this is actually quite an emotional thing to see.
A new era begins. -
Carl Miller reposted
Oxford Generative AI Summit
@OxGenAI
We're delighted to announce that @carljackmiller, technology researcher and author, is joining us as a speaker at #oxgen23!
Carl's first book, "The Death of the Gods: The New Global Power Grab", won the 2019 Transmission Prize.
Read his bio here: www.oxgensummit.org/carlmiller -
Carl Miller reposted
Intelligence Squared
@intelligence2
Why are extremists moving from the fringes into mainstream politics and civil life?
@julie_renbe joins us with @carljackmiller on today's podcast to explore. Listen now wherever you get your podcasts.
pod.link/708371900/episode/774cc8a5b35bf30a916bd82152f601d6 -
Carl Miller reposted
Carnegie Council
@carnegiecouncil
How is AI reshaping global and individual power dynamics? @CarlJackMiller shares his insights with Senior Fellow @AnjaKasp in the latest episode of the "Artificial Intelligence & Equality" podcast.
Episode available wherever you stream your podcasts. carnegiecouncil.co/3LfUOp1 -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
There's been over 6,000 votes in our digital deliberation around AI governance. It's really a wonderful thing to see a meaningful debate tumble into life.
Today, our most divisive statement: the 'pursuit of AI super-intelligence' as a legitimate goal.
www.recursivepublic.com -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
There's been over 6,000 votes in our digital deliberation around AI governance. It's really a wonderful thing to see a meaningful debate tumble into life.
Today, our most divisive statement: the 'pursuit of AI super-intelligence' as a legitimate goal.
www.recursivepublic.com -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I speak to @carnegiecouncil about AI, power, and how it can be shaped, moulded and controlled.
www.carnegiecouncil.org/media/series/aiei/code-power-resp… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carnegie Council
@carnegiecouncil
NEW: In the latest episode of the “Artificial Intelligence & Equality” podcast, @CarlJackMiller joins Senior Fellow @AnjaKasp to discuss how AI is reshaping power dynamics.
Listen to the discussion on YouTube or wherever you stream your podcasts.
carnegiecouncil.co/45I0wIL -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I spoke to @daronacemogIu for @intelligence2 about a topic I know on lots of minds at the mo - AI, how it can be controlled, and the different ways that moments of revolutionary technological change can play out
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ACfNTG83Ppg -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Our digital democratic debate on AI governance is now underway! It's one of the ten projects OpenAI have funded to find ways to govern AI.
Already seems to be some consensus emerging, but also two different groups that disagree on some key issues.
Join: www.recursivepublic.com -
Carl Miller reposted
Jasper Jackson
@JaspJackson
Join us at 5pm for an exploration of Influence Operations with a stellar panel of @wiczipedia @Shayan86 and @carljackmiller.
The Bureau of Investigative Journalism
@TBIJ
Join us next week for our latest TBIJ Live: How are *you* being manipulated online?
Tech Editor @JaspJackson will be joined by:
🟠 @wiczipedia
🟠 @carljackmiller
🟠 @Shayan86
Watch here at 5pm next Wed, or you can sign up on LinkedIn www.linkedin.com/uas/login?session_redirect=https%3A%2F%2… (1/2) -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Our digital democratic debate on AI governance is now underway! It's one of the ten projects OpenAI have funded to find ways to govern AI.
Already seems to be some consensus emerging, but also two different groups that disagree on some key issues.
Join: www.recursivepublic.com -
Carl Miller reposted
Intelligence Squared
@intelligence2
Is AI an existential threat to humanity?
Don't miss this important debate with @carljackmiller, @mer__edith, @sougwen and Stuart Russell.
Hosted by @madhumita29 live at the Southbank Centre 👇
intelligencesquared.com/events/debate-ai-is-an-existentia… -
Carl Miller reposted
The New Statesman
@NewStatesman
The cofounder of the Centre for the Analysis of Social Media, @carljackmiller, on disinformation, online safety and protecting the BBC.
From @NS_Spotlight www.newstatesman.com/spotlight/tech-regulation/emerging-t… -
Carl Miller reposted
The New Statesman
@NewStatesman
“I’ve had extremists phone up with threats and conspiracy theorists turning up at the office. It’s settled now as part of the job.”
The cofounder of the Centre for the Analysis of Social Media, @carljackmiller, speaks to @NS_Spotlight. www.newstatesman.com/spotlight/tech-regulation/emerging-t… -
Carl Miller reposted
Flynn Devine
@FlynnDevine
I was recently awarded a grant by @OpenAI to explore how we can democratise #artificialinteligence development.
Myself, @shuyanglin, @akrasodomski, @carljackmiller and @tsuijiawei are running a pilot with #vtaiwan and @ChathamHouse.
More coming soon… -
Carl Miller reposted
The Bureau of Investigative Journalism
@TBIJ
Join us next week for our latest TBIJ Live: How are *you* being manipulated online?
Tech Editor @JaspJackson will be joined by:
🟠 @wiczipedia
🟠 @carljackmiller
🟠 @Shayan86
Watch here at 5pm next Wed, or you can sign up on LinkedIn www.linkedin.com/uas/login?session_redirect=https%3A%2F%2… (1/2) -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
*Thrilled* to announce that I and colleagues been awarded one of the grants by OpenAI to try to democratise the development of artificial intelligence. The idea is called The Recursive Public, a quick thread on it below and an invitation to be part of it.
-
Carl Miller reposted
giulio quaggiotto
@gquaggiotto
Recursive public - an experiment in collective intelligence for AI governance www.recursivepublic.com (powered by vTaiwan) @carljackmiller
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
*Thrilled* to announce that I and colleagues been awarded one of the grants by OpenAI to try to democratise the development of artificial intelligence. The idea is called The Recursive Public, a quick thread on it below and an invitation to be part of it.
Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We're starting the consultation really soon, and i'd love you to be part of it, and infinitely grateful if you can send this over to anyone else who might want to, as well. You can sign up here: docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSeUnNLYSs7qKHRZ8M_g0jkHg…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It's an amazing team involved. Alex Krasodomski and Rowan Wilkinson from Chatham House, Shu Yang Lin and Jai-Wei Cui from vTaiwan, and Flynn Devine from the Turing Institute. Thanks for reading :)
-
Carl Miller reposted
Chris French profchrisfrench.bsky.social 🇺🇦
@chriscfrench
Fantastic talk and Q&A from @carljackmiller for @GreenwichSitP (especially considering that Carl had not slept for 30 hours!). Looking forward to a return visit!
-
Carl Miller reposted
Greenwich SitP
@GreenwichSitP
Join us for "The Hidden Reality of Power Today" with @carljackmiller, where we will explore the evolving nature of power in our digital age, from politics to crime. Free, no need to book.
📅 Tuesday, August 8th at 7:30 PM
📍 Davy’s Wine Vaults, Greenwich
sitp.online/sitp/greenwich -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
*Thrilled* to be working with @TBIJ to dig deeper into influence operations and how they work
Idea is to fuse artificial intelligence with investigative journalism to spot illicit influence and expose the financial/organisational realities underneath it
www.thebureauinvestigates.com/stories/2023-07-27/what-are… -
Carl Miller reposted
Catrin Nye
@CatrinNye
Incredible to be nominated for a British Podcast Award alongside this lot 🥳
What a team: @JamieJBartlett, Ed Main, Natalie Truswell, @Osman_Iqbal_BBC, @JournoJoJo, @AishaDoherty, @_Sampat 🔥
British Podcast Awards
@britpodawards
Congratulations to:
A Very British Cult
Acid Dream: The Great LSD Plot
Burn Wild @bbc5live @bbcsounds
Call Bethel @Telegraph
I'm Not a Monster S2: The Shamima Begum Story
Pig Iron @tortoise
for being nominated in the Documentary category
#britishpodcastawards -
Carl Miller reposted
Chatham House
@ChathamHouse
Independent Thinking🎙️| Artificial intelligence – A threat to democracy?
This week on the podcast, @bronwenmaddox and guests discuss AI's challenge to democracy, with:
▪@TechMilly
▪@tdesouzadias
▪@akrasodomski
▪@carljackmiller
Listen in full:
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/artificial-intelligence-a-t… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I jump onto this podcast with @ChathamHouse trying to untangle, with my fellow panellists, this knotty problem of AI and democracy.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/artificial-intelligence-a-t… -
Carl Miller reposted
Cyprus Forum
@CypForum
@carljackmiller is the founder of the Centre for the Analysis of Social Media at @Demos in 2011 and #casmtechnology in 2014, and has spent the last decade researching social media intelligence (SOCMINT), extremism, online..
Join this year's #cyprusforum 👉2023.cyprusforum.cy/save-your-seat/ -
Carl Miller reposted
Chatham House
@ChathamHouse
Artificial intelligence | We hear from the experts
Experts explain the enormous power of AI, its positive potential and the risks involved, with:
▪@TechMilly
▪@hickspeggy
▪@DameWendyDBE
▪@carljackmiller
▪James ManyikaThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
hello all o/
I'm also working on a podcast series looking at AI and power: over AI, jobs, within governance, via other inequalities. Ultimately, who is in control? And how?
If you think there's someone I need to speak to over the next six weeks - come get in touch :) -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
In brighter news, I'm going to be part of a *huge* @intelligence2 event at the Southbank Centre in late September debating whether AI is an existential threat to humanity.
intelligencesquared.com/events/debate-ai-is-an-existentia… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
At least what has happened to this site over the last six months will forever stand as testament to that idea that removing content moderation isn't just plainly immoral but also commercially stupid.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
'Transparency reporting' from an organisation whose changes to data access now means that independent replication or verification of any of these numbers is financially impossible.
No-one seriously interested in transparency would have changed their API in the way Twitter did.
Safety
@Safety
Transparency is fundamental to everything we do at Twitter. As we review our approach to transparency reporting for the future, today we’re publishing our 21st report, with data on our policy enforcement for the first half of 2022. Read more here: blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2023/an-update-on-t…
-
Carl Miller reposted
European Commission Coordinator
@EUAntisemitism
Alarmed by the recent rise of #antisemitic content on
@Twitter, I join 18 Antisemitism Special Envoys & Coordinators worldwide & call on @lindayacc to address #antisemitism with rigour & adhere to EU law.
#hatespeech is not #freespeech.
#no2antisemitism
Read the letter 👇 -
Carl Miller reposted
@eliothiggins.bsky.social
@EliotHiggins
The editor of the totally independent The Grayzone proving his independent credentials by appearing at the UN on behalf of Russia to utter a bunch of garbage about the conflict in Ukraine.
Krautbender
@ArtWendeley
One of the more infamous propagandists @MaxBlumenthal does not hesitate to tell lies about stuff like „HIMARS attacks on civilian targets“ in front of the UN on behalf of Russia.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Bellingcat
@bellingcat
We’re partnering with @studentvieworg @Demos and @PSHEassociation to produce a media literacy course for UK classrooms.
Teachers, sign up to the first webinar to discover how we can help your students be more resilient to disinformation and use critical thinking skillsets.
The Student View
@studentvieworg
Calling all teachers! 📢Join our exclusive beta test for the EMIF Media Literacy Champions Webinar and enhance media literacy skills in your classroom. Sign up now for 28.6.23 ➡️ www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/media-literacy-champions-pshe-medi…
@bellingcat @Demos @PSHEassociation @EMIF_Fund -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'll be at @ChathamHouse on June 26th where me and other panellists try to make sense of the intersection of two of the most important hot-button issues we're living through.
Part of London Climate Action Week 2023 - and open to all!
www.chathamhouse.org/events/all/research-event/will-chatg… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
My latest episode of @intelligence2 is out, 'The Battle for Your Brain'. I speak with one of the world's experts in the ethics of neuroscience, @NitaFarahany. Huge technical leaps forward have *just* happened, devices can now decipher thoughts rather than broad states. ...
(1/2)
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
As usual with tech, this brings with it a bundle of possibly life-saving and cataclysmic new possibilities. And so the question is the one we ask more and more of ourselves: can we set up the guardrails, standards, norms, decisively and quickly enough?
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/intelligence-squared/id7083… -
Carl Miller reposted
advaya
@advaya_co
"I do think we'll bring all this under control... a very good sign that we are is that we're all worried about this now, we're all thinking about it, and we're all talking about it. This is no longer a creature of the Valley." - @carljackmiller www.youtube.com/watch?v=GsLEtoJVA2Y&ab_channel=advaya
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Very pleased to say that I'm part of Chatham House's Taskforce on responsible AI. Can't really think of a more important or pressing issue at the moment.
www.chathamhouse.org/about-us/our-departments/digital-soc… -
Carl Miller reposted
The Fix Media
@TheFixMedia
Researcher @carljackmiller told us last year that Wikipedia is “weirdly under the radar” for mainstream media. We’re trying to fix this – this time, by looking at the long-term challenges @Wikipedia faces, from information warfare to generative #ai.
thefix.media/2023/5/23/generative-ai-and-declining-reader… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
My investigation with @rehakansara @rachellekrygier is out this weekend with @BBCtrending - it's a story of deep fake journalists, real journalists in hiding, the head of State and thousands of 'digital troops' pumping out pro-government hashtags
www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct5d92 -
Carl Miller reposted
Reha रेहा
@rehakansara
Since March, @rachellekrygier and I have been looking into how the Venezuelan government use old Bolivarian tactics to ‘control the narrative.’ It’s led us into a digital hole where deepfakes, paid propagandists and ‘gaming the algorithm’ co-exist. On BBC Sounds w @carljackmiller
BBC Trending
@BBCtrending
Social media has become both a liability and an asset for the Venezuelan government in their efforts to control public perceptions. In the last episode of #trolled @carljackmiller explores the tactics being used by the government to quash dissent online www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct5d92
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
My investigation with @rehakansara @rachellekrygier is out this weekend with @BBCtrending - it's a story of deep fake journalists, real journalists in hiding, the head of State and thousands of 'digital troops' pumping out pro-government hashtags
www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct5d92 -
Carl Miller reposted
BBC Trending
@BBCtrending
Social media has become both a liability and an asset for the Venezuelan government in their efforts to control public perceptions. In the last episode of #trolled @carljackmiller explores the tactics being used by the government to quash dissent online www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct5d92
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Our new investigation is out today (and my first for BBC Trending!) We look at the system of digital control that has emerged Venezuela. It’s one where the government has linked pumping pro-government hashtags directly to its system of social support.
BBC Trending
@BBCtrending
Social media has become both a liability and an asset for the Venezuelan government in their efforts to control public perceptions. In the last episode of #trolled @carljackmiller explores the tactics being used by the government to quash dissent online www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct5d92
-
Carl Miller reposted
Jamie Bartlett 🇬🇧
@JamieJBartlett
With @ruthmayer I’ve been investigating the mysterious death of a charity founder who claimed to have a life threatening brain tumour - but didn’t
A story of celebrity obsession & the world of Munchausen Syndrome
Our new podcast out today @BBCSounds
www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0fhzh45/episodes/player -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Here's me hanging out with Melanie Smith @ISDglobal at Public Safety Canada's Summit on Disinformation in Ottawa. International cooperation (plus domestic government focus) is really ramping up on the issue now, and it's really brilliant - truly an honour - to be part of it.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I spoke in the first session, with one message, really: disinformation is a horrible way of describing the problem. Most lies online we don't need to care about. The ones we do are propagated by organised professionals and there's a better name for that: information operations
-
Carl Miller reposted
Catrin Nye
@CatrinNye
A Very British Cult is on @BBCOne tonight at 11.25 📺
Also on @BBCiPlayer now!
www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001krb2/a-very-british-cult
Catrin Nye
@CatrinNye
18 months ago, I got a call from Dawn saying her boyfriend was trying to escape a life coaching group...that was actually a cult.
It started the weirdest & most fascinating investigation of my career.
A Very British Cult is out now.
Watch @BBCiPlayer: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001krb2/a-very-british-cult -
Carl Miller reposted
Catrin Nye
@CatrinNye
INCREDIBLE. So proud of our team and more than anything the people who spoke to us absolutely knowing they would suffer because of it. True heroes.
TEAM: Natalie Truswell, @Osman_Iqbal_BBC, @JamieJBartlett, Ed Main, @JournoJoJo, @AishaDoherty, @mrbenlister, @jikat, Ravin Sampat -
Carl Miller reposted
Adilah Khan
@AdilahIK
Beyond Disinformation session with @polinaivanovva @carljackmiller and @DavidLoyn chairing the panel @frontlineclub @UniWestminster @CheveningFCDO #cheveningfellow #sajp2023
-
Carl Miller reposted
David Loyn
@DavidLoyn
Support @evangershkovich, now in Russian jail. @frontlineclub Wednesday night. His close friend @polinaivanovva is on a panel to discuss influence operations with @carljackmiller. ‘Beyond Disinformation.’ www.eventbrite.com/e/598595012797.
#journalismisnotacrime -
Carl Miller reposted
The Centre for Finance and Security (CFS) at RUSI
@CFS_RUSI
🚨NEW! @RUSI_org team authored a conference report, inspired by the first meeting of RUSI’s State Threats Taskforce. Check out now👇🧵
rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/conference-rep… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Important to remember that the majority of online manipulation campaigns are economically motivated. Not the ones grabbing the headlines, but spam still beats geopolitics as the main thing these bad actors care about.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Catrin Nye
@CatrinNye
The first reviews are in and we are Delighted with our Picks Of The Day.
A Very British Cult.
Coming this Wednesday 5th April to @BBCiPlayer @bbcthree @BBCSounds @BBCOne & @BBCRadio4. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Data access to social media companies isn’t just a transparency issue, it’s a national security issue
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'm going to be talking influence operations and disinformation @frontlineclub with @polinaivanovva next week - come along
www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/panel-discussion-beyond-disinforma… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
No Researcher in the world should be talking about online harms, presenting social media research or talking about how it's changing society without also raising the threat of data access. Because it won't be researchers who fix this one, but everyone else
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Care about stopping hate speech? Or stemming information warfare? Countering extremism? Electoral integrity?
This single move is going to remove a vast chunk of social media research that informs all of that.
There should be questions in Parliament about this.
Developers
@XDevelopers
Today we are launching our new Twitter API access tiers! We’re excited to share more details about our self-serve access. 🧵
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Care about stopping hate speech? Or stemming information warfare? Countering extremism? Electoral integrity?
This single move is going to remove a vast chunk of social media research that informs all of that.
There should be questions in Parliament about this.
Developers
@XDevelopers
Today we are launching our new Twitter API access tiers! We’re excited to share more details about our self-serve access. 🧵
-
Carl Miller reposted
Polina Ivanova
@polinaivanovva
London! I'll be speaking at @frontlineclub next week about life and reporting inside Russia's propaganda bubble -- and with @carljackmiller, about his great work into how Russia tries to export its worldview.
Come! 7pm Weds,April5: www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/panel-discussion-beyond-disinforma…
www.frontlineclub.com/events/ -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
All disinformation/info ops researchers and wonks out there - if there's one thing you should read on all of that this week, let it be this:
carnegieendowment.org/2023/03/16/phase-based-tactical-ana… -
Carl Miller reposted
Oliver Marsh (tech & society)
@olivermmarsh
Round-up of the week:
Research on antisemitism on Twitter after Musk takeover - which found more than 2x in volumes of posts and a surge in new accounts - I worked on with @carljackmiller , CASM, and @ISDglobal is out: www.isdglobal.org/isd-publications/antisemitism-on-twitte… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It will be less and less down to the arbitrary discretion of big tech owners to define what it a legitimate response to online hate speech. It's taken awhile, but democratic authorities and - through them - regulators are going to be doing so instead
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/tackle-antisemitism-or-well-hu… -
Carl Miller reposted
@openmicmedia.bsky.social
@openmicmedia
The 2x rise in antisemitic tweets observed by @carljackmiller & @ISDglobal has a number of underlying causes, and can't only be attributed to Musk's content-moderation rollbacks.
arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/03/antisemitism-on-twitt… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Independent assessment isn’t when you ‘partner’ with an organisation to do research which you then decide to release.
It’s when independent organisations do the research themselves. There’s an enormous difference. -
Carl Miller reposted
Ars Technica
@arstechnica
Antisemitism on Twitter has more than doubled since Elon Musk took over arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/03/antisemitism-on-twitt…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'm grateful to the @washingtonpost for covering our research that has tracked a doubling of antisemitism on Twitter since Musk took over.
Twitter's press email, when contacted for comment by the Post, auto-replied with a poop emoji.
www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2023/03/20/antisemitic-tw… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Morning all - I've written this piece which sums up our new research on antisemitism on the platform over its acquisition by Elon Musk, and in the months thereafter.
theconversation.com/antisemitism-on-twitter-has-more-than… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Morning all - I've written this piece which sums up our new research on antisemitism on the platform over its acquisition by Elon Musk, and in the months thereafter.
theconversation.com/antisemitism-on-twitter-has-more-than… -
Carl Miller reposted
The Conversation U.S.
@ConversationUS
Yes, there is more #antisemitism here than before @ElonMusk took over
theconversation.com/antisemitism-on-twitter-has-more-than… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I've written for the @ConversationUS looking at our report out today looking at antisemitism on Twitter before and after it was bought by Elon Musk. It doubles.
Research like this, by the way, vanishes the moment platforms charge researchers for data.
theconversation.com/antisemitism-on-twitter-has-more-than… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I've written for the @ConversationUS looking at our report out today looking at antisemitism on Twitter before and after it was bought by Elon Musk. It doubles.
Research like this, by the way, vanishes the moment platforms charge researchers for data.
theconversation.com/antisemitism-on-twitter-has-more-than… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Heya folks - new research out from us at CASM and @ISDglobal out today. It looks at the amount of antisemitism on Twitter before, during and after Elon Musk's takeover.
It has more than doubled in the period since the acquisition.
🧵: findings, methods, caveats -
Carl Miller reposted
Victor Asal
@Victor_Asal
Antisemitism on Twitter has more than doubled since Elon Musk took over the platform @ConversationUS @carljackmiller
theconversation.com/antisemitism-on-twitter-has-more-than… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Heya folks - new research out from us at CASM and @ISDglobal out today. It looks at the amount of antisemitism on Twitter before, during and after Elon Musk's takeover.
It has more than doubled in the period since the acquisition.
🧵: findings, methods, caveats
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The report itself is here: beamdisinfo.org/deployments/antisemitism-on-twitter-befor…
And I've written about it for @ConversationUS @ConversationUK here:
theconversation.com/antisemitism-on-twitter-has-more-than…Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
And then use more ML to learn the correct combo of classifier outcomes most likely to reflect the right decision.
Caveats:
The ensemble obviously isn’t perfect - we evaluated it to have a f1 of 0.76
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We also would have missed antisemitism not containing any one of 191 monikers epithets, expressions we used as collection terms. And we'd also have missed antisemitism already taken down by the platform before we collected data in December of last year.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Prof. Ed de Quincey
@eddequincey
Great to hear @carljackmiller talk at @KeeleUniversity this afternoon, and have a chat afterwards. It was nice to be reminded me of the halcyon days at the start of Web 2.0. Although there is much to be frustrated by in the digital world, was good to hear about vTaiwan and Polis.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
There is an elemental tension at the heart of all of this I think. Platforms designed to grow really big just aren't the ones that will make our societies flourish.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I was on this podcast talking about, well quite a lot of different things actually. But primarily looking at the differences opening up between Europe and its regulation of social media, and America and its absence of it.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/firewall/id1199693682?i=100… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I was on this podcast talking about, well quite a lot of different things actually. But primarily looking at the differences opening up between Europe and its regulation of social media, and America and its absence of it.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/firewall/id1199693682?i=100… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I was on this podcast talking about, well quite a lot of different things actually. But primarily looking at the differences opening up between Europe and its regulation of social media, and America and its absence of it.
podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/firewall/id1199693682?i=100… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If people are interested in influence operations and haven't seen it, take a look at the DISARM framework.
It's good for seeing the sheer variety of behaviours which are involved in illicit influence beyond just spamming disinfo around.
...
disarmframework.herokuapp.com
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It's also good to see the sheer variety of responses to them, beyond fact checking and digital literacy - everything from hardening the mechanics of the platforms targeted through to litigation and counter-memetics.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Very odd - an article I wrote about the 77th brigade, having previously run it by the 77th brigade and MOD, published in @WiredUK of all places, is being blocked by Twitter as potentially harmful. There’s some very broken mechanics afoot there.
-
Carl Miller reposted
advaya
@advaya_co
Join advaya's upcoming course #thedigitalage and explore the tech dynamics shaping our political landscape. Learn to navigate & thrive in the digital age w/ @NathalieNahai, @carljackmiller, @Ayishat_Akanbi and more. Register here: www.digitalage-course.com
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I was one of the four experts this week on the Inquiry where we were untangling the question: 'Is everything OK at Facebook?'
www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct39vb -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I wrote a review of a brilliant book called Chaos Machines that looks at what platforms optimised for growth actually do to society
'Required reading' is a cliche to describe a book, I know - but I really wish more people focussed on platform mechanics
literaryreview.co.uk/are-you-outraged-yet -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Hi y'all - i spoke to University of Warwick talking about our work on social media, vaccine hesitancy and conspiracy theories
www.youtube.com/watch?v=zMD_D20L8t8 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'm so glad people have started doing this sort of investigation!
Dig into the people, money, software and infrastructure of the people who are doing online manipulation in the most organised and effective ways and profiting most from it.
www.theguardian.com/world/2023/feb/15/aims-software-avata… -
Carl Miller reposted
Rogers Brubaker
@wrbucla
just seeing now this excellent critique of focus on disinformation. @carljackmiller and @gavinbwilde
on "different epistemic worlds" with parallel structures & authorities where "truth-claims are arrived at & discussed." h/t @KenzieBurchell
1 of 2
www.worldpoliticsreview.com/misinformation-vs-disinformat… -
Carl Miller reposted
advaya
@advaya_co
NEW COURSE! The Digital Age takes a critical and in-depth look at where we find ourselves to better understand the lines along which power is operating in this age. We talk power + tech in the context of globalised capitalism.
Early birds available now: digitalage-course.com -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If you want to understand where information warfare comes from, I wrote this in 2017 about one of the most important trailblazers of that shadowy tradecraft, a man called Andres Sepulveda.
www.wired.co.uk/article/carl-miller-disinformation-gets-c… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I’ve often felt this regarding innovation. Govts and large orgs pay fortunes to bring in these professional services firms to advise on how to use emerging tech, which the consultants do not build, often don’t understand and can’t retain the talent for.
www.ft.com/content/fb1254dd-a011-44cc-bde9-a434e5a09fb4 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
What is the wittiest reply to a tweet that you’ve ever made?
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
93% of tweets don’t receive a reply
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It’s such a weird, wonderful convention to me that airline pilots will always announce the micro-weather conditions as you come into land on a foreign continent. Of all the info I need, it probably isn’t to know that there’s a light SSE breeze at 3mph across runway 2.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It’s such a weird, wonderful convention to me that airline pilots will always announce the micro-weather conditions as you come into land on a foreign continent. Of all the info I need, it probably isn’t to know that there’s a light SSE breeze at 3mph across runway 2.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'm flying out to Silicon Valley today for 'FOO Camp', a weekend where really some of the best internet researchers in the world meet and all geek out. Always been an excellent leading signal on where research is going. Will share insights with you all whenever I can.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Looking back at our history, I think we'll see America as the place that successfully created the conditions to create web2, and Europe as the place that brought it under democratic control.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Across the decade now of studying social media, I return to one elemental tension. The characteristics that makes platforms grow are not those that make them healthy to democracies. Attention-optimising algos, virals, habit-forming tech, trending mechanisms all...
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
2/ have tangled together to create the information environments and diets I think we're all increasingly aware are harmful both psychologically and socially. They both exploit our psychologies and are exploitable themselves by bad actors.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Social media platforms have got to mature into a post-growth phase now in their mechanics. It's hard, because if one does alone, they'll probably become extinct. This is something for us all to think about.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/The EU is now talking about 'foreign information manipulation and interference'. Despite the fact it creates the acronym FIMI, this is a huge step forwards. I'll briefly give my view on why.
First, disinformation is a horrible way of understanding the problem.Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
interference and manipulation that *may* involve lying, but loads of other things too, from false identities to manipulating search engines.
Focussing on FIMI lets us focus on these bad actors. There are money flows, orgs, technical infrastructure there
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
including, by the way, companies that actually sell this stuff. we can do stuff about all that
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It's always galling when debates about online manipulation become about content takedown. Far more important to talk about platform mechanics. We need to change the terrain that information warfare flourishes in rather than tactically focus on individual operations.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Some things that could blunt online manipulation fairly easily. Especially during vulnerable moments (elections, crises etc)
- Require more information during account sign-up
- Blunt virals.
- Add friction when amplifying.
- Tune down curation/trending mechanisms
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
- To be honest with you, just slow everything down. Modern manipulation works by both exploiting both the way our psychologies and social media platforms work and making everything less reflective, knee-jerk, automated and curated will help a lot.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Looks looks amazing from @I_W_M (well, I did always secretly want to work in the games industry)
www.iwm.org.uk/iwm-institute/war-games-jam -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If there’s one thing the EU can do to protect and promote research into influence operations it’s data access. Twitter is monetising theirs. Rumours that Facebook’s might go. TikTok doesn’t even have one. We’re possibly backsliding and it won’t be fixed by us researchers.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
At an EU event today, I spoke most about the companies openly selling online manipulation - fake accounts, reviews, search manipulation, attacks on trending and curation etc. the problem isn’t lies circulating online, it’s the who info landscape being shaped in shadowy ways
-
Carl Miller reposted
EUvsDisinfo
@EUvsDisinfo
One crucial thing to help researchers of foreign information manipulation and interference #fimi is to ensure access to data of social media platforms. Sooner or later the #eu will have to intervene in the backsliding of data access @carljackmiller
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Here in Brussels, there is a real sense of firm resolution to respond to (new acronym) ‘FIMI’ - foreign information manipulation and interference. They have a far more sophisticated grasp of the problem than I often hear from governments, and the most strategic response
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The EU is holding a big event today - the first point from the External Action Service was: ‘if disinformation is the bullet, the bit you see, information manipulation is the gun. If fires it, propels it’ www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/beyond-disinformation-–-eu-respon…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Jelena Sofronijevic
@jelsofron
Jim Heltsin! @LanceRogoff's Muppets in Moscow details making 'custom Slavic puppets' in the Soviet Union - and what Boris Berezovsky made of Big Bird.
presented by @carljackmiller, produced by @Conboyle_, and now available on our @intelligence2 podcast🔊pod.link/708371900/episode/91f3b2013d0626fe29b20ca8babe1d16
Intelligence Squared
@intelligence2
What connects the collapse of the Soviet Union and Sesame Street? Find out tomorrow with @LanceRogoff
Join us tomorrow. #intelligencesquared
intelligencesquared.com/events/muppets-in-moscow-the-stor… -
Carl Miller reposted
Chris French profchrisfrench.bsky.social 🇺🇦
@chriscfrench
Get your diary out! Details of all @GreenwichSitP talks up until August now up on our website (@DannyVet, @PaulZenon, @emmyloutaylor, @Ema_SB, Anna Stone, @MrMMarsh, and @carljackmiller): sitp.online/sitp/greenwich
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Going over to Brussels for this later today. The focus on adversarial actors, what they're doing, and how to respond is an amazing step forwards from the usual framing of disinformation and a generalised worry of lies circulating online.
European Union in the UK
@EUdelegationUK
On Tuesday @EU_eeas will be discussing our adversaries’ tactics & 🇪🇺 responses on foreign information manipulation and interference (FIMI) with leading experts & policy-makers.
We will also unveil our first threat report analysing #fimi.
More ℹ️ www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/beyond-disinformation-–-eu-respon… -
Carl Miller reposted
Lutz Güllner 🇪🇺 谷 力 哲
@LutzGuellner
We are looking forward to our great lineup of speakers; @JosepBorrellF @TofvessonMikael @rglucks1 @NATOBrazeB @joannekeatwork @lageneralista @carljackmiller @AAlaphilippe @wiczipedia www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/beyond-disinformation-–-eu-respon…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'm going to be giving a keynote up at Keele on March 15th about my life as a researcher exploring the digital world. It'll mix the two halves of work: story-driven journalistic investigations and data-driven research. Come and say hello if you're around!
www.keele.ac.uk/research-at-keele-month/ -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Really one of the favourite interviews I've ever done for @intelligence2 -from @LanceRogoff, the thrilling, scary, deeply moving story of taking the Muppets to Moscow, and really precipitating a conversation about the kind of society Russia might become
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/muppets-in-moscow-the-story… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We (at CASM/ISD) starting new work on information warfare on wikipedia, looking at suspicious editing behaviour, gaming of governance processes and harassment towards editors. Anyone who has a view on any of this, please get in touch, I'd love to hear from you.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Twitter charging for tweets is bad news for platform transparency and accountability, and will likely throttle grassroots, higher risk, more casual or speculative forms of research
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Democracies are being hit by a tangle of different, and quite rapidly evolving hostile state activity, that much is clear
So, I'm glad to join @RUSI_org's State Threats Taskforce (STT) to think about how we detect, attribute and respond to them.
rusi.org/explore-our-research/projects/rusi-state-threats… -
Carl Miller reposted
Midas
@midascampaigns
A wonderful @intelligence2 event with Natasha @LanceRogoff last night, where she discussed her book 'Muppets in Moscow' with the brilliant @carljackmiller. You can watch it back here: www.intelligencesquaredplus.com/videos/muppets-in-moscow-…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I cannot tell you how much I am looking forward to chairing this @intelligence2 event tonight:
intelligencesquared.com/events/muppets-in-moscow-the-stor… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Sweden has just adopted the presidency of the EU Commission - and hosted an event focussed on tech regulation to mark the event, attended by regulators, diplomats, researchers, tech people. I went over to Stockholm to speak at it, and wanna share what I said.
Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Last was the power of the founder. Tech giants are strange companies in a way - in the way that decision-making shares are structured. Many have protected the decision making of the founders, even when their ownership gets diluted. So all of the other powers concentrates not just
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
To the company, but a single person at the very top of it.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Off to Stockholm today to talk about the many powers of tech giants at an event to mark Sweden's assumption of the EU presidency. Fitting, given the EU is probably the most important entity in the world to guardrail their powers.
swedish-presidency.consilium.europa.eu/en/events/conferen… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'm really proud of this - CASM contributed to a landmark report led by @ISDglobal on climate disinformation.
It shows how online influence and disinformation has so thoroughly migrated out of elections to target these existential global issues.
www.isdglobal.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/Deny-Deceive… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ 'Disinformation' isn't primarily about being lured in by falsehoods. It's about entirely parallel epistemic worlds that have been build, variously rejecting mainstream journalism, scientific method, academia, politics. Just like ours, it has investigators, controversies...
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ Morning everyone - end of last year was (as usual) frenetic - so I want to re-share a white paper we released that talks about Beam - a counter-disinformation/info ops/extremism capability we've spent the last 5 years growing with @ISDglobal
beamdisinfo.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/signal-2022-11…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
2/ I know lots of organisations are turning to the problem of disinformation at the moment, and I hope this might help in laying our what we found the different layers to be in an effective response, from underlying tech to the right team and ultimately reactions and effects
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
EDMO is looking for experts to join a joint effort to assess the impact of the EU's Code of Practice on disinformation. Looks interesting, and, god knows, we need a way of evaluating the spread of counter-disinfo efforts that are going on.
edmo.eu/2022/12/22/edmo-experts-call-for-interest/ -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'm very glad (and grateful) that BBC Digital Planet recently covered our work on information warfare and Wikipedia. I've long thought - still think - it's a massively under-researched and hugely significant platform.
Thanks @ShiromaTSilva and team -
Carl Miller reposted
Anton Protsiuk
@antonprotsyuk
Top 2022 stories by @TheFixMedia:
• @davidtvrdon's subscriber onboarding guide
• @glepeyko on @carljackmiller's new anti-disinfo tool
• @albertopi on Google updates
• @ekjlofgren's guides on introducing solutions journalism & making changes stick
thefix.media/2023/1/3/five-most-popular-stories-of-2022-f… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Very happy new year everyone!
Over the Christmas break, this long read was written that covers what we're trying to do with Beam (across CASM and ISD) to scale our responses to influence ops, disinfo and information threats across the board.
www.aretenews.com/new-tool-for-fighting-disinformation-he… -
Carl Miller reposted
Catrin Nye
@CatrinNye
Well chuffed that our long read - Jobfished: The con that tricked dozens into working for a fake design agency - is on this list of most engaging stories of 2022. @Chartbeat analysed 28 million pieces of content & we made the list 🥳 @leo_sands @DivyaTalwar1 @mrbenlister @_Sampat
Chartbeat
@Chartbeat
Presenting the most engaging stories of 2022 lp.chartbeat.com/2022-most-engaging-stories?cid=C00807&hs… #2022engagingstories
-
Carl Miller reposted
Hleb Liapeika
@liapeika
It's been 2+ years of repressions in Belarus, and I looked into the state of independnent journalism in my home country. Here is a full article, and below is a quick thread with main points
spoiler: it's the darkest time for Belarusian media
thefix.media/2022/12/21/in-jail-in-exile-or-burned-out-st… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I chaired the @intelligence2 Sunday debate this week about the protests rocking China with two towering authorities on the country - @YashengHuang and @Bkerrychina.
How worried should Xi be? Listen here:
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-sunday-debate-will-prot… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
My other pet research hates:
- Giving research the title 'X on social media' when you've just researched Twitter.
- Taking a conceptual framework and breaking down its categories into a larger amount of categories.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Whenever someone intervenes in a debate to either say something is complex or interlinked with something else, it's very often straw-manning. No-one serious either thinks the world is simple, nor argues phenomena in the wilds act in any kind of isolation.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Whenever someone intervenes in a debate to either say something is complex or interlinked with something else, it's very often straw-manning. No-one serious either thinks the world is simple, nor argues phenomena in the wilds act in any kind of isolation.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Jennie King (jkingy.bsky.social)
@jkingy
The project @EcoBotNet - a long-standing partner in exposing #climate disinfo and greenwashing - just won “Innovation of the Year” at the British Journalism Awards. 🎉
Check out their website, built in part from @ISDglobal and CASM’s climate dashboards!
eco-bot.net -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Huge congrats to our partners @EcoBotNet who have won Innovation of the Year at the British Journalism Awards!
Us at CASM Tech, alongside Eco-bot, @ISDglobal and others all worked together over COP-26 to expose climate disinfo and corporate greenwashing
eco-bot.net -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If anyone is interested in studying malicious automation in action, I’d say 500 bots have followed me in the last couple of hours.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Faye Flam
@fayeflam
I wrote about social science experiments on crowdsourcing social media instead of using attention-based algorithms. The result was better quality information: www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2022-02-08/social-medi…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Buried underneath all of the froth happening on Twitter at the moment is an experiment more exciting than anything I’ve seen tried by a tech giant. I explain what’s going on for @WIRED www.wired.com/story/elon-musk-embraces-twitters-radical-c…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'd like to re-share this piece that myself and @gavinbwilde wrote recently. It's on why we really shouldn't collapse the problem of state-based online influence to one of disinformation. It's really hobbling our response to it.
www.worldpoliticsreview.com/misinformation-vs-disinformat… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I think the photo editor was anticipating a different headline
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I recently had the great pleasure of talking about technology, power and how's it changing today (and whether i'd got it right in 2018) with the fine gentlemen from @ManOverboardhq
linktr.ee/ManOverboardPodcast -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is what we need tons more off - actually digging down into the underlying commercial and technical ways that illicit influence actually happens online. Totally invaluable
medium.com/tisanelabs/trolling-as-a-service-91cb893e880 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I recently spoke at an event for the EU on disinformation and the lessons of the Ukraine war. It's recorded here if you'd like to take a look:
www.facebook.com/EUinUK/videos/873234697021028 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We recently published a paper explaining more about how (and why) we do the online research we do on influence ops, extremism, hate and disinformation. It really needs a whole new smooshing together of tech and different skills. I hope it's helpful.
beamdisinfo.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/signal-2022-11… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I remember ages ago now, someone from Twitter said (perhaps somewhat inadvisedly) that they were on top of bots and that tweet got retweeted (by bots) thousands of times. In the Musk era, it feels like the same thing is happening to the entire platform.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'd like to re-share this piece that myself and @gavinbwilde wrote recently. It's on why we really shouldn't collapse the problem of state-based online influence to one of disinformation. It's really hobbling our response to it.
www.worldpoliticsreview.com/misinformation-vs-disinformat… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I think we can safely conclude at this point that Musk has very definitively not solved the problem of bots on Twitter.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Every time I log into Twitter, I'm vaguely surprised the whole thing is still running
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If you're into intelligence and security studies, this is really well worth taking a look at. I spoke at it last year, and the attendees clearly get a ton out of it, both academic exposure and getting to know people in the field
thecsi.org.uk/international-security-and-intelligence-isi… -
Carl Miller reposted
The Fix Media
@TheFixMedia
With the help of Beam, journalists have revealed the scale and details of the pro-Russian social media campaign at the beginning of the war. Now, the team behind the tool invites journalists to get in touch and see if it can help in their investigations.
thefix.media/2022/11/23/beam-is-a-new-multilingual-tool-t… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If you're interested in looking at where we're deploying Beam to counter information threats, we're putting them up on this page here: beamdisinfo.org/deployments/
One of our big aims is to get it working in more overlooked info spaces and underserved languages in the years ahead. -
Carl Miller reposted
Aviv Ovadya 🥦
@metaviv
This approach used by Twitter—bridging-based ranking—can be used all over social media!
This thread explores its full potential: x.com/metaviv/status/1578010491028480001
(It's from ancient history, when the 'experiment' that @kcoleman & @carljackmiller describe was called Birdwatch)
Aviv Ovadya 🥦
@metaviv
This is incredibly exciting, and great model for what we need more of going forward.
Most social media has a "bias toward division." 😡
@Birdwatch introduces a counteracting force.
It uses a form of bridging-based ranking (www.belfercenter.org/publication/bridging-based-ranking) to overcome that bias.
/1 -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Buried underneath all of the froth happening on Twitter at the moment is an experiment more exciting than anything I’ve seen tried by a tech giant. I explain what’s going on for @WIRED www.wired.com/story/elon-musk-embraces-twitters-radical-c…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Literary Review
@Lit_Review
'The charge is not simply that YouTube and Facebook have allowed polarising, extremist, conspiracist, hateful material to persist on their platforms; it is also that they have actively pushed people’s attention towards it.'
literaryreview.co.uk/are-you-outraged-yet -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Buried underneath all of the froth happening on Twitter at the moment is an experiment more exciting than anything I’ve seen tried by a tech giant. I explain what’s going on for @WIRED www.wired.com/story/elon-musk-embraces-twitters-radical-c…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I written a piece with @gavinbwilde about the problem of conflating disinformation and illicit influence online www.worldpoliticsreview.com/misinformation-vs-disinformat…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carnegie Endowment
@CarnegieEndow
A hyper-fixation on exposing disinformation does little to resolve the larger issue at hand, argue @gavinbwilde and @carljackmiller for @WPReview:
www.worldpoliticsreview.com/misinformation-vs-disinformat… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I written a piece with @gavinbwilde about the problem of conflating disinformation and illicit influence online www.worldpoliticsreview.com/misinformation-vs-disinformat…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I seriously don’t think Twitter the platform is going to implode everyone. The company might be in trouble, but the actual technical capacity to deliver it is an asset, and would be sold off alongside the user base and archive.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/The eagle-eyed vis nerds out there might spot that the front-page of our new website on Beam (beamdisinfo.org) is a manipulable, zoomable 3D version of an earlier mapping we did of networks pushing pro-Russian hashtags.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
2/ The location of each account (in both) isn't based on retweets or follows, but on the measured difference in the language use of the accounts across the last 200 messages they've sent.
More info on that here: files.casmtechnology.com/message-based-community-detectio…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
3/ Anyway, thought i'd flag that we're trying to be more experimental and adventurous around the way we visualise influence operations online - and especially interested in ways that allow wider audiences to interrogate them themselves.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is wishful thinking, but I really hope the civic tech scenes of the European capitals manage to find a way to tap into and use the big tech layoffs.
The time is ripe to connect that newly idle talent with socially meaningful opportunities. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Given the ridiculous amount of idle talent now sloshing around in the Valley, there has never been a better time to set up a tech company (if you can find the money).
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Good morning everyone!
Today we're launching, well, not really a new counter-disinfo capability, because we've been building and using it for five years. But a much greater effort to talk about how it works, and what we've learned doing this strange new kind of research.
🧵 -
Carl Miller reposted
Institute for Strategic Dialogue
@ISDglobal
Today we are proud to announce the official launch of Beam, our counter-disinformation capability developed in collaboration with CASM Technology.
Read on to find out more, or check out our new website: beamdisinfo.org -
Carl Miller reposted
Jamie Bartlett 🇬🇧
@JamieJBartlett
There are a lot of good but sometimes slightly technical descriptions of what has been going on with FTX & its founder ‘SBF. This is the simplest non-technical way I can describe it to non-crypto people (Ie the 99% of people who have never heard of @cz_binance or Sam etc)
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Good morning everyone!
Today we're launching, well, not really a new counter-disinfo capability, because we've been building and using it for five years. But a much greater effort to talk about how it works, and what we've learned doing this strange new kind of research.
🧵Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We learned that fancy tech only really matters when you plug it into powerful solutions, and as important to detection for Beam is the experimentation and eval of responses to information threats to see what works. We've learned to work much more in coalitions and to...
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
take whatever we can learn from a particular context - especially the tradecraft of bad actors, and apply that elsewhere.
Anyway, I hope that all's helpful. Congrats for getting to the end of a long, methods-based thread. Any further info you want, DM me. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Our counter-disinformation technology - Beam - is powering daily briefings throughout COP-27 by a coalition of civic society groups, Climate Action Against Disinformation.
You can sign up for them here: climatedigital.typeform.com/to/hvGiQcYE
And please send on to anyone who might benefit -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ Four quick predictions for where influence operations are going, that I've just made at the @G7 #factsvsdisinformation conference.
(1) Strategic evolution. We've become used to campaigns targeting Western audiences, using wedge issues to hasten social division. -
Carl Miller reposted
Solutions Journalism Network
@soljourno
You're gonna see a lot of arguing today. And tomorrow. But this @Flipboard is about DEpolariziation: people ditching the toxic talk to understand each other.
Get stories from @carljackmiller, @amandaripley, @KristiEaton, @PoppyNoor, and @A_MacLeod_Tyee.
flipboard.com/@soljourno/what-s-working-to-de-polarize-us… -
Carl Miller reposted
European Union in the UK
@EUdelegationUK
@carljackmiller 👉🏻 “The EU is the only actor in the world that can and should intervene to regulate the digital space. The future regulatory tapestry will look hugely differently from our current landscape”
European Union in the UK
@EUdelegationUK
In the second section of our panel, the @EU_Commission’s Krisztina Stum said 👉🏻 “The code of practice on disinformation amounts to a new deal in the 🇪🇺’s combat against #disinformation. It is a voluntary code and complying with its terms is in the best interests of companies”
-
Carl Miller reposted
The Fix Media
@TheFixMedia
It's not just @Facebook and @Twitter where disinformation is raging, @carljackmiller points out in the interview with @antonprotsyuk.
Learn more about the role of @Wikipedia in conveying facts 👉 thefix.media/2022/11/1/wikipedia-is-a-coveted-target-of-i… -
Carl Miller reposted
Aspen UK
@uk_aspen
Founder of the Centre for the Analysis of Social Media @carljackmiller joins us w/ @EUdelegationUK on Nov 8 10:00 GMT to discuss #disinformation online in the Ukraine war & its threat to the international community. Register www.aspenuk.org/events/countering-the-kremlins-disinforma… #aspenukevents
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
What is everyone’s thoughts about Birdwatch?
-
Carl Miller reposted
The Fix Media
@TheFixMedia
Wikipedia might be the most important target of information warfare – and yet it gets surprisingly little media coverage compared to Facebook & Twitter. “We really need more coverage on information spaces as precious as this one”, @carljackmiller believes
thefix.media/2022/11/01/wikipedia-is-a-coveted-target-of-… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I have an unanticipated free day in Toronto (thanks, fog). What should I do Twitter?!
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Social media use is radically reconfiguring in Russia.
We all know telegram use sharply up, YouTube is the real outlier for me. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Wikipedia is - my view - the first digital wonder of the world. The largest collection of human knowledge ever assembled for free, it’s unbelievably precious. But we shouldn’t think it’s exempt from the information warfare swirling across the world
www.wired.com/story/wikipedia-state-sponsored-disinformat… -
Carl Miller reposted
The Fix Media
@TheFixMedia
Recent research report by the CASM and @ISDglobal looks at @Wikipedia as a target of information warfare. We spoke with @CarlJackMiller about the report’s findings – and the broader risks Wikipedia might face as authoritarian regimes are growing in power.
thefix.media/2022/11/1/wikipedia-is-a-coveted-target-of-i… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Anyone who thinks you’re gonna solve platform governance with better code has literally not learned a single one of the painfully earned lessons of the past decade.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ I've written about Max Fisher's Chaos Machines in this month's edition of @Lit_Review
Among a whole genre really of books criticising big tech, this is the cleanest account that traces:
big tech's race for attention >
recommender algos >
...
literaryreview.co.uk/are-you-outraged-yet -
Carl Miller reposted
Anton Protsiuk
@antonprotsyuk
Recent report by CASM & @ISDglobal looks at Wikipedia as a target of information warfare.
For @TheFixMedia, I spoke with co-author @carljackmiller about the report, more theoretical risks to Wikipedia & why media spend way too little time covering it.
thefix.media/2022/11/1/wikipedia-is-a-coveted-target-of-i… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I spoke to @antonprotsyuk about wikipedia and information warfare, stretching all the way back to 2018 when I first started to worry it may be targeted. Then to 2019/2020 when we investigated it for the BBC and now more data-driven research out last week
thefix.media/2022/11/1/wikipedia-is-a-coveted-target-of-i… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ I've written about Max Fisher's Chaos Machines in this month's edition of @Lit_Review
Among a whole genre really of books criticising big tech, this is the cleanest account that traces:
big tech's race for attention >
recommender algos >
...
literaryreview.co.uk/are-you-outraged-yetPost not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Fisher recommends to simply turn those recommender algos off. I agree, but this will never be the companies voluntarily doing so. They think it'll destroy them.
To my mind, this is ultimately a story of unrestrained capitalism, and it'll need a political intervention
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
now to set principles around how content should be served up to people. The good news is that at least in Europe we're moving towards that, but it's taken ten years, so much damage, and there's a long way to go yet.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Benjamin Strick
@BenDoBrown
How Spain looked on as dozens were crushed to death at its border - a visual investigation showing our findings at #bbcafricaeye on the deaths that happened earlier this year on Africa's border with Europe.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/extra/z8i55dsu8w/spain-morocco-border -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
My absolute language bugbears are ‘piece’ and ‘space’. You see them bloody everywhere, weakly emulating some kind of management consultese, barely ever actually being clear as to what either the piece or indeed space is. There is always either a more precise or interesting alt
-
Carl Miller reposted
Aspen UK
@uk_aspen
1/2 Next week, in partnership w/ @EUdelegationUK, we will be convening an in-person, 2-part event on Kremlin-led disinformation in the Ukraine war. Join us on Nov 8 10:00 GMT, register: www.aspenuk.org/events/countering-the-kremlins-disinforma…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Attention is our most important resource online, and winning it probably the most difficult challenge for information warfare officers. Actually getting something in front of you, getting you to pay attention, that's far more difficult and fragile than crafting an untruth.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Wow - read this.
Reminder: covert influence in the real world flows through lots of channels. Us researchers normally only see a small slice of it.
Gints Knoks
@Knoks
1/13 Here's a Russian propaganda story for @christogrozev un @bellingcat right out of the movies. We're in Venice, unintentionally eavesdropping on a conversation between 2 Russian guys (a bartender and his friend) and one of the regulars... So 🧵
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Never perfect, I do need to say that Twitter is the one platform that recognised first and most that networks like theirs can cause harm, that attention algos are social poison.
I'm genuinely sorry to see a whole swathe of top execs go today, fired overnight. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ We need fewer journalists (imo) just covering examples or acts of disinformation online. We know it's there. There are two areas to really dig into:
(a) to really deeply spend time with conspiracy theorists to understand how they form and work in ways that are genuinely human
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
rather than utterly dismissive. Dismiss the beliefs, sure, but don't dismiss the very human reasons people are drawn into conspiracy theories. And there's still far, far too much writing that doesn't move past being simply bewildered about the beliefs they have.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
(b) there are actual organisational for-profit entities supplying online manipulation. They will have personnel, bank accounts, pitch decks. They will be hiring people. They will have clients, and case studies. Journalists really, really need to dig into that.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ 'Disinformation' isn't primarily about being lured in by falsehoods. It's about entirely parallel epistemic worlds that have been build, variously rejecting mainstream journalism, scientific method, academia, politics. Just like ours, it has investigators, controversies...
Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
5/ Spamming facts, literacy, debunking, fact-checking, basically interventions at the rational level are not going to work. They're deflected, disassembled, simply ignored. We have to wake up to the facts that basically cults are beginning to dominate our political landscape
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
6/ and know that the interventions are going to have to begin to recognising the sense of drift and drive for meaning that have brought people there in the first place and the emotional and social place where all of this starts from.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Disinformation people (and actually anyone from FB who'd be kind enough to respond):
Am I right in thinking that there's been a trend away from 'coordinated inauthentic behaviour' and towards a wider, more flexible concept of 'adversarial behaviours'?
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
BTW - thank you everyone! I feel very lucky that some genuine world experts give me their thoughts on this
-
Carl Miller reposted
Sage
@Sage_Publishing
Expressing his love for Research Methods, @carljackmiller is discussing information warfare at our London office this evening as part of our Social Science Perspectives series.
#researchmethods #socialscience -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
2018, I started arguing that Wikipedia was overlooked as a venue for info warfare
www.newstatesman.com/science-tech/2018/08/wikipedia-has-r…
In 2019 we did an investigation for the BBC that found documents written by PRC officials arguing to China to support cadres on Wikipedia - www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-49921173 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is astonishing, amazing journalism
@eliothiggins.bsky.social
@EliotHiggins
Ever wonder how Russian cruise missiles find their way into Ukrainian playgrounds, power stations, and apartment buildings? Well thanks to @bellingcat’s @christogrozev wonder no more. It’s time to meet the team behind the targeting of Russian missiles on civilian infrastructure.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ This feels like the moment during the General Election when the Conservative Twitter account rebranded itself a fact-checking account in the middle of a live debate
A lot of ppl work passionately to protect electoral integrity + confront manipulation of online public lifePost not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
3/ But now with the online vote for the next Prime Minister, there is a rising clamour of experts extremely concerned about the integrity of the election administered as it is by a private org not specialised in cyber-security.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
4/ Where at the moment all we really know is that the way it's being handled is bypassing the careful structures that have been put in place for a General Election. We know far less how the Tories intend to keep the election safe from interference.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Go to DEFCON any year and you’ll see identities spoofed, websites merrily hacked, e-commerce scripted, robot hoovers hijacked, laptops hacked with light.
The Tories, a private organisation with ‘advice’ from GCHQ/NSCSC are not the right org to deliver a safe online vote. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Come on Tuesday evening, and talk information warfare/disinformation and how we can go about researching it -
www.eventbrite.com/e/social-science-perspectives-on-disin… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Absolutely bonkers. British politics is total and utter madness.
metro.co.uk/2022/10/22/boris-johnson-reaches-100-backers-… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If anyone is after some cheery weekend reading, we just published a report about trying to characterise suspicious editing behaviour on wikipedia
files.casmtechnology.com/information-warfare-and-wikipedi… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It is so much easier to create new technology than it is to be genuinely creative about definitions and concepts. If i was king of the world, the next 50 counter-disinfo startups would be stuffed full of philosophers creating new vocab and standards of evidence
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Honestly tech community, if I hear ‘feature not bug’ one more time…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Those wanting to study illicit, shadowy online influence operations would do much better to create methods to understand how culty movements are formed and exploited over time than how outright falsehoods are spammed at people.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ Counter-disinformation is now blooming into a full industry - it reminds me of the early days of 'preventing violent extremism' in the UK, when I first started my career.
Just like PVE in the early days however, it's extremely unclear what actually works. A few thoughts: -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I’ve seen this time and time again in Silicon Valley. Not just billionaires, but all kinds and levels of the tech economy. The basic fact is that part of being disruptive is not bothering to learn about the subject matter area that you’re trying to upend
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The way you see tech billionaires slide into geopolitics seized with the idea that they obviously have the solution isn’t an accident. The idea that a - their - way of problem solving can disrupt any industry vertical sits at the very heart of Silicon Valley ideology.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The way you see tech billionaires slide into geopolitics seized with the idea that they obviously have the solution isn’t an accident. The idea that a - their - way of problem solving can disrupt any industry vertical sits at the very heart of Silicon Valley ideology.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We're going to be doing more research on information warfare on Wikipedia with a new project kicking off later this month. If you've looked at this, or have examples of activity or behaviour you think suspicious, I'd like to hear from you. Thank you!
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Those wanting to study illicit, shadowy online influence operations would do much better to create methods to understand how culty movements are formed and exploited over time than how outright falsehoods are spammed at people.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The most neglected, overlooked field (imo) in social science is Cult Studies: how people are pulled into smothering ideologies, detached from family
Explains swathes of US politics + online life, and helpful no doubt in really getting to grips with how people can be pulled out -
Carl Miller reposted
@eliothiggins.bsky.social
@EliotHiggins
To build on this, my personal belief is most counter-disinformation work fails to address the fundamental issues that lead to the creation of disinformation, and generally misunderstands the source of disinformation in the first place.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ Counter-disinformation is now blooming into a full industry - it reminds me of the early days of 'preventing violent extremism' in the UK, when I first started my career.
Just like PVE in the early days however, it's extremely unclear what actually works. A few thoughts: -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ Counter-disinformation is now blooming into a full industry - it reminds me of the early days of 'preventing violent extremism' in the UK, when I first started my career.
Just like PVE in the early days however, it's extremely unclear what actually works. A few thoughts:Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Observation 2. Probably the most important innovation the burgeoning field of counter-disinfo needs right now is (a) standards around how to talk about the approaches that are being used in ways that don't undermine them, (b) clear, fair ways of comparing capabilities
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Any new founder looking to move into this area: don't build yet another secret model. Build something that can be used to test and compare them.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Wikipedia is often so good at keeping up with current events. The shortest Prime Ministerial tenure
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Has to be it. And surely a General Election
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If you're interested in how and whether disinformation is affecting something you care about and new to social media research, we put together a guide with some very accessible, straightforward research methods to help:
www.academia.edu/43847901/The_101_of_Disinformation_Detec… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We're going to be doing more research on information warfare on Wikipedia with a new project kicking off later this month. If you've looked at this, or have examples of activity or behaviour you think suspicious, I'd like to hear from you. Thank you!
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This looks absolutely brilliant! www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/chernobyl-the-lost-tapes-screening…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
New research from us is out today! It's on information warfare on Wikipedia about the invasion of Ukraine
This is our first foray from CASM/@ISDglobal to try to find on Wikipedia what we track across social media: coordinated, covert attempts to manipulate our info ecologies -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Thoughtful piece on the research we put out earlier today - and grateful for the responses from @Wikimedia
www.wired.com/story/wikipedia-state-sponsored-disinformat… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
New research from us is out today! It's on information warfare on Wikipedia about the invasion of Ukraine
This is our first foray from CASM/@ISDglobal to try to find on Wikipedia what we track across social media: coordinated, covert attempts to manipulate our info ecologies
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The subject: suspicious editing behaviour on the English-language Wikipedia page for the Russo-Ukrainian war.
It's freely available here: files.casmtechnology.com/information-warfare-and-wikipedi…
A brief discussion below where i'll go through the paper's main pointsPost not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This does reveal some interesting stuff: below, we see how two known sock-puppet accounts are close to each other. adding seven URLs introduced to the seed page.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
There's more; i'll leave intrepid readers to the full paper.
There's also a lot more we can do to improve and build out our methodologies to detect suspicious activity on Wikipedia. It's an unbelievably precious creation, and we're going to do what we can to help protect it -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If you're interested in how and whether disinformation is affecting something you care about and new to social media research, we put together a guide with some very accessible, straightforward research methods to help:
www.academia.edu/43847901/The_101_of_Disinformation_Detec… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I think i'm going to vote for the least viral, most boring, least retweetable politician in every election from now on
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/I wonder where Silicon Valley exceptionalism is something of a red herring in how we think about the tech giants. We also buy into the mythos when we say that they're differently and exceptionally worse actors than anyone else. The problem is really just unrestrained capitalism
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It's not that they're different from the oil and steel monopolies, or tobacco or large mining concerns or anyone else - it's actually that they have exactly the same incentives, and that these sometimes clash with public health and truth. And in those circumstances companies
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
just don't - and actually can't - make the right decisions without the intervention of government and civic society, often hot on the heels of press expose and public concern.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is just unbelievable
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is absolutely excellent news. Conspiracy theories are so difficult to puncture in the minds of the people who hold them. The next best thing is due process.
Alex Jones told to pay $965m damages to Sandy Hook victims' families www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-63237092 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
You can have wield all sorts of illicit influence online without overt disinformation, and all sorts of disinformation is spread without having any influence. The problem is that we've mapped both concepts on top of each other.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The exploitation of conspiracy theories and theorists by autocratic states is one of the most overlooked parts of geopolitics today
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Would recommend
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Anyone who’s been gritting their teeth through Solovyov content since Feb, should watch this
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Twitter can be a bewildering place
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
YouTube has got off way, way too lightly over the years
Martin Lewis
@MartinSLewis
Today's FRIDAY poll: Acme Inc has just created the world's first CorporateDeleteButton® and, congratulations, you have won a first choice to use it. It deletes an entire corporation from history, so as if it never existed.
You MUST choose one of these firms to delete, pick... -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Just think of all the decent politicians who have failed to get anywhere because they wouldn’t change their rhetoric to the kind of thing that would break through on social media. Genuinely, that’s as much of a cost as the rise of polarising sectarian populists.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Really such an interesting article theintercept.com/2022/10/05/russia-ukraine-putin-cia/
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I’ve never been quite sure about the idea of ‘inoculating’ a population against information threats. Metaphors can be stretched too far. Have people seen evidence that it works, beyond the explicit pre-bunking before feb 24th?
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I don't want tech giants:
- To give handouts to journalistic organisations
- Train people in digital literacy
- Take the role of police online
- Decide what is/isn't disinfo.
I want them to pay tax alongside us and everyone else - and we fund police/librarians/journalists -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Do you remember when the tech giants' defensive line was: 'the answer to bad speech is more speech' ?
Whatever happened to that? -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'm always surprised by how much attention it *looks* like orchestrated propagandists pay to the comments threads of mainstream news articles. We tend to view influence ops as primarily broadcast, but a lot of it is really about dominating reply spaces.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Our poor lizard brains are so frail in the face of infinite information and powerful machine learning.
We’ll never be good citizens without first understanding all the weaknesses, heuristics and biases we carry around inside ourselves wherever we go. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Totally remarkable
Igor Kyivskyi
@Ihor_from_Kyiv
The Russian Occupiers in the Kherson direction began to surrender together with military equipment
Part one 1/1 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
A top-tier think tank talent and over 7 years totally pioneering in that weird field of social media research that we first joined: Josh thanks for everything you've done for demos - it's a list far longer than even the long storm of achievements you listed below
Josh Smith
@Jphsmith
So last week was my last week @Demos; after 7 years it's been strange not to be in over the last few days. But has given me some time to reflect on the breadth of work you get to do at a #thinktank 1/
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I don't like disinformation - i don't think it's a good label - at all - for illicit state influence online. I think it leads us to assume a much too rationalist conception of the problem. But raising it, I often get a 'think tanker talking about definitions' eye-roll
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
My big fear for the future of disinfo is in the use of natural language processing and virtual agents to emulate long-term conversations and contacts with people. It’d be much less broadcast, more discursive, manipulation coming through social bonds, even friendships not lies.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
“Russian narrative has been very present here… Now it’s time for Ukrainian truths”
www.nytimes.com/2022/10/04/world/africa/kuleba-africa-tou… -
Carl Miller reposted
Stephen Khan
@StephenKhan
This will be a fantastic event – @carljackmiller a very engaging, funny and illuminating speaker. Hosted by @SAGEPublishers @ConversationUK and @CfSocialScience www.eventbrite.com/e/social-science-perspectives-on-disin…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It’s surprising to me that we don’t link the transgressions of big tech more firmly to unchecked markets and unrestrained capitalism. We seem to think these companies are particularly or differently evil in some way. But they’re just profit-maximising like any other corp.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Vitality is really one of the most powerful forces that has seized society. I remember putting together a book proposal - ‘Viral’ - in 2015. I wish I’d written it.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Years and years before Cambridge Analytica, there was already an electoral 'consultant' running amok in elections across Latin America, genuinely trailblazing (in my view) the tradecraft of illicit influence we're struggling with today.
www.wired.co.uk/article/carl-miller-disinformation-gets-c… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Come and talk information warfare and disinformation with me in London in October?
www.eventbrite.com/e/social-science-perspectives-on-disin… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Come and talk information warfare and disinformation with me in London in October?
www.eventbrite.com/e/social-science-perspectives-on-disin… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I’m currently at a conference at Wilton Park on disinformation. Which is one of the most beautiful venues ever.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Jamie Bartlett 🇬🇧
@JamieJBartlett
Episode 10 of The Missing Cryptoqueen is now out.
The hunt it back on: Israel, Dubai, Luxembourg, The Eurovision Song Contest & Krispy Kremes.
Sorry, it’s taken me & @GeorgiaJCatt a while. And welcome to our new teammate @ByrnesyGsy! www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/p0d30qz3?partner=uk.co.bbc&orig… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Google 'buy retweets' and tell me there aren't some low hanging fruit to combat platform manipulation.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Zahed Amanullah
@zahed
.@carljackmiller guests this @bbcworldservice podcast that features Polis, a technology that attempts to provide a more accurate assessment of opinions on controversial topics.
A case study takes place in #harrogate, with my opinion on it at 17:30. www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct3j2q -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is a useful thing for disinfo researchers - makes available the various public datasets of influence operations disclosures made by the platforms - www.io-archive.org
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Anyone who describes the impact of social media as simply amplifying or de-frictioning older phenomena - something I hear a lot at conferences - really doesn’t recognise the way it’s proactively designed and tested to give users a particular experience.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Twitter - what digital literacy programmes do you think are most worth remembering?
Either tremendously successful, unsuccessful, or that tried something different? -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It's so striking that flashback to 2016 and Facebook here (like the other platforms) really considered false news stories as 'hoaxes' and, as such, "a form of news feed spam".
It's not that the platforms weren't thinking about the problem, it's that
about.fb.com/news/2015/01/news-feed-fyi-showing-fewer-hoa…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
it was broadly considered to be a user-experience issue primarily, rather than something that had deep societal political (indeed, democratic) implications. I'm not posting this to bash Facebook, but to show the danger in building something of vast societal consequence when
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
you're really unable to grasp that consequence yourself, and actually come from an industry that simply isn't used to doing so or able to do so.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Years and years before Cambridge Analytica, there was already an electoral 'consultant' running amok in elections across Latin America, genuinely trailblazing (in my view) the tradecraft of illicit influence we're struggling with today.
www.wired.co.uk/article/carl-miller-disinformation-gets-c… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'm putting out here my chronology of how counter-disinfo has evolved. Please really do dispute this and argue with me, i'm stress testing.
PHASE 1. 2013ish-2016 (largely platform-funded initiatives)
- Digital literacy
- Fact-checking
- Counter-speech -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/The threat (as i see it) to Wikipedia and other open-source environments from states isn't vandalism, it's entryism leading to co-option. People secretly supported by states over the long term to make entirely legitimate edits, building up their reputation within the community
Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
3/ At the same time the state would harass, threaten, put pressure on and try to drive away any editors or communities who stand in the way of doing that. You'd bank on the fact that you can out-last, and out-grind volunteer communities in the long term.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
4/ The same, really, might be said for lots of other open networks too. I think we still hold very crude ideas of what information warfare looks like: bots spamming stuff. If you're an info officer working for a state and you're still doing that, you're an unimaginative idiot.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
2018, I started arguing that Wikipedia was overlooked as a venue for info warfare
www.newstatesman.com/science-tech/2018/08/wikipedia-has-r…
In 2019 we did an investigation for the BBC that found documents written by PRC officials arguing to China to support cadres on Wikipedia - www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-49921173Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
2022 - we're about to publish research looking at pro-Russian activities on Wikipedia, looking at the almost 800k edits across 300k pages made by 86 banned editors who had been active on the page regarding the Russian invasion of Ukraine.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Lesson: disinformation researchers - move beyond Twitter and Crowdtangle. There's a whole world of vulnerable information ecosystems out there, and we need more methods and detection regimens that work (and are used) across all of them.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This group, Forensic Architect, do some really amazing work - forensic-architecture.org
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
You are not being targeted by an influence campaign when you’re squinting at a fact, trying to decide if it’s true. You’re being targeted when your view of the world is being soothed, flattered, confirmed and gently guided in a certain direction.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
You are not being targeted by an influence campaign when you’re squinting at a fact, trying to decide if it’s true. You’re being targeted when your view of the world is being soothed, flattered, confirmed and gently guided in a certain direction.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
About a decade ago, I spent a year arguing with the 9/11 truth movement. What I learned was it’s members drew an incredible amount of meaning from being involved. They wore T-shirts: it was an identity. They had friends there. And it’s meaningful to be in on a big secret…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
That you’re trying to wake the rest of the world up to. I’m sure its going to be the same for anti-Vax, or any of the conspiracist communities that came after it. And you don’t correct that just with better facts. The attachments are much deeper than reason.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If you don’t think the problem is disinfo, but instead coordinated actors using a whole tradecraft of illicit influence of which disinfo is a part, new solutions open up for you. Rather than trying to regulate truth on the internet, you can directly target those actors
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is the way forwards - finding economic, legal and technical ways of putting more pressure on the people who are willing to game online systems either for profit or geopolitical advantage.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Very pleased - thrilled actually - to say, as of today I'm a Visiting Fellow at the King's War Studies Department, Intelligence and Security Group. @kclintelligence
What a fab team. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I've interviewed a few people over the years who have actually conducted influence operations. They always say the same thing:
'I don't lie about the world to get someone to change their mind. I tell them something they already believe and guide that in a certain direction.' -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Whoever arms us with the new conceptual landscape, the terms and definitions we need to fight back against the kind of information we now see - they should win the Nobel Prize.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
My problem with using 'disinfo' as a fairly poor analytical umbrella term for illicit influence operations is that we're now at the point when the idea is being baked both into law (with the online safety bill) and also the machinery for govt.
... -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
My problem with using 'disinfo' as a fairly poor analytical umbrella term for illicit influence operations is that we're now at the point when the idea is being baked both into law (with the online safety bill) and also the machinery for govt.
...
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Setting up groups in whitehall with the self-stated aim of reducing or responding to 'disinformation' that is propagated completely misses all the other nefarious way that influence is exerted online. By definition, it kind of creates blind spots that'll be hard to reverse
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
in the years ahead as they become deeper, firmer parts of public life, government, law, funding mechanisms, grants, public lectures etc etc.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Another musing from disinformation conferences I'd like to share is about a key gap that I think exists between influence ops and responses.
It's emotion vs. reason
Those on the front lines pulling influence ops stress how emotive they are. How they appeal to identity, and...Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Likewise, a lot of what we throw at the problem are fact checking, digital literacy, games to teach how to source claims etc. Helping us navigate all these epistemic icebergs floating in the sea of user-generated content.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
BTW i have no quarrel with digital literacy or fact checking, but it speaks completely past the problem of the kind of influence campaigns I've just laid out. They're two different worlds, using two different ideas for how influence works.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I was at a disinformation conference today, and a solid thread was actually how disinformation consists of remarkably little of the content influence operations rely on. Much more common are cherry-picked truths, emotive appeals. The lie often happens at the sub-content level...
Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
that underlie the content that i believe really are new. And not simply the scale - people always talk about how it's simply an increase in quantity. But it's a qualitative change: seeing something super highly shared, or up-ranked or engaged with on digital platforms
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
changes how much you trust it, where you think it's from and the authority you think its carries. It's not just old stuff, more than before.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Heading to Manchester for a conference on disinformation. I really did miss this part of my work over COVID - so much more than I thought I would.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Marc Goodman in the Harvard Journal of Law and Technology. In 1997...
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ There's a real fracturing happening in where important online stuff is happening. Tons of new streaming, fundraising, gaming, networking platforms. You really can't just study Twitter and Facebook anymore (you never really could). A thread on what this means for researchers
Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
My team is generally opting to go for the latter, which which means language analysis through text analytics, mainly. Natural language is the common output of so many of these platforms, whilst engagement and connection data aren't, and on many aren't that available.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Keen to know peoples' thoughts and how they're approaching this.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Intelligence Squared
@intelligence2
📚 Essential reading ahead of tonight's event with @gonultol.
Gönül Tol
@gonultol
The cover of my book has gone live. It will be out in August 😊
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This will be fun - @intelligence2 ers - i'll see you this evening!
intelligencesquared.com/events/erdogans-war-the-quest-for… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is interesting for disinfo researchers - not for the chronology I put together for how disinfo developed, but for all the really good ideas and critiques that people then gave.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'm putting out here my chronology of how counter-disinfo has evolved. Please really do dispute this and argue with me, i'm stress testing.
PHASE 1. 2013ish-2016 (largely platform-funded initiatives)
- Digital literacy
- Fact-checking
- Counter-speech -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I recently spoke to @samuelmoyn for @intelligence2 about his new book arguing that war (waged by Western states in the forms of drones, laywers etc) has been tweaked to be less randomly brutal, and in so doing more palatable + easier to sustain.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6_Wp_uD4TY -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'm putting out here my chronology of how counter-disinfo has evolved. Please really do dispute this and argue with me, i'm stress testing.
PHASE 1. 2013ish-2016 (largely platform-funded initiatives)
- Digital literacy
- Fact-checking
- Counter-speechPost not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Phase 3 (CIB becomes more sophisticated, foundations give more funding, larger responses)
- Specialist dashboards, web-accessible interfaces
- Account-based patterns/heuristics
- Beginning of blending between earlier methods
- Specific deployments to protect elections.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Phase 4. CIB & Responses both commercialise
-VC startups - models/ML.
- Third-party content moderation companies
- AI also applied to previous approaches like network analysis, OSINT)
- Threat actor analysis of emerging forums/markets offering disinformation/CIB-as-a-service. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If you're into disinformation research, this is an absolutely fascinating read - one of the big TLDRs is that whilst disinfo has ballooned as a topic of concern, there actually hasn't been a ton of money flowing into solutions.
www.gmfus.org/news/ai-startups-and-fight-against-misdisin… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is so incredibly moving - the liberation of Balaklyia
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The most vicious and worrying forms of disinformation aren't just spamming out a lie. It's epistemic confrontation: building entirely alternative experts, authorities and methods to validate the truth. This is why I've always been so worried about conspiracy theories...
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Amazing investigation
jake tacchi
@jaketacchi
NEW 🇷🇺 INVESTIGATION - 🧵
Six months ago two audio clips appeared online.
They were recorded inside Moscow's Brateyevo police station on a day when large anti-war demonstrations swept Russia. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
To me, the people prosecuting information operations now are like those devastating natural ecologies. Driven by person interest, and maybe even with some sort of self-justification, but wilfully blind to the wider and historic damage that they're doing.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Sasha Fegan
@sashafegan
Thanks @carljackmiller for the great quote in my article 😊 www.lowyinstitute.org/the-interpreter/web3-coming-nationa…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Going through old books and found this. 2008. My train journey tomorrow just got more interesting.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
In an age of information warfare, why would we expect Wikipedia to be exempt?
Overlooking it means a lot of Wikipedia editors standing in the way of hostile state activity can feel isolated and alone - restofworld.org/2022/russias-6-month-war-on-wikipedia/?ut… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
COP 27 is just around the corner
If it's anything like COP26, we'll see a lot of attempts to fold it into conspiracy theories and the culture wars. As an extension of social control by shadowy elites, and an attempt to 'bring down' the West from within
www.isdglobal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Summative-Re… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
To those who do it, the manipulation of information is a route towards power, influence and profit. We have done an extremely bad (largely non-existent) job at getting stuck into those incentives and changing what they look like.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The most vicious and worrying forms of disinformation aren't just spamming out a lie. It's epistemic confrontation: building entirely alternative experts, authorities and methods to validate the truth. This is why I've always been so worried about conspiracy theories...
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is exactly what they're been doing for decades now. Numerology, pseudo-scientific 'journals', the seeing of hidden patterns -it's all there. And with autocratic states amplifying and entrenching that world, it's going to get worse.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It is very strange but I think true, that in a world full of data and technology, we know less and less about how our lives are shaped and who is doing the shaping. Algorithmic decision-making, tech giants, info warfare, 'deep fakes' - i see each as extension of that basic fact
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The information age is characterised not just by the centrality of information but also threats to it. Information both surrounds us more and more, but we've probably never been more worried by it, or suspicious of it. The key paradox of our age, I think.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
🥹
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It is fairly mad to me that we try to up-skill entire populations with digital literacy skills to detect influence operations when companies openly offer platform manipulation services with total impunity.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is very interesting - a survey of around 100 (primarily American and European) researchers of influence operations - what they look at, how they look at it
carnegieendowment.org/2022/08/02/best-practice-guidance-f… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Every time I hear 'sentiment analysis', I shudder...
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Gian is a brilliant tech journalist. If you're in Brussels, grab a coffee with him!
Gian M. Volpicelli
@Gmvolpi
Today is my first day on @POLITICOEurope majestic tech desk— covering AI, emerging tech and much more. Needless to say I'm utterly stoked!
If you are in Brussels and want to grab a coffee/meet-and-greet/send tips, hit me up! -
Carl Miller reposted
The Voices Of War
@TheVoicesOfWar
Is #ukraine winning the global #informationwar?
During my chat with @SpencerGuard, we talked about @carljackmiller's research into possible #russian #influenceoperations in #brics countries. Who is 'winning' there?
Here is that interview 👇👇👇
www.podbean.com/ew/pb-t3bn3-11df90e -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Spammers - far more important than most people think.
In a world of unlimited digital content, capturing attention really is the basis for so much power.
Victoire Rio
@riovictoire
Facebook just reported on what got the most views in the US last quarter.
* 5 out of the 20 most viewed links * came from spammers. Not media. Not creators.
Where it gets more wild is that all 5⃣ posts came from a single actor - with a long history in … 🇲🇲Myanmar
/ 🧵 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If you see disinformation hitting an area that you care about - maybe you want to raise the alarm but don't know how to go about measuring it.
We put together a straightforward way of making sense of disinfo that anyone can do
www.isdglobal.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/isd_101.pd -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
A while ago now, myself and others wrote a paper that looked at how to study platforms like Twitter to understand more general attitudes in ways that are robust. This has become quite a common form of research in recent years, so i thought to re-share:
demosuk.wpengine.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Road_to_r… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Am I correct that the current regulatory line of thinking for DAOs is to treat every holder of a governance token as essentially a director of a DAO as if it were a business?
So practically if 10k anonymous wallets pool crypto in a DAO, what is supposed to happen? -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Politics in America continues to terrify me - especially how radicalism mixes with tech.
I am genuinely consoled, however, by the number and sheer variety of people really very fervently now working to protect democracy and electoral integrity -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We created this mapping of the Twitter political universe back in 2015 for News Night.
We don't live entirely in narrow echo chambers online, but information flows do tend fo be very partisan -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We know that western liberal democratic militaries 'manoeuvre' in information spaces, and have built capability to do so.
What we need are rules of engagement in information. What do we consider it legitimate (or not) for our states to do? With what end? What what limits? -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The crazy growth of the tech giants has
1) now means everyone defines themselves as a tech company, even if they're not
2) we fetishise exponential growth - which i genuinely worry about - because there's plenty of other extremely decent models out there -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I would say, probably the most underrated quality for any new start-up, research group, etc is simply staying power. The ability to hang around, dig in, keep going. The problem you end up working on is hardly ever the one you started out to solve.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Working on creating 3D representations of online influence operations, based on the general way that participating social media accounts use language. Will be unbelievably cool if we can get it work.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The thing that a lot of ML start-ups don't want to shout about is that unless you're Google, the underlying idea for the machine learning you're using is (a) very likely a published approach in the field, (b) unlikely to actually be your company's.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It is genuinely difficult to know how well any of these new disinformation technologies work. So many of the explanations basically boil down to: an arrow saying 'data' going into a box saying 'machine learning' and then another arrow saying 'resilience increased'.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It is genuinely difficult to know how well any of these new disinformation technologies work. So many of the explanations basically boil down to: an arrow saying 'data' going into a box saying 'machine learning' and then another arrow saying 'resilience increased'.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Anyone around Medicine festival this Friday?! Come and say hello :)
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
🎉🎉
Intelligence Squared
@intelligence2
As warfare became more humane in the twenty-first century did it also become endless?
@samuelmoyn and @carljackmiller discuss later today on Intelligence Squared+ 👇
intelligencesquared.com/events/forever-war-how-conflict-b… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I was involved in this last week - very proud of it
www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct3j2q -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
A brilliant comment made in an event I was in last week (Chatham House, so I won't attribute) looked back to a now-declassified report from the Political Warfare Executive during the Second World War.
The finding? That outright lies didn't really work to influence publics
1/2 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
‘And then, there were none’
-
Carl Miller reposted
BBC World Service
@bbcworldservice
Can an online debating platform help people divided by their politics meet in the middle?
www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct3j2q -
Carl Miller reposted
RISING Global Peace Forum
@RISINGforum
#digitalpeace: this blog by @katyminshall and @carljackmiller was written in different times but, especially in the light of the #ukrainerussianwar and the online war, it's still a very relevant debate blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/nation-states-… #data #transparency
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Word of the day: splooting
-
Carl Miller reposted
The Computational Democracy Project
@compdem
Easy to understand, 23 minute piece on @bbcworldservice about @polis in Taiwan and the UK!
Thank you @carljackmiller, @MyraAnubi
@ShiromaTSilva
www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct3j2q -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I've reported my first BBC radio programme!
We hear so much about the threats that technology poses to democracy, but this is a story about how it can also make it stronger, even change what it is
With @MyraAnubi @ShiromaTSilva @bbcworldservice
www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct3j2q -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This looks great
Jonathan Corpus Ong
@jonathan_c_ong
Thrilled to get my physical copy of #trollsforsale, a collection of short essays and lectures about the Philippines’ disinformation-for-hire industry and what we can do about it. We intended this to be accessible to all at Php220 from Lazada online: www.lazada.com.ph/products/trolls-for-sale-by-jonathan-co…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I've reported my first BBC radio programme!
We hear so much about the threats that technology poses to democracy, but this is a story about how it can also make it stronger, even change what it is
With @MyraAnubi @ShiromaTSilva @bbcworldservice
www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3ct3j2q -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I've just finished recording a 30 minute story for Radio 4 on how technology can actually strengthen democracy. I don't get to focus on too many positive stories; they feel amazing when I do.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Wow - metro.co.uk/2022/08/03/tory-leadership-vote-delayed-after…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
.@YouTube what ads are you running on your platform?
So yes, I did click through. One of those six questions? The other image I've pasted here.
This is completely outrageous. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
.@YouTube what ads are you running on your platform?
So yes, I did click through. One of those six questions? The other image I've pasted here.
This is completely outrageous. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
A brilliant comment made in an event I was in last week (Chatham House, so I won't attribute) looked back to a now-declassified report from the Political Warfare Executive during the Second World War.
The finding? That outright lies didn't really work to influence publics
1/2
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
They'd already found things we now see all the time during online influence campaigns: that selectively picked truths are more powerful
It really is all about amplification and cherry-picking. You can paint whatever world you want like that. There are enough truths out there -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Have you built a model to detect hate speech (or something similar)?
I'd love to hear from you. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
To be effective, detections of illicit influence campaigns need to be connected to effective responses to them; ways of making them less effective, long-lived of levying reputational or economic costs in conducting them and of degrading their technical capacity to them out.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
One thing we need to get much better at is to work out how online influence operations link to influence across other fields - from PMCs to economic inducements. Hard to do, I know, but just looking at spammy activity on a single platform isn't getting us there.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
New episode of @intelligence2!
I speak to the brilliant @johnsweeneyroar as he traces the arc of Putin's life, from disputed early beginnings to KGB underling, collapse of the USSR, St Petersburg politics, bombings in Russia, Chechnya, Ukraine, and now
open.spotify.com/episode/0Ck68no7IbIGv8nuI9dwWb -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
New report!
CASM + @ISDglobal, looking at how extremist and disinformation actors are moving away from mainstream SM platforms and where they're going. This raises absolutely huge challenges for regulation, and simply just keeping track w/t/ phenomenon
www.isdglobal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/Researching-… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is one of the most remarkable threads I have genuinely ever read
Christo Grozev
@christogrozev
Today FSB announced that they have “foiled a plot by Ukraine’s intelligence services” to lure Russian military pilots to surrender to Ukraine – with their planes – in return for millions of USD in payments (thread).
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
To this I’ll add: TikTok has no public API. We can’t research the platform at scale. The exposure of bad stuff online is a function of data availability, not a fair reflection of where it’s happening.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Over the last past few months, I’ve met a number of people who *only* (not primarily, only) get their news from TikTok - one explicitly to avoid the manipulation of the MSM (and so making his news diet prey to a single, opaque content curation algo) www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-62238307
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
One of the striking things I’ve noticed about a lot of the software to do online influence ops (/illicit online marketing) is the emphasis they put on spoofing platforms to run paid ads from lots of seemingly unconnected accounts. Lots of emphasis on that.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ A really big gap has opened up. Disinformation has become enormous - not only as a issue, but something commentated on, researched, written about. But barely any of this knows how it's actually done: the software, the tools, trade-offs, services on offer.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
There’s a wonderful bit in Dune. They’ve just completed interstellar travel, but now -NOW - is a new challenge: they need to adjust all their time pieces to local time. Don’t worry though, Duke Atreides has assigned a ‘tech’ to take care of it.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
CASM + @GI_TOC work together to build a system to detect the sale of endangered plants or animals on the internet that is:
- platform agnostic
- scaled
- learns from itself
The latest is on pangolins. Horrible trade. Proud of the work to expose it.
globalinitiative.net/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/GITOC-MMF… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Anyone who thinks liberal and conservative mainstream media are in cahoots to suppress the population needs to see how much rival outfits within the same news organisation loathe each other.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Over the last past few months, I’ve met a number of people who *only* (not primarily, only) get their news from TikTok - one explicitly to avoid the manipulation of the MSM (and so making his news diet prey to a single, opaque content curation algo) www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-62238307
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ A really big gap has opened up. Disinformation has become enormous - not only as a issue, but something commentated on, researched, written about. But barely any of this knows how it's actually done: the software, the tools, trade-offs, services on offer.
Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
3/ The consequence? A constantly evolving set of capabilities with constantly lowering barriers to entry. More specialised services too, and a wider range. If you want to confront 'disinformation' look at disrupting this and the organised ppl who use it as much as anywhere else.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
4/ We just have to do better than what we are. Because alongside the purveyors of online manipulation are organisations with financial histories and client lists. This is really what will expose the realities of online manipulation, not surfacing content-level examples of it.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I've wholeheartedly come to the conclusion that the most overlooked piece of the disinformation puzzle is also the lowest hanging fruit to actually doing something about it.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ A really big gap has opened up. Disinformation has become enormous - not only as a issue, but something commentated on, researched, written about. But barely any of this knows how it's actually done: the software, the tools, trade-offs, services on offer.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Recorded Future looked at disinformation-for-hire outfits on Russian-lang parts of the darknet, seeking services to both trash and boost a fictitious corporation. V. interesting study whose experience in accessing such services is be summarised thusly:
go.recordedfuture.com/hubfs/reports/cta-2019-0930.pdf -
Carl Miller reposted
The Voices Of War
@TheVoicesOfWar
Last week @TheVoicesOfWar sailed past 50,000 downloads!!! 🥳🎉🎇🎊
Some of the guests who've appeared on the show are (in order of appearance): @tonyingesson, @ThreshedThought, @adalhaug, @DrAndyNo, @JasonPackLibya, @DPBEthics, @davidwhetham, @carljackmiller, @peterwsinger... -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This was a really brilliant interview - an @intelligence2 event on Greed, Fortune and the Hunt for the Missing Crypto Queen with @JamieJBartlett and Layla Begum.
To me, the most striking thing was that crypto provided the techno-babbled explanation (1/3)
www.youtube.com/watch?v=7sJ6jkbFAeY
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
For why something so gravity-defying, so too-good-to-be true as OneCoin was plausible (after all, hadn't bitcoin defied gravity too?)
but it was actually the close social bonds of the multi-level marketing that really drove the trust and investment. The success...
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
of OneCoin came from wrapping together something distant, complex and inexplicable (the tech) with something so familiar, close to you and reassuring (the recommendation to invest, via MLM)
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
“The risk of Russia resorting to nuclear weapons in the Ukraine war is overstated”.
trendsresearch.org/insight/the-ukraine-war-nuclear-risks-… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I just interviewed @johnsweeneyroar about Killer in the Kremlin (which I also just finished today). I really cannot recommend it enough; intrepid, dogged brave reporting on the most difficult and dangerous journalistic terrain you could imagine
Read it
www.penguin.co.uk/books/453960/killer-in-the-kremlin-by-s… -
Carl Miller reposted
Intelligence Squared
@intelligence2
Our online event with @johnsweeneyroar and @carljackmiller on Putin's Long War is just about to get under way. Join the livestream and ask your questions at: intelligencesquared.com/events/putins-long-war-from-chech…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Courtney Stephenson
@CourtSteph13
Excited that my first @Demos report 'Movers and Stayers', co-authored with @kslharrison launches today! We spoke to people from coastal and ex-industrial towns and developed our vision for levelling up towns, drawing on what they told us. Some of our key takeaways in a 🧵
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Today!
intelligencesquared.com/events/putins-long-war-from-chech… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We're currently tracking around 700 of China's diplomats (ambassadors, consular officials etc) on FB and TW. A few thoughts and interesting patterns re: changes in their behaviour over the invasion of Ukraine. This is preliminary; not firmed-up claims.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We're currently tracking around 700 of China's diplomats (ambassadors, consular officials etc) on FB and TW. A few thoughts and interesting patterns re: changes in their behaviour over the invasion of Ukraine. This is preliminary; not firmed-up claims.
Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
6) Across all regions, they're keener on using these kinds of phrases than Zelensky (this phrasal analysis, as presented, is crude: there are all kinds of transliterations across languages i'm not paying attention to here).
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
7) Last, layer named entity recognition on top of the military messages, you can see it's a mixed bag. Some to do with Ukraine of course, but also Hong Kong, Taiwan, Afghanistan, Pakistan. Russia doesn't dominate.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Setting the problem up as 'disinformation' completely hamstrings you, because there is basically no intervention either govt or platforms can make to constantly correct normal people propagating info that is untrue. You just can't do it.
Instead... 1/2
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
You need to see the problem as a small number of bad actors using a constantly evolving deceptive and covert tradecraft within organised campaigns to express illicit forms of influence through digital life. This is a completely completely different kind of problem.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'll be speaking about online hostile state influence and disinformation at the Cambridge Security Conference (in Cambridge) on Friday/Sat - do say hello if you're around!
thecsi.org.uk/conference/ -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Is there any reasonably broad view of the different kinds (let alone origins) of disinfo associated with the UK?
It seems to me that there's this process where people look for disinfo from places where it's already known to come from, which over times massively skews us -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is both brilliant work and utterly horrific at the same time. www.bellingcat.com/news/2022/03/17/hospitals-bombed-and-a…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
19 July, I'm talking to @johnsweeneyroar for @intelligence2 about Putin (and his new book, Killer in the Kremlin).
Come join us
intelligencesquared.com/events/putins-long-war-from-chech… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I honestly cannot believe the Online Safety Bill is back in play during the leadership contest.
As vote-getting as it might be to trash it as some form of 'woke' overreach; in reality getting rid of it will plunge public life back onto the whims of distant tech companies. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I can’t vouch for this translation of course, but there have been a few moments over the war when Margarita Simonyan (editor in chief of RT) has been luridly candid about the thinking happening over there.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Um. Honestly watch this from 1.20 onwards…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
‘Lower taxes’ is literally the least imaginative campaign platform of all time.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Apologies, this is a grumpy tweet.
It is a ridiculous thing to see a slew of huge professional services companies who are **not innovative in any way whatsoever** advising government on technology innovation. These are companies who are charging to advise on what they cannot do. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I get asked a lot about how the malign online influence of one state differs from another, which have greatest impact in the UK.
I can't answer them because any answer imo implies there is we know more about these phenomena than we don't know, whereas the opposite is true. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'm going into Parliament later today to give evidence about online state influence activities for the National Security Bill. What an... interesting day to go in.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Of the absolutely endless sea of work being done on the digital conflict around Ukraine, this is one of the most noteworthy and broadest in scope.
query.prod.cms.rt.microsoft.com/cms/api/am/binary/RE50KOK
For those short on time, I'll pull out a few of the most striking and specific claims, below:Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
America/Europe to undermine Western unity
Nonaligned to sustain UN/diplomatic support (this is the one I've been looking most at)
They now call these perpertators 'Advance Persistent Manipulator' (APM) teams
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
"We’re concerned that many current Russian cyber influence operations currently go for months without proper detection, analysis, or public reporting" - This is undoubtedly true
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
🍿
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
You know what doesn't get enough visibility or funding in disinformation response? Threat-actor research
The nitty gritty work of actually tracking the disinformation services that are offered, technology that develops, the norms that emerge from the ppl who perpetrate it -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It might not have rippled out much beyond the circles of the journalists, fact-checkers and researchers who use it, but rumours abound that Meta will shut down a tool called Crowdtangle - the only way really to see what's going on, on FB. Here's the former CEO talking about it
Brandon Silverman
@brandonsilverm
I've been offline for most of the last week but thought I'd jump in with a few thoughts about the article below. 🧵 below:
www.theverge.com/2022/6/23/23180357/meta-crowdtangle-shut…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is a big deal.
If it goes away - or is replaced with something more restricted - you'll notice a difference almost immediately. All those stories about the bad things that happen on social media - their scale, targets, consequences - etc - will just dry up...
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
And so also, therefore, will the scrutiny and public accountability over the largest social media platform in the world.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Devon county show 🔥
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is one of the most interesting articles I’ve read in months www.reuters.com/investigates/special-report/usa-hackers-l…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Whether it’s fact checking or digital literacy, many of the ways we have of countering disinfo rely on the active cooperation of its targets. Most of the time however it’s audience are willing participants, having their suspicions confirmed and beliefs buttressed
-
Carl Miller reposted
Jonathan Fink 🇬🇧 🇺🇦 Silicon Curtain Podcast
@CurtainSilicon
In my interview with @carljackmiller we discussed the death of the 20th century’s propaganda weapons, and the creation of more powerful, ones in the 21st. Carl is an extaordinary expert in the field, and it's a compelling and quite scary conversation.
www.youtube.com/channel/UC3J6Rx5Qcx6-v6W9BBgF8sw -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Very odd to me that, in the world of disinformation response, so completely full of vocab like 'machine learning' and 'innovation' - there's been basically no true disruption at all. When did a response come in that everything on its head? All our responses v. incremental
-
Carl Miller reposted
Dan McCrum
@FD
MONEY MEN is out today!
The thrilling true story of Wirecard’s wild rise and crashing fall charts an investigation like no other. It reveals hidden worlds of short sellers and whistleblowers, pornographers and private militias, hackers and spies. 🧵1/6
www.amazon.co.uk/House-Wirecard-Dan-McCrum/dp/178763504X -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
For @intelligence2 I speak to @cblatts about his brilliant new book 'Why we Fight'. Organised conflict is so ruinous, he tells us, that it actually needs quite specific conditions to erupt and persist. Understanding the various logics (there are five)...
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/why-we-fight-with-christoph…
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
that lead to conflict can help you understand how to build insulation from them - whether it's gang warfare in Colombia or gigantic inter-state conflict. I found the whole discussion thoroughly important; obviously given current events, but in a wider sense too.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Catrin Nye
@CatrinNye
My mum has become the latest person to be priced out of her home town in mid Wales due to a severe lack of affordable rentals & the explosion of holiday & second homes. For owners they bring in great money compared to long term rentals but that means no homes for people like mum.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Just a reminder that (some) states almost certainly have wikipedia in their information warfare crosshairs
www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-49921173 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Does anyone - really *anyone* - believe the world would be a better place if large technology companies could operate with greater secrecy? That the digital age would be better shaped to giving humans fulfilling and meaningful lives?
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This would be a very dark day for tech transparency
If it happens, I can't see how governments could avoid putting some sort of replacement on a statutory basis. Simply cannot have large online services operating in ways researchers/journalists can't see
www.theverge.com/2022/6/23/23180357/meta-crowdtangle-shut… -
Carl Miller reposted
The Lowy Institute
@LowyInstitute
Are liberal democracies responding in the right ways to online misinformation? In this episode of Rules Based Audio, @sashafegan speaks to @carljackmiller about online manipulation, disinformation, misinformation and inauthentic behaviour. Listen here: www.lowyinstitute.org/publications/rules-based-audio-what…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
With BBC Monitoring, we've built a system to track China's diplomats and state media across Twitter and Facebook. Followed about 800 accounts now for 2 years now, and a stable of algorithms identifies nine themes (military, human rights etc) across four languages
Isn't it cool? -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Any ideas, hunches, bugbears about what China and the messaging its state media and diplomats might have put out (say, over the Ukraine invasion) that you want us to dig into -
let me know!
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
With BBC Monitoring, we've built a system to track China's diplomats and state media across Twitter and Facebook. Followed about 800 accounts now for 2 years now, and a stable of algorithms identifies nine themes (military, human rights etc) across four languages
Isn't it cool? -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
With BBC Monitoring, we've built a system to track China's diplomats and state media across Twitter and Facebook. Followed about 800 accounts now for 2 years now, and a stable of algorithms identifies nine themes (military, human rights etc) across four languages
Isn't it cool? -
Carl Miller reposted
Jamie Bartlett 🇬🇧
@JamieJBartlett
The Missing Cryptoqueen book is now out!
The story of the multi-billion dollar Ponzi scheme OneCoin, crypto-hype, investor FOMO & a missing founder.
Our podcast was just one part of this crazy story. Now here's the rest...
www.penguin.co.uk/books/112/1120307/the-missing-cryptoque… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Here’s a bit more information coming out about the Russian cyber warfare we were all expecting - although seems most known successes have either been stolen data or DDOS. www.politico.com/news/2022/06/22/russian-hackers-target-u…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Vesper-Tink Lynd
@Majka821
Cypherpunks once saw the crypto-currency as a victory for freedom and decentralization. Instead, bitcoin has become a playground for the already powerful, creating new forms of control. @carljackmiller opencanada.org/bitcoins-broken-promise/
-
Carl Miller reposted
The Lowy Institute
@LowyInstitute
In this latest episode of Rules Based Audio, @sashafegan talks to @carljackmiller - Research Director at the Centre for the Analysis of Social Media at UK think tank Demos about online manipulation, disinformation, misinformation and inauthentic behaviour. www.lowyinstitute.org/publications/rules-based-audio-what…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Crypto is just another brilliant example that we really do believe what we want to believe. We are astonishingly bad, humans, at reconciling the world we want with the one that actually exists.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The pitch was that crypto was to decentralise power. It just didn't do that - not in wealth, who controlled it or who mined it. All it did was to create an arena of money and power where the weak weren't protected by the usual rules
I wrote this in 2018
opencanada.org/bitcoins-broken-promise/ -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Bitcoin really hasn't turned out even remotely as it was intended to.
- Rather than a currency, it's become a speculative asset.
- Rather than efficient, the energy and CPU costs are extravagant
- Rather than decentralised, ownership and mining power are hugely concentrated -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If you want to work on studying information warfare professionally, this job is a very good opportunity to do so:
jobs.kcl.ac.uk/gb/en/job/047766/Research-Associate-in-the… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is absolutely crazy - so utterly beyond the bounds of normal statecraft
www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10930999/Gordon-Brown-cl… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I've heard a lot of people in events and things over the past few weeks calling for a 'western information warfare'. Whilst I understand the sentiment (and the frustration) there are two big, linked reasons why it wouldn't ever work.
1. You don't fight the kind of illicit... -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I've heard a lot of people in events and things over the past few weeks calling for a 'western information warfare'. Whilst I understand the sentiment (and the frustration) there are two big, linked reasons why it wouldn't ever work.
1. You don't fight the kind of illicit...Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
value out of information - it's only good to achieve a certain effect. As information spaces before more militarised, you can bet people will begin to trust them less and less. And democracies need most people to trust at least some info - be it science, experts, journalism, govt
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The only way forwards here to confront information warfare is to build a range of asymmetric responses to put more pressure, cost and risk on the people that do it outside of the information space. Diplomacy, criminal law, cyber-offensive action - there's lots of options there
-
Carl Miller reposted
This Is Not A Drill - with Gavin Esler
@DrillPod
If you haven't listened already, check out our latest war bulletin.
@carljackmiller tells @SnellArthur the information war in the global south, and why millions think Russia is winning the conflict.
Listen: kite.link/DMukwb29 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
What's up with Chinese state media and diplomats (ambassadors, consular officials etc) not talking about 'biological' or 'biolab' anymore?
Seems to have dropped off the agenda. Odd for such an earth shattering scandal. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Trying to solve for the problem of fake news today is like trying to design pikes to resist cavalry charges when the enemy has already developed tanks.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Diana Pinchuk🇺🇦
@diana_pinchuk
The closing Keynote from @carljackmiller at @devfest_ukraine about information warfare is mesmerizing. The whole conference was worth this talk. Donate at devfest.gdg.org.ua/donate/ to receive access to it. BTW, we've gathered $128k for this moment to help Ukraine
#devfestforukraine -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Hi everyone! 👋 Really happy and honoured to be here today
#devfestforukraine -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
By themselves, digital literacy training and tech giant takedown are never going to solve information warfare - it's far too dynamic.
We need to put way, way more pressure both on the most harmful actors who do it and the grey-zone services and suppliers who serve them. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I keep wondering when societal worry about disinformation will evolve into a focus on search engine manipulation. It's done on an industrial scale, corrals vast amounts of attention, and is just as important (imho) to manipulation as sending explicit narratives on social media.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I can't believe we're still focussed on mis/disinformation as the fundamental way of phrasing the problem of online manipulation. It just isn't the only way or most important way that illicit influence online works.
-
Carl Miller reposted
This Is Not A Drill - with Gavin Esler
@DrillPod
Ukraine might be winning the information war in the West, but for those in the Global South, news about the war is much more pro-Russian. Why is this?
@carljackmiller joins @SnellArthur to discuss why millions think Russia is winning.
Listen: kite.link/DMukwb29 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We've got a new website at CASM where we talk about the work we're doing to respond to online harms, the tech we're building to do it and the partnerships I'm very proud we're part of. If you have 5 minutes, take a look!
www.casmtechnology.com -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I spoke to @SnellArthur for a podcast I've become a huge fan of since February - @doomsday_pod
I try to pull apart a bit more about how illicit influence really works. It has as much to do with the seedy world of spam as that of grand geopolitics.
kite.link/DMukwb29 -
Carl Miller reposted
Brett Scott
@Suitpossum
I've heard a lot of people claim that Bitcoin is somehow a unique weapon to protect yourself from inflation. The current #cryptocrash should make you doubt that, but I used to work in 'inflation hedging', so let me offer a perspective to help you decide for yourself. Thread 1/15
-
Carl Miller reposted
This Is Not A Drill - with Gavin Esler
@DrillPod
If you're in the West, you would think Ukraine is winning the information war. However in the Global South, social media is packed with pro-Russia content. Why is this?
Out early for backers, @carljackmiller joins @SnellArthur for another war bulletin.
www.patreon.com/posts/67710368 -
Carl Miller reposted
GDG DevFest Ukraine
@devfest_ukraine
Morning, folks! ✌️
Meet our next keynote speaker — Carl Miller (@carljackmiller) with his talk “Fighting Back Against Information Warfare”.
Donate to support Ukraine and get access to Carl’s talk at devfest.gdg.org.ua 🇺🇦
See you at the event! -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
CASM, @ISDglobal and a lot of climate organisations collaborated across 2021 to track and respond to various attempts to derail COP26 using social media. This is what we saw: www.isdglobal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Deny-Deceive…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
A few words from me on why I'm talking at @devfest_ukraine
Register: devfest.gdg.org.ua
#devfestforukraine #standwithukraine -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We've released new research today with @ISDglobal and a phalanx of climate action organisations on climate disinformation.
It came out of a real-time 24/hr war room we were all running last year to defend COP26. This pulls out the bigger trends
www.isdglobal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Deny-Deceive… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Saying we need to counter disinformation is kind of like saying we need to counter snooping on street corners. It's a technique that - like spying - is part of a tradecraft constantly developing.
We're countering the specific influence of bad actors who... 🧵 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
A few words from me on why I'm talking at @devfest_ukraine
Register: devfest.gdg.org.ua
#devfestforukraine #standwithukraine -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We've released new research today with @ISDglobal and a phalanx of climate action organisations on climate disinformation.
It came out of a real-time 24/hr war room we were all running last year to defend COP26. This pulls out the bigger trends
www.isdglobal.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Deny-Deceive…Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1) There was a really big push over the summit to keep the focus on the 'hypocrisy' of political elites and delegates. On the softer end, lots of photos of planes but that hardened into conspiracies of a new world order and a new climate lockdown to take over from public health.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The second tries to absolve certain countries of climate action simply by blaming others. Western narratives blames China, China blames the West.
The third sought to deny the viability of renewables. The Texas blackouts was a good example of this - which used...
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
explicit viral disinformation about power failures by using totally unrelated images of frozen wind turbines (or ones being de-iced by helicopters, etc).
The last framed electric vehicles as part hoax, part elitist plot. Includes debunked claims that EVs are equally bad.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
As you've probably noticed, outright disinformation here is wrapped up in more ambiguous conflicts around framing, issue salience and narrative. This is something i go on about a lot: disinformation is just one tactic of online influence.
Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Major global conversations are going to be targeted by the very same techniques developed to attack elections and in war. Defending them is going to need to be equally as strategic.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Huge thanks to the indefatigable @jkingy @f_arcostanzoand Łukasz Janulewicz for shepherding this report to pub. And to the brilliant orgs I am very proud we worked with: @consciousadnet @ClimateNexus @EcoBotNet @foeeurope @Purpose @ausreset @stopfundingheat
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I'll be giving the closing keynote at Dev Fest Ukraine - @devfest_ukraine - about how we fight back against information warfare
Society will ultimately challenge, manage and defang these kinds of information threats and devs will be at the heart of it
devfest.gdg.org.ua -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
“Our people are doing everything to make sure the land burns under the feet of the occupiers” www.economist.com/europe/2022/06/05/ukraines-partisans-ar…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
States defend, explain and promote themselves on social media of course. What's interesting is how they use their hundreds of diplomats spread across the world to address different audiences/regions in different ways and at different times.
Our new study
plus-pages.com/page/RwbbAiso/WmImBhwAk/bbcm-china-repor -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
States defend, explain and promote themselves on social media of course. What's interesting is how they use their hundreds of diplomats spread across the world to address different audiences/regions in different ways and at different times.
Our new study
plus-pages.com/page/RwbbAiso/WmImBhwAk/bbcm-china-repor -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Is anyone seriously looking at what the emergence of DAOs is going to mean for regulation? There's thousands of them.
How are governments going to fine or sanction the behaviour of... things that have no legal impersonation? Who do you even pick up the phone to? -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We've launched a major new report today with @BBCMonitoring
It's a multi-lingual, multi-regional window into China's public diplomacy on Facebook and Twitter across most of 2021. Tons of things to say, which I'll pull out below, and here in full for free
plus-pages.com/page/RwbbAiso/WmImBhwAk/bbcm-china-repor -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We've launched a major new report today with @BBCMonitoring
It's a multi-lingual, multi-regional window into China's public diplomacy on Facebook and Twitter across most of 2021. Tons of things to say, which I'll pull out below, and here in full for free
plus-pages.com/page/RwbbAiso/WmImBhwAk/bbcm-china-reporPost not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Lots more to say, but I'll leave it there for now. Huge thanks to everyone who worked so hard on this report - all the language teams at BBCM and Ahmed, Chris and Justin from CASM. Over the next year, we're really going to focus on building out more sophisticated
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
and sociologically informed ways of understanding the audience reaction to, and ultimate impact of, this kind of messaging: when it's working, when it's challenged, and much more understanding public diplomacy as a two-way, discursive form of engagement states do.
thanks! -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is going to be really great
I'm chairing an @intelligence2 live event on June 23, talking to @JamieJBartlett and @Layla_Begum_Ali about one of the biggest scams in history.
intelligencesquared.com/events/jamie-bartlett-on-greed-fo… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Twitter you need to settle a raging debate I’m currently in.
Who is more famous, globally? -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Twitter you need to settle a raging debate I’m currently in.
Who is more famous, globally? -
Carl Miller reposted
Alex Krasodomski
@akrasodomski
🚨Super excited to finally share The Good Web Project, a pandemic-long bit of work with @peterpomeranzev. It's our shot at answering one question about the Internet - 𝑤ℎ𝑎𝑡 𝑑𝑜𝑒𝑠 𝑔𝑜𝑜𝑑 𝑙𝑜𝑜𝑘 𝑙𝑖𝑘𝑒? Half-fittingly, it's also my last paper after 7 years at @Demos.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
VCs are pushing a whole generation of new counter-disinfo start-ups into a familiar mould:
some magical proprietary artificial intelligence algorithm that can identify illicit activity as a service.
VC love this business model - it can scale super fast. It just doesn't work -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Saying we need to counter disinformation is kind of like saying we need to counter snooping on street corners. It's a technique that - like spying - is part of a tradecraft constantly developing.
We're countering the specific influence of bad actors who... 🧵
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
are willing to dip into a tradecraft of manipulation, emotional exploitation, polarisation-baiting, content curation gaming, search engine exploitation AND the propagation of disinformation (amongst other things) to exert the influence that they want.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Exactly like counter-intelligence is framed around responding to the general intelligence threats posed by certain states, so counter-influence work needs to do the same. Rather than trying to build policies to stop any actor knowingly lying online
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The prevalence of 'disinformation' (and before that fake news) as a phrase used to merely irritate me as a researcher. But now entire gov teams have been set up to counter it; we're looking at legislation/regulatory action, all underlain by a basic misconception of the problem
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I can't believe we're still focussed on mis/disinformation as the fundamental way of phrasing the problem of online manipulation. It just isn't the only way or most important way that illicit influence online works.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Illicit influence is more about:
- Amplifying certain truths over others than lying.
- Harnessing emotions than rational thought
- Telling you something you already agree than changing your view about the world.
- Attacking the communities that stand in the way of this -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I can't believe we're still focussed on mis/disinformation as the fundamental way of phrasing the problem of online manipulation. It just isn't the only way or most important way that illicit influence online works.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We're launching our year-long study of China's diplomats on social media with @BBCMonitoring at Broadcasting House today! Gosh, it feels good to be back to having events in person.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is a piece I wrote with @katyminshall @TwitterUK back in 2020 about how to respond to the increasing potent way that states project their power onto information 'theatres' such as Twitter
blog.twitter.com/en_us/topics/company/2020/nation-states-… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is really funny
Francis Scarr
@francis_scarr
I normally only watch the morning edition of 60 Minutes, Russian state TV's flagship daytime talk show, but today I tuned into the afternoon episode too
Judging by what I saw, their producers aren't coping very well with the workload of wall-to-wall war coverage
(with subtitles) -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is cool - the @TheEconomist followed up on our research looking at accounts pumping pro-invasion hashtags in March. Just came out.
They went further with their own analysis. Two things struck me most.
(1) Possible impact. 🧵
www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2022/05/14/russia-is-swa… -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Can you just imagine if the BBC just started making explicit nuclear threats, complete with CGI of giant tsunami waves?
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
VCs are pushing a whole generation of new counter-disinfo start-ups into a familiar mould:
some magical proprietary artificial intelligence algorithm that can identify illicit activity as a service.
VC love this business model - it can scale super fast. It just doesn't work
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I've spent ten years now digging around in social media research and i'm lucky enough to have some unbelievably capable NLP colleagues. If there's one thing i've learned, it's that there's no universal, fully automated way of catching IO or disinfo.
Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Ultimately you need mixed-skills teams of investigations gelling OSINT skills, investigatory data science, linguists, tool developers and ML people all working together. That is utterly, manifestly different from some kind of plug-in service or grand (but secret) model.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I genuinely worry that this VC-driven model of supporting early tech innovation is harming our response to disinformation and information threats. I do. I've never really come across a starker solution-to-problem mismatch as the one i've just spoken about.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Open question. Has anyone who's ever worked in any kind of integrity, health or infosec (etc etc) role for any platform ever encountered any external bot-identifying service/API that they thought was even remotely accurate?
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is cool - the @TheEconomist followed up on our research looking at accounts pumping pro-invasion hashtags in March. Just came out.
They went further with their own analysis. Two things struck me most.
(1) Possible impact. 🧵
www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2022/05/14/russia-is-swa…Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
(2) 44% of the accounts we researched are now banned or deleted. This is pretty striking, especially given Twitter, in response to a BBC article also working from our research saw "no evidence of widespread co-ordination to artificially amplify sentiment around the Ukraine war."
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
That's here: www.bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-trending-61351342
I'm sure there's subtlety there in what Twitter are banning these accounts for (such as stealing other peoples' photos), but slightly mysterious to me if they're all being banned on individual-level transgressions rather than CIB. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is fascinating - a look at Chinese public procurements to show a whole industry of firms specialising in 'marketing' China to Western audiences, including Western influencers and massive amounts of paid advertising
chinatalk.substack.com/p/selling-chinas-story-how-the-chi… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I spoke to @gideonrachman for @intelligence2 about the idea of the emergence, from 2000 onwards, of 'the strongman', a new kind of leader around the world.
Genuinely one of the most interesting interviews I've ever given. Now on Youtube
www.youtube.com/watch?v=vOWyYVDMx10&t=65s -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Y'know, for all of this breakneck search for completely new, disruptive ideas, many VCs are (ironically) totally unoriginal in the kinds of business models they support.
Hard problems are not all solved by rapidly scaling software-as-a-service tech companies. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
An unfortunate trend is that the tradecraft in illicit influence online is moving in two directions: both becoming more sophisticated and easier to access and use at the same moment. It's becoming both more common and more rarefied.
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is absolutely astonishing - watch it to the end. If anyone has any idea as to why this made it onto Russian TV, I’d love to hear it.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is absolutely astonishing - watch it to the end. If anyone has any idea as to why this made it onto Russian TV, I’d love to hear it.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I spoke @Mishcon_de_Reya about how lawyers need to become part of the response to information warfare.Consumers, defamation, criminal law;we need ways of levying costs to the people who wantonly do it
that go beyond expose in journalism and then take-down
www.linkedin.com/video/event/urn:li:ugcPost:6930135249582… -
Carl Miller reposted
Tagesspiegel
@Tagesspiegel
Wie Fakeprofile bei Twitter Stimmung für #russland machen:
Der Social-Media-Experte Carl Miller hat 1,7 Millionen Tweets mit prorussischen Hashtags analysiert. Er klagt über mangelnden politischen Druck im Kampf gegen Desinformation. (T+) plus.tagesspiegel.de/gesellschaft/medien/interview-mit-so… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
“Until we get the last name of the military genius who laid down a B.T.G. by the river and he answers for it publicly, we won’t have had any military reforms,” - Russian bloggers turning on military leadership www.nytimes.com/2022/05/15/world/europe/pro-russian-war-b…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Jurgen Habermas and JK Rowling. That took all of 5 seconds.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I should point out, I wasn’t endorsing what Rowling has said politically. Only that she wrote the biggest selling series in history
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Thoughts on the Daily Mail's latest attempt to describe crypto in a single sentence...?
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
👇👇👇
Bellingcat
@bellingcat
Bellingcat's Tech Team has built a new tool which allows you to collect and analyse TikTok posts. Our step-by-step guide shows you how to install it, how to use it, and how to analyse what you find. www.bellingcat.com/resources/how-tos/2022/05/11/this-new-…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The BBC Disinformation Team @julianagragnani @MedhaviArora Seraj Ali has just released a deep dive on the 9.9k accounts our research looked at back in March that had shared pro-invasion hashtags five or more times
What they've found is fascinating🧵
www.bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-trending-61351342 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The BBC Disinformation Team @julianagragnani @MedhaviArora Seraj Ali has just released a deep dive on the 9.9k accounts our research looked at back in March that had shared pro-invasion hashtags five or more times
What they've found is fascinating🧵
www.bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-trending-61351342Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
They also found an Aeronautical engineers who was entirely genuine.a good reminder that you always seen authentic and inauthentic activity wrapped up together, often with confusingly similar profiles, when you try to research this sorts of campaigns.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
As researchers we can try to find and foreground suspicious patterns, but it's then open source intelligence and investigative journalism that can really dig deeper into what's going on
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Tens of millions of dollars? They can’t even get the level of US aid to Ukraine right.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Thanks all - that's a scrap of Russian i've learned today :)
-
Carl Miller reposted
Mishcon de Reya
@Mishcon_de_Reya
Join us on 16 May for a session with Dr @carljackmiller, author of ‘The Death of the Gods: The New Global Power Grab’ and Research Director at @demos’ Centre for the Analysis of Social Media. Register now to join the discussion on information warfare: www.mishcon.com/news/events/current/information-warfare-h…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Well, if television is the main medium…
Igor Sushko
@igorsushko
#russia #may9th: TV systems have been hacked for May 9th. Message: "Your hands are covered in blood from deaths of thousands of Ukrainians and children."
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
From threatening nuclear tsunamis, now Russia’s pundits are wishing for the return of ‘humane’ Lavrentiy Beria who ran the NKVD under Stalin.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Ourselves at CASM and @ISDglobal are currently putting together a whole ensemble of classifiers to identify hate across social media, and then seeing which combos produce the best results. If you’ve worked on or used any hate model, I’d love to hear from you.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The more unthinkable the scam, the more likely scammers will exploit it. www.bbc.com/news/uk-61079742
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Factoids from our up-coming research:
China's 393 diplomats that we measured were retweeted 899,391 times in 2021, avg. of 12.4 per Tweet.
They also received a total of 5,883,361 ‘likes’; an average of 64.9 likes per message on Twitter and 38.7 on Facebook. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Thanks for having me #chevening @CheveningFCDO!
If you'd like to take a look at the White Paper, here it is
www.casmtechnology.com/case-studies/discourse-driven-comm… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Myself and @ChloeColliver2 wrote this about the need for a truly sector-wide response to online manipulation across civic society. Sharable, transparent tech to detect it, plugged into a far wider array of responses than those available to the platforms
www.isdglobal.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/isd_201.pdf -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
We've released research recently with BBC Monitoring on China's use of diplomatic assets on social media -
crestresearch.ac.uk/comment/chinas-digital-diplomacy/ -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Has anyone seen the actual research for this? Was expecting more to have emerged by now than just a press release.
www.gov.uk/government/news/uk-exposes-sick-russian-troll-… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If there is an online harm overlooked and neglected beyond any other, it has to be environmental crime.
Here's our investigation in Feb.
www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-60247540 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I’ve never read anything about tires even remotely as interesting as this
Trent Telenko
@TrentTelenko
It has been a little while since I've talked about truck tires, but I've been DM-ed a couple of photos what are worth a thread.🧵
This is a Russian Grad launch truck with really old tires.👇
1/ -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If you want a more optimistic story about technology, I wrote this www.wired.co.uk/article/taiwan-democracy-social-media
-
Carl Miller reposted
Jamesin Seidel
@seidtweets
What is a Koda? Who knows.
But what we can know, is the rarity of their different characteristics.
I did a quick rarity calculation. Public spreadsheet here: docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1FFRXkwPvVhTNgbWwigEX4R8aO…
#othersidemeta #koda #kodagang -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Does anyone else get the sense that Russia's propagandists aren't the sharpest knives in the drawer? It doesn't seem to be where they're sending their most glittering or innovative active measures talent
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If there's one thing we all can do to protect ourselves from online manipulation, it's simply to slow down. Don't scan, read. Stop before sharing. Manipulative material is usually designed to interact with your lizard brain. Give your rational processes time to kick in
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I hadn’t seen this until now. Shortly before the invasion, Ukrainian state security closed two ‘bit farms’ actually operating in Ukraine. 18k accounts, they said, tasked with spreading panic, partly through bomb threats
ssu.gov.ua/en/novyny/sbu-likviduvala-18ty-tysiachnu-botof… -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Extraordinary that they’re briefing this kind of thing. www.nytimes.com/2022/05/01/world/europe/russian-general-d…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Can you just imagine if the BBC just started making explicit nuclear threats, complete with CGI of giant tsunami waves?
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is interesting but I can’t see anything in terms of exposed tradecraft - targeting replies, coordinated amplification - that wasn’t well known about already www.gov.uk/government/news/uk-exposes-sick-russian-troll-…
-
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ I have a new investigation out with @BBCClick and @ShiromaTSilva about the online wildlife trade.
This is undercover filming in Bangladesh, featuring a trader talking about African Grey Parrots. You can't sell wild caught African Greys under international law. -
Carl Miller reposted
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
An absolutely wild fact in the book Moneyland:
There are Chinese officials who extract eggs from their wives, fertilise them, implant them in a Japanese surrogate to create an apparently unrelated Japanese child they can then use to move their wealth out of China and hide it. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The Belarusian Railway Partisans - amazing story www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/04/23/ukraine-belarus-r…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The whole point of democratic law and regulation to control social media platforms is to restrain whatever arbitrary opinions are held by their owners. Musk might be a 'free speech absolutist' (whatever that means) but Europe isn't; neither is the UK.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
What a brilliant initiative www.bbc.com/beyondfakenews/trusted-news-initiative/projec…
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Well, if Elon Musk buys Twitter, that will be the final ending to the age where anyone thought that social media companies could self-regulate in any meaningful or acceptably effective way.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
People mistaking difficult problems for easy ones, actually is the problem. Especially when they're billionaires who think they have the solution.
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It's absolutely, totally, emphatically 100% beyond me why Elon Musk thinks any of the problems related to Twitter that he talks about are either easily soluble, or that he's any better position to do it than anyone else
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It's absolutely, totally, emphatically 100% beyond me why Elon Musk thinks any of the problems related to Twitter that he talks about are either easily soluble, or that he's any better position to do it than anyone else
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I’ll say this again and again - TikTok is the platform I’m most concerned about. Huge user base, no platform-wide visibility to researchers, no sense of how effective any platform enforcement really is. www.bbc.co.uk/news/60867414
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
What proportion of people are involved in any crypto collection primarily for the community and only secondarily (if at all) for personal enrichment?
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
I just honestly cannot see any possible world where Johnson voluntarily quits.
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/sue-gray-report-so-damning-bor…
#suegrayreport -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
The head of Russia Today in what is 100% the most fascinating thing I’ve seen to come out of Russian television.
Anyone consuming RT content should have to watch this first.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ Four quick predictions for where influence operations are going, that I've just made at the @G7 #factsvsdisinformation conference.
(1) Strategic evolution. We've become used to campaigns targeting Western audiences, using wedge issues to hasten social division. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
When we say Kyiv is winning the information war, far too often we only mean information spaces we inhabit.
Pulling apart the most obvious RU info op to date (as we did using semantic modelling), very clear it is targeting BRICS, Africa, Asia. Not the West really at all. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
One of the great, historic speeches by a head of state. ‘Many things are always lacking in war. But what is in abundance is pain, dirt, and death’.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
1/ I have a new investigation out with @BBCClick and @ShiromaTSilva about the online wildlife trade.
This is undercover filming in Bangladesh, featuring a trader talking about African Grey Parrots. You can't sell wild caught African Greys under international law. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Marc Goodman in the Harvard Journal of Law and Technology. In 1997...
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
If you haven't seen @Avaaz work on disinformation, you really should check it out: secure.avaaz.org/campaign/en/disinfo_report_us_2020/
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is what I said at the NATO conference today:
One of the key problems is that the platforms we central to our social and political lives are also ones that have enormous commercial incentives to grow. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
With #ge2019 in full swing, it's an excellent time to share my 7 tips to stop being manipulated online:
1. Guard against outrage
2. Don't passive scroll
3. Actively find info
4. Slow down online
5. Don't trust metrics
6. Use non-online sources
7. Spend your attention wisely
👇 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
To brighten your weekend, here's a thread on my seven rules to protect yourself from online manipulation
1. Guard against outrage
2. Don't passive scroll
3. Actively find info
4. Slow down online.
5. Don't trust metrics
6. Use non-online sources
7. Spend your attention wisely -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
An absolutely wild fact in the book Moneyland:
There are Chinese officials who extract eggs from their wives, fertilise them, implant them in a Japanese surrogate to create an apparently unrelated Japanese child they can then use to move their wealth out of China and hide it. -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Friends! An investigation we’ve been working really hard on has been broadcast on @BBCClick today. I spent a month using GDPR to try to pull all my personal data into one place: 7000 pages in total.
See below, for a story of two business models:
www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m0005cx6 -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
My favourite thing that's ever happened on Twitter: A week ago, I tweeted a 30-year old video I'd seen online of James Burke giving an eerily accurate prediction of digital politics today. It went viral - and the BBC had him back on to give a prediction for the next 30 years.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
It's 1985. James Burke is walking around in some hills. And then he delivers a scintillating piece to camera about how politics is going to change in the digital age.
Totally. Crazy. -
Post not available here, view on X
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
2/ Sophisticated online influence activities are now so camouflaged and obfuscated that even dedicated teams working within major technology companies cannot reliably detect them at scale.
We cannot rely on educational interventions to remotely protect us from online influence -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Bitcoin really hasn't turned out even remotely as it was intended to.
- Rather than a currency, it's become a speculative asset.
- Rather than efficient, the energy and CPU costs are extravagant
- Rather than decentralised, ownership and mining power are hugely concentrated -
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
This is really interesting. Facebook has been taking a hammering. It’s users are going on it much, much less frequently than they used to.
-
Carl Miller
@carljackmiller
Every single New York Times front page since 1852. Look at the growth of pictures in news.
(h/t Josh Begley).



























































































































































































