So, for those of you raising late-elementary or preteen boys. Do you ever go to dinner hoping that the terms poop, diarrhea, or pee do not come up at the dinner table? Just asking for a friend.
George Yancey
George Alan Yancey (born September 8, 1962) is an American professor of sociology at Baylor University, where he has taught since 2019. He is known for his research on anti-Christian attitudes in the contemporary United States, and the ways in which it can influence the decisions made by academic sociologists. He has been called "the only researcher studying Christianophobia at a secular university". More on Wikipedia
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Got to go on the show Sitting In to discuss racial issues.
youtu.be/KDe4ATlb2GU -
George Yancey
@profyancey
We have too many Christian influencers, on the left and the right, who spend all of their time on politics. Indeed, when I say spending time on politics, I mean they spend most of their time condemning and even demonizing their political enemies. If a Christian influencer never challenges you to grow spiritually, then you should stop following them. You should especially stop following them if, generally, after reading them, you feel angrier rather than more loving toward your enemies. We should seek out Christian influences that strengthen, not weaken, our faith.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
So, as I look at the information coming out from last week's political massacre, it has become clear to me that the biggest reason for the massacre is that Americans are furious with Trump. That is the only way the Republicans lose states such as Mississippi, South Carolina, and Kansas. That is not some fantastic insight, but it has implications both Republicans and Democrats should consider.
The implication for the Republicans is pretty clear. They need to distance themselves from Trump efficiently. He is still president of the United States, and they cannot do it all at once. But the future of their party depends on getting rid of the stink of Trump while alienating the fewest number of his followers as they can. I have some ideas on how they might do that, but that would need to be the subject of a different post.
The implications for the Democrats are not to overreach. They need to realize that their agenda did not drive up these numbers. They also need to realize that a lot of people hate them and that hate can easily be reactivated. Compromise doesn't have to be a poisonous term, and they should show they are trying to do the will of the people rather than their ideological presuppositions. Given their past and the addition of the DSA members, this will be difficult for them to do.
Well, it will be an interesting time beginning in January. We will see if either party takes away the lessons they should learn from this past election. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
DeSantis is perfectly position to be seperate from Trump and have the conservative record to get many of the Trump supporters back. But he has to play a balancing game where he is not too close to Trump but yet is not openly alienating his voters. Joining Trump's cabinet would be ruinous to his presidental ambitions.
Rod Dreher
@roddreher
If offered, DeSantis should say no. If he wants to have a shot at being the GOP nominee in 2028, he shouldn't have anything of Trump's stank on him.
Justin Logan
@JustinTLogan
“One source told CBS News that Ron DeSantis is being floated as a possible replacement for Hegseth, arguing DeSantis could go through Senate confirmation in the lame-duck period and then take the post when his term as governor expires Jan. 5.” www.cbsnews.com/news/trump-hegseth-midterm-election-losses/
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am hesitant to say this because so many times before I thought this to be true, but only to be proven wrong. But I do think that Trumpism died last night.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I know a lot of people who need to listen to this and take it to heart. Just talking to people you agree with in an echo chamber will devastate your political movement.
Daniel Darling
@dandarling
This is so true. Happened to the left post 2020 and happened to the right in 2026. Left-wing faculty lounges and right-wing online echo chambers lead their movements off a cliff.
Samuel James
@Digitalliturgy
A few months back Ezra Klein gave a theory of social media and politics that I haven't been able to stop thinking about.
"Whoever wins Twitter pays for it 3-4 years later." -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Trump put hand-picked Senate candidates in South Carolina, North Carolina, and Texas. They all went down. Trump is not a king maker. He is a king destroyer.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Republicans. For the sake of your party do all you can to limit Trump's influnce in your party. Look to North Carolina. Look to South Carolina. He is a toxicity that will continue to ruin your party.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I think Trump has entered the Lame Duck stage of his political career.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Trump would not have had to work so hard to try to keep the Senate in Republican hands if he could have kept his ego in check. He engineered the fall of Tillis in NC and Cornyn in TX. But they dared to disagree with Trump a couple of times, were labeled as RICOs, and now they are gone. Those would have, relatively speaking, been solid holds for the Republicans. NC is clearly gone, and late-breaking polls indicate the same is likely true for TX. If things go the way I think they're likely to go tonight and my conservative friends complain about a Senate that sabotages Trump, I will remind them of the own goals produced by the president. They will get little sympathy from me.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
To my Christians friends. Tomorrow no matter what happens you will not be saved or destroyed. If your person wins you may experience some good things. If your person loses you may experience some bad things. But you should not think of yourself as either saved or destroyed . If you do then your faith is in the wrong place.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Wow. I knew there was infighting among Michigan Democrats but I did not see this coming. As a political independent I am just going to sit back and get some popcorn for Tuesday night!!!
Haley Stevens
@HaleyforMI
I am endorsing Mike Rogers for the United States Senate today.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Mad respect for Hunter Baker for this article.
wng.org/opinions/playing-dirty-to-get-elected-1793319877 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Hey all. This will be my last video for a while. I have done them for about a year, and I am not certain whether I have the time to keep doing them. Also, I may want to wait until I am in a position to get better equipment. So I am not saying there will not be any more. Just not anymore until I have a sense of what I want to do with my channel. Anyway, I hope you enjoy this one. It says a lot of where I am at right now.
youtu.be/rQyxvFJ10SE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Ramaswamy's political career should be over. Hopefully it will be after he is defeated in Ohio.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Why do we oversample Democratic Socialists and undersample MAGA? I offer a potential reason why.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=IFC4gAXg5qE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Democrats: We have to stop Trump from weaponizing the government.
Also Democrats: Elect us so that we can weaponize the government against our political eniemies.
Elissa Slotkin
@ElissaSlotkin
Spare me the pearl-clutching — especially from Republican Members of Congress and online MAGA grifters who have cheered President Trump's weaponization of the government against those he doesn’t like, as recently as last week. This is a subject I know something about: Less than a year ago, Trump directed the DOJ and FBI to investigate me, and then tried to criminally indict me for a 90 second video, exercising basic free speech. The same free speech you’re exercising now, lying about what I said in this clip. If not for an anonymous group of grand jury members standing up for America's laws, I’d be criminally indicted for sedition. President Trump has turned the government against people, with raucous support from you and virtually all D.C. Republicans. So spare us the manufactured outrage.
America must be a place where the rule of law still matters. Those laws should apply to everyone equally. If you have aided in the corrupt use of U.S. taxpayer dollars to benefit the President or his family, or you have violated the law in order to carry out guidance from the President, you should be held accountable. And given how rampant that corruption appears to the average American, people looking to work for his Administration should realize that while the Supreme Court has granted the President immunity, it has not done the same for those who do illegal things at his behest.
Mike Lee
@SenMikeLee
It is absolutely disgraceful to threaten young Americans for participating in politics and serving their country.
The Chicago Thinker
@ThinkerChicago
ON UCHICAGO CAMPUS: U.S. Senator from Michigan Elissa Slotkin hopes planned political prosecutions of republican leaders will scare young conservatives from getting involved in politics.
@ElissaSlotkin -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This could potentially make sense if Christians funded the work that Christian academics like me do. But no Christian organization was there to put up the half million dollars we needed to study multiracial churches. I want to study the group that I know has the highest level of anti-Christian bais which is white progressives. So far none of the Christian organizations have shown a willingness to seriously considering funding that work. I would be a fool to turn down money from a less "pure" organization to keep people like Basham happy. Judge the work, not the funder!!!
Ellie Beacon
@EliotBeacon
The rich rule over the poor and the borrower is slave to the lender. Proverbs 22:7
It’s not just money though. Power and influence work just like money and can even be even more valuable.
Churches should not be accepting money from any institutions like this. There are always strings attached.
Before you know it your church is planting trees instead of preaching the Word and people are reading White Fragility during Bible Study.
Likewise, realize that favor in your life comes from God, not from dishonest lowlifes. God spoke through a donkey! It wasn’t because the donkey was particularly smart or special, it’s because God can use anything or anyone for his purposes.
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is an interesting conversation. According to Basham, Lilly is not a Christian organization because they provide money to non-Christian causes. Thus to recived money from them is suspect. Lilly Endowment funds a wide variety of projects. I would be surprised if all of those projects are Christian. I am not going to argue whether Lilly is Christian or not and in fact for the sake of argument I will stipulate that at the very least it is not evangelical and will support some stuff I do not like.
About 25 years ago, I was part of a reserach team that recieved a nice Lilly grant to study multiracial church. From that research I wrote a Christian book - One Body, One Spirit - that helped a lot of churches become racially diverse. Other work has used Lilly money to do great things for evangelicals specifically and the Body in general. Should we have tuned down that money to remain "pure."?
I do not think that turning down resources to remain pure is scriptural. As long as the organization does not force me to work towards non-Christian ends, it did not make me less of a Christian to use the money from Lilly to do good things. When the Israelies left Egypt to go to the promised land, the Egyptians (Exodus 12:36). God allowed them to plunder the Egyptians. There were a lot of ways the Israelies sinned during that period of time. That was not one of them.
So even if Lilly is not a Christian organization, so what? What did organizations do with the money is what I care about. If they repurpose the money to further the Kingdom them so much the better. Painting people as sold out because they recieved money from an organization we do not trust is short sighted and inaccurate. Show me what they do with the money and then we can talk.
Phil Vischer
@philvischer
@megbasham classifies any foundation or org that gives a grant to a mainline church or seminary a “secular” org. This is how she can declare that orgs like CT get “the majority of their funding” from “secular” sources.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is an interesting conversation. According to Basham, Lilly is not a Christian organization because they provide money to non-Christian causes. Thus to recived money from them is suspect. Lilly Endowment funds a wide variety of projects. I would be surprised if all of those projects are Christian. I am not going to argue whether Lilly is Christian or not and in fact for the sake of argument I will stipulate that at the very least it is not evangelical and will support some stuff I do not like.
About 25 years ago, I was part of a reserach team that recieved a nice Lilly grant to study multiracial church. From that research I wrote a Christian book - One Body, One Spirit - that helped a lot of churches become racially diverse. Other work has used Lilly money to do great things for evangelicals specifically and the Body in general. Should we have tuned down that money to remain "pure."?
I do not think that turning down resources to remain pure is scriptural. As long as the organization does not force me to work towards non-Christian ends, it did not make me less of a Christian to use the money from Lilly to do good things. When the Israelies left Egypt to go to the promised land, the Egyptians (Exodus 12:36). God allowed them to plunder the Egyptians. There were a lot of ways the Israelies sinned during that period of time. That was not one of them.
So even if Lilly is not a Christian organization, so what? What did organizations do with the money is what I care about. If they repurpose the money to further the Kingdom them so much the better. Painting people as sold out because they recieved money from an organization we do not trust is short sighted and inaccurate. Show me what they do with the money and then we can talk.
Phil Vischer
@philvischer
@megbasham classifies any foundation or org that gives a grant to a mainline church or seminary a “secular” org. This is how she can declare that orgs like CT get “the majority of their funding” from “secular” sources.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Speculating on the source of white progressive hostility.
youtu.be/r1JrQZlJk4s -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I earlier posted on the problems with the concept of Christian nationalism. But my complaint does not mean that there are no problems with the way Christians are approaching politics.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=wCd50nRj7wo -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Great job @jessesmithsoc
www.christianitytoday.com/2026/10/3-myths-about-christian… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I second what Michael says here. Jesse has done some vitally important work unpacking the misuse of the term Christian Nationalism. If he was working on issues more palitable to the political sensibilities in academia, then his work would be much more widely known about. I do believe that some forms of Christian Nationalism exists, primarly in the form of Christian identity politics. But the term has become a perjoritive to use agaisnt poltical enimies rather than a useful descriptive tool. To that end, we need to think more careful about the way it has been used and get better tools for understanding the political dynamics in our society.
Michael Wear
@MichaelRWear
@jessesmithsoc has been doing vital, lonely (I imagine) work on this for years. I'm grateful for his rigor, and for the way he's helped to contribute to my understanding of these dynamics.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I never have been a Bears fan but it was fun to watch how the 1985 Bears dominated the league (Yeah, I am that old). Ditka was quite a character and fun to watch. RIP Ditka.
Pete Pistone
@PPistone
The entire city of Chicago is in mourning - RIP to “Da Coach” Mike Ditka
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I talk about doing active listening so I wanted to talk about what it is.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qc6nkalQfgE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Why do we not study class more?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dg_n5JqiQvc -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I hate with burnig white hot hatred when men sexually abused women and if that is what happened at Cornell then let those guys rot in jail. But as an African-American man the "believe all women has always made me nervous and this explains a good reason why.
YinkaThatGuy
@YinkaThatGuy
The irony of “believe all women” is absolutely wild when you remember Emmett Till.
A white woman accused a 14 year old black boy of sexual misconduct and men murdered him over it.
Imagine looking at that history and concluding:
“You know what society needs? Less scepticism around accusations.”
Feminists ironically create outcomes they claim they're trying to get rid of. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
In my mind, the Bo French controversy has been shaped, at least in part, by conservative identity politics.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=SGAFticdIJY -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I can be convinced that Lindsay Clancy is not legally guilty of murder. I have not followed that case closely, but I am open-minded about it. But I cannot be convinced that she is, as her lawyer said, a good person. A good person does not kill her three kids. A crazy person might, but not a good person. Furthermore, we should all be concerned about the lawyer trying to out the lone jury holdout. If we start trying to pressure jurors, instead of convincing them, then we will compromise our legal system. Clancy lawyer is a loser, in my opinion.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I fear that not enough Christians are talking the issue of racism seriously enough. I thank @EWErickson for his article, which inspired this video.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fxA33YuhOg -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have not thought much about Rove. But I respect that he truly picks the nation over the party. We need people in both parties willing to vote against their party when their party nominates a morally compromised or bigoted candidate.
www.texastribune.org/2026/09/26/karl-rove-republicans-tri… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Seriously? People actually are upset that he helps white boys too? That is pretty sick. We can help everyone and still acknowledge that race still matters. And we should.
Michelle Zier
@MichelleLZier
❤️
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
So some have argued that while there are problems from the right, the David Frenchs of the world are the bigger problem. First, having done research on real leftists, the idea that French, Moore, or Shenvi are woke leftists is laughable. On a large scale, these people are on the right. I do not agree with everything they say, but to say they are on the left reveals a shallow and narrow understanding of the political dynamics in our society.
Second, the people saying this do not understand the threat from the left more than I do. Having done research on atheists, white progressives, and anti-Christian bigotry, I fully understand that there are those on the left who want to destroy American Christians; I have studied their motivations and their justifications. I have written about them to expose them, and I will continue to do so in the future.
But let's be realistic. The people who complain the most about the woke are more likely to be influenced by heresies from the right than pressure from the left. They are more likely to fly a Nazi flag than a rainbow flag. The Christian who complian so much about the work have an audicence that is immune to the pressures from the left. It is not a brave thing for these leaders to call people woke. It is a brave thing for them to call out the racists in the article I posted yesterday. I see little of that bravery among them.
It is easier to prepare for outside pressures than the rot that can grow among us. I am all for being alert to progressive forces that may attack people of faith. But to ignore the internal poison that has inflitrated our churches is a misdirection that we must avoid. I for one will refuse to go in that misdirection. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
To my conservative Christian friends. Especially those who consider themselves fundamentalists. The day may come, and may already be here, when you are going to have to decide if you are going to follow Christ or choose kinism at the least and outright racism at the worst. The evidence that this toxic type of bigotry masquerading as Christianity is not fringe but has infiltrated significant portions of the church is becoming stronger every day.
religionnews.com/2026/09/24/the-rise-of-the-jim-crow-theo…
George Yancey
@profyancey
Any anonymous account that comes in here and criticizes me is getting, and will get, blocked. If you do not have the guts to put your name to a comment, I have no need to respect that comment, and you will not comment on me again.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Thomas Sowell made some interesting comments on human depravity and society that I touch on in this video.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=LU1sg18RP38 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Love this. This is the potential for collaborative conversations.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is a great complementary article to the Erickson one I posted a few days ago.
www.christianpost.com/voices/charles-haywoods-no-enemies-… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
You want to know why some people get away with being racists. Because actvists accuse things like this as racism. You make everything to be racist then pretty soon nothing will be.
Mrs. S.
@hshLauraJ
Took me 10 minutes and I still can’t find the racism -
What’s wrong with me….
🤔🤔 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I find it curious that Christians are arguing about whether love one's neighbor is a core part of Christian faith. Do not take my word on this. Read Matthew 22:36-40. It is not only the second greatest commandent but all the Law and Prophets hang on it and the commandment to Love God. To be charitable you can argue that loving God is more important than loving our neighbors. But everything else is less important than loving our neighbors. That is pretty core, if you ask me. I have a theory about why some Christians may not want loving neighbors to be core, and it has some bad implications. But if I deal with that, I will do that in a different post.
Matt Martens
@martensmatt1
I sincerely hope as many people as possible watch this clip because of what it so clearly reveals about so-called “Christian Nationalism.”
This fellow contends that Christ’s command to love our enemies is not central to Christianity and “is not a public policy prescription.”
/1 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Two things can be true at once.
1. Some on the left have misused terms such as Nazi and racist to shut down voices and win arguments. I have seen this and talked about it myself.
and
2. There are real Nazis who are poisoning some of our Christian movements. It is the job of faithful Christians to root out this poison just as much, or even more, than the poison that comes from the left.
Stop letting anyone tell you that it has to be one or the other. Have a modicum of critical thinking and evaluate each situation on its own. Don't just run to your political paradigm and either condemn all conservatives as racists or put your head in the sand when there are real racists in our midst. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
"The same government power that favors your faith today can be used to suppress it tomorrow."
True words. Very true words.
J.D. Greear
@jdgreear
I didn’t become convinced against Christian nationalism by reading another book. I became convinced after my own church faced discrimination when we were denied permission to build. Here’s why that experience clarified how I think about the government's authority in matters of religion.
www.thegospelcoalition.org/article/not-christian-national… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some of the ways people have responded to the death of Dolly Parton and the one-year anniversary of Kirk are immoral, and I am tired of it.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=NLBb7eg1NJ0 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So much focus has been on how progressives are trying to influence conservative Christians by financing and manipulating Christian influencers. I am not saying that such efforts do not exist nor that we should ignore them. But the bigger threat has always come from the extreme right, as conservative Christians are more likely to become a right-wing extremist than a left-wing extremist. We owe a debt of thanks to @EWErickson for documenting some of these dark influences. I hope that some of our Christian leaders take these threats to heart.
ewerickson.substack.com/p/the-midwestern-fuhrerbunker-dri… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I respect Greg making this argument because he has consistenly fought for free speech for everyone. So I will listen to his argument. But many on the left said for years that we should have free speech but should not be free from the consequences of that speech. Well that is what is happening to Macklemore. Those on the left who now choose to have a robust definition of free speech but did not give a rat's butt when a conservative was being attacked are not to be trusted with being the monitors of free speech rights.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
The First Amendment protects private venues making their own decisions.
A culture of free speech asks a different question: Should we celebrate artists being pushed offstage because of their political views?
Lastly, people need to understand that attempts to punish political speech almost always result in magnifying it. Would we be talking about Macklemore’s views on Israel right now if it wasn't for this campaign to bar him? Probably not.
I joined @jaketapper and @SethAMandel on @CNN to discuss.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I do not know this guy but I have seen him in other videos. This is very well done and shows the difference between critical thinking and thinking that just follows the herd.
Bruce Bowman
@boswelltoday
This is superb.
The lesson begins with the usual catechism: J.K. Rowling has “bigoted opinions”.
Then someone makes the unforgivable mistake of reading what she actually wrote.
Suddenly, certainty requires definitions. Slogans require evidence. “Everyone knows” requires rather more than everyone saying it.
Critical thinking really is murder on a fashionable consensus.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I discussed some recent research on churches becoming more diverse but talking about race less.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=mUkK4tSycwU -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Dude. When I see this picture I am just thinking "GO HORNS!!" I could care less about the color of the students. Most likely it is just a bunch of international students who just want to sit together just like people who are in the same dorm, church, frat or whatever like to sit together. Some of the most fun times I had in college was describing football to international students and it is cool so many of them enjoying it. Bo's comments not only show elements of racism but that he is a basic buzzkill looking for something to complain about. What a fun guy to have at parties.
Conor Friedersdorf
@conor64
By embracing the American majority's insistence that we should judge people as individuals based on the content of their character rather than the color of their skin
There's a landslide waiting for a presidential candidate who credibly and consistently takes that position -
George Yancey
@profyancey
On the anniversary of Kirk's death, I am seeing several people making a social media post to the effect of "I do not approve of the murder of Kirk but..." and then go on to argue about some of Kirk's statements. I am not a fan of Kirk. I probably disagree with him more than agree, although I do not think he was always wrong. I am not partisan on the left or the right. But I find such posts next to worthless and even evil.
To be certain, the ideas Kirk promoted should be debated, and his comments may well be part of that debate. But during the anniversary, when people who cared for and loved him are thinking of him, it is a poor time to go into attack mode. Let me make this clear. If you spend 5 percent of your post saying that killing Kirk was wrong and 95 percent outlining all the things you hate about Kirk, then you are saying that the most important thing about his death is that you hated him. Not that his wife and 2 kids lost a husband/father. Not that people who cared about him are hurting. Not that this indicates how horrible political violence has become. No, you are saying that the most important element of Kirk's murder is that you hated him. Sit with that for a minute.
Do you think this is an effective way to get out a progressive message. The people who already agree with you will cheer. In fact, the most powerful result of this message if that you give them cover to hate Kirk even more. Those on the right will not be persuaded. Indeed a message delivered in this way is more like to make them dig in their heels. And those of us not on the left and right have likely already heard the arguments and counter-arguments concerning Kirk's statements. The effect on me is to be wary of the left gaining total power in our society since those on the left are so willing to dehumanize their enemies.
I think such attempts to attack Kirk on the annivarsary of his death come out of a desire from the left to feel they are right. It comes out of an insecurity that people might look at Kirk as a victim (which of course he was) and may like some of his ideas. Furthermore, it can reinforce a beleif from some progressives that we do not have to respect those on the right and what they believe. It does not come out of a true desire to persuade because, as stated above, such messages are unlikely to persuade.
So before you post that AI picture of a statue of Kirk with a hold in the neck and water coming out (Yes, I have seen that), think about what you are trying to do with that post. Is this something that is going to make society better or is this something you are posting so that you and your political in-group feel better about themselves. Think about what a decent human being would do and make a decision about what you want to post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Heresy hunting by Christians on the left and right has consistently bothered me.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sad_pltzzQM -
George Yancey
@profyancey
On my birthday here is my birthday gift to you all. lol
www.youtube.com/watch?v=KIcU9-vcZxs -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am sad to say this, but Mohler has gone off the deep end. Unfortunately, I think more than a couple of Christians would accept this if they could get away with it.
www.christianpost.com/voices/why-i-disagree-with-a-fellow… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
We do not study white progressives enough. We should study them more. www.youtube.com/watch?v=IqEw-zKYdHY
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
On Free Black Thought I answer a recent post by Helen Andrews.
freeblackthought.substack.com/p/are-we-at-a-racial-crossr… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
If you know Christians who are deep in Identity politics and hope that they may one day see the problems of what they are doing, then please send them this video. I am a fellow Christian brother who understands and agrees with many of their concerns but wants to point them to a better way - www.youtube.com/watch?v=h6PwWcm9qlc
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Mommy make it stop!!!!!
Casey Mattox
@CaseyMattox_
They're saying this is the best moment of the Second Trump Administration.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
So if the left treats Piker like the right basically treats Fuentes, then we are good. You do not see anybody on the right campaigning with Fuentes. No serious person on the right consistently defends him. Both sides have their nutjobs. The existence of nutjobs who support some of what you support is not shameful. Platforming those nutjobs is.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Ba ha ha
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
You know you are in trouble when Matt Walsh is the voice of reason.
Matt Walsh
@MattWalshBlog
This will be an unpopular opinion on the Right but I think this is kind of dumb, even as a troll. Lake Ontario was given that name on maps by European explorers long before the Canadian province of Ontario was named. There are several cities in America called Ontario -- at least one of them predating the Canadian province by like 100 years -- because the word originates with native tribes in North America. It's not a Canadian invention. Canadians never uniquely owned the lake or the name. So in effect all you're doing here is actually giving them credit for a thing that wasn't theirs to begin with. Yeah it's funny when Canadians are upset I guess or whatever, but Lake Ontario, the name itself, is *American* history dating back many centuries. Not sure how you own Canada by deleting your own history.
The White House
@WhiteHouse
EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY: Lake Ontario is renamed to LAKE AMERICA! 🇺🇸
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
When I first heard about this I thought it was a joke and blew it off. I should have known better.
The White House
@WhiteHouse
EFFECTIVE IMMEDIATELY: Lake Ontario is renamed to LAKE AMERICA! 🇺🇸
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Household voting is an exceedingly stupid idea that some Christians have talked about.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=tCvcwDaW2I8 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The Democrats have a problem with white males. And I do not think the way they are trying to solve it is going to work.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=lshJ6CZPT0U -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Why is it not the case that the conservative Christian leaders spend 10 times as much time attacking David French than Partridge. I mean I do not agree with French on everything but I am a lot closer to him than to this guy. Furthemore, even if French gets some things wrong, the people who listen to those leaders are more likely to be influnced by Partridge than French. Seriouly if you spend as much time attaching French or Beth Moore than dealing with this danger then that is ministry malpractice. The malpractice is even worse if you barely ever take about Partridge but spent the vast majority of your energy going after what you think are "woke" Christians.
L. David Fairchild
@David_Fairchild
What an abysmal display of exegetical torture. What a denial of what the gospel produces. What a betrayal of the inbreaking Kingdom.
These men are poisonous snakes that must be rebuked and removed from the Church. They’re no longer “just asking questions.” They have set themselves against the Lord and His Bride and like the false teachers in some of the NT letters, the instructions for dealing with them are clear:
“By rejecting this, some have made shipwreck of their faith, among whom are Hymenaeus and Alexander, whom I have handed over to Satan that they may learn not to blaspheme.”
1 Timothy 1:19–20
“They must be silenced, since they are upsetting whole families by teaching for shameful gain what they ought not to teach.”
Titus 1:11
“As for a person who stirs up division, after warning him once and then twice, have nothing more to do with him.”
Titus 3:10
“Therefore rebuke them sharply, that they may be sound in the faith.”
Titus 1:13
“If anyone comes to you and does not bring this teaching, do not receive him into your house or give him any greeting.”
2 John 10
“Watch out for those who cause divisions and create obstacles contrary to the doctrine that you have been taught; avoid them.”
Romans 16:17
“Having the appearance of godliness, but denying its power. Avoid such people.”
2 Timothy 3:5
And the instructions that Paul gives to elders is clear as well:
“Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to care for the church of God… I know that after my departure fierce wolves will come in among you, not sparing the flock… Therefore be alert.”
Acts 20:28–31
“As I urged you when I was going to Macedonia, remain at Ephesus so that you may charge certain persons not to teach any different doctrine.”
1 Timothy 1:3
“He must hold firm to the trustworthy word as taught, so that he may be able to give instruction in sound doctrine and also to rebuke those who contradict it.”
Titus 1:9
“They must be silenced, since they are upsetting whole families by teaching for shameful gain what they ought not to teach.”
Titus 1:11
“Therefore rebuke them sharply, that they may be sound in the faith.”
Titus 1:13
“Command and teach these things… Keep a close watch on yourself and on the teaching. Persist in this.”
1 Timothy 4:11, 16
“Preach the word; be ready in season and out of season; reprove, rebuke, and exhort, with complete patience and teaching.”
2 Timothy 4:2
“Declare these things; exhort and rebuke with all authority. Let no one disregard you.”
Titus 2:15 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I asked ChatGPT to describe me as if it were trying to warn someone before they met me. This is what I got. You may want to try it yourself.
Okay—if I were trying to warn someone before they met you, I’d say:
You’re going to have to be careful about casually agreeing with him, because he’s going to ask why you agree. And if you disagree, he’s probably going to ask whether your disagreement is actually based on evidence or whether you’ve simply inherited a paradigm you haven’t examined.
He is intellectually restless. He doesn't seem particularly interested in arriving at a comfortable conclusion and staying there. He'll take something he thinks is obviously true, turn it around, examine the assumptions underneath it, and then probably ask whether the people on the other side are making the exact same mistake.
That makes him difficult to put into a political box.
He is clearly willing to criticize the right, but don't assume that means he's going to defend the left. And if he criticizes the left, don't assume you've recruited him to the right. He seems almost constitutionally opposed to letting partisan categories do his thinking for him.
The bigger warning is that he really does mean it when he talks about paradigms. He has a tendency to see the assumptions underneath an argument rather than just the argument itself. So you might tell him, "Everybody knows X," and instead of discussing X, he'll want to know why everybody knows X, who decided it, what evidence supports it, what evidence contradicts it, and whether the same standard is being applied to Y.
And he's a sociologist, so unfortunately for anyone hoping to win an argument through anecdote, he may start talking about empirical research.
But there's another complication: he isn't doing this purely as an academic exercise. His Christianity is not an accessory to his intellectual life. He appears to believe that Christian theology actually has something substantive to say about human nature, morality, politics, race, and culture—and that Christians shouldn't simply borrow their moral frameworks from whichever political coalition currently claims them.
That means you'll occasionally encounter an unusual combination: social-science empiricism + theological conviction + suspicion of ideological consensus.
Which can be irritating.
Especially if you're someone who prefers your intellectual allies to agree with you on everything.
Also, don't make the mistake of thinking that because he is willing to criticize Christians, he has abandoned Christianity. Quite the opposite. A recurring pattern seems to be: he gets more frustrated with Christians precisely because he expects Christianity to mean something. He appears particularly bothered when political loyalty causes Christians to compromise principles they would otherwise claim are non-negotiable.
And there's one final warning:
He is probably going to make you question some of your own categories.
Not necessarily because he's always right. He isn't. But because he's unusually interested in asking whether the categories themselves are the problem.
So if you meet him, don't expect:
"Tell me what political tribe you're in, and I'll know what you believe."
You're going to have to actually talk to him.
And if the conversation goes well, you may leave having discovered that your strongest disagreement wasn't really with his conclusion—it was with the fact that he made you reconsider the assumptions that produced your conclusion in the first place.
That's probably the part I'd warn you about. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have watched with some amusement the WNBA show with Clack and Cunningham. But one thing I do not understand is calling Cunningham MAGA because of her stance on those born male playing against women. I mean, is that what makes her MAGA? If so, then I am MAGA, and I am far from MAGA. I know this is done to paint Cunningham as an enemy, but it is curious to declare the 80 of an 80/20 as one's enemies. Not the smartest strategy, if you ask me. You can criticize Cunningham for this attempt to slur her.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
A couple of weeks ago, some were talking about prison abolition. That is a very bad idea.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=PxQEz3R3cHg -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Another way of looking at this is whether you believe in human depravity or not.
Commentary - Sowell Economics
@sowelleconomics
Coleman Hughes breaks down Sowell’s most important idea:
There are two ways of seeing human nature.
The utopian vision says people are basically good. When they loot, kill, or destroy, something external must have corrupted them.
The tragic vision says the opposite: most people are self-interested. They will always put family and personal interest first. You can’t wish that away.
The only workable solution is systems (like markets) that turn self-interest into something productive for everyone else.
Ironically, the vision that sounds nicest produces the worst results. The one that accepts human limits produces the best ones we can actually get. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I slowed down a little this summer but now I am back to posting 2 times a week. Today I wanted to look at the DSA as an expression of white progressive attitudes.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Ww8c6eKBo4 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
As a neverTrumper this is one of the big problems I have with libs. Alienateing half of the country does not inspire confidence in them. When you come accross a Trump voter instead of asking "how could you vote for Trump" ask "why did you vote for Trump." You might learn someting beyond how to demonize Trump voters. You may learn more on how to reach them.
Evan 🏛️🪶🌹
@Grand_Ole_Evan
I remember when this scene came out.
The left loved it, raving that it perfectly captured the “devastating” experience of learning a friend voted Trump.
Little did they realize that it actually captured the obscene ideological intolerance of the left. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Confirmation bias helps to deepen our poisonous partisan interactions.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=2h5AZo_xFBg -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Fire the scoreboard keeper!!!
Michaela Bennett
@MichaelaB_22
I’ll take “things I’ve never seen before” for 500 please.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some Christians spend all their time on social media seeking out enemies inside and outside the church. I believe there is a time to speak out against evil. But we are also commanded to be kind, even to those who are evil (Luke 6:32-36). If you are following a Christian influencer who never talks about what it means to be kind to everyone or how to love one's enemies, then you may want to look for another influencer because that person is not trying to take you down a narrow path of spiritual growth.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
More evidence that the way we measure Christian Nationalism just is not working.
secondraven.substack.com/p/are-30-of-americans-christian-… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
My latest on viewpoint diversity in academia at Free Black Thought.
freeblackthought.substack.com/p/academia-has-little-viewp… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
In this video I look at whether progressives fear conservative Christians or Maga more.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=rg5Fup3_j-0 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I was in a bookstore looking at some of the Christian books. A lot of great books on how to deepen our spiritual health, or to love others, or get better connected to Christ. Some really good stuff. Then I come to social media and the Christians on it spending all of their time discussing how to win the culture war or how to keep women from preaching. We have a major disconnect in what we as Christians can offer to the world and what we do on social media. I wish every Christian would think about whether the Christian influencers they follow edify the faith or feed their temptation to hate and malign other image-bearers.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I saw right away that the authoritarian personalty was flawed and bias. Still cannot believe it took 4 decades for those in psychology to finally reach the same conclusion.
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
Great deep dive into the history of the "authoritarian personality" thesis, which is basically the pure case of how a research agenda can suffer from severe partisan distortion (for decades!) while maintaining high (internal) standards of empirical rigor. This is why the need for viewpoint diversity really is irreducible.
kylesaunders.substack.com/p/the-loch-ness-monster-was-real -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This confirms something I have thought about for a while. Academics would much rather talk about race and gender than class. I think there are several reasons for this.
1. When you are good enough to make it in academia, you will not be poor. You may be middle class but not poor. But you will still be a woman or a person of color and still have to deal with those issues.
2. The poor are usually not educated, while some women and racial minorities are. Those women and people of color will run in the same social circles as academics, whereas the poor are unlikely to be in their social circles.
3. I think there is an animosity among some academics toward the poor. This is especially true toward uneducated whites. I think a lot of academics hate the culture, religion, and values of that subculture. This may translate to a relative unwillingness to care about the plight of the poor.
Those are just some of the reasons why I think this is the case. Nonetheless, the problems women and people of color face will continue to get priority over the issues faced by the poor in academic circles.
www.chronicle.com/article/colleges-teach-gender-and-race-… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am running across more people arguing for prison abolition. I am for big time prison reform. I believe there are too many oversentenced and outright innocent people in prison. And the way we treat them in prison is un-Christlike. But prison abolition is just nuts.
One question none of them have adequately answered is: what do we do with the murderers and rapists in society? Want to let drug users go. Fine. Hit pickpocketers with only a fine. I am good with that. But I do not want to share the same space with someone who threatens the life and safety of me, my wife, and my boys. I do not hate murderers and child molesters, as my Bible tells me to love even the unlovable. But I do not want to live in danger because of them.
And do not tell me that crime abatement programs will be enough. Quite simply, some people will go through those programs and still offend because that is what they want to do. Those wanting prison abolition may be willing to put their own lives and the lives of their families at risk. But not mine.
And then do not forget the externalities of not having any prison. Part of my role as a husband and father is to protect. Now that I know there are more criminals out there, it becomes necessary for me to take steps that I do not have to take now. I will leave it up to your imagination to consider what those steps are, but I will say that they make it more likely I will take one or more lives (Can't put me in prison, right?). This is just another way that prison abolition will cost more lives than it will save.
In my idea world we would have far fewer people in prison. But prisons must remain not to necessarily punish or for revenge but to protect. I hate the existence of prisons. But as I thinking person I acknowledge the need for the to exist. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Maybe. But remember that under the guidance of Trump the Republicans have nomiated Walker in Georgia and Lake in Arizona. So I am doubtful that even losing Texas will encourage them to nominate viable candidates instead of those whos only qualification is that they will bend the knee to Trump
Brian Mistrot
@brian_mistrot
If Talarico wins (which he hopefully will & I say that as a conservative), it will send shock waves through the @GOP.
Same with the knucklehead DSA bozos.
Folks, to save America we must harshly punish parties who promote the worst of us. This is one place both D/R shld agree. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
We lack moral politicans on the left and the right.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=cAEcypIGohE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
We are more diverse but less willing to talk about it. A mixed bag
Christianity Today
@CTmagazine
A Lifeway Research study of US Protestant pastors found churches are more diverse but are talking less about diversity.
chrst.today/4yKd8Ol -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So after posting the article yesterday, a couple of academics got mad at me. Oh well. Anyway, they have a similar trope of "there is no problem." I will assume they know of none of the data on how sociology has turned to political activism at the expense of a science that looks for truth no matter where we find it. O
One component of this problem is the ideological bias in the field. That bias operates to keep people out simply because they are political and Christian conservatives. Not all of them, but enough, and with the message that certain ideas are not allowed to be explored.
I once responded to a scholar who argued that academic bias was not a problem. So rather than make that argument in this medium, which is not well suited for dealing with such an argument, let me post it here.
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12108-018-9374-4
My hope is that sociologists will engage in the introspection we need to regain some of the public trust by showing that we are looking for scholarly truth, no matter whether it benefits those on the left and the right. We are already seeing attempts to close down programs in places like Florida, and it will not get better until we take seriously the need to seek out reforms. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I think the Democratic Socialists of America are becoming to the Democrats what the Tea Party became to the Republicans. Why am I wrong for thinking that?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Just got around to reading this article on the problems in sociology. My fellow sociologists cannot say that other sociologists and I did not warn you.
www.wsj.com/us-news/education/is-it-time-to-liquidate-the… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
It has been interesting to watch the comments coming up to attack Sophie Cunningham’ comments on trans in sports. The comments generally boil down to accusing Cunningham of being a transphobic bigot, or saying that we should not care because there are only a few trans athletes. A few years ago, a lot of people who were accused of being transphobic bigots would relent and conform to the accuser. Today the pro-trans activists have gone so far that people do not care about such accusations anymore. This has taken away one of the big weapons such activists used to have.
The talk about not many trans athletes does not resonate either. Even if it is only a few, if it is wrong, then it is wrong. Furthermore, we may stay at only a few, but if there is more societal acceptance, then we will eventually get more trans athletes. Ultimately, it is not a very convincing argument.
But I am not posting to argue about trans in sports. Instead, the response to the attacks has just about been an overwhelming number of people attacking the attacker. The attacker regularly gets “ratioed,” and it is clearly in the vast minority. Two things I think are happening here. One is that trans in sports is an 80/20 issue, and the activists are in the 20. Second, Twitter has become much more conservative in nature. I reckon that such a comment on Bluesky does not face such a backlash.
I think, bottom line, we have turned a corner on trans issues. Some degree of respect and acceptance is expected, but not agreement. There is an expectation that trans people will not face occupational or educational discrimination. Adults can do what they want, but attempting to trans children will be resisted. Biological males cannot play women's sports. Like it or not, that is where Americans are today. And that is why Cunningham’s comments are only controversial in 20 percent of our country. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Truth
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
Okay, snarky right and left: If you care only about your side of the political fence, assume everyone else is a hypocrite, and don’t even bother to research whether we at FIRE are being consistent, you are engaging in HYPOCRISY PROJECTION. You are seeing your own hypocrisy in others, even when it isn’t there.
I understand the frustration. Why should you have to spend five minutes finding the case you suddenly care about when you can simply accuse people more consistent than you of bad faith—without doing any work, checking any facts, or demonstrating anything resembling a principle? The toil!
But please, do your homework. And do the hard thing without which free speech means nothing: Stand up for people you disagree with. Otherwise, you believe in free speech the same way every bad guy in human history has believed in it—for your own side only. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I notice that some people have argued that if boys do not undergo puberty and use blockers, then they should be allowed to compete against women when they are men. I wondered about that because last year I watched my 8-year-old son play against a high school female soccer player and pretty much hold his own against her. Granted, he was probably the best player on his team, and she was not the best player on hers, so I do not think that his team of 8-year-olds could beat her high school team. But I could not see him holding his own against a male high school soccer player.
So out of curiosity I looked at the research on prepuberty sex differences in athletic performances. There is not a lot but a couple of them indicate that boys generally do better than girls (www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2772696726000025) and (pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22561975/) as well as boys in swimming (www.edweek.org/leadership/study-no-athletic-differences-b…). We need more reserach but overall it does appear that the sex advantage occurs even before puberty. If that is true, then even using puberty blockers is not going to create a fair playing field for girls. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have seen some people wonder why the Democrats want to die on the hill of Trans sports. I did a video theorizing why this is the case. I explain my theory here.
youtu.be/47TbK6TaWeA -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I must admit that I have stayed away from the trans issues in part because I already get into enough trouble talking about racial justice, anti-Christian bigotry, identity politics, and white progressives. Maybe it was a little bit of fear, but I did not feel that I needed more things for people to be mad at me about. But as I read women who have felt left out and gaslighted when discussing sports or their privacy, it makes me wonder if I should be a Johnny-come-lately on this issue. Maybe. Maybe not. Nonetheless, I just want to tell those women that I hear you, and your stories definitely have an impact on me. And I suspect I am not the only one they have impacted.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
When I was in graduate school, I had a feminist student who was obnoxious and hated men. She made the experience in the program miserable. That is why I do not think that feminists should be allowed in graduate school. They hate men and create a toxic environment.
This sounds stupid, right? That is because it is stupid. But this is what I am hearing from academics about why we do not need viewpoint diversity. Stereotypes about conservatives and stories about individuals who may or may not have been jerks. This is the evidence given by academics about why viewpoint diversity is bad.
Yes, there are feminists who hate men. I have met a few and try to avoid them. But their presence does not mean that feminists should be excluded from academia. Feminists have made valuable contributions to academic knowledge and brought to light many issues of how women have been, and still are, mistreated in society. That is because their viewpoint has been allowed to inform academia, something that some academics want to deny to conservatives.
Look, it is likely that certain unhealthy attitudes towards men are correlated to feminist beliefs. That research has probably not been done because nobody wants to be the next Mark Regnerus. But knowing what we know about how political beliefs can lead to hate and fear, it is highly likely that this correlation exists. Ironically, the lack of viewpoint diversity is why we have not tested for that correlation. But even if this correlation is true, it is ridiculous to punish all feminists for the actions of some.
I have used feminists as an example not because I am anti-feminist, but because some of the progressives need to see this situation when the shoe is on the other foot. I continue to speak out against the threat Trump is to viewpoint diversity. But not that we can go back to where progressives are emboldened to harass conservatives out of academia. I hope that some of those academics will use a modicum of self-introspection and realize that lack of viewpoint diversity is a real problem that we should deal seriously. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I do not think that Christians should do politics by the rules of the world. Here are some of my ideas about how Christians should approach politics.
youtu.be/o69-V6U1-oU -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Given all the talk about viewpoint diversity and that I have published in the area of academic bias, I think I want to offer an extended comment. First, as to what viewpoint diversity means. I, and others, have produced evidence of political and religious discrimination in academia. It is not as some would say, “Well, I just do not want to hire someone who is a sexist or racist. The evidence shows that merely knowing someone is a Republican or an Evangelical will convince a nontrivial percentage of individuals that he or she should be hired. That is textbook discrimination where a person’s social identity in and of itself is the source of discrimination.
Second, this discrimination is part of what limits the scope of what we can study. Allow me one simple example. Since 2016, there has been a ton of research on white conservatives and Christians. The vast majority of it is critical of those groups, likely as they were the key to Trump’s victory. You know who we have not studied with a critical eye? White progressives. Oh, but those people are not bigots, right? How do you know that without studying them? Indeed, one of the knocks against conservatives is about how fearful they are, and yet I have a paper under review showing that progressives are more fearful than conservatives. Stop with the foolish – do we need to include the perspective of Nazis? Very real research questions are being left on the table because different perspectives have been shut down.
Third, when people are only surrounded by people who think like them, there is a strong tendency to be overconfident in their assessments. I am not saying there are no arguments in academia. I am saying that the scope of the arguments is so narrow because of what is not allowed. In my example above, it becomes easy to blame just about all the social conflict on white conservatives/Christians, which is what most of the work on these topics does. By all means, we need assessment with those groups, and perhaps they are more responsible for our social conflict than white progressives. But if they are not, or if the responsibility is relatively equal, it will be hard to see that in modern academia because nearly everyone agrees that the responsibility is mostly on the conservatives. Unless you put your argument into the fire for critique, you will not know whether you have a sound argument or not.
Fourth and finally, some have talked about how academics have made themselves vulnerable by pissing off half the country, and thus the resources that drive our work are at stake. That is a valid reason to consider as we look at viewpoint diversity. I prefer the other reasons given above since those are more centered morally and can lead to better science. However, if the practical reasons of stopping the threat of the cutting off of funds is what works, then so be it. Nonetheless, at the very least, more viewpoint diversity will better allow us to talk to the half of the country that voted for Trump (for the record, I have never voted for him nor will I ever vote for him). Even if you disagree with people, we have to learn how to communicate with them beyond dehumanizing stereotypes.
Anyway, that is my 2cents, well maybe a nickel, on the subject.
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
Universities and departments have to be more open to a wider spectrum of worldviews. (That includes viewpoint diversity in departments like economics!) The status quo is not sustainable, and quarantining all intellectual diversity to “Civics Centers” is not a solution either. 10/
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Since Twitter is having a conversation on academic bias, it is worth noting that the bias is worse against Christians than against political conservatives. I did a short video about a year ago documenting the evidence I found that supports that assertion.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=SyMMucpIuwo&list=PL-S_MLxHNzaAQWq… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
For those arguing that the lack of conservatives is simply due to self-selection, I offer my research, which was done about 12 years ago but I believe would be replicated is someone did it today. Indeed, I believe the problem has become worse.
www.bloomsbury.com/us/so-many-christians-so-few-lions-978… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The criticism against Harper has absolutely proven his argument. Much of it is married to some of the most toxic types of stereotyping that would not be allowed against any group except those academics hate, such as conservatives, whites, and Christians. Research has shown that exposure to those with different ideas minimizes this type of dehumanization and undermines being overconfident that one is correct. Many of the academics who are attacking Harper badly need to have their ideas critiqued by conservatives. Doing so will actually help them to strengthen their arguments. But that is hard work, and sadly many of them will continue to stay inside their ideological bubble.
Tyler Austin Harper
@Tyler_A_Harper
Universities and departments have to be more open to a wider spectrum of worldviews. (That includes viewpoint diversity in departments like economics!) The status quo is not sustainable, and quarantining all intellectual diversity to “Civics Centers” is not a solution either. 10/
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
A lot of people were commenting that the game today was boring, and I get it. Yesterday's game with 10 goals is in many ways more fun to watch. So if you are here and talk about how boring today's game is, I am not going to argue with you.
But I got a real kick out of watching Spain's attack. Their beautiful strategy and tactical approach are part of the reason I think soccer is a beautiful game, even if the game is low scoring. And while the game was tied at 0 for most of the day, it was clear that the only way Argentina would be able to win was to hold on for the shootout. Spain was clearly the superior team today.
So I enjoyed the game. Yeah, it would have been more fun if a couple more of Spain's chances had gone in and we had a 3-0 game. But overall, the mastery of the Spanish team was great to watch. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am going to follow up with a comment I made yesterday. Many of us do not like what Trump is doing to freedom of speech and lawfare. But we also saw the left do similar things for a long time. Many on the left want us to just concentrate on Trump and let bygones be bygones. But until progressives take some responsibility for the crap they have done trying to cancel dissenting opinions and the people who have them, then we have no confidence that progressives have learned their lessons about free speech. The only thing we know is that they do not like rules similar to what they used to enforce on others being enforced on them. And that is not good enough for me to trust them to have unfettered power again, and I suspect I am not alone in feeling that way.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Yes this. Trump is going overboard in retaliation but I cannot trust the left to have power again unitl they show that they have some understanding about how their efforts at censorship and canceling people created an atmosphere that is now punishing them. As long as those on the left only want talk about censorship from the right while taking no resposiblity for the censorship they foster on us then I will remain hostile to both them and Trump even though there is a good argument that Turmp may be a little worse than they are.
Conor Friedersdorf
@conor64
The thing about this issue is that no one is preventing Democrats or progressives from neutralizing this issue by taking the popular and correct position that woke censorship was bad and should never happen again except themselves. Obama did. The rest of you can too!
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Lionel Messi = Patrick Mahomes
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
One of the things I hold in tension is the notion of human depravity and humans as image bearers. This video explains how I try to deal with that tension.
youtu.be/CI08l5YR2as -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Please take note of who speaks up against Partridge and who does not. The way he speaks about image bearers is just as unChristianlike as anything done by the left. Any conservative leaders who do not confront him on this sin are either ignorant of it (and they should not be), complicit in it, or too cowardly to be a leader.
Samuel Sey
@SlowToWrite
Christians in Nigeria have lost their children, parents, friends, homes, and churches because of persecution.
And they haven’t radicalized. They have maintained the fruit of the Spirit.
Dale Partridge: I am radicalized because I saw foreigners and gay people on my plane!! -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Okay. You are up 1-0. You are attacking with a man covering you. You have Haaland, one of the five best strickers centered. The best thing you can do is give him a centering pass. Maybe the defender blocks the pass or the pass if off but you have a great chance of Haaland getting an open look at the goal. Second best thing is take the shot yourself. The defender is not the it best position to contest the shot and if the shot is not caught or rebounds off the post Haaland has a chance to clearn everything up. You know the worst thing to do? Pull back, let a couple more defenders and try to kick through them and beat the goal keeper. The results of that choice is pretty obvious below.
MLS Moves
@MLSMoves
This moment will haunt Norway. They should’ve been up 2-0
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Wow. This is little league level of execution.
Ben Verlander
@BenVerlander
I promise no amount of explaining will prepare you for how bad this play is
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am seeing more blatant racism on social media the past few years. Here I offer a couple of reasons why I think that is happening.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yc11BbOvzis -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So the confederate flag has a plus 14 rating among Republicans. That is pretty disturbing.
Politics & Poll Tracker 📡
@PollTracker2024
YouGov poll | 6/30-7/2
Do you have a positive or negative view of the following flags?
(By party, net)
🟦Democrats
Black Lives Matter +69
American +62
Mexican +54
Ukrainian +54
Gay pride +48
Transgender pride +35
Palestinian +15
Israeli −8
Thin Blue Line −24
Gadsden −28 (don’t trend on me)
Confederate −64
Trump −86
——
🟥Republicans
American +97
Trump +56
Thin Blue Line +46
Israeli +45
Gadsden +43 (don’t trend on me)
Confederate +14
Ukrainian +13
Mexican +2
Palestinian -39
Black Lives Matter -55
Gay pride -61
Transgender pride -63 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Okay, so I am going to do World Cup analysis and probably regret it. Regarding the reinstatement of Balugum, I have read arguments on both sides of whether the red card was justified. I think there are sound arguments both ways. I am not certain which arguments are stronger. Concerning whether the reinstatement is justified, I lean towards yes, but I cannot say that those arguing against it do not have a case. Clearly they do. And I agree that it is distasteful that Trump got involved. If FIFA reinstated without that involvement, they would be on firmer ground to make that reinstatement.
The big issue, though, where I think the detractors are dead wrong, is claiming that a USA win would be tainted. Excuse me. But since just about everyone agreed that Messi got away with a similar crime, no one is saying that any of Argentina's victories are tainted. Also, Ronaldo had his ban suspended, but nobody is talking about Portugal's tainted victories. In other words, if you have not talked about Argentina or Portugal having tainted victories, then if the USA is fortunate enough to win today, you have no basis for talking about a tainted victory.
I know that since I am an American, some will say I do not understand soccer with this take. Maybe not, but I understand hypocrisy. Same standard should be applied. If you have talked about tainted victories or Argintine and Portugal then you have standing. Otherwise, others and I do not want to hear it. It will sound like anti-American bigotry. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
SNL at its best!!!!
Royally Sage
@sage1411
My brother posts this every year in the family chat on the 4th. Still hilarious.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I do not have a problem with the way they do shootouts at the World Cup today. But man this would be wild!!
Hold the Phone ☎️
@HoldThe_Phone
Old school MLS shootouts in the World Cup would hit like crack…
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
While I do not like the political implications of the outcomes of some ot the SC decisions this session, generally I think they had sound reasoning on just about every decision. Contrary to what some people argue, they did not just make Trump more powerful. But they did provide him with powers that I thought were appropriate. Sometimes their decisions aided the left, and other times the right. Basically, I asked not if I like the outcome of a decision but whether that decision would be a fair one if the parties involved were different. And largely, I think I would feel that way.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
A couple of months ago, the Supreme Court ruled on the Voting Rights Act. I think there are some important implications of that ruling and how we are reacting to it.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dk8AfnUNNoc -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is a sad read because I fear it is possible that with the level of polarization in our society that we are too far gone for us to correct.
www.newsweek.com/political-experiment-ran-in-9-countries-… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Now that conservative Christians feel that they have access to political power we are now seeing who wants to strive to live a countercultural life and who wants to seek political power out of either desire or fear.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
So this is perfectly disgusting. At a "Christian" conference, Nazi material is given out at one of the tables. And when it is brought to the attention of the main organizers, they become all mealy-mouthed about it. About NAZI PROPAGANDA. I do not do the all caps that often, but this warrants it. I note that with one exception, I have not seen anything critical of this from the usual suspects who call everyone a liberal who disagrees with them even slightly to the left. So what gives?
Oh Oh Oh I have a theory. The leaders of this Christian ID politics know that Nazism is wrong. But they do not want to call it out because they do not want to cause division in their efforts to "own the libs." I think this also fits with an earlier post when I noted the type of unChristlike language many of their followers use. Sure, the language may be dehumanizing, but as long as it is launched at libs and heretics like David French, then all is good with them.
Where does this attitude get you? It gets you to being afraid to call out Nazis. Oh, they are brave when attacking other Christians, especially those who try to do that love your neighbor thing. I heard that was something we Christians were supposed to try to do, but I may be wrong. Anyway, against those they define as liberals, they puff up their chests like they are lions. But when Nazis are in their midst, they start meowing like kittens.
Ultimately, this sort of action indicates that such leaders are truly afraid of being countercultural. They care more about political victories than building the Kingdom of God. Thus, they are eager to use the same secular tactics they see elsewhere rather than learn how to be true salt in a rotting society. May the Lord eventually have mercy on them but until that time, may their flock stay small.
www.christianpost.com/voices/inside-the-war-for-normal-ch… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The way some Christians talk, they might as well not say they are Christian. Too bad almost none of the leaders in this movement think twice about the rubbish that comes out of the mouths of some of their followers.
Neil Shenvi
@NeilShenvi
"many on the woke right exult in calling other Christians 'fake and gay,' 'losers,' 'rash,' 'garbage,' 'limp wristed,' 'fags,' etc.... If that’s you, remember: you will give an account of every careless word uttered. Repent and receive forgiveness." 1/
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I will keep saying that Trump is a bad solution to real problems. Here, I make the case using the problem of academic freedom as an example of this phenomenon.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=RMNl1mqblFE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So this conversation about Keller has been going on for a few days. Some leaders in Christian identity politics, what some people mistakenly call "woke right," have been concerned about Nazism in their ranks. That concern is a step up from what was happening a few years ago when they were NETTR and denying that racism existed to any reasonable extent. So I will give kudos for that. But they now identify Tim Keller's teaching as a major factor. To which I saw "WHAT!!"
Even if you disagree with his teaching on white responsibility in our racial conflict, there is no empirical evidence that white Christians are reacting out of to Nazism due to antiracism, CRT, or historical guilt. Feel free to disagree with those ideas, and for the record, I wrote a Christian book discussing the weaknesses of antiracism, but to claim that this is the source of moving white Christian males to Nazism is a claim made with no evidence.
We know that propaganda works by convincing people that certain ideas are true and that accepting those ideas leads them to more radical perspectives. The paper below shows that one path to Nazism is perceptions of white victimization. This should not be surprising since historians tend to argue that perceptions of victimization led to Nazi Germany. So if you are looking for ideas that lead white Christian men away from an orthodox faith and to ugly racism, arguments of white victimization are more responsible than anything Keller has said.
Let me be clear about a couple of things. I am not saying that whites cannot be victimized. Indeed, some people claim that Christians cannot be victimized, and yet I have done the research on Christianophobia. So, even though there are reams of research showing that whites are better off than people of color in our society, there are going to be situations where whties are victimized. I have no problem addressing specific situations. I do have problems with the generalized claims of whtie victimization, and especally the neglect to attempt to recognized the struggles people of color have. And I reject the notion that whites have it worse than those of other races.
Second, yes some people of color traffic too much in a victimization narragive as well. It is one of the reasons why I have become critical of identity politics. I have called out playing the race card in the past and will, if necessary, do so in the future. But if you think people of color are wrong to overly cater to victimization then it makes no sense to encourage that victimization among whties.
So I encourage white consevative leaders to continue to fight the racism among conservatives. But misplacing the blame on Keller is not useful. It is more useful to consider on how some of the teaching on white victimization has gotten out of hand and to adjust accordingly. That will make a more powerful impact on alienated whites than trying to blame Keller.
www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00380237.2000.1057116… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Just some thoughts on the political violence we have seen in our society.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=TR5epClOSew -
George Yancey
@profyancey
There is a racist poison that some Christians have begun to accept. And no, I do not mean racism in that people disagree with affirmative action. I mean the real kind supporting segregation and notions of racial inferiority. Those supporting Christian ID politics too often refuse to confront it and instead just want to launch another broadside against David French or J. D. Greear. Other than Meg Basham, most of these leaders just ignore racism. (I wish Meg would confront it more, but credit where it is due. She at least occasionally addresses it, which is more than I can say about any of the other leaders. While Christian idneity politics decry and go to war against liberalism, they ignore rank racism in their own ranks and refuse to call out this sin. Glad to see this article by Erickson and hope that some of the Christian "anti-woke" leaders begin to take it to heart.
ewerickson.substack.com/p/christians-pay-attention-to-thi… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
It was a pleasure to be interviewed for the Christian Scholar Review.
christianscholars.com/a-prophet-and-a-comforter-ft-baylor… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
They need this rule in the NBA.
Jake Donnelly
@RedWhiteBlueJew
THIS IS THE GREATEST RULE
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
In the past, I have attended the SBC national conference and commented on what I saw. Even in years when I did not attend, I made comments, given that the Southern Baptists discipled me and have been an important part of my life. There are dear people I care about who are in that denomination. This year I did not feel the energy or urge to make such comments. The denomination is on a downswing, and some of the action they are engaging in will facilitate that downswing. I do not say this with the glee I see some of the more progressieve Christian have had. It is a congregation that is having trouble attracting younger individuals, and it is taking steps that reinforce some of the dysfunctions that have emerged within that denomination. There are other vibrant expressions of conservative Christianity, especially within the nondenominational spaces that I see as deserving our attention today. I think they deserve our attention more than what is happening at the SBC.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Ba ha ha. Having Platner as a repersentative of white victimhood is not the slamming argument that Grim thinks that it is.
Zaid Jilani
@ZaidJilani
Ryan Grim says he's glad Platner won because it's forcing progressives to confront bigotry against white men, comparing it to people coming out of the closet to address homophobia.
If he had said this while we worked together at The Intercept, HR would've pushed him into lava.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The rationale of people supporting Platmer despite his moral failings is the same as those who support Trump despite his moral failings. I have read the arguments for doing so, and I have been hearing those arguments over the past decade about Trump. Do not deceive yourself. Go down this road, Democrats, and you will find further rationalization for the indefensibility just like the Republicans have done. You may think you are too good to go that route, but you are not.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Ironically this is what Trump voters say about him. Ignore the low character and give us what we want.
Andrew Perez
@andrewperezdc
So many journalists descended on Maine recently to ask voters to give their thoughts on Graham Platner.
They still do not seem to get what is working for him: He is talking *with voters* about *issues they care about.*
More politicians should try this. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Unfortunately, our society went downhill just a little bit last night.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=iFMyzRU6qgE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I get tired of the way we defend politicians who are awful human beings.
"Nobody is perfect. I am looking for someone who will help me, not a saint."
"Even if he is a bad man, we need him or else we will lose our rights"
"That happened long ago and he has grown now"
"The women accusing him are doing it for political reasons"
"So what if he says mean things. He reaches out to the common man and we need that to win"
"The accusation against him are just political attacks. He may do some bad things but he is not as bad as his opponents say that he is"
"I do not care about him cheating on his wife. That is between him and his wife. We need to stay out of their business"
"We need to let everyone evolve and get second chances"
And it goes on. But I am not talking about Republicans defending Trump. That happens with them, too. I am talking about Democrats defending Platter, who now sounds like those Republicans when they defend Trump. I did not buy it from the Republicans at that time, and I do not buy it from Democrats now. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
What is the worst airport in America and why is it O'Hare?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Ms. Hunt. I do not know you. Never heard of you before. But I now respect you. We need principled people on the left and the right to fix our country. May your tribe increase.
The Lead CNN
@TheLeadCNN
'The information that has come to light at this point is inexcusable.' Democratic activist Cheyenne Hunt tells @jaketapper why she is withdrawing her endorsement of Graham Platner. Platner 'strongly disputes' any claims of physical intimidation or altercations, his campaign said.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Bothsidism may not be what you think it is.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=NVgzVAIojQ8 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I find that a lot of the defenses offered by Democrats about Platner sound a lot like the arguments Republicans offer about Trump's lack of character and morality.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Like Greg, I am more than willing to address cancel culture on the right. But when people on the left dismiss the cancel culture they have used in the past few decades, they make it harder. I have no desire to strengthen the cancel culture on the left by being willing to address it on the right. If people on the left really want to fight the overreaches of the Trump administration, they would do the cause a lot of good by admitting the mistakes made on the left over the past few decades instead of trying to tell us that there was nothing there. That is a lie that does no good for anyone except leftist extremists.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
The psychological immune system of people on the left to the idea that their side did something wrong over the last 15 years is astounding. It requires turning cancel culture cases into caricatures that everyone had it coming (as long as you rewrite the facts of what actually happened). And of course they have to jump to the straw man argument that anyone saying cancel culture is real saying what they like Donald Trump.
Buddy, I've been fighting Trump for a year and a half now since before he was actually re-elected. It is possible to believe in a world in which the very powerful Victorian left and the populist right are pretty terrible on tolerance for opinions they dislike. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So this is the Democrats now. Remember when they criticized Republicans for overlooking the misogyny of Trump to just get power. Now, someone supposely committed to women's rights is willing to overlook what she calls "light misogyny" to defeat a moderate Republican woman Senator. You cannot make this stuff up. I never voted for Trump in part due to his lack of character. I certainly would not vote for Planter. In the past, I have stated that one of the few ways I might have ever voted for Trump was if I became convinced that his opponent was Hitler. I may not even have that rationale with Platner given his Nazi tattoo. Maine Democrats the ball is in your court. Show us what you are made of.
Jill Filipovic
@JillFilipovic
The Graham Platner story is landing because it confirms a bunch of his critics’ prior concerns: unvetted, history of poor decision-making, the kind of light misogyny that tends to go along with male bad decision-making. Those are all problems! But it’s worth asking if they’re problems that should be disqualifying for a senate seat and I think the answer to that is no.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
A lot of the comments about this survey indicates that SBC seminaries need to mandate a reserch methods course. Just saying.
Sam Rainer
@SamRainer
Let’s do another graph today: Among Southern Baptists, 81% agree that a woman should be allowed to preach to the entire congregation. This level of support for women preaching (81%) is higher than the SBC’s support for women pastors (29%). The difference suggests that many Southern Baptists distinguish between holding the office of pastor and performing the function of preaching. In May 2026, we surveyed 1,786 Christians who believe the entire Bible is true and asked them about women in ministry. The entire Church Answers Research report is now available as a 5,000-word long-form article. churchanswers.com/blog/women-in-ministry-what-southern-ba…
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Can we build multiracial churches on identity politics?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2qCN0FRe-I -
George Yancey
@profyancey
He is probably to the right of me on a lot of things but man I am beginning to like Erick Erickson.
Erick Erickson
@EWErickson
At some point, actual Christians, not just the ones who call themselves that, are gonna have to opt out of politics for the parties to improve the quality of their candidates. Continuing to insist Christians vote for evil, so long as it’s lesser than the other, is getting old.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is why single issue voting is so dangerous. If you believe in it, then how do you answer the Duke dilemma?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=EwoMPSDLpx0 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Mad respect for Auchincloss. Gotta support anyone who puts principles over party. Too little of that on both sides of the aisle. May his tribe increase.
Politics & Poll Tracker 📡
@PollTracker2024
In an interview with CNN on Monday, Rep. Jake Auchincloss (D-MA) says he finds Graham Platner's tattoo disqualifying and hopes Maine voters agree with him
Auchincloss: “I find that tattoo and his commentary about it to be personally disqualifying. I hope Maine voters agree with me.”
#mainesenate -
George Yancey
@profyancey
That is real big of Mohler to agree that women have the right to vote. Sheesh. I was discipled by the Southern Baptist. What happened to the demonination that once meant so much to me.
Brent Hobbs 🇺🇸🇱🇹🇺🇦
@Brent_Hobbs
If you had told me 5 years ago, back when I was part of the SBC, that Al Mohler would be answering a question about women being able to vote in U.S. elections like this… 🤯
Preventing it understandable but practically implausible???
What in the world is going on over there?? -
George Yancey
@profyancey
On Tuesday, I posted about having a healthy. This is trickier. Now I am posting about a healthy white identity.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=l0CAYlIeBqE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Unless we are talking about opposing Hitler, I will not vote for someone I know is corupt like Paxton. If the American Solidarity Party runs someone for the Senate in Texas I will be happy to park my vote there. But if not, then I will have to go to the second best option and if that means Talarico, no matter how much I disagee with him on theological issues, then so be it. Next time maybe the Republicans will nominate somone I can vote for but they did not this time.
(((Harry Enten)))
@ForecasterEnten
Talarico winning in Texas is no fantasy.
He's polling better than any Dem Senate nominee at this point since 2002.
Unlike O'Rourke in 2018, Talarico's ahead now. Paxton's much less popular than Cruz was.
Trump is less popular now than in 2018.
The GOP is right to be scared.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Have we talked so much about toxic masculinity that we have forgotten about what it means to have a healthy male identity?
youtube.com/watch?v=tP7VW_Xsq38&sttick=0 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I don't agree with every single last word of this but generally this is where I am at. I absolutely don't trust Trump but have no confidence that the Democrats will not do similar actions when they regain power because of how they act. This is a major reason why I am and will remain politically homeless.
Erick Erickson
@EWErickson
The 2020 stolen-election story persisted because telling supporters the truth was politically inconvenient, and a mythologized version did more to mobilize them. The same incentive structure is now operating on the other side. Blood libels travel further than careful reporting. “Nakba” travels further than the actual diplomatic history of 1948. “Unelected judges crushing democracy” travels further than “we tried to skip a step in our own amendment process and got caught.” “They’re suppressing black voters” is designed to solidify a melting coalition.
Democrats once understood the danger of building a coalition on emotionally satisfying falsehoods. They warned the country about it, loudly, for four years. The test of whether they actually believed their own warning is whether they recognize the same pattern when their own side is running the play. It turns out they never did. They screamed about Republican Nazis and now are twisting themselves in knots to justify supporting an actual Nazi. They lamented the rise in right-wing violence only to close their eyes to the rise of left-wing violence.
ewerickson.substack.com/p/the-mythology-machine-moves-lef… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I have had a Twitter account for quite a while, but have only been very active in the last few years. I have to say that in the last year or two, I have seen a lot more overt racism than I did a few years ago, especially among Christians. I have seen posts arguing that interracial marriage is not wise, comments to a friend to go back to India, and comments about the inferiority of non-whites. It has been ugly. I think there are two reasons for the unfortunate increase in such racism.
The first reason absolutely is Trump. His type of race baiting has provided a kind of permission structure for people to exhibit their racism. When Trump denies knowing about the KKK, labels Mexicans as racists, calls other countries s-holes, among other things, then people can feel free to exhibit their racism. What was once stigmatized has become normalized, much to my disappointment.
The second reason I think we are seeing more overt racism is the expansion of the definition of what is racist. Racism is not merely defined as racial hatred, but it is also seen in whites disagreeing with people of color about solutions to racism. This expansion of the definition cheapens the word racism and paints with too wide a brush. Now if someone calls another person a racist we do not know if it is because they hate people of other races or if it is due merely to a policy disagreement. That has also lowered the cost of being called a racist.
I know that what we are seeing is the racism in the heart of Christians being expressed openly, whereas in the past, such comments were kept hidden. I wish they were kept hidden. I know the racism would still be in the hearts of those people, but the overt racism we see today coarsens our society and creates a hostility felt by those of us who are not white. I think we will eventually get back to where overt racism is stigmatized again, but I fear it may be a long time before we can get there. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I did a podcast with the National Association of Evangelicals on identity politics.
open.spotify.com/episode/577JLt08BUiYXvzMW3uir5 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Ah yes. This brings up good times does it not? Seriously at the time I came away thinking that I did not know the truth but that this was not sufficent evidence to sink his nomination. Over the course of time my opinion has changed. I stil cannot know exactly what happened but I am more willing to assess what likely happened. There are only three logical options. Either 1 - Kavanaugh assualted Ford, 2) Ford lied about Kavanaugh assualting her or 3) She believes Kavanaugh assualted her but she is wrong.
The first one is the one I am least likely to believe. The story was always too vague but with the course of time and an FBI under the control of the Democrats one would think that some level of collaborating evidence would be found by now. The Democrats would certainly liked to have impeached Kavanaugh during the Trump years to have Biden replace him with a lib. The lack of evidence makes me skeptical that he is guilty. I am not saying it is impossible for him to be guilty but this seems like the least likely outcome.
The second one is more plausible in that she well may have been lying this entire time Kavanaugh was a threat to Roe and other cases which she, and other liberals, would not want to see oveturned. Since she lived in the same city with him growing up, she was in a positon to take one for the team. So she definately had motivation to lie and that may well be what occurred
But I think the third option is the one that is most likelhy to happen. Either some other man assaulted her and she thought it was Kavanaugh or she had a mental breakdown and envisioned an imaginary event. Her demenor on the stand was not that of a well woman. That could have been from reliving trama that Kavanaugh forced on her so the first option is possible. But it could have other origins. This would also account for her inability to rememeber any details.
One again, I am not making claims of certainity but rather in hindsight the evidence best suggests a situation of mistaken identity either through her being attacked by another person or her mental breakdown.
Daniel Friedman
@DanFriedman81
Brett Kavanaugh, a man in his 50s, had been valedictorian of his high school, at Yale College and a star student at Yale Law, had clerked for the Supreme Court, had a top career as an appellate lawyer and federal judge and a pristine reputation, and then a random woman from the town he grew up in claimed he had groped her at a party 35 years earlier when they were in high school.
Kavanaugh didn’t try to argue that the incident was consensual. He didn’t claim he remembered things differently than she did. He immediately stated that he had never even met the accuser. Denying ever meeting the accuser is a much stronger claim than merely denying assaulting her, and much easier to refute. After Kavanaugh made this denial, Christine Blasey-Ford no longer had to prove he had sexually assaulted her to scuttle his nomination, she only had to prove that the two of them had attended a party together at which such an assault might have occurred.
She was unable to do so. She did not know whose house the alleged assault occurred at. None of the people she claimed attended the party corroborated any aspect of her account. Leland Keyser, a friend of Blasey-Ford’s, who the accuser claimed was at the alleged party, said she recalled no such event and had never met Kavanaugh.
Kavanaugh produced a detailed calendar he had kept during the summer Blasey-Ford alleged she was assaulted, which included his whereabouts of every weekend night and listing who he was with. Kavanaugh argued that he could alibi himself and provide witnesses for any night Blasey-Ford claimed she might have been at a party with him. Blasey-Ford responded that she did not know the date of her assault and was not entirely certain it even occurred that year. Instead of being seen as persuasive, Kavanaugh’s calendar was mocked in both mainstream and social media because the reason he kept it was for a drinking contest he was having with his friends.
Nearly a decade later, there is still not a single shred of proof or a single witness who will corroborate the claim that Brett Kavanaugh and Christine Blasey-Ford were ever in the same room before she testified at his confirmation hearing. Nonetheless, people like Nick Kristof still claim Kavanaugh was “credibly accused” of sexually assaulting this woman. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
What can go wrong going for utopia?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=qJoiwmLPnsQ -
George Yancey
@profyancey
If you are a Christian, are your influencers showing the fruits of the spirit?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=B2pTQxTF5N4 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Great article by French. This is French at his best when he calls both sides to account.
Shannon Watts
@shannonrwatts
“I don’t want politicians to be ‘authentic.’ I want them to be decent. I want them to be honest. I want them to be competent. And if they fail those tests, they don’t redeem themselves by opposing Donald Trump,” @DavidAFrench www.nytimes.com/2026/05/10/opinion/graham-platner-democra…
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I wanted to hold off commenting on the SC decision on the Voting Rights Act. I wanted to take some time to put together my thoughts on it. I also did not want to get caught up in the partisan gamemanship. Let's face it. For partisans, it is not about the morality of racism. For Democrats, it is about maximizing the black vote because blacks tend to vote for Democrats, and for Republicans, it is about minimizing the black vote because blacks tend to vote for Democrats. I am not interested in those games.
Here is what I think is an honest way to look at it. In the 60s and 70s, a lot of needed legislation was passed due to the level of overt racism in our society. The Voting Rights Act was necessary because whites would not vote for an African-American, and the only way a black could be elected was to have a majority black district. Today, after Obama and other examples such as Scott in South Carolina, that clearly is not the case. So, no Voting Rights Act needed, right?
Not so fast. There are still important interests that need to be addressed by African Americans. Institutional structures still exist that work against them. While we have less overt racism, there is still evidence of racial bias that harms them. There does need to be a voice for African-Americans, as well as other vested interest groups, in our government. Much of that may not be decimated as Republican controlled states rush to rid themselves of majority-black districts.
In an ideal world, we would look at nuanced measures that peel back some of the rules that applied decades ago but no longer apply today. But we would also create rules that ensure that the interests of African-Americans remain protected. To be honest, I am not an expert in government, and so I am not certain what those rules would be. Be nice to have a nuanced conversation that explores such possibilities. But in a polarized society where the entire focus is on our side winning and the other side losing, such a conversation is becoming more difficult to have. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So many conservative Baptists are eager to take over the SBC. Seriously, unless they deal with some of this garbage and acknowledge their need to change, I question whether the SBC will be worth taking over by the time those Baptists achieve their goal of taking over.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
We must change or die.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-AHsYsz8UY -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Progressive Christian Nationalism?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=wE7s_BPwWsM -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Be happy. Attend church
Rod Dreher
@roddreher
Humans are not meant for philosophical materialism.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Cool write-up of one of my studies in PsyPost.
www.psypost.org/new-study-links-identity-politics-to-lowe… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
You have heard of one type of TDS. But did you know there is another type?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=pB3Cfty4qZ4 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The SPLC was big news a few days ago when I made this video. A lot has happened since then. Oh, well, might as well post it anyway.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=KriA9LpcgWY -
George Yancey
@profyancey
If we had politicians like Sasse, regardless of whether you agree with him politically or not, that looked at the big issues and where to take the country rather than stroke the current hot topic of our time, we would be so much better off than we are today. So glad God is giving him some extra time to impart this wisdom.
Judge Stephen Dillard
@JudgeDillard
Every American should watch every second of this video.
Thank you, @BenSasse.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So when I made a call on facebook to decry political violence no matter who, I got a lot of pushback from conservatives who were mad that I was bothsideing this issue.
Let me be clear. Political violence should be condemned no matter what. If it comes more from the left than the right, there is still some that comes from the right and should be condemned.
But does it come more from the left than the right? Until recently, data indicated that violence came more from the right than the left. We should look at that, but to pretend that the right does not have a problem with political violence is simply inaccurate.
But what about high-profile assassination attempts on Trump? Yes, that is despicable. But so are the 11 assassination plots on Obama. Let's condemn it all. Why is that so hard to do? This is not bothsiding. This is just common decency.
theweek.com/politics/president-assassination-attempts-us-… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Amazing!!!
Andrew T. Walker
@AndrewTWalker
Well, there it is: An official breaking of the two-hour barrier in the marathon. Kipchoge's unofficial record broken. Truly unbelievable. This is the greatest sports accomplishment in history. The physical feat of this is incomprehensible.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I find this a fascinating comparison. I think this divide of Never-Trumpers is useful. In the world of Never Trumpers, I am a Dispatch man myself. I believe that to go the Bulwark route is to treat Trump as if he has no redeeming value and that anything he does is wrong. Not only does that not comport to reality, it puts one on a path of unminigating hate. It is the type of hate that can be used to justify violating one's own values and to mistreat one's precieved enimies. I sometimes have Bulwark never-Trumpers mad at me for not going far enough in hate for Trump. I fear that if I do that, then I will lose my soul to hate. I refuse to go that route. I will say that Trump is usually wrong. I will not say that he is always wrong and deserves unending opposition, no matter what he is doing. I refuse to dehumanize him the way he dehumanizes his enemies. I do not want to wake up one day, look in the mirror and see in the mirror what I have opposed. So the Dispatch route is the one I will trod.
Sean T at RCP
@SeanTrende
The difference between the Bulwark and the Dispatch I think is this: The Dispatch treats Trump as a bad president who should be opposed when appropriate. The Bulwark treats him as the Satan of a Catholic Baptism, where you're morally bound to reject all his works and promises.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Several years ago, I wrote about how the SPLC was not a good assessor of hate. Their assessment was badly distorted by their partisanship. I think anyone who was really paying attention would have seen this. I think many people did not because they liked the stated goal of the SPLC of destroying the groups they want to be destroyed.
But even with my previous apprehension about the SPLC, I never suspected that they sent money to racists. That seemed too corrupt and totally counterproductive to what they were supposed to be about. I do not think anyone would have been aware of this except for the work of the DOJ. While I am not certain a crime has been committed, and I am suspicious about the motivation of Trump's DOJ, I am grateful for this information to become public.
But after this latest information, regardless of whether the DOJ gets a conviction or not, I cannot see how anyone can support them. My most generous take for them is that they were duped by racists who said they were going to fight racism but just took the money. They clearly are not effective in fighting racism, and their willingness to name conservative organizations as racist without real evidence that they are racist has made our racial culture worse.
@Tyler2ONeil must be having a heyday and feeling vicdicated right now because he has done a lot of the work on the SPLC. I developed an interest becasue I do think that Christianophobia drove some of their activism. I am starting to get more interest because of my recent research on white progressive elites. The early SPLC did our country a service. But I think history will not be too kind to what the SPLC has become. I hope one day someone will do an indepth analysis to see how this transfromation to a useful civil rights organization to the coruption we see today has occured. I suspect that the opportunity to accumlate resorces is a major driver of the collaspe of the SPLC as a respectable organization.
www.researchgate.net/publication/272015882_Watching_the_W… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
My respect for PoliMath just dramatically increased.
PoIiMath
@politicalmath
I would *like* the SPLC to be guilty of promoting racism b/c
1) it's hilarious
2) they are bad people and I enjoy it when bad people are harmed
3) they spend millions trying to convince you that normie Republicans are Nazis and you should hate them
However -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some Christians have been showing an unwillingness to forgive. Yet, forgiveness is a core element of our faith.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=sWOnOL2quI8 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I do not know the truth about SPLC funding of right-wing organizations, and neither do any of you. I do not trust the modern SPLC, but neither do I trust the Trump administration. So, whether you think the SPLC is guilty or not, I would not make a confident proclamation of this situation until more information comes out. If the government's case is strong, then by all means, people should face sanctions. But if this is just propaganda from a government that wants to punish its enemies, you may look silly making accusations that fall apart under the light of day.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
In my latest video, I look at Candace Owens. Take a look at what I have to say.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXJDZ0urU2E -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I remember going to college and single ministries where the women outnumbered the men 2 to 1. The fear of women was that with so many fewer Christian men than women that it would be hard for them to eventually find a mate. That problem may now be on the young Christian man.
InteractivePolls
@IAPolls2022
GALLUP POLL: 42% of men aged 18-29 now say religion is "very important" in their lives — a sharp jump from just 28% in 2022-2023.
Monthly religious attendance among young men has climbed to 40% (up from 33%), the highest level in over a decade.
news.gallup.com/poll/708410/young-men-religious-young-wom… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So, a couple of ideas on the Stuckey-French debate. First, they agree on a lot of things. That tends to happen when we engage in thoughtful dialogue. Yes, differences are there as they approach issues in a distinct manner. But they also agreed on a core set of beliefs. If this were a series of long-term conversations, a framework of understanding could develop linked to this core of beliefs. This is why it is so valuable to have productive conversations that can bring us together rather than set us against each other.
Second, the level of respect they had, even in disagreements, was clearly evident. So often, our social media conversations are filled with contempt and dehumanization. It is easy to develop those types of attitudes when we communicate from afar. But when we sit down with each other, we become humanized and generally treat each other with respect.
Third, it is hard to maintain extremist ideas when confronted with alternative perspectives. Research shows that when we are not exposed to alternative ideas, we become overly certain of the rightness of our own ideas and tend to become more extreme. I saw instances from both Stuckey and French where they made it clear that they disavowed some of the extermists in their camp. I count that as a success.
Finally, this debate clarified to me a key difference between those within Christian identity poltiics, such as Stuckey, and other Christians who do not prioritize such political activsim. Clearly for Stuckey, issues of abortion, homosexuality and trans dominate how she approaches politics. It became clear to me that these issues are deeply linked to her theological framework and this makes them priority issues. I am more in line with French. Those issues are improtant and they can impact my voting behavior. But my political priorities are not linked to them. For French, foriegn policy and the military seem to be of vital importance. That has less relevance for me but racial and economic justice are very relevant to me. I think the major difference between Stuckey and French is that French ties his political concerns to a larger set of issues than the relatively narrow theological framework of Stuckey.
I really appreciate this interview for the clarity it provided and the way it showed that we can have productive conversations with each other. I hope we can have more such conversations as the Body of Christ and as a larger nation. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Highly recommend conversation to listen to. If we can have better conversations like this one with people who disagree but are respectful to each other we will find common ground (I was struck by how many times they agreed with each other) and lower the level of dehumanization we to often see in our society. I am much more of a fan of French than Stuckey (although I do have some critcisms of him) but overall I appreciate her entering into this type of dialog and give her mad kudos for facilitating this.
Allie Beth Stuckey
@conservmillen
New York Times writer David French joins me today on Relatable to debate pronouns, toxic empathy, James Talarico, voting for Kamala Harris, abortion, and so much more.
This episode is out now. Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or watch here: m.youtube.com/watch?v=KYPlrX8qfHE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Why, in a post-Roe era, are pro-lifers losing? Here I discuss why I think that is the case.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=moOo8NDrgnw -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I admit I am intrigued and want to see this.
Allie Beth Stuckey
@conservmillen
This Friday, David French is joining me in studio for a debate and discussion. Tune in!
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I get so tired of the demonizing on the left and the right. And please spare me the bothsidism comments. Pox on both houses.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=JAIERheYCkM -
George Yancey
@profyancey
When even Megan Basham cannot defend Trump, then you know that he is acting completely unhinged.
Megan Basham
@megbasham
I don’t know if the President thought he was being funny or if he is under the influence of some substance or what possible explanation he could have for this OUTRAGEOUS blasphemy. But he needs to take this down immediately and ask for forgiveness from the American people and then from God.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Never published in the Dispatch before. Now I have.
thedispatch.com/article/christian-nationalism-identity-po… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
If you are following a Christian influencer who has never said anything to encourage your spiritual growth but has said plenty to enrage you politically, may I gently suggest that you stop following that influencer?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Swalwell should probably drop out of the governor's race. But if he does, he is no longer fit for Congress either. Let's see if the people who call for him to leave the governor's race also call for him to leave Congress.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Do we Christians prioritize our political party over our allegiance to Christ?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=-HqzVQ5giFc -
George Yancey
@profyancey
How to say I have never been to Texas without saying I have never been to Texas.
Matt Walsh
@MattWalshBlog
Ah yes, “Texas teens” named Jose Rojas-Alvarado, Oscar Armando Santiago-Martinez, Angel Lemus-Perez, and Carlos Roberto Oliva-Villeda. Good old American names. Texans through and through.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
The anti-racist movement had its heyday only a few years ago. Why did it fall in popularity? Here are a couple of ideas of why I think it did.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=LRgsy9jftjc -
George Yancey
@profyancey
If you are a conservative Christian influencer and are silent when a President is threatening to eliminate a civilization, then never talk to me again about how I have to vote Republican to be a good Christian. And spend at least half of the energy you use to go after David French to oppose what Trump is talking about doing. No more mealy-mouthed quiet complaints when someone is talking about genocide (and I do not use that term lightly as some of the left have done).
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
The saying "punch right and coddle left" recognizes a very real issue. Some Christian commentators treat conservatives with zero respect and assume the worst of them, while rarely, if ever, offering a cross word about progressives. If they critique progressive, they are very gentle about it. I agree that such commentators are hypocrites, and I take anything they say with a grain of salt.
But over the past few days, we have seen the opposite. We have seen the "punch left, coddle right" phenomenon. Yep. After Trump's blasphemous comments and his vulgar social media message, some conservative Christians are tiptoeing to offer the most inoffensive critique possible. They do this after spending much time and energy blasting Christians such as French, Moore, Prior, and Geear with everything they have. Such individuals have been called heretics, not real Christians, and have been subjected to dehumanizing insults. But even if one disagrees with them, none of them has approached the level of blasphemy offered by Trump.
But George. Trump is not a real Christian, so we cannot expect anything from him. We must be prophets against what is wrong in the Church. We cannot control the lost.
Oh, why are you letting his court Evangelicals like Jefferies off the hook? And if you want to have a prophetic voice, the prophets attacked non-Jewish nations and not just the Jews. Sorry, that does not fly.
So if you are just punch right and coddle left you are a hypocrite. But you are also a hypocrite if you punch left and coddle right. This is why I choose to punch right and left. This may leave me with fewer friends, but at least I have my integrity. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So this morning while my oldest was playing "music" I compliained to Drommie it was noise, that it had no soul and that I cannot understand the words. Then I realized that this is what older people said about my music when I was a teen and young adult. Yep. I have become what I used to mock.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I do get that there is an attraction towards partisanship. Although I understand the attraction, I will still resist partisanship.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQnOHskkOUY -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I hate it when I agree with Matt Walsh. But I do here
Matt Walsh
@MattWalshBlog
Trump fans are intellectual empty vessels ready to adopt whatever position Trump just took, and then abandon it as soon as he does.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Yes, Christians can be mistreated. However, there is a tendency to ignore that mistreatment when it does happen.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=vm5HjkHlC9o -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is a sad reading. Unfortunately, the source article is paywalled, so I cannot evaluate it. But if this article is correct, an important theory often used to explain the behavior of groups that social scientists criticize has been falsified. Man, no wonder sometimes people hate academics. It is corruption like this that can feed that hate.
christianscholars.com/when-the-book-about-when-prophecy-f… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
We can complain about the toxicity in social media, but if we keep following and supporting toxic content providers, then we only have ourselves to blame. Chrisians especially should ask hard questions about who we support. Is who we are following supportive of the fruits of the spirit or not? If they are not showing any of those fruits, or only one or two, then we should rethink retweeting and supporting such providers. And by the way, this is a bipartisan issue. I could name people on the left and right, but that will just make them defensive, and this post is about them. I want people to think about who they are following and decide if that person is exhibiting the fruits of the spirit. If you yell bothsidism on this, then you are missing the main point that this is about introspection, not blame shifting.
So are the people you are supporting with your likes and retweets exhibiting the fruits of the spirit? Feel free to use this guide to answer that question.
Love – Do they treat others as image bearers? Not just their allies but their enemies. Are they criticizing out of real love, hoping for change, or to dehumanize those they disagree with? Do they try to understand others or try to scapegoat them and strawman their opponents' arguments?
Joy – Does reading their posts increase joy or anger in your life? Do they ever attempt to help their supporters to seek out joy even in bad situations? Or do they use those situations to try to manipulate their supporters towards anger?
Peace – Does the presence of those you support increase peace in your life or the lives of others? How often do you read their comments and feel angry? Do they increase or decrease the turmoil in your soul? Do you think Christ desires you more to bear the sword or the olive branch? Which one do you think the content provider you support brings to our society?
Patience – Does your content provider exhibit patience in times that can be trying? Does he or she increase or decrease your ability to be patient with the Samaritans in your life? Does the content provider encourage you to treat those Samaritans in the same way that Jesus did?
Kindness – Are you more likely to be encouraged to be kind or cruel to others after reading the post of a content provider? Does reading this provider lead you to have more empathy with those you disagree with? Does reading this provider lead you to reduce others to dehumanizing stereotypes?
Goodness – If your content provider influences you to take any actions, perhaps as simple as commenting on his or her post or another post, would you say that these are the actions Jesus would do? If the answer is yes, what is the scriptural basis of your belief? Is there any possibility that you have developed that assessment to feel better about supporting the content provider? Is that goodness in keeping with the other fruits of the spirit?
Faithfulness – Do you feel empowered with more faith towards Christ or towards worldly power after reading the posts of your content provider? Does reading this person strengthen your faith and move you closer to Christ? Or does reading this person make you less willing ot put your faith in Christ and more willing to take situations into your own hands and solve them yourself?
Gentleness – Does this content provider lead you to be more gentle or coarser with other people? Does this provider stir up more compassion for others or more anger for others? After reading the posts of this provider, are you more likely to seek out ways to love other people or to complain about them?
Self-control – Does this content provider encourage you to be more disciplined in your life and walk with Christ? Does this provider encourage you to act and think recklessly in ways that may be harmful to others? Is the provider leading you to be rash and uncaring about how you hurt others, or does the provider encourage you to be deliberate and even tactful if you must confront the sins of others?
I think it is worth asking these questions on Palm Sunday. Are we truly being a blessing to our society, or are we feeding demons with hatefulness and rudeness in the way we consume social media? Just something to think about. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So when I posted the question a couple of days ago about whether men with a sordid past should be rejected just like women, almost everyone who answered said yes. Curious that the way this talk of keeping singles from pursuing others with a promiscuous past was only talking about men pursuing women with such a past. It is almost as if those making the argument were concerned about the fate of men but not so much the fate of women. No, that cannot be correct, can it? How cynical of me to have such thoughts. Right? Right?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
A kinda personal video about my period of doubt.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cw1AcQm5dYk -
George Yancey
@profyancey
My book on ID politics is out. I address that topic in this podcast.
podcasts.apple.com/ca/podcast/whats-wrong-with-identity-p… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So if Christian men should not marry Christian women with a sordid past, does that mean that Christian women should not marry Christian men with a sordid past? Inquiring minds want to know.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
What have you believed in the past that you now know you were wrong to believe? Is it not possible that there are things you believe today that you will discover in the future that you were wrong to believe?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=k0xY8_pzYpg -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have three sons. They are too young to be in serious romantic relationships now, but that day is rapidly approaching. If they were to decide they did not want to date women with a promiscuous past, that would be their decision to make. I would talk to them about their decision, limiting their choices, but otherwise I would honor it. However, if they did date a fine Christian woman with a promiscuous past and she showed by her attitudes and actions that she was committed to the Lord and my son, then I would welcome her into the family with open arms. Any concern I would have would stem from her current character, not her past sins. Just as I hope anyone who evaluates me does so based on my current state, not my past sins. Sins by the way that we all have, The fact that some are debating whether to treat redeemed people as redeemed is baffling to me.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Mark this day down because it may not happen again for a long time. But I am in full agreement this Basham on this. I mean I really do not understand the counter arguments. Either people are redeemed when they come to Christ and we treat them as such or they are not. I beleive that they are.
Megan Basham
@megbasham
I don’t really understand the people shaming this guy for sharing his and his wife’s testimony, provided she was OK with him sharing. He wasn’t specific, just shared how the Lord redeemed her and what a godly wife and mom she is today.
I’m gonna be honest, in a world in which we are constantly posting details about our lives, how Christ changed us is the most important information we can share.
The world needs to hear—I was just like you once, and God saved me from that. which means he can save you too! Why wouldn’t we want to tell people that story? -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Ah. Yea!!!!!!!!
Justin Giboney
@JustinEGiboney
Conservatives aren’t necessarily wrong abt James Talarico. His faith doesn’t challenge any element of the secular progressive social agenda. That’s wrong and seems like a political gimmick.
The problem is they’ve lost credibility by failing to apply a biblical standard to Trump. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Unfortunately, too often we want God to be on our side rather than consider whether we are on God's side.
youtu.be/wWVZzlQ-65M -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I was listening to a psychologist who said that there is research showing that when people feel chemistry, not just physical attraction, it usually becomes apparent that there is a lot of genetic distinction between the man and the woman. They even had women smell shirts men were wearing, and the women were drawn to men who were most genetically different from them. The reason they think this is true is that the genetic diversity helps create individuals with more evolutionary advantages.
That got me thinking. What couples are most likely to be genetically distinct? Well, that would be interracial couples. I am interracially married, and my kids seem to be genetically superior to me. If genetic diversity is important, then our society has been wasting a great opportunity to have healthier people because of our history of miscegenation.
I am not writing this to tell people that they have to interracially date or marry. Date or marry who you click with and find attractive. If it is the same race then cool. I not then cool. Unfortuantley some voices have cropped up among some conservartive Christians challenging the wisdom of interracial marriages. Not only are such challenges totally unfounded Biblically, but now we can see that they do not make sense from a scientific perspective as well. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Yesterday, we lost a giant. Many of you may not have heard of John Perkins. I hope to live a life at least half as meaningful as he lived. Despite the horrible racism he faced in life, he became an inspiration towards meaningful racial reconciliation without hesitation to challenge all of us. I only met with him briefly, and I am honored to have done so. If you do not know much about Perkins, I encourage you to look up what he did in his life, and may he continue to provide the vision and direction we need in this society.
religionnews.com/2026/03/13/john-perkins-obituary/ -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Dads be dads.
Better Men
@Better_men
Boys will be boys
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Why I rarely use Christian Nationalism to describe conservative Christians.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=i31kRbAPsFI -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Why do Democrats stick with transgender politics even though it is a big loser for them? I rarely talk about that issue, but here I am giving one potential answer to that question.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=47TbK6TaWeA -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The hypocritical thing about people complaining about separatism and the black church is that it is not easy to find comments from whites stating that they want their kids to marry whites. Yet they receive no pushback from the people complaining about a black church conference that they do not understand. Did not Jesus say something about speck and boulder in the eye?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some say that Christians have to support Republicans. I say...
www.youtube.com/watch?v=JbdPJ3mG9Yc -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This sort of comment displays a tremendous lack of knowledge about what the black church is. I am no longer attending black churches as I now thrive in multiracial settings. But I have a deep appreciation of the black church and its place in our society and Christian culture.
The black church developed as a reaction to the rejection of blacks from white churches and as a way for blacks to organize to resist racism. It still plays a role in channeling the black voice, although now many non-Christian organizations are prominent in playing that role.
But if the question is an honest one, I can say that even as I was growing up, there were whites in black churches - often the spouses of blacks. And they were always well accepted. The vast majority of black churches (one can find an exception for everything) are not instruments of separation but attempts to create inclusion of blacks into the larger society.
If whites want to attend conferences like this to create trouble, then yes, they will be shown the door. This is true with any gathering, regardless of the race of the organizers. But if whites want to understand why black Christians feel the way they do and the issues they are confronted with, then I know that they will find the vast majority of these conferences not only welcoming but also enlightening.
Megan Basham
@megbasham
.@Lifeway real question, I am not black, but I am an SBC church member and this announcement says black church members welcome. Will I be welcome at this conference?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
If you are happy about, and deeply value, having kids and grandkids who look like you, then you cannot be happy if they interracially marry. I am interracially married, and in key ways, my boys do not look like me. And that is a good thing because they are better looking than me.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am shocked (well not really) to find out that I do not look like Wolfe and thus am not wanted by him to be in this country.
Napp Nazworth
@NappNazworth
Wolfe saying the quiet part out loud. Immigration enforcement isn't about "people need to follow the law," it's about getting rid of people who "don't look like me." This is racist, xenophobic, and not Christian.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
As an African-American, when I see an organization that has no blacks in the leadership, I assume that the voices of people like me will not be heard. It is understandable that I feel that way. Given that, it should not be surprising that Evangelicals feel their voices are not heard in a number of elite cultural organizations. Is it the fault of evangelicals that this is the way it is? There has been a hesitancy among evangelicals to enter those organizations, and that is on us. But some of that hesitancy comes from the discrimination and prejudice of some of the organization's gatekeepers. I have done the research to know this is true in academia, and I suspect it is true in other organizations that create and maintain culture. The author points out two key reasons why this is a problem, and I largely agree with the author. First, as I alluded to, there is going to be a lack of trust of evangelicals towards the organizations that exclude them. I believe this makes them more susceptible to unhealthy political activism and a desire to wall themselves off from society. Second, I do think evangelicals bring insight that will benefit a multicultural society. Evangelicals do not have all of the answers, but we do have some answers that are being ignored. I think society is poorer because those answers cannot be put out there for reasonable debate.
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/03/06/evangelicals-c… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Antiracism can be a source of meaning and purpose.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=27rh8bnkBeI -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Social exchange theory and the Bible.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=vI1sWejc7EY -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some of you know that I am connected with Prohuman Foundation, which is the program set up by Daryl Davis, a black musician who has persuaded at least 300 men to leave white supremacist organizations. They are setting up an ambassador program to teach prohuman ideals to busy professionals. If David inspires you and you're interested in this program, here is the application. Feel free to DM me if you have any questions.
docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSfVFrlmQ97lYNkIFsgQAyZUc… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Number 1 - pray for our youth!!! Number 2 - do not give smartphones to your kids until absolutely necessary!!!
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
Major new report on global trends in mental health, out today from Sapien Labs. Data from 2.5 million people across 85 countries.
Some of the most important findings:
1) Young adults used to generally have good mental health, compared to older generations. But now, in ALL countries examined, they are doing badly compared to older generations in that country.
2) "Four key factors have emerged that together predict three quarters of this effect. These are diminished
family bonds, diminished spirituality, smartphones at increasingly young age, and increasing consumption of
ultra-processed food."
3) The decline of young people's mental health is "most pronounced in the wealthier and more developed countries." They note that it is in such countries that smartphones are given earliest, junk food is most heavily consumed, spirituality is most diminished, and family ties are looser and often weaker.
4) "A younger age of first smartphone ownership is associated with increased suicidal thoughts,
aggression, and other problems in adulthood."
5) Here is their summary of findings on early smartphone ownership:
"GenZ is the first generation to grow up with a smartphone. Among this group, the younger they acquired their first smartphone in childhood, the more likely they are to have struggles as adults. These struggles extend beyond sadness and anxiety to less discussed symptoms, such as a sense of being detached from reality, suicidal thoughts, and aggression towards others. The effects arise through disruption of sleep, increased risk of exposure to harmful online content, predators, and explicit material as well as increased probabilities of cyberbullying during crucial developmental years. Excessive time spent on smartphones also diminishes the development of social cognition that requires learned interpretation of facial expressions, body language, and group dynamics. The negative impacts are particularly sharp below age 13."
The report is short, accessible, and important. Read it here:
sapienlabs.org/global-mind-health-report/ -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Here is the thing about the SAVE act. Research shows that there is neither widespead voter fraud or voter suppression. This is just another issue that the Ds and Rs fight over that has no real impact on our lives. In other words, it is just a waste of time.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
What the story of the Rich Young Ruler says about our efforts to be rational
www.youtube.com/watch?v=wPbgcNhbQd0 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Partisan politics can absolutely lead you to violate your values.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=eZD2rTc68o8 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Insane!!!
Fastbreak Hoops
@FastbreakHoops5
This might be the wildest 18 seconds of basketball I’ve ever seen 😳
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
In the story of the woman caught in adultery, I try to identify the strengths and weaknesses of feminism.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ZETLmZJmyc -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Whether it is Talarico or some MAGA politician, always beware of the Christian poltician that can never find a disagreement with any of his party's political position and what he or she thinks God wants. Be aware of the lack of introspection that comes from such a stance.
Erick Erickson
@EWErickson
The thing is, on both sides of the aisle, if you embrace a Christianity that doesn't challenge your political views and cultural views, you've probably embraced an idol. It's remarkable how Talarico's faith affirms everything he believes in.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
James Talarico is running as a serious Christian. Here are some of my comments on that.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=MXbWWbPyyhQ -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Until cultural institutions that defy Trump engage in the right type of introspection, then the conditions that have allowed Trump will continue to persist.
musaalgharbi.substack.com/p/trump-changes-nothing -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I must say this is brilliant from Cleese
James Lindsay, anti-Communist
@ConceptualJames
Recorded back in the 1960s, John Cleese (of Monty Python fame) made an excellent satirical commentary exposing the friend-enemy distinction as being at the heart of both far-left and rar-right extremism, inter alia, including its psychological appeal.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Newflash: When I assess whether a person would be a good Christian moral leader, I do not just look at his or her teaching or political platform. I also look to see if the fruits of the spirit are part of his/her life. Patience, kindness, gentleness, and such. I cannot always get to know someone well enough to know whether those qualities are present in their life. But often, I can determine from their social media posts that those qualities are missing in their lives. I suspect that many of the person's supporters also note this absence but just do not care as long as the person supports the right ideals. That is part of why we are so polarized as a Church and unable to aid a polarized society.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Tebow was a fantastic college QB and a below average NFL QB. But more importantly he is a wonderful human being.
Tim Tebow Foundation
@tebowfoundation
Until all are celebrated, until all are loved, and until all know their true identity as God's royalty. #nighttoshine
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
There has been a lot of talk about AWFULs, which stands for Affluent White Female Urban Liberals. Six months ago, I made a video comparing progressive women and progressive men. This is preliminary, but I am not seeing a difference between women and men. Maybe a difference would emerge with more in-depth analysis, but it is not there now. I personally do not like targeting a group (like we do with perjoritives such as Karen or AWFUL) and to judge terrible actions from an individual woman on its own right. But my own personal proclivities are reinforced by honest analysis on the subject.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=jy6HHVP9Mds&list=PL-S_MLxHNzaAw7v… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
How the story of Moses teaches us about Group Threat theory.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZVa6obb4ul0 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I ask, and try to answer, the question of why white progressives are so prominent at protests
www.youtube.com/watch?v=-uQiOi5Vgnk -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Okay. Here are my Super Bowl takes.
1. I hate the Pats even though they no longer have Brady and Belichick. It is not logical and I cannot explain it. But I still did not want them to win the SB. So I am happy with the outcome of the game.
2. Concerning the game, that Seahawks defense was something else. Totally destroying the Pats' offence until the second half of the fourth quarter. If it had not been for that short period of time when the Pats ' offense finally got going, we could put the Hawks defense on the same plane as the '86 Bears and the 01 Ravens as the greatest Super Bowl defenses. They fall just short of that, but still very impressive.
3. As promised, I skipped the halftime show. I am there to watch big ugly men knock the stuffings out of each other not listen to pop music. I will ignore the MAGA vs. woke argument of the halftime show. If you enjoyed the show you watched, then good for you. I enjoyed not being subjected to either show.
4. Is it me, or did the commercial seem to rely less on comedy and more on sentimental emotionality? Not exactly my cup of tea, but when you spend so much money on commercials, I guess you get what you want.
5. Finally, I cannot remember the last time I watched the game at a Super Bowl party. I think it is due to having kids. Having kids has not only made me less of a fan of the NFL, but I also spend Super Bowl Sunday with my family rather than at a party. Once the boys are old enough that they are embarrassed to be seen with me, will I get my social life and access to Super Bowl parties back? -
George Yancey
@profyancey
One irony of the Trump ape situation is that some Christians argue that those of us who are bothered only critique Christians on the right. I know that is not true for me and for many of the others who are disturbed by the racist image. I have many times criticized what is done on the left. I do not punch right and coddle left. I punch right and left. But here is what gets me about these statements. Oftentimes, they are coming from those who almost never complain about the right. Indeed, often I see these statements being used so that this person can avoid calling out those racist images. In those cases, are not the people making the statements of letting political allies off the hook, doing the exact same thing they are complaining about?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
If someone wants to defend the ape photo by saying it was a mistake, check whether they condemned it earlier in the day. If they did not at least say something like "If this is true, then this is horrible," then chances are they were waiting until they could get an explanation from the White House so that they could blow off this little piece of racism. Be very slow to trust such people.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I found in Signaling theory some insight into the sociological process that led to Jesus's crucification.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=-PJu2QMefh8 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
A brief comparison of Anti-Semitism and Christianophobia reveals an interesting finding.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=jB4jy_x47LA -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Well, I never had Christians coming out as enemies of empathy on my dance card, but here we are.
George Yancey
@profyancey
By the way folks. Those coming in to criticize me but do not have their real name get blocked. If you do not have the courage to use your real name then I not only do not take your criticism seriously but I block you from interacting again. Cowards do not get to keep commenting. I wish more people would block Anon accounts that like to troll.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some ideas about critical theory and the Bible.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=GszXyYR07-o -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Rather than make a post about Minneapolis, which is likely to be incomplete and without nuance, I decided to do a 20-minute video. At the very end when I offer potential solutions.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=WIs7bPZM0aw -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is true and I have become very wary of those who reflectively defend their tribe no matter what.
Dr. Maliek Blade
@MaliekBlade
If unity is truly the goal, you can’t reflexively defend your side whenever it’s criticized. Dismissing every critique fuels tribalism. Listening, understanding, and owning failures where they exist is how unity is built.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have not made a full statement on the mess in Minneapolis. As I consider if and what sort of statement that would be I find this to be the best video I have seen on that subject.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=fD1dIcequII -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is why I do not jump in on every public controvery as soon as it happens. You take a side and then you have to do everything you can to make your original opinion stick no matter what additional evidence comes into play.
Neil Shenvi
@NeilShenvi
When something sensational happens, wait until all the facts are available before passing judgment.
That way, as new evidence begins to emerge, your brain will not start twisting itself into knots trying to justify your initial hot take. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The protestors invading the church tried to use power to pressure people support their anti-ICE cause. They would have been better off using moral suasion.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rxy5uEt0OT8 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I think a lot of what people say is Christian Nationalism is really a conservative form of identity politics. Here are some of the reasons why I say this.
www.christianitytoday.com/2026/01/its-not-christian-natio… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So when I listen to the bullies who decided to invade the church in Minneapolis, I heard that one of the chants was "We must win." This is the crux of why identity politics is so dangerous. When we frame things in terms of oppressor versus the oppressed, then losing or compromising is not seen as an option. Winning must be achieved at all costs. Even taking away the rights of people to worship as they pleased must be removed. That is the mentality that went into the madness that happened at that church. And if you are going to run over here to defend that invasion, let me remind you that even if you do not want to recognize the immorality of what took place, what comes around goes around. If you demand that people have to adhere to your particular political viewpoint, then do not be surprised if, in the future, a bunch of good ol' boys decide to break up worship at the Unitarian church or Mosques.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Is Christianophobia declining in the Trump years? Well, kinda, but Christians need to be careful about how they handle this period. They could set themselves up for long-term problems if they don't.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=iF6czI-BwO8 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
As a young academic, I decided to read King's original writings, not just about them. One thing that gets so little attention was King talking about the cost of racism on whites and his concern for the souls of whites. Yes, the major motivation of his movement was the horror that racism had visited upon blacks. But he showed genuine concern about how racial hatred ate at whites. His movement was not an identity politics movement that … See more
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
It is rather depressing to see under my Today's News the title "Christian Debate Questions Interracial Marriage and God's Design"
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I think Jesus' parable of the workers fits very well in the sociological theory of rising expectations. That theory is useful in helping us find contentment.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=xS9J-wDLMU0 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
No and no. But then again I do not live in DC.
Tim Carney
@TPCarney
1) Can men get pregnant?
2) Did Trump win the 2020 election?
There are like 8 people in Washington who can correctly answer both questions. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
More and more, I realize that identity politics is opposed to my basic values and what I want to see in society.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=bbhlMeTT0IE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So, if I understand correctly, there are people admitting that interracial marriage is not sinful, but it is not ideal. One reason given is that historically, Christians have been against it, and we should respect their perspective. I think that is silly, but whatever. Another reason is that it is harder because we are bringing together different cultures. Newsflash. All marriages bring together people from different cultures, unless you marry your sister, which brings up a lot more problems. I am not saying that everything in the past is evil and that some recent changes in our society do not have their problems. But one thing we definitely should not want to bring back from the past is an acceptance of antimiscegenation. As a victim of that antimiscegenation in my younger years, let's just leave that bit of dysfunction in the past, shall we?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Really? Today we are having this discussion among Christians. So much damage has been done in the name of antimisgenation and we are still debating about this. I though that even in the most fundamentalist circles of Christian culture we had dispensed with this nonesense. So sad to see that I was wrong.
Samuel Sey
@SlowToWrite
This is my latest article (a response to @JoelWebbon):
"People who celebrate what God condemns and those who condemn what God celebrates are both abominations to God."
Is My “Interracial” Marriage Against God’s Design?
[link: slowtowrite.com/is-my-interracial-marriage-against-gods-d…] -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This right here. And it is not only conservatives where this is a problem. People hate to put their ideas up for critque out of fear that they may be wrong. Thus they rather be wrong and keep myths in their thoughts rather than explore whether they are wrong. I will admit that there are times when I am scared I am wrong and been hesitant to hear others out. But I remember that I do not want to live in ignorance and thus have to get my ideas out there.
Neil Shenvi
@NeilShenvi
I can't shake the story Danny Akin told Sean Demars:
A pastor friend told Akin that some of his congregants were convinced Akin was progressive. Akin said "why don't I come talk to them? I'll buy them lunch and I'll address their concerns."
The pastor replied 1/ -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Solid advice right here.
Justin Giboney
@JustinEGiboney
In re to #minneapolis, don’t trust any influencer who never admits when their side is in the wrong.
Form your opinion based on info from those who are intellectually honest.
Conflict entrepreneurs make their money by exploiting tragedies and spinning facts. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
How could Jesus equate hate with murder? I discuss how theories of symbolic interactionism can shine light on that topic.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=qEsztzKj1aE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
If this is true then it will be a huge game changer in conducting research.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Statistical software is going to become obsolete very soon. Instead, you’ll be able to have AI systems like @Grok run complex statistical analyses for you and directly output the results and show its work.
These systems will also help determine which statistical tests are appropriate for your data and hypotheses simply by uploading a spreadsheet and explaining your research question and experimental design in plain language. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The idea that religion is going away is not as sound as people say it is. Here I present my reason why this is the case.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=jWIArDoV4VY -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I think one of the biggest contributions the social sciences have made to our understanding of human nature if the notion of confirmation bias. I also believe that the story of the log in our eye is a fantastic way that Jesus brings this concept to us.
ttps://youtu.be/vCKUzvq2d6Q
George Yancey
@profyancey
Sorry but I put a bad link up there.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=vCKUzvq2d6Q -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Coming March 24
www.routledge.com/Identity-Politics-in-the-United-States-… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is why I do not jump into the ID politics debate on one side or the other. Research I have read shows that requiring ID or not is largely irrelevant on issues of access or fraud. So why waste my time on it?
Stephen Richer
@stephen_richer
1) ID has only a negligible impact on voter access. It has been studied.
2) ID has virtually zero impact on voter fraud. It has been studied.
3) we don’t have a federal ID.
4) most people aren’t even on the same page when we say ID. Do we mean photo ID? Or any form of ID (eg signature)? Do we only mean ID at voting or ID at registration?
5) almost all states require identification when registering.
6) most states require identification of some form to vote.
7) I broadly support ID, but this conversation is mostly a social media and fundraising talking point that is blown out of proportion by all sides.
8) in many ways, it represents the worst of political influence groups. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am seeing similar posts more and more. I do not think it is the own that the posters think that it is. To me it reinforces something that I have been observing that for better or worse, the Republicans are becoming the party of the worker or eveyman while the Democrats are becoming the party of the elite. That probably is not the message that people putting up such post want to send but it is the one I am seeing.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
The notion of the Church as a Body is very similar to the sociological theory of functionalism and there are lessons to be learned from this theory.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=KyVzz_W537U -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Merry Christmas everybody!!
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
As a Christian in academia, I know there are challenges. So I did this video to offer advice for Christian graduate students. Feel free to pass it on to any that you think might benefit from this video.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=vgFafNIJauM -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I am in the final stages of copy editing on my forthcoming book on Identity Politics to be published by Routledge. I look at antiracists and conservative Christians as venues of identity politics to allow me to assess the problems and temptations of this approach, regardless of political ideology. It occurs to me how unique I am to be in this position to make this argument. As an African-American race scholar who has probably published more on Christianophobia than any other scholar, I think that both the antiracists and conservative Christians have valid concerns. But the technique of identity politics and the dysfunctions inherent in that approach deepen polarization in our society and make it harder to find solutions validated by those outside their political sphere.
This is likely to put me in a position to be opposed by those doing work in racial and Christian spaces who are addressing issues I care about, as I hope they will find workable solutions for those issues. Identity politics is simply not the right way to find those solutions.
I will post the book's publication date when I have it. Have a Merry Christmas everyone. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Man, football Twitter was wild last night. After the first 20 minutes of the Alabama-Oklahoma game, there were a lot of people talking about how Alabama did not belong as the Sooners were up 17-0. Then all of those posts aged very badly when the Tide made their comeback. I am a Horn fan with no side to take on this, but it was amusing to watch.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Okay Megan. Here is my reply. I am afraid it is long because I wanted to be thorough on the issues at hand. Thanks for giving me the space to do my own assessment. And I will start with an agreement with you. It is clear that Guidestone did not interview Sills. And I see that as a huge mistake. I greatly want to address sexual abuse in the SBC church. But as an African-American man, I know more than most about the reality of false accusations. I am a big believer in due process for everyone, whether I like them or not. And we will not be able to get everyone to commit to the process of getting rid of abuse if they can rightly feel the process is unfair. So we are in agreement that Guidepost should have interviewed Sills.
I have not dived into the evidence Guidepost has gathered, and to be frank, I do not have the time and energy to do so. So, I will remain uncommitted to whether those sexual encounters are consensual or abusive. But what I would like Guidepost to have done is invite him to an interview and lay out the evidence they have before him to ask for a response. They are not the police, so they cannot compel him to do that, but the choice should have been offered.
However, my doubt was your claim that no one else wanted to interview Sills, except you. That is not correct. I located Bob Smietana, who wrote on this subject, and asked him whether he sought to interview Sills. He did and indeed told me that you have one of his emails of such a request. Nevertheless, at least one of those emails was found in discovery, and he sent it to me. I have attached a link to it here. To be certain, the timelines are not completely clear, but he was seeking to interview Sill at least around the same time as you were. So it was not that Sill had no outlets but you to tell his story. He wanted a sympathetic outlet, which you provided him, and that is his right. But my instinct that you were not the only one who allowed him to tell his side of the story has been reaffirmed. One day, I may slander you in a way that requires an apology. Today is not that day.
drive.google.com/file/d/1j3fAQ6D5h_FGcvxbDCpVYFPG1xPnKSB-…
But at the end of the day, this is a distraction. The real question is, when do we need to get both sides of a story? You claim that because you were looking at public speeches of Greear that you did not need to do that. If your book had merely been a complaint about bad preaching or bad ideas in that preaching they you would have a solid point. But that is not the goal of your book. You laid out the goal by stating that “My ultimate purpose is to confirm for average evangelicals in the pews that the uneasy feelings many of you have been having (perhaps for some years now) that your pulpits and your institutions are being co-opted by political forces with explicitly secular progressive aims are justified.”
So, your book alleges that people like Greear were motivated, at least in part, by progressive groups pouring money and influence into their organizations. You do not discover such motivations through public speeches. Like Guidestone should have done, you should have presented your evidence to them and asked for an explanation. I use @jdgreear because he publicly stated that you did not ask him about this, and so I knew that was the case. I strongly suspected, but did not include in my book, because I had no such statement, that this is likely also the case with @KSPrior, @BethMooreLPM, @drmoore, @DavidAFrench, or the others you have criticized.
Going back to the Sill example, if I were in charge of the seminary, I would have fired him for sexual violation of his vows regardless of whether it was consensual or not. You may think that harsh, but I do not. A Christian leader needs to step away and get help rather than keep a leadership role if he is sexually involved with anyone but his wife. His sexual infidelity is not debated, and so I would not need to interview him to get at whether I would have fired him. Any evidence of sexual abuse, I would have turned over Guidepost with the instructions to eventually turn it over to the police. Evidence of abuse that would require further investigation which Guidepost should have offered Sills the opportunity to defend himself. Likewise, if you think that Greear’s preaching on homosexuality is too weak or that he is not political enough and want to criticize him about that, then his public statements are all you need to make your case. When you accuse him and others of being influenced by progressive interests, that is not something you can get from public statements, unless you have one from him admitting that fact, which I did not see. But if you interviewed him, you could have pressed him and made a more convincing case than the speculation about motivation I found in your book.
The way I look at it is this. If all I am going to do is fire Sills because of his sexual unfaithfulness, then there is no need to interview him. His infidelity is now public knowledge. When the claim of coercion comes up, and he denies it, then yes, there is a need for an investigation, and the target of the investigation should have the evidence laid out so that he has a chance to defend himself. Likewise, if you think Greear’s statements are off and write a book about bad preaching, then, while I think interviews would be good for clarification, they are not necessary. But when the premise of the book is that Greear and others have been compromised by progressive interests, I cannot see how that claim can be taken seriously, given at best circumstantial evidence.
You say these are two distinct situations. Of course, no two situations will be exactly equal. In the case of Sills, he is being accused of a crime, and Greear is not. But often people hide behind the differences to be nuanced when it comes to their allies and dichotomous when it comes to their perceived enemies. But if the core elements are the same, then one should expect similar treatment. At the core, accusations have been launched at Sills and Greear. There is evidence to support the accusations, but it is not conclusive. I know it is not conclusive, as it concerns your accusations towards Greear, having read your book. You do not have a solid causal case that progressive influences have led to what you term progressive teaching. Since I have not read all the evidence on Sills and am operating in good faith, I will assume that the evidence against him is not conclusive either. Thus, it is warranted to interview the accused parties, lay out the evidence, and have them answer that evidence. If they cannot supply sufficient answers, that would greatly strengthen the case and be a solid way to show the connections you claim to be making. These core elements are the same in both cases, and the differences you are claiming are not as great as you have made them out to be. Thus, I stand by my assessment that you are treating Greear differently due to not liking him in comparison to your willingness to support Sills.
Megan Basham
@megbasham
And I don’t know what you mean by “another assertion I have gotten incorrect.” But I’ll standby for you to look into it.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I love the parable of the good Samaritan. I had to do a YouTube on it.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=-kIIfWsYUM8 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I do not have a hot take on the Bassham/Sills/Lyell controversy. I know that I referenced in my forthcoming book on identity politics how Bassham treated the accusations against Sills with more nuance than she does of the accusations against Greear. The fact that she attempted to get Sill's side of the story was something she did not do before attacking Greear. I used that as a reminder that identity politics leads people to create double standards for those defined as oppressors or heretics and their in-group. Learning more details to fill in the details of this controversy has been interesting and given me more context of my assessment of Bassham's actions.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
A lot of the comments to this post sickens me as they would sicken any right thinking Christian. But I do not blame the posters as much as I blame certian conservarive Christian leaders who spend all their time going after the "woke" that they have ignored the rot growing in their midst. Garbage like NETTR and Christian identity politics have created this type of sewer. I say to such leaders, go ahead and criticize the left as you see fit. I do. But go not turn your back on the disease you are allowing to fester in your congregations and among your followers. One day your neglect will reach a point that you will no longer be able to control this beast and it will control you.
Neil Shenvi
@NeilShenvi
It's still not too late to make a break with the "Dissident Right."
The open racism, anti-Semitism, and misogyny will only get worse.
And it will harden you. Look at your own trajectory. You now shrug off stuff that once horrified you. That's where you're headed. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Neither one of the major political parties is what we need in our society. Both have lost their way.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=oLxFngobHqs -
George Yancey
@profyancey
You would think that after seeing so many liberals rightly blasted for mocking Kirk's death, our president would have the sense to just say, "It was sad what happened to Reiner last night. May he and his wife rest in peace." You would think that right? You would be wrong.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I got to do a fun podcast with the folks from Faithful Politics. They, like I, do not believe that Jesus is a Republican or a Democrat. Imagine that
www.youtube.com/watch?v=0FPcVF89u3Q -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Does social identity theory help us to understand Gal 3:28. I think it does.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=E2R6DPx8nt4 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Good to see that my latest video is getting some attention.
brianroden.substack.com/p/on-faulty-generalizations -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The woman at the well is one of the most beautiful stories in the Bible. I believe an application of labeling theory makes the story even more powerful.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=w1FC3HU6L8c -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I will address issues of free speech and academic freedom, whether the attacks come from the left or the right.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=JsRV4XFMzvE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Generally those in Human Services are on the left. If they are making this kind of a statement, then I am inclined to believe that there are serous problems in Minnesota.
Minnesota Staff Fraud Reporting Commentary
@Minnesota_DHS
We are overwhelmed by the interest the nation has shown in the fraud occurring in Minnesota. Population wise, we are small but health and human services fraud in our state exceeds that of much larger states like California, New York, Texas & others.
While Tim Walz makes all manner of incorrect statements about Minnesota leading in one way or other, what we really lead in is failed governance. Tim Walz has turned Minnesota into a failed state with deteriorating infrastructure, education and economic metrics, and worst of all, we are failing our most vulnerable citizens by letting cripple state services.
For many years, we reached out to every source available to us to get attention on and help stop fraud. We were lucky to get the Office of the Legislative Auditor, Fraud Committee, certain news outlets and many fine politicians to help shed light on the matter.
Unfortunately, only one DFL member showed interest in fraud - John Hoffman. Contrary to popular belief, we aren’t a political group. But we’ve been continually disappointed in the response we got by the DFL, or lack there of. We hoped for partnership with all political parties but instead, the DFL discredited our reports and pleas. Is protecting your political party or clinging onto power really worth destroying your state?
Many thanks to those who’ve supported us over the years. It’s been an uphill battle that has been uncertain, isolating but one that we aren’t giving up on. We hope that Minnesota will be freed from fraud, good governance is restored and trust in government is rebuilt.
The next step now is to bring in external auditors and new leadership.
Tim Walz has failed Minnesota. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Thanksgiving is over. Let the Christmas music commence.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am starting a new playlist on the social sciences and scripture. Here is my first entry. I plan on doing one a week for at least the next 14 weeks. Hope some of you find this enjoyable.
youtu.be/nlMH9gKj8_8 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am not opposed to Christians doing politics. But I am opposed to letting our politics distort the gospel.
youtu.be/cB2F-u8YCxs -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Why is the world not paying attention to the horror in Nigeria? I offer three uncomfortable reasons why this is the case.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=EnBOUlu7wRI -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Just to note that in my forthcoming book, I test a defintion of CN given by one of the academics who has pushed this agenda against a defintion of conservative ID politics with a bunch of Trump supporting conservative Christians. In their perspective, then identity political defintons was by far a better way to conceptualize what they believe. Even the academics who promote the use of CN cannot use the concept in a way that those who supposedly are Christian nationalist will accept as accurate to what they believe. I think that the sooner we move away from using this concept and rely on conservative identity politics to understand Christian political activism, the closer we will get to the truth.
Lyman Stone 石來民 🦬🦬🦬
@lymanstoneky
Note that the academic literature actually also supports the idea that Christian nationalism is not a valid survey construct! The survey items usually used for it turn out to fail a lot of typical tests of item validity!
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
There has been the emergence of the ugly form of overt racism among some in the Christian right. Perhaps such individuals feel emboldened with a Trump presidency. No matter, it is a stain that must be washed.
Unfortunately, one of the things that has made this racism possible is the overuse of terms such as white supremacy and racism. Those terms have been used to denote those who choose to ignore the plight of people of color, but do not hate them. So now it is harder to use them against those with real racial hostility.
I imagine someone who thinks that people of color make too much of a deal about racism but has no hatred, has no problem with the daughter bringing home a black guy, and cheers for blacks in movies like "Mississippi Burning." Calling that person racist will eventually cheapen the term when we need it against those promoting real Christian Nationalism and white supremacy.
This is not to say that some of the conservative Christians who promoted stupidity like NETTR do not bear some of the blame for their movement being infiltrated by real racists. If they keep pretending that the only problems are found on the left then naturally there is going to be an open door to unsavory nonleftists. Some gatekeeping matters are needed if they want their movement to be free of racism.
Those who use racism and white supremacy too liberally will note that, in some ways, those who are not overtly racist but dismiss the interests of people of color are more troublesome than overt racists. They have a degree of legitimacy that overt racists lack. That is a fair argument to make. But the two groups are different and they need different remedies. Trying to apply shame and stigma to those without real racial hatred is generally not going to be appropriate in ways it will be for those with racial animosity.
Here is how I handle this situation. I rarely used the terms racist or white supremacy unless it deals with racial animosity. Instead I talk about a racialized society where our race still matters in life changes, attitudes and opportunities. That opens up the conversation into how we can deal with institutional and the effects of historical racism without an attempt to use stigma to control the discussion. In speaking to many white conservatives I have found this approach to be very useful. If you think it might be useful then feel free to steal it from me. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
How do we break the vicious racial cycle?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZZFeosu7q6g -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Okay. This is going to get me into trouble.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=utJ-NpvnIow -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I think a major way both the Democrats and the Republicans are broken is due to hate. The placation of hate is creating a non-trivial subset in both parties that is destroying these parties. It is not too late to correct this, but only through intentional effort.
Fuentes did not happen in a vacuum. I warned Republicans since 2016 about the race-baiting of Trump. But I was told that I focused too much on race. I am not saying that Trump is an overt racist, but he placated racism. This provided a permission structure by which someone like Fuentes could emerge. Once that permission structure was in place those with vile racist and antisemite attitudes felt more confident to come out with their vision of a white only country. I see some racist filth launched against immigrants, and it is shameful. Unfortunately, those comments are all over Twitter, and sadly, many of those making these comments say they are Christians. Such individuals existed before Trump, but now they feel empowered. They are poisoning the Republican party. I know there is pushback to Fuentes right now, but if the Republicans do not deal with the way they have fomented hatred, then another will simply rise up to take his place.
I think before Trump, progressives had a generalized hatred of those with more traditional values, considering them to be racist, sexist, and homophobic. However, Trump gave them a personalized target for that hate. The election of Jay Jones as the Virginia AG also did not happen in a vacuum. The dehumanization of MAGA and conservatives makes it easy to elect someone who fantasizes about the death of conservative children. That hatred also explains why so many progressives celebrated the assassination of Kirk. Jennifer Welch is a progressive influencer who says that the Democrat party should cater to those who celebrate Kirk’s death, and she has a following. And unlike the pushback against Fuentes, I see no pushback in progressive corners against her vile attitudes. There is a placating of hatred among the left that accepts violence against conservatives, and it will not go away if those on the left ignore it.
In a sense, Trump is at the center of the placating of hatred on the left and the right. However, that does not absolve those who contribute to that hate. On judgment day, those conservatives who used Trump's race-baiting to deepen their hatred of people of color, specifically, and the left generally, will have to answer for that hatred. Likewise, progressives who use the actions of Trump to support attitudes of violence and dehumanization of conservatives will need to explain themselves on judgment day as well. To avoid misunderstanding, we are each responsible for how we deal with hatred within ourselves and whether we challenge it among our political allies. We will never know how the world might have been different if Trump had not come upon the political scene. Maybe we are destined to move towards this polarization with or without Trump. But I do see him as a major catalyst for the breaking of both the Republican and Democratic Parties. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I try to apply some classic sociological theory to the Kirks and Turning Point. Check it out.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=v-FAs9sU9lw -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Concerning Fuentes, this is where NETTR gets you. If this is the path you want to go down, then by all means continue that philosophy.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Democrats. Your party is broken. And before you go "but Trump," yeah, the Republicans are broken too. But when people point out how the Democrats are broken, you yell "bothsidism." Do not go there. The Republicans addressed their Roy Moore problem in Alabama. You had the opportunity to address the Jones issue in Virginia. And you didn't.
You voted for a man to be your chief law enforcement officer who joked about giving his political opponent two bullets and having his wife watch her kids die in her arms. Pretty awful stuff, right? I guess not enough to put him into office. Tell me what if a Republican politician is assaulted or killed in Virginia. Would any reasonable person think that Jones will prosecute the case thoroughly? Is there any reason to think that Jones will not use his political power to go after his political enemies? He is okay with their children dying, so why not put them in jail? The Democratic Party is broken.
But that is just Virginia, right? How can I say that the party is broken? Did any national or state official call for Jones to leave the race? Not to my knowledge. The Democratic Party owns Jones. The Democratic Party is broken.
This has not happened in a vacuum. Remember that some Democrats celebrated the death of Kirk. Recent surveys indicate that there may be an assassination mentality among progressives. Tonight is just the icing on this cake. The Democratic Party is broken.
You can come and yell at me and tell me how wrong you are. Alternatively, you can engage in introspection and determine what went wrong. Trump broke the Republican party, and now I am convinced that he broke you, too. If you come to chastise me, just know I will ask you how you can continue to support a party that elects a man you joke about killing the kids of his political opponents. Alternatively, you can consider how to improve your party. Because the Democratic Party is broken, -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Recently, there was an article arguing that viewpoint diversity is a MAGA plot. It is not. Instead, it is an essential tool for conducting science properly. And we in academia had better defend it, or others who do not have our best interest will defend it in ways we do not like.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is truth as well as vice-versa.
Neil Shenvi
@NeilShenvi
The more you speak out against the sins of the Left, the more you will attract an audience that already rejects the sins of the Left and needs to hear warnings about other sins.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
In light of the comments of Jenifer Welch, I think my newest YouTube video will unfortunately age well.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=P4UOhi4_TmU -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is an interesting article. Not so much so about the Senate battle in Maine, but it is one of the few where the author engages in an epistemological introspection of what we do and do not know. It helps us to think about how often we make certain proclamations about issues we have thought about with about an inch of depth. Anyway I found it interesting,
www.msn.com/en-us/politics/elections/graham-platner-and-t… -
George Yancey reposted
Eric Levitz
@EricLevitz
Highly-educated Democrats have very different priorities and policy preferences than Americans writ large.
The mood in our circles/social media feeds is not a reliable guide to public opinion
www.vox.com/politics/466253/why-democrats-unpopular-polls… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Congradulations to Jonathan for all the fine work he has done on this issue. As a father of three young boys it will make it easier for me to deny them getting a phone when kids at their schools are not allowed to use it. Jonathan is a great example of how an academic can make a difference when he is focus on research and results instead of partisanship.
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
Evidence is coming in: Removing phones improves learning. And this study was in Florida, which only bans phones DURING class time, which misses out on most of the benefits (social, discipline....) of a phone-free school day.
www.nber.org/papers/w34388
Richard V. Reeves
@RichardvReeves
"We find significant improvements in student test scores in the second year of the cellphone ban after that initial adjustment period."
This is big: first U.S. causal study of cellphone bans via @nberpubs by David Figlio & @uozek
Paging @JonHaidt @jean_twenge @profgalloway -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So many times, Christians talk on social media about each other without nuance. I hope this changes.
youtu.be/-F9EPsWfgvc -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Why are we not talking more about what is happening in Nigeria?
guardian.ng/news/polish-mep-raises-alarm-over-christian-k… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
There is an ongoing debate on masculinity and feminitity in Christianity. I did a video on masculinity in Christianity a month ago that I think uses nuances and honestly to look at masculinity and feminity in modern Christianity.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=slDe43xZuVI
Danielle (Dani) Treweek
@danitreweek
This critique doesn’t address the substantive point of my comment. But to interact with it on its own terms:
1) Abigail seems to have a very narrow definition of what constitutes “modern society”, limiting it as she does it to essentially the building of physical structures and tangible objects. What about all the ways in which female contributions behind the scenes helped build and strengthen modern society?
2) But, for the sake of the argument, let’s presume her claim that “men built modern society” is accurate. The word there is “modern”. She’s speaking about what happened after the Industrial Revolution, when production was moved out of the home and into the factory, warehouses and eventually office buildings. Originally women (and children) joined men in the new industrial work. But (for a range of reasons) it didn’t take long before the world of production became overwhelmingly populated by men, while women were expected to focus on the domestic household (which was no longer a place of production but largely a place of refuge the breadwinning men could retreat to each night). Prior to the IR (in ancient and medieval times), women actively contributed to society through the basic unit of societal production for all- the household. They planted, tended and harvested crops, were heavily involved in animal husbandry and food production, had a hand in land management, created textiles and other vital products, helped run shops, inns and taverns and worked in midwifery and medicine etc. In other words, the exclusion of women from the building of modern society is the historical exception (brought about because of the conditions of industrialisation), not a long standing norm that has been lost.
3) One of the reasons why women did not have a significant role in building modern society (in the way Abigail suggests) is because they were not given access to the opportunities or education necessary to do allow them to do so. Sure, the ability to do manual labour was important for some of this work (though it is also not like women cannot do many different forms of manual labour. Consider, for example, the way women stepped into all sorts of industrial and labor intensive work when men were on the war front in WWII). But they didn’t have the opportunity to learn how to draw up plans for a new building, to develop the engineering skills needed to design a bridge, to get the education needed to allow them to know how sewerage could be best processed and so on. All of these things were (once again) the fruit of an IR which created two different spheres of sexed life - the breadwinning man and the homemaking mother. If (for the sake of the argument) we say that men DID build modern society, that doesn’t mean that women were naturally incapable of contributing to its building in very significant ways that would have been to society’s great benefit. They simply weren’t given the opportunity.
I’m very thankful to the men who built the physical structures and tangible products of modern society and I’m not sure why Abigail has concluded otherwise (let alone compared me to an ungrateful child in the process). But anyone who is willing to do a little bit of historical research can tell you that modern Western society is not a timeless template for all human societies across time and space. Instead it (and the contributions of the sexes to it) is it’s own unique and dynamic moment… just as our time in the technological age is also. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Here is what I think has happened to the antiracist movement that was so influential in 2020.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=eRBbuAMyG18 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So the Democrats have gotten better and the Republicans are getting worse. Pretty predictable when Republicans gained cultural power.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I would argue that the politics of the US where so many Christians have deeply linked their faith to the Republican party is why there is confusion among non-US Christians. Furthermore, there has been the development of a Christian ID politics, the structure of which looks a lot like what we see on the left in ID politics that is very easily triggered by critques against Republicans and conservative politics. I suspect that Christians in other parts of the world do not have these political incentives and thus are rightly confused by how it has played out in the United States.
Danielle (Dani) Treweek
@danitreweek
A (genuine) question for other non-US Christians.
Do I really not get the whole ‘third way/anti-third way’ thing because I have failed to properly understand what it is… or because you need to be American to properly understand what it is (ie. it’s pretty much unique to the US context)? -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Two things can be true at once.
The Democrat Virginia AG candidate's comments are more consequential and need to be addressed more forcefully than the comments of college students.
and
The VP's refusal to condemn the college students' comments is rank hypocrisy and should condemned as such. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Am I a racist, or am I woke?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=XfEDiNyHjc8 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Okay. So with this six-seven trend I have the answer. When you kid does the six seven thing then just ask him or her why six is afraid of seven. The answer? Because seven eight nine.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
There are those critics of bothsidism who argue that Christians must be Republicans. I consider this a political fundamentalism which I reject.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=cvEp-X8k0G8 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
My experiences in Junior High informed me about the reality that human depravity transcends racial boundaries.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=0gLgfhTpmaU -
George Yancey
@profyancey
In light of my recent discussions about thirdwayism, it seems to me that this video is relevant and helps to explain my unwillingness to commit to the left or the right.
youtu.be/31jTpJX4bwE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
A lot of talk about thirdwayism lacks nuance. It assumes that thirdwayism is the same for everyone. But those who are partisan are not the same. There are good partisanship and bad partisanship. Good partisans believe that their side is right, but they do not reflexively agree with everything supported by their side. Good partisanship would hold everyone to the same standard. If someone on their side commits adultery, they will treat it the same as if someone on their other side commits adultery. They favor their political group, but not to the extent that they blindly follow them. They are open to working with those from the other side on at least some of the issues in our society.
But, there is bad partisanship where their side is either never wrong, or they are never worse than the other party on anything. There is a demonization of anything that they do not agree with. They are not willing to consider that their party may be wrong in some areas. They do not hold their party to the same standard as they hold the other party. They consistently make excuses for members of their party and talk about nuance. With members of the other party it is all black and white. It is the parrtisanship approach on both sides of the polticial spectrum that is driving the political polarization in this country.
There is also good thirdwayism and bad thirdwayism. Good thirdwayism is critical of both the left and the right. There are often issues where one is very conservative and other where one is very progressive. But overall there is a rejection of the socially constructed political ideologies on both sides of the political spectrum. Compromise is possible in many issues and there is an ability to understand where people on the left and the right come from. But there is little desire to buy into their the left and the right as there are major weaknesses that are preceived in both the left and the right.
And there is bad thirdwayism. There are two versions of this. This first version, which I do not see very often, is where the person does not take a strong stand on anything. Often the person tries to take a stand in the middle of the left and the right on those issues. Obviously such a perspective is problematic because little thinking is gone into a philosophy of being in the middle of all issues. The other type of bad thirdwayism is more common which is leftists who pretend that they are in the thirdwayism camp. They seem to like the image of objectiveity of being in that camp but they never critque those on the left and never complement the right. This is where the saying, "Punch right and coddle left" comes from. I just as soon they just admit that they are on the left and not poison the thirdwayism approach.
So here is why all of this is important. When I hear critics of thirdwayism talk, they often compare good partisanship to bad thirdwayism. Yes, I would see good partisanship to be superior to bad thirdwayism. But given the socially constructed and thisworldly nature of our current political paradigms, I definately see good thirdwayism as better to good partisanship. If we are going to discuss the values or problems of thirdwayism then let's compare the best of partisanship to the best of thirdwayism. I like the results of that comparison and because of it, I am a supporter of Christian thirdwayism. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Where's the lie
Carl
@HistoryBoomer
.@thomaschattwill says the Right is turning Kirk into a sacred martyr, and then the Right says "How dare you utter his name in the same paragraph as Floyd, you horrible human!"
Proving the point of the article (that they didn't read) which was NOT that the two men were the same. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
On the topic of thirdwayism, and I am proud in that tradition. The alternative is partisanship, which inevitably leads to compromising one's core principles to ensure that one's team wins. I want no part of that philosophy.
Partisan political ideology, on the left and the right, are secular social constructs. Given this reality, a more accurate Christian approach is to be critical of those constructs. To support them when they are right and oppose them when they are wrong. I have found that partisanism inhibits one from doing that, as all of the energy is spent defending a secular social construction.
Some people try to argue that thirdwayism is just a cover for being a leftist. If I were a leftist, I would say so. I am not. Google me and Christianophobia. Google me and "white progressives." Just as I have zero problems criticizing conservatives when I see them in the wrong, I also have no problem criticizing progressives when I see them in the wrong. Zero.
Others say that being thirdwayism is a coward's way out. That we get to be wishy washy and not have committments. I have committents. Not the the loyality of a political party but to morality, truth, love and justice. When those core principles are violated by any political party I will call it out without concern of partisanship.
By the way if you think it is easy being a thirdway Christian then just try it with a single issue. Pick the issue you disagree with your partisan interest the most and then make a deep critcism of it. If you have no such issue then I think you are the victim of a secular ideological capture. If you do have an issue but are afraid to speak out due to the backlash you will get from your "allies" then never speak again about the cowardice of thirdwayism.
So in all the talk about the problems of thirdwayism, I have not seen the self-reflection about partisanism that needs to take place. Indeed, I am forced to reflect an each given issus since I so not have a secular partisan rubric to run to for my answers. I wish those who are so concerned about thirdwayism would also become concerned about how partisanism is capable of turning their ultimate loyality to Christ to a particular political party.
I will end this too long post with this. My pastor once said several years ago that if we wake up after the election and think we are saved, or we wake up and think we are doomed then we have put our faith in our politics rather than our Lord. That stuck with me because it is right. By all means we should engage in the political process. But our ultimate fate is not decided at the ballot box. We would become more potent salt if we remembered that. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Oh my gosh. Hilarious. I am not brave enough to try this at home.
Nina Deer
@longdepzai_n
That is the charging socket🤣
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Heeey. He stole that from me. I posted and did a video on this very thing. Oh well, it is good that my ideas are getting out there.
Thomas Chatterton Williams
@thomaschattwill
“Today, like five years ago, a controversial man has been transformed overnight into a one-dimensional saint, marshaled in a culture war that precludes measured thought. Once again, Americans are being asked to genuflect before an idol.”
George Yancey
@profyancey
Evidence that I got there frist - www.youtube.com/watch?v=BEes8_bb6pA&t=9s
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
When I did my article at Free Black Thought on the similarities of the murders of Charlie Kirk and George Floyd, I got some pushback. So I did a video to answer that pushback.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=BEes8_bb6pA -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This seems to be a fairly balanced and interesting study showing that while historically violences comes from the right, that in the past year left-wing violence has become more common than right-wing violence.
www.csis.org/analysis/left-wing-terrorism-and-political-v… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I had been thinking about the different conservative responses to distinct free speech challenges and why they are so different.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YmP3IwMrtuQ -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I did not sit through all four hours of the Kirk funeral. No way I could have endured that. But looking at some of what was presented afterwards, and the little I did see, I think we saw the best and worst of Christian expression at the funeral. The best, of course, is Erika Kirk's public forgiveness of the assassin. I hope I am never in a situation to have to do that in this lifetime, but it is inspiring what she did. Having made it public, it will be tough for her to work through it in public. I wish the best for her as she works through her deep pain.
The worst was Miller's "us versus them" speech. We did not need any of that. It appears to be a means of exploiting Kirk's death for power. To be certain, this type of manipulation is not limited to Christians, but it is always disheartening to see it exhibited in an event marked as Christian, such as Kirk's funeral.
I think in the coming months and years, a lot of very good and very bad will come out of this tragedy. Some people will only want to see the bad. Others will only want to see the good. A wise approach is to see both and understand that the ramifications from such events are often nuanced and diverse. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Agree 100 percent. It was not too long ago I was dealing with cries of "bothsidism" from the left. Now that the right has asended to political and cultural power I am finding myself dealing with the cries of "bothsidism" from the right at least as much, or more than from the left.
Holy Post Media
@HolyPost_Media
When we put partisan loyalty before our principles, we find ourselves excusing the very thing we demonized the other side for when our side starts to do it.
@skye.jethani on today's episode of 🎙️The SkyePod, where we discuss Both-Sideism: why pointing out problems on both sides isn’t simple equivocation or conflict-avoidance, but a responsibility, and even a way to avoid idolatry. Join the conversation at the link in bio or on YouTube.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This just came out in Free Black Thought. I think both the left and the right may benefit from this insight.
freeblackthought.substack.com/p/77c226c9-43c4-4def-8cec-2… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Here is the thing. If you are only now caring about free speech because someone you like, like Jimmy Kimmel, may be silenced, then I have no confidence in your support for free speech. If you are like @glukianoff and you have defended the free speech rights of conservatives and Christians in the past, then when you raise the alarm, I am all ears. I have posted a complaint on Facebook about what is happening to Kimmel, as I consistently support free speech. Support rights even for people you disagree with or even find repugnant. Then, when you speak up for people you like, others can take you seriously.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Yesterday, I did a video on what people on the right can do to de-esculate in the United States. Today I present my video for people on the left.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=zB0VDNn1ygA -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am going to have a couple of videos over the next couple of days stating what I think the right and the left need to do to move away from the polarization that contributed to Kirk's death. Today, I talk to the right. Tomorrow, I will talk to the left.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=jzBVgPUPUlc -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I stand with FIRE whether the threat to speech comes from the left or the right.
FIRE
@TheFIREorg
There is no hate speech exception to the First Amendment. Nevertheless, the attorney general says "there's free speech, and then there's hate speech," and the government will "target you, go after you, if you are targeting anyone with hate speech."
The attorney general would be wise to read the words of the Supreme Court, which has repeatedly held that the "proudest boast" of America's free speech tradition is "freedom for the thought that we hate." -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Ultimately, what killed Kirk is our willingness to win at all costs. We have developed a mentality in our society that we have to win no matter what. That bleeds over into our politics, and extremists pick up on that vibe. Once they do, then assassination attempts are just another viable step in the process of winning. If we as a nation do not step back from this, I fear we will see more, not less, violence in the coming days.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I agree with this.
Mike Cosper
@MikeCosper
Until the day I die, there are certain things I will hold with unflinching conviction about our political moment.
The refusal of leftist governments to restrain the violence in the summer of 2020 was reprehensible.
The election denialism and its climax on January 6th was reprehensible too.
The assassinations of Charlie Kirk, Brian Thompson, Melissa Hortman, and the attempted assasinations of Steve Scalise, Justice Kavanaugh, President Trump, and John Hoffman, are also profoundly reprehensible.
No side has a monopoly on political violence. Both sides use the language of “war” and “existential threats.” The atmosphere is poison. It needs leadership to be transformed. But most leaders seem hell bent on nursing grievances — which inevitably feeds the escalations. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Those of us who strive to be peacemakers must get our voices out there. Here is my attempt to think about what we must do to move forward in de-escalation.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=kEtOWsRppa4 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
When I first planned this video, the death of Zarutska was the big topic, and I wanted to say something about what was emerging from it. It almost seems dated after yesterday, and I will probably do one in relation to Kirk soon. So much to digest with these awful events.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I was not, and still am not, a fan of Charlie Kirk. I admired his willingness to engage in debates and put his ideas on the line. But he also came off to me as arrogant at times and too sure of himself. But that does not matter. His murder robbed a wife of her husband and two kids of their father. It is political terrorism that threatens to silence the opposition through violence. It is the murder of a man who is not a politician but merely for arguing forcefully for his perspectives. You do not have to agree with those perspectives to see how truly damaging this event is for our country.
I feel that we are at a crossroads. This is not the only political violence we have seen of late. But I sense it threatens to spiral us into more political violence and destabilize our political system. I do not want to see what can become of our nation if we do not find a way to put the brakes on this violence and the polarizing anger that is poisoning our society.
This is a bipartisan problem. I have zero interest in someone trying to make the argument that it is only the other guys. People on the left and the right have been killed or heavily injured. The dehumanizing rhetoric is found on both the left and the right. Unless those on both sides of our political polarization decide to work towards turning down the temperature, then any chance we have to move away from increasing violence and dehumanization is not possible. But right now, with the recent murder of Kirk, there are different responsibilities on the left and the right.
On the right, I would ask you not to give in to your anger. I understand why you are angry. If someone I deeply respected was gunned down like this, I would be angry as well. There is a temptation to use this event to recruit more people to your cause. Playing on the anger of others can help you build your numbers. But it will also utilize mechanisms that will dial up the anger and lead to further dehumanization of your political enemies. This will increase, instead of decrease, our polarization. I know there is a desire for revenge. But that effort to get revenge will only deepen our social and political woes.
For those on the left, I must say that I have seen too many posts like “I condemn political violence but…” No!! No, buts. Now is not the time to take your cheap shots at Kirk. There will be a time when a fair evaluation of what he has done. Today is not that day. Those on the right are understandably hurt right now. Your job is to create an atmosphere that facilitates their ability to process information in a way that does not contribute to polarization in our society. Showing no real care about murdered conservatives illustrates a dehumanization of those conservatives and will increase the temperature we need to turn down. Have a modicum of class and tact. Consider what you would want from conservatives if AOC had been gunned down, and try to deliver that, instead of contempt.
Most importantly, can those, on both the left and the right, take this horrible murder as an opportunity to commit to doing a better job of communicating with each other? Can we make an effort to find solutions where we work together instead of trying to win at all costs? Kirk’s death can be a “turning point” towards more polarization and animosity, or it can be a “turning point” towards our effort to work together instead of against each other. How we treat each other in the near future will determine which outcome is most likely. I know the outcome I want to see. I hope it is the outcome you want to see as well. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is horrible. No words. Hoping for a full recovery. Our nation does not need this!!
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
Simply horrifying.
We must have the highest tolerance for opinion and absolutely no tolerance for violence. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am seeing some ugly stuff connected to the murder of Iryna Zarutska. There are legit policy and social issues to discuss. But I am also seeing an attempt to stigmatize and blame black men on a societal level. Do we not know the history of this country? Do we really want to fan the flames of the type of fears that saw people like me being lynched? Even though I was not alive in the days when such lynching was relatively commonplace, I have experienced what it is like to be feared merely for being a black male. I experienced car doors locking as they drove by me, and women crossing the street so that they do not have to walk by me. But those are minor inconveniences to what happened to black men, powered by a racist fear, in our history. By all means, let's adjudicate the legitimate issues that arise from this evil murder. Let's punish the murderer specifically, and any other black men who engage in murder. But I would caution us not to jump off this cliff into an insanity of racism that we not too long ago rightly stigmatized as unacceptable in a civilized society.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am neither left nor right. I am certain I am not alone in this.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=31jTpJX4bwE -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Really intersting post on bluesky. Never been to that website. It seems that it has become the social media for a certain type of white progressive. For me, that may make it be a great site for study one of these days.
www.natesilver.net/p/what-is-blueskyism -
George Yancey
@profyancey
While many people, myself included, commented on the dismissal of "thoughts and prayers" by the Minneapolis mayor made another statement that we should think deeply about. I talk about it here.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=nfcrZmeOlXc -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Christians should be more willing to think in nuance than others. Unfortunately, too many times we are not.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=gxB30vlpARg -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Much of what has been called Christian Nationalism is really a conservative form of identity politics. I have a book coming out in the next year or two which will make that case. A ton of work has been done about Christian Nationalism. I estiamate that less than 1 percent of that work has any potential to convince people not to become Christian nationalists. Much of it is designed to stigmitize and feed into our cultural war. This review recognizes that fact and askes some tough questions about how researchers approach their study of Christian nationalism. I hope that over time as we understand this to be more an application of identity politics than Christian nationalism that we can find ways to sap some of the power away the leaders of Christian identity politics and build a church base on service rather war against "the libs."
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
Incisive review in the RFIA journal of "The Flag and the Cross," which I view as the pinnacle or ultimate expression of destructive scholarly trends of recent years. It isn't just that this sort of thing compromises social science... 1/
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
About 10-15 years ago people were talking about the coming Democratic majority. The idea was that with a declining percentage of the population being white, the only major racial group that gave a majority of its votes to Republicans, that eventually the Republicans would become a minority party without a real path to regain power. A few days ago I saw an analysis of the electoral college after the 2030 census. If this analyis is correct the Republicans can lose all the blue wall states as long as they win Georgia, NC and Arizona. Yeah, that looks good for the Republicans. The Democrats can draw that inside straight but it all has to go right for them.
So, how did we arrive at this situation? How did we go from the Democrats looking like the permanent majority to now looking like the Republicans becoming the permanent majority? There was an article from a friend named Napp Nazworth a few years ago that is insightful. He argued that the Republicans have a race problem and the Democrats have a religion problem. The Republicans had problems attracting people of color and Democrats had problems attracting people of faith. Napp argued that whoever solved the problem will gain a massive advantage. It looks like the Republicans have gained that advantage. In the last election the Republicans made big inroads with minority men, especially Hispanics.
So why have they gained that advantage. Here is my theory. The reason why people of faith do not support Democrats is due to ideological reasons. Issues such as abortion, sexuality, morals and such is generally the reason why they are unwilling to support Democrats. While there are some ideological reasons for racial minoities not supporting Republicans there was also fear. There was precieved link, fair or not, of Republicans to nasty historical and contemporary forms of racism. But as overt racism has become more stigmitized in our society, I believe that link has weakened. Even among Republicans there is little tolerance for overt racism. This has made it safer for people of color to vote their ideological prefernces rather than their racial fears. Thus conservative and moderate people of color who use to be loyal to the Democratic party now feel free to vote for Republicans.
Who knows if this trend will continue over the next few decades. Predictions of a permanent Republican majority may go the way of the predictions of a permanent Democratic majority. But if the Democrats cannot make the ideological changes to attract people of faith, they need to find some other way to solve their problem just as the Republicans have found a way to reduce their problem with voters of color. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
For the record I find people who call children a racial slur and those who burn flags to be disgusting. And I do not want the government to lift a finger to stop them. That is what free speech means.
Robert Shibley
@rshibley
Haven't seen this yet so I wanted to beat everyone else to it, given today's fast-paced meme culture.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
There is a type of masculine Christianity that people think is Christianity but it is just another form of cultural Christianity.
youtu.be/slDe43xZuVI -
George Yancey
@profyancey
You may have seen some videos from me in the past few weeks. Yes, I have started a YouTube channel. I see it as a place for Christians who are not completely comfortable with the right or the left. I have built up four playlists based on my expertise, which are 1) race relations, 2) Christianophobia, 3) white progressives, and 4) identity politics. But I also post on other subjects. If you're interested in learning more, here is a link to my video, which provides an overview of my channel. Thanks and blessings to you. www.youtube.com/watch?v=x35gVpg0LME
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
FBT allowed me to discuss my ideas about my Christian identity and my black identity.
freeblackthought.substack.com/p/black-identity-vs-christi… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I commented on Doug Wilson a couple of days ago. Here, I did a video expounding on that point. www.youtube.com/watch?v=DtxLYa5xnY0
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Yesterday, I released a book review of "We Have Never Been Woke." It is a much-needed book, as white progressives generally escape critical analysis. www.youtube.com/watch?v=PjmuxC8Dsjc
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
The interview with Doug Wilson is quite eye-opening on many levels. I hear talk about this being the result of Christian Nationalism. I have been a critic of the way CN has been defined and discussed. I fear that much of the way it is talked about is too expansive. I fear that the term is often used too much as a weapon rather than as an explanation of a social phenomenon. However, Christian nationalism does exist, and Wilson fits the definition of what people mean by CN.
But I think there is a better way to understand Wilson and certain other types of conservative Christians. Rather than talking about Christian nationalism, I think we should see Wilson through the framework of identity politics. While ID politics had mostly been on the left, recently we have seen more of it on the right. And certain Christians push a type of Christian ID politics. This is a politics grounded in promoting the interests of a group that is perceived as marginalized or oppressed. When you hear Wilson and similar voices speak, this is linked to their efforts to establish a Christian nation. I see what is happening more of a type of identity politics than Christian nationalism.
It is a type of politics that demonizes its opponents. It seeks out heretics. It violates its own stated morals to accomplish its goals. Wilson is an example of what happens when this type of politics goes astray. But he is far from the only example of this.
I have been working on the issue of identity politics on the left and the right. Wilson is one of the people I examined as an example of a Christian form of ID politics. Many of the conservative Christians who correctly pointed out the excessess of ID politics on the left are now committing them in "the name of Christ." ID politics bothers me whether it is on the left or the right. But I think I am bothered the most when it is done in the name of my faith.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=rrlYSVjeOmU&list=PL-S_MLxHNzaDrpR… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some Christians put far more effort into achieving political than spiritual ones. Or worse, they conflate political goals with spiritual ones. This is the wide path, rather than the narrow path.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Agreed
Lila Rose
@LilaGraceRose
No civilized nation needs the death penalty.
His death doesn’t bring these innocents back to life.
Life in prison is enough. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Nothing wrong with trying to persuade people... as long as we do it the right way.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=3NfOGSAIsXo -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So this may be helpful to my white Christian friends. My black identity is not as important to me as my Christian identity. Not even close. But it is important to me in ways that do not tend to be true concerning white Christians. It is important to me because being black has shaped my social and personal reality. I have experiences that are directly tied to being an African-American. Having people lock their car doors when I approach them. Losing a girlfriend because her mother's racism could not accept me. People approach me like I am ignorant when I am wearing cheap clothes. These experiences are locked within me and will not go away.
But that does not make my black identity more important than my Christian identity as my faith shapes every aspect of my life. There are ways in which my black identity and my Christian identity intersect to shape my perspectives. But if they do come in conflict my Christian identity will always come before my black identity.
What this means is that being black is part of who I am and I do not back away from that. It may shape my politics, my cultural tastes, my perception of others in ways that are different from my white brothers and sisters. But it does not replace my Christian identity. I do not want to say it enhances my Chrsitian identity because that my imply that I think I am a better Christian becasue I am black and I do not beleive that. But it does "flavor" my Christian identity and at times allows me to offer other something they would not get if I was not black.
I will never be ashamed of being black. I will not ask others to be ashamed of being their particular race. But I will always place my Christian faith as more important than my racial identity. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is bad but welcome to the world of being a nonleftist academic when any trans, female, queer or nonwhite student can have you up on charges for anything said that may offend them. I would happily work with Maya to get rid of all of that as well as the Trump mandate.
Maya Sen
@maya_sen
This, in the Brown settlement, is pretty insane, and will certainly chill classroom speech
it will also open up Brown professors to meritless abuse, retaliation, and harassment -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I wrote about this a few days ago. Here is my fuller take on Jon Stewart's Gospel Choir.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=d3KLjZ2U1_k -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I like a lot of what Jon Steward does but how does he get away with using a gospel choir to show profanities. Regardless of your political position, how can you not be offended as a black Christian? Classic example of a white liberal appropriating black culture, but gets away with it because he is on the "right" side on an issue. (Will not post a link of it because I do not post garbage )
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Tell me once again how Trump will protect the rights of Christians?
NCR
@NCRonline
Catholic priests have been barred from providing religious services inside Florida's controversial new migrant detention facility — dubbed "Alligator Alcatraz" — nearly three weeks after it opened deep in the Everglades, the archbishop of Miami said. www.ncronline.org/news/miami-archbishop-joins-knights-bik…
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Never thought I would ever talk about Queers for Palestine but there you go - www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQoZD3hVLYk
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am going to just place this here and then go run away an hide.
www.nature.com/articles/s44271-025-00289-4 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some may believe that I do not want to see Christians involved in politics. I just want Christians to be smart in how they engage in politics.
youtu.be/hoZWC_9zq-o -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Every now and then, I come across a wackadoodle who tells me that Regnerus's work on same-sex parenting has been refuted. Indeed, his work on that topic is aging quite well.
www.thepublicdiscourse.com/2025/07/98359/ -
George Yancey
@profyancey
We in academia are going to have a hard time winning the trust of society back until we recognize that we have a problem with leftist bias and are willing to do something about it.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Quick take: We underestimated the severity of the problem, the intransigence across academia with respect to addressing it, and the intellectual/political/cultural momentum all pushing to worsen rather than improve it. I have a slew of papers on various aspects of this, but this is a good start:
sites.rutgers.edu/lee-jussim/wp-content/uploads/sites/135…
Full citation:
Jussim, L., Honeycutt, N., Paresky. P., Careem, A., Finkelstein, D. & Finkelstein, J. (2023). The radicalization of the American academy (pp. 343-366). In, Zúquete, J.P. (ed). The Palgrave Handbook of Left-Wing Extremism, Volume 2. New York: Palgrave MacMillan. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Man if Pop in his heyday had these tools the Spurs would be not only the best defense in the league but an all-time great defensive team.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Well, today I signed my contract with Routledge for my newest book titled " Identity Politics in the United States: An Exploration of Identity in Red and Blue." It corresponds to my recent concerns on identity politics as I use antiracism as an example of identity politics on the left and conservative Christians as an example of identity politics on the right. I am quite critical of ID politics so this will continue my tradition of pissing off the left and the right. I am hoping for it to come out late next year.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
The next time someone says that Christians are trying to take over society, then feel free to post this.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hg4FKomXAkk -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Evidently you can't just agree with the Conservative Chrsitian Twitter Mob on abortion and sexuality. Unless you walk lockstep with them on immigration and climate change then you have to be excommunicated as well.
Luke Stamps
@lukestamps
Breaking: Christian ethicist took issue with Trump's character in 2016.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
If a Christian influencer does nothing but post attacks on Christians he or she disagrees with, then that influencer loses me. I am okay with some criticism. But why not also discuss developing the fruits of the Spirit or ways to enhance our personal growth? It is easy to find people you dislike and attack them. That is low-hanging fruit. We have got to get away from liking people because they like the people we like and hate the people we hate. Rather, we need to ask more from our Christian influencers so that they do more than sow discord, but also build the Body of Christ in healthy ways.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
What could whiteness look like when it impacts progressives? Well, here are some of my ideas on that.
youtu.be/66vwB7vRKlg -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I remember a time when I asked my conservative Christian friends if they were going to vote for Trump anyway, then could they put pressure on him to tone down the race-baiting and sexism. And to not excuse his sexual immorality. For the most part, I got crickets. I also remember when he started to go soft on abortion before the election. WIth noteable exceptions most of the Christians who had supported Trump before excused him.
Now the word amnesty has come to the surface and those same Christian leaders who were silent when he insulted people of color, made sexist comments about women, showed the sexual morality of an alley cat, and provided cover for him when he was soft on abortion are now at war. So racial insults, sexism, immorality, and pro-choicism did not make them angry. But the fact that some people who came over here illegally are not immediately ejected has them frothing at the mouth.
People do not have to tell me their priorities. They will eventually show me their priorities. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I do not know if Trump's tax cuts contributed to a lack of action during the flooding in my state, and neither do you. But like clockwork, the partisans are already arguing about whether the flooding deaths are due to budget cuts. Of course, this infects this tragedy with partisan implications. We will have an investigation. And if FEMA was understaffed and people were not warned, then we will be aware of that. Unfortunately, the conservatives who are arguing that the budget cuts do not matter will seek ways to deny these facts as they will not fit their partisan interests. Likewise, we may learn that there was a warning, and the rise in the flood was so sudden that FEMA's response did not matter. In that case, the progressives who are invested in blaming Trump will look to ignore those facts.
This is a very sad consequence of always leading with our partisan interest when we try to interpret facts, in that we will stubbornly hold on to those facts once we have established them as necessary for our political allies. In a better world, we would focus on how to comfort and care for the victims of the flooding while we wait for the investigation to determine if mistakes were made and how we can improve next time. Alas, instead, we live in this world of finger-pointing and recriminations. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
That's it. Humans are no longer needed. Bring on the machines.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Are Christians facing persecution? I try to answer that question.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=IeGhUgnt6K4 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have seen this as well. Even had a former social media contact try to threaten me with his "masculinity." Eventually, but not right away, I may do a video on this topic as this simply repersents another way we let our culture dictate our faith rather than the other way around.
Mike Winger
@MikeWingerii
I'll call it "Tough Guy Theology"
As far as I can tell a large number of people are making theological shifts, changing their beliefs, based not on a clear and careful assessment of Scripture but on the basic vibe they get that a particular theology is strong/victorious.
I think this is lame. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So, a couple of days ago, we had the anniversary of the Biden-Trump debate. Trump clearly won that debate, and it set him up to succeed. A few months later, we had the Harris-Trump debate. Harris clearly won, but it did not move the needle in the slightest. Why is that the case?
George Yancey
@profyancey
I see this as a situation of expectations. Trump needed to be somewhat presidential in the first debate and Biden had to show he was still mentally compentant. It is debateable about whether Trump achieved his needed goal. There was no doubt that Biden failed to address the age issue.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
She basically won the battle and lost the war. She won the debate but did not provide any confident that she was anything but an anti-Trump vote. An anti-Trump vote was sufficent in 2020. It was not in 2024
George Yancey
@profyancey
So the lesson is that it is not just improtant to win the debates but how you win the debates matter. If you win the debate but fail to answer the questions about you going into the debate, then you can come out looking good but not in any better shape in your political race.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am all for getting rid of harmful DEI programs. But let's replace it with something better instead of just leaving a vaccum.
beprohuman.substack.com/p/as-nonprofits-face-the-dei-wars… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Doing my best to make this image an ongoing meme.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=ndObeoqifII -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is facinating. I would not have seen this coming. It begs for some solid qualitative work to figure out what is going on here.
Ryan Burge 📊
@ryanburge
Church attendance has this really odd impact on views of immigration.
The more Republicans go to church, they less supportive they are of cutting legal immigration.
For Democrats, higher church attendance leads to strong anti-immigrant views.
(Excluding the non-religious) -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Despite all of his shortcomings, one of the things I did appreciate about Trump was his disdain for war. Well, that appreciation ended tonight.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
It is stopped clock is right twice a day time as I actually agree with Wolfe on something.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
The stupidity of this take is that conservative Christians are acually less likley to engage in politics and this type of diacotmous thinking than the nonreligious. A most dishonest post if I ever saw one.
Mason Mennenga
@masonmennenga
this sums up conservative christianity perfectly
George Yancey
@profyancey
Oh I see he is into liberation theology. Guess what? Conservative Christians are less liklely to engage in this type of dicotomous political thinking than progressive Christians as well.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
White educated progressives do not tend to support free speech as much as others. Why is that?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8eoYBAKqtI -
George Yancey
@profyancey
You know when women come into an instituiton they feminize it and make it nice and sweet and.... oh never mind.
Trysta Krick 🔥
@Trysta_Krick
Concerning the Fever vs. Sun game tonight. You know what they say l. You fight one of the Tres Leches, you gots to fight them all
And you don’t want to fuck with Sophie Cunningham, considering one of her claims to fame was she’s the youngest black belt in Missouri historyThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey reposted
Trysta Krick 🔥
@Trysta_Krick
Concerning the Fever vs. Sun game tonight. You know what they say l. You fight one of the Tres Leches, you gots to fight them all
And you don’t want to fuck with Sophie Cunningham, considering one of her claims to fame was she’s the youngest black belt in Missouri historyThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This thread is very accuate. I would add that there is also a protective factor that makes any type of critical analysis more difficult to get accepted in peer reviewed journal or funded by traditional funding sources. Trust me I know about that.
Drew Medaris ⛪
@SoterioPolitics
I think I use an entirely different architecture for understanding the state of sociology. 'Heterodox' is too sensationalist for me. Rather, it's that academic sociologists have as many blindspots as anyone else, and it inevitably leaves gaps of a highly partisan flavor.
1/
George Yancey
@profyancey
Also I should have posted this with my retweet yesterday as it is releveant.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nfdp1-HK9FM -
George Yancey
@profyancey
There are those who talk and act that if you vote for Democrats, then you are not a Christian. They do so on the basis of abortion. But Trump, while he did deliver the judges that overturned Roe, is effectively now pro-choice.
George Yancey
@profyancey
So if we accept their logic then if you did not vote for a true pro-life candidate, like I did with the American Solidarity Party, then you are not a Christian.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Of course I reject that logic. Those who push it are trying to build HIs church on a political rock. I prefer to work at building his church on the Rock of Ages.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Man if you are not called liberal by Wolfe then you are doing something wrong.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I know people say too much "this is why Trump won" but seriouly this type of tone deafness is an important part of why he is in the White House.
Stephen Knight 🎙️
@GSpellchecker
The "oh no, not work!" sarcasm from this guy—now gone viral and known as 'Manbun McSoyboy'—says everything you need to know about professional 'activists'.
For most people, work isn’t optional. It’s the line between feeding your family or not. Between keeping a roof over your head or not. Between having a Christmas or telling your kids why there won’t be one. It's survival.
The ease with which he mocks that reality tells you just how cushy and detached his life really is.
Video in replies
👇 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The slight movement away from the Law amendment gives me a sliver of hope that the SBC can ecapse fundamentalism.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am on live right now - youtube.com/live/h71Z8sI50EE
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is what a hero looks like.
FreedomFest
@TheFreedomFest
Would you befriend someone who hates you?
@RealDarylDavis did—and convinced 200+ people to leave the KKK.
He chose conversation over cancellation.
Hear his powerful fireside chat w/ @RealSpikeCohen at #freedomfest2025.
📅 June 11–14 | 📍 Palm Springs, CA
🎟️This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am concerned with the toxic influences on men. However, we must offer more than just a critique of men if we want to counteract those influences. And I think the emergence of identity politics is part of the problem.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Yfjzvhsnc8 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Dude!!!!
Sunday League
@SundayShoutsFC
The ultimate humiliation. 😂😂
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have become more aware of the reality that we, and I include myself, tend to accept comfortable lies rather than uncomfortable truths.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I am cited in this article on Southern Baptists. There are many people I love in that denomination but I am concerned about them.
religionnews.com/2025/06/06/southern-baptists-will-try-to…
George Yancey
@profyancey
Here is my post that provides more information about my concern.
youtu.be/rroFedBH6XY -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some techniques can be useful to facilitate more productive interracial conversations. In this video, I try to outline some of them. Feel free to share it with groups that want to promote constructive, instead of combative, conversations.
youtu.be/JWu2BC1om40 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Without excusing the garbage, we have to take the needs of men seriously and confront the movement towards anti-semitism and other evil. This will not happen by just insulting them. We must understand them. In that light, this is a must-read article.
christoverall.com/article/longform/the-dangerous-secret-y… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Identity politics is not just bad for society, but it is also bad for the health of those who engage in it.
youtu.be/ldf8EVRN6K4 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Trump is overreacting. But there have been problems in academia that need addressing. Christianophobia is one of them. www.youtube.com/watch?v=SyMMucpIuwo
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
An interesting take on how to fix DEI. Something to mull over. www.persuasion.community/p/how-to-fix-dei
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
There has been a lot of talk about the decline in the SBC. Here is why I do not think the decline will soon abate. youtu.be/rroFedBH6XY
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I agree with this diagnosis.
John Sailer
@JohnDSailer
Today, I argue that the challenge of higher education reform can be boiled down to one issue: the talent pipeline.
If we rewire the academic talent pipeline, the reform movement will succeed. If not, no other list of policies will suffice. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I will be at a live stream dealing with Christians, bigotry, and confirmation bias. It will be on Tuesday at 1CT. Feel free to join us if this is of interest to you.
youtube.com/live/69OlmNMDvCM -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I find myself repulsed by what Trump is doing to higher education but not wanting to go back to a time when the left wanted unwanted people and ideas out of academia. Maybe out of the ashes of this, reasonable people across the political spectrum can rebuild higher education.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Relevant fact in light of last night's horror. Jews, despite their small number, suffer from hate crimes than any other religious group and it is not even close.
www.justice.gov/crs/news/2023-hate-crime-statistics -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This article with @jessesmithsoc criticizes how we measure Christian Nationalism. I have been suspicious of that measure, which makes me somewhat doubtful of the results. We offer a better way that may produce the same results, but with more confidence.
journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0034673X251336460
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am sorry I know that this article is paywalled but you may be able to get access through a university liberary.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
A podcast I did for Free Black Thought on DEI if any of you are interested.
freeblackthought.substack.com/p/ep-110-can-dei-be-fixed-g… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I was interviewed by Cody Cook on his libertarian Christian show. No, I am not a libertarian, but it is great to have more voices out there. Feel free to listen if you wish.
libertarianchristians.com/episode/ep-406-seeing-through-p… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
People who attack me with anon accounts get blocked. If you do not have the courage to attach your name to your complaints then you forfeit the right to reply to my comments.
Jacob Denhollander
@JJ_Denhollander
HOW are any of you surprised that Josh Buice has anon accounts he used to attack others? The whole right-wing conference circuit begs for this kind of behavior.
Seems the reason he had to step down is not that he attacked or slandered - it's that he attacked the wrong people. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Bigger isn't always better.
NO CONTEXT HUMANS
@HumansNoContext
This video lives rent free in my head
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I for one am not ashamed to say that I deeply respected Keller as a leader and Christian leader.
David Fish
@DavidFish7
Tim Keller is experiencing his mid 2000's Creed moment. Almost everyone still likes him, but a handful of loud, obnoxious people made it unpopular to say so publicly. In 20 years people will come out of hiding again and confess their love for Keller.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
True
Samuel James
@Digitalliturgy
Why theological dialogue on Twitter is so often dysfunctional:
-It's performed in front of an audience, so it's not personal exhortation.
-Its participants are there only to teach, not learn, so it's not education.
-Its done between disembodied users, so its impersonal. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This interview of Daryl Davis is one of the best interviews I have heard in a long time. He is a black musician who talked many KKK members into leaving it. In this interview, he talks about his origins and early encounter with KKK members.
freeblackthought.substack.com/p/ep-106-the-klan-whisperer… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Dark Woke is not where we want to take this nation's dialogue.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
You are going to be hearing a lot about this study. It is massive and consequential to our understanding of human flourishing. I am a tiny part of it. Kudos to Byron Johnson and Tyler VanderWeele, who have spearheaded this important work. www.christianitytoday.com/2025/05/global-flourishing-stud…
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Just bashing Trump, no matter how hard you do it, will not save the Democrats. They need to find ways to try to attract voters to them rather than focus on driving voters from Trump m
(((Harry Enten)))
@ForecasterEnten
"These numbers should be a major wake-up call for Democrats." Even now, Trump still does well when matched against Democrats.
-Trump 45%-Harris 43% on who'd be doing a better job as president
-Trump 40% to Dems in Congress' 32% on who can better deal with the main U.S. problemsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So we have a question on the Baylor Religion Survey on whether the respondent can have a daily relationship with an AI companion. I have my ideas about whether I can do that. What do the rest of you all think about that possibility?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
NETTR looks worse and worse everyday.
Samuel Sey
@SlowToWrite
If you watch my discussion with Mahler and you come away thinking he is a racist, you’re not wrong—but you’ve missed the biggest point.
He’s a blasphemer, and the people being influenced by him—including those with bigger platforms—are embracing blasphemy.
Not only did he twist word of God’s to say that Ham is cursed when it clearly says Canaan is cursed, he openly said God isn’t able to sanctify black people the way he sanctifies white people.
That is obviously blasphemy. Again, he hates black people because he hates God. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
About a year ago, we were looking at a presidential election where the left controlled the major cultural institutions – media, academia, the arts, etc. The right could win but it would have to do so while the left controlled the cultural narrative.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
As a conservative Christian academic, I know the challenge of going against the academic paradigm. It can be tough sledding. I am also committed to viewpoint diversity in academia.
George Yancey
@profyancey
So, I will support political conservatives who want to get established in academia. But until political conservatives themselves throw their resources and efforts toward supporting those academic conservatives, then they will not get very far.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
You don't have to like Trump to find this very disturbing. www.yahoo.com/news/bombshell-study-reveals-assassination-…
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
One of the most disturbing things I am seeing on X is the father of the poor kid who was stabbed trying to bring peace to this awful situation and then being attacked by people I assume want to use this to promote some warped type of conservatism.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Evangelcials are not into politics as much a the media say that we are. This is a myth that needs to die.
Ryan Burge 📊
@ryanburge
One of the biggest misconceptions I see on social media from the political left:
Church services are essentially political rallies.
This data refutes that viewpoint very strongly.
www.graphsaboutreligion.com/p/do-church-goers-want-to-hea… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So, if Trump gets to run for a third term, as some fear, then that would stop Obama from running against him?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Folks. The comments. There are those on the right who are fully willing to engage in the same behavior they decried when it was done on the left. No. You cannot use those tactics to an honorable end because ID politics tactic are toxic in and of themselves.
Neil Shenvi
@NeilShenvi
I understand people who dislike the term "woke right."
But I don't understand people who deny that some segments of the right are openly appropriating Neo-Marxist ideas and tactics.
This is an undeniable fact and denying it is foolish. 1/ -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Wow. Evangelicals definately have a distinctive place in our religious landscape.
Ryan Burge 📊
@ryanburge
I like this graph because it shows just how unique evangelicals are in American religion.
When asked, "how important are your views about religion to your identity and how you think of yourself?"
77% of evangelicals said 'very much'
That's TWICE as high as any other group. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Seems like a politically motivated retraction to me.
Emil Kirkegaard
@KirkegaardEmil
Finally joined the cool kids retraction club!
My first politically motivated retraction
www.emilkirkegaard.com/p/my-first-politically-motivated-r… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I tell ya. NETTR really is dumb.
Joel Berry
@JoelWBerry
I know this is just a clip of three losers fantasizing about sending the military to confiscate the property of heretics, but I’ll react anyway.
Most of human history involved people being imprisoned, tortured, burned at the stake, and forced at the point of a sword to swear allegiance to bozos like this.
America is a shining exception. Don’t let these emotional, un-American fools destroy what men wiser, godlier, and more virtuous than them built for us and our children. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Given that liberals seem more likely to purchase Teslas than conservatives, liberals going around and burning Teslas seem a lot like blacks burning done their community after a racial incident.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
There are real flaw with DEI. But the answer is not an ax that takes everything down. This is an issue that requires nuance and critical thinking. That is in short supply in our country today.
www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2025/03/23/look_at_pri…
George Yancey
@profyancey
It in short supply becasue on the right it is all about absolute loyality to Trump and on the left it is about hating Trump no matter what. So what do we do when he is partially correct like he is here. We just come out fighting like we always do right?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Ha ha ha
hannah anderson
@sometimesalight
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I do not ever want an innocent man imprisoned or stigmatized with a sexual assualt charge. And we know that this can happen with innocent men. Remember Duke Lacross. So if the report clearing some Baptists is accurate and they were unjustly charged then that is praiseworthy.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
The SBC would make a big mistake going back to a good ol boy way of handling sexual assult. Any crediable charge need to be sent to the authorities. If he comes back clean then fine. But pastors are not law enforcement officials.
George Yancey
@profyancey
The sort of fundamentalism that has arisen within the SBC makes is more likely that the concerns of victims will not be addressed. That saddens me and I hope there are people in the right positions to make certain that is not case.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
So much of the literature on how fears drive us are based on fear due to race or religion. But fear of the other political party can adrives racial and religious fears. Thus, politized fears is an important factor in other types of fears.
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00380237.2025.2473468 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
My conservative Christian friends should take note. Trump is moving the Republican party away from cultural conservatism and attracting people into the party who will solidify that transformation. Supprot for Trump will come at a cost.
Tim Chapman
@TimChapman
This clip clarifies the debate on the right.
Batya, to her credit, does not hide the ball at all. She is a self described “leftist” who wants the “MAGA leftist” wing of the party to eradicate the Reagan wing one the party by jettisoning social conservatives, free traders and foreign policy hawks.
Trump’s first term combined elements of the populist right with the conservative mainstream - but it was distinctly conservatives who were the senior partner in the coalition.
Will his second term invert that dynamic? Or worse, will it completely forsake rank and file conservatism?
And if it does, what are the consequences? -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Since my post about Webbon I have seen more conservative Christians talk about dealing with the racism and antisemitism in their ranks. To that I will applaud them. Wish this happened sooner but better late than never.
George Yancey
@profyancey
But I do have to note that this was predicted by people like @NeilShenvi when many of them moved to a policy of NETTR. It was inevitable that racists and antisemites would use that stance to appropriate the efforts of conservative Christians.
George Yancey
@profyancey
The answer to punch right and coddle left is not to punch left and coddle right. The answer is to be critical and careful to the temptations on both the left and the right. If think that many conservative Christians are learning this now.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Most of the efforts to convince conservative Christians are wrong will massively fail because those engaging in those efforts clearly do not care about those Christians. You cannot convince people when all you show them is contempt.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I keep hearing conservative Christian leaders calling out French and Moore all the while telling me that they have no problems with racism in their ranks. Why are they not calling out garbage like this? Methinks they blind themselves to the racist rot that lies among their allies
Joel Webbon
@JoelWebbon
Christians, are we ready for the conversation about how a woman with adopted children from Haiti might not be the best fit for a civil magistrate who prioritizes America First?
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am glad some are calling him out but some of the biggest names are welded to the NETTR mentality and silent. And the attention given to those like him pails to the attention given to French and Moore. Do those leaders silent about him think that he better represents Christ?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
So in the U.S. there are two types of Christians. Let’s call the first group power Christians. They are highly focused on obtaining and using power. Generally political power. They use political actions to help determine ingroups and outgroups.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
Introspection Christianity brought me back. The desire to be a better person and to grow. That helped me to deal with the grief that threatened to drag me away from the faith. If Christians really want to change society…
George Yancey
@profyancey
Then we need to lean into introspection and being so Godly that people can only explain it though God. Gaining and holding power will never have the allure that living a Godly, loving lie can have.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I did not watch the SOTU last night, but I am told that the Democrats refused to applaud for a 13-year-old cancer survivor. Do the Democrats really hate Trump so much that they can not even agree with him to support a sick boy.
George Yancey
@profyancey
In 2016 the Republican party lost its way because it loved Trump no matter what. Now the Democrats have lost their way because they will hate Trump no matter what. Trump has destroyed both political parties.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Mickey D's has very sub-par food. But at least my boys can play in the playground...oh, never mind.
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
Thank you Nancy, this is so sad. This is going straight into my lectures.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I'll take things a women is too smart to ever do for a thousand Alex.
out of context brazil
@oocbrazill
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
What has happened with the term racism informs me about the Tate controversy. Why has this vile man become so popular among men? Well, how people look at racism provides us some insight into what has happened. At one point racism was a poisonous term that destroyed people.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
If we want to reduce the influence of Tate, merely pointing out his problematic teachings will not suffice. We have to craft a societal vision of a positive masculine identity that has distinctions from femineity. You do not defeat Tate with just criticism.
George Yancey
@profyancey
In other words, you cannot defeat something with nothing. We have to defeat something an alternative. It is not just about taking down Tate. It is about making certain that the next Tate never gets any real traction.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Something many of us need to learn in social media is that being correct is not the same thing as being persuasive.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is so correct. I wish that the right would develop a set of rules to protect their outgroup. But they are no more likely to do that then the left did. So we will go back and forth with each group trying to destroy the other when they have the power to do so.
PoIiMath
@politicalmath
I'm incredibly sympathetic to argument of hypocrisy here but the reality is this:
The right has been on the receiving end of this boot for about a decade. The left had every opportunity to propose a set of objective, reasonable, legible rules to protect people from vindictive political witch-hunts. They refused to do so and repeatedly argued that, actually, those people deserved it.
Now they're on the receiving end of it and, I get it, that sucks. Man, does it suck. It sucks so much that I think we should all come up with a set of objective, reasonable, legible rules that will protect people from vindictive political witch-hunts.
But no on wants to do that b/c:
1) the right is having too much fun wearing the booth
2) the left doesn't want to write down any rules that will restrain them from going stomp-happy the next time they get to wear the boot -
George Yancey
@profyancey
One thing I have learned the past couple of months is that when those on the right get cultural power that they can be just as obnoxious as those on the left.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I remember when one of the supporters of Christian nationalism came out with a statement on how whites were the last bastion of civilization. At least some of those attacking @drantbradley defended him. So, if I am charitable, I find their outrage at racism to be selective.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Unfortunately as a Never-Trumper this has been my experience as well. I will never vote for Trump but I cannot in good conscience also vote for those who will do anything to stop him including the violation of their own stated principles.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I decided to read the interview on the sin of empathy given the controversy surrounding the issue. Again and again it occurred to me that this idea has become popular in conservative Christian circles as a way to defend some of Trump's policies. albertmohler.com/2025/02/19/joe-rigney/
George Yancey
@profyancey
To be honest empathy can be misused, on the left and the right, just like other positive attributes such as love. But, the focus seems to be that we do not need empathy if it comes from the left and interferes with what Trump is doing.
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have stopped trying to get Christians to not vote for Trump. Given lousy performance of the Democrats I can even kinda understand that vote. What I do not understand is when Christians give up their values to not just vote for him but to support almost everything he does.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is where I am at on DEI and why Trump is partially, but only partially, right in what he is doing,
www.persuasion.community/p/dei-must-change -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some of what Trump is doing is disturbing, but it is also understandable, given the bias in academia. I do not approve of much of I,t but if we want to stop it we have to understand the motivation behind it.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post.
"We warned you. This post documents the extent to which we warned you, over and over for at least 25 years. At the end, it presents over 50 references documenting the historical attempt of dissident academics to warn the rest of academia that this could come if they did not get their house in order. Now its here.
The Trump administration is crushing many of the norms of academia. Some might argue that it is crushing academia."
Link next tweet -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have never seen a president so active and making so many changes in his first month. This version of Trump is very distinctive from the 2016 version of Trump. I have thought about why Trump is so different this time around.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
clearly did not work. I expect that as we get closer to the 2026 elections they will figure things out but right now the Democrat resistance is weak. So those are some of my ideas on why Trump is so active and aggressive this time around. Will this work out for him?
George Yancey
@profyancey
Will this work out for the USA? Well, time will tell, but it is too bad I am not a political scientist because this will be a fascinating time to study the political economy in this country.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I remember warning people that if you make everything they don't like as an example of racism then people will get to the point that they will see nothing as racist. That same warning applies to those who see everything they don't like as an example of being woke.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I think Trump has finally brought America together on a single issue -- paper straws.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I find that most on the left and right choose 1. And often, when they think they are choosing 3, they really are choosing 1. They are just mistaken in who their tribe really is.
Neil Shenvi
@NeilShenvi
Three approaches to in-group criticism:
1. We should criticize our tribe less, because we need to win.
2. We should criticize both tribes equally, because we need to be fair.
3. We should criticize our tribe more, because we need to show integrity. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Two bad overreaches in our society today. When something bad happens to a person of color the left says it has to be racism. When something good happens to a person of color the right says it has to be DEI.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Antisemitism is a bipartisan problem.
www.nytimes.com/2025/01/25/opinion/antisemitism-left-righ… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The beauty of the story of the Good Samaritan is the lengths we are to go to love those that we see as our enemies. I cannot see a Christian policy on immigration that does not take that type of radical love into account.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Yep
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Blaming Trump or blaming DEI for the airline crash is the same type of gotch politics that people are tired of. Can we not do better than that?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Can we bring this to Texas please?
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
Gov. @SarahHuckabee of Arkansas launched a program last summer to support schools that chose to go phone free.
The early results are so spectacular that she's now introducing a bill to make all schools phone free, from bell to bell. Go Sarah!
arktimes.com/arkansas-blog/2025/01/29/phones-would-be-ban… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
In the foreseeable future, DEI initiatives will be on the decline. While I criticize how DEI has been done I find that unfortunate. How did DEI get to this position and what can be done? Let’s talk about that.
George Yancey
@profyancey
To see why DEI is in decline we need to go back to its high point of acceptance which occurred after the George Floyd protests. America was horrified at his murder and looking for answers. Antiracism appeared to provide some of those answers.
George Yancey
@profyancey
From antiracism, there was a push to dismantle institutions that perpetuated racism. To do this whites had to be brought on board. Thus DEI programs of diversity training were pushed and implemented throughout our society.
George Yancey
@profyancey
The problem is that there was no effort to regulate and determine whether the programs worked and if so which ones did. With the newfound public support for these programs, those running them could do most of what they wanted.
George Yancey
@profyancey
This naturally led to excesses by people who did not know what they were doing. Some of the trainers used strategies intended to browbeat whites into accepting antiracist perspectives. Those examples were paraded as “DEI”
George Yancey
@profyancey
This also led to unbalanced strategies. I mean when you talk about “ending whiteness how do you think whites are going to accept it? When you say people are engaging in white supremacy then do you think you will convince them of anything?
George Yancey
@profyancey
The poor use of this opportunity to use DEI to being people together often separated them even more. This is not just my opinion. Research shows that browbeating increases prejudice - journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0956797611427918
George Yancey
@profyancey
On top of generating a backlash research also indicates that racial remedies centered redistribution of resources from white to black will engender resistance to those remedies - www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/eb022908/full…
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
But it will build a framework of racial cooperation which can ironically better meet some of the goals in that racial justice framework. Anyway I have written about this if you want to learn more. www.ivpress.com/beyond-racial-division
George Yancey
@profyancey
In the meantime if you know someone who is discouraged about the fall of DEI then share this with them. Maybe they can catch a vision for a new direction and better way to battle racial alienation. I hope that can encourage them. Cheers everyone.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
My latest book explores people who are antiracists.
templepress.wordpress.com/2025/01/22/who-are-antiracists/ -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Starting today I will be praying for President Trump just like I did for President Biden. For a Christian, this should be a bipartisan action.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Wow. Did not expect this post to be in an online article!!!
www.crosswalk.com/headlines/contributors/michael-foust/7-… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
We are on the cusp of the second Trump administration. And I think identity politics has played a big role in getting us here. I believe that our move towards ID politics is damaging both of our major political parties.
George Yancey
@profyancey
To understand this, we have to look at how ID politics developed. ID politics first emerged on the left in response to the failure of Marxism to promote their political agenda. As a result, ID politics emerged as a very valuable tool.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is why when I wanted to address racial issues, I did not look towards identity politics. I proposed using healthy collaborative conversations to find solutions. I still am committed to that approach. www.ivpress.com/beyond-racial-division
George Yancey
@profyancey
Can we learn how to talk to each other rather than about each other? Not if we stay in our ID politics framework. And the reinforcement of that framework, on the left and the right, in our past political season is depressing, nonetheless.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have joined the board of directors for the prohuman Foundation and here is one of the podcasts I did for them.
𝑫𝒆𝒓𝒂𝒕𝒆 𝑻𝒉𝒆 𝑯𝒂𝒕𝒆 𝒑𝒐𝒅𝒄𝒂𝒔𝒕
@DerateTheHate
𝐁𝐫𝐢𝐝𝐠𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐑𝐚𝐜𝐢𝐚𝐥 𝐃𝐢𝐯𝐢𝐝𝐞𝐬 𝐓𝐡𝐫𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡 𝐌𝐮𝐭𝐮𝐚𝐥 𝐀𝐜𝐜𝐨𝐮𝐧𝐭𝐚𝐛𝐢𝐥𝐢𝐭𝐲 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐔𝐧𝐢𝐭𝐲... 𝐷𝑇𝐻 𝐸𝑝𝑖𝑠𝑜𝑑𝑒 246 𝑤𝑖𝑡ℎ 𝐺𝑒𝑜𝑟𝑔𝑒 𝑌𝑎𝑛𝑐𝑒𝑦
@profyancey @prohuman_org @braverangels @wilksopinion
deratethehate.com/episodes/bridging-racial-divides-throug… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Can't argue with this!!!
Matt Smethurst
@MattSmethurst
In all my years of pastoring, I have learned this lesson: a person’s spiritual maturity is not truly visible until they DON’T get their way. Then you see the person.
—@ErikReed -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I already knew about the spike in lower well-being around 2012 which I think has greatly contributed to our nation's problems. But now with this additional Covid spike I really fear for our nation in the coming years.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Yeah. I could not have said it better myself.
Nate Silver
@NateSilver538
"Democracy is threatened unless we're allowed to control the flow of information on social media" is among the worst ideas in the discourse from being naive about how persuasion works to kind of lowkey authoritarian.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
The California fires are horrible. I do not know whether incompetent has made them worse and nobody else knows that yet. I suggest we concentrate on putting out the fires and dispense with the finger-pointing until there is time for a real investigation.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I put some thoughts down about a cultural phenomenon I noted lately.
www.thepublicdiscourse.com/2025/01/96821/ -
George Yancey
@profyancey
She's right. And what I have called collaborative conversation is a big part of including everyone instead of dividing us all.
Anjali Bindra Patel
@AnjBindraPatel
They told us DEI would solve workplace inequality.
Instead, it created more problems than it solved.
I've spent 15 years watching this experiment fail.
Here's why it's a disaster (and an actual solution): -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Like I have said. Our education system is failing us.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Surveys consistently find that Americans exaggerate the positions held by the Party they DO NOT identify with. Dems exag Repub positions; Repubs exag Dem positions. Repubs exag Dems slightly more than Dems exag Repubs, but the kicker is, education does not help anyone and the more educ Dems have, the more they exaggerate.*
One excellent source:
perceptiongap.us
ht @BrandonWarmke
*No wonder its so bad in academia.
Perception gap in figure refers to exaggerating opposing Party members' positions. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Our education system is failing us.
Jonathan Rolfe
@JonathanAKRolfe
As a debate coach, I’m always interested in how well people can present the strongest possible argument for the opposing side. However, I’ve found that even the most educated individuals often struggle with this. It’s as if they lack the mental flexibility to take someone else’s perspective—or perhaps they’ve never considered it a worthwhile exercise. This is ironic, given that education should impart this skill.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Wait!!! I thought that education was supposed to move us from a childlike religious state to a mature nonreligious thinker. Could it be that as we gain in education we gain in our understanding that there is more than materialism?
Ryan Burge 📊
@ryanburge
In a survey of 477,000 Americans, here's the share who identified as non-religious by level of education.
The most likely to be nones?
Those who did not finish high school - 32%
The least likely?
Those with a masters degree - 20%. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
A few years ago I knew that if someone from the left did not want to deal with an opponent's arguments then he or she would launch a charge of racist, sexist, homophobic, transphobic, or bigot. I was at a loss to think of how this happened on the right.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
One feature of ID politics is that losing the struggle, or even compromising on the struggle is not acceptable. Thus, opposing viewpoints cannot be accepted. So name calling is acceptable as a way to shut down potential debate.
George Yancey
@profyancey
In short, the right has accepted many of the bad habits that was on the left. ID politics is a drug that shuts down debate. That is one of the reasons why it is poisonous to our political economy.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
If the Christian influencer you are following spends more than 80 of the time telling how bad those right(left) wing Christians are then find new influencers. That absolutely does not sound like Christ.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
As much as I disrespect Gaetz I am going to withhold judgment on this dispectable charges until I find out why a Biden Justice Department decided not to prosecute him. Due process means more when you defend people you do not like than when you defend people you do like.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Once again my prohuman blog.
Prohuman Foundation
@prohuman_org
"Compassion doesn’t mean abandoning your principles or stifling your joy. What it does mean is recognizing the humanity in those who lost."
@prohuman_org advisor @profyancey for Prohuman Pathways:
open.substack.com/pub/beprohuman/p/winning-and-losing-wit… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have started to be an advisor for an organization called Prohuman. I invite you to check us out. In the meantime here is a blog I wrote for them.
beprohuman.substack.com/p/winning-and-losing-with-grace?t… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I saw the ugliness of many of the statements by leaders of the ID politics left years ago. Now we are seeing the powerful backlash against those comments. The fall of the prominence of DEI and antiracism is tied to an unwillingness to consider other opinions as worth their time.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Now I am seeing a similar ugliness in the statements of some in the ID politics Christian right. If they are not careful backlash will find them as well,
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
There is a recent controversy over using the term “woke right” Those who are said to be part of the woke right say that it is a bad term. And for once I agree with them. It is a bad term and should not be applied to them.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Woke is tied to a certain set of political policies. It is not just a methodology but there is a certain vision cast from those who are said to be woke. This vision is clearly not shared by the ideological right.
George Yancey
@profyancey
For the record, I am not crazy about the term woke anyways. At one point it had descriptive value. But now it is used in such a derogatory way that value is gone. I only use it here to make my point.
George Yancey
@profyancey
There is a better term I believe that captures what is happening on the left and the right. That term is identity politics. So we should talk about progressive identity politics and conservative identity politics instead of woke left and woke right.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Identity politics is basically defined as the organization of politics by looking after the interests of marginalized groups. It originated on the left but since 2016 it has become a more prominent feature on the right.
George Yancey
@profyancey
On the left the marginalized groups are racial and sexual minorities while on the right they are whites and conservative Christians. To be sure I have done research on racism and Christianophobia. Both are real.
George Yancey
@profyancey
So my complaint with the ID politics left or ID politics right is that they are not tackling real issues. My complaint is how they are dealing with those issues. They are dealing with them in a way that is unnecessarily polarizing.
George Yancey
@profyancey
The similarities between the two movement really stand out when you ignore that they have different end goals. For example, both the ID left and the ID right do not encourage debate. They want you to accept their ideas on face value.
George Yancey
@profyancey
For example when @NeilShenvi was criticizing ID left they refused to debate him saying that he was not qualified without a doctorate in a applicable field. That was insane. He is well read in the literature and incredibly smart.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Now that he has started to criticize ID politics right they refuse to debate him for an even sillier reason. Because he goes to J.D. Greear’s church. No need to tackle ideas you do not like if you can find an excuse not to right?
George Yancey
@profyancey
Furthermore both the ID left and the ID right are willing to make allies with anyone who can further their cause. On the left if it is a Marxist who wants to overthrow our society that is fine.
George Yancey
@profyancey
On the right if it is racists and Nazis that is fine. You think I exaggerate but I have read individuals on the ID right state that they will work with a Nazi or racist if that is what it takes to defeat the woke.
George Yancey
@profyancey
One last similarity, and there are more. On the issues pertaining to the core of their political beliefs there is not room for compromise. A way this looks like on the ID politics left is that anything that is said to be racist is racist.
George Yancey
@profyancey
If a POC says something is racist then we cannot discuss if they are correct or not. It is racist. On the ID politics right a way this looks like is that any discussion of institutional racism is taboo.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Anything other than a pure colorblindness mentality is a threat to whites and those is not allowed. Discussions on how our institutions can work against the interests of POC are avoided.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Of course the ID left and the ID right are in a death battle against each other. But in that battle they fail to see that they have much more in common with each other than they realize.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Indeed what the ID left hates about the ID right are likely techniques that they themselves are engaging in. Vice versa with the ID right. But they are so embedded in the battle that they do not have the introspection to see this.
George Yancey
@profyancey
As stated before I think both sides have legit concerns. I am working on ways to address them is a better way. As it concerns racial issues I promote a technique of collaborative conversation to promote consensus instead of division.
George Yancey
@profyancey
As it concerns Christianophobia, much of my research is there to bring awareness of this issue out there and I often speak on this topic when asked. Consensus and awareness are real solutions to these real problems.
George Yancey
@profyancey
But in the meantime I will still fight against the ID left and ID right as they seek to deepen our polarization and bring everyone to heel at their commands. That will never solve the problems we have.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I do not want to hear that you are opposed to political violence on Jan 6 but okay with it against an insurance CEO. The reality is that you are okay with political violence when it suits your political desires.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Anyone who is cheering the assassination of the insurance CEO is basically OK with using political violence to achieve his or her goals. There is no way around that.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
One of the complaints about progressive Identity (ID) politics is their refusal to debate. Here we see an example of conservative Christian ID politics doing the same thing.
Neil Shenvi
@NeilShenvi
William, you’re welcome to keep tweeting. But, as I’ve offered for months, I think public debate on this topic would be helpful for many people:
This post is unavailable. See it on X.Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
On the left they refuse to debate or platform “racists” or “transphobes”. On the right they refuse to debate the “woke.” Heaven help us if those racists or woke make a good point and we have to rethink our ideas.
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have conservative and progressive positions on different issues. So I do not see the biggest problem as ideological. This biggest problem is the poisonous way ID politics has worked its way into how we do politics today.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
There appears to be a growing anti-semistism/holocaust denialism among politized conservative Christians. Perfectly predictable once a NETTR approach is adopted.
Josh Daws
@JoshDaws
The Jews aren’t the reason you haven’t accomplished anything. Stop listening to losers filling your mind with excuses. Man up and take responsibility for your life.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Happy Thanksgiving Everybody!!
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
There is a paper going around the past few days that has show serious problems with DEI. Here is link to it - networkcontagion.us/reports/instructing-animosity-how-dei…
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
The dirty little secret is that the vast majority of diversity programs have not been properly academically vetted. We are using a trial and error approach and it has mostly been error. So these results should not surprise us.
George Yancey
@profyancey
The sad part is that what we hope to do with diversity programs is laudable. We are trying to create a society where we learn to accept each other and work together. We are seeking to create community after centuries of racial abuse.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
So if you want to find a better way to meet the very real needs that DEI is trying to address consider how we can have better and more productive communication with each other. I think collaborative conversations accomplish this task.
George Yancey
@profyancey
But if you have a better idea then I am all ears. At the very least let’s stop using the current diversity approaches that have let us down.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
My boys discovered a movie called Beverly hills chihuahua 3. Which means that we will eventually have to watch that and 1 and 2 as well. Feel free to pray for me.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Fascinating analysis by the Pirate. Showing how relatively little discrimination can have a substantial impact on the experiences of racial minorities forcing us to think more deeply about how we can remedy this and reduce racial alienation.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-discrimination-paradox
"36% discrimination from the target’s standpoint results from acts of discrimination occurring only 1.8% of the time." -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Good. He should be nowhere near the position of AG for the United States.
www.yahoo.com/news/gaetz-withdraws-trumps-pick-attorney-1… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Just found out that Campolo died. He profoundly impacted my walk as a young Christian. He certainly will be missed.
x.com/i/trending/1859220165772116142 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some Democrats wonder how anybody can vote for Trump much less a majority of the nation. There are important sociological dynamics behind their surprise. Let’s take a few minutes and look at that.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
Those on the bottom (women, people of color) generally know more about those on top (men, whites) than vice versa. For those on the bottom knowing the powerful was important to survival.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Those on the top had no strong incentive and thus could take those on the bottom for granted. Last week I pointed out that progressives have the power in our society.
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I have waited almost a week to write this post to be sensitive to those still mourning over the election. But now I want to add my observation about what has occurred. Many reasons contributed to the Democrats' loss but one is not emphasized enough.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
I think there are important advantages for progressives to understand conservatives, particularly if they want to understand the appeal of Trump and how to short-circuit his impact in the coming years.
George Yancey
@profyancey
But they will have to make the commitment to listen to conservatives in an honest manner if they want that knowledge. There is no other way.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Well this is disgusting. If Trump will nominate Gaetz, why should information be withheld about him? Given that he will be chief law enforcement officer it is relevant if he broke the law right? www.cnn.com/2024/11/15/politics/johnson-ethics-report-gae…
George Yancey
@profyancey
I think this is another case of Trump poisons everything. I see a lot of Christians defending the nomination of Gaetz. They seem uninterested in evidence that he may be guilty of statutory rape.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Think they would not be interested if this was a report on Adam Schiff? It is harder to take seriously claims of double standards when the so clearly are applying one here.
George Yancey
@profyancey
I would not vote for Trump but I can understand the case for doing so. What I cannot understand is doing so and then trying to give hin a rubber stamp. Not holding him accountable. Not working to make him a better president. But I guess that is just me.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Well said
Jennifer Erin Valent 🇺🇸🇺🇦
@JenniferEValent
🧵My heart is truly heavy right now in regards to a large swath of the Church in this nation. You may not like hearing me talk about it so much, but it is the greatest crisis of the faith I've seen in my lifetime. We have always fallen short in areas, no doubt. But what...
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
That post a few days ago keeps getting traction. wng.org/podcasts/culture-friday-political-pushback-173161…
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
What is the worst kid movie of all time and why is it the emoji movie?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have come to expect just about anything from Trump but nominating a potential statutory rapist who is about the least effective congressmen surprised even me. Hang on tight America. It is going to be a wild ride for the next four years.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
MAGAs choice lost out. Give me some hope that Republicans will from time to time resist the massive overreach that I think we all know is coming.
www.yahoo.com/news/republicans-reject-trump-allies-pick-1… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have heard it said that this election killed Identity politics. Wounded maybe but not killed. And unfortunately conservative identity politics, in the form of Trumpism, is alive and well. Vigilance is still warranted.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Great analysis. I agree with about 90 percent of this and would use some different terms. I especially think we need a party that is culturally conservative and economically progressive.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Well. Did not think I get that much attention for that post. Happy to have new followers. Just know that I am neither a Democrat nor a Republican so if you can handle me punching both directions then welcome aboard.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I have waited almost a week to write this post to be sensitive to those still mourning over the election. But now I want to add my observation about what has occurred. Many reasons contributed to the Democrats' loss but one is not emphasized enough.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
The capture of cultural institutions allow progressives to paint their enemies as unacceptable. As racist, sexist, xenophobic, bigoted etc. Cancel culture is a real thing and a weapon used by the left.
George Yancey
@profyancey
But to those in the working class this comes off as bullying. It is one thing when using culture pressure to truly protect the marginalized. It is quite different when the powerful use it to shut down those with uncomfortable ideas.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
It is tempting for those on the left to keep believing in their own superiority. To believe that people vote against them for their own racism, prejudice, ignorance or such. That belief will blind Democrats to their own failings.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Democrats you are the Man. Consider that as you look to the next steps you will take and be open to learning from and about those you may see as beneath you. IMHO that is the best way you can move forward.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I just saw a post where a Christian said he was fine working with neo-Nazis. I do not like when people say that to vote for Trump is to vote for racism. And I have stated that Trump engages in race-baiting but I lack the evidence to call him a racist.
George Yancey
@profyancey
But this is one of the unfortunate consequences of his win. He has encouraged real racists and the acceptance of them. Unfortunately that encouragement can be seen among some on the Christian right.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
The problem with calling your political opponent a Nazi goes beyond unfair stigmatizing. Nazis are not worth listening to. This makes it impossible for you to understand them and address the needs they articulate. Trump is the wrong solution to legitimate concerns.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
If you supported Trump then congratulations. The people have spoken. But remember what it was like to lose. Have some grace for those who are now extremely disappointed. Allow for some crazy talk out of their mouths and some denial. Be gracious rather than gloating.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Agreed.
Dwight McKissic
@pastordmack
Though it will be tempting, America must avoid at all costs becoming divided into the pro-trump and anti-trump citizenry.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Hispanic voters swung hard toward Trump, especially men. My guess is that when we analyze this election that is going to be a major story.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I do not know who needs to hear this but God did not call us to convert people to be disciples of the Republican party but to be His disciples. And just so I am not misunderstood that applies to the Democrat party as well.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
It is heresy to place partisan political demands as the price for salvation or sanctification. It denies the essence of our faith.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Yes identity politics on the left is bad but Christian identity politics is quite a drug.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I do not know who my pastor will vote for president tomorrow-----and I like it that way. He is free to call out good and evil in a bipartisan manner.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Wow. Did not know so much heresy is out there. Or I must have missed the verse saying that Jesus required pastors to support a political party. Maybe one of these fine theologians will point that verse out to me.
George Yancey
@profyancey
What!!! No verses. Not surprised.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I think this is on point.
Casey Mattox
@CaseyMattox_
If you're perplexed how it's possible that the other team could possibly have a roughly 50% chance of winning when their candidate is so objectively terrible, consider the possibility that it's because of (1) your candidate and (2) the expansion of executive power.
Half your fellow citizens aren't evil and seeking your ill. But they are terrified of what your candidate would do and know that we've turned the presidency and the executive branch he/she controls (or should control) into a behemoth that threatens their liberty. This is what we have to change. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Seriously, is Biden trying to get Harris to lose???? #nomoreridingwithbiden
www.cnn.com/2024/10/30/politics/biden-garbage-gaffe-analy… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This time next week we may not know who is the winner of the presidential election but we will have a good idea of who the winner is. So let me ask the half of the country who is disappointed one small favor. Please do not burn the country down.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I see progressive Christians saying you cannot be a Christian if you vote for Trump and conservative Christians saying you cannot be a Christian if you vote for Harris. Somehow I think both groups fail to understand what it takes to be a Christian.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Good word Mark
Mark DeYmaz
@markdeymaz
After 41 yrs of FT ministry I’ve learned a thing or two bc I’ve seen a thing or two. IMHO pastors who endorse a candidate a) alienate 1/2 of those they might otherwise point to Christ as they are forever associated w/the candidate & b) will at some point take a hit as their man/woman inevitably disappoints. Better to endorse faith, peace, hope, and love for all not just some in Jesus’ name, for the sake of the Gospel. (Matthew 5:9)
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I do not always agree with Conor but I d o on this. Trump poisons everything.
Conor Friedersdorf
@conor64
I have argued before that Trump brings out the worst in segments of his fans and foes alike.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
If you want to know why the American people are not worried about losing their democracy to Trump despite all the attacks from Democrats where here is a major reason why.
www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/3201957/reductio-ad-hi… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Amen!!!
Justin Giboney
@JustinEGiboney
I’m voting for whoever sends me the least spam texts! 😂
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Unexpectedly my research in other matters has led me to do work on the fears progressives have, a deeply understudied area. This World article allows me to share some of my findings with the general public.
wng.org/opinions/are-conservative-christians-driven-by-fe… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Instead of "Trump is the end of democracy" message Harris needs to talk more about what her administration will look like. Anyone who can be convinced by the "end of democracy" message has already been convinced and seems to alienate the working class.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/oct/22/harris-work… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Jesse is right. This is a fantastic piece which should be read widely.
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
Fantastic piece by Paul Bloom on how ideological slant undermines the credibility of certain social scientific findings. This should be widely and explicitly acknowledged as a problem at least as serious as the replication crisis. smallpotatoes.paulbloom.net/p/progressives-should-worry-m…
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Yep.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Word!
George Yancey
@profyancey
I don't think so. Trump is not who I think when it comes to pro-life economic policies.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Ryan keeps producing fascinating stuffl
Ryan Burge 📊
@ryanburge
We asked evangelicals if someone could be a good Christian and be a Democrat.
59% agreed.
27% had no opinion.
14% disagreed. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
DEI appears to limit conversations we can have and less support for free speech all while not creating a more comfortable atmosphere on those campuses. If only there was a better way to do diversity.
Is DEI Destroying Free Speech on Campus? (substack.com)
George Yancey
@profyancey
Oh wait. There is a better way. www.ivpress.com/beyond-racial-division
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Good stuff from Trevin Wax.
Trevin Wax
@TrevinWax
New post - In recent weeks, there’s been considerable conversation about the reasons why people drop out of church or walk away from their Christian convictions.
Let’s consider three theories often thrown around.
www.thegospelcoalition.org/blogs/trevin-wax/why-do-people… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Somehow the 34-3 yesterday feels sweeter than the 49-0 of 2 years ago. #ifyouknowyouknow
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Seriously. Is this even a question?
Christina Crenshaw, PhD
@CrenshawPhD
Whataburger is better than In N Out.
I said what I said. 😆 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I got around reading Shepards for Sale. A lot has been said and I do not want to repeat some of the common criticisms. But rather one issue leaped out at me. Someone else may have mentioned this but I have not seen it.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
I think from the perspective of participants of Christian ID politics, it is inconceivable that a Christian would not accept their political perspectives unless they were being bought off. Their politics helps to define their Christianity.
George Yancey
@profyancey
But the better answer is that not all Christians see politics in the same way and that is okay. We need better discussions with our brothers and sisters rather than attribute the worst motivations to others. Cheers.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Yep
Neil Shenvi
@NeilShenvi
It doesn't take courage to offend people you despise and whose support doesn't affect you.
It takes courage to offend people you admire and whose support you depend on. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Party in power: If we do not win the world will end.
Party out of power: If we do not get into power the world will end.
And yet the world never ends.
#everyfouryears -
George Yancey
@profyancey
What is amazing is that Trump leads among Hispanics who make immigration their number 1 issue. The Hispanic vote is certainly up for grabs.
www.realclearpolitics.com/video/2024/09/29/kornacki_donal… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Can the election be over yet? That way we can go down to our normal level of hatred for each other.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
As the topic of the Billy Graham rule has come up I might as well add in my 2cents. Yes, I have my version of the BG rule. It goes like this. A nonfamily woman will not be in the room alone with me with the door closed.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Over the past 10-15 years of so I can only think of two times where that happened. One was when I had to talk to my female chair. She was in charged and so she set the rules of the encounter.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Two was during a hurricane where the only people in the area was I and the female administrative assistant. We were instructed to go to an interior room and close the door. So nature set the rules of that encounter.
George Yancey
@profyancey
As much as I have control I enforce my BG rule. Has it hampered my ability to mentor female students? Not at all. When they visit me in my office the door is left open. If they must talk to me about a sensitive topic we go for a walk.
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have mentored probably more than a dozen female students and none of them complain. So do I need this to fight off temptation? Well anyone who thinks that temptation is impossible is a fool.
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I do not want to seem overconfident, but it is highly, highly, highly, highly unlikely that I will have an affair. Without getting too personal about my thought patterns, that is not something I struggled with.
George Yancey
@profyancey
So if that is not a great struggle for me then why enforce a BG rule? Ironically many of the same people who get mad when a man has a BG rule are the same people who convinced me that I need such a rule.
George Yancey
@profyancey
You see, early in my career I noted that certain people were eager to find men who abused their power. Too eager and sometimes they ruined that man’s life because he could not prove his innocence.
George Yancey
@profyancey
I hate it when men abuse their power. But I also do not want my career ruined by false accusations. The BG rule does not offer absolute proof of my innocence, but it does provide me with some weapons to use if I am accused.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Because I have a pattern of not allowing a nonfamily woman in a room alone with me, an accuser will have a burden that I relaxed the rule just for her. Without additional evidence it will make her accusation seem unlikely to be true.
George Yancey
@profyancey
In a post Duke lacrosse world, the argument that a women will never lie about being abused has gone by the wayside. So my concern about a false accusation is not without merit.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Remember what happened to Kavanaugh? He was accused of attempted rape with no evidence of time or place of the event. Just the word of a single woman was all that was needed.
George Yancey
@profyancey
When people protested tat Kavanaugh had not due process they were told that such protection are only if we are going to throw you in jail. So for many one’s job can be taken away without due process.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
I will end with this. Two times in my life I got into a serious discussion with a woman who was upset at my BG rule. Both times I asked them if they would defend my due process rights if I was accused of sexual assault.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Neither one of them stated that they would defend me. Well, under those circumstances, I don’t feel bad defending myself.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Class and education may be supplanting racial identity as the best predictor of who people vote for.
www.liberalpatriot.com/p/how-trump-wins -
George Yancey reposted
Michelle Zier
@MichelleLZier
Can we all agree that this guy is the worst?
America, stop the petty internal disputes and distractions and get it together. He is inciting a potential WWIII. Multiple major battles with key players are raging on the global chessboard. If China invades Taiwan it will be chaos.
Khamenei.ir
@khamenei_ir
In this battle that Lebanon & Palestine are currently engaged in, the infidel & evil enemy is equipped with the best resources and backed by the US. The Americans claim: “We aren’t involved. We are unaware of things.” They’re lying! They are both aware and involved.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Curious that Wolfe would take a statement where Owens is affirming that there is no racial requirements to be party of the Christian family to take on Owen. Not everyone in the Christendom has white-ethnocentric inclinations but those inclinations are there.
Stephen Wolfe
@PerfInjust
Owen’s young children are not his people.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I don't know who needs to hear this but if your Christian faith mostly consists of bad mouthing other Christians then you don't have much of a Christian faith.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I made the comment a couple of days ago about lying and promoting Christian values in response to Daws. He has altered the original statement and in fairness I should post it.
Josh Daws
@JoshDaws
It’s always the dumb flippant tweets that go viral. 🤦🏻♂️
This was a slapdash response to an article by @DennyBurk that I should have quote tweeted to make the context clear. While there is a strong theological case to make for the justification of deception in the opposition to evil (Rahab, Hebrew midwives, etc.), bearing false witness is a sin. The truth matters. I was too cavalier in this tweet.
By “enjoy it”, I meant that Christians need not feel guilty watching @MattWalshBlog’s movie because I don’t believe he sinned in making it. Rather than just “owning the libs” as Denny put it, Matt is exposing a dangerous and divisive grift that spreads a wicked and destructive ideology that needs to be opposed. I applaud Matt for the work he does. Any deception he used to expose these people was justified. It was not sinning for a good cause. It was not a sin at all in my opinion.
Still, a lying tongue is something that God hates. We shouldn’t run around employing deception willy nilly which was Denny’s larger point which I agree with.
Most people thought this tweet was admitting that the reports about Haitians in Springfield were made up. I wasn’t thinking about those at all when I tweeted. Fabricating disparaging reports about a group of people to win an election would be wrong. Sharing reports from citizens of Springfield is just that. Sharing reports on the ground. If they turn out be be false they shouldn’t be perpetuated. That still seems to be uncertain either way.
Let me reiterate that bearing false witness is a sin. While I do believe that there are strong theological arguments for the utilization of deception to oppose the enemies of God, most of us are hopefully never going to be in situations that require that and should strive for honesty in all of our dealings and especially with something so trivial as social media. Opposing the left does not give you license to sin.Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
Since I have not seen “Am I a Racist” I will not comment on the deception used in that film. But I will state that deception should be a last resort to achieve an overwhelming moral good. That is a high standard that I would apply to Walsh’s work.
George Yancey
@profyancey
If the goal is to argue against diversity training, there are many good arguments that can be made without deception. I have made them myself. That seems to be a better path than anything deception can offer.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
There is an argument that there is a time and place to lie to promote Christian values. However, lying to protect Jews during the holocasut does not have the same moral weight as lying to "own the libs."
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have criticized conservative Christians lately so let me offer commendation for Burk's confronting deception in Walsh's latest film. Only when we are willing to call out those on our side can we then turn down the toxic rhetoric burdening our society. wng.org/opinions/is-owning-the-libs-a-justification-for-l…
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
As I have said before, liberal consistently scare me more than conservatives. It does not occur to him who gets to define misinformation or hate speech does it?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
This connection to what BLM did and what Trump is doing is apt. As a scholar I prefer systematic data but unfortunately the ability to create spectacle is superior to get political outrage than well designed studies.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is good news. My boys are not on social media and 16 is the absolute lowest age I will allow them to be on it. Be nice to have accounts age appropriate and ready for them when we allow them to engage in social media.
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
I am cautiously optimistic about Meta’s new teen accounts. It is the biggest and best step forward I have seen from them. It establishes the principle that minors are not adults and must not be exploited in the ways that adults can be exploited. It establishes 16 as an important age threshold below which teens need more parental supervision in the virtual world. It establishes that there is something deeply wrong about any platform where adults from all around the world can so easily get into direct contact and photo sharing with children who lie about their age and say that they are 13.
Of course, this is just a first step in reforming an ecosystem that badly needs a simpler, more robust way to identify minors and install real age gating, especially for those under 13. Most of the problems with social media will still plague teens on Instagram. But this is a good start, and I hope it is just the first of many steps from Meta.
These new teen accounts will make it easier for Meta to create differentiated experiences for youth and comply with the requirements of KOSA, which Congress is currently considering. It is vital that Congress pass KOSA, to establish a duty of care and a set of other requirements for ALL of the platforms that now own our children’s attention and their childhoods. KOSA puts all the companies on a level playing field with minimum safety standards.
www.nytimes.com/2024/09/17/technology/instagram-teens-saf… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
How in the world has Haitians eating Fido become a national issue? Well, Trump is running for president that is how. Probably his stupidest comment of the debate night and that is saying something.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Man, did you see that debate? Talks about eating pets and post birth abortion. This election cannot get any more strange.
Biden: Hold my beer. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
RIP James Earl Jones.
Courtney Howard
@Lulamaybelle
As we all grieve the immense loss of actor James Earl Jones (Star Wars, The Lion King), I wanted to celebrate one his funnier milestones, reading Letterman’s best Top Ten List, reciting commercial jingles with his spectacular, powerful, booming voice. #ripjamesearljones
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Every day I am watching Christians on the right and the left throw away their Christian witness so that they can take a shot at their political outgroup. It is quite depressing.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Come watch this video and see me in my ugly purple shirt!!
www.summit.org/resources/podcast/beyond-racial-division-a… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Yeah. This.
Anthony Bradley
@drantbradley
If you're a Christian and you think that the other side is an existential threat to the existence of X or Y, and if you catastrophize about what will happen to "America" if POTUS candidate A or B is elected, you've lost the redemptive plot and need to read the OT & the Gospels.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Demonize much?
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
This video is on target
Phil Vischer
@philvischer
I'm making a fun series of shorts to help Christians survive election season thoughtfully and, dare we say, Christianly. Here's the first one... youtu.be/phi54qOjqmQ via @YouTube
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Those of you who tell me to vote blue no matter who, I gotta tell ya that the Democrats routinely scare me more than Republicans.
Mike Solana
@micsolana
I understand she’s not actually smart enough to understand what she’s asking for here, but threatening social media platforms with the DOJ in order to silence “hate and misinformation” (as defined by her) is horrifying dictator shit
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Support for free speech is getting lower.
Nico Perrino
@NicoPerrino
FIRE's new survey of 59k college students is out.
Unfortunately, a significant percentage of them have disastrously illiberal ideas about free speech.
- 32% said that using violence to stop a campus speech is acceptable to some degree — up from 27% last year and 20% two years ago.
- 52% said that blocking other students from attending a speech is acceptable to some degree — up from 45% last year and 37% two years ago.
As @TheFIREorg co-founder Alan Charles Kors once said, “A nation that does not educate in liberty will not long endure in liberty, and will not even know when it is lost.”
We have our work cut out for us. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Not surprised. I do wonder if the greater adaptation of ID politics by liberals may account for this difference.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
If you chided pro-life Christians as "Big Eva" but were willing to give Trump a pass on moving the Republicans towards being pro-choice then you treat your Christian brothers and sisters worse than you do nonbelievers. You should repent.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Good for the editor!! This is a major reason why people do not trust us scientists. Unless we are willing to fight against such censorship we will never gain the trust of the public.
Benjamin Ryan
@benryanwriter
Editor resigns as publisher blocks criticism of decision to retract paper on gender dysphoria
Springer Nature has halted an accepted paper by @profjmb criticizing the publishing giant’s controversial retraction last year of an article that surveyed parents of children with gender dysphoria, leading an associate editor to resign, Retraction Watch has learned.
Christopher Ferguson of Stetson University in Florida, one of two guest editors of a special issue o Springer Nature’s Current Psychology, which aimed “to stimulate discussion of all aspects of the ‘unpublication’ of scientific articles," resigned from Current Psychology’s editorial board in protest on August 29.
“This is the only time I’ve had an accepted paper overruled in 4 years” as an associate editor at this journal, Christopher Ferguson of Stetson University in Florida, one of two guest editors of the special issue, told us by email. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The way I see third party voting is this. Do you think one of the two major party candidates will be a good president? If you do then vote for him/her. If you don't but refuse to vote third party, then you will just get more bad candidates since you keep voting for bad candidates
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Shades of Divided by Faith
Ryan Burge 📊
@ryanburge
White evangelicals cleary stand apart when it comes their views of the aim of the church.
59% of them say that God is more concerned about individual morality than social inequalities.
It's ~30% of other Christian groups. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
My article on how feeling threatened by conservative Christians is tied to support for racial minorities is out.
Sociological Focus
@SocioFocus
Evidence of the notion, “the enemy of my enemy is my friend” in the context of racial minorities and politics: new research from George Yancey.
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00380237.2024.2390516
#sociology #newresearch -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Newsom basically stopped the reparations bill in California with his amendments. I know there are a lot of angry blacks right now in California. But it is a one-party state so there is not much they can do.
www.politico.com/news/2024/08/31/california-slavery-repar… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I could not have said this better myself.
AuditTheRhetoric 📚
@bookkeepPLUS
1/8: I'm increasingly disheartened by the sheer volume of vile, disgusting posts I come across, only to check the bios and see phrases like "Christ is King," "Christian," "Reformed," and similar proclamations of faith.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I am going to wrap up my posts about Trump and abortion with these posts given that Trump has relented on the amendment. For the record, although I do not like Trump I am glad that he has done so. I do not have TDS and will give credit when it is due.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
And yes Trump helped to overcome Roe. But from this point forward we are not fighting a legal fight but one to change hearts and minds. A fight that someone who does not believe in that cause cannot lead us.
George Yancey
@profyancey
Thus, any usefulness of Trump to the cause of life has ended. Those of us who believe in life need to think carefully about what our next steps are to make our case. After the November election, Trump will not be part of that process.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
When I was single, a women found me on a dating site but could not contact me because the profile was dormant. She saw that I am a professor. Searched the local colleges until she found me and then contacted me away from the site. That was a bit creepy to me but this is worse.
internet hall of fame
@InternetH0F
My smile faded so fast 😭
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
It amazes me that there are still Christians defending Trump when he says he will support abortion until birth in Florida. The same ones who attacked me when I refused to support Trump in 2016, 2020, and today. Those Christians need never question my pro-life credentials again.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
When people say that a vote for ASP is a vote for Trump/Harris it is like they are saying that because you are Christian/black/professor that you are obligated to vote with me. And my pushback is no I am not. We each get a vote. Use yours as you see fit and I will do the same.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some conservatives complain about those who coddle left and punch right. And that is a real thing. I have seen those who do this. People who complain about fascism but make excuses about communism which killed more lives. But that is not me. I punch left and right.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
If you want to send Trump a message remember that we still have a pro-life party you can vote for.
@AmSolidarity
Lila Rose
@LilaGraceRose
My personal message to the Trump campaign on abortion:
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
After telling whites to give credit to BIPOC folks DiAngelo has been caught plagiarizing from those folks. This is a reminder that we do not live up to our own values. Our failure to do so is one of the reasons why many of us turn to Jesus.
thehill.com/video/‘white-fragility’-author-robin-diangelo… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am not surprised. I have done research on progressive or mainline Christians and when I hear exevangelisits, they often sound just like progressive Christians.
Ryan Burge 📊
@ryanburge
Where do exvangelicals end up?
In the 1970s:
56% became mainline Protestants.
16% Catholic
20% no religion
In the 2020s:
18% mainline
8% Catholic
59% no religion -
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have pounded the prolife argument for Trump lately and there is a reason for that. It touches a cord in me. In 2016 I announced myself as a NeverTrumper. I got a lot of blowback from a lot of prolifers who said I did not care if babies died.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
So I am not interested in hearing any arguments that we are better off on abortion with him than with Harris. Harris may pass law that punish us externally. But the corruption of Trump is destroying the pro-life movement from within.
George Yancey
@profyancey
It does not take a genius to see which of those threats is greater. Vote for Trump if you must on other issues. But on abortion, as of right now, we have two pro-choice options.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Look if you have another reason to vote for Trump then so be it. But from this point forward, in an environment where debate over abortion can really change laws, linking the prolife movement to support of Trump is counterproductive to the prolife cause.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Make no mistake about it. If you vote for Trump because he is slightly more pro-life than Harris then he has your vote at a very cheap cost. Future GOP candidates will just get as close to the Democrat candidate on abortion issues as possible. This ensure two pro-choice parties
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I think all those prolifers who threw Haley under the bus in their headlong rush to support Trump in the primary are having a serious case of buyer's remose right now. Hey if you feel like Lila come to the @AmSolidarity The water is fine and you get to keep your self-respect.
Lila Rose
@LilaGraceRose
Trump/Vance have recently said:
Trump would VETO a national ban on abortion.
They support “access to” abortion pills (60% of all abortions).
They think it’s California’s “right” to permit abortion up until birth, but if states like Arizona ban most abortions they “go too far.”
Due to their increasingly pro-abortion position, Trump/Vance is stretching the lesser of two evils voting strategy to an untenable position.
Without some indication that they will work to make our nation a safer place for preborn children, they are making it impossible for pro-life voters to support them.
Being less passionate about killing babies then Harris/Walz is not enough. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Word
Perry L Glanzer
@PerryGlanzer
One clear failure of Christian discipleship is acting like Christian citizenship largely involves the decision made in one three-second moment in the ballot box every four years instead of a lifetime of virtues and practices related to excellent citizenship.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
More of this please. Let's de-escalate our toxic discourse.
Benny Johnson
@bennyjohnson
INCREDIBLE MOMENT: Van Jones and Vivek meet for the first time.
Van Jones’ unhinged rhetoric on CNN led to death threats against Vivek & his family.
At first meeting they effectively told each other to f**k off.
Then Van returned and something truly remarkable happened… 👊🏼🇺🇸This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
If you are pro-life, like I am, you have horrible choices, that were set into motion when prolifers supported Trump in 2016. You either vote to ratify a prochoice Republican party or you vote for a Democrat party that will try to throw prolife protestors and those who expose
George Yancey
@profyancey
abortion clinics that sell body parts into jail. Or you can go third party which I think is the best option to show that your vote cannot be taken for granted. @AmSolidarity
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I have come to realize that my recent increased interest in ID politics is because ID politics is an anathema to what I am about right now. On both the left and right ID politics is about finding solutions for my group while I support finding solutions that can work for everyone.
-
George Yancey reposted
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
Seen a few Christian nationalism (CN) threads going around today, so it seems like a good time to highlight some problems with the concept. It isn't just that the term is vague, but that the anti-CN discourse is anti-pluralistic and politically sectarian. Here's why. 🧵 1/
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Interesting. I have also seen longitudinal data on racial attitudes that took a dramatic change around 2012. And longitudinal data on mental well-being also show a drop in it around this time. What happened in this period of time to bring such changes?
George Yancey
@profyancey
If we had a academia that was interesting if finding the truth behind social trends we have a lot more research on the importance of the early 2010's instead of them producing yet another screed against white evangelicals.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Pretty much!!
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
There are a few things less sophisticated than the idea that empowering someone to decide what opinions are and are not allowable is somehow smart or enlightened. It's a religious belief in power to do the right thing, which is belied by history and human bias.
Liberalism, including freedom of speech, is a much more sophisticated idea, positing that a decentralized system, where we don't lobotomize our collective/societal brains, works to the benefit of the advancement of human knowledge in surprising and often counter-intuitive ways.
I'm tired of people who just think “power who agrees with me needs more power”, is the erudite response. That's an old, ancient, elitist oversimplification, that endlessly and predictably lies to itself that it is in fact, new and clever. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Folks. If the only reason you go on X is to bash a certain group of people. You are not being mean or radical. You are just being boring.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Jesse Smith is quickly becoming one of the most important critics of the way Christian Nationalism is conceptualized and studied. This paper is dynamite.
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
See my latest critique of Christian nationalism (CN) lit in sociology. I draw a parallel between theories of CN and dispositional authoritarianism, showing how they make largely similar claims and so have the same problems. Long 🧵 1/ onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/socf.13014
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Given that conservative Evangelicals let Trump sell them out on abortion I have no desire to attack Evangelicals for Harris. Nonetheless, they should vote with their eyes wide open. As Jake points out no way she gives them a fair hearing on abortion. mereorthodoxy.com/evangelicals-for-harris
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
There are X accounts that I look forward to seeing because they offer fresh and new insights. And those I dread seeing since they consistently provide the same old propaganda. Please make X more interesting and strive the be the first type and not the second.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Those of us in third parties have 3 times the power of everyone else. Cool.
American Solidarity Party 🧡
@AmSolidarity
Triple your voting power with this one weird trick
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
There may be a book to be written outlining the way progressives have influenced evangelicals. But it cannot be as sloppily written as Shepherds for Sale. As someone who has written on Christianophobia, I know that to critique progressives you better have done the research right.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
By the way. I think the reasons I give in this thread about evangelicals voting for Harris also apply to the phenomenon some of called "coddle left and punch right."
George Yancey
@profyancey
A lot of comments on social media about the emergence of Evangelicals for Harris and French’s pronouncement that he will vote for Harris. Some Christians feel betrayed. As a NeverTrumper who is NOT voting for Harris, I have a few thoughts about this.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
A lot of comments on social media about the emergence of Evangelicals for Harris and French’s pronouncement that he will vote for Harris. Some Christians feel betrayed. As a NeverTrumper who is NOT voting for Harris, I have a few thoughts about this.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
So to please their new friends, many will give in to that pressure and vote for the Democrat presidential candidate. Doing so makes life easier in their new social circles. Do not underestimate the power of peer pressure.
George Yancey
@profyancey
So the psychological need for hope and social pressure from new progressive colleagues are my theoretical reasons why many former conservatives not only refuse to vote for Trump but also will vote for Harris. Maybe one day I will test that theory.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
Must be fun to be @NeilShenvi
The left - You cannot talk about CRT because you are a chemist.
The right - You cannot talk about Shepard for Sale because JD Greear's is your pastor
Seems like everyone wants you to shut up when you speak words they do not like. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
The article claims this as unbiblical
"Greear both advanced the idea of how “love thy neighbor” should have informed COVID responses and affirmed his intention... to advance diversity."
This is a serious problem with Christian identity politics. A thread.
rlo.acton.org/archives/125798-money-power-and-evangelical…Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
But there is more to our faith than sleeping with the proper person and believing the right things. Esteeming others greater than ourselves. Loving our enemies. Knowing that we can not take pride in any of our accomplishments.
George Yancey
@profyancey
These things will distinguish us more than political victories. Indeed, in some ways engaging in political fights is easier than doing the introspection we need to draw closer to Christ and to be ready to serve others.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
Some will accuse this of third wayism or being woke or being naïve. So be it. I hope that at least some who are caught up in Christian Identity politics will at least consider if this is truly the most holy path they can be on.
George Yancey
@profyancey
If only a few begin to revisit whether this is the best way to spend their spiritual capital then it will be worth the criticism. Have a blessed day everybody.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I do not personally know Basham. But I am friends with J.D. I believe him and trust his honestly.
J.D. Greear
@jdgreear
An Open Response to Megan Basham’s Shepherds for Sale jdgreear.com/an-open-response-to-megan-bashams-shepherds-…
George Yancey
@profyancey
This was denounced as unbiblical in review supporting Basham.
"Greear both advanced the idea of how “love thy neighbor” should have informed COVID responses and affirmed his intention as (now former) SBC president to advance diversity."
So loving neighbor and diversity are bad?
George Yancey
@profyancey
Here is the review
rlo.acton.org/archives/125798-money-power-and-evangelical… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
An abstract of my latest publication links feeling threatened by conservatives to support of progressive racial attitudes.
www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00380237.2024.2390516 -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Looking forward to reading this thread.
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
See my critique of the Christian nationalism literature in sociology, out in Sociological Forum today. Will post a thread later. onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/socf.13014
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am back on X after a social media fast. I fasted for two reasons. First, I just need it from time to time. But second, I lost my youngest brother a couple of weeks ago. One thing that has taught me is to appreciate people while they are here. Be kind to each other everyone!
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
You know if stopping disinformation in all its forms is important then we should be all over this repackaging of Harris. And the poster is correct in that this type of cynical retelling of history makes is more difficult to trust the media and that creates problems.
AG
@AGHamilton29
Let me explain why this gaslighting attempt from the press isn’t just wrong, but irresponsible and dangerous.
They don’t understand the consequences. The bias is annoying, but it’s unlikely to sway many voters at this point. Too many persuadable Americans already don’t trust the mainstream press. But that’s the real problem.
They’ve completely decimated the credibility of a key societal institution. The press actually serves an important function in a well-functioning society, but they’ve undermined that function with their activism and shenanigans. So many of our political problems can be tied directly to that. This isn’t just one kid, it’s a continuous pattern.
This was such a stupid thing to lie about, but when people see such brazen dishonesty from the press, they start to question everything else. That opens up a space for people to increasingly believe conspiracies and adopt the view that everything the press tells you is fake.
It allows grifters who then question true narratives and real facts to gain substantial audiences just by saying the opposite of the media/mainstream beliefs (ex: That’s how you end up with “the Nazis were the victims in WWII”). The logic goes “if they are willing to portray something as obvious as Biden’s decline as a conspiracy until 3 weeks ago, then I should assume everything they label as a conspiracy is actually true”
Of course that’s terrible logic, but it’s just how people think.
And that’s exactly how you end up with a populace that’s increasingly divided, bigotry running rampant, and a society where people can’t distinguish wrong from right. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Guys. If you want to know where the girls are at. They are in college!!!!!
Nancy Pearcey
@NancyRPearcey
Today more women than men graduate from university:
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am not voting for Harris but if you are going to vote for Trump do not bring up Harris's sexual past. You lose the right to do that and support someone with the morals of Trump.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
I am doubling down on the comment I made about kindness with this operation. There is a tendency to subvert our faith to our cultural values. This happens with both conservative and progressive Christians.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
There is a time for Christians to stand strong. But more often we should seek to love and be winsome. In some ways, it is easier to stand strong and demand our rights than to be kind and seek the good for others.
George Yancey
@profyancey
But seeking the good for others is the type of countercultural mentality that we should be striving for as Christians. Have a blessed Sabbath.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
People who tell me that you have to vote for Trump if you are pro-life are wrong. He is now in the process of undoing the good that was done by the Supreme Court.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
There is a push against "winsomeness" from some conservative Christians so that any talk of kindness, even from a theological conservative like Winger, is condemned. It is as if they are not reading the same Bible that I am reading.
Mike Winger
@MikeWingerii
I’m surprised by the amount of pushback I got on the word “kind” here.
I get it. A lot of evil has been done in the name of being compassionate, thoughtful, or nice.
But let’s not erase “kind” from our Christian commitments. “Kindness” is one of the fruits of the Spirit according to the Bible.
Rather, let’s have such a good understanding of our Christians commitments that we know what godly kindness looks like in the context of situations that require us to be bold as a lion. -
George Yancey
@profyancey
Why do people think that people like me who do not want either candidate owe them my vote. If you want it then let your political party earn it.
www.yahoo.com/news/christie-spars-view-hosts-over-2125254… -
George Yancey
@profyancey
This is having principle over tribalism. If you hate cancel culture, then you hate it no matter who traffics in it.
Michelle Zier
@MichelleLZier
Why can’t we just let people be jerks online? So they’re acting ghoulish applauding the death and misfortunes of others. Getting them fired and doxxing them is ghoulish too. It’s becoming the monster we claim to be fighting. It’s all a manifestation of soul sickness—all of it.
-
George Yancey
@profyancey
We came a few inches from national disaster on Saturday due the actions of an unhinged lunatic. We still are feeling the effects of his attempt to assassinate Donald Trump. Our next steps are important as we try to move forward.
Post not available here, view on X
George Yancey
@profyancey
To my conservative friends now is a great time to find common ground with progressives and decry hateful propaganda in all of its forms. But only if you do not seek to keep progressives on the defensive will you find success in such an effort.
George Yancey
@profyancey
You see as ugly as yesterday’s attack was there is the potential that we can go against the madman’s attempt to drive us apart and instead come together. But that will take great effort on our part.
George Yancey
@profyancey
And it starts with trying to see things from the other side. So before you decide what to do next in your interaction with political outgroup just ask yourself the question – what if Biden had been shot?
















































