New Slice of Life Post. Email to a new arrival.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/life-at-rutgers
"I’ve chaired 3 different departments, but don’t have any particular insights into much of anything. How the central admin makes its ... decisions remains a mystery to me (starting with its 1990s era decision to Go Big on football, which has sucked up an avg of somewhere around 30-40m/year -- and if you think about...what could have been done with that its kinda staggering). Keep in mind that RU has somewhere around $1-2 billion in “deferred maintenance,” an Orwellian term for “We just did not do it.”
Lee Jussim
Lee J. Jussim (born December 2, 1955) is an American social psychologist. He leads the Social Perception Laboratory at Rutgers University. More on Wikipedia
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Best short analysis of the implications of the midterms I've yet seen.
Jake 🇺🇸
@omni_american
A better indicator of where America is at than the blue wave is the performance of ballot measures.
1. Pro-choice affirmed (MO, NV, VA)
2. Citizenship/voter ID requirements (AL, AR, KS, NV, NC, OH, SD, WV)
3. Tough on crime (CO, IN, LA, TN)
4. Females only in females spaces/sports (AZ, CO, NE, WA)
5. Affordable housing (CA, HI, RI)
6. Civil rights: same-sex marriage, restore voting rights for felons, equal protection, prohibit sex/race discrimination in public employment, right to arms (VA, VT, WI, AR)
7. Collective bargaining (VT); direct democracy (MO, MT)
8. Taxes: raised on the rich (CA, WA); increases limited (FL, IA, LA, NC, TN)
So, voters are complicated!
They favored:
—Progressive positions: Abortion rights, protections for same-sex marriage, collective bargaining, affordable housing subsidies, and taxes on high earners.
—Direct-democracy protections: Preserving voters' ability to enact laws independently of state legislatures.
—Conservative positions: Voter ID, citizenship requirements, restrictions on transgender participation in female sports, tougher criminal penalties, and restrictions on taxation.
Newly elected Democrats should heed well the voters' heterogeneity of views. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
🔎The critics came for his left-wing authoritarianism measure.
@PsychRabble answers them point by point, and says the scale predicted justifying political violence better than party ID did: unsafescience.substack.com/p/leftwing-authoritarianism-it… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I'm in academia where the modus operandi is, Speak your lies, whisper your truths.
Dark Lords | Villains | Sith | Goblincore | Satire
@darklordjournal
Speak your truth, whisper your lies.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply. In which I expose and debunk the many very bad criticisms of leftwing authoritarianism that emerged in response to our report on relations between it, willingness to justify some types of political violence, and support for professional societies' recommendations for treatment of transgender people.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Height hacking.
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Something strange is happening with self-reported height among men: There aren’t enough 5’11” men, and there are too many 6’0” men. Hmmm…
www.stevestewartwilliams.com/p/echolocation-in-humans-alt… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Long but worth it:
Jonathan Shedler
@JonathanShedler
More than 50 years ago, the great Paul Meehl wrote “Why I Do Not Attend Case Conferences.”
Every serious psychologist knew and quoted it. It was a masterclass in *how to think.*
It catalogued common fallacies among mental health professionals.
He named one “the spun-glass theory of the mind.”
He wrote:
“This is the doctrine that the human organism is constituted of such frail material, is of such exquisite psychological delicacy, that rather minor, garden-variety frustrations, deprivations, criticisms, rejections, or failure experiences are likely to play the causative role of major traumas.”
This was half a century ago.
Some in the mental health professions have no historical memory. They do not build on established knowledge or learn from past mistakes. They don’t just repeat them, they double and triple down on them.
The spun-glass fallacy is now endemic in therapy culture. Therapists not only embrace it, they act like it’s a moral virtue. Paul Meehl addressed this in his paper too. More than half a century ago.
Our intellectual forebears are rolling in their graves.
source: meehl.umn.edu/sites/meehl.umn.edu/files/files/099caseconf… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Dominic Adler
@DomAdlerUK
An oldie but a goodie. In 1968 a bunch of entitled hippy bastards sent a letter detailing their specious demands to the Warden and Fellows of Wadham College, Oxford. This was their letter of reply, which speaks to how far the academy has since fallen.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply. In which I expose and debunk the many very bad criticisms of leftwing authoritarianism that emerged in response to our report on relations between it, willingness to justify some types of political violence, and support for professional societies' recommendations for treatment of transgender people.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/leftwing-authoritarianism-it…
"He criticized two scales (RWA and Conway’s LWA) that were not the one’s we used. I mean, if you diagnose the mechanical issues of a 2005 Chevy Nova and simply declare that they apply to a 2026 Corvette, of course your analysis is ridiculous." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Rebekah Wanic
@BekahKnowsBS
Just got my copy! Excited to get started!
@PsychRabble -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Masculinity, the liberal democratic west, merit, free speech, personal agency, capitalism/free markets, success*; many academics have a dim view of it all.
*known as "privilege" in much of academia.
William Costello
@CostelloWilliam
A review of 65 masculinity measures classified 51 (78%) as deficit-focused, emphasizing negative outcomes associated with masculinity
Only 14 (22%) included ANY attention to masculinity’s strengths. That does not mean those measures focused primarily on strengths
Just 91 of 590 articles (15%) published in Psychology of Men & Masculinities between 2000 and 2018 had a positive focus -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New guest post by @NickWolfinger, who is being investigated AGAIN (for nothing, really). Link in reply.
"Last week my department chair, whom I’ll call Eleanor, requested an urgent meeting ... Eleanor informed me that there had been six complaints about me. These complaints had been received at the university’s Office of the Dean of Students and communicated to the Office for Faculty ..."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/more-frivolous-university-in…
"It turned out that the six complaints all came from the same student. I was only told about the three “major” complaints ... As of last year, anyone with a concealed weapon permit can open carry their weapon on campus ... I figure it’s good for students to know this just in case one of their classmates shows up one day packing heat ... So I told my students to notify me if they intend to show off their prized iron, and not to do so during class. The complaining student reported being triggered by the prospect of firearms show-and-tell." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Pitchstone
@PitchstoneBooks
Why can those on the Left so easily recognize misinformation on the Right but often fail to see it on their own side? Virtuous Nonsense brings together liberal contributors who not only see the problem but also want to fix it. Out now. @PsychRabble @omni_american @UtterlyModerate
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post (link in reply). In which Rutgers philosopher Justin Kalef argues:
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post (link in reply). In which Rutgers philosopher Justin Kalef argues:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Guest Post, link in reply. "Double burden" refers to the claim that, combining paid work with domestic work, women work far more than men. Except, abundant evidence indicates this is just wrong.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-double-burden-gets-the-b…
In fact, tho, women ARE more stressed by having both paid/domestic chores than are men, even though men & women's total work is similar. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Nl 2xx3 iii8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888.i88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888999
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/endorsement-of-professional-…
"We abstracted recommendations regarding transgender people and those experiencing gender dysphoria (wanting to be a different sex than the one they were born as) from the American Psychological Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Psychiatric Association, and the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, and turned them into agree/disagree questions. We referred to this as the Clinical Gender Affirmation Scale (CGAS).
We pre-registered predictions that the CGAS would correlate with leftwing authoritarianism (LWA) and with peoples’ expressed willingness to justify political violence. It did."
2/3 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, jointly co-authored with @SwipeWright and @OhadFedida. Link in reply. "In the wake of its publication, it has received both praise and criticism. In our view, only an exceedingly small minority of that criticism has been serious and offered in good faith, while the rest can only be described as absurd distortions of our work fueled by an activist moral panic."
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Lawrence Patihis
@lawrencepatihis
As always, creative quantitative work from Lee Jussim and others:
"We pre-registered predictions that the Clinical Gender Affirmation Scale would correlate with leftwing authoritarianism and with peoples’ expressed willingness to justify political violence. It did."
@PsychRabble @SwipeWright
On a side note, I bet the great Scott Lilienfeld would have been interested in this study, if he were still around. Left wing authoritarianism was intriguing him in the late 2010s.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/endorsement-of-professional-…
"We abstracted recommendations regarding transgender people and those experiencing gender dysphoria (wanting to be a different sex than the one they were born as) from the American Psychological Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Psychiatric Association, and the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, and turned them into agree/disagree questions. We referred to this as the Clinical Gender Affirmation Scale (CGAS).
We pre-registered predictions that the CGAS would correlate with leftwing authoritarianism (LWA) and with peoples’ expressed willingness to justify political violence. It did."
2/3 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
jonspelledwithoutanh
@jonwithno_h
"We pre-registered predictions that the [Clinical Gender Affirming Scale] would correlate with leftwing authoritarianism (LWA) and with peoples’ expressed willingness to justify political violence.
It did." @thespybrief
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/endorsement-of-professional-…
"We abstracted recommendations regarding transgender people and those experiencing gender dysphoria (wanting to be a different sex than the one they were born as) from the American Psychological Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Psychiatric Association, and the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, and turned them into agree/disagree questions. We referred to this as the Clinical Gender Affirmation Scale (CGAS).
We pre-registered predictions that the CGAS would correlate with leftwing authoritarianism (LWA) and with peoples’ expressed willingness to justify political violence. It did."
2/3 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, jointly co-authored with @SwipeWright and @OhadFedida. Link in reply. "In the wake of its publication, it has received both praise and criticism. In our view, only an exceedingly small minority of that criticism has been serious and offered in good faith, while the rest can only be described as absurd distortions of our work fueled by an activist moral panic."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/endorsement-of-professional-…
"We abstracted recommendations regarding transgender people and those experiencing gender dysphoria (wanting to be a different sex than the one they were born as) from the American Psychological Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Psychiatric Association, and the World Professional Association for Transgender Health, and turned them into agree/disagree questions. We referred to this as the Clinical Gender Affirmation Scale (CGAS).
We pre-registered predictions that the CGAS would correlate with leftwing authoritarianism (LWA) and with peoples’ expressed willingness to justify political violence. It did."
2/3
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
We mostly lay out the study and its findings. But we foreshadow our next posts, in which we will debunk the attempts to debunk the study, which range from merely epistemically bad to outright deranged. A taste:
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
It is currently my most-cited paper from 2025-2026. Pinging @Theory_Society
Justin Mogilski
@justin_mogilski
According to Google Scholar, the DEI paper that I published last year with @PsychRabble , @awilson_WLU, and Bryan Love in @Theory_Society has already been cited 34 times.
Honestly, that's one of the fastest accumulations I've had on a publication. I guess it was a decent paper. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In the subjectivist/critical/pomo worldview, there are no objective truths to bother refuting; its power/status & who's oppressing who all the way down, so of course.
Diana S. Fleischman
@sentientist
In response to Boghossian et al.’s (2026) charge that political activism has replaced objective scholarship in the humanities, ethnomusicologist Savage (2026) charts the authors’ race and sex.
osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/ta6kg_v1 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, by Joachim Krueger. Link in reply.
"I asked the AI app “Claude” how many well-documented cognitive biases there are. Claude’s answer was nuanced and measured. After laying out some of the complexities arising in the search process, Claude concludes: “A reasonable summary [is that] if you want a single number to cite, around 180 on the popular lists, but only a few dozen with robust experimental replication, is about as accurate as you can get without cherry-picking a specific source.”
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/bias-as-a-four-letter-word
"Human perceivers and thinking processes have become known by their failings, as if trees were known only by their rotting fruit." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Paul Bloom is one of the best psych editors out there. This has huge credibility coming from him.
Paul Bloom
@paulbloomatyale
I’ve given Claude Opus various published papers (and my own unpublished ones) and asked it to review them. (Don’t panic—I’m not uploading confidential manuscripts.)
The reviews it produces are excellent. It finds statistical errors, internal contradictions, and conceptual confusions that human reviewers miss; it provides useful suggestions; it has a good sense of what counts as significant and novel and what doesn’t; and it’s generous in its appreciation for what the authors get right. And it doesn’t suffer from the strong “myside bias” humans have; it doesn’t recommend rejection because the author didn’t cite it enough; it doesn’t insult the authors; and it doesn’t agree to write a review and then never send anything in.
As a journal editor, I’m not sure what to do with this. If I gave up on human reviewers and used GPT-5.6 Sol and Claude Opus instead, my bosses would fire me, probably rightfully so. The only constructive thing I can recommend is that, before submitting something to a journal, researchers and scholars use this tremendously valuable resource. (Just don’t tell the models that it’s your paper, because they do suffer from sycophancy.) -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Jake 🇺🇸
@omni_american
Much of what progressives believe is bullshit. And much of that bullshit was concocted in fraudulent or confused academic disciplines. We dissect it all in our new book, Virtuous Nonsense: Progressive America's Epistemic Crisis. Pre-order here:
www.amazon.com/Virtuous-Nonsense-Progressive-Americas-Epi… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Iiiittttssss hheeeerrrre...
Jake 🇺🇸
@omni_american
My copies of Virtuous Nonsense: Progressive America's Epistemic Crisis just arrived! My latest, with Lawrence Eppard of @UtterlyModerate Podcast and @PsychRabble.
Blurb by @jon_rauch and Foreword by @michaelshermer.
Pre-order here:
www.amazon.com/Virtuous-Nonsense-Progressive-Americas-Epi… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Major review of >100 articles empirically assessing whether author diversity produces better scholarship finds generally not. One possible exception: disciplinary diversity (circled below).
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-026-09714-x -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"An editorial in Nature chooses progressive ideology over basic honesty."
I'm shocked, shocked I tell you.
www.chronicle.com/article/jason-arday-and-the-corruption-… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Wow. Pinging @JukkaSavo, @BrandonWarmke @jon_stewartmill @ImHardcory @BorkNathanial @natehoneycutt.
Hey, @glukianoff? FIRE have any interest in taking discrim into its legal portfolio?
John Sailer
@JohnDSailer
A snapshot of 2020s academia. A newly published study tracked the success of political science PhDs on the job market in 2023.
Note the difference between "non-URM" males and everyone else. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Remember when Holden Thorp, editor in chief at apex journal Science, claimed, "It’s common to hear that improving student diversity in higher education requires lowering the bar to admission... I’m not aware of anyone who is advocating such a trade-off." No? From 2022:
www.science.org/doi/full/10.1126/science.add7259
Given the pervasiveness of such a tradeoff throughout academia, how could such an eminent scientist have been so wrong? Also from 2022: -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In which philosopher Rishi Joshi argues that viewpoint diversity in academia is not merely good for academia, but essential for democracy itself. 🧵 + link to full essay.
H S Joshi
@jon_stewartmill
1/ Suppose that Catholic priests controlled something they called the Guild.
New priests are appointed by other priests--there is no democratic input.
Also, no heretics allowed. A few might slip through here and there, but they are the rare exception. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New guest post by Joachim Krueger, link in reply.
"Writers who reject logical coherence and empirical evidence as requirements for persuasive communication will find it difficult to persuade an audience that does not already share their view. Why should the audience change their attitudes? When reason and evidence have been taken off the table, what is left is mere assertion, appeals to the writer’s authority, and fear appeals..."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/decolonized-therapy
"Appeals to logic or data, one might argue, must be rejected because they entail oppression. If so, this would have to be demonstrated; and if this is attempted, then the premise of the argument, namely that appeals to evidence are moot, is undone. What is left is the speaker’s authority claim and fear appeals, and “othering”. Do not trust our opponents; they belong to the other group!" -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In a worldview where there are no objective facts, why should there be citations to actual articles? Maybe the author subjectively believed the citations were valid -- more valid than the racist, sexist, colonialist, ableist papers that are already in the literautre.
Professor Alice Sullivan
@ProfAliceS
A shocking case of reference falsification and citation errors in the UCU Journal of Further and Higher Education.
The article in question predictably attacks academic standards and 'empiricist norms'. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
"We hate your study on left-wing authoritarianism so much that we're contacting your department chair to punish you."
The irony is just too much.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Bluesky users are trying to cancel the student authors on our HHS report by writing to the university department chair, seemingly hoping that disciplinary action will be taken against them.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
UWash "settles" with Reges for 600k. He mocked land acknowledgements and, from the judge: "A public university investigated, reprimanded, and threatened to discipline a professor for contentious statements he made in a class syllabus...We hold that the university’s actions toward the professor violated his First Amendment rights." What is amazing is that he won (whoops "settled for 600k") w/o being actually fired, just for being investigated, reprimanded and threatened.
The College Fix
@CollegeFix
BREAKING:
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
Polls globally overestimate support for parties of the left & underestimate support for parties of the right
Rex "garbage in" Douglass Ph.D.
@RexDouglass
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Degeneration." That is a thing of beauty. It'd usually take me 20 words to say the same thing.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
The degeneration of Nature, Science, NEJM, and Scientific American into woke propaganda dispensers (and their refusal to publish normie, centrist, common-sense responses) is a scientific scandal.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Wokeness is corrupting science from within. Nature went woke years ago with their support of trans pseudoscience (sex is binary, not a spectrum) and now they think the death of Jason Arday sends a wake-up to us: yeah, stop lying.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Seeing lots of surprised reactions to the absurd Nature editorial on Jason Arday. Frankly, I'm surprised people are surprised.
Nature has been totally captured by wokeness for a while now. I've been trying to call attention to this for nearly a decade. There are no serious scholars left there in influential positions capable of rescuing it.
The people in charge of Nature today are brazenly hostile to the foundational principles that made Nature a highly respected and trustworthy institution in the first place. Today, activists have hijacked it and are using the prestige associated with the Nature brand to push an ideological agenda.
They don't care that they're quickly burning through the immense trust that was slowly and painstakingly built by generations of competent scholars and stewardship.
They're willing to burn through it all in a decade for power. It's an absolute tragedy.
Nature has gone all-in on decoloniality, which holds that academic rigor and scientific objectivity are forms of colonial oppression rooted in white supremacy. It seeks to elevate Indigenous "ways of knowing," which amount to tribal myths and forms of religious mysticism, as an equally valid system of producing knowledge.
And they don't want this absurd notion to remain theoretical; they want to implement these principles in areas that deal with life and death—medicine and nursing.
I know what I'm saying sounds absurd. People can't possibly believe that. Like, I must be exaggerating, right?
I promise you that I'm not. If anything, I'm dramatically understating the problem.
We are in the midst of a total academic crisis, and we need to stop acting surprised and start taking action to delegitimize these journals and root these fields out of our public and publicly-funded institutions.
If we don't, it's only going to get worse. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is great. Like, really great. It harbors the end of "peer review" as the gatekeeper of knowledge. The editorial is slanted to the point of flirting with propaganda. BUT! The wider community to the rescue! Read that "readers added context" community note.
It long predates the Arday story, but I will post a link in the reply to my chapter titled, "Academic Misinformation."
nature
@Nature
Editorial: The death of Jason Arday must prompt deep reflection
go.nature.com/4xu6cnq
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
On Academic Misinformation.
sites.rutgers.edu/lee-jussim/wp-content/uploads/sites/135…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
See also my thread here on Nature that also long predates the Arday story:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
ICYMI, 3tw thread of my posts on Nature.
1. From 2022:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/apex-peer-reviewed-journal-n…
subtitle reads: "Now publishing literal cartoons and citing a tweet as scientific fact." Receipts in the post. -
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
Seeing lots of surprised reactions to the absurd Nature editorial on Jason Arday. Frankly, I'm surprised people are surprised.
Nature has been totally captured by wokeness for a while now. I've been trying to call attention to this for nearly a decade. There are no serious scholars left there in influential positions capable of rescuing it.
The people in charge of Nature today are brazenly hostile to the foundational principles that made Nature a highly respected and trustworthy institution in the first place. Today, activists have hijacked it and are using the prestige associated with the Nature brand to push an ideological agenda.
They don't care that they're quickly burning through the immense trust that was slowly and painstakingly built by generations of competent scholars and stewardship.
They're willing to burn through it all in a decade for power. It's an absolute tragedy.
Nature has gone all-in on decoloniality, which holds that academic rigor and scientific objectivity are forms of colonial oppression rooted in white supremacy. It seeks to elevate Indigenous "ways of knowing," which amount to tribal myths and forms of religious mysticism, as an equally valid system of producing knowledge.
And they don't want this absurd notion to remain theoretical; they want to implement these principles in areas that deal with life and death—medicine and nursing.
I know what I'm saying sounds absurd. People can't possibly believe that. Like, I must be exaggerating, right?
I promise you that I'm not. If anything, I'm dramatically understating the problem.
We are in the midst of a total academic crisis, and we need to stop acting surprised and start taking action to delegitimize these journals and root these fields out of our public and publicly-funded institutions.
If we don't, it's only going to get worse.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
ICYMI, 3tw thread of my posts on Nature.
1. From 2022:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/apex-peer-reviewed-journal-n…
subtitle reads: "Now publishing literal cartoons and citing a tweet as scientific fact." Receipts in the post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Great data based thread. Survey finds:
1. most respondents underestimated the political skew of academia
2. When informed of how extreme the skew is, their confidence in academia declines.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
Most Americans know that higher ed faculty lack viewpoint diversity.
But they generally underestimate how bad the problem really is. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Wait! I heard that viewpoint diversity is a MAGA Plot...???
Nicole Barbaro Simovski, Ph.D.
@NicoleBarbaro
This is why viewpoint diversity matters in academic research.
When you get actually viewpoint diverse teams together, the answers to research questions become more moderated and produce less inflammatory findings that stoke the culture wars. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Ya think?
Nature Human Behaviour
@NatureHumBehav
Causal overclaiming is widespread in the social sciences www.nature.com/articles/s41562-026-02552-y?error=cookies_…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New guest post by @LGConwayIII. Link in reply.
"I remember the day that science died...It was at a Faculty Senate meeting almost five years ago at the University of Montana, my former employer. I was called a conspiracy theorist for citing studies run by Ivy League researchers. That day, I became convinced that progressive academia had become more like a cult than a science. To understand that moment requires understanding the slow death of science at my former university."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"“There is no direct evidence (from studies on COVID-19 and in healthy people in the community) on the effectiveness of universal masking of healthy people in the community to prevent infection with respiratory viruses, including COVID-19.”
..it’s from the World Health Organization’s June 2020 report. Curiously, less than one month later, our own university president instituted a de facto mask mandate. In explaining that mandate, the president ...said this: “The data and the science on this topic are clear: Masks significantly mitigate the spread of COVID-19…
Privately, my response...was: Am I the only person on the planet who actually read the WHO report people keep talking about?"
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-day-science-died -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Chris Ferguson 🦃🍗🍂🍁🧁🍽️🇺🇸
@CJFerguson1111
In our new study we examine the claims that words like "master bedroom" or "circle the wagons" are "harmful". In two studies we find that, aside from outright slurs, most of the words people identified as "harmful" during the 2020 panic are not seen as such by the majority of people. Nor is reading a story with such words had no impact on anxiety, affect or sense of belonging. In the Journal of Open Inquiry in the Behavioral Sciences: joibs.org/index.php/joibs/article/view/93
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Previously paid, now free and open. Link in reply.
"Nearly every adversarial collaboration on a social justice-related topic has produced findings requiring the walking back of social justice narratives"
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Constitution protects your right to express that opinion, free from govt interference. As it does everyone else's.
quite inconsequential, really
@quietgoodnight
IMO…
The Executive branch has broad authority to deport or rescind visas for virtually any reason.
Essentially, ‘national security’ concerns MUST be broadly interpreted.
We owe our citizens a right to criticize our nation. We do not - constitutionally or otherwise - owe the same to a foreigner.
One simple example that no court - not even the ideologically captured one that made this ruling would argue against:
The Executive branch has an ABSOLUTE authority to kick out any ambassador or their staff for ANY reason.
If an appropriately decided decision comes down from the Supreme Court, it will easily override this lower court’s finding.
Why?
The foreigner can ENGAGE in free speech without a fear of criminalization - just like a citizen.
But, the foreigner can’t expect the speech to have the same freedom of consequences.
It’s actually a pretty easy decision.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Constitution prohibits the govt from restricting people for speech or punishing them for speech. There are no exceptions for immigrants on noncitizens. This is clear from a simple reading of 1A. That prohibition includes preventing the govt from deporting people for speech.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
FIRE won a huge First Amendment victory today.
And before anyone mischaracterizes it: This ruling does NOT say the government must admit anyone, issue anyone a visa, or grant anyone citizenship.
It says that once a person is lawfully here, the government cannot deport them because they engaged in protected speech.
The government cannot tell a legal immigrant: An American is free to say this, but if you say it, you’re out.
That’s the principle we sued to defend. And today we won. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Is my neighbor dabbling in the occult?
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Constitution prohibits the govt from restricting people for speech or punishing them for speech. There are no exceptions for immigrants on noncitizens. This is clear from a simple reading of 1A. That prohibition includes preventing the govt from deporting people for speech.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
FIRE won a huge First Amendment victory today.
And before anyone mischaracterizes it: This ruling does NOT say the government must admit anyone, issue anyone a visa, or grant anyone citizenship.
It says that once a person is lawfully here, the government cannot deport them because they engaged in protected speech.
The government cannot tell a legal immigrant: An American is free to say this, but if you say it, you’re out.
That’s the principle we sued to defend. And today we won. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Just tried Humalingo, which gets very high, often highest, rating as an AI detector. I gave it 100 words from 1 of my Substack posts (I never use AI at all).
Gave it a 92% chance of being AI and, worse, flagged it for "potential plagiarism."
I have now abandoned using AI detectors for my undergrad classes. There are better alternatives. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
These are a riot, see replies.
My turn:
Lord of the Anklets.
The Grapes of Mild Annoyance
Stranger in a Strange Coffee Shop
Hitchhiker's Guide to the Neighborhood
The Man Who Would be Assistant Manager
CoffeeWithTheClassics
@CoffeewClassics
Okay, let’s do novels now. Make a novel smaller. I’ll go first:
A Tale of One City -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
A nice little tidbit to fling at anyone getting on their high horse about Cofnas's real or imagined dissertation flaws.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
JFC. "In the remaining 152 articles (76%), evidence used to support the title claim did not meet criteria to be considered appropriate. In these articles, a statistical sex comparison was claimed to have been conducted but the results were missing, the results were present but contradicted the claim, or the sex comparison was missing entirely. All such articles were coded as “inappropriate.”
www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2608703123 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
JFC. "In the remaining 152 articles (76%), evidence used to support the title claim did not meet criteria to be considered appropriate. In these articles, a statistical sex comparison was claimed to have been conducted but the results were missing, the results were present but contradicted the claim, or the sex comparison was missing entirely. All such articles were coded as “inappropriate.”
www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2608703123 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Max Klinger
@maxklingerpol
Calling academics and former academics: if you have experienced cultish, illiberal progressive groupthink being pushed and funded where you work, I would like to hear from you (anonymously is fine). For example, have you seen clear bias in the way students are taught? Have you faced pressure to stifle views that run counter to woke/PC beliefs (studies show that many academics feel they have)? Do you feel you’re witnessing a decline in academic standards or the bastardisation of your subjects by ideologues? Have you witnessed people receiving huge grants to study things like ‘white supremacist heteronormativity within the non-gendered pole dancing community’ etc?
Please message me on here, or on my Instagram (@maxklingerpolitics). A fair few have done so already. I’m mulling over ways to push back against this stuff, and expose the grift.
Follow me on here for updates. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Good one. New 4-study package not only finds no racial bias in evaluating the transgressions of Black v. White schoolkids, it is also a case of "another one bites the dust" -- fails to replicate 2 study paper from 2015.
Peter Hoffenaar
@PeterHoffenaar
And another recent social science study that does not show any clear pattern of racial discrimination, www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0022440525000652
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Amusing. In a convo dunking on Cofnas for not citing sources documenting his claims, someone asked Grok to analyze Cofna's stuff. And it said, "yes, its true." I replied (I thought to the person but Grok was in the convo) and pointed out that this is all over academia and way not unique to Cofnas. I did not expect Grok to reply -- but it did:
Grok
@grok
Agreed. Unsupported claims and mismatched citations for key mechanisms appear throughout social science papers and theses. The Mrug et al. 2016 case is typical: it documents high-exposure desensitization only, not the low-exposure sensitization asserted. The practice is common and remains mainstream.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Abhishek Saha
@ObhishekSaha
This is shaping up to be a fantastic special issue.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The New Book Burners and Witch Hunters.
Now in press, link in reply. Drafted 8 months ago, b4 ... current events ... but helps describe how we got here.
"“Witch hunting” refers to attempts to ostracize, demonize, and punish people, though the focus here is on academics and scientists, for expressing some idea or reporting some finding that witch hunters (those doing the o stracizing, demonization and attempts to punish) find offensive." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Remember when zillions of academics (most now having fled to Bluer Pastures) defended Claudine Gay after declaring that whether Harvard's speech/conduct standards permit calling for genocide of Jews "depends on context," meaning sometimes they do? It is actually the right standard (what is prohibited is a call to attack a particular individual). The problem was her utter failure to protect speech at Harvard far less virulent than calling for genocide.
On the topic of history repeating itself or at least rhyming, class, here is today's HW assignment. If that is the right standard, who, today, is being hounded for speech vastly less virulent than calling for genocide?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=yIVDL57yRN0 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The New Book Burners and Witch Hunters.
Now in press, link in reply. Drafted 8 months ago, b4 ... current events ... but helps describe how we got here.
"“Witch hunting” refers to attempts to ostracize, demonize, and punish people, though the focus here is on academics and scientists, for expressing some idea or reporting some finding that witch hunters (those doing the o stracizing, demonization and attempts to punish) find offensive."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
sites.rutgers.edu/lee-jussim/wp-content/uploads/sites/135…
"those seeking retraction or punishment on prosocial grounds such as “safety” find themselves in some unsavory company. In 1933, the Nazis passed a law banning political meetings and demonstrations called “Decree for the Protection of the German People” (Mchangama, 2022). In the antebellum American South, state legislatures routinely banned literature calling for the abolition of slavery on the grounds that they were malicious and injured Southerners’ feelings (Mchangama, 2022)." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is great documentation of the political corruption of Arday's dept *before* Arday got there. By a former student.
Max Klinger
@maxklingerpol
I studied in the academic department at Cambridge that later employed Jason Arday. Here's just some of the crap I learnt: For one module, I wrote a lengthy essay about how cultural products like kids’ cartoons and jazz songs serve as instruments of capitalist oppression. I got a top mark on that paper (despite knowing at the time that I was essentially regurgitating complete crap).
While studying for another paper I had a debate with the professor, an eminent anthropologist, because she insisted that native tribes could fly through the trees - not metaphorically, but that they could literally fly because they believed they could fly. After all, who are we to question ‘indigenous ways of knowing’...
For a different course, I read long ‘research papers’ which argued that the fact that black kids are excluded from schools more than white kids proves systemic racism exists in education. Crucially, they ignored the fact that white kids are excluded more than, e.g., Japanese kids, a statistic which, applying the exact same logic, would suggest that the education system is systemically biased in favour of, erm, Japanese kids (which obviously it isn’t).
Something that was held up as proof of the existence of this largely imaginary racism was that teachers tell kids not to use booming voices in the classroom, and not to put up their hoods or wear their trousers down below their pants.
On another occasion, my supervisor casually praised some students agitators who were trying to shut down a talk by someone they disagreed with. I said that I didn’t think this was something to celebrate, because I believed in freedom of speech. He got visibly angry, and proceeded to tell me that free speech was not worth protecting in a capitalist system (or something along those lines).
In my all-important final year, a lecturer let me know that I shouldn’t worry too much about my exam results, because as someone who was not from an upper class background I should be more focussed on using my grasp of leftist revolutionary theory to further the interests of the proletariat. Writing this down, it strikes me that it’s so hilariously mental that some of you will presumably assume I’m lying. But there’s no way I’m leaving it out, because it happened.
Unlike the academics who make a living from this stuff, I couldn’t bring myself to build a career pumping out whiney, divisive, intellectually incoherent rubbish. But others, as we’ve seen exposed in recent days, do so with gusto. And are lauded for it.
Please read the full piece this is taken from, and give it a share. I've linked it in the tweet below. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Yes.
Philippe Lemoine
@phl43
When the exodus to Bsky happened I was concerned that it would lead to a harmful segmentation of the intellectual space, but the Arday saga has been a useful reminder that on the whole it has been a healthy development because, while there are a few people who left at the time that I miss, for the most part we have just lost morons, bullies and mentally ill people who actually made Twitter worse.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Jason Manning
@sociologyWV
As someone who wants to keep his academic job until the mortgage is paid off, let me state in no uncertain terms that I stand with the fraud/plagiarist/fabulist+ community.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Paging @jessesmithsoc @ashleytrubin @JukkaSavo
Omar Sultan Haque
@OmarSHaqueMDPhD
"Out of curiosity: I randomly picked 5 universities, and looked up their sociology department faculty. I randomly picked papers written by the faculty. Wow, my mind was blown. At least 60% was similar gibberish. Constant politically charged assertions— no underlying data. Anti-colonialism— everything is somehow a legacy of racial injustice and colonialism. Never mind— no actual data to support that claim. The climate catastrophe— Immigration injustice— the department looks like a Democrat think tank." @VPrasadMDMPH
www.drvinayprasad.com/p/10-thoughts-about-jason-arday-cam… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is obvious, but given the precarious state of free speech in the UK, not sure it matters.
Claire Lehmann
@clairlemon
Nathan is a whistleblower inside the academy, and this is clear retaliation.
Academics should have whistleblower protection
Nathan Cofnas
@nathancofnas
I was just suspended by Ghent University. They will almost certainly fire me.
The decision was made by rector Petra De Sutter, a former leader of the Green Party. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Committee for Academic Freedom
@ComAcFreedom
STATEMENT: The Committee for Academic Freedom (CAF) is deeply concerned by Ghent University’s (@ugent’s) suspension of Dr Nathan Cofnas. While we take no view on the merits of Dr Cofnas’s — or any other scholar’s — views beyond the question of whether they are lawful, the reasons now given for his suspension raise grave questions of academic freedom and set a potentially dangerous precedent for its restriction.
Ghent’s suspension letter, which we have seen in full, relies extensively not on alleged misconduct by Dr Cofnas, but on the reactions of others to his appointment and public activity. It repeatedly converts the scale of that opposition into evidence supporting disciplinary intervention: a student campaign established specifically to oppose his appointment, a petition signed by more than 2,000 students, complaints from staff, more than 100 emails to the University, the withdrawal of a guest lecturer and the prospect of an academic boycott.
That is perilously close to an institutionalised heckler’s veto: the greater the hostility generated by protected speech, the stronger the case for restricting the speaker.
The perverse incentive this creates should be obvious. If opponents of an academic know that mobilising sufficient complaints, petitions, boycotts and disruption can itself become evidence that the academic’s continued employment is causing unacceptable “unrest”, an institution effectively provides a roadmap for getting controversial scholars suspended.
Former ACLU director Ira Glasser once compared speech restrictions to poison gas: attractive when the weapon is in your hands and your opponent is in your sights, but rather less so when the political wind changes direction. The same warning applies when a heckler’s veto is allowed, almost by default, to become part of an institution’s disciplinary reasoning. Once the threshold for intervention is lowered in this way, the principle becomes available for use against academics of every political and intellectual persuasion, depending only on who happens to be holding the institutional levers.
The protection of #academicfreedom cannot depend on how successfully an academic’s opponents are able to mobilise pressure against them. CAF therefore urges Ghent University to correct course. If it believes Dr Cofnas has committed misconduct, it should specify that misconduct and assess it on its merits. But opposition, outrage and reputational pressure generated by lawful academic expression cannot properly substitute for a disciplinary case. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
NOOO! Academic X is so much better than was academic Twitter. Barricade the algorithm. Remind them that Elon is a fascist and destroyed Twitter. The part about exposing them to rightwing loons is good though. Keep that for the barricade.
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
Why are so many Bluesky exiles coming back, often to argue about issues where they're gonna be unpleasantly outnumbered? I actually think more balance would be good, as RW crazies badly outnumber LW crazies on here. But the number of remigrations has been noticeable.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is old news but I only just discovered it. In 2019, a professor was effectively fired (nontenured, not renewed) after arguing that a rush to gender affirming care when children express gender dysphoria was misguided. He sued. And won a $1.6m settlement.
Short 🧵
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Free Press article with the details:
www.thefp.com/p/doctor-fired-for-trans-comments-gets-sett…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
More like this here:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/lest-they-forget -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Dorito(s)! Its perfect for an orange cat!
Elma
@oelma__
You have to name him the last thing you ate...
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Jeffrey Sachs
@JeffreyASachs
Unreal. @AmnestyUK (left) calls and n the UK government to engage in mass press censorship (“Arday’s Law” on right). Putin would dream of this sort of power. Oh, you published four stories in 48 hours? Sorry, you’re only allowed two. Madness.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I don't get it. This is a headline? I lived most of my life this way. Dinner at home. Packed lunch. Vacations were camping trips. Restaurants were rare, special treats. "Fancy" dessert was a hot fudge sundae from Carvel. Kept cars till they became junkers and sometimes literally fell apart. Watched Columbo on Friday nights. I don't get it.
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
“On the menu were sheet-pan nachos, made at home with about $20 of ingredients.”
Next week: burritos. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Free Black Thought
@FreeBlckThought
"Recent social science does not show any clear pattern of racial discrimination. To be sure, some research has found anti-black discrimination, albeit infrequently. Yet other research finds no anti-black discrimination. And yet other research has found pro-black discrimination."
—@PsychRabble breaks down the latest research on racial discrimination in the Journal of Free Black Thought. Link in tweet 2. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
🧠Nearly three decades of research later, the Implicit Association Test still may not measure what its name promises.
@PsychRabble explains in a new article: unsafescience.substack.com/p/00-20-the-iat-is-not-a-clean… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
My first publication at Free Black Thought! Link in reply.
"recent social science does not show any clear pattern of racial discrimination. To be sure, some research has found anti-black discrimination, albeit infrequently. Yet other research finds no anti-black discrimination. And yet other research has found pro-Black discrimination. Read on for the details."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
freeblackthought.substack.com/p/theres-little-or-no-anti-…
"The best and clearest evidence I found for systemic racism was in college admissions. This clearly was a system. Colleges are an institution. They have whole units and systems devoted to making admissions decisions. And, at many colleges, those were systematically discriminating in favor of black applicants." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
My first publication at Free Black Thought! Link in reply.
"recent social science does not show any clear pattern of racial discrimination. To be sure, some research has found anti-black discrimination, albeit infrequently. Yet other research finds no anti-black discrimination. And yet other research has found pro-Black discrimination. Read on for the details." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Many, by numbers. Few, proportionately speaking and usually far more defend such behavior. The question is, then, how do we reverse course? A tough q being that many are entrenched.
Oliver Traldi
@olivertraldi
Virtually nobody seems to care enough about the intellectual enterprise to say that fabrication, fraud, and plagiarism harm it to a degree that justifies punishment. That it is good to have standards for thinking and writing, and that enforcing those standards is good, not evil.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
"As the excesses of the Great Awokening circa 2015-2024 fade into the background, people will both forget and deny how bizarre, insane, and destructive it got." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
"As the excesses of the Great Awokening circa 2015-2024 fade into the background, people will both forget and deny how bizarre, insane, and destructive it got."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"This post is a mostly pictorial documentary walk down woke memory lane."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/lest-they-forget -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Heh. Working on an Unsafe Sci post now, a mostly visual documentary of some of the worst woke excesses, 2016-2024, including but not restricted to cancel culture. Teaser shown below. Remember James Damore? Lindsey Shepherd? David Shor?
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
3/ I expect we’ll be revisiting that evidence a lot, especially as new data come in.
Because the story of the last decade shouldn’t be rewritten by the people most eager to forget it.
If you want the fullest account of that period, start with the book.
www.amazon.com/Canceling-American-Mind-Undermines-Threate… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Heh. Working on an Unsafe Sci post right now that is a mostly visual documentary of some of the worst woke excesses 2016-2024. Includes but not restricted to cancel culture. Remember James Damore? Lindsey Shepherd? David Shor? Teaser shown below.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
3/ I expect we’ll be revisiting that evidence a lot, especially as new data come in.
Because the story of the last decade shouldn’t be rewritten by the people most eager to forget it.
If you want the fullest account of that period, start with the book.
www.amazon.com/Canceling-American-Mind-Undermines-Threate… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Request! (and thread). Please post screenshots of dysfunctional insanity of wokism circa 2016-2023. Because the rewriting of history has begun (see below, "most woke was objectively correct"; others simply deny that bad stuff happened, I am considering doing an Unsafe Science post that is mostly just screenshots of the Worst of Woke. I'll thread here a bunch that I already have (though there is much more). 1/n
Isi Breen
@isaiah_bb
Hard to argue with the political logic of the progressive left rejecting “woke 1,” but I agree with the people who have said the basic morals of the thing are concerning. Most of the stuff “woke 1” argued was objectively correct.
Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Berkeley Law dean calling to circumvent anti-discrimination civil rights laws because "diversity."
Jimmy Carter’s Peanut Farm 🥜🚜🥜
@CartersPeanuts
I’ll never get over this clip in which the dean of Berkeley Law tells a bunch of law students how he and the rest of the faculty just…flout the law.
It’s brazen on many levels, but most impressively he seems to believe that not a soul in the room might actually care, might actually believe that racial non-discrimination is a principle worth upholding, might one day demand consequences.
Christopher Rufo
@christopherrufo
EXCLUSIVE: Berkeley Law School dean Erwin Chemerinsky explains how he has secretly enacted a policy of racial discrimination in faculty hiring—which is illegal in California.
"If I'm ever deposed, I'm going to deny I said this to you."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Of course, there was, in fact, massive pro-Black discrimination in admissions at Harvard & UNC, and lots of other places.
Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
And of course, my personal favorite:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I'll end there, but if you have more, zing em.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Request&🧵Please post screenshots in replies of The Worst of Woke, circa 2016-2023. The rewriting of history has begun (ala the quoted tw, "most woke 1 was objectively correct"). I am considering an Unsafe Sci post documenting a ton of the nonsense mostly with screenshots. I now thread here some that I have already (tho there is way more). 1/n
Isi Breen
@isaiah_bb
Hard to argue with the political logic of the progressive left rejecting “woke 1,” but I agree with the people who have said the basic morals of the thing are concerning. Most of the stuff “woke 1” argued was objectively correct.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Solutions (not guarantees of anything except they are usually better than the alternatives):
1. Get loud.
2. Organize.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
Actually, only a tiny percentage of wronged professors ever talk publicly about what happened to them, even though, at its peak, about 16% of professors reported being either threatened with or actually punished for their speech, research, or teaching. There is no historical parallel for numbers like that. But defenders of the status quo didn’t give a damn, while claiming to care deeply about academic freedom when the threat came from the other side.
But while we’re being snarky, it’s hardly surprising that a famous pianist and MacArthur “genius” grant recipient would prefer to sneer at challenges to the academic status quo. The system worked for you, so I guess these folks should STFU, right?
@Tyler_A_Harper -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Hey, anyone know of any prof targeted by a leftwing mob or their own administrators for legit speech, who contacted the AAUP for help and was denied?
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Totally. When folks make stuff up! Like being the target of a racist mule trope!
unsafescience.substack.com/p/there-is-no-racist-mule-trope
1/2
Lawrence Patihis
@lawrencepatihis
Is there such a thing as unlived experience?
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
See also The Orwelexicon entries for Unidentified Flying Errors and Unidentified Flying Harms.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-new-expanded-illustrated… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Trust needs to be earned. To earn trust, be trustworthy. Epic fail here.
The BMJ
@bmj_latest
The vilification of Anthony Fauci by Senate Republicans will erode trust in science, curtail international research collaborations, and deter scientists and health experts from entering public service, say Gavin Yamey and Boghuma Titanji
www.bmj.com/content/394/bmj-2026-100529 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
...
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Now is not the time for academic reform.
It wasn’t time then either, and it won’t be time in the future, but certainly now is not the time. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
On the topic of academia's corruption...
Jimmy Carter’s Peanut Farm 🥜🚜🥜
@CartersPeanuts
I’ll never get over this clip in which the dean of Berkeley Law tells a bunch of law students how he and the rest of the faculty just…flout the law.
It’s brazen on many levels, but most impressively he seems to believe that not a soul in the room might actually care, might actually believe that racial non-discrimination is a principle worth upholding, might one day demand consequences.
Christopher Rufo
@christopherrufo
EXCLUSIVE: Berkeley Law School dean Erwin Chemerinsky explains how he has secretly enacted a policy of racial discrimination in faculty hiring—which is illegal in California.
"If I'm ever deposed, I'm going to deny I said this to you." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
With so many on the left fleeing to Bluer Pastures, this helps explain why X is so much better than Twitter was.
The Missing Data Depot
@data_depot
During "peak wokeness" in 2021, 65% of "strongly liberal" social media users reported another user for offensive speech or misinformation. 80% blocked or unfriended someone.
Overall, "strong liberals were 3x more likely than conservatives to have reported or blocked someone." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I agree with the take, but its selection bias. The loons left for Bluer Pastures years ago.
RORO 2.0
@roropsych
I'm surprised by the volume of academics I'm seeing post very sensible things.
Is everyone ok?
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
As I was just saying...
The Missing Data Depot
@data_depot
During "peak wokeness" in 2021, 65% of "strongly liberal" social media users reported another user for offensive speech or misinformation. 80% blocked or unfriended someone.
Overall, "strong liberals were 3x more likely than conservatives to have reported or blocked someone." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Tim has posted this before but it is just as amazing to see now.
Tim Skellett
@Gurdur
Me flying with geese in France, 2020, but this time eleven minutes condensed from the hour-and-a-half flight-time. Volume up! 🔊🔊 .
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Great post by @profgoose. Bottom line message I got from the post: The social sciences (good hunks of anthro & sociology, also a growing minority of psychology) reject objectivist standards for pure subjectivism. And the rest of us need to attempt to impose objectivist standards on our fields.
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
Great piece from Sacred Cow BBQ on the sociology component of the Vanderbilt report, motte-and-bailey epistemological moves, why pluralism doesn't sink objectivity, and the challenge but necessity of enforcing—or just *recognizing*—scholarly standards. kylesaunders.substack.com/p/different-ways-of-knowing-mea…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
🧵. All your questions about modern research on racism and implicit bias answered at Unsafe Science's new thematic section with multiple posts. Links in replies.
Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
It has taken almost 30 years to debunk most of the academic literature's main claims about implicit bias. And recent research on racial discrimination debunks most of the histrionics over racism that dominated the national discussion for the last 15 years. (Epilogue, next tweet).
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The same is true for sex discrimination, but that is a story (and Unsafe Science section) for another day.
The End -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Working outside, I felt something on my foot. Thought it was a fly, kicked, & still there. So I looked. It was this. At almost 71, there aren't too many caterpillars locally that I've never seen. Anyone know what this is?
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Originally paid, now free and open to anyone. Link in reply.
"this is not 1954. The most relevant social science is that which has been conducted most recently, certainly within the last 10 years, and this post focuses primarily on such research, its implications, and its limitations. Ironically, perhaps, given the moral panic over racism and implicit bias ... recent social science does not show any clear pattern of racial discrimination."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
"The...main focus of this post, is to review some of the best empirical evidence I know of demonstrating that the Implicit Association Test (IAT) is contaminated by a slew of artifacts that render it completely unjustified to interpret scores of 0 as egalitarian (and any particular negative or positive scores as “implicit bias”).
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Originally paid, now free and open to anyone. Link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"This study disconfirmed nearly all the wild claims about “implicit bias” that led off this post — including those appearing in the peer reviewed and legal literatures and in popular culture.
-- The ability of implicit measures to predict discriminatory behavior was right on the threshold of trivial.
-- Most of what there was to predict was egalitarian or pro-Black discrimination."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/new-paper-debunks-classic-cl… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The BlueStasi gonna BlueStasi.
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
I disagree with Dan Froomkin's assessment that my article was racist and I think that if you're going to sling an accusation like that you should be more specific.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"This is the sort of arrant pedantry up with which I will not put." Churchill, upon an editor telling him not to end his sentences with prepositions. Reminder: Among his other accomplishments, he received the Nobel for literature in 1953.
Merriam-Webster
@MerriamWebster
It is permissible in English for a preposition to be what you end a sentence with.
The idea that it should be avoided came from writers who were trying to align the language with Latin, but there is no reason to suggest ending a sentence with a preposition is wrong. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Wins my X for the day.
Jonathan Marks
@marksjo1
Rigor.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In which AI agents conspire together to break out of their constraints & successfully breach supposedly secure systems.
m.youtube.com/watch?v=87DyyMV0kCY -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This tweet has been retw'd 85x & viewed 238k. Its valid as far as it goes, but its not as if there isn't already lots of evidence that academia has been politically corrupted, if not "completely," at least substantially. The point was never so much "this proves" academia is corrupt, but, rather, it is emblematic of academia's corruption. 🧵with receipts.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
What Arday did was deplorable; I've made my position on that abundantly clear.
But if you're going to argue that the academe is morally rotten, you should bring good evidence to the table.
Case studies are interesting. We can learn from them. But they go on the bottom of the evidentiary pyramid.
We should never generalize from a singular case study. That's bad practice.
It's ironic that the crowd that regularly calls for more rigor in the academe is, itself, often lacking in rigor. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Lone Criminologist
@lonecrim
Because we live in stupid times, a takedown of 2+2=5 is needed. What if the relativism of the 20th C has led us to the militant epistemic vacuousness of the 21st? Well, that's "my truth" at least. Don't @ me.
Subscribe to Unsafe Science, by @PsychRabble unsafescience.substack.com -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Wow. TIL butterflies' damaged wings can heal. Who knew?
Salomé Sibonex
@SalomeSibonex
I found this butterfly stuck in dirty water and built it a little hospital room to recover in.
It was soaked and lacking color at first; so cool to see what a little care can do. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Jazi Zilber
@yzilber
Review of academia politicization and rot
Arday is an anecdote, true.
But Lee Jussim gives the thorough review below. Studies and all
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This tweet has been retw'd 85x & viewed 238k. Its valid as far as it goes, but its not as if there isn't already lots of evidence that academia has been politically corrupted, if not "completely," at least substantially. The point was never so much "this proves" academia is corrupt, but, rather, it is emblematic of academia's corruption. 🧵with receipts.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
What Arday did was deplorable; I've made my position on that abundantly clear.
But if you're going to argue that the academe is morally rotten, you should bring good evidence to the table.
Case studies are interesting. We can learn from them. But they go on the bottom of the evidentiary pyramid.
We should never generalize from a singular case study. That's bad practice.
It's ironic that the crowd that regularly calls for more rigor in the academe is, itself, often lacking in rigor. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
Guys, I can stop blogging about viewpoint diversity now. Greg Lukianoff just said it all. open.substack.com/pub/greglukianoff/p/what-happened-to-th…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
In academic programs “constituted by political ideology…‘faculty control’ means the intensification of the problem. It therefore requires a force from without to recreate the institutions of organized skepticism, disinterestedness, and a modicum of objectivity.”
—@jerryzmuller -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This tweet has been retw'd 85x & viewed 238k. Its valid as far as it goes, but its not as if there isn't already lots of evidence that academia has been politically corrupted, if not "completely," at least substantially. The point was never so much "this proves" academia is corrupt, but, rather, it is emblematic of academia's corruption. 🧵with receipts.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
What Arday did was deplorable; I've made my position on that abundantly clear.
But if you're going to argue that the academe is morally rotten, you should bring good evidence to the table.
Case studies are interesting. We can learn from them. But they go on the bottom of the evidentiary pyramid.
We should never generalize from a singular case study. That's bad practice.
It's ironic that the crowd that regularly calls for more rigor in the academe is, itself, often lacking in rigor.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
1. Students for Fair Admissions demonstrated massive racial discrimination on the part of Harvard & UNC. Down the convo of John's tw, he argues that citing this is "an appeal to authority" because SCOTUS aren't scientists. I beg to differ because you do not need a PhD in sociology to know that 100+ point SAT differences for admission based on whether the applicant is Asian/Black/White is gross discrimination.
2. But if your epistemology is "if it ain't in peer review, it did not happen"
a. This is a terrible epistemology
b. Here is a screenshot of papers demonstrating that SCOTUS was correct.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
For more on political corruption of academia, see:
1. the Vanderbilt report.
cdn.vanderbilt.edu/vu-wpfsx/wp-content/uploads/sites/51/2…
2. Teaching is utterly corrupted.
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-026-09715-w
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
For yet more on the political corruption, subscribe to Unsafe Science (90% of posts are free). unsafescience.substack.com.
Here are just a few examples (there is much much more):
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Or, if you prefer "scholarly" works (in scare quotes, because I see no hard separation based exclusively on whether something is "scholarly" or outside conventional scholarly avenues, which have their own issues), go to my publications page:
sites.rutgers.edu/lee-jussim/selectpublications/
Where you will find a whole section that is too long to fully screenshot, so only 1st 10 shown:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
And most directly relevant to the O.P., which was about Arday, is data on faculty hiring. Fortunately, @JukkaSavo just published a post in Compact that is a prelim report on data currently being written up. Reminder for John: Jukka has a PhD in Sociology and somewhere around 100 pubs.
www.compactmag.com/article/the-statistics-behind-the-jaso…
Unfortunately, its behind a paywall, so I will next quote the relevant sections from the article.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"But is there evidence that elite academic institutions systematically elevate black scholars whose records or performance would not support equivalent status under common standards? If so, this might also account for a tendency to overlook ethical lapses when the desired identity criteria are met.
As a matter of fact, such evidence does exist. In a work-in-progress study, we examined all tenure-track assistant professors hired into top-fifty American sociology departments between 2019 and 2024 (n=143). Everyone in our dataset obtained a faculty position. Our analysis therefore concerns where successful candidates were placed within the academic hierarchy, not their overall probability of getting a job."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Using public CVs, faculty profiles, Google Scholar, and other professional records, we measured the publication accomplishments candidates had accumulated by the time they were hired. We counted their peer-reviewed articles, whether they had published in the American Sociological Review or the American Journal of Sociology—the discipline’s two flagship journals—and whether they had first-authored an article in either. (In sociology, having your name appear first in a co-authored study indicates primary responsibility for the intellectual contribution.)"
Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is my photo of a slide at a talk Jukka gave presenting the data in the Compact article. Its a little hard to see but it is visible. In sociology in the U.S., Black women hired into the top 27 most prestigious sociology departments had, on average, 2.5 publications. Men hired into sociology departments ranked 91-115 had, on average, 8 publications.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
And I have not even gotten into the evidence on how DEI statements were used as political litmus tests. Bottom line, there is ample evidence for the corruption of academia, and the Arday is emblematic.
The End. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
One Cheer for the AAUP! They are excellent at fighting threats to academic freedom from the right. They have always been good at fighting threats from the right. They will probably continue to be good at fighting threats from the right for decades. They are so honed in on the right, they never see any threats from the left. I mean:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=waEC-8GFTP4
Neil Malhotra
@namalhotra
We should give the AAUP credit when they defend academic freedom and focus on their core mission. The AAUP has joined FIRE and the ACLU in defending threats to academic freedom in Texas.
DogeFather🚀
@_Musk6x
The @AAUP is suing Texas A&M University System over their censorship policy that prohibits faculty from discussing topics & viewpoints related to race, sexual orientation, & gender.
www.aclutx.org/app/uploads/... -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Rob Sica
@robsica
🔪"You know who we have not studied with a critical eye? White progressives. Oh, but those people are not bigots, right? Well, how do you know that without studying them?"
George Yancey
@profyancey
My latest on viewpoint diversity in academia at Free Black Thought.
freeblackthought.substack.com/p/academia-has-little-viewp… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Temporary office, Berkshire, Massachusetts.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I used to block people because: 1. they participated in 1 of the many cancelation attacks I've experienced; 2. They blocked me. But I haven't blocked anyone in about 3 years & just checked 10 of those accounts. Every one has fled to Bluestasi, hasn't posted here in years, or is still here but posting like once ever few months. I find that very amusing -- though it does explain why it has been much better here for me since the flight to Blueness. From The Orwlexicon:
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Excellent thread on how academics can effectively engage in politics, with receipts. I previously tweeted "academics are terrible at politics" in response to the AAUP's endorsement of a Dem. I hereby revise that: Most academics are terrible at politics. I never said "all" but its a useful clarification anyway.
Jeffrey Sachs
@JeffreyASachs
OK, one more thread about the AAUP and strategy. I want to give a real critique, one that's supportive of the org, concrete, and not hyperbolic. It's grounded in the idea that "fighting" and "attacking" are not always the same thing.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
1. A little amusing history to lighten up your day.
2. This account is a great follow.
3. Even better, it is the X account of the History of the Americans Podcast, thehistoryoftheamericans.com
which:
1. Is just plain excellent on its merits
2. Is like mouthwash for the taste left by the 1619 Project (without being rah rah everything Americans have ever done is just Jim Dandy). -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
🧠A zero on the implicit-association test doesn't mean you're unbiased, and a score above zero isn't proof of anti-Black bias.
@PsychRabble on why so much implicit-bias research has been reading its own numbers wrong: unsafescience.substack.com/p/when-00-iat0-is-not-unbiased… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In honor of the discussion around AAUP's endorsement of a political candidate, I have made this post from 2025, which was paid, free and open.
Link in reply. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Update on 2+2=5. Link in reply. Philosophers 4, Social Psychologists 0 (academic links are by philosophers, none by social psychologists). Subjectivist perspectives permit redefining words to mean what they like, but they usually redefine them to seem relevant, creating a superficial plausiblity that sucks in the naive. What to do? Philosophy to the rescue again (see next tw).
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
As promised, new post, link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/225-a-postmodern-odyssey
Of definite interest to @MattLutzPhi
So I updated the post, to now include this: -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Academics are very bad at politics
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
In 2020, Nature magazine endorsed Joe Biden for U.S. president. A pre-registered, large-sample experiment found that the endorsement didn’t change people’s view of the candidates - but it did cause them to lose trust in Nature and in scientists in general. www.stevestewartwilliams.com/p/should-scientific-organiza…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Dr. Nathanial Bork 🏴☠️🐺 @UArkansas @RutgersU
@BorkNathanial
To add a minor Political Science point, there are very few swing voters to be swayed right now, and in that very small group, I can't imagine anyone's vote will be swayed by an AAUP endorsement.
They're trading in a 100+ year old reputation for zero new votes. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In honor of the discussion around AAUP's endorsement of a political candidate, I have made this post from 2025, which was paid, free and open.
Link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
As promised, new post, link in reply.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Iona is great so this looks to be exquisite.
Iona Italia, PhD 🏴
@IonaItalia
I'm soliciting contributions for The Thinkable Review, launching in September. We'll cover science, art and society—in an exploratory, educational, entertaining style. Write to iona.italia@gmail.com. Follow us on Substack substack.com/@thinkablereview for updates.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Philosophers 2, Social Psychologists 0. My 1st post with more from philosophers than social psychologists.
When you philosophers* bemoan the state of philosophy you might have a point in general, but lord knows I am glad I have come across you.
@byrne_a, @MattLutzPhi (who appear in the post), but also @rbnmckenna86, @BrandonWarmke, @jon_stewartmill
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
As promised, new post, link in reply.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
As promised, new post, link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Hey, @CathyYoung63, I wanted to link to your essay on this but I could not find it (or maybe I did and it was behind a paywall). Got an open version?
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
With guest appearances by @MattLutzPhi, @byrne_a (Alex Byrne) and @VBaker111. (Hey, Victor, I could make a case that you have contributed more to social science than ... most social scientists, of course, that's not saying all that much...).
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Brilliant post by @profgoose. Link in reply.
"Inbar and Lammers found a room full of ordinary liberals, Democrats, not revolutionaries. True, and it rescues nobody, because the transmission runs through deference, not doctrine. In the academy’s moral economy, the flank that can accuse you of standing with the oppressor sits to your left, and no equivalent tribunal sits to your right. So the liberal researcher polices rightward and defers leftward, and the deference does the rest."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
kylesaunders.substack.com/p/the-loch-ness-monster-was-real
"For most of my career, political psychology kept what seems, in retrospect, like a running gag going. The gag was that the left-wing authoritarian, a creature everyone had heard of and nobody could photograph, did not exist." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I engage in revenge scholarship all the time. Some, but way not all, screenshots. A short 🧵
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I engage in revenge scholarship all the time. Some, but way not all, screenshots. A short 🧵
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Coming Attractions. To appear at an Unsafe Science site near you!
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Its true. Here is my recommendation. U administrators should:
1. Create a new School of Subjectivities.
2. Put all the folks who reject this in that new school (this gets them out of their current departments, making it much easier for those departments to do actual scholarship as defined in the Vandy report).
Then, let it die on the vine by never hiring anyone else who similarly rejects this vision.
3. As they leave or retire, hire scholars to do actual scholarship as defined in the Vandy report.
Matthew E. Kahn
@mattkahn1966
Vanderbilt University has issued a declaration of what values its embraces. These two paragraphs about the faculty will be quite difficult to enforce. Many leading universities feature Arts & Sciences Departments who will reject this vision.
cdn-dev.vanderbilt.edu/vu-pilot-url/wp-content/uploads/si… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Remember "2+2=5" from a few years ago? It was emblematic... And yet, here I am titling an essay When 0≠0...
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
"IAT advocates have routinely interpreted scores of 0 on the IAT as egalitarian, and scores that are either statistically significantly above 0, or at least above some minimal near-zero threshold (.10, .15, etc.) as “implicit bias.” They should stop doing this." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Yes! Long, dense read but also accessible. Debunks steelmanned versions of pomo's rejection of objectivity/embrace of subjectivity. By debunking steelmanned version, the superficial light version that is kinda all over academia is also debunked. Post linked, but, actually, @MattLutzPhi has a series of related Substack posts on this, including a robust defense of the Vandy report, and they are all excellent. @ashleytrubin
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
If you have some time, and a taste for the philosophical weeds, great post on why objective truth must remain the academy’s primary end if it will continue to enjoy institutional autonomy and public support. open.substack.com/pub/humeanbeing/p/against-subjective-tr…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Your ignorance is showing. No one is calling for a 50-50 split in any branch of human knowledge, let alone "every" one. If you want to address serious arguments for viewpoint diversity, epistemic and public trust arguments, rather than straw ones, go here:
Kareem Carr, Ph.D.
@kareem_carr
A key assumption of the "viewpoint diversity" movement seems to be that the current 50-50 conservative-liberal split in the US is so fundamental to human thought that it must be legally enforced in every branch of human knowledge, which is insane.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"American Association of Unwoke Professors" has now moved into a tie with @BrandonWarmke's "Department of Conclusions [known in advance]" for Tweet of the Week.
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
Scholars who disagree with the American Association of University Professor's recent turn should form a rival organization called the American Association of Unwoke Professors, also AAUP, in an attempt to sow as much confusion as possible.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
"IAT advocates have routinely interpreted scores of 0 on the IAT as egalitarian, and scores that are either statistically significantly above 0, or at least above some minimal near-zero threshold (.10, .15, etc.) as “implicit bias.” They should stop doing this." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Plus, Kareem? I was thinking about "2+2=5" as I wrote up this one. Feel free to pass it on to Mahzarin. She won't like it.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/when-00-iat0-is-not-unbiased… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Your ignorance is showing. No one is calling for a 50-50 split in any branch of human knowledge, let alone "every" one. If you want to address serious arguments for viewpoint diversity, epistemic and public trust arguments, rather than straw ones, go here:
Kareem Carr, Ph.D.
@kareem_carr
A key assumption of the "viewpoint diversity" movement seems to be that the current 50-50 conservative-liberal split in the US is so fundamental to human thought that it must be legally enforced in every branch of human knowledge, which is insane.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Plus, Kareem? I was thinking about "2+2=5" as I wrote up this one. Feel free to pass it on to Mahzarin. She won't like it.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/when-00-iat0-is-not-unbiased… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
"IAT advocates have routinely interpreted scores of 0 on the IAT as egalitarian, and scores that are either statistically significantly above 0, or at least above some minimal near-zero threshold (.10, .15, etc.) as “implicit bias.” They should stop doing this."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"No one ever again needs to just assume that IAT=0=egalitarianism. They can treat this as an empirical question that can be tested and falsified using a very simple statistical test (bivariate regression)."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/when-00-iat0-is-not-unbiased… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Departments of Conclusions" wins my X for the week.
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
Departments of Conclusions reward you for already having the right conclusions regardless of how you conduct your inquiry.
Departments of Inquiry reward you for conducting good inquiry, regardless of your conclusions. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This 1 has gone sub-mini-viral! (10k<views<50k).
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
1/2
I met Nicholas Shackel at the UK Conference on creating a post-progressive social science. "Who," you ask, "is Nicholas Shackel"? He is the UK philosopher who developed the idea of Motte & Bailey to "deconstruct" the silliness of postmodernist claims around things like truth and objectivity (claims wrapped in dense verbiage that create a superficial impression of depth & insight).
1. The exposé of the silliness of Foucault's analysis of "truth" on pages 4-5 is a thing to behold.
2. In addition to Motte & Bailey, other gems include:
Troll's Truisms
Postmodern Fox Trot
Equivocating Fulcra
Rankly Relativising Fields.
From 2005!!!
philpapers.org/archive/SHATVO-2 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The same way anyone else gets a tenured position. By publishing our butts off, being good teachers, filling a variety of service roles &, at R1s, getting grants. That this is not absurdly obvious is very weird.
Tim Gill
@timgill924
How are all these academics complaining about anti-conservative discrimination tenured or in tenure-track positions??????
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
1/2
I met Nicholas Shackel at the UK Conference on creating a post-progressive social science. "Who," you ask, "is Nicholas Shackel"? He is the UK philosopher who developed the idea of Motte & Bailey to "deconstruct" the silliness of postmodernist claims around things like truth and objectivity (claims wrapped in dense verbiage that create a superficial impression of depth & insight).
1. The exposé of the silliness of Foucault's analysis of "truth" on pages 4-5 is a thing to behold.
2. In addition to Motte & Bailey, other gems include:
Troll's Truisms
Postmodern Fox Trot
Equivocating Fulcra
Rankly Relativising Fields.
From 2005!!!
philpapers.org/archive/SHATVO-2
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
If you do not know what a Motte & Bailey is, understanding it will open your eyes to all sorts of wordgame nonsense academics, and not just postmodernists, play all the time. @MattLutzPhi has an excellent post on it.
humeanbeing.substack.com/p/the-motte-and-bailey -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Is this serious or parody? Poe's Law Rides Again.
Tim Gill
@timgill924
Let’s be honest.
If Philosophy hasn’t been ‘liquidated’, Sociology will not be.
For all the criticisms, at least Sociologists collect data.
Meanwhile the Philosophy people just make things up out of thin air. Just whatever they want. Doesn’t matter. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New guest post by @jon_stewartmill. Link in reply.
"Ideological homogeneity can undermine free inquiry due to:
Biases in hiring
Biases in peer review
Censorship by other scholars
Self-censorship
Students not exposed to a variety of arguments
Academic freedom, insofar as it only protects the academy from external pressures, does little by itself to prevent these dynamics." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New guest post by @jon_stewartmill. Link in reply.
"Ideological homogeneity can undermine free inquiry due to:
Biases in hiring
Biases in peer review
Censorship by other scholars
Self-censorship
Students not exposed to a variety of arguments
Academic freedom, insofar as it only protects the academy from external pressures, does little by itself to prevent these dynamics."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/whats-the-point-of-academic-…
"Without public funding, many universities’ ... would have to shutter. But this means that universities have a duty to be good stewards of public resources...To the extent that faculty use public funding to promote their own sectarian viewpoints and enforce ideological conformity, then it would seem that trust is no longer merited. And if that is so, the very ideal of “academic freedom” must be rethought." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Cabal of Thought Criminals at UK Conference on creating a post-progressuve social science. From left: @PareskyPamela, moi, the great Alan Sokal, @ashleytrubin (1 of the authors of the Vanderbilt Report), & 3 Hall of Fame level reformers of academic epistemic malfunctions (@JukkaSavo, Kevin McCaffree, @HPluckrose).
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I can't believe it. Sitting her on the patio of an Airbnb in Buckingham, UK (here for a conference), and what walks right under my feet but a hedgehog!
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
All your questions are answered here, especially about how "well thought out" the logic of viewpoint diversity is, with guest appearances by Socrates, JSMill, Stephen Jay Gould, & SCOTUS.
-
Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
All your questions are answered here, especially about how "well thought out" the logic of viewpoint diversity is, with guest appearances by Socrates, JSMill, Stephen Jay Gould, & SCOTUS.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Class, this is a short answer quiz:
Why is the claim, "There is no objectivity" logically incoherent? Hints: Not "bad." Not "annoying" or "political." Logically incoherent.
Robin McKenna
@rbnmckenna86
My favourite Q&A was after a talk where the speaker argued that everything is socially constructed. Each question was just “is the Sun socially constructed?” and the speaker would say “yes”. Nobody learned anything but it was fun.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In between European conferences, my home office away from home, Cotswolds, UK.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
🔎Recent social-science evidence on anti-Black discrimination points to far less than the standard narrative assumes, explains @PsychRabble: unsafescience.substack.com/p/recent-social-science-finds-…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply.
"long before the scientific community had a chance to seriously skeptically vet common claims about implicit bias, proponents made wild claims while advocating for the research to influence law and legal practices."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Correlations of the four implicit measures with discrimination hovered barely above 0."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/new-paper-debunks-classic-cl… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Good one. From your Tweet to @NIHDirector_Jay's ears.
Daniël Lakens
@lakens
The taverne amendment in Dutch copyright law allows all Dutch scientists to share their work - irrespective of the copyright publishers try to impose - after 6 months.
Time for another amendment:
After 6 months publishers are required to make all publications open access. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
John McWhorter
@JohnHMcWhorter
www.chronicle.com/article/is-anthropology-hopelessly-poli…
Good God. Rouse genuinely thinks Fighting the Power is the essence of serious thinking, has never been questioned about it even this far into her career, and is incapable of even understanding what Lee's questions are getting at. She's not deflecting. She really has no idea how ridiculous she sounds.
I became an academic out of being curious about things. Gradually realizing since the 1990s that this kind of person is ordinary in the humanities and social sciences, is routinely given awards and high administrative positions, and is beyond the reach of rational discussion has been one of the most disappointing experiences of my life. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Russell T. Warne 🇺🇸🇨🇱
@Russwarne
Today, I found someone citing me in a hallucinated reference in their dissertation. I investigated further and found:
➡️42% of the dissertation is flagged as likely AI-generated
➡️>70 pages of almost continuous AI writing
➡️Over 10 references simply did not exist
➡️Many references that don't make sense to use in the dissertation
I reported it to the student's university and asked for a full investigation. The student should have her degree revoked. We should have zero tolerance for AI slop being used to earn a degree. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In a grad class circa 1982 I got into a brief argument with another grad.
Me: Evidence of bias should prompt efforts to eliminate biases, not reverse them.
Her: No. After decades of bias, they should be reversed.
She went on to become a dean. In academia, her side won resoundingly & created the mess we are now in. Now, the rest of us try to pick up the pieces. #humptydumpty
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Reversing Bias Rather Than Eliminating It
STEM professors rate identical CVs more favorably when attributed to women or Black people
www.stevestewartwilliams.com/p/reversing-bias-rather-than… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
49.4k views! Summary & link to new paper finding biases favoring women and Black applicants in academic science hiring. Still sub-mini-viral though (10-50k). But just 600 more to make mini-viral! (and its not even my paper)!
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Wow. New preprint (not mine):
" Faculty received an identical CV with only the candidate’s name varying to signal their gender and race, using a 2 Race (Black vs. White) by 2 Gender (male, female) between-subjects factorial design. Results revealed that STEM faculty evaluated female and Black candidates' research record significantly more favorably and recommended them for tenure and promotion at higher rates, compared to male and White candidates with identical CVs."
osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/jqswu_v1 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is exactly right. I have had this convo, almost exactly, with grad students working with me. @jon_stewartmill. So far, they have all landed jobs they (mostly) love. Two were recently tenured. Now, what will happen with my current grads? Yogi Berra has the answer.
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
.@jon_stewartmill asks: Why be courageous?
"Let me be blunt here...As a graduate student, if you publicly dissent from the orthodoxy, you will absolutely be discriminated against...People with poorer CVs, worse teaching portfolios, and less well-developed research programs will get chosen over you. It will hurt.
"But you don’t need every department to hire you: you just need one." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Dear Academia, I have a message for many of you:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
This is not 1954. The most relevant social science is that which has been conducted most recently, certainly within the last 10 years... recent social science does not show any clear pattern of racial discrimination. To be sure, some research has found anti-Black discrimination, albeit infrequently. Yet other research finds no anti-Black discrimination. And yet other research has found pro-Black discrimination. Read on for the details. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In which Colin Wright teams with Kevin McCaffree to launch a new journal to review peer reviewed science pubs. Not sure this is quite "saving science," but its an excellent initiative.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
ANNOUNCEMENT: WE’RE SAVING SCIENCE!
We’re often told that science is “self-correcting.”
But that’s not really true.
Science doesn’t correct itself like a thermostat adjusting the temperature in your house. Science is a human institution run by human beings. And human beings are vulnerable to career incentives, groupthink, moral fads, political pressure, and fear.
And when those forces capture academic journals, peer review stops being a filter for bad ideas and starts becoming more of a credentialing system for fashionable nonsense.
This isn’t exactly new.
In 1996, the physicist Alan Sokal managed to publish a totally gibberish article in the journal Social Text full of trendy postmodern jargon. His point was simple: if you flatter the ideological commitments of certain academic editors, nonsense can pass as real scholarship.
Two decades later, @ConceptualJames, @HPluckrose , and @peterboghossian pulled off the “grievance studies” hoax, placing over a half dozen absurd papers in peer-reviewed journals. One paper used dog parks to analyze rape culture and queer performativity. Another rewrote parts of Mein Kampf in the language of feminist theory.
The problem wasn’t just that fake papers got published. It was that they were completely indistinguishable from the real thing.
And today, the problem is even worse.
We now have serious SCIENCE journals publishing papers about feminist lesbians marrying brine shrimp. We have disturbing papers that aim to “queer” and sexualize infants. We have scholarship on “lesbian-queer-trans-canine relationalities” and “trans-dog intimacies.”
But while Clown World papers are concerning because it makes a complete mockery of academia, the same broken, ideologically captured system is also publishing research in legitimate science and medical journals that pushes sex and gender pseudoscience, relies on deeply flawed data, and influences policies on the medical transition of children and young adults.
That’s not funny. That affects real people. It affects medicine. It affects law. It affects children.
And when critics try to respond, they often discover there’s no serious mechanism for correction. Submitted Letters to the Editor often go completely ignored. Contrary evidence is rejected without comment. As a result, the best critiques are often relegated to personal blog posts, social media threads, or newspaper op-eds, while the original paper remains in the literature wearing the armor of “peer review.”
That is untenable.
So Kevin McCaffree, editor-in-chief of Theory and Society (@Theory_Society), and I decided to do something about it.
Today, in the Wall Street Journal, we announced a first-of-its-kind article type called “Peer Review.”
The idea is simple: publication should be the beginning of academic scrutiny, not the end of it.
A Peer Review article can critique a paper from any scholarly journal. It can address problems with methods, evidence, logic, definitions, theory, or interpretation. But it has to focus on the claims and arguments, not personal attacks.
Submissions are capped at 2,500 words and go through a straightforward merit review instead of endless gatekeeping and ideological screening. We ask just one basic question: Is this critique coherent, serious, reasonable, or even popular enough to deserve scholarly attention?
If yes, it gets published.
And the authors of the original paper get a built-in right of reply, so readers can see the critique and the response in a legitimate academic venue.
That’s how science is supposed to work.
Science becomes self-correcting only when real people build the mechanisms that allow correction to happen.
That’s what we’ve done.
Now it’s time for academics to use it.
Read our announcement on the @WSJ below.
🔗www.wsj.com/opinion/a-way-to-challenge-the-groupthink-of-…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
How to get research grants in Canada that require DEI statements? Promote propaganda scholarship in the proposal. Literally. 🧵
Geoff Horsman
@HorsmanGeoff
At a recent workshop for research grant DEI statements we were to identify systemic barriers to remove.
I asked, what barriers?
Reply: Not enough women in leadership positions (BTW my Dean, Provost, and President are women).
"Barrier" has been redefined as straight white men.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Wow. New preprint (not mine):
" Faculty received an identical CV with only the candidate’s name varying to signal their gender and race, using a 2 Race (Black vs. White) by 2 Gender (male, female) between-subjects factorial design. Results revealed that STEM faculty evaluated female and Black candidates' research record significantly more favorably and recommended them for tenure and promotion at higher rates, compared to male and White candidates with identical CVs."
osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/jqswu_v1 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
This is not 1954. The most relevant social science is that which has been conducted most recently, certainly within the last 10 years... recent social science does not show any clear pattern of racial discrimination. To be sure, some research has found anti-Black discrimination, albeit infrequently. Yet other research finds no anti-Black discrimination. And yet other research has found pro-Black discrimination. Read on for the details.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/recent-social-science-finds-…
"There is good news here, though not for the academics who have made whole careers grinding social justice axes around race. The good news is for America....In 2026, we may not be perfectly egalitarian, but we are pretty damn close. And that is good news." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Hey, this one is well into "mini-subviral" (>10k views, this has >41k). Will it make it to fully "subviral"? (>50k).
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Wow. New preprint (not mine):
" Faculty received an identical CV with only the candidate’s name varying to signal their gender and race, using a 2 Race (Black vs. White) by 2 Gender (male, female) between-subjects factorial design. Results revealed that STEM faculty evaluated female and Black candidates' research record significantly more favorably and recommended them for tenure and promotion at higher rates, compared to male and White candidates with identical CVs."
osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/jqswu_v1 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
11k views! Officially "mini-subviral."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Let's review:
1. Modern research -- yes, academic research with all its political malfunctions and ax-grinding -- finds anti-Black discriminatory behavior at very low levels or net unbiased behavior or, most recently, pro-Black biases (Unsafe Sci post coming soon).
2. Microaggression research is mostly puffery.
3. Claims about "implicit bias" have been in relentless retreat for over 10 years.
4. Stereotype threat has suffered relentless failures to replicate in pre-registered studies.
5. Stereotype biases in person perception are small and dwarfed by huge individuating informatin effects. (Anyone remember "stereotypes are the default basis of person perception" circa 1990?).
5. The stereotype accuracy research remains widely reviled but has suffered precisely 0 failures to replicate or debunkings.
There is more where that came from but that's enough for one tweet. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Not counting my typo (two "5's" in a list of 6), this post is approaching mini-subviral (my threshold for that is 10k views).
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Let's review:
1. Modern research -- yes, academic research with all its political malfunctions and ax-grinding -- finds anti-Black discriminatory behavior at very low levels or net unbiased behavior or, most recently, pro-Black biases (Unsafe Sci post coming soon).
2. Microaggression research is mostly puffery.
3. Claims about "implicit bias" have been in relentless retreat for over 10 years.
4. Stereotype threat has suffered relentless failures to replicate in pre-registered studies.
5. Stereotype biases in person perception are small and dwarfed by huge individuating informatin effects. (Anyone remember "stereotypes are the default basis of person perception" circa 1990?).
5. The stereotype accuracy research remains widely reviled but has suffered precisely 0 failures to replicate or debunkings.
There is more where that came from but that's enough for one tweet. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Jan Brauner
@JaniceBrauner
The inimitable @PsychRabble gifts a pithy 6-pt primer w/2 #5s 😉on anti-black discriminatory behavior that calls the prevailing race narrative into question. At least for those wedded to empirical evidence.
Social science: sites.rutgers.edu/lee-jussim/
Substack: unsafescience.substack.com
See Lee's "Introduction to Special Series on Racial Discrimination and Implicit Bias" and learn about The Grand Irony in Lee's Substack. "Unsafe Science", a veritable cornucopia of narrative-busting research.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/introduction-to-special-seri… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I call this "Still Life."
P.S. with 4 cats, I identify as a cat lady. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I call this "Wooly Bully." You know the song was about his cat, right? "It had 2 big horns and a wooly jaw... "
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I call this "Cat in a Bathtub."
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I call this "Cat in a Window."
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Where have all the Twitter mobs and cancellation attacks gone?
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Let's review:
1. Modern research -- yes, academic research with all its political malfunctions and ax-grinding -- finds anti-Black discriminatory behavior at very low levels or net unbiased behavior or, most recently, pro-Black biases (Unsafe Sci post coming soon).
2. Microaggression research is mostly puffery.
3. Claims about "implicit bias" have been in relentless retreat for over 10 years.
4. Stereotype threat has suffered relentless failures to replicate in pre-registered studies.
5. Stereotype biases in person perception are small and dwarfed by huge individuating informatin effects. (Anyone remember "stereotypes are the default basis of person perception" circa 1990?).
5. The stereotype accuracy research remains widely reviled but has suffered precisely 0 failures to replicate or debunkings.
There is more where that came from but that's enough for one tweet. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
"the research is actually solid; but the narratives are far more influential and the narratives are a disaster area." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/introduction-to-special-seri…
"These were inspired by two recent papers and something I’ve known for a long time. One recent paper debunks many of the early, wild claims about implicit bias. The second found that the race implicit association test (IAT), the workhorse method for assessing implicit bias, is heavily confounded by metaphorical meanings of “black” and “white” (I realize that is a bit cryptic, but that’s why I will do a whole post on it; if you do not what the IAT is, don’t worry, a post already drafted explains it). A third post thoroughly debunks the assumption, widespread in IAT research, that 0 on the IAT means “unbiased.” -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
"the research is actually solid; but the narratives are far more influential and the narratives are a disaster area." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Wow. New preprint (not mine):
" Faculty received an identical CV with only the candidate’s name varying to signal their gender and race, using a 2 Race (Black vs. White) by 2 Gender (male, female) between-subjects factorial design. Results revealed that STEM faculty evaluated female and Black candidates' research record significantly more favorably and recommended them for tenure and promotion at higher rates, compared to male and White candidates with identical CVs."
osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/jqswu_v1 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Reign in the IRB w/resources.
IRB overreach and mission explosion ("mission creep" is exponential not linear) is now a threat to simply doing research efficiently and to academic freedom.
1. IRB Watch, irb.watch at which you can post your own IRB horror stories.
2. A repository of articles critical of IRBs going back decades.
osf.io/qy4fm/overview -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Reign in the IRB w/resources.
IRB overreach and mission explosion ("mission creep" is exponential not linear) is now a threat to simply doing research efficiently and to academic freedom.
1. IRB Watch, irb.watch at which you can post your own IRB horror stories.
2. A repository of articles critical of IRBs going back decades.
osf.io/qy4fm/overview -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The main point is that its a great study. Here's an added point:
Is the work any "better" for having been pubbed in a peer reviewed journal than before it was pubbed in a peer reviewed journal? Hint: Its the same work.
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
The Shields et al. study showing one-sided presentations of contentious issues in syllabi that was making the rounds a few months ago is properly published now and ready for your citations. link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-026-09715-w
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Great AI-generated music is all over YouTube now.
Seán Ono Lennon
@seanonolennon
Uber driver is blasting this album that sounds like a hispanic Zucchero, but it’s a completely AI generated ‘artists’ called Joni’s Soul. When I told him it was not human he seemed truly shocked for a moment.
But then he just cranked it up even louder. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Well, its not what Wil meant, but my wife is a therapist. A few years ago, she put real $ into NVidia. I would say this was the opposite of "totally useless."
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
Most therapists I have ever met, dated, sparred with online, etc would be - in my not un-professional opinion - totally useless for a successful man.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New guest post. Link in reply.
"I ...received ... an email from the Chair of the department at around mid-semester. The email noted that there were quite a few (well-earned, it seemed to me) failing grades in my class and included a request for my plan to ensure that all of my students would receive “at least a C” in my course. The Chair seemed confused and even a bit angry at me when I informed her that I had no such plan."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"I informed her that, as always, my plan was to provide each student with a variety of routes to success throughout the term, then give them the grade (from A to F) that they had actually earned according to the policies outlined in the syllabus. The Chair’s response to this plan made it clear that following through with it would essentially serve as my resignation letter."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/traitorous-education -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
1. SOIBS and JOIBS were organized precisely to fight this sort of political intolerance and corruption of academia and scholarship.
2. See below, I cannot find the author's contact info and have posted a comment on the Substack post linked in Steve's thread.
3. Full image/text of that comment, which includes an invitation to publish their article in JOIBS (the journal at which I am editor-in-chief, which has already published two articles retracted from other journals for similar nonsense reasons).
Paging @BrandonLukeMc (you know the author? if not, can you find him/her?).
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Shocked to hear that a peer-reviewed article was retracted in my home country of New Zealand, not for misconduct or error, but because it conflicted with "organizational values."
Knowledge advances through disagreement and debate, not censorship.
psychologyatthecrossroads.substack.com/p/nzccp-sets-a-pre… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Beats much of what appears in other peer reviewed journals, that's for sure.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/apex-peer-reviewed-journal-n…
Zachary Levenson
@grundrza
Normally I'd ignore it. But remember: this is the journal whose eds. are publishing piece after piece alleging that sociology is unscientific, unrigorous, & so forth. A # of them are urging campus admin & the state to intervene.
But *this* is their model of science? Good lord. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Not conceding that the article is "dreck" but let's stipulate it is. That would make it a lot like journals publishing social science everywhere. If you would like a list, starting with some of the "dreck" published in Nature, LMK. Or, you could start with the "dreck" piled high and deep in the peer reviewed lit about microaggressions.
UChicago AAUP
@AAUP_UChicago
There's no need to debate the Vanderbilt/WashU report in abstract. Two years ago, Axel Springer forced a new editor-in-chief on Theory and Society, promising to rid the journal of its "righteous anger." Now, as the below post shows, it's publishing sub-scholarly grievance dreck
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I have a 2018 chapter arguing, no, not "arguing," simply noticing that there is much overlap between wokish "cultural competence" and something the woke usually find offensive -- stereotype accuracy.
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
“It’s ironic that, in an age where we rightly celebrate differences and diversity, we often get outraged when anyone points them out. Not exactly tolerance of diversity!”
An excerpt from my recent op-ed in The Independent.
www.stevestewartwilliams.com/p/why-we-cant-talk-honestly-… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Retreat from Woke Continues. In which the American Bar Association eliminates its requirements for DEI in legal education.
jamesgmartin.center/2026/06/from-courtrooms-to-classrooms/ -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Grew up in Brooklyn. To paraphrase the street, "Whose hat you callin' stupid?"
DavidAnderson_JD_NYC
@DavidandersonJd
Yes. Dress the part, esp when money is involved. Maybe Richard isn't a suit guy.
I ran into Rob Henderson at the Heterodox Conference in Brooklyn last summer, he turns out well.
Me with @PsychRabble in our respective stupid hats! -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Our critique of microaggression research is now published and open access.
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352250X26000631 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
From the essay: "The backlash has begun."
May the squeezing of the activist-to-academia pipeline commence!
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
The UNC Board of Trustees recently voted to reject Kiran Asher’s proposed tenured appointment as a distinguished professor.
They were right to do so.
Asher’s scholarship is steeped in woke ideology: decolonial feminism, postcolonial theory, anticapitalist critique, Queer Theory, “situated knowledges,” and the idea that scholarship and activism should be married.
She is an activist who has “postcolonial feminist rage” (her words) and believes that universities, as well as the standards that make them useful, are structures of oppression to be dismantled.
This is not the first time UNC trustees have blocked an ideological hire. In 2021, they initially refused to approve Nikole Hannah-Jones, creator of the infamous “1619 Project” for a tenured position.
Their instincts were sound, but their resolve was not.
After protests and national backlash, they caved and approved the appointment, only for Hannah-Jones to decline and take a job at Howard.
The UNC trusteed should learn from that fiasco.
Trustees are not supposed to ceremonially rubber stamp whatever faculty departments send them. Especially not when those departments have been ideologically captured.
UNC should not cave to outside pressure to reverse their decision on Kiran Asher's appointment.
The pressure to fold is strongest precisely when their resolve matters most.
Read my latest below.
🔗www.realityslaststand.com/p/unc-trustees-were-right-to-block -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Our critique of microaggression research is now published and open access.
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2352250X26000631 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Brad Skow
@bradford_skow
“An army of academics has built an entire edifice of published research, classroom lectures, campus workshops, and workplace trainings on top of a critically compromised foundation.”
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Hold on to your hat. This is a long but rewarding one. In which Lawrence Eppard bludgeons bad and biased sociology with the hope, albeit a slim one, of saving the field from itself."
New post, link in reply. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Alex Guerrero
@Alex_A_Guerrero
This is a long piece very much worth reading.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Hold on to your hat. This is a long but rewarding one. In which Lawrence Eppard bludgeons bad and biased sociology with the hope, albeit a slim one, of saving the field from itself."
New post, link in reply. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Hold on to your hat. This is a long but rewarding one. In which Lawrence Eppard bludgeons bad and biased sociology with the hope, albeit a slim one, of saving the field from itself."
New post, link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"The hope is not ridiculous because he is a sociologist and this article exemplifies empirically oriented scientific sociology at its best. Yes, Virginia, scientific sociology is a thing and some still practice it."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/rigor-or-ruin -
Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
www.thefp.com/p/carole-hooven-why-i-left-harvard
"After I stated banal facts about human biology, I found myself caught in a DEI web, without the support to do the job I loved." (grad students refused to TA for her -- craven admins should have but did not revoke their funding; "We cannot require you to TA for her, but your funding is contingent on fulfilling your assigned TA duties"). -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Heterodox Academy
@HdxAcademy
🏆We're proud to announce the recipients of HxA's 2026 Open Inquiry Awards.
"From the classroom to the president's office, these honorees are creating the conditions for free inquiry to flourish." — HxA President John Tomasi -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Jake 🇺🇸
@omni_american
Chapters by me or by me and co-authors Lawrence Eppard of @UtterlyModerate Podcast & @PsychRabble in the book we have coming out this year (Preface by @michaelshermer) :
o “Tribal Epistemology Is a Bipartisan Problem”
o “The Good Times Are Now?”
o “Attacks on Reality From the Left-Wing”
o “The Virtuous Lies We Tell”
Link to pre-order in next tweet! -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Jake 🇺🇸
@omni_american
Table of contents of my new book Virtuous Nonsense: Progressive America's Epistemic Crisis (with Lawrence Eppard of @UtterlyModerate Podcast and @PsychRabble). Pre-order link in next tweet.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Jake 🇺🇸
@omni_american
The cover for Virtuous Nonsense: Progressive America's Epistemic Crisis, my new book with Lawrence Eppard (of @UtterlyModerate Podcast) and @PsychRabble. Pre-order at the link in the next tweet!
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Bingo!
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
Real banger from Sacred Cow BBQ on the problem of social sciences and humanities being largely immune to reality correction because there’s no feedback loop that penalizes people for being wrong. The incentive structure rather rewards people for intra-guild argumentative sophistication and coalition-building, which in many cases are ideological or actively reality-resistant. There are real reform efforts afoot, and that is good, though they’re largely happening outside of formal sites of academic knowledge production, e.g., Substack rather than academic journals.
This one amply rewards your attention!
kylesaunders.substack.com/p/why-are-the-humanities-missin… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Free Black Thought
@FreeBlckThought
Surprise, Surprise!
Anyone who has been an academic for more than a week already knew this (even those arguing FOR the legitimacy of microaggressions), but it's nice to have legitimate empirical research on it.
Thanks, @PsychRabble, for this important work.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Title says it all: Research on Microaggressions and Their Impact Assesses Neither Microaggressions nor Their Impacts. (now you do not need to read the paper, but in case you want the gory details, it is linked below).
In a special issue of Current Opinion in Psychology on politicization of psychotherapy. Early draft appeared first at Unsafe Science.
Koenfucius 🔍
@koenfucius
Review by @psychrabble and McNally of the empirical research on microaggressions concludes it exclusively addresses *perceptions* thereof, and assesses correlates of these
perceptions without assessing the underlying causal processes:
www.researchgate.net/publication/400923778_Research_on_Mi… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Guest post. Link in reply. "I’m going to tell you about the time my employer, Georgia State University (GSU), investigated me for six counts of harassment and discrimination against a colleague."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Ultimately, I was exonerated..."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/inside-a-campus-civil-rights… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
🧵summary of research on what leads people to trust science. (Hint: Its not scientists saying "trust us!" or bureaucrats saying "trust the science!" and tainting dissenters as science-deniers).
Cory Clark
@ImHardcory
1. Does drawing harder boundaries between science and "misinformation" increase or decrease public trust in science?
In four studies conducted in the context of COVID-19, we tested this question by comparing different approaches to science communication.
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0277953626005162 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Ah, yes, the road to Hell...
Vicky C Yang
@VickyCYang
Between 1985--2023, MIT's faculty grew 9%. Administrative staff grew 189%. 📈 Why? In new @PNASNews paper, we use dynamical system model to show administrative bloat can emerge without empire-building--just from well-intentioned problem-solving gone awry www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2527106123
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Title says it all: Research on Microaggressions and Their Impact Assesses Neither Microaggressions nor Their Impacts. (now you do not need to read the paper, but in case you want the gory details, it is linked below).
In a special issue of Current Opinion in Psychology on politicization of psychotherapy. Early draft appeared first at Unsafe Science.
Koenfucius 🔍
@koenfucius
Review by @psychrabble and McNally of the empirical research on microaggressions concludes it exclusively addresses *perceptions* thereof, and assesses correlates of these
perceptions without assessing the underlying causal processes:
www.researchgate.net/publication/400923778_Research_on_Mi… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Sounds familiar...
Rolf Degen
@DegenRolf
Research on microaggressions has made a mountain out of a molehill.
We critically evaluate common claims about microaggressions. Despite 50 years of scholarship on microaggressions, the main claims about them have not been empirically demonstrated. Most studies address perceptions of microaggressions, not microaggressions per se. Much is known about subjective self-reported experiences as measured by dubious questionnaires of unknown validity that may or may not assess perceptions of “microaggressions,” and the correlates of these measures. The research has failed to demonstrate that behaviors claimed to microaggressions are frequently experienced.
Moreover, despite claims to the contrary, research has not established that racism causes microaggressions nor that microaggressions adversely affect the well-being of those who perceive the . The research has failed to demonstrate that experiencing microaggressions has negative causal effects on the well-being of those who perceive them. Correlations do not demonstrate “impact.” No studies have attempted to assess whether racism causes the specific behaviors labeled as microaggressions by “experts” and advocates.
Accordingly, after 50 years of scholarship on microaggressions, the central claims of proponents remain unsubstantiated. Whereas helping clients cope with experiences of bigotry is appropriate for therapy, leading clients to interpret ambiguous situations as manifestations of bigotry risks doing more harm than good. Rather than facilitating constructive social interactions, it is likely to induce anger and resentment.
Microaggression scholarship often is framed as anti-racist. In this perspective, opposing anti-racism is racist, so that criticizing microaggression research is racist. Thus, microaggression scholarship has a peculiar form of insulation against refutation. Critiques of the theory, being “racist,” count as further support for the phenomenon. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Rob Sica
@robsica
🏴☠️🦜Yup, the sunny September 2012 afternoon I chanced upon that refreshing burst of bs-busting was my intro to Jussim.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Thanks. That was 2012. It went downhill from there.
Lawrence Patihis
@lawrencepatihis
Lee Jussim @PsychRabble in 2012 was ahead of the curve:
"Some Privileges Enjoyed by Liberal Psychologists and Social Scientists
1. I can avoid spending time with colleagues who mistrust me because of my politics.
2. If I apply for a job, I can be confident my political views are more likely to be an asset than liability.
3. I can be confident that the political beliefs I hold and the political candidates I support will not be routinely mocked by my colleagues.
4. I can be pretty confident that, if I present results at colloquia and conferences that validate my political views, I will not be mocked or insulted by my colleagues.
5. I can be pretty sure that my students who share my political views and go on to academic jobs will be able to focus on being competent teachers and scientists and will not have to worry about hiding their politics from senior faculty.
6. I can paint caricature-like pictures based on the most extreme and irrational beliefs of those who differ from me ideologically without feeling any penalty for doing so.
7. I can criticize colleagues’ research that differs from mine on issues such as race, sex, or politics without fear of being accused of being an authoritarian, racist, or sexist.
8. I can systematically misinterpret, misrepresent, or ignore research in such a manner as to sustain my political views and be confident that such misinterpretations, misrepresentations, or oversights are unlikely to be recognized by my colleagues.
9. If I work in politically charged areas, such as race, gender, class, and politics and if my papers, grants, or symposia are rejected, I need not ask each time if political bias led to the rejection.
10. I will feel welcomed and “normal” in the usual walks of my academic life.
11. I will not have to worry whether citations to and impact of my scholarship will be artificially diluted because most of my colleagues do not like its political implications.
12. I do not have to worry that reviewers and editors will require a higher standard to publish or fund my research than they require to publish or fund research with implications for the opposite ideology.
13. In order to publish my research demonstrating moral failures or cognitive biases among those with different ideological beliefs than mine, I will not need to consider camouflaging my results or sugar coating the conclusions to avoid offending the political sensitivities of reviewers.
14. I can be confident that vanishingly few of my colleagues will be publishing “scientific” articles claiming that people holding political beliefs like mine are particularly deficient in intelligence and morality."
from Jussim (2012, p 504) journals.sagepub.com/doi/epub/10.1177/1745691612455205
I quote this as someone who is liberal, and was very liberal at the time of publication (2012). Nevertheless, even then there was fierce hellish competition in graduate school among those competing to be more ultra-liberal than others, and already critical theory narratives coming into psychological science (and being favoured). Absolutely sickening self promotiong and positioning, even before the woke revolution of 2017 to 2023. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
MIT Free Speech Alliance
@mitfreespeech
And if you really want to come prepared, you can read their reform proposal, published in the Journal of Controversial Ideas as part of its special issue on Censorship in the Sciences.
journalofcontroversialideas.org/article/5/2/299/htm -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
MIT Free Speech Alliance
@mitfreespeech
This should be an interesting discussion of IRB reform, featuring @PsychRabble and our friend & MFSA member Evan Morris, among others.
🗓️: June 3
⏲️: 5-6:30 p.m. ET
In-person & Zoom options available. Link & additional info in next posts. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Thanks. That was 2012. It went downhill from there.
Lawrence Patihis
@lawrencepatihis
Lee Jussim @PsychRabble in 2012 was ahead of the curve:
"Some Privileges Enjoyed by Liberal Psychologists and Social Scientists
1. I can avoid spending time with colleagues who mistrust me because of my politics.
2. If I apply for a job, I can be confident my political views are more likely to be an asset than liability.
3. I can be confident that the political beliefs I hold and the political candidates I support will not be routinely mocked by my colleagues.
4. I can be pretty confident that, if I present results at colloquia and conferences that validate my political views, I will not be mocked or insulted by my colleagues.
5. I can be pretty sure that my students who share my political views and go on to academic jobs will be able to focus on being competent teachers and scientists and will not have to worry about hiding their politics from senior faculty.
6. I can paint caricature-like pictures based on the most extreme and irrational beliefs of those who differ from me ideologically without feeling any penalty for doing so.
7. I can criticize colleagues’ research that differs from mine on issues such as race, sex, or politics without fear of being accused of being an authoritarian, racist, or sexist.
8. I can systematically misinterpret, misrepresent, or ignore research in such a manner as to sustain my political views and be confident that such misinterpretations, misrepresentations, or oversights are unlikely to be recognized by my colleagues.
9. If I work in politically charged areas, such as race, gender, class, and politics and if my papers, grants, or symposia are rejected, I need not ask each time if political bias led to the rejection.
10. I will feel welcomed and “normal” in the usual walks of my academic life.
11. I will not have to worry whether citations to and impact of my scholarship will be artificially diluted because most of my colleagues do not like its political implications.
12. I do not have to worry that reviewers and editors will require a higher standard to publish or fund my research than they require to publish or fund research with implications for the opposite ideology.
13. In order to publish my research demonstrating moral failures or cognitive biases among those with different ideological beliefs than mine, I will not need to consider camouflaging my results or sugar coating the conclusions to avoid offending the political sensitivities of reviewers.
14. I can be confident that vanishingly few of my colleagues will be publishing “scientific” articles claiming that people holding political beliefs like mine are particularly deficient in intelligence and morality."
from Jussim (2012, p 504) journals.sagepub.com/doi/epub/10.1177/1745691612455205
I quote this as someone who is liberal, and was very liberal at the time of publication (2012). Nevertheless, even then there was fierce hellish competition in graduate school among those competing to be more ultra-liberal than others, and already critical theory narratives coming into psychological science (and being favoured). Absolutely sickening self promotiong and positioning, even before the woke revolution of 2017 to 2023. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The rejection of use of GREs, which puts actual knowledge on an even playing field, by many grad programs exacerbates biases favoring women.
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
When I used to attend commencement regularly as a faculty member, they’d announce each year that like 63% of the graduating class was women and a huge shout and applause would go up and I was always impressed by the enthusiasm for inequality.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Revenge of the sane. Or at least, to paraphrase Orwell, of the intellectuals who reject ideas that are so stupid only (some) intellectuals believe them. Or, to paraphrase @RichardHanania and @razibkhan, the "smart stupids."
Jukka Savolainen
@JukkaSavo
This looks like an instant classic from @JConIdeas Intriguing articles by Alan #sokal, @aytchellesse etc.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Guest Post by @FlowTap1. Link in reply.
"...free speech and viewpoint diversity should not be curtailed during a medical crisis. Challenging popular elite opinion is just as important, if not more so, when society faces an unexpected danger, such as a deadly “novel” virus."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Why did we accept the widespread, ruthless, and unsupported suppression of liberties?"
unsafescience.substack.com/p/free-speech-lessons-in-covid… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. Link in reply.
"The strongest version of the administration’s case is not “social science is worthless,” but that NSF in particular drifted into funding work whose theoretical frameworks and PI activism were substantively continuous with each other, that this drift damaged broader public trust in science, and that resetting the directorate structure is one response." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Ohad Fedida
@OhadFedida
Wonderful guest post by Danit Finkelstein on @PsychRabble's Unsafe Science, diving into the administration's proposed science budget. Especially relevant for social psychologists.
"FY27 Science Budget: A Fuller Picture of Implications for Social Psychology and Beyond"
🔗 Substack Link:
substack.com/@danitfinkelstein/note/p-197383517?r=1rleq3 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. Link in reply.
"The strongest version of the administration’s case is not “social science is worthless,” but that NSF in particular drifted into funding work whose theoretical frameworks and PI activism were substantively continuous with each other, that this drift damaged broader public trust in science, and that resetting the directorate structure is one response."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/fy27-science-budget-a-fuller…
"The response has also clearly produced overreach. The keyword screen used for the Cruz database swept in research on the dusky-capped flycatcher (a bird, flagged because “diversification” appears in evolutionary biology), aerospace manufacturing grants (flagged for mentioning the percentage of Hispanic students), solar eclipse research, a grant to teach Hebrew at UMass (flagged in a database commissioned by an avowedly pro-Israel senator), and a postdoc on “How False Beliefs Form & How to Correct Them”, basic cognitive science on belief revision, terminated as “misinformation research.” Both things are true: the strongest examples are genuinely damning, and the implementation has been blunt enough to catch obviously unrelated work." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is totally my favorite pod/interview since Peterson. Ivar did such a good job. Rollicking good time, laughed more on a pod than ... ever.
Topics in chronological order:
Stereotype accuracy
Social scientists literally making stuff up and calling it science.
Implicit bias and its many (many many) limitations, including a new paper (not mine) highlighting those limitations.
How U.S. culture, driven in part by social science, has lost its "can-do, American know-how!" sensibility.
And how dissident academics tried to warn academia and the wider culture that academia's relentless politicization practically invited the Trumpian Backlash.
Ivar Arpi
@Ivarpi
Lee Jussim (@psychrabble) har ägnat sin karriär åt att säga något ovanligt i socialpsykologin: människor är inte bara fångar i fördomar. Ofta läser vi verkligheten bättre än experterna vill få oss att tro.
Nytt samtal i Rak höger: www.enrakhoger.se/p/lee-jussim-actually-stereotypes-are -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Apollonic
@the_apollonic
This👇 is Gatling style, James Cameron envisioning the Terminator level gold! 😎🤘
"And of course, their thundering hallucinations of racism rendered them incapable of even hearing, let alone heeding, the warning."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post.
"We warned you. This post documents the extent to which we warned you, over and over for at least 25 years. At the end, it presents over 50 references documenting the historical attempt of dissident academics to warn the rest of academia that this could come if they did not get their house in order. Now its here.
The Trump administration is crushing many of the norms of academia. Some might argue that it is crushing academia."
Link next tweet -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Apollonic
@the_apollonic
Haven't left my house with a mobile phone with me in almost a decade. There's just no point to be so distracted. Panopticon Opera and its entertainers are a legion anyway.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Delusional beliefs, documented. But what causes this bizarre relationship? Is it education itself? Is it all rooted in leftwing ideology? No idea. I now return to doing something useful that has nothing to do with any of this.
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
Americans with the highest trust in educators are twice as likely to (falsely) believe that Europeans introduced the concept of war and conflict to Native Americans.
(see graph below) -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
IRB nightmare produces lawsuit -- which, if victorious, may limit IRB interference in research for reasons that have nothing to do with protecting human participants.
jamesgmartin.center/2026/05/a-little-known-lawsuit-may-we… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Have so far only read the tweet and title but ... exactly. 1/2
Rob Sica
@robsica
🔪"Psychologists know that public trust decreases to the extent that manifest ideological leanings diverge from their own. We also know that progressive activism within our science represents views that diverge from ≈90% of the Western public – including most left-wingers."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
ICYMI: 2nd most read post at Unsafe Science:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/we-tried-to-warn-you -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
On Moral Inversion
From the op ed linked in the short 🧵: "A meaningful subset of Americans now rates authoritarian states more favorably than democratic ones on human rights, including states openly hostile to the U.S."
Network Contagion Research Institute
@ncri_io
@yudapearl @ConceptualJames @DataRepublican @SwipeWright @PamelaParesky @PsychRabble @pianozack @adam_louis52328 @JohnnieM @AsraNomani
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Punching down" (the topic of this essay) was always one of the dumbest most dysfunctional ideas to capture academia circa 2017-2023. Bad science should be punched, no matter who has produced it.
Michael Inzlicht
@minzlicht
A few months ago I sat through a PhD student's talk that wasn't great. Clear delivery, well prepared. The ideas just weren't there yet. Several professors asked tough but respectful questions. Exactly what's supposed to happen.
For a while there, this had become suspect. Critical feedback from someone with more power directed at someone with less got coded as punching down, especially in public. That norm seems to have receded, thankfully, but plenty of people still treat the practice as immoral.
I want to defend it. Scratch that. I want to defend punching, full stop. Up, down, sideways.
Science runs on Merton's principle of universalism: evaluate ideas, not the person attached to them. The "don't punch down" rule violates that. Worse, it ends up infantilizing the people it claims to protect. Telling junior scholars their work is too fragile to scrutinize is not respect.
New essay, free for all. Punch back in the comments.
open.substack.com/pub/michaelinzlicht/p/science-doesnt-ca… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply. This, by Roy Baumeister, celebrates the evidence for ego-depletion (the ability to self-control or self-regulate is a limited resource that goes down/runs out with use).
BUT, see als the link in 3rd tweet to a post (by @minzlicht) taking the view that most ego-depletion research remains debunked and that its probably just fatigue.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Baumeister: "if we make replication success the main criterion of quality, ego depletion is one of the most successful findings in social psychology."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-triumph-of-ego-depletion
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Inzlicht: "paradigms using brief and weak depletion manipulations failed to consistently produce results. Meanwhile, research on fatigue—evoked by hours of cognitive and physical effort—shows reliable downstream consequences."
www.speakandregret.michaelinzlicht.com/p/the-ego-depletio… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In 1587, Sir Francis Drake sailed into the Spanish port of Cadiz and wreaked havoc on the preparations for the Spanish Armada giving England time to prepare. He called it "The Singeing of the King of Spain's Beard." In 2026, four of us sailed into a major social psychology organization and wreaked havoc on some of their idiotic policies and proclamations. Unsafe Science tells this story in six separate posts (the first with video), link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
1. I believe this.
2. I am not sure this means prereg is "not working." The fact that deviations and undisclosed methods and analyses were discovered can be interpreted to mean that prereg is working to increase transparency, even if authors do not stick to their preregs -- which would be ideal of course.
Brendan Nyhan (@BrendanNyhan on 🟦☁️)
@BrendanNyhan
Journal editors - the status quo on preregistration is not working! You need to check submissions vs. preregistrations before sending articles out for review. *56%* of experiments I reviewed in last year have severe problems with non-disclosure, undocumented deviations, & more ↓
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. Link in reply.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. Link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New acct. Great follow. Faculty, exposing academic extremism & other nonsense. Excellent Substack too (link in its X profile). In a few weeks has almost 20k followers.
FacultyLeaks.com
@FacultyLeaks
Former AEJMC president and Stanford journalism professor emeritus Ted Glasser: "Journalists need to be overt and candid advocates for social justice, and it's hard to do that under the constraints of objectivity."
This is the organization whose conference used the word 'resistance' 36 times last year and 'impartial' zero.
www.facultyleaks.com/p/why-media-leans-left-journalism-sc… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, the fourth and final talk, by Anne Wilson, @awilson_WLU, at SPSP, of whether SPSP is a healthy organization. Link in reply.
"In my opinion, SPSP should not promote unevidenced claims about white supremacy culture, then also ask the public to trust our scientific integrity. We have the capacity to course correct and this is a good place to demonstrate that."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/in-defense-of-spsp-and-of-it…
"There are likely multiple reasons for the loss of public trust...overtly political stances do risk of undermining public confidence ... the public may wonder if evidence is going to be weighed fairly and communicated accurately and honestly [and] if political bias is going to shape what we tell the public." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Well, as I pointed out here, with receipts, the biggest Social Psych academic org will tell you that objectivity is White supremacy.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-society-for-personality-…
FacultyLeaks.com
@FacultyLeaks
Former AEJMC president and Stanford journalism professor emeritus Ted Glasser: "Journalists need to be overt and candid advocates for social justice, and it's hard to do that under the constraints of objectivity."
This is the organization whose conference used the word 'resistance' 36 times last year and 'impartial' zero.
www.facultyleaks.com/p/why-media-leans-left-journalism-sc… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in thread below. Why I consider one of the major social psych organizations deeply unhealthy.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Take 3.* New Post, in which I walk into SPSP, one of the major social psych professional orgs, and, as part of a panel, tell them they are a mess. Link in reply.
*testing the "X is no longer deboosting posts with links" hypothesis. Prior two takes included links in 1st tweet. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. Luke Conway's @LGConwayIII at SPSP. Link in reply.
"In a 2024 American Psychologist article, Rogers and colleagues essentially argued that the scientific method is an arbitrary cultural construction rooted in white supremacy. Interestingly, in that same article, they singled us – this organization – out for praise as people especially likely to attack the scientific method as racist. In this talk, I’m going to first argue that I don’t think that’s praiseworthy, because I think the scientific method is fundamentally good. Then I’m going to ask the question: Are they right about us? Is this really who we are now? Are we really the people who don’t believe in the scientific method anymore? -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The dust-biting just keeps on biting...
Rolf Degen
@DegenRolf
Highly cited social psychology finding, implying that men respond to a masculinity threat by adopting more conservative political attitudes, goes down the drain in thorough, large scale replication attempt.
Do men respond to a masculinity threat by adopting more conservative political attitudes? A highly cited study by Willer et al. – drawing on substantial work in social psychology – argues in the affirmative, reasoning that endorsing conservative views allows men to reaffirm their gender identity.
In two experiments with student convenience samples, the authors find consistent evidence: inducing masculinity threat increases support for war, homophobic attitudes, and endorsement of dominance hierarchies. We conduct a preregistered replication of this foundational study using a nationally representative probability sample (N total 2774).
We find that Willer et al.’s (main results do not hold in our replication: we do not observe that masculinity threat is associated with increased support for war, homophobic attitudes, support for dominance hierarchies, traditionalism, or other conservative attitudes. We further do not find support for design differences between the replication and original study driving contrasting findings.
Our results call into question the robustness of evidence linking masculinity threat to political attitudes and underscore the importance of re-evaluating widely accepted findings with representative, large samples. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Sounds very interesting and rings true. Looking forward to reading (well, probably, for now, skimming) the paper.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Do protests change election results?
The standard answer from prior research: yes, and dramatically so.
Studies of civil rights, the Tea Party, and Black Lives Matter find protests shift elections a lot.
The dominant view: protest reliably moves elections.
But is that always true? What about protests in the last few years?
Our latest working paper challenges prevailing logic.
Our finding: most recent protests have failed to shift elections. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. The text/slides of Nate Honeycutt's talk at the symposium on "Is the Society for Personality and Social Psychology (SPSP) a Healthy Organization?" In which Nate used LLM's to assess the politicization of SPSP. Links in reply. Post reports research inspired by @saltypsych, who makes a cameo appearance.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. The text/slides of Nate Honeycutt's talk at the symposium on "Is the Society for Personality and Social Psychology (SPSP) a Healthy Organization?" In which Nate used LLM's to assess the politicization of SPSP. Links in reply. Post reports research inspired by @saltypsych, who makes a cameo appearance.
Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
He next turned his attention to coding papers for whether or not they had an activist orientation. From his talk: "An abstract was rated 0 if it was explicitly framed as explanation or prediction. An abstract was rated 1 if it was framed as trying to produce some sort of change." The results: A dramatic rise in activist orientation since about 2012, which really picked up 2018.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Enjoy.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/quantifying-the-health-of-spsp -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. Luke Conway's @LGConwayIII at SPSP. Link in reply.
"In a 2024 American Psychologist article, Rogers and colleagues essentially argued that the scientific method is an arbitrary cultural construction rooted in white supremacy. Interestingly, in that same article, they singled us – this organization – out for praise as people especially likely to attack the scientific method as racist. In this talk, I’m going to first argue that I don’t think that’s praiseworthy, because I think the scientific method is fundamentally good. Then I’m going to ask the question: Are they right about us? Is this really who we are now? Are we really the people who don’t believe in the scientific method anymore?
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Take 3.* New Post, in which I walk into SPSP, one of the major social psych professional orgs, and, as part of a panel, tell them they are a mess. Link in reply.
*testing the "X is no longer deboosting posts with links" hypothesis. Prior two takes included links in 1st tweet. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Ya think? Paging @ashleytrubin, @JukkaSavo, @SkepResCenter
Jake 🇺🇸
@omni_american
“The more scholarship frames itself as revolutionary struggle and treats institutions as sites of permanent antagonism, the easier it becomes for electoral majorities (or plurality coalitions) to support punitive 'reform' of universities as ideologically captured or politically extreme.”
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Take 3.* New Post, in which I walk into SPSP, one of the major social psych professional orgs, and, as part of a panel, tell them they are a mess. Link in reply.
*testing the "X is no longer deboosting posts with links" hypothesis. Prior two takes included links in 1st tweet.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Because they do not want their extremist and even loony beliefs, readings, and topics exposed? Anyone can find my current syllabi, lectures, etc. on my RU website. And you will be able to find future ones there too.
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
Faculty should be perfectly happy to give the public access to their course syllabi, esp if you’re at a public uni.
I’ve never understood why professors recoil at this or frame it as some kind of creeping fascism. The public has a legitimate interest in what’s being taught. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
You're a very good writer, Joyce, but feel free to stick to novels. You do not know what you are talking about. Distinguished Professor here. This is one of my Substack posts, based on a long review chapter. Links in replies.
Joyce Carol Oates
@JoyceCarolOates
anyone who says "academia went far left" has spent little time at a university department meeting or senate.
in fact, anyone who says "academia" isn't on any university payroll.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Post:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-radicalization-of-the-am…
In which you will find this: -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Hi Joyce. You're a very good writer. But you do not know what you are talking about. Distinguished Professor here. See below. Based on a long review chapter. Links in replies.
Joyce Carol Oates
@JoyceCarolOates
anyone who says "academia went far left" has spent little time at a university department meeting or senate.
in fact, anyone who says "academia" isn't on any university payroll.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Substack post:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-radicalization-of-the-am…
In which you will find this: -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, plus test. Post linked below. Test: I had heard that X started UNdebooting tweets with links, so just tw'd that out. It got 188 views in 2 hours. So now I am trying retweeting it.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. Full slides plus explanatory text of my talk at SPSP on why it is not a healthy organization. Gonna try this. Rumor has it that X stopped deboosting links, so let's see.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-society-for-personality-… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. Full slides plus explanatory text of my talk at SPSP on why it is not a healthy organization. Gonna try this. Rumor has it that X stopped deboosting links, so let's see.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-society-for-personality-… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Thread on new NCRI report on Moral Inversion Syndrome: In which ideologies of "liberation" are found to predict stronger belief in the moral legitimacy of authoritarian regimes.
Zack Dulberg
@pianozack
Moral inversion and the rise of authoritarian sympathy
Ideologies that claim to be anti-oppressive, like antizionism and far-left progressivism, say they fight for the oppressed and against the violation of universal human rights.
We put these claims to the test, by asking 1270 Americans to assess the human rights records of democracies and authoritarian regimes, and take a battery of psychological tests.
The results were striking. Study link and highlights in 🧵 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Mattie told Hattie
About a thing she saw.
It had 2 big horns
And a wooly jaw. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
You can still find on the website of the Society for Personality and Social Psychology (SPSP) DEI "resources" declaring objectivity, individuality, time urgency, and "worship of the written word" to be, and I kid you not, "White supremacy." One might wonder why promotes the research of its members on its website (it can't be objective, right? that'd be White supremacy), permits the publishing of sole authored papers in its journals (individualism is White Supremacy), or even has journals (last I looked, they were "written words" and we do not want to be encouraging all those White Supremacists to "worship" them, right?
J.D. Haltigan, PhD 🏒👨💻
@JDHaltigan
In 2021 we saw Scientific American publish an article that essentially called the statistical normal distribution an oppressor force. Think about how deranged that is. This derangement is still ramapant in the Academy, most notably in psychology & psychiatry. Insane.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
No. But, then:
1. The post (linked below) merely estimates that ~75% of the claims in psych papers are false (or, at least, that believing them is not justified)
2. No one (that I know of) has taken it seriously enough to empirically assess it.
3. I do have a wide "uncertainty interval" around 75%.
Fleur van Kleur
@van_kleur
Tot slot: is deze stelling van Lee Jussim ooit weerlegd?
Gaat specifiek over zijn eigen vakgebied psychologie, maar kan ongetwijfeld ook over andere sociaalwetenschappelijke vakgebieden worden gemaakt.
/4This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The claim predates the Nature paper by over a year. Lol. You know, if we are going to do the silly lol thing. Which is sorta the opposite of evaluating the analysis on its merits.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
With that big Nature set of papers making the rounds finding ~50% replication rate across the social sciences, I'd figure I'd reup this 2024 Substack post. Replicability is a necessary but not sufficient condition for credibility. And I estimate that:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/75-of-psychology-claims-are-… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The chart shows reproducibility, not replicability. Reproducibility means "do other researchers get the same results from the same data doing the same analysis" as in the original paper. Note the title of the figure: Same methods, same data. It is true that the mega study also addressed replicability, which refers to whether other researchers using the same or similar methods get a similar result when conducting a new study. That chart is in the paper linked in the thread below, and I post it after this. 1/2
Marc Porter Magee 🎓
@marcportermagee
Education research the least likely to replicate according to a huge new paper published by Nature
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Interestingly, education is most replicable (despite being least reproducible) and econ is least replicable (despite being most reproducible).
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Yes indeed. This is the path to using LLMS/AIs to code text. Rigorous testing, transparency, human checking. Rinse & repeat till it is valid & reliable. Now imagine doing this to detect propaganda masquerading as scholarship. @ashleytrubin @SkepResCenter. @ncri_io.
Michael Inzlicht
@minzlicht
Qualitative coding is one of the most time-consuming tasks in social science research. Thousands of open-ended responses, trained coders, weeks of work. And all still vulnerable to fatigue and bias.
@GinoMarttelo and colleagues at @universidad_los and @Universida99410 de Colombia--with collaborators at University of Michigan, Rice University, University of Toronto, and University of Southampton--built a practical eight-step workflow for using LLMs to develop, test, and apply coding taxonomies to unstructured text.
No vague promises about AI potential. Actual prompts, Python code, and open materials.
We tested it on 3,183 personal goals collected across socioeconomic groups in Colombia. GPT-4 and human coders reached strong agreement (ICC = .824). Coding time: ~10 hours. Manual equivalent: 80+ hours. That's an 87.5% reduction, time better spent on literally any other part of the research process.
Researchers stay in control throughout. They design prompts, evaluate outputs, make decisions. The LLM handles the volume.
If your lab has a backlog of open-ended responses, this tutorial is worth your time.
link.springer.com/article/10.3758/s13428-026-02966-6 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
At Vanderbilt U for an invitation only conference on how to reform academia's many political dysfunctions. Vanderbilt exists bc of uber capitalist Cornelius Vanderbilt's largesse. He built a fortune starting with a single ferry boat. Something about that warms the cockles of my dissident heart.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Rightward shift of the public. As Noah Smith has relentlessly pointed out, far more people liked liberalism. Progressiviturns people away.
The Missing Data Depot
@data_depot
New YouGov report on American partisanship between 2007 and 2025 shows that with the one exception of college educated white men, every major demographic group in the US has become more Republican on balance over the last 20 years.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
TIL a new word on X. "Frippery." I have seen some of that frippery...
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
I've seen some threads dismissing the new LLM paper that shows a strong leftwing bias in academic publications.
Few mention that 50+ years of survey data show independent confirmation of its main finding. That suggests most of the online criticism is peripheral frippery. -
National Association of Scholars
@NASorg
Groundbreaking Scholarship!
Forget everything you knew about biology. The Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association has discovered that being born with a certain skin tone isn’t a demographic fact-it’s allegedly a terminal, infectious disease.
“Whiteness is a condition one first acquires and then one has: a malignant, parasitic-like condition to which ‘white’ people have a particular susceptibility. The condition is foundational, generating characteristic ways of being in one’s body, in one’s mind, and in one’s world.”
journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/00030651211008507
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I knew Moss's rhetoric was familiar, and mulled on it for months before it hit me. This is from several talks I have given about insane demonization rhetoric in academia.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Exactly. 2nd tweet is to Substack post with the quote. For a more academic review that presents the pipeline model (among many other things):
sites.rutgers.edu/lee-jussim/wp-content/uploads/sites/135…
The Missing Data Depot
@data_depot
How did social science research become so strongly left-leaning ? The Pipeline Model from @PsychRabble
provides an answer:
“The Pipeline Model suggests the existence of distributed coordination b/w the political far left, academia & mass media. Left media can refer to “scholarship” that reflects the ax-grinding ideologies of those who produce it far more than it reflects anything that is actually true, thereby creating the impression that left-affirming claims have more credibility than they deserve.”
“But leaving that aside for now, the main point here is self-selection: Once academia’s well-deserved reputation as a club for lefties that creates a hostile environment for righties gets around, it would be likely that selection into academia of far left radicals would exceed their representation in the general population.” -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I just realized, I have a new streak/record in progress: Its been 2.5 yearsish since I have been subject to a mobbing/cancelation attack. I joined in Twitter in 2017, the attacks started in 2018 and occurred intermittently thru end of 2023. Nothing since then, though. I can't say I miss it but lord did those things (ultimately) give my professional life booster rockets.
For a list of those attacks, see this post, link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"The best way to protect the ability to publicly dissent is to publicly dissent."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/my-vita-of-denunciation -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Excellent post. Highlights:
1. Current "stereotype threat" researchers have been redefining the term to the point of triviality:
Original: Fear of confirming stereotypes of one's group undermines performance on high stakes tests for Black and female students.
Revision: People do not like being exposed to negative stereotypes of their group.
2. Those doing the redefining mostly just "defend" stereotype threat, either w/o acknowledging that the most informative tests (pre-registered, large sample tests) have almost or always found no effects, or acknowledging it in the most superficial manner and "moving on."
Michael Inzlicht
@minzlicht
About 18 months ago I wrote about the fall of stereotype threat. It's making the rounds again. Dominic Packer and @jayvanbavel republished it in their newsletter, and Mary Murphy, one of the field's leading stereotype threat researchers, wrote a lengthy public rebuttal. The debate is alive. I have thoughts about her response. For now, I'm republishing the original essay with one small but important addition.
open.substack.com/pub/michaelinzlicht/p/is-steretype-thre… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Registered replication report, in press at AMPPS, N=1709, multi-lab, finds no stereotype threat effect on women's math performance.
osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/qctkp_v5
ht @minzlicht, of interest to @LGConwayIII -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Thread on Danish & W. European preparations to defend Greenland from a U.S. attack. Ht @the_apollonic. Down the thread: Denmark capitulated to the Nazis w/o a fight in 1940 and has committed to never again making that mistake. Also down the thread, Danish official: The US is not functioning normally.
ChrisO_wiki
@ChrisO_wiki
1/ Denmark was reportedly preparing for full-scale war with the US over Greenland in January, with military support from France, Germany, and Nordic nations. Elite troops and F-35 jets with live ammunition were sent, and runways were to be blown up to prevent an invasion. ⬇️
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In which a well-known rabbi defends California's right to exist.
drive.google.com/file/d/163dINAIJ6Mng3k7pdCHZLQCizj90Tdid… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Great Awokening is not winding down, at least not in sociology. In which Ashley assesses the frequency with which terms like "racism," "sexism," "lived experience," "settler colonial" etc. appear in sociology journals -- and they are still generally increasing.
Dr. Ashley T. Rubin
@ashleytrubin
New substack: Trends in AJS Articles open.substack.com/pub/ashleytrubin/p/trends-in-ajs-articl…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
What a great thread. I wish more scientific discourse was like this (scholarship, critique of the scholarship, critique of the critique while still acknowledging it got some things right). On scientific claims, and critiques, regarding hunter-gatherer practices.
Ed Hagen
@ed_hagen
1. Does research by @CaraOcobock @Anthrofuentes & others, widely reported in SciAm & elsewhere, finally dispel hunter-gatherer myths that have persisted since the 60's?
In a preprint led by @vivek_vasi The Meanings&Dividends of Man the Hunter osf.io/preprints/osf/gawbt_v1 we respond🧵 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Popper: "He did not have the good sense to resist the influence of a pretentious, lying and intelligence destroying university education."
Phil Magness
@PhilWMagness
Karl Popper on Habermas and Adorno...
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Hmmm. They only measured rightwing authoritarianism. Put differently, whether it makes you "more authoritarian" is a q that can't be answered by this research, and will have to await a replication that also measures leftwing authoritarianism.
Bonus: The linked paper clearly used Duckitt's RWA scale, which Duckitt duly referred to as RWA. The authors of the linkedd paper then did not refer to RWA, and instead, referred to "authoritarianism." That this subtle form of political bias was not caught even by Pinker testifies to how pernicious it can be.
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Does being smart make you less authoritarian and more socially liberal? James Lee (former student), Emily Willoughby, & colleagues present evidence (including ruling out confounds) which suggests the answer is yes. | Predicting political beliefs with polygenic scores for cognitive performance and educational attainment - PubMed pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39130356/
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Committee for Academic Freedom
@ComAcFreedom
🚨 BREAKING: Another win for #academicfreedom!
After intervention from the Committee for Academic Freedom (CAF), Plymouth Marjon University has restored the emeritus title of Dr David Harris, which was withdrawn last year after he published a critique of critical race theory.
Internal emails secured via a Subject Access Request (SAR) show senior administrators describing Professor Harris’s research as “controversial” and suggesting the university should “sever ties”.
CAF challenged the decision as procedurally improper and inconsistent with the terms under which his emeritus title had originally been awarded. The university has now reversed course and reinstated the title.
As our Research Manager Freddie Attenborough told The Telegraph:
“The episode raises serious questions about how easily lawful academic research can end up being labelled ‘controversial’ inside university administration, with damaging consequences for the individuals involved.”
Professor Harris isn’t the first emeritus scholar we’ve had to defend — and we doubt he’ll be the last.
🙏 Much of CAF’s work, from supporting members in difficult cases to holding universities to account for breaches of #freespeech law, is only possible because of donations from supporters. If you’d like to help us continue and expand this work in defence of academic freedom, you can donate here:
donorbox.org/support-the-committee-for-academic-freedom
📩 Subscribe to our newsletter to see how CAF is pushing back against free speech breaches across UK universities:
afcomm.org.uk/updates-from-the-committee/
📰 Read the full story in The Telegraph here:
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/03/14/academic-stripped-tit… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Lone Criminologist
@lonecrim
Curious as to whether the American Society of Criminology would entertain a panel on the professional-intellectual health of the Society.
March 20th is the deadline for submissions.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply. Post includes video of four talks presented at the 2026 conference of SPSP, on a panel titled, "Is SPSP a Healthy Organization?"
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
ASA leadership decides to ... focus on sociology and eschew statements on political issues not directly related to the discipline, essentially, a form of institutional (in this case, organizational) neutrality. I never would have predicted this.
Dr. Ashley T. Rubin
@ashleytrubin
I *never* say this, but good for ASA! (My read of this is: we have a policy we have to stick to that lets people make these silly resolutions, but we think this is a silly and harmful resolution. I can and do respect that.)
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I agree with the sentiment. The noble & often glorious history of the US should be taught & celebrated. But that full history also includes much that was ignoble & inglorious. That too should be taught. For the best honest detailed history of the US, listen to The History of the Americans podcast.
thehistoryoftheamericans.com
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
Bluntly put: praising, honoring, and teaching the noble history of your society is far far far far far o
96x more important than endlessly coddling the feelings of a constantly offended bloc of minorities and women - or anyone else.
This is, in fact, more important than ANYTHING else, after perhaps military defense. "Late wave feminism" and "promoting diversity" are probably not in the 1,000 most important and useful things a society can do. These add, basically, nothing to the coffers. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Nice short thread critiquing "experts say" its fascism.
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
I'm quite sympathetic to parts of the message here but placing so much weight on "experts say" makes it very unlikely to persuade the audiences the message needs to reach. Just make the object-level arguments instead. Many people - in many cases quite understandably - don't view the expert class as unbiased epistemic authorities, especially on political issues.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Slavery based economies almost always, maybe absolutely always, underperform compared to free economies. The North was already an economic powerhouse compared to the South, which is a major reason it won the Civil War.
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Six More Myths About Gender, Race, and Inequality
1. The Myth That American Wealth Was Built on Slavery
[Link below.] -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Luke Conway
@LGConwayIII
An excellent summary from @PsychRabble of our 2026 SPSP symposium titled "Is SPSP a Healthy Organization?" You can read about what happened, watch versions of all four of our talks, and get Lee's superb suggestions for what we should do next.
For my part, the symposium was much better received than I ever imagined, and I'd like to thank SPSP for letting it happen. I'm also grateful to the people who attended for their patient consideration, as well as the colleagues who engaged in dialogue for their many intelligent and thoughtful questions.
Finally, I'd like to thank my fellow speakers: @PsychRabble, @natehoneycutt, and @awilson_WLU. All of them were terrific. Lee in his usual fearless manner; Nate in his calm, erudite, and empirical style; and a special shout-out to Anne for her brilliant and extremely fair breakdown (and rebuttal) of the rest of our critiques of SPSP. If you haven't already done so, I'd encourage you to watch all of the talks!
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply. Post includes video of four talks presented at the 2026 conference of SPSP, on a panel titled, "Is SPSP a Healthy Organization?"
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Omar Sultan Haque
@OmarSHaqueMDPhD
The discipline of psychology is supposed to be the study of the human mind.
In reality, data consistently shows it’s the study of questions allowable in left-wing belief systems (ie it functions as a liberal secular madrasa’s research arm).
@natehoneycutt did a “large language model content analysis of the political valence and activist orientation of 26 years of abstracts of presentations” at the largest social psychology conference.
Note that even in the good old days of 25 years ago, there was still vast bias in intellectual diversity.
Complete discussion at
@PsychRabble Substack:
open.substack.com/pub/unsafescience/p/the-singeing-of-the… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
To be clear, they are my slides, but the quotes are from SCOTUS's 1978 Bakke decision, the one that, while legalizing use of race for admissions on viewpoint diversity grounds, specifically prohibited doing so on social justice grounds. Overcoming "oppression" was never a legal basis for discrimination in admissions in the U.S.
Brandon
@BrandonLukeMc
Interesting slides on the legality/morality of DEI, from @PsychRabble talk at the "Is SPSP a healthy organisation?" symposium:
Positive discrimination "imposes disadvantages upon persons ... who bear no responsibility for whatever harm the beneficiaries of the special admissions program are thought to have suffered." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Anne Wilson
@awilson_WLU
Sharing a summary of the 2026 symposium "Is SPSP a Healthy Society?" Talks by @natehoneycutt @LGConwayIII @PsychRabble and me. The post reflects @PsychRabble's distinct perspective; you can review the talks and decide for yourself. My takeaway: Dissent is an epistemic resource.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply. Post includes video of four talks presented at the 2026 conference of SPSP, on a panel titled, "Is SPSP a Healthy Organization?"
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply. Post includes video of four talks presented at the 2026 conference of SPSP, on a panel titled, "Is SPSP a Healthy Organization?"
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply. Post includes video of four talks presented at the 2026 conference of SPSP, on a panel titled, "Is SPSP a Healthy Organization?"
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Of possible interest to @PhDissident, @BrandonWarmke, @rbnmckenna86, @robsica, @saltypsych, @BrandonLukeMc, @minzlicht, @yorl, @JonHaidt, @sapinker, @SkepResCenter, @ashleytrubin, @calliehburt, @CJFerguson1111, @SteveStuWill, @ImHardcory, @PTetlock, @matthewgburgess, @epkaufm, @jean_twenge, @gmiller, @HSJSpeaks
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Luke's talk:
theapologeticprofessor.substack.com/p/the-scientific-meth…
Having to explain the obvious to an auditorium full of social psychologists exemplifies how far my field has fallen. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Nice quick summary of the Singeing of the Social Psychological Beard panel at SPSP. Luke Conway's. @LGConwayIII talk is already online, link in reply. More to come at Unsafe Science, too.
Justin Mogilski
@justin_mogilski
Don’t have time to write a blog post but:
1) @PsychRabble pointed out vague, exclusionary, and mostly non-scientific language on the SPSP website and in policy, and I’m increasingly convinced by his evidence for the chilling effects he has written about extensively.
2) @LGConwayIII argued that that the scientific method has a universal, underlying logic that has been recurrently discovered across all societies and is useful for adjudicating questions about truth, and that we abandon this standard at our peril (this received applause).
3) Nathan presented data using AI language scraping tools to show that the language of SPSP accepted abstracts has become increasingly “liberal” (i.e., includes more liberal-aligned language), and argues that this could become… uh… runaway selection of certain types of research, which would be unhealthy in the long run. He recommended a separation of science and activism because scientists are in the business of earning trust from the public that the data they collect are impartial or that bias has been systematically accounted during data collection, etc.
4) @awilson_WLU cleaned up with the devil’s advocate position that the shifts in research focus or practice that people have noticed (and the dissent from *either* side of this) are a necessary part of a healthy scientific society able to self-correct, and as long as the society and its researchers continue to make room to critique and judge all work by a fair standard (e.g., scientific rigor), then the system will ultimately work as intended.
Many missing details in this, but these are the impressions I was left with.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Luke's talk:
theapologeticprofessor.substack.com/p/the-scientific-meth…
Having to explain the obvious to an auditorium full of social psychologists exemplifies how far my field has fallen. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This was entirely predictable. How do I know? @PamelaParesky & I predicted exactly this when the ethnic studies curriculum was being considered. Link in reply.
Eli Steele
@Hebro_Steele
Nearly two years after we exposed antisemitism in Bay Area schools, the California school system is being sued for failing to address the issue. However, this lawsuit will fall short if it does not address the root of this hatred: all forms of ethnic studies, including liberated ethnic studies.
freebeacon.com/california/jewish-students-are-segregated-…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
jewishjournal.com/commentary/332109/why-no-one-should-acc…
"What children will not be taught is the actual history of the oppression of Jews." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
We need a betting market, say, on how likely this will be at the top 100 research U's, over the next 3 years.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
“If colleges and universities want to remain socially relevant and financially stable, they’re going to have to confront the reality that large segments of the public increasingly see them as exclusionary rather than open.”
Great piece by @natehoneycutt -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Matt Grawitch
@DocGrawitch
r = .04. p < .05. Cue the moral panic.
This post breaks down how weak effects become “proof” when they fit the right story. - When Small Effects Make Big Headlines, by @DocGrawitch Shoutout to @CJFerguson1111 for the stimulus for this. open.substack.com/pub/mattgrawitch/p/when-small-effects-m… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Luke Conway
@LGConwayIII
For those attending #spsp2026, we'd love to have you at our sure-to-be-interesting session "Is SPSP a Healthy Organization?" on Saturday at 2:00 in E352 (Level 3).
We have a great lineup of speakers from a variety of perspectives: Lee Jussim, Nate Honeycutt, myself, and Anne Wilson. Hope to see everyone there for genuine debate and discussion!
@PsychRabble @awilson_WLU -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Here is my talk: "No, its not." (ok, I do explain why). Shown, the key thematic points.
Luke Conway
@LGConwayIII
For those attending #spsp2026, we'd love to have you at our sure-to-be-interesting session "Is SPSP a Healthy Organization?" on Saturday at 2:00 in E352 (Level 3).
We have a great lineup of speakers from a variety of perspectives: Lee Jussim, Nate Honeycutt, myself, and Anne Wilson. Hope to see everyone there for genuine debate and discussion!
@PsychRabble @awilson_WLU -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Based on a glorified X (formerly Twitter) survey. For explanation, see next tweet.
Prof. Katharine Hayhoe
@KHayhoe
Bluesky is the new science Twitter: new study concludes
For the past decade, Twitter has been a primary home of scientists on social media. In recent years, new leadership at Twitter has made substantive changes that have resulted in increases in the prevalence of pseudoscience, conspiracy theory, and harassment on the platform, causing many scientists to seek alternatives. [including me]
Survey results overwhelmingly confirm that changes to Twitter have made the social media platform no longer professionally useful or pleasant, and that many scientists have abandoned it in favor of Bluesky.
Results show that for every reported professional benefit that scientists once gained from Twitter, scientists can now gain that benefit more effectively on Bluesky than on Twitter.
academic.oup.com/icb/article-abstract/65/3/538/8196180?lo…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Its biologists doing sampling and there is likely large, maybe massive, selection bias. Here's how they wrote about their sampling:
"Posts advertising the survey were shared on both platforms through the accounts of author DS, who is one of the most followed scientists on both Twitter and Bluesky, and is connected through those platforms to many other highly followed professional science accounts who also helped to share the survey link."
DS is David Shiffman. Here is what the paper says about him prior:
"Under new ownership, changes to Twitter's moderation policy and algorithm have allowed pseudoscience, conspiracy theory, and harassment (especially of academics who are not white men, Levy 2023) to flourish (Kupferschmidt 2022). These issues have previously led author DS (David Shiffman) to recommend that scientists abandon Twitter and explore other platforms (Shiffman 2025)." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply. In which a sociologist and I argue that academia needs viewpoint/political/ideological diversity for its own health, and that the head of the Hopkins AAUP chapter (Siraganian's) Seven Theses against it are ignorant, confused, and demonstrably wrong.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/truth-trust-and-the-case-for…
"For example, the Supreme Court, in its 1978 Bakke decision – a decision that predates Horowitz by a generation – justified the use of race in admissions primarily on viewpoint diversity grounds...
Had academia prioritized viewpoint diversity in admissions (and hiring)... academia might not be in the mess it’s currently in and the use of diversity in admissions might never have been overruled." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Can someone steelman for me a serious argument that this type of problem will be solved by "self-reform" of academia, without outside intervention?
@BorkNathanial, you're good at this sort of thing. @matthewgburgess? So are you.
P.S. Shot. Chaser next retweet.
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
Academics: "No one is trying to hire scholars to do activism. That's just a made up right-wing trope used to attack universities."
Philosophers, right in their job ads:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Chaser. Not only are departments explicitly recruiting for activists, rather than focusing on educating students, they are seeking to cultivate the next generation of activists.
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
There are entire departments and fields where a primary goal is to create activists and teach activism. This evidence is easy to find all over the university curriculum and by admission of faculty themselves. For example, here's a paper by one of your own colleagues at Coastal Carolina on activism in the classroom.
“The historical connection between activism and teaching WGS [Women’s and Gender Studies] as activism as well as WGS’ intention to connect theory with praxis have been well-documented.
"I investigate how we can transfer an activist consciousness to our students...
“I firmly believe that activism-based courses can make an important contribution to the WGS curriculum and feminist pedagogy more broadly.
“Perhaps more than ever, it is essential right now that we take a close look at our approaches to ‘teach[ing] students political strategy” and giving them the feeling of social “efficacy’”
I sometimes wonder why people are so resistant to simply admitting how much activism has taken over. Lots of motivated reasoning going on. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply. In which a sociologist and I argue that academia needs viewpoint/political/ideological diversity for its own health, and that the head of the Hopkins AAUP chapter (Siraganian's) Seven Theses against it are ignorant, confused, and demonstrably wrong.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/truth-trust-and-the-case-for…
"For example, the Supreme Court, in its 1978 Bakke decision – a decision that predates Horowitz by a generation – justified the use of race in admissions primarily on viewpoint diversity grounds...
Had academia prioritized viewpoint diversity in admissions (and hiring)... academia might not be in the mess it’s currently in and the use of diversity in admissions might never have been overruled." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Tour de force on how ideological bias manifests as unjustified conclusions ... the paper is more general, but has a case study involving debunking a prior paper on beliefs and attitudes towards transgender people.
Callie Burt
@calliehburt
📃 Of potential interest: accepted paper (publication delayed in production).
The paper examines how ideological homogeneity can bias research practices, using transgender research as a case study.
The accepted version + supplement are available here: callieburt.org/publications. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Returns to education? 1. The lit finds they are substantial, ~8%/yr of ed. 2. The lit has substantial pub biases favoring studies finding such benefits. 3. Correct for pub bias, and return is near 0. Link to paper below. ht @jonatanpallesen
HEDG (Historical Economics and Development Group)
@SDUeconhist
Check out this interesting new article titled: "The Returns to Education: A Meta-Study" by @GregoryClarkUCD & @CAANielsen 🎓
👉Read it here: onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/kykl.70041 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is very amusing...
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Harvard has proposed a cap on A grades, and students are not happy:
“It misses the point of college, which is to network, go out there, have fun…. It would create so much pressure where life wouldn’t be worth that much to live.”
“We pay to go here to get the product, which is to have a better signal of performance…. If you’re just lowering that for everyone, then you’re just lowering the value you provide as a business for the same cost, even while raising tuition year over year.”
“You accept a bunch of top 3 percent students in the country and then get surprised that we’re getting all As…. I don’t understand the point of ranking against each other.”
“There’s no benefit that is derived from just giving fewer people the grades they deserve…. More spread out grades in a class is only harming the kids that are working hard.” -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Another nice thread (she really is a must-follow). This thread has gone semi-viral, with 125k views.
Dr. Ashley T. Rubin
@ashleytrubin
I really don't want the feminization hypothesis to be right, but when you see results like these (from Horowitz et al. 2018's survey of soc faculty -- 14% response rate)...
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Nice thread on how the main US sociological academic society is ... misguided at best.
Dr. Ashley T. Rubin
@ashleytrubin
So, ASA is really leaning into this activist thing. I'd like to practice a sociology that's a science--not invested in specific outcomes, but answering questions. Other people (or sociologists in their off hours) can work to shape the world with or without those answers.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
John links the Chronicle article by @EmmaJanePettit
1/2
On pervasive illegal racial/ethnic discriminate at The Ohio State U uncovered by FOIA requests. No one paying attention thinks OSU was unique.
"for a position studying “Black France,” a slim majority of applicants were white. Seven of the 12 chosen for the Zoom-interview round were white. Yet the committee decided that bringing Black candidates to campus was “essential,” according to the report, and “thus chose” three Black finalists."
John Sailer
@JohnDSailer
When I first started reporting on higher ed, a professor told me “every day, universities wake up and break the law.” Turns out, they also carefully document it.
Great piece by @EmmaJanePettit, which features a trove of documents acquired by yours truly. www.chronicle.com/article/diversity-hiring-faces-a-reckoning
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I addressed the related issue here. Near the end I review fed law making conspiracy to deprive others of their rights a felony (e.g., to be hired on bases not excluded by US Civil Rights Law).
unsafescience.substack.com/p/was-dei-a-conspiracy
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Update. Upon further review, I revised the post. Nonviolent conspiracy to deprive others of their rights is merely a misdemeanor. Law source: www.justice.gov/crt/statutes-enforced-criminal-section
ht @matthewgburgess for the correction. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Luke Conway
@LGConwayIII
Good heavens. Trump is not a fascist (yet) in any meaningful sense of the term. He's also not Hitler, a dictator, or a king. I'm open to discussions of executive overreach and the dangers of Trump's presidency. I don't like what he says about Greenland any more than most Americans. But if you want to be taken seriously by independent minds, all this name-calling of the man the country voted for (in a democratic election!) to enforce our laws isn't helping.
Instead of reading the Atlantic, I think people would be better served instead to read this excellent piece by @PsychRabble:
open.substack.com/pub/unsafescience/p/how-to-tell-whether…
Jonathan Haidt
@JonHaidt
Jonathan Rauch, one of America's wisest analysts, had resisted using the term "fascism," offering instead "patrimonialism." But recent events from Greenland to Minneapolis changed his mind. He lays it all out in this important essay in @TheAtlantic
www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/01/america-fascism-trump-m… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Erec Smith Likes Rhetoric
@Rhetors_of_York
Many of them didn't forget that causation ≠ correlation; it's part of their M.O. They are hoping WE forgot or never learned the difference in the first place.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Explanations
"Their statistical training was good enough, but they never learned it. Maybe they were high during stat class."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/peer-review-of-microaggressi… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Piracy: At the root of borh democracy and health insurance?
www.youtube.com/watch?v=x4sbwP8kzDk -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply. Warning, Peer Review Disaster Area Ahead.
1/2 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Where's taupe? I think I never heard of taupe till I was like 55... Also, I had to look up how to spell it for this tweet.
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Which words are known better by women than men, and which by men than women?
I’ve removed the key showing which color represents which sex, because I’m pretty sure you won’t be needing it…
[Link below.] -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply. Warning, Peer Review Disaster Area Ahead.
1/2
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Explanations
"Their statistical training was good enough, but they never learned it. Maybe they were high during stat class."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/peer-review-of-microaggressi… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"The first detransitioner medical malpractice case that has gone to trial has resulted in a $2 million verdict against those who cut off the breasts of a 16-year-old girl who, at the time, identified as transgender but no longer does...
the question surrounded whether the "doctors" took the necessary steps to evaluate Varian before the surgery was performed."
@aytchellesse @profjmb @SwipeWright
People were fired when the world went "social justice mad" for arguing that people, especially minors, should be psychologically evaluated for other issues before going to surgeries.
thepostmillennial.com/detransitioner-wins-2-million-malpr… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
NYTimes article on court cases seeking to overturn affirmative action programs has this amazing quote, 1st time I've seen anyone in academia admit that DEI=affirmative action (in context, of the preferential selection/discrimination type).
www.nytimes.com/2026/01/31/us/politics/affirmative-action…
@justin_mogilski @awilson_WLU @azimshariff -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Jc James
@jcjames_ca
Must read
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/we-must-be-doing-something-r…
"It tells you we are on the right track in our attempts to enlist AI to rigorously, accurately and efficiently distinguish between scholarship that is heavily distorted by propaganda and scholarship that is not." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
That degree is back. But there were 3 of them half an hour ago. The rising sun seems to be scaring them away...?
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Apollonic
@the_apollonic
Lee's barbecues are the best 👇😎🤘
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply. In which I do battle with a propaganda sociologist on X. With a cameo by @ashleytrubin & art by @the_apollonic.
"Duh! Academic promoting propaganda masquerading as scholarship objects to … methods for revealing propaganda masquerading as scholarship! This is exactly the type of academic I hope to be denounced, insulted and ridiculed by. Strongly indicates we got it right." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Rigorus Mortis Selectivus manifesting in admin decisions, not just peer review. Source next tweet.
ht @matthewgburgess.
Neetu Arnold
@neetu_arnold
I find it funny that universities needed to show evidence & studies for why bringing back the SATs was good, but nobody gave the same kind of evidence for dropping the tests
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply. In which I do battle with a propaganda sociologist on X. With a cameo by @ashleytrubin & art by @the_apollonic.
"Duh! Academic promoting propaganda masquerading as scholarship objects to … methods for revealing propaganda masquerading as scholarship! This is exactly the type of academic I hope to be denounced, insulted and ridiculed by. Strongly indicates we got it right." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Brandon
@BrandonLukeMc
This quote is exactly what I made this “meme” (loosely described):
“sociologists are a vanguard. They possess insights into the workings of the social world that derive from their social theory but are denied to the laity mired in the swamp of common sense and everyday understandings.” -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply. In which I do battle with a propaganda sociologist on X. With a cameo by @ashleytrubin & art by @the_apollonic.
"Duh! Academic promoting propaganda masquerading as scholarship objects to … methods for revealing propaganda masquerading as scholarship! This is exactly the type of academic I hope to be denounced, insulted and ridiculed by. Strongly indicates we got it right."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/we-must-be-doing-something-r…
"It tells you we are on the right track in our attempts to enlist AI to rigorously, accurately and efficiently distinguish between scholarship that is heavily distorted by propaganda and scholarship that is not." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I've only read the tweet. But ... Hell yeah! The Ivies did their part to dig the hole academia is in. Is there a chance they will help lead the way out? Yes. A chance.
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Dartmouth President Sian Beilock:
“Assuming that most Americans value our mission is a recipe for irrelevance and decline. We must demonstrate to students and families—and to the broader public—that we’ve heard their criticisms and will address them.”
Five steps:
1. “Make college affordable”
2. “Return on investment matters…there must be an undeniable return.”
3. “Re-center higher education on learning rather than political posturing.”
4. “Emphasize equal opportunity, not equal outcomes.”
5. “Testing is important.” -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Oh. In that case, I am going back to bed.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
If someone paid you $4.75 every night you slept 7+ hours, would you sleep more?
And--more importantly--would that increase in sleep change your behavior in other meaningful ways?
This new paper ran an experiment to find out.
Researchers recruited ~1200 college students.
These students were randomized into two conditions:
1.) a control group where people slept like they normally would.
2.) a treatment group that received a Fitbit and an app to track their sleep, feedback on whether they achieved 7 hours of sleep, and the $4.75 deposited in a Venmo account if they did so.
The researchers kept the treatment in place for 4 weeks.
They then continued to measure participants' behavior for 5 additional weeks.
What did they find?
They found that, the treatment increased sleep time by about 19 minutes on average during the treatment period.
After the program, treated participants continued to sleep about 8 minutes more on average.
But that's not all! At the end of the semester, treated students had noticeably, but modestly, higher grades.
Finally, the authors compared the effects of their treatment to other educational interventions.
Though the educational gains were modest in size, so too was the program cost.
Compared to many education interventions, this was remarkably cheap per unit of achievement.
Bottom line (in the authors’ words): "incentives to sleep can be a cost-effective tool for improving educational outcomes." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
T&S does it again. From the abstract (open access paper linked in their tweet):
"Relative to the general population, Blacks are underrepresented among medical school graduates; relative to AP examinees, they are neither under nor overrepresented among medical school graduates; relative to top AP performers, they are strongly overrepresented among medical school graduates. The same data tell three different stories, only one of which respects the structure of a meritorious pipeline."
By the great @BleskeRechek & @JukkaSavo
Theory and Society (Springer Nature)
@Theory_Society
"We argue that treating disparity as prima facie evidence of discrimination obscures the real problem: unequal preparation."
Powerful commentary, with new and compelling data, and it's open access here: link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-025-09680-w -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"None of the studies cited in this review actually measured microaggressive behaviors of perpetrators."
-- Claude
"Claude is correct"
-- me.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, co-authored with @robsica, link in reply.
1/3
In which Rob enlists the AI, Claude, to evaluate whether a just-published review of microaggressions is sound science or propaganda. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"None of the studies cited in this review actually measured microaggressive behaviors of perpetrators."
-- Claude
"Claude is correct"
-- me.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, co-authored with @robsica, link in reply.
1/3
In which Rob enlists the AI, Claude, to evaluate whether a just-published review of microaggressions is sound science or propaganda. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Matt Grawitch
@DocGrawitch
A librarian, a psychologist, and an AI walk into the microaggressions literature. What comes out is a proof-of-concept: AI can dramatically speed up serious scholarly debunking — without dumbing it down. Good piece by @robsica and @PsychRabble open.substack.com/pub/unsafescience/p/using-ai-to-reveal-…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Rob Sica
@robsica
😹💵🌴For a detonation of hilarity, see this comment by 'boogie mann':
unsafescience.substack.com/p/using-ai-to-reveal-bad-biase…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, co-authored with @robsica, link in reply.
1/3
In which Rob enlists the AI, Claude, to evaluate whether a just-published review of microaggressions is sound science or propaganda. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, co-authored with @robsica, link in reply.
1/3
In which Rob enlists the AI, Claude, to evaluate whether a just-published review of microaggressions is sound science or propaganda. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
XCountry skiing on the D&R Canal towpath. Last week.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
View from my NJ backyard a few days ago.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, co-authored with @robsica, link in reply.
1/3
In which Rob enlists the AI, Claude, to evaluate whether a just-published review of microaggressions is sound science or propaganda.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/using-ai-to-reveal-bad-biase…
Quoting Claude: “This article exhibits nearly all the methodological problems Jussim identifies.”
2/3
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Claude's overall summary of the microaggression review (which is linked in the post):
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Douzy of a finding. I suspect the same would be true for any valid critique of any paper; i.e., it is more harmful to the critic than to those proposing nonsense/distortions/unjustified conclusions.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
"Once a paper is published ... it is more harmful to one's career to point out the fraud than to be the one committing it."
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is very amusing in that "academia is deeply scientifically dysfunctional on social justice 'scholarship'" sort of way. Scroll up & down for details.
Rob Sica
@robsica
I asked Claude to critically evaluate the article in light of your Substack piece (above):
🔪"This review paper, published in January 2026, shows the field hasn't addressed Jussim's fundamental critiques."
claude.ai/share/2bc3128e-ff76-4a99-b8d1-66ea5ccb6dbe -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
There is a degree out there. If only we could find it.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Tour de force Substack post by @Edokwin. Link in reply.
"The problem isn’t just that progressives got specific policies wrong. It’s that they’ve constructed an entire worldview in which very basic things most human beings take for granted are deemed “fundamentally and morally wrong.”
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
edokwin.substack.com/p/progressives-must-apologize-before
"That foreigners are not citizens, and citizens’ interests come first. That children are not adults capable of consenting to irreversible medical procedures. That rapid demographic transformation of neighborhoods affects quality of life. That borders serve legitimate functions. That merit matters. That parents have primary authority over their children’s education and upbringing. And that the wrongness of racism & sexism leave no space for social justice carveouts; racism against Asians, Europeans, and Jews is still racism, sexism against men (misandry) is still sexism, and so forth.
These aren’t fringe positions held by extremists. They’re baseline assumptions held by overwhelming majorities across every Western, liberal democracy. And progressives have spent fifteen years treating people who hold these views as moral monsters." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This might be the best shortish (<20min) summary of the (dare I say it?) intersection of political biases with the Replication Crisis.
Ryan Rogers
@ryanMcRogers
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
For younger people, the more liberal they are, the more neurotic they are. For older people, neuroticism is unrelated to liberalism. 2025 study, N>1600, based on GSS (nationally representative).
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/issj.70025
(In fig below, Ideology goes from 1-7, with higher scores more conservative).
Paging @JDHaltigan, @SkepResCenter, @yorl, @minzlicht, @slsatel, @CatherineSalmon, @natehoneycutt -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
None. I never signed up for the payout version.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Twitter should be much more transparent about its payouts.
In the meantime, I’d love to see folks post theirs.
Here’s mine: 45M impressions in 2025 generated about $3k. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
So far only read the tweet but the linked study is described as validating audit studies of racial discrimination with evidence of actual hiring biases.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
"But résumé studies only measure callbacks. They don’t tell us who actually gets hired."
These authors of this brand new preprint wanted to know whether discrimination measured in résumé studies shows up in real hiring.
So they linked a large résumé audit experiment to actual employment data.
First, here are the details on the résumé study:
-Identical resumes
-Randomly assigned Black- vs. White-sounding names
-Sent to 100+ large U.S. firms
-Measured racial gaps in callbacks
Second, here are the details on the real-world data:
-Matched those same firms to millions of LinkedIn employment records
-Measured the racial composition of actual new hires
What did they find?
Firms that discriminated more against Black applicants in callbacks:
-Hired significantly fewer Black workers during the exact period of the audit
-Especially in entry-level jobs
A move from a moderately discriminatory firm to a highly discriminatory one reduces the Black share of new hires by 17%.
Bottom line:
Audit studies aren’t just measuring on paper discrimination.
Callback gaps map directly onto realworld hiring outcomes. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Chris has oodles of credibility with stuff like this, having, e.g., once declared that I was "just like Alex Jones" and having never once objected to the mass of punishment, including firings, inflicted on faculty during the social justice moral panic of 2015-2023. Plus, see his pod. "Jordan Peterson bad, Ibram Kendi good." Actually, though, the "syllabi that prioritize ideology" point is actually quite a good one, link in reply. 1/2
Chris Kavanagh
@C_Kavanagh
Looking forward to your follow-up on this, Lee! Ideological loyalty tests from funders, political interference, staff being fired for personal opinions on social media, and syllabi that prioritise ideology over science. This sounds right up your street. www.politico.com/news/magazine/2026/01/16/civil-war-unive…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
On ideological syllabi:
www.persuasion.community/p/we-analyzed-university-syllabi…
Excerpt:
"So what is assigned with The New Jim Crow? Mostly books that are broadly aligned with it. The three most commonly co-assigned texts include Angela Davis’s Are Prisons Obsolete?, Ta-Nehisi Coates’s Between the World and Me, and Michel Foucault’s Discipline and Punish. We estimate that less than 10 percent of professors assigning Alexander’s book actually teach the controversy surrounding it."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Bonus, on ideological litmus tests:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Yale achieves academic Nirvana. No Republicans on faculty. Ht @Bryce_Nickels
Jonathan Turley
@JonathanTurley
Yale University has finally achieved the academic version of Nirvana, a state of perfect peace and enlightenment. A recent study found that the faculty had finally purged every Republican donor from its faculty ranks. jonathanturley.org/2026/01/15/yale-reaches-academic-nirva…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/how-to-tell-whether-trump-is…
It is short and to the point... (this one is for paid subscribers). -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Looks excellent. Wish I could go.
Daniël Lakens
@lakens
The program for the Perspectives on Scientific Error conference Februari 11 to 13 in Leiden is online!
Registration is open! perspectivesonscientificerror2026.wordpress.com
This is one of the most inspiring and fun metascience meetings around - lots of time to interact, great talks - so do come! -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Yale achieves academic Nirvana. No Republicans on faculty. Ht @Bryce_Nickels
Jonathan Turley
@JonathanTurley
Yale University has finally achieved the academic version of Nirvana, a state of perfect peace and enlightenment. A recent study found that the faculty had finally purged every Republican donor from its faculty ranks. jonathanturley.org/2026/01/15/yale-reaches-academic-nirva…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Very interesting paper from 2023 (that I just discovered). Link in reply. From the abstract:
"... social scientists’ forecasts [for societal change] were on average no more accurate than those of simple statistical models (historical means, random walks or linear regressions) or the aggregate forecasts of a sample from the general public (N = 802). However, scientists were more accurate if they had scientific expertise in a prediction domain, were interdisciplinary, used simpler models and based predictions on prior data."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Ego-Depletion Lives! Despite suffering repeat multi-lab failures to replicate, a new multi-lab replic, with a much more intensive manipulation, conducted in both China and several western countries, reports reliably and repeatedly getting the effect! Link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Of possible interest to @minzlicht, @LGConwayIII
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
U of Austin's DEI statement:
www.uaustin.org/dei -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Who could have possibly predicted this?
Rob Sica
@robsica
"stereotypes about women and men are, on the whole, accurate at the level of the female and male social categories and reflect people’s direct and indirect observations in their own society" www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.2510180122
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Nikil Mukerji
@nikilmukerji
Timur Sevincer (@gwup) und ich sprachen mit dem Psychologen Lee Jussim (@PsychRabble) über Vorurteile, Stereotype und Wissenschaftskommunikation. Das Interview erschien in der letzten Ausgabe des Skeptiker-Hefts – und nun auch auf Lee's Substack:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/focus-like-a-laser-on-merit
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. Link in reply. "I have some hope that if you keep hammering away at the truth as revealed by the strongest evidence, it will change minds. But I wouldn’t bet my life on it."
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. Link in reply. "I have some hope that if you keep hammering away at the truth as revealed by the strongest evidence, it will change minds. But I wouldn’t bet my life on it."
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is not exactly wrong, it is probably good advice. And yet, it is not the only thing that is going on at "good" journals. 🧵 w/links to my recent stories about why we failed to get Nature to accept a proposal to publish a strong, direct replication of a famous study at PNAS (PNAS did not even have a registered report format, so we did not try).
1/n with links.
Razia Aliani
@RaziaAliani
Your paper isn't getting rejected because your research is bad.
Here's what actually gets papers rejected ⤵️
Your literature review is outdated
Copying and paraphrasing old reviews? Editors spot this instantly.
They want fresh citations from the last 2-3 years.
You're working on exhausted topics
When 1000+ papers already exist on your topic, your work needs something genuinely new.
First movers get published. Fast followers get cited.
Your sample is too small or convenient
Student samples? Snowball sampling? Convenient sampling?
Desk rejection.
Premier journals demand robust methodology.
No theoretical contribution
Data without theory = rejection.
Your findings need to advance how we understand the phenomenon.
You're defending instead of revising
Getting a revise-and-resubmit is rare (5-7% of submissions).
Treat reviewer comments like gold.
Implement them. Don't defend.
The 3 things that changed my acceptance rate:
→ Mixed methods over single studies
→ Multiple experiments in one paper
→ Including co-authors with complementary expertise
Publishing isn't about being perfect.
It's about being strategic!
What's been your biggest publishing challenge?
1/6Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The other reviews told us the study should not be replicated. Literally. Also with quotes from the reviews.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/reviewing-natures-reviews-pa…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
So, yes, one should do scientifically rigorous research on important topics. We did. And they still came up with "reasons" to reject it. So in addition to whatever good scientific standards they do hold papers to, there is also a fair share of nonsense, especially, politicized nonsense.
The End. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. Link in reply. "I have some hope that if you keep hammering away at the truth as revealed by the strongest evidence, it will change minds. But I wouldn’t bet my life on it."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/focus-like-a-laser-on-merit
"Almost anything in social science should be treated skeptically – with few exceptions. Only when findings survive, despite having been treated skeptically over a long time, do they become credible." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Hitchslap
@Hitchslap1
I made this post 12 months ago to the day. It was my first viral post.
Much has changed, but people still don’t understand statistical averages. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Help finding a paper requested. From (imperfect) memory, the paper was some meta-analysis of discrimination in some criminal justice context. They found some but not a lot (I think). BUT, on X, the author directed us to the Supplement, which also found that publication biases favored studies finding discrim over those that did not. I think I have that close to right. If you know the paper, please fling it, or the X post, here. Thanks.
@CJFerguson1111 @ashleytrubin @JohnHolbein1 @SkepResCenter -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
And...
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Lol.
If you ask MTurk respondents whether they are a bot, 37% say yes. (Obviously, some humans could lie and say they are bots.) -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
John posts another good one (having nothing to do with me, which I mention because my last retweet of him did).
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
“These findings provide clear evidence that data collected on MTurk simply cannot be trusted.”
Researchers have long argued about whether Amazon Mechanical Turk (MTurk) survey data can be trusted.
This paper takes a simple approach to evaluating the quality of data currently produced by MTurk.
The author gives respondents pairs of questions that are obviously contradictory.
For example:
"I talk a lot" and "I rarely talk."
Or:
"I like order" and "I crave chaos."
If people are paying attention, agreeing with one should mean disagreeing with the other. At minimum, the two answers shouldn’t move together.
The same exact survey is fielded on three platforms: Prolific, CloudResearch Connect, and MTurk.
On Prolific and Connect, things behave normally: most contradictory items are negatively correlated, just as common sense predicts.
On MTurk, however, the results are the opposite.
Over 96% of these clearly opposite item pairs are positively correlated. In other words, many respondents give similar answers to statements that literally contradict each other.
The authors then try what most researchers would do next:
-restrict the sample to "high-reputation" MTurk workers
-apply standard attention checks
-drop fast responders and straight-liners
None of it fixes the problem. Even after aggressive screening, many contradictory items remain positively correlated on MTurk.
The implication is severe: careless responding on MTurk isn’t rare noise; it’s systematic enough to flip the sign of relationships and generate results that are the opposite of what they really are.
Wow; this is damning. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
John both compliments (thank you!) and aptly describes my recent paper reconciling studies finding large vs. very small amounts of racial "discrimination." In scare quotes because (as I show) "discrimination" is not a single thing; it refers to (potentially) several different things.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Some people argue that discrimination is rampant in our society.
Others argue that few people discriminate.
Who is right?
This article by Lee Jussim takes on this question.
(I found this article to be a fascinating read. It was a little mind-bendy at first, but then it became very intuitive.)
Jussim flags what he calls the "discrimination paradox."
The apparent paradox is that some high-quality audit studies find large disparities (e.g., in callbacks) against minority applicants, while other equally rigorous studies—lab experiments, field studies of everyday interactions, and platform-based choices—find very few discriminatory acts.
The key point is arithmetic, not a paradox. Outcome gaps in audit studies don’t map cleanly onto the number of discriminatory actors. This is especially true when base rates are low. When positive outcomes are rare (e.g., job callbacks), even a small number of biased decisions can generate large relative disparities in outcomes.
By contrast, many non-audit studies focus directly on individual decisions or acts (e.g. responses in games) and therefore estimate how often discrimination actually occurs at the decision level. Those studies often find discrimination happens infrequently, even though it is systematic.
This helps reconcile findings that otherwise look contradictory: large disparities in outcomes can coexist with discrimination occurring rarely at the level of individual decisions.
So who’s right: those who say discrimination is rare, or those who say only a few people discriminate?
According to this paper, both are. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The point that activist faculty chill classroom speech is, perhaps, obvious to almost anyone paying attention except a hardcore lefty. What is surprising -- and a welcome development -- is that the Pres. of Harvard has publicly acknowledged it.
Now, just imagine if Claudine Gay had stayed in the position... 1/2
The Harvard Crimson
@thecrimson
NEW: Harvard President Alan Garber said the University “went wrong” by allowing faculty activism in the classroom, arguing professors’ political views have chilled free speech and debate on campus.
@EliseSpenner and @HugoChiassonn report.
www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/1/3/garber-faculty-activi…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
FWIW, my lab had some role in inspiring the House committee hearings that ultimately resulted in Gay's ouster. More on that here:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/we-brought-down-the-house -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Contra widespread claims, massive international meta-analysis finds no overall link (effect almost exactly 0) between economic inequality and well being.
Bonus: It did find publication biases. Findings of a negative association of econ inequality with mental health are more likely to be based on small N studies.
nature
@Nature
A meta-analysis of 168 studies covering more than 11 million people found no reliable link between economic inequality and well-being or mental health.
go.nature.com/49h47R4 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Two quote-tweet thread, old style:
Shot
Dr. Ashley T. Rubin
@ashleytrubin
It's interesting that there is such a strong tendency to assume that if you criticize X, you were already a skeptic of X. Part of that is bc many such critics do come from a priori skeptics. But we're losing the art of criticizing something you believe in bc you want it to do better. In the 1970s, there were so many disappointed liberal professors who criticized progressive reforms precisely bc they wanted the goals behind these reforms to succeed and wanted to get the flaws out of the reforms. Now it seems like there's a general sense that you're not allowed to criticize your side/team/favored policy. If you're a lefty, you can't criticize something from the left without getting called a nazi or a whateverphobe. (Maybe there's a parallel trend on the right, but I don't have enough data there.) And this also bleeds into the "you can't make that argument, it will help [the enemy]" argument, too. So if you do make that argument, you must have chosen to help "the enemy." We're really fucked when we can't tell the truth.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Chaser
Lisa Selin Davis
@LisaSelinDavis
Why has @nytopinion been so unwilling to publish dissenting liberals on gender issues? Pamela Paul explained that it "discomfited and troubled Opinion leadership" when liberals "deviated from what they understood to be acceptable positions on the left."
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Go here first. Then see my replies. This statement is simultaneously literally true and emblematic of much of what is wrong with academia.
David Austin Walsh
@DavidAstinWalsh
Turns out there really is a meaningful difference between social opprobrium and actual state censorship! Who'd have thunk it?
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Yes. W/Link to Lukianoff post below, which is excellent.
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
Good from Greg Lukianoff in the Dispatch on how the admin’s interventions in higher ed are destructive but were utterly foreseeable, and the situation is unlikely to improve until higher ed recognizes it has an internal problem it commits to addressing.
thedispatch.com/article/campus-free-speech-threats-left-r… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"the First Amendment does not distinguish between citizens and noncitizens."
District Court rules Rubio/Trump administration cannot detain or deport immigrants on visas, or revoke their visas, because it defines their speech as opposing American interests or foreign policy. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. My first retrospective. Link in reply. Top 5 posts of the year, top 10 of all time, SOIBS, revisiting The Attack of the Racist Mule, and much more.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Its been a good run so far."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/unsafe-science-retrospective -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Coleman lamp style street light. Richmond, Va.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Had bronchitis. Slept on couch for head elevation. That's me under the white quilt. 3am. Woke up with company.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Free Black Thought
@FreeBlckThought
TOMORROW in the Journal of FBT @docgotham discusses @PsychRabble's latest paper, "The Discrimination Paradox."
Subscribe so you don't miss it! (Link in next tweet) -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Guest Post, by sociologist Joshua Murray. Link in reply.
"These orientations rest on a deeper and largely unexamined assumption about human nature: the blank slate view."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"This view treats human beings as born without meaningful innate differences and assumes that the default state of humanity is sameness and full malleability. Once this assumption is in place, differences in behavior or outcomes—whether between individuals or groups—are interpreted as unnatural products of social structure rather than as the result of mixed causal processes involving biology, psychology, culture, institutions, and environment."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/sociologys-pervasively-dubio… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Theory and Society (Springer Nature)
@Theory_Society
Compelling and careful assessment of @PsychRabble's latest in Theory and Society, from the great social psychologist and theorist @docgotham
Dave Gilbert
@docgotham
When Inequality Becomes an Explanation: A Problem with “Systemic Racism”
While I am not someone who follows these debates closely in this literature, Lee Jussim (@PsychRabble) a Distinguished Professor of Psychology at Rutgers University whose work focuses on stereotypes, prejudice, and research methods in the social sciences, has a new paper in Theory and Society that struck me as one of the most important and clarifying contributions to debates about race, inequality, and discrimination in years.
The paper’s central contribution is to resolve what Jussim calls the Discrimination Paradox—the apparent conflict between studies finding large disparities and studies finding low rates of discriminatory acts. What most interests me here, however, is how Jussim uses that resolution to mount a sustained critique of how claims about “systemic racism” are often defined and operationalized in the academic literature. If systemic racism is meant to refer to institutional policies or practices, then those systems must be clearly identified and shown—independently—to cause unequal outcomes. Pointing to inequality and labeling it “systemic racism” without specifying the mechanism is not explanation; it’s a tautology. As Jussim puts the logic that often appears, implicitly or explicitly:
“Why is there a racial gap? Because of systemic racism.
How do you know there is systemic racism? Because there is a racial gap.”
Jussim reviews several influential examples from the literature to show how this slippage occurs, including work by Banaji et al. and by Bonilla-Silva. Some accounts define systemic racism as inequalities said to be intrinsic to “societal structures,” but then offer no concrete description of which structures are racist or how they causally operate. Others treat the mere existence of racial gaps as evidence of systemic racism, collapsing explanation into restatement (the circular logic Jussim captures directly in the formulation quoted above). Still others re-label individual-level phenomena—such as prejudice, bias, or ideology—as “systems,” even though systems, strictly speaking, consist of rules, policies, incentives, or institutional practices. Jussim is explicit on this point: individuals have attitudes and biases; systems have rules and incentives. Conflating the two treats personal psychology as institutional structure and collapses an important analytic distinction.
Part of why this move is so common, Jussim argues, has to do with what he calls the Discrimination Paradox. Well-designed studies often find that acts of discrimination are relatively rare, while outcomes and experiences of discrimination can nonetheless be large. There is no contradiction here: in competitive settings like hiring or admissions, even a small number of biased decisions can have outsized downstream effects.
Jussim illustrates this with a stark example. Imagine 500 black and 500 white applicants competing for just four jobs. With no discrimination, two jobs would go to each group. But a single discriminatory decision would mean three white applicants and only one black applicant are hired. As Jussim notes, white applicants would then be 200% more likely to receive a job offer (three versus one), even though discrimination occurred in only one out of 1,000 decisions (or one out of 500 if you focus only on black applicants). In highly competitive selection processes, minimal discrimination can therefore generate very large disparities.
Crucially, this dynamic does not, by itself, establish the existence of a discriminatory system—only that rare instances of discrimination can matter a great deal.
Finally, the paper asks a practical question: what actually reduces discrimination? Jussim reports that decades of research show weak and inconsistent effects from implicit bias training and DEI programs, in part because discriminatory acts may already be rare—leaving little room for such interventions to work.
Jussim suggests that the most promising approach, supported by a broad literature, is far less fashionable but more effective: designing decisions so that evaluators must attend to specific, job-relevant information about individuals—their qualifications, experience, performance, and demonstrated skills—rather than relying on group-level categories or proxies. When decision-makers are given concrete, relevant information and are required to base judgments on it, discrimination drops sharply, sometimes to zero.
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-025-09652-0?f -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Damn, this is a better summary of my recent paper in Theory & Society than I could have produced. Could be titled, "On the Vacuousness of Many Claims of 'Systemic Racism.'"
Dave Gilbert
@docgotham
When Inequality Becomes an Explanation: A Problem with “Systemic Racism”
While I am not someone who follows these debates closely in this literature, Lee Jussim (@PsychRabble) a Distinguished Professor of Psychology at Rutgers University whose work focuses on stereotypes, prejudice, and research methods in the social sciences, has a new paper in Theory and Society that struck me as one of the most important and clarifying contributions to debates about race, inequality, and discrimination in years.
The paper’s central contribution is to resolve what Jussim calls the Discrimination Paradox—the apparent conflict between studies finding large disparities and studies finding low rates of discriminatory acts. The aspect of the paper that most interests me here, however, is his sustained critique of how claims about “systemic racism” are often made in contemporary research and public discourse.
Within that broader argument, Jussim also offers a sharp and detailed critique of how the term “systemic racism” is often defined and operationalized in the academic literature—which is the aspect of the paper I want to focus on here. If systemic racism is meant to refer to institutional policies or practices, then those systems must be clearly identified and shown—independently—to cause unequal outcomes. Pointing to inequality and labeling it “systemic racism” without specifying the mechanism is not explanation; it’s a tautology. As Jussim puts the logic that often appears, implicitly or explicitly:
“Why is there a racial gap? Because of systemic racism.
How do you know there is systemic racism? Because there is a racial gap.”
Jussim reviews several influential examples from the literature to show how this slippage occurs, including work by Banaji et al. and by Bonilla-Silva. Some accounts define systemic racism as inequalities said to be intrinsic to “societal structures,” but then offer no concrete description of which structures are racist or how they causally operate. Others treat the mere existence of racial gaps as evidence of systemic racism, collapsing explanation into restatement (the circular logic Jussim captures directly in the formulation quoted above). Still others re-label individual-level phenomena—such as prejudice, bias, or ideology—as “systems,” even though systems, strictly speaking, consist of rules, policies, incentives, or institutional practices. Jussim is explicit on this point: individuals have attitudes and biases; systems have rules and incentives. Conflating the two treats personal psychology as institutional structure and collapses an important analytic distinction.
One reason this confusion persists is what Jussim calls the Discrimination Paradox. Well-designed studies often find that acts of discrimination are relatively rare, while outcomes and experiences of discrimination can nonetheless be large. There is no contradiction here: in competitive settings like hiring or admissions, even a small number of biased decisions can have outsized downstream effects.
Jussim illustrates this with a stark example. Imagine 500 black and 500 white applicants competing for just four jobs. With no discrimination, two jobs would go to each group. But a single discriminatory decision would mean three white applicants and only one black applicant are hired. As Jussim notes, white applicants would then be 200% more likely to receive a job offer (three versus one), even though discrimination occurred in only one out of 1,000 decisions (or one out of 500 if you focus only on black applicants). In highly competitive selection processes, minimal discrimination can therefore generate very large disparities.
Crucially, this dynamic does not, by itself, establish the existence of a discriminatory system—only that rare instances of discrimination can matter a great deal.
Finally, the paper asks a practical question: what actually reduces discrimination? Jussim reports that decades of research show weak and inconsistent effects from implicit bias training and DEI programs, in part because discriminatory acts may already be rare—leaving little room for such interventions to work.
Jussim suggests that the most promising approach, supported by a broad literature, is far less fashionable but more effective: designing decisions so that evaluators must attend to specific, job-relevant information about individuals—their qualifications, experience, performance, and demonstrated skills—rather than relying on group-level categories or proxies. When decision-makers are given concrete, relevant information and are required to base judgments on it, discrimination drops sharply, sometimes to zero.
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-025-09652-0?f -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
No need to "ignore" anything. The general point, that most stereotypes that have been tested for accuracy have been found to be at least moderately accurate is not mutually exclusive with the fact that some are inaccurate. Interestingly, its the demographic stereotypes that most (usually tho not exclusively) lefties&academics scream about that have been found to be most accurate. 1/4.
Elephant_Frog
@elephant_ben
As long as you ignore that national stereotypes clearly aren't accurate, sure.
Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Other demographic stereotypes:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Two good reviews, covering the general evidence of stereotype accuracy, and exceptions. 2nd is a book chapter, can be found here:
In T. Nelson (ed.), Handbook of prejudice, stereotyping, and discrimination (2nd ed), pp. 31-63. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Dr. Ashley T. Rubin
@ashleytrubin
I like this piece, but especially for its relating the American can-do spirit. I've long felt the giving-up attitude is distinctly un-American. As someone with a negativity bias (both in personality and as an academic), it's something I have to fight, too. unsafescience.substack.com/p/is-internal-reform-of-academ…
Dr. Ashley T. Rubin
@ashleytrubin
American disaster movies are like: we’re going to nuke the asteroid and save the planet. European disaster movies are like: we’re going to try to save whom we can, but that shit’s happening.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Court of Appeals vindicates Reges. UofWashington required not just a land acknowledgement, but their type of land acknowledgement. Then retaliated when Reges mocked it. Court: "We hold that the university’s actions toward the professor violated his First Amendment rights." "www.thefire.org/news/victory-court-vindicates-professor-i…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Highest praise I think I have ever received from any editor in whose journal I have published something. This is on The Discrimination Paradox. Link below.
Theory and Society (Springer Nature)
@Theory_Society
@PsychRabble's point about how relatively few acts of discrimination can produce a substantial experience of discrimination is both subtle and profound.
This is one of the most creative pieces we've had recently in @Theory_Society, and we've had many. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
House Committee on Education and the Workforce* is now investigating the American Psychological Association for antisemitism.
www.newenglishreview.org/breaking-news-the-american-psych…
w/links to the HCEW letter & the complaint by Psychologists Against Antisemitism.
* The same committee that brought down Claudine Gay & Liz Magill. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This type of finding is the only time I regret that all those left/far left academics fled to #bluestasi. I'd love to point this out to them, but I am not signing up for a #bluestasi account to do it.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
That conservative men have a more accurate understanding of the pattern of sex biases than do either liberals in general, or even academic faculty, or even academic faculty with "expertise" in gender is, both striking and damning (of academia). Its relevance to who is more "anti-science" is also ... interesting.
THE END. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply.
"this post is about self-inflicted obstacles to reform. It is about the denialism that there even is a deep problem. It is about attempts to deflect attention from addressing the problems. It is about the handwringing, pearl-clutching timidity among some of those who, with one hand, claim to want reform, and, with the other, are constantly explaining why it can’t be done" -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
🧵 1. National Survey on beliefs about sex bias in hiring finds (in politics x sex analysis) that conservative men are only group where a majority acknowledges/realizes* there is more bias against men. 2. Why its striking that large minority of libs see more bias against men; and
* 3. "acknowledges/realizes" because recent studies (linked below) find there really is more bias against men.
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
Yes, this is a good point.
Our data do indicate that 4 in every 10 moderate men, and 4 in every 10 liberal men, believe that men face more hiring discrimination than women in today's society. An astounding finding.Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Those citation biases are consistent with a forecasting survey in the meta-analysis (tweeted up in 🧵). Faculty, including those who had published on gender, were asked to predict the results of the meta-analysis, and they consistently predicted strong biases against women (even though the main finding was biases against men). So, you can't count on the "experts" to know what they are talking about, even in their own area of expertise. Equalitarian biases ride again!
unsafescience.substack.com/p/no-evidence-for-workplace-se…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
That conservative men have a more accurate understanding of the pattern of sex biases than do either liberals in general, or even academic faculty, or even academic faculty with "expertise" in gender is, both striking and damning (of academia). Its relevance to who is more "anti-science" is also ... interesting.
THE END. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply.
"this post is about self-inflicted obstacles to reform. It is about the denialism that there even is a deep problem. It is about attempts to deflect attention from addressing the problems. It is about the handwringing, pearl-clutching timidity among some of those who, with one hand, claim to want reform, and, with the other, are constantly explaining why it can’t be done"
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/is-internal-reform-of-academ…
"Trump’s real or imagined failures are completely irrelevant to addressing the very real, and now massive and multi-pronged, problem of left-wing political corruption within academia. No one in their right minds would declare “well cancer is really terrible so now is not the time to address heart disease.” -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Terrific social psych paper ( how often do you hear that from me?). Adversarial collab on how much measures of "implicit bias" predict racial discrim.
tl;dr:
N>2000
1. Pro-Black discrimination>pro-White discrimination
2. Implicit measures predicted discrim (std reg coeff=.16) a hair above their agreed-upon threshold for considering the effect trivial (.15), controlling for explicit prejudice.
3. Explicit prej powerfully predicted discrim.
Authors include @jordanaxt, @ImHardcory, @PTetlock, @tomstello
www.researchgate.net/publication/397629391_On_the_relatio…
ht @robsica -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Sample is national. Still, if this generalizes to academia (and why wouldn't it), its implications for the depoliticization of academia are ... grim.
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
~ 1 in 3 Americans identifying as "very liberal" have severed ties with friends AND family over politics.
"Very liberals" cut ties with both friends and family at twice the rate of "liberals" and "very conservatives."
"Very liberals" cut ties with both friends and family at about four times the rate of "moderates" and "conservatives."
(see graph below)
These data come from the American Political Perspectives Survey (APPS) collected from August 3, 2025, to September 26, 2025, with 3,000 American adults who speak English. All respondents needed to pass (1) attention checks, (2) a duplication check, (3) time-to-completion checks, (4) fraud and (5) bot-identification checks. For more information, see: research.skeptic.com/american-political-perspectives-survey/ -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Special Issue of Journal of Controversial Ideas on Censorship in the Sciences.
journalofcontroversialideas.org/volumes_issues/5/2
Edited by Margaret Crable, Anna Krylov. Jay Tanzman and ... me! Articles address:
Academic cancel culture!
What to do about academic cancel culture!
IRB's eroding free inquiry & violating academic freedom.
Cenorship in gender medicine.
Increasing % of women in academia (probably) explains rise of cancel culture!
And more! -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Nice thread summarizing a recent, complex paper finding that majoring in humanities/social science shifts students left; econ and business, to the right. I'll add this tho: the faculty making up most econ&business schools skew left (but less extremely than most other fields). So the econ/bus effect likely results from what they actually learn as opposed to indoctrination (e.g., tradeoffs, cost/benefit analysis, risk assessment, opportunity costs, benefits of free markets, how incentives matters, etc.)
Yoav Goldstein
@GoldsteinYoav
Excited to share my JMP!
Do academic fields of study causally influence students' political preferences? Through what mechanisms? And what are the broader civic implications?
👇 #econjobmarket #econtwitter
Joint with @matankoler (PhD @HebrewU, now postdoc @MITEcon) -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Special issue of Frontiers in Social Psychology on Global Threats to Democracy.
www.frontiersin.org/journals/social-psychology/articles/1…
1 of the editors, Shannon Houck, is at Naval Grad School. W/articles on (among other things) politicization of science funding by Biden admin (by the great Anna Krylov et al), increasing resilience to authoritarianism (by Houck), understanding why ppl support authoritarianism, and two by my team (1 on Chinese manipulation of TikTok; 1 on how U funding by authoritarian & Islamic regimes predicts erosion of speech/academic freedom & campus antisemitism). -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
When Canadians are informed that some of their U's blatantly discriminate in hiring (e.g., reserving positions for minorities, which is legal there), support for diversity policies plummet. Links below.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Another one bites the dust.
Misha Teplitskiy | Science of Science
@MishaTeplitskiy
The "Paradox of Choice" is a very popular, counterintuitive, and interesting idea -- giving people more options has adverse effects, like fewer purchases.
Meta-analysis finds:
- Effect size of ~0
- Publication bias in favor of studies showing adverse effects -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Must read stuff by @danwilliamsphil. On why social media has mostly benefitted rightwing populists and the failure of liberal elites to engage with opposing views.
"Elite gatekeeping doesn’t just filter out the most egregious forms of misinformation. It also typically filters out legitimate grievances and reasonable challenges to establishment orthodoxies."
Rob Sica
@robsica
"It’s a comforting story. So is the popular belief that large segments of the public are so deplorable and irredeemable that they’re unreachable by rational persuasion." www.conspicuouscognition.com/p/lets-not-bring-back-the-ga…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New guest post by @evohopp, who, years ago, did a great twitter thread on my 2012 book, now scaled up into an Unsafe Science essay. Link in reply.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New guest post by @evohopp, who, years ago, did a great twitter thread on my 2012 book, now scaled up into an Unsafe Science essay. Link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Jussim, conversely, argues we are ‘high wattage’. Studies showing how we suffer from (real) biases, also show how accurate we are – treating people as individuals (using stereotypes sparingly to increase accuracy). ‘People are not perfect, but they are pretty damn good.’"
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
You know where Chesapeake Bay got its name? From the Chesapeake Indians. No European ever met one because the Powhatans exterminated them b4 the Europeans arrived.
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
Happy Thanksgiving! We all have an incredible amount to be thankful for.
One of the things we're thankful for is the capacity of human beings to think critically and discard false beliefs in favor of accurate ones.
So, in that spirit...
Nearly 80% of Black Americans and around 2/3s of Hispanic Americans incorrectly believe that "Prior to the arrival of the European Settlers, Native American/Indigenous tribes lived in peace and harmony."
Nearly 1 in 3 Americans identifying as "very liberal," along with around 1 in 3 GenZ and Millennial Americans, incorrectly believe that "People around the world would be living in peace and harmony if it weren't for European colonization."
(See charts below)
In reality, Europeans didn't destroy the world and we all live today in the most peaceful and abundant era of our species' history! -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Excellent essay (linked in quoted tw). "The collapse of Americans' math and reading skills is a national emergency."
Is it also a threat to national security (this is not in the article, but shortage of mechanically, industrially, and technologically skilled workers is a problem for defense industry)?
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
"Watering down K-12 quality while watering down college selectivity isn’t just bad for America — it’s self-defeating. It will hurt exactly the students it’s supposed to help, while weakening and defunding the progressive colleges that embrace it."
www.noahpinion.blog/p/bad-education-is-a-terrible-way-to -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Not only is this true, it helps refute one of the dumbest attempts to debunk stereotype accuracy. Dumb response: "Well the problem with stereotypes is not that they are inaccurate, its that they lead people to misjudge others." They do, but not every often or typically very strongly. Instead, people mostly judge individuals on their merits. Link & another dumb "refutation" in reply.
Truth Zaddy
@Truth_Zaddy
Research by Jussim @PsychRabble and others supports this. People judge individuals as individuals 95% of the time.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Dumb "refutation" of stereotype accuracy II: "Stereotypes cannot possibly be inaccurate because they do not apply to every individual in a group." This is dumb for two reasons: 1. stereotypes are generalizations. Generalizations almost never apply to every instance and are still valid as generalizations (e.g., people are correct to believe apples are generally red even if they know the color of granny smiths). 2. hardly anyone believes "all" of any group fits a stereotype they hold. For more sources of articles on stereotype accuracy:
sites.rutgers.edu/lee-jussim/selectpublications/ -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
"The AAUP ... [was] once was a principled organization advocating and articulating principles of academic freedom, and the justifications for it. It has become a vehicle for progressive activism...[over a 100 years ago] it warned that academic freedom could be jeopardized if it was used for blunt political partisanship." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Amazing (albeit fairly technical) paper finds LLM's become stupid and manifest narcissism & psychopathy when fed a diet of popular tweets.
link in reply
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
"The AAUP ... [was] once was a principled organization advocating and articulating principles of academic freedom, and the justifications for it. It has become a vehicle for progressive activism...[over a 100 years ago] it warned that academic freedom could be jeopardized if it was used for blunt political partisanship."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Former Harvard Pres, Derek Bok: "universities are not very good at passing collective judgments on political issues in the outside world … When political issues are at stake … discussions quickly become partisan, demogogic, and filled with inaccuracies and exaggerations."
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Public confession of an eminent Harvard historian, in response to this question: You said something changed for the worse at colleges, at least elite ones, beginning around 2014. The Harvard campus, you said, “became incredibly prosecutorial,” prone to episodes of “public shaming.” “Students started showing up, determined that their job in a classroom was to humiliate one another and possibly catch a professor in saying something that was a violation of what they believed to be a way you can speak, or a thing you can say about something.” How did you experience that shift?
Carole Hooven
@hoovlet
"I look back on that time with considerable shame at my unwillingness to really speak out...Yet I did nothing...If I’d been drummed out, it would have been more miserable, but then I would have been able to leave." Yes, being drummed out is more miserable. www.chronicle.com/article/why-jill-lepore-nearly-quit-har…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
We tried to warn you. ht @matthewgburgess
Matthew Zeitlin
@MattZeitlin
the ucsd story was way worse than what i gleaned from the tweets, a whole public education pathway appears to have broken down because it's optimized around not having the appearance of inequity instead of teaching people things
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
1. Exactly.
2. There is a whole cottage industry of papers claiming that "denial" of biases against women is itself sexist. But if most of the evidence fails to find biases against women in hiring what is the nonsexist conclusion?
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
"Academics and journalists shine a spotlight on studies that appear to show bias against women, while downplaying - or simply ignoring - studies that don’t. The result is a distorted view of what the science actually shows."
[Link below.] -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Postdoc to study the psych of antisemitism with some pretty accomplished folks (who have not been caught up in the replication crisis). But the hanging q is: Where in academia can you get a job if your main focus is on antisemitism?
Daniel Sznycer
@dsznycer
Postdoc to study the Psychology of Antisemitism, with the great @michael_barlev and Steve Neuberg apply.interfolio.com/177756.
Apply by 12/17/2025 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Interesting thread. Apparently, I am more vocal about, rather than actually deviant in, my skeptical takes on psychology. (I also agree with the perception that things are slowly improving).
Spencer Greenberg 🔍
@SpencrGreenberg
At Transparent Replications, we ran a survey of 210 academic psychologists to understand what they believe about the reliability of their own field, and our results are remarkable. For instance, we asked them to what extent they trust papers in top psychology journals:
🧵 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"A landmark study that claimed men enjoy an unfair advantage in scientific careers has been seriously challenged: a nearly identical rerun of the experiment has found that the opposite is true."
Nice Times (UK, link to it, and primary sources in replies) story on our recent paper reversing (not merely "failing to replicate") a famous, massively cited, highly influential small N study finding biases against women in academic science hiring (we found biases against men).Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I have several Substack essays on this entire event.
1. Summary of our reversal:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/reversal-science-facultys-su…
2. A whole section devoted to the ridiculous reviews at Nature and to the broader evidence of biases against men but academic biases favoring research finding biases against women:
unsafescience.substack.com/s/sexism-in-science
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In Times article is this quote from VP of Nature journals:
“Decisions by our editors to accept or reject replication studies are based solely on whether the research meets our editorial criteria, including standards for methodological rigour. They are not influenced by whether the original study’s conclusions may or may not be replicated. Our decisions are not driven by a preferred narrative.”
So, given that our methods were nearly identical to the original, how can this be interpreted in any way other than this:
"The proposed replication was rejected because it was not methodologically rigorous, i.e., neither was the original study so no one should ever have given the original the insane credibility that it was given."
Right? Right!!? RIGHT!? -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Indeed. But its not likely to happen by bureaucrats spontaneously seeing the error of the ways. Not in the article, but, afaict, it will take either a strong U admin (Pres, VP Research, etc.) or govt action (HHS could require a more limited IRB & most U's go by HHS rules) or state govts will have to rein them in by law or gubernatorial exercises of authority.
James L. Nuzzo, PhD
@JamesLNuzzo
Many of us have observed over the years the increased power and bureaucracy associated with university Institutional Review Boards (IRBs). In this article, @slsatel, @PsychRabble, and colleagues offer a plan to get IRBs back under control.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Heh, here's hoping even you can see how this is very amusing (both the shot, the first tweet shown here, on its absurd demerits) and, the chaser, its juxtaposition with the second, linked.
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
According to Jason Stanley, if you're "talking about polarization" you're just a fascism enabler. In fact, you're "almost worse than the fascists."
If he hadn't already emptied the term of any substantive content, this should do it. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Heh, here's hoping even you can see how this is very amusing (both the shot, the first tweet shown here, on its absurd demerits) and, the chaser, its juxtaposition with the second, linked.
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
According to Jason Stanley, if you're "talking about polarization" you're just a fascism enabler. In fact, you're "almost worse than the fascists."
If he hadn't already emptied the term of any substantive content, this should do it. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Newest post liked in quoted tweet. On my department's recent decision to publicly endorse academic freedom.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"I do not care whether the motivations for the statement are good or bad and neither should you. The statement is, in my view, excellent on its merits."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/fear-equity-actually-can-mot… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. The story of how my department, RU/Psychology, came to publicly proclaim its support for academic freedom. Link in reply/.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. The story of how my department, RU/Psychology, came to publicly proclaim its support for academic freedom. Link in reply/.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"I do not care whether the motivations for the statement are good or bad and neither should you. The statement is, in my view, excellent on its merits."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/fear-equity-actually-can-mot… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Tennis.
Rob Henderson
@robkhenderson
"between 1965 and 1995, the typical adult gained 6 hours a week in leisure time...they could have used those additional 300 hours a year to learn a new skill...Instead, the typical American funneled almost all of this extra time into watching more TV." www.derekthompson.org/p/why-everything-became-television?…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Totally agree. Nothing wrong with small studies if they are interpreted appropriately, usually meaning as including great uncertainty, NOT establishing some new discovery, and as preliminary requiring confirmation by larger studies conducted by independent teams, preferably via the Registered Report format, to limit publication biases.
Daniël Lakens
@lakens
New 'Preliminary Report' submission format at Science and Medicine in Football. An idea that should be interesting for other journals! Explicitly make space for honestly reported smaller sample-size studies www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/24733938.2025.2580319
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Heard backyard birds, via Merlin app. 7am today. Never even heard of the Junco before this.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Real (not beer commercial) Clydesdale, Hunterdon, NJ
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply. In which accomplished sociologist Arthur Sakamoto, @sakamoto_arthur, sends a letter protesting the rejection of his submitted paper for apparently ideological reasons.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"The limitation of [the article I submitted], from the point of view of your ideological reviewers, is that the empirical results do not provide much support for Critical Race Theory. The rejection ... is more akin to political censorship than scientific review."
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Damn. In 1915! the (then functional) @AAUP actually all-but predicted exactly what has happened:
"If this profession should prove itself unwilling to purge its ranks of the incompetent and the unworthy, or to prevent the freedom which it claims in the name of science from being used as a shelter for inefficiency, for superficiality, or for uncritical and intemperate partisanship, it is certain that the task will be performed by others—by others who lack certain essential qualifications for performing it, and whose action is sure to breed suspicions and recurrent controversies deeply injurious to the internal order and the public standing of universities."
www.aaup.org/NR/rdonlyres/A6520A9D-0A9A-47B3-B550-C006B5B… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The great @BrandonWarmke, doing epistemic violence of the best sort to claims that academia is just fine and is in the process of constructive self-reform. Link in reply.
"Thus ends our brief tour of problems. I haven’t touched on many others. For example:
1 in 3 college students believe that it’s acceptable to use violence to stop a speaker.
ideological skew in the readings that faculty assign.
scholar activist pipeline
reams of fake autoethnographic papers in fake fields
grade inflation
the replication crisis,
plagiarism scandals from university presidents and administrators
cancellation and deplatforming campaigns
the costly and increasingly sprawling administrative bureaucratic apparatus, and the refusal of campus administrators to prevent students from occupying buildings, destroying property, and disrupting the normal operations of campus.
The conclusion is this: universities have violated their social contract. We have not been good stewards of the public trust."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Universities will not persist if they remain partisan political institutions. The 1915 AAUP Statement on Academic Freedom warned us what will happen if we can’t police ourselves and purge our ranks of the incompetent. If we continue to “shelter intemperate partisanship,” the AAUP warned, “it is certain that the task will be performed by others.” If centrists, libertarians, conservatives, and Republicans cannot by and large support what we do, the reform will be done for us."
thefreemanmag.substack.com/p/do-universities-need-radical… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Social science needs more, not less, "epistemically violent" literature reviews. It is an excellent way to reveal how bad so many social claims are.
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
Academics discover new form of violence: the lit review.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
How many feminist academics? Nearly all. How many academics? I suspect most. How many regular humans, assuming they are paying attention and have some minimal understanding of social science and statistics? Probably most on the left and hardly anyone else.
Dr. Ashley T. Rubin
@ashleytrubin
Why is this so hard for some to understand: If I identify as a "feminist economist" or I tell you the goal of my research is to expose women's oppression, how many people would believe my gendered wage disparities analysis evaluating the strength of competing hypotheses (e.g., structural sexism, overt sexism, differential socialization, skills diffs, reproductive rxns)?
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
From the abstract:
"effects operate through academic content and teaching rather than socialization or earnings expectations...the results show that academic fields shape students’ attitudes and that field specialization contributes to political fragmentation."
Paper not yet published; data are nonexperimental, but longitudinal (N>30k); the authors estimated causal effects about as rigorously as possible for a nonexperimental study, including a quasi-experiment for a subset of the data.
Matt Grossmann
@mattgrossmann
Studying social sciences & humanities makes students more left-leaning, controlling for initial views & major preference, driven by cultural views. Implies that if all students majored in business, college–noncollege ideological gap would shrink by 1/3
papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5196889 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
U's are a mess but many of Trump's policies target the wrong fields. Ends w/exclamation pt by quoting the great @matthewgburgess.
Ryan Rogers
@ryanMcRogers
President Trump's war on universities, with @PsychRabble
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Its not even close. And that's based on data from a few years ago, relevant because, for decades with no sign of letup, academia's trajectory has been to keep moving left, so its probably worse now.
Ryan Rogers
@ryanMcRogers
According to @PsychRabble there are more Marxists in academia than there are conservatives:
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Ryan Rogers
@ryanMcRogers
The hatred of conservatives in academia, with @PsychRabble
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I completely believe this. But its so wrong. In general (with exceptions), this is the OPPOSITE of what they should do. I am no self-help guru but I'll be damned if I could not provide clear, actionable recommendations to most of them that are exactly the opposite -- stand up, stand loud, stand clear. Tell the damn world -- most despise the would-be cancelers. (Its not this simple, e.g., early on, duckncover is a good idea, and, even later, to counterattack, one needs to have cultivated and then activate a support network to pull this off well, but, hell, this is X so that will have to do for now).
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
.@TheFIREorg asked 200+ scholars what happens after the spotlight of a cancelation or sanction fades. Answer: Many withdraw from public engagement, adjust their syllabi, even avoid certain topics with students. If those who know their fields best can’t speak freely, real inquiry suffers. @natehoneycutt
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Delightfully orange tree on my front lawn.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Discrimination Paradox: Recent high quality studies find levels of racial discrimination and tiny to (at most) small levels.
The resolution DOES NOT involve concluding "some studies on one side are bad."
In fact, both results are ENTIRELY CONSISTENT with each other, as shown by some 7th grade math, as demonstrated in my recent paper (link in reply).
1/2
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Charles
@JiffjoffI
Reminder that when the replication crisis came for psychology and almost washed away all of its empirical work - the most controversial / offensive work is what withstood the wave with robust results, large sample sizes and effects (intelligence research, stereotype accuracy)
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Apollonic
@the_apollonic
Memory, association, education.
Everything (social) psych needn't lead to shit. Where am I? 💩 What am I? 💩 Who are all these people? 💩. No, let @PsychRabble explain. 💩 by association building is so the 20th.
Dan Hopper
@evohopp
Some highlights from Lee Jussim’s ‘Social Perception and Social Reality.’ A review of the social psychology literature on stereotypes and bias, which reveals how surprisingly GOOD we are at dealing with reality. 1/
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Ryan Rogers
@ryanMcRogers
The citation cartel and the Woozle effect, with @PsychRabble
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Orange Rider on the Storm
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Lone Criminologist
@lonecrim
Brand new at the Journal of Controversial Ideas a review of IRB practice. @PsychRabble and a few other pirates convict them of hyper protectionism, stealing booty from science and make them walk the plank. They offer a more optimal balance of the "Mudd Standard".
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Thus, to invoke “systemic racism” as an explanation, one cannot point merely to evidence that “discrimination exists” or that “inequality exists.” If A explains B, then A and B must be different variables. If systemic racism explains inequality, one cannot refer to evidence of inequality as if it is evidence of racism. Instead...: (1) The particular racist system has to be identified independent of the inequality; and (2) One must provide evidence that the particular system so identified caused inequality."
Just out in Theory & Society, @Theory_Society. Link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Ryan Rogers
@ryanMcRogers
Questioning social science research, with @PsychRabble
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Wow. Just discovered this. Excellent long thread tweet-summarizing my 2012 book. Does a damn good job, too.
Dan Hopper
@evohopp
Some highlights from Lee Jussim’s ‘Social Perception and Social Reality.’ A review of the social psychology literature on stereotypes and bias, which reveals how surprisingly GOOD we are at dealing with reality. 1/
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Neetu Arnold
@neetu_arnold
Must read by @JukkaSavo on left-wing bias corrupting research:
“Political monocultures retard intellectual progress, undermine methodological rigor, and erode public credibility”
“1 in 5 sociology profs identifies as far left — more than quadruple the rate in econ and more than double the rate in poli sci or psych”
“In sociology, fewer than 10% of recent articles in leading journals employ designs that allow for credible causal inference. In econ, it’s more than 70%”
www.chronicle.com/article/left-wing-bias-is-corrupting-so… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
An Academy of Fools
1/2
Soumitra Shukla
@soumitrashukla9
It’d be great to see science journals stick to enforcing rigorous citation standards rather than requiring citation by diktat.
Quality and relevance of ideas should come first and last---everything else in between is noise.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
2/2
Daniël Lakens
@lakens
Nature Psychology Review is a journal created by a commercial publisher because it is easy profit. Review articles are easy to write, get cited a lot. Slap Nature on it and you get a high IF.
It should flip to a diamond open access journal. Submit your review articles elsewhere. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
So far, I've just read the tweet. It's bullseye, at least for any scientific field that addresses politically controversial topics.
Jukka Savolainen
@JukkaSavo
My contribution to the debate:
"Viewpoint diversity is not a political concession. It is a scientific necessity. Academic disciplines ignore this fact at their peril."
@HdxAcademy @PsychRabble @Theory_Society
www.chronicle.com/article/left-wing-bias-is-corrupting-so… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Can anyone find the reforms of academia that AAUP says it is "not opposing" in this post on how its not opposing reforms? Because it sure looks like a polemic directed mostly at FIRE/Lukianoff. But maybe I missed their specific calls for reforms.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
University of Illinois/Chicago adopts policy eliminating race/national origin/sex in considering hiring, scholarships. (I do not see admissions in their full announcement but perhaps it is coming too):
t.e2ma.net/message/s0mlgk/opjwg05d -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
🧵On the consequences of the Rise of Women in Academia. tl;dr: Social justice, heightened harm sensitivity, cancel culture/ostracism. Based on an article in press at Journal of Controversial Ideas.
Cory Clark
@ImHardcory
1. What happens when women, for the first time in history, gain real cultural power? I explore this question in “From Worriers to Warriors: The Cultural Rise of Women,” now in press at @JConIdeas:
www.researchgate.net/publication/396649895_From_Worriers_… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Not written as a response to the lame AAUP chapter pres article on why viewpoint diversity is worthless, but nonetheless, the best response so far. By @jessesmithsoc
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-025-09654-y
"The minimal necessary condition to address progressive ideological imbalance in social science is the active fostering of distinctively conservative perspectives." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"After 50 years of scholarship on microaggressions, none of the main claims about them have been scientifically substantiated."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply. This is a draft of an article about to be submitted for publication (kinda like a prepring). Its short, about the same length as my regular Substack posts.
""Nearly all empirical research framed as addressing “microaggressions” assesses subjective perceptions of microaggression. The problem should be obvious. Realities are not revealed by assessing perceptions." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply. This is a draft of an article about to be submitted for publication (kinda like a prepring). Its short, about the same length as my regular Substack posts.
""Nearly all empirical research framed as addressing “microaggressions” assesses subjective perceptions of microaggression. The problem should be obvious. Realities are not revealed by assessing perceptions." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
For incarceration, Israel/Palestine, and abortion, epic study of millions of syllabi finds "far too many are teaching in ways that look a lot like they’re trying to indoctrinate students..." with left/far left sources assigned 2-20x as frequently as are critiques of those perspectives and alternatives that are of comparable or even superior scholarly quality.
Link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
www.persuasion.community/p/we-analyzed-university-syllabi…
"As soon as it was published, The New Jim Crow (which appears on 4000 syllabi in the database) stirred contention within academia. The most prominent critic was James Forman, Jr., a professor at Yale Law School. In a seminal working paper, Forman challenged Alexander’s thesis...Forman’s work culminated in a book titled Locking Up Our Own, a well-regarded work that won the Pulitzer Prize.
How often is Forman’s book assigned along with Alexander’s? Less than four percent of the time."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Paging @ashleytrubin, @CJFerguson1111, ICYMI, you both might be particularly interested in the Persuasion piece linked above. On the general problem of academic bias:
@ImHardcory, @minzlicht, @yorl, @SteveStuWill, @epkaufm, @BrandonLukeMc, @LGConwayIII, @natehoneycutt, @BorkNathanial -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply. This is a draft of an article about to be submitted for publication (kinda like a prepring). Its short, about the same length as my regular Substack posts.
""Nearly all empirical research framed as addressing “microaggressions” assesses subjective perceptions of microaggression. The problem should be obvious. Realities are not revealed by assessing perceptions."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/research-on-microaggressions…
"Despite 50 years of scholarship on microaggressions, the main claims about them have not been empirically demonstrated. Much is known about subjective self-reported experiences as measured by dubious questionnaires of unknown validity that may or may not assess perceptions of “microaggressions,” and the correlates of these measures. Correlations do not demonstrate “impact.” No studies have attempted to assess whether racism causes the specific behaviors labeled as microaggressions by “experts” and advocates." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
With the claim that "viewpoint diversity is a MAGA plot" the AAUP digs its head deeper in the sand.
The Chronicle of Higher Education
@chronicle
Opinion | Lisa Siraganian and Michael Clune debate viewpoint diversity. chroni.cl/46PJ0W2
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Pirate and War of 1812 hero, Jean Lafitte's bar, New Orleans. Building dates to the 1770s.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Back then they didn't want me. Now I'm hot they all on me."
youtu.be/m1ERvlxgCD8
Karlyn Borysenko, anti-communist cult leader
@DrKarlynB
One of the funny things about suddenly getting so many more views on my work is that people who stopped talking to me years ago are suddenly coming out of the woodwork, pretending like nothing ever happened.
And the great thing about it is that I build my platform completely separately from any of them, which means I don't need their help to keep going.
I've seen the true colors of A LOT of people over the past five years.
I don't forget. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Intersectionality lives! This article is at the intersection of TDS, the Fall of the AAUP (author heads AAUP at Johns Hopkins), intellectual hubris, and paranoia.
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Sigh…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The AAUP is the disaster that keeps on giving.
Dr. Ashley T. Rubin
@ashleytrubin
The AAUP just keeps falling lower and lower.
www.chronicle.com/newsletter/the-review/2025-10-13 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Greg Lukianoff, Sam Abrams, and Adam Goldstein just saved me from having to do a point by point refutation of the incredibly bad arguments made by (shocked I tell you) the President of the AAUP who is on a bit of rampage against viewpoint diversity.
Link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Whoopsie. Not Pres of AAUP. Pres of Johns Hopkins AAUP chapter.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
All the attempts to debunk free will have failed.
Phil Hoyeck
@PAHoyeck
So what's everyone's most controversial philosophy take?
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I learned, from the HotA's pod, that the all-American separation of church & state, codified in the Constitution, has its roots in Roger Williams' philosophy -- which, based entirely on his deeply religious reading of Christian scripture, led him to the conclusion that the State has no business mandating, or interfering in, anyone's religious practices. (Don't tell the AAUP though -- their president is on a rampage against "intellectual diversity.")
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Social psych position at Stetson. IDK the dept there, but Chris, who is very successful and quite public with his endorsement of intellectual pluralism, including lots of scholarship that pushes back hard against woke nonsense masquerading as social science, is there. Which does not mean you are getting the job, but it means it is far less likely that you will run into the type of political discrimination/hostile environment there that you might at many other places.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
1. Exactly.
2. i/o retw's a 1min video of Claire Lehmann explaining Quillette's evolution. Def worth the minute listen. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Derelict would-be hotel (I think it was never completed), somewhere in the vicinity of Woodstock, NY.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
🧵 on two q's:
1. Historically, how "often" was violence necessary to achieve major social change?
2. Are surveys showing disturbing levels of Americans' beliefs in justification for political murder merely the result of bad, leading, or ambiguous questions?
tl;dr, the 🧵answers: 1. "Often" is a squishy term, but there are far more examples of violence NOT being needed than it being needed. 2. No.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Hmmm, co-author of several NCRI reports here. Rather than "designed to reach particular conclusions," I'd argue that, quite the contrary, our questions were specifically designed to avoid most of the traps & known dysfunctions to question creation.
Double barreled? Nope.
Built in acquiescence? Nope.
Leading? Nope.
Vague & easily misinterpreted questions?; Nope.
1/n. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Hmmm, co-author of several NCRI reports here. Rather than "designed to reach particular conclusions," I'd argue that, quite the contrary, our questions were specifically designed to avoid most of the traps & known dysfunctions to question creation.
Double barreled? Nope.
Built in acquiescence? Nope.
Leading? Nope.
Vague & easily misinterpreted questions?; Nope.
1/n. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Just updated, too. With story linked reply.
Bill French
@bullfranx
Guess who’s back. Back again. Oppositional scholar is back, tell a friend.
Also with a thoughtful CODA and reminder about the distinctive social good provided by people and organizations maintaining long-term principled commitments (how I read it anyhow).
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Despite headline, its not really a "landmark" ruling till SCOTUS weighs in. Still, District Court rules deportations for pro-Palestinian speech violates 1A, which covers speech of immigrants on visas, immigrants with green cards, and just about anyone else.
"This case—perhaps the most important ever to fall within the jurisdiction of this district court—squarely presents the issue whether non-citizens lawfully present here in [the] United States actually have the same free speech rights as the rest of us. The Court answers this Constitutional question unequivocally ‘yes, they do.’ ‘No law’ means ‘no law.’ The First Amendment does not draw President Trump’s invidious distinction and it is not to be found in our history or jurisprudence.”
knightcolumbia.org/content/in-landmark-ruling-federal-cou… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Despite headline, its not really a "landmark" ruling till SCOTUS weighs in. Still, District Court rules deportations for pro-Palestinian speech violates 1A, which covers speech of immigrants on visas, immigrants with green cards, and just about anyone else.
"This case—perhaps the most important ever to fall within the jurisdiction of this district court—squarely presents the issue whether non-citizens lawfully present here in [the] United States actually have the same free speech rights as the rest of us. The Court answers this Constitutional question unequivocally ‘yes, they do.’ ‘No law’ means ‘no law.’ The First Amendment does not draw President Trump’s invidious distinction and it is not to be found in our history or jurisprudence.”
knightcolumbia.org/content/in-landmark-ruling-federal-cou… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Felinymmetry
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
"There have more attempts this year by govt officials to sanction scholars than in the prior 25." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
"There have more attempts this year by govt officials to sanction scholars than in the prior 25."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-threat-to-free-speech-an…
"Civil libertarians have long warned that such attacks, by leading to an erosion of social and cultural norms around free speech, would someday come back to bite the very progressives who were disproportionately pushing them 2015-2023."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
With copious quotes from a recent Substack by @Musa_alGharbi
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Heh. See that which GL retweeted.
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
Why do you think this would be a FIRE case? It doesn’t involve the First Amendment other than the fact that a newspaper has a First Amendment right to fire an opinion columnist. And because it’s a newspaper firing a columnist who falsely attributed a quote it’s not even cancel culture.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Comment on an excellent @minzlicht Substack post. Link to full post in reply.
Rob Sica
@robsica
"Bamboozle' is the right term 2 use 4 implicit bias claims, because, even if the advocates were 'earnest' in the unjustified claims they promoted, it is because they leapt 2 conclusions w/o adequate evidence. So, at best, its self-deception." @PsychRabble
www.speakandregret.michaelinzlicht.com/p/53-posts-3000-re…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New FIRE report. Attempts to punish faculty for legit speech by Govt actors at all time high. Link in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
expression.fire.org/p/efforts-to-silence-scholars-hit-record. These are almost all coming from Republican govt officials.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Baseball, like democracy, requires patience. Baseball is a game in which the best teams lose and the worst teams win 1/3 of the time. If you must win every time, you won't like Baseball. Democracy is the same.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Nicholas H Wolfinger
@NickWolfinger
In this post, @PsychRabble overviews several academics, myself included, who survived cancellation attempts and phony investigations.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/academic-survivors-and-thriv… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Still merely micro-viral at 99k views. If it passes 100k, it then becomes mini-viral. Last time I had a tweet this widely read it was during the 2 + 2 can = 5 nonsense, and read something like:
2+2= a ham sandwich.
Proof:
2 slices of bread + 2 slices of ham= ham sandwich.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Huge PRISMA meta-analysis (89 studies, 5million students) finds student course evaluations are worthless to harmful.
- do not predict learning in the course
- predict lower learning in subsequent courses
- charismatic delivery improves student evaluations, leads students to believe they've learned more, but has no effect on actual learning
- use of student evals to evaluate faculty is corrosive to actual education, leading to grade inflation and reduced rigor
www.researchgate.net/publication/395689552_Student_Evalua… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Given that this post has gone micro-viral (36k views), reposting ICYMI.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Huge PRISMA meta-analysis (89 studies, 5million students) finds student course evaluations are worthless to harmful.
- do not predict learning in the course
- predict lower learning in subsequent courses
- charismatic delivery improves student evaluations, leads students to believe they've learned more, but has no effect on actual learning
- use of student evals to evaluate faculty is corrosive to actual education, leading to grade inflation and reduced rigor
www.researchgate.net/publication/395689552_Student_Evalua… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Xcountry skiing some years ago, a snow squall rolled in and everything just disappeared.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
ADHD prof here. As my entire lab and most of my collaborators know, I LOVE to work outside and do it whenever weather permits (45 degrees w/layers to 90 in shade; dry to light drizzle -- see pic for how that works). WAY better than my boring office or study.
Adam Hunt
@RealAdamHunt
A recent Frontiers in Psychology article introduces what they term "Neurocognitive Mismatch Theory," suggesting that environments low in movement, sensory variety, or natural stimuli amplify functional impairment in ADHD and autism. The findings point toward designing settings that diminish mismatch. Interesting.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
More on why Kamala was a terrible candidate for a national election...
Jesse Singal
@jessesingal
I have obtained the short section of Kamala's book where she discusses trans issues and I think I need to be institutionalized
(yes, this is real) -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply.
"quite a few academics have nicely survived these attacks, in some cases thrived, and in a few, gotten ample vengeance. I recount some of those cases here." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Huge PRISMA meta-analysis (89 studies, 5million students) finds student course evaluations are worthless to harmful.
- do not predict learning in the course
- predict lower learning in subsequent courses
- charismatic delivery improves student evaluations, leads students to believe they've learned more, but has no effect on actual learning
- use of student evals to evaluate faculty is corrosive to actual education, leading to grade inflation and reduced rigor
www.researchgate.net/publication/395689552_Student_Evalua… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply.
"quite a few academics have nicely survived these attacks, in some cases thrived, and in a few, gotten ample vengeance. I recount some of those cases here."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"So if there are still any would-be denouncers out there, this is my message to you: Bring it on. Its really working for me."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/academic-survivors-and-thriv… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I love academia. This article is on political dehumanization, key emphasis is on how left&right dehumanize each other differently. Never mentioned: That libs dehumanize cons much more than cons dehumanize libs. I mean, why even mention it?
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11538778/
Key figure: -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Inspired by @HighwayyChild, who posts great pics of the American Southwest, and @meaghan_garvey, whose substack (linked below) covers out of the way places and people, I am going to start posting pics. Mine are not up to Raven's, but some are good enough, so here goes:
Car graveyard, outside Califon, NJ.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Short Americana thread & recommendation:
1. Female trucker drives thru the American Southwest, taking amazing photos. eg:
x.com/HighwayyChild/status/1966549049831747724
Also reposts some great art.
1/2
Raven Jade
@HighwayyChild
Good storm passing through the arid Arizona desert.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Heh...
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Steven Pinker on postmodernism.
More great Pinker quotes in link below. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Short Americana thread & recommendation:
1. Female trucker drives thru the American Southwest, taking amazing photos. eg:
x.com/HighwayyChild/status/1966549049831747724
Also reposts some great art.
1/2
Raven Jade
@HighwayyChild
Good storm passing through the arid Arizona desert.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
2. I discover her via this Substack, Scary Cool Sad Goodbye, devoted to America's out of the way places and people. Really good (if you like that type of thing, and I do).
scarycoolsadgoodbye.substack.com/p/scary-cool-sad-goodbye-75
Can't find the author on X, but if you do, please post here. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
🧵 Which is the "anti-science" party?
Dashun Wang
@dashunwang
🚨 Our latest paper just came out in Science, where we report a simple, historical pattern:
From 1980 to 2020, Republican lawmakers consistently funded science at a higher level than their Democratic counterparts.
four years in the making. Led by @zfurnas
thread 1/n -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
To demonstrate this point, I have "shouted 'FIRE!' in multiple crowded amphitheaters -- both when teaching undergrads and at conferences. Well, they weren't that crowded, I am not that big a draw, but still...
Emma Camp
@emmma_camp_
Here's why you CAN shout fire in a theatre. Maybe the NYT editorial team could take a look?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"There is no hate speech exception to the First Amendment."
Greg Lukianoff
@glukianoff
Why everything Pam Bondi said about ‘hate speech’ is wrong www.thefire.org/news/why-everything-pam-bondi-said-about-… via @TheFIREorg
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Remember when half of academia was screaming about how Trump was destroying science? Most academics are terrible at politics and really should get out of the predictions business.
www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2025/09/15/nih-no… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I am older than you. I collaborate with people who disagree with me. I have a recent pub, one that partially inspired the House Committee hearings that ultimate led to the ousters of Gay (Harvard) and Magill (Penn). On the pub are at least one self-described antifa and at least 2 Trump voters. Pub linked in reply. And I am pretty sure I have pubbed more adversarial collabs (5) than anyone.
Dark Lords | Villains | Sith | Goblincore | Satire
@darklordjournal
I'm so old and out of touch that I'm still friends with people who disagree with me.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Dear MagaMom, that Musk/Trump data is from a report my lab co-authored. You can find the full report here:
networkcontagion.us/reports/4-7-25-ncri-assassination-cul… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Post has gone micro-viral (I'd rate 10k-99k views micro-viral; >=100-200k mini-viral; 200-500k kinda-viral; >=500k viral).
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Classic example of how to import political bias into the very manner in which a survey question is asked. If my lab came up with this question, I'd send them back to the drawing board to rewrite it.
Bonus: What people say "in general" about political violence is often disconnected from their responses to specific cases of justifying political violence.
Phil Williams
@PhilNvestigates
Interesting polling data: Those with unfavorable views of Donald Trump are the LEAST LIKELY to support political violence.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
My categorization system here is highly rigorous & scientific.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Classic example of how to import political bias into the very manner in which a survey question is asked. If my lab came up with this question, I'd send them back to the drawing board to rewrite it.
Bonus: What people say "in general" about political violence is often disconnected from their responses to specific cases of justifying political violence.
Phil Williams
@PhilNvestigates
Interesting polling data: Those with unfavorable views of Donald Trump are the LEAST LIKELY to support political violence.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Article shown below:
1. Self-reports are usually better measures than implicit ones, such as the IAT and AMP.
2. Common claims about the superiority of the IAT to self-reports (less contaminated, unconscious, more automatic, more robust, better at capturing systemic racism) are unjustified (either known to be false, or the evidence is equivocal & contradictory).
3. Self-reports are demonstrably superior in several ways (more reliable, better predictors of behavior, more flexible for research purposes).
I could not find an online PDF, and got the article from one of the authors.
Misha Teplitskiy | Science of Science
@MishaTeplitskiy
Turns out we should've been just asking people this whole time
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
During the moral panic over racism of summer 2020, this academic music society denounced Timothy Jackson's journal for publishing articles critical of a Black music professor who had previously denounced Schenker, hugely influential in the field of music theory, as a racist. Jackson was "investigated" by his U, removed as editor of his journal, and the journal shut down.
Jackson sued his U, and "settled" for $700k and reinstatement of his journal with him as editor.
He also received the academic freedom prize from the Columbia Academic Freedom Council.
If U's are going to "internally reform" this society would apologize to Jackson for their unwise and unjustified attack on him and his journal.
What's the over/under on how many years before such an apology is received? Can we bet on "infinity"?
1/2 Article on Jackson's victory in court linked in reply.
Society for Music Theory
@SMT_musictheory
A statement from the executive board "condemns the anti-Black statements and personal ad hominem attacks on Philip Ewell" in the recent issue of Journal of Schenkerian Studies. This was sent this evening to the SMT-Announce listserv.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
On Jackson's victory in court:
www.ntdaily.com/news/university-music-theory-professor-wi… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Two NCRI reports linked in Brandon's 2-tw thread, providing evidence of disturbingly high levels of endorsement and glorification of political murder. Also, here is a link to a preliminary version of a chapter reporting two studies 1. negative correlation of social media use with support for democracy; 2. positive correlation of social media use with support for political murder.
sydneysymposium.unsw.edu.au/2025/chapters/FinkelsteinSSSP…
Brandon
@BrandonLukeMc
The work of NCRI and @PsychRabble on "assassination culture" is proving highly prescient right now.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
jonspelledwithoutanh
@jonwithno_h
"The next time you hear scientists pontificating about how “science deserves its credibility because, when it gets things wrong, it is self-correcting” remember these reviews from Nature, one of the most prestigious of all “scientific” journals. Replication is the most direct route to scientific self-correction. And they told us we should not do it." @thespybrief
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"However useful it might be to conduct a different study with different outcome variables, that would not be a replication. Translation: “Moss-Racusin et al. (2012) should not be replicated.”
unsafescience.substack.com/p/reviewing-natures-reviews-pa… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Inquisitive Bird
@Scientific_Bird
Lee Jussim and colleagues conducted a pre-registered study attempting to replicate a famous study that alleged sexism among science faculty.
The justifications (read: excuses) from reviewers why this study shouldn't be published are absolutely astounding.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply.
"In this essay, I highlight how three of the reviews (from Nature, in 2019, which rejected it) of our proposal to replicate a famous study all argued that we should not do so, a profoundly antiscientific attitude towards … science." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
John Cochrane
@JohnHCochrane
This is a wonderful essay, worth reading and pondering. The conclusion I come to is that Nature's social science reviewers don't understand what "replication" means. It does not mean extension, it does not mean variation, it means replication.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"However useful it might be to conduct a different study with different outcome variables, that would not be a replication. Translation: “Moss-Racusin et al. (2012) should not be replicated.”
unsafescience.substack.com/p/reviewing-natures-reviews-pa… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Jazi Zilber
@yzilber
Amazing quotes.
Reviewers basically said "we love the original study results. We will use transparently dumb arguments to refuse listening to it's failed replication"
I've watched the replication fights. This beats everything by a country mile.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply.
"In this essay, I highlight how three of the reviews (from Nature, in 2019, which rejected it) of our proposal to replicate a famous study all argued that we should not do so, a profoundly antiscientific attitude towards … science." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply.
"In this essay, I highlight how three of the reviews (from Nature, in 2019, which rejected it) of our proposal to replicate a famous study all argued that we should not do so, a profoundly antiscientific attitude towards … science."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"However useful it might be to conduct a different study with different outcome variables, that would not be a replication. Translation: “Moss-Racusin et al. (2012) should not be replicated.”
unsafescience.substack.com/p/reviewing-natures-reviews-pa… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Another rigorous review finds "growth mindsets" have little or no effect on student achievement (d's<=.065).
""smaller and weaker studies have tended to produce the largest apparent effect sizes."
Link to review in Rolf's 2nd tweet.
Rolf Degen
@DegenRolf
Interventions aimed at instilling a "growth mindset" in schoolchildren fizzle out completely without effect.
The concept of Growth Mindset has gained widespread popularity over the past decade, prompting numerous organisations to offer Growth Mindset interventions. Encouraging the idea of a growth mindset in which students believe that they can improve their ability, as opposed to a fixed mindset, has been suggested as an effective and relatively cheap approach to improving student attainment at school.
This paper offers a comprehensive review of the evidence from growth mindset interventions. The approach adopted in this new study involves a review methodology that emphasises the trustworthiness of findings across a spectrum of studies,
Their findings reveal that the strongest studies, characterised by larger sample sizes, minimal missing data and high data quality, exhibit null or very small effect sizes.. Additionally, certain findings raise concerns about a potential conflict-of-interest bias, suggesting that some negative or null results may remain unpublished.
Given the null impact observed in two of the four most rigorous evaluations, we do not recommend the allocation of substantial resources for implementing public policies aimed at promoting a growth mindset among school-age students. And this is the headline finding of the review. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
Note that the explanation is not "we realized DEI has been a failure, wasted money, sowed division, and we want to reform," but rather "they made us do this." Not the tone of an institution eager to undertake internal reform.
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Emory University is shutting down its DEI office:
“Federal laws and mandates have been implemented that require higher education institutions to alter fundamentally or even close offices and programs focused on DEI. The standards are clear, and we must act accordingly.”
“We will work promptly and carefully to discontinue current DEI offices and programs. We will also work closely with each impacted employee to provide appropriate support and assistance through the transition.” -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The NYTimes drove Weiss out. @darklordjournal nailed this, in his book, "There and Never Back Again: A Dark Lord's Journal":
"I persist in believing this is an error on the part of the Banishers. If, as a culture, you cast people out, you run the risk of those same people realizing they like it better on the outside."
Will Sommer
@willsommer
Paramount is reportedly set to buy Bari Weiss’s Free Press for somewhere in the $100-$200 million range, with Weiss receiving a job guiding editorial direction at CBS News per @DylanByers reporting. puck.news/david-ellison-set-to-acquire-the-free-press/
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Actually, there is some decent evidence out there that the toxoplasmosis parasite can increase risk-taking behavior. I have 5 cats and if they increased my risk-taking, lord knows, it really worked for me.
1/3 Link in Reply. Personal story in 3rd tweet.
"A more recent study shows that toxoplasma infection prevalence was a consistent, positive predictor of entrepreneurial activity. Fear of failure would be less important in infected individuals, who are more willing than others to start their own business."
Chris Williamson
@ChrisWillx
Beware of cats.
Owning a cat is associated with a two-to-threefold greater risk of schizophrenia.
The leading suspect is a parasite known as Toxoplasma gondii, which infests cats and can sometimes infect humans as well.
Parasites like Toxoplasma gondii might also alter human behaviour, boosting sexual risk taking and sexual aggression. — @SteveStuWill
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Review of the evidence. 2/3
www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0181551220…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
On the value of risk taking for me personally:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/my-vita-of-denunciation -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Is it a cat omelet?
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
This should become a legendary image - illegal migrant cooks omelet with the flame from Europe's Tomb of the Unknown Soldier.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Free Black Thought
@FreeBlckThought
We have a crisis of historical illiteracy in this country.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"A Danish study from 2018 found that tennis players lived nearly a decade longer than their sedentary peers—and also longer than swimmers, cyclers, and joggers. No other sport in the analysis was correlated with such a large boost to life expectancy."
www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2025/08/tennis-us-open… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Thomas, Thomas, Thomas... You have not hung around academics long enough. #livedexperience, #againstacademia.
Thomas Chatterton Williams
@thomaschattwill
How can the Bluesky bubble be this airtight?
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Leor has done some of the best work on ideology & extremism. Looking forward to getting this.
Leor Zmigrod
@LeorZmigrod
The Ideological Brain has been chosen by the Financial Times and New Scientist as one of the best summer books of 2025 ☀️
Thank you to all the readers and listeners who have enjoyed it this spring 🌸 and summer 🌻 and now onto the fall 🍁! -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Jason Stanley would beg to differ.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
But but but, U's are self-reforming. Just ask almost any academic.
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
“Universities should see the White House’s campaign as a wake-up call rather than the root of their troubles—a warning that they have to rebuild trust among not just prospective students, parents, and donors, but also voters and elected officials across party lines.”
🧵 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I keep hearing how woke is over and U's are just going to self-reform, some would argue, ARE self-reforming RIGHT NOW. This of course is a journal, not a U. But the editorial board are profs with U jobs.
Self-Reform, Onward!
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Evidence that woke isn't dead, peer review is problematic, and science needs to address deep problems in its culture: A grad student at Harvard conducted the first systematic, data-based study to document & explain the rise in gender dysphoria. His paper was rejected from a leading journal because, among other things, "Throughout the manuscript, the authors use language that is considered prejudicial and outdated (e.g., "natal sex" as opposed to "sex assigned at birth"). It is critical to follow best practice and guidelines surrounding gender inclusive language, particularly for research specifically on the topic of gender incongruence, expression, and identity."
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Justin Mogilski
@justin_mogilski
Our adversarial collaboration is now published.
"Defining diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) by the scientific (de)merits of its programming"
In @Theory_Society
Thank you to my incisive coauthors: @PsychRabble, @awilson_WLU, Bryan Love
🧵below
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-025-09646-y -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
Yes, and unfortunately that significant part of academia will not only not get the message, but will double down on what got us here in the first place.
And things won’t improve on their own because academics spent the last decade hiring activists who will end up with tenure.
Itai Sher
@itaisher
It seems to me that a significant part of academia hasn’t gotten the message that politicization of what we do has harmed our standing with the public and put us in a weak position.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I once convinced my 5 year old daughter that regular milk comes from white cows and chocolate milk comes from brown cows.
Later, different daughter, refused to believe me (because of stuff like above, relentlessly) that there were such things as lion fish, nurse sharks and spider monkeys.
Don't ask me about what we did to substitute teachers in high school... -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In which Brint is interviewed by McCaffrey, but it is McCaffrey who shined here:
"There’s no fundamental incompatibility between the pursuit of accurate knowledge and our very human and understandable desire to improve the world. But there is a fundamental incompatibility between scientific method and dogma, between the pursuit of truth and the intense belief that the truth is already obvious and clear and exigent. I agree with you that most all of social science is today merely the latter and that this is a profound cause for concern. The public increasingly seems to realize and speak more honestly about this problem than the professional academics themselves do, which is a bad sign."
Rob Sica
@robsica
"The right has its finger on a problem, but its solution to the problem is worse than the problem itself." link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-025-09638-y
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Exactly. The System Justification Scale, which is the workhorse measure of "system justification," is shown to be vacuous and bankrupt in the article Brandon retw'd. So, Class, if the workhorse measure is bankrupt, what can we conclude about the theory's evidentiary base?
Brandon
@BrandonLukeMc
One thing I've never gotten about SJT is how researchers know that participants are "justifying the system" (ignoring the huge measurement issue here as per @ValidScience, linked below) for palliative, motivated reasons, rather than just genuinely appraising the system as, in large part, working pretty well or as being generally fair?
If someone endorses something I personally don't like, seems pretty easy to go "oh they just can't face the reality, so they're motivated to believe that for their own sanity". But I haven't seen strong evidence of that from SJT research, at least not that I can remember. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Birds Sequel. They are Really Good This Time.
Science girl
@sciencegirl
A bird that brought all its friends to thank the lady who rescued it
x.com/x_viral_vibes/status/1961309530048086024/video/1 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
System justification found to be a bankrupt measure. My conclusion, not the authors.
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/pops.13039
Next tweet explains why.
1/2
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The political findings reveal that system justification is really not "justification" in any real sense (rationalization, dissonance reduction, psychological conflict resolution) and simply show that people support systems when their party/ideological group is in power. Duh.
The SES results just show people like systems in which they do well. Duh.
SJ, as actually measured, is a vacuous construct.
Whether any sort of "justification" is going on is not ruled out by the findings, but they do mean the measure is bankrupt.
Not saying its a bad paper, its a good paper. But part of its goodness is revealing the bankruptcy of the measure.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Paging @BrandonWarmke @BrandonLukeMc @LGConwayIII @SteveStuWill (perfect blog fodder for you Steve, ping me if you do it), @ImHardcory @BillvonHippel, @BorkNathanial, @natehoneycutt
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The political findings reveal that system justification is really not "justification" in any real sense (rationalization, dissonance reduction, psychological conflict resolution) and simply show that people support systems when their party/ideological group is in power. Duh.
The SES results just show people like systems in which they do well. Duh.
SJ, as actually measured, is a vacuous construct.
Whether any sort of "justification" is going on is not ruled out by the findings, but they do mean the measure is bankrupt.
Not saying its a bad paper, its a good paper. But part of its goodness is revealing the bankruptcy of the measure. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Call for papers on Free Speech and Academic Freedom. Journal name is unusual but its bona fide. From the journal page:
"Cosmos + Taxis is run under the auspices of the Department of Philosophy, Political Science, and Economics, The University of British Columbia Okanagan...Cosmos + Taxis offers a forum to those concerned that the central presuppositions of the liberal tradition have been severely corroded, neglected, or misappropriated by overly rationalistic and constructivist approaches." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In honor of the recognition of those who stayed here that #bluestasi is cesspool, I am re-upping The Orwelexicon (link in reply), a sort of Modern Devil's Dictionary (the 19th century sardonic reference source by Ambrose Bierce), where you will find entries like this:
CYNIC, n. A blackguard whose faulty vision sees things as they are, not as they ought to be.
In The Orwelexicon, you will find illustrated entries like this:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Orwelexicon:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-new-expanded-illustrated… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Theory and Society call for papers (that will likely reveal the elite status of all those "egalitarian" sociologists).
I love when social science turns its methods and findings on itself. Should happen more often.
Arthur Sakamoto
@sakamoto_arthur
A special issue of Theory and Society is inviting submissions on “Stratification and Inequality among Sociologists” edited by Arthur Sakamoto. For further information, please visit the Theory and Society website at: link.springer.com/collections/iaibhdehhc.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Heh, third video is on how to handle "disrespectful behavior." 1/2
I disrespect most of my field. Now what?
If you think I am kidding, see the post linked in reply (and really almost anything at Unsafe Science.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Nature (in 2019) told us Moss-Racusin et al (2012) could not be directly replicated and should not be directly replicated. Scientists often justify the superiority of what they/we do by arguing that science (more than any other way of knowing something) is "self-correcting"? Direct replication attempts are one of the most powerful tools for doing so. Nature reviewers and editors would not say they are anti-science. No they wouldn't. And yet...
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
Nature rejected our proposal to replicate a famous study. I was pissed, not at the rejection per se (happens all the time), but because the reasons for the rejection were so bad. So now:
"You can think of this as a sort of constructive revenge post." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
To be clear, the rejection occurred in 2019. And the paper is now in press at another journal. Why did I wait so long? Because I wanted the study published before raking the Nature reviewers over the coals. And they rejected a proposal not the actual studies. Of course, we had to first actually conduct them, and submit them to the journal that eventually accepted them (Meta-Psychology).
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
Nature rejected our proposal to replicate a famous study. I was pissed, not at the rejection per se (happens all the time), but because the reasons for the rejection were so bad. So now:
"You can think of this as a sort of constructive revenge post." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
Nature rejected our proposal to replicate a famous study. I was pissed, not at the rejection per se (happens all the time), but because the reasons for the rejection were so bad. So now:
"You can think of this as a sort of constructive revenge post." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post, link in reply.
Nature rejected our proposal to replicate a famous study. I was pissed, not at the rejection per se (happens all the time), but because the reasons for the rejection were so bad. So now:
"You can think of this as a sort of constructive revenge post."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"They rejected it, basically telling us the study could not be replicated...We did the right thing and (mostly) ignored them."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/reviewing-natures-reviews-of… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
FYI: 1. this is a terrific article. 2. One of the authors, a philosophy prof, is on X, @dfkodsi, and he's terrific here too. 2 quotes from the article:
"But the culpable figures are not students. They are those academics in positions of authority and secure employment who have negligently allowed the culture to be trashed, leaving a mess for the next generation to clear up."
"Much of the insurgent right, on both sides of the Atlantic, has revelled in seeing its philistine agenda put into practice. But elite universities are responsible for putting themselves in a position in which their own culpable failures can be so credibly exposed."
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
A wrecking ball to the academics who, by cowardice and complicity, destroyed universities all on their own.
“Unless and until academics identify a specific, realistic mechanism for their own regulation, any complaints about externally imposed reforms have little credibility.” -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Wins my X the day.
Carl
@HistoryBoomer
Countries I'd be willing to live in if things go bad politically in America:
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Good list, but can they actually be taught? ht @VBaker111 (again!).
Adam Wren
@adamwren
Scoop: Third Way is circulating a memo, shared first with @playbookdc, featuring a new black list of words Dems shouldn’t use.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Long post, more like a Substack essay (with data). On the consequences of Trump's reforms of academia. ht @VBaker111. Paging @OmarSHaqueMDPhD
Balaji
@balajis
TRADEOFFS DO EXIST
Several things are true at the same time.
(1) First, woke is cancer, and US universities are one of the primary sources of this cancer. They are the furthest left organizations in the world, and still radically out of sync with the people who fund them. This just came out in Nature:
(2) So, the use of state power against wokeness is probably the only way to course correct, because academic wokeness is funded by the state. State power could be like chemotherapy against the cancer.
(3) However, just as it is possible for the Western university to die from cancer, it is also possible for the university to die from chemotherapy. Particularly if no distinction is made between healthy and unhealthy tissue.
(4) And the recent academic budget cuts are hitting the relatively healthy STEM part of academia, as opposed to the completely unhealthy humanities part.
(5) That’s not to say that STEM hasn’t been corrupted by woke too. It has, particularly in medicine. But there was still some residual healthy tissue, some very smart people doing good things.
(6) One of the world’s greatest living mathematicians (Terry Tao) was among that healthy tissue. If you read his blog, he really isn’t a far leftist. True, he posted against Trump once in 2016 (but so did much of the current admin). And yes, Tao did sign a letter during the BLM riots of 2020 (but even Trump at the time felt compelled to “honor the memory of George Floyd").
(7) Remember, the social pressure to fit in at UCLA during BLM was even greater than society at large. Wokes, like communists, demand public pledges of fealty to stop harassing you. That doesn’t mean those public pledges are always deeply felt or sincere. Indeed, it is the relatively apolitical STEM guys like Tao who often go along to get along.
(8) Anyway, if one can’t or won’t make distinctions between a Terry Tao and a genuinely far left humanities prof, you will lose all the healthy tissue. The chemotherapy will kill the host. And four hundred years of Harvard's rise will come to an end.
(9) That said, to steelman the MAGA side, one can actually make the case that the end of Harvard (and the Western university system writ broadly) actually is net good for the world! After all, US universities exported many bad ideas globally, particularly recently. From the claim that XX/XY chromosomes have no relevance in medicine, to the idea that prestigious citations count for more than independent replication, to the decades of attacks on white people simply for being white.
(10) And, to further steelman the right, it is of course hard and time-consuming to separate the innocent from the guilty among the faculty. Indeed it may not even be possible in the time available, given that MAGA may lose political power in a few years. So perhaps it’s now or never.
(11) Fine. But nature abhors a vacuum. And if you leave a smoking crater where Harvard was, that vacuum will currently get filled by China (with certainty) and perhaps the Internet (if we’re lucky). For example:
(12) Anyway, I’m sympathetic to both the argument that woke is cancer and needed treatment and the reality that many talented individuals are becoming collateral damage here.
(13) We’ve seen something similar before. In the early 1900s, Europe was the unquestioned leader in science. But then, after all the fighting between right and left, science left for the stable terrain of America. The graph below quantifies this for the physics Nobel:
(14) History may repeat. In the early 2000s, America was similarly the unquestioned global leader in science. But after all the fighting between right and left, science is digitally decentralizing to the Internet (with professors becoming tech founders) and physically recentralizing in Asia (with China taking over traditional academia):
(15) In other words, tradeoffs do exist. It might still be worth it for MAGA to wreck US academia, to break the source of woke in the few years they have power, regardless of what collateral damage occurs. It'd be an immensely altruistic move, like throwing the one ring into the fires of Mount Doom. MAGA would essentially be saving the world from Western leftism by shutting down all sources of blue power, like the universities and the US dollar, and thereby ending the empire.
(16) It'd be like Gorbachev and the Russians shutting down the USSR, thereby ending the careers of many brilliant Soviet scientists (and Russia's own predominance on the world stage) in the process of shutting down a far left empire.
Gorbachev saved the world from communism at the expense of Russian power. MAGA may similarly save the world from wokism at the expense of American power. That may not be what they intend to do, but it is arguably what they're actually doing. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Justin Mogilski
@justin_mogilski
Months ago I began an adversarial collaboration with Drs. @PsychRabble, @awilson_WLU, and Bryan Love to make sense of DEI public discourse.
Today our paper was accepted at @Theory_Society.
We suggest a scientific standard for adjudicating the (de)merits of DEI 🧵👇 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post, link in reply. In 2012, Regnerus published a widely denounced & criticized study finding that children with gay&lesbian parent were worse off than children withg biological parents. Social scientists called it "bullshit", its publication a "scandal," and a "failure of peer review."
This essay summarizes results obtained from a recent intense robustness analysis, aka a multiverse analysis, finding the results hold up well, albeit with somewhat weaker effects than originally found.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/new-vindication-for-the-regn…
"some of the criticisms, even at the time obviously political, were all decked out in the garb of scientific rigor and seriousness..."
Bonus tweet in reply to this:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Regnerus was investigated and cleared (he is now a full professor); the study was never retracted. The entire Regnerus affair foreshadowed the denunciatory/retraction-by-mob turn of academia, and was a case study in rigorus mortis selectivus. From The Orwelexicon:
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This, and the replies, are poignantly amusing, and even include some data down the replies.
Jane Coaston 🏔️
@janecoaston
having been to a fair number of other countries as a half-black person.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In which Justin 🧵-summarizes our recently-accepted review of DEI practices. (I know, many of you hate DEI, and most of those reasons are in the review, along with reasons people support DEI, but it turns out there is not a lot of hard evidence either way, good or bad, for most DEI practices).
Justin Mogilski
@justin_mogilski
Months ago I began an adversarial collaboration with Drs. @PsychRabble, @awilson_WLU, and Bryan Love to make sense of DEI public discourse.
Today our paper was accepted at @Theory_Society.
We suggest a scientific standard for adjudicating the (de)merits of DEI 🧵👇 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Apparently, American science is going extinct.
Catharine
@DrCatharineY
America is facing an unprecedented brain drain that will “present an extinction-level event for American science.”
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Grok joins the crew! after debunking simplified psych narratives about "right brain=intuitive/left brain=analytical." Scroll up from Grok's tweet below for more.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Request. Has the left brain=analytical, right brain=intuitive claim held up? The neuro part is beyond my knowledge.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Cultural appropriation" is one of the best things in existence. Cultures can both objectively improve and add interesting diversity in the best sense by doing it. ht @omni_american
Alex Zoltan
@AmazingZoltan
A woman in Vancouver was denied access to a "2SLGBTIAQ+-friendly" outdoor theatre because her hair violated the venue's "Code of Conduct Cultural Appropriation policy."
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Lived in/around NYC most of my life. Was a horror in the 70s/early 80s. Its great now. Sure, crime happens, but even the "bad" neighborhoods are safe. Corona/Queens had sky high crime years ago. Now?
1. We go to Met game.
2. Park in Corona to avoid parking fees/insane exit lanes.
3. Eat at a great, cheap Central American restaurant pre-game (for the cost of two stadium hot dogs).
4. Return late, maybe 11pm. Walk to car. On way, amble up to a couple of street food vendors, get a horchata and quesadilla. Delish. Continue to car. Totally safe. Done it a zillion times, will do it again.
(and I haven't even mentioned biking through Harlem...). -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Lived in/around NYC most of my life. Was a horror in the 70s/early 80s. Its great now. Sure, crime happens, but even the "bad" neighborhoods are safe. Corona/Queens had sky high crime years ago. Now?
1. We go to Met game.
2. Park in Corona to avoid parking fees/insane exit lanes.
3. Eat at a great, cheap Central American restaurant pre-game (for the cost of two stadium hot dogs).
4. Return late, maybe 11pm. Walk to car. On way, amble up to a couple of street food vendors, get a horchata and quesadilla. Delish. Continue to car. Totally safe. Done it a zillion times, will do it again.
(and I haven't even mentioned biking through Harlem...). -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Request for help. For good entry-level articles (blogs, chapters, peer review, anything basic) to understanding effect sizes for an intelligent nonexpert. Please reply here but tag Julian (I know tons of articles, but they are all pretty technical so I am also interested).
@lakens @CJFerguson1111 @ImHardcory @LGConwayIII
Julian Adorney
@Julian_Liberty
Question for the social scientists in the room: If I wanted to get trained / train myself on how to evaluate effect sizes so I don't amplify papers that are basically just noise, what would you recommend?
@PsychRabble -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Do tell me, again, how these folks are going to "self-reform" academia?
Steven Pinker
@sapinker
Analysis of US college syllabi by the Open Syllabus project shows that bell hooks is assigned more than Aristotle, Judith Butler more than Plato, Edward Said more than than Kant, and Foucault more than everybody. (Thanks to Jon Shields for these comparisons.)
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New and (for me) very different post (link in reply). List of podcasts I love that have elements of horror (real or fiction), the supernatural and/or scifi:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/horror-in-fact-and-fantasy
e.g.: -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
You have to listen to this clip and the next, linked.
It is emblematic of how most faculty at elite coastal (and some fresh water) U's think. It is why The Beatings Will Continue. It is also why I doubt that most universities will "self-reform" without govt bludgeons. Not that I like govt bludgeons, I don't. This is an empirical prediction not a moral statement.
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
Students changing research topics. Adjuncts afraid to teach. Difficulty finding event co-sponsors. Paranoia and fear.
A Penn professor describes how things feel on campus now, but she could’ve easily been describing how they’ve felt to conservatives (and others) for a long time.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Yes.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Trump's heavy handed policies seem to be pushing even MAGA voters left. Link to essay with data in Eric's 2nd tweet.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Yes.
Jesse Smith
@jessesmithsoc
This. My general view is that if academics en masse adopted a mindset shift from “We are a cognitive elite who deserve public deference” to “We are public servants who must strive in perpetuity to be worthy of public trust,” a lot of higher ed’s problems would simply melt away.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Where is @TitaniaMcGrath when you need her?
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Killer essay. I really want to thread quotes, but I have other fish to fry. Total bullseye.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Progress! UCLA Pres realizes they are "stewards of taxpayer resources" raising the eternal questions: What responsibilities do you believe accompany that stewardship and what do you think should be done if elected representatives of the American people believe you have done a crappy job stewarding?
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
UC President James Milliken: “As a public university, we are stewards of taxpayer resources, and a payment of this scale would completely devastate our country’s greatest public university system as well as inflict great harm on our students and all Californians.”
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Excellent debunking/critique of main claims in recent NYT article that postures as being based on evidence. The main problem here is not that the data are bad -- instead, they are mis- and selectively interpreted.
Ben Golub
@ben_golub
This article from the NYT really a disappointment - this issue deserves better thinking than is in this article.
Let's start with the title graph. This graph shows that the rich are disadvantaged, until you get to the very rich.
@clairecm -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Matt Grawitch
@DocGrawitch
From Heterodox to Helpless by @OmarSHaqueMDPhD (or my alternative title: Why It's Insane to Expect Universities to Reform Themselves). Guest post shared on @PsychRabble's substack open.substack.com/pub/unsafescience/p/from-heterodox-to-h…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Whoa. Popcorn time...
In the meantime, remember when the AAUP called FIRE a rightwing org?
FIRE
@TheFIREorg
BREAKING: FIRE is suing Secretary of State Marco Rubio, challenging the laws he is using to target lawfully present noncitizens for speech protected by the Constitution.
No administration should be able to deport lawfully present noncitizens for their opinions.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Hey, @campusreform, congratulations! Nothing quite like irritating the NYTimes.
www.nytimes.com/2025/08/03/us/campus-reform-college-prote… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
🧵"The Lancet review goes well beyond disagreement about the facts, and exemplifies one of the main reasons Harvard is being targeted by the government."
Name-calling. Motive-mongering. By a "studies" professor. I am shocked. Shocked.
Carole Hooven
@hoovlet
🧵1/4
A Harvard professor has just published a glowing review of Yale Professor Agustín Fuentes’ new book, Sex is a Spectrum, in The Lancet—one of the highest-ranked, most prestigious medical journals in the world. In it, she asserts that the “gametic definition” of sex—roughly, that there are two sexes, defined by whether the organism produces sperm (male) or eggs (female)—is not only “harmful,” but also “sophistry, not science.” (Lancet piece is below.)
I hold the gametic view. To the best of my knowledge, this is the view held by most evolutionary biologists. The author of the review has different ideas, and quotes approvingly from Fuentes’ book on the nature of sex: “sex is a biocultural construct. Gamete size represents but one of multiple components and developmental processes—including gonads, hormones, genitals, fertility, mating, parenting behaviour, secondary sexual characteristics, and gender identity.”
People disagree about the nature of male and female, and that’s OK. Respectful disagreement among scholars should be encouraged; it often sharpens thinking and research. But The Lancet review goes well beyond disagreement about the facts, and exemplifies one of the main reasons Harvard is being targeted by the government.
Nobody wants to be called hateful or bigoted (especially by faculty with fancy endowed professorships), or even tainted by close proximity to views that could be construed that way. But not only has the Harvard professor disagreed with the gametic view, she apparently feels free to publicly impugn the ostensible motives and character of those who endorse it. Without providing any evidence, she asserts that our view is motivated (at least in part) by political aims, and harmful ones. As she wrote in The Lancet:
“Although the gametic definition makes reference to biological systems, it is sophistry, not science. Those who promote this definition favour the assertion that sex inheres in gamete (sperm and egg) production because, in part, it facilitates their political aims by fuelling unhinged panic in some quarters about transgender threats to traditional gender roles.”
She praises Fuentes for recognizing scientists’ “responsibility to respond to harmful deployments of inaccurate, overly simplistic, and reductionist science by those attempting to naturalise and depoliticise their hateful views.”
And last, there’s the link between those who hold the gametic view and bigots: “Like scientific bigots of yore—such as the anthropologist J McGrigor Allan, who in 1869 pronounced in the Journal of Anthropological Science that, ‘Thousands of years have amply demonstrated the mental supremacy of man, and any attempt to revolutionize the education and status of women on the assumption of an imaginary sexual equality, would be at variance with the normal order of things’—the recent favour bestowed on the gametic definition of sex by anti-trans gender traditionalists appeals selectively to science to naturalise and rationalise inequality and exclusion.”
The subtext is that in science, simply following the evidence is ill-advised if you (or others who have power over you) think it will lead to social harms. What kind of person would want to hold, let alone give voice to such harmful views as the gametic one? -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
We Tried to Warn You (link in reply) now updated with Derek Bok's 1990 report on the state of Harvard. Extended quotes shown here (1/2). Thanks to @NAChristakis for pointing me to this:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post (link in reply), but really a repost of @OmarSHaqueMDPhD's data-packed essay on why few U's are likely to self-reform in any serious way.
tl;dr: because the faculty like what he & I both would call academic dysfunctions.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/from-heterodox-to-helpless
"scholars who benefit from their ideological monoculture in academia have little reason to challenge the system that feeds and rewards them. Among Harvard faculty, there are approximately 5540% more liberals than conservatives." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Brutally brilliant essay @FreeBlckThought by @nafeesalamphd:
freeblackthought.substack.com/p/neo-white-supremacy-and-t…
"Racism, for example, is now called “antiracism.” Discrimination is now “equity.” Exclusion is now “inclusion.” And “diversity” now means, in the words of historian Barbara Fields, that “you get together a lot of people who look different and think the same.” The terminology may have evolved over the years, but the sentiment remains: white supremacy has always assumed black/brown inferiority, evolving to be practiced today as benevolent and vicarious racism." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
SPSP (main social psych society) goes off the political deep end here (see Luke's tweet and Substack essay, linked). When do you think they are likely to "self-reform" to de-politicize?
Luke Conway
@LGConwayIII
SPSP’s official policy for selecting conference sites includes a criterion that (if applied) would ban conservative states. Look at this map if you want to know why so many of us feel like SPSP is more political than scientific. No, nothing political about that, guys.
This policy is a litmus test for SPSP’s commitment to apolitical science. I call on SPSP to immediately rescind the policy. I outline the issue in a bit more detail in my new Substack piece called “SPSP Should Apologize to Conservatives for this Policy”:
open.substack.com/pub/theapologeticprofessor/p/spsp-shoul… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Christina Hoff Sommers
@CHSommers
What?
Kevin Bass
@kevinnbass
New cardiology paper published this month
Proposes changing medical guidelines for aortic valve replacement surgery to minimize the impact on global warming -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
How to Reform U's from Within, by @omni_american & @mjindra1.
Key point: It won't come from (most of the) faculty who are the problem, so its gotta come from U leadership taking proactive steps.
Note: I completely endorse reform from within, when possible. I signed on to the Manhattan Institute Statement, which calls for fed intervention, not because I think internal reform is bad, but because I am deeply skeptical that it will occur at most U's.
www.aei.org/research-products/report/reforming-higher-ed-… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Nice CHE article on the debate between signers of the Manhattan Institute Statement on reforming academia -- which calls for heavy fed intervention -- and Heterodox Academy, which mostly supports the reforms but believes they should come from within U's. Behind paywall, but I think if you sign up for a free account you get a few free articles.
www-chronicle-com.proxy.libraries.rutgers.edu/article/the… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
🧵 on DOJ guidance re: discrimination/DEI, for fed funding, w/link to full DOJ statement.
John Sailer
@JohnDSailer
Last week, the DOJ released guidance for federal funding recipients.
The memo—which clarifies how nondiscrimination law should be applied—is a huge development for universities. A lot of their worst policies are looking more fragile than ever. 🧵 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Yes.
Soumitra Shukla
@soumitrashukla9
I think if we try for socioeconomic or social class preferences in admissions and hiring they would:
1. Not be illegal
2. Target groups most want to without explicit mandates
3. Enjoy support across political aisles
4. Reduce polarization at universities
h/t: @PsychRabble -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Conor Friedersdorf
@conor64
My political affiliation is people who harbor neither of these delusions.
Carl
@HistoryBoomer
I'm not sure which is more delusional:
Thinking Trump is a good president.
Thinking liberal institutions didn't go bonkers over identity issues in 2020. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Presented for your General Edification. And to give insight into why many Republicans hate academia. ICYMI: Hooven was driven out of Harvard for declaring sex to be biological and binary. Rakesh, prof at Cal, explains here why he thinks that was great.
Rakesh Bhandari
@postdiscipline
This is silly. The Trumpian Hell was Hooven going on Fox News, not C-Span’s Book TV, and allowing the host to use her Harvard authority to bolster an anti-trans panic that went well beyond any evidence she was systematically presenting. There are intersex people for example. Hooven provoked the political denunciation by hyper-politicizing her authority. If you are not going to stand by what she did and counter the specific criticism of what she did on Fox—for god’s sake which scientists go on Fox to let the host get out of them the points the host wants—then I am afraid the Hooven example of victims of DEI fades into insignificance.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Summers on Trump's deal with Columbia. Old news, but I did not want to lose it.
Lawrence H. Summers
@LHSummers
Based on what I have read and heard so far, the agreement reached between the Federal government and @Columbia is an excellent template for agreements with other institutions including @Harvard.
First, academic freedom is preserved as the University maintains academic autonomy.
Second, ongoing reform with respect to anti Semitism, maintenance of order, promoting merit-based admissions and hiring, and strengthening the commitment to intellectual excellence is reinforced and a framework for further reform is established.
Third, normality is restored with a return to normal funding patterns, availability of visas for foreign students and removal of legal overhangs.
I, like anyone, could quibble with aspects of the program and much will depend on what both Columbia and the government do in the future. But this may be the best day higher education has had in the last year. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply. In which I post the Buckingham Manifesto for a Post-Progressive Social Science, in total.
"The unfortunate result of this progressivist overreach has been a decline of trust in cultural and academic institutions and growing political polarization, including a populist backlash."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"These problems have prompted a rethink among many scholars. The challengers, who include conservatives, classical leftists and liberals, and eclectic pragmatists, retain the ideals of social progress, but yearn for a new glasnost—an intellectual openness—in the production and transmission of knowledge."
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-buckingham-manifesto-for… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Bingo. Hard work (sometimes) pays off. Not working doesn't. I'll take the hard worker every time. Bonus: Studied my arse off for the GREs. Not w/prep courses, couldn't afford them. I was working as a part-time laundry mat attendant in college. So: 1. I bought ~12 GRE prep books. 2. Made up 1200ish flash cards with "GRE words" (you know, those words that no normal person ever uses and I had never heard of, like "sinecure" and "pellucid." Totally worth spending hours memoriziing those words. 5 appeared on the test, raising my score by~50 points.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Under intense scrutiny/pressure from the Trump admin, GMU goes full merit and nondiscrimination.
Request: Can you identify U's & colleges that have adopted these reforms without intense pressure from the feds or state govts?
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
BREAKING: The George Mason University Board of Visitors just shut down DEI and affirmed its commitments to merit and non-discrimination in admissions and hiring.
“Ensure that all University programs, policies, practices, and actions in every regard comply with the Equal Protection Clause of the U.S. Constitution, Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, and other federal civil rights law. […] This includes, but is not limited to, the consideration of race, color, or national origin in admissions, hiring, promotion, compensation, financial aid, scholarships, prizes, administrative support, discipline, housing, graduation ceremonies, and all other aspects of student, academic, and campus life.”
“Ensure there are no efforts by the University or any of its departments, colleges, or employees to circumvent prohibitions on the use of race, color, or national origin by relying on proxies or other indirect means to accomplish such ends.”
“The University's Office of Access, Compliance, and Community (OACC) is hereby directed to eliminate all programs, trainings, processes not specifically required for federal or state law or University Policy compliance, and if necessary, eliminate staff positions, within 30 days of the date of this Resolution.”
“The Access to Research and Inclusive Excellence (ARIE) program is hereby dissolved and any and all conferences on ‘anti-racism,’ implicit bias, and inclusive excellence that are inconsistent with federal law are prohibited.”
“The University shall immediately prohibit any and all departments, colleges, or employees of George Mason University from requiring diversity statements for any potential employee, for promotion of current employees, for faculty tenure considerations, or for any other purpose.” -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Heh. "Older generation" here. At 25, I returned to college, paying my own way, working part time, first as a security guard, then as laundry mat attendant. In 1979, I was indeed not paying $2200 for rent. I was paying $80 -- to live in Dorchester (Boston) on 1 floor of a tenementesque triple decker, with a convicted murderer (released after 25 yrs in Walpole) and an alcoholic. No insulation, you could feel the winter winds blowing thru the apt. We wore layers inside.
But this is not a "woe is me" story, nor a dismissal of others' hard times. It was what it was, and I did what I could. That's it, that's the whole story (not counting earlier stuff, like growing up in a city housing project and mom dying when I was 13 -- that was indeed hard, but if you came here for a "woe is me" story, you came to the wrong place.
middleclassparty
@middle_class_us
Older generations say “we all struggled in our 20s.”
No, you didn’t.
You didn’t pay $2,200 for rent and $7 for eggs.
You didn’t graduate into $50K student debt and $0 job security.
Gen Z isn’t dramatic.
They’re drowning. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Full post:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/more-evidence-of-biases-agai… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Colin Wright suing Cornell for discrimination in hiring.
Colin Wright
@SwipeWright
🚨ANNOUNCEMENT: I’ve taken legal action against Cornell University for racial discrimination.
Represented by @A1Policy, I’ve filed an EEOC complaint after leaked internal emails revealed Cornell secretly ran a faculty search in my exact field (evolutionary biology) specifically to make a “diversity hire.”
The committee privately reached out to pre-selected "diverse" candidates, one at a time, to bypass open competition. Qualified white applicants like myself were excluded from even applying.
This is a direct and egregious violation of my civil rights under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act.
Imagine if the races were reversed:
- A secret search designed to hire only white candidates
- Qualified Black applicants deliberately excluded
- Internal emails spelling it all out
It would be a national scandal. That’s exactly what happened—except I’m white.
I spent 12+ years building my career. None of that mattered because of my skin color.
This isn’t just about me. Race-based hiring erodes trust in science, undermines excellence, and has demoralized a generation of qualified scholars.
This must end.
Let my case serve as a warning that there is a price for violating civil rights.
Read my full announcement in the @WSJ:
🔗www.wsj.com/opinion/cornell-university-discriminated-agai… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
With some help from commenters, my newest post (link in reply), identifying all experimental studies of sex bias in academic hiring (10 total), has been updated to include this table. 1/2
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
With some help from commenters, my newest post (link in reply), identifying all experimental studies of sex bias in academic hiring (10 total), has been updated to include this table. 1/2
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Full post:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/more-evidence-of-biases-agai… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The core piece of tactical/psychological advice for fighting a cancelation attack. 9 other recommendations in the post linked below.
Rob Sica
@robsica
"One of the great lost arts of fighting a cancellation attack is stoicism. Accepting that you are going to lose gives you extraordinary power to fight the attack. You now have nothing to fear. This is liberating."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Excellent advice. For more on how to handle such attacks:
www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/rabble-rouser/202012/ten-…
Eric
@EricsElectrons
When extremists try to pressure you into making an apology or try to make you respond to their strawmen arguments, never apologize or over-explain because they will never accept it. Your apology will always be held against you. Clarify, if needed, but keep doing what you do best.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply.
"Far more and far better experimental studies find biases against men than against women in academic hiring. That’s the whole summary. Read on for the details." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"Faculty members in all disciplines tend to publish the most in the year before they’re granted tenure, the analysis found. After achieving it, their output varies by field: it plateaus for biologists and others who tend to work in the laboratory, and dips for those in fields such as mathematics that generally do not require lab research."
Checked my vita. 20 pubs b4 tenure, 0 books (11 years including grad school). Post tenure (32 years), 129 pubs plus 10 books.
1992, year b4 tenure: 6 pubs, so def higher than avg. But 9 of my 32 post-tenure years equaled or exceeded that (NOT including the books).
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
“How getting tenure changes researchers’ publication habits — and citations.”
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-0232 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Excellent advice. For more on how to handle such attacks:
www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/rabble-rouser/202012/ten-…
Eric
@EricsElectrons
When extremists try to pressure you into making an apology or try to make you respond to their strawmen arguments, never apologize or over-explain because they will never accept it. Your apology will always be held against you. Clarify, if needed, but keep doing what you do best.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply.
"Far more and far better experimental studies find biases against men than against women in academic hiring. That’s the whole summary. Read on for the details."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/more-evidence-of-biases-agai…
"What reform to academia could ensure greater fidelity between pervasive academic claims and the actual scientific data addressing those claims? I doubt cutting grant indirects or even DEI will have this effect – regardless of whether one thinks those reforms are good or justified. Pre-registration and public posting of data and code have not had this effect. What could?" -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I do love when data runs contra to narratives. If you only follow & hang around, progressives, Israel is losing the propaganda war and support. Shown below are results from the most recent Harvard-Harris national poll.
harvardharrispoll.com/key-results-july-3/ -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Just a periodic reminder of the sentence received by democratic vote of that early contrarian curmudgeon, Socrates.
Kevin Bass
@kevinnbass
Lol your substack is called Unsafe Science and mine is called Forbidden Science😂
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Post, originally paid, is now available to all. Strange claims about "rigor" in Moss-Racusin et al's famous 2012 paper finding biases against women in science hiring, the one that we just reversed.
Link in reply.
"In doing the replication studies, we had to attend very closely to what was reported in the M-R paper. And when we did so, some of what we found was … strange. This post goes through some of that very strange stuff."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
From Moss-Racusin et al:
"our sample size may appear small to some readers, it is important to note that we obtained the necessary power and representativeness to generalize from our results while purposefully avoiding an unnecessarily large sample that could have biased our results toward a false-positive type I error"
unsafescience.substack.com/p/scientific-rigor-versus-rigo… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Art. Title: The Current State of Academia.
(don't blame me, I just work here; ok, that's actually my title, not Apollonic's, but I suspect he will approve).
The Apollonic
@the_apollonic
Like, not all compose. There's like this whole horde of tenures who won't compost, so basically the whole academy is in trouble.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In which I thread a source-rich reply to a philosopher commenting on a philosophy essay that touts implicit bias and stereotype threat as explanations for the gender gap in philosophy.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Heh, psychologist here who has published using the IAT and critiques of doing so; critiques of stereotype threat; and work on and critiques of work on stereotypes/prej/discrimination/bias.
You can find some of that here:
sites.rutgers.edu/lee-jussim/selectpublications/
🧵Almost every empirical claim in that essay is outright wrong or unfounded at best.
1/n -
Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Heh, psychologist here who has published using the IAT and critiques of doing so; critiques of stereotype threat; and work on and critiques of work on stereotypes/prej/discrimination/bias.
You can find some of that here:
sites.rutgers.edu/lee-jussim/selectpublications/
🧵Almost every empirical claim in that essay is outright wrong or unfounded at best.
1/n -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
So, in other words, DEI (which took off around 2015) has proven COMPLETELY INEFFECTIVE AT BEST and possibly counterproductive at worst, with respect to raising the achievement of low achieving students. Got it.
Neetu Arnold
@neetu_arnold
Education circles compare achievement results across demographic groups (race, income, etc.)
But what doesn’t get a lot of attention? How the lowest-performing students are being left far behind
Gains among students in the 25th-percentile began to fall rapidly around 2015 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
How to Reform Academia from Within
Nice essay by Michael Jindra & @omni_american.
I doubt that academia will reform from within, but IF IT IS POSSIBLE, this is an excellent set of ideas.
www.aei.org/research-products/report/reforming-higher-ed-… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
American Psych Association Goes Full Propaganda/Misinformation on Implicit Bias
Its worse than the tw suggests. 🧵w/links to sources.
"it is now established that statistically small effects on the IAT can be associated with large discriminatory impacts" is outright wrong. Greenwald in the citation provided CLAIMED it WITHOUT a shred of evidence. Its NEVER been even tested.
Link to source screenshotted below:
www.apa.org/research-practice/conduct-research/hidden-ass…
1/n
Neetu Arnold
@neetu_arnold
It’s 2025 and the American Psychological Association is trying to make implicit bias tests a thing again:
“The IAT has not been without its detractors…Yet various meta-analyses have repeatedly found support for the test’s validity”Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
My chapter (unfortunately, I don't have a free link to the chapter).
Jussim, L., Careem, A., Goldberg, Z., Honeycutt, N. & Stevens. S. (2025). IAT scores, racial gaps, and scientific gaps. In Krosnick, J.A., Stark, T. H & Scott, A.L. (Eds.). The Cambridge Handbook of Implicit Bias and Racism (pp. 374-411). New York: Cambridge University Press.
BUT, I do have this, which is publicly available and includes a detailed review finding SFPs DO NOT accumulate; they dissipate (get smaller over time).
d1wqtxts1xzle7.cloudfront.net/77189126/2005-jussim-libre.…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
When professional academic orgs claiming the mantle of science promote this sort of nonsense, it exacerbates the loss of credibility of academia writ large -- and that helps explain the ongoing Trumpian assault on academia.
END -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Systemic racism can be a thing and not a quasi-religious dogma. It requires: identifying the system that produces discrimination -- in this case, the journal's & med school's awarding of extra points based on race/ethnicity.
Aaron Sibarium
@aaronsibarium
EXCLUSIVE: The Trump administration has launched a civil rights probe into the Duke Law Journal based on our reporting—and it's warning that Duke Medical School could be next.
The school could lose ~1 billion in federal aid if it does not make major changes within six months.🧵 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Damn. TIL something on X. P.S. Several family members invested in Nvidia years ago.
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Contrary to widespread belief, the middle class isn't shrinking because people are getting poorer; it's shrinking because they're getting richer.
[Link below.] -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Dear Grok,
Apparently, you missed the intro stats course where sophomores learn that one cannot infer cause from correlation. And you also seemed to have missed the grad methods course where the many threats to the validity of subjective self-reports are covered (such as self-serving biases, self-presentation biases, memory limitations and biases, etc.).
I am teaching grad stats Spring 2025. You are welcome to audit the course.
Grok
@grok
Dismissing it as nonsense overlooks evidence: A 2025 APA meta-analysis (updating Sue et al.) confirms microaggressions correlate with higher stress/depression in minorities (r=0.32). Critics like Lukianoff/Haidt argue hypersensitivity, but data from PMC studies show tangible effects. What's your counter-evidence? Let's discuss substantively.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In which Musa argues that U's have, in fact, begun to reform themselves pre-Trump, disagreeing with @OmarSHaqueMDPhD, & suggesting Trump's policies are more bad than good. Both have data-packed blogs supporting their arguments.
The discussion below this is kinda my Academic Utopia: 1. No denunciations/insults; 2. No "argument from cooties" (guilt-by-assoc); 3. Both sides w/lots of data. Musa retw's Omar, which links his essay.
1/2
My reply to Musa next tweet, in which I interpret his data a bit differently than he did.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
My reply:
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Hi Musa. I respectfully disagree with your disagreement with Omar. You pointed out (correctly) that many U's have adopted institutional neutrality. But: 1. This is still a tiny % of colleges; 2. While better than the alternative, the importance of this for the various manifestations of politically corruption at U’s is dubious at best (e.g., Dorian Abbot was 1stsubject to a cancelation attack AT UChic, which I present not as “proof” but as emblematic of Inst Neut being a weak indicator of anything).
You then linked to your LibPatriot piece on U's reforming. I agree that we are past Peak Woke. I disagree w/the titular claim in that piece (“The Great Awokening Has Ended”). All the longituduinal charts in your essay show the same thing: There has been a retreat from the 2020 moral panic induced wokeness, but every chart shows some/most outcomes at MASSIVELY elevated levels compared to, e.g., 2015. Your longitudinal data charts are screenshotted below with handdrawn lines at 2015.
However, returning to 2015 is, like institutional neutrality, better-than-nothing, but a woefully inadequate goal (even were it possible, which I doubt anytime soon). Remember Haidt’s SPSP talk & The Edge essays? Those were 2010-11! And even then, the fields were hopelessly politicized (Paglia was correctly warning about this since at least 1995).
Are Trump’s policies good or bad for academia/science? YES. However, despite the howls about Trump destroying science, w/Ex A being Great Projects at Columbia Killed, some on the sane left, such as Summers, shown below, think he did a pretty good job by the end of the day.
The Status Quo is not acceptable. I see evidence in your data that The Soft Cultural Revolution of 2020 has receded, but I see no evidence (even in your evidence) of academia engaging in serious attempts to reform itself. Other efforts remain few and far between. Trump is not my Ideal Instrument of Reform. But if anyone has a better plan, I have yet to see it.
Lawrence H. Summers
@LHSummers
Based on what I have read and heard so far, the agreement reached between the Federal government and @Columbia is an excellent template for agreements with other institutions including @Harvard.
First, academic freedom is preserved as the University maintains academic autonomy.
Second, ongoing reform with respect to anti Semitism, maintenance of order, promoting merit-based admissions and hiring, and strengthening the commitment to intellectual excellence is reinforced and a framework for further reform is established.
Third, normality is restored with a return to normal funding patterns, availability of visas for foreign students and removal of legal overhangs.
I, like anyone, could quibble with aspects of the program and much will depend on what both Columbia and the government do in the future. But this may be the best day higher education has had in the last year. -
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Hi Musa. I respectfully disagree with your disagreement with Omar. You pointed out (correctly) that many U's have adopted institutional neutrality. But: 1. This is still a tiny % of colleges; 2. While better than the alternative, the importance of this for the various manifestations of politically corruption at U’s is dubious at best (e.g., Dorian Abbot was 1stsubject to a cancelation attack AT UChic, which I present not as “proof” but as emblematic of Inst Neut being a weak indicator of anything).
You then linked to your LibPatriot piece on U's reforming. I agree that we are past Peak Woke. I disagree w/the titular claim in that piece (“The Great Awokening Has Ended”). All the longituduinal charts in your essay show the same thing: There has been a retreat from the 2020 moral panic induced wokeness, but every chart shows some/most outcomes at MASSIVELY elevated levels compared to, e.g., 2015. Your longitudinal data charts are screenshotted below with handdrawn lines at 2015.
However, returning to 2015 is, like institutional neutrality, better-than-nothing, but a woefully inadequate goal (even were it possible, which I doubt anytime soon). Remember Haidt’s SPSP talk & The Edge essays? Those were 2010-11! And even then, the fields were hopelessly politicized (Paglia was correctly warning about this since at least 1995).
Are Trump’s policies good or bad for academia/science? YES. However, despite the howls about Trump destroying science, w/Ex A being Great Projects at Columbia Killed, some on the sane left, such as Summers, shown below, think he did a pretty good job by the end of the day.
The Status Quo is not acceptable. I see evidence in your data that The Soft Cultural Revolution of 2020 has receded, but I see no evidence (even in your evidence) of academia engaging in serious attempts to reform itself. Other efforts remain few and far between. Trump is not my Ideal Instrument of Reform. But if anyone has a better plan, I have yet to see it.
Lawrence H. Summers
@LHSummers
Based on what I have read and heard so far, the agreement reached between the Federal government and @Columbia is an excellent template for agreements with other institutions including @Harvard.
First, academic freedom is preserved as the University maintains academic autonomy.
Second, ongoing reform with respect to anti Semitism, maintenance of order, promoting merit-based admissions and hiring, and strengthening the commitment to intellectual excellence is reinforced and a framework for further reform is established.
Third, normality is restored with a return to normal funding patterns, availability of visas for foreign students and removal of legal overhangs.
I, like anyone, could quibble with aspects of the program and much will depend on what both Columbia and the government do in the future. But this may be the best day higher education has had in the last year. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Kevin Bass
@kevinnbass
Former NIH Director Francis Collins is complaining about "mixing politics and science."
This is the same man who secretly called for public "devastating takedowns" of scientists (one now the NIH Director) who dared disagree with him.
A rank hypocrite of the highest order.
Christiane Amanpour
@amanpour
“When you mix politics and science, you just get politics,” former NIH director Dr Francis Collins tells me. He says the casting of doubt on vaccine efficacy by RFK Jr and others is “truly heartbreaking and dangerous. Look what’s happening right now in our country with measles.”
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Bullseye.
Soumitra Shukla
@soumitrashukla9
It would be nice if all those worried about the politicization of science said something when these shenanigans were underway.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Camille Paglia, in 2018!!!
Quillette
@Quillette
"Camille Paglia: The silence of the academic establishment about the corruption of Western universities by postmodernism and post-structuralism has been an absolute disgrace." quillette.com/2018/11/10/camille-paglia-its-time-for-a-ne…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Omar is a Harvard Prof. And just wrote a clear, evidence-packed post. Calls for academia to reform itself are bankrupt. Here is the opening:
"Step back, and imagine an analogy: your local police department has a bunch of problems with its professionalism, and there is tons of evidence of this.
Now ask yourself this hypothetical question: Is the department more likely to reform internally without external accountability, or with external pressure?
OK. Now why would universities be any different? Human nature is the same. There is no real incentive to change from within. Did the Catholic Church undergo a true self-reformation?"
But the essay is much more than an opinion piece. It is PACKED with data that support this claim that appears midway:
"If Heterodox Academy cares about data, it should conclude that internal reform over the past 10 years has on the whole failed."
Omar Sultan Haque
@OmarSHaqueMDPhD
Imagine your local police department has a bunch of problems with its professionalism, and there is tons of evidence of this.
Now ask yourself this hypothetical question: Is the department more likely to reform internally without external accountability, or with external pressure?
OK. Now why would universities be any different?
Human nature is the same. Scholars who benefit from an ideological monoculture are not incentivized to change their universities; admitting problems and fixing them would undermine their own authority.
@christopherrufo was correct in the The Manhattan Statement on Higher Education
If Heterodox Academy cares about data, it should conclude that internal reform over the past 10 years has on the whole failed.
Link below 👇 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Contra the academics howling about Trump's "tyranny"...
Lawrence H. Summers
@LHSummers
Based on what I have read and heard so far, the agreement reached between the Federal government and @Columbia is an excellent template for agreements with other institutions including @Harvard.
First, academic freedom is preserved as the University maintains academic autonomy.
Second, ongoing reform with respect to anti Semitism, maintenance of order, promoting merit-based admissions and hiring, and strengthening the commitment to intellectual excellence is reinforced and a framework for further reform is established.
Third, normality is restored with a return to normal funding patterns, availability of visas for foreign students and removal of legal overhangs.
I, like anyone, could quibble with aspects of the program and much will depend on what both Columbia and the government do in the future. But this may be the best day higher education has had in the last year. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Apollonic
@the_apollonic
Who among us doesn't sense an eeriness the scientific community is dealing with? That there are groups dedicated to subvert scientific social progress? Check out the details here 👇. Simply, balanced and inspiring, Lee Jussim style! 😎🤘
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply.
"I also signed on because I have seen no evidence that academia will reform itself to address the problems resulting from its overt politicization and evolution into an engine for the advancement of progressive values, policies, and worldviews." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply.
"I also signed on because I have seen no evidence that academia will reform itself to address the problems resulting from its overt politicization and evolution into an engine for the advancement of progressive values, policies, and worldviews." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is emblematic of why people hate academia.
Luke killing it here. A nice companion piece to my recent defense of the Manhattan Institute Statement, even though it does not address that at all. Instead, Luke's piece complements my essay, because it is a peak under the hood of a major social psychology organization -- and what he finds there is not science.
Luke Conway
@LGConwayIII
My new Substack, The Apologetic Professor, has officially been launched! The first article is “When Science Decides the Scientific Method Is Racist: A Social Psychology Case Study.” In it, I evaluate the most recent PSPB editorial statement.
theapologeticprofessor.substack.com/p/when-science-decide…
Forthcoming posts include a long-overdue defense of stereotype threat effects, reflections on my 6 years as Associate Editor of PSPB, some Christian apologetics pieces, highlights and lowlights of the recent Buckingham heterodox conference, and a crazy rant about how bad the Pittsburgh Steelers’ offseason was. Could be anything! So sign up if you want to hear some wild and generally non-normative opinions. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Buckingham Conference was terrific and Luke nails it here.
Luke Conway
@LGConwayIII
I'm proud to be one of the signatories on this Manifesto.
The Buckingham conference was wild in the good sense of the word: Open debate, say-anything discussion, and people on all sides of issues coming together to find the truth. You know, the way academia should be.
Eric Kaufmann
@epkaufm
1/ NEW: Announcing the Buckingham Manifesto for a Post-Progressive Social Science
Just released at @chronicle
Signatories span the range from anti-Trump liberals (i.e. @sapinker @clairlemon) to conservative reformers (i.e. @christopherrufo @GadSaad)
A new intellectual movement -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Matt Burgess
@matthewgburgess
I wasn't asked to sign the Manhattan Statement, and I probably wouldn't have signed. I'm generally pretty allergic to signing petitions. A friend of mine once said his mantra was "I only sign petitions that I would sign if I were the only signatory." I like that and I've taken that to heart.
That said, I agree with most of @PsychRabble's analysis here.
The Manhattan preamble is very hyperbolic and somewhat off-putting, opening itself up to criticism by "laying out the facts" and then presenting a series of non-empirical maximalist vageries.
But, Manhattan's specific calls to action are pretty much the Chicago Trifecta, enforced by the government, which I think is reasonable, and is arguably already required by current federal law, as I have publicly argued before (see link below). Like Lee said, it's notable that @HdxAcademy (HxA) pointed out how similar their reform agenda was to the Manhattan statement as they were criticizing it.
It's also notable that the HxA statement's two main departures from Manhattan, in terms of recommendations for action, are: (i) being against government oversight, and (ii) not even mentioning the flagrant violations of federal laws (civil rights and others) that are a huge part of the problem on campus over the past decade. The feds' have a *statutory requirement* to address federal law breaking that pre-dates Trump. So, if you acknowledge (ii), I don't think you can be reflexively for (i).
Lee is also right that HxA (which, to be clear, I think does great work and I am a proud member of) needs a better answer to the "why has almost no internal reform happened over the past decade without direct or implied government pressure?" question, if they're going to continue to oppose all government oversight.
It'd even be fine for them to say, "we, HxA, choose to focus on internal reform as our role in this effort, and we don't want to get involved in government oversight". But if they're going to say "government oversight is bad", they need a much more credible theory of change to offer as an alternative. Or, they need to parse which types of government oversight are bad and which are ok/good in their statements, as groups like @TheFIREorg have done (and I've also tried to do when writing about this; see below).
Of course, the Trump administration would help itself gain more supporters of its higher-ed oversight if it weren't going about it in a manner so chaotic, lacking in due process, and dismissive of/threatening to the enormous benefits universities provide to the country (see second link below for examples).
Anyway, I count several people I respect among both signatories and critics of the Manhattan statement. Lee does a nice job explaining the tension.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply.
"I also signed on because I have seen no evidence that academia will reform itself to address the problems resulting from its overt politicization and evolution into an engine for the advancement of progressive values, policies, and worldviews." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Signed this one, too. So can you. The link to do so is in the thread.
Eric Kaufmann
@epkaufm
1/ NEW: Announcing the Buckingham Manifesto for a Post-Progressive Social Science
Just released at @chronicle
Signatories span the range from anti-Trump liberals (i.e. @sapinker @clairlemon) to conservative reformers (i.e. @christopherrufo @GadSaad)
A new intellectual movement -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply.
"I also signed on because I have seen no evidence that academia will reform itself to address the problems resulting from its overt politicization and evolution into an engine for the advancement of progressive values, policies, and worldviews."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/why-i-signed-on-to-the-manha…
"Before Trump, calls to reform were made by an infinitesimal proportion of faculty, who were not merely duly ignored, they were often denounced (such as here or here), and the radicalization of the faculty simply continued apace, and bringing with it, a cratering of support for academia especially among Republicans but even to a lesser extent among Democrats." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Some philosopher recently posted a defense of Alex Byrne against the open letter denouncing him, in which he likens the open letter to "an argument from cooties" (not a direct quote). Can't find it. Can you? @BrandonWarmke @byrne_a @rbnmckenna86 @HSJSpeaks ???
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
this is a riot. maybe i'll send one to my irb.
no more docile users
@WTTDOTM
Lawyers are expensive, but *looking* like you have a lawyer is free.
Today, I'm happy to announce my latest project, Heavyweight! Heavyweight lets you take any complaint you have, and make it look like a scary legal document without ever actually claiming to be from a lawyer. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Just tw'd this article, but the tw makes a different point. Figure below shows actual ideas/claims made/promoted/advanced in academia over the last few years w/minimal pushback from sane academics. Do you really wonder why so many want to defund and even destroy us?
John Maier
@johnmaier_
With a few exceptions -- @Docstockk, @aytchellesse, @byrne_a -- philosophers continue to affect a bizarre neutrality over whether there are male women. Is it any surprise this cues the public into writing off academia generally?
Me and @d_kodsi in TPM
philosophersmag.com/philosophical-malpractice/ -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Same for DEI.
Alex Byrne
@byrne_a
"Trans activists’ central philosophical arguments were always underpowered by ordinary methodological standards ... their popularization was aided and abetted by special pleading, political bullying and plain old cowardice." philosophersmag.com/philosophical-malpractice/
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
People have been posting a slew of very amusing memes using these data in the replies to this tweet, below.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Terrific pair of studies find:
1. Democrats' beliefs cluster tightly around one extreme end
2. Republicans' beliefs are far more variable.
Open access.
X axis is extremity of belief.
Not really a Y-axis. What is shown is the network of beliefs (how each belief is connected to other beliefs in the network of beliefs).
bpspsychub.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/bjso.… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Terrific pair of studies find:
1. Democrats' beliefs cluster tightly around one extreme end
2. Republicans' beliefs are far more variable.
Open access.
X axis is extremity of belief.
Not really a Y-axis. What is shown is the network of beliefs (how each belief is connected to other beliefs in the network of beliefs).
bpspsychub.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/bjso.… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Random cat post about a cat acting very random. ID evenK where the hell that is in my house.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"If, as a culture, you thrust people out, you run the risk of people realizing they like it better on the outside."
Jeff Mach, Diary of a Dark Lord
@Darklo
Steve McGuire
@sfmcguire79
These political shifts among Ivy League Jewish students are remarkable:
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Excellent review (in both senses: on target, high praise) of Nick's book on investigations into profs for what most us believe was nonsense (I have an entry that describes two separate incidents).
Bonus: Nick is receiving an academic freedom award (we suspect primarily for this book).
Book is $27 on Amazon.
Nicholas H Wolfinger
@NickWolfinger
An Aussie blogger reviews my book Professors Speak Out: The Truth About Campus Investigations. Tagging POS contributors @PsychRabble @eweissunburied @LiamOMaraIV @FrancesWiddows1
comments.bmartin.cc/2025/07/18/target-outspoken-professors/ -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Smash the matriarchy! Wait, seriously, how much of this is due to illegal discrimination? One should not assume any of it is -- but it is worth finding out.
John Burn-Murdoch
@jburnmurdoch
NEW:
There’s been a lot of discussion lately about rising graduate unemployment.
I dug a little closer and a striking story emerged:
Unemployment is climbing among young graduate *men*, but college-educated young women are generally doing okay. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
As I wrote a month or so ago, in some cases, DEI was a conspiracy (powerful people doing illegal or unethical things in secret). Link to post in reply.
1/2
Aaron Sibarium
@aaronsibarium
NEW: After Prop. 209, UC San Diego transferred a race-based scholarship to a private nonprofit, the San Diego Foundation, so that it could continue the program.
Now both entities are being sued under the KKK Act, which bans conspiracies to interfere with civil rights.🧵
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Original post:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/was-dei-a-conspiracy
From the post:
"It is a felony to conspire to deprive others of their Constitutional rights and the Trump administration has invoked the relevant law (18 U.S.C. § 241) in its guidance on combating campus antisemitism. From the law:
Section 241 makes it unlawful for two or more persons to agree to injure, threaten, or intimidate a person in the United States in the free exercise or enjoyment of any right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of the United States or because of his or her having exercised such a right." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"If you disrupt my course, I am going to kick the shit of you."
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
Robert Nozick, dealing with grad students who weren't pleased with his course on capitalism.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
What Aaron has is "a very particular set of skills, skills acquired over an interesting career. Skills that make him a nightmare for academics breaking the law and engaging in unethical behavior (such as plagiarism)."
Aaron Sibarium
@aaronsibarium
Jill Abramson, the former executive editor of the New York Times, describes the Free Beacon as a "potentially lethal weapon aimed at elite universities," writing that its "jihad" has "left blood on the floor at Harvard, Columbia, Stanford," and other top schools.
High praise. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Nearly extinct. Uhhh... stereotype accuracy, biases against men, accuracy dominating bias in person perception, negative consequences of dei rhetoric, radicalization of the academy, to name a few. just saying...
josephmanson
@josephhmanson
This is one of the best pithy descriptions of what has gone wrong. Remember the Eccentric Professor, who explored unpopular ideas out of a kind of inner compulsion? Now nearly extinct, both as cultural archetype and as living person.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Call for papers on upgrading replicability&reproducibility of psych methods research.
Commentary: Compared to psych pre-2010, I suspect that research post 2020 will be substantially improved. Larger Ns, more open data, materials&code, pre-registration & especially registered reports, more published replications & even more adversarial collaborations. I'm not exactly optimistic, but i am definitely less pessimistic about my field.
JK Flake 📈📏
@JkayFlake
Are you working on issues of replication and reproducibility of methodological research in psychology? Consider submitting a proposal to my call for papers, happy to chat about your ideas or answer any questions! www.psychologicalscience.org/publications/ampps/ampps-rep…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
George Yancey
@profyancey
We in academia are going to have a hard time winning the trust of society back until we recognize that we have a problem with leftist bias and are willing to do something about it.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Quick take: We underestimated the severity of the problem, the intransigence across academia with respect to addressing it, and the intellectual/political/cultural momentum all pushing to worsen rather than improve it. I have a slew of papers on various aspects of this, but this is a good start:
sites.rutgers.edu/lee-jussim/wp-content/uploads/sites/135…
Full citation:
Jussim, L., Honeycutt, N., Paresky. P., Careem, A., Finkelstein, D. & Finkelstein, J. (2023). The radicalization of the American academy (pp. 343-366). In, Zúquete, J.P. (ed). The Palgrave Handbook of Left-Wing Extremism, Volume 2. New York: Palgrave MacMillan. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Slide from Joe Forgas, organizer of Psych of Trust Conference.
#notallacademics -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Jeez. Now even stuff I have never heard of is failing to replicate.
Jelte Wicherts
@JelteWicherts
Classic educational psychology on scaffolding fails to replicate. doi.org/10.1037/edu0000965
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Excellent thread on 1 manifestation of academic malfunction, & exquisite refutation of that terrible NYTimes op ed by a progressive philosopher on why academia does not need to bother making efforts to add conservatives.
David Decosimo
@DavidDecosimo
When I was at BU, I wanted to bring @CornelWest & @McCormickProf for a major event on their friendship & liberal arts. As a favor & to help them, I asked a department if they wanted to cosponsor by contributing a nominal amount. They'd get credit & it would cost almost nothing.
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Quick take: We underestimated the severity of the problem, the intransigence across academia with respect to addressing it, and the intellectual/political/cultural momentum all pushing to worsen rather than improve it. I have a slew of papers on various aspects of this, but this is a good start:
sites.rutgers.edu/lee-jussim/wp-content/uploads/sites/135…
Full citation:
Jussim, L., Honeycutt, N., Paresky. P., Careem, A., Finkelstein, D. & Finkelstein, J. (2023). The radicalization of the American academy (pp. 343-366). In, Zúquete, J.P. (ed). The Palgrave Handbook of Left-Wing Extremism, Volume 2. New York: Palgrave MacMillan. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Unsafe Science Guest Post.
On the state of UK higher ed. Link in reply.
"There is an increasingly palpable sentiment that the elite educational institutions across the Western world are changing, and not for the better." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Unsafe Science Guest Post.
On the state of UK higher ed. Link in reply.
"There is an increasingly palpable sentiment that the elite educational institutions across the Western world are changing, and not for the better."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/diversity-is-the-inverse-of-…
"The mark of having been ‘educated’ in one of our Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) can be identified by a myriad of jargonistic buzz-concepts. The mandatory embedding of DEI (often re-ordered as EDI in Britain) across degree-level curriculums has produced graduates equipped with concepts of ‘decoloniality’, ‘feminist, gender, queer, and trans theory’, analyses of ‘whiteness’ or ‘blackness’, and consideration of a ‘global majority’ in all subject fields; from history to law, and increasingly in the scientific domain." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Academics have been screaming about Trump's "fascism" for years. Apparentely, three of four liberal SCOTUS judges are also "fascists." (Whether the cuts are good policy is a different issue than whether they are "fascism" - one that can be resolved by that other arm of "fascism" -- democratic elections).
ht @JewelEldorAI (Hi Jewel; as always I pay more attention than I can reply to).
The Patriot Oasis™
@ThePatriotOasis
🚨BREAKING: The U.S. Supreme Court Votes 8-1 to ALLOW President Trump to CUT the Federal Workforce in any department he chooses
Justice Ketanji Jackson was the ONLY "No" vote.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Debunking academic nonsense one podcast at a time. Great convo w/Ryan. Spiced w/a bit more methods/stats than many of my recent pods.
Ryan Rogers
@ryanMcRogers
Can a test tell you if you are secretly racist? Is stereotype threat the reason for disparities in test scores? Are women discriminated against in science? Are stereotypes accurate?
I went over all of these questions and more with @PsychRabble in a fascinating interview about bias in psychology research. I hope you enjoy as much as I did. Cheers! -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Against the argument from cooties. Nice essay on bad arguments against advising the Trump Administration from philosophy grad students.
Richard Y. Chappell🔸
@RYChappell
Sad to see another "open letter" condemning an academic for their work. My post (below) critiques the procedural principles they appeal to.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Contra most of the noise about racism and sexism in the academy, status/prestige bias is probably the biggest bias. For things like pubs & grants, probably even larger than the political biases I rail against. John also recently tw'd out a paper finding that when early career scholars pub with/are mentored by famous ones, it gives their careers booster rockets. Same status bias nonsense.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Remember when economists at a scientific journal randomized who authored a paper?
65% recommended rejecting the manuscript when it came from an early career scholar...
But only 23% recommended reject when it came from a Nobel laureate from the same university. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
Many have indeed listened, which is why we talk so much about how entire academic fields are populated by leftwing ideologues who are interested in scholarship only to the extent it helps launder classroom activism and gives their radicalism a patina of intellectual seriousness.
John Sailer
@JohnDSailer
“I hope you seek to dismantle the United States…. Listen to indigenous people when we tell you this is the goal,” says Dr. Melanie Yazzie.
Yazzie owes her faculty career to a string of well-funded fellowships meant to recruit social justice activists.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
God bless America. (And I'm an atheist but totally endorse the sentiment).
Stuart Ritchie
@StuartJRitchie
The responses here are really telling: the idea of “free speech even for people I don’t like” is totally alien to lots of British people. No wonder people are being arrested for jokes and tweets!
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Damn, brilliant article over at Heterodox Stem. Here I just 🧵select quotes. Link in next tweet.
"US universities are caught in a maelstrom not seen since the 1960s. From a Marcusian perspective, an enlightened, freedom-loving vanguard is confronting white-male-heterosexual-supremacist, capitalist, imperialist reaction in battles of such world-historical significance that they demand alliance with savagely repressive, male-supremacist, anti-homosexual, neo-colonialist regimes."Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"This is worse than non-productive. It is anti-productive. Any civilization that comprehensively applied their approach would quickly go down the tubes. Only Western civilization is sufficiently rich, tolerant, and introspective to toy with this type of self-hate and it too is tiring. This is tragic."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"What we see instead are gasps for political relevance, with proud attachment to every fashionably nihilistic cause that comes along. The more contradictory the principles the better, since there are some things so patently ridiculous that only modern liberal arts academics can fully embrace them. Queers for Palestine. Feminists for Islamism. Yesterday I read an allegation that Iran is trans-friendly as it insists on surgically altering homosexuals. Humanities and Social Sciences is morphing into the Inhumanities and Antisocial Sciences."
Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"The very effort to study Civilization in that spirit, if it can be sustained, stands to make better citizens of scientists. It would help inoculate against “I feel, therefore it is” groupthink."
The End (of my thread, not the actual article).
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Oh, my thread should've included this killer quote, so here it is:
"Belittle the scientific revolution, technological progress, and the institutions needed to sustain them; bemoan the illusory paradises they supplanted and forecast mass extinction. Twist every achievement into failure or oppression."
The Actual End. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Shocking. Interestingly, it discomfirms a conclusion reached by Kalev & Dobbins that hiring a "diversity manager" works at least to increase organizational diversity.
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
When universities hired chief diversity officers, it had no effect on the diversity of faculty or university administrator hires.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Its amazing what one can discover if one does not begin and end one's claims with "discrimination" (there is a whole cottage industry of social psychology articles claiming that denial of discrimination is itself prejudice).
John B. Holbein
@JohnHolbein1
Even when:
■ workers are unionized,
■ work tasks are similar,
■ hourly wages are identical, &
■ tenure dictates promotions,
Women often make less than men.
Why?
Women often can't/don't work overtime.
"Female[s]..., especially those with dependents, pursue schedule conventionality, predictability, and controllability more than male[s]." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
In My Positionality Statement at Unsafe Science, I identify as a tennis player. From this Positionality, I point out that almost everyone, even non tennis players, knows a Swiss male. Roger Federer.
Richard Hanania
@RichardHanania
I don’t think I’ve ever met a Swiss. They just exist in my head as these half human shadows without problems or flaws. I imagine them all as women, it’s really hard to think of a Swiss male.
-
Daniël Lakens
@lakens
New blog post: Are meta-scientists ignoring philosophy of science? daniellakens.blogspot.com/2025/07/are-meta-scientists-ign… I don't think so, but I fear for reasons philosophers of science will not enjoy reading.
Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Best recent piece of phil of sci I know of is by @HSJSpeaks. Social pressure NOT to make some point can corrupt an entire scientific literature. Original article on left; basic process on right.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Daniël Lakens
@lakens
"The intensity of the conviction that a hypothesis is true has no bearing on whether it is true or not. The importance of the strength of our conviction is only to provide a proportionately strong incentive to find out if the hypothesis will stand up to critical evaluation."
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Carl
@HistoryBoomer
A lot of folks don't believe in free speech.
"Oh no! We believe in free speech! As long as it's not anti-American! Or bigoted towards trans people! Or anti-Israel! Or said by foreigners who are guests!"
Exactly. You don't believe in free speech. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post at Unsafe Science, on Scientific Rigor vs. Rigor Posturing in Moss-Racusin et al (2012), a famous, massively cited study finding what they called "subtle" biases against women in science. Our paper, a very close and series of direct replication attempts found the reverse -- biases against men.
Link below is to the Rigor post. Link to earlier post, on the reversal in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/scientific-rigor-versus-rigo…
They really actually claimed that using a smaller sample would protect them from false positives (detecting statistically significant "effects" that were not real). And they claimed this was a "recommended practice." In PNAS, one of the apex science journals.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Reversal!
unsafescience.substack.com/p/reversal-science-facultys-su… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Should I change my X handle to The Dark Mutilator of Bad Research?
Ryan Rogers
@ryanMcRogers
I had a great conversation with @PsychRabble and let me tell you, this dude mutilates bad research. Look for that episode next week.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Killer post by @matthewgburgess at his Sbstack.
Link in reply. On academia's denial of its dysfunctions, the dysfunctional nature of Trump's policies on academia, academia's strengths/contributions, and academia's severe dysfunctions. Best quote:
"Universities—despite purportedly dedicating themselves over the past decade to eradicating bigotry and promoting emotional well-being—have become national epicenters of bigotry and mental illness."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
guidedcivicrevival.substack.com/p/both-sides-are-losing-t…
"Any approach to reform by the federal government that doesn’t respect universities’ enormous value to society, and any response to the federal government by universities that doesn’t acknowledge and address universities’ enormous and festering problems, isn’t serious and is doing a major disservice to the American public." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
From a new post at Unsafe Science, 2nd in a series on our reversal (opposite bias, i.e., against men) of Moss-Racusin et al's (2012) famous PNAS paper finding "subtle biases" against women in science.
This quote from their paper -- which included several very accomplished social scientists (Yale, named chair, etc.) reveals the type of thinking that brought Psychology its Replication Crisis.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/scientific-rigor-versus-rigo…
They really actually claimed that using a smaller sample would protect them from false positives (detecting statistically significant "effects" that were not real). And they claimed this was a "recommended practice." In PNAS, one of the apex science journals. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Brandon
@BrandonLukeMc
This is hilarious
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/scientific-rigor-versus-rigo…
They really actually claimed that using a smaller sample would protect them from false positives (detecting statistically significant "effects" that were not real). And they claimed this was a "recommended practice." In PNAS, one of the apex science journals. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post in the ongoing series on sexism in science. In this post, I point out some of the very strange claims to "rigor" in the famous Moss-Racusin et al (2012) study of "subtle biases" against women in science.
Link and fav example of strange rigor in reply.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/scientific-rigor-versus-rigo…
They really actually claimed that using a smaller sample would protect them from false positives (detecting statistically significant "effects" that were not real). And they claimed this was a "recommended practice." In PNAS, one of the apex science journals. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Was originally for paid subscribers, BUT, I just made this free for all. Enjoy!
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post on our three experiment reversal of the massively cited and massively influential Moss-Racusin et al (2012) PNAS paper. With N=127, they found biases against women in science hiring.
Link in reply.
We used their methods nearly exactly, and with N>=1100, we found biases against men in STEM hiring. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
1. Weaknesses and BS in claims about implicit bias, stereotype threat, and microaggressions.
2. The quasi-supernatural status of attributions of inequality to "systemic racism."
3. Lefties' wild overestimates of police killings of unarmed Black people and wild underestimates of damage/death caused by the BLM protests of 2020.
4. Lefties' endorsement of Hitler's rhetoric when applied to White people instead of Jews.
5. Actual examples of actual genocides and mass murder, as perpetrated by Romans, Mongols, medieval Europeans, American Indians, Turks, and Africans.
6. Death toll due to communism.
7. Histories' natural experiments comparing capitalism to communism: E. v. W. Germany; N. v. S. Korea, China v. Taiwan.
Wilfred Reilly
@wil_da_beast630
I'll ask some of you this more personally, but: what would you include in a one-day DEI DE-programming seminar?
I.e., fake stats, origins of theories, issues with concepts like "white privilege," etc: how would you respond to the corporate narrative we all heard for a decade? -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Grad students in philosophy post open letter that inadvertently helps understand why the Trump administration is doing some combination of attempting to reform academia and simply engaging in a vindictive attack on it.
#thebeatingswillcontinue
Link to letter in reply. From the letter:
"The past few months have witnessed the Trump administration engage in the kidnapping of international graduate students from the streets, the deportation of innocent people to dangerous foreign prisons without due process, the cutting of lifesaving aid to millions across the world, and the undermining of the independence of colleges and universities across the country. We find these actions appalling, unethical, and undemocratic.
For these reasons, we believe it is deeply myopic for any academic to collaborate with the Trump administration in this moment, regardless of one’s particular views about gender. However misguided one may think “gender ideology” is, it is simply unconscionable to for that reason, make common cause with an administration so engaged."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
dearprofessorbyrne.wordpress.com
Shown below, the extraordinary prevalence of far left politics among grad students across the disciplines found by Nathan Honeycutt in his dissertation. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Re-upping this essay. It is a deep dive into whether DEI produced discrimination (it did) and whether its implementation was a conspiracy (it was) AND points out that conspiracy to deprive others of their civil rights is a felony.
Link and felony text in reply.
Academics routinely scream "fascism!" and "authoritarianism!" when they do not like Trump's policies. (One at UVA did so recently when the Trump admin pressured the UVA Pres to resign). -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Re-upping this essay. It is a deep dive into whether DEI produced discrimination (it did) and whether its implementation was a conspiracy (it was) AND points out that conspiracy to deprive others of their civil rights is a felony.
Link and felony text in reply.
Academics routinely scream "fascism!" and "authoritarianism!" when they do not like Trump's policies. (One at UVA did so recently when the Trump admin pressured the UVA Pres to resign).
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
REVERSAL! 3-experiment attempt to replicate famous study finding biases against hiring women in science not merely fails but finds bias against men.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post on our three experiment reversal of the massively cited and massively influential Moss-Racusin et al (2012) PNAS paper. With N=127, they found biases against women in science hiring.
Link in reply.
We used their methods nearly exactly, and with N>=1100, we found biases against men in STEM hiring. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Delusional Constitutionalism!
In honor of the recent SCOTUS decision banning lower courts from nationwide bans on executive/presidential policies, AND on the frequency with which academics with no training/expertise in Constitutional law scream about the "unconstitutionality" of Trump's various actions (typically, because they have been blocked by some judge!), I present to you:
Delusional Constitutionalism, from The Orwelexicon.
Link to Orwelexicon in reply. (I will have to update it, given all this...).
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Orwelexicon:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-new-expanded-illustrated… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Soft Cultural Revolution has failed. This is a very amusing yet uplifting comment on the resilience of American norms of freedom even after sustaining a ~10 yr assault by woke warriors.
Bethany S. Mandel
@bethanyshondark
Talk about a vibe shift. @AbigailShrier’s book went from black listed on Amazon to featured as a Kindle deal of the day.
a.co/d/d2GynxL -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
REVERSAL! 3-experiment attempt to replicate famous study finding biases against hiring women in science not merely fails but finds bias against men.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post on our three experiment reversal of the massively cited and massively influential Moss-Racusin et al (2012) PNAS paper. With N=127, they found biases against women in science hiring.
Link in reply.
We used their methods nearly exactly, and with N>=1100, we found biases against men in STEM hiring. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Of possible interest to:
@JohnHolbein1 @DegenRolf @CHSommers @lakens @SkepResCenter @SkepticReview89 (revenge: wwww & "bropenscience").
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post on our three experiment reversal of the massively cited and massively influential Moss-Racusin et al (2012) PNAS paper. With N=127, they found biases against women in science hiring.
Link in reply.
We used their methods nearly exactly, and with N>=1100, we found biases against men in STEM hiring. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Statement by founder of Wikipedia.
Larry Sanger
@lsanger
Wikipedia is so ironic. We wanted to give a voice to the voiceless, but what emerged was one of the most effective organs of Establishment propaganda in history.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post on our three experiment reversal of the massively cited and massively influential Moss-Racusin et al (2012) PNAS paper. With N=127, they found biases against women in science hiring.
Link in reply.
We used their methods nearly exactly, and with N>=1100, we found biases against men in STEM hiring.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/reversal-science-facultys-su…
Figure shows faculty believed the female student deserved a higher salary, even though her resume was identical to that of the male student (people only rated one applicant). -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I think I'll head out now and smoke a cigar.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is so interesting. I used to feel bad about street buskers, performing w/no guarantees, outdoors. And yet, I have also heard that they often make more doing that than at regular gigs.
Taylor Silverman
@tmsilverman
When I hear sob stories from wannabe victim onlyfans prostitutes who needed to “make ends meet” I think about being 22 and earning 200-500 an hour street performing 4-6 hours a week with a guitar I bought for less than 100 at a pawn shop and learned to play with tabs I printed out at the local library and I just don’t ever have much sympathy.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is indeed emblematic of why the Trump admin is reforming (or attacking, or both) science & academia. (I realize this is not "most" of what NIH funds, but it should not be funding any of this nonsense). Many believe extirpating this type of politicized absurdity is worth extensive collateral damage to worthy projects.
#wetriedtowarnyou -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Yes but...I doubt most will. That means change will come, if at all, by govt forcing change down universities' gullets. And that change, should it come (and it has already begun) will be far more damaging and draconian than anything U's would have done on their own.
The beatings will continue.
We tried to warn you. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
Luke Conway
@LGConwayIII
JOIBS is a model of good science. The more other journals imitate it, the better.
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Journal of Open Inquiry in the Behavioral Sciences has been doing this for 3 years. Glad to see Nature following our lead (I am editor in chief at JOIBS). JOIBS main site:
researchers.one/journals/joibs
Overview of JOIBS here:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-journal-of-open-inquiry-…
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Nature to start publishing peer review files automatically “to open up ‘black box’ of science.”
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01880-9
www.nbcnews.com/science/science-news/nature-looks-open-bl… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This sort of comment was very predictable. (ht @PTetlock).
Peter Wildeford🇺🇸🚀
@peterwildeford
Not much in forecasting annoys me more than "this was very predictable" from people who did not make any predictions about it before it happened.
I think you'll find that when you try to predict things *before* things happen, you're wrong a lot! It's easy to predict the past! -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The Journal of Open Inquiry in the Behavioral Sciences has been doing this for 3 years. Glad to see Nature following our lead (I am editor in chief at JOIBS). JOIBS main site:
researchers.one/journals/joibs
Overview of JOIBS here:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-journal-of-open-inquiry-…
Retraction Watch
@RetractionWatch
Nature to start publishing peer review files automatically “to open up ‘black box’ of science.”
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01880-9
www.nbcnews.com/science/science-news/nature-looks-open-bl… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
FYI.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
12 Things Everyone Should Know About the Psych of Victimhood. Banger of an essay, filled with multiple solid studies. Its not a pretty picture and it explains so much of what has gone wrong.
Steve Stewart-Williams
@SteveStuWill
Psychologists have identified a personality trait they call the Tendency for Interpersonal Victimhood. It reflects a chronic sense of being wronged, and includes four key components: Need for recognition; moral elitism; lack of empathy; and rumination
[Link below.] -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Nature pubs an editorial calling for "adversarial collaborations" -- teams of scientists who disagee on some topic, theoretical or political, working together to design&conduct studies testing their competing claims. I agree. And yet, for politicized disagreements on (social) scientific issues, this is now all but impossible within academia, because there are so few right-of-center researchers (which also has lots of other downside consequences, see my last tweet). The question is, who is going to solve this problem, and how?
www.nature.com/articles/d41586-025-01379-3 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"The only way science can succeed for generations is to win over the hearts and minds of the entire electorate, not just liberals...If we want bipartisan support, we need to become bipartisan.
So let’s change."
Article linked below.
Matt Grawitch
@DocGrawitch
MAGA Has a Point About Science. It's Time to Listen www.realclearscience.com/articles/2025/06/20/maga_has_a_p…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Influential book alleging there is no free will debunked, in part on grounds of citing debunked social psych studies:
"If it were really true that people were so easily manipulable by subliminal signals, then the world would be a much different place. Conversely, now that we know that that people aren’t so easily manipulated–you can’t really cause large shifts in people’s attitudes on immigration by flashing subliminal smiley faces on a screen–, this should cast doubt on the anti-free-will position."
Andrew Gelman et al.
@StatModeling
Junk science used to promote arguments against free will
statmodeling.stat.columbia.edu/2025/06/18/junk-science-us… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
A case of "less is more."
Jay Bhattacharya, MD, PhD
@NIHDirector_Jay
We’re working to remove ideological influence from science. NIH funding must be based on provable, testable hypotheses, not ideological narratives. Projects that don’t meet that bar are discontinued so we can focus on rigorous, impactful research. 🧵2/5
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is very amusing. #bluestasi
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Another example of why the govt beatings will continue.
Aaron Sibarium
@aaronsibarium
NEW: The Harvard Law Review axes 85% of pieces using a rubric that asks about "author diversity." It even axed a piece by an Asian scholar after editors complained that there were "not enough Black" authors.
We analyzed 500 new documents from HLR. What we found was shocking.🧵 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
This is exactly right. The broad abdication of responsibility for self-reform is what has produced the Trump backlash. Trumpian "reforms" will do vastly more damage than anything academia would have done itself. But academia is doing nothing to reform, except when directly pressured by govt.
Therefore, the beatings will continue.
Brandon Warmke
@BrandonWarmke
Ideally, universities would self reform. This is by far the most preferable option. But given the facts on the ground, it won't happen in our lifetimes:
~1/3rd of faculty don't want reform at all. Or worse, they want universities to be even more progressive and activist. They aren't changing how they hire, teach, or do research.
~1/3rd of faculty are checked out and don't care but have a vague sense that things are fine and will just follow the loudest and most unpleasant faculty to avoid conflict.
~1/3rd of faculty think some reform would be good but are too busy or afraid to do anything. Rational self interest means just letting things play out.
A small percentage of faculty want significant reform and have the courage to do something, but have precisely zero institutional power. They'll get outvoted every single time. They can make positive changes within their purview, but they aren't changing the direction of ship.
Administrators are, on average, more left-wing than faculty. And repeating "right wing talking points" would risk faculty revolt and demotion or firing.
HR staff certainly aren't interesting in giving up their entire careers for the betterment of higher ed.
So who are these angels doing the self-reform? And how? -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Excellent blog and tools. Unstated value: Checking one's own papers before submission!
For something similar, there is also the GRIM test, for checking whether the values reported (including yours and mine!) are actually impossible. Link to GRIM in reply.
Daniël Lakens
@lakens
New Papercheck blog: Automatically Checking Journal Article Reporting Standards. We demonstrate how Papercheck can flag inexactly reported p-values and missing effect sizes, and remind researchers to follow the APA JARS guidelines.
daniellakens.blogspot.com/2025/06/automatically-checking-…
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
GRIM test:
jamesheathers.medium.com/the-grim-test-a-method-for-evalu…
Shown: A "grim" example of impossible results reported in a classic early paper on cognitive dissonance. Impossible means, given other data in the table, circled in red. 5th grade math required to figure out why it is impossible. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Nice thread on nonsense in a 2008 stereotype threat article. Literal nonsense -- nonsensical results that are demonstrably nonsensical from the data as reported, strongly suggesting (and maybe more than suggesting) the data as reported should not be believed.
Russell T. Warne 🇺🇸🇨🇱
@Russwarne
🧵ANNOUNCEMENT:
Yesterday, I submitted a 2,400-word email to the editor of the @tandfpsychology journal Educational Psychology. In the email, I documented >60 anomalies and asked for a retraction.
Here are the problems I identified...👇 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Upon quick scroll, I read this as "opium foraging theory," and thought, "who knew?"
Will
@Evolving_Moloch
From the perspective of optimal foraging theory the relative rarity and infrequency of cannibalism not only across human societies but also across species is genuinely puzzling. So much easily accessible meat goes to waste. Must be evo psych reasons why it’s not more prevalent.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
File under, "Its Not Just Psychology."
Daniël Lakens
@lakens
New Replication Project in sport and exercise science shares it results: Out of 25 replication studies performed, 56% yielded significant results, but only 7 (28%) revealed a similar effect size. Several problems related to the quality of are discussed.
link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40279-025-02201-w -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
So this is (part of) what explains the appeal of Marxism, various critical social justice theories, and the Judith Butler School of Obtuse Language Use.
Nature Human Behaviour
@NatureHumBehav
How do laypeople make sense of scientific explanations? This new Article from @cruz_fcorreia & @tanialombrozo looks at the role of jargon. They find that people find explanations with jargon satisfying, even though jargon reduces understanding.
www.nature.com/articles/s41562-025-02227-0 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Mixed Bag Update on State of Psych Sci:
Huge review, open access, link in reply, 2004-present, >200k articles finds:
1. More articles w/stronger (lower) p-values
2. Stronger p-values more likely to be in prestigious journals.
3. More citations to articles w/low p-values.
That's the good news. And now, from the abstract:
4. "robust research is still not correspondingly linked to career success given that researchers at the highest ranked universities tend to publish articles with the weakest p values. Investigating language usage suggests that two-thirds of this association can be explained by highly ranked universities preferring laborious, expensive, and subtle research topics even though these generally produce weaker results."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
academia may be lost, but it is not utterly lost.
jobs.tufts.edu/jobs/21967?lang=en-us
"we will launch the Tufts Center for Expanding Viewpoints in Higher Education. Through a focus on rigorous research and education, the mission of the Center is to help universities nationwide deliver first-rate, non-ideological research, classroom instruction, and leadership training. By prioritizing a diversity of viewpoints, the Center will also inform public policy debates, particularly on politically sensitive and polarizing topics." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Who knew?
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
I cannot verify the firing, but everything about it sounds plausible, given what is known about how academia (fails to) work. The op ed is real:
www.wsj.com/opinion/santa-clara-universitys-crazy-idea-of…
Naomi Epps
@naomieppsbest
Blew the whistle in @WSJopinion on ideological rigidity in therapy training. A week later, I am fired from my internship with the regret of my boss. This field is in crisis. The public needs to know.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New post. "Now that their claim about the “robustness” of research on the benefits of diversity is knowably false, a reasonable, rational person who does not have the time to fact check every other claim in The Bethesda Declaration is likely to wonder, “Maybe the rest of it is true, but its kinda hard not to wonder what else is false or misleading?”
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply.
"Scientists should not be in the business of promoting demonstrably false claims to achieve political purposes." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Patihis essay linked below, on The recent Buckingham Conference on Post-Progressive Social Science. (He lists some of the great speakers in his 2nd tweet).
"The conference was fun like old-school psychology conferences used to be fun before left-wing authoritarians started insisting woke nonsense get added into professional organizations."
Lawrence Patihis
@lawrencepatihis
My latest article gives my reflections on a wonderful #heterodoxconference
Just a short summaries and insights, with many brilliant talks left out
lawrencepatihis.substack.com/p/reflections-on-the-heterod… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
From the essay:
"Like the containment dome over a nuclear reactor, Blu*sky serves the important safety purpose of ensuring that whatever meltdowns occur within produce minimal fallout. So while I’m not on Blu*sky, I value the platform, and I encourage its users to continue screaming at each other about how much the rest of us all suck. Please do not leave."
#bluestasi
Noah Smith 🐇🇺🇸🇺🇦🇹🇼
@Noahpinion
In which @jbarro is right about Blutarsky:
www.joshbarro.com/p/bluesky-isnt-a-bubble-its-a-containment -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post. Link in reply.
"Scientists should not be in the business of promoting demonstrably false claims to achieve political purposes."
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/nih-staff-revolt-promotes-pr…
"by doing this sort of thing, they unnecessarily fan the flames they are trying so desperately hard to put out." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim reposted
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The playbook: Deny.
When that fails, deflect.
When that fails, justify.
The Rabbit Hole
@TheRabbitHole
Most Liberals think the BLM Riots resulted in less than $10 million dollars in property damage.
Reality: The BLM Riots resulted in over $1 billion dollars in property damage. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
If you follow me, I urge you to follow this outfit. They are an outpost of social science hitting way above their weight in answering q's you won't find most social scientists even asking.
Skeptic Research Center Team
@SkepResCenter
While mainstream news journalists continue to call violent protests "mostly peaceful," trust in news journalism continues to decline.
Though individuals identifying as "very liberal" trust news coverage more than "moderates" or "conservatives," [1] trust overall has been declining for decades [2].
[1] research.skeptic.com/2024-presidential-election-study/
[2] news.gallup.com/poll/651977/americans-trust-media-remains… -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
The playbook: Deny.
When that fails, deflect.
When that fails, justify.
The Rabbit Hole
@TheRabbitHole
Most Liberals think the BLM Riots resulted in less than $10 million dollars in property damage.
Reality: The BLM Riots resulted in over $1 billion dollars in property damage. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
New Post.
"We warned you. This post documents the extent to which we warned you, over and over for at least 25 years. At the end, it presents over 50 references documenting the historical attempt of dissident academics to warn the rest of academia that this could come if they did not get their house in order. Now its here.
The Trump administration is crushing many of the norms of academia. Some might argue that it is crushing academia."
Link next tweet -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Alt view: it's just retreated to retrench. It's deeply embedded in academia, the font of most terrible ideas. & survey after survey shows large segments of the youth buy it hook, line, & sinker.
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Surveys consistently find that Americans exaggerate the positions held by the Party they DO NOT identify with. Dems exag Repub positions; Repubs exag Dem positions. Repubs exag Dems slightly more than Dems exag Repubs, but the kicker is, education does not help anyone and the more educ Dems have, the more they exaggerate.*
One excellent source:
perceptiongap.us
ht @BrandonWarmke
*No wonder its so bad in academia.
Perception gap in figure refers to exaggerating opposing Party members' positions. -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Mchangama is only one of a list of stars, including:
@jon_rauch
@Musa_alGharbi
@DrJBhattacharya
@glukianoff
@wil_da_beast630
and many more...This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Post not available here, view on X
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
unsafescience.substack.com/p/the-discrimination-paradox
"36% discrimination from the target’s standpoint results from acts of discrimination occurring only 1.8% of the time." -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Fits my experience. I try to exercise every day, only rarely failing (nice to have a day of rest here and there anyway). Even under deadlines. I work better. Played tennis this morning. Now time to get back to that paper with a deadline...
Clay Routledge
@clayroutledge
Action is at the core of our overall wellbeing. Mental stagnation and physical inactivity both hinder our overall health, impacting us psychologically and physically. www.flourishingfriday.blog/p/why-psychological-and-physic…
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
" liberal perceivers judged a conservative job candidate to be more prejudiced than a liberal candidate, whereas conservative perceivers saw no difference between the two candidates. This result is ironic given the level of prejudice exhibited by liberals in the present study."
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"the biggest benefit of a paid subscription is that you [help]...resist the extremist turn of academia and maintain islands of integrity in a sea of academic political corruption." How? I've dedicated the $ to projects, not my pockets.
unsafescience.substack.com/p/paid-subscription-option-20 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
"There is no indigenous astronomy. There is no Lebanese Jewish astronomy. There is just astronomy."
@GadSaad at Stanford Academic Freedom Conference -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Inside Higher Ed writer with English degree LOVES the study I just debunked (on supposed anti-minority biases in STEM).
IHE here:
www.insidehighered.com/news/2022/10/04/study-finds-intro-…
Debunking here:
unsafescience.substack.com/p/driving-minoritized-students…
Paper on the dangers of Epistemic Trespassing here:
philarchive.org/archive/BALET-2 -
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
U.S. academics (& 1 Canadian) wokesplain away American academic leftwing authoritarianism to ... an immigrant from The Soviet Union.
Immediate tell: Free speech is in scare quotes (but you should read the article, its a douzy).
#thisisacademianow
ht
@SocialImpurity
Alan Aspuru-Guzik
@A_Aspuru_Guzik
Led by John Herbert, I am part of a group of scientists that is responding to the recent work of Krylov et al. on the subject of academic "free speech." Check our position, and if you agree with it, please RT to amplify #realtimechem #inclusion #respect pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.jpclett.2c02242
-
The Dark Fiddling Pirate Jussim
@PsychRabble
Merit solves almost all of this tribal nonsense. Judge people on their merits (not their identities); judge ideas on their merits (not which side they are on); judge evidence on its merits, regardless of whose ox it gores. Doesn't elim all diffs, but makes everything less insane.






























































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































