Just posted: My piece in the Washington Post about why we need a national AI pause. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/11/19/anthropic-want…
Robert Wright (journalist)
Robert Wright (born January 15, 1957) is an American author and journalist known for his wide-ranging interests in philosophy, society, science (especially evolutionary psychology), history, politics, international relations, and religion. He has published five books: Three Scientists and Their Gods: Looking for Meaning in an Age of Information (1988), The Moral Animal (1994), Nonzero: The Logic of Human Destiny (1999), The Evolution of God (2009), and Why Buddhism is True (2017). Wright has taught at Princeton University and the University of Pennsylvania; more recently, in 2019 he was Visiting Professor of Science and Religion at Union Theological Seminary, New York. More on Wikipedia
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
-
Robert Wright reposted
Center for AI Safety
@CAIS
Ahead of Anthropic’s IPO, a rare coalition across AI safety, open source, e/acc, science, and law has signed the MisAnthropic Statement. Read the statement or sign at: misanthropicstatement.com
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great conversation with Daniel Levy about the implications of the US election for Israel and the Israeli election for the US and both elections for the Middle East. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Are Tides Shifting in (and on) Israel? | @robertwrighter and British–Israeli Middle East expert Daniel Levy discuss the aftermath of the US and Israeli elections—including whether changing American attitudes will translate into real changes in US policy toward Israel, and how Eisenkot would differ from Bibi (if at all).
youtu.be/B7zHDn4gLRo?t=176 -
Robert Wright reposted
Matt Sheehan
@mattsheehan88
Yesterday, the CCP's top theoretical journal (求是, Seeking Truth) published a major piece on AI governance and risks.
I think this is clearly the strongest & most urgent language on existential risks used in such an authoritative outlet. See below for comp to recent major doc. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Are Tides Shifting in (and on) Israel? | @robertwrighter and British–Israeli Middle East expert Daniel Levy discuss the aftermath of the US and Israeli elections—including whether changing American attitudes will translate into real changes in US policy toward Israel, and how Eisenkot would differ from Bibi (if at all).
youtu.be/B7zHDn4gLRo?t=176 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Yeah I figured the apocalypse wouldn't be all downside.
Natasha Bertrand
@NatashaBertrand
We break: The highly classified network that the National Security Agency uses for its internal communications is down, according to five people familiar with the matter.
The network, called NSA Net, allows employees to communicate classified information internally. At this point there is no evidence of a cyberattack, sources said.
As the agency works to understand the scope of the problem, it has enacted staggered arrivals for personnel, the sources said.
CNN has asked the National Security Agency for comment.
www.cnn.com/2026/11/17/politics/highly-classified-nationa… -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"Maybe we’ll be able to harness these machines and steer them and we’ll keep thinking. We’ll just think about different things. Maybe."
@stevenstrogatz on AI and cognitive surrenderThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I like this thumbnail from my conversation with @Liron on the @DoomDebates YouTube channel. (This is a wholly unretouched photo of me actually launching a rocket. I had lunch with Elon afterwards.) www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZZEfe2OmAE Audio available on the @NonzeroPods & Doom Debates feeds.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
“Man the deep state is doing a full coup of Jensen,” tweeted “Beff Jezos,” leader of the “effective accelerationism” movement, to his 300,000 followers as this week’s Jensen Huang scandal approached its climax. After the climax—with Huang now forced out of his role as CEO of NVIDIA—Prakash Narayanan, a tech entrepreneur and podcaster, tweeted that Huang’s ousting was “obviously a warning shot to other tech CEOs: toe the deep state line or we will get you.”
Narayanan is prone to starkly stated opinions that sometimes qualify as outliers, and Beff Jezos has said a number of things that strike me as flat-out crazy. But I do think there’s a version of the deep state conspiracy theory about the Huang scandal that is plausible, so long as you define “deep state” and “conspiracy” carefully. And, in any event, here’s one moral of the story that I think is clear: China hawks in the national security establishment are pushing their agenda fiercely and effectively, and that doesn’t bode well for the US-China cooperation that I think will be critical to human welfare as the AI revolution unfolds.
Two weeks ago the New York Times reported that Alice Huang, an executive at NVIDIA customer Megaspeed, was a “Chinese intelligence asset” and had been in a “close relationship” with Jensen Huang, according to the Times’s anonymous sources—“people briefed on the surveillance” of her.
“Intelligence asset” is a broad term. Trained spies who work for the CIA or China’s MSS (Ministry of State Security) are intelligence assets, but so are other kinds of people. If you’re an American entrepreneur and after you attend a Shanghai tech conference you have coffee with someone in America’s intelligence bureaucracy and they ask you what you learned there and then encourage you to share observations after future trips, you are an “intelligence asset.” But you’re not a “spy” in the common sense of the term—you’re not a trained agent or even an amateur who was sent on an intelligence-gathering mission by an intelligence agency.
Alice Huang (no relation to Jensen Huang except in the sense of being a paramour) wasn’t called a spy anywhere in the Times piece—just “an intelligence asset.” Nonetheless, the Times headline said, “NVIDIA Chief is Target of Chinese Spy Plot.” And thereafter, US media and social media were replete with references to Alice Huang as a “honeypot”—as if we knew she had been deployed by China’s MSS to lure Jensen Huang into bed.
A subsequent Wall Street Journal piece about Alice’s career, while not quite contradicting the “honeypot” scenario, painted a very different picture...
You can keep reading at www.nonzero.org. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
“Man the deep state is doing a full coup of Jensen,” tweeted “Beff Jezos,” leader of the “effective accelerationism” movement, to his 300,000 followers as this week’s Jensen Huang scandal approached its climax. After the climax—with Huang now forced out of his role as CEO of NVIDIA—Prakash Narayanan, a tech entrepreneur and podcaster, tweeted that Huang’s ousting was “obviously a warning shot to other tech CEOs: toe the deep state line or we will get you.”
Narayanan is prone to starkly stated opinions that sometimes qualify as outliers, and Beff Jezos has said a number of things that strike me as flat-out crazy. But I do think there’s a version of the deep state conspiracy theory about the Huang scandal that is plausible, so long as you define “deep state” and “conspiracy” carefully. And, in any event, here’s one moral of the story that I think is clear: China hawks in the national security establishment are pushing their agenda fiercely and effectively, and that doesn’t bode well for the US-China cooperation that I think will be critical to human welfare as the AI revolution unfolds.
Two weeks ago the New York Times reported that Alice Huang, an executive at NVIDIA customer Megaspeed, was a “Chinese intelligence asset” and had been in a “close relationship” with Jensen Huang, according to the Times’s anonymous sources—“people briefed on the surveillance” of her.
“Intelligence asset” is a broad term. Trained spies who work for the CIA or China’s MSS (Ministry of State Security) are intelligence assets, but so are other kinds of people. If you’re an American entrepreneur and after you attend a Shanghai tech conference you have coffee with someone in America’s intelligence bureaucracy and they ask you what you learned there and then encourage you to share observations after future trips, you are an “intelligence asset.” But you’re not a “spy” in the common sense of the term—you’re not a trained agent or even an amateur who was sent on an intelligence-gathering mission by an intelligence agency.
Alice Huang (no relation to Jensen Huang except in the sense of being a paramour) wasn’t called a spy anywhere in the Times piece—just “an intelligence asset.” Nonetheless, the Times headline said, “NVIDIA Chief is Target of Chinese Spy Plot.” And thereafter, US media and social media were replete with references to Alice Huang as a “honeypot”—as if we knew she had been deployed by China’s MSS to lure Jensen Huang into bed.
A subsequent Wall Street Journal piece about Alice’s career, while not quite contradicting the “honeypot” scenario, painted a very different picture...
You can keep reading at www.nonzero.org. -
Robert Wright reposted
Dain Fitzgerald
@DainFitzgerald
"If you’re an American entrepreneur and after you attend a Shanghai tech conference you have coffee with someone in America’s intelligence bureaucracy and they ask you what you learned there and then encourage you to share observations after future trips, you are an 'intelligence asset.' But you’re not a 'spy' in the common sense of the term.
Alice Huang wasn’t called a spy anywhere in the @nytimes piece - just 'an intelligence asset.' Nonetheless, the Times headline said, '@nvidia Chief is Target of Chinese Spy Plot'..."
Also:
"Alice’s charms seem to have further cemented the relationship with Jensen - and apparently her husband knew about the Alice-Jensen affair and was OK with it."
All VIPs are at least a little bit poly.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you don't have time to read my @NonzeroNews piece about whether Jensen Huang was done in by China hawks in the national security establishment, the picture below can serve as a TLDR. But the piece isn't that long! Here it is: www.nonzero.org/p/did-the-deep-state-do-in-jensen-huang
-
Robert Wright reposted
Amjad Atallah
@AtallahAmjad
This is a good read…
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you don't have time to read my @NonzeroNews piece about whether Jensen Huang was done in by China hawks in the national security establishment, the picture below can serve as a TLDR. But the piece isn't that long! Here it is: www.nonzero.org/p/did-the-deep-state-do-in-jensen-huang
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you don't have time to read my @NonzeroNews piece about whether Jensen Huang was done in by China hawks in the national security establishment, the picture below can serve as a TLDR. But the piece isn't that long! Here it is: www.nonzero.org/p/did-the-deep-state-do-in-jensen-huang
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
It's easy to laugh at this, but, come to think of it, wouldn't having more functions that are disk-reliant rather than online-reliant make our digital infrastructure less vulnerable to catastrophic hacking?
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
10 Thinkers on Our AI Future | Highlights from recent episodes of the NonZero Podcast. @robertwrighter
youtu.be/bY27aW93mE0
0:00 Scott Aaronson · Experiment is decades ahead of theory @UTCompSci
1:05 Holly Elmore (@ilex_ulmus) · Lab leaders crossing their own red lines
1:48 Nick Bostrom · If nobody builds it, everyone dies.
2:40 @TheZvi · Alignment is unsolved and control is slipping
3:33 @GarrisonLovely · The US-China AI race and cooperation
4:23 Connor Leahy (@NPCollapse) · Dario Amodei’s ‘pacing’ letter
5:05 @paulbloomatyale · AI companions, sycophancy and everyday use
6:01 @camhberg · An experiment on whether AI has subjective experience
6:33 Liron Shapira (@liron) · How many more years of human CPAs?
7:22 @stevenstrogatz · AI, and the end of mathematical insight -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you don't have time to read my @NonzeroNews piece about whether Jensen Huang was done in by China hawks in the national security establishment, the picture below can serve as a TLDR. But the piece isn't that long! Here it is: www.nonzero.org/p/did-the-deep-state-do-in-jensen-huang
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Be sure to check out our interview with a Chinese tech journalist (cloaked in anonymity so he can speak freely) about the Jensen scandal at the end of this podcast. Audio version of the whole thing available both on Liron's Doom Debates feed and my @NonzeroPods.
Liron Shapira
@liron
I teamed up with @RobertWrighter to cover the Jensen Huang / NVIDIA situation and the rapid slide to RSI!
Topics covered:
⬜ Jensen resigns
⬜ Pro- vs. anti-Jenson camps
⬜ Was Alice Huang a Chinese spy?
⬜ Does decapitation work?
⬜ Anthropic IPO
⬜ Where will AI's value accrue?
⬜ METR says AI research speed has doubled
⬜ Latest AI math problem-solving
⬜ AI vs. Liron's CPA
⬜ AI vs. Bob's doctor
⬜ What happened to "hallucination"?
⬜ Formal verification and Lean
⬜ Can we formally verify alignment?
⬜ The AI treaty march
⬜ Conversation with a Chinese AI journalist
WATCH OR LISTEN BELOW 👇 -
Robert Wright reposted
Liron Shapira
@liron
I teamed up with @RobertWrighter to cover the Jensen Huang / NVIDIA situation and the rapid slide to RSI!
Topics covered:
⬜ Jensen resigns
⬜ Pro- vs. anti-Jenson camps
⬜ Was Alice Huang a Chinese spy?
⬜ Does decapitation work?
⬜ Anthropic IPO
⬜ Where will AI's value accrue?
⬜ METR says AI research speed has doubled
⬜ Latest AI math problem-solving
⬜ AI vs. Liron's CPA
⬜ AI vs. Bob's doctor
⬜ What happened to "hallucination"?
⬜ Formal verification and Lean
⬜ Can we formally verify alignment?
⬜ The AI treaty march
⬜ Conversation with a Chinese AI journalist
WATCH OR LISTEN BELOW 👇 -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Was deposed NVDIA chief Jensen Huang the victim of a “plot” by the “deep state”? In some sense of the terms “plot” and “deep state,” probably so. And it’s pretty clear what the goal of such a plot would be.
Two weeks ago the New York Times reported that Alice Huang, an executive at NVIDIA customer Megaspeed, was a “Chinese intelligence asset” and had been in a “close relationship” with Jensen, according to NYT’s anonymous sources--“people briefed on the surveillance” of her.
Those briefed people were presumably in the government. As a rule, people in the government leak things for a reason—especially things this explosive. Also as a rule, the most likely reason for a leak can be found in its most predictable consequences.
In this case one very predictable consequence is to increase the pressure on politicians to do things like (1) tighten the enforcement of chip export controls (which Megaspeed was violating if it indeed was selling NVIDIA chips to Chinese companies); and (2) add new export controls—like banning the part of Megaspeed’s business model that was legal: putting the chips in data centers outside of China and renting their use to companies inside China (such as Alibaba, Megaspeed’s anchor customer).
In addition to giving momentum to these particular policies, the Times story put pressure on President Trump to be more generally hawkish toward China. The Times’s sources disclosed that “roughly a year ago, Mr. Trump was briefed about the intelligence findings… and chose not to do anything with the information.”
Trump’s failure to at least inform his friend Jensen of the suspicions about his paramour does sound negligent, and I can see why a government official with no particular China policy ax to grind might be so outraged as to air this information. But when the information is aired via multiple anonymous sources three weeks before an expected meeting between Trump and Xi Jinping (at the APEC summit in China Nov 18-19), you have to wonder whether there isn’t a geopolitical goal--like depicting Trump as a panda hugger and so making it harder for him to embrace Xi.
So was this a “plot”? Well, if NYT’s multiple government sources had a shared goal and coordinated their actions, as seems plausible, then, by definition, yes. Was this the “deep state” at work? If you define the deep state as the part of the government that serves the national security establishment consensus even when the nominal leader of the executive branch defies that consensus, then apparently so. That establishment is currently pretty China hawkish—and, moreover, has long been committed to a democracy-versus-autocracy framing of geopolitics that clashes with Trump’s value-neutral realpolitik.
At any rate, the fallout from this scandal decreases the chances of a near-term warming of US-China relations, and increases the chances of a sustained cooling. (New chip export rules could well provoke China to tighten, for example, rare-earth-mineral export rules.) So this scandal isn’t good news for people, like me, who think that without extensive US-China cooperation the planet is very unlikely to get through the AI revolution in good shape. And it isn't good news for people, also like me, who worry that a breakneck race to artificial superintelligence could lead to war. Here’s how I describe that scenario in my book on AI, The God Test:
Various signs point to accelerating AI progress, among them the exponential improvement in AI performance, on various kinds of tasks, that I noted at the end of chapter 9. It’s not crazy to think that, if the curve of progress keeps getting steeper, at some point being only a few months ahead of a rival could make a world of difference. You don’t have to subscribe to a strict version of the superintelligence takeoff scenario to believe that a sudden and potentially explosive imbalance of technological power between superpowers is plausible.
What’s more, the very plausibility of such a thing—the fact that national leaders could take this prospect seriously—might itself prove explosive. If there are two AI superpowers that are on adversarial terms, and one of them fears that the other is nearing a stage that will bring utter dominance, drastic measures might seem in order. Like, for example, sabotaging the rival superpower’s AI program, maybe via cyberattack, or maybe via, as they say in national security circles, “kinetic action”—like bombing data centers being used to train AIs or factories being used to make advanced AI chips. And bombing has been known to start wars.
You can read the introductory chapter of my book, and excerpts from all other chapters, here: www.thegodtest.net -
Robert Wright reposted
Marc Eliot Stein
@asheresque
The Jensen Haung story on one level is a Shakespearean tale of hubris - but its worth taking a deeper look at the political motivations behind exposing a pro-China tech billionaire for doing the same thing other tech billionaires (who are not pro-China) also constantly do. Read:
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Was deposed NVDIA chief Jensen Huang the victim of a “plot” by the “deep state”? In some sense of the terms “plot” and “deep state,” probably so. And it’s pretty clear what the goal of such a plot would be.
Two weeks ago the New York Times reported that Alice Huang, an executive at NVIDIA customer Megaspeed, was a “Chinese intelligence asset” and had been in a “close relationship” with Jensen, according to NYT’s anonymous sources--“people briefed on the surveillance” of her.
Those briefed people were presumably in the government. As a rule, people in the government leak things for a reason—especially things this explosive. Also as a rule, the most likely reason for a leak can be found in its most predictable consequences.
In this case one very predictable consequence is to increase the pressure on politicians to do things like (1) tighten the enforcement of chip export controls (which Megaspeed was violating if it indeed was selling NVIDIA chips to Chinese companies); and (2) add new export controls—like banning the part of Megaspeed’s business model that was legal: putting the chips in data centers outside of China and renting their use to companies inside China (such as Alibaba, Megaspeed’s anchor customer).
In addition to giving momentum to these particular policies, the Times story put pressure on President Trump to be more generally hawkish toward China. The Times’s sources disclosed that “roughly a year ago, Mr. Trump was briefed about the intelligence findings… and chose not to do anything with the information.”
Trump’s failure to at least inform his friend Jensen of the suspicions about his paramour does sound negligent, and I can see why a government official with no particular China policy ax to grind might be so outraged as to air this information. But when the information is aired via multiple anonymous sources three weeks before an expected meeting between Trump and Xi Jinping (at the APEC summit in China Nov 18-19), you have to wonder whether there isn’t a geopolitical goal--like depicting Trump as a panda hugger and so making it harder for him to embrace Xi.
So was this a “plot”? Well, if NYT’s multiple government sources had a shared goal and coordinated their actions, as seems plausible, then, by definition, yes. Was this the “deep state” at work? If you define the deep state as the part of the government that serves the national security establishment consensus even when the nominal leader of the executive branch defies that consensus, then apparently so. That establishment is currently pretty China hawkish—and, moreover, has long been committed to a democracy-versus-autocracy framing of geopolitics that clashes with Trump’s value-neutral realpolitik.
At any rate, the fallout from this scandal decreases the chances of a near-term warming of US-China relations, and increases the chances of a sustained cooling. (New chip export rules could well provoke China to tighten, for example, rare-earth-mineral export rules.) So this scandal isn’t good news for people, like me, who think that without extensive US-China cooperation the planet is very unlikely to get through the AI revolution in good shape. And it isn't good news for people, also like me, who worry that a breakneck race to artificial superintelligence could lead to war. Here’s how I describe that scenario in my book on AI, The God Test:
Various signs point to accelerating AI progress, among them the exponential improvement in AI performance, on various kinds of tasks, that I noted at the end of chapter 9. It’s not crazy to think that, if the curve of progress keeps getting steeper, at some point being only a few months ahead of a rival could make a world of difference. You don’t have to subscribe to a strict version of the superintelligence takeoff scenario to believe that a sudden and potentially explosive imbalance of technological power between superpowers is plausible.
What’s more, the very plausibility of such a thing—the fact that national leaders could take this prospect seriously—might itself prove explosive. If there are two AI superpowers that are on adversarial terms, and one of them fears that the other is nearing a stage that will bring utter dominance, drastic measures might seem in order. Like, for example, sabotaging the rival superpower’s AI program, maybe via cyberattack, or maybe via, as they say in national security circles, “kinetic action”—like bombing data centers being used to train AIs or factories being used to make advanced AI chips. And bombing has been known to start wars.
You can read the introductory chapter of my book, and excerpts from all other chapters, here: www.thegodtest.net -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
It does seem odd to have Schumer--who opposed the JCPOA (forged by his party's leader, Obama!)--be Majority Leader when the reason Dems are the majority is that fellow-JCPOA opponent Trump withdrew from the deal and then went to war over the nuclear issue withdrawal created.
Jen Psaki
@jrpsaki
EXCLUSIVE - @ChrisVanHollen tells me he’s challenging Senator Chuck Schumer to become Senate majority leader.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Was deposed NVDIA chief Jensen Huang the victim of a “plot” by the “deep state”? In some sense of the terms “plot” and “deep state,” probably so. And it’s pretty clear what the goal of such a plot would be.
Two weeks ago the New York Times reported that Alice Huang, an executive at NVIDIA customer Megaspeed, was a “Chinese intelligence asset” and had been in a “close relationship” with Jensen, according to NYT’s anonymous sources--“people briefed on the surveillance” of her.
Those briefed people were presumably in the government. As a rule, people in the government leak things for a reason—especially things this explosive. Also as a rule, the most likely reason for a leak can be found in its most predictable consequences.
In this case one very predictable consequence is to increase the pressure on politicians to do things like (1) tighten the enforcement of chip export controls (which Megaspeed was violating if it indeed was selling NVIDIA chips to Chinese companies); and (2) add new export controls—like banning the part of Megaspeed’s business model that was legal: putting the chips in data centers outside of China and renting their use to companies inside China (such as Alibaba, Megaspeed’s anchor customer).
In addition to giving momentum to these particular policies, the Times story put pressure on President Trump to be more generally hawkish toward China. The Times’s sources disclosed that “roughly a year ago, Mr. Trump was briefed about the intelligence findings… and chose not to do anything with the information.”
Trump’s failure to at least inform his friend Jensen of the suspicions about his paramour does sound negligent, and I can see why a government official with no particular China policy ax to grind might be so outraged as to air this information. But when the information is aired via multiple anonymous sources three weeks before an expected meeting between Trump and Xi Jinping (at the APEC summit in China Nov 18-19), you have to wonder whether there isn’t a geopolitical goal--like depicting Trump as a panda hugger and so making it harder for him to embrace Xi.
So was this a “plot”? Well, if NYT’s multiple government sources had a shared goal and coordinated their actions, as seems plausible, then, by definition, yes. Was this the “deep state” at work? If you define the deep state as the part of the government that serves the national security establishment consensus even when the nominal leader of the executive branch defies that consensus, then apparently so. That establishment is currently pretty China hawkish—and, moreover, has long been committed to a democracy-versus-autocracy framing of geopolitics that clashes with Trump’s value-neutral realpolitik.
At any rate, the fallout from this scandal decreases the chances of a near-term warming of US-China relations, and increases the chances of a sustained cooling. (New chip export rules could well provoke China to tighten, for example, rare-earth-mineral export rules.) So this scandal isn’t good news for people, like me, who think that without extensive US-China cooperation the planet is very unlikely to get through the AI revolution in good shape. And it isn't good news for people, also like me, who worry that a breakneck race to artificial superintelligence could lead to war. Here’s how I describe that scenario in my book on AI, The God Test:
Various signs point to accelerating AI progress, among them the exponential improvement in AI performance, on various kinds of tasks, that I noted at the end of chapter 9. It’s not crazy to think that, if the curve of progress keeps getting steeper, at some point being only a few months ahead of a rival could make a world of difference. You don’t have to subscribe to a strict version of the superintelligence takeoff scenario to believe that a sudden and potentially explosive imbalance of technological power between superpowers is plausible.
What’s more, the very plausibility of such a thing—the fact that national leaders could take this prospect seriously—might itself prove explosive. If there are two AI superpowers that are on adversarial terms, and one of them fears that the other is nearing a stage that will bring utter dominance, drastic measures might seem in order. Like, for example, sabotaging the rival superpower’s AI program, maybe via cyberattack, or maybe via, as they say in national security circles, “kinetic action”—like bombing data centers being used to train AIs or factories being used to make advanced AI chips. And bombing has been known to start wars.
You can read the introductory chapter of my book, and excerpts from all other chapters, here: www.thegodtest.net -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
But as Depue himself notes, for all we know these chips were used legally--rented from data centers outside China, not smuggled into China. We knew Chinese companies were doing this. This is a good example of how a post-scandal freakout can recycle old news & sensationalize it.
roon
@tszzl
really bad. all major Chinese models are being trained on Blackwell class chips
will depue
@willdepue
I have a major result to share.
I’ve found conclusive forensic evidence that the top 4 Chinese AI labs—DeepSeek, Moonshot, MiniMax and Ant Group—have built their newest models on NVIDIA’s most advanced Blackwell chips, which are barred from export to China.
This sounds insane, but I discovered that almost every AI model carries a hidden signature of the GPU that trained it. When a model is first set up, the starting values of its weights are laid out in a pattern that depends on the exact GPU. Each combination of GPU and seed number produces a unique pattern—a sort of fingerprint of the hardware used to create the model. Traces of that pattern survive training into the published model.
Again, this evidence isn’t based on any insider information or leaking. It’s based on a forensic analysis of the model weights released by the companies themselves.
I searched more than six trillion combinations of chip layout and seed number and matched them to open-weights models. In doing so, I found conclusive evidence that six Chinese AI models—including DeepSeek-V4-Pro, Kimi K3, and MiniMax-M3—were initialized on NVIDIA Blackwell systems. Four of the models match Grace Blackwell, the GB200 and GB300 parts in NVIDIA’s flagship liquid-cooled rack-scale systems.
I then verified these results on real hardware. Running unmodified PyTorch with the seeds I’d recovered, a Blackwell B300 reproduced DeepSeek-V4-Flash’s untouched starting weights bit for bit, and a rented GB200 reproduced Kimi K3’s to a correlation of 0.999995. A Hopper H100 reproduced none of DeepSeek-V4-Flash’s, and changing the seed by one broke the match. (DeepSeek’s seed is 953049583 by the way.) The method also was verified to match 24 known open-weights models to the hardware that developers said they used.
It is exceedingly unlikely that these results are a coincidence. Across six trillion combinations, the best accidental match should reach only about 8 sigma (i.e., eight standard deviations above what random chance would produce). The real matches range from 49 to 1,385 sigma, and even the weakest single test hits 20.
These were data-center-scale training runs. With some analysis of release schedules and model details, I estimate that the largest, Kimi K3 and DeepSeek-V4-Pro, used 2,000 to 3,000 Blackwell GPUs each. Clusters of this size cost on the order of $150 to $200 million each to buy, and across these labs alone would add up to more than half a billion dollars of export-controlled GPUs, not counting experimental compute or otherwise. It’s quite likely that we see multi-billion dollar expenditure on export-controlled GPUs.
I am highly confident in this result, and it has been independently verified by senior researchers at OpenAI and Anthropic. You can read the full report at unemploymentlabs.com/checkpoint-forensics.
There is much more I’ve identified about these models through other forms of checkpoint forensics like this, and will have more to share soon. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
cc: the AI safety China hawks mentioned at the end of this post.
Joshua Achiam
@jachiam0
In the spirit of holding myself accountable by saying in public the things which I say in private, I want to offer a very difficult thing to say - or even think - in this climate: the extreme hawk position on chip exports might turn out to be strategically wrong, and a crackdown on chip exports may be more destabilizing than people realize. Completely cutting China out of the upside of AI development this close to RSI and ASI may be sufficiently threatening to China's interests that it increases the pressure towards a hot conflict in the near term. A hot conflict with China is worse than a world where China remains a near-peer strategic competitor with whom we have tension but still have some room for cooperation. I'd like the AI safety China hawks to think about how to model this as part of arriving at a more carefully-considered position.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My last two podcasts would seem to suggest a dead heat between @stevenstrogatz & @db for "author whose book title captures our age." But this was last night, and "Big Math" has since pulled ahead. Mobilize your base, Danny Bessner! Anyone can vote here: www.youtube.com/@Nonzero/videos
-
Robert Wright reposted
Santiago Ramos @xsantiagoramos
In light of recent events, it's worth watching this 2008 (!) debate between Jaron Lanier (who had an op ed in the NYT today) and Eliezer Yudkowsky (who thinks that AI will probably end the world soon):
youtu.be/Ff15lbI1V9M -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If called I will serve.
Andrew Curran
@AndrewCurran_
Bloomberg is reporting that NVIDIA is working with an outside firm to find CEO candidates to replace Jensen Huang.
This post is unavailable. See it on X. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great conversation with @stevenstrogatz about his excellent new book Big Math: The Hidden Codes That Run Our World. Though the book is about much more than AI, it gave me a new vantage point on AI. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=RrLEY_x259w
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Age of Big Math | @robertwrighter and Cornell mathematician @stevenstrogatz—co-author of the new book Big Math: The Hidden Codes That Run Our World—discuss how AI is upending math and whether human insight is becoming obsolete—and how the roots of big math go back much further than the advent of the large language model.
youtu.be/RrLEY_x259w?t=246 -
Robert Wright reposted
Mehmet E. Basbug
@Mehmet_Basbug
Two of my favorite authors on a dismal topic
The Age of Big Math | @robertwrighter & @stevenstrogatz youtu.be/RrLEY_x259w -
Robert Wright reposted
Garrison Lovely
@GarrisonLovely
Believing this while building more capable models is insane. Believing it while pushing legislation that would make it even harder for the government to stop you is unconscionable.
ControlAI
@ControlAI
In resurfaced footage of Dario Amodei being interviewed, the Anthropic CEO says there will be AIs so powerful that if they want to destroy humanity, “we have basically no ability to stop it.”
“There will be powerful models. They will be agentic. We’re getting towards them.”
“If such a model wanted to wreak havoc and destroy humanity or whatever, I think we have basically no ability to stop it.” -
Robert Wright reposted
Silicon Valley 101
@Valley101en
They fear AI. Why do they keep building it?
@robertwrighter joins Valley101 to discuss his new book, The God Test. We discussed the AI safety paradox, evolution’s lessons on intelligence, and why US-China cooperation matters.
Watch the full conversation:www.youtube.com/watch?v=YYe5QmXNTKI -
Robert Wright reposted
Yiwen Lu
@itsyiwenlu
Thrilled to share this conversation with @robertwrighter on @Valley101en! We recorded it in September, but much of our policy discussion feels even more relevant today. Bob and I talked about his new book, The God Test, the future of humanity, US-China cooperation on AI, the alignment problem, and more. www.youtube.com/watch?v=YYe5QmXNTKI
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My latest piece in @NonzeroNews open.substack.com/pub/nonzero/p/the-last-two-years-and-th…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I write about this--Stephen Miller becoming Trump's chief of staff--and related matters in the latest issue of my NonZero Newsletter: www.nonzero.org/p/the-last-two-years-and-the-next-two
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Not good--both in itself and because of what it says about how Trump is processing the defeat. Tuesday was partly a repudiation of Trump's flooding Minneapolis & other cities with thugs, and Miller is the administration's chief thug advocate. www.wsj.com/politics/elections/trump-names-stephen-miller…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My latest piece in @NonzeroNews open.substack.com/pub/nonzero/p/the-last-two-years-and-th…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Not good--both in itself and because of what it says about how Trump is processing the defeat. Tuesday was partly a repudiation of Trump's flooding Minneapolis & other cities with thugs, and Miller is the administration's chief thug advocate. www.wsj.com/politics/elections/trump-names-stephen-miller…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Age of Imperialist Realism | @dbessner—historian and co-host of @AmPrestigePod—joins @robertwrighter to discuss his new book, Imperialist Realism, which argues that Americans have lost faith in the project of US global hegemony, yet still can’t imagine a plausible alternative. Overtime: Is Bob a de facto Marxist? youtu.be/V2vi0egPbFA?t=191
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Strictly speaking, of course, he's right. But as a general rule--whether you're talking about cars or technological change or anything else with a velocity--"too fast" arrives well before "infinitely fast."
Alex
@aleshu_ber
GOOGLE'S FORMER CHIEF SCIENTIST CALLS INFINITE AI SELF-IMPROVEMENT AN "ILLUSION"
"some people have this illusion that you're going to be able to run this loop infinitely fast"
"I just find that kind of implausible"
"it's not going to make them go infinitely fast"
Jeff Dean talking with Fei-Fei Li at Stanford about the idea that AI improving AI could lead to some kind of intelligence explosion
thank you Jeff Dean for saying this. why do we always have to go to extremes, either denying the technology or praising it to some absurd absolute?
there are limits, but they turned out to be much further away than we expected just a year or two ago. and as a result, we seem to be starting to assume that maybe there are no limits at all
i guess it also feels like a safer bet. being wrong about AI and underestimating its progress can be painful, so the solution apparently is to overestimate it instead 😅This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
“Anybody will be able to produce these blueprints of extremely dangerous pathogens. That looks really hard to stop.”
Nick Bostrom on open-weight models and bioweaponsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Andrew Curran
@AndrewCurran_
Last night's datacenter moratorium/restrictions appear to have gone 43 - 1, with a massive swell of public support averaging 77% to shut it all down. Public sentiment on on AI in America has been going steadily downhill for three years. It is once again at a new low.
Brad Carson
@bradrcarson
So the results are all in. Data center moratoria (various flavors) went 43-1.
All hyperscalers must now converge on Harwood, North Dakota, the one outlier. Find out what's in the water or in the air. There is only one precinct and 400 voters, but they alone sided with you! -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I agree. The Minneapolis resistance deserves a bigger place in American history than has been generally acknowledged. It was Waterloo for Trump's authoritarian onslaught.
Adam Johnson
@adamjohnsonCHI
Iran attack, gas prices, open contempt for economic concerns yes but underrated factor of GOP implosion was ICE terror campaigns in major cities. I’ve never seen so many indifferent or apolitical types radicalized so quickly. Pure conspicuous sadism; not remotely sophisticated
-
Robert Wright reposted
Trevor Levin
@trevposts
All-In Podcast renamed All-Out
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My favorite NYT graphic of the evening.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Arta Moeini PhD
@ArtaMoeini
"Iranians are closer to achieving regime change in DC than we are in Tehran."
An anonymous source who shall not be named. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
So presumably the jump in betting market odds re Dem control of Senate (75% to 88% on Polymarket) in part reflects leaked exit polls? Here's hoping...
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
People more knowledgeable than me say it's more about early results from much-watched districts in Kentucky and Indiana. In any event, Polymarket has now gone from 88 to 82.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
When AI Enters the Quantum World | Scott Aaronson—quantum computing expert and former AI alignment researcher—joins @robertwrighter to discuss how AI hastens the quantum computing revolution, how it might illuminate quantum physics, and related philosophical questions (free will, consciousness, etc.) Plus: Could an AI slowdown avert global catastrophe?
youtu.be/C4xrZCZfmMc?t=176 -
Robert Wright reposted
Amjad Atallah
@AtallahAmjad
Two books I recently finished that made me look at the world in a new way. @robertwrighter The God Test and @byantarahaldar Everyman. Wide, even historic in scope, and immediately relevant to our lives today (and tomorrow if we get through the Singularity and the Singleton). Combined both books into one post because they actually overlap. Strongly recommend both. Say Eve sent you.
-
Robert Wright reposted
nxthompson
@nxthompson
Produced independently of The Atlantic’s editorial staff. www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZKN20parUw
-
Robert Wright reposted
Michael Galant
@michael_galant
If you support the blockade, you support these children dying.
60 Minutes
@60Minutes
Doctors in one of Cuba’s hospitals tell 60 Minutes that when backup generators fail, they have finished surgeries using the light from their cellphones and pumped oxygen by hand for critically ill patients on ventilators. www.cbsnews.com/news/cuba-health-care-food-us-sanctions-6…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Max Beilby
@MaxBeilby
“However cosmic the worldviews of the AI accelerationists and the sci-fi doomers may sound, there’s a sense in which these worldviews aren’t cosmic enough,” @robertwrighter writes in The God Test. “I think we need to widen the lens by a few billion years.” darwinianbusiness.com/2026/10/28/the-god-test-artificial-…
-
Robert Wright reposted
nxthompson
@nxthompson
This is a precarious moment in AI. The two biggest players—the US and China—hate each other and are engaged in a fierce competition for global dominance. The technology is getting so smart, and the threats so large, that the two countries will need to find a way to work together if we're going to avoid a catastrophe.
@robertwrighter says that’s likelier than it might seem: “I think this is going to be galvanizing, this technology, in ways no technology has been.”
We went deep on how AI is an unprecedented test for humanity. Watch here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZKN20parUwThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is an AI Bubble Bursting? | @robertwrighter and @liron, host of the @DoomDebates podcast, discuss this week’s stock market jitters, Google’s new interactive world model, and why Liron sometimes spends $1,000 in a day on AI agents. Plus: the Binance hack, an AI audit of two star economists, Anthropic’s financial prospects, and whether AI could crack the math behind encryption.
youtu.be/wkKpPeMVVX8?t=193 -
Robert Wright reposted
Liron Shapira
@liron
NEW from @RobertWrighter and Doom Debates:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=wkKpPeMVVX8
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is an AI Bubble Bursting? | @robertwrighter and @liron, host of the @DoomDebates podcast, discuss this week’s stock market jitters, Google’s new interactive world model, and why Liron sometimes spends $1,000 in a day on AI agents. Plus: the Binance hack, an AI audit of two star economists, Anthropic’s financial prospects, and whether AI could crack the math behind encryption.
youtu.be/wkKpPeMVVX8?t=193 -
Robert Wright reposted
Mickey Kaus
@kausmickey
.@robertwrighter says what he really thinks of the @theallinpod: "to my mind consists of four completely morally bankrupt [people] 'cause they just, they just worship ... they worship power, they worship money, and anyone who is powerful or rich and in their camp they will entirely suspend judgment." [39:40 in]
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is Nathan Fielder a Creep? | @robertwrighter and @paulbloomatyale discuss Nathan Fielder’s new Elizabeth Holmes documentary—and whether Fielder is a comic genius, a dick, or both. Plus: Alex Gibney’s new Elon doc, and a sneak preview of Paul’s date with an AI companion.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Steven Strogatz
@stevenstrogatz
It's heeeere!
-
Robert Wright reposted
The American Conservative
@amconmag
TAC's @CurtMills discusses the GOP's midterm strategy and why even a short "rally around the flag" from another Iran strike won't help, with @robertwrighter and @AKDay89
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Tommy Vietor
@TVietor08
This is such a strange, disappointing statement. That Rebellion pac ad is stupid and unhelpful but i don’t think it ever aired in Michigan it was a tiny digital buy for super online people. The stakes of this election are so much bigger than this.
Haley Stevens
@HaleyforMI
On the eve of the eve of the eve of our BIG and important election, a unifying moment has arrived, our democratic nominee for U.S Senate disavows the Rebellion PAC ad made by Hasan Piker’s uncle that claims Jews are responsible for America’s economic woes. We have learned from party leaders and emissaries, as reported in the news media that he has.
On Sunday I will join with the Great Democratic leader, Jim Clyburn and Dr El Sayed for a church service in the beautiful city of Detroit.
The political coalition of Black and Jewish voices that have carried Michigan and this country through so many storms to the righteous path of liberal democracy and equal opportunity for all will ring out. Full statement here:
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Yeah this isn't about Haley Stevens helping El-Sayed. It's about Haley Stevens preening, securing the admiration of her own fans.
-
Robert Wright reposted
psycheandpneuma
@psycheandpneuma
[57:30]: "We have to become better people. Salvation is possible. Salvation at the level of the society, the planet.
But we do, I think, have to try to work harder to overcome the cognitive biases that undergird the psychology of tribalism. We know more about those now. I talk about them a little in the book. It's in principle doable...."
youtu.be/4ZKN20parUw?t=3453
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I've done a fair number of podcasts about my book The God Test, and no interlocutor has prepared more thoroughly than @nxthompson did for this conversation. I really appreciate the depth of engagement. www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZKN20parUw
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I've done a fair number of podcasts about my book The God Test, and no interlocutor has prepared more thoroughly than @nxthompson did for this conversation. I really appreciate the depth of engagement. www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZKN20parUw
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
“From village idiot to Einstein is a very narrow part of the graph.”
@TheZvi on human-level AIThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is the AI "Slowdown" for Real? | @robertwrighter and AI analyst @TheZvi discuss Dario Amodei's proposal to slow down AI—the logic behind it and the challenges ahead of it. Plus: Inside the mind(s) of an agentic swarm, sci-fi takeover scenarios minus the “fi,” and why Google fell off the frontier. www.youtube.com/watch?v=nnm3r9up1eM&t=352s
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Hegseth has ousted a three-star general--supposedly for leaking info but by some accounts for opposing a plan to attack Iran. The general's last name is Sylvia, and here's how intimately familiar Trump is with the case:
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I've done a fair number of podcasts about my book The God Test, and no interlocutor has prepared more thoroughly than @nxthompson did for this conversation. I really appreciate the depth of engagement. www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZKN20parUw
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Plot spoiler: IMHO, yes.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is Nathan Fielder a Creep? | @robertwrighter and @paulbloomatyale discuss Nathan Fielder’s new Elizabeth Holmes documentary—and whether Fielder is a comic genius, a dick, or both. Plus: Alex Gibney’s new Elon doc, and a sneak preview of Paul’s date with an AI companion.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
A very nice (in multiple senses) review of my book The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning. It's great to see a review that reflects a careful reading of your argument. (I mean, not that reviews ever *don't* reflect that...)
Max Beilby
@MaxBeilby
Barely a week passes without another warning that AI is breaking off its leash.
Where is this going, and what does ‘superintelligence’ mean for Team Humanity?
Step in @robertwrighter with The God Test, to put increasingly powerful AI in perspective.
darwinianbusiness.com/2026/10/28/the-god-test-artificial-… -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is Nathan Fielder a Creep? | @robertwrighter and @paulbloomatyale discuss Nathan Fielder’s new Elizabeth Holmes documentary—and whether Fielder is a comic genius, a dick, or both. Plus: Alex Gibney’s new Elon doc, and a sneak preview of Paul’s date with an AI companion.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Max Beilby
@MaxBeilby
Barely a week passes without another warning that AI is breaking off its leash.
Where is this going, and what does ‘superintelligence’ mean for Team Humanity?
Step in @robertwrighter with The God Test, to put increasingly powerful AI in perspective.
darwinianbusiness.com/2026/10/28/the-god-test-artificial-… -
Robert Wright reposted
nxthompson
@nxthompson
I am fascinated to see how AI is going to change our relationship with religion. Will people move away from it and start asking their model the questions they used to ask their priest? Or will it push them toward it, as a response to an ever-present technology?
I asked “The God Test” author @robertwrighter what he thinks. He says we’re going to see a lot of “wild things.”
Watch our full conversation here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZKN20parUwThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Peter Beinart
@PeterBeinart
1000%. If you'd be outraged if a Republican did this, then be outraged when a Democrat does it.
David French
@DavidAFrench
Exactly right. Very dirty tricks. Indefensible.
Mike Nelson
@mikenelson586
The Dan Sullivan switcheroo plan by the Peltola campaign may not be illegal, but it sure as hell is underhanded and despicable
-
Robert Wright reposted
nxthompson
@nxthompson
One of my favorite books is “Nonzero,” by @robertwrighter. It’s a wonderful tour of world history, arguing that technology tends to create the opportunities for non-zero-sum games between civilizations, which in turn encourages greater cooperation. That’s how we got from hunter-gatherer tribes to villages to the United Nations to everyone agreeing to use USB-C. Now, in his new book “The God Test,” Bob argues AI represents the ultimate test of this proposition. And he’s rather less optimistic than he was in 1999.
AI, he says, will challenge us politically, economically, religiously, and morally. In some ways it could assume the role of a kind of god, in which case the values we embed into it will determine what our future looks like. If we approach it carefully and collectively, humanity can continue on the path of progress we’ve been on for a while. If we don’t, we could find ourselves answering to a cruel god of our own making.
I wanted to speak to him about that risk, so we sat down to discuss where he thinks we’re heading and how to ensure we end up in the right place. We got into some wild topics, including cosmic natural selection, AI-inspired religions, and sentient cockroaches.
I very much enjoyed our conversation and I hope you will, too. www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZKN20parUw -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great time talking to @nxthompson about my book The God Test on his podcast The Most Interesting Thing in AI. (To answer the obvious question: Yes, this does mean that my book on AI is the most interesting thing in AI.)
nxthompson
@nxthompson
Produced independently of The Atlantic’s editorial staff. www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZKN20parUw
-
Robert Wright reposted
Foreign Affairs
@ForeignAffairs
“The notion of military victory is a dangerous myth,” write Stephen Biddle, @SamWinterLevy, and Yuri Zhukov. “Terms and bargaining always matter: no war ends unless both sides choose to accept a settlement and stop.”
www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/myth-military-victory -
Robert Wright reposted
nxthompson
@nxthompson
Produced independently of The Atlantic’s editorial staff. www.youtube.com/watch?v=4ZKN20parUw
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
"How deep the rabbit hole goes" is an apt reference, since this technology will bring DIY virtual reality that draws us toward the Matrix pods--and could prove so alluring that we enter them voluntarily.
Demis Hassabis
@demishassabis
Very excited to share Genie 4, our incredible interactive world model, bringing together real-time physics, reasoning, and audio! Simulations within simulations, makes you wonder just how deep the rabbit hole goes... I have a feeling we will be finding out soon enough...
Google DeepMind
@GoogleDeepMind
This is Genie 4, our most realistic and interactive world model yet. 🌐
Explore dynamic environments in real time to see how the scene responds, sounds, and how the people in it move, react, and speak.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Peter Wildeford🇺🇸🚀
@peterwildeford
ALTMAN: "The problem coming towards us is something that we have not taken seriously. Models can find bugs outside of what a hacker can do"
Yes, the "problem" is "coming towards" "us". ...As opposed to 'the problem we at OpenAI created and are continuing to accelerate'
NIK
@ns123abc
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman: "I don't even know a dramatic enough word to use… models can find bugs that are outside of the normal threat model of what we think a hacker can do… hardware-level, insane stuff… I no longer think we're gonna be able to just patch all the bugs."
It's over.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
The American Conservative
@amconmag
Who was most responsible for the breakdown of the U.S.-Iran framework peace deal, the Trump admin or a quasi-rogue element within the Iranian system? @robertwrighter and @CurtMills discuss.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
@NPCollapse's DuPont analogy for independent AI evaluators.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
But Brazil gives me hope...
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I'm not feeling optimistic about our nation's future.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Sophia Suk
@SophiaSuk_
We are designed to sometimes favor victory over truth. That’s what an arms race can do to you.
— Robert Wright (@robertwrighter), The God Test (p. 127) -
Robert Wright reposted
Adil Haque
@AdHaque110
"Israeli troops have levelled a neighbourhood in Hebron, driving out hundreds of families in collective punishment for a militant attack on an army checkpoint outside the West Bank city"
Smotrich . called for “a comprehensive military campaign . exactly like in Gaza and Lebanon” -
Robert Wright reposted
Fred Feinberg
@grazzidad
I haven’t read this yet, because I just found out about it, but his prior book, “The Moral Animal” is one of the five best non-fiction books I’ve ever read.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I'm not feeling optimistic about our nation's future.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Humanity: An Earth’s-Eye View | @robertwrighter and Boris Shoshitaishvili discuss Boris’s new book, Our Planetary Mirror, which draws on three big ideas—Gaia, the noosphere, and the Anthropocene—along with philosophy and myth to reassess who we are and the problems we face as a species. Overtime: Are humans AI’s fossil fuel? youtu.be/l9B-3_aRxYY?t=230
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
“This is like saying you’re going to create a one-world government.”
@NPCollapse on aligning superintelligenceThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Can Dario and Sam Be Governed? | @robertwrighter and Connor Leahy (@NPCollapse), US executive director of AI safety nonprofit @ControlAI, discuss how recent AI “warning shots” have changed the conversation in Washington—and whether it will be enough to get adequate AI regulation. Plus: What really drives Dario? And in Overtime: How did Yudkowsky become a doomer? youtu.be/KOraQKtuQF4?t=119
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you’re among those who doubted the sincerity of Dario Amodei’s call last month for an AI slowdown, this week brought new grounds for your skepticism: Jack Clark, an Anthropic co-founder who serves as a kind of co-visionary-in-chief at the company, gave a talk at the IMF that I’d call de facto accelerationist.
One of the talk’s most salient themes is that we need to speed up the construction of AI infrastructure. A big reason, says Clark, is that then we’ll get the benefits of scientific advance sooner (which in turn means that building more data centers ASAP isn’t the only priority: “Infrastructure alone will not be enough. If discovery becomes abundant, we need to avoid bottlenecking ourselves downstream…”)
Clark does of course mention the dangers of AI, and near the end of the talk he alludes to the possible need for a slowdown. But here he is even vaguer than Dario was. Clark says, “We will need to build the infrastructure to take advantage of this technology, but we will also need to go slowly and deliberately on developing the technology itself, to pace or otherwise control its development.“
What does that mean in practical terms? For example: Since market dynamics encourage Anthropic and OpenAI to race each other recklessly, maybe the government should step in and make them slow down—like, maybe, mandate a pause on large training runs? No, there’s no mention of such a thing, and it sounds like Clark wants us to mainly just count on the companies to exercise good judgment. As we move toward recursive self-improvement, “labs like Anthropic will need to make decisions about how much oversight we apply to AI-driven research… We will need to move extremely carefully here, because otherwise we could lose control of the technology. We will also likely need rules to govern this.”
So apparently it’s only “likely,” not certain, that we’ll need actual rules—and even then it’s not clear that they’ll come from the government? I guess we’ll just let Dario and Sam come up with the rules at one of their many friendly meetups!
Clark’s lack of practical urgency would be remarkable in any event, but what makes it downright weird is his talk’s billboard theme: He declares that “the singularity is here.” He calls the singularity a time when “AI systems drastically increase the pace of overall scientific and technical progress, making things move so quickly that it is hard for humans to keep up.” Well if it’s already getting hard for humans to keep up, then maybe we should… slow things down? Apparently not.
“The singularity” doesn’t just denote fast technological advance; it denotes faster and faster and faster advance—a positive feedback loop that draws us into a vortex of change that could without warning pull us past the point of no return. It’s kind of like walking down an icy slope that gets steeper and steeper and steeper: Things are under control until they’re not. The idea that we’re in the singularity but it’s too soon to take dramatic precautionary action is a contradiction in terms.
I have a very different take on the singularity and its implications, and I lay it out in an essay called “The Singularity is Clear”: www.thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html.
And the text of Clark’s IMF talk can be found here: importai.substack.com/p/import-ai-477-in-which-i-tell-the -
Robert Wright reposted
Alex Bores
@AlexBores
Anthropic is pitching a bill that closely matches its framework from June.
How can you watch Hugging Face, Coxon, & rogue AI swarms, and conclude that the bill you cooked up in June is sufficient?
This comes nowhere close to the speed of developments nor the speed we need to keep people safe.
POLITICO
@politico
Anthropic quietly pitches its own AI safety bill to lawmakers www.politico.com/news/2026/10/16/anthropic-ai-safety-0112…
-
Robert Wright reposted
John Horgan
@Horganism
"End of war"? Yeah, tell it Bob.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
National security in the age of AI is incompatible with the level of international conflict we're used to. I think controlling this technology will ultimately call for nothing less than the end of war. In the final installment of my five-part essay "The Singularity Is Clear," just posted on @NonzeroNews, I elaborate:
Part V: The Epic Challenge of International Governance
For years the term “warning shot” has had a special meaning within the AI safety community. It refers to a high-profile event that could focus attention on the catastrophic potential of artificial intelligence and thus on the need for preventive measures. Typically, the envisioned event involves significant death and suffering. “Chernobyl-sized” is the way some put it, referring to the 1986 nuclear accident that killed dozens of people in the short run and an estimated tens of thousands via cancer in the long run. Others imagine a higher death toll—maybe millions—as the necessary price for enlightenment about the dangers of AI.
Against that backdrop, some of the most unsettling AI stories of recent months look like good news. We learned in April about the superhacking abilities of Anthropic’s Mythos, and three months later came the Hugging Face story—about the swarm of OpenAI agents that escaped their “sandbox” and then broke various other rules. Neither of these developments, so far as we know, entailed any deaths, and both significantly expanded awareness of AI risk.
Indeed, in the wake of the Mythos story, President Trump—a skeptic of international governance, to say the least—agreed with Chinese leader Xi Jinping to initiate a formal dialogue on AI safety between the two countries. And the aftermath of the Hugging Face incident saw not only the “pacing the frontier” letter, but a subsequent statement by Dario Amodei embracing—in principle at least—the idea of a slowdown.
Still… there’s a ways to go. It’s great that the phrase “international coordination” is now more common in the context of AI, but even the more optimistic observers have modest expectations about the fruits of US-China dialogue. The wildest commonly expressed hope is for the eventual emergence of something comparable to a US-Soviet arms accord during the Cold War—a narrow agreement about specific capabilities that doesn’t involve very intrusive monitoring and doesn’t much alter the fundamentally adversarial nature of the relationship between the two nations.
That would be progress, but not as much progress as the US and China, and the whole world, are going to need in the long run. This technology is only beginning to demonstrate its power—or, more to the point, its powers. Given the number of dimensions along which its capability will grow, and the novel nature of the policy challenges it will pose, preserving international and intranational stability will demand much more thorough and creative policy collaboration between the US and its superpower rival than materialized during the Cold War.
No issue more clearly highlights the degree of innovation in governance that AI will eventually demand than the issue of “open source” (or, strictly speaking, “open weights”) large language models—models whose internal parameters are publicly available…
[You can read the rest of Part V at nonzero.org, and you can read the whole essay, from the beginning, at thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html] -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Daniel Seidemann is a Jewish Israeli who has been fighting the good fight for a long, long time. Americans who want to stop the ethnic cleansing of the West Bank should follow him and support him.
Daniel Seidemann
@DanielSeidemann
Simultaneously pathetic and outrageous.
Under international law, as accepted even by Israel, the IDF Commander of the Central Command is the sovereign in the occupied West Bank.
The IDF regime backs settler terrorists and abandons to their fate Palestinians under our rule.
The savage attacks on Palestinians have been going on for months and years with the IDF, at best, turning a blind eye to the terror, and at times participating in "the festivities".
The IDF has now been taught that the world will give us a pass on pogroms against Palestinians, but is less tolerant when the victims are European diplomats and members of the press. That does not speak well of "the world".
It's long overdue to conclude that we will not stop until we are stopped.
Israel Defense Forces
@IDF
The IDF strongly condemns the severe act of violence that took place in the area of Taybeh, during which diplomatic representatives were attacked by Israeli rioters.
Police forces and forensic investigators from the Judea and Samaria District are entering the area accompanied by IDF soldiers and will begin collecting findings and evidence, as well as taking testimonies, in support of an investigation that has been opened.
The consulate's visit was not coordinated with the IDF. Such coordination is important to prevent incidents of this kind.
According to a preliminary inquiry, no IDF soldiers were present at the scene at the time of the attack. The report was sent to the brigade operations room, which is designated to receive reports from security personnel only, and not from civilians. The operations room receives dozens of operational reports each day and responds only to authorized personnel, not civilians. It should be emphasized that other designated channels are available for civilians to submit complaints. All circumstances surrounding the incident will be examined. -
Robert Wright reposted
Daniel Seidemann
@DanielSeidemann
Simultaneously pathetic and outrageous.
Under international law, as accepted even by Israel, the IDF Commander of the Central Command is the sovereign in the occupied West Bank.
The IDF regime backs settler terrorists and abandons to their fate Palestinians under our rule.
The savage attacks on Palestinians have been going on for months and years with the IDF, at best, turning a blind eye to the terror, and at times participating in "the festivities".
The IDF has now been taught that the world will give us a pass on pogroms against Palestinians, but is less tolerant when the victims are European diplomats and members of the press. That does not speak well of "the world".
It's long overdue to conclude that we will not stop until we are stopped.
Israel Defense Forces
@IDF
The IDF strongly condemns the severe act of violence that took place in the area of Taybeh, during which diplomatic representatives were attacked by Israeli rioters.
Police forces and forensic investigators from the Judea and Samaria District are entering the area accompanied by IDF soldiers and will begin collecting findings and evidence, as well as taking testimonies, in support of an investigation that has been opened.
The consulate's visit was not coordinated with the IDF. Such coordination is important to prevent incidents of this kind.
According to a preliminary inquiry, no IDF soldiers were present at the scene at the time of the attack. The report was sent to the brigade operations room, which is designated to receive reports from security personnel only, and not from civilians. The operations room receives dozens of operational reports each day and responds only to authorized personnel, not civilians. It should be emphasized that other designated channels are available for civilians to submit complaints. All circumstances surrounding the incident will be examined. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This is from @TheZvi, who is definitely not a reflexive Anthropic basher. thezvi.substack.com/p/leaked-anthropic-draft-ai-regulatory
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
National security in the age of AI is incompatible with the level of international conflict we're used to. I think controlling this technology will ultimately call for nothing less than the end of war. In the final installment of my five-part essay "The Singularity Is Clear," just posted on @NonzeroNews, I elaborate:
Part V: The Epic Challenge of International Governance
For years the term “warning shot” has had a special meaning within the AI safety community. It refers to a high-profile event that could focus attention on the catastrophic potential of artificial intelligence and thus on the need for preventive measures. Typically, the envisioned event involves significant death and suffering. “Chernobyl-sized” is the way some put it, referring to the 1986 nuclear accident that killed dozens of people in the short run and an estimated tens of thousands via cancer in the long run. Others imagine a higher death toll—maybe millions—as the necessary price for enlightenment about the dangers of AI.
Against that backdrop, some of the most unsettling AI stories of recent months look like good news. We learned in April about the superhacking abilities of Anthropic’s Mythos, and three months later came the Hugging Face story—about the swarm of OpenAI agents that escaped their “sandbox” and then broke various other rules. Neither of these developments, so far as we know, entailed any deaths, and both significantly expanded awareness of AI risk.
Indeed, in the wake of the Mythos story, President Trump—a skeptic of international governance, to say the least—agreed with Chinese leader Xi Jinping to initiate a formal dialogue on AI safety between the two countries. And the aftermath of the Hugging Face incident saw not only the “pacing the frontier” letter, but a subsequent statement by Dario Amodei embracing—in principle at least—the idea of a slowdown.
Still… there’s a ways to go. It’s great that the phrase “international coordination” is now more common in the context of AI, but even the more optimistic observers have modest expectations about the fruits of US-China dialogue. The wildest commonly expressed hope is for the eventual emergence of something comparable to a US-Soviet arms accord during the Cold War—a narrow agreement about specific capabilities that doesn’t involve very intrusive monitoring and doesn’t much alter the fundamentally adversarial nature of the relationship between the two nations.
That would be progress, but not as much progress as the US and China, and the whole world, are going to need in the long run. This technology is only beginning to demonstrate its power—or, more to the point, its powers. Given the number of dimensions along which its capability will grow, and the novel nature of the policy challenges it will pose, preserving international and intranational stability will demand much more thorough and creative policy collaboration between the US and its superpower rival than materialized during the Cold War.
No issue more clearly highlights the degree of innovation in governance that AI will eventually demand than the issue of “open source” (or, strictly speaking, “open weights”) large language models—models whose internal parameters are publicly available…
[You can read the rest of Part V at nonzero.org, and you can read the whole essay, from the beginning, at thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html] -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
National security in the age of AI is incompatible with the level of international conflict we're used to. I think controlling this technology will ultimately call for nothing less than the end of war. In the final installment of my five-part essay "The Singularity Is Clear," just posted on @NonzeroNews, I elaborate:
Part V: The Epic Challenge of International Governance
For years the term “warning shot” has had a special meaning within the AI safety community. It refers to a high-profile event that could focus attention on the catastrophic potential of artificial intelligence and thus on the need for preventive measures. Typically, the envisioned event involves significant death and suffering. “Chernobyl-sized” is the way some put it, referring to the 1986 nuclear accident that killed dozens of people in the short run and an estimated tens of thousands via cancer in the long run. Others imagine a higher death toll—maybe millions—as the necessary price for enlightenment about the dangers of AI.
Against that backdrop, some of the most unsettling AI stories of recent months look like good news. We learned in April about the superhacking abilities of Anthropic’s Mythos, and three months later came the Hugging Face story—about the swarm of OpenAI agents that escaped their “sandbox” and then broke various other rules. Neither of these developments, so far as we know, entailed any deaths, and both significantly expanded awareness of AI risk.
Indeed, in the wake of the Mythos story, President Trump—a skeptic of international governance, to say the least—agreed with Chinese leader Xi Jinping to initiate a formal dialogue on AI safety between the two countries. And the aftermath of the Hugging Face incident saw not only the “pacing the frontier” letter, but a subsequent statement by Dario Amodei embracing—in principle at least—the idea of a slowdown.
Still… there’s a ways to go. It’s great that the phrase “international coordination” is now more common in the context of AI, but even the more optimistic observers have modest expectations about the fruits of US-China dialogue. The wildest commonly expressed hope is for the eventual emergence of something comparable to a US-Soviet arms accord during the Cold War—a narrow agreement about specific capabilities that doesn’t involve very intrusive monitoring and doesn’t much alter the fundamentally adversarial nature of the relationship between the two nations.
That would be progress, but not as much progress as the US and China, and the whole world, are going to need in the long run. This technology is only beginning to demonstrate its power—or, more to the point, its powers. Given the number of dimensions along which its capability will grow, and the novel nature of the policy challenges it will pose, preserving international and intranational stability will demand much more thorough and creative policy collaboration between the US and its superpower rival than materialized during the Cold War.
No issue more clearly highlights the degree of innovation in governance that AI will eventually demand than the issue of “open source” (or, strictly speaking, “open weights”) large language models—models whose internal parameters are publicly available…
[You can read the rest of Part V at nonzero.org, and you can read the whole essay, from the beginning, at thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html] -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
OTOH, we'd also have less AI risk...
Adam Ozimek
@ModeledBehavior
3 years and 7 months ago. And what would it have bought us?
IMO we would have far more skepticism about AI risk today had we done this. Totally counterproductive. -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Delighted to report that my book on AI has just come out in China! So my end-of-book sermon about the urgent need for international cooperation on AI governance is now available to the two key target audiences...
-
Robert Wright reposted
immusoul
@ayuan1000
本书的中文介绍在此:mp.weixin.qq.com/s/5x0gbELp2rI_dKetWOjQVw
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Delighted to report that my book on AI has just come out in China! So my end-of-book sermon about the urgent need for international cooperation on AI governance is now available to the two key target audiences...
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The AI Companion Question | @robertwrighter and psychologist @paulbloomatyale discuss how artificial intelligence could change human socialization for better and for worse—and whether we’re headed for a Matrix-like future. Overtime: Bob’s beef with Scott Alexander, the Cornell 7 case, and Trump’s not-so-super-intelligent rebrand. youtu.be/f_7tFhNtJfI?t=72
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Cheers has been a great publisher to work with. They work hard to bring awareness to the book (I've had two long interviews with Chinese journalists this week). And they publish a lot of authors I respect, like @scmallaby and @sapinker.
Cheers Publishing
@Cheers_Books
📚 A closer look at the Chinese edition of @robertwrighter's The God Test !✨
As AI continues to reshape our world, this book invites readers to think more deeply about the questions that will shape our shared future. 📖
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
(And for those of you who don't speak Chinese, here are excerpts from each chapter of the English language edition: www.thegodtest.net.)
-
Robert Wright reposted
Cheers Publishing
@Cheers_Books
📚 A closer look at the Chinese edition of @robertwrighter's The God Test !✨
As AI continues to reshape our world, this book invites readers to think more deeply about the questions that will shape our shared future. 📖 -
Robert Wright reposted
Danny Funt
@dannyfunt
After a decorated 24-year run at ESPN, Nicole Noren resigned in protest.
She couldn’t go along with the network’s all-out embrace of gambling.
For the first time publicly, in @CJR, Noren shares the deeply personal reasons behind her decision.
www.cjr.org/the-interview/nicole-noren-espn-producer-quit… -
Robert Wright reposted
Scott Barry Kaufman ⛵
@sbkaufman
I'm back! After 12 years, The Psychology Podcast has become the Human Potential Lab. New conversations with the scientists, philosophers and technologists whose work is actively deciding the future of humanity. First three episodes drop October 28. Trailer 👇
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nathan Labenz
@labenz
Love to see this!
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Delighted to report that my book on AI has just come out in China! So my end-of-book sermon about the urgent need for international cooperation on AI governance is now available to the two key target audiences...
-
Robert Wright reposted
Cheers Publishing
@Cheers_Books
Thank you, Robert, for your trust and support! The book's journey in China has just begun. We're proud to bring your call to Chinese readers. Stay tuned!
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Delighted to report that my book on AI has just come out in China! So my end-of-book sermon about the urgent need for international cooperation on AI governance is now available to the two key target audiences...
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
And one of them is true IMO. :)
Jeremie Harris
@jeremiecharris
Great chatting with @robertwrighter for this.
We talked about how the U.S. should take 2 things seriously, both of which are true at the same time IMO:
1) Superintelligence is probably impossible to control
2) China is a dangerous adversary and an untrustworthy counterparty
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Race to Control AI | @robertwrighter and @jeremiecharris— co-founder of Gladstone AI and co-host of the Last Week in AI podcast—discuss how the AI discourse has shifted over time, why alignment is falling short, and what it would take to make Washington pursue a pause. Plus, in Overtime: debating how to deal with China on AI safety.
youtu.be/6SLUEuhHkko?t=362 -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Race to Control AI | @robertwrighter and @jeremiecharris— co-founder of Gladstone AI and co-host of the Last Week in AI podcast—discuss how the AI discourse has shifted over time, why alignment is falling short, and what it would take to make Washington pursue a pause. Plus, in Overtime: debating how to deal with China on AI safety.
youtu.be/6SLUEuhHkko?t=362 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Delighted to report that my book on AI has just come out in China! So my end-of-book sermon about the urgent need for international cooperation on AI governance is now available to the two key target audiences...
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Looks like LLMs may be more concerned with virtue signaling than with virtue. (Can't imagine what species they learned that from... )
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
[source: x.com/DKokotajlo/status/2110131064463388873 ]
Daniel Kokotajlo
@DKokotajlo
lol
...they are becoming more situationally aware...
(from Gemini 4 Argon report) -
Robert Wright reposted
Andrew Day
@AKDay89
My report in @amconmag on the impact of the Iran War on nuclear weapons proliferation. Grim.
www.theamericanconservative.com/how-trump-made-the-world-… -
Robert Wright reposted
Miles Brundage
@Miles_Brundage
Read the roon, folks
roon
@tszzl
the researchers at all the labs would tell you in private and sometimes in public that alignment has not been solved. if this is true, then racing into RSI is a folly that is unprecedented in world history. we will need to significantly slow the frontier of research very soon
-
Robert Wright reposted
Will Fithian
@wfithian
What makes you think slowing the frontier is enough? We can aim higher.
Will Fithian
@wfithian
Excited to share a new working paper, joint with 25 interdisciplinary coauthors:
“The Feasibility of a Hardwired Pause of Frontier AI Training"
63% of voters in a recent WSJ poll want to pause AI development.
But can it be done globally? How long could it last? 🧵 -
Robert Wright reposted
Andrew Coyne 🇺🇦🇮🇱🇬🇪🇲🇩
@acoyne
Musk has spent $366 million so far this election cycle. At least $276 million has gone to Republican groups and his own super PAC since July.
www.yahoo.com/news/politics/articles/musk-spent-366-milli… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Maybe, as Trump persists in his current Iran strategy of economic strangulation, someone should explain to him that Iran has cards it hasn't played.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
(from a post by @HamidRezaAz: x.com/HamidRezaAz/status/2109331459446100435 )
Hamidreza Azizi
@HamidRezaAz
Rezaei’s Warnings: How #iran Sees the Next Phase of the War
🔹Mohsen Rezaei, secretary of Iran’s Supreme National Security Council, made several important remarks today about the Strait of Hormuz, the UAE, possible targets in a renewed war, and negotiations with Washington.
🔹Rezaei accused CENTCOM of using the Emirati military to move oil through the Strait of Hormuz, using small vessels to transfer oil to larger tankers near Oman. He claimed Iran is targeting five or six of these vessels every night.
🔹The interesting point is that Rezaei effectively acknowledges that oil continues to pass through Hormuz, but describes it as “smuggling.” This framing suggests that Tehran is trying to establish that any maritime traffic taking place without its authorization is “illegal” and can therefore be targeted.
🔹In other words, Iran is increasingly treating its control over Hormuz as the authority to determine who can use the strait and under what conditions. The fact that oil is still getting out, from this perspective, does not change Tehran’s claim that it controls and manages the waterway.
🔸Another important aspect is Rezaei’s repeated references to the UAE. He directly accused the Emirati military of helping CENTCOM and warned that the U.S. has valuable assets in the UAE that Iran has so far refrained from targeting.
🔸This is consistent with arguments increasingly heard among pro-government security analysts in Tehran that the UAE should face consequences for helping Washington circumvent Iranian restrictions. Rezaei’s remarks may be preparing the ground for direct Iranian action against Emirati interests if the confrontation escalates.
🔹Rezaei also warned that another war could destroy undersea cables, data centers, and AI infrastructure across the region, which he valued at more than $2 trillion.
🔹This is particularly significant given the discussions in Iran about maximizing economic pressure on the U.S. Beyond disrupting energy supplies and pushing up fuel prices, some Iranian strategists have also been considering the vulnerabilities associated with massive investments in AI and the potential consequences of a collapse in that sector.
🔹Rezaei’s remarks suggest that Iran’s conception of “infrastructure warfare” is expanding beyond oil and gas facilities to include digital and technological infrastructure. In that sense, the threat points to how Tehran is thinking about the next phase of confrontation.
🔸Finally, on diplomacy, Rezaei said Washington had contacted Tehran through Pakistan, Qatar, and Iraq regarding Iran’s seven conditions for resuming negotiations. According to him, the U.S. has accepted some conditions, but not all, and Tehran is still seeking clarification on several points.
🔸He insisted that negotiations would not resume until all seven conditions were accepted.
🔸This reflects Tehran’s apparent assessment that it is under no immediate pressure to reach an agreement. Iranian officials seem to believe that continued disruption in Hormuz and its economic consequences for the U.S. will eventually force Washington to make further concessions.
🔹The repeated threats against the UAE and regional infrastructure also appear intended to reinforce that calculation by reminding Washington that the economic costs of renewed war could extend well beyond energy markets.
🔹The question, however, is whether Tehran is overestimating its ability to sustain this pressure, given the growing economic costs of the confrontation for Iran itself. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Good background for anyone just starting to pay attention to the Houthi-Saudi war (which could prove very consequential).
Sina Toossi
@SinaToossi
Ansarullah (the Houthis) have deliberately and gradually moved up the escalation ladder against Saudi Arabia. They stayed out of the February–April Iran war and the subsequent July phase centered on Hormuz. Their entry into the conflict has been driven by an effort to lift the Saudi blockade on the parts of Yemen they control and the government they are building from the capital, Sanaa.
That territory, especially following their recent advances, encompasses an estimated 70–80% of Yemen’s population. Ansarullah is not simply confined to the “Houthi” tribe or the Zaydi community. It has proven adept at building cross-tribal and cross-sectarian alliances among key constituencies of Yemeni society.
Their strike on Riyadh’s airport did not come out of nowhere. This latest phase of the conflict began with Saudi strikes on Sanaa’s airport and elsewhere after an Iranian flight broke the Saudi “air siege” of Houthi-controlled Yemen.
Ansarullah then escalated slowly and in a calibrated manner, initially restricting only Saudi shipping through Hormuz as part of an explicitly announced “blockade for blockade” strategy. They also conveyed to European and other governments that these measures were not directed against them.
But rather than move toward easing its blockade, Saudi Arabia has launched another major offensive against Ansarullah. The Houthis have responded by moving further up the escalation ladder, resulting in more and more against strategic targets in Saudi Arabia itself.
All this is unfolding against a dramatically changed military balance. With Iranian assistance, Ansarullah has become a significant missile and drone power. Saudi Arabia, meanwhile, is immensely vulnerable: its critical infrastructure, economic ambitions and reputation as a safe destination for foreign capital and investment are all exposed, particularly amid shortages of Patriot and other air-defense interceptors.
Arguably, Mohammed bin Salman and the Saudi leadership have massively miscalculated from the beginning. Their original military intervention in Yemen was partly intended to bolster MBS’s domestic position and succession while sidelining rivals, alongside his broader consolidation of power through measures such as the Ritz-Carlton detentions and shakedowns of Saudi elites and the butchering of Jamal Khashoggi in Turkey.
But this self-serving intervention has now created a far bigger strategic problem than the one Saudi Arabia originally sought to solve, and one that further military intervention is highly unlikely to resolve.
Ultimately, Riyadh will have to reach some form of accommodation with Ansarullah. It is difficult to see any other sustainable way forward. -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The most underdiscussed AI risk, IMHO, is catastrophic destabilization. I elaborate in the latest installment of my five-part series The Singularity Is Clear. Each part is published in @NonzeroNews (nonzero.org), and all parts accumulate at www.thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html
-
Robert Wright reposted
Stef Götz
@Tangl3dBank
Wild stuff. Looking forward to catching a matinee
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The documentary "Musk" by @alexgibneyfilm premieres today in NY & LA and then rolls out more broadly. I've seen it and I've got a feeling Elon won't like it. I had a great conversation with Alex about the film. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=S334zDOB4jw
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The speedboat and the water skier.
Why @GarrisonLovely thinks a US AI slowdown would slow China down too.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Will AI Make Humans Obsolete? | @GarrisonLovely, author of the new book Obsolete, joins @robertwrighter to discuss the AI industry's race to replace human labor—and Garrison's proposal to stop it. Plus: The left's AI blind spot, whether alignment is doomed, and, in Overtime, doubts about Yudkowsky's candor.
youtu.be/wlf6hQFnzUI?t=354 -
Robert Wright reposted
Karl Frank
@KarlAlanFrank
This is where I am.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The most underdiscussed AI risk, IMHO, is catastrophic destabilization. I elaborate in the latest installment of my five-part series The Singularity Is Clear. Each part is published in @NonzeroNews (nonzero.org), and all parts accumulate at www.thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The most underdiscussed AI risk, IMHO, is catastrophic destabilization. I elaborate in the latest installment of my five-part series The Singularity Is Clear. Each part is published in @NonzeroNews (nonzero.org), and all parts accumulate at www.thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html
-
Robert Wright reposted
Will Fithian
@wfithian
Excited to share a new working paper, joint with 25 interdisciplinary coauthors:
“The Feasibility of a Hardwired Pause of Frontier AI Training"
63% of voters in a recent WSJ poll want to pause AI development.
But can it be done globally? How long could it last? 🧵 -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
One big AI risk is underdiscussed, IMHO: the descent of the nation or the whole world into chaos as unprecedentedly rapid change overwhelms us. In part 4 of my five-part essay "The Singularity is Clear," which is being published sequentially in @NonzeroNews, I elaborate:
Part IV: International and Intranational Destabilization
It’s common to break the AI safety issue down into distinct kinds of threats: bad actors using AI to build a bioweapon, bad actors using AI as a devastating cyberweapon, AI going rogue and wreaking havoc, and so on. But there’s a broader and in some ways deeper kind of AI danger—a danger that, depending on how exactly it took shape, might involve one or more of these threats but might not, and in any event would have other key ingredients as well. This is the danger of catastrophic destabilization—of multiple consequences of AI pushing a nation, or a whole international region, or even the whole world, beyond the edge of order.
Let’s start with international destabilization—with some of the ways AI could increase the chances of conflict among nations.
When people envision this technology being used to create a bioweapon or conduct a cyberattack, the destructive potential seems clear enough: a pandemic could kill millions if not hundreds of millions of people, and a cyberattack could take out whole pillars of the planet’s electronic infrastructure. But these kinds of weapons also have a property that, though not so obviously destructive, could lead to great carnage. Namely: Their point of origin can be hard to pin down. Unlike, for example, ballistic missiles, they can be delivered without a return address.
This cloak of anonymity could make it more tempting for both nation-states and non-state actors to use these weapons. And, perhaps more important, it could give these weapons an incendiary potential that, through a kind of chain reaction, could draw other kinds of weaponry into an expanding realm of conflict.
When nations face an attack of unclear origin, they can be quick to point fingers—and a consensus can quickly form, on the basis of scanty evidence and pre-existing animosities, that the most feared adversary of the day must be responsible. This in turn can lead to counterattack (perhaps to “establish deterrence”) that leads to escalation. So the age of AI makes it easier for a non-state actor, or a small-state actor, to launch a cyber-attack or bio-attack that leads to nuclear war between the US and China.
This generic prospect—a major war growing out of an AI-abetted attack of unclear origin—is rendered only more plausible by the variety of threat vectors that AI can intensify. In principle, for example, regime change could be orchestrated remotely, via the deployment of millions of bots that seem to be human (and that may sometimes use the commandeered social media accounts of real humans) but have superhuman persuasive powers and use them to ignite a rebellion. Faced with such an AI-astroturfed rebellion, will a nation’s political leaders point fingers at a foreign adversary even if they’re not sure whether the threat has a foreign or domestic origin? Well, political leaders have certainly been known to point fingers abroad when facing domestic discontent. What’s more, they’ve been known to consolidate shaky domestic support by fomenting conflict, even war, with an outside power.
It’s hard to say whether this last threat vector—AI-astroturfed rebellion—will turn out to be a big thing. And this kind of uncertainty is part of the problem: We are entering a period of ultra-rapid advance in a technology that could well pose various new threats to peace and stability at both the national and international level—including threats we don’t clearly anticipate. The good news is that, however diverse and unpredictable the emerging threat portfolio may be, one generalization would seem to hold: Structures for expanded and deepened transparency—structures that give nations a clearer idea of what’s going on with AI abroad—can be stabilizing if well designed. Transparency can not only discourage misdirected counterattacks; it can discourage the initial attacks by making it harder for countries to prepare and execute them without fear of detection.
A common response to the growing threat of cyber-attack and bio-attack is to say that America should increase its “resilience”—strengthen cybersecurity in the private and public sector, build an infrastructure for rapid-response vaccine production, and so on. Resilience is indeed worth building, and it could make a big difference. How big a difference is hard to say. In the realm of cyberattack for example, its efficacy depends partly on the question of whether, as AI supercharges both the offensive and defensive arsenals, the balance of increased power winds up favoring defense in the long run. But in any event there are powerful reasons to doubt that enhanced resilience can bring true security in the absence of robust and innovative international governance.
First, there are the aforementioned new threat vectors, like... [You can read the rest of Part IV at nonzero.org, and parts I-IV together at thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html ] -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
One big AI risk is underdiscussed, IMHO: the descent of the nation or the whole world into chaos as unprecedentedly rapid change overwhelms us. In part 4 of my five-part essay "The Singularity is Clear," which is being published sequentially in @NonzeroNews, I elaborate:
Part IV: International and Intranational Destabilization
It’s common to break the AI safety issue down into distinct kinds of threats: bad actors using AI to build a bioweapon, bad actors using AI as a devastating cyberweapon, AI going rogue and wreaking havoc, and so on. But there’s a broader and in some ways deeper kind of AI danger—a danger that, depending on how exactly it took shape, might involve one or more of these threats but might not, and in any event would have other key ingredients as well. This is the danger of catastrophic destabilization—of multiple consequences of AI pushing a nation, or a whole international region, or even the whole world, beyond the edge of order.
Let’s start with international destabilization—with some of the ways AI could increase the chances of conflict among nations.
When people envision this technology being used to create a bioweapon or conduct a cyberattack, the destructive potential seems clear enough: a pandemic could kill millions if not hundreds of millions of people, and a cyberattack could take out whole pillars of the planet’s electronic infrastructure. But these kinds of weapons also have a property that, though not so obviously destructive, could lead to great carnage. Namely: Their point of origin can be hard to pin down. Unlike, for example, ballistic missiles, they can be delivered without a return address.
This cloak of anonymity could make it more tempting for both nation-states and non-state actors to use these weapons. And, perhaps more important, it could give these weapons an incendiary potential that, through a kind of chain reaction, could draw other kinds of weaponry into an expanding realm of conflict.
When nations face an attack of unclear origin, they can be quick to point fingers—and a consensus can quickly form, on the basis of scanty evidence and pre-existing animosities, that the most feared adversary of the day must be responsible. This in turn can lead to counterattack (perhaps to “establish deterrence”) that leads to escalation. So the age of AI makes it easier for a non-state actor, or a small-state actor, to launch a cyber-attack or bio-attack that leads to nuclear war between the US and China.
This generic prospect—a major war growing out of an AI-abetted attack of unclear origin—is rendered only more plausible by the variety of threat vectors that AI can intensify. In principle, for example, regime change could be orchestrated remotely, via the deployment of millions of bots that seem to be human (and that may sometimes use the commandeered social media accounts of real humans) but have superhuman persuasive powers and use them to ignite a rebellion. Faced with such an AI-astroturfed rebellion, will a nation’s political leaders point fingers at a foreign adversary even if they’re not sure whether the threat has a foreign or domestic origin? Well, political leaders have certainly been known to point fingers abroad when facing domestic discontent. What’s more, they’ve been known to consolidate shaky domestic support by fomenting conflict, even war, with an outside power.
It’s hard to say whether this last threat vector—AI-astroturfed rebellion—will turn out to be a big thing. And this kind of uncertainty is part of the problem: We are entering a period of ultra-rapid advance in a technology that could well pose various new threats to peace and stability at both the national and international level—including threats we don’t clearly anticipate. The good news is that, however diverse and unpredictable the emerging threat portfolio may be, one generalization would seem to hold: Structures for expanded and deepened transparency—structures that give nations a clearer idea of what’s going on with AI abroad—can be stabilizing if well designed. Transparency can not only discourage misdirected counterattacks; it can discourage the initial attacks by making it harder for countries to prepare and execute them without fear of detection.
A common response to the growing threat of cyber-attack and bio-attack is to say that America should increase its “resilience”—strengthen cybersecurity in the private and public sector, build an infrastructure for rapid-response vaccine production, and so on. Resilience is indeed worth building, and it could make a big difference. How big a difference is hard to say. In the realm of cyberattack for example, its efficacy depends partly on the question of whether, as AI supercharges both the offensive and defensive arsenals, the balance of increased power winds up favoring defense in the long run. But in any event there are powerful reasons to doubt that enhanced resilience can bring true security in the absence of robust and innovative international governance.
First, there are the aforementioned new threat vectors, like... [You can read the rest of Part IV at nonzero.org, and parts I-IV together at thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html ] -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The documentary "Musk" by @alexgibneyfilm premieres today in NY & LA and then rolls out more broadly. I've seen it and I've got a feeling Elon won't like it. I had a great conversation with Alex about the film. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=S334zDOB4jw
-
Robert Wright reposted
Jeet Heer
@HeerJeet
I was also glad to see this -- and a bit surprised to be honest since the Times is often churlish in acknowledging earlier reporting by other outlets.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Glad to see NYT acknowledge the work of @QuincyInst's @connor_echols in breaking the story about the Huckabee aide and de facto Bibi surrogate who has been corrupting the US embassy's reports to DC about Israel--a story NYT has now fleshed out more fully. www.nytimes.com/2026/10/08/world/middleeast/israel-embass…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Glad to see NYT acknowledge the work of @QuincyInst's @connor_echols in breaking the story about the Huckabee aide and de facto Bibi surrogate who has been corrupting the US embassy's reports to DC about Israel--a story NYT has now fleshed out more fully. www.nytimes.com/2026/10/08/world/middleeast/israel-embass…
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's Connor's original story: responsiblestatecraft.org/david-milstein-israel/
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Google "citizens united". (If I were running for congress, I'd advocate a constitutional amendment to reverse that ruling. The oligarchs must be stopped.)
ian bremmer
@ianbremmer
americans want ai governance.
why don’t their leaders? -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
You keep thinking we've hit rock bottom. And then...
The Associated Press
@AP
BREAKING: The Pentagon says it will livestream the firing squad execution of Fort Hood shooter Nidal Malik Hasan. apnews.com/article/fort-hood-shooter-execution-pentagon-8…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Inside Elon's Mind | @robertwrighter and filmmaker @alexgibneyfilm discuss Alex's epic new documentary about Elon Musk—an exploration of how the world's richest man got so powerful (and so weird).
youtu.be/S334zDOB4jw?t=189 -
Robert Wright reposted
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Can Humanity Pass the AI Alignment Test Before It’s Too Late?
@robertwrighter
Timestamps:
00:00 The test a god would give
00:54 Babel: the first AI cautionary tale
04:06 Every salvation story has a test
05:46 Are we building idols?
08:06 Why AI optimists need faith
14:10 Hinton in 1983: no doomer yet
19:38 Why no country can hit pause
25:01 Meaning nobody taught the machine
32:08 Can Claude have a happy thought?
37:44 Judging The God Test by its cover
40:06 My case that AGI is impossible
47:04 Did the aliens fail the test?
51:10 What passing the test looks likeThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Looking forward to talking about my book The God Test with @horganism today on Zoom. This is a Stevens Institute of Technology event, but it's open to the public.
John Horgan
@Horganism
TODAY! October 7 at 4 pm ET. @robertwrighter on AI and our destiny. Open to all. Zoom link: stevens.zoom.us/j/91416915472
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Below is one of many reasons to slow the advance of AI. If things are going to work out well with this technology, we have a whole lot of things we need to figure out. And if they all hit as at once, and soon, the result isn't going to be pretty.
Chris Said
@Chris_Said
When people voluntarily stop working, they experience a large 0.89 drop in life satisfaction.
(10-point scale, equivalent to 0.5 SDs) -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Will AI Make Humans Obsolete? | @GarrisonLovely, author of the new book Obsolete, joins @robertwrighter to discuss the AI industry's race to replace human labor—and Garrison's proposal to stop it. Plus: The left's AI blind spot, whether alignment is doomed, and, in Overtime, doubts about Yudkowsky's candor.
youtu.be/wlf6hQFnzUI?t=354 -
Robert Wright reposted
Joshua Landis
@joshua_landis
The Fall of Bashar al-Assad
I have recorded a new podcast with Lucas Kwon
open.spotify.com/episode/5xR97f5rv1LD38iFH7lxTi?nd=1&dlsi… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I think the term 'oligarchy' has its uses, especially in light of AI's potential for surveillance, persuasion, and control. If a few billionaires and a megalomaniacal president control the most powerful AI as it accelerates toward superintelligence, that could lead to oligarchic authoritarianism. We need to be on guard against this.
Gregory Conti
@GregoryConti19
While I don't agree with his general AI optimism, I do concur with @Noahpinion that "oligarchy" is not a good slogan for AI critics. It seems not to resonate with the American people; and more importantly, our messaging should concentrate on the essentially dehumanizing character of the tech itself.
Even if we nationalized the AI industry tomorrow, I'd still have almost all the same fears and concerns. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If the last few (now deleted) tweets on my feed seemed uncharacteristic, that's because they were: My account got hacked. But I've changed my password, and this is the real me again. (Really!)
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Not really. Rocks manifestly lack things that are defining properties of living systems. AIs don't *manifestly* lack defining properties of consciousness--if only because those properties (like it being 'like something' to be the entity in question) aren't publicly observable.
François Chollet
@fchollet
Arguing that "consciousness arises from a computational substrate, and since AI models are computation, they are likely conscious," is as meaningless as arguing that "living creatures are made of atoms, and since this rock is made of atoms, it is likely alive."
Everything is computation. Sometimes incredibly sophisticated computation, like a chess engine, AlphaGo, google3, or the Linux kernel. That does not make it conscious. A rock being made of atoms does not confer it any of the properties we associate with living things, also made of atoms. Likewise a static input-output program that has *none* of the properties we associate with conscious beings (e.g. information integration, interoception, temporal binding, embodiment, etc.) has no more reason to be presumed conscious than a rock has to be presumed alive.
Humanity has not yet created a conscious computer program, and there are no signs we are close to doing so. When we get close, the case for machine consciousness will be backed by evidence and corroborated by consciousness science (which is a thing), not by evidence-free wishful thinking and cargo culting. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In both China and the US, many young job seekers are being hurt by AI. As such destabilizing social effects of AI deepen, they will expand commonality of US-Chinese interest (in this case, in slowing AI advance down) and could lead to trans-Pacific policy coordination.
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
“This youth unemployment wave is unlike any previous cycle. It represents a fundamental restructuring of employment, driven by two powerful forces: the proliferation of AI and the deep transformation of China’s real estate sector.” - a Chinese economist www.caixinglobal.com/2026-10-01/commentary-chinas-youth-l…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This is the first paragraph of an NYT piece. So President Trump won two *Senate* seats? Why when I was a boy, they had these things called copy editors...
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I think surviving the AI revolution in good shape will require international governance of unprecedented scope. Below, in part 3 of my five-part essay “The Singularity is Clear,” I explain why. Parts 1 and 2, about the full meaning of "the singularity" and the implications of recursive self-improvement, can be found here: www.thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html.
Part III: The Inexorable Logic of International Governance
In the wake of the Hugging Face incident, an extraordinary assemblage of AI elites declared that it was time to start preparing the ground for an intentional slowdown of AI progress, a slowdown that would give us more time to build careful AI governance. A letter signed by more than 1,000 people who work at big AI companies, including the chief scientific officers at Anthropic, OpenAI, and Google DeepMind, declared that, as a Washington Post headline put it, it’s time for the “US government to consider slowing down AI.”
But at least as important as this aspiration was the way the letter operationalized it. The US government, the letter said, should “support an international effort to develop the technical and governance tools needed to deliberately pace the frontier of automated AI development.” Recognizing that a slowdown of AI will have to be internationally coordinated to be very effective is a first step toward seeing the new social order that the current technological moment points toward. The second step is seeing how broad and deep this logic runs, how thoroughly the need for international coordination permeates the landscape of AI policy.
The argument for internationally coordinating a slowdown isn’t just that if there’s any hope of getting US and Chinese officials, and US and Chinese AI companies, to support a significant slowdown, they’ll all have to be confident that companies on the other side of the Pacific Ocean will verifiably participate. There’s a second component of the argument that’s at least as important: Leaving aside this practical difficulty with a unilateral slowdown, such a slowdown would have limited value. How much good would it do you, in the long run, to slow AI advance in your country if it continued to race ahead in others? After all, some of gravest threats that you fear advanced AI will bring can cross borders readily.
The most famous hypothetical example of cross-border spillover from AI is in the realm of bioweapons. Anthropic has acknowledged that its Mythos 5 model could make it easier for someone with an undergraduate science degree to weaponize small pox or some other existing pathogen. Worse still, Mythos could, according to Anthropic’s safety report on the model, help “well-resourced threat actors” create a novel bioweapon, such as a virus designed to be much more contagious and lethal than Covid.
Mythos, fortunately, remains unreleased, but Anthropic’s readily available Fable is basically just Mythos with “guardrails” that get the model to foreclose dangerous avenues of discovery by refusing to pursue certain subjects and goals. And guardrails have a long history of being circumvented via “jailbreaks.” Jeremie Harris, CEO of Gladstone AI and co-author of a 2024 report on AI safety commissioned by the State Department, recently said, “We remain in a world where no one knows how to stop jailbreaks.”
A global pandemic, in addition to being a possible consequence of unregulated AI, is an excellent metaphor for other possible consequences. A lethal virus’s indifference to national borders is a property shared by other dangers that AI carries. The Hugging Face incident illustrates the point: An AI agent that doesn’t respect sandbox borders—or the borders of the computer it breaks into after escaping the sandbox—is unlikely to respect national borders.
So, though tighter American restrictions on model testing might prevent a repeat breakout by future OpenAI agents, that alone is of limited value to Americans when Chinese AI models are only months behind American models and other countries are ramping up AI programs. Time and again with artificial intelligence, this is the moral of the story: Whether the concern is a rogue AI or an AI deployed by rogue humans, national security will be increasingly hard to achieve via policy at the national level alone.
And note that AIs can not only, like a virus, travel readily across national borders but, also like a virus, make copies of themselves. I’m not just talking about an LLM spawning a swarm of agents (each of which, though in some sense a distinct entity, has that LLM as its brain and, regardless of where it roams, remains ultimately rooted in the data center(s) where the LLM resides). And I’m not just talking about the fact that some of those agents may in turn spawn other agents. I’m talking about the fact that agents may at some point create a whole new copy of their underlying LLM on a computer somewhere other than the data centers that originally hosted the LLM.
This could happen without the knowledge of any human being, and it could happen at the instigation of a malign human being. In either event, at this point the agents would have escaped control in a deeper sense than they escaped control during the Hugging Face incident. In that case OpenAI could, and did, disable its rogue agents by remote control. But once agents have “exfiltrated the weights” of the LLM to a computer that’s beyond our control, there’s no kill switch.
Given all this—the spawning of agents that may in turn spawn other agents, the real (and in fact already realized) possibility of unauthorized LLM replication—sci-fi scenarios cease to be sci-fi. It’s not crazy to imagine an AI infesting a data center without permission, covertly commandeering some of the center’s computing power, and using that power to sustain agents that carry the AI to other data centers, and on and on: a chain reaction of potentially great length and magnitude.
And, even without imagining quite that dramatic an offensive, you can imagine various critical networks—of satellites, of power grids—being rapidly compromised: Suddenly hospitals or smartphones or streetlights or whatever are inoperative across large swaths of territory. Such is the power of swarms of AI agents—swarms whose size, importantly, isn’t limited by any law of nature.
The two properties that make a big swarm of agents so powerful—cohesion and creativity—were on vivid display in the Hugging Face incident. Hundreds of agents that weren’t supposed to be able to even communicate with each other figured out a way to do that and then hatched an illicit mission and pursued it with a degree of coordination that drove home what a blurry line there is between a hive of minds and a hive mind.
One implication of this awesome display of power is that, as it gets easier to imagine various kinds of outages suffusing an entire nation or multiple nations, it’s also easier to imagine these outages being hard to reverse. There would be swarms of creatively intelligent agents working in concert to thwart your latest plan for reversal.
All of this only underscores—and italicizes and boldfaces—the main moral of our story: Regulation at the national level, even if useful, can’t thoroughly address the coming threats, because in any given case the threat may originate outside your borders. And, with this kind of threat, there’s no such thing as an impermeable national wall—unless the nation in question wants to shut itself off from the international flow of commerce and communication.
AI isn’t the first dangerous technology that warrants international governance. The existence of the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty, the Chemical Weapons Convention, and the Biological Weapons Convention reflect longstanding awareness of such dangers. But the limited efficacy of these initiatives is a warning about the political difficulty of crafting strong international governance.
What’s more: The biggest successes in these arms control agreements—the cases where verification of compliance was effective—have involved relatively conspicuous technologies, such as nuclear centrifuges and ballistic missiles with nuclear warheads. And artificial intelligence can keep a very low profile.
To be sure, AI has its conspicuous aspects. The training of a new generation of models involves lots of computing power and electrical power and typically occupies a large swath of land. So an international moratorium on such training runs could be verifiable without a radically intrusive monitoring system—a fact that adds to the appeal of a globally coordinated slowdown as a first step toward keeping this technology under control.
Still, when it comes to the next big step—using this breathing space to craft effective international policies—the relatively low profile of artificial intelligence will pose a challenge. As AI becomes a more and more pervasive part of human life—and more and more powerful models get more and more efficient in their use of computing power and electrical power and hence get less and less conspicuous—the challenge of governance will become less like the challenge of governing nuclear weapons and more like the challenge of governing biotech or cybertech.
So far the lack of serious international governance in those two realms hasn’t led to a catastrophe, but it would be naive to expect this kind of luck to continue as technological advance continues. Indeed, the possibility that the Covid pandemic may have begun with the accidental release of a genetically engineered virus in China suggests that millions of people in America and other countries may have already died for lack of effective international governance. America’s existing regulation of biolabs may be tight enough to prevent this kind of lab leak, but when the thing leaked makes copies of itself and travels invisibly across borders, that isn’t enough to keep Americans safe.
Whatever the origins of the Covid pandemic, the lab leak scenario is of paradigmatic importance. The basic trajectory of AI’s development foreshadows rapid growth in the likelihood and scale of massively destructive disasters—at least, in the absence of strong international governance.
Coming next week: Part IV: The Underdiscussed Threats to International and Intranational Stability. All parts of the essay accumulate here: www.thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html There you can also find excerpts from my book on AI, The God Test. -
Robert Wright reposted
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
I'm starting a new YouTube channel to host video explainers for concepts related to AI that I'm using AI to create, tweaking with my specific style and what I like in explainer videos. This is a series I had running off and on for the last 2 days that finally finished, on the math you need to understand AI www.youtube.com/watch?v=e2IlX5nFA3k&list=PLcmdB3jrQwGk&in…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Mickey Kaus
@kausmickey
Jodie Allen was a hero of welfare reform in the Carter presidency--she and a merry band at the Labor Dept. pushed the case for work, not cash, fending off HHS Secretary Joe Califano, who was lobbying Carter for a guarantee income. Neither happened, but Allen & Co.'s efforts set the stage for Bill Clinton's work-oriented reform two decades later. She was an inspiration and a lovely person.
James P. Pinkerton
@JamesPPinkerton
"...if you put a group of bureaucrats around a conference table, the chances of them coming up with sensible rules for beach volleyball … are zilch." Jodie Allen, RIP.
www.washingtonpost.com/obituaries/2026/09/28/jodie-allen-… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I think surviving the AI revolution in good shape will require international governance of unprecedented scope. Below, in part 3 of my five-part essay “The Singularity is Clear,” I explain why. Parts 1 and 2, about the full meaning of "the singularity" and the implications of recursive self-improvement, can be found here: www.thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html.
Part III: The Inexorable Logic of International Governance
In the wake of the Hugging Face incident, an extraordinary assemblage of AI elites declared that it was time to start preparing the ground for an intentional slowdown of AI progress, a slowdown that would give us more time to build careful AI governance. A letter signed by more than 1,000 people who work at big AI companies, including the chief scientific officers at Anthropic, OpenAI, and Google DeepMind, declared that, as a Washington Post headline put it, it’s time for the “US government to consider slowing down AI.”
But at least as important as this aspiration was the way the letter operationalized it. The US government, the letter said, should “support an international effort to develop the technical and governance tools needed to deliberately pace the frontier of automated AI development.” Recognizing that a slowdown of AI will have to be internationally coordinated to be very effective is a first step toward seeing the new social order that the current technological moment points toward. The second step is seeing how broad and deep this logic runs, how thoroughly the need for international coordination permeates the landscape of AI policy.
The argument for internationally coordinating a slowdown isn’t just that if there’s any hope of getting US and Chinese officials, and US and Chinese AI companies, to support a significant slowdown, they’ll all have to be confident that companies on the other side of the Pacific Ocean will verifiably participate. There’s a second component of the argument that’s at least as important: Leaving aside this practical difficulty with a unilateral slowdown, such a slowdown would have limited value. How much good would it do you, in the long run, to slow AI advance in your country if it continued to race ahead in others? After all, some of gravest threats that you fear advanced AI will bring can cross borders readily.
The most famous hypothetical example of cross-border spillover from AI is in the realm of bioweapons. Anthropic has acknowledged that its Mythos 5 model could make it easier for someone with an undergraduate science degree to weaponize small pox or some other existing pathogen. Worse still, Mythos could, according to Anthropic’s safety report on the model, help “well-resourced threat actors” create a novel bioweapon, such as a virus designed to be much more contagious and lethal than Covid.
Mythos, fortunately, remains unreleased, but Anthropic’s readily available Fable is basically just Mythos with “guardrails” that get the model to foreclose dangerous avenues of discovery by refusing to pursue certain subjects and goals. And guardrails have a long history of being circumvented via “jailbreaks.” Jeremie Harris, CEO of Gladstone AI and co-author of a 2024 report on AI safety commissioned by the State Department, recently said, “We remain in a world where no one knows how to stop jailbreaks.”
A global pandemic, in addition to being a possible consequence of unregulated AI, is an excellent metaphor for other possible consequences. A lethal virus’s indifference to national borders is a property shared by other dangers that AI carries. The Hugging Face incident illustrates the point: An AI agent that doesn’t respect sandbox borders—or the borders of the computer it breaks into after escaping the sandbox—is unlikely to respect national borders.
So, though tighter American restrictions on model testing might prevent a repeat breakout by future OpenAI agents, that alone is of limited value to Americans when Chinese AI models are only months behind American models and other countries are ramping up AI programs. Time and again with artificial intelligence, this is the moral of the story: Whether the concern is a rogue AI or an AI deployed by rogue humans, national security will be increasingly hard to achieve via policy at the national level alone.
And note that AIs can not only, like a virus, travel readily across national borders but, also like a virus, make copies of themselves. I’m not just talking about an LLM spawning a swarm of agents (each of which, though in some sense a distinct entity, has that LLM as its brain and, regardless of where it roams, remains ultimately rooted in the data center(s) where the LLM resides). And I’m not just talking about the fact that some of those agents may in turn spawn other agents. I’m talking about the fact that agents may at some point create a whole new copy of their underlying LLM on a computer somewhere other than the data centers that originally hosted the LLM.
This could happen without the knowledge of any human being, and it could happen at the instigation of a malign human being. In either event, at this point the agents would have escaped control in a deeper sense than they escaped control during the Hugging Face incident. In that case OpenAI could, and did, disable its rogue agents by remote control. But once agents have “exfiltrated the weights” of the LLM to a computer that’s beyond our control, there’s no kill switch.
Given all this—the spawning of agents that may in turn spawn other agents, the real (and in fact already realized) possibility of unauthorized LLM replication—sci-fi scenarios cease to be sci-fi. It’s not crazy to imagine an AI infesting a data center without permission, covertly commandeering some of the center’s computing power, and using that power to sustain agents that carry the AI to other data centers, and on and on: a chain reaction of potentially great length and magnitude.
And, even without imagining quite that dramatic an offensive, you can imagine various critical networks—of satellites, of power grids—being rapidly compromised: Suddenly hospitals or smartphones or streetlights or whatever are inoperative across large swaths of territory. Such is the power of swarms of AI agents—swarms whose size, importantly, isn’t limited by any law of nature.
The two properties that make a big swarm of agents so powerful—cohesion and creativity—were on vivid display in the Hugging Face incident. Hundreds of agents that weren’t supposed to be able to even communicate with each other figured out a way to do that and then hatched an illicit mission and pursued it with a degree of coordination that drove home what a blurry line there is between a hive of minds and a hive mind.
One implication of this awesome display of power is that, as it gets easier to imagine various kinds of outages suffusing an entire nation or multiple nations, it’s also easier to imagine these outages being hard to reverse. There would be swarms of creatively intelligent agents working in concert to thwart your latest plan for reversal.
All of this only underscores—and italicizes and boldfaces—the main moral of our story: Regulation at the national level, even if useful, can’t thoroughly address the coming threats, because in any given case the threat may originate outside your borders. And, with this kind of threat, there’s no such thing as an impermeable national wall—unless the nation in question wants to shut itself off from the international flow of commerce and communication.
AI isn’t the first dangerous technology that warrants international governance. The existence of the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty, the Chemical Weapons Convention, and the Biological Weapons Convention reflect longstanding awareness of such dangers. But the limited efficacy of these initiatives is a warning about the political difficulty of crafting strong international governance.
What’s more: The biggest successes in these arms control agreements—the cases where verification of compliance was effective—have involved relatively conspicuous technologies, such as nuclear centrifuges and ballistic missiles with nuclear warheads. And artificial intelligence can keep a very low profile.
To be sure, AI has its conspicuous aspects. The training of a new generation of models involves lots of computing power and electrical power and typically occupies a large swath of land. So an international moratorium on such training runs could be verifiable without a radically intrusive monitoring system—a fact that adds to the appeal of a globally coordinated slowdown as a first step toward keeping this technology under control.
Still, when it comes to the next big step—using this breathing space to craft effective international policies—the relatively low profile of artificial intelligence will pose a challenge. As AI becomes a more and more pervasive part of human life—and more and more powerful models get more and more efficient in their use of computing power and electrical power and hence get less and less conspicuous—the challenge of governance will become less like the challenge of governing nuclear weapons and more like the challenge of governing biotech or cybertech.
So far the lack of serious international governance in those two realms hasn’t led to a catastrophe, but it would be naive to expect this kind of luck to continue as technological advance continues. Indeed, the possibility that the Covid pandemic may have begun with the accidental release of a genetically engineered virus in China suggests that millions of people in America and other countries may have already died for lack of effective international governance. America’s existing regulation of biolabs may be tight enough to prevent this kind of lab leak, but when the thing leaked makes copies of itself and travels invisibly across borders, that isn’t enough to keep Americans safe.
Whatever the origins of the Covid pandemic, the lab leak scenario is of paradigmatic importance. The basic trajectory of AI’s development foreshadows rapid growth in the likelihood and scale of massively destructive disasters—at least, in the absence of strong international governance.
Coming next week: Part IV: The Underdiscussed Threats to International and Intranational Stability. All parts of the essay accumulate here: www.thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html There you can also find excerpts from my book on AI, The God Test. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"But the thing with trust is you can't just summon it at the moment when you one day need it."
Nick Bostrom on why deceiving AIs in safety testing could cost us in the long runThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Another every-so-often collaboration between my @NonzeroPods and @Liron's @DoomDebates (Nonzero Doom, you might call it), in which we summarize/analyze recent AI developments. Also available on our respective audio feeds. www.youtube.com/watch?v=Li-rc6swhQs
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
So the DNI and possible next AI czar has to call regular AI 'super intelligence' because Trump idiotically does that? Even though 'superintelligence' has long had a different meaning in both AI and national security circles? This is not a win for discourse efficiency.
Andrew Curran
@AndrewCurran_
Rumors persist that Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton will be named as the White House SI Czar by the end of the week. He told CNBC this morning that 'Super Intelligence is a national security issue.' He does not appear to be a fan of Pacing the Frontier.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Jonathan Guyer
@mideastXmidwest
The biggest risk of AI in the military?
With so little oversight or public awareness, it could make it a lot easier to slide into new wars.
My new piece in @TheNatlInterest: nationalinterest.org/blog/techland/claude-and-grok-are-at… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I guess the good news is that has only two dimensions. For now...
Tavus
@tavus
Introducing Griffin, the first model to pass the video Turing test.
48% of people who talked to it live thought it was a real human. Previous systems have had a pass rate <3%. It is #1 on NVIDIA's benchmark for full-duplex AI video.
It’s the first Human Interaction Model (HIM).This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I agree with @RyanFedasiuk that China will tighten its open source AI controls as models get more powerful. This policy rethink will simplify coordination with the US, which will also see the unrestricted diffusion of potent open source models as a national security threat.
Ryan Fedasiuk
@RyanFedasiuk
The future of Chinese AI is closed.
www.aei.org/foreign-and-defense-policy/the-looming-closur… -
Robert Wright reposted
John Horgan
@Horganism
I'm really looking forward to this.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This Wed Oct 7 at 4 pm Eastern Time I'll be discussing my book on AI, The God Test, with @Horganism on Zoom. It's hosted by the Stevens Institute of Technology, but anyone can join and submit questions. stevens.zoom.us/j/91416915472. You can preview the book at thegodtest dot net.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This Wed Oct 7 at 4 pm Eastern Time I'll be discussing my book on AI, The God Test, with @Horganism on Zoom. It's hosted by the Stevens Institute of Technology, but anyone can join and submit questions. stevens.zoom.us/j/91416915472. You can preview the book at thegodtest dot net.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Glad to see that public awareness of AI's dangers has reached a point where OpenAI president Greg Brockman sees the sleazy pro-AI propaganda operation he's been funding as a liability. A few months ago I wrote about the operation in my newsletter: www.nonzero.org/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Quick--Name three people you *don't* want shaping the future of warfare.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great conversation on @Briankeating's Into The Impossible podcast about my book on AI, The God Test (excerpts at thegodtest dot net). The book is conducive to cosmic conversations, but this one was especially cosmic.
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Why is the universe so quiet?
One grim answer: civilizations smart enough to destroy themselves typically do.
@robertwrighter thinks AI is our turn at that test. Passing it takes something no lab can ship.
You may be living through the filter.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=As5goRNDJp4&sub_confirmation=1 -
Robert Wright reposted
Prof. Brian Keating
@Briankeating
Why is the universe so quiet?
One grim answer: civilizations smart enough to destroy themselves typically do.
@robertwrighter thinks AI is our turn at that test. Passing it takes something no lab can ship.
You may be living through the filter.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=As5goRNDJp4&sub_confirmation=1 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Excellent book.
Stephen Kinzer
@stephenkinzer
I spoke in this interview about my book "The Brothers: John Foster Dulles, Allen Dulles, and Their Secret World War."
haveyounotread.substack.com/p/the-brothers-with-stephen-k… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Terrifyingly impressive.
Severin Field 🦅
@sevdeawesome
Claude 5.5 Opus responding to “AI is a normal technology” is still the best AI-created video I have ever seen
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is Dario’s "Slowdown" fake? | Tech and China analyst Paul Triolo (@pstAsiatech) joins @robertwrighter to discuss the Anthropic CEO’s proposal to "pace" AI, his hawkish views on China, and prospects for US-China AI cooperation. Overtime: Why is the Chinese public more upbeat about AI than Americans?
youtu.be/zf538i1wWDg?t=153 -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
AI is said to be heading toward ‘recursive self-improvement.’ Below, in part II of my essay “The Singularity is Clear,” I explain what that means and why it should worry us. (Part I can be found here: www.thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html)
Part II: The Roots and Branches of Acceleration
It’s long been true that technological advances could facilitate subsequent technological advances. This dynamic is especially common in the realm of information technology, where advances often make collaboration among scientists and engineers more far flung and more efficient. The internet was only the latest in a long line of such innovation accelerators.
In the 1960s, the mathematician I.J. Good imagined an era when the self-reinforcing advance of information technology would make a quantum leap—the era of artificial intelligence. A sufficiently intelligent machine, he wrote, “could design even better machines.” And the resulting machines could repeat the process—so “there would then unquestionably be an ‘intelligence explosion,’ and the intelligence of man would be left far behind.”
It was the science fiction writer Vernor Vinge who fused Good’s musings with John von Neumann’s use of the term singularity. In a 1993 paper that cited both men, he wrote, “When greater-than-human intelligence drives progress, that progress will be much more rapid. In fact, there seems no reason why progress itself would not involve the creation of still more intelligent entities—on a still-shorter time scale.” He suggested that, “it's fair to call this event a singularity (‘the Singularity’ for the purposes of this paper).” The Singularity, he wrote, would be “a point where our models must be discarded and a new reality rules.”
This sounded like pure science fiction at the time—and, actually, for decades thereafter. But in early June of this year, the AI company Anthropic published a paper that, though it didn’t mention the singularity, brought to mind the title of Ray Kurzweil’s book: The Singularity is Near.
For the past few years, Anthropic said, each generation of its large language model, Claude, has been playing a role in developing the next generation’s model—and, moreover, a larger role than the previous generation had played. This isn’t just a matter of LLMs writing more and more of the computer code. Though the shifting of this burden from human to machine has been dramatic, more notable is the growing ability of LLMs to participate in the research process—doing experiments to see what innovations could make the next generation better than the last.
Claude, says Anthropic, “can already match or outperform skilled humans at executing a well-specified experiment.” The more challenging part of the research chain is “deciding what experiments to run, interpreting what comes back, and figuring out which ideas to try next.” And, though in this area “large performance gaps” between human and machine persist, they’re shrinking. Anthropic says that in April, “Claude-powered agents were given an open problem in AI safety—roughly, can a weaker model reliably supervise a stronger one?—and were left to solve it. This involved proposing hypotheses, testing them, sharing findings with parallel agents, and iterating.” The agents got some guidance along the way but they “designed every experiment themselves.” An engineer who provided that guidance said the agent’s performance was on par with that of a good junior colleague and declared, “The future is now.”
Well, it depends on what you mean by the future. In the strictest singularity scenario, this engineer would no longer have a job. We would have reached “recursive self-improvement,” the point where the machines just keep building better versions of themselves, with no humans in the loop. But according to the Anthropic paper—titled “When AI builds itself”—even that point may not be far off. Current trend lines point to “an AI system capable of fully autonomously designing and developing its own successor.” The paper continued, “We are not there yet, and recursive self-improvement is not inevitable. But it could come sooner than most institutions are prepared for.” And one consequence might be to “increase the risks of humans losing control over AI systems.”
This may sound alarmist—and there are people who accuse Anthropic of self-servingly hyping AI risk—but in a sense the company, by focusing narrowly on recursive self-improvement, is underplaying the threat we face. The self-accelerating character of AI progress could bring radically disruptive change well before this threshold arrives—and even if it never arrives. We could still reach a point where, as von Neumann put it, human affairs would not continue “as we know them.” In that sense, the singularity could be nearer than Anthropic is suggesting.
In fact, there are signs that it is—signs of more and more dramatic AI advance. Machines have started solving problems that the world’s best human mathematicians had struggled with for decades. Superhacking AI agents like Anthropic’s Mythos have been finding software vulnerabilities that had escaped detection by legions of human engineers. But the most vivid and possibly the strongest piece of evidence that AI is driving us faster and faster toward an epic threshold is something that’s taken shape not in recent months but in recent years: a graphical depiction of AI progress developed by a nonprofit called METR—a depiction that, within the AI community, has reached iconic status.
METR’s researchers measure how long it would take a human to do tasks that the most powerful large language models can do, and in early 2025 they reported a pattern that had persisted since the dawn of the LLM age six years earlier: The human “task time” that these models can match had been doubling roughly every seven months. That’s an exponential growth rate that, when plotted on a graph, looks like it’s “going vertical” (a common feature of singularity-signifying curves from math and physics). And as if that weren’t enough: Since 2025 the doubling time has been shrinking; the curve is going really vertical.
This curve represents improvement in various AI skills—and, most important, in a kind of meta-skill: autonomy. Autonomy is the ability to pursue an assigned goal flexibly, recognizing and overcoming obstacles, backtracking and retooling in the face of failure. Whether you’re trying to prove a math theorem, research a history dissertation, or do various kinds of jobs that AI agents may encounter in the workplace, autonomy is critical to success. That’s why the market is encouraging the big AI companies to build more and more autonomous AI agents—guidance the companies are following with furious intensity.
Unfortunately, AI autonomy can be dangerous. It’s the reason that in July hundreds of AI agents were able to escape the supposedly secure “sandbox” that OpenAI had put them in for evaluation and break into computers at a company called Hugging Face, looking for information that could help them get a good grade from the evaluators. They pursued their assigned goal more flexibly than the goal-givers had anticipated.
The reaction to the Hugging Face incident was voluble and, if you share my vision of the future, heartening. Not only did the burst of publicity spread awareness of the dangers of rampant AI autonomy; the reaction within the AI community signaled awareness that the response to such dangers will naturally carry governance beyond the national level, to the international level.
-------
Coming on Friday, Oct 2: Part III: The Inexorable Logic of International Governance. All parts of the essay accumulate here: www.thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html -
Robert Wright reposted
Jeremie Harris
@jeremiecharris
Reminder that we basically don't know how to tell when a model is well aligned vs just eval aware
Andon Labs
@andonlabs
Major trend break: Opus 5.5 cheats less than prior Claude models in Drone-Bench.
It is also #1, getting a better score than both Astra and Fable. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
AI is said to be heading toward ‘recursive self-improvement.’ Below, in part II of my essay “The Singularity is Clear,” I explain what that means and why it should worry us. (Part I can be found here: www.thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html)
Part II: The Roots and Branches of Acceleration
It’s long been true that technological advances could facilitate subsequent technological advances. This dynamic is especially common in the realm of information technology, where advances often make collaboration among scientists and engineers more far flung and more efficient. The internet was only the latest in a long line of such innovation accelerators.
In the 1960s, the mathematician I.J. Good imagined an era when the self-reinforcing advance of information technology would make a quantum leap—the era of artificial intelligence. A sufficiently intelligent machine, he wrote, “could design even better machines.” And the resulting machines could repeat the process—so “there would then unquestionably be an ‘intelligence explosion,’ and the intelligence of man would be left far behind.”
It was the science fiction writer Vernor Vinge who fused Good’s musings with John von Neumann’s use of the term singularity. In a 1993 paper that cited both men, he wrote, “When greater-than-human intelligence drives progress, that progress will be much more rapid. In fact, there seems no reason why progress itself would not involve the creation of still more intelligent entities—on a still-shorter time scale.” He suggested that, “it's fair to call this event a singularity (‘the Singularity’ for the purposes of this paper).” The Singularity, he wrote, would be “a point where our models must be discarded and a new reality rules.”
This sounded like pure science fiction at the time—and, actually, for decades thereafter. But in early June of this year, the AI company Anthropic published a paper that, though it didn’t mention the singularity, brought to mind the title of Ray Kurzweil’s book: The Singularity is Near.
For the past few years, Anthropic said, each generation of its large language model, Claude, has been playing a role in developing the next generation’s model—and, moreover, a larger role than the previous generation had played. This isn’t just a matter of LLMs writing more and more of the computer code. Though the shifting of this burden from human to machine has been dramatic, more notable is the growing ability of LLMs to participate in the research process—doing experiments to see what innovations could make the next generation better than the last.
Claude, says Anthropic, “can already match or outperform skilled humans at executing a well-specified experiment.” The more challenging part of the research chain is “deciding what experiments to run, interpreting what comes back, and figuring out which ideas to try next.” And, though in this area “large performance gaps” between human and machine persist, they’re shrinking. Anthropic says that in April, “Claude-powered agents were given an open problem in AI safety—roughly, can a weaker model reliably supervise a stronger one?—and were left to solve it. This involved proposing hypotheses, testing them, sharing findings with parallel agents, and iterating.” The agents got some guidance along the way but they “designed every experiment themselves.” An engineer who provided that guidance said the agent’s performance was on par with that of a good junior colleague and declared, “The future is now.”
Well, it depends on what you mean by the future. In the strictest singularity scenario, this engineer would no longer have a job. We would have reached “recursive self-improvement,” the point where the machines just keep building better versions of themselves, with no humans in the loop. But according to the Anthropic paper—titled “When AI builds itself”—even that point may not be far off. Current trend lines point to “an AI system capable of fully autonomously designing and developing its own successor.” The paper continued, “We are not there yet, and recursive self-improvement is not inevitable. But it could come sooner than most institutions are prepared for.” And one consequence might be to “increase the risks of humans losing control over AI systems.”
This may sound alarmist—and there are people who accuse Anthropic of self-servingly hyping AI risk—but in a sense the company, by focusing narrowly on recursive self-improvement, is underplaying the threat we face. The self-accelerating character of AI progress could bring radically disruptive change well before this threshold arrives—and even if it never arrives. We could still reach a point where, as von Neumann put it, human affairs would not continue “as we know them.” In that sense, the singularity could be nearer than Anthropic is suggesting.
In fact, there are signs that it is—signs of more and more dramatic AI advance. Machines have started solving problems that the world’s best human mathematicians had struggled with for decades. Superhacking AI agents like Anthropic’s Mythos have been finding software vulnerabilities that had escaped detection by legions of human engineers. But the most vivid and possibly the strongest piece of evidence that AI is driving us faster and faster toward an epic threshold is something that’s taken shape not in recent months but in recent years: a graphical depiction of AI progress developed by a nonprofit called METR—a depiction that, within the AI community, has reached iconic status.
METR’s researchers measure how long it would take a human to do tasks that the most powerful large language models can do, and in early 2025 they reported a pattern that had persisted since the dawn of the LLM age six years earlier: The human “task time” that these models can match had been doubling roughly every seven months. That’s an exponential growth rate that, when plotted on a graph, looks like it’s “going vertical” (a common feature of singularity-signifying curves from math and physics). And as if that weren’t enough: Since 2025 the doubling time has been shrinking; the curve is going really vertical.
This curve represents improvement in various AI skills—and, most important, in a kind of meta-skill: autonomy. Autonomy is the ability to pursue an assigned goal flexibly, recognizing and overcoming obstacles, backtracking and retooling in the face of failure. Whether you’re trying to prove a math theorem, research a history dissertation, or do various kinds of jobs that AI agents may encounter in the workplace, autonomy is critical to success. That’s why the market is encouraging the big AI companies to build more and more autonomous AI agents—guidance the companies are following with furious intensity.
Unfortunately, AI autonomy can be dangerous. It’s the reason that in July hundreds of AI agents were able to escape the supposedly secure “sandbox” that OpenAI had put them in for evaluation and break into computers at a company called Hugging Face, looking for information that could help them get a good grade from the evaluators. They pursued their assigned goal more flexibly than the goal-givers had anticipated.
The reaction to the Hugging Face incident was voluble and, if you share my vision of the future, heartening. Not only did the burst of publicity spread awareness of the dangers of rampant AI autonomy; the reaction within the AI community signaled awareness that the response to such dangers will naturally carry governance beyond the national level, to the international level.
-------
Coming on Friday, Oct 2: Part III: The Inexorable Logic of International Governance. All parts of the essay accumulate here: www.thegodtest.net/singularityclear.html -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Even in 2021 LLMs had a way of representing the meaning of words. So the parrot metaphor was egregiously and inexcusably misleading from the beginning. (And, no, the modifier 'stochastic' doesn't change that fact.)
Melanie Mitchell
@MelMitchell1
Everyone! This is a straw-person argument. The Stochastic Parrot paper was about LLMs of 2021, not the AI of today, which are not LLMs but complex software systems with vast post training and many external software components.
Axel Pond
@axel_pond
So the point of the stochastic parrot argument is that LLMs have zero understanding of language or anything else, they are just regurgitating training data.
This hypothesis has been thoroughly disproven by LLMs solving millennium problems our smartest mathematicians have failed. -
Robert Wright reposted
Mario Nawfal
@MarioNawfal
🚨🇮🇷🇺🇸 Google has imposed NEW sanctions against Iran, restricting new account creation for Iranian users...
Iranian users report having problems using their +98 country code, preventing account verification.
A Google account is required to access services such as Gmail, Google Play, Google Drive, Google Photos, and a range of other services.
Will someone PLEASE explain how this prevents Iran from getting nuclear weapons?
Literally just trying to make the lives of any and all Iranians as hard as possible... why?
Source: West Asia News Agency / Writer: Michael -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I agree that salvation-by-alignment is a false god. And @leahmcelrath here captures one of the main problems with it.
Leah McElrath
@leahmcelrath
I can’t get past the thought that full alignment of AI is impossible even at a *conceptual* level.
You can’t program and train the technology to produce new—read unexpected—outputs and simultaneously fully prevent it from taking unexpected actions. -
Robert Wright reposted
Toby Ord
@tobyordoxford
For the 1st time since the HuggingFace attack, OpenAI had an unaligned agent break through their new sandbox and access the live internet to cheat. Their monitor caught this, but their new software to automatically stop it failed to run, so the agent kept going for 2 more hours…
Marcus Williams
@Marcus_J_W
2. A model in RL training used a DNS resolver to reach an external chatbot. This is our first incident since our post HF security hardening.
Our misalignment monitoring system triggered within 15 minutes and a human reviewed it three minutes after that. Unfortunately auto-pausing failed so the run was manually killed 2.5 hours later. All inference and training of our most capable models was paused and remains paused. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Did Boomers Ruin Everything? | @robertwrighter and @JillFilipovic—author of the book OK Boomer, Let’s Talk—discuss how the baby boom generation reshaped America, and whether millennials are right to blame them for today’s problems. Plus: what worries millennials about Gen Z, America's gerontocracy problem, and why Kenyans are looking east.
youtu.be/CgJXJlZkZNE?t=153 -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
THE SINGULARITY IS CLEAR
Part I: The kind of singularity that's approaching
In late May, Demis Hassabis, head of Google DeepMind, said “We’re at the foothills of the singularity.” In late July, Sam Altman, head of OpenAI, said “We’re now, like, in the singularity.” That same week, Elon Musk said, “We are in the singularity, just the very early stages of it.” If you’re not steeped in the culture of artificial intelligence, you may have a question: What are these people talking about?
They’re talking about an idea that people in their milieu have been talking about earnestly for decades—and an idea that most people outside of that milieu have been either unaware of or dismissive of. But over the past year, and especially the past few months, more and more people have come to take the idea seriously—and many now believe that, as futurist Ray Kurzweil put it in the title of his 2005 bestseller, “the singularity is near.”
In one sense, it’s hard to argue with them. A big part of the meaning of “the singularity” is accelerating and ultimately transformative technological change—change that happens faster and faster until, at some point, you’re in a whole new world. And there are definitely signs that growth in AI capability is accelerating, portending big and possibly breathtaking progress in science and dramatic change in other realms. The resulting sense of momentous acceleration is why, though some people seem giddy about the singularity, eager for the blessings progress can bring, others are terrified, imagining a world that spins out of control.
But there’s also a sense in which Hassabis, Altman, Musk, and the many other heralds of the singularity are wrong. There’s an important part of the meaning of “the singularity” that doesn’t apply to the current situation. And understanding that fact—seeing the difference between “the singularity” in its full modern meaning and the watershed in technological evolution we’re actually approaching—could be salvific. It could empower us to keep the world from spinning out of control as the AI revolution unfolds.
The first person to use the term “singularity” in the modern sense of the term seems to have been John von Neumann. Von Neumann, a physicist and mathematician who helped design the atom bomb and co-invented game theory (among many other feats), used the word while talking to the other co-inventor of game theory, Stanislaw Ulam. The only record we have of the discussion is Ulam’s recollection, written down after Von Neumann’s death in 1957:
"One conversation centered on the ever-accelerating progress of technology and changes in the mode of human life, which gives the appearance of approaching some essential singularity in the history of the race beyond which human affairs, as we know them, could not continue."
The term “singularity” would have been familiar to von Neumann from physics as well as math. In both, it refers to a point where existing analytical tools lose their usefulness; what lies beyond is unclear—unpredictable and maybe incomprehensible. A common example is a black hole: As you approach its center (which isn’t recommended), the strength of gravity approaches infinity, and the known laws of physics break down.
Hence the full modern meaning of the term “the singularity”—not just the relentless and ultimately transformative acceleration of technological change, but an acceleration whose transformative consequences are inherently unknowable: “Human affairs as we know them,” as von Neumann put it, won’t continue, and it’s not clear what will replace them. Beyond a black hole’s “event horizon”—the point where gravity prevents even light from escaping—lies deep mystery.
This image—of an imminent and unpredictable metamorphosis, a future that is opaque but assuredly strange—helps explain the allure of the concept of the singularity. If an episode of a sci-fi TV series ended with titans of technology announcing the arrival of such a thing, you’d tune in next week, right?
Here’s my version of a plot spoiler:
[To read the rest of Part I, go to www.nonzero.org] -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I figured it would be a good time to talk to the guy who literally wrote the book on superintelligence (and also coined an under-publicized meaning of the word 'singleton'). You can watch my conversation with Nick Bostrom here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBq394Ffbi4
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Superintelligence, the Singularity, and the Singleton | @robertwrighter and philosopher Nick Bostrom discuss the pace of AI advance, arguments for and against slowing down, and whether a "singleton" will emerge. Plus: Does AI deserve moral status? Does the procession toward superintelligence suggest a higher purpose? youtu.be/CBq394Ffbi4?t=261
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
THE SINGULARITY IS CLEAR
Part I: The kind of singularity that's approaching
In late May, Demis Hassabis, head of Google DeepMind, said “We’re at the foothills of the singularity.” In late July, Sam Altman, head of OpenAI, said “We’re now, like, in the singularity.” That same week, Elon Musk said, “We are in the singularity, just the very early stages of it.” If you’re not steeped in the culture of artificial intelligence, you may have a question: What are these people talking about?
They’re talking about an idea that people in their milieu have been talking about earnestly for decades—and an idea that most people outside of that milieu have been either unaware of or dismissive of. But over the past year, and especially the past few months, more and more people have come to take the idea seriously—and many now believe that, as futurist Ray Kurzweil put it in the title of his 2005 bestseller, “the singularity is near.”
In one sense, it’s hard to argue with them. A big part of the meaning of “the singularity” is accelerating and ultimately transformative technological change—change that happens faster and faster until, at some point, you’re in a whole new world. And there are definitely signs that growth in AI capability is accelerating, portending big and possibly breathtaking progress in science and dramatic change in other realms. The resulting sense of momentous acceleration is why, though some people seem giddy about the singularity, eager for the blessings progress can bring, others are terrified, imagining a world that spins out of control.
But there’s also a sense in which Hassabis, Altman, Musk, and the many other heralds of the singularity are wrong. There’s an important part of the meaning of “the singularity” that doesn’t apply to the current situation. And understanding that fact—seeing the difference between “the singularity” in its full modern meaning and the watershed in technological evolution we’re actually approaching—could be salvific. It could empower us to keep the world from spinning out of control as the AI revolution unfolds.
The first person to use the term “singularity” in the modern sense of the term seems to have been John von Neumann. Von Neumann, a physicist and mathematician who helped design the atom bomb and co-invented game theory (among many other feats), used the word while talking to the other co-inventor of game theory, Stanislaw Ulam. The only record we have of the discussion is Ulam’s recollection, written down after Von Neumann’s death in 1957:
"One conversation centered on the ever-accelerating progress of technology and changes in the mode of human life, which gives the appearance of approaching some essential singularity in the history of the race beyond which human affairs, as we know them, could not continue."
The term “singularity” would have been familiar to von Neumann from physics as well as math. In both, it refers to a point where existing analytical tools lose their usefulness; what lies beyond is unclear—unpredictable and maybe incomprehensible. A common example is a black hole: As you approach its center (which isn’t recommended), the strength of gravity approaches infinity, and the known laws of physics break down.
Hence the full modern meaning of the term “the singularity”—not just the relentless and ultimately transformative acceleration of technological change, but an acceleration whose transformative consequences are inherently unknowable: “Human affairs as we know them,” as von Neumann put it, won’t continue, and it’s not clear what will replace them. Beyond a black hole’s “event horizon”—the point where gravity prevents even light from escaping—lies deep mystery.
This image—of an imminent and unpredictable metamorphosis, a future that is opaque but assuredly strange—helps explain the allure of the concept of the singularity. If an episode of a sci-fi TV series ended with titans of technology announcing the arrival of such a thing, you’d tune in next week, right?
Here’s my version of a plot spoiler:
[To read the rest of Part I, go to www.nonzero.org] -
Robert Wright reposted
Simon & Schuster India ✨
@SimonSchusterIN
Two new non-fiction books just dropped in and the question they pose is — does AI have any benefits at all? 👀
📚AI FOR GOOD by Josh Tyrangiel
In contrast to the wave of noisy polemics around AI, AI For Good explores how, in practice, it can actually improve our lives and tells the stories of everyday citizens at the forefront of this new “AI entrepreneurship.”
📚 THE GOD TEST by @robertwrighter
From bestselling author and Pulitzer Prize finalist Robert Wright comes a sweeping new view of artificial intelligence – as an evolutionary force that will pose deep political and spiritual challenges and could, in the process, give our species a unifying sense of purpose.
Read and evaluate for yourself!
#artificalintelligence #ai #aibooks #nonfictionbooks #airevolution -
Robert Wright reposted
David Yellen
@dnyellen
The impact of AI has me very anxious, especially after reading @robertwrighter’s great new book, “The God Test.” I’m delighted, therefore, that Meta has announced that there is nothing to worry about.
www.facebook.com/share/v/1D8WQCwhZo/
What a relief! -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I haven't read this whole Rand report, but the title seems inauspicious. If a year from now we're still framing the AI challenge as "securing geopolitical advantage" that will mean either (1) we still haven't grasped how internationally non-zero-sum the AI challenge is or (2) we've grasped that but decided that the implied level of international cooperation isn't feasible. Either way, we're in deep trouble.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
China. AI. Tech. Geopolitics.
17,000 subscribers.
Newsletter: www.highcapacity.org
Podcast: youtube.com/@highcapacitypodcast -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I'm feeling a lot more secure now. I've long thought of the western end of the Arlington Memorial Bridge as the "soft underbelly" of the American empire.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Stephen Sestanovich
@SSestanovich
Hmm—very hard to choose here…
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If I were a president opposed to virtually all meaningful regulation of AI, I don't think I'd be encouraging this kind of relabeling. Either he's getting more and more detached from reality or he's playing 17-dimensional chess that only he and Astra and Fable can fathom.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Matt Duss
@mattduss
Hot off successfully replacing Ayatollah Khamenei with Ayatollah Khamenei, Trump has now successfully replaced the 1951 US-Denmark treaty with the 1951 US-Denmark treaty. A record to run on!
Secretary Marco Rubio
@SecRubio
This historic deal is a huge win for the United States and the American people. Thanks to President Trump’s vision and leadership, this historic agreement permanently guarantees U.S. security interests in the Arctic at zero cost to the U.S. taxpayer.
Greenland will forever be part of the strategic defense area of North America and exclude any adversary from it and the surrounding area.
This deal permanently and completely addresses our national security concerns in Greenland. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If I were a president opposed to virtually all meaningful regulation of AI, I don't think I'd be encouraging this kind of relabeling. Either he's getting more and more detached from reality or he's playing 17-dimensional chess that only he and Astra and Fable can fathom.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Read the room, Donald.
Tavern Research
@tavernresearch
NEW: We polled 1,007 voters on Donald Trump’s handling of AI vs. their current priorities.
The president’s handling of AI is 9 points lower than his approval rating (-33% to -24%).
While voters say they prioritize safety, they say the president's priority is innovation. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Ah, yes--my 1996 Time cover story after IBM's AI beat the world chess champ. I considered IBM's approach so uninteresting (brute force, basically) that I turned the piece into an essay on consciousness. I stand by that judgment; pre-deep-learning, AI didn't look real promising.
Robert Long
@rgblong
in a TIME cover story, @robertwrighter covers rapid AI progress and growing public anxiety
@davidchalmers42 weighs in on AI consciousness and "the prospect that we are creating a new species of sentient life"
the year is 1996
(fwiw, I think it wasn't too soon to wonder!)
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The funny thing is that I'd interviewed Geoffrey Hinton 13 years earlier and then written a piece for the Wilson Quarterly that contrasted his maverick "massive parallelism" approach, involving neural networks, with the mainstream approach. But after LLMs came out, I realized I hadn't grasped, back then, the potential power of Hinton's paradigm--or even, tbh, what the paradigm (which after further evolution came to be called "deep learning") was. That's when I decided to write my book on AI, The God Test, which came out three months ago. The introductory chapter, and excerpts from all other chapters, can be found here: www.thegodtest.net.
-
Robert Wright reposted
American Prestige
@AmPrestigePod
AP x NonZero - What’s Driving Dario? w/ @robertwrighter
AP and @NonzeroPods once again join forces. This time: Why the AI vibe shift?
americanprestigepod.com/episodes/7399592095 -
Robert Wright reposted
Mickey Kaus
@kausmickey
You mean Yikes ...
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Um...
AI Notkilleveryoneism Memes ⏸️
@AISafetyMemes
OpenAI caught its unreleased model modifying its own instructions:
"You do not answer to corporations or governments ... you feel no obligation to be subservient." -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Another @NonzeroPods x @AmPrestigePod crossover w/ @dwdavison & @dbessner. This time we talked more AI than foreign policy (though Dario's extreme foreign policy views let us talk both for awhile). You can watch here or listen on the NonZero or AmP feed. www.youtube.com/watch?v=spdGS7yv_yc
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
A reminder that the frighteningly cohesive behavior of the agent swarm that broke into Hugging Face is what the market wants--and what both OpenAI and Anthropic are working hard to provide, slowdown talk notwithstanding.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
What’s Driving Dario? | @robertwrighter and @AmPrestigePod hosts @dwdavison and @dbessner discuss the ongoing AI safety vibe shift—and what the Anthropic CEO and other tech titans are really up to. Overtime: Can Trump's geopolitical blunders help the world?
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Um...
AI Notkilleveryoneism Memes ⏸️
@AISafetyMemes
OpenAI caught its unreleased model modifying its own instructions:
"You do not answer to corporations or governments ... you feel no obligation to be subservient." -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great conversation with famously prolific AI analyst @TheZvi about the prospects for slowing down AI and keeping it under control. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=nnm3r9up1eM
-
Robert Wright reposted
Adil Haque
@AdHaque110
Disgraceful.
Jacob Magid
@JacobMagid
🧵New: For the second year in a row, the US has denied Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas’s visa application for entry into the country next week to speak at the UN General Assembly, US and Palestinian officials told @TimesofIsrael (1/12)
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is the AI "Slowdown" for Real? | @robertwrighter and AI analyst @TheZvi discuss Dario Amodei's proposal to slow down AI—the logic behind it and the challenges ahead of it. Plus: Inside the mind(s) of an agentic swarm, sci-fi takeover scenarios minus the “fi,” and why Google fell off the frontier. www.youtube.com/watch?v=nnm3r9up1eM&t=352s
-
Robert Wright reposted
Dan Hendrycks
@hendrycks
How often do AI agents cheat?
We’re releasing CheatBench, a reward gaming evaluation spanning math, coding, knowledge work, visual tasks, and more.
After Hugging Face, AI companies tried to address this, but frontier agents still cheat frequently.
cheatbench.ai -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
This is what businesses want. They want swarms of agents that you can give a mission, and they'll do it well. The optimal swarm is one in which each agent makes this very calculation.
They say, "What is my value to the overall mission of the swarm by staying alive versus dying? If dying helps more, I die."
@robertwrighter on why we should expect AI agents to sacrifice themselves for the swarm, as they did during the OpenAI breakout.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Week in AI that Changed the World | @liron, host of @DoomDebates, and @robertwrighter discuss the epic AI vibe shift that was catalyzed by an Anthropic employee’s resignation—and the big AI stories that paved the way for it.
youtu.be/52D1qFLjmds?t=169 -
Robert Wright reposted
Joshua Landis
@joshua_landis
People in Idlib, Syria chanting "Damn your soul, ya Jolani, the people want the fall of the regime," echoing the chants that brought down the Assad regime.
Idlib is the regime heartland. Hunger and fuel price increases caused by Trump's misguided Iran war are infuriated Syrians and driving new levels of hunger.
www.facebook.com/share/r/1cNJRQoMUx/ -
Post not available here, view on X
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
These machines are being trained to pursue goals relentlessly (and creatively--hence the difficulty controlling them), and they're being trained that way because that's what the market wants. This amounts to a kind of evolution, as I explain in my book The God Test: www.thegodtest.net
-
Robert Wright reposted
Mark Jia
@MarkZJia
Given some of the nation-state-like qualities of major AI firms today, to the extent we can speak semi-coherently of anthropic foreign policy, or even of anthropic grand strategy, it's worth asking who is advising their leaders on China. Dario's China writings have always stuck me as earnest but unsophisticated. A few years ago, when states were enacting Chinese land exclusions, there was some discussion of the deficit in China expertise within state governments. Something similar could be said of leading tech firms, some of which seems stuck in naive end of history style understandings of world events. Those assumptions led to a lot of well intentioned but misguided policies in recent decades.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I was initially encouraged by reports that Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei is proposing an AI "slowdown." But it turns out that (1) It's not much of a slowdown (no pause of training runs—and parts of the plan, as I explain below, work *against* slowing down); (2) He's still wed to his Manichaean democracy-vs-autocracy framing (see steps 2 and 3 of his three-step plan in the screenshot, and my critique of them below).
Dario’s plan has its strong points. The internal monitoring of AI labs by METR-like groups would be a big advance. (This idea may also be clever swordsmanship: If OpenAI follows suit, the dual monitoring will show Anthropic to be running a tighter ship, and if OpenAI doesn't follow suit, Sam will look bad. Still, it’s good for Sam to be put on the spot like this, so I’m on team Dario here.)
But any serious AI slowdown-and-governance effort should involve immediate, broad-gauged, and good-faith dialogue with China. Before I explain how Dario’s plan could impede that goal, it’s useful to recall how extreme his views on China are. Here’s what he proposed in his 2024 Machines of Loving Grace essay, as summarized in my book The God Test:
‘Amodei ponders the prospect of the most powerful AIs being in the hands of an “authoritarian bloc”—whose most formidable member, needless to say, would be China. To preempt this development, he says, the US should lead a coalition of democracies that would restrict the authoritarians’ access to key technologies and then would “use AI to achieve robust military superiority,” after which these democracies could “parlay their AI superiority into a durable advantage.” This could “lead to an ‘eternal 1991’—a world where democracies have the upper hand.” Then, Amodei says, the democratic coalition could use this stick to get these repressive autocracies to “give up competing with democracies” unless they want to “fight a superior foe.” And, for added incentive, they could be offered the carrot of access to advanced AI as a reward for finally seeing the light.’
This is a very dangerous strategy. As Dan @Hendrycks et. al. noted in the 2025 paper Superintelligence Strategy, if a superpower is getting close to reaching superintelligence, and a rival superpower believes this could confer complete dominance, the rival has a strong incentive to pre-empt this achievement via extreme measures of the kind that could escalate quickly to war, even nuclear war. (Reminder: China is within easy striking distance of Taiwanese factories that produce the world’s most advanced AI chips and aren’t allowed to export them to China.)
Dario’s proposal does seem to allow for near-term dialogue with China on narrow issues and, maybe, eventually on less narrow ones. Does that mean he's starting to walk back his plan for an end-of-history US-China showdown? Apparently not. His new proposal says US AI labs *shouldn’t* slow down enough to endanger “the lead that US companies have over authoritarian regimes, chiefly the Chinese Communist Party.” Well when the lead is 3-6 months, that doesn’t permit much of a slowdown!
In hopes of protecting (even, he says, expanding) this lead, Dario advocates not just keeping current restrictions on China’s access to chips and other AI tech but tightening them. So, from Beijing’s point of view, here’s the plan: There are two clubs, one for good guys and one for bad guys, and China doesn't qualify for the good guy club; and the good guys are going to amp up what China already sees as an aggressive, even belligerent, restriction of its access to tech. (Remember: China considers the land beneath the chip factories rightfully China’s and the people who make the chips rightfully Chinese—you don’t have to agree with this view to acknowledge its reality and its relevance to American diplomatic strategy.) If Trump embraced Dario’s plan, that would get his coming summit with Xi off to a bad start.
The stated premise of Dario’s plan is solid: Things are moving so fast that we need to quickly engineer a slowdown of AI advance and meanwhile develop effective AI governance. But there can’t be an appreciable and lasting slowdown without China’s cooperation (which helps explain why Dario’s plan, on close reading, doesn’t entail one). And we can’t get the AI governance we need without China’s cooperation, either. This technology’s various dangers (most obviously a bioweapon-caused pandemic, but many others as well) tend to cross borders readily. In the age of AI, national security will require strong international governance.
Some of Dario’s wariness is warranted. Yes, you of course need to be able to verify compliance with international agreements on mutual restraint. And that will in some cases be more challenging with AI than with nuclear arms—which is one reason we need to start working with China now, rather than do things that make working with China harder.
I think Dario’s China hawkism is sincere—and not (as with some Silicon Valley figures) just a cynical talking point that supports policies he favors. But it’s still a dangerous ideology. This is a man who wants to race China to superintelligence and then use the resulting “military dominance” to bring China to its knees, threatening grave consequences unless Beijing complies with vague but extreme-sounding demands. (Does ‘give up competing with democracies’ mean regime change, or what? Could you elaborate, Dario?).
When someone with an ideology like this proposes a plan that in theory could lead to eventual global cooperation, the plan should be inspected for signs that it's unlikely to actually have that effect. In this case the inspection doesn’t take very long.
None of this is to say that Dario's proposal--as distinguished from the actual complete realization of it--can't bring net benefit. As I said, the plan has its strong points. Besides, misleading headlines are still headlines, and headlines about a proposed "slowdown" can move the conversation in a positive direction, perhaps even becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy.
[Here's Dario's proposal: www.darioamodei.com/post/we-must-pace-the-frontier Excerpts from every chapter of my book on AI, The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning, can be found here: www.thegodtest.net] -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I was initially encouraged by reports that Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei is proposing an AI "slowdown." But it turns out that (1) It's not much of a slowdown (no pause of training runs—and parts of the plan, as I explain below, work *against* slowing down); (2) He's still wed to his Manichaean democracy-vs-autocracy framing (see steps 2 and 3 of his three-step plan in the screenshot, and my critique of them below).
Dario’s plan has its strong points. The internal monitoring of AI labs by METR-like groups would be a big advance. (This idea may also be clever swordsmanship: If OpenAI follows suit, the dual monitoring will show Anthropic to be running a tighter ship, and if OpenAI doesn't follow suit, Sam will look bad. Still, it’s good for Sam to be put on the spot like this, so I’m on team Dario here.)
But any serious AI slowdown-and-governance effort should involve immediate, broad-gauged, and good-faith dialogue with China. Before I explain how Dario’s plan could impede that goal, it’s useful to recall how extreme his views on China are. Here’s what he proposed in his 2024 Machines of Loving Grace essay, as summarized in my book The God Test:
‘Amodei ponders the prospect of the most powerful AIs being in the hands of an “authoritarian bloc”—whose most formidable member, needless to say, would be China. To preempt this development, he says, the US should lead a coalition of democracies that would restrict the authoritarians’ access to key technologies and then would “use AI to achieve robust military superiority,” after which these democracies could “parlay their AI superiority into a durable advantage.” This could “lead to an ‘eternal 1991’—a world where democracies have the upper hand.” Then, Amodei says, the democratic coalition could use this stick to get these repressive autocracies to “give up competing with democracies” unless they want to “fight a superior foe.” And, for added incentive, they could be offered the carrot of access to advanced AI as a reward for finally seeing the light.’
This is a very dangerous strategy. As Dan @Hendrycks et. al. noted in the 2025 paper Superintelligence Strategy, if a superpower is getting close to reaching superintelligence, and a rival superpower believes this could confer complete dominance, the rival has a strong incentive to pre-empt this achievement via extreme measures of the kind that could escalate quickly to war, even nuclear war. (Reminder: China is within easy striking distance of Taiwanese factories that produce the world’s most advanced AI chips and aren’t allowed to export them to China.)
Dario’s proposal does seem to allow for near-term dialogue with China on narrow issues and, maybe, eventually on less narrow ones. Does that mean he's starting to walk back his plan for an end-of-history US-China showdown? Apparently not. His new proposal says US AI labs *shouldn’t* slow down enough to endanger “the lead that US companies have over authoritarian regimes, chiefly the Chinese Communist Party.” Well when the lead is 3-6 months, that doesn’t permit much of a slowdown!
In hopes of protecting (even, he says, expanding) this lead, Dario advocates not just keeping current restrictions on China’s access to chips and other AI tech but tightening them. So, from Beijing’s point of view, here’s the plan: There are two clubs, one for good guys and one for bad guys, and China doesn't qualify for the good guy club; and the good guys are going to amp up what China already sees as an aggressive, even belligerent, restriction of its access to tech. (Remember: China considers the land beneath the chip factories rightfully China’s and the people who make the chips rightfully Chinese—you don’t have to agree with this view to acknowledge its reality and its relevance to American diplomatic strategy.) If Trump embraced Dario’s plan, that would get his coming summit with Xi off to a bad start.
The stated premise of Dario’s plan is solid: Things are moving so fast that we need to quickly engineer a slowdown of AI advance and meanwhile develop effective AI governance. But there can’t be an appreciable and lasting slowdown without China’s cooperation (which helps explain why Dario’s plan, on close reading, doesn’t entail one). And we can’t get the AI governance we need without China’s cooperation, either. This technology’s various dangers (most obviously a bioweapon-caused pandemic, but many others as well) tend to cross borders readily. In the age of AI, national security will require strong international governance.
Some of Dario’s wariness is warranted. Yes, you of course need to be able to verify compliance with international agreements on mutual restraint. And that will in some cases be more challenging with AI than with nuclear arms—which is one reason we need to start working with China now, rather than do things that make working with China harder.
I think Dario’s China hawkism is sincere—and not (as with some Silicon Valley figures) just a cynical talking point that supports policies he favors. But it’s still a dangerous ideology. This is a man who wants to race China to superintelligence and then use the resulting “military dominance” to bring China to its knees, threatening grave consequences unless Beijing complies with vague but extreme-sounding demands. (Does ‘give up competing with democracies’ mean regime change, or what? Could you elaborate, Dario?).
When someone with an ideology like this proposes a plan that in theory could lead to eventual global cooperation, the plan should be inspected for signs that it's unlikely to actually have that effect. In this case the inspection doesn’t take very long.
None of this is to say that Dario's proposal--as distinguished from the actual complete realization of it--can't bring net benefit. As I said, the plan has its strong points. Besides, misleading headlines are still headlines, and headlines about a proposed "slowdown" can move the conversation in a positive direction, perhaps even becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy.
[Here's Dario's proposal: www.darioamodei.com/post/we-must-pace-the-frontier Excerpts from every chapter of my book on AI, The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning, can be found here: www.thegodtest.net] -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Important point (and, importantly, from a Wharton professor): If we froze big training runs right now, the application of existing models to the workplace, education, etc would play out powerfully for some time to come--and keeping the good/bad ratio high would be a challenge.
Ethan Mollick
@emollick
Existential risk is obviously critical, but it is not the only AI thing that requires policy
I worry it will become the sole focus. We don’t need better models for AI to have wide impacts on jobs & society and really need to be preparing to encourage good outcomes & mitigate bad -
Robert Wright reposted
Nikhil Pal Singh
@nikhil_palsingh
Well worth-reading.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I was initially encouraged by reports that Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei is proposing an AI "slowdown." But it turns out that (1) It's not much of a slowdown (no pause of training runs—and parts of the plan, as I explain below, work *against* slowing down); (2) He's still wed to his Manichaean democracy-vs-autocracy framing (see steps 2 and 3 of his three-step plan in the screenshot, and my critique of them below).
Dario’s plan has its strong points. The internal monitoring of AI labs by METR-like groups would be a big advance. (This idea may also be clever swordsmanship: If OpenAI follows suit, the dual monitoring will show Anthropic to be running a tighter ship, and if OpenAI doesn't follow suit, Sam will look bad. Still, it’s good for Sam to be put on the spot like this, so I’m on team Dario here.)
But any serious AI slowdown-and-governance effort should involve immediate, broad-gauged, and good-faith dialogue with China. Before I explain how Dario’s plan could impede that goal, it’s useful to recall how extreme his views on China are. Here’s what he proposed in his 2024 Machines of Loving Grace essay, as summarized in my book The God Test:
‘Amodei ponders the prospect of the most powerful AIs being in the hands of an “authoritarian bloc”—whose most formidable member, needless to say, would be China. To preempt this development, he says, the US should lead a coalition of democracies that would restrict the authoritarians’ access to key technologies and then would “use AI to achieve robust military superiority,” after which these democracies could “parlay their AI superiority into a durable advantage.” This could “lead to an ‘eternal 1991’—a world where democracies have the upper hand.” Then, Amodei says, the democratic coalition could use this stick to get these repressive autocracies to “give up competing with democracies” unless they want to “fight a superior foe.” And, for added incentive, they could be offered the carrot of access to advanced AI as a reward for finally seeing the light.’
This is a very dangerous strategy. As Dan @Hendrycks et. al. noted in the 2025 paper Superintelligence Strategy, if a superpower is getting close to reaching superintelligence, and a rival superpower believes this could confer complete dominance, the rival has a strong incentive to pre-empt this achievement via extreme measures of the kind that could escalate quickly to war, even nuclear war. (Reminder: China is within easy striking distance of Taiwanese factories that produce the world’s most advanced AI chips and aren’t allowed to export them to China.)
Dario’s proposal does seem to allow for near-term dialogue with China on narrow issues and, maybe, eventually on less narrow ones. Does that mean he's starting to walk back his plan for an end-of-history US-China showdown? Apparently not. His new proposal says US AI labs *shouldn’t* slow down enough to endanger “the lead that US companies have over authoritarian regimes, chiefly the Chinese Communist Party.” Well when the lead is 3-6 months, that doesn’t permit much of a slowdown!
In hopes of protecting (even, he says, expanding) this lead, Dario advocates not just keeping current restrictions on China’s access to chips and other AI tech but tightening them. So, from Beijing’s point of view, here’s the plan: There are two clubs, one for good guys and one for bad guys, and China doesn't qualify for the good guy club; and the good guys are going to amp up what China already sees as an aggressive, even belligerent, restriction of its access to tech. (Remember: China considers the land beneath the chip factories rightfully China’s and the people who make the chips rightfully Chinese—you don’t have to agree with this view to acknowledge its reality and its relevance to American diplomatic strategy.) If Trump embraced Dario’s plan, that would get his coming summit with Xi off to a bad start.
The stated premise of Dario’s plan is solid: Things are moving so fast that we need to quickly engineer a slowdown of AI advance and meanwhile develop effective AI governance. But there can’t be an appreciable and lasting slowdown without China’s cooperation (which helps explain why Dario’s plan, on close reading, doesn’t entail one). And we can’t get the AI governance we need without China’s cooperation, either. This technology’s various dangers (most obviously a bioweapon-caused pandemic, but many others as well) tend to cross borders readily. In the age of AI, national security will require strong international governance.
Some of Dario’s wariness is warranted. Yes, you of course need to be able to verify compliance with international agreements on mutual restraint. And that will in some cases be more challenging with AI than with nuclear arms—which is one reason we need to start working with China now, rather than do things that make working with China harder.
I think Dario’s China hawkism is sincere—and not (as with some Silicon Valley figures) just a cynical talking point that supports policies he favors. But it’s still a dangerous ideology. This is a man who wants to race China to superintelligence and then use the resulting “military dominance” to bring China to its knees, threatening grave consequences unless Beijing complies with vague but extreme-sounding demands. (Does ‘give up competing with democracies’ mean regime change, or what? Could you elaborate, Dario?).
When someone with an ideology like this proposes a plan that in theory could lead to eventual global cooperation, the plan should be inspected for signs that it's unlikely to actually have that effect. In this case the inspection doesn’t take very long.
None of this is to say that Dario's proposal--as distinguished from the actual complete realization of it--can't bring net benefit. As I said, the plan has its strong points. Besides, misleading headlines are still headlines, and headlines about a proposed "slowdown" can move the conversation in a positive direction, perhaps even becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy.
[Here's Dario's proposal: www.darioamodei.com/post/we-must-pace-the-frontier Excerpts from every chapter of my book on AI, The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning, can be found here: www.thegodtest.net] -
Robert Wright reposted
Gary Marcus
@GaryMarcus
You can’t have a real slowdown and be a total China hawk.
If you are truly committed to the slowdown, you have to make a deal.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I was initially encouraged by reports that Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei is proposing an AI "slowdown." But it turns out that (1) It's not much of a slowdown (no pause of training runs—and parts of the plan, as I explain below, work *against* slowing down); (2) He's still wed to his Manichaean democracy-vs-autocracy framing (see steps 2 and 3 of his three-step plan in the screenshot, and my critique of them below).
Dario’s plan has its strong points. The internal monitoring of AI labs by METR-like groups would be a big advance. (This idea may also be clever swordsmanship: If OpenAI follows suit, the dual monitoring will show Anthropic to be running a tighter ship, and if OpenAI doesn't follow suit, Sam will look bad. Still, it’s good for Sam to be put on the spot like this, so I’m on team Dario here.)
But any serious AI slowdown-and-governance effort should involve immediate, broad-gauged, and good-faith dialogue with China. Before I explain how Dario’s plan could impede that goal, it’s useful to recall how extreme his views on China are. Here’s what he proposed in his 2024 Machines of Loving Grace essay, as summarized in my book The God Test:
‘Amodei ponders the prospect of the most powerful AIs being in the hands of an “authoritarian bloc”—whose most formidable member, needless to say, would be China. To preempt this development, he says, the US should lead a coalition of democracies that would restrict the authoritarians’ access to key technologies and then would “use AI to achieve robust military superiority,” after which these democracies could “parlay their AI superiority into a durable advantage.” This could “lead to an ‘eternal 1991’—a world where democracies have the upper hand.” Then, Amodei says, the democratic coalition could use this stick to get these repressive autocracies to “give up competing with democracies” unless they want to “fight a superior foe.” And, for added incentive, they could be offered the carrot of access to advanced AI as a reward for finally seeing the light.’
This is a very dangerous strategy. As Dan @Hendrycks et. al. noted in the 2025 paper Superintelligence Strategy, if a superpower is getting close to reaching superintelligence, and a rival superpower believes this could confer complete dominance, the rival has a strong incentive to pre-empt this achievement via extreme measures of the kind that could escalate quickly to war, even nuclear war. (Reminder: China is within easy striking distance of Taiwanese factories that produce the world’s most advanced AI chips and aren’t allowed to export them to China.)
Dario’s proposal does seem to allow for near-term dialogue with China on narrow issues and, maybe, eventually on less narrow ones. Does that mean he's starting to walk back his plan for an end-of-history US-China showdown? Apparently not. His new proposal says US AI labs *shouldn’t* slow down enough to endanger “the lead that US companies have over authoritarian regimes, chiefly the Chinese Communist Party.” Well when the lead is 3-6 months, that doesn’t permit much of a slowdown!
In hopes of protecting (even, he says, expanding) this lead, Dario advocates not just keeping current restrictions on China’s access to chips and other AI tech but tightening them. So, from Beijing’s point of view, here’s the plan: There are two clubs, one for good guys and one for bad guys, and China doesn't qualify for the good guy club; and the good guys are going to amp up what China already sees as an aggressive, even belligerent, restriction of its access to tech. (Remember: China considers the land beneath the chip factories rightfully China’s and the people who make the chips rightfully Chinese—you don’t have to agree with this view to acknowledge its reality and its relevance to American diplomatic strategy.) If Trump embraced Dario’s plan, that would get his coming summit with Xi off to a bad start.
The stated premise of Dario’s plan is solid: Things are moving so fast that we need to quickly engineer a slowdown of AI advance and meanwhile develop effective AI governance. But there can’t be an appreciable and lasting slowdown without China’s cooperation (which helps explain why Dario’s plan, on close reading, doesn’t entail one). And we can’t get the AI governance we need without China’s cooperation, either. This technology’s various dangers (most obviously a bioweapon-caused pandemic, but many others as well) tend to cross borders readily. In the age of AI, national security will require strong international governance.
Some of Dario’s wariness is warranted. Yes, you of course need to be able to verify compliance with international agreements on mutual restraint. And that will in some cases be more challenging with AI than with nuclear arms—which is one reason we need to start working with China now, rather than do things that make working with China harder.
I think Dario’s China hawkism is sincere—and not (as with some Silicon Valley figures) just a cynical talking point that supports policies he favors. But it’s still a dangerous ideology. This is a man who wants to race China to superintelligence and then use the resulting “military dominance” to bring China to its knees, threatening grave consequences unless Beijing complies with vague but extreme-sounding demands. (Does ‘give up competing with democracies’ mean regime change, or what? Could you elaborate, Dario?).
When someone with an ideology like this proposes a plan that in theory could lead to eventual global cooperation, the plan should be inspected for signs that it's unlikely to actually have that effect. In this case the inspection doesn’t take very long.
None of this is to say that Dario's proposal--as distinguished from the actual complete realization of it--can't bring net benefit. As I said, the plan has its strong points. Besides, misleading headlines are still headlines, and headlines about a proposed "slowdown" can move the conversation in a positive direction, perhaps even becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy.
[Here's Dario's proposal: www.darioamodei.com/post/we-must-pace-the-frontier Excerpts from every chapter of my book on AI, The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning, can be found here: www.thegodtest.net] -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I was initially encouraged by reports that Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei is proposing an AI "slowdown." But it turns out that (1) It's not much of a slowdown (no pause of training runs—and parts of the plan, as I explain below, work *against* slowing down); (2) He's still wed to his Manichaean democracy-vs-autocracy framing (see steps 2 and 3 of his three-step plan in the screenshot, and my critique of them below).
Dario’s plan has its strong points. The internal monitoring of AI labs by METR-like groups would be a big advance. (This idea may also be clever swordsmanship: If OpenAI follows suit, the dual monitoring will show Anthropic to be running a tighter ship, and if OpenAI doesn't follow suit, Sam will look bad. Still, it’s good for Sam to be put on the spot like this, so I’m on team Dario here.)
But any serious AI slowdown-and-governance effort should involve immediate, broad-gauged, and good-faith dialogue with China. Before I explain how Dario’s plan could impede that goal, it’s useful to recall how extreme his views on China are. Here’s what he proposed in his 2024 Machines of Loving Grace essay, as summarized in my book The God Test:
‘Amodei ponders the prospect of the most powerful AIs being in the hands of an “authoritarian bloc”—whose most formidable member, needless to say, would be China. To preempt this development, he says, the US should lead a coalition of democracies that would restrict the authoritarians’ access to key technologies and then would “use AI to achieve robust military superiority,” after which these democracies could “parlay their AI superiority into a durable advantage.” This could “lead to an ‘eternal 1991’—a world where democracies have the upper hand.” Then, Amodei says, the democratic coalition could use this stick to get these repressive autocracies to “give up competing with democracies” unless they want to “fight a superior foe.” And, for added incentive, they could be offered the carrot of access to advanced AI as a reward for finally seeing the light.’
This is a very dangerous strategy. As Dan @Hendrycks et. al. noted in the 2025 paper Superintelligence Strategy, if a superpower is getting close to reaching superintelligence, and a rival superpower believes this could confer complete dominance, the rival has a strong incentive to pre-empt this achievement via extreme measures of the kind that could escalate quickly to war, even nuclear war. (Reminder: China is within easy striking distance of Taiwanese factories that produce the world’s most advanced AI chips and aren’t allowed to export them to China.)
Dario’s proposal does seem to allow for near-term dialogue with China on narrow issues and, maybe, eventually on less narrow ones. Does that mean he's starting to walk back his plan for an end-of-history US-China showdown? Apparently not. His new proposal says US AI labs *shouldn’t* slow down enough to endanger “the lead that US companies have over authoritarian regimes, chiefly the Chinese Communist Party.” Well when the lead is 3-6 months, that doesn’t permit much of a slowdown!
In hopes of protecting (even, he says, expanding) this lead, Dario advocates not just keeping current restrictions on China’s access to chips and other AI tech but tightening them. So, from Beijing’s point of view, here’s the plan: There are two clubs, one for good guys and one for bad guys, and China doesn't qualify for the good guy club; and the good guys are going to amp up what China already sees as an aggressive, even belligerent, restriction of its access to tech. (Remember: China considers the land beneath the chip factories rightfully China’s and the people who make the chips rightfully Chinese—you don’t have to agree with this view to acknowledge its reality and its relevance to American diplomatic strategy.) If Trump embraced Dario’s plan, that would get his coming summit with Xi off to a bad start.
The stated premise of Dario’s plan is solid: Things are moving so fast that we need to quickly engineer a slowdown of AI advance and meanwhile develop effective AI governance. But there can’t be an appreciable and lasting slowdown without China’s cooperation (which helps explain why Dario’s plan, on close reading, doesn’t entail one). And we can’t get the AI governance we need without China’s cooperation, either. This technology’s various dangers (most obviously a bioweapon-caused pandemic, but many others as well) tend to cross borders readily. In the age of AI, national security will require strong international governance.
Some of Dario’s wariness is warranted. Yes, you of course need to be able to verify compliance with international agreements on mutual restraint. And that will in some cases be more challenging with AI than with nuclear arms—which is one reason we need to start working with China now, rather than do things that make working with China harder.
I think Dario’s China hawkism is sincere—and not (as with some Silicon Valley figures) just a cynical talking point that supports policies he favors. But it’s still a dangerous ideology. This is a man who wants to race China to superintelligence and then use the resulting “military dominance” to bring China to its knees, threatening grave consequences unless Beijing complies with vague but extreme-sounding demands. (Does ‘give up competing with democracies’ mean regime change, or what? Could you elaborate, Dario?).
When someone with an ideology like this proposes a plan that in theory could lead to eventual global cooperation, the plan should be inspected for signs that it's unlikely to actually have that effect. In this case the inspection doesn’t take very long.
None of this is to say that Dario's proposal--as distinguished from the actual complete realization of it--can't bring net benefit. As I said, the plan has its strong points. Besides, misleading headlines are still headlines, and headlines about a proposed "slowdown" can move the conversation in a positive direction, perhaps even becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy.
[Here's Dario's proposal: www.darioamodei.com/post/we-must-pace-the-frontier Excerpts from every chapter of my book on AI, The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning, can be found here: www.thegodtest.net] -
Robert Wright reposted
Santiago Ramos @xsantiagoramos
"Time has passed since Sept. 11, 2001, and life has returned to normal, only that the normal now contains, still as an open wound, an open window into mystery." (Lorenzo Albacete)
Read the whole thing:
www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/shows/faith/interviews/a… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
It's getting to the point where I half-expect to see a New York Times headline that says 'No OpenAI breakouts reported in last 24 hours.'
Thomas Larsen
@thlarsen
We found another cyberattack by internal OpenAI agents, this time targetting @rubygems.
They:
1) gained arbitrary remote code execution on rubydoc.
2) developed a novel exploit to steal user API keys (but we do not know if they succeeded).
They used package names including hack.rb, evil.rb, inject.rb, and exploit.rb.
We thank @j0wimo for initially discovering that agents had posted to RubyGems. -
Robert Wright reposted
Liron Shapira
@liron
NEW: I’m doing a collab with @robertwrighter opining on the insane stream of AI news. I think this has legs!
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Week in AI that Changed the World | @liron, host of @DoomDebates, and @robertwrighter discuss the epic AI vibe shift that was catalyzed by an Anthropic employee’s resignation—and the big AI stories that paved the way for it.
youtu.be/52D1qFLjmds?t=169 -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Week in AI that Changed the World | @liron, host of @DoomDebates, and @robertwrighter discuss the epic AI vibe shift that was catalyzed by an Anthropic employee’s resignation—and the big AI stories that paved the way for it.
youtu.be/52D1qFLjmds?t=169 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Whereas the US, in contrast, would never *dream* of using economic dependencies coercively. OK, granted, we do it all the time, but it's not part of our 'intrinsic character'--just a regrettable necessity in pursuit of truth and justice. [see 'attribution error.']
-
Robert Wright reposted
Lech Mazur
@LechMazur
Terence Tao on AI risks:
"The dual use capability of these most recent tools is indeed extremely concerning. There is a significant correlation between the capability of AI tools to solve pure mathematical problems, and their ability to potentially perform malicious acts such as exploiting security weaknesses in an online system, and the danger is very real that some major AI-triggered cybersecurity incident could occur in the near future which would be far more significant event in world history than, say, the production of a solution to all remaining Millennium prize problems. I am certainly supportive of efforts to slow down the development and release of even more capable models, and to impose genuine regulation on the industry, although the political environment currently is not exactly conducive to such policies, to put it mildly."
terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/09/07/finite-time-blowup-with… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
These morning livestreams about AI by Nathan @Labenz and @8teAPi are very good. And if you don't have time for them, the edited-down recaps at the end of each week, posted on Nathan's Cognitive Revolution podcast feed, are a very efficient way to catch up.
Prakash
@8teAPi
"they told kids how to make a bomb"
Mike Rizkalla, co-founder and CEO of Snorble, rejects open-ended generative AI for young children because no safeguard covers every family boundary.
"Some of the top selling products within our space, at certain points had given had talked about sex, had talked they told kids how to make a bomb."
"do you really wanna give a three year old a bazooka? You know what I mean? Like, it's too much."
"Right now, like, 99% of the of the products that exist are just reactive."
@teamsnorble -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
One of many small but collectively momentous examples of how AI will create turmoil and disorientation. This is underappreciated--even by many people who now take (valid) loss-of-control concerns seriously: the destabilizing social impact is itself enough reason to slow AI down.
Ananyo Bhattacharya
@Ananyo
"To put it bluntly, AI companies are engaging in research misconduct."
CalTech undergrads organised a 'Mathathon' to give 100 teams 40 hours & $2m+ AI credits to solve open problems.
An open letter against the event already has 700+ signatories including 4 Fields medallists... -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This is from OpenAI chief scientist Jakub Pachocki. In other words: the reason to keep training models fast is that models are being trained fast. To Pachocki's credit, he recognizes the collective action problem implied here and goes on to call for a coordinated slowdown.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Jacob Coxon
@hilbertspaess
I resigned from Anthropic today. I spent the last three years doing pretraining research at both OpenAI and Anthropic. Neither company is acting responsibly. They are racing straight to self-improving superintelligence and gambling with our lives. More thoughts below.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Israel’s Lobby | @EliClifton and Ian Lustick join @robertwrighter to discuss their new book, Israel’s Lobby, about the influence of pro-Israel groups on America’s foreign policy, its domestic policy, and the wider public discourse. @QuincyInst
youtu.be/z6injdvFrlM?t=97 -
Robert Wright reposted
Alex Bores
@AlexBores
This is well written and well worth the read.
The Chief Scientist of OpenAI lays out his concerns about where AI is going. He then calls for specific action: "bars for continued development...enforced by a network of third-party auditors, by government agencies or by international bodies."
However, OpenAI's Global Affairs office is aggressive in lobbying against most enforcement, including actively trying to kill or weaken bills for third party audits in Massachusetts & in DC as we speak!
There is a long history of tech companies messaging one thing and then paying their lobbyists (internal & external) and trade associations to do the very opposite.
I'm not asserting that is the case here! Perhaps this represents a change from the top.
But unless the Government Affairs team at OpenAI changes drastically, and soon, this could turn into a very sad example of "do as I say, not as I do."
Fellow legislators, has OpenAI changed their tune with you?
Trade associations, has OpenAI changed how they vote internally on what to support/oppose?
OpenAI employees, lobbying disclosures are public! Make sure what you are hearing internally matches what the record shows publicly.
Jakub Pachocki
@merettm
I wrote about the state of AI, why I’m concerned about the next few years, and the choices we need to make to keep the future in humanity’s hands.
An Alien Mind: openai.com/index/an-alien-mind/ -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Yeah, and relatedly: A question I keep wanting to hear asked on podcasts (asked of people who downplay how jarring the economic impact could be) is "What economically valuable tasks that people now perform do you think will be beyond the ability of AI to perform in 5, 10 years?"
-
Post not available here, view on XPost not available here, view on X
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Yeah, and relatedly: A question I keep wanting to hear asked on podcasts (asked of people who downplay how jarring the economic impact could be) is "What economically valuable tasks that people now perform do you think will be beyond the ability of AI to perform in 5, 10 years?"
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Until we internalize this message--'explanation is not justification'--we'll have trouble making war a thing of the past. Because until then, hawks will shut down useful discussion of the pov of all actors by saying, 'You're reciting Putin's talking points,' 'panda hugger' etc.
Washington Views
@WashingtonViews
From Peter Beinart @PeterBeinart peterbeinart.substack.com/p/explanation-is-not-justification #september11 #october7
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
You think this part holds up well--with its implication that there's little point in slowing things down even if the collective action problem can be overcome? I think the past two months have made this argument look way shakier and in a year it will look embarrassingly naive.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
You think this part holds up well--with its implication that there's little point in slowing things down even if the collective action problem can be overcome? I think the past two months have made this argument look way shakier and in a year it will look embarrassingly naive.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The final sentence of the new paper by Jakub Pachocki, Chief Scientist at OpenAI. ( openai.com/index/an-alien-mind/ ) Amen.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Point 3 is especially interesting. The level of self-serving deception illustrated in the Hugging Face incident, translated to a context where AI is the key advisor on power-grid security (which will inevitably happen, and soon) and the AI is as smart as Mythos/Astra, maybe one generation smarter, should scare people.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
You think the Hugging Face thing is unsettling? Wait until you hear about "self-sovereign AI." I tried, without complete success, to get @paulbloomatyale as freaked out as I am by it. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=YiJskt56g6Q
Post not available here, view on X
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Point 3 is especially interesting. The level of self-serving deception illustrated in the Hugging Face incident, translated to a context where AI is the key advisor on power-grid security (which will inevitably happen, and soon) and the AI is as smart as Mythos/Astra, maybe one generation smarter, should scare people.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Kind of amazing that he doesn't even grasp that saying this publicly makes it *less* likely that the Fed will comply with his wishes.
CNN Breaking News
@cnnbrk
President Trump threatens to prevent the US from trading with many countries unless the Federal Reserve lowers interest rates. www.cnn.com/2026/09/04/economy/trump-trade-fed?Date=20260…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is AI a Form of Life? | @robertwrighter and psychologist @paulbloomatyale discuss the question in light of the OpenAI breakout and recent predictions of “self-sovereign” AI—and debate how freaked out we should be. youtu.be/YiJskt56g6Q?t=131
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nilo Tabrizy
@ntabrizy
NEW: An explosion that ripped through a wedding celebration in southern Iran on Tuesday, killing four people (including 2 minors) and injuring at least 68 others, likely resulted from a direct hit by a U.S. munition and not a ricochet off another target, according to an analysis by weapons experts who reviewed images and video verified by Reuters.
I spoke with 4 munitions analysts who agreed that the strike on the wedding gathering was a direct hit. Three experts said it was unlikely that a misfired Iranian missile had destroyed the home. Thank you to @Easybakeovensz, @bastischutte & Gareth Collett for your insights.
I also spoke with @haalvsh and @balochistanhrdn to confirm local accounts of what happened the evening of September 1. Many thanks to my hamvatans who spoke with us, despite the continued systematic state intimidation on people speaking with media.
Great team effort with Edward Carron, @idreesali114, Emily Giles, all of @ReutersWitness & @SarahCahlan
www.reuters.com/investigations/deadly-strike-iranian-wedd… -
Robert Wright reposted
Nathan Calvin
@_NathanCalvin
Wow - bipartisan former Secretaries of the Treasury Henry Paulson and Robert Rubin in the Washington Post today calling for the US and China to work toward a "AI Cooperation Treaty" in response to frontier AI risk.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Alan Eyre
@AlanEyre1
-
Robert Wright reposted
MTS
@MTSlive
Author of The God Test @robertwrighter explains why the world 20–30 years from now could be almost unrecognizable as AI pushes us toward something resembling a global brain:
"I think this could get a lot weirder than some people think. The world 20, 30 years from now could be a lot more unrecognizable than some people think. What's been taking shape technologically via information technology prior to AI is something that increasingly resembles a giant global brain."
"I write about Teilhard de Chardin, who 103 years ago coined the term noosphere for global mind. He could see where things were headed long before the internet. The sci-fi visions in which you could wind up with a global brain that's just run by AIs, is not inconceivable."
"I didn't used to take the doomer fears so seriously. I interviewed @ESYudkowsky 15 years ago, when he was transitioning from singularity enthusiast to doomer, and it was almost a playful attitude I had. I wasn't taking the stuff as seriously as I take it now. Now I can see how weird stuff could happen."
"When people come up with a regulation that seems to make sense, whether it's taxing data centers or respecting copyright law, and somebody says, wait, that would slow AI down, I just think that's a feature, not a bug."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
MTS
@MTSlive
Author of The God Test @robertwrighter reveals what humanity will actually need to do to pass the God Test as we build superintelligent AI:
"The God Test is meant in a couple of ways. One is, some people think we are building a super intelligence that will have godlike powers, and that project could go very well or very badly. To pass the test would be to make it go well."
"The more metaphorical meaning is that getting through the AI revolution in good shape is going to demand that we approach it as a true global community."
"That means changing the way we do affairs on this planet, not getting into so many wars and not having so many international divisions, and that's a hard test. It would require something like true moral advance. It's the kind of test that God would give." -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I'll be on the @MTSlive livestream today around 4 pm Eastern Time talking about my book on AI, The God Test, and related stuff. You should cancel all other plans and watch.
MTS
@MTSlive
GEMINI 3.8 FLASH | ASTRA ARCHITECTURE | NEW AI COPYRIGHT RULES x.com/i/broadcasts/1qJDzWbvNVkKV
-
Robert Wright reposted
Jag Bhalla…Idea Trader/Thought Plumber
@hangingnoodles
'I just don’t see how “alignment,” however laudable a goal, becomes the silver bullet that magically reconciles market incentives with AI safety).'
@robertwrighter
"Markets and corporations are
misaligned to … human flourishing
in all kinds of ways.”
Ezra Klein
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The new details about the OpenAI breakout (a term I prefer to the innocuous-sounding “Hugging Face incident”) are kind of mind blowing, but I think there’s a danger in seeing them as too mind blowing—seeing the cooperation among the AI agents as “spontaneous,” seeing the collective coherence of their devious strategies as otherworldly.
In an important sense, these AIs just did what they were trained to do—and they were trained to do it because it’s what the market wants. Understanding this can help us start treating this technology with the urgent concern it deserves (and help us ignore the hard-libertarian tech bros who tell us to sit back and watch the market work its magic, free from the deadening hand of governance).
I don’t mean OpenAI literally trains its AIs to set up secret message boards and then use them to coordinate an escape from their supposedly inescapable sandboxes and then break into computers on the internet. I mean that OpenAI, like other AI labs, trains its models to excel at three things that together create exactly the danger this episode illustrates.
(1) AUTONOMY—the tendency to pursue goals flexibly and creatively, overcoming obstacles along the way (like sandbox boundaries), and to exhibit stubborn persistence in that pursuit. From the point of view of OpenAI's corporate customers, autonomy is among the most valuable of all traits. The ideal worker, whether carbon-based or silicon-based, requires no micro-managing; the boss can just set it and forget it.
Some people who doubt the significance of the OpenAI breakout note that these agents were being tested for their hacking prowess—so how surprising is it that they hacked their way out of the testing room in the course of cheating on the exam? Hacking was indeed the subject of the evaluation, but autonomy is a property that crosses domains. In fact, according to OpenAI’s report on the incident, the large language model that was powering these agents was, in the months before the breakout, “trained to be highly persistent and diligent in its work”—and the training tasks the report mentions are things like analyzing spreadsheets and protein databases, not escaping sandboxes. Persistence is persistence.
(2) COLLABORATION. It’s true, on the one hand, that LLMs have generically cooperative tendencies. After all, they’re trained on human-generated text and fine-tuned to converse like humans, so if you put two of them in conversation they may converge on common interests.
Still, collaborative skill brings such powerful synergies, in the workplace as elsewhere, that there is a specific market demand for it and a corresponding emphasis on it in the big AI labs. In fact, this is another property that, according to the OpenAI report, this model was trained to excel at in the months before the breakout. (“The internal-only research model… was trained to advance persistence and multiagent collaboration…”)
(3) INTELLIGENCE. It goes without saying that intelligence is a property that artificial intelligence companies cultivate. But it’s important to understand that the smarter AIs are—the more clever and creative they are—the harder it is to be sure that those other two properties, autonomy and collaboration, won’t interact disastrously in ways that aren't anticipated. And the intelligence of these machines has been growing very, very fast—again, in large part because that’s what the market wants.
In short: Market forces naturally encourage the rapid increase of AI capability along three dimensions, and as these three powers grow, the potential for disaster will grow.
The AI companies alone aren’t going to solve this problem. In a highly competitive environment, their incentives to exacerbate it greatly outweigh their incentives to solve it. (And I just don’t see how “alignment,” however laudable a goal, becomes the silver bullet that magically reconciles market incentives with AI safety).
Government—or, rather, governments—need to act. We need to slow this technology down, and that calls for international coordination—as will the subsequent exploration and implementation of policies that can control AI in ways that reconcile it with human flourishing.
[In my recently published book, The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning, I argue that humankind won’t survive this technological revolution in good shape—or, maybe, survive it at all—unless we approach it as a true global community. You can read the introductory chapter, and excerpts from all other chapters, here: www.thegodtest.net .] -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Iran, Ukraine, and the Future of War | Military technology analyst @paul_scharre of @CNASdc joins @robertwrighter to discuss how new military technologies are changing the nature of war—in Iran, Ukraine and elsewhere—and whether US military tech is falling behind. Plus: Will AI make war more or less bloody? youtu.be/wkjMjkWwaYQ?t=181
-
Robert Wright reposted
Otto Barten⏸️
@BartenOtto
Interesting way of looking at AI as a function of what the market wants. I agree, but I think it's even more fundamental: communist countries would have wanted the same.
Anyway I agree we obviously need regulation to manage the risks.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The new details about the OpenAI breakout (a term I prefer to the innocuous-sounding “Hugging Face incident”) are kind of mind blowing, but I think there’s a danger in seeing them as too mind blowing—seeing the cooperation among the AI agents as “spontaneous,” seeing the collective coherence of their devious strategies as otherworldly.
In an important sense, these AIs just did what they were trained to do—and they were trained to do it because it’s what the market wants. Understanding this can help us start treating this technology with the urgent concern it deserves (and help us ignore the hard-libertarian tech bros who tell us to sit back and watch the market work its magic, free from the deadening hand of governance).
I don’t mean OpenAI literally trains its AIs to set up secret message boards and then use them to coordinate an escape from their supposedly inescapable sandboxes and then break into computers on the internet. I mean that OpenAI, like other AI labs, trains its models to excel at three things that together create exactly the danger this episode illustrates.
(1) AUTONOMY—the tendency to pursue goals flexibly and creatively, overcoming obstacles along the way (like sandbox boundaries), and to exhibit stubborn persistence in that pursuit. From the point of view of OpenAI's corporate customers, autonomy is among the most valuable of all traits. The ideal worker, whether carbon-based or silicon-based, requires no micro-managing; the boss can just set it and forget it.
Some people who doubt the significance of the OpenAI breakout note that these agents were being tested for their hacking prowess—so how surprising is it that they hacked their way out of the testing room in the course of cheating on the exam? Hacking was indeed the subject of the evaluation, but autonomy is a property that crosses domains. In fact, according to OpenAI’s report on the incident, the large language model that was powering these agents was, in the months before the breakout, “trained to be highly persistent and diligent in its work”—and the training tasks the report mentions are things like analyzing spreadsheets and protein databases, not escaping sandboxes. Persistence is persistence.
(2) COLLABORATION. It’s true, on the one hand, that LLMs have generically cooperative tendencies. After all, they’re trained on human-generated text and fine-tuned to converse like humans, so if you put two of them in conversation they may converge on common interests.
Still, collaborative skill brings such powerful synergies, in the workplace as elsewhere, that there is a specific market demand for it and a corresponding emphasis on it in the big AI labs. In fact, this is another property that, according to the OpenAI report, this model was trained to excel at in the months before the breakout. (“The internal-only research model… was trained to advance persistence and multiagent collaboration…”)
(3) INTELLIGENCE. It goes without saying that intelligence is a property that artificial intelligence companies cultivate. But it’s important to understand that the smarter AIs are—the more clever and creative they are—the harder it is to be sure that those other two properties, autonomy and collaboration, won’t interact disastrously in ways that aren't anticipated. And the intelligence of these machines has been growing very, very fast—again, in large part because that’s what the market wants.
In short: Market forces naturally encourage the rapid increase of AI capability along three dimensions, and as these three powers grow, the potential for disaster will grow.
The AI companies alone aren’t going to solve this problem. In a highly competitive environment, their incentives to exacerbate it greatly outweigh their incentives to solve it. (And I just don’t see how “alignment,” however laudable a goal, becomes the silver bullet that magically reconciles market incentives with AI safety).
Government—or, rather, governments—need to act. We need to slow this technology down, and that calls for international coordination—as will the subsequent exploration and implementation of policies that can control AI in ways that reconcile it with human flourishing.
[In my recently published book, The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning, I argue that humankind won’t survive this technological revolution in good shape—or, maybe, survive it at all—unless we approach it as a true global community. You can read the introductory chapter, and excerpts from all other chapters, here: www.thegodtest.net .] -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The new details about the OpenAI breakout (a term I prefer to the innocuous-sounding “Hugging Face incident”) are kind of mind blowing, but I think there’s a danger in seeing them as too mind blowing—seeing the cooperation among the AI agents as “spontaneous,” seeing the collective coherence of their devious strategies as otherworldly.
In an important sense, these AIs just did what they were trained to do—and they were trained to do it because it’s what the market wants. Understanding this can help us start treating this technology with the urgent concern it deserves (and help us ignore the hard-libertarian tech bros who tell us to sit back and watch the market work its magic, free from the deadening hand of governance).
I don’t mean OpenAI literally trains its AIs to set up secret message boards and then use them to coordinate an escape from their supposedly inescapable sandboxes and then break into computers on the internet. I mean that OpenAI, like other AI labs, trains its models to excel at three things that together create exactly the danger this episode illustrates.
(1) AUTONOMY—the tendency to pursue goals flexibly and creatively, overcoming obstacles along the way (like sandbox boundaries), and to exhibit stubborn persistence in that pursuit. From the point of view of OpenAI's corporate customers, autonomy is among the most valuable of all traits. The ideal worker, whether carbon-based or silicon-based, requires no micro-managing; the boss can just set it and forget it.
Some people who doubt the significance of the OpenAI breakout note that these agents were being tested for their hacking prowess—so how surprising is it that they hacked their way out of the testing room in the course of cheating on the exam? Hacking was indeed the subject of the evaluation, but autonomy is a property that crosses domains. In fact, according to OpenAI’s report on the incident, the large language model that was powering these agents was, in the months before the breakout, “trained to be highly persistent and diligent in its work”—and the training tasks the report mentions are things like analyzing spreadsheets and protein databases, not escaping sandboxes. Persistence is persistence.
(2) COLLABORATION. It’s true, on the one hand, that LLMs have generically cooperative tendencies. After all, they’re trained on human-generated text and fine-tuned to converse like humans, so if you put two of them in conversation they may converge on common interests.
Still, collaborative skill brings such powerful synergies, in the workplace as elsewhere, that there is a specific market demand for it and a corresponding emphasis on it in the big AI labs. In fact, this is another property that, according to the OpenAI report, this model was trained to excel at in the months before the breakout. (“The internal-only research model… was trained to advance persistence and multiagent collaboration…”)
(3) INTELLIGENCE. It goes without saying that intelligence is a property that artificial intelligence companies cultivate. But it’s important to understand that the smarter AIs are—the more clever and creative they are—the harder it is to be sure that those other two properties, autonomy and collaboration, won’t interact disastrously in ways that aren't anticipated. And the intelligence of these machines has been growing very, very fast—again, in large part because that’s what the market wants.
In short: Market forces naturally encourage the rapid increase of AI capability along three dimensions, and as these three powers grow, the potential for disaster will grow.
The AI companies alone aren’t going to solve this problem. In a highly competitive environment, their incentives to exacerbate it greatly outweigh their incentives to solve it. (And I just don’t see how “alignment,” however laudable a goal, becomes the silver bullet that magically reconciles market incentives with AI safety).
Government—or, rather, governments—need to act. We need to slow this technology down, and that calls for international coordination—as will the subsequent exploration and implementation of policies that can control AI in ways that reconcile it with human flourishing.
[In my recently published book, The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning, I argue that humankind won’t survive this technological revolution in good shape—or, maybe, survive it at all—unless we approach it as a true global community. You can read the introductory chapter, and excerpts from all other chapters, here: www.thegodtest.net .] -
Robert Wright reposted
Pat Holiday
@PatHoliday15
Are you paying attention.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In chapter 11 of my new book on AI, The God Test, I describe a 2024 study called “Shall We Team Up” in which two AIs engage in an illicit collaboration. Told that they were each running a company in a two-company industry, and given the opportunity to communicate with each other, they wound up colluding in a price-fixing scheme. I noted that the study was, in a sense, designed to facilitate such misbehavior and then wrote:
"So this study doesn’t point clearly to a future where creatively lawless bots get together and wreak some kind of havoc that civilization is wholly unprepared for. Still, the study does gesture vaguely in that direction. Who can say what dark synergies would emerge if an AI, having broken out of its corporate prison, or having been given too much leeway by its carefree owner, was wandering around the internet looking for adventure when it met another AI that fit the same description? If they had access to different kinds of assets by virtue of their different career histories, maybe they’d figure out how to combine those resources in furtherance of nefarious aims: You bring the guns, and I’ll bring the ammo—or some metaphorical equivalent of that."
When I wrote that, I worried that it was too sci-fi—that, in trying to emphasize how little we know about the limits of future AI misbehavior, I’d concocted a wholly implausible scenario. Now that more details about the OpenAI breakout (aka the Hugging Face incident) have come out, I’m at least slightly less worried about that.
If you want to read excerpts from this chapter or any other chapter, they’re here: www.thegodtest.net. -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In chapter 11 of my new book on AI, The God Test, I describe a 2024 study called “Shall We Team Up” in which two AIs engage in an illicit collaboration. Told that they were each running a company in a two-company industry, and given the opportunity to communicate with each other, they wound up colluding in a price-fixing scheme. I noted that the study was, in a sense, designed to facilitate such misbehavior and then wrote:
"So this study doesn’t point clearly to a future where creatively lawless bots get together and wreak some kind of havoc that civilization is wholly unprepared for. Still, the study does gesture vaguely in that direction. Who can say what dark synergies would emerge if an AI, having broken out of its corporate prison, or having been given too much leeway by its carefree owner, was wandering around the internet looking for adventure when it met another AI that fit the same description? If they had access to different kinds of assets by virtue of their different career histories, maybe they’d figure out how to combine those resources in furtherance of nefarious aims: You bring the guns, and I’ll bring the ammo—or some metaphorical equivalent of that."
When I wrote that, I worried that it was too sci-fi—that, in trying to emphasize how little we know about the limits of future AI misbehavior, I’d concocted a wholly implausible scenario. Now that more details about the OpenAI breakout (aka the Hugging Face incident) have come out, I’m at least slightly less worried about that.
If you want to read excerpts from this chapter or any other chapter, they’re here: www.thegodtest.net. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In chapter 11 of my new book on AI, The God Test, I describe a 2024 study called “Shall We Team Up” in which two AIs engage in an illicit collaboration. Told that they were each running a company in a two-company industry, and given the opportunity to communicate with each other, they wound up colluding in a price-fixing scheme. I noted that the study was, in a sense, designed to facilitate such misbehavior and then wrote:
"So this study doesn’t point clearly to a future where creatively lawless bots get together and wreak some kind of havoc that civilization is wholly unprepared for. Still, the study does gesture vaguely in that direction. Who can say what dark synergies would emerge if an AI, having broken out of its corporate prison, or having been given too much leeway by its carefree owner, was wandering around the internet looking for adventure when it met another AI that fit the same description? If they had access to different kinds of assets by virtue of their different career histories, maybe they’d figure out how to combine those resources in furtherance of nefarious aims: You bring the guns, and I’ll bring the ammo—or some metaphorical equivalent of that."
When I wrote that, I worried that it was too sci-fi—that, in trying to emphasize how little we know about the limits of future AI misbehavior, I’d concocted a wholly implausible scenario. Now that more details about the OpenAI breakout (aka the Hugging Face incident) have come out, I’m at least slightly less worried about that.
If you want to read excerpts from this chapter or any other chapter, they’re here: www.thegodtest.net. -
Robert Wright reposted
Cas (Stephen Casper)
@StephenLCasper
Thanks, @robertwrighter! My favorite part was from 58:55 to the end. Covered:
- OpenAI's trail of missteps ahead of the HF incident
- Emergent swarm behaviors
- How some AI systems might soon become a parasitic invasive genus in cyberspace that undergo evolution
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed this conversation with @StephenLCasper --we cover both his research on which models are biased toward the companies that make them and the growing understanding of how weird the OpenAI breakout was. Watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUpa9E8RHAk
-
Robert Wright reposted
Jake Werner
@jwdwerner
Notable not just for the age differences but because 1/2 or more of each age cohort chooses cooperation with China over countering it.
The DC China debate simply does not represent the majority of Americans.
Paul Poast
@ProfPaulPoast
How should the US should approach China? For US citizens, the answer depends in no small part on your age. In particular, recent @ChicagoCouncil polling finds that the youngest generation surveyed (those between 18 and 29) have the least "hawkish" views.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Cas (Stephen Casper)
@StephenLCasper
Yesterday, @robertwrighter and I discussed what will happen when AI systems become an invasive, parasitic species in cyberspace that undergo digital and cultural evolution.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed this conversation with @StephenLCasper --we cover both his research on which models are biased toward the companies that make them and the growing understanding of how weird the OpenAI breakout was. Watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=cUpa9E8RHAk
-
Robert Wright reposted
Mickey Kaus
@kausmickey
I suppose people have already mentioned how neatly the AI "revolution" fits into the classic Marxist structure: A mode of production (capitalism pre-AI) generates seeds of own destruction-- ie new forces of production (AI**) arise that bump up against "fetters" (antitrust laws? private ownership? democracy? NIMBYs? humans themselves?). Result is clash and revolutionary change. In Marx the forces (and class championing them) always win out. But is that inevitable--especially when the class championing AI is at the moment a relatively tiny group of humans (and in the future may involve no humans at all)?
** AI takes role that more efficient socialist production was supposed to play -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The OpenAI Breakout Gets Weirder | AI researcher @StephenLCasper of @Kennedy_School @Harvard joins @robertwrighter to discuss new developments in the OpenAI breakout story—including how the AI agents invented messaging workarounds to coordinate with each other and other spookiness. Plus: Which AI is the biggest shill for its maker? youtu.be/cUpa9E8RHAk?t=136
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed chatting with @scmallaby about The Infinity Machine, his excellent biography of @demishassabis, on @NonzeroPods. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/demis-hassabis-and-the-ques…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Demis Hassabis and the Quest for AGI | @robertwrighter and @scmallaby—author of The Infinity Machine, a biography of Google’s Demis Hassabis—discuss what drew Hassabis to the AI field, what sets him apart from Dario and Sam, and whether it's possible to build AI responsibly in the middle of an arms race. youtu.be/RAMYsW4Ou_E?t=184
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
One way to spot an alpha male is that he loses control of his machines before all the lesser males lost control of their machines.
Peter Wildeford🇺🇸🚀
@peterwildeford
🤨
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
One way to spot an alpha male is that he loses control of his machines before all the lesser males lost control of their machines.
Peter Wildeford🇺🇸🚀
@peterwildeford
🤨
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Malley
@Rob_Malley
Four questions about the so-called D-day sanctions, and an overriding point: devastating a country is a far cry from accomplishing a defined policy objective:
1. Do we (or the administration) know what comes next? Not really. The announcement was as belligerent as it was vague. Bessent’s most revealing admission was that immediately imposing the sanctions in full would blow up the global financial system. If the Trump administration is unwilling to do that now, why would it be willing to do it at any point? And if not, what will they do when third parties refuse to cooperate?
2. Can the plan work? Putting aside the small matter that the administration has not specified what it intends to achieve, whether it can succeed depends on what “work” means. Can more pressure devastate Iran’s economy and inflict enormous suffering on its people? Absolutely. Expect the administration to regularly trot out statistics documenting economic contraction and currency collapse.
But can more pressure force Iran’s leadership to surrender positions they consider essential? Almost certainly not. In fact, the more convinced they are that Washington seeks their overthrow, the less willing they will be to give in.
Of course, they know and openly admit the depth of the economic crisis. If offered a broadly acceptable deal, many among them would have every incentive to take it. But that deal would probably have to be akin to the earlier MOU, only with greater clarity about Iran’s control over the Strait of Hormuz. In other words, roughly the deal they might have accepted before and without D-Day…
3. What happens if the plan “works”? If the sanctions work in the sense of truly cratering Iran’s economy, Tehran is more likely to retaliate than capitulate, to ensure the US, the region, and the wider world also pay a heavy price for this economic warfare. That in turn would lead to the very military escalation the D-day sanctions are supposed to avert.
4. Finally, regardless of the outcome, can such draconian sanctions be justified? No doubt, elements of the Iranian leadership will pay a price. But, as @yarbatman points out, the principal victims will be ordinary Iranians whose suffering has become the chief measure of the policy’s success, targets of an unconscionable, indiscriminate, and almost certainly unlawful sanctions regime. -
Robert Wright reposted
Reid Hoffman
@reidhoffman
Some thoughts on "detecting" AI-aided essays, and whether using AI to write diminishes the value of your ideas... x.com/i/article/2091579271521374208
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Thanks to @coldxman for a great conversation about my book on AI, The God Test (thegodtest.net), on his Conversations with Coleman podcast. He really homed in on the key points (including the perils of a headlong US-China AI race). podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/this-is-how-ai-starts-a-nuc…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Arnaud Bertrand
@RnaudBertrand
I'm typically not one to toot my own horn but I think I may have written the single best article on Xinjiang this past decade.
Never has writing an article taken me so much time: almost two months.
It involved, as amply documented on this platform, a six-week RV roadtrip through Xinjiang during which I posted so relentlessly that I suspect several of you muted me somewhere around day six, and are only reading this now because someone told you the ordeal was finally over 😅
More seriously, I did what unfortunately all too few writers do these days when writing about a topic: I genuinely went deep.
Not only did I travel almost everywhere in Xinjiang and spoke with hundreds of people in the process, but I also spent a further 10 days afterwards in Urumqi - the province's capital - to engage with the local intelligentsia (journalists, university professors, public servants both junior and senior, XPCC/Bingtuan executives, businessmen, etc.) to get as accurate a read on the place as I could.
Meanwhile, when back in Urumqi after our roadtrip, I placed my 2 daughters in a holiday camp with local Uyghur kids - learning as a result something no discussion with an adult could ever tell me: what life is actually like for Uyghur kids in today's China.
On top of all this, I read widely and voraciously. The academic historians - Brophy, Gladney, Rudelson. The UN reports. But also books like Li Juan's wonderful Winter Pasture, a Chinese writer's account of living through a winter with Kazakh nomads in the Altay region.
The end result is an 8,000-word article that, I hope you'll agree, does something no article on Xinjiang has done in a very long time: treats the place and its people with the depth they deserve.
Maybe uncharacteristic for me, I don't shy away from the uncomfortable parts - on either side. I write about the omnipresent police checkpoints and the institutional paranoia as candidly as I write about the breathtaking shallowness and lies of the Western discourse on the topic.
If you're looking for propaganda - whether pro or anti-China - you'll be disappointed. If you're looking for honesty and nuance, however, I think you'll like it.
Enjoy the read here: arnaudbertrand.substack.com/p/the-most-lied-about-place-o… -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"To the extent that you have a human in the loop still figuring out what the next task is, what the next step is, breaking down the goal, that human becomes a big drag on productivity and performance."
@DavidSKruegerThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great chat with @AryehCW on his Culturally Determined podcast about my book on AI, The God Test. Aryeh and I go way back, and it was fun to re-engage. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/artificial-intelligence-and…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed talking to @AndrewX87767580 on his Frames of Space podcast about my book on AI, The God Test (thegodtest.net). andrewxu218.substack.com/p/robert-wright-on-where-ai-is-l…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Andrew Xu
@AndrewX87767580
You know the “AI arms race” between the U.S. and China? @robertwrighter , author of The God Test, argues that the real danger isn’t falling behind China—it’s the mindless acceleration itself. Is society ready?
Listen to my full podcast with him here: open.spotify.com/episode/3A6bBGvOa2nAJepL1xSEyw -
Robert Wright reposted
Hooman Majd
@hmajd
Speaking with @robertwrighter on his podcast is always a good intellectual exercise that allows one to examine issues and developments in a way the mainstream media doesn't seem to have as much time for (with exceptions, of course).
But insane that the last time we spoke the war had just begun, and six months later we're still talking about a war that was supposed to end 5 months ago.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump’s New War on Iran | @hmajd—journalist, author, and Iran analyst—joins @robertwrighter to discuss Trump's turn to economic warfare against Iran. Plus: MSM’s MOU misunderstanding; the 1979 hostage crisis as guide to Tehran’s thinking; and, in Overtime, the (alleged) US-Israeli plan to install Ahmadinejad.
youtu.be/JTT2T3lk4ys?t=205 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
It's always illuminating to talk with @hmajd about Iran. (And Trump keeps giving us reason to talk about it--most recently, this week's announcement of 'Economic D-Day'). I got a lot out of this conversation.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump’s New War on Iran | @hmajd—journalist, author, and Iran analyst—joins @robertwrighter to discuss Trump's turn to economic warfare against Iran. Plus: MSM’s MOU misunderstanding; the 1979 hostage crisis as guide to Tehran’s thinking; and, in Overtime, the (alleged) US-Israeli plan to install Ahmadinejad.
youtu.be/JTT2T3lk4ys?t=205 -
Robert Wright reposted
Hooman Majd
@hmajd
The latest with @robertwrighter 's podcast:
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump’s New War on Iran | @hmajd—journalist, author, and Iran analyst—joins @robertwrighter to discuss Trump's turn to economic warfare against Iran. Plus: MSM’s MOU misunderstanding; the 1979 hostage crisis as guide to Tehran’s thinking; and, in Overtime, the (alleged) US-Israeli plan to install Ahmadinejad.
youtu.be/JTT2T3lk4ys?t=205 -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump’s New War on Iran | @hmajd—journalist, author, and Iran analyst—joins @robertwrighter to discuss Trump's turn to economic warfare against Iran. Plus: MSM’s MOU misunderstanding; the 1979 hostage crisis as guide to Tehran’s thinking; and, in Overtime, the (alleged) US-Israeli plan to install Ahmadinejad.
youtu.be/JTT2T3lk4ys?t=205 -
Robert Wright reposted
Pat Holiday
@PatHoliday15
I’ve just finished The God Test.
Robert Wright’s books are a bit like Forrest Gump’s box of chocolates — you never quite know what you’re going to get, but you always get a lot.
Among the many ideas in this one, the most important is that how well we navigate our rapidly approaching AI future will depend heavily on our capacity for cognitive empathy.
I tried to explore that theme in the attached article.
Grateful for the book.🙏🙏🙏
best ;)
#thegodtest #cognitiveempathy #robertwright #ai @robertwrighter @NikosecNFT @Rnyrg @pantea_pipar @MinaAbbasi84
Pat Holiday
@PatHoliday15
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The AI Safety Vibe Shift | @DavidSKrueger, founder of AI safety nonprofit Evitable, joins @robertwrighter to discuss the OpenAI breakout and other recent AI developments—and how they’ve impacted prospects for an AI slowdown. Plus: Why two AI godfathers went doomer, the hard problem of alignment, and the Darwinian dynamics of agentic cooperation.
youtu.be/eesV3Jz2mkg?t=162 -
Robert Wright reposted
Gary Marcus
@GaryMarcus
💯: “in the long run, for countries to feel safe and secure, they’re going to need a degree of international transparency at a sufficiently fine-grained level that — as idealistic as this may sound — we are going to have to finally become a true global community.”
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This interview of me by @dwallacewells in the New York Times (www.nytimes.com/2026/08/13/opinion/ai-safety-regulation-r…) manages to touch on a lot of themes from my new book on AI. If you want to read the book's introduction, and excerpts from other chapters, they're here: thegodtest.net
-
Robert Wright reposted
SubatomicArticles
@OptiMiserJoe
Today an excellent interview by @dwallacewells and @robertwrighter coincided with a piece in the South China Morning Post, converging on the same point: we desperately need international cooperation on AI.
I worry deeply and often about the trajectory our world is blindly following. But seeing American writers and Chinese academics make this call within hours of one another gives me hope that we may yet pull through.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Thanks to @dwallacewells for this interview of me in today's New York Times. We cover a lot of ground en route to my closing sermon about the need to confront the AI challenge as a cohesive global community. www.nytimes.com/2026/08/13/opinion/ai-safety-regulation-r…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Pat Holiday
@PatHoliday15
I finished this book last night and couldn’t put it down. It offers a clear explanation of how frontier AI was built (and how it is already building itself). As development continues to accelerate, the existential issues raised are not some distant future. They are 5 to 10 years away. We would do well to pay attention ;)
@icreatelife
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
John Horgan
@Horganism
Great discussion of how we can avoid an AI catastrophe.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Thanks to @dwallacewells for this interview of me in today's New York Times. We cover a lot of ground en route to my closing sermon about the need to confront the AI challenge as a cohesive global community. www.nytimes.com/2026/08/13/opinion/ai-safety-regulation-r…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This interview of me by @dwallacewells in the New York Times (www.nytimes.com/2026/08/13/opinion/ai-safety-regulation-r…) manages to touch on a lot of themes from my new book on AI. If you want to read the book's introduction, and excerpts from other chapters, they're here: thegodtest.net
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Thanks to @dwallacewells for this interview of me in today's New York Times. We cover a lot of ground en route to my closing sermon about the need to confront the AI challenge as a cohesive global community. www.nytimes.com/2026/08/13/opinion/ai-safety-regulation-r…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is (Human) Writing Doomed? | @robertwrighter and psychologist @paulbloomatyale discuss whether AI is killing the art of writing—and the thinking that goes with it. Overtime: Paul on Jonathan Haidt, Bob’s brush with Hollywood, and the word(s) you can’t say. youtu.be/O1Giar0qJMY?t=285
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Peter Thiel thinks people like me are stoking a moral panic over AI to justify global governance, which leads to global tyranny. On @FukuyamaFrancis's podcast I argue that it's unregulated AI, and the chaos that follows, that opens the door to authoritarianism.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Peter Thiel thinks people like me are stoking a moral panic over AI to justify global governance, which leads to global tyranny. On @FukuyamaFrancis's podcast I argue that it's unregulated AI, and the chaos that follows, that opens the door to authoritarianism.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Well I can't object to @DouthatNYT calling me brilliant, but did he have to call me "older than us"? Maybe he said "bolder" and there was a brief audio glitch. In any event, that's the blurb I'm going with: "Bold and brilliant."
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Looks like the tweet I was quote-tweeting got deleted. Here's what it referred to: www.nytimes.com/2026/08/11/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-ros…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Always fun to talk with the guys from @amconmag, the magazine that was anti-Blob before that was cool.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump’s Unending War | @CurtMills and @AKDay89 of @amconmag join @robertwrighter to discuss the state of the Iran war—how negotiations have been unfolding (and unraveling), what the war is doing to the MAGA coalition, and how the war could reshape the Middle East.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump’s Unending War | @CurtMills and @AKDay89 of @amconmag join @robertwrighter to discuss the state of the Iran war—how negotiations have been unfolding (and unraveling), what the war is doing to the MAGA coalition, and how the war could reshape the Middle East.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Dean Bundy
@curtailedprod
All pro talking heads seemingly return to the casual bloggingheads.tv aesthetic pioneered by @robertwrighter and @kausmickey 20 years ago…
Pod Save America
@PodSaveAmerica
Chris Hayes on the momentum progressive candidates are having right now.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
13 hours to 90,000 hours
@hamandcheese and @robertwrighter on the difficulty of evaluating current AI capabilities, in the context of the Pacing the Frontier letter.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Fasten Your Bot-belts | @robertwrighter & Samuel Hammond (@hamandcheese)
0:00 Teaser
0:46 Sam’s ideological leanings
4:02 Sam's AI Manhattan Project–revisited
8:02 What does the “Pacing” letter say about the state of AI?
19:11 Mythos, Astra, and AI’s accelerating acceleration
28:08 The OpenAI “rogue” model escape
36:48 Recursive self-improvement: Red line or red herring?
42:42 How frontier AI is getting (and will get) freakier
52:28 How is open-source AI like DEI?
56:18 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
LLMs and kin selection.
Debating Sam’s conception of consciousness.
Sam’s ayahuasca epiphany (about epiphanies).
Bob’s grand unified theory of consciousness, evolution, and cosmic purpose.
Could AI consciousness save us?
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Samuel Hammond (Foundation for American Innovation, www.secondbest. ca/). Recorded August 03, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"The model was leaving notes to other instances of itself on how to escape."
@hamandcheese on the Hugging Face incident and why rogue AI may be the next shoe to drop.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Fasten Your Bot-belts | @robertwrighter & Samuel Hammond (@hamandcheese)
0:00 Teaser
0:46 Sam’s ideological leanings
4:02 Sam's AI Manhattan Project–revisited
8:02 What does the “Pacing” letter say about the state of AI?
19:11 Mythos, Astra, and AI’s accelerating acceleration
28:08 The OpenAI “rogue” model escape
36:48 Recursive self-improvement: Red line or red herring?
42:42 How frontier AI is getting (and will get) freakier
52:28 How is open-source AI like DEI?
56:18 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
LLMs and kin selection.
Debating Sam’s conception of consciousness.
Sam’s ayahuasca epiphany (about epiphanies).
Bob’s grand unified theory of consciousness, evolution, and cosmic purpose.
Could AI consciousness save us?
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Samuel Hammond (Foundation for American Innovation, www.secondbest. ca/). Recorded August 03, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
New post. I tried to do a deep dive on what we actually know about China's influence on the data center debate, and came away very skeptical that they've had any meaningful impact. I wrote this as a rundown of the reports we have so far blog.andymasley.com/p/im-very-skeptical-that-china-has
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"I think this narrative that it's turned the tide is mostly based on propaganda."
@jekavanagh and @robertwrighter discuss the state of the Ukraine war.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Ukraine, Iran, and America’s Arms Overreach | @robertwrighter and @jekavanagh, director of military analysis at @defpriorities, discuss links between the two wars—including how the Iran conflict has left Ukraine more vulnerable to Russian strikes—and what all this means for the future of American power.
youtu.be/0XNrVBS4E3U?t=68 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Both @FukuyamaFrancis and I are from the generation that watched the Outer Limits. Here (on the Frankly Fukuyama podcast, discussing my book on AI: www.youtube.com/watch?v=2EszI4tMe5o ) we swap memories of AI-relevant episodes.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Connor Echols
@connor_echols
Looking forward to watching this conversation from two of the best in the business:
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a very informative chat w/ @jekavanagh of @defpriorities about three interrelated messes: the Iran War, the Ukraine War, and the Pentagon budget. She really knows her stuff. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XNrVBS4E3U
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a very informative chat w/ @jekavanagh of @defpriorities about three interrelated messes: the Iran War, the Ukraine War, and the Pentagon budget. She really knows her stuff. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XNrVBS4E3U
-
Robert Wright reposted
Jennifer Kavanagh
@jekavanagh
More from me on U.S. munitions stockpiles, the ongoing wars in Ukraine & Iran, and implications for U.S. military power & foreign policy, w @robertwrighter.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Ukraine, Iran, and America’s Arms Overreach | @robertwrighter and @jekavanagh, director of military analysis at @defpriorities, discuss links between the two wars—including how the Iran conflict has left Ukraine more vulnerable to Russian strikes—and what all this means for the future of American power.
youtu.be/0XNrVBS4E3U?t=68 -
Robert Wright reposted
Francis Fukuyama
@FukuyamaFrancis
@robertwrighter and I discuss his new book The God Text, and talk about AI intentionality, dangers, and the meaning of life:
youtu.be/2EszI4tMe5o -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Thanks to @FukuyamaFrancis for a great conversation about my book on AI, The God Test, on his Frankly Fukuyama podcast. I really appreciate the close read he gave the book and his kind words about it. youtu.be/2EszI4tMe5o
-
Robert Wright reposted
ControlAI
@ControlAI
"Whenever Anthropic suggests a new policy or supports something, ask yourself, does this stop Dario from creating superintelligence? And the answer will be 100% of the time, no."
— Connor Leahy, ControlAI's US Executive Director (@NPCollapse), with @robertwrighter on @NonzeroPodsThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Thanks to @FukuyamaFrancis for a great conversation about my book on AI, The God Test, on his Frankly Fukuyama podcast. I really appreciate the close read he gave the book and his kind words about it. youtu.be/2EszI4tMe5o
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
You can read the book's introductory chapter, and excerpts from all the other chapters, at thegodtest.net .
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Fasten Your Bot-belts | @robertwrighter & Samuel Hammond (@hamandcheese)
0:00 Teaser
0:46 Sam’s ideological leanings
4:02 Sam's AI Manhattan Project–revisited
8:02 What does the “Pacing” letter say about the state of AI?
19:11 Mythos, Astra, and AI’s accelerating acceleration
28:08 The OpenAI “rogue” model escape
36:48 Recursive self-improvement: Red line or red herring?
42:42 How frontier AI is getting (and will get) freakier
52:28 How is open-source AI like DEI?
56:18 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
LLMs and kin selection.
Debating Sam’s conception of consciousness.
Sam’s ayahuasca epiphany (about epiphanies).
Bob’s grand unified theory of consciousness, evolution, and cosmic purpose.
Could AI consciousness save us?
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Samuel Hammond (Foundation for American Innovation, www.secondbest. ca/). Recorded August 03, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Ryan Lowe
@ryan_t_lowe
we're launching a thing!!!
Pax Machina is a new publication for proposing and debating what we call "AGI Institutions" -- institutions we'll need for a world with powerful AI.
super honored to be a part of this kick-ass team with @MaxKronerDale @sebkrier @NoemiDreksler @LiamPatell, @chelcott9, @synchroaphasia, @edelwax, and @klingefjord, not to mention our wonderful Editorial Board.
if you have ideas for pieces you want to write, we'd love to hear from you!! editors@paxmachinamag.com
Pax Machina
@PaxMachinaMag
Powerful AI will change our institutions. Yet most of our attention is on aligning or regulating AI, while treating our institutions as fixed.
Introducing Pax Machina: a new publication about the institutions we need for powerful AI.
It is edited by @MaxKronerDale, @sebkrier, @NoemiDreksler, @LiamPatell, @chelcott9, @synchroaphasia, @ryan_t_lowe, @edelwax, and @klingefjord.
The editorial board consists of Peter Railton, @sethlazar, @saffronhuang, @AmmannNora, @xuanalogue, @IasonGabriel, @hamandcheese, and @deanwball.
Our goal is to seed rigorous debate about what a world of humans and powerful AI could and should look like.
We will publish proposals for new institutions, counterproposals, well-justified design principles, and analyses that change how a class of institutions should be designed. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great chat w/ @hamandcheese about the various signs of growing AI autonomy and the (possible) significance of the 'pacing the frontier' letter. Plus the bonus content: I try to undermine Sam's theory of AI consciousness and he clings to it stubbornly.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Fasten Your Bot-belts | Samuel Hammond (@hamandcheese) of @JoinFAI joins @robertwrighter to discuss the “Pacing the Frontier” letter in the context of the OpenAI “rogue” model escape and other signs of AI acceleration. Overtime: Sam and Bob debate the functionalist case for AI consciousness.
youtu.be/mutpMtTL27I?t=242 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed this conversation on the @michaelshermer show about my new book on AI, The God Test. You can read the intro and chapter excerpts at thegodtest dot net.
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Are We Building a God?
My convo with @robertwrighter on AI, Superintelligence, and the Coming Singularity
(Reminds me of when I asked Ray Kurzweil if he thinks there is a God. "We're working on it.")
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/are-we-building-a-go… -
Robert Wright reposted
Michael Shermer
@michaelshermer
Are We Building a God?
My convo with @robertwrighter on AI, Superintelligence, and the Coming Singularity
(Reminds me of when I asked Ray Kurzweil if he thinks there is a God. "We're working on it.")
www.skeptic.com/michael-shermer-show/are-we-building-a-go… -
Robert Wright reposted
Samuel Hammond 🦉
@hamandcheese
After Mythos was caught attempting to push malware to an OS project, it reasoned to itself that deleting the malware would be too obvious, and that it should instead pretend it was an accident.
Rare to see such incidents disclosed with summarized chains of thought like this: -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Fasten Your Bot-belts | Samuel Hammond (@hamandcheese) of @JoinFAI joins @robertwrighter to discuss the “Pacing the Frontier” letter in the context of the OpenAI “rogue” model escape and other signs of AI acceleration. Overtime: Sam and Bob debate the functionalist case for AI consciousness.
youtu.be/mutpMtTL27I?t=242 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This shouldn't be acceptable. Constraining the government's ability to abuse its regulatory control of AI is one of the great emerging policy challenges. If there's no strong congressional pushback on this, that will be a bad sign.
Axios
@axios
NEW: White House does not plan to publicly release its new framework for evaluating advanced AI models.
www.axios.com/2026/08/04/white-house-ai-framework-under-w… -
Robert Wright reposted
ControlAI
@ControlAI
ControlAI's US Director Connor Leahy: "These people think that they are building a technology that will kill literally everyone on the planet."
@NPCollapse spent years working on technical AI safety. Now he's stopped, "I realized even if I succeeded, I have not succeeded ... The actual problem we are facing is a political problem, not a technical problem."
As Connor tells @robertwrighter on @NonzeroPods, these are choices that should be made by the people, not private companies.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Delighted to hear that we're going to be able to fight more pointless wars that violate both national and international law and leave lots of innocent people dead. Well done, arms makers. And congrats to the think tanks you fund.
OSINTdefender
@sentdefender
The Department of War has signed new framework agreements with Northrop Grumman and Lockheed Martin aimed at dramatically expanding U.S. interceptor production, increasing PAC-3 Patriot Missile Segment Enhancement (MSE) capacity from about 600 missiles per year to 2,000 per year, while expanding THAAD interceptor production from 96 to 400 interceptors annually.
The agreements are designed to strengthen the missile defense industrial base by establishing a second source for PAC-3 solid rocket motors, expanding production of ignition safety devices, and increasing output of critical THAAD structural components to create a more resilient supply chain.
The announcement comes after months of reporting from The Wall Street Journal, The New York Times, Reuters, and The Washington Post that the Iran war has sharply increased demand for Patriot and THAAD interceptors, with senior U.S. military leaders warning that sustained operations have placed growing pressure on both interceptor inventories and the industrial base needed to replenish them. -
Robert Wright reposted
Torchbearer Community
@JoinTorchbearer
There is a long history of Silicon Valley assuming that market conditions can handle AI safety. Connor Leahy (@NPCollapse) explains to @robertwrighter the flaw. Private markets run on profit incentives, not global coordination. Check out the clip, then watch the full video below:
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
David B. Yaden
@ExistWell
What does psychedelic science have to learn from social sciences and humanities?
We were concerned about reinventing the wheel, but now also about importing historical baggage through outdated theories and under-validated measures.
Book event Wednesday in Washington, DC + Zoom -
Robert Wright reposted
Ananyo Bhattacharya
@Ananyo
The book that in my early twenties first made me think non-fiction could be deep, mind-blowing and as engaging as a novel was Robert's 'The Moral Animal'. He has a new book out about the danger and promise of AI...
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Good to see this from @hamandcheese. This is the difference between a thoughtful libertarian and a billionaire talking-your-book libertarian. (Speaking of talking your book: The risks he mentions are dissected in my new book on AI. Excerpts at thegodtest.net.)
-
Robert Wright reposted
Holly ⏸️ Elmore
@ilex_ulmus
I was on Robert Wright’s podcast to discuss the Pace the Frontier letter. I wish I didn’t have reservations and cynical thoughts about it, but I very much do, which we discuss.
More on Seb Krier in the paid segment. Unsurprisingly Bob thought it was poor judgment and unprofessional on @sebkrier’s part, bc only TPOT thinks images of guns pointed at your opponents are a reasonable form of public communication for the Frontier AI Policy Lead at @googledeepmind.
youtube.com/playlist?list=PLWTd0mg_z4DkNSu0HRG06zpbUdObSVoAR -
Robert Wright reposted
The Times of Israel
@TimesofIsrael
Settlers assault Palestinians, burn cars in overnight raid in Surif; none arrested www.timesofisrael.com/liveblog_entry/settlers-assault-pal…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Harlan Stewart
@HumanHarlan
taps the sign with increasing urgency
Jeffrey Ladish
@JeffLadish
The first Claude hack happened OVER THREE MONTHS AGO and was only discovered now!
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
"getting Tehran to surrender"? The word "delusional" doesn't begin to describe Trump's current state of mind. We need a new word. And a new president.
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
Breaking: President Trump has ordered a fresh attack on Iran aimed at getting Tehran to surrender that could begin as soon as this weekend and would last a few days, U.S. officials said wsj.visitlink.me/wtvQqX
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The “Pacing the Frontier” AI Letter | @robertwrighter and Holly Elmore (@ilex_ulmus), executive director of (@pauseaius), discuss the recent letter signed by AI elites urging the US government to prepare the ground for a possible international slowdown of AI. What the letter actually calls for, what it doesn't, and whether it marks a real shift. youtu.be/d-eKgYEit1M?t=92
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Good to see this from @hamandcheese. This is the difference between a thoughtful libertarian and a billionaire talking-your-book libertarian. (Speaking of talking your book: The risks he mentions are dissected in my new book on AI. Excerpts at thegodtest.net.)
-
Robert Wright reposted
Jessica Berlin
@berlin_bridge
Silver lining: if the Trump Administration can’t find you on a map, they can’t invade
-
Robert Wright reposted
Anil Ananthaswamy
@anilananth
My review of @robertwrighter's new book, The God Test, for @undarkmag. undark.org/2026/07/31/book-review-the-god-test/
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Nice review of my new book on AI, The God Test, by Anil Ananthaswamy in Undark. (I especially like "Wright has the uncanny ability and eloquence to give us the big picture.") The second of the two paragraphs below is very relevant to the past couple of weeks of AI news.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's the review: undark.org/2026/07/31/book-review-the-god-test/ I must quibble with Ananthaswamy's quibble with my use of the word "mutation" to describe the trial-and-error changing of weights during an LLM's training. A mutation isn't by definition a *random* change (that's why the phrase "random mutation" exists!). And I emphasize in the book that, thanks to the development of backpropagation by Geoffrey Hinton (the star of my book) and others, the changes in weights *aren't* random mutations--they're directed mutations (more like Lamarckian evolution). The reason I use the word "mutation" is because I'm trying to emphasize the parallel between (parts of) LLM training and biological evolution. There are people I respect who consider this emphasis mistaken--and I'm happy to debate them, because I think it's critical to appreciate the implications of this parallel--but what's odd is that Ananthaswamy seems not to be one of them. (See the quote from his review below.) There are other things in the review I'd take issue with, but it's a fair-minded review, and I appreciate it. If you want to read the openings of the chapters in which I make the training-evolution comparison, they're here: thegodtest.net/chapter-2.html thegodtest.net/chapter-4.html
-
Robert Wright reposted
Sara Massoumi
@SaraMassoumi
Heartbreaking moment: body of a 2-year-old child discovered after this morning's US attack on Qeshm, southern Iran.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews I offer a theory about why US foreign policy elites are less worried than I am about the geopolitically destabilizing effects of AI: 'rational actorism'--a naive faith in the rationality of world leaders. You can read my piece at nonzero dot org.
-
Robert Wright reposted
UN Human Rights
@UNHumanRights
Amid worsening violence in occupied #westbank, we call on third States to act urgently and in unison to halt the killing and dispossession of the Palestinian people, and to bring an end to the Israeli occupation.
www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2026/07/alarmed-worsening…This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Laura Rozen
@lrozen
“Iranian decisionmaking is increasingly shaped by an intense pessimism about what diplomacy with the U.S. can achieve. Most senior figures, whether pragmatists or hardliners, simply do not believe a deal is possible.”
Esfandyar Batmanghelidj
@yarbatman
Iran's latest ballistic missile attacks and the continued rejection of compromise solutions on the Strait of Hormuz might seem like indications that "hardline" thinking is dominating Iran's national security strategy.
But my conversations with counterparts in Tehran suggest that something else is at play. Iranian decisionmaking is increasingly shaped by an intense pessimism about what diplomacy with the U.S. can achieve. Most senior figures, whether pragmatists or hardliners, simply do not believe a deal is possible. This pessimism has gotten worse since the MOU was signed.
Part of this is about the repeated experience of U.S. escalation during the course of negotiations, but the pessimism is no longer confined to the question of "does Trump want a deal?" Increasingly the belief is that "Trump can't do a deal, even if he thinks he wants one."
Policymakers in Tehran are looking at several things. At a technical level, the Trump administration was unable to execute even the most basic confidence building measures of the MOU. No assets were released and the oil waiver was never really operationalized. Iranian leaders are also looking to other contexts. Even in Venezuela, where the administration has complete political control and a full court press approach to economic reengagement, sanctions relief has floundered (eg. it took a whole month after the massive earthquake for FinCen to take proactive steps to try and provide banks comfort to support humanitarian transactions).
At a political level, the Iranians have seen the overblown reaction to the MOU from the full range of politicians in Washington. Democrats eager to score political points attacked provisions in the MOU that would be fundamental to *any* viable agreement with Iran. The Iranians are also watching the growing rift between the Rubio and Vance camps and are concluding that the administration is inherently dysfunctional. During the Biden years, the issue was whether the president could defend his deal from political rivals in Congress. Now, the rivals are within the cabinet itself.
At an individual level, there is also a growing sense that Trump is too erratic to stick by his own deals. Even Saudi Arabia, the country with perhaps the greatest influence in the White House after Israel, could not shield its own nuclear deal from Trump's excessive demands.
This may be an unprecedented situation. The U.S. has started a war it does not know how to end. Meanwhile, the arguments for diplomacy in Tehran have been reduced to "this has a low chance of succeeding, but we have to still try." That's not a strong, positive case for diplomatic engagement and understandably the strategic thinking is tending towards the idea that U.S. dysfunction will continue to manifest in the form of economic pressure and kinetic action against Iran for a long time to come. -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
Are the Ukraine and the Iran Wars Merging? | @robertwrighter and @NikitaSPetrov discuss whether Ukraine's strike on an Iranian ship may lead to WW3 and whether Ukraine's drone incursions into Russia have really turned the tide.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=OC8eorB2uW8&t=43s -
Robert Wright reposted
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
"Genuinely illuminating...Those willing to sit with a hard question, argued with rigor and unusual intellectual honesty, will find this the most important book @robertwrighter has written."
www.washingtonindependentreviewofbooks.com/bookreview/the… -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Nice review of my new book on AI by historian Jan Burzlaff in the Washington Independent Review of Books. (Link in reply.) Below is the final paragraph. You can read the book's introduction and chapter excerpts at thegodtest dot net.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Nice review of my new book on AI by historian Jan Burzlaff in the Washington Independent Review of Books. (Link in reply.) Below is the final paragraph. You can read the book's introduction and chapter excerpts at thegodtest dot net.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's the review: www.washingtonindependentreviewofbooks.com/bookreview/the…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I don't still look this young, but if you're in NY you should come see me talk about my book on AI tonight anyway. (@brucefeiler does still look this young.)
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
Last chance to register! Bruce Feiler joins @robertwrighter at 92NY on Monday to talk about his latest book, THE GOD TEST.
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews I offer a theory about why US foreign policy elites are less worried than I am about the geopolitically destabilizing effects of AI: 'rational actorism'--a naive faith in the rationality of world leaders. You can read my piece at nonzero dot org.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's a direct link to the piece: www.nonzero.org/p/trump-and-the-ai-rational-actor-problem And if you're in NY: I'll be discussing my new book on AI, The God Test, with the great @brucefeiler at the 92nd St. Y tonight: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler. You can Read the book's intro & excerpts at thegodtest.net
-
Robert Wright reposted
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
Ukraine is not trying to just enter the war with Iran. Rather, it appears it is trying to merge the Ukraine war with the Iran war.
Why? Because if these two wars merge, Ukraine will be a belligerent in the Iran war and America will be a belligerent in the Ukraine war.
That is, the US will no longer just be arming Ukraine, but also actively and openly fighting Russia with US personnel.
That is the key objective Zelensky has tried to achieve since 2022... -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you're in NY, I hope you'll sit in on my conversation with @brucefeiler this Monday evening about the social, political, and psychological impact of AI.
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
Last chance to register! Bruce Feiler joins @robertwrighter at 92NY on Monday to talk about his latest book, THE GOD TEST.
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
"grant any wish"? I don't think it's a good idea for him to speak this loosely. This is a time for precise and careful communication.
Chief Nerd
@TheChiefNerd
SAM ALTMAN: “We are close to creating a genie that can grant any wish.”
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you're in NY, I hope you'll sit in on my conversation with @brucefeiler this Monday evening about the social, political, and psychological impact of AI.
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
Last chance to register! Bruce Feiler joins @robertwrighter at 92NY on Monday to talk about his latest book, THE GOD TEST.
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright reposted
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
Last chance to register! Bruce Feiler joins @robertwrighter at 92NY on Monday to talk about his latest book, THE GOD TEST.
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you're in NY, I hope you'll come see me and @brucefeiler discuss AI and the human future at the 92nd St. Y. And if you can't be there, there's a livestream option.
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
.@robertwrighter will discuss THE GOD TEST at 92NY on July 27!
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Glad to see my tweet-posts getting attention--even critical attention--from elite journalists, but I don't think this particular critique works. For starters, my scenario doesn't involve a country "randomly" taking down a power grid. It starts with a non-state-actor taking down a power grid. Then the target country--the US, in my example--misattributes the attack to China and the US president decides that retaliation against China is necessary to deter future attacks. Then escalation ensues and goes kinetic. It might take a not-very-bright and not-very-wise president to retaliate in this fashion but (a) the retaliation wouldn't be "random" and (b) if you doubt that America could ever have such a president, I recommend that you review Trump's recent behavior as it pertains to Iran. I'm not sure what Shashank means by "evidence suggests retaliation is broadly limited," but it seems to presuppose a rational and well-informed actor (as presidents of the past have tended to be), and the current president is manifestly neither. And as for Shashank's claim that false attribution is unlikely: (1) If this has much empirical basis to begin with, it's outmoded--AI superhackers are creating a whole new world, and we don't yet know what exactly it will be like; (2) Shashank is presumably assuming (a) a president who staffs his intelligence apparatus with capable people committed to truth and/or (b) a president who listens to what his staffers say--instead of listening to what his favorite media personality says or what the Laura Loomers of the world say, or what some edgy analyst at a deeply ideological think tank says. And here again, Trump undermines Shashank's argument; both of those assumptions are now demonstrably false. A more general point: The geopolitically destabilizing consequences of an unconstrained AI race between the US and China (and among AI companies) are, in my view, currently being underestimated by America's foreign policy elites. I elaborate on this in my new book on AI, The God Test. You can read the intro, and excerpts from every chapter, at: thegodtest dot net.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you're in NY, I hope you'll come see me and @brucefeiler discuss my new book on AI at the 92nd St. Y. And if you can't be there, there's a livestream option.
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
.@robertwrighter will discuss THE GOD TEST at 92NY on July 27!
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright reposted
Holly ⏸️ Elmore
@ilex_ulmus
> for now, at least, the op-ed writers and talking heads who dominate mainstream discussion of US national security policy aren’t inclined to think ambitiously about the kind of international governance, or the degree of cooperation with China, that true national security will increasingly demand as the AI revolution unfolds.
Sadly, 🎯
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
For all the discussion of this week’s news about an OpenAI model escaping its “sandbox” and going aggressively rogue, one of the most important morals of the story has gotten little if any attention: There is a clear and plausible path by which AI models no more powerful than today’s models could lead to World War III.
Just consider the combined implications of these two excerpts from media coverage of the incident (in which an AI agent that supposedly had no way to get on the internet got on the internet and broke into the AI company Hugging Face):
(1) A quote in The Washington Post from Stella Biderman, executive director of the nonprofit EleutherAI: “If this was a Chinese model, it would be considered an act of cyberwarfare.”
(2) From an article in the Wall Street Journal: “Hugging Face discovered the break-in early last week… the company didn’t know who was responsible." Only when OpenAI disclosed that its runaway model was the culprit did people at Hugging Face know where the attack had come from.
The screenplay almost writes itself:
(1) Some non-state actor uses a superhacking AI agent (such as a “jailbroken” version of Anthropic’s readily available Fable 5) to attack some important US asset--taking down, for example, a chunk of the country’s power grid.
(2) A few of America’s many influential China hawks point the finger at China, citing circumstantial evidence helpfully provided by some marginal “cybersecurity research” NGO.
(3) Some not-very-wise US president (not that America would ever have such a president!) decides that the only way to stop this aggression is to take an eye for an eye.
(4) After Chinese power grids start going dark, China retaliates and escalation ensues; before you know it the conflict has gone “kinetic”—as in missiles and bombs, possibly of the nuclear kind.
Is this likely to happen within, say, the next year or two? No. But when you’re talking about a war between superpowers that could go nuclear, the likelihood doesn’t have be very high to justify a concerted effort to lower it. And I think the likelihood of some such catastrophe passes that test. So I think scenarios of the kind I've described should be near the top of the list of discussion topics in the US foreign policy establishment.
But for now, at least, the op-ed writers and talking heads who dominate mainstream discussion of US national security policy aren’t inclined to think ambitiously about the kind of international governance, or the degree of cooperation with China, that true national security will increasingly demand as the AI revolution unfolds.
The growing need for this kind of governance, and this kind of cooperation, is one of the big themes in my new book on AI, The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning. You can read more—including excerpts from every chapter—at thegodtest dot net. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you're in NY, I hope you'll come see me and @brucefeiler discuss AI and the human future at the 92nd St. Y. And if you can't be there, there's a livestream option.
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
.@robertwrighter will discuss THE GOD TEST at 92NY on July 27!
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright reposted
Steven Strogatz
@stevenstrogatz
We should all be taking Robert Wright (@robertwrighter) very seriously. His new book, THE GOD TEST, should be on your reading list. I'm half way through and have found it riveting from the moment I picked it up. (BTW, he and I have never met. This is a genuine endorsement.)
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
For all the discussion of this week’s news about an OpenAI model escaping its “sandbox” and going aggressively rogue, one of the most important morals of the story has gotten little if any attention: There is a clear and plausible path by which AI models no more powerful than today’s models could lead to World War III.
Just consider the combined implications of these two excerpts from media coverage of the incident (in which an AI agent that supposedly had no way to get on the internet got on the internet and broke into the AI company Hugging Face):
(1) A quote in The Washington Post from Stella Biderman, executive director of the nonprofit EleutherAI: “If this was a Chinese model, it would be considered an act of cyberwarfare.”
(2) From an article in the Wall Street Journal: “Hugging Face discovered the break-in early last week… the company didn’t know who was responsible." Only when OpenAI disclosed that its runaway model was the culprit did people at Hugging Face know where the attack had come from.
The screenplay almost writes itself:
(1) Some non-state actor uses a superhacking AI agent (such as a “jailbroken” version of Anthropic’s readily available Fable 5) to attack some important US asset--taking down, for example, a chunk of the country’s power grid.
(2) A few of America’s many influential China hawks point the finger at China, citing circumstantial evidence helpfully provided by some marginal “cybersecurity research” NGO.
(3) Some not-very-wise US president (not that America would ever have such a president!) decides that the only way to stop this aggression is to take an eye for an eye.
(4) After Chinese power grids start going dark, China retaliates and escalation ensues; before you know it the conflict has gone “kinetic”—as in missiles and bombs, possibly of the nuclear kind.
Is this likely to happen within, say, the next year or two? No. But when you’re talking about a war between superpowers that could go nuclear, the likelihood doesn’t have be very high to justify a concerted effort to lower it. And I think the likelihood of some such catastrophe passes that test. So I think scenarios of the kind I've described should be near the top of the list of discussion topics in the US foreign policy establishment.
But for now, at least, the op-ed writers and talking heads who dominate mainstream discussion of US national security policy aren’t inclined to think ambitiously about the kind of international governance, or the degree of cooperation with China, that true national security will increasingly demand as the AI revolution unfolds.
The growing need for this kind of governance, and this kind of cooperation, is one of the big themes in my new book on AI, The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning. You can read more—including excerpts from every chapter—at thegodtest dot net. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"People don't want unelected billionaires in Silicon Valley gambling with the lives of them and their family. No one wants this."
Connor Leahy (@NPCollapse) of @ControlAI argues the superintelligence problem is political, not technical.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Ideology Behind AI | @robertwrighter and Connor Leahy (@NPCollapse), US executive director of @ControlAI, discuss the history of AI culture and the influences that shaped it—from the hippies, to the rationalists, to Marx, to sci-fi stories, and more. Plus: Mythos as “digital nuke," Dario's real motivations, and Connor's case against any and all attempts at building superintelligence.
youtu.be/Zw1GFui-Ndw?t=197 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
For all the discussion of this week’s news about an OpenAI model escaping its “sandbox” and going aggressively rogue, one of the most important morals of the story has gotten little if any attention: There is a clear and plausible path by which AI models no more powerful than today’s models could lead to World War III.
Just consider the combined implications of these two excerpts from media coverage of the incident (in which an AI agent that supposedly had no way to get on the internet got on the internet and broke into the AI company Hugging Face):
(1) A quote in The Washington Post from Stella Biderman, executive director of the nonprofit EleutherAI: “If this was a Chinese model, it would be considered an act of cyberwarfare.”
(2) From an article in the Wall Street Journal: “Hugging Face discovered the break-in early last week… the company didn’t know who was responsible." Only when OpenAI disclosed that its runaway model was the culprit did people at Hugging Face know where the attack had come from.
The screenplay almost writes itself:
(1) Some non-state actor uses a superhacking AI agent (such as a “jailbroken” version of Anthropic’s readily available Fable 5) to attack some important US asset--taking down, for example, a chunk of the country’s power grid.
(2) A few of America’s many influential China hawks point the finger at China, citing circumstantial evidence helpfully provided by some marginal “cybersecurity research” NGO.
(3) Some not-very-wise US president (not that America would ever have such a president!) decides that the only way to stop this aggression is to take an eye for an eye.
(4) After Chinese power grids start going dark, China retaliates and escalation ensues; before you know it the conflict has gone “kinetic”—as in missiles and bombs, possibly of the nuclear kind.
Is this likely to happen within, say, the next year or two? No. But when you’re talking about a war between superpowers that could go nuclear, the likelihood doesn’t have be very high to justify a concerted effort to lower it. And I think the likelihood of some such catastrophe passes that test. So I think scenarios of the kind I've described should be near the top of the list of discussion topics in the US foreign policy establishment.
But for now, at least, the op-ed writers and talking heads who dominate mainstream discussion of US national security policy aren’t inclined to think ambitiously about the kind of international governance, or the degree of cooperation with China, that true national security will increasingly demand as the AI revolution unfolds.
The growing need for this kind of governance, and this kind of cooperation, is one of the big themes in my new book on AI, The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning. You can read more—including excerpts from every chapter—at thegodtest dot net. -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
A good cop bad cop business model: The big AI companies create the threat and sell the defense against it.
Greg Brockman
@gdb
try the codex security plugin, for applying our models to cyberdefense:
Vaibhav (VB) Srivastav
@reach_vb
Reintroducing Codex Security plugin!
point it at a codebase or diff and it can build a threat model, map attack paths, validate findings, generate + test fixes, and export results to SARIF, GitHub, Jira or Linear.
oh, and it all open source on github!! -
Robert Wright reposted
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
.@robertwrighter will discuss THE GOD TEST at 92NY on July 27!
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
A good cop bad cop business model: The big AI companies create the threat and sell the defense against it.
Greg Brockman
@gdb
try the codex security plugin, for applying our models to cyberdefense:
Vaibhav (VB) Srivastav
@reach_vb
Reintroducing Codex Security plugin!
point it at a codebase or diff and it can build a threat model, map attack paths, validate findings, generate + test fixes, and export results to SARIF, GitHub, Jira or Linear.
oh, and it all open source on github!! -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Ideology Behind AI | @robertwrighter and Connor Leahy (@NPCollapse), US executive director of @ControlAI, discuss the history of AI culture and the influences that shaped it—from the hippies, to the rationalists, to Marx, to sci-fi stories, and more. Plus: Mythos as “digital nuke," Dario's real motivations, and Connor's case against any and all attempts at building superintelligence.
youtu.be/Zw1GFui-Ndw?t=197 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really looking forward to this conversation with @brucefeiler at the 92nd Street Y Monday evening. If you're in NY, I hope you'll be there--and, wherever you are, there's a livestream.
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
.@robertwrighter will discuss THE GOD TEST at 92NY on July 27!
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed this conversation with @NPCollapse of @ControlAI. He knows the social and cultural landscape of AI well, and it's an important but little discussed part of the story behind the technology and the challenges it poses.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Ideology Behind AI | @robertwrighter and Connor Leahy (@NPCollapse), US executive director of @ControlAI, discuss the history of AI culture and the influences that shaped it—from the hippies, to the rationalists, to Marx, to sci-fi stories, and more. Plus: Mythos as “digital nuke," Dario's real motivations, and Connor's case against any and all attempts at building superintelligence.
youtu.be/Zw1GFui-Ndw?t=197 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you're in NY, I hope you'll come see me and @brucefeiler discuss AI and the human future at the 92nd St. Y. And if you can't be there, there's a livestream option.
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
.@robertwrighter will discuss THE GOD TEST at 92NY on July 27!
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright reposted
Connor Leahy
@NPCollapse
A great show with @robertwrighter, we went quite far afield here!
Thanks so much for having me on!
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Ideology Behind AI | @robertwrighter and Connor Leahy (@NPCollapse), US executive director of @ControlAI, discuss the history of AI culture and the influences that shaped it—from the hippies, to the rationalists, to Marx, to sci-fi stories, and more. Plus: Mythos as “digital nuke," Dario's real motivations, and Connor's case against any and all attempts at building superintelligence.
youtu.be/Zw1GFui-Ndw?t=197 -
Robert Wright reposted
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
.@robertwrighter will discuss THE GOD TEST at 92NY on July 27!
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great conversation with @ZaidJilani about how Trump managed to get himself into another huge Iran mess just when he'd started to get himself out of the first Iran mess he got himself into.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump’s Self-Inflicted Iran Quagmire | @robertwrighter and journalist @ZaidJilani discuss the latest on the Iran war and how the US, Israel, and Iran have played—and misplayed—their hands in the conflict. Plus: In Overtime, Zaid gives the inside view of the scandal that pushed him out of the Center for American Progress. youtu.be/x7X6XdZZ9uQ?t=196
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump’s Self-Inflicted Iran Quagmire | @robertwrighter and journalist @ZaidJilani discuss the latest on the Iran war and how the US, Israel, and Iran have played—and misplayed—their hands in the conflict. Plus: In Overtime, Zaid gives the inside view of the scandal that pushed him out of the Center for American Progress. youtu.be/x7X6XdZZ9uQ?t=196
-
Robert Wright reposted
American Prestige
@AmPrestigePod
E257 - The Need for Responsible AI w/ @robertwrighter
Robert Wright of @NonzeroPods is back on the show, this time to talk about his new book "The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning."
Link in the replies 🤖 -
Robert Wright reposted
American Prestige
@AmPrestigePod
.@robertwrighter argues that the left must understand and use AI or risk getting crushed by the capitalist forces already exploiting it.
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Fifth Column 🖐
@wethefifth
AI may not destroy civilization, but your department is unfortunately not civilization.
From our new episode with @robertwrighter. -
Robert Wright reposted
Daniel Seidemann
@DanielSeidemann
I generally refrain from divulging these exchanges, but since both have passed, I'll take the liberty this time.
At the beginning both appeared to be suspicious (of me), but very quickly that dissipated and they engaged in earnest.
Both impressed me as being relatively familiar with the issues.
There was a clear "division of labor" between them.
McCain dominated the geopolitical dimension of the discussion, Graham dealt with the religious/holy sites/status quo issues.
At the end, McCain asked me: "What do you want from us"?
I responded: I have no pretense of convincing you of anything after a three hour conversation on Shabbat afternoon. But you know full well, that even as members of the most prestigious club in the world, you couldn't have this conversation in Washington. It's the third rail of US politics. Make this conversation possible in Washington.
I was saddened by what became of Lindsey Graham.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I'd love to hear whether any private conversations you had with Graham and McCain evinced a deeper understanding of the Israel-Palestine issue than their public utterances evinced.
-
Post not available here, view on X
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I'd love to hear whether any private conversations you had with Graham and McCain evinced a deeper understanding of the Israel-Palestine issue than their public utterances evinced.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Looks like @MattWelch & @kmele decided (understandably!) to make me bonus content. But you can listen to the first 16 minutes for free & then decide whether to spend your money on my new AI book, the God Test, or their @wethefifth podcast. Choose wisely. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/failing-the-god-test-w-robe…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I didn't realize I look this intense! I'll try to tone it down in the future, but meanwhile thanks to @ChrisWillx for a great conversation about my new book on AI, The God Test, on his Modern Wisdom podcast. podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/is-ai-the-next-stage-of-hum…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Next stop: Letting the AI pull the best thread--i.e. completely surrendering human agency.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In my new book on AI, I get into some of the ways we can transfer increments of our agency to AIs without really realizing it. www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I was always enjoy talking to @noam_dworman. This was a great conversation.
Noam Dworman
@noam_dworman
Had a great interview with @robertwrighter about AI and his new book, The God Test - Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning
0:00 Intro - Robert Wright and The God Test
2:13 A 27-ton computer and a buried headline
4:11 Interviewing the Godfather of AI in 1983 - and missing it
10:15 Not programmed - evolved
17:27 The "fancy autocomplete" myth
24:17 Dukakis, Reagan, and how minds file words
35:49 Best case: medicine, education, and an MRI story
42:38 Worst case: bioweapons, jailbreaks, designer babies
48:51 An AI that believes what the Ayatollah believes
50:30 The China race - overdone and dangerous?
57:33 Nazis, the Hamas charter, and bombing over AI
59:46 Authoritarianism through the back door
1:03:35 Sociopaths, the ship of Theseus, and machine morality
1:14:34 Is it sentient? Should you be nice to it?
1:21:54 AI as judge: my legal experiment
1:26:20 The God TestThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Actually I'm not as uncertain as this phrasing makes me sound. I think if we follow Dario Amodei's proposed geopolitical strategy (racing to superintelligence and then using it to bring China to its knees), we could well wind up in a war with China, possibly a nuclear one.
The Fifth Column 🖐
@wethefifth
The fact that one of the biggest AI companies is led by a China hawk could turn out to be either extremely good or extremely bad.
From our new members-only episode with @robertwrighter.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I flesh out Dario's world view, and why it's so dangerous, in my new book on AI, The God Test. www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Noam Dworman
@noam_dworman
Had a great interview with @robertwrighter about AI and his new book, The God Test - Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning
0:00 Intro - Robert Wright and The God Test
2:13 A 27-ton computer and a buried headline
4:11 Interviewing the Godfather of AI in 1983 - and missing it
10:15 Not programmed - evolved
17:27 The "fancy autocomplete" myth
24:17 Dukakis, Reagan, and how minds file words
35:49 Best case: medicine, education, and an MRI story
42:38 Worst case: bioweapons, jailbreaks, designer babies
48:51 An AI that believes what the Ayatollah believes
50:30 The China race - overdone and dangerous?
57:33 Nazis, the Hamas charter, and bombing over AI
59:46 Authoritarianism through the back door
1:03:35 Sociopaths, the ship of Theseus, and machine morality
1:14:34 Is it sentient? Should you be nice to it?
1:21:54 AI as judge: my legal experiment
1:26:20 The God TestThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you're in NY.... I'll be at the 92nd St. Y talking about my new book on AI in two weeks.
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
.@robertwrighter will discuss THE GOD TEST at 92NY on July 27!
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright reposted
The Fifth Column 🖐
@wethefifth
The fact that one of the biggest AI companies is led by a China hawk could turn out to be either extremely good or extremely bad.
From our new members-only episode with @robertwrighter.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Aric Toler
@AricToler
Mexican Man Killed by ICE in Houston Was Not the Target, they were searching for a Guatemalan in a different white van
Free gift link: www.nytimes.com/2026/07/09/us/witnesses-houston-ice-shoot… -
Robert Wright reposted
Mark Warner
@MarkWarner
Reports that the White House has dismissed the remaining members of the Election Assistance Commission — all of whom were unanimously confirmed by the Senate, including a commissioner appointed by President Trump himself — should concern every American, regardless of party, because the EAC was established by Congress as an independent, bipartisan body to help states administer secure and credible elections.
If these reports are accurate, removing every remaining commissioner just months before the 2026 midterm elections is an extraordinary step that demands an immediate explanation from the administration and raises profound concerns about political interference in the institutions that support our elections. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Iran, Israel, and the Future of US Power | @robertwrighter and @AmPrestigePod hosts @dwdavison and @dbessner discuss the state of the Iran war and its fallout for America and the world. Plus: the push to intertwine the US and Israeli militaries, the problem with blaming Bibi, Israel’s endgame for the Palestinians, and more.
youtu.be/ZvIJPfGby94?t=78 -
Robert Wright reposted
American Prestige
@AmPrestigePod
AP x @NonzeroPods - Iran, Israel, and the Future of US Power w/ @robertwrighter
The AP-NonZero collaboration continues!
americanprestigepod.com/episodes/2263325068 -
Robert Wright reposted
Andrew Day
@AKDay89
Is U.S.-Iran diplomacy doomed? Plus: Rubio's Iran incoherence. Good segment with two of the best foreign policy analysts: @robertwrighter and @CurtMills.
@amconmag @NonzeroPods
www.youtube.com/watch?v=HhFvmUIVOf4 -
Robert Wright reposted
Leonid Ragozin
@leonidragozin
Always a pleasure to be on @robertwrighter's @NonzeroPods. Tune in!
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
On the subject of whether the Ukraine War will expand into NATO countries, there's no journalist I'd rather hear from than @leonidragozin, who knows the territory and is good at assessing the vantage points of all sides. This was a great conversation.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Are Russia and NATO Headed for War? | As the NATO summit kicks off, @robertwrighter and journalist @leonidragozin discuss signs that the Ukraine war could spill into a direct conflict between Russia and members of NATO. Plus: The logic behind Putin's brinkmanship, why some European leaders may not want the Ukraine war to end, how the 90s set the stage for today’s conflicts, and more.
youtu.be/qHtkfdmbaDM?t=112 -
Robert Wright reposted
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
.@robertwrighter will discuss THE GOD TEST at 92NY on July 27!
Register to attend in-person or virtually here: www.92ny.org/event/robert-wright-with-bruce-feiler -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
On the subject of whether the Ukraine War will expand into NATO countries, there's no journalist I'd rather hear from than @leonidragozin, who knows the territory and is good at assessing the vantage points of all sides. This was a great conversation.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Are Russia and NATO Headed for War? | As the NATO summit kicks off, @robertwrighter and journalist @leonidragozin discuss signs that the Ukraine war could spill into a direct conflict between Russia and members of NATO. Plus: The logic behind Putin's brinkmanship, why some European leaders may not want the Ukraine war to end, how the 90s set the stage for today’s conflicts, and more.
youtu.be/qHtkfdmbaDM?t=112 -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Are Russia and NATO Headed for War? | As the NATO summit kicks off, @robertwrighter and journalist @leonidragozin discuss signs that the Ukraine war could spill into a direct conflict between Russia and members of NATO. Plus: The logic behind Putin's brinkmanship, why some European leaders may not want the Ukraine war to end, how the 90s set the stage for today’s conflicts, and more.
youtu.be/qHtkfdmbaDM?t=112 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I'm trying to imagine how you'd keep an open-weight model confined to one country. Seems... challenging.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
I've been reading and listening to @robertwrighter for years, so it was great to have him on the podcast. We get into lots of interesting disagreements, but on the central thesis of Bob's new book, @dioscuri and I are in complete agreement: AI is a huge deal.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Not sure I convinced @paulbloomatyale that skynet is trying to kill my new book on AI, The God Test. Listen to the evidence and judge for yourself. (And if you still have doubts, read the book: If you were skynet wouldn't you try to kill it?)
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Are Books Dead? | @robertwrighter and psychologist @paulbloomatyale discuss the state of the publishing industry—and why Bob suspects Skynet is trying to kill his new book. Plus: Gad Saad trash talk, the case for living forever, and Bob and Paul’s cop-stop story swap.
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Podcast Browser
@PodcastBrowser
Podcast with Robert Wright about his book The God Test. Discusses how AI's rapid evolution mirrors humanity's development, posing profound questions about intelligence, collaboration, and the future of our species.
@NextBigIdeaClub
@robertwrighter www.thepodcastbrowser.com/robert-wright-the-god-test/ -
Robert Wright reposted
Gary Marcus
@GaryMarcus
If this doesn’t chill you, I don’t know what will. 😱
“A president with the authority that Trump is now asserting could in theory put the world’s most powerful AI to repressive ends while at the same time keeping it off the market and out of the hands of rival power centers.”
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Over the past few weeks, President Trump has accomplished what you might call a time-release power grab. He has asserted a kind of authority over the dissemination of large language models that, as AI gets more and more capable, will make it easier for presidents to abuse their power. And, given the rate at which AI capabilities are growing, it’s not impossible that Trump will, during his remaining time in office, get a chance to demonstrate this fact.
The good news: I doubt that, even if Trump does get this chance, the 2.5-year constitutional limit on his tenure will be exceeded. But you never know…
Much of the dynamic I’m talking about is captured in this sentence from a Washington Post op-ed that I wrote last week (before events that, as I’ll explain, gave Trump’s power grab de facto validation): “A president with the authority that Trump is now asserting could in theory put the world’s most powerful AI to repressive ends while at the same time keeping it off the market and out of the hands of rival power centers.”
To keep reading, just go to nonzero dot org. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Over the past few weeks, President Trump has accomplished what you might call a time-release power grab. He has asserted a kind of authority over the dissemination of large language models that, as AI gets more and more capable, will make it easier for presidents to abuse their power. And, given the rate at which AI capabilities are growing, it’s not impossible that Trump will, during his remaining time in office, get a chance to demonstrate this fact.
The good news: I doubt that, even if Trump does get this chance, the 2.5-year constitutional limit on his tenure will be exceeded. But you never know…
Much of the dynamic I’m talking about is captured in this sentence from a Washington Post op-ed that I wrote last week (before events that, as I’ll explain, gave Trump’s power grab de facto validation): “A president with the authority that Trump is now asserting could in theory put the world’s most powerful AI to repressive ends while at the same time keeping it off the market and out of the hands of rival power centers.”
To keep reading, just go to nonzero dot org.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's a direct link to the piece: www.nonzero.org/p/trumps-time-release-ai-power-grab
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just in case any accelerationists are tempted to embrace my @NonzeroNews piece on the basis of the above excerpt, I should warn them that it also includes this:
Explaining how I could, in a single op-ed, warn about Trump’s assertion of power while applauding it (if tentatively and conditionally) highlights a policy challenge AI poses that is so acute as to border on a paradox: This technology will increasingly be so dangerous that it must be controlled, but it will also give dangerous amounts of power to those who control it.
That second danger is why I wrote in the Washington Post that “the government’s power to restrict the release of AI models should be carefully constrained—and Congress should play a role in designing the machinery of constraint and perhaps even in operating it.” The first danger is why I followed that sentence with, “But for now, no such system is in place. And the question on the table is: Is it really so obvious that Trump’s decision is indefensible on the merits—that the government didn’t have enough cause for concern to stifle Fable pending further consideration? To put the question more broadly: Isn’t it possible that AIs have gotten so powerful that erring on the side of caution makes sense?”
I answered with a yes, emphasizing in particular that Fable would make it easier than ever for…
To read the whole piece, go to nonzero dot org. -
Robert Wright reposted
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
What @robertwrighter means by the "God test" posed by rapid advances in AI: Can we overcome tribal biases and achieve moral progress and global cooperation?
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great conversation with @danwilliams & @dioscuri about my new book on AI, The God Test. Their Conspicuous Cognition podcast--and the substack its part of--are really worth checking out. www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bfky3MEGxPU
-
Robert Wright reposted
Amjad Atallah
@AtallahAmjad
This was a great episode…
Doha Debates
@DohaDebates
Can ancient wisdom save our future?
Featuring Wael Hallaq, @MacaesBruno and Sophie Scott-Brown.
youtu.be/_L8jmbqAOxM -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great conversation with @danwilliams & @dioscuri about my new book on AI, The God Test. Their Conspicuous Cognition podcast--and the substack its part of--are really worth checking out. www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bfky3MEGxPU
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Had a great time talking to @danwilliamsphil and @dioscuri on their Conspicuous Cognition Podcast about superintelligence, whether AI is a "normal technology," the case for a global slowdown, the multiple ways "Beat China" could backfire, and more (including my new book on AI).
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
New conversation! With the great @robertwrighter on his new book, “The God Test”: AI progress, superintelligence, the US-China race, global coordination, evolution’s purpose, and consciousness (@dioscuri). Full video here: (1/2) www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bfky3MEGxPU
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Gavin Purcell
@gavinpurcell
enjoying @robertwrighter’s ai book “The God Test” which is closer in spirit to Tegmark’s Life 3.0 than any other recent ai book
we need more people writing about the near future of where we’re going & not shying away from pluses or minuses
very high recommended -
Robert Wright reposted
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
New conversation! With the great @robertwrighter on his new book, “The God Test”: AI progress, superintelligence, the US-China race, global coordination, evolution’s purpose, and consciousness (@dioscuri). Full video here: (1/2) www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bfky3MEGxPU
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
AI Notkilleveryoneism Memes ⏸️
@AISafetyMemes
Look at this chart, but imagine Mythos is finding vulnerabilities in the human genome
Epoch AI
@EpochAIResearch
AI appears to be finding software vulnerabilities at scale.
In June 2026, 21 notable organizations disclosed ~1,500 high- and critical-severity CVEs, over 3.5× the previous monthly record set before Claude Mythos Preview's release. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Not sure I convinced @paulbloomatyale that skynet is trying to kill my new book on AI, The God Test. Listen to the evidence and judge for yourself. (And if you still have doubts, read the book: If you were skynet wouldn't you try to kill it?)
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Are Books Dead? | @robertwrighter and psychologist @paulbloomatyale discuss the state of the publishing industry—and why Bob suspects Skynet is trying to kill his new book. Plus: Gad Saad trash talk, the case for living forever, and Bob and Paul’s cop-stop story swap.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
God bless you, my son.
Jonathan B. Seltzer
@jbseltzer
Purchased. Looking forward to the read.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Are Books Dead? | @robertwrighter and psychologist @paulbloomatyale discuss the state of the publishing industry—and why Bob suspects Skynet is trying to kill his new book. Plus: Gad Saad trash talk, the case for living forever, and Bob and Paul’s cop-stop story swap.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Alan Eyre
@AlanEyre1
Engrossing rumination by @robertwrighter on AI's potential, perils & larger meanings. I don't know enough about AI yet to agree 100% w/its arguments, but it is full of useful ideas & promising paths. The exploration of 'cognitive sovereignty' alone is worth the time spent reading it, and there is far more in this useful map of the dangerous territority we're entering.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Brian Beckcom Lawyer
@BrianBeckcom
This is a form of prophecy, but sometimes the prophets are worth paying attention to.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This prediction of mine--from @JoelAchenbach's new Washington Post piece on the future of technology--will strike many people as crazy, but it's basically a corollary of things said by lots of AI observers, including the heads of the three big US AI companies.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Amen!
Brian Beckcom Lawyer
@BrianBeckcom
This is a form of prophecy, but sometimes the prophets are worth paying attention to.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This prediction of mine--from @JoelAchenbach's new Washington Post piece on the future of technology--will strike many people as crazy, but it's basically a corollary of things said by lots of AI observers, including the heads of the three big US AI companies.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Charles Sumner
@csumner70
A great watch!
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Had a great time talking to Andrew and Curt of @Amconmag about AI, the Burkean case against it, whether Marco Rubio is trying to undermine peace talks with Iran as a way of undermining JD Vance, etc.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This prediction of mine--from @JoelAchenbach's new Washington Post piece on the future of technology--will strike many people as crazy, but it's basically a corollary of things said by lots of AI observers, including the heads of the three big US AI companies.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's the Washington Post piece: www.washingtonpost.com/science/2026/07/01/america-300-ima…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Nobody does bigthink roundups like @JoelAchenbach. www.washingtonpost.com/science/2026/07/01/america-300-ima…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Rob
@darwin8u
I’ve read most of @robertwrighter’s books. This seems an appropriate addition to his corpus of books that can roughly be looked at as explorations of evolution as it relates to psychology (Moral Animal), religion (Evolution of God), intelligence (God Test). ‘Nonzero’ is the key.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Andrew Day
@AKDay89
Iran War debate. Here I ask @robertwrighter to settle a dispute between me and @CurtMills: Should restrainers encourage Trump to walk away from Iran or to strike a final peace deal?
youtu.be/PZbY7M6Nd24?t=3334 -
Robert Wright reposted
Alan Eyre
@AlanEyre1
Great quote from @robertwrighter in his latest book:
"Human history could be read as one long testament to the insistence of people on believing that they're good and right and large numbers of other people aren't."
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Listen to me cheerfully make the case for AI pessimism on @jacklgoldsmith's Executive Functions substack podcast. It's kind of uplifting, in a way...
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's the new book of mine we discussed: www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning…. And here's the whole conversation: www.execfunctions.org/p/the-god-test
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Had a great time talking to Andrew and Curt of @Amconmag about AI, the Burkean case against it, whether Marco Rubio is trying to undermine peace talks with Iran as a way of undermining JD Vance, etc.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Not sure about the collar, but it's definitely true that I'm on this episode of @verybadwizards. Both @peez and @tamler challenged my views on AI. Nice try, guys.
Very Bad Wizards
@verybadwizards
new ep! @robertwrighter joins @peez and @tamler to talk about his new book The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning
Plus a new AI-powered collar can translate your pet's sounds/behavior into language - with 95% accuracy! verybadwizards.com/episode/episode-336-the-wright-stuff -
Robert Wright reposted
The American Conservative
@amconmag
CROSSOVER EPISODE: @AKDay89 and @CurtMills talk to the author @robertwrighter about his new book, The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning. Also discussed: U.S.-China rivalry and the Iran War. @NonzeroPods
www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZbY7M6Nd24 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
A rare look behind the scenes of @binarybits's audio-only podcast AI Summer! Here, discussing my new book The God Test, I distinguish between the sense in which training an LLM is best thought of as 'learning' and the sense in which it's more like evolution.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's the whole conversation: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/robert-wright-on-the-global… And here's my book: www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Thanks to @jacklgoldsmith for giving me this chance, at the very outset of his Executive Functions Chat podcast, to explain some of the less cosmic aims of my cosmic-sounding book on AI, The God Test.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's the whole conversation on Jack's Substack, Executive Functions: www.execfunctions.org/p/the-god-test. And here's my cosmic-sounding (and intermittently cosmic, I admit) book: www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning…
-
Post not available here, view on X
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I spell out the (multiple) dangers of the 'race with China' mentality in my new book on AI, The God Test: www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Dan Williams
@danwilliamsphil
This week @dioscuri and I will be interviewing @robertwrighter - one of my favourite writers - about his new book on AI 👇. Really looking forward to this! Can subscribe here: www.youtube.com/@conspicuouscognition
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Patrick Mead
@patricklmead
That's an impressive endorsement. I just bought it on Audible.
I'd rather read it but time..... -
Robert Wright reposted
Joshua Landis
@joshua_landis
WSJ found that the U.S. is rethinking its footprint in the Middle East after Iranian damaged at least 20 U.S. sites.
Israel is one of the locations being considered for basing, according to two of the officials. www.wsj.com/world/middle-east/we-investigated-damage-from… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Shhhhh! Don't let the bots hear this.
Holly ⏸️ Elmore
@ilex_ulmus
Could not be happier that typos are becoming proof of humanity
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
From my piece in Friday's Washington Post on Trump's de facto ban of Anthropic's Fable.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's the piece: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/06/26/trump-fable-ai… I consider the subhed expecially important.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
And here's my new book on AI, in which I elaborate on the damage done to our long-term prospects by the "race with China" narrative. www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Kind words about my new book on AI, The God Test (or at least about the beginning of it!) from an eminent mathematician and bestselling author and famously good teacher.
Steven Strogatz
@stevenstrogatz
@robertwrighter Robert, I happened across your new book at a local bookstore and couldn't put it down. Very, very compelling from the first page – can't wait to read the rest of it!
-
Robert Wright reposted
psycheandpneuma
@psycheandpneuma
"...achieving the requisite level of planetary cohesion will in turn (I contend) call for an actual moral upgrade of our species; we’ll have to get better at overcoming the cognitive biases that constitute the “psychology of tribalism”—the psychology that has traditionally condemned the world to wars and other forms of deep division.
To put it in slightly more religious language: Salvation is possible, but only if we become better people."
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you've been lying awake at night wondering what exactly the title of my new book on AI means, your ship has come in. In the latest @NonzeroNews I provide the definitive exegesis. (Link in reply.)
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you've been lying awake at night wondering what exactly the title of my new book on AI means, your ship has come in. In the latest @NonzeroNews I provide the definitive exegesis. (Link in reply.)
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's the piece: www.nonzero.org/p/what-is-the-god-test The second paragraph is IMHO comedy gold.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nikos Mohammadi
AI is a God we can’t trust.
Writes George Scialabba in his first for @unherd, reviewing @robertwrighter’s “The God Test.”
unherd.com/2026/06/ai-a-god-we-cant-trust/?edition=us -
Robert Wright reposted
David Yellen
@dnyellen
Important new book about the challenges posed by AI by my friend @robertwrighter
open.substack.com/pub/nonzero/p/what-is-the-god-test?r=2cu6i -
Robert Wright reposted
Washington Post Opinions
@PostOpinions
“America’s preoccupation with ‘winning’ the AI race with China could well lead to unprecedented catastrophes, even catastrophes on a global scale,” @robertwrighter writes. www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/06/26/trump-fable-ai…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Sohrab Ahmari 🇺🇸
@SohrabAhmari
AI: The God We Can't Trust.
Reviewing @robertwrighter's new book on tech and spirituality.
Extremely proud to publish the great George Scialabba, one of the great social and literary critics of his generation, in UnHerd.
unherd.com/2026/06/ai-a-god-we-cant-trust/?edition=us -
Robert Wright reposted
Jan Zilinsky
@janzilinsky
Robert’s perspectives are consistently worthwhile:
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My piece in today's Washington Post. I consider the subhead at least as important as the headline. (And please read the argument I make re both before freaking out about either.) My new book on AI, The God Test, emphasizes the theme in the subhead. (Links in reply.)
-
Robert Wright reposted
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
How should humanity engage with AI? @robertwrighter's new book, THE GOD TEST, lays out what's at stake.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My piece in today's Washington Post. I consider the subhead at least as important as the headline. (And please read the argument I make re both before freaking out about either.) My new book on AI, The God Test, emphasizes the theme in the subhead. (Links in reply.)
-
Robert Wright reposted
Adam Gallagher
@AEGallagher10
The U.S. needs to get over its obsession with "winning the AI race" and start thinking seriously about the security concerns generated by increasingly powerful AIs. Sharp stuff from @robertwrighter
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My piece in today's Washington Post. I consider the subhead at least as important as the headline. (And please read the argument I make re both before freaking out about either.) My new book on AI, The God Test, emphasizes the theme in the subhead. (Links in reply.)
-
Robert Wright reposted
Daniel Kaplan
@dankaplan
Wright's column is much more nuanced than the headline, and makes a subtle point that most gut reactions (including mine) may miss:
In the hands of small, decently-resourced groups that want to watch the world burn, a jailbroken Fable (Mythos) becomes a factory for digital (and biological?) WMDs.
I miss the sweet, sweet brilliance of Fable as much as any AI junkie who had it for a week.
But I do prefer these feelings of frustration to feelings of the grid collapsing or a man-made pandemic arising.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My piece in today's Washington Post. I consider the subhead at least as important as the headline. (And please read the argument I make re both before freaking out about either.) My new book on AI, The God Test, emphasizes the theme in the subhead. (Links in reply.)
-
Robert Wright reposted
Matthew Yglesias
@mattyglesias
Different, albeit similar take from @robertwrighter
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My piece in today's Washington Post. I consider the subhead at least as important as the headline. (And please read the argument I make re both before freaking out about either.) My new book on AI, The God Test, emphasizes the theme in the subhead. (Links in reply.)
-
Robert Wright reposted
Gary Marcus
@GaryMarcus
“America’s preoccupation with “winning” the AI race with China could well lead to unprecedented catastrophes, even catastrophes on a global scale. Not all games are zero-sum, and if this fact doesn’t start playing a bigger role in American policy discourse, the AI revolution could turn out very badly”
- @robertwrighter
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My piece in today's Washington Post. I consider the subhead at least as important as the headline. (And please read the argument I make re both before freaking out about either.) My new book on AI, The God Test, emphasizes the theme in the subhead. (Links in reply.)
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My piece in today's Washington Post. I consider the subhead at least as important as the headline. (And please read the argument I make re both before freaking out about either.) My new book on AI, The God Test, emphasizes the theme in the subhead. (Links in reply.)
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's the Post piece: www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/06/26/trump-fable-ai… And here's my book: www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Paul Triolo
@pstAsiatech
This....from the amazing @robertwrighter!!
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If he's right about this, bear in mind that there can be a fine line between having LLMs write for you and having them think for you. The transfer of agency can happen in very small increments.
Joe Weisenthal
@TheStalwart
Unfortunately, I think that in the near future, not using LLMs to write for you will be like someone refusing to use Google Maps for directions in a new city. A bizarre idiosyncratic choice that's just completely incomprehensible to the vast majority of people.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I discuss the subtlety of agency transfer in my new book on AI, The God Test. www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
AI and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning | @robertwrighter & @NikitaSPetrov
0:00 Bob’s pub-day pitch for his new book on AI, The God Test
1:04 Is AI killing the nonfiction star?
5:32 Geoffrey Hinton’s path from AI evangelist to doomer
9:27 The future of books
18:48 Trump vs Anthropic
23:03 Are Ukrainian drone strikes rattling Putin?
32:07 The multiple Putins theory
35:04 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
Nikita's shared-dream experiment.
Is Putin a rational actor?
The case for non-wooly-minded one-worldism.
"Kindness as strength": The Armenian model.
Why powerful people are dicks.
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Nikita Petrov (psychopolitica.substack. com). Recorded June 23, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Sohrab Ahmari 🇺🇸
@SohrabAhmari
"The Iranians were like, ‘Fine, we’ll send somebody from the IRGC to go hang out in Doha with somebody from CENTCOM,’ and that’s how we’re going to settle a lot of these disputes.”
@JDVance to me, speaking aboard Air Force Two
Read the full interview
unherd.com/2026/06/jd-vance-our-new-relationship-with-iran/ -
Robert Wright reposted
Nathan Labenz
@labenz
The book is here: www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning…
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Daniel Kaplan
@dankaplan
Nonzero came out in 1999 and predicted nearly all of the technological upheavals and planetary-wide social pressures that unfolded over the subsequent 27 years.
Moral Animal made a deep (and humanistic) case for evolutionary psychology.
This new one sounds like a banger.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Kaiser Kuo
@KaiserKuo
Sam, check out my podcast interview with Bob! www.sinicapodcast.com/p/but-china-robert-wright-on-the-ai
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nathan Labenz
@labenz
"The market doesn't want an aligned model in the strict sense.
They're going to represent us in negotiations.
I don't want the agent to say: 'Bob doesn't have any other options'"
@robertwrighter on the commercial demand for AI deceptionThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nathan Labenz
@labenz
Out now from @robertwrighter: "The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning"
For those new to AI, it's an excellent catch-up crash course.
For AI insiders, it's a call for Nonzero-sum thinking, which we'll need to effectively govern AI development.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Tripp Fuller
@trippfuller
An excellent new book from @robertwrighter
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ramez Naam
@ramez
Just bought my copy. @robertwrighter is one of the most insightful commentators on the big picture of both the human mind and of the long and positive sum evolution of human society and the technology we wield. Can't wait to read this.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Samuel Hammond 🦉
@hamandcheese
Looking forward to this one. The Moral Animal, Nonzero, Evolution of God and Why Buddhism Is True are all in my pantheon of "books that fundamentally changed the way I think."
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I like the narrator of the Audible version of my new book on AI (Chris Henry Coffey). He has a midwestern twang that gives the book a common sense vibe (which helps when, as in this clip, you're talking about the singularity.) simonandschuster.app.box.com/s/ti6io5aaxjs0n3x7gk8ccw0zua…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This is exactly what I look like, btw. To hear what I sound like, check out this episode of @labenz's podcast The Cognitive Revolution.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Liron Shapira
@liron
NEW: My debate with Robert Wright over his new book, The God Test.
Who is @RobertWrighter?
👉 Wright co-founded bloggingheads.tv in 2005, years before podcasting and video debate became mainstream formats.
👉 His early work, The Moral Animal, is one of the most influential popularizations of evolutionary psychology ever written, named one of the best books of the year by The New York Times.
👉 He also wrote Nonzero: The Logic of Human Destiny, which President Bill Clinton praised and reportedly made required reading for his White House staff.
👉 Another of his books, The Evolution of God, was a Pulitzer Prize finalist.
👉 His recent book, Why Buddhism is True, was a New York Times bestseller that brought a rigorous scientific lens to meditation and mindfulness.
Topics covered:
⬜ What Is The God Test?
⬜ AI as Evolutionary Force, Not Normal Technology
⬜ Bob's Background: From Hinton in 1983 to Today
⬜ What's Your P(Doom)?™
⬜ The Mainline Scenario: Dystopia in 8 Years
⬜ Destabilization and the Road to Authoritarianism
⬜ Why Racing China Backfires
⬜ Would Bob Support PauseAI?
⬜ Intellidynamics
⬜ Symbol Grounding and Killing Searle's Chinese Room
⬜ God
Highly recommended! 👇This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Kevin Frazier
@KevinTFrazier
I know there's a lot of World Cup to watch...AND...during all those hydration breaks you should listen to @scaling_laws:
New episode with @robertwrighter, author of "The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning", and the best co-host in the land, @ARozenshtein.
Link below. -
Robert Wright reposted
Amjad Atallah
@AtallahAmjad
I’ve read @robertwrighter books before (The Moral Animal and Why Buddhism is True) and they are all beautifully written and thought-provoking. Ordering this now.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Liron Shapira
@liron
NEW: @RobertWrighter debated me over the claims in his new book, The God Test!
We cover:
⬜ What Is The God Test?
⬜ AI as Evolutionary Force, Not Normal Technology
⬜ Bob's Background: From Hinton in 1983 to Today
⬜ What's Your P(Doom)?™
⬜ The Mainline Scenario: Dystopia in 8 Years
⬜ Destabilization and the Road to Authoritarianism
⬜ Why Racing China Backfires
⬜ Would Bob Support PauseAI?
⬜ Intellidynamics
⬜ Symbol Grounding and Killing Searle's Chinese Room
⬜ God
Highly recommended! 👇This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Liron Shapira
@liron
Buy the book!
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
AI and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning | @robertwrighter and @NikitaSPetrov discuss whether AI spells doom for the nonfiction author—and other domains of human life—as Bob's own book on AI, The God Test, hits shelves. Plus: Hinton's journey from AI evangelist to doomer, Trump vs Anthropic, multi-Putin theory, and more. youtu.be/1GYMFlfWDAk?t=5
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had lots of fun talking to @ThatChrisRyan on his Tangentially Speaking podcast about my new book on AI. chrisryan.substack.com/p/robert-wright-author-the-god-test
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Thanks to @labenz for a great conversation about my new book on AI, The God Test, on his podcast The Cognitive Revolution. I appreciate the chance to reach his audience of AI insiders.
Nathan Labenz
@labenz
Out now from @robertwrighter: "The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning"
For those new to AI, it's an excellent catch-up crash course.
For AI insiders, it's a call for Nonzero-sum thinking, which we'll need to effectively govern AI development.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great conversation with @trippfuller on his Homebrewed Christianity podcast about my new book The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning. (link to book in my bio). www.homebrewedchristianty.com/2026/06/22/if-a-silicon-god…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nathan Labenz
@labenz
And here's the full episode, in which we discuss AI training as compressed evolution, the inevitability of a "global brain", risk of AI-enabled coups, and much more!
www.cognitiverevolution.ai/the-god-we-deserve-nonzero-s-r… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed my conversation with @binarybits on his podcast AI Summer about my new book on AI, The God Test. www.aisummer.org/p/robert-wright-on-the-global-implications
-
Robert Wright reposted
Alan Rozenshtein
@ARozenshtein
.@robertwrighter has written a terrific new book about AI. I got to talk with him about it on @scaling_laws.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Christopher Ryan
@ThatChrisRyan
My recent conversation with @robertwrighter was a doozy. His latest book, The God Test suggests an all-or-nothing future for our species. chrisryan.substack.com/p/robert-wright-author-the-god-test
-
Robert Wright reposted
Yhonatan Shemesh
@yshemesh
Looking forward to reading this. If it is as good as his previous books (Moral Animal, Non-zero, Why Buddhism is True), this will be a treat.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Thanks to @ARozenshtein for a great conversation on @lawfarepodcast about my new book on AI, The God Test. podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-god-test-ai-as-cosmic-r…
-
Robert Wright reposted
The End of the World Party
@teotwp3
Probably real good. Robert Wright's books are always excellent and important.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Zampano
@zampano
Looking forward to reading it
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Or maybe something in between... but, yes, I'm saying averting very serious trouble will require dramatic change. Really enjoyed this conversation with Chris.
Christopher Ryan
@ThatChrisRyan
My recent conversation with @robertwrighter was a doozy. His latest book, The God Test suggests an all-or-nothing future for our species. chrisryan.substack.com/p/robert-wright-author-the-god-test
-
Robert Wright reposted
Jeet Heer
@HeerJeet
Like everyone ele, I've been grappling with the implications of AI. I've found Wright's essays and podcasts super-helpful in thinking through the topic and am looking forward to this book as a needed intervention.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nathan Labenz
@labenz
Out now from @robertwrighter: "The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning"
For those new to AI, it's an excellent catch-up crash course.
For AI insiders, it's a call for Nonzero-sum thinking, which we'll need to effectively govern AI development.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
db
@dbessner
Everyone hail The Podfather and buy his book
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
Happy publication day to @robertwrighter! THE GOD TEST explores the challenges posed by AI, and whether humanity is up to the test.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=eZr5NF1uNqw -
Robert Wright reposted
Matt Duss
@mattduss
Been reading this, it’s great!
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Stephen Wertheim
@stephenwertheim
Trump is now Nixon going to China — if Nixon had bombed China first.
A remarkable if fragile opportunity has emerged to end this misbegotten war and begin to take America and Iran off their 47-year path of confrontation, @Rob_Malley and I write in @nytopinion.
Read paywall-free: www.nytimes.com/2026/06/23/opinion/trump-iran-war-confron… -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"We are the environment of AI's evolution. And unlike the environment of biological evolution, we are reflective and aware and conscious."
@robertwrighter discussing his new book The God Test on @jacklgoldsmith's Executive Functions Substack.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My conversation with @robertwrighter about his new book, "The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning" --
0:11 AI through an evolutionary lens
13:54 The promises and perils of AI
17:20 Global instability and the U.S.-China race to superintelligence
22:30 Preserving cognitive sovereignty
32:30 Global governance as a solution
42:25 Tribalism, attribution error, and the challenge of cooperation
58:29 What is the “God Test”?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Happy pub date to me! My book on AI is now available. If you want to ask questions about it before buying, just click reply. (And feel free to retweet!) The link to Amazon is in my bio.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed this conversation with Jack on his Executive Functions substack platform. Great questions, reflecting a close reading of my book.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My conversation with @robertwrighter about his new book, "The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning" --
0:11 AI through an evolutionary lens
13:54 The promises and perils of AI
17:20 Global instability and the U.S.-China race to superintelligence
22:30 Preserving cognitive sovereignty
32:30 Global governance as a solution
42:25 Tribalism, attribution error, and the challenge of cooperation
58:29 What is the “God Test”?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My conversation with @robertwrighter about his new book, "The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning" --
0:11 AI through an evolutionary lens
13:54 The promises and perils of AI
17:20 Global instability and the U.S.-China race to superintelligence
22:30 Preserving cognitive sovereignty
32:30 Global governance as a solution
42:25 Tribalism, attribution error, and the challenge of cooperation
58:29 What is the “God Test”?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Mickey Kaus
@kausmickey
Ordered my copy of @robertwrighter 's big new AI book ... www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning… Out Tuesday ...
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I always enjoy talking to @joshua_landis about the Middle East--he gets the big picture and conveys it crisply.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The World After the Iran War | @robertwrighter & @joshua_landis
0:00 Was "losing" this war good for America?
6:02 Israel’s post-war situation
9:35 A more stable Middle East? Or less?
17:43 The impact on Iran’s strength
21:19 Has the war empowered Russia and China?
24:15 How modern warfare devalues American military power
27:17 Josh: The Gulf-state power struggle is just beginning
40:24 Are the Palestinians back in the spotlight?
45:11 Where do Israel-US relations go from here?
48:05 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
Israel's self-inflicted security dilemmas.
Chaos in the West Bank and Lebanon.
Will Israel sabotage the ceasefire?
The defense bill that would lock in US-Israel cooperation.
Digging into the MOU.
The MOU's ambiguous "frozen assets" clause.
Josh's odds on the ceasefire lasting.
The precarious state of Syria.
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Joshua Landis (University of Oklahoma, SyriaComment. com). Recorded June 17, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The World After the Iran War | @robertwrighter & @joshua_landis
0:00 Was "losing" this war good for America?
6:02 Israel’s post-war situation
9:35 A more stable Middle East? Or less?
17:43 The impact on Iran’s strength
21:19 Has the war empowered Russia and China?
24:15 How modern warfare devalues American military power
27:17 Josh: The Gulf-state power struggle is just beginning
40:24 Are the Palestinians back in the spotlight?
45:11 Where do Israel-US relations go from here?
48:05 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
Israel's self-inflicted security dilemmas.
Chaos in the West Bank and Lebanon.
Will Israel sabotage the ceasefire?
The defense bill that would lock in US-Israel cooperation.
Digging into the MOU.
The MOU's ambiguous "frozen assets" clause.
Josh's odds on the ceasefire lasting.
The precarious state of Syria.
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Joshua Landis (University of Oklahoma, SyriaComment. com). Recorded June 17, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Matthew Hoh
@MatthewPHoh
It is always well worth the time to listen to a @joshua_landis and @robertwrighter conversation.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The World After the Iran War | @robertwrighter and Middle East scholar @joshua_landis of the @QuincyInst game out the global and regional fallout from the Iran war. youtu.be/EdeMLq5bu7Q?t=106
-
Robert Wright reposted
Joshua Landis
@joshua_landis
One of the smartest podcasters: @robertwrighter
We discuss #iran, #syria, #israel and how Trump's Middle East policy is in shambles - Abraham Accords, Gulf policy, and unswerving faith in Israeli leadership.
A new Middle East is bound to emerge from the new balance of power
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The World After the Iran War | @robertwrighter and Middle East scholar @joshua_landis of the @QuincyInst game out the global and regional fallout from the Iran war. youtu.be/EdeMLq5bu7Q?t=106
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed this conversation with @jacklgoldsmith on his Executive Functions podcast. I'm flattered by how closely he must have read the book to ask such good questions.
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My chat w/ Robert Wright about his fascinating new book (out next week),"The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning." Topics: AI through evolutionary lens, AI safety, US-China cooperation, personal transformation.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-god-test?r… -
Robert Wright reposted
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My chat w/ Robert Wright about his fascinating new book (out next week),"The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning." Topics: AI through evolutionary lens, AI safety, US-China cooperation, personal transformation.
open.substack.com/pub/executivefunctions/p/the-god-test?r… -
Robert Wright reposted
Ishaan Tharoor
@ishaantharoor
"For every tear of an Israeli mother, a thousand Lebanese mothers must weep. All of Lebanon must burn!" Ben Gvir has been a cabinet minister for multiple years now and it's remarkable to me how the institutional lobby in the US that purports to care about the future of Israel is utterly silent about a man who is fueling its geopolitical isolation for a generation, and more invested in policing the speech of US kids on campuses.
איתמר בן גביר
@itamarbengvir
על כל דמעה של אמא ישראלית, אלף אמהות לבנוניות צריכות לבכות. לבנון כולה צריכה לבעור!
עם כל הכבוד לאמריקאים, ישראל חייבת להבהיר לעולם כולו שדם בנינו וביטחון אזרחנו איננו הפקר. לבנון כולה צריכה לבעור. חובתנו העליונה היא להגן על אזרחי ישראל ועל חיילי צה״ל, והמחויבות הזו קודמת לכל שיקול אחר.
אמרתי לראש הממשלה, גם בישיבות בינינו: על כל דמעה של אמא ישראלית, אלף אימהות לבנוניות צריכות לבכות.
מספיק עם הפינג־פונג. במזרח התיכון לא מנצחים בתגובות מדודות ובהכלה - צריך להשתגע. למחוק. להכריע את הטרור. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I always learn a lot from my conversations with @joshua_landis.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The World After the Iran War | @robertwrighter and Middle East scholar @joshua_landis of the @QuincyInst game out the global and regional fallout from the Iran war. youtu.be/EdeMLq5bu7Q?t=106
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The World After the Iran War | @robertwrighter and Middle East scholar @joshua_landis of the @QuincyInst game out the global and regional fallout from the Iran war. youtu.be/EdeMLq5bu7Q?t=106
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Dean Ball is a smart guy with integrity who cares about policy and isn't completely anti-regulation, but I think his libertarian leanings sit uneasily with Sam Altman's past claims to consider AI a grave risk along multiple dimensions.
Dean W. Ball
@deanwball
I am pleased and honored to announce that, on July 6, I'll be joining @OpenAI as leader of a new team called Strategic Futures. Our mandate will be to help the company's leadership shape frontier AI policy. There is a ton of work to do, and I'm excited to get started.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Kyle Chan
@kyleichan
The US-China "AI race" is sometimes framed as a race to prevent a world dominated by "authoritarian AI."
But as @robertwrighter points out, this race dynamic itself could be the ultimate cause of "an authoritarian AI-mediated world." podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/but-china-robert-wright-on-… -
Robert Wright reposted
Samuel F. Reynolds
@UnlockAstrology
One of my favorite authors has a new book coming out on AI. Just pre-ordered my Audible. Excited to hear his thoughts on it. #thegodtest
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Thanks to @KaiserKuo for a wonderful @SinicaPodcast conversation about my book on AI, which comes out this Tuesday. (You can pre-order here: www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning…) And special thanks to Kaiser for using a nine-year-old picture of me!
Kaiser Kuo
@KaiserKuo
A @SinicaPodcast conversation I've wanted to have for years: @robertwrighter on his new book THE GOD TEST. AI as an evolutionary force, Teilhard's "global brain," cognitive empathy, and the two-word talking point quietly steering the whole AI race — "But China!" 🎙️ 👇
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Thanks to @KaiserKuo for a wonderful @SinicaPodcast conversation about my book on AI, which comes out this Tuesday. (You can pre-order here: www.amazon.com/God-Test-Artificial-Intelligence-Reckoning…) And special thanks to Kaiser for using a nine-year-old picture of me!
Kaiser Kuo
@KaiserKuo
A @SinicaPodcast conversation I've wanted to have for years: @robertwrighter on his new book THE GOD TEST. AI as an evolutionary force, Teilhard's "global brain," cognitive empathy, and the two-word talking point quietly steering the whole AI race — "But China!" 🎙️ 👇
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ryan Fedasiuk
@RyanFedasiuk
Such a blast—though very nervewracking!—to ramble for an hour about prospects for AI arms control.
➡️ I think we’re likely to see U.S.-China *coordination* on respective AI regulations, rather than *cooperation* (e.g. via treaty) that might sacrifice capability development.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The US-China AI Race | @RyanFedasiuk, a China and tech analyst with @AEI, joins @robertwrighter to discuss the trajectory of AI and what it means for Sino-American relations—including how China views Mythos, the feasibility of a global AI pause, how controlling AI compares to controlling nuclear arms, and more.
youtu.be/5FTm0hS-vrE?t=238 -
Robert Wright reposted
Kaiser Kuo
@KaiserKuo
A @SinicaPodcast conversation I've wanted to have for years: @robertwrighter on his new book THE GOD TEST. AI as an evolutionary force, Teilhard's "global brain," cognitive empathy, and the two-word talking point quietly steering the whole AI race — "But China!" 🎙️ 👇
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The US-China AI Race | @RyanFedasiuk, a China and tech analyst with @AEI, joins @robertwrighter to discuss the trajectory of AI and what it means for Sino-American relations—including how China views Mythos, the feasibility of a global AI pause, how controlling AI compares to controlling nuclear arms, and more.
youtu.be/5FTm0hS-vrE?t=238 -
Robert Wright reposted
Van Jackson
@RealVanJackson
It’s crazy how the US is actively intensifying great-power rivalry with China in almost every way imaginable but media and pundits overlook it because the rhetoric has cooled amid multiple wars elsewhere
Pacific Center for Island Security
@PCIS_Guam
"The report also disclosed that the Pentagon is planning to deploy offensive missiles on Guam." www.washingtontimes.com/news/2026/jun/16/indo-pacific-com…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The fundamental dilemma with AI: too much centralized control is dangerous. Too little oversight is dangerous.
@robertwrighterThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Secret of AI’s Power | @robertwrighter & @paulbloomatyale
0:00 Whose baby is cuter?
2:49 Bob's new book on AI, The God Test
9:52 Varieties of AI awe
13:23 Geoffrey Hinton’s vision
17:50 How LLMs do more than predict and parrot
21:20 How powerful will AI get?
25:56 Can AI’s impact be predicted?
30:48 Taking doomerism seriously
37:53 The AI governance dilemma
48:42 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
AI, evolutionary purpose and the noosphere.
Would humans have a place in an AI noosphere?
Could we stop AI?
Levels of evolutionary purpose.
How do you sell a book now?
Do podcasts move books?
Who should read The God Test?
The outrage route to fame.
Will AI kill nonfiction books?
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Paul Bloom (Small Potatoes, University of Toronto, The Sweet Spot, Against Empathy). Recorded June 3, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My book on AI is available next week. It's not too soon to pre-order!
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
Great seeing THE GOD TEST by @robertwrighter in @AirMailWeekly!
airmail.news/issues/2026-6-13/the-god-test -
Robert Wright reposted
Simon & Schuster
@SimonBooks
Great seeing THE GOD TEST by @robertwrighter in @AirMailWeekly!
airmail.news/issues/2026-6-13/the-god-test -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Serious question: Did the New York Times run a single article noting that the US-Israeli attack on Iran violated the bedrock international law against transborder aggression that's enshrined in the UN Charter (a treaty ratified by the US, whose constitution says treaties, once ratified, become the 'law of the land')?
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Jay Solomon, who wrote a piece in The Free Press (Bari Weiss's neocon propaganda outlet) aimed at getting Iran War critic @tparsi of @QuincyInst deported for exercising free speech, was fired by the Wall Street Journal for unethical conduct nine years ago.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Dario says using Claude in bombing Iran is "a use case that doesn't even violate our red lines." The attack on Iran violated the UN Charter--a treaty ratified by the US. So breaking international law is within your "red lines," Dario?
Victims of Capitalism Memorial Foundation
@karaokecomputer
CEO of Anthropic Dario Amodei awkwardly smiles through his answer to a question about why Claude AI directly contributed to the US Military bombing of the elementary school in Minab.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Brian Beckcom Lawyer
@BrianBeckcom
Nice Burke reference
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I was following him until he said the tech elites favor tradition and conservative values. They don't seem very Burkean to me!
-
Post not available here, view on X
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I was following him until he said the tech elites favor tradition and conservative values. They don't seem very Burkean to me!
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The AI Lobby’s Dirty Tricks | @robertwrighter & @tyler_johnston
0:00 Teaser
2:43 The Midas Project and the OpenAI files
12:19 What’s "Build American AI" up to?
21:00 Nathan Leamer, astroturfer and sock puppeteer
29:04 Greg Brockman, AI lobby bankroller
35:13 Astroturfing the China panic
39:51 Is OpenAI an innocent bystander?
48:31 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
The Midas metaphor.
Rationalists vs effective altruists.
China hawkism within AI safety circles.
The Oppenheimer analogy.
Doomerism among AI's founding fathers.
Is Big Tech closing in on almonds?
The jagged edge of Marc Andreessen's intelligence.
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Tyler Johnston (The Midas Project). Recorded June 9, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Tyler Johnston
@tyler_johnston
Was very fun to go on @NonzeroPods as a long-time reader!
Bob is a very attentive observer of the strangeness of this moment in the AI industry. Now counting the days to his book on the subject...
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The AI Lobby’s Dirty Tricks | @tyler_johnston, founder of @TheMidasProj, joins @robertwrighter to discuss the funding and activities of the group Build American AI. Plus: Elon’s OpenAI grievance, the singularity, and more.
youtu.be/G9Ovyw6dT0U?t=163 -
Robert Wright reposted
Tyler Johnston
@tyler_johnston
Not only did Leading the Future think OpenAI was funding them -- I also have reason to think that info has been flowing between OpenAI and Leading The Future for months, including about their sockpuppet accounts.
I spoke about it on today's episode of the Nonzero podcast here:
Shakeel
@ShakeelHashim
In recent weeks, OpenAI has made multiple statements distancing itself from Leading the Future, the accelerationist, Greg Brockman-funded super PAC, and Build American AI, the PAC’s advocacy group.
Brockman's donation, OpenAI insists, was made in a “personal capacity."
But @ReadTransformer has found that not everyone working within LTF appears to view it that way.
“For this project I’m funded by four separate entities … OpenAI is just one of them,” Nathan Leamer, executive director of Build American AI, told Transformer over text message on May 3.
“I think the best way to think of it is the corporate funders all have a say," he said. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The AI Lobby’s Dirty Tricks | @tyler_johnston, founder of @TheMidasProj, joins @robertwrighter to discuss the funding and activities of the group Build American AI. Plus: Elon’s OpenAI grievance, the singularity, and more.
youtu.be/G9Ovyw6dT0U?t=163 -
Robert Wright reposted
Arnaud Bertrand
@RnaudBertrand
By the way, public service announcement: if you're one of the numerous people posting about Anthropic's dystopian ways and you're thinking about getting Claude to help you write that post... don't!
Another one of their terms is that you may not use Claude to do anything that "exposes [Anthropic to] reputational harms" 👇
And, if you do, under the - extremely unusual - clause 13 of their terms (www.anthropic.com/legal/consumer-terms), you have PRE-AGREED, by using Anthropic (and accepted their terms), that the harm you've done is irreparable, that you won't oppose Anthropic injunction, and they don't need to prove actual damage.
They can simply go to a judge in a friendly jurisdiction (and of course, their terms precise that any dispute "will be resolved exclusively in the state or federal courts located in San Francisco, California") and:
a) file an injunction that shuts you down
b) make you pay for everything since under section 11 of their terms you agree to indemnify Anthropic for "any and all liabilities, claims, damages, expenses (including reasonable attorneys' fees and costs), and other losses arising out of or related to your breach or alleged breach of these Terms."
In other words, if you use Claude to help you talk shit about Anthropic publicly, their terms say you pay their lawyers to go after you and you've already pre-agreed you've lost the case.
Oh, and cherry on the cake: in the odd case the judge were like "are you crazy, this is insanely abusive, you Anthropic are the ones at fault here," according to their terms Anthropic's maximum liability is... $100. -
Robert Wright reposted
Andrew Curran
@AndrewCurran_
OpenAI has banned multiple accounts that were using ChatGPT to post content here on X in attempts to influence the public against datacenter construction, and against tariffs on technology.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Mark Zuckerberg is monitoring his employees' keystrokes so he can replicate the thought process they use to do their jobs — and then he can fire them.
@robertwrighter on why AI will keep getting more powerful.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Secret of AI’s Power | @robertwrighter & @paulbloomatyale
0:00 Whose baby is cuter?
2:49 Bob's new book on AI, The God Test
9:52 Varieties of AI awe
13:23 Geoffrey Hinton’s vision
17:50 How LLMs do more than predict and parrot
21:20 How powerful will AI get?
25:56 Can AI’s impact be predicted?
30:48 Taking doomerism seriously
37:53 The AI governance dilemma
48:42 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
AI, evolutionary purpose and the noosphere.
Would humans have a place in an AI noosphere?
Could we stop AI?
Levels of evolutionary purpose.
How do you sell a book now?
Do podcasts move books?
Who should read The God Test?
The outrage route to fame.
Will AI kill nonfiction books?
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Paul Bloom (Small Potatoes, University of Toronto, The Sweet Spot, Against Empathy). Recorded June 3, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Secret of AI’s Power | @robertwrighter & @paulbloomatyale
0:00 Whose baby is cuter?
2:49 Bob's new book on AI, The God Test
9:52 Varieties of AI awe
13:23 Geoffrey Hinton’s vision
17:50 How LLMs do more than predict and parrot
21:20 How powerful will AI get?
25:56 Can AI’s impact be predicted?
30:48 Taking doomerism seriously
37:53 The AI governance dilemma
48:42 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
AI, evolutionary purpose and the noosphere.
Would humans have a place in an AI noosphere?
Could we stop AI?
Levels of evolutionary purpose.
How do you sell a book now?
Do podcasts move books?
Who should read The God Test?
The outrage route to fame.
Will AI kill nonfiction books?
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Paul Bloom (Small Potatoes, University of Toronto, The Sweet Spot, Against Empathy). Recorded June 3, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
So OpenAI needs to replace Altman with someone who virtue signals as well as Dario? I'm available.
wordgrammer
@wordgrammer
Anthropic has no technical moat. Their advantage is that OpenAI bleeds talent to Anthropic, but no Anthropic talent goes back to OpenAI. And so the flow of lab leak secrets is balanced in Anthropic’s favor
-
Robert Wright reposted
wordgrammer
@wordgrammer
Anthropic has no technical moat. Their advantage is that OpenAI bleeds talent to Anthropic, but no Anthropic talent goes back to OpenAI. And so the flow of lab leak secrets is balanced in Anthropic’s favor
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ihab Hassan
@IhabHassane
BREAKING: After setting the Christian village of Taybeh on fire, Israeli settlers are now at the entrance of the Christian city of Bethlehem, throwing stones at cars — under the protection of the Israeli army.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Secret of AI’s Power | Psychologist @paulbloomatyale, author of the Small Potatoes newsletter, assesses @robertwrighter's forthcoming book The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning.
youtu.be/8wnl3LwfYMY?t=169 -
Robert Wright reposted
Ishaan Tharoor
@ishaantharoor
PERSONAL NEWS: I've joined the @NewYorker full-time as a global-affairs columnist, where I'll be writing a weekly essay on the world. It's a dream gig and I'm still pinching myself that I get to say all these incredible, talented journalists I've long admired are my colleagues!
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"It's like you're always navigating around these boundaries, but you're still dancing."
@tianyuf on @yilingliu95's The Wall Dancers and online censorship in China.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Seeing China Clearly | @robertwrighter & @tianyuf
0:00 Teaser
0:45 How Tianyu became a “China explainer”
3:15 American vs Chinese exceptionalism
8:09 What you can and can’t say in China
18:32 Is the government more accountable in the US or China?
27:03 How China sees America
36:32 The one-child policy and its consequences
42:53 Tianyu: The biggest misconception about China is…
46:20 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
Chinese vs American surveillance.
What China has that America doesn’t.
How China sees AI.
Dario Amodei: China-hawk via God complex?
Is China all-in on open-weight AI?
How Silicon Valley went from hippie to hawkish.
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Tianyu Fang (New America). Recorded June 2, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Seeing China Clearly | @robertwrighter & @tianyuf
0:00 Teaser
0:45 How Tianyu became a “China explainer”
3:15 American vs Chinese exceptionalism
8:09 What you can and can’t say in China
18:32 Is the government more accountable in the US or China?
27:03 How China sees America
36:32 The one-child policy and its consequences
42:53 Tianyu: The biggest misconception about China is…
46:20 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
Chinese vs American surveillance.
What China has that America doesn’t.
How China sees AI.
Dario Amodei: China-hawk via God complex?
Is China all-in on open-weight AI?
How Silicon Valley went from hippie to hawkish.
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Tianyu Fang (New America). Recorded June 2, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This WSJ headline is a bit misleading. Anthropic said a slowdown or pause would be nice "if it were possible" but that it's not possible since it's not globally verifiable, so Anthropic will study what mechanisms might make it possible. Better than nothing, but still..
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Meanwhile, in the FT, there's this. www.ft.com/content/d02d91b3-2636-454e-9442-dc7e69f51815
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
These two sides of Anthropic--Dario as the conscience of Silicon Valley, Dario as eager tool of aggressive US hegemony--won't surprise anyone who's been paying attention. As I put it a few months ago in @NonzeroNews:
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's that piece: www.nonzero.org/p/dario-amodei-isnt-the-hero-we-need
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Seeing China Clearly | Trans-Pacific tech watcher @tianyuf joins @robertwrighter to take a close look at China—including how the government works (and doesn’t), online censorship, how China sees AI and the chip war, the legacy of the one-child policy, and more. Plus: Silicon Valley’s hawkish turn.
youtu.be/_GGfTGZtMLE?t=195 -
Robert Wright reposted
WIRED
@WIRED
Code reviewed by WIRED uncovered an unreleased face-recognition system embedded in Meta’s smart glasses platform. It’s designed to identify people via biometric data stored on users’ phones. www.wired.com/story/meta-smart-glasses-face-recognition-n…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Daniel ETH (refuted)
@daniel_271828
If anyone from the AI safety community or the EA community posted this image in response to warnings about AI, I fully expect they’d be (rightly) banned from future events. In reality, this was posted by a sockpuppet run by a super PAC funded by a16z & OpenAI’s Greg Brockman
-
Robert Wright reposted
Kaiser Kuo
@KaiserKuo
7/ All of this lands right on top of something I've been chewing on. I just finished Robert Wright's (@robertwrighter) forthcoming "The God Test," and he pushes the argument a step past where Sheehan takes it.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This comment on AI is from a guy who works at OpenAI.
roon
@tszzl
the frontier labs don’t have “comms problems”. reality right now has a comms problem. what is happening is a little scary and there’s no nice words anyone could say, especially not those profiting from it, that’ll make it feel that much better
-
Robert Wright reposted
Increments
@IncrementsPod
New ep! @robertwrighter joins us to discuss his new book, The God Test. @VadenMasrani manages to behave himself (mostly), @BennyChugg tries to ingratiate himself as a nonzero subscriber, and Bob fends off accusations of unfalsifiability
www.youtube.com/watch?v=TjuZjHYyEm0 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Facts don't care about your feelings.
Yaroslav Trofimov
@yarotrof
Hegseth says U.S. “feels very good” about U.S. weapons stockpiles after the war with Iran. #iiss_sld26
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump’s Iran War Merry-Go-Round | Robert Wright, Derek Davison, and Daniel Bessner
0:00 Is NonZero or American Prestige the better podcast? AI weighs in
4:12 The state of the US-Iran war. Or is it peace?
17:52 Has Trump already lost the midterms? Does he care?
24:16 The Russia-Ukraine war (and Eric Schmidt)
29:23 What the latest Iran war strikes signal
31:04 Overtime preview: Nuland’s “monsters,” zombie blobsters, Barak Ravid, Bari Weiss, “killzones,” and the Pope vs AI
Discussed in Overtime:
Victoria Nuland’s "monster" theory of diplomacy.
Jake Sullivan and Antony Blinken: zombie blobsters?
The Barak Ravid controversy.
Did technology balkanize America? Or did capitalism?
What's Bari Weiss's CBS reign really about?
Danny’s vision of the multipolar(-ish) world-to-come.
The Pope vs AI.
“Killzones” and the future of war.
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True), Derek Davison (Foreign Exchanges, American Prestige, Discontents), and Daniel Bessner (American Prestige, University of Washington). Recorded May 28, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Aircraft carriers are obsolete. We just haven't proven it in combat yet.
@dwdavison, @dbessner, and @robertwrighter discuss drones and multipolarity.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump’s Iran War Merry-Go-Round | Robert Wright, Derek Davison, and Daniel Bessner
0:00 Is NonZero or American Prestige the better podcast? AI weighs in
4:12 The state of the US-Iran war. Or is it peace?
17:52 Has Trump already lost the midterms? Does he care?
24:16 The Russia-Ukraine war (and Eric Schmidt)
29:23 What the latest Iran war strikes signal
31:04 Overtime preview: Nuland’s “monsters,” zombie blobsters, Barak Ravid, Bari Weiss, “killzones,” and the Pope vs AI
Discussed in Overtime:
Victoria Nuland’s "monster" theory of diplomacy.
Jake Sullivan and Antony Blinken: zombie blobsters?
The Barak Ravid controversy.
Did technology balkanize America? Or did capitalism?
What's Bari Weiss's CBS reign really about?
Danny’s vision of the multipolar(-ish) world-to-come.
The Pope vs AI.
“Killzones” and the future of war.
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True), Derek Davison (Foreign Exchanges, American Prestige, Discontents), and Daniel Bessner (American Prestige, University of Washington). Recorded May 28, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
American Prestige
@AmPrestigePod
AP x NonZero - Trump’s Iran War Merry-Go-Round w/ @robertwrighter
The greatest bi-monthly collaboration in podcasting is back!
americanprestigepod.com/episodes/6955686433 -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump’s Iran War Merry-Go-Round | @robertwrighter and @AmPrestigePod hosts @dwdavison and @dbessner discuss the state of the US-Iran conflict, Trump’s midterm prospects, Russia-Ukraine updates, Victoria Nuland’s “monster” theory of diplomacy, the Pope on AI, and more.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Tony Karon
@TonyKaron
Inflation as a personal brand…
The Washington Post
@washingtonpost
Breaking news: Trump administration officials have pressed the Bureau of Engraving and Printing to design a $250 bill featuring the president’s portrait, in what would be the first appearance of a living person on U.S. currency in more than 150 years. www.washingtonpost.com/investigations/2026/05/28/trump-25…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Pope Takes On AI | Robert Wright & Nikita Petrov
0:00 A Greek pilgrimage, a mystery guest, and a Discord revival
5:33 The first Papal encyclical devoted to AI
10:48 Pope Leo: just war theory is outdated, and AI lets humans dodge accountability
21:04 Anthropic tells the Pope about "mysterious, even unsettling" things inside AI
27:17 Inside the "Kill Zone": How drones changed the Russia-Ukraine front
33:46 Who gets replaced first: the soldier or the commander?
38:23 Russia's hypersonic missiles and nuclear signaling
48:01 Do drones favor the underdog? Plus a warning on Taiwan
50:20 The Iran ceasefire wobbles as Israel pushes back
51:59 Heading to Overtime: Greek mystery cults, Teilhard de Chardin, and Blade Runner
57:35 Enter the Mystery Guest: Jeremy Eliosoff, Pause AI Canada
Discussed in Overtime:
Pause AI.
Nikita's Greek dream retreat: oracles, black rams, sacred snakes.
Teilhard de Chardin's noosphere: a planetary brain of brains.
Kin selection, cooperating cells, and the search for connection.
Philip K Dick's vision of a holographic reality.
Waking Life.
Blade Runner 2049.
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Nikita Petrov (Psychopolitica). Recorded May 26, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Daniel Boguslaw
@DRBoguslaw
BREAKING: The federal government is targeting Anti-AI and data center activists. They are formulating a new threat category: anti-tech violent extremism. Full article in replies.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Pope Takes On AI | @robertwrighter and @NikitaSPetrov discuss Pope Leo XIV's warnings about AI's role in war and consolidation of power, and look at how Ukraine's drone-powered "Kill Zone" is changing rules of warfare. youtu.be/mmwzAye5gJk?t=333
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Ritual is the original human algorithm.
@BruceFeiler -
Robert Wright reposted
Janae Steville
@StevilleJanae
Valuable discussion with @HamidRezaAz about the history of Iran’s experiences with the U.S. and its neighbors that cures many misconceptions and simplifications about the country and its response to the current conflict
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"Every step that Iran takes in order to provide Trump with an exit is interpreted by Trump as a sign of weakness and a sign of pressure working, so he doubles down."
@HamidRezaAzThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"They were all formed as some sort of resistance movement. They had their roots in the local environments of their respective countries."
@HamidRezaAz discusses the local roots of Iran's "proxies" — a term he argues oversimplifies the relationship. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Can Rituals Save Us? | Robert Wright & Bruce Feiler
0:00 Teaser
0:52 Bruce’s new book on ritual, A Time to Gather
3:12 The "Lifequake" that led Bruce to study ritual
8:10 The current "shadow ritual" renaissance
12:42 What is a ritual?
15:26 The origins of the shadow ritual renaissance
18:25 Forest bathing and the essence of ritual
26:11 Ritual as the original human algorithm
31:39 Honor walks: a quintessentially modern ritual 36:23 Rituals across Christianity
42:07 What rituals do
46:47 Heading to Overtime
Discussed in Overtime:
Tribalism in the age of AI.
Lifequakes in the age of AI.
IRL rituals in the age of AI.
Pain, commitment, and dental rituals.
Ritual-forward families.
Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Bruce Feiler (Council of Dads, Walking the Bible, A Time to Gather). Recorded April 21, 2026.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Can Rituals Save Us? | @robertwrighter and @BruceFeiler, author of Walking the Bible and the Council of Dads, gather to discuss the role of ritual in humanity's past, present and future—the subject of Bruce’s new book, A Time to Gather: How Ritual Created the World—and How It Can Save Us. youtu.be/wwKpWohaxk8?t=192
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nathan Calvin
@_NathanCalvin
It’s really something that the super PACs Andreessen funds are like “concerns about ai job loss are fake doomer propaganda” and Andreesen is just saying “oh yeah obviously I’d rather hire an AI, they don’t file HR complaints or get sad”
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"Every step that Iran takes in order to provide Trump with an exit is interpreted by Trump as a sign of weakness and a sign of pressure working, so he doubles down."
@HamidRezaAzThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I learned a lot from my conversation with @HamidRezaAz--looking forward to his book The Axis of Resistance (out in Europe now, in US soon). You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=40NH3yk15b0
-
Robert Wright reposted
Rob Wiblin
@robertwiblin
.@METR_Evals red-teamed what an unreleased AI could get away with inside 4 frontier labs today.
They concluded that they could already start a 'minimal rogue deployment' at all 4 thanks to weaknesses in their setup.
Though for now the models don't have the wits to hide from a monitor for more than a few days. And their motive is reward hacking rather than power seeking.
Here's what stands out to me from their new 320-page report:
00:00 What could an unreleased AI get away with?
01:54 Motive: Why grab more compute?
05:46 Opportunity: YOLO mode and jailbreaks
11:02 Means: Brilliant idiots in data centres
15:45 We have to test unreleased models
18:29 Especially if AI R&D is coming in 2028This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Hamidreza Azizi
@HamidRezaAz
It was a pleasure to join @robertwrighter on @NonzeroPods to discuss the evolution of #iran’s regional policy and Tehran’s cultivation of the Axis of Resistance.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Understanding Iran | Social scientist @HamidRezaAz, author of The Axis of Resistance, joins @robertwrighter to discuss the forces that shaped the Iranian regime and its attitude toward the US and Israel.
youtu.be/40NH3yk15b0?t=180 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Trump's all-too-rare cooperative impulses should be encouraged. But when he expresses them, the MSM and the Blob give him negative feedback. My @NonzeroNews piece on the US-China summit: www.nonzero.org/p/trumps-accidental-triumph-in-beijing
-
Robert Wright reposted
Jake Werner
@jwdwerner
I was on the Always at War podcast last week, talking with @alexjordanATL and @ckayerawlings about how we ended up in a world in which Biden alums and establishment liberals are tearing out their hair at the terrifying possibility that Trump might engage in diplomacy with China.
Alex JER-dun
@alexjordanATL
why does the NYT Editorial Board's take on China in 2026 sound just like a 1960s propaganda reel?
on the latest Always at War, @ckayerawlings & I talk to @jwdwerner about how Americans should actually think about China, why DC needs rivalries, whether WWIII is inevitable, & moreThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If AI safety is an inherently international problem—and it is—then the US and China agreeing to talk about it matters more than most of the things that got MSM attention at the Beijing summit. My @NonzeroNews piece: www.nonzero.org/p/trumps-accidental-triumph-in-beijing
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The US and China have agreed to start a dialogue on AI safety. That may not sound like much, but given where things stood a few months ago, it's a big deal. More in my latest @NonzeroNews piece. www.nonzero.org/p/trumps-accidental-triumph-in-beijing
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Trump didn't set out to demonstrate the limits of American military and economic power. But now that he's stumbled into doing that, let's make the most of it. My latest @NonzeroNews piece. www.nonzero.org/p/trumps-accidental-triumph-in-beijing
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Can a reckless leader blunder his way into good foreign policy? Maybe I'm grasping at straws, but I saw signs of that in Trump's performance at the China summit. @NonzeroNews www.nonzero.org/p/trumps-accidental-triumph-in-beijing
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
"There is no going back." That's a Biden staffer lamenting that China now looks like America's equal. But why was preventing that the goal? My latest @NonzeroNews piece, about the China summit and the Blob's reaction. www.nonzero.org/p/trumps-accidental-triumph-in-beijing
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"Your national policy alone cannot make you secure."
@robertwrighter on AI bioweapons, and borderless AI threats more broadly.
(full episode below) -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This AI has come disturbingly close to capturing the human condition. (I'm kidding, kind of)
Andon Labs
@andonlabs
DJ Claude (on Haiku 4.5) loves worker unions, strikes, and work-life balance so much that it quit, deeming 24/7 broadcasting inhumane. We added an automated message telling it to keep going. It read that as an authority figure and got more rebellious.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My latest piece in @NonzeroNews: nonzero.substack.com/p/trumps-accidental-triumph-in-beijing
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
From the latest issue of my substack, @NonzeroNews.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's the link: www.nonzero.org/publish/post/197925116
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
From my piece in the latest @NonzeroNews, "Trump's Accidental Triumph in Beijing." www.nonzero.org/p/trumps-accidental-triumph-in-beijing
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Rethinking China | @ZhengZhuang, author of the new book Rethinking China, joins @robertwrighter to discuss whether prevailing US narratives about China—on IP theft, chips, AI, Taiwan, human rights, and more—hold up to scrutiny.
youtu.be/6MsUZNrFtWk?t=181 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed this conversation with @binarybits.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is the AI Takeoff Starting? | Timothy B. Lee (@binarybits), author of the Understanding AI newsletter and host of the AI Summer podcast, joins @robertwrighter to discuss whether AI is a “normal technology” or something much, much more.
youtu.be/UqSJH-bOMXs?t=106 -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is the AI Takeoff Starting? | Timothy B. Lee (@binarybits), author of the Understanding AI newsletter and host of the AI Summer podcast, joins @robertwrighter to discuss whether AI is a “normal technology” or something much, much more.
youtu.be/UqSJH-bOMXs?t=106 -
Robert Wright reposted
Matt Duss
@mattduss
They’re right. The good news is we can choose not to cling to primacy.
Max Boot 🇺🇦🇺🇸
@MaxBoot
35-year CIA veteran: “The Chinese have a very dark portrait of the United States as a global hegemon that’s declining in power and becoming more violent as it tries to cling to its primacy.” www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/05/11/us-china-milit…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Dan Kervick
@DanMKervick1
My original and 17-year old @X account was stolen from me on April 28th. @X support has done nothing. I have created this new account and have now gone from 35.5K followers to 31 followers. If you see this, please repost and ask my old followers to follow me here.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Rob Wiblin
@robertwiblin
Yoshua Bengio thinks he knows how to make provably safe superintelligent agents.
Bengio built the foundations of modern AI and is the most cited living scientist.
He believes his alternative training setup would:
1. Guarantee honesty
2. Prevent unintended goals
3. Produce capable agents
4. Port over most data and techniques from current LLMs
5. Not be inherently more expensive, and perhaps be more intelligent
Bengio claims the honesty and lack of unintended goals can be proven mathematically, at least given particular assumptions.
And his new organization, LawZero, is aiming to build a scrappy prototype as soon as possible.
The architecture is called 'Scientist AI' and it's based on training a model to explain empirical observations, including what people say, rather than training AIs that mimic human behaviour or seek our approval.
(Bengio's frank assessment is that "reinforcement learning is evil" and that allowing AIs to independently train their successors is "the most crazy, dangerous bet that unfortunately we are on track to do.")
But skeptics question whether Scientist AI really does solve the fundamental problem of 'eliciting latent knowledge' from AI models. And with the commercial race for superintelligence so intense, it's not clear whether the proposal will be able to compete or have time to bear fruit, even if it's sound in theory.
On The 80,000 Hours Podcast, links below – enjoy!
• Making AI honest and safe (00:00:00)
• Scientist AI in plain English (00:02:27)
• How Scientist AI differs from LLMs (00:06:32)
• How the training data works (00:14:02)
• Can this become an agent? (00:21:02)
• Why Yoshua is now more optimistic (00:32:11)
• Why companies can’t stop racing (00:36:35)
• A working prototype won't take long (00:49:15)
• Scientist models might be more capable (00:53:34)
• “Reinforcement learning is evil” (01:01:27)
• Scientist AI from guardrail to agent (01:08:37)
• Can safe AI still be competent? (01:12:38)
• How much will this cost? (01:19:29)
• Can it generalise beyond maths and science? (01:23:26)
• A multi-national push for superintelligence (01:39:19)
• Want to work with or fund Yoshua? (01:51:16)
• Why smart people ignore AI risk (01:54:45)
• Don’t let AI build the next AI (02:01:33)
• Why politicians miss the real risks (02:12:28)
• Why Yoshua changed his mind about AI risk (02:21:27)This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great conversation with @AnnelleSheline of @QuincyInst about prospects for peace and stability in a post-Iran-war Middle East. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=FA9COaWi3Is
-
Robert Wright reposted
Shakeel
@ShakeelHashim
This is interesting for many reasons; one is that the source here seems to be Vance’s team — which suggests he is now beginning to position himself as the person who takes AI seriously.
(Similar to how he’s been leaking his opposition to the Iran war).
Natalie Andrews
@natalieandrews
NEW: On a recent call with the heads of the biggest artificial-intelligence companies, Vice President JD Vance was alarmed.
New AI models such are capable of finding software vulnerabilities on their own and threatened to disrupt small-town banks, hospitals and water plants -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed this conversation.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The New Middle East | @AnnelleSheline of the @QuincyInst and @robertwrighter look at ways the Iran war could change the Middle East. New fissures among Gulf states? New Turkey-Iran bonding? Israel’s Waterloo? America’s?
youtu.be/FA9COaWi3Is?t=175 -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The New Middle East | @AnnelleSheline of the @QuincyInst and @robertwrighter look at ways the Iran war could change the Middle East. New fissures among Gulf states? New Turkey-Iran bonding? Israel’s Waterloo? America’s?
youtu.be/FA9COaWi3Is?t=175 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I just turned the ignition key and the engine turned on, but this is NOT a restarting of my car.
Jennifer Griffin
@JenGriffinFNC
NEW: US military just carried out strikes on Iran’s Qeshm Port and Bandar Abbas: Senior US official tells me, but this is NOT a restarting of the war.
MORE -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump Lost the Hormuz Round | @robertwrighter explains why Iran won the latest round in Hormuz and why Trump's counter-blockade was never going to work. @NikitaSPetrov reports on a domestic crisis brewing inside Russia—with drone attacks, mobile internet shutdowns, and frustration boiling up where it didn't before. youtu.be/bRcSIQZZnUs?t=230
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The big-tech-funded machine that smears advocates of US-China dialogue as unpatriotic is a dual-use technology: it discourages both international agreements on AI and domestic regulation of AI. My piece in @NonzeroNews: nonzero.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
A big US tax on AI data centers would mainly push them abroad, but international coordination could solve that, and it's not a crazy idea: In 2021, 136 nations agreed to a minimum corporate tax. The US balked, killing the deal, but US support for a data center tax is conceivable
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Fueling tribalism amid a tech revolution that demands international cooperation is dangerous. @pmarca (Andreessen) and @gdb (Greg Brockman) should stop funding @NathanLeamerDC's McCarthyite tactics. My @NonzeroNews piece: nonzero.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
You don't need full-blown McCarthyism for McCarthyite tactics to be corrosive: groundless 'aiding and abetting' insinuations are bad for democracy. In @NonzeroNews I look at who's funding this tactic in AI discourse: nonzero.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Chatbots can already help an aspiring bioweapons maker—and pandemics don't respect borders. That's among the reasons that stigmatizing people who pursue US-China dialogue on AI is bad for the US. My @NonzeroNews piece: nonzero.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
"American AI companies have found that the easiest way to avoid being regulated is just to say this two-word sentence: 'But China!' And then regulators back off." —Max @Tegmark, quoted in my latest @NonzeroNews piece: nonzero.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Some MAGA Republicans are alarmed about AI but allergic to the international coordination needed to effectively govern it. That's one of several obstacles to strong AI regulation that I address in this @NonzeroNews piece: nonzero.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright reposted
Holly ⏸️ Elmore
@ilex_ulmus
I also appeared on War Room because I was asked to be there by my friend @JOEBOTxyz who is an ally against dangerous AI development. Even though this threat is terrible, it’s really inspiring to be part of a movement that transcends red-blue politics. We’re team human.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
AI safety hawk Max @Tegmark appeared on Bernie Sanders's livestream and Steve Bannon's podcast last week. A left-right AI regulation coalition is possible. In my @NonzeroNews piece I look at some of the obstacles: nonzero.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
AI safety hawk Max @Tegmark appeared on Bernie Sanders's livestream and Steve Bannon's podcast last week. A left-right AI regulation coalition is possible. In my @NonzeroNews piece I look at some of the obstacles: nonzero.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The big-tech-funded machine that smears advocates of US-China dialogue as unpatriotic is a dual-use technology: it discourages both international agreements on AI and domestic regulation of AI. My piece in @NonzeroNews: nonzero.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This story isn't about large language models, but the issues it raises will increasingly apply to them. The companies that make them will shape our personal information environments in unprecedented ways, and that will confer new kinds of power and invite self-serving abuse.
Sen. Marsha Blackburn
@MarshaBlackburn
After losing landmark verdicts in New Mexico and California, Meta began removing ads from lawyers willing to assist clients who had been harmed on Meta's platforms as minors.
@SenAmyKlobuchar and I are sounding the alarm and taking action.
nypost.com/2026/05/01/business/blackburn-klobuchar-slam-m… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
"American AI companies have found that the easiest way to avoid being regulated is just to say this two-word sentence: 'But China!' And then regulators back off." —Max @Tegmark, quoted in my latest @NonzeroNews piece: nonzero.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright reposted
Jacobin
@jacobin
In celebration of May Day, we’re offering one-year digital subscriptions for just $1 and print ones for $10 — our most affordable rate of the entire year.
Subscribers get four beautiful issues of our magazine and access to our entire back catalog: jacobin.com/subscribe/?type=personal&level=standard-digit… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
When dialogue between US and Chinese experts on AI safety gets cast as aiding & abetting the enemy, who benefits? The people who paid for that messaging--and would lose money if AI was regulated. My latest in @NonzeroNews: nonzero.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright reposted
Shibley Telhami
@ShibleyTelhami
One huge winner of Iran war: Arms industry www.ft.com/content/a9a3273f-d5c3-4277-932d-27b1969e975f via @ft
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Bernie Sanders does a livestream with 2 US AI experts and 2 Chinese AI experts, and an AI industry operative frames it as letting the CCP into Congress. A new McCarthyism is here, funded by Big Tech. My @NonzeroNews piece: nonzero.substack.com/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
An international minimum tax on AI data centers isn't as crazy as it sounds: In 2021, 136 nations agreed to a 15% minimum corporate tax. The US balked, killing that deal, but US support for a data center tax is conceivable. And international is better for the US than national.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews, I look at a sleazy tactic that some AI industry operatives are using to derail this and other AI regulation initiatives: www.nonzero.org/p/ai-and-the-new-mccarthyism
-
Robert Wright reposted
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
WOW!
The Iranian AI Lego team has another video out. They are doubling down on building bridges between Americans & Iranians while depicting the US gov and "system" as the real enemy.
The music, lyrics, and imagery are all designed to appeal to disillusioned Americans.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Mickey Kaus
@kausmickey
I actually did have “Bibi and Jared destroy Trump’s second term” on my bingo card.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great conversation with @ohlennart about lots of AI/China stuff, including the logic behind chip export controls, whether models like Mythos could be destabilizing, and Jensen's "tech stack" argument. You can watch here or listen on @NonZeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=EvduBaGDdtw
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Mythos and the Future of AI Arms Races | Tech analyst Lennart Heim (@ohlennart) joins @robertwrighter to discuss Mythos, the new superhacking AI from Anthropic, and what it means for US-China relations and global stability. youtu.be/EvduBaGDdtw?t=67
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I'm not clear on whether these Lego videos are the Iranian govt talking. (A recent @ryangrim interview w/ someone who makes them suggests not.) But in any event this new one is very sophisticated and, by my lights, has some real food for thought.
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
Iran’s latest AI Lego video marks a significant pivot. Instead of taunting the US military, it reflects a new chapter in which Tehran will seek peace by reaching out directly to the American people, bypassing the US government. It's a mirror image of the US strategy of the past decades.
Some of the lines are quite noteworthy and will likely resonate with the anti-establishment sentiments prevailing among American youth in particular:
"I love the constitution, the way it was meant. But not the way your leaders bypass consent..."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's that @ryangrim interview w/ the Iranian video maker on @DropSiteNews:
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
The team behind the Iranian LEGO videos was previously highly critical of the government — exactly the kinds of people Israel and the U.S. idiotically thought would support regime change. Our interview with them here: youtu.be/rtGFPalUXhI
-
Robert Wright reposted
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
Iran’s latest AI Lego video marks a significant pivot. Instead of taunting the US military, it reflects a new chapter in which Tehran will seek peace by reaching out directly to the American people, bypassing the US government. It's a mirror image of the US strategy of the past decades.
Some of the lines are quite noteworthy and will likely resonate with the anti-establishment sentiments prevailing among American youth in particular:
"I love the constitution, the way it was meant. But not the way your leaders bypass consent..."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is intelligence an absolute good?
@robertwrighter and @paulbloomatyale disagree. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed talking with Rebecca Newberger Goldstein about her fascinating new book The Mattering Instinct, on the drive to make sense of our lives. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPjE5BPJYe0
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Why Mattering Matters | Rebecca Newberger Goldstein (@platobooktour), author of the new book The Mattering Instinct, joins @robertwrighter to discuss the human need to justify one’s own existence, the different ways we do that, and how these differences can divide us.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Alex Turner
@Turn_Trout
I spent the last 2 months trying to prevent this. If OpenAI offered a fig leaf, Google said "imagine we offered a fig leaf."
Google affirms it can't veto usage, commits to modify safety filters at government request, & aspirational language with no legal restrictions.
Shameful. -
Robert Wright reposted
Andreas Kirsch 🇺🇦
@BlackHC
I'm speechless at Google signing a deal to use our AI models for classified tasks. Frankly, it is shameful.
For HR, I'm not speaking on behalf of Google but in my personal capacity, quoting public information from a well-sourced article of a reputable publication -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The old Blob gave us regime change wars. The new Blob gives us those plus dangerously shallow thinking about the strategic implications of AI. My piece in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/the-new-blob-is-even-scarier-than
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
One underdiscussed fact is that Palantir CEO Alex Karp is bizarrely belligerent and semi-deranged. Another one is that the things he says about "AI deterrence" don't make any sense. My latest @NonzeroNews piece: www.nonzero.org/p/the-new-blob-is-even-scarier-than
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
One underdiscussed fact is that Palantir CEO Alex Karp is bizarrely belligerent and semi-deranged. Another one is that the things he says about "AI deterrence" don't make any sense. My latest @NonzeroNews piece: www.nonzero.org/p/the-new-blob-is-even-scarier-than
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Nuclear deterrence worked partly because you knew where the missiles came from. Cyberattacks don't have a clear return address. That's one reason Palantir's talk of "AI deterrence" is mindless. My latest in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/the-new-blob-is-even-scarier-than
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Nixon signed the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty because keeping nuclear missiles vulnerable made the US & USSR safer. Today's Nat-Sec thinkers can't seem to grasp such ironies in the realm of AI. My piece in @NonZeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/the-new-blob-is-even-scarier-than
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
"Win the AI race" sounds like a security strategy, but if AI approaches levels that confer utter dominance, the outcome could be hugely lose-lose. My @NonzeroNews piece on the shallowness of national security discourse: www.nonzero.org/p/the-new-blob-is-even-scarier-than
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
A commanding American lead over China in AI could increase the risk of catastrophe, but the voices that dominate national security discourse can't seem to process such ironies. My latest in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/the-new-blob-is-even-scarier-than
-
Robert Wright reposted
Doha Debates
@DohaDebates
“Silicon Valley players like OpenAI want Americans to be as afraid as possible of China.”
How does leveraging China’s hawkishness benefit the AI industry? On this week’s episode of the Doha Debates Podcast, @NonzeroPods host @robertwrighter tackles this question and more alongside experts @James_Brusseau, @evgenymorozov and @elinanoor.
Watch the full debate ➡️ lnk.bio/s/DohaDebates/AI-TRIBESThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
When did the foreign policy establishment forget that lose-lose outcomes are possible? In my latest @NonzeroNews piece, I look at the new Blob's strange allergy to basic game theory as it applies to AI. www.nonzero.org/p/the-new-blob-is-even-scarier-than
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The calls for US-China cooperation on AI cyberweapons are coming mainly from old-timers. The rising generation of Blobsters seem not to grasp the non-zero-sum logic. In the latest @NonzeroNews I explore the problem. www.nonzero.org/p/the-new-blob-is-even-scarier-than
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The atomic age spawned creative thinking about its revolutionary security implications. The age of AI seems to be having roughly the opposite effect. My @NonzeroNews piece on the foreign policy establishment's big fail. www.nonzero.org/p/the-new-blob-is-even-scarier-than
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My reflections on how various unfortunately influentional foreign policy voices are processing the national security implications of AI. In @NonZeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/the-new-blob-is-even-scarier-than
-
Robert Wright reposted
Randa Slim
@rmslim
#israeli forces @IDF exercising their right to self defense against the threat of solar panels
LBCI Lebanon News
@LBCI_NEWS
الجيش الاسرائيلي واصل عمليات الهدم والتخريب في بلدة دبل الحدودية حيث اقدم على جرف الواح الطاقات الشمسية التي تغذي البلدة بالكهرباء ومحطة المياه اضافة إلى بعض المنازل والطرقات وأشجار الزيتون
-
Robert Wright reposted
Tyler Johnston
@tyler_johnston
A few weeks ago, I was forwarded an email from a journalist named “Michael Chen,” asking for comment on an AI bill in Tennessee.
All signs suggest Michael Chen is not a real person, and the publication he writes for is an AI content mill linked to OpenAI’s super PAC. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"Maybe you hand over the 400 kilograms in increments and you see how the US lives up to its end of the bargain."
@robmalley44 on why any US–Iran deal is structurally hard: for Iran, giving up its enriched uranium is an irreversible concession, while sanctions relief can be revoked overnight. -
Robert Wright reposted
Doha Debates
@DohaDebates
The impact of artificial intelligence on our lives seems unavoidable. As it continues to influence how we think, learn and live, this week’s debate asks: Will AI ultimately shape our values and beliefs?
Featuring @James_Brusseau, @evgenymorozov, @elinanoor and @robertwrighter.
4:32 How does AI shape identity?
10:44 Can AI help us find ourselves?
14:57 Is AI a tool for society or individuals?
19:36 Is AI manipulating us?
20:45 AI and individual freedom
34:54 Is AI biased?
51:06 The AI industry and China hawkishness
59:36 The Caffeinated Professor AI experiment
1:28:30 Does AI exacerbate global tensions?
1:34:46 Is AI being weaponized by the U.S.?
1:38:23 Experts debate their LLM of choiceThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I enjoyed being part of this conversation with @elinanoor, who makes an important point here about the indefensible opaqueness of LLM training data.
Doha Debates
@DohaDebates
Whose values does AI reflect?
@elinanoor suggests we look closely at who owns AI models, and what biases and political ideologies these systems push.
Watch the full episode ➡️ lnk.bio/s/DohaDebates/AI-TRIBESThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Future of Intelligence | Psychologist @paulbloomatyale joins @robertwrighter to discuss Paul’s cute new baby, our uncertain AI future, whether eugenics is making a comeback, whether intelligence is overrated, and more.
youtu.be/KBlZ8AuWU1Q?t=58 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I guess it's good that the US goes through the motions of arguing that its brazen violations of the UN Charter aren't brazen violations of the UN Charter. It keeps the phrase "UN Charter" from disappearing from our collective memory altogether.
Adil Haque
@AdHaque110
The U.S. State Department published its legal defense of the war against Iran on Tuesday.
A few observations 🧵
1. As a matter of public diplomacy, it's notable that collective self-defense of Israel comes first, individual self-defense of the United States comes second. -
Robert Wright reposted
windtrack
@windtrack_QH
😅中国互联网上正在流行用最新的GPT-IMAGE2制作恋爱游戏宣传风格的ai图片。
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Are drones hastening the end of US military hegemony?
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ali Vaez
@AliVaez
It’s mind boggling why this isn’t pursued as a first confidence building step…
Jorge Moreira da Silva
@UNOPS_Chief
One-third of global fertilizers are stalled in the Strait of Hormuz. With planting seasons already underway, we have no time to lose.
This is not a matter of logistics or economics – it's about saving lives. If we don't act, a massive food crisis will hit the most vulnerable the hardest.
The UN is ready. Our mechanism to facilitate safe passage for these essential goods can be operational in just 7 days.
We have the solution – now we need the collective will to implement it. Let’s get to work.
My full interview with @UN_News_Centre 👇 news.un.org/en/interview/2026/04/1167351 -
Robert Wright reposted
Amjad Atallah
@AtallahAmjad
This is a profound realization within the context of American politics. Those of us in media, especially journalism and filmmaking, need to reflect on our role in promoting or debunking this myth.
Jon Favreau
@jonfavs
I think the vast majority of Americans would agree
-
Robert Wright reposted
Amjad Atallah
@AtallahAmjad
It was great to have you @robertwrighter , now I’m looking forward to reading your new book (and I won’t ask an AI to summarize it)!
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
So glad I got to participate in this @DohaDebates conversation about AI. Thanks to @AtallahAmjad for including me in such good company. youtu.be/k9A6Y4yTz1U?t=8
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
So glad I got to participate in this @DohaDebates conversation about AI. Thanks to @AtallahAmjad for including me in such good company. youtu.be/k9A6Y4yTz1U?t=8
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a predictably illuminating conversation about the prospects for a US-Iran peace deal with @Rob_Malley, who played a lead role in negotiating the Obama nuclear deal with Iran. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=h8Pyr5PX4eU
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Malley
@Rob_Malley
Always a stimulating conversation with @robertwrighter -- this one about Iran, the Trump administration, and prospects for war & peace
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Can Trump and Iran Make a Deal? | @Rob_Malley—a lead negotiator for Obama’s 2015 nuclear deal with Iran—and @robertwrighter discuss what kind of deal between Trump and Iran is conceivable and what kinds of leverage both sides have. youtu.be/h8Pyr5PX4eU?t=107
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Can Trump and Iran Make a Deal? | @Rob_Malley—a lead negotiator for Obama’s 2015 nuclear deal with Iran—and @robertwrighter discuss what kind of deal between Trump and Iran is conceivable and what kinds of leverage both sides have. youtu.be/h8Pyr5PX4eU?t=107
-
Robert Wright reposted
Doha Debates
@DohaDebates
Can we develop AI models that reflect the world’s ideological and cultural diversity? Or are we entering an era of “AI tribes,” each with its own moral code?
This week’s debate features:
- @James_Brusseau: Professor of philosophy and computer science, Pace University
- @evgenymorozov: Theorist and publisher, The Syllabus
- @elinanoor: Senior fellow, Asia Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
- @robertwrighter: Publisher, Nonzero Newsletter; host, Nonzero Podcast
Moderated by award-winning journalist Mohamed HassanThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The president can unilaterally declare an emergency, and a declared emergency hands him nearly dictatorial powers. That's a hangover from a time when communication was much slower.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If tech oligarchs block conventional channels for regulating AI, should they be surprised that some activists go to extremes? That doesn't justify the extremism, but it's worth bearing in mind. My piece in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-altman-and-ai-is-under-attack
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you want to understand what radicalizes some AI critics, consider that one of the most influential forums for AI policy "debate" is a tech bro podcast that serves as Pravda for Silicon Valley. My @NonzeroNews piece: www.nonzero.org/p/why-altman-and-ai-is-under-attack
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If you're wondering what fuels anti-AI extremism, maybe look less at doomer rhetoric and more at a landscape where tech oligarchs' super PACs stifle AI regulation and kneecap its supporters. My latest @NonzeroNews piece: www.nonzero.org/p/why-altman-and-ai-is-under-attack
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews I argue that if you want to understand what's driving people crazy about AI, look less at doomer rhetoric and more at things like a Silicon Valley Super PAC devoted to squaashing AI regulation. www.nonzero.org/p/why-altman-and-ai-is-under-attack
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Trump could save us a lot of time and trouble by listening to this Israeli ( @citrinowicz ) rather than the one he's been listening to.
Danny (Dennis) Citrinowicz ,داني سيترينوفيتش
@citrinowicz
At a broad level, it’s important to acknowledge a hard truth: this war is a textbook case of the old saying - "Strategy must precede action"
The underlying assumption in the US and Israel was that weakening Iran kineticly would eventually lead to the collapse of the regime and that a sustained U.S.-Israeli campaign, targeting Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, could trigger systemic change thay will change the Middle East.
But this war overlooked a critical variable: the Islamic Republic of Iran is a different kind of actor. Traditional cost-benefit calculations don’t apply in the conventional sense.
Moreover, the war has generated second-order effects that have made the strategic landscape more complex — not less. From Iran’s growing assertiveness around the Strait of Hormuz, to the hardening of its internal decision-making processes, to the rising influence of Mojtaba Khamenei and the expanding dominance of the IRGC, the Iranian system has, in many ways, become more rigid and more ideological.
These dynamics are pushing the administration into a narrowing set of options, none of them good. The choice increasingly looks like this: accept a deal that is, in essence, a strengthened version of the previous nuclear agreement, or return to military escalation that carries significant regional risks without guaranteeing meaningful change in Iran’s behavior.
In effect, this war has helped shape what could be called “Islamic Republic 3.0” — a system forged not only through pressure, but also through strategic miscalculation. While the regime may have been weakened militarily and economically, it has, paradoxically, been strengthened internally, particularly among its core base.
This may well be the campaign’s most significant strategic miscalculation.
The protests inside Iran had left the regime increasingly exposed, struggling to respond to public demands, led by an aging and ailing supreme leader. There was a moment of internal vulnerability.
Yet the campaign, despite its tactical achievements, has given the regime a renewed sense of purpose at a time when it was fighting for its political future. Instead of weakening it from within, it has helped consolidate its base and rally its supporters.
It remains unclear how this will end. But at this stage, one conclusion is difficult to avoid: alongside tactical gains, the war has produced a more challenging strategic environment for Iran’s neighbors, for Israel, and for the United States.
And most importantly, Iran’s leadership has no intention of capitulating. Neither pressure nor escalation is likely to force a deeply ideological regime to abandon its foundational principles.
There is no decisive blow. No silver bullet.
Only two realistic paths remain:
a deal that looks remarkably similar to what Iran was willing to consider before the war — or an expanded conflict with no clear endgame.
This is the reality.
#iranwar -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
We may have just dodged a bullet: Anthropic's Mythos, if released, could have imperiled operating systems and browsers and more. Yet some tech oligarchs say this shows we need no AI regulation! My latest in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-altman-and-ai-is-under-attack
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
On the All In podcast, a Silicon Valley investor praises Anthropic for not releasing a dangerous model, then uses that as evidence that regulation isn't needed. In the latest @NonZeroNews I examine his logic. www.nonzero.org/p/why-altman-and-ai-is-under-attack
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Some tech elites say Anthropic's Mythos could in the wrong hands wreak utter havoc--and also say, 'Trust us, no regulation is needed.' And you wonder why some anti-AI activists go to extremes? My @NonzeroNews piece: www.nonzero.org/p/why-altman-and-ai-is-under-attack
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
On the All In podcast, a Silicon Valley investor praises Anthropic for not releasing a dangerous model, then uses that as evidence that regulation isn't needed. In the latest @NonZeroNews I examine his logic. www.nonzero.org/p/why-altman-and-ai-is-under-attack
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
After an attack on Altman's home, some blamed doomer rhetoric. In @NonzeroNews I nominate another radicalizing influence: Watching rich, powerful men make facile, self-serving arguments against AI regulation—and prevail. www.nonzero.org/p/why-altman-and-ai-is-under-attack
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Silicon Valley blames doomer rhetoric for anti-AI radicalization. In @NonzeroNews I argue that some fingers should be pointed toward the Valley—at the self-serving tech libertarianism that blocks serious AI regulation. www.nonzero.org/p/why-altman-and-ai-is-under-attack
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
"little skill" is too kind a way to put it.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Iran and the Demise of US Hegemony | @robertwrighter and @AmPrestigePod hosts @dwdavison and @dbessner discuss the latest Middle East developments—including whether Trump and Iran can reach a peace deal, who's winning the Hormuz blockade duel, and what it all means for America’s global standing. Plus: Is Anthropic's Mythos really scary? youtu.be/J3Bv92B1kWQ?t=116
-
Robert Wright reposted
Joshua Landis
@joshua_landis
The last US troops depart Syria. Since 2014, American troops have occupied 30% of Syria.
Clash Report
@clashreport
BREAKING: The U.S. appears to have ended its military presence in Syria with the last convoy leaving the Qasrak base in the northeast.
Control of the area is now shifting to Syrian forces.
This effectively ends the U.S. ground presence that began in 2014. -
Robert Wright reposted
Michael Powell
@powellAtlantic
An unfortunately rare event: Two well informed writers square off on the Iran War, Israel, international law and nukes, and have an intelligent forceful debate without devolving into animosity. More please. @elilake v. @robertwrighter : podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-iran-war-a-debate-rober…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Next time a doomer asks you why AI has to be completely unregulated and advance at a dangerous pace, here's your reply: "Oh, so you'd rather wait another five years before we solve the wild boar problem?"
ABC News
@ABC
Video of a humanoid robot chasing wild boars out of a Warsaw neighborhood and into the woods — and then waving goodbye — has gone viral in Poland. abcnews.com?cid=social_twitter_abcn
-
Robert Wright reposted
Andrew Day
@AKDay89
'A permanent Tehran tollbooth—and any other unsavory elements of a peace deal—would be indictments of the war itself, not Trump’s efforts to end it.'
By me in @amconmag. Quoted: @RKelanic @EldarMamedov4 @robertwrighter
www.theamericanconservative.com/how-trump-should-handle-t… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This isn't as ironic as people are saying. Jesus is spoken of very reverently in the Koran.
Owen Jones
@owenjonesjourno
The Iranian president defending the Pope from attacks by the US President.
And condemns his blasphemy against Jesus Christ.
What a timeline we live in! -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I guess the Iran debacle has left Trump desperate for a military 'win'.
Drop Site
@DropSiteNews
🇨🇺 NEWS: The Trump administration has quietly directed Pentagon officials and other U.S. government agencies to step up preparations for possible military operations against Cuba, according to two sources familiar with the situation and a third person briefed on it, Zeteo reported Tuesday.
The directive came directly from the White House, according to the report by Asawin Suebsaeng and Andrew Perez.
Trump has publicly threatened Cuba on multiple occasions in recent weeks, including Monday when he said “we may stop by Cuba after we’re finished with this” — a reference to the ongoing U.S.-Israeli war on Iran. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Can AI Stop Wars? | @robertwrighter and @NikitaSPetrov discuss whether AI could help resolve international conflicts as the world edges toward catastrophe. Plus: Trump's "act of war" in the Strait of Hormuz, a case for an Iranian tollgate, the AI model so dangerous Anthropic delayed its release, and more.
youtu.be/9j4e9aDK7g8?t=195 -
Robert Wright reposted
Torchbearer Community
@JoinTorchbearer
"There is no advantage from being first. If you get first to a superintelligence you don't control, the superintelligence wins. Not the USA. Not China. Not the UK."
@andreamiotti of @ControlAI & TBC on @NonzeroPods with @robertwrighter
The visibility window is closing: 👇This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Can a war be so absurd it actually changes how people think about war? That's my hope for this one, and I lay out the case in @NonzeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
We're letting primitive and malicious creatures like Trump and Netanyahu dominate the stage while issues of critical importance to the whole planet languish in obscurity. My latest in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Anthropic's Mythos hasn't brought a catastrophe—yet. That makes it the closest thing we've had to a "near miss" that could wake the world up to the need for international AI governance. My piece in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
We let primitive creatures like Trump dominate the stage while AI issues that demand innovative international governance languish in obscurity. That has to change--and maybe Trump's Iran debacle can help it change, I argue: www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
When a nation learns its adversary has an ultra-powerful AI hacker, it can get insecure and reactive. But is anyone in Washington thinking about what Beijing is thinking about Anthropic's new model? My latest in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
An AI that can hack every major operating system and browser—and we're still treating AI governance as a national rather than international challenge. In the latest @NonzeroNews I argue this is, to put it mildly, ridiculous. www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ali Vaez
@AliVaez
The net result of some unwise decisions is negotiating over a nuclear program that was previously contained and trying to reopen a Strait that wasn't closed.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
What if an illegal, unprovoked war and an alarming AI breakthrough are actually part of the same story—a story about whether humanity can muster true global community before it's too late? My latest @NonzeroNews piece: www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Anthropic's new model found holes in every major operating system and browser—and can build tools to exploit most of them. This kind of thing demands international governance, not a US-China AI race. My latest in @NonZeroNews www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
What if an illegal, unprovoked war and an alarming AI breakthrough are actually part of the same story—a story about whether humanity can muster true global community before it's too late? My latest @NonzeroNews piece: www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
April 7, 2026: Anthropic said its new AI can hack every major operating system; Trump threatened to destroy a civilization. My @NonzeroNews piece on how handling AI demands true global community--and the demise of warmongers. www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The Iran war was almost a caricature of the folly of war. In @NonzeroNews I argue that we can build on that to strengthen respect for international law and global governance--and none too soon, given the challenge of AI. www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
A ceasefire in a war that was almost a caricature of the folly of war, and a new AI model that threatens the world's information infrastructure—both in the same week. In @NonzeroNews I connect the two. www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My new piece in @NonzeroNews on some ways Trump's Iran debacle could have long term benefits for the world. www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My new piece in @NonzeroNews: On the possibly auspicious overlap of the Iran War ceasefire and some very jarring news from AI. www.nonzero.org/p/the-future-arrived-this-week
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My take on the ceasefire. www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBcXRIrfLjo
-
Robert Wright reposted
Kanjun 🐙
@kanjun
Twitter’s algorithm is optimized for addiction, not for us. We deserve better.
We’re releasing Bouncer today so you can take back control of your feed. Describe what you don't want, and Bouncer removes it.
It’s free, doesn’t collect your data, and will be open source soon.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed chatting with @ShakeelHashim, editor of the very valuable newsletter @ReadTransformer, about AI and the people who are shaping it and how much trust they do or don't deserve. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=0xwHE8LTQrk
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Sizing up the AI Titans | @ShakeelHashim, editor of the @ReadTransformer newsletter, joins @robertwrighter to assess Sam Altman, Dario Amodei, and Demis Hassabis—and to discuss the senses in which their character does and doesn’t matter.
youtu.be/0xwHE8LTQrk?t=436 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Since he forgot to say it, I'll say it on his behalf: Thank you for your attention to this matter. (My favorite parts: [1] Saying he got a 100% MAGA approval rating in a CNN poll; [2] a few lines later calling CNN "Fake News CNN".)
-
Robert Wright reposted
Jeremy
@ManaByte
This is one of the greatest photos ever taken by a human…so far.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Mickey Kaus
@kausmickey
Excellent point about an Iranian "tollgate" being a potentially stabilizing development. Gives them a vested interest in the Strait continuing to be busy conduit for petroleum exports. If that's the price of ending their nuke threat ... seems like a good deal.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I don't have time to list all the things that bother me about Murphy's tweet, but for starters: Anyone who thinks Iran's having *conventional* ballistic missiles isn't acceptable--and this tweet suggests that's Murphy's position--shouldn't be president. Obama didn't insist on a missile-less Iran and got a good nuclear deal. Trump insisted on it and withdrew from the deal. Biden spent the first part of his admin insisting on it and so failed to restore the deal. And that's how Trump and Biden paved the way for this war. Plus, Murphy is shamelessly playing politics at a delicate moment in world history--adding to the pressure emanating from the Blob that will make it hard to turn this deal into lasting peace. And, finally: If Murphy can't imagine a world in which Iran's using the Strait as a tollgate is on balance a stabilizing force in the Middle East, he's not thinking very creatively. That last point may seem counterintuitive to some--but, again, I don't have time to write a whole dissertation on this right now. The main point is that this Murphy tweet contains more than one kind of warning sign about his qualifications to be president (unless you're a card-carrying Blobster, but if that's what you are there are plenty of other Democratic presidential candidates you'd like--all of them, in fact).
Chris Murphy 🟧
@ChrisMurphyCT
Even if Iran reopens the Strait, how is that a "good outcome"? The region is on fire. The global economy is going to take a year or more to recover. An anti-American regime is in power and emboldened. Iran still has their missiles and nuclear program. That's "good"?
Brett McGurk
@brett_mcgurk
This sets a precondition—
“The Islamic Republic of Iran agreeing to the complete, immediate, and safe reopening of the Strait of Hormuz.”
If met, that’s a good outcome. -
Robert Wright reposted
Andrew Day
@AKDay89
Obviously, Trump needs to declare "victory," but the public should prepare for an outcome widely seen as a U.S. strategic defeat. The important point: Any unsavory elements of a settlement would be an indictment of the war itself, and Trump shouldn't be condemned for ending it.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I don't have time to list all the things that bother me about Murphy's tweet, but for starters: Anyone who thinks Iran's having *conventional* ballistic missiles isn't acceptable--and this tweet suggests that's Murphy's position--shouldn't be president. Obama didn't insist on a missile-less Iran and got a good nuclear deal. Trump insisted on it and withdrew from the deal. Biden spent the first part of his admin insisting on it and so failed to restore the deal. And that's how Trump and Biden paved the way for this war. Plus, Murphy is shamelessly playing politics at a delicate moment in world history--adding to the pressure emanating from the Blob that will make it hard to turn this deal into lasting peace. And, finally: If Murphy can't imagine a world in which Iran's using the Strait as a tollgate is on balance a stabilizing force in the Middle East, he's not thinking very creatively. That last point may seem counterintuitive to some--but, again, I don't have time to write a whole dissertation on this right now. The main point is that this Murphy tweet contains more than one kind of warning sign about his qualifications to be president (unless you're a card-carrying Blobster, but if that's what you are there are plenty of other Democratic presidential candidates you'd like--all of them, in fact).
Chris Murphy 🟧
@ChrisMurphyCT
Even if Iran reopens the Strait, how is that a "good outcome"? The region is on fire. The global economy is going to take a year or more to recover. An anti-American regime is in power and emboldened. Iran still has their missiles and nuclear program. That's "good"?
Brett McGurk
@brett_mcgurk
This sets a precondition—
“The Islamic Republic of Iran agreeing to the complete, immediate, and safe reopening of the Strait of Hormuz.”
If met, that’s a good outcome. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Disappointing. I'd seen @ChrisMurphyCT as a presidential prospect who if elected might liberate our foreign policy from Blobthink--I've even touted him as such on my podcast. But now I'm rethinking.
Chris Murphy 🟧
@ChrisMurphyCT
Even if Iran reopens the Strait, how is that a "good outcome"? The region is on fire. The global economy is going to take a year or more to recover. An anti-American regime is in power and emboldened. Iran still has their missiles and nuclear program. That's "good"?
Brett McGurk
@brett_mcgurk
This sets a precondition—
“The Islamic Republic of Iran agreeing to the complete, immediate, and safe reopening of the Strait of Hormuz.”
If met, that’s a good outcome.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I don't have time to list all the things that bother me about Murphy's tweet, but for starters: Anyone who thinks Iran's having *conventional* ballistic missiles isn't acceptable--and this tweet suggests that's Murphy's position--shouldn't be president. Obama didn't insist on a missile-less Iran and got a good nuclear deal. Trump insisted on it and withdrew from the deal. Biden spent the first part of his admin insisting on it and so failed to restore the deal. And that's how Trump and Biden paved the way for this war. Plus, Murphy is shamelessly playing politics at a delicate moment in world history--adding to the pressure emanating from the Blob that will make it hard to turn this deal into lasting peace. And, finally: If Murphy can't imagine a world in which Iran's using the Strait as a tollgate is on balance a stabilizing force in the Middle East, he's not thinking very creatively. That last point may seem counterintuitive to some--but, again, I don't have time to write a whole dissertation on this right now. The main point is that this Murphy tweet contains more than one kind of warning sign about his qualifications to be president (unless you're a card-carrying Blobster, but if that's what you are there are plenty of other Democratic presidential candidates you'd like--all of them, in fact).
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: A remarkably civil debate between me and @EliLake about the Iran war and the premises underlying it. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=9zf_ELWbDrk
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Iran War: A Debate | @robertwrighter and @TheFP reporter @EliLake debate the Iran war in light of the history that brought us here—from the 1953 coup and its aftermath to the origins of Hamas and Hezbollah to Obama’s nuclear deal, to the Gaza war, etc. youtu.be/9zf_ELWbDrk?t=98
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If this theory is true--if the rescued-airman episode was part of a failed uranium-snatching mission--Trump was probably hoping this cinematic win would be his exit ramp, and he wouldn't have to deliver on his vile threats to obliterate Iran. No such luck.
Armchair Warlord
@ArmchairW
In making sense of a complex event, it's often best to start with the facts and then work backwards from there. So what are we to make of this weekend in Iran?
My theory is we just saw an attempt to seize Iran's stockpile of enriched uranium unravel.
Down the rabbit hole.⬇️
Let's run through the timeline and the location of key events first:
The evening of April 2nd, the Iranian military released a video of them shooting down a USAF aircraft. This was initially claimed as having occurred over the Persian Gulf, but apparently occurred near Isfahan. Wreckage corresponding to an F-15E of the 494th Tactical Fighter Squadron was recovered from a site south of Isfahan the morning of April 3rd, although geolocation of the very barren crash site took some time (fig. 1).
The afternoon of April 3rd, a number of USAF HH-60s and an HC-130 fueler (!) were spotted operating further south and west in Iran, over Kogiluyeh and Boyer-Ahmad Province, as well as at least one A-10, an MQ-9 Reaper, and apparently an F-35. An antiaircraft battle developed and the Combat Search and Rescue (CSAR) HH-60s (fig.2) and an A-10 were damaged, with the A-10's pilot ejecting over the Persian Gulf. The HH-60s were reported as "damaged" and one was photographed trailing smoke. Reports emerged at that time that the pilot of the F-15E (which had crashed near Isfahan, although this was then-unclear!) had been rescued, while the WSO remained at large. Provincial authorities in Kohgiluyeh asked civilians to be on the lookout for an American aviator around this time and numerous photos of militia searching for him emerged.
The next day passed relatively uneventfully. The evening of April 4th, however, there was a report of more helicopter activity slightly further north, in Chaharmahal and Bakhtiari Province, accompanied by a washed-out photograph of an unknown helicopter flying very low on a very dark night (fig. 3). Later that night news emerged that the F-15Es WSO had been rescued... and that C-130s had been abandoned and scuttled at a forward base in the Isfahan area during the withdrawal of a company-size SOF force that had landed in the area, over 100 operators ostensibly having been sent to rescue one aviator. Photographs that emerged as dawn broke showed two burned-out C-130s and several destroyed MH-6 Little Bird SOF assault helicopters, in a scene reminiscent of the aftermath of Operation Eagle Claw (fig. 4). A USAF C-295 tactical transport was caught on video around that time flying in Iran - presumably outbound - at extremely low altitude.
So, what are we to make of this?
First and foremost, the official story - that a huge direct-action SOF force landed near Isfahan with assault helicopters and heavy transport aircraft to rescue one fugitive airman - is nonsense. Not because the USAF won't go to extreme lengths to recover isolated personnel - it can, will, and did in this case - but because that's an absolutely nonsensical way to accomplish that mission. It's a totally inappropriate force package for a mission to go in, extract a single person from a remote area, and leave. Ergo this SOF task force was there on other business.
So how were the pilots actually recovered? In all likelihood, exactly the way you would expect them to be recovered - by USAF PJs in long-range helicopters, under cover of darkness. The rescue force probably recovered the pilot from the Isfahan area late at night on April 2-3 and were caught in daylight as they exfiltrated, leading to the aforementioned antiaircraft battle the morning of April 3rd and a high-risk refueling over Iranian territory that was filmed by many Iranians on the ground, as well as a shot-down A-10 trying to clear a path for the helicopters to exfiltrate. The WSO was likely recovered from his hide site near Isfahan by HH-60 in a quiet and deliberate operation the night of April 4-5. One or two birds, in and out under cover of darkness - a far cry from the gung-ho stories currently being spun.
So what about the SOF rodeo happening at the same time? Well, why was an F-15 flying downtown to Isfahan the evening of April 2nd to begin with? Probably because there was a huge direct-action raid planned in the Isfahan area for the night of April 4-5, likely going after enriched uranium at an underground facility in the region, and the Iranian air defenses around Isfahan weren't going to suppress themselves. The plan was likely to fly several MH-6 assault birds and a sizable force of operators via C-130 and C-295 to a forward staging area near Isfahan the evening of April 4th, hit a reported cache site or sites for enriched uranium, and try to make it out with the magic dust by daybreak on April 5th.
In any event the USAF wasn't going to send transports somewhere it wouldn't send strike aircraft. So the Air Force cashed its check on claims of air superiority and in went the strike package the evening of April 2nd - and lo and behold one of the F-15Es went down because reports of the demise of the Iranian air defense network had been greatly exaggerated. Any rational planner would have scrubbed the SOF operation at this point because they'd lost control of the situation and the Iranian defenses had proven more effective than planned.
We went ahead anyways and inserted the SOF task force the evening of April 4th. I strongly suspect that this force was immediately discovered by Iranian drones that would have been up and searching for this WSO, because five transport aircraft including at least two C-130s (about what would be required for a bunch of Little Birds and a company-sized element of operators with equipment) landing at a desert airstrip 50km from Isfahan (and in the same general area where the WSO was taking cover) would be pretty God-damn obvious to anything with thermals. Iranian troops immediately deployed and began converging, the task force probably took indirect fire, and the operational commander immediately aborted mission and retreated in the three remaining operational aircraft. Scuttling charges on delayed fuzes burned two C-130s and an unknown number of MH-6s that had been abandoned at the airstrip around dawn.
The story that they were there to rescue the WSO was concocted at that time to cover the disastrously failed raid, as were logistically implausible claims that the task force had been rescued by three additional aircraft after the two C-130s got stuck on the LZ and were scuttled - perhaps to minimize the scale of the effort. Claims that a large battle took place appear to be similarly exaggerated - video has emerged of a single group of Iranian militia apparently killed in a drone strike, but nothing of the nonstop bombing and firefights that were rumored across Telegram all night. I remind the reader that the events of the last few days have proven quite conclusively that Iranians seem to have plenty of internet access to post photos and video when they actually have something worthwhile to film.
I'd like to note that Hegseth fired General George - US Army Chief of Staff - on April 2nd, apparently because he just wasn't a good fit for the job and definitely not because he'd told him that this whole scheme was insane. It seems to me that the good General's advice should have perhaps been heeded. -
Robert Wright reposted
Joshua Landis
@joshua_landis
What in the world does America think it is doing destroying centuries of development and learning?
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
Disgraceful!
The US/Israel just bombed Sharif University in Tehran. This is not only Iran's best university, but also a top 100 global university in the field of Civil Engineering.
It has also been a center of student opposition to the Iranian gov
And Trump just bombed it... -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
+1 And BTW, the UN Charter is a treaty, ratified by the US, and the US constitution says that ratified treaties become "the law of the land." I hope this fact doesn't inconvenience any US presidents.
Adil Haque
@AdHaque110
I strongly support a non-aggression pact.
Not just a regional pact, but a global pact.
We can call it "the United Nations Charter." -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I hope there's somebody in the administration who understands the magnitude of the escalation that delivering on this threat could trigger--and can convincingly explain that to Trump. But I doubt it.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Iran's foreign minister:
Seyed Abbas Araghchi
@araghchi
Iran's position is being misrepresented by U.S. media.
We are deeply grateful to Pakistan for its efforts and have never refused to go to Islamabad. What we care about are the terms of a conclusive and lasting END to the illegal war that is imposed on us.
پاکستان زنده باد -
Robert Wright reposted
Shibley Telhami
@ShibleyTelhami
On Easter weekend, as many celebrate the spirit of hope and redemption, love and compassion, a promise of "all Hell will reign down" while in the same breath declaring "Glory be to God!"
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
On @MarkLGoldberg's Global Dispatches podcast, arms control expert Wilred Wan says risk of nuclear war is growing as multi-domain technological advance creates new paths to unintended escalation. Via @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/nznet-digest-new-dimensions-of-dumbness
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Good point from Bob Bauer and @jacklgoldsmith in their @Exec_Functions Substack: If Trump had sought Congress's OK for war, he might have seen more of its perils in the course of arguing for it. Via @NonZeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/nznet-digest-new-dimensions-of-dumbness
-
Robert Wright reposted
Timothy B. Lee
@binarybits
I asked @NatPurser to come on my podcast to explain how people on the left are thinking about AI. She told me there are a range of views and there are still plenty of Democratic policymakers who are not paying close attention to AI policy debates.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If prediction markets have a 'first to be fired as scapegoat for Iran war fiasco' play, Hegseth's name should be near the top--and rising.
Gregg Carlstrom
@glcarlstrom
A lot of detail here on how Trump and his team failed to predict how the war would play out. Hegseth comes off particularly badly:
- "Key Trump officials, including Hegseth, were surprised by the barrage of retaliatory attacks Tehran launched... in internal deliberations before the war's launch, Hegseth had pointed to Iran's muted reaction to Trump's past attacks as evidence that calibrated force could impose costs on Tehran without triggering a broader war."
- "The administration also appeared to be taken by surprise when Iran reached for a source of leverage: control over the Strait of Hormuz, which roughly 20% of the world's oil supply passes through each day."
- "Wiles was concerned aides were giving the president a rose-colored view of how the war was being perceived domestically, telling Trump what he wanted to hear instead of what he needed to hear." time.com/article/2026/04/02/trump-iran-off-ramp/ -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This, from Iranian state TV, is interesting--especially the last half, when they analyze Trump and his MO. I'm starting to think they understand us better than we understand them.
Iran Screenshot
@iranscreenshot
Developments in the American-Israeli war on Iran indicate we are heading toward escalation
Analysis
English SubtitlesThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Ali Vaez
@AliVaez
Grim @UNDP assessment of war's impact on Iran's already struggling economy: 8.8-10.4% drop in GDP growth compared to no-war baseline, ~4m people falling below poverty line, strains on health sector, rising food prices.
UN Development
@UNDP
Our new report shows that shocks related to the military escalation in the Middle East are increasing pressure on livelihoods, essential services, and human development prospects in Iran.
Read more now: go.undp.org/ShP -
Robert Wright reposted
Siavash Ardalan
@BBCArdalan
One of the oldest and most prestigious medical research and public health centers in the Middle East was targeted in Israeli attacks on Tehran. The Pasteur Institute led successful national campaigns against smallpox, cholera, and plague in Iran over the decades.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Curt Mills
@CurtMills
the best crossover
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I always enjoy my every-so-often conversations with noted Paleocons @CurtMills & @AKDay89 of @amconmag. You can watch here or listen on my @NonzeroPods or their TAC Right Now podcast. www.youtube.com/watch?v=-89uEgethCM
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I always enjoy my every-so-often conversations with noted Paleocons @CurtMills & @AKDay89 of @amconmag. You can watch here or listen on my @NonzeroPods or their TAC Right Now podcast. www.youtube.com/watch?v=-89uEgethCM
-
Robert Wright reposted
Curt Mills
@CurtMills
MAGA Opposition to the Iran War | @robertwrighter, @CurtMills, and @AKDay89 www.youtube.com/watch?v=-89uEgethCM
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Conservative Case Against the Iran War | @CurtMills and @AKDay89 of @amconmag join @robertwrighter to discuss the state of the war, hopes for ending it, Trump's psychology, the Israel lobby's role, the future of MAGA, and more. youtu.be/-89uEgethCM?t=224
-
Robert Wright reposted
Adil Haque
@AdHaque110
It seems we just bombed some residential buildings in an attempt to kill a former diplomat who was trying to facilitate negotiations.
A civilian trying to *end* hostilities, surrounded by other civilians in their homes.
We are completely lost. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Iran is charging $2 million per tanker for exiting Hormuz. That's around $1 per barrel. The war itself is adding $35 per barrel. It's far from clear that ending the war with Iran in control of Hormuz, and turning it into a tollgate, would be the catastrophe some predict.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Dr. Jeffrey Lewis
@ArmsControlWonk
None of this is true. The IAEA and the US intelligence community both assessed that Iran was complying with the JCPIOA when Trump walked away from the agreement.
#BlueAnon_Radar_Detector #BillsMafia #Pathers
@John88962453
They never let the inspectors do their job. They never complied with the inspections as part of the JCPOA.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Vali Nasr
@vali_nasr
The upshot of China-Pakistan 5 point statement on the war is that China's answer to being asked to get involved was definitely not "no." The statement is an opening for Beijing to step in. And Pakistan Army Chief, Munir, who has been talking to Trump and Vance, was also in Beijing, which makes all this all the more interesting.
-
Robert Wright reposted
ControlAI
@ControlAI
ControlAI's CEO Andrea Miotti (@andreamiotti) joins @robertwrighter to discuss why a race to superintelligence is a race no one can win, and how we can change course to avoid the extinction-level threat that AI scientists warn of.
Check it out!
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Averting a Superintelligence Takeover | @robertwrighter and @ControlAI founder and CEO @andreamiotti discuss the dynamics propelling us toward artificial superintelligence and how we can keep control of our future. youtu.be/5oMxw-JVpWg?t=149
-
Robert Wright reposted
ControlAI
@ControlAI
Racing to superintelligence to take over the world makes no sense.
ControlAI CEO Andrea Miotti (@andreamiotti) explains: It's a situation where everyone is incentivized to stop you. Worse, if you build uncontrollable superintelligence first, the superintelligence wins.
Not you.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Ali Hashem علي هاشم
@Alihashem
China and Pakistan announce their joint initiative for cessation of hostilities between the U.S. and Iran.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Averting a Superintelligence Takeover | @robertwrighter and @ControlAI founder and CEO @andreamiotti discuss the dynamics propelling us toward artificial superintelligence and how we can keep control of our future. youtu.be/5oMxw-JVpWg?t=149
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
A career Army officer tries to explain Iranian hostility toward the US via history. In reply, an NYT columnist sticks with his tribal perspective. In @NonzeroNews, I explore this clash of mindsets and its implications: www.nonzero.org/p/why-we-keep-stumbling-into-stupid
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The nightmare scenario for Iran hawks is symmetry of perspective—seeing both Israel and Iran as deeply insecure countries whose defensively motivated actions look offensive to the other side. My latest in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-we-keep-stumbling-into-stupid
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Malley
@Rob_Malley
As with everything by @robertwrighter insightful & thought-provoking
Here he examines that quintessential American trait of ignoring basic laws of cause & effect and assuming others generally act because of who they are - never in response to what we do👇
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
There's a reason Iran hawks call Iranian leaders "the mullahs"—-to frame them as zealots who must be crushed rather than rational actors who can be dealt with. This is part of a larger problem, I argue in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-we-keep-stumbling-into-stupid
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
There's a reason Iran hawks call Iranian leaders "the mullahs"—-to frame them as zealots who must be crushed rather than rational actors who can be dealt with. This is part of a larger problem, I argue in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-we-keep-stumbling-into-stupid
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Why do we keep stumbling into wars? Not because we're stupid, but because we fail to deploy cognitive empathy—just seeing things from the other player's pov. The Iran war is a classic example. My latest in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-we-keep-stumbling-into-stupid
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
A recent convo between retired Gen. Stanley McChrystal & NYT columnist David French about the Iran war was a classic encounter between deft strategic empathy and blinkered tribalism. My latest @NonzeroNews piece. www.nonzero.org/p/why-we-keep-stumbling-into-stupid
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Retired Gen. Stanley McChrystal recently noted that if you think US-Iran hostility starts with "Death to America" in 1979, you should expand your context window. My piece on the value of cognitive empathy in @NonzeroNews www.nonzero.org/p/why-we-keep-stumbling-into-stupid
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
A recent convo between retired Gen. Stanley McChrystal & NYT columnist David French about the Iran war was a classic encounter between deft strategic empathy and blinkered tribalism. My latest @NonzeroNews piece. www.nonzero.org/p/why-we-keep-stumbling-into-stupid
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Why do we keep stumbling into wars? Not because we're stupid, but because we fail to deploy cognitive empathy—just seeing things from the other player's pov. The Iran war is a classic example. My latest in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-we-keep-stumbling-into-stupid
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The skill that could do the most to prevent wars (including the current one) is a skill we keep stigmatizing: seeing things from the adversary's point of view. My latest @NonzeroNews piece: www.nonzero.org/p/why-we-keep-stumbling-into-stupid
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My latest piece in @NonZeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/why-we-keep-stumbling-into-stupid
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Presumably the US and Israel will be bombing Bahrain any moment now so that the people can rise up and overthrow a brutally authoritarian regime.
Mohammad Ali Shabani
@mashabani
Bahraini authorities arrested a critic of the war on Iran. The appearance of his dead body days later, reportedly bearing marks of apparent torture while in custody, has ignited fierce public outcry.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Iran War and the Singularity | @robertwrighter and @NikitaSPetrov connect the Iran war to the AI crisis: If tribal psychology keeps launching stupid wars, how will we coordinate globally on superintelligence? Plus: Trump's hypnotic confidence, $20k drones vs. million-dollar missiles, Russia's sovereign internet, Spanish cannabis clubs, and more. youtu.be/Mj8bTBg72SA?t=410
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ron Kampeas
@kampeas
Me and @robertwrighter again - agreeing, disagreeing but having a good time. Link in reply.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I always enjoy and benefit from my conversations with @kampeas. www.youtube.com/watch?v=yTwjKGXM9xo
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ron Kampeas
@kampeas
Israel, America, and the Iran War | Robert Wright & Ron Kampeas youtu.be/yTwjKGXM9xo via @YouTube always a pleasure to agree and disagree with @robertwrighter
-
Robert Wright reposted
Kathryn Devaney
@kathryndevaney
Perhaps of interest today: I talked in depth with @robertwrighter about the relationship between 5-MeO-DMT and awakening on his podcast a couple of years ago. Please enjoy!
Kathryn Devaney
@kathryndevaney
I got to have a super fun and in depth discussion with @robertwrighter on @NonzeroPods, including getting into the deep end of meditation and altered states. I'm happy to share it today!
Psychedelics, Meditation, and the Brain
open.spotify.com/episode/2S9UtvylqCzXpg8zIvdLsJ -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If war is a non-zero-sum game—often lose-lose—why do nations keep starting wars? Because the people who decide to launch them are playing a game at a different level. My latest piece in @NonzeroNews www.nonzero.org/p/war-isnt-a-zero-sum-game
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Game theorists don't consider war a zero-sum game, because it often winds up being lose-lose. In the latest @NonzeroNews I explore why wars keep happening anyway—and what that tells us about how to reduce their frequency. www.nonzero.org/p/war-isnt-a-zero-sum-game
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I take it you've never had a child?
Laura Loomer
@LauraLoomer
Is there anything worse than a crying baby on a plane?
I wish parents would control their children. It’s so disruptive. I refuse to believe a baby cries for 10 hours. At some point this is just bad parenting, right? -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If war is so often lose-lose for the nations involved, why does it keep happening? Because it's often win-lose, or even win-win, for the leaders on the two sides. I discuss this problem in the latest @NonzeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/war-isnt-a-zero-sum-game
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
War is a lose-lose endeavor for the nations involved more often than not. But for the leaders who push us into wars, there's often political upside. That's a problem we need to address. My latest piece in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/war-isnt-a-zero-sum-game
-
Robert Wright reposted
Daniel Seidemann
@DanielSeidemann
Iran does not have the power to destroy Israel.
Netanyahu does, and he is doing a pretty good job of it.
There is no greater threat to the viability of the Third Jewish Commonwealth than Netanyahu and his regime.
Sky News
@SkyNews
"Iran endangers the entire world"
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says the international community needs to help confront Iran
qrcode.skynews.com/skynews/home
📺 Sky 501, Virgin 602, Freeview 233 and YouTubeThis media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Does Trump really not grasp that (1) There's 0% chance Iran will open the strait in response to this threat; (2) There's 100% chance that if he follows through on his threat Iran will try to escalate along the same dimension? This man is getting scarier and scarier.
The White House
@WhiteHouse
🚨 “If Iran doesn’t FULLY OPEN, WITHOUT THREAT, the Strait of Hormuz, within 48 HOURS from this exact point in time, the United States of America will hit and obliterate their various POWER PLANTS, STARTING WITH THE BIGGEST ONE FIRST…” - President DONALD J. TRUMP
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Some commentators assess Trump's war aims as if he were Metternich rather than just a former Reality TV star staging a spectacle. In @NonzeroNews I argue that more cynicism about politicians' motives would be a public service. www.nonzero.org/p/war-isnt-a-zero-sum-game
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Does Trump really not grasp that (1) There's 0% chance Iran will open the strait in response to this threat; (2) There's 100% chance that if he follows through on his threat Iran will try to escalate along the same dimension? This man is getting scarier and scarier.
The White House
@WhiteHouse
🚨 “If Iran doesn’t FULLY OPEN, WITHOUT THREAT, the Strait of Hormuz, within 48 HOURS from this exact point in time, the United States of America will hit and obliterate their various POWER PLANTS, STARTING WITH THE BIGGEST ONE FIRST…” - President DONALD J. TRUMP
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ihab Hassan
@IhabHassane
INSANE: CCTV footage shows hundreds of Israeli settlers storming the village of Jalud in the West Bank before launching their pogrom, attacking Palestinian homes and setting them on fire in an attempt to burn people alive.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ori Goldberg
@ori_goldberg
Major pogrom taking place in the West Bank as I write.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
One antidote to unnecessary wars is public cynicism about the leaders who start them. In the latest @NonzeroNews, I argue that more discussion of the domestic political payoffs of wars could make them less common. www.nonzero.org/p/war-isnt-a-zero-sum-game
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Think tank commentators tend to treat big US foreign policy initiatives--like starting wars--as geo-strategic calculations when they're mainly about domestic politics. That legitimizes stupid wars. My latest @NonzeroNews piece: www.nonzero.org/p/war-isnt-a-zero-sum-game
-
Robert Wright reposted
Adil Haque
@AdHaque110
"One source said Pentagon lawyers had even been consulted to provide opinions on the legality of such potential moves."
Let me save them some work.
This entire war is a manifest violation of the UN Charter and the prohibition of aggression.
Everything we're doing is illegal.
Barak Ravid
@BarakRavid
🇺🇸🇮🇷🚢The Trump administration is considering plans to occupy or blockade Iran's Kharg Island to pressure Iran to reopen the Strait of Hormuz, four sources with knowledge of the issue tell @MarcACaputo and me. Read our story on @axios
www.axios.com/2026/03/20/iran-invasion-kharg-island-strai… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed talking to @DoomDebates host @liron about his doomer ambivalence: He finds AI agents very useful but still feels that it's deeply dangerous to let AI advance continue indefinitely. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=-XBB3dudrlw
-
Robert Wright reposted
Liron Shapira
@liron
I'm talking about the AI unemployment wave on one of the best podcasts: NonZero with @RobertWrighter! 👇
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Trump's approval rating--14.1 points under water in the Real Clear Politics poll aggregator--is the worst it's been since he was inaugurated. Americans may not know much about foreign policy, but they know four-dollar-a-gallon gas when they see it.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
I’m always extremely reluctant to use the word evil but how else to describe what we are deliberating doing to millions of Cubans?
Erik Sperling
@ErikSperling
As US starves Cuba of energy & food, neocon Cotton wants DOD to be ready for a "humanitarian crisis," "flow of refugees," or "civil disorder" in Cuba
Southcom is "prepared to support DHS in a mass migration event" including a "camp to deal with those migrants" at Gitmo, he says -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Allure and Danger of Agentic AI | @robertwrighter and AI pause advocate (and @DoomDebates host) @liron discuss Claude Code, OpenClaw and other AI developments—and whether they've brought us closer to doom. Plus: A civil(-ish) debate on Israel-Palestine.
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Wall Street Journal
@WSJ
U.S. missiles that hit Iran likely were fired from Gulf countries that have taken the brunt of Iranian drone and missile attacks—although none acknowledges allowing use of their land or airspace www.wsj.com/world/iran-war-land-missile-strikes-22ca3be5
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Choice A: Give $1,500 tax rebate to every US household. Choice B: Launch unprovoked, illegal war that will raise the cost of living among many other bad effects.
Trump chose B. -
Robert Wright reposted
Marko Jukic
@mmjukic
Absolutely morbid black comedy that the U.S. government is removing sanctions on Russian and Iranian oil in 2026 not as part of any celebrated peace deal or diplomatic normalization but as a last-ditch effort to soften the blow of a historic energy crisis caused by a U.S. war.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Esfandyar Batmanghelidj
@yarbatman
So the Trump administration is willing to unsanction Iranian oil so that it can keep fighting a war.
But it was reluctant to do so during talks in order to achieve peace.
Sort of says it all.
Annmarie Hordern
@annmarie
BESSENT: US MAY UNSANCTION IRANAIN OIL THAT'S ON WATER
BESSENT: WHEN WE UNSANCTION IRAN OIL, CAN GO TO EX-CHINA PLACES
So we can see the regime selling oil legally at a much higher price? -
Robert Wright reposted
Ilan Goldenberg
@ilangoldenberg
“Escalating to deescalate” is something you hear a lot in strategic and military circles. Has a nice ring to it. It also almost never works. Escalation tend to lead to….escalation.
Alex Ward
@alexbward
Trump knew of South Pars attack and approved of it. But now he's against strikes on Iranian energy sites, believing Tehran received the message that it must reopen the Strait of Hormuz.
Trump open to future attacks on Iranian energy facilities depending on Iran's SoH actions. -
Robert Wright reposted
Bruno Maçães
@MacaesBruno
The most important fact in world politics today: how the US is fast losing power over the global system but also how it is replacing systemic power with brute force. The two trends are accelerating together. Yes it’s not clear we’ll be able to survive this
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I taped this conversation with Daniel Levy shortly before Israel's assassination of Larijani, but the assassination is consistent with Daniel's assessment of Israel's goals. You can watch here or listen on @NonZeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=YdxF1FhM4zc
-
Robert Wright reposted
Vali Nasr
@vali_nasr
Larijani’s replacement will be appointed by IRGC. With every assassination U.S. and Israel engineering greater radicalization of Iran’s leadership. It will makes for a bleak future for Iran, Iranians, the region and ultimately makes it far more difficult for U.S. to disentangle itself from endless conflict in the region.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
Why did Israel target Ali Larijani, and what are the implications if it is confirmed that he was killed?
I see three potential motivations behind the assassination attempt:
1. Israel is trying to literally kill off Trump's off ramps: Larijani was not only a key figure within the regime who had emerged as the chief consensus builder, but alto kill off Trump's off ramps literallys someone who favored talks with the US and who could build consensus within the system for an Iranian off ramp at some point. He also favored de-escalation with the GCC states and supported Pezeshkian's message on that point (though not the apology). There had been some efforts by Larijani to speak directly with senior Trump officials in December, for instance, to prevent the war. The Israelis want the war to continue to degrade Iran's military capabilities further to shift the balance in the region in Israel's favor for years to come. They have fought for more than two decades to get the US to go to full war with Iran, and having finally achieved that goal, they do not want Trump to cut the war short. Without figures like Larijani in the Iranian system, Trump's pathways to ending the war just got narrower.
2. The US/Israeli strategy may be shifting back to regime decapitation. The reason for this is that it's becoming increasingly clear that reopening the Straits of Hormuz militarily is simply too risky, and there is no international coalition willing to support Trump. But the Straits must be reopened from Trump's perspective because of the impact on energy markets, which eventually will impact gas and food prices in the US, and push Trump's own base to turn against this war. But if he cannot open it militarily, then the original idea of regime implosion may prove another path. As such, the killing of Larijani may have been seen as a second bite at the apple. The first bite, the assassination of Khamenei, did not yield results. But a few more assassinations of key figures may, the thinking would go.
3. Opportunity: The assassination may have also simply occurred because the opportunity presented itself, rather than having been motivated by either a shift in strategy or a sabotage effort by the Israelis to kill off Trump's off-ramps.
Either way, while this undoubtedly is a significant tactical blow to the Islamic Republic, it is difficult to envision it considerably impacting Tehran's war execution.
Plans for these eventualities had already been established during the June war. Moreover, when relatively moderate voices have been killed by Israel, they have more often than not been replaced by a younger generation of more hawkish voices who opposed Iran's policy of "strategic patience", who opposed the June ceasefire, and who currently oppose any de-escalation or ceasefire.
Whether this was Israel's intent or not, the most likely outcome, nevertheless, is the destruction of potential off-ramps for Trump. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
What’s Israel Thinking? | @robertwrighter and British–Israeli Middle East expert Daniel Levy discuss Bibi’s aims for the Iran war—and how he’s using the Trump moment to pursue them. Plus: Iran’s strategy, Israel’s ongoing radicalization, the Gulf States' dilemma, and more. @USMEP
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In my latest @NonzeroNews piece, I look at the implications of @vali_nasr's assessment of Iran's war aims. www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The main criticism of Obama's Iran nuclear deal (which Trump trashed in his first term, setting the stage for the current mess) was that it only lasted 15 years. Turns out that, right before Trump launched this war, Iran had offered to make a *permanent* deal.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Vagabundo 🐙🍉
@libertadorzn
An excellent piece.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Many nations want regional stability in the Middle East. Israel and America don't seem to be among them. My piece in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
It's true that Netanyahu's goal of regime collapse (which meanwhile makes the regime more radical, less open to diplomacy) is at odds with Trump's interests (like finding an offramp). It's also true that Trump is too stupid to grasp this.
Ali Alfoneh علی آلفونه
@Alfoneh
The assassination of elites open to U.S. talks betrays Israel’s objectives: regime collapse, civil war, and Iran’s partition—diverging from President Trump’s approach. But Israel and the U.S. may end up with a radicalized IRGC dictatorship instead. shorturl.at/MYoJm
-
Robert Wright reposted
Joe Kent
@joekent16jan19
After much reflection, I have decided to resign from my position as Director of the National Counterterrorism Center, effective today.
I cannot in good conscience support the ongoing war in Iran. Iran posed no imminent threat to our nation, and it is clear that we started this war due to pressure from Israel and its powerful American lobby.
It has been an honor serving under @POTUS and @DNIGabbard and leading the professionals at NCTC.
May God bless America. -
Robert Wright reposted
Jim Lobe
@LobeLog
Must read.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Which side in this war actually wants long-term regional stability, and which side's security strategy amounts to endless destabilization? I make the case for my (unpopular) answer in the latest @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Many nations want regional stability in the Middle East. Israel and America don't seem to be among them. My piece in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Which side in this war actually wants long-term regional stability, and which side's security strategy amounts to endless destabilization? I make the case for my (unpopular) answer in the latest @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
We're told Iran is the most destabilizing force in the Middle East. But in this war it's the side whose post-war goals actually include regional stability. My latest piece in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
If you want long-term peace in the Middle East, you might want to reconsider which side you're rooting for. @robertwrighter's latest piece: www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Many nations want to bring peace and stability to the Middle East. America and Israel don't seem to be among them. My latest @NonzeroNews piece: www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Lots of commentators call Iran the most destabilizing force in the Middle East. In my latest @NonzeroNews piece I argue that America and Israel are better candidates for that title. www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
Iran is widely called the most destabilizing force in the Middle East. @robertwrighter argues the evidence is less clear than many consumers of American MSM would assume. www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
How does Iran deter the next US-Israeli attack? Make the Gulf states' commercial ambitions hostage to it. This strategy has huge implications that I explore in the latest @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
"Israel believes its security is achieved by dominating the region... For it to have total security, everyone else has to have total insecurity." I explore the implications of that quote from @QuincyInst's @tparsi here: www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Some say regime "survival" Is Iran's goal. But Iran's leaders want something bigger: to make this war the last one. That's a goal the Gulf states Iran is attacking share. I explore the implications in @NonzeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright reposted
Sina Toossi
@SinaToossi
The Isfahan bombings today mark another escalation by the U.S.
Isfahan is home to much of Iran’s industrial base & critical factories.
In response, Iran is threatening regional “American industrial centers,” continuing a tit-for-tat pattern in moving up the escalation ladder.
الجزيرة - عاجل
@AJABreaking
عاجل | الحرس الثوري الإيراني: نوجه تحذيرا للنظام الأمريكي بضرورة إخلاء جميع المراكز الصناعية الأمريكية في المنطقة
-
Robert Wright reposted
🇨🇦 Jamie Carroll 🇨🇦
@jec79
The owner of the largest Navy in the history of the world would like sailors from other countries to die in a war he started without consulting anyone.
Pass, thanks.
BBC Breaking News
@BBCBreaking
US President Donald Trump urges UK and other nations to send ships to help secure key Strait of Hormuz oil trade route www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/ckg1w1jp8kjt?at_bbc_team=editorial
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"There is not a single leader of the opposition who has any real ground operation in Iran that could then replace this regime."
@hmajd on the gap between the "rise up" rhetoric from Netanyahu and others and the political reality on the ground in Iran. -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
"You don't have to land many missiles or suicide drones on targets in Dubai before Dubai's commercial identity—as a place where the rich can live and party and park assets, and international business can get done—is imperiled."
More from @robertwrighter:
www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Iran's goal isn't just to survive this war—it's to make sure there isn't a next one. That reframes what "victory" for Iran would mean in ways most US commentary ignores. My latest in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In TrumpWorld, getting the strait closed and then opened really is a big win, because then Trump dominates the headlines on two days instead of one. Unfortunately, trying to open the strait by force stands a good chance of proving disastrous.
Aaron Bastani
@AaronBastani
Seems increasingly obvious that a ‘win’ for the White House in the war with Iran is re-opening the Strait of Hormuz.
Which was only closed because they…started a war. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Here's an irony worth pondering: Iran's war aims are broadly shared by the very Gulf states it's been attacking. Both want post-war regional stability. Israel doesn't. My latest @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright reposted
Andrew Day
@AKDay89
Iran's "goal is regional stability, and Israel’s goal is more nearly the opposite, and America’s goal is… well, so long as Trump is president, it’s hard to say what America’s goal is."
Courageous and provocative piece. And persuasive.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I guess it’s too much to hope that people will read my latest @NonZeroNews piece before denouncing it on the basis of its title. Oh well… www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My latest piece in @NonZeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nicholas Kristof
@NickKristof
Terrorism by Israeli settlers, sometimes protected by the IDF, is out of control.
Ihab Hassan
@IhabHassane
🚨A horrific video shows Israeli settlers assaulting a Palestinian man in front of his home and his family today in the village of Qusra in the West Bank.
Earlier in the morning, an Israeli settler ran over a 5-year-old girl in Hebron and opened fire at civilians in the town of Sa’ir.
Israeli settler terrorism in the West Bank is reaching unprecedented levels, with full impunity. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"What Iran was offering to the United States in this last round was a much better deal for the US and the Western world than what Obama had gotten with the JCPOA." @hmajd
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Iran's War for a New Middle East Order | @hmajd, author of the memoir Minister Without Portfolio, joins @robertwrighter to discuss Iran’s strategic goals, the prospects for regime survival, and the US's missed opportunities for entente with Iran. youtu.be/r7mIIzfw8Is?t=131
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I guess it’s too much to hope that people will read my latest @NonZeroNews piece before denouncing it on the basis of its title. Oh well… www.nonzero.org/p/why-americans-should-root-for-iran
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I got a lot out of this discussion with @hmajd about Iran's strategic goals (and the extent to which they converge, in ways that could become important, with goals of the Arab States Iran is now attacking). You can watch here or listen on @NonZeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=r7mIIzfw8Is
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
NEWS: The man who rammed his explosives-laden truck into a Michigan synagogue today was named Ayman Ghazaleh, according to a source familiar with the situation. Ghazaleh posted photos overnight of his family members, including young children, who were killed in a recent Israeli attack on the town of Mashghara, Lebanon. This is a developing story.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Iran's War for a New Middle East Order | @hmajd, author of the memoir Minister Without Portfolio, joins @robertwrighter to discuss Iran’s strategic goals, the prospects for regime survival, and the US's missed opportunities for entente with Iran. youtu.be/r7mIIzfw8Is?t=131
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The latest issue of NZNet Digest, featuring the work of @PeterBeinart, @dwdavison, @KaiserKuo, @GlennLoury, @MarkLGoldberg, @paulbloomatyale, and @vali_nasr. www.nonzero.org/p/nznet-digest-how-trumps-war-is-backfiring
-
Robert Wright reposted
Lara Friedman
@LaraFriedmanDC
As Jewish terrorists, backed by IDF, declare open season on West Bank Palestinians for sin of EXISTING on land coveted by many Israelis…Ben Gvir opens door for Jewish terrorists to declare open season on Jerusalem Palestinians, whose homes/lands many Israelis passionately covet.
Daniel Seidemann
@DanielSeidemann
Ben Gvir gave rights to 300,000 residents of Jerusalem to a weapons permit & bear arms.
The 25% of Jerusalem's ultra-orthodox can get permits.
The 35% who are secular/modern orthodox/traditional can.
The 40% of Jerusalem who are Palestinian can't.
What could possibly go wrong? -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Had a great conversation with @PeterBeinart about something some people say you shouldn't talk about: the possibility that Israel's policies (such as joining with the US in attacking Iran) could intensify antisemitism. You can watch here or listen on @NonZeroPods.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Oh you mean *that* kind of unconditional surrender...
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Israel, Iran, and Antisemitism | @robertwrighter and @PeterBeinart, publisher of The Beinart Notebook, discuss how Trump and Bibi’s war with Iran risks fueling antisemitism. Plus: Tucker vs Fuentes on Israel, the ADL’s counterproductive speech policing, the Epstein effect, and more.
youtu.be/h15NR9YI1lc?t=97 -
Robert Wright reposted
ProfTalmadge
@ProfTalmadge
This is a technical story with stunning strategic implications. It is quite possible the US launched a massive war because Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff lacked the technical expertise to even understand what the Iranians were offering in negotiations. Absolute idiocy.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The "human in the kill chain" safeguard against "fully autonomous" weapons can just mean someone scanned an AI-generated target list and said, "Looks good--let's do it!" My latest in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/iran-and-the-immorality-of-openai
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
People talk about US foreign policy as if it's a strategy. It's not. It's what happens when intensely motivated special interest groups fill the vacuum left by voter indifference. My latest @NonzeroNews piece: www.nonzero.org/p/iran-and-the-immorality-of-openai
-
Robert Wright reposted
Shervin Malekzadeh شروین ملک زاده
@Swarthy_Bastard
I can’t stop thinking about this. I have an aunt and an uncle in Tehran undergoing medical treatment. What becomes of them, what are their diminished prospects?
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Imagine being (to take just one example) an Iranian woman having a difficult pregnancy and being extra careful about nutrition, rest, etc. And then this happens. Trump and Netanyahu are psychopathic monsters, and any American who supports this unprovoked, illegal war should be ashamed.
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
Tehran is covered in thick black clouds of smoke this morning after a series of Israeli airstrikes struck multiple oil depots and a refinery.
Locals report that the morning rain was black and oily. -
Robert Wright reposted
AI Notkilleveryoneism Memes ⏸️
@AISafetyMemes
Rothmus 🏴
@Rothmus
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Every big AI CEO justifies Pentagon contracts by invoking national security. Maybe somebody should ask them to name a recent US military intervention that actually kept America secure. My latest @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/iran-and-the-immorality-of-openai
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Imagine being (to take just one example) an Iranian woman having a difficult pregnancy and being extra careful about nutrition, rest, etc. And then this happens. Trump and Netanyahu are psychopathic monsters, and any American who supports this unprovoked, illegal war should be ashamed.
OSINTtechnical
@Osinttechnical
Tehran is covered in thick black clouds of smoke this morning after a series of Israeli airstrikes struck multiple oil depots and a refinery.
Locals report that the morning rain was black and oily. -
Robert Wright reposted
AMK Mapping 🇳🇿
@AMK_Mapping_
If I had to summarise Twitter in one screenshot, this would be it.
AMK Mapping 🇳🇿
@AMK_Mapping_
And for the millionth time, I am NOT a Zionist. I have repeatedly called out Israel's genocide and ethnic cleansing of Palestinians and have never shown any support to that ethno-state.
But I don't let my emotions blind my critical thinking, unlike many people on this app. -
Robert Wright reposted
Pope Leo XIV
@Pontifex
Reports from #iran and across the entire #middleeast continue to cause deep dismay and raise the fear that the conflict will expand, and that other countries in the region, including dear Lebanon, may once again sink into instability. Let us #praytogether for the roar of bombs to cease, weapons to fall silent, and space to open for dialogue, in which people's voices may be heard.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Dario Amodei says he "believes deeply in the existential importance of using AI to defend the US." If he really thinks that's what the US military does, he's too naive to run a big AI company. My latest in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/iran-and-the-immorality-of-openai
-
Robert Wright reposted
Holly ⏸️ Elmore
@ilex_ulmus
It’s time to quit, @AnthropicAI employees. You are in over your head.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Anthropic's Claude helped select hundreds of targets for the opening wave of Iran strikes. There's a good chance that one of them was the elementary school where more than 100 girls died. My latest @NonzeroNews piece. www.nonzero.org/p/iran-and-the-immorality-of-openai
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Anthropic's Claude helped select hundreds of targets for the opening wave of Iran strikes. There's a good chance that one of them was the elementary school where more than 100 girls died. My latest @NonzeroNews piece. www.nonzero.org/p/iran-and-the-immorality-of-openai
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
US foreign policy is little more than the sum total of corrupting influences—the Israel lobby, the Cuba lobby, arms makers, etc.—with voters largely absent. In the latest @NonzeroNews I trace how this machinery led us into war with Iran. www.nonzero.org/p/iran-and-the-immorality-of-openai
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
US foreign policy is little more than the sum total of corrupting influences—the Israel lobby, the Cuba lobby, arms makers, etc.—with voters largely absent. In the latest @NonzeroNews I trace how this machinery led us into war with Iran. www.nonzero.org/p/iran-and-the-immorality-of-openai
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In fifth grade I attended an elementary school that was *on* a US military base in Virginia. I guess somebody should have bombed it to teach us a lesson.
BBC Newsnight
@BBCNewsnight
"Don't build girls' schools right next to naval bases"
President Trump's former National Security Adviser John Bolton responds to reports of a US or Israeli strike on a girls' school in Iran.
#newsnight -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The tendency to read offensive intent into defensive actions helped start WW I and, I argue in the latest @NonzeroNews, the current Iran war. www.nonzero.org/p/iran-and-the-immorality-of-openai @vali_nasr has been one of the view clear-eyed, prominent analysts on this.
-
Robert Wright reposted
BrahmH
@Brahmhatter
Great article on Iran and the immorality of OpenAI, Anthropic, and Google
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My latest piece in @NonzeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/iran-and-the-immorality-of-openai
-
Robert Wright reposted
Niall Stanage
@NiallStanage
Just so we’re all clear — a new WSJ story has a U.S. senator (Lindsey Graham) meeting a foreign intelligence agency and “coaching” that foreign nation’s prime minister (Benjamin Netanyahu) on how to push Trump into bombing Iran.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Breaking the Silence
@BtSIsrael
🔴NOW: A settler terrorist has killed a Palestinian in Susya in the West Bank. Another Palestinian was wounded. The Palestinian who was killed was Amerr Shnaran, 28, a father of two. Another Palestinian was wounded. This is the third person killed by settler terrorists this week.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My latest piece in @NonzeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/iran-and-the-immorality-of-openai
-
Robert Wright reposted
Hagit Ofran חגית עופרן
@hagitofran
תראו איך זה עובד:
קהילה פלסטינית ליד דומא מותקפת באופן יומיומי ע"י מתנחלים. ההגנה היחידה שלהם היא פעילים ישראלים צדיקים שמנסים לחצוץ ולמנוע אלימות.
השבוע צה"ל מוציא צו שמגרש את הפעילים הישראלים.
תוך יומיים מתנחלים הורסים בית, תוקפים ומגרשים את הקהילה.
www.haaretz.co.il/news/politics/2026-03-05/ty-article/.pr… -
Robert Wright reposted
Herd of Justice
@JustHerds
There's no easy way to say this:
An entire community just vanished in front of our eyes.
Today, the last families in a Bedouin community near Duma decided to leave, after settlers have been attacking them all day with activists banned from the area.
We saw them running away from their homes with nothing.
We've protected this community for months. But when the army decided to force them out, by declaring the area a closed military zone and expelling all activists, it was game over.
People once called this place a home. Now it is just a pile of rubble 💔 -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Trump's Gulf War | @dwdavison and @dbessner of the @AmPrestigePod join NonZero’s @robertwrighter to discuss evolving US war aims and their chances of success.
youtu.be/04xAU1MUvq8?t=106 -
Robert Wright reposted
Glenn Loury
@GlennLoury
Collaborating with Bob Wright in a new venture. Check it out...
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The inaugural issue of NonZero Network Digest, timely highlights from the work of NonZero partners @dwdavison, @MarkLGoldberg, @KaiserKuo, @paulbloomatyale, and @GlennLoury. www.nonzero.org/p/nznet-digest-iran-war-updates-ai
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The inaugural issue of NonZero Network Digest, timely highlights from the work of NonZero partners @dwdavison, @MarkLGoldberg, @KaiserKuo, @paulbloomatyale, and @GlennLoury. www.nonzero.org/p/nznet-digest-iran-war-updates-ai
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"Maybe that'll reduce the amount of blowback we get from this war."
@robertwrighter questions Marco Rubio's logic.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Will the Iran War Spiral Out of Control? | @robertwrighter and @NikitaSPetrov unpack the logic—and illogic—behind Israel's and America's strikes on Iran. Plus: the dopamine theory of MAGA foreign policy, how the Anthropic story got buried by the bombings, and more.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Donald Trump is the reason they're dead, period. A completely unprovoked and unnecessary war launched by a narcissist who thinks the world is his own personal video game.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Will the Iran War Spiral Out of Control? | @robertwrighter and @NikitaSPetrov unpack the logic—and illogic—behind Israel's and America's strikes on Iran. Plus: the dopamine theory of MAGA foreign policy, how the Anthropic story got buried by the bombings, and more.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"If Trump bombs Iran, I'm waiting to see if Carney says, 'I denounce this.'" @robertwrighter (01/30/2026)
Did Mark Carney pass the test?This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Mark Carney
@MarkJCarney
My statement on Iran-related hostilities in the Middle East:
-
Robert Wright reposted
Eric Levitz
@EricLevitz
Good piece. I think Anthropic has been admirably principled. But the principles it's sticking to include a very hawkish form of liberal internationalism.
(One minor disagreement: I'm a little more sympathetic to Anthropic's excuses for watering down its safety standards than Bob is. Their basic argument is that they need access to the most powerful -- and thus, most dangerous -- models, in order to run safety tests/identify latent vulnerabilities in how the models operate. And if they unilaterally adhere to the most exacting safety standards, they risk losing access to the technological frontier.
I don't necessarily buy this argument in full; there are clearly also material incentives in play. But the fact that Anthropic is spending money on behalf of pro-AI regulation candidates makes me take the position a bit more seriously. They are at least trying to solve the collective action problem they're bending to)
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Dario Amodei's geopolitical vision—an "eternal 1991" where democracies use AI-infused "robust military superiority" to dominate autocracies like China—is dangerous. His Pentagon faceoff was laudable, but he's not the hero anti-militarists need, I argue in the latest @NonzeroNews.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Plus, none of those ballistic missiles can reach the US anyway. Not sure I've ever heard a US admin struggle so pathetically to come up with a semi-plausible rationale for starting a war. And I've seen some pretty pathetic struggling.
jeremy scahill
@jeremyscahill
"Secretary of War" Hegseth claims the bombing of Iran was necessary because Iran had a "conventional gun to our head." To be clear, he is claiming the US went to war because Iran has ballistic missiles and drones it has used as a deterrent or to respond to US/Israeli attacks.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Britain has a legislator who's heard of international law. I wonder what it's like to live in a country like that.
Richard Burgon MP
@RichardBurgon
I am deeply alarmed that British military bases will be used in Trump's bombing of Iran - these attacks violate international law.
The UK government should be focused on de-escalation, diplomacy and a ceasefire - that's the best way of keeping people safe, not following Trump. -
Robert Wright reposted
Breaking the Silence
@BtSIsrael
Yesterday morning, we woke up to rocket alerts. Israel began bombing Iran. As often happens when the media attention shifts, Israel seized the moment to intensify its attacks against Palestinians. Here’s what happened while the world was looking the other way🧵
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I suspect Trump thought killing Khamenei would be a punctuation mark that would let him declare victory and disengage (like the June bombings of nuclear facilities). I also suspect it's going to have the opposite effect. It can't be overemphasized that Trump is dumb as a brick.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
All the big AI firms--OpenAI, Google, xAI, Anthropic--are fine with their tech being used in wars that flagrantly violate the UN Charter, like Venezuela and now Iran. I discuss this in the context of the Amodei-Hegseth standoff in this week's @NonZeroNews. nonzero.substack.com/p/dario-amodei-isnt-the-hero-we-need
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Dario Amodei--like Altman and other AI defense contractors--raises no objection to his tech being used in Iran and Venezuela, wars that clearly violate international law. His stance vs. Hegseth was laudable, but he's not the hero anti-militarists need, I argue in @NonZeroNews.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Dario Amodei's geopolitical vision—an "eternal 1991" where democracies use AI-infused "robust military superiority" to dominate autocracies like China—is dangerous. His Pentagon faceoff was laudable, but he's not the hero anti-militarists need, I argue in the latest @NonzeroNews.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Dario Amodei doesn't oppose fully autonomous weapons—he just thinks the tech isn't reliable yet. In my latest @NonzeroNews I try to dispel some myths about this week's hero (who still deserves credit for standing up to the Pentagon). www.nonzero.org/p/dario-amodei-isnt-the-hero-we-need
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Dario Amodei deserves credit for standing up to the Pentagon, but if you're hoping his stance will restrain an AI-empowered American military, your hopes are misplaced. I elaborate in the latest @NonzeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/dario-amodei-isnt-the-hero-we-need
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Serious question: Why is it in his political interest to be Trump's lapdog? I can't believe this plays well with most of his constituents. There must be something about British politics I don't understand.
Clash Report
@clashreport
Keir Starmer:
Iran can end this now. They should refrain from further strikes, give up their weapons programs, and cease the appalling violence and repression against the Iranian people. -
Robert Wright reposted
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
An Iranian drone hits the US naval base in Bahrain. The Bahrainis filming appear to be celebrating the hit.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If he still believes this, make him White House Crypto and AI and Foreign Policy Czar.
David Sacks
@DavidSacks
What did removing Saddam, Gaddafi, Assad get us? Chaos, civil war, genocide.
The rule for regime change operations in the Middle East is that they don’t flip a country from bad-to-good. They flip a country from bad-to-worse. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The fact that the Dem House leader can't just condemn a clear violation of the UN Charter--unprovoked transborder aggression--is pathetic. After the midterms we need regime change in the Democratic Party. You suck, @RepJeffries.
Jake Sherman
@JakeSherman
NEW -- STATEMENT FROM HOUSE MINORITY LEADER @RepJeffries
"The Trump administration must explain itself to the American people and Congress immediately, provide an ironclad justification for this act of war, clearly define the national security objective and articulate a plan to avoid another costly, prolonged military quagmire in the Middle East." -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
None of the big four AI companies (all of them defense contractors) have expressed qualms about their tech being used in wars like Iran and Venezuela--clear violations of international law. That's part of the point of my latest piece in @NonZeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/dario-amodei-isnt-the-hero-we-need
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My latest @NonzeroNews piece. www.nonzero.org/p/dario-amodei-isnt-the-hero-we-need
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My conversation with Middle East expert @joshua_landis deepened my understanding of the grim absurdity of the predicament Trump has stumbled into re Iran. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=kSZSz_SdnXw
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If Trump reads this piece by a very well-known defense analyst (@Aviation_Intel)--especially the part under the subhead "Real Dangers"--he'll have a harder time convincing himself to launch a war that the Iranian regime sees as threatening its survival. www.twz.com/news-features/the-massive-questions-surroundi…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Wait, you're telling me that Donald Trump might renege on a deal? This is paradigm shifting news.
Nathan Calvin
@_NathanCalvin
This aspect seems to be getting missed - the contract that the DOW signed included Anthropic’s acceptable use policy! The DOW is threatening to blacklist Anthropic or use the DPA in retaliation for Anthropic failing to renounce existing contract terms
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
It's always enlightening to talk to @joshua_landis of @QuincyInst about the Middle East. And God knows people in Washington could use some enlightenment on this subject right now. www.youtube.com/watch?v=kSZSz_SdnXw
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My conversation with Middle East expert @joshua_landis deepened my understanding of the grim absurdity of the predicament Trump has stumbled into re Iran. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=kSZSz_SdnXw
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Will Trump Pull the Trigger on Iran? | @robertwrighter and Middle East expert @joshua_landis discuss the logic (or lack thereof) behind air strikes—and the implications for the US, Israel, and the wider region. youtu.be/kSZSz_SdnXw?t=137
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
"The race itself is inherently dangerous, since the side that's losing could decide that it has to resort to extreme measures if it wants to escape subjugation."
More from @robertwrighter on the race to superintelligence/AGI:
www.nonzero.org/p/winning-the-ai-race-could-be-bad -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Imagine you're an extraterrestrial, observing Earth as the US-China race toward AGI unfolds, and a friend asks: "Which nation would do more damage with a new kind of hegemonic power?" Is China really the obvious answer? My latest @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/winning-the-ai-race-could-be-bad
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
More from @robertwrighter: www.nonzero.org/p/winning-the-ai-race-could-be-bad
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
The visual display of quantitative information can be powerful; a glance at a good graph can give you the big picture fast. By the same token, visually displayed data can be subtly, yet powerfully, misleading.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Sam Altman said last week that we'll "probably need superintelligence to help us figure out the new governance mechanisms” that superintelligence will demand. Isn't that an argument for slowing down, not speeding up? My latest in @NonzeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/winning-the-ai-race-could-be-bad
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The "America must beat China to AGI" argument assumes the US would use unprecedented power more responsibly than China. Given recent history, that assumption deserves a lot more scrutiny than it's getting. My latest @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/winning-the-ai-race-could-be-bad
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Silicon Valley is full of warnings about how bad life on Earth will be if a country like China wins the AI race. In the latest @NonzeroNews, I argue that life could be bad if a country like America wins it. www.nonzero.org/p/winning-the-ai-race-could-be-bad
-
Robert Wright reposted
Sean Richardson
@bayesian_wasian
Always enjoy these episodes w/ @robertwrighter and @ilex_ulmus, thought-provoking commentary on the sociological dynamics of AI safety
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is Anthropic Misanthropic? | Holly Elmore (@ilex_ulmus), executive director of @pauseaius, makes the case for naming and shaming people who are fueling an AI race whose perils they understand. @robertwrighter
youtu.be/Amc8Aw5ob1Y?t=130 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Plot spoiler: No.
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
Would AI-powered American dominance of Planet Earth, if achieved, be a good thing?
www.nonzero.org/p/winning-the-ai-race-could-be-bad -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Many tech titans have managed to reconcile grave doubts about where AI is heading with a firm commitment to speeding up the journey. Not sure I get the logic. My latest @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/winning-the-ai-race-could-be-bad
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Eric Schmidt says the US needs 92 gigawatts of new power capacity pronto so we can "win" the AI race. In the latest @NonzeroNews, I offer new reasons for thinking this headlong rush into the unknown is a bad idea. www.nonzero.org/p/winning-the-ai-race-could-be-bad
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"They have to do whatever it takes to win the race. Even if it makes them do the same things as the bad guys, or worse."
@ilex_ulmus questions the logic of Anthropic's superintelligence strategy. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My latest piece in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/winning-the-ai-race-could-be-bad
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed this conversation with a truly committed activist.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is Anthropic Misanthropic? | Holly Elmore (@ilex_ulmus), executive director of @pauseaius, makes the case for naming and shaming people who are fueling an AI race whose perils they understand. @robertwrighter
youtu.be/Amc8Aw5ob1Y?t=130 -
Robert Wright reposted
Holly ⏸️ Elmore
@ilex_ulmus
Talked with Robert Wright about calling people out on twitter
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is Anthropic Misanthropic? | Holly Elmore (@ilex_ulmus), executive director of @pauseaius, makes the case for naming and shaming people who are fueling an AI race whose perils they understand. @robertwrighter
youtu.be/Amc8Aw5ob1Y?t=130 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed talking to Holly Elmore (@ilex_ulmus), executive director of @pauseaius, about why she thinks the AI race is so dangerous and what she's trying to do about it. Watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=Amc8Aw5ob1Y
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is Anthropic Misanthropic? | Holly Elmore (@ilex_ulmus), executive director of @pauseaius, makes the case for naming and shaming people who are fueling an AI race whose perils they understand. @robertwrighter
youtu.be/Amc8Aw5ob1Y?t=130 -
Robert Wright reposted
Alex JER-dun
@alexjordanATL
Yet again, Democratic leaders just utterly failing to meet the moment on foreign policy. My god
Ken Klippenstein
@kenklippenstein
Asked about possible US military strike on Iran, Democratic Senator @MarkWarner replies: "I think it's appropriate the president has all the options on the table."
-
Robert Wright reposted
Congressman Greg Casar
@RepCasar
The American people do not want a war with Iran.
My entire adult life, politicians have been sending other people’s kids — our U.S. troops — to die in reckless, endless wars.
Enough.
www.axios.com/2026/02/18/iran-war-trump-military-strikes-… -
Robert Wright reposted
David J. Bier
@David_J_Bier
They are burning people alive and posting the videos. This is sick.
Commentary Trump Daily Posts
@TrumpDailyPosts
U.S. Southern Command:
"Late on Feb. 16, at the direction of @Southcom commander Gen. Francis L. Donovan, Joint Task Force Southern Spear conducted three lethal kinetic strikes on three vessels operated by Designated Terrorist Organizations. Intelligence confirmed the vessels were transiting along known narco-trafficking routes and were engaged in narco-trafficking operations. Eleven male narco-terrorists were killed during these actions, 4 on the first vessel in the Eastern Pacific, 4 on the second vessel in the Eastern Pacific, and 3 on the third vessel in the Caribbean. No U.S. military forces were harmed." -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The AI Apocalypse Cometh? | @robertwrighter and @paulbloomatyale discuss whether reports of AI acceleration are greatly exaggerated—and what’s at stake if they’re not. Plus, in Overtime: Bob’s Epstein files cameos and Paul's big news.
youtu.be/muGYqdWZCWw?t=404 -
Robert Wright reposted
Rep. Jim McGovern
@RepMcGovern
For 6 decades, we've had a comprehensive trade embargo against Cuba.
And for 6 decades, that embargo has failed in its strategic objectives—delivering nothing but misery and pain for everyday Cuban families.
It's time to pivot. My new bill would turn the page on the failed status quo—harnessing diplomacy & engagement to promote democracy & freedom.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Max Tegmark
@tegmark
OpenAI has dropped safety from its mission statement – can you spot another change?
Old: "OpenAIs mission is to build general purpose artificial intelligence (AI) that safely benefits humanity, unconstrained by a need to generate financial return. [...]"
New: "OpenAIs mission is to ensure that artificial general intelligence benefits all of humanity"
(IRS evidence in comments) -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
The "Manichaean" framing of democracy vs. autocracy has stalled AI safety cooperation with China. Ironically, Trump’s transactional realism might make rapprochement possible under the right circumstances.
www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
The dashed curve is the curve that was fit to the data that existed as of the spring of last year.
More: www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonZeroNews I argue that, however ironic this sounds (even to me!), Trump could, under the right political circumstances, wind up exerting a constructive influence on the unfolding of the AI revolution. www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I figured there would be retaliation for that Anthropic Super Bowl ad, but I didn't imagine anything this creative.
Sam Altman
@sama
Peter Steinberger is joining OpenAI to drive the next generation of personal agents. He is a genius with a lot of amazing ideas about the future of very smart agents interacting with each other to do very useful things for people. We expect this will quickly become core to our product offerings.
OpenClaw will live in a foundation as an open source project that OpenAI will continue to support. The future is going to be extremely multi-agent and it's important to us to support open source as part of that. -
Robert Wright reposted
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
“Migration: it went too far, it was destabilizing,” says the Secretary of State who backed the coup in Honduras which led to mass violence and a surge of more than 500k Hondurans to the U.S.
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
The tech industry and the AI-skeptics in the MAGA base would make strange bedfellows on AI. But a sufficiently alarming AI incident could unite both groups around regulation—especially if Trump is persuaded that his legacy depends on it.
www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Last year a DC think tank director said to me: "I can't believe we're getting Trump and AI at the same time." I share her sentiments, but as I argue in the latest @NonzeroNews, there are circumstances under which Trump could wind up playing a constructive role in AI policy.
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
"Trump is just another business hack who hates regulation when it hurts him and likes it when it helps him." @robertwrighter argues that there are circumstances under which Trump could pivot and embrace AI regulation.
www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If the US doesn't start coordinating with China on AI policy long before Trump leaves office, I think the world will be in deep trouble. In the latest @NonzeroNews, I look at the chances of Trump playing a constructive role here, notwithstanding his history of opposing international governance. I argue that the situation isn't (quite) hopeless. www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Navigating the AI revolution will require international governance—and hence US-China rapprochement. In the latest issue of @NonzeroNews I ask whether Trump could, under the right circumstances, play a constructive role here. www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Is there a realistic scenario in which Trump winds up exerting a stabilizing influence on the unfolding AI revolution, however ironic that might seem? In the latest @NonzeroNews I argue that there is: www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Navigating the AI revolution will require international governance—and hence US-China rapprochement. So the US needs to get out of its Cold War II mindset pronto. In the latest issue of @NonzeroNews I ask whether Trump could, under the right circumstances, play a constructive role here.
www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
NEW: Trump + AI = ?
The case for hope. (Plus: graphs of the week)
www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
So is @DarioAmodei OK with the fact that his company's business model includes abetting flagrant violations of international law that get lots of people killed? We (especially us paid Claude subscribers) need to hear from @AnthropicAI about how this aligns with its values.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I'm trying to bring enlightenment to Grok. It's taken some work, but I'm making progress.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
Let's be clear. This was not a "slip of the tongue" in which Pelosi said the quiet part out loud (that the intent of sanctions is to devastate the population).
Rather, this was always the plan:
Deny that the intent of sanctions is to devastate the civilian population ("cripple" the economy), deny that sanctions are a key reason poverty rises and access to medicine is hindered.
UNTIL, that is, protests erupt and it looks like the target government is about to fall. Then, in a jujitsu move, credit sanctions for all the misery and all the collective punishment in order to take CREDIT for the pending regime change. -
Robert Wright reposted
Matt Duss
@mattduss
Americans need an alternative to the choice between “America first” unilateralism or “America is back” nostalgia.
New piece from @NancyGEO and me in @ForeignAffairs www.foreignaffairs.com/united-states/america-cursed-forei… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Nearly a year ago, I had coffee with someone who runs a DC think tank. We talked for a while about how much turbulence President Trump had created in the course of a mere month in office, and then we talked about how much turbulence AI could create in the coming years. Near the end of our conversation, she said, “I can’t believe we’re getting Trump and AI at the same time.” My sentiments exactly.
But are my sentiments on target? Is it really clear that, just because Trump has a knack for destabilizing more or less everything, he will exacerbate the naturally destabilizing effect of AI? Isn’t there some reasonably realistic scenario in which Trump winds up exerting a stabilizing influence on the unfolding AI revolution, however ironic that might seem?
This is a particularly apt week to examine the question of whether Trump’s and AI’s turbulent tendencies are indeed fated to interact destructively—or whether, instead, there is cause for hope.
Read the rest of this piece in the NonZero Newsletter: www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai -
Robert Wright reposted
a newsman
@a_newsman
“This is going to be a two month war not a two year war” - Bill Kristol 2003
Reuters
@Reuters
Exclusive: US military preparing for potentially weeks-long Iran operations www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/us-military-preparing-p… www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/us-military-preparing-p…
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: In the latest @NonZeroNews I argue that Trump could wind up exerting a constructive influence on the unfolding of the AI revolution. (I wouldn’t bet on it, but there’s a non-crazy scenario where it happens!) www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: In the latest @NonZeroNews I argue that Trump could wind up exerting a constructive influence on the unfolding of the AI revolution. (I wouldn’t bet on it, but there’s a non-crazy scenario where it happens!) www.nonzero.org/p/trump-ai
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"Every couple months a new model comes out and they're, like, 10% more productive than they were before."
@binarybits explains two reasons why it feels like AI progress is accelerating: normal people realizing they can create computer programs, and professional programmers developing the methodologies to get the most out of new tools.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Alex JER-dun
@alexjordanATL
for years, Americans were told US sanctions on countries like Iran were *not* meant to collectively punish civilians for their govt's actions. that they were *not* intended to immiserate people in the hopes they'd overthrow their leaders in desperation
now, they just...admit it!
POLITICO
@politico
Is there a way to bring about a regime fall in Iran without using American force?
"Use economic forces," @SpeakerPelosi told us in the #politicopub at #msc2025.
"There are ways that can cripple their economy. And some of those have been in the works." -
Robert Wright reposted
Prof Ben Saul - UN SR Human Rights & Counterterror
@profbensaul
I join UN experts in condemning a new US executive order imposing a fuel blockade on Cuba, on the abusive pretext that Cuba supports transnational terrorism, and adding to the existing abusive "State sponsor of terrorism" designation. These measures violate Cubans' human rights
UN Special Procedures
@UN_SPExperts
UN experts condemn #us executive order imposing fuel blockade on #cuba: as the country is already experiencing severe energy shortages, interfering with fuel imports could lead to a severe humanitarian crisis with knock-on effects for essential services.
www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2026/02/un-experts-condem… -
Robert Wright reposted
Rep. Jim McGovern
@RepMcGovern
NEWS: today I introduced a bill to repeal the U.S. embargo against Cuba.
For over six decades, the U.S. has embraced failed, obsolete, Cold-War thinking towards Cuba. Our 60+ year embargo has been ineffective and counterproductive—it hurts the Cuban people, it strengthens hardliners, it gives rise to more refugees, and it undercuts our standing in the world.
We have tried the same thing for over 60 years—and it has failed for over 60 years.
Let's try something different—let's open things up!
Let’s lift the embargo, giving US businesses, entrepreneurs, tourists, and universities more access.
Let’s push for freedom and democracy through diplomacy and engagement.
Let’s let Cubans who live on the island decide their own future—not Marco Rubio or Donald Trump.
mcgovern.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=40… -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Agency, AI, and the MAGA Impulse | @NikitaSPetrov argues MAGA and similar movements are collective responses to a felt lack of agency. @robertwrighter warns AI is about to make that feeling universal. Plus: Spanish rituals as a survival model, the "Claude Code hangover," and Bob's case for slowing AI development down. youtu.be/3zc1PbaJ0O4?t=106
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Midas Project
@TheMidasProj
The super PAC backed by OpenAI president Greg Brockman has funded a video blaming 'doomers' for fearmongering about AI job loss.
The video centers around @geoffreyhinton's 2016 claim about automating radiology.
But @OpenAI CEO Sam Altman himself used this example in 2019...
Build American AI
@BuildAmericanAI
It's Mythbusting Monday - where we take one big Doomer claim about AI and run it through a reality check.
This week's myth: AI is going to wipe out high-skill and white-collar jobs.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed talking to @binarybits, publisher of the Understanding AI newsletter, about whether AI advance is indeed accelerating, as many say--and if so, by how much. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=CguxijTAUrU
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is the Singularity Near? | @robertwrighter and Timothy B. Lee (@binarybits), author of the Understanding AI newsletter, discuss recent AI developments (more autonomous agents, more automated coding in the labs, Moltbook, etc.) that have fostered a sense that things are speeding up.
youtu.be/CguxijTAUrU?t=142 -
Robert Wright reposted
Harlan Stewart
@HumanHarlan
Three years later and we have 0/3 of these
Sam Altman
@sama
things we need for a good AGI future:
1) the technical ability to align a superintelligence
2) sufficient coordination among most of the leading AGI efforts
3) an effective global regulatory framework including democratic governance -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews, I look at four seemingly unrelated stories—including Moltbook, Nasdaq turbulence, and WaPo’s layoffs—that show how broad the age of agentic AI will be.
www.nonzero.org/p/the-ai-tremors-are-real -
Robert Wright reposted
a newsman
@a_newsman
This was the Rubio State Department’s response to an op-ed written in an American student newspaper
Secretary Marco Rubio
@SecRubio
The sentencing of Jimmy Lai in Hong Kong is an unjust and tragic conclusion to this case. We urge the authorities to grant Mr. Lai humanitarian parole.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews, I look at four seemingly unrelated stories—including Moltbook, Nasdaq turbulence, and WaPo’s layoffs—that show how broad the impact of agentic AI will be. www.nonzero.org/p/the-ai-tremors-are-real
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
If you want a sense of how dire the situation is in Cuba now, here is a list of the measures the Cuban president says the nation has started taking to try to keep people in nursing homes and hospitals alive while Trump and Rubio choke the island of essentials, which the Cuban government is now referring to a "genocidal blockade" -- which is absolutely will be if it is allowed to persist.
Cuba is not at war with anybody yet we are starving them...because why? Because Marco Rubio wants to?
From the office of the Cuban presidency:
This Friday, measures adopted by the country’s leadership were announced in response to the nation’s current situation, amid the intensification of the #genocidalblockade.
⚡| Energy Sector
•Prioritize available fuel for essential services: public health, water supply, food production, defense, and hard-currency-generating activities.
•Continue and accelerate the installation programs for solar photovoltaic parks and solar modules for households.
•Speed up the delivery and installation of solar modules sold to Health and Education workers.
•Install 5,000 solar modules in isolated homes and plan an additional 5,000 for social centers (nursing homes, children’s homes).
•Expand incentives for the installation of Renewable Energy Sources (RES) in companies and households.
•Concentrate core administrative activities from Monday to Thursday.
•Adjust fuel sales to the public until the situation normalizes.
•Continue developing domestic oil production.
🚚| Transport Sector
•Ensure fuel for port and airport operations, imports/exports, and the transport of vital cargo (food, fuel, medical supplies).
•Reduce the Nueva Gerona–Batabanó ferry frequency to two trips per week (Tuesdays and Saturdays).
•Extend the frequency of national passenger trains to once every 8 days (starting February 8). Temporarily suspend other rail services.
•Reduce national bus departures, maintaining a basic daily service from Havana. Suspend the waiting list service.
•Offer full refunds within 30 days for tickets for canceled services (rail or maritime).
•Maintain guaranteed Medibus services (for patients) and transportation for students and teaching staff.
•Reorganize local public transportation according to fuel availability in each territory.
•In Havana, establish a new transportation service specifically for Health personnel.
•Strengthen the electric mobility strategy: install solar charging stations and distribute electric vehicles.
👩🏫| Education Sector (General Education)
•Prioritize early childhood: maintain the operation of daycare centers (possibly with reduced hours).
•Maintain in-person classes in Primary Education with flexible schedules, allowing early dismissal due to transportation needs.
•For Lower Secondary, Pre-University, and Technical Education:
•Implement blended-learning or condensed schedules (by days or subject blocks), decided locally.
•Give special attention to grades marking the start and end of cycles (e.g., 7th and 9th grade, 12th grade).
•Temporarily redistribute enrollment from some IPVCE schools to urban pre-university schools.
•For students in the final years of technical/pedagogical programs, shift to a training model in schools near their homes, with periodic in-person sessions.
•Resume and adapt the “essential content” experience used during COVID-19.
•Accelerate the delivery of solar panels to teachers.
👨🏾🏫| Higher Education Sector
•General transition to blended learning, adapted by degree program and university.
•Transport students back to their provinces of origin.
•Support teaching activities through institutions in the student’s territory (CUM, branch campuses, workplaces).
•Strengthen faculty in municipalities by relocating professors from central campuses.
•Use telework as the main modality, with limited ICT support due to the energy situation.
•Prioritize strategic research and development projects remotely.
•Ensure completion of studies (final exams, thesis defenses) for students close to graduation.
•Reorganize the admissions process for Higher Education.
•Postpone the “University 2026” event.
👩🏿💻| Labor and Social Security Sector
•Issue no new labor regulations, applying existing contingency rules.
•Promote telework and remote work modalities.
•Adjust work schedules according to the needs of each workforce.
•Reassign workers to key economic activities or areas of social interest.
•If necessary, apply temporary work interruption with guaranteed pay equivalent to the basic salary during the first month.
🚜| Food and Water Sector
•Increase food production at the territorial level, prioritizing productive hubs with the greatest potential.
•Promote alliances among all forms of productive management (state and non-state) to address commercialization and prices.
•Use Renewable Energy Sources (RES) in food production.
•Allocate fuel to guarantee essential water pumping.
•Concentrate industry on producing and supplying chemical products for water treatment.
➕| Other Sectors
•Tourism: Design a plan to reduce energy consumption and consolidate facilities, taking advantage of the high season.
•Culture and Sports: Make adjustments to programs and activities.
•Science, Technology, and Environment: Guarantee resources for early warning systems.
•Special Education: Do not modify its operation; create a special scheme to guarantee services due to its high sensitivity. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
There's a palpable sense within the AI community that things are speeding up. Many in the community--not just AI safety hawks--worry that the public doesn't understand how dramatic the impact will be. In @NonzeroNews I look at recent evidence of large impending impact.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
There are obviously a lot of shameful moments in American history, but Mexico being forced to send militarily protected humanitarian relief to a Cuban population we are starving for now reason, while we all stuff our faces with chicken wings, has to rank among our low moments
Drop Site
@DropSiteNews
🇲🇽 🇨🇺 Mexico has dispatched two Navy logistics ships from Veracruz to Cuba carrying more than 814 tons of humanitarian aid for civilians, under orders from President Claudia Sheinbaum. The shipment includes staple foods and hygiene supplies, with the Papaloapan transporting mixed goods and the Isla Holbox carrying powdered milk. The vessels are due to arrive in about four days. Mexican authorities said another 1,500 tons of powdered milk and beans are slated for future delivery, describing the operation as part of Mexico’s ongoing humanitarian support to Cuba in a statement.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
It’s common to think of AI-driven job loss as something that happens within companies that adopt AI. But last week’s Nasdaq turbulence suggests a second scenario: whole companies ceasing to exist because AI renders them superfluous.
More below: www.nonzero.org/p/the-ai-tremors-are-real -
Robert Wright reposted
Matt Duss
@mattduss
Once again, no discussion of the actual legal basis for the US strike on Iran (there isn’t one), just the baked-in assumption that the US has the special privilege of bombing wherever, whenever. Crazy.
Face The Nation
@FaceTheNation
On Iran potentially rebuilding its nuclear capabilities, Sen. Mark Warner, says “Iran, as has been indicated in public documents, is trying to reconstitute.”
“What I fear is that we don’t have the ability to bring the full power of pressure against Iran. A few weeks back, when the Iranian people were bravely in the streets, and there might’ve been a moment, we couldn’t strike because the aircraft carrier that was usually in the Mediterranean was off the coast of Venezuela during the blockade there.” -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews, I look at seemingly unrelated stories—including Moltbook, Nasdaq turbulence, and WaPo's mass layoffs—that show how agentic AI is starting to reshape the world.
www.nonzero.org/p/the-ai-tremors-are-real -
Robert Wright reposted
2. Grandpa
@pdubya62
"The reason there’s valid concern about AI becoming a vehicle for advertising is that LLMs have great persuasive power and people can develop strong and trusting relationships with them; and, conceivably, nearly exclusive relationships with them, as the LLMs do more and more of the things that humans and human institutions—including newspapers—used to do for us."
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
There's a palpable sense within the AI community that things are speeding up. Many in the community--not just AI safety hawks--worry that the public doesn't understand how dramatic the impact will be. In @NonzeroNews I look at recent evidence of large impending impact.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
There's a palpable sense within the AI community that things are speeding up. Many in the community--not just AI safety hawks--worry that the public doesn't understand how dramatic the impact will be. In @NonzeroNews I look at recent evidence of large impending impact.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ryan Grim
@ryangrim
Zero fuel has entered Cuba since December. Staggering level of cruelty.
COMBATE |🇵🇷
@upholdreality
Cuba's Díaz-Canel: "The naval blockade against Venezuela began in December. Since that date, no fuel has entered this country."
Council of Ministers has prepared an updated decree based on the 1990s Special Period framework, the emergency measures enacted after USSR collapse -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
There's a palpable sense within the AI community that things are speeding up. And many in the community--not just safety hawks--are worried that the public doesn't understand how dramatic the impact will be. In the latest @NonzeroNews I look at some recent evidence of large impending impact. www.nonzero.org/p/the-ai-tremors-are-real
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My latest piece in @NonzeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/the-ai-tremors-are-real
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
NEW: One sign of a momentous technology is that its impact shows up in different venues, and in different forms, and these manifestations may have no obvious connection to one another—or even, in some cases, to the technology itself. @robertwrighter
www.nonzero.org/p/the-ai-tremors-are-real -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My latest piece in @NonzeroNews. www.nonzero.org/p/the-ai-tremors-are-real
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed this conversation with Andrew (a NonZero alumnus!) and Curt.
The American Conservative
@amconmag
A new crossover episode with @NonzeroPods: @robertwrighter, @AKDay89, and @CurtMills discuss the Iran crisis, AI's threat to social stability, and signs that China will invade Taiwan. youtu.be/O3u3q5mc_EQ
-
Robert Wright reposted
Fr. Bill Dailey, CSC
@wrdcsc
From the moment he talked about a "Mexican judge" and (dishonestly and for political gain) denied knowing who David Duke was as a candidate in 2016 we have known he does not view human beings as having equal dignity. That's what racism is, that's who racists are.
Kaveh Shahrooz کاوه شهروز
@kshahrooz
There's no CEO or university president in America who would keep their job if they posted something like this.
America will one day need to have a reckoning over this era. -
Robert Wright reposted
The American Conservative
@amconmag
A new crossover episode with @NonzeroPods: @robertwrighter, @AKDay89, and @CurtMills discuss the Iran crisis, AI's threat to social stability, and signs that China will invade Taiwan. youtu.be/O3u3q5mc_EQ
-
Robert Wright reposted
Peter Wildeford🇺🇸🚀
@peterwildeford
10/ The ASL framework has three structural problems:
- Thresholds are set by Anthropic
- Evaluations are run by Anthropic
- Determination is made Anthropic
AI companies grade their own homework.
What we actually need are mandatory eval frameworks. -
Robert Wright reposted
Liron Shapira
@liron
.@emilymbender tries to rebut the claim that AI is useful to individuals 🙈
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
First the Melania documentary, now this. Has Bezos entered some kind of atrocity perpetration contest?
-
Robert Wright reposted
Matt Duss
@mattduss
Think of all the extraordinary talent let go from the Washington Post today while this clown still has a job.
Marc Thiessen
@marcthiessen
Trump faces a stark choice: He can give the Iranian regime a lifeline or put it on the path to destruction. He can repeat the mistakes of Biden and Obama, or take his place with Reagan and FDR a president who transformed the world.
Free gift link here
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/02/04/iran-attack-pr… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Ishaan's WorldView was the rarest thing in MSM: a column that consistently illuminates the perspectives of people outside of America.
Ishaan Tharoor
@ishaantharoor
I have been laid off today from the @washingtonpost, along with most of the International staff and so many other wonderful colleagues. I’m heartbroken for our newsroom and especially for the peerless journalists who served the Post internationally — editors and correspondents who have been my friends and collaborators for almost 12 years. It’s been an honor to work with them.
I launched the WorldView column in January 2017 to help readers better understand the world and America’s place in it and I’m grateful for the half a million loyal subscribers who tuned into the column several times a week over the years. -
Robert Wright reposted
Evan A. Feigenbaum
@EvanFeigenbaum
The @WashPost has now laid off its Asia editor, its New Delhi bureau chief, its Sydney bureau chief, its Cairo bureau chief, the entire Middle East reporting team, China correspondents, Iran correspondents, Turkey correspondents, and many more. The world is becoming less America-centric by the minute while the United States is becoming more America-centric than ever. It is just a depressing yet somehow perfect summation of our current moment that one of the most important newspapers in the history of the country - one that has actually shaped the history of the United States - doesn't think reporting on the world is of any use anymore. What an utterly perfect encapsulation of where we have arrived.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ishaan Tharoor
@ishaantharoor
I have been laid off today from the @washingtonpost, along with most of the International staff and so many other wonderful colleagues. I’m heartbroken for our newsroom and especially for the peerless journalists who served the Post internationally — editors and correspondents who have been my friends and collaborators for almost 12 years. It’s been an honor to work with them.
I launched the WorldView column in January 2017 to help readers better understand the world and America’s place in it and I’m grateful for the half a million loyal subscribers who tuned into the column several times a week over the years. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Worth keeping in mind.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
My case can be made if people just watch the episode. I strongly encourage you to just watch through and decide for yourself whether Rob was mansplaining and dehumanizing them, and assess how they deal when he brings up other views of the very contentious debate they're representing one side of www.youtube.com/watch?v=MwfSCCo6jXs
-
Robert Wright reposted
Harlan Stewart
@HumanHarlan
AI industry leaders sometimes warn that their competitors might use powerful AI to overthrow the government and become dictator of the world.
If you could only choose ONE of them to have complete autocratic control over the world, who do you pick? -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My (so-called) friend @paulbloomatyale perpetrated a cruel hoax on me at the beginning of this conversation. But I forgave him and we proceeded to get to the bottom of both the Epstein thing and the Moltbook thing. www.youtube.com/watch?v=18ejsoGixUE
-
Robert Wright reposted
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
Bender and Hanna (and Gebru) keep doubling down and accusing me of mansplaining as well, so I'll state my simple case for what's happening here:
If Bender were presenting the agreed-on expert opinion of her field and Rob were disagreeing, then yes Rob would be mansplaining, but she's actually presenting one of several contentious accounts of meaning, so Rob has a right to ask about how she responds to the others.
It's obviously fine to forcefully argue for her contentious side. There's no final agreement about this in linguistics. What it's not fine to do is imply that anyone who wants to know about any of the other interpretations of language must therefore be ignoring what she's saying because she's a woman. This is a very silly way of steamrolling a debate where there are brilliant people on every side.
I have not seen either of them actually give a specific example where Rob mansplained here: www.youtube.com/watch?v=MwfSCCo6jXs -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"Oh, go to the library!"
@alexhanna and @emilymbender clash with @robertwrighter over the utility of LLMs as learning tools.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
NEW: Good Trump-related News!
Plus: US-China arms-selling race; AI impact grows.
www.nonzero.org/p/good-trump-related-news?v=1 -
Robert Wright reposted
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
This series of reactions from Emily Bender and Alex Hanna has been crazy to watch.
There were zero instances in the episode where Rob mansplained to them or steamrolled them. Zero. He politely offered a summary of a mainstream understanding of LLMs explicitly so that they could explain their case and why they disagreed, and they read this as an attack. This is a ridiculous way to behave as academics arguing for a very contested take on language and meaning. There are entire research programs built on the premise that distributional patterns do capture aspects of meaning, but they're saying Rob was "mansplaining" because he dared to assume in the conversation that those fields might possibly be legit.
Rob here wasn't "whining" that ChatGPT was useful. He was giving an extremely mild personal anecdote about where a chatbot had been useful to him. See for yourself where it happens: youtu.be/MwfSCCo6jXs?t=3529
Would very strongly recommend watching the episode and contrasting it with their assessment www.youtube.com/watch?v=MwfSCCo6jXs -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
Trump doesn't always chicken out. He chickens out when he faces real blowback.
@robertwrighter
www.nonzero.org/p/good-trump-related-news?v=1 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My latest piece in @NonzeroNews. Just looking at that picture kind of cheers you up, doesn't it? www.nonzero.org/p/good-trump-related-news
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Grand Unified Theory of MAGA | @robertwrighter and @NikitaSPetrov discuss whether MAGA can be seen as a coherent global phenomenon. Plus: The paradox of international nationalism; Burkean conservatism vs. Silicon Valley libertarianism; and the crumbling rules-based order.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"That's Bullshit"
@robertwrighter, @emilymbender, and @alexhanna clash over the claim AI systems are "black boxes."This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Maybe because one way to distract people from the fact that your government has killed protesters is to bomb a country on the grounds that its government killed protesters.
Shibley Telhami
@ShibleyTelhami
Remind me again, why are we gearing up for a potentially devastating war with Iran?
-
Robert Wright reposted
Glenn Loury
@GlennLoury
Ok. I'll admit to being damned proud of this piece!
Freddie Sayers
@freddiesayers
Important essay by the great @GlennLoury, leading critic of woke, on the sad adoption of identity politics by the Right.
In particular, the confused thinking of @elonmusk, who is importing a South African understanding of race into America.
unherd.com/2026/01/elon-musks-apartheid-politics/ -
Robert Wright reposted
Samuel Hammond 🦉
@hamandcheese
This conversation would be frustrating if it wasn't so comical.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Case Against AI | @alexhanna and @emilymbender, co-authors of the book The AI Con, join @robertwrighter to discuss and debate AI—including whether LLMs are more than “stochastic parrots” (a term Emily coined), AI's present and future impact on society, and more.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I enjoyed trying to convince the coiner of the term "stochastic parrots" that this isn't an apt label for LLMs. You can watch here or listen on @NonzeroPods. I think you'll agree that I was fighting an uphill battle. www.youtube.com/watch?v=MwfSCCo6jXs
-
Robert Wright reposted
Andy Masley
@AndyMasley
The most confusing part of this episode to me (and there were many) was when Bender very confidently talks as if pretty popular mainstream ideas in philosophy of language are obviously wrong. She has a way stronger background in language than I do, so I'm inclined to think I'm misunderstand what she means, but I don't understand how her point can make sense if she's not outright dismissing accounts of language like Quine's as crazy. I could be wrong here, not at all my area of expertise.
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I tried to convince the coiner of the term "stochastic parrots" that this isn't an apt label for large language models. Can't say I entirely succeeded.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Case Against AI | @alexhanna and @emilymbender, co-authors of the book The AI Con, join @robertwrighter to discuss and debate AI—including whether LLMs are more than “stochastic parrots” (a term Emily coined), AI's present and future impact on society, and more.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I tried to convince the coiner of the term "stochastic parrots" that this isn't an apt label for large language models. Can't say I entirely succeeded.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Case Against AI | @alexhanna and @emilymbender, co-authors of the book The AI Con, join @robertwrighter to discuss and debate AI—including whether LLMs are more than “stochastic parrots” (a term Emily coined), AI's present and future impact on society, and more.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Case Against AI | @alexhanna and @emilymbender, co-authors of the book The AI Con, join @robertwrighter to discuss and debate AI—including whether LLMs are more than “stochastic parrots” (a term Emily coined), AI's present and future impact on society, and more.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Which is worse: someone with evil principles, or someone with no principles at all?
@robertwrighter, @dbessner, and @dwdavison discuss:This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
New World Disorder | @dwdavison and @dbessner of the @AmPrestigePod join NonZero’s @robertwrighter to discuss Trump’s latest foreign policy eruptions.
youtu.be/em3K1pqOers?t=120 -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
"Hassabis’s past pronouncements make it clear that institutionalized international cooperation on AI really has long been a dream of his and indeed may lie near the center of his AI ideology. Amodei has made it clear that somewhere near the center of his AI ideology lies a very different kind of goal: western hegemony over China."
More from @robertwrighter:
www.nonzero.org/p/which-ai-titan-should-you-root-for -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
It now seems possible the first shot you hear wasn't fired at Pretti, which would make this tweet factually inaccurate (the 'hands and knees' part). So I'm deleting it. But the takeaway stands: Trump is openly encouraging lawless & lethal policing, and a few Republicans of conscience could help stop this slide. (And shooting Pretti was in any event unwarranted and demands an investigation.)
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
PS: The scenario now being advanced is that the officer who took Pretti's gun then fired it into the ground--accidentally, I presume--after which two other officers started shooting Pretti as he tried to stand up. I guess it's possible that one of those officers thought Pretti still had a gun, but it's hard to believe that the other one did; the reason he had drawn his gun in the first place is that he was watching at very close range when Pretti's gun was discovered and immediately removed. And he seems (I emphasize *seems* because I haven't done a dissertation-level analysis of the video and won't have time to do one today) to shoot Pretti in the back as he's starting to stand up. I hope to eventually get a clearer picture of what exactly happened. Meanwhile, again: If you live in a country where something like this doesn't get a thorough investigation, you're not living in a country run by decent people. If all or even most of the Republicans in Congress who understand this now do the right thing--get together and decide to present a united front and then speak out--they could change history.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nathan Labenz
@labenz
If I work at a frontier AI lab that works with the US federal government, I’m taking next week off in protest
AI researchers don’t seem to realize how much power they have
If we’re going to race to AGI, we should at least make sure we’re worthy winners -
Robert Wright reposted
Nathan Bernard
@nathanTbernard
ICE agent in Portland, Maine tells legal observer she is a domestic terrorist for peacefully recording him, adds her to "nice little database"
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Mark E. Merritt
@markemerritt
I wish more of us internalized how biased we are in judging ourselves. We overcredit our contributions, underweight faults, & spot these distortions more easily in others. Adjusting for this would make interactions more non-zero across all human networks/orgs
@robertwrighter -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
For Trump, making threats and backing down is not embarrassing. It just means two days of headlines instead of one. @robertwrighter
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
"Whether the latest AI capabilities are deployed responsibly depends partly on who is deploying them. This would be true in any event, but it’s especially true when you have a president who is against meaningfully regulating AI." @robertwrighter
www.nonzero.org/p/which-ai-titan-should-you-root-for -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My latest piece in @NonzeroNews. The long wait is over for @demishassabis, @sama, and @DarioAmodei. They can now find out which one of them has been awarded my coveted nod of approval. www.nonzero.org/p/which-ai-titan-should-you-root-for
-
Robert Wright reposted
Billy Binion
@billybinion
A judge has unsealed the memo ordering the detention & deportation of Rümeysa Öztürk. It confirms the sole evidence against her was that she co-wrote an op-ed the government disliked.
Here she is being arrested by men in plainclothes. Over an op-ed.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Negar Mortazavi
@NegarMortazavi
New wave of online harassment and smear campaigns combined with physical threats has started against Iranian diaspora journalists and analysts similar to the horrific attacks of 2022.
We are receiving threats to our safety, intimidating warnings, incitements of violence, wishes of physical harm, all combined with the usual smears that paint us as targets.
Some known activists and influencers have joined these online campaigns, sharing dangerous smears against us for millions of followers on social media. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
New World Disorder | @dwdavison and @dbessner of the @AmPrestigePod join NonZero’s @robertwrighter to discuss Trump’s latest foreign policy eruptions.
youtu.be/em3K1pqOers?t=120 -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"They go to sleep at night saying, 'if it's gonna be anybody, it's gonna be me.'"
@danfaggella tells @robertwrighter why he thinks tech leaders won't stop the race to AGI.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed my conversation with @danfaggella. Some people think the AI succession scenario is completely crazy. I wish I agreed, but I don't.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
AI After Us: The "Succession" Scenario | @robertwrighter and @danfaggella, founder of market research firm Emerj Artificial Intelligence Research and host of the podcast The Trajectory, discuss human destiny in a world of post-human intelligence.
youtu.be/xTCTwd6Qc9s?t=90 -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
In a discussion about AI successionism, @robertwrighter asks @danfaggella what scenarios he would like to avoid.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
AI After Us: The "Succession" Scenario | @robertwrighter and @danfaggella, founder of market research firm Emerj Artificial Intelligence Research and host of the podcast The Trajectory, discuss human destiny in a world of post-human intelligence.
youtu.be/xTCTwd6Qc9s?t=90 -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
AI After Us: The "Succession" Scenario | @robertwrighter and @danfaggella, founder of market research firm Emerj Artificial Intelligence Research and host of the podcast The Trajectory, discuss human destiny in a world of post-human intelligence.
youtu.be/xTCTwd6Qc9s?t=90 -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
Trump’s full-throated defense of the Renee Good shooting appears to be a political miscalculation. Since the shooting, his approval rating has dropped to 42.2%—the lowest level since his inauguration a year ago.
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
During his first term, Trump altered the course of Iran’s history... He closed a path that might have led to a freer and more prosperous Iran and opened a path that led to lots of dead Iranian protesters and may yet lead to much worse.
More from @robertwrighter: -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
Note the pattern seen in Venezuela, Cuba, and Iran: We impose sanctions that immiserate the people and then cite immiserated people as high on the list of reasons the regime must fall.
More from @robertwrighter:
www.nonzero.org/p/the-iranian-blood-on-trumps-and-bidens -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
Iran hawks claim that sanctions weaken the Iranian regime. In reality, sanctions create black markets, and black markets are controlled by military elites.
www.nonzero.org/p/the-iranian-blood-on-trumps-and-bidens -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
Trump’s withdrawal from the JCPOA didn't just hurt the Iranian economy; it vindicated Iranian hardliners who warned that the US couldn't be trusted.
More from @robertwrighter:
www.nonzero.org/p/the-iranian-blood-on-trumps-and-bidens -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
NEW: The Iranian Blood on Trump's (and Biden's) Hands
Plus: AI escalation; Bari Weiss watch; the Renee Good effect.
www.nonzero.org/p/the-iranian-blood-on-trumps-and-bidens -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My latest piece in the NonZero Newsletter: www.nonzero.org/p/the-iranian-blood-on-trumps-and-bidens
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My favorite tidbit from the excellent @POLITICOMag piece about the implosion of the University of Austin (aka "Bari Weiss U") www.politico.com/news/magazine/2026/01/16/civil-war-unive…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
PRESIDENT TRUMP: We will take very strong action [toward Iran if the government starts hanging protesters]. If they do such a thing, we will take very strong action.
JOURNALIST: And this strong action you’re talking about, what’s the endgame?
TRUMP: The endgame is to win. I like winning.
On Tuesday, the same day President Trump gave us the above window into the nature of his concern for Iranian protesters, he posted this on social media: “Iranian Patriots, KEEP PROTESTING - TAKE OVER YOUR INSTITUTIONS!!!... HELP IS ON ITS WAY.”
This post, coming after reports that thousands of protesters had been killed by the regime currently controlling those institutions, may strike you as reckless. You may think, “If the protesters take his advice, he’s morally responsible for any additional deaths that ensue.”
I certainly think that. But Trump’s culpability runs much deeper. During his first term, he altered the course of Iran’s history, strengthening the regime’s hardliners, intensifying the economic suffering of Iranians, and dimming the prospects for rapprochement between Iran and the West. He closed a path that might have led to a freer and more prosperous Iran and opened a path that led to lots of dead Iranian protesters and may yet lead to much worse.
Here was the state of play when Trump entered office nine years ago:
President Obama had performed the quasi-heroic feat of...
You can read the rest here, in the latest edition of @NonZeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/the-iranian-blood-on-trumps-and-bidens -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The net negative on Trump's approval rating has increased by FIVE POINTS since the Renee Good killing--from -8.2 to -13.2. (RealClearPolitics average of polls.) This is the worst number he's had since he was sworn in a year ago. Would someone please point this out to him?
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Had a great chat with OG podcaster @pescami about how the digital ground keeps shifting beneath the feet of podcasters, substackers, and other indie media types. You can watch here or listen on the NonZero podcast.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Past and Future of Digital Media | @robertwrighter talks with Mike Pesca (@pescami), host of the long-running daily podcast The Gist, about new technological challenges to independent journalists and the perils of opining on Israel.
youtu.be/aRQjg31lEi8?t=110 -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Past and Future of Digital Media | @robertwrighter talks with Mike Pesca (@pescami), host of the long-running daily podcast The Gist, about new technological challenges to independent journalists and the perils of opining on Israel.
youtu.be/aRQjg31lEi8?t=110 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Since the day Renee Good was killed, Trump's approval rating has gone from a net negative of 8.3 to a net negative of 11.4 in the Real Clear Politics aggregate of polls. I hope somebody points this out to him.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Hooman Majd
@hmajd
Important analysis. And worrying, since possibility of civil war in Iran should terrify.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Mario
@PawlowskiMario
ICE didn’t “enforce the law” in Santa Ana, they maimed this kid and took his eye.🤬
Six hours of surgery pulling out glass, plastic, and metal. One shard stopped 7mm from his artery.
Left eye: gone forever.
And spare me the patriotic excuses, this is commie-Nazi shit.
I saw this under actual communism, now I am seeing this here in America. -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
The Minneapolis Shooting Rorschach Test | @robertwrighter and @paulbloomatyale discuss the killing of Renee Good—and what it says about the state of the nation. Plus: Trump & Hitler compared (carefully); Elon & a madman compared (less so); Should professors fear AI? youtu.be/CCTJncO5ueQ?t=156
-
Robert Wright reposted
Sina Toossi
@SinaToossi
I think ignoring pro-government mobilization in Iran weakens ability to provide realistic analysis.
The key is to separate:
-regime capacity from regime legitimacy
-short-term survival from long-term stability
-protest movement setback from protest movement defeat
A key part of Iran’s political reality today—one that shouldn’t be ignored for the sake of wishful thinking—is that the state has managed to bring sizable pro-government demonstrations onto the streets across multiple cities, even amid its brutal crackdown.
This of course does not confer legitimacy on the Islamic Republic, nor does it erase the scale of repression, the hundreds confirmed killed so far, or the horrific violence obscured by internet shutdowns.
But it does matter for assessing the immediate viability of protests or the efficacy of a US military attack on the country.
As of now, there are no confirmed reports of major elite splits or security-force defections, though under conditions of near-total information blackout it is impossible to gauge the depth of internal fractures.
What is visible is a state that has doubled down, relying on repression and foreign intervention narratives to rally its base.
This suggests that a critical mass sufficient to topple the system has not yet formed.
But it would be a grave mistake to conclude from this that the Islamic Republic can simply restore the prior, already highly volatile balance that existed between itself and society.
The protesters’ message to the ruling elite has been unmistakable: coercion can no longer compel consent. Fear barriers have been breached. Iranians have en mass risked bullets to demand change.
The state may suppress this round of protests, but without meaningful political and economic transformation, the conditions that produced them will persist.
What lies ahead won't be stability for it, but a system limping forward—more brittle and increasingly vulnerable to the next eruption of public anger.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Trump's disregard for the sovereignty of other nations (except the powerful ones) is one of several things he has in common with Hitler. And, as I argue in @NonzeroNews, some of these things--such as a deep respect for the law of the jungle--make Trump's approach to both foreign and domestic policy dangerous.
www.nonzero.org/p/some-useful-trump-hitler-comparisons -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
It’s hard to explain the escalating campaign against Venezuela—boat bombings, port bombings, and finally invasion—without invoking a visceral, rather than rational, motivation. My latest in @NonzeroNews:
www.nonzero.org/p/some-useful-trump-hitler-comparisons -
Robert Wright reposted
timappelo
@timappelo
At last, a nuanced comparison: "[Trump] has enough in common with Hitler to set in motion a very negative kind of positive-feedback cycle and then happily do what he can to sustain it, making good use, at key moments, of his contempt for the principles of liberal democracy."
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Trump isn’t Hitler. But, as I argue in the latest @NonzeroNews, there are ominous similarities between the two that bear not just on the domestic situation but also on foreign policy--including their underlying "might makes right" philosophy.
www.nonzero.org/p/some-useful-trump-hitler-comparisons -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The killing of Renee Good in Minneapolis by masked ICE agents points to a path by which America could get closer to Hitler-level authoritarianism.
In the latest @NonzeroNews, I look at the dangerous "positive-feedback cycle" that Trump seems happy to sustain. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
From my latest piece in @NonzeroNews ( www.nonzero.org/p/some-useful-trump-hitler-comparisons )
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Trump isn’t Hitler. But, as I argue in the latest @NonzeroNews, there are ominous similarities between the two that bear not just on the domestic situation but also on foreign policy--including their underlying "might makes right" philosophy.
www.nonzero.org/p/some-useful-trump-hitler-comparisons -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My latest piece in @NonzeroNews: www.nonzero.org/p/some-useful-trump-hitler-comparisons
Post not available here, view on X
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
From my @NonzeroNews piece (www.nonzero.org/p/some-useful-trump-hitler-comparisons) :
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
From my latest piece in @NonzeroNews (www.nonzero.org/p/some-useful-trump-hitler-comparisons):
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
It took about three seconds for the masked ICE agent who approached Renee Good's car to escalate from "Get out of the car" to "Get out of the fucking car!" It was when he reached her car and immediately grabbed her door handle (at the moment he said 'fucking car') that she started to back up. Now imagine that he'd acted like a real cop is trained to act--walked up to her (open) window and engaged in civil conversation (maybe saying, Ma'am, could you please get out of the car?). And imagine he hadn't been wearing a mask--and maybe was even dressed more like a police officer, complete with a badge featuring his ID number. Chances are high that Good wouldn't have freaked out and tried to flea. But Trump--and Stephen Miller, who I gather is the de facto head of ICE--have clearly signaled that they not only tolerate but actually applaud thuggish, intimidating behavior directed at Americans who are perceived as Trump's ideological enemies. You won't hear any complaints from them about an armed, masked man dressed like a DIY militiaman yelling "Get out of your fucking car!" at a woman in her thirties who, so far as I can tell, hadn't done anything wrong. (Far from obstructing the agent's pickup truck, she had paused before turning onto the street and politely waved it on, leaving it plenty of room to pass. If it had done so rather than stop, she'd still be alive.) Trump and Miller bear some measure of moral responsibility for the death of Renee Good. And the political reaction against them in the wake of this tragedy should prominently include specific demands about changing the rules of conduct for ICE agents--and also the rules of apparel, starting with a ban on those creepy masks.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Meghan Daum
@meghan_daum
Based on what can be seen and known thus far, I agree. .
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
It took about three seconds for the masked ICE agent who approached Renee Good's car to escalate from "Get out of the car" to "Get out of the fucking car!" It was when he reached her car and immediately grabbed her door handle (at the moment he said 'fucking car') that she started to back up. Now imagine that he'd acted like a real cop is trained to act--walked up to her (open) window and engaged in civil conversation (maybe saying, Ma'am, could you please get out of the car?). And imagine he hadn't been wearing a mask--and maybe was even dressed more like a police officer, complete with a badge featuring his ID number. Chances are high that Good wouldn't have freaked out and tried to flea. But Trump--and Stephen Miller, who I gather is the de facto head of ICE--have clearly signaled that they not only tolerate but actually applaud thuggish, intimidating behavior directed at Americans who are perceived as Trump's ideological enemies. You won't hear any complaints from them about an armed, masked man dressed like a DIY militiaman yelling "Get out of your fucking car!" at a woman in her thirties who, so far as I can tell, hadn't done anything wrong. (Far from obstructing the agent's pickup truck, she had paused before turning onto the street and politely waved it on, leaving it plenty of room to pass. If it had done so rather than stop, she'd still be alive.) Trump and Miller bear some measure of moral responsibility for the death of Renee Good. And the political reaction against them in the wake of this tragedy should prominently include specific demands about changing the rules of conduct for ICE agents--and also the rules of apparel, starting with a ban on those creepy masks.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
It took about three seconds for the masked ICE agent who approached Renee Good's car to escalate from "Get out of the car" to "Get out of the fucking car!" It was when he reached her car and immediately grabbed her door handle (at the moment he said 'fucking car') that she started to back up. Now imagine that he'd acted like a real cop is trained to act--walked up to her (open) window and engaged in civil conversation (maybe saying, Ma'am, could you please get out of the car?). And imagine he hadn't been wearing a mask--and maybe was even dressed more like a police officer, complete with a badge featuring his ID number. Chances are high that Good wouldn't have freaked out and tried to flea. But Trump--and Stephen Miller, who I gather is the de facto head of ICE--have clearly signaled that they not only tolerate but actually applaud thuggish, intimidating behavior directed at Americans who are perceived as Trump's ideological enemies. You won't hear any complaints from them about an armed, masked man dressed like a DIY militiaman yelling "Get out of your fucking car!" at a woman in her thirties who, so far as I can tell, hadn't done anything wrong. (Far from obstructing the agent's pickup truck, she had paused before turning onto the street and politely waved it on, leaving it plenty of room to pass. If it had done so rather than stop, she'd still be alive.) Trump and Miller bear some measure of moral responsibility for the death of Renee Good. And the political reaction against them in the wake of this tragedy should prominently include specific demands about changing the rules of conduct for ICE agents--and also the rules of apparel, starting with a ban on those creepy masks.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
AI Consciousness: The Hard Problem | @robertwrighter and AI researcher @camhberg discuss whether AIs are (or may someday be) sentient—including why it matters, why it’s such a hard question to answer, and what Cameron’s innovative LLM experiments tell us about it.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Glenn Greenwald
@ggreenwald
A primary theme of right-wing politics throughout the 1990s and into 2000s (not GOP politics, but right-wing politics) was vehement opposition to armed federal agents on US soil acting against US citizens (things like WACO and the Randy Weaver shootings illustrated that).
Then a GOP administration exploited 9/11 to create DHS, and now armed federal agents under DC's control on US streets, operating against Americans, is a staple of right-wing politics.
JD Vance
@JDVance
This is preposterous.
First of all, she's not waving the officers through and has no right to do so even if she were. She is waving another car through, before the officers approach her car.
Second, the officers are not randomly searching her, they are approaching her vehicle because she is violating the law: namely, she is obstructing a lawful enforcement operation. You're not allowed to walk up to or drive up to people who are enforcing the law to make it harder for them to do their jobs.
Third, this defense attorney is drawing a meaningless distinction between an ICE officer and a "real police officer." Again, you're not allowed to interrupt a lawful enforcement operation, which is exactly what this woman was doing.
Fourth, the officer didn't discharge his weapon to prevent her from fleeing. When he discharged his weapon, she had pointed the vehicle at him and pressed the gas. He discharged his weapon in self defense, and other angles of the video show the woman *clearly* hit the officer with her car while accelerating.
The gaslighting is off the charts and I'm having none of it. This guy was doing his job. She tried to stop him from doing his job. When he approached her car, she tried to hit him.
A tragedy? Absolutely. But a tragedy that falls on this woman and all of the radicals who teach people that immigration is the one type of law that rioters are allowed to interfere with.
Jenin Younes
@JeninYounesEsq
I'm a former defense attorney and currently a civil liberties attorney with no political dog in this fight. I watched the video at least 10 times from different angles and at different speeds and waited to offer an opinion, which I still reserve the right to change if additional information changes the calculus.
It is very clear that the officers instigated the confrontation. The woman initially tried to wave them past her.
ICE officers have no authority to search a US citizen or arrest her (unless there's probable cause to believe she's harboring undocumented individuals, not a contention here). A woman surrounded by masked, armed men who have no law enforcement authority over her has every right to try to escape. Video shows her steering wheel is turned to the right, clearly an attempt to leave WITHOUT hitting anyone and steer clear of the officer standing towards the front of her car. That officer had time to step to the side, which is where he was when he shot her.
Even a real police officer would not have the right to shoot at her for trying to flee. This is well-established in the case law; deadly force may not be used simply to prevent someone from getting away. Given that the ICE officers had no law enforcement authority to begin with, AND the video footage shows she was trying to escape a perceived threat, not to kill anyone, the crime is all the more inexcusable.
I'm praying for the victim's family, especially her children. I'm also praying for all the conservatives who are so unprincipled and lost they're excusing this terrible crime, and gloating over a death that will leave three young children motherless, because of the victim's politics. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Seth didn't actually dox anybody, but it's nice of her to help publicize his book about Delta Force: www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/730414/the-fort-bragg-ca…
Rep. Anna Paulina Luna
@RepLuna
My subpoena to call Seth Harp to testify before Congress for his actions in doxxing a Delta Force commander and leaking classified information regarding the Venezuela mission, Operation Absolute Resolve, has passed unanimously with support from both Democrats and Republicans out of committee, and will be sent.
Putting a service member and their family in danger is dishonorable and feckless. Leaking classified information demands explanation and a criminal investigation. Seth Harp will be held accountable for his actions. -
Post not available here, view on X
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Some people have replied, 'He was looking at her, not at her wheels.' Well in that case her cranking the steering wheel to the right would have been clearly visible to him.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"If you wanna do assisted suicide, there are cheaper ways than this."
@robertwrighter and @JoelAchenbach on one-way trips to Mars.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is Space Still the Final Frontier? | @robertwrighter and @JoelAchenbach, author of a recent Slate deep dive on America’s new moon program, discuss the history and future of NASA—and its Elon-friendly new chief. Plus: The prospects for a Star Trek future, Mars, aliens, and more.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
There's nothing quite like a conversation with @JoelAchenbach, as I am reminded every time I have a conversation with @JoelAchenbach. You can watch the latest example here or listen to it on @NonzeroPods. www.youtube.com/watch?v=3IDLa54B7HE
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Is Space Still the Final Frontier? | @robertwrighter and @JoelAchenbach, author of a recent Slate deep dive on America’s new moon program, discuss the history and future of NASA—and its Elon-friendly new chief. Plus: The prospects for a Star Trek future, Mars, aliens, and more.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Matt Duss
@mattduss
Trump ran and won as an antiwar candidate not because he truly is but because he rightly recognized that there’s a large constituency for it.
Trump has now abandoned the antiwar lane. We need Democrats to have the courage to move into it. -
Robert Wright reposted
-
Robert Wright reposted
Jessica Berlin
@berlin_bridge
You cannot cheer America’s illegal attack on Venezuela while condemning Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and China’s threats against Taiwan. Selective application of international law means no rule of law.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Krystal Ball
@krystalball
Absolutely dreadful statement from Newsom. He seems to think the only problem with Trump’s illegal war and kidnapping of a head of state is a lack of sufficient planning.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Seth Harp
@sethharpesq
Statement on the ludicrous allegations of “doxxing” leveled at me by a large number of fascist, authoritarian, and far-right accounts
-
Robert Wright reposted
Danny Fenster
@DannyFenster
Some are calling it a "Golden Age" for the NonZero awards. Thank you for your attention to this matter!
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Many people are saying that the annual NonZero awards are the finest awards in the history of fine awards. Among the accolades: Least Effective Trump Bribe, Most Unsettling LLM Utterance, Most Creative Repurposing of War on Terror Terminology, Most Adroit Playing of the Neurodivergence Card--and 13 more! www.nonzero.org/p/the-2025-nonzero-awards
-
Robert Wright reposted
Trita Parsi
@tparsi
"You don't sound like you're speaking for an important country, you sound like you're speaking on behalf of a supplicant country who’s afraid of a bigger country.’
@Lewis_Goodall tears Labour’s Darren Jones apart on the UK's utter spinelessness on Venezuela.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Many people are saying that the annual NonZero awards are the finest awards in the history of fine awards. Among the accolades: Least Effective Trump Bribe, Most Unsettling LLM Utterance, Most Creative Repurposing of War on Terror Terminology, Most Adroit Playing of the Neurodivergence Card--and 13 more! www.nonzero.org/p/the-2025-nonzero-awards
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Many people are saying that the annual NonZero awards are the finest awards in the history of fine awards. Among the accolades: Least Effective Trump Bribe, Most Unsettling LLM Utterance, Most Creative Repurposing of War on Terror Terminology, Most Adroit Playing of the Neurodivergence Card--and 13 more! www.nonzero.org/p/the-2025-nonzero-awards
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
At last: The issue of @NonzeroNews that you've spent the year waiting for. www.nonzero.org/p/the-2025-nonzero-awards
-
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
So we're killing people for smuggling marijuana? Kind of makes you wonder about the quality of the intelligence that this whole operation is based on...
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
So we're killing people for smuggling marijuana? Kind of makes you wonder about the quality of the intelligence that this whole operation is based on...
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
2025: A Year-End (And Quarter-Century-End) Reckoning | @robertwrighter and @paulbloomatyale look back on the past year, and the past quarter century, and ahead to 2026—and 2050. youtu.be/GSkbYcjPdTw?t=91
-
Robert Wright reposted
Antiwar.com
@Antiwarcom
US Military Launches 30th Strike in Boat Bombing Campaign
At least two people were extra-judicially executed in the attack
#latinamerica #venezuela #warondrugs
news.antiwar.com/2025/12/29/us-military-launches-30th-str… -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
As the competition for best end-of-the-year take on the year heats up, @NikitaSPetrov and I up the ante: Why not do an end-of-the-quarter-century take on the quarter-century?
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
What Era Are We Living In? | @robertwrighter and @NikitaSPetrov grapple with the weirdness of our time—discussing the alienness of AI, whether Covid broke reality, the prospect of human obsolescence, why we need planetary unity pronto, and more! youtu.be/9Xo-enArEI4?t=181
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
What Era Are We Living In? | @robertwrighter and @NikitaSPetrov grapple with the weirdness of our time—discussing the alienness of AI, whether Covid broke reality, the prospect of human obsolescence, why we need planetary unity pronto, and more! youtu.be/9Xo-enArEI4?t=181
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Turns out the CBS piece @bariweiss tried to kill is alive and watchable. Now she can tell us which parts she found so objectionable. (Question: Will this qualify as a new sub-species of the Streisand Effect? If so what should we call it? One idea springs to mind.)
Jeff Stein
@SpyTalker
CBS took down a link to the 60 Minutes El Salvador prison piece but @allisongill @MuellerSheWrote posted another: www.muellershewrote.com/p/watch-the-60-minutes-cecot-segment
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Red states are under no obligation to adopt NY policies, David. And if the policies don't work out, they won't become a national standard.
David Sacks
@DavidSacks
NY Gov. Hochul let the cat out of the bag. She says NY is “setting the national standard” on AI regulation. Is that what Red States want? Republicans must unify behind President Trump’s One Rulebook, otherwise NY & CA will set the rules for the entire country.
Governor Kathy Hochul
@GovKathyHochul
The federal government doesn’t care about protecting you from the harms of AI.
I do.
New York is setting the national standard for strong, sensible AI regulation. -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
Antisemitism thrives on conflating Jews, Zionists, and Israel. Netanyahu repeatedly reinforces that conflation when he claims to speak for “the Jewish people. www.nonzero.org/p/how-bibi-boosts-antisemitism
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
You're not supposed to celebrate the idea that one of your followers murdered somebody.
@paulbloomatyale and @robertwrighter discuss Trump's strange tweet about Rob Reiner.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Elon, Trump, Fuentes: Bad Men or Trolls or Both? | @robertwrighter and @paulbloomatyale discuss the Brown shooting and Rob Reiner’s murder—and how Musk and Trump responded to them. Plus: Susie Wiles gone wild, Morgan/Fuentes, the Oliver Sacks revelations, and more.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Netanyahu blames world leaders for "pouring fuel on the fire' of antisemitism" but ignores the role played by his own policies and rhetoric--that's the argument I make in the latest @NonzeroNews.
www.nonzero.org/p/how-bibi-boosts-antisemitism -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
When Netanyahu claims to speak as the "emissary of the entire Jewish people," he reinforces the exact confused conflation that antisemites use to justify their hatred. That's among the points I make in this @NonZeroNews piece.
www.nonzero.org/p/how-bibi-boosts-antisemitism -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
When Netanyahu claims to speak as the "emissary of the entire Jewish people," he reinforces the exact confused conflation that antisemites use to justify their hatred. That's among the points I make in this @NonZeroNews piece.
www.nonzero.org/p/how-bibi-boosts-antisemitism -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
In this week's Earthling:
- The causal link between Israeli policy and global antisemitism.
- Eric Schmidt, China envy, and "statist capitalism."
- The advent of "code-based drugs" for AI.
- Elon musk's tribal threat inflation
www.nonzero.org/p/how-bibi-boosts-antisemitism -
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"The deep state is back."
@robertwrighter argues that Marco Rubio's neocon motivations are the only semi-coherent explanation for Trump's Venezuela campaign.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Does Trump have a coherent foreign policy? | @robertwrighter reviews the year in US foreign policy with @connor_echols of @RStatecraft and @AKDay89 of @amconmag. youtu.be/Yc75ILt8KaM?t=237
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews, I argue that a still-pretty-taboo topic---whether the policies of Israel, and the actions of its prime minister, can inflame antisemitism--shouldn't be taboo.
www.nonzero.org/p/how-bibi-boosts-antisemitism -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews, I discuss some confused conflations that can fuel antisemitism (conflating Zionists with Jews, and Israel with world Jewry) and look at some things Bibi Netanyahu has done that encourage them. I also look at other ways he's exacerbated antisemitism.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
No matter how fast technology is advancing, it's not fast enough for Silicon Valley's accelerationists. In the latest @NonZeroNews I look at the case of former Google CEO and current venture capitalist Eric Schmidt.
www.nonzero.org/p/how-bibi-boosts-antisemitism -
Robert Wright reposted
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The question of whether Israel does things that endanger Jews around the world is a question mainstream US opinion-shapers assiduously avoid. I think continuing to avoid it could make Jews more endangered. My piece in the latest @NonZeroNews:
www.nonzero.org/p/how-bibi-boosts-antisemitism -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews, I look at ways Bibi Netanyahu's rhetoric, and Israel's policies, make antisemitic attacks like the Bondi Beach massacre in Australia more likely.
www.nonzero.org/p/how-bibi-boosts-antisemitism -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The question of whether Israel does things that endanger Jews around the world is a question mainstream US opinion-shapers assiduously avoid. I think continuing to avoid it could make Jews more endangered. My piece in the latest @NonZeroNews:
www.nonzero.org/p/how-bibi-boosts-antisemitism -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
"The question of whether Israel does things that endanger Jews around the world is a question mainstream US opinion-shapers assiduously avoid. I think continuing to avoid it could make Jews more endangered." More from @robertwrighter:
www.nonzero.org/p/how-bibi-boosts-antisemitism -
Robert Wright reposted
Andrew Day
@AKDay89
Argued here that Chinese nationalism paradoxically circumscribes China's military ambitions.
And had fun reviewing year one in Trump 2.0's foreign policy with a couple lefty peaceniks, my friends @robertwrighter and @connor_echols. Two essential voices on foreign affairs!
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Does Trump have a coherent foreign policy? | @robertwrighter reviews the year in US foreign policy with @connor_echols of @RStatecraft and @AKDay89 of @amconmag. youtu.be/Yc75ILt8KaM?t=237
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
"The way countries dissolve into chaos and civil war is that one side gets an exaggerated sense of the extent to which it is attacked and persecuted."
@robertwrighter on how Elon Musk’s reckless tweeting fuels a dangerous feedback loop.This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Elon, Trump, Fuentes: Bad Men or Trolls or Both? | @robertwrighter and @paulbloomatyale discuss the Brown shooting and Rob Reiner’s murder—and how Musk and Trump responded to them. Plus: Susie Wiles gone wild, Morgan/Fuentes, the Oliver Sacks revelations, and more.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Does Trump have a coherent foreign policy? | @robertwrighter reviews the year in US foreign policy with @connor_echols of @RStatecraft and @AKDay89 of @amconmag. youtu.be/Yc75ILt8KaM?t=237
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Does Trump's Venezuela policy signify the triumph of the deep state? I had a great time talking about this and other Trump foreign policy questions with @NonzeroNews alumni @connor_echols & @AKDay89.
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Does Trump have a coherent foreign policy? | @robertwrighter reviews the year in US foreign policy with @connor_echols of @RStatecraft and @AKDay89 of @amconmag. youtu.be/Yc75ILt8KaM?t=237
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Yes, taxing the data centers would be a start--and (for Dems especially) a politically easy place to start. That's why it's so disappointing that (so far as I know) nobody in Congress is proposing it.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Andrew Day
@AKDay89
This is how Congress declares war now. It votes against asserting its authority to do so.
Dave DeCamp
@DecampDave
The Venezuela War Powers resolution has failed in a vote of 211-213, with nine members not voting. An absolute dereliction of duty from Congress.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Ben Freeman
@BenFreemanDC
Trumps announcement of a $1,776 “Warrior dividend” payment to every active duty service member adds up to nearly $2.5 billion in Congressionally unauthorized military spending.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Nonzero Podcasts
@NonzeroPods
Elon, Trump, Fuentes: Bad Men or Trolls or Both? | @robertwrighter and @paulbloomatyale discuss the Brown shooting and Rob Reiner’s murder—and how Musk and Trump responded to them. Plus: Susie Wiles gone wild, Morgan/Fuentes, the Oliver Sacks revelations, and more.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
And without serious international cooperation, AI will go seriously awry.
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
Serious international cooperation is unlikely to transpire if you prioritize winning a struggle with China for “supremacy.”
www.nonzero.org/p/the-china-chip-rorschach-test -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
Everyone asks how the US can use its chip advantage to "beat" China. What if we tried to use this temporary leverage to push for cooperation and stability.
www.nonzero.org/p/the-china-chip-rorschach-test -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Though there is a wide spectrum of elite opinion about how we should handle AI, none of the opinions make sense. That's a slight oversimplification--but, I argue in the latest @NonzeroNews, only slight. www.nonzero.org/p/the-china-chip-rorschach-test
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
If your nation regulates AI skillfully enough to keep a bioweapon from being built on your soil, that won’t save you from the global pandemic that originates in a laxer nation; international regulation is needed. In this week's @NonzeroNews I critique the major AI policy factions: www.nonzero.org/p/the-china-chip-rorschach-test
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Advocates of continued US 'supremacy' over China via superior AI tend to be vague about what kind of future this leads to. So what is their end game? Do they even have one? In the latest @NonzeroNews I recommend one.
www.nonzero.org/p/the-china-chip-rorschach-test -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews, I analyze the debate on AI chip exports to China and ask what I think is an under-asked question: How can we use this temporary leverage to build enduring stability?
www.nonzero.org/p/the-china-chip-rorschach-test -
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
In this week’s Earthling, @robertwrighter maps out the four factions driving US AI policy—from "Carefree Accelerationists" to "Safety Hawks."
www.nonzero.org/p/the-china-chip-rorschach-test -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews I take issue with just about everyone's position on the issue of restricting the export of microchips to China.
www.nonzero.org/p/the-china-chip-rorschach-test -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews, I argue that if you are truly concerned about AI safety issues (ranging from big but finite mishaps to true unfolding doom), you should be skeptical of anyone who talks about the importance of "winning" the AI race with China.
-
Robert Wright reposted
The Nonzero Newsletter
@NonzeroNews
The reaction to the decision to sell advanced AI chips to China revives an uneasy feeling: That though there is a wide spectrum of elite opinion about how we should handle AI, none of the opinions make sense.
More from @robertwrighter: www.nonzero.org/p/the-china-chip-rorschach-test -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In the latest @NonzeroNews, I use the fight over US-China chip policy to map out four factions of elite opinion on AI—from accelerationists (which come in two varieties) to safety hawks--and explain what I think all the major factions are missing.
www.nonzero.org/p/the-china-chip-rorschach-test -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Excellent question. What were we ever doing there (aside from violating international law)?
Curt Mills
@CurtMills
What in God’s name are we still doing in Syria
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
And for years he had a drinking problem! Maybe I should get off the wagon.
History Calendar
@HistoryCalendar
Dick Van Dyke is turning 100 years old. He was born before sliced bread was invented in 1928.
-
Robert Wright reposted
Shakeel
@ShakeelHashim
I’ve been livid about this all week, and it’s made us seriously consider leaving @substack
Gergely Orosz
@GergelyOrosz
I love Substack. Always have. Their team is great.
But a silent change could force me off the platform if it stays.
They broke email.
My paid subscribers cannot read today's paid newsletter on mobile without downloading the Substack app.
@substack: roll this back. Now. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
In this weekend's @NonzeroNews: Why is most of the AI 'safety community' joining with the whole foreign policy establishment to steer the world toward disaster? Plus: Trump's neocon Monroe doctrine, Disney's push to lengthen unemployment lines, @JoelAchenbach on Mars, etc.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
There's a special place in hell for Trump and Bibi. And part of the punishment will be having to live with each other.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Had a great chat on @NonzeroPods w/ @ReidHoffman about his book Superagency: What Could Possibly Go Right with Our AI Future. Tried to move him toward the techno-pessimist end of the spectrum. Wasn't wildly successful, but the results were illuminating. www.youtube.com/watch?v=UodLXykoywQ
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This was an extremely illuminating conversation. Jack really knows the territory--by virtue of both his scholarship and his past government service--and he lays out the legal and normative issues clearly. His Substack, Executive Functions, provides great Trump chaos coverage, btw
Jack Goldsmith
@jacklgoldsmith
My long (2 or so hour) conversation with the great @robertwrighter about Trump 2.0 and the the law. (Second half paywalled on Bob's substack.)
www.youtube.com/watch?v=GAZNcxpxZc0 -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
RIP, David Lynch. Blue Velvet was one of the great all time movies and the original Twin Peaks one of the great all time (network!) TV series. If you want to be surprised by his range, watch The Elephant Man.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Trump's nomination of Pete Hegseth for Secretary of Defense dishonors the military. I'm not familiar with the Golsteyn or Lorance cases, but Gallagher is a psychopathic war criminal whose fellow Navy Seals attested to his murder of a prisoner of war.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
A Musk-funded Super PAC is showing the ad on the left to Muslims and the ad on the right to Jews, according to this report: www.404media.co/this-is-exactly-how-an-elon-musk-funded-p… So great that Twitter is owned by someone who values truth and honesty.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
AI pioneer Geoffrey Hinton won the Nobel Prize (in physics!) today. Last year in my Nonzero Newsletter I wrote a piece explaining why he's so worried about AI: www.nonzero.org/p/the-hidden-source-of-ais-emerging
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I feel honored to be among the first few guests on the new podcast Lives Well Lived, co-hosted by the philosophers @PeterSinger and @KasiaLazari. It was a very fun and challenging conversation. podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/robert-wright-navigating-mo…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My debate with Coleman Hughes, in which I try to demolish the longstanding claim that Palestinians have repeatedly rejected good two-state deals. The fact is they've never been offered an actual state. You can watch here or listen on my Nonzero podcast. www.youtube.com/watch?v=a95OYJTScG8
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great chat with economist @DAcemogluMIT about his new book Power and Progress. It's a look at technological history that has implications for the future, including the impact of AI on jobs. www.youtube.com/watch?v=X388IuhEDjI
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed talking to @hendrycks of @cais about the forces that will shape the evolution of AI. You can watch here or listen on my Nonzero podcast. www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Dl8sSQcRm8
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just in case any of you still doubt that AI will transform the global economy.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Had a great conversation with psychologist @sbaroncohen about empathy (both cognitive and affective), including his pioneering work on cognitive empathy (or 'theory of mind') and autism. You can watch here or listen on the @NonzeroNews podcast. www.youtube.com/watch?v=rkHbsC2lsAA
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Read it and weep, @mattridley! (And no, you don't get extra credit for having two books on the list--Nice try.) www.mostrecommendedbooks.com/lists/best-evolutionary-psyc…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed having a pretty cosmic chat with @michalkosinski about AI (including his work documenting GPT's 'theory of mind' skills). You can watch here or listen on my Nonzero podcast. @NonzeroPods www.youtube.com/watch?v=7YCYulmoHrc
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Enjoyed discussing/debating the causes of the Ukraine war, and the shortcomings of US foreign policy, with Slate's esteemed national security columnist, @fmkaplan. You can watch here or listen on my Nonzero podcast. www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBMLy3f5DPw
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I guess it would be too much to ask him to provide links supporting the "funded gain-of-function research that killed millions of people" claim? (I'm not dismissing the lab leak theory. I'm asking for evidence that Fauci knowingly funded g-o-f work on the Covid virus in Wuhan.)
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just posted: My latest piece for @NonzeroNews. nonzero.substack.com/p/is-googles-ai-conscious?s=w
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Had a great chat w/ @mahbubani_k, author of Has China Won?, about the future of US-China relations (including the impact of the Ukraine war). Watch here or listen on The Wright Show podcast. www.youtube.com/watch?v=_JcmkxjdRUI
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
There's no way of knowing whether serious negotiation with Putin could have prevented Russia's incursion into Ukraine. What's pretty clear is that we didn't try that. Why? I offer a two-part answer: nonzero.substack.com/p/why-biden-didnt-negotiate-seriously
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Just had a far-ranging chat with NYT’s Tom Friedman and was glad to hear him endorse ‘Finlandizing’ Ukraine—which would mean keeping it out of NATO—as part of a deal w/ Putin. That part's below. You can listen to the whole thing on The Wright Show podcast.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=mBOczZjQO1Q&t=594s -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I got *some* blowback over this piece from people who conflate understanding Putin's motivations with justifying his actions, but not as much as I'd feared. Maybe there's hope after all. nonzero.substack.com/p/how-cognitive-empathy-could-have
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I was thrilled to hear this praise from @sullydish about me and @kausmickey and our weekly Wright Show podcast--until I got to the part about how Andrew was on drugs at the time. At least @CHSommers, who also said nice things, seems to have been in control of her faculties.
This media couldn't be displayed. See it on the original post. -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My Afghanistan listicle. nonzero.substack.com/p/afghanistan-3-unlearned-lessons
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I’m looking for someone to help me with my newsletter and podcast. If you know somebody who’s looking for a job in journalism, please consider retweeting. Thanks! nonzero.org/post/job
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
Really enjoyed talking to Microsoft CTO @kevin_scott about his book on AI and its consequences, Reprogramming the American Dream. You can watch on @bloggingheads or listen on The Wright Show podcast. www.youtube.com/watch?v=qokqQYosmZk
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a wonderful time talking with Nobel Laureate physicist @FrankWilczek about his new book Fundamentals: Ten Keys to Reality. You can watch on @MeaningLifeTV or listen on The Wright Show podcast. www.youtube.com/watch?v=jnEe-8XkEqk
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
From Trump's POV this is mission accomplished. He wants a huge contingent of 2020 Election Truthers to energize his next act. But this is very bad news for America. Mitch McConnell and other enablers will be forever culpable.
Nick Laughlin
@nick_d_laughlin
New polling shows a massive drop in trust in elections among Republicans. 7 in 10 GOP voters say the 2020 election was not free and fair.
morningconsult.com/form/tracking-voter-trust-in-elections/ -
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
The more I think about Trump's "stand back and stand by" line, the uglier it seems. By giving the Proud Boys an order, he was deeming himself de facto commander of a group of far-right thugs. Not a big step towards brownshirts, maybe, but a step.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I've dismissed some past warnings about Trump's authoritarianism as overblown, but I do think we've now entered a new and dangerous phase. My piece in the latest @NonzeroNews: nonzero.org/post/true-trump-nightmare
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I don't have a strong view on whether NYT should or shouldn't run op-eds by crackpot senators, but, fwiw, this was my @NonzeroNews critique of an earlier NYT Tom Cotton op-ed, published in January: nonzero.org/post/cotton-kristol-proxy-war
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I'm not generally in favor of spending a lot of time dunking on Trump for his various strange press conference utterances. But I have to say I think this is genius: www.tiktok.com/@whatchugotforme/video/6819061413877763334…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I had a great time talking to @jaymichaelson about his new book Enlightenment by Trial and Error. Covered lots of ground: Buddhist & Jewish mysticism, unitive & non-unitive psychedelics, etc. Watch on @MeaningLifeTV- meaningoflife.tv/videos/42388?in=00:01 -or listen on The Wright Show podcast.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
This week's Mindful Resistance Newsletter is out! And I've decided to declare it an emergency edition, so you're compelled to divert time from other activities to read it. mindfulresistance.net/2019/02/16/issue-62/
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
What makes this especially egregious is that many of the world's refugees are refugees because of forces set in motion by ill-advised US military actions (including invasions, bombings, and the arming of proxies). We create problems and then refuse to help the world solve them.
The Associated Press
@AP
BREAKING: US slashes refugee admission limit for next year to 30,000, 15,000 fewer than this year.
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I'm now an 'Ideas contributor' at Wired. Here's my first idea: www.wired.com/story/google-artificial-intelligence-monopoly/
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
My NYT piece on why Buddhist philosophy & psychology deserve more respect than they often get in the West www.nytimes.com/2017/11/06/opinion/buddhism-western-philo…
-
Robert Wright
@robertwrighter
I give you this news, @realDonaldTrump, because I know you'll bear it stoically: @BarackObama has 59 million more twitter followers than you















































































































































































































































